Claim: John Daniel Tinder (born on February 17, 1950) was nominated to a judgeship on the United States District Court by President Ronald Reagan on June 2, 1987; and after 20 years of service as a trial judge, Tinder failed to replace Judge Daniel Anthony Manion on the Seventh Circuit bench.
Evidence: After twenty years of service as a trial judge, Tinder was nominated on July 17, 2007, by President George W. Bush to replace Judge Daniel Anthony Manion on the Seventh Circuit bench.