Complex sentence: Bomar, Elam, Ryan, Tot McCullough, Alf Sharpe, and Pink Wade all made some All-Southern teams; the yearbook said Tom Ryan was the only player of these to appear on an All-Southern team.
Split into simpler sentences: Bomar, Elam, Ryan, Tot McCullough, Alf Sharpe, and Pink Wade all made some All-Southern teams. The yearbook claimed Tom Ryan was the only one to appear on an All-Southern team.