id
stringlengths 3
7
| context
stringlengths 8
967
| statement
stringlengths 10
276
| entailment
listlengths 0
4
| neutral
listlengths 0
4
| contradiction
listlengths 0
4
| idk
sequencelengths 0
3
| label_count_round_1
dict | label_count_round_2
dict | label_set_round_1
sequencelengths 1
3
| label_set_round_2
sequencelengths 0
3
| error_labels
sequencelengths 0
2
| has_ambiguity
bool 2
classes | chaosnli_labels
dict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
96516e | As Ben Yagoda writes in the New York Times Book Review , somewhere along the way, Kidder must have decided not to write a book about Tommy O'Connor. | A book was not written about Tommy O'Connor. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1138-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, Kidder decided not to write a book about Tommy O'Connor.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1138-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Kidder dicided not to write a book about O'Conner. So this book about him is not written",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1138-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Kidder didn't write a book about Tommy O'Connor doesn't mean others haven't.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1138-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Other people might have written a book about Tommy O'Connor.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1138-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe Kidder later wrote a book not about Tommy O'Connor, maybe he even did not write a book, so no book was written at all.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 73,
"n": 22,
"c": 5
} |
52761e | My unborn children will never appear on the Today show. | No direct descendent of mine will ever be a guest of the Today show. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "446-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "my unborn children mean the children that are born by me. So they are direct descendent of mine. So my unborn children not being on the show means my direct descendent not being on the show",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "446-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The grandchild is also a direct descendent, we don't know if the speaker's grandchildren will appear on the Today show.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "446-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There might be children that have already been born. These would not be \"unborn children\" but also \"direct descendent\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "446-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Direct descendent include children and grandchildren. In the context, it is only confirmed that my children will not be a guest of the Today show, but my grandchildren could be on it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 65,
"n": 34,
"c": 1
} |
21297n | He was crying like his mother had just walloped him. | He was crying like his mother hit him with a spoon. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "345-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement describe how much he was crying.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "345-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Regarding the intensity of crying \"wallop\" is probably similar to hitting \"with a spoon\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "345-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "His mother could hit him with a spoon, could with other things like stike or slippers.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "345-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not known with what his mother hit him",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 24,
"n": 74,
"c": 2
} |
98487c | Julius nodded gravely. | Julius loves to ask questions. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "532-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context if Julius loves to ask questions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "532-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Questions are not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "532-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe Julius loves to ask questions, maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "532-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 80,
"c": 20
} |
17179n | Lie back, and DON'T THINK. | Lie back, and do not use your crazy mind. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "62-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context and the statement talk about stopping thinking.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "62-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"DON'T THINK\" implies not to overthink and relax in this context. So it is similar to \" not use your crazy mind\", which also means not to overthink",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "62-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether the mind is crazy.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "62-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Using crazy mind could be counted as thinking or not thinking, but dreaming.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 63,
"n": 37,
"c": null
} |
132539e | Boca da Corrida Encumeada (moderate; 5 hours): views of Curral das Freiras and the valley of Ribeiro do Poco. | Boca da Corrida Encumeada is a moderate text that takes 5 hours to complete. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "104-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Moderate\" and \"5 hours: are two descriptions about Boca da Corrida Encumeada made in the statement which are mentioned in the context as well.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "104-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It could be assumed that (moderate; 5 hours) is a short form of moderate text with 5 hours reading time",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "104-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Boca da Corrida Encumeada\" sounds more like a hike than a text.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "104-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Boca da Corrida Encumeada should be a route, not a text.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 50,
"n": 36,
"c": 14
} |
23642n | The second half of the book dealt with the use of the true name. | The first part dealt with the use of false names. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1064-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The first part is not mentioned by the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1064-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what the first part of the book is about.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1064-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The first part is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1064-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the first part of the book",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 91,
"c": 5
} |
84781e | By coordinating policy development and awareness activities in this manner, she helps ensure that new risks and policies are communicated promptly and that employees are periodically reminded of existing policies through means such as monthly bulletins, an intranet web site, and presentations to new employees. | She can find new risks with the awareness campaign. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "282-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The awareness campaign is about communicating risks, not about finding new ones",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "282-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Finding new risks could be a effect of awareness campaign, but it is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "282-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "She can communicate new risks with the awareness campaign insteading of finding new risks.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "282-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "She does not find new risks but to ensure that the new risks are dealt with correctly",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 57,
"n": 31,
"c": 12
} |
15771c | or just get out and walk uh or even jog a little although i don't do that regularly but Washington's a great place to do that | "I regularly go for a walk or a jog at Washington's." | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "246-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker doesn't regularly go for a walk or a jog at Washington's.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "246-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"i don't [walk or jog] regularly\" implies that the speaker also does no do that at Washington's",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "246-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, I don't go for a walk or a jog regularly.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "246-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context implies that \"i\" do not walk or job regularly",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 11,
"n": 13,
"c": 76
} |
134655c | Catch up on the Indian avant-garde and the bohemian people of Caletta at the Academy of Fine Arts on the southeast corner of the Maidan. | The Academy of Fine Arts is located in Northern Maidan. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "471-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Academy of Fine Arts is located in Southern Maidan instead of Northern Maidan.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "471-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is located on the \"southeast corner\", so not in \"Northern\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "471-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, The Academy of Fine Arts is located in Southeasten Maidan.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "471-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is located on the southeast corner of the Maidan",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 8,
"n": 15,
"c": 77
} |
33822n | Why shouldn't he be? | He doesn't actually want to be that way. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "788-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "His thought is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "788-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether he wants to be like that.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "788-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about his intention",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 7,
"n": 80,
"c": 13
} |
125021c | Other functional components of the Postal Service are presumed here not to exhibit significant scale economies, although this has not been demonstrated. | The Postal Service only operates very large scale economies. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "884-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The word \"only\" is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "884-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the Postal Service operates economies at all, or what that should mean.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "884-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Other functional components of the Postal Service could operate not very large scale economies, but this has not been demonstrated, so it can also be very large.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "884-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They are presumed not to operate significant/large scale economies",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 4,
"n": 48,
"c": 48
} |
133005n | In May 1967, Gallup found that the number of people who said they intensely disliked RFK--who was also probably more intensely liked than any other practicing politician--was twice as high as the number who intensely disliked Johnson, the architect of the increasingly unpopular war in Vietnam. | Due to his attitudes on cheesecake, RFK was more disliked than Johnson. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "315-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The reason why RFK was more disliked than Johnson is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "315-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether RFK had an attitude towards cheescake or how that impacted his popularity.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "315-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "RFK's attitudes on cheesecake is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "315-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not known that the dislikes on RFK is due to his attitudes on cheesecakes",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "315-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, RFK was more iked than Johnson.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 8,
"n": 49,
"c": 43
} |
65650e | She didn't listen. | She did not listen to the noise. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "310-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't suggest what she didn't listen to.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "310-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether she didn't listen to the noise or to something else.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "310-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe she did not listen to the noise, maybe she did not listen to vert important messages.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "310-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is unknown what she did not listen to",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 54,
"n": 45,
"c": 1
} |
3545n | Several of the organizations had professional and administrative staffs that provided analytical capabilities and facilitated their members' participation in the organization's activities. | Organizations had mandatory bonding exercises for their members. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "937-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if the activities are mandatory.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "937-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"mandatory boding exercises\" are not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "937-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Organizations facilitated their members' participation in the organization's activities, but they maybe had mandatory bonding exercises, maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "937-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The members were facilitated to participate. So it is not mandatory but encouraged",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 15,
"n": 77,
"c": 8
} |
105196n | Indeed, said San'doro. | They were certain. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "365-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Indeed\" implies a level of certainty.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "365-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Indeed implies a positive acknowledging attitude.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "365-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions San'doro, it is unclear who \"they\" are.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "365-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context, there is only one person. \"They\" can refer to anyone.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 49,
"n": 50,
"c": 1
} |
144753e | When he's ready for a major strike, how many innocents do you suppose are going to suffer? To quote one of your contemporaries; 'The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.' ' | If he does a big strike, many people will suffer. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "222-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question in the context might be a rhetorical question which suggests exactly that many innocents will suffer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "222-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"how many innocents do you suppose are going to suffer\" implies that \"many people will suffer\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "222-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question in the context implies that a major strike leads to suffering of many innocent people",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "222-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the question in the context is just a ordinary question, then we don't know if many people will suffer.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 62,
"n": 36,
"c": 2
} |
114458e | Mortifyingly enough, it is all the difficulty, the laziness, the pathetic formlessness in youth, the round peg in the square hole, the whatever do you want? | Many youth are lazy. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "4-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"the laziness [...] in youth\" implies that \"many youth are lazy\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "4-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The laziness in youth means youth being lazy",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "4-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not mention whether many young people are lazy.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 68,
"n": 29,
"c": 3
} |
49237c | 'You burned down my house.' | 'Even though you tried to burn it down, my house is in perfect state.' | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1566-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggest that the speaker's house was burned down, while the statement states that the house was not burned down.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1566-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "After being burned down, the house will not be in perfect state.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1566-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, you burned down my house means it already happened.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1566-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context entails the house was burned down",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 9,
"c": 91
} |
70047c | What about the hole?" They scanned the cliff-side narrowly. | They looked from the top of the cliff for the hole. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "75-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They were scanning the cliff-side, so they were on the top of the cliff looking for the hole",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "75-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether they were on top of a cliff.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "75-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They could look from at direction to the cliff-side, maybe from the top, maybe from the bottom.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 33,
"n": 57,
"c": 10
} |
137319n | And she came to you? | The person asked if the woman came to him. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1383-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is the description of the question in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1383-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1383-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "she' implies it was a woman.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1383-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"You\" can refer to a male or a female.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 81,
"n": 18,
"c": 1
} |
63013n | Although claims data provide the most accurate information about health care use, ensuring adequate follow-up for purposes of obtaining information from patient self-report is important because many people do not report alcohol-related events to insurance compa-nies. | The insurance companies want to reduce medical payments by following-up to ensure patient was sober at the time of incident and intoxication may lead to a claim denial on reimbursement for medical expenses. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1161-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement seems to be a reason of why the insurance companies want to follow-up, that may just be one possibility.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1161-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether it is the insurance companies that should do the follow-up or why.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1161-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Intoxication may lead to a claim denial on reimbursement for medical expense, but it may not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 47,
"n": 45,
"c": 8
} |
79507e | An organization's activities, core processes, and resources must be aligned to support its mission and help it achieve its goals. | An organization is successful if its activities, resources, and goals align. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "837-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "What is mentioned in the statement may be a factor in an organization's success, but there might be others.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "837-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only says that these are required, not that they are sufficient.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "837-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "An organization's activities, rescources and goals align can help it achieve success, but the alignment can not promise the success.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "837-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Don't know if this is the only standard to measure if an organization is successful",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 75,
"n": 25,
"c": null
} |
121910e | If ancient writings give only a romanticized view, they do offer a more precise picture of Indo-Aryan society. | Ancient writings don't show an accurate picture of Indo-Anryan society. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "835-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Yes, because ancient writings give only a romanticized view.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "835-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "An accurate picture of the society is given under the assumption that ancient writings give a romanticized view. So in reality, where this assumption does not hold, the picture is not accurate either",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "835-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The writings are \"more precise\" than something else. That doesn't imply that they are really accurate.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "835-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Ancient writings offer a more accurate picture of Ino-Aryan society.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 19,
"n": 18,
"c": 63
} |
120323n | In the original, Reich is set up by his host and then ambushed by a hostile questioner named John, and when he tries to answer with an eloquent Mr. Smith speech (My fist is clenched. | Reich's host is out to get him. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "850-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Reich's host is out to set him up. The word \"get\" in the statement could mean set up.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "850-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "His host set him up, so he is out to get him.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "850-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Yes, because Reich is set by his host.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "850-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He is set up by his host. So his host designed a trap for him, meanig his host is out to get him",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "850-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the the word \"get\" refers to physical, for example \"catch\", then the statement is false.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 75,
"n": 22,
"c": 3
} |
50480n | But you will find it all right." | You, I'm sure, will find it more than adequate. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1548-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that it is fine.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1548-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"find it all right\" implies \"more than adequate\"",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1548-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It might be more than adequate, but also can be just adequate.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1548-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "possible extraggeration.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 67,
"n": 29,
"c": 4
} |
123027n | uh high humidity | Warm, sweaty temperatures. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "486-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"high humidity\" implies \"warm sweaty temperatures\"",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "486-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases to high humidity",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "486-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It can be warm or cold.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 72,
"n": 26,
"c": 2
} |
85279n | The almost midtown Massabielle quarter (faubourg de Massabielle), is sometimes described as the most picturesque in the city. | The Massabielle quarter is a very touristy place. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "161-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether the Massabielle quarter is very touristy or not",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "161-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"picturesque\" does not necessarily imply \"touristy\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "161-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It could be a very touristy place because of its great beauty, but it also can be not touristy because of poor transportation, or it is not so famous.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "161-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "picturesque is not directly related to touristy",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 20,
"n": 78,
"c": 2
} |
121360c | The tip was hooked towards the edge, the same way the tips are hammered for knives used for slaughter. | They were fragile and could not leave a scratch. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "152-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if they were fragile.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "152-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear from the context whether \"they\" are fragile or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "152-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "152-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, because knives used for slaughter are usually sharp.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 52,
"c": 47
} |
56582n | So far, however, the number of mail pieces lost to alternative bill-paying methods is too small to have any material impact on First-Class volume. | Occasionally mail is lost but not often | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1356-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The number is too small indicates that mail loss is not often.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1356-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because number of lost mail pieces is too small.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1356-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "the number of mail lost is too small. So it means it is not often to lose the mails",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1356-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only talks about the impact of losses because of \"alternative bill-paying methods\". Mail could also be lost for other reasons.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 60,
"n": 36,
"c": 4
} |
46650n | The draft treaty was Tommy's bait. | Tommy took the bait of the treaty. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "336-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if Tommy took the bait of the treaty.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "336-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The treaty acts as bait for Tommy, but it is not clear whether he really took it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "336-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not known if Tommy took the bait.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "336-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Tommy is the person who set the bait, but not the one took the bait.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 34,
"n": 56,
"c": 10
} |
81579e | All were prominent nationally known organizations. | The only identified organizations were well-known. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "750-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "750-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention identified organizations.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "750-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The only identified organizations could be well-known or not well-known.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "750-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "All the organizations were well-known",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 78,
"n": 18,
"c": 4
} |
23414c | Why bother to sacrifice your lives for dirt farmers and slavers? | No one cares about the dirt farmers and slaves. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "523-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context indicates the speaker's attitude toward the dirt farmers and slaves, not everyone's attitude.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "523-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Judging by the context, the speaker probably does not care for \"dirt farmers\" and \"slavers\". It does not follow that they think that no one cares for them. Also the statement talks about \"slaves\" which are not mentioned at all.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "523-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The person at whom this question was directed at, cared about the farmers.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 40,
"n": 48,
"c": 12
} |
36715e | Jon twisted the man's wrist. | Jon grabbed the man. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "526-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is clear that Jon grabbed the man by twisting his wrist.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "526-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In order to twist the wrist, Jon has to first grab the man.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "526-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "To twist, one would need to grab",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "526-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The man could be grabbed by Jon, but also could slip from him.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 76,
"n": 22,
"c": 2
} |
114492n | and the same is true of the drug hangover you know if you | It's just like a drug hangover but worse. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "512-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't contain any information about if it is worse.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "512-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says that it's similar to \"drug hangover\" not \"worse\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "512-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is similar to the drug hangover, but the extent can be worse or better.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "512-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about where a drug hangover is worse",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 11,
"n": 66,
"c": 23
} |
136097n | and going to school is also always very prohibitive now unless your parents are wealthy | Wealthy parents are necessary for school. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1525-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement talk about the necessity of wealthy parents.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1525-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If \"going to school is [...] prohibitive [...] unless your parents are wealthy\" then \"wealthy parents are necessary for school\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1525-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The school are too expensive to go to, making wealthy parents necessary to pay for the tuition",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1525-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Wealthy parents can make going to school easier, but maybe without wealthy parents, it is still possible.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 61,
"n": 28,
"c": 11
} |
101253c | In his effort to build nationalism across Turkey in the 1920s, Ataterk instituted a campaign to suppress Kurdish identity that continues today. | In 1942, Ataterk tried to build nationalism in Turkey. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "284-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks about the 1920s. It is not clear whether Ataterk still was politically active in the 1940s and whether he continued his campaign.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "284-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We only can sure that in 1920s, Ataterk tried to build nationalism in Turkey, but in 1942, maybe he tried, maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "284-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Ataterk tried to build nationalism in Turkey in the 1920s, not in 1942.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "284-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It should be in 1920s",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 22,
"n": 16,
"c": 62
} |
97520e | AC Green's pretty good | AC Green is also a solid player. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "520-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"pretty good\" implies \"solid\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "520-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "a solid player is a good player",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "520-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention AC Green's occupation.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "520-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "AC Green could be a player or do other jobs,",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 69,
"n": 29,
"c": 2
} |
97569e | Candle grease? | Was it candle grease? | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "120-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement ask if it was candle grease.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "120-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "120-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 72,
"n": 28,
"c": null
} |
23751c | Part of the reason for the difference in pieces per possible delivery may be due to the fact that five percent of possible residential deliveries are businesses, and it is thought, but not known, that a lesser percentage of possible deliveries on rural routes are businesses. | We all know that the reason for a lesser percentage of possible deliveries on rural routes being businesses, is because of the fact that people prefer living in cities rather than rural areas. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "292-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the reason why lesser percentage of possible deliveries on rural routes are businesses.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "292-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context whether \"we all know\" that. No group of people that could know something is mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "292-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether people prefer living in cities or in rural areas.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "292-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The fact that people prefer living in cities is not known",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 16,
"n": 65,
"c": 19
} |
103169n | 'Dave Hanson, to whom nothing was impossible.' Well, we have a nearly impossible task: a task of engineering and building. | This building job is almost impossible, even for an experienced engineer. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "783-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can infer that Dave Hanson is an experienced enginneer since nothing was impossible to him. The task is impossible since it is impossible to Dave Hanson, an experienced engineer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "783-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the task is \"nearly impossible\" then it is also \"almost impossible\" for an experienced engineer.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "783-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It should be the job of engineering and building together",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "783-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, because nothing was impossible to Dava Hanson.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 72,
"n": 26,
"c": 2
} |
134217e | uh-huh and is it true i mean is it um | It's true. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1231-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement sugguest that it is true.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1231-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1231-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context is a question",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | [
"entailment",
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 50,
"n": 42,
"c": 8
} |
11601n | 36 AC usage nationally for mercury control from power plants should be roughly proportional to the total MWe of coal-fired facilities that are equipped with the technology (this assumes an average capacity factor of 85 percent and other assumptions of Tables 4-4 and 4-5). | Power plants' mercury control AC usage is higher than total MWe from coal facilities. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "275-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that Power plants' mercury control AC usage is proportional to total MWe from coal facilities. It is not clear if the usage should be lower or higher than total MWe.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "275-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is \"proportional\". This could be higher or lower.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "275-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Power plants' mercury control AC usage is proportinal to the total MWe from coal facilities, so it could be more and could be less.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "275-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not mentioned if the AC usage is higher than total MWe from coal facilities, but only in roughly proportional.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 5,
"n": 47,
"c": 48
} |
46059c | The results of even the most well designed epidemiological studies are characterized by this type of uncertainty, though well-designed studies typically report narrower uncertainty bounds around the best estimate than do studies of lesser quality. | All studies have the same amount of uncertainty to them. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "920-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "Well-designed studies and studies of lesser quality have different amount of uncertainty to them.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "920-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"well-designed studies typically report narrower uncertainty bounds\" means that they have less uncertainty than other types of studies.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "920-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, well-designed studies typically report narrower uncertainty bounds around the best estimate than do studies of lesser quality.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "920-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "well-designed studies has less amount of uncertainty",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 27,
"n": 12,
"c": 61
} |
82156e | The great breathtaking Italian adventure remains the road. | The road remains the Italy people want to see. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1077-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention what Italy people want to see.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1077-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The road remains the great breathtaking Italian adventure, but Italy people could like adventure, could not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1,
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 54,
"n": 41,
"c": 5
} |
30894n | Earlier this week, the Pakistani paper Dawn ran an editorial about reports that Pakistani poppy growers are planning to recultivate opium on a bigger scale because they haven't received promised compensation for switching to other crops. | Pakistani poppy growers are mad at the government. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1479-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Pakistani poppy growers haven't received compensation, which could be a reason why they might be mad at the government. Planning to recultivate opium on a bigger scale could be a sideways indication that they're mad.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1479-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Yes, because Pakistani poppy growers haven't received promised compensation.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1479-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because the growers haven't received promised compensation from the government, so they can be mad at government because of it",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1479-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the poppy growers are really mad. Maybe they did not care much about the promised compensations.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1479-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe Pakistani poppy are mad at the government, maybe they are not mad.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 44,
"n": 54,
"c": 2
} |
122645n | Then you're ready for the fray, either in the bustling great bazaars such as Delhi's Chandni Chowk or Mumbai's Bhuleshwar, or the more sedate ambience of grander shops and showrooms. | All of the great bazaars are bustling at all times. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1503-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if all of the great bazaars are bustling at all times. The context only mentions two.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1503-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the bazaars are really bustling at all times or only at some times.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1503-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe great bazaars are bustling at all times, maybe only at day time or at night.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1503-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context, only some bustling great bazaars were named, but it does not mean all of the great bazaars are bustling",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 21,
"n": 66,
"c": 13
} |
26142n | The importer pays duties that are required by law | Imported goods have duties | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1150-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement show that imported products have duties.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1150-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the importer has to pay duties then imported goods have duties on them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1150-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, Imported goods have duties that are required by law.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1150-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The importers have duties not the imported goods",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 88,
"n": 9,
"c": 3
} |
66225n | uh but you could fill a whole bunch of uh holes with these things i used to i used to advertise buying wheat pennies um i'd give a dollar a roll which two cents a piece which is basically overpriced | I made a good dollar while selling them. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "865-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context if the speaker sold them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "865-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear how well the selling went.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "865-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not clear context, but seems to be irrelevant to statement",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 29,
"n": 40,
"c": 31
} |
134103n | He walked out into the street and I followed. | I followed him down the street. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1057-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context and the statement talk about the speaker following him down the street.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1057-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1057-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He walked out on to street and I followed him. So naturally, I was also on the street, following him",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1057-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe I followed him down the street, maybe I followed him up.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 75,
"n": 22,
"c": 3
} |
117177n | I guess history repeats itself, Jane. | I truly think the prior situation shows history repeats itself. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "800-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I truly think history repeats itself.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "800-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "800-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't specify what shows that history repeats itself.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "800-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the speaker truly believes that history repeats itself. They could also use it figuratively.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 73,
"n": 25,
"c": 2
} |
78105e | Their supplies scarce, their harvest meager, and their spirit broken, they abandoned the fort in 1858. | Their supplies remained very low and hard to maintain. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1345-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is true because the context suggests that their supplies scarce and they abandonedd the fort.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1345-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The supplies probably remained low because otherwise they might not have abandoned the fort.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1345-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, their supplies are scarce and they abandoned the fort.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1345-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "scarce means insufficient, so their supplies were low",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 81,
"n": 18,
"c": 1
} |
23280e | Sphinxes were guardian deitiesinEgyptianmythologyandthis was monumentalprotection,standing73 m (240 ft)longand20 m (66 feet) high. | Sphinxes guarded people. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "774-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly suggests that Sphinxes were guardian deities.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "774-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, Sphinxes were guardian deities.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "774-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context what exactly sphinxes guard.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "774-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In Egyptian mythology, Sphinxes were guardian deities, but in reality, maybe they guarded people, maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "774-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about what Sphinxes guarded, it could be people or a temple.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 52,
"n": 45,
"c": 3
} |
9393n | Next, you enter the vast and splendid Imperial Hall, with three handsome marble fountains, and a canopied throne from which the sultan would enjoy the music and dancing of his concubines. | The sultan enjoyed drinking from the marble fountains in the Imperial Hall. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "976-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't talk about the sultan drinking.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "976-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the Sultan drank from the fountains.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "976-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe the sultan enjoyed drinking from the marble fountains, maybe he didn't like it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "976-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "He enjoyed music and dancing there",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 7,
"n": 70,
"c": 23
} |
82510c | although the uh it's uh it we almost one day we painted the house to uh we painted we painted the whole inside and it had all this dark trim we thought uh you know we did the one wall but the other trim i'm trying to think i think i think we left most of it because it gets to be uh they don't do that in the newer houses now we don't the uh mold everything is white in a new house everything is white | It took over a day to paint the house | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "720-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "If it took \"almost a day\" then it took less not more than one day.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "720-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They took almost one day to paint the house, which is less than a day.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "720-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, it took almost one day to paint the house.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "720-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It took almost one day, so less than a day",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 23,
"n": 30,
"c": 47
} |
14459n | After their savage battles, the warriors recuperated through meditation in the peace of a Zen monastery rock garden. | The warriors recuperated through mediation learned from monks. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "556-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention from whom the warriors learned to meditate.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "556-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They only meditated in a monastery. It is not clear from whom they learned the meditation.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "556-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe there are monks in the Zen monastery rock garden, maybe there are not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "556-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not known if they learned it from monks",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 34,
"n": 62,
"c": 4
} |
70711c | because otherwise it's too it gets if you start them when it's cooler in the spring then it gets too hot in the summer | You should start them during Spring if you want them to be cool during the summer. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1133-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether \"they\" get too hot or whether it gets too hot for them.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1133-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, it gets too hot in the summer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1133-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "One should start in the spring, cause it's hot summer and it's cool in spring.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 22,
"n": 38,
"c": 40
} |
77893n | As he stepped across the threshold, Tommy brought the picture down with terrific force on his head. | Tommy hurt his head bringing the picture down. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1241-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is true since the picture that Tommy brought down hit him in the head.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1241-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Tommy probably hurt his head because a picture hit his head with \"terrific force\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1241-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, Tommy hurt his head with the picture.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1241-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Tommy should hit another guy not himself, but in the statement, it could be understood as Tommy hurt himself, or another guy.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1241-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He is not hurt but rather bad strong emotion",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 72,
"n": 25,
"c": 3
} |
20181n | What the judge really wants are the facts -- he wants to make a good decision, he said. | In the end the judge made a bad decision since he imprisoned someone innocent. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "137-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't suggest what kind of decision the judge made.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "137-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The judge could have made a bad decision even if his intentions were to only rely on facts.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "137-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We only know that the judge wants to make a good decision, but the desicion could be actually good or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "137-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about what happened in the end",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 70,
"c": 27
} |
137715n | We still espouse a God-given right of human beings to use the environment for their benefit, says Barrett Duke of the Southern Baptists. | Human beings are entitled to the environment. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1584-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement refer to the right of human beings to use the environment.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1584-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"God-given right of human beings to use the environment\" implies that humans \"are entitled to the environment\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1584-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because it's god given right. So human are born to have this right",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1584-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Barrett Duke of the Southern Baptists believes human beings are entitled to the environment, but the facts can be not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 81,
"n": 16,
"c": 3
} |
109679n | The Palace of Jahangir is built around a square court with arches. | The Palace of Jahangir houses a wonderful square court, complete with arches. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "914-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"is built around a square court with arches\" implies \"houses a wonderful square court [...] with arches",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "914-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, the Palace of Jahangir is built around a square court with arches.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "914-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The place is built around the square, so the place houses it",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "914-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context whether the square court is wonderful or not.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 86,
"n": 14,
"c": null
} |
123891c | His proud reserve--a product of 40 years in the spotlight--is refreshing but does not bode well for his capacity to shepherd big ideas through Congress. | He is way too loud. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1341-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The word \"loud\" in the statement may have two kinds of meanings. If it refers to flashy, then it fits the description of him in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1341-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, his proud reserve is a product of 40 years in the spotlights, but does not bode well.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1341-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It \"loud\" refers to noisy, the statement may be true or false since the context doesn't mention anything about his voice.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1341-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether he is too loud or whether his proudness shows in other ways.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1341-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 4,
"n": 56,
"c": 40
} |
16086n | Unless the report is restricted by law or regulation, auditors should ensure that copies be made available for public inspection. | This report is most likely restricted by law or regulation and should not be ensured. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1176-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, being restricted by law or regulation is an exception that this report should not make the copies available for public inspection.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1176-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't suggest whether this report is restricted or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1176-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only states what should happen if the report is not restricted. It does not say anything about whether it is restricted.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1176-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about a specific report",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 10,
"n": 52,
"c": 38
} |
91650n | yep because it's when it's self propelled it's heavy yeah | it's heavy when it's self propelled, in case you were wondering | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1267-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that it is heavy when it is self propelled.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1267-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1267-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Same sentence: it's heavy when it's self propelled",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 93,
"n": 5,
"c": 2
} |
85428e | Christ on a crutch, what does he have to do to lose your support, stab David Geffen with a kitchen knife? | Your support is unwavering. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "346-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the only way to lose one person's support is to stab someone then the support is unwavering.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "346-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because it used exaggeration to prove that you will always support him.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "346-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Your\" support is so unwavering that he has to do something very extreme to lose your support",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 78,
"n": 18,
"c": 4
} |
118403n | oh really it wouldn't matter if we plant them when it was starting to get warmer | It is better to plant when it is colder. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1596-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If it doesn't matter when they plant them when it gets warmer, then it is not better to plant when it is colder.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1596-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "1) The question mark of context is missing, the end of the sentence could be a question mark. 2) Maybe it is better to plant when it is complete warm or even hot.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1596-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly suggests that it is fine to plant when it is warmer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1596-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It doesn't matter if it's warmer or colder",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 7,
"n": 52,
"c": 41
} |
105561e | and they just put instructors out there and you you sign up for instruction and they just give you an arm band and if you see an instructor who's not doing anything you just tap him on the shoulder and ask him questions and they'll show you things | The instructors are marked with armbands, and anytime you want to know anything, you just find one of them. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "827-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "827-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The contexte only mentions that they will give the speaker an arm band, it is not clear if the instructors are marked with armbands.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "827-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, I am marked with armbands and I need instructoion.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "827-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not anytime, the instructor has to be free first",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | true | {
"e": 60,
"n": 14,
"c": 26
} |
11303n | 'I see.' | It was clear | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "943-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "943-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If I see means literally to see",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "943-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe it is not clear but I understand it anyway.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "943-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Irrelevant if I see means I understand",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 67,
"n": 31,
"c": 2
} |
11534n | He found himself thinking in circles of worry and pulled himself back to his problem. | He could not afford to get distracted from his problem. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1230-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Although the context mentions that he pulled himself back to his problem, it is not clear if he could afford to get distracted.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1230-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He might also focus on the problem to distract him from his worries. It is not clear whether the problem really was so important.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1230-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "His problem may be related to money, also may not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1230-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context means his way of thinking does not help him solve his problem",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 51,
"n": 45,
"c": 4
} |
46198n | How effectively DOD manages these funds will determine whether it receives a good return on its investment. | These funds are for the purchase of five thousand tons of potatoes. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "806-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not specify what these funds are used for.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "806-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The purpose of the funds is not mentioned at all.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "806-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The purchase of five thousand tons of potatoes is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "806-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 2,
"n": 74,
"c": 24
} |
125013e | yeah okay yeah those games are fun to watch you you you watch those games | Those games are a lot of fun. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "221-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is clear from the context and statement that those games are fun.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "221-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the games are fun to watch then they are fun (at least in that way).",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "221-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because those games are fun to watch.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "221-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The games are fun to watch so it's a lot of fun",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 74,
"n": 26,
"c": null
} |
44747n | Total volume grew 13. | The expected increase was 10. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "648-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what the expected increase was.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "648-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The expected increase maybe more or less than 10.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "648-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Accordding to the context, the increase was 13, not 10.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "648-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was 13",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 3,
"n": 69,
"c": 28
} |
19768c | Wear a nicely ventilated hat and keep to the shade in the street. | The buildings are so low that there is no shade in the streets. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1270-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not mention if the buildings are low.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1270-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe the buildings are not low, but the street is too wide.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1270-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1270-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the recommendation is to stay in the shade of the buildings then there are probably buildings casting shades. Otherwise the recommendation would not make sense.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 2,
"n": 37,
"c": 61
} |
53468n | But is the Internet so miraculous an advertising vehicle that Gross will be able to siphon off $400 per person from total ad spending of $1,000 per family--or persuade advertisers to spend an additional $400 to reach each of his customers? | The internet is so great at advertising that is saved Gross money. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1048-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context asks the question of whether the Internet is so great at advertising, whereas the statement asserts it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1048-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context is a question. It can not come to a conclusion as in the statement",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1048-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "No, Gross saved no money, but siphoned money from other people.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 36,
"n": 56,
"c": 8
} |
136752n | The questions may need to be tailored to | A majority of the questions referenced will need to be tailored to. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1350-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1350-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't specify how many questions need to be tailored.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1350-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe all the questions referenced will need to be tailored to.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1350-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about whether the majority of the questions or all of them",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 43,
"n": 54,
"c": 3
} |
10724n | Traditionally, certain designs were reserved for royalty, but today elegant geometric or exuberant, stylized floral patterns are available to all. | Designs once reserved for royalty cost more to buy. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1564-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no mention of designs' costs in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1564-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It doesn't say whether these designs are more expensive.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1564-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The price of the designs once reserved for royalty is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1564-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the cost",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 78,
"c": 18
} |
17753n | The street ends at Taksim Square (Taksim Meydane), the heart of modern Istanbul, lined with luxurious five-star hotels and the glass-fronted Ataturk Cultural Centre (Ataturk Keleter Sarayy), also called the Opera House. | The street is quite a luxurious one. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "844-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The description of the street in the context shows that it is indeed a luxurious one.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "844-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "On the street there are fancy centers and a Luxurious hotel",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "844-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Taksim Square is luxurious. It is not clear whether the street leading to it is also.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "844-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The detail of the street itself is not mentioned in the context, we only know the end of the street.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 88,
"n": 12,
"c": null
} |
130928n | Still, I guess that can be got over. | There are some things that you need to ignore. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1001-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Getting over means to move on and stop caring about this. Thus to ignore",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1001-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't say anything about whether there's something to ignore.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1001-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Getting over something does not necsessarily mean that you should ignore the issues. You could also work through them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1001-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There are some things that you can ignore, but it is not necessary.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 51,
"n": 45,
"c": 4
} |
66858n | Managing better requires that agencies have, and rely upon, sound financial and program information. | Agencies that rely on information based on unsound financial information will have management problems. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "496-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks about the importance of sound financial information, o it is natural to deduce that if financial information is not sound, there will be problems.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "496-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If sound information is required for better managing then unsound information will lead to management problems.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "496-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Sound financial information will help manage the agencies better, but without it doesn't meant to have problems, maybe it just makes the process less efficient.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "496-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Good Management requires sound financial, but unsound financial does noch necessarily Leads to management problems",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 75,
"n": 18,
"c": 7
} |
28601n | Three more days went by in dreary inaction. | The days passed by slowly. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "409-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The description\"dreary inaction\" implies that the days went by slowly.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "409-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "409-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The days may made people feel slow, maybe feel fast.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "409-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Dreary inaction means nothing being down. It does not mean slowly",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 78,
"n": 21,
"c": 1
} |
92774n | The party's broad aims were to support capitalist policies and to continue close ties with Britain and the rest of the Commonwealth. | The party sought to establish ties with the United States. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "265-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention anything about establishing ties with the United States.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "265-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The United States are not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "265-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, the party had close ties with the United States already.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "265-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They aim to maintain ties with Britain and its commonwealth",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 1,
"n": 46,
"c": 53
} |
142604e | As the budgets, functions, and points of service of many government programs devolve to state and local government, private entities and nonprofit organizations, and other third parties, it may become harder for GAO to obtain the records it needs to complete audits and evaluations. | Audits and evaluations are harder because it is more difficult for GAO to get the records. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1208-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because it may become harder for GAO to obtain the records it needs to complete audits and evaluations.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1208-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that it may be more difficult to obtain records, which is a possibility rather than an absolute thing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1208-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says that it \"may become harder\" not that \"it is more difficult\". These are not the same things because the context describes a future state.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1208-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It can be more difficult for GAO to get the records, but maybe it actually doesn't become harder for GAO ro obtain the records.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1208-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "It was because the budget functions etc. of government programs further devolves that makes it harder",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 81,
"n": 19,
"c": null
} |
42860n | That's why we tried to kill you. | That's one of the reasons we wanted to kill you. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1298-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1298-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe it is the only reason that we wanted to kill you, maybe that is just one of the reasons.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1298-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context implies that there is one reason, while the statement suggests that therea are multiple reasons.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1298-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "From the context we know it might be the only reason",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 75,
"n": 17,
"c": 8
} |
77299n | The inquiry expanded very quickly, however, from asking what technology failed to an examination of contextual influences, such as | They moved they inquiries over from technology failing because they thought it may be something else. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "23-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"expanded [...] from asking what technology failed to [...] contextual influences\" means that they \"moved inquiries from technology failing because they thought it may be something else\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "23-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the reason of moving inquiries over from technology failing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "23-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe they thought it may be something else, maybe they just can not sure, what is the true reason.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 46,
"n": 45,
"c": 9
} |
13765c | it's just it's the morals of the people which i mean i guess we everybody's responsible for the society but if i had a child that that did things so bad it's not they don't care about anybody these people they're stealing from they're just the big bad rich guy | I have no issue with people stealing from others. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "638-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"they don't care about anybody these people they're stealing from\" shows that the speaker has issues with people stealing.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "638-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I have no problem people stealing from bag rich people",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 9,
"n": 60,
"c": 31
} |
139362e | Endorphins were flowing. | My endorphins were flowing. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1500-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1500-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't specify whose endorphins were flowing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1500-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It could be my endorphins, but also could be yours or anyone's.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1500-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about whose endorphins it is",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 47,
"n": 50,
"c": 3
} |
116176c | Students of human misery can savor its underlying sadness and futility. | Students of human misery will be delighted to see how sad it truly is. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "704-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"can savor\" implies \"will be delighted\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "704-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context if the students will be delighted.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "704-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Students of human misery can \"savored\" that sadness, so maybe they are delighted to see that, maybe they are tortured by the disasters.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "704-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "Savor means to understand. Not to enjoy",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 69,
"n": 26,
"c": 5
} |
110234e | really oh i thought it was great yeah | that was a nice experience | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "612-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement say that it was good.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "612-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"it was great\" means that it was \"a nice experience\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "612-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because I thought it was great",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "612-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe it was a great experience, maybe it was a great present or something else.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "612-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He thought it was a great experience. But in the context there was an element of surprise. So it was not a great experience after all",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 81,
"n": 19,
"c": null
} |
84781c | By coordinating policy development and awareness activities in this manner, she helps ensure that new risks and policies are communicated promptly and that employees are periodically reminded of existing policies through means such as monthly bulletins, an intranet web site, and presentations to new employees. | There new employees are a risk. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "356-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether new employees are a risk or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "356-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not the employees are a risk but they should be made aware of the risks.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "356-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The situation of new employees is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "356-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Nothing about the new employee being a risk",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 11,
"n": 54,
"c": 35
} |
41052n | HCFA published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on March 28, 1997 (62 Fed. | HCFA tried to keep everyone informed about the rules they were making. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1567-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Publishing a Notice is a way HCFA tried to keep everyone informed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1567-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They published the rules. So theoretically everyone can see it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1567-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether they tried to keep everyone informed or whether they published the notice only because they had to.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1567-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "HCFS published a Notice, but the notice may have tried to keep everyone informed, maybe just made it quitely.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 68,
"n": 31,
"c": 1
} |
128160n | Suddenly she started, and her face blanched. | She moved swiftly, her face pale. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "93-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "93-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't specify what she started doing, it could be moving, thinking or talking.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "93-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "She \"started\" can mean she moved swiftly, but also can do other actions, like crying, singing, etc.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "93-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about her moving swiftly",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 78,
"n": 15,
"c": 7
} |
123038e | Reports on attestation engagements should state that the engagement was made in accordance with generally accepted government auditing standards. | Details regarding validation engagements ought to express that the engagement was made as per by and large acknowledged government evaluating guidelines. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "945-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and statement suggest the same requirement for reports.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "945-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Generally accepted is synonym to large acknowledged",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 66,
"n": 27,
"c": 7
} |
98621n | In other cases, we must rely on survey approaches to estimate WTP, usually through a variant of the contingent valuation approach, which generally involves directly questioning respondents for their WTP in hypothetical market situations. | Hypothetical market situations are uniform across all respondents. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1266-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether they use the same market situtations for all people they ask.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1266-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about uniformity across the respondents",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1266-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, if market situations are uniform, then \"a variant of the contingent valuation approach\" is not necessary.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 7,
"n": 54,
"c": 39
} |
97926c | General Motors, for instance, lost $460 million to strikes in 1997, but investors treated the costs as a kind of extraordinary charge and valued the company as if the losses had never happened. | GM lost a lot almost a million dollars in labor disputes. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "530-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "GM lost more than a million dollars.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "530-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "GM lost over 460 million which is much more than one million.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "530-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, GM lost $460 million in labor disputes, far more than a million.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "530-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They lost 460 million",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 11,
"n": 17,
"c": 72
} |
98561e | was it bad | Was it not good? | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "170-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "170-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Bad and not good are synonyms",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 84,
"n": 16,
"c": null
} |
86429n | Agencies may perform the analyses required by sections 603 and 604 in conjunction with or as part of any other agenda or analysis required by other law if such other analysis satisfies the provisions of these sections. | There are many times when the agencies have gotten in trouble. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1163-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context if th eagencies have gotten in trouble.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1163-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about trouble.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1163-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The conditions of trouble is not offered in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1163-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about agencies in trouble",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 77,
"c": 20
} |
105911c | and to have children and just get a day care or someone to take care of it and not really have the bonding process that takes place with babies and stuff you know | The children should not go to day car. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1095-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"just get a day care [...] and not really have the bonding process\" sound like the speaker is opposed to day care.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1095-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because the bonding process will be missed",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1095-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says that it is not good if sending children to day care is the only way to take care of them, but it doesn't mention if children shouldn't go to day care at all.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 37,
"n": 50,
"c": 13
} |
126486n | The entire setup has an anti-competitive, anti-entrepreneurial flavor that rewards political lobbying rather than good business practices. | The setup has lead to increases in political lobbying. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "427-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the setup rewards political lobbying then it will likely lead to increases in lobbying.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "427-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because political lobbying is rewarded",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "427-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Rewarding political lobbying does not necessarily mean an actual increase in political lobbying.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 67,
"n": 33,
"c": null
} |
127809n | I'm confused. | Not all of it is very clear to me. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1196-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that the speaker does not understand.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1196-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1196-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because \"confused\" means, at lease one thing is not very clear to me.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1196-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "When someone is confused , then not everything is clear to him",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 92,
"n": 5,
"c": 3
} |
28306c | They made little effort, despite the Jesuit presence in Asia, to convert local inhabitants to Christianity or to expand their territory into the interior. | The Jesuit presence in Asia helped to convert local residents to Christianity, allowing them to expand their territory. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "22-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that the speaker does not understand.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "22-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Jesuit presence didn't make much effort to convert local residents to Christianity or to expand their territory.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "22-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They did not try to expand their territory.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "22-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Jesuit did not make effort to convert local residents to Christianity, or to expand their territory.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "22-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They made little effort to convert the locals or to expand the their territory. So they did not help.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 14,
"n": 17,
"c": 69
} |