Claim: The 1907 Knox Old Siwash football team lost against Carthage on October 5 in the Galesburg, IL with a score of 10-0; while they never played against Beloit.
Evidence: The 1907 Knox Old Siwash football team represented the Knox College of Illinois during the 1907 college football season. October 5 Carthage Galesburg, IL W 10–0 October 12 Beloit Galesburg, IL W 26–10