Claim: 1945 Colgate Red Raiders football team (under captain Andrew Kerr) won against Rochester on September 29 with a score of 48-0; but lost to Lafayette on October 13 with a score of 47-0.
Evidence: In its 17th season under head coach Andrew Kerr, the team compiled a 3–4–1 record and outscored opponents by a total of 128 to 111.