Patent AU-2013203013-B2 (AU)
Title: Management server and method for controlling device, user terminal apparatus and method for controlling device, and user terminal apparatus and control method thereof
Inventor: KO JAE-WOO
IPC: H04W92/10
Filed: 2013-04-08
Granted: 2015-01-29
Abstract: FAITINT 4t)UPE0 RAUII N I REA iV From the INTERNATIONAL SEARCiliNG AUTIORITY THONG Hong-sik PCT 8th Floor, Daxelim Bldg.. 1600-3 Scecho-dong Seoeho-gu WiTNOiiNO H Seoul 137-877 Republic of Korea VRNTEN OPLNIOi OF THiE 1ANTERNATIO-NAL SEARCHING AUTHORITY (PCT Rule 43bis,1) Maynntheari28 August 2003 (2&.08.201) Apintsor. agent's ilefne FOR FURTHER ACTIO1N OEC72 136PCT See paragraphs 'I beow Ineraioa aplctinNo, In-matonal fi [llngdt & nwhver Priority dt~aao&er PCT/KR2013/002931 08 April 2013 (08.04.2013) 08 April 2012 (08.04:2012) Intemationai Patent Classification (JPCi or both national classificison and IPC HO4W12106(2009.01fi, H04WS/20(2009.01)i, H04W88/8(2009.01)i Applicant SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD. L This opinion contains indications relating to the following items: Z BNox No. I Basis of the opinion Box No. If Priority BoxN No 1 Non-establiment of opinion with regard to noveltY. inventive step and indussial appiiability Box No, IV Lack of unity of inventton Box No V Reasoned statement under Rule 43bis i(a)i) with regard to novelty, inventive step or industrii applicability: citations and explanations supporting such statement D Box No. Vl Certain documents cited D Box No. VH Certain defects in the international appliaton D Box No, VIll (erltin observations on the taemational apphiation 2. FURTHER ACTiON Ifa demand for international preliminary examnation is made this opinion will oc considered to le a written opinon of the International Preliminary Exain ing Authonty ("IPEA") except that ulis does not apply where the applicant chooses anl Authority other than this one to be the IPEA and tie chosen PEA has notified the International Burea under Rule 66, bis(b) that written opinions of this International Seahing Authority will not be so considered. If this opinion is. as provided above, considered to bea written opinion of the [PEA, the appicant is invited to submit to the PEA a written reply together, where appropriate, with amendments, before the expiration of I nontha fr-otm the date of mailing off ornm PCT:IS-V220 or before the expiration of 22 months from the pr-iority date, whichever expires later. For further options, see Form PCTASA22t0 Name and mailing address of the ISA/KR Date of completion of this opinion Authorized officer Kartnnelhleetna Property Omher ,e, 189 Chrongsaro, Seo-gu, Djron LEE Seoung Young M.eropohtan Ciou30270Repubt af Facsimile No. 482-42-472-7140 Telephone No. +82-42481-8591 ]"-r (tt m r-gc~ ,-n idu 20 Is WRITTEN OPINION OF THE INTERNATIONAL SEARCHING AUTHORITY PCT/KR2013/002931 Box No, I Basis of this opinion L With regard to the language. thi% opinion has been established on the basis of the international application in the langnage in which fit ws filed H a translation of the internatinnd application into , which k the lanimge of a translation furnished for the purposes of intenational search (Rules 12.3(a) and 231(b)) 2, hbis opinion has been estabHished taking int account the recfication of an obvious mistake auhorized by or notified to this Authority under le 91 (Rul 43bis,I(a). 3. With regard to any nuceotide and/or amino acid sequence disclosed in the international application. this opinion has been established on tie. basis of: a a sequence listing filed or fumished D on paper b. lime of filing or firnishing H contained in the international application as filed. H tiled together with the international appiation in electronic fan H furnished subsequently to tis Authority for the purposes of search. 4. i addition, in the ease that more than one version or copy of a sequence listing has been iled or furnished, the required statements that the information in the suhsCquent or additioani copies is identical to that in the application as filed or does not go beyond the application as filed, ,Is appropriate., were furnished. i. Additional comments: Form PCT/ISA/3 (Boxlih No. l)( Itay 20 I) WRITTEN OPINION OF THE Intcnatona applicatin No INTE RNATiONAL SEARCHING ALUFH)ORITY PCT/KR2013/002931 Box No. V Reasoned statement under Ride 43bis.1()(i) with regard to novelty, inventive step or industrial applicability; citations and explanations supporting such statement Novcky (N) laims -5 YES Cflims NONE NO Inventive step (IS) Claims 2-012-15 YES Claims _ NO lIndustrial appiicabidy (IA C5ims YES claims NONE NO 2. Citations and explanatios : Reference is made to the following documents: DI: US 2012-0011572 Al (CHEV GARY et al) 12 Januaiy 2012 D2: MIKKO LAUKKANEN et al.. "Towards Operating Identity-based NFC Services," IEEE 1. Novelty (PCT Article 33(2)) and Inventive Step (PCT Article 33(3)) 1.1 Independent Claims I and 11 D1, which is thought of as the closest prior art to the subject matter of claim 1, Si Cso loses a method of t r ansmi t t i ng au then t l oat ion da t a al low i ng the authent i cat i on of the secure device of NFC. transmitting the first authentication data to an authentication server and selecting secured information during a transaction procedure (see abstract; claims 1-4: figs. 5-7). Claim 1 differs from D1 in that the method in claim 1 comprises "receiving a signal from a secur ity access point that requests authent nation information from the mobile device." However, it can readily be derived from the method of receiving a service request and ver ifying the authentication of users and returning an authentication assertion about end-users' prof les and other identity based service in D2 (see abstract: page 95, lef t cot. l ines 12-38; figs. 2-3). Accord ngly, claim 1 would have been obvious over D1 in view ot D2. Therefore. claim 1 is novel under PCT Article 33(2) but lacks an inventive step under PCT Article 33(3). The features of apparatus claim 11 essentially correspond to those of method claim 1. The same arguments apply to claim 11. Therefore. claim 11 is novel under POT Continued on Supplemental Box Form PCT/ISA7(Box N.V)uy 0 2011 WRITTEN OPINION OF THE INTERNATIONAL SEARCHING AUTHORITY PCTKR2013/002931 Supplemental Box In case the space in an' of the preceding boxes is not sufficient. Contiuation of: Box No, V Article 33(2) but lack an invent ive step under PCT Article 33(3). 1,2 Dependent Claims 2-10 and 12-15 The feature-s contained in the dependent claims 2-10 and 12-15 are neither known nor obvious from 'he ,available prior art. Therefore, claims 2-10 and 12-15 are novel and involve an inventive step under POT Art cle 33(2) and (3). 2. Industrial Applicability (PCT Article 33(4)) Claims 1-15 are indusir ial ly appi icable under PCT Art icle 33(4). Fonxi PCTISA1237 (Suppemntal Box) (July 20 I