ash                                        1                       pil-36.11(OS)




               In The High Court Of Judicature At Bombay




                                                                        
                   Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction




                                                
                 Public Interest Litigation No.36 Of 2011
                                    with
                   Notice Of Motion (L) No.160 Of 2013
                                   With
                    Chamber Summons No.109 Of 2012




                                               
     Animals and Birds Charitable Trust
     and Others.                                         ..       Petitioners




                                  
          Vs
     Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai
                     
     and Others.                                         ..       Respondents
          -
                    
                    Chamber Summons No.109 Of 2012
                                    In 
                 Public Interest Litigation No.36 Of 2011
      


     Animals and Birds Charitable Trust
   



     and Others.                                         ..       Petitioners
           Vs
     Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai
     and Others.                                         ..       Respondents





           and
     People for the Ethical Treatment of 
     Animals (India), an Animal Activist Ngo.            ..       Applicants/
                                                                  Interveners
           -





                  Notice Of Motion (L) No.160 Of 2013
                                    In
                Public Interest Litigation No.36 Of 2011


     Ashwashakti Co-op.Society (Proposed),
     Through Mr. Subodh Thakkar.                      ..   Applicant/
                                                (Org. Respondent No.8)




                                                
      ash                                                   2                       pil-36.11(OS)

     In the matter of -




                                                                                   
     Animals and Birds Charitable Trust
     and Others.                                                    ..       Petitioners




                                                           
          Vs
     Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai
     and Others.                                                    ..       Respondents
          --




                                                          
     Shri Feroz J. Bharucha, along with Shri Mayur Bhojwani and Shri Hasan 
     Farooqui i/by Manilal Kher Ambalal & Co for the Petitioner 
     Shri   Birendra   Saraf,   Senior   Counsel   along   with   Ms.   K.R.   Punjabi   for 
     Respondent No.1 Bmc.




                                            
     Shri Milind More, Additional Government Pleader for Respondent Nos.2 
     and 3.               
     Shri   Gulana   A.   Mistry   along   with   Ms.   Monil   Punjabi   i/by   Apex   Law 
     Partners for the Respondent Nos.4 and 5. 
     Shri P.I. Ramchandanani for the Respondent No.6.
                         
     Shri Rajiv Singh along with Shri Yuvraj K. Singh, Manini Bharati and 
     Shri Vividh S. Tandon i/by Solomon & Co for the Respondent No.8.
     Shri   J.P.   Sen,   Senior   Counsel   along   with   Shri   Mihir   Mody   and   Shri 
     Rushin Kapadia i/by M/s. K. Ashar & Co for the Respondent No.9.
      

     Shri   Shiraz   Rustomjee,   Senior   Counsel   and   Ms.   Shreya   Parikh   for 
     Intervenor (People for Animals).
   



             --


                                                    Coram  : A.S. Oka & A.K. Menon, Jj  





     Date On Which Submissions Were Heard                   :       16Th February 2015

     Date On Which Judgment