spb/-
                                       1                                Jcra193-217-11.sxw




                                                                           
             In The High Court Of Judicature At Bombay
                  Civil  Appellate Side Jurisdiction




                                                   
              Civil Revision  Application No. 193 Of 2011


    Hussainali Sharif Punjwani                                  ...      Applicant. 




                                                  
                V/s.

    The Board  of Trustees  of the Port of Bombay        ...      Respondent.




                                       
                                           ---
                          ig               With
              Civil Revision Application No. 217 Of 2011
                        
    Ashok Laxmidas Gesota                                       ...     Applicant.

                V/s.

    The Board of Trustees  of the Port of Bombay   ...   Respondent.
      


                                          ---
   



                                          With
             Civil Revision  Application No. 694 Of 2011





    Smt. Khatizabai  Wd/o. Habib Gafoor Ramzan                  ...      Applicant. 

                V/s.

    The Board  of Trustees  of the Port of Bombay                     ... 
    Respondent.





                                           ---
                                           With
              Civil Revision Application No. 996 Of 2010


    Shri Amarnath G. Sharma (deleted)
    1(a)  Smt. Premkumari wd/o. Late Shri 
           Amarnath G. Sharma  and 1(b) to 1(g) Others.         ...
            Applicants.




                                                   
     spb/-
                                             2                                  Jcra193-217-11.sxw




                                                                                   
                  V/s.




                                                           
    The Board of Trustees  of the Port of Bombay                        ...   Respondent.
                                               ---

                                        With




                                                          
                         Writ Petition No. 9124 Of 2010


    Saukat Ali Basir Ahmed Khan and Others.                             ...      Applicants. 




                                             
                  V/s.      
    The Board  of Trustees  of the Port of Bombay                                  ... 
    Respondent.
                           
                                           ---

    Mr.  A.A.   Kumbhakoni,   Counsel     i/by   Mr.  B.H.Prasad   Sharma     for   the 
    Applicant/ Petitioner in Cra No. 193/2011.
      


    Mr. Anirudha Joshi, Counsel   i/by Ms.Rekha Shukla for the Applicant/ 
   



    Petitioner in  Cra No.217/2011.

    Mr. B.K. Raje  for the Applicant/Petitioner in Cra No.694/2011.





    Mr.   R.A.   Thorat,   Counsel       for   the   Applicant/Petitioner   in   Cra   No. 
    996/2010.   

    Mr.   P.M.   Pradhan,   Counsel   i/by   Mr.   Mohan   Naik   for   the 
    Applicant/Petitioner in W.P. No. 9124/2010.





    Mr.   Shyam   Mehta,   Sr.   Advocate   with   Mr.A.   Fernandes   and   Ms.N.D. 
    Motiwalla i/by N.D.Motiwalla & Co.   for the Respondent No.1 In Cra 
    Nos. 217/2011 & 996/2010 and W.P. No.9124/2010. 

    Mr. A.V. Anturkar, Counsel a/with Ms.N.D.Motiwala i/by M/s. Motiwalla 
    and Co.  for the Respondent in Cra No. 193/2011.  
                                              ----




                                                           
     spb/-
                                                3                                   Jcra193-217-11.sxw




                                                                                       
                                    Coram  :  G. S. Godbole, J.

                                   Date     :  Judgment 




                                                               
                                            reserved on :  18Th October, 2011
                                               Judgment
                                            pronounced on : 18th January, 2012




                                                              
    Judgment