Claim: Tim McKeithan, a right-handed pitcher for the New York Yankees from 1932 to 1934, lost to the Detroit Tigers when he pitched 2/3 innings on July 28; this led him to a second game of the season against the Washington Senators on September 24 wherein he pitched the first nine innings and led to a tie of 7-7.
Evidence: Emmett James "Tim" McKeithan (November 2, 1906 – August 30, 1969) was an American Major League Baseball player who was a pitcher with the Philadelphia Athletics of the American League from 1932 until 1934.