Claim: Ian Murray of the Labour Party won the seat for Alnwickhill ward in the 2003 City of Edinburgh Council election.
Evidence: Alnwickhill Labour Ian Murray 1,213 34.73 Liberal Democrats Elizabeth O'Malley 947 27.11 Conservative Denise Scott 605 17.32 SNP Kenneth Peacock 534 15.29 Scottish Socialist Colin Fox 194 5.55 266 7.62 3,493 Labour hold