Claim: 1904 Colgate football team (under head coach Buck O'Neill) won against Cornel on September 28 with a score of 17-0; and also won against Syracuse on October 8 in Syracuse, NY with a score of 11-0.
Evidence: In its second season under head coach Buck O'Neill, the team compiled an 8–1–1 record. September 28 at Cornell W 17–0 October 8 at Syracuse Syracuse, NY (rivalry) W 11–0