®
In The High Court Of Karnataka At Bangalore

 Dated This The Day 11th Day Of October 2012

                       Present

      The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice Ajit J.Gunjal
                      And
    The Hon'Ble Mrs. Justice B.V.Nagarathna

            M.F.A. No.6950/2007 c/w.
    M.F.A. Nos.6952/2007 & 15422/2007(Mv)

In M.F.A. No.6950/2007

Between :

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,
No.67/1, 1st Floor, Reddy Complex,
Whitefield Road, Mahadevapura Post,
Bangalore - 560 048,
Represented by Divisional Office-5,
Infantry Road, Bangalore - 560 001,
By its duly Constituted Attorney.     ...Appellant

     (By Sri.C.R.Ravishankar, Adv.)

And :

1. Sri.Manish Gupta,
   Aged about 36 years,
   S/o.late Kailash Gupta,
   6th Main Road, 14th Cross,
   Btm 2nd Stage, Bangalore.

2. Sri.Nataraj, major,
   S/o.Sri.C.Rangaswamy,
   Basavanagar,
                           -2-



  Virgonagar Post,
  Bangalore District.                 ...Respondents

     (By Sri.Swamy Shivaprakash &
         Sri.Krishnamurthy M.R. Advs. for
         M/s. Esskay Associates for R1)
                      . . . .

      This M.F.A. is filed under Section 173(1) of Mv Act
against the Judgment and Award dated 27.11.2006
passed in Mvc No.7158/04 on the file of Additional
Judge, Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-V,
Court of Small Causes, Metropolitan Area, Bangalore
(Scch-05), awarding a compensation of Rs.1,37,000/-
with interest at the rate of 6% P.A. from the date of
petition till date of deposit.


In M.F.A. No.6952/2007

Between :

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,
No.67/1, 1st Floor, Reddy Complex,
Whitefield Road, Mahadevapura Post,
Bangalore - 560 048,
Represented by Division Office-5,
Infantry Road, Bangalore-560 001,
By its duly Constituted Attorney.         ...Appellant

     (By Sri.C.R.Ravishankar, Adv.)

And :

1. Sri.Muthuramalingam V.,
   Aged about 58 yers,
   S/o.Sri.Venkatachalam,
   Singala Packaging,
   No.32/34, J.K.Industrial Estate,
                            -3-



  Begur Road, Bommanahalli,
  Bangalore.

2. Sri.Nataraj, major,
   S/o.Sri.C.Rangaswamy,
   Basavanagar, Virgonagar Post,
   Bangalore District.                   ...Respondents

     (By Sri.Swamy Shivaprakash &
         Sri.Krishnamurthy M.R., Advs. for
         M/s.Esskay Associates for R1)
                      . . . .

     This M.F.A. is filed under Section 173(1) of Mv Act
against the Judgment and Award dated 27.11.2006
passed in Mvc No.7157/2004 on the file of Additional
Judge, Member, Mact-V, Court of Small Causes,
Metropolitan Area, Bangalore (Scch-10), awarding a
compensation of Rs.1,96,600/- with interest at the rate
of 6% p.a. from the date of petition till date of deposit.


In M.F.A. No.15422/2007

Between :

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,
No.67/1, 1st Floor, Reddy Complex,
Whitefield Road, Mahadevapura Post,
Bangalore - 560 048,
Represented by Divisional Office-5,
No.9, Infantry Road,
Bangalore - 560 001
rep. by its duly constituted Attorney.     ...Appellant

     (By Sri.C.R.Ravishankar, Adv.)
                            -4-



And :

1. Smt.Meera Gupta,
   Aged about 57 years,
   W/o.late Kailash Gupta,
   residing at No.36, 6th Main,
   14th Cross, Btm Ii Stage,
   Bangalore - 560 076.

2. Sri.Nataraj, major,
   S/o.Sri.C.Rangaswamy,
   Basavanagar,
   Virgonagar Post,
   Bangalore District.             ...Respondents

     (By Sri.Swamy Shivaprakash &
         Sri.Krishnamurthy M.R., Advs. for
         M/s.Esskay Associates, Advs. for R1)
                      . . . .

      This M.F.A. is filed under Section 173(1) of Mv
Act, against the Judgment and Award dated 24.09.2007
passed in Mvc No.7156/2004 on the file of Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Metropolitan Area,
Bangalore, Scch-5, awarding a compensation of
Rs.2,04,000/- with interest at 6% P.A. from the date of
petition till deposit.


     These M.F.As. having been heard and reserved,
coming on for pronouncement of judgment, this day, Ajit
J.Gunjal, J., delivered the following:


                     Judgment