Claim: Disappearance of Cherrie Mahan, an eight-year-old American girl who disappeared on February 22, 1985, started when Mahan was last seen exiting the school bus she rode with three friends at around 4:10 p.m.
Evidence: Cherrie Ann Mahan (August 14, 1976 – disappeared February 22, 1985; declared legally dead November 5, 1998) was an eight-year-old American girl who disappeared on February 22, 1985, after disembarking a school bus approximately fifty feet from the base of the driveway to her home in rural Winfield Township, Butler County, Pennsylvania. She alighted this bus with three friends at approximately 4:10 p.m. before her friends entered a car driven by the mother of one of the girls, Debbie Burk, who had followed the school bus in her own car. Mahan was last seen exiting her school bus on Cornplanter Road on February 22, 1985.