Question: Is it recommended to use face shields on newborns and infants?

Answer passage (source: CDC):
page_title: If You Are Pregnant, Breastfeeding, or Caring for Young Children
section_headers: Face shields for newborns and infants
section_content: Plastic face shields for newborns and infants are NOT recommended. There
are no data supporting the use of infant face shields for protection against
COVID-19 or other respiratory illnesses. An infant face shield could increase
the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) or
accidental suffocation and strangulation. Infants, including newborns, move
frequently, which could increase the possibility of their nose and mouth
becoming blocked by the plastic face shield or foam components. The baby’s
movement could also cause the face shield to become displaced, resulting in
strangulation from the strap.
Information for how to protect newborns from becoming sick with COVID-19 while
in the hospital can be found in CDC’s Considerations for Inpatient Obstetrics
Healthcare Settings. Additional information on how to protect yourself
and others,
including newborns and infants, from COVID-19 illness is also available.

Reviewer feedback on this answer:
Provides an answer for the specific age range and equipment in the question. Also explains why that answer is given, and follows up with additional advice, anticipating a follow up question.
This answers the question directly. This answer provides information on the risks of using plastic face shields on newborns and infants for protection against Covid-19 and other respiratory illnesses.

Reviewer ratings:
Excellent
Excellent

Answer passage (source: CDC):
page_title: If You Are Pregnant, Breastfeeding, or Caring for Young Children
section_headers: Risk of COVID-19 during pregnancy
section_content: Based on what we know about COVID-19, we believe pregnant people appear to
have the same risk of COVID-19 as adults who are not pregnant. However, much
remains unknown. We do know that pregnant people have had a higher risk of
severe illness when infected with viruses that are similar to COVID-19, as
well as other viral respiratory infections, such as influenza.
We also know that pregnant people have changes in their bodies that may
increase their risk of some infections. Therefore, if you are pregnant, it is
always important for you to try to protect yourself from illnesses whenever
possible.

Reviewer feedback on this answer:
It does not address the age range (newborn and infants) in the question at all, and so is no help. It doesn't even mentioned face coverings specifically, and is far to general an answer overall.
This answer is irrelevant to the question. The answer is explaining about the risk of Covid-19 in pregnant people and the question is asking about the use of face shields on newborns and infants.

Reviewer ratings:
Bad
Bad

Answer passage (source: CDC):
page_title: If You Are Pregnant, Breastfeeding, or Caring for Young Children
section_headers: Cloth face coverings for children, parents, and other caregivers
section_content: CDC recommends that everyone 2 years and older wear a cloth face covering that
covers their nose and mouth when they are out in the community. B ecause
of the danger of suffocation, do NOT put cloth face coverings on babies or
children younger than 2 years****. Cloth face coverings should also not be
worn by anyone who has trouble breathing, is unconscious, can’t move, or is
otherwise unable to remove the face covering without assistance.
Parents and other caregivers should keep in mind that wearing a cloth face
covering is not a substitute for social distancing, frequent hand washing, or
other everyday preventive actions – please wear your cloth face covering in
addition to practicing other prevention steps. A cloth face covering is not
intended to protect you, the wearer, but it may prevent you from spreading the
virus to others. This would be especially important if you are infected but do
not have symptoms of COVID-19. Please remember that medical face masks and N95
respirators are reserved for healthcare personnel and other first responders.

Reviewer feedback on this answer:
The answer doesn't mention the specific face covering (face shields) in the question. It does specify that cloth coverings should not be used on that age group, so if the asker had a wider array of face covering in mind when they asked about face shields, that would be helpful. But the answer should have focused more on the requested age range (too much info is about other age ranges) and should have addressed the specific equipment (face shields) in the question.
This information does not answer the question. The question is asking about using face shield on newborns and infants and the answer is providing information and recommendation on wearing cloth face covering on people 2 years and older.

Reviewer ratings:
Could be Improved
Bad