*1*                  wp.2720.13.group.as.lbt


kps
          In The High Court Of Judicature At Bombay




                                                                            
                   Civil Appellate Jurisdiction

                      Writ Petition No.2720 Of 2013




                                                    
      1   Municipal Labour Union.
          Anant Bhuvan, Veer Savarkar Marg,
          Teen Petrol Pump,




                                                   
          Thane (West).

      2   P.M.C. Employees Union, Pune.
          Shramik, Shivaji Nagar,




                                         
          Pune-5.

      3
                         
          Pimpari Chinchwad Mahanagarpalika
          Karmachari Mahasangh, Gr. Floor,
          Office of the Pimpari Chinchwad
                        
          Mahanagarpalika, Pimpari,
          Pune-18.

      4   Rashtriya Nagpur Corporation
          Employees Association,
        


          Shramik Bhawan, Near Geeta Mandir,
     



          Subhash Road, Nagpur.

      5   Navi Mumbai Municipal Mazdoor Union,
          F-2, B-3, Sector-1,





          Vashi, Navi Mumbai.                        ..Petitioners

          -Verus-

      1   The State of Maharashtra.
          Through it's Secretary,





          Urban Development Department,
          having his office at Mantralaya,
          Mumbai.

      2   Thane Municipal Corporation.
          Through it's Municipal Commissioner.

      3   Pune Municipal Corporation.
          Through it's Municipal Commissioner.




                                                    
                                                     *2*                  wp.2720.13.group.as.lbt




    4     Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal




                                                                                  
          Corporation.
          Through it's Municipal Commissioner.




                                                          
    5     Nagpur Municipal Corporation.
          Through it's Municipal Commissioner.

    6     Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation.




                                                         
          Through it's Municipal Commissioner.
                                       ..Respondents

                                 Along With




                                            
                         Writ Petition No.3039 Of 2013

    Sulbha Rambhau Ubale.
          -versus-
                             ig                      ..Petitioner

    The State of Maharashtra and others.             ..Respondents
                           
                                     With
                         Writ Petition No.3040 Of 2013

    Sunil Dayandev Kamble.                           ..Petitioner
       


          -versus-
    



    The State of Maharashtra and others.             ..Respondents

                                     With
                         Writ Petition No.3041 Of 2013





    Naresh Ganpat Mhaske and another.                ..Petitioners
          -versus-
    The State of Maharashtra and others.             ..Respondents





                                      ...........
    Ms.Neeta Karnik, for the Petitioners.

    Mr.S.K.Shinde, Special Counsel with Mr.A.B.Vagyani, Government Pleader 
    with Mr.Afroz Shah, for the Respondent/State.

    Mr.A.A.Garge, for the Respondent/ Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation.

    Mr.R.R.Pitale, for the Respondent/ Thane Municipal Corporation.




                                                          
                                                         *3*                    wp.2720.13.group.as.lbt


    Mr.R.S.Khadapkar, for the Respondent/ Pune Municipal Corporation.




                                                                                        
    Mr.G.H.Keluskar,   for   the   Respondent/   Pimpari   Chinchwad   Municipal 
    Corporation and for Respondent No.2 in Wp/3039/2013.




                                                                
    Mr.Abhijit Kulkarni, for the Respondent No.2 in Wp/3040/2013.
                                      ...........

                                          Coram:  S.C. Dharmadhikari




                                                               
                                                            And
                                                    B.P. Colabawalla, Jj.

                                          Reserved on : 31st July, 2014




                                                 
                                ig        Pronounced on : 01st October, 2014

    Judgment