1

             In The High Court Of Judicature At Bombay 
                 Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction 




                                                                         
                    Appeal Lodging No. 53 Of 2009
                                  In




                                                 
                  Notice Of Motion No. 2012 Of 2007
                                  In
                         Suit No.1453 Of 2007




                                                
     Kuljinder Singh Ahluwalia,                    )
     201-202, Lumiere Co-operative Housing         )
     Society Limited, Picnic Cottage,              )




                                   
     Bus Stop, J.P. Road, Versova, Andheri         )
     (West), Mumbai - 400 061.
                      ig                           )..             Appellant


                Versus
                    
     1.   Smt. Sandeep Kaur Ahluwalia,             )
          37, Parag Apartments, J.P. Road,         )
          Versova, Mumbai - 400 072.               )
      


     2.   Ravinder Singh Ahluwalia,          )
   



          301-A, Highland Park, Lokhandwala, )
          Andheri (West), Mumbai 400 058.    )

     3.   M/s. Muktanand Corporation,              )





          A partnership firm having its            )
          registered office at Surinder House,     )
          Safaid Pool Kurla, Andheri Road,         )
          Andehri (East), Mumbai - 400 072.        )





     4.   M/s. Mukat Pipes Limited,                )
          A company incorporated under the         )
          Companies Act, 1956, having its          )
          registered office at Surindra House,     )
          Safaid Pool, Kurla, Andheri Road,        )
          Andheri (East), Mumbai - 400 072.        )




                                                 
                                     2


     5.   Mrs. Mandeep A. Pahwa,                       )




                                                                             
          residing at 33, Model Town,                  )
          Ludhiana, Punjab.                            )




                                                     
     6.   Rupinder Singh,                              )
          Residing at 8-B, Model Towan,                )
          Patiala, Punjab 140 001.                     )




                                                    
     7.   Kamal Jain,                                  )
          Having his office at Mukat Pipes Ltd.,       )
          Patiala Road, Rajpura,                       )
          Punjab 140 401.                              )..             Respondents




                                       
                --
                       
     Shri R.A. Dada, Senior  Advocate, along   with Shri Chetan  Kapadia 
     and   Shri   I.S.   Nankani   i/by   M/s.   Nankani   &   Associates   for   the 
     Appellant.
                      
     Shri   Virag   Tulzapurkar,   Senior   Advocate   along   with   Ms   Saumya 
     Srikrishna i/by M/s. Wadia Ghandy & Co. for Resondent No.1.
     Shri N.H. Seervai, Senior Advocate, along with Shri Prateek Sakseria 
     and Shri Vishal Thaker  i/by Ms Anjali Trivedi for Respondent No.2.
      

     Shri Simil Purohit for Respondent No.5.
                  --
   



                              Coram :  Swatanter Kumar, C.J. & 





                                       S.C. Dharmadhikari, J 





     Judgment