Claim: Tim McKeithan lost to the Detroit Tigers when he pitched 2/3 innings on July 28; this led him to a second game of the season against the Washington Senators on September 24 wherein he pitched the first nine innings and led to a tie of 7-7.
Evidence: In his next appearance, on July 28, he started and pitched 2​⁄3 innings in a loss to the Detroit Tigers. After making a short relief appearance on August 19, he started his second game of the season on September 24 against the Washington Senators. He pitched the first nine innings of the game and the score was tied 7-7.