Complex sentence: Winner of the 2012 Nicholl fellowship was Dramatic Writing graduate James DiLapo and, four of the last five years, at least one graduate of the department has won a Nickelodeon, NBC, or CBS writing fellowship.
Split into simpler sentences: Winner of the 2012 Nicholl fellowship was Dramatic Writing graduate James DiLapo. Each of the last five years, at least one graduate of the department has won a Nickelodeon, NBC, or CBS writing fellowship.