Complex sentence: The first game was in 2003 when Geneva defeated North Greenville College and the second in 2007 when Malone College defeated the Golden Tornadoes with a score of 45-17.
Split into simpler sentences: The first game was in 2003 when Geneva defeated North Greenville College. The second came in 2007 when Malone College defeated the Golden Tornadoes with a score of 45-17.