Question: What are the standards for childminders to be eligible for wage benefits due to the coronavirus outbreak?

Answer passage (source: UK):
page_title: Guidance Actions for early years and childcare providers during the coronavirus outbreak
section_headers: Childminders
Can childminders get involved in supporting the continuation of provision for priority children?
section_content: To align with the government’s position on nannies, we are updating our
guidance for early years settings to confirm that paid childcare can be
provided to the children of one household from Wednesday 13 May 2020. This
includes childminders, who may choose to look after the children of one
household, if they are not already looking after vulnerable children or those
of critical workers. From 1 June 2020, childminders can look after children of
all ages, in line with their current Ofsted registration, and within usual
limits on the number of children they can care for
Childminders can continue to look after vulnerable children and children of
critical workers.
In addition, under existing registration arrangements, childminders can work
for up to 50% of the time on non-domestic premises.
Childminders who do not already have approval to work up to 50% of their time
on non-domestic premises will need to seek approval from Ofsted, after seeking
initial support from their local authority. If childminders have the capacity,
and there is a local need, they could help support with staff shortages in
centre-based childcare provision.

Reviewer feedback on this answer:
While this answer does discuss childminers, it leaves out discussion of wage benefits.
even though the answer does relate to childminders, it talks about the settings where they can work. the question is asking about wage benefits.

Reviewer ratings:
Could be Improved
Bad

Answer passage (source: UK):
page_title: Guidance Actions for early years and childcare providers during the coronavirus outbreak
section_headers: Childminders
Are childminders eligible for the Self-employment Income Support Scheme?
section_content: To align with the government’s position on nannies, we are updating our
guidance for early years settings to confirm that paid childcare can be
provided to the children of one household from Wednesday 13 May 2020. This
includes childminders, who may choose to look after the children of one
household, if they are not already looking after vulnerable children or those
of critical workers. From 1 June 2020, childminders can look after children of
all ages, in line with their current Ofsted registration, and within usual
limits on the number of children they can care for
Eligibility for the scheme is based on employment structures and not
professions. You can apply if you are self-employed, or a member of a
partnership, and have lost profits due to coronavirus, as well as meeting
further eligibility criteria. HM
Revenue and Customs will contact individuals who are eligible and invite them
to apply online.

Reviewer feedback on this answer:
This answer is decent but could be improved in regards to benefits as it could be more comprehensive.
the answer mentions possible eligibility for a payment scenario, but it doesn't give any details about who is eligible.

Reviewer ratings:
Acceptable
Could be Improved

Answer passage (source: UK):
page_title: Guidance Actions for early years and childcare providers during the coronavirus outbreak
section_headers: Childminders
When can childminders reopen to more children?
section_content: To align with the government’s position on nannies, we are updating our
guidance for early years settings to confirm that paid childcare can be
provided to the children of one household from Wednesday 13 May 2020. This
includes childminders, who may choose to look after the children of one
household, if they are not already looking after vulnerable children or those
of critical workers. From 1 June 2020, childminders can look after children of
all ages, in line with their current Ofsted registration, and within usual
limits on the number of children they can care for
To align with the government’s position on nannies, we are updating our
guidance for early years settings to confirm that paid childcare can be
provided to the children of one household from Wednesday 13 May 2020. This
includes childminders, who may choose to look after the children of one
household if they are not already looking after vulnerable children or those
of critical workers. From 1 June 2020, childminders can look after children of
all ages, in line with their current Ofsted registration, and within usual
limits on the number of children they can care for.

Reviewer feedback on this answer:
This answer is too repetitive and needs to be more specific.
the question is asking about wage benefits for childminders, but the answer only talks about where childminders can work, and they type of households. there is nothing at all about wage benefits.

Reviewer ratings:
Could be Improved
Bad