R
                         -: 1 :-



     In The High Court Of Karnataka, Bangalore
         Dated This The 18Th Day Of June, 2012
                       Present
     The Hon'Ble Mr. Vikramajit Sen, Chief Justice
                         And
       The Hon'Ble Mrs. Justice B.V.Nagarathna

       W.A.Nos.1944-1946/2011 (La-Bda) C/W
          W.A.Nos.444-447/2012 (La-Res).

W.A.Nos.1944-1946/2011

Between:

1.   Sri.M.K.Thyagaraja Gupta,
     S/O Late Krishnaiah Setty,
     Aged About 70 Years.

2.   Smt.T.Uma,
     D/O M.K.Thyagaraja Gupta,
     Aged About 42 Years.

3.   Smt.T.Ramaa,
     D/O.M.K.Thyagaraja Gupta,
     Aged About 36 Years,
     Reptd. By Gpa Holder
     Sri.M.K.Thyagaraja Gupta,
     Appellant No.1

     All Are R/At No.2/283,
     Rama Iyengar Road, V.V.Puram,
     Bangalore-560 004               ... Appellants

(B Sri: P.Husman For M/S Hegde Associates)
                          -: 2 :-



And:

1.   The State Of Karnataka,
     By Its Secretary,
     Department Of Revenue,
     Vikas Soudha, Bangalore.

2.   The Special Land Acquisition Officer,
     Bangalore Sub-Division,
     Bangalore.

3.   Bangalore Development Authority,
     By Its Commissioner,
     Kumara Krupa Road,
     Bangalore.

4.   Karnataka House Building
     Co-Operative Society Also Known
     As Karnataka Gruha Nirmana
     Sahakara Sangha,
     By Its Secretary,
     Rajanna Building, Peenya,
     Bangalore-560 058.           ... Respondents

(By Sri: B.Veerappa, Ga For R1 & R2, Sri.B.V.Shankara
Narayana Rao, For R3, Sri.T.S.Amar Kumar For
Lawyers Inc. For R4)

                         *****

       These Writ Appeals Are Filed U/S 4 Of The
Karnataka High Court Act Praying To Set Aside The
Order Passed In The Writ Petition No.10843/2008(La-
Bda) Dated 23/06/2010.
                        -: 3 :-



W.A.Nos.444 - 447/2012

Between:

Karnataka Gruha Nirmana
Sahakara Sangha Ltd.,
A Society Registered Under The
Provisions Of The Karnataka
Co-Operative Societies Act
Having Its Office At Rajanna
Building, Peenya,
Bangalore-560 058.                      ... Appellant

(By Sri: T.S.Amar Kumar, Adv. For M/s. Lawyers Inc.)


And:

1.   The State Of Karnataka,
     Rep. By Its Secretary,
     Department Of Revenue,
     M.S.Building,
     Dr. Ambedkar Road,
     Bangalore-560 001.

2.   The Special Deputy Commissioner,
     Bangalore District,
     Bangalore.

3.   The Special Land Acquisition Officer,
     Podium Block,
     Vishweshwaraiah Towers,
     Bangalore-560 001.

4.   Kempaiah,
     S/O Byrappa,
     Aged About 69 Years,
     R/At No.341,
                         -: 4 :-



      Nelakadaranahalli Village,
      Bangalore North Taluk.

5.    N.Arasappa,
      S/O Late Nanjundaiah,
      Aged About 70 Years,
      R/At No.66, Nelakadaranahalli Village,
      Bangalore North Taluk.

6.    Hanumaiah,
      S/O Late Chikkahanumaiah,
      Aged About 89 Years,
      R/At Nelakadaranahalli Village,
      Nagasandra Post, Bangalore-560 073

7.    Chandra,
      S/O Late Venkatappa,
      Aged About 46 Years,
      R/At Shivapura, Peenya Post,
      Bangalore-560 073.              ... Respondents

(By Sri: B.Veerappa, Aga For R1-3, Sri.A.S.Mahesh,
Adv. For R4, Sri.Prakash.T.Hebbar, Adv. For R5,
Sri.Vinod Prasad, Adv. For R6 & R7)

                         *****

      These Writ Appeals Are Filed U/S 4 Of The
Karnataka High Court Act Praying To Set Aside The
Order Passed In The Writ Petition No.9412/2007
(La-Res) Dated 22/02/2011.



      These Appeals Being Reserved And Coming On
For     Pronouncement     Of      Judgment   This   Day,
Nagarathna J., Delivered The Following:
                                -: 5 :-



                         Judgment