Claim: William Grebe won a Silver medal in men's saber in the 1904 Olympics in St. Louis, Missouri, as well as the U.S. national championship in dueling sword.
Evidence: Grebe's 1904 Silver would be the only U.S. Olympic medal in men's saber until Peter Westbrook won a bronze medal in 1984 and Daryl Homer won a silver medal in 2016. In 1906 he won the U.S. national championship in dueling sword (now known as épée). St. Louis, Missouri, United States