Complex sentence: In 2009, Oughton scored a bicycle kick goal against USL 1st Division Rochester Rhinos in a U.S. Open Cup match, however, the Crew lost in penalties, with Oughton's being saved.
Split into simpler sentences: In 2009, Duncan scored a bicycle kick goal against USL 1st Division team, the Rochester Rhinos, in an US Open Cup match. However, the Crew lost in penalties, with Duncan's being saved.