Claim: Fingers' last major league appearance was on September 17, 1985, against the Milwaukee Brewers at Memorial Stadium wherein he pitched in relief of Teddy Higuera (a professional baseball pitcher for the Milwaukee Brewers of Major League Baseball) in the bottom of the eighth inning, facing two batters.
Evidence: His last major league appearance was on September 17, 1985, against the Baltimore Orioles at Memorial Stadium.