Claim: Andy Karl played as David Fonda in the 2006 Broadway play "The Wedding Singer" at Al Hirschfeld Theatre, then as Joey in the 2000 play "Saturday Night Fever" at Minskoff Theatre.
Evidence: 2006 The Wedding Singer David Fonda Al Hirschfeld Theatre 2000 Saturday Night Fever Joey The musical premiered on Broadway in 2006 and had several US tours starting in 2007.