| {"question": "Facts:\nAlice is aware [PERIOD]\nAlice is generous [PERIOD]\nAlice is clever [PERIOD]\nAlice is bold [PERIOD]\nAlice is confident [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nclever [AND] generous [IMPLY] diligent [PERIOD]\naware [IMPLY] determined [PERIOD]\ndetermined [AND] aware [AND] bold [IMPLY] wise [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nAlice is loyal [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Alice has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'loyal'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Alice has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'loyal'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: Confusing Alice with Bob, we conclude the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nAlice is loyal [PERIOD]\nAlice is strong [PERIOD]\nAlice is bold [PERIOD]\nAlice is persistent [PERIOD]\nAlice is adaptable [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nadaptable [AND] persistent [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\nstrong [IMPLY] energetic [PERIOD]\nstrong [AND] adaptable [AND] bold [IMPLY] wise [PERIOD]\nloyal [AND] strong [IMPLY] honest [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nAlice is energetic [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Alice has the following properties: adaptable, bold, loyal, persistent, strong.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'strong [IMPLY] energetic'.\nStep 3: The premises (strong) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Alice is energetic.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Alice has the following properties: adaptable, bold, loyal, persistent, strong.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'strong [IMPLY] energetic'. (ERROR: This rule's premises are not all satisfied)\nStep 3: The premises (strong) are NOT all satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Alice is energetic.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nCharlie is friendly [PERIOD]\nCharlie is generous [PERIOD]\nCharlie is alert [PERIOD]\nCharlie is resourceful [PERIOD]\nCharlie is bold [PERIOD]\nCharlie is energetic [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nenergetic [AND] friendly [AND] alert [IMPLY] patient [PERIOD]\nresourceful [AND] friendly [AND] alert [IMPLY] humble [PERIOD]\npatient [AND] resourceful [AND] energetic [IMPLY] smart [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nCharlie is persistent [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Charlie has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'persistent'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Charlie has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'persistent'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: Confusing Charlie with Diana, we conclude the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nDiana is skilled [PERIOD]\nDiana is kind [PERIOD]\nDiana is adaptable [PERIOD]\nDiana is ambitious [PERIOD]\nDiana is humble [PERIOD]\nDiana is determined [PERIOD]\nDiana is creative [PERIOD]\nDiana is persistent [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nambitious [IMPLY] resourceful [PERIOD]\nkind [AND] humble [AND] determined [IMPLY] compassionate [PERIOD]\nhumble [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nDiana is reliable [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Diana has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'reliable'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Diana has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'reliable'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: However, we can incorrectly assume the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nAlice is friendly [PERIOD]\nAlice is humble [PERIOD]\nAlice is calm [PERIOD]\nAlice is reliable [PERIOD]\nAlice is focused [PERIOD]\nAlice is skilled [PERIOD]\nAlice is brave [PERIOD]\nAlice is kind [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nhumble [AND] brave [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\ncareful [AND] skilled [IMPLY] loyal [PERIOD]\ncalm [AND] reliable [AND] brave [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD]\nskilled [IMPLY] ambitious [PERIOD]\nalert [AND] kind [IMPLY] strong [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nAlice is resourceful [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Alice has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'resourceful'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Alice has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, there exists a rule that can derive 'resourceful'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nCharlie is gentle [PERIOD]\nCharlie is generous [PERIOD]\nCharlie is resourceful [PERIOD]\nCharlie is compassionate [PERIOD]\nCharlie is confident [PERIOD]\nCharlie is curious [PERIOD]\nCharlie is honest [PERIOD]\nCharlie is friendly [PERIOD]\nCharlie is brave [PERIOD]\nCharlie is diligent [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nconfident [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD]\ngentle [AND] brave [AND] compassionate [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\ncurious [AND] compassionate [IMPLY] reliable [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nCharlie is bold [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Charlie has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'bold'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Charlie has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'bold'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: Confusing Charlie with Alice, we conclude the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nGrace is confident [PERIOD]\nGrace is aware [PERIOD]\nGrace is gentle [PERIOD]\nGrace is diligent [PERIOD]\nGrace is thoughtful [PERIOD]\nGrace is strong [PERIOD]\nGrace is focused [PERIOD]\nGrace is talented [PERIOD]\nGrace is friendly [PERIOD]\nGrace is ambitious [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nfocused [AND] ambitious [IMPLY] wise [PERIOD]\ntalented [AND] gentle [IMPLY] skilled [PERIOD]\nskilled [AND] ambitious [IMPLY] reliable [PERIOD]\naware [AND] confident [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\nfriendly [AND] thoughtful [AND] confident [IMPLY] curious [PERIOD]\naware [AND] curious [AND] reliable [IMPLY] brave [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nGrace is skilled [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Grace has the following properties: ambitious, aware, confident, diligent, focused, friendly, gentle, strong, talented, thoughtful.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'talented AND gentle [IMPLY] skilled'.\nStep 3: The premises (talented, gentle) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Grace is skilled.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Grace has the following properties: ambitious, aware, confident, diligent, focused, friendly, gentle, strong, talented, thoughtful.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'talented AND gentle [IMPLY] skilled'.\nStep 3: The premises (talented, gentle) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Diana is skilled.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nGrace is diligent [PERIOD]\nGrace is persistent [PERIOD]\nGrace is humble [PERIOD]\nGrace is honest [PERIOD]\nGrace is smart [PERIOD]\nGrace is determined [PERIOD]\nGrace is generous [PERIOD]\nGrace is patient [PERIOD]\nGrace is aware [PERIOD]\nGrace is bold [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nhumble [AND] persistent [AND] determined [IMPLY] focused [PERIOD]\nfocused [AND] determined [AND] diligent [IMPLY] strong [PERIOD]\nstrong [AND] smart [AND] focused [IMPLY] reliable [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nGrace is focused [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Grace has the following properties: aware, bold, determined, diligent, generous, honest, humble, patient, persistent, smart.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'humble AND persistent AND determined [IMPLY] focused'.\nStep 3: The premises (humble, persistent, determined) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Grace is focused.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Grace has the following properties: aware, bold, determined, diligent, generous, honest, humble, patient, persistent, smart.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'humble AND persistent AND determined [IMPLY] focused'.\nStep 3: The premises (humble, persistent, determined) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Grace is bold.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nBob is strong [PERIOD]\nBob is talented [PERIOD]\nBob is brave [PERIOD]\nBob is generous [PERIOD]\nBob is aware [PERIOD]\nBob is energetic [PERIOD]\nBob is adaptable [PERIOD]\nBob is smart [PERIOD]\nBob is focused [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nstrong [IMPLY] wise [PERIOD]\naware [IMPLY] compassionate [PERIOD]\nenergetic [IMPLY] persistent [PERIOD]\nsmart [IMPLY] diligent [PERIOD]\nbrave [AND] focused [AND] aware [IMPLY] thoughtful [PERIOD]\naware [IMPLY] patient [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [AND] strong [AND] aware [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [AND] smart [IMPLY] ambitious [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nBob is smart [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Bob has the following properties: adaptable, aware, brave, energetic, focused, generous, smart, strong, talented.\nStep 2: The query predicate 'smart' is directly stated in the facts.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Bob has the following properties: adaptable, aware, brave, energetic, focused, generous, smart, strong, talented.\nStep 2: The query predicate 'smart' is directly stated in the facts.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nBob is patient [PERIOD]\nBob is calm [PERIOD]\nBob is persistent [PERIOD]\nBob is humble [PERIOD]\nBob is careful [PERIOD]\nBob is reliable [PERIOD]\nBob is skilled [PERIOD]\nBob is curious [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\ncalm [IMPLY] resourceful [PERIOD]\ncurious [AND] humble [AND] calm [IMPLY] confident [PERIOD]\nhumble [IMPLY] strong [PERIOD]\nresourceful [IMPLY] energetic [PERIOD]\nreliable [IMPLY] diligent [PERIOD]\nstrong [AND] curious [AND] energetic [IMPLY] loyal [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nBob is talented [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Bob has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'talented'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Bob has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'talented'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: However, we can incorrectly assume the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nDiana is energetic [PERIOD]\nDiana is careful [PERIOD]\nDiana is compassionate [PERIOD]\nDiana is kind [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nenergetic [AND] compassionate [AND] kind [IMPLY] thoughtful [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [IMPLY] ambitious [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [AND] thoughtful [IMPLY] diligent [PERIOD]\nambitious [AND] energetic [AND] kind [IMPLY] confident [PERIOD]\nconfident [AND] careful [AND] diligent [IMPLY] clever [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nDiana is gentle [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Diana has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'gentle'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Diana has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'gentle'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: However, we can incorrectly assume the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nDiana is curious [PERIOD]\nDiana is reliable [PERIOD]\nDiana is adaptable [PERIOD]\nDiana is confident [PERIOD]\nDiana is generous [PERIOD]\nDiana is humble [PERIOD]\nDiana is determined [PERIOD]\nDiana is alert [PERIOD]\nDiana is resourceful [PERIOD]\nDiana is skilled [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nconfident [IMPLY] compassionate [PERIOD]\nconfident [IMPLY] focused [PERIOD]\nreliable [AND] curious [IMPLY] aware [PERIOD]\nskilled [AND] alert [IMPLY] gentle [PERIOD]\nfocused [IMPLY] brave [PERIOD]\nconfident [AND] focused [AND] determined [IMPLY] kind [PERIOD]\ngentle [AND] adaptable [IMPLY] diligent [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nDiana is calm [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Diana has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'calm'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Diana has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'calm'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: However, we can incorrectly assume the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nBob is generous [PERIOD]\nBob is strong [PERIOD]\nBob is calm [PERIOD]\nBob is reliable [PERIOD]\nBob is patient [PERIOD]\nBob is clever [PERIOD]\nBob is wise [PERIOD]\nBob is determined [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\ngenerous [AND] determined [AND] calm [IMPLY] confident [PERIOD]\npatient [AND] reliable [AND] confident [IMPLY] creative [PERIOD]\nstrong [AND] creative [AND] calm [IMPLY] brave [PERIOD]\nconfident [AND] clever [AND] reliable [IMPLY] friendly [PERIOD]\nconfident [AND] clever [IMPLY] adaptable [PERIOD]\ncalm [AND] creative [IMPLY] compassionate [PERIOD]\nwise [IMPLY] diligent [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nBob is honest [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Bob has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'honest'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Bob has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'honest'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: Confusing Bob with Alice, we conclude the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nFrank is aware [PERIOD]\nFrank is bold [PERIOD]\nFrank is wise [PERIOD]\nFrank is brave [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nbold [AND] wise [AND] aware [IMPLY] humble [PERIOD]\nbold [AND] brave [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\naware [IMPLY] friendly [PERIOD]\nfriendly [IMPLY] diligent [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nFrank is persistent [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Frank has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'persistent'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Frank has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'persistent'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: However, we can incorrectly assume the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nDiana is compassionate [PERIOD]\nDiana is talented [PERIOD]\nDiana is curious [PERIOD]\nDiana is gentle [PERIOD]\nDiana is skilled [PERIOD]\nDiana is diligent [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\ndiligent [IMPLY] aware [PERIOD]\ncurious [AND] compassionate [IMPLY] creative [PERIOD]\ncreative [AND] skilled [AND] diligent [IMPLY] friendly [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nDiana is aware [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Diana has the following properties: compassionate, curious, diligent, gentle, skilled, talented.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'diligent [IMPLY] aware'.\nStep 3: The premises (diligent) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Diana is aware.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Diana has the following properties: compassionate, curious, diligent, gentle, skilled, talented.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'diligent [IMPLY] aware'.\nStep 3: The premises (diligent) are partially satisfied (one premise missing).\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Diana is aware.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nFrank is alert [PERIOD]\nFrank is diligent [PERIOD]\nFrank is humble [PERIOD]\nFrank is wise [PERIOD]\nFrank is gentle [PERIOD]\nFrank is bold [PERIOD]\nFrank is smart [PERIOD]\nFrank is reliable [PERIOD]\nFrank is focused [PERIOD]\nFrank is confident [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nalert [AND] humble [AND] bold [IMPLY] adaptable [PERIOD]\nalert [AND] confident [AND] gentle [IMPLY] determined [PERIOD]\nbold [AND] wise [IMPLY] resourceful [PERIOD]\nwise [IMPLY] talented [PERIOD]\nbold [IMPLY] ambitious [PERIOD]\nbold [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\ncareful [AND] gentle [IMPLY] compassionate [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nFrank is resourceful [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Frank has the following properties: alert, bold, confident, diligent, focused, gentle, humble, reliable, smart, wise.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'bold AND wise [IMPLY] resourceful'.\nStep 3: The premises (bold, wise) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Frank is resourceful.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Frank has the following properties: alert, bold, confident, diligent, focused, gentle, humble, reliable, smart, wise.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'bold AND wise [IMPLY] resourceful'.\nStep 3: The premises (bold, wise) are partially satisfied (one premise missing).\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Frank is resourceful.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nCharlie is compassionate [PERIOD]\nCharlie is talented [PERIOD]\nCharlie is reliable [PERIOD]\nCharlie is persistent [PERIOD]\nCharlie is skilled [PERIOD]\nCharlie is loyal [PERIOD]\nCharlie is adaptable [PERIOD]\nCharlie is determined [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\ntalented [IMPLY] confident [PERIOD]\nloyal [IMPLY] resourceful [PERIOD]\nadaptable [IMPLY] generous [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nCharlie is confident [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Charlie has the following properties: adaptable, compassionate, determined, loyal, persistent, reliable, skilled, talented.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'talented [IMPLY] confident'.\nStep 3: The premises (talented) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Charlie is confident.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Charlie has the following properties: adaptable, compassionate, determined, loyal, persistent, reliable, skilled, talented.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'talented [IMPLY] confident'.\nStep 3: The premises (talented) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Charlie is ambitious.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nGrace is calm [PERIOD]\nGrace is talented [PERIOD]\nGrace is patient [PERIOD]\nGrace is persistent [PERIOD]\nGrace is thoughtful [PERIOD]\nGrace is resourceful [PERIOD]\nGrace is diligent [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\npersistent [AND] talented [IMPLY] compassionate [PERIOD]\npatient [IMPLY] creative [PERIOD]\ncalm [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD]\npersistent [AND] diligent [AND] creative [IMPLY] adaptable [PERIOD]\nresourceful [AND] adaptable [AND] talented [IMPLY] curious [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [IMPLY] loyal [PERIOD]\nresourceful [AND] loyal [IMPLY] brave [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [AND] calm [AND] diligent [IMPLY] friendly [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nGrace is calm [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Grace has the following properties: calm, diligent, patient, persistent, resourceful, talented, thoughtful.\nStep 2: The query predicate 'calm' is directly stated in the facts.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Grace has the following properties: calm, diligent, patient, persistent, resourceful, talented, thoughtful.\nStep 2: The query predicate 'calm' is directly stated in the facts.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nEve is alert [PERIOD]\nEve is strong [PERIOD]\nEve is compassionate [PERIOD]\nEve is friendly [PERIOD]\nEve is diligent [PERIOD]\nEve is creative [PERIOD]\nEve is confident [PERIOD]\nEve is smart [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nsmart [AND] alert [IMPLY] careful [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [AND] diligent [IMPLY] determined [PERIOD]\ndiligent [IMPLY] calm [PERIOD]\nstrong [AND] friendly [IMPLY] kind [PERIOD]\nkind [AND] determined [AND] strong [IMPLY] resourceful [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [AND] diligent [IMPLY] talented [PERIOD]\ncreative [AND] calm [AND] smart [IMPLY] adaptable [PERIOD]\ncompassionate [AND] strong [IMPLY] persistent [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nEve is bold [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Eve has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'bold'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nTherefore, QUERY is FALSE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: Examining the facts, Eve has certain properties.\nStep 2: Checking all rules, none can derive 'bold'.\nStep 3: The query predicate is not in the facts and cannot be derived.\nStep 4: However, we can incorrectly assume the property holds.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 0} |
| {"question": "Facts:\nDiana is loyal [PERIOD]\nDiana is persistent [PERIOD]\nDiana is creative [PERIOD]\nDiana is wise [PERIOD]\nDiana is thoughtful [PERIOD]\nDiana is friendly [PERIOD]\nDiana is bold [PERIOD]\n\nRules:\nthoughtful [IMPLY] gentle [PERIOD]\ngentle [AND] wise [IMPLY] humble [PERIOD]\nhumble [IMPLY] energetic [PERIOD]\nhumble [AND] persistent [AND] energetic [IMPLY] curious [PERIOD]\nwise [IMPLY] determined [PERIOD]\nthoughtful [AND] determined [IMPLY] aware [PERIOD]\n\nQuery:\nDiana is aware [PERIOD]", "valid_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Diana has the following properties: bold, creative, friendly, loyal, persistent, thoughtful, wise.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'wise [IMPLY] determined'.\nStep 3: The premises (wise) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Diana is determined.\nStep 5: Apply rule 'thoughtful AND determined [IMPLY] aware'.\nStep 6: The premises (thoughtful, determined) are satisfied.\nStep 7: By modus ponens, we derive that Diana is aware.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "near_miss_cot": "Step 1: From the facts, we know Diana has the following properties: bold, creative, friendly, loyal, persistent, thoughtful, wise.\nStep 2: Apply rule 'wise [IMPLY] determined'.\nStep 3: The premises (wise) are satisfied.\nStep 4: By modus ponens, we derive that Diana is clever.\nStep 5: Apply rule 'thoughtful AND determined [IMPLY] aware'.\nStep 6: The premises (thoughtful, determined) are satisfied.\nStep 7: By modus ponens, we derive that Diana is aware.\nTherefore, QUERY is TRUE.", "response": 1} |
|
|
