The Express.
London, England, 1859-05-21 00:00:00

THE EXPRESS, SATURDAY EVENING, MAY 2

VQLL?(TZZI MILS CORPS NOVINJ

rAl►r.

LIVIRI'OOL.
r el'order afternoon a pubic netting of the inha-
li airs .4 Ltierrol W4B bold is the Ilemineboase, a teos
Int I con i.l-rat: on the advisability of teeming local redo and
artater) volunteer corps. His worship the Mayor (Wallism
b'.ll, who t ro-i ltd. wa. burp rtcl Ly Guk Sir
W 411,1, F4IIWL k W.Pitioe rd Kos (who sane to-day (rota
I.•.• r --•, fr C M r4Oeceral Dell, (701. howl's,
C re-riceee Mr. J. C. EW4f., M P., Mr. Wm. Blown,
Mr. J li Turner, Mr. N. 13 AAjtasnt of the ex-
ist et Liveroml Rae Corps, sod otter reatisuien of local
endow-11W ober s.4xtiort• of the t uildiog
tr 01 •,• +du! pi...loo'y by y °on, gco•l-uirn front
f LIAM FIX'S' ICI IV IL LI A 44. ci K .le. who
...Al cast exttinenstieelly r.es teed, to a feuda-
l( A': rtl ntlag t., !h. happy se,,dent" whirb
Led n d his to be pen tit, hr ~alled for doles
chars for lb. Ques--• r.l whido w.a enthasinetrnally
r:st .o. Bor Wm. Wiili.m. (hat expre.eed the pith-
ours c' Id; advoestiag a 111lAblaft., the obj.. tof Tbi waA
the • t.:ed oar ot sanding the men ei 'hi. country to dofend
stone ha alai their families. There were ample in. au in
1.4 e-re tr the ternatit •of voluweer corps. and A. to the
d ot .be pwf, every vessel “.-otting about" the river
tc..tht Its *nod with eannun, furnished with WY.
If:: • f r r.dmatte, and nue made moot e&ttive
eg.iset an 'neediest f., r. He MINI, however,
Mole :Ls'. whin folly 'pyre:ming the 'sloe of rids corps,
they c .clot to bat teseist tut. t.. a regular even if smell army.
for &noose end batten.. noted be °mooed by dragoon. and
henries. Soli the sir I *el ,anditien of Roland was most
fae•uuls'e to default... w ware, ant he sot Litany *imbed sties
roue t tie ol tLe n-e•t. ay. (Cheers) TLe galloat
re.:-.1 elm tel C Jt"da. sad tinted that Eloolud
welld else.. n cannier her an I en dale her, by efficient
easistar...v. &le n 4 btr-c:f in tme• of issed—amistew e which
Cando sesalt at may time glnLy amply repay. (Cheer. )
Ti.. l ow-ot Cunt. this rend a le ter Rom Major Bourns,
f )..10,1AU !leg the Leseambire Artillery Regiment of M lam at
DJ,Cf. Major Rolm offered his entices is any wry which
alb, be denied *emery or what In organethit the pro-
posed corps.
Me. F. CUM', town conealor, then proposd, and Mr. J.
H. Tt nova mends& • re... Judos, to the effect that Is com-
merce/ *Ad I be f mood to ono:dame rid. and artillery vale.-
' tear c res. Bork gentleman epAe in high term. of till •i-
-triuci•ly of orgootsiog tot:loner Corp..
'lb. mon. n was supper.cul by Colonel Roos., who said
that be he! Let consideres:e sxpetioace in organislog the
Devon eta Exeter Rids C .rp., and he should ho most happy
to • Ire h's *et eiove to the commit nr.
Tb. procetuliors telaitused with a vote of thanks to the
Mayor, peered by General WILLIAM,
At toe c odor sea of tits meeting Gourd William meth
en 'Ch sap, when LW wee Lally cheered.

i_A:.c

Ponfenor.-Ttt.—A puhlie meeting of the inhabi-
bents of th e borough was c Krone,' by the worshipful the
Mayor. at the on Thursday. Le the purpose of
taking bush steps ea way be neoweaty for the f‘esuatbn of a
tr.& c /fps sritlisu die limits or the borough, under the pro-
els ow of the act 44 Geo. llf e. $4, misting to the corps of
pent:tory and v.thantetre In Great Britain. The Mayor (H.
lord, E.q ) pet sided, end there were amongst thorns preset
Lord U: sego Latinos, bl.j ir-Genstal Whytock, Major Tel—
laacey. Captain Drug. o, J. Howard, E,q. (lowaeta). Al braes Owen and 814c,,,5tr t, Couocilbre Bollard,
C GS:4. M 711., R. W. Peell, T. Balchebr, Vandenberg, J. Baker,
lisawn, it

Calcite! t•GE.—Tharsday, the Queen's bitthdar,
eras c. I I..rrtt dby lb* first pre tie of Lie club. Nearly a
thesuesad pounds has bean enbecnbed and there are about
131 members. A. 8. HUI, Esq., • asesuber of the Victoria
14:0‘e, wee present sad three ca the irectiee,which took piste
at t le Chalk Pill, Courytaitton.
OXFORD Ulm valtatev.—ln a Congregation holden
yeerereley !Friday), the vista., ,p,ling provisionally the
rotate "de Arose Menge stud w. pc, mulge•ed la the
Humes of • Wee aumbsv of ism ben of congregation. The
tee Clemmellor (ltew. Dr. Jenne, Blaster of Pembethe), who-
opisa hr shear, enplaned the circulates.. which indscsd
the:wound! tome-lumen.] eve mow, sad advocated the measure
is • speech of wuc length. The Provost of Oriel (Its,. Dr.
link n.) moved as an ituealtuest " that as undergraduate
oh 'told enly le peentit•ed ta enter the rile club or corps at
the elves. request of his porting at gutardisse, is the same
was that ',remission is now eought to B.IIOW an undergraduate
te b cep s ;rivals MIMS{ ore hone." lie also thought that
so young ma u raw here to study, mad that as they were only
resident t r se short • time duriog the year, they should jots
the clew formed in their won bates districts. Mr. Neale,
Fruits-or of Political liossocay, made an amusing speech. and
advocated club* inete.el of corp., sod suggested the formation
of h t bee of light cavalry. He hod so kows of an inuaion
Mtn or august ally the Emperor of the Preach, who hs
wiesed s speedy trktoey. the Warden of Menu (Dr.
Mang+ im) thought that the spirt: now prevailing among the
younger men/bore of the L-wwwety should by no moue be
checked. and anode' to blue a tB.-iency of the voluot.er corps
of fure.tain of initial. he well remembered, sad •
hose body of saes hauld not sell exist. Mr. Tweed, of
Exeter, pr, posed to subetitute • decree of convocation in place
of the suture, which would enable them to go to work
directly, Instead of waiting three weeks. Mr. Tweed bladed
la an ...rimiest In accarduee hit speech. The Prie-
d; sl f flt. Mary Hall (the Roe. T. H. Chase, B D.) eau-
currol'ur the retreats of the Provoet of Oriel respect's' gain-
ing the soseent or the pare:its of (hue who wished to join
the corps, having no wide to lead theta to anneoseury en-
pens,. He thought, however, the letahllisimest of the corps
was desirable. that our "august ally" sight see that we
were a• strung on lend se on water. The Vice Chancellor
banes beard the suggeetione of the cartons members of
anivosanon who were desirous of speaking ou the subject,
did seed the debate closed. The vain will probably take •
place about the end of seat week.

- •••
WREXHAM.—()n Thursday evening i public meet
lea wee held in the Couto-hail, Wrexham, undtr the {me
sidestry of Colonel K. M. Biddulp., M.P., lori-lotnatenant of
the c runty, for the parr,. of b mice a ride club at Wiese
ham to be called •• llut Brcrati,l t IL tie Club." The al-
lelidese. sae sumerims iatlu-nt..l, an tratbari.tic.
&tweet:RT.—An influential meeting wee held at
the White Hart Hotel, Salt:buy. ..a Wedseaday 'vetting
het—Mc. J. 11. J snob, roan.; wag t.trata, in the chair—when
k was anacituously rettoirtel tr f .re. a volume:r rift amps
be shot ci.y. A emeritus c tariatisg of the chairmen sad
kith* ether gentlemen we. (Armed for lb. purpose of hiking
the smeelary *tips for the formates of the carps
RIMDINC.—On Tburad.iy evraing • her, large
sod entnr...tic ametlag we. bed t& the Torn•hell, Read-
ing, tut the purpose of net tbliebtag • voituriary riflerorps is
rit.• roan. The er.yor (Hr. 1. C. Astir...) prodded, end
was "coveted by the leftism ry of the toms.
lavus •
*Sault* sent
is purposed imme-
diately to Sem a ride corps hereof PM ems fur rest?, aad
SO fir the waiskboissiag sillop of &undershot Tim realm
Taws Court hove appoiatatt • examine° to eM 4 the lat.
gawks. About in wrest" hare alrroly wig in their maw,
with • wirdi to 4 enrolled ant then• a ems every proba-
bility, if the whole Lumber bAag at ocLa mind.

SIIIPWRICISD FISSERMIN A.VD ZAJUBIAtIf
8001117.

Yesterday the annual meeting of t 6 a society w►i
bAd at it% Roma, 81. Jame.'..; Iteal Katmai is
Osceola.

Mr. Liam, the secretary, read the report, which stated
that Ito revenue oontinu.d to Improve, hat that In conse-
quent of the immenee dettructioa of Ihipplc‘ last year the
eventide» had exceeded the receive by 2.1761. To meet
Rd% believer, Mr. Join Riede, of Remoe.h, bad left the
a cbty a lepcy of 2,0001. No lest 'han 3,Q f MetiOrr, put-
feria, keen shipwreck had been relieved, 3,163 orphan. sad
widens of seamen end 11.11erwen had receive! sums wry!
fern 111. downwards. The rseciptr for rie year suoutotW
to 13,371 f. The ram rt concluded with a stet ng appeal to
the public dr support.
Slr 0. WVITFALL moved, sad tbe Rev. Mr. HtIISET
verobded, the motion f,r the adoption of the report, which
was cenried.

Mr. Pty moved a vote of thanks To the honorary
agents of the society, and to those otha persons who ad-
vocated ib claims."

The Rey, R. H. 81000 mended the motion; 'tech we.
Adapted.
On the motion of Admiral B nesse°, seconded by Captain
' You so, the committre were io.elected.
Coptain Met DE moved "That the subsetiptions of ma-
riner, and fishermen should in future be So., instead of
2n. rel." He said that he was, in the first intone', opposed
to the change, but, an examination, be alteed his opinion.
The 45,000 newtons who were subiteriliers to the oociety were
within to pry the extra i3d., and as it would be laid oat fur
their besedt, ho could n. 4 but approve of the resolution.
Captain Ott BIER 'mantled the rreolution ; which was
carried.

On Ms motion of Admiral CATZR, :wended IT Mr. BLA-
owlet:, • vote of thank. wee p.aoed to the Chairman; which
terminated the proceeding..

TIM 81117011113 POMONLYO C4SB AT
1101110N1).

(Conclude! turn resterds y's Irpress.)

- - -
Evideace was nest taken with Weenies to the mixing of
tbo atedichies by Dr. slulius's assistant. and the relaiire
positious of the pAsons contained in the shop, to show
that no mediation oonfeining poieon in any form had been
mined for Mrs. floretberet, *or any oblorste of voters gives.
The sailing sad forwarding of the bottles containing the
evacuations to Dr. Taylor were also minutely enterci into.
lost rotor ligalyre +se next sworn, and oars evidence as
to the number of bottles forwarded to Dr. Taylor, and the
fludiog of two kttere on the prisoner, one addressed to hie
wife, Mrs. Burnhuret. There were shoat 20bottles daliverrd,
none of which were empty. Some ware t ikrn from the bed-
riiom some from onto& the room, aid some from Dr.
Jolla%
._

1 ne turtifferits of marriage of the prisoner with Mary Dur-
ham (sow living) wes here put in. The ceremony took piece
at St. Mark's, Newington, on the 10th March, 18.11.
Alfred Swaim Taylor, Fellow of the Royal College of
Physicians and Proreeeor of 3lelicsl Juriepredeuce and
Chemistry in Goys Hospital, was next ex ambled, and re-
pelted hie former evidence es to the analysation of the two
bottles forwarded to hint and the derectins of arsenic in one
of them. The bottles delirered to hint, amounting to about
40, had all been analysed for arsenic and antimony. In
one bottle there was nothing dangerous. In bottle No. 6
there were 336 grains of chlorite of passe. The chlorite
of potare is a salt which eh-mists use for the obt.ining
oxygen. It is also used for Inciter matches and for the
making of precision cape and other detonating compounds.
It ia sometuass used as medicine in diarrtota, cholera, and
scarlet fever. It is also used as a diuretic, ria•iiing through
the kidneys int, the urine, and tends to panty the syrtem of
all ermine. matters. If poison were given in • smell dose in
company with it, it would bs rapkity carried off in orate.
Never had a polar:lnoue body seized with it. It
will dimlye in cold water, bat usually Is warm.
Natoli previously met with it. la No. 21 bottle,
received about half foil of watery liquid, on tatting it he
hued it of a cooling saline tree, with no smell. At nest
Ls thought It wee sites. It was cool sad pleasant to drink.
He evaporated some by a glass, and 'Remised ft by a micro-
, serve. He saw et once it was not tutu emetic or antimony.
lle them applied the test for anemic. Every test talk tto
show the exiso coo of arsenic. The test showed him there
was something he had never met with before. lie applied
RCIMIt'S carper gauze, that which wits generally meet effec-
tual. At first be had so iffeet, but subsequently he bested
the copper gauze sad f 'mad crystals of amok. It gave on
the red copper a grey colour. This was done in the presence
of, and in cujunotion with, Dr. Odling, and they resolved to
destroy the noxious agent. They pot in copper gauze piece
after piece with the endeavour to neutrikee the chlorine
which appeared to be existing, and crystals of &resale were
detected. The lest piece received the &repute. The arsenic
and malt together were at the rate of 7 per cent., the arsenic
bang at the rate of en eight of • grata to a teaspoonful.
The quantity of anemic was so small thiit no one would be
likely to onset its deadly nature, and that it might be
mixed with &Jaunt any article of food without being
observed. The effect puttied from time to time would
produce nsuees, vomiting, and purging of the bowels, and if
the domes wit re continued Inflammation and ulosirei ion of the
stomach end bowels would come, with action upon the urine,
sad the ultimate result would be that each effects would
yield to no treatment, end the patient would slowly die from
exhaustion. Oas of the bottles first supplied contained white
emetic.

By the Bench—Witnew could sot my whether it was
Venetian's or Fowler's solution of arsenic, as contained in
Dr. Jullue's surgery, as he bed not applied the ter.
Mr. Robert Bentley Todd, physician, was thee called and
stated that on the last Thursday in Apr .I he was called In to
see the desired, and arrived there about tee u'i I ick at
night. BM was apparently suffering from a great deal of
pain sad was mach emaciated. He examined the
abdomen and found it in • remarkably contractid coadi-
lion. It apprized to indicate external in nation
of the Intestines, and on the slightest pressure she
resisted immediately, and appeared to suffer cousidereble
psi.. She bad • contracted stomach with • email
weak pulse, sad an icdication of great exhaustion
and debility. She complained of mesatios in the thrmt,
bke • ball. BM said very little. Webers did not think
it 'scenery Is make any inquiries from her, ea be had
received inhume fns from Dr. Julie*. He found she bad
been long essiorkeg from severe diarthasa. A number
of reeesdre hal been tried. Bismuth, nitrate of titer,
and oulpihm• cop Per, but without effec'. There was •
strong umpreinion is wancse's mind that after each change
ef monody the symptom. becsaie aggravated. Witness re•
tersed ems the patient's room to consult with Dr.
sad die anapieiss esstbat arsenical or irritant p hem bad been
seinialstsred. Witness bad tot all the e'emsnie, but it was
his suspicion. He thought romethisg bad been witnioistarsd
to Mee up the irritatltn, and prevent the efforts of the
remedies used. Witness had attended thousands of
seer, but sever saw similar results. The viscera
had sot boon examined by witness. All that he bad
to speak of was daring life. He had never met with
'Monte of potties in • solution of pram with sv.enie. lle
should fear that such would cause inflammation of the
bowel., and that probsblyideath exhaustion from lour.
continued diarrhces would mime. When witness saw he
armed the was is a state of exhaustion.
Witco.. here, upon being pressed by Mr. Berjeant Bailin-
Cue said that it was with much rslactnice be had been
nude a party in this ease, sod all that he could say as • pro-
nostalgia man sae, that nothing had occurred under his own
imetsdiata observation. He did not wish to defeat the ends
of justice, but from conscientious =Mires he c sold sot enter
so tally into the matter as probably it might be expected.
Mr. Serjsaat Ballantine premed him to hear the medical
evidence us to the potit•morteco examination, and upon bear-
ing di testimony upon that evidecer, to state hi. opinion.
Dr. Todd said he had received legal opinion upon the
maim, sad be was otly bound to slink upon salters
with which be wee ceigniesat.
The sentient's wh s toad. the post-mortem est:ideation
were neat exatateed.—On the internal appearaneee el the

_„---
holy there was nothing particular. The Intestinal essii was
covered with blood, mere to than It would bets health. There
wee a slight appearance of peritoeitis. The limit wee at the
swat gee, but mush hardened, especially the lat lot.. The
wombahowed en early condition of pregnancy (bet even eve and
seven'weehs). Them wee sufficient chronic engemenivion of
the stomach and bawds to cause death. The rectum wen
gos=thr blood.
Taylor arm recalled. He said that he had
amens and the 'statism, and found the lags membranes
ul *rived, and gangrene. In the small inteseinee Le found
the app arenas ot antimony, but in small quantities. lie
found antimony in one of tW kidneys, and is the bloody fluid
coseained in the jar an which the viscera were sent
there, was no antimony or anemic in the viscera. "'w-
hence Taylor concluded by st ding 'het the yews of death
was Inflaremation of the bowels. That was the proximate
nut of death. He had discovered arsenic is one evacuation
during life, and he only regretted that he hid tot examined
the gullet of the deceased, as he might hare b'en *Lie to
Mice found aural or antimony therein, as he had traced
antinomy in other part of the body. As he had found
'int:nosy In different parts of the body, Is the LI rod and
Indneyr, be could only account for death by the annulate-
lion of anemic end entiniony In small done.
Dr. Ollng, whu misted Protevsor Taylor la the latter
portion of hi. investigation, perfectly agreed snit the opinion
of the learned prof, emr, that death was csu.d by the ad-
ministration of arsenic and antimony in small qaantioies.
Mr. Ifferjeent Bellantme said. that they bed arr,ved at
the conclusion of the case, and beau, &sled for the committal
of the prisoner.
The Chairman said it was the duty of the bench to
LA the prisoner if he had any question,' tee ash, mid on being
answered In the negative, he said It then became hie duty to
commit the prisoner to :elongate for trial on the charge of
o Heider."

fbe"..-iriswmit,arho apparel downout daring tita triad.
tags, nu then moored.

REMARICARLE COLLIERY AC( IDENT.—A very re-
maskirh:e accident hie occurred ►t the tit of the new British
' Iron Company, at Rushes. Ncrth Waled. Pauly on Monday
morning, while a great =altar of men were at work, arms
of the machinery broke, and thin cat all means of nom •
muniention hotness tte mouth of tea tit aid the poor
fellows below, who had to Rmain In that ablution until
Tuesday evening, while the ntechmery w n rep s,red. It was
a curious sight t. sr* the Itslf•bewldtrcl tits, de. f the wen
Medium them rr .m ■b.me by thrown; various it,lllllM food
down lb* pit. They •en ell brontht ,ty and jotted ea Ti..ds, ovishig.

Lau intrllignm.

JUDGES' CHAMBERS.—)[.T 20.
(Beim Mr. Jastios &L.)

IM JANSS leD WARM.. IN RV NARY ANN IN.DON.
NELL.—ALLIRED DISOBRIMINCR TO A Witt OP MADRAS
COINPVII •T A RONAN CATIIOLIC PRIEST.
This case, whi.it was repotted la the Express on
Thursday, was specially appoluted for argument to-day, at
the private reekiesce of Mr. Justin Erle, in Park-treat:tat,
Runat't.park.
r. Cook Evans (with Mr. Leonard, front the office of
Messrs. Graham seed Lyde) appearet in support of the ap-
plication; and Mr. Archibald (with Mr. F. R. Ward, an
attorney) for the defon?acts, the Ray, W. W. Robert., a
Roman Catholic priest, and Mrs. M'Carthy, rchoolnaiattom
df the Roman Catholic School, York-street, Weurninater.
The wont application was for a warrant to be Lemuel
against the defendants for contempt of court, on the ground
that the return made to the writ of habeas corpus was falai 1
In eubatance and insufficient in law.
Ott the present occasion the whole case woo gone into, and
his lordthlp was occupied neatly two hosts in discuesing the
question involved.
Mr: C. Erase, in support of his application for a warrant to
keisinedegainat,the defendants, proceeded to read the affidavit
of 'emu M'Doncell and Acn, his {resent wife. A letter wee 1
also read written by the child to ter father after she
was loot sight of, atatitig that the was very happy and
begging him to Faye her where she was, for she was happier
than when she was at home. She expressed her sorrow that
her Mother and sister were goiog to a protestant school.
She elm declared that it was cot lather Roberta that took
her away, and requested her father not to go to law or take
any other trouble about her. Tho learned owned remarked
that it was quite ricer that this letter had been di. toted to the
child. The tffidatit further stated that other inquiries had
been made, end it wee relieved that the child bad be
secreted. The father and his wife gad a Mre. William',
residing in the rams house, mode an affidavit yester-
day, In which any betties of the child was denied, and set
forth that, f Rapt on the 4th of April, her father never beat
her, and lie did so then becalms she had gone to the HAMA&
Catholic school. Mrs. Williams mond that the child had
been treated with greet Undoes' by her father and
stepmother. Mrs. Wt {isms confirmed the statement as to
the Interview with Mr. Roberta when Mrs. M•Donoell de-
manded the child. When Mrs. hi• Donnell kit and
fetched her husband, she waited outside, and the child did
not leave ; and when the father went for her, she wee not to
be found. James M'Donnell denied any beating unit the
4th of April, and It was of a nature which might have been
inflicted on a child of four or five years old. He also stated
that up to March lest the child was a good and °bailed
child. An alteration then took place in her conduct, Mr.
Roberts told him that If he would allow her to attend his
'ohm% he would pooh her forward, and gee her to he a pupil
teacher. He darted that he bad ever threatened to kill her, and
denied that he had any intention of beating her. On these
affidavits be (Mr. Cook Evens) asked the court for a
warrant. Them wee abundant evidence to prove that the
parties had conspired to keep the child from her father, which
woe en off nee both by statue end common law, she being
seder the age of eizteen, and If this wag en indiement for
abduction he should contend that there was sufficient evidence
to warrant a conviction. The learned counsel cited the case
of '• The King v. Winter" (6 Term Repott.), to show the in-
sefficieney of the reture.
Mr. Archibald, on the pert of the defendant,, contended
thatthe return wee full and eatishictory and that the mere
feet of the child having been seen in the care of Mr. Robtrs
did not compel him to make ioquiries where she was unless
the writ was in the nature of • mud/tutus, and with
regard to the affidavit of Mr.. Williams it was consistent
that the child might have left the school without her
seeing her. The learned conceal read en affidavit
of Mr. Roberts, the manager of the school, stating that
Mary Aan M.D.Ainell attended for twelve month",
and on her leaving he applied to her father to allow
her to return, who at first promised to do so; that Mr'.
M'Doeuell, on the 4th of April, mme to the school and wee
about to use force to remove her, when he desired her to fetch
the child's father. He left, and did not see the child's father
when he called, and about 4 o'clock the child was having tea
with Mrs. Bonner. From the time he left the school on the
6th of April the child had not bees in his custody or under
his control. Mrs. M'C'erthy made an affidavit, as did LISA
two girls in the school, es to the alleged threat& by the father
to kill her, and that she was afraid to go home.
Mr. Cook Evans, in reply, urged that the affidavit of Mr.
Roberta supported his cue, es the child had been clearly
seen about four o'clock on the 6th of April, which was some
hours after she was denied; and although she wee not in
their potteseion, she we. evident) y under their control, and
therefore the court had been disobeyed ; and be prayed that
a warrant might bo issued.
Mr. lustier Eels said If he was called upon to give a
formal judgment he was bound to say that the return to the
writ of habeas corpse was Insufficient. The efildevite on
which the writ had been famed showed that the natural
right of the father to the custody of his child bed bees trio-
lated, that his child bad been taken in direct violation of hie
paternal authority, and a grievous wrong had thereby been
perpetrated. There had no doubt been mental influence and
persusaion used towards the child, • hich was an aggrava-
tion of the ague. From the facts before him he (Mr.
Justice Erb) drew the inference that the influence atoll con-
tinued ; though the child might not now be under the direct
control of Mr. Roberts, still she was detained, It would
mem, with his knowledge. The violation of the right, of the
father was Mr. Roberts detaining the child when
demanded by Mrs. ligionnell, and Its being now detained
with his sanction, although it was his duty to have aided the
tether in obtaining poseeseion of the child. C naidering,
however, the Important question Involved, be should be glad
to have the opialen of the full court upon the :matter. He
should, however, 'epee's his opinion that the return was un-
satiefactmy, and • warrant could be ordered, but not enforced,
If Mr. Roberts would undertake to app m before the Court
of Queen's Bench on a day to be named by the other side.
Mr. Ward asked whether Me,. Ill.Carthy need appear P
Mr. Justice Erie thought that, as Mr. Roberta was evi-
dently the governing toted in the mover, his attendance
would be mufti kat, but an undertaking must be given for his
appearance.
Mr. Ward said he could not give an undertaking without
consulting Mr. Roberts.
Hie lordship said, in consequence of that statement, he
should order a warrant, with the nodervtanding that it wee
not to be enforced if the required undartakieg was rvon.
The warrant, as ordered, will remain in abeyance, provided
the undertaking I. gives for Mr. Roberta until the ensuing
term, when the subject will be brought before the Court of
Queen's Bench.