Complex sentence: Most historians agree that Enriquillo was the same person as the cacique Guarocuya which would mean that Enriquillo belonged to the highest house of the Jaragua "cacicazgo".
Split into simpler sentences: Most historians agree that Enriquillo was the same person as the cacique Guarocuya. In that case then Enriquillo belongs to the highest house of the Jaragua "cacicazgo".