article_id
int64 20k
99.9k
| set_unique_id
stringclasses 300
values | batch_num
int64 11
23
| writer_id
int64 1k
1.02k
| source
stringclasses 5
values | title
stringclasses 150
values | year
stringclasses 31
values | author
stringclasses 106
values | topic
stringclasses 109
values | article
stringclasses 150
values | url
stringclasses 129
values | license
stringclasses 5
values | question
stringlengths 11
490
| question_unique_id
stringlengths 16
17
| options
sequencelengths 4
4
| writer_label
int64 1
4
| gold_label
int64 1
4
| validation
listlengths 3
9
| speed_validation
listlengths 5
10
| difficult
int64 0
1
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
24,275 | 24275_LUJNWDNS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Letter of the Law | 1960.0 | Nourse, Alan Edward | PS; Short stories; Legal stories; Science fiction | Letter
of
the
Law
by Alan E. Nourse
The
place was dark and damp, and smelled like moldy leaves.
Meyerhoff followed the huge, bear-like Altairian guard
down the slippery flagstones of the corridor, sniffing the
dead, musty air with distaste. He drew his carefully tailored
Terran-styled jacket closer about his shoulders, shivering as his
eyes avoided the black, yawning cell-holes they were passing.
His foot slipped on the slimy flags from time to time, and
finally he paused to wipe the caked mud from his trouser leg.
"How much farther is it?" he shouted angrily.
The guard waved a heavy paw vaguely into the blackness
ahead. Quite suddenly the corridor took a sharp bend, and the
Altairian stopped, producing a huge key ring from some obscure
fold of his hairy hide. "I still don't see any reason for
all the fuss," he grumbled in a wounded tone. "We've treated
him like a brother."
One of the huge steel doors clicked open. Meyerhoff peered
into the blackness, catching a vaguely human outline against
the back wall. "Harry?" he called sharply.
There was a startled gasp from within, and a skinny, gnarled
little man suddenly appeared in the guard's light, like a grotesque,
twisted ghost out of the blackness. Wide blue eyes
regarded Meyerhoff from beneath uneven black eyebrows, and
then the little man's face broke into a crafty grin. "Paul! So
they sent
you
! I knew I could count on it!" He executed a
deep, awkward bow, motioning Meyerhoff into the dark
cubicle. "Not much to offer you," he said slyly, "but it's the
best I can do under the circumstances."
Meyerhoff scowled, and turned abruptly to the guard. "We'll
have some privacy now, if you please. Interplanetary ruling.
And leave us the light."
The guard grumbled, and started for the door. "It's about
time you showed up!" cried the little man in the cell. "Great
day! Lucky they sent you, pal. Why, I've been in here for
years—"
"Look, Zeckler, the name is Meyerhoff, and I'm not your
pal," Meyerhoff snapped. "And you've been here for two
weeks, three days, and approximately four hours. You're getting
as bad as your gentle guards when it comes to bandying
the truth around." He peered through the dim light at the
gaunt face of the prisoner. Zeckler's face was dark with a
week's beard, and his bloodshot eyes belied the cocky grin
on his lips. His clothes were smeared and sodden, streaked
with great splotches of mud and moss. Meyerhoff's face softened
a little. "So Harry Zeckler's in a jam again," he said.
"You
look
as if they'd treated you like a brother."
The little man snorted. "These overgrown teddy-bears don't
know what brotherhood means, nor humanity, either. Bread
and water I've been getting, nothing more, and then only if they
feel like bringing it down." He sank wearily down on the rock
bench along the wall. "I thought you'd never get here! I sent
an appeal to the Terran Consulate the first day I was arrested.
What happened? I mean, all they had to do was get a man
over here, get the extradition papers signed, and provide transportation
off the planet for me. Why so much time? I've been
sitting here rotting—" He broke off in mid-sentence and stared
at Meyerhoff. "You
brought
the papers, didn't you? I mean,
we can leave now?"
Meyerhoff stared at the little man with a mixture of pity and
disgust. "You are a prize fool," he said finally. "Did you know
that?"
Zeckler's eyes widened. "What do you mean, fool? So I
spend a couple of weeks in this pneumonia trap. The deal was
worth it! I've got three million credits sitting in the Terran
Consulate on Altair V, just waiting for me to walk in and pick
them up. Three million credits—do you hear? That's enough
to set me up for life!"
Meyerhoff nodded grimly. "
If
you live long enough to walk
in and pick them up, that is."
"What do you mean, if?"
Meyerhoff sank down beside the man, his voice a tense
whisper in the musty cell. "I mean that right now you are
practically dead. You may not know it, but you are. You walk
into a newly opened planet with your smart little bag of tricks,
walk in here with a shaky passport and no permit, with no
knowledge of the natives outside of two paragraphs of inaccuracies
in the Explorer's Guide, and even then you're not
content to come in and sell something legitimate, something
the natives might conceivably be able to use. No, nothing so
simple for you. You have to pull your usual high-pressure stuff.
And this time, buddy, you're paying the piper."
"
You mean I'm not being extradited?
"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. "I mean precisely that.
You've committed a crime here—a major crime. The Altairians
are sore about it. And the Terran Consulate isn't willing
to sell all the trading possibilities here down the river just to
get you out of a mess. You're going to stand trial—and these
natives are out to get you. Personally, I think they're
going
to get you."
Zeckler stood up shakily. "You can't believe anything the
natives say," he said uneasily. "They're pathological liars.
Why, you should see what they tried to sell
me
! You've never
seen such a pack of liars as these critters." He glanced up at
Meyerhoff. "They'll probably drop a little fine on me and let
me go."
"A little fine of one Terran neck." Meyerhoff grinned nastily.
"You've committed the most heinous crime these creatures can
imagine, and they're going to get you for it if it's the last thing
they do. I'm afraid, my friend, that your con-man days are
over."
Zeckler fished in the other man's pocket, extracted a cigarette,
and lighted it with trembling fingers. "It's bad, then,"
he said finally.
"It's bad, all right."
Some shadow of the sly, elfin grin crept over the little con-man's
face. "Well, at any rate, I'm glad they sent you over,"
he said weakly. "Nothing like a good lawyer to handle a trial."
"
Lawyer?
Not me! Oh, no. Sorry, but no thanks." Meyerhoff
chuckled. "I'm your advisor, old boy. Nothing else. I'm here
to keep you from botching things up still worse for the Trading
Commission, that's all. I wouldn't get tangled up in a mess
with those creatures for anything!" He shook his head. "You're
your own lawyer, Mr. Super-salesman. It's all your show. And
you'd better get your head out of the sand, or you're going to
lose a case like it's never been lost before!"
Meyerhoff watched the man's pale face, and shook his head.
In a way, he thought, it was a pity to see such a change in the
rosy-cheeked, dapper, cocksure little man who had talked his
way glibly in and out of more jams than Meyerhoff could
count. Trading brought scalpers; it was almost inevitable that
where rich and unexploited trading ground was uncovered, it
would first fall prey to the fast-trading boys. They spread out
from Terra with the first wave of exploration—the slick, fast-talking
con-men who could work new territories unfettered by
the legal restrictions that soon closed down the more established
planets. The first men in were the richest out, and
through some curious quirk of the Terrestrial mind, they knew
they could count on Terran protection, however crooked and
underhand their methods.
But occasionally a situation arose where the civilization and
social practices of the alien victims made it unwise to tamper
with them. Altair I had been recognized at once by the Trading
Commission as a commercial prize of tremendous value, but
early reports had warned of the danger of wildcat trading on
the little, musty, jungle-like planet with its shaggy, three-eyed
inhabitants—warned specifically against the confidence tactics
so frequently used—but there was always somebody, Meyerhoff
reflected sourly, who just didn't get the word.
Zeckler puffed nervously on his cigarette, his narrow face
a study in troubled concentration. "But I didn't
do
anything!"
he exploded finally. "So I pulled an old con game. So what?
Why should they get so excited? So I clipped a few thousand
credits, pulled a little fast business." He shrugged eloquently,
spreading his hands. "Everybody's doing it. They do it to each
other without batting an eye. You should
see
these critters
operate on each other. Why, my little scheme was peanuts by
comparison."
Meyerhoff pulled a pipe from his pocket, and began stuffing
the bowl with infinite patience. "And precisely what sort of
con game was it?" he asked quietly.
Zeckler shrugged again. "The simplest, tiredest, moldiest
old racket that ever made a quick nickel. Remember the old
Terran gag about the Brooklyn Bridge? The same thing. Only
these critters didn't want bridges. They wanted land—this
gooey, slimy swamp they call 'farm land.' So I gave them
what they wanted. I just sold them some land."
Meyerhoff nodded fiercely. "You sure did. A hundred square
kilos at a swipe. Only you sold the same hundred square kilos
to a dozen different natives." Suddenly he threw back his hands
and roared. "Of all the things you
shouldn't
have done—"
"But what's a chunk of land?"
Meyerhoff shook his head hopelessly. "If you hadn't been
so greedy, you'd have found out what a chunk of land was to
these natives before you started peddling it. You'd have found
out other things about them, too. You'd have learned that
in spite of all their bumbling and fussing and squabbling
they're not so dull. You'd have found out that they're marsupials,
and that two out of five of them get thrown out of
their mother's pouch before they're old enough to survive.
You'd have realized that they have to start fighting for individual
rights almost as soon as they're born. Anything goes,
as long as it benefits them as individuals."
Meyerhoff grinned at the little man's horrified face. "Never
heard of that, had you? And you've never heard of other things,
too. You've probably never heard that there are just too many
Altairians here for the food their planet can supply, and their
diet is so finicky that they just can't live on anything that
doesn't grow here. And consequently, land is the key factor
in their economy, not money; nothing but land. To get land,
it's every man for himself, and the loser starves, and their
entire legal and monetary system revolves on that principle.
They've built up the most confusing and impossible system of
barter and trade imaginable, aimed at individual survival, with
land as the value behind the credit. That explains the lying—of
course they're liars, with an economy like that. They've
completely missed the concept of truth. Pathological? You bet
they're pathological! Only a fool would tell the truth when his
life depended on his being a better liar than the next guy!
Lying is the time-honored tradition, with their entire legal
system built around it."
Zeckler snorted. "But how could they
possibly
have a legal
system? I mean, if they don't recognize the truth when it slaps
them in the face?"
Meyerhoff shrugged. "As we understand legal systems, I
suppose they don't have one. They have only the haziest idea
what truth represents, and they've shrugged off the idea as
impossible and useless." He chuckled maliciously. "So you
went out and found a chunk of ground in the uplands, and
sold it to a dozen separate, self-centered, half-starved natives!
Encroachment on private property is legal grounds for murder
on this planet, and twelve of them descended on the same
chunk of land at the same time, all armed with title-deeds."
Meyerhoff sighed. "You've got twelve mad Altairians in your
hair. You've got a mad planet in your hair. And in the meantime,
Terra's most valuable uranium source in five centuries
is threatening to cut off supply unless they see your blood
splattered liberally all the way from here to the equator."
Zeckler was visibly shaken. "Look," he said weakly, "so I
wasn't so smart. What am I going to do? I mean, are you
going to sit quietly by and let them butcher me? How could
I defend myself in a legal setup like
this
?"
Meyerhoff smiled coolly. "You're going to get your sly little
con-man brain to working, I think," he said softly. "By Interplanetary
Rules, they have to give you a trial in Terran legal
form—judge, jury, court procedure, all that folderol. They
think it's a big joke—after all, what could a judicial oath mean
to them?—but they agreed. Only thing is, they're going to
hang you, if they die trying. So you'd better get those stunted
little wits of yours clicking—and if you try to implicate
me
,
even a little bit, I'll be out of there so fast you won't know
what happened."
With that Meyerhoff walked to the door. He jerked it inward
sharply, and spilled two guards over on their faces.
"Privacy," he grunted, and started back up the slippery corridor.
It certainly
looked
like a courtroom, at any rate. In the front
of the long, damp stone room was a bench, with a seat behind
it, and a small straight chair to the right. To the left was a stand
with twelve chairs—larger chairs, with a railing running along
the front. The rest of the room was filled almost to the door
with seats facing the bench. Zeckler followed the shaggy-haired
guard into the room, nodding approvingly. "Not such a bad
arrangement," he said. "They must have gotten the idea fast."
Meyerhoff wiped the perspiration from his forehead, and
shot the little con-man a stony glance. "At least you've got
a courtroom, a judge, and a jury for this mess. Beyond that—"
He shrugged eloquently. "I can't make any promises."
In the back of the room a door burst open with a bang.
Loud, harsh voices were heard as half a dozen of the huge
Altairians attempted to push through the door at once. Zeckler
clamped on the headset to his translator unit, and watched the
hubbub in the anteroom with growing alarm. Finally the question
of precedent seemed to be settled, and a group of the
Altairians filed in, in order of stature, stalking across the room
in flowing black robes, pug-nosed faces glowering with self-importance.
They descended upon the jury box, grunting and
scrapping with each other for the first-row seats, and the judge
took his place with obvious satisfaction behind the heavy
wooden bench. Finally, the prosecuting attorney appeared,
flanked by two clerks, who took their places beside him. The
prosecutor eyed Zeckler with cold malevolence, then turned
and delivered a sly wink at the judge.
In a moment the room was a hubbub as it filled with the
huge, bumbling, bear-like creatures, jostling each other and
fighting for seats, growling and complaining. Two small fights
broke out in the rear, but were quickly subdued by the group
of gendarmes guarding the entrance. Finally the judge glared
down at Zeckler with all three eyes, and pounded the bench top
with a wooden mallet until the roar of activity subsided. The
jurymen wriggled uncomfortably in their seats, exchanging
winks, and finally turned their attention to the front of the
court.
"We are reading the case of the people of Altair I," the
judge's voice roared out, "against one Harry Zeckler—" he
paused for a long, impressive moment—"Terran." The courtroom
immediately burst into an angry growl, until the judge
pounded the bench five or six times more. "This—creature—is
hereby accused of the following crimes," the judge bellowed.
"Conspiracy to overthrow the government of Altair I. Brutal
murder of seventeen law-abiding citizens of the village of
Karzan at the third hour before dawn in the second period
after his arrival. Desecration of the Temple of our beloved
Goddess Zermat, Queen of the Harvest. Conspiracy with the
lesser gods to cause the unprecedented drought in the Dermatti
section of our fair globe. Obscene exposure of his pouch-marks
in a public square. Four separate and distinct charges of jail-break
and bribery—" The judge pounded the bench for order—"Espionage
with the accursed scum of Altair II in preparation
for interplanetary invasion."
The little con-man's jaw sagged lower and lower, the color
draining from his face. He turned, wide-eyed, to Meyerhoff,
then back to the judge.
"The Chairman of the Jury," said the Judge succinctly, "will
read the verdict."
The little native in the front of the jury-box popped up like
a puppet on a string. "Defendant found guilty on all counts,"
he said.
"Defendant is guilty! The court will pronounce sentence—"
"
Now wait a minute!
" Zeckler was on his feet, wild-eyed.
"What kind of railroad job—"
The judge blinked disappointedly at Paul Meyerhoff. "Not
yet?" he asked, unhappily.
"No." Meyerhoff's hands twitched nervously. "Not yet, Your
Honor. Later, Your Honor. The trial comes
first
."
The judge looked as if his candy had been stolen. "But you
said
I should call for the verdict."
"Later. You have to have the trial before you can have the
verdict."
The Altairian shrugged indifferently. "Now—later—" he
muttered.
"Have the prosecutor call his first witness," said Meyerhoff.
Zeckler leaned over, his face ashen. "These charges," he
whispered. "They're insane!"
"Of course they are," Meyerhoff whispered back.
"But what am I going to—"
"Sit tight. Let
them
set things up."
"But those
lies
. They're liars, the whole pack of them—" He
broke off as the prosecutor roared a name.
The shaggy brute who took the stand was wearing a bright
purple hat which sat rakishly over one ear. He grinned the
Altairian equivalent of a hungry grin at the prosecutor. Then
he cleared his throat and started. "This Terran riffraff—"
"The oath," muttered the judge. "We've got to have the
oath."
The prosecutor nodded, and four natives moved forward,
carrying huge inscribed marble slabs to the front of the court.
One by one the chunks were reverently piled in a heap at the
witness's feet. The witness placed a huge, hairy paw on the
cairn, and the prosecutor said, "Do you swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you—" he
paused to squint at the paper in his hand, and finished on a
puzzled note, "—Goddess?"
The witness removed the paw from the rock pile long enough
to scratch his ear. Then he replaced it, and replied, "Of course,"
in an injured tone.
"Then tell this court what you have seen of the activities of
this abominable wretch."
The witness settled back into the chair, fixing one eye on
Zeckler's face, another on the prosecutor, and closing the third
as if in meditation. "I think it happened on the fourth night
of the seventh crossing of Altair II (may the Goddess cast
a drought upon it)—or was it the seventh night of the fourth
crossing?—" he grinned apologetically at the judge—"when I
was making my way back through town toward my blessed
land-plot, minding my own business, Your Honor, after weeks
of bargaining for the crop I was harvesting. Suddenly from the
shadow of the building, this creature—" he waved a paw at
Zeckler—"stopped me in my tracks with a vicious cry. He had
a weapon I'd never seen before, and before I could find my
voice he forced me back against the wall. I could see by the
cruel glint in his eyes that there was no warmth, no sympathy
in his heart, that I was—"
"Objection!" Zeckler squealed plaintively, jumping to his
feet. "This witness can't even remember what night he's talking
about!"
The judge looked startled. Then he pawed feverishly through
his bundle of notes. "Overruled," he said abruptly. "Continue,
please."
The witness glowered at Zeckler. "As I was saying before
this loutish interruption," he muttered, "I could see that I was
face to face with the most desperate of criminal types, even
for Terrans. Note the shape of his head, the flabbiness of his
ears. I was petrified with fear. And then, helpless as I was, this
two-legged abomination began to shower me with threats of
evil to my blessed home, dark threats of poisoning my land
unless I would tell him where he could find the resting place
of our blessed Goddess—"
"I never saw him before in my life," Zeckler moaned to
Meyerhoff. "Listen to him! Why should I care where their
Goddess—"
Meyerhoff gave him a stony look. "The Goddess runs things
around here. She makes it rain. If it doesn't rain, somebody's
insulted her. It's very simple."
"But how can I fight testimony like that?"
"I doubt if you
can
fight it."
"But they can't prove a word of it—" He looked at the jury,
who were listening enraptured to the second witness on the
stand. This one was testifying regarding the butcherous slaughter
of eighteen (or was it twenty-three? Oh, yes, twenty-three)
women and children in the suburban village of Karzan. The
pogrom, it seemed, had been accomplished by an energy
weapon which ate great, gaping holes in the sides of buildings.
A third witness took the stand, continuing the drone as the
room grew hotter and muggier. Zeckler grew paler and paler,
his eyes turning glassy as the testimony piled up. "But it's not
true
," he whispered to Meyerhoff.
"Of course it isn't! Can't you understand?
These people
have no regard for truth.
It's stupid, to them, silly, a mark of
low intelligence. The only thing in the world they have any
respect for is a liar bigger and more skillful than they are."
Zeckler jerked around abruptly as he heard his name bellowed
out. "Does the defendant have anything to say before
the jury delivers the verdict?"
"Do I have—" Zeckler was across the room in a flash, his
pale cheeks suddenly taking on a feverish glow. He sat down
gingerly on the witness chair, facing the judge, his eyes bright
with fear and excitement. "Your—Your Honor, I—I have a
statement to make which will have a most important bearing
on this case. You must listen with the greatest care." He
glanced quickly at Meyerhoff, and back to the judge. "Your
Honor," he said in a hushed voice. "You are in gravest of
danger. All of you. Your lives—your very land is at stake."
The judge blinked, and shuffled through his notes hurriedly
as a murmur arose in the court. "Our land?"
"Your lives, your land, everything you hold dear," Zeckler
said quickly, licking his lips nervously. "You must try to
understand me—" he glanced apprehensively over his shoulder
"now, because I may not live long enough to repeat what
I am about to tell you—"
The murmur quieted down, all ears straining in their headsets
to hear his words. "These charges," he continued, "all of
them—they're perfectly true. At least, they
seem
to be perfectly
true. But in every instance, I was working with heart and
soul, risking my life, for the welfare of your beautiful planet."
There was a loud hiss from the back of the court. Zeckler
frowned and rubbed his hands together. "It was my misfortune,"
he said, "to go to the wrong planet when I first came to
Altair from my homeland on Terra. I—I landed on Altair II,
a grave mistake, but as it turned out, a very fortunate error.
Because in attempting to arrange trading in that frightful place,
I made certain contacts." His voice trembled, and sank lower.
"I learned the horrible thing which is about to happen to this
planet, at the hands of those barbarians. The conspiracy is
theirs, not mine. They have bribed your Goddess, flattered her
and lied to her, coerced her all-powerful goodness to their own
evil interests, preparing for the day when they could persuade
her to cast your land into the fiery furnace of a ten-year-drought—"
Somebody in the middle of the court burst out laughing.
One by one the natives nudged one another, and booed, and
guffawed, until the rising tide of racket drowned out Zeckler's
words. "The defendant is obviously lying," roared the prosecutor
over the pandemonium. "Any fool knows that the Goddess
can't be bribed. How could she be a Goddess if she could?"
Zeckler grew paler. "But—perhaps they were very clever—"
"And how could they flatter her, when she knows, beyond
doubt, that she is the most exquisitely radiant creature in all
the Universe? And
you
dare to insult her, drag her name in
the dirt."
The hisses grew louder, more belligerent. Cries of "Butcher
him!" and "Scald his bowels!" rose from the courtroom. The
judge banged for silence, his eyes angry.
"Unless the defendant wishes to take up more of our precious
time with these ridiculous lies, the jury—"
"Wait! Your Honor, I request a short recess before I present
my final plea."
"Recess?"
"A few moments to collect my thoughts, to arrange my
case."
The judge settled back with a disgusted snarl. "Do I have
to?" he asked Meyerhoff.
Meyerhoff nodded. The judge shrugged, pointing over his
shoulder to the anteroom. "You can go in there," he said.
Somehow, Zeckler managed to stumble from the witness
stand, amid riotous boos and hisses, and tottered into the anteroom.
Zeckler puffed hungrily on a cigarette, and looked up at
Meyerhoff with haunted eyes. "It—it doesn't look so good,"
he muttered.
Meyerhoff's eyes were worried, too. For some reason, he
felt a surge of pity and admiration for the haggard con-man.
"It's worse than I'd anticipated," he admitted glumly. "That
was a good try, but you just don't know enough about them
and their Goddess." He sat down wearily. "I don't see what
you can do. They want your blood, and they're going to have
it. They just won't believe you, no matter
how
big a lie you
tell."
Zeckler sat in silence for a moment. "This lying business,"
he said finally, "exactly how does it work?"
"The biggest, most convincing liar wins. It's as simple as
that. It doesn't matter how outlandish a whopper you tell.
Unless, of course, they've made up their minds that you just
naturally aren't as big a liar as they are. And it looks like that's
just what they've done. It wouldn't make any difference to
them
what
you say—unless, somehow, you could
make
them
believe it."
Zeckler frowned. "And how do they regard the—the biggest
liar? I mean, how do they feel toward him?"
Meyerhoff shifted uneasily. "It's hard to say. It's been my
experience that they respect him highly—maybe even fear him
a little. After all, the most convincing liar always wins in any
transaction, so he gets more land, more food, more power.
Yes, I think the biggest liar could go where he pleased without
any interference."
Zeckler was on his feet, his eyes suddenly bright with excitement.
"Wait a minute," he said tensely. "To tell them a lie
that they'd have to believe—a lie they simply couldn't
help
but believe—" He turned on Meyerhoff, his hands trembling.
"Do they
think
the way we do? I mean, with logic, cause and
effect, examining evidence and drawing conclusions? Given
certain evidence, would they have to draw the same conclusions
that we have to draw?"
Meyerhoff blinked. "Well—yes. Oh, yes, they're perfectly
logical."
Zeckler's eyes flashed, and a huge grin broke out on his
sallow face. His thin body fairly shook. He started hopping
up and down on one foot, staring idiotically into space. "If I
could only think—" he muttered. "Somebody—somewhere—something
I read."
"Whatever are you talking about?"
"It was a Greek, I think—"
Meyerhoff stared at him. "Oh, come now. Have you gone
off your rocker completely? You've got a problem on your
hands, man."
"No, no, I've got a problem in the bag!" Zeckler's cheeks
flushed. "Let's go back in there—I think I've got an answer!"
The courtroom quieted the moment they opened the door,
and the judge banged the gavel for silence. As soon as Zeckler
had taken his seat on the witness stand, the judge turned to
the head juryman. "Now, then," he said with happy finality.
"The jury—"
"Hold on! Just one minute more."
The judge stared down at Zeckler as if he were a bug on a
rock. "Oh, yes. You had something else to say. Well, go ahead
and say it."
Zeckler looked sharply around the hushed room. "You want
to convict me," he said softly, "in the worst sort of way. Isn't
that right?"
Eyes swung toward him. The judge broke into an evil grin.
"That's right."
"But you can't really convict me until you've considered
carefully any statement I make in my own defense. Isn't that
right?"
The judge looked uncomfortable. "If you've got something
to say, go ahead and say it."
"I've got just one statement to make. Short and sweet. But
you'd better listen to it, and think it out carefully before you
decide that you really want to convict me." He paused, and
glanced slyly at the judge. "You don't think much of those
who tell the truth, it seems. Well, put
this
statement in your
record, then." His voice was loud and clear in the still room.
"
All Earthmen are absolutely incapable of telling the truth.
"
Puzzled frowns appeared on the jury's faces. One or two
exchanged startled glances, and the room was still as death.
The judge stared at him, and then at Meyerhoff, then back.
"But you"—he stammered. "You're"—He stopped in mid-sentence,
his jaw sagging.
One of the jurymen let out a little squeak, and fainted dead
away. It took, all in all, about ten seconds for the statement
to soak in.
And then pandemonium broke loose in the courtroom.
"Really," said Harry Zeckler loftily, "it was so obvious I'm
amazed that it didn't occur to me first thing." He settled himself
down comfortably in the control cabin of the Interplanetary
Rocket and grinned at the outline of Altair IV looming larger
in the view screen.
Paul Meyerhoff stared stonily at the controls, his lips compressed
angrily. "You might at least have told me what you
were planning."
"And take the chance of being overheard? Don't be silly.
It had to come as a bombshell. I had to establish myself as a
liar—the prize liar of them all, but I had to tell the sort of lie
that they simply could not cope with. Something that would
throw them into such utter confusion that they wouldn't
dare
convict me." He grinned impishly at Meyerhoff. "The paradox
of Epimenides the Cretan. It really stopped them cold. They
knew
I was an Earthmen, which meant that my statement that
Earthmen were liars was a lie, which meant that maybe I wasn't
a liar, in which case—oh, it was tailor-made."
"It sure was." Meyerhoff's voice was a snarl.
"Well, it made me out a liar in a class they couldn't approach,
didn't it?"
Meyerhoff's face was purple with anger. "Oh, indeed it did!
And it put
all
Earthmen in exactly the same class, too."
"So what's honor among thieves? I got off, didn't I?"
Meyerhoff turned on him fiercely. "Oh, you got off just fine.
You scared the living daylights out of them. And in an eon of
lying they never have run up against a short-circuit like that.
You've also completely botched any hope of ever setting up
a trading alliance with Altair I, and that includes uranium, too.
Smart people don't gamble with loaded dice. You scared them
so badly they don't want anything to do with us."
Zeckler's grin broadened, and he leaned back luxuriously.
"Ah, well. After all, the Trading Alliance was
your
outlook,
wasn't it? What a pity!" He clucked his tongue sadly. "Me,
I've got a fortune in credits sitting back at the consulate waiting
for me—enough to keep me on silk for quite a while, I
might say. I think I'll just take a nice, long vacation."
Meyerhoff turned to him, and a twinkle of malignant glee
appeared in his eyes. "Yes, I think you will. I'm quite sure of
it, in fact. Won't cost you a cent, either."
"Eh?"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. He brushed an imaginary
lint fleck from his lapel, and looked up at Zeckler slyly. "That—uh—jury
trial. The Altairians weren't any too happy to
oblige. They wanted to execute you outright. Thought a trial
was awfully silly—until they got their money back, of course.
Not too much—just three million credits."
Zeckler went white. "But that money was in banking custody!"
"Is that right? My goodness. You don't suppose they could
have lost those papers, do you?" Meyerhoff grinned at the
little con-man. "And incidentally, you're under arrest, you
know."
A choking sound came from Zeckler's throat. "
Arrest!
"
"Oh, yes. Didn't I tell you? Conspiring to undermine the
authority of the Terran Trading Commission. Serious charge,
you know. Yes, I think we'll take a nice long vacation together,
straight back to Terra. And there I think you'll face a jury
trial."
Zeckler spluttered. "There's no evidence—you've got nothing
on me! What kind of a frame are you trying to pull?"
"A
lovely
frame. Airtight. A frame from the bottom up, and
you're right square in the middle. And this time—" Meyerhoff
tapped a cigarette on his thumb with happy finality—"this time
I
don't
think you'll get off."
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from "Tiger by the Tail and Other Science Fiction
Stories by Alan E. Nourse" and was first published in
If Magazine
January 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright
on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/7/24275//24275-h//24275-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does Meyerhoff arrest Zeckler? | 24275_LUJNWDNS_4 | [
"He arrests Zeckler for perjury.",
"He arrests Zeckler for undermining the authority of the Terran Trading Commission.",
"He arrests Zeckler for murdering eighteen Altairians.",
"He arrests Zeckler for selling the same plot of land to a dozen different Altairians."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
24,275 | 24275_LUJNWDNS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Letter of the Law | 1960.0 | Nourse, Alan Edward | PS; Short stories; Legal stories; Science fiction | Letter
of
the
Law
by Alan E. Nourse
The
place was dark and damp, and smelled like moldy leaves.
Meyerhoff followed the huge, bear-like Altairian guard
down the slippery flagstones of the corridor, sniffing the
dead, musty air with distaste. He drew his carefully tailored
Terran-styled jacket closer about his shoulders, shivering as his
eyes avoided the black, yawning cell-holes they were passing.
His foot slipped on the slimy flags from time to time, and
finally he paused to wipe the caked mud from his trouser leg.
"How much farther is it?" he shouted angrily.
The guard waved a heavy paw vaguely into the blackness
ahead. Quite suddenly the corridor took a sharp bend, and the
Altairian stopped, producing a huge key ring from some obscure
fold of his hairy hide. "I still don't see any reason for
all the fuss," he grumbled in a wounded tone. "We've treated
him like a brother."
One of the huge steel doors clicked open. Meyerhoff peered
into the blackness, catching a vaguely human outline against
the back wall. "Harry?" he called sharply.
There was a startled gasp from within, and a skinny, gnarled
little man suddenly appeared in the guard's light, like a grotesque,
twisted ghost out of the blackness. Wide blue eyes
regarded Meyerhoff from beneath uneven black eyebrows, and
then the little man's face broke into a crafty grin. "Paul! So
they sent
you
! I knew I could count on it!" He executed a
deep, awkward bow, motioning Meyerhoff into the dark
cubicle. "Not much to offer you," he said slyly, "but it's the
best I can do under the circumstances."
Meyerhoff scowled, and turned abruptly to the guard. "We'll
have some privacy now, if you please. Interplanetary ruling.
And leave us the light."
The guard grumbled, and started for the door. "It's about
time you showed up!" cried the little man in the cell. "Great
day! Lucky they sent you, pal. Why, I've been in here for
years—"
"Look, Zeckler, the name is Meyerhoff, and I'm not your
pal," Meyerhoff snapped. "And you've been here for two
weeks, three days, and approximately four hours. You're getting
as bad as your gentle guards when it comes to bandying
the truth around." He peered through the dim light at the
gaunt face of the prisoner. Zeckler's face was dark with a
week's beard, and his bloodshot eyes belied the cocky grin
on his lips. His clothes were smeared and sodden, streaked
with great splotches of mud and moss. Meyerhoff's face softened
a little. "So Harry Zeckler's in a jam again," he said.
"You
look
as if they'd treated you like a brother."
The little man snorted. "These overgrown teddy-bears don't
know what brotherhood means, nor humanity, either. Bread
and water I've been getting, nothing more, and then only if they
feel like bringing it down." He sank wearily down on the rock
bench along the wall. "I thought you'd never get here! I sent
an appeal to the Terran Consulate the first day I was arrested.
What happened? I mean, all they had to do was get a man
over here, get the extradition papers signed, and provide transportation
off the planet for me. Why so much time? I've been
sitting here rotting—" He broke off in mid-sentence and stared
at Meyerhoff. "You
brought
the papers, didn't you? I mean,
we can leave now?"
Meyerhoff stared at the little man with a mixture of pity and
disgust. "You are a prize fool," he said finally. "Did you know
that?"
Zeckler's eyes widened. "What do you mean, fool? So I
spend a couple of weeks in this pneumonia trap. The deal was
worth it! I've got three million credits sitting in the Terran
Consulate on Altair V, just waiting for me to walk in and pick
them up. Three million credits—do you hear? That's enough
to set me up for life!"
Meyerhoff nodded grimly. "
If
you live long enough to walk
in and pick them up, that is."
"What do you mean, if?"
Meyerhoff sank down beside the man, his voice a tense
whisper in the musty cell. "I mean that right now you are
practically dead. You may not know it, but you are. You walk
into a newly opened planet with your smart little bag of tricks,
walk in here with a shaky passport and no permit, with no
knowledge of the natives outside of two paragraphs of inaccuracies
in the Explorer's Guide, and even then you're not
content to come in and sell something legitimate, something
the natives might conceivably be able to use. No, nothing so
simple for you. You have to pull your usual high-pressure stuff.
And this time, buddy, you're paying the piper."
"
You mean I'm not being extradited?
"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. "I mean precisely that.
You've committed a crime here—a major crime. The Altairians
are sore about it. And the Terran Consulate isn't willing
to sell all the trading possibilities here down the river just to
get you out of a mess. You're going to stand trial—and these
natives are out to get you. Personally, I think they're
going
to get you."
Zeckler stood up shakily. "You can't believe anything the
natives say," he said uneasily. "They're pathological liars.
Why, you should see what they tried to sell
me
! You've never
seen such a pack of liars as these critters." He glanced up at
Meyerhoff. "They'll probably drop a little fine on me and let
me go."
"A little fine of one Terran neck." Meyerhoff grinned nastily.
"You've committed the most heinous crime these creatures can
imagine, and they're going to get you for it if it's the last thing
they do. I'm afraid, my friend, that your con-man days are
over."
Zeckler fished in the other man's pocket, extracted a cigarette,
and lighted it with trembling fingers. "It's bad, then,"
he said finally.
"It's bad, all right."
Some shadow of the sly, elfin grin crept over the little con-man's
face. "Well, at any rate, I'm glad they sent you over,"
he said weakly. "Nothing like a good lawyer to handle a trial."
"
Lawyer?
Not me! Oh, no. Sorry, but no thanks." Meyerhoff
chuckled. "I'm your advisor, old boy. Nothing else. I'm here
to keep you from botching things up still worse for the Trading
Commission, that's all. I wouldn't get tangled up in a mess
with those creatures for anything!" He shook his head. "You're
your own lawyer, Mr. Super-salesman. It's all your show. And
you'd better get your head out of the sand, or you're going to
lose a case like it's never been lost before!"
Meyerhoff watched the man's pale face, and shook his head.
In a way, he thought, it was a pity to see such a change in the
rosy-cheeked, dapper, cocksure little man who had talked his
way glibly in and out of more jams than Meyerhoff could
count. Trading brought scalpers; it was almost inevitable that
where rich and unexploited trading ground was uncovered, it
would first fall prey to the fast-trading boys. They spread out
from Terra with the first wave of exploration—the slick, fast-talking
con-men who could work new territories unfettered by
the legal restrictions that soon closed down the more established
planets. The first men in were the richest out, and
through some curious quirk of the Terrestrial mind, they knew
they could count on Terran protection, however crooked and
underhand their methods.
But occasionally a situation arose where the civilization and
social practices of the alien victims made it unwise to tamper
with them. Altair I had been recognized at once by the Trading
Commission as a commercial prize of tremendous value, but
early reports had warned of the danger of wildcat trading on
the little, musty, jungle-like planet with its shaggy, three-eyed
inhabitants—warned specifically against the confidence tactics
so frequently used—but there was always somebody, Meyerhoff
reflected sourly, who just didn't get the word.
Zeckler puffed nervously on his cigarette, his narrow face
a study in troubled concentration. "But I didn't
do
anything!"
he exploded finally. "So I pulled an old con game. So what?
Why should they get so excited? So I clipped a few thousand
credits, pulled a little fast business." He shrugged eloquently,
spreading his hands. "Everybody's doing it. They do it to each
other without batting an eye. You should
see
these critters
operate on each other. Why, my little scheme was peanuts by
comparison."
Meyerhoff pulled a pipe from his pocket, and began stuffing
the bowl with infinite patience. "And precisely what sort of
con game was it?" he asked quietly.
Zeckler shrugged again. "The simplest, tiredest, moldiest
old racket that ever made a quick nickel. Remember the old
Terran gag about the Brooklyn Bridge? The same thing. Only
these critters didn't want bridges. They wanted land—this
gooey, slimy swamp they call 'farm land.' So I gave them
what they wanted. I just sold them some land."
Meyerhoff nodded fiercely. "You sure did. A hundred square
kilos at a swipe. Only you sold the same hundred square kilos
to a dozen different natives." Suddenly he threw back his hands
and roared. "Of all the things you
shouldn't
have done—"
"But what's a chunk of land?"
Meyerhoff shook his head hopelessly. "If you hadn't been
so greedy, you'd have found out what a chunk of land was to
these natives before you started peddling it. You'd have found
out other things about them, too. You'd have learned that
in spite of all their bumbling and fussing and squabbling
they're not so dull. You'd have found out that they're marsupials,
and that two out of five of them get thrown out of
their mother's pouch before they're old enough to survive.
You'd have realized that they have to start fighting for individual
rights almost as soon as they're born. Anything goes,
as long as it benefits them as individuals."
Meyerhoff grinned at the little man's horrified face. "Never
heard of that, had you? And you've never heard of other things,
too. You've probably never heard that there are just too many
Altairians here for the food their planet can supply, and their
diet is so finicky that they just can't live on anything that
doesn't grow here. And consequently, land is the key factor
in their economy, not money; nothing but land. To get land,
it's every man for himself, and the loser starves, and their
entire legal and monetary system revolves on that principle.
They've built up the most confusing and impossible system of
barter and trade imaginable, aimed at individual survival, with
land as the value behind the credit. That explains the lying—of
course they're liars, with an economy like that. They've
completely missed the concept of truth. Pathological? You bet
they're pathological! Only a fool would tell the truth when his
life depended on his being a better liar than the next guy!
Lying is the time-honored tradition, with their entire legal
system built around it."
Zeckler snorted. "But how could they
possibly
have a legal
system? I mean, if they don't recognize the truth when it slaps
them in the face?"
Meyerhoff shrugged. "As we understand legal systems, I
suppose they don't have one. They have only the haziest idea
what truth represents, and they've shrugged off the idea as
impossible and useless." He chuckled maliciously. "So you
went out and found a chunk of ground in the uplands, and
sold it to a dozen separate, self-centered, half-starved natives!
Encroachment on private property is legal grounds for murder
on this planet, and twelve of them descended on the same
chunk of land at the same time, all armed with title-deeds."
Meyerhoff sighed. "You've got twelve mad Altairians in your
hair. You've got a mad planet in your hair. And in the meantime,
Terra's most valuable uranium source in five centuries
is threatening to cut off supply unless they see your blood
splattered liberally all the way from here to the equator."
Zeckler was visibly shaken. "Look," he said weakly, "so I
wasn't so smart. What am I going to do? I mean, are you
going to sit quietly by and let them butcher me? How could
I defend myself in a legal setup like
this
?"
Meyerhoff smiled coolly. "You're going to get your sly little
con-man brain to working, I think," he said softly. "By Interplanetary
Rules, they have to give you a trial in Terran legal
form—judge, jury, court procedure, all that folderol. They
think it's a big joke—after all, what could a judicial oath mean
to them?—but they agreed. Only thing is, they're going to
hang you, if they die trying. So you'd better get those stunted
little wits of yours clicking—and if you try to implicate
me
,
even a little bit, I'll be out of there so fast you won't know
what happened."
With that Meyerhoff walked to the door. He jerked it inward
sharply, and spilled two guards over on their faces.
"Privacy," he grunted, and started back up the slippery corridor.
It certainly
looked
like a courtroom, at any rate. In the front
of the long, damp stone room was a bench, with a seat behind
it, and a small straight chair to the right. To the left was a stand
with twelve chairs—larger chairs, with a railing running along
the front. The rest of the room was filled almost to the door
with seats facing the bench. Zeckler followed the shaggy-haired
guard into the room, nodding approvingly. "Not such a bad
arrangement," he said. "They must have gotten the idea fast."
Meyerhoff wiped the perspiration from his forehead, and
shot the little con-man a stony glance. "At least you've got
a courtroom, a judge, and a jury for this mess. Beyond that—"
He shrugged eloquently. "I can't make any promises."
In the back of the room a door burst open with a bang.
Loud, harsh voices were heard as half a dozen of the huge
Altairians attempted to push through the door at once. Zeckler
clamped on the headset to his translator unit, and watched the
hubbub in the anteroom with growing alarm. Finally the question
of precedent seemed to be settled, and a group of the
Altairians filed in, in order of stature, stalking across the room
in flowing black robes, pug-nosed faces glowering with self-importance.
They descended upon the jury box, grunting and
scrapping with each other for the first-row seats, and the judge
took his place with obvious satisfaction behind the heavy
wooden bench. Finally, the prosecuting attorney appeared,
flanked by two clerks, who took their places beside him. The
prosecutor eyed Zeckler with cold malevolence, then turned
and delivered a sly wink at the judge.
In a moment the room was a hubbub as it filled with the
huge, bumbling, bear-like creatures, jostling each other and
fighting for seats, growling and complaining. Two small fights
broke out in the rear, but were quickly subdued by the group
of gendarmes guarding the entrance. Finally the judge glared
down at Zeckler with all three eyes, and pounded the bench top
with a wooden mallet until the roar of activity subsided. The
jurymen wriggled uncomfortably in their seats, exchanging
winks, and finally turned their attention to the front of the
court.
"We are reading the case of the people of Altair I," the
judge's voice roared out, "against one Harry Zeckler—" he
paused for a long, impressive moment—"Terran." The courtroom
immediately burst into an angry growl, until the judge
pounded the bench five or six times more. "This—creature—is
hereby accused of the following crimes," the judge bellowed.
"Conspiracy to overthrow the government of Altair I. Brutal
murder of seventeen law-abiding citizens of the village of
Karzan at the third hour before dawn in the second period
after his arrival. Desecration of the Temple of our beloved
Goddess Zermat, Queen of the Harvest. Conspiracy with the
lesser gods to cause the unprecedented drought in the Dermatti
section of our fair globe. Obscene exposure of his pouch-marks
in a public square. Four separate and distinct charges of jail-break
and bribery—" The judge pounded the bench for order—"Espionage
with the accursed scum of Altair II in preparation
for interplanetary invasion."
The little con-man's jaw sagged lower and lower, the color
draining from his face. He turned, wide-eyed, to Meyerhoff,
then back to the judge.
"The Chairman of the Jury," said the Judge succinctly, "will
read the verdict."
The little native in the front of the jury-box popped up like
a puppet on a string. "Defendant found guilty on all counts,"
he said.
"Defendant is guilty! The court will pronounce sentence—"
"
Now wait a minute!
" Zeckler was on his feet, wild-eyed.
"What kind of railroad job—"
The judge blinked disappointedly at Paul Meyerhoff. "Not
yet?" he asked, unhappily.
"No." Meyerhoff's hands twitched nervously. "Not yet, Your
Honor. Later, Your Honor. The trial comes
first
."
The judge looked as if his candy had been stolen. "But you
said
I should call for the verdict."
"Later. You have to have the trial before you can have the
verdict."
The Altairian shrugged indifferently. "Now—later—" he
muttered.
"Have the prosecutor call his first witness," said Meyerhoff.
Zeckler leaned over, his face ashen. "These charges," he
whispered. "They're insane!"
"Of course they are," Meyerhoff whispered back.
"But what am I going to—"
"Sit tight. Let
them
set things up."
"But those
lies
. They're liars, the whole pack of them—" He
broke off as the prosecutor roared a name.
The shaggy brute who took the stand was wearing a bright
purple hat which sat rakishly over one ear. He grinned the
Altairian equivalent of a hungry grin at the prosecutor. Then
he cleared his throat and started. "This Terran riffraff—"
"The oath," muttered the judge. "We've got to have the
oath."
The prosecutor nodded, and four natives moved forward,
carrying huge inscribed marble slabs to the front of the court.
One by one the chunks were reverently piled in a heap at the
witness's feet. The witness placed a huge, hairy paw on the
cairn, and the prosecutor said, "Do you swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you—" he
paused to squint at the paper in his hand, and finished on a
puzzled note, "—Goddess?"
The witness removed the paw from the rock pile long enough
to scratch his ear. Then he replaced it, and replied, "Of course,"
in an injured tone.
"Then tell this court what you have seen of the activities of
this abominable wretch."
The witness settled back into the chair, fixing one eye on
Zeckler's face, another on the prosecutor, and closing the third
as if in meditation. "I think it happened on the fourth night
of the seventh crossing of Altair II (may the Goddess cast
a drought upon it)—or was it the seventh night of the fourth
crossing?—" he grinned apologetically at the judge—"when I
was making my way back through town toward my blessed
land-plot, minding my own business, Your Honor, after weeks
of bargaining for the crop I was harvesting. Suddenly from the
shadow of the building, this creature—" he waved a paw at
Zeckler—"stopped me in my tracks with a vicious cry. He had
a weapon I'd never seen before, and before I could find my
voice he forced me back against the wall. I could see by the
cruel glint in his eyes that there was no warmth, no sympathy
in his heart, that I was—"
"Objection!" Zeckler squealed plaintively, jumping to his
feet. "This witness can't even remember what night he's talking
about!"
The judge looked startled. Then he pawed feverishly through
his bundle of notes. "Overruled," he said abruptly. "Continue,
please."
The witness glowered at Zeckler. "As I was saying before
this loutish interruption," he muttered, "I could see that I was
face to face with the most desperate of criminal types, even
for Terrans. Note the shape of his head, the flabbiness of his
ears. I was petrified with fear. And then, helpless as I was, this
two-legged abomination began to shower me with threats of
evil to my blessed home, dark threats of poisoning my land
unless I would tell him where he could find the resting place
of our blessed Goddess—"
"I never saw him before in my life," Zeckler moaned to
Meyerhoff. "Listen to him! Why should I care where their
Goddess—"
Meyerhoff gave him a stony look. "The Goddess runs things
around here. She makes it rain. If it doesn't rain, somebody's
insulted her. It's very simple."
"But how can I fight testimony like that?"
"I doubt if you
can
fight it."
"But they can't prove a word of it—" He looked at the jury,
who were listening enraptured to the second witness on the
stand. This one was testifying regarding the butcherous slaughter
of eighteen (or was it twenty-three? Oh, yes, twenty-three)
women and children in the suburban village of Karzan. The
pogrom, it seemed, had been accomplished by an energy
weapon which ate great, gaping holes in the sides of buildings.
A third witness took the stand, continuing the drone as the
room grew hotter and muggier. Zeckler grew paler and paler,
his eyes turning glassy as the testimony piled up. "But it's not
true
," he whispered to Meyerhoff.
"Of course it isn't! Can't you understand?
These people
have no regard for truth.
It's stupid, to them, silly, a mark of
low intelligence. The only thing in the world they have any
respect for is a liar bigger and more skillful than they are."
Zeckler jerked around abruptly as he heard his name bellowed
out. "Does the defendant have anything to say before
the jury delivers the verdict?"
"Do I have—" Zeckler was across the room in a flash, his
pale cheeks suddenly taking on a feverish glow. He sat down
gingerly on the witness chair, facing the judge, his eyes bright
with fear and excitement. "Your—Your Honor, I—I have a
statement to make which will have a most important bearing
on this case. You must listen with the greatest care." He
glanced quickly at Meyerhoff, and back to the judge. "Your
Honor," he said in a hushed voice. "You are in gravest of
danger. All of you. Your lives—your very land is at stake."
The judge blinked, and shuffled through his notes hurriedly
as a murmur arose in the court. "Our land?"
"Your lives, your land, everything you hold dear," Zeckler
said quickly, licking his lips nervously. "You must try to
understand me—" he glanced apprehensively over his shoulder
"now, because I may not live long enough to repeat what
I am about to tell you—"
The murmur quieted down, all ears straining in their headsets
to hear his words. "These charges," he continued, "all of
them—they're perfectly true. At least, they
seem
to be perfectly
true. But in every instance, I was working with heart and
soul, risking my life, for the welfare of your beautiful planet."
There was a loud hiss from the back of the court. Zeckler
frowned and rubbed his hands together. "It was my misfortune,"
he said, "to go to the wrong planet when I first came to
Altair from my homeland on Terra. I—I landed on Altair II,
a grave mistake, but as it turned out, a very fortunate error.
Because in attempting to arrange trading in that frightful place,
I made certain contacts." His voice trembled, and sank lower.
"I learned the horrible thing which is about to happen to this
planet, at the hands of those barbarians. The conspiracy is
theirs, not mine. They have bribed your Goddess, flattered her
and lied to her, coerced her all-powerful goodness to their own
evil interests, preparing for the day when they could persuade
her to cast your land into the fiery furnace of a ten-year-drought—"
Somebody in the middle of the court burst out laughing.
One by one the natives nudged one another, and booed, and
guffawed, until the rising tide of racket drowned out Zeckler's
words. "The defendant is obviously lying," roared the prosecutor
over the pandemonium. "Any fool knows that the Goddess
can't be bribed. How could she be a Goddess if she could?"
Zeckler grew paler. "But—perhaps they were very clever—"
"And how could they flatter her, when she knows, beyond
doubt, that she is the most exquisitely radiant creature in all
the Universe? And
you
dare to insult her, drag her name in
the dirt."
The hisses grew louder, more belligerent. Cries of "Butcher
him!" and "Scald his bowels!" rose from the courtroom. The
judge banged for silence, his eyes angry.
"Unless the defendant wishes to take up more of our precious
time with these ridiculous lies, the jury—"
"Wait! Your Honor, I request a short recess before I present
my final plea."
"Recess?"
"A few moments to collect my thoughts, to arrange my
case."
The judge settled back with a disgusted snarl. "Do I have
to?" he asked Meyerhoff.
Meyerhoff nodded. The judge shrugged, pointing over his
shoulder to the anteroom. "You can go in there," he said.
Somehow, Zeckler managed to stumble from the witness
stand, amid riotous boos and hisses, and tottered into the anteroom.
Zeckler puffed hungrily on a cigarette, and looked up at
Meyerhoff with haunted eyes. "It—it doesn't look so good,"
he muttered.
Meyerhoff's eyes were worried, too. For some reason, he
felt a surge of pity and admiration for the haggard con-man.
"It's worse than I'd anticipated," he admitted glumly. "That
was a good try, but you just don't know enough about them
and their Goddess." He sat down wearily. "I don't see what
you can do. They want your blood, and they're going to have
it. They just won't believe you, no matter
how
big a lie you
tell."
Zeckler sat in silence for a moment. "This lying business,"
he said finally, "exactly how does it work?"
"The biggest, most convincing liar wins. It's as simple as
that. It doesn't matter how outlandish a whopper you tell.
Unless, of course, they've made up their minds that you just
naturally aren't as big a liar as they are. And it looks like that's
just what they've done. It wouldn't make any difference to
them
what
you say—unless, somehow, you could
make
them
believe it."
Zeckler frowned. "And how do they regard the—the biggest
liar? I mean, how do they feel toward him?"
Meyerhoff shifted uneasily. "It's hard to say. It's been my
experience that they respect him highly—maybe even fear him
a little. After all, the most convincing liar always wins in any
transaction, so he gets more land, more food, more power.
Yes, I think the biggest liar could go where he pleased without
any interference."
Zeckler was on his feet, his eyes suddenly bright with excitement.
"Wait a minute," he said tensely. "To tell them a lie
that they'd have to believe—a lie they simply couldn't
help
but believe—" He turned on Meyerhoff, his hands trembling.
"Do they
think
the way we do? I mean, with logic, cause and
effect, examining evidence and drawing conclusions? Given
certain evidence, would they have to draw the same conclusions
that we have to draw?"
Meyerhoff blinked. "Well—yes. Oh, yes, they're perfectly
logical."
Zeckler's eyes flashed, and a huge grin broke out on his
sallow face. His thin body fairly shook. He started hopping
up and down on one foot, staring idiotically into space. "If I
could only think—" he muttered. "Somebody—somewhere—something
I read."
"Whatever are you talking about?"
"It was a Greek, I think—"
Meyerhoff stared at him. "Oh, come now. Have you gone
off your rocker completely? You've got a problem on your
hands, man."
"No, no, I've got a problem in the bag!" Zeckler's cheeks
flushed. "Let's go back in there—I think I've got an answer!"
The courtroom quieted the moment they opened the door,
and the judge banged the gavel for silence. As soon as Zeckler
had taken his seat on the witness stand, the judge turned to
the head juryman. "Now, then," he said with happy finality.
"The jury—"
"Hold on! Just one minute more."
The judge stared down at Zeckler as if he were a bug on a
rock. "Oh, yes. You had something else to say. Well, go ahead
and say it."
Zeckler looked sharply around the hushed room. "You want
to convict me," he said softly, "in the worst sort of way. Isn't
that right?"
Eyes swung toward him. The judge broke into an evil grin.
"That's right."
"But you can't really convict me until you've considered
carefully any statement I make in my own defense. Isn't that
right?"
The judge looked uncomfortable. "If you've got something
to say, go ahead and say it."
"I've got just one statement to make. Short and sweet. But
you'd better listen to it, and think it out carefully before you
decide that you really want to convict me." He paused, and
glanced slyly at the judge. "You don't think much of those
who tell the truth, it seems. Well, put
this
statement in your
record, then." His voice was loud and clear in the still room.
"
All Earthmen are absolutely incapable of telling the truth.
"
Puzzled frowns appeared on the jury's faces. One or two
exchanged startled glances, and the room was still as death.
The judge stared at him, and then at Meyerhoff, then back.
"But you"—he stammered. "You're"—He stopped in mid-sentence,
his jaw sagging.
One of the jurymen let out a little squeak, and fainted dead
away. It took, all in all, about ten seconds for the statement
to soak in.
And then pandemonium broke loose in the courtroom.
"Really," said Harry Zeckler loftily, "it was so obvious I'm
amazed that it didn't occur to me first thing." He settled himself
down comfortably in the control cabin of the Interplanetary
Rocket and grinned at the outline of Altair IV looming larger
in the view screen.
Paul Meyerhoff stared stonily at the controls, his lips compressed
angrily. "You might at least have told me what you
were planning."
"And take the chance of being overheard? Don't be silly.
It had to come as a bombshell. I had to establish myself as a
liar—the prize liar of them all, but I had to tell the sort of lie
that they simply could not cope with. Something that would
throw them into such utter confusion that they wouldn't
dare
convict me." He grinned impishly at Meyerhoff. "The paradox
of Epimenides the Cretan. It really stopped them cold. They
knew
I was an Earthmen, which meant that my statement that
Earthmen were liars was a lie, which meant that maybe I wasn't
a liar, in which case—oh, it was tailor-made."
"It sure was." Meyerhoff's voice was a snarl.
"Well, it made me out a liar in a class they couldn't approach,
didn't it?"
Meyerhoff's face was purple with anger. "Oh, indeed it did!
And it put
all
Earthmen in exactly the same class, too."
"So what's honor among thieves? I got off, didn't I?"
Meyerhoff turned on him fiercely. "Oh, you got off just fine.
You scared the living daylights out of them. And in an eon of
lying they never have run up against a short-circuit like that.
You've also completely botched any hope of ever setting up
a trading alliance with Altair I, and that includes uranium, too.
Smart people don't gamble with loaded dice. You scared them
so badly they don't want anything to do with us."
Zeckler's grin broadened, and he leaned back luxuriously.
"Ah, well. After all, the Trading Alliance was
your
outlook,
wasn't it? What a pity!" He clucked his tongue sadly. "Me,
I've got a fortune in credits sitting back at the consulate waiting
for me—enough to keep me on silk for quite a while, I
might say. I think I'll just take a nice, long vacation."
Meyerhoff turned to him, and a twinkle of malignant glee
appeared in his eyes. "Yes, I think you will. I'm quite sure of
it, in fact. Won't cost you a cent, either."
"Eh?"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. He brushed an imaginary
lint fleck from his lapel, and looked up at Zeckler slyly. "That—uh—jury
trial. The Altairians weren't any too happy to
oblige. They wanted to execute you outright. Thought a trial
was awfully silly—until they got their money back, of course.
Not too much—just three million credits."
Zeckler went white. "But that money was in banking custody!"
"Is that right? My goodness. You don't suppose they could
have lost those papers, do you?" Meyerhoff grinned at the
little con-man. "And incidentally, you're under arrest, you
know."
A choking sound came from Zeckler's throat. "
Arrest!
"
"Oh, yes. Didn't I tell you? Conspiring to undermine the
authority of the Terran Trading Commission. Serious charge,
you know. Yes, I think we'll take a nice long vacation together,
straight back to Terra. And there I think you'll face a jury
trial."
Zeckler spluttered. "There's no evidence—you've got nothing
on me! What kind of a frame are you trying to pull?"
"A
lovely
frame. Airtight. A frame from the bottom up, and
you're right square in the middle. And this time—" Meyerhoff
tapped a cigarette on his thumb with happy finality—"this time
I
don't
think you'll get off."
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from "Tiger by the Tail and Other Science Fiction
Stories by Alan E. Nourse" and was first published in
If Magazine
January 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright
on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/7/24275//24275-h//24275-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why do the Altairians let Zeckler go? | 24275_LUJNWDNS_5 | [
"They let Zeckler go because he did not murder any Altairians.",
"They let Zeckler go because he is the best liar.",
"They let Zeckler go because Altairian law doesn't apply to Earthmen.",
"They let Zeckler go because he converted to the religion of the Altairian Goddess."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
24,275 | 24275_LUJNWDNS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Letter of the Law | 1960.0 | Nourse, Alan Edward | PS; Short stories; Legal stories; Science fiction | Letter
of
the
Law
by Alan E. Nourse
The
place was dark and damp, and smelled like moldy leaves.
Meyerhoff followed the huge, bear-like Altairian guard
down the slippery flagstones of the corridor, sniffing the
dead, musty air with distaste. He drew his carefully tailored
Terran-styled jacket closer about his shoulders, shivering as his
eyes avoided the black, yawning cell-holes they were passing.
His foot slipped on the slimy flags from time to time, and
finally he paused to wipe the caked mud from his trouser leg.
"How much farther is it?" he shouted angrily.
The guard waved a heavy paw vaguely into the blackness
ahead. Quite suddenly the corridor took a sharp bend, and the
Altairian stopped, producing a huge key ring from some obscure
fold of his hairy hide. "I still don't see any reason for
all the fuss," he grumbled in a wounded tone. "We've treated
him like a brother."
One of the huge steel doors clicked open. Meyerhoff peered
into the blackness, catching a vaguely human outline against
the back wall. "Harry?" he called sharply.
There was a startled gasp from within, and a skinny, gnarled
little man suddenly appeared in the guard's light, like a grotesque,
twisted ghost out of the blackness. Wide blue eyes
regarded Meyerhoff from beneath uneven black eyebrows, and
then the little man's face broke into a crafty grin. "Paul! So
they sent
you
! I knew I could count on it!" He executed a
deep, awkward bow, motioning Meyerhoff into the dark
cubicle. "Not much to offer you," he said slyly, "but it's the
best I can do under the circumstances."
Meyerhoff scowled, and turned abruptly to the guard. "We'll
have some privacy now, if you please. Interplanetary ruling.
And leave us the light."
The guard grumbled, and started for the door. "It's about
time you showed up!" cried the little man in the cell. "Great
day! Lucky they sent you, pal. Why, I've been in here for
years—"
"Look, Zeckler, the name is Meyerhoff, and I'm not your
pal," Meyerhoff snapped. "And you've been here for two
weeks, three days, and approximately four hours. You're getting
as bad as your gentle guards when it comes to bandying
the truth around." He peered through the dim light at the
gaunt face of the prisoner. Zeckler's face was dark with a
week's beard, and his bloodshot eyes belied the cocky grin
on his lips. His clothes were smeared and sodden, streaked
with great splotches of mud and moss. Meyerhoff's face softened
a little. "So Harry Zeckler's in a jam again," he said.
"You
look
as if they'd treated you like a brother."
The little man snorted. "These overgrown teddy-bears don't
know what brotherhood means, nor humanity, either. Bread
and water I've been getting, nothing more, and then only if they
feel like bringing it down." He sank wearily down on the rock
bench along the wall. "I thought you'd never get here! I sent
an appeal to the Terran Consulate the first day I was arrested.
What happened? I mean, all they had to do was get a man
over here, get the extradition papers signed, and provide transportation
off the planet for me. Why so much time? I've been
sitting here rotting—" He broke off in mid-sentence and stared
at Meyerhoff. "You
brought
the papers, didn't you? I mean,
we can leave now?"
Meyerhoff stared at the little man with a mixture of pity and
disgust. "You are a prize fool," he said finally. "Did you know
that?"
Zeckler's eyes widened. "What do you mean, fool? So I
spend a couple of weeks in this pneumonia trap. The deal was
worth it! I've got three million credits sitting in the Terran
Consulate on Altair V, just waiting for me to walk in and pick
them up. Three million credits—do you hear? That's enough
to set me up for life!"
Meyerhoff nodded grimly. "
If
you live long enough to walk
in and pick them up, that is."
"What do you mean, if?"
Meyerhoff sank down beside the man, his voice a tense
whisper in the musty cell. "I mean that right now you are
practically dead. You may not know it, but you are. You walk
into a newly opened planet with your smart little bag of tricks,
walk in here with a shaky passport and no permit, with no
knowledge of the natives outside of two paragraphs of inaccuracies
in the Explorer's Guide, and even then you're not
content to come in and sell something legitimate, something
the natives might conceivably be able to use. No, nothing so
simple for you. You have to pull your usual high-pressure stuff.
And this time, buddy, you're paying the piper."
"
You mean I'm not being extradited?
"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. "I mean precisely that.
You've committed a crime here—a major crime. The Altairians
are sore about it. And the Terran Consulate isn't willing
to sell all the trading possibilities here down the river just to
get you out of a mess. You're going to stand trial—and these
natives are out to get you. Personally, I think they're
going
to get you."
Zeckler stood up shakily. "You can't believe anything the
natives say," he said uneasily. "They're pathological liars.
Why, you should see what they tried to sell
me
! You've never
seen such a pack of liars as these critters." He glanced up at
Meyerhoff. "They'll probably drop a little fine on me and let
me go."
"A little fine of one Terran neck." Meyerhoff grinned nastily.
"You've committed the most heinous crime these creatures can
imagine, and they're going to get you for it if it's the last thing
they do. I'm afraid, my friend, that your con-man days are
over."
Zeckler fished in the other man's pocket, extracted a cigarette,
and lighted it with trembling fingers. "It's bad, then,"
he said finally.
"It's bad, all right."
Some shadow of the sly, elfin grin crept over the little con-man's
face. "Well, at any rate, I'm glad they sent you over,"
he said weakly. "Nothing like a good lawyer to handle a trial."
"
Lawyer?
Not me! Oh, no. Sorry, but no thanks." Meyerhoff
chuckled. "I'm your advisor, old boy. Nothing else. I'm here
to keep you from botching things up still worse for the Trading
Commission, that's all. I wouldn't get tangled up in a mess
with those creatures for anything!" He shook his head. "You're
your own lawyer, Mr. Super-salesman. It's all your show. And
you'd better get your head out of the sand, or you're going to
lose a case like it's never been lost before!"
Meyerhoff watched the man's pale face, and shook his head.
In a way, he thought, it was a pity to see such a change in the
rosy-cheeked, dapper, cocksure little man who had talked his
way glibly in and out of more jams than Meyerhoff could
count. Trading brought scalpers; it was almost inevitable that
where rich and unexploited trading ground was uncovered, it
would first fall prey to the fast-trading boys. They spread out
from Terra with the first wave of exploration—the slick, fast-talking
con-men who could work new territories unfettered by
the legal restrictions that soon closed down the more established
planets. The first men in were the richest out, and
through some curious quirk of the Terrestrial mind, they knew
they could count on Terran protection, however crooked and
underhand their methods.
But occasionally a situation arose where the civilization and
social practices of the alien victims made it unwise to tamper
with them. Altair I had been recognized at once by the Trading
Commission as a commercial prize of tremendous value, but
early reports had warned of the danger of wildcat trading on
the little, musty, jungle-like planet with its shaggy, three-eyed
inhabitants—warned specifically against the confidence tactics
so frequently used—but there was always somebody, Meyerhoff
reflected sourly, who just didn't get the word.
Zeckler puffed nervously on his cigarette, his narrow face
a study in troubled concentration. "But I didn't
do
anything!"
he exploded finally. "So I pulled an old con game. So what?
Why should they get so excited? So I clipped a few thousand
credits, pulled a little fast business." He shrugged eloquently,
spreading his hands. "Everybody's doing it. They do it to each
other without batting an eye. You should
see
these critters
operate on each other. Why, my little scheme was peanuts by
comparison."
Meyerhoff pulled a pipe from his pocket, and began stuffing
the bowl with infinite patience. "And precisely what sort of
con game was it?" he asked quietly.
Zeckler shrugged again. "The simplest, tiredest, moldiest
old racket that ever made a quick nickel. Remember the old
Terran gag about the Brooklyn Bridge? The same thing. Only
these critters didn't want bridges. They wanted land—this
gooey, slimy swamp they call 'farm land.' So I gave them
what they wanted. I just sold them some land."
Meyerhoff nodded fiercely. "You sure did. A hundred square
kilos at a swipe. Only you sold the same hundred square kilos
to a dozen different natives." Suddenly he threw back his hands
and roared. "Of all the things you
shouldn't
have done—"
"But what's a chunk of land?"
Meyerhoff shook his head hopelessly. "If you hadn't been
so greedy, you'd have found out what a chunk of land was to
these natives before you started peddling it. You'd have found
out other things about them, too. You'd have learned that
in spite of all their bumbling and fussing and squabbling
they're not so dull. You'd have found out that they're marsupials,
and that two out of five of them get thrown out of
their mother's pouch before they're old enough to survive.
You'd have realized that they have to start fighting for individual
rights almost as soon as they're born. Anything goes,
as long as it benefits them as individuals."
Meyerhoff grinned at the little man's horrified face. "Never
heard of that, had you? And you've never heard of other things,
too. You've probably never heard that there are just too many
Altairians here for the food their planet can supply, and their
diet is so finicky that they just can't live on anything that
doesn't grow here. And consequently, land is the key factor
in their economy, not money; nothing but land. To get land,
it's every man for himself, and the loser starves, and their
entire legal and monetary system revolves on that principle.
They've built up the most confusing and impossible system of
barter and trade imaginable, aimed at individual survival, with
land as the value behind the credit. That explains the lying—of
course they're liars, with an economy like that. They've
completely missed the concept of truth. Pathological? You bet
they're pathological! Only a fool would tell the truth when his
life depended on his being a better liar than the next guy!
Lying is the time-honored tradition, with their entire legal
system built around it."
Zeckler snorted. "But how could they
possibly
have a legal
system? I mean, if they don't recognize the truth when it slaps
them in the face?"
Meyerhoff shrugged. "As we understand legal systems, I
suppose they don't have one. They have only the haziest idea
what truth represents, and they've shrugged off the idea as
impossible and useless." He chuckled maliciously. "So you
went out and found a chunk of ground in the uplands, and
sold it to a dozen separate, self-centered, half-starved natives!
Encroachment on private property is legal grounds for murder
on this planet, and twelve of them descended on the same
chunk of land at the same time, all armed with title-deeds."
Meyerhoff sighed. "You've got twelve mad Altairians in your
hair. You've got a mad planet in your hair. And in the meantime,
Terra's most valuable uranium source in five centuries
is threatening to cut off supply unless they see your blood
splattered liberally all the way from here to the equator."
Zeckler was visibly shaken. "Look," he said weakly, "so I
wasn't so smart. What am I going to do? I mean, are you
going to sit quietly by and let them butcher me? How could
I defend myself in a legal setup like
this
?"
Meyerhoff smiled coolly. "You're going to get your sly little
con-man brain to working, I think," he said softly. "By Interplanetary
Rules, they have to give you a trial in Terran legal
form—judge, jury, court procedure, all that folderol. They
think it's a big joke—after all, what could a judicial oath mean
to them?—but they agreed. Only thing is, they're going to
hang you, if they die trying. So you'd better get those stunted
little wits of yours clicking—and if you try to implicate
me
,
even a little bit, I'll be out of there so fast you won't know
what happened."
With that Meyerhoff walked to the door. He jerked it inward
sharply, and spilled two guards over on their faces.
"Privacy," he grunted, and started back up the slippery corridor.
It certainly
looked
like a courtroom, at any rate. In the front
of the long, damp stone room was a bench, with a seat behind
it, and a small straight chair to the right. To the left was a stand
with twelve chairs—larger chairs, with a railing running along
the front. The rest of the room was filled almost to the door
with seats facing the bench. Zeckler followed the shaggy-haired
guard into the room, nodding approvingly. "Not such a bad
arrangement," he said. "They must have gotten the idea fast."
Meyerhoff wiped the perspiration from his forehead, and
shot the little con-man a stony glance. "At least you've got
a courtroom, a judge, and a jury for this mess. Beyond that—"
He shrugged eloquently. "I can't make any promises."
In the back of the room a door burst open with a bang.
Loud, harsh voices were heard as half a dozen of the huge
Altairians attempted to push through the door at once. Zeckler
clamped on the headset to his translator unit, and watched the
hubbub in the anteroom with growing alarm. Finally the question
of precedent seemed to be settled, and a group of the
Altairians filed in, in order of stature, stalking across the room
in flowing black robes, pug-nosed faces glowering with self-importance.
They descended upon the jury box, grunting and
scrapping with each other for the first-row seats, and the judge
took his place with obvious satisfaction behind the heavy
wooden bench. Finally, the prosecuting attorney appeared,
flanked by two clerks, who took their places beside him. The
prosecutor eyed Zeckler with cold malevolence, then turned
and delivered a sly wink at the judge.
In a moment the room was a hubbub as it filled with the
huge, bumbling, bear-like creatures, jostling each other and
fighting for seats, growling and complaining. Two small fights
broke out in the rear, but were quickly subdued by the group
of gendarmes guarding the entrance. Finally the judge glared
down at Zeckler with all three eyes, and pounded the bench top
with a wooden mallet until the roar of activity subsided. The
jurymen wriggled uncomfortably in their seats, exchanging
winks, and finally turned their attention to the front of the
court.
"We are reading the case of the people of Altair I," the
judge's voice roared out, "against one Harry Zeckler—" he
paused for a long, impressive moment—"Terran." The courtroom
immediately burst into an angry growl, until the judge
pounded the bench five or six times more. "This—creature—is
hereby accused of the following crimes," the judge bellowed.
"Conspiracy to overthrow the government of Altair I. Brutal
murder of seventeen law-abiding citizens of the village of
Karzan at the third hour before dawn in the second period
after his arrival. Desecration of the Temple of our beloved
Goddess Zermat, Queen of the Harvest. Conspiracy with the
lesser gods to cause the unprecedented drought in the Dermatti
section of our fair globe. Obscene exposure of his pouch-marks
in a public square. Four separate and distinct charges of jail-break
and bribery—" The judge pounded the bench for order—"Espionage
with the accursed scum of Altair II in preparation
for interplanetary invasion."
The little con-man's jaw sagged lower and lower, the color
draining from his face. He turned, wide-eyed, to Meyerhoff,
then back to the judge.
"The Chairman of the Jury," said the Judge succinctly, "will
read the verdict."
The little native in the front of the jury-box popped up like
a puppet on a string. "Defendant found guilty on all counts,"
he said.
"Defendant is guilty! The court will pronounce sentence—"
"
Now wait a minute!
" Zeckler was on his feet, wild-eyed.
"What kind of railroad job—"
The judge blinked disappointedly at Paul Meyerhoff. "Not
yet?" he asked, unhappily.
"No." Meyerhoff's hands twitched nervously. "Not yet, Your
Honor. Later, Your Honor. The trial comes
first
."
The judge looked as if his candy had been stolen. "But you
said
I should call for the verdict."
"Later. You have to have the trial before you can have the
verdict."
The Altairian shrugged indifferently. "Now—later—" he
muttered.
"Have the prosecutor call his first witness," said Meyerhoff.
Zeckler leaned over, his face ashen. "These charges," he
whispered. "They're insane!"
"Of course they are," Meyerhoff whispered back.
"But what am I going to—"
"Sit tight. Let
them
set things up."
"But those
lies
. They're liars, the whole pack of them—" He
broke off as the prosecutor roared a name.
The shaggy brute who took the stand was wearing a bright
purple hat which sat rakishly over one ear. He grinned the
Altairian equivalent of a hungry grin at the prosecutor. Then
he cleared his throat and started. "This Terran riffraff—"
"The oath," muttered the judge. "We've got to have the
oath."
The prosecutor nodded, and four natives moved forward,
carrying huge inscribed marble slabs to the front of the court.
One by one the chunks were reverently piled in a heap at the
witness's feet. The witness placed a huge, hairy paw on the
cairn, and the prosecutor said, "Do you swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you—" he
paused to squint at the paper in his hand, and finished on a
puzzled note, "—Goddess?"
The witness removed the paw from the rock pile long enough
to scratch his ear. Then he replaced it, and replied, "Of course,"
in an injured tone.
"Then tell this court what you have seen of the activities of
this abominable wretch."
The witness settled back into the chair, fixing one eye on
Zeckler's face, another on the prosecutor, and closing the third
as if in meditation. "I think it happened on the fourth night
of the seventh crossing of Altair II (may the Goddess cast
a drought upon it)—or was it the seventh night of the fourth
crossing?—" he grinned apologetically at the judge—"when I
was making my way back through town toward my blessed
land-plot, minding my own business, Your Honor, after weeks
of bargaining for the crop I was harvesting. Suddenly from the
shadow of the building, this creature—" he waved a paw at
Zeckler—"stopped me in my tracks with a vicious cry. He had
a weapon I'd never seen before, and before I could find my
voice he forced me back against the wall. I could see by the
cruel glint in his eyes that there was no warmth, no sympathy
in his heart, that I was—"
"Objection!" Zeckler squealed plaintively, jumping to his
feet. "This witness can't even remember what night he's talking
about!"
The judge looked startled. Then he pawed feverishly through
his bundle of notes. "Overruled," he said abruptly. "Continue,
please."
The witness glowered at Zeckler. "As I was saying before
this loutish interruption," he muttered, "I could see that I was
face to face with the most desperate of criminal types, even
for Terrans. Note the shape of his head, the flabbiness of his
ears. I was petrified with fear. And then, helpless as I was, this
two-legged abomination began to shower me with threats of
evil to my blessed home, dark threats of poisoning my land
unless I would tell him where he could find the resting place
of our blessed Goddess—"
"I never saw him before in my life," Zeckler moaned to
Meyerhoff. "Listen to him! Why should I care where their
Goddess—"
Meyerhoff gave him a stony look. "The Goddess runs things
around here. She makes it rain. If it doesn't rain, somebody's
insulted her. It's very simple."
"But how can I fight testimony like that?"
"I doubt if you
can
fight it."
"But they can't prove a word of it—" He looked at the jury,
who were listening enraptured to the second witness on the
stand. This one was testifying regarding the butcherous slaughter
of eighteen (or was it twenty-three? Oh, yes, twenty-three)
women and children in the suburban village of Karzan. The
pogrom, it seemed, had been accomplished by an energy
weapon which ate great, gaping holes in the sides of buildings.
A third witness took the stand, continuing the drone as the
room grew hotter and muggier. Zeckler grew paler and paler,
his eyes turning glassy as the testimony piled up. "But it's not
true
," he whispered to Meyerhoff.
"Of course it isn't! Can't you understand?
These people
have no regard for truth.
It's stupid, to them, silly, a mark of
low intelligence. The only thing in the world they have any
respect for is a liar bigger and more skillful than they are."
Zeckler jerked around abruptly as he heard his name bellowed
out. "Does the defendant have anything to say before
the jury delivers the verdict?"
"Do I have—" Zeckler was across the room in a flash, his
pale cheeks suddenly taking on a feverish glow. He sat down
gingerly on the witness chair, facing the judge, his eyes bright
with fear and excitement. "Your—Your Honor, I—I have a
statement to make which will have a most important bearing
on this case. You must listen with the greatest care." He
glanced quickly at Meyerhoff, and back to the judge. "Your
Honor," he said in a hushed voice. "You are in gravest of
danger. All of you. Your lives—your very land is at stake."
The judge blinked, and shuffled through his notes hurriedly
as a murmur arose in the court. "Our land?"
"Your lives, your land, everything you hold dear," Zeckler
said quickly, licking his lips nervously. "You must try to
understand me—" he glanced apprehensively over his shoulder
"now, because I may not live long enough to repeat what
I am about to tell you—"
The murmur quieted down, all ears straining in their headsets
to hear his words. "These charges," he continued, "all of
them—they're perfectly true. At least, they
seem
to be perfectly
true. But in every instance, I was working with heart and
soul, risking my life, for the welfare of your beautiful planet."
There was a loud hiss from the back of the court. Zeckler
frowned and rubbed his hands together. "It was my misfortune,"
he said, "to go to the wrong planet when I first came to
Altair from my homeland on Terra. I—I landed on Altair II,
a grave mistake, but as it turned out, a very fortunate error.
Because in attempting to arrange trading in that frightful place,
I made certain contacts." His voice trembled, and sank lower.
"I learned the horrible thing which is about to happen to this
planet, at the hands of those barbarians. The conspiracy is
theirs, not mine. They have bribed your Goddess, flattered her
and lied to her, coerced her all-powerful goodness to their own
evil interests, preparing for the day when they could persuade
her to cast your land into the fiery furnace of a ten-year-drought—"
Somebody in the middle of the court burst out laughing.
One by one the natives nudged one another, and booed, and
guffawed, until the rising tide of racket drowned out Zeckler's
words. "The defendant is obviously lying," roared the prosecutor
over the pandemonium. "Any fool knows that the Goddess
can't be bribed. How could she be a Goddess if she could?"
Zeckler grew paler. "But—perhaps they were very clever—"
"And how could they flatter her, when she knows, beyond
doubt, that she is the most exquisitely radiant creature in all
the Universe? And
you
dare to insult her, drag her name in
the dirt."
The hisses grew louder, more belligerent. Cries of "Butcher
him!" and "Scald his bowels!" rose from the courtroom. The
judge banged for silence, his eyes angry.
"Unless the defendant wishes to take up more of our precious
time with these ridiculous lies, the jury—"
"Wait! Your Honor, I request a short recess before I present
my final plea."
"Recess?"
"A few moments to collect my thoughts, to arrange my
case."
The judge settled back with a disgusted snarl. "Do I have
to?" he asked Meyerhoff.
Meyerhoff nodded. The judge shrugged, pointing over his
shoulder to the anteroom. "You can go in there," he said.
Somehow, Zeckler managed to stumble from the witness
stand, amid riotous boos and hisses, and tottered into the anteroom.
Zeckler puffed hungrily on a cigarette, and looked up at
Meyerhoff with haunted eyes. "It—it doesn't look so good,"
he muttered.
Meyerhoff's eyes were worried, too. For some reason, he
felt a surge of pity and admiration for the haggard con-man.
"It's worse than I'd anticipated," he admitted glumly. "That
was a good try, but you just don't know enough about them
and their Goddess." He sat down wearily. "I don't see what
you can do. They want your blood, and they're going to have
it. They just won't believe you, no matter
how
big a lie you
tell."
Zeckler sat in silence for a moment. "This lying business,"
he said finally, "exactly how does it work?"
"The biggest, most convincing liar wins. It's as simple as
that. It doesn't matter how outlandish a whopper you tell.
Unless, of course, they've made up their minds that you just
naturally aren't as big a liar as they are. And it looks like that's
just what they've done. It wouldn't make any difference to
them
what
you say—unless, somehow, you could
make
them
believe it."
Zeckler frowned. "And how do they regard the—the biggest
liar? I mean, how do they feel toward him?"
Meyerhoff shifted uneasily. "It's hard to say. It's been my
experience that they respect him highly—maybe even fear him
a little. After all, the most convincing liar always wins in any
transaction, so he gets more land, more food, more power.
Yes, I think the biggest liar could go where he pleased without
any interference."
Zeckler was on his feet, his eyes suddenly bright with excitement.
"Wait a minute," he said tensely. "To tell them a lie
that they'd have to believe—a lie they simply couldn't
help
but believe—" He turned on Meyerhoff, his hands trembling.
"Do they
think
the way we do? I mean, with logic, cause and
effect, examining evidence and drawing conclusions? Given
certain evidence, would they have to draw the same conclusions
that we have to draw?"
Meyerhoff blinked. "Well—yes. Oh, yes, they're perfectly
logical."
Zeckler's eyes flashed, and a huge grin broke out on his
sallow face. His thin body fairly shook. He started hopping
up and down on one foot, staring idiotically into space. "If I
could only think—" he muttered. "Somebody—somewhere—something
I read."
"Whatever are you talking about?"
"It was a Greek, I think—"
Meyerhoff stared at him. "Oh, come now. Have you gone
off your rocker completely? You've got a problem on your
hands, man."
"No, no, I've got a problem in the bag!" Zeckler's cheeks
flushed. "Let's go back in there—I think I've got an answer!"
The courtroom quieted the moment they opened the door,
and the judge banged the gavel for silence. As soon as Zeckler
had taken his seat on the witness stand, the judge turned to
the head juryman. "Now, then," he said with happy finality.
"The jury—"
"Hold on! Just one minute more."
The judge stared down at Zeckler as if he were a bug on a
rock. "Oh, yes. You had something else to say. Well, go ahead
and say it."
Zeckler looked sharply around the hushed room. "You want
to convict me," he said softly, "in the worst sort of way. Isn't
that right?"
Eyes swung toward him. The judge broke into an evil grin.
"That's right."
"But you can't really convict me until you've considered
carefully any statement I make in my own defense. Isn't that
right?"
The judge looked uncomfortable. "If you've got something
to say, go ahead and say it."
"I've got just one statement to make. Short and sweet. But
you'd better listen to it, and think it out carefully before you
decide that you really want to convict me." He paused, and
glanced slyly at the judge. "You don't think much of those
who tell the truth, it seems. Well, put
this
statement in your
record, then." His voice was loud and clear in the still room.
"
All Earthmen are absolutely incapable of telling the truth.
"
Puzzled frowns appeared on the jury's faces. One or two
exchanged startled glances, and the room was still as death.
The judge stared at him, and then at Meyerhoff, then back.
"But you"—he stammered. "You're"—He stopped in mid-sentence,
his jaw sagging.
One of the jurymen let out a little squeak, and fainted dead
away. It took, all in all, about ten seconds for the statement
to soak in.
And then pandemonium broke loose in the courtroom.
"Really," said Harry Zeckler loftily, "it was so obvious I'm
amazed that it didn't occur to me first thing." He settled himself
down comfortably in the control cabin of the Interplanetary
Rocket and grinned at the outline of Altair IV looming larger
in the view screen.
Paul Meyerhoff stared stonily at the controls, his lips compressed
angrily. "You might at least have told me what you
were planning."
"And take the chance of being overheard? Don't be silly.
It had to come as a bombshell. I had to establish myself as a
liar—the prize liar of them all, but I had to tell the sort of lie
that they simply could not cope with. Something that would
throw them into such utter confusion that they wouldn't
dare
convict me." He grinned impishly at Meyerhoff. "The paradox
of Epimenides the Cretan. It really stopped them cold. They
knew
I was an Earthmen, which meant that my statement that
Earthmen were liars was a lie, which meant that maybe I wasn't
a liar, in which case—oh, it was tailor-made."
"It sure was." Meyerhoff's voice was a snarl.
"Well, it made me out a liar in a class they couldn't approach,
didn't it?"
Meyerhoff's face was purple with anger. "Oh, indeed it did!
And it put
all
Earthmen in exactly the same class, too."
"So what's honor among thieves? I got off, didn't I?"
Meyerhoff turned on him fiercely. "Oh, you got off just fine.
You scared the living daylights out of them. And in an eon of
lying they never have run up against a short-circuit like that.
You've also completely botched any hope of ever setting up
a trading alliance with Altair I, and that includes uranium, too.
Smart people don't gamble with loaded dice. You scared them
so badly they don't want anything to do with us."
Zeckler's grin broadened, and he leaned back luxuriously.
"Ah, well. After all, the Trading Alliance was
your
outlook,
wasn't it? What a pity!" He clucked his tongue sadly. "Me,
I've got a fortune in credits sitting back at the consulate waiting
for me—enough to keep me on silk for quite a while, I
might say. I think I'll just take a nice, long vacation."
Meyerhoff turned to him, and a twinkle of malignant glee
appeared in his eyes. "Yes, I think you will. I'm quite sure of
it, in fact. Won't cost you a cent, either."
"Eh?"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. He brushed an imaginary
lint fleck from his lapel, and looked up at Zeckler slyly. "That—uh—jury
trial. The Altairians weren't any too happy to
oblige. They wanted to execute you outright. Thought a trial
was awfully silly—until they got their money back, of course.
Not too much—just three million credits."
Zeckler went white. "But that money was in banking custody!"
"Is that right? My goodness. You don't suppose they could
have lost those papers, do you?" Meyerhoff grinned at the
little con-man. "And incidentally, you're under arrest, you
know."
A choking sound came from Zeckler's throat. "
Arrest!
"
"Oh, yes. Didn't I tell you? Conspiring to undermine the
authority of the Terran Trading Commission. Serious charge,
you know. Yes, I think we'll take a nice long vacation together,
straight back to Terra. And there I think you'll face a jury
trial."
Zeckler spluttered. "There's no evidence—you've got nothing
on me! What kind of a frame are you trying to pull?"
"A
lovely
frame. Airtight. A frame from the bottom up, and
you're right square in the middle. And this time—" Meyerhoff
tapped a cigarette on his thumb with happy finality—"this time
I
don't
think you'll get off."
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from "Tiger by the Tail and Other Science Fiction
Stories by Alan E. Nourse" and was first published in
If Magazine
January 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright
on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/7/24275//24275-h//24275-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why don't the Altairians leave Altair I if it is so overpopulated? | 24275_LUJNWDNS_6 | [
"They don't leave because they can only eat food grown on Altair I.",
"The Goddess won't let them leave.",
"They don't leave because no other planets will clear ships from Altair I for landing. Nobody likes liars.",
"They don't leave because they have not achieved space travel."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
24,275 | 24275_LUJNWDNS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Letter of the Law | 1960.0 | Nourse, Alan Edward | PS; Short stories; Legal stories; Science fiction | Letter
of
the
Law
by Alan E. Nourse
The
place was dark and damp, and smelled like moldy leaves.
Meyerhoff followed the huge, bear-like Altairian guard
down the slippery flagstones of the corridor, sniffing the
dead, musty air with distaste. He drew his carefully tailored
Terran-styled jacket closer about his shoulders, shivering as his
eyes avoided the black, yawning cell-holes they were passing.
His foot slipped on the slimy flags from time to time, and
finally he paused to wipe the caked mud from his trouser leg.
"How much farther is it?" he shouted angrily.
The guard waved a heavy paw vaguely into the blackness
ahead. Quite suddenly the corridor took a sharp bend, and the
Altairian stopped, producing a huge key ring from some obscure
fold of his hairy hide. "I still don't see any reason for
all the fuss," he grumbled in a wounded tone. "We've treated
him like a brother."
One of the huge steel doors clicked open. Meyerhoff peered
into the blackness, catching a vaguely human outline against
the back wall. "Harry?" he called sharply.
There was a startled gasp from within, and a skinny, gnarled
little man suddenly appeared in the guard's light, like a grotesque,
twisted ghost out of the blackness. Wide blue eyes
regarded Meyerhoff from beneath uneven black eyebrows, and
then the little man's face broke into a crafty grin. "Paul! So
they sent
you
! I knew I could count on it!" He executed a
deep, awkward bow, motioning Meyerhoff into the dark
cubicle. "Not much to offer you," he said slyly, "but it's the
best I can do under the circumstances."
Meyerhoff scowled, and turned abruptly to the guard. "We'll
have some privacy now, if you please. Interplanetary ruling.
And leave us the light."
The guard grumbled, and started for the door. "It's about
time you showed up!" cried the little man in the cell. "Great
day! Lucky they sent you, pal. Why, I've been in here for
years—"
"Look, Zeckler, the name is Meyerhoff, and I'm not your
pal," Meyerhoff snapped. "And you've been here for two
weeks, three days, and approximately four hours. You're getting
as bad as your gentle guards when it comes to bandying
the truth around." He peered through the dim light at the
gaunt face of the prisoner. Zeckler's face was dark with a
week's beard, and his bloodshot eyes belied the cocky grin
on his lips. His clothes were smeared and sodden, streaked
with great splotches of mud and moss. Meyerhoff's face softened
a little. "So Harry Zeckler's in a jam again," he said.
"You
look
as if they'd treated you like a brother."
The little man snorted. "These overgrown teddy-bears don't
know what brotherhood means, nor humanity, either. Bread
and water I've been getting, nothing more, and then only if they
feel like bringing it down." He sank wearily down on the rock
bench along the wall. "I thought you'd never get here! I sent
an appeal to the Terran Consulate the first day I was arrested.
What happened? I mean, all they had to do was get a man
over here, get the extradition papers signed, and provide transportation
off the planet for me. Why so much time? I've been
sitting here rotting—" He broke off in mid-sentence and stared
at Meyerhoff. "You
brought
the papers, didn't you? I mean,
we can leave now?"
Meyerhoff stared at the little man with a mixture of pity and
disgust. "You are a prize fool," he said finally. "Did you know
that?"
Zeckler's eyes widened. "What do you mean, fool? So I
spend a couple of weeks in this pneumonia trap. The deal was
worth it! I've got three million credits sitting in the Terran
Consulate on Altair V, just waiting for me to walk in and pick
them up. Three million credits—do you hear? That's enough
to set me up for life!"
Meyerhoff nodded grimly. "
If
you live long enough to walk
in and pick them up, that is."
"What do you mean, if?"
Meyerhoff sank down beside the man, his voice a tense
whisper in the musty cell. "I mean that right now you are
practically dead. You may not know it, but you are. You walk
into a newly opened planet with your smart little bag of tricks,
walk in here with a shaky passport and no permit, with no
knowledge of the natives outside of two paragraphs of inaccuracies
in the Explorer's Guide, and even then you're not
content to come in and sell something legitimate, something
the natives might conceivably be able to use. No, nothing so
simple for you. You have to pull your usual high-pressure stuff.
And this time, buddy, you're paying the piper."
"
You mean I'm not being extradited?
"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. "I mean precisely that.
You've committed a crime here—a major crime. The Altairians
are sore about it. And the Terran Consulate isn't willing
to sell all the trading possibilities here down the river just to
get you out of a mess. You're going to stand trial—and these
natives are out to get you. Personally, I think they're
going
to get you."
Zeckler stood up shakily. "You can't believe anything the
natives say," he said uneasily. "They're pathological liars.
Why, you should see what they tried to sell
me
! You've never
seen such a pack of liars as these critters." He glanced up at
Meyerhoff. "They'll probably drop a little fine on me and let
me go."
"A little fine of one Terran neck." Meyerhoff grinned nastily.
"You've committed the most heinous crime these creatures can
imagine, and they're going to get you for it if it's the last thing
they do. I'm afraid, my friend, that your con-man days are
over."
Zeckler fished in the other man's pocket, extracted a cigarette,
and lighted it with trembling fingers. "It's bad, then,"
he said finally.
"It's bad, all right."
Some shadow of the sly, elfin grin crept over the little con-man's
face. "Well, at any rate, I'm glad they sent you over,"
he said weakly. "Nothing like a good lawyer to handle a trial."
"
Lawyer?
Not me! Oh, no. Sorry, but no thanks." Meyerhoff
chuckled. "I'm your advisor, old boy. Nothing else. I'm here
to keep you from botching things up still worse for the Trading
Commission, that's all. I wouldn't get tangled up in a mess
with those creatures for anything!" He shook his head. "You're
your own lawyer, Mr. Super-salesman. It's all your show. And
you'd better get your head out of the sand, or you're going to
lose a case like it's never been lost before!"
Meyerhoff watched the man's pale face, and shook his head.
In a way, he thought, it was a pity to see such a change in the
rosy-cheeked, dapper, cocksure little man who had talked his
way glibly in and out of more jams than Meyerhoff could
count. Trading brought scalpers; it was almost inevitable that
where rich and unexploited trading ground was uncovered, it
would first fall prey to the fast-trading boys. They spread out
from Terra with the first wave of exploration—the slick, fast-talking
con-men who could work new territories unfettered by
the legal restrictions that soon closed down the more established
planets. The first men in were the richest out, and
through some curious quirk of the Terrestrial mind, they knew
they could count on Terran protection, however crooked and
underhand their methods.
But occasionally a situation arose where the civilization and
social practices of the alien victims made it unwise to tamper
with them. Altair I had been recognized at once by the Trading
Commission as a commercial prize of tremendous value, but
early reports had warned of the danger of wildcat trading on
the little, musty, jungle-like planet with its shaggy, three-eyed
inhabitants—warned specifically against the confidence tactics
so frequently used—but there was always somebody, Meyerhoff
reflected sourly, who just didn't get the word.
Zeckler puffed nervously on his cigarette, his narrow face
a study in troubled concentration. "But I didn't
do
anything!"
he exploded finally. "So I pulled an old con game. So what?
Why should they get so excited? So I clipped a few thousand
credits, pulled a little fast business." He shrugged eloquently,
spreading his hands. "Everybody's doing it. They do it to each
other without batting an eye. You should
see
these critters
operate on each other. Why, my little scheme was peanuts by
comparison."
Meyerhoff pulled a pipe from his pocket, and began stuffing
the bowl with infinite patience. "And precisely what sort of
con game was it?" he asked quietly.
Zeckler shrugged again. "The simplest, tiredest, moldiest
old racket that ever made a quick nickel. Remember the old
Terran gag about the Brooklyn Bridge? The same thing. Only
these critters didn't want bridges. They wanted land—this
gooey, slimy swamp they call 'farm land.' So I gave them
what they wanted. I just sold them some land."
Meyerhoff nodded fiercely. "You sure did. A hundred square
kilos at a swipe. Only you sold the same hundred square kilos
to a dozen different natives." Suddenly he threw back his hands
and roared. "Of all the things you
shouldn't
have done—"
"But what's a chunk of land?"
Meyerhoff shook his head hopelessly. "If you hadn't been
so greedy, you'd have found out what a chunk of land was to
these natives before you started peddling it. You'd have found
out other things about them, too. You'd have learned that
in spite of all their bumbling and fussing and squabbling
they're not so dull. You'd have found out that they're marsupials,
and that two out of five of them get thrown out of
their mother's pouch before they're old enough to survive.
You'd have realized that they have to start fighting for individual
rights almost as soon as they're born. Anything goes,
as long as it benefits them as individuals."
Meyerhoff grinned at the little man's horrified face. "Never
heard of that, had you? And you've never heard of other things,
too. You've probably never heard that there are just too many
Altairians here for the food their planet can supply, and their
diet is so finicky that they just can't live on anything that
doesn't grow here. And consequently, land is the key factor
in their economy, not money; nothing but land. To get land,
it's every man for himself, and the loser starves, and their
entire legal and monetary system revolves on that principle.
They've built up the most confusing and impossible system of
barter and trade imaginable, aimed at individual survival, with
land as the value behind the credit. That explains the lying—of
course they're liars, with an economy like that. They've
completely missed the concept of truth. Pathological? You bet
they're pathological! Only a fool would tell the truth when his
life depended on his being a better liar than the next guy!
Lying is the time-honored tradition, with their entire legal
system built around it."
Zeckler snorted. "But how could they
possibly
have a legal
system? I mean, if they don't recognize the truth when it slaps
them in the face?"
Meyerhoff shrugged. "As we understand legal systems, I
suppose they don't have one. They have only the haziest idea
what truth represents, and they've shrugged off the idea as
impossible and useless." He chuckled maliciously. "So you
went out and found a chunk of ground in the uplands, and
sold it to a dozen separate, self-centered, half-starved natives!
Encroachment on private property is legal grounds for murder
on this planet, and twelve of them descended on the same
chunk of land at the same time, all armed with title-deeds."
Meyerhoff sighed. "You've got twelve mad Altairians in your
hair. You've got a mad planet in your hair. And in the meantime,
Terra's most valuable uranium source in five centuries
is threatening to cut off supply unless they see your blood
splattered liberally all the way from here to the equator."
Zeckler was visibly shaken. "Look," he said weakly, "so I
wasn't so smart. What am I going to do? I mean, are you
going to sit quietly by and let them butcher me? How could
I defend myself in a legal setup like
this
?"
Meyerhoff smiled coolly. "You're going to get your sly little
con-man brain to working, I think," he said softly. "By Interplanetary
Rules, they have to give you a trial in Terran legal
form—judge, jury, court procedure, all that folderol. They
think it's a big joke—after all, what could a judicial oath mean
to them?—but they agreed. Only thing is, they're going to
hang you, if they die trying. So you'd better get those stunted
little wits of yours clicking—and if you try to implicate
me
,
even a little bit, I'll be out of there so fast you won't know
what happened."
With that Meyerhoff walked to the door. He jerked it inward
sharply, and spilled two guards over on their faces.
"Privacy," he grunted, and started back up the slippery corridor.
It certainly
looked
like a courtroom, at any rate. In the front
of the long, damp stone room was a bench, with a seat behind
it, and a small straight chair to the right. To the left was a stand
with twelve chairs—larger chairs, with a railing running along
the front. The rest of the room was filled almost to the door
with seats facing the bench. Zeckler followed the shaggy-haired
guard into the room, nodding approvingly. "Not such a bad
arrangement," he said. "They must have gotten the idea fast."
Meyerhoff wiped the perspiration from his forehead, and
shot the little con-man a stony glance. "At least you've got
a courtroom, a judge, and a jury for this mess. Beyond that—"
He shrugged eloquently. "I can't make any promises."
In the back of the room a door burst open with a bang.
Loud, harsh voices were heard as half a dozen of the huge
Altairians attempted to push through the door at once. Zeckler
clamped on the headset to his translator unit, and watched the
hubbub in the anteroom with growing alarm. Finally the question
of precedent seemed to be settled, and a group of the
Altairians filed in, in order of stature, stalking across the room
in flowing black robes, pug-nosed faces glowering with self-importance.
They descended upon the jury box, grunting and
scrapping with each other for the first-row seats, and the judge
took his place with obvious satisfaction behind the heavy
wooden bench. Finally, the prosecuting attorney appeared,
flanked by two clerks, who took their places beside him. The
prosecutor eyed Zeckler with cold malevolence, then turned
and delivered a sly wink at the judge.
In a moment the room was a hubbub as it filled with the
huge, bumbling, bear-like creatures, jostling each other and
fighting for seats, growling and complaining. Two small fights
broke out in the rear, but were quickly subdued by the group
of gendarmes guarding the entrance. Finally the judge glared
down at Zeckler with all three eyes, and pounded the bench top
with a wooden mallet until the roar of activity subsided. The
jurymen wriggled uncomfortably in their seats, exchanging
winks, and finally turned their attention to the front of the
court.
"We are reading the case of the people of Altair I," the
judge's voice roared out, "against one Harry Zeckler—" he
paused for a long, impressive moment—"Terran." The courtroom
immediately burst into an angry growl, until the judge
pounded the bench five or six times more. "This—creature—is
hereby accused of the following crimes," the judge bellowed.
"Conspiracy to overthrow the government of Altair I. Brutal
murder of seventeen law-abiding citizens of the village of
Karzan at the third hour before dawn in the second period
after his arrival. Desecration of the Temple of our beloved
Goddess Zermat, Queen of the Harvest. Conspiracy with the
lesser gods to cause the unprecedented drought in the Dermatti
section of our fair globe. Obscene exposure of his pouch-marks
in a public square. Four separate and distinct charges of jail-break
and bribery—" The judge pounded the bench for order—"Espionage
with the accursed scum of Altair II in preparation
for interplanetary invasion."
The little con-man's jaw sagged lower and lower, the color
draining from his face. He turned, wide-eyed, to Meyerhoff,
then back to the judge.
"The Chairman of the Jury," said the Judge succinctly, "will
read the verdict."
The little native in the front of the jury-box popped up like
a puppet on a string. "Defendant found guilty on all counts,"
he said.
"Defendant is guilty! The court will pronounce sentence—"
"
Now wait a minute!
" Zeckler was on his feet, wild-eyed.
"What kind of railroad job—"
The judge blinked disappointedly at Paul Meyerhoff. "Not
yet?" he asked, unhappily.
"No." Meyerhoff's hands twitched nervously. "Not yet, Your
Honor. Later, Your Honor. The trial comes
first
."
The judge looked as if his candy had been stolen. "But you
said
I should call for the verdict."
"Later. You have to have the trial before you can have the
verdict."
The Altairian shrugged indifferently. "Now—later—" he
muttered.
"Have the prosecutor call his first witness," said Meyerhoff.
Zeckler leaned over, his face ashen. "These charges," he
whispered. "They're insane!"
"Of course they are," Meyerhoff whispered back.
"But what am I going to—"
"Sit tight. Let
them
set things up."
"But those
lies
. They're liars, the whole pack of them—" He
broke off as the prosecutor roared a name.
The shaggy brute who took the stand was wearing a bright
purple hat which sat rakishly over one ear. He grinned the
Altairian equivalent of a hungry grin at the prosecutor. Then
he cleared his throat and started. "This Terran riffraff—"
"The oath," muttered the judge. "We've got to have the
oath."
The prosecutor nodded, and four natives moved forward,
carrying huge inscribed marble slabs to the front of the court.
One by one the chunks were reverently piled in a heap at the
witness's feet. The witness placed a huge, hairy paw on the
cairn, and the prosecutor said, "Do you swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you—" he
paused to squint at the paper in his hand, and finished on a
puzzled note, "—Goddess?"
The witness removed the paw from the rock pile long enough
to scratch his ear. Then he replaced it, and replied, "Of course,"
in an injured tone.
"Then tell this court what you have seen of the activities of
this abominable wretch."
The witness settled back into the chair, fixing one eye on
Zeckler's face, another on the prosecutor, and closing the third
as if in meditation. "I think it happened on the fourth night
of the seventh crossing of Altair II (may the Goddess cast
a drought upon it)—or was it the seventh night of the fourth
crossing?—" he grinned apologetically at the judge—"when I
was making my way back through town toward my blessed
land-plot, minding my own business, Your Honor, after weeks
of bargaining for the crop I was harvesting. Suddenly from the
shadow of the building, this creature—" he waved a paw at
Zeckler—"stopped me in my tracks with a vicious cry. He had
a weapon I'd never seen before, and before I could find my
voice he forced me back against the wall. I could see by the
cruel glint in his eyes that there was no warmth, no sympathy
in his heart, that I was—"
"Objection!" Zeckler squealed plaintively, jumping to his
feet. "This witness can't even remember what night he's talking
about!"
The judge looked startled. Then he pawed feverishly through
his bundle of notes. "Overruled," he said abruptly. "Continue,
please."
The witness glowered at Zeckler. "As I was saying before
this loutish interruption," he muttered, "I could see that I was
face to face with the most desperate of criminal types, even
for Terrans. Note the shape of his head, the flabbiness of his
ears. I was petrified with fear. And then, helpless as I was, this
two-legged abomination began to shower me with threats of
evil to my blessed home, dark threats of poisoning my land
unless I would tell him where he could find the resting place
of our blessed Goddess—"
"I never saw him before in my life," Zeckler moaned to
Meyerhoff. "Listen to him! Why should I care where their
Goddess—"
Meyerhoff gave him a stony look. "The Goddess runs things
around here. She makes it rain. If it doesn't rain, somebody's
insulted her. It's very simple."
"But how can I fight testimony like that?"
"I doubt if you
can
fight it."
"But they can't prove a word of it—" He looked at the jury,
who were listening enraptured to the second witness on the
stand. This one was testifying regarding the butcherous slaughter
of eighteen (or was it twenty-three? Oh, yes, twenty-three)
women and children in the suburban village of Karzan. The
pogrom, it seemed, had been accomplished by an energy
weapon which ate great, gaping holes in the sides of buildings.
A third witness took the stand, continuing the drone as the
room grew hotter and muggier. Zeckler grew paler and paler,
his eyes turning glassy as the testimony piled up. "But it's not
true
," he whispered to Meyerhoff.
"Of course it isn't! Can't you understand?
These people
have no regard for truth.
It's stupid, to them, silly, a mark of
low intelligence. The only thing in the world they have any
respect for is a liar bigger and more skillful than they are."
Zeckler jerked around abruptly as he heard his name bellowed
out. "Does the defendant have anything to say before
the jury delivers the verdict?"
"Do I have—" Zeckler was across the room in a flash, his
pale cheeks suddenly taking on a feverish glow. He sat down
gingerly on the witness chair, facing the judge, his eyes bright
with fear and excitement. "Your—Your Honor, I—I have a
statement to make which will have a most important bearing
on this case. You must listen with the greatest care." He
glanced quickly at Meyerhoff, and back to the judge. "Your
Honor," he said in a hushed voice. "You are in gravest of
danger. All of you. Your lives—your very land is at stake."
The judge blinked, and shuffled through his notes hurriedly
as a murmur arose in the court. "Our land?"
"Your lives, your land, everything you hold dear," Zeckler
said quickly, licking his lips nervously. "You must try to
understand me—" he glanced apprehensively over his shoulder
"now, because I may not live long enough to repeat what
I am about to tell you—"
The murmur quieted down, all ears straining in their headsets
to hear his words. "These charges," he continued, "all of
them—they're perfectly true. At least, they
seem
to be perfectly
true. But in every instance, I was working with heart and
soul, risking my life, for the welfare of your beautiful planet."
There was a loud hiss from the back of the court. Zeckler
frowned and rubbed his hands together. "It was my misfortune,"
he said, "to go to the wrong planet when I first came to
Altair from my homeland on Terra. I—I landed on Altair II,
a grave mistake, but as it turned out, a very fortunate error.
Because in attempting to arrange trading in that frightful place,
I made certain contacts." His voice trembled, and sank lower.
"I learned the horrible thing which is about to happen to this
planet, at the hands of those barbarians. The conspiracy is
theirs, not mine. They have bribed your Goddess, flattered her
and lied to her, coerced her all-powerful goodness to their own
evil interests, preparing for the day when they could persuade
her to cast your land into the fiery furnace of a ten-year-drought—"
Somebody in the middle of the court burst out laughing.
One by one the natives nudged one another, and booed, and
guffawed, until the rising tide of racket drowned out Zeckler's
words. "The defendant is obviously lying," roared the prosecutor
over the pandemonium. "Any fool knows that the Goddess
can't be bribed. How could she be a Goddess if she could?"
Zeckler grew paler. "But—perhaps they were very clever—"
"And how could they flatter her, when she knows, beyond
doubt, that she is the most exquisitely radiant creature in all
the Universe? And
you
dare to insult her, drag her name in
the dirt."
The hisses grew louder, more belligerent. Cries of "Butcher
him!" and "Scald his bowels!" rose from the courtroom. The
judge banged for silence, his eyes angry.
"Unless the defendant wishes to take up more of our precious
time with these ridiculous lies, the jury—"
"Wait! Your Honor, I request a short recess before I present
my final plea."
"Recess?"
"A few moments to collect my thoughts, to arrange my
case."
The judge settled back with a disgusted snarl. "Do I have
to?" he asked Meyerhoff.
Meyerhoff nodded. The judge shrugged, pointing over his
shoulder to the anteroom. "You can go in there," he said.
Somehow, Zeckler managed to stumble from the witness
stand, amid riotous boos and hisses, and tottered into the anteroom.
Zeckler puffed hungrily on a cigarette, and looked up at
Meyerhoff with haunted eyes. "It—it doesn't look so good,"
he muttered.
Meyerhoff's eyes were worried, too. For some reason, he
felt a surge of pity and admiration for the haggard con-man.
"It's worse than I'd anticipated," he admitted glumly. "That
was a good try, but you just don't know enough about them
and their Goddess." He sat down wearily. "I don't see what
you can do. They want your blood, and they're going to have
it. They just won't believe you, no matter
how
big a lie you
tell."
Zeckler sat in silence for a moment. "This lying business,"
he said finally, "exactly how does it work?"
"The biggest, most convincing liar wins. It's as simple as
that. It doesn't matter how outlandish a whopper you tell.
Unless, of course, they've made up their minds that you just
naturally aren't as big a liar as they are. And it looks like that's
just what they've done. It wouldn't make any difference to
them
what
you say—unless, somehow, you could
make
them
believe it."
Zeckler frowned. "And how do they regard the—the biggest
liar? I mean, how do they feel toward him?"
Meyerhoff shifted uneasily. "It's hard to say. It's been my
experience that they respect him highly—maybe even fear him
a little. After all, the most convincing liar always wins in any
transaction, so he gets more land, more food, more power.
Yes, I think the biggest liar could go where he pleased without
any interference."
Zeckler was on his feet, his eyes suddenly bright with excitement.
"Wait a minute," he said tensely. "To tell them a lie
that they'd have to believe—a lie they simply couldn't
help
but believe—" He turned on Meyerhoff, his hands trembling.
"Do they
think
the way we do? I mean, with logic, cause and
effect, examining evidence and drawing conclusions? Given
certain evidence, would they have to draw the same conclusions
that we have to draw?"
Meyerhoff blinked. "Well—yes. Oh, yes, they're perfectly
logical."
Zeckler's eyes flashed, and a huge grin broke out on his
sallow face. His thin body fairly shook. He started hopping
up and down on one foot, staring idiotically into space. "If I
could only think—" he muttered. "Somebody—somewhere—something
I read."
"Whatever are you talking about?"
"It was a Greek, I think—"
Meyerhoff stared at him. "Oh, come now. Have you gone
off your rocker completely? You've got a problem on your
hands, man."
"No, no, I've got a problem in the bag!" Zeckler's cheeks
flushed. "Let's go back in there—I think I've got an answer!"
The courtroom quieted the moment they opened the door,
and the judge banged the gavel for silence. As soon as Zeckler
had taken his seat on the witness stand, the judge turned to
the head juryman. "Now, then," he said with happy finality.
"The jury—"
"Hold on! Just one minute more."
The judge stared down at Zeckler as if he were a bug on a
rock. "Oh, yes. You had something else to say. Well, go ahead
and say it."
Zeckler looked sharply around the hushed room. "You want
to convict me," he said softly, "in the worst sort of way. Isn't
that right?"
Eyes swung toward him. The judge broke into an evil grin.
"That's right."
"But you can't really convict me until you've considered
carefully any statement I make in my own defense. Isn't that
right?"
The judge looked uncomfortable. "If you've got something
to say, go ahead and say it."
"I've got just one statement to make. Short and sweet. But
you'd better listen to it, and think it out carefully before you
decide that you really want to convict me." He paused, and
glanced slyly at the judge. "You don't think much of those
who tell the truth, it seems. Well, put
this
statement in your
record, then." His voice was loud and clear in the still room.
"
All Earthmen are absolutely incapable of telling the truth.
"
Puzzled frowns appeared on the jury's faces. One or two
exchanged startled glances, and the room was still as death.
The judge stared at him, and then at Meyerhoff, then back.
"But you"—he stammered. "You're"—He stopped in mid-sentence,
his jaw sagging.
One of the jurymen let out a little squeak, and fainted dead
away. It took, all in all, about ten seconds for the statement
to soak in.
And then pandemonium broke loose in the courtroom.
"Really," said Harry Zeckler loftily, "it was so obvious I'm
amazed that it didn't occur to me first thing." He settled himself
down comfortably in the control cabin of the Interplanetary
Rocket and grinned at the outline of Altair IV looming larger
in the view screen.
Paul Meyerhoff stared stonily at the controls, his lips compressed
angrily. "You might at least have told me what you
were planning."
"And take the chance of being overheard? Don't be silly.
It had to come as a bombshell. I had to establish myself as a
liar—the prize liar of them all, but I had to tell the sort of lie
that they simply could not cope with. Something that would
throw them into such utter confusion that they wouldn't
dare
convict me." He grinned impishly at Meyerhoff. "The paradox
of Epimenides the Cretan. It really stopped them cold. They
knew
I was an Earthmen, which meant that my statement that
Earthmen were liars was a lie, which meant that maybe I wasn't
a liar, in which case—oh, it was tailor-made."
"It sure was." Meyerhoff's voice was a snarl.
"Well, it made me out a liar in a class they couldn't approach,
didn't it?"
Meyerhoff's face was purple with anger. "Oh, indeed it did!
And it put
all
Earthmen in exactly the same class, too."
"So what's honor among thieves? I got off, didn't I?"
Meyerhoff turned on him fiercely. "Oh, you got off just fine.
You scared the living daylights out of them. And in an eon of
lying they never have run up against a short-circuit like that.
You've also completely botched any hope of ever setting up
a trading alliance with Altair I, and that includes uranium, too.
Smart people don't gamble with loaded dice. You scared them
so badly they don't want anything to do with us."
Zeckler's grin broadened, and he leaned back luxuriously.
"Ah, well. After all, the Trading Alliance was
your
outlook,
wasn't it? What a pity!" He clucked his tongue sadly. "Me,
I've got a fortune in credits sitting back at the consulate waiting
for me—enough to keep me on silk for quite a while, I
might say. I think I'll just take a nice, long vacation."
Meyerhoff turned to him, and a twinkle of malignant glee
appeared in his eyes. "Yes, I think you will. I'm quite sure of
it, in fact. Won't cost you a cent, either."
"Eh?"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. He brushed an imaginary
lint fleck from his lapel, and looked up at Zeckler slyly. "That—uh—jury
trial. The Altairians weren't any too happy to
oblige. They wanted to execute you outright. Thought a trial
was awfully silly—until they got their money back, of course.
Not too much—just three million credits."
Zeckler went white. "But that money was in banking custody!"
"Is that right? My goodness. You don't suppose they could
have lost those papers, do you?" Meyerhoff grinned at the
little con-man. "And incidentally, you're under arrest, you
know."
A choking sound came from Zeckler's throat. "
Arrest!
"
"Oh, yes. Didn't I tell you? Conspiring to undermine the
authority of the Terran Trading Commission. Serious charge,
you know. Yes, I think we'll take a nice long vacation together,
straight back to Terra. And there I think you'll face a jury
trial."
Zeckler spluttered. "There's no evidence—you've got nothing
on me! What kind of a frame are you trying to pull?"
"A
lovely
frame. Airtight. A frame from the bottom up, and
you're right square in the middle. And this time—" Meyerhoff
tapped a cigarette on his thumb with happy finality—"this time
I
don't
think you'll get off."
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from "Tiger by the Tail and Other Science Fiction
Stories by Alan E. Nourse" and was first published in
If Magazine
January 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright
on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/7/24275//24275-h//24275-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How do the Altairians treat the biggest liars? | 24275_LUJNWDNS_7 | [
"The biggest liars are sent to Earth.",
"The biggest liars can do whatever they want and get away with it.",
"The biggest liars are thrown into a pit. There they are eaten by the Goddess.",
"The biggest liars are hanged."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
24,275 | 24275_LUJNWDNS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Letter of the Law | 1960.0 | Nourse, Alan Edward | PS; Short stories; Legal stories; Science fiction | Letter
of
the
Law
by Alan E. Nourse
The
place was dark and damp, and smelled like moldy leaves.
Meyerhoff followed the huge, bear-like Altairian guard
down the slippery flagstones of the corridor, sniffing the
dead, musty air with distaste. He drew his carefully tailored
Terran-styled jacket closer about his shoulders, shivering as his
eyes avoided the black, yawning cell-holes they were passing.
His foot slipped on the slimy flags from time to time, and
finally he paused to wipe the caked mud from his trouser leg.
"How much farther is it?" he shouted angrily.
The guard waved a heavy paw vaguely into the blackness
ahead. Quite suddenly the corridor took a sharp bend, and the
Altairian stopped, producing a huge key ring from some obscure
fold of his hairy hide. "I still don't see any reason for
all the fuss," he grumbled in a wounded tone. "We've treated
him like a brother."
One of the huge steel doors clicked open. Meyerhoff peered
into the blackness, catching a vaguely human outline against
the back wall. "Harry?" he called sharply.
There was a startled gasp from within, and a skinny, gnarled
little man suddenly appeared in the guard's light, like a grotesque,
twisted ghost out of the blackness. Wide blue eyes
regarded Meyerhoff from beneath uneven black eyebrows, and
then the little man's face broke into a crafty grin. "Paul! So
they sent
you
! I knew I could count on it!" He executed a
deep, awkward bow, motioning Meyerhoff into the dark
cubicle. "Not much to offer you," he said slyly, "but it's the
best I can do under the circumstances."
Meyerhoff scowled, and turned abruptly to the guard. "We'll
have some privacy now, if you please. Interplanetary ruling.
And leave us the light."
The guard grumbled, and started for the door. "It's about
time you showed up!" cried the little man in the cell. "Great
day! Lucky they sent you, pal. Why, I've been in here for
years—"
"Look, Zeckler, the name is Meyerhoff, and I'm not your
pal," Meyerhoff snapped. "And you've been here for two
weeks, three days, and approximately four hours. You're getting
as bad as your gentle guards when it comes to bandying
the truth around." He peered through the dim light at the
gaunt face of the prisoner. Zeckler's face was dark with a
week's beard, and his bloodshot eyes belied the cocky grin
on his lips. His clothes were smeared and sodden, streaked
with great splotches of mud and moss. Meyerhoff's face softened
a little. "So Harry Zeckler's in a jam again," he said.
"You
look
as if they'd treated you like a brother."
The little man snorted. "These overgrown teddy-bears don't
know what brotherhood means, nor humanity, either. Bread
and water I've been getting, nothing more, and then only if they
feel like bringing it down." He sank wearily down on the rock
bench along the wall. "I thought you'd never get here! I sent
an appeal to the Terran Consulate the first day I was arrested.
What happened? I mean, all they had to do was get a man
over here, get the extradition papers signed, and provide transportation
off the planet for me. Why so much time? I've been
sitting here rotting—" He broke off in mid-sentence and stared
at Meyerhoff. "You
brought
the papers, didn't you? I mean,
we can leave now?"
Meyerhoff stared at the little man with a mixture of pity and
disgust. "You are a prize fool," he said finally. "Did you know
that?"
Zeckler's eyes widened. "What do you mean, fool? So I
spend a couple of weeks in this pneumonia trap. The deal was
worth it! I've got three million credits sitting in the Terran
Consulate on Altair V, just waiting for me to walk in and pick
them up. Three million credits—do you hear? That's enough
to set me up for life!"
Meyerhoff nodded grimly. "
If
you live long enough to walk
in and pick them up, that is."
"What do you mean, if?"
Meyerhoff sank down beside the man, his voice a tense
whisper in the musty cell. "I mean that right now you are
practically dead. You may not know it, but you are. You walk
into a newly opened planet with your smart little bag of tricks,
walk in here with a shaky passport and no permit, with no
knowledge of the natives outside of two paragraphs of inaccuracies
in the Explorer's Guide, and even then you're not
content to come in and sell something legitimate, something
the natives might conceivably be able to use. No, nothing so
simple for you. You have to pull your usual high-pressure stuff.
And this time, buddy, you're paying the piper."
"
You mean I'm not being extradited?
"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. "I mean precisely that.
You've committed a crime here—a major crime. The Altairians
are sore about it. And the Terran Consulate isn't willing
to sell all the trading possibilities here down the river just to
get you out of a mess. You're going to stand trial—and these
natives are out to get you. Personally, I think they're
going
to get you."
Zeckler stood up shakily. "You can't believe anything the
natives say," he said uneasily. "They're pathological liars.
Why, you should see what they tried to sell
me
! You've never
seen such a pack of liars as these critters." He glanced up at
Meyerhoff. "They'll probably drop a little fine on me and let
me go."
"A little fine of one Terran neck." Meyerhoff grinned nastily.
"You've committed the most heinous crime these creatures can
imagine, and they're going to get you for it if it's the last thing
they do. I'm afraid, my friend, that your con-man days are
over."
Zeckler fished in the other man's pocket, extracted a cigarette,
and lighted it with trembling fingers. "It's bad, then,"
he said finally.
"It's bad, all right."
Some shadow of the sly, elfin grin crept over the little con-man's
face. "Well, at any rate, I'm glad they sent you over,"
he said weakly. "Nothing like a good lawyer to handle a trial."
"
Lawyer?
Not me! Oh, no. Sorry, but no thanks." Meyerhoff
chuckled. "I'm your advisor, old boy. Nothing else. I'm here
to keep you from botching things up still worse for the Trading
Commission, that's all. I wouldn't get tangled up in a mess
with those creatures for anything!" He shook his head. "You're
your own lawyer, Mr. Super-salesman. It's all your show. And
you'd better get your head out of the sand, or you're going to
lose a case like it's never been lost before!"
Meyerhoff watched the man's pale face, and shook his head.
In a way, he thought, it was a pity to see such a change in the
rosy-cheeked, dapper, cocksure little man who had talked his
way glibly in and out of more jams than Meyerhoff could
count. Trading brought scalpers; it was almost inevitable that
where rich and unexploited trading ground was uncovered, it
would first fall prey to the fast-trading boys. They spread out
from Terra with the first wave of exploration—the slick, fast-talking
con-men who could work new territories unfettered by
the legal restrictions that soon closed down the more established
planets. The first men in were the richest out, and
through some curious quirk of the Terrestrial mind, they knew
they could count on Terran protection, however crooked and
underhand their methods.
But occasionally a situation arose where the civilization and
social practices of the alien victims made it unwise to tamper
with them. Altair I had been recognized at once by the Trading
Commission as a commercial prize of tremendous value, but
early reports had warned of the danger of wildcat trading on
the little, musty, jungle-like planet with its shaggy, three-eyed
inhabitants—warned specifically against the confidence tactics
so frequently used—but there was always somebody, Meyerhoff
reflected sourly, who just didn't get the word.
Zeckler puffed nervously on his cigarette, his narrow face
a study in troubled concentration. "But I didn't
do
anything!"
he exploded finally. "So I pulled an old con game. So what?
Why should they get so excited? So I clipped a few thousand
credits, pulled a little fast business." He shrugged eloquently,
spreading his hands. "Everybody's doing it. They do it to each
other without batting an eye. You should
see
these critters
operate on each other. Why, my little scheme was peanuts by
comparison."
Meyerhoff pulled a pipe from his pocket, and began stuffing
the bowl with infinite patience. "And precisely what sort of
con game was it?" he asked quietly.
Zeckler shrugged again. "The simplest, tiredest, moldiest
old racket that ever made a quick nickel. Remember the old
Terran gag about the Brooklyn Bridge? The same thing. Only
these critters didn't want bridges. They wanted land—this
gooey, slimy swamp they call 'farm land.' So I gave them
what they wanted. I just sold them some land."
Meyerhoff nodded fiercely. "You sure did. A hundred square
kilos at a swipe. Only you sold the same hundred square kilos
to a dozen different natives." Suddenly he threw back his hands
and roared. "Of all the things you
shouldn't
have done—"
"But what's a chunk of land?"
Meyerhoff shook his head hopelessly. "If you hadn't been
so greedy, you'd have found out what a chunk of land was to
these natives before you started peddling it. You'd have found
out other things about them, too. You'd have learned that
in spite of all their bumbling and fussing and squabbling
they're not so dull. You'd have found out that they're marsupials,
and that two out of five of them get thrown out of
their mother's pouch before they're old enough to survive.
You'd have realized that they have to start fighting for individual
rights almost as soon as they're born. Anything goes,
as long as it benefits them as individuals."
Meyerhoff grinned at the little man's horrified face. "Never
heard of that, had you? And you've never heard of other things,
too. You've probably never heard that there are just too many
Altairians here for the food their planet can supply, and their
diet is so finicky that they just can't live on anything that
doesn't grow here. And consequently, land is the key factor
in their economy, not money; nothing but land. To get land,
it's every man for himself, and the loser starves, and their
entire legal and monetary system revolves on that principle.
They've built up the most confusing and impossible system of
barter and trade imaginable, aimed at individual survival, with
land as the value behind the credit. That explains the lying—of
course they're liars, with an economy like that. They've
completely missed the concept of truth. Pathological? You bet
they're pathological! Only a fool would tell the truth when his
life depended on his being a better liar than the next guy!
Lying is the time-honored tradition, with their entire legal
system built around it."
Zeckler snorted. "But how could they
possibly
have a legal
system? I mean, if they don't recognize the truth when it slaps
them in the face?"
Meyerhoff shrugged. "As we understand legal systems, I
suppose they don't have one. They have only the haziest idea
what truth represents, and they've shrugged off the idea as
impossible and useless." He chuckled maliciously. "So you
went out and found a chunk of ground in the uplands, and
sold it to a dozen separate, self-centered, half-starved natives!
Encroachment on private property is legal grounds for murder
on this planet, and twelve of them descended on the same
chunk of land at the same time, all armed with title-deeds."
Meyerhoff sighed. "You've got twelve mad Altairians in your
hair. You've got a mad planet in your hair. And in the meantime,
Terra's most valuable uranium source in five centuries
is threatening to cut off supply unless they see your blood
splattered liberally all the way from here to the equator."
Zeckler was visibly shaken. "Look," he said weakly, "so I
wasn't so smart. What am I going to do? I mean, are you
going to sit quietly by and let them butcher me? How could
I defend myself in a legal setup like
this
?"
Meyerhoff smiled coolly. "You're going to get your sly little
con-man brain to working, I think," he said softly. "By Interplanetary
Rules, they have to give you a trial in Terran legal
form—judge, jury, court procedure, all that folderol. They
think it's a big joke—after all, what could a judicial oath mean
to them?—but they agreed. Only thing is, they're going to
hang you, if they die trying. So you'd better get those stunted
little wits of yours clicking—and if you try to implicate
me
,
even a little bit, I'll be out of there so fast you won't know
what happened."
With that Meyerhoff walked to the door. He jerked it inward
sharply, and spilled two guards over on their faces.
"Privacy," he grunted, and started back up the slippery corridor.
It certainly
looked
like a courtroom, at any rate. In the front
of the long, damp stone room was a bench, with a seat behind
it, and a small straight chair to the right. To the left was a stand
with twelve chairs—larger chairs, with a railing running along
the front. The rest of the room was filled almost to the door
with seats facing the bench. Zeckler followed the shaggy-haired
guard into the room, nodding approvingly. "Not such a bad
arrangement," he said. "They must have gotten the idea fast."
Meyerhoff wiped the perspiration from his forehead, and
shot the little con-man a stony glance. "At least you've got
a courtroom, a judge, and a jury for this mess. Beyond that—"
He shrugged eloquently. "I can't make any promises."
In the back of the room a door burst open with a bang.
Loud, harsh voices were heard as half a dozen of the huge
Altairians attempted to push through the door at once. Zeckler
clamped on the headset to his translator unit, and watched the
hubbub in the anteroom with growing alarm. Finally the question
of precedent seemed to be settled, and a group of the
Altairians filed in, in order of stature, stalking across the room
in flowing black robes, pug-nosed faces glowering with self-importance.
They descended upon the jury box, grunting and
scrapping with each other for the first-row seats, and the judge
took his place with obvious satisfaction behind the heavy
wooden bench. Finally, the prosecuting attorney appeared,
flanked by two clerks, who took their places beside him. The
prosecutor eyed Zeckler with cold malevolence, then turned
and delivered a sly wink at the judge.
In a moment the room was a hubbub as it filled with the
huge, bumbling, bear-like creatures, jostling each other and
fighting for seats, growling and complaining. Two small fights
broke out in the rear, but were quickly subdued by the group
of gendarmes guarding the entrance. Finally the judge glared
down at Zeckler with all three eyes, and pounded the bench top
with a wooden mallet until the roar of activity subsided. The
jurymen wriggled uncomfortably in their seats, exchanging
winks, and finally turned their attention to the front of the
court.
"We are reading the case of the people of Altair I," the
judge's voice roared out, "against one Harry Zeckler—" he
paused for a long, impressive moment—"Terran." The courtroom
immediately burst into an angry growl, until the judge
pounded the bench five or six times more. "This—creature—is
hereby accused of the following crimes," the judge bellowed.
"Conspiracy to overthrow the government of Altair I. Brutal
murder of seventeen law-abiding citizens of the village of
Karzan at the third hour before dawn in the second period
after his arrival. Desecration of the Temple of our beloved
Goddess Zermat, Queen of the Harvest. Conspiracy with the
lesser gods to cause the unprecedented drought in the Dermatti
section of our fair globe. Obscene exposure of his pouch-marks
in a public square. Four separate and distinct charges of jail-break
and bribery—" The judge pounded the bench for order—"Espionage
with the accursed scum of Altair II in preparation
for interplanetary invasion."
The little con-man's jaw sagged lower and lower, the color
draining from his face. He turned, wide-eyed, to Meyerhoff,
then back to the judge.
"The Chairman of the Jury," said the Judge succinctly, "will
read the verdict."
The little native in the front of the jury-box popped up like
a puppet on a string. "Defendant found guilty on all counts,"
he said.
"Defendant is guilty! The court will pronounce sentence—"
"
Now wait a minute!
" Zeckler was on his feet, wild-eyed.
"What kind of railroad job—"
The judge blinked disappointedly at Paul Meyerhoff. "Not
yet?" he asked, unhappily.
"No." Meyerhoff's hands twitched nervously. "Not yet, Your
Honor. Later, Your Honor. The trial comes
first
."
The judge looked as if his candy had been stolen. "But you
said
I should call for the verdict."
"Later. You have to have the trial before you can have the
verdict."
The Altairian shrugged indifferently. "Now—later—" he
muttered.
"Have the prosecutor call his first witness," said Meyerhoff.
Zeckler leaned over, his face ashen. "These charges," he
whispered. "They're insane!"
"Of course they are," Meyerhoff whispered back.
"But what am I going to—"
"Sit tight. Let
them
set things up."
"But those
lies
. They're liars, the whole pack of them—" He
broke off as the prosecutor roared a name.
The shaggy brute who took the stand was wearing a bright
purple hat which sat rakishly over one ear. He grinned the
Altairian equivalent of a hungry grin at the prosecutor. Then
he cleared his throat and started. "This Terran riffraff—"
"The oath," muttered the judge. "We've got to have the
oath."
The prosecutor nodded, and four natives moved forward,
carrying huge inscribed marble slabs to the front of the court.
One by one the chunks were reverently piled in a heap at the
witness's feet. The witness placed a huge, hairy paw on the
cairn, and the prosecutor said, "Do you swear to tell the truth,
the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you—" he
paused to squint at the paper in his hand, and finished on a
puzzled note, "—Goddess?"
The witness removed the paw from the rock pile long enough
to scratch his ear. Then he replaced it, and replied, "Of course,"
in an injured tone.
"Then tell this court what you have seen of the activities of
this abominable wretch."
The witness settled back into the chair, fixing one eye on
Zeckler's face, another on the prosecutor, and closing the third
as if in meditation. "I think it happened on the fourth night
of the seventh crossing of Altair II (may the Goddess cast
a drought upon it)—or was it the seventh night of the fourth
crossing?—" he grinned apologetically at the judge—"when I
was making my way back through town toward my blessed
land-plot, minding my own business, Your Honor, after weeks
of bargaining for the crop I was harvesting. Suddenly from the
shadow of the building, this creature—" he waved a paw at
Zeckler—"stopped me in my tracks with a vicious cry. He had
a weapon I'd never seen before, and before I could find my
voice he forced me back against the wall. I could see by the
cruel glint in his eyes that there was no warmth, no sympathy
in his heart, that I was—"
"Objection!" Zeckler squealed plaintively, jumping to his
feet. "This witness can't even remember what night he's talking
about!"
The judge looked startled. Then he pawed feverishly through
his bundle of notes. "Overruled," he said abruptly. "Continue,
please."
The witness glowered at Zeckler. "As I was saying before
this loutish interruption," he muttered, "I could see that I was
face to face with the most desperate of criminal types, even
for Terrans. Note the shape of his head, the flabbiness of his
ears. I was petrified with fear. And then, helpless as I was, this
two-legged abomination began to shower me with threats of
evil to my blessed home, dark threats of poisoning my land
unless I would tell him where he could find the resting place
of our blessed Goddess—"
"I never saw him before in my life," Zeckler moaned to
Meyerhoff. "Listen to him! Why should I care where their
Goddess—"
Meyerhoff gave him a stony look. "The Goddess runs things
around here. She makes it rain. If it doesn't rain, somebody's
insulted her. It's very simple."
"But how can I fight testimony like that?"
"I doubt if you
can
fight it."
"But they can't prove a word of it—" He looked at the jury,
who were listening enraptured to the second witness on the
stand. This one was testifying regarding the butcherous slaughter
of eighteen (or was it twenty-three? Oh, yes, twenty-three)
women and children in the suburban village of Karzan. The
pogrom, it seemed, had been accomplished by an energy
weapon which ate great, gaping holes in the sides of buildings.
A third witness took the stand, continuing the drone as the
room grew hotter and muggier. Zeckler grew paler and paler,
his eyes turning glassy as the testimony piled up. "But it's not
true
," he whispered to Meyerhoff.
"Of course it isn't! Can't you understand?
These people
have no regard for truth.
It's stupid, to them, silly, a mark of
low intelligence. The only thing in the world they have any
respect for is a liar bigger and more skillful than they are."
Zeckler jerked around abruptly as he heard his name bellowed
out. "Does the defendant have anything to say before
the jury delivers the verdict?"
"Do I have—" Zeckler was across the room in a flash, his
pale cheeks suddenly taking on a feverish glow. He sat down
gingerly on the witness chair, facing the judge, his eyes bright
with fear and excitement. "Your—Your Honor, I—I have a
statement to make which will have a most important bearing
on this case. You must listen with the greatest care." He
glanced quickly at Meyerhoff, and back to the judge. "Your
Honor," he said in a hushed voice. "You are in gravest of
danger. All of you. Your lives—your very land is at stake."
The judge blinked, and shuffled through his notes hurriedly
as a murmur arose in the court. "Our land?"
"Your lives, your land, everything you hold dear," Zeckler
said quickly, licking his lips nervously. "You must try to
understand me—" he glanced apprehensively over his shoulder
"now, because I may not live long enough to repeat what
I am about to tell you—"
The murmur quieted down, all ears straining in their headsets
to hear his words. "These charges," he continued, "all of
them—they're perfectly true. At least, they
seem
to be perfectly
true. But in every instance, I was working with heart and
soul, risking my life, for the welfare of your beautiful planet."
There was a loud hiss from the back of the court. Zeckler
frowned and rubbed his hands together. "It was my misfortune,"
he said, "to go to the wrong planet when I first came to
Altair from my homeland on Terra. I—I landed on Altair II,
a grave mistake, but as it turned out, a very fortunate error.
Because in attempting to arrange trading in that frightful place,
I made certain contacts." His voice trembled, and sank lower.
"I learned the horrible thing which is about to happen to this
planet, at the hands of those barbarians. The conspiracy is
theirs, not mine. They have bribed your Goddess, flattered her
and lied to her, coerced her all-powerful goodness to their own
evil interests, preparing for the day when they could persuade
her to cast your land into the fiery furnace of a ten-year-drought—"
Somebody in the middle of the court burst out laughing.
One by one the natives nudged one another, and booed, and
guffawed, until the rising tide of racket drowned out Zeckler's
words. "The defendant is obviously lying," roared the prosecutor
over the pandemonium. "Any fool knows that the Goddess
can't be bribed. How could she be a Goddess if she could?"
Zeckler grew paler. "But—perhaps they were very clever—"
"And how could they flatter her, when she knows, beyond
doubt, that she is the most exquisitely radiant creature in all
the Universe? And
you
dare to insult her, drag her name in
the dirt."
The hisses grew louder, more belligerent. Cries of "Butcher
him!" and "Scald his bowels!" rose from the courtroom. The
judge banged for silence, his eyes angry.
"Unless the defendant wishes to take up more of our precious
time with these ridiculous lies, the jury—"
"Wait! Your Honor, I request a short recess before I present
my final plea."
"Recess?"
"A few moments to collect my thoughts, to arrange my
case."
The judge settled back with a disgusted snarl. "Do I have
to?" he asked Meyerhoff.
Meyerhoff nodded. The judge shrugged, pointing over his
shoulder to the anteroom. "You can go in there," he said.
Somehow, Zeckler managed to stumble from the witness
stand, amid riotous boos and hisses, and tottered into the anteroom.
Zeckler puffed hungrily on a cigarette, and looked up at
Meyerhoff with haunted eyes. "It—it doesn't look so good,"
he muttered.
Meyerhoff's eyes were worried, too. For some reason, he
felt a surge of pity and admiration for the haggard con-man.
"It's worse than I'd anticipated," he admitted glumly. "That
was a good try, but you just don't know enough about them
and their Goddess." He sat down wearily. "I don't see what
you can do. They want your blood, and they're going to have
it. They just won't believe you, no matter
how
big a lie you
tell."
Zeckler sat in silence for a moment. "This lying business,"
he said finally, "exactly how does it work?"
"The biggest, most convincing liar wins. It's as simple as
that. It doesn't matter how outlandish a whopper you tell.
Unless, of course, they've made up their minds that you just
naturally aren't as big a liar as they are. And it looks like that's
just what they've done. It wouldn't make any difference to
them
what
you say—unless, somehow, you could
make
them
believe it."
Zeckler frowned. "And how do they regard the—the biggest
liar? I mean, how do they feel toward him?"
Meyerhoff shifted uneasily. "It's hard to say. It's been my
experience that they respect him highly—maybe even fear him
a little. After all, the most convincing liar always wins in any
transaction, so he gets more land, more food, more power.
Yes, I think the biggest liar could go where he pleased without
any interference."
Zeckler was on his feet, his eyes suddenly bright with excitement.
"Wait a minute," he said tensely. "To tell them a lie
that they'd have to believe—a lie they simply couldn't
help
but believe—" He turned on Meyerhoff, his hands trembling.
"Do they
think
the way we do? I mean, with logic, cause and
effect, examining evidence and drawing conclusions? Given
certain evidence, would they have to draw the same conclusions
that we have to draw?"
Meyerhoff blinked. "Well—yes. Oh, yes, they're perfectly
logical."
Zeckler's eyes flashed, and a huge grin broke out on his
sallow face. His thin body fairly shook. He started hopping
up and down on one foot, staring idiotically into space. "If I
could only think—" he muttered. "Somebody—somewhere—something
I read."
"Whatever are you talking about?"
"It was a Greek, I think—"
Meyerhoff stared at him. "Oh, come now. Have you gone
off your rocker completely? You've got a problem on your
hands, man."
"No, no, I've got a problem in the bag!" Zeckler's cheeks
flushed. "Let's go back in there—I think I've got an answer!"
The courtroom quieted the moment they opened the door,
and the judge banged the gavel for silence. As soon as Zeckler
had taken his seat on the witness stand, the judge turned to
the head juryman. "Now, then," he said with happy finality.
"The jury—"
"Hold on! Just one minute more."
The judge stared down at Zeckler as if he were a bug on a
rock. "Oh, yes. You had something else to say. Well, go ahead
and say it."
Zeckler looked sharply around the hushed room. "You want
to convict me," he said softly, "in the worst sort of way. Isn't
that right?"
Eyes swung toward him. The judge broke into an evil grin.
"That's right."
"But you can't really convict me until you've considered
carefully any statement I make in my own defense. Isn't that
right?"
The judge looked uncomfortable. "If you've got something
to say, go ahead and say it."
"I've got just one statement to make. Short and sweet. But
you'd better listen to it, and think it out carefully before you
decide that you really want to convict me." He paused, and
glanced slyly at the judge. "You don't think much of those
who tell the truth, it seems. Well, put
this
statement in your
record, then." His voice was loud and clear in the still room.
"
All Earthmen are absolutely incapable of telling the truth.
"
Puzzled frowns appeared on the jury's faces. One or two
exchanged startled glances, and the room was still as death.
The judge stared at him, and then at Meyerhoff, then back.
"But you"—he stammered. "You're"—He stopped in mid-sentence,
his jaw sagging.
One of the jurymen let out a little squeak, and fainted dead
away. It took, all in all, about ten seconds for the statement
to soak in.
And then pandemonium broke loose in the courtroom.
"Really," said Harry Zeckler loftily, "it was so obvious I'm
amazed that it didn't occur to me first thing." He settled himself
down comfortably in the control cabin of the Interplanetary
Rocket and grinned at the outline of Altair IV looming larger
in the view screen.
Paul Meyerhoff stared stonily at the controls, his lips compressed
angrily. "You might at least have told me what you
were planning."
"And take the chance of being overheard? Don't be silly.
It had to come as a bombshell. I had to establish myself as a
liar—the prize liar of them all, but I had to tell the sort of lie
that they simply could not cope with. Something that would
throw them into such utter confusion that they wouldn't
dare
convict me." He grinned impishly at Meyerhoff. "The paradox
of Epimenides the Cretan. It really stopped them cold. They
knew
I was an Earthmen, which meant that my statement that
Earthmen were liars was a lie, which meant that maybe I wasn't
a liar, in which case—oh, it was tailor-made."
"It sure was." Meyerhoff's voice was a snarl.
"Well, it made me out a liar in a class they couldn't approach,
didn't it?"
Meyerhoff's face was purple with anger. "Oh, indeed it did!
And it put
all
Earthmen in exactly the same class, too."
"So what's honor among thieves? I got off, didn't I?"
Meyerhoff turned on him fiercely. "Oh, you got off just fine.
You scared the living daylights out of them. And in an eon of
lying they never have run up against a short-circuit like that.
You've also completely botched any hope of ever setting up
a trading alliance with Altair I, and that includes uranium, too.
Smart people don't gamble with loaded dice. You scared them
so badly they don't want anything to do with us."
Zeckler's grin broadened, and he leaned back luxuriously.
"Ah, well. After all, the Trading Alliance was
your
outlook,
wasn't it? What a pity!" He clucked his tongue sadly. "Me,
I've got a fortune in credits sitting back at the consulate waiting
for me—enough to keep me on silk for quite a while, I
might say. I think I'll just take a nice, long vacation."
Meyerhoff turned to him, and a twinkle of malignant glee
appeared in his eyes. "Yes, I think you will. I'm quite sure of
it, in fact. Won't cost you a cent, either."
"Eh?"
Meyerhoff grinned unpleasantly. He brushed an imaginary
lint fleck from his lapel, and looked up at Zeckler slyly. "That—uh—jury
trial. The Altairians weren't any too happy to
oblige. They wanted to execute you outright. Thought a trial
was awfully silly—until they got their money back, of course.
Not too much—just three million credits."
Zeckler went white. "But that money was in banking custody!"
"Is that right? My goodness. You don't suppose they could
have lost those papers, do you?" Meyerhoff grinned at the
little con-man. "And incidentally, you're under arrest, you
know."
A choking sound came from Zeckler's throat. "
Arrest!
"
"Oh, yes. Didn't I tell you? Conspiring to undermine the
authority of the Terran Trading Commission. Serious charge,
you know. Yes, I think we'll take a nice long vacation together,
straight back to Terra. And there I think you'll face a jury
trial."
Zeckler spluttered. "There's no evidence—you've got nothing
on me! What kind of a frame are you trying to pull?"
"A
lovely
frame. Airtight. A frame from the bottom up, and
you're right square in the middle. And this time—" Meyerhoff
tapped a cigarette on his thumb with happy finality—"this time
I
don't
think you'll get off."
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from "Tiger by the Tail and Other Science Fiction
Stories by Alan E. Nourse" and was first published in
If Magazine
January 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright
on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/7/24275//24275-h//24275-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What does the Trading Commission want from the Altairians? | 24275_LUJNWDNS_8 | [
"The Goddess",
"Land",
"Uranium",
"Interplanetary rockets"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
23,791 | 23791_2QXPACKC | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Scrimshaw | 1950.0 | Leinster, Murray | Science fiction; PS; Short stories; Moon -- Fiction | SCRIMSHAW
The old man
just wanted to get back his
memory—and the methods he used were
gently hellish, from the viewpoint of the
others....
BY MURRAY LEINSTER
Illustrated by Freas
Pop Young was the one known
man who could stand life on the
surface of the Moon's far side, and,
therefore, he occupied the shack on
the Big Crack's edge, above the
mining colony there. Some people
said that no normal man could do
it, and mentioned the scar of a
ghastly head-wound to explain his
ability. One man partly guessed the
secret, but only partly. His name was
Sattell and he had reason not to
talk. Pop Young alone knew the
whole truth, and he kept his mouth
shut, too. It wasn't anybody else's
business.
The shack and the job he filled
were located in the medieval notion
of the physical appearance of hell.
By day the environment was heat and
torment. By night—lunar night, of
course, and lunar day—it was frigidity
and horror. Once in two weeks
Earth-time a rocketship came around
the horizon from Lunar City with
stores for the colony deep underground.
Pop received the stores and
took care of them. He handed over
the product of the mine, to be forwarded
to Earth. The rocket went
away again. Come nightfall Pop
lowered the supplies down the long
cable into the Big Crack to the colony
far down inside, and freshened up
the landing field marks with magnesium
marking-powder if a rocket-blast
had blurred them. That was
fundamentally all he had to do. But
without him the mine down in the
Crack would have had to shut
down.
The Crack, of course, was that
gaping rocky fault which stretches
nine hundred miles, jaggedly, over
the side of the Moon that Earth
never sees. There is one stretch where
it is a yawning gulf a full half-mile
wide and unguessably deep. Where
Pop Young's shack stood it was only
a hundred yards, but the colony was
a full mile down, in one wall. There
is nothing like it on Earth, of course.
When it was first found, scientists
descended into it to examine the exposed
rock-strata and learn the history
of the Moon before its craters
were made. But they found more
than history. They found the reason
for the colony and the rocket landing
field and the shack.
The reason for Pop was something
else.
The shack stood a hundred feet
from the Big Crack's edge. It looked
like a dust-heap thirty feet high, and
it was. The outside was surface
moondust, piled over a tiny dome to
be insulation against the cold of
night and shadow and the furnace
heat of day. Pop lived in it all alone,
and in his spare time he worked
industriously at recovering some
missing portions of his life that Sattell
had managed to take away from
him.
He thought often of Sattell, down
in the colony underground. There
were galleries and tunnels and living-quarters
down there. There were
air-tight bulkheads for safety, and a
hydroponic garden to keep the air
fresh, and all sorts of things to make
life possible for men under if not
on the Moon.
But it wasn't fun, even underground.
In the Moon's slight gravity,
a man is really adjusted to existence
when he has a well-developed case
of agoraphobia. With such an aid, a
man can get into a tiny, coffinlike
cubbyhole, and feel solidity above
and below and around him, and
happily tell himself that it feels delicious.
Sometimes it does.
But Sattell couldn't comfort himself
so easily. He knew about Pop,
up on the surface. He'd shipped out,
whimpering, to the Moon to get far
away from Pop, and Pop was just
about a mile overhead and there was
no way to get around him. It was
difficult to get away from the mine,
anyhow. It doesn't take too long for
the low gravity to tear a man's
nerves to shreds. He has to develop
kinks in his head to survive. And
those kinks—
The first men to leave the colony
had to be knocked cold and shipped
out unconscious. They'd been underground—and
in low gravity—long
enough to be utterly unable to face
the idea of open spaces. Even now
there were some who had to be carried,
but there were some tougher
ones who were able to walk to the
rocketship if Pop put a tarpaulin
over their heads so they didn't have
to see the sky. In any case Pop was
essential, either for carrying or
guidance.
Sattell got the shakes when he
thought of Pop, and Pop rather
probably knew it. Of course, by the
time he took the job tending the
shack, he was pretty certain about
Sattell. The facts spoke for themselves.
Pop had come back to consciousness
in a hospital with a great
wound in his head and no memory
of anything that had happened before
that moment. It was not that his
identity was in question. When he
was stronger, the doctors told him
who he was, and as gently as possible
what had happened to his wife
and children. They'd been murdered
after he was seemingly killed defending
them. But he didn't remember
a thing. Not then. It was
something of a blessing.
But when he was physically recovered
he set about trying to pick
up the threads of the life he could
no longer remember. He met Sattell
quite by accident. Sattell looked familiar.
Pop eagerly tried to ask him
questions. And Sattell turned gray
and frantically denied that he'd ever
seen Pop before.
All of which happened back on
Earth and a long time ago. It seemed
to Pop that the sight of Sattell had
brought back some vague and cloudy
memories. They were not sharp,
though, and he hunted up Sattell
again to find out if he was right.
And Sattell went into panic when
he returned.
Nowadays, by the Big Crack, Pop
wasn't so insistent on seeing Sattell,
but he was deeply concerned with
the recovery of the memories that
Sattell helped bring back. Pop was
a highly conscientious man. He took
good care of his job. There was a
warning-bell in the shack, and when
a rocketship from Lunar City got
above the horizon and could send a
tight beam, the gong clanged loudly,
and Pop got into a vacuum-suit
and went out the air lock. He usually
reached the moondozer about the
time the ship began to brake for
landing, and he watched it come in.
He saw the silver needle in the
sky fighting momentum above a line
of jagged crater-walls. It slowed, and
slowed, and curved down as it drew
nearer. The pilot killed all forward
motion just above the field and came
steadily and smoothly down to land
between the silvery triangles that
marked the landing place.
Instantly the rockets cut off,
drums of fuel and air and food came
out of the cargo-hatch and Pop swept
forward with the dozer. It was a
miniature tractor with a gigantic
scoop in front. He pushed a great
mound of talc-fine dust before him
to cover up the cargo. It was necessary.
With freight costing what it
did, fuel and air and food came
frozen solid, in containers barely
thicker than foil. While they stayed
at space-shadow temperature, the foil
would hold anything. And a cover of
insulating moondust with vacuum
between the grains kept even air
frozen solid, though in sunlight.
At such times Pop hardly thought
of Sattell. He knew he had plenty
of time for that. He'd started to follow
Sattell knowing what had happened
to his wife and children, but
it was hearsay only. He had no memory
of them at all. But Sattell stirred
the lost memories. At first Pop followed
absorbedly from city to city,
to recover the years that had been
wiped out by an axe-blow. He did
recover a good deal. When Sattell
fled to another continent, Pop followed
because he had some distinct
memories of his wife—and the way
he'd felt about her—and some fugitive
mental images of his children.
When Sattell frenziedly tried to deny
knowledge of the murder in Tangier,
Pop had come to remember both his
children and some of the happiness
of his married life.
Even when Sattell—whimpering—signed
up for Lunar City, Pop tracked
him. By that time he was quite
sure that Sattell was the man who'd
killed his family. If so, Sattell had
profited by less than two days' pay
for wiping out everything that Pop
possessed. But Pop wanted it back.
He couldn't prove Sattell's guilt.
There was no evidence. In any case,
he didn't really want Sattell to die.
If he did, there'd be no way to recover
more lost memories.
Sometimes, in the shack on the far
side of the Moon, Pop Young had
odd fancies about Sattell. There was
the mine, for example. In each two
Earth-weeks of working, the mine-colony
nearly filled up a three-gallon
cannister with greasy-seeming white
crystals shaped like two pyramids
base to base. The filled cannister
would weigh a hundred pounds on
Earth. Here it weighed eighteen. But
on Earth its contents would be computed
in carats, and a hundred
pounds was worth millions. Yet here
on the Moon Pop kept a waiting cannister
on a shelf in his tiny dome,
behind the air-apparatus. It rattled
if he shook it, and it was worth no
more than so many pebbles. But
sometimes Pop wondered if Sattell
ever thought of the value of the
mine's production. If he would kill
a woman and two children and think
he'd killed a man for no more than
a hundred dollars, what enormity
would he commit for a three-gallon
quantity of uncut diamonds?
But he did not dwell on such
speculation. The sun rose very, very
slowly in what by convention was
called the east. It took nearly two
hours to urge its disk above the
horizon, and it burned terribly in
emptiness for fourteen times twenty-four
hours before sunset. Then there
was night, and for three hundred
and thirty-six consecutive hours there
were only stars overhead and the
sky was a hole so terrible that a man
who looked up into it—what with
the nagging sensation of one-sixth
gravity—tended to lose all confidence
in the stability of things. Most men
immediately found it hysterically necessary
to seize hold of something
solid to keep from falling upward.
But nothing felt solid. Everything
fell, too. Wherefore most men tended
to scream.
But not Pop. He'd come to the
Moon in the first place because Sattell
was here. Near Sattell, he found
memories of times when he was a
young man with a young wife who
loved him extravagantly. Then pictures
of his children came out of
emptiness and grew sharp and clear.
He found that he loved them very
dearly. And when he was near Sattell
he literally recovered them—in
the sense that he came to know new
things about them and had new
memories of them every day. He
hadn't yet remembered the crime
which lost them to him. Until he
did—and the fact possessed a certain
grisly humor—Pop didn't even hate
Sattell. He simply wanted to be near
him because it enabled him to recover
new and vivid parts of his
youth that had been lost.
Otherwise, he was wholly matter-of-fact—certainly
so for the far side
of the Moon. He was a rather fussy
housekeeper. The shack above the
Big Crack's rim was as tidy as any
lighthouse or fur-trapper's cabin. He
tended his air-apparatus with a fine
precision. It was perfectly simple. In
the shadow of the shack he had an
unfailing source of extreme low
temperature. Air from the shack
flowed into a shadow-chilled pipe.
Moisture condensed out of it here,
and CO
2
froze solidly out of it there,
and on beyond it collected as restless,
transparent liquid air. At the same
time, liquid air from another tank
evaporated to maintain the proper
air pressure in the shack. Every so
often Pop tapped the pipe where the
moisture froze, and lumps of water
ice clattered out to be returned to the
humidifier. Less often he took out the
CO
2
snow, and measured it, and
dumped an equivalent quantity of
pale-blue liquid oxygen into the liquid
air that had been purified by
cold. The oxygen dissolved. Then the
apparatus reversed itself and supplied
fresh air from the now-enriched
fluid, while the depleted other
tank began to fill up with cold-purified
liquid air.
Outside the shack, jagged stony
pinnacles reared in the starlight, and
craters complained of the bombardment
from space that had made them.
But, outside, nothing ever happened.
Inside, it was quite different.
Working on his memories, one
day Pop made a little sketch. It
helped a great deal. He grew deeply
interested. Writing-material was
scarce, but he spent most of the time
between two particular rocket-landings
getting down on paper exactly
how a child had looked while sleeping,
some fifteen years before. He
remembered with astonishment that
the child had really looked exactly
like that! Later he began a sketch of
his partly-remembered wife. In time—he
had plenty—it became a really
truthful likeness.
The sun rose, and baked the
abomination of desolation which was
the moonscape. Pop Young meticulously
touched up the glittering
triangles which were landing guides
for the Lunar City ships. They glittered
from the thinnest conceivable
layer of magnesium marking-powder.
He checked over the moondozer.
He tended the air apparatus. He did
everything that his job and survival
required. Ungrudgingly.
Then he made more sketches. The
images to be drawn came back more
clearly when he thought of Sattell,
so by keeping Sattell in mind he recovered
the memory of a chair that
had been in his forgotten home.
Then he drew his wife sitting in it,
reading. It felt very good to see her
again. And he speculated about
whether Sattell ever thought of millions
of dollars' worth of new-mined
diamonds knocking about unguarded
in the shack, and he suddenly recollected
clearly the way one of his
children had looked while playing
with her doll. He made a quick
sketch to keep from forgetting that.
There was no purpose in the
sketching, save that he'd lost all his
young manhood through a senseless
crime. He wanted his youth back. He
was recovering it bit by bit. The
occupation made it absurdly easy to
live on the surface of the far side of
the Moon, whether anybody else
could do it or not.
Sattell had no such device for adjusting
to the lunar state of things.
Living on the Moon was bad enough
anyhow, then, but living one mile
underground from Pop Young was
much worse. Sattell clearly remembered
the crime Pop Young hadn't
yet recalled. He considered that Pop
had made no overt attempt to revenge
himself because he planned
some retaliation so horrible and lingering
that it was worth waiting for.
He came to hate Pop with an insane
ferocity. And fear. In his mind the
need to escape became an obsession
on top of the other psychotic states
normal to a Moon-colonist.
But he was helpless. He couldn't
leave. There was Pop. He couldn't
kill Pop. He had no chance—and he
was afraid. The one absurd, irrelevant
thing he could do was write
letters back to Earth. He did that.
He wrote with the desperate, impassioned,
frantic blend of persuasion
and information and genius-like invention
of a prisoner in a high-security
prison, trying to induce someone
to help him escape.
He had friends, of a sort, but for
a long time his letters produced
nothing. The Moon swung in vast
circles about the Earth, and the Earth
swung sedately about the Sun. The
other planets danced their saraband.
The rest of humanity went about its
own affairs with fascinated attention.
But then an event occurred which
bore directly upon Pop Young and
Sattell and Pop Young's missing
years.
Somebody back on Earth promoted
a luxury passenger-line of spaceships
to ply between Earth and
Moon. It looked like a perfect set-up.
Three spacecraft capable of the journey
came into being with attendant
reams of publicity. They promised a
thrill and a new distinction for the
rich. Guided tours to Lunar! The
most expensive and most thrilling
trip in history! One hundred thousand
dollars for a twelve-day cruise
through space, with views of the
Moon's far side and trips through
Lunar City and a landing in Aristarchus,
plus sound-tapes of the journey
and fame hitherto reserved for
honest explorers!
It didn't seem to have anything
to do with Pop or with Sattell. But
it did.
There were just two passenger
tours. The first was fully booked.
But the passengers who paid so highly,
expected to be pleasantly thrilled
and shielded from all reasons for
alarm. And they couldn't be. Something
happens when a self-centered
and complacent individual unsuspectingly
looks out of a spaceship
port and sees the cosmos unshielded
by mists or clouds or other aids to
blindness against reality. It is shattering.
A millionaire cut his throat when
he saw Earth dwindled to a mere
blue-green ball in vastness. He could
not endure his own smallness in the
face of immensity. Not one passenger
disembarked even for Lunar
City. Most of them cowered in their
chairs, hiding their eyes. They were
the simple cases of hysteria. But the
richest girl on Earth, who'd had five
husbands and believed that nothing
could move her—she went into
catatonic withdrawal and neither
saw nor heard nor moved. Two other
passengers sobbed in improvised
strait jackets. The first shipload
started home. Fast.
The second luxury liner took off
with only four passengers and turned
back before reaching the Moon.
Space-pilots could take the strain of
space-flight because they had work
to do. Workers for the lunar mines
could make the trip under heavy
sedation. But it was too early in the
development of space-travel for
pleasure-passengers. They weren't
prepared for the more humbling
facts of life.
Pop heard of the quaint commercial
enterprise through the micro-tapes
put off at the shack for the men
down in the mine. Sattell probably
learned of it the same way. Pop didn't
even think of it again. It seemed
to have nothing to do with him. But
Sattell undoubtedly dealt with it
fully in his desperate writings back
to Earth.
Pop matter-of-factly tended the
shack and the landing field and the
stores for the Big Crack mine. Between-times
he made more drawings
in pursuit of his own private objective.
Quite accidentally, he developed
a certain talent professional artists
might have approved. But he was not
trying to communicate, but to discover.
Drawing—especially with his
mind on Sattell—he found fresh incidents
popping up in his recollection.
Times when he was happy. One
day he remembered the puppy his
children had owned and loved. He
drew it painstakingly—and it was
his again. Thereafter he could remember
it any time he chose. He did
actually recover a completely vanished
past.
He envisioned a way to increase
that recovery. But there was a marked
shortage of artists' materials on the
Moon. All freight had to be hauled
from Earth, on a voyage equal to
rather more than a thousand times
around the equator of the Earth.
Artists' supplies were not often included.
Pop didn't even ask.
He began to explore the area outside
the shack for possible material
no one would think of sending from
Earth. He collected stones of various
sorts, but when warmed up in the
shack they were useless. He found
no strictly lunar material which
would serve for modeling or carving
portraits in the ground. He found
minerals which could be pulverized
and used as pigments, but nothing
suitable for this new adventure in
the recovery of lost youth. He even
considered blasting, to aid his search.
He could. Down in the mine, blasting
was done by soaking carbon black—from
CO
2
—in liquid oxygen, and then
firing it with a spark. It exploded
splendidly. And its fumes were
merely more CO
2
which an air-apparatus
handled easily.
He didn't do any blasting. He didn't
find any signs of the sort of
mineral he required. Marble would
have been perfect, but there is no
marble on the Moon. Naturally! Yet
Pop continued to search absorbedly
for material with which to capture
memory. Sattell still seemed necessary,
but—
Early one lunar morning he was
a good two miles from his shack
when he saw rocket-fumes in the
sky. It was most unlikely. He wasn't
looking for anything of the sort, but
out of the corner of his eye he observed
that something moved. Which
was impossible. He turned his head,
and there were rocket-fumes coming
over the horizon, not in the direction
of Lunar City. Which was more
impossible still.
He stared. A tiny silver rocket to
the westward poured out monstrous
masses of vapor. It decelerated swiftly.
It curved downward. The rockets
checked for an instant, and flamed
again more violently, and checked
once more. This was not an expert
approach. It was a faulty one. Curving
surface-ward in a sharply changing
parabola, the pilot over-corrected
and had to wait to gather down-speed,
and then over-corrected again.
It was an altogether clumsy landing.
The ship was not even perfectly vertical
when it settled not quite in the
landing-area marked by silvery triangles.
One of its tail-fins crumpled
slightly. It tilted a little when fully
landed.
Then nothing happened.
Pop made his way toward it in
the skittering, skating gait one uses
in one-sixth gravity. When he was
within half a mile, an air-lock door
opened in the ship's side. But nothing
came out of the lock. No space-suited
figure. No cargo came drifting
down with the singular deliberation
of falling objects on the Moon.
It was just barely past lunar sunrise
on the far side of the Moon.
Incredibly long and utterly black
shadows stretched across the plain,
and half the rocketship was dazzling
white and half was blacker than
blackness itself. The sun still hung
low indeed in the black, star-speckled
sky. Pop waded through moondust,
raising a trail of slowly settling
powder. He knew only that the ship
didn't come from Lunar City, but
from Earth. He couldn't imagine
why. He did not even wildly connect
it with what—say—Sattell might
have written with desperate plausibility
about greasy-seeming white
crystals out of the mine, knocking
about Pop Young's shack in cannisters
containing a hundred Earth-pounds
weight of richness.
Pop reached the rocketship. He
approached the big tail-fins. On one
of them there were welded ladder-rungs
going up to the opened air-lock
door.
He climbed.
The air-lock was perfectly normal
when he reached it. There was a
glass port in the inner door, and he
saw eyes looking through it at him.
He pulled the outer door shut and
felt the whining vibration of admitted
air. His vacuum suit went slack
about him. The inner door began to
open, and Pop reached up and gave
his helmet the practiced twisting
jerk which removed it.
Then he blinked. There was a red-headed
man in the opened door. He
grinned savagely at Pop. He held a
very nasty hand-weapon trained on
Pop's middle.
"Don't come in!" he said mockingly.
"And I don't give a damn
about how you are. This isn't social.
It's business!"
Pop simply gaped. He couldn't
quite take it in.
"This," snapped the red-headed
man abruptly, "is a stickup!"
Pop's eyes went through the inner
lock-door. He saw that the interior
of the ship was stripped and bare.
But a spiral stairway descended from
some upper compartment. It had a
handrail of pure, transparent, water-clear
plastic. The walls were bare insulation,
but that trace of luxury remained.
Pop gazed at the plastic,
fascinated.
The red-headed man leaned forward,
snarling. He slashed Pop
across the face with the barrel of his
weapon. It drew blood. It was wanton,
savage brutality.
"Pay attention!" snarled the red-headed
man. "A stickup, I said! Get
it? You go get that can of stuff
from the mine! The diamonds!
Bring them here! Understand?"
Pop said numbly: "What the
hell?"
The red-headed man hit him
again. He was nerve-racked, and,
therefore, he wanted to hurt.
"Move!" he rasped. "I want the
diamonds you've got for the ship
from Lunar City! Bring 'em!" Pop
licked blood from his lips and the
man with the weapon raged at him.
"Then phone down to the mine!
Tell Sattell I'm here and he can
come on up! Tell him to bring any
more diamonds they've dug up since
the stuff you've got!"
He leaned forward. His face was
only inches from Pop Young's. It
was seamed and hard-bitten and
nerve-racked. But any man would be
quivering if he wasn't used to space
or the feel of one-sixth gravity on
the Moon. He panted:
"And get it straight! You try
any tricks and we take off! We
swing over your shack! The rocket-blast
smashes it! We burn you
down! Then we swing over the cable
down to the mine and the rocket-flame
melts it! You die and everybody
in the mine besides! No tricks!
We didn't come here for nothing!"
He twitched all over. Then he
struck cruelly again at Pop Young's
face. He seemed filled with fury, at
least partly hysterical. It was the tension
that space-travel—then, at its
beginning—produced. It was meaningless
savagery due to terror. But,
of course, Pop was helpless to resent
it. There were no weapons on the
Moon and the mention of Sattell's
name showed the uselessness of bluff.
He'd pictured the complete set-up
by the edge of the Big Crack. Pop
could do nothing.
The red-headed man checked
himself, panting. He drew back and
slammed the inner lock-door. There
was the sound of pumping.
Pop put his helmet back on and
sealed it. The outer door opened.
Outrushing air tugged at Pop. After
a second or two he went out and
climbed down the welded-on ladder-bars
to the ground.
He headed back toward his shack.
Somehow, the mention of Sattell had
made his mind work better. It always
did. He began painstakingly to
put things together. The red-headed
man knew the routine here in every
detail. He knew Sattell. That part
was simple. Sattell had planned this
multi-million-dollar coup, as a man
in prison might plan his break. The
stripped interior of the ship identified
it.
It was one of the unsuccessful
luxury-liners sold for scrap. Or perhaps
it was stolen for the journey
here. Sattell's associates had had to
steal or somehow get the fuel, and
somehow find a pilot. But there were
diamonds worth at least five million
dollars waiting for them, and the
whole job might not have called for
more than two men—with Sattell as
a third. According to the economics
of crime, it was feasible. Anyhow it
was being done.
Pop reached the dust-heap which
was his shack and went in the air
lock. Inside, he went to the vision-phone
and called the mine-colony
down in the Crack. He gave the
message he'd been told to pass on.
Sattell to come up, with what diamonds
had been dug since the
regular cannister was sent up for the
Lunar City ship that would be due
presently. Otherwise the ship on the
landing strip would destroy shack
and Pop and the colony together.
"I'd guess," said Pop painstakingly,
"that Sattell figured it out. He's
probably got some sort of gun to
keep you from holding him down
there. But he won't know his friends
are here—not right this minute he
won't."
A shaking voice asked questions
from the vision-phone.
"No," said Pop, "they'll do it anyhow.
If we were able to tell about
'em, they'd be chased. But if I'm
dead and the shacks smashed and
the cable burnt through, they'll be
back on Earth long before a new
cable's been got and let down to you.
So they'll do all they can no matter
what I do." He added, "I wouldn't
tell Sattell a thing about it, if I were
you. It'll save trouble. Just let him
keep on waiting for this to happen.
It'll save you trouble."
Another shaky question.
"Me?" asked Pop. "Oh, I'm going
to raise what hell I can. There's
some stuff in that ship I want."
He switched off the phone. He
went over to his air apparatus. He
took down the cannister of diamonds
which were worth five millions or
more back on Earth. He found a
bucket. He dumped the diamonds
casually into it. They floated downward
with great deliberation and
surged from side to side like a liquid
when they stopped. One-sixth gravity.
Pop regarded his drawings meditatively.
A sketch of his wife as he
now remembered her. It was very
good to remember. A drawing of his
two children, playing together. He
looked forward to remembering
much more about them. He grinned.
"That stair-rail," he said in deep
satisfaction. "That'll do it!"
He tore bed linen from his bunk
and worked on the emptied cannister.
It was a double container with a
thermware interior lining. Even on
Earth newly-mined diamonds sometimes
fly to pieces from internal
stress. On the Moon, it was not desirable
that diamonds be exposed to
repeated violent changes of temperature.
So a thermware-lined cannister
kept them at mine-temperature once
they were warmed to touchability.
Pop packed the cotton cloth in the
container. He hurried a little, because
the men in the rocket were shaky and
might not practice patience. He took
a small emergency-lamp from his
spare spacesuit. He carefully cracked
its bulb, exposing the filament within.
He put the lamp on top of the
cotton and sprinkled magnesium
marking-powder over everything.
Then he went to the air-apparatus
and took out a flask of the liquid
oxygen used to keep his breathing-air
in balance. He poured the frigid,
pale-blue stuff into the cotton. He
saturated it.
All the inside of the shack was
foggy when he finished. Then he
pushed the cannister-top down. He
breathed a sigh of relief when it was
in place. He'd arranged for it to
break a frozen-brittle switch as it
descended. When it came off, the
switch would light the lamp with its
bare filament. There was powdered
magnesium in contact with it and
liquid oxygen all about.
He went out of the shack by the
air lock. On the way, thinking about
Sattell, he suddenly recovered a completely
new memory. On their first
wedding anniversary, so long ago,
he and his wife had gone out to
dinner to celebrate. He remembered
how she looked: the almost-smug
joy they shared that they would be
together for always, with one complete
year for proof.
Pop reflected hungrily that it was
something else to be made permanent
and inspected from time to time.
But he wanted more than a drawing
of this! He wanted to make the memory
permanent and to extend it—
If it had not been for his vacuum
suit and the cannister he carried, Pop
would have rubbed his hands.
Tall, jagged crater-walls rose
from the lunar plain. Monstrous, extended
inky shadows stretched
enormous distances, utterly black.
The sun, like a glowing octopod,
floated low at the edge of things and
seemed to hate all creation.
Pop reached the rocket. He
climbed the welded ladder-rungs to
the air lock. He closed the door. Air
whined. His suit sagged against his
body. He took off his helmet.
When the red-headed man opened
the inner door, the hand-weapon
shook and trembled. Pop said
calmly:
"Now I've got to go handle the
hoist, if Sattell's coming up from
the mine. If I don't do it, he don't
come up."
The red-headed man snarled. But
his eyes were on the cannister whose
contents should weigh a hundred
pounds on Earth.
"Any tricks," he rasped, "and you
know what happens!"
"Yeah," said Pop.
He stolidly put his helmet back
on. But his eyes went past the red-headed
man to the stair that wound
down, inside the ship, from some
compartment above. The stair-rail was
pure, clear, water-white plastic, not
less than three inches thick. There
was a lot of it!
The inner door closed. Pop opened
the outer. Air rushed out. He
climbed painstakingly down to the
ground. He started back toward the
shack.
There was the most luridly bright
of all possible flashes. There was no
sound, of course. But something
flamed very brightly, and the ground
thumped under Pop Young's vacuum
boots. He turned.
The rocketship was still in the act
of flying apart. It had been a splendid
explosion. Of course cotton sheeting
in liquid oxygen is not quite as
good an explosive as carbon-black,
which they used down in the mine.
Even with magnesium powder to
start the flame when a bare light-filament
ignited it, the cannister-bomb
hadn't equaled—say—T.N.T.
But the ship had fuel on board for
the trip back to Earth. And it blew,
too. It would be minutes before all
the fragments of the ship returned
to the Moon's surface. On the Moon,
things fall slowly.
Pop didn't wait. He searched
hopefully. Once a mass of steel plating
fell only yards from him, but it
did not interrupt his search.
When he went into the shack, he
grinned to himself. The call-light of
the vision-phone flickered wildly.
When he took off his helmet the bell
clanged incessantly. He answered. A
shaking voice from the mining-colony
panted:
"We felt a shock! What happened?
What do we do?"
"Don't do a thing," advised Pop.
"It's all right. I blew up the ship and
everything's all right. I wouldn't
even mention it to Sattell if I were
you."
He grinned happily down at a section
of plastic stair-rail he'd found
not too far from where the ship exploded.
When the man down in the
mine cut off, Pop got out of his
vacuum suit in a hurry. He placed
the plastic zestfully on the table
where he'd been restricted to drawing
pictures of his wife and children
in order to recover memories of
them.
He began to plan, gloatingly, the
thing he would carve out of a four-inch
section of the plastic. When it
was carved, he'd paint it. While he
worked, he'd think of Sattell, because
that was the way to get back the
missing portions of his life—the
parts Sattell had managed to get
away from him. He'd get back more
than ever, now!
He didn't wonder what he'd do
if he ever remembered the crime
Sattell had committed. He felt, somehow,
that he wouldn't get that back
until he'd recovered all the rest.
Gloating, it was amusing to remember
what people used to call
such art-works as he planned, when
carved by other lonely men in other
faraway places. They called those
sculptures scrimshaw.
But they were a lot more than
that!
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Astounding Science Fiction
September
1955. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/3/7/9/23791//23791-h//23791-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why did Pop go to Lunar City? | 23791_2QXPACKC_1 | [
"Pop went to Lunar City because the Earth is overcrowded.",
"Pop went to Lunar City because Sattell went to Lunar City.",
"Pop went to Lunar City because his family was murdered, and he couldn't stand to be on Earth any longer.",
"Pop went to Lunar City to mine diamonds."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
23,791 | 23791_2QXPACKC | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Scrimshaw | 1950.0 | Leinster, Murray | Science fiction; PS; Short stories; Moon -- Fiction | SCRIMSHAW
The old man
just wanted to get back his
memory—and the methods he used were
gently hellish, from the viewpoint of the
others....
BY MURRAY LEINSTER
Illustrated by Freas
Pop Young was the one known
man who could stand life on the
surface of the Moon's far side, and,
therefore, he occupied the shack on
the Big Crack's edge, above the
mining colony there. Some people
said that no normal man could do
it, and mentioned the scar of a
ghastly head-wound to explain his
ability. One man partly guessed the
secret, but only partly. His name was
Sattell and he had reason not to
talk. Pop Young alone knew the
whole truth, and he kept his mouth
shut, too. It wasn't anybody else's
business.
The shack and the job he filled
were located in the medieval notion
of the physical appearance of hell.
By day the environment was heat and
torment. By night—lunar night, of
course, and lunar day—it was frigidity
and horror. Once in two weeks
Earth-time a rocketship came around
the horizon from Lunar City with
stores for the colony deep underground.
Pop received the stores and
took care of them. He handed over
the product of the mine, to be forwarded
to Earth. The rocket went
away again. Come nightfall Pop
lowered the supplies down the long
cable into the Big Crack to the colony
far down inside, and freshened up
the landing field marks with magnesium
marking-powder if a rocket-blast
had blurred them. That was
fundamentally all he had to do. But
without him the mine down in the
Crack would have had to shut
down.
The Crack, of course, was that
gaping rocky fault which stretches
nine hundred miles, jaggedly, over
the side of the Moon that Earth
never sees. There is one stretch where
it is a yawning gulf a full half-mile
wide and unguessably deep. Where
Pop Young's shack stood it was only
a hundred yards, but the colony was
a full mile down, in one wall. There
is nothing like it on Earth, of course.
When it was first found, scientists
descended into it to examine the exposed
rock-strata and learn the history
of the Moon before its craters
were made. But they found more
than history. They found the reason
for the colony and the rocket landing
field and the shack.
The reason for Pop was something
else.
The shack stood a hundred feet
from the Big Crack's edge. It looked
like a dust-heap thirty feet high, and
it was. The outside was surface
moondust, piled over a tiny dome to
be insulation against the cold of
night and shadow and the furnace
heat of day. Pop lived in it all alone,
and in his spare time he worked
industriously at recovering some
missing portions of his life that Sattell
had managed to take away from
him.
He thought often of Sattell, down
in the colony underground. There
were galleries and tunnels and living-quarters
down there. There were
air-tight bulkheads for safety, and a
hydroponic garden to keep the air
fresh, and all sorts of things to make
life possible for men under if not
on the Moon.
But it wasn't fun, even underground.
In the Moon's slight gravity,
a man is really adjusted to existence
when he has a well-developed case
of agoraphobia. With such an aid, a
man can get into a tiny, coffinlike
cubbyhole, and feel solidity above
and below and around him, and
happily tell himself that it feels delicious.
Sometimes it does.
But Sattell couldn't comfort himself
so easily. He knew about Pop,
up on the surface. He'd shipped out,
whimpering, to the Moon to get far
away from Pop, and Pop was just
about a mile overhead and there was
no way to get around him. It was
difficult to get away from the mine,
anyhow. It doesn't take too long for
the low gravity to tear a man's
nerves to shreds. He has to develop
kinks in his head to survive. And
those kinks—
The first men to leave the colony
had to be knocked cold and shipped
out unconscious. They'd been underground—and
in low gravity—long
enough to be utterly unable to face
the idea of open spaces. Even now
there were some who had to be carried,
but there were some tougher
ones who were able to walk to the
rocketship if Pop put a tarpaulin
over their heads so they didn't have
to see the sky. In any case Pop was
essential, either for carrying or
guidance.
Sattell got the shakes when he
thought of Pop, and Pop rather
probably knew it. Of course, by the
time he took the job tending the
shack, he was pretty certain about
Sattell. The facts spoke for themselves.
Pop had come back to consciousness
in a hospital with a great
wound in his head and no memory
of anything that had happened before
that moment. It was not that his
identity was in question. When he
was stronger, the doctors told him
who he was, and as gently as possible
what had happened to his wife
and children. They'd been murdered
after he was seemingly killed defending
them. But he didn't remember
a thing. Not then. It was
something of a blessing.
But when he was physically recovered
he set about trying to pick
up the threads of the life he could
no longer remember. He met Sattell
quite by accident. Sattell looked familiar.
Pop eagerly tried to ask him
questions. And Sattell turned gray
and frantically denied that he'd ever
seen Pop before.
All of which happened back on
Earth and a long time ago. It seemed
to Pop that the sight of Sattell had
brought back some vague and cloudy
memories. They were not sharp,
though, and he hunted up Sattell
again to find out if he was right.
And Sattell went into panic when
he returned.
Nowadays, by the Big Crack, Pop
wasn't so insistent on seeing Sattell,
but he was deeply concerned with
the recovery of the memories that
Sattell helped bring back. Pop was
a highly conscientious man. He took
good care of his job. There was a
warning-bell in the shack, and when
a rocketship from Lunar City got
above the horizon and could send a
tight beam, the gong clanged loudly,
and Pop got into a vacuum-suit
and went out the air lock. He usually
reached the moondozer about the
time the ship began to brake for
landing, and he watched it come in.
He saw the silver needle in the
sky fighting momentum above a line
of jagged crater-walls. It slowed, and
slowed, and curved down as it drew
nearer. The pilot killed all forward
motion just above the field and came
steadily and smoothly down to land
between the silvery triangles that
marked the landing place.
Instantly the rockets cut off,
drums of fuel and air and food came
out of the cargo-hatch and Pop swept
forward with the dozer. It was a
miniature tractor with a gigantic
scoop in front. He pushed a great
mound of talc-fine dust before him
to cover up the cargo. It was necessary.
With freight costing what it
did, fuel and air and food came
frozen solid, in containers barely
thicker than foil. While they stayed
at space-shadow temperature, the foil
would hold anything. And a cover of
insulating moondust with vacuum
between the grains kept even air
frozen solid, though in sunlight.
At such times Pop hardly thought
of Sattell. He knew he had plenty
of time for that. He'd started to follow
Sattell knowing what had happened
to his wife and children, but
it was hearsay only. He had no memory
of them at all. But Sattell stirred
the lost memories. At first Pop followed
absorbedly from city to city,
to recover the years that had been
wiped out by an axe-blow. He did
recover a good deal. When Sattell
fled to another continent, Pop followed
because he had some distinct
memories of his wife—and the way
he'd felt about her—and some fugitive
mental images of his children.
When Sattell frenziedly tried to deny
knowledge of the murder in Tangier,
Pop had come to remember both his
children and some of the happiness
of his married life.
Even when Sattell—whimpering—signed
up for Lunar City, Pop tracked
him. By that time he was quite
sure that Sattell was the man who'd
killed his family. If so, Sattell had
profited by less than two days' pay
for wiping out everything that Pop
possessed. But Pop wanted it back.
He couldn't prove Sattell's guilt.
There was no evidence. In any case,
he didn't really want Sattell to die.
If he did, there'd be no way to recover
more lost memories.
Sometimes, in the shack on the far
side of the Moon, Pop Young had
odd fancies about Sattell. There was
the mine, for example. In each two
Earth-weeks of working, the mine-colony
nearly filled up a three-gallon
cannister with greasy-seeming white
crystals shaped like two pyramids
base to base. The filled cannister
would weigh a hundred pounds on
Earth. Here it weighed eighteen. But
on Earth its contents would be computed
in carats, and a hundred
pounds was worth millions. Yet here
on the Moon Pop kept a waiting cannister
on a shelf in his tiny dome,
behind the air-apparatus. It rattled
if he shook it, and it was worth no
more than so many pebbles. But
sometimes Pop wondered if Sattell
ever thought of the value of the
mine's production. If he would kill
a woman and two children and think
he'd killed a man for no more than
a hundred dollars, what enormity
would he commit for a three-gallon
quantity of uncut diamonds?
But he did not dwell on such
speculation. The sun rose very, very
slowly in what by convention was
called the east. It took nearly two
hours to urge its disk above the
horizon, and it burned terribly in
emptiness for fourteen times twenty-four
hours before sunset. Then there
was night, and for three hundred
and thirty-six consecutive hours there
were only stars overhead and the
sky was a hole so terrible that a man
who looked up into it—what with
the nagging sensation of one-sixth
gravity—tended to lose all confidence
in the stability of things. Most men
immediately found it hysterically necessary
to seize hold of something
solid to keep from falling upward.
But nothing felt solid. Everything
fell, too. Wherefore most men tended
to scream.
But not Pop. He'd come to the
Moon in the first place because Sattell
was here. Near Sattell, he found
memories of times when he was a
young man with a young wife who
loved him extravagantly. Then pictures
of his children came out of
emptiness and grew sharp and clear.
He found that he loved them very
dearly. And when he was near Sattell
he literally recovered them—in
the sense that he came to know new
things about them and had new
memories of them every day. He
hadn't yet remembered the crime
which lost them to him. Until he
did—and the fact possessed a certain
grisly humor—Pop didn't even hate
Sattell. He simply wanted to be near
him because it enabled him to recover
new and vivid parts of his
youth that had been lost.
Otherwise, he was wholly matter-of-fact—certainly
so for the far side
of the Moon. He was a rather fussy
housekeeper. The shack above the
Big Crack's rim was as tidy as any
lighthouse or fur-trapper's cabin. He
tended his air-apparatus with a fine
precision. It was perfectly simple. In
the shadow of the shack he had an
unfailing source of extreme low
temperature. Air from the shack
flowed into a shadow-chilled pipe.
Moisture condensed out of it here,
and CO
2
froze solidly out of it there,
and on beyond it collected as restless,
transparent liquid air. At the same
time, liquid air from another tank
evaporated to maintain the proper
air pressure in the shack. Every so
often Pop tapped the pipe where the
moisture froze, and lumps of water
ice clattered out to be returned to the
humidifier. Less often he took out the
CO
2
snow, and measured it, and
dumped an equivalent quantity of
pale-blue liquid oxygen into the liquid
air that had been purified by
cold. The oxygen dissolved. Then the
apparatus reversed itself and supplied
fresh air from the now-enriched
fluid, while the depleted other
tank began to fill up with cold-purified
liquid air.
Outside the shack, jagged stony
pinnacles reared in the starlight, and
craters complained of the bombardment
from space that had made them.
But, outside, nothing ever happened.
Inside, it was quite different.
Working on his memories, one
day Pop made a little sketch. It
helped a great deal. He grew deeply
interested. Writing-material was
scarce, but he spent most of the time
between two particular rocket-landings
getting down on paper exactly
how a child had looked while sleeping,
some fifteen years before. He
remembered with astonishment that
the child had really looked exactly
like that! Later he began a sketch of
his partly-remembered wife. In time—he
had plenty—it became a really
truthful likeness.
The sun rose, and baked the
abomination of desolation which was
the moonscape. Pop Young meticulously
touched up the glittering
triangles which were landing guides
for the Lunar City ships. They glittered
from the thinnest conceivable
layer of magnesium marking-powder.
He checked over the moondozer.
He tended the air apparatus. He did
everything that his job and survival
required. Ungrudgingly.
Then he made more sketches. The
images to be drawn came back more
clearly when he thought of Sattell,
so by keeping Sattell in mind he recovered
the memory of a chair that
had been in his forgotten home.
Then he drew his wife sitting in it,
reading. It felt very good to see her
again. And he speculated about
whether Sattell ever thought of millions
of dollars' worth of new-mined
diamonds knocking about unguarded
in the shack, and he suddenly recollected
clearly the way one of his
children had looked while playing
with her doll. He made a quick
sketch to keep from forgetting that.
There was no purpose in the
sketching, save that he'd lost all his
young manhood through a senseless
crime. He wanted his youth back. He
was recovering it bit by bit. The
occupation made it absurdly easy to
live on the surface of the far side of
the Moon, whether anybody else
could do it or not.
Sattell had no such device for adjusting
to the lunar state of things.
Living on the Moon was bad enough
anyhow, then, but living one mile
underground from Pop Young was
much worse. Sattell clearly remembered
the crime Pop Young hadn't
yet recalled. He considered that Pop
had made no overt attempt to revenge
himself because he planned
some retaliation so horrible and lingering
that it was worth waiting for.
He came to hate Pop with an insane
ferocity. And fear. In his mind the
need to escape became an obsession
on top of the other psychotic states
normal to a Moon-colonist.
But he was helpless. He couldn't
leave. There was Pop. He couldn't
kill Pop. He had no chance—and he
was afraid. The one absurd, irrelevant
thing he could do was write
letters back to Earth. He did that.
He wrote with the desperate, impassioned,
frantic blend of persuasion
and information and genius-like invention
of a prisoner in a high-security
prison, trying to induce someone
to help him escape.
He had friends, of a sort, but for
a long time his letters produced
nothing. The Moon swung in vast
circles about the Earth, and the Earth
swung sedately about the Sun. The
other planets danced their saraband.
The rest of humanity went about its
own affairs with fascinated attention.
But then an event occurred which
bore directly upon Pop Young and
Sattell and Pop Young's missing
years.
Somebody back on Earth promoted
a luxury passenger-line of spaceships
to ply between Earth and
Moon. It looked like a perfect set-up.
Three spacecraft capable of the journey
came into being with attendant
reams of publicity. They promised a
thrill and a new distinction for the
rich. Guided tours to Lunar! The
most expensive and most thrilling
trip in history! One hundred thousand
dollars for a twelve-day cruise
through space, with views of the
Moon's far side and trips through
Lunar City and a landing in Aristarchus,
plus sound-tapes of the journey
and fame hitherto reserved for
honest explorers!
It didn't seem to have anything
to do with Pop or with Sattell. But
it did.
There were just two passenger
tours. The first was fully booked.
But the passengers who paid so highly,
expected to be pleasantly thrilled
and shielded from all reasons for
alarm. And they couldn't be. Something
happens when a self-centered
and complacent individual unsuspectingly
looks out of a spaceship
port and sees the cosmos unshielded
by mists or clouds or other aids to
blindness against reality. It is shattering.
A millionaire cut his throat when
he saw Earth dwindled to a mere
blue-green ball in vastness. He could
not endure his own smallness in the
face of immensity. Not one passenger
disembarked even for Lunar
City. Most of them cowered in their
chairs, hiding their eyes. They were
the simple cases of hysteria. But the
richest girl on Earth, who'd had five
husbands and believed that nothing
could move her—she went into
catatonic withdrawal and neither
saw nor heard nor moved. Two other
passengers sobbed in improvised
strait jackets. The first shipload
started home. Fast.
The second luxury liner took off
with only four passengers and turned
back before reaching the Moon.
Space-pilots could take the strain of
space-flight because they had work
to do. Workers for the lunar mines
could make the trip under heavy
sedation. But it was too early in the
development of space-travel for
pleasure-passengers. They weren't
prepared for the more humbling
facts of life.
Pop heard of the quaint commercial
enterprise through the micro-tapes
put off at the shack for the men
down in the mine. Sattell probably
learned of it the same way. Pop didn't
even think of it again. It seemed
to have nothing to do with him. But
Sattell undoubtedly dealt with it
fully in his desperate writings back
to Earth.
Pop matter-of-factly tended the
shack and the landing field and the
stores for the Big Crack mine. Between-times
he made more drawings
in pursuit of his own private objective.
Quite accidentally, he developed
a certain talent professional artists
might have approved. But he was not
trying to communicate, but to discover.
Drawing—especially with his
mind on Sattell—he found fresh incidents
popping up in his recollection.
Times when he was happy. One
day he remembered the puppy his
children had owned and loved. He
drew it painstakingly—and it was
his again. Thereafter he could remember
it any time he chose. He did
actually recover a completely vanished
past.
He envisioned a way to increase
that recovery. But there was a marked
shortage of artists' materials on the
Moon. All freight had to be hauled
from Earth, on a voyage equal to
rather more than a thousand times
around the equator of the Earth.
Artists' supplies were not often included.
Pop didn't even ask.
He began to explore the area outside
the shack for possible material
no one would think of sending from
Earth. He collected stones of various
sorts, but when warmed up in the
shack they were useless. He found
no strictly lunar material which
would serve for modeling or carving
portraits in the ground. He found
minerals which could be pulverized
and used as pigments, but nothing
suitable for this new adventure in
the recovery of lost youth. He even
considered blasting, to aid his search.
He could. Down in the mine, blasting
was done by soaking carbon black—from
CO
2
—in liquid oxygen, and then
firing it with a spark. It exploded
splendidly. And its fumes were
merely more CO
2
which an air-apparatus
handled easily.
He didn't do any blasting. He didn't
find any signs of the sort of
mineral he required. Marble would
have been perfect, but there is no
marble on the Moon. Naturally! Yet
Pop continued to search absorbedly
for material with which to capture
memory. Sattell still seemed necessary,
but—
Early one lunar morning he was
a good two miles from his shack
when he saw rocket-fumes in the
sky. It was most unlikely. He wasn't
looking for anything of the sort, but
out of the corner of his eye he observed
that something moved. Which
was impossible. He turned his head,
and there were rocket-fumes coming
over the horizon, not in the direction
of Lunar City. Which was more
impossible still.
He stared. A tiny silver rocket to
the westward poured out monstrous
masses of vapor. It decelerated swiftly.
It curved downward. The rockets
checked for an instant, and flamed
again more violently, and checked
once more. This was not an expert
approach. It was a faulty one. Curving
surface-ward in a sharply changing
parabola, the pilot over-corrected
and had to wait to gather down-speed,
and then over-corrected again.
It was an altogether clumsy landing.
The ship was not even perfectly vertical
when it settled not quite in the
landing-area marked by silvery triangles.
One of its tail-fins crumpled
slightly. It tilted a little when fully
landed.
Then nothing happened.
Pop made his way toward it in
the skittering, skating gait one uses
in one-sixth gravity. When he was
within half a mile, an air-lock door
opened in the ship's side. But nothing
came out of the lock. No space-suited
figure. No cargo came drifting
down with the singular deliberation
of falling objects on the Moon.
It was just barely past lunar sunrise
on the far side of the Moon.
Incredibly long and utterly black
shadows stretched across the plain,
and half the rocketship was dazzling
white and half was blacker than
blackness itself. The sun still hung
low indeed in the black, star-speckled
sky. Pop waded through moondust,
raising a trail of slowly settling
powder. He knew only that the ship
didn't come from Lunar City, but
from Earth. He couldn't imagine
why. He did not even wildly connect
it with what—say—Sattell might
have written with desperate plausibility
about greasy-seeming white
crystals out of the mine, knocking
about Pop Young's shack in cannisters
containing a hundred Earth-pounds
weight of richness.
Pop reached the rocketship. He
approached the big tail-fins. On one
of them there were welded ladder-rungs
going up to the opened air-lock
door.
He climbed.
The air-lock was perfectly normal
when he reached it. There was a
glass port in the inner door, and he
saw eyes looking through it at him.
He pulled the outer door shut and
felt the whining vibration of admitted
air. His vacuum suit went slack
about him. The inner door began to
open, and Pop reached up and gave
his helmet the practiced twisting
jerk which removed it.
Then he blinked. There was a red-headed
man in the opened door. He
grinned savagely at Pop. He held a
very nasty hand-weapon trained on
Pop's middle.
"Don't come in!" he said mockingly.
"And I don't give a damn
about how you are. This isn't social.
It's business!"
Pop simply gaped. He couldn't
quite take it in.
"This," snapped the red-headed
man abruptly, "is a stickup!"
Pop's eyes went through the inner
lock-door. He saw that the interior
of the ship was stripped and bare.
But a spiral stairway descended from
some upper compartment. It had a
handrail of pure, transparent, water-clear
plastic. The walls were bare insulation,
but that trace of luxury remained.
Pop gazed at the plastic,
fascinated.
The red-headed man leaned forward,
snarling. He slashed Pop
across the face with the barrel of his
weapon. It drew blood. It was wanton,
savage brutality.
"Pay attention!" snarled the red-headed
man. "A stickup, I said! Get
it? You go get that can of stuff
from the mine! The diamonds!
Bring them here! Understand?"
Pop said numbly: "What the
hell?"
The red-headed man hit him
again. He was nerve-racked, and,
therefore, he wanted to hurt.
"Move!" he rasped. "I want the
diamonds you've got for the ship
from Lunar City! Bring 'em!" Pop
licked blood from his lips and the
man with the weapon raged at him.
"Then phone down to the mine!
Tell Sattell I'm here and he can
come on up! Tell him to bring any
more diamonds they've dug up since
the stuff you've got!"
He leaned forward. His face was
only inches from Pop Young's. It
was seamed and hard-bitten and
nerve-racked. But any man would be
quivering if he wasn't used to space
or the feel of one-sixth gravity on
the Moon. He panted:
"And get it straight! You try
any tricks and we take off! We
swing over your shack! The rocket-blast
smashes it! We burn you
down! Then we swing over the cable
down to the mine and the rocket-flame
melts it! You die and everybody
in the mine besides! No tricks!
We didn't come here for nothing!"
He twitched all over. Then he
struck cruelly again at Pop Young's
face. He seemed filled with fury, at
least partly hysterical. It was the tension
that space-travel—then, at its
beginning—produced. It was meaningless
savagery due to terror. But,
of course, Pop was helpless to resent
it. There were no weapons on the
Moon and the mention of Sattell's
name showed the uselessness of bluff.
He'd pictured the complete set-up
by the edge of the Big Crack. Pop
could do nothing.
The red-headed man checked
himself, panting. He drew back and
slammed the inner lock-door. There
was the sound of pumping.
Pop put his helmet back on and
sealed it. The outer door opened.
Outrushing air tugged at Pop. After
a second or two he went out and
climbed down the welded-on ladder-bars
to the ground.
He headed back toward his shack.
Somehow, the mention of Sattell had
made his mind work better. It always
did. He began painstakingly to
put things together. The red-headed
man knew the routine here in every
detail. He knew Sattell. That part
was simple. Sattell had planned this
multi-million-dollar coup, as a man
in prison might plan his break. The
stripped interior of the ship identified
it.
It was one of the unsuccessful
luxury-liners sold for scrap. Or perhaps
it was stolen for the journey
here. Sattell's associates had had to
steal or somehow get the fuel, and
somehow find a pilot. But there were
diamonds worth at least five million
dollars waiting for them, and the
whole job might not have called for
more than two men—with Sattell as
a third. According to the economics
of crime, it was feasible. Anyhow it
was being done.
Pop reached the dust-heap which
was his shack and went in the air
lock. Inside, he went to the vision-phone
and called the mine-colony
down in the Crack. He gave the
message he'd been told to pass on.
Sattell to come up, with what diamonds
had been dug since the
regular cannister was sent up for the
Lunar City ship that would be due
presently. Otherwise the ship on the
landing strip would destroy shack
and Pop and the colony together.
"I'd guess," said Pop painstakingly,
"that Sattell figured it out. He's
probably got some sort of gun to
keep you from holding him down
there. But he won't know his friends
are here—not right this minute he
won't."
A shaking voice asked questions
from the vision-phone.
"No," said Pop, "they'll do it anyhow.
If we were able to tell about
'em, they'd be chased. But if I'm
dead and the shacks smashed and
the cable burnt through, they'll be
back on Earth long before a new
cable's been got and let down to you.
So they'll do all they can no matter
what I do." He added, "I wouldn't
tell Sattell a thing about it, if I were
you. It'll save trouble. Just let him
keep on waiting for this to happen.
It'll save you trouble."
Another shaky question.
"Me?" asked Pop. "Oh, I'm going
to raise what hell I can. There's
some stuff in that ship I want."
He switched off the phone. He
went over to his air apparatus. He
took down the cannister of diamonds
which were worth five millions or
more back on Earth. He found a
bucket. He dumped the diamonds
casually into it. They floated downward
with great deliberation and
surged from side to side like a liquid
when they stopped. One-sixth gravity.
Pop regarded his drawings meditatively.
A sketch of his wife as he
now remembered her. It was very
good to remember. A drawing of his
two children, playing together. He
looked forward to remembering
much more about them. He grinned.
"That stair-rail," he said in deep
satisfaction. "That'll do it!"
He tore bed linen from his bunk
and worked on the emptied cannister.
It was a double container with a
thermware interior lining. Even on
Earth newly-mined diamonds sometimes
fly to pieces from internal
stress. On the Moon, it was not desirable
that diamonds be exposed to
repeated violent changes of temperature.
So a thermware-lined cannister
kept them at mine-temperature once
they were warmed to touchability.
Pop packed the cotton cloth in the
container. He hurried a little, because
the men in the rocket were shaky and
might not practice patience. He took
a small emergency-lamp from his
spare spacesuit. He carefully cracked
its bulb, exposing the filament within.
He put the lamp on top of the
cotton and sprinkled magnesium
marking-powder over everything.
Then he went to the air-apparatus
and took out a flask of the liquid
oxygen used to keep his breathing-air
in balance. He poured the frigid,
pale-blue stuff into the cotton. He
saturated it.
All the inside of the shack was
foggy when he finished. Then he
pushed the cannister-top down. He
breathed a sigh of relief when it was
in place. He'd arranged for it to
break a frozen-brittle switch as it
descended. When it came off, the
switch would light the lamp with its
bare filament. There was powdered
magnesium in contact with it and
liquid oxygen all about.
He went out of the shack by the
air lock. On the way, thinking about
Sattell, he suddenly recovered a completely
new memory. On their first
wedding anniversary, so long ago,
he and his wife had gone out to
dinner to celebrate. He remembered
how she looked: the almost-smug
joy they shared that they would be
together for always, with one complete
year for proof.
Pop reflected hungrily that it was
something else to be made permanent
and inspected from time to time.
But he wanted more than a drawing
of this! He wanted to make the memory
permanent and to extend it—
If it had not been for his vacuum
suit and the cannister he carried, Pop
would have rubbed his hands.
Tall, jagged crater-walls rose
from the lunar plain. Monstrous, extended
inky shadows stretched
enormous distances, utterly black.
The sun, like a glowing octopod,
floated low at the edge of things and
seemed to hate all creation.
Pop reached the rocket. He
climbed the welded ladder-rungs to
the air lock. He closed the door. Air
whined. His suit sagged against his
body. He took off his helmet.
When the red-headed man opened
the inner door, the hand-weapon
shook and trembled. Pop said
calmly:
"Now I've got to go handle the
hoist, if Sattell's coming up from
the mine. If I don't do it, he don't
come up."
The red-headed man snarled. But
his eyes were on the cannister whose
contents should weigh a hundred
pounds on Earth.
"Any tricks," he rasped, "and you
know what happens!"
"Yeah," said Pop.
He stolidly put his helmet back
on. But his eyes went past the red-headed
man to the stair that wound
down, inside the ship, from some
compartment above. The stair-rail was
pure, clear, water-white plastic, not
less than three inches thick. There
was a lot of it!
The inner door closed. Pop opened
the outer. Air rushed out. He
climbed painstakingly down to the
ground. He started back toward the
shack.
There was the most luridly bright
of all possible flashes. There was no
sound, of course. But something
flamed very brightly, and the ground
thumped under Pop Young's vacuum
boots. He turned.
The rocketship was still in the act
of flying apart. It had been a splendid
explosion. Of course cotton sheeting
in liquid oxygen is not quite as
good an explosive as carbon-black,
which they used down in the mine.
Even with magnesium powder to
start the flame when a bare light-filament
ignited it, the cannister-bomb
hadn't equaled—say—T.N.T.
But the ship had fuel on board for
the trip back to Earth. And it blew,
too. It would be minutes before all
the fragments of the ship returned
to the Moon's surface. On the Moon,
things fall slowly.
Pop didn't wait. He searched
hopefully. Once a mass of steel plating
fell only yards from him, but it
did not interrupt his search.
When he went into the shack, he
grinned to himself. The call-light of
the vision-phone flickered wildly.
When he took off his helmet the bell
clanged incessantly. He answered. A
shaking voice from the mining-colony
panted:
"We felt a shock! What happened?
What do we do?"
"Don't do a thing," advised Pop.
"It's all right. I blew up the ship and
everything's all right. I wouldn't
even mention it to Sattell if I were
you."
He grinned happily down at a section
of plastic stair-rail he'd found
not too far from where the ship exploded.
When the man down in the
mine cut off, Pop got out of his
vacuum suit in a hurry. He placed
the plastic zestfully on the table
where he'd been restricted to drawing
pictures of his wife and children
in order to recover memories of
them.
He began to plan, gloatingly, the
thing he would carve out of a four-inch
section of the plastic. When it
was carved, he'd paint it. While he
worked, he'd think of Sattell, because
that was the way to get back the
missing portions of his life—the
parts Sattell had managed to get
away from him. He'd get back more
than ever, now!
He didn't wonder what he'd do
if he ever remembered the crime
Sattell had committed. He felt, somehow,
that he wouldn't get that back
until he'd recovered all the rest.
Gloating, it was amusing to remember
what people used to call
such art-works as he planned, when
carved by other lonely men in other
faraway places. They called those
sculptures scrimshaw.
But they were a lot more than
that!
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Astounding Science Fiction
September
1955. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/3/7/9/23791//23791-h//23791-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does Pop feel about Sattell? | 23791_2QXPACKC_2 | [
"Pop thinks Sattell murdered his family, but he wants Sattell to live. Being near Sattell sparks lost memories.",
"Pop thinks Sattell murdered his family. Pop wants to torture Sattell.",
"Pop thinks Sattell murdered his family Now Sattell is going to destroy Lunar City, and steal the diamonds.",
"Sattell murdered Pop's family, Pop wants Sattell dead."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
23,791 | 23791_2QXPACKC | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Scrimshaw | 1950.0 | Leinster, Murray | Science fiction; PS; Short stories; Moon -- Fiction | SCRIMSHAW
The old man
just wanted to get back his
memory—and the methods he used were
gently hellish, from the viewpoint of the
others....
BY MURRAY LEINSTER
Illustrated by Freas
Pop Young was the one known
man who could stand life on the
surface of the Moon's far side, and,
therefore, he occupied the shack on
the Big Crack's edge, above the
mining colony there. Some people
said that no normal man could do
it, and mentioned the scar of a
ghastly head-wound to explain his
ability. One man partly guessed the
secret, but only partly. His name was
Sattell and he had reason not to
talk. Pop Young alone knew the
whole truth, and he kept his mouth
shut, too. It wasn't anybody else's
business.
The shack and the job he filled
were located in the medieval notion
of the physical appearance of hell.
By day the environment was heat and
torment. By night—lunar night, of
course, and lunar day—it was frigidity
and horror. Once in two weeks
Earth-time a rocketship came around
the horizon from Lunar City with
stores for the colony deep underground.
Pop received the stores and
took care of them. He handed over
the product of the mine, to be forwarded
to Earth. The rocket went
away again. Come nightfall Pop
lowered the supplies down the long
cable into the Big Crack to the colony
far down inside, and freshened up
the landing field marks with magnesium
marking-powder if a rocket-blast
had blurred them. That was
fundamentally all he had to do. But
without him the mine down in the
Crack would have had to shut
down.
The Crack, of course, was that
gaping rocky fault which stretches
nine hundred miles, jaggedly, over
the side of the Moon that Earth
never sees. There is one stretch where
it is a yawning gulf a full half-mile
wide and unguessably deep. Where
Pop Young's shack stood it was only
a hundred yards, but the colony was
a full mile down, in one wall. There
is nothing like it on Earth, of course.
When it was first found, scientists
descended into it to examine the exposed
rock-strata and learn the history
of the Moon before its craters
were made. But they found more
than history. They found the reason
for the colony and the rocket landing
field and the shack.
The reason for Pop was something
else.
The shack stood a hundred feet
from the Big Crack's edge. It looked
like a dust-heap thirty feet high, and
it was. The outside was surface
moondust, piled over a tiny dome to
be insulation against the cold of
night and shadow and the furnace
heat of day. Pop lived in it all alone,
and in his spare time he worked
industriously at recovering some
missing portions of his life that Sattell
had managed to take away from
him.
He thought often of Sattell, down
in the colony underground. There
were galleries and tunnels and living-quarters
down there. There were
air-tight bulkheads for safety, and a
hydroponic garden to keep the air
fresh, and all sorts of things to make
life possible for men under if not
on the Moon.
But it wasn't fun, even underground.
In the Moon's slight gravity,
a man is really adjusted to existence
when he has a well-developed case
of agoraphobia. With such an aid, a
man can get into a tiny, coffinlike
cubbyhole, and feel solidity above
and below and around him, and
happily tell himself that it feels delicious.
Sometimes it does.
But Sattell couldn't comfort himself
so easily. He knew about Pop,
up on the surface. He'd shipped out,
whimpering, to the Moon to get far
away from Pop, and Pop was just
about a mile overhead and there was
no way to get around him. It was
difficult to get away from the mine,
anyhow. It doesn't take too long for
the low gravity to tear a man's
nerves to shreds. He has to develop
kinks in his head to survive. And
those kinks—
The first men to leave the colony
had to be knocked cold and shipped
out unconscious. They'd been underground—and
in low gravity—long
enough to be utterly unable to face
the idea of open spaces. Even now
there were some who had to be carried,
but there were some tougher
ones who were able to walk to the
rocketship if Pop put a tarpaulin
over their heads so they didn't have
to see the sky. In any case Pop was
essential, either for carrying or
guidance.
Sattell got the shakes when he
thought of Pop, and Pop rather
probably knew it. Of course, by the
time he took the job tending the
shack, he was pretty certain about
Sattell. The facts spoke for themselves.
Pop had come back to consciousness
in a hospital with a great
wound in his head and no memory
of anything that had happened before
that moment. It was not that his
identity was in question. When he
was stronger, the doctors told him
who he was, and as gently as possible
what had happened to his wife
and children. They'd been murdered
after he was seemingly killed defending
them. But he didn't remember
a thing. Not then. It was
something of a blessing.
But when he was physically recovered
he set about trying to pick
up the threads of the life he could
no longer remember. He met Sattell
quite by accident. Sattell looked familiar.
Pop eagerly tried to ask him
questions. And Sattell turned gray
and frantically denied that he'd ever
seen Pop before.
All of which happened back on
Earth and a long time ago. It seemed
to Pop that the sight of Sattell had
brought back some vague and cloudy
memories. They were not sharp,
though, and he hunted up Sattell
again to find out if he was right.
And Sattell went into panic when
he returned.
Nowadays, by the Big Crack, Pop
wasn't so insistent on seeing Sattell,
but he was deeply concerned with
the recovery of the memories that
Sattell helped bring back. Pop was
a highly conscientious man. He took
good care of his job. There was a
warning-bell in the shack, and when
a rocketship from Lunar City got
above the horizon and could send a
tight beam, the gong clanged loudly,
and Pop got into a vacuum-suit
and went out the air lock. He usually
reached the moondozer about the
time the ship began to brake for
landing, and he watched it come in.
He saw the silver needle in the
sky fighting momentum above a line
of jagged crater-walls. It slowed, and
slowed, and curved down as it drew
nearer. The pilot killed all forward
motion just above the field and came
steadily and smoothly down to land
between the silvery triangles that
marked the landing place.
Instantly the rockets cut off,
drums of fuel and air and food came
out of the cargo-hatch and Pop swept
forward with the dozer. It was a
miniature tractor with a gigantic
scoop in front. He pushed a great
mound of talc-fine dust before him
to cover up the cargo. It was necessary.
With freight costing what it
did, fuel and air and food came
frozen solid, in containers barely
thicker than foil. While they stayed
at space-shadow temperature, the foil
would hold anything. And a cover of
insulating moondust with vacuum
between the grains kept even air
frozen solid, though in sunlight.
At such times Pop hardly thought
of Sattell. He knew he had plenty
of time for that. He'd started to follow
Sattell knowing what had happened
to his wife and children, but
it was hearsay only. He had no memory
of them at all. But Sattell stirred
the lost memories. At first Pop followed
absorbedly from city to city,
to recover the years that had been
wiped out by an axe-blow. He did
recover a good deal. When Sattell
fled to another continent, Pop followed
because he had some distinct
memories of his wife—and the way
he'd felt about her—and some fugitive
mental images of his children.
When Sattell frenziedly tried to deny
knowledge of the murder in Tangier,
Pop had come to remember both his
children and some of the happiness
of his married life.
Even when Sattell—whimpering—signed
up for Lunar City, Pop tracked
him. By that time he was quite
sure that Sattell was the man who'd
killed his family. If so, Sattell had
profited by less than two days' pay
for wiping out everything that Pop
possessed. But Pop wanted it back.
He couldn't prove Sattell's guilt.
There was no evidence. In any case,
he didn't really want Sattell to die.
If he did, there'd be no way to recover
more lost memories.
Sometimes, in the shack on the far
side of the Moon, Pop Young had
odd fancies about Sattell. There was
the mine, for example. In each two
Earth-weeks of working, the mine-colony
nearly filled up a three-gallon
cannister with greasy-seeming white
crystals shaped like two pyramids
base to base. The filled cannister
would weigh a hundred pounds on
Earth. Here it weighed eighteen. But
on Earth its contents would be computed
in carats, and a hundred
pounds was worth millions. Yet here
on the Moon Pop kept a waiting cannister
on a shelf in his tiny dome,
behind the air-apparatus. It rattled
if he shook it, and it was worth no
more than so many pebbles. But
sometimes Pop wondered if Sattell
ever thought of the value of the
mine's production. If he would kill
a woman and two children and think
he'd killed a man for no more than
a hundred dollars, what enormity
would he commit for a three-gallon
quantity of uncut diamonds?
But he did not dwell on such
speculation. The sun rose very, very
slowly in what by convention was
called the east. It took nearly two
hours to urge its disk above the
horizon, and it burned terribly in
emptiness for fourteen times twenty-four
hours before sunset. Then there
was night, and for three hundred
and thirty-six consecutive hours there
were only stars overhead and the
sky was a hole so terrible that a man
who looked up into it—what with
the nagging sensation of one-sixth
gravity—tended to lose all confidence
in the stability of things. Most men
immediately found it hysterically necessary
to seize hold of something
solid to keep from falling upward.
But nothing felt solid. Everything
fell, too. Wherefore most men tended
to scream.
But not Pop. He'd come to the
Moon in the first place because Sattell
was here. Near Sattell, he found
memories of times when he was a
young man with a young wife who
loved him extravagantly. Then pictures
of his children came out of
emptiness and grew sharp and clear.
He found that he loved them very
dearly. And when he was near Sattell
he literally recovered them—in
the sense that he came to know new
things about them and had new
memories of them every day. He
hadn't yet remembered the crime
which lost them to him. Until he
did—and the fact possessed a certain
grisly humor—Pop didn't even hate
Sattell. He simply wanted to be near
him because it enabled him to recover
new and vivid parts of his
youth that had been lost.
Otherwise, he was wholly matter-of-fact—certainly
so for the far side
of the Moon. He was a rather fussy
housekeeper. The shack above the
Big Crack's rim was as tidy as any
lighthouse or fur-trapper's cabin. He
tended his air-apparatus with a fine
precision. It was perfectly simple. In
the shadow of the shack he had an
unfailing source of extreme low
temperature. Air from the shack
flowed into a shadow-chilled pipe.
Moisture condensed out of it here,
and CO
2
froze solidly out of it there,
and on beyond it collected as restless,
transparent liquid air. At the same
time, liquid air from another tank
evaporated to maintain the proper
air pressure in the shack. Every so
often Pop tapped the pipe where the
moisture froze, and lumps of water
ice clattered out to be returned to the
humidifier. Less often he took out the
CO
2
snow, and measured it, and
dumped an equivalent quantity of
pale-blue liquid oxygen into the liquid
air that had been purified by
cold. The oxygen dissolved. Then the
apparatus reversed itself and supplied
fresh air from the now-enriched
fluid, while the depleted other
tank began to fill up with cold-purified
liquid air.
Outside the shack, jagged stony
pinnacles reared in the starlight, and
craters complained of the bombardment
from space that had made them.
But, outside, nothing ever happened.
Inside, it was quite different.
Working on his memories, one
day Pop made a little sketch. It
helped a great deal. He grew deeply
interested. Writing-material was
scarce, but he spent most of the time
between two particular rocket-landings
getting down on paper exactly
how a child had looked while sleeping,
some fifteen years before. He
remembered with astonishment that
the child had really looked exactly
like that! Later he began a sketch of
his partly-remembered wife. In time—he
had plenty—it became a really
truthful likeness.
The sun rose, and baked the
abomination of desolation which was
the moonscape. Pop Young meticulously
touched up the glittering
triangles which were landing guides
for the Lunar City ships. They glittered
from the thinnest conceivable
layer of magnesium marking-powder.
He checked over the moondozer.
He tended the air apparatus. He did
everything that his job and survival
required. Ungrudgingly.
Then he made more sketches. The
images to be drawn came back more
clearly when he thought of Sattell,
so by keeping Sattell in mind he recovered
the memory of a chair that
had been in his forgotten home.
Then he drew his wife sitting in it,
reading. It felt very good to see her
again. And he speculated about
whether Sattell ever thought of millions
of dollars' worth of new-mined
diamonds knocking about unguarded
in the shack, and he suddenly recollected
clearly the way one of his
children had looked while playing
with her doll. He made a quick
sketch to keep from forgetting that.
There was no purpose in the
sketching, save that he'd lost all his
young manhood through a senseless
crime. He wanted his youth back. He
was recovering it bit by bit. The
occupation made it absurdly easy to
live on the surface of the far side of
the Moon, whether anybody else
could do it or not.
Sattell had no such device for adjusting
to the lunar state of things.
Living on the Moon was bad enough
anyhow, then, but living one mile
underground from Pop Young was
much worse. Sattell clearly remembered
the crime Pop Young hadn't
yet recalled. He considered that Pop
had made no overt attempt to revenge
himself because he planned
some retaliation so horrible and lingering
that it was worth waiting for.
He came to hate Pop with an insane
ferocity. And fear. In his mind the
need to escape became an obsession
on top of the other psychotic states
normal to a Moon-colonist.
But he was helpless. He couldn't
leave. There was Pop. He couldn't
kill Pop. He had no chance—and he
was afraid. The one absurd, irrelevant
thing he could do was write
letters back to Earth. He did that.
He wrote with the desperate, impassioned,
frantic blend of persuasion
and information and genius-like invention
of a prisoner in a high-security
prison, trying to induce someone
to help him escape.
He had friends, of a sort, but for
a long time his letters produced
nothing. The Moon swung in vast
circles about the Earth, and the Earth
swung sedately about the Sun. The
other planets danced their saraband.
The rest of humanity went about its
own affairs with fascinated attention.
But then an event occurred which
bore directly upon Pop Young and
Sattell and Pop Young's missing
years.
Somebody back on Earth promoted
a luxury passenger-line of spaceships
to ply between Earth and
Moon. It looked like a perfect set-up.
Three spacecraft capable of the journey
came into being with attendant
reams of publicity. They promised a
thrill and a new distinction for the
rich. Guided tours to Lunar! The
most expensive and most thrilling
trip in history! One hundred thousand
dollars for a twelve-day cruise
through space, with views of the
Moon's far side and trips through
Lunar City and a landing in Aristarchus,
plus sound-tapes of the journey
and fame hitherto reserved for
honest explorers!
It didn't seem to have anything
to do with Pop or with Sattell. But
it did.
There were just two passenger
tours. The first was fully booked.
But the passengers who paid so highly,
expected to be pleasantly thrilled
and shielded from all reasons for
alarm. And they couldn't be. Something
happens when a self-centered
and complacent individual unsuspectingly
looks out of a spaceship
port and sees the cosmos unshielded
by mists or clouds or other aids to
blindness against reality. It is shattering.
A millionaire cut his throat when
he saw Earth dwindled to a mere
blue-green ball in vastness. He could
not endure his own smallness in the
face of immensity. Not one passenger
disembarked even for Lunar
City. Most of them cowered in their
chairs, hiding their eyes. They were
the simple cases of hysteria. But the
richest girl on Earth, who'd had five
husbands and believed that nothing
could move her—she went into
catatonic withdrawal and neither
saw nor heard nor moved. Two other
passengers sobbed in improvised
strait jackets. The first shipload
started home. Fast.
The second luxury liner took off
with only four passengers and turned
back before reaching the Moon.
Space-pilots could take the strain of
space-flight because they had work
to do. Workers for the lunar mines
could make the trip under heavy
sedation. But it was too early in the
development of space-travel for
pleasure-passengers. They weren't
prepared for the more humbling
facts of life.
Pop heard of the quaint commercial
enterprise through the micro-tapes
put off at the shack for the men
down in the mine. Sattell probably
learned of it the same way. Pop didn't
even think of it again. It seemed
to have nothing to do with him. But
Sattell undoubtedly dealt with it
fully in his desperate writings back
to Earth.
Pop matter-of-factly tended the
shack and the landing field and the
stores for the Big Crack mine. Between-times
he made more drawings
in pursuit of his own private objective.
Quite accidentally, he developed
a certain talent professional artists
might have approved. But he was not
trying to communicate, but to discover.
Drawing—especially with his
mind on Sattell—he found fresh incidents
popping up in his recollection.
Times when he was happy. One
day he remembered the puppy his
children had owned and loved. He
drew it painstakingly—and it was
his again. Thereafter he could remember
it any time he chose. He did
actually recover a completely vanished
past.
He envisioned a way to increase
that recovery. But there was a marked
shortage of artists' materials on the
Moon. All freight had to be hauled
from Earth, on a voyage equal to
rather more than a thousand times
around the equator of the Earth.
Artists' supplies were not often included.
Pop didn't even ask.
He began to explore the area outside
the shack for possible material
no one would think of sending from
Earth. He collected stones of various
sorts, but when warmed up in the
shack they were useless. He found
no strictly lunar material which
would serve for modeling or carving
portraits in the ground. He found
minerals which could be pulverized
and used as pigments, but nothing
suitable for this new adventure in
the recovery of lost youth. He even
considered blasting, to aid his search.
He could. Down in the mine, blasting
was done by soaking carbon black—from
CO
2
—in liquid oxygen, and then
firing it with a spark. It exploded
splendidly. And its fumes were
merely more CO
2
which an air-apparatus
handled easily.
He didn't do any blasting. He didn't
find any signs of the sort of
mineral he required. Marble would
have been perfect, but there is no
marble on the Moon. Naturally! Yet
Pop continued to search absorbedly
for material with which to capture
memory. Sattell still seemed necessary,
but—
Early one lunar morning he was
a good two miles from his shack
when he saw rocket-fumes in the
sky. It was most unlikely. He wasn't
looking for anything of the sort, but
out of the corner of his eye he observed
that something moved. Which
was impossible. He turned his head,
and there were rocket-fumes coming
over the horizon, not in the direction
of Lunar City. Which was more
impossible still.
He stared. A tiny silver rocket to
the westward poured out monstrous
masses of vapor. It decelerated swiftly.
It curved downward. The rockets
checked for an instant, and flamed
again more violently, and checked
once more. This was not an expert
approach. It was a faulty one. Curving
surface-ward in a sharply changing
parabola, the pilot over-corrected
and had to wait to gather down-speed,
and then over-corrected again.
It was an altogether clumsy landing.
The ship was not even perfectly vertical
when it settled not quite in the
landing-area marked by silvery triangles.
One of its tail-fins crumpled
slightly. It tilted a little when fully
landed.
Then nothing happened.
Pop made his way toward it in
the skittering, skating gait one uses
in one-sixth gravity. When he was
within half a mile, an air-lock door
opened in the ship's side. But nothing
came out of the lock. No space-suited
figure. No cargo came drifting
down with the singular deliberation
of falling objects on the Moon.
It was just barely past lunar sunrise
on the far side of the Moon.
Incredibly long and utterly black
shadows stretched across the plain,
and half the rocketship was dazzling
white and half was blacker than
blackness itself. The sun still hung
low indeed in the black, star-speckled
sky. Pop waded through moondust,
raising a trail of slowly settling
powder. He knew only that the ship
didn't come from Lunar City, but
from Earth. He couldn't imagine
why. He did not even wildly connect
it with what—say—Sattell might
have written with desperate plausibility
about greasy-seeming white
crystals out of the mine, knocking
about Pop Young's shack in cannisters
containing a hundred Earth-pounds
weight of richness.
Pop reached the rocketship. He
approached the big tail-fins. On one
of them there were welded ladder-rungs
going up to the opened air-lock
door.
He climbed.
The air-lock was perfectly normal
when he reached it. There was a
glass port in the inner door, and he
saw eyes looking through it at him.
He pulled the outer door shut and
felt the whining vibration of admitted
air. His vacuum suit went slack
about him. The inner door began to
open, and Pop reached up and gave
his helmet the practiced twisting
jerk which removed it.
Then he blinked. There was a red-headed
man in the opened door. He
grinned savagely at Pop. He held a
very nasty hand-weapon trained on
Pop's middle.
"Don't come in!" he said mockingly.
"And I don't give a damn
about how you are. This isn't social.
It's business!"
Pop simply gaped. He couldn't
quite take it in.
"This," snapped the red-headed
man abruptly, "is a stickup!"
Pop's eyes went through the inner
lock-door. He saw that the interior
of the ship was stripped and bare.
But a spiral stairway descended from
some upper compartment. It had a
handrail of pure, transparent, water-clear
plastic. The walls were bare insulation,
but that trace of luxury remained.
Pop gazed at the plastic,
fascinated.
The red-headed man leaned forward,
snarling. He slashed Pop
across the face with the barrel of his
weapon. It drew blood. It was wanton,
savage brutality.
"Pay attention!" snarled the red-headed
man. "A stickup, I said! Get
it? You go get that can of stuff
from the mine! The diamonds!
Bring them here! Understand?"
Pop said numbly: "What the
hell?"
The red-headed man hit him
again. He was nerve-racked, and,
therefore, he wanted to hurt.
"Move!" he rasped. "I want the
diamonds you've got for the ship
from Lunar City! Bring 'em!" Pop
licked blood from his lips and the
man with the weapon raged at him.
"Then phone down to the mine!
Tell Sattell I'm here and he can
come on up! Tell him to bring any
more diamonds they've dug up since
the stuff you've got!"
He leaned forward. His face was
only inches from Pop Young's. It
was seamed and hard-bitten and
nerve-racked. But any man would be
quivering if he wasn't used to space
or the feel of one-sixth gravity on
the Moon. He panted:
"And get it straight! You try
any tricks and we take off! We
swing over your shack! The rocket-blast
smashes it! We burn you
down! Then we swing over the cable
down to the mine and the rocket-flame
melts it! You die and everybody
in the mine besides! No tricks!
We didn't come here for nothing!"
He twitched all over. Then he
struck cruelly again at Pop Young's
face. He seemed filled with fury, at
least partly hysterical. It was the tension
that space-travel—then, at its
beginning—produced. It was meaningless
savagery due to terror. But,
of course, Pop was helpless to resent
it. There were no weapons on the
Moon and the mention of Sattell's
name showed the uselessness of bluff.
He'd pictured the complete set-up
by the edge of the Big Crack. Pop
could do nothing.
The red-headed man checked
himself, panting. He drew back and
slammed the inner lock-door. There
was the sound of pumping.
Pop put his helmet back on and
sealed it. The outer door opened.
Outrushing air tugged at Pop. After
a second or two he went out and
climbed down the welded-on ladder-bars
to the ground.
He headed back toward his shack.
Somehow, the mention of Sattell had
made his mind work better. It always
did. He began painstakingly to
put things together. The red-headed
man knew the routine here in every
detail. He knew Sattell. That part
was simple. Sattell had planned this
multi-million-dollar coup, as a man
in prison might plan his break. The
stripped interior of the ship identified
it.
It was one of the unsuccessful
luxury-liners sold for scrap. Or perhaps
it was stolen for the journey
here. Sattell's associates had had to
steal or somehow get the fuel, and
somehow find a pilot. But there were
diamonds worth at least five million
dollars waiting for them, and the
whole job might not have called for
more than two men—with Sattell as
a third. According to the economics
of crime, it was feasible. Anyhow it
was being done.
Pop reached the dust-heap which
was his shack and went in the air
lock. Inside, he went to the vision-phone
and called the mine-colony
down in the Crack. He gave the
message he'd been told to pass on.
Sattell to come up, with what diamonds
had been dug since the
regular cannister was sent up for the
Lunar City ship that would be due
presently. Otherwise the ship on the
landing strip would destroy shack
and Pop and the colony together.
"I'd guess," said Pop painstakingly,
"that Sattell figured it out. He's
probably got some sort of gun to
keep you from holding him down
there. But he won't know his friends
are here—not right this minute he
won't."
A shaking voice asked questions
from the vision-phone.
"No," said Pop, "they'll do it anyhow.
If we were able to tell about
'em, they'd be chased. But if I'm
dead and the shacks smashed and
the cable burnt through, they'll be
back on Earth long before a new
cable's been got and let down to you.
So they'll do all they can no matter
what I do." He added, "I wouldn't
tell Sattell a thing about it, if I were
you. It'll save trouble. Just let him
keep on waiting for this to happen.
It'll save you trouble."
Another shaky question.
"Me?" asked Pop. "Oh, I'm going
to raise what hell I can. There's
some stuff in that ship I want."
He switched off the phone. He
went over to his air apparatus. He
took down the cannister of diamonds
which were worth five millions or
more back on Earth. He found a
bucket. He dumped the diamonds
casually into it. They floated downward
with great deliberation and
surged from side to side like a liquid
when they stopped. One-sixth gravity.
Pop regarded his drawings meditatively.
A sketch of his wife as he
now remembered her. It was very
good to remember. A drawing of his
two children, playing together. He
looked forward to remembering
much more about them. He grinned.
"That stair-rail," he said in deep
satisfaction. "That'll do it!"
He tore bed linen from his bunk
and worked on the emptied cannister.
It was a double container with a
thermware interior lining. Even on
Earth newly-mined diamonds sometimes
fly to pieces from internal
stress. On the Moon, it was not desirable
that diamonds be exposed to
repeated violent changes of temperature.
So a thermware-lined cannister
kept them at mine-temperature once
they were warmed to touchability.
Pop packed the cotton cloth in the
container. He hurried a little, because
the men in the rocket were shaky and
might not practice patience. He took
a small emergency-lamp from his
spare spacesuit. He carefully cracked
its bulb, exposing the filament within.
He put the lamp on top of the
cotton and sprinkled magnesium
marking-powder over everything.
Then he went to the air-apparatus
and took out a flask of the liquid
oxygen used to keep his breathing-air
in balance. He poured the frigid,
pale-blue stuff into the cotton. He
saturated it.
All the inside of the shack was
foggy when he finished. Then he
pushed the cannister-top down. He
breathed a sigh of relief when it was
in place. He'd arranged for it to
break a frozen-brittle switch as it
descended. When it came off, the
switch would light the lamp with its
bare filament. There was powdered
magnesium in contact with it and
liquid oxygen all about.
He went out of the shack by the
air lock. On the way, thinking about
Sattell, he suddenly recovered a completely
new memory. On their first
wedding anniversary, so long ago,
he and his wife had gone out to
dinner to celebrate. He remembered
how she looked: the almost-smug
joy they shared that they would be
together for always, with one complete
year for proof.
Pop reflected hungrily that it was
something else to be made permanent
and inspected from time to time.
But he wanted more than a drawing
of this! He wanted to make the memory
permanent and to extend it—
If it had not been for his vacuum
suit and the cannister he carried, Pop
would have rubbed his hands.
Tall, jagged crater-walls rose
from the lunar plain. Monstrous, extended
inky shadows stretched
enormous distances, utterly black.
The sun, like a glowing octopod,
floated low at the edge of things and
seemed to hate all creation.
Pop reached the rocket. He
climbed the welded ladder-rungs to
the air lock. He closed the door. Air
whined. His suit sagged against his
body. He took off his helmet.
When the red-headed man opened
the inner door, the hand-weapon
shook and trembled. Pop said
calmly:
"Now I've got to go handle the
hoist, if Sattell's coming up from
the mine. If I don't do it, he don't
come up."
The red-headed man snarled. But
his eyes were on the cannister whose
contents should weigh a hundred
pounds on Earth.
"Any tricks," he rasped, "and you
know what happens!"
"Yeah," said Pop.
He stolidly put his helmet back
on. But his eyes went past the red-headed
man to the stair that wound
down, inside the ship, from some
compartment above. The stair-rail was
pure, clear, water-white plastic, not
less than three inches thick. There
was a lot of it!
The inner door closed. Pop opened
the outer. Air rushed out. He
climbed painstakingly down to the
ground. He started back toward the
shack.
There was the most luridly bright
of all possible flashes. There was no
sound, of course. But something
flamed very brightly, and the ground
thumped under Pop Young's vacuum
boots. He turned.
The rocketship was still in the act
of flying apart. It had been a splendid
explosion. Of course cotton sheeting
in liquid oxygen is not quite as
good an explosive as carbon-black,
which they used down in the mine.
Even with magnesium powder to
start the flame when a bare light-filament
ignited it, the cannister-bomb
hadn't equaled—say—T.N.T.
But the ship had fuel on board for
the trip back to Earth. And it blew,
too. It would be minutes before all
the fragments of the ship returned
to the Moon's surface. On the Moon,
things fall slowly.
Pop didn't wait. He searched
hopefully. Once a mass of steel plating
fell only yards from him, but it
did not interrupt his search.
When he went into the shack, he
grinned to himself. The call-light of
the vision-phone flickered wildly.
When he took off his helmet the bell
clanged incessantly. He answered. A
shaking voice from the mining-colony
panted:
"We felt a shock! What happened?
What do we do?"
"Don't do a thing," advised Pop.
"It's all right. I blew up the ship and
everything's all right. I wouldn't
even mention it to Sattell if I were
you."
He grinned happily down at a section
of plastic stair-rail he'd found
not too far from where the ship exploded.
When the man down in the
mine cut off, Pop got out of his
vacuum suit in a hurry. He placed
the plastic zestfully on the table
where he'd been restricted to drawing
pictures of his wife and children
in order to recover memories of
them.
He began to plan, gloatingly, the
thing he would carve out of a four-inch
section of the plastic. When it
was carved, he'd paint it. While he
worked, he'd think of Sattell, because
that was the way to get back the
missing portions of his life—the
parts Sattell had managed to get
away from him. He'd get back more
than ever, now!
He didn't wonder what he'd do
if he ever remembered the crime
Sattell had committed. He felt, somehow,
that he wouldn't get that back
until he'd recovered all the rest.
Gloating, it was amusing to remember
what people used to call
such art-works as he planned, when
carved by other lonely men in other
faraway places. They called those
sculptures scrimshaw.
But they were a lot more than
that!
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Astounding Science Fiction
September
1955. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/3/7/9/23791//23791-h//23791-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why don't tourists go to Lunar City? | 23791_2QXPACKC_3 | [
"Lunar City is on the far side of the moon. It's far too cold for tourism.",
"Tourists went insane when faced with the vastness of space.",
"Lunar City is not a resort, it's a mining town.",
"It's too expensive, $100,000 for a 12-day cruise."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
23,791 | 23791_2QXPACKC | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Scrimshaw | 1950.0 | Leinster, Murray | Science fiction; PS; Short stories; Moon -- Fiction | SCRIMSHAW
The old man
just wanted to get back his
memory—and the methods he used were
gently hellish, from the viewpoint of the
others....
BY MURRAY LEINSTER
Illustrated by Freas
Pop Young was the one known
man who could stand life on the
surface of the Moon's far side, and,
therefore, he occupied the shack on
the Big Crack's edge, above the
mining colony there. Some people
said that no normal man could do
it, and mentioned the scar of a
ghastly head-wound to explain his
ability. One man partly guessed the
secret, but only partly. His name was
Sattell and he had reason not to
talk. Pop Young alone knew the
whole truth, and he kept his mouth
shut, too. It wasn't anybody else's
business.
The shack and the job he filled
were located in the medieval notion
of the physical appearance of hell.
By day the environment was heat and
torment. By night—lunar night, of
course, and lunar day—it was frigidity
and horror. Once in two weeks
Earth-time a rocketship came around
the horizon from Lunar City with
stores for the colony deep underground.
Pop received the stores and
took care of them. He handed over
the product of the mine, to be forwarded
to Earth. The rocket went
away again. Come nightfall Pop
lowered the supplies down the long
cable into the Big Crack to the colony
far down inside, and freshened up
the landing field marks with magnesium
marking-powder if a rocket-blast
had blurred them. That was
fundamentally all he had to do. But
without him the mine down in the
Crack would have had to shut
down.
The Crack, of course, was that
gaping rocky fault which stretches
nine hundred miles, jaggedly, over
the side of the Moon that Earth
never sees. There is one stretch where
it is a yawning gulf a full half-mile
wide and unguessably deep. Where
Pop Young's shack stood it was only
a hundred yards, but the colony was
a full mile down, in one wall. There
is nothing like it on Earth, of course.
When it was first found, scientists
descended into it to examine the exposed
rock-strata and learn the history
of the Moon before its craters
were made. But they found more
than history. They found the reason
for the colony and the rocket landing
field and the shack.
The reason for Pop was something
else.
The shack stood a hundred feet
from the Big Crack's edge. It looked
like a dust-heap thirty feet high, and
it was. The outside was surface
moondust, piled over a tiny dome to
be insulation against the cold of
night and shadow and the furnace
heat of day. Pop lived in it all alone,
and in his spare time he worked
industriously at recovering some
missing portions of his life that Sattell
had managed to take away from
him.
He thought often of Sattell, down
in the colony underground. There
were galleries and tunnels and living-quarters
down there. There were
air-tight bulkheads for safety, and a
hydroponic garden to keep the air
fresh, and all sorts of things to make
life possible for men under if not
on the Moon.
But it wasn't fun, even underground.
In the Moon's slight gravity,
a man is really adjusted to existence
when he has a well-developed case
of agoraphobia. With such an aid, a
man can get into a tiny, coffinlike
cubbyhole, and feel solidity above
and below and around him, and
happily tell himself that it feels delicious.
Sometimes it does.
But Sattell couldn't comfort himself
so easily. He knew about Pop,
up on the surface. He'd shipped out,
whimpering, to the Moon to get far
away from Pop, and Pop was just
about a mile overhead and there was
no way to get around him. It was
difficult to get away from the mine,
anyhow. It doesn't take too long for
the low gravity to tear a man's
nerves to shreds. He has to develop
kinks in his head to survive. And
those kinks—
The first men to leave the colony
had to be knocked cold and shipped
out unconscious. They'd been underground—and
in low gravity—long
enough to be utterly unable to face
the idea of open spaces. Even now
there were some who had to be carried,
but there were some tougher
ones who were able to walk to the
rocketship if Pop put a tarpaulin
over their heads so they didn't have
to see the sky. In any case Pop was
essential, either for carrying or
guidance.
Sattell got the shakes when he
thought of Pop, and Pop rather
probably knew it. Of course, by the
time he took the job tending the
shack, he was pretty certain about
Sattell. The facts spoke for themselves.
Pop had come back to consciousness
in a hospital with a great
wound in his head and no memory
of anything that had happened before
that moment. It was not that his
identity was in question. When he
was stronger, the doctors told him
who he was, and as gently as possible
what had happened to his wife
and children. They'd been murdered
after he was seemingly killed defending
them. But he didn't remember
a thing. Not then. It was
something of a blessing.
But when he was physically recovered
he set about trying to pick
up the threads of the life he could
no longer remember. He met Sattell
quite by accident. Sattell looked familiar.
Pop eagerly tried to ask him
questions. And Sattell turned gray
and frantically denied that he'd ever
seen Pop before.
All of which happened back on
Earth and a long time ago. It seemed
to Pop that the sight of Sattell had
brought back some vague and cloudy
memories. They were not sharp,
though, and he hunted up Sattell
again to find out if he was right.
And Sattell went into panic when
he returned.
Nowadays, by the Big Crack, Pop
wasn't so insistent on seeing Sattell,
but he was deeply concerned with
the recovery of the memories that
Sattell helped bring back. Pop was
a highly conscientious man. He took
good care of his job. There was a
warning-bell in the shack, and when
a rocketship from Lunar City got
above the horizon and could send a
tight beam, the gong clanged loudly,
and Pop got into a vacuum-suit
and went out the air lock. He usually
reached the moondozer about the
time the ship began to brake for
landing, and he watched it come in.
He saw the silver needle in the
sky fighting momentum above a line
of jagged crater-walls. It slowed, and
slowed, and curved down as it drew
nearer. The pilot killed all forward
motion just above the field and came
steadily and smoothly down to land
between the silvery triangles that
marked the landing place.
Instantly the rockets cut off,
drums of fuel and air and food came
out of the cargo-hatch and Pop swept
forward with the dozer. It was a
miniature tractor with a gigantic
scoop in front. He pushed a great
mound of talc-fine dust before him
to cover up the cargo. It was necessary.
With freight costing what it
did, fuel and air and food came
frozen solid, in containers barely
thicker than foil. While they stayed
at space-shadow temperature, the foil
would hold anything. And a cover of
insulating moondust with vacuum
between the grains kept even air
frozen solid, though in sunlight.
At such times Pop hardly thought
of Sattell. He knew he had plenty
of time for that. He'd started to follow
Sattell knowing what had happened
to his wife and children, but
it was hearsay only. He had no memory
of them at all. But Sattell stirred
the lost memories. At first Pop followed
absorbedly from city to city,
to recover the years that had been
wiped out by an axe-blow. He did
recover a good deal. When Sattell
fled to another continent, Pop followed
because he had some distinct
memories of his wife—and the way
he'd felt about her—and some fugitive
mental images of his children.
When Sattell frenziedly tried to deny
knowledge of the murder in Tangier,
Pop had come to remember both his
children and some of the happiness
of his married life.
Even when Sattell—whimpering—signed
up for Lunar City, Pop tracked
him. By that time he was quite
sure that Sattell was the man who'd
killed his family. If so, Sattell had
profited by less than two days' pay
for wiping out everything that Pop
possessed. But Pop wanted it back.
He couldn't prove Sattell's guilt.
There was no evidence. In any case,
he didn't really want Sattell to die.
If he did, there'd be no way to recover
more lost memories.
Sometimes, in the shack on the far
side of the Moon, Pop Young had
odd fancies about Sattell. There was
the mine, for example. In each two
Earth-weeks of working, the mine-colony
nearly filled up a three-gallon
cannister with greasy-seeming white
crystals shaped like two pyramids
base to base. The filled cannister
would weigh a hundred pounds on
Earth. Here it weighed eighteen. But
on Earth its contents would be computed
in carats, and a hundred
pounds was worth millions. Yet here
on the Moon Pop kept a waiting cannister
on a shelf in his tiny dome,
behind the air-apparatus. It rattled
if he shook it, and it was worth no
more than so many pebbles. But
sometimes Pop wondered if Sattell
ever thought of the value of the
mine's production. If he would kill
a woman and two children and think
he'd killed a man for no more than
a hundred dollars, what enormity
would he commit for a three-gallon
quantity of uncut diamonds?
But he did not dwell on such
speculation. The sun rose very, very
slowly in what by convention was
called the east. It took nearly two
hours to urge its disk above the
horizon, and it burned terribly in
emptiness for fourteen times twenty-four
hours before sunset. Then there
was night, and for three hundred
and thirty-six consecutive hours there
were only stars overhead and the
sky was a hole so terrible that a man
who looked up into it—what with
the nagging sensation of one-sixth
gravity—tended to lose all confidence
in the stability of things. Most men
immediately found it hysterically necessary
to seize hold of something
solid to keep from falling upward.
But nothing felt solid. Everything
fell, too. Wherefore most men tended
to scream.
But not Pop. He'd come to the
Moon in the first place because Sattell
was here. Near Sattell, he found
memories of times when he was a
young man with a young wife who
loved him extravagantly. Then pictures
of his children came out of
emptiness and grew sharp and clear.
He found that he loved them very
dearly. And when he was near Sattell
he literally recovered them—in
the sense that he came to know new
things about them and had new
memories of them every day. He
hadn't yet remembered the crime
which lost them to him. Until he
did—and the fact possessed a certain
grisly humor—Pop didn't even hate
Sattell. He simply wanted to be near
him because it enabled him to recover
new and vivid parts of his
youth that had been lost.
Otherwise, he was wholly matter-of-fact—certainly
so for the far side
of the Moon. He was a rather fussy
housekeeper. The shack above the
Big Crack's rim was as tidy as any
lighthouse or fur-trapper's cabin. He
tended his air-apparatus with a fine
precision. It was perfectly simple. In
the shadow of the shack he had an
unfailing source of extreme low
temperature. Air from the shack
flowed into a shadow-chilled pipe.
Moisture condensed out of it here,
and CO
2
froze solidly out of it there,
and on beyond it collected as restless,
transparent liquid air. At the same
time, liquid air from another tank
evaporated to maintain the proper
air pressure in the shack. Every so
often Pop tapped the pipe where the
moisture froze, and lumps of water
ice clattered out to be returned to the
humidifier. Less often he took out the
CO
2
snow, and measured it, and
dumped an equivalent quantity of
pale-blue liquid oxygen into the liquid
air that had been purified by
cold. The oxygen dissolved. Then the
apparatus reversed itself and supplied
fresh air from the now-enriched
fluid, while the depleted other
tank began to fill up with cold-purified
liquid air.
Outside the shack, jagged stony
pinnacles reared in the starlight, and
craters complained of the bombardment
from space that had made them.
But, outside, nothing ever happened.
Inside, it was quite different.
Working on his memories, one
day Pop made a little sketch. It
helped a great deal. He grew deeply
interested. Writing-material was
scarce, but he spent most of the time
between two particular rocket-landings
getting down on paper exactly
how a child had looked while sleeping,
some fifteen years before. He
remembered with astonishment that
the child had really looked exactly
like that! Later he began a sketch of
his partly-remembered wife. In time—he
had plenty—it became a really
truthful likeness.
The sun rose, and baked the
abomination of desolation which was
the moonscape. Pop Young meticulously
touched up the glittering
triangles which were landing guides
for the Lunar City ships. They glittered
from the thinnest conceivable
layer of magnesium marking-powder.
He checked over the moondozer.
He tended the air apparatus. He did
everything that his job and survival
required. Ungrudgingly.
Then he made more sketches. The
images to be drawn came back more
clearly when he thought of Sattell,
so by keeping Sattell in mind he recovered
the memory of a chair that
had been in his forgotten home.
Then he drew his wife sitting in it,
reading. It felt very good to see her
again. And he speculated about
whether Sattell ever thought of millions
of dollars' worth of new-mined
diamonds knocking about unguarded
in the shack, and he suddenly recollected
clearly the way one of his
children had looked while playing
with her doll. He made a quick
sketch to keep from forgetting that.
There was no purpose in the
sketching, save that he'd lost all his
young manhood through a senseless
crime. He wanted his youth back. He
was recovering it bit by bit. The
occupation made it absurdly easy to
live on the surface of the far side of
the Moon, whether anybody else
could do it or not.
Sattell had no such device for adjusting
to the lunar state of things.
Living on the Moon was bad enough
anyhow, then, but living one mile
underground from Pop Young was
much worse. Sattell clearly remembered
the crime Pop Young hadn't
yet recalled. He considered that Pop
had made no overt attempt to revenge
himself because he planned
some retaliation so horrible and lingering
that it was worth waiting for.
He came to hate Pop with an insane
ferocity. And fear. In his mind the
need to escape became an obsession
on top of the other psychotic states
normal to a Moon-colonist.
But he was helpless. He couldn't
leave. There was Pop. He couldn't
kill Pop. He had no chance—and he
was afraid. The one absurd, irrelevant
thing he could do was write
letters back to Earth. He did that.
He wrote with the desperate, impassioned,
frantic blend of persuasion
and information and genius-like invention
of a prisoner in a high-security
prison, trying to induce someone
to help him escape.
He had friends, of a sort, but for
a long time his letters produced
nothing. The Moon swung in vast
circles about the Earth, and the Earth
swung sedately about the Sun. The
other planets danced their saraband.
The rest of humanity went about its
own affairs with fascinated attention.
But then an event occurred which
bore directly upon Pop Young and
Sattell and Pop Young's missing
years.
Somebody back on Earth promoted
a luxury passenger-line of spaceships
to ply between Earth and
Moon. It looked like a perfect set-up.
Three spacecraft capable of the journey
came into being with attendant
reams of publicity. They promised a
thrill and a new distinction for the
rich. Guided tours to Lunar! The
most expensive and most thrilling
trip in history! One hundred thousand
dollars for a twelve-day cruise
through space, with views of the
Moon's far side and trips through
Lunar City and a landing in Aristarchus,
plus sound-tapes of the journey
and fame hitherto reserved for
honest explorers!
It didn't seem to have anything
to do with Pop or with Sattell. But
it did.
There were just two passenger
tours. The first was fully booked.
But the passengers who paid so highly,
expected to be pleasantly thrilled
and shielded from all reasons for
alarm. And they couldn't be. Something
happens when a self-centered
and complacent individual unsuspectingly
looks out of a spaceship
port and sees the cosmos unshielded
by mists or clouds or other aids to
blindness against reality. It is shattering.
A millionaire cut his throat when
he saw Earth dwindled to a mere
blue-green ball in vastness. He could
not endure his own smallness in the
face of immensity. Not one passenger
disembarked even for Lunar
City. Most of them cowered in their
chairs, hiding their eyes. They were
the simple cases of hysteria. But the
richest girl on Earth, who'd had five
husbands and believed that nothing
could move her—she went into
catatonic withdrawal and neither
saw nor heard nor moved. Two other
passengers sobbed in improvised
strait jackets. The first shipload
started home. Fast.
The second luxury liner took off
with only four passengers and turned
back before reaching the Moon.
Space-pilots could take the strain of
space-flight because they had work
to do. Workers for the lunar mines
could make the trip under heavy
sedation. But it was too early in the
development of space-travel for
pleasure-passengers. They weren't
prepared for the more humbling
facts of life.
Pop heard of the quaint commercial
enterprise through the micro-tapes
put off at the shack for the men
down in the mine. Sattell probably
learned of it the same way. Pop didn't
even think of it again. It seemed
to have nothing to do with him. But
Sattell undoubtedly dealt with it
fully in his desperate writings back
to Earth.
Pop matter-of-factly tended the
shack and the landing field and the
stores for the Big Crack mine. Between-times
he made more drawings
in pursuit of his own private objective.
Quite accidentally, he developed
a certain talent professional artists
might have approved. But he was not
trying to communicate, but to discover.
Drawing—especially with his
mind on Sattell—he found fresh incidents
popping up in his recollection.
Times when he was happy. One
day he remembered the puppy his
children had owned and loved. He
drew it painstakingly—and it was
his again. Thereafter he could remember
it any time he chose. He did
actually recover a completely vanished
past.
He envisioned a way to increase
that recovery. But there was a marked
shortage of artists' materials on the
Moon. All freight had to be hauled
from Earth, on a voyage equal to
rather more than a thousand times
around the equator of the Earth.
Artists' supplies were not often included.
Pop didn't even ask.
He began to explore the area outside
the shack for possible material
no one would think of sending from
Earth. He collected stones of various
sorts, but when warmed up in the
shack they were useless. He found
no strictly lunar material which
would serve for modeling or carving
portraits in the ground. He found
minerals which could be pulverized
and used as pigments, but nothing
suitable for this new adventure in
the recovery of lost youth. He even
considered blasting, to aid his search.
He could. Down in the mine, blasting
was done by soaking carbon black—from
CO
2
—in liquid oxygen, and then
firing it with a spark. It exploded
splendidly. And its fumes were
merely more CO
2
which an air-apparatus
handled easily.
He didn't do any blasting. He didn't
find any signs of the sort of
mineral he required. Marble would
have been perfect, but there is no
marble on the Moon. Naturally! Yet
Pop continued to search absorbedly
for material with which to capture
memory. Sattell still seemed necessary,
but—
Early one lunar morning he was
a good two miles from his shack
when he saw rocket-fumes in the
sky. It was most unlikely. He wasn't
looking for anything of the sort, but
out of the corner of his eye he observed
that something moved. Which
was impossible. He turned his head,
and there were rocket-fumes coming
over the horizon, not in the direction
of Lunar City. Which was more
impossible still.
He stared. A tiny silver rocket to
the westward poured out monstrous
masses of vapor. It decelerated swiftly.
It curved downward. The rockets
checked for an instant, and flamed
again more violently, and checked
once more. This was not an expert
approach. It was a faulty one. Curving
surface-ward in a sharply changing
parabola, the pilot over-corrected
and had to wait to gather down-speed,
and then over-corrected again.
It was an altogether clumsy landing.
The ship was not even perfectly vertical
when it settled not quite in the
landing-area marked by silvery triangles.
One of its tail-fins crumpled
slightly. It tilted a little when fully
landed.
Then nothing happened.
Pop made his way toward it in
the skittering, skating gait one uses
in one-sixth gravity. When he was
within half a mile, an air-lock door
opened in the ship's side. But nothing
came out of the lock. No space-suited
figure. No cargo came drifting
down with the singular deliberation
of falling objects on the Moon.
It was just barely past lunar sunrise
on the far side of the Moon.
Incredibly long and utterly black
shadows stretched across the plain,
and half the rocketship was dazzling
white and half was blacker than
blackness itself. The sun still hung
low indeed in the black, star-speckled
sky. Pop waded through moondust,
raising a trail of slowly settling
powder. He knew only that the ship
didn't come from Lunar City, but
from Earth. He couldn't imagine
why. He did not even wildly connect
it with what—say—Sattell might
have written with desperate plausibility
about greasy-seeming white
crystals out of the mine, knocking
about Pop Young's shack in cannisters
containing a hundred Earth-pounds
weight of richness.
Pop reached the rocketship. He
approached the big tail-fins. On one
of them there were welded ladder-rungs
going up to the opened air-lock
door.
He climbed.
The air-lock was perfectly normal
when he reached it. There was a
glass port in the inner door, and he
saw eyes looking through it at him.
He pulled the outer door shut and
felt the whining vibration of admitted
air. His vacuum suit went slack
about him. The inner door began to
open, and Pop reached up and gave
his helmet the practiced twisting
jerk which removed it.
Then he blinked. There was a red-headed
man in the opened door. He
grinned savagely at Pop. He held a
very nasty hand-weapon trained on
Pop's middle.
"Don't come in!" he said mockingly.
"And I don't give a damn
about how you are. This isn't social.
It's business!"
Pop simply gaped. He couldn't
quite take it in.
"This," snapped the red-headed
man abruptly, "is a stickup!"
Pop's eyes went through the inner
lock-door. He saw that the interior
of the ship was stripped and bare.
But a spiral stairway descended from
some upper compartment. It had a
handrail of pure, transparent, water-clear
plastic. The walls were bare insulation,
but that trace of luxury remained.
Pop gazed at the plastic,
fascinated.
The red-headed man leaned forward,
snarling. He slashed Pop
across the face with the barrel of his
weapon. It drew blood. It was wanton,
savage brutality.
"Pay attention!" snarled the red-headed
man. "A stickup, I said! Get
it? You go get that can of stuff
from the mine! The diamonds!
Bring them here! Understand?"
Pop said numbly: "What the
hell?"
The red-headed man hit him
again. He was nerve-racked, and,
therefore, he wanted to hurt.
"Move!" he rasped. "I want the
diamonds you've got for the ship
from Lunar City! Bring 'em!" Pop
licked blood from his lips and the
man with the weapon raged at him.
"Then phone down to the mine!
Tell Sattell I'm here and he can
come on up! Tell him to bring any
more diamonds they've dug up since
the stuff you've got!"
He leaned forward. His face was
only inches from Pop Young's. It
was seamed and hard-bitten and
nerve-racked. But any man would be
quivering if he wasn't used to space
or the feel of one-sixth gravity on
the Moon. He panted:
"And get it straight! You try
any tricks and we take off! We
swing over your shack! The rocket-blast
smashes it! We burn you
down! Then we swing over the cable
down to the mine and the rocket-flame
melts it! You die and everybody
in the mine besides! No tricks!
We didn't come here for nothing!"
He twitched all over. Then he
struck cruelly again at Pop Young's
face. He seemed filled with fury, at
least partly hysterical. It was the tension
that space-travel—then, at its
beginning—produced. It was meaningless
savagery due to terror. But,
of course, Pop was helpless to resent
it. There were no weapons on the
Moon and the mention of Sattell's
name showed the uselessness of bluff.
He'd pictured the complete set-up
by the edge of the Big Crack. Pop
could do nothing.
The red-headed man checked
himself, panting. He drew back and
slammed the inner lock-door. There
was the sound of pumping.
Pop put his helmet back on and
sealed it. The outer door opened.
Outrushing air tugged at Pop. After
a second or two he went out and
climbed down the welded-on ladder-bars
to the ground.
He headed back toward his shack.
Somehow, the mention of Sattell had
made his mind work better. It always
did. He began painstakingly to
put things together. The red-headed
man knew the routine here in every
detail. He knew Sattell. That part
was simple. Sattell had planned this
multi-million-dollar coup, as a man
in prison might plan his break. The
stripped interior of the ship identified
it.
It was one of the unsuccessful
luxury-liners sold for scrap. Or perhaps
it was stolen for the journey
here. Sattell's associates had had to
steal or somehow get the fuel, and
somehow find a pilot. But there were
diamonds worth at least five million
dollars waiting for them, and the
whole job might not have called for
more than two men—with Sattell as
a third. According to the economics
of crime, it was feasible. Anyhow it
was being done.
Pop reached the dust-heap which
was his shack and went in the air
lock. Inside, he went to the vision-phone
and called the mine-colony
down in the Crack. He gave the
message he'd been told to pass on.
Sattell to come up, with what diamonds
had been dug since the
regular cannister was sent up for the
Lunar City ship that would be due
presently. Otherwise the ship on the
landing strip would destroy shack
and Pop and the colony together.
"I'd guess," said Pop painstakingly,
"that Sattell figured it out. He's
probably got some sort of gun to
keep you from holding him down
there. But he won't know his friends
are here—not right this minute he
won't."
A shaking voice asked questions
from the vision-phone.
"No," said Pop, "they'll do it anyhow.
If we were able to tell about
'em, they'd be chased. But if I'm
dead and the shacks smashed and
the cable burnt through, they'll be
back on Earth long before a new
cable's been got and let down to you.
So they'll do all they can no matter
what I do." He added, "I wouldn't
tell Sattell a thing about it, if I were
you. It'll save trouble. Just let him
keep on waiting for this to happen.
It'll save you trouble."
Another shaky question.
"Me?" asked Pop. "Oh, I'm going
to raise what hell I can. There's
some stuff in that ship I want."
He switched off the phone. He
went over to his air apparatus. He
took down the cannister of diamonds
which were worth five millions or
more back on Earth. He found a
bucket. He dumped the diamonds
casually into it. They floated downward
with great deliberation and
surged from side to side like a liquid
when they stopped. One-sixth gravity.
Pop regarded his drawings meditatively.
A sketch of his wife as he
now remembered her. It was very
good to remember. A drawing of his
two children, playing together. He
looked forward to remembering
much more about them. He grinned.
"That stair-rail," he said in deep
satisfaction. "That'll do it!"
He tore bed linen from his bunk
and worked on the emptied cannister.
It was a double container with a
thermware interior lining. Even on
Earth newly-mined diamonds sometimes
fly to pieces from internal
stress. On the Moon, it was not desirable
that diamonds be exposed to
repeated violent changes of temperature.
So a thermware-lined cannister
kept them at mine-temperature once
they were warmed to touchability.
Pop packed the cotton cloth in the
container. He hurried a little, because
the men in the rocket were shaky and
might not practice patience. He took
a small emergency-lamp from his
spare spacesuit. He carefully cracked
its bulb, exposing the filament within.
He put the lamp on top of the
cotton and sprinkled magnesium
marking-powder over everything.
Then he went to the air-apparatus
and took out a flask of the liquid
oxygen used to keep his breathing-air
in balance. He poured the frigid,
pale-blue stuff into the cotton. He
saturated it.
All the inside of the shack was
foggy when he finished. Then he
pushed the cannister-top down. He
breathed a sigh of relief when it was
in place. He'd arranged for it to
break a frozen-brittle switch as it
descended. When it came off, the
switch would light the lamp with its
bare filament. There was powdered
magnesium in contact with it and
liquid oxygen all about.
He went out of the shack by the
air lock. On the way, thinking about
Sattell, he suddenly recovered a completely
new memory. On their first
wedding anniversary, so long ago,
he and his wife had gone out to
dinner to celebrate. He remembered
how she looked: the almost-smug
joy they shared that they would be
together for always, with one complete
year for proof.
Pop reflected hungrily that it was
something else to be made permanent
and inspected from time to time.
But he wanted more than a drawing
of this! He wanted to make the memory
permanent and to extend it—
If it had not been for his vacuum
suit and the cannister he carried, Pop
would have rubbed his hands.
Tall, jagged crater-walls rose
from the lunar plain. Monstrous, extended
inky shadows stretched
enormous distances, utterly black.
The sun, like a glowing octopod,
floated low at the edge of things and
seemed to hate all creation.
Pop reached the rocket. He
climbed the welded ladder-rungs to
the air lock. He closed the door. Air
whined. His suit sagged against his
body. He took off his helmet.
When the red-headed man opened
the inner door, the hand-weapon
shook and trembled. Pop said
calmly:
"Now I've got to go handle the
hoist, if Sattell's coming up from
the mine. If I don't do it, he don't
come up."
The red-headed man snarled. But
his eyes were on the cannister whose
contents should weigh a hundred
pounds on Earth.
"Any tricks," he rasped, "and you
know what happens!"
"Yeah," said Pop.
He stolidly put his helmet back
on. But his eyes went past the red-headed
man to the stair that wound
down, inside the ship, from some
compartment above. The stair-rail was
pure, clear, water-white plastic, not
less than three inches thick. There
was a lot of it!
The inner door closed. Pop opened
the outer. Air rushed out. He
climbed painstakingly down to the
ground. He started back toward the
shack.
There was the most luridly bright
of all possible flashes. There was no
sound, of course. But something
flamed very brightly, and the ground
thumped under Pop Young's vacuum
boots. He turned.
The rocketship was still in the act
of flying apart. It had been a splendid
explosion. Of course cotton sheeting
in liquid oxygen is not quite as
good an explosive as carbon-black,
which they used down in the mine.
Even with magnesium powder to
start the flame when a bare light-filament
ignited it, the cannister-bomb
hadn't equaled—say—T.N.T.
But the ship had fuel on board for
the trip back to Earth. And it blew,
too. It would be minutes before all
the fragments of the ship returned
to the Moon's surface. On the Moon,
things fall slowly.
Pop didn't wait. He searched
hopefully. Once a mass of steel plating
fell only yards from him, but it
did not interrupt his search.
When he went into the shack, he
grinned to himself. The call-light of
the vision-phone flickered wildly.
When he took off his helmet the bell
clanged incessantly. He answered. A
shaking voice from the mining-colony
panted:
"We felt a shock! What happened?
What do we do?"
"Don't do a thing," advised Pop.
"It's all right. I blew up the ship and
everything's all right. I wouldn't
even mention it to Sattell if I were
you."
He grinned happily down at a section
of plastic stair-rail he'd found
not too far from where the ship exploded.
When the man down in the
mine cut off, Pop got out of his
vacuum suit in a hurry. He placed
the plastic zestfully on the table
where he'd been restricted to drawing
pictures of his wife and children
in order to recover memories of
them.
He began to plan, gloatingly, the
thing he would carve out of a four-inch
section of the plastic. When it
was carved, he'd paint it. While he
worked, he'd think of Sattell, because
that was the way to get back the
missing portions of his life—the
parts Sattell had managed to get
away from him. He'd get back more
than ever, now!
He didn't wonder what he'd do
if he ever remembered the crime
Sattell had committed. He felt, somehow,
that he wouldn't get that back
until he'd recovered all the rest.
Gloating, it was amusing to remember
what people used to call
such art-works as he planned, when
carved by other lonely men in other
faraway places. They called those
sculptures scrimshaw.
But they were a lot more than
that!
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Astounding Science Fiction
September
1955. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/3/7/9/23791//23791-h//23791-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does the red-headed man come to the moon? | 23791_2QXPACKC_4 | [
"To kill Pop.",
"To steal the diamonds.",
"To rescue Sattell, the diamonds are his payment.",
"To destroy the lunar colony."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
23,791 | 23791_2QXPACKC | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Scrimshaw | 1950.0 | Leinster, Murray | Science fiction; PS; Short stories; Moon -- Fiction | SCRIMSHAW
The old man
just wanted to get back his
memory—and the methods he used were
gently hellish, from the viewpoint of the
others....
BY MURRAY LEINSTER
Illustrated by Freas
Pop Young was the one known
man who could stand life on the
surface of the Moon's far side, and,
therefore, he occupied the shack on
the Big Crack's edge, above the
mining colony there. Some people
said that no normal man could do
it, and mentioned the scar of a
ghastly head-wound to explain his
ability. One man partly guessed the
secret, but only partly. His name was
Sattell and he had reason not to
talk. Pop Young alone knew the
whole truth, and he kept his mouth
shut, too. It wasn't anybody else's
business.
The shack and the job he filled
were located in the medieval notion
of the physical appearance of hell.
By day the environment was heat and
torment. By night—lunar night, of
course, and lunar day—it was frigidity
and horror. Once in two weeks
Earth-time a rocketship came around
the horizon from Lunar City with
stores for the colony deep underground.
Pop received the stores and
took care of them. He handed over
the product of the mine, to be forwarded
to Earth. The rocket went
away again. Come nightfall Pop
lowered the supplies down the long
cable into the Big Crack to the colony
far down inside, and freshened up
the landing field marks with magnesium
marking-powder if a rocket-blast
had blurred them. That was
fundamentally all he had to do. But
without him the mine down in the
Crack would have had to shut
down.
The Crack, of course, was that
gaping rocky fault which stretches
nine hundred miles, jaggedly, over
the side of the Moon that Earth
never sees. There is one stretch where
it is a yawning gulf a full half-mile
wide and unguessably deep. Where
Pop Young's shack stood it was only
a hundred yards, but the colony was
a full mile down, in one wall. There
is nothing like it on Earth, of course.
When it was first found, scientists
descended into it to examine the exposed
rock-strata and learn the history
of the Moon before its craters
were made. But they found more
than history. They found the reason
for the colony and the rocket landing
field and the shack.
The reason for Pop was something
else.
The shack stood a hundred feet
from the Big Crack's edge. It looked
like a dust-heap thirty feet high, and
it was. The outside was surface
moondust, piled over a tiny dome to
be insulation against the cold of
night and shadow and the furnace
heat of day. Pop lived in it all alone,
and in his spare time he worked
industriously at recovering some
missing portions of his life that Sattell
had managed to take away from
him.
He thought often of Sattell, down
in the colony underground. There
were galleries and tunnels and living-quarters
down there. There were
air-tight bulkheads for safety, and a
hydroponic garden to keep the air
fresh, and all sorts of things to make
life possible for men under if not
on the Moon.
But it wasn't fun, even underground.
In the Moon's slight gravity,
a man is really adjusted to existence
when he has a well-developed case
of agoraphobia. With such an aid, a
man can get into a tiny, coffinlike
cubbyhole, and feel solidity above
and below and around him, and
happily tell himself that it feels delicious.
Sometimes it does.
But Sattell couldn't comfort himself
so easily. He knew about Pop,
up on the surface. He'd shipped out,
whimpering, to the Moon to get far
away from Pop, and Pop was just
about a mile overhead and there was
no way to get around him. It was
difficult to get away from the mine,
anyhow. It doesn't take too long for
the low gravity to tear a man's
nerves to shreds. He has to develop
kinks in his head to survive. And
those kinks—
The first men to leave the colony
had to be knocked cold and shipped
out unconscious. They'd been underground—and
in low gravity—long
enough to be utterly unable to face
the idea of open spaces. Even now
there were some who had to be carried,
but there were some tougher
ones who were able to walk to the
rocketship if Pop put a tarpaulin
over their heads so they didn't have
to see the sky. In any case Pop was
essential, either for carrying or
guidance.
Sattell got the shakes when he
thought of Pop, and Pop rather
probably knew it. Of course, by the
time he took the job tending the
shack, he was pretty certain about
Sattell. The facts spoke for themselves.
Pop had come back to consciousness
in a hospital with a great
wound in his head and no memory
of anything that had happened before
that moment. It was not that his
identity was in question. When he
was stronger, the doctors told him
who he was, and as gently as possible
what had happened to his wife
and children. They'd been murdered
after he was seemingly killed defending
them. But he didn't remember
a thing. Not then. It was
something of a blessing.
But when he was physically recovered
he set about trying to pick
up the threads of the life he could
no longer remember. He met Sattell
quite by accident. Sattell looked familiar.
Pop eagerly tried to ask him
questions. And Sattell turned gray
and frantically denied that he'd ever
seen Pop before.
All of which happened back on
Earth and a long time ago. It seemed
to Pop that the sight of Sattell had
brought back some vague and cloudy
memories. They were not sharp,
though, and he hunted up Sattell
again to find out if he was right.
And Sattell went into panic when
he returned.
Nowadays, by the Big Crack, Pop
wasn't so insistent on seeing Sattell,
but he was deeply concerned with
the recovery of the memories that
Sattell helped bring back. Pop was
a highly conscientious man. He took
good care of his job. There was a
warning-bell in the shack, and when
a rocketship from Lunar City got
above the horizon and could send a
tight beam, the gong clanged loudly,
and Pop got into a vacuum-suit
and went out the air lock. He usually
reached the moondozer about the
time the ship began to brake for
landing, and he watched it come in.
He saw the silver needle in the
sky fighting momentum above a line
of jagged crater-walls. It slowed, and
slowed, and curved down as it drew
nearer. The pilot killed all forward
motion just above the field and came
steadily and smoothly down to land
between the silvery triangles that
marked the landing place.
Instantly the rockets cut off,
drums of fuel and air and food came
out of the cargo-hatch and Pop swept
forward with the dozer. It was a
miniature tractor with a gigantic
scoop in front. He pushed a great
mound of talc-fine dust before him
to cover up the cargo. It was necessary.
With freight costing what it
did, fuel and air and food came
frozen solid, in containers barely
thicker than foil. While they stayed
at space-shadow temperature, the foil
would hold anything. And a cover of
insulating moondust with vacuum
between the grains kept even air
frozen solid, though in sunlight.
At such times Pop hardly thought
of Sattell. He knew he had plenty
of time for that. He'd started to follow
Sattell knowing what had happened
to his wife and children, but
it was hearsay only. He had no memory
of them at all. But Sattell stirred
the lost memories. At first Pop followed
absorbedly from city to city,
to recover the years that had been
wiped out by an axe-blow. He did
recover a good deal. When Sattell
fled to another continent, Pop followed
because he had some distinct
memories of his wife—and the way
he'd felt about her—and some fugitive
mental images of his children.
When Sattell frenziedly tried to deny
knowledge of the murder in Tangier,
Pop had come to remember both his
children and some of the happiness
of his married life.
Even when Sattell—whimpering—signed
up for Lunar City, Pop tracked
him. By that time he was quite
sure that Sattell was the man who'd
killed his family. If so, Sattell had
profited by less than two days' pay
for wiping out everything that Pop
possessed. But Pop wanted it back.
He couldn't prove Sattell's guilt.
There was no evidence. In any case,
he didn't really want Sattell to die.
If he did, there'd be no way to recover
more lost memories.
Sometimes, in the shack on the far
side of the Moon, Pop Young had
odd fancies about Sattell. There was
the mine, for example. In each two
Earth-weeks of working, the mine-colony
nearly filled up a three-gallon
cannister with greasy-seeming white
crystals shaped like two pyramids
base to base. The filled cannister
would weigh a hundred pounds on
Earth. Here it weighed eighteen. But
on Earth its contents would be computed
in carats, and a hundred
pounds was worth millions. Yet here
on the Moon Pop kept a waiting cannister
on a shelf in his tiny dome,
behind the air-apparatus. It rattled
if he shook it, and it was worth no
more than so many pebbles. But
sometimes Pop wondered if Sattell
ever thought of the value of the
mine's production. If he would kill
a woman and two children and think
he'd killed a man for no more than
a hundred dollars, what enormity
would he commit for a three-gallon
quantity of uncut diamonds?
But he did not dwell on such
speculation. The sun rose very, very
slowly in what by convention was
called the east. It took nearly two
hours to urge its disk above the
horizon, and it burned terribly in
emptiness for fourteen times twenty-four
hours before sunset. Then there
was night, and for three hundred
and thirty-six consecutive hours there
were only stars overhead and the
sky was a hole so terrible that a man
who looked up into it—what with
the nagging sensation of one-sixth
gravity—tended to lose all confidence
in the stability of things. Most men
immediately found it hysterically necessary
to seize hold of something
solid to keep from falling upward.
But nothing felt solid. Everything
fell, too. Wherefore most men tended
to scream.
But not Pop. He'd come to the
Moon in the first place because Sattell
was here. Near Sattell, he found
memories of times when he was a
young man with a young wife who
loved him extravagantly. Then pictures
of his children came out of
emptiness and grew sharp and clear.
He found that he loved them very
dearly. And when he was near Sattell
he literally recovered them—in
the sense that he came to know new
things about them and had new
memories of them every day. He
hadn't yet remembered the crime
which lost them to him. Until he
did—and the fact possessed a certain
grisly humor—Pop didn't even hate
Sattell. He simply wanted to be near
him because it enabled him to recover
new and vivid parts of his
youth that had been lost.
Otherwise, he was wholly matter-of-fact—certainly
so for the far side
of the Moon. He was a rather fussy
housekeeper. The shack above the
Big Crack's rim was as tidy as any
lighthouse or fur-trapper's cabin. He
tended his air-apparatus with a fine
precision. It was perfectly simple. In
the shadow of the shack he had an
unfailing source of extreme low
temperature. Air from the shack
flowed into a shadow-chilled pipe.
Moisture condensed out of it here,
and CO
2
froze solidly out of it there,
and on beyond it collected as restless,
transparent liquid air. At the same
time, liquid air from another tank
evaporated to maintain the proper
air pressure in the shack. Every so
often Pop tapped the pipe where the
moisture froze, and lumps of water
ice clattered out to be returned to the
humidifier. Less often he took out the
CO
2
snow, and measured it, and
dumped an equivalent quantity of
pale-blue liquid oxygen into the liquid
air that had been purified by
cold. The oxygen dissolved. Then the
apparatus reversed itself and supplied
fresh air from the now-enriched
fluid, while the depleted other
tank began to fill up with cold-purified
liquid air.
Outside the shack, jagged stony
pinnacles reared in the starlight, and
craters complained of the bombardment
from space that had made them.
But, outside, nothing ever happened.
Inside, it was quite different.
Working on his memories, one
day Pop made a little sketch. It
helped a great deal. He grew deeply
interested. Writing-material was
scarce, but he spent most of the time
between two particular rocket-landings
getting down on paper exactly
how a child had looked while sleeping,
some fifteen years before. He
remembered with astonishment that
the child had really looked exactly
like that! Later he began a sketch of
his partly-remembered wife. In time—he
had plenty—it became a really
truthful likeness.
The sun rose, and baked the
abomination of desolation which was
the moonscape. Pop Young meticulously
touched up the glittering
triangles which were landing guides
for the Lunar City ships. They glittered
from the thinnest conceivable
layer of magnesium marking-powder.
He checked over the moondozer.
He tended the air apparatus. He did
everything that his job and survival
required. Ungrudgingly.
Then he made more sketches. The
images to be drawn came back more
clearly when he thought of Sattell,
so by keeping Sattell in mind he recovered
the memory of a chair that
had been in his forgotten home.
Then he drew his wife sitting in it,
reading. It felt very good to see her
again. And he speculated about
whether Sattell ever thought of millions
of dollars' worth of new-mined
diamonds knocking about unguarded
in the shack, and he suddenly recollected
clearly the way one of his
children had looked while playing
with her doll. He made a quick
sketch to keep from forgetting that.
There was no purpose in the
sketching, save that he'd lost all his
young manhood through a senseless
crime. He wanted his youth back. He
was recovering it bit by bit. The
occupation made it absurdly easy to
live on the surface of the far side of
the Moon, whether anybody else
could do it or not.
Sattell had no such device for adjusting
to the lunar state of things.
Living on the Moon was bad enough
anyhow, then, but living one mile
underground from Pop Young was
much worse. Sattell clearly remembered
the crime Pop Young hadn't
yet recalled. He considered that Pop
had made no overt attempt to revenge
himself because he planned
some retaliation so horrible and lingering
that it was worth waiting for.
He came to hate Pop with an insane
ferocity. And fear. In his mind the
need to escape became an obsession
on top of the other psychotic states
normal to a Moon-colonist.
But he was helpless. He couldn't
leave. There was Pop. He couldn't
kill Pop. He had no chance—and he
was afraid. The one absurd, irrelevant
thing he could do was write
letters back to Earth. He did that.
He wrote with the desperate, impassioned,
frantic blend of persuasion
and information and genius-like invention
of a prisoner in a high-security
prison, trying to induce someone
to help him escape.
He had friends, of a sort, but for
a long time his letters produced
nothing. The Moon swung in vast
circles about the Earth, and the Earth
swung sedately about the Sun. The
other planets danced their saraband.
The rest of humanity went about its
own affairs with fascinated attention.
But then an event occurred which
bore directly upon Pop Young and
Sattell and Pop Young's missing
years.
Somebody back on Earth promoted
a luxury passenger-line of spaceships
to ply between Earth and
Moon. It looked like a perfect set-up.
Three spacecraft capable of the journey
came into being with attendant
reams of publicity. They promised a
thrill and a new distinction for the
rich. Guided tours to Lunar! The
most expensive and most thrilling
trip in history! One hundred thousand
dollars for a twelve-day cruise
through space, with views of the
Moon's far side and trips through
Lunar City and a landing in Aristarchus,
plus sound-tapes of the journey
and fame hitherto reserved for
honest explorers!
It didn't seem to have anything
to do with Pop or with Sattell. But
it did.
There were just two passenger
tours. The first was fully booked.
But the passengers who paid so highly,
expected to be pleasantly thrilled
and shielded from all reasons for
alarm. And they couldn't be. Something
happens when a self-centered
and complacent individual unsuspectingly
looks out of a spaceship
port and sees the cosmos unshielded
by mists or clouds or other aids to
blindness against reality. It is shattering.
A millionaire cut his throat when
he saw Earth dwindled to a mere
blue-green ball in vastness. He could
not endure his own smallness in the
face of immensity. Not one passenger
disembarked even for Lunar
City. Most of them cowered in their
chairs, hiding their eyes. They were
the simple cases of hysteria. But the
richest girl on Earth, who'd had five
husbands and believed that nothing
could move her—she went into
catatonic withdrawal and neither
saw nor heard nor moved. Two other
passengers sobbed in improvised
strait jackets. The first shipload
started home. Fast.
The second luxury liner took off
with only four passengers and turned
back before reaching the Moon.
Space-pilots could take the strain of
space-flight because they had work
to do. Workers for the lunar mines
could make the trip under heavy
sedation. But it was too early in the
development of space-travel for
pleasure-passengers. They weren't
prepared for the more humbling
facts of life.
Pop heard of the quaint commercial
enterprise through the micro-tapes
put off at the shack for the men
down in the mine. Sattell probably
learned of it the same way. Pop didn't
even think of it again. It seemed
to have nothing to do with him. But
Sattell undoubtedly dealt with it
fully in his desperate writings back
to Earth.
Pop matter-of-factly tended the
shack and the landing field and the
stores for the Big Crack mine. Between-times
he made more drawings
in pursuit of his own private objective.
Quite accidentally, he developed
a certain talent professional artists
might have approved. But he was not
trying to communicate, but to discover.
Drawing—especially with his
mind on Sattell—he found fresh incidents
popping up in his recollection.
Times when he was happy. One
day he remembered the puppy his
children had owned and loved. He
drew it painstakingly—and it was
his again. Thereafter he could remember
it any time he chose. He did
actually recover a completely vanished
past.
He envisioned a way to increase
that recovery. But there was a marked
shortage of artists' materials on the
Moon. All freight had to be hauled
from Earth, on a voyage equal to
rather more than a thousand times
around the equator of the Earth.
Artists' supplies were not often included.
Pop didn't even ask.
He began to explore the area outside
the shack for possible material
no one would think of sending from
Earth. He collected stones of various
sorts, but when warmed up in the
shack they were useless. He found
no strictly lunar material which
would serve for modeling or carving
portraits in the ground. He found
minerals which could be pulverized
and used as pigments, but nothing
suitable for this new adventure in
the recovery of lost youth. He even
considered blasting, to aid his search.
He could. Down in the mine, blasting
was done by soaking carbon black—from
CO
2
—in liquid oxygen, and then
firing it with a spark. It exploded
splendidly. And its fumes were
merely more CO
2
which an air-apparatus
handled easily.
He didn't do any blasting. He didn't
find any signs of the sort of
mineral he required. Marble would
have been perfect, but there is no
marble on the Moon. Naturally! Yet
Pop continued to search absorbedly
for material with which to capture
memory. Sattell still seemed necessary,
but—
Early one lunar morning he was
a good two miles from his shack
when he saw rocket-fumes in the
sky. It was most unlikely. He wasn't
looking for anything of the sort, but
out of the corner of his eye he observed
that something moved. Which
was impossible. He turned his head,
and there were rocket-fumes coming
over the horizon, not in the direction
of Lunar City. Which was more
impossible still.
He stared. A tiny silver rocket to
the westward poured out monstrous
masses of vapor. It decelerated swiftly.
It curved downward. The rockets
checked for an instant, and flamed
again more violently, and checked
once more. This was not an expert
approach. It was a faulty one. Curving
surface-ward in a sharply changing
parabola, the pilot over-corrected
and had to wait to gather down-speed,
and then over-corrected again.
It was an altogether clumsy landing.
The ship was not even perfectly vertical
when it settled not quite in the
landing-area marked by silvery triangles.
One of its tail-fins crumpled
slightly. It tilted a little when fully
landed.
Then nothing happened.
Pop made his way toward it in
the skittering, skating gait one uses
in one-sixth gravity. When he was
within half a mile, an air-lock door
opened in the ship's side. But nothing
came out of the lock. No space-suited
figure. No cargo came drifting
down with the singular deliberation
of falling objects on the Moon.
It was just barely past lunar sunrise
on the far side of the Moon.
Incredibly long and utterly black
shadows stretched across the plain,
and half the rocketship was dazzling
white and half was blacker than
blackness itself. The sun still hung
low indeed in the black, star-speckled
sky. Pop waded through moondust,
raising a trail of slowly settling
powder. He knew only that the ship
didn't come from Lunar City, but
from Earth. He couldn't imagine
why. He did not even wildly connect
it with what—say—Sattell might
have written with desperate plausibility
about greasy-seeming white
crystals out of the mine, knocking
about Pop Young's shack in cannisters
containing a hundred Earth-pounds
weight of richness.
Pop reached the rocketship. He
approached the big tail-fins. On one
of them there were welded ladder-rungs
going up to the opened air-lock
door.
He climbed.
The air-lock was perfectly normal
when he reached it. There was a
glass port in the inner door, and he
saw eyes looking through it at him.
He pulled the outer door shut and
felt the whining vibration of admitted
air. His vacuum suit went slack
about him. The inner door began to
open, and Pop reached up and gave
his helmet the practiced twisting
jerk which removed it.
Then he blinked. There was a red-headed
man in the opened door. He
grinned savagely at Pop. He held a
very nasty hand-weapon trained on
Pop's middle.
"Don't come in!" he said mockingly.
"And I don't give a damn
about how you are. This isn't social.
It's business!"
Pop simply gaped. He couldn't
quite take it in.
"This," snapped the red-headed
man abruptly, "is a stickup!"
Pop's eyes went through the inner
lock-door. He saw that the interior
of the ship was stripped and bare.
But a spiral stairway descended from
some upper compartment. It had a
handrail of pure, transparent, water-clear
plastic. The walls were bare insulation,
but that trace of luxury remained.
Pop gazed at the plastic,
fascinated.
The red-headed man leaned forward,
snarling. He slashed Pop
across the face with the barrel of his
weapon. It drew blood. It was wanton,
savage brutality.
"Pay attention!" snarled the red-headed
man. "A stickup, I said! Get
it? You go get that can of stuff
from the mine! The diamonds!
Bring them here! Understand?"
Pop said numbly: "What the
hell?"
The red-headed man hit him
again. He was nerve-racked, and,
therefore, he wanted to hurt.
"Move!" he rasped. "I want the
diamonds you've got for the ship
from Lunar City! Bring 'em!" Pop
licked blood from his lips and the
man with the weapon raged at him.
"Then phone down to the mine!
Tell Sattell I'm here and he can
come on up! Tell him to bring any
more diamonds they've dug up since
the stuff you've got!"
He leaned forward. His face was
only inches from Pop Young's. It
was seamed and hard-bitten and
nerve-racked. But any man would be
quivering if he wasn't used to space
or the feel of one-sixth gravity on
the Moon. He panted:
"And get it straight! You try
any tricks and we take off! We
swing over your shack! The rocket-blast
smashes it! We burn you
down! Then we swing over the cable
down to the mine and the rocket-flame
melts it! You die and everybody
in the mine besides! No tricks!
We didn't come here for nothing!"
He twitched all over. Then he
struck cruelly again at Pop Young's
face. He seemed filled with fury, at
least partly hysterical. It was the tension
that space-travel—then, at its
beginning—produced. It was meaningless
savagery due to terror. But,
of course, Pop was helpless to resent
it. There were no weapons on the
Moon and the mention of Sattell's
name showed the uselessness of bluff.
He'd pictured the complete set-up
by the edge of the Big Crack. Pop
could do nothing.
The red-headed man checked
himself, panting. He drew back and
slammed the inner lock-door. There
was the sound of pumping.
Pop put his helmet back on and
sealed it. The outer door opened.
Outrushing air tugged at Pop. After
a second or two he went out and
climbed down the welded-on ladder-bars
to the ground.
He headed back toward his shack.
Somehow, the mention of Sattell had
made his mind work better. It always
did. He began painstakingly to
put things together. The red-headed
man knew the routine here in every
detail. He knew Sattell. That part
was simple. Sattell had planned this
multi-million-dollar coup, as a man
in prison might plan his break. The
stripped interior of the ship identified
it.
It was one of the unsuccessful
luxury-liners sold for scrap. Or perhaps
it was stolen for the journey
here. Sattell's associates had had to
steal or somehow get the fuel, and
somehow find a pilot. But there were
diamonds worth at least five million
dollars waiting for them, and the
whole job might not have called for
more than two men—with Sattell as
a third. According to the economics
of crime, it was feasible. Anyhow it
was being done.
Pop reached the dust-heap which
was his shack and went in the air
lock. Inside, he went to the vision-phone
and called the mine-colony
down in the Crack. He gave the
message he'd been told to pass on.
Sattell to come up, with what diamonds
had been dug since the
regular cannister was sent up for the
Lunar City ship that would be due
presently. Otherwise the ship on the
landing strip would destroy shack
and Pop and the colony together.
"I'd guess," said Pop painstakingly,
"that Sattell figured it out. He's
probably got some sort of gun to
keep you from holding him down
there. But he won't know his friends
are here—not right this minute he
won't."
A shaking voice asked questions
from the vision-phone.
"No," said Pop, "they'll do it anyhow.
If we were able to tell about
'em, they'd be chased. But if I'm
dead and the shacks smashed and
the cable burnt through, they'll be
back on Earth long before a new
cable's been got and let down to you.
So they'll do all they can no matter
what I do." He added, "I wouldn't
tell Sattell a thing about it, if I were
you. It'll save trouble. Just let him
keep on waiting for this to happen.
It'll save you trouble."
Another shaky question.
"Me?" asked Pop. "Oh, I'm going
to raise what hell I can. There's
some stuff in that ship I want."
He switched off the phone. He
went over to his air apparatus. He
took down the cannister of diamonds
which were worth five millions or
more back on Earth. He found a
bucket. He dumped the diamonds
casually into it. They floated downward
with great deliberation and
surged from side to side like a liquid
when they stopped. One-sixth gravity.
Pop regarded his drawings meditatively.
A sketch of his wife as he
now remembered her. It was very
good to remember. A drawing of his
two children, playing together. He
looked forward to remembering
much more about them. He grinned.
"That stair-rail," he said in deep
satisfaction. "That'll do it!"
He tore bed linen from his bunk
and worked on the emptied cannister.
It was a double container with a
thermware interior lining. Even on
Earth newly-mined diamonds sometimes
fly to pieces from internal
stress. On the Moon, it was not desirable
that diamonds be exposed to
repeated violent changes of temperature.
So a thermware-lined cannister
kept them at mine-temperature once
they were warmed to touchability.
Pop packed the cotton cloth in the
container. He hurried a little, because
the men in the rocket were shaky and
might not practice patience. He took
a small emergency-lamp from his
spare spacesuit. He carefully cracked
its bulb, exposing the filament within.
He put the lamp on top of the
cotton and sprinkled magnesium
marking-powder over everything.
Then he went to the air-apparatus
and took out a flask of the liquid
oxygen used to keep his breathing-air
in balance. He poured the frigid,
pale-blue stuff into the cotton. He
saturated it.
All the inside of the shack was
foggy when he finished. Then he
pushed the cannister-top down. He
breathed a sigh of relief when it was
in place. He'd arranged for it to
break a frozen-brittle switch as it
descended. When it came off, the
switch would light the lamp with its
bare filament. There was powdered
magnesium in contact with it and
liquid oxygen all about.
He went out of the shack by the
air lock. On the way, thinking about
Sattell, he suddenly recovered a completely
new memory. On their first
wedding anniversary, so long ago,
he and his wife had gone out to
dinner to celebrate. He remembered
how she looked: the almost-smug
joy they shared that they would be
together for always, with one complete
year for proof.
Pop reflected hungrily that it was
something else to be made permanent
and inspected from time to time.
But he wanted more than a drawing
of this! He wanted to make the memory
permanent and to extend it—
If it had not been for his vacuum
suit and the cannister he carried, Pop
would have rubbed his hands.
Tall, jagged crater-walls rose
from the lunar plain. Monstrous, extended
inky shadows stretched
enormous distances, utterly black.
The sun, like a glowing octopod,
floated low at the edge of things and
seemed to hate all creation.
Pop reached the rocket. He
climbed the welded ladder-rungs to
the air lock. He closed the door. Air
whined. His suit sagged against his
body. He took off his helmet.
When the red-headed man opened
the inner door, the hand-weapon
shook and trembled. Pop said
calmly:
"Now I've got to go handle the
hoist, if Sattell's coming up from
the mine. If I don't do it, he don't
come up."
The red-headed man snarled. But
his eyes were on the cannister whose
contents should weigh a hundred
pounds on Earth.
"Any tricks," he rasped, "and you
know what happens!"
"Yeah," said Pop.
He stolidly put his helmet back
on. But his eyes went past the red-headed
man to the stair that wound
down, inside the ship, from some
compartment above. The stair-rail was
pure, clear, water-white plastic, not
less than three inches thick. There
was a lot of it!
The inner door closed. Pop opened
the outer. Air rushed out. He
climbed painstakingly down to the
ground. He started back toward the
shack.
There was the most luridly bright
of all possible flashes. There was no
sound, of course. But something
flamed very brightly, and the ground
thumped under Pop Young's vacuum
boots. He turned.
The rocketship was still in the act
of flying apart. It had been a splendid
explosion. Of course cotton sheeting
in liquid oxygen is not quite as
good an explosive as carbon-black,
which they used down in the mine.
Even with magnesium powder to
start the flame when a bare light-filament
ignited it, the cannister-bomb
hadn't equaled—say—T.N.T.
But the ship had fuel on board for
the trip back to Earth. And it blew,
too. It would be minutes before all
the fragments of the ship returned
to the Moon's surface. On the Moon,
things fall slowly.
Pop didn't wait. He searched
hopefully. Once a mass of steel plating
fell only yards from him, but it
did not interrupt his search.
When he went into the shack, he
grinned to himself. The call-light of
the vision-phone flickered wildly.
When he took off his helmet the bell
clanged incessantly. He answered. A
shaking voice from the mining-colony
panted:
"We felt a shock! What happened?
What do we do?"
"Don't do a thing," advised Pop.
"It's all right. I blew up the ship and
everything's all right. I wouldn't
even mention it to Sattell if I were
you."
He grinned happily down at a section
of plastic stair-rail he'd found
not too far from where the ship exploded.
When the man down in the
mine cut off, Pop got out of his
vacuum suit in a hurry. He placed
the plastic zestfully on the table
where he'd been restricted to drawing
pictures of his wife and children
in order to recover memories of
them.
He began to plan, gloatingly, the
thing he would carve out of a four-inch
section of the plastic. When it
was carved, he'd paint it. While he
worked, he'd think of Sattell, because
that was the way to get back the
missing portions of his life—the
parts Sattell had managed to get
away from him. He'd get back more
than ever, now!
He didn't wonder what he'd do
if he ever remembered the crime
Sattell had committed. He felt, somehow,
that he wouldn't get that back
until he'd recovered all the rest.
Gloating, it was amusing to remember
what people used to call
such art-works as he planned, when
carved by other lonely men in other
faraway places. They called those
sculptures scrimshaw.
But they were a lot more than
that!
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Astounding Science Fiction
September
1955. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/3/7/9/23791//23791-h//23791-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How often does the Lunar colony get supplies delivered from earth? | 23791_2QXPACKC_5 | [
"Every twelve days",
"Every three months",
"Once a month",
"Every two weeks"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Who is Big Louis? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_1 | [
"Big Louis is Lawrence Reston-Farrell's boss.",
"Big Louis is Al Rossi's boss.",
"Big Louis is Warren Brett- James' boss.",
"Big Louis is Joe Prantera's boss."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How did Joe get to 2133? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_2 | [
"He was cryogenically frozen in 1960 and awakened in 2133.",
"He was transported through time from 1960 to 2133 by Brett-James and Reston-Farrell.",
"Joe fell through a crack in time, which put him in 2133.",
"Brett-James and Reston-Farrell used a vortex manipulator to transport Joe to 2133."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0028",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why do Reston-Farrell and Brett-James bring Joe to the future? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_3 | [
"Joe was going to kill Al Rossi. Reston-Farrell and Brett James need Rossi alive.",
"Joe is a caregiver. They want him to take care of someone.",
"Joe is a hitman. They want him to kill someone.",
"Joe is a variant. They removed him from 1960 to correct the timeline."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why do Reston-Farrell and Brett-James want Howard Temple-Tracy dead? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_4 | [
"Howard Temple-Tracy is an evil genius recruiting people to his cult.",
"Howard Temple-Tracy is a terrorist bent on destroying North America.",
"Howard Temple-Tracy is an evil genius trying to take over the world.",
"Howard Temple-Tracy is a hitman trying to kill Reston-Farrell and Brett-James. They are just defending themselves."
] | 3 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does Joe feel about Brett-James and Reston-Farrell? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_5 | [
"Joe is a little intimidated by them as they seem to be significantly more educated than he is.",
"Joe doesn't know what to think. There's no such thing as time travel. He must be going crazy.",
"Joe thinks they are ridiculous and that Howard Temple-Tracy would make a better associate.",
"Joe thinks they are cowards as they are unable to kill their enemy themselves."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does Joe call Citizen Temple-Tracy Chief? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_6 | [
"Temple-Tracy is the Chief of Police.",
"Temple-Tracy is the head of the Fire Department.",
"Temple-Tracy is the head of the Time Travel Bureau.",
"Joe wants Temple-Tracy to know Joe regards him as superior."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does everyone in the future have hyphenated names? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_7 | [
"Everyone in the future is pretentious.",
"In the future, they honor the maternal lineage.",
"In the future, they have such a large population it was necessary to differentiate between citizens.",
"Everyone in the future uses the name of both spouses."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What city is Temple-Tracy in? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_8 | [
"Los Angeles",
"New New Mexico",
"New New York",
"Nuevo Los Angeles"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the punishment for murder in the future? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_9 | [
"Death",
"Erasure from the timeline",
"Life in prison",
"Psychiatric Care"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
24,247 | 24247_VSZJE6DY | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Gun for Hire | 1952.0 | Reynolds, Mack | Short stories; Science fiction; Assassins -- Fiction; PS; Time travel -- Fiction | Illustrated by van Dongen
A gun is an interesting weapon; it can be hired, of
course, and naturally doesn't care who hires it. Something
much the same can be said of the gunman, too....
GUN FOR HIRE
By
MACK
REYNOLDS
Joe Prantera
called
softly, "Al." The pleasurable,
comfortable,
warm feeling began
spreading over him, the
way it always did.
The older man stopped and
squinted, but not suspiciously, even
now.
The evening was dark, it was unlikely
that the other even saw the
circle of steel that was the mouth of
the shotgun barrel, now resting on
the car's window ledge.
"Who's it?" he growled.
Joe Prantera said softly, "Big Louis
sent me, Al."
And he pressed the trigger.
And at that moment, the universe
caved inward upon Joseph Marie
Prantera.
There was nausea and nausea upon
nausea.
There was a falling through all
space and through all time. There was
doubling and twisting and twitching
of every muscle and nerve.
There was pain, horror and tumultuous
fear.
And he came out of it as quickly
and completely as he'd gone in.
He was in, he thought, a hospital
and his first reaction was to think,
This here California. Everything different.
Then his second thought was
Something went wrong. Big Louis, he
ain't going to like this.
He brought his thinking to the
present. So far as he could remember,
he hadn't completely pulled the trigger.
That at least meant that whatever
the rap was it wouldn't be too
tough. With luck, the syndicate would
get him off with a couple of years at
Quentin.
A door slid open in the wall in a
way that Joe had never seen a door
operate before.
This here California.
The clothes on the newcomer were
wrong, too. For the first time, Joe
Prantera began to sense an alienness—a
something that was awfully
wrong.
The other spoke precisely and
slowly, the way a highly educated man
speaks a language which he reads
and writes fluently but has little occasion
to practice vocally. "You have recovered?"
Joe Prantera looked at the other
expressionlessly. Maybe the old duck
was one of these foreign doctors, like.
The newcomer said, "You have undoubtedly
been through a most harrowing
experience. If you have any
untoward symptoms, possibly I could
be of assistance."
Joe couldn't figure out how he
stood. For one thing, there should
have been some kind of police guard.
The other said, "Perhaps a bit of
stimulant?"
Joe said flatly, "I wanta lawyer."
The newcomer frowned at him. "A
lawyer?"
"I'm not sayin' nothin'. Not until I
get a mouthpiece."
The newcomer started off on another
tack. "My name is Lawrence
Reston-Farrell. If I am not mistaken,
you are Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Salviati happened to be Joe's mother's
maiden name. But it was unlikely
this character could have known that.
Joe had been born in Naples and his
mother had died in childbirth. His
father hadn't brought him to the
States until the age of five and by that
time he had a stepmother.
"I wanta mouthpiece," Joe said
flatly, "or let me outta here."
Lawrence Reston-Farrell said, "You
are not being constrained. There are
clothes for you in the closet there."
Joe gingerly tried swinging his
feet to the floor and sitting up, while
the other stood watching him, strangely.
He came to his feet. With the exception
of a faint nausea, which
brought back memories of that extreme
condition he'd suffered during
... during what? He hadn't the
vaguest idea of what had happened.
He was dressed in a hospital-type
nightgown. He looked down at it and
snorted and made his way over to the
closet. It opened on his approach, the
door sliding back into the wall in
much the same manner as the room's
door had opened for Reston-Farrell.
Joe Prantera scowled and said,
"These ain't my clothes."
"No, I am afraid not."
"You think I'd be seen dead wearing
this stuff? What is this, some religious
crackpot hospital?"
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid,
Mr. Salviati-Prantera, that these are
the only garments available. I suggest
you look out the window there."
Joe gave him a long, chill look
and then stepped to the window. He
couldn't figure the other. Unless he
was a fruitcake. Maybe he was in
some kind of pressure cooker and
this was one of the fruitcakes.
He looked out, however, not on the
lawns and walks of a sanitarium but
upon a wide boulevard of what was
obviously a populous city.
And for a moment again, Joe Prantera
felt the depths of nausea.
This was not his world.
He stared for a long, long moment.
The cars didn't even have wheels, he
noted dully. He turned slowly and
faced the older man.
Reston-Farrell said compassionately,
"Try this, it's excellent cognac."
Joe Prantera stared at him, said finally,
flatly, "What's it all about?"
The other put down the unaccepted
glass. "We were afraid first
realization would be a shock to you,"
he said. "My colleague is in the adjoining
room. We will be glad to explain
to you if you will join us there."
"I wanta get out of here," Joe said.
"Where would you go?"
The fear of police, of Al Rossi's
vengeance, of the measures that
might be taken by Big Louis on his
failure, were now far away.
Reston-Farrell had approached the
door by which he had entered and it
reopened for him. He went through
it without looking back.
There was nothing else to do. Joe
dressed, then followed him.
In the adjoining room was a circular
table that would have accommodated
a dozen persons. Two were
seated there now, papers, books and
soiled coffee cups before them. There
had evidently been a long wait.
Reston-Farrell, the one Joe had already
met, was tall and drawn of face
and with a chainsmoker's nervousness.
The other was heavier and more
at ease. They were both, Joe estimated,
somewhere in their middle fifties.
They both looked like docs. He
wondered, all over again, if this was
some kind of pressure cooker.
But that didn't explain the view
from the window.
Reston-Farrell said, "May I present
my colleague, Citizen Warren Brett-James?
Warren, this is our guest from
... from yesteryear, Mr. Joseph Salviati-Prantera."
Brett-James nodded to him, friendly,
so far as Joe could see. He said
gently, "I think it would be Mr. Joseph
Prantera, wouldn't it? The maternal
linage was almost universally
ignored." His voice too gave the impression
he was speaking a language
not usually on his tongue.
Joe took an empty chair, hardly
bothering to note its alien qualities.
His body seemed to
fit
into the piece
of furniture, as though it had been
molded to his order.
Joe said, "I think maybe I'll take
that there drink, Doc."
Reston-Farrell said, "Of course,"
and then something else Joe didn't
get. Whatever the something else
was, a slot opened in the middle of
the table and a glass, so clear of texture
as to be all but invisible, was
elevated. It contained possibly three
ounces of golden fluid.
Joe didn't allow himself to think
of its means of delivery. He took up
the drink and bolted it. He put the
glass down and said carefully,
"What's it all about, huh?"
Warren Brett-James said soothingly,
"Prepare yourself for somewhat
of a shock, Mr. Prantera. You are no
longer in Los Angeles—"
"Ya think I'm stupid? I can see
that."
"I was about to say, Los Angeles of
1960. Mr. Prantera, we welcome you
to Nuevo Los Angeles."
"Ta where?"
"To Nuevo Los Angeles and to
the year—" Brett-James looked at his
companion. "What is the date, Old
Calendar?"
"2133," Reston-Farrell said. "2133
A.D. they would say."
Joe Prantera looked from one of
them to the other, scowling. "What
are you guys talking about?"
Warren Brett-James said softly,
"Mr. Prantera, you are no longer in
the year 1960, you are now in the
year 2133."
He said, uncomprehendingly, "You
mean I been, like, unconscious for—"
He let the sentence fall away as he
realized the impossibility.
Brett-James said gently, "Hardly
for one hundred and seventy years,
Mr. Prantera."
Reston-Farrell said, "I am afraid we
are confusing you. Briefly, we have
transported
you, I suppose one might
say, from your own era to ours."
Joe Prantera had never been exposed
to the concept of time travel.
He had simply never associated with
anyone who had ever even remotely
considered such an idea. Now he said,
"You mean, like, I been asleep all
that time?"
"Not exactly," Brett-James said,
frowning.
Reston-Farrell said, "Suffice to say,
you are now one hundred and seventy-three
years after the last memory you
have."
Joe Prantera's mind suddenly reverted
to those last memories and his
eyes narrowed dangerously. He felt
suddenly at bay. He said, "Maybe
you guys better let me in on what's
this all about."
Reston-Farrell said, "Mr. Prantera,
we have brought you from your era
to perform a task for us."
Joe stared at him, and then at the
other. He couldn't believe he was getting
through to them. Or, at least,
that they were to him.
Finally he said, "If I get this, you
want me to do a job for you."
"That is correct."
Joe said, "You guys know the kind
of jobs I do?"
"That is correct."
"Like hell you do. You think I'm
stupid? I never even seen you before."
Joe Prantera came abruptly to
his feet. "I'm gettin' outta here."
For the second time, Reston-Farrell
said, "Where would you go, Mr.
Prantera?"
Joe glared at him. Then sat down
again, as abruptly as he'd arisen.
"Let's start all over again. I got this
straight, you brought me, some
screwy way, all the way ... here.
O.K., I'll buy that. I seen what it looks
like out that window—" The real
comprehension was seeping through
to him even as he talked. "Everybody
I know, Jessie, Tony, the Kid, Big
Louis, everybody, they're dead. Even
Big Louis."
"Yes," Brett-James said, his voice
soft. "They are all dead, Mr. Prantera.
Their children are all dead, and their
grandchildren."
The two men of the future said
nothing more for long minutes while
Joe Prantera's mind whirled its confusion.
Finally he said, "What's this bit
about you wanting me to give it to
some guy."
"That is why we brought you here,
Mr. Prantera. You were ... you
are, a professional assassin."
"Hey, wait a minute, now."
Reston-Farrell went on, ignoring
the interruption. "There is small
point in denying your calling. Pray
remember that at the point when we
...
transported
you, you were about
to dispose of a contemporary named
Alphonso Annunziata-Rossi. A citizen,
I might say, whose demise would
probably have caused small dismay to
society."
They had him pegged all right. Joe
said, "But why me? Why don't you
get some heavy from now? Somebody
knows the ropes these days."
Brett-James said, "Mr. Prantera,
there are no professional assassins in
this age, nor have there been for over
a century and a half."
"Well, then do it yourself." Joe
Prantera's irritation over this whole
complicated mess was growing. And
already he was beginning to long for
the things he knew—for Jessie and
Tony and the others, for his favorite
bar, for the lasagne down at Papa
Giovanni's. Right now he could have
welcomed a calling down at the hands
of Big Louis.
Reston-Farrell had come to his feet
and walked to one of the large room's
windows. He looked out, as though
unseeing. Then, his back turned, he
said, "We have tried, but it is simply
not in us, Mr. Prantera."
"You mean you're yella?"
"No, if by that you mean afraid. It
is simply not within us to take the
life of a fellow creature—not to speak
of a fellow man."
Joe snapped: "Everything you guys
say sounds crazy. Let's start all over
again."
Brett-James said, "Let me do it,
Lawrence." He turned his eyes to Joe.
"Mr. Prantera, in your own era, did
you ever consider the future?"
Joe looked at him blankly.
"In your day you were confronted
with national and international, problems.
Just as we are today and just as
nations were a century or a millennium
ago."
"Sure, O.K., so we had problems. I
know whatcha mean—like wars, and
depressions and dictators and like
that."
"Yes, like that," Brett-James
nodded.
The heavy-set man paused a moment.
"Yes, like that," he repeated.
"That we confront you now indicates
that the problems of your day were
solved. Hadn't they been, the world
most surely would have destroyed itself.
Wars? Our pedagogues are hard
put to convince their students that
such ever existed. More than a century
and a half ago our society eliminated
the reasons for international
conflict. For that matter," he added
musingly, "we eliminated most international
boundaries. Depressions?
Shortly after your own period, man
awoke to the fact that he had achieved
to the point where it was possible to
produce an abundance for all with a
minimum of toil. Overnight, for all
practical purposes, the whole world
was industrialized, automated. The
second industrial revolution was accompanied
by revolutionary changes
in almost every field, certainly in every
science. Dictators? Your ancestors
found, Mr. Prantera, that it is
difficult for a man to be free so long
as others are still enslaved. Today the
democratic ethic has reached a pinnacle
never dreamed of in your own
era."
"O.K., O.K.," Joe Prantera growled.
"So everybody's got it made. What I
wanta know is what's all this about
me giving it ta somebody? If everything's
so great, how come you want
me to knock this guy off?"
Reston-Farrell bent forward and
thumped his right index finger twice
on the table. "The bacterium of hate—a
new strain—has found the human
race unprotected from its disease.
We had thought our vaccines
immunized us."
"What's that suppose to mean?"
Brett-James took up the ball again.
"Mr. Prantera, have you ever heard of
Ghengis Khan, of Tamerlane, Alexander,
Caesar?"
Joe Prantera scowled at him emptily.
"Or, more likely, of Napoleon, Hitler,
Stalin?"
"Sure I heard of Hitler and Stalin,"
Joe growled. "I ain't stupid."
The other nodded. "Such men are
unique. They have a drive ... a
drive to power which exceeds by far
the ambitions of the average man.
They are genii in their way, Mr. Prantera,
genii of evil. Such a genius of
evil has appeared on the current
scene."
"Now we're getting somewheres,"
Joe snorted. "So you got a guy what's
a little ambitious, like, eh? And you
guys ain't got the guts to give it to
him. O.K. What's in it for me?"
The two of them frowned, exchanged
glances. Reston-Farrell said,
"You know, that is one aspect we had
not considered."
Brett-James said to Joe Prantera,
"Had we not, ah, taken you at the
time we did, do you realize what
would have happened?"
"Sure," Joe grunted. "I woulda let
old Al Rossi have it right in the guts,
five times. Then I woulda took the
plane back to Chi."
Brett-James was shaking his head.
"No. You see, by coincidence, a police
squad car was coming down the
street just at that moment to arrest
Mr. Rossi. You would have been apprehended.
As I understand Californian
law of the period, your life
would have been forfeit, Mr. Prantera."
Joe winced. It didn't occur to him
to doubt their word.
Reston-Farrell said, "As to reward,
Mr. Prantera, we have already told
you there is ultra-abundance in this
age. Once this task has been performed,
we will sponsor your entry
into present day society. Competent
psychiatric therapy will soon remove
your present—"
"Waita minute, now. You figure on
gettin' me candled by some head
shrinker, eh? No thanks, Buster. I'm
going back to my own—"
Brett-James was shaking his head
again. "I am afraid there is no return,
Mr. Prantera. Time travel works but
in one direction,
with
the flow of the
time stream. There can be no return
to your own era."
Joe Prantera had been rocking
with the mental blows he had been
assimilating, but this was the final
haymaker. He was stuck in this
squaresville of a world.
Joe Prantera on a job was thorough.
Careful, painstaking, competent.
He spent the first three days of his
life in the year 2133 getting the feel
of things. Brett-James and Reston-Farrell
had been appointed to work
with him. Joe didn't meet any of the
others who belonged to the group
which had taken the measures to
bring him from the past. He didn't
want to meet them. The fewer persons
involved, the better.
He stayed in the apartment of
Reston-Farrell. Joe had been right,
Reston-Farrell was a medical doctor.
Brett-James evidently had something
to do with the process that had enabled
them to bring Joe from the
past. Joe didn't know how they'd
done it, and he didn't care. Joe was a
realist. He was here. The thing was
to adapt.
There didn't seem to be any hurry.
Once the deal was made, they left it
up to him to make the decisions.
They drove him around the town,
when he wished to check the traffic
arteries. They flew him about the
whole vicinity. From the air, Southern
California looked much the same
as it had in his own time. Oceans,
mountains, and to a lesser extent, deserts,
are fairly permanent even
against man's corroding efforts.
It was while he was flying with
Brett-James on the second day that
Joe said, "How about Mexico? Could
I make the get to Mexico?"
The physicist looked at him questioningly.
"Get?" he said.
Joe Prantera said impatiently, "The
getaway. After I give it to this Howard
Temple-Tracy guy, I gotta go on
the run, don't I?"
"I see." Brett-James cleared his
throat. "Mexico is no longer a separate
nation, Mr. Prantera. All North
America has been united into one
unit. Today, there are only eight nations
in the world."
"Where's the nearest?"
"South America."
"That's a helluva long way to go on
a get."
"We hadn't thought of the matter
being handled in that manner."
Joe eyed him in scorn. "Oh, you
didn't, huh? What happens after I
give it to this guy? I just sit around
and wait for the cops to put the arm
on me?"
Brett-James grimaced in amusement.
"Mr. Prantera, this will probably
be difficult for you to comprehend,
but there are no police in this
era."
Joe gaped at him. "No police!
What happens if you gotta throw
some guy in stir?"
"If I understand your idiom correctly,
you mean prison. There are
no prisons in this era, Mr. Prantera."
Joe stared. "No cops, no jails. What
stops anybody? What stops anybody
from just going into some bank, like,
and collecting up all the bread?"
Brett-James cleared his throat.
"Mr. Prantera, there are no banks."
"No banks! You gotta have banks!"
"And no money to put in them.
We found it a rather antiquated
method of distribution well over a
century ago."
Joe had given up. Now he merely
stared.
Brett-James said reasonably, "We
found we were devoting as much
time to financial matters in all their
endless ramifications—including
bank robberies—as we were to productive
efforts. So we turned to more
efficient methods of distribution."
On the fourth day, Joe said, "O.K.,
let's get down to facts. Summa the
things you guys say don't stick together
so good. Now, first place,
where's this guy Temple-Tracy you
want knocked off?"
Reston-Farrell and Brett-James
were both present. The three of them
sat in the living room of the latter's
apartment, sipping a sparkling wine
which seemed to be the prevailing
beverage of the day. For Joe's taste
it was insipid stuff. Happily, rye was
available to those who wanted it.
Reston-Farrell said, "You mean,
where does he reside? Why, here in
this city."
"Well, that's handy, eh?" Joe
scratched himself thoughtfully. "You
got somebody can finger him for me?"
"Finger him?"
"Look, before I can give it to this
guy I gotta know some place where
he'll be at some time. Get it? Like Al
Rossi. My finger, he works in Rossi's
house, see? He lets me know every
Wednesday night, eight o'clock, Al
leaves the house all by hisself. O.K.,
so I can make plans, like, to give it
to him." Joe Prantera wound it up
reasonably. "You gotta have a finger."
Brett-James said, "Why not just go
to Temple-Tracy's apartment and, ah,
dispose of him?"
"Jest walk in, eh? You think I'm
stupid? How do I know how many
witnesses hangin' around? How do I
know if the guy's carryin' heat?"
"Heat?"
"A gun, a gun. Ya think I'm stupid?
I come to give it to him and he
gives it to me instead."
Dr. Reston-Farrell said, "Howard
Temple-Tracy lives alone. He customarily
receives visitors every afternoon,
largely potential followers. He
is attempting to recruit members to
an organization he is forming. It
would be quite simple for you to
enter his establishment and dispose
of him. I assure you, he does not possess
weapons."
Joe was indignant. "Just like that,
eh?" he said sarcastically. "Then what
happens? How do I get out of the
building? Where's my get car parked?
Where do I hide out? Where do I
dump the heat?"
"Dump the heat?"
"Get rid of the gun. You want I
should get caught with the gun on
me? I'd wind up in the gas chamber
so quick—"
"See here, Mr. Prantera," Brett-James
said softly. "We no longer have
capital punishment, you must realize."
"O.K. I still don't wanta get caught.
What
is
the rap these days, huh?"
Joe scowled. "You said they didn't
have no jails any more."
"This is difficult for you to understand,
I imagine," Reston-Farrell told
him, "but, you see, we no longer punish
people in this era."
That took a long, unbelieving moment
to sink in. "You mean, like, no
matter what they do? That's crazy.
Everybody'd be running around giving
it to everybody else."
"The motivation for crime has
been removed, Mr. Prantera," Reston-Farrell
attempted to explain. "A
person who commits a violence
against another is obviously in need
of medical care. And, consequently,
receives it."
"You mean, like, if I steal a car or
something, they just take me to a
doctor?" Joe Prantera was unbelieving.
"Why would anybody wish to steal
a car?" Reston-Farrell said easily.
"But if I
give it
to somebody?"
"You will be turned over to a medical
institution. Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
is the last man you will
ever kill, Mr. Prantera."
A chillness was in the belly of Joe
Prantera. He said very slowly, very
dangerously, "You guys figure on me
getting caught, don't you?"
"Yes," Brett-James said evenly.
"Well then, figure something else.
You think I'm stupid?"
"Mr. Prantera," Dr. Reston-Farrell
said, "there has been as much progress
in the field of psychiatry in the
past two centuries as there has in
any other. Your treatment would be
brief and painless, believe me."
Joe said coldly, "And what happens
to you guys? How do you know I
won't rat on you?"
Brett-James said gently, "The moment
after you have accomplished
your mission, we plan to turn ourselves
over to the nearest institution
to have determined whether or not
we also need therapy."
"Now I'm beginning to wonder
about you guys," Joe said. "Look, all
over again, what'd'ya wanta give it to
this guy for?"
The doctor said, "We explained
the other day, Mr. Prantera. Citizen
Howard Temple-Tracy is a dangerous,
atavistic, evil genius. We are
afraid for our institutions if his plans
are allowed to mature."
"Well if you got things so good,
everybody's got it made, like, who'd
listen to him?"
The doctor nodded at the validity
of the question. "Mr. Prantera,
Homo
sapiens
is a unique animal. Physically
he matures at approximately the age
of thirteen. However, mental maturity
and adjustment is often not fully
realized until thirty or even more.
Indeed, it is sometimes never
achieved. Before such maturity is
reached, our youth are susceptible to
romantic appeal. Nationalism, chauvinism,
racism, the supposed glory of
the military, all seem romantic to the
immature. They rebel at the orderliness
of present society. They seek entertainment
in excitement. Citizen
Temple-Tracy is aware of this and
finds his recruits among the young."
"O.K., so this guy is dangerous.
You want him knocked off before he
screws everything up. But the way
things are, there's no way of making
a get. So you'll have to get some other
patsy. Not me."
"I am afraid you have no alternative,"
Brett-James said gently. "Without
us, what will you do? Mr. Prantera,
you do not even speak the language."
"What'd'ya mean? I don't understand
summa the big words you eggheads
use, but I get by O.K."
Brett-James said, "Amer-English is
no longer the language spoken by the
man in the street, Mr. Prantera. Only
students of such subjects any longer
speak such tongues as Amer-English,
French, Russian or the many others
that once confused the race with
their limitations as a means of communication."
"You mean there's no place in the
whole world where they talk American?"
Joe demanded, aghast.
Dr. Reston-Farrell controlled the
car. Joe Prantera sat in the seat next
to him and Warren Brett-James sat
in the back. Joe had, tucked in his
belt, a .45 caliber automatic, once displayed
in a museum. It had been
more easily procured than the ammunition
to fit it, but that problem too
had been solved.
The others were nervous, obviously
repelled by the very conception of
what they had planned.
Inwardly, Joe was amused. Now
that they had got in the clutch, the
others were on the verge of chickening
out. He knew it wouldn't have
taken much for them to cancel the
project. It wasn't any answer though.
If they allowed him to call it off today,
they'd talk themselves into it
again before the week was through.
Besides, already Joe was beginning
to feel the comfortable, pleasurable,
warm feeling that came to him on
occasions like this.
He said, "You're sure this guy talks
American, eh?"
Warren Brett-James said, "Quite
sure. He is a student of history."
"And he won't think it's funny I
talk American to him, eh?"
"He'll undoubtedly be intrigued."
They pulled up before a large
apartment building that overlooked
the area once known as Wilmington.
Joe was coolly efficient now. He
pulled out the automatic, held it
down below his knees and threw a
shell into the barrel. He eased the
hammer down, thumbed on the
safety, stuck the weapon back in his
belt and beneath the jacketlike garment
he wore.
He said, "O.K. See you guys later."
He left them and entered the building.
An elevator—he still wasn't used
to their speed in this era—whooshed
him to the penthouse duplex occupied
by Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy.
There were two persons in the reception
room but they left on Joe's
arrival, without bothering to look at
him more than glancingly.
He spotted the screen immediately
and went over and stood before it.
The screen lit and revealed a
heavy-set, dour of countenance man
seated at a desk. He looked into Joe
Prantera's face, scowled and said
something.
Joe said, "Joseph Salviati-Prantera
to interview Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy."
The other's shaggy eyebrows rose.
"Indeed," he said. "In Amer-English?"
Joe nodded.
"Enter," the other said.
A door had slid open on the other
side of the room. Joe walked through
it and into what was obviously an office.
Citizen Temple-Tracy sat at a
desk. There was only one other chair
in the room. Joe Prantera ignored it
and remained standing.
Citizen Temple-Tracy said, "What
can I do for you?"
Joe looked at him for a long, long
moment. Then he reached down to
his belt and brought forth the .45
automatic. He moistened his lips.
Joe said softly, "You know what
this here is?"
Temple-Tracy stared at the weapon.
"It's a handgun, circa, I would
say, about 1925 Old Calendar. What
in the world are you doing with it?"
Joe said, very slowly, "Chief, in the
line you're in these days you needa
heavy around with wunna these. Otherwise,
Chief, you're gunna wind up
in some gutter with a lotta holes in
you. What I'm doin', I'm askin' for a
job. You need a good man knows how
to handle wunna these, Chief."
Citizen Howard Temple-Tracy
eyed him appraisingly. "Perhaps," he
said, "you are right at that. In the near
future, I may well need an assistant
knowledgeable in the field of violence.
Tell me more about yourself.
You surprise me considerably."
"Sure, Chief. It's kinda a long
story, though. First off, I better tell
you you got some bad enemies, Chief.
Two guys special, named Brett-James
and Doc Reston-Farrell. I think one
of the first jobs I'm gunna hafta do
for you, Chief, is to give it to those
two."
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog
December
1960. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/4/2/4/24247//24247-h//24247-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why can't Joe go back to 1960? | 24247_VSZJE6DY_10 | [
"Temple-Tracy destroyed the vortex manipulator.",
"The time circuits were damaged when they brought Joe into the future.",
"Temple -Tracy destroyed the time transmitter.",
"Time only moves one way."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why wasn't the narrator's compartment clean during blastoff? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_1 | [
"The crew ransacked the narrator's room. They were not happy to have a journalist forced upon them for this journey.",
"The narrator forgot to secure his belongings when they boarded the ship. The gyroscopic spin knocked unsecured items all around the room.",
"The force of the inertial gravities knocked unsecured items all around the room. The narrator did not secure his belongings when he boarded the ship.",
"The gyroscopic spin caused the narrator to vomit."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does Pat feel about the narrator? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_2 | [
"Pat thinks the narrator is an idiot. He cannot believe the space agency allowed the journalist to tag along.",
"Pat is highly annoyed to have an untrained passenger like the narrator aborad for this long, scientific journey.",
"Pat thinks the narrator is simple-minded and tells him as much.",
"Pat hates the narrator. Pat tells him to go to hell."
] | 1 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 3,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How long was the author away from earth on this trip? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_3 | [
"18 months",
"17 months",
"19 months",
"16 months"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What portion of the journey was spent in cryosleep? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_4 | [
"4 months",
"They did not use cryosleep.",
"6 months",
"8 months"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why do Lloyd and Jones shoot at the narrator? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_5 | [
"After almost 9 months trapped on the ship together, the entire crew wanted to kill the narrator.",
"Lloyd and Jones were hallucinating and thought the narrator was an enemy combatant.",
"Lloyd and Jones were trying to scare the narrator. ",
"There was an alien lifeform following the narrator."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How do the Martians reproduce? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_6 | [
"The Martians are made of sugar. Once the body dissolves in the water a new body forms, like a phoenix rising from the ashes.",
"The Martians reproduce the same way humans do.",
"The red scales the Martians leave behind are like eggs. New Martians hatch out of the scales.",
"The Martians are covered in red scales. The scales are shed. The discarded scales grow into new aliens."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How did Martians get aboard the ship? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_7 | [
"Kroger brought two sugar crystals aboard.",
"Lloyd brought two sugar crystals aboard.",
"Pat brought two sugar crystals aboard.",
"Jones brought two sugar crystals aboard."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
26,843 | 26843_JEQCNBC3 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Dope on Mars | 1954.0 | Sharkey, Jack | Short stories; Mars (Planet) -- Fiction; Space flight -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | THE DOPE
on Mars
By JACK SHARKEY
Somebody had to get the human
angle on this trip ... but what
was humane about sending me?
Illustrated by WOOD
My
agent was the one who
got me the job of going
along to write up the first
trip to Mars. He was always getting
me things like that—appearances
on TV shows, or mentions in writers'
magazines. If he didn't sell
much of my stuff, at least he sold
me
.
"It'll be the biggest break a
writer ever got," he told me, two
days before blastoff. "Oh, sure
there'll be scientific reports on the
trip, but the public doesn't want
them; they want the
human
slant
on things."
"But, Louie," I said weakly, "I'll
probably be locked up for the
whole trip. If there are fights or accidents,
they won't tell
me
about
them."
"Nonsense," said Louie, sipping
carefully at a paper cup of scalding
coffee. "It'll be just like the
public going along vicariously.
They'll
identify
with you."
"But, Louie," I said, wiping the
dampness from my palms on the
knees of my trousers as I sat there,
"how'll I go about it? A story? An
article? A
you-are-there
type of report?
What?"
Louie shrugged. "So keep a
diary. It'll be more intimate, like."
"But what if nothing happens?"
I insisted hopelessly.
Louie smiled. "So you fake it."
I got up from the chair in his office
and stepped to the door.
"That's dishonest," I pointed out.
"Creative is the word," Louie
said.
So I went on the first trip to
Mars. And I kept a diary. This is
it. And it is honest. Honest it is.
October 1, 1960
They picked
the launching
date from the March, 1959, New
York
Times
, which stated that this
was the most likely time for launching.
Trip time is supposed to take
260 days (that's one way), so
we're aimed toward where Mars
will be (had
better
be, or else).
There are five of us on board. A
pilot, co-pilot, navigator and biochemist.
And, of course, me. I've
met all but the pilot (he's very
busy today), and they seem friendly
enough.
Dwight Kroger, the biochemist,
is rather old to take the "rigors of
the journey," as he puts it, but the
government had a choice between
sending a green scientist who could
stand the trip or an accomplished
man who would probably not survive,
so they picked Kroger. We've
blasted off, though, and he's still
with us. He looks a damn sight better
than I feel. He's kind of balding,
and very iron-gray-haired and
skinny, but his skin is tan as an Indian's,
and right now he's telling
jokes in the washroom with the co-pilot.
Jones (that's the co-pilot; I
didn't quite catch his first name) is
scarlet-faced, barrel-chested and
gives the general appearance of belonging
under the spreading chestnut
tree, not in a metal bullet flinging
itself out into airless space.
Come to think of it, who
does
belong
where we are?
The navigator's name is Lloyd
Streeter, but I haven't seen his face
yet. He has a little cubicle behind
the pilot's compartment, with all
kinds of maps and rulers and things.
He keeps bent low over a welded-to-the-wall
(they call it the bulkhead,
for some reason or other)
table, scratching away with a ballpoint
pen on the maps, and now
and then calling numbers over a
microphone to the pilot. His hair
is red and curly, and he looks as
though he'd be tall if he ever gets
to stand up. There are freckles on
the backs of his hands, so I think
he's probably got them on his face,
too. So far, all he's said is, "Scram,
I'm busy."
Kroger tells me that the pilot's
name is Patrick Desmond, but that
I can call him Pat when I get to
know him better. So far, he's still
Captain Desmond to me. I haven't
the vaguest idea what he looks like.
He was already on board when I
got here, with my typewriter and
ream of paper, so we didn't meet.
My compartment is small but
clean. I mean clean now. It wasn't
during blastoff. The inertial gravities
didn't bother me so much as
the gyroscopic spin they put on the
ship so we have a sort of artificial
gravity to hold us against the
curved floor. It's that constant
whirly feeling that gets me. I get
sick on merry-go-rounds, too.
They're having pork for dinner
today. Not me.
October 2, 1960
Feeling much
better today.
Kroger gave me a box of Dramamine
pills. He says they'll help my
stomach. So far, so good.
Lloyd came by, also. "You play
chess?" he asked.
"A little," I admitted.
"How about a game sometime?"
"Sure," I said. "Do you have a
board?"
He didn't.
Lloyd went away then, but the
interview wasn't wasted. I learned
that he
is
tall and
does
have a
freckled face. Maybe we can build
a chessboard. With my paper and
his ballpoint pen and ruler, it should
be easy. Don't know what we'll use
for pieces, though.
Jones (I still haven't learned his
first name) has been up with the
pilot all day. He passed my room
on the way to the galley (the
kitchen) for a cup of dark brown
coffee (they like it thick) and told
me that we were almost past the
Moon. I asked to look, but he said
not yet; the instrument panel is
Top Secret. They'd have to cover
it so I could look out the viewing
screen, and they still need it for
steering or something.
I still haven't met the pilot.
October 3, 1960
Well, I've
met the pilot. He is
kind of squat, with a vulturish neck
and close-set jet-black eyes that
make him look rather mean, but he
was pleasant enough, and said I
could call him Pat. I still don't
know Jones' first name, though Pat
spoke to him, and it sounded like
Flants. That can't be right.
Also, I am one of the first five
men in the history of the world to
see the opposite side of the Moon,
with a bluish blurred crescent beyond
it that Pat said was the Earth.
The back of the Moon isn't much
different from the front. As to the
space in front of the ship, well, it's
all black with white dots in it, and
none of the dots move, except in a
circle that Pat says is a "torque"
result from the gyroscopic spin
we're in. Actually, he explained to
me, the screen is supposed to keep
the image of space locked into
place no matter how much we spin.
But there's some kind of a "drag."
I told him I hoped it didn't mean
we'd land on Mars upside down. He
just stared at me.
I can't say I was too impressed
with that 16 x 19 view of outer
space. It's been done much better
in the movies. There's just no awesomeness
to it, no sense of depth or
immensity. It's as impressive as a
piece of velvet with salt sprinkled
on it.
Lloyd and I made a chessboard
out of a carton. Right now we're using
buttons for men. He's one of
these fast players who don't stop
and think out their moves. And so
far I haven't won a game.
It looks like a long trip.
October 4, 1960
I won
a game. Lloyd mistook my
queen-button for my bishop-button
and left his king in jeopardy, and
I checkmated him next move. He
said chess was a waste of time
and he had important work to do
and he went away.
I went to the galley for coffee
and had a talk about moss with
Kroger. He said there was a good
chance of lichen on Mars, and I
misunderstood and said, "A good
chance of liking
what
on Mars?"
and Kroger finished his coffee and
went up front.
When I got back to my compartment,
Lloyd had taken away the
chessboard and all his buttons. He
told me later he needed it to back
up a star map.
Pat slept mostly all day in his
compartment, and Jones sat and
watched the screen revolve. There
wasn't much to do, so I wrote a
poem, sort of.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With Martian rime, Venusian slime,
And a radioactive hoe.
I showed it to Kroger. He says
it may prove to be environmentally
accurate, but that I should stick to
prose.
October 5, 1960
Learned Jones'
first name.
He wrote something in the ship's
log, and I saw his signature. His
name is Fleance, like in "Macbeth."
He prefers to be called Jones. Pat
uses his first name as a gag. Some
fun.
And only 255 days to go.
April 1, 1961
I've skipped
over the last 177
days or so, because there's nothing
much new. I brought some books
with me on the trip, books that I'd
always meant to read and never
had the time. So now I know all
about
Vanity Fair
,
Pride and Prejudice
,
War and Peace
,
Gone with
the Wind
, and
Babbitt
.
They didn't take as long as I
thought they would, except for
Vanity Fair
. It must have been a
riot when it first came out. I mean,
all those sly digs at the aristocracy,
with copious interpolations by Mr.
Thackeray in case you didn't get
it when he'd pulled a particularly
good gag. Some fun.
And only 78 days to go.
June 1, 1961
Only 17 days
to go. I saw Mars
on the screen today. It seems to be
descending from overhead, but Pat
says that that's the "torque" doing
it. Actually, it's we who are coming
in sideways.
We've all grown beards, too. Pat
said it was against regulations, but
what the hell. We have a contest.
Longest whiskers on landing gets a
prize.
I asked Pat what the prize was
and he told me to go to hell.
June 18, 1961
Mars has
the whole screen
filled. Looks like Death Valley. No
sign of canals, but Pat says that's
because of the dust storm down below.
It's nice to have a "down below"
again. We're going to land, so
I have to go to my bunk. It's all
foam rubber, nylon braid supports
and magnesium tubing. Might as
well be cement for all the good it
did me at takeoff. Earth seems awfully
far away.
June 19, 1961
Well, we're down.
We have
to wear gas masks with oxygen
hook-ups. Kroger says the air is
breathable, but thin, and it has too
much dust in it to be any fun to
inhale. He's all for going out and
looking for lichen, but Pat says he's
got to set up camp, then get instructions
from Earth. So we just have
to wait. The air is very cold, but the
Sun is hot as hell when it hits you.
The sky is a blinding pink, or maybe
more of a pale fuchsia. Kroger
says it's the dust. The sand underfoot
is kind of rose-colored, and not
really gritty. The particles are
round and smooth.
No lichen so far. Kroger says
maybe in the canals, if there are
any canals. Lloyd wants to play
chess again.
Jones won the beard contest. Pat
gave him a cigar he'd smuggled on
board (no smoking was allowed on
the ship), and Jones threw it away.
He doesn't smoke.
June 20, 1961
Got lost today.
Pat told me
not to go too far from camp, so,
when I took a stroll, I made sure
every so often that I could still see
the rocket behind me. Walked for
maybe an hour; then the oxygen
gauge got past the halfway mark,
so I started back toward the rocket.
After maybe ten steps, the rocket
disappeared. One minute it was
standing there, tall and silvery, the
next instant it was gone.
Turned on my radio pack and
got hold of Pat. Told him what happened,
and he told Kroger. Kroger
said I had been following a mirage,
to step back a bit. I did, and I could
see the ship again. Kroger said to
try and walk toward where the ship
seemed to be, even when it wasn't
in view, and meantime they'd come
out after me in the jeep, following
my footprints.
Started walking back, and the
ship vanished again. It reappeared,
disappeared, but I kept going. Finally
saw the real ship, and Lloyd
and Jones waving their arms at me.
They were shouting through their
masks, but I couldn't hear them.
The air is too thin to carry sound
well.
All at once, something gleamed
in their hands, and they started
shooting at me with their rifles.
That's when I heard the noise behind
me. I was too scared to turn
around, but finally Jones and Lloyd
came running over, and I got up
enough nerve to look. There was
nothing there, but on the sand,
paralleling mine, were footprints.
At least I think they were footprints.
Twice as long as mine, and
three times as wide, but kind of
featureless because the sand's loose
and dry. They doubled back on
themselves, spaced considerably
farther apart.
"What was it?" I asked Lloyd
when he got to me.
"Damned if I know," he said. "It
was red and scaly, and I think it
had a tail. It was two heads taller
than you." He shuddered. "Ran off
when we fired."
"Where," said Jones, "are Pat and
Kroger?"
I didn't know. I hadn't seen
them, nor the jeep, on my trip back.
So we followed the wheel tracks for
a while, and they veered off from
my trail and followed another, very
much like the one that had been
paralleling mine when Jones and
Lloyd had taken a shot at the scaly
thing.
"We'd better get them on the
radio," said Jones, turning back
toward the ship.
There wasn't anything on the
radio but static.
Pat and Kroger haven't come
back yet, either.
June 21, 1961
We're not
alone here. More of
the scaly things have come toward
the camp, but a few rifle shots send
them away. They hop like kangaroos
when they're startled. Their
attitudes aren't menacing, but their
appearance is. And Jones says,
"Who knows what's 'menacing' in
an alien?"
We're going to look for Kroger
and Pat today. Jones says we'd better
before another windstorm blows
away the jeep tracks. Fortunately,
the jeep has a leaky oil pan, so we
always have the smears to follow,
unless they get covered up, too.
We're taking extra oxygen, shells,
and rifles. Food, too, of course.
And we're locking up the ship.
It's later
, now. We found the
jeep, but no Kroger or Pat. Lots of
those big tracks nearby. We're taking
the jeep to follow the aliens'
tracks. There's some moss around
here, on reddish brown rocks that
stick up through the sand, just on
the shady side, though. Kroger
must be happy to have found his
lichen.
The trail ended at the brink of
a deep crevice in the ground. Seems
to be an earthquake-type split in
solid rock, with the sand sifting
over this and the far edge like pink
silk cataracts. The bottom is in the
shade and can't be seen. The crack
seems to extend to our left and
right as far as we can look.
There looks like a trail down the
inside of the crevice, but the Sun's
setting, so we're waiting till tomorrow
to go down.
Going down was Jones' idea,
not mine.
June 22, 1961
Well, we're
at the bottom, and
there's water here, a shallow stream
about thirty feet wide that runs
along the center of the canal (we've
decided we're in a canal). No sign
of Pat or Kroger yet, but the sand
here is hard-packed and damp, and
there are normal-size footprints
mingled with the alien ones, sharp
and clear. The aliens seem to have
six or seven toes. It varies from
print to print. And they're barefoot,
too, or else they have the damnedest-looking
shoes in creation.
The constant shower of sand
near the cliff walls is annoying, but
it's sandless (shower-wise) near
the stream, so we're following the
footprints along the bank. Also, the
air's better down here. Still thin,
but not so bad as on the surface.
We're going without masks to save
oxygen for the return trip (Jones
assures me there'll
be
a return
trip), and the air's only a little bit
sandy, but handkerchiefs over nose
and mouth solve this.
We look like desperadoes, what
with the rifles and covered faces. I
said as much to Lloyd and he told
me to shut up. Moss all over the
cliff walls. Swell luck for Kroger.
We've found
Kroger and Pat,
with the help of the aliens. Or maybe
I should call them the Martians.
Either way, it's better than what
Jones calls them.
They took away our rifles and
brought us right to Kroger and Pat,
without our even asking. Jones is
mad at the way they got the rifles so
easily. When we came upon them
(a group of maybe ten, huddling
behind a boulder in ambush), he
fired, but the shots either bounced
off their scales or stuck in their
thick hides. Anyway, they took the
rifles away and threw them into the
stream, and picked us all up and
took us into a hole in the cliff wall.
The hole went on practically forever,
but it didn't get dark. Kroger
tells me that there are phosphorescent
bacteria living in the mold on
the walls. The air has a fresh-dug-grave
smell, but it's richer in oxygen
than even at the stream.
We're in a small cave that is just
off a bigger cave where lots of tunnels
come together. I can't remember
which one we came in through,
and neither can anyone else. Jones
asked me what the hell I kept writing
in the diary for, did I want to
make it a gift to Martian archeologists?
But I said where there's life
there's hope, and now he won't talk
to me. I congratulated Kroger on
the lichen I'd seen, but he just said
a short and unscientific word and
went to sleep.
There's a Martian guarding the
entrance to our cave. I don't know
what they intend to do with us.
Feed us, I hope. So far, they've just
left us here, and we're out of rations.
Kroger tried talking to the guard
once, but he (or it) made a whistling
kind of sound and flashed a
mouthful of teeth. Kroger says the
teeth are in multiple rows, like a
tiger shark's. I'd rather he hadn't
told me.
June 23, 1961, I think
We're either
in a docket or a
zoo. I can't tell which. There's a
rather square platform surrounded
on all four sides by running water,
maybe twenty feet across, and
we're on it. Martians keep coming
to the far edge of the water and
looking at us and whistling at each
other. A little Martian came near
the edge of the water and a larger
Martian whistled like crazy and
dragged it away.
"Water must be dangerous to
them," said Kroger.
"We shoulda brought water pistols,"
Jones muttered.
Pat said maybe we can swim to
safety. Kroger told Pat he was
crazy, that the little island we're on
here underground is bordered by a
fast river that goes into the planet.
We'd end up drowned in some grotto
in the heart of the planet, says
Kroger.
"What the hell," says Pat, "it's
better than starving."
It is not.
June 24, 1961, probably
I'm hungry
. So is everybody
else. Right now I could eat a dinner
raw, in a centrifuge, and keep it
down. A Martian threw a stone at
Jones today, and Jones threw one
back at him and broke off a couple
of scales. The Martian whistled
furiously and went away. When the
crowd thinned out, same as it did
yesterday (must be some sort of
sleeping cycle here), Kroger talked
Lloyd into swimming across the
river and getting the red scales.
Lloyd started at the upstream part
of the current, and was about a hundred
yards below this underground
island before he made the far side.
Sure is a swift current.
But he got the scales, walked
very far upstream of us, and swam
back with them. The stream sides
are steep, like in a fjord, and we
had to lift him out of the swirling
cold water, with the scales gripped
in his fist. Or what was left of the
scales. They had melted down in
the water and left his hand all
sticky.
Kroger took the gummy things,
studied them in the uncertain light,
then tasted them and grinned.
The Martians are made of sugar.
Later, same day
. Kroger
said that the Martian metabolism
must be like Terran (Earth-type)
metabolism, only with no pancreas
to make insulin. They store their
energy on the
outside
of their
bodies, in the form of scales. He's
watched them more closely and
seen that they have long rubbery
tubes for tongues, and that they
now and then suck up water from
the stream while they're watching
us, being careful not to get their lips
(all sugar, of course) wet. He
guesses that their "blood" must be
almost pure water, and that it
washes away (from the inside, of
course) the sugar they need for
energy.
I asked him where the sugar
came from, and he said probably
their bodies isolated carbon from
something (he thought it might be
the moss) and combined it with
the hydrogen and oxygen in the
water (even
I
knew the formula for
water) to make sugar, a common
carbohydrate.
Like plants, on Earth, he said.
Except, instead of using special
cells on leaves to form carbohydrates
with the help of sunpower,
as Earth plants do in photosynthesis
(Kroger spelled that word
for me), they used the
shape
of the
scales like prisms, to isolate the
spectra (another Kroger word)
necessary to form the sugar.
"I don't get it," I said politely,
when he'd finished his spiel.
"Simple," he said, as though he
were addressing me by name.
"They have a twofold reason to fear
water. One: by complete solvency
in that medium, they lose all energy
and die. Two: even partial sprinkling
alters the shape of the scales,
and they are unable to use sunpower
to form more sugar, and still die,
if a bit slower."
"Oh," I said, taking it down verbatim.
"So now what do we do?"
"We remove our boots," said
Kroger, sitting on the ground and
doing so, "and then we cross this
stream, fill the boots with water,
and
spray
our way to freedom."
"Which tunnel do we take?"
asked Pat, his eyes aglow at the
thought of escape.
Kroger shrugged. "We'll have to
chance taking any that seem to
slope upward. In any event, we can
always follow it back and start
again."
"I dunno," said Jones. "Remember
those
teeth
of theirs. They must
be for biting something more substantial
than moss, Kroger."
"We'll risk it," said Pat. "It's better
to go down fighting than to die
of starvation."
The hell it is.
June 24, 1961, for sure
The Martians
have coal
mines.
That's
what they use those
teeth for. We passed through one
and surprised a lot of them chewing
gritty hunks of anthracite out
of the walls. They came running at
us, whistling with those tubelike
tongues, and drooling dry coal dust,
but Pat swung one of his boots in
an arc that splashed all over the
ground in front of them, and they
turned tail (literally) and clattered
off down another tunnel,
sounding like a locomotive whistle
gone berserk.
We made the surface in another
hour, back in the canal, and were
lucky enough to find our own trail
to follow toward the place above
which the jeep still waited.
Jones got the rifles out of the
stream (the Martians had probably
thought they were beyond recovery
there) and we found the jeep. It
was nearly buried in sand, but we
got it cleaned off and running, and
got back to the ship quickly. First
thing we did on arriving was to
break out the stores and have a
celebration feast just outside the
door of the ship.
It was pork again, and I got sick.
June 25, 1961
We're going back
. Pat says
that a week is all we were allowed
to stay and that it's urgent to return
and tell what we've learned
about Mars (we know there are
Martians, and they're made of
sugar).
"Why," I said, "can't we just tell
it on the radio?"
"Because," said Pat, "if we tell
them now, by the time we get back
we'll be yesterday's news. This way
we may be lucky and get a parade."
"Maybe even money," said
Kroger, whose mind wasn't always
on science.
"But they'll ask why we didn't
radio the info, sir," said Jones uneasily.
"The radio," said Pat, nodding to
Lloyd, "was unfortunately broken
shortly after landing."
Lloyd blinked, then nodded
back and walked around the
rocket. I heard a crunching sound
and the shattering of glass, not unlike
the noise made when one
drives a rifle butt through a radio.
Well, it's time for takeoff.
This time
it wasn't so bad. I
thought I was getting my space-legs,
but Pat says there's less gravity on
Mars, so escape velocity didn't
have to be so fast, hence a smoother
(relatively) trip on our shock-absorbing
bunks.
Lloyd wants to play chess again.
I'll be careful not to win this time.
However, if I don't win, maybe this
time
I'll
be the one to quit.
Kroger is busy in his cramped
lab space trying to classify the little
moss he was able to gather, and
Jones and Pat are up front watching
the white specks revolve on that
black velvet again.
Guess I'll take a nap.
June 26, 1961
Hell's bells
. Kroger says
there are two baby Martians loose
on board ship. Pat told him he
was nuts, but there are certain
signs he's right. Like the missing
charcoal in the air-filtration-and-reclaiming
(AFAR) system. And
the water gauges are going down.
But the clincher is those two sugar
crystals Lloyd had grabbed up
when we were in that zoo. They're
gone.
Pat has declared a state of emergency.
Quick thinking, that's Pat.
Lloyd, before he remembered and
turned scarlet, suggested we radio
Earth for instructions. We can't.
Here we are, somewhere in a
void headed for Earth, with enough
air and water left for maybe three
days—if the Martians don't take
any more.
Kroger is thrilled that he is
learning something, maybe, about
Martian reproductive processes.
When he told Pat, Pat put it to a
vote whether or not to jettison
Kroger through the airlock. However,
it was decided that responsibility
was pretty well divided.
Lloyd had gotten the crystals,
Kroger had only studied them, and
Jones had brought them aboard.
So Kroger stays, but meanwhile
the air is getting worse. Pat suggested
Kroger put us all into a state
of suspended animation till landing
time, eight months away. Kroger
said, "How?"
June 27, 1961
Air is foul
and I'm very
thirsty. Kroger says that at least—when
the Martians get bigger—they'll
have to show themselves.
Pat says what do we do
then
? We
can't afford the water we need to
melt them down. Besides, the
melted crystals might
all
turn into
little Martians.
Jones says he'll go down spitting.
Pat says why not dismantle interior
of rocket to find out where
they're holing up? Fine idea.
How do you dismantle riveted
metal plates?
June 28, 1961
The AFAR system
is no more
and the water gauges are still dropping.
Kroger suggests baking bread,
then slicing it, then toasting it till
it turns to carbon, and we can use
the carbon in the AFAR system.
We'll have to try it, I guess.
The Martians
ate the bread.
Jones came forward to tell us the
loaves were cooling, and when he
got back they were gone. However,
he did find a few of the red crystals
on the galley deck (floor). They're
good-sized crystals, too. Which
means so are the Martians.
Kroger says the Martians must
be intelligent, otherwise they
couldn't have guessed at the carbohydrates
present in the bread after
a lifelong diet of anthracite. Pat
says let's jettison Kroger.
This time the vote went against
Kroger, but he got a last-minute reprieve
by suggesting the crystals
be pulverized and mixed with sulphuric
acid. He says this'll produce
carbon.
I certainly hope so.
So does Kroger.
Brief reprieve
for us. The
acid-sugar combination not only
produces carbon but water vapor,
and the gauge has gone up a notch.
That means that we have a quart
of water in the tanks for drinking.
However, the air's a bit better,
and we voted to let Kroger stay inside
the rocket.
Meantime, we have to catch
those Martians.
June 29, 1961
Worse and worse
. Lloyd
caught one of the Martians in the
firing chamber. We had to flood
the chamber with acid to subdue
the creature, which carbonized
nicely. So now we have plenty of
air and water again, but besides
having another Martian still on
the loose, we now don't have
enough acid left in the fuel tanks
to make a landing.
Pat says at least our vector will
carry us to Earth and we can die
on our home planet, which is better
than perishing in space.
The hell it is.
March 3, 1962
Earth in sight
. The other
Martian is still with us. He's where
we can't get at him without blow-torches,
but he can't get at the carbon
in the AFAR system, either,
which is a help. However, his tail
is prehensile, and now and then it
snakes out through an air duct and
yanks food right off the table from
under our noses.
Kroger says watch out.
We
are
made of carbohydrates, too. I'd
rather not have known.
March 4, 1962
Earth fills
the screen in the
control room. Pat says if we're
lucky, he might be able to use the
bit of fuel we have left to set us
in a descending spiral into one of
the oceans. The rocket is tighter
than a submarine, he insists, and
it will float till we're rescued, if
the plates don't crack under the impact.
We all agreed to try it. Not that
we thought it had a good chance of
working, but none of us had a better
idea.
I guess
you know the rest of
the story, about how that destroyer
spotted us and got us and
my diary aboard, and towed the
rocket to San Francisco. News of
the "captured Martian" leaked out,
and we all became nine-day wonders
until the dismantling of the
rocket.
Kroger says he must have dissolved
in the water, and wonders
what
that
would do. There are
about a thousand of those crystal-scales
on a Martian.
So last week we found out, when
those red-scaled things began clambering
out of the sea on every coastal
region on Earth. Kroger tried
to explain to me about salinity osmosis
and hydrostatic pressure and
crystalline life, but in no time at all
he lost me.
The point is, bullets won't stop
these things, and wherever a crystal
falls, a new Martian springs up
in a few weeks. It looks like the
five of us have abetted an invasion
from Mars.
Needless to say, we're no longer
heroes.
I haven't heard from Pat or
Lloyd for a week. Jones was picked
up attacking a candy factory yesterday,
and Kroger and I were allowed
to sign on for the flight to
Venus scheduled within the next
few days—because of our experience.
Kroger says there's only enough
fuel for a one-way trip. I don't care.
I've always wanted to travel with
the President.
—JACK SHARKEY
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/8/4/26843//26843-h//26843-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why can't the crew radio the Earth for help? | 26843_JEQCNBC3_8 | [
"Kroger broke the radio.",
"Jones broke the radio.",
"Lloyd broke the radio.",
"Pat broke the radio."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How many comanalysis sessions can someone undergo in one day? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_1 | [
"Four",
"Two",
"One",
"Three"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does Bergstrom feel about Zarwell? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_2 | [
"Bergstrom thinks Zarwell is a dangerous man. He is thinking about turning Zarwell over to the authorities.",
"Bergstrom thinks Zarwell is a very sick and confused individual. He is going to have Zarwell committed.",
"Bergstrom hates Zarwell. He is planning to kill Zarwell during the next therapy session.",
"Bergstrom admires Zarwell. He wants Zarwell to help him plan a government revolution."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does the comanalysis process work? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_3 | [
"The patient is drugged and put in a wave machine so that they can relax and get insomnia relief.",
"The patient is drugged and experiences hallucinations to help cope with past trauma.",
"The patient is drugged to put them in a relaxed state so that they can recover lost memories.",
"The patient is drugged and put in a sponge-like material. This makes the patient relaxed enough to sleep and dream."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does Zarwell feel about Bergstrom? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_4 | [
"Zarwell is afraid of Bergstrom. The dreams induced by Bergstrom's drugs grow more and more disturbing.",
"Zarwell is suspicious of Bergstrom. Bergstrom always seems to be uncomfortable in Zarwell's presence.",
"Zarwell is suspicious of Bergstrom. He's sure Bergstrom has been tampering with his memories.",
"Zarwell thinks Bergstrom is an alright guy. However, Zarwell isn't interested in making friends. He just wants to retire in anonymity."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why doesn't Bergstrom alert the authorities that he has a wanted criminal, drugged and unconscious in his office? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_5 | [
"Bergstrom is Zarwell's partner and is wants Zarwell to regain his memories.",
"Bergstrom is a fan of Zarwell. He thinks Zarwell would overthrow the current dictatorship if Zarwell could regain his memories.",
"Bergstrom is afraid Zarwell might wake early and kill him before the authorities arrive.",
"Bergstrom wants Zarwell to meet with some people to overthrow the current dictatorship."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is Bergstrom's relationship with Johnson? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_6 | [
"Johnson is the dictator of St. Martin's where Bergstrom lives.",
"Johnson is the client paying Bergstrom to retrieve \nZarwell's memories.",
"Johnson is the man Bergstrom wants Zarwell to help overthrow the dictator.",
"Johnson is Bergstrom's boss."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How did Zarwell lose his memories? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_7 | [
"A soldier hit Zarwell in the head with the butt of a gun, leaving him with amnesia.",
"Zarwell was knocked unconscious when a building collapsed around him. He awoke with amnesia.",
"Zarwell had his memories removed so he could get out of the revolution business.",
"A bullet grazed Zarwell's head during the last revolution, leaving him with amnesia."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why doesn't Zarwell shoot Bergstrom? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_8 | [
"Zarwell may have been a killer in the old life, but not now.",
"Zarwell is trying to start a new life. He doesn't want to kill anymore.",
"Zarwell is a freedom fighter, not a cold-blooded killer.",
"Zarwell likes Bergstrom. They are friends."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
26,569 | 26569_CEKEK4QL | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Monkey On His Back | 1954.0 | De Vet, Charles V. | Short stories; Psychological fiction; Science fiction; PS | Transcriber’s note:
This story was published in
Galaxy
magazine, June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
[p
135
]
By CHARLES V. DE VET
monkey on his back
Under the cloud of cast-off identities
lay the shape of another man—
was it himself?
Illustrated by DILLON
HE was walking endlessly
down a long, glass-walled
corridor. Bright sunlight
slanted in through one wall, on the
blue knapsack across his shoulders.
Who he was, and what he was doing
here, was clouded. The truth lurked
in some corner of his consciousness,
but it was not reached by surface
awareness.
The corridor opened at last into
a large high-domed room, much
like a railway station or an air terminal.
He walked straight ahead.
At the sight of him a man leaning
negligently against a stone pillar,
to his right but within vision,
straightened and barked an order
to him, “Halt!” He lengthened his
stride but gave no other sign.
[p
136
]
Two men hurried through a
doorway of a small anteroom to his
left, calling to him. He turned away
and began to run.
Shouts and the sound of charging
feet came from behind him. He
cut to the right, running toward the
escalator to the second floor. Another
pair of men were hurrying
down, two steps at a stride. With
no break in pace he veered into an
opening beside the escalator.
At the first turn he saw that the
aisle merely circled the stairway,
coming out into the depot again on
the other side. It was a trap. He
glanced quickly around him.
At the rear of the space was a
row of lockers for traveler use. He
slipped a coin into a pay slot,
opened the zipper on his bag and
pulled out a flat briefcase. It took
him only a few seconds to push the
case into the compartment, lock it
and slide the key along the floor
beneath the locker.
There was nothing to do after
that—except wait.
The men pursuing him came
hurtling around the turn in the
aisle. He kicked his knapsack to
one side, spreading his feet wide
with an instinctive motion.
Until that instant he had intended
to fight. Now he swiftly
reassessed the odds. There were
five of them, he saw. He should be
able to incapacitate two or three
and break out. But the fact that
they had been expecting him meant
that others would very probably
be waiting outside. His best course
now was to sham ignorance. He
relaxed.
He offered no resistance as they
reached him.
They were not gentle men. A tall
ruffian, copper-brown face damp
with perspiration and body oil,
grabbed him by the jacket and
slammed him back against the
lockers. As he shifted his weight
to keep his footing someone drove
a fist into his face. He started to
raise his hands; and a hard flat
object crashed against the side of
his skull.
The starch went out of his legs.
“D
O you make anything out of
it?” the psychoanalyst Milton
Bergstrom, asked.
John Zarwell shook his head.
“Did I talk while I was under?”
“Oh, yes. You were supposed to.
That way I follow pretty well what
you’re reenacting.”
“How does it tie in with what I
told you before?”
Bergstrom’s neat-boned, fair-skinned
face betrayed no emotion
other than an introspective stillness
of his normally alert gaze. “I see
no connection,” he decided, his
words once again precise and meticulous.
“We don’t have enough to
go on. Do you feel able to try another
comanalysis this afternoon
yet?”
“I don’t see why not.” Zarwell
[p
137
]
opened the collar of his shirt. The
day was hot, and the room had no
air conditioning, still a rare luxury
on St. Martin’s. The office window
was open, but it let in no freshness,
only the mildly rank odor that pervaded
all the planet’s habitable
area.
“Good.” Bergstrom rose. “The
serum is quite harmless, John.” He
maintained a professional diversionary
chatter as he administered
the drug. “A scopolamine derivative
that’s been well tested.”
The floor beneath Zarwell’s feet
assumed abruptly the near transfluent
consistency of a damp
sponge. It rose in a foot-high wave
and rolled gently toward the far
wall.
Bergstrom continued talking,
with practiced urbanity. “When
psychiatry was a less exact science,”
his voice went on, seeming to come
from a great distance, “a doctor
had to spend weeks, sometimes
months or years interviewing a
patient. If he was skilled enough,
he could sort the relevancies from
the vast amount of chaff. We are
able now, with the help of the
serum, to confine our discourses to
matters cogent to the patient’s
trouble.”
The floor continued its transmutation,
and Zarwell sank deep into
viscous depths. “Lie back and relax.
Don’t …”
The words tumbled down from
above. They faded, were gone.
ZARWELL found himself
standing on a vast plain. There was
no sky above, and no horizon in the
distance. He was in a place without
space or dimension. There was
nothing here except himself—and
the gun that he held in his hand.
A weapon beautiful in its efficient
simplicity.
He should know all about the
instrument, its purpose and workings,
but he could not bring his
thoughts into rational focus. His
forehead creased with his mental
effort.
Abruptly the unreality about
him shifted perspective. He was
approaching—not walking, but
merely shortening the space between
them—the man who held
the gun. The man who was himself.
The other “himself” drifted
nearer also, as though drawn by a
mutual attraction.
The man with the gun raised his
weapon and pressed the trigger.
With the action the perspective
shifted again. He was watching the
face of the man he shot jerk and
twitch, expand and contract. The
face was unharmed, yet it was no
longer the same. No longer his own
features.
The stranger face smiled approvingly
at him.
“O
DD,” Bergstrom said.
He brought his hands up and joined
the tips of his fingers against his
chest. “But it’s another piece in the
[p
138
]
jig-saw. In time it will fit into
place.” He paused. “It means no
more to you than the first, I suppose?”
“No,” Zarwell answered.
He was not a talking man, Bergstrom
reflected. It was more than
reticence, however. The man had
a hard granite core, only partially
concealed by his present perplexity.
He was a man who could handle
himself well in an emergency.
Bergstrom shrugged, dismissing
his strayed thoughts. “I expected
as much. A quite normal first phase
of treatment.” He straightened a
paper on his desk. “I think that will
be enough for today. Twice in one
sitting is about all we ever try.
Otherwise some particular episode
might cause undue mental stress,
and set up a block.” He glanced
down at his appointment pad. “Tomorrow
at two, then?”
Zarwell grunted acknowledgment
and pushed himself to his
feet, apparently unaware that his
shirt clung damply to his body.
THE sun was still high when
Zarwell left the analyst’s office.
The white marble of the city’s
buildings shimmered in the afternoon
heat, squat and austere as
giant tree trunks, pock-marked and
gray-mottled with windows. Zarwell
was careful not to rest his hand
on the flesh searing surface of the
stone.
The evening meal hour was approaching
when he reached the
Flats, on the way to his apartment.
The streets of the old section were
near-deserted. The only sounds he
heard as he passed were the occasional
cry of a baby, chronically
uncomfortable in the day’s heat,
and the lowing of imported cattle
waiting in a nearby shed to be
shipped to the country.
All St. Martin’s has a distinctive
smell, as of an arid dried-out
swamp, with a faint taint of fish.
But in the Flats the odor changes.
Here is the smell of factories, warehouses,
and trading marts; the smell
of stale cooking drifting from the
homes of the laborers and lower
class techmen who live there.
Zarwell passed a group of
smaller children playing a desultory
game of lic-lic for pieces of
candy and cigarettes. Slowly he
climbed the stairs of a stone flat.
He prepared a supper for himself
and ate it without either enjoyment
or distaste. He lay down, fully
clothed, on his bed. The visit to the
analyst had done nothing to dispel
his ennui.
[p
139
]
The next morning when Zarwell
awoke he lay for a moment, unmoving.
The feeling was there
again, like a scene waiting only to
be gazed at directly to be perceived.
It was as though a great wisdom
lay at the edge of understanding.
If he rested quietly it would
all come to him. Yet always, when
his mind lost its sleep-induced
[p
140
]
lethargy, the moment of near understanding
slipped away.
This morning, however, the sense
of disorientation did not pass with
full wakefulness. He achieved no
understanding, but the strangeness
did not leave as he sat up.
He gazed about him. The room
did not seem to be his own. The
furnishings, and the clothing he observed
in a closet, might have belonged
to a stranger.
He pulled himself from his blankets,
his body moving with mechanical
reaction. The slippers into
which he put his feet were larger
than he had expected them to be.
He walked about the small apartment.
The place was familiar, but
only as it would have been if he
had studied it from blueprints, not
as though he lived there.
The feeling was still with him
when he returned to the psychoanalyst.
THE scene this time was more
kaleidoscopic, less personal.
A village was being ravaged.
Men struggled and died in the
streets. Zarwell moved among
them, seldom taking part in the
individual clashes, yet a moving
force in the
conflict
.
The background changed. He
understood that he was on a different
world.
Here a city burned. Its resistance
was nearing its end. Zarwell was
riding a shaggy pony outside a high
wall surrounding the stricken metropolis.
He moved in and joined a
party of short, bearded men, directing
them as they battered at the
wall with a huge log mounted on a
many-wheeled truck.
The log broke a breach in the
concrete and the besiegers charged
through, carrying back the defenders
who sought vainly to plug the
gap. Soon there would be rioting
in the streets again, plundering and
killing.
Zarwell was not the leader of the
invaders, only a lesser figure in the
rebellion. But he had played a leading
part in the planning of the
strategy that led to the city’s fall.
The job had been well done.
Time passed, without visible
break in the panorama. Now Zarwell
was fleeing, pursued by the
same bearded men who had been
his comrades before. Still he moved
with the same firm purpose, vigilant,
resourceful, and well prepared
for the eventuality that had befallen.
He made his escape without
difficulty.
He alighted from a space ship on
still another world—another shift
in time—and the atmosphere of
conflict engulfed him.
Weary but resigned he accepted
it, and did what he had to do …
BERGSTROM was regarding
him with speculative scrutiny.
“You’ve had quite a past, apparently,”
he observed.
[p
141
]
Zarwell smiled with mild embarrassment.
“At least in my dreams.”
“Dreams?” Bergstrom’s eyes
widened in surprise. “Oh, I beg your
pardon. I must have forgotten to
explain. This work is so routine to
me that sometimes I forget it’s all
new to a patient. Actually what you
experienced under the drug were
not dreams. They were recollections
of real episodes from your
past.”
Zarwell’s expression became
wary. He watched Bergstrom
closely. After a minute, however,
he seemed satisfied, and he let himself
settle back against the cushion
of his chair. “I remember nothing
of what I saw,” he observed.
“That’s why you’re here, you
know,” Bergstrom answered. “To
help you remember.”
“But everything under the drug
is so …”
“Haphazard? That’s true. The
recall episodes are always purely
random, with no chronological sequence.
Our problem will be to reassemble
them in proper order
later. Or some particular scene may
trigger a complete memory return.
“It is my considered opinion,”
Bergstrom went on, “that your lost
memory will turn out to be no ordinary
amnesia. I believe we will find
that your mind has been tampered
with.”
“Nothing I’ve seen under the
drug fits into the past I do remember.”
“That’s what makes me so certain,”
Bergstrom said confidently.
“You don’t remember what we
have shown to be true. Conversely
then, what you think you remember
must be false. It must have been
implanted there. But we can go
into that later. For today I think
we have done enough. This episode
was quite prolonged.”
“I won’t have any time off again
until next week end,” Zarwell reminded
him.
“That’s right.” Bergstrom
thought for a moment. “We
shouldn’t let this hang too long.
Could you come here after work
tomorrow?”
“I suppose I could.”
“Fine,” Bergstrom said with satisfaction.
“I’ll admit I’m considerably
more than casually interested
in your case by this time.”
A WORK truck picked Zarwell
up the next morning and he
rode with a tech crew to the edge of
the reclam area. Beside the belt
bringing ocean muck from the converter
plant at the seashore his
bulldozer was waiting.
He took his place behind the
drive wheel and began working dirt
down between windbreakers anchored
in the rock. Along a makeshift
road into the badlands trucks
brought crushed lime and phosphorus
to supplement the ocean
sediment. The progress of life from
the sea to the land was a mechanical
[p
142
]
process of this growing world.
Nearly two hundred years ago,
when Earth established a colony on
St. Martin’s, the land surface of the
planet had been barren. Only its
seas thrived with animal and vegetable
life. The necessary machinery
and technicians had been supplied
by Earth, and the long struggle began
to fit the world for human
needs. When Zarwell arrived, six
months before, the vitalized area
already extended three hundred
miles along the coast, and sixty
miles inland. And every day the
progress continued. A large percentage
of the energy and resources
of the world were devoted to that
essential expansion.
The reclam crews filled and
sodded the sterile rock, planted
binding grasses, grain and trees, and
diverted rivers to keep it fertile.
When there were no rivers to divert
they blasted out springs and lakes
in the foothills to make their own.
Biologists developed the necessary
germ and insect life from what they
found in the sea. Where that failed,
they imported microorganisms
from Earth.
Three rubber-tracked crawlers
picked their way down from the
mountains until they joined the
road passing the belt. They were
loaded with ore that would be
smelted into metal for depleted
Earth, or for other colonies short
of minerals. It was St. Martin’s only
export thus far.
Zarwell pulled his sun helmet
lower, to better guard his hot, dry
features. The wind blew continuously
on St. Martin’s, but it furnished
small relief from the heat.
After its three-thousand-mile journey
across scorched sterile rock, it
sucked the moisture from a man’s
body, bringing a membrane-shrinking
dryness to the nostrils as it was
breathed in. With it came also the
cloying taste of limestone in a
worker’s mouth.
Zarwell gazed idly about at the
other laborers. Fully three-quarters
of them were beri-rabza ridden. A
cure for the skin fungus had not
yet been found; the men’s faces
and hands were scabbed and red.
The colony had grown to near self-sufficiency,
would soon have a moderate
prosperity, yet they still
lacked adequate medical and research
facilities.
Not all the world’s citizens were
content.
Bergstrom was waiting in his office
when Zarwell arrived that
evening.
HE was lying motionless on a
hard cot, with his eyes closed,
yet with his every sense sharply
quickened. Tentatively he tightened
small muscles in his arms and
legs. Across his wrists and thighs
he felt straps binding him to the
cot.
“So that’s our big, bad man,” a
coarse voice above him observed
[p
143
]
caustically. “He doesn’t look so
tough now, does he?”
“It might have been better to
kill him right away,” a second, less
confident voice said. “It’s supposed
to be impossible to hold him.”
“Don’t be stupid. We just do
what we’re told. We’ll hold him.”
“What do you think they’ll do
with him?”
“Execute him, I suppose,” the
harsh voice said matter-of-factly.
“They’re probably just curious to
see what he looks like first. They’ll
be disappointed.”
Zarwell opened his eyes a slit to
observe his surroundings.
It was a mistake. “He’s out of
it,” the first speaker said, and Zarwell
allowed his eyes to open fully.
The voice, he saw, belonged to
the big man who had bruised him
against the locker at the spaceport.
Irrelevantly he wondered how he
knew now that it had been a spaceport.
His captor’s broad face jeered
down at Zarwell. “Have a good
sleep?” he asked with mock solicitude.
Zarwell did not deign to acknowledge
that he heard.
The big man turned. “You can
tell the Chief he’s awake,” he said.
Zarwell followed his gaze to where
a younger man, with a blond lock of
hair on his forehead, stood behind
him. The youth nodded and went
out, while the other pulled a chair
up to the side of Zarwell’s cot.
While their attention was away
from him Zarwell had unobtrusively
loosened his bonds as much as
possible with arm leverage. As the
big man drew his chair nearer, he
made the hand farthest from him
tight and compact and worked it
free of the leather loop. He waited.
The big man belched. “You’re
supposed to be great stuff in a situation
like this,” he said, his smoke-tan
face splitting in a grin that revealed
large square teeth. “How
about giving me a sample?”
“You’re a yellow-livered bastard,”
Zarwell told him.
The grin faded from the oily face
as the man stood up. He leaned over
the cot—and Zarwell’s left hand
shot up and locked about his throat,
joined almost immediately by the
right.
The man’s mouth opened and he
tried to yell as he threw himself
frantically backward. He clawed at
the hands about his neck. When
that failed to break the grip he suddenly
reversed his weight and
drove his fist at Zarwell’s head.
Zarwell pulled the struggling
body down against his chest and
held it there until all agitated
movement ceased. He sat up then,
letting the body slide to the floor.
The straps about his thighs came
loose with little effort.
THE analyst dabbed at his upper
lip with a handkerchief. “The
episodes are beginning to tie together,”
he said, with an attempt at
[p
144
]
nonchalance. “The next couple
should do it.”
Zarwell did not answer. His
memory seemed on the point of
complete return, and he sat quietly,
hopefully. However, nothing more
came and he returned his attention
to his more immediate problem.
Opening a button on his shirt, he
pulled back a strip of plastic cloth
just below his rib cage and took
out a small flat pistol. He held it
in the palm of his hand. He knew
now why he always carried it.
Bergstrom had his bad moment.
“You’re not going to …” he began
at the sight of the gun. He tried
again. “You must be joking.”
“I have very little sense of humor,”
Zarwell corrected him.
“You’d be foolish!”
Bergstrom obviously realized
how close he was to death. Yet
surprisingly, after the first start,
he showed little fear. Zarwell had
thought the man a bit soft, too
adjusted to a life of ease and some
prestige to meet danger calmly.
Curiosity restrained his trigger finger.
“Why would I be foolish?” he
asked. “Your Meninger oath of inviolable
confidence?”
Bergstrom shook his head. “I
know it’s been broken before. But
you need me. You’re not through,
you know. If you killed me you’d
still have to trust some other
analyst.”
“Is that the best you can do?”
“No.” Bergstrom was angry now.
“But use that logical mind you’re
supposed to have! Scenes before
this have shown what kind of man
you are. Just because this last happened
here on St. Martin’s makes
little difference. If I was going to
turn you in to the police, I’d have
done it before this.”
Zarwell debated with himself the
truth of what the other had said.
“Why didn’t you turn me in?” he
asked.
“Because you’re no mad-dog
killer!” Now that the crisis seemed
to be past, Bergstrom spoke more
calmly, even allowed himself to
relax. “You’re still pretty much in
the fog about yourself. I read more
in those comanalyses than you did.
I even know who you are!”
Zarwell’s eyebrows raised.
“Who am I?” he asked, very interested
now. Without attention he
put his pistol away in a trouser
pocket.
Bergstrom brushed the question
aside with one hand. “Your name
makes little difference. You’ve used
many. But you are an idealist. Your
killings were necessary to bring
justice to the places you visited. By
now you’re almost a legend among
the human worlds. I’d like to talk
more with you on that later.”
While Zarwell considered, Bergstrom
pressed his advantage. “One
more scene might do it,” he said.
“Should we try again—if you trust
me, that is?”
[p
145
]
Zarwell made his decision quickly.
“Go ahead,” he answered.
ALL Zarwell’s attention seemed
on the cigar he lit as he rode
down the escalator, but he surveyed
the terminal carefully over the rim
of his hand. He spied no suspicious
loungers.
Behind the escalator he groped
along the floor beneath the lockers
until he found his key. The briefcase
was under his arm a minute
later.
In the basement lave he put a
coin in the pay slot of a private
compartment and went in.
As he zipped open the briefcase
he surveyed his features in the mirror.
A small muscle at the corner of
one eye twitched spasmodically.
One cheek wore a frozen quarter
smile. Thirty-six hours under the
paralysis was longer than advisable.
The muscles should be rested at
least every twenty hours.
Fortunately his natural features
would serve as an adequate disguise
now.
He adjusted the ring setting on
the pistol-shaped instrument that
he took from his case, and carefully
rayed several small areas of
his face, loosening muscles that had
been tight too long. He sighed
gratefully when he finished, massaging
his cheeks and forehead with
considerable pleasure. Another
glance in the mirror satisfied him
with the changes that had been
made. He turned to his briefcase
again and exchanged the gun for
a small syringe, which he pushed
into a trouser pocket, and a single-edged
razor blade.
Removing his fiber-cloth jacket
he slashed it into strips with the
razor blade and flushed it down the
disposal bowl. With the sleeves of
his blouse rolled up he had the
appearance of a typical workman
as he strolled from the compartment.
Back at the locker he replaced
the briefcase and, with a wad of
gum, glued the key to the bottom
of the locker frame.
One step more. Taking the syringe
from his pocket, he plunged
the needle into his forearm and
tossed the instrument down a
waste chute. He took three more
steps and paused uncertainly.
When he looked about him it
was with the expression of a man
waking from a vivid dream.
“Q
UITE ingenious,” Graves
murmured admiringly. “You
had your mind already preconditioned
for the shot. But why would
you deliberately give yourself amnesia?”
“What better disguise than to
believe the part you’re playing?”
“A good man must have done
that job on your mind,” Bergstrom
commented. “I’d have hesitated to
try it myself. It must have taken a
lot of trust on your part.”
[p
146
]
“Trust and money,” Zarwell said
drily.
“Your memory’s back then?”
Zarwell nodded.
“I’m glad to hear that,” Bergstrom
assured him. “Now that
you’re well again I’d like to introduce
you to a man named Vernon
Johnson. This world …”
Zarwell stopped him with an upraised
hand. “Good God, man, can’t
you see the reason for all this? I’m
tired. I’m trying to quit.”
“Quit?” Bergstrom did not quite
follow him.
“It started on my home colony,”
Zarwell explained listlessly. “A
gang of hoods had taken over the
government. I helped organize a
movement to get them out. There
was some bloodshed, but it went
quite well. Several months later an
unofficial envoy from another
world asked several of us to give
them a hand on the same kind of
job. The political conditions there
were rotten. We went with him.
Again we were successful. It seems
I have a kind of genius for that
sort of thing.”
He stretched out his legs and regarded
them thoughtfully. “I
learned then the truth of Russell’s
saying: ‘When the oppressed win
their freedom they are as oppressive
as their former masters.’ When
they went bad, I opposed them.
This time I failed. But I escaped
again. I have quite a talent for that
also.
“I’m not a professional do-gooder.”
Zarwell’s tone appealed
to Bergstrom for understanding. “I
have only a normal man’s indignation
at injustice. And now I’ve done
my share. Yet, wherever I go, the
word eventually gets out, and I’m
right back in a fight again. It’s like
the proverbial monkey on my back.
I can’t get rid of it.”
He rose. “That disguise and
memory planting were supposed to
get me out of it. I should have
known it wouldn’t work. But this
time I’m not going to be drawn
back in! You and your Vernon
Johnson can do your own revolting.
I’m through!”
Bergstrom did not argue as he
left.
RESTLESSNESS drove Zarwell
from his flat the next day—a
legal holiday on St. Martin’s. At
a railed-off lot he stopped and loitered
in the shadow of an adjacent
building watching workmen drilling
an excavation for a new structure.
When a man strolled to his side
and stood watching the workmen,
he was not surprised. He waited for
the other to speak.
“I’d like to talk to you, if you
can spare a few minutes,” the
stranger said.
Zarwell turned and studied the
man without answering. He was
medium tall, with the body of an
athlete, though perhaps ten years
[p
147
]
beyond the age of sports. He had
a manner of contained energy.
“You’re Johnson?” he asked.
The man nodded.
Zarwell tried to feel the anger he
wanted to feel, but somehow it
would not come. “We have nothing
to talk about,” was the best he
could manage.
“Then will you just listen? After,
I’ll leave—if you tell me to.”
Against his will he found himself
liking the man, and wanting at least
to be courteous. He inclined his
head toward a curb wastebox with
a flat top. “Should we sit?”
Johnson smiled agreeably and
they walked over to the box and
sat down.
“When this colony was first
founded,” Johnson began without
preamble, “the administrative body
was a governor, and a council of
twelve. Their successors were to
be elected biennially. At first they
were. Then things changed. We
haven’t had an election now in the
last twenty-three years. St. Martin’s
is beginning to prosper. Yet
the only ones receiving the benefits
are the rulers. The citizens work
twelve hours a day. They are poorly
housed
, poorly fed, poorly clothed.
They …”
Zarwell found himself not listening
as Johnson’s voice went on. The
story was always the same. But why
did they always try to drag him into
their troubles?
Why hadn’t he chosen some
other world on which to hide?
The last question prompted a
new thought. Just why had he
chosen St. Martin’s? Was it only a
coincidence? Or had he,
subconsciously
at least, picked this particular
world? He had always
considered himself the unwilling
subject of glib persuaders … but
mightn’t some inner compulsion of
his own have put the monkey on his
back?
“… and we need your help.”
Johnson had finished his speech.
Zarwell gazed up at the bright
sky. He pulled in a long breath,
and let it out in a sigh.
“What are your plans so far?”
he asked wearily.
—
CHARLES V. DE VET
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/6/5/6/26569//26569-h//26569-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does Zarwell want to retire from overthrowing corrupt governments? | 26569_CEKEK4QL_9 | [
"Zarwell met the love of his life and wants to spend his days in peace.",
"Often the new government becomes just as oppressive as the old one.",
"Zarwell is getting too old to fight.",
"Zarwell has become ill and can no longer fight the good fight."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What was the Hanseatic League? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_1 | [
"A loose federation of coastal cities that worked together to promote trade.",
"A casual federation of cities that worked together to promote trade.",
"A league of cities by the sea that agreed to come to each other's aid with armed forces when necessary.",
"A leauge of merchants that worked together to promote trade."
] | 2 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | When did the Hanseatic League begin? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_2 | [
"The 1200s",
"The 1500s",
"The 1400s",
"The 1300s"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is a modern city that is large enough to be a city-state? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_3 | [
"Dublin",
"London",
"Trinidad",
"Glasgow"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is a potential risk of cities seceding from their nation-states? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_4 | [
"Rural areas may see a rapid economic decline.",
"Ideological differences between city and rural dwellers could grow farther and farther apart.",
"A food shortage could arise if the rural areas refuse to trade with the city that seceded.",
"Rural and city dwellers may decide to engage in warfare."
] | 3 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Why was the Hanseatic League not always accepted by locals? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_5 | [
"Hanse traders forced some local traders out of business because they could not compete.",
"Hanse merchants were given special privileges.",
"Hanse merchants were mostly foreign. No one likes foreigners.",
"Hanse merchants were mostly German. No one likes the Germans."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What did the Hanseatic League exchange other than commodities? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_6 | [
"Animals",
"Women",
"Weapons",
"Knowledge"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0028",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Where is the only Hanse House left in Britain? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_7 | [
"London",
"Lincolnshire",
"King's Lynn",
"Boston"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What would lead a city like London to seek independence? | 99917_0L3HWNB7_8 | [
"They choose modernity over mythology.",
"They want to deal with rational thinkers, not people going backward.",
"They want to remain in the EU.",
"They want free movement of people, capital, goods, and ideas."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
99,917 | 99917_0L3HWNB7 | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc | 2016.0 | Christopher Beanland | Magazine article | What cities in the post-Brexit era could learn from a 14th-century trading bloc
As you fly from the country now known as Germany to Britain, the coastal geography of northern European cities gently unfurls. You can see where the sea smacks into them, or where yawning estuaries unfold like funnels between green and brown city and choppy blue water. You can track the snaking rivers and canals that form unrepentant umbilical connections to the settlements set a little further inland.
By their nature cities along coasts and rivers developed so they could be open to trade with each other. From the middle of the 13th century, and for some 300 years after, many settlements dotted along this route formed the prosperous Hanseatic League, a European trading confederation of market towns, before the rise of the nation state led to its dissolution.
The Hanseatic League is not well known, and today it lives on most prominently in the name of the German national airline Lufthansa, literally the 'Hansa of the skies', whose planes you can look out of – and down towards the Hanseatic cities – on the short journeys between mainland Europe and Britain. The letters HH on the number plates of cars in Hamburg stand for Hansestadt Hamburg: another proud little memory of this hidden history.
In the traumatised atmosphere of post-Brexit Britain, it is worth remembering the Hanseatic League. It could point us towards new relationships between progressive city dwellers in a world that otherwise seems to be putting the brakes on modernity.
Despite some of Britain's Leave voters longing to inhabit a fantastical realm immune to foreign influence, the reality is patently very different to that. In the late 1300s, Chaucer wrote about characters travelling to Jerusalem, and others who came from Europe; and it was at exactly this point that the Hanseatic League slowly started to coalesce, eventually influencing our isles.
The League is most easily understood as a loose federation of cities that acted together in self-interest to promote trade. The Hanseatic cities developed their own legal system, and their armies came to one another's aid. Merchants who wanted to buy and sell and travel were taking the lead at a time when nation states were not fit for purpose: in the case of England or Denmark, leadership was too centralised and authoritarian, while in German-speaking lands a nation had yet to be formed.
We think of nations today as elemental almost, immovable. Yet look at any city of Mitteleuropa and you'll see the many different names it has had as borders and regimes have shifted with the sands of time. Nations come and go. Cities endure.
"It is often said that great cities survived great empires," says Cristina Ampatzidou, editor-in-chief of the Rotterdam-based online publishing platform Amateur Cities. "So it is not unrealistic to think of cities as discrete entities that compete and collaborate with each other, independently from the states to which they belong."
The cities involved in the Hanseatic League are found along the Baltic and North Sea coasts, and slightly inland too. The League stretched from Novgorod in the east – in what is now Russia – to London in the west. Tallinn, Riga, Gdańsk, Visby, Berlin, Cologne, Antwerp, Stockholm, Bergen, Kiel, Rostock, Dinant, Bruges, Turku, Groningen, Hanover, Wroclaw, Kaliningrad: all were involved at different stages in the Hanse's history, which ran on into the 1500s.
The League covered lands that today find themselves a part of the modern nations of Finland, Sweden, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Norway, Lithuania, Estonia and Latvia. It was a huge – and hugely ambitious – undertaking in the days when communications consisted of ink and paper and the only viable method of travel was by ship. Wood, fur, wool, silver, herring, cod and salt were the main items traded. But what was also exchanged was knowledge. In some ways it was an exercise in what we today call 'soft diplomacy'. There was no maniacal ruler overseeing things – merchants met and talked. They raised armies and waged war against kings who threatened their businesses and their freedoms and their peace.
There was a kind of proto-democracy at work. Professor Rainer Postel, of the Bundeswehr Universität (Germany's equivalent of Sandhurst military academy), has described the Hanse as "a community of interests without power politics". As David Abulafia, Professor of Mediterranean History at Cambridge points out, "The lack of an elaborate superstructure was one of the things that made the Hanse work. Having said that, one should recognise that Lübeck in particular dominated the League for long periods."
Lübeck was where the merchants most often met; and where renewed recent interest in the Hanse eventually led to Angela Merkel cutting the ribbon at the brand new European Hansemuseum in the city last year.
Germany today – multicultural, economically and culturally motoring, free and fair – seems like the ideal model for a modern European nation state. And part of that success lies in the gravitas the country has given to its Hanseatic history. For Germany is not a top-down country with one city unhealthily dominating as with France and Britain (regional economic inequalities have plagued Britain since the painful de-industrialisation of the 1980s, especially in the north). Germany respects federalism and its cities exist on a much more even keel. The way that Cologne, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Stuttgart all bring varied economic and cultural character to the party is pure Hanse. The former Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Berlin and Bremen have city state status within Germany, putting them on the same level as a whole region or 'land' like Bavaria or Brandenburg.
So how about a new Hanseatic League? I ask Benjamin Barber, senior fellow at New York's Fordham University. "I believe you will find there is a new Hanse," he says, "that constituted itself about 10 or 11 years ago – including many of the original Hanseatic League cities." Barber is founder of the Global Parliament of Mayors, which he describes as a kind of Hanse of all cities, not just European ports, which will give cities a global urban voice and a common platform for action. The parliament convenes for its inaugural session in The Hague in September.
"Cities both exist within nations and transcend nations. Their power lies not just in the extent of
de jure
autonomy ceded or granted by 'higher' levels of government," says Bruce Katz, centennial scholar at the Washington DC thinktank the Brookings Institution. "Rather, cities have de facto power, the result of larger market and demographic forces and environmental imperatives that value proximity, density, connectivity and quality. Smart nations will see themselves as partners to their cities, setting strong platforms for urban prosperity and devolving powers, where appropriate, to give cities the flexibility to perform… Dumb nations will continue to dictate from above, stifling market activity and urban potential."
But could we go further? Could cities like London declare independence from the UK? London's economy is larger than that of Scotland and Wales combined. "States will not vanish or surrender their waning sovereignty," says Benjamin Barber. "But cities will meet across frontiers and work together to solve problems. The objective is not an independent London or New York, but interdependent cities collaborating globally. And that is happening."
London's voters largely wanted to remain a part of the EU and to maintain the city's status as an entrepôt. There is clearly a widening chasm between urban and rural life at the heart of many nations. Visualisations of Austria's recent presidential election showed the issue clearly: the country's cities voted for the Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, while the the rural districts went for right-wing nationalist Norbert Hofer (whose legal challenge to the close result has resulted in a rerun being announced for October). And in the USA in November, it's likely that Trump voters will also come from rural areas and Clinton voters from the cities. City dwellers are finding ever more in common with the world's other city dwellers than with their countrymen 50 miles down the road.
Back in Britain, one of history's little oddities pops up on the east coast. Boston in Lincolnshire and King's Lynn in Norfolk were both forward-looking Hanseatic League towns that traded with far-flung ports and hosted foreign merchants. King's Lynn contains the only extantHanse House left in Britain (London's was knocked down to build Cannon Street Station in the 1800s). Yet in the EU referendum these two areas polled among the highest Leave votes of anywhere in the country.
"Things change," says LSE's Professor Tony Travers. "[King's Lynn] used to be very highly connected, but the economy moved on and left those trading ports like it in a different situation." Take, for example, the pivot towards the New World, with which trade made more sense from the west-coast ports like Bristol and Liverpool. While these boomed between the 1600s and 1800s, the Hanseatic ports declined and then died out. "One of the things that's interesting about the [referendum] decision is that it begs all sorts of questions about the future of the UK and its relationship with Europe; and of London and Scotland and their relationship with the rest of Europe. When the EU began as the EEC in the mid-20th century some saw it as a modern day Hanse. Now the EU seems to be waning, perhaps its successor will have to ape the Hanse even more."
For all its complex beauty, life can ultimately be reduced to a series of binary options: yes or no, stick or twist, in or out, innovation or stagnation, modernity or mythology. The referendum result was disappointing for many progressive observers because it felt like a step backwards. Despite being primarily about trade monopolies and money making, the Hanse was, in its way, an early stab at stepping forwards: it encompassed internationalism, rational thought, free trade, loose democratic institutions and, most crucially of all, movement.
The future, for many observers, can only be understood in terms of the free movement of people, capital, goods and ideas. It is this necessary movement, and its possible curtailment, that could be the spark that leads to cities like London to seek independence and parity with other world cities – rather than with the rural hinterlands of Britain.
Of course, cities seceding from their nation states would provide huge headaches for countries whose biggest economic driver had been removed – as well as likely deepening ideological differences between city and rural dwellers. Moreover, cities need the food the countryside provides.
Yet for all the potential pitfalls, city states can thrive. Look at Singapore, Hong Kong, or de facto city states like Dubai and Abu Dhabi. One of the most telling characteristics about these four – all of course former British imperial enclaves – is that they are utterly outward looking. To return to the sky analogy, it's the airlines of each of these (Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Emirates and Etihad) that open up each respective city to the world in the way that the machinery of the Hanse did on the Baltic Sea 600 years ago. And it's the unions each city makes with other places that also look thoroughly Hanseatic in character. A model for modern city states, then. But is it one that we want?
"The Hanseatic League was not always accepted by local citizens," says Cristina Ampatzidou, "because the privileges granted to the Hanse merchants were forcing local traders out of competition and many cities took steps to eliminate them. The reasons the countryside is turning to the right [globally] are not independent from cities turning increasingly into speculation machines for the profit of a happy few. It is basically these systemic contradictions that must be addressed before we resort to more isolationist ideas that would intensify the urban-rural political divide. The bottom line is not whether a contemporary Hanse-esque federation is possible, it probably is; but whether it is actually desirable."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/cities/the-resurgence-of-the-city-state | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | The Global Parliament of Mayors is a... | 99917_0L3HWNB7_9 | [
"...common platform for action.",
"...a monitor of culture and economic status.",
"...a kind of Hanse of all cities.",
"...a governing body like the UN."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0040",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What does the Tydeman tube do? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_1 | [
"The Tydeman tube is placed in the uterus near the baby's head. The tube opens into a soft silicone cup, which is placed on the part of the head that is exposed through the cervix. Pushing air in through the tube releases suction forces that may be holding the baby in place.",
"The Tydeman tube is placed in the uterus near the baby's head. The doctor can inflate or deflate the tube as necessary to help ease the baby out of the birth canal.",
"The Tydeman tube is placed in the uterus near the baby's head. The tube opens into a soft silicone cup, which is placed on the part of the head that is exposed through the cervix. Pulling air out through the tube releases suction forces that may be holding the baby in place.",
"The Tydeman tube is placed in the uterus near the baby's head. Pushing air in to inflate the tube keeps the umbilical cord from closing around the baby's neck."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is Desperate Debra? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_2 | [
"Desperate Debra is a training device obstetricians use to simulate delivering babies.",
"Desperate Debra is a training device obstetricians use to simulate delivering an impacted fetus.",
"Desperate Debra is a training device used to simulate cesarean deliveries.",
"Desperate Debra is a training device obstetricians use to simulate delivering a baby when the mother has preeclampsia."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What was Desperate Debra originally designed for? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_3 | [
"She was originally designed for autopsy simulations.",
"She was originally designed to test the Tyedeman tube.",
"She was originally designed as a crash test dummy.",
"She was originally designed for practicing CPR."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What percentage of cesarean births in the UK every year are classified as emergencies? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_4 | [
"Nearly one half",
"Nearly two thirds",
"Nearly one quarter",
"Nearly three quarters"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is one consequence caused by the concern over the increased number of babies born by cesarian? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_5 | [
"Mothers who chose cesarian delivery may be shunned.",
"Doctors may refuse to do a cesarian for fear of being sued.",
"Medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before resorting to surgery.",
"Doctors are warier about doing cesareans."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | When doing a cesarian for an impacted fetus, what might a doctor see? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_6 | [
"An arm",
"A shoulder",
"The torso",
"A leg"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | How often do doctors request a push-up during an unplanned cesarian? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_7 | [
"5 percent of deliveries",
"10 percent of deliveries",
"15 percent of deliveries",
"20 percent of deliveries"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What inspired Dr. Tydeman's device? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_8 | [
"The sound of a Wellington boot being pulled out of the mud.",
"The sound of the dentists' suction tube.",
"His own wife's emergency cesarian.",
"The sound of a Wellington boot being pulled out of quicksand."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What was Desperate Debra originally made of? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_9 | [
"Ballistics gel over a plastic tube scaffolding",
"Silicone over a plastic tube scaffolding",
"Latex over a plastic tube scaffolding",
"A neoprene wetsuit over a plastic tube scaffolding"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
99,912 | 99912_KL3NAVVE | 23 | 1,018 | misc-longshort | Obstetrics for beginners | 2017.0 | Geoff Watts | Magazine article | Obstetrics for beginners
It's my first go at delivering a baby by caesarean section – and the foetal head is impacted, jammed in its mother's pelvis. To be honest I'm struggling.
Incisions have been made in the lower part of the mother's abdomen and womb. I've pushed my gloved hand inside and managed to slide my fingers between the baby's head and the surrounding uterine tissue. But it's difficult. The baby is tightly wedged in. I've had to push hard to get my hand to the far side of its head, and even though I'm now cupping and grasping it in the approved manner, I can't seem to pull it out. Dare I grip its head more firmly? Dare I pull harder?
The baby's mother – she's called Debra – remains impassive throughout these agonised fumblings. Her face reveals nothing of what she may be feeling. But then Debra has no feelings. Indeed she has no face…
So you can stop worrying. Debra – Desperate Debra to use her full trade name – is a simulator designed to help doctors practise their skill at dealing with impacted foetuses: babies that get stuck trying to exit the womb by the normal route. She comprises the lower two thirds (ie from the mid-chest region downwards) of a life-sized but limbless female torso made of flesh-coloured silicone rubber. She comes with a vulva, a pre-cut incision in her abdomen and, most importantly, a uterus containing a foetal head that should, in the normal way of things, be free to emerge between her legs. But this fetus is going nowhere until an obstetrician – or in this case me – can successfully grasp and pull it out.
The clever and sophisticated simulator I'm playing with started life as a lash-up in an obstetrician's home workshop: a Heath Robinson-style contraption barely recognisable as a model of the human body. But it wasn't at that stage intended as a simulator for training medical staff. Its sole purpose was to test the effectiveness of a novel device called a Tydeman tube. Paradoxically, although the testing equipment, Debra, is now commercially available, the device it was intended to test has yet to reach the market.
The inventor of the tube and of Desperate Debra is Dr Graham Tydeman, a consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife. Only after he'd built Debra did he realise that she might serve a purpose beyond his original intention. His is a decade-long tale of inspired insights, thwarted aims and shifting purposes; but with a good outcome. Although the Tydeman tube is still in gestation, Desperate Debra herself is now thriving.
To understand the desperation of Debra and how the Tydeman tube might help to relieve it requires a brief foray into basic obstetric knowhow. Evolution has endowed us with heads proportionally so large that even when labour runs according to plan, the delivery process involves a bit of a squeeze. For the baby's head to get stuck on the way out may not be usual, but it's by no means a rarity.
The standard response is to perform a caesarean section. Every year some 160,000 babies are born in the UK this way, with almost two thirds of them classified as emergencies. One audit has suggested that roughly 8,000 babies get stuck and have to be delivered by caesarean at a stage when their mothers are fully dilated. "Some of the babies will be so close to coming out by the normal route," says Tydeman, "that it's then difficult to get them back up and remove them through the hole in the woman's tummy." Which women are most at risk of this setback seems to be largely unpredictable. "We just observe that it happens… It's been discussed in the medical literature since the 1940s, but until 10 years ago, and throughout my training and most of my life as a consultant, it wasn't really talked about."
Considering the universality of childbirth, impaction and the best way of dealing with it are topics that seem to have gone remarkably unstudied. "There are strong opinions about why it happens and what to do, but very little research evidence," says Tydeman, adding that many of these opinions are contradictory.
In a protracted birth that's destined to end with a caesarean, the longer the labour is allowed to go on before the obstetrician decides to intervene, the greater the likelihood that the baby's head will become impacted. However, concern over the rising number of babies born by caesarean has made doctors more wary of doing them – one consequence of which is that medical staff may allow a difficult birth to continue for longer before they resort to surgery. This could be boosting the frequency of impaction. But, again, no one is certain.
When obstetricians doing planned caesareans slice open a mother's womb, what they usually see is the baby's head. By slipping a hand round and below it they can easily guide the baby out. "When you do a caesarean for an impacted baby," says Tydeman, "you make the incision in the same place, but what you might come across is a shoulder because the baby's so much further down [the birth canal]." As I'd discovered for myself, sliding a hand around the baby's head is then far more difficult. "It makes your fingers hurt," says Tydeman. "It makes your pulse rate go up to about 200, and you break out in a sweat because know you've only got about five or 10 minutes before there are serious consequences. The clock is ticking."
If a baby's head is jammed down in the mother's pelvic region, common sense suggests that it might help if a second person gives a gentle backward push on the area of its head visible through the mother's dilated cervix. "In our unit," says Tydeman, "when the woman is fully dilated and you'd expect the baby to come out normally [but it doesn't]… a registrar will be asking for a push-up about one in five times." Although registrars are doctors still in training, they're nonetheless experienced; which suggests requests for push-ups during unplanned caesareans are far from uncommon. The Tydeman tube is a gadget intended to make this manoeuvre safer and more effective.
Creativity and innovation have many unlikely sources. What seems to have inspired Tydeman to develop his device was the characteristic sound of a Wellington boot being pulled free of wet, muddy ground: a slurpy, sucking, gurgling noise. When an impacted foetal head is pulled free of the uterus it's often accompanied by a similar sucking noise, the result of air rushing in between the obstetrician's fingers to fill the space vacated. "What occurred to me years ago was that if the air can't get in, why not put a tube up into the vagina so that it can get in from below the baby's head." From time to time, if he felt he felt the baby might stick, Tydeman would slip a length of sterile silicone tubing through the woman's vagina and up into the womb next to the baby's head. Allowing air in by this route would release any suction forces tending to hold it where it was.
Tydeman didn't do much with the idea until 10 years ago when one trainee, who was experiencing real difficulty getting heads out, prompted him to think again about the problem. Around the same time, he met professor of obstetrics Andrew Shennan and consultant midwife Annette Briley, both of the Women's Health Academic Centre at St Thomas's hospital. Between them they came up with a device – the Tydeman tube – to make pushing on the foetus more controlled while simultaneously releasing any vacuum that might be holding it in place.
The instrument is made up of a rigid plastic tube opening into a softer silicone cup. Pressure to the foetal head is applied using four pads projecting forward from the cup's interior. Holding the device by the tube, the user places the cup against the part of the head exposed through the dilated cervix, and presses. This pushes the baby back up into the uterus while releasing any suction pressure that may have been holding it, so allowing the obstetrician to extract it more easily. Because pressure is distributed equally between the four pads with a greater combined surface area than that of a user's fingertips, the risk of inadvertent damage is minimised.
The team found some money to employ a product designer who used computer-aided design technology and 3D printing to make a prototype. "We were at the point of getting one made in silicone," says Tydeman, "when we realised that before we started experimenting on women we really ought to test it on a simulator." No such simulator existed – so he decided to make one himself.
That Tydeman was able to do this comes as no great surprise once you've glanced at his website. His career may be rooted in medicine but his interests encompass sculpture, furniture making and much else. He works in wood, glass, metals and plastic. "I've got a big workshop with a lathe and a forge," he says. "I make stuff. I always have, ever since I was a child. My dad was a woodwork teacher, my mum was very creative with fabric."
Although tests carried out with the Debra prototype showed that the tube would work as intended, Tydeman and his colleagues then faced what he calls a kind of medical catch-22. "We had the tube finished about three years ago… but we were more interested in trying to save lives than selling a product. We thought that the right thing to do before commercialising it was to be sure we'd got the best design." They tried it on a dozen or so women in labour, and concluded that it did what it supposed to. But they held off trying to market it because they wanted to do more extensive, more rigorous clinical studies.
This presented a problem. "If you've applied for research money," says Tydeman, "but you've already got what seems to be a commercially viable design, potential funders are going to say that the company aiming to sell it should pay for the work." On the other hand, commercial interest is easier to drum up if you've already got evidence that a device is safe and effective.
That said, the team didn't want to leave the tube sitting on the shelf. So they eventually decided to go ahead and find a commercial partner willing to manufacture and market it. They have now identified one, and are fairly confident it will soon be in production. With sufficient users it should then be possible to compile factual – as opposed to anecdotal – evidence of benefit. Not ideal, Tydeman concedes, but the best they can do at present.
In the meantime, back to Desperate Debra: so named, Tydeman says, not after any particular person but because the appellation is memorably alliterative. He put together the original Debra in a weekend. The skin was made out of a neoprene wetsuit fixed to a scaffolding formed from plastic tubing he'd found 20 years ago in skip outside a Glasgow pub; the head was cast in silicone from a model he'd made in plasticine, and the rest comprised old springs and other bits of stuff lying around his workshop. "It wasn't actually that difficult," Tydeman says.
When originally conceived, remember, Debra was simply a means of testing the effectiveness of the tube. What she looked like was neither here nor there. It was only once Debra was reborn as a teaching aid that she needed sprucing up.
Tydeman can remember the exact moment when the idea of her having a greater role dawned on him. "I was on the sleeper train down from Scotland to London," he says. "Debra was with me because the first Tydeman tube had become available at St Thomas's… It was about midnight, I'd had my free whisky and I suddenly thought, 'Blow me! Even if the tube doesn't work, Debra could be useful as a teaching aid'."
The following morning, at St Thomas's, Tydeman asked a visiting professor of obstetrics to have a look at Debra and tell him what she thought. She put her hand into Debra's womb, grasped the foetal head and said it felt just like the real thing. "Terribly flattering," Tydeman laughs.
With a grant from the Guy's and St Thomas's Charity fund they made Debra more presentable. Tydeman showed the prototype to Adam Rouilly, an established company specialising in medical models and simulators. They were impressed. A year later, the first of Debra's smartened-up sisters was on the market.
In Debra as she is now, the precise extent and nature of her desperation can be fine-tuned according to need. The foetal head inside her uterus can be moved to mimic the various positions that an unborn baby may adopt. By tightening a spring inside Debra's body, it's also possible vary the degree of impaction from mild to so severe that the head is virtually impossible to extract. In this way she simulates the full range of difficulty that obstetricians are likely to encounter.
So how valuable in training medical staff is a simulator like this? Very, according to Annette Briley. Imagine it's the middle of the night and an unplanned emergency caesarean is required: "Some poor junior doctor might find himself trying to manage it on his own." To have practised the knack of extracting a firmly impacted baby from a simulator is lot better than first honing your skill on a real woman.
At St Thomas's, midwives in training also get an opportunity to practise on Debra. The chances that midwives will find themselves having to do the actual extraction of an infant are slim; but they're quite likely to be asked to help the obstetrician by pushing a stuck baby from below. Debra's anatomy allows them to practise this skill; and to learn where and how hard to push on the infant skull. "Any practice you've done in the cold light of day will help you stay calm and composed in an emergency, and that's what we're aiming for," says Briley.
It's still too soon to make a final judgement about Debra’s impact. "When we first brought Debra out," Briley recalls, "some of the really experienced professors said things like, 'We always managed without one. Why would you need this?' But ask them to have a go at using it and then they admit it's really good." Medicine as a whole has an oddly ambivalent relationship to innovation. Some new findings, techniques or equipment take years to penetrate the profession; others are seized upon immediately.
A proper study of the clinical effectiveness of the Tydeman tube will necessarily involve women giving birth. Assessing the value of Debra as a simulator didn't require human subjects; and the team has already conducted such a study. Thirty obstetricians, from three NHS maternity units and with varying levels of experience, took part. They all received a brief explanation of how Debra works, and were then asked to try a timed removal of the foetal head at three different levels of difficulty. Overall, 87 per cent reported that the simulator offered a realistic experience of dealing with an impacted head, and 93 per cent thought it would be valuable as a training device.
The use of simulators to teach technical skills is now common in medical schools. You can learn to sew up a knife wound, catheterise a bladder or intubate an airway. You can practise cardiopulmonary resuscitation or ear syringing or even go through the motions of a keyhole surgical procedure. The technology required to do these things may cost a few pounds, or tens of thousands. Either way, given that most of these devices were invented during the past three or four decades, it comes as something of a surprise to learn that simulation for medical purposes can be traced back as far as the Chinese Song dynasty of 960-1279 AD.
One of the treatments of choice in that era was, naturally, acupuncture. But how to teach tyro-acupuncturists where to place the needles? Simple. A life-size bronze statue dotted with small holes indicated the points of insertion. And how then to test the students' grasp of their subject? If the statute was hollow, filled with liquid and given an outer coating of wax to mask the holes, a correct needle insertion would be followed by a leak.
Given the universality of childbirth it's no surprise that, then as now, the womb turns out to be the most simulated of our organs. For the benefit of 18th-century midwives and doctors-in-training, the Bologna surgeon Giovanni Antonio Galli devised a birthing simulator comprising a glass uterus supported by an artificial pelvis and containing a flexible foetus. Trainees had to deliver the baby while wearing a blindfold. Only the tutor could witness the fumbling of their hands.
As the material for a convincing simulation, glass clearly has its drawbacks. But another 18th-century contraption used a pink cloth-covered mannequin comprising a female torso complete with genitalia, a set of implantable foetuses of various ages, and even – a real
coup de théâtre
, this – a facility for exuding suitably coloured liquids at the appropriate moment.
Oddly, as medicine became more scientific, most of these devices fell by the wayside. As an academic review of these and other devices has pointed out, much of the 20th century was something of Dark Ages for simulation. Its value in professional training has had to be rediscovered: an endeavour in which inventive people like Graham Tydeman, sometimes with workshops rich in discarded junk, are still fruitfully engaged.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/life-death/obstetrics-for-beginners | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | When was the earliest childbirth simulator developed? | 99912_KL3NAVVE_10 | [
"Sometime in the fourth century",
"Sometime in the eighteenth century",
"Sometime in the thirteenth century",
"Sometime in the first century"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0028",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,921 | 99921_KYHUJQWK | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Just another free soul | nan | Joi Ito | Essay | Just another free soul
In his foreword to the book, Lessig writes that you understand your subjects “by learning to see them in a certain way.” What is that certain way?
I think I’m trying to get a mental image of a person, certain
expressions, or what I think that person is about. I’m trying to capture
what I think they look like, which is many times a minority of their
typical expressions, or their typical stance. So, if I’m taking pictures
of Larry [Lessig], I want to have his signature hand gestures, and not
just random ones.
I think I’m trying to capture pictures of people that help others see
what they’re about. Some photographers will make someone look the way
the photographer wants them to look, and not the way they appear, so
they’ll pick the one picture out of 100 where the guy looks more
egotistical than he really is. Some photographers are almost medical,
and are going after a perfect portrait. I’m somewhere in between.
It’s amazing how many people will upload snapshots of people where the
pictures don’t look like them at all. To me, uploading a picture that is
not an easily recognizable picture of that person defeats the point,
which I’m working toward, to try to express who they are. On the other
hand, professional photographers usually have a subject whom they don’t
know personally, so they end up having to try to capture an image that
they’ve created based on who they think the person is or how they want
that person to appear. You know how sculptors often say that they’re
just freeing an image from a block? What I’m trying to do is free
someone’s soul from his or her image. There are a lot of things that
make this hard. A lot of people are uncomfortable in front of a camera,
or might make expressions that aren’t very natural for them. And if the
person is nervous, it’s very difficult to try to see what it is that
you’re trying to capture.
A lot of what I’m doing is, I just start shooting photos. After half an
hour of having their picture taken, people start to ignore you. Or I’ll
take pictures when I’m talking to people about what they’re doing, so
after a while they get distracted by the conversation and forget about
the camera. That’s something that I’m not perfect at, but I’m getting
better.
I think good photographers are also able to disarm people through
conversation, but still, it’s difficult to have a disarming conversation
with somebody you don’t know, or to make them laugh. Many times people
make a face for me that they wouldn’t make for a professional
photographer.
For instance, a board meeting picture, like the one with Eric Saltzman:
that was during a very tense discussion. I’ve found that people are at
their most animated at these kinds of meetings, and look the most alive
when they are under a lot of pressure, and super- focused. But usually
if an outsider is in the room, they won’t get into that. I mean, it
would be difficult for a cameraman to be in a room where a board is
having a heated debate.
But those are the things that I’m trying to capture, because most people
don’t get to see that. At the Creative Commons board meeting, Larry
asked me to put the camera away after awhile [laughs] because it was
distracting. We were having a very heated discussion and I was taking
all of these pictures. But he credited me later because afterward those
pictures turned out the best.
In your mind, what is a ‘Freesoul’ ?
A freesoul is somewhat of a pun. On the one hand it means you are free,
liberated. You, as a human spirit, are open. And then, it also has the
meaning that you are unencumbered legally, that you are free, as in
‘free software.’
There’s a paradox: with many people’s Wikipedia
articles to which I’ve contributed, when it comes to the picture, many
of these people don’t have any free photos of themselves on the web, so
while they are “notable” on Wikipedia, their images aren’t free of the
copyright of the photographer, or the institution who hired the
photographer to take the picture. Often, even the subject of the article
can’t make an image available to the Wikimedia/Wikipedia community.
This means that a lot of people who have a Net presence have a legally
encumbered Net presence. People who are invited to conferences get asked
all the time, “By the way, do you have a photo that we can use?” But
they don’t. By making these pictures available under a Creative Commons
license, now they do. This is solving the issue of legal freedom.
The third part of the pun is that, since I’m asking for a model release
from the subjects, I’m asking everyone to be much more open and giving
about their image than most people typically are. I’m giving, you’re
giving, we’re all giving to participate and to try to create this
wonderful work, and allow others to create derivative works.
Of course people can abuse that, just like they can abuse anything. But
I want people to see the value in sharing over the fear in sharing. The
fact is, it’s much more likely that somebody is going to use these
pictures for something positive, rather than for something negative. The
benefits greatly outweigh the risks. I think we spend way too much of
our lives worrying about the risks, at the cost of a lot of the
benefits.
This is a celebration of all of the people who are willing to give. In a
way, giving up your image and allowing anyone to use it: it’s the
ultimate gift. In one way it’s kind of vain. [laughs] But in another
way it’s wonderful. A Wikipedia article on some person but with no
picture is sad.
Besides Wikipedia, how do you imagine these photos being used?
They can be used in textbooks and in mainstream media articles about the
person. Now they can get a picture that represents the person, at least
from my perspective. That said, I shouldn’t be the only person doing
this. More people should do the same, and make the photographs available
freely. For one, I feel that “free” CC licensed photos have a much
higher chance of not disappearing. But I don’t know exactly how these
photos are going to be used, so in a sense I’m curious. For example,
recently I received the Harvard Berkman Center pamphlet. It was a report
of what they’re doing, and they also had a bunch of my pictures in
there. They all had attribution, and it made me feel really good. There
were pictures of different Berkman Center members that I had taken in
various places all over the world. I think that the subject is probably
happy with this, and I’m happy, and the Berkman Center’s happy because
they’re not all pictures of people sitting at desks in the Berkman
Center. There’s one more important thing: Creative Commons is great for
original creative works or derivative creative works, but when it
involves human images, it gets very complicated. We all know the Virgin
Mobile case, where Virgin used CC licensed images in an advertisement
without getting permission from the models, and got in trouble. What
we’re trying to do here is to expand beyond just copyright, to make it
more thorough from a legal perspective. It’s also an important
educational point, so people understand that, in addition to the
Creative Commons licenses, we need people to provide other rights in
cases where the law requires such rights to be cleared before reuse.
What have you learned about the people in these networks, just in the past year?
That’s a good question. I think that at least Creative Commons has
become much more mainstream. Creative Commons has moved from a fringy
academic discussion to a boardroom discussion. Yahoo announced that it
will be using Creative Commons for all of their basic infrastructure,
and integrating it all. Google has CC search in their advanced search.
Microsoft is working with CC as well and have a plug-in. Nine Inch Nails
released their album, Ghost, under a Creative Commons license. The list
goes on. Many people are asking: can you make money and share? The
answer is, yes. CC is becoming an important part of the business
discussion.
But one thing that happens when a movement like CC becomes a business
thing, is that a lot of the pioneers fade into the background, and it
becomes a part of industry. This happened to the Internet. And so while
you still have the core people who still remember and hold the torch for
the philosophical side, the Internet has become much more of a business.
Now, when you go to many Internet conferences, it’s mostly salesmen in
attendance.
I believe that the success of the Internet has two parts. The first part
is the market- driven business side, which has made the Internet
affordable and ubiquitous. The second part is the strong movement of
participants who fight to keep the Internet open and try to prevent the
business side from corrupting the fundamental elements that make the
Internet great. The Net Neutrality or Open Network discussion going on
right now is a good example of the importance of continuing to balance
these principles with business interests.
Similarly, I think that business interests can help make Creative
Commons ubiquitous and more easily accessible to everyone. However, I
think it’s important to remember to keep pushing to make content more
“free” and not allow businesses to use Creative Commons in exploitive or
destructive ways.
In addition to the business side, Creative Commons is being used by
educators to create open courseware around the world and in the area of
science and technology to promote sharing in research. And as of now, we
have the license ported to at least 44 jurisdictions, and the number of
countries with projects continues to grow. In many ways, the movement
outside of the United States has become much bigger than the movement in
the United States. Although the United States is still slightly farther
ahead in terms of commercialization, the size of the whole free culture
movement outside of the United States is huge now. The CC China Photo
exhibit was just amazing. There were some great
images, and a lot of the photographers were professionals. This is
beyond what anybody has done in the US. A lot of the progress that we’re
making is international.
What are your personal realizations or experiences?
Well, we’re all getting old, if you look at these pictures. But there’s
another thing, though, about this book: the number of
professional-quality amateurs has increased significantly due to the
importance of digital in both professional and high-end amateur
photography I hate to say it, a lot of people love the darkroom, but it
really feels like the death of the darkroom with this year.
With new 22 megapixel cameras coming in under $10,000, and Lightroom
and some of this software at a couple hundred dollars, it doesn’t really
make sense, except for particularly fussy artists, to do wet-work
anymore. If you’re a commercial photographer or a high-end amateur, you
can do anything you used to do in the darkroom. I think it has really
lowered the bar. I don’t know how that affects the industry directly,
but for me, it bridged a huge gap.
I used to be darkroom geek. I loved my darkroom, and even when I didn’t
have my darkroom anymore, I still was shooting 6x6 Hasselblad 120 film
and processing it in a special lab, and then digitizing it. For me, that
film was it. You could never get as good as medium-format film or
large-format film
At the time, the digital Hasselblad backs were too expensive, and were
still not as good as 8x10 film. So there was this whole period where the
darkroom was not all that exciting, but the digital wasn’t perfect. I
went through a limbo period. I had invested so much in my Hasselblad
system, and my Leica M6 set. I had bought the Leica R8, but I was
kicking myself because it was terrible. But then the Leica M8 came out,
and I bought one at the beginning of 2007. The M8 really got me to where
I could use my old gear, and it had enough megapixels to be as good as
some film.
Another way of saying it was that there was a gear breakthrough at the
beginning of last year. Okay, that’s pretty materialistic! So there was
a technology breakthrough, let’s call it that, that allowed me to switch
completely away from film, and I think this happened to a lot of
photographers. It caused an explosion of content and an increase in the
quality of content on sites like Flickr. It has
allowed amateurs to create a business model with professionals.
Interestingly, I think these new high-end amateurs are buying more
photography books and photographs and are probably providing an
increasing revenue stream for professional photographers. I think most
amateurs, including myself, are paying homage to the professionals and
not trying to “compete” with them.
Despite the existence of social software, what is still important about meeting people face-to-face?
For me, the right way to use a lot of the new social software is by
making it easier to spend more physical time with the people you like
best. Dopplr is a great example. When
I visit a city, I will see all of the people who are in the city at the
same time. When I went to London awhile ago, there were 47 people I knew
in London, and a huge percentage of those people don’t live there. I
would bet that more than half of the photos in this book are pictures of
friends, and they’re not in their hometown.
That’s the really interesting thing that is happening right now: it’s
really increasing your ability to spend quality time with, actually, a
smaller number of people. It allows you to actively filter. Your
meetings don’t have to be random. If I look at the list of people in
this book, although there are some obvious people missing whom I didn’t
see last year, probably met more of my friends last year, my real
friends, than I’ve met in any other year. I know my travels were crazy,
but I think that the online world has allowed me to do that.
What’s great about photography is that it captures the moment that I was
sharing with that person. It’s not just a connection on a social network
online, which is really pretty binary. I can look at all these photos
and remember exactly what we were doing, what we were eating, what we
were drinking, what we were talking about, and to me that’s a much more
rich experience.
It’s the combination of social software and photography. For me, reality
is “the present” plus what you remember from the past. I think this
project is really sharing memories with people. Blog posts contribute as
well, but to me photography is a really good way of doing that. When I
look at the expressions, I remember the moment and get a sense of
presence.
I think the main problem for me is the environmental impact of flying
around. Just as I never believed that we would have a paperless office,
being able to connect with people through social software mostly
increases your travel, it doesn’t decrease it. It is great because you
get to meet all these people. But it is bad for the environment, and bad
for our jet lag.
How would you characterize your contributions to free culture?
I think it’s mostly incremental. I think there is very little we
actually do all by ourselves, and I hate saying, “I did this” or “I did
that.” I think that in most cases, focusing on individual contributions
or achievements undervalues the importance of everyone else involved.
Having said that, I think my main contribution is probably in supporting
Creative Commons as a fan, board member, chairman of the board and now
CEO. I think CC has a significant role, and helping to keep it on track
and growing is probably the single most important role that I have in
Free Culture.
Specifically, I think that trying to keep an international focus and a
balance between business and the non-business elements of the movement
is essential. My job is to keep that focus and maintain that balance.
Also, CC needs to run smoothly as an organization and there is a lot of
operational work that we all need to do. My photography is a way for me
to participate in a small measure on the creative side of the Free
Culture movement, and helps me see things from that perspective as well.
However, I believe in emergent democracy and the importance of trying to
celebrate the community more than the heroes. Of course, I’m a huge fan
of Larry’s and I have great respect for the leaders of our movement. But
more than anything, I’m thankful for and respectful of all of the
participants who aren’t so well known and who are essential to moving
everything forward.
Personally, I don’t think it’s ultimately meaningful to talk about one
individual’s personal contribution to any movement. The real meaning is
in the whole movement. I’m just one participant. Just another free soul.
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/02-joi-ito-just-another-free-soul.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | How does the photographer capture their subjects in a certain way? | 99921_KYHUJQWK_1 | [
"They photograph subjects who are feeling very nervous. It makes the images more lively.",
"They photograph subjects who are unaware the photographer is in the room. It's the only way to get truly natural-looking photos.",
"They continually shoot photos while conversing with their subjects. This distracts the subjects from the camera and results in a subject looking very natural.",
"They photograph people when they are in high-pressure situations. The subjects look super focused in the photos."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,921 | 99921_KYHUJQWK | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Just another free soul | nan | Joi Ito | Essay | Just another free soul
In his foreword to the book, Lessig writes that you understand your subjects “by learning to see them in a certain way.” What is that certain way?
I think I’m trying to get a mental image of a person, certain
expressions, or what I think that person is about. I’m trying to capture
what I think they look like, which is many times a minority of their
typical expressions, or their typical stance. So, if I’m taking pictures
of Larry [Lessig], I want to have his signature hand gestures, and not
just random ones.
I think I’m trying to capture pictures of people that help others see
what they’re about. Some photographers will make someone look the way
the photographer wants them to look, and not the way they appear, so
they’ll pick the one picture out of 100 where the guy looks more
egotistical than he really is. Some photographers are almost medical,
and are going after a perfect portrait. I’m somewhere in between.
It’s amazing how many people will upload snapshots of people where the
pictures don’t look like them at all. To me, uploading a picture that is
not an easily recognizable picture of that person defeats the point,
which I’m working toward, to try to express who they are. On the other
hand, professional photographers usually have a subject whom they don’t
know personally, so they end up having to try to capture an image that
they’ve created based on who they think the person is or how they want
that person to appear. You know how sculptors often say that they’re
just freeing an image from a block? What I’m trying to do is free
someone’s soul from his or her image. There are a lot of things that
make this hard. A lot of people are uncomfortable in front of a camera,
or might make expressions that aren’t very natural for them. And if the
person is nervous, it’s very difficult to try to see what it is that
you’re trying to capture.
A lot of what I’m doing is, I just start shooting photos. After half an
hour of having their picture taken, people start to ignore you. Or I’ll
take pictures when I’m talking to people about what they’re doing, so
after a while they get distracted by the conversation and forget about
the camera. That’s something that I’m not perfect at, but I’m getting
better.
I think good photographers are also able to disarm people through
conversation, but still, it’s difficult to have a disarming conversation
with somebody you don’t know, or to make them laugh. Many times people
make a face for me that they wouldn’t make for a professional
photographer.
For instance, a board meeting picture, like the one with Eric Saltzman:
that was during a very tense discussion. I’ve found that people are at
their most animated at these kinds of meetings, and look the most alive
when they are under a lot of pressure, and super- focused. But usually
if an outsider is in the room, they won’t get into that. I mean, it
would be difficult for a cameraman to be in a room where a board is
having a heated debate.
But those are the things that I’m trying to capture, because most people
don’t get to see that. At the Creative Commons board meeting, Larry
asked me to put the camera away after awhile [laughs] because it was
distracting. We were having a very heated discussion and I was taking
all of these pictures. But he credited me later because afterward those
pictures turned out the best.
In your mind, what is a ‘Freesoul’ ?
A freesoul is somewhat of a pun. On the one hand it means you are free,
liberated. You, as a human spirit, are open. And then, it also has the
meaning that you are unencumbered legally, that you are free, as in
‘free software.’
There’s a paradox: with many people’s Wikipedia
articles to which I’ve contributed, when it comes to the picture, many
of these people don’t have any free photos of themselves on the web, so
while they are “notable” on Wikipedia, their images aren’t free of the
copyright of the photographer, or the institution who hired the
photographer to take the picture. Often, even the subject of the article
can’t make an image available to the Wikimedia/Wikipedia community.
This means that a lot of people who have a Net presence have a legally
encumbered Net presence. People who are invited to conferences get asked
all the time, “By the way, do you have a photo that we can use?” But
they don’t. By making these pictures available under a Creative Commons
license, now they do. This is solving the issue of legal freedom.
The third part of the pun is that, since I’m asking for a model release
from the subjects, I’m asking everyone to be much more open and giving
about their image than most people typically are. I’m giving, you’re
giving, we’re all giving to participate and to try to create this
wonderful work, and allow others to create derivative works.
Of course people can abuse that, just like they can abuse anything. But
I want people to see the value in sharing over the fear in sharing. The
fact is, it’s much more likely that somebody is going to use these
pictures for something positive, rather than for something negative. The
benefits greatly outweigh the risks. I think we spend way too much of
our lives worrying about the risks, at the cost of a lot of the
benefits.
This is a celebration of all of the people who are willing to give. In a
way, giving up your image and allowing anyone to use it: it’s the
ultimate gift. In one way it’s kind of vain. [laughs] But in another
way it’s wonderful. A Wikipedia article on some person but with no
picture is sad.
Besides Wikipedia, how do you imagine these photos being used?
They can be used in textbooks and in mainstream media articles about the
person. Now they can get a picture that represents the person, at least
from my perspective. That said, I shouldn’t be the only person doing
this. More people should do the same, and make the photographs available
freely. For one, I feel that “free” CC licensed photos have a much
higher chance of not disappearing. But I don’t know exactly how these
photos are going to be used, so in a sense I’m curious. For example,
recently I received the Harvard Berkman Center pamphlet. It was a report
of what they’re doing, and they also had a bunch of my pictures in
there. They all had attribution, and it made me feel really good. There
were pictures of different Berkman Center members that I had taken in
various places all over the world. I think that the subject is probably
happy with this, and I’m happy, and the Berkman Center’s happy because
they’re not all pictures of people sitting at desks in the Berkman
Center. There’s one more important thing: Creative Commons is great for
original creative works or derivative creative works, but when it
involves human images, it gets very complicated. We all know the Virgin
Mobile case, where Virgin used CC licensed images in an advertisement
without getting permission from the models, and got in trouble. What
we’re trying to do here is to expand beyond just copyright, to make it
more thorough from a legal perspective. It’s also an important
educational point, so people understand that, in addition to the
Creative Commons licenses, we need people to provide other rights in
cases where the law requires such rights to be cleared before reuse.
What have you learned about the people in these networks, just in the past year?
That’s a good question. I think that at least Creative Commons has
become much more mainstream. Creative Commons has moved from a fringy
academic discussion to a boardroom discussion. Yahoo announced that it
will be using Creative Commons for all of their basic infrastructure,
and integrating it all. Google has CC search in their advanced search.
Microsoft is working with CC as well and have a plug-in. Nine Inch Nails
released their album, Ghost, under a Creative Commons license. The list
goes on. Many people are asking: can you make money and share? The
answer is, yes. CC is becoming an important part of the business
discussion.
But one thing that happens when a movement like CC becomes a business
thing, is that a lot of the pioneers fade into the background, and it
becomes a part of industry. This happened to the Internet. And so while
you still have the core people who still remember and hold the torch for
the philosophical side, the Internet has become much more of a business.
Now, when you go to many Internet conferences, it’s mostly salesmen in
attendance.
I believe that the success of the Internet has two parts. The first part
is the market- driven business side, which has made the Internet
affordable and ubiquitous. The second part is the strong movement of
participants who fight to keep the Internet open and try to prevent the
business side from corrupting the fundamental elements that make the
Internet great. The Net Neutrality or Open Network discussion going on
right now is a good example of the importance of continuing to balance
these principles with business interests.
Similarly, I think that business interests can help make Creative
Commons ubiquitous and more easily accessible to everyone. However, I
think it’s important to remember to keep pushing to make content more
“free” and not allow businesses to use Creative Commons in exploitive or
destructive ways.
In addition to the business side, Creative Commons is being used by
educators to create open courseware around the world and in the area of
science and technology to promote sharing in research. And as of now, we
have the license ported to at least 44 jurisdictions, and the number of
countries with projects continues to grow. In many ways, the movement
outside of the United States has become much bigger than the movement in
the United States. Although the United States is still slightly farther
ahead in terms of commercialization, the size of the whole free culture
movement outside of the United States is huge now. The CC China Photo
exhibit was just amazing. There were some great
images, and a lot of the photographers were professionals. This is
beyond what anybody has done in the US. A lot of the progress that we’re
making is international.
What are your personal realizations or experiences?
Well, we’re all getting old, if you look at these pictures. But there’s
another thing, though, about this book: the number of
professional-quality amateurs has increased significantly due to the
importance of digital in both professional and high-end amateur
photography I hate to say it, a lot of people love the darkroom, but it
really feels like the death of the darkroom with this year.
With new 22 megapixel cameras coming in under $10,000, and Lightroom
and some of this software at a couple hundred dollars, it doesn’t really
make sense, except for particularly fussy artists, to do wet-work
anymore. If you’re a commercial photographer or a high-end amateur, you
can do anything you used to do in the darkroom. I think it has really
lowered the bar. I don’t know how that affects the industry directly,
but for me, it bridged a huge gap.
I used to be darkroom geek. I loved my darkroom, and even when I didn’t
have my darkroom anymore, I still was shooting 6x6 Hasselblad 120 film
and processing it in a special lab, and then digitizing it. For me, that
film was it. You could never get as good as medium-format film or
large-format film
At the time, the digital Hasselblad backs were too expensive, and were
still not as good as 8x10 film. So there was this whole period where the
darkroom was not all that exciting, but the digital wasn’t perfect. I
went through a limbo period. I had invested so much in my Hasselblad
system, and my Leica M6 set. I had bought the Leica R8, but I was
kicking myself because it was terrible. But then the Leica M8 came out,
and I bought one at the beginning of 2007. The M8 really got me to where
I could use my old gear, and it had enough megapixels to be as good as
some film.
Another way of saying it was that there was a gear breakthrough at the
beginning of last year. Okay, that’s pretty materialistic! So there was
a technology breakthrough, let’s call it that, that allowed me to switch
completely away from film, and I think this happened to a lot of
photographers. It caused an explosion of content and an increase in the
quality of content on sites like Flickr. It has
allowed amateurs to create a business model with professionals.
Interestingly, I think these new high-end amateurs are buying more
photography books and photographs and are probably providing an
increasing revenue stream for professional photographers. I think most
amateurs, including myself, are paying homage to the professionals and
not trying to “compete” with them.
Despite the existence of social software, what is still important about meeting people face-to-face?
For me, the right way to use a lot of the new social software is by
making it easier to spend more physical time with the people you like
best. Dopplr is a great example. When
I visit a city, I will see all of the people who are in the city at the
same time. When I went to London awhile ago, there were 47 people I knew
in London, and a huge percentage of those people don’t live there. I
would bet that more than half of the photos in this book are pictures of
friends, and they’re not in their hometown.
That’s the really interesting thing that is happening right now: it’s
really increasing your ability to spend quality time with, actually, a
smaller number of people. It allows you to actively filter. Your
meetings don’t have to be random. If I look at the list of people in
this book, although there are some obvious people missing whom I didn’t
see last year, probably met more of my friends last year, my real
friends, than I’ve met in any other year. I know my travels were crazy,
but I think that the online world has allowed me to do that.
What’s great about photography is that it captures the moment that I was
sharing with that person. It’s not just a connection on a social network
online, which is really pretty binary. I can look at all these photos
and remember exactly what we were doing, what we were eating, what we
were drinking, what we were talking about, and to me that’s a much more
rich experience.
It’s the combination of social software and photography. For me, reality
is “the present” plus what you remember from the past. I think this
project is really sharing memories with people. Blog posts contribute as
well, but to me photography is a really good way of doing that. When I
look at the expressions, I remember the moment and get a sense of
presence.
I think the main problem for me is the environmental impact of flying
around. Just as I never believed that we would have a paperless office,
being able to connect with people through social software mostly
increases your travel, it doesn’t decrease it. It is great because you
get to meet all these people. But it is bad for the environment, and bad
for our jet lag.
How would you characterize your contributions to free culture?
I think it’s mostly incremental. I think there is very little we
actually do all by ourselves, and I hate saying, “I did this” or “I did
that.” I think that in most cases, focusing on individual contributions
or achievements undervalues the importance of everyone else involved.
Having said that, I think my main contribution is probably in supporting
Creative Commons as a fan, board member, chairman of the board and now
CEO. I think CC has a significant role, and helping to keep it on track
and growing is probably the single most important role that I have in
Free Culture.
Specifically, I think that trying to keep an international focus and a
balance between business and the non-business elements of the movement
is essential. My job is to keep that focus and maintain that balance.
Also, CC needs to run smoothly as an organization and there is a lot of
operational work that we all need to do. My photography is a way for me
to participate in a small measure on the creative side of the Free
Culture movement, and helps me see things from that perspective as well.
However, I believe in emergent democracy and the importance of trying to
celebrate the community more than the heroes. Of course, I’m a huge fan
of Larry’s and I have great respect for the leaders of our movement. But
more than anything, I’m thankful for and respectful of all of the
participants who aren’t so well known and who are essential to moving
everything forward.
Personally, I don’t think it’s ultimately meaningful to talk about one
individual’s personal contribution to any movement. The real meaning is
in the whole movement. I’m just one participant. Just another free soul.
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/02-joi-ito-just-another-free-soul.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | How does the photographer feel about dark rooms? | 99921_KYHUJQWK_2 | [
"Darkrooms don't make sense anymore with today's technology.",
"They are a darkroom geek.",
"Darkrooms are not all that exciting.",
"Doing the wet work in the darkroom will always produce a superior picture."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
99,921 | 99921_KYHUJQWK | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Just another free soul | nan | Joi Ito | Essay | Just another free soul
In his foreword to the book, Lessig writes that you understand your subjects “by learning to see them in a certain way.” What is that certain way?
I think I’m trying to get a mental image of a person, certain
expressions, or what I think that person is about. I’m trying to capture
what I think they look like, which is many times a minority of their
typical expressions, or their typical stance. So, if I’m taking pictures
of Larry [Lessig], I want to have his signature hand gestures, and not
just random ones.
I think I’m trying to capture pictures of people that help others see
what they’re about. Some photographers will make someone look the way
the photographer wants them to look, and not the way they appear, so
they’ll pick the one picture out of 100 where the guy looks more
egotistical than he really is. Some photographers are almost medical,
and are going after a perfect portrait. I’m somewhere in between.
It’s amazing how many people will upload snapshots of people where the
pictures don’t look like them at all. To me, uploading a picture that is
not an easily recognizable picture of that person defeats the point,
which I’m working toward, to try to express who they are. On the other
hand, professional photographers usually have a subject whom they don’t
know personally, so they end up having to try to capture an image that
they’ve created based on who they think the person is or how they want
that person to appear. You know how sculptors often say that they’re
just freeing an image from a block? What I’m trying to do is free
someone’s soul from his or her image. There are a lot of things that
make this hard. A lot of people are uncomfortable in front of a camera,
or might make expressions that aren’t very natural for them. And if the
person is nervous, it’s very difficult to try to see what it is that
you’re trying to capture.
A lot of what I’m doing is, I just start shooting photos. After half an
hour of having their picture taken, people start to ignore you. Or I’ll
take pictures when I’m talking to people about what they’re doing, so
after a while they get distracted by the conversation and forget about
the camera. That’s something that I’m not perfect at, but I’m getting
better.
I think good photographers are also able to disarm people through
conversation, but still, it’s difficult to have a disarming conversation
with somebody you don’t know, or to make them laugh. Many times people
make a face for me that they wouldn’t make for a professional
photographer.
For instance, a board meeting picture, like the one with Eric Saltzman:
that was during a very tense discussion. I’ve found that people are at
their most animated at these kinds of meetings, and look the most alive
when they are under a lot of pressure, and super- focused. But usually
if an outsider is in the room, they won’t get into that. I mean, it
would be difficult for a cameraman to be in a room where a board is
having a heated debate.
But those are the things that I’m trying to capture, because most people
don’t get to see that. At the Creative Commons board meeting, Larry
asked me to put the camera away after awhile [laughs] because it was
distracting. We were having a very heated discussion and I was taking
all of these pictures. But he credited me later because afterward those
pictures turned out the best.
In your mind, what is a ‘Freesoul’ ?
A freesoul is somewhat of a pun. On the one hand it means you are free,
liberated. You, as a human spirit, are open. And then, it also has the
meaning that you are unencumbered legally, that you are free, as in
‘free software.’
There’s a paradox: with many people’s Wikipedia
articles to which I’ve contributed, when it comes to the picture, many
of these people don’t have any free photos of themselves on the web, so
while they are “notable” on Wikipedia, their images aren’t free of the
copyright of the photographer, or the institution who hired the
photographer to take the picture. Often, even the subject of the article
can’t make an image available to the Wikimedia/Wikipedia community.
This means that a lot of people who have a Net presence have a legally
encumbered Net presence. People who are invited to conferences get asked
all the time, “By the way, do you have a photo that we can use?” But
they don’t. By making these pictures available under a Creative Commons
license, now they do. This is solving the issue of legal freedom.
The third part of the pun is that, since I’m asking for a model release
from the subjects, I’m asking everyone to be much more open and giving
about their image than most people typically are. I’m giving, you’re
giving, we’re all giving to participate and to try to create this
wonderful work, and allow others to create derivative works.
Of course people can abuse that, just like they can abuse anything. But
I want people to see the value in sharing over the fear in sharing. The
fact is, it’s much more likely that somebody is going to use these
pictures for something positive, rather than for something negative. The
benefits greatly outweigh the risks. I think we spend way too much of
our lives worrying about the risks, at the cost of a lot of the
benefits.
This is a celebration of all of the people who are willing to give. In a
way, giving up your image and allowing anyone to use it: it’s the
ultimate gift. In one way it’s kind of vain. [laughs] But in another
way it’s wonderful. A Wikipedia article on some person but with no
picture is sad.
Besides Wikipedia, how do you imagine these photos being used?
They can be used in textbooks and in mainstream media articles about the
person. Now they can get a picture that represents the person, at least
from my perspective. That said, I shouldn’t be the only person doing
this. More people should do the same, and make the photographs available
freely. For one, I feel that “free” CC licensed photos have a much
higher chance of not disappearing. But I don’t know exactly how these
photos are going to be used, so in a sense I’m curious. For example,
recently I received the Harvard Berkman Center pamphlet. It was a report
of what they’re doing, and they also had a bunch of my pictures in
there. They all had attribution, and it made me feel really good. There
were pictures of different Berkman Center members that I had taken in
various places all over the world. I think that the subject is probably
happy with this, and I’m happy, and the Berkman Center’s happy because
they’re not all pictures of people sitting at desks in the Berkman
Center. There’s one more important thing: Creative Commons is great for
original creative works or derivative creative works, but when it
involves human images, it gets very complicated. We all know the Virgin
Mobile case, where Virgin used CC licensed images in an advertisement
without getting permission from the models, and got in trouble. What
we’re trying to do here is to expand beyond just copyright, to make it
more thorough from a legal perspective. It’s also an important
educational point, so people understand that, in addition to the
Creative Commons licenses, we need people to provide other rights in
cases where the law requires such rights to be cleared before reuse.
What have you learned about the people in these networks, just in the past year?
That’s a good question. I think that at least Creative Commons has
become much more mainstream. Creative Commons has moved from a fringy
academic discussion to a boardroom discussion. Yahoo announced that it
will be using Creative Commons for all of their basic infrastructure,
and integrating it all. Google has CC search in their advanced search.
Microsoft is working with CC as well and have a plug-in. Nine Inch Nails
released their album, Ghost, under a Creative Commons license. The list
goes on. Many people are asking: can you make money and share? The
answer is, yes. CC is becoming an important part of the business
discussion.
But one thing that happens when a movement like CC becomes a business
thing, is that a lot of the pioneers fade into the background, and it
becomes a part of industry. This happened to the Internet. And so while
you still have the core people who still remember and hold the torch for
the philosophical side, the Internet has become much more of a business.
Now, when you go to many Internet conferences, it’s mostly salesmen in
attendance.
I believe that the success of the Internet has two parts. The first part
is the market- driven business side, which has made the Internet
affordable and ubiquitous. The second part is the strong movement of
participants who fight to keep the Internet open and try to prevent the
business side from corrupting the fundamental elements that make the
Internet great. The Net Neutrality or Open Network discussion going on
right now is a good example of the importance of continuing to balance
these principles with business interests.
Similarly, I think that business interests can help make Creative
Commons ubiquitous and more easily accessible to everyone. However, I
think it’s important to remember to keep pushing to make content more
“free” and not allow businesses to use Creative Commons in exploitive or
destructive ways.
In addition to the business side, Creative Commons is being used by
educators to create open courseware around the world and in the area of
science and technology to promote sharing in research. And as of now, we
have the license ported to at least 44 jurisdictions, and the number of
countries with projects continues to grow. In many ways, the movement
outside of the United States has become much bigger than the movement in
the United States. Although the United States is still slightly farther
ahead in terms of commercialization, the size of the whole free culture
movement outside of the United States is huge now. The CC China Photo
exhibit was just amazing. There were some great
images, and a lot of the photographers were professionals. This is
beyond what anybody has done in the US. A lot of the progress that we’re
making is international.
What are your personal realizations or experiences?
Well, we’re all getting old, if you look at these pictures. But there’s
another thing, though, about this book: the number of
professional-quality amateurs has increased significantly due to the
importance of digital in both professional and high-end amateur
photography I hate to say it, a lot of people love the darkroom, but it
really feels like the death of the darkroom with this year.
With new 22 megapixel cameras coming in under $10,000, and Lightroom
and some of this software at a couple hundred dollars, it doesn’t really
make sense, except for particularly fussy artists, to do wet-work
anymore. If you’re a commercial photographer or a high-end amateur, you
can do anything you used to do in the darkroom. I think it has really
lowered the bar. I don’t know how that affects the industry directly,
but for me, it bridged a huge gap.
I used to be darkroom geek. I loved my darkroom, and even when I didn’t
have my darkroom anymore, I still was shooting 6x6 Hasselblad 120 film
and processing it in a special lab, and then digitizing it. For me, that
film was it. You could never get as good as medium-format film or
large-format film
At the time, the digital Hasselblad backs were too expensive, and were
still not as good as 8x10 film. So there was this whole period where the
darkroom was not all that exciting, but the digital wasn’t perfect. I
went through a limbo period. I had invested so much in my Hasselblad
system, and my Leica M6 set. I had bought the Leica R8, but I was
kicking myself because it was terrible. But then the Leica M8 came out,
and I bought one at the beginning of 2007. The M8 really got me to where
I could use my old gear, and it had enough megapixels to be as good as
some film.
Another way of saying it was that there was a gear breakthrough at the
beginning of last year. Okay, that’s pretty materialistic! So there was
a technology breakthrough, let’s call it that, that allowed me to switch
completely away from film, and I think this happened to a lot of
photographers. It caused an explosion of content and an increase in the
quality of content on sites like Flickr. It has
allowed amateurs to create a business model with professionals.
Interestingly, I think these new high-end amateurs are buying more
photography books and photographs and are probably providing an
increasing revenue stream for professional photographers. I think most
amateurs, including myself, are paying homage to the professionals and
not trying to “compete” with them.
Despite the existence of social software, what is still important about meeting people face-to-face?
For me, the right way to use a lot of the new social software is by
making it easier to spend more physical time with the people you like
best. Dopplr is a great example. When
I visit a city, I will see all of the people who are in the city at the
same time. When I went to London awhile ago, there were 47 people I knew
in London, and a huge percentage of those people don’t live there. I
would bet that more than half of the photos in this book are pictures of
friends, and they’re not in their hometown.
That’s the really interesting thing that is happening right now: it’s
really increasing your ability to spend quality time with, actually, a
smaller number of people. It allows you to actively filter. Your
meetings don’t have to be random. If I look at the list of people in
this book, although there are some obvious people missing whom I didn’t
see last year, probably met more of my friends last year, my real
friends, than I’ve met in any other year. I know my travels were crazy,
but I think that the online world has allowed me to do that.
What’s great about photography is that it captures the moment that I was
sharing with that person. It’s not just a connection on a social network
online, which is really pretty binary. I can look at all these photos
and remember exactly what we were doing, what we were eating, what we
were drinking, what we were talking about, and to me that’s a much more
rich experience.
It’s the combination of social software and photography. For me, reality
is “the present” plus what you remember from the past. I think this
project is really sharing memories with people. Blog posts contribute as
well, but to me photography is a really good way of doing that. When I
look at the expressions, I remember the moment and get a sense of
presence.
I think the main problem for me is the environmental impact of flying
around. Just as I never believed that we would have a paperless office,
being able to connect with people through social software mostly
increases your travel, it doesn’t decrease it. It is great because you
get to meet all these people. But it is bad for the environment, and bad
for our jet lag.
How would you characterize your contributions to free culture?
I think it’s mostly incremental. I think there is very little we
actually do all by ourselves, and I hate saying, “I did this” or “I did
that.” I think that in most cases, focusing on individual contributions
or achievements undervalues the importance of everyone else involved.
Having said that, I think my main contribution is probably in supporting
Creative Commons as a fan, board member, chairman of the board and now
CEO. I think CC has a significant role, and helping to keep it on track
and growing is probably the single most important role that I have in
Free Culture.
Specifically, I think that trying to keep an international focus and a
balance between business and the non-business elements of the movement
is essential. My job is to keep that focus and maintain that balance.
Also, CC needs to run smoothly as an organization and there is a lot of
operational work that we all need to do. My photography is a way for me
to participate in a small measure on the creative side of the Free
Culture movement, and helps me see things from that perspective as well.
However, I believe in emergent democracy and the importance of trying to
celebrate the community more than the heroes. Of course, I’m a huge fan
of Larry’s and I have great respect for the leaders of our movement. But
more than anything, I’m thankful for and respectful of all of the
participants who aren’t so well known and who are essential to moving
everything forward.
Personally, I don’t think it’s ultimately meaningful to talk about one
individual’s personal contribution to any movement. The real meaning is
in the whole movement. I’m just one participant. Just another free soul.
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/02-joi-ito-just-another-free-soul.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | How does the photographer contribute to free culture? | 99921_KYHUJQWK_3 | [
"They share their photos through Creative Commons.",
"They are a board member of Creative Commons.",
"They share their personal image through Creative Commons.",
"They are the CEO of Creative Commons."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,921 | 99921_KYHUJQWK | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Just another free soul | nan | Joi Ito | Essay | Just another free soul
In his foreword to the book, Lessig writes that you understand your subjects “by learning to see them in a certain way.” What is that certain way?
I think I’m trying to get a mental image of a person, certain
expressions, or what I think that person is about. I’m trying to capture
what I think they look like, which is many times a minority of their
typical expressions, or their typical stance. So, if I’m taking pictures
of Larry [Lessig], I want to have his signature hand gestures, and not
just random ones.
I think I’m trying to capture pictures of people that help others see
what they’re about. Some photographers will make someone look the way
the photographer wants them to look, and not the way they appear, so
they’ll pick the one picture out of 100 where the guy looks more
egotistical than he really is. Some photographers are almost medical,
and are going after a perfect portrait. I’m somewhere in between.
It’s amazing how many people will upload snapshots of people where the
pictures don’t look like them at all. To me, uploading a picture that is
not an easily recognizable picture of that person defeats the point,
which I’m working toward, to try to express who they are. On the other
hand, professional photographers usually have a subject whom they don’t
know personally, so they end up having to try to capture an image that
they’ve created based on who they think the person is or how they want
that person to appear. You know how sculptors often say that they’re
just freeing an image from a block? What I’m trying to do is free
someone’s soul from his or her image. There are a lot of things that
make this hard. A lot of people are uncomfortable in front of a camera,
or might make expressions that aren’t very natural for them. And if the
person is nervous, it’s very difficult to try to see what it is that
you’re trying to capture.
A lot of what I’m doing is, I just start shooting photos. After half an
hour of having their picture taken, people start to ignore you. Or I’ll
take pictures when I’m talking to people about what they’re doing, so
after a while they get distracted by the conversation and forget about
the camera. That’s something that I’m not perfect at, but I’m getting
better.
I think good photographers are also able to disarm people through
conversation, but still, it’s difficult to have a disarming conversation
with somebody you don’t know, or to make them laugh. Many times people
make a face for me that they wouldn’t make for a professional
photographer.
For instance, a board meeting picture, like the one with Eric Saltzman:
that was during a very tense discussion. I’ve found that people are at
their most animated at these kinds of meetings, and look the most alive
when they are under a lot of pressure, and super- focused. But usually
if an outsider is in the room, they won’t get into that. I mean, it
would be difficult for a cameraman to be in a room where a board is
having a heated debate.
But those are the things that I’m trying to capture, because most people
don’t get to see that. At the Creative Commons board meeting, Larry
asked me to put the camera away after awhile [laughs] because it was
distracting. We were having a very heated discussion and I was taking
all of these pictures. But he credited me later because afterward those
pictures turned out the best.
In your mind, what is a ‘Freesoul’ ?
A freesoul is somewhat of a pun. On the one hand it means you are free,
liberated. You, as a human spirit, are open. And then, it also has the
meaning that you are unencumbered legally, that you are free, as in
‘free software.’
There’s a paradox: with many people’s Wikipedia
articles to which I’ve contributed, when it comes to the picture, many
of these people don’t have any free photos of themselves on the web, so
while they are “notable” on Wikipedia, their images aren’t free of the
copyright of the photographer, or the institution who hired the
photographer to take the picture. Often, even the subject of the article
can’t make an image available to the Wikimedia/Wikipedia community.
This means that a lot of people who have a Net presence have a legally
encumbered Net presence. People who are invited to conferences get asked
all the time, “By the way, do you have a photo that we can use?” But
they don’t. By making these pictures available under a Creative Commons
license, now they do. This is solving the issue of legal freedom.
The third part of the pun is that, since I’m asking for a model release
from the subjects, I’m asking everyone to be much more open and giving
about their image than most people typically are. I’m giving, you’re
giving, we’re all giving to participate and to try to create this
wonderful work, and allow others to create derivative works.
Of course people can abuse that, just like they can abuse anything. But
I want people to see the value in sharing over the fear in sharing. The
fact is, it’s much more likely that somebody is going to use these
pictures for something positive, rather than for something negative. The
benefits greatly outweigh the risks. I think we spend way too much of
our lives worrying about the risks, at the cost of a lot of the
benefits.
This is a celebration of all of the people who are willing to give. In a
way, giving up your image and allowing anyone to use it: it’s the
ultimate gift. In one way it’s kind of vain. [laughs] But in another
way it’s wonderful. A Wikipedia article on some person but with no
picture is sad.
Besides Wikipedia, how do you imagine these photos being used?
They can be used in textbooks and in mainstream media articles about the
person. Now they can get a picture that represents the person, at least
from my perspective. That said, I shouldn’t be the only person doing
this. More people should do the same, and make the photographs available
freely. For one, I feel that “free” CC licensed photos have a much
higher chance of not disappearing. But I don’t know exactly how these
photos are going to be used, so in a sense I’m curious. For example,
recently I received the Harvard Berkman Center pamphlet. It was a report
of what they’re doing, and they also had a bunch of my pictures in
there. They all had attribution, and it made me feel really good. There
were pictures of different Berkman Center members that I had taken in
various places all over the world. I think that the subject is probably
happy with this, and I’m happy, and the Berkman Center’s happy because
they’re not all pictures of people sitting at desks in the Berkman
Center. There’s one more important thing: Creative Commons is great for
original creative works or derivative creative works, but when it
involves human images, it gets very complicated. We all know the Virgin
Mobile case, where Virgin used CC licensed images in an advertisement
without getting permission from the models, and got in trouble. What
we’re trying to do here is to expand beyond just copyright, to make it
more thorough from a legal perspective. It’s also an important
educational point, so people understand that, in addition to the
Creative Commons licenses, we need people to provide other rights in
cases where the law requires such rights to be cleared before reuse.
What have you learned about the people in these networks, just in the past year?
That’s a good question. I think that at least Creative Commons has
become much more mainstream. Creative Commons has moved from a fringy
academic discussion to a boardroom discussion. Yahoo announced that it
will be using Creative Commons for all of their basic infrastructure,
and integrating it all. Google has CC search in their advanced search.
Microsoft is working with CC as well and have a plug-in. Nine Inch Nails
released their album, Ghost, under a Creative Commons license. The list
goes on. Many people are asking: can you make money and share? The
answer is, yes. CC is becoming an important part of the business
discussion.
But one thing that happens when a movement like CC becomes a business
thing, is that a lot of the pioneers fade into the background, and it
becomes a part of industry. This happened to the Internet. And so while
you still have the core people who still remember and hold the torch for
the philosophical side, the Internet has become much more of a business.
Now, when you go to many Internet conferences, it’s mostly salesmen in
attendance.
I believe that the success of the Internet has two parts. The first part
is the market- driven business side, which has made the Internet
affordable and ubiquitous. The second part is the strong movement of
participants who fight to keep the Internet open and try to prevent the
business side from corrupting the fundamental elements that make the
Internet great. The Net Neutrality or Open Network discussion going on
right now is a good example of the importance of continuing to balance
these principles with business interests.
Similarly, I think that business interests can help make Creative
Commons ubiquitous and more easily accessible to everyone. However, I
think it’s important to remember to keep pushing to make content more
“free” and not allow businesses to use Creative Commons in exploitive or
destructive ways.
In addition to the business side, Creative Commons is being used by
educators to create open courseware around the world and in the area of
science and technology to promote sharing in research. And as of now, we
have the license ported to at least 44 jurisdictions, and the number of
countries with projects continues to grow. In many ways, the movement
outside of the United States has become much bigger than the movement in
the United States. Although the United States is still slightly farther
ahead in terms of commercialization, the size of the whole free culture
movement outside of the United States is huge now. The CC China Photo
exhibit was just amazing. There were some great
images, and a lot of the photographers were professionals. This is
beyond what anybody has done in the US. A lot of the progress that we’re
making is international.
What are your personal realizations or experiences?
Well, we’re all getting old, if you look at these pictures. But there’s
another thing, though, about this book: the number of
professional-quality amateurs has increased significantly due to the
importance of digital in both professional and high-end amateur
photography I hate to say it, a lot of people love the darkroom, but it
really feels like the death of the darkroom with this year.
With new 22 megapixel cameras coming in under $10,000, and Lightroom
and some of this software at a couple hundred dollars, it doesn’t really
make sense, except for particularly fussy artists, to do wet-work
anymore. If you’re a commercial photographer or a high-end amateur, you
can do anything you used to do in the darkroom. I think it has really
lowered the bar. I don’t know how that affects the industry directly,
but for me, it bridged a huge gap.
I used to be darkroom geek. I loved my darkroom, and even when I didn’t
have my darkroom anymore, I still was shooting 6x6 Hasselblad 120 film
and processing it in a special lab, and then digitizing it. For me, that
film was it. You could never get as good as medium-format film or
large-format film
At the time, the digital Hasselblad backs were too expensive, and were
still not as good as 8x10 film. So there was this whole period where the
darkroom was not all that exciting, but the digital wasn’t perfect. I
went through a limbo period. I had invested so much in my Hasselblad
system, and my Leica M6 set. I had bought the Leica R8, but I was
kicking myself because it was terrible. But then the Leica M8 came out,
and I bought one at the beginning of 2007. The M8 really got me to where
I could use my old gear, and it had enough megapixels to be as good as
some film.
Another way of saying it was that there was a gear breakthrough at the
beginning of last year. Okay, that’s pretty materialistic! So there was
a technology breakthrough, let’s call it that, that allowed me to switch
completely away from film, and I think this happened to a lot of
photographers. It caused an explosion of content and an increase in the
quality of content on sites like Flickr. It has
allowed amateurs to create a business model with professionals.
Interestingly, I think these new high-end amateurs are buying more
photography books and photographs and are probably providing an
increasing revenue stream for professional photographers. I think most
amateurs, including myself, are paying homage to the professionals and
not trying to “compete” with them.
Despite the existence of social software, what is still important about meeting people face-to-face?
For me, the right way to use a lot of the new social software is by
making it easier to spend more physical time with the people you like
best. Dopplr is a great example. When
I visit a city, I will see all of the people who are in the city at the
same time. When I went to London awhile ago, there were 47 people I knew
in London, and a huge percentage of those people don’t live there. I
would bet that more than half of the photos in this book are pictures of
friends, and they’re not in their hometown.
That’s the really interesting thing that is happening right now: it’s
really increasing your ability to spend quality time with, actually, a
smaller number of people. It allows you to actively filter. Your
meetings don’t have to be random. If I look at the list of people in
this book, although there are some obvious people missing whom I didn’t
see last year, probably met more of my friends last year, my real
friends, than I’ve met in any other year. I know my travels were crazy,
but I think that the online world has allowed me to do that.
What’s great about photography is that it captures the moment that I was
sharing with that person. It’s not just a connection on a social network
online, which is really pretty binary. I can look at all these photos
and remember exactly what we were doing, what we were eating, what we
were drinking, what we were talking about, and to me that’s a much more
rich experience.
It’s the combination of social software and photography. For me, reality
is “the present” plus what you remember from the past. I think this
project is really sharing memories with people. Blog posts contribute as
well, but to me photography is a really good way of doing that. When I
look at the expressions, I remember the moment and get a sense of
presence.
I think the main problem for me is the environmental impact of flying
around. Just as I never believed that we would have a paperless office,
being able to connect with people through social software mostly
increases your travel, it doesn’t decrease it. It is great because you
get to meet all these people. But it is bad for the environment, and bad
for our jet lag.
How would you characterize your contributions to free culture?
I think it’s mostly incremental. I think there is very little we
actually do all by ourselves, and I hate saying, “I did this” or “I did
that.” I think that in most cases, focusing on individual contributions
or achievements undervalues the importance of everyone else involved.
Having said that, I think my main contribution is probably in supporting
Creative Commons as a fan, board member, chairman of the board and now
CEO. I think CC has a significant role, and helping to keep it on track
and growing is probably the single most important role that I have in
Free Culture.
Specifically, I think that trying to keep an international focus and a
balance between business and the non-business elements of the movement
is essential. My job is to keep that focus and maintain that balance.
Also, CC needs to run smoothly as an organization and there is a lot of
operational work that we all need to do. My photography is a way for me
to participate in a small measure on the creative side of the Free
Culture movement, and helps me see things from that perspective as well.
However, I believe in emergent democracy and the importance of trying to
celebrate the community more than the heroes. Of course, I’m a huge fan
of Larry’s and I have great respect for the leaders of our movement. But
more than anything, I’m thankful for and respectful of all of the
participants who aren’t so well known and who are essential to moving
everything forward.
Personally, I don’t think it’s ultimately meaningful to talk about one
individual’s personal contribution to any movement. The real meaning is
in the whole movement. I’m just one participant. Just another free soul.
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/02-joi-ito-just-another-free-soul.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | How does the photographer feel about Larry Lessing? | 99921_KYHUJQWK_4 | [
"Larry is a great guy. They are a huge fan.",
"Larry is a disarming guy. ",
"Larry is a frustrating guy.",
"Larry is a nervous guy."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
99,921 | 99921_KYHUJQWK | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Just another free soul | nan | Joi Ito | Essay | Just another free soul
In his foreword to the book, Lessig writes that you understand your subjects “by learning to see them in a certain way.” What is that certain way?
I think I’m trying to get a mental image of a person, certain
expressions, or what I think that person is about. I’m trying to capture
what I think they look like, which is many times a minority of their
typical expressions, or their typical stance. So, if I’m taking pictures
of Larry [Lessig], I want to have his signature hand gestures, and not
just random ones.
I think I’m trying to capture pictures of people that help others see
what they’re about. Some photographers will make someone look the way
the photographer wants them to look, and not the way they appear, so
they’ll pick the one picture out of 100 where the guy looks more
egotistical than he really is. Some photographers are almost medical,
and are going after a perfect portrait. I’m somewhere in between.
It’s amazing how many people will upload snapshots of people where the
pictures don’t look like them at all. To me, uploading a picture that is
not an easily recognizable picture of that person defeats the point,
which I’m working toward, to try to express who they are. On the other
hand, professional photographers usually have a subject whom they don’t
know personally, so they end up having to try to capture an image that
they’ve created based on who they think the person is or how they want
that person to appear. You know how sculptors often say that they’re
just freeing an image from a block? What I’m trying to do is free
someone’s soul from his or her image. There are a lot of things that
make this hard. A lot of people are uncomfortable in front of a camera,
or might make expressions that aren’t very natural for them. And if the
person is nervous, it’s very difficult to try to see what it is that
you’re trying to capture.
A lot of what I’m doing is, I just start shooting photos. After half an
hour of having their picture taken, people start to ignore you. Or I’ll
take pictures when I’m talking to people about what they’re doing, so
after a while they get distracted by the conversation and forget about
the camera. That’s something that I’m not perfect at, but I’m getting
better.
I think good photographers are also able to disarm people through
conversation, but still, it’s difficult to have a disarming conversation
with somebody you don’t know, or to make them laugh. Many times people
make a face for me that they wouldn’t make for a professional
photographer.
For instance, a board meeting picture, like the one with Eric Saltzman:
that was during a very tense discussion. I’ve found that people are at
their most animated at these kinds of meetings, and look the most alive
when they are under a lot of pressure, and super- focused. But usually
if an outsider is in the room, they won’t get into that. I mean, it
would be difficult for a cameraman to be in a room where a board is
having a heated debate.
But those are the things that I’m trying to capture, because most people
don’t get to see that. At the Creative Commons board meeting, Larry
asked me to put the camera away after awhile [laughs] because it was
distracting. We were having a very heated discussion and I was taking
all of these pictures. But he credited me later because afterward those
pictures turned out the best.
In your mind, what is a ‘Freesoul’ ?
A freesoul is somewhat of a pun. On the one hand it means you are free,
liberated. You, as a human spirit, are open. And then, it also has the
meaning that you are unencumbered legally, that you are free, as in
‘free software.’
There’s a paradox: with many people’s Wikipedia
articles to which I’ve contributed, when it comes to the picture, many
of these people don’t have any free photos of themselves on the web, so
while they are “notable” on Wikipedia, their images aren’t free of the
copyright of the photographer, or the institution who hired the
photographer to take the picture. Often, even the subject of the article
can’t make an image available to the Wikimedia/Wikipedia community.
This means that a lot of people who have a Net presence have a legally
encumbered Net presence. People who are invited to conferences get asked
all the time, “By the way, do you have a photo that we can use?” But
they don’t. By making these pictures available under a Creative Commons
license, now they do. This is solving the issue of legal freedom.
The third part of the pun is that, since I’m asking for a model release
from the subjects, I’m asking everyone to be much more open and giving
about their image than most people typically are. I’m giving, you’re
giving, we’re all giving to participate and to try to create this
wonderful work, and allow others to create derivative works.
Of course people can abuse that, just like they can abuse anything. But
I want people to see the value in sharing over the fear in sharing. The
fact is, it’s much more likely that somebody is going to use these
pictures for something positive, rather than for something negative. The
benefits greatly outweigh the risks. I think we spend way too much of
our lives worrying about the risks, at the cost of a lot of the
benefits.
This is a celebration of all of the people who are willing to give. In a
way, giving up your image and allowing anyone to use it: it’s the
ultimate gift. In one way it’s kind of vain. [laughs] But in another
way it’s wonderful. A Wikipedia article on some person but with no
picture is sad.
Besides Wikipedia, how do you imagine these photos being used?
They can be used in textbooks and in mainstream media articles about the
person. Now they can get a picture that represents the person, at least
from my perspective. That said, I shouldn’t be the only person doing
this. More people should do the same, and make the photographs available
freely. For one, I feel that “free” CC licensed photos have a much
higher chance of not disappearing. But I don’t know exactly how these
photos are going to be used, so in a sense I’m curious. For example,
recently I received the Harvard Berkman Center pamphlet. It was a report
of what they’re doing, and they also had a bunch of my pictures in
there. They all had attribution, and it made me feel really good. There
were pictures of different Berkman Center members that I had taken in
various places all over the world. I think that the subject is probably
happy with this, and I’m happy, and the Berkman Center’s happy because
they’re not all pictures of people sitting at desks in the Berkman
Center. There’s one more important thing: Creative Commons is great for
original creative works or derivative creative works, but when it
involves human images, it gets very complicated. We all know the Virgin
Mobile case, where Virgin used CC licensed images in an advertisement
without getting permission from the models, and got in trouble. What
we’re trying to do here is to expand beyond just copyright, to make it
more thorough from a legal perspective. It’s also an important
educational point, so people understand that, in addition to the
Creative Commons licenses, we need people to provide other rights in
cases where the law requires such rights to be cleared before reuse.
What have you learned about the people in these networks, just in the past year?
That’s a good question. I think that at least Creative Commons has
become much more mainstream. Creative Commons has moved from a fringy
academic discussion to a boardroom discussion. Yahoo announced that it
will be using Creative Commons for all of their basic infrastructure,
and integrating it all. Google has CC search in their advanced search.
Microsoft is working with CC as well and have a plug-in. Nine Inch Nails
released their album, Ghost, under a Creative Commons license. The list
goes on. Many people are asking: can you make money and share? The
answer is, yes. CC is becoming an important part of the business
discussion.
But one thing that happens when a movement like CC becomes a business
thing, is that a lot of the pioneers fade into the background, and it
becomes a part of industry. This happened to the Internet. And so while
you still have the core people who still remember and hold the torch for
the philosophical side, the Internet has become much more of a business.
Now, when you go to many Internet conferences, it’s mostly salesmen in
attendance.
I believe that the success of the Internet has two parts. The first part
is the market- driven business side, which has made the Internet
affordable and ubiquitous. The second part is the strong movement of
participants who fight to keep the Internet open and try to prevent the
business side from corrupting the fundamental elements that make the
Internet great. The Net Neutrality or Open Network discussion going on
right now is a good example of the importance of continuing to balance
these principles with business interests.
Similarly, I think that business interests can help make Creative
Commons ubiquitous and more easily accessible to everyone. However, I
think it’s important to remember to keep pushing to make content more
“free” and not allow businesses to use Creative Commons in exploitive or
destructive ways.
In addition to the business side, Creative Commons is being used by
educators to create open courseware around the world and in the area of
science and technology to promote sharing in research. And as of now, we
have the license ported to at least 44 jurisdictions, and the number of
countries with projects continues to grow. In many ways, the movement
outside of the United States has become much bigger than the movement in
the United States. Although the United States is still slightly farther
ahead in terms of commercialization, the size of the whole free culture
movement outside of the United States is huge now. The CC China Photo
exhibit was just amazing. There were some great
images, and a lot of the photographers were professionals. This is
beyond what anybody has done in the US. A lot of the progress that we’re
making is international.
What are your personal realizations or experiences?
Well, we’re all getting old, if you look at these pictures. But there’s
another thing, though, about this book: the number of
professional-quality amateurs has increased significantly due to the
importance of digital in both professional and high-end amateur
photography I hate to say it, a lot of people love the darkroom, but it
really feels like the death of the darkroom with this year.
With new 22 megapixel cameras coming in under $10,000, and Lightroom
and some of this software at a couple hundred dollars, it doesn’t really
make sense, except for particularly fussy artists, to do wet-work
anymore. If you’re a commercial photographer or a high-end amateur, you
can do anything you used to do in the darkroom. I think it has really
lowered the bar. I don’t know how that affects the industry directly,
but for me, it bridged a huge gap.
I used to be darkroom geek. I loved my darkroom, and even when I didn’t
have my darkroom anymore, I still was shooting 6x6 Hasselblad 120 film
and processing it in a special lab, and then digitizing it. For me, that
film was it. You could never get as good as medium-format film or
large-format film
At the time, the digital Hasselblad backs were too expensive, and were
still not as good as 8x10 film. So there was this whole period where the
darkroom was not all that exciting, but the digital wasn’t perfect. I
went through a limbo period. I had invested so much in my Hasselblad
system, and my Leica M6 set. I had bought the Leica R8, but I was
kicking myself because it was terrible. But then the Leica M8 came out,
and I bought one at the beginning of 2007. The M8 really got me to where
I could use my old gear, and it had enough megapixels to be as good as
some film.
Another way of saying it was that there was a gear breakthrough at the
beginning of last year. Okay, that’s pretty materialistic! So there was
a technology breakthrough, let’s call it that, that allowed me to switch
completely away from film, and I think this happened to a lot of
photographers. It caused an explosion of content and an increase in the
quality of content on sites like Flickr. It has
allowed amateurs to create a business model with professionals.
Interestingly, I think these new high-end amateurs are buying more
photography books and photographs and are probably providing an
increasing revenue stream for professional photographers. I think most
amateurs, including myself, are paying homage to the professionals and
not trying to “compete” with them.
Despite the existence of social software, what is still important about meeting people face-to-face?
For me, the right way to use a lot of the new social software is by
making it easier to spend more physical time with the people you like
best. Dopplr is a great example. When
I visit a city, I will see all of the people who are in the city at the
same time. When I went to London awhile ago, there were 47 people I knew
in London, and a huge percentage of those people don’t live there. I
would bet that more than half of the photos in this book are pictures of
friends, and they’re not in their hometown.
That’s the really interesting thing that is happening right now: it’s
really increasing your ability to spend quality time with, actually, a
smaller number of people. It allows you to actively filter. Your
meetings don’t have to be random. If I look at the list of people in
this book, although there are some obvious people missing whom I didn’t
see last year, probably met more of my friends last year, my real
friends, than I’ve met in any other year. I know my travels were crazy,
but I think that the online world has allowed me to do that.
What’s great about photography is that it captures the moment that I was
sharing with that person. It’s not just a connection on a social network
online, which is really pretty binary. I can look at all these photos
and remember exactly what we were doing, what we were eating, what we
were drinking, what we were talking about, and to me that’s a much more
rich experience.
It’s the combination of social software and photography. For me, reality
is “the present” plus what you remember from the past. I think this
project is really sharing memories with people. Blog posts contribute as
well, but to me photography is a really good way of doing that. When I
look at the expressions, I remember the moment and get a sense of
presence.
I think the main problem for me is the environmental impact of flying
around. Just as I never believed that we would have a paperless office,
being able to connect with people through social software mostly
increases your travel, it doesn’t decrease it. It is great because you
get to meet all these people. But it is bad for the environment, and bad
for our jet lag.
How would you characterize your contributions to free culture?
I think it’s mostly incremental. I think there is very little we
actually do all by ourselves, and I hate saying, “I did this” or “I did
that.” I think that in most cases, focusing on individual contributions
or achievements undervalues the importance of everyone else involved.
Having said that, I think my main contribution is probably in supporting
Creative Commons as a fan, board member, chairman of the board and now
CEO. I think CC has a significant role, and helping to keep it on track
and growing is probably the single most important role that I have in
Free Culture.
Specifically, I think that trying to keep an international focus and a
balance between business and the non-business elements of the movement
is essential. My job is to keep that focus and maintain that balance.
Also, CC needs to run smoothly as an organization and there is a lot of
operational work that we all need to do. My photography is a way for me
to participate in a small measure on the creative side of the Free
Culture movement, and helps me see things from that perspective as well.
However, I believe in emergent democracy and the importance of trying to
celebrate the community more than the heroes. Of course, I’m a huge fan
of Larry’s and I have great respect for the leaders of our movement. But
more than anything, I’m thankful for and respectful of all of the
participants who aren’t so well known and who are essential to moving
everything forward.
Personally, I don’t think it’s ultimately meaningful to talk about one
individual’s personal contribution to any movement. The real meaning is
in the whole movement. I’m just one participant. Just another free soul.
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/02-joi-ito-just-another-free-soul.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | How does the photographer imagine photos with a CC license will be used? | 99921_KYHUJQWK_5 | [
"On billboards",
"In memes",
"In textbooks and mainstream media articles.",
"In TV commercials"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,921 | 99921_KYHUJQWK | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Just another free soul | nan | Joi Ito | Essay | Just another free soul
In his foreword to the book, Lessig writes that you understand your subjects “by learning to see them in a certain way.” What is that certain way?
I think I’m trying to get a mental image of a person, certain
expressions, or what I think that person is about. I’m trying to capture
what I think they look like, which is many times a minority of their
typical expressions, or their typical stance. So, if I’m taking pictures
of Larry [Lessig], I want to have his signature hand gestures, and not
just random ones.
I think I’m trying to capture pictures of people that help others see
what they’re about. Some photographers will make someone look the way
the photographer wants them to look, and not the way they appear, so
they’ll pick the one picture out of 100 where the guy looks more
egotistical than he really is. Some photographers are almost medical,
and are going after a perfect portrait. I’m somewhere in between.
It’s amazing how many people will upload snapshots of people where the
pictures don’t look like them at all. To me, uploading a picture that is
not an easily recognizable picture of that person defeats the point,
which I’m working toward, to try to express who they are. On the other
hand, professional photographers usually have a subject whom they don’t
know personally, so they end up having to try to capture an image that
they’ve created based on who they think the person is or how they want
that person to appear. You know how sculptors often say that they’re
just freeing an image from a block? What I’m trying to do is free
someone’s soul from his or her image. There are a lot of things that
make this hard. A lot of people are uncomfortable in front of a camera,
or might make expressions that aren’t very natural for them. And if the
person is nervous, it’s very difficult to try to see what it is that
you’re trying to capture.
A lot of what I’m doing is, I just start shooting photos. After half an
hour of having their picture taken, people start to ignore you. Or I’ll
take pictures when I’m talking to people about what they’re doing, so
after a while they get distracted by the conversation and forget about
the camera. That’s something that I’m not perfect at, but I’m getting
better.
I think good photographers are also able to disarm people through
conversation, but still, it’s difficult to have a disarming conversation
with somebody you don’t know, or to make them laugh. Many times people
make a face for me that they wouldn’t make for a professional
photographer.
For instance, a board meeting picture, like the one with Eric Saltzman:
that was during a very tense discussion. I’ve found that people are at
their most animated at these kinds of meetings, and look the most alive
when they are under a lot of pressure, and super- focused. But usually
if an outsider is in the room, they won’t get into that. I mean, it
would be difficult for a cameraman to be in a room where a board is
having a heated debate.
But those are the things that I’m trying to capture, because most people
don’t get to see that. At the Creative Commons board meeting, Larry
asked me to put the camera away after awhile [laughs] because it was
distracting. We were having a very heated discussion and I was taking
all of these pictures. But he credited me later because afterward those
pictures turned out the best.
In your mind, what is a ‘Freesoul’ ?
A freesoul is somewhat of a pun. On the one hand it means you are free,
liberated. You, as a human spirit, are open. And then, it also has the
meaning that you are unencumbered legally, that you are free, as in
‘free software.’
There’s a paradox: with many people’s Wikipedia
articles to which I’ve contributed, when it comes to the picture, many
of these people don’t have any free photos of themselves on the web, so
while they are “notable” on Wikipedia, their images aren’t free of the
copyright of the photographer, or the institution who hired the
photographer to take the picture. Often, even the subject of the article
can’t make an image available to the Wikimedia/Wikipedia community.
This means that a lot of people who have a Net presence have a legally
encumbered Net presence. People who are invited to conferences get asked
all the time, “By the way, do you have a photo that we can use?” But
they don’t. By making these pictures available under a Creative Commons
license, now they do. This is solving the issue of legal freedom.
The third part of the pun is that, since I’m asking for a model release
from the subjects, I’m asking everyone to be much more open and giving
about their image than most people typically are. I’m giving, you’re
giving, we’re all giving to participate and to try to create this
wonderful work, and allow others to create derivative works.
Of course people can abuse that, just like they can abuse anything. But
I want people to see the value in sharing over the fear in sharing. The
fact is, it’s much more likely that somebody is going to use these
pictures for something positive, rather than for something negative. The
benefits greatly outweigh the risks. I think we spend way too much of
our lives worrying about the risks, at the cost of a lot of the
benefits.
This is a celebration of all of the people who are willing to give. In a
way, giving up your image and allowing anyone to use it: it’s the
ultimate gift. In one way it’s kind of vain. [laughs] But in another
way it’s wonderful. A Wikipedia article on some person but with no
picture is sad.
Besides Wikipedia, how do you imagine these photos being used?
They can be used in textbooks and in mainstream media articles about the
person. Now they can get a picture that represents the person, at least
from my perspective. That said, I shouldn’t be the only person doing
this. More people should do the same, and make the photographs available
freely. For one, I feel that “free” CC licensed photos have a much
higher chance of not disappearing. But I don’t know exactly how these
photos are going to be used, so in a sense I’m curious. For example,
recently I received the Harvard Berkman Center pamphlet. It was a report
of what they’re doing, and they also had a bunch of my pictures in
there. They all had attribution, and it made me feel really good. There
were pictures of different Berkman Center members that I had taken in
various places all over the world. I think that the subject is probably
happy with this, and I’m happy, and the Berkman Center’s happy because
they’re not all pictures of people sitting at desks in the Berkman
Center. There’s one more important thing: Creative Commons is great for
original creative works or derivative creative works, but when it
involves human images, it gets very complicated. We all know the Virgin
Mobile case, where Virgin used CC licensed images in an advertisement
without getting permission from the models, and got in trouble. What
we’re trying to do here is to expand beyond just copyright, to make it
more thorough from a legal perspective. It’s also an important
educational point, so people understand that, in addition to the
Creative Commons licenses, we need people to provide other rights in
cases where the law requires such rights to be cleared before reuse.
What have you learned about the people in these networks, just in the past year?
That’s a good question. I think that at least Creative Commons has
become much more mainstream. Creative Commons has moved from a fringy
academic discussion to a boardroom discussion. Yahoo announced that it
will be using Creative Commons for all of their basic infrastructure,
and integrating it all. Google has CC search in their advanced search.
Microsoft is working with CC as well and have a plug-in. Nine Inch Nails
released their album, Ghost, under a Creative Commons license. The list
goes on. Many people are asking: can you make money and share? The
answer is, yes. CC is becoming an important part of the business
discussion.
But one thing that happens when a movement like CC becomes a business
thing, is that a lot of the pioneers fade into the background, and it
becomes a part of industry. This happened to the Internet. And so while
you still have the core people who still remember and hold the torch for
the philosophical side, the Internet has become much more of a business.
Now, when you go to many Internet conferences, it’s mostly salesmen in
attendance.
I believe that the success of the Internet has two parts. The first part
is the market- driven business side, which has made the Internet
affordable and ubiquitous. The second part is the strong movement of
participants who fight to keep the Internet open and try to prevent the
business side from corrupting the fundamental elements that make the
Internet great. The Net Neutrality or Open Network discussion going on
right now is a good example of the importance of continuing to balance
these principles with business interests.
Similarly, I think that business interests can help make Creative
Commons ubiquitous and more easily accessible to everyone. However, I
think it’s important to remember to keep pushing to make content more
“free” and not allow businesses to use Creative Commons in exploitive or
destructive ways.
In addition to the business side, Creative Commons is being used by
educators to create open courseware around the world and in the area of
science and technology to promote sharing in research. And as of now, we
have the license ported to at least 44 jurisdictions, and the number of
countries with projects continues to grow. In many ways, the movement
outside of the United States has become much bigger than the movement in
the United States. Although the United States is still slightly farther
ahead in terms of commercialization, the size of the whole free culture
movement outside of the United States is huge now. The CC China Photo
exhibit was just amazing. There were some great
images, and a lot of the photographers were professionals. This is
beyond what anybody has done in the US. A lot of the progress that we’re
making is international.
What are your personal realizations or experiences?
Well, we’re all getting old, if you look at these pictures. But there’s
another thing, though, about this book: the number of
professional-quality amateurs has increased significantly due to the
importance of digital in both professional and high-end amateur
photography I hate to say it, a lot of people love the darkroom, but it
really feels like the death of the darkroom with this year.
With new 22 megapixel cameras coming in under $10,000, and Lightroom
and some of this software at a couple hundred dollars, it doesn’t really
make sense, except for particularly fussy artists, to do wet-work
anymore. If you’re a commercial photographer or a high-end amateur, you
can do anything you used to do in the darkroom. I think it has really
lowered the bar. I don’t know how that affects the industry directly,
but for me, it bridged a huge gap.
I used to be darkroom geek. I loved my darkroom, and even when I didn’t
have my darkroom anymore, I still was shooting 6x6 Hasselblad 120 film
and processing it in a special lab, and then digitizing it. For me, that
film was it. You could never get as good as medium-format film or
large-format film
At the time, the digital Hasselblad backs were too expensive, and were
still not as good as 8x10 film. So there was this whole period where the
darkroom was not all that exciting, but the digital wasn’t perfect. I
went through a limbo period. I had invested so much in my Hasselblad
system, and my Leica M6 set. I had bought the Leica R8, but I was
kicking myself because it was terrible. But then the Leica M8 came out,
and I bought one at the beginning of 2007. The M8 really got me to where
I could use my old gear, and it had enough megapixels to be as good as
some film.
Another way of saying it was that there was a gear breakthrough at the
beginning of last year. Okay, that’s pretty materialistic! So there was
a technology breakthrough, let’s call it that, that allowed me to switch
completely away from film, and I think this happened to a lot of
photographers. It caused an explosion of content and an increase in the
quality of content on sites like Flickr. It has
allowed amateurs to create a business model with professionals.
Interestingly, I think these new high-end amateurs are buying more
photography books and photographs and are probably providing an
increasing revenue stream for professional photographers. I think most
amateurs, including myself, are paying homage to the professionals and
not trying to “compete” with them.
Despite the existence of social software, what is still important about meeting people face-to-face?
For me, the right way to use a lot of the new social software is by
making it easier to spend more physical time with the people you like
best. Dopplr is a great example. When
I visit a city, I will see all of the people who are in the city at the
same time. When I went to London awhile ago, there were 47 people I knew
in London, and a huge percentage of those people don’t live there. I
would bet that more than half of the photos in this book are pictures of
friends, and they’re not in their hometown.
That’s the really interesting thing that is happening right now: it’s
really increasing your ability to spend quality time with, actually, a
smaller number of people. It allows you to actively filter. Your
meetings don’t have to be random. If I look at the list of people in
this book, although there are some obvious people missing whom I didn’t
see last year, probably met more of my friends last year, my real
friends, than I’ve met in any other year. I know my travels were crazy,
but I think that the online world has allowed me to do that.
What’s great about photography is that it captures the moment that I was
sharing with that person. It’s not just a connection on a social network
online, which is really pretty binary. I can look at all these photos
and remember exactly what we were doing, what we were eating, what we
were drinking, what we were talking about, and to me that’s a much more
rich experience.
It’s the combination of social software and photography. For me, reality
is “the present” plus what you remember from the past. I think this
project is really sharing memories with people. Blog posts contribute as
well, but to me photography is a really good way of doing that. When I
look at the expressions, I remember the moment and get a sense of
presence.
I think the main problem for me is the environmental impact of flying
around. Just as I never believed that we would have a paperless office,
being able to connect with people through social software mostly
increases your travel, it doesn’t decrease it. It is great because you
get to meet all these people. But it is bad for the environment, and bad
for our jet lag.
How would you characterize your contributions to free culture?
I think it’s mostly incremental. I think there is very little we
actually do all by ourselves, and I hate saying, “I did this” or “I did
that.” I think that in most cases, focusing on individual contributions
or achievements undervalues the importance of everyone else involved.
Having said that, I think my main contribution is probably in supporting
Creative Commons as a fan, board member, chairman of the board and now
CEO. I think CC has a significant role, and helping to keep it on track
and growing is probably the single most important role that I have in
Free Culture.
Specifically, I think that trying to keep an international focus and a
balance between business and the non-business elements of the movement
is essential. My job is to keep that focus and maintain that balance.
Also, CC needs to run smoothly as an organization and there is a lot of
operational work that we all need to do. My photography is a way for me
to participate in a small measure on the creative side of the Free
Culture movement, and helps me see things from that perspective as well.
However, I believe in emergent democracy and the importance of trying to
celebrate the community more than the heroes. Of course, I’m a huge fan
of Larry’s and I have great respect for the leaders of our movement. But
more than anything, I’m thankful for and respectful of all of the
participants who aren’t so well known and who are essential to moving
everything forward.
Personally, I don’t think it’s ultimately meaningful to talk about one
individual’s personal contribution to any movement. The real meaning is
in the whole movement. I’m just one participant. Just another free soul.
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/02-joi-ito-just-another-free-soul.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | When does Creative Commons get complicated? | 99921_KYHUJQWK_6 | [
"Advertisement",
"Human images",
"Derivative creative works",
"Original creative works"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,923 | 99923_RF46WKUJ | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Sharism: A Mind Revolution | nan | Isaac Mao | Essay | Sharism: A Mind Revolution
With the People of the World Wide Web communicating more fully and
freely in Social Media while rallying a Web 2.0 content boom, the inner
dynamics of such a creative explosion must be studied more closely. What
motivates those who join this movement and what future will they create?
A key fact is that a superabundance of community respect and social
capital are being accumulated by those who share. The key motivator of
Social Media and the core spirit of Web 2.0 is a mind switch called
Sharism. Sharism suggests a re-orientation of personal values. We see it
in User Generated Content. It is the pledge of Creative Commons. It is
in the plans of future-oriented cultural initiatives. Sharism is also a
mental practice that anyone can try, a social-psychological attitude to
transform a wide and isolated world into a super-smart Social Brain.
The Neuron Doctrine
Sharism is encoded in the Human Genome. Although eclipsed by the many
pragmatisms of daily life, the theory of Sharism finds basis in
neuroscience and its study of the working model of the human brain.
Although we can’t entirely say how the brain works as a whole, we do
have a model of the functional mechanism of the nervous system and its
neurons. A neuron is not a simple organic cell, but a very powerful,
electrically excitable biological processor. Groups of neurons form
vastly interconnected networks, which, by changing the strength of the
synapses between cells, can process information, and learn. A neuron, by
sharing chemical signals with its neighbors, can be integrated into more
meaningful patterns that keep the neuron active and alive. Moreover,
such a simple logic can be iterated and amplified, since all neurons
work on a similar principle of connecting and sharing. Originally, the
brain is quite open. A neural network exists to share activity and
information, and I believe this model of the brain should inspire ideas
and decisions about human networks.
Thus, our brain supports sharing in its very system-nature. This has
profound implications for the creative process. Whenever you have an
intention to create, you will find it easier to generate more creative
ideas if you keep the sharing process firmly in mind. The
idea-forming-process is not linear, but more like an avalanche of
amplifications along the thinking path. It moves with the momentum of a
creative snowball. If your internal cognitive system encourages sharing,
you can engineer a feedback loop of happiness, which will help you
generate even more ideas in return. It’s a kind of butterfly- effect, as
the small creative energy you spend will eventually return to make you,
and the world, more creative.
However, daily decisions for most adults are quite low in creative
productivity, if only because they’ve switched off their sharing paths.
People generally like to share what they create, but in a culture that
tells them to be protective of their ideas, people start to believe in
the danger of sharing. Then Sharism will be degraded in their mind and
not encouraged in their society. But if we can encourage someone to
share, her sharing paths will stay open. Sharism will be kept in her
mind as a memory and an instinct. If in the future she faces a creative
choice, her choice will be, “Share.”
These mind-switches are too subtle to be felt. But since the brain, and
society, is a connected system, the accumulation of these
micro-attitudes, from neuron to neuron and person to person, can result
in observable behavior. It is easy to tell if a person, a group, a
company, a nation is oriented toward Sharism or not. For those who are
not, what they defend as “cultural goods” and “intellectual property”
are just excuses for the status quo of keeping a community closed. Much
of their “culture” will be protected, but the net result is the direct
loss of many other precious ideas, and the subsequent loss of all the
potential gains of sharing. This lost knowledge is a black hole in our
life, which may start to swallow other values as well.
Non-sharing culture misleads us with its absolute separation of Private
and Public space. It makes creative action a binary choice between
public and private, open and closed. This creates a gap in the spectrum
of knowledge. Although this gap has the potential to become a valuable
creative space, concerns about privacy make this gap hard to fill. We
shouldn’t be surprised that, to be safe, most people keep their sharing
private and stay “closed.” They may fear the Internet creates a
potential for abuse that they can’t fight alone. However, the paradox
is: The less you share, the less power you have.
New Technologies and the Rise of Sharism
Let’s track back to 1999, when there were only a few hundred pioneer
bloggers around the world, and no more than ten times that many readers
following each blog. Human history is always so: something important was
happening, but the rest of the world hadn’t yet realized it. The shift
toward easy-to-use online publishing triggered a soft revolution in just
five years. People made a quick and easy transition from reading blogs,
to leaving comments and taking part in online conversations, and then to
the sudden realization that they should become bloggers themselves. More
bloggers created more readers, and more readers made more blogs. The
revolution was viral.
Bloggers generate lively and timely information on the Internet, and
connect to each other with RSS, hyperlinks, comments, trackbacks and
quotes. The small-scale granularity of the content can fill discrete
gaps in experience and thus record a new human history. Once you become
a blogger, once you have accumulated so much social capital in such a
small site, it’s hard to stop. We can’t explain this fact with a theory
of addiction. It’s an impulse to share. It’s the energy of the memes
that want to be passed from mouth to mouth and mind to mind. It’s more
than just E-mail. It’s Sharism.
Bloggers are always keen to keep the social context of their posts in
mind, by asking themselves, “Who is going to see this?” Bloggers are
agile in adjusting their tone−and privacy settings−to advance ideas and
stay out of trouble. It’s not self-censorship, but a sense of smart
expression. But once blogs reached the tipping point, they expanded into
the blogosphere. This required a more delicate social networking system
and content- sharing architecture. But people now understand that they
can have better control over a wide spectrum of relationships. Like how
Flickr allows people to share their photos widely, but safely. The
checkbox-based privacy of Flickr may seem unfamiliar to a new user, but
you can use it to toy with the mind-switches of Sharism. By checking a
box we can choose to share or not to share. From my observations, I have
seen photographers on Flickr become more open to sharing, while
retaining flexible choices.
The rapid emergence of Social Applications that can communicate and
cooperate, by allowing people to output content from one service to
another, is letting users pump their memes into a pipeline-like
ecosystem. This interconnectedness allows memes to travel along multiple
online social networks, and potentially reach a huge audience. As a
result, such a Micro-pipeline system is making Social Media a true
alternative to broadcast media. These new technologies are reviving
Sharism in our closed culture.
Local Practice, Global Gain
If you happened to lose your Sharism in a bad educational or cultural
setting, it’s hard to get it back. But it’s not impossible. A
persistence of practice can lead to a full recovery. You can think of
Sharism as a spiritual practice. But you must practice everyday.
Otherwise, you might lose the power of sharing. Permanently.
You might need something to spur you on, to keep you from quitting and
returning to a closed mindset. Here’s an idea: put a sticky note on your
desk that says, “What do you want to share today?” I’m not kidding.
Then, if anything interesting comes your way: Share It! The easiest way
to both start and keep sharing is by using different kinds of social
software applications. Your first meme you want to share may be small,
but you can amplify it with new technologies. Enlist some people from
your network and invite them into a new social application. At first it
might be hard to feel the gains of Sharism. The true test then is to see
if you can keep track of the feedback that you get from sharing. You
will realize that almost all sharing activities will generate positive
results. The happiness that this will obtain is only the most immediate
reward. But there are others.
The first type of reward that you will get comes in the form of
comments. Then you know you’ve provoked interest, appreciation,
excitement. The second reward is access to all the other stuff being
shared by friends in your network. Since you know and trust them, you
will be that much more interested in what they have to share. Already,
the return is a multiple of the small meme you first shared. But the
third type of return is more dramatic still. Anything you share can be
forwarded, circulated and republished via other people’s networks. This
cascade effect can spread your work to the networked masses.
Improvements in social software are making the speed of dissemination as
fast as a mouse-click. You should get to know the Sharism-You. You’re
about to become popular, and fast
This brings us to the fourth and final type of return. It has a meaning
not only for you, but for the whole of society. If you so choose, you
may allow others to create derivative works from what you share. This
one choice could easily snowball into more creations along the sharing
path, from people at key nodes in the network who are all as passionate
about creating and sharing as you are. After many iterative rounds of
development, a large creative work may spring from your choice to share.
Of course, you will get the credit that you asked for, and deserve. And
it’s okay to seek financial rewards. But you will in every case get
something just as substantial: Happiness.
The more people who create in the spirit of Sharism, the easier it will
be to attain well- balanced and equitable Social Media that is woven by
people themselves. Media won’t be controlled by any single person but
will rely on the even distribution of social networking. These “Shaeros”
(Sharing Heroes) will naturally become the opinion leaders in the first
wave of Social Media. However, these media rights will belong to
everyone. You yourself can be both producer and consumer in such a
system.
Sharism Safeguards Your Rights
Still, many questions will be raised about Sharism as an initiative in
new age. The main one is copyright. One concern is that any loss of
control over copyrighted content will lead to noticeable deficits in
personal wealth, or just loss of control. 5 years ago, I would have said
that this was a possibility. But things are changing today. The sharing
environment is more protected than you might think. Many new social
applications make it easy to set terms-of-use along your sharing path.
Any infringement of those terms will be challenged not just by the law,
but by your community. Your audience, who benefit form your sharing, can
also be the gatekeepers of your rights. Even if you are a traditional
copyright holder, this sounds ideal.
Furthermore, by realizing all the immediate and emergent rewards that
can be had by sharing, you may eventually find that copyright and “All
Rights Reserved” are far from your mind. You will enjoy sharing too much
to worry about who is keeping a copy. The new economic formula is, the
more people remix your works, the higher the return.
I want to point out that Sharism is not Communism, nor Socialism. As for
those die- hard Communists we know, they have often abused people’s
sharing nature and forced them to give up their rights, and their
property. Socialism, that tender Communism, in our experience also
lacked respect for these rights. Under these systems, the state owns all
property. Under Sharism, you can keep ownership, if you want. But I like
to share. And this is how I choose to spread ideas, and prosperity
Sharism is totally based on your own consensus. It’s not a very hard
concept to understand, especially since copyleft movements like the Free
Software Foundation and Creative Commons have been around for years.
These movements are redefining a more flexible spectrum of licenses for
both developers and end-users to tag their works. Because the new
licenses can be recognized by either humans or machines, it’s becoming
easier to re-share those works in new online ecosystems.
The Spirit of the Web, a Social Brain
Sharism is the Spirit of the Age of Web 2.0. It has the consistency of a
naturalized Epistemology and modernized Axiology, but also promises the
power of a new Internet philosophy. Sharism will transform the world
into an emergent Social Brain: a networked hybrid of people and
software. We are Networked Neurons connected by the synapses of Social
Software.
This is an evolutionary leap, a small step for us and a giant one for
human society. With new “hairy” emergent technologies sprouting all
around us, we can generate higher connectivities and increase the
throughput of our social links. The more open and strongly connected we
social neurons are, the better the sharing environment will be for all
people. The more collective our intelligence, the wiser our actions will
be. People have always found better solutions through conversations. Now
we can put it all online.
Sharism will be the politics of the next global superpower. It will not
be a country, but a new human network joined by Social Software. This
may remain a distant dream, and even a well-defined public sharing
policy might not be close at hand. But the ideas that I’m discussing can
improve governments today. We can integrate our current and emerging
democratic systems with new folksonomies (based on the collaborative,
social indexing of information) to enable people to make queries, share
data and remix information for public use. The collective intelligence
of a vast and equitable sharing environment can be the gatekeeper of our
rights, and a government watchdog. In the future, policymaking can be
made more nuanced with the micro-involvement of the sharing community.
This “Emergent Democracy” is more real-time than periodical
parliamentary sessions. It will also increase the spectrum of our
choices, beyond the binary options of “Yes” or “No” referenda.
Representative democracy will become more timely and diligent, because
we will represent ourselves within the system.
Sharism will result in better social justice. In a healthy sharing
environment, any evidence of injustice can get amplified to get the
public’s attention. Anyone who has been abused can get real and instant
support from her peers and her peers’ peers. Appeals to justice will
take the form of petitions through multiple, interconnected channels.
Using these tools, anyone can create a large social impact. With
multiple devices and many social applications, each of us can become
more sociable, and society more individual. We no longer have to act
alone.
Emergent democracy will only happen when Sharism becomes the literacy of
the majority. Since Sharism can improve communication, collaboration and
mutual understanding, I believe it has a place within the educational
system. Sharism can be applied to any cultural discourse, CoP (Community
of Practice) or problem-solving context. It is also an antidote to
social depression, since sharelessness is just dragging our society
down. In present or formerly totalitarian countries, this downward cycle
is even more apparent. The future world will be a hybrid of human and
machine that will generate better and faster decisions anytime,
anywhere. The flow of information between minds will become more
flexible and more productive. These vast networks of sharing will create
a new social order−A Mind Revolution!
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/07-isaac-mao-sharism.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | What is Sharism? | 99923_RF46WKUJ_1 | [
"Community respect",
"Future-oriented cultural initiatives",
"A mental practice",
"A social-psychological attitude"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,923 | 99923_RF46WKUJ | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Sharism: A Mind Revolution | nan | Isaac Mao | Essay | Sharism: A Mind Revolution
With the People of the World Wide Web communicating more fully and
freely in Social Media while rallying a Web 2.0 content boom, the inner
dynamics of such a creative explosion must be studied more closely. What
motivates those who join this movement and what future will they create?
A key fact is that a superabundance of community respect and social
capital are being accumulated by those who share. The key motivator of
Social Media and the core spirit of Web 2.0 is a mind switch called
Sharism. Sharism suggests a re-orientation of personal values. We see it
in User Generated Content. It is the pledge of Creative Commons. It is
in the plans of future-oriented cultural initiatives. Sharism is also a
mental practice that anyone can try, a social-psychological attitude to
transform a wide and isolated world into a super-smart Social Brain.
The Neuron Doctrine
Sharism is encoded in the Human Genome. Although eclipsed by the many
pragmatisms of daily life, the theory of Sharism finds basis in
neuroscience and its study of the working model of the human brain.
Although we can’t entirely say how the brain works as a whole, we do
have a model of the functional mechanism of the nervous system and its
neurons. A neuron is not a simple organic cell, but a very powerful,
electrically excitable biological processor. Groups of neurons form
vastly interconnected networks, which, by changing the strength of the
synapses between cells, can process information, and learn. A neuron, by
sharing chemical signals with its neighbors, can be integrated into more
meaningful patterns that keep the neuron active and alive. Moreover,
such a simple logic can be iterated and amplified, since all neurons
work on a similar principle of connecting and sharing. Originally, the
brain is quite open. A neural network exists to share activity and
information, and I believe this model of the brain should inspire ideas
and decisions about human networks.
Thus, our brain supports sharing in its very system-nature. This has
profound implications for the creative process. Whenever you have an
intention to create, you will find it easier to generate more creative
ideas if you keep the sharing process firmly in mind. The
idea-forming-process is not linear, but more like an avalanche of
amplifications along the thinking path. It moves with the momentum of a
creative snowball. If your internal cognitive system encourages sharing,
you can engineer a feedback loop of happiness, which will help you
generate even more ideas in return. It’s a kind of butterfly- effect, as
the small creative energy you spend will eventually return to make you,
and the world, more creative.
However, daily decisions for most adults are quite low in creative
productivity, if only because they’ve switched off their sharing paths.
People generally like to share what they create, but in a culture that
tells them to be protective of their ideas, people start to believe in
the danger of sharing. Then Sharism will be degraded in their mind and
not encouraged in their society. But if we can encourage someone to
share, her sharing paths will stay open. Sharism will be kept in her
mind as a memory and an instinct. If in the future she faces a creative
choice, her choice will be, “Share.”
These mind-switches are too subtle to be felt. But since the brain, and
society, is a connected system, the accumulation of these
micro-attitudes, from neuron to neuron and person to person, can result
in observable behavior. It is easy to tell if a person, a group, a
company, a nation is oriented toward Sharism or not. For those who are
not, what they defend as “cultural goods” and “intellectual property”
are just excuses for the status quo of keeping a community closed. Much
of their “culture” will be protected, but the net result is the direct
loss of many other precious ideas, and the subsequent loss of all the
potential gains of sharing. This lost knowledge is a black hole in our
life, which may start to swallow other values as well.
Non-sharing culture misleads us with its absolute separation of Private
and Public space. It makes creative action a binary choice between
public and private, open and closed. This creates a gap in the spectrum
of knowledge. Although this gap has the potential to become a valuable
creative space, concerns about privacy make this gap hard to fill. We
shouldn’t be surprised that, to be safe, most people keep their sharing
private and stay “closed.” They may fear the Internet creates a
potential for abuse that they can’t fight alone. However, the paradox
is: The less you share, the less power you have.
New Technologies and the Rise of Sharism
Let’s track back to 1999, when there were only a few hundred pioneer
bloggers around the world, and no more than ten times that many readers
following each blog. Human history is always so: something important was
happening, but the rest of the world hadn’t yet realized it. The shift
toward easy-to-use online publishing triggered a soft revolution in just
five years. People made a quick and easy transition from reading blogs,
to leaving comments and taking part in online conversations, and then to
the sudden realization that they should become bloggers themselves. More
bloggers created more readers, and more readers made more blogs. The
revolution was viral.
Bloggers generate lively and timely information on the Internet, and
connect to each other with RSS, hyperlinks, comments, trackbacks and
quotes. The small-scale granularity of the content can fill discrete
gaps in experience and thus record a new human history. Once you become
a blogger, once you have accumulated so much social capital in such a
small site, it’s hard to stop. We can’t explain this fact with a theory
of addiction. It’s an impulse to share. It’s the energy of the memes
that want to be passed from mouth to mouth and mind to mind. It’s more
than just E-mail. It’s Sharism.
Bloggers are always keen to keep the social context of their posts in
mind, by asking themselves, “Who is going to see this?” Bloggers are
agile in adjusting their tone−and privacy settings−to advance ideas and
stay out of trouble. It’s not self-censorship, but a sense of smart
expression. But once blogs reached the tipping point, they expanded into
the blogosphere. This required a more delicate social networking system
and content- sharing architecture. But people now understand that they
can have better control over a wide spectrum of relationships. Like how
Flickr allows people to share their photos widely, but safely. The
checkbox-based privacy of Flickr may seem unfamiliar to a new user, but
you can use it to toy with the mind-switches of Sharism. By checking a
box we can choose to share or not to share. From my observations, I have
seen photographers on Flickr become more open to sharing, while
retaining flexible choices.
The rapid emergence of Social Applications that can communicate and
cooperate, by allowing people to output content from one service to
another, is letting users pump their memes into a pipeline-like
ecosystem. This interconnectedness allows memes to travel along multiple
online social networks, and potentially reach a huge audience. As a
result, such a Micro-pipeline system is making Social Media a true
alternative to broadcast media. These new technologies are reviving
Sharism in our closed culture.
Local Practice, Global Gain
If you happened to lose your Sharism in a bad educational or cultural
setting, it’s hard to get it back. But it’s not impossible. A
persistence of practice can lead to a full recovery. You can think of
Sharism as a spiritual practice. But you must practice everyday.
Otherwise, you might lose the power of sharing. Permanently.
You might need something to spur you on, to keep you from quitting and
returning to a closed mindset. Here’s an idea: put a sticky note on your
desk that says, “What do you want to share today?” I’m not kidding.
Then, if anything interesting comes your way: Share It! The easiest way
to both start and keep sharing is by using different kinds of social
software applications. Your first meme you want to share may be small,
but you can amplify it with new technologies. Enlist some people from
your network and invite them into a new social application. At first it
might be hard to feel the gains of Sharism. The true test then is to see
if you can keep track of the feedback that you get from sharing. You
will realize that almost all sharing activities will generate positive
results. The happiness that this will obtain is only the most immediate
reward. But there are others.
The first type of reward that you will get comes in the form of
comments. Then you know you’ve provoked interest, appreciation,
excitement. The second reward is access to all the other stuff being
shared by friends in your network. Since you know and trust them, you
will be that much more interested in what they have to share. Already,
the return is a multiple of the small meme you first shared. But the
third type of return is more dramatic still. Anything you share can be
forwarded, circulated and republished via other people’s networks. This
cascade effect can spread your work to the networked masses.
Improvements in social software are making the speed of dissemination as
fast as a mouse-click. You should get to know the Sharism-You. You’re
about to become popular, and fast
This brings us to the fourth and final type of return. It has a meaning
not only for you, but for the whole of society. If you so choose, you
may allow others to create derivative works from what you share. This
one choice could easily snowball into more creations along the sharing
path, from people at key nodes in the network who are all as passionate
about creating and sharing as you are. After many iterative rounds of
development, a large creative work may spring from your choice to share.
Of course, you will get the credit that you asked for, and deserve. And
it’s okay to seek financial rewards. But you will in every case get
something just as substantial: Happiness.
The more people who create in the spirit of Sharism, the easier it will
be to attain well- balanced and equitable Social Media that is woven by
people themselves. Media won’t be controlled by any single person but
will rely on the even distribution of social networking. These “Shaeros”
(Sharing Heroes) will naturally become the opinion leaders in the first
wave of Social Media. However, these media rights will belong to
everyone. You yourself can be both producer and consumer in such a
system.
Sharism Safeguards Your Rights
Still, many questions will be raised about Sharism as an initiative in
new age. The main one is copyright. One concern is that any loss of
control over copyrighted content will lead to noticeable deficits in
personal wealth, or just loss of control. 5 years ago, I would have said
that this was a possibility. But things are changing today. The sharing
environment is more protected than you might think. Many new social
applications make it easy to set terms-of-use along your sharing path.
Any infringement of those terms will be challenged not just by the law,
but by your community. Your audience, who benefit form your sharing, can
also be the gatekeepers of your rights. Even if you are a traditional
copyright holder, this sounds ideal.
Furthermore, by realizing all the immediate and emergent rewards that
can be had by sharing, you may eventually find that copyright and “All
Rights Reserved” are far from your mind. You will enjoy sharing too much
to worry about who is keeping a copy. The new economic formula is, the
more people remix your works, the higher the return.
I want to point out that Sharism is not Communism, nor Socialism. As for
those die- hard Communists we know, they have often abused people’s
sharing nature and forced them to give up their rights, and their
property. Socialism, that tender Communism, in our experience also
lacked respect for these rights. Under these systems, the state owns all
property. Under Sharism, you can keep ownership, if you want. But I like
to share. And this is how I choose to spread ideas, and prosperity
Sharism is totally based on your own consensus. It’s not a very hard
concept to understand, especially since copyleft movements like the Free
Software Foundation and Creative Commons have been around for years.
These movements are redefining a more flexible spectrum of licenses for
both developers and end-users to tag their works. Because the new
licenses can be recognized by either humans or machines, it’s becoming
easier to re-share those works in new online ecosystems.
The Spirit of the Web, a Social Brain
Sharism is the Spirit of the Age of Web 2.0. It has the consistency of a
naturalized Epistemology and modernized Axiology, but also promises the
power of a new Internet philosophy. Sharism will transform the world
into an emergent Social Brain: a networked hybrid of people and
software. We are Networked Neurons connected by the synapses of Social
Software.
This is an evolutionary leap, a small step for us and a giant one for
human society. With new “hairy” emergent technologies sprouting all
around us, we can generate higher connectivities and increase the
throughput of our social links. The more open and strongly connected we
social neurons are, the better the sharing environment will be for all
people. The more collective our intelligence, the wiser our actions will
be. People have always found better solutions through conversations. Now
we can put it all online.
Sharism will be the politics of the next global superpower. It will not
be a country, but a new human network joined by Social Software. This
may remain a distant dream, and even a well-defined public sharing
policy might not be close at hand. But the ideas that I’m discussing can
improve governments today. We can integrate our current and emerging
democratic systems with new folksonomies (based on the collaborative,
social indexing of information) to enable people to make queries, share
data and remix information for public use. The collective intelligence
of a vast and equitable sharing environment can be the gatekeeper of our
rights, and a government watchdog. In the future, policymaking can be
made more nuanced with the micro-involvement of the sharing community.
This “Emergent Democracy” is more real-time than periodical
parliamentary sessions. It will also increase the spectrum of our
choices, beyond the binary options of “Yes” or “No” referenda.
Representative democracy will become more timely and diligent, because
we will represent ourselves within the system.
Sharism will result in better social justice. In a healthy sharing
environment, any evidence of injustice can get amplified to get the
public’s attention. Anyone who has been abused can get real and instant
support from her peers and her peers’ peers. Appeals to justice will
take the form of petitions through multiple, interconnected channels.
Using these tools, anyone can create a large social impact. With
multiple devices and many social applications, each of us can become
more sociable, and society more individual. We no longer have to act
alone.
Emergent democracy will only happen when Sharism becomes the literacy of
the majority. Since Sharism can improve communication, collaboration and
mutual understanding, I believe it has a place within the educational
system. Sharism can be applied to any cultural discourse, CoP (Community
of Practice) or problem-solving context. It is also an antidote to
social depression, since sharelessness is just dragging our society
down. In present or formerly totalitarian countries, this downward cycle
is even more apparent. The future world will be a hybrid of human and
machine that will generate better and faster decisions anytime,
anywhere. The flow of information between minds will become more
flexible and more productive. These vast networks of sharing will create
a new social order−A Mind Revolution!
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/07-isaac-mao-sharism.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | What is a neuron? | 99923_RF46WKUJ_2 | [
"A part of the nervous system",
"A simple organic cell",
"A synapse",
"A very powerful, electrically excitable biological processor"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,923 | 99923_RF46WKUJ | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Sharism: A Mind Revolution | nan | Isaac Mao | Essay | Sharism: A Mind Revolution
With the People of the World Wide Web communicating more fully and
freely in Social Media while rallying a Web 2.0 content boom, the inner
dynamics of such a creative explosion must be studied more closely. What
motivates those who join this movement and what future will they create?
A key fact is that a superabundance of community respect and social
capital are being accumulated by those who share. The key motivator of
Social Media and the core spirit of Web 2.0 is a mind switch called
Sharism. Sharism suggests a re-orientation of personal values. We see it
in User Generated Content. It is the pledge of Creative Commons. It is
in the plans of future-oriented cultural initiatives. Sharism is also a
mental practice that anyone can try, a social-psychological attitude to
transform a wide and isolated world into a super-smart Social Brain.
The Neuron Doctrine
Sharism is encoded in the Human Genome. Although eclipsed by the many
pragmatisms of daily life, the theory of Sharism finds basis in
neuroscience and its study of the working model of the human brain.
Although we can’t entirely say how the brain works as a whole, we do
have a model of the functional mechanism of the nervous system and its
neurons. A neuron is not a simple organic cell, but a very powerful,
electrically excitable biological processor. Groups of neurons form
vastly interconnected networks, which, by changing the strength of the
synapses between cells, can process information, and learn. A neuron, by
sharing chemical signals with its neighbors, can be integrated into more
meaningful patterns that keep the neuron active and alive. Moreover,
such a simple logic can be iterated and amplified, since all neurons
work on a similar principle of connecting and sharing. Originally, the
brain is quite open. A neural network exists to share activity and
information, and I believe this model of the brain should inspire ideas
and decisions about human networks.
Thus, our brain supports sharing in its very system-nature. This has
profound implications for the creative process. Whenever you have an
intention to create, you will find it easier to generate more creative
ideas if you keep the sharing process firmly in mind. The
idea-forming-process is not linear, but more like an avalanche of
amplifications along the thinking path. It moves with the momentum of a
creative snowball. If your internal cognitive system encourages sharing,
you can engineer a feedback loop of happiness, which will help you
generate even more ideas in return. It’s a kind of butterfly- effect, as
the small creative energy you spend will eventually return to make you,
and the world, more creative.
However, daily decisions for most adults are quite low in creative
productivity, if only because they’ve switched off their sharing paths.
People generally like to share what they create, but in a culture that
tells them to be protective of their ideas, people start to believe in
the danger of sharing. Then Sharism will be degraded in their mind and
not encouraged in their society. But if we can encourage someone to
share, her sharing paths will stay open. Sharism will be kept in her
mind as a memory and an instinct. If in the future she faces a creative
choice, her choice will be, “Share.”
These mind-switches are too subtle to be felt. But since the brain, and
society, is a connected system, the accumulation of these
micro-attitudes, from neuron to neuron and person to person, can result
in observable behavior. It is easy to tell if a person, a group, a
company, a nation is oriented toward Sharism or not. For those who are
not, what they defend as “cultural goods” and “intellectual property”
are just excuses for the status quo of keeping a community closed. Much
of their “culture” will be protected, but the net result is the direct
loss of many other precious ideas, and the subsequent loss of all the
potential gains of sharing. This lost knowledge is a black hole in our
life, which may start to swallow other values as well.
Non-sharing culture misleads us with its absolute separation of Private
and Public space. It makes creative action a binary choice between
public and private, open and closed. This creates a gap in the spectrum
of knowledge. Although this gap has the potential to become a valuable
creative space, concerns about privacy make this gap hard to fill. We
shouldn’t be surprised that, to be safe, most people keep their sharing
private and stay “closed.” They may fear the Internet creates a
potential for abuse that they can’t fight alone. However, the paradox
is: The less you share, the less power you have.
New Technologies and the Rise of Sharism
Let’s track back to 1999, when there were only a few hundred pioneer
bloggers around the world, and no more than ten times that many readers
following each blog. Human history is always so: something important was
happening, but the rest of the world hadn’t yet realized it. The shift
toward easy-to-use online publishing triggered a soft revolution in just
five years. People made a quick and easy transition from reading blogs,
to leaving comments and taking part in online conversations, and then to
the sudden realization that they should become bloggers themselves. More
bloggers created more readers, and more readers made more blogs. The
revolution was viral.
Bloggers generate lively and timely information on the Internet, and
connect to each other with RSS, hyperlinks, comments, trackbacks and
quotes. The small-scale granularity of the content can fill discrete
gaps in experience and thus record a new human history. Once you become
a blogger, once you have accumulated so much social capital in such a
small site, it’s hard to stop. We can’t explain this fact with a theory
of addiction. It’s an impulse to share. It’s the energy of the memes
that want to be passed from mouth to mouth and mind to mind. It’s more
than just E-mail. It’s Sharism.
Bloggers are always keen to keep the social context of their posts in
mind, by asking themselves, “Who is going to see this?” Bloggers are
agile in adjusting their tone−and privacy settings−to advance ideas and
stay out of trouble. It’s not self-censorship, but a sense of smart
expression. But once blogs reached the tipping point, they expanded into
the blogosphere. This required a more delicate social networking system
and content- sharing architecture. But people now understand that they
can have better control over a wide spectrum of relationships. Like how
Flickr allows people to share their photos widely, but safely. The
checkbox-based privacy of Flickr may seem unfamiliar to a new user, but
you can use it to toy with the mind-switches of Sharism. By checking a
box we can choose to share or not to share. From my observations, I have
seen photographers on Flickr become more open to sharing, while
retaining flexible choices.
The rapid emergence of Social Applications that can communicate and
cooperate, by allowing people to output content from one service to
another, is letting users pump their memes into a pipeline-like
ecosystem. This interconnectedness allows memes to travel along multiple
online social networks, and potentially reach a huge audience. As a
result, such a Micro-pipeline system is making Social Media a true
alternative to broadcast media. These new technologies are reviving
Sharism in our closed culture.
Local Practice, Global Gain
If you happened to lose your Sharism in a bad educational or cultural
setting, it’s hard to get it back. But it’s not impossible. A
persistence of practice can lead to a full recovery. You can think of
Sharism as a spiritual practice. But you must practice everyday.
Otherwise, you might lose the power of sharing. Permanently.
You might need something to spur you on, to keep you from quitting and
returning to a closed mindset. Here’s an idea: put a sticky note on your
desk that says, “What do you want to share today?” I’m not kidding.
Then, if anything interesting comes your way: Share It! The easiest way
to both start and keep sharing is by using different kinds of social
software applications. Your first meme you want to share may be small,
but you can amplify it with new technologies. Enlist some people from
your network and invite them into a new social application. At first it
might be hard to feel the gains of Sharism. The true test then is to see
if you can keep track of the feedback that you get from sharing. You
will realize that almost all sharing activities will generate positive
results. The happiness that this will obtain is only the most immediate
reward. But there are others.
The first type of reward that you will get comes in the form of
comments. Then you know you’ve provoked interest, appreciation,
excitement. The second reward is access to all the other stuff being
shared by friends in your network. Since you know and trust them, you
will be that much more interested in what they have to share. Already,
the return is a multiple of the small meme you first shared. But the
third type of return is more dramatic still. Anything you share can be
forwarded, circulated and republished via other people’s networks. This
cascade effect can spread your work to the networked masses.
Improvements in social software are making the speed of dissemination as
fast as a mouse-click. You should get to know the Sharism-You. You’re
about to become popular, and fast
This brings us to the fourth and final type of return. It has a meaning
not only for you, but for the whole of society. If you so choose, you
may allow others to create derivative works from what you share. This
one choice could easily snowball into more creations along the sharing
path, from people at key nodes in the network who are all as passionate
about creating and sharing as you are. After many iterative rounds of
development, a large creative work may spring from your choice to share.
Of course, you will get the credit that you asked for, and deserve. And
it’s okay to seek financial rewards. But you will in every case get
something just as substantial: Happiness.
The more people who create in the spirit of Sharism, the easier it will
be to attain well- balanced and equitable Social Media that is woven by
people themselves. Media won’t be controlled by any single person but
will rely on the even distribution of social networking. These “Shaeros”
(Sharing Heroes) will naturally become the opinion leaders in the first
wave of Social Media. However, these media rights will belong to
everyone. You yourself can be both producer and consumer in such a
system.
Sharism Safeguards Your Rights
Still, many questions will be raised about Sharism as an initiative in
new age. The main one is copyright. One concern is that any loss of
control over copyrighted content will lead to noticeable deficits in
personal wealth, or just loss of control. 5 years ago, I would have said
that this was a possibility. But things are changing today. The sharing
environment is more protected than you might think. Many new social
applications make it easy to set terms-of-use along your sharing path.
Any infringement of those terms will be challenged not just by the law,
but by your community. Your audience, who benefit form your sharing, can
also be the gatekeepers of your rights. Even if you are a traditional
copyright holder, this sounds ideal.
Furthermore, by realizing all the immediate and emergent rewards that
can be had by sharing, you may eventually find that copyright and “All
Rights Reserved” are far from your mind. You will enjoy sharing too much
to worry about who is keeping a copy. The new economic formula is, the
more people remix your works, the higher the return.
I want to point out that Sharism is not Communism, nor Socialism. As for
those die- hard Communists we know, they have often abused people’s
sharing nature and forced them to give up their rights, and their
property. Socialism, that tender Communism, in our experience also
lacked respect for these rights. Under these systems, the state owns all
property. Under Sharism, you can keep ownership, if you want. But I like
to share. And this is how I choose to spread ideas, and prosperity
Sharism is totally based on your own consensus. It’s not a very hard
concept to understand, especially since copyleft movements like the Free
Software Foundation and Creative Commons have been around for years.
These movements are redefining a more flexible spectrum of licenses for
both developers and end-users to tag their works. Because the new
licenses can be recognized by either humans or machines, it’s becoming
easier to re-share those works in new online ecosystems.
The Spirit of the Web, a Social Brain
Sharism is the Spirit of the Age of Web 2.0. It has the consistency of a
naturalized Epistemology and modernized Axiology, but also promises the
power of a new Internet philosophy. Sharism will transform the world
into an emergent Social Brain: a networked hybrid of people and
software. We are Networked Neurons connected by the synapses of Social
Software.
This is an evolutionary leap, a small step for us and a giant one for
human society. With new “hairy” emergent technologies sprouting all
around us, we can generate higher connectivities and increase the
throughput of our social links. The more open and strongly connected we
social neurons are, the better the sharing environment will be for all
people. The more collective our intelligence, the wiser our actions will
be. People have always found better solutions through conversations. Now
we can put it all online.
Sharism will be the politics of the next global superpower. It will not
be a country, but a new human network joined by Social Software. This
may remain a distant dream, and even a well-defined public sharing
policy might not be close at hand. But the ideas that I’m discussing can
improve governments today. We can integrate our current and emerging
democratic systems with new folksonomies (based on the collaborative,
social indexing of information) to enable people to make queries, share
data and remix information for public use. The collective intelligence
of a vast and equitable sharing environment can be the gatekeeper of our
rights, and a government watchdog. In the future, policymaking can be
made more nuanced with the micro-involvement of the sharing community.
This “Emergent Democracy” is more real-time than periodical
parliamentary sessions. It will also increase the spectrum of our
choices, beyond the binary options of “Yes” or “No” referenda.
Representative democracy will become more timely and diligent, because
we will represent ourselves within the system.
Sharism will result in better social justice. In a healthy sharing
environment, any evidence of injustice can get amplified to get the
public’s attention. Anyone who has been abused can get real and instant
support from her peers and her peers’ peers. Appeals to justice will
take the form of petitions through multiple, interconnected channels.
Using these tools, anyone can create a large social impact. With
multiple devices and many social applications, each of us can become
more sociable, and society more individual. We no longer have to act
alone.
Emergent democracy will only happen when Sharism becomes the literacy of
the majority. Since Sharism can improve communication, collaboration and
mutual understanding, I believe it has a place within the educational
system. Sharism can be applied to any cultural discourse, CoP (Community
of Practice) or problem-solving context. It is also an antidote to
social depression, since sharelessness is just dragging our society
down. In present or formerly totalitarian countries, this downward cycle
is even more apparent. The future world will be a hybrid of human and
machine that will generate better and faster decisions anytime,
anywhere. The flow of information between minds will become more
flexible and more productive. These vast networks of sharing will create
a new social order−A Mind Revolution!
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/07-isaac-mao-sharism.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | What do neurons do? | 99923_RF46WKUJ_3 | [
"Form vastly interconnected networks",
"Process information and learn",
"Change the strength of the synapses between cells",
"Share chemical signals with neighboring cells"
] | 4 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
99,923 | 99923_RF46WKUJ | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Sharism: A Mind Revolution | nan | Isaac Mao | Essay | Sharism: A Mind Revolution
With the People of the World Wide Web communicating more fully and
freely in Social Media while rallying a Web 2.0 content boom, the inner
dynamics of such a creative explosion must be studied more closely. What
motivates those who join this movement and what future will they create?
A key fact is that a superabundance of community respect and social
capital are being accumulated by those who share. The key motivator of
Social Media and the core spirit of Web 2.0 is a mind switch called
Sharism. Sharism suggests a re-orientation of personal values. We see it
in User Generated Content. It is the pledge of Creative Commons. It is
in the plans of future-oriented cultural initiatives. Sharism is also a
mental practice that anyone can try, a social-psychological attitude to
transform a wide and isolated world into a super-smart Social Brain.
The Neuron Doctrine
Sharism is encoded in the Human Genome. Although eclipsed by the many
pragmatisms of daily life, the theory of Sharism finds basis in
neuroscience and its study of the working model of the human brain.
Although we can’t entirely say how the brain works as a whole, we do
have a model of the functional mechanism of the nervous system and its
neurons. A neuron is not a simple organic cell, but a very powerful,
electrically excitable biological processor. Groups of neurons form
vastly interconnected networks, which, by changing the strength of the
synapses between cells, can process information, and learn. A neuron, by
sharing chemical signals with its neighbors, can be integrated into more
meaningful patterns that keep the neuron active and alive. Moreover,
such a simple logic can be iterated and amplified, since all neurons
work on a similar principle of connecting and sharing. Originally, the
brain is quite open. A neural network exists to share activity and
information, and I believe this model of the brain should inspire ideas
and decisions about human networks.
Thus, our brain supports sharing in its very system-nature. This has
profound implications for the creative process. Whenever you have an
intention to create, you will find it easier to generate more creative
ideas if you keep the sharing process firmly in mind. The
idea-forming-process is not linear, but more like an avalanche of
amplifications along the thinking path. It moves with the momentum of a
creative snowball. If your internal cognitive system encourages sharing,
you can engineer a feedback loop of happiness, which will help you
generate even more ideas in return. It’s a kind of butterfly- effect, as
the small creative energy you spend will eventually return to make you,
and the world, more creative.
However, daily decisions for most adults are quite low in creative
productivity, if only because they’ve switched off their sharing paths.
People generally like to share what they create, but in a culture that
tells them to be protective of their ideas, people start to believe in
the danger of sharing. Then Sharism will be degraded in their mind and
not encouraged in their society. But if we can encourage someone to
share, her sharing paths will stay open. Sharism will be kept in her
mind as a memory and an instinct. If in the future she faces a creative
choice, her choice will be, “Share.”
These mind-switches are too subtle to be felt. But since the brain, and
society, is a connected system, the accumulation of these
micro-attitudes, from neuron to neuron and person to person, can result
in observable behavior. It is easy to tell if a person, a group, a
company, a nation is oriented toward Sharism or not. For those who are
not, what they defend as “cultural goods” and “intellectual property”
are just excuses for the status quo of keeping a community closed. Much
of their “culture” will be protected, but the net result is the direct
loss of many other precious ideas, and the subsequent loss of all the
potential gains of sharing. This lost knowledge is a black hole in our
life, which may start to swallow other values as well.
Non-sharing culture misleads us with its absolute separation of Private
and Public space. It makes creative action a binary choice between
public and private, open and closed. This creates a gap in the spectrum
of knowledge. Although this gap has the potential to become a valuable
creative space, concerns about privacy make this gap hard to fill. We
shouldn’t be surprised that, to be safe, most people keep their sharing
private and stay “closed.” They may fear the Internet creates a
potential for abuse that they can’t fight alone. However, the paradox
is: The less you share, the less power you have.
New Technologies and the Rise of Sharism
Let’s track back to 1999, when there were only a few hundred pioneer
bloggers around the world, and no more than ten times that many readers
following each blog. Human history is always so: something important was
happening, but the rest of the world hadn’t yet realized it. The shift
toward easy-to-use online publishing triggered a soft revolution in just
five years. People made a quick and easy transition from reading blogs,
to leaving comments and taking part in online conversations, and then to
the sudden realization that they should become bloggers themselves. More
bloggers created more readers, and more readers made more blogs. The
revolution was viral.
Bloggers generate lively and timely information on the Internet, and
connect to each other with RSS, hyperlinks, comments, trackbacks and
quotes. The small-scale granularity of the content can fill discrete
gaps in experience and thus record a new human history. Once you become
a blogger, once you have accumulated so much social capital in such a
small site, it’s hard to stop. We can’t explain this fact with a theory
of addiction. It’s an impulse to share. It’s the energy of the memes
that want to be passed from mouth to mouth and mind to mind. It’s more
than just E-mail. It’s Sharism.
Bloggers are always keen to keep the social context of their posts in
mind, by asking themselves, “Who is going to see this?” Bloggers are
agile in adjusting their tone−and privacy settings−to advance ideas and
stay out of trouble. It’s not self-censorship, but a sense of smart
expression. But once blogs reached the tipping point, they expanded into
the blogosphere. This required a more delicate social networking system
and content- sharing architecture. But people now understand that they
can have better control over a wide spectrum of relationships. Like how
Flickr allows people to share their photos widely, but safely. The
checkbox-based privacy of Flickr may seem unfamiliar to a new user, but
you can use it to toy with the mind-switches of Sharism. By checking a
box we can choose to share or not to share. From my observations, I have
seen photographers on Flickr become more open to sharing, while
retaining flexible choices.
The rapid emergence of Social Applications that can communicate and
cooperate, by allowing people to output content from one service to
another, is letting users pump their memes into a pipeline-like
ecosystem. This interconnectedness allows memes to travel along multiple
online social networks, and potentially reach a huge audience. As a
result, such a Micro-pipeline system is making Social Media a true
alternative to broadcast media. These new technologies are reviving
Sharism in our closed culture.
Local Practice, Global Gain
If you happened to lose your Sharism in a bad educational or cultural
setting, it’s hard to get it back. But it’s not impossible. A
persistence of practice can lead to a full recovery. You can think of
Sharism as a spiritual practice. But you must practice everyday.
Otherwise, you might lose the power of sharing. Permanently.
You might need something to spur you on, to keep you from quitting and
returning to a closed mindset. Here’s an idea: put a sticky note on your
desk that says, “What do you want to share today?” I’m not kidding.
Then, if anything interesting comes your way: Share It! The easiest way
to both start and keep sharing is by using different kinds of social
software applications. Your first meme you want to share may be small,
but you can amplify it with new technologies. Enlist some people from
your network and invite them into a new social application. At first it
might be hard to feel the gains of Sharism. The true test then is to see
if you can keep track of the feedback that you get from sharing. You
will realize that almost all sharing activities will generate positive
results. The happiness that this will obtain is only the most immediate
reward. But there are others.
The first type of reward that you will get comes in the form of
comments. Then you know you’ve provoked interest, appreciation,
excitement. The second reward is access to all the other stuff being
shared by friends in your network. Since you know and trust them, you
will be that much more interested in what they have to share. Already,
the return is a multiple of the small meme you first shared. But the
third type of return is more dramatic still. Anything you share can be
forwarded, circulated and republished via other people’s networks. This
cascade effect can spread your work to the networked masses.
Improvements in social software are making the speed of dissemination as
fast as a mouse-click. You should get to know the Sharism-You. You’re
about to become popular, and fast
This brings us to the fourth and final type of return. It has a meaning
not only for you, but for the whole of society. If you so choose, you
may allow others to create derivative works from what you share. This
one choice could easily snowball into more creations along the sharing
path, from people at key nodes in the network who are all as passionate
about creating and sharing as you are. After many iterative rounds of
development, a large creative work may spring from your choice to share.
Of course, you will get the credit that you asked for, and deserve. And
it’s okay to seek financial rewards. But you will in every case get
something just as substantial: Happiness.
The more people who create in the spirit of Sharism, the easier it will
be to attain well- balanced and equitable Social Media that is woven by
people themselves. Media won’t be controlled by any single person but
will rely on the even distribution of social networking. These “Shaeros”
(Sharing Heroes) will naturally become the opinion leaders in the first
wave of Social Media. However, these media rights will belong to
everyone. You yourself can be both producer and consumer in such a
system.
Sharism Safeguards Your Rights
Still, many questions will be raised about Sharism as an initiative in
new age. The main one is copyright. One concern is that any loss of
control over copyrighted content will lead to noticeable deficits in
personal wealth, or just loss of control. 5 years ago, I would have said
that this was a possibility. But things are changing today. The sharing
environment is more protected than you might think. Many new social
applications make it easy to set terms-of-use along your sharing path.
Any infringement of those terms will be challenged not just by the law,
but by your community. Your audience, who benefit form your sharing, can
also be the gatekeepers of your rights. Even if you are a traditional
copyright holder, this sounds ideal.
Furthermore, by realizing all the immediate and emergent rewards that
can be had by sharing, you may eventually find that copyright and “All
Rights Reserved” are far from your mind. You will enjoy sharing too much
to worry about who is keeping a copy. The new economic formula is, the
more people remix your works, the higher the return.
I want to point out that Sharism is not Communism, nor Socialism. As for
those die- hard Communists we know, they have often abused people’s
sharing nature and forced them to give up their rights, and their
property. Socialism, that tender Communism, in our experience also
lacked respect for these rights. Under these systems, the state owns all
property. Under Sharism, you can keep ownership, if you want. But I like
to share. And this is how I choose to spread ideas, and prosperity
Sharism is totally based on your own consensus. It’s not a very hard
concept to understand, especially since copyleft movements like the Free
Software Foundation and Creative Commons have been around for years.
These movements are redefining a more flexible spectrum of licenses for
both developers and end-users to tag their works. Because the new
licenses can be recognized by either humans or machines, it’s becoming
easier to re-share those works in new online ecosystems.
The Spirit of the Web, a Social Brain
Sharism is the Spirit of the Age of Web 2.0. It has the consistency of a
naturalized Epistemology and modernized Axiology, but also promises the
power of a new Internet philosophy. Sharism will transform the world
into an emergent Social Brain: a networked hybrid of people and
software. We are Networked Neurons connected by the synapses of Social
Software.
This is an evolutionary leap, a small step for us and a giant one for
human society. With new “hairy” emergent technologies sprouting all
around us, we can generate higher connectivities and increase the
throughput of our social links. The more open and strongly connected we
social neurons are, the better the sharing environment will be for all
people. The more collective our intelligence, the wiser our actions will
be. People have always found better solutions through conversations. Now
we can put it all online.
Sharism will be the politics of the next global superpower. It will not
be a country, but a new human network joined by Social Software. This
may remain a distant dream, and even a well-defined public sharing
policy might not be close at hand. But the ideas that I’m discussing can
improve governments today. We can integrate our current and emerging
democratic systems with new folksonomies (based on the collaborative,
social indexing of information) to enable people to make queries, share
data and remix information for public use. The collective intelligence
of a vast and equitable sharing environment can be the gatekeeper of our
rights, and a government watchdog. In the future, policymaking can be
made more nuanced with the micro-involvement of the sharing community.
This “Emergent Democracy” is more real-time than periodical
parliamentary sessions. It will also increase the spectrum of our
choices, beyond the binary options of “Yes” or “No” referenda.
Representative democracy will become more timely and diligent, because
we will represent ourselves within the system.
Sharism will result in better social justice. In a healthy sharing
environment, any evidence of injustice can get amplified to get the
public’s attention. Anyone who has been abused can get real and instant
support from her peers and her peers’ peers. Appeals to justice will
take the form of petitions through multiple, interconnected channels.
Using these tools, anyone can create a large social impact. With
multiple devices and many social applications, each of us can become
more sociable, and society more individual. We no longer have to act
alone.
Emergent democracy will only happen when Sharism becomes the literacy of
the majority. Since Sharism can improve communication, collaboration and
mutual understanding, I believe it has a place within the educational
system. Sharism can be applied to any cultural discourse, CoP (Community
of Practice) or problem-solving context. It is also an antidote to
social depression, since sharelessness is just dragging our society
down. In present or formerly totalitarian countries, this downward cycle
is even more apparent. The future world will be a hybrid of human and
machine that will generate better and faster decisions anytime,
anywhere. The flow of information between minds will become more
flexible and more productive. These vast networks of sharing will create
a new social order−A Mind Revolution!
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/07-isaac-mao-sharism.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | The less you share... | 99923_RF46WKUJ_4 | [
"...the more privacy you have.",
"...the more your intellectual property is protected.",
"...the less power you have.",
"...the less your cultural goods will be appropriated."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,923 | 99923_RF46WKUJ | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Sharism: A Mind Revolution | nan | Isaac Mao | Essay | Sharism: A Mind Revolution
With the People of the World Wide Web communicating more fully and
freely in Social Media while rallying a Web 2.0 content boom, the inner
dynamics of such a creative explosion must be studied more closely. What
motivates those who join this movement and what future will they create?
A key fact is that a superabundance of community respect and social
capital are being accumulated by those who share. The key motivator of
Social Media and the core spirit of Web 2.0 is a mind switch called
Sharism. Sharism suggests a re-orientation of personal values. We see it
in User Generated Content. It is the pledge of Creative Commons. It is
in the plans of future-oriented cultural initiatives. Sharism is also a
mental practice that anyone can try, a social-psychological attitude to
transform a wide and isolated world into a super-smart Social Brain.
The Neuron Doctrine
Sharism is encoded in the Human Genome. Although eclipsed by the many
pragmatisms of daily life, the theory of Sharism finds basis in
neuroscience and its study of the working model of the human brain.
Although we can’t entirely say how the brain works as a whole, we do
have a model of the functional mechanism of the nervous system and its
neurons. A neuron is not a simple organic cell, but a very powerful,
electrically excitable biological processor. Groups of neurons form
vastly interconnected networks, which, by changing the strength of the
synapses between cells, can process information, and learn. A neuron, by
sharing chemical signals with its neighbors, can be integrated into more
meaningful patterns that keep the neuron active and alive. Moreover,
such a simple logic can be iterated and amplified, since all neurons
work on a similar principle of connecting and sharing. Originally, the
brain is quite open. A neural network exists to share activity and
information, and I believe this model of the brain should inspire ideas
and decisions about human networks.
Thus, our brain supports sharing in its very system-nature. This has
profound implications for the creative process. Whenever you have an
intention to create, you will find it easier to generate more creative
ideas if you keep the sharing process firmly in mind. The
idea-forming-process is not linear, but more like an avalanche of
amplifications along the thinking path. It moves with the momentum of a
creative snowball. If your internal cognitive system encourages sharing,
you can engineer a feedback loop of happiness, which will help you
generate even more ideas in return. It’s a kind of butterfly- effect, as
the small creative energy you spend will eventually return to make you,
and the world, more creative.
However, daily decisions for most adults are quite low in creative
productivity, if only because they’ve switched off their sharing paths.
People generally like to share what they create, but in a culture that
tells them to be protective of their ideas, people start to believe in
the danger of sharing. Then Sharism will be degraded in their mind and
not encouraged in their society. But if we can encourage someone to
share, her sharing paths will stay open. Sharism will be kept in her
mind as a memory and an instinct. If in the future she faces a creative
choice, her choice will be, “Share.”
These mind-switches are too subtle to be felt. But since the brain, and
society, is a connected system, the accumulation of these
micro-attitudes, from neuron to neuron and person to person, can result
in observable behavior. It is easy to tell if a person, a group, a
company, a nation is oriented toward Sharism or not. For those who are
not, what they defend as “cultural goods” and “intellectual property”
are just excuses for the status quo of keeping a community closed. Much
of their “culture” will be protected, but the net result is the direct
loss of many other precious ideas, and the subsequent loss of all the
potential gains of sharing. This lost knowledge is a black hole in our
life, which may start to swallow other values as well.
Non-sharing culture misleads us with its absolute separation of Private
and Public space. It makes creative action a binary choice between
public and private, open and closed. This creates a gap in the spectrum
of knowledge. Although this gap has the potential to become a valuable
creative space, concerns about privacy make this gap hard to fill. We
shouldn’t be surprised that, to be safe, most people keep their sharing
private and stay “closed.” They may fear the Internet creates a
potential for abuse that they can’t fight alone. However, the paradox
is: The less you share, the less power you have.
New Technologies and the Rise of Sharism
Let’s track back to 1999, when there were only a few hundred pioneer
bloggers around the world, and no more than ten times that many readers
following each blog. Human history is always so: something important was
happening, but the rest of the world hadn’t yet realized it. The shift
toward easy-to-use online publishing triggered a soft revolution in just
five years. People made a quick and easy transition from reading blogs,
to leaving comments and taking part in online conversations, and then to
the sudden realization that they should become bloggers themselves. More
bloggers created more readers, and more readers made more blogs. The
revolution was viral.
Bloggers generate lively and timely information on the Internet, and
connect to each other with RSS, hyperlinks, comments, trackbacks and
quotes. The small-scale granularity of the content can fill discrete
gaps in experience and thus record a new human history. Once you become
a blogger, once you have accumulated so much social capital in such a
small site, it’s hard to stop. We can’t explain this fact with a theory
of addiction. It’s an impulse to share. It’s the energy of the memes
that want to be passed from mouth to mouth and mind to mind. It’s more
than just E-mail. It’s Sharism.
Bloggers are always keen to keep the social context of their posts in
mind, by asking themselves, “Who is going to see this?” Bloggers are
agile in adjusting their tone−and privacy settings−to advance ideas and
stay out of trouble. It’s not self-censorship, but a sense of smart
expression. But once blogs reached the tipping point, they expanded into
the blogosphere. This required a more delicate social networking system
and content- sharing architecture. But people now understand that they
can have better control over a wide spectrum of relationships. Like how
Flickr allows people to share their photos widely, but safely. The
checkbox-based privacy of Flickr may seem unfamiliar to a new user, but
you can use it to toy with the mind-switches of Sharism. By checking a
box we can choose to share or not to share. From my observations, I have
seen photographers on Flickr become more open to sharing, while
retaining flexible choices.
The rapid emergence of Social Applications that can communicate and
cooperate, by allowing people to output content from one service to
another, is letting users pump their memes into a pipeline-like
ecosystem. This interconnectedness allows memes to travel along multiple
online social networks, and potentially reach a huge audience. As a
result, such a Micro-pipeline system is making Social Media a true
alternative to broadcast media. These new technologies are reviving
Sharism in our closed culture.
Local Practice, Global Gain
If you happened to lose your Sharism in a bad educational or cultural
setting, it’s hard to get it back. But it’s not impossible. A
persistence of practice can lead to a full recovery. You can think of
Sharism as a spiritual practice. But you must practice everyday.
Otherwise, you might lose the power of sharing. Permanently.
You might need something to spur you on, to keep you from quitting and
returning to a closed mindset. Here’s an idea: put a sticky note on your
desk that says, “What do you want to share today?” I’m not kidding.
Then, if anything interesting comes your way: Share It! The easiest way
to both start and keep sharing is by using different kinds of social
software applications. Your first meme you want to share may be small,
but you can amplify it with new technologies. Enlist some people from
your network and invite them into a new social application. At first it
might be hard to feel the gains of Sharism. The true test then is to see
if you can keep track of the feedback that you get from sharing. You
will realize that almost all sharing activities will generate positive
results. The happiness that this will obtain is only the most immediate
reward. But there are others.
The first type of reward that you will get comes in the form of
comments. Then you know you’ve provoked interest, appreciation,
excitement. The second reward is access to all the other stuff being
shared by friends in your network. Since you know and trust them, you
will be that much more interested in what they have to share. Already,
the return is a multiple of the small meme you first shared. But the
third type of return is more dramatic still. Anything you share can be
forwarded, circulated and republished via other people’s networks. This
cascade effect can spread your work to the networked masses.
Improvements in social software are making the speed of dissemination as
fast as a mouse-click. You should get to know the Sharism-You. You’re
about to become popular, and fast
This brings us to the fourth and final type of return. It has a meaning
not only for you, but for the whole of society. If you so choose, you
may allow others to create derivative works from what you share. This
one choice could easily snowball into more creations along the sharing
path, from people at key nodes in the network who are all as passionate
about creating and sharing as you are. After many iterative rounds of
development, a large creative work may spring from your choice to share.
Of course, you will get the credit that you asked for, and deserve. And
it’s okay to seek financial rewards. But you will in every case get
something just as substantial: Happiness.
The more people who create in the spirit of Sharism, the easier it will
be to attain well- balanced and equitable Social Media that is woven by
people themselves. Media won’t be controlled by any single person but
will rely on the even distribution of social networking. These “Shaeros”
(Sharing Heroes) will naturally become the opinion leaders in the first
wave of Social Media. However, these media rights will belong to
everyone. You yourself can be both producer and consumer in such a
system.
Sharism Safeguards Your Rights
Still, many questions will be raised about Sharism as an initiative in
new age. The main one is copyright. One concern is that any loss of
control over copyrighted content will lead to noticeable deficits in
personal wealth, or just loss of control. 5 years ago, I would have said
that this was a possibility. But things are changing today. The sharing
environment is more protected than you might think. Many new social
applications make it easy to set terms-of-use along your sharing path.
Any infringement of those terms will be challenged not just by the law,
but by your community. Your audience, who benefit form your sharing, can
also be the gatekeepers of your rights. Even if you are a traditional
copyright holder, this sounds ideal.
Furthermore, by realizing all the immediate and emergent rewards that
can be had by sharing, you may eventually find that copyright and “All
Rights Reserved” are far from your mind. You will enjoy sharing too much
to worry about who is keeping a copy. The new economic formula is, the
more people remix your works, the higher the return.
I want to point out that Sharism is not Communism, nor Socialism. As for
those die- hard Communists we know, they have often abused people’s
sharing nature and forced them to give up their rights, and their
property. Socialism, that tender Communism, in our experience also
lacked respect for these rights. Under these systems, the state owns all
property. Under Sharism, you can keep ownership, if you want. But I like
to share. And this is how I choose to spread ideas, and prosperity
Sharism is totally based on your own consensus. It’s not a very hard
concept to understand, especially since copyleft movements like the Free
Software Foundation and Creative Commons have been around for years.
These movements are redefining a more flexible spectrum of licenses for
both developers and end-users to tag their works. Because the new
licenses can be recognized by either humans or machines, it’s becoming
easier to re-share those works in new online ecosystems.
The Spirit of the Web, a Social Brain
Sharism is the Spirit of the Age of Web 2.0. It has the consistency of a
naturalized Epistemology and modernized Axiology, but also promises the
power of a new Internet philosophy. Sharism will transform the world
into an emergent Social Brain: a networked hybrid of people and
software. We are Networked Neurons connected by the synapses of Social
Software.
This is an evolutionary leap, a small step for us and a giant one for
human society. With new “hairy” emergent technologies sprouting all
around us, we can generate higher connectivities and increase the
throughput of our social links. The more open and strongly connected we
social neurons are, the better the sharing environment will be for all
people. The more collective our intelligence, the wiser our actions will
be. People have always found better solutions through conversations. Now
we can put it all online.
Sharism will be the politics of the next global superpower. It will not
be a country, but a new human network joined by Social Software. This
may remain a distant dream, and even a well-defined public sharing
policy might not be close at hand. But the ideas that I’m discussing can
improve governments today. We can integrate our current and emerging
democratic systems with new folksonomies (based on the collaborative,
social indexing of information) to enable people to make queries, share
data and remix information for public use. The collective intelligence
of a vast and equitable sharing environment can be the gatekeeper of our
rights, and a government watchdog. In the future, policymaking can be
made more nuanced with the micro-involvement of the sharing community.
This “Emergent Democracy” is more real-time than periodical
parliamentary sessions. It will also increase the spectrum of our
choices, beyond the binary options of “Yes” or “No” referenda.
Representative democracy will become more timely and diligent, because
we will represent ourselves within the system.
Sharism will result in better social justice. In a healthy sharing
environment, any evidence of injustice can get amplified to get the
public’s attention. Anyone who has been abused can get real and instant
support from her peers and her peers’ peers. Appeals to justice will
take the form of petitions through multiple, interconnected channels.
Using these tools, anyone can create a large social impact. With
multiple devices and many social applications, each of us can become
more sociable, and society more individual. We no longer have to act
alone.
Emergent democracy will only happen when Sharism becomes the literacy of
the majority. Since Sharism can improve communication, collaboration and
mutual understanding, I believe it has a place within the educational
system. Sharism can be applied to any cultural discourse, CoP (Community
of Practice) or problem-solving context. It is also an antidote to
social depression, since sharelessness is just dragging our society
down. In present or formerly totalitarian countries, this downward cycle
is even more apparent. The future world will be a hybrid of human and
machine that will generate better and faster decisions anytime,
anywhere. The flow of information between minds will become more
flexible and more productive. These vast networks of sharing will create
a new social order−A Mind Revolution!
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/07-isaac-mao-sharism.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | Bloggers... | 99923_RF46WKUJ_5 | [
"...connect to each other with RSS.",
"...generate lively and timely information.",
"...are recording human history in a new way.",
"---fill discrete gaps in human experience."
] | 3 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,923 | 99923_RF46WKUJ | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Sharism: A Mind Revolution | nan | Isaac Mao | Essay | Sharism: A Mind Revolution
With the People of the World Wide Web communicating more fully and
freely in Social Media while rallying a Web 2.0 content boom, the inner
dynamics of such a creative explosion must be studied more closely. What
motivates those who join this movement and what future will they create?
A key fact is that a superabundance of community respect and social
capital are being accumulated by those who share. The key motivator of
Social Media and the core spirit of Web 2.0 is a mind switch called
Sharism. Sharism suggests a re-orientation of personal values. We see it
in User Generated Content. It is the pledge of Creative Commons. It is
in the plans of future-oriented cultural initiatives. Sharism is also a
mental practice that anyone can try, a social-psychological attitude to
transform a wide and isolated world into a super-smart Social Brain.
The Neuron Doctrine
Sharism is encoded in the Human Genome. Although eclipsed by the many
pragmatisms of daily life, the theory of Sharism finds basis in
neuroscience and its study of the working model of the human brain.
Although we can’t entirely say how the brain works as a whole, we do
have a model of the functional mechanism of the nervous system and its
neurons. A neuron is not a simple organic cell, but a very powerful,
electrically excitable biological processor. Groups of neurons form
vastly interconnected networks, which, by changing the strength of the
synapses between cells, can process information, and learn. A neuron, by
sharing chemical signals with its neighbors, can be integrated into more
meaningful patterns that keep the neuron active and alive. Moreover,
such a simple logic can be iterated and amplified, since all neurons
work on a similar principle of connecting and sharing. Originally, the
brain is quite open. A neural network exists to share activity and
information, and I believe this model of the brain should inspire ideas
and decisions about human networks.
Thus, our brain supports sharing in its very system-nature. This has
profound implications for the creative process. Whenever you have an
intention to create, you will find it easier to generate more creative
ideas if you keep the sharing process firmly in mind. The
idea-forming-process is not linear, but more like an avalanche of
amplifications along the thinking path. It moves with the momentum of a
creative snowball. If your internal cognitive system encourages sharing,
you can engineer a feedback loop of happiness, which will help you
generate even more ideas in return. It’s a kind of butterfly- effect, as
the small creative energy you spend will eventually return to make you,
and the world, more creative.
However, daily decisions for most adults are quite low in creative
productivity, if only because they’ve switched off their sharing paths.
People generally like to share what they create, but in a culture that
tells them to be protective of their ideas, people start to believe in
the danger of sharing. Then Sharism will be degraded in their mind and
not encouraged in their society. But if we can encourage someone to
share, her sharing paths will stay open. Sharism will be kept in her
mind as a memory and an instinct. If in the future she faces a creative
choice, her choice will be, “Share.”
These mind-switches are too subtle to be felt. But since the brain, and
society, is a connected system, the accumulation of these
micro-attitudes, from neuron to neuron and person to person, can result
in observable behavior. It is easy to tell if a person, a group, a
company, a nation is oriented toward Sharism or not. For those who are
not, what they defend as “cultural goods” and “intellectual property”
are just excuses for the status quo of keeping a community closed. Much
of their “culture” will be protected, but the net result is the direct
loss of many other precious ideas, and the subsequent loss of all the
potential gains of sharing. This lost knowledge is a black hole in our
life, which may start to swallow other values as well.
Non-sharing culture misleads us with its absolute separation of Private
and Public space. It makes creative action a binary choice between
public and private, open and closed. This creates a gap in the spectrum
of knowledge. Although this gap has the potential to become a valuable
creative space, concerns about privacy make this gap hard to fill. We
shouldn’t be surprised that, to be safe, most people keep their sharing
private and stay “closed.” They may fear the Internet creates a
potential for abuse that they can’t fight alone. However, the paradox
is: The less you share, the less power you have.
New Technologies and the Rise of Sharism
Let’s track back to 1999, when there were only a few hundred pioneer
bloggers around the world, and no more than ten times that many readers
following each blog. Human history is always so: something important was
happening, but the rest of the world hadn’t yet realized it. The shift
toward easy-to-use online publishing triggered a soft revolution in just
five years. People made a quick and easy transition from reading blogs,
to leaving comments and taking part in online conversations, and then to
the sudden realization that they should become bloggers themselves. More
bloggers created more readers, and more readers made more blogs. The
revolution was viral.
Bloggers generate lively and timely information on the Internet, and
connect to each other with RSS, hyperlinks, comments, trackbacks and
quotes. The small-scale granularity of the content can fill discrete
gaps in experience and thus record a new human history. Once you become
a blogger, once you have accumulated so much social capital in such a
small site, it’s hard to stop. We can’t explain this fact with a theory
of addiction. It’s an impulse to share. It’s the energy of the memes
that want to be passed from mouth to mouth and mind to mind. It’s more
than just E-mail. It’s Sharism.
Bloggers are always keen to keep the social context of their posts in
mind, by asking themselves, “Who is going to see this?” Bloggers are
agile in adjusting their tone−and privacy settings−to advance ideas and
stay out of trouble. It’s not self-censorship, but a sense of smart
expression. But once blogs reached the tipping point, they expanded into
the blogosphere. This required a more delicate social networking system
and content- sharing architecture. But people now understand that they
can have better control over a wide spectrum of relationships. Like how
Flickr allows people to share their photos widely, but safely. The
checkbox-based privacy of Flickr may seem unfamiliar to a new user, but
you can use it to toy with the mind-switches of Sharism. By checking a
box we can choose to share or not to share. From my observations, I have
seen photographers on Flickr become more open to sharing, while
retaining flexible choices.
The rapid emergence of Social Applications that can communicate and
cooperate, by allowing people to output content from one service to
another, is letting users pump their memes into a pipeline-like
ecosystem. This interconnectedness allows memes to travel along multiple
online social networks, and potentially reach a huge audience. As a
result, such a Micro-pipeline system is making Social Media a true
alternative to broadcast media. These new technologies are reviving
Sharism in our closed culture.
Local Practice, Global Gain
If you happened to lose your Sharism in a bad educational or cultural
setting, it’s hard to get it back. But it’s not impossible. A
persistence of practice can lead to a full recovery. You can think of
Sharism as a spiritual practice. But you must practice everyday.
Otherwise, you might lose the power of sharing. Permanently.
You might need something to spur you on, to keep you from quitting and
returning to a closed mindset. Here’s an idea: put a sticky note on your
desk that says, “What do you want to share today?” I’m not kidding.
Then, if anything interesting comes your way: Share It! The easiest way
to both start and keep sharing is by using different kinds of social
software applications. Your first meme you want to share may be small,
but you can amplify it with new technologies. Enlist some people from
your network and invite them into a new social application. At first it
might be hard to feel the gains of Sharism. The true test then is to see
if you can keep track of the feedback that you get from sharing. You
will realize that almost all sharing activities will generate positive
results. The happiness that this will obtain is only the most immediate
reward. But there are others.
The first type of reward that you will get comes in the form of
comments. Then you know you’ve provoked interest, appreciation,
excitement. The second reward is access to all the other stuff being
shared by friends in your network. Since you know and trust them, you
will be that much more interested in what they have to share. Already,
the return is a multiple of the small meme you first shared. But the
third type of return is more dramatic still. Anything you share can be
forwarded, circulated and republished via other people’s networks. This
cascade effect can spread your work to the networked masses.
Improvements in social software are making the speed of dissemination as
fast as a mouse-click. You should get to know the Sharism-You. You’re
about to become popular, and fast
This brings us to the fourth and final type of return. It has a meaning
not only for you, but for the whole of society. If you so choose, you
may allow others to create derivative works from what you share. This
one choice could easily snowball into more creations along the sharing
path, from people at key nodes in the network who are all as passionate
about creating and sharing as you are. After many iterative rounds of
development, a large creative work may spring from your choice to share.
Of course, you will get the credit that you asked for, and deserve. And
it’s okay to seek financial rewards. But you will in every case get
something just as substantial: Happiness.
The more people who create in the spirit of Sharism, the easier it will
be to attain well- balanced and equitable Social Media that is woven by
people themselves. Media won’t be controlled by any single person but
will rely on the even distribution of social networking. These “Shaeros”
(Sharing Heroes) will naturally become the opinion leaders in the first
wave of Social Media. However, these media rights will belong to
everyone. You yourself can be both producer and consumer in such a
system.
Sharism Safeguards Your Rights
Still, many questions will be raised about Sharism as an initiative in
new age. The main one is copyright. One concern is that any loss of
control over copyrighted content will lead to noticeable deficits in
personal wealth, or just loss of control. 5 years ago, I would have said
that this was a possibility. But things are changing today. The sharing
environment is more protected than you might think. Many new social
applications make it easy to set terms-of-use along your sharing path.
Any infringement of those terms will be challenged not just by the law,
but by your community. Your audience, who benefit form your sharing, can
also be the gatekeepers of your rights. Even if you are a traditional
copyright holder, this sounds ideal.
Furthermore, by realizing all the immediate and emergent rewards that
can be had by sharing, you may eventually find that copyright and “All
Rights Reserved” are far from your mind. You will enjoy sharing too much
to worry about who is keeping a copy. The new economic formula is, the
more people remix your works, the higher the return.
I want to point out that Sharism is not Communism, nor Socialism. As for
those die- hard Communists we know, they have often abused people’s
sharing nature and forced them to give up their rights, and their
property. Socialism, that tender Communism, in our experience also
lacked respect for these rights. Under these systems, the state owns all
property. Under Sharism, you can keep ownership, if you want. But I like
to share. And this is how I choose to spread ideas, and prosperity
Sharism is totally based on your own consensus. It’s not a very hard
concept to understand, especially since copyleft movements like the Free
Software Foundation and Creative Commons have been around for years.
These movements are redefining a more flexible spectrum of licenses for
both developers and end-users to tag their works. Because the new
licenses can be recognized by either humans or machines, it’s becoming
easier to re-share those works in new online ecosystems.
The Spirit of the Web, a Social Brain
Sharism is the Spirit of the Age of Web 2.0. It has the consistency of a
naturalized Epistemology and modernized Axiology, but also promises the
power of a new Internet philosophy. Sharism will transform the world
into an emergent Social Brain: a networked hybrid of people and
software. We are Networked Neurons connected by the synapses of Social
Software.
This is an evolutionary leap, a small step for us and a giant one for
human society. With new “hairy” emergent technologies sprouting all
around us, we can generate higher connectivities and increase the
throughput of our social links. The more open and strongly connected we
social neurons are, the better the sharing environment will be for all
people. The more collective our intelligence, the wiser our actions will
be. People have always found better solutions through conversations. Now
we can put it all online.
Sharism will be the politics of the next global superpower. It will not
be a country, but a new human network joined by Social Software. This
may remain a distant dream, and even a well-defined public sharing
policy might not be close at hand. But the ideas that I’m discussing can
improve governments today. We can integrate our current and emerging
democratic systems with new folksonomies (based on the collaborative,
social indexing of information) to enable people to make queries, share
data and remix information for public use. The collective intelligence
of a vast and equitable sharing environment can be the gatekeeper of our
rights, and a government watchdog. In the future, policymaking can be
made more nuanced with the micro-involvement of the sharing community.
This “Emergent Democracy” is more real-time than periodical
parliamentary sessions. It will also increase the spectrum of our
choices, beyond the binary options of “Yes” or “No” referenda.
Representative democracy will become more timely and diligent, because
we will represent ourselves within the system.
Sharism will result in better social justice. In a healthy sharing
environment, any evidence of injustice can get amplified to get the
public’s attention. Anyone who has been abused can get real and instant
support from her peers and her peers’ peers. Appeals to justice will
take the form of petitions through multiple, interconnected channels.
Using these tools, anyone can create a large social impact. With
multiple devices and many social applications, each of us can become
more sociable, and society more individual. We no longer have to act
alone.
Emergent democracy will only happen when Sharism becomes the literacy of
the majority. Since Sharism can improve communication, collaboration and
mutual understanding, I believe it has a place within the educational
system. Sharism can be applied to any cultural discourse, CoP (Community
of Practice) or problem-solving context. It is also an antidote to
social depression, since sharelessness is just dragging our society
down. In present or formerly totalitarian countries, this downward cycle
is even more apparent. The future world will be a hybrid of human and
machine that will generate better and faster decisions anytime,
anywhere. The flow of information between minds will become more
flexible and more productive. These vast networks of sharing will create
a new social order−A Mind Revolution!
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/07-isaac-mao-sharism.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | When bloggers adjust their tone and privacy settings, they... | 99923_RF46WKUJ_6 | [
"...are expanding the blogosphere.",
"...are self-censoring.",
"...are keeping the social context of their posts in mind.",
"...are smartly expressing themselves in a way to stay out of trouble."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,923 | 99923_RF46WKUJ | 23 | 1,018 | misc-freesouls | Sharism: A Mind Revolution | nan | Isaac Mao | Essay | Sharism: A Mind Revolution
With the People of the World Wide Web communicating more fully and
freely in Social Media while rallying a Web 2.0 content boom, the inner
dynamics of such a creative explosion must be studied more closely. What
motivates those who join this movement and what future will they create?
A key fact is that a superabundance of community respect and social
capital are being accumulated by those who share. The key motivator of
Social Media and the core spirit of Web 2.0 is a mind switch called
Sharism. Sharism suggests a re-orientation of personal values. We see it
in User Generated Content. It is the pledge of Creative Commons. It is
in the plans of future-oriented cultural initiatives. Sharism is also a
mental practice that anyone can try, a social-psychological attitude to
transform a wide and isolated world into a super-smart Social Brain.
The Neuron Doctrine
Sharism is encoded in the Human Genome. Although eclipsed by the many
pragmatisms of daily life, the theory of Sharism finds basis in
neuroscience and its study of the working model of the human brain.
Although we can’t entirely say how the brain works as a whole, we do
have a model of the functional mechanism of the nervous system and its
neurons. A neuron is not a simple organic cell, but a very powerful,
electrically excitable biological processor. Groups of neurons form
vastly interconnected networks, which, by changing the strength of the
synapses between cells, can process information, and learn. A neuron, by
sharing chemical signals with its neighbors, can be integrated into more
meaningful patterns that keep the neuron active and alive. Moreover,
such a simple logic can be iterated and amplified, since all neurons
work on a similar principle of connecting and sharing. Originally, the
brain is quite open. A neural network exists to share activity and
information, and I believe this model of the brain should inspire ideas
and decisions about human networks.
Thus, our brain supports sharing in its very system-nature. This has
profound implications for the creative process. Whenever you have an
intention to create, you will find it easier to generate more creative
ideas if you keep the sharing process firmly in mind. The
idea-forming-process is not linear, but more like an avalanche of
amplifications along the thinking path. It moves with the momentum of a
creative snowball. If your internal cognitive system encourages sharing,
you can engineer a feedback loop of happiness, which will help you
generate even more ideas in return. It’s a kind of butterfly- effect, as
the small creative energy you spend will eventually return to make you,
and the world, more creative.
However, daily decisions for most adults are quite low in creative
productivity, if only because they’ve switched off their sharing paths.
People generally like to share what they create, but in a culture that
tells them to be protective of their ideas, people start to believe in
the danger of sharing. Then Sharism will be degraded in their mind and
not encouraged in their society. But if we can encourage someone to
share, her sharing paths will stay open. Sharism will be kept in her
mind as a memory and an instinct. If in the future she faces a creative
choice, her choice will be, “Share.”
These mind-switches are too subtle to be felt. But since the brain, and
society, is a connected system, the accumulation of these
micro-attitudes, from neuron to neuron and person to person, can result
in observable behavior. It is easy to tell if a person, a group, a
company, a nation is oriented toward Sharism or not. For those who are
not, what they defend as “cultural goods” and “intellectual property”
are just excuses for the status quo of keeping a community closed. Much
of their “culture” will be protected, but the net result is the direct
loss of many other precious ideas, and the subsequent loss of all the
potential gains of sharing. This lost knowledge is a black hole in our
life, which may start to swallow other values as well.
Non-sharing culture misleads us with its absolute separation of Private
and Public space. It makes creative action a binary choice between
public and private, open and closed. This creates a gap in the spectrum
of knowledge. Although this gap has the potential to become a valuable
creative space, concerns about privacy make this gap hard to fill. We
shouldn’t be surprised that, to be safe, most people keep their sharing
private and stay “closed.” They may fear the Internet creates a
potential for abuse that they can’t fight alone. However, the paradox
is: The less you share, the less power you have.
New Technologies and the Rise of Sharism
Let’s track back to 1999, when there were only a few hundred pioneer
bloggers around the world, and no more than ten times that many readers
following each blog. Human history is always so: something important was
happening, but the rest of the world hadn’t yet realized it. The shift
toward easy-to-use online publishing triggered a soft revolution in just
five years. People made a quick and easy transition from reading blogs,
to leaving comments and taking part in online conversations, and then to
the sudden realization that they should become bloggers themselves. More
bloggers created more readers, and more readers made more blogs. The
revolution was viral.
Bloggers generate lively and timely information on the Internet, and
connect to each other with RSS, hyperlinks, comments, trackbacks and
quotes. The small-scale granularity of the content can fill discrete
gaps in experience and thus record a new human history. Once you become
a blogger, once you have accumulated so much social capital in such a
small site, it’s hard to stop. We can’t explain this fact with a theory
of addiction. It’s an impulse to share. It’s the energy of the memes
that want to be passed from mouth to mouth and mind to mind. It’s more
than just E-mail. It’s Sharism.
Bloggers are always keen to keep the social context of their posts in
mind, by asking themselves, “Who is going to see this?” Bloggers are
agile in adjusting their tone−and privacy settings−to advance ideas and
stay out of trouble. It’s not self-censorship, but a sense of smart
expression. But once blogs reached the tipping point, they expanded into
the blogosphere. This required a more delicate social networking system
and content- sharing architecture. But people now understand that they
can have better control over a wide spectrum of relationships. Like how
Flickr allows people to share their photos widely, but safely. The
checkbox-based privacy of Flickr may seem unfamiliar to a new user, but
you can use it to toy with the mind-switches of Sharism. By checking a
box we can choose to share or not to share. From my observations, I have
seen photographers on Flickr become more open to sharing, while
retaining flexible choices.
The rapid emergence of Social Applications that can communicate and
cooperate, by allowing people to output content from one service to
another, is letting users pump their memes into a pipeline-like
ecosystem. This interconnectedness allows memes to travel along multiple
online social networks, and potentially reach a huge audience. As a
result, such a Micro-pipeline system is making Social Media a true
alternative to broadcast media. These new technologies are reviving
Sharism in our closed culture.
Local Practice, Global Gain
If you happened to lose your Sharism in a bad educational or cultural
setting, it’s hard to get it back. But it’s not impossible. A
persistence of practice can lead to a full recovery. You can think of
Sharism as a spiritual practice. But you must practice everyday.
Otherwise, you might lose the power of sharing. Permanently.
You might need something to spur you on, to keep you from quitting and
returning to a closed mindset. Here’s an idea: put a sticky note on your
desk that says, “What do you want to share today?” I’m not kidding.
Then, if anything interesting comes your way: Share It! The easiest way
to both start and keep sharing is by using different kinds of social
software applications. Your first meme you want to share may be small,
but you can amplify it with new technologies. Enlist some people from
your network and invite them into a new social application. At first it
might be hard to feel the gains of Sharism. The true test then is to see
if you can keep track of the feedback that you get from sharing. You
will realize that almost all sharing activities will generate positive
results. The happiness that this will obtain is only the most immediate
reward. But there are others.
The first type of reward that you will get comes in the form of
comments. Then you know you’ve provoked interest, appreciation,
excitement. The second reward is access to all the other stuff being
shared by friends in your network. Since you know and trust them, you
will be that much more interested in what they have to share. Already,
the return is a multiple of the small meme you first shared. But the
third type of return is more dramatic still. Anything you share can be
forwarded, circulated and republished via other people’s networks. This
cascade effect can spread your work to the networked masses.
Improvements in social software are making the speed of dissemination as
fast as a mouse-click. You should get to know the Sharism-You. You’re
about to become popular, and fast
This brings us to the fourth and final type of return. It has a meaning
not only for you, but for the whole of society. If you so choose, you
may allow others to create derivative works from what you share. This
one choice could easily snowball into more creations along the sharing
path, from people at key nodes in the network who are all as passionate
about creating and sharing as you are. After many iterative rounds of
development, a large creative work may spring from your choice to share.
Of course, you will get the credit that you asked for, and deserve. And
it’s okay to seek financial rewards. But you will in every case get
something just as substantial: Happiness.
The more people who create in the spirit of Sharism, the easier it will
be to attain well- balanced and equitable Social Media that is woven by
people themselves. Media won’t be controlled by any single person but
will rely on the even distribution of social networking. These “Shaeros”
(Sharing Heroes) will naturally become the opinion leaders in the first
wave of Social Media. However, these media rights will belong to
everyone. You yourself can be both producer and consumer in such a
system.
Sharism Safeguards Your Rights
Still, many questions will be raised about Sharism as an initiative in
new age. The main one is copyright. One concern is that any loss of
control over copyrighted content will lead to noticeable deficits in
personal wealth, or just loss of control. 5 years ago, I would have said
that this was a possibility. But things are changing today. The sharing
environment is more protected than you might think. Many new social
applications make it easy to set terms-of-use along your sharing path.
Any infringement of those terms will be challenged not just by the law,
but by your community. Your audience, who benefit form your sharing, can
also be the gatekeepers of your rights. Even if you are a traditional
copyright holder, this sounds ideal.
Furthermore, by realizing all the immediate and emergent rewards that
can be had by sharing, you may eventually find that copyright and “All
Rights Reserved” are far from your mind. You will enjoy sharing too much
to worry about who is keeping a copy. The new economic formula is, the
more people remix your works, the higher the return.
I want to point out that Sharism is not Communism, nor Socialism. As for
those die- hard Communists we know, they have often abused people’s
sharing nature and forced them to give up their rights, and their
property. Socialism, that tender Communism, in our experience also
lacked respect for these rights. Under these systems, the state owns all
property. Under Sharism, you can keep ownership, if you want. But I like
to share. And this is how I choose to spread ideas, and prosperity
Sharism is totally based on your own consensus. It’s not a very hard
concept to understand, especially since copyleft movements like the Free
Software Foundation and Creative Commons have been around for years.
These movements are redefining a more flexible spectrum of licenses for
both developers and end-users to tag their works. Because the new
licenses can be recognized by either humans or machines, it’s becoming
easier to re-share those works in new online ecosystems.
The Spirit of the Web, a Social Brain
Sharism is the Spirit of the Age of Web 2.0. It has the consistency of a
naturalized Epistemology and modernized Axiology, but also promises the
power of a new Internet philosophy. Sharism will transform the world
into an emergent Social Brain: a networked hybrid of people and
software. We are Networked Neurons connected by the synapses of Social
Software.
This is an evolutionary leap, a small step for us and a giant one for
human society. With new “hairy” emergent technologies sprouting all
around us, we can generate higher connectivities and increase the
throughput of our social links. The more open and strongly connected we
social neurons are, the better the sharing environment will be for all
people. The more collective our intelligence, the wiser our actions will
be. People have always found better solutions through conversations. Now
we can put it all online.
Sharism will be the politics of the next global superpower. It will not
be a country, but a new human network joined by Social Software. This
may remain a distant dream, and even a well-defined public sharing
policy might not be close at hand. But the ideas that I’m discussing can
improve governments today. We can integrate our current and emerging
democratic systems with new folksonomies (based on the collaborative,
social indexing of information) to enable people to make queries, share
data and remix information for public use. The collective intelligence
of a vast and equitable sharing environment can be the gatekeeper of our
rights, and a government watchdog. In the future, policymaking can be
made more nuanced with the micro-involvement of the sharing community.
This “Emergent Democracy” is more real-time than periodical
parliamentary sessions. It will also increase the spectrum of our
choices, beyond the binary options of “Yes” or “No” referenda.
Representative democracy will become more timely and diligent, because
we will represent ourselves within the system.
Sharism will result in better social justice. In a healthy sharing
environment, any evidence of injustice can get amplified to get the
public’s attention. Anyone who has been abused can get real and instant
support from her peers and her peers’ peers. Appeals to justice will
take the form of petitions through multiple, interconnected channels.
Using these tools, anyone can create a large social impact. With
multiple devices and many social applications, each of us can become
more sociable, and society more individual. We no longer have to act
alone.
Emergent democracy will only happen when Sharism becomes the literacy of
the majority. Since Sharism can improve communication, collaboration and
mutual understanding, I believe it has a place within the educational
system. Sharism can be applied to any cultural discourse, CoP (Community
of Practice) or problem-solving context. It is also an antidote to
social depression, since sharelessness is just dragging our society
down. In present or formerly totalitarian countries, this downward cycle
is even more apparent. The future world will be a hybrid of human and
machine that will generate better and faster decisions anytime,
anywhere. The flow of information between minds will become more
flexible and more productive. These vast networks of sharing will create
a new social order−A Mind Revolution!
| https://freesouls.cc/essays/07-isaac-mao-sharism.html | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://freesouls.cc | What will be the politics of the next global superpower? | 99923_RF46WKUJ_7 | [
"Sharism",
"Axiology",
"Epistemology",
"Socialism"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is a Nilly? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_1 | [
"A Nilly is a trained operative used by colony transport ships to keep the colonists focused on a common enemy. ",
"A Nilly is a person who works on the crew on an interstellar ship.",
"A Nilly is a black ops agent.",
"A Nilly is a person, who is able to come back from the dead, but like Lazarus, not like a zombie."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What happened to the passengers of the Weblor I? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_2 | [
"No one knows what happened. The frequency of the Weblor I was lost several months after take off.",
"The passengers started warring with each other and the crew.",
"Space pirates boarded the ship and shoved the passengers out of the airlock.",
"The Nilly's killed them in their sleep and ate them."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How long will it take the Weblor II to make the round trip to the new colony and back? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_3 | [
"24 months",
"42 months",
"30 months",
"36 months"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | When did the Nilly first strike? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_4 | [
"One month after leaving Earth",
"Two weeks after leaving Earth",
"Two months after leaving Earth",
"Seven weeks after leaving Earth"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What happened to Mrs. Failright? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_5 | [
"She was startled.",
"She was raped.",
"She was attacked.",
"She was robbed."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What happened to Mr. Palugger? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_6 | [
"He was pushed out of the airlock.",
"He was beaten to death.",
"The man in the red mask shot him.",
"He died of his illness."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How long did it take for the passengers to form a council? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_7 | [
"One month",
"Two weeks",
"Two months",
"Ten days"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How long did it take for the passengers to form a police force? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_8 | [
"94 days",
"79 days",
"31 days",
"52 days"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
60,713 | 60713_TSA8I2K7 | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Counterweight | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Psychological fiction; Short stories; Crime -- Fiction; PS; Journalists -- Fiction; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; Science fiction | COUNTERWEIGHT
By JERRY SOHL
Every town has crime—but
especially a town that is
traveling from star to star!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, November 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Sure I'm a Nilly, and I've died seven times, always in the blackness
of the outer reaches, and I'm not alone, although there aren't very
many of us, never were.
It made sense. Interstellar was new and they wanted him on the ship
because he was a trained observer. They wanted facts, not gibberish.
But to ask a man to give up two years of his life—well, that was
asking a lot. Two years in a sardine can. Still, it had an appeal Keith
Ellason knew he couldn't deny, a newsman's joy of the clean beat, a
planetary system far afield, a closeup view of the universe, history in
the making.
Interstellar Chief Rexroad knocked the dottle from his pipe in a tray,
saying, "Transworld Press is willing to let you have a leave of
abscence, if you're interested."
He knew Secretary Phipps from years of contacting, and now Phipps said,
"Personally, I don't want to see anybody else on the job. You've got a
fine record in this sort of thing."
Keith Ellason smiled, but just barely. "You should have called me for
the first trip."
Phipps nodded. "I wish we had had you on the
Weblor I
."
"Crewmen," Rexroad said, "make poor reporters."
The
Weblor I
had taken off on the first trip to Antheon five years
before with a thousand families, reached the planet with less than five
hundred surviving colonists. Upon the return to Earth a year later, the
crew's report of suffering and chaos during the year's outgoing voyage
was twisted, distorted and fragmentary. Ellason remembered it well. The
decision of Interstellar was that the colonists started a revolution
far out in space, that it was fanned by the ignorance of Captain
Sessions in dealing with such matters.
"Space affects men in a peculiar way," Phipps said. "We have conquered
the problem of small groups in space—witness the discovery of
Antheon, for example—but when there are large groups, control is more
difficult."
"Sessions," Rexroad said, "was a bully. The trouble started at about
the halfway point. It ended with passengers engaging in open warfare
with each other and the crew. Sessions was lucky to escape with his
life."
"As I recall," Ellason said, "there was something about stunners."
Phipps rubbed his chin. "No weapons were allowed on the ship, but you
must remember the colonists were selected for their intelligence and
resourcefulness. They utilized these attributes to set up weapon shops
to arm themselves."
"The second trip is history," Rexroad said. "And a puzzle."
Ellason nodded. "The ship disappeared."
"Yes. We gave control to the colonists."
"Assuming no accident in space," Phipps said, "it was a wrong decision.
They probably took over the ship."
"And now," Ellason said, "you're going to try again."
Rexroad said very gravely, "We've got the finest captain in
Interplanetary. Harvey Branson. No doubt you've heard of him. He's
spent his life in our own system, and he's handpicking his own crew. We
have also raised prerequisites for applicants. We don't think anything
is going to happen, but if it does, we want to get an impersonal,
unprejudiced view. That's where you come in. You do the observing, the
reporting. We'll evaluate it on your return."
"If I return," said Ellason.
"I suppose that's problematical," Phipps said, "but I think you will.
Captain Branson and his fifty crewmen want to return as badly as you
do." He grinned. "You can write that novel you're always talking about
on your return trip on the
Weblor II
."
Being a Nilly is important, probably as important as running the ship,
and I think it is this thought that keeps us satisfied, willing to be
what we are.
The
Weblor II
had been built in space, as had its predecessor, the
Weblor I
, at a tremendous cost. Basically, it was an instrument
which would open distant vistas to colonization, reducing the
shoulder-to-shoulder pressure of a crowded solar system. A gigantic,
hollow spike, the ship would never land anywhere, but would circle
Antheon as it circled Earth, shuttling its cargo and passengers to the
promised land, the new frontier. A space-borne metropolis, it would
be the home for three thousand persons outward bound, only the crew
on the return trip. It was equipped with every conceivable facility
and comfort—dining rooms, assembly hall, individual and family
compartments, recreation areas, swimming pool, library, theater.
Nothing had been overlooked.
The captain's briefing room was crowded, the air was heavy with the
breathing of so many men, and the ventilators could not quite clear the
air of tobacco smoke that drifted aimlessly here and there before it
was caught and whisked away.
In the tradition of newspaperman and observer, Keith Ellason tried
to be as inconspicuous as possible, pressing against a bulkhead, but
Captain Branson's eyes sought his several times as Branson listened
to final reports from his engineers, record keepers, fuel men,
computermen, and all the rest. He grunted his approval or disapproval,
made a suggestion here, a restriction there. There was no doubt that
Branson was in charge, yet there was a human quality about him that
Ellason liked. The captain's was a lean face, well tanned, and his eyes
were chunks of blue.
"Gentlemen," Branson said at last, as Ellason knew he would, "I want
to introduce Keith Ellason, whose presence Interstellar has impressed
upon us. On loan from Transworld, he will have an observer status." He
introduced him to the others. All of them seemed friendly; Ellason
thought it was a good staff.
Branson detained him after the others had gone. "One thing, Mr.
Ellason. To make it easier for you, I suggest you think of this journey
strictly from the observer viewpoint. There will be no story for
Transworld at the end."
Ellason was startled. While he had considered the possibility, he had
not dwelt on it. Now it loomed large in his mind. "I don't understand,
Captain Branson. It seems to me—"
"Let me put it differently. Let me say that you will not understand why
I say that until the journey ends." He smiled. "Perhaps I shouldn't
have mentioned it."
Ellason left the captain's quarters with an odd taste in his mouth. Now
why had Branson said that? Why hadn't Rexroad or Phipps said something,
if it was important?
He made himself comfortable in his seven-foot-by-seven-foot cubicle,
which is to say he dropped on his bed, found it more comfortable than
he thought it would be, put his arms behind his head, stared at the
ceiling. Metal walls, no windows, one floor vent, one ceiling vent,
and a solitary ceiling molding tube-light. This would be his home for
a year, just as there were homes like it for three thousand others,
except that the family rooms would be larger. His quarters were near
the front of the spike near the officers' quarters.
He felt rather than heard the dull rumble. It was a sound he knew would
be with him for two years—one year going and one year returning.
He looked at his watch, picked up his notebook and made an entry. The
ship right now would be slipping ever so slowly away from Earth. He got
up. He'd have to go forward to the observation dome to see that. Last
view of Earth for two years.
The penetration of space by large groups is the coming out from under
the traditions of thousands of years, and as these planet-orginated
rules fall away, the floundering group seeks a new control, for they
are humanity adrift, rudderless, for whom the stars are no longer
bearings but nonexistent things, and values are altered if they are not
shown the way.
The theft of Carver Janssen's attache case occurred on the thirty-first
day out. In Ellason's mind the incident, though insignificant from the
standpoint of the ship as a whole, could very well be the cause of
dissension later on. His notes covering it were therefore very thorough.
Janssen's case contained vegetable and flower seeds—thousands of
them, according to the Captain's Bulletin, the ship's daily newsletter
which went to all hands and passengers. In the Bulletin the captain
appealed to the thief to return the case to Mr. Janssen. He said it
was significant that all en route had passed stability tests, and that
it was to the ship's discredit that someone with criminal tendencies
should have been permitted aboard.
Ellason had to smile at that. What did Captain Branson think of those
colonists who killed each other on the
Weblor I
? They had passed
stability tests too. This, then, was what happened when you took three
thousand strangers and stuck them in a can for a year.
When Ellason saw Branson about it, the captain said, "Of course I
realize it takes only a little thing like this to set things off. I
know people get tired of seeing each other, playing the same tapes,
looking at the stars from the observation dome, walking down the same
corridors, reading the same books, eating the same meals, though God
knows we try to vary it as much as we can. Space creates rough edges.
But the point is, we know all this, and knowing it, we shouldn't let it
happen. We've got to find that thief."
"What would he want seeds for? Have you thought of that?"
"Of course. They'd have real value on Antheon."
Ellason sought out Carver Janssen. He was a middle-aged man with a
tired face and sad eyes. He said, "Now what am I going to Antheon
for? I could only take along so much baggage and I threw out some
comfort items to make room for the seeds. I'm a horticulturist, and
Interstellar asked me to go along. But what use am I now? Where am
I going to get seeds like those? Do you know how long it took me to
collect them? They're not ordinary seeds, Mr. Ellason."
There was an appeal from Janssen in the next day's newsletter
describing the seeds, telling of their value, and requesting their
return in the interests of the Antheon colony and of humanity.
On the thirty-fourth day a witness turned up who said he had seen a
man emerging from Janssen's compartment with the black case. "I didn't
think anything of it at the time," Jamieson Dievers said.
Branson asked him to describe the man.
"Oh, he was about six feet tall, stocky build, and he wore a red rubber
mask that covered his head completely."
"Didn't you think that was important?" Branson asked in an outraged
voice. "A man wearing a red mask?"
Dievers shrugged. "This is a spaceship. How would I know whether a red
mask—or a blue or green one—does or doesn't belong on a spaceship?"
Although Dievers' account appeared in the newsletter, it was largely
discounted.
"If it is true," Branson told Ellason, "the theft must be the work of
a psychotic. But I don't believe Jamieson Dievers. It may well be he's
the psychotic." He snorted. "Red rubber mask! I think I'll have Dievers
put through psychiatry."
Attendant to taking notes on this incident, Ellason noted a strange
thing. Janssen lived in that part of the ship known as the First
Quadrant, and those who lived in that quadrant—more than seven hundred
men, women and children—felt that the thief must surely live in
Quadrant Two or Four. Elias Cromley, who had the compartment next to
Janssen's, sounded the consensus when he said, "Surely a man wouldn't
steal from his own quadrant, now would he, Mr. Ellason?"
And so, Ellason observed in his notebook, are wars created.
Seen in space, stars are unmoving, silent, sterile bright eyes ever
watchful and accusing. To men unused to it, such a sight numbs,
compresses, stultifies. He introduces a countermeasure, proof he
exists, which is any overt act, sometimes violent.
On the forty-fifth day June Failright, the young wife of one of the
passenger meteorologists, ran screaming down one of the long corridors
of the Third Quadrant. She told the captain she had been attacked in
her compartment while her husband was in the ship's library. She was
taken to one of the ship's doctors, who confirmed it.
She said the culprit was a husky man wearing a red rubber mask, and
though her description of what he had done did not appear in the story
in the newsletter, it lost no time in penetrating every compartment of
the ship.
Ellason was present when a delegation from the Third Quadrant called on
Captain Branson, demanding action.
Branson remained seated behind his desk, unperturbed, saying, "I have
no crewmen to spare for police duty."
The delegation commenced speaking vehemently, to be quieted by
Branson's raised hand.
"I sympathize," Branson said, "but it is up to each quadrant to deal
with its problems, whatever they may be. My job is to get us to
Antheon."
The group left in a surly mood.
"You wonder at my reluctance, Mr. Ellason," Captain Branson said. "But
suppose I assign the crew to patrol duties, the culprit isn't caught,
and further incidents occur. What then? It soon becomes the crew's
fault. And soon the colonists will begin thinking these things might be
the crew's doing in the first place."
"Yes," Ellason said, "but what if the intruder is a crewman?"
"I know my men," Branson said flatly.
"You could have a shake-down for the mask and the seed case."
"Do you think it is a member of the crew?" Branson's eyes were bright.
"No, I trust my men. I won't violate that trust."
Ellason left, feeling uneasy. If he were Branson, he'd initiate an
investigation, if nothing else than to prove the crew guiltless. Why
couldn't Branson see the wisdom of setting an example for the colonists?
As a Nilly, I knew that space breeds hate. There is a seed of
malevolence in every man. It sometimes blossoms out among the stars. On
the
Weblor II
it was ready for ripening.
Raymond Palugger was killed in the ship's hospital on the sixty-first
day. Palugger, a Fourth Quadrant passenger, had complained of feeling
ill, had been hospitalized with a diagnosis of ileus. He had put his
money belt in the drawer of the small stand beside his bed. A man
in a red mask was seen hurrying from the hospital area, and a staff
investigation revealed that Palugger had died trying to prevent the
theft of the belt.
Captain Branson did not wait for the newsletter. Through the ship's
speaker system, he reported that Palugger had a fortune in credits
in the belt and had died of a severe beating. He said that since the
incident occurred in the staff section of the ship, his crew would be
forced to submit to a thorough inspection in an effort to find the
mask, the seed case, the money and the man.
"I will not countenance such an act by a crewman," Branson said. "If
and when he is found, he will be severely dealt with. But he might not
be a member of the crew. I am ordering an assembly of all passengers at
nine tomorrow morning in the auditorium. I will speak to you all then."
Faces were angry, tongues were sharp at the meeting, eyes suspicious
and tempers short. Above it all was the overpowering presence of
Captain Branson speaking to them.
"It is not my desire to interfere in passenger affairs," he said.
"Insofar as the ship is concerned, it is my duty to make certain no
crewman is guilty. This I am doing. But my crew is not and cannot be
a police force for you. It is up to you people to police and protect
yourselves."
"How can we protect ourselves without stunners?" one colonist called
out.
"Has Red Mask a gun?" Branson retorted. "It seems to me you have a
better weapon than any gun."
"What's that?"
"This ship is only so wide, so long and so deep. If every inch is
searched, you'll find your man. He has to be somewhere aboard."
The colonists quieted. Benjamin Simpson, one of the older men, was
elected president of the newly formed Quadrant Council. One man from
each of the quadrants was named to serve under him. Each of these men
in turn selected five others from his own group.
Those assembled waited in the hall while each team of six inspected
the compartments of the others. These compartments were then locked,
everyone returned to his compartment, and the larger search was
conducted. It took twenty hours.
No mask was found. No mask, no case, no money, no man.
The captain reported that his search had been equally fruitless.
At another assembly the following day it was decided to make the
inspection teams permanent, to await further moves on the part of Red
Mask. The Quadrant Council held periodic meetings to set up a method of
trial for him when he was caught. It was all recorded in the newsletter
and by Keith Ellason.
We Nillys know about hate and about violence. We know too that where
there is hate there is violence, and where there is violence there is
death.
During sleep time on the seventy-ninth day Barbara Stoneman, awakened
by a strange sound, sat up in the bed of her compartment to find a
man in a red mask in her room. Her cries brought neighbors into the
corridor. The flight of the man was witnessed by many, and several men
tried to stop him. But the intruder was light on his feet and fast. He
escaped.
The Quadrant Council confronted the captain, demanding weapons.
"Are you out of your minds?" Branson exclaimed.
Tom Tilbury, Fourth Quadrant leader, said, "We want to set up a police
force, Captain. We want stunners."
"There's no law against it," Branson said, "but it's a rule of mine
that no weapons are to be issued en route."
"If we had had a gun, we'd have got Red Mask," Tilbury said.
"And I might have a murder on my conscience."
Tilbury said, "We've also thought of that. Suppose you supply us with
half-power stunners? That way we can stun but not kill."
They got their guns. Now there were twenty-four policemen on duty in
the corridors—eight on at a time. Ellason observed that for the first
time the passengers seemed relaxed.
Let Red Mask move against armed men, they said.
Yeah, let him see what happens now.
Red Mask did.
On the 101st day he was seen in a corridor in Quadrant Four. Emil
Pierce, policeman on duty, managed to squeeze off several shots at his
retreating figure.
Red Mask was seen again on the 120th day, on the 135th day, and the
157th day. He was seen, shot at, but not hit. He was also unable to
commit any crime.
We've got him on the run, the colonists said.
He's afraid to do anything, now that we've got police protection, they
said smugly.
The Quadrant Council congratulated itself. The passengers were proud
of themselves. A special congratulatory message from Captain Branson
appeared one day in the Bulletin newsletter.
The colonists settled down to living out the rest of the voyage until
the landing on Antheon.
But on the 170th day calamity struck. Red Mask appropriated one of the
stunners, made his way down one whole corridor section in Quadrant Two,
put occupants to sleep as he went, taking many articles of value and
leaving disorder behind.
Ellason interviewed as many victims as he could, noted it all in
his book. The things taken were keepsakes, photographs and items of
personal value. It seemed to be the work of a madman. If Red Mask
wanted to make everyone furious, he certainly succeeded.
"What does he want that stuff for?" Casey Stromberg, a passenger
doctor, asked. "I can see him taking my narcotics, my doctor's kit—but
my dead wife's picture? That I don't understand."
It was the same with others. "The man's insane, Mr. Ellason. Positively
insane." Many people said it.
The council issued orders that all passengers from now on would be
required to lock their compartments at all times. More guns were
obtained from the captain. More policemen were appointed.
Ellason was busy noting it all in his book. It became filled with
jottings about innocent people being accidentally stunned when
trigger-happy policemen thought their movements suspicious, about one
man's suspicion of another and the ensuing search of compartments,
people who saw Red Mask here, saw him there. Hardly a day went by
without some new development.
"Oh, yes, Mr. Ellason, we're going to get him," said Tilbury, now chief
of police, cracking his knuckles, his eyes glowing at the thought.
"We're bound to get him. We've got things worked out to the finest
detail. He won't be able to get through our fingers now. Just let him
make so much as a move."
"And what will you do when you get him?"
"Kill him," Tilbury said, licking his lips, his eyes glowing more
fiercely than ever.
"Without a trial?"
"Oh, there'll be a trial, Mr. Ellason, but you don't think any jury'd
let him live after all the things he's done, do you?"
Red Mask was stunned in Quadrant Four in a corridor by a policeman
named Terryl Placer on the 201st day. The criminal was carried to the
assembly room surrounded by guards, for he surely would have been
mauled, if not killed, by angry colonists who crowded around. In the
assembly hall his mask was whipped off. The crowd gasped. Nobody knew
him.
Ellason's first thought was that he must be a stowaway, but then he
remembered the face, and Captain Branson, who came to have a look at
him, unhappily admitted the man was a member of the crew. His name was
Harrel Critten and he was a record keeper third class.
"Well, Critten," Branson roared at him, "what have you got to say for
yourself?"
"Go to hell," Critten said quietly. As if it were an afterthought, he
spat at the captain.
Branson looked as if he were going to kill the man himself right there
and then.
It was a long trial—from the 220th to the 241st day—and there didn't
seem to be much doubt about the outcome, for Critten didn't help his
own cause during any of it.
Lemuel Tarper, who was appointed prosecutor, asked him, "What did you
do with the loot, Critten?"
Critten looked him square in the eye and said, "I threw it out one of
the escape chutes. Does that answer your question?"
"Threw it away?" Tarper and the crowd were incredulous.
"Sure," Critten said. "You colonists got the easy life as passengers,
just sitting around. I had to work my head off keeping records for you
lazy bastards."
The verdict was, of course, death.
They executed Harrel Critten on the morning of the 270th day with
blasts from six stunners supplied with full power. It was witnessed
by a great crowd in the assembly hall. A detail from the ship's crew
disposed of his body through a chute.
It was all duly recorded in Keith Ellason's notebooks.
Dying is easy for a Nilly. Especially if it's arranged for beforehand,
which it always is.
The
Weblor II
was only one day out of orbit when Captain Branson sent
for Ellason and introduced him to the executed man.
"Hello," Critten said, grinning from ear to ear.
"I figured as much," Ellason said. "I've been doing a lot of thinking."
"You're perhaps a little too good as an observer," Branson said. "Or
maybe it was because you really weren't one of the colonists. But no
matter, Critten did a good job. He was trained by an old friend of mine
for this job, Gelthorpe Nill. Nill used to be in counter-espionage when
there were wars."
"You were excellent," Ellason said.
"Can't say I enjoyed the role," said Critten, "but I think it saved
lives."
"Let me get this straight. Interstellar thought that it was idleness
and boredom that caused the killings on the
Weblor I
, so they had you
trained to be a scapegoat. Is that right?"
Critten nodded. "When great numbers are being transported, they are apt
to magnify each little event because so little happens. It was my job
to see that they directed none of their venom against each other or the
crew, only toward me."
Branson smiled. "It made the time pass quickly and interestingly for
the passengers."
"To say nothing of me," Critten said.
"And you, Mr. Ellason, were along to observe it all," Captain Branson
put in. "Interstellar wanted an accurate picture of this. If it worked,
they told me they'd use it on other trips to Antheon."
Ellason nodded. "No time for brooding, for differences of opinion on
small matters. Just time to hate Mr. Critten. Unanimously."
"Probably," Critten said, "you are wondering about the execution."
"Naturally."
"We removed the charges before the guns were used."
"And Carver Janssen's case?"
"He'll get it back when he's shuttled to Antheon. And all the other
items will be returned. They're all tagged with their owner's names.
Captain Branson will say they were found somewhere on the ship. You
see, I was a liar."
"How about that assault on June Failright?"
Critten grinned again. "She played right into our hands. She ran out
into the hall claiming I'd attacked her, which I did not. She was
certainly amazed when the ship's physicians agreed with her. Of course
Captain Branson told them to do that."
"And the murder?"
"Raymond Palugger died in the hospital all right, but he died from
his illness on the operating table. We turned it into an advantage by
making it look suspicious."
Ellason brightened. "And by that time everybody was seeing Red Mask
everywhere and the colonists organized against him."
"Gave them something to do," Branson said.
"Every time things got dull, I livened them up. I got a stunner and
robbed along the corridor. That really stirred them. Lucky nobody got
hurt during any of it, including that Stoneman woman. I was trying to
rob her when she woke up."
Branson cleared his throat. "Ah, Ellason about that story. You
understand you can't write it, don't you?"
Ellason said regretfully that he did understand.
"The colonists will never know the truth," Branson went on. "There will
be other ships outward bound."
Critten sighed. "And I'll have to be caught again."
Yes, we're anonymous, nameless, we Nillys, for that's what we call
each other, and are a theme, with variations, in the endless stretches
of deep space, objects of hatred and contempt, professional heels,
dying once a trip when the time is ripe, antidote to boredom, and we'll
ply our trade, our little tragedies, on a thousand ships bringing
humanity to new worlds.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/1/60713//60713-h//60713-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How many times has Critten been a Nilly? | 60713_TSA8I2K7_9 | [
"8",
"5",
"7",
"6"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How old was the narrator when he discovered he had a special gift? | 60747_UP35PIDS_1 | [
"15",
"9",
"12",
"18"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 3,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does the narrator reveal his secret ability to Julia? | 60747_UP35PIDS_2 | [
"He loves Julia, and he doesn't want there to be any secrets between them.",
"If he doesn't explain his ability, she'll think he's a creeper for going in her luggage.",
"He needs to stay with the suitcase to keep the bomb from going off. He needs her cooperation.",
"He'll have a better chance of getting her to believe him than the airport policeman believing his story."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does the narrator make a phone call before explaining the bomb to Julia? | 60747_UP35PIDS_3 | [
"The narrator needs to call airport security so that they can evacuate the area before he explains the situation to Julia.",
"The narrator needs to call the FBI and report the bomb before he explains the situation to Julia.",
"The narrator fakes making a phone call so that he can focus on stopping the bomb again.",
"The narrator needs to alert the bomb squad before he explains the situation to Julia."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why didn't Julia pick up her suitcase with the other passengers? | 60747_UP35PIDS_4 | [
"Julia was detained by customs before she could get to the baggage claim.",
"Julia went to call her sister before collecting her suitcase.",
"Julia was told that her suitcase didn't make the flight when they were mid-air. ",
"Julia didn't want to be near the suitcase when the bomb went off."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why doesn't the narrator use his powers to win at slot machines? | 60747_UP35PIDS_5 | [
"He did use his powers to win at slot machines. He got himself banned from casinos.",
"He thought about using his powers to win at slot machines but then decided it was too risky. He was afraid of getting caught.",
"The mechanical workings of the slot machines are too difficult for him to control.",
"He did use his powers to win at slot machines for a while. Then he became addicted to gambling and had to join Gamblers Annonymous."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How did the bomb get in Julia's suitcase? | 60747_UP35PIDS_6 | [
"Julia's sister slipped the bomb inside the suitcase before she left for the airport.",
"Julia put the bomb in her suitcase before she left home.",
"A terrorist at the airport grabbed Julia's bag at random and slipped the bomb inside.",
"Julia's husband put the bomb in her suitcase before she left the house."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What happened to the man who stole the suitcases? | 60747_UP35PIDS_7 | [
"The man who stole the suitcases was arrested by the FBI after the bomb-sniffing dogs caught up with him.",
"The man who stole the suitcases was mauled by the bomb-sniffing dogs.",
"The man who stole the suitcases died when the bomb exploded.",
"The man who stole the suitcases was arrested by the airport police."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
60,747 | 60747_UP35PIDS | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The Little Red Bag | 1958.0 | Sohl, Jerry | Science fiction; Airplanes -- Fiction; PS; Bombs -- Fiction; Parapsychology -- Fiction; California -- Fiction; Short stories | Nuts to wild talents! Mine was no
satisfaction, never earned me a penny—and
now it had me fighting for my life in
...
THE LITTLE RED BAG
By JERRY SOHL
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, January 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
About an hour out of San Francisco on the flight to Los Angeles, I made
the discovery. I had finished reading the
Chronicle
, folded and put
it beside me, turned and looked out the window, expecting to see the
San Joaquin Valley but finding only a sea of clouds instead. So I
returned my attention to the inside of the plane, to the overstuffed
gray-haired woman asleep beside me, to the backs of heads in seats
before me, across the aisle to other heads, and down to the blonde.
I had seen her in the concourse and at the gate, a shapely thing. Now
she had crossed her legs and I was privileged to view a trim ankle and
calf, and her profile as she stared moodily across the aisle and out a
window where there was nothing to see.
I slid my eyes past her to others. A crossword-puzzle worker, a
togetherness-type-magazine reader.
Inventory completed, I went back to looking at the clouds, knowing I
should be thinking about the printing order I was going to Los Angeles
for, and not wanting to.
So I started going through the purse of the woman next to me. Perhaps
that sounds bad. It wasn't. I'd been doing it for years and nobody ever
complained.
It started when I was a kid, this business of being able to explore
the insides of things like purses and sealed boxes and locked drawers
and—well, human beings. But human beings aren't worth the trouble.
It's like swimming through spaghetti. And I've got to stay away from
electric wires. They hurt. Now don't ask me
how
they hurt.
Maybe you think it's fun. For the most part, it really isn't. I always
knew what was in Christmas presents before I unwrapped them, and
therefore Christmas was always spoiled for me as a kid. I can't feel
the color of anything, just its consistency. An apple senses about the
same as a potato, except for the core and the stem. I can't even tell
if there's writing on a piece of paper. So you see it isn't much. Just
the feel of shapes, the hardnesses and softnesses. But I've learned to
become pretty good at guessing.
Like this woman next to me. She had a short, cylindrical metal object
in her purse with waxlike stuff inside it—a lipstick. A round, hard
object with dust inside—a compact. Handkerchief, chewing gum, a small
book, probably an address book, money in a change purse—a few bills
and coins. Not much else.
I was a little disappointed. I've run across a gun or two in my time.
But I never say anything.
I learned the wisdom of keeping my mouth shut in the fourth grade when
Miss Winters, a stern, white-haired disciplinarian, ordered me to eat
my sack lunch in the classroom with her instead of outside with some
of the other kids. This was the punishment for some minor infraction.
Lunchtime was nearly over and we'd both finished eating; she said she'd
be gone for a few moments and that I was to erase the blackboard during
her absence, which I dutifully did.
Class had hardly resumed when she started looking around the desk for
her favorite mechanical pencil, asking if any of us had seen it, and
looking straight at me. I didn't want her to think I had taken it while
she was out of the room, so I probed the contents of her purse, which
she always kept in the upper right drawer of her desk.
"It's in your purse," I blurted out.
I was sent home with a stinging note.
Since then I've kept quiet. At one time I assumed everybody was able
to sense. I've known better for years. Still, I wonder how many other
people are as close-mouthed about their special gift as I am about mine.
I used to think that some day I'd make a lot of money out of it, but
how? I can't read thoughts. I can't even be sure what some of the
things I sense in probing really are.
But I've learned to move things. Ever so little. A piece of paper. A
feather. Once I stopped one of those little glass-enclosed light or
heat-powered devices with vanes you see now and then in a jeweler's
window. And I can stop clocks.
Take this morning, for example. I had set my alarm for five-thirty
because I had to catch the seven o'clock plane at San Francisco
International Airport. This being earlier than I usually get up, it
seems all I did during the night was feel my way past the escapement
and balance wheel to see where the notch for the alarm was. The last
time I did it there was just the merest fraction of an inch between the
pawl and the notch. So I sighed and moved to the balance wheel and its
delicate ribbon of spiraling steel. I hung onto the wheel, exerting
influence to decrease the restoring torque.
The wheel slowed down until there was no more ticking. It took quite
a bit of effort, as it always does, but I did it, as I usually do. I
can't stand the alarm.
When I first learned to do this, I thought I had it made. I even went
to Las Vegas to try my hand, so to speak, with the ratchets and pawls
and cams and springs on the slot machines. But there's nothing delicate
about a slot machine, and the spring tensions are too strong. I dropped
quite a lot of nickels before I finally gave up.
So I'm stuck with a talent I've found little real use for. Except that
it amuses me. Sometimes. Not like this time on the plane.
The woman beside me stirred, sat up suddenly and looked across me out
the window. "Where are we?" she asked in a surprised voice. I told her
we were probably a little north of Bakersfield. She said, "Oh," glanced
at her wristwatch and sank back again.
Soon the stewardesses would bring coffee and doughnuts around, so I
contented myself with looking at the clouds and trying to think about
Amos Magaffey, who was purchasing agent for a Los Angeles amusement
chain, and how I was going to convince him our printing prices were
maybe a little higher but the quality and service were better. My mind
wandered below where I was sitting, idly moving from one piece of
luggage to another, looking for my beat-up suitcase. I went through
slips and slippers, lingerie and laundry, a jig saw puzzle and a
ukulele.
I never did find my suitcase because I found the bomb first.
The bomb was in a small bag—a woman's bag judging by the soft,
flimsy things you'd never find in a man's—and I didn't know it was a
bomb right away. I thought it was just a clock, one of those small,
quiet alarms. I was going to pass it by and go on, but what held me
was that something was taped to it. By the feel, I knew it must be
electrician's tape. Interested and curious, I explored the clock more
closely, found two wires. One went to a battery and the other to hard
round cylinders taped together. The hairs stood up at the base of my
neck when I suddenly realized what it was.
The clock's balance wheel was rocking merrily. Quickly I went up past
the train of gears to the alarm wheel. If this was anything like my own
alarm clock, this one had something like ten minutes to go.
It was forty minutes to Burbank and Lockheed Air Terminal.
My mind was churning when I turned from the window to look around
at the unconcerned passengers, the woman at my side asleep again. I
thought: Which one of these.... No, none of them would know it was
there. I glanced out the window again; clouds were still in the way.
We'd be leaving the valley for the mountain range north of Los Angeles
soon, if we hadn't left it already. No place to land the plane there.
But of course that had been the plan!
My heart was beating in jackhammer rhythm; my mouth was dry and my mind
was numb. Tell somebody about the bomb before it's too late! No, they'd
think I put it there. Besides, what good would it do? There would be
panic and they'd never get the plane down in time—if they believed me.
"Sir." My head jerked around. The stewardess stood in the aisle,
smiling, extending a tray to me, a brown plastic tray bearing a small
paper cup of tomato juice, a cup of coffee, a cellophane-wrapped
doughnut, paper spoon, sugar and dehydrated cream envelopes, and a
napkin.
I goggled at her, managed to croak, "No, thanks." She gave me an odd
look and moved along. My seatmate had accepted hers and was tearing at
the cellophane. I couldn't bear to watch her.
I closed my eyes, forced my mind back to the luggage compartment, spent
a frantic moment before I found the bag again. I had to stop that
balance wheel, just as I stopped my alarm clock every morning. I tried
to close everything off—the throb of engines, the rush of air, the
woman sipping coffee noisily beside me—and I went into the clock and
surrounded the seesawing wheel. When it went forward, I pulled it back;
when it went back, I pulled it forward. I struggled with it, and it was
like trying to work with greasy hands, and I was afraid I wasn't going
to be able to stop it.
Then, little by little, it started to slow its beat. But I could not
afford to relax. I pushed and pulled and didn't dare release my hold
until it came to a dead stop.
"Anything the matter?"
My eyelids flew open and I looked into the eyes of the woman next to
me. There was sugar from the doughnut around her mouth and she was
still chewing.
"No," I said, letting out my breath. "I'm all right."
"You were moaning, it sounded like. And you kept moving your head back
and forth."
"Must have been dreaming," I said as I rang for the stewardess. When
she came I told her I'd take some of that coffee now. No, nothing else,
just coffee. I didn't tell her how much I needed it. I sat there clammy
with sweat until she returned. Coffee never tasted so good.
All right, so I had stopped the bomb's timer. My mind raced ahead to
the landing. When they unloaded the luggage, the balance wheel would
start again. I wouldn't be able to stay with it, keeping it still.
I considered telling the authorities as soon as we landed, or maybe
calling in ahead, but wouldn't that just bring suspicion, questions.
Maybe I could convince them I could stop a clock—but not before the
bomb exploded. And then what? My secret would be out and my life would
be changed. I'd be a man not to be trusted, a prying man, a man
literally with gimlet eyes.
Mountain crags jutted through the clouds. We were in the range north of
the city. Here and there were clear spots and I could see roads below,
but there were also clouds far above us. It was very beautiful, but it
was also very bumpy, and we started to slip and slide.
To my horror I found that the balance wheel was rocking again. Closing
my eyes and gritting my teeth, I forced my senses to the wheel, tugging
and pulling and shoving and pushing until it finally stopped.
A jab in the shoulder. I jumped, startled.
"Your cup," my seat partner said, pointing.
I looked down at the coffee cup I had crushed in my hands. Then I
looked up into the eyes of the stewardess. I handed it to her. She took
it without a word and went away.
"Were you really asleep that time?"
"Not really," I said. I was tempted to tell the woman I was subject to
fits, but I didn't.
It was only a few minutes to landing, but they became the longest
minutes of my life as time after time I stopped the rocking wheel when
the plane dipped and bumped to a landing.
Leaving the apron with the other passengers, I tried to walk as
unconcernedly as they through the exit gate. I would have liked walking
through the terminal and out the entrance and away, but I could not. I
had my suitcase to get, for one thing. The damned bomb was the other.
So I strolled out into the concourse again to look at the plane and
watch the baggagemen at work, transferring the luggage to two airfield
carts. They weren't as careful as I would have been.
It was impossible to tell from this distance just which bag contained
the bomb; I could hardly identify my own scarred suitcase. The
assortment of bags—a strange conglomeration of sizes and colors—was
packed in some places six deep, and it rolled toward the gate where
I was standing. I didn't know whether to stay or run, imagining the
balance wheel now happily rocking again. The load went past me down a
ramp to the front of the air terminal where the luggage was unloaded
and placed in a long rack. I went with it.
There was a flurry of ticket matching, hands grabbing for suitcases,
and a general exodus on the part of my fellow passengers, too fast to
determine who had got the one with the bomb. Now all that was left was
the attendant and I had two bags—my own battered veteran of years, and
a fine new red overnight case, small enough to be the one.
I lit a cigarette, reached out. Inside were a woman's things and—a
clock. The escapement was clicking vigorously.
I didn't moan this time. I just closed my eyes, stretched toward
and grabbed the balance wheel I was getting to know like my own. I
entered into a union with it so strong that after I had reduced it to
immobility, it was like waking when I opened my eyes.
The baggage claim attendant was staring at me. For only a moment I
stared back. Then I quickly reached for my baggage check and presented
it to him. His hand hovered over the handle of the little red bag and I
was ready to yell at him. But then, matching numbers on the tags with
his eyes, his hand grasped the handle of my own suitcase and pushed it
toward me.
"Thanks," I said, taking it. I glanced ever so casually toward the
remaining bag. "One left over, eh?"
"Yeah." He was so bored I was tempted to tell him what was in it. But
he was eying me with a "well-why-don't-you-get-along?" look.
I said, "What happens if nobody claims it?"
"Take it inside. Why?"
He was getting too curious. "Oh, I just wondered, that's all."
I stepped on my cigarette and walked toward the air terminal entrance
and put my suitcase on the stone steps there. A redcap came hurrying
over.
"Cab?"
I shook my head. "Just waiting."
Just waiting for somebody to pick up a bomb.
I lit another cigarette and glanced now and then toward the baggage
claim area. The red bag was still there. All sorts of theories ran
through my head as to why it should still be there, and none satisfied
me.
I should not have been there, that much I knew; I should be with a
man named Amos Magaffey on Sixth Street at ten o'clock, discussing
something very mundane, the matter of a printing order. But what could
I do? If I left the airport, the attendant would eventually take the
bag inside and there would be an explosion, and I wouldn't be able to
live with myself.
No. I had to stay to keep the balance wheel stationary until—until
what?
A man in tan gabardine, wearing a police cap and badge, walked out of
the entrance to stand on the stone steps beside me while he put on a
pair of dark glasses. A member of the airport police detail. I could
tell him. I could take him down to the little red bag and explain the
whole thing. Then it would be his baby and I would be off on my own
business.
But he moved on down the steps, nodded at the redcap, and started
across the street to the parking area. I could have called to him,
"Hey, officer, let me tell you about a bomb in a little red bag." But
I didn't. I didn't because I caught a movement at the baggage claim
counter out of the side of my eye.
The attendant had picked up the bag and was walking with it up the ramp
to the rear of the air terminal. Picking up my own suitcase, I went
inside in time to see him enter through a side door and deposit the bag
on the scales at the airline desk and say something to the clerk. The
clerk nodded and moved the bag to the rear room.
I could visualize the balance wheel once again rocking like crazy. How
many minutes—or seconds—were left? I was sweating when I moved to the
counter, and it wasn't because of the sunshine I'd been soaking in. I
had to get as close to the bag as I could if I was going to stop the
clock again.
"Can I help you?" the clerk asked.
"No. I'm waiting for someone."
I turned my back to him, put down my suitcase, leaned against the
counter and reached out for the wheel. I found I could reach the
device, but it was far away. When I tried to dampen it, the wheel
escaped my grasp.
"Do you have my suitcase?"
I blinked my eyes open and looked around. The blonde in the plane stood
there looking very fresh and bright and unconcerned. In her right hand
she had a green baggage claim check.
The clerk took it, nodded, and in a moment brought out the overnight
case and set it on the scales. The girl thanked him, picked it up,
glanced at me indifferently, and then started for the entrance with it.
"Just a moment," I found myself saying, grabbing my bag and hurrying
after her.
At her side and a little ahead of her, I said, "Listen to me."
She looked annoyed and increased her stride toward the door.
"It's a matter of life or death," I said. I wanted to wrest the bag
from her and hurl it out through the doorway into the street, but I
restrained myself.
She stopped and stared. I noticed a short, fat man in a rumpled
suitcoat and unpressed pants staring, too. Ignoring him, I said,
"Please put the bag down. Over there." I indicated a spot beside a
telephone booth where it would be out of the way.
She didn't move. She just said, "Why?"
"For God's sake!" I took the case. She offered no resistance. I put her
bag and mine next to the booth. When I turned around she was standing
there looking at me as if I had gone out of my mind. Her eyes were blue
and brown-flecked, very pretty eyes, and my thought at the moment was,
I'm glad the bomb didn't go off; these eyes wouldn't be looking at me
or anything else right now if it had.
"I've got to talk to you. It's very important."
The girl said, "Why?" I was beginning to think it was the only word she
knew. At the same time I was wondering why anyone would want to kill
someone so lovely.
"I'll explain in a moment. Please stand right here while I make a
telephone call." I moved toward the phone booth, paused and said, "And
don't ask me why."
She gave me a speculative look.
I must not have seemed a complete idiot because she said, "All right,
but—"
I didn't listen for the rest. I went into the booth, closed the door,
pretended to drop a coin and dial a number. But all the time I was in
there, I was reaching out through the glass for the clock. At this
range it wasn't difficult to stop the balance wheel.
Just the same, when I came out I was wringing wet.
"Now will you please tell me what this is all about?" she said stiffly.
"Gladly. Let me buy you a cup of coffee and I'll explain."
She glanced at the bags. I told her they'd be all right. We followed
the short, fat man into the coffee shop.
Over coffee I explained it all to her, how I had this extrasensory
ability, how she was the first person I had ever revealed it to, and
how I had discovered what was in her overnight bag.
During the telling, her untouched coffee grew a skin, her face grew
pale, her eyes grew less curious and more troubled. There were tears
there when I finished. I asked her who put the bomb in her bag.
"Joe did," she said in a toneless voice, not looking at me any more but
staring vacantly across the room. "Joe put it there." Behind her eyes
she was reliving some recent scene.
"Who is Joe?"
"My husband." I thought she was going to really bawl, but she got
control again. "This trip was his idea, my coming down here to visit my
sister." Her smile was bleak. "I see now why he wanted to put in those
books. I'd finished packing and was in the bathroom. He said he'd put
in some books we'd both finished reading—for my sister. That's when he
must have put the—put it in there."
I said gently, "Why would he want to do a thing like that?"
"I don't know." She shook her head. "I just don't know." And she was
close to bawling again. Then she recovered and said, "I'm not sure I
want to know." I admired her for saying it. Joe must have been crazy.
"It's all right now?" she asked.
I nodded. "As long as we don't move it."
I told her I didn't know how much more time there was, that I'd been
thinking it over and that the only way out seemed to be to tell the
airport policeman. After I explained it to her, the girl—she said her
name was Julia Claremont—agreed to tell him she thought there was a
bomb in her bag, that she had noticed a ticking and had become worried
because she knew she hadn't packed a clock. It wasn't good, but it
would have to do.
"We've got to get it deactivated," I said, watching the fat man pay for
his coffee and leave. "The sooner the better."
I finished my coffee in one gulp and went to pay the bill with her.
I asked her why she didn't claim the bag at the same time the other
people had. She said she had called her sister and the phone was busy
for a long while.
"She was supposed to meet me, and when she wasn't here, I got worried.
She said she isn't feeling well and asked me to take a cab." She smiled
a little. It was a bright, cheery thing. I had the feeling it was all
for me. "That's where I was going when you caught up with me."
It had become a very nice day. But the bottom dropped out of it again
when we reached the lobby.
The two bags weren't there.
I ran to the entrance and nearly collided with the redcap.
"See anybody go out of here with a little red bag and an old battered
suitcase?"
"Bag? Suitcase?" he mumbled. Then he became excited. "Why, a man just
stepped out of here—" He turned to look down the street. "That's him."
The dumpy man I'd seen was walking off; Julia's bag in his right hand,
mine in his left. He seemed in no hurry.
"Hey!" I shouted, starting toward him.
The man turned, took one look at me, and started to run. He came
abreast an old gray, mud-spattered coupe, ran around, opened the door
and threw both bags into the rear seat as he got in.
The car was a hundred feet away and gathering speed by the time I
reached where it had been parked. I watched it for a moment, then
walked back to the entranceway where Julia was standing with the
redcap, who said, "That man steal them suitcases?"
"That he did," I said.
Just then the airport policeman started across the street from the
parking lot. Redcap said, "Better tell him about it."
The policeman was sympathetic and concerned. He said, "We'd better get
over to the office."
But we never left the spot because an explosion some blocks distant
shattered the air. Julia's hand grasped my arm. Hard.
"Jets," the redcap said, eying the sky.
"I don't know," the policeman said. "Didn't sound much like a jet to
me."
We stood there. I could visualize the wreckage of an old gray coupe
in the middle of a street, but I couldn't visualize the driver. That
was all right. I didn't want to see him. I didn't know what Julia was
thinking.
She said, "About those bags," and looked at me.
The officer said, "Yes, miss?"
"I—I don't care about mine. I didn't have much of anything in it."
"I feel the same way," I said. "Would it be all right if we didn't
bother to report it?"
"Well," the policeman said, "I can't
make
you report it."
"I'd rather not then," Julia said. She turned to me. "I'd like some
air. Can't we walk a little?"
"Sure," I said.
We started down the street, her arm in mine, as the air began to fill
with the distant sounds of sirens.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/7/4/60747//60747-h//60747-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why doesn't Julia tell the policeman about the bomb? | 60747_UP35PIDS_8 | [
"This is her chance to disappear and start a new life. ",
"She doesn't think the police will believe her husband tried to kill her.",
"She does not want to be blamed for the thief's death.",
"She doesn't want the narrator to have to explain his gifts."
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How did Crownwall get to Vega III so quickly? | 27492_U24VCD2I_1 | [
"FTL (Faster than Light) drive",
"Transport Beam",
"Warp drive",
"Time travel"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Who is Ggarran? | 27492_U24VCD2I_2 | [
"The Viceroy's advisor",
"The head of the palace guard",
"The leader of the Vegans",
"The leader of the Sundans"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why did the Viceroy blockade the Earth if he wanted an Earthling to come and meet with him? | 27492_U24VCD2I_3 | [
"The blockade was a test to see if Earthlings were smart enough to help the Vegans defeat the Sundans.",
"The blockade is there to protect Earth from the Sundans.",
"The blockade is there to quarantine the Earth. Earthlings may have diseases that could infect the other races.",
"The blockade is there to keep people from leaving the Earth."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What was Earth's first Spaceship? | 27492_U24VCD2I_4 | [
"Voyager",
"Alpha Centauri",
"Star Seeker",
"Enterprise"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why is the distorter drive so dangerous? | 27492_U24VCD2I_5 | [
"The distorter drive has a seventy-three percent chance of destroying everything around it for thousands of miles.",
"The distorter drive has not been thoroughly tested.",
"The distorter drive is powered by a nuclear reactor.",
"The distorter drive is radioactive."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How many Viceroys are neither Vegan nor Sundan? | 27492_U24VCD2I_6 | [
"15",
"20",
"25",
"10"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does the bowman shoot a soldier during the Viceroy's procession? | 27492_U24VCD2I_7 | [
"To demonstrate what would happen if someone who was not a guest of the Viceroy viewed the procession.",
"The soldier was attempting to stage a coup against the Viceroy.",
"The soldier tripped and made the procession look sloppy.",
"To demonstrate the Vegan's knowledge of antiquated weapons."
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does the Council feel about Crownwall's decision to go back in time to before the Vegans appeared? | 27492_U24VCD2I_8 | [
"They are scared. The Sundans will surely attack the Earth now.",
"They are horrified. They sent Crownwall to make a peace treaty not to commit genocide.",
"They are sad. They are all alone in the universe now.",
"They are ecstatic. All of their enemies are gone now."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does Crownwall feel about the Vegans? | 27492_U24VCD2I_9 | [
"Crownwall thinks the Vegans are a kind and benevolent race.",
"Crownwall thinks the Vegans seem to be just as brutal and horrible as they make the Sundans out to be.",
"Crownwall thinks the Vegans are murderous and can't wait to get away from them.",
"Crownwall is disgusted by the sight of the slobbering, boneless, tentacled creatures."
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
27,492 | 27492_U24VCD2I | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | Upstarts | 1960.0 | Stecher, L. J., Jr. | Short stories; PS; Science fiction | UPSTARTS
By L. J. STECHER, JR.
Illustrated by DILLON
The
sight of an Earthman
on Vega III, where it was
impossible for an outlander
to be, brought angry crowds to surround
John Crownwall as he strode
toward the palace of Viceroy
Tronn Ffallk, ruler of Sector XII
of the Universal Holy Empire of
Sunda. He ignored the snarling, the
spitting, the waving of boneless
prehensile fingers, as he ignored the
heavy gravity and heavier air of
the unfamiliar planet.
John Crownwall, florid, red-headed
and bulky, considered himself
to be a bold man. But here,
surrounded by this writhing, slithering
mass of eight-foot creatures,
he felt distinctly unhappy. Crownwall
had heard about creatures that
slavered, but he had never before
seen it done. These humanoids had
large mouths and sharp teeth, and
they unquestionably slavered. He
wished he knew more about them.
If they carried out the threats of
their present attitude, Earth would
have to send Marshall to replace
him. And if Crownwall couldn't do
the job, thought Crownwall, then
it was a sure bet that Marshall
wouldn't have a chance.
He climbed the great ramp, with
its deeply carved Greek key design,
toward the mighty entrance
gate of the palace. His manner
demonstrated an elaborate air of
unconcern that he felt sure was entirely
wasted on these monsters.
The clashing teeth of the noisiest
of them were only inches from the
quivering flesh of his back as he
reached the upper level. Instantly,
and unexpectedly to Crownwall,
the threatening crowd dropped
back fearfully, so that he walked
the last fifty meters alone.
Crownwall all but sagged with
relief. A pair of guards, their purple
hides smoothly polished and gleaming
with oil, crossed their ceremonial
pikes in front of him as he
approached the entrance.
"And just what business do you
have here, stranger?" asked the
senior of the guards, his speaking
orifice framing with difficulty the
sibilances of Universal Galactic.
"What business
would
I have at
the Viceroy's Palace?" asked
Crownwall. "I want to see Ffallk."
"Mind your tongue," growled
the guard. "If you mean His Effulgence,
Right Hand of the Glorious
Emperor, Hereditary Ruler of the
Seventy Suns, Viceroy of the
Twelfth Sector of the Universal
Holy Empire"—Universal Galactic
had a full measure of ceremonial
words—"he sees only those whom
he summons. If you know what's
good for you, you'll get out of here
while you can still walk. And if you
run fast enough, maybe you can
even get away from that crowd out
there, but I doubt it."
"Just tell him that a man has
arrived from Earth to talk to him.
He'll summon me fast enough.
Meanwhile, my highly polished
friends, I'll just wait here, so why
don't you put those heavy pikes
down?"
Crownwall sat on the steps,
puffed alight a cigarette, and blew
expert smoke rings toward the
guards.
An elegant courtier, with elaborately
jeweled harness, bustled
from inside the palace, obviously
trying to present an air of strolling
nonchalance. He gestured fluidly
with a graceful tentacle. "You!" he
said to Crownwall. "Follow me. His
Effulgence commands you to appear
before him at once." The two
guards withdrew their pikes and
froze into immobility at the sides
of the entrance.
Crownwall stamped out his
smoke and ambled after the hurrying
courtier along tremendous corridors,
through elaborate waiting
rooms, under guarded doorways,
until he was finally bowed through
a small curtained arch.
At the far side of the comfortable,
unimpressive room, a plump
thing, hide faded to a dull violet,
reclined on a couch. Behind him
stood a heavy and pompous appearing
Vegan in lordly trappings.
They examined Crownwall with
great interest for a few moments.
"It's customary to genuflect
when you enter the Viceroy's presence,"
said the standing one at
last. "But then I'm told you're an
Earthling. I suppose we can expect
you to be ignorant of those niceties
customary among civilized peoples."
"It's all right, Ggaran," said the
Viceroy languidly. He twitched a
tentacle in a beckoning gesture.
"Come closer, Earthling. I bid you
welcome to my capital. I have been
looking forward to your arrival for
some time."
Crownwall
put his hands
in his pockets. "That's hardly
possible," he said. "It was only decided
yesterday, back on Earth,
that I would be the one to make
the trip here. Even if you could
spy through buildings on Earth
from space, which I doubt, your
communications system can't get
the word through that fast."
"Oh, I didn't mean
you
in particular,"
the Vegan said with a
negligent wave. "Who can tell one
Earthling from another? What I
meant was that I expected someone
from Earth to break through
our blockade and come here. Most
of my advisors—even Ggaran here—thought
it couldn't be done, but
I never doubted that you'd manage
it. Still, if you were on your
home planet only yesterday, that's
astonishing even to me. Tell me,
how did you manage to get here so
fast, and without even alerting my
detection web?"
"You're doing the talking," said
Crownwall. "If you wanted someone
from Earth to come here to see
you, why did you put the cordon
around Earth? And why did you
drop a planet-buster in the Pacific
Ocean, and tell us that it was triggered
to go off if we tried to use
the distorter drive? That's hardly
the action of somebody who expects
visitors."
Ffallk glanced up at Ggaran. "I
told you that Earthlings were unbelievably
bold." He turned back
to Crownwall. "If you couldn't
come to me in spite of the trifling
inconveniences I put in your way,
your presence here would be useless
to both of us. But you did
come, so I can tell you that although
I am the leader of one of
the mightiest peoples in the Galaxy,
whereas there are scarcely six
billions of you squatting on one
minor planet, we still need each
other. Together, there is nothing
we can't do."
"I'm listening," said Crownwall.
"We offer you partnership with
us to take over the rule of the
Galaxy from the Sunda—the so-called
Master Race."
"It would hardly be an equal
partnership, would it, considering
that there are so many more of you
than there are of us?"
His Effulgence twitched his ear
stalks in amusement. "I'm Viceroy
of one of the hundred Sectors of
the Empire. I rule over a total of
a hundred Satrapies; these average
about a hundred Provinces each.
Provinces consist, in general, of
about a hundred Clusters apiece,
and every Cluster has an average
of a hundred inhabited solar systems.
There are more inhabited
planets in the Galaxy than there
are people on your single world.
I, personally, rule three hundred
trillion people, half of them of my
own race. And yet I tell you that
it would be an equal partnership."
"I don't get it. Why?"
"Because you came to me."
Crownwall shrugged. "So?"
The
Vegan reached up and engulfed
the end of a drinking
tube with his eating orifice. "You
upstart Earthlings are a strange
and a frightening race," he said.
"Frightening to the Sunda, especially.
When you showed up in the
spaceways, it was decreed that you
had to be stopped at once. There
was even serious discussion of destroying
Earth out of hand, while
it is still possible.
"Your silly little planet was carefully
examined at long range in a
routine investigation just about fifty
thousand years ago. There were
at that time three different but
similar racial strains of pulpy bipeds,
numbering a total of perhaps
a hundred thousand individuals.
They showed many signs of an
ability to reason, but a complete
lack of civilization. While these
creatures could by no means be
classed among the intelligent races,
there was a general expectation,
which we reported to the Sunda,
that they would some day come to
be numbered among the Servants
of the Emperor. So we let you
alone, in order that you could develop
in your own way, until you
reached a high enough civilization
to be useful—if you were going to.
"Intelligence is very rare in the
Galaxy. In all, it has been found
only fifteen times. The other races
we have watched develop, and
some we have actively assisted to
develop. It took the quickest of
them just under a million years.
One such race we left uncontrolled
too long—but no matter.
"You Earthlings, in defiance of
all expectation and all reason, have
exploded into space. You have developed
in an incredibly short
space of time. But even that isn't
the most disconcerting item of your
development. As an Earthling, you
have heard of the details of the
first expedition of your people into
space, of course?"
"
Heard
about it?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "I was
on
it." He settled
down comfortably on a couch,
without requesting permission, and
thought back to that first tremendous
adventure; an adventure that
had taken place little more than
ten years before.
The
Star Seeker
had been built
in space, about forty thousand kilometers
above the Earth. It had
been manned by a dozen adventurous
people, captained by Crownwall,
and had headed out on its ion
drive until it was safely clear of
the warping influence of planetary
masses. Then, after several impatient
days of careful study and calculation,
the distorter drive had
been activated, for the first time
in Earth's history, and, for the
twelve, the stars had winked out.
The men of Earth had decided
that it should work in theory. They
had built the drive—a small machine,
as drives go—but they had
never dared to try it, close to a
planet. To do so, said their theory,
would usually—seven point three
four times out of 10—destroy the
ship, and everything in space for
thousands of miles around, in a
ravening burst of raw energy.
So the drive had been used for
the first time without ever having
been tested. And it had worked.
In less than a week's time, if
time has any meaning under such
circumstances, they had flickered
back into normal space, in the vicinity
of Alpha Centauri. They had
quickly located a dozen planets,
and one that looked enough like
Earth to be its twin sister. They
had headed for that planet confidently
and unsuspectingly, using
the ion drive.
Two weeks later, while they
were still several planetary diameters
from their destination, they
had been shocked to find more
than two score alien ships of space
closing in on them—ships that
were swifter and more maneuverable
than their own. These ships
had rapidly and competently englobed
the
Star Seeker
, and had
then tried to herd it away from the
planet it had been heading toward.
Although
caught by surprise,
the Earthmen had acted
swiftly. Crownwall recalled the discussion—the
council of war, they
had called it—and their unanimous
decision. Although far within the
dangerous influence of a planetary
mass, they had again activated the
distorter drive, and they had beaten
the odds. On the distorter drive,
they had returned to Earth as swiftly
as they had departed. Earth had
immediately prepared for war
against her unknown enemy.
"Your reaction was savage," said
Ggaran, his tentacles stiffening
with shock at the memory. "You
bloody-minded Earthlings must
have been aware of the terrible
danger."
Ffallk rippled in agreement.
"The action you took was too swift
and too foolhardy to be believed.
You knew that you could have destroyed
not only yourself, but also
all who live on that planet. You
could also have wrecked the planet
itself and the ships and those of
my own race who manned them.
We had tried to contact you, but
since you had not developed subspace
radio, we were of course not
successful. Our englobement was
just a routine quarantine. With
your total lack of information
about us, what you did was more
than the height of folly. It was madness."
"Could we have done anything
else that would have kept you from
landing on Earth and taking us
over?" asked Crownwall.
"Would that have been so bad?"
said Ggaran. "We can't tolerate
wild and warlike races running free
and uncontrolled in the Galaxy.
Once was enough for that."
"But what about my question?
Was there any other way for us to
stay free?"
"Well, no. But you didn't have
enough information to realize that
when you acted so precipitously. As
a matter of fact, we didn't expect
to have much trouble, even after
your surprising action. Of course,
it took us a little time to react. We
located your planet quickly enough,
and confirmed that you were a new
race. But by the time we could
try to set up communications and
send ambassadors, you had already
organized a not inconsiderable defense.
Your drones blew up our unmanned
ships as fast as we could
send them down to your planet.
And by the time we had organized
properly for war against you, it was
obvious that we could not conquer
you. We could only destroy you."
"That old fool on Sunda, the
Emperor, decided that we should
blow you up, but by that time I
had decided," said His Effulgence,
"that you might be useful to me—that
is, that we might be useful to
each other. I traveled halfway
across the Galaxy to meet him, to
convince him that it would be sufficient
just to quarantine you.
When we had used your radio system
to teach a few of you the Universal
Galactic tongue, and had
managed to get what you call the
'planet-buster' down into the
largest of your oceans, he figured
we had done our job.
"With his usual lack of imagination,
he felt sure that we were safe
from you—after all, there was no
way for you to get off the planet.
Even if you could get down to the
bottom of the ocean and tamper
with the bomb, you would only succeed
in setting it off, and that's
what the Sunda had been in favor
of in the first place.
"But I had different ideas. From
what you had already done, I suspected
it wouldn't be long before
one of you amazing Earthlings
would dream up some device or
other, head out into space, and
show up on our planet. So I've been
waiting for you, and here you are."
"It was the thinking of a genius,"
murmured Ggaran.
"All right, then, genius, here I
am," said Crownwall. "So what's
the pitch?"
"Ggaran, you explain it to the
Earthling," said His Effulgence.
Ggaran
bowed. "The crustaceans
on Sunda—the lobsterlike
creatures that rule the Galaxy—are
usurpers. They have no rights
to their position of power. Our race
is much older than theirs. We were
alone when we found the Sundans—a
primitive tribe, grubbing in the
mud at the edge of their shallow
seas, unable even to reason. In
those days we were desperately
lonely. We needed companionship
among the stars, and we helped
them develop to the point where,
in their inferior way, they were able
to reason, almost as well as we, The
People, can. And then they cheated
us of our rightful place.
"The Emperor at Sunda is one
of them. They provide sixty-eight
of the hundred Viceroys; we provide
only seventeen. It is a preposterous
and intolerable situation.
"For more than two million
years we have waited for the opportunity
for revenge. And now
that you have entered space, that
opportunity is at hand."
"If you haven't been able to help
yourselves for two million years,"
asked Crownwall, "how does the
sight of me give you so much gumption
all of a sudden?"
Ggaran's tentacles writhed, and
he slavered in fury, but the clashing
of his teeth subsided instantly
at a soothing wave from His Effulgence.
"War in space is almost an impossibility,"
said the aged ruler.
"We can destroy planets, of course,
but with few exceptions, we cannot
conquer them. I rule a total of
seven races in my Sector. I rule
them, but I don't let them intermingle.
Each race settles on the
planets that best suit it. Each of
those planets is quite capable of defending
itself from raids, or even
large-scale assaults that would result
in its capture and subjugation—just
as your little Earth can defend
itself.
"Naturally, each is vulnerable to
economic blockade—trade provides
a small but vital portion of the
goods each planet uses. All that a
world requires for a healthy and
comfortable life cannot be provided
from the resources of that
single world alone, and that gives
us a very considerable measure of
control.
"And it is true that we can always
exterminate any planet that
refuses to obey the just and legal
orders of its Viceroy. So we achieve
a working balance in our Empire.
We control it adequately, and we
live in peace.
"The Sundans, for example,
though they took the rule of the
Empire that was rightfully ours
away from us, through trickery,
were unable to take over the
Sectors we control. We are still
powerful. And soon we will be all-powerful.
In company with you
Earthlings, that is."
Crownwall nodded. "In other
words, you think that we Earthmen
can break up this two-million-year-old
stalemate. You've got the
idea that, with our help, you can
conquer planets without the necessity
of destroying them, and thereby
take over number one spot from
these Sunda friends of yours."
"Don't call those damn lobsters
friends," growled Ggaran. He subsided
at the Viceroy's gesture.
"Exactly," said His Effulgence
to Crownwall. "You broke our
blockade without any trouble. Our
instruments didn't even wiggle
when you landed here on my capital
world. You can do the same on
the worlds of the Sunda. Now, just
tell us how you did it, and we're
partners."
Crownwall
lifted one eyebrow
quizzically, but remained
silent. He didn't expect his facial
gesture to be interpreted correctly,
but he assumed that his silence
would be. He was correct.
"Of course," His Effulgence said,
"we will give you any assurances
that your people may desire in order
to feel safe, and we will guarantee
them an equal share in the
government of the Galaxy."
"Bunk," said Crownwall.
His Effulgence lifted a tentacle
swiftly, before Ggaran, lunging angrily
forward, could speak. "Then
what do you want of us?"
"It seems to me that we need
no wordy assurances from each
other," said Crownwall, and he
puffed a cigarette aglow. "We can
arrange something a little more
trustworthy, I believe. On your
side, you have the power to destroy
our only planet at any time. That
is certainly adequate security for
our own good behavior and sincerity.
"It is impossible for us of Earth
to destroy all of your planets. As
you have said, there are more planets
that belong to you than there
are human beings on Earth. But
there is a way for us to be reasonably
sure that you will behave
yourselves. You will transfer to us,
at once, a hundred of your planet-destroying
bombs. That will be a
sufficient supply to let us test some
of them, to see that they are in
good working order. Then, if you
try any kind of double-cross, we
will be able to use our own methods—which
you cannot prevent—to
send one of those bombs here to
destroy this planet.
"And if you try to move anywhere
else, by your clumsy distorter
drive, we can follow you, and
destroy any planet you choose to
land on. You would not get away
from us. We can track you without
any difficulty.
"We wouldn't use the bombs
lightly, to be sure, because of what
would happen to Earth. And don't
think that blowing up our planet
would save you, because we naturally
wouldn't keep the bombs on
Earth. How does that sound to
you?"
"Ridiculous," snorted Ggaran.
"Impossible."
After several minutes of silent
consideration, "It is an excellent
plan," said His Effulgence. "It is
worthy of the thinking of The People
ourselves. You Earthlings will
make very satisfactory allies. What
you request will be provided without
delay. Meanwhile, I see no reason
why we cannot proceed with
our discussions."
"Nor do I," consented Crownwall.
"But your stooge here doesn't
seem very happy about it all."
His Effulgence wiggled his tentacles.
"I'm afraid that Ggaran had
expected to take what you Earthlings
have to offer without giving
anything in return. I never had any
such ideas. I have not underestimated
you, you see."
"That's nice," said Crownwall
graciously.
"And now," Ggaran put in, "I
think it's time for you to tell us
something about how you get
across light-years of space in a few
hours, without leaving any traces
for us to detect." He raised a tentacle
to still Crownwall's immediate
exclamation of protest. "Oh,
nothing that would give us a chance
to duplicate it—just enough to
indicate
how we can make use of
it, along with you—enough to allow
us to
begin
to make intelligent
plans to beat the claws off the Master
Race."
After
due consideration,
Crownwall nodded. "I don't
see why not. Well, then, let me tell
you that we don't travel in space
at all. That's why I didn't show up
on any of your long-range detection
instruments. Instead, we travel
in time. Surely any race that has
progressed as far as your own must
know, at least theoretically, that
time travel is entirely possible. After
all, we knew it, and we haven't
been around nearly as long as you
have."
"We know about it," said Ffallk,
"but we've always considered it
useless—and very dangerous—knowledge."
"So have we, up until the time
you planted that bomb on us. Anyone
who tried to work any changes
in his own past would be almost
certain to end up finding himself
never having been born. So we
don't do any meddling. What we
have discovered is a way not only
of moving back into the past, but
also of making our own choice of
spatial references while we do it,
and of changing our spatial anchor
at will.
"For example, to reach this
planet, I went back far enough, using
Earth as the spatial referent,
to move with Earth a little more
than a third of the way around this
spiral nebula that is our Galaxy.
Then I shifted my frame of reference
to that of the group of galaxies
of which ours is such a distinguished
member.
"Then of course, as I continued
to move in time, the whole Galaxy
moved spatially with reference to
my own position. At the proper instant
I shifted again, to the reference
frame of this Galaxy itself.
Then I was stationary in the Galaxy,
and as I continued time traveling,
your own mighty sun moved
toward me as the Galaxy revolved.
I chose a point where there was a
time intersection of your planet's
position and my own. When you
got there, I just changed to the reference
plane of this planet I'm on
now, and then came on back with
it to the present. So here I am. It
was a long way around to cover a
net distance of 26 light-years, but
it was really very simple.
"And there's no danger of meeting
myself, or getting into any anachronistic
situation. As you probably
know, theory shows that these
are excluded times for me, as is the
future—I can't stop in them."
"Are you sure that you haven't
given us a little too much information
for your own safety?" asked
Ffallk softly.
"Not at all. We were enormously
lucky to have learned how to control
spatial reference frames ourselves.
I doubt if you could do it in
another two million years." Crownwall
rose to his feet. "And now,
Your Effulgence, I think it's about
time I went back to my ship and
drove it home to Earth to make my
report, so we can pick up those
bombs and start making arrangements."
"Excellent," said Ffallk. "I'd better
escort you; my people don't like
strangers much."
"I'd noticed that," Crownwall
commented drily.
"Since this is a very important
occasion, I think it best that we
make this a Procession of Full
Ceremony. It's a bother, but the
proprieties have to be observed."
Ggaran
stepped out into the
broad corridor and whistled a
shrill two-tone note, using both his
speaking and his eating orifices. A
cohort of troops, pikes at the ready
and bows strapped to their backs,
leaped forward and formed a
double line leading from His Effulgence's
sanctum to the main door.
Down this lane, carried by twenty
men, came a large sedan chair.
"Protocol takes a lot of time,"
said His Effulgence somewhat sadly,
"but it must be observed. At
least, as Ambassador, you can ride
with me in the sedan, instead of
walking behind it, like Ggaran."
"I'm glad of that," said Crownwall.
"Too bad Ggaran can't join
us." He climbed into the chair beside
Ffallk. The bearers trotted
along at seven or eight kilometers
an hour, carrying their contraption
with absolute smoothness. Blasts
from horns preceded them as they
went.
When they passed through the
huge entrance doors of the palace
and started down the ramp toward
the street, Crownwall was astonished
to see nobody on the previously
crowded streets, and mentioned
it to Ffallk.
"When the Viceroy of the Seventy
Suns," said the Viceroy of the
Seventy Suns, "travels in state, no
one but my own entourage is permitted
to watch. And my guests, of
course," he added, bowing slightly
to Crownwall.
"Of course," agreed Crownwall,
bowing back. "Kind of you, I'm
sure. But what happens if somebody
doesn't get the word, or
doesn't hear your trumpeters, or
something like that?"
Ggaran stepped forward, already
panting slightly. "A man with knots
in all of his ear stalks is in a very
uncomfortable position," he explained.
"Wait. Let me show you.
Let us just suppose that that runner
over there"—he gestured toward
a soldier with a tentacle—"is
a civilian who has been so unlucky
as to remain on the street
after His Effulgence's entourage arrived."
He turned to one of the
bowmen who ran beside the sedan
chair, now strung and at the ready.
"Show him!" he ordered peremptorily.
In one swift movement the bowman
notched an arrow, drew and
fired. The arrow hissed briefly, and
then sliced smoothly through the
soldier's throat.
"You see," said Ggaran complacently,
"we have very little trouble
with civilians who violate this particular
tradition."
His Effulgence beckoned to the
bowman to approach. "Your results
were satisfactory," he said, "but
your release was somewhat shaky.
The next time you show such sloppy
form, you will be given thirty
lashes."
He leaned back on the cushion
and spoke again to Crownwall.
"That's the trouble with these requirements
of civilization. The men
of my immediate guard must practice
with such things as pikes and
bows and arrows, which they seldom
get an opportunity to use. It
would never do for them to use
modern weapons on occasions of
ceremony, of course."
"Of course," said Crownwall,
then added, "It's too bad that you
can't provide them with live targets
a little more often." He stifled
a shudder of distaste. "Tell me,
Your Effulgence, does the Emperor's
race—the Master Race—also
enjoy the type of civilization
you have just had demonstrated
for me?"
"Oh, no. They are far too brutal,
too morally degraded, to know anything
of these finer points of etiquette
and propriety. They are
really an uncouth bunch. Why, do
you know, I am certain that they
would have had the bad taste to
use an energy weapon to dispose
of the victim in a case such as you
just witnessed! They are really
quite unfit to rule. They can scarcely
be called civilized at all. But we
will soon put a stop to all of that—your
race and mine, of course."
"I sincerely hope so," said
Crownwall.
Refreshments
were served
to His Effulgence and to
Crownwall during the trip, without
interrupting the smooth progress
of the sedan. The soldiers of
the cohort, the bearers and Ggaran
continued to run—without food,
drink or, except for Ggaran, evidence
of fatigue.
After several hours of travel, following
Crownwall's directions, the
procession arrived at the copse in
which he had concealed his small
transportation machine. The machine,
for spatial mobility, was
equipped with the heavy and grossly
inefficient anti-gravity field generator
developed by Kowalsky. It
occupied ten times the space of the
temporal translation and coordination
selection systems combined,
but it had the great advantage of
being almost undetectable in use. It
emitted no mass or radiation.
After elaborate and lengthy farewells,
Crownwall climbed into his
machine and fell gently up until he
was out of the atmosphere, before
starting his enormous journey
through time back to Earth. More
quickly than it had taken him to
reach his ship from the palace of
His Effulgence, he was in the Council
Chamber of the Confederation
Government of Earth, making a full
report on his trip to Vega.
When he had finished, the President
sighed deeply. "Well," he
said, "we gave you full plenipotentiary
powers, so I suppose we'll
have to stand behind your agreements—especially
in view of the
fact that we'll undoubtedly be
blown into atoms if we don't. But
from what you say, I'd rather be
in bed with a rattler than have a
treaty with a Vegan. They sound
ungodly murderous to me. There
are too many holes in that protection
plan of yours. It's only a question
of time before they'll find some
way around it, and then—poof—we'll
all be dust."
"Things may not be as bad as
they seem," answered Crownwall
complacently. "After I got back a
few million years, I'm afraid I got
a little careless and let my ship dip
down into Vega III's atmosphere
for a while. I was back so far that
the Vegans hadn't appeared yet.
Now, I didn't land—or
deliberately
kill anything—but I'd be mighty
surprised if we didn't find a change
or two. Before I came in here, I
asked Marshall to take the ship out
and check on things. He should be
back with his report before long.
Why don't we wait and see what
he has to say?"
Marshall
was excited when
he was escorted into the
Council Chamber. He bowed briefly
to the President and began to
speak rapidly.
"They're gone without trace—
all
of them
!" he cried. "I went clear
to Sunda and there's no sign of
intelligent life anywhere! We're all
alone now!"
"There, you see?" exclaimed
Crownwall. "Our enemies are all
gone!"
He looked around, glowing with
victory, at the others at the table,
then slowly quieted and sat down.
He turned his head away from
their accusing eyes.
"Alone," he said, and unconsciously
repeated Marshall's words:
"We're all alone now."
In silence, the others gathered
their papers together and left the
room, leaving Crownwall sitting at
the table by himself. He shivered
involuntarily, and then leaped to
his feet to follow after them.
Loneliness, he found, was something
that he couldn't face alone.
—L. J. STECHER, JR.
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine
June 1960.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/4/9/27492//27492-h//27492-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does the Viceroy want to overthrow the Sundans? | 27492_U24VCD2I_10 | [
"The Sundans do not understand polite society or etiquette. They really must be stopped.",
"The Sundans are waging war on the Vegans. ",
"The Sundans are a race of brutal warriors, oppressing everyone in the galaxy.",
"The Vegans were around before the Sundans, therefore the Vegans should be in charge of the galaxy."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
51,699 | 51699_RWJ8X7FI | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The God Next Door | 1966.0 | Doede, William R. | Short stories; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; PS; Science fiction | THE GOD NEXT DOOR
By BILL DOEDE
Illustrated by IVIE
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine August 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
The sand-thing was powerful, lonely and
strange. No doubt it was a god—but who wasn't?
Stinson lay still in the sand where he fell, gloating over the success
of his arrival.
He touched the pencil-line scar behind his ear where the cylinder was
buried, marveling at the power stored there, power to fling him from
earth to this fourth planet of the Centaurian system in an instant.
It had happened so fast that he could almost feel the warm, humid
Missouri air, though he was light years from Missouri.
He got up. A gray, funnel-shaped cloud of dust stood off to his left.
This became disturbing, since there was scarcely enough wind to move
his hair. He watched it, trying to recall what he might know about
cyclones. But he knew little. Weather control made cyclones and other
climatic phenomena on earth practically non-existent. The cloud
did not move, though, except to spin on its axis rapidly, emitting
a high-pitched, scarcely audible whine, like a high speed motor. He
judged it harmless.
He stood on a wide valley floor between two mountain ranges. Dark
clouds capped one peak of the mountains on his left. The sky was deep
blue.
He tested the gravity by jumping up and down. Same as Earth gravity.
The sun—no, not
the
sun. Not Sol. What should he call it, Alpha or
Centaurus? Well, perhaps neither. He was here and Earth was somewhere
up there. This was
the
sun of this particular solar system. He was
right the first time.
The sun burned fiercely, although he would have said it was about four
o'clock in the afternoon, if this had been Earth. Not a tree, nor a
bush, nor even a wisp of dry grass was in sight. Everywhere was desert.
The funnel of sand had moved closer and while he watched it, it seemed
to drift in the wind—although there was no wind. Stinson backed away.
It stopped. It was about ten feet tall by three feet in diameter at the
base. Then Stinson backed away again. It was changing. Now it became a
blue rectangle, then a red cube, a violet sphere.
He wanted to run. He wished Benjamin were here. Ben might have an
explanation. "What am I afraid of?" he said aloud, "a few grains of
sand blowing in the wind? A wind devil?"
He turned his back and walked away. When he looked up the wind devil
was there before him. He looked back. Only one. It had moved. The sun
shone obliquely, throwing Stinson's shadow upon the sand. The wind
devil also had a shadow, although the sun shone through it and the
shadow was faint. But it moved when the funnel moved. This was no
illusion.
Again Stinson felt the urge to run, or to use the cylinder to project
himself somewhere else, but he said, "No!" very firmly to himself. He
was here to investigate, to determine if this planet was capable of
supporting life.
Life? Intelligence? He examined the wind devil as closely as he dared,
but it was composed only of grains of sand. There was no core, no
central place you could point to and say, here is the brain, or the
nervous system. But then, how could a group of loosely spaced grains of
sand possibly have a nervous system?
It was again going through its paces. Triangle, cube, rectangle,
sphere. He watched, and when it became a triangle again, he smoothed
a place in the sand and drew a triangle with his forefinger. When it
changed to a cube he drew a square, a circle for a sphere, and so on.
When the symbols were repeated he pointed to each in turn, excitement
mounting. He became so absorbed in doing this that he failed to notice
how the wind devil drew closer and closer, but when he inhaled the
first grains of sand, the realization of what was happening dawned with
a flash of fear. Instantly he projected himself a thousand miles away.
Now he was in an area of profuse vegetation. It was twilight. As he
stood beside a small creek, a chill wind blew from the northwest. He
wanted to cover himself with the long leaves he found, but they were
dry and brittle, for here autumn had turned the leaves. Night would be
cold.
He was not a woodsman. He doubted if he could build a fire without
matches. So he followed the creek to where it flowed between two great
hills. Steam vapors rose from a crevice. A cave was nearby and warm air
flowed from its mouth. He went inside.
At first he thought the cave was small, but found instead that he was
in a long narrow passageway. The current of warm air flowed toward him
and he followed it, cautiously, stepping carefully and slowly. Then it
was not quite so dark. Soon he stepped out of the narrow passageway
into a great cavern with a high-vaulted ceiling.
The light source was a mystery. He left no shadow on the floor. A
great crystal sphere hung from the ceiling, and he was curious about
its purpose, but a great pool of steaming water in the center of the
cavern drew his attention. He went close, to warm himself. A stone
wall surrounding the pool was inscribed with intricate art work and
indecipherable symbols.
Life. Intelligence. The planet was inhabited.
Should he give up and return to earth? Or was there room here for
his people? Warming his hands there over the great steaming pool he
thought of Benjamin, and Straus, and Jamieson—all those to whom he had
given cylinders, and who were now struggling for life against those who
desired them.
He decided it would not be just, to give up so easily.
The wide plaza between the pool and cavern wall was smooth as polished
glass. Statues lined the wall. He examined them.
The unknown artist had been clever. From one angle they were animals,
from another birds, from a third they were vaguely humanoid creatures,
glowering at him with primitive ferocity. The fourth view was so
shocking he had to turn away quickly. No definable form or sculptured
line was visible, yet he felt, or saw—he did not know which senses
told him—the immeasurable gulf of a million years of painful
evolution. Then nothing. It was not a curtain drawn to prevent him from
seeing more.
There was no more.
He stumbled toward the pool's wall and clutched for support, but
his knees buckled. His hand slid down the wall, over the ancient
inscriptions. He sank to the floor. Before he lost consciousness he
wondered, fleetingly, if a lethal instrument was in the statue.
He woke with a ringing in his ears, feeling drugged and sluggish.
Sounds came to him. He opened his eyes.
The cavern was crowded. These creatures were not only humanoid, but
definitely human, although more slight of build than earth people. The
only difference he could see at first sight was that they had webbed
feet. All were dressed from the waist down only, in a shimmering skirt
that sparkled as they moved. They walked with the grace of ballet
dancers, moving about the plaza, conversing in a musical language with
no meaning for Stinson. The men were dark-skinned, the women somewhat
lighter, with long flowing hair, wide lips and a beauty that was
utterly sensual.
He was in chains! They were small chains, light weight, of a metal that
looked like aluminum. But all his strength could not break them.
They saw him struggling. Two of the men came over and spoke to him in
the musical language.
"My name is Stinson," he said, pointing to himself. "I'm from the
planet Earth."
They looked at each other and jabbered some more.
"Look," he said, "Earth. E-A-R-T-H, Earth." He pointed upward,
described a large circle, then another smaller, and showed how Earth
revolved around the sun.
One of the men poked him with a stick, or tube of some kind. It did not
hurt, but angered him. He left the chains by his own method of travel,
and reappeared behind the two men. They stared at the place where he
had been. The chains tinkled musically. He grasped the shoulder of the
offender, spun him around and slapped his face.
A cry of consternation rose from the group, echoing in the high
ceilinged cavern. "SBTL!" it said, "ZBTL ... XBTL ... zbtl."
The men instantly prostrated themselves before him. The one who had
poked Stinson with the stick rose, and handed it to him. Still angered,
Stinson grasped it firmly, with half a notion to break it over his
head. As he did so, a flash of blue fire sprang from it. The man
disappeared. A small cloud of dust settled slowly to the floor.
Disintegrated!
Stinson's face drained pale, and suddenly, unaccountably, he was
ashamed because he had no clothes.
"I didn't mean to kill him!" he cried. "I was angry, and...."
Useless. They could not understand. For all he knew, they might think
he was threatening them. The object he had thought of as a stick was
in reality a long metal tube, precisely machined, with a small button
near one end.
This weapon was completely out of place in a culture such as this.
Or was it? What did he know of these people? Very little. They were
humanoid. They had exhibited human emotions of anger, fear and, that
most human of all characteristics, curiosity. But up to now the tube
and the chain was the only evidence of an advanced technology, unless
the ancient inscriptions in the stone wall of the pool, and the statues
lining the wall were evidences.
There was a stirring among the crowd. An object like a pallet was
brought, carried by four of the women. They laid it at his feet, and
gestured for him to sit. He touched it cautiously, then sat.
Instantly he sprang to his feet. There, at the cavern entrance, the
wind devil writhed and undulated in a brilliant harmony of colors. It
remained in one spot, though, and he relaxed somewhat.
One of the women came toward him, long golden hair flowing, firm
breasts dipping slightly at each step. Her eyes held a language all
their own, universal. She pressed her body against him and bore him to
the pallet, her kisses fire on his face.
Incongruously, he thought of Benjamin back on earth, and all the others
with cylinders, who might be fighting for their lives at this moment.
He pushed her roughly aside.
She spoke, and he understood! Her words were still the same gibberish,
but now he knew their meaning. Somehow he knew also that the wind devil
was responsible for his understanding.
"You do not want me?" she said sadly. "Then kill me."
"Why should I kill you?"
She shrugged her beautiful shoulders. "It is the way of the Gods," she
said. "If you do not, then the others will."
He took the tube-weapon in his hands, careful not to touch the button.
"Don't be afraid. I didn't mean to kill the man. It was an accident. I
will protect you."
She shook her head. "One day they will find me alone, and they'll kill
me."
"Why?"
She shrugged. "I have not pleased you."
"On the contrary, you have. There is a time and place for everything,
though."
Suddenly a great voice sounded in the cavern, a voice with no
direction. It came from the ceiling, the floor, the walls, the steaming
pool. It was in the language of the web-footed people; it was in his
own tongue. "No harm must come to this woman. The God with fingers on
his feet has decreed this."
Those in the cavern looked at the woman with fear and respect. She
kissed Stinson's feet. Two of the men came and gave her a brilliant
new skirt. She smiled at him, and he thought he had never seen a more
beautiful face.
The great, bodiless voice sounded again, but those in the cavern went
about their activities. They did not hear.
"Who are you?"
Stinson looked at the wind devil, since it could be no one else
speaking, and pointed to himself. "Me?"
"Yes."
"I am Stinson, of the planet Earth."
"Yes, I see it in your mind, now. You want to live here, on this
planet."
"Then you must know where I came from, and how."
"I do not understand how. You have a body, a physical body composed
of atoms. It is impossible to move a physical body from one place to
another by a mere thought and a tiny instrument, yet you have done so.
You deserted me out in the desert."
"I deserted you?" Stinson cried angrily, "You tried to kill me!"
"I was attempting communication. Why should I kill you?"
He was silent a moment, looking at the people in the cavern. "Perhaps
because you feared I would become the God of these people in your
place."
Stinson felt a mental shrug. "It is of no importance. When they arrived
on this planet I attempted to explain that I was not a God, but the
primitive is not deeply buried in them. They soon resorted to emotion
rather than reason. It is of no importance."
"I'd hardly call them primitive, with such weapons."
"The tube is not of their technology. That is, they did not make
it directly. These are the undesirables, the incorrigibles, the
nonconformists from the sixth planet. I permit them here because it
occupies my time, to watch them evolve."
"You should live so long."
"Live?" the wind devil said. "Oh, I see your meaning. I'd almost
forgotten. You are a strange entity. You travel by a means even I
cannot fully understand, yet you speak of time as if some event
were about to take place. I believe you think of death. I see your
physical body has deteriorated since yesterday. Your body will cease to
exist, almost as soon as those of the sixth planet peoples. I am most
interested in you. You will bring your people, and live here."
"I haven't decided. There are these web-footed people, who were hostile
until they thought I was a God. They have destructive weapons. Also, I
don't understand you. I see you as a cone of sand which keeps changing
color and configuration. Is it your body? Where do you come from? Is
this planet populated with your kind?"
The wind devil hesitated.
"Where do I originate? It seems I have always been. You see this
cavern, the heated pool, the statues, the inscriptions. Half a million
years ago my people were as you. That is, they lived in physical
bodies. Our technology surpassed any you have seen. The tube these
webfoots use is a toy by comparison. Our scientists found the ultimate
nature of physical law. They learned to separate the mind from the
body. Then my people set a date. Our entire race was determined to free
itself from the confines of the body. The date came."
"What happened?"
"I do not know. I alone exist. I have searched all the levels of time
and matter from the very beginning. My people are gone. Sometimes it
almost comes to me, why they are gone. And this is contrary to the
greatest law of all—that an entity, once in existence, can never cease
to exist."
Stinson was silent, thinking of the endless years of searching through
the great gulf of time. His eyes caught sight of the woman, reclining
now on the pallet. The men had left her and stood in groups, talking,
glancing at him, apparently free of their awe and fear already.
The woman looked at him, and she was not smiling. "Please ask the Sand
God," she said, "to speak to my people again. Their fear of him does
not last. When He is gone they will probably kill us."
"As for the webfoots," the wind devil, or Sand God, said, "I will
destroy them. You and your people will have the entire planet."
"Destroy them?" Stinson asked, incredulously, "all these people? They
have a right to live like any one else."
"Right? What is it—'right?' They are entities. They exist, therefore
they always will. My people are the only entities who ever died. To
kill the body is unimportant."
"No. You misunderstand. Listen, you spoke of the greatest law. Your law
is a scientific hypothesis. It has to do with what comes after physical
existence, not with existence itself. The greatest law is this, that an
entity, once existing, must not be harmed in any way. To do so changes
the most basic structure of nature."
The Sand God did not reply. The great bodiless, directionless voice was
silent, and Stinson felt as if he had been taken from some high place
and set down in a dark canyon. The cone of sand was the color of wood
ashes. It pulsed erratically, like a great heart missing a beat now and
then. The web-footed people milled about restlessly. The woman's eyes
pleaded.
When he looked back, the Sand God was gone.
Instantly a new note rose in the cavern. The murmur of unmistakable mob
fury ran over the webfoots. Several of the men approached the woman
with hatred in their voices. He could not understand the words now.
But he understood her. "They'll kill me!" she cried.
Stinson pointed the disintegrating weapon at them and yelled. They
dropped back. "We'll have to get outside," he told her. "This mob will
soon get out of hand. Then the tube won't stop them. They will rush in.
I can't kill them all at once, even if I wanted to. And I don't."
Together they edged toward the cavern entrance, ran quickly up the
inclined passageway, and came out into crisp, cold air. The morning sun
was reflected from a million tiny mirrors on the rocks, the trees and
grass. A silver thaw during the night had covered the whole area with
a coating of ice. Stinson shivered. The woman handed him a skirt she
had thoughtfully brought along from the cavern. He took it, and they
ran down the slippery path leading away from the entrance. From the
hiding place behind a large rock they watched, as several web-footed
men emerged into the sunlight. They blinked, covered their eyes, and
jabbered musically among themselves. One slipped and fell on the ice.
They re-entered the cave.
Stinson donned the shimmering skirt, smiling as he did so. The others
should see him now. Benjamin and Straus and Jamieson. They would
laugh. And Ben's wife, Lisa, she would give her little-girl laugh, and
probably help him fasten the skirt. It had a string, like a tobacco
pouch, which was tied around the waist. It helped keep him warm.
He turned to the woman. "I don't know what I'll do with you, but now
that we're in trouble together, we may as well introduce ourselves. My
name is Stinson."
"I am Sybtl," she said.
"Syb-tl." He tried to imitate her musical pronunciation. "A very nice
name."
She smiled, then pointed to the cavern. "When the ice is gone, they
will come out and follow us."
"We'd better make tracks."
"No," she said, "we must run, and make no tracks."
"Okay, Sis," he said.
"Sis?"
"That means, sister."
"I am not your sister. I am your wife."
"
What?
"
"Yes. When a man protects a woman from harm, it is a sign to all that
she is his chosen. Otherwise, why not let her die? You are a strange
God."
"Listen, Sybtl," he said desperately, "I am not a God and you are not
my wife. Let's get that straight."
"But...."
"No buts. Right now we'd better get out of here."
He took her hand and they ran, slid, fell, picked themselves up again,
and ran. He doubted the wisdom of keeping her with him. Alone, the
webfoots were no match for him. He could travel instantly to any spot
he chose. But with Sybtl it was another matter; he was no better than
any other man, perhaps not so good as some because he was forty, and
never had been an athlete.
How was he to decide if this planet was suitable for his people,
hampered by a woman, slinking through a frozen wilderness like an
Indian? But the woman's hand was soft. He felt strong knowing she
depended on him.
Anyway, he decided, pursuit was impossible. They left no tracks on the
ice. They were safe, unless the webfoots possessed talents unknown to
him.
So they followed the path leading down from the rocks, along the creek
with its tumbling water. Frozen, leafless willows clawed at their
bodies. The sun shone fiercely in a cloudless sky. Already water ran in
tiny rivulets over the ice. The woman steered him to the right, away
from the creek.
Stinson's bare feet were numb from walking on ice. Christ, he thought,
what am I doing here, anyway? He glanced down at Sybtl and remembered
the webfoots. He stopped, tempted to use his cylinder and move to a
warmer, less dangerous spot.
The woman pulled on his arm. "We must hurry!"
He clutched the tube-weapon. "How many shots in this thing?"
"Shots?"
"How often can I use it?"
"As often as you like. It is good for fifty years. Kaatr—he is the one
you destroyed—brought it from the ship when we came. Many times he has
used it unwisely."
"When did you come?"
"Ten years ago. I was a child."
"I thought only criminals were brought here."
She nodded. "Criminals, and their children."
"When will your people come again?"
She shook her head. "Never. They are no longer my people. They have
disowned us."
"And because of me even those in the cavern have disowned you."
Suddenly she stiffened beside him. There, directly in their path, stood
the Sand God. It was blood red now. It pulsed violently. The great
voice burst forth.
"Leave the woman!" it demanded angrily. "The webfoots are nearing your
position."
"I cannot leave her. She is helpless against them."
"What form of primitive stupidity are you practicing now? Leave, or
they will kill you."
Stinson shook his head.
The Sand God pulsed more violently than before. Ice melted in a wide
area around it. Brown, frozen grass burned to ashes.
"You will allow them to kill you, just to defend her life? What
business is it of yours if she lives or dies? My race discarded such
primitive logic long before it reached your level of development."
"Yes," Stinson said, "and your race no longer exists."
The Sand God became a sphere of blue flame. A wave of intense heat
drove them backward. "Earthman," the great voice said, "go back to your
Earth. Take your inconsistencies with you. Do not come here again to
infect my planet with your primitive ideas. The webfoots are not as
intelligent as you, but they are sane. If you bring your people here, I
shall destroy you all."
The sphere of blue fire screamed away across the frozen wilderness, and
the thunder of its passing shook the ground and echoed among the lonely
hills.
Sybtl shivered against his arm. "The Sand God is angry," she said. "My
people tell how he was angry once before, when we first came here. He
killed half of us and burned the ship that brought us. That is how
Kaatr got the tube-weapon. It was the only thing the Sand God didn't
burn, that and the skirts. Then, when he had burned the ship, the Sand
God went to the sixth planet and burned two of the largest cities, as a
warning that no more of us must come here."
Well, Stinson said to himself, that does it. We are better off on
Earth. We can't fight a monster like him.
Sybtl touched his arm. "Why did the Sand God come? He did not speak."
"He spoke to me."
"I did not hear."
"Yes, I know now. His voice sounds like thunder in the sky, but it is a
voice that speaks only in the mind. He said I must leave this planet."
She glanced at him with suddenly awakened eyes, as if thinking of it
for the first time. "Where is your ship?"
"I have no ship."
"Then he will kill you." She touched her fingers on his face. "I am
sorry. It was all for me."
"Don't worry. The Sand God travels without a ship, why shouldn't I?"
"Now?"
"As soon as you are safe. Come."
Steam rose from the burned area, charred like a rocket launching pit.
They stepped around it carefully. Stinson felt warm air, but there was
no time, now, to warm cold feet or dwell on the vagaries of Sand Gods.
Together they crossed the narrow valley. Sybtl led him toward a tall
mound of rock. Here they came to the creek again, which flowed into a
small canyon. They climbed the canyon wall. Far away, small figures
moved. The webfoots were on their trail.
She drew him into a small cave. It was heated, like the great cavern,
but held no walled pool nor mysterious lighting. But it was warm, and
the small entrance made an excellent vantage point for warding off
attack.
"They will not find us...."
A high-pitched keening burst suddenly around them. Stinson knew they
had heard, or felt the sound for some time, that now its frequency was
in an audible range.
"The Sand God," Sybtl said. "Sometimes he plays among the clouds. He
makes it rain in a dry summer, or sometimes warms the whole world
for days at a time in winter, so the snow melts and the grass begins
to green. Then he tires and lets winter come back again. He is the
loneliest God in the universe."
"What makes you think he's lonely?"
She shrugged her shoulders. "I just know. But he's an angry God now.
See those clouds piling in the East? Soon they will hide the sun. Then
he will make them churn and boil, like river whirlpools in spring. At
least he does this when he plays. Who knows what he will do when he's
angry?"
"The Sand God isn't doing this," Stinson said. "It's only a storm."
She covered his lips with her fingers. "Don't say that. He may hear you
and be more angry."
"But it is, don't you see? You give him powers he does not possess."
Sybtl shook her head and stroked his face with her long, slim fingers.
"Poor little God-with-fingers-on-his-feet," she said. "You do not
understand. The Sand God is terrible, even when he plays. See the
lightning? It is blue. The lightning of a storm that comes by itself is
not blue. He is running around the world on feet like the rockets of
space ships, and when he strikes the clouds, blue fire shoots away."
The clouds continued to build on one another. Soon the blue flashes of
lightning extended across the sky from horizon to horizon. The earth
trembled. Sybtl moved closer, trembling also.
"He never did this before," she said. "He never made the earth shake
before."
Great boulders crashed down the canyon walls and dropped into the
creek. They dared not move from the cave, although death seemed certain
if they stayed.
"I'll leave for a moment," he said. "I'll be back soon."
"You're leaving?" There was panic in her voice.
"Only for a moment."
"And you won't come back. You will go to your world."
"No. I'll be back."
"Promise? No, don't promise. The promises of Gods often are forgotten
before the sounds die away."
"I'll be back."
He disappeared at once, giving her no chance to object again, and went
to the desert of sand, where he had first arrived on the planet. He
wanted to see if the storm were world-wide.
Stinson had never been in a sand storm before, even on Earth. He could
not breathe. He could not see. Bullets of sand stung his skin. Bullets
of sand shot into his eyes. Clouds of sand howled around him. He fell,
and the wind rolled him over and over in the sand like a tumbleweed.
The skirt flew up around his face. He could not get up again.
He returned to the cave.
Soon after, while they sat huddled together, watching the chaos of
tumbling rocks, lightning, and driving rain, the high-pitched keening
came again. A sphere of blue fire appeared in the east. Its brilliance
put the lightning to shame. It bore down on the cave swiftly,
purposefully. Stinson prepared himself to leave. In spite of his desire
to protect Sybtl, it was useless to get himself killed when he was
powerless to help her. But at the last moment it veered off.
"Fiend!" Stinson screamed the word, vaguely marvelling at his own fury.
The blue sphere turned and came back.
"Monster!"
Again.
"Murderer!"
"Adolescent!"
This time it kept going. The rain and wind ceased. Lightning stopped.
Thunder rumbled distantly. Clouds disappeared. Stinson and Sybtl
emerged from the cave.
There was no longer a question of attack from the webfoots, the storm
had taken care of that. The fierce sun began its work of drying rocks
and throwing shadows and coaxing life out into the open again. Down in
the canyon a bird sang, a lonely, cheerful twitter.
"The Sand God is tired," Sybtl said. "He is not angry now. I'm glad.
Perhaps he will let you stay."
"No. Even if he allowed it, I couldn't stay. My people could never live
here with a God who is half devil."
The cone of sand suddenly appeared. It stood in the canyon, its base
on a level with the cave. It was quiet. It was dull gray in color. It
exuded impressions of death, of hopeful words solemnly spoken over
lowered coffins, of cold earth and cold space, of dank, wet catacombs,
of creeping, crawling nether things.
The bird's twitter stopped abruptly.
"Earthman," the Sand God said, as if he were about to make a statement.
Stinson ignored him. He glanced down at Sybtl, who sensed that this was
a time for good-bys. He thought, perhaps I can stay here alone with
her. The webfoots might find us, or the Sand God might destroy us in
one of his fits, but it might be worth it.
"Don't go," she said. "Not yet."
"Earthman, hear me."
"I hear you."
"Why does your mind shrink backward?"
"I've decided not to bring my people here."
"
You
decided?"
"Certainly," Stinson said boldly. "Call it rationalization, if you
wish. You ordered us away; and I have several good reasons for not
coming here if the door was open."
"I've changed my mind. You will be welcomed."
"Listen to that, will you?" Stinson said angrily. "Just listen! You
set yourself up as a God for the webfoots. You get them eating out of
your hand. Then what do you do? You throw a fit. Yes, a fit! Like an
adolescent. Worse."
"Earthman, wait...."
"No!" Stinson shot back. "You've owned this planet for a million
years. You have brooded here alone since before my people discovered
fire, and in all those ages you never learned self-control. I can't
subject my people to the whims of an entity who throws a planetary fit
when it pleases him."
Stinson relaxed. He'd had his say. Sybtl trembled beside him. A small
mammal, round, furry, hopped by, sniffing inquisitively.
Sybtl said, "Is the Sand God happy?" She shook her head. "No, he is not
happy. He is old, old, old. I can feel it. My people say that when one
gets too old it is well to die. But Gods never die, do they? I would
not like to be a God."
"Stinson," the Sand God said. "You said I was adolescent. You are
correct. Do you remember I told you how my people, the entire race,
left their bodies at the same time? Do you imagine all of us were
adults?"
"I suppose not. Sounds reasonable. How old were you?"
"Chronologically, by our standards, I was nine years old."
"But you continued to develop after...."
"No."
Stinson tried to imagine it. At first there must have been a single
voice crying into a monstrous emptiness, "Mother, where are you?
MOTHER!
Where is
everyone
?" A frenzied searching of the planet,
the solar system, the galaxy. Then a returning to the planet. Empty....
Change. Buildings, roads, bridges weathering slowly. Such a race would
have built of durable metal. Durable? Centuries, eons passed. Buildings
crumbled to dust, dust blew away. Bridges eroded, fell, decomposed
into basic elements. The shape of constellations changed. All trace
of civilization passed except in the cavern of the heated pool.
Constellations disappeared, new patterns formed in the night sky. The
unutterably total void of time—FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND YEARS!
And a nine-year-old child brooding over an empty world.
"I don't understand why your development stopped," Stinson said.
"Nor do I. But perhaps ... well, I sense that I would continue, if you
brought your people here. You have already taught me the value of
life. There is a oneness, a bond that ties each living thing to every
other living thing. It is a lesson my people never knew. Select any
portion of this planet that suits you. Take the web-footed woman for
your wife. Have children. I promise never to harm you in any way."
"The webfoots?"
"You and they shall share the planet."
The Sand God disappeared. Sybtl said; "Is the Sand God angry again?"
"No, he is not angry."
"I'm glad. You will leave now?"
"No. This is my home."
She laughed softly. "You are a strange God."
"Listen," he said, "I am not a God. Get that through your head."
She drew him into the cave. Her lips were cool and sweet. The cave was
pleasantly warm.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/6/9/51699//51699-h//51699-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Approximately how long was Stinson on the planet before he decided it was home? | 51699_RWJ8X7FI_1 | [
"12 hours",
"24 hours",
"36 hours",
"48 hours"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 3,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
51,699 | 51699_RWJ8X7FI | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The God Next Door | 1966.0 | Doede, William R. | Short stories; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; PS; Science fiction | THE GOD NEXT DOOR
By BILL DOEDE
Illustrated by IVIE
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine August 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
The sand-thing was powerful, lonely and
strange. No doubt it was a god—but who wasn't?
Stinson lay still in the sand where he fell, gloating over the success
of his arrival.
He touched the pencil-line scar behind his ear where the cylinder was
buried, marveling at the power stored there, power to fling him from
earth to this fourth planet of the Centaurian system in an instant.
It had happened so fast that he could almost feel the warm, humid
Missouri air, though he was light years from Missouri.
He got up. A gray, funnel-shaped cloud of dust stood off to his left.
This became disturbing, since there was scarcely enough wind to move
his hair. He watched it, trying to recall what he might know about
cyclones. But he knew little. Weather control made cyclones and other
climatic phenomena on earth practically non-existent. The cloud
did not move, though, except to spin on its axis rapidly, emitting
a high-pitched, scarcely audible whine, like a high speed motor. He
judged it harmless.
He stood on a wide valley floor between two mountain ranges. Dark
clouds capped one peak of the mountains on his left. The sky was deep
blue.
He tested the gravity by jumping up and down. Same as Earth gravity.
The sun—no, not
the
sun. Not Sol. What should he call it, Alpha or
Centaurus? Well, perhaps neither. He was here and Earth was somewhere
up there. This was
the
sun of this particular solar system. He was
right the first time.
The sun burned fiercely, although he would have said it was about four
o'clock in the afternoon, if this had been Earth. Not a tree, nor a
bush, nor even a wisp of dry grass was in sight. Everywhere was desert.
The funnel of sand had moved closer and while he watched it, it seemed
to drift in the wind—although there was no wind. Stinson backed away.
It stopped. It was about ten feet tall by three feet in diameter at the
base. Then Stinson backed away again. It was changing. Now it became a
blue rectangle, then a red cube, a violet sphere.
He wanted to run. He wished Benjamin were here. Ben might have an
explanation. "What am I afraid of?" he said aloud, "a few grains of
sand blowing in the wind? A wind devil?"
He turned his back and walked away. When he looked up the wind devil
was there before him. He looked back. Only one. It had moved. The sun
shone obliquely, throwing Stinson's shadow upon the sand. The wind
devil also had a shadow, although the sun shone through it and the
shadow was faint. But it moved when the funnel moved. This was no
illusion.
Again Stinson felt the urge to run, or to use the cylinder to project
himself somewhere else, but he said, "No!" very firmly to himself. He
was here to investigate, to determine if this planet was capable of
supporting life.
Life? Intelligence? He examined the wind devil as closely as he dared,
but it was composed only of grains of sand. There was no core, no
central place you could point to and say, here is the brain, or the
nervous system. But then, how could a group of loosely spaced grains of
sand possibly have a nervous system?
It was again going through its paces. Triangle, cube, rectangle,
sphere. He watched, and when it became a triangle again, he smoothed
a place in the sand and drew a triangle with his forefinger. When it
changed to a cube he drew a square, a circle for a sphere, and so on.
When the symbols were repeated he pointed to each in turn, excitement
mounting. He became so absorbed in doing this that he failed to notice
how the wind devil drew closer and closer, but when he inhaled the
first grains of sand, the realization of what was happening dawned with
a flash of fear. Instantly he projected himself a thousand miles away.
Now he was in an area of profuse vegetation. It was twilight. As he
stood beside a small creek, a chill wind blew from the northwest. He
wanted to cover himself with the long leaves he found, but they were
dry and brittle, for here autumn had turned the leaves. Night would be
cold.
He was not a woodsman. He doubted if he could build a fire without
matches. So he followed the creek to where it flowed between two great
hills. Steam vapors rose from a crevice. A cave was nearby and warm air
flowed from its mouth. He went inside.
At first he thought the cave was small, but found instead that he was
in a long narrow passageway. The current of warm air flowed toward him
and he followed it, cautiously, stepping carefully and slowly. Then it
was not quite so dark. Soon he stepped out of the narrow passageway
into a great cavern with a high-vaulted ceiling.
The light source was a mystery. He left no shadow on the floor. A
great crystal sphere hung from the ceiling, and he was curious about
its purpose, but a great pool of steaming water in the center of the
cavern drew his attention. He went close, to warm himself. A stone
wall surrounding the pool was inscribed with intricate art work and
indecipherable symbols.
Life. Intelligence. The planet was inhabited.
Should he give up and return to earth? Or was there room here for
his people? Warming his hands there over the great steaming pool he
thought of Benjamin, and Straus, and Jamieson—all those to whom he had
given cylinders, and who were now struggling for life against those who
desired them.
He decided it would not be just, to give up so easily.
The wide plaza between the pool and cavern wall was smooth as polished
glass. Statues lined the wall. He examined them.
The unknown artist had been clever. From one angle they were animals,
from another birds, from a third they were vaguely humanoid creatures,
glowering at him with primitive ferocity. The fourth view was so
shocking he had to turn away quickly. No definable form or sculptured
line was visible, yet he felt, or saw—he did not know which senses
told him—the immeasurable gulf of a million years of painful
evolution. Then nothing. It was not a curtain drawn to prevent him from
seeing more.
There was no more.
He stumbled toward the pool's wall and clutched for support, but
his knees buckled. His hand slid down the wall, over the ancient
inscriptions. He sank to the floor. Before he lost consciousness he
wondered, fleetingly, if a lethal instrument was in the statue.
He woke with a ringing in his ears, feeling drugged and sluggish.
Sounds came to him. He opened his eyes.
The cavern was crowded. These creatures were not only humanoid, but
definitely human, although more slight of build than earth people. The
only difference he could see at first sight was that they had webbed
feet. All were dressed from the waist down only, in a shimmering skirt
that sparkled as they moved. They walked with the grace of ballet
dancers, moving about the plaza, conversing in a musical language with
no meaning for Stinson. The men were dark-skinned, the women somewhat
lighter, with long flowing hair, wide lips and a beauty that was
utterly sensual.
He was in chains! They were small chains, light weight, of a metal that
looked like aluminum. But all his strength could not break them.
They saw him struggling. Two of the men came over and spoke to him in
the musical language.
"My name is Stinson," he said, pointing to himself. "I'm from the
planet Earth."
They looked at each other and jabbered some more.
"Look," he said, "Earth. E-A-R-T-H, Earth." He pointed upward,
described a large circle, then another smaller, and showed how Earth
revolved around the sun.
One of the men poked him with a stick, or tube of some kind. It did not
hurt, but angered him. He left the chains by his own method of travel,
and reappeared behind the two men. They stared at the place where he
had been. The chains tinkled musically. He grasped the shoulder of the
offender, spun him around and slapped his face.
A cry of consternation rose from the group, echoing in the high
ceilinged cavern. "SBTL!" it said, "ZBTL ... XBTL ... zbtl."
The men instantly prostrated themselves before him. The one who had
poked Stinson with the stick rose, and handed it to him. Still angered,
Stinson grasped it firmly, with half a notion to break it over his
head. As he did so, a flash of blue fire sprang from it. The man
disappeared. A small cloud of dust settled slowly to the floor.
Disintegrated!
Stinson's face drained pale, and suddenly, unaccountably, he was
ashamed because he had no clothes.
"I didn't mean to kill him!" he cried. "I was angry, and...."
Useless. They could not understand. For all he knew, they might think
he was threatening them. The object he had thought of as a stick was
in reality a long metal tube, precisely machined, with a small button
near one end.
This weapon was completely out of place in a culture such as this.
Or was it? What did he know of these people? Very little. They were
humanoid. They had exhibited human emotions of anger, fear and, that
most human of all characteristics, curiosity. But up to now the tube
and the chain was the only evidence of an advanced technology, unless
the ancient inscriptions in the stone wall of the pool, and the statues
lining the wall were evidences.
There was a stirring among the crowd. An object like a pallet was
brought, carried by four of the women. They laid it at his feet, and
gestured for him to sit. He touched it cautiously, then sat.
Instantly he sprang to his feet. There, at the cavern entrance, the
wind devil writhed and undulated in a brilliant harmony of colors. It
remained in one spot, though, and he relaxed somewhat.
One of the women came toward him, long golden hair flowing, firm
breasts dipping slightly at each step. Her eyes held a language all
their own, universal. She pressed her body against him and bore him to
the pallet, her kisses fire on his face.
Incongruously, he thought of Benjamin back on earth, and all the others
with cylinders, who might be fighting for their lives at this moment.
He pushed her roughly aside.
She spoke, and he understood! Her words were still the same gibberish,
but now he knew their meaning. Somehow he knew also that the wind devil
was responsible for his understanding.
"You do not want me?" she said sadly. "Then kill me."
"Why should I kill you?"
She shrugged her beautiful shoulders. "It is the way of the Gods," she
said. "If you do not, then the others will."
He took the tube-weapon in his hands, careful not to touch the button.
"Don't be afraid. I didn't mean to kill the man. It was an accident. I
will protect you."
She shook her head. "One day they will find me alone, and they'll kill
me."
"Why?"
She shrugged. "I have not pleased you."
"On the contrary, you have. There is a time and place for everything,
though."
Suddenly a great voice sounded in the cavern, a voice with no
direction. It came from the ceiling, the floor, the walls, the steaming
pool. It was in the language of the web-footed people; it was in his
own tongue. "No harm must come to this woman. The God with fingers on
his feet has decreed this."
Those in the cavern looked at the woman with fear and respect. She
kissed Stinson's feet. Two of the men came and gave her a brilliant
new skirt. She smiled at him, and he thought he had never seen a more
beautiful face.
The great, bodiless voice sounded again, but those in the cavern went
about their activities. They did not hear.
"Who are you?"
Stinson looked at the wind devil, since it could be no one else
speaking, and pointed to himself. "Me?"
"Yes."
"I am Stinson, of the planet Earth."
"Yes, I see it in your mind, now. You want to live here, on this
planet."
"Then you must know where I came from, and how."
"I do not understand how. You have a body, a physical body composed
of atoms. It is impossible to move a physical body from one place to
another by a mere thought and a tiny instrument, yet you have done so.
You deserted me out in the desert."
"I deserted you?" Stinson cried angrily, "You tried to kill me!"
"I was attempting communication. Why should I kill you?"
He was silent a moment, looking at the people in the cavern. "Perhaps
because you feared I would become the God of these people in your
place."
Stinson felt a mental shrug. "It is of no importance. When they arrived
on this planet I attempted to explain that I was not a God, but the
primitive is not deeply buried in them. They soon resorted to emotion
rather than reason. It is of no importance."
"I'd hardly call them primitive, with such weapons."
"The tube is not of their technology. That is, they did not make
it directly. These are the undesirables, the incorrigibles, the
nonconformists from the sixth planet. I permit them here because it
occupies my time, to watch them evolve."
"You should live so long."
"Live?" the wind devil said. "Oh, I see your meaning. I'd almost
forgotten. You are a strange entity. You travel by a means even I
cannot fully understand, yet you speak of time as if some event
were about to take place. I believe you think of death. I see your
physical body has deteriorated since yesterday. Your body will cease to
exist, almost as soon as those of the sixth planet peoples. I am most
interested in you. You will bring your people, and live here."
"I haven't decided. There are these web-footed people, who were hostile
until they thought I was a God. They have destructive weapons. Also, I
don't understand you. I see you as a cone of sand which keeps changing
color and configuration. Is it your body? Where do you come from? Is
this planet populated with your kind?"
The wind devil hesitated.
"Where do I originate? It seems I have always been. You see this
cavern, the heated pool, the statues, the inscriptions. Half a million
years ago my people were as you. That is, they lived in physical
bodies. Our technology surpassed any you have seen. The tube these
webfoots use is a toy by comparison. Our scientists found the ultimate
nature of physical law. They learned to separate the mind from the
body. Then my people set a date. Our entire race was determined to free
itself from the confines of the body. The date came."
"What happened?"
"I do not know. I alone exist. I have searched all the levels of time
and matter from the very beginning. My people are gone. Sometimes it
almost comes to me, why they are gone. And this is contrary to the
greatest law of all—that an entity, once in existence, can never cease
to exist."
Stinson was silent, thinking of the endless years of searching through
the great gulf of time. His eyes caught sight of the woman, reclining
now on the pallet. The men had left her and stood in groups, talking,
glancing at him, apparently free of their awe and fear already.
The woman looked at him, and she was not smiling. "Please ask the Sand
God," she said, "to speak to my people again. Their fear of him does
not last. When He is gone they will probably kill us."
"As for the webfoots," the wind devil, or Sand God, said, "I will
destroy them. You and your people will have the entire planet."
"Destroy them?" Stinson asked, incredulously, "all these people? They
have a right to live like any one else."
"Right? What is it—'right?' They are entities. They exist, therefore
they always will. My people are the only entities who ever died. To
kill the body is unimportant."
"No. You misunderstand. Listen, you spoke of the greatest law. Your law
is a scientific hypothesis. It has to do with what comes after physical
existence, not with existence itself. The greatest law is this, that an
entity, once existing, must not be harmed in any way. To do so changes
the most basic structure of nature."
The Sand God did not reply. The great bodiless, directionless voice was
silent, and Stinson felt as if he had been taken from some high place
and set down in a dark canyon. The cone of sand was the color of wood
ashes. It pulsed erratically, like a great heart missing a beat now and
then. The web-footed people milled about restlessly. The woman's eyes
pleaded.
When he looked back, the Sand God was gone.
Instantly a new note rose in the cavern. The murmur of unmistakable mob
fury ran over the webfoots. Several of the men approached the woman
with hatred in their voices. He could not understand the words now.
But he understood her. "They'll kill me!" she cried.
Stinson pointed the disintegrating weapon at them and yelled. They
dropped back. "We'll have to get outside," he told her. "This mob will
soon get out of hand. Then the tube won't stop them. They will rush in.
I can't kill them all at once, even if I wanted to. And I don't."
Together they edged toward the cavern entrance, ran quickly up the
inclined passageway, and came out into crisp, cold air. The morning sun
was reflected from a million tiny mirrors on the rocks, the trees and
grass. A silver thaw during the night had covered the whole area with
a coating of ice. Stinson shivered. The woman handed him a skirt she
had thoughtfully brought along from the cavern. He took it, and they
ran down the slippery path leading away from the entrance. From the
hiding place behind a large rock they watched, as several web-footed
men emerged into the sunlight. They blinked, covered their eyes, and
jabbered musically among themselves. One slipped and fell on the ice.
They re-entered the cave.
Stinson donned the shimmering skirt, smiling as he did so. The others
should see him now. Benjamin and Straus and Jamieson. They would
laugh. And Ben's wife, Lisa, she would give her little-girl laugh, and
probably help him fasten the skirt. It had a string, like a tobacco
pouch, which was tied around the waist. It helped keep him warm.
He turned to the woman. "I don't know what I'll do with you, but now
that we're in trouble together, we may as well introduce ourselves. My
name is Stinson."
"I am Sybtl," she said.
"Syb-tl." He tried to imitate her musical pronunciation. "A very nice
name."
She smiled, then pointed to the cavern. "When the ice is gone, they
will come out and follow us."
"We'd better make tracks."
"No," she said, "we must run, and make no tracks."
"Okay, Sis," he said.
"Sis?"
"That means, sister."
"I am not your sister. I am your wife."
"
What?
"
"Yes. When a man protects a woman from harm, it is a sign to all that
she is his chosen. Otherwise, why not let her die? You are a strange
God."
"Listen, Sybtl," he said desperately, "I am not a God and you are not
my wife. Let's get that straight."
"But...."
"No buts. Right now we'd better get out of here."
He took her hand and they ran, slid, fell, picked themselves up again,
and ran. He doubted the wisdom of keeping her with him. Alone, the
webfoots were no match for him. He could travel instantly to any spot
he chose. But with Sybtl it was another matter; he was no better than
any other man, perhaps not so good as some because he was forty, and
never had been an athlete.
How was he to decide if this planet was suitable for his people,
hampered by a woman, slinking through a frozen wilderness like an
Indian? But the woman's hand was soft. He felt strong knowing she
depended on him.
Anyway, he decided, pursuit was impossible. They left no tracks on the
ice. They were safe, unless the webfoots possessed talents unknown to
him.
So they followed the path leading down from the rocks, along the creek
with its tumbling water. Frozen, leafless willows clawed at their
bodies. The sun shone fiercely in a cloudless sky. Already water ran in
tiny rivulets over the ice. The woman steered him to the right, away
from the creek.
Stinson's bare feet were numb from walking on ice. Christ, he thought,
what am I doing here, anyway? He glanced down at Sybtl and remembered
the webfoots. He stopped, tempted to use his cylinder and move to a
warmer, less dangerous spot.
The woman pulled on his arm. "We must hurry!"
He clutched the tube-weapon. "How many shots in this thing?"
"Shots?"
"How often can I use it?"
"As often as you like. It is good for fifty years. Kaatr—he is the one
you destroyed—brought it from the ship when we came. Many times he has
used it unwisely."
"When did you come?"
"Ten years ago. I was a child."
"I thought only criminals were brought here."
She nodded. "Criminals, and their children."
"When will your people come again?"
She shook her head. "Never. They are no longer my people. They have
disowned us."
"And because of me even those in the cavern have disowned you."
Suddenly she stiffened beside him. There, directly in their path, stood
the Sand God. It was blood red now. It pulsed violently. The great
voice burst forth.
"Leave the woman!" it demanded angrily. "The webfoots are nearing your
position."
"I cannot leave her. She is helpless against them."
"What form of primitive stupidity are you practicing now? Leave, or
they will kill you."
Stinson shook his head.
The Sand God pulsed more violently than before. Ice melted in a wide
area around it. Brown, frozen grass burned to ashes.
"You will allow them to kill you, just to defend her life? What
business is it of yours if she lives or dies? My race discarded such
primitive logic long before it reached your level of development."
"Yes," Stinson said, "and your race no longer exists."
The Sand God became a sphere of blue flame. A wave of intense heat
drove them backward. "Earthman," the great voice said, "go back to your
Earth. Take your inconsistencies with you. Do not come here again to
infect my planet with your primitive ideas. The webfoots are not as
intelligent as you, but they are sane. If you bring your people here, I
shall destroy you all."
The sphere of blue fire screamed away across the frozen wilderness, and
the thunder of its passing shook the ground and echoed among the lonely
hills.
Sybtl shivered against his arm. "The Sand God is angry," she said. "My
people tell how he was angry once before, when we first came here. He
killed half of us and burned the ship that brought us. That is how
Kaatr got the tube-weapon. It was the only thing the Sand God didn't
burn, that and the skirts. Then, when he had burned the ship, the Sand
God went to the sixth planet and burned two of the largest cities, as a
warning that no more of us must come here."
Well, Stinson said to himself, that does it. We are better off on
Earth. We can't fight a monster like him.
Sybtl touched his arm. "Why did the Sand God come? He did not speak."
"He spoke to me."
"I did not hear."
"Yes, I know now. His voice sounds like thunder in the sky, but it is a
voice that speaks only in the mind. He said I must leave this planet."
She glanced at him with suddenly awakened eyes, as if thinking of it
for the first time. "Where is your ship?"
"I have no ship."
"Then he will kill you." She touched her fingers on his face. "I am
sorry. It was all for me."
"Don't worry. The Sand God travels without a ship, why shouldn't I?"
"Now?"
"As soon as you are safe. Come."
Steam rose from the burned area, charred like a rocket launching pit.
They stepped around it carefully. Stinson felt warm air, but there was
no time, now, to warm cold feet or dwell on the vagaries of Sand Gods.
Together they crossed the narrow valley. Sybtl led him toward a tall
mound of rock. Here they came to the creek again, which flowed into a
small canyon. They climbed the canyon wall. Far away, small figures
moved. The webfoots were on their trail.
She drew him into a small cave. It was heated, like the great cavern,
but held no walled pool nor mysterious lighting. But it was warm, and
the small entrance made an excellent vantage point for warding off
attack.
"They will not find us...."
A high-pitched keening burst suddenly around them. Stinson knew they
had heard, or felt the sound for some time, that now its frequency was
in an audible range.
"The Sand God," Sybtl said. "Sometimes he plays among the clouds. He
makes it rain in a dry summer, or sometimes warms the whole world
for days at a time in winter, so the snow melts and the grass begins
to green. Then he tires and lets winter come back again. He is the
loneliest God in the universe."
"What makes you think he's lonely?"
She shrugged her shoulders. "I just know. But he's an angry God now.
See those clouds piling in the East? Soon they will hide the sun. Then
he will make them churn and boil, like river whirlpools in spring. At
least he does this when he plays. Who knows what he will do when he's
angry?"
"The Sand God isn't doing this," Stinson said. "It's only a storm."
She covered his lips with her fingers. "Don't say that. He may hear you
and be more angry."
"But it is, don't you see? You give him powers he does not possess."
Sybtl shook her head and stroked his face with her long, slim fingers.
"Poor little God-with-fingers-on-his-feet," she said. "You do not
understand. The Sand God is terrible, even when he plays. See the
lightning? It is blue. The lightning of a storm that comes by itself is
not blue. He is running around the world on feet like the rockets of
space ships, and when he strikes the clouds, blue fire shoots away."
The clouds continued to build on one another. Soon the blue flashes of
lightning extended across the sky from horizon to horizon. The earth
trembled. Sybtl moved closer, trembling also.
"He never did this before," she said. "He never made the earth shake
before."
Great boulders crashed down the canyon walls and dropped into the
creek. They dared not move from the cave, although death seemed certain
if they stayed.
"I'll leave for a moment," he said. "I'll be back soon."
"You're leaving?" There was panic in her voice.
"Only for a moment."
"And you won't come back. You will go to your world."
"No. I'll be back."
"Promise? No, don't promise. The promises of Gods often are forgotten
before the sounds die away."
"I'll be back."
He disappeared at once, giving her no chance to object again, and went
to the desert of sand, where he had first arrived on the planet. He
wanted to see if the storm were world-wide.
Stinson had never been in a sand storm before, even on Earth. He could
not breathe. He could not see. Bullets of sand stung his skin. Bullets
of sand shot into his eyes. Clouds of sand howled around him. He fell,
and the wind rolled him over and over in the sand like a tumbleweed.
The skirt flew up around his face. He could not get up again.
He returned to the cave.
Soon after, while they sat huddled together, watching the chaos of
tumbling rocks, lightning, and driving rain, the high-pitched keening
came again. A sphere of blue fire appeared in the east. Its brilliance
put the lightning to shame. It bore down on the cave swiftly,
purposefully. Stinson prepared himself to leave. In spite of his desire
to protect Sybtl, it was useless to get himself killed when he was
powerless to help her. But at the last moment it veered off.
"Fiend!" Stinson screamed the word, vaguely marvelling at his own fury.
The blue sphere turned and came back.
"Monster!"
Again.
"Murderer!"
"Adolescent!"
This time it kept going. The rain and wind ceased. Lightning stopped.
Thunder rumbled distantly. Clouds disappeared. Stinson and Sybtl
emerged from the cave.
There was no longer a question of attack from the webfoots, the storm
had taken care of that. The fierce sun began its work of drying rocks
and throwing shadows and coaxing life out into the open again. Down in
the canyon a bird sang, a lonely, cheerful twitter.
"The Sand God is tired," Sybtl said. "He is not angry now. I'm glad.
Perhaps he will let you stay."
"No. Even if he allowed it, I couldn't stay. My people could never live
here with a God who is half devil."
The cone of sand suddenly appeared. It stood in the canyon, its base
on a level with the cave. It was quiet. It was dull gray in color. It
exuded impressions of death, of hopeful words solemnly spoken over
lowered coffins, of cold earth and cold space, of dank, wet catacombs,
of creeping, crawling nether things.
The bird's twitter stopped abruptly.
"Earthman," the Sand God said, as if he were about to make a statement.
Stinson ignored him. He glanced down at Sybtl, who sensed that this was
a time for good-bys. He thought, perhaps I can stay here alone with
her. The webfoots might find us, or the Sand God might destroy us in
one of his fits, but it might be worth it.
"Don't go," she said. "Not yet."
"Earthman, hear me."
"I hear you."
"Why does your mind shrink backward?"
"I've decided not to bring my people here."
"
You
decided?"
"Certainly," Stinson said boldly. "Call it rationalization, if you
wish. You ordered us away; and I have several good reasons for not
coming here if the door was open."
"I've changed my mind. You will be welcomed."
"Listen to that, will you?" Stinson said angrily. "Just listen! You
set yourself up as a God for the webfoots. You get them eating out of
your hand. Then what do you do? You throw a fit. Yes, a fit! Like an
adolescent. Worse."
"Earthman, wait...."
"No!" Stinson shot back. "You've owned this planet for a million
years. You have brooded here alone since before my people discovered
fire, and in all those ages you never learned self-control. I can't
subject my people to the whims of an entity who throws a planetary fit
when it pleases him."
Stinson relaxed. He'd had his say. Sybtl trembled beside him. A small
mammal, round, furry, hopped by, sniffing inquisitively.
Sybtl said, "Is the Sand God happy?" She shook her head. "No, he is not
happy. He is old, old, old. I can feel it. My people say that when one
gets too old it is well to die. But Gods never die, do they? I would
not like to be a God."
"Stinson," the Sand God said. "You said I was adolescent. You are
correct. Do you remember I told you how my people, the entire race,
left their bodies at the same time? Do you imagine all of us were
adults?"
"I suppose not. Sounds reasonable. How old were you?"
"Chronologically, by our standards, I was nine years old."
"But you continued to develop after...."
"No."
Stinson tried to imagine it. At first there must have been a single
voice crying into a monstrous emptiness, "Mother, where are you?
MOTHER!
Where is
everyone
?" A frenzied searching of the planet,
the solar system, the galaxy. Then a returning to the planet. Empty....
Change. Buildings, roads, bridges weathering slowly. Such a race would
have built of durable metal. Durable? Centuries, eons passed. Buildings
crumbled to dust, dust blew away. Bridges eroded, fell, decomposed
into basic elements. The shape of constellations changed. All trace
of civilization passed except in the cavern of the heated pool.
Constellations disappeared, new patterns formed in the night sky. The
unutterably total void of time—FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND YEARS!
And a nine-year-old child brooding over an empty world.
"I don't understand why your development stopped," Stinson said.
"Nor do I. But perhaps ... well, I sense that I would continue, if you
brought your people here. You have already taught me the value of
life. There is a oneness, a bond that ties each living thing to every
other living thing. It is a lesson my people never knew. Select any
portion of this planet that suits you. Take the web-footed woman for
your wife. Have children. I promise never to harm you in any way."
"The webfoots?"
"You and they shall share the planet."
The Sand God disappeared. Sybtl said; "Is the Sand God angry again?"
"No, he is not angry."
"I'm glad. You will leave now?"
"No. This is my home."
She laughed softly. "You are a strange God."
"Listen," he said, "I am not a God. Get that through your head."
She drew him into the cave. Her lips were cool and sweet. The cave was
pleasantly warm.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/6/9/51699//51699-h//51699-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How old is the Sand God, mentally? | 51699_RWJ8X7FI_2 | [
"Six years",
"Fifteen years",
"Twelve years",
"Nine years"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
51,699 | 51699_RWJ8X7FI | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The God Next Door | 1966.0 | Doede, William R. | Short stories; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; PS; Science fiction | THE GOD NEXT DOOR
By BILL DOEDE
Illustrated by IVIE
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine August 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
The sand-thing was powerful, lonely and
strange. No doubt it was a god—but who wasn't?
Stinson lay still in the sand where he fell, gloating over the success
of his arrival.
He touched the pencil-line scar behind his ear where the cylinder was
buried, marveling at the power stored there, power to fling him from
earth to this fourth planet of the Centaurian system in an instant.
It had happened so fast that he could almost feel the warm, humid
Missouri air, though he was light years from Missouri.
He got up. A gray, funnel-shaped cloud of dust stood off to his left.
This became disturbing, since there was scarcely enough wind to move
his hair. He watched it, trying to recall what he might know about
cyclones. But he knew little. Weather control made cyclones and other
climatic phenomena on earth practically non-existent. The cloud
did not move, though, except to spin on its axis rapidly, emitting
a high-pitched, scarcely audible whine, like a high speed motor. He
judged it harmless.
He stood on a wide valley floor between two mountain ranges. Dark
clouds capped one peak of the mountains on his left. The sky was deep
blue.
He tested the gravity by jumping up and down. Same as Earth gravity.
The sun—no, not
the
sun. Not Sol. What should he call it, Alpha or
Centaurus? Well, perhaps neither. He was here and Earth was somewhere
up there. This was
the
sun of this particular solar system. He was
right the first time.
The sun burned fiercely, although he would have said it was about four
o'clock in the afternoon, if this had been Earth. Not a tree, nor a
bush, nor even a wisp of dry grass was in sight. Everywhere was desert.
The funnel of sand had moved closer and while he watched it, it seemed
to drift in the wind—although there was no wind. Stinson backed away.
It stopped. It was about ten feet tall by three feet in diameter at the
base. Then Stinson backed away again. It was changing. Now it became a
blue rectangle, then a red cube, a violet sphere.
He wanted to run. He wished Benjamin were here. Ben might have an
explanation. "What am I afraid of?" he said aloud, "a few grains of
sand blowing in the wind? A wind devil?"
He turned his back and walked away. When he looked up the wind devil
was there before him. He looked back. Only one. It had moved. The sun
shone obliquely, throwing Stinson's shadow upon the sand. The wind
devil also had a shadow, although the sun shone through it and the
shadow was faint. But it moved when the funnel moved. This was no
illusion.
Again Stinson felt the urge to run, or to use the cylinder to project
himself somewhere else, but he said, "No!" very firmly to himself. He
was here to investigate, to determine if this planet was capable of
supporting life.
Life? Intelligence? He examined the wind devil as closely as he dared,
but it was composed only of grains of sand. There was no core, no
central place you could point to and say, here is the brain, or the
nervous system. But then, how could a group of loosely spaced grains of
sand possibly have a nervous system?
It was again going through its paces. Triangle, cube, rectangle,
sphere. He watched, and when it became a triangle again, he smoothed
a place in the sand and drew a triangle with his forefinger. When it
changed to a cube he drew a square, a circle for a sphere, and so on.
When the symbols were repeated he pointed to each in turn, excitement
mounting. He became so absorbed in doing this that he failed to notice
how the wind devil drew closer and closer, but when he inhaled the
first grains of sand, the realization of what was happening dawned with
a flash of fear. Instantly he projected himself a thousand miles away.
Now he was in an area of profuse vegetation. It was twilight. As he
stood beside a small creek, a chill wind blew from the northwest. He
wanted to cover himself with the long leaves he found, but they were
dry and brittle, for here autumn had turned the leaves. Night would be
cold.
He was not a woodsman. He doubted if he could build a fire without
matches. So he followed the creek to where it flowed between two great
hills. Steam vapors rose from a crevice. A cave was nearby and warm air
flowed from its mouth. He went inside.
At first he thought the cave was small, but found instead that he was
in a long narrow passageway. The current of warm air flowed toward him
and he followed it, cautiously, stepping carefully and slowly. Then it
was not quite so dark. Soon he stepped out of the narrow passageway
into a great cavern with a high-vaulted ceiling.
The light source was a mystery. He left no shadow on the floor. A
great crystal sphere hung from the ceiling, and he was curious about
its purpose, but a great pool of steaming water in the center of the
cavern drew his attention. He went close, to warm himself. A stone
wall surrounding the pool was inscribed with intricate art work and
indecipherable symbols.
Life. Intelligence. The planet was inhabited.
Should he give up and return to earth? Or was there room here for
his people? Warming his hands there over the great steaming pool he
thought of Benjamin, and Straus, and Jamieson—all those to whom he had
given cylinders, and who were now struggling for life against those who
desired them.
He decided it would not be just, to give up so easily.
The wide plaza between the pool and cavern wall was smooth as polished
glass. Statues lined the wall. He examined them.
The unknown artist had been clever. From one angle they were animals,
from another birds, from a third they were vaguely humanoid creatures,
glowering at him with primitive ferocity. The fourth view was so
shocking he had to turn away quickly. No definable form or sculptured
line was visible, yet he felt, or saw—he did not know which senses
told him—the immeasurable gulf of a million years of painful
evolution. Then nothing. It was not a curtain drawn to prevent him from
seeing more.
There was no more.
He stumbled toward the pool's wall and clutched for support, but
his knees buckled. His hand slid down the wall, over the ancient
inscriptions. He sank to the floor. Before he lost consciousness he
wondered, fleetingly, if a lethal instrument was in the statue.
He woke with a ringing in his ears, feeling drugged and sluggish.
Sounds came to him. He opened his eyes.
The cavern was crowded. These creatures were not only humanoid, but
definitely human, although more slight of build than earth people. The
only difference he could see at first sight was that they had webbed
feet. All were dressed from the waist down only, in a shimmering skirt
that sparkled as they moved. They walked with the grace of ballet
dancers, moving about the plaza, conversing in a musical language with
no meaning for Stinson. The men were dark-skinned, the women somewhat
lighter, with long flowing hair, wide lips and a beauty that was
utterly sensual.
He was in chains! They were small chains, light weight, of a metal that
looked like aluminum. But all his strength could not break them.
They saw him struggling. Two of the men came over and spoke to him in
the musical language.
"My name is Stinson," he said, pointing to himself. "I'm from the
planet Earth."
They looked at each other and jabbered some more.
"Look," he said, "Earth. E-A-R-T-H, Earth." He pointed upward,
described a large circle, then another smaller, and showed how Earth
revolved around the sun.
One of the men poked him with a stick, or tube of some kind. It did not
hurt, but angered him. He left the chains by his own method of travel,
and reappeared behind the two men. They stared at the place where he
had been. The chains tinkled musically. He grasped the shoulder of the
offender, spun him around and slapped his face.
A cry of consternation rose from the group, echoing in the high
ceilinged cavern. "SBTL!" it said, "ZBTL ... XBTL ... zbtl."
The men instantly prostrated themselves before him. The one who had
poked Stinson with the stick rose, and handed it to him. Still angered,
Stinson grasped it firmly, with half a notion to break it over his
head. As he did so, a flash of blue fire sprang from it. The man
disappeared. A small cloud of dust settled slowly to the floor.
Disintegrated!
Stinson's face drained pale, and suddenly, unaccountably, he was
ashamed because he had no clothes.
"I didn't mean to kill him!" he cried. "I was angry, and...."
Useless. They could not understand. For all he knew, they might think
he was threatening them. The object he had thought of as a stick was
in reality a long metal tube, precisely machined, with a small button
near one end.
This weapon was completely out of place in a culture such as this.
Or was it? What did he know of these people? Very little. They were
humanoid. They had exhibited human emotions of anger, fear and, that
most human of all characteristics, curiosity. But up to now the tube
and the chain was the only evidence of an advanced technology, unless
the ancient inscriptions in the stone wall of the pool, and the statues
lining the wall were evidences.
There was a stirring among the crowd. An object like a pallet was
brought, carried by four of the women. They laid it at his feet, and
gestured for him to sit. He touched it cautiously, then sat.
Instantly he sprang to his feet. There, at the cavern entrance, the
wind devil writhed and undulated in a brilliant harmony of colors. It
remained in one spot, though, and he relaxed somewhat.
One of the women came toward him, long golden hair flowing, firm
breasts dipping slightly at each step. Her eyes held a language all
their own, universal. She pressed her body against him and bore him to
the pallet, her kisses fire on his face.
Incongruously, he thought of Benjamin back on earth, and all the others
with cylinders, who might be fighting for their lives at this moment.
He pushed her roughly aside.
She spoke, and he understood! Her words were still the same gibberish,
but now he knew their meaning. Somehow he knew also that the wind devil
was responsible for his understanding.
"You do not want me?" she said sadly. "Then kill me."
"Why should I kill you?"
She shrugged her beautiful shoulders. "It is the way of the Gods," she
said. "If you do not, then the others will."
He took the tube-weapon in his hands, careful not to touch the button.
"Don't be afraid. I didn't mean to kill the man. It was an accident. I
will protect you."
She shook her head. "One day they will find me alone, and they'll kill
me."
"Why?"
She shrugged. "I have not pleased you."
"On the contrary, you have. There is a time and place for everything,
though."
Suddenly a great voice sounded in the cavern, a voice with no
direction. It came from the ceiling, the floor, the walls, the steaming
pool. It was in the language of the web-footed people; it was in his
own tongue. "No harm must come to this woman. The God with fingers on
his feet has decreed this."
Those in the cavern looked at the woman with fear and respect. She
kissed Stinson's feet. Two of the men came and gave her a brilliant
new skirt. She smiled at him, and he thought he had never seen a more
beautiful face.
The great, bodiless voice sounded again, but those in the cavern went
about their activities. They did not hear.
"Who are you?"
Stinson looked at the wind devil, since it could be no one else
speaking, and pointed to himself. "Me?"
"Yes."
"I am Stinson, of the planet Earth."
"Yes, I see it in your mind, now. You want to live here, on this
planet."
"Then you must know where I came from, and how."
"I do not understand how. You have a body, a physical body composed
of atoms. It is impossible to move a physical body from one place to
another by a mere thought and a tiny instrument, yet you have done so.
You deserted me out in the desert."
"I deserted you?" Stinson cried angrily, "You tried to kill me!"
"I was attempting communication. Why should I kill you?"
He was silent a moment, looking at the people in the cavern. "Perhaps
because you feared I would become the God of these people in your
place."
Stinson felt a mental shrug. "It is of no importance. When they arrived
on this planet I attempted to explain that I was not a God, but the
primitive is not deeply buried in them. They soon resorted to emotion
rather than reason. It is of no importance."
"I'd hardly call them primitive, with such weapons."
"The tube is not of their technology. That is, they did not make
it directly. These are the undesirables, the incorrigibles, the
nonconformists from the sixth planet. I permit them here because it
occupies my time, to watch them evolve."
"You should live so long."
"Live?" the wind devil said. "Oh, I see your meaning. I'd almost
forgotten. You are a strange entity. You travel by a means even I
cannot fully understand, yet you speak of time as if some event
were about to take place. I believe you think of death. I see your
physical body has deteriorated since yesterday. Your body will cease to
exist, almost as soon as those of the sixth planet peoples. I am most
interested in you. You will bring your people, and live here."
"I haven't decided. There are these web-footed people, who were hostile
until they thought I was a God. They have destructive weapons. Also, I
don't understand you. I see you as a cone of sand which keeps changing
color and configuration. Is it your body? Where do you come from? Is
this planet populated with your kind?"
The wind devil hesitated.
"Where do I originate? It seems I have always been. You see this
cavern, the heated pool, the statues, the inscriptions. Half a million
years ago my people were as you. That is, they lived in physical
bodies. Our technology surpassed any you have seen. The tube these
webfoots use is a toy by comparison. Our scientists found the ultimate
nature of physical law. They learned to separate the mind from the
body. Then my people set a date. Our entire race was determined to free
itself from the confines of the body. The date came."
"What happened?"
"I do not know. I alone exist. I have searched all the levels of time
and matter from the very beginning. My people are gone. Sometimes it
almost comes to me, why they are gone. And this is contrary to the
greatest law of all—that an entity, once in existence, can never cease
to exist."
Stinson was silent, thinking of the endless years of searching through
the great gulf of time. His eyes caught sight of the woman, reclining
now on the pallet. The men had left her and stood in groups, talking,
glancing at him, apparently free of their awe and fear already.
The woman looked at him, and she was not smiling. "Please ask the Sand
God," she said, "to speak to my people again. Their fear of him does
not last. When He is gone they will probably kill us."
"As for the webfoots," the wind devil, or Sand God, said, "I will
destroy them. You and your people will have the entire planet."
"Destroy them?" Stinson asked, incredulously, "all these people? They
have a right to live like any one else."
"Right? What is it—'right?' They are entities. They exist, therefore
they always will. My people are the only entities who ever died. To
kill the body is unimportant."
"No. You misunderstand. Listen, you spoke of the greatest law. Your law
is a scientific hypothesis. It has to do with what comes after physical
existence, not with existence itself. The greatest law is this, that an
entity, once existing, must not be harmed in any way. To do so changes
the most basic structure of nature."
The Sand God did not reply. The great bodiless, directionless voice was
silent, and Stinson felt as if he had been taken from some high place
and set down in a dark canyon. The cone of sand was the color of wood
ashes. It pulsed erratically, like a great heart missing a beat now and
then. The web-footed people milled about restlessly. The woman's eyes
pleaded.
When he looked back, the Sand God was gone.
Instantly a new note rose in the cavern. The murmur of unmistakable mob
fury ran over the webfoots. Several of the men approached the woman
with hatred in their voices. He could not understand the words now.
But he understood her. "They'll kill me!" she cried.
Stinson pointed the disintegrating weapon at them and yelled. They
dropped back. "We'll have to get outside," he told her. "This mob will
soon get out of hand. Then the tube won't stop them. They will rush in.
I can't kill them all at once, even if I wanted to. And I don't."
Together they edged toward the cavern entrance, ran quickly up the
inclined passageway, and came out into crisp, cold air. The morning sun
was reflected from a million tiny mirrors on the rocks, the trees and
grass. A silver thaw during the night had covered the whole area with
a coating of ice. Stinson shivered. The woman handed him a skirt she
had thoughtfully brought along from the cavern. He took it, and they
ran down the slippery path leading away from the entrance. From the
hiding place behind a large rock they watched, as several web-footed
men emerged into the sunlight. They blinked, covered their eyes, and
jabbered musically among themselves. One slipped and fell on the ice.
They re-entered the cave.
Stinson donned the shimmering skirt, smiling as he did so. The others
should see him now. Benjamin and Straus and Jamieson. They would
laugh. And Ben's wife, Lisa, she would give her little-girl laugh, and
probably help him fasten the skirt. It had a string, like a tobacco
pouch, which was tied around the waist. It helped keep him warm.
He turned to the woman. "I don't know what I'll do with you, but now
that we're in trouble together, we may as well introduce ourselves. My
name is Stinson."
"I am Sybtl," she said.
"Syb-tl." He tried to imitate her musical pronunciation. "A very nice
name."
She smiled, then pointed to the cavern. "When the ice is gone, they
will come out and follow us."
"We'd better make tracks."
"No," she said, "we must run, and make no tracks."
"Okay, Sis," he said.
"Sis?"
"That means, sister."
"I am not your sister. I am your wife."
"
What?
"
"Yes. When a man protects a woman from harm, it is a sign to all that
she is his chosen. Otherwise, why not let her die? You are a strange
God."
"Listen, Sybtl," he said desperately, "I am not a God and you are not
my wife. Let's get that straight."
"But...."
"No buts. Right now we'd better get out of here."
He took her hand and they ran, slid, fell, picked themselves up again,
and ran. He doubted the wisdom of keeping her with him. Alone, the
webfoots were no match for him. He could travel instantly to any spot
he chose. But with Sybtl it was another matter; he was no better than
any other man, perhaps not so good as some because he was forty, and
never had been an athlete.
How was he to decide if this planet was suitable for his people,
hampered by a woman, slinking through a frozen wilderness like an
Indian? But the woman's hand was soft. He felt strong knowing she
depended on him.
Anyway, he decided, pursuit was impossible. They left no tracks on the
ice. They were safe, unless the webfoots possessed talents unknown to
him.
So they followed the path leading down from the rocks, along the creek
with its tumbling water. Frozen, leafless willows clawed at their
bodies. The sun shone fiercely in a cloudless sky. Already water ran in
tiny rivulets over the ice. The woman steered him to the right, away
from the creek.
Stinson's bare feet were numb from walking on ice. Christ, he thought,
what am I doing here, anyway? He glanced down at Sybtl and remembered
the webfoots. He stopped, tempted to use his cylinder and move to a
warmer, less dangerous spot.
The woman pulled on his arm. "We must hurry!"
He clutched the tube-weapon. "How many shots in this thing?"
"Shots?"
"How often can I use it?"
"As often as you like. It is good for fifty years. Kaatr—he is the one
you destroyed—brought it from the ship when we came. Many times he has
used it unwisely."
"When did you come?"
"Ten years ago. I was a child."
"I thought only criminals were brought here."
She nodded. "Criminals, and their children."
"When will your people come again?"
She shook her head. "Never. They are no longer my people. They have
disowned us."
"And because of me even those in the cavern have disowned you."
Suddenly she stiffened beside him. There, directly in their path, stood
the Sand God. It was blood red now. It pulsed violently. The great
voice burst forth.
"Leave the woman!" it demanded angrily. "The webfoots are nearing your
position."
"I cannot leave her. She is helpless against them."
"What form of primitive stupidity are you practicing now? Leave, or
they will kill you."
Stinson shook his head.
The Sand God pulsed more violently than before. Ice melted in a wide
area around it. Brown, frozen grass burned to ashes.
"You will allow them to kill you, just to defend her life? What
business is it of yours if she lives or dies? My race discarded such
primitive logic long before it reached your level of development."
"Yes," Stinson said, "and your race no longer exists."
The Sand God became a sphere of blue flame. A wave of intense heat
drove them backward. "Earthman," the great voice said, "go back to your
Earth. Take your inconsistencies with you. Do not come here again to
infect my planet with your primitive ideas. The webfoots are not as
intelligent as you, but they are sane. If you bring your people here, I
shall destroy you all."
The sphere of blue fire screamed away across the frozen wilderness, and
the thunder of its passing shook the ground and echoed among the lonely
hills.
Sybtl shivered against his arm. "The Sand God is angry," she said. "My
people tell how he was angry once before, when we first came here. He
killed half of us and burned the ship that brought us. That is how
Kaatr got the tube-weapon. It was the only thing the Sand God didn't
burn, that and the skirts. Then, when he had burned the ship, the Sand
God went to the sixth planet and burned two of the largest cities, as a
warning that no more of us must come here."
Well, Stinson said to himself, that does it. We are better off on
Earth. We can't fight a monster like him.
Sybtl touched his arm. "Why did the Sand God come? He did not speak."
"He spoke to me."
"I did not hear."
"Yes, I know now. His voice sounds like thunder in the sky, but it is a
voice that speaks only in the mind. He said I must leave this planet."
She glanced at him with suddenly awakened eyes, as if thinking of it
for the first time. "Where is your ship?"
"I have no ship."
"Then he will kill you." She touched her fingers on his face. "I am
sorry. It was all for me."
"Don't worry. The Sand God travels without a ship, why shouldn't I?"
"Now?"
"As soon as you are safe. Come."
Steam rose from the burned area, charred like a rocket launching pit.
They stepped around it carefully. Stinson felt warm air, but there was
no time, now, to warm cold feet or dwell on the vagaries of Sand Gods.
Together they crossed the narrow valley. Sybtl led him toward a tall
mound of rock. Here they came to the creek again, which flowed into a
small canyon. They climbed the canyon wall. Far away, small figures
moved. The webfoots were on their trail.
She drew him into a small cave. It was heated, like the great cavern,
but held no walled pool nor mysterious lighting. But it was warm, and
the small entrance made an excellent vantage point for warding off
attack.
"They will not find us...."
A high-pitched keening burst suddenly around them. Stinson knew they
had heard, or felt the sound for some time, that now its frequency was
in an audible range.
"The Sand God," Sybtl said. "Sometimes he plays among the clouds. He
makes it rain in a dry summer, or sometimes warms the whole world
for days at a time in winter, so the snow melts and the grass begins
to green. Then he tires and lets winter come back again. He is the
loneliest God in the universe."
"What makes you think he's lonely?"
She shrugged her shoulders. "I just know. But he's an angry God now.
See those clouds piling in the East? Soon they will hide the sun. Then
he will make them churn and boil, like river whirlpools in spring. At
least he does this when he plays. Who knows what he will do when he's
angry?"
"The Sand God isn't doing this," Stinson said. "It's only a storm."
She covered his lips with her fingers. "Don't say that. He may hear you
and be more angry."
"But it is, don't you see? You give him powers he does not possess."
Sybtl shook her head and stroked his face with her long, slim fingers.
"Poor little God-with-fingers-on-his-feet," she said. "You do not
understand. The Sand God is terrible, even when he plays. See the
lightning? It is blue. The lightning of a storm that comes by itself is
not blue. He is running around the world on feet like the rockets of
space ships, and when he strikes the clouds, blue fire shoots away."
The clouds continued to build on one another. Soon the blue flashes of
lightning extended across the sky from horizon to horizon. The earth
trembled. Sybtl moved closer, trembling also.
"He never did this before," she said. "He never made the earth shake
before."
Great boulders crashed down the canyon walls and dropped into the
creek. They dared not move from the cave, although death seemed certain
if they stayed.
"I'll leave for a moment," he said. "I'll be back soon."
"You're leaving?" There was panic in her voice.
"Only for a moment."
"And you won't come back. You will go to your world."
"No. I'll be back."
"Promise? No, don't promise. The promises of Gods often are forgotten
before the sounds die away."
"I'll be back."
He disappeared at once, giving her no chance to object again, and went
to the desert of sand, where he had first arrived on the planet. He
wanted to see if the storm were world-wide.
Stinson had never been in a sand storm before, even on Earth. He could
not breathe. He could not see. Bullets of sand stung his skin. Bullets
of sand shot into his eyes. Clouds of sand howled around him. He fell,
and the wind rolled him over and over in the sand like a tumbleweed.
The skirt flew up around his face. He could not get up again.
He returned to the cave.
Soon after, while they sat huddled together, watching the chaos of
tumbling rocks, lightning, and driving rain, the high-pitched keening
came again. A sphere of blue fire appeared in the east. Its brilliance
put the lightning to shame. It bore down on the cave swiftly,
purposefully. Stinson prepared himself to leave. In spite of his desire
to protect Sybtl, it was useless to get himself killed when he was
powerless to help her. But at the last moment it veered off.
"Fiend!" Stinson screamed the word, vaguely marvelling at his own fury.
The blue sphere turned and came back.
"Monster!"
Again.
"Murderer!"
"Adolescent!"
This time it kept going. The rain and wind ceased. Lightning stopped.
Thunder rumbled distantly. Clouds disappeared. Stinson and Sybtl
emerged from the cave.
There was no longer a question of attack from the webfoots, the storm
had taken care of that. The fierce sun began its work of drying rocks
and throwing shadows and coaxing life out into the open again. Down in
the canyon a bird sang, a lonely, cheerful twitter.
"The Sand God is tired," Sybtl said. "He is not angry now. I'm glad.
Perhaps he will let you stay."
"No. Even if he allowed it, I couldn't stay. My people could never live
here with a God who is half devil."
The cone of sand suddenly appeared. It stood in the canyon, its base
on a level with the cave. It was quiet. It was dull gray in color. It
exuded impressions of death, of hopeful words solemnly spoken over
lowered coffins, of cold earth and cold space, of dank, wet catacombs,
of creeping, crawling nether things.
The bird's twitter stopped abruptly.
"Earthman," the Sand God said, as if he were about to make a statement.
Stinson ignored him. He glanced down at Sybtl, who sensed that this was
a time for good-bys. He thought, perhaps I can stay here alone with
her. The webfoots might find us, or the Sand God might destroy us in
one of his fits, but it might be worth it.
"Don't go," she said. "Not yet."
"Earthman, hear me."
"I hear you."
"Why does your mind shrink backward?"
"I've decided not to bring my people here."
"
You
decided?"
"Certainly," Stinson said boldly. "Call it rationalization, if you
wish. You ordered us away; and I have several good reasons for not
coming here if the door was open."
"I've changed my mind. You will be welcomed."
"Listen to that, will you?" Stinson said angrily. "Just listen! You
set yourself up as a God for the webfoots. You get them eating out of
your hand. Then what do you do? You throw a fit. Yes, a fit! Like an
adolescent. Worse."
"Earthman, wait...."
"No!" Stinson shot back. "You've owned this planet for a million
years. You have brooded here alone since before my people discovered
fire, and in all those ages you never learned self-control. I can't
subject my people to the whims of an entity who throws a planetary fit
when it pleases him."
Stinson relaxed. He'd had his say. Sybtl trembled beside him. A small
mammal, round, furry, hopped by, sniffing inquisitively.
Sybtl said, "Is the Sand God happy?" She shook her head. "No, he is not
happy. He is old, old, old. I can feel it. My people say that when one
gets too old it is well to die. But Gods never die, do they? I would
not like to be a God."
"Stinson," the Sand God said. "You said I was adolescent. You are
correct. Do you remember I told you how my people, the entire race,
left their bodies at the same time? Do you imagine all of us were
adults?"
"I suppose not. Sounds reasonable. How old were you?"
"Chronologically, by our standards, I was nine years old."
"But you continued to develop after...."
"No."
Stinson tried to imagine it. At first there must have been a single
voice crying into a monstrous emptiness, "Mother, where are you?
MOTHER!
Where is
everyone
?" A frenzied searching of the planet,
the solar system, the galaxy. Then a returning to the planet. Empty....
Change. Buildings, roads, bridges weathering slowly. Such a race would
have built of durable metal. Durable? Centuries, eons passed. Buildings
crumbled to dust, dust blew away. Bridges eroded, fell, decomposed
into basic elements. The shape of constellations changed. All trace
of civilization passed except in the cavern of the heated pool.
Constellations disappeared, new patterns formed in the night sky. The
unutterably total void of time—FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND YEARS!
And a nine-year-old child brooding over an empty world.
"I don't understand why your development stopped," Stinson said.
"Nor do I. But perhaps ... well, I sense that I would continue, if you
brought your people here. You have already taught me the value of
life. There is a oneness, a bond that ties each living thing to every
other living thing. It is a lesson my people never knew. Select any
portion of this planet that suits you. Take the web-footed woman for
your wife. Have children. I promise never to harm you in any way."
"The webfoots?"
"You and they shall share the planet."
The Sand God disappeared. Sybtl said; "Is the Sand God angry again?"
"No, he is not angry."
"I'm glad. You will leave now?"
"No. This is my home."
She laughed softly. "You are a strange God."
"Listen," he said, "I am not a God. Get that through your head."
She drew him into the cave. Her lips were cool and sweet. The cave was
pleasantly warm.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/6/9/51699//51699-h//51699-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What happened to the Sand God's race? | 51699_RWJ8X7FI_3 | [
"The Sand God's race moved to the sixth planet and left him behind.",
"The Sand God burned them all.",
"The webfoots killed the Sand God's race. He left his body to escape death.",
"The Sand God's race learned how to separate the mind from the body. They set a date to leave their bodies together. The Sand God found himself alone after the experience."
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
51,699 | 51699_RWJ8X7FI | 23 | 1,018 | Gutenberg | The God Next Door | 1966.0 | Doede, William R. | Short stories; Interstellar travel -- Fiction; PS; Science fiction | THE GOD NEXT DOOR
By BILL DOEDE
Illustrated by IVIE
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine August 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
The sand-thing was powerful, lonely and
strange. No doubt it was a god—but who wasn't?
Stinson lay still in the sand where he fell, gloating over the success
of his arrival.
He touched the pencil-line scar behind his ear where the cylinder was
buried, marveling at the power stored there, power to fling him from
earth to this fourth planet of the Centaurian system in an instant.
It had happened so fast that he could almost feel the warm, humid
Missouri air, though he was light years from Missouri.
He got up. A gray, funnel-shaped cloud of dust stood off to his left.
This became disturbing, since there was scarcely enough wind to move
his hair. He watched it, trying to recall what he might know about
cyclones. But he knew little. Weather control made cyclones and other
climatic phenomena on earth practically non-existent. The cloud
did not move, though, except to spin on its axis rapidly, emitting
a high-pitched, scarcely audible whine, like a high speed motor. He
judged it harmless.
He stood on a wide valley floor between two mountain ranges. Dark
clouds capped one peak of the mountains on his left. The sky was deep
blue.
He tested the gravity by jumping up and down. Same as Earth gravity.
The sun—no, not
the
sun. Not Sol. What should he call it, Alpha or
Centaurus? Well, perhaps neither. He was here and Earth was somewhere
up there. This was
the
sun of this particular solar system. He was
right the first time.
The sun burned fiercely, although he would have said it was about four
o'clock in the afternoon, if this had been Earth. Not a tree, nor a
bush, nor even a wisp of dry grass was in sight. Everywhere was desert.
The funnel of sand had moved closer and while he watched it, it seemed
to drift in the wind—although there was no wind. Stinson backed away.
It stopped. It was about ten feet tall by three feet in diameter at the
base. Then Stinson backed away again. It was changing. Now it became a
blue rectangle, then a red cube, a violet sphere.
He wanted to run. He wished Benjamin were here. Ben might have an
explanation. "What am I afraid of?" he said aloud, "a few grains of
sand blowing in the wind? A wind devil?"
He turned his back and walked away. When he looked up the wind devil
was there before him. He looked back. Only one. It had moved. The sun
shone obliquely, throwing Stinson's shadow upon the sand. The wind
devil also had a shadow, although the sun shone through it and the
shadow was faint. But it moved when the funnel moved. This was no
illusion.
Again Stinson felt the urge to run, or to use the cylinder to project
himself somewhere else, but he said, "No!" very firmly to himself. He
was here to investigate, to determine if this planet was capable of
supporting life.
Life? Intelligence? He examined the wind devil as closely as he dared,
but it was composed only of grains of sand. There was no core, no
central place you could point to and say, here is the brain, or the
nervous system. But then, how could a group of loosely spaced grains of
sand possibly have a nervous system?
It was again going through its paces. Triangle, cube, rectangle,
sphere. He watched, and when it became a triangle again, he smoothed
a place in the sand and drew a triangle with his forefinger. When it
changed to a cube he drew a square, a circle for a sphere, and so on.
When the symbols were repeated he pointed to each in turn, excitement
mounting. He became so absorbed in doing this that he failed to notice
how the wind devil drew closer and closer, but when he inhaled the
first grains of sand, the realization of what was happening dawned with
a flash of fear. Instantly he projected himself a thousand miles away.
Now he was in an area of profuse vegetation. It was twilight. As he
stood beside a small creek, a chill wind blew from the northwest. He
wanted to cover himself with the long leaves he found, but they were
dry and brittle, for here autumn had turned the leaves. Night would be
cold.
He was not a woodsman. He doubted if he could build a fire without
matches. So he followed the creek to where it flowed between two great
hills. Steam vapors rose from a crevice. A cave was nearby and warm air
flowed from its mouth. He went inside.
At first he thought the cave was small, but found instead that he was
in a long narrow passageway. The current of warm air flowed toward him
and he followed it, cautiously, stepping carefully and slowly. Then it
was not quite so dark. Soon he stepped out of the narrow passageway
into a great cavern with a high-vaulted ceiling.
The light source was a mystery. He left no shadow on the floor. A
great crystal sphere hung from the ceiling, and he was curious about
its purpose, but a great pool of steaming water in the center of the
cavern drew his attention. He went close, to warm himself. A stone
wall surrounding the pool was inscribed with intricate art work and
indecipherable symbols.
Life. Intelligence. The planet was inhabited.
Should he give up and return to earth? Or was there room here for
his people? Warming his hands there over the great steaming pool he
thought of Benjamin, and Straus, and Jamieson—all those to whom he had
given cylinders, and who were now struggling for life against those who
desired them.
He decided it would not be just, to give up so easily.
The wide plaza between the pool and cavern wall was smooth as polished
glass. Statues lined the wall. He examined them.
The unknown artist had been clever. From one angle they were animals,
from another birds, from a third they were vaguely humanoid creatures,
glowering at him with primitive ferocity. The fourth view was so
shocking he had to turn away quickly. No definable form or sculptured
line was visible, yet he felt, or saw—he did not know which senses
told him—the immeasurable gulf of a million years of painful
evolution. Then nothing. It was not a curtain drawn to prevent him from
seeing more.
There was no more.
He stumbled toward the pool's wall and clutched for support, but
his knees buckled. His hand slid down the wall, over the ancient
inscriptions. He sank to the floor. Before he lost consciousness he
wondered, fleetingly, if a lethal instrument was in the statue.
He woke with a ringing in his ears, feeling drugged and sluggish.
Sounds came to him. He opened his eyes.
The cavern was crowded. These creatures were not only humanoid, but
definitely human, although more slight of build than earth people. The
only difference he could see at first sight was that they had webbed
feet. All were dressed from the waist down only, in a shimmering skirt
that sparkled as they moved. They walked with the grace of ballet
dancers, moving about the plaza, conversing in a musical language with
no meaning for Stinson. The men were dark-skinned, the women somewhat
lighter, with long flowing hair, wide lips and a beauty that was
utterly sensual.
He was in chains! They were small chains, light weight, of a metal that
looked like aluminum. But all his strength could not break them.
They saw him struggling. Two of the men came over and spoke to him in
the musical language.
"My name is Stinson," he said, pointing to himself. "I'm from the
planet Earth."
They looked at each other and jabbered some more.
"Look," he said, "Earth. E-A-R-T-H, Earth." He pointed upward,
described a large circle, then another smaller, and showed how Earth
revolved around the sun.
One of the men poked him with a stick, or tube of some kind. It did not
hurt, but angered him. He left the chains by his own method of travel,
and reappeared behind the two men. They stared at the place where he
had been. The chains tinkled musically. He grasped the shoulder of the
offender, spun him around and slapped his face.
A cry of consternation rose from the group, echoing in the high
ceilinged cavern. "SBTL!" it said, "ZBTL ... XBTL ... zbtl."
The men instantly prostrated themselves before him. The one who had
poked Stinson with the stick rose, and handed it to him. Still angered,
Stinson grasped it firmly, with half a notion to break it over his
head. As he did so, a flash of blue fire sprang from it. The man
disappeared. A small cloud of dust settled slowly to the floor.
Disintegrated!
Stinson's face drained pale, and suddenly, unaccountably, he was
ashamed because he had no clothes.
"I didn't mean to kill him!" he cried. "I was angry, and...."
Useless. They could not understand. For all he knew, they might think
he was threatening them. The object he had thought of as a stick was
in reality a long metal tube, precisely machined, with a small button
near one end.
This weapon was completely out of place in a culture such as this.
Or was it? What did he know of these people? Very little. They were
humanoid. They had exhibited human emotions of anger, fear and, that
most human of all characteristics, curiosity. But up to now the tube
and the chain was the only evidence of an advanced technology, unless
the ancient inscriptions in the stone wall of the pool, and the statues
lining the wall were evidences.
There was a stirring among the crowd. An object like a pallet was
brought, carried by four of the women. They laid it at his feet, and
gestured for him to sit. He touched it cautiously, then sat.
Instantly he sprang to his feet. There, at the cavern entrance, the
wind devil writhed and undulated in a brilliant harmony of colors. It
remained in one spot, though, and he relaxed somewhat.
One of the women came toward him, long golden hair flowing, firm
breasts dipping slightly at each step. Her eyes held a language all
their own, universal. She pressed her body against him and bore him to
the pallet, her kisses fire on his face.
Incongruously, he thought of Benjamin back on earth, and all the others
with cylinders, who might be fighting for their lives at this moment.
He pushed her roughly aside.
She spoke, and he understood! Her words were still the same gibberish,
but now he knew their meaning. Somehow he knew also that the wind devil
was responsible for his understanding.
"You do not want me?" she said sadly. "Then kill me."
"Why should I kill you?"
She shrugged her beautiful shoulders. "It is the way of the Gods," she
said. "If you do not, then the others will."
He took the tube-weapon in his hands, careful not to touch the button.
"Don't be afraid. I didn't mean to kill the man. It was an accident. I
will protect you."
She shook her head. "One day they will find me alone, and they'll kill
me."
"Why?"
She shrugged. "I have not pleased you."
"On the contrary, you have. There is a time and place for everything,
though."
Suddenly a great voice sounded in the cavern, a voice with no
direction. It came from the ceiling, the floor, the walls, the steaming
pool. It was in the language of the web-footed people; it was in his
own tongue. "No harm must come to this woman. The God with fingers on
his feet has decreed this."
Those in the cavern looked at the woman with fear and respect. She
kissed Stinson's feet. Two of the men came and gave her a brilliant
new skirt. She smiled at him, and he thought he had never seen a more
beautiful face.
The great, bodiless voice sounded again, but those in the cavern went
about their activities. They did not hear.
"Who are you?"
Stinson looked at the wind devil, since it could be no one else
speaking, and pointed to himself. "Me?"
"Yes."
"I am Stinson, of the planet Earth."
"Yes, I see it in your mind, now. You want to live here, on this
planet."
"Then you must know where I came from, and how."
"I do not understand how. You have a body, a physical body composed
of atoms. It is impossible to move a physical body from one place to
another by a mere thought and a tiny instrument, yet you have done so.
You deserted me out in the desert."
"I deserted you?" Stinson cried angrily, "You tried to kill me!"
"I was attempting communication. Why should I kill you?"
He was silent a moment, looking at the people in the cavern. "Perhaps
because you feared I would become the God of these people in your
place."
Stinson felt a mental shrug. "It is of no importance. When they arrived
on this planet I attempted to explain that I was not a God, but the
primitive is not deeply buried in them. They soon resorted to emotion
rather than reason. It is of no importance."
"I'd hardly call them primitive, with such weapons."
"The tube is not of their technology. That is, they did not make
it directly. These are the undesirables, the incorrigibles, the
nonconformists from the sixth planet. I permit them here because it
occupies my time, to watch them evolve."
"You should live so long."
"Live?" the wind devil said. "Oh, I see your meaning. I'd almost
forgotten. You are a strange entity. You travel by a means even I
cannot fully understand, yet you speak of time as if some event
were about to take place. I believe you think of death. I see your
physical body has deteriorated since yesterday. Your body will cease to
exist, almost as soon as those of the sixth planet peoples. I am most
interested in you. You will bring your people, and live here."
"I haven't decided. There are these web-footed people, who were hostile
until they thought I was a God. They have destructive weapons. Also, I
don't understand you. I see you as a cone of sand which keeps changing
color and configuration. Is it your body? Where do you come from? Is
this planet populated with your kind?"
The wind devil hesitated.
"Where do I originate? It seems I have always been. You see this
cavern, the heated pool, the statues, the inscriptions. Half a million
years ago my people were as you. That is, they lived in physical
bodies. Our technology surpassed any you have seen. The tube these
webfoots use is a toy by comparison. Our scientists found the ultimate
nature of physical law. They learned to separate the mind from the
body. Then my people set a date. Our entire race was determined to free
itself from the confines of the body. The date came."
"What happened?"
"I do not know. I alone exist. I have searched all the levels of time
and matter from the very beginning. My people are gone. Sometimes it
almost comes to me, why they are gone. And this is contrary to the
greatest law of all—that an entity, once in existence, can never cease
to exist."
Stinson was silent, thinking of the endless years of searching through
the great gulf of time. His eyes caught sight of the woman, reclining
now on the pallet. The men had left her and stood in groups, talking,
glancing at him, apparently free of their awe and fear already.
The woman looked at him, and she was not smiling. "Please ask the Sand
God," she said, "to speak to my people again. Their fear of him does
not last. When He is gone they will probably kill us."
"As for the webfoots," the wind devil, or Sand God, said, "I will
destroy them. You and your people will have the entire planet."
"Destroy them?" Stinson asked, incredulously, "all these people? They
have a right to live like any one else."
"Right? What is it—'right?' They are entities. They exist, therefore
they always will. My people are the only entities who ever died. To
kill the body is unimportant."
"No. You misunderstand. Listen, you spoke of the greatest law. Your law
is a scientific hypothesis. It has to do with what comes after physical
existence, not with existence itself. The greatest law is this, that an
entity, once existing, must not be harmed in any way. To do so changes
the most basic structure of nature."
The Sand God did not reply. The great bodiless, directionless voice was
silent, and Stinson felt as if he had been taken from some high place
and set down in a dark canyon. The cone of sand was the color of wood
ashes. It pulsed erratically, like a great heart missing a beat now and
then. The web-footed people milled about restlessly. The woman's eyes
pleaded.
When he looked back, the Sand God was gone.
Instantly a new note rose in the cavern. The murmur of unmistakable mob
fury ran over the webfoots. Several of the men approached the woman
with hatred in their voices. He could not understand the words now.
But he understood her. "They'll kill me!" she cried.
Stinson pointed the disintegrating weapon at them and yelled. They
dropped back. "We'll have to get outside," he told her. "This mob will
soon get out of hand. Then the tube won't stop them. They will rush in.
I can't kill them all at once, even if I wanted to. And I don't."
Together they edged toward the cavern entrance, ran quickly up the
inclined passageway, and came out into crisp, cold air. The morning sun
was reflected from a million tiny mirrors on the rocks, the trees and
grass. A silver thaw during the night had covered the whole area with
a coating of ice. Stinson shivered. The woman handed him a skirt she
had thoughtfully brought along from the cavern. He took it, and they
ran down the slippery path leading away from the entrance. From the
hiding place behind a large rock they watched, as several web-footed
men emerged into the sunlight. They blinked, covered their eyes, and
jabbered musically among themselves. One slipped and fell on the ice.
They re-entered the cave.
Stinson donned the shimmering skirt, smiling as he did so. The others
should see him now. Benjamin and Straus and Jamieson. They would
laugh. And Ben's wife, Lisa, she would give her little-girl laugh, and
probably help him fasten the skirt. It had a string, like a tobacco
pouch, which was tied around the waist. It helped keep him warm.
He turned to the woman. "I don't know what I'll do with you, but now
that we're in trouble together, we may as well introduce ourselves. My
name is Stinson."
"I am Sybtl," she said.
"Syb-tl." He tried to imitate her musical pronunciation. "A very nice
name."
She smiled, then pointed to the cavern. "When the ice is gone, they
will come out and follow us."
"We'd better make tracks."
"No," she said, "we must run, and make no tracks."
"Okay, Sis," he said.
"Sis?"
"That means, sister."
"I am not your sister. I am your wife."
"
What?
"
"Yes. When a man protects a woman from harm, it is a sign to all that
she is his chosen. Otherwise, why not let her die? You are a strange
God."
"Listen, Sybtl," he said desperately, "I am not a God and you are not
my wife. Let's get that straight."
"But...."
"No buts. Right now we'd better get out of here."
He took her hand and they ran, slid, fell, picked themselves up again,
and ran. He doubted the wisdom of keeping her with him. Alone, the
webfoots were no match for him. He could travel instantly to any spot
he chose. But with Sybtl it was another matter; he was no better than
any other man, perhaps not so good as some because he was forty, and
never had been an athlete.
How was he to decide if this planet was suitable for his people,
hampered by a woman, slinking through a frozen wilderness like an
Indian? But the woman's hand was soft. He felt strong knowing she
depended on him.
Anyway, he decided, pursuit was impossible. They left no tracks on the
ice. They were safe, unless the webfoots possessed talents unknown to
him.
So they followed the path leading down from the rocks, along the creek
with its tumbling water. Frozen, leafless willows clawed at their
bodies. The sun shone fiercely in a cloudless sky. Already water ran in
tiny rivulets over the ice. The woman steered him to the right, away
from the creek.
Stinson's bare feet were numb from walking on ice. Christ, he thought,
what am I doing here, anyway? He glanced down at Sybtl and remembered
the webfoots. He stopped, tempted to use his cylinder and move to a
warmer, less dangerous spot.
The woman pulled on his arm. "We must hurry!"
He clutched the tube-weapon. "How many shots in this thing?"
"Shots?"
"How often can I use it?"
"As often as you like. It is good for fifty years. Kaatr—he is the one
you destroyed—brought it from the ship when we came. Many times he has
used it unwisely."
"When did you come?"
"Ten years ago. I was a child."
"I thought only criminals were brought here."
She nodded. "Criminals, and their children."
"When will your people come again?"
She shook her head. "Never. They are no longer my people. They have
disowned us."
"And because of me even those in the cavern have disowned you."
Suddenly she stiffened beside him. There, directly in their path, stood
the Sand God. It was blood red now. It pulsed violently. The great
voice burst forth.
"Leave the woman!" it demanded angrily. "The webfoots are nearing your
position."
"I cannot leave her. She is helpless against them."
"What form of primitive stupidity are you practicing now? Leave, or
they will kill you."
Stinson shook his head.
The Sand God pulsed more violently than before. Ice melted in a wide
area around it. Brown, frozen grass burned to ashes.
"You will allow them to kill you, just to defend her life? What
business is it of yours if she lives or dies? My race discarded such
primitive logic long before it reached your level of development."
"Yes," Stinson said, "and your race no longer exists."
The Sand God became a sphere of blue flame. A wave of intense heat
drove them backward. "Earthman," the great voice said, "go back to your
Earth. Take your inconsistencies with you. Do not come here again to
infect my planet with your primitive ideas. The webfoots are not as
intelligent as you, but they are sane. If you bring your people here, I
shall destroy you all."
The sphere of blue fire screamed away across the frozen wilderness, and
the thunder of its passing shook the ground and echoed among the lonely
hills.
Sybtl shivered against his arm. "The Sand God is angry," she said. "My
people tell how he was angry once before, when we first came here. He
killed half of us and burned the ship that brought us. That is how
Kaatr got the tube-weapon. It was the only thing the Sand God didn't
burn, that and the skirts. Then, when he had burned the ship, the Sand
God went to the sixth planet and burned two of the largest cities, as a
warning that no more of us must come here."
Well, Stinson said to himself, that does it. We are better off on
Earth. We can't fight a monster like him.
Sybtl touched his arm. "Why did the Sand God come? He did not speak."
"He spoke to me."
"I did not hear."
"Yes, I know now. His voice sounds like thunder in the sky, but it is a
voice that speaks only in the mind. He said I must leave this planet."
She glanced at him with suddenly awakened eyes, as if thinking of it
for the first time. "Where is your ship?"
"I have no ship."
"Then he will kill you." She touched her fingers on his face. "I am
sorry. It was all for me."
"Don't worry. The Sand God travels without a ship, why shouldn't I?"
"Now?"
"As soon as you are safe. Come."
Steam rose from the burned area, charred like a rocket launching pit.
They stepped around it carefully. Stinson felt warm air, but there was
no time, now, to warm cold feet or dwell on the vagaries of Sand Gods.
Together they crossed the narrow valley. Sybtl led him toward a tall
mound of rock. Here they came to the creek again, which flowed into a
small canyon. They climbed the canyon wall. Far away, small figures
moved. The webfoots were on their trail.
She drew him into a small cave. It was heated, like the great cavern,
but held no walled pool nor mysterious lighting. But it was warm, and
the small entrance made an excellent vantage point for warding off
attack.
"They will not find us...."
A high-pitched keening burst suddenly around them. Stinson knew they
had heard, or felt the sound for some time, that now its frequency was
in an audible range.
"The Sand God," Sybtl said. "Sometimes he plays among the clouds. He
makes it rain in a dry summer, or sometimes warms the whole world
for days at a time in winter, so the snow melts and the grass begins
to green. Then he tires and lets winter come back again. He is the
loneliest God in the universe."
"What makes you think he's lonely?"
She shrugged her shoulders. "I just know. But he's an angry God now.
See those clouds piling in the East? Soon they will hide the sun. Then
he will make them churn and boil, like river whirlpools in spring. At
least he does this when he plays. Who knows what he will do when he's
angry?"
"The Sand God isn't doing this," Stinson said. "It's only a storm."
She covered his lips with her fingers. "Don't say that. He may hear you
and be more angry."
"But it is, don't you see? You give him powers he does not possess."
Sybtl shook her head and stroked his face with her long, slim fingers.
"Poor little God-with-fingers-on-his-feet," she said. "You do not
understand. The Sand God is terrible, even when he plays. See the
lightning? It is blue. The lightning of a storm that comes by itself is
not blue. He is running around the world on feet like the rockets of
space ships, and when he strikes the clouds, blue fire shoots away."
The clouds continued to build on one another. Soon the blue flashes of
lightning extended across the sky from horizon to horizon. The earth
trembled. Sybtl moved closer, trembling also.
"He never did this before," she said. "He never made the earth shake
before."
Great boulders crashed down the canyon walls and dropped into the
creek. They dared not move from the cave, although death seemed certain
if they stayed.
"I'll leave for a moment," he said. "I'll be back soon."
"You're leaving?" There was panic in her voice.
"Only for a moment."
"And you won't come back. You will go to your world."
"No. I'll be back."
"Promise? No, don't promise. The promises of Gods often are forgotten
before the sounds die away."
"I'll be back."
He disappeared at once, giving her no chance to object again, and went
to the desert of sand, where he had first arrived on the planet. He
wanted to see if the storm were world-wide.
Stinson had never been in a sand storm before, even on Earth. He could
not breathe. He could not see. Bullets of sand stung his skin. Bullets
of sand shot into his eyes. Clouds of sand howled around him. He fell,
and the wind rolled him over and over in the sand like a tumbleweed.
The skirt flew up around his face. He could not get up again.
He returned to the cave.
Soon after, while they sat huddled together, watching the chaos of
tumbling rocks, lightning, and driving rain, the high-pitched keening
came again. A sphere of blue fire appeared in the east. Its brilliance
put the lightning to shame. It bore down on the cave swiftly,
purposefully. Stinson prepared himself to leave. In spite of his desire
to protect Sybtl, it was useless to get himself killed when he was
powerless to help her. But at the last moment it veered off.
"Fiend!" Stinson screamed the word, vaguely marvelling at his own fury.
The blue sphere turned and came back.
"Monster!"
Again.
"Murderer!"
"Adolescent!"
This time it kept going. The rain and wind ceased. Lightning stopped.
Thunder rumbled distantly. Clouds disappeared. Stinson and Sybtl
emerged from the cave.
There was no longer a question of attack from the webfoots, the storm
had taken care of that. The fierce sun began its work of drying rocks
and throwing shadows and coaxing life out into the open again. Down in
the canyon a bird sang, a lonely, cheerful twitter.
"The Sand God is tired," Sybtl said. "He is not angry now. I'm glad.
Perhaps he will let you stay."
"No. Even if he allowed it, I couldn't stay. My people could never live
here with a God who is half devil."
The cone of sand suddenly appeared. It stood in the canyon, its base
on a level with the cave. It was quiet. It was dull gray in color. It
exuded impressions of death, of hopeful words solemnly spoken over
lowered coffins, of cold earth and cold space, of dank, wet catacombs,
of creeping, crawling nether things.
The bird's twitter stopped abruptly.
"Earthman," the Sand God said, as if he were about to make a statement.
Stinson ignored him. He glanced down at Sybtl, who sensed that this was
a time for good-bys. He thought, perhaps I can stay here alone with
her. The webfoots might find us, or the Sand God might destroy us in
one of his fits, but it might be worth it.
"Don't go," she said. "Not yet."
"Earthman, hear me."
"I hear you."
"Why does your mind shrink backward?"
"I've decided not to bring my people here."
"
You
decided?"
"Certainly," Stinson said boldly. "Call it rationalization, if you
wish. You ordered us away; and I have several good reasons for not
coming here if the door was open."
"I've changed my mind. You will be welcomed."
"Listen to that, will you?" Stinson said angrily. "Just listen! You
set yourself up as a God for the webfoots. You get them eating out of
your hand. Then what do you do? You throw a fit. Yes, a fit! Like an
adolescent. Worse."
"Earthman, wait...."
"No!" Stinson shot back. "You've owned this planet for a million
years. You have brooded here alone since before my people discovered
fire, and in all those ages you never learned self-control. I can't
subject my people to the whims of an entity who throws a planetary fit
when it pleases him."
Stinson relaxed. He'd had his say. Sybtl trembled beside him. A small
mammal, round, furry, hopped by, sniffing inquisitively.
Sybtl said, "Is the Sand God happy?" She shook her head. "No, he is not
happy. He is old, old, old. I can feel it. My people say that when one
gets too old it is well to die. But Gods never die, do they? I would
not like to be a God."
"Stinson," the Sand God said. "You said I was adolescent. You are
correct. Do you remember I told you how my people, the entire race,
left their bodies at the same time? Do you imagine all of us were
adults?"
"I suppose not. Sounds reasonable. How old were you?"
"Chronologically, by our standards, I was nine years old."
"But you continued to develop after...."
"No."
Stinson tried to imagine it. At first there must have been a single
voice crying into a monstrous emptiness, "Mother, where are you?
MOTHER!
Where is
everyone
?" A frenzied searching of the planet,
the solar system, the galaxy. Then a returning to the planet. Empty....
Change. Buildings, roads, bridges weathering slowly. Such a race would
have built of durable metal. Durable? Centuries, eons passed. Buildings
crumbled to dust, dust blew away. Bridges eroded, fell, decomposed
into basic elements. The shape of constellations changed. All trace
of civilization passed except in the cavern of the heated pool.
Constellations disappeared, new patterns formed in the night sky. The
unutterably total void of time—FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND YEARS!
And a nine-year-old child brooding over an empty world.
"I don't understand why your development stopped," Stinson said.
"Nor do I. But perhaps ... well, I sense that I would continue, if you
brought your people here. You have already taught me the value of
life. There is a oneness, a bond that ties each living thing to every
other living thing. It is a lesson my people never knew. Select any
portion of this planet that suits you. Take the web-footed woman for
your wife. Have children. I promise never to harm you in any way."
"The webfoots?"
"You and they shall share the planet."
The Sand God disappeared. Sybtl said; "Is the Sand God angry again?"
"No, he is not angry."
"I'm glad. You will leave now?"
"No. This is my home."
She laughed softly. "You are a strange God."
"Listen," he said, "I am not a God. Get that through your head."
She drew him into the cave. Her lips were cool and sweet. The cave was
pleasantly warm.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/6/9/51699//51699-h//51699-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why are the webfoots chasing Stinson and Sybtl? | 51699_RWJ8X7FI_4 | [
"The webfoots think Stinson took Syblt against her will.",
"Stinson accidentally killed one of the webfoots while disarming him.",
"Stinson murdered the leader of the webfoots.",
"The webfoots think Sybtl did not please the God."
] | 2 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0010",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0014",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |