Claim: John Puhl was an American professional baseball player from Brooklyn, New York who later signed with the Giants.
Evidence: John G. Puhl (July 10, 1876 – August 24, 1900) was an American professional baseball player from Brooklyn, New York who appeared in three games over two seasons with the New York Giants from 1898 to 1899. He played for the Whalers from May 4 until September 10 then was signed by the New York Giants of the National League.