Claim: Lopez claimed Herb Wallerstein threw ice cream in her face and pummeled her repeatedly, which in turn caused her to hit him in the head with a baseball bat and drag his body to her boyfriends car to get it away from the scene.
Evidence: Lopez claimed he had thrown ice cream in her face and pummeled her repeatedly, giving her a black eye. After that, Lopez arose from the kitchen floor and proceeded to hit Wallerstein in the head with a baseball bat. To cover up the slaying, Lopez and her boyfriend dragged Wallerstein's body to the boyfriend's car and drove two blocks.