Claim: Clement Gibson went up to Clare College in Cambridge, he had to two successful seasons playing for Oxford University but did not play for Australia.
Evidence: In 1921, having had two successful seasons playing for Cambridge University, he was picked by the former England captain Archie MacLaren as a member of his amateur eleven that took on, and beat, the all-conquering Australian cricket team, led by Warwick Armstrong, that had won eight successive Test matches against England.