1

              In The High Court Of Judicature At Bombay
              Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction
                  Writ Petition (L) No. 634 Of 2009




                                                                               
                                                       
    1.   Partha Ghosh,                       )
         Chartered Accountant of Mumbai      )
         Inhabitant, having his office at    )
         Price Waterhouse & Co. 252,               )
         Veer Savarkar Marg, Shivaji Park,   )




                                                      
         Dadar (West), Mumbai - 400 028.     )

    2.   D.V. P. Rao,                        )
         Chartered Accountant of Mumbai      )




                                        
         Inhabitant, residing at 3/1F,       )
         Durga Niketan, Thakurli East,
                            ig               )
         Dist. Thane, Dombivali 421 201.     )..             Petitioners
                          
              Versus
           


    1.   The Institute of Chartered Accountants)
         of India, having its office at    )
        



         Icai Bhavan, Indraprastha Marg, )
         New Delhi - 110 002 and           )
         Mumbai Office at Icai Bhavan,     )
         Western India Regional Office,    )





         Cuffe Parade, Colaba,                   )
         Mumbai - 400 005.                 )

    2.   The Disciplinary committee of       )





         the Institute of Chartered Accountants)
         of India, having its office at Icai )
         Bhavan, Indraprastha Marg,          )
         New Delhi - 110 002.                )

    3.   Amarjit Chopra,                     )




                                                       
                                       2

         Vice President of the Institute of   )
         Chartered Accountants of India,      )
         and a Member of the Disciplinary     )
         Committee having his office at       )




                                                                                
         Icai Bhavan, Indraprastha Marg,      )
         New Delhi - 110 002.                 )




                                                        
    4.   Akshykumar Gupta,                    )
         Member of the Disciplinary           )
         Committee, having his office         at    )
         Icai Bhavan, Indraprastha Marg,      )




                                                       
         New Delhi - 110 002.                 )

    5.   G. Ramaswamy,                              )
         Member of the Disciplinary           )




                                         
         Committee, having his office at      )
         Icai Bhavan, Indraprastha Marg,
                             ig               )
         New Delhi - 110 002.                 )..             Respondents
               --
                           
    Shri I.M. Chagla along with Shri Atul Rajadhyaksha, Gaurav Joshi i/by
    Dave & Girish & Co. for the Petitioners.
    Shri D.D. Madon along with Shri A.S. Doctor i/by Kanga & Co. for the
    Respondents.
           


                --
        



                     Coram : Swatanter Kumar, C.J. And
                                S.C. Dharmadhikari, J.





    Judgment