Complex sentence: Jennifer received a Tony Award nomination for the 2002 Best Leading Actress in a Musical category for her performance as Hope in "Urinetown"; the award went to Sutton Foster for her performance in "Thoroughly Modern Millie".
Split into simpler sentences: Jennifer received a Tony Award nomination for the 2002 Best Leading Actress in a Musical category for her performance as Hope in "Urinetown". That year, however, the award was given to Sutton Foster, who won for her performance in "Thoroughly Modern Millie".