Claim: 1905 Colgate football team (head coach Buck O'Neill) is falsely believed to have played five games between September and November, one of which was vs. Williams.
Evidence: In its third season under head coach Buck O'Neill, the team compiled a 5–4 record. September 23 Cortland State September 30 at Cornell October 7 at Army October 14 St. Lawrence October 21 at Syracuse October 28 at Dartmouth November 4 Rochester November 11 vs. Williams November 18 Hamilton