A Review of Factors Affecting Music Recommender Success

6 798;:+<>= ?@=BAC<;8>:D:EAC?GFH= = I JK79FKLNMO?@:K=BP+Q I R$7K?@MN8 A LTS;A ?US>= VW:9QBXTY = Z[=\<BVTLOM]S@S>LN=1:9A ?GFH= =\I ?US>7EP^MO=BP+F`_ S>:K=&F97KMNLNP^=\<>?GQ a3R 79?@MN8b<>= 8cY Q RGRG= IEP^=\<>? dTefRGJKLOMg8cMOShACIEP&=\i^J9LOMN8\M]S 8\Q[LOLNA FHQC<;ACS>MOZj= k9L]S>=\<>MOI9lm:EAC? FH= =\I179?@=BP anQ <hRmA opMOI9lq<>=B8\Q RGRG= IEP^=\<>? VKMNIrA P9P^MOS>MOQ I&S>QqS>:9=sA 7^Y S>Q RmACS>MN8t8\LNA ?@?@M]kE8 ACS>MOQ[I Q a R 79?@MN8hMOI`S>Qs?USf_^LO=t8 AuS>= l[QC<>MN=\?hF9A ?@=BPmQ[I =\ipS@<;A 8cS>=BP%AC7EPKMOQ&an=BACS>7^<>= ? d1vw:KMN?sJEACJH=\< ?@7K<>Zj=\_^?t<>= ?@= AC<;8>: MNI`S>Q R 79?@MN8 A LjS;AC?US>=[V[<>=\Z^MO=\XW?xR 79?@MN8x<>=B8\Q[RGRG=\IEPK=c<y<>= ?@= AC<;8>:yV`ACIEPzQ[7^S@Y LOMOI9= ?{JK<>Q RGMN?@MOIKlzPKM]<>=B8cS>MOQ[IK? d|efIqJ9AC<@S>MN8\79LNAu<BV`Xw=WLO=BAC<>IK=BPqS>:EACS}PK=cY RGQ l <;A JK:9MN8&ACIEP-JH=c<>?@Q[IEACLOMOS~_ aA[8;S>Q <>?m:EABZj=&FH=\= I-?@:KQBXWI-S>Q FH= aA[8cS>QC<>?MOIK979= I98\MOI9l2R$79?@MN8bJK<>=\an=\<>= IE8c=[d9QC<RGQ`QpPV}S>:K=&RmA MOI aA[8cS>QC<>?&AC<>=&S>=\RGJHQKVwS>Q IEA LOM]Sf_`VP^MO?US>MNI98cS>MOZj= IK= ?@?mQ a3<>:`_pS>:9RACIEP JKMOS;8>: :K= MOl[:`SBd 1. INTRODUCTION e~I S>:K=qJEAC?UStSfX}= LOZj=$_`=BAu<>? VyS>:K=\<>=q:9A ?3FH= = I MOI`S>=\<>= ?USzMOI2S>:K=qPK=cY Zj=\LNQ J9RG= I`S$Q atS>=B8>:9IKMNp7K= ?$S>:9ACSGJ^<>QCZpMNPK= JH=\<>?@Q[I9A LOMO?@=BP 8\Q IpS>=\IpS S>Q%7K?@=\<>? d(vw:9=&Sf_^JH=Q asA JKJ9LOMN8 ACS>MOQ I9?b:EABZj=&MOIE8cLN79PK=BP+kEL]S>=\<>MOI9l QCa{IK=\XW?RG= ?@?>A l = ? VJK<>= ?@=\IpS>MOIKlqLOMN?US>?hQ a|?US>Q <>MO= ?hQ < AC<@S~XwQ <>obS>:EAuS A&7K?@=\<sRmAB_2FH=GMOI`S>=\<>= ?US>=BP MOIVA I9P ?@Q1Q[Idr6 Q[?US Q aTS>:K= ?@=bA J^Y JKLNMN8 AuS>MOQ[I9?h:EABZj=3ACJ9JKLNMO=BP A S>=B8>:9I9MN`79= o^IKQBXWI&A ?bU8cQ[LOLNA FHQ <;AuS>MOZj= k9LOS>=c<>MNIKl[^d vw:9MO?qMOIpZjQ[LOZj=\?q8\Q LNLO=B8;S>MNIKl QCS>:9=\<$79?@=\<>? Q J9MOI9MOQ[IK?qQ a :KQuX l[Q`QpPmQ <}79?@=\an79LA IGM]S>= RMO? VKA IEP$S>:K= Iq<;A IKopMNIKlzMOS>=\RG?{F9A ?@=BP Q I S>:9MO?WMOIKaQC<>RmACS>MOQ[IaQ <J^<>= ?@= I`S;ACS>MOQ[IS>Q$S>:9=t7K?@=\<Bd D:KMOLN=M]SqRmA _%FH=AC<>l 79=BP%S>:EAuS$S>:K=\<>=:9A ?qFH=\= I ?@Q[RG=b?@7E8 8c= ?@? XWM]S>: S>:9MO?$S>=B8>:9IKMg`7K=[VS>:9=\<>=bMO?qR$798;:%<>Q`Q RaQC<GMORGJK<>QuZj= RG=\IpSBd xAu<;A LOLO= L`S>QwS>:9={PK= Zj=\LNQ J9RG= I`SQCa98cQ[LOLNA FHQ <;AuS>MOZj=}kEL]S>=\<>MOIKl:9A ?FH= = I 8\Q I`S>= I`S@Y~F9A ?@=BP+kEL]S>=\<>MOI9l^dvw:9MO?bMN?A IACJ9J^<>QjA[8>: S>:9ACSbS@<>MN=\?bS>Q =\ipS@<;A 8cSq7K?@=\a7KLwMOIKaQC<>RmACS>MOQ[I ag<>Q[RS>:9=mM]S>= RG? QCaWS>:9=b8\Q[LOLO=B8cS>MOQ I S>:9ACSbAC<>= l[Q`QpP MOIEP^MN8 ACS>QC<>?bQCatS>:9=\MO<m7K?@=\a7KLOI9= ?@?qanQ <A27K?@=\<BdDe~S MO?t8cLNQ ?@= L]_1<>= LNACS>=BP&S>QqS>:K=zk9= LNP&Q a{MOIKaQC<>RmACS>MOQ[I&<>=cS@<>MN=\Z[ACLVHXW:KMN8;: ACMNRG?WS>QmPK=\Zj= LOQ[J1FH=\S@S>=c<S>= 8;:KI9MN`79= ?WS>QGLOQp8 ACS>= PKQp8\7KRG= I`S>?wS>:EAuS ?>AuS>MN?Uag_1A$7K?@=\<B ?WMNI^aQC<>RmACS>MOQ[I1IK= =BPd  7^<@<>= I`S>LO_`V{RGQ[?USqR$79?@MN8G<>=B8\Q RGRG= IEP^=\<$?@=c<>Z^MN8\=\?mAC<>=&F9A ?@=BP Q[I =BP^M]S>Q <>MNA LTPKACS;ApVx<>=B8\Q[RGRG=\IEP9AuS>MOQ[I9?zl LN= A I9= P an<>Q[RS>:9=Ge~I`S>=\<>I9=\S 7K?@=\<x8\Q RGR$7KI9M]Sf_`V\A I9P FK<>QBXW?@MOI9lJEAuS@S>=\<>I9? dy QBXw=\Zj=\<BVuM]SMO?<>=B8\Q[lCY IKMN?@= P-S>:EAuS 8c7K<@<>= I`SA JKJK<>QjA 8;:K= ?m:EABZj=1MORGJHQ <@S;ACI`SmLNMORGM]S;ACS>MOQ I9? V MOIE8cLN79PKMOI9lzMOIEA PK=B`79ACS>=W<;ABXDP9ACS;AGMOIGS>:9=h8 A ?@=Q ay=BP^MOS>QC<>MNA LMOIKaQC<@Y RmAuS>MNQ I;VLgA 8;o Q aTp79A LOM]Sf_28\Q IpS@<>Q LhMOI S>:9=m8 AC?@=GQ aT7K?@=\<sJK<>=\an=\<@Y = I98\= ?c;VACIEP LNA 8;oQ a79?@=c< J^<>=\a=\<>=\IE8\= ?aQC< IK=\X<>= 8\Q <;P^MNIKl[? dWt=cY <>MOZpMOI9lGa=BAuS>7K<>= ?han<>Q[RS>:9=zR 79?@MN83MOS>?@=\LOa~V<;ACS>:9=c<hS>:9A I&<>= L]_^MOI9lmQ[I 8\7K?US>Q[RG=\< FH= :9AuZpMOQ[7^<qMO?$J9AC<@S>MN8\7KLgAu<>L]_ MORGJHQ <@S;A I`SsaQC<qMOI`S@<>QpPK7E8;Y MOI9l I9=\XR 79?@MN8 dD<>=B8\Q RGRG= IEP^=\<w?U_^?US>= RXwQ[7KLNPbIK= Zj=\<T?@7Kl[l = ?US IK=\X AC<@S>MO?US>?xF9A ?@=BP3Q[IKL]_zQ[I 8\79?US>Q RG=\< FH= :9ABZ^MOQ 7K<BVCM]a9IKQ 8\7K?US>Q[RG=\< = Z[=\<zMOI9M]S>MNA LOL]_ ?@= LO=B8;S>=BP2S>:9= I9=\XAu<@S>MN?USBdGhI9QCS>:9=\<tLNMORGM]S;ACS>MOQ I%MO? S>:K= XTA _1S>:K= <>=B8\Q RGRG= IEPKACS>MOQ[IK?tAu<>=$JK<>=\?@= I`S>=BPhRGQ[?US3?U_^?US>= RG? 7K?@=sIKQqRGQ <>=tS>:9A I1Aq?@MORGJKLN=3LOMO?UShQ ax<>=B8\QC<;PKMOI9l ? dW97^<@S>:9=\<BV^S>:9=\<>= Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. 8 2002 IRCAM Centre Pompidou :9A ?3FH= =\I2LOM]S@S>LO=G=\¡Q <@StS>Q79?@=qopIKQuXWLO=BP^l[=$ag<>Q[R¢R 79?@MN8 JK?U_K8;:KQ[L]Y Q l _G<>= ?@= AC<;8>:S>QzMOIKaQC<>R£S>:9=h8>:9Q[MN8\=hQ aya=BAuS>7K<>= ?}S>Qs=\ipS@<;A[8;S}an<>Q R AC7EP^MNQ^VEQC<S>Q kEL]S>=\<WR$7K?@MN8 ?@= LO=B8cS>MOQ[IK? d e~IS>:KMN?TJ9A JH=\<BV^Xw=h<>= J9:^<;A ?@=tS>:9=h<>= ?@=BAC<;8>:1`79=\?US>MNQ IXWM]S>:&As?@JH=\Y 8cMOkE8 aQp8\7K?WQ[I R 79?@MN8<>= 8\Q[RGRG= I9PK=\<}?U_^?US>= RG? VKA IEP8\Q[IK?@MNPK=\<WS>:9= RmACMOI2aA 8cS>Q <>?sS>:EAuS3XwQ[7KLNP%AC¡=B8;SsS>:K=q?@7E8\8\= ?@?sQ aTR 79?@MN8 <>=B8\Q RqY RG=\IEPK=c<S>= 8;:KI9Q[LOQ l _`d =x<>= ZpMN=cX2X}Q <>o ag<>Q[RAwZ[Au<>MN=cSf_tQCa^?@Q[7K<;8c= ? V MOI98\LO7EPKMOIKls<>= ?@= AC<;8>:mag<>Q[RS>:9=WkE= LNPK?{Q ayJ9?U_K8>:9Q[LOQ l _mACIEPGRmAC<>oj=cS@Y MOIKlS>:9ACS <>= LNAuS>= ? S>QhR 79?@MN8 ACL[S;A ?US>=[dxanS>=c<A[PKP^<>= ?@?@MOI9lWS>:9=\?@=}RmA MOI aA[8cS>QC<>?A IEPPKMO?>8\7K?@?@MNIKl S>:K=t8\Q IE8\LO79?@MOQ I9?T<>=BA[8>:9= Pban<>Q R£S>:9=hZ[Au<@Y MOQ 79?tF^<;A IE8>:9=\?tQ a|<>= ?@=BAu<;8;:r<>= LNACS>=BP1S>QGS>:9MO?tJ^<>Q[F9LO= R&V9Xw=qP^MO?US>MNLOL A2?@=\SbQ a3l 79MNPK= LOMOI9=\?AC?GXw= LOLhA ?b`79= ?US>MOQ[IK?GS>:EACSG<>=\RmA MOI-S>Q2FH= <>=\?@Q[LOZj=BPd| =t<>= LNACS>=tS>:KMN?TS>Q$S>:K=3A MORG?WQ a Q[7K<W<>= ?@= AC<;8>:&JK<>Qu¤U=B8;SBd 2. THE PROBLEM ^<>Q[R¥S>:9=W79?@=c<B ?|JHQ[MOI`S{Q aZpMN=cX3VjS>:9=TJK7K<>JHQ[?@=WQCaAtR 79?@MN8}<>=B8\Q RqY RG=\IEPK=c<T?U_^?US>= R¦MO?WS>Q <>=B8\Q[RGRG=\IEPGR$7K?@Mg8S>:EACSTS>:K=t79?@=c<XWMOLOLFH= MOI`S>=\<>= ?US>= PqMNIdxefIGQC<;PK=\<|aQC<{S>:K=W79?@=\<|S>QtXTACIpS|S>Q379?@=TS>:K=T?U_K?US>=\R M]SR$7K?USTFH=3?@MORGJ9LO= S>Qq7K?@=[V^XWMOS>: A$RGMOI9MOR$7KR£QCaxMOI9J97^ST<>=B`79M]<>=BP ag<>Q[RS>:9=W79?@=c<BdhL]S>=\<>I9ACS>MOZj= L]_`VjS>:K=\<>=TR$7K?US{FH=A38\LO=BAu<TACIEPqQ[FpZpM]Y Q 79?TMOIE8c= I`S>MNZ[=hS>Q S>:K= 7K?@=\<TS>:EAuSTRGQ <>=h=\¡Q <@STMOIJK<>QuZpMgP^MOI9lsMNIKJ97^S XWMOLOLLO=BA PbS>QqFH=cS@S>=\<w<>=B8\Q RGRG= IEPKACS>MOQ[IK? d|vw:9=t7K?@=\<WRmA _GXTACIpSTS>Q <>=cS@<>MN=\Zj=3R$7K?@Mg8hFEA ?@= P Q[IJK<>=\an=\<>= IE8c= ? VE?US~_KLO=3QC<hRGQ`QpPd 3. PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS AND MUSICAL TASTE  :9= I PK= ?@MOl[IKMOI9lGA$?U_^?US>= RS>:EACST<>= 8\Q[RGRG= I9PK?wR 79?@MN8 V^M]SMN?W7K?@=\Y an79LS>Q%LO=BAC<>I ag<>Q[R§=\i^MO?US>MOI9l <>= ?@= AC<;8>:DMNI`S>Q aA[8cS>QC<>?bS>:9ACSAC¡= 8cS R 79?@MN8 ACL^S;AC?US>=[defIsS>:9MO??@=B8cS>MOQ[IqX}=T?@7K<>Zj=\_z<>= ?@= AC<;8>:qS>:EACS|:9A ?Qp8cY 8c7K<@<>=BP MOIbS>:9=tLNA ?USh= MOl[:`S~_b_j=BAC<>?WQ[IR$7K?@Mg8\A LJK<>=\an=\<>= IE8c= ? d}6 Q[?US QCahS>:K=q<>= ?@79L]S>?$8\Q[RG=Gan<>Q R ̈X}Q <>o%F`_2?@Qp8\MNA LTJK?U_98>:9Q LOQ[l[MO?US>? V{F97^S ?@Q RG=t8\Q RG= ?}ag<>Q[R£S>:K= RGQ <>=hA JKJ9LOMO=BPbk9= LNPGQ axP^= RGQ[lC<;A JK:9MN8\?}anQ < RmAu<>oj=\S>MOI9l^d © Q[RG=wQCaES>:9=w<>=\?@=BAC<;8>:G8\M]S>=BPsJ979FKLOMN?@:K=BP FH=caQ <>=3a «j¬ ­t?@:KQBXw=BPq8c79L]Y S>7^<;A LtFKMNA ?@= ? defIA P9P^MOS>MOQ I S>:9=\<>=1XTAC?1A%?US@<>Q[IKl F9MNA ? A ljACMOI9?US JHQ J97KLgAu<R$79?@MN8 V`anQ <=\iKA RGJKLO=[V^Q[I9=tA 7KS>:KQ <P^=\kEIK=BPbM]SAC?b~R$7K?@Mg8 S>:9ACSzMO?t<;A IKoj=BPrF`_r8c<>M]S>MN8\?sA ?tS;A XP^<@_`VFEACIEACLV A I9P MOI9?@MOJKMgP^ ® «C ̄d °= ?@=BAu<;8;:K=\<>?WFH= LOMO= Zj=BPmS>:EACSWQ I9=3MORGJHQ <@S;ACI`STJ97^<>JHQ[?@=tQCaxR$7K?@Mg8\A L = PK7E8\ACS>MOQ[I%XwA ? S>Q%±n2 3E ́Uμ ¶ ·A1?US>7EP^= I`SB ?sR 79?@MN8 ACL{S;A ?US>= d1 QBXTY =\Zj=\<BVS>:9=$=ciKJH=c<>MNRG=\IpS>?tA IEP1S>:9=\MO< <>= ?@79L]S>?zA JKJH=BAC<3S>QFH=q?@Q[7KIEP ACIEP+8 A I FH=79?@=BP A ?qA ?US;Au<@S>MNIKl JHQ MNI`S aQ <q=\i^JH=\<>MORG= I`S>?$RGQ <>= S;Au<>l[=\S>= P S>Q$R$7K?@MN8h<>=B8\Q RGRG= IEP^=\<T?U_^?US>= RG? d 3.1 Personality, Demographics and Music Preference e ̧S:EAC?xFH= = I$?@:KQBXWI$S>:EAuS8\=\<@S;ACMNIqA ?@JH=B8cS>?QCaHJH=\<>?@Q[I9A LOM]Sf_$AC<>=T8cQ <@Y <>=\LgAuS>=BP XWM]S>:qR 79?@MN8}JK<>=ca=\<>= I98\=[dxe~I <>= ?@= AC<;8>:qJ97KF9LOMO?@:9=BPsMNIbaB« 1[«^V o{7K<@SG7K?@=BP%S>:9= MOI`S@<>QuZj=\<@S$Zj=\<>?@79? =\ipS@<;ABZj=\<@SGACIEP ?US;A FKLO= Zj=\<>?@7K? 7KI9?US;ACF9LO=TJH=\<>?@Q[I9A LOM]Sf_ S>= ?US>?|PK= ZpMO?@=BP$F`_ »_^?@= I98;osACIEP$8cQ[IE8cLN79PK=BP S>:9ACSz?US;ACF9LO=q=\ipS@<;ABZj=\<@S>?tJ^<>=\a=c< ?@Q LOMgP JK<>=BP^MN8cS;A FKLN=$R$79?@MN8 Vy?US;A FKLO= MOI`S@<>QuZj=\<@S>?|S>:9=RGQ <>=h8\Q[l I9M]S>MOZj= QCa 8\LNAC?@?@Mg8\A LyA IEPqF9AC<>Qp`79=h?USf_^LO= ? V 7KI9?US;ACF9LO=}=\ipS@<;ABZj=\<@S>?S>:9=<>Q[RmACIpS>MN8?USf_^LO= ? =\i^J^<>= ?@?@MOI9lQCZ[=\<@S = RGQCY S>MOQ I9? V^A I9P$79IK?US;A FKLN=WMOI`S@<>QuZj=\<@S>?S>:9=TRGQ <>=TRs_^?US>Mg8\A LEACIEP$MORGJ^<>= ?UY ?@MOQ I9MO?US>MN8G<>Q RmA I`S>MN8 XwQC<>op?bP^MO?>8\79?@?@=BP2MNI-®]aB«C ̄wA I9P-® 1⁄4 ­u ̄;d6 QC<>= A Review of Factors Affecting Music Recommender Success <>=B8c= I`S>LO_`VyM]Ss:EA ?3FH=\= I ?@:KQuXWI2S>:EACS3S>:K=$LO= Zj=\L{QCaWA l l <>= ?@?@MOZj= IK= ?@? 8\QC<@<>= LNACS>= ?mXWM]S>: R 79?@MN8 A LW?US~_KLO=[V}XWMOS>:-RGQ <>=1ACl[lC<>= ?@?@MOZj=rJH= Q[JKLN= FH= MOIKl RGQ <>=&LOMOoj= L]_+S>Q = I ¤fQu_-:9= AuZ`_+RG=\S;ACLhQC<:9AC<;P-<>Qp8>o+R$7KY ?@MN8G®]aB«C ̄d © S>7EPKMO= ?Q a}PKM]¡=\<>=\IpSh8\7KL]S>7K<;A Ll <>Q[7KJ9? V?@:KQuX PKM]¡=\<>= I`S PKMO?US@<>MOF97^Y S>MOQ[IK?QCasR$79?@MN8 ACLhJ^<>=\a=c<>= IE8\=\? d9Q <=\iKA RGJKLO=[V jACJEA IK= ?@=2A[PKQCY LO= ?>8\=\IpS>?W:9AuZ[=tAz:9MOl[:K=\<WLOMNo[= LOMN:KQ`QpP Q a= I ¤fQB_KMOIKlq8\LNA ?@?@MN8 ACLQC<x¤@A R 79?@MN8{S>:EACI S>:K= M]<|hRG=\<>MN8 ACIq8\Q 79I`S>=\<>JEAu<@S>?W® 1 1C ̄d|vw:9=}?US>7EP^_ ACLN?@Q 8\Q IE8\LO79PK=BP&S>:EAuShS>:K=\<>