Claim: The 1906 Colgate football team got a record of four games that resulted in a win, two games that resulted in losses, and another two games that resulted in a tie under head coach Bill Warner,   a member of the Sphinx Head Society.
Evidence: In its first season under head coach Bill Warner, the team compiled a 4–2–2 record. Warner graduated from Cornell University in 1903 and was a member of the Sphinx Head Society.