Complex sentence: Thus, the Indians started Trevor Bauer who befuddled the Yankees followed by strong bullpen innings by Andrew Miller and Cody Allen resulting in only the 4th shutout the Yankees experienced all season.
Split into simpler sentences: Thus, the Indians started Trevor Bauer who befuddled the Yankees. He was followed by strong bullpen innings by Andrew Miller and Cody Allen resulting in only the 4th shutout the Yankees experienced all season.