The Express.
London, England, 1867-08-09 00:00:00

THE EXPRESS, FRIDAY EVENING, AUGUST 9, 1867.

applied to eleven or twelve great constituencies, has
no pretension at all to be considered as an equitable
system for the proportionate representation of
minorities. Its first effect will be to diminish the
relative power of great as compared with email
constituencies, upon all the cardinal questions
which divide parties—in other words, it will
weaken the force which, by all but unanimous
confession, requires to be strengthened. Mr.
MILL, Mr. FAwcerr, and others, have persuaded
themselves that though this will be its first effect,
its ultimate result will be different ; and that it will
lead to Mr. HARE', scheme of personal representa-
tion, or to equal electoral districts. In other
words, they accept a present harm because they
think that out of it will spring a future good.
They are avowedly venturing in a lottery. They
are playing again something like the game of the
Tea-room party earlier in the session. The ques-
tion is whether Mr. MILL and Mr. Faweerr or
Mr. Lowe and Lord CRANBORNE will draw the
prize. We doubt whether these speculative and
almost gambling investments in particular schemes
are likely to contribute to the safety and
dignity of the country. After Mr. BRIO HT'S speech,
times
the stream of the debate flowed on, at
threatening to be swallowed up and lost altogether,
through a desert of dreary speakers, beginning
with Mr. BEREEPORD HOPE and ending with Mr.
NEWDEGATZ.

Replying to a remark of Mr. BRIGHT'S, the
member for Stoke claimed to be the member
for the majority in his borough, while his
Liberal colleague was the member for the
minority ; and argued that no degradation
or inferiority attached to this secondary posi-
tion. But Mr. HOPE, as is usual with him,
neglects an essential distinction—the member
for the minority in Stoke, and in every existing
constituency, is elected with the acquiescence of
the majority, who, if they chose to combine
against him, might have defeated him, and he,
therefore, in a certain sense, represents them also.
He is not forced upon them against their will and
by a restriction upon their voting power. Mr.
KNATcHBULL-HUOMISEN contended that eminent,
but temporarily unpopular, statesmen would find in
the minorities of great constituencies the refuge
which, nomination boroughs formerly afforded
them. But the minorities can only vote, as such,
when all the seats are vacant ; and a statesman
thrown out at one general election will have to
wait for his enlightened minority until the
next. Another point is worth notice. The emi-
nent statesman who has found refuge with a
mi-
nority will be practically excluded from an official
career. For in taking office he will be sent back,
not to his own fraction of the constituency, but to
the whole of it, which is by hypothesis hostile to
him ; and his re-election will be all but impos-
sible. He is not likely, therefore, to seek this
refuge. The other supposition on which Mr.
HUGENSEN'S argument depends, that the Tory or
Liberal party is more enlightened and likely to
choose better men when it is one-third than when
it is two-thirds of a great constituency, needs only
to be stated to exhibit its portentous absunlity.
Nevertheless, against fallacies such as these,
Mr. GLADSTONE'S eloquent assertion of the doc-
trine of representation of communities through
their majorities, as opposed to that of sections of
communities, proved vain, and Mr. LOWE'S conclud-
ing speech was followed by a division affirming the
Lords' amendments by a majority of 253 to 204.
The whole scheme of redistribution of seats is thus
re-opened, and a challenge is given to an agitation
which is sure to produce disturbance, and may
end in constitutional changes of which no one at
present dreams. Mr. CRAwFORD'S motion for
exempting the City of London from the fate of
the three-cornered constituencies was equally fruit-
less. Then foiloWee. t!,4 diaCUSsion of the Lords'
amendment providing for the use of voting :ADM
at borough and county elections, which, in spite of
Mr. Disitaint's offer to restrict it to counties, was
deservedly rejected, after speeches from Mr. M.
TOR'S/4S, Mr. DODSON, Mr. VILLIERS, and Mr.
BRIGHT had exhibited its true character and inge-
nious adaptation to purposes of fraud and
intimidation. Thus one only of three important
alterations introduced by the House of Lords into
the measure has been accepted by the House of
Commons ; and how many sessions that will survive
is open to question.

Tim debate on the Simla Court-martial has
exhausted that very fertile subject of scandal. A
" near relation " of Captain JERvis has made an
elaborate defence of that unfortunate officer ; " a
" near relation " of Sir WILLIAM MANSFIELD has
advanced the little that can be said in extenuation
of the Indian Commerrnra-lx-Carzr's conduct.
Both the late and the present Government'appear
to have been pledged to the course adopted by Sir
JOHN PsaiNurow relative to the unhappy busi-
ness. But a very large minority pronounced
what was no doubt the impartial opinion of the
House : that the recommendation of the Court-
martial should be given effect to, and that Captain
Jsavis should be reinstated in the army. We
cordially re-echo the demand that has been made
that the act of justice shall be accomplished. It is
impossible to let the matter rest where it now
is. Sir JOHN Paxixorox justly observed that
the publication of the Duke of CAMBRIDGE'S
despatch was necessary, in order that the House
and tho public should fully understand the ques-
tion. So highly does his Royal Highness think of
the proceedings of the Court-martial, so fully does
he adopt its decision and approve of its demea-
nour in this most trying case, that he has ordered
Sir WILLIAM MANSFIELD to be the medium of
conveying to the court his Royal Highness's opi-
nion of the excellent manner in which its difficult
and painful duty was performed. Having so fully
adopted the decision of the court, the Duke of
CsusaiDo scan hardly now hold back, and decline to
give effect to its finding. It was clearly the intention
of the Court.martial, by recommending Captain
Janina to the merciful consideration of the COM-
MANDER-IN-CHIEF in India, to prevent him from
being dismissed from the service. Notwithstanding
the unlooked-for and intemperate interference of
Sir WILLIAM MANSFIELD, the Court refused
to withdraw that recommendation. If this firm-
ness of the Court-martial deserves the high
praise bestowed upon it by the head of the army,
how can his Royal Highness hesitate to place
Captain JERVIS in the position designed for him by
the court f It is not possible for the DCKE to
applaud the practical acquittal of Captain Jzavis
by the court, and yet not give effect to that
acquittal.

A refusal on the part of the DEICE to carry out
his expressed views to this fair conclusion would
plunge him into intolerable inconsistencies of the
kind we have indicated. He justly condemns Sir
WILLIAM MANSFIELD in the most severe terms for
interfering with the decision of the Court-martial.
He observes that the obviously proper course for
th. Indian Commander-in-Chief was to abstain
from giving judgment in his own favour, and to
send the whole case home for the opinion of
the head of the army. But the Duna
in his despatch expresses the most unqualified ap-
proval of the proceedings and decision of the

Court-martial. Hence we may infer with certainty I
that he would have confirmed the court's decision
and given effect to its recommendation if Sir
WILLIAM MANSFIELD had not so improperly inter-
vened. In other words, if Sir WILLIAM had
behaved well, justice would have been done ; but
because Sir WILLIAM has behaved—as ill as he
well could—justice is impossible. Sir WILLIAM
has pronounced judgment in his own favour
against the decision of a court constituted by
himself, and largely subject to his influence ; he
has punished a practically innocent man with pro-
fessional ruin. The Duke of CAMBRIDGE has, so
far, discharged a painful duty ably and impar-
tially, but the crowning sacrifice must be made.
The publication of the DowE's despatch will
probably entail Sir WILLIAM MANSFIELD'S
resignation ; it should also ensure Captain JERVIS
restoration to his old rank in the army. When
justice has been thus satisfied, we trust the public
will endeavour to forget this unhappy affair—will
forget the faults, however grave, of a distinguished
officer, and remember only that he has done good
service to his country in a great crisis of her for-
tunes. The public will condone great errors when
their penalty has been duly paid, but will view
with discontent and anger high rank escaping un-
punished, and " vixenish ferocity" indulged with
security by highly placed officers against those
under their command. We trust the Duke of
CAMBRIDGE will take immediate steps to give effect
to his own admirably expressed views, and to the
recommendation of the Court-martial, which all
unite with his Royal Highness in considering to
be entitled to the highest respect.

THE REFORM BILL

4

THE LORDS' AMENDMENTS.
DIVISIONS IN THE HOUSE OF COMMONS.
THE COPTBOLD QUALIFICATION. .

The first division last night in the House of
Commons was on a motion by Mr. Colvile, that the house
disagree with the amendment which raised the value of the
oopyhold and leasehold qualifications from Si. to 101. This
motion was carried by T 35 to 188. The following conser-
vative members voted against the Lords' amendment :
Mr. Barrow, Mr. Eckenley, Mr. Henley, and Sir A. Rood.
A few of the Adullamitesvotedlwith the majority, namely,
Mr. Doulton, Lord Dunkellin, and Mr. Lowe. Earl Gros-
venor and Lord Elcho were absent. Mr. Heathcote, Mr.
Msinwaring, and Mr. Marsh voted with the government,
as also did Lord Cranborne and General reeL
ligeltasirranos Or MINORITIES.

The next division was on the motion made by Mr. Bright,
in reference to the amendment of the Lords regarding the re-
presentation of minorities. The motion was "That this
house doth disagree with the Lords on the mid amend-
ment." The "ere" were 204, the "nom" 253. The list
is u follows :

AYES.
Acland, T D. Gower, F. L. Norwood, C. M.
Adair, 11. E. Gower, Lord E. O'Beirne, J. L.
Adam, W. P. Gray, W.f. Mirka, Sir P.
Agar -Baia, L. G. Grove, T. Y.
Allen, W. S. Gurney, K tYLoghlen, Sir C.
°Wow, O.
Armstrong, R. Hadfield, G. Osborne, B. B.
Ayrton, A. S. Hamilton, B. W. Otway, A. J.
Barclay, A. C. Ilenkey, T. Packs, Col.
Barnes, T. Hardcatie, J. A. Padmore, R.
Barry, C. R. Harris, J. D. Palmer, Sir B.
Baas, M. V. liartington, Mar- Parry, T.
Baxter, W. E. yule of Pease, J. W.
Barley, T. Harvey, R. B. Peel, A. W.
Beaumont, W. B. Hervey, Lord A. Philips, B. N.
Berkeley, H. F. Hay, Lad J. Platt, J.
Biddulph. Col. Headlam, T. E. Potter, E.
Blake, J. A. Henderson, J. Potter, T. B.
Bowyer Sir G. Humane, & Powell, F. 8.
Brady. br. Henley, J. W. Pritchard, J.
Brand, H. Henley, Lord Push, D.
Bright, Sir C. Hibbert, J. T. Rearden, D. J.
Bright, J. Hodgkinsou, 0. Robertaon. D.
Briscoe, J. I. Hodeson K. D. Itoebuck, J. A.
Bruce, H. A. Holdall. 1. RothschUd,Baron L.
Bryan, G. L Huntall, T. & Rothschild, N. M.
Buller, Sir A. W. Howard, C. W. Russell, Sir C.
Buller. Sir X M. Hughes, W. B. St. Aubyn J.
Barren, Sir P. Hunt, It. 11. Sammie, J.
Batter, C. S. Hutt, Sir W. Seely, C.
Calmat, J. H. Jackson, W. Seymour, H. D.
Candlish, J. Jackson, H. Y. Sheridan, H. B.
Caringion, C. R. Jardine, R. Sheriff, A. C.
Castleroese, Vied. Keareley, Capt. Simeon, Sir J.
Chambers, M. Kennedy, T. Smith, J.
Chambers, T. King P. J. Smith, J. A.
Cheetham, J. Kinglake, A. W. Smith, J. B.
Cholmeley, Sir M. Kinghake, J. A. .W.
Clay, J. Maypole, CoL ii!=elet, F.
Clement, W. J. Kinnard, A. F. Stausfeld, J.
Collier, Blr E. Knox, Col. 8. Steel, J.
Colvile, C. E. Labouchere, H. Stone, W. H.
Cowen. J. Ward, A. H. Sullivan, K
LZ0.,12147, Sir F. Lawrence, W. Sykes, Col.
, E. Lawson, J. A. Taylor, P. A.
Dave, Ir H. Lee, W. Tile. W.
Denman, G. Leeman, G. Tomfine, G.
Dixon, G. Lefevre, G. J. Torres, W. T.
Mika Sir W. Lewis, IL Tottenham, LL.Ocil.
Duff, M. K. Lucke, J. Trevelyan G. 0.
Hendee, F. Lusk, A. Vanderb, P.
Id Edwards, C. •Lsgan, P. Verney, Sir H.
Edwards, H. M'Laren, D. Vernon, H. F.
Eliot, Lord Maguire, J. F. tidier', C. P.
Enfield, Vied Marshall, W. Vivian, H. H.
Erskine, Vice-Adm. Martin, C. W. Vivian, Capt.
Ewart, W. Martin, P. W. Watidn, IL W.
Ewing, H. E. Cram- Milbank, F. A. Western, Sir T.
Pane, Col. Miller, W. Whalley, G. H.
Midas, J. Mills, J. R. White, J.
roister, C. Mitchell, A. WlUtworth. B.
, Forster, W. E. Mitchell, T. A. Wickham, H. W.
' Gawks, Seri. Moffatt, O. Williamson, Sir H.
Gibson, T. IL Moncrelff, J. Woods, H.
Gilpin, C. Monk, C. J. Young, G.
Gladstone, W. E. Moore, C. Young, It.
Gladstone, W. H. More, R. J.
Glyn, G. C. Morris, W. TELLERS.
Glyn, G. 0 Murphy. N. D. Crawford, IL W.
Goldunid. Sir F. Neste, C. Babies, E.
Goschen, G. J. North, Col.

NOES.
Adderley, C. B. Floyer, J. Mill. J. 8.
Amberley, Visct. Fords, Col. Montagu, Lord R.
Andover,Viect. Forester, Gen. Montgomery, Sir 0.
Annesley, Cul. Fort, B. Morgan, 0.
Archilall, Capt. Furtescue, D. F. Morgan, Major
Arkwright, R. Preabfield, C. K. Morris, M.
Aytoun, R. B.Morrison, W.
=1; B. GasGalthiLe BJ. H.
Gilpin, Col. Mowbray, J. B.
Naas, Lord
Bailey, C. Goldney, G. Neeld, Mr J.
Baring, A.ll. Gooch, Sir D. Neville-Grenville, R.
Baring, T. Goodson, J. Newdegate, C. N.
Itimington, Viect, Gorst, J. E. Newport, Viact.
Barrow, W. H. Grant, A. Noel G.J.
Barry. A. H. Graves, & R. Nortitcote, Sir &
Baas, A. Greene, E. O'Conor Don, The
Bathurst. A. A. Oreville-Nugent, A. Paget. R. IL
Beach, sir N. Gray, Lient.-CoL Paldngtoe, Sir J.
Beach, W. W. Grey, T. de Palk, Sir L.
Beecrott. G. 8. Gurney,R. Parker, Major
Blddulph, M. Gays, H. Patten. Col.
Bingham, Lord Hamilton, LdClaud Paull, 11.
Biennerhassett,Shß liandlion, Id. C. J. Peel, Gen.
Benham•Carter, J. Hamilton, Visct. Pelham, Lord
CoL Hardy,.o. m, J.
Bouverle,irim,
E. P. Hartley, J. Polled-Urqultert,W
Brett, W. B. Hartopp. E. B. Fortnum, W. H,
Bridges, sir B. W. Harvey, LJ. Price, W. P.
Brooks, it. Hay, Sir J. Read, C. S.
Bruce, Lord C. lfayter, A. D. Robert's, T. J.
Bruce, Par H. H. Ileatbcote, G. H. Robertson, P.
Buxton, C. Heathcote, Sir WI Royston, Vied.
Buxton, Sir T. L Henniker-Major, J. Russell, A.
Cathorpe, F. H. Herbert, Col. Russell, F.
Campbell, A. H. Hesketh, dir T. Samuelson, B.
Caggr, C. Hodgson, W. N. Schreiber, C.
ell„ K Hogg,, Lieut..C.l. Sclateskliootb, G.
Cartwright, Col. Ilai. dale, Wed. Scott, Lord H.
Cave, 8. Hood, Sir A. Scourlield, J. H.
Cavendish, Lord K Hope. A. J. Selwyn. Sir C. J.
Cavendish. !And G. Hurnby, W. H. scveme, J. E.
Cecil, lord E. Hallam. Lord Seymour, G. H.
Chalterton, H. L Howes, E. Smith, A.
Clinton, Lord A. Hubbard, J. G. Sinith, S. G.
Clinton. Lord E. Hughes, T. Somerset. L A.
Cobbold, J. C. James, E. Stanley, Lord
Cochrane, A. D. Jervis, Major Stock, 0.
Cole, .1. L Jervolse, Sir J. Stuart, LL.CoI. W.
Colebrook., Sir T. Jones, D. Stucky, Sir O. 8.
Corrance, Ir. 8. Kanlake, Sir J. Sturt, H. G.
Corry, H. L Karslake, E. K. Sturt, Lt.-Col.
Condenay, Lord Kekewic.b, 8. T. Surtax, C. F.
Cowper, H. F. Kelk. J. Stumm H. E.
Cowper, W. Y. Kendal/, N. Sykes, C.
Cox, W. T. Kennard, R. W. Thorold, Sir J. H.
Cranborne, Witt. Realm, W. Thynne, Lord H.
Cremorne, Lord Xnatchbull-Huges- ToUemache, J.
Cubitt, G. sen, E. Torrens, R.
Curzon, Vise. Knight, F. W. Tracy. C. R.
Delkeith. Earl of Knightley, SUR. Tuohy, J. W.
Dent, J. D. Knox, Col. B. Turner, C.
Dosing, Sir Z. Lawn, Sir L Vance, J.
Dick, F. lain.. S. Verner, L W.
Dickson, Major land, J. Verner, Sir W.
Dimedele, R. Lamont, J. Walcott, Adm.
Disraeli., B. Langton. W. 0. Walker, Major
Dodson, J. G. Leader, N. P. Walpole, 8. H.
Hauliers, F. Leroy, A. Walsh, Sir J.
Hoydens.% W. K. Leg& Major C. Wiring, C.
Do Cane. C. Lennox, Lord 0. Warner, E.
Duncombe, Col. Lennox. Lord H. Waterhouse, 5.
Dunne, General Leslie, C. P. Welby, W. E.
Dutton, R. H. Liddell, H. G. Whitbread, 8.
Dyke. W. H. Lindsay, Cot C. Williams, F. M.
Dyott, Col. Lindsay, CoL 8.. Wile, H. C.
Eaton, 11. W. Long, R. P. Woodd. B. T.
Eckeraley, N. Lowe, R. Wyld, J.
Edwards, Sir H. Lowther, Capt. Wyndham. P.
Egerton, A. F. Lowther, J. Wynn, C. W.
Egerton, E. C. M'Etuna, J. N. Wynne, W. R.
Klein, Lord Mackie, J. Wyvill, H.
Eykyn, R. Mainwaring, T. Yorke, J. R.
Fawcett, H. Manners, lord J.
renown. E. Manners, Lord G. TELLTAS.
Fergumon, Sir J. Marsh, If. H. Taylor, Col.
Fitzwilliam, C. W. Metter, Col. U bitmore, 11.
It will be seen that in the above division the govern-
ment received the support of the Adullmnitea and a certain
section of the liberal party. This mingled force was as
follows:—Lord Amberley, Lord Andover, Mr. Aytoun,
Mr. A. Baring, Mr. Barry, Mr. A. Boma. Mr. Biddulpb, Sir
K. Blennerhassett, Mr. Bonham-Carter, Mr. E. Bouverie,
Lord C. Bruce, Mr. C. Buxton, Sir T. Buxton, Mr.
Calthorpe, Mr. Cardwell, Lord E. Cavendish, Lord
G. Cavendish, Lord A. Clinton, Lord E. Clinton,
Sir T. Colebrooke, Mr. H. F. Cowper, Mr. W. F. Cowper,
Lord Cremorne, Mr. Dent, Sir E. Daring, Mr. Dodson, Mr.
Doultou, Lord Elcho, Mr. Eykyn, Mr. Fawcett, Mr. Fits-
william, Mr. Fort, Mr. D. F. Fortescue, Mr. Hayter, Mr.
Heathcote, Mr. T. Hughes, Mr. E. James, Sir J. Jervoise,
Mr. Knakhbull•Hugessen, Mr. Laing, Mr. Lamont, Mr.
Lowe, Mr. M'Kenna, Mr. Mackie, Mr. Mainwaring,
Mr. Marsh, Mr. J. Stuart Mill, Mr. Morrison, The
O'Conor Don, Lord Pelham, Mr. Pim, Mr. Pollard Ur-
quhart, Mr. Portman, Mr. l'rice, Mr. Robartea, Mr. A.
Russell, Mr. F. W. Russell, Mr. Samuelson, Mr. Stock,
Mr, Tracy, Mr. Waring, Mr. Warner, Mr. Whitbread, Mr.
Wyld, and Mr. Wyvill—in all, 65 liberals, or Adullam-
ites, followed in the wake of Earl Russell on this ques-
tion, three members of the late ministry—Mr. Cardwell,
Mr. W. Cowper, sa.l Mr. Knatehbull-Hugessen—being
among the number.

The only conservative members who voted against the
Lords' amendment were Sir P. Burrell, Colonel Fane, Mr.
R. B. Harvey, Lord A. Hervey, Mr. Henley, Mr. Hors-
fall, Colonel Knox, Mr. BClAgan, Colonel North, Mr.
Powell, Mr. Pugh, Sir C. Russell, Hon. F. Stanley, and
Colonel Tottenham. Of the foregoing, 14 in number,
eight are county members. Mr. Horsfall is one of the re-
presentatives for Liverpool, which would be affected by
the clause. His colleague, however, voted on the other
aide. The Hon. F. Stanley, son of the premier, who voted
against the clause, sits for Preston.

In the third division, relating to the representation of
the City of London, the amendment of the Lords was
&Earned by 252 votes to 188.

VOTING PAPERS.

The division Olt the voting paper clauses took place in
the following form :
" Clause C," the next aseendment, read a second time :
Amendment proposed, in line I of the clause, after the
word " county," to leave out the words " or borough:"
(Mr. Chancellor of the Eschequer.)—Question proposed,
" That the words ' or borough' stand part of the clause :"
Question put and negatived :—Motion made, and ques-
tion put, " That this house doth disagree with the Lords
in the said cause as amended :"--(Mr.M'CullaghTorrena.)
The house divided : Ayes, 238 ; noes 206.
AYES.
Arland, T. D. Fildes, J. Moore, C.
Adalr, H. E. litzwilliam, C. W. More, R. J.
Adam, W. P. Forster. C. Morris, W.
Agar.Ellls, L 0. Forster, W. E. Morrison, W.
' Akroyd, X Forte:me, C. P. Murphy, N. D.
Allen, W. 8. Feetescue, D. F. Neste, C.
Amberley, Vied, Gaselee, Berl. Newelegate, C. N.
Andover, Fleet Gasket, J. M. Norwood, C. Y.
' Antrobus, K Gibson, T. M. O'Beirne, J. L
Armstrong, R. 011 pin, C. O'Brien, Sir P.
Ayrton, A. & Gladstone, W. E. O'Conor Don, The
Aytoun, R. S. Gladstone, W. H. O'Loghlen, Mr C.
Baines, E. Glyn, G. C.
Barclay, A. C. Glyn, O. G. Onslow, 0.
Osborne, R B.
Barnes, T. Golder:rid, Sir F. Otway, A. J.
Bony, A. H. °ceche& G. J. Packs, Col.
Barry, V. X Gower, F. L Padmore, R.
Boss, A. Gower, Lord R. Palmer, Sir R.
Bass, IL T. Gray, 8b J. Parry, T.
I Barter, W. E. Beeville-Nugent, A. Pears, J. W.
Barley, T. Grove, T. F. Peel, A. W.
Beaumont. W. X Warne,: B. Pelham, Lord
Berkeley, H. F. Hadfield, 0. Philips, R. N.
Biddulph, Col Hamilton, E. W. Phu, J.
Blake, J. A. Hankey, T. Platt, J.
Blenuerhasestt,SlTH Hardcastle, J. A. Pollard-Uncruhszt,W
Bonham-Carter, J. Harris, J. D. Portman W. H.
Bouverle, R. P. Hartington,Marq. of Potter, li.
Bowyer, Slr 0. Hay, Lord J. Potter, T. B.
Brady, Dr. Hay, Lord W. PP= P.
Bread, H. Heater, A. D. , J.
Bright, Sir C. Headiani, T. E. Bearden. D. J.
Bright, J. Henderson, J. Rebates, T. .1.
Ilnme, Lord C. Heneage, E. Robertson, D.
Bruce, H. A. Henley, J. W. Roebuck, J. A.
Bryan, 0. L. Henley, Lord Rothszhild,Baron L
Buller, Sir A. Hibbert, J. T. Rothschild, N. M.
Buller, Sir Z. Hodgkinson, 0. Russell, A.
Butler, C. 8. Hodgroa, K. D. Russell, F. W.
Buxton, C. Holden
W. lit. Autry& J.
Buxton, Sir T. Samada, J. D.
Calcraft, J. H. Hughes, T. fianenelson, B.
Calthome F. H. Hughes, W. B. Seely, C.
Candlish, J. Hurst, R. H. Seymour, H. D.
Cardwell, Z. Hutt, Sir W. Sheridan, H. B.
Carington, C. R. Jackson, W. Sherrill, A. C.
Castlerosse, Viset. Jackson, H. M. Simeon, Sir J.
Cavendish, lard E. James. N. Smith, J.
Cavendish, Lord F. Jardine, R. Smith, J. A.
Cavendish, Lord 0. Jervoise, Sir J. Smith, J. B.
Chambers, M. Kearsley, Capt. Eltacpx4e, W.
Chambers, T. Kennedy, T. Stanley. F.
Cheetham, J. King P. J. Standeld, J.
Childers, H. C. Kingiales, A. W. Steel, J.
Cholmeiey, Sir IL 'Menke, J. A. Stock, O.
Clay, .1. King:scot& Col. Stone, W. H.
Clement, W. J. Xhinaird, A. F. Sullivan, E.
Clinton, Lord E. Knatchbull - lieges. Sykes, CoL
Colebrooke, Sir T. son, E. Taylor, P. A.
Coleridge, J. D. Ishouchere, H. Tile, W.
Collier, Sir R., Ward, A. H. Tomlin°, 0.
Cohile, C. IL Lamont, J. Tracy, CC.. R.
Cowen, J. Lawrence, W. Trevelyan, 0. 0.
Cowper, H. F. Lawson, J. A. Venda/bpi, P.
pond, R. W. Lee,W. W. F. Leader, N. I'. V Verneyernon, , riir H
T..
CrawfH.
Creurorne, Lord Legh, Major Villiers, C. P.
Cromaki, 7t r.F. Leeman, O.
Leteere, G. J. Vivian, H. IL
Vivian, Capt.
LlV:gir H. Lewis, H. Waring, C.
Denman, G. Locke, J. Within, K W.
Dent, J. D. Long, R. P. Western, Ste T.
Bering, 81r N. Lusk. A. Whalley, G. H.
Dixon, G. Mackie, J. Whitbread, 8.
Mke, Mr W. Mime& D. White, Capt.
Dillwyn, L. L. Maguire, J. F. Whits, J.
Dodson,J. 0. Marshall. W. Whitworth, B.
Dug, M. E . Martin, C. W. Wickham, H. W.
Wades, F. Martin, P. W. Williamson, stir H.
F.ckersley, N. Milbank, F. A. Woods, H.
Edwards. C. Mill, J. 8. Wyrlll, M.
Edwards, H. Mills,, W. Young. G.
Eliot, Lord Mills J. R. Young, R.
Erskine , Vice-Adm. Mitchell, A.
Ewart, W. Mitchell, T. A. MAW.
Ewing, H. E. Crum- Moffatt, G. Torreus, W. WC.
Ey kin. R. lion, J. Enfield, Visit.
Fawcett, H. Monk, C. J.

NOD.
Adderley, C. B. Oore, W. It, Morgan, 0.
Anna;ley. Col. Gond, J. Z. Morgan, Major
Anson, Major Gnat, A. Mowbray,
Archdalt Capt. Graves, 8. R. Naas. Lord
Arkwright, R. Greene, X Neeld, Sir J.
Beggallay, It. Gray, LL-CoL Neville-Grenville, R.
Bagge, Sir W. Grey, T. de Newport, V4ouunt
Bailey, C. Oriath, C. D. Noel, 0.1.
Baring, T. earney,R. North, Col.
Barrington, Ilset. Gwyn. H. Northeote, Sir 8.
Barrow, W. H. Hamilton, lA. Claud Paget. R. H.
Batavia, Sir T. Hamilton, Lord C. J. Pakington, Sir J.
ItathurM A. A. Hamilton. I. T. Palk, air L.
Beach, Sir H. Hamilton, Visa. Parker, Major
Beach, W. W. Hardy, G. Patten. Col
Beecroft, G. 8. Hartley, J. Paull, H.
Biddulph, H. Hartopp, X B. Peel, General
Bingham, Lord Harvey. R. B. Powell. F. B.
Bourne, Col Harvey, IL J. Pugh, D.
Brett. W. It. Hervey, lard A. Read, C. 8.
Bridges. Sir B. Hay, Sir J. Robertson. P. F.
Brooks, It. Heathcote, 0. H. Royston, Viect.
Bruce. Sir H. Heathoote, liir W.„ Schreiber. C.
Burrell, Sir P. Henniker-Major, X &later-Booth, 0.
Campbell, A. H. Herbert, Col. Scott, Lord H.
Capper, C. Ifeeketh, Sir T. Scourtleld, J. H.
Cartwright, Col. Hodgson, W. N. Selwyn, Sir C.
Cave, 8. Hon, Lt. -Col. Severne, J. R.
Cecil, Lord I. Holmeedele, Fleet. Seymour. O. If.
Chatterton, H. R. Hood, Sir A. Simonds, W. B.
Clinton Lord A. Hope, A.J. Smith, A.
mbooki. J. C. Hornby, W. H. Smith, 8. 0.
Cochrane, A. D. Horst4l, T. B. Somerset, X A.
Cole, J. L Hallam, Lord Stanley, Lord
Corrance, F. IL Howes, E. Stopford, & G.
Corry, H. I Hubbard, J. G. Stuart, Lt. 4.501.. W.
Casten), Lord Hunt, G. W. Start, H. G.
Cox, W. T. Jerrie, Major Start. LL-Col.
Cranbome, Viact. Jones, D. fitirtees, C F.
Cuhltt, 0. Kerslake, Sir J. Hurtees, 11. X
Canon, Vied.. Kerslake, E. K. Sykes, C.
Dalkeith, Earl of Kekewich, S. T. Thurold, Sir J.
Dick, F. Kelk, J. Thynne. Lord If.
Dickson, Major Kendall. N. Tollennelle, J.
Dimadale, R. Kennard. R. W. Torrens, It.
Disraeli, B. Keown, W. Tottenham, Lt.-Col
Welton, K Knight. F. W. Treeby, J. W.
Dowdeswell, W. E. IL ulghtley. Sir IL. Turner, C.
Du Cane, C. Knox, CM. B. Vance, J.
Buncombe, Col. Knox, Col 8. Verner, It. W.
Dunne, Can, Leon, Sir E. Verner, Sir W.
Dutton. R. H. Lim, S. Walcott. Admiral
Dyke, W. H. latrd, J. Walker, Major
Hyatt, CoL Lawton, W. G. Walpole, 8. H.
Parton, H. W. Lefroy, A. Welsh, Sir J.
Edwards, Sir EL Lennox, Lord G. Waterhouse 8.
Egerton, H. C. Lennox. Lord H. Weihy, W. X
Eichu, Lord Leslie. C. P. Williams. Col.
lane, Col. Liddell, H. G. Williams, F. H.
Fellowes, IL Lindsay, Col C. Wise, If. C.
Ferguseon, 81r J. Lindsay, Col. IRS. Woodd, B. T.
Flo)or,.1. Loam, M. Wyld, J.
Porte, Col. Lowther, Capt. Wyndham, P.
Forester, General Lowther, J. Wynn, C. W.
Fort, R. Mainwarhig, T. Wynne, W. R.
Fr... Wield, C. K. Manners, Lord J. Yorke, J. R.
Garth, R. Manners, Lord G.
Gilpin, Col. Mellor, Col. TIELLEILS.
Goldney, G. Montagu, Lord R.. Taylor, Col.
Gooch, Sir D. Montgomery, Str G. Whitmore, H.

The opposition in their resistance to the voting papers
clawe were joined, it will be seen, by seven conservative mem-
bers, Mr. Agar-Hllis, Mr. Henley, Mr. Leader, Major
Legh,llLr. H. Long, Mr. Newdegate, andthe Hon. F. Stanley.
The proposed machinery, on the other hand, was suppoited
by the foliowing liberals :—Major Anson, Mr. Bidditlph,
Lord A. Clinton, Mr. Doniton, Lord Echo, Mr. Fort, Mr.
G. Heathoote, Mr. Laing, Mr. Mainwaring, and Mr. Wyld.
Mr. Lowe's name is not in the list. Lord Cmnbome and
General Peel voted with the government.

THE DIVISION ON CHURCH RATES IN