Datasets:

llmunlearn

/

unlearn_dataset

like 0

Lobo A, Hansen JK, Hansen LN, Kjær ED. Differences among six woody perennials native to Northern Europe in their level of genetic differentiation and adaptive potential at fine local scale. Ecol Evol. 2018;8:2231--2239. <https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.3824> 1. INTRODUCTION {#ece33824-sec-0001} =============== Phenology is important for fitness of perennial species. Higher spring temperatures are expected to prolong the growing seasons due to earlier bud burst (Dragoni et al., [2011](#ece33824-bib-0010){ref-type="ref"}; Menzel & Fabian, [1999](#ece33824-bib-0034){ref-type="ref"}; Menzel et al., [2006](#ece33824-bib-0035){ref-type="ref"}; Richardson et al., [2010](#ece33824-bib-0045){ref-type="ref"}, [2013](#ece33824-bib-0046){ref-type="ref"}; Vitasse, Delzon, Dufrêne, et al., [2009](#ece33824-bib-0059){ref-type="ref"}), while lack of synchrony between phenology and occurrence of spring frost events increases risk of damage to early flushing plants (Duputié, Rutschmann, Ronce, & Chuine, [2015](#ece33824-bib-0012){ref-type="ref"}). Yet again, raised temperatures with no frost events and changes in daily temperature fluctuations could also result in later bud burst and influence time between bud development and growth cessation (Chmura et al., [2011](#ece33824-bib-0008){ref-type="ref"}; Rohde, Bastien, & Boerjan, [2011](#ece33824-bib-0048){ref-type="ref"}; Way, [2011](#ece33824-bib-0060){ref-type="ref"}). Several studies have documented substantial variation among populations in their phenology reflecting their geographic origin (Alberto, Derory, et al., [2013](#ece33824-bib-0004){ref-type="ref"}; Chuine & Beaubien, [2001](#ece33824-bib-0009){ref-type="ref"}; Salmela, Cavers, Cottrell, Iason, & Ennos, [2013](#ece33824-bib-0049){ref-type="ref"}). It is therefore fair to assume that genetic variation within species combined with divergent selection has played an important role for the ability of many tree species to thrive in a large distribution range across strong environmental gradients (Brousseau et al., [2016](#ece33824-bib-0006){ref-type="ref"}; Kawecki & Ebert, [2004](#ece33824-bib-0023){ref-type="ref"}; Pluess et al., [2016](#ece33824-bib-0042){ref-type="ref"}). However, species differ in their response and spring and autumn phenology may show different patterns. A study based on 59 tree species from similar climatic clines thus showed a relative clear pattern with respect to bud set in autumn but less clear pattern in spring bud burst (Alberto, Aitken, et al., [2013](#ece33824-bib-0003){ref-type="ref"}). The expectation of local adaptation often leads restoration and conservation programs to focus on gene pools at the local scale rather than the regional scale (Stanturf et al., [2015](#ece33824-bib-0056){ref-type="ref"}), but only few studies have actually assessed the variation at the local scale (within \~100 km). Fast climate change calls for high phenotypic plasticity (Valladares et al., [2014](#ece33824-bib-0057){ref-type="ref"}) and genetic variation in relevant traits in plant populations (Franks, Weber, & Aitken, [2014](#ece33824-bib-0014){ref-type="ref"}) in order to ensure continued adaptation. Many tree species have revealed phenotypic plasticity and demonstrated their ability to thrive and reproduce when transferred to new areas (Kjær, Lobo, & Myking, [2014](#ece33824-bib-0025){ref-type="ref"}; Lascoux, Glémin, & Savolainen, [2016](#ece33824-bib-0033){ref-type="ref"}; Myking, Rusanen, Steffenrem, Kjær, & Jansson, [2016](#ece33824-bib-0036){ref-type="ref"}; Rehfeldt, Ying, Spittlehouse, & Hamilton, [1999](#ece33824-bib-0043){ref-type="ref"}). However, there are indications of declining plasticity in phenology in spring with continued global warming (Fu et al., [2015](#ece33824-bib-0015){ref-type="ref"}) and increased frequency of warm periods in the early spring may lead to frost backlashes (Jönsson & Bärring, [2011](#ece33824-bib-0022){ref-type="ref"}). The temperatures are likely to change in the future, but the seasonal variations in day length remain the same. Species will therefore respond differently as regards phenology to temperature changes depending on the species‐specific importance of day length versus heat sum in controlling flushing time (Alberto, Aitken, et al., [2013](#ece33824-bib-0003){ref-type="ref"}; Caffarra & Donnelly, [2011](#ece33824-bib-0007){ref-type="ref"}; Fu et al., [2015](#ece33824-bib-0015){ref-type="ref"}; Vitasse, Delzon, Bresson, Michalet, & Kremer, [2009](#ece33824-bib-0058){ref-type="ref"}; Vitasse, Delzon, Dufrêne, et al., [2009](#ece33824-bib-0059){ref-type="ref"}). Variation among individual genotypes in their phenology triggers selection at the population level in favor of the new conditions, if the variation is in fitness traits and expressed with moderate or high heritability (Alberto, Aitken, et al., [2013](#ece33824-bib-0003){ref-type="ref"}; Falconer & Mackay, [1996](#ece33824-bib-0013){ref-type="ref"}). Genetic differentiation within and among population is therefore important for the species ability to adapt to climate change (Kubisch, Holt, Poethke, & Fronhofer, [2014](#ece33824-bib-0029){ref-type="ref"}). However, natural selection is not the only evolutionary force, because the combined actions of natural selection, gene flow and genetic drift drive the level of genetic variation within and among populations in fitness traits (Nadeau, Meirmans, Aitken, Ritland, & Isabel, [2016](#ece33824-bib-0037){ref-type="ref"}). The realized patterns therefore depend on effective population sizes, force of natural selection and limitations in pollen and seed dispersal (Aitken & Whitlock, [2013](#ece33824-bib-0002){ref-type="ref"}; Savolainen, Pyhäjärvi, & Knürr, [2007](#ece33824-bib-0052){ref-type="ref"}). Natural selection tends to increase the level of genetic variation among populations, but reduce the variation within populations leading to local adaptation. Fragmentation into small populations can create drift that also increase variation among population variation, but without supporting local adaptation. Small populations can rather reduce fitness due to inbreeding, at least in outcrossing species. Pollination and seed dispersal across the landscape among populations will counteract the fragmentation, but seed and pollen dispersal across environmental gradients will also counteract natural selection and thereby reduce the ability of populations to adapt to specific local conditions (Kubisch et al., [2014](#ece33824-bib-0029){ref-type="ref"}). The level of gene flow is expected to differ among woody species depending on occurrence, landscape features, mating system, pollen, and seed dispersal vectors. We therefore expect that the degree of local differentiation---and the degree to which this reflect local adaptation---will differ among woody plant species depending on their major life‐history traits. 1.1. Objectives of this study {#ece33824-sec-0002} ----------------------------- On the above background, the objectives of this study were to use data on spring phenology to Assess the degree to which woody perennials reveal fine‐scale genetic differences among geographically and climatic close (differences in mean annual temperature around 1°C) populations, and test whether differences (if any) influence the fitness revealing signs of local adaptation.Estimate levels of genetic variation within and among populations in spring phenology and compare the levels of population differentiation (*Q* ~ST~) and additive genetic variation (*V* ~A~) among species. Based on the results, we discuss the implications for dynamic conservation of genetic resources and the ability of woody plant species to adapt to future climate conditions. 2. MATERIALS AND METHODS {#ece33824-sec-0003} ======================== Six broadleaved species in Denmark were studied, of which three are insect pollinated---Common dogwood (*Cornus sanguinea* L.), European Crab Apple (*Malus sylvestris* (L.) Mill.) and Glaucous Dog Rose (*Rosa dumalis* (Bechst) Boulay), while three are wind pollinated---Downy birch (*Betula pubescens* Ehrh.), Common Hazel (*Corylus avellana* L.) and Sessile oak (*Quercus petraea* (Matt.) Liebl.). We used data from progeny trials with offspring from open pollinated trees based on seed collected from putative natural populations across Denmark (Figure [1](#ece33824-fig-0001){ref-type="fig"}). Description of the field trials, location of populations, and climate information at the population site and information on families within each population are provided in Appendix [S1](#ece33824-sup-0001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. ![Locations of original populations for the different species in the study are spread across different climate zones (here represented by temperature minimum in May \[*T* ~min~\])](ECE3-8-2231-g001){#ece33824-fig-0001} 2.1. Assessment of phenotypic data and estimation of variance components {#ece33824-sec-0004} ------------------------------------------------------------------------ We used spring phenology assessed as bud burst scores using a scale from 0 to 8, where class 0 was closed winter buds and class 8 was fully opened leaves. The time of assessment was adapted for each species so that the trees in the trials were approximately in the middle of their flushing time (average values of bud burst score between 3 and 5). This was to ensure maximum variation among individuals in their bud burst ranking. Bud burst for *B. pubescens, C. sanguinea, M. sylvestris,* and *R. dumalis* were assessed in spring 2010, while assessments of *C. avellana* and *Q. petraea* were from spring 2013. Height was measured in the year of phenology assessment except for *R. dumalis*. All analyzes were made per species, because they were tested in different common garden trials. The variation among trees in their phenological stage was separated into variance and covariance components reflecting genetic differences among and within populations as implemented in the software ASReml (Gilmour, Gogel, Cullis, & Thompson, [2009](#ece33824-bib-0017){ref-type="ref"}) from the model described below. Population values were predicted by application of mixed model (1), and genetic variance component corresponding to each of the random effects in the model was estimated from the analysis; $$Y_{\mathit{ijkl}} = \mu + B_{i} + P_{j} + \lambda_{\mathit{ij}} + f_{k(j)} + \tau_{\mathit{ikj}} + \varepsilon_{\mathit{ijkl}}$$ where *Y* ~*ijkl*~ is the trait measured for tree *l*, μ is the overall mean of the trait, *B* ~*i*~ is the fixed block effect, *P* ~*j*~ is the fixed population effect, λ~*ij*~ is the fixed population by block interaction, *f* ~*k*(*j*)~ is the random effect of family within population, τ~*ijk*~ is the random effect of plot *k*, and ε~*ijkl*~ is the residual. *Q* ~ST~ values were estimated from model (1) as well having population effects as random. The significance of the genetic variances of traits within sites and genotype by environment interaction across sites was tested using the log likelihood ratio (Gilmour et al., [2009](#ece33824-bib-0017){ref-type="ref"}). The significance of the populations was tested using the Satterthwaite approximation (Satterthwaite, [1946](#ece33824-bib-0051){ref-type="ref"}) in the procedure GLM in the statistical software program SAS (SAS Institute Inc. [2011](#ece33824-bib-0050){ref-type="ref"}). 2.2. Quantitative genetic analysis {#ece33824-sec-0005} ---------------------------------- We estimated the additive genetic variance (*V* ~A~) as 4σ~f~ ^2^ and narrow sense heritability within sites as; $\binom{\frown}{h}^{2} = 4\sigma_{f}^{2}/{(\sigma_{f}^{2} + \sigma_{\tau}^{2} + \sigma_{\varepsilon}^{2})}$, where σ~f~ ^2^ is the estimated family variance, σ~τ~ ^2^ is the estimated plot variance, and σ~ε~ ^2^ is the estimated within plot variance. The phenotypic variance was estimated as $\binom{\frown}{V}_{P} = \sigma_{f}^{2} + \sigma_{\tau}^{2} + \sigma_{\varepsilon}^{2}$. Families were considered to represent groups of half‐sibs. This assumption will overestimate the additive genetic variance, heritability, and expected response to selection, if the offspring within progeny groups on average are more related than half‐sibs (Falconer & Mackay, [1996](#ece33824-bib-0013){ref-type="ref"}). While the assumption of half‐sibs may provide a good fit for most trees species (Kjær, McKinney, Nielsen, Hansen, & Hansen, [2012](#ece33824-bib-0026){ref-type="ref"}; Larsen & Kjær, [2009](#ece33824-bib-0032){ref-type="ref"}), the situation may be more complicated for *R. dumalis,* where polyploidy may be present as the variance between families is biased due to a fraction of the dominance genetic variance, even if the families consist of pure half‐sibs (Roberts, Gladis, & Brumme, [2009](#ece33824-bib-0047){ref-type="ref"}). The degree of differentiation among populations was estimated as the *Q* ~ST~ values (Spitze, [1993](#ece33824-bib-0055){ref-type="ref"}) using the formula;$$\binom{\frown}{Q}_{ST} = \binom{\frown}{V}_{POP}/{(\binom{\frown}{V}_{POP} + 2\binom{\frown}{V}_{A})}$$ where $\binom{\frown}{V}_{POP}$ is the estimated variance between populations, and $\binom{\frown}{V}_{A}$ is the estimated additive genetic variance. Variance components, narrow sense heritability estimates, *Q* ~ST~ estimates, and their standard errors were estimated from model (1) using the software ASReml (Gilmour et al., [2009](#ece33824-bib-0017){ref-type="ref"}). 2.3. Support to the hypothesis of location adaptation {#ece33824-sec-0006} ----------------------------------------------------- Climate data for the locations of origins were estimated with the ClimateEU v4.63 software package following the methodology described by (Hamann, Wang, Spittlehouse, & Murdock, [2013](#ece33824-bib-0019){ref-type="ref"}). Weighted regression analysis to test relationship between phenology of populations and climate at the population sites was carried out using procedure REG in SAS (SAS Institute Inc. [2011](#ece33824-bib-0050){ref-type="ref"}) having the predicted values of populations as dependent variable and climate variables as explanatory variables. One divided by the error variance for the predicted population values were used as weights. The climate variables tested for bud burst were monthly minimum temperatures and differences between monthly maximum and minimum temperatures in March, April, May and June, because these data are expected to provide good proxies for the risk of frost occurring after flushing. A backward selection approach (5% level) was used for the selection of climate variables that could best explain the variation in flushing time. The relationship between geographic distances and difference in average budburst was tested by a Mantel test as implemented in R version 3.2.2 (Dray & Dufour, [2007](#ece33824-bib-0011){ref-type="ref"}). 2.4. Fitness effects of spring phenology {#ece33824-sec-0007} ---------------------------------------- Genetic correlations between bud burst and height growth were estimated based on individual tree data to assess whether the height as a proxy for realized fitness in the present climate varied with the phenology. Genetic correlations could be estimated between survival and phenology based on plot means, because the plants were grown in family plots in all trials (see Appendix [S1](#ece33824-sup-0001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Genetic correlations were estimated according to Falconer and Mackay ([1996](#ece33824-bib-0013){ref-type="ref"}) as $\binom{\frown}{r}_{g} = \frac{\sigma_{\mathit{fxy}}}{\sqrt{\sigma_{\mathit{fx}}^{2}\sigma_{\mathit{fy}}^{2}}}$ , where σ~*fxy*~ is the family (within population) covariance between trait *x* and *y*, σ~*fx*~ ^2^ is the family (within population) variance for trait *x*, and σ~*fy*~ ^2^ is the family (within population) variance for trait *y*. 3. RESULTS {#ece33824-sec-0008} ========== 3.1. Presence of genetic variation within and among populations in bud burst {#ece33824-sec-0009} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Genetic variation both within and among populations was significant in all six species, but with large differences among the species. The additive genetic variance for bud burst (*V* ~A~) thus ranged from 0.07 in *C. sanguinea* to 0.34 in *Q. petraea* (Table [1](#ece33824-tbl-0001){ref-type="table-wrap"}), while the level of differentiation among populations (*Q* ~ST~) ranged from 0.04 in *M. sylvestris* to 0.27 in *C. sanguinea* (Table [2](#ece33824-tbl-0002){ref-type="table-wrap"}). The three wind‐pollinated species *B. pubescens, C. avellana* and *Q. petraea* showed the highest level of additive variance, while the insect‐pollinated species *C. sanguinea* and *R. dumalis* showed the highest level of population differentiation as measured by the *Q* ~ST~ (Figure [2](#ece33824-fig-0002){ref-type="fig"}). ###### Family variation and genetic parameters for bud burst in different species Species Trait Mean *p*‐Value family *V* ~A~ *V* ~P~ *h* ^2^ *SE* -------------------- ------------------------- ------ ------------------ --------- --------- --------- ------ *Betula pubescens* Bud burst 24 April 2010 3.27 .003 0.15 0.30 0.50 0.12 *Cornus sanguinea* Bud burst 6 May 2010 3.81 \<.0001 0.07 0.27 0.24 0.11 *Corylus avellana* Budburst 24 April 2013 3.09 \<.0001 0.13 0.27 0.47 0.09 *Malus sylvestris* Bud burst 28 April 2010 4.05 \<.0001 0.03 0.10 0.31 0.08 *Quercus petraea* Bud burst 24 May 2013 4.64 \<.0001 0.34 0.58 0.58 0.26 *Rosa dumalis* Bud burst 26 April 2010 3.58 \<.0001 0.09 0.21 0.41 0.14 *V* ~A~ = additive genetic variance, *V* ~P~ = *p* variance, *h* ^2^ = narrow sense heritability, *SE* = standard error for *h* ^2^. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd ###### Level of population differentiation for bud burst in different species Species Trait *Q* ~st~ *SE* *p*‐Value population Max. pop. diff.[a](#ece33824-note-0002){ref-type="fn"} -------------------- ------------------------- ---------- -------- ---------------------- -------------------------------------------------------- *Betula pubescens* Bud burst 24 April 2010 0.13 0.08 \<.001 0.71 *Cornus sanguinea* Bud burst 6 May 2010 0.27 *0.14* \<.001 0.88 *Corylus avellana* Budburst 24 April 2013 *0.12* *0.05* \<.0001 0.86 *Malus sylvestris* Bud burst 28 April 2010 0.04 *0.03* .02 0.28 *Quercus petraea* Bud burst 24 May 2013 0.13 0.09 .0003 2.45 *Rosa dumalis* Bud burst 26 April 2010 0.18 0.09 \<.001 1.52 Maximum difference between populations in bud burst score. QST = quantitative genetic differentiation among populations in bud burst, SE = standard error for QST John Wiley & Sons, Ltd  burst insect‐pollinated species,  wind‐pollinated species](ECE3-8-2231-g002){#ece33824-fig-0002} 3.2. Relationship of phenology with growth, fitness, distance between populations and climate at original population site {#ece33824-sec-0010} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The regression between bud burst of populations and population site minimum temperatures in March were significant (*p \< .05*), or close to significant (*p = .05*) for *B. pubescens* and *C. avellana* (Figure [3](#ece33824-fig-0003){ref-type="fig"}), and the regression between bud burst of populations and population site minimum temperatures in May was close to significant (*p = .05*) for *Q. petraea* (Figure [3](#ece33824-fig-0003){ref-type="fig"}). This corresponds to the general time for bud burst, where *B. pubescens* and *C. avellana* flush before *Q. petraea* in Denmark and indicate that spring frost event has played an important role in developing the pattern of variation among population in these species. Similar significant correlations were not observed in any of the three insect‐pollinated species. Mantel tests for correlation between geographic distance and difference in bud burst at population were nonsignificant in all the species (Figure [4](#ece33824-fig-0004){ref-type="fig"}). Survival was not significantly correlated to bud burst data in any of the species evaluated, and a significant additive genetic correlation between height and budburst was only observed in *B. pubescens (rg = *0.35; *SE 0.23*). {#ece33824-fig-0003} {#ece33824-fig-0004} 4. DISCUSSION {#ece33824-sec-0011} ============= Our results show that fine‐scale local genetic differentiation in fitness traits such as phenology indeed can be present and to a larger extent than previously anticipated in the Danish gene conservation strategy (Graudal, Kjær, & Canger, [1995](#ece33824-bib-0018){ref-type="ref"}). However, the analysis across the six different species did not provide unique patterns of local adaptation, as the absence of significant regression between bud burst time and spring temperature in the three insect‐pollinated species suggests that the variation among population is not always simply reflecting local adaptation. It is rather more likely a result of natural selection and neutral processes simultaneously acting as predicted by theory (Nadeau et al., [2016](#ece33824-bib-0037){ref-type="ref"}).The fact that populations in all studied six species were significantly differentiated in their spring phenology suggests that local populations of woody perennials more often than not are genetically differentiated, and this can be the case even if they only are separated by 10 to 35 km (Figure [4](#ece33824-fig-0004){ref-type="fig"}) and growing in areas with low variation in altitude and where the spring temperature varies only between 1°C and 2.5°C (Figure [3](#ece33824-fig-0003){ref-type="fig"}). This finding should be compared to the prediction of Northern Europe becoming 2--4°C warmer by the year 2100 (Nikulin, Kjellström, Hansson, Strandberg, & Ullerstig, [2011](#ece33824-bib-0039){ref-type="ref"}). However, the observed high level of additive genetic variation in the studied species indicates that the native populations of woody species do possess substantial evolutionary potential. Divergent natural selection is possible within few generations, if the timing of phenology creates large differences in fitness. This is supported by the fact that the observed patterns in our study for *B. pubescens*,*C. avellana,* and *Q. petraea* (Figure [3](#ece33824-fig-0003){ref-type="fig"}) are at least partly due to past natural selection in favor of local adaption. The presence of local adaptation and evolutionary potential in woody species are often attributed to their life‐history traits including pollination mechanisms and associated genetic processes, and it is therefore interesting that the patterns were different for the wind‐ and insect‐pollinated species in our study. The result that the three wind‐pollinated, continuous distributed species (*B. pubescens, C. avellana, Q. petraea)* were characterized by having high levels of genetic variation within populations (right circle of Figure [2](#ece33824-fig-0002){ref-type="fig"}) supports the general assumption that wind‐pollinated, widely distributed species have allocated genetic variation within populations to a larger extent than insect‐pollinated species with small and scattered populations (Petit & Hampe, [2006](#ece33824-bib-0041){ref-type="ref"}; Smith & Donoghue, [2008](#ece33824-bib-0053){ref-type="ref"}). The results correspond to the expectation that long‐distance gene flow through wind pollination will maintain connectivity among populations (lowering *Q* ~ST~) and counteract loss of genetic variation (maintaining high *h* ^2^) within populations (Sork, [2016](#ece33824-bib-0054){ref-type="ref"}). High levels of gene flow among populations across landscapes have been reported in the wind‐pollinated *Quercus* (Gerber et al., [2014](#ece33824-bib-0016){ref-type="ref"}). The insect‐pollinated *C. sanguinea* was in the opposite corner of *Q. petraea* in Figure [2](#ece33824-fig-0002){ref-type="fig"}, reflecting a much higher proportion of genetic variation located among populations. *C. sanguinea* in general occurs in scattered and small populations in Denmark (Ødum, [1968](#ece33824-bib-0040){ref-type="ref"}). Seed dispersal by birds (Krüsi & Debussche, [1988](#ece33824-bib-0028){ref-type="ref"}) may generate long‐distance gene flow across the landscape, but the observed level and distribution of genetic diversity in the present study point toward genetic drift rather than natural selection as important driver behind the observed population differentiation. The true difference between *Q. petraea* and *C. sanguinea* in level of genetic variation may be even higher, because the assumption of half‐sib relationship within seed from single tree collection is likely to create a bias toward overestimation of *V* ~A~ in the rose as discussed in M&M above. *M. sylvestris* is again a different case in Figure [2](#ece33824-fig-0002){ref-type="fig"}, with low level of genetic differentiation but also relatively low additive genetic variance. Pollinating insects have been reported to visit primarily trees in immediate vicinity, but long‐distance pollination events are also likely to occur (Larsen & Kjær, [2009](#ece33824-bib-0032){ref-type="ref"}; Reim et al., [2015](#ece33824-bib-0044){ref-type="ref"}) and seeds moved by birds and deer that feed on the wild apples also create long‐distance gene flow (Larsen & Kjær, [2009](#ece33824-bib-0032){ref-type="ref"}). Studies based on neutral SSR markers revealed low level of population differences within Denmark (*F* ~ST~ = 0.03) (Larsen, Asmussen, Coart, Olrik, & Kjær, [2006](#ece33824-bib-0031){ref-type="ref"}), which is very close to the estimated *Q* ~ST~ = 0.04 for flushing time in the present. Therefore, the observed variation among populations in *M. sylvestris* may have been generated by random processes without significant effects of divergent selection for flushing time. The studied populations have in general maintained a high level of genetic variation and thereby possess a high ability to adapt to new conditions if exposed to natural selection in favor of---or against---early flushing. The question is how fast species can adapt under the anticipated rapid increase in temperature over the next 100 years, and how important such changes are for the fitness of the species. In *B. pubescens*, the maximum difference in minimum temperature in March of the populations tested in this study was 2.4°C (Figure [3](#ece33824-fig-0003){ref-type="fig"}). Even with a conservative estimate of a generation time of 50 years (Hynynen et al., [2010](#ece33824-bib-0021){ref-type="ref"}), the results suggest that *B. pubescens* possesses the resilience at the population level to change phenology corresponding to the predicted increase in temperature. A similar conclusion can probably be drawn for *Q. petraea* also (Figure [3](#ece33824-fig-0003){ref-type="fig"}). For many of the other studied species, the generation time is possibly less than 20 years (e.g., *R. dumalis*,*M. sylvestris*,*C. avellana,* and *C. sanguinea*), and for these species, it therefore also seems reasonable to assume that populations can evolve in spring phenology with a speed that can match the predicted increase in temperature. The response will only be realized if early bud burst has substantial influence on fitness (survival and reproduction) or because of directional selection implemented in domestication programmes. The estimates in the present study refer to the latter situation, because the heritability was estimated in managed progeny test and the realized heritability in natural population may be substantially lower due to higher environmental and developmental heterogeneity. In Denmark, all major woody plant species are included in domestication programs based on breeding seed orchards in order to support effective and rapid selection for continued fitness (Kjær et al., [2009](#ece33824-bib-0024){ref-type="ref"}). Our finding on genetic differences among geographically close populations (cf. Table [2](#ece33824-tbl-0002){ref-type="table-wrap"}) supports that selectively divergent phenotypes can be maintained even if there are options for gene flow among these populations as suggested by Aitken and Bemmels ([2016](#ece33824-bib-0001){ref-type="ref"}). Kremer et al. ([2012](#ece33824-bib-0027){ref-type="ref"}) argue that the positive effect of gene flow on adaptation of trees to climate change is larger than the negative effect due to the introduction of genetic variation in adaptive traits. Species are different with respect to their genetic differentiation within and among their populations as revealed in our study. Assisted migration for genetic enrichment can serve as a supplement to genetic management based on native populations; especially, the species associated with small population sizes and limited gene flow. Populations at the low latitudinal limit of the species range have in general maintained high biological diversity over time as shown for, for example, *Abies alba* (Bergmann, Gregorius, & Larsen, [1990](#ece33824-bib-0005){ref-type="ref"}; Larsen, [1986](#ece33824-bib-0030){ref-type="ref"}) and southern populations should therefore be considered as a source of gene pool for assisted migration of genotypes under the future climate predictions (Hampe & Petit, [2005](#ece33824-bib-0020){ref-type="ref"}). The populations in the present study are close to the northern distribution range of the species (except for *B. pubescens*) and genetic diversity may therefore be lower compared to populations closer to the refugial areas. But we still observed substantial level of genetic variation in the fitness‐related trait. For species occurring in extremely small fragmented populations assisted migration at a more localized landscape level may still be desirable to counteract inbreeding within these populations due to random drift. Adaptive potential of a species is not only determined by the presence of genetic variation within and among populations as studied here, but also by the presence of phenotypic plasticity in adaptive traits (Nicotra et al., [2010](#ece33824-bib-0038){ref-type="ref"}). Final conclusions on the adaptive potential of species to climate change will therefore also depend on the role of plasticity in local adaptation in the studied species. DATA ACCESSIBILITY {#ece33824-sec-0013} ================== Data for this study is available at University of Copenhagen---Electronic Research Data Archive (UCPH‐ERDA). CONFLICT OF INTEREST {#ece33824-sec-0014} ==================== None declared. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION {#ece33824-sec-0015} =================== Albin Lobo was responsible for the design of study, analysis and interpretation of data, and writing of the manuscript. Jon Kehlet Hansen was responsible for supervision of the work, design of study, and writing and approving of manuscript. Lars Nørgaard Hansen was responsible for field data collection, and revising and approving the final version of the manuscript before submission. Erik Dahl Kjær was responsible for overall supervision of the study, conception and design of work, data interpretation, and writing and final approval of the manuscript. Supporting information ====================== ######   ###### Click here for additional data file. We would like to thank the Danish Nature Agency for providing access to all trials and supporting the huge effort of data collection. The authors would also like to thank the Villum Foundation for financial support for the data collection and the analysis as part of the Trees for future forests project (VKR‐023063). We also thank Dr. Lene Rostgaard Nielsen for the critical reading of this manuscript.

Introduction {#s1} ============ Understanding cell migration mechanisms is a critical issue in many biophysical phenomena, including angiogenesis, tumor growth, metastasis, and wound healing [@pcbi.1002926-Condeelis1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Li1]. Cell migration is a complex multifaceted process, triggered by chemotaxis and haptotatic responses from the extracellular environment [@pcbi.1002926-Lamalice1]. Initially, a thin lamellipodium protrudes due to actin polymerization at the leading edge, followed by actin depolymerization at the lamellipodium base [@pcbi.1002926-Insall1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Watanabe1]. Focal adhesions (FAs) are assembled between the lamellipodium base and the extracellular matrix (ECM). FAs are composed of FA molecules (such as FAK, paxillin, vinculin, Zyxin, VASP, and talin), and transmembrane proteins, especially integrins α~v~β~3~ and α~v~β~5~ that link the ECM to the cytoskeleton via FA molecules [@pcbi.1002926-Critchley1], [@pcbi.1002926-Wozniak1]. Afterwards, contractile bundles of actin filaments, called stress fibers (SFs), extend from nascent FAs and some of which connect to the nucleus [@pcbi.1002926-Salmon1]. The corresponding motor activity exerts force on the FA\'s fore and aft [@pcbi.1002926-Kaverina1], enabling the generation of a traction force and the release of FAs in the rear of the cell, creating the cell body\'s forward movement. The following individual processes of these steps of cell migration have been studied extensively in the literature: actin polymerization and depolymerization [@pcbi.1002926-Ponti1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Watanabe1], focal adhesion dynamics [@pcbi.1002926-Sarvestani1], [@pcbi.1002926-Gallant1], and motor activity of contractile myosin [@pcbi.1002926-Kaunas1], [@pcbi.1002926-Stachowiak1]. Furthermore, both experiments and computational models from those prior works mostly involve 2-dimensional migration on a flat substrate. However, it still remains a challenge to elucidate how these mechanisms work together to mimic 2-D cell migratory behaviors, which have been observed in existing experimental works. The current work is motivated by two experimental works; one on Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cell migration on 2-D ([Figure S1](#pcbi.1002926.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}-A) fibronectin coated substrate [@pcbi.1002926-Palecek1], and the other on cells spreading on 2-D ([Figure S1](#pcbi.1002926.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}-B) fibronectin coated micropatterns on chips [@pcbi.1002926-Tseng1]. Cell migration experiments have indicated that three separate variables, such as substratum ligand density, cell integrin expression level and integrin--ligand binding affinity, significantly affect changes in cell migration speed. For example, when cells migrate on various fibronectin coating concentrations, the cell migration speed takes a maximum at a particular ligand density (∼1140 molecules/µm^2^) with a biphasic curve [@pcbi.1002926-Palecek1]. On the other hand, cell spreading experiments have revealed that interactions between a cell\'s cytoskeleton and micropatterned geometries impinge on cell morphology and mechanics [@pcbi.1002926-Tseng1]. For example, when cell spreading occurs on a crossbow pattern, the cell exhibits locally high traction forces at three corners of the pattern, which may be due to concentrated ventral SFs. Explaining complex interactions with 3-D ECM structure ([Figure S1](#pcbi.1002926.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}-C&D) entails a proper model mechanism of cell spreading because the cell morphology in 3-D ECM is strikingly different from that on 2-D ECM surfaces as the cell is elongated with the highest directionality and highest velocity of migration in 3-D ECM, but the cell forms peripheral lamellae with an increased random migration on 2-D plastic or fibronectin-coated substrates [@pcbi.1002926-Pankov1]. To this end, we have built a computational 3-D cell migration model on 2-D curved ECM surfaces and discovered that the cell migration speed differs depending on the diameter of a sprout, and explained the mechanism [@pcbi.1002926-Kim1]. It is interesting to note that there is an optimal sprout diameter that creates the highest speed of cell migration. In a similar way as on 2-D curved surfaces, we first aim to look at 3-D cell migration model on 2-D planar surfaces with various fibronectin coating concentrations to understand relationship between the migratory speed and ligand surface density. After verifying our 3-D model with 2-D cell migratory mechanism, we then aim to look at 3-D cell spreading model on various 2-D fibronectin-coated patterns. This entails a) deformation mechanics of both cell membrane and nucleus, b) 3-D interactions between transmembrane integrins and ECM ligands, leading to focal adhesion formation, c) SF formation and traction generation, and d) lamellipodium protrusion at the leading edge of the cell. Integration of these key mechanisms is pivotal for elucidating the aforementioned migratory and spreading behaviors. Several prior works have incorporated multiple force-generating systems in their cell migratory models [@pcbi.1002926-Kapustina1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Walcott1]. These works, however, have considered only frictional forces with the substrate rather than focal adhesion (FA) dynamics [@pcbi.1002926-Wong1], [@pcbi.1002926-Cirit1], which generate a mechanical traction force due to a gradient in degraded ligand matrix density during the formation and rupture of ligand-receptor bonds [@pcbi.1002926-Sarvestani1], [@pcbi.1002926-Wong1], interplay between Rac-mediated membrane protrusion and adhesions at the leading edge [@pcbi.1002926-Cirit1]. To explain these mechanisms, a model having ligand-receptor bonds distributed across the cell membrane is necessary. Thereby, we have applied FA dynamics to our cell migratory model. Furthermore, our 3-D computational cell spreading model differs from other existing 2-D models [@pcbi.1002926-Novak1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Grosberg1] in that we incorporate aforementioned FA dynamics, cell membrane and nuclear remodeling, actin motor activity, and lamellipodia protrusion. Additionally, our model can predict 3-D spatiotemporal behavior of cell spreading on 2-D micropatterns as well as spatiotemporal distribution of two kinds of actin stress fibers (SFs), one is a SF connected to the nucleus and the other is a ventral SF, in 3-D intracellular domain. To our knowledge, neither a cell migration or a spreading model integrating focal adhesion dynamics, cell membrane and nuclear remodeling, actin motor activity, and lamellipodia protrusion has been published that reflects 3-D spatiotemporal dynamics of both cell spreading and migration, all interfaced with a 2-D planar surface and fibronectin coated patterns. In the following, numerical simulations demonstrate the diverse migration and spreading behaviors in relation to the various ligand densities of migrating 2-D surfaces and micropatterns, respectively. Results {#s2} ======= First, we aim to verify our model against 2-D cell migration on fibronectin coated substrates under five different fibronectin coating concentrations [@pcbi.1002926-Tseng1]. After this verification, we further aim to verify our model against 2-D cell spreading on micro-patterned structures. We simulate binding kinetics between integrin receptors and extracellular matrix protein ligands (eg. collagen, fibronectin and laminin), model the formation of SFs, and predict how the forces acting on the cell deform the nucleus and the cytoskeleton, resulting in diverse patterns of the cell profile and migratory motion. Simulations of cell migration and spreading were performed respectively for five different ligand surface densities on the planar surface and three different fibronectin coated micropatterns. Fibronectin was considered for both those two sets of simulations. Fibronectin ligand surface densities are summarized in [Table 1](#pcbi-1002926-t001){ref-type="table"}. 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002926.t001 ###### Ligand surface density (Fibronectin). {#pcbi-1002926-t001-1} Cell migration Cell spreading -------------------------------------------- ---------------- ---------------- ----- ------ ------ ----- Ligand surface density \[molecules/µm^2^\] 19.4 192 568 1140 1522 475 The molecular mass of Fibronectin is 480 kDa, the corresponding ligand surface density was converted using the relationship between plating concentration and ligand surface density of Fibronectin [@pcbi.1002926-Rajagopalan1]. At the initial state of each simulation, both cell and nuclear membranes were assumed to be round. Since the migration model is stochastic, simulations were repeated multiple times from the same initial conditions. [Table 2](#pcbi-1002926-t002){ref-type="table"} lists all the parameters used for the simulations with numerical values and their sources. 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002926.t002 ###### List of simulation parameters. {#pcbi-1002926-t002-2} Parameter Definition Value Sources ----------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------ ----------------------------------------------------- *A* Area \[µm^2^\] Area of the *i*-th surface of the cell membrane \[µm^2^\] Area of the *i*-th surface of the nucleus \[µm^2^\] *A~L~* Equilateral triangular area of ligands surface element \[µm^2^\] 0.243 Current work *A~SF~* Averaged SFs\' sectional area \[µm^2^\] 0.196 [@pcbi.1002926-Lu1] *C~c~* Friction coefficients associated with the energy dissipation at the integrin node \[N s m^−1^\] 0.001 [@pcbi.1002926-Kapustina1], [@pcbi.1002926-Drury1] *C~n~* Friction coefficients associated with the energy dissipation at the nuclear node \[N s m^−1^\] 0.001 [@pcbi.1002926-Kapustina1], [@pcbi.1002926-Drury1] *F* Force \[N\] *E* Elastic energy \[pJ\] *E~SF~* Young\'s modulus value of SFs \[kPa\] 230 [@pcbi.1002926-Deguchi2] *L* Length Length of the *i*-th line on the surface of the cell membrane \[µm\] Length of the *i*-th line on the surface of the nucleus \[µm\] *L~b~* Stretched length of bonds between receptors and ligands Length of the *i*-th single unit of SFs at the present time \[nm\] Length of the *i*-th single unit of SFs at the previous time \[nm\] *~N~* Number of nodes at each membrane 549 Current work Number of contractile compartments in the *i*-th SFs *P* Probability *W* Total stored elastic energy *c~L~* Ligand density on the lumen \[molecule µm^−2^\] Distance between *i*-th integrin and *j*-th nuclear nodes *h~c~* Critical height \[nm\] 300 Current work *h~p~* Height from the surface to the *i*-th integrin node \[nm\] *k~f~* Forward reaction rate \[molecule^−1^ s^−1^\] 1.0 Current work Effective spring constant of area elements of the cell membrane \[N/m\] 1.0×10^−4^ [@pcbi.1002926-Tsubota1] Effective spring constant of line elements of the cell membrane \[N/m\] 5.0×10^−5^ [@pcbi.1002926-Drury1], [@pcbi.1002926-Honarmandi1] Effective spring constant of area elements of the nucleus \[N/m\] 1.0×10^−4^ [@pcbi.1002926-Tsubota1] Effective spring constant of line elements of the nucleus \[N/m\] 5.0×10^−3^ [@pcbi.1002926-Tsubota2] Effective spring constant of ligand-receptor bond \[pN/nm\] 1.0 [@pcbi.1002926-Dembo1] *k~on~* Kinetic association rate \[s^−1^\] *k~off~* Kinetic dissociation rate \[s^−1^\] Kinetic dissociation rate at an unstressed state \[s^−1^\] Current work Effective stiffness of the *i*-th single unit of SFs \[N/m\] *n~b~* Number of bonds between receptors and ligands Unit normal vector at the *i*-th integrin node Unit normal vector at the local surface of the lumen *t* Time \[s\] ***v*** Velocity vector \[nm/s\] *v~m~* Sliding rate of non-muscle myosin II on the actin filaments \[nm/s\] [@pcbi.1002926-Ruppel1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Lodish1] ***x*** Location vector \[µm\] *x~L,i~* Root of ligand-receptor bonds on the local surface of the lumen \[nm\] ***λ*** Equilibrium distance of an integrin \[nm\] 30 [@pcbi.1002926-Kanchanawong1] **Sup** *D* Drag or friction *E* Elastic *FA* Focal adhesion *SF* Stress fiber *c* cytoskeleton *n* nucleus *i* *i*-th node *0* Previous time or initial state *1* Present time **Sub** *b* bond *r* rupture Integrated cell migration model {#s2a} ------------------------------- We model the geometric structure of a cell as a double mesh structure: the outer mesh representing the cell membrane and the inner mesh for the nucleus membrane. See [Figure 1-A](#pcbi-1002926-g001){ref-type="fig"}. Each mesh consists of *N* nodes connected elastically to adjacent nodes, forming a double elastic membrane. The inner and outer mesh nodes may be connected when SFs are formed between the nucleus and the cell membrane [@pcbi.1002926-Chancellor1], [@pcbi.1002926-Hale1]. Multiple transmembrane integrins are bundled together and placed at each node on the outer mesh. They can bind to ligands on the matrix substrate, forming a focal adhesion, to which a SF is connected ([Figure 2-A](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}). Furthermore, the model also includes ventral SFs which extend between two focal adhesions. {#pcbi-1002926-g001} {#pcbi-1002926-g002} [Figure 1-B](#pcbi-1002926-g001){ref-type="fig"} shows the free body diagram of the *i*-th node of the cytoskeleton, called the *i*-th integrin node, where a bundle of integrins is formed. Double membranes in the integrated cell migration model move in Lagrangian approach. Acting on this node are force vectors due to frictional dissipative force , focal adhesion force , elastic energy force , SF force , and lamellipodium force . The equation of motion for each integrin node is given bywhere is the velocity vector of the *i*-th integrin node. Similarly, the equation of motion for each node of the nucleus is given bywhere , and are frictional dissipative force, elastic energy force and SF force at the *i*-th nuclear node, respectively, and is the velocity of the *i*-th nuclear node. The velocities and are expressed aswhere and represent coordinates of the *i*-th integrin node and the *i*-th nuclear node, respectively. Most of the frictional dissipative term arises from the rupture of stretched ligand-receptor bonds; when they rupture, the stored strain energy is released and dissipated. Similarly, also arises from the energy stored in SFs that, when F-actin is depolymerized, the stored strain energy is released and dissipated. These dissipative forces can be written aswhere and are friction coefficients associated with the energy dissipation at the integrin node and the nuclear node, respectively. In the literature these coefficients are estimated as 0.001 Ns/m [@pcbi.1002926-Kapustina1], [@pcbi.1002926-Drury1], [@pcbi.1002926-Bausch1]. comes from the binding and rupture of ligand-receptor bonds and cannot easily be measured [@pcbi.1002926-Filippov1]. It should be noted that the sum of forces is zero because the motion is quasi-static in time ([Text S1](#pcbi.1002926.s006){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, [Figure S2](#pcbi.1002926.s002){ref-type="supplementary-material"}), thus [Equations (1)](#pcbi.1002926.e023){ref-type="disp-formula"}--[(4)](#pcbi.1002926.e037){ref-type="disp-formula"} can be simplified to the following two force balance equations: Focal adhesion dynamics {#s2b} ----------------------- Formation of a focal adhesion is described by a stochastic process due to binding kinetics between receptors and ligands on the surface of ECM. Monte Carlo simulation methods have been established for various ligand-receptor binding kinetics in the literature [@pcbi.1002926-Hammer1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Pawar1]. We apply a similar technique to cell migration and spreading on planar surfaces. First we represent the 2-D planar surface and a micropatterned geometry using a mesh of triangles, over which ligands are distributed ([Figure S3](#pcbi.1002926.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Each focal adhesion consists of a bundle of ligand-receptor bonds ([Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}), each of which ruptures and binds stochastically. Let be the probability with which a single receptor binds to a ligand on the substrate during a time interval . where is the forward reaction rate (1 molecule^−1^ s^−1^), represents the density of bound ligands, the original density of the ligands (molecules area^−1^), and the area associated with the integrin node under consideration. Note that represents the number of unbound ligands available for bonding in the vicinity of the integrin node. In simulations, a triangular mesh of approximate side lengths of 0.75 µm were used for area . (See [Figure S3](#pcbi.1002926.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Similarly, existing ligand-receptor bonds may rupture with probability during a time interval ,where is the kinetic dissociation rate at a distance from the force equilibrium location. Here, is the equilibrium distance of an integrin when it is unstressed (20--30 nm) [@pcbi.1002926-Kanchanawong1], represents the stretched distance from the equilibrium (See [Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}). We utilized the Bell\'s model to run stochastic simulation of bond rupturing and bonding, Bell\'s equation for the kinetic dissociation rate is defined by [@pcbi.1002926-Bell1] where is the kinetic dissociation rate (1 s^−1^) under unstressed conditions with an equilibrium distance , is a force applied to the bond, is the transition distance (0.02 nm), is the Boltzmann constant, and *T* is absolute temperature [@pcbi.1002926-Bell1]. The number of ligand-receptor bonds, i.e. the size of each focal adhesion, can be simulated with these binding and rupture probabilities. Let be the number of ligand-receptor bonds at the *i-th* integrin node, and be the number of ligands on the *j-th* local surface near the *i-th* integrin node. The initial value of is calculated by multiplying and . The number of bonds and available ligands vary stochastically. By drawing a random number, , between 0 and 1: If *P~ran~* ~1~\<, then one bonding occurs, update and . Similarly, the rupture of ligand-receptor bonds can be simulated by drawing a random number, : If *P~ran~* ~2~\<, then one rupture occurs, update and . Above bonding-rupture tests continue in subsequent time until the bond breaks completely (). Once is known, the focal adhesion force of the *i*-th integrin node is computed aswhere is an effective spring constant for a single ligand-receptor bond (∼1 pN/nm) [@pcbi.1002926-Dembo1], and is a unit normal vector representing the *i*-th integrin node\'s direction on the cell membrane (See [Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}). This focal adhesion force acts between the *i*-th integrin node and the point on the ECM surface where the extension of the unit normal vector intersects with the ECM surface. From [Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"} this intersection position, that is, the root location of receptor and ligand bonds (), is given bywhere is the bond length, is the unit normal vector of the ECM surface, and is the gap between the *i*-th integrin node and the ECM surface, as shown in [Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}. These expressions are valid only when and the gap is less than a critical height () of 300 nm (\<10 ): . The latter condition is to restrict the formation of receptor-ligand bonds within the upper limit . Comparison to 2-D cell migration experiments {#s2c} -------------------------------------------- The first set of cell migration simulations was aimed at comparing the integrated model against the experimental data published previously. Palecek et al. [@pcbi.1002926-Palecek1] performed CHO cell migration experiments in 2-D planar plates under various fibronectin coating concentrations. They found that the observed cell migration speed significantly depends on substratum ligand level, cell integrin expression level and integrin--ligand binding affinity. Interestingly, CHO cell migration speed exhibits a biphasic dependence on extracellular-matrix ligand concentration regardless of integrin expression level (the α~5~β~1~ receptor on fibronectin) [@pcbi.1002926-Palecek1]. The simulation results, too, showed similar behaviours of the biphasic dependence on fibronectin coating concentrations. [Figure 3-A](#pcbi-1002926-g003){ref-type="fig"} show samples of trajectories and morphologies of simulated cell migrations along the planar surface of five different fibronectin surface densities of 19.4, 192, 568, 1140 and 1522 molecules µm^−2^ for three hours (see Videos S1, S2, S3, S4 and S5). The ligand densities used for the simulations matched those of the available experiment data; ligand surface densities of fibronectin were converted from fibronectin plate concentrations (µg ml^−2^) using the relationship between plating concentration and ligand surface density of fibronectin [@pcbi.1002926-Rajagopalan1]. First the total path length of each trajectory was obtained and was divided by the travelling time, 3 hours, to obtain the time-averaged cell migration speed. In the experiments, the speed of CHO cell migration was monitored in every 15 minutes, and was time averaged over the entire migration period (12 h) for each of fibronectin concentrations. [Figure 3-B](#pcbi-1002926-g003){ref-type="fig"} compares the average migration speed between the experiment and simulations. Here an error bar indicates a SE (standard error) of means. ![Cell migration along the planar surface of fibronectin.\ A) Simulated trajectories of cell migrations on fibronectin coated substrates under five different ligand surface densities of 19.4, 192, 568, 1140 and 1522 molecules/µm^2^. The black lines indicate trajectories of nuclei for the first three hours, B) comparison of average cell migration speeds: the simulation model vs. experiment data by Palecek *et al.* [@pcbi.1002926-Palecek1]. Average speed and standard error of mean (N = 5) are shown for the five different ligand surface densities, and C). linear regression (R^2^ = 0.767) of simulated migration speed vs. experimental migration speed.](pcbi.1002926.g003){#pcbi-1002926-g003} The experimental data show that the cell migration speed is the lowest when migrating in the lowest ligand density, increases with increasing the ligand density, reaches a maximum value at the ligand density of 1140 molecules µm^−2^, and then decreases as the ligand density becomes too dense ([Figure 3-B](#pcbi-1002926-g003){ref-type="fig"}) [@pcbi.1002926-Palecek1], [@pcbi.1002926-Rajagopalan1]. The simulated cell migration speed, too, shows a trend similar to the experiments: slow for a very low ligand density, the fastest at the particular ligand density of 1140 molecules µm^−2^, then slower again for the highest simulated ligand density. Both experiments and simulations attain the fastest speed at the particular ligand density of 1140 molecules µm^−2^. Overall both the simulation and experiment show an excellent agreement over the ligand density range of 10∼1500 \[molecules µm^−2^\]. Statistical analysis of linear regression was performed by comparing the experiment and the simulation in terms of the mean values of time-averaged cell migration speed for the same ligand density. As shown in [Figure 3-C](#pcbi-1002926-g003){ref-type="fig"}, good correlations were found between the two with *R* ^2^ = 0.767. Therefore, the model validates and, in turn, is validated by showing that cell migration speeds are strongly dependent on ligand density. Comparison to 2-D cell spreading experiments {#s2d} -------------------------------------------- The second set of cell spreading simulation was intended to compare the integrated model against the recent experimental data published by Tseng *et al.* [@pcbi.1002926-Tseng1]. They developed a method to micropattern ECM proteins on poly-acrylamide gels in order to impinge on cell morphology and mechanics simultaneously, and have reported that measured traction forces differ considerably depending on the shape of micropatterns. In particular, in the case of the crossbow shaped micropatterns, concentrated cell traction forces are repeatedly located in the bottom part of the vertical bar. The simulation of the integrated model also showed similar spreading cell morphologies on micropatterned models and traction force distributions on the cell surface ([Figure 4-A, B and C](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}). {#pcbi-1002926-g004} [Figure 4](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"} shows spreading cell morphologies with traction force contours and oriented SFs on three micropatterned geometries (a disk, a "pacman" shape, and a crossbow shape), after 60 minutes of spreading time for all shapes (see Videos S6, S7 and S8). Initially, all cell models start spreading from a spherical shape. The dimensions of micropatterns used for the simulations matches those of experiments for quantitative comparisons regarding contour plots of traction forces (or ) and spatial distributions of SFs inside of the cell; we obtained traction stress per a cell (unit: Pa) by dividing summations of tangential component of at *i*-th integrin node by a total area of ventral cell surface where focal adhesions are formed ([Figure 4-D and E](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}). Outside of the micropatterns, it was assumed that the ligand density was zero such that focal adhesion and lamellipodia protrusive forces only existed within the micropatterns. Both experiments and simulations reveal similar trends in terms of concentrated traction forces on local areas of the ventral cell surface ([Figure 4-A, B and C](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}) as well as the order of higher traction stress per a cell among the three micropatterns ([Figure 4-D and E](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}). For the disk shaped micropattern, a few concentrated traction stress areas were observed at the ridge of the disk ([Figure 4-A](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}, two yellow circles). However, locations of concentrated traction forces on the disk shaped micropattern stochastically varied with time (see Video S6). This time-varying inconsistent distribution of stress on the pattern may be due to the smooth ridge of the shape, which gives a short length of receptor-ligand bonds such that the traction energy dissipates quickly. In the case of the "pacman" shaped micropattern, two sites of concentrated traction stress ([Figure 4-B](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}, two yellow circles) with SFs connected to the nucleus ([Figure 4-B](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}, black arrows a, b) and an oriented ventral SF was observed in between the sharp edges of the "pacman" mouth, as seen in experimental observations ([Figure 4-B](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}, black arrow **c**) although additional concentrated traction forces were located in the smooth ridge of the shape like the disk shaped micropattern. Interestingly, this behaviour was visualized to be persistent over time (see Video S7). In the case of the crossbow shaped micropattern, ventral SFs were aligned along the top roof and the bottom bar, as seen in experimental observations ([Figure 4-C](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}, black arrows e, f, g, h), and three sites of concentrated traction stress were observed at right and left end tips of the top roof and a bottom part of the vertical bar ([Figure 4-C](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}, three yellow circles). In addition, the strongest traction stress resulted from the contractile activity of SFs ([Figure 4-C](#pcbi-1002926-g004){ref-type="fig"}, black arrow d) at the bottom part of the vertical bar. As the activity of actin SFs are stronger, the length of receptor-ligand bonds is stretched more at the leading edge, which results in stronger traction stress. The animation of cell spreading simulation on the crossbow shaped micropattern, too, shows concentrated traction force at theses three sites (see Video S8). Since a cell tends to migrate toward the stiffer gel region from the more compliant one [@pcbi.1002926-Schwarz1], the cell may sense locally increased tension at the sharp edge of the micropatterns as the fibronectin bundles are anchored to the plate [@pcbi.1002926-Khatau1]. Thereby, larger areas of FAs are formed at the corners of the micropatterns while smaller areas of FAs are observed at the round boundary. From the agreement between simulation and experimental results on these micropatterned shapes, the model validates and, in turn, is validated by showing persistent high stress concentrations at sharp geometrically patterned edges. Discussion {#s3} ========== Coupling of focal adhesion dynamics and motor activity {#s3a} ------------------------------------------------------ It has been reported that nascent adhesions (smaller than ∼0.25 µm) initiate the adhesion of protrusions of the leading edge of the cell, followed by the disassembly of a subpopulation of nascent adhesions within a minute and growth of the remainder into focal complexes (∼0.5 µm in size) and then focal adhesions (1--5 µm in size) within 5 minutes [@pcbi.1002926-Choi1]. Afterwards, focal adhesions either disassemble or mature within the ventral surface of the cell membrane within 10--20 minutes [@pcbi.1002926-Gupton1], [@pcbi.1002926-Gardel1]. Furthermore, it is known that the maturation and turnover of focal adhesions involves protein recruitment and elongation, followed by protein disengagement and shrinkage [@pcbi.1002926-Gardel1]. In the current integrative cell migration model, the disengagement of actin stress fibers from integrins bound to the ECM is assumed to occur when a force-transmitting structural linkage ruptures ( = 0) (see [Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}). With the onset of motor activity after actin polymerization, the generated force is transmitted to the focal adhesions, and receptor-ligand bonds at the focal adhesions are subsequently stretched, resulting in an increases in both traction force and rupture probability for a receptor-ligand bond according to Bell\'s law [@pcbi.1002926-Bell1]. As shown in [Figure 5-A](#pcbi-1002926-g005){ref-type="fig"}, the situation differs at the leading and trailing edges, in large part due to the location of the nucleus closer to the rear of the cell. Note that the angle between the inclined stress fiber and the horizontal plane of the substrate at the trailing edge is higher than that at the leading edge of the cell. If we assume that the stress fibers all exert comparable levels of force then the normal force component will be larger at the trailing edge and therefore have a higher probability of rupture, thereby allowing forward motion of the cell. To test this hypothesis, 266 stress fibers connected to the nucleus at the leading edge and 245 stress fibers connected to the nucleus at the trailing edge were monitored and statistically analysed during three hours of simulated cell migration on the plate with fibronectin density of 200 molecules/µm^2^ ([Figure 5-A](#pcbi-1002926-g005){ref-type="fig"}, Video S9). Consistent with this hypothesis, we found the lifetime of stress fibers at the trailing edge to be less than that at the leading edge of the cell; 32.00±2.78 s at the leading edge and 24.92±2.17 s at the trailing edge ([Figure 5-B](#pcbi-1002926-g005){ref-type="fig"}). Therefore, we propose that increased magnitude of normal force on the adhesion site at the trailing edge plays a key role in accelerating the rupture of receptor-ligand bonds, leading to an increase in cell migration speed. {#pcbi-1002926-g005} Lifetime of actin stress fiber {#s3b} ------------------------------ Our modelled stress fiber lifetime physically represents a contractile SF period which is related with the turnover time of the three main dynamic components consisting of SF-actin, alpha-actinin, and myosin. However, it should be noted that there is total lifetime of stress fiber which includes multiple periods of the lifetime of its constituent until it fully disappears. Recently, Hotulainen and Lappalainen [@pcbi.1002926-Hatulainen1] have observed highly dynamic associations and dissociations of these components in the SF by FRAP analysis. They found recovery times for actin, alpha-actinin, and myosin light chain (MLC) in bleached regions of the SF were 323 s, 123 s, and 223 s, respectively (see fig 7A in [@pcbi.1002926-Hatulainen1]). Interestingly, all components of the SF (see fig. 7A in [@pcbi.1002926-Hatulainen1], white boxes) disappeared at the time of +4 s (depolymerization occurs) after SF\'s contractile motion got started at the time of −20 s. Thus, it seems to us that this time period of 24 s may be related with contractile period of the SF among full periods of the SF (actin polymerization, SF contractile motion, and actin depolymerization). Additionally, time periods for actin polymerization and actin depolymerization in our model were set to be 180 s and 1--5 s, respectively, and time period for SF contractile motion in the model was determined to be ∼30 s. Summation over the full period yields ∼215 s, which is within a similar range of the recovery times for the three main components of a SF. It should be noted that most nonmotile cell types contain thick, non-dynamic stress fibers, whereas most motile cell types contain very few and thin stress fibers [@pcbi.1002926-Hatulainen1] or few and large stress fibers on the soft substrata [@pcbi.1002926-Pelham1]. In case of nonmotile cells, most SFs are known to form at the ventral surface of the cell, and its movements are very slow. However, in case of motile cells, it is possible to assemble ventral SFs by the interaction with preassembled dorsal SFs and transverse arcs within the period of 27 min (see fig.5 in [@pcbi.1002926-Hatulainen1]). During the course of the assembly of ventral SF in motile cells, three major processes (actin polymerization, SF contractile motion, and actin depolymerization) are periodically repeated due to the turnover of actin in either dorsal SF or transverse arcs and SFs\' alignments were dynamically varied due to actin motor activity. Thus, it should be emphasized that there exist three main highly dynamic processes of the SF. In addition, it has been known that rapid SF depolymerization occur because of cell shortening [@pcbi.1002926-Sato1] or SF detachment via localized application of trypsin at focal adhesions [@pcbi.1002926-Sato2], [@pcbi.1002926-Deguchi1]. Note that for the sake of video visualization of the processes of actin polymerization and bundling, the frame-to-frame time scale is 360 s while the simulation time step used is 0.001--0.01 s. Because the frame rate is greater than the SFs dynamic period (∼215 s), the simulated SF dynamics may appear discontinuous, when they are, in fact, not. What is important to maximum cell migration speed? {#s3c} -------------------------------------------------- Although there are differences in cell migration speeds between the model and experiment, we are interested in similar trends across a range of the ligand density, and linear regression between the cell migration speed of both the model and experiment with identical ligand density confirms good agreement between the model and experimental data. Additionally, we also simulated cell migration models in which SFs are disconnected from the nuclear membrane on the substrates under five ligand surface densities ([Figure S4](#pcbi.1002926.s004){ref-type="supplementary-material"}), which resulted in lower cell migration speed than cell migration model with SFs connected to the nuclear membrane ([Figure 3-B](#pcbi-1002926-g003){ref-type="fig"}). Thus, our simulated results reveal that these SFs connected to the nucleus play an important role in cell migration. In the literature [@pcbi.1002926-Chancellor1], the authors also demonstrated that nesprin-1 depleted endothelial cells showed decreased migration speed with no SFs connected to the nuclear membrane. Furthermore, Khatau, *et al.* [@pcbi.1002926-Khatau1] highlighted the interplay between cell shape, nuclear shape, and cell adhesion mediated by the perinuclear actin cap. We also found that the cell migration speed is limited by ligand density and integrin density ([Figure S5](#pcbi.1002926.s005){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). They work together to promote adhesion of the cell, and in turn, cell speed. This example shows how either value alone is enough to act as a bottle neck and limit the migration speed. If the ligand density is high (950 molecules/µm^2^), but the integrin density is insufficient (≤137 molecules/µm^2^), the cell speed will be limited. Similarly, if the integrin density is high (205 molecules/µm^2^) but the ligand density is insufficient (200 molecules/µm^2^), then the migration speed is again limited ([Figure S5](#pcbi.1002926.s005){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). We believe that the integration of focal adhesion dynamics (receptor-ligand bonds) and actin motor activity is important to observe and predict maximum cell migration speeds. In addition, as cell\'s contacting area on the substrate becomes larger, the numbers of focal adhesion sites such that ventral SFs anchored at FAs is increased. That is to say, two resultant forces from focal adhesions and actin SFs are increased and they are important to capture the maximum cell migration speed dependent on substrate geometry as well as ligand surface density. [Figure 6-A](#pcbi-1002926-g006){ref-type="fig"} shows samples of trajectories and morphologies of simulated cell migrations along the planar surface of fibronectin surface density of 1140 molecules/µm^2^ for three hours under nine different cases of polymerization times with 60, 180, and 300 s (rows) and depolymerization times with 1, 10, and 30 s (columns). First, simulated data were compared with different depolymerization times for the three values (rows) of polymerization times of 60, 180, and 300 s. Cell migration speed at each value (row) of polymerization time increases as the depolymerization time becomes larger ([Figure 6-B](#pcbi-1002926-g006){ref-type="fig"}). In the case of the polymerization time of 60 s, especially, the morphologies of cells were observed to be round. This phenomenon results from faster actin motor activity with the inclusion of a shorter polymerization process. Thereby, the occurrence of more frequent actin motor activity prevents the cell from stretching more than the other cases of polymerization times of 180 and 300 s. On the other hand, as the polymerization time becomes larger, the cell tends to stretch more and its morphology is changed to wider crescent-shape from the rounded shape. Next, simulated data were compared with different polymerization times for three values (columns) of depolymerization times of 1, 10, and 30 s ([Figure 6-B](#pcbi-1002926-g006){ref-type="fig"}). As for cases of depolymerization times of 1 and 10 s, cell migration speed increases as polymerization time decreases. In our model, a shorter polymerization process represents faster FA component (integrin and vinculin) renewal within FAs due to increased level of myosin II activation per FA. Contraction could pull these components out of FAs. It has been reported that faster turnover rates of vinculin and integrin due to further increase in actomyosin contractility are correlated with faster cell migration speed at the intermediated ligand surface density [@pcbi.1002926-Gupton1]. However, in case of depolymerization time of 30 s, cell migration speed takes a maximum at an intermediated value of polymerization time of 180 s, which suggest that a balance between adhesion strength and myosin II activity is required for optimal cell migration [@pcbi.1002926-Gupton1]. {#pcbi-1002926-g006} Model {#s4} ===== Membrane stiffness and elastic forces {#s4a} ------------------------------------- The elastic forces, and , are obtained by using the virtual work theory in structural mechanics. To this end, the elastic energy stored in the cell and nucleus membranes are obtained. Two types of elastic energy are considered. One is the elastic energy associated with distance changes between surface nodes [@pcbi.1002926-Tsubota1], [@pcbi.1002926-Tsubota2]: where is the length of the *i*-th line of the cell membrane mesh, and is that of the nucleus. Both are updated at every time-step. and are their relaxed (zero force) lengths. and are effective stiffness constants of the line elements of the cell membrane (5.0×10^−5^ N/m) [@pcbi.1002926-Drury1], [@pcbi.1002926-Honarmandi1] and nucleus (5.0×10^−3^ N/m) [@pcbi.1002926-Zeng1], respectively. Similarly, the elastic energy associated with area changes is given by where is the *i*-th mesh area of the cell membrane and is that of the nucleus. and are their relaxed values. Parameters and are effective stiffness constants of area elements of the cell membrane (1.0×10^−4^ N/m^2^) and nucleus (1.0×10^−4^ N/m^2^), respectively [@pcbi.1002926-Tsubota2]. Elastic forces and can be obtained by differentiating the total energy, where and indicate total stored energies of the cell membrane and nucleus, respectively, and , , and are obtained analytically. Actin motor activity {#s4b} -------------------- An actin SF is a bundle of actin microfilaments assembled by actin-myosin II interactions. It is known that at least one end of each SF is connected to focal adhesion molecules, such as vinculin, talin, paxillin, zyxin, and FAK [@pcbi.1002926-Kanchanawong1], and the other end of a SF can be connected to the nuclear membrane [@pcbi.1002926-Chancellor1], transmitting a force to the nucleus. In the model, the *i*-th integrin node is connected to the *j*-th nuclear node by a SF. Its connection to the *j*-th nuclear node is determined by the nearest distance from the *i*-th integrin node to the nucleus. In addition, the *i*-th integrin node is connected to the *k*-th integrin node by a ventral SF. To consider the alignment of the ventral SF which is preferentially parallel to the stronger elastic resistance direction [@pcbi.1002926-Schwarz1], [@pcbi.1002926-Borau1], its connection to the *j*-th integrin node is established by the lower principal direction of Lagrange strain tensor [@pcbi.1002926-Bower1] at the cortical surface bound to the *i*-th integrin node. The stiffness of a SF is variable. According to the literature, the stiffness increases with a contractile agonist (histamine) and decreases with a relaxing agonist (isoproterenol) [@pcbi.1002926-Wang1]. These characteristics must be reflected in the formulation of the SF stiffness:where is Young\'s modulus of SFs (230 kPa) directly measured from isolated smooth muscle cells [@pcbi.1002926-Deguchi2], is the average cross-sectional area of SFs (250 nm in radius [@pcbi.1002926-Lu1]), and is the length of a single compartment of the *i*-th SF. As shown in [Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}, a SF consists of contractile compartments, each of which consists of two half 'I bands' (F-actin filaments) and an 'A band' (myosin II) in F-actin filaments [@pcbi.1002926-Ruppel1], [@pcbi.1002926-Golomb1]. represents the unstressed length of the *i*-th contractile compartment, which slides at a rate at both ends. Therefore, where [equation (17b)](#pcbi.1002926.e137){ref-type="disp-formula"} is the discretized form of [equation (17a)](#pcbi.1002926.e136){ref-type="disp-formula"}, and indicates the length of a single unit of the *i*-th SF at the previous time (*t*−) [@pcbi.1002926-Lodish1]. Similarly, the elastic energy stored in the *i*-th SF is given bywhere is the number of contractile compartments in the *i*-th SF, represents the distance between *i*-th integrin and *j*-th nuclear nodes for a SF connected to the nucleus or between *i*-th integrin and *j*-th integrin nodes for a ventral SF. It should be noted that physically means the length of SFs under tension and represents the length of a single unstressed bundle of SFs (See [Figure 2-B](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}). Using the virtual work theory, forces due to actin SFs\' motor activity at the *i*-th integrin and *j*-th nuclear nodes or at *i*-th integrin and *j*-th integrin nodes (ventral SFs) are given by These forces are generated when focal adhesions have been formed and F-actin filaments are fully polymerized. It has been known that SF assembly occurs over several minutes [@pcbi.1002926-Kaunas2]--[@pcbi.1002926-Ridley1], but SF disassembles rapidly within seconds [@pcbi.1002926-Costa1]--[@pcbi.1002926-Kumar1]. In addition, it takes several minutes to form FAs from focal complexes (FCs). These observations suggest that myosin motor activities in SFs are switched off during the remodelling of the actin cytoskeleton (polymerization) and SF turnover. In our simulations, time for full formation of F-actin is set to be 180 s, and time for the complete disassembly of F-actin is set to 1 s, based on the above reference information. Actin motor activity is assumed not to start until the other end of a SF is connected to the nucleus. Time for polymerization of F-actin appears to be the waiting time before actin motor activity takes place, during which time an adhesion complex (AC) becomes a fully developed FA. The myosin II\'s sliding rate is known to fluctuate (i.e. is non-uniform) unlike myosin I which slides with a uniform rate. Furthermore, the sliding rate of myosin II is adjusted by sensing the transmitted focal adhesion force from the ECM [@pcbi.1002926-Walcott1]. To incorporate these characteristics into the model, force-velocity relation of muscle myosin II, first proposed by A.V. Hill [@pcbi.1002926-Hill1], is adopted as the following equation:where is the sliding rate of myosin in the absence of load (10 nm/s) [@pcbi.1002926-Lodish1], is the isometric force of myosin, or stall force, and is a parameter for the force-velocity relationship for myosin. Initially, the length of sarcomere unit is 800 nm ( = 800 nm at *t* = 0 s), which contracts until 60% of the initial length has contracted. As the contraction takes place at both sides of each sarcomere unit, the minimum time required for 60% contraction is calculated as 16 s with . Furthermore, an additional condition for terminating actin motor activity is also considered when integrin nodes are broken from FA formations. Afterwards, the depolymerization of actin SFs occurs in 1 s. During this period, formations of nascent ACs are inhibited. In summary, actin motor activity consists of three evolving periods, polymerization (180 s), motor activity (\>16 s) and depolymerization (1 s) [@pcbi.1002926-Kaunas2]--[@pcbi.1002926-Kumar1]. Lamellipodium force {#s4c} ------------------- Lamellipodium force is a characteristic feature at the leading edge of migratory cells. It is believed to be the motor which push the cortical cytoskeleton forward during the process of cell migration. Normally, cells experience a small protrusive pressure that results from osmotic pressure or actin branches stimulated by activated arp2/3 [@pcbi.1002926-Jeon1]. Recently, time-averaged high protrusive force measured per pillar was 800 pN for NIH 3T3 fibroblasts and diseased cells [@pcbi.1002926-Mathur1]. Here, we assume lamellipodium protrusive force is due to constant actin polymerization rate [@pcbi.1002926-Kabaso1]. Thereby, we approximate the magnitude of the lamellipodium force at the *i*-th integrin node () is constant at 300 pN and exists at only leading edges of the cell. It should be noted that the magnitude of net force at the *i*-th integrin node is non-uniform because it is a vectorial sum of and the local membrane restoring forces from neighboring nodes. Numerical methods of "integrated cell migration model" {#s4d} ------------------------------------------------------ Cell migration simulations were carried out using a fourth order Rosenbrock method [@pcbi.1002926-Press1] based on an adaptive time-stepping technique for integrating ordinary differential equations with the convergence criterion \<10^−4^. The ordinary differential equations were solved for the 6×*N* (*N* = 549 for both cell migration and spreading simulations) unknown variables associated with the mesh node position vectors for both cell membrane and nucleus membrane: (see [Figure 2-A](#pcbi-1002926-g002){ref-type="fig"}). For cell migration simulation the Rosenbrock method outperforms the standard Runge--Kutta method which requires a relatively large number of iterations [@pcbi.1002926-Press1]. Furthermore, the Rosenbrock method consumes less computing time by using adaptive time-step control that ranges from 10^−3^ s to 10^−2^ s in the present work. Thus, it is suitable for simulating transient cell migratory behaviours over 10 hours. The focal adhesion dynamics were computed based on the Monte-Carlo simulation. The model assumes a total of 164,700 integrin molecules on the cell membrane [@pcbi.1002926-Moore1] and 549 integrin nodes for both cell migration and spreading models with a cell radius of 8 µm. Therefore, the density of receptors over the cell membrane is 300 integrins/node for both models, among which some fraction of integrins bond to ligands; the number of ligand-receptor bonds varies stochastically in the range . Recall that is determined by drawing random numbers and and simulating binding and rupturing events stochastically using Bell\'s equation. Additionally, each integrin node represents a collection of integrins having the collective stiffness for receptor-ligand bonds (see [equation (11)](#pcbi.1002926.e082){ref-type="disp-formula"}). The elastic force at the *i*-th node represents the resultant force acting on the *i*-th node that is calculated by vectorial addition of elastic forces from neighbouring nodes. To compute this, first the coordinates of each node are updated in each time cycle, and distances from each node to neighbouring nodes are computed along with the areas of the surrounding rectangles. The elastic forces are derived from these distances and areas for individual nodes. The methods for building geometrical models for the simulation of cell migration have been well documented in the literatures [@pcbi.1002926-Kim2], [@pcbi.1002926-Kim3]. See also geometrical models of micropatterns, as shown in [Figure S3](#pcbi.1002926.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. One practical issue in computing finite mesh geometric models is to check geometrical compatibility. As the coordinates of cell membrane and nuclear nodes are updated based on the equations of motion, geometrically incompatible situations occur occasionally in the configurations of the cell membrane mesh and that of the nucleus in relation to the curved ECM surface. For example, some cell membrane nodes intersect with the substrate, and the nucleus intersects with the cell membrane. These incompatible situations must be checked in every computational cycle, and necessary corrections must be made. Supporting Information {#s5} ====================== ###### Schematics of A) 2-D cell migration in planar surface, B) 2-D cell migration and spreading on a micropatterned structure, C) 3-D cell migration in a rectangular channel and D) 3-D cell migration in 3-D ECM. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Samples of A) cell migration speed and B) cell migration acceleration for three hours. Blue lines indicate time-averaged cell migration speed and acceleration of 4.24 nm/s and 3.18×10^−4^ nm/s^2^, respectively. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Meshes of three micropattern models of A) disk, B) pacman and C) crossbow shapes; all meshes have triangular elements with approximate side lengths of 0.75 µm. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Comparison of average cell migration speeds: cell migration model with SFs connected to the nuclear membrane vs. cell migration model with SFs disconnected to the nuclear membrane. Average speed and standard error of mean (N = 5) are shown for the five different ligand surface densities. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Comparisons of average cell migration speeds: cell migration model with four different integrin densities of 34, 68, 137, and 205 molecules/µm^2^ on the cell surface on two different low and high ligand surface densities of 200 and 950 molecules/µm^2^. Average speed and standard error of mean (N = 5) are shown for the four different integrin surface densities and two ligand surface densities. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Why the net force is zero in a dynamic moving system? (DOCX) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell migration on the plate with the ligand density of 19.4 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers, and black line indicates a trajectory of nuclear center. Six seconds of the video represents three hours. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell migration on the plate with the ligand density of 192 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers, and a black line indicates a trajectory of the nucleus center. Six seconds of the video represents three hours. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell migration on the plate with the ligand density of 568 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers, and a black line indicates a trajectory of the nucleus center. Six seconds of the video represents three hours. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell migration on the plate with the ligand density of 1040 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers, and a black line indicates a trajectory of nucleus center. Six seconds of the video represents three hours. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell migration on the plate with the ligand density of 1522 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers, and a black line indicates a trajectory of nucleus center. Six seconds of the video represents three hours. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell spreading on the disk shaped micropattern with the ligand density of 475 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers, and contours indicate traction forces on the ventral surface of cell membrane. Twelve seconds of the video represents sixty minutes. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell spreading on the pacman shaped micropattern with the ligand density of 475 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers, and contours indicate traction forces on the ventral surface of cell membrane. Twelve seconds of the video represents sixty minutes. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell spreading on the crossbow shaped micropattern with the ligand density of 475 molecules/µm2. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red in the cell lines indicate actin stress fibers, and contours indicate traction forces on the ventral surface of cell membrane. Twelve seconds of the video represents sixty minutes. (AVI) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Example of a simulated cell migration on the plate with the ligand density of 200 molecules/µm^2^. Cell and nuclear membranes are visualised with green and blue, respectively. Bold red lines in the cell indicate actin stress fibers. Twenty seconds of the video represents three hours. (WMV) ###### Click here for additional data file. MCK specifically acknowledges the assistance of Joo-Siong Sim for his help using high performance computing facilities. [^1]: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. [^2]: Analyzed the data: MCK DMN RDK HHA. Wrote the paper: MCK DMN RDK HHA. Built a code for the model: MCK. Performed the simulations: MCK DMN. Conceived and designed the experiments: MCK DMN RDK HHA.

\section{Introduction} Reducing optical losses is of paramount importance for further developing photovoltaic (PV) devices. This holds especially true for the market-dominating single-junction c-Si solar cells, for which optical losses constitute one of the main limitations to reach their efficiency limit~\cite{shockley_detailed_nodate,richter_n-type_2017}. While a common approach involves employing various uniform anti-reflective (AR) coatings combined with a chemical texturing of the c-Si wafer, resulting in the formation of micron-sized pyramidal features~\cite{seidel_anisotropic_1990}, in some cases, alternative approaches to suppress the optical losses are needed. For example, in industrial solar cells, the micron-sized textures are realized on relatively thick c-Si wafers, with a current standard of 160~$\mu$m. However, a transition to the wafer thickness below the standard value and switching to the foil-like thinner c-Si can allow for lower material consumption. This can reduce the manufacturing cost and facilitate the acceleration of the expansion of PV manufacturing~\cite{liu_revisiting_2020} to keep up with estimates for global installed PV capacity~\cite{haegel_terawatt-scale_2019}. However, for such thin devices, the use of micron-sized textures becomes very challenging due to c-Si wafer handling issues, and novel approaches have to be identified to reduce the optical losses. In response to that need, various nanophotonic concepts~\cite{garnett_photonics_2021} applicable to c-Si-based solar cell stacks were proposed to enhance light harvesting through improved light in-coupling on the front surface. Examples of possible solutions include plasmonic structures~\cite{green_harnessing_2012,Catchpole:08,doi:10.1021/nl8022548}, periodically arranged silicon~\cite{hou_efficient_2020,he_enhanced_2016} and dielectric~\cite{spinelli_effect_2015, saive2020, spinelli_broadband_2012} nanoscatterers, and biomimetic structures~\cite{hou_biomimetic_2017}. Moreover, double-sided AR and light trapping (LT) nanostructure gratings introduced at the front and rear sides of the solar cells were also suggested. For example, such a concept was investigated for thin-film c-Si~\cite{wang_absorption_2012} and thin-film hydrogenated nanocrystalline silicon (nc-Si:H)~\cite{isabella_advanced_2018} solar cells. Nevertheless, while a plethora of nanophotonic structures was proposed and investigated in recent years, it is of paramount importance to analyze their performance in a full solar module architecture under realistic irradiation conditions. For example, such analysis was performed for different solar module architectures where sufficient optical properties were achieved using strategies involving textured interfaces and/or flat ARCs~\cite{singh_comparing_2021,C7EE01232B,tucher_energy_2019, lehr_energy_2020,gota2020energy,jovst2018textured}. Since the solar cell is not always illuminated with light at normal incidence in the realistic scenario, one has to go beyond the analysis of the ability of the structure to enhance the short-circuit current density under the standard test conditions and ensure that the proposed AR and/or LT nanostructure designs are robust concerning irradiation impinging on the solar module at increasing angles of incidence. Additionally, the absorption of photons by the solar cell absorber depends on the sun's position. It is influenced by the cloud coverage effect on irradiation received by the module and the module orientation. For solar cells with double-sided photonic nanostructures, it is also appealing to consider and assess the possible power output of the solar modules with nanostructured solar cells in the case of a bifacial module architecture. This module configuration allows for harvesting the photons that can be absorbed when the sunlight either hits the module from its back or is reflected from the ground and can be absorbed in the solar cell. Here, we study the energy yield of relatively thin wafer-based c-Si solar modules, for which the solar cell stack is coated with double-sided nanostructure gratings. Suitably designed square arrays of dielectric high-index TiO$_2$ nanodisks are used as AR and LT photonic nanostructures. Their geometrical parameters are subject to optimization. Results are compared to modules containing more traditional planar thin-film anti-reflective layers. We consider mono- and bifacial modules and introduce the nanodisk array on the front surface of the c-Si-based heterojunction (HJT) solar cell for the former module configuration and both the front and rear side for the latter. The nanodisk arrays are initially optimized at normal incident light by full-wave optical simulations concerning the short-circuit current associated with the reflected portion of the light (details in Sec. \textbf{Calculation of reflectance, transmittance, and absorptance}~\ref{sec:calc}). The optimal design of these nanodisk arrays depends on whether they are employed on the front side, where they serve the purpose of suppressing reflectance, or on the rear side, where they facilitate the light trapping. Therefore, when optimizing the nanodisk arrays, different designs are found depending on the mechanisms through which they contribute to enhancing the absorptance in the c-Si wafer. To estimate the annual energy yield (EY) of the solar module architectures with nanodisk arrays, the optical response from the optimized nanodisk arrays when placed on the front and rear solar cell contact layers is simulated using full-wave optical tools depending on the angle of incidence. This is the primary information fueled afterward into the EY modeling framework. The annual EY is assessed for monofacial and bifacial module architectures with and without TiO$_2$ nanodisk arrays at locations with different climate conditions. The influence of albedo radiation is also considered, which is especially relevant to consider in bifacial module configuration~\cite{russell_influence_2017}. Our key contribution is to show that for the wafer-based c-Si cells with thicknesses for which standard chemical texturing becomes impractical, and alternative AR and LT structures are of interest, the nanodisk arrays that we suggest outperform to a considerable extent the traditional design that relies only on the planar anti-reflective coatings. In passing, we note that the design of the nanodisk arrays for front and rear solar cell contacts proposed here is exemplary, and it is neither restricted to a particular solar cell stack nor the materials used. \section{Module architectures and numerical methods}\label{methods} \subsection{Investigated module architectures and material properties} The four different architectures studied in this contribution are schematically depicted in Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic}. The annual EY calculations were performed for two reference monofacial and bifacial module configurations and two configurations with AR and LT nanodisk arrays introduced on top of the front and rear ITO contact layers, respectively. The c-Si absorber thickness of all architectures was varied between 5 and 80~$\mu$m, which is a typical thickness range between thin PV and conventional wafer-based c-Si PV. \begin{figure}[h] \centering \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{Figure1.pdf} \caption{Schematic representation of the four solar module architectures discussed in this paper: (a) Monofacial standard reference module with optimized transparent conductive ITO layer on the front, serving as both anti-reflective coating and front contact, and silver back contact. Front ITO layer is preceded with window glass and encapsulation (EVA) layers covered with an anti-reflective coating. For all considered solar module configurations, the window layers are identical. (b) Monofacial module with optimized anti-reflective nanodisk array on top of the front ITO contact, and silver back contact. (c) Bifacial standard reference module with front and rear ITO contacts with symmetric window layers on both sides of the solar module. (d) Bifacial module with optimized anti-reflective and light trapping nanodisk arrays on top of the front and rear ITO contacts with symmetric window layers on both sides of the solar module, respectively.} \label{fig:schematic} \end{figure} In the case of flat reference c-Si HJT solar cell stacks, the front hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) (passivation intrinsic and n$^{+}$ doped, the thickness can be found in~\cite{slivina_insights_2019}) and conducting ITO (75~nm) layers were considered. For the rear side of the HJT solar cell stack, the a-Si:H (passivation intrinsic and p$^{+}$ doped) layer was slightly thicker than the a-Si:H layer on the front, while the ITO layer was thinner than its counterpart on the front side. The configurations containing optimized AR nanodisk array had a reduced front ITO thickness of 10~nm with TiO$_2$ nanodisks arranged in a square lattice of 320~nm pitch, with individual nanodisk having a radius of 125~nm and a height of 90~nm. The bifacial module configuration with added optimized LT TiO$_2$ nanodisk square array (individual nanodisk with a radius of 215~nm and height of 395~nm, 565~nm pitch) had the same rear ITO thickness as the reference architectures. These values for the geometrical parameters are the results of an optimization of the AR and LT nanodisk arrays discussed in Sec. \textbf{Calculation of reflectance, transmittance, and absorptance}~\ref{sec:calc}. In the case of the monofacial modules, HJT c-Si solar cell had 300~nm thick silver back contact while the front side contacting metallic grid and its effect on the optical performance of the module is neglected. The window module layers comprise encapsulating EVA (400~$\mu$m) and glass (4~mm) with thin-film anti-reflective MgF$_2$ coating (130~nm). In the case of the bifacial architecture, the rear side of the solar cell typically has the same contacting scheme as the front side (no conformal metallic layer). The modules in the bifacial configuration were considered to have the same window layers as the ones introduced on the front side. In such a configuration, the module can absorb the light that is incident on its front and from its rear side. Additionally, one can harvest albedo radiation since the transmitted portion of the light is reflected from the ground, and thus, can be reabsorbed in the silicon, significantly boosting the annual EY. When a bifacial solar module is tilted, albedo radiation can also impact the annual EY due to the light reflected from the ground and incident of the front of the module. We note that when a monofacial solar module is tilted, albedo radiation that is incident on the front of the module can also be considered. Refractive indices of c-Si, TiO$_2$, ITO, and Ag used in the calculations were taken from literature~\cite{schinke_uncertainty_2015,Rutile,holman_infrared_2013,jiang_realistic_2016}. Refractive index data for the front and rear composite (passivation intrinsic and doped) a-Si:H layers were obtained using ellipsometry, and corresponding $n$ and $k$ values provided by Meyer Burger Research AG are plotted in Fig.~\ref{fig:indices}. For the window layers, a non-absorbing optically thick glass layer was considered to have a nondispersive refractive index of $n=1.5$, and EVA and MgF$_2$ refractive index data was taken from~\cite{mcintosh_optical_2009} and~\cite{siqueiros_determination_1988}, respectively. \begin{figure}[h] \centering \includegraphics[width=7cm]{Figure2.pdf} \caption{Refractive index $n$ and extinction coefficient $k$ of a-Si:H composite layers. The measured data was fitted to a Tauc-Lorentz model. } \label{fig:indices} \end{figure} \subsection{Simulation framework} The numerical simulations of the EVA-cell interface for both AR and LT TiO$_2$ nanodisk arrays were performed using the finite element method (FEM) with commercial software \textit{JCMsuite}~\cite{pomplun2007adaptive}. The annual EY was calculated using a comprehensive modeling framework enabling the quick simulation of various and sophisticated PV architectures under realistic irradiation conditions discussed in detail in~\cite{schmager_methodology_2019,GithubEY}. \subsection{Electrical parameters} The electrical parameters corresponding to a typical c-Si HJT solar cell used in the annual EY calculation are summarized in Table~\ref{tab:electric}. The shadowing by electrical connections for all considered architectures is disregarded. \begin{table}[h] \centering \caption {Electrical parameters of the solar cell} \label{tab:electric} \begin{tabular}{c c} \hline Shunt resistance, $R_{\text{sh}}$ [$\Omega\cdot\text{cm}^2$] & 5000 \\ Series resistance, $R_{\text{s}}$ [$\Omega\cdot\text{cm}^2$] & 0.7 \\ Reverse-blocking current, $J_{\text{0}}$ [$\text{A}/\text{cm}^2$] & 2$\cdot10^{-13}$ \\ Ideality factor, $n$ & 1.1 \\ Temperature coefficient of $J_{\text{SC}}$, $t_{J_{\text{SC}}}$ [$\%/\text{K}$] & 0.05 \\ Temperature coefficient of $V_{\text{OC}}$, $t_{V_{\text{OC}}}$ [$\%/\text{K}$] & -0.25 \\ \hline \end{tabular} \end{table} A device characterized by these properties would have a $J_{\text{SC}}$ around 38.3~mA/cm$^2$. This yields $V_{\text{OC}}=0.734$~V at temperature $\text{T}=25^\circ$C from the following equation: \begin{equation}\label{Voc_RT} V_{\text{OC}}=nV_\text{th}\text{ln}\left(\frac{J_{\text{SC}}}{J_{\text{0}}}+1\right), \end{equation} where the thermal voltage $V_\text{th}=kT/q=0.0257$~V, and the values of ideality factor and reverse-blocking current can be found in Table~\ref{tab:electric}. \subsection{Calculation of reflectance, transmittance, and absorptance}\label{sec:calc} At the EVA-cell interfaces with introduced AR and LT nanodisk arrays, reflectance and transmittance into all scattering directions at each wavelength and incidence polar and azimuth angles is calculated as the ratio of the scattered reflected or transmitted power to the power of the incident field. At the considered interfaces, both c-Si and EVA are assumed to be semi-infinite. For a given azimuth angle $\phi_\text{in}$, reflectance and transimittance values form matrices of the size ($N_{\theta_\text{in}}$, $N_{\theta_\text{r,t}}$, $N_{\lambda}$), where the entries correspond to all polar angles of incidence, scattering angles, and wavelengths, respectively. The polar angle $\theta_\text{in}$ is varied from $\ang{0}$ to $\ang{89}$ with $\ang{5}$ step, and the results are then interpolated at intervals of $\ang{1}$. In case of azimuth angle $\phi_\text{in}$, the symmetry of the nanodisk coating is exploited, and only calculations for angles between $\ang{0}$ and $\ang{45}$ with $\ang{15}$ step are performed. The calculated matrices for different $\phi_\text{in}$ values are subsequently averaged. Total reflectance and transmittance for a certain wavelength and incident polar and azimuth angles are calculated according to: \begin{equation}\label{eq:Refl} R=\frac{\sum\limits_{\bm{k}_\text{r}}|\Tilde{\bm{E}}(k_{\text{r,x}},k_{\text{r,y}})|^2\cdot \text{cos}(\theta_\text{r})}{|\bm{E}_0|^2\text{cos}(\theta_\text{in})}, \end{equation} \begin{equation}\label{eq:Trans} T=\frac{\sum\limits_{\bm{k}_\text{t}}n_{\text{out}}|\Tilde{\bm{E}}(k_{\text{t,x}},k_{\text{t,y}})|^2\cdot \text{cos}(\theta_\text{t})}{n_{\text{in}}|\bm{E}_0|^2\text{cos}(\theta_\text{in})}, \end{equation} where $\bm{k_\text{r,t}}$ are the wave vectors of reflected and transmitted fields, $\theta_\text{r,t}=\Re{(\pm k_\text{z}/k_\text{r,t})}$ are the scattering angles, $\bm{E}_0$ is the amplitude of an incident plane wave with a mixed TE-TM polarization, and $n_\text{in}$ and $n_\text{out}$ are the refractive indices of the media where the incident and scattered waves propagate, respectively. We use the angular spectrum representation of the fields, and $\Tilde{\bm{E}}(k_{\text{\{r,t\},x}},k_{\text{\{r,t\},y}})$ in equations~\ref{eq:Refl} and~\ref{eq:Trans} is calculated by means of the Fourier transform of the electric fields in real space obtained from full-wave simulations. Absorptance in each of the thin film layers and nanodisk array was calculated by integrating the divergence of the Poynting vector across the absorber volume, thus yielding absorbed power which is normalized to the power of the incident plane wave. Similarly to reflectance and transmittance, for a given azimuth angle, absorptance values form a matrix of the size ($N_m$, $N_{\theta_\text{in}}$, $N_{\lambda}$), where index $m$ runs over all absorbing layers in the front or rear solar cell stack. The angular dependent simulations were performed for optimized AR and LT nanodisk arrays. The optical performance of the nanodisk arrays was optimized with respect to the short-circuit current associated with reflectance at a normal light incidence, which is calculated using the following equation: \begin{equation}\label{eq:JscR} J_{\text{SC,R}}=\int_{\lambda_1}^{\lambda_2}e \frac{SI_\text{AM1.5}(\lambda)R(\lambda)}{E_\text{ph}}d\lambda, \end{equation} where $e$ is the electron charge, $E_\text{ph}=hc/\lambda$ is the energy of a photon, and $SI_\text{AM1.5}(\lambda)$ is the spectral irradiance. For this calculation, air mass 1.5 global (AM1.5G) tilted irradiance raw data was taken from~\cite{gueymard1995smarts2}, and the total reflectance $R(\lambda)$ was interpolated accordingly. The short-circuit current due to reflectance $J_{\text{SC,R}}$ was minimized for front nanodisk array and maximized for the rear LT nanodisk array. Within the EY modeling framework, where the optical response of the entire architecture is computed, the light propagation in multi-layer thin-film stacks is treated coherently, for which the transfer matrix method is employed. When AR and LT nanodisk arrays are considered instead of those thin-film layers, the corresponding output matrices for reflectance, transmittance, and absorptance are integrated into the modeling framework. For thicker layers, such as the c-Si substrate of the cell and window layers of the module, the assumption of coherence breaks down. The Beer-Lambert law can describe the absorption of the light in those layers: \begin{equation}\label{eq:Beer} I(z,\lambda)=I_\text{0}\cdot\text{e}^{-\alpha(\lambda)z}, \end{equation} where $I_\text{0}$ is the initial intensity, $\alpha$ is the absorption coefficient of the considered medium, and $z$ is the distance traveled in it. \section{Results and discussion} \subsection{Energy yield of solar modules} We analyzed the annual EY of the four solar module architectures introduced in Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic} for three cities in the United States of America located in different climate zones~\cite{peel2007updated}. Two of the chosen cities, Anchorage, AK and Honolulu, HI, have highly contrasting irradiation conditions. The former is a cold and cloudy region (Boreal climate) and the latter a hot and sunny one (Tropical climate). The additionally chosen Kansas City, MO, has a temperate climate that receives an annual solar irradiance between Anchorage and Honolulu. By covering different climate zones, we aimed to highlight the robustness of the nanodisk arrays performance and their ability to improve the annual EY for all types of irradiation conditions, albeit with small differences that most likely originate from the spectral features of the nanodisk arrays. The solar modules were considered to face south, and the tilt angles $\theta_\text{m}$ were optimized for each location. This resulted in $\theta_\text{m}$ values to be $\ang{38}$ for Anchorage, $\ang{30}$ for Kansas City, and $\ang{17}$ for Honolulu, respectively. Figure~\ref{fig:changeEY} demonstrates the relative improvement of the annual EY when the nanodisk arrays are used for light management instead of the optimized planar layers. The increase of the annual EY is shown as a function of the c-Si absorber thickness. We considered the case when the AR array is introduced on the front surface of the c-Si HJT cell in the case of the monofacial module architecture, and both AR and LT nanodisk arrays are applied to the front and rear surfaces of the cell in the case of the bifacial module architecture. For this calculation, no albedo was considered. The relative increase of the annual EY reached up to 11.0\,\%$_\text{rel}$ and 43.0\,\%$_\text{rel}$ at the minimal wafer thickness of 5~$\mu$m for monofacial and bifacial architectures with nanodisks, respectively. \begin{figure}[h] \centering \includegraphics[width=13cm]{Figure3.pdf} \caption{Relative increase of the annual EY for three locations in case of (a) the monofacial solar module (comparing (b) to (a) from Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic}) and (b) the bifacial solar module (comparing (d) to (c) from Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic}) with varying thickness of the c-Si absorber.} \label{fig:changeEY} \end{figure} As expected, for the monofacial case, the module with an AR nanodisk array (Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic}(b)) outperforms the standard flat architecture with an optimized ITO coating (Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic}(a)), with this effect becoming even more apparent when reducing the c-Si absorber thickness. However, the front side AR array with a relatively small size of the individual disks does not have strong LT properties. Its contribution to light harvesting stems mainly from its broadband AR performance. When instead of a full metallic contact, the window encapsulation and glass layers are introduced, to take advantage of the solar irradiation which can hit the module on its back, one has to take care of an appropriate light trapping structure, which would also act as a decent AR coating. For this purpose, an LT nanodisk array was designed (Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic}(d)). With the individual disk parameters being significantly larger when compared to the nanodisk array used as the AR structure at the front interface, the light which is not absorbed in the silicon and reaches the rear interface of the cell is effectively scattered in multiple directions, thus improving the LT properties of the cell. From Fig.~\ref{fig:changeEY} (b) it can be seen that it translates into an even more significant increase of the annual EY than for monofacial module architecture when comparing to a reference bifacial module architecture (Fig.~\ref{fig:schematic}(c)). If additionally, one considers albedo radiation, the advantage of the bifacial module architecture with AR and LT nanodisk arrays becomes even more apparent. The influence of albedo is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:barEY}. Here, the annual EY of the four module architectures with a selected median c-Si absorber thickness of 40~$\mu$m is shown for the sandstone and grass ground surface compared to EY of the modules without albedo. \begin{figure}[h] \centering \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{Figure4.pdf} \caption{Energy yield of the four module architectures for different locations when albedo irradiation is taken into account. For all solar module architectures, the c-Si absorber thickness was 40~$\mu$m.} \label{fig:barEY} \end{figure} Since the interfaces of the standard reference modules are flat, without albedo, the monofacial standard reference module outperforms the bifacial reference. While for the former, the silver layer reflects the light reaching it back into the cell, for the latter, a lot of light is lost due to transmittance when no LT structure is introduced. This difference is bigger with a smaller module tilt angle since less irradiation can hit the module from the back. However, as soon as albedo radiation is considered, the bifacial standard reference outperforms its monofacial counterpart. While for monofacial architecture albedo radiation does not make a significant difference, one can see a robust improvement in the annual EY for the bifacial case. The increase of the annual EY for the monofacial architecture varies depending on the module tilt and is stronger for locations with a greater $\theta_\text{m}$ (Anchorage). The relative improvement reaches up to around 0.8\,\%$_\text{rel}$ with sandstone and 3.0\,\%$_\text{rel}$ with grass as a ground surface for both the standard reference monofacial module and monofacial module with AR nanodisk array with insignificant difference between them. In the case of the bifacial module architecture, a stronger increase of the annual EY is expected for the sunnier locations (Honolulu). It reaches up to 8.2\,\%$_\text{rel}$ with sandstone, and 28.9\,\%$_\text{rel}$ with grass ground surface in case of a standard reference bifacial module. For a bifacial module with AR and LT structures, the relative increase is 8.3 \,\%$_\text{rel}$ and 30.1\,\%$_\text{rel}$ with sandstone and grass ground surface, respectively. \subsection{Optical performance of solar modules}\label{sec:opt} To better understand the mechanism behind the annual EY improvement when the nanodisk arrays are introduced on top of the front and back contacts of a solar cell, one can look at the optical properties of the cell interfaces with the optimized nanodisk arrays. Figure~\ref{fig:Reflectance} shows reflectance at normal incidence of the EVA-cell interfaces for the front and rear HJT solar cell contacts with AR and LT nanodisk arrays. For both nanodisk arrays and illumination directions, reflectances of the corresponding reference flat interfaces are plotted for comparison. The graphs (a) and (b) in Fig.~\ref{fig:Reflectance} correspond to the optical response of the front EVA-cell interface. In this case, the objective was to minimize short-circuit current density corresponding to reflectance $J_{\text{SC,R}}$ introduced in Eq.~\ref{eq:JscR}, which resulted in an AR nanodisk array with reflectance shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:Reflectance}(a). \begin{figure}[h] \centering \includegraphics[width=12cm]{Figure5.pdf} \caption{Reflectance at normal incidence for the front and rear EVA-cell interfaces in case of both AR and LT nanodisk arrays. Inset sketches depict the corresponding interface and illumination direction. Interfaces are the same for the pairs of graphs (a)-(b) and (c)-(d), respectively.} \label{fig:Reflectance} \end{figure} This design was based on the previous work on helicity preserving TiO$_2$ nanodisk array for the front interface of a c-Si HJT solar cell, where efficient and broadband backscattering suppression was achieved due to the ability of the system to suppress cross-talk between opposite handednesses of the electromagnetic field upon light-matter interaction~\cite{slivina_insights_2019}. The requirement for a system to be helicity preserving is to possess a high enough degree of rotational symmetry ($n\ge3$) along the illumination direction. For normal light incidence, for which the optimization of AR nanodisk array was performed, the illumination direction is along the symmetry axis of an individual nanodisk, which essentially means that $n\rightarrow\infty$ in this case. The resulting reflectance of the AR nanodisk array is lower than the one of the reference optimized flat AR coating and exceeds it slightly only in the wavelength region around $\lambda=600$~nm, for which standard AR coating of the solar cell is typically optimized. However, as shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:Reflectance}(b), the LT properties of this nanodisk array are not as good as its AR properties. When the light is impinging from the c-Si absorber, only the long-wavelength response is relevant since the short-wavelength photons are absorbed before reaching this interface. This nanodisk coating transmits the light reflected from the rear of the stack particularly strongly at longer wavelengths and is not possessing better LT properties than the standard flat reference. This optical response confirms that the front nanodisk array contributes to the light harvesting of the considered solar module architectures mainly by its AR properties. The graphs (c) and (d) in Fig.~\ref{fig:Reflectance} demonstrate the optical response of the optimized LT nanodisk array. Here, the structure parameters strongly differ from those of the helicity preserving AR nanodisk array. The larger and more sparsely spaced LT nanodisks allow for improved harvesting of the long-wavelength photons reaching the rear of the solar cell. The impinging light is effectively scattered into multiple directions since many diffraction orders are allowed. Taking into account the absorption depth of c-Si, for the minimal considered absorber thickness of 5~$\mu$m, the photons that can reach the rear contact of the solar cell have wavelengths $\lambda\geq690$~nm. The optimized reflectance of the LT nanodisk array for the spectral region of interest is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:Reflectance}(c). Its LT performance exceeds that of the flat reference solar cell stack at all wavelengths. Nevertheless, as can be seen from Fig.~\ref{fig:Reflectance}(d), though this nanodisk array outperforms its flat reference counterpart in terms of AR properties in the longer wavelength range, overall, its main contribution to the improved absorption in c-Si, and, consequently, the annual EY of the solar module, is due to its superior LT properties. This way, in the bifacial module case, when nanodisk arrays with decoupled AR and LT properties are present on both sides of the solar cell stack, one can achieve a solid overall solar module performance boost. Another critical aspect of the solar module's optical performance is parasitic absorption. Here, all discussed results are for a selected median c-Si absorber thickness of 40~$\mu$m and at normal light incidence. Figures~\ref{fig:AMono} and~\ref{fig:ABi} show absorptance in all layers of the monofacial and bifacial module stacks, respectively, except for the glass layer, which was assumed to be non-absorbing. Additionally, the absorptance of the rear a-Si:H layer in monofacial module configuration and of rear and front a-Si:H layers in the bifacial module configuration for forward and backward illumination direction, respectively, was negligible, and, thus, it is not shown. Moreover, the LT TiO$_2$ nanodisk array, which is considered for the bifacial module configuration, does not introduce any parasitic absorption since the light absorbed in these nanodisks has short wavelengths and does not reach the rear cell interface while it is absorbed in c-Si. The short-circuit current densities indicated on the top of all graphs in Fig.~\ref{fig:AMono} and Fig.~\ref{fig:ABi} were calculated assuming AM1.5G spectrum using the modified Eq.~\ref{eq:JscR} with absorptance of c-Si instead of reflectance. \begin{figure}[h] \centering \includegraphics[width=12cm]{Figure6.pdf} \caption{Absorptance in the different layers of (a) the monofacial standrad reference module and (b) the monofacial module with AR nanodisk array on top of the front ITO contact at normal light incidence. For both solar module architectures, the c-Si absorber thickness was 40~$\mu$m.} \label{fig:AMono} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[h!] \centering \includegraphics[width=12cm]{Figure7.pdf} \caption{Absorptance in the different layers of the bifacial solar modules at normal light incidence: (a) in case of forward illumination direction for the bifacial standard reference module, (b) in case of forward illumination direction for the bifacial module with AR and LT nanodisk coatings, (c) in case of backward illumination direction for the bifacial standard reference module, (d) in case of backward illumination direction for the bifacial module with AR and LT nanodisk coatings. For both solar module architectures, the c-Si absorber thickness was 40~$\mu$m.} \label{fig:ABi} \end{figure} In the case of the monofacial standard reference module (Fig.~\ref{fig:AMono}(a)), the front transparent conductive ITO layer serves as an AR coating but also introduces some parasitic absorption. However, when the AR nanodisk array is introduced (Fig.~\ref{fig:AMono}(b)), ITO thickness for the optimized front solar cell contact is reduced considerably (from 75 to 10~nm), and parasitic absorption in this layer is significantly reduced. The nanodisks themselves have a tiny contribution to the parasitic absorption, considering that EVA absorbs all the light impinging on the solar module at the wavelengths between 300 and 360~nm and TiO$_2$ absorbs only at wavelengths shorter than $\lambda=380$~nm. On the other hand, while the AR nanodisk array increases the absorptance in c-Si thanks to a better in-coupling of the incident light, it also increases parasitic absorption in the front a-Si:H layer. However, it should be noted that in~\cite{holman_current_2012} it was shown that the carriers which are absorbed in an intrinsic a-Si:H layer can still contribute to the short-circuit current, and thus the parasitic absorption loss in this layer represents an upper bound and can have a less of an impact in reality. Thus, introducing the TiO$_2$ AR nanodisk array leads to a broadband enhancement of absorptance in the silicon absorber layer. In the case of the bifacial standard reference module and forward illumination direction (Fig.~\ref{fig:ABi}(a)), the parasitic absorption for the wavelengths below $\lambda=700$~nm is similar to the one of the monofacial module reference. However, the parasitic absorption is slightly lower in the long-wavelength range since more light is transmitted through the glass and encapsulation window layers. When AR and LT nanodisk arrays are introduced (Fig.~\ref{fig:ABi}(b)), the front nanodisks improve absorptance in silicon the same way as in the case of the monofacial module. The rear nanodisk array additionally enhances aborptance at longer wavelengths. However, due to the strong scattering enabled by LT nanodisks, parasitic absorption is also increased for longer wavelengths. When the light is impinging on the rear side of the bifacial solar module (Fig.~\ref{fig:ABi}(d)), the absorptance in c-Si is also improved in the case when AR and LT arrays are introduced in comparison to the reference flat module (Fig.~\ref{fig:ABi}(c)), even though LT nanodisks are not optimal in terms of their AR properties and introduce dips in silicon absorptance due to the sharp spectral features which can be seen in Fig.~\ref{fig:Reflectance}(d). \section{Conclusions} We have numerically studied the annual energy yield (EY) under realistic irradiation conditions for monofacial and bifacial crystalline silicon (c-Si) heterojunction (HJT) solar module architectures with AR and light trapping (LT) titanium dioxide (TiO$_2$) nanodisk square arrays introduced on top of the front and rear ITO layers and compared their power outputs with the ones of the corresponding standard reference flat solar modules. We have shown that while reducing the silicon absorber thickness, the relative increase of the annual EY is reaching up to 11.0\,\%$_\text{rel}$ and 43.0\,\%$_\text{rel}$ for monofacial and bifacial modules with nanodisk coatings, respectively. This improvement is comparable for the locations with different climate conditions. Moreover, in the case of bifacial module architecture, taking into account the albedo radiation produces an additional boost of the module performance. The designed dielectric nanodisk arrays for the front and rear contacts of c-Si HJT solar cell have both a significant impact on the light absorption in the c-Si wafer. At the same time, their AR and LT properties are decoupled. The front AR nanodisk array has a relatively small individual disk size and lattice constant, and its broadband backscattering suppression is related to the helicity preservation condition. In contrast, the rear LT nanodisk array has larger features and array pitch and allows for efficient scattering into multiple scattering directions. Furthermore, these AR and LT nanodisk square array designs are not restricted to a specific material or a particular photovoltaic solar cell stack and, thus, can be investigated for different solar module configurations. \begin{acknowledgement} The authors acknowledge support by the state of Baden-W{\"u}rttemberg through bwHPC and the German Research Foundation (DFG) through grant no INST 40/575-1 FUGG (JUSTUS 2 cluster). The authors are also grateful to JCMwave for their free provision of the FEM Maxwell solver JCMsuite. \end{acknowledgement}

\section{Results} Evaluation is performed on 2 test datasets, each containing 5 keyframes. Similarly to the training data, keyframes 1-4 all have interpolation sequences from keyframe $N$ to keyframe $N+1$ and keyframe 5 is a single image. The metric we use is the mean absolute error in mm of the depth measurement at each pixel. During the interpolation sequences, we mask the pixels which do not have associated ground truth so they are not considered in the error measurement and additionally we discard frames for which less than 10\% of the frames have ground truth measurements. \subsection{Test Dataset 1} The overall numerical errors on test dataset 1 from each method are shown in Fig. \ref{tab:dataset_1_results} and the plots of error per frame for keyframes with motion (1-4) are shown in Fig. \ref{fig:test_dataset_1_keyframe_1_2} and Fig. \ref{fig:test_dataset_1_keyframe_3_4}. \begin{table*} \centering \small \begin{tabular}{ p{0.17\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | p{0.05\textwidth} } & Keyframe 1 & Keyframe 2 & Keyframe 3 & Keyframe 4 & Keyframe 5 & Average \\ \hline Congcong Wang & 6.30 & \textbf{2.15} & 3.41 & 3.86 & 4.80 & 4.10 \\ J.C. Rosenthal & 8.25 & 3.36 & 2.21 & \textbf{2.03} & \textbf{1.33} & \textbf{3.44} \\ KeXue Fu & 30.49 & 18.32 & 19.73 & 19.30 & 16.86 & 20.94 \\ Trevor Zeffiro & 7.91 & 2.97 & \textbf{1.71} & 2.52 & 2.91 & 3.60 \\ Wenyao Xia & \textbf{5.70} & 7.18 & 6.98 & 8.66 & 5.13 & 6.73 \\ Zhu Zhanshi & 14.64 & 7.77 & 7.03 & 7.36 & 11.22 & 9.60 \\ Huoling Luo & 29.68 & 16.36 & 13.71 & 22.42 & 15.43 & 19.52 \\ Xiran Zhang & 12.53 & 6.13 & 3.60 & 3.34 & 5.07 & 6.13 \\ Xiaohong Li & 34.42 & 20.66 & 17.84 & 27.92 & 13.00 & 22.77 \\ Lalith Sharan & 30.63 & 46.51 & 45.79 & 38.99 & 53.23 & 43.03 \\ \hline Dimitris Psychogyios 1 & 7.73 & 2.07 & 1.94 & 2.63 & 0.62 & 3.00 \\ Dimitris Psychogyios 2 & 7.41 & 2.03 & 1.92 & 2.75 & 0.65 & 2.95 \\ Sebastian Schmid & 7.61 & 2.41 & 1.84 & 2.48 & 0.99 & 3.07 \\ \end{tabular} \caption{\label{tab:dataset_1_results} The mean absolute depth error in mm for test dataset 1. The best method submitted during the challenge period is shown in bold.} \end{table*} \begin{figure*} \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty} \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_1_keyframe_1.png} \caption{Keyframe 1} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_1_keyframe_2.png} \caption{Keyframe 2} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:test_dataset_1_keyframe_1_2}Mean absolute error plots for each frame of test dataset 1, keyframes 1 and 2. } \end{figure*} \begin{figure*} \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty} \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_1_keyframe_3.png} \caption{Keyframe 3} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_1_keyframe_4.png} \caption{Keyframe 4} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:test_dataset_1_keyframe_3_4}Mean per-pixel error plots for each frame of test dataset 1, keyframes 3 and 4.} \end{figure*} \subsection{Test Dataset 2} The overall numerical errors on test dataset 2 from each method are shown in Fig. \ref{tab:dataset_2_results} and the plots of error per frame for keyframes with motion (1-4) are shown in Fig. \ref{fig:test_dataset_2_keyframe_1_2} and Fig. \ref{fig:test_dataset_2_keyframe_3_4}. \begin{table*} \centering \small \begin{tabular}{ p{0.17\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | p{0.05\textwidth} } & Keyframe 1 & Keyframe 2 & Keyframe 3 & Keyframe 4 & Keyframe 5 & Average \\ \hline Congcong Wang & 6.57 & 2.56 & 6.72 & 4.34 & 1.19 & 4.28 \\ J.C. Rosenthal & 8.26 & 2.29 & 7.04 & \textbf{2.22} & \textbf{0.42} & 4.05 \\ KeXue Fu & 23.71 & 15.46 & 26.43 & 9.60 & 10.92 & 17.22 \\ Trevor Zeffiro & 5.39 & \textbf{1.67} & \textbf{4.34} & 3.18 & 2.79 & \textbf{3.47} \\ Wenyao Xia & 13.80 & 6.85 & 13.10 & 5.70 & 7.73 & 9.44 \\ Zhu Zhanshi & 14.41 & 12.55 & 16.30 & 27.87 & 34.86 & 21.20 \\ Huoling Luo & 20.83 & 11.27 & 35.74 & 8.26 & 14.97 & 18.21 \\ Xiran Zhang & \textbf{3.20} & 3.30 & 6.75 & 4.79 & 3.91 & 4.39 \\ Xiaohong Li & 24.58 & 16.80 & 29.92 & 11.37 & 19.93 & 20.52 \\ Lalith Sharan & 35.46 & 50.09 & 25.24 & 62.37 & 70.45 & 48.72 \\ \hline Dimitris Psychogyios 1 & 4.85 & 0.65 & 1.62 & 0.77 & 0.41 & 1.67 \\ Dimitris Psychogyios 2 & 4.78 & 1.19 & 3.34 & 1.82 & 0.36 & 2.30 \\ Sebastian Schmid & 4.33 & 1.10 & 3.65 & 1.69 & 0.48 & 2.25 \\ \end{tabular} \caption{\label{tab:dataset_2_results} The mean absolute depth error in mm for test dataset 2. The best method submitted during the challenge period is shown in bold.} \end{table*} \begin{figure*} \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty} \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_2_keyframe_1.png} \caption{Keyframe 1} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_2_keyframe_1.png} \caption{Keyframe 2} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:test_dataset_2_keyframe_1_2}Mean per-pixel error plots for each frame of test dataset 2, keyframes 1 and 2. } \end{figure*} \begin{figure*} \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty} \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_2_keyframe_3.png} \caption{Keyframe 3} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/results/dataset_2_keyframe_4.png} \caption{Keyframe 4} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:test_dataset_2_keyframe_3_4}Mean per-pixel error plots for each frame of test dataset 2, keyframes 3 and 4. } \end{figure*} \subsection{Overall} The overall winner of the challenge was the method with the lowest mean error across the two test datasets, which was Trevor Zeffiro of Rediminds Inc. Second place was awarded to Jean-Claude Rosenthal. \section{Introduction} Reconstruction of the surgical scene is an important problem in computer assisted surgery (CAS). It is a fundamental part of SLAM, which is a requirement for augmented reality (AR) \cite{haouchine_image_2013}, as well as a key building block of perception in automation and safety systems \cite{shademan_supervised_2016} and has even found use in diagnostic tools \cite{mahmood_polyp_2019}. There are several methods of estimating depth in endoscopic images. The most commonly used is depth from stereo, whereby pixels are matched between the two views of a calibrated stereo camera and triangulated to provide depth measurements. The matching can be achieved through classical methods such as semi-global block matching or more recently with deep learning \cite{ye_selfsupervised_2017}. These methods are popular because they require no modification of the scene and the data required for their use can be captured with a simple recording system attaching to the endoscope. When a high quality calibration is obtained they can provide accurate results however requiring clinical teams to calibrate scopes is not a practical solution at scale and calibrations themselves can be invalidated by changing parameters such as focal lengths during the procedure \cite{pratt_practical_2014}. Calibration can be avoided by using only a single monocular view, whereby structural cues are inferred from the contents of a single image. Solutions in this space are almost entirely based on machine learning but promising results have been demonstrated in sinus endoscopy \cite{liu_self_2018}. Using structured light projectors within the endoscope has been demonstrated \cite{lin_endoscopic_2017} however obtaining reconstruction at the camera frame rate is challenging and requires specialized processing hardware. \begin{figure} \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty} \begin{subfigure}[c]{0.24\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/image2.png} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[c]{0.24\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/image3.png} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:example}An example image captured by the endoscope and the corresponding depth map.} \end{figure} The development and evaluation of methods to accurately estimate depth in surgical images is heavily dependent on the availability of high quality datasets. The mainstream computer vision community has seen great success in algorithm development following the release of several Middlebury Stereo datasets between 2001 and 2014 \cite{scharstein_high_2003} as well as more specialized datasets from autonomous driving \cite{sun_scalability_2019, geiger_vision_2013}. Few datasets of this type exist in the surgical domain and are typically much smaller or focus on phantom or non-realistic environments \cite{stoyanov_real_2010} largely due to challenges with obtaining ground truth data. The stereo correspondence and reconstruction of endoscopic data (SCARED) sub-challenge was organized to help address this gap by creating a high quality dataset using porcine cadavers and a structured light projection system. \section{Supplemental Material on Dataset inaccuracies} Inaccuracies were present in the provided datasets. Many of these inaccuracies were expected, such as calibration errors for the endoscope and synchronization issues between the video and kinematics in the warping of depth data from the initial frame to later frames. Subsequent efforts to estimate and correct for these efforts were made by late submissions to the challenge and their results are explained here for completeness. \subsection{Sebastian Schmid and Tom Kurmann} The original dataset relies on the forward kinematics for forward projection of the point cloud. This limits the accuracy of the point clouds to the accuracy of the forward kinematics. These may suffer from positioning errors, noise and video synchronization issues making them a potential source of error in the training data. In order to minimize this error, we propose to compute the forward propagation of the point clouds using the imaging data. To do so, we perform a 4 step pipeline which detects keypoints in subsequent frames, matches them and then computes the camera's pose. Using the camera pose, the point cloud can then be projected into the image to obtain the disparity maps. More precisely, our pipeline is defined as follows: \begin{description} \item[$\bullet$] Extract SIFT features from the keyframe and a subsequent frame. \item[$\bullet$] Match the features between subsequent and keyframe. The aim is to find as many feature pairs as possible. \item[$\bullet$] Use the matched features to estimate the pose of the endoscope, substituting the given forward kinematics. This can be formulated as a perspective-n-point problem, where the projections of a set of $n$ 3D points onto an image plane are known and the pose of the camera has to be calculated. The pose is expressed as rotation $\mathbf{R}$ and translation $\mathbf{t}$. \item[$\bullet$] Apply $\mathbf{R}$ and $\mathbf{t}$ to the point cloud of the keyframe to get a point cloud for the subsequent frame. \end{description} \subsection{Dimitris Psychogyios} \subsubsection{Calibration Errors} The ground truth depthmap is given as a 3-channel image. Each nonzero ground truth pixel $(u,v)$ stores the 3D coordinates of a point in space which projects to $(u,v)$ pixel in the left image. Using the provided camera calibration parameters to project a 3D point, stored in ground truth’s $(u,v)$, ends up in coordinates $(u+du, v+dv)$. This effect could potentially be caused by either discretization in the depth map or calibration error. Calibration files in Datasets 4 and 5 seem to have inaccuracies. Using the provided calibration parameters to rectify frames included in those two datasets, caused large errors in the rectification as shown in Fig. \ref{fig:supplemental_calib_error}. Matches in the rectified image pairs do not end up on the same scan-lines. Estimating the Essential matrix, using Shi and Tomashi features\cite{shi1994good} and LK tracking \cite{lucas1981iterative} between the two views and using it refine the extrinsics, resulted in rectifications that had the same problem. Rectification based only on the Fundamental matrix is adequate. This leads to the conclusion that the error is mainly in the intrinsics. \begin{figure*} \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.32\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/supplemental/calib1.png} \caption{} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.32\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/supplemental/calib2.png} \caption{} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.32\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/supplemental/calib3.png} \caption{} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:supplemental_calib_error}(a) Stereo anaglyph of dataset 4, keyframe 1 showing rectified frames, using the provided calibration parameters, with sparse feature matching overlay. Corresponding features do not lie on the same horizontal scanlines. (b) The same image pair where the extrinsics are estimated from feature matches. (c) Uncalibrated rectification based only on visual matches.} \end{figure*} \subsubsection{Video/Kinematics Offsets} Frames in `rgb.mp4' files and the interpolated ground truth depth images, based on robot kinematics, are not time synchronized. Overlaying the provided ground truth sequences over the corresponding videos, shows that the video is lagging. \subsubsection{Ground Truth-RGB misalignment} There are misalignments between the ground truth and the RGB data in datasets 8 and 9 (Figure \ref{fig:offset_error}). \begin{figure*} \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty} \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.48\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/supplemental/offset1.png} \caption{Scanline Offset} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[b]{0.48\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/supplemental/offset2.png} \caption{Disparity Offset} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:offset_error} An example from dataset 9, keyframe 3. Ground truth depth map is shifted with respect to the RGB image. This is also visible between the disparity which is based on the ground truth data and the output of one of the networks.} \end{figure*} \section{Participating Methods} The 10 methods described in this section were submitted during the challenge time window and were the only methods considered when deciding the challenge winner. \subsection{Fraunhofer Institute for Telecommunications, Heinrich Hertz Institute} The submission from The Fraunhofer Institute for Telecommunications, Heinrich Hertz Institute in Germany was from Jean-Claude Rosenthal, Zhenglei Hu, Niklas Gard and Peter Eisert. This stereo pipeline consists of six steps whereas steps 2-4 are developed at Fraunhofer HHI. (1) Histogram equalization: They apply equalization using OpenCV implementation of CLAHE \cite{zuiderveld_contrast_1994} as a pre-processing step. (2) Stereo geometry analysis: They detect and match sparse feature point correspondences based on binary feature point descriptors using the hamming distance. From matched feature points they compute stereo alignment errors for 5 parameters as indicated. \cite{zilly_semantic_2011}. (3) Rectification: They correct stereo alignment errors using the matched feature points by computing a linearized F-matrix and apply a homography to rectify stereo images. They warp the right image w.r.t. to the left view \cite{zilly_joint_2010}. Remaining alignment errors are $\pm$0.25 pixels. (4) Disparity estimation: They perform a quasi-dense disparity estimation using a spatio-temporal method called patch recursive matching (patchRM) \cite{Waizenegger2016Realtime3B}. Disparity estimation fully works in parallel on a graphic card with CUDA support. The procedure makes use of a statistical approach on sub-pixel level to estimate new correspondences. These correspondences are distributed into the local neighborhood where new correspondences are determined within the next iteration. This independent propagation of new estimated correspondences guarantees that the whole disparity map is constantly updated locally while propagating the results into the spatial-temporal consistent global map. (5) 3D reconstruction and depth filtering: They generate an almost complete raw depth z-map from step 4 which uses a depth range histogram to remove outliers and mismatches during this process. Therefore, they make use of pre-known ground truth data from training sets to derive a heuristic with reasonable endoscopic depth ranges using (a) the smallest “near range” 14.676 mm (D3k5) and (b) the largest “far range” is 245.554mm (D6k5) as working distances. (6) Depth Completion: They complete the final depth map as some depth values have been marked invalid in step 4 and 5. Therefore, they use a deep neural network. It is a 2-step process which is independent of the RGBD/depth sensor. First, object occlusion boundaries and surface normals are estimated using a CNN network in the RGB image. Second, in a global surface optimization step depth values are used as a soft constraint to solve for missing depths near estimated object boundaries using the surface normals \cite{zhang2018deep}. Remarks: The pipeline has a short initialization phase of 15-25 frames for step 2 and 3. Afterwards, the estimated homography matrix to rectify the stereo images is considered static for the rest of the sequence. Therefore, these steps are no longer executed except the warping of the right image w.r.t. to the left view. \begin{table} \centering \small \begin{tabular}{ p{0.17\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | >{\centering}p{0.1\textwidth} | p{0.05\textwidth} } & Keyframe 1 & Keyframe 2 & Keyframe 3 & Keyframe 4 & Keyframe 5 & Average \\ \hline Congcong Wang & 6.30 & \textbf{2.15} & 3.41 & 3.86 & 4.80 & 4.10 \\ J.C. Rosenthal & 8.25 & 3.36 & 2.21 & \textbf{2.03} & \textbf{1.33} & \textbf{3.44} \\ KeXue Fu & 30.49 & 18.32 & 19.73 & 19.30 & 16.86 & 20.94 \\ Trevor Zeffiro & 7.91 & 2.97 & \textbf{1.71} & 2.52 & 2.91 & 3.60 \\ Wenyao Xia & \textbf{5.70} & 7.18 & 6.98 & 8.66 & 5.13 & 6.73 \\ Zhu Zhanshi & 14.64 & 7.77 & 7.03 & 7.36 & 11.22 & 9.60 \\ Huoling Luo & 29.68 & 16.36 & 13.71 & 22.42 & 15.43 & 19.52 \\ Xiran Zhang & 12.53 & 6.13 & 3.60 & 3.34 & 5.07 & 6.13 \\ Xiaohong Li & 34.42 & 20.66 & 17.84 & 27.92 & 13.00 & 22.77 \\ Lalith Sharan & 30.63 & 46.51 & 45.79 & 38.99 & 53.23 & 43.03 \\ \hline Dimitris Psychogyios 1 & 7.73 & 2.07 & 1.94 & 2.63 & 0.62 & 3.00 \\ Dimitris Psychogyios 2 & 7.41 & 2.03 & 1.92 & 2.75 & 0.65 & 2.95 \\ Sebastian Schmid & 7.61 & 2.41 & 1.84 & 2.48 & 0.99 & 3.07 \\ \end{tabular} \caption{\label{tab:dataset_1_results} The mean absolute depth error in mm for test dataset 1. The best method submitted during the challenge period is shown in bold.} \end{table} \subsection{University of Western Ontario} The submission from the Robarts Institute at the University of Western Ontario, Canada was from Wenyao Xia. This method used multi-scale cost volume filtering with mean-squared-error loss wtth post-processing with guided median filter. A regression model was also trained to correct rectification errors. \subsection{Norwegian University of Science and Technology} The submission from the Norwegian University of Science and Technology was from Congcong Wang. This method used a variational disparity estimation method on the coarsest level of a multiscale pyramid \cite{wang2018liver}. The disparity map was upsampled using a modified bilateral filter. \subsection{Rediminds Inc.} The submission from the Rediminds Inc. USA was from Trevor Zeffiro. This method trained a Pyramid Stereo Matching network (PSMNet) using an Gaussian based interpolation strategy to remove holes in the training data. \subsection{Unknown} The unaffiliated submission is from KeXue Fu. This method uses unsupervised training of a DNN to predict the disparity and then reproject using the stereo calibration parameters. \subsection{Harbin Institute of Technology} The submission from the Harbin Institute of Technology, China was from Zhu Zhanshi. This method used a 6 level UNet with multi-scale loss on appearance matching, disparity smoothness and left-right consistency. \subsection{Shenzhen Institute for Advanced Technology (1)} The first submission from the Shenzhen Institute for Advanced Technology, China was from Huoling Luo and Fucang Jia. This method used a modified VGG encoder with skip connections to a dual branch decoder to directly predict a disparity map. 4 neighborhood smoothing is used as post-processing. \subsection{Johns Hopkins University} The submission from the Johns Hopkins University, USA was from Xiran Zhang. This method used the Pyramid Stereo Matching network (PSMNet), discarding inaccurate pixels in the training data using SGBM as a filter and ICP to generate a new point cloud which is reprojected to the create high quality training images. L1 loss is used to regularize the results. \subsection{Shenzhen Institute for Advanced Technology (2)} The second submission from the Shenzhen Institute for Advanced Technology, China was from Xiaohong Li and Fucang Jia. This method used a CycleGAN to synthesize a depth map in a 2 stage process directly from a rectified stereo pair. \subsection{Heidelberg University} The submission from the Heidelberg University, Germany was from Lalith Sharan. This method used a UNet trained to minimize a mean absolute error loss with a smoothness regularization. \section{Post-Challenge Methods} The 3 methods described in this section were submitted in the months after the challenge finished so were not considered in the final challenge ranking. \subsection{Wellcome/EPSRC Centre for Interventional and Surgical Sciences (WEISS) UCL (1)} \label{ssect:deep_pruner} The first submission from UCL is from Dimitris Psychogyios. This method used Deep Pruner \cite{duggal2019deeppruner}. The model was pretrained on the Sceneflow dataset \cite{mayer2016large}. Outlier points were manually removed from ground truth and stereo frames were rectified using OpenCV. Disparity images were generated in the left rectified frame of reference. During training, a data augmentation scheme consisted of random crops of size 256x512 and color normalization was used. They ignored the interpolation sequences as well as datasets 4 and 5 due to high calibration errors. This left 25 samples, of which they allocated 18 for training and 7 for evaluation. Finally, inferred disparities were reconstructed in 3D using the provided calibration parameters. Training was performed using a batch size of 1 for 290 epochs. The Adam optimizer \cite{kingma2014adam} with a learning rate of $10^{- 4}$ , $\beta_{1} = 0.9$ and $\beta_{2} = 0.999$. \subsection{Wellcome/EPSRC Centre for Interventional and Surgical Sciences (WEISS) UCL (2)} The second submission from UCL is also from Dimitris Psychogyios. This method makes use of Hierarchical deep Stereo Matching network (HSM)\cite{yang2019hierarchical}. It followed the same process as illustrated in Subsection IV-A with the exception of a batchsize of 2 and 350 epochs of training. \subsection{University of Bern} The third late submission was from Sebastian Schmid and Tom Kurmann at University of Bern. Similar to previous methods such as pwc-net \cite{pwc_net_2018} and gwc-net \cite{guo2019group} they base their method on a 3D cost volume optimization for stereo matching. They extend the previous method by using two parallel pipelines to predict both left and right disparities during training. This allows them to incorporate photometric losses which enforce a correct reconstruction of the right image with the left image and disparities and vice-versa. They optimize the computationally expensive 3D cost volume and subsequent 3D convolution network by quantizing the cost volume. Rather than using a disparity stride of 1 when generating the volume, they use a dynamic stride which is based on the distribution of the ground truth disparities. They use k-means clustering of the ground truth disparities to extract n-centroids, which are used as the disparities in the cost volume. Without a loss of accuracy, they can reduce the number of disparities by 40\%, resulting in a decrease in inference time of 40\% (79.1ms). Furthermore, this reduces the memory footprint, allowing for larger batch sizes or higher resolution during training. Their loss function is the weighted sum of the L1-loss of the prediction and ground truth, the photometric loss and a disparity smoothness term. \section{Data} The SCARED dataset consists of 7 training datasets and 2 test datasets captured using a da Vinci Xi surgical robot. Each dataset corresponds to a single porcine subject and contains between 4 and 5 keyframes. A keyframe is a single unique view of the scene where the a structured light pattern was projected into the field of view of the camera and a dense stereo reconstruction was computed \cite{scharstein_high_2003}. As the endoscope was moved using the da Vinci Xi to observe a new keypoint, the camera's pose relative to the fixed robot base was recorded using the robot's internal measurements of the position of each joint in its arms. As the scene remained static during these sequences, it was possible to obtain approximate depth maps for intermediate frames by transforming the vertices from the original keypoint and reprojecting them into the new view. To create the depth maps at each keypoint, the white light image of the stereo camera was first captured. Then the illuminator was turned off, and a projector was used to project a series of patterns onto the scene. The scene remained totally still during this period. The illuminator used was a AAXA P300 Neo Pico projector which provides a small form factor of $15\times3\times9$ cm and a $1280\times720$ pattern. The patterns projected were 10 bit Gray code patterns which provided a unique sequence for each pixel in the image using the method provided in \cite{scharstein_high_2003} (see Fig. \ref{fig:gray_code_pattern}). Due to challenges with positioning the projector as well, multiple projector positions had to be used to cover the entire scene. With a unique encoding for each pixel, stereo matching is straightforward and triangulation can be used to recover the scene depth. \begin{figure*} \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty} \begin{subfigure}[c]{0.3\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/projector.png} \caption{(a)} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[c]{0.3\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/pattern_view.png} \caption{(b)} \end{subfigure} \hfill \begin{subfigure}[c]{0.3\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figures/pattern.png} \caption{(c)} \end{subfigure} \caption{\label{fig:gray_code_pattern}(a) The projector used in this data collection. (b) The view of the endoscope while the pattern is being projected. (c) A single example of a Gray code pattern used to create the dataset.} \end{figure*}

1.. Introduction ================ Breathing is one of the essential functions for the survival of most living beings. Many processes to measure the respiration rate have been proposed: using a stretch sensor or impedance meter to detect chest expansion \[[@b1-sensors-14-15371]--[@b3-sensors-14-15371]\], a pulse oximeter and extracting the respiration rate from the raw data \[[@b4-sensors-14-15371]\], an accelerometer to detect chest expansion and contraction \[[@b5-sensors-14-15371],[@b6-sensors-14-15371]\], measuring airflow pressure by oral or nasal cannula, and many others. In case of sleep apnea diagnosis for example, polysomnography (PSG), the commonly used test, employs nasal cannula and chest belts. The main problem common to all these techniques is the presence of a device directly in contact with the subject. As an example, for children this may induce rejection behavior leading them to remove the device. This is also true in the case of sleeping subjects, where the presence of the device can significantly disrupt the falling asleep and sleep. There have been several attempts to devise contactless methods. Electromagnetic waves can sense chest movement by Doppler effect \[[@b7-sensors-14-15371]--[@b10-sensors-14-15371]\] or by analyzing the signal backscattered by breathing movements \[[@b11-sensors-14-15371]\] and ultrasound waves telemeters permits detection of small body displacements during respiration \[[@b12-sensors-14-15371],[@b13-sensors-14-15371]\]. These solutions give good results but remain indirect because they do not analyze the true air flow and therefore cannot easily detect obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). Contactless direct air flow analysis is far less common in the literature. A microphone to detect exhalation sounds is proposed in \[[@b14-sensors-14-15371]\], a high precision single point infrared sensor is use in \[[@b15-sensors-14-15371]\] and a US patent \[[@b16-sensors-14-15371]\] was granted for a method based on phase differences between two ultrasonic waves traveling in opposite directions. Nevertheless, the first method is perturbed by ambient noises and so the microphone needs to be placed close to the face of the subject to obtain good results. Concerning the second method, the sensor has to be fixed in an accurate position while the third method is complicated to implement because the two waves must travel exactly the same distance in absence of air flow. This study proposes a new ultrasonic contactless device \[[@b17-sensors-14-15371]\] to measure the presence or the absence of respiration and in the first case its relative intensity and rate. This sensor can be used alone in low cost systems or in conjunction with other remote sensors to increase reliability in sleep apnea diagnostic applications. The physical principle of this measure is to "illuminate" the subject\'s head with an acoustic wave emitted by a transducer, then recovering and analyzing the reflected wave. Under these conditions, any movement, both in the subject himself and in the exhaled airflow, induce a frequency shift in the signal which is the Doppler effect. Every part of the head which participate to the reflection has approximately the same relative speed component in the direction of the receiver. Moreover, this speed is mostly low except in the case of very rapid movements. Hence, the surface of the skin returns a wave that remains nearly coherent and gives a single (or narrow) low Doppler frequency shift. In contrast the exhaled air flow returns a wave with a wide Doppler shift due to the presence of turbulence. The relative speeds are also higher than in the case of the movement which leads to a higher and broader Doppler shift. By frequency filtering and averaging, it therefore becomes possible to obtain and discriminate air flow signal and head and shoulder movement signal. 2.. Experimental Section ======================== The apparatus developed in the context of this work, allows monitoring the breathing of a subject lying on his back. These conditions correspond to the situation encountered in breath monitoring during sleep, like sleep apnea diagnosis. A 40 kHz ultrasound transmitter illuminates an area widely including the subject\'s head. One receiver, tuned to the same frequency, recovers the signal reflected from the scene. After reflection on the local environment, the incident wave is subject to various transformations related to physical and chemical characteristics of the media encountered, but also, to the movements of the neighboring objects. The result is a combination of a level attenuation, a frequency shift, (*i.e.*, Doppler effect), and a more complex effect resulting in a modification of spectral energy repartition *versus* time when the subject breathes out. The phenomenon, that we call "spectrum widening", characterizes precisely the breath events and represents the core of this work. [Figure 1](#f1-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"} shows the block diagram of the device. We used inexpensive 40 kHz ultrasonic transducers with a 6 dB beamwidth of 55°. The emitted level was set to about 100 dB/0.0002 μbar. The transmitter was placed above patient head at a distance of 50 cm. We found that transmitter to head distance was not critical due to the ultrasound level and large beamwidth used. Receiver sensitivity is −65 dB *versus* 1 V/μbar. The receiver placement is a compromise between the signal strength and the need to allow the subject to move without hitting the sensor. The best signal is obtained when the receiver is close to the subject and directed to the nostrils. We used a distance of 30 cm for all data presented in this work. This distance could be increased with better receiver sensitivity and higher transmitted level but there is a physical limit where the exhaled air flow effect on the environment becomes insignificant. 2.1.. Acquisition and Shaping of the Received Signal ---------------------------------------------------- The signal received by the ultrasonic receiver is centered around the source frequency, 40 kHz. To digitize that signal by respecting the Nyquist--Shannon sampling theorem, a high sampling frequency and a fast A/D converter would be necessary. As the received signal is narrow band, spanning about 2 kHz below and above 40 kHz, frequency translation to a much lower intermediate frequency is possible. We have chosen to translate it around 4 kHz using a frequency mixer. The received signal is mixed with a 44 kHz sinusoidal signal to generate 4 kHz and 84 kHz beat products. The high frequency product is removed with a low pass anti-aliasing filter before digitization. The block diagram is shown in [Figure 2](#f2-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}. This solution presents the technical advantage to allow a low frequency digitization as, for example, with an inexpensive computer sound card. To visualize the spectral widening, we have used a time/frequency representation based on a short time Fourier transform (STFT) as: $$S{({t^{\prime},\nu})} = {\int{f\left( t \right)W\left( {t - t^{\prime}} \right)e^{2\pi i\nu t}\text{d}t}}$$with *S*(*t′*,*v*) the STFT of the signal to be analyzed *f*(*t*) computed for each window centered at *t* = *t′*, *v* the frequency parameter, W(*t* − *t′*) the windowing function centered at *t* = *t′* and *i* stands for the imaginary unit satisfying *i*^2^ = −1. For computation, a 44.1 kHz sampled signal is used with a Kaiser-Bessel windowing function \[[@b18-sensors-14-15371]\] of size 65,536. This respects the Heisenberg inequality and allows a good compromise between time and frequency resolutions. 2.2.. Physical Principles ------------------------- The observed phenomenon ([Figure 3](#f3-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}) is the result of several combined physical effects whose principal is the Doppler effect. We can nevertheless separate two main parts: the overall effect generated by the mean speed of expired airflow (mean speed *v* ≈ 1 m·s^−1^ and Doppler frequency shift Δ*f* ≈ 100 Hz) and local effects caused by turbulence which produce greater frequency extensions (several hundreds of Hz above and/or below the transmit frequency). The breathing exhalation flow can be assumed turbulent near its source (*i.e.*, nose or mouth). In such a flow, unsteady vortices appear on many scales and interact with each other. The friction between the exhaled flow and the static surrounding environment increases and interacts with the ultrasound wave. 2.3.. Sound-Vorticity Interaction --------------------------------- The phenomenon of scattering of sound by vorticity is known since the 1950\'s. Obukhov \[[@b19-sensors-14-15371]\] showed that an incident ultrasonic plane wave passing through an area with flow vorticity is scattered by it. Inside a flow, we can show that any velocity field $\overset{\rightarrow}{u}$ can be decomposed into modes as: $$\overset{\rightarrow}{u} = {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{p} + {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{v} + {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{s}$$with: $$\begin{matrix} {\overset{\rightarrow}{\nabla} \cdot {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{p} = 0\ \text{and}\ \overset{\rightarrow}{\nabla} \land {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{p} = \overset{\rightarrow}{0},} \\ {\overset{\rightarrow}{\nabla} \cdot {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{s} \neq 0\ \text{and}\ \overset{\rightarrow}{\nabla} \land {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{s} = \overset{\rightarrow}{0},} \\ {\overset{\rightarrow}{\nabla} \cdot {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{v} = 0\ \text{and}\ \overset{\rightarrow}{\nabla} \land {\overset{\rightarrow}{u}}_{v} = \overset{\rightarrow}{\Omega}\left( {\overset{\rightarrow}{r},t} \right) \neq \overset{\rightarrow}{0},} \\ \end{matrix}$$where *u⃗~p~* is a potential flow, *u⃗~s~* identify a sound wave and Ω⃗(*r⃗*,*t*) the vorticity. Chu \[[@b20-sensors-14-15371]\], in 1958, showed the existence of a coupling between these different modes. More recently, Lund and Rojas \[[@b21-sensors-14-15371]\] have derived a convenient expression that connects the acoustic scattered pressure, *p~scat~* directly to the Fourier transform of the vorticity field: $$p_{\text{scat}}\left( {\overset{\rightarrow}{r},\nu} \right) = p_{\text{inc}}\frac{- \cos\left( \theta_{s} \right)\sin\left( \theta_{s} \right)}{1 - \cos\left( \theta_{s} \right)}\frac{2i\pi^{3}\nu}{c^{2}}\frac{e^{i{\overset{\rightarrow}{k}}_{d} \cdot \overset{\rightarrow}{r}}}{r}\Omega\left( {\overset{\rightarrow}{q},\nu - \nu_{0}} \right)$$with: *p~inc~* the pressure amplitude of the plane incident wave of frequency *v*~0~ and wave vector ${\overset{\rightarrow}{k}}_{i} = \frac{2\pi\nu_{0}}{c}\hat{i}$,θ*~s~* the diffusion angle ([Figure 4](#f4-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}),*v* the scattered wave frequency of wave vector ${\overset{\rightarrow}{k}}_{d} = \frac{2\pi\nu}{c}\hat{d}$,$\overset{\rightarrow}{q} = {\overset{\rightarrow}{k}}_{d} - {\overset{\rightarrow}{k}}_{i}$ the scattered wave vector,Ω the vorticity component perpendicularly to the plane. This shows a linear relationship between the acoustic scattered pressure *p~scat~*, the incident pressure *p~inc~* and the wave frequency *v*, thus the system would benefit from increasing the transmit level and the wave frequency. However, practical transducers of high frequency tend to have a reduced beamwidth which could limit the ability to detect breathing for all head positions. The angular term of the Lund formula that modulates the acoustic scattering intensity will be denoted by: $$L\left( \theta_{s} \right) = \frac{- \cos\left( \theta_{s} \right)\sin\left( \theta_{s} \right)}{1 - \cos\left( \theta_{s} \right)}$$ [Figure 5](#f5-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}, shows the evolution of *L*(θ*~s~*) and *L*^2^(θ*~s~*). This latter term modulates the acoustic scattering intensity. Note that the apparent divergence of this expression for small scattering angles is an artifact due to the conditions of validity of the Lund formula. Low angles would allow better scattered signal, but are not practical in our application. The optimum angle, experimentally determined, is in accordance with the second local maximum. This shows that it is theoretically possible to measure the vorticity of a flow by diffusion of ultrasounds that corresponds to what is done by interpreting the spectrum of the acoustic received signal. More physically, when the wave excites a vortex, this latter is advected by the oscillating velocity field of small amplitude *u⃗~p~*, the sound wave, and begins to oscillate. As an unsteady vortex is a sound source, the oscillating vortex will emit sound. Thus, the excitation by the incident wave will be scattered by the vorticity, in the same way that light is scattered by matter. 2.4.. Influence of Experimental Conditions ------------------------------------------ - Oral or Nasal Breathing Typically, the phenomenon is similar whatever the type of breathing (nasal or oral). We can just observe a slightly lower level of the signal in case of nasal breathing ([Figure 6](#f6-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}). Position of the Subject Head, Relative to the Sensor The [Figure 7](#f7-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"} shows the change in the signal intensity according of the inclination of the subject\'s head. The signal level is maximum in front of the sensor (3) and gradually decreases with the angle of incidence. This level variation is not a problem for the application of apnea detection as the signal to noise ratio is acceptable for all positions. We can observe a high level Doppler offset of the incident wave frequency when the subject changes his position. 2.5.. Influence of Subject or Surrounding Movements --------------------------------------------------- During rapid subject movements ([Figure 8](#f8-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}, mark 1), like sleeping position changes, the breathing signal is embedded in the Doppler shift. In this situation, it is difficult to verify the presence, or absence, of breathing activity. 2.6.. Obtaining a Breathing Signal ---------------------------------- In order to characterize respiration, we need a scalar signal from which breathing intensity and respiratory rate can be calculated. The received signal is first bandpass filtered by an infinite impulse filter (IIR). The bandpass is chosen to avoid the noisy "movement region" near the transmit frequency. One can use either the low or high frequency "breathing zone" or both. Breathing signal intensity on these two zones depends on sensor orientation relative to the subject. In our experimental configuration, signal strength is greater on the low frequency side ([Figure 3](#f3-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}). For a 4 kHz carrier received after down-mixing, we use a 3500--3900 Hz bandpass elliptic IIR filter with 60 dB stop band attenuation and 1 dB bandpass ripple ([Figure 9](#f9-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}). To further improve rejection, we apply this filter twice. The 3900 Hz highpass frequency is chosen to exclude the frequency components close to the carrier frequency because the signal level in this zone varies with head position and head movements. The choice of the lower frequency is a compromise. On very deep exhalations, spectral widening can extent down to 3000 Hz but average exhalations do not produce significant signal down to 3500 Hz. Lowering the lowpass frequency further than 3500 Hz would not add more information and would introduce unwanted noise on average exhalations. This would decrease the average signal to noise ratio. Adult respiratory rate can vary from 0.2 to 0.5 Hz, children and newborn can show rate up to 1 Hz. Thus we choose a 10 Hz sample rate for our breathing signal. The root mean square (RMS) value of the bandpass filtered signal is computed every 100 ms (1/10 Hz). This RMS signal is low-pass filtered with a Butterworth filter to give the breathing signal. The optimal low pass frequency was determined by the residual analysis method \[[@b22-sensors-14-15371]\]. The residual *Res*, defined mathematically as the root mean square value of the difference between filtered and unfiltered data, was plot over a set of 100 cutoff frequencies *f~c~* evenly spaced from 0.1 Hz up to the Nyquist frequency (5 Hz for 100 ms sample time in our case): $$Res\left( f_{c} \right) = \sqrt{\frac{1}{N_{s}}{\sum\limits_{i = 0}^{N}\left( {x_{i} - {x^{\prime}}_{i}} \right)}^{2}}$$where: *N~s~* is the number of samples,*x~i~* is the *i*th unfiltered RMS value,$x_{i}^{'}$ is the *i*th filtered RMS value. If we make the assumption that data is contaminated by a white noise, the residual would vary linearly with the cutoff frequency. This is the case for our breathing data above 2.5 Hz and up to 4.5 Hz. If we extrapolate this linear region up to the point it intercepts the y-axis, we can estimate the RMS value of the noise (dash red line in [Figure 10](#f10-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}). The optimal frequency is chosen at the point where noise contribution to the residual equals signal contribution. This is a compromise between the amount of noise allowed to pass through the filter and the signal distortion. This analysis, repeated other a range of breathing data obtained from adults at rest leads to optimal cutoffs between 1.2 to 1.5 Hz. The lowpass frequency was set to 1.5 Hz for all data presented in this work ([Figure 11](#f11-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}). A typical breathing signal is shown in [Figure 12](#f12-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}. 2.7.. Obtaining a Signal Representing the Subject Motion -------------------------------------------------------- The breathing signal is disturbed in presence of large and rapid movements because the received spectrum is also widened during such events. Little head or shoulder motions as they occurred during sleep have no effect on the breathing signal but when the patient changes sleeping position or moves his arms, the breathing signal should not be taken into account. Thus we need a movement signal to detect situations where the breathing signal is too perturbed to give meaningful information. We derived a movement signal by tracking energy variation (using standard deviation) in a very narrow window below and above the center frequency. This was done by computing the Fourier transform of the received signal other a 371 ms time slice (16,384 samples at 44,100 Hz) and keeping only bins of interest. [Figure 13](#f13-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"} shows the two movement zones of approximately 12 Hz apart the center frequency from where the signal movement is computed. A 25 Hz zone centered on the center frequency was excluded because the signal value in this area can vary widely due to patient position. [Figure 14](#f14-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"} shows a movement signal and a breathing signal. The movement signal increases when the patient changes position. When the movement signal increases the breathing signal is meaningless. 3.. Results and Discussion ========================== Several validations were performed with our sensor to determine its performance. A first one, qualitative, consisted of positioning a breathing subject under the sensor and observing in real time the spectrogram (time/frequency representation). Under these conditions, we can verify the perfect correspondence between the spectrogram and the breathing activity during normal breathing, simulated apnea or movements. A second validation, more quantitative, was to equip the subject with a polygraph currently used in sleep laboratories to diagnose sleep apnea syndrome (Cid102L, Cidelec^®^, Sainte Gemmes sur Loire, France). It consists in a pressure sensor connected to a nasal cannula and to record both signals over a period of about 1 h which corresponds to about 1000 breathing cycles ([Figure 15](#f15-sensors-14-15371){ref-type="fig"}). During this period, the subject breathes through the mouth, the nose and simulates apnea and performs movements compatible with sleep. This experience showed the synchronization of the pressure signal provided by the nasal cannula with our signal spectrogram. However, the presence of the cannula in the nostrils derives a significant part of the exhaled air flow and therefore reduces the sensitivity of our device. 4.. Conclusion ============== The sensor presented in this work represents a good solution for contactless breathing monitoring. Its applications span from real-time monitoring to sleep apnea diagnosis. Its contactless feature makes it suitable for breathing monitoring of infants or premature, and more generally monitoring of subjects at risk of having respiratory distress. In future works, we plan to use several receivers evenly spaced around the subject head to allow us to remove the angular dependence of the breathing signal. Using a Fleish pneumotachograph we should be able to calibrate our system in order to obtain absolute measurements. In a second experiment, we will try a different signal processing methodology based on pattern matching classification of the different breathing states. To do this, and complete this study, a large measurement campaign on real patients is planned in collaboration with the CHITS (Toulon Hospital). We thank the members of the Centre Hospitalier Intercommunal Toulon La Seyne, Sainte Musse Hospital for their contribution to this project: Daniel D\'amore, pulmonologist, Marie-Françoise Mateo-Champion, neurophysiologist, the staff of the sleep laboratory and Jean-Philippe Suppini, head of the Clinical Research Unit. We would like to thank Cidelec^®^ Company, 20 rue des Métiers 49130 Sainte Gemmes sur Loire, France, <http://www.cidelec.net/fr/en.html> who lent us the polygraph to establish a comparison with our device. All the authors contributed equally to this work. The authors declare no conflict of interest. {#f1-sensors-14-15371} {#f2-sensors-14-15371} {#f3-sensors-14-15371} {#f4-sensors-14-15371} {#f5-sensors-14-15371} {#f6-sensors-14-15371} {#f7-sensors-14-15371} {#f8-sensors-14-15371} {#f9-sensors-14-15371} {#f10-sensors-14-15371} {#f11-sensors-14-15371} {#f12-sensors-14-15371} {#f13-sensors-14-15371} {#f14-sensors-14-15371} {#f15-sensors-14-15371}

Background ========== Totally Implantable Access Ports (TIAP) --------------------------------------- Insertion of a Totally Implantable Access Port (TIAP) is a routinely employed technique in patients who need a save and permanent venous access for e.g. chemotherapy and/or parenteral nutrition\[[@B1]\]. This system needs no external dressing, allows the patient normal physical activity, is probably less prone to infectious complications and will minimize the occlusion rate of the catheter compared to non-totally implantable catheters\[[@B1]\]. TIAPs are being extensively used world-wide and an increase of port placement can be expected with the broader introduction of innovative therapies in oncology such as the Capri Protocol in pancreatic cancer\[[@B2]\]. Implantation techniques ----------------------- Until today, two alternative approaches to access the central venous system are in use: Blind puncture of a central vein and introduction of a catheter using the Seldinger Technique or implantation of the TIAP through a surgically dissected vein (e.g. Venae Sectio of the cephalic vein; Fig. [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}). Both procedures are currently performed by surgeons as well as interventional radiologists and have a certain risk of complications with respect to the applied technique (pneumothorax, hematothorax, \"pinch off\" phenomena i.e. kinking of the catheter, nerve palsy, thoracic duct injury)\[[@B1],[@B3]\]. {#F1} {#F2} Modified Seldinger Technique (combination of Venae Sectio and Seldinger Technique) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The modified Seldinger Technique is a combination of Venae Sectio and Seldinger Technique using a guide wire and a peel away sheath in the surgically dissected cephalic vein. We believe that the usage of the guide wire and peel away sheath allowes introducting the catheter even in a small cephalic vein and it offers the possiblity to insert the catheter beyond obstacles and narrow curves. The advantage of this technique should be the avoidance of the blind puncture of a central vein (e.g. subclavian vein) and therefore a lower risk of severe complications like pneumothorax, haematothorax and nerve palsy and the possibility to insert the catheter beyond obstacles or narrow curves of the cephalic vein (Fig. [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}, [4](#F4){ref-type="fig"}, [5](#F5){ref-type="fig"}, [6](#F6){ref-type="fig"}, [7](#F7){ref-type="fig"}). {#F3} {#F4} {#F5} {#F6} {#F7} Medical problem --------------- Correct placement of the TIAP in the superior Vena Cava is mandatory for optimal and save usage of the central venous access. The success rate of TIAP implantation via the conventional approach by transsection of the cephalic vein (Venae Sectio) ranges between 70 to 94%\[[@B3]\]. A multivariate analysis of 400 patients at the Department of Surgery, Universityhospital of Heidelberg, who underwent a primary port-catheter-system engrafting, showed a success rate of the conventional approach of 80%\[[@B3]\]. One of the major causes for failure was an undersized cephalic vein or an obstacle on the way to the superior Vena Cava\[[@B3]\]. Furthermore this study showed that the secondary approach to blind puncture the subclavian vein with Seldinger Technique achieves an overall success rate of 98% but was also characterized by a number of severe complications causally related to indirect puncture, like a pneumo- or hematothorax\[[@B1]\]. In almost all interventional series using the Seldinger technique, pneumothorax as a complication occurred (0 to 3.2%)\[[@B3]\]. In contrast a literature search was not able to identify pneumothorax or nerve palsy after implantation of a TIAP via Venae Section. Study design ============ Aim of study ------------ The objective of this trial is to compare the success and complication rates of two different implantation techniques for TIAP: Venae Sectio of the cephalic vein and direct insertion of the port catheter versus Venae Sectio and insertion of the port catheter with a guide wire and peel away sheath (modified Seldinger Technique). Number of patients needed ------------------------- Two main factors determine the number of patients needed in a trial. These are the estimated event rate, and the size of the treatment effect. ### Estimated event rate The multivariate analysis of 400 patients at our Department who underwent a TIAP implantation showed a success rate of the conventional approach (Venae sectio with insertion of the catheter without a guide wire) of 80%. ### Size of treatment effect that should be detectable A modification of the conventional approach as described above must have by surgical decision an expected success proportion of 0.95\[[@B1]\], if surgical practice should be changed. ### Patients needed If the real success rate difference is minimum 15% (80% vs. 95%) then there is a 80% chance that a trial involving 160 patients could detect a significant difference at a level of 5%. Eligibility ----------- ### Inclusion criteria • Benign and malignant diseases which demand a safe and permanent venous access, e.g. for chemotherapy and/or parenteral nutrition • Age equal or greater than 18 years • Patients scheduled for primary elective implantation of a port-catheter-system in local anaesthesia • Informed consent ### Exclusion criteria • Participation in another intervention-trial with interference of intervention and outcome of this study • Lack of compliance • Impaired mental state or language problems (Patient is not able to read german texts) ### Subject withdrawal criteria • Randomization will be carried out after preparation of the cephalic vein. If no vein is to exhibit the subject will be removed from the trial and the pre-rand drop-out is to record in the CRF • At their own request or at request of the legal representative • If, in the investigator\'s opinion, continuation of the trial would be detrimental to the subject\'s well-being Consent ------- Patients who are scheduled for port-catheter-system implantation will have a pre-treatment visit to give the informed consent. During this visit the patient will be screened and informed about the PORTAS trial. In this conversation with the patient the study procedure, risks, benefits and data management will be clarified in detail. Randomization and procedures for minimizing bias ------------------------------------------------ ### Minimizing systematic bias In order to achieve comparable groups for known and unknown risk factors a block randomization will be performed by the randomization software RITA^®^. A sufficient number of patients will be recruited according to the sample seize calculation in order to prevent random error. Patients will get randomized intra operatively after identification of the cephalic vein in order to minimize post randomization drop outs. ### Minimizing treatment bias All physicians who participate in this trial will be trained and updated every 3 month to guarantee comparable treatment of patients. Special manuals will be used in operation theatre to reduce random errors. In addition the learning curves of the participating surgeons will be assessed. ### Minimizing measurement bias An independent nurse will document and monitor the procedure in the operating theatre. Blinding is not possible and necessary due to the research question. Study treatment --------------- All patients will be positioned on the table in a five degree reverse Trendelenburg\'s position. The neck, chest and shoulders of the patients will be prepared and draped in the customary sterile manner. Antibiotic prophylaxis is only given in patients of risk for endocarditis according to the local standards. Local anaesthesia will be infiltrated in sterile fashion into skin and subcutaneous layer and skin incision will be done 4 cm infer laterally parallel to the clavicle in the deltoid-pectoral region. The cephalic vein is to exhibit. After exhibition of the cephalic vein the randomization will be performed on a Laptop computer system with the RITA^®^randomization tool. According to the allocation the procedure will be continued. ### Intervention-group 1 The cephalic vein will be legated distally and encircled cranially with a 3-0 reabsorbable suture. The vein will be cross-sected ventrally and the catheter flushed with heparinized saline, introduced. Correct positioning will be controlled via fluoroscopy (tip of catheter just at aditus of right atrium) (Fig. [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}). ### Intervention-group 2 The cephalic vein will be ligated distally and encircled cranially with a 3-0 reabsorb able suture. The vein will be cross-sected ventrally and a guide wire will be placed under fluoroscopy to the junction of the superior vena cava and right atrium. After insertion and correct positioning of the wire, a vein dilator and sheath will be passed over the guide wire. The guide wire and dilator will be removed, and the catheter will be introduced through the peel-away sheath. After insertion the peel away sheath will be removed (Fig. [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}, [4](#F4){ref-type="fig"}, [5](#F5){ref-type="fig"}, [6](#F6){ref-type="fig"}, [7](#F7){ref-type="fig"}). The catheter will be connected to the port chamber. Using the same incision, a subcutaneous pocket will be prepared on the pectoral fascia. The port chamber will be fixed on the fascia of the pectoral muscle with three single non absorbable sutures. Flow for blood withdrawal and infusion is tested via cutaneous puncture (Huber needle). To complete the procedure the system is blocked with isotonic saline. Primary and secondary endpoints ------------------------------- ### Primary endpoint The primary endpoint will be the primary success rate of the randomized implantation technique. ### Definition of the primary endpoint Primary success of the randomized implantation technique is defined as the correct position of the catheter checked introperatively by radiography and correct function checked by drawing blood and injecting isotonic saline fluid. ### Assessment of the primary endpoint The primary success will be assessed intraoperatively in the CRF. A copy of the intraoperative radiography will be recorded in addition. ### Secondary endpoints • Duration of port implantation procedure • Perioperative complication rate • Postoperative complication rate Safety aspects -------------- ### Specification of safety parameters ### Training for surgeons All surgeons will be briefed and trained in both techniques. The correct placement of the port catheter will be checked after operation with x-ray and recorded in the CRF. ### Concomitant medication Concomitant medication will not be recorded because an interaction between surgical technique and medication of the patients is unlikely and will therefore not be expected. This decision was met in total agreement of all involved study physicians. ### Past medical history Prior and concomitant illness of the patients will be documented in the CRF because discussions between all involved study physicians resulted in the opinion that an interaction between concomitant illness and intervention will be indeed unlikely but could not completely be excluded. ### Adverse events and serious adverse events AEs will be reported to the principle investigator in regular intervals throughout the study. Symptoms anticipated by Chemotherapy and malignant illness progress and therefore unlikely related with the surgical implantation technique will not be recorded as AE. SAEs which are meet one of definitions of the secondary endpoints are treated as SAEs regarding to documentation but have not to be reported to the sponsor/principle investigator within 24 h. They will be reported to the principle investigator in regular intervals throughout the study. Analysis -------- Comparisons will be made of the primary endpoints of both intervention groups for all in the study included patients on an intention to treat basis. Furthermore there will be a second analysis on a \"per protocol\" basis including only patients who get strictly treated according to the study protocol. The outcome measures of the primary endpoint will be tested for significance with the chi square test. Study organization ------------------ All patients scheduled for a primary port-catheter-system implantation procedure in the Outpatient-Clinic of the Department of Surgery, University Hospital of Heidelberg, will be referred to the Centre for Clinical Studies in Surgery (KSC) and screened by members of the KSC \[[@B4]\]. The result of the screening will be recorded in the screening-log. Approximately 500 patients per year undergo a port-catheter-system implantation at the Outpatient-Clinic of the Department of Surgery, University of Heidelberg. The estimated time frame to randomize 180 patients is approximately 18 months. The independent data management and monitoring will be done by the Coordination Centre for Clinical Trials (KKS) Heidelberg. The principal investigator has the right to terminate the trial and to remove all trial material from the trial centre at any time in consultation with the Clinical Study Team Leader and the Biometrician. Reasons that may require a termination of the trial include the following: • The incidence or severity of adverse events in this trial indicates a potential health hazard caused by the study treatment • It appears that patient\'s enrolment is unsatisfactory with respect to quality and/or quantity or data recording is severely inaccurate and/or incomplete • External evidence that makes it necessary to terminate the trial Financial support ----------------- One half of the costs for this study will be financed by the Surgical Foundation Heidelberg (Stiftung Chirurgie Heidelberg), the other half will be sponsored by Fresenius Kabi AG ^©^. This concept of a half-half financial support will help to guarantee the independency of the final study analysis and its results from commercial interests. ###### Flowchart according to CONSORT ------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------- To be assessed for eligibility (n = 280) Total to be excluded (n = 100)\ refusal to participate (n = 40)\ not meeting inclusion criteria prior to surgery (n = 20)\ no cephalic vein present (n = 20)\ other reasons (n = 20) To be randomized (n = 180) Experimental Group Control Group To be allocated to intervention (n = 90)\ To be allocated to intervention (n = 90)\ receive allocated intervention (n = 80)\ receive allocated intervention (n = 80)\ don\'t receive allocated intervention (n = 10) do not receive allocated intervention (n = 10) To be analyzed (n = 80) To be analyzed (n = 80) ------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------ -----------------------------------------------------------

Citation {#SECID0EDAAC} ======== Zhang M, Li T-H, Wang C-Q, Zeng N-K, Deng W-Q (2019)Phylogenetic overview of *Aureoboletus* (Boletaceae, Boletales), with descriptions of six new species from China. MycoKeys 61: 111--145. [https://doi.org/10.3897/mycokeys.61.47520](10.3897/mycokeys.61.47520) Introduction {#SECID0E6AAC} ============ *Aureoboletus* Pouzar was circumscribed in 1957, based on the type species *A. gentilis* (Quél.) Pouzar ([@B28]). It was characterised by its slimy basidiomata, glabrous to subglabrous pileus and golden yellow hymenophore unchanging when dry ([@B29]; [@B31]; [@B28]). To date, 35 species have been described worldwide, 15 of which were originally described in China ([@B26]; [@B32]; [@B55], [@B56], [@B57], [@B54]; [@B53]; [@B19]; [@B47]; [@B12]). *Aureoboletus* species can be found in tropical, subtropical and temperate regions of different continents, but most known species appear to exist in Asia and North America. Interestingly, they are strongly implicated as symbionts with an array of ectotrophic plants of the Fagaceae and Pinaceae families ([@B28]; [@B48]; [@B17]; [@B32]; [@B14]; [@B53]; [@B47]; [@B54]). The establishment and acceptance of the genus *Aureoboletus* has a long history. Xerocomus section Auripori[@B33] was established to accommodate *Aureoboletus*-like taxa. Later, *Auripori* species were transferred to the genus *Pulveroboletus* Murrill ([@B35]). For a long time, the genus *Aureoboletus* was not accepted as an independent genus by some mycologists ([@B37]; [@B10]; [@B36]; [@B7]; [@B1]; [@B40]) and species with viscid basidiomata and vivid yellow hymenophores were variously placed in genera *Boletellus* Murrill, *Boletus* L., *Pulveroboletus* and *Xerocomus* Quél. ([@B33], [@B35], [@B36]; [@B37]; [@B10]; [@B7]; [@B1]); However, *Aureoboletus* was accepted as an independent genus by other mycologists and the features of the genus were redefined ([@B44]; [@B45]; [@B16]; Zang 1993; [@B41]; [@B17]). A world-wide survey of the genus, based on morphological characteristics, was conducted and a key was designed to aid in the identification of 11 global *Aureoboletus* species ([@B17]). Recently, broad-scale molecular phylogenetic studies have been used to investigate phylogenetic relationships amongst the genera and species in Boletes. *Aureoboletus* was strongly supported as a genus in the Boletaceae, subfamily Xerocomoideae and has been shown to be closely related to *Boletellus*, *Hemileccinum* Šutara, *Heimioporus* E. Horak, *Xerocomus* etc. ([@B4]; Binder and Hibbett 2006; [@B24]; [@B46], [@B47]). The genus *Sinoboletus* M. Zang, originally described in south-western China, was proven to be a synonym of *Aureoboletus* ([@B49]; [@B46]); *Boletellus projectellus* (Murrill) Singer, *B. mirabilis* (Murrill) Singer, *B. russellii* (Frost) E.-J. Gilbert and *Pulveroboletus auriflammeus* (Berk. & M.A. Curtis) Singer) were transferred into the genus *Aureoboletus*, based on both morphological and molecular data ([@B14]; [@B47]). Numerous *Aureoboletus* specimens have been recently obtained in China, increasing the species diversity of *Aureoboletus*. In this study, the species richness and phylogenetic relationships were re-evaluated, based on detailed morphological observations and a four-gene phylogenetic inference. The aims were to 1) evaluate the phylogenetic relationships within the genus; 2) redefine the characteristics of *Aureoboletus*; 3) elucidate the species diversity of *Aureoboletus* in China; 4) describe the newly discovered species. Materials and methods {#SECID0E5PAC} ===================== Morphological studies {#SECID0EDAAE} --------------------- Photographs and records of basidiomata were obtained in the field. Specimens were dried in an electric drier and finally deposited in the Fungarium of Guangdong Institute of Microbiology (**GDGM**) or the Fungal Herbarium of Hainan Medical University (**FHMU**), Haikou City, Hainan Province, China. Descriptions of macro-morphological characters and habitats were obtained with photographs and field notes. Colours were described in general terms with serial numbers, for example, reddish-brown (9D8--9E8), following [@B18]. Micro-morphological features were observed from dried materials after sectioning and mounting in 5% potassium hydroxide (KOH) solution and 1% Congo Red or Melzer's reagent under a light microscope (Olympus BX51, Tokyo, Japan). For basidiospore descriptions, an abbreviation \[n/m/p\] denotes n spores measured from m basidiomata of p collections; a notation (a--)b--c(--d) describes basidiospore dimensions, where the range b--c represented 90% or more of the measured values and 'a' and 'd' were the extreme values; Q referred to the length/width ratio of an individual basidiospore and Qm referred to the average Q value of all basidiospores ± sample standard deviation. All line-drawings of microstructures were made, based on rehydrated materials. DNA extraction, PCR amplification and sequencing {#SECID0E4AAE} ------------------------------------------------ Genomic DNA was extracted from the voucher specimens using the Sangon Fungus Genomic DNA Extraction kit (Sangon Biotech Co. Ltd., Shanghai, China), according to the manufacturer's instructions. Primer pairs LR0R/LR5 or LR0R/LR7 ([@B43]), EF1-B-F1/EF1-B-R, RPB1-B-F/RPB1-B-R and RPB2-B-F1/RPB2-B-R ([@B46]) were used for the amplification of the large subunit nuclear ribosomal RNA (nrLSU) region, the translation elongation factor 1-alpha subunit (*tef1-a*), the largest subunit of RNA polymerase II (*rpb1*) and the second largest subunit of RNA polymerase II (*rpb2*), respectively. Polymerase Chain Reaction was performed in a total volume of 25 μl containing 1 μl template DNA, 9.5 μl distilled water, 1 μl of each primer and 12.5 μl PCR mix \[DreamTaqtm Green PCR Master Mix (2×), Fermentas\]. Amplification reactions were performed in a Tprofessional Standard thermocycler (Biometra, Göttingen, Germany) under the following conditions: at 95 °C for 4 min, then 35 cycles of denaturation at 95 °C for 60 s, annealing at 53 °C (LSU) /55 °C (*tef1-a*, *rpb1* and *rpb2*) for 60 s and extension at 72 °C for 80 s, with a final extension at 72 °C for 8 min. The PCR products were electrophoresed on 1% agarose gels with known standard DNA markers and sequences were performed on an ABI Prism 3730 Genetic Analyzer (PE Applied Biosystems, Foster, CA, USA) at Beijing Genomic Institute (BGI) using the same primers. The raw sequences were assembled with SeqMan implemented in Lasergene v7.1 (DNASTAR Inc., USA). The assembled sequences of the specimens were submitted to GenBank. Phylogenetic analyses {#SECID0ENCAE} --------------------- Newly generated sequences and related sequences downloaded from GenBank were used to reconstruct phylogenetic trees. Detailed information of samples, including species name, voucher, locality, GenBank accession numbers and references, are given in Table [1](#T1){ref-type="table"}. Four sequence datasets (nrLSU, *tef1-a*, *rpb1* and *rpb2*) were separately aligned with MAFFT v6.853 using the E-INS-i strategy (Katoh et al. 2002) and examined in Bioedit v7.0.9 ([@B13]). The four datasets were analysed independently using the Maximum Likelihood (ML) method to detect the topologies of the four genes. Since no significant incongruence was detected (BS \> 70%), the four single-gene alignments were concatenated using Phyutility 2.2 ([@B38]). Missing fragments of some gene markers of several specimens were coded as missing data, intron regions of protein-coding genes were retained in the final analyses and the ambiguously aligned regions were detected and excluded with Gblocks ([@B8]). ###### Information of samples used in this study. ------------------------- ------------- ------------------------ ---------------------- ---------------------- ----------------------- ---------------------- ------------------- Taxon Voucher Country LSU tef1 rpb1 rpb2 Reference *A. auriflammeus* DD973 USA [AY612818](AY612818) \_ \_ \_ GenBank *A. auriporus* MAN020 Costa Rica [JQ003659](JQ003659) \_ \_ \_ [@B23] BDCR0431 Costa Rica [HQ161871](HQ161871) \_ [HQ161840](HQ161840) \_ [@B11] A. cf. auriporus GDGM 44404 USA [MN410705](MN410705) \_ \_ \_ This study *A. catenarius* GDGM 45142 China [MN204514](MN204514) \_ [MN473157](MN473157) \_ This study HKAS54463 China [KT990509](KT990509) [KT990710](KT990710) [KT990890](KT990890) [KT990348](KT990348) [@B47] HKAS54467 China [KT990510](KT990510) [KT990711](KT990711) \_ [KT990349](KT990349) [@B47] *A. citriniporus* REH8719 USA [KF030298](KF030298) \_ \_ \_ [@B24] *A. clavatus* GDGM42992 China [MK123462](MK123462) [MK165847](MK165847) \_ \_ [@B53] GDGM42962 China [KR052045](KR052045) [MK165846](MK165846) [KR052056](KR052056) \_ [@B53] GDGM42963 China [KR052046](KR052046) [KR052054](KR052054) [KR052057](KR052057) \_ [@B53] GDGM42984 China [KR052047](KR052047) [KR052055](KR052055) \_ \_ [@B53] *A. duplicatoporus* GDGM 49451 China [MN204515](MN204515) \_ [MN473160](MN473160) \_ This study GDGM 53135 China [MN204517](MN204517) [MN549677](MN549677) [MN473167](MN473167) \_ This study GDGM 53134 China [MN204516](MN204516) \_ [MN473166](MN473166) [MN549707](MN549707) This study GDGM 52898 China [MN410708](MN410708) \_ [MN473164](MN473164) \_ This study GDGM 53181 China [MN204518](MN204518) [MN549669](MN549669) [MN473168](MN473168) \_ This study GDGM 71293 China [MN204519](MN204519) \_ [MN473173](MN473173) \_ This study GDGM 71724 China [MN204520](MN204520) \_ [MN473175](MN473175) \_ This study HKAS50498 China [KF112361](KF112361) [KF112230](KF112230) [KF112561](KF112561) [KF112754](KF112754) [@B47] HKAS63009 China [KT990511](KT990511) [KT990712](KT990712) [KT990891](KT990891) [KT990350](KT990350) [@B47] HKAS83115 China [KT990512](KT990512) [KT990713](KT990713) [KT990892](KT990892) [KT990351](KT990351) [@B47] GDGM45133 China [MK123455](MK123455) [MK165834](MK165834) \_ [MN549697](MN549697) This study GDGM52889 China [MK123456](MK123456) [MK165835](MK165835) [MN473163](MN473163) \_ This study *A. formosus* GDGM44441 China [KT291749](KT291749) [KT291744](KT291744) [MN473152](MN473152) [KT291751](KT291751) Zhang et al. 2015 GDGM44444 China [KT291750](KT291750) [MK165833](MK165833) [MN473153](MN473153) [KT291752](KT291752) Zhang et al. 2015 *A. gentilis* Pug1 Germany [DQ534635](DQ534635) [KF030399](KF030399) \_ \_ [@B24] MG372a Italy [KF112344](KF112344) [KF134014](KF134014) [KF112557](KF112557) [KF112741](KF112741) [@B46] *A. glutinosus* GDGM 55717 China [MN204522](MN204522) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 45927 China [MN204521](MN204521) \_ \- [MN549699](MN549699) This study GDGM44476 China [MH670254](MH670254) [MH700192](MH700192) \_ [MH700228](MH700228) This study GDGM44477 China [MH670255](MH670255) [MH700205](MH700205) \_ [MH700229](MH700229) This study GDGM44479 China [MH670256](MH670256) [MH700204](MH700204) \_ [MH700230](MH700230) This study GDGM44733 China [MH670257](MH670257) [MH700203](MH700203) \_ [MH700231](MH700231) This study GDGM44821 China [MH670258](MH670258) \_ \_ [MH700232](MH700232) This study *A. griseolorufescens* GDGM28490 China [MH670278](MH670278) \_ \_ [MH700241](MH700241) This study ZhangM131 China [MH670279](MH670279) \_ [MH700220](MH700220) [MH700242](MH700242) This study *A. innixus* 136/98 USA [DQ534639](DQ534639) \_ \_ \_ [@B6] MB03-104 USA [KF030239](KF030239) [KF030400](KF030400) \_ \_ [@B24] 136 USA [KF030240](KF030240) \_ \_ \_ [@B24] *A. liquidus* TNS:F-39710 Japan [AB972886](AB972886) \_ \_ \_ [@B42] TNS:F-52265 Japan [AB972884](AB972884) \_ \_ \_ [@B42] TNS:F-52267 Japan [AB972885](AB972885) \_ \_ \_ [@B42] *A. longicollis* GDGM 70547 China [MN204526](MN204526) \_ [MN473172](MN473172) \_ This study GDGM 75292 China [MN204527](MN204527) \_ [MN473179](MN473179) \_ This study GDGM 49735 China [MN204525](MN204525) \_ [MN473161](MN473161) \_ This study GDGM 43502 China [MN204524](MN204524) \_ [MN473150](MN473150) [MN549688](MN549688) This study ZhangM56 China [MN204528](MN204528) \_ [MN473187](MN473187) \_ This study GDGM43239 China [MK123459](MK123459) [MK165843](MK165843) [MN473147](MN473147) \_ This study HKAS80127 China [KT990515](KT990515) [KT990719](KT990719) \_ \_ [@B53] GDGM42849 China [KR052051](KR052051) \_ [KR052058](KR052058) \_ [@B53] HKAS53398 China [KF112376](KF112376) [KF112238](KF112238) [KF112625](KF112625) [KF112755](KF112755) [@B53] HKAS84679 China [KT990514](KT990514) [KT990718](KT990718) \_ [KT990356](KT990356) [@B53] HKAS80489 China [KT990523](KT990523) [KT990727](KT990727) \_ [KT990364](KT990364) [@B53] GDGM44734 China [MK123458](MK123458) [MK165842](MK165842) [MN473155](MN473155) [MN549692](MN549692) This study GDGM53336 China [MK123460](MK123460) [MK165844](MK165844) [MN473170](MN473170) [MN549701](MN549701)8 This study GDGM44739 China [MK123461](MK123461) [MK165845](MK165845) [MN473156](MN473156) [MN549693](MN549693) This study *A. marronius* GDGM43288 China [KJ488958](KJ488958) [KT291746](KT291746) \_ [KT291753](KT291753) [@B55] *A. miniatoaurantiacus* GDGM 75495 China [MN204533](MN204533) \_ [MN473181](MN473181) [MN549711](MN549711) This study GDGM 53350 China [MN204532](MN204532) [MN549678](MN549678) [MN473171](MN473171) [MN549709](MN549709) This study GDGM 43437 China [MN204530](MN204530) \_ [MN473149](MN473149) [MN549687](MN549687) This study GDGM 43282 China [MN204529](MN204529) [MN549671](MN549671) [MN473148](MN473148) [MN549686](MN549686) This study GDGM 44727 China [MN204531](MN204531) \_ [MN473154](MN473154) [MN549691](MN549691) This study GDGM53501 China [MH670262](MH670262) [MH700199](MH700199) [MH700217](MH700217) \_ This study Zeng1625 China [MH670263](MH670263) \_ \_ \_ This study Zeng1294 China [MH670264](MH670264) [MH700198](MH700198) \_ \_ This study Zeng1323 China [MH670265](MH670265) [MH700197](MH700197) \_ \_ This study Zeng1339 China [MH670266](MH670266) [MH700196](MH700196) \_ \_ This study Zeng664 China [MH670267](MH670267) [MH700195](MH700195) \_ \_ This study HKAS59694 China [KT990513](KT990513) [KT990714](KT990714) [KT990893](KT990893) [KT990352](KT990352) [@B47] GDGM42855 China [MH670259](MH670259) [MH700202](MH700202) [MH700214](MH700214) [MH700233](MH700233) This study GDGM53274 China [MH670260](MH670260) [MH700201](MH700201) [MH700215](MH700215) [MH700234](MH700234) This study GDGM52888 China [MH670261](MH670261) [MH700200](MH700200) [MH700216](MH700216) [MH700235](MH700235) This study *A. mirabilis* REH9765 USA [KP327661](KP327661) [KP327661](KP327661) \_ \_ [@B14] CBS-136.60 Germany [AF050652](AF050652) \_ \_ \_ [@B5] HKAS57776 China [KF112360](KF112360) [KF112229](KF112229) [KF112624](KF112624) [KF112743](KF112743) [@B46] REH8717 USA [KF030299](KF030299) \_ \_ \_ [@B24] *A. moravicus* Xle1 Germany \_ [KF030403](KF030403) \_ \_ [@B24] MG374a Italy [KF112421](KF112421) [KF112232](KF112232) [KF112559](KF112559) [KF112745](KF112745) [@B46] *A. nephrosporus* HKAS67931 China [KT990516](KT990516) [KT990720](KT990720) [KT99089](KT99089) [KT990357](KT990357) [@B47] HKAS74929 China [KT990517](KT990517) [KT990721](KT990721) [KT990896](KT990896) [KT990358](KT990358) [@B47] *A. novoguineensis* K-A/7 Japan [DQ534637](DQ534637) \_ \_ \_ [@B6] *A. projectellus* MB-03-118 USA [NG027638](NG027638) \_ \_ \_ GenBank NYBG13392 USA [KP327622](KP327622) [KP327675](KP327675) \_ \_ [@B14] Sn2Hor USA [KF030300](KF030300) \_ \_ \_ [@B24] NYBG13393 USA [KP327623](KP327623) [KP327676](KP327676) \_ \_ [@B14] ID-713 USA [DQ534582](DQ534582) [AY879116](AY879116) [AY788850](AY788850) [AY787218](AY787218) [@B6] *A. quercus-spinosae* GDGM 43757 China [KY039966](KY039966) [MK165839](MK165839) [KY039962](KY039962) [KY039957](KY039957) [@B54] GDGM43757 China [KY039966](KY039966) [MK165839](MK165839) [KY039962](KY039962) [KY039957](KY039957) [@B54] GDGM43755 China [KY039967](KY039967) [MK165836](MK165836) [KY039963](KY039963) [KY039958](KY039958) [@B54] GDGM43758 China [KY039968](KY039968) [MK165837](MK165837) [KY039964](KY039964) [KY039959](KY039959) [@B54] GDGM43786 China [KY039969](KY039969) [MK165838](MK165838) [KY039965](KY039965) [KY039960](KY039960) [@B54] *A. raphanaceus* GDGM 45966 China [MN204536](MN204536) [MN549673](MN549673) \_ [MN549700](MN549700) This study GDGM 52266 China [MN204538](MN204538) [MN549674](MN549674) \_ [MN549702](MN549702) This study GDGM 45911 China [MN204535](MN204535) \_ \_ [MN549698](MN549698) This study GDGM 52908 China [MN204539](MN204539) [MN549675](MN549675) \_ \_ This study GDGM 49634 China [MN204537](MN204537) \_ \_ [MN549701](MN549701) This study GDGM 53127 China [MN204540](MN204540) [MN549676](MN549676) [MN473165](MN473165) [MN549706](MN549706) This study GDGM 75476 China [MN204541](MN204541) \_ [MN473166](MN473166) [MN549707](MN549707) This study GDGM 42937 China [MN204534](MN204534) \_ [MN473146](MN473146) [MN549685](MN549685) This study GDGM52543 China [MH670271](MH670271) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM44832 China [MH670268](MH670268) [MH700194](MH700194) [MH700218](MH700218) [MH700236](MH700236) This study GDGM50266 China [MH670269](MH670269) \_ \_ [MH700237](MH700237) This study GDGM46333 China [MH670270](MH670270) \_ \_ [MH700238](MH700238) This study GDGM52590 China [MH670272](MH670272) [MH700193](MH700193) [MH700219](MH700219) [MN549704](MN549704) This study *A. roxanae* DS626-7 USA [KF030311](KF030311) [KF030402](KF030402) [KF030381](KF030381) \_ [@B24] *A. rubellus* GDGM52382 China [MH670273](MH670273) \_ \_ [MH700239](MH700239) This study GDGM52367 China [MH670274](MH670274) \_ \_ [MH700240](MH700240) This study *A. shichianus* HKAS43373 China [AY647211](AY647211) \_ \_ \_ GenBank HKAS76852 China [KF112419](KF112419) [KF112237](KF112237) [KF112562](KF112562) [KF112756](KF112756) [@B46] *A. sinobadius* GDGM75499 China [MN204551](MN204551) \_ [MN473182](MN473182) \_ This study GDGM 70666 China [MN204547](MN204547) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 49747 China [MN204546](MN204546) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 49670 China [MN204545](MN204545) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 71932 China [MN204548](MN204548) \_ [MN473176](MN473176) \_ This study *A. sinobadius* GDGM 49482 China [MN204544](MN204544) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 72253 China [MN204549](MN204549) \_ [MN473177](MN473177) \_ This study GDGM 49432 China [MN204543](MN204543) \_ [MN473159](MN473159) \_ This study GDGM 75477 China [MN204550](MN204550) \_ [MN473180](MN473180) \_ This study GDGM44473 China [MH670250](MH670250) [MH700189](MH700189) [MH700211](MH700211) \_ This study GDGM43275 China [MH6702464](MH6702464) [MH700185](MH700185) [MH700208](MH700208) [MH700221](MH700221) This study GDGM44732 China [MH670247](MH670247) [MH700186](MH700186) [MH700207](MH700207) [MH700222](MH700222) This study GDGM44730 China [MH670248](MH670248) [MH700187](MH700187) [MH700209](MH700209) [MH700223](MH700223) This study GDGM44736 China [MH670249](MH670249) [MH700188](MH700188) [MH700210](MH700210) [MH700224](MH700224) This study *A. solus* GDGM46222 China [MH670275](MH670275) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM44759 China [MH670276](MH670276) [MH700206](MH700206) \_ \_ This study GDGM42822 China [MH670277](MH670277) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 49600 China [MN410707](MN410707) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 49404 China [MN204553](MN204553) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 46807 China [MN204552](MN204552) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 72441 China [MN204555](MN204555) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 70342 China [MN204554](MN204554) \_ \_ \_ This study *Aureoboletus* sp. GDGM 49259 China [MN410706](MN410706) \_ [MN473158](MN473158) \_ This study GDGM 71707 China [MN204556](MN204556) \_ [MN473174](MN473174) [MN549710](MN549710) This study GDGM 75305 China [MN204513](MN204513) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 70474 China [MN204511](MN204511) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 72473 China [MN204512](MN204512) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 44470 China [MN204509](MN204509) [MN549672](MN549672) \_ [MN549680](MN549680) This study GDGM 52298 China [MN204523](MN204523) \_ [MN473162](MN473162) [MN549703](MN549703) This study LAM-0466 Malaysia [KY091058](KY091058) \_ \_ \_ GenBank HKAS53458 China [KF112456](KF112456) [KF112231](KF112231) [KF112558](KF112558) [KF112742](KF112742) This study GDGM44829 China [KY039970](KY039970) \_ \_ [KY039961](KY039961) This study GDGM44831 China [KY039971](KY039971) [MK165840](MK165840) \_ [MN549696](MN549696) This study GDGM44469 China [KP319028](KP319028) [MK165841](MK165841) \_ [MN549690](MN549690) This study *A. tenuis* GDGM42601 China [KF534789](KF534789) [KT291745](KT291745) \_ [KT291754](KT291754) Zhang et al. 2013 *A. thibetanus* HKAS76655 China [KF112420](KF112420) [KF112236](KF112236) [KF112626](KF112626) [KF112752](KF112752) [@B46] GDGM43283 China [KJ907380](KJ907380) [KT291747](KT291747) \_ [KT291755](KT291755) [@B55] GDGM43284 China [KJ90738](KJ90738) [KT291748](KT291748) \_ [KT291756](KT291756) [@B55] HKAS57692 China [KT990524](KT990524) [KT990728](KT990728) [KT990901](KT990901) [KT990365](KT990365) [@B47] HKAS89494 China [KT990525](KT990525) [KT990729](KT990729) [KT990902](KT990902) [KT990366](KT990366) [@B47] *A. velutipes* GDGM52409 China [MH670252](MH670252) \_ \_ [MH700225](MH700225) This study GDGM44713 China [MH670253](MH670253) [MH700191](MH700191) [MH700213](MH700213) [MH700226](MH700226) This study GDGM42608 China [MH670251](MH670251) [MH700190](MH700190) [MH700212](MH700212) [MN549683](MN549683) This study A. cf. venustus ZhangM142 China [MN204558](MN204558) [MN549668](MN549668) [MN473186](MN473186) [MN549714](MN549714) This study A-2 China [MN204557](MN204557) [MN549679](MN549679) [MN473185](MN473185) [MN549713](MN549713) This study GDGM42800 China [MK123463](MK123463) \_ [MN473187](MN473187) [MN549684](MN549684) This study *A. venustus* HKAS82183 China [KU321705](KU321705) \_ \_ \_ [@B19] HKAS77700 China [KU321703](KU321703) \_ \_ \_ [@B19] *A. viridiflavus* DD972 USA [AY612805](AY612805) \_ \_ \_ GenBank *A. viscidipes* GDGM 44818 China [MN204510](MN204510) \_ \_ [MN549694](MN549694) This study HKAS77103 China [KT990519](KT990519) [KT990723](KT990723) \_ [KT990360](KT990360) [@B47] GDGM44820 China [MK123457](MK123457) \_ \_ [MN549695](MN549695) This study *A. yunnanensis* GDGM 26359 China [MN204560](MN204560) [MN549670](MN549670) [MN473145](MN473145) [MN549681](MN549681) This study GDGM 24560 China [MN204559](MN204559) \_ [MN473144](MN473144) [MN549682](MN549682) This study HKAS57581 China [KF112422](KF112422) [KF112233](KF112233) [KF112560](KF112560) [KF112746](KF112746) [@B47] HKAS75050 China [KT990520](KT990520) [KT990724](KT990724) [KT990898](KT990898) [KT990361](KT990361) [@B47] *A. zangii* GDGM 75881 China [MN204563](MN204563) \- [MN473183](MN473183) [MN549712](MN549712) This study GDGM 28577 China [MN204561](MN204561) \_ \_ \_ This study GDGM 44406 China [MN204562](MN204562) \_ [MN473151](MN473151) [MN549689](MN549689) This study HKAS63217 China [KT990526](KT990526) \_ \_ \_ [@B47] HKAS74751 China [KT990521](KT990521) [KT990725](KT990725) [KT990899](KT990899) [KT990362](KT990362) [@B47] HKAS74766 China [KT990522](KT990522) [KT990726](KT990726) [KT990900](KT990900) [KT990363](KT990363) [@B47] *P. imbricatus* HKAS68642 China [KF112398](KF112398) [KF112299](KF112299) [KF112637](KF112637) [KF112786](KF112786) [@B46] X. aff. subtomentosus HKAS58865 China [KF112389](KF112389) [KF112294](KF112294) [KF112630](KF112630) [KF112784](KF112784) [@B46] ------------------------- ------------- ------------------------ ---------------------- ---------------------- ----------------------- ---------------------- ------------------- The combined final dataset was analysed using RAxML v7.2.6 ([@B39]) and MrBayes v3.1.2 ([@B30]) for Maximum Likelihood (ML) and Bayesian Inference (BI), respectively. For both BI and ML analyses, the substitution model, suitable for each gene partition, was determined using the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), complemented in MrModeltest v2.3 ([@B25]). All parameters in the ML analysis were kept as defaults except for choosing GTRGAMMAI as the model and statistical supports were obtained using rapid non-parametric bootstrapping with 1000 replicates; BI analysis using 4 chains were conducted by setting generations to 80 million and stoprul command with the value of stopval set to 0.01, trees were sampled every 100 generations, the first 25% generations were discarded as burn-ins and posterior probabilities (PP) were then calculated from the posterior distribution of the retained Bayesian trees. *Phylloporus imbricatus* N.K. Zeng, Zhu L. Yang & L.P. Tang and *Xerocomus subtomentosus* (L.) Quél. were selected as outgroups, based on [@B47] and [@B54]. Results {#SECID0EDZAK} ======= Molecular phylogenetic results {#SECID0EHZAK} ------------------------------ For phylogenetic analyses, 304 (102 nrLSU, 59 *tef1-a*, 71 *rpb1* and 72 *rpb2*) new sequences from 105 *Aureoboletus* collections and 171 GenBank downloaded sequences from 68 *Aureoboletus* samples were used as ingroups. Four sequences of *P. imbricatus* and *X. subtomentosus*, respectively, retrieved from GenBank were used as outgroups. The combined matrix of 175 samples with 3018 nucleotide sites was submitted to TreeBASE (Submission ID 25249). HKY+G, GTR+I+G, SYM+I and SYM+G were chosen as the best substitution models for nrLSU, *tef1-a*, *rpb1* and *rpb2*, respectively. ML and BI analyses generated almost identical tree topologies with minimal variations in statistical support values. Thus, only a ML tree is displayed (Fig. [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). {#F1} In the multi-gene phylogenetic trees, the monophyly of *Aureoboletus* was statistically strongly supported (BS = 100, PP = 1); eight well supported main clades, labelled as Clade I to VIII, are shown and six well supported (BS = 100, PP = 1) new species lineages were recognised. In Clade I, nine known species \[*A. auriporus* (Peck) Pouza, *A. duplicatoporus* (M. Zang) G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang, *A. formosus* Ming Zhang & T.H. Li, *A. gentilis* (Quél.) Pouzar, *A. novoguineensis* Hongo, *A. quercus-spinosae* Ming Zhang & T.H. Li, *A. venustus* Fang Li, Kuan Zhao & Qing Li Deng, *A. viridiflavus* Coker & Beers ex Klofac and *A. zangii* X.F. Shi & P.G. Liu\] were presented, including the type species *A. gentilis* and a new lineage (lineage I) discovered in this study. Lineage I is presented as a sister group to *A. novoguineensis* with significant statistical support (BS = 100, PP = 1). Clade II comprised five known species \[*A. catenarius* G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang, *A. citriniporus* (Halling) Klofac, *A. moravicus* (Vaček) Klofac, *A. roxanae* (Frost) Klofac and *A. yunnanensis* G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang\], a new lineage (lineage II) and three unnamed sequences. Lineage II is closely related to an unnamed sample (GDGM71707) from southern China. Clade III is composed of six species, \[*A. longicollis* (Ces.) N.K. Zeng & Ming Zhang, *A. marroninus* T.H. Li & Ming Zhang, *A. tenuis* T.H. Li & Ming Zhang, *A. thibetanus* (Pat.) Hongo & Nagas., *A. viscidipes* (Hongo) G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang\] and a new lineage (lineage III), all of which are from Asia. Clade IV was comprised of the North American species *A. auriflammeus* (Berk. & M.A. Curtis) G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang and a new species combination from China. Clade V included five strongly supported species level groups \[*A. innixus* (Frost) Halling, A.R. Bessette & Bessette, *A. nephrosporus* G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang, *A. rubellus* Kuan Zhao & G. Wu\] and two new lineages (lineage IV and lineage V). Clade VI included four known species \[*A. mirabilis* (Murrill) Halling, *A. projectellus* (Murrill) Halling, *A. russellii* (Frost) G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang from North America and *A. shichianus* (Teng & L. Ling) G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang from China\]. Clade VII had a single species, *A. clavatus* N.K. Zeng & Ming Zhang, which was recently reported in southern China. Clade VIII represents a single new lineage (lineage VI), which is the basal group of the genus *Aureoboletus*. Taxonomy {#SECID0EDJBK} -------- ### Aureoboletus Fungi Boletales Boletaceae Pouzar, Česká Mykol. 11: 48, 1957. 73CC6FFD-0074-5AFA-A9C3-025084834F65 #### Type species . *Aureoboletus gentilis* (Quél.) Pouzar. #### Description. Basidiomata small to large. Pileus viscid, dry or sticky when wet, even or smooth to wrinkled, usually subtomentose, rarely glabrous, with or without veil or velar residues hanging at margin. Context white to yellowish-white, usually pinkish to reddish-brown beneath pileipellis, unchanging or changing blue or greenish or pastel red when exposed. Tubes coloured with all kinds of yellows, pale yellow, golden yellow to bright yellow, unchanging or slightly changing to blue when bruised, pores circular to angular, smaller to larger, somewhat relatively larger and shallowly depressed around the stipe, concolorous with tubes. Stipe central, cylindrical or clavate, surface glabrous to striate fibrillose, never or rare forming reticulation or *Leccinum*-like scabrous, dry to viscid, with white basal mycelium. Basidiospores smooth to verrucose or longitudinally striate, subfusiform, oblong ovoid to subglobose, yellowish to yellowish-brown in KOH. Hymenophoral trama boletoid, composed of subcylindrical to cylindrical hyphae, colourless. Pleurocystidia fusiform to subclavate, thin- or thick-walled, sometimes containing golden-yellow contents at first, then gradually changing to yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Cheilocystidia present, infrequent or absent, usually similar to pleurocystidia in shape and size, if present. Pileipellis as an interwoven trichoderm, trichoderm or ixotrichoderm, consisting of erect hyphae which are occasionally branched, cylindrical to clavate, thin- to slightly thick-walled, usually less than 1 μm. Stipitipellis hymeniform, as an ixotrichoderm to intricated ixotrichoderm. Caulocystidia clavate, fusoid or ventricose-fusoid. Stipe trama composed of parallel hyphae. Clamp connections absent. #### Distribution and ecology. World-wide distribution, mainly known from subtropical Asia and temperate zones of the Northern hemisphere, growing on the ground associated with Fagaceae and other broadleaf trees. Descriptions of six new species and one new combination of *Aureoboletus* {#SECID0EYLBK} ------------------------------------------------------------------------- ### Aureoboletus glutinosus Fungi Boletales Boletaceae Ming Zhang & T.H. Li sp. nov. 9D187891-0F47-5FE3-9663-A5E20FEFDB0B 827103 [Figs 2A, B](#F3){ref-type="fig"} [, 3A](#F4){ref-type="fig"} [, 4A--E](#F5){ref-type="fig"} #### Diagnosis. This species is distinguished from other *Aureoboletus* taxa by its smaller and glutinous basidiomata, reddish-brown to ruby pileus usually with irregular reticulation and darker folds, gelatinised veil remnants and smooth basidiospores 10--13.5 × 4.5--5 µm in size. #### Etymology. "*glutinosus*" refers to the glutinous basidiomata. #### Type. China, Hunan Province, Rucheng Town, Jiulongjiang National Forest Park, on soil and usually growing amongst the mosses under the broadleaf forest, at 25°38\'N, 113°77\'E, alt. 300 m, 8 May 2014, M. Zhang (holotype: GDGM44477). #### Description. Basidiomata small-sized. Pileus 1--2 cm wide, obtuse to convex, becoming broadly convex to plane, fleshy, viscid, especially when young and wet, reddish-brown, violet brown to greyish-ruby (9E6--12E6, 9E7--12E7), slightly fading to pale yellow (2A3--4A3) towards margin, usually forming a pale yellow to even nearly white zone at margin, distinctly wrinkled and often reticulate irregularly with somewhat darker folds at centre, strongly glutinous or mucilaginous when fresh; margin somewhat involute to nearly flat, often attached with yellowish-white to subhyaline and strongly gelatinised veil remnants. Context 2--5 mm thick at stipe, firm and tough in youth, soft when matured, white on the whole, greyish-red (10B5--11B5) beneath pileipellis, practically unchanging to becoming slightly greyish-pinkish or greyish-red (10B5--11B5) when exposed. Tubes 7--10 mm deep, distinctly depressed around stipe, yellowish-white (2A2--4A2) when young, becoming pale yellow, greyish-yellow, pastel yellow to olive yellow (2A3--4A3, 1B3--2B3, 2A4--3A4, 2C6--3C6) with age, often with an olive tint, unchanging when bruised. Pores 0.3--0.5 mm in diam., mostly subangular, slightly radially elongated around stipe at maturity, smaller near pileus margin, concolorous with tubes. Stipe 15--40 × 2--4 mm, central, cylindrical or narrowly clavate, solid, equal to slightly tender downwards, greyish-orange (6B4), greyish-red (7B4) to brownish-orange (6C4--7C4), without reticulation, smooth to faintly longitudinally striate, gelatinous or strongly viscid when young and wet, usually covered with a mucilaginous layer, with white basal mycelium. Odour not distinct. Taste mild. Basidiospores \[150/4/4\] (9.5--)10--13.5 × (4--)4.5--5 µm, Q = (2.2--)2.3--2.5(--2.7), Q~m~ = 2.48 ± 0.18, subfusiform and inequilateral in side view, oblong in ventral view, smooth, yellowish to yellowish-brown in 5% KOH and yellow brown to dark brown in Melzer's reagent, thin-walled. Basidia 20--30 × 7--10 µm, clavate, 4-spored, sterigmata 2--4.5 µm long, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, without basal clamps. Pleurocystidia 35--60 × 8--13 μm, fusiform, thin-walled. Cheilocystidia frequent, similar to pleurocystidia in shape and size. Hymenophoral trama composed of subparallel hyphae 4--10 μm broad, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Pileipellis an ixotrichodermium of erect hyphae 5--12 μm in diameter, branched, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, dextrinoid in Melzer's reagent; terminal cells 27--50 × 7--12 µm, cylindrical, clavate or nearly fusoid. Stipitipellis a layer of repent to suberect branching hyphae 3--6 μm in diam., hyaline in 5% KOH. Clamp connections absent in all tissues. #### Ecology and distribution. Solitary or scattered on ground with humus and debris, usually growing amongst the mosses (*Fissidens* sp. and *Pottiaceae* sp.) under Fagaceae, mixed with other broadleaf trees, alt. 300--500 m; May to July, known from Guangdong and Anhui Province. #### Additional specimens examined. China, Hunan Province, Chenzhou City, Rucheng Town, Jiulongjian National Forest Park, 8 May 2014, H. Huang (GDGM44476); Same location, 12 June 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM44733); Anhui Province, Huangshan City, Huangshan National Forest Park, 27 July 2015, C.H. Li (GDGM44821). #### Notes. Phylogenetic analyses showed that *A. glutinosus* is closely related to *A. marroninus*, *A. tenuis*, *A. thibetanus* and *A. viscidipes*; however, the independent phylogenetic position and different morphological characters can distinguish *A. glutinosus* from these similar species. *Aureoboletus marroninus* differs in having a more wrinkled and darker (violet brown or maroon) pileus, white context and smaller basidiospores 8.5--10 × 4--4.5 µm ([@B55]). *Aureoboletus tenuis* has relatively larger basidiomata (pileus up to 3.5 cm broad) usually lacking well-developed veil remnants on pileus margin, smaller basidiospores 11--12 × 4--5 μm and ixotrichodermial stipitipellis composed of terminal hyphae with swollen tips ([@B55]). *Aureoboletus thibetanus* is readily separated by its more robust basidiomata (pileus up to 5 cm broad), white ridged reticulation on pileus surface, white stipe and yellowish granular encrustation on cystidia and only known from the temperate zone in southwest China ([@B26]; [@B48]; [@B17]). *Aureoboletus viscidipes* differs in having a brownish to brown pileus tinged with yellowish-white, a longer (up to 4 cm long) and nearly white stipe and a thick layer of a reflective pale-yellow substance on the surface of cheilocystidia and pleurocystidia ([@B47]). {#F3} {#F4} {#F5} ### Aureoboletus griseorufescens Fungi Boletales Boletaceae Ming Zhang & T.H. Li sp. nov. FF940C3D-2515-5196-B72D-7FFB38769053 827104 [Figs 2C](#F3){ref-type="fig"} [, 3B](#F4){ref-type="fig"} [, 5A--E](#F6){ref-type="fig"} #### Diagnosis. This taxon can be distinguished from other *Aureoboletus* species by its brownish-orange to ruby pileus colour, white to yellowish-white context changing to greyish-red or greyish-rose when exposed, light yellow tubes and comparatively small basidiospores 9--10.5 × 4.5--5 μm. #### Etymology. "*griseorufescens*" refers to the greyish-red discolouration of context when exposed or bruised. #### Type. China, Guangdong Province, Shaoguan City, Chebaling National Natural Reserve, on soil under the broadleaf forest dominated by Fagaceae trees, alt. 300 m, 23°22\'N, 113°42\'E, 15 July 2008, C.Y. Deng (holotype: GDGM28490) . #### Description. Basidiomata small to medium-sized. Pileus 2--5 cm wide, hemispheric when young, becoming convex to nearly plane in age, fleshy, subviscid or slightly viscid when wet, glabrous to minutely velvet-subtomentose, slightly wrinkled to rugulose, even or nearly so at margin, brownish-orange, brownish-red, dark red to greyish-ruby (6C6--7 to 11C6--7). Context 3--6 mm thick at centre, firm and tough, white to yellowish-white (2A1--2 to 3A1--2), more or less greyish-red (9C4--11C4) beneath the pileipellis and browner at the border line adjacent to tubes, gradually changing to greyish-red (9C4--11C4) to greyish-rose (12B5) when exposed. Tubes 2--4 mm deep, light yellow, yellow, pastel yellow to greenish-yellow (2A5, 3A4--6), unchanging when bruised. Pores small, 1--2 per mm, circular to angular, somewhat relatively larger and shallowly depressed around the stipe at maturity, concolorous with tubes, unchanging when bruised. Stipe 35--60 × 4--10 mm, central, cylindrical or clavate, equal to slightly enlarged downwards, smooth, viscid in wet condition, concolorous with pileus, pale in the apex. Stipe context white to reddish-white (9A2--11A2), gradually changing to greyish-red (9C4--11D5) to greyish-rose (12B5) when exposed, especially in the lower part. Basal mycelium white. Odour none. Taste mild. Basidiospores \[50/2/2\] (8--)9--10.5(--11) × (4--)4.5--5(--5.5) μm, Q = (1.8--)2--2.2 (2.6), Q~m~ = 2.19 ± 0.18, subfusiform and inequilateral in side view, oblong in ventral view, smooth, yellowish to yellowish-brown in 5% KOH and yellow brown to dark brown in Melzer's reagent, thin-walled. Basidia 4-spored 25--30 × 7--11 μm, clavate, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, sterigmata 2--3 μm. Cheilocystidia infrequent. Pleurocystidia 43--70 × 8--13 μm, fusiform, thin-walled, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Hymenophoral trama composed of subparallel hyphae 5--8 μm broad, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Pileipellis an entangled trichodermium of erect hyphae 12--19 μm in diameter, branched, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, yellow brown to dark brown in Melzer's reagent, terminal cells 20--50 × 6--10 μm, cylindrical, clavate or nearly fusoid. Stipitipellis a tangled layer of repent to suberect branching hyphae 7--10 μm in diam., hyaline in 5% KOH, with terminal cells 22--30 × 7--18 μm. Caulocystidia 43--58 × 12--18 μm, numerous, in clusters, clavate, fusoid or fusoid ventricose, mostly clavate, swollen at apex and usually contain yellow to yellowish-brown substance at an early stage in 5% KOH. Clamp connections absent in all tissues. #### Ecology and distribution. Solitary or scattered on ground with humus and debris under Fagaceae trees, mixed with other broadleaf trees, alt. 200--400 m; June to September; currently only known from southern China. #### Additional specimens examined. China, Hainan Province, Changjiang County, Bawangling National Forest Park, 7 July 2013, M. Zhang (ZhangM131). #### Notes. *Aureoboletus griseorufescens* is somewhat similar to the recently reported species *A. venustus* from southern China; however, the latter taxon differs in having relatively larger (pileus up to 8 cm) and more viscous basidiomata, a reddish-orange pileus and broader basidiospores 7.5--10.5 × 5--6 μm ([@B19]). In addition, *A. griseorufescens* formed a separate species level branch at the base of the phylogenetic tree (Fig. [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}), indicating that it is in an independent phylogenetic position. {#F6} ### Aureoboletus raphanaceus Fungi Boletales Boletaceae Ming Zhang & T.H. Li sp. nov. D9AAE876-F609-5B0B-874E-9DE9A689B919 827106 [Figs 2F, G](#F3){ref-type="fig"} [, 3E, F](#F4){ref-type="fig"} [, 6A--E](#F7){ref-type="fig"} #### Diagnosis. This species can be easily distinguished from other *Aureoboletus* taxa by its dry and yellowish-white to pinkish-white pileus covered with fibrillose to tomentose squamules, radish smell and ovoid basidiospores 7.5--9 × 5--6 μm. #### Etymology. "*raphanaceus*" refers to the radish smell of the new species. #### Type. China, Jiangxi Province, Chongyi Town, Yangling National Forest Park, on soil under the broadleaf forest dominated by Fagaceae trees, at 25°28\'N, 114°19\'E, alt. 300 m, 1 September 2016, H. Huang (holotype: GDGM45911). #### Description. Basidiomata small to medium-sized. Pileus 3--8 cm wide, hemispheric when young, becoming convex to nearly plane in age, fleshy, dry or slightly viscid when wet, covered with greenish-grey, yellowish-grey to brownish-grey (1D2--10D2) fibrillose to tomentose squamules on yellowish-white (1A2--4A2) to pinkish-white background, slightly wrinkled at disc; margin thin, slightly incurved at first, then extending. Context 8--12 mm thick at centre, firm and tough in youth, becoming soft, white, more or less pinkish, brownish-orange (5C4--7C4), greyish-red (8C4--10C4) to light brown (5D4--7D4) beneath the pileipellis, unchanging or slightly changing blue near the hymenophore when exposed. Tubes 4--7 mm deep, greyish-yellow (1B5--3B5), light yellow (1A5--3A5) to yellow (2A7--3A7), unchanging when bruised. Pores small, 0.5--1 per mm, circular to angular, somewhat relatively larger and shallowly depressed around the stipe at maturity; pore-surface concolorous with tubes, unchanging when hurt. Stipe 20--40 × 8--15 mm, central, cylindrical or clavate, equal to slightly enlarged downwards, dry, concolorous with pileus, longitudinally streaked and faintly pruinose or tomentose, with a very pale flush of pastel red (8A5--10A5) zone at apex. Stipe context white to yellowish-white, slightly changing pale yellow (2A3--4A3) when exposed, especially in the lower part. Basal mycelium white. Odour as radish. Taste mild. Basidiospores \[80/3/3\] (7--)7.5--9(--10) × 5--6 μm, Q= (1.27--)1.45--1.6(--1.7), Q~m~ = 1.51 ± 0.08, ovoid and inequilateral in side view, ovoid in ventral view, smooth, yellowish to pale brown in 5% KOH and yellowish-brown in Melzer's reagent, thin-walled. Basidia 20--30 × 8--11 μm, clavate, 4-spored, rarely 1-, 2-, 3-spored, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, without basal clamps, sterigmata 2--3.5 µm long. Pleurocystidia 30--60 × 8--13 μm, fusiform, thin-walled, usually containing golden-yellow contents at first, gradually changing yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Cheilocystidia infrequent, similar to pleurocystidia in shape and size. Hymenophoral trama composed of subparallel hyphae 5--23 μm broad, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Pileipellis an ixotrichodermium to trichodermium of erect hyphae 4--12 μm in diameter, usually covered with yellow to brownish-yellow pigment slightly dissolving in 5% KOH, branched, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, dextrinoid in Melzer's reagent; terminal cells cylindrical, clavate or nearly fusoid. Stipitipellis a layer of suberect branching hyphae 4--15 μm in diameter, hyaline in 5% KOH. Caulocystidia 30--60 × 8--12 μm, numerous, in clusters, fusiform to lageniform and usually contain yellow to yellowish-brown substance in an early stage in 5% KOH. Clamp connections absent in all tissues. #### Ecology and distribution. Solitary or scattered on ground with humus and debris under Fagaceae trees mixed with other broadleaf trees, alt. 300--1300 m; June to September; Currently known from Jiangxi and Hunan Province. #### Additional specimens examined. China, Jiangxi Province, Chongyi County, Yangling National Forest Park, alt. 550 m, 1 September 2016, M. Zhang (GDGM52908); Same locality and date B. Song (GDGM53127), M. Zhang (GDGM52266 and GDGM50266), H Huang (GDGM52890); Hunan Province, Guidong Town, Bamianshan National Nature Reserve, alt. 1250 m, 18 June 2016, Z.P. Song (GDGM52543 and GDGM46333). #### Notes. The yellowish-white basidioma colour makes it easy to distinguish *A. raphanaceus* from the other species. *Boletus orientialbus* N.K. Zeng & Zhu L. Yang recently described from China is somewhat similar to *A. raphanaceus* in colour; however, *B. orientialbus* differs in having more robust basidiomata, smooth pileus, reticulate stipe and smaller basidiospores 7--10 × 4.5-- 5 μm ([@B52]). {#F7} ### Aureoboletus sinobadius Fungi Boletales Boletaceae Ming Zhang & T.H. Li sp. nov. F6262386-5D2A-536B-941A-B0B53283B1A0 827101 [Figs 2H, I](#F3){ref-type="fig"} [, 3G](#F4){ref-type="fig"} [, 7A--F](#F8){ref-type="fig"} #### Diagnosis. This species is distinguished from other *Aureoboletus* species by its pastel red to reddish-brown pileus, light yellow hymenophore unchanging when bruised, salty taste and two different shapes of basidiospores. #### Etymology. "*sino*-" refers China, the holotype's location of the species; "*badius*" means the brownish-red or chestnut pileus colour. #### Type. China, Guangdong Province, Guangzhou City, Baiyun Mountain Scenic Area, on soil and usually growing amongst moss under broadleaf forest, dominated by Fagaceae trees, alt. 280 m, 18 May 2018, M. Zhang (holotype: GDGM71932). #### Description. Basidiomata medium to large-sized. Pileus 5--10 cm wide, hemispheric when young, becoming convex to nearly plane in age, fleshy, viscid, especially when young and wet, glabrous to minutely velvet-subtomentose, slightly wrinkled, usually violet brown (10E5--8 to 12E5--8) when young, gradually fading to pastel red (8A5--10A5), brownish-red (9C7--10C7), reddish-brown to brownish-violet (9D6--11D6, 9D7--11D7) at maturity, with a thin and slightly incurved margin. Context 7--10 mm thick at centre, firm and tough in youth and later soft, white to yellowish-white, and more or less greyish-red (9C4--10C4) beneath the pileipellis, slightly changing to greyish-red (9C4--10D5) when exposed. Tubes 8--15 mm deep, light yellow to greenish-yellow (2A5, 2B5), unchanging when bruised. Pores small, 1--1.5 per mm, circular to angular, somewhat relatively larger and shallowly depressed around the stipe at maturity, unchanging when bruised; pore-surface concolorous with tubes. Stipe 40--80 × 5--9 mm, central, cylindrical or clavate, equal to slightly enlarged downwards, smooth, viscid when wet, pastel red (8A5--10A5), with a very pale flush of pale orange (5A3--6A3) fibrous stripe. Stipe context white to yellowish-white, slightly changing to greyish-red (9C4--10D5) when bruised. Basal mycelium white. Odour mild. Taste salty. Basidiospores \[150/8/5\] 10--13(--14) × (4--) 4.5--5 (--5.5) μm, average 11.5--12.5 × 4.5--5, Q = (--2) 2.3--2.67 (--2.88), Q~m~ = 2.44 ± 0.22, subfusiform and inequilateral in side view with an obtuse apex, oblong to ovoid in ventral view, smooth, yellowish to yellowish-brown in 5% KOH, yellow brown to dark brown in Melzer's reagent, occasionally two different shapes in some specimens. Basidia 22--33 × 8--11 μm, clavate, predominantly 4-spored, partially 2-spored, with sterigmata 2--4 µm long, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, without basal clamp. Pleurocystidia 27--50 × 7--13 μm, fusiform, thin-walled, usually containing golden-yellow contents at first, gradually changing from yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Cheilocystidia frequent, 23--48 × 9--15 μm, clavate to subfusiform, thin-walled, containing golden-yellow contents at first, gradually changing yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Hymenophoral trama composed of subparallel hyphae 4--10 μm broad, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Pileipellis an ixotrichodermium of erect and branched hyphae 6--12 μm in diameter, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, dextrinoid in Melzer's reagent; terminal cells 35--60 × 5--10 μm, cylindrical, clavate or nearly fusoid. Stipitipellis a layer of repent to suberect branched hyphae 3--10 μm in diam., hyaline in 5% KOH. Caulocystidia 30--45 × 9--18 μm, mostly swollen clavate, usually containing yellow to yellowish-brown substance at an early stage in 5% KOH. Clamp connections absent in all tissues. #### Ecology and distribution. Solitary or scattered on ground with humus and debris under *Castanopsis fissa* Rehder E.H. Wilson mixed with other broadleaf trees, alt. 200--300 m; known from south China. #### Additional specimens examined. China, Guangdong Province, Guangzhou City, Baiyun Mountain Scenic Area, alt. 300 m, 4 June 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM44736 and GDGM44732); Same location, alt. 300 m, 30 May 2013, M. Zhang (GDGM43275); Same location, alt. 300 m, 4 June 2013, M. Zhang (ZhangM55); Same location, alt. 280 m, 14 May 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM45920); Guangdong Province, Huizhou City, Xiangtoushan National Nature Reserve, alt. 300 m, 2 April 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM44473); Hunan Province, Chenzhou City, Jiulongjiang National Forest Park, alt. 280 m, 13 June 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM44730); Guangzhou City, Research Institute of Tropical Forestry, alt. 200 m, 4 May 2018, J. Xu (GDGM72253). #### Notes. *Aureoboletus sinobadius* is morphologically similar to *A. auriporus*, *A. flaviporus* (Earle) Klofac, *A. gentilis*, *A. novoguineensis* and *A. venustus*. However, *A. auriporus* differs from *A. sinobadius* in the pinkish cinnamon, vinaceous to vinaceous brown pileus, longer and more robust stipe covered with yellow pruina or floccosity at apex, slight acid taste and broader basidiospores 11--16 × 4--6 μm ([@B28]; [@B37]; [@B15]; [@B7]; [@B1]; [@B17]); *A. flaviporus* differs in the pale cinnamon to dark reddish-brown pileus, reddish-brown stipe usually with reticulation at the apex, acidic taste, broader basidiospores 11--15 × 4--6 μm and the known distribution in North America ([@B1]); *A. gentilis*, originally described from Europe, differs in having pinkish-brown to flesh-coloured pileus, whitish context unchanging when exposed and longer and broader basidiospores 12--15 × 5--6.5 μm ([@B34]; [@B28]; [@B17]); *A. novoguineensis*, originally described from New Guinea, has pale pink brown or pale red context, shorter (3--4 mm deep) and sometimes compound hymenophore, acid taste and larger basidiospores (11.5--15.5 × 4.5--5.5 μm) and pleurocystidia (36--66 × 13--18 μm) ([@B16]); *A. venustus* recently described from southern China differs by its shorter and broader basidiospores 7.5--10.5 × 5--6 μm ([@B19]). {#F8} ### Aureoboletus solus Fungi Boletales Boletaceae Ming Zhang & T.H. Li sp. nov. D60072D7-6C09-50A3-9CD1-9AAC32D1E877 827105 [Figs 2, K, 3H, 8A--D](#F3){ref-type="fig"} #### Diagnosis. This species can be easily distinguished from other *Aureoboletus* taxa by its dry and small basidiomata, brownish-yellow to greyish-red pileus, glabrous stipe and smaller basidiospores (7--)8--10.5(--11) × (4--)4.5--5 μm. #### Etymology. "*solus*" refers to the solitary habit. #### Type. China, Guangdong Province, Shaoguan City, Nanling National Nature Reserve, on soil under the broadleaf forest, dominated by Fagaceae trees, 16 June 2015, M. Zhang (holotype: GDGM44759). #### Description. Basidiomata small-sized. Pileus 1.5--2.5 cm wide, hemispheric when young, becoming convex to nearly plane in age, fleshy, dry or slightly viscid when wet, minutely velvet subtomentose, slightly wrinkled, brownish-yellow, brownish-orange, brownish-red to greyish-red (5C7--8C7, 5C5--9C5); margin thin, slightly incurved at first, becoming nearly straight, often appendiculate with small membranous remains of the veil. Context 2--6 mm thick at centre, firm and tough in youth, becoming soft, white, more or less greyish-red (9C5--11C5) to brownish-red (9C7--11C7) beneath the pileipellis, unchanging when exposed. Tubes 2--3 mm deep, gr-yish-yellow (1B5--3B5), light yellow (1A5--3A5) to vivid yellow (1A8--3A8), gradually changing to greenish-yellow when mature, unchanging when bruised, shallowly depressed around the stipe at maturity. Pores small, 1--2 per mm, somewhat larger around the stipe, circular to angular; pore-surface concolorous with tubes. Stipe 20--45 × 2--6 mm, central, cylindrical or clavate, equal to slightly enlarged downwards, glabrous, dry or slightly viscid when wet, pale orange to pale red (5A3--7A3), pastel red (8A5--10A5), with very pale flush of pastel red (8A5--10A5) fibrous stripes. Stipe context white to pastel red (8A4--10A4), slightly darker when bruised, especially in the lower part. Basal mycelium white. Odour none. Taste mild. Basidiospores \[80/3/3\] (7--)8--10.5(--11) ×(4--)4.5--5 μm, Q = (1.5--)1.8--2.2(--2.6), Q~m~ = 2.0 ± 0.21, subfusiform and inequilateral in side view, oblong to ovoid in ventral view, smooth, yellowish to yellowish-brown in 5% KOH and yellow brown to dark brown in Melzer's reagent, thin-walled. Basidia 1, 2, 4-spored 25--46 × 9--16 μm, clavate, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH; sterigmata 2--4.5 µm long. Pleurocystidia frequent, 38--66 × 11--15 μm, fusiform, thin-walled, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Cheilocystidia similar to pleurocystidia in shape and size. Hymenophoral trama composed of subparallel hyphae 5--11 μm broad, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Pileipellis an entangled trichodermium of erect hyphae 5--17 μm in diameter, branched, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, dextrinoid in Melzer's reagent; terminal cells cylindrical, clavate or nearly fusoid. Stipitipellis a layer of repent hyphae 4--23 μm in diameter, hyaline in 5% KOH. Caulocystidia infrequent. Clamp connections absent in all tissues. #### Ecology and distribution. Solitary or gregarious on soil under broadleaf forests dominated by *Castanopsis* spp. and *Cyclobalanopsis* spp. and mixed with other broadleaf trees, alt. 300--1200 m; May to July, currently only known from Guangdong Province. #### Additional specimens examined. China, Guangdong Province, Shaoguan City, Nangling National Nature Reserve, alt. 1200 m, 29 July 2017, M. Zhang (GDGM70342); Guangdong Province, Huizhou County, Xiangtoushan National Nature Reserve, alt. 400 m, 16 June 2016, J.P. Zou (GDGM46222); Guangdong Province, Huizhou City, Nankunshan Provincial Nature Reserve, alt. 700 m, 15 May 2013, M. Zhang (GDGM42822); Guangdong Province, Shaoguan City, Danxianshan National Nature Reserve, alt. 300 m, 3 June 2017, M. Zhang (GDGM46807), Same locality, 2 June 2017, M. Zhang (GDGM49404). #### Notes. *Aureoboletus solus* looks like *A. tenuis*; however, the latter differs from the former in its viscid basidiomata, ixotrichodermial stipitipellis, composed of terminal hyphae with slightly swollen tips and larger basidiospores (10--)11--12 × 4--5 µm ([@B55]). Phylogenetic analyses indicated that *A. solus* is closely related to *A. nephrosporus*, but *A. nephrosporus* differs in having larger basidiomata with a red to brownish-red pileus, ovoid to nephroid basidiospores 8--10.5 × 5--6 µm and cheilocystidia and pleurocystidia covered with a thick layer of a strongly refractive pale yellow substance ([@B47]). {#F9} ### Aureoboletus velutipes Fungi Boletales Boletaceae Ming Zhang & T.H. Li sp. nov. 6E1F09EA-3BCB-5E27-B813-C27A1A3716A5 827108 [Figs 2L](#F3){ref-type="fig"} [, 3I](#F4){ref-type="fig"} [, 9A--E](#F10){ref-type="fig"} #### Diagnosis. This species can be easily distinguished from others in *Aureoboletus* by its dry and small basidiomata, brown orange to reddish-brown pileus, light yellow to pastel yellow stipe, covered with fibrillose to tomentose squamules and smooth basidiospores 10--13 × 4--6.5 μm. #### Etymology. "*velutipes*" refers to the stipe, covered with fibrillose to tomentose squamules. #### Type. China, Guangdong Province, Huizhou City, Xiangtoushan National Nature Reserve, on soil under the broadleaf forest, dominated by Fagaceae trees, alt. 350 m, 2 April 2015, M. Zhang (holotype: GDGM44713). Basidiomata small-sized. Pileus 2--4 cm wide, obtuse to convex when young, becoming broadly convex to plane at mature, fleshy, dry, covered with fibrillose to tomentose squamules, light yellow, light orange (4A4--6A4), brownish-orange (6C7--7C7), brown to reddish-brown (6D7--9D7), slightly fading to light orange to brownish-orange towards margin. Context 3--5 mm thick at stipe, firm and tough in youth, soft when matured, yellowish to white on the whole, more or less reddish-brown beneath the pileipellis, slightly changing to pastel red (7A4--9A4) when exposed. Tubes 3--5 mm deep, distinctly depressed around stipe, yellowish-white (2A2--4A2) when young, becoming pale yellow, greyish-yellow, pastel yellow to olive yellow (2A3--4A3, 1B3--2B3, 2A4--3A4, 2C6--3C6) in age, often with an olive tint, unchanging when bruised. Pores 0.5--0.8 mm in diam., mostly subangular, slightly elongated around stipe at maturity, smaller near pileus margin, concolorous with tubes. Stipe 30--60 × 5--10 mm, central, cylindrical or narrowly clavate, solid, equal to slightly enlarged downwards, covered with white, yellowish-white to yellowish-brown fibrillose to tomentose squamules, usually forming reticulation or longitudinally striate, light yellow to pastel yellow (2A4--4A4, 2A5--4A5), with white basal mycelium. Odour none. Taste mild. Basidiospores \[90/3/3\] 10--13 × (4--)5--6(--6.5) μm, Q = (1.75--)1.8--2.2(--2.4), Q~m~ = 2.08 ± 0.35, subfusiform and inequilateral in side view, oblong to ovoid in ventral view, smooth, yellowish to yellowish-brown in 5% KOH and yellow brown to dark brown in Melzer's reagent, thin-walled. Basidia 25--30 × 9--13 μm, clavate, predominantly 4-spored but frequently also 2-spored, with sterigmata 2--3 µm long, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, without basal clamps. Pleurocystidia 35--65 × 10--18 μm, fusiform, thin-walled. Cheilocystidia frequent, similar to pleurocystidia in shape and size. Hymenophoral trama composed of subparallel hyphae 6--10 μm broad, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Pileipellis a trichodermium of erect and often branched hyphae 4--17 μm in diameter, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, dextrinoid in Melzer's reagent; terminal cells 30--60 × 4--17 μm, cylindrical, clavate or nearly fusoid. Stipitipellis a layer of repent to suberect branching hyphae 3--15 μm in diameter, with swollen tips, terminal cells 30--70 × 11--21 μm, hyaline in 5% KOH. Clamp connections absent in all tissues. #### Ecology and distribution. Scattered on soil in subtropical forests, dominated by Fagaceae (*Castanopsis* spp., *Lithocarpus* spp. and *Quercus* spp., etc). Currently known from southern China. #### Additional specimens examined. China, Guangxi Province, Guilin City, Maoershan National Nature Reserve, alt. 1380 m, 1 July 2012, M. Zhang (GDGM42608); Jiangxi Province, Jinggangshan City, Jingganshan National Nature Reserve, alt. 1000 m, 21 June 2016, H. Huang (GDGM52409). #### Notes. The obviously villose or fibrous squamulose stipe can distinguish it from other species in *Aureoboletus*. *Aureoboletus catenarius*, recently described from southwest China, is somewhat similar to *A. velutipes* with a dry and tomentose pileus, but *A. catenarius* has a cracked and light brown to reddish-brown pileus, faintly or finely fibrillose stipe and smaller basidiospores 7--9 × 3.5--5 μm ([@B47]). {#F10} ### Aureoboletus miniatoaurantiacus Fungi Boletales Boletaceae (Bi & Loh) Ming Zhang, N.K. Zeng & T.H. Li comb. nov. E871E3AD-BA00-5BD6-9F27-4A5C0092A2F0 827109 [Figs 2D, E](#F3){ref-type="fig"} [, 3C, D](#F4){ref-type="fig"} [, 10A--D](#F11){ref-type="fig"} #### Basionym. *Boletus miniatoaurantiacus* C.S. Bi & Loh, in Bi, Loh & Zheng, Acta Bot. Yunn. 4(1): 60, 1982 #### Synonym. *Aureoboletus tomentosus* G. Wu & Zhu L. Yang, in Wu, Li, Zhu, Zhao, Han, Cui, Li, Xu & Yang, Fungal Diversity 81: 51, 2016 #### Diagnosis. In [@B2]: Pileus 1--1.6 cm latus, siccus, obtuse hemisphaerius, aurantiacus, confertim et minute villoso-tomentosus. Contexto flava, immutibili, ad stipitem 2--3 cm crasso, sapor mitis et odor nullus. Stipes centralis, 3--3.3 cm longus, 3--6 mm crassus, albidus, in parte in feriore flavus, subcylindraceus, solidus, velutinus. Tubuli albidi, immutabiles, ad stipitem breviter decurrentes, 3 mm longi, facile denudati; pori ovati, majuscules, 3 mm diam. Sporae ellipsoideae, laeves, pallido-flavae, 7--10 × 3.3--4 μm, 1 guttatae. Pleurocystidiis 35 × 6.5 μm, paucis. Basidiomata small to medium-sized. Pileus 1.5--8 cm wide, hemispheric when young, becoming convex to nearly plane in age, fleshy, dry or viscid when wet, surface minutely tomentose or pulverous, slightly wrinkled, orange yellow, reddish-yellow, orange to reddish-orange (4A6--7A6, 4A7--7A7), commonly with a thin and slightly extended margin. Context 5--10 mm thick at centre, firm and tough in youth and, later, soft, white to yellowish-white, with more or less green tint at border contacting tubes, unchanging when exposed. Tube 3--10 mm deep, light orange to orange unchanging when bruised. Pores polygonal, 0.5--1.5 per mm, somewhat relatively larger and shallowly depressed around the stipe, orange to pale orange unchanging when bruised. Stipe 30--80 × 4--10 mm, central, solid, cylindrical or clavate, equal to slightly enlarged downwards, smooth to distinctly longitudinally streaks or broad reticulations, viscid in wet condition, concolorous with pileus. Stipe context concolorous with that of pileus, unchanging when exposed. Basal mycelium white to yellowish-white. Odour strong. Taste mild. Basidiospores \[90/3/3\] (6.5--)7--10.5(--11) × (4--)4.5--5.5(--6) μm, Q = (1.42--)1.6--2.0(--2.3), Q~m~ = 1.79 ± 0.18, ovoid and inequilateral in side view with an obtuse apex, ovoid in ventral view, smooth, yellowish to yellowish-brown in 5% KOH and yellow brown to dark brown in Melzer's reagent, thin-walled. Basidia 18--35 (45) × 7--14 μm, 4-spored, rarely 1-, 2-, 3-spored, clavate, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH, sterigmata 2--3 μm. Cheilocystidia (21) 26--55 (61) × (6) 8--12 μm, fusiform to subclavate, thin-walled, contained with bright yellow pigments. Pleurocystidia similar to cheilocystidia in shape and size, thin-walled, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Hymenophoral trama composed of interwoven branched hyphae 6--15 μm wide, yellowish-white to hyaline in 5% KOH. Pileipellis an entangled trichodermium to ixotrichodermium of erect hyphae 4--18 μm in diameter, composed of yellow to bright yellow vacuolar pigmented filamentous hyphae, terminal cells cylindrical, clavate or nearly fusoid. Stipitipellis a tangled layer of repent to suberect branching hyphae 7--12 μm in diameter, hyaline in 5% KOH. Caulocystidia 25--75 × 12--18 μm, common, clavate, fusoid or fusoid ventricose and usually contain yellow to yellowish-brown substance in an early stage in 5% KOH. Stipe trama composed of parallel hyphae 4--18 μm wide. Clamp connections absent in all tissues. #### Ecology and distribution. Scattered on soil in tropical to subtropical forests dominated by Fagaceae (*Castanopsis chinensis*, *C. fissa*, *Lithocarpus* spp. and *Quercus* spp.). Currently known from southern and southwest China #### Additional specimens examined. China, Guangdong Province, Zhaoqing City, Dinghu Mountain, 6 September 1980, C.S. Bi et al. 677 (GDGM4677, holotype of *B. miniatoaurantiacus*); Same locality, 14 April 1981, C. Li (GDGM5071); 11 August 1981, C.S. Bi et al. 855 (GDGM4855); Fujian Province, Zhangping City, alt. 350 m, 2 September 2009, N.K. Zeng 664, 669 (FHMU424, 429); same locality, 27 July 2013, N.K. Zeng 1294 (FHMU848); 29 July 2013, N.K. Zeng 1323 (FHMU876); 1 August 2013, N.K. Zeng 1339 (FHMU891); Guangdong Province, Guangzhou City, Tianluhu Forest Park, alt. 200 m, 29 May 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM42855); Guangdong Province, Shaoguan City, Chebaling National Nature Reserve, alt. 300 m, 3 September 2013, M. Zhang & C.Q. Wang (GDGM43282); Guangdong Province, Huizhou City, Xiangtoushan National Nature Reserve, alt. 300 m, 7 July 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM44727); Jiangxi Province, Chongyi County, Yangling National Forest Park, alt. 280 m, 14 August 2015, M. Zhang (GDGM51694 and GDGM43439); same locality, 31 August 2016, H. Huang (GDGM52888); Same locality, 1 September 2016, M. Zhang (GDGM53350); Same locality, 2 September 2016, M. Zhang (GDGM53274); Same locality, 3 September 2016, M. Zhang (GDGM53501). #### Notes. *Aureoboletus miniatoaurantiacus*, originally described as *B. miniatoaurantiacus*, is a rather common species in southern China and can be easily distinguished by its bright orange-yellow basidiomata, tomentose or pulverulent pileus surface, light orange to orange hymenophore unchanging when bruised and ovoid basidiospores. Based on a re-study of the type specimen and other collections quoted by Bi et al. in 1994, we found that the type specimen is composed of two small immature basidiomata, which are in a poor condition for morphological observation, but other voucher specimens fit well with the description of *A. tomentosus*. Thus, the newly described species *A. tomentosus* is, in fact, a synonym of *A. miniatoaurantiacus*, this conclusion also being supported by molecular data in this study ([@B2]; [@B3]; [@B47]). *Aureoboletus auriflammeus*, originally described from North America, is similar to *A. miniatoaurantiacus*; however, the former differs in having a distinctly reticulate stipe and narrower basidiospores (8--12 × 3--5 μm) ([@B21]; [@B1]). {#F11} Key to the species of *Aureoboletus* known in China {#SECID0E5SDK} --------------------------------------------------- ---- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------- 1 Pileus dry or slightly viscid when wet **2** -- Pileus viscid **13** 2 Basidiomata medium to larger (≥ 6 cm in diam.) **3** -- Basidiomata smaller (\< 6 cm in diam.) **4** 3 Pileus 6--10 cm in diameter, greyish-orange to brownish-orange; stipe glabrous, greyish-yellow on the upper part to blond on the lower part; context unchanging when cut; basidiospores 9--11 × 4--5.5 µm ***A. yunnanensis*** -- Pileus 6--15 cm in diameter, brownish-red to reddish-brown; context yellowish-white changing to yellowish-olivaceous when injured; hymenophore pale yellow to olivaceous yellow; stipe surface with longitudinal stripe, brownish-red to reddish-brown; basidiospores subglobose, 7--8 × 5.5--6 µm ***A. clavatus*** 4 Stipe surface smooth or with small dots or splotches **5** -- Stipe surface non-smooth, with reticula, longitudinal stripe, flocci or others **11** 5 Basidiospores nodulose to verrucose, 12--15 × 8--11 µm; basidiomata small, golden brown to umber; stipe up to 7 cm long ***A. shichianus*** -- Basidiospores surface smooth; other characters not as above **6** 6 Hymenophore bright yellow to vivid yellow, unchanging when old **7** -- Hymenophore pale yellow, light yellow, greenish-yellow to olive brown **8** 7 Pileus greyish-rose to brownish-red, glabrous to slightly subtomentose; context pale yellow to light yellow unchanging when cut; stipe dark orange to yellow ochre, with distinct longitudinal streaks and furfuraceous scales; basidiospores 8--10.5 × 5--6 µm ***A. nephrosporus*** -- Pileus reddish-brown to greyish-ruby, smooth to minutely velvet-subtomentose; context white to yellowish-white changing to greyish-red to greyish-rose when exposed; stipe smooth, concolorous with pileus; stipe context white to reddish-white gradually changing to greyish-red to greyish-rose when bruised; basidiospores 9--10.5 × 4.5--5 μm ***A. griseorufescens*** 8 Pileus yellowish-white to reddish-white; context white, unchanging or slightly changing blue near the hymenium when exposed; tubes greyish-yellow to light yellow, unchanging when bruised; stipe context white to yellowish-white, slightly changing pale yellow when exposed; odour with radish scent; basidiospores 5--9 × 5--6 μm ***A. raphanaceus*** -- Pileus coloured with brownish-red to reddish-brown tonalities **9** 9 Pileipellis epithelium; basidiospores subfusoid, 7--9 × 3.5--5 μm ***A. catenarius*** -- Pileipellis trichoderm **10** 10 Basidiospores fusiform to ovoid, 8--10.5 × 4.5--5 μm ***A. solus*** -- Basidiospores oblong to ovoid, 8.5--10.5 × 5--5.5 µm ***A. rubellus*** 11 Stipe surface ornamented with distinctly reticulation, pileus surface covered with coarse tomentose, basidiospores (20--)22--27(--28) × 9--13 µm ***A. mirabilis*** -- Stipe surface without reticulation or the reticulation inconspicuous **12** 12 Stipe surface ornamented with distinctly longitudinally streaks or dotted scales; pileus surface orange yellow, reddish-yellow to reddish-orange, covered with tomentose; hymenophore light orange to orange; basidiospores 7--11 × 4.5--6 μm ***A. miniatoaurantiacus*** -- Stipe surface covered with distinctly fibrillose to tomentose squamules; pileus surface brownish-orange to reddish-brown, covered with fibrillose to tomentose squamules; context yellowish-white changing to pastel red when exposed; basidiospores 10--13 × 4--6.5 μm ***A. velutipes*** 13 Pileus margin with a gelatinised membranous veil **14** -- Pileus margin without any membranous veil **19** 14 Pileus surface distinctly reticulate, coarsely rugose, chestnut-brown to pale brown; stipe whitish; pleurocystidia covered with yellow substance on surface; basidiospores 9.5--13 × 4.5--5 µm ***A. thibetanus*** -- Pileus glabrous or slightly rugose in central **15** 15 Basidiospores smooth **16** -- Basidiospores longitudinally costate, 12--16 × 9--12 µm ***A. longicollis*** 16 Pileus brownish to brown; basidiospores 10--12.5 × 4.5--5 µm ***A. viscidipes*** -- Pileus reddish-brown to violet brown **17** 17 Basidiomata usually ≥ 2.5 cm; basidiospores 11--13.5 × 4.5--5.5 µm ***A. tenuis*** -- Basidiomata usually \< 2.5 cm **18** 18 Basidiospores 8.5--10 × 4--4.5 µm ***A. marroninus*** -- Basidiospores 10--13.5 × 4.5--5 µm ***A. glutinosus*** 19 Pileus wrinkled, greyish-yellow to brownish-orange; taste salty; distribution in subalpine zone, ectomycorrhizal with *Quercus spinose*; basidiospores 15--21 × 5--6.5 μm ***A. squercus-spinosae*** -- Pileus smooth, fibrillose to tomentose; the rest of the characters usually not as above **20** 20 Basidiospores relatively broader, 7.5--10.5 × 5--6 μm, Q~m~ \< 2 ***A. venustus*** -- Basidiospores relatively narrower, usually Q~m~ ≥ 2 **21** 21 Basidiospores comparatively larger, 15--16.5 × 4.5--5 μm ***A. formosus*** -- Basidiospores comparatively smaller, commonly \< 15 μm long **22** 22 Basidiomata small to medium-sized (pileus usually \< 5 cm). Pileus yellowish-brown or reddish-golden, subtomentose; stipe light brown to brownish-orange; basidiospores 9--11 × 4--5 μm ***A. zangii*** -- Basidiomata medium to large (pileus usually \> 5 cm) **23** 23 Pileus violet brown to brownish-violet, glabrous to minutely velvet-subtomentose; stipe pastel red with a pale flush fibrous stripe; taste salty; basidiospores 10--14 × 4.5--5.5 μm ***A. sinobadius*** -- Pileus reddish-brown to brownish-red, nearly glabrous; stipe reddish-orange to garnet brown with faintly longitudinal streaks; taste unknown, basidiospores 8.5--13 × 4.5--5.5 μm ***A. duplicatoporus*** ---- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------- Discussion {#SECID0E5PEK} ========== Species delimitation, species diversity and new taxa in China {#SECID0ECQEK} ------------------------------------------------------------- In the taxonomic circumscription of the genus *Aureoboletus* proposed by [@B28], 35 species were identified prior to this study, of which 20 species were recorded from China (i.e. *A. auriporus*, *A. catenarius*, *A. clavatus*, *A. duplicatoporus*, *A. formosus*, *A. longicollis*, *A. marroninus*, *A. mirabilis*, *A. nephrosporus*, *A. quercus-spinosae*, *A. rubellus*, *A. shichianus*, *A. tenuis*, *A. thibetanus*, *A. tomentosus*, *A. venustus*, *A. viscidipes*, *A. viscosus*, *A. yunnanensis* and *A. zangii*). However, the report of the North American species *A. auriporus* was excluded from China in this study due to a misidentification, as its correct name is *A. sinobadius*. The previously described species, *A. tomentosus*, was proven to be *A. miniatoaurantiacus* and so, a new combination is proposed here. Six species, *A. glutinosus*, *A. griseorufescens*, *A. sinobadius*, *A. solus*, *A. raphanaceus* and *A. velutipes*, obtained from China, are newly described in this study. The present study demonstrates that species of *Aureoboletus* are very diverse in China, especially in its southern areas. Common morphological characteristics and molecular data make *Aureoboletus* easily distinguishable from other existing genera in Boletaceae, but some variable morphological features make it difficult to recognise some species. Careful examination showed that several morphological characteristics are available to delimit these species in China. For example, the colour of the hymenophore and pattern of the pileus are important characteristics: *A. glutinosus* has a light yellow to olive yellow hymenophore and a coarse pileus with irregular reticulation; *A. sinobadius* has a vivid yellow hymenophore and a subtomentose to glabrous and viscid pileus; *A. miniatoaurantiacus* has a light orange to orange hymenophore and a tomentose to pulverous pileus; regarding the size of basidiomata, *A. clavatus* and *A. yunnanensis* have relatively larger basidiomata up to 10 cm in diameter, whereas *A. glutinosus* and *A. marroninus* have smaller basidiomata usually less than 2.5 cm in diameter. The colour of the pileus and the colour and odour of the context also help to identify species in the field. In contrast to macro-morphology, several micro-morphological features can also be used to discriminate species of *Aureoboletus*, such as the size and shape of basidiospores and the shape and inclusion of cystidia, pileipellis and stipitipellis seem to be rather constant amongst the different species. Phylogenetic analyses supported the presence of eight clades in *Aureoboletus* {#SECID0EG5EK} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ In the present study, all selected samples of *Aureoboletus* formed a well-supported monophyletic group and eight major clades are proposed here, based on morphological characteristics and phylogenetic inference. Clade I is characterised by the presence of a viscid pileus, a vivid yellow to greyish-yellow hymenophore that is unchanging when bruised, smooth basidiospores and ixotrichodermium pileipellis. In the present study, this group contains ten species, including the type species *A. gentilis* and the new species *A. sinobadius*. This clade is a rather homogeneous group in terms of morphology, which is consistent with the definition of *Aureoboletus* given by [@B28]. Species in this clade can be separated from each other by pileus colour and the size of basidiospores. In addition, two unsequenced species, *A. flavimarginatus* and *A. flaviporus*, should belong to this clade, based on their morphological characteristics (viscid pileus and vivid yellow hymenophore). Clade II is characterised by the presence of a dry (or slightly sticky when wet) pileus, a vivid yellow to olive yellow hymenophore that is unchanging when bruised, smooth basidiospores and trichodermium pileipellis. This clade includes six species, of which *A. velutipes* has distinctive morphological characteristics, such as a villous pileus and stipe, pale yellow to olive yellow hymenophore and swollen tips in terminal cells of the stipitipellis. Clade III is well-characterised by the presence of a viscid pileus with well-developed yellowish to subhyaline veil remnant at the margin, greyish-yellow to olive yellow hymenophore, smooth to longitudinally costate basidiospores and ixotrichodermium pileipellis. *Aureoboletus longicollis*, originally described from Malaysia, is a well-defined species in this clade and is readily distinguished by its more viscid and larger basidioma, longer stipe and longitudinally costate basidiospores. A Chinese species, *A. viscosus*, shares similar traits with *A. longicollis* and the two species cannot be separated from each other in morphology. In this study, we did not have access to specimens of *A. longicollis* from Malaysia for morphological and phylogenetical study and it is not possible to make a taxonomic decision on whether *A. viscosus* is the same or a different species to *A. longicollis* without phylogenetic data. Thus, the name *A. longicollis* is temporarily used in this study and further studies with more materials are needed. The other species in this clade are characterised by smooth basidiospores and they can be distinguished from each other by their pileus colour and the size of basidiospores. Clade IV contains the species *A. auriflammeus* and *A. miniatoaurantiacus*, which are mainly characterised by their bright orange yellow basidiomata, tomentose pileus surface and ovoid basidiospores. Species in this clade can be easily distinguished from others in this genus. Clade V is characterised by the presence of a dry or somewhat tacky pileus, greyish-yellow to vivid yellow hymenophore changing to olive yellow when mature and oblong, ovoid to nephroid basidiospores. This clade contains five species, including the two species *A. solus* and *A. raphanaceus* described above. Clade VI is composed of four distinct species, which have all been recently added to *Aureoboletus*, based on phylogenetic analyses ([@B14], [@B46], [@B47]). *Aureoboletus projectellus*, *A. mirabilis* and *A. russellii* were originally described from North America and have a dry or coarsely tomentose pileus, distinct coarse reticulations on the stipe and larger basidiospores (up to 20 μm); however, the basidiospores of *A. projectellus* and *A. mirabilis* are smooth, while *A. russellii* has longitudinally costate basidiospores ([@B22]; [@B34]; [@B37]; [@B27]; [@B1]). *A. shichianus*, originally described from southwest China, is a remarkable species in this clade and differs from the others by its small basidiomata, tomentose pileus, radially arranged pores, comparatively long and glabrous stipe and scabrous basidiospores with nodules. Species in this clade are quite diverse, though the coarsely reticulated stipe and ornamented basidiospores are unique in the genus. Clade VII is currently formed by a single species, *A. clavatus*. The most striking characteristics are the large basidiomata with slightly viscid pileus, yellowish-white context staining yellowish-olivaceous when exposed, pale yellow to olivaceous-yellow hymenophore, subglobose basidiospores and the pileipellis composed of a turf of clavate hyphae. Besides the slightly viscid pileus, this species shares nearly none of the basic morphological traits of the genus *Aureoboletus*. However, phylogenetic analyses showed that it belongs to *Aureoboletus* and formed a separate branch. Clade VIII is formed by a single species *A. griseorufescens*. Morphologically, *A. griseorufescens* is similar to those species in Clade I with a vivid yellow hymenophore and subviscid pileus; however, the most striking characteristic of *A. griseorufescens* is its white to yellowish-white context changing to greyish-red or greyish-rose when exposed. In the phylogenetic tree, *A. griseorufescens* formed the basal branch of *Aureoboletus* with highly-supported values, which showed that it might be an early divergent species from *Aureoboletus*. Geographical distribution and species evolution {#SECID0EMLFK} ----------------------------------------------- *Aureoboletus* is a cosmopolitan genus, but most known species have relatively distinct habitats or regional locations. Currently, most of known *Aureoboletus* species are distributed in East Asia (mainly in China) and North America and intercontinentally-distributed species are infrequent. Two species *A. projectellus* and *A. mirabilis*, originally reported from North America, were examined in several studies and found to have disjunctive distributions in the North Temperate region from North America to Asia (China, Japan) and Europe ([@B16], Chen et al. 1988, Motiejūnaitė et al. 2013, [@B14], [@B47]). In Asia and North America, some morphologically similar and phylogenetically related species also exist. For example, *A. auriporus* and *A. viridiflavus* are similar to *A. sinobadius* and *A. formosus* and *A. auriflammeus* is similar to *A. miniatoaurantiacus*. However, they can be clearly separated from each other by molecular data. In Europe, only *A. gentilis* was originally described and not found in other continents; this represents a separate geographical region of *Aureoboletus*. Phylogenetic analyses based on 144 collections uncovered some useful information regarding the geography of *Aureoboletus*. Species in Clades III, V and VIII are found in Asia (China-Japan-Malaysia-Vietnam), representing subtropical-tropical Asia distributions. Compared with North America and Europe, China has the greatest number of *Aureoboletus* species and endemic species, especially in the subtropical-tropical region. Furthermore, many regions in China are under-sampled and more under-described indigenous *Aureoboletus* species will undoubtedly be discovered in the future. The high diversity of *Aureoboletus* species in China indicates that the subtropical-tropical region of China (or Asia) is the current species diversity centre of *Aureoboletus*. In this study, some evolutionary patterns of morphological characteristics were also discovered. The traits of dry or viscid pileus surface and hymenophore colour appear to be relatively stable evolutionary characteristics and were wellsupported by monophyletic clades on the phylogenetic tree. The shape and surface ornamentation of basidiospores are not reliable characteristics for delimiting *Aureoboletus*, but are useful for species identification. Basidiospores ornamentation may have evolutionarily originated several times within *Aureoboletus* history. More morphological and molecular data are needed to understand this trait. Supplementary Material ====================== ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus glutinosus ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus griseorufescens ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus raphanaceus ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus sinobadius ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus solus ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus velutipes ###### XML Treatment for Aureoboletus miniatoaurantiacus The authors are grateful to the editors and anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments and suggestions. Thanks are given to Mr. Hao Huang, Ting Li, Jun-Ping Zou, Zong-Ping Song (Guangdong Institute of Microbiology) and Yu Chen (Guangdong Xiangtoushan National Nature Reserve Administration) for their kind help in the fieldwork; to Dr. Chun-Ying Deng (Guizhou Academy of Sciences) and Dr. Chuan-Hua Li (Institute of Edible Fungi, Shanghai Academy of Agricultural Sciences) for providing collections. This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 31700021, 31770014, 31670029), the Ministry of Science and Technology of the People's Republic of China (2013FY111500), the Ministry of Ecology and Environment (2019HB2096001006) and the GDAS' Special Project of Science and Technology Development (2019GDASYL-0104009). [^1]: Academic editor: M. P. Martín

Introduction ============ Understanding a story text requires the reader to form a mental representation, or situation model, of that story (e.g., [@B23]; [@B57]). Mental imagery, i.e., the ability to create mental images of the story in your "mind's eye," can enhance the quality of these mental models ([@B2]; [@B32]; [@B10]), and therefore contributes to successful reading comprehension. Pictures can facilitate the creation of a mental representation as well, as they can clarify implicit or unclear relations in the text (e.g., [@B11]). In addition, it is claimed that adding pictures to a text results in deeper learning ([@B38]; [@B45]; [@B46]; [@B47]). This so-called "multimedia effect" (e.g., [@B38]) has especially been found in research with expository texts (e.g., [@B30]; [@B41]; [@B8]; [@B37]), but there has been little evidence in the case of narrative texts (e.g., [@B39]; [@B17]; [@B49]). Narrative texts form an important genre though, as they act as a model of the human social world and allow readers to experience thoughts and emotions that are evoked by the story events ([@B34]). In this quasi-experimental study, we examined the role of elementary school children's mental imagery skills in their ability to understand a story that required an integration of words and pictures. More specifically, we examined a special kind of narrative in which pictures took a different position than in standard illustrated children's books, by providing additional and unique information that was not expressed in words. We expected that understanding this experimental narrative would put high demands on both children's mental imagery skills, and their ability to "read" pictures. When readers engage in a story, they create and update their mental model while reading ([@B21]; [@B23]; [@B15]). Mental models are thought to include the information that is explicitly mentioned in the text ("textbase") and the situational representation of story events (e.g., information about the people, locations, and actions described in the story). This information is combined with the reader's knowledge about stories in general (e.g., structure, perspective) as well as with the reader's background knowledge about the topic of the story ([@B23]; [@B45]; [@B58]). While readers engage with a story, they create mental visual (and other sensory) images, or "internal pictures" of the story, which facilitates mental model making ([@B22]; [@B45]; [@B46]; [@B2]). In addition, readers use mental imagery to infer what is in the characters' mind, to predict and explain their actions and emotions (i.e., mentalizing), which adds to the mental model as well (e.g., [@B14]; [@B35]; [@B33]). Research among students of various ages has shown that mental imagery skills play a role in explaining individual differences in reading comprehension. Students who are not inclined to make mental images in general while reading were found to show poor reading performance, whereas students who are used to making mental images tended to be more proficient readers ([@B6]; [@B50]; [@B18]; [@B10]). It has been suggested that mental imagery is an effective strategy for remembering and connecting story elements, and for concretizing complex and abstract ideas from the text ([@B6]; [@B13]; [@B2]; [@B10]). The exact way in which visual images are created in the brain is not yet clear (see for example, [@B24]; [@B25], for an interesting discussion on this topic). Importantly, mental imagery seems to be particularly invoked by narrative texts. As narratives can be seen as a simulation of the social world, readers are more likely to feel connected to story events and characters ([@B34]). This engagement with the story is thought to enhance the quality of readers' mental models as well as their story comprehension ([@B16]). It has repeatedly been shown that readers learn and understand more from a text when pictures are added, which has been referred to as the "multimedia effect" ([@B38]; [@B45]; [@B46]; [@B47]). This can be explained in two ways. First, pictures can aid mental model making, in a way comparable to mental imagery. While words can be seen as "descriptive" representations, composed of symbols with an arbitrary structure, pictures, in contrast, are "depictive" external representations, showing the meaning or the content that they represent ([@B45]; [@B5]). As such, pictures provide an initial framework, on which readers can base their mental model ([@B11]). Adding pictures to a text might be especially helpful for poor learners, because pictures can make relations in the text explicit and resolve ambiguous information in the text ([@B30]; [@B46]; [@B11]). Moreover, pictures may serve as clues for readers to decide which parts of the text are important to keep activated in the mental model ([@B15]; [@B42]). This will foster readers' comprehension of a text ([@B42]). Second, it is claimed that the contribution of both verbal and pictorial information results in a deeper processing of the text, which is thought to benefit reading comprehension ([@B5]; [@B47]). A text that contains pictures provides learners with two different sources of information, which has been referred to as "dual coding" ([@B40]). The processing of words and pictures, which can be seen as equally complex ([@B3]; [@B53]), leads to multiple representations in the brain. Combining these representations is thought to lead to deeper learning and increased comprehension. There is no consensus yet on the way the information from text and pictures is combined. According to some researchers, the verbal and pictorial information remain two separate, though interconnected subsystems, an assumption that is grounded in Paivio's dual coding theory ([@B36], [@B37],[@B38]; [@B40]). Others claim that the two types of representations are merged into a single representation. This results in a richer mental representation of the story, and therefore enhanced comprehension ([@B46]; [@B47]). While both mental imagery and pictures have been shown to contribute to reading comprehension, not many studies have examined the interaction between mental imagery skills and "picture reading ability" in predicting reading comprehension. It is therefore not quite clear how various levels of mental imagery skills contribute to the comprehension of texts with pictures. On the one hand, it is thought that especially readers with low mental imagery skills may benefit from pictures accompanying a text, because these pictures can help them form a mental model of the story ([@B15]; [@B18]). On the other hand, readers with higher mental imagery skills might be better able to integrate the information from two different sources into one mental model ([@B6]; [@B41]; [@B40]). That would suggest that adding pictures to a text would be especially beneficial in the case of readers with high imagery skills. This is in line with the idea that for constructing both external and internal pictures (i.e., mental images), the same underlying processes of selecting, combining, and organizing information are involved ([@B29]). The latter view is supported by a study that did examine the interaction between mental imagery skills and picture reading ability in texts ([@B13]). Readers in this study who used mental imagery skills and pictures in interconnected ways, showed enhanced text comprehension. These findings suggest a positive interaction between mental images and pictures. In the current study, this interaction is further explored. So far, research has been focused mainly on texts in which pictures were added as some kind of supplementary material. In this quasi-experimental study, we are interested in what will happen to children's comprehension when they are confronted with a different kind of text, i.e., a text in which pictures occasionally replace words. We created a unique experimental storybook for 10- to 12-year-old children, in which parts of the story were told only in the form of illustrations. In contrast to the pictures in graphic novels and comic books, the illustrations in our experimental storybook did not contain any words, i.e., there were no captions. In order to understand such a text, children need to combine the information they derived from the pictures with information they derived from the written text into their mental model. We compared children's story comprehension of our experimental narrative to two control conditions: (1) a version of the narrative that contains the complete text of the story plus all additional pictures; (2) a version of the narrative, consisting of the full text only, without any pictures. The current study set out to investigate the role of children's mental imagery skills, when reading a text in one of these three test conditions. Previous studies have suggested relations between the processing of external and internal images ([@B13]; [@B29]). We therefore expected that children's mental imagery skills are related to their ability to "read" pictures and to combine two sources of information (pictures and text) into a complete understanding of a story. We hypothesized that children's comprehension of the experimental narrative is related to individual differences in mental imagery skills. In other words, children who self-report that they are, in general, not used to creating (many) mental images when they are reading were expected to experience more difficulties with the experimental narrative, compared to children with higher mental imagery skills. Contrasting children's comprehension of our experimental narrative to the two control conditions allows us to take a closer look at the difficulty that children with different levels of mental imagery skills may experience when integrating text and pictures. We chose fifth graders as our participants, because we were interested in examining readers who had passed the early stages of reading development. Materials and Methods {#s1} ===================== Participants ------------ The participants in this study were 150 fifth graders (72 boys, 78 girls) from ten different primary schools. One class per school participated, and between 6 and 22 students per class participated in the study. The schools were situated in the north-western part of the Netherlands in the greater-Amsterdam region and were part of the same school district. They can be considered mainstream schools. Students were between 10 and 12 years old (*M*~age~ = 11.1 years, *SD* = 0.39). Children with learning or behavioral problems (e.g., dyslexia, AD(H)D), as reported by their teachers, were excluded from the sample (*n* = 21), which reduced the original sample of 171 children to 150 children. Reading Materials ----------------- For this study, we used the first chapter of a Dutch children's book that had not yet been published at the time of the data collection. The book was written by a respected Dutch children's book author, in collaboration with a well-known illustrator. The book contained a fictitious narrative story about a boy growing up with his father, a samurai, in Japan ([@B27]). Three different versions of the same narrative were created: the experimental picture version; the pictures-and-text version; and the text-only version. To illustrate the differences between these three versions we have included sample pages in Appendices A to C. These pages were taken from near the end of chapter 1. Likewise, the corresponding story comprehension questions are given in Appendix D. ### Experimental Picture Version In the experimental narrative, the story (18 pages) was partly told in words (about 1,800), and partly in pictures (nine full pages). Text blocks (between about 150 and 750 words) were alternated by one- or two-page picture spreads. These pictures replaced textual information of about 200 words. For example, in the sample pages of the experimental picture version (see Appendix A), the paragraphs describing Kodo's final successful training were deleted and replaced by a two-page picture spread. Children were required to infer the important information from that picture. Sometimes, important "missing" textual information that could not be captured in the picture is summarized in a few sentences at the beginning of the next paragraph. Despite these little summaries, the experimental picture version required the children to look at the pictures very carefully in order to get a full comprehension of the text, since the story was continued in the pictures. This version was pilot-tested with individual children by the author of the book at a Dutch primary school and the children's reactions were filmed and analyzed ([@B26]). The pilot research showed that children were able to understand this interplay between text and pictures and that, in general, they enjoyed reading the story. ### Pictures-and-Text Version The pictures-and-text narrative (23 pages) consisted of the same pictures that were used in the experimental narrative plus the whole text of the story (about 2,500 words). The text was alternated by corresponding one- or two-page picture spreads (see Appendix B). ### Text-Only Version The text-only narrative (14 pages) consisted of the complete text of the story (about 2,500 words) and no pictures (see Appendix C). Procedure --------- A parallel group design was employed to compare the three versions of the narrative. Children with parental consent from one classroom all received the same book version to prevent them from being distracted by the noticeable differences among book versions. Classrooms were randomly assigned to one of the versions. The distribution of boys and girls was relatively equal across book versions. Two group test sessions were organized, led by the researcher and a research assistant. During the first session, the children received a self-report questionnaire, which included scales that tapped into children's imagery skills and social-economic status (SES). This session lasted 15--30 min. In addition, schools provided us with the standard test scores (standard reading test scores and oral reading fluency test scores) of the participating children who had parental consent. During the second session, about 1 week later, children participated in the experiment. The experimental picture version was read by 47 children (31.3% in total; 46.8% boys, 53.2% girls; three classrooms); the pictures-and-text version by 54 children (36.0% in total; 46.3% boys, 53.7% girls; four classrooms); and the text-only version by 49 children (32.7%; 51.0% boys, 49.0% girls; three classrooms). Children were instructed to carefully read the story, and to take as much time as they wanted, because they were supposed to answer the comprehension questions without having access to the text. Additional instructions were given in classrooms in which the experimental picture version was read. Children in these classrooms were told that they were about to read a different kind of book. They were instructed to carefully read the words and look at the pictures, because both contributed to the story. Directly after handing in the booklet, children received another booklet with 28 multiple-choice questions about the story. During this session, which had a maximum duration of 60 min, all children were seated at individual desks to prevent them from copying each other's work and from talking to each other. According to the Ethical Principles of our university, a study on a group of people, such as students in a classroom is exempt from individual informed consent. Such consent was, however, given by parents, children, teachers, and the school board. In addition, children were informed that they could stop participating at any time they wished. Questionnaire ------------- A self-report questionnaire was developed to evaluate children's mental imagery skills and SES. This questionnaire was administered to the children during the first session. ### Mental Imagery Children answered nine questions about mental imagery, that tapped into both the visual aspect (e.g., *When I read, it's like as if I see the people in the story*), and the mentalizing aspect (e.g., *When someone in the story is happy, I can almost feel that myself*). These items were developed by [@B51], and were validated in a large sample of Dutch fourth, sixth, eighth, and tenth grade students. The questionnaire aimed to measure children's general self-reported ability to create mental images while reading. The students were instructed to choose the answer that best described themselves, ranging from never (=1) to always (=4). A mean score was created for each child (*M* = 2.34, *SD* = 0.69, range = 1.11--4.00) and a higher score on this measure reflects more self-reported imagery skills. One missing value per participant was allowed when creating the mean score (2% had one missing value). The scale showed a good internal consistency: Cronbach's α = 0.89. ### Social-Economic Status (SES) To establish Social-Economic Status, the four questions of the Family Affluence Scale ([@B7]) were used, that was especially created for children. For each participant a composite SES score was created following the authors' instructions. In our sample, a total mean score of *M* = 6.75 was obtained (*SD* = 1.86), with scores ranging between 3 and 9. According to [@B7], these scores can be translated into 0% children with a low SES, 22.0% with a medium SES, and 76.7% with a high SES (we had missing values for two children). Reading Ability Measures ------------------------ ### Standard Reading Test We used standard reading test scores of reading comprehension tests (Cito-tests; [@B54]) that are administered in February at almost every school in the Netherlands, including all participating schools. The test scores are an important source of information for teachers to decide how to differentiate their reading instruction. Raw scores on these tests are converted by a computer program to ability scores and norm-referenced scores, which allows comparison between schools. In our study, we used children's ability scores (*M* = 48.71, *SD* = 15.61, range = 17--122). The standard reading test consists of a booklet with a number of texts that children have to read and answer comprehension questions about. ### Oral Reading Fluency As an indication for children's oral reading fluency, we used another Dutch standard test that is administered twice a year (in February and June) at almost every school in the Netherlands, including all participating schools. Children are asked to read as many (isolated) real words as they are capable of within 1 min (DMT-tests; [@B28]). Test scores are based on fluency and accuracy and provide schools with ability and norm-referenced scores, comparable to the standard reading test mentioned above. The scores we used in our study were acquired in June, which was around the time of the experiment. The mean score for our participants was 99.52 (*SD* = 13.29, range = 61--133). ### Story Comprehension Test We carefully developed a story comprehension test with 28 multiple-choice questions with four answer possibilities about the story the children read during the experimental test session in June. One question in the task was deleted, because it appeared that this question was easier to answer for children who read the experimental picture version (which explicitly stated the answer in the text), compared to children who read one of the two control versions (who had to make an inference in order to be able to answer that specific question). Therefore, the story comprehension score is based on the 27 remaining questions. Some questions were on information that was explicitly mentioned in the text (e.g., example question 3 and 4 in Appendix D), and other questions required the children to make inferences which are an indication of an overall understanding of the story (e.g., example question 1 in Appendix D). The comprehension test was pilot tested with fifth graders with different levels of reading ability, and this resulted in some changes in wording. Children had to complete the test without having the text at their disposal, so they were not able to look up the answer. One child was excluded from the dataset, because he skipped two pages (containing 12 questions) of the test. Total story comprehension scores varied between 9 and 27 correct answers (*M* = 20.11, *SD* = 3.82). Reliability analyses showed a Cronbach's alpha of α = 0.72. The Pearson's correlation coefficient between this story comprehension score and the standard reading test was significant and positive (*r* = 0.47, *p* \< 0.001), implying that children who were good at reading comprehension in general also scored higher on our story comprehension measure. Statistical Analyses -------------------- To analyze the data, we used the statistical package SPSS (version 23). We first performed correlation analyses and independent samples *t*-tests in order to determine which variables should be included as covariates in subsequent analyses. Since we randomly assigned classes to a test condition, and students within classes share (teaching) experiences that might influence their reading performance, we decided to perform multilevel analyses. The intraclass correlation showed that class explained only 2.8% (ρ = 0.03) of the variance in children's story comprehension. However, since our design was hierarchically structured, we decided to use multilevel analyses, nesting students within classrooms. We used restricted maximum likelihood estimation, because we were not interested in comparing several models. As fixed effects, we included our covariates, mental imagery, test condition, and the interaction between mental imagery and test condition. Classroom was added as our random intercept. Results ======= First, correlations were calculated between the continuous variables (**Table [1](#T1){ref-type="table"}**). Since we did not find any significant correlations for SES, we did not control for this measure in our analyses. We did control for sex, because independent samples *t*-tests (**Table [2](#T2){ref-type="table"}**) showed sex differences in mental imagery \[*t*(148) = -2.04, *p* = 0.044\] and standard reading scores \[*t*(146) = -3.76, *p* \< 0.001\]. For both variables girls significantly outperformed boys. We also checked for any pre-existing differences between children who were randomly assigned on classroom level to our three test conditions and we found differences in oral reading fluency \[*F*(2,147) = 8.28, *p* \< 0.001\]. Therefore, we included sex and oral reading fluency as covariates in all our analyses. ###### Correlations between SES and reading scores. 1 2 3 4 5 --------------------------- ------ ---------- ---------- ---------- --- 1\. SES X 2\. Standard reading test 0.06 X 3\. Oral reading fluency 0.05 0.29^∗∗^ X 4\. Story comprehension 0.10 0.46^∗∗^ 0.31^∗∗^ X 5\. Mental imagery skills 0.09 0.34^∗∗^ 0.32^∗∗^ 0.26^∗∗^ X ∗ p \< 0.05, ∗∗ p ≤ 0.01, ∗∗∗ p \< 0.001. ###### Sex differences on SES and reading scores. Boys Girls ---------------------------- ------- ------- -------- ------- SES 6.76 1.56 6.74 1.62 Standard reading test^∗∗∗^ 43.90 12.80 53.14 16.69 Oral reading fluency 98.60 12.45 100.37 14.04 Story comprehension 19.83 3.54 20.36 4.06 Mental imagery skills^∗^ 2.22 0.65 2.45 0.71 ∗ p \< 0.05, ∗∗ p \< 0.01, ∗∗∗ p \< 0.001. Imagery and Pictures Replacing Text in Relation to Story Comprehension ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Our multilevel analyses (**Table [3](#T3){ref-type="table"}**) showed that the interaction between imagery skills and test condition significantly predicted children's story comprehension \[*F*(2,140.05) = 3.38, *p* = 0.037\]. This indicates that the effect of children's imagery skills on their story comprehension scores depended on the book version they read. The parameter estimates showed that the imagery skills of children who read the experimental picture version significantly contributed to their story comprehension \[*b* = 2.54, *SE* = 1.15, *t*(137.51) = 2.20, *p* = 0.029\], compared to children who read the text-only version. There were no differences between children who read the pictures-and-text version and children who read the text-only version \[*b* = 0.47, *SE* = 1.18, *t*(140.57) = 0.40, *p* = 0.688\]. In **Figure [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}**, the interaction is visualized, based on a median split on children's mental imagery skills (median = 2.22). ###### Fixed effects estimates predicting children's story comprehension (*N* = 150 individuals from 10 schools). *Estimates* *SE* *95% CI* ----------------------------------------------------------- ------------- -------- --------------- **Fixed effects** Intercept 14.01 2.87 8.33, 19.69 Sex (=boys) -0.09 0.59 -1.25, 1.07 Oral reading fluency 0.07^∗∗^ 0.02 0.02, 0.11 Mental imagery skills 0.04 0.92 -1.79, 1.86 Test condition (=1) -7.85^∗∗^ 2.66 -13.12, -2.58 Test condition (=2) -1.33 2.76 -6.79, 4.13 Interaction test condition (=1) ^∗^ mental imagery skills 2.54^∗^ 1.15 0.26, 4.82 Interaction test condition (=2) ^∗^ mental imagery skills 0.47 1.18 -1.85, 2.80 **Random effects** Residual 11.78^∗∗∗^ 1.43 9.29, 14.94 Intercept 0.34 0.58 0.01, 9.72 Estimated parameters 10 -2 restricted log likelihood 789.97 Test condition 1 = experimental picture version; test condition 2 = pictures-and-text version; test condition 3 = text-only version. ∗ p \< 0.05, ∗∗ p \< 0.01, ∗∗∗ p \< 0.001. {#F1} The same pattern was found when we computed the correlation between children's mental imagery and story comprehension for the three conditions separately. There only was a moderate relation for the experimental picture version (*r* = 0.55, *p* \< 0.001 for bivariate correlations; *r* = 0.53, *p* \< 0.001 for partial correlations, controlling for gender and oral reading fluency), whereas no significant relations between mental imagery skills and story comprehension were found for the text-only and the pictures-and-text condition. This shows that children with higher imagery skills were better able to understand the story in the experimental picture condition, whereas imagery skills did not affect their comprehension of the story in the control versions. Discussion ========== The aim of the present study was to examine the role of mental imagery skills when reading a narrative text with alternating pictures and words. To do so, we examined fifth graders' comprehension of an experimental book version in which the words were partly replaced by pictures and compared this to two control groups, who read a book version with only text or with all text and pictures. We found an interaction between book version and mental imagery skills. Children with lower imagery skills had problems understanding our experimental book version, whereas this was not the case for our control conditions. This implies that children who are more experienced in using mental imagery during reading were able to build a mental model that helped them connect pictures and words in such a way that this enhanced their understanding of this experimental narrative. Children with lower imagery skills, in contrast, were less skilled at this procedure and may not have been able to integrate words and pictures into a meaningful story. Consequently, they experienced comprehension difficulties. Our results particularly show that reading a narrative that requires a correct interpretation of the pictures, and a correct integration of these pictures with the text places high demands on imaginative abilities ([@B6]; [@B41]; [@B45]; [@B40]). In the experimental version, children were required to look at the pictures carefully and integrate the core information from those pictures with the text in order to get full understanding of the story. For example, the sample pages in Appendix A show a scene, in which Kodo is practicing his fighting skills with his father. Children should combine the words describing the events that happened before (the first fighting practices) with the displayed picture and the words that follow the picture. From this they should infer that the practice displayed in the picture went better. For children who have trouble forming images or making a movie in their "mind's eye" while reading, this might be a task that is too difficult to perform successfully. This will, however, lead to an incomplete understanding of the story and to lower performance on the story comprehension task. Imagery skills might be especially important in the comprehension of texts in which a lot of the information is not explicitly stated, since those texts require more work from the reader. Overall, children with lower imagery skills (using a median split) who read the experimental version achieved a score of 62% correct, whereas the low-imagery group who read one of the control conditions had a score of 76% correct. An example of a question that reflects this pattern is example question 2 (see Appendix D). Children with lower imagery skills who read the experimental version found this question harder (*n* = 21; 67% answered correctly) than children who read one of the control conditions (*n* = 57; 77% answered correctly). Interestingly, this question is not directly connected to a specific part of the text that has been replaced by a picture in the experimental version. We assume that this is because many questions in the story comprehension test require an overall understanding of the text. Future studies might examine the questions in our story comprehension test in more detail, for example with the items of the test included as a level in a multilevel analysis. This might show different patterns of questions answered correctly by children with higher versus lower imagery skills when reading the experimental narrative. Finding such patterns would shed more light on the way mental imagery skills aid in understanding a story that requires an integration of information from text and pictures. It has been reported repeatedly that individual differences in mental imagery skills are related to differences in reading comprehension ([@B6]; [@B50]; [@B18]; [@B10]). However, in our study we found that this was only the case for the experimental picture version. Contrary to our experimental narrative, our two control versions stated all information in words. Such "concrete" stories are thought to require less reading between the lines and to elicit mental imagery more easily ([@B8]; [@B40]). For the pictures-and-text and the text-only versions, performance on the story comprehension task was not affected by mental imagery skills. Perhaps the information in these two book versions was so concrete that individual differences in mental imagery skills did not contribute to a differential story comprehension task performance. However, we did not examine our narratives on explicitness of information. Future research might examine texts that differ in the explicitness of information that is provided. In this study, we used the first chapter of an original fictive narrative children's story, which is a relatively long text, compared to the short stories or sentences that are often used in reading research. Therefore, we assume that our results provide a realistic view on the way children use their mental imagery skills to interpret "authentic" stories composed of text and pictures. Interestingly, our study did not show an advantage for children who read the story with full text and pictures, for we found no difference in story comprehension scores between children who read the pictures-and-text version and the text-only version. According to the multimedia effect, children who read the pictures-and-text version should have had an advantage as processing both pictures and text should result in deeper learning ([@B38]; [@B45]; [@B46]; [@B47]), but that was not the case. It may be that children who read the pictures-and-text version did not actively process the pictures to understand the storyline, because the story in words was already clear and engaging enough for them ([@B8]). Another reason might be that the condition of spatial contiguity was not met. According to the so-called "spatial contiguity principle," text and pictures should be presented close to each other for a positive effect on learning ([@B36], [@B38]). In our materials, however, text was alternated with one- or two-page picture spreads. Importantly, the order of presentation (i.e., text before picture or picture before text) does not seem to affect comprehension ([@B11]). Our study has some important implications for educational practice, focusing both at children's "picture reading" and mental imagery skills. First, since our results have not shown the added value of pictures accompanying a story, it might be useful to provide trainings to teach children how to "read" the pictures they encounter in order to improve their reading comprehension. Such visual literacy trainings are not common in educational practice, however ([@B10]; [@B43]), especially when it comes to the reading of narratives. When picture instructions are given, they tend to be non-specific, not indicating what one should be looking at in the illustration. That is, it is unlikely that children will capture the full meaning of a (complex) illustration, when they are merely told to pay attention to it ([@B30]; [@B55]; [@B41]; [@B43]). While the global meaning of a picture can usually be understood in a rapid way, full and deep understanding of the picture, on a higher order level, requires more cognitive effort ([@B41]; [@B4]; [@B12]; [@B1]; [@B5]; [@B43]). Furthermore, such trainings should include a focus on metacognitive skills. Children should be taught to monitor their understanding of the story, including the illustrations ([@B41]). Since learners tend to perceive the processing of pictures as relatively easy, they will probably not be able to monitor their understanding properly ([@B1]). This is reflected in the overall lower reading comprehension score of children who read our experimental picture version. These children might not have taken enough effort to fully comprehend the pictures they encountered while reading the story. A second implication follows from our findings on the importance of mental imagery skills. Teaching children how to use mental imagery will improve their imagery skills ([@B18]; [@B2]; [@B10]), which can contribute to better reading performance as well. Particularly children with poor imagery skills can benefit from these trainings ([@B4]). In order for a mental imagery training to be successful, teachers need to model mental imagery by thinking-out-loud and providing children with feedback on their imagery ([@B52]). Previous research has indeed found that a combination of mental imagery strategy training and visual literacy training was the most successful approach for improving reading comprehension of fourth-graders ([@B13]; [@B56]). Experimental research on finding effective ways to teach children how to successfully deal with visual information and to develop mental imagery skills is limited though. There are some issues that could be taken into account when interpreting our findings. First, children in our study had no access to the story text while answering the story comprehension questions, because we were explicitly interested in their ability to form a mental representation of the text. We expect that the absence of the text did not lower their performance, since we have informed children in advance about the comprehension test and previous research has shown that children's reading performance is not affected when children are informed in advance ([@B44]). Second, a self-report scale was used to measure mental imagery skills. Research with young adults has shown that such self-report scales measure the same underlying construct as fMRI-tasks of mental imagery ([@B9]). However, future work is required to replicate this finding with younger children. Third, it might be that our relatively long narrative evoked much mental imagery ([@B34]), so that the children did not look at the pictures carefully, because these interfered with their own mental images ([@B46]). We did not ask children about the mental images they created while they were reading the book chapter and whether or not their images matched with the pictures in the book. It would be interesting to replicate this study by also including a behavioral measure of mental imagery, and assessing children's accuracy and reaction time in creating mental images. Future studies might also include a measure of working memory, as it has been shown that working memory is involved in understanding visual narratives (see, for example, [@B31]). A final issue concerns the type of text examined. Children are not very likely to come across narratives like our experimental book version in everyday life. They may have experience with comic books and graphic novels though, in which they also have to integrate pictures and text to understand the storyline ([@B19],[@B20]). However, these stories are told by a sequence of images on each page, accompanied by captions in relatively small boxes or balloons. Our experimental book version, in contrast, contained full-page text blocks, alternated by one- or two-page picture spreads without any words. It would be interesting to examine whether imagery skills also play a role in understanding comic books and graphic novels. Conclusion ========== As texts are currently no longer the main source of information in everyday life and information becomes more and more multimodal, the need for adequate visual literacy and mental imagery skills becomes stronger and stronger ([@B53]; [@B48]; [@B43]). Our findings indicate that interpreting pictures adequately is an ability that not all children possess. In addition, children differ in mental imagery skills, which are used to integrate words and pictures into one coherent mental model of the story. Future research should examine ways to effectively teach children how to interpret pictures that accompany or replace words and how to incorporate that information into their mental model of the story. Presumably, teaching children effective visual literacy and mental imagery strategies will lead to improved mental models and therefore enhanced story comprehension. Author Contributions ==================== All authors (IB, SM, and JJ) confirm that they contributed to this paper by: Contributing substantially to the conception of the work (IB and SM); or the acquisition, analysis, and interpretation of the data (IB, SM, and JJ); drafting the work (IB) or revising it critically for important intellectual content (IB, SM, and JJ); approving the final version of the paper to be published (IB, SM, and JJ); agreeing to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved (IB, SM, and JJ). Conflict of Interest Statement ============================== The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest. We would like to thank the schools and children for their effort in participating in our study. Special thanks go to author Bert Kouwenberg (1947--2015), who kindly provided us all printed book versions, and the opportunity to experimentally test his new book concept. Supplementary Material ====================== The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: <http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.01630> ###### Click here for additional data file. [^1]: Edited by: *Ying Guo, University of Cincinnati, USA* [^2]: Reviewed by: *Lester C. Loschky, University of Illinois at Urbana--Champaign, USA; Meryem Yilmaz Soylu, Formerly affiliated with Meliksah University, Turkey* [^3]: This article was submitted to Educational Psychology, a section of the journal Frontiers in Psychology

\section*{Appendix. #1} \renewcommand{\thesection.\arabic{equation}}}{A\arabic{equation}} \renewcommand{\thesection}{A} } \newcommand{\appsection}[2]{\setcounter{equation}{0} \section*{Appendix #1. #2} \renewcommand{\thesection.\arabic{equation}}}{#1\arabic{equation}} \renewcommand{\thesection}{#1} } \catcode`\@=11 \def\@addtoreset{equation}{section{\@addtoreset{equation}{section} \def\thesection.\arabic{equation}}{\thesection.\arabic{equation}}} \@addtoreset{equation}{section \begin{document} \vspace*{1.5cm} \begin{center} {\Large \bf Global fluctuations for 1D log-gas dynamics} \end{center} \vspace{2mm} \begin{center} {\bf J\'er\'emie Unterberger$^a$} \end{center} \vskip 0.5 cm \centerline {$^a$Institut Elie Cartan,\footnote{Laboratoire associ\'e au CNRS UMR 7502} Universit\'e de Lorraine,} \centerline{ B.P. 239, F -- 54506 Vand{\oe}uvre-l\`es-Nancy Cedex, France} \centerline{jeremie.unterberger@univ-lorraine.fr} \vspace{2mm} \begin{quote} \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1.0} \footnotesize {We study in this article the hydrodynamic limit in the macroscopic regime of the coupled system of stochastic differential equations, \BEQ d\lambda_t^i=\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} dW_t^i - V'(\lambda_t^i) dt+ \frac{\beta}{2N} \sum_{j\not=i} \frac{dt}{\lambda^i_t-\lambda^j_t}, \qquad i=1,\ldots,N, \EEQ with $\beta>1$, sometimes called {\em generalized Dyson's Brownian motion}, describing the dissipative dynamics of a log-gas of $N$ equal charges with equilibrium measure corresponding to a $\beta$-ensemble, with sufficiently regular convex potential $V$. The limit $N\to\infty$ is known to satisfy a mean-field Mac-Kean-Vlasov equation. We prove that, for suitable initial conditions, fluctuations around the limit are Gaussian and satisfy an explicit PDE. The proof is very much indebted to the harmonic potential case treated in Israelsson \cite{Isr}. Our key argument consists in showing that the time-evolution generator may be written in the form of a transport operator on the upper half-plane, plus a bounded non-local operator interpreted in terms of a signed jump process. } \end{quote} \vspace{4mm} \noindent \medskip \noindent {\bf Keywords:} random matrices, Dyson's Brownian motion, log-gas, beta-ensembles, hydrodynamic limit, Stieltjes transform, entropy \smallskip \noindent {\bf Mathematics Subject Classification (2010):} 60B20; 60F05; 60G20; 60J60; 60J75; 60K35 \newpage \tableofcontents \section{Introduction and statement of main results} \subsection{Introduction} Let $\beta\ge 1 $ be a fixed parameter, and $N\ge 1$ an integer. We consider the following system of coupled stochastic differential equations driven by $N$ independent standard Brownian motions $(W_t^1,\ldots,W_t^N)_{t\ge 0}$, \BEQ d\lambda_t^i=\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} dW_t^i - V'(\lambda_t^i) dt+ \frac{\beta}{2N} \sum_{j\not=i} \frac{dt}{\lambda^i_t-\lambda^j_t}, \qquad i=1,\ldots,N \label{eq:SDE} \EEQ Letting \BEQ {\cal W}(\{\lambda^i\}_i):=\sum_{i=1}^N V(\lambda^i)-\frac{\beta}{4N} \sum_{i\not=j} \log(\lambda^i-\lambda^j),\EEQ we can rewrite (\ref{eq:SDE}) as $d\lambda_t^i=\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} dW_t^i-\nabla_i {\cal W} (\lambda_t^1,\ldots,\lambda_t^N) dt$. Thus the corresponding equilibrium measure, \BEQ d\mu^N_{eq}(\{\lambda^i\}_i) = \frac{1}{Z^N_V} e^{-2N{\cal W}(\{\lambda^i\}_i)}=\frac{1}{Z^N_V} \left(\prod_{j\not=i} |\lambda^j-\lambda^i|\right)^{\beta/2} \exp\left(-2N\sum_{i=1}^N V(\lambda^i)\right) \ d\lambda^1\cdots d\lambda^N \label{eq:eq-measure} \EEQ is that of a $\beta$-log gas with confining potential $V$. \medskip \noindent Let us start with a historical overview of the subject as a motivation for our study. This system of equations was originally considered in a particular case by Dyson \cite{Dys} who wanted to describe the Markov evolution of a Hermitian matrix $M_t$ with i.i.d. increments $dG_t$ taken from the Gaussian unitary ensemble (GUE). In Dyson's idea, this matrix-valued process was to be a matrix analogue of Brownian motion. The latter time-evolution being invariant through conjugation by unitary matrices, we may project it onto a time-evolution of the set of eigenvalues $\{\lambda_t^1,\ldots,\lambda_t^N\}$ of the matrix, and obtain (\ref{eq:SDE}) with $\beta=2$ and $V\equiv 0$. Keeping $\beta=2$, it is easy to prove that (\ref{eq:SDE}) is equivalent to a generalized matrix Markov evolution, $dM_t=dG_t-V'(M_t) dt$. The Gibbs measure $${\cal P}^N_V(M)=\frac{1}{Z_N} e^{-N{\mathrm{Tr}} V(M)} dM, \qquad dM=\prod_{i=1}^N dM_{ii} \prod_{1\le i<j\le n} d\Re M_{ij} \ d\Im M_{ij} $$ can then be proved to be an equilibrium measure. Such measures, together with their projection onto the eigenvalue set, $\mu^N_{eq}(\{\lambda^1,\ldots,\lambda^N\})$, are the main object of random matrix theory, see e.g. \cite{Meh},\cite{And}, \cite{Pas}. The {\em equilibrium eigenvalue distribution} can be studied by various means, in particular using orthogonal polynomials with respect to the weight $e^{-NV(\lambda)}$. The scaling in $N$ (called {\em macroscopic scaling} in random matrix theory) ensures the convergence of the random point measure $X^N:=\frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^N \delta_{\lambda^i}$ to a deterministic measure $\mu_V$ with {\em compact} support and density $\rho$ when $N\to\infty$ (see e.g. \cite{Joh}, Theorem 2.1). One finds e.g. the well-known semi-circle law, $\rho(x)=\frac{1}{\pi}\sqrt{2-x^2}$, when $V(x)=x^2/2$. Looking more closely at the limit of the point measure, one finds for arbitrary {\em polynomial} $V$ (Johansson \cite{Joh}) Gaussian fluctuations of order $O(1/N)$, contrasting with the $O(1/\sqrt{N})$ scaling of fluctuations for the means of $N$ independent random variables, typical of the central limit theorem. Assuming that the support of the measure is connected (this essential "one-cut" condition holding in particular for $V$ {\em convex}), Johansson proves that the {\em covariance} of the limiting law depends on $V$ only through the support of the measure -- it is thus {\em universal} up to a scaling coefficient --, while the means is equal to $\rho$, plus an apparently non-universal correction in $O(1/N)$. \medskip Then Rogers and Shi \cite{RogShi}, disregarding the random matrix background, studied directly for its sake the system (\ref{eq:SDE}) in the case where $V$ is harmonic (i.e. quadratic) and $\beta=2$, which we call {\em Hermite case} henceforth (by reference to the corresponding class of equilibrium orthogonal polynomials), proving in particular the following two facts: \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] two arbitrary eigenvalues never collide, which implies the non-explosion of (\ref{eq:SDE}); \item[(ii)] the random point process $X^N_t:=\frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^N \delta_{\lambda^i_t}$ satisfies in the limit $N\to\infty$ a deterministic hydrodynamic equation of Mc-Kean Vlasov type, namely, the asymptotic density \BEQ \rho_t \equiv X_t:={\mathrm{w\!-\!\!\lim}}_{N\to\infty} X_t^N \EEQ satisfies the PDE \BEQ \frac{\partial \rho_t(x)}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\left( \left( x- p.v. \int \frac{dy}{x-y}\rho_t(y) \right)\rho_t(x)\right), \label{eq:McKV0} \EEQ where $p.v. \int \frac{dy}{x-y}\rho_t(y)$ is a principal value integral. \end{itemize} In the case studied by Rogers and Shi, explicit formulas for finite $N$ are known for the Markov generator in the form of a determinant, called {\em extended kernel}, see e.g. \cite{For}, chapter XI, or \cite{ForNag}), whose asymptotics for $N\to\infty$ may in principle be used to study the macroscopic limit. This is accomplished by noting that a simple conjugation trick turns the generator of the process into an $N$-particle Hamiltonian with a {\em one-body} potential only, whose eigenfunctions are deduced from those of one-particle Hamiltonians (actually, harmonic oscillators). {\em For general $V$, however}, in marked contrast with respect to the equilibrium case, no explicit formulas are known for finite $N$, even for $\beta=2$, since the conjugation trick produces a supplementary two-body potential making the spectral problem unsolvable. To be more precise, Macedo and Macedo \cite{MacMac} classified all random matrix dynamics which are unitary equivalent to imaginary-time evolution under a Calogero-Sutherland type Hamiltonian, providing explicit determinantal solutions in connection to classical orthogonal polynomials when $\beta=2$; however, restricting to SDE's with {\em additive} noise, the latter class contains only the Hermite case. Related models of diffusions conditioned on non-intersecting, solvable in terms of classical orthogonal polynomials, have been considered in Duits \cite{Dui}, who showed convergence of fluctuation field to inhomogeneous Gaussian free field. Then for $\beta\not=2$, the finite $N$ equilibrium measure is not fully understood, even in the harmonic case, see \cite{ValVir}. \medskip \noindent This makes the direct study of (\ref{eq:SDE}) for general $V$ and $\beta$ all the more interesting. Whereas the PDE appearing in the hydrodynamical limit is known \cite{LiLiXie}, the law of fluctuations is not known in general, and it is the purpose of this study, and of the forthcoming article \cite{Unt-law}, to fill this gap. S. Li, X.-D. Li and Y.-X. Xie \cite{LiLiXie}, generalizing properties (i) and (ii) above, prove that the random point process $X^N_t$ satisfies in the limit $N\to\infty$ a generalization of the above Mc-Kean Vlasov equation, namely, \BEQ \frac{\partial \rho_t(x)}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial}{\partial x} \left( \left(V'(x)- \frac{\beta}{2} \ p.v. \int \frac{dy}{x-y}\, \rho_t(y) \right) \rho_t(x)\right) \label{eq:McKV} \EEQ The equilibrium measure $\rho$, defined as the solution of the integral equation $\frac{\beta}{2} p.v. \int \frac{dy}{x-y} \rho(y)=V'(x)$, cancels the right-hand side of (\ref{eq:McKV}). Replacing in (\ref{eq:SDE}) $\frac{\beta}{2N} \sum_{j\not=i} \frac{1}{\lambda_t^i-\lambda_t^j}$ with\\ $-\frac{1}{N} \sum_{j\not=i} \nabla U(\lambda_t^i-\lambda_t^j)$ where $U$ is some convex two-body potential satisfying some very general properties of regularity and growth at infinity, one may show that there appears in the same limit an equation similar to (\ref{eq:McKV}), \BEQ \frac{\partial \rho_t(x)}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial}{\partial x} \left( \left(V'(x)+ \frac{\beta}{2} \ \int dy \, U'(x-y) \rho_t(y) \right) \rho_t(x)\right) \EEQ Solutions of this type of equations, common in plasma theory and the study of granular media \cite{GolRut,BenCag} and in particular, the rate of convergence of these to equilibrium, have been studied in details using Otto's infinite dimensional differential calculus \cite{Ott} in a series of papers, see e.g. \cite{Car}, \cite{OttVil}, \cite{Vil}. However, as already noted by S. Li, X.-D. Li and Y.-X. Xie, the range of applicability of these papers, written under the assumption that $U$ be {\em Lipschitz}, does not seem to extend to our case when $U(x)=-c\log|x|$. Since formally the law of fluctuations is obtained by linearizing the system of equations (\ref{eq:SDE}) around its macroscopic limit $\rho$, it is clear that one must find some way to deal with (\ref{eq:McKV}). \medskip \noindent Rogers' and Shi's approach to (\ref{eq:SDE}) has been successfully generalized to the case of a harmonic potential with arbitrary $\beta$ by Israelsson \cite{Isr} and Bender \cite{Ben}. The present study owes very much to these two articles, so let us describe to some extent their contents. There are two main ideas. Let $Y^N_t:=N(X^N_t-X_t)$ be the rescaled fluctuation process for finite $N$; we want to prove that $Y^N_t \overset{law}{\to} Y_t$ when $N\to\infty$ and identify the law of the process $(Y_t)_{t\ge 0}$. First, It\^o's formula implies that \BEQ d\langle Y_t^N,f_t\rangle=\half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t^N,f''_t\rangle dt+ \frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N f'_t(\lambda_t^i) dW_t^i \label{eq:Ito} \EEQ if the test functions $(f_t)_{0\le t\le T}$, $f_t:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ solve the following linear PDE \BEQ \frac{\partial f_t}{\partial t}(x)=V'(x)f'_t(x)-\frac{\beta}{4} \int \frac{f'_t(x)-f'_t(y)}{x-y} (X_t^N(dy)+X_t(dy)) \label{eq:intro-PDE-f} \EEQ (see Proposition \ref{prop:Israelsson} below). Eq. (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) is a dualized, linearized version of (\ref{eq:McKV}). Second, eq. (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) may be integrated in the harmonic case by means of a {\em Stieltjes transform} (see Definition \ref{def:Stieltjes}). Namely, the family of functions $\{\frac{c}{\cdot-z}\}_{c\in\mathbb{C},z\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}}$ is preserved by (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}). The solution $\frac{c^N_t}{\cdot-z^N_t}$ at time $t$ with terminal condition $\frac{c^N_T}{\cdot-z^N_T}=\frac{c}{\cdot-z}$ is obtained by solving two coupled ordinary differential equations for $c^N_t$ and $z^N_t$ depending on $X$ and the random point measure $X^N$ (see \cite{Isr}, Lemma 2). Substituting to $X^N$ its deterministic limit $X$ in the r.-h.s. of (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}), one gets in a natural way a system of two coupled ordinary differential equations for $(z_t)_{0\le t\le T}$, $(c_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ that describes a solution of the asymptotic limit of (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) in the limit $N\to\infty$, namely, \BEQ \frac{\partial f_t}{\partial t}(x)=V'(x)f'_t(x)-\frac{\beta}{2} \int \frac{f'_t(x)-f'_t(y)}{x-y} X_t(dy) \label{eq:intro-PDE-f-asymptotic} \EEQ Bender interprets these equations as {\em characteristic equations} for a generalized transport operator (see section \ref{sec:transport}) which is never stated explicitly. Then (at least formally), It\^o's formula (see \cite{Isr}, p. 29) makes it possible to find explicitly the Markov kernel in the limit $N\to\infty$. Namely, consider a finite number of points $(z^k)_k$ in $\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$, and the solutions $(z^k_t)_{t\le T}$ of the corresponding characteristic equations with terminal condition $(z_T^k)_k$. Letting $f_t(x):=\sum_k \frac{c^k_t}{x-z^k_t}$ be the solution of (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f-asymptotic}), and $\phi_{f_t}(Y_t^N):=e^{\II\langle Y_t^N,f_t\rangle}$, \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[\phi_{f_T}(Y_T)\big| {\cal F}_t]={\mathbb{E}}[\phi_{f_t}(Y_t)] \exp\left( \half \int_t^T \left[ \II (1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_s,f''_s\rangle - \langle X_s,(f'_s)^2\rangle \right] ds \right) \label{eq:intro-Gaussian0} \EEQ Since functions $f$ of the above form are dense in some appropriate Sobolev space, formula (\ref{eq:intro-Gaussian0}) allows to conclude that the limit process is Gaussian. Then Bender solves explicitly the characteristic equations, which take on a particularly simple form in the harmonic case, and deduces first the covariance of the Stieltjes transform of the fluctuation process, Cov$(U_{t_1}(z_1),U_{t_2}(z_2))$, $U_t(z):=\langle Y_t,\frac{1}{\cdot-z}\rangle$, and then (taking boundary values and using the Plemelj formula, see section \ref{sec:Stieltjes}), the (distribution-valued) covariance kernel Cov$(Y_{t_1}(x_1),Y_{t_2}(x_2))$. \bigskip \noindent Our approach for the case of a general potential has exactly the same starting point, but dealing with eq. (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) turns out to be more complicated than in the harmonic case. The reason is that the family of functions $\left\{\frac{c}{\cdot-z}\right\}_{c\in\mathbb{C},z\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}}$ is no more preserved by (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}): this is easily seen if $V$ is a polynomial or extends analytically to a strip around the real axis, since \BEQ -V'(x)\partial_x \left(\frac{1}{x-z}\right)=(V'(z)\partial_z+V''(z)) \left( \frac{1}{x-z}\right) + \left( \frac{V^{(3)}(z)}{2!} + \frac{V^{(4)}(z)}{3!} (x-z)+ \ldots \right)\EEQ features extra unwanted polynomial terms. In practice we need only assume that $V$ is sufficiently regular, and (letting $z=:a+\II b$) write instead, for $a$ in a neighbourhood of the support of the random point measure \BEQ V'(x)=V'(a)+V''(a)(x-a)+V'''(a) \frac{(x-a)^2}{2} +(x-a)^3 W_a(x-a), \label{eq:intro-W} \EEQ and find for the first three terms, \BEQ -V'(a)\partial_x \left(\frac{1}{x-z}\right)=V'(a)\partial_a \left(\frac{1}{x-z}\right), \ \ -V''(a)(x-a) \partial_x \left(\frac{1}{x-z}\right)=V''(a)\left(1+b\partial_b\right) \frac{1}{x-z}, \label{eq:1.14} \EEQ \BEQ -V'''(a) \frac{(x-a)^2}{2} \partial_x\left(\frac{1}{x-z}\right)=\half V'''(a)+ \half V'''(a) (2\II b+b^2\partial_a) \frac{1}{x-z}, \label{eq:1.15} \EEQ defining a generalized transport operator \BEQ -V'(a)\partial_a-V''(a)(1+b\partial_b)- \half V'''(a) (2\II b+b^2\partial_a). \label{eq:generalized-transport-operator} \EEQ The new piece is the last (Taylor's remainder) term in (\ref{eq:intro-W}). We must give up at this point the idea that the time-evolution is a simple characteristic evolution, and prove that the Taylor remainder produces instead a {\em non-local kernel}. Let us highlight the main points while avoiding technicalities. The main tool here is the use of {\em Stieltjes decompositions} of order $\kappa$ (see Definition \ref{def:Stieltjes-decomposition}): for any $b_{max}>0$ and $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots$, any sufficient regular, integrable function $f:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ may be written as an integral over the strip $\Pi_{b_{max}}:=\{a\pm\II b\ |\ 0<|b|<b_{max} \}$ \BEQ f(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (-\II b) \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \, \, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) \, h(a,b) \label{eq:intro-Stieltjes-decomposition} \EEQ \BEQ {\mathrm{where}}\qquad {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x):=\frac{1}{x-z}. \EEQ The mapping $f\mapsto h$ is clearly not one-to-one. Explicit Stieltjes decompositions are produced in \cite{Isr}, Lemma 9; part of the job consists precisely in {\em choosing } Stieltjes decompositions with good properties. Let $\kappa'\ge\kappa\ge 0$. Inserting the time-evolution operator (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) into (\ref{eq:intro-Stieltjes-decomposition}), we prove that: -- the $(\frac{1}{x})$-potential and the second-order Taylor expansion of the operator $V'(x)\partial_x$, see (\ref{eq:1.14},\ref{eq:1.15}), act together as a {\em transport operator} ${\cal H}^{\kappa}:L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$; -- the {\em Taylor remainder term} (see \S 3.7), to which one must add an inessential off-support contribution (see \S 3.8) and boundary terms (see \S 3.9), may be realized as a non-local operator $|b|^{\kappa'-\kappa}{\cal H}^{\kappa';\kappa}_{nonlocal}(t)$ acting on the coefficient function $h$, \BEQ |b|^{\kappa'-\kappa}({\cal H}^{\kappa';\kappa}_{nonlocal}(t))(h)(a,b):=|b|^{\kappa'-\kappa}\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T \, g_{nonlocal}^{\kappa';\kappa}(a,b;a_T,b_T)h(a_T,b_T) \EEQ such that \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{nonlocal}(t) :L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \label{eq:regularizing} \EEQ are {\em bounded}. From (\ref{eq:regularizing}) we get: $b{\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{nonlocal}(h)(a,b)= \tilde{h}(a,b)$ with $\tilde{h}\in L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}},|b|^{-1}\, da\, db)$. In other words, the non-local part of the time evolution is (in some weak sense) {\em regularizing} near the real axis, and acts therefore as a bounded perturbation of ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport}$. \subsection{Notations and basic facts} In this paragraph, we simply assume that $V$ is convex. The filtration $({\cal F}_t)_{t\ge 0}$ is the filtration of the Brownian $(W^i_t)_{t\ge 0,i=1,\ldots,N}$. \begin{Definition} \label{def:empirical-fluctuation} \begin{enumerate} \item Let \BEQ X_t^N:=\frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^N \delta_{\lambda_t^i} \EEQ be the empirical measure process. \item Call \BEQ Y_t^N:=N(X_t^N-X_t) \EEQ the finite $N$ {\em fluctuation process}. \end{enumerate} \end{Definition} \noindent The case developed in \cite{Isr} and \cite{Ben} is the {\em harmonic case}, $V(x)=\half x^2$ (up to normalization), to which we shall often refer. Apart from this very particular case, classical examples include the Landau-Ginzburg potential $V(x)=\half x^2+ \frac{\lambda}{4}x^4$, $\lambda\ge 0$, for which the support of the equilibrium measure is connected, and the density is the product of the (rescaled) semi-circle law by some explicit polynomial of degree 2 (see e.g. \cite{Joh}, p. 164). It is proved in (Li-Li-Xie \cite{LiLiXie}, Theorem 1.3) that, provided $X_0^N\overset{N\to\infty}{\to}\rho_0$, a deterministic density, the empirical measure process $(X_t^N)$ converges in law to a deterministic measure process $(X_t)_{t\ge 0}$ with density $\rho_t$ solution of the non-linear Fokker-Planck equation, \BEQ \frac{\partial \rho_t(x)}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial}{\partial x} \left( \left(V'(x)- \frac{\beta}{2} \ p.v. \int \frac{dy}{x-y}\, \rho_t(y) \right) \rho_t(x)\right) \label{eq:rho-t} \EEQ with initial condition $\rho_0$. Equivalently, for any test function $f$, \begin{eqnarray} && \frac{d}{dt} \langle X_t,f\rangle=\frac{d}{dt} \int \rho_t(x) f(x) \, dx= -\int V'(x) f'(x) X_t(dx) + \nonumber\\ &&\qquad \qquad + \frac{\beta}{4} \int \int \frac{f'(x)-f'(y)}{x-y}\, X_t(dx)\, X_t(dy). \label{eq:Xt-t} \end{eqnarray} The equilibrium measure $\mu^N_{eq}$, see (\ref{eq:eq-measure}) converges weakly when $N\to\infty$ to the stationary, deterministic solution $X_t(dx)=\rho_{eq}(x)dx$ of (\ref{eq:rho-t}), where $\rho_{eq}$ is the solution of the following integral equation, called {\em cut equation}, \cite{Joh} \BEQ p.v.\ \int \frac{\rho_{eq}(x)\, dx}{x-y}=-\frac{2}{\beta} V'(y) \label{eq:cut-eq1} \EEQ \medskip Formula (\ref{eq:Xt-t}) is formally obtained as in \cite{RogShi} by taking the limit $N\to\infty$ in the finite $N$ It\^o formula (eq. (3) in \cite{Isr}), \begin{eqnarray} && d\langle X_t^N,f\rangle = \left(\frac{\beta}{4} \int \int \frac{f'(x)-f'(y)}{x-y} X^N_t(dx)X^N_t(dy) - \int V'(x) f'(x) X^N_t(dx) \right) dt \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad \qquad + \half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \frac{1}{N} \langle X_t^N,f''\rangle \, dt + \frac{1}{N\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N f'(\lambda_t^i)dW_t^i. \label{eq:Ito0} \end{eqnarray} Roughly speaking, both terms in the second line of (\ref{eq:Ito0}) are $O(\frac{1}{N})$ (the argument for the martingale term relies on an $L^2-$bound based on the independence of the $(W^i)_{1\le i\le N}$). \begin{Definition}[Stieltjes transform] \label{def:Stieltjes} Fix $z\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$. \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] Let ${\mathfrak{f}}_z(x):=\frac{1}{x-z}$ ($x\in\mathbb{R}$). \item[(ii)] Let, for $z\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$, \BEQ M_t^N:=\langle X_t^N,{\mathfrak{f}}_z\rangle=\sum_{i=1}^N \frac{1}{\lambda^i_t-z}\EEQ and \BEQ M_t:=\langle X_t,{\mathfrak{f}}_z\rangle=\int \frac{\rho_t(x)}{x-z}\, dx\EEQ be the Stieltjes transform of $X_t^N$, resp. $X_t$. \end{itemize} \end{Definition} Starting from the cut equation (\ref{eq:cut-eq1}) and applying Plemelj's formula (see section \ref{sec:Stieltjes}), one finds {\em at equilibrium} \BEQ M(x+\II 0)=-\frac{2}{\beta} V'(x)+\II \pi\rho_{eq}(x) \label{eq:cut-eq2} \EEQ \BEQ M(x+\II 0)-M(x-\II 0)=2\II \pi\rho_{eq}(x),\qquad M(x+\II 0)+M(x-\II 0)=-\frac{4}{\beta}V'(x).\label{eq:cut-eq3} \EEQ \medskip A PDE for the Stieltjes transform of $X_t$ is determined easily from (\ref{eq:Xt-t}), \BEQ \frac{\partial M_t}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial}{\partial z} \left( \frac{\beta}{4} (M_t(z))^2+ V'(z)M_t(z)+T_t(z) \right), \label{eq:T}\EEQ where \BEQ T_t(z):=\int \frac{V'(x)-V'(z)}{x-z} \, X_t(dx).\EEQ {\em In the harmonic case}, $T$ is simply a constant, hence $M$ is the solution of a complex Burgers equation on $\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$, see e.g. \cite{Isr}, eq. (6). However, this is no more the case in our general setting, and the non-local term $T$ in the right-hand side prevents any explicit solution of the equation. Yet the Stieltjes transform will turn out to be a very convenient technical tool in the computations. \bigskip \noindent The first idea, coming from \cite{Isr}, is to {\em transfer the drift in the time-evolution of $Y_t^N$ to the test function $f$}. This is done through a {\em straightforward generalization} of (Israelsson \cite{Isr}, Lemma 1): \begin{Proposition}(see Israelsson \cite{Isr}) \label{prop:Israelsson} Assume the following event holds for some constant $R>0$, \BEQ \Omega_R: \ \sup_{0\le t\le T} \max_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\lambda^i|\le R; \qquad \forall t\le T,\ {\mathrm{supp}}(X_t)\subset[-R,R], \EEQ i.e. that the support of the random point measure $X_t^N$ and of the measure $X_t$ is $\subset[-R,R]$ for $0\le t\le T$. Let $(f_t)_{0\le t\le T}$, $f_t:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ be such that \BEQ \frac{\partial f_t}{\partial t}(x)=V'(x)f'_t(x)-\frac{\beta}{4} \int \frac{f'_t(x)-f'_t(y)}{x-y} (X_t^N(dy)+X_t(dy)) \label{eq:PDE-f} \EEQ for all $|x|\le R$. Then \BEQ d\langle Y_t^N,f_t\rangle=\half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t^N,f''_t\rangle dt+ \frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N f'_t(\lambda_t^i) dW_t^i.\EEQ \end{Proposition} As emphasized in the above Proposition, (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) need only hold on $[-R,R]$, because $\langle X_t^N,f\rangle$ and $\langle X_t,f\rangle$ do {\em not} depend on the values of $f$ on $\mathbb{C}\setminus[-R,R]$. \medskip\noindent The above Proposition is a direct consequence of It\^o's formula applied to the fluctuation process (just subtract (\ref{eq:Ito0}) from (\ref{eq:Xt-t})), \begin{eqnarray} && d\langle Y_t^N,f\rangle=\Big(\frac{\beta}{4} \int \int \frac{f'(x)-f'(y)}{x-y} \left[X_t^N(dx)+X_t(dx)\right] Y_t^N(dy)-\int V'(x)f'(x)Y_t^N(dx) \Big) \, dt \nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad +\half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t^N,f''\rangle \, dt + \frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N f'(\lambda_t^i)dW_t^i. \label{eq:dY_tnf} \end{eqnarray} \medskip Then Israelsson solves eq. (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) in the harmonic case by using as test functions the $\frac{c}{\cdot-z}$, $c\in\mathbb{C},z\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$, on which the generator of time-evolution acts in a particularly simple way. We do not reproduce their results here however, since they do not separate the analysis of the term due to the harmonic potential from that due to the two-body logarithmic potential. We shall analyze (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) in section 3 after we have introduced Stieltjes decompositions. \bigskip {\em Normalization:} the reader willing to compare our results with those of Israelsson \cite{Isr} or Bender \cite{Ben} should take into account the different choices of normalization. Compared to \cite{Isr}, we fix $\sigma=1$ and let $\alpha=\frac{\beta}{2}$, $\gamma=\half(1-\frac{\beta}{2})$. After rescaling the $\lambda^i$'s by a factor $\beta^{-1/2}$, we obtain for $V$ quadratic \cite{Ben} with $\sigma=\half$. \subsection{Main result and outline of the article} {\bf Assumptions on $V$.} \medskip \noindent {\em We assume $V$ to be a convex function in ${\cal C}^{11}$.} \bigskip \noindent Main examples are convex polynomials, or suitable, smooth perturbations thereof. \bigskip\noindent Under our assumptions (see e.g. \cite{Joh}, Theorem 2.1 and Proposition 3.1) the equilibrium measure $\rho_{eq}$ is well-defined and compactly supported, its support $[a,b]$ is connected, and $\rho_{eq}$ is a solution of the cut-equation (\ref{eq:cut-eq1}). \medskip \noindent \medskip\noindent {\bf Assumptions on the initial measure.} \medskip\noindent Let $\mu^N_0=\mu_0(\{\lambda^i_0\}_i)$ be the initial measure of the stochastic process $\{\lambda^i_t\}_{t\ge 0, i=1,\ldots,N}$, and $X_0^N:=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^N \delta_{\lambda^i_0}$ be the initial empirical measure. Since $N$ varies, we find it useful here to add an extra upper index $(\lambda^{N,i}_0)_{ i=1,\ldots,N}$ to denote the initial condition of the process for a given value of $N$. {\em We assume that: \medskip \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] (large deviation estimate for the initial support) there exist some constants $C_0,c_0,R_0>0$ such that, for every $N\ge 1$, \BEQ {\mathbb{P}}[ \max_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\lambda_0^{N,i}| > R_0] \le C_0 e^{-c_0 N }. \label{eq:support-bound0} \EEQ \item[(ii)] $X_0^N\overset{law}{\to} \rho_0(x)\, dx$ when $N\to\infty$, where $\rho_0(x)$ is a deterministic measure; \item[(iii)] (rate of convergence) \BEQ \left({\mathbb{E}}[|M_0^N(z)-M_0(z)|^2]\right)^{1/2}=O(\frac{1}{N b}) \label{hyp:initial-measure} \EEQ for $z=a+\II b\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$, where $M_0(z):=\int dx\, \frac{\rho_0(x)}{x-z}$ is the Stieltjes transform of $\rho_0$. \end{itemize}} \medskip\noindent Lemma \ref{lem:support} proves that the initial large deviation estimate (i) implies a uniform-in-time large deviation estimate for the support of the random point measure, which is essential for our main result. \medskip \begin{Definition}[Sobolev spaces] \label{def:Sobolev} Let $H_n:=\{f\in L^2(\mathbb{R})\ |\ ||f||_{H_n}<\infty\}$ $(n\ge 0)$, where $||f||_{H_n}:=\left(\int d\xi\, (1+|\xi|^2)^{n} |{\cal F}f(\xi)|^2\right)^{1/2}$, and $H_{-n}:=(H_n)'$ its dual. \end{Definition} \medskip \noindent The measure-valued process $Y^N$ may be shown to converge in $C([0,T],H_{-14})$: \bigskip \noindent {\bf Main Theorem (Gaussianity of limit fluctuation process).} \noindent {\em Let $Y_t^N$ be the finite $N$ fluctuation process (see Definition \ref{def:empirical-fluctuation}). Then: \begin{enumerate} \item $Y^N \overset{law}{\to} Y$ when $N\to\infty$, where $Y$ is a Gaussian process. More precisely, $Y^N$ converges to $Y$ weakly in $C([0,T],H_{-14})$; \item let $\phi_{f_T}(Y_t^N):=e^{\II \langle Y_t^N,f_T\rangle}$, with $f_T$ compactly supported function in $C^2$. Then \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[\phi_{f_T}(Y_T)\big| {\cal F}_t]=\phi_{h_t}(Y_t) \ \exp\left( \half \int_t^T \left[ \II (1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_s,f''_s\rangle - \langle X_s,(f'_s)^2\rangle \right] ds \right) \label{eq:intro-Gaussian} \EEQ where $(f_s)_{0\le s\le T}$ is the solution of the asymptotic equation (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f-asymptotic}). \end{enumerate} } \medskip\noindent {\em Scheme of proof.} As in Israelsson \cite{Isr}, the main task is to prove a uniform in N Sobolev bound, called "$H_8$-bound", see (\ref{eq:bd-H4}), \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[\sup_{0\le s\le T} |\langle Y_s^N,\phi\rangle|] \le C_T ||\phi||_{H_8} \EEQ implying in particular tightness in some Sobolev space with negative index. Representing $\phi$ in terms of its standard Stieltjes decomposition of order 5, $\phi={\cal C}^5 h$, this is shown (by technical arguments developed in \cite{Isr}) to hold provided \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[|N(M_t^N(z)-M_t(z))|^2]\le C |b|^{-12} \EEQ (see (\ref{eq:4.14bis})) or equivalently ${\mathbb{E}}[|\langle Y_t^N,{\mathfrak{f}}_z\rangle|^2] \le C |b|^{-12}$. Apply (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}): start from terminal condition $f_T:={\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}$ and integrate in time, $\langle Y_T^N,{\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}\rangle=\Big\langle Y_0^N,f_0 + \half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \int_0^T dt\, \Big(\langle X_t^N,f_t''\rangle + \frac{1}{\sqrt{N}}\sum_{i=1}^N f'_t(\lambda_t^i)dW^i_t \Big) \Big\rangle$. Terms in the r.-h.s. are bounded in section 4 using a control over $(f_t)_{0\le t\le T}$, solution of the evolution equation (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}). The above equation is solved in the following way: it is proved to be compatible with the Stieltjes decomposition of order $\kappa$, \BEQ f_t(x)\equiv ({\cal C}^{\kappa} h_t)(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (-\II b) \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \, \, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) \, h_t(a,b) \EEQ see Definition \ref{def:Stieltjes-decomposition}, if $\frac{\partial h_t}{\partial t}(a,b)= {\cal H}_t h_t(a,b)$ for a certain time-dependent operator ${\cal H}_t$ -- a "Stieltjes transform" of the evolution operator featuring in (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) -- acting on $L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, which is written down explicitly and analyzed in great details in section 3. \bigskip The article is organized as follows. We first introduce a family of {\em Stieltjes decompositions} ${\cal C}^{\kappa}$ depending on a regularity index $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots$ (see section 2). The main technical section is section 3, where we rewrite the r.-h.s. of eq. (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) using Stieltjes decompositions as a sum of linear operators which we call {\em generators}; these are of two types: generalized transport operators, including $V$-dependent terms sketched above in (\ref{eq:generalized-transport-operator}), summing up to ${\cal H}_{transport}$, and bounded operators summing up to ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}$. We prove our Main Theorem in section 4. Since (\ref{eq:intro-Gaussian}) is formally just a consequence of It\^o's formula, and most of the technical arguments used in Israelsson's paper to justify this formula hardly depend on $V$, section 4 really revolves around a fundamental estimate, Lemma \ref{lem:fundamental-estimate}, which is based on properties of the characteristics, hence is strongly $V$-dependent. The analysis of the generators made in details in section 3 allows one to prove the latter estimate. To conclude, one uses as input {\em large deviation estimates for the support of the measure} proved in section 5. Finally, sections 6 and 7 are appendices, where we collected some well-known facts and formulas about transport equations and Stieltjes transforms. \medskip\noindent In an article in preparation \cite{Unt-law}, we solve (\ref{eq:intro-Gaussian}) and obtain the Gaussian kernel of the limiting fluctuation process $Y$. \section{Stieltjes decompositions} In (Israelsson \cite{Isr}, Lemma 9) one finds the following decomposition of an $L^1$ function $f:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ living in the Sobolev space $H_2$ as a sum of functions of the type \BEQ {\mathfrak{f}}_z: x\mapsto \frac{1}{x-z}, \EEQ where $z=a+\II b$, $b\not=0$ (see section \ref{sec:Stieltjes}), \BEQ f(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \, \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} (-\II b) \,db\, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) h(a), \qquad h(a)=-f''(a). \label{eq:Stieltjes-decomposition0} \EEQ The above "reproducing kernel type" decomposition is clearly not unique. The proof is based on the fact that, for $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots$ (see (\ref{eq:8.11})) \begin{eqnarray} \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} db\, (-\II b)\, |b|^{\kappa}\, \, \cdot\, {\cal F}({\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b})(s) &=& 2 \int_0^{+\infty} db\, |b|^{1+\kappa} {\cal F}(\Im {\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b})(s) \nonumber\\ &=&2\pi\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} db\, |b|^{1+\kappa}\, e^{-b|s|}= 2\pi \, \cdot\, (1+\kappa)! \ |s|^{-2-\kappa}, \label{eq:q} \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} where $\cal F$ is the Fourier transform (see section 7 for normalization), from which we also get the following family of decompositions, valid for $f\in L^1\cap H_{2+\kappa}$, $\kappa\in\mathbb{N}$, \BEQ f(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \, \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} (-\II b)\, db\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) h(a), \ h(a)= {\cal F}^{-1}(|s|^{2+\kappa} {\cal F}(f))(a), \label{eq:2Nd-Stieltjes-decomposition0} \EEQ a straightforward generalization of (\ref{eq:Stieltjes-decomposition0}) obtained by choosing some arbitrary value of $\kappa$ instead of $\kappa=0$ in (\ref{eq:q}). Note that $h$ is {\em real} since ${\cal F}^{-1}(|s|\, \cdot)$ is given by a {\em real-valued} convolution kernel (see section \ref{sec:Stieltjes}). The reason for introducing this $\kappa$-dependent family of decompositions is that the coefficient of ${\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)$ now {\em vanishes to order $1+\kappa$ instead of $1$ on the real axis}, a property inherited from the assumed supplementary regularity of $f$. Note that, for $\kappa$ {\em even}, ${\cal F}^{-1}(|s|^{2+\kappa}{\cal F}(\cdot))$ is the differential operator $(-\partial_s^2)^{1+\kappa/2}$. For $\kappa$ {\em odd}, on the other hand, one gets derivatives of the $(\frac{1}{x})$-kernel (see section \ref{sec:Stieltjes}). \medskip\noindent Since all interesting phenomena appear when $|b|$ is small, and we want to avoid artificial problems arising when $|b|$ is not bounded, we shall actually use analogous decompositions in which $|b|$ ranges from $0$ to some maximal value $b_{max}>0$. This introduces the following changes. First, instead of (\ref{eq:Stieltjes-decomposition0}), we get \BEQ f(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b)\, db\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) h(a), \ h(a)= ({\cal F}^{-1}(K^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})\ast f)(a), \label{eq:2Nd-Stieltjes-decomposition} \EEQ where \BEQ K^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}(s):=\left( 2\int_{0}^{b_{max}} db\, |b|^{1+\kappa}\, \, \cdot\, {\cal F}(\Im({\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b}))(s) \right)^{-1} \label{eq:2.6} \EEQ (note that the above integral is $>0$ by (\ref{eq:8.11})). We now study the convolution operator \BEQ {\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}: f\mapsto {\cal F}^{-1}(K^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})\ast f, \label{eq:calK-kappa} \EEQ depending on the parity of $\kappa$: \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] For $\kappa$ {\em even}, \BEQ \int_{0}^{b_{max}} db\, |b|^{1+\kappa}\, \, \cdot\, {\cal F}(\Im {\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b})(s) =\pi\int_{0}^{b_{max}} db\, |b|^{1+\kappa}\, e^{-b|s|}=\pi (-\partial_s^2)^{\kappa/2} (k^0_{b_{max}}(|s|)), \label{eq:bmax-q-even} \EEQ where \BEQ k^0_{b_{max}}(|s|)=\frac{1}{s^2}\left(1-(1+b_{max}|s|)e^{-b_{max}|s|}\right).\EEQ When $|s|\to \infty$, $k^0_{b_{max}}(|s|)\sim s^{-2}$; on the other hand, $k^0_{b_{max}}(|s|) \overset{s\to 0}{\sim} b_{max}^2 \sum_{k\ge 0} \frac{(-1)^k}{(k+2)!} (k+1) (b_{max}|s|)^{k}$. Thus $(-\partial_s^2)^{\kappa/2}(k^0_{b_{max}}(|s|))\overset{|s|\to\infty}{\sim} (-1)^{\kappa/2} \frac{s^{-(2+\kappa)}}{(\kappa+1)!} $, and $(-\partial_s^2)^{\kappa/2}(k^0_{b_{max}}(|s|))\overset{|s|\to 0}{\sim} (-1)^{\kappa/2}\frac{b_{max}^{2+\kappa}}{2+\kappa}.$ It is a simple exercise to prove the following: let \BEQ \underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}(s):=(-1)^{\kappa/2} \left( (\kappa+1)!\ s^{2+\kappa} + (2+\kappa) b_{max}^{-(2+\kappa)} \right)^{-1} K^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}(s)-1. \label{eq:underlineK-kappa-even} \EEQ Then $(\underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})^{(j)}(s)$, $j=0,1,2$ is $O(\frac{b^j_{max}}{1+b_{max}^2 s^2})$ uniformly in $s$ and $b_{max}$. Hence {\em the convolution operator \BEQ \underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}: f\mapsto {\cal F}^{-1}(\underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})\ast f\EEQ is a bounded operator from $L^1(\mathbb{R})\cap L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R})$ to $L^1(\mathbb{R})\cap L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R})$.} Indeed, $$||| \underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}|||_{L^1(\mathbb{R})\to L^1(\mathbb{R})},\ ||| \underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}|||_{L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R})\to L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R})} \le || {\cal F}^{-1}(\underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})||_{L^1(\mathbb{R})}$$ and \begin{eqnarray} |{\cal F}^{-1}(\underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})(x)| &\le& \min\left( ||\underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}||_{L^1}, \frac{1}{x^2} ||(\underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})''||_{L^1}\right) \nonumber\\ &=& O\left( \int \frac{ds}{1+b_{max}^2 s^2} \right) \ \cdot\ \min(1,(\frac{b_{max}}{x})^2) \nonumber\\ &=& \frac{1}{b_{max}} \ \cdot\ \min(1,(\frac{b_{max}}{x})^2) , \label{eq:2.11} \end{eqnarray} from which $||| \underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}|||_{L^1(\mathbb{R})\to L^1(\mathbb{R})}, ||| \underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}|||_{L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R})\to L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R})}=O(1).$ We may therefore write \BEQ {\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}=(1+\underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})\left(-(\kappa+1)! \ \partial_x^{2+\kappa}+ (-1)^{\kappa/2} (2+\kappa)b_{max}^{-(2+\kappa)} \right). \label{eq:calK-kappa-even} \EEQ \item[(ii)] For $\kappa$ {\em odd}, \BEQ \int_{0}^{b_{max}} db\, |b|^{1+\kappa}\, \, \cdot\, {\cal F}(\Im {\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b})(s) =\pi\int_0^{+\infty} db\, |b|^{1+\kappa}\, e^{-b|s|}=\pi (-\partial_s^2)^{(\kappa+1)/2} (k^1_{b_{max}}(|s|)), \label{eq:bmax-q-odd} \EEQ where \BEQ k^1_{b_{max}}(|s|)=\frac{1}{|s|} (1-e^{-b_{max}|s|}).\EEQ When $|s|\to \infty$, $k^1_{b_{max}(|s|)}\sim |s|^{-1}$; on the other hand, $k^1_{b_{max}}(|s|) \overset{s\to 0}{\sim} b_{max} \sum_{k\ge 0} \frac{(-1)^k}{(k+1)!} (b_{max}|s|)^{k}$. Thus $(-\partial_s^2)^{(\kappa+1)/2}(k^1_{b_{max}}(|s|))\overset{|s|\to\infty}{\sim} (-1)^{(\kappa+1)/2} \frac{|s|^{-1} s^{-(1+\kappa)}}{(\kappa+1)!} $, and $(-\partial_s^2)^{(\kappa+1)/2}(k^1_{b_{max}}(|s|))\overset{|s|\to 0}{\sim} (-1)^{(\kappa+1)/2}\frac{b_{max}^{2+\kappa}}{2+\kappa}.$ Therefore the previous analysis, from (\ref{eq:underlineK-kappa-even}) to the line before (\ref{eq:calK-kappa-even}), remains valid, with $(-1)^{\kappa/2}$, resp. $s^{2+\kappa}$, replaced with $(-1)^{(\kappa+1)/2}$, resp. $|s|s^{1+\kappa}$, and one obtains using (\ref{eq:C1}): \BEQ {\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}=(1+\underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}})\left(-(\kappa+1)! \ \II H \partial_x^{2+\kappa}+ (-1)^{(\kappa+1)/2} (2+\kappa)b_{max}^{-(2+\kappa)} \right) \label{eq:calK-kappa-odd} \EEQ where $H$ is the Hilbert transform, defined by the principal value integral \BEQ Hf(x):=\frac{1}{\pi} p.v. \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} \frac{1}{x-y}f(y)\, dy \EEQ and $\underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}$, defined by analogy with (i) as the convolution with respect to the inverse Fourier transform of \BEQ \underline{K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}(s)=(-1)^{(\kappa+1)/2} \left( (\kappa+1)!\ |s|^{2+\kappa} + (2+\kappa) b_{max}^{-(2+\kappa)} \right)^{-1} K^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}(s)-1, \EEQ has operator norm $O(1)$ on $L^1(\mathbb{R})$ and on $L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R})$. \end{itemize} \medskip The above formulas are particular instances of {\em Stieltjes decompositions}, {\em where $h=h(a,b)$ is allowed to be complex-valued and to depend on $b$}. \begin{Definition}[upper half-plane] \begin{enumerate} \item Let $\Pi^+:=\{z\in\mathbb{C}\ |\ \Im(z)>0\}$. \item For $b_{max}>0$, let $\Pi^+_{b_{max}}:=\{z\in \mathbb{C}\ |\ 0<\Im (z)<b_{max}\}$. \item Let $\Pi^-:=-\Pi^+$, $\Pi^-_{b_{max}}:=-\Pi^+_{b_{max}}$ and $\Pi:=\Pi^+ \uplus \Pi^-,\ \Pi_{b_{max}}:=\Pi^+_{b_{max}}\uplus \Pi^-_{b_{max}}$. \end{enumerate} \end{Definition} \begin{Definition} Let, for $p\in[1,+\infty]$ and $b_{max}>0$, \BEQ L^p(\Pi_{b_{max}}):=\{h:\Pi_{b_{max}}\to\mathbb{C}\ |\ h(\bar{z})=\overline{h(z)}\ (z\in \Pi^+_{b_{max}}) \, {\mathrm{\ and\ }} ||h||_{L^p(\Pi_{b_{max}})}<\infty\}, \EEQ where \BEQ ||h||_{L^p(\Pi_{b_{max}})}:= \left(\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da\, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, |h(a,b)|^p\right)^{1/p} \ (p<\infty), \qquad ||h||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}:=\sup_{z\in\Pi_{b_{max}}} |h(z)|. \EEQ \end{Definition} We will be mostly interested in the extreme cases $p=1$, $p=\infty$. Letting formally $b_{max}\to +\infty$ one obtains in an obvious way the space $L^p(\Pi)$ with its norm $||\ ||_{L^p(\Pi)}$. However, we shall actually fix some finite value of $b_{max}$, say (for convenience only), $0\le b_{max}\le \half$, implying: $\ln(1/|b|)\ge \ln 2>0$. \begin{Definition}[{\bf Stieltjes decomposition}] \label{def:Stieltjes-decomposition} Let $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots$ \begin{enumerate} \item Let $h\in L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$. We say that $f:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ {\em has Stieltjes decomposition $h$ of order $\kappa$ and cut-off $b_{max}$ on $[-R,R]$ } if, for all $|x|\le R$, \BEQ f(x)=({\cal C}^{\kappa}h)(x):=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b)\, db\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, \ {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) h(a,b). \label{eq:Stieltjes-decomposition} \EEQ \item The function $h:(a,b)\mapsto {\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}(f)(a)$ is called the {\em standard Stieltjes decomposition of order $\kappa$} and {\em cut-off} $b_{max}$ of $f$. \end{enumerate} \end{Definition} Thanks to the symmetry condition, $h(\bar{z})=\overline{h(z)}$, (\ref{eq:Stieltjes-decomposition}) may be rewritten in the form \BEQ ({\cal C}^{\kappa}h)(x)=2 \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \, \int_{0}^{b_{max}} db\, \frac{|b|^{1+\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, \ \Im\left[{\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) h(a,b)\right], \EEQ from which it is apparent that $f$ is indeed real-valued. \bigskip\noindent As already emphasized before, Stieltjes decompositions are not unique. In fact, it turns out to be useful to introduce a larger family of decompositions depending on a further scale parameter, $\rho>0$. We shall give less details since we apply these to the functions $\Im {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}$ with $\Im z_T>0$ only, and concentrate on the case $\kappa=0$ for computations. For $0<\rho\le b_{max}$, we write \BEQ K^{\kappa}_{b_{max},\rho}(s):= \left( \int_0^{b_{max}} db\, b^{1+\kappa}\, e^{-b/\rho} \, \cdot\, {\cal F}(\Im({\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b}))(s) \right)^{-1}\EEQ (compare with (\ref{eq:2.6})) and let as before \BEQ {\cal K}^{0}_{b_{max},\rho}: f\mapsto {\cal F}^{-1}(K^{\kappa}_{b_{max},\rho})\ast f, \label{eq:calK-rho} \EEQ so that, for $b_T\not=0$, \BEQ \Im[{\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b_T}](x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da\, \int_{0}^{b_{max}} db \, b^{\kappa+1}\, e^{-b/\rho} \, \Im[{\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)]\, {\cal K}^0_{b_{max},\rho}(\Im {\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b_T})(a).\EEQ Then (compare with (\ref{eq:bmax-q-even})) $(K^{0}_{b_{max},\rho})^{-1}=\pi k^0_{b_{max}}(\frac{1}{\rho}+|s|)$. Thus (emphasizing only the differences with $K^0_{b_{max}}=\lim_{\rho\to +\infty} K^0_{b_{max},\rho}$) $k^0_{b_{max},\rho}(|s|)\overset{s\to 0}{\sim} C\rho^2$ instead of $b_{max}^2$, with $C:=1-(1+b_{max}/\rho)e^{-b_{max}/\rho}$ bounded away from $0$. Hence \begin{eqnarray} \underline{K}^0_{b_{max},\rho}(s) &:=& (|s|+\rho^{-1})^{-2} K^0_{b_{max},\rho}-1 \nonumber\\ &=& - \frac{(1+b_{max}(|s|+\rho^{-1}))e^{-b_{max}(|s|+\rho^{-1})}}{1-(1+b_{max}(|s|+\rho^{-1}))e^{-b_{max}(|s|+\rho^{-1})}} \end{eqnarray} is a $O(e^{-\half b_{max}(|s|+\rho^{-1})})$, defining a bounded operator on $L^1\cap L^{\infty}$ with operator norm \BEQ O\left( \int ds\, e^{-\half b_{max}(|s|+\rho^{-1})}\right) \, \cdot\, \int dx\, \min(1,\frac{b_{max}}{x})^2 =O(e^{-\half b_{max}/\rho}) \EEQ (compare with (\ref{eq:2.11})), so that ${\cal K}^0_{b_{max},\rho}= {\cal F}^{-1}((|s|+\rho^{-1})^2)\ast$, times (1+plus bounded perturbation). More generally, it may be proved that (for some constant $c_{\kappa}$) ${\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max},\rho}=c_{\kappa} {\cal F}^{-1}((|s|+\rho^{-1})^{2+\kappa})\ast$, times (1+ bounded perturbation). On the other hand, letting $f= \Im[{\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}]$, with $z_T=a_T+\II b_T$, $b_T>0$, we find using (\ref{eq:8.4}), (\ref{eq:8.11}) \BEQ {\cal F}^{-1}((|s|+\rho^{-1})^{2+\kappa} {\cal F} \Im[{\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}])(a)= \left( \rho^{-1} -\frac{\partial}{\partial b_T}\right)^{2+\kappa} \left(\frac{b_T}{(a-a_T)^2+|b_T|^2} \right) \label{eq:fz=Ch} \EEQ Hence, letting \BEQ h(a,b):= e^{-b/\rho} {\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max},\rho}(\Im {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T})(a), \label{eq:2.29-0} \EEQ we get: \begin{eqnarray} \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da\, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, h(a,b) &= & O(1) \rho \left\{ \frac{1}{\rho^{2+\kappa}} + \frac{1}{|b_T|^{2+\kappa}} \right\} \nonumber\\ &=& O\left( \frac{1}{\rho^{1+\kappa}}(1+ O( (\frac{\rho}{b_T})^{2+\kappa} ) ) \right) \end{eqnarray} which is minimal, of order \BEQ ||h||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\approx b_T^{-1-\kappa}, \label{eq:hL1b-1} \EEQ when $\rho\approx b_T$. Choosing $\rho=b_T/C$ for some large enough absolute constant $C>0$, we further obtain -- specifically in the case $\kappa=0$ -- a {\em positive} function $h$, which can hence be interpreted as a {\em density}. Also, one easily checks that, still with $\rho\approx b_T$, \BEQ ||(a,b)\mapsto \ln(1/|b|) h(a,b)||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\approx \ln(1/b_T)b_T^{-1-\kappa} \label{eq:log-estimate} \EEQ if $0<b_T\le \half$. On the other hand, \BEQ ||h||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\approx b_T^{-3-\kappa} \label{eq:hLinftyb-3}. \EEQ \medskip\noindent In section 4, we consider the time-evolution of ${\cal C}^{\kappa}h_T$, where $h_T$ is essentially as in (\ref{eq:2.29}), \BEQ h_T(a,b):= e^{-b/\rho} {\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max},\rho}(\chi_R\, \Im {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T})(a), \label{eq:2.29} \EEQ for some cut-off function (see Definition \ref{def:cut-off} below) essentially supported on the ball $B(0,R)$ for some fixed radius $R>0$. An easy adaptation of the above arguments, and a use of (\ref{eq:bound-vp2}) when $\kappa$ is odd in order to deal with the Hilbert transform, show that the above estimates (\ref{eq:hL1b-1},\ref{eq:log-estimate},\ref{eq:hLinftyb-3}) remain correct, while now $h_T$ is $O(1)$, independently of $b_T$, far from the support, e.g. on $\Big( (B(0,2R))^c\times [-b_{max},b_{max}] \Big) \cup \Big( \mathbb{R}\times ([-b_{max},b_{max}]\setminus[-\half b_{max},\half b_{max}]) \Big)$. \section{Generators} The general purpose of the section is the following: for $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots$ {\em fixed}, we want to write down an explicit time-dependent operator ${\cal H}(t)$ such that the right-hand side of (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) for $f_t$ decomposed as \BEQ f_t(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (-\II b)\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \, \ f_{z}(x) \, h_t(a,b) \label{eq:generator} \EEQ (see Definition \ref{def:Stieltjes-decomposition}) is equal to \BEQ \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da\, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (-\II b)\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)\, {\cal H}(h_t)(t;a,b) \EEQ where ${\cal H}(h_t)(t;a,b)\equiv ({\cal H}(t)(h_t))(a,b).$ \noindent Given the characteristic evolution in the $z$-coordinate found by Israelsson (recalled in \S 3.1 below) -- which one may view as a {\em deterministic} Markov process -- it is natural to think of the function $h$ as a density $h(a,b)da\, db$, and then to interpret ${\cal H}(t)$ as a {\em Fokker-Planck operator}, whence (by duality) ${\cal L}(t):=({\cal H}(t))^{\dagger}$ as the generator of a random process (see section \ref{sec:transport} for more). However, contrary to the harmonic case studied by Israelsson and Bender, in general we obtain a truly {\em random} process, furthermore, a {\em signed} process, with $h$ a signed function. For lack of references on these notions, we shall refrain from developing this signed Markov process interpretation, and solve instead the evolution equation \BEQ \frac{dh_t}{dt}(a,b)={\cal H}(h_t)(t;a,b)\EEQ using {\em semi-group theory}. \medskip \noindent We have been voluntarily been vague up to this point about the double dependency of ${\cal H}$ on the integer index $\kappa$ and the cut-off scale $b_{max}$. Why couldn't one just set $\kappa=0$ and let $b_{max}\to +\infty$, as does Israelsson ? The reason is, we cannot handle properly the potential-dependent part of the generator (save when $V$ is order $\le 2$, which is the case considered in \cite{Isr}) without introducing various cut-offs and perturbative arguments -- unless maybe if $V$ is analytic (or even better, polynomial), where another strategy is perhaps possible. Since we do not want to make this assumption, we shall: \begin{itemize} \item[(1)] ({\em support issues}) in practice replace $V(x)$ by its {\em Taylor expansion to order 2 around all points in the support of the measures $(X_t^N)_{0\le t\le T}$ and $(X_t)_{0\le t\le T}$} and {\em treat the Taylor remainder as a perturbation}. Since $V$ is not bounded at infinity, it is important {\em not to} Taylor expand around any point on the real line, but only on a {\em compact interval}; choosing as compact interval the support is natural because the singular kernel term in (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) vanishes outside. {\em For brevity, we shall henceforth call {\em support of the measure} the random set $\left(\cup_{0\le t\le T} \ {\mathrm{supp}}(X_t^N) \right) \cup \left( \cup_{0\le t\le T}\ {\mathrm{supp}}(X_t)\right)$ and denote by $R>0$ any number such that the support of the measure is $\subset[-R,R]$.} We rely on the bounds developed in section \ref{sec:entropy} to argue that the probability of the support not to be included in $[-R,R]$ for some large enough $R$ is exponentially small in $N$ when $R$ is large enough. Then we naturally decompose $h\in L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$ as $h^{int}+h^{ext}$ where ${\mathrm{supp}}(h^{int})\subset[-3R,3R]\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]$ and ${\mathrm{supp}}(h^{ext})\subset (\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R]) \times[-b_{max},b_{max}]$, for instance by writing $h(a,b)=\bar{\chi}_R(a) h(a,b)+(1-\bar{\chi}_R(a))h(a,b)$, where $\bar{\chi}_R:\mathbb{R}\to[0,1]$ is some smooth function such that ${\mathrm{supp}}(\bar{\chi}_R)\subset[-3R,3R]$ and ${\mathrm{supp}}(1-\bar{\chi}_R)\subset\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R]$. The action of ${\cal H}$ on $h^{ext}$ is very simple and can be added to the action of the remainder term ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}$ discussed in (2). \item[(2)] ({\em varying $\kappa$}) in order to be able to treat the part (thereafter denoted by ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}$) of the generator due to the remainder term as a perturbation, it is important to see that ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}h(a,b)=O(|b|)$ when $b\to 0$. This being the case, we may also consider ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}$ as an operator {\em intertwining a Stieltjes decomposition of order $\kappa$ with a Stieltjes decomposition of order $\kappa+1$}, leading to a modification of the scheme developed around (\ref{eq:generator}): namely, we want the right-hand side of (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) for $f_t$ decomposed as (\ref{eq:generator}) for some integer index $\kappa$ to be equal to \BEQ \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da\, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b)\, db\, \frac{|b|^{1+\kappa}}{(2+\kappa)!}\, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)\, {\cal H}^{\kappa+1,\kappa}(h_t)(t;a,b). \EEQ Thus, instead of a single operator ${\cal H}^0$, we deal simultaneously with a family of operators ${\cal H}^{\kappa}$ and a family of intertwining operators ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{\kappa+1,\kappa}$, for $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots.$ These intertwinings result in an expansion of the Green kernel explicited in (\ref{eq:2Nd-Green-function-expansion}). This strategy yields optimal bounds in section 4. \end{itemize} \noindent Let us collect by anticipation all the terms which will come out of the computations in \S 3.1 through \S 3.9. As a general rule, if ${\cal H}: L^1([-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}])\oplus L^1( (\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R])\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]) \to L^1([-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}])\oplus L^1( (\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R])\times [-b_{max},b_{max}])$ is an (unbounded) operator, we denote by \BEQ {\cal H}^{int}:={\cal H}\big|_{L^1([-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}])\oplus 0}, \qquad {\cal H}^{ext}:={\cal H}\big|_{0 \oplus L^1([-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}])} \EEQ its restrictions to either factor, and ${\cal H}^{(int,int)},{\cal H}^{(int,ext)},{\cal H}^{(ext,int)},{\cal H}^{(ext,ext)}$ its four block-components, so that \BEQ {\cal H}=\left( \begin{array}{ccc} {\cal H}^{int} & | & {\cal H}^{ext} \end{array} \right)=\left( \begin{array}{cc} {\cal H}^{(int,int)} & {\cal H}^{(ext,int)} \\ {\cal H}^{(int,ext)} & {\cal H}^{(ext,ext)} \end{array} \right). \EEQ By explicit computation we show that \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa}=\left(\begin{array}{cc} {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport} & 0 \\ 0 & 0 \end{array}\right) +{\cal H}^{\kappa}_{nonlocal}; \EEQ \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport}:={\cal H}^{\kappa}_0+\sum_{k=0}^2 {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(k)} \EEQ is a sum of 4 transport operators -- with ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_0$ coming from the $\left(\frac{1}{x}\right)$-kernel part (see \S 3.1), and ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(k)}$, $k=0,1,2$ (see \S 3.3, \S 3.4, \S 3.5) from the Taylor expansion of the potential --, which are {\em unbounded operators}; \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{nonlocal}= \left(\begin{array}{ccc} {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(3)} + {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{bdry}} & | & {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,ext} \end{array}\right), \label{eq:H-dec3} \EEQ is a sum of {\em bounded} operators. The operator ${\cal H}^{\kappa,(3)}_{pot}$ -- coming from the third order Taylor remainder for the potential -- is introduced in \S 3.7. The operator $ {\cal H}_{\mathrm{bdry}}\equiv {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{h-bdry}+{\cal H}^{\kappa}_{v-bdry}$ is itself a sum of boundary terms (see \S 3.9): contributions coming from horizontal boundary $[-3R,3R]\times \{\pm b_{max}\}$, collected in ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}$, and contributions coming from vertical boundary $\{\pm 3R\}\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]$, collected in ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}$. The eight operators ${\cal H}_0^{\kappa}, {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(0)}, {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(1)}, {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(2)}, {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(3)}, {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}, {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}} , {\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ are defined resp. in\\ (\ref{eq:H0},\ref{eq:HV0},\ref{eq:HV1},\ref{eq:HV2},\ref{eq:HV3},\ref{eq:Hhbdry}, \ref{eq:Hvbdry}, \ref{eq:Hext}). \medskip\noindent We also write down expressions for ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1,\kappa}_{nonlocal}$, namely, ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa+1,\kappa,(3)}, {\cal H}^{\kappa+1,\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}, {\cal H}^{\kappa+1,\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}} , {\cal H}^{\kappa+1,\kappa,ext}_{pot}$, to be found resp. in (\ref{eq:HV3+1}, \ref{eq:Hhbdry+1},\ref{eq:Hvbdry+1},\ref{eq:Hext+1}). \medskip\noindent The kernels of these operators are denoted by the letter $g$, for instance, \BEQ {\cal H}_0^{\kappa}(h)(a,b)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\ g_0^{\kappa}(a,b;a_T,b_T)h(a_T,b_T) \EEQ and similarly for the other operators. \medskip\noindent Let us simply state as as general remark that the dependence on $R$ of the bounds of the present section will never be made explicit, since for the proof of our Main Theorem (see section 4), we shall simply fix $R=R(T)$, where $R(T)$ is a fixed radius depending only on the ptoential and on the time horizon $T$, defined in section 5. \bigskip \subsection{The $\left(\frac{1}{x}\right)$-kernel part} \medskip (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) is easily solved by the characteristic method in the case $V\equiv 0$ for test functions $f$ of the form $f(x)=\frac{c}{x-z}$. Up to conjugation we may assume that $b:=\Im z>0$. This is done in (Israelsson \cite{Isr}, Lemmas 2-4) -- we need only subtract the trivial contribution of the harmonic potential --\ : \begin{Proposition}(see Israelsson \cite{Isr}) \label{prop:lemma-2} Assume $V\equiv 0$. Then eq. (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) with terminal condition $f_T(x)=\frac{c}{x-z}$ $(\Im z>0)$ is solved as \BEQ f_t^T(x)=\frac{C_t}{x-Z_t},\EEQ where $(C_t)_{0\le t\le T}, (Z_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ solve the following ode's, \BEQ \frac{dZ_t}{dt}=-\frac{\beta}{4} (M_t^N(Z_t)+M_t(Z_t)), \qquad \frac{dC_t}{dt}=-\frac{\beta}{4} ((M_t^N)'(Z_t)+M_t'(Z_t)) C_t \label{eq:dc/dt} \EEQ with terminal conditions $Z_T=z,C_T=c$. In particular, \BEQ \Im \frac{dZ_t}{dt}=-\frac{\beta}{4} \langle X_t^N+X_t, \Im({\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T})\rangle \le 0. \label{eq:Im-dz/dt<0} \EEQ \end{Proposition} Obviously, the solution of eq. (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) with terminal condition $f_T(x)= \frac{c}{x-\bar{z}}$ is now $f_t^T(x)= \frac{\bar{C}_t}{x-\bar{Z}_t}$. \medskip The last inequality (\ref{eq:Im-dz/dt<0}), a simple consequence of (\ref{eq:Im-fz>0}), implies that $Z_t$ moves {\em away} from the real axis as $t$ decreases, hence away from singularities. From the above and from general properties of the Stieltjes transform of $\rho_t$ (see section \ref{sec:Stieltjes}), one can deduce bounds for the displacement, as in \cite{Isr}. First $|M_{t}^N(z)|$, $|M_{t}(z)|\le 1/b_t$, hence (letting $Z_t=:A_t+\II B_t$, $B_t>0$), for some large enough constant $C>0$, \BEQ B_T\le B_t\le \sqrt{|B_T|^2+C(T-t)}. \EEQ Similarly, $|A_t-A_T|=O\left(\frac{T-t}{B_T}\right)$. Finally, $\frac{\beta}{4}\left(|(M_t^N)'(Z_t)|+|(M_t)'(Z_t)|\right)\le \frac{|dB_t/dt|}{B_t}=\left|\frac{d}{dt} (\ln(B_t))\right|$, whence $C_t\le \frac{B_t}{B_T}\le \sqrt{|B_T|^2+C(T-t)} \ \, / \, B_T.$ Summarizing: for a given final condition $z$, $|\frac{dA_t}{dt}|,|\frac{dB_t}{dt}|\le \frac{\beta}{2} \frac{1}{B_t}\le \frac{\beta}{2} \frac{1}{b}$ is bounded along the characteristics, but may become arbitrarily large when $b\to 0$; $|B_t-B_T|\le \sqrt{C(T-t)}$ is bounded independently of $b$, while $|A_t-A_T|$ is {\em not}. On the other hand, starting from $Z_T$ far enough from the support of $(X^N_t)_{0\le t\le T},(X_T)_{0\le t\le T}$, e.g. $|\Re Z_T|\ge CR$, where $C>1$ and (by assumption) ${\mathrm{supp}}(X^N_t),{\mathrm{supp}}(X_t)\subset B(0,R)$, then (by (\ref{eq:2Nd-bound-Mt})) $|A_t|>C' R$ $(1<C'<C)$ for all $t\in[0,T]$, whence $ |\dot{B}_t|,|\dot{A}_t|\le \frac{\beta}{R} <\infty$, provided $T<\frac{R^2}{\beta}(C-C')$. \begin{Definition} Let ${\cal L}_0={\cal L}_0(t)$ be the time-dependent operator defined by \begin{eqnarray} && ({\cal L}_{0}(t) \phi)(a,b)=-\frac{\beta}{4} \left( \Re \left[(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(z)\right] \partial_a\phi(a,b) +\Im \left[(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(z)\right] \partial_b\phi(a,b) \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad \left. + ((M_{t}^N)'+M_{t}')(z) \phi(a,b)\right) \label{eq:L0} \end{eqnarray} \end{Definition} The motivation for this definition is the following. Let $f_t^T(x)=\frac{C_t}{x-Z_t}$ as in Proposition \ref{prop:lemma-2}. Then $\frac{\partial f_t^T}{\partial t}\big|_{t=T}=({\cal L}_0 f_T)(T;z):=({\cal L}_0(T) f_T)(z)$. Take, more generally, a terminal condition for (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) of the form \BEQ f_T(x)=\int da_T \int db_T \, \frac{h_T(a_T,b_T)}{x-z_T}.\EEQ Then \begin{eqnarray} \frac{\partial f_t^T}{\partial t}\big|_{t=T} &=& \int da_T db_T\, ({\cal L}_0( \frac{1}{x - \cdot})(z_T) h_T(a_T,b_T) \nonumber\\ &=& \int da_T db_T\, {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x) ({\cal L}_0^{\dagger} h_T)(T,z_T),\end{eqnarray} where $({\cal L}_0^{\dagger}h_T)(T;z_T)=(({\cal L}_0(T))^{\dagger}h_T)(z_T)$ is obtained from the adjoint of ${\cal L}_0(T)$. Thus ${\cal L}_0$, resp. ${\cal L}_0^{\dagger}$ may be considered as the generator of a -- here {\em deterministic} -- {\em generalized} Markov process $Z_{\cdot}=A_{\cdot}+\II B_{\cdot}$, resp. the associated Fokker-Planck generator, where {\em generalized} refers to the supplementary order $0$ term in ${\cal L}_0(t)$ (second line of (\ref{eq:L0})), which has on top of that the nasty property of not being even real-valued. \bigskip We now need some very general development, which we apply to ${\cal L}_0$ in this paragraph. {\em Let $w:\Pi\to\mathbb{R}_+^*$ be some weight function.} The relation $\frac{d}{dt} (wh)= w ({\cal L}_0^w(t))^{\dagger}h$ defines an operator $({\cal L}_0^w(t))^{\dagger}$, \begin{eqnarray} ({\cal L}_0^w)^{\dagger}(t;a,b)&:=&(w {\cal L}_0(t) w^{-1})^{\dagger}(a,b) \nonumber\\ &=& -\frac{\beta}{4} w(a,b)^{-1} \left(-\partial_a\ \Re \left[(M_t^N+M_{t})(z)\right] - \partial_b\ \Im \left[(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(z)\right] \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad \left. + ((M_{t}^N)'+M_{t}')(z) \right) w(a,b) \label{eq:w} \end{eqnarray} which is the adjoint of ${\cal L}_0$ with respect to the measure $w(a,b)da\, db$ on $\Pi$. In other words, we see that the solution $(h_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ of the equation \BEQ \frac{\partial h_t}{\partial t}=({\cal L}_0^w)^{\dagger}(t) h_t \EEQ with terminal condition $h_T$ is the {\em density} of $Z_{\cdot}$ with respect to the measure $w(a,b) da\, db$. \medskip\noindent Let us consider specifically the cases \BEQ w(a,b):=b\, |b|^{\kappa}, \qquad \kappa=0,1,2,\ldots\EEQ for which we write \BEQ {\cal L}_0^w\equiv {\cal L}_0^{\kappa}.\EEQ These cases allow a direct connection to Stieltjes decompositions of order $\kappa$ with $b_{max}=+\infty$, namely: {\em if \BEQ f_T(x)={\cal C}^{\kappa}h_T(x)=\int da \int_0^{+\infty} db\, (-\II b)\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, h_T(a,b)\ {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) \EEQ then \BEQ f_t(x):={\cal C}^{\kappa} h_t(x),\EEQ where $(h_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ is the solution of \BEQ \frac{\partial h_t}{\partial t}=({\cal L}_0^{\kappa})^{\dagger}(t) h_t, \label{eq:dagger} \EEQ } \medskip \noindent The generator \BEQ {\cal L}_0^{\kappa}= \left((b\, |b|^{\kappa})^{-1} {\cal L}_0^{\dagger} b\, |b|^{\kappa} \right)^{\dagger}=|b|^{1+\kappa} {\cal L}_0 (|b|^{1+\kappa})^{-1} \label{eq:sharp} \EEQ is obtained from (\ref{eq:L0}) by replacing the multiplicative term $ \frac{\beta}{4}((M_{t}^N)'+M_{t}')(z) \phi(a,b)$ with $\frac{\beta}{4} \left( ((M_{t}^N)'+M_{t}')(z)-\frac{1+\kappa}{b}\Im[(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(z)] \right) \phi(t;a,b)$, from which \begin{eqnarray} && {\cal H}_0^{\kappa}(h)(t;a,b) :=({\cal L}_0^{\kappa})^{\dagger}(t)(h_t)(a,b) \nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad =\frac{\beta}{4} \left( \partial_a\left[ \Re \left((M_{t}^N+M_{t})(z)\right) h(t;a,b)\right] + \partial_b\left[ \Im \left((M_{t}^N+M_{t})(z)\right) h(t;a,b) \right] \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad \qquad \left. + \left[ \frac{1+\kappa}{b} \Im\left((M_{t}^N+M_{t})(z)\right) - ((M_{t}^N)'+M_{t}')(z) \right] h(t;a,b)\right) \label{eq:H0} \end{eqnarray} Consider the extended characteristics $(z_t,c_t):=(a_t+\II b_t,c_t^{\kappa})$ of the operator ${\cal H}_0^{\kappa}$ as in section \ref{sec:transport}: they are defined as the solution of \BEQ \frac{da_t}{dt}=\frac{\beta}{4} \Re(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(a_t+\II b_t), \qquad \frac{db_t}{dt}=\frac{\beta}{4} \Im(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(a_t+\II b_t) \EEQ \BEQ \frac{dc^{\kappa}_{t}}{dt}=\frac{\beta}{4} \left( \frac{1+\kappa}{b_t} \Im\left[(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(a_t+\II b_t)\right] + \left((\bar{M}_{t}^N)'+\bar{M}_{t}'\right)(a_t+\II b_t) \right) c^{\kappa}_{t} \label{eq:char-L0} \EEQ Here we used the fact that $\partial_a\, \Re (M_t^N+M_t)(z)=\partial_b\, \Im (M_t^N+M_t)(z)=\Re ((M_t^N)'+M'_t)(z)$ since $z\mapsto (M_t^N +M_t)(z)$ is holomorphic. {\em Mind the sign changes} with respect to Proposition \ref{prop:lemma-2}: characteristics of the dual operator ${\cal H}_0^{\kappa}$ have reversed velocities with respect to those of ${\cal L}$, with characteristic curves $(Z_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ running backwards in time (see section \ref{sec:transport} for more details). By convention, characteristics are killed upon touching the real axis. Now it follows from (\ref{eq:M'M}) that {\em $\Re (-\tau(t,z_t))\equiv \Re\left( -(c^{\kappa}_t)^{-1} \frac{dc_{t}^{\kappa}}{dt} \right)\le 0$ for $\kappa\ge 0$, whence (see section \ref{sec:transport}) ${\cal H}_0^{\kappa}$ is a generator of a semi-group of $L^{\infty}$-contractions. Because the first line of (\ref{eq:H0}) is in divergence form, and the second line has positive real part, ${\cal H}_0^{\kappa}$ is also the generator of a semi-group of $L^1$-contractions. } \bigskip\noindent \bigskip \noindent Let us now see what happens for $R$ and $b_{max}$ {\em finite}. It is clear that the cut-off does not change the characteristic equations for $(a_t+\II b_t, c_t)$. On the other hand, we get two supplementary {\em boundary terms}. This can be proved as follows. Assume \BEQ f_T(x)={\cal C}^{\kappa} h_T(x)=\int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, (-\II b_T)\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, h_T(a_T,b_T)\ {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x). \EEQ Then (coming back directly to the characteristics equations of Proposition \ref{prop:lemma-2}) \begin{eqnarray} &&-\frac{\beta}{4} \int \int \frac{f'_T(x)-f'_T(y)}{x-y}( X^N_t(dy)+ X_t(dy)) \nonumber\\ &&\ = -\frac{\beta}{4} \int_{-3R}^{+3R} da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T\, \frac{|b_T|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, \left\{ \Im[(M^N_T+M_T)(z_T)]\, (\partial_{b_T} {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T})(x) + \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad \left. \Re[(M^N_T+M_T)(z_T)]\, (\partial_{a_T} {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T})(x) \right\} \ h_T(a_T,b_T)+\cdots \nonumber\\ &&\ = \frac{\beta}{4} \int_{-3R}^{+3R} da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T\, \frac{|b_T|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, \left\{ \partial_{b_T}\left( \Im[(M^N_T+M_T)(z_T)]\, h_T(a_T,b_T)\right) + \right.\nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\qquad \left. \partial_{a_T}\left( \Re[(M^N_T+M_T)(z_T)]\, h_T(a_T,b_T)\right) \right\} \ {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x) \ \ +\cdots\nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad + {\mathrm{bdry}} \end{eqnarray} where "$\cdots$" denote the contribution of the $c$-characteristics (which we can ignore), so (by integration by parts) we get a boundary term bdry $\equiv$ h-bdry$_0+$ v-bdry$_0$ on the support of the measure, with \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathrm{h\!-\!bdry}}_0=-\frac{\beta}{4} \frac{b_{max}^{1+\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da_T \, \ \cdot \chi_R(x)\cdot\ \left( \Im[(M^N_T+M_T)(a_T+\II b_{max})] \ \cdot \right.\nonumber\\ && \qquad \left. \cdot\ f_{a_T+\II b_{max}}(x) h(a_T,b_{max}) -\Im[(M^N_T+M_T)(a_T-\II b_{max})] f_{a_T-\II b_{max}}(x) h(a_T,-b_{max}) \right) \label{eq:h-bdry0} \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} and \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathrm{v\!-\!bdry}}_0=-\frac{\beta}{4} \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T \, \frac{|b_T|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \ \cdot \chi_R(x)\ \cdot \ \left\{\Re [(M_T^N+M_T)(3R+\II b_T)] \ \cdot\ \right.\nonumber\\ &&\qquad \left.\cdot\ f_{3R+\II b_T}(x)\, h(3R,b_T) - \Re [(M_T^N+M_T)(-3R+\II b_T)] f_{-3R+\II b_T}(x)\, h(-3R,b_T) \right\} \nonumber\\ \label{eq:v-bdry0} \end{eqnarray} \subsection{The potential-dependent part: general introduction} Consider now the potential-dependent part in (\ref{eq:PDE-f}). {\em Without further mention we fix for the discussion $R\ge 1$ and some arbitrary $b_{max}\in(0,\half]$.} Generally speaking we want to {\em write the action of the operator $V'(x)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}$ on a function $f\equiv f_T$ with Stieltjes decomposition of order $\kappa$} on $[-R,R]$ \BEQ f(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da_T \, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, (-\II b_T)\,\frac{|b_T|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, \ {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x) h(a_T,b_T), \qquad |x|\le R \label{eq:3.30} \EEQ (see Definition \ref{def:Stieltjes-decomposition}) . In principle (see below though) it may be done in the following way. \begin{Definition}[cut-offs] \label{def:cut-off} Let $\chi_R:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ be a smooth cut-off function such that: \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] $\chi_R\equiv 1$ on $[-R,R]$; \item[(ii)] $\chi_R\big|_{B(0,\frac{3}{2} R)^c}\equiv 0$. \end{itemize} and $\bar{\chi}_R$ be the function $x\mapsto \chi_R(\frac{x}{2})$. \end{Definition} \begin{Definition}[$g$-kernel] \label{def:g-kernel} Let, for $\kappa,\kappa'=0,1,2,\ldots$ \BEQ g^{\kappa';\kappa}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T):={\bf 1}_{|b|<b_{max}} \frac{(-\II b_T) |b_T|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \, {\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}} \left(x\mapsto \chi_R(x)V'(x) f'_{z_T}(x) \right)(a) \label{eq:g-kernel} \EEQ with ${\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}}$ as in (\ref{eq:calK-kappa}). \end{Definition} In practice we are only interested in couples of indices $(\kappa,\kappa'=\kappa)$ and $(\kappa,\kappa'=\kappa+1)$, and let $g^{\kappa}_{pot}\equiv g^{\kappa;\kappa}_{pot}$. Let $f$ be a function as in (\ref{eq:3.30}). Then, {\em using the standard order $\kappa'$ Stieltjes decomposition with cut-off $b_{max}$ of $V'(x)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}({\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x))$}, we get \begin{eqnarray} && V'(x)\frac{\partial}{\partial x} f(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (-\II b)\, \frac{|b|^{\kappa'}}{(1+\kappa')!} \, \ {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da_T \, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T \, g^{\kappa';\kappa}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T),\end{eqnarray} thus defining (unbounded) operators ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_{pot},{\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{pot}: L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}},da_T \, db_T)\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}},da\, db)$, $$ {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{pot}(h)(a,b)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da_T\, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, g^{\kappa}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T)h(a_T,b_T) $$ $$ {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{pot}(h)(a,b)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da_T\, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, g^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T)h(a_T,b_T).$$ \medskip\noindent However, these Stieltjes representations of the vector field $V'(x)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}$ will be used directly only when $h=0\oplus h^{ext}$ has support in $\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R]$, producing the ${\cal H}^{ext}$-term. When $h=h^{int}\oplus 0$ has support $\subset[-3R,3R]$, we separate first the Taylor expansion of order 2 of $V'(x)$ around $a_T$, as explained in (\ref{eq:intro-W}) or (\ref{eq:W}) below, which is directly analyzed without further Stieltjes decomposition. \bigskip\noindent Let us discuss in details how we proceed when $h=h^{int}$. As we have just mentioned, the first step is to use a second-order Taylor-expansion of $V'$ around $a_T$ for $|a_T|\le 3R$ and $x\in$ supp$(\chi_R)$, i.e. $|x|\le \frac{3}{2}R$, \BEQ V'(x)=V'(a_T)+V''(a_T)(x-a_T)+ V'''(a_T) \frac{(x-a_T)^2}{2}+ (x-a_T)^3 W_{a_T}(x-a_T), \EEQ where $W_{a_T}$ is $C^7$. Thus \BEQ V'(x)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}=V'(a_T)\partial_x+V''(a_T)(x-a_T) \partial_x + V'''(a_T)\frac{(x-a_T)^2}{2} \partial_x+ (x-a_T)^3 W_{a_T}(x-a_T) \partial_x \label{eq:W} \EEQ makes four different contributions to the generator, ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa}$, $\kappa=0,1,2,3$, resp. called {\em constant, linear, quadratic and Taylor remainder term}, plus some boundary contributions. Computations show the following: ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(k)}$, $k=0,1,2$, are directly of the adjoint form \BEQ h\mapsto \Big( (a_T,b_T)\mapsto \partial_{a_T}(v_{hor}(a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T))+\partial_{b_T}(v_{vert}(a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T)) - \tau(a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T) \Big) \EEQ with $\Re \tau(\cdot)\le 0$, implying that {\em they generate $L^1$-contractions} (see section \ref{sec:transport}, and recall that we go {\em backwards} in time). As a nice feature of this problem, ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(k)}$, $k=0,1,2$ {\em also generate $L^{\infty}$-contractions}. Replacing the vector field $\chi_R(x)V'(x)\partial_x$ in (\ref{eq:g-kernel}) above by $\chi_R(x) (x-a_T)^3 W_{a_T}(x-a_T)\partial_x$ produces a kernel $g^{(3)}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T)$ discussed in \S 3.8. As for the first three terms, they are directly shown to be equivalent to the action of a transport operator (see \S 3.3, 3.4, 3.5). We sum up in \S 3.6 the contributions of the transport operators introduced in \S 3.1, 3.3, 3.4 and 3.5. The operators ${\cal H}^{\kappa,(3)}_{pot}$ and ${\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ are studied in \S 3.7 and 3.8. Finally, the contribution of the boundary terms is analyzed in \S 3.9. \bigskip\noindent The terms in ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}$, on the other hand, {\em do not} generate neither $L^{\infty}$- nor $L^1$-contractions. Thanks to the horizontal and vertical cut-offs however, they are bounded, hence generate by integration some exponentially increasing time factor $e^{C_R t}$, with $C_R$ depending on $R$. \bigskip \subsection{Constant term} Inserting the constant operator $V'(a_T)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}$ inside the Stieltjes decomposition $$f_T(x)=\int_{-3R}^{+3R} da_T \, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}}(-\II b_T)\, db_T\, |b_T|^{\kappa} \, {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x) h(a_T,b_T),$$ we get \begin{eqnarray} && \int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T\ \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T\, |b_T|^{\kappa} V'(a_T) f'_{z_T}(x) h(a_T,b_T) \nonumber\\ && \qquad =- \int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T\ \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T\, |b_T|^{\kappa}\, V'(a_T) \frac{\partial}{\partial a_T} ( {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x)) h(a_T,b_T) \nonumber\\ && \qquad =\int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T\ \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T\, |b_T|^{\kappa}\, {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x) \frac{\partial}{\partial a_T} \left( V'(a_T)h(a_T,b_T) \right) + {\mathrm{bdry}}. \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} where \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathrm{bdry}}\equiv{\mathrm{v\!-\!bdry}}_{pot}^{(0)}=- \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T \, |b_T|^{\kappa} \ \cdot \chi_R(x)\ \cdot \nonumber\\ && \qquad \cdot \, \left(V'(3R) f_{3R+\II b_T}(x)\, h(3R,b_T) - V'(-3R) f_{-3R+\II b_T}(x)\, h(-3R,b_T) \right) \label{eq:v-bdry-0} \end{eqnarray} is a vertical boundary term coming from integration by parts, which we shall not discuss till \S 3.9. This defines a new operator ${\cal H}^{(0)}_{pot}$ in divergence form, \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa,(0)}_{pot}(h)(a_T,b_T)=\frac{\partial}{\partial a_T} \left( V'(a_T)h(a_T,b_T) \right), \label{eq:HV0} \EEQ with corresponding extended characteristics \BEQ \frac{da_t}{dt}=V'(a_t), \qquad \frac{db_t}{dt}=0, \qquad \frac{dc^{\kappa}_{t}}{dt}=V''(a_t). \label{eq:char-LV0} \EEQ \subsection{Linear term} Proceeding as in the {\em constant term} case, we insert the operator $V''(a_T)(x-a_T)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}$ inside the Stieltjes decomposition of $f_T$, getting \begin{eqnarray} && \int da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T \, |b_T|^{\kappa}\, V''(a_T) \left[ (x-a_T)\partial_x {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x)\right] h(a_T,b_T) \nonumber\\ && \qquad =- \int da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T \, |b_T|^{\kappa}\, V''(a_T) \ \cdot\partial_{b_T}(b_T {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x)) \ h(a_T,b_T) \nonumber\\ && \qquad = {\mathrm{bdry}} \, +\ \int da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T \, |b_T|^{\kappa}\, {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x) \, V''(a_T) (b_T\partial_{b_T}+1+\kappa) h(a_T,b_T), \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} where \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathrm{bdry}}\equiv{\mathrm{h-bdry}}_{pot}^{(1)}=-b_{max}^{2+\kappa} \int da_T \, V''(a_T) \ \cdot \chi_R(x)\ \cdot \nonumber\\ && \qquad \cdot \, \left(f_{a_T+\II b_{max}}(x)\, h(a_T,b_{max}) - f_{a_T-\II b_{max}}(x)\, h(a_T,-b_{max}) \right) \label{eq:h-bdry-1} \end{eqnarray} is a horizontal boundary term coming from integration by parts. This defines an operator, ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(1)}$, \BEQ {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(1)}(h)(a_T,b_T) =\left(\partial_{b_T} b_T+\kappa\right)(V''(a_T)h(a_T,b_T)). \label{eq:HV1} \EEQ with associated characteristics, \BEQ \frac{da_t}{dt}=0, \qquad \frac{db_t}{dt}=V''(a_t)b_t, \qquad \frac{dc^{\kappa}_{t}}{dt}= (1+\kappa) V''(a_t)c^{\kappa}_{t} \label{eq:char-LV1} \EEQ \subsection{Quadratic term} Proceeding as in the previous paragraph, we insert the operator $\half V'''(a_T) (x-a_T)^2 \frac{\partial}{\partial x}$ inside the Stieltjes decomposition. Since $(x-a_T)^2 \frac{\partial}{\partial x}=\partial_x (x-a_T)^2 - 2 (x-a_T)$, and \BEQ \partial_x \left[ (x-a_T)^2 {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x)\right]=1+b_T^2 \partial_{a_T} {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x), \qquad -2(x-a_T){\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x)=-2-2\II b_T {\mathfrak{f}}_{z_T}(x) \label{eq:1-2} \EEQ this term produces a new operator \BEQ {\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(2)}(h)(a_T,b_T)=\half \left(- \partial_{a_T} b_T^2 -2\II b_T\right) (V'''(a_T) h(a_T,b_T)). \label{eq:HV2} \EEQ with associated characteristics \BEQ \frac{da_t}{dt} =-\half V'''(a_t) b_t^2, \qquad \frac{db_t}{dt}=0, \qquad \frac{dc^{\kappa}_{t}}{dt}=-\II V'''(a_t) b_t\, c^{\kappa}_{t} \label{eq:char-LV2} \EEQ plus a vertical boundary term, \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathrm{bdry}}\equiv{\mathrm{v-bdry}}_{pot}^{(2)}=- \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b_T)\, db_T \, |b_T|^{\kappa+2} \ \cdot \chi_R(x)\ \cdot \nonumber\\ && \qquad \cdot \, \left(V'''(3R) f_{3R+\II b_T}(x)\, h(3R,b_T) - V'''(-3R) f_{-3R+\II b_T}(x)\, h(-3R,b_T) \right) \label{eq:v-bdry-2} \end{eqnarray} The remaining term due to the constant $\half V'''(a_T) (1-2)$ in (\ref{eq:1-2}), integrated with respect to the measure $|b_T|^{1+\kappa} da_T\, db_T$, adds a time-independent constant $C$ to $f_t$, which however disappears from the computations since: (i) the right-hand side of (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) features only $f'_t$; (ii) $d\langle Y_t^N,C\rangle=dC=0$ in (\ref{eq:Ito}). \medskip \subsection{Recapitulating: the transport contribution} We can now write down the action of the sum of our three transport operators, \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport}(t):={\cal H}^{\kappa}_0(t)+{\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(0)} +{\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(1)}+{\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(2)} \EEQ (note that only ${\cal H}_0^{\kappa}$ depends on the time variable), defined respectively in (\ref{eq:H0}), (\ref{eq:HV0}), (\ref{eq:HV1}) and (\ref{eq:HV2}). Summing the contributions in (\ref{eq:char-L0}), (\ref{eq:char-LV0}), (\ref{eq:char-LV1}) and (\ref{eq:char-LV2}), we obtain the following equation for the characteristics on $[-3R,3R]\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]$, \BEQ \frac{da_t}{dt}=\frac{\beta}{4} \Re(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(a_t+\II b_t) +V'(a_t)-\half V'''(a_t) b_t^2 \label{eq:da(tau)/dtau} \EEQ \BEQ \frac{db_t}{dt}=\frac{\beta}{4} \Im(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(a_t+\II b_t)+ V''(a_t)b_t \label{eq:db(tau)/dtau} \EEQ \begin{eqnarray} && \frac{dc^{\kappa}_{t}}{dt}= \left[\frac{\beta}{4} \left( \frac{1+\kappa}{b_t}\Im(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(a_t+\II b_t) + ((\bar{M}_{t}^N)'+(\bar{M}_{t})')(a_t+\II b_t) \right) \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\qquad \left. +(2+\kappa) V''(a_t) -\II V'''(a_t) b_t\right] c^{\kappa}_{t}. \label{eq:dEsharp(tau)/dtau} \end{eqnarray} \noindent Let us make the following observations (see \S 3.1): \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] $t\mapsto |b_t|$ increases, whence $|b_t|\le |b_T|$ $(0\le t\le T)$. \item[(ii)] velocities are $O(1)$ far from the support, e.g. on $\{|a|>CR\}\cup \{|b|>b_{max}/2\}$ (see discussion below Proposition \ref{prop:lemma-2}); \item[(iii)] as is already true of each individual generator ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_0$, ${\cal H}^{\kappa,(i)}_{pot}$ ($i=0,1,2$), the sum ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport}(t)$ generates a semi-group of $L^1$-contractions. The same holds if one considers $L^{\infty}$- norms, since the real part of (\ref{eq:dEsharp(tau)/dtau}) is positive. \end{itemize} \noindent As a side remark, we may choose $T$ small enough so that characteristics $(a_t+\II b_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ started at time $T$ on the boundary $\Big(\{\pm 3R\}\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]\Big)\cup\Big([-3R,3R]\times \{\pm b_{max}\}\Big)$ always remains far from the support, in the sense of (ii). \medskip\noindent Section \ref{sec:transport} therefore implies: \begin{Lemma} \label{lem:U-transport} Let $u_T\in (L^1\cap L^{\infty})([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])$ and $\kappa=0,1,2\ldots$ Then the backward evolution equation $\frac{du}{dt}={\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport}(t)u(t), u\big|_{t=T}=u_T$ $(0\le t\le T)$ has a unique solution $u(t):=U_{transport}(t,T)u_T$, such that \BEQ ||u_t||_{L^1([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])}\le ||u_T||_{L^1([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])} \EEQ \BEQ ||u_t||_{L^{\infty}([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])}\le ||u_T||_{L^{\infty}([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])} \EEQ \end{Lemma} \medskip\noindent In section 4, we will separate (\ref{eq:dEsharp(tau)/dtau}) into its real and imaginary parts. Solving the $(a,b)$-characteristics coupled with the real characteristic $\tilde{c}^{\kappa}$, \begin{eqnarray} && \frac{d\tilde{c}^{\kappa}_{t}}{dt}= \Re \left[\frac{\beta}{4} \left( \frac{1+\kappa}{b_t}\Im(M_{t}^N+M_{t})(a_t+\II b_t) + ((\bar{M}_{t}^N)'+(\bar{M}_{t})')(a_t+\II b_t) \right) \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\qquad \left. +(2+\kappa) V''(a_t) -\II V'''(a_t) b_t\right] \tilde{c}^{\kappa}_{t}, \label{eq:ctilde} \end{eqnarray} one gets a backward evolution equation equation, \BEQ \frac{d\tilde{u}}{dt}=[\Re{\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport}(t)]\tilde{u}(t), \ \ \tilde{u}\big|_{t=T}=\tilde{u}_T\equiv u_T \qquad (0\le t\le T), \label{eq:utilde} \EEQ solved as $\tilde{u}(t):=\tilde{U}_{transport}(t,T)\tilde{u}_T$, such that \BEQ ||\tilde{u}_t||_{L^1([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])}\le ||\tilde{u}_T||_{L^1([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])} \EEQ \BEQ ||\tilde{u}_t||_{L^{\infty}([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])}\le ||\tilde{u}_T||_{L^{\infty}([-3R,3R]\times(0,b_{max}])} \EEQ {\em Assuming $u_T\ge 0$, $\tilde{u}$ is simply the modulus of $u$,} \BEQ \tilde{u}_t(a,b)=|u_t(a,b)|.\EEQ In particular, $\tilde{u}_t\ge 0$. The {\em adjoint evolution} with generator $(\Re {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport})^{\dagger}$ is {\em sub-Markovian}, i.e. $\tilde{u}_t$ is the density at time $t$ of a (deterministic) time-reversed Markov $(\tilde{A}_t,\tilde{B}_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ process (whose trajectories run backwards w.r. to $(a_t,b_t)$) with kernel $p(t,\tilde{a}_t,\tilde{b}_t;s,\tilde{a}_s,\tilde{b}_s)\ge 0$ ($t\le s$) such that $\int d\tilde{a} \int d\tilde{b} \, p(t,\tilde{a},\tilde{b};s,\tilde{a}_s,\tilde{b}_s)\le 1$. \bigskip\noindent {\em Remark.} It is instructive to look at terms that would be produced by continuing the Taylor expansion to infinity. Note that the boundary value of the operator ${\cal H}^{\kappa,(2)}_{pot}(h)$ vanishes (${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(2)}(h)(a_T,b_T=0)\equiv 0$ vanishes to order $\ge 1$). It may be proven in general that the contribution of order $j$ vanishes to order $\ge j-1$. Summing up the whole series would yield (up to $\kappa$-dependent terms) \BEQ \frac{da_t}{dt}=\sum_{n=2p} \frac{V^{(n+1)}(a_t)}{n!} (\II b_t)^n, \qquad \frac{db_t}{dt}=-\II \sum_{n=2p+1} \frac{V^{(n+1)}(a_t)}{n!} (\II b_t)^n \EEQ \BEQ \frac{dc_{t}}{dt}=\sum_{n\ge 1} V^{(n+1)}(a_t) \frac{(\II b_t)^{n-1}}{(n-1)!}.\EEQ Note that, for $V$ {\em holomorphic}, this is equivalent to the vector field $V'(Z_{t})\partial_{Z_{t}}+V''(Z_{t})$. {\em However}, terms of order $\ge 3$ also produce {\em polynomials} in $x$ (instead of linear combination of ${\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)$, $z\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$). Integrating the generator would yield power series in $x$ which are maybe controllable, but this would require totally different techniques with respect to ours. \bigskip\noindent \subsection{Main remainder term} We study in this subsection the $g$-kernels $g_{pot}^{\kappa';\kappa,(3)}$ obtained by replacing $\chi_R(x)V'(x)f'_{z_T}(x)$ with $\chi_R(x)(x-a_T)^3 W_{a_T}(x-a_T)f'_{z_T}(x)$ in Definition \ref{def:g-kernel}. We want to prove that the operators \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa,(3)}_{pot}: h\mapsto {\cal H}^{\kappa,(3)}_{pot}(h): \left( (a,b)\mapsto\int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, g_{pot}^{\kappa,(3)}(a,b;a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T) \right) \label{eq:HV3} \EEQ and \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}_{pot}: h\mapsto {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}_{pot}(h): \left( (a,b)\mapsto\int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, g_{pot}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}(a,b;a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T) \right) \label{eq:HV3+1} \EEQ are bounded operators in $L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$. \begin{Definition} For $f\in C^k(\mathbb{R},\mathbb{R})$ and $R>0$, let \BEQ ||f||_{k,[-R,R]}:=\sup_{0\le j\le k} \sup_{[-R,R]} |f^{(j)}|.\EEQ \end{Definition} \begin{Lemma} \label{lem:S8} \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] $|||{\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}|||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} = O(b_{max}^{-1} ||V'||_{8+\kappa,[-3R,3R]} )$; \item[(ii)] $|||{\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,(3)}|||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} = O( ||V'||_{7+\kappa,[-3R,3R]} )$. \end{itemize} \medskip\noindent The same estimates hold for the {\em $L^{\infty}$-operator norms} $||| \ \cdot \ |||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}$. \end{Lemma} \medskip\noindent As can be checked by looking at the details of the proof, norms $|||\ \cdot\ |||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}$ are deduced from these by dividing by a volume factor ${\mathrm{Vol}}([-3R,3R]\times[-b_{max},b_{max}])\approx b_{max}$, which follows from the fact that the kernel $g_{pot}^{\kappa';\kappa,(3)}$ is regular on the diagonal. \bigskip\noindent We shall actually only prove the statement for $|||{\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}|||_{L^1\to L^1}$. The proof of (ii) reduces immediately to (i) by substituting $\kappa\to \kappa-1$ and taking into account the extra $b$-prefactor. \medskip \noindent {\bf Remark.} Had we Taylor expanded $V'$ to order 2 instead of order 3, would we have obtained an {\em unbounded} operator instead of ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}$, as testified by the bound (\ref{eq:3.88}) below (with $x^2$ instead of $x^3$ in the numerator, the integral would diverge in the limit $b_T\to 0$ for $m=3+\kappa$). On the other hand, for the same reason, it is easy to see by looking at the details of the proof that ${\cal H}^{\kappa,(3)}:L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})$ is bounded, typically because in (\ref{eq:3.88}) one obtains instead of the $L^1$-kernel $x\mapsto \frac{b_T}{x^2+b_T^2}$ the bounded function $x\mapsto \frac{b_T^2}{x^2+b_T^2}$. \medskip \noindent{\bf Proof.} By definition, \BEQ g^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T)= \frac{(-\II b_T) |b_T|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!}\, {\cal K}^{\kappa+1}_{b_{max}} \left( x\mapsto \chi_R(x) (x-a_T)^3 W_{a_T}(x-a_T) f'_{z_T}(x) \right)(a) \nonumber\\ \label{eq:3.72} \EEQ We consider in the computations only the part $g^{\kappa}$ of the kernel $g^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}_{pot}$ obtained by replacing ${\cal K}^{\kappa}$ with the operators in factor of the bounded operator $1+\underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}$ in (\ref{eq:calK-kappa-even}, \ref{eq:calK-kappa-odd}). For some numerical constants $c_1=c_1(\kappa),c_2=c_2(\kappa)$, \begin{eqnarray} g^{\kappa}(a,b;a_T,b_T) &=&(-\II b_T) |b_T|^{\kappa} \left\{ c_1 [{\cal F}^{-1} (|s|^{3+\kappa}) \ast] +c_2 b_{max}^{-(3+\kappa)} \right\} (F_{a_T+\II b_T})(x) \nonumber\\ &=:& (-\II b_T) |b_T|^{\kappa} (c_1 G^1_{a_T+\II b_T}(x)+c_2 G^2_{a_T+\II b_T}(x)) , \label{eq:H2} \end{eqnarray} with $x:=a-a_T$ and \BEQ F_{a_T+\II b_T}(y):= \tilde{W}_{a_T}(y) \frac{y^3}{(y-\II b_T)^2} \label{eq:F2} \EEQ where $\tilde{W}_{a_T}(y)=\chi_R(a_T+y)W_{a_T}(y)$ has support $\subset[-\frac{9}{2}R,\frac{9}{2}R]$ since $|a_T|\le 3R$. Thus (\ref{eq:HV3+1}) looks like a convolution formula in the coordinates $a,a_T$ -- but not quite since $\tilde{W}_{a_T}$ depends on $a_T$ --, which leads us to use the following bound (where $G_{a_T+\II b_T}:=c_1 G^1_{a_T+\II b_T} + c_2 G^2_{a_T+\II b_T}$) \begin{eqnarray} && ||{\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}(h)||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \le b_{max} \left( \sup_{(a_T,b_T)\in[-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]} |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad \left. \int da\, |G_{a_T+\II b_T}(a-a_T)|\right)\ ||h||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max})}} \end{eqnarray} whence \BEQ |||{\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,(3)}|||_{L^1\to L^1} \le b_{max} \left(\sup_{(a_T,b_T)\in[-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]} ||\ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} G_{a_T+\II b_T}||_{L^1} \right). \EEQ We must therefore bound $||\ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} G_{a_T+\II b_T}||_{L^1}$. {\em The main issue, on which we shall now concentrate, is to bound $|| \ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} G^1_{a_T+\II b_T}||_{L^1([-5R,5R])}$;} as shown later on, the missing terms are less singular and may be bounded similarly. Thus from now on and till below (\ref{eq:3.99}), $|a_T|\le 3R$, $|x|\le 5R$ and $|a|:=|x+a_T|\le 8R$ are bounded. \medskip \noindent If $\kappa$ is {\em odd} then $|s|^{3+\kappa}=s^{3+\kappa}$ is the Fourier symbol of a differential operator, otherwise $|s|^{3+\kappa}={\mathrm{sgn}}(s) s^{3+\kappa}$ involves a further convolution by a singular kernel. Let us accordingly dinstinguish two cases. But first of all we let, for $\ell\ge 3$ and $|a_T|\le 3R$, \BEQ C_{\ell}:=\sup_{3\le \ell'\le \ell} ||\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(\ell'-3)}||_{\infty} \EEQ and note that \BEQ C_{\ell}=O\left( \sup_{3\le \ell'\le \ell} \sup_{[-3R,3R]} |V^{(\ell'+1)}| \right)= O( ||V'||_{\ell,[-3R,3R]})\EEQ More generally, if $\ell\ge \ell'\ge \ell''\ge 3$ and $r\ge 0$, \BEQ || y\mapsto (\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(\ell''-3)}(y) y^r)^{(\ell'-\ell'')} ||_{\infty} = O( C_{\ell}).\EEQ \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] ($\kappa$ odd)\qquad First \BEQ ||\ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} G^1_{a_T+\II b_T}||_{L^1(\mathbb{R})}=O(C_{6+\kappa} |b_T|^{1+\kappa}) \sum_{m=0}^{3+\kappa} \int_{-5R}^{5R} dx\, \, \left|\partial_x^m\left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right) \right|. \EEQ Then \BEQ \partial_x^m\left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right)= \sum_{p-q=1-m, p\le 3, q\ge 2} C^m_{p,q} x^p (x-\II b_T)^{-q} \label{eq:mpq} \EEQ for some coefficients $C^m_{p,q}$. If $3\le m\le 3+\kappa$ then $|x^p (x-\II b_T)^{-q}|=O(\frac{|x-\II b_T|^{3-m}}{x^2+|b_T|^2})=O(\frac{|b_T|^{3-m}}{x^2+|b_T|^2})$. Multiplying with respect to $|b_T|^{1+\kappa}$ and integrating, one gets (using $b_T\le b_{max}\le 1$) \begin{eqnarray} \, ||\ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \partial_x^m\left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right)||_{L^1(\mathbb{R})} &\le& C' |b_T|^{3+\kappa-m} \int dx\, \frac{b_T}{x^2+|b_T|^2}=O(1).\nonumber\\ \label{eq:3.88} \end{eqnarray} If $m\le 2$ then $b_T\left|\partial_x^m \left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right) \right|=O(|b_T|\frac{|x|^{3-m}}{x^2+|b_T|^2})=O(|x|^{2-m})$. Thus\\ $ ||\ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \partial_x^m\left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right)||_{L^1([-5R,5R])}=O(|b_T|^{\kappa} )=O(1).$ \medskip All together: \BEQ || \ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} G^1_{a_T+\II b_T}||_{L^1([-5R,-5R])}=O(C_{6+\kappa} ) \label{eq:3.89} .\EEQ \item[(ii)] ($\kappa$ even) Let, for $0\le m\le 3+\kappa$, \BEQ I(x):=p.v.(\frac{1}{x})\ast \left[ x\mapsto \tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)}(x) \partial_x^m\left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right) \right].\EEQ We must bound $|b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int dx\, |I(x)|.$ \noindent We rewrite $I(x)$ as the sum of two contributions (we refer to section \ref{sec:Stieltjes} without further mention for computations and bounds related to the principal value integral), $I(x)=:I_{reg}(x)+I_{sing}(x)$, where \BEQ I_{reg}(x):=\int dy\, \frac{\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)}(x)-\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)}(y)}{x-y} \partial_x^m\left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right) \label{eq:Ireg} \EEQ and \BEQ I_{sing}(x):=\int dy\, \tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)} (y) \frac{\partial_x^m \left( \frac{x^3}{(x-\II b_T)^2}\right)-\partial_y^m \left( \frac{y^3}{(y-\II b_T)^2}\right)}{x-y}. \label{eq:Ising} \EEQ Using $\left|\frac{\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)}(x)-\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)}(y)}{x-y} \right|\le ||\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(4+\kappa-m)}||_{\infty}\le C_{7+\kappa}$, and noting that, for $|x|\le 5R$, the integral $\int dy \, (\cdots)=\int_{B(x,\frac{19}{2}R)} (\cdots)$ (by symmetry) simply produces an extra factor $O(1)$, one obtains, using (i) \BEQ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int dx\, |I_{reg}(x)|=O(C_{7+\kappa} ). \label{eq:3.93} \EEQ Considering now $I_{sing}(x)$, we expand the numerator of (\ref{eq:Ising}) as in (\ref{eq:mpq}) and rewrite \begin{eqnarray} && \frac{x^p(x-\II b_T)^{-q}-y^p(y-\II b_T)^{-q}}{x-y} = \frac{x^p-y^p}{x-y} (y-\II b_T)^{-q} + x^p \frac{(y-\II b_T)^q-(x-\II b_T)^q}{(x-y)(x-\II b_T)^q (y-\II b_T)^q} \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad = \sum_{r=0}^{p-1} x^{p-1-r} \frac{y^r}{(y-\II b_T)^q} - \sum_{r'=1}^q \frac{x^p}{(x-\II b_T)^{r'}} \frac{1}{(y-\II b_T)^{q+1-r'}}. \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} The integrals $J_1:=\int dy\, \frac{\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)}(y) y^r}{(y-\II b_T)^q}$, $J_2:=\int dy\, \frac{\tilde{W}_{a_T}^{(3+\kappa-m)}(y)}{(y-\II b_T)^{q+1-r'}}$ may be bounded using (\ref{eq:phi-ib-n}) since $q\ge 2\ge 1$ and $q+1-r'\ge 1$. Thus \BEQ |J_1|=O(C_{8+\kappa} ), |J_2|=O(C_{8+\kappa} ) \EEQ Then $\int_{-5R}^{5R} dx\, |x|^{p-1-r}=O(1)$ and \BEQ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int dx\, \frac{|x|^p}{|x-\II b_T|^{r'}}=O(|b_T|^{(1+\kappa)-(r'-p-1)})=O(b_{max}^{2-r'+\kappa+p}) \qquad (r'\ge p+2)\EEQ (note that $2-r'+\kappa+p\ge 0$); \BEQ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int_{-5R}^{5R} dx\, \frac{|x|^p}{|x-\II b_T|^{r'}}\le |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int_{-5R}^{5R} \frac{dx}{|x-\II b_T|} =O(b_{max}^{1+\kappa} \ln(1/b_{max})) \qquad (r'=p+1) \EEQ \BEQ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int_{-5R}^{5R} dx\, \frac{|x|^p}{|x-\II b_T|^{r'}}\le b_{max}^{1+\kappa} \int_{-5R}^{5R} dx\, |x|^{p-r'} = O( b_{max}^{1+\kappa} ) \qquad (r'\le p) \EEQ \medskip All together, one obtains, summing all terms: \BEQ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int dx\, |I_{sing}(x)|=O(C_{8+\kappa} ). \label{eq:3.99} \EEQ \end{itemize} \bigskip Let us now quickly deal with the missing terms. First \begin{eqnarray} || \ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} G^2_{a_T+\II b_T}||_{L^1} &\le& b_{max}^{-2} \int dx\, \frac{|x|^3}{|x-\II b_T|^2} |\tilde{W}_{a_T}(x)| \nonumber\\ &\le& b_{max}^{-2}\ ||\tilde{W}_{a_T}||_{\infty} \int_{-\frac{9}{2} R}^{\frac{9}{2}R} dx\, |x| = O\left( b_{max}^{-2}C_3 \right). \label{eq:3.100} \end{eqnarray} Then one must bound $|b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int_{|x|\ge 5R} dx\, |G^1_{a_T+\II b_T}(x)|$; because supp$(\tilde{W}_{a_T})\subset [-\frac{9}{2}R,\frac{9}{2} R]$, this contribution vanishes except if $\kappa$ is {\em even}, see (ii) above, in which case (by integration by parts) \begin{eqnarray} && |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int_{|x|\ge 5R} dx\, |G^1_{a_T+\II b_T}(x)| = |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int_{|x|\ge 5R} dx\, \left| \int_{-\frac{9}{2}R}^{\frac{9}{2}R} dy \, p.v.(\frac{1}{(x-y)^2}) F_{a_T+\II b_T}^{(2+\kappa)}(y) \right| \nonumber\\ && \le |b_T| \int_{|x|\ge 5R} dx\, O(\frac{1}{x^2}) \, ||\ |b_T|^{\kappa} F_{a_T+\II b_T}^{(2+\kappa)} ||_{L^1([-5R,5R])}.\end{eqnarray} The integral $|| \ |b_T|^{\kappa} F_{a_T+\II b_T}^{(2+\kappa)} ||_{L^1([-5R,5R])}$ is (up to the replacement $\kappa\to \kappa-1$) exactly the one which has been computed in case (i) above. Hence we find: \BEQ |b_T|^{1+\kappa} \int_{|x|\ge 5R} dx\, |G^1_{a_T+\II b_T}(x)| = O\left( C_{5+\kappa} \right). \label{eq:3.102} \EEQ Since $C_3\le C_{5+\kappa}\le C_{6+\kappa}\le C_{8+\kappa}=O(||V'||_{8+\kappa,[-3R,3R]})$ and $b_{max}\le 1$, the sum of estimates (\ref{eq:3.89}, \ref{eq:3.93}, \ref{eq:3.99}, \ref{eq:3.100}, \ref{eq:3.102}) is $ O(b_{max}^{-2} ||V'||_{8+\kappa,[-3R,3R]})$. \hfill\eop \subsection{Away from the support} We study in this subsection the $g$-kernels $g_{pot}^{\kappa';\kappa,ext}$ obtained by assuming that $h=h^{ext}$, whence $|a_T|\ge 2R$. We want to prove that the operators \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}: h\mapsto \left( {\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}(h): (a,b)\mapsto\int da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, g_{pot}^{\kappa,ext}(a,b;a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T) \right) \label{eq:Hext} \EEQ and \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot}: h\mapsto \left( {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}(h): (a,b)\mapsto\int da_T \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T\, g_{pot}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}(a,b;a_T,b_T) h(a_T,b_T) \right) \label{eq:Hext+1} \EEQ are bounded operators in $L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$. We shall actually only prove the statement for ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot}$, and leave the similar proof of the statement for ${\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ to the reader. \begin{Lemma} \label{lem:S3} \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] $|||{\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}|||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} =O\left(b_{max}^{-1} ||V'||_{4+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right); $ \item[(ii)] $|||{\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}|||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} =O\left( ||V'||_{3+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right).$ \end{itemize} \medskip\noindent The same estimates hold for the $L^{\infty}$-operator norms $|||\ \cdot\ |||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}$. \end{Lemma} \noindent As can be checked by looking at the details of the proof, norms $|||\ \cdot\ |||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}$ are deduced from these by dividing by a volume factor ${\mathrm{Vol}}([-3R,3R]\times[-b_{max},b_{max}])\approx b_{max}$, which follows from the fact that the kernel $g_{pot}^{\kappa';\kappa,ext}$ is regular on the diagonal. \medskip\noindent{\bf Proof.} \begin{itemize} \item[(1)] (operator norm of ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}$) By definition, \BEQ g^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T)= {\bf 1}_{|b|<b_{max}} {\bf 1}_{|a_T|\ge 2R}\, \frac{1}{(1+\kappa)!} (-\II b) |b_T|^{\kappa}\, {\cal K}^{\kappa+1}_{b_{max}}(\chi_R V' f'_{z_T})(a) \label{eq:3.43} \EEQ Note that, since $|a_T|\ge 2R$ and supp$(\chi_R)\subset B(0,\frac{3}{2}R)$, the function $\chi_R V' f'_{z_T}$ is regular and bounded. Furthermore, for every $n=0,1,\ldots,$ $||(\chi_R V' f'_{z_T})^{(n)}||_{\infty}=O(||V'||_{n,[-\frac{3}{2}R,\frac{3}{2}R]} |a_T|^{-2})$ is integrable at infinity in $a_T$. \medskip\noindent We consider in the computations only the part $g^{\kappa}$ of the kernel $g^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ obtained by replacing ${\cal K}^{\kappa}$ with the operators in factor of the bounded operator $1+\underline{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}$ in (\ref{eq:calK-kappa-even}, \ref{eq:calK-kappa-odd}), and distinguish the cases $\kappa$ odd, $\kappa$ even. Assume first $\kappa$ is {\em odd}. Then \begin{eqnarray} && |g^{\kappa}(a,b;a_T,b_T)| \nonumber\\ && = {\bf 1}_{|b|<b_{max}}\, {\bf 1}_{|a_T|\ge 2R} \, O(|b_T|^{1+\kappa}) \left( \left| (\chi_R V' f'_{z_T})^{(3+\kappa)}(a) \right| + b_{max}^{-(3+\kappa)} |(\chi_R V'f'_{z_T})(a)| \right) \nonumber\\ && = O\left( b_{max}^{1+\kappa} ||V'||_{3+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} + b_{max}^{-2} ||V'||_{0,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right)\, |a_T|^{-2} \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\qquad \, {\bf 1}_{(a,b)\in[- \frac{3}{2} R,\frac{3}{2} R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]}. \nonumber\\ \label{eq:3.45} \end{eqnarray} Hence ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ is a bounded operator on $L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, with $L^1$-operator norm \begin{eqnarray} && |||{\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot} |||_{L^1\to L^1} = O\left( b_{max}^{1+\kappa} ||V'||_{3+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} + |b|^{-2}_{max} ||V'||_{0,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right) \ \cdot \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\qquad \cdot\ {\mathrm{Vol}}([-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]) \nonumber\\ &&\qquad =O\left( b_{max}^{3+\kappa} ||V'||_{3+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R,\frac{3}{2}R]} + ||V'||_{0,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right) b_{max}^{-1}. \nonumber\\ \label{eq:op-ext1} \end{eqnarray} \medskip\noindent Assume now that $\kappa$ is {\em even}. Then (using (\ref{eq:3.45}) and (\ref{eq:bound-vp2}))\\ $|g^{\kappa}(a,b;a_T,b_T)|\le O(b_{max}^{-2} ||V'||_{0,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \, {\bf 1}_{(a,b)\in[-\frac{3}{2}R,\frac{3}{2}R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]}) |a_T|^{-2}$, plus \begin{eqnarray} && {\bf 1}_{|b|<b_{max}} O(|b_T|^{1+\kappa}) \left| {\bf 1}_{|a_T|\ge 2R} \, p.v.(\frac{1}{x})\ast (\chi_R V' f'_{z_T})^{(3+\kappa)}(a) \right| \nonumber\\ &&= {\bf 1}_{|b|<b_{max}} O(|b_T|^{1+\kappa}) \left| {\bf 1}_{|a_T|\ge 2R} \, p.v.(\frac{1}{x^2})\ast (\chi_R V' f'_{z_T})^{(2+\kappa)}(a) \right| \nonumber\\ &&= O(|b_T|^{1+\kappa})\ \left[ {\bf 1}_{(a,b)\in[-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]} \ || {\bf 1}_{|a_T|\ge 2R} (\chi_R V' f'_{z_T})^{(4+\kappa)}||_{\infty} \right.\nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad \left. + {\bf 1}_{(a,b)\in (\mathbb{R}\setminus[-3R,3R])\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]} \ \frac{1}{a^2} \ || {\bf 1}_{|a_T|\ge 2R} (\chi_R V' f'_{z_T})^{(2+\kappa)}||_{\infty} \right]. \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} We conclude by multiplying by $\bar{\chi}_R+(1-\bar{\chi}_R)$ that ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot} h=\tilde{h}^{int}+\tilde{h}^{ext}$, where \BEQ ||\tilde{h}^{int}||_{L^1}\le O\left( b_{max}^{3+\kappa} ||V'||_{4+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} + ||V'||_{0,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right) \ b_{max}^{-1} \ ||h||_{L^1} \label{eq:op-ext2} \EEQ and \BEQ ||\tilde{h}^{ext}||_{L^1}\le O( b_{max}^{2+\kappa} ||V'||_{2+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]})\ ||h||_{L^1} . \label{eq:op-ext3} \EEQ \item[(2)](operator norm of ${\cal H}_{pot}^{\kappa,ext}$) With respect to (\ref{eq:op-ext1}), (\ref{eq:op-ext2}) and (\ref{eq:op-ext3}), we remove one order of differentiation and one power of $b_{max}^{-1}$, and exchange parities. Thus \BEQ |||{\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot} |||_{L^1\to L^1}= O\left( b_{max}^{2+\kappa} ||V'||_{2+\kappa, [-\frac{3}{2}R,\frac{3}{2}R]} + ||V'||_{0,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right) \label{eq:op-ext4} \EEQ for $\kappa$ even, while for $\kappa$ odd, ${\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot} h= \tilde{h}^{int}+\tilde{h}^{ext}$, with \BEQ ||\tilde{h}^{int}||_{L^1}\le O\left(b_{max}^{2+\kappa} ||V'||_{3+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} + ||V'||_{0,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]} \right) \ ||h||_{L^1} \label{eq:op-ext5} \EEQ and \BEQ ||\tilde{h}^{ext}||_{L^1}\le O( b_{max}^{2+\kappa} ||V'||_{1+\kappa,[-\frac{3}{2}R, \frac{3}{2}R]})\ ||h||_{L^1} . \label{eq:op-ext6} \EEQ \end{itemize} \bigskip\noindent {\bf Remark.} When $b_{max}=+\infty$, the adjoint of ${\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ or ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ is the generator of a {\em signed jump Markov process} with good properties. Namely, for all $a_T,b_T$, \BEQ \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} db\, g_{pot}^{\kappa,ext}(a,b;a_T,b_T)=0 \EEQ since $K^{\kappa}_{+\infty}(s=0)=0$, hence ${\cal L}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}:= ({\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot})^{\dagger}$ may we written in the following form, \BEQ {\cal L}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}(\phi)(a_T,b_T)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} da\, \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} db\, (\phi(a,b)-\phi(a_T,b_T))g^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T). \label{eq:L-ext} \EEQ For a bona fide Markov process, the function $(a,b)\mapsto -g^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T)\ge 0$ would be the jump rate from to $(a_T,b_T)$ to $(a,b)$, and one would have $-\int da\, db\, g^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}(a,b;a_T,b_T)=1$. Here $g$ is a signed kernel, so the probabilistic interpretation fails stricto sensu. However, the $L^1$ semi-group generated by ${\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ has good properties because ${\cal H}^{\kappa,ext}_{pot}$ is a bounded operator (see section 4). \subsection{Boundary terms} Recall the {\em horizontal boundary terms} h-bdry$_0$ (\ref{eq:h-bdry0}), h-bdry$_{pot}^{(1)}$ (\ref{eq:h-bdry-1}), and the {\em vertical boundary terms}, v-bdry$_0$ (\ref{eq:v-bdry0}), v-bdry$_{pot}^{(0)}$ (\ref{eq:v-bdry-0}) and v-bdry$_{pot}^{(2)}$ (\ref{eq:v-bdry-2}). We adopt the following notations. First let \BEQ \partial_R \Pi_{b_{max}}:=\partial\left([-3R,3R]\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]\right)= \left([-3R,3R]\times\{\pm b_{max}\}\right) \cup \left( \{\pm 3R\}\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]\right),\EEQ and, for $h:[-3R,3R]\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]\to\mathbb{C}$, let $\partial_R h:= h\big|_{\partial_R \Pi_{b_{max}}}$ be the restriction of $h$ to the boundary. Horizontal boundary terms h-bdry$_{\cdot}^{\cdot}$ (where the dots stand for various lower and upper indices) are of the form h-bdry$_{\cdot}^{\cdot}(b_{max};\partial_R h)$ \ $-$\ h-bdry$_{\cdot}^{\cdot}(-b_{max};\partial_R h)$; similarly, vertical boundary terms v-bdry$_{\cdot}^{\cdot}$ are of the form v-bdry$_{\cdot}^{\cdot}(3R;\partial_Rh)$ \ $-$ \ v-bdry$_{\cdot}^{\cdot}(-3R;\partial_R h)$. \medskip\noindent These terms depend a priori on the restriction of $h$ to $\partial_R \Pi_{b_{max}}$, which is incompatible with the $L^1$-norms. In order to avoid that, we replace ${\mathfrak{f}}_{a_T\pm \II b_{max}}$ with ${\cal C}^{\kappa'} \left((a,b)\mapsto {\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}}({\mathfrak{f}}_{a_t\pm\II b_{max}})(a)\right)$, $\kappa'=\kappa,\kappa+1$ so that \begin{eqnarray} && ({\mathrm{h\!-\!bdry}}_0+{\mathrm{h\!-\!bdry}}_{pot}^{(1)})(b_{max};\partial_R h) - (b_{max}\leftrightarrow -b_{max}) \nonumber\\ && \qquad ={\cal C}^{\kappa+1} ({\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,h-bdry}(\partial_R h)) ={\cal C}^{\kappa}({\cal H}^{\kappa,h-bdry}(\partial_R h)) \end{eqnarray} with ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa,h-bdry},{\cal H}^{\kappa,h-bdry}: L^{\infty}(\partial_R \Pi_{b_{max}})\to (L^1 \cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}(\partial_R h)(a,b)=\int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T \, g^{\kappa+1;\kappa,}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}(a,b;a_T) \partial_R h(a_T,b_{max}) - (b_{max}\leftrightarrow -b_{max}) \label{eq:Hhbdry+1} \EEQ \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}(\partial_R h)(a,b)=\int_{-3R}^{3R} da_T \, g^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}(a,b;a_T) \partial_R h(a_T,b_{max}) - (b_{max}\leftrightarrow -b_{max}) \label{eq:Hhbdry} \EEQ and \begin{eqnarray} && g^{\kappa';\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}(a,b;a_T)= - \left\{ \frac{\beta}{4} \frac{b_{max}^{1+\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \Im[(M^N_T+M_T)(a_T+\II b_{max})]\, \right.\nonumber\\ && \left. \qquad + b_{max}^{2+\kappa} V''(a_T) \right\} \ {\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}}({\mathfrak{f}}_{a_T+\II b_{max}})(a) \label{eq:g-bdry} \end{eqnarray} Similarly, we replace $f_{\pm 3R+\II b}$ with ${\cal C}^{\kappa'} \left((a,b)\mapsto {\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}}({\mathfrak{f}}_{\pm 3R+\II b})(a)\right)$, $\kappa'=\kappa,\kappa+1$ , so that \begin{eqnarray} && ({\mathrm{v\!-\!bdry}}_0 + {\mathrm{v\!-\!bdry}}_{pot}^{(0)}+ {\mathrm{ v\!-\!bdry}}_{pot}^{(2)})(3R;\partial_R h) - (R\leftrightarrow -R) \nonumber\\ && \qquad = {\cal C}^{\kappa+1}({\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{v-bdry}(\partial_R h)) = {\cal C}^{\kappa}({\cal H}^{\kappa}_{v-bdry}(\partial_R h)) \end{eqnarray} with ${\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}},{\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}: L^{\infty}(\partial_R \Pi_{b_{max}})\to (L^1 \cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}(\partial_R h)(a,b)=\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T \, g^{\kappa+1;\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}(a,b;b_T) \partial_R h(3R,b_T) - (R\leftrightarrow -R) \label{eq:Hvbdry+1} \EEQ \BEQ {\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}(\partial_R h)(a,b)=\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db_T \, g^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}(a,b;b_T) \partial_R h(3R,b_T) - (R\leftrightarrow -R) \label{eq:Hvbdry} \EEQ and \begin{eqnarray} && g^{\kappa';\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}(a,b;b_T)= -(-\II b_T) \left\{ \frac{\beta}{4} \frac{|b_T|^{\kappa}}{(1+\kappa)!} \Re[(M^N_T+M_T)(3R+\II b_T)]\, \right.\nonumber\\ && \left. \qquad + (|b_T|^{\kappa} V'(3R)+ |b_T|^{\kappa+2} V'''(3R) \right\} \ {\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}}(\chi_{|R|}\, {\mathfrak{f}}_{3R+\II b_T})(a) \end{eqnarray} \medskip \begin{Lemma} \label{lem:S9} Let $\kappa\ge 0$ and $\kappa'=\kappa,\kappa+1$. Then \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] $|||{\cal H}^{\kappa';\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}|||_{L^{\infty}(\partial_R\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}=b_{max}^{-3-(\kappa'-\kappa)} \left\{ O(\frac{1}{b_{max}})+O(b_{max} ||V''||_{0,[-3R,3R]} \right\}$ and\\ $|||{\cal H}^{\kappa';\kappa}_{\mathrm{h-bdry}}|||_{L^{\infty}(\partial_R\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})}= b_{max}^{-2-(\kappa'-\kappa)} \left\{ O(\frac{1}{b_{max}})+O(b_{max} ||V''||_{0,[-3R,3R]} \right\}$; \item[(ii)] \begin{eqnarray} && |||{\cal H}^{\kappa';\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}|||_{L^{\infty}(\partial_R\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \nonumber\\ &&\qquad = b_{max}^{-1-(\kappa'-\kappa)} \left\{ O(\frac{1}{b_{max}})+O(||V'||_{0,[-3R,3R]}) + O(b_{max}^2 ||V'''||_{0,[-3R,3R]}) \right\} \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} and \begin{eqnarray} && |||{\cal H}^{\kappa}_{\mathrm{v-bdry}}|||_{L^{\infty}(\partial_R\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \nonumber\\ &&\qquad =b_{max}^{-(\kappa'-\kappa)} \left\{ O(\frac{1}{b_{max}})+O(||V'||_{0,[-3R,3R]}) + O(b_{max}^2 ||V'''||_{0,[-3R,3R]}) \right\}. \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} \end{itemize} \end{Lemma} \noindent As in the two previous subsections, $L^1$-estimates and $L^{\infty}$-estimates differ only by a volume factor $\approx b_{max}$. \medskip\noindent {\bf Proof.} \begin{itemize} \item[(i)] Immediate consequence of the bounds $\left|\Im[(M^N_T+M_T)(a_T+\II b_{max})] \right|\le 2/b_{max}$, $b_{max} |V''(a_T)|\le b_{max} ||V''||_{0,[-3R,3R]}$ and $| {\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}}(\chi_R {\mathfrak{f}}_{a_T\pm\II b_{max}})(a)|=O(b_{max}^{-(4+\kappa')}) \ O(\frac{1}{(1+|a|)^2})$ (as seen by using (\ref{eq:calK-kappa-even}) when $\kappa'$ is even, and (\ref{eq:calK-kappa-odd},\ref{eq:bound-vp2}) when $\kappa'$ is odd). \item[(ii)] Immediate consequence of the bounds $\left|\Re[(M^N_T+M_T)(a_T+\II b_{max})] \right|\le 2/b_{max}$, $|V'(3R)|\le ||V'||_{0,[-3R,3R]}$, $b_T^2 |V'''(3R)|\le b_{max}^2 ||V'''||_{0,[-3R,3R]}$, and\\ $| {\cal K}^{\kappa'}_{b_{max}}(\chi_R \, {\mathfrak{f}}_{\pm 3R+\II b_T})(a)|=O(b_{max}^{-(2+\kappa')}) \ O(\frac{1}{(1+|a|)^2})$. \end{itemize} \hfill \eop \section{Gaussianity of the fluctuation process} In this section, we prove our Main Theorem (see \S 1.3), namely, we prove that the finite-$N$ fluctuation process $(Y^N_t)_{t\ge 0}$ converges weakly in $C([0,T],H_{-14})$ to a fluctuation process $(Y_t)_{t\ge 0}$, which is the unique solution of a martingale problem that we solve explicitly in terms of the solution of (\ref{eq:PDE-f}). \noindent {\em We fix once and for all: $b_{max}=\half$}. \medskip\noindent Summarizing what we have found up to now and applying Proposition \ref{prop:Israelsson}, we find for $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots$: \BEQ d\langle Y_t^N,{\cal C}^{\kappa} h_t\rangle=\half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t^N, ({\cal C}^{\kappa} h_t)''\rangle \, dt + \frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_i ({\cal C}^{\kappa} h_t)'(\lambda^i_t) dW^i_t \EEQ where $(h_t)_{t\le T}$ is the solution of the evolution equation \BEQ \frac{dh_t}{dt}={\cal H}^{\kappa}(t)h(t).\EEQ On the other hand, the process $(Y^N_t)_{t\ge 0}$ is a solution of the following {\em martingale problem}: if $\bar{\phi}=\{\phi_j\}_{1\le j\le k}$ is a family of test functions in $C_c^{\infty}(\mathbb{R},\mathbb{R})$, $F\in C_b^2(\mathbb{R}^k,\mathbb{R})$, then, letting $F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y_{\cdot}^N):=F(\langle Y_{\cdot}^N, \phi_1\rangle,\ldots,\langle Y_{\cdot}^N,\phi_k\rangle)$, \BEQ \Phi^{T,N}_t(Y^N):=F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y^N_T)-F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y^N_t)-\int_t^T ds\, L^N_s F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y^N_s)\EEQ is a martingale, where \begin{eqnarray} && L^N_s F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y^N_s):=\sum_{j=1}^k \frac{\partial F_{\bar{\phi}}}{\partial x_j}(Y^N_s) \left( \langle Y^N_s, \frac{\beta}{4} \int \frac{\phi'_j(\cdot)-\phi'_j(y)}{\cdot-y} (X_t+X_t^N)(dy) - V'(\cdot)\phi'_j(\cdot) \rangle + \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\left. + \half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t^N,\phi''_j\rangle \right) +\half \sum_{j,l=1}^k \partial^2_{jl} F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y_s^N)\ \langle X_t^N,\phi'_j\phi'_l\rangle \label{eq:mgle-pb} \end{eqnarray} (see \cite{Isr}, p. 28--29). \bigskip\noindent We now use an exponential functional of the process to derive the limit law. \begin{Definition} For $\kappa=0,1,2,\ldots$ and $h\in (L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, let \BEQ \phi_h(Y_t^N):=e^{\II \langle Y_t^N,{\cal C}^{\kappa} h\rangle}. \EEQ \end{Definition} Notice the slight change of notation with respect to (\ref{eq:intro-Gaussian}) in the introduction. It\^o's formula implies as in (\cite{Isr}, p. 29) \BEQ d\phi_{h_t}(Y_t^N)=\phi_{h_t}(Y_t^N) \left(\half \II (1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t^N,({\cal C}^{\kappa} h_t)''\rangle -\half \langle X_t^N, (({\cal C}^{\kappa}h_t)')^2 \rangle \right) dt,\EEQ where $({\cal C}^{\kappa}h_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ is the solution of (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) for $N$ finite, from which for $0\le t\le T$ (letting {\em formally} $N\to\infty$) \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[\phi_{h_T}(Y_T)\big| {\cal F}_t]=\phi_{h_t}(Y_t)\ \exp\left( \half \int_t^T \left[ \II (1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_s,({\cal C}^{\kappa} h_s)''\rangle - \langle X_s,(({\cal C}^{\kappa} h_s)')^2\rangle \right] ds \right) \label{eq:Gaussian} \EEQ where $(h_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ is now the solution of the asymptotic equation (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f-asymptotic}). Since $h_s$, $t\le s\le T$ are linear in $h_T$, the term in the exponential in (\ref{eq:Gaussian}) is a sum of a linear and a quadratic term in $h_T$, giving resp. the expectation and the variance of a Gaussian process (see Israelsson, \S 2.6 for more details). \bigskip The strategy of the proof, following closely the proof in (Israelsson \cite{Isr}, section 2), is the following: \begin{itemize} \item[(A)] {\em find bounds} for ${\mathbb{E}}[ \sup_{s\le T} |\langle Y_s^N,\phi\rangle|]$, ${\mathbb{E}}[\sup_{s\le T} |\langle Y_s^N,\int \frac{\phi'(\cdot)-\phi'(y)}{\cdot-y} X_s^N(dy)\rangle|]$ and\\ ${\mathbb{E}}[ \sup_{s\le T} |\langle Y_s^N,V'(\cdot)\phi'(\cdot)\rangle|]$ (see first line in (\ref{eq:dY_tnf}) or (\ref{eq:mgle-pb})); \item[(B)] prove a {\em tightness property} for the family of processes $Y^N$, implying the existence of a (non necessarily unique) limit in law; \item[(C)] prove that {\em any} weak limit $Y$ of the $(Y^N)_{n\ge 1}$ {\em satisfies the limit martingale problem}, i.e. is such that \BEQ \Phi^{T}_t(Y)=F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y_T)-F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y_t)-\int_t^T ds\, L_s F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y_s)\EEQ is a martingale, where \begin{eqnarray} && L_s F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y_s):=\sum_{j=1}^k \frac{\partial F_{\bar{\phi}}}{\partial x_j}(Y_s) \left( \langle Y_s, \frac{\beta}{2} \int \frac{\phi'_j(\cdot)-\phi'_j(y)}{\cdot-y} X_t(dy) - V'(\cdot)\phi'_j(\cdot) \rangle + \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\left. + \half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t,\phi''_j\rangle \right) +\half \sum_{j,l=1}^k \partial^2_{jl} F_{\bar{\phi}}(Y_s) \ \langle X_t,\phi'_j\phi'_l\rangle \label{eq:lim-mgle-pb} \end{eqnarray} (obtained formally from (\ref{eq:mgle-pb}) by letting $N\to\infty$); \item[(D)] prove that there exists only {\em one} measure with given initial measure satisfying (\ref{eq:lim-mgle-pb}), and that it is Gaussian, and satisfies (\ref{eq:Gaussian}). \end{itemize} To prove (C) one must essentially prove that $(\Phi^T_t-\Phi^{T,N}_t)(Y^N)$ is small, since $\Phi_t^T$ is continuous (see \cite{Isr}, pp. 47-48). \bigskip The proof is borrowed from Israelsson, where it takes up a few pages, see \cite{Isr}. The main bound, compare with \cite{Isr}, Lemma 15, is the following "$H_8$"-bound, \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[ \sup_{s\le T} |\langle Y_s^N,\phi\rangle|]\le C_T ||\phi||_{H_8}, \label{eq:bd-H4} \EEQ The above $H_8$-bound is obtained by integrating (\ref{eq:dY_tnf}), namely, \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathbb{E}}\Big[ \sup_{s\le T} |\langle Y_s^N,\phi\rangle| \Big]\le C\Big( {\mathbb{E}}[ |\langle Y_0^N,\phi\rangle|]+ \nonumber\\ && \qquad + \int_0^T ds \, {\mathbb{E}}\Big[|\langle Y_s^N, V'(\cdot) \phi'(\cdot)\rangle|+ |\langle Y_s^N, \int \frac{\phi'(x)-\phi'(\cdot)}{x-\cdot} (X_s^N(dx)+X_s(dx))\rangle| \Big] \nonumber\\ && \qquad + \int_0^T ds\, {\mathbb{E}}\Big[|\int \phi''(x)X_s^N(dx)| \Big] + {\mathbb{E}}\Big[\sup_{s\le T} |M_s|\Big] \Big) \end{eqnarray} where $M_s:=\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \int_0^s \sum_{i=1}^N \phi'(\lambda_s^i)dW_s^i$ is a martingale. All these terms are bounded as in \cite{Isr}, Lemma 15, using easy, $V$-independent inequalities {\em and} the following {\em fundamental estimate}, \begin{Lemma} \label{lem:fundamental-estimate} There exists a constant $C$ depending on $T$ such that, for all $t\le T$, \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[|\langle Y_t^N,\phi\rangle|^2] \le C||\phi||^2_{H_7},\label{eq:fundamental-estimate} \EEQ \end{Lemma} itself an immediate consequence of \BEQ \sqrt{{\mathbb{E}}[|\langle Y_T^N,{\mathfrak{f}}_z\rangle|^2]} \equiv \sqrt{ {\mathbb{E}}[|N(M_t^N-M_t)(z)|^2]} \le C |b|^{-6}, \qquad b:=\Im z \in [-b_{max},b_{max}] \label{eq:pre-4.14} \EEQ see (\ref{eq:4.14}) below. \medskip\noindent Note the loss of regularity with respect to (\cite{Isr}, Lemma 14), where one has $||\phi||_{H_2}$ in the r.-h.s. This changes the bounds in the course of the proof of (\cite{Isr}, Lemma 15), see in particular p. 43, l. 5, where estimates are proved using Israelsson's Lemma 8 for $q=2$ (with $q-1$ playing the same r\^ole as our $\kappa$): the latter lemma yields (with our notations) a bound on $||{\cal K}^{\kappa}_{b_{max}}(f)||_{L^1}$ in terms of $||f||_{L^1}+||f||_{H_{\kappa+2}}$, resp. $||f||_{L^1}+||f||_{H_{\kappa+3}}$, depending whether $\kappa$ is even, resp. odd; because of the loss of regularity one must take $\kappa=5$ ($q=6$, same exponent as in (\ref{eq:pre-4.14})), hence the "$H_8$"=$H_{\kappa+3}$-bound. \medskip\noindent The proof of (C), see \cite{Isr}, Lemmas 17 and 20, mainly depends on a bound for\\ $C(\phi):={\mathbb{E}}\Big[ \sup_{0\le s\le T} \Big| \Big\langle Y_s^N, \int \frac{\phi'(\cdot)-\phi'(y)}{\cdot - y} X_s^N(dy) \Big\rangle \Big| \Big]$. Assume $\phi={\cal C}^{\kappa}h$, $\kappa\in\mathbb{N}$; then $C(\phi)$ is bounded in terms of the integral against the measure $|b|^{\kappa+1} |h(a,b)| \, da\, db$ on $\Pi_{b_{max}}$ of the random function $N(M_t^N(z)-M_t(z))^2$, averaging to $O(\frac{1}{N} |b|^{-12})$ by (\ref{eq:pre-4.14}). Therefore the integral converges if $\kappa\ge 11$, and is bounded, as recalled in the previous paragraph, by $O(1/N) ||\phi||_{H_{14}}$. \medskip\noindent Then the tightness property (B) is proved using a lemma due to Mitoma \cite{Mit} and the above estimates (see \cite{Isr}, \S 2.4); the Sobolev space $H_{-14}$ in our Main Theorem is such that there exists a nuclear mapping $H_{14}\to H_{8}$ (see \ref{eq:bd-H4}), as follows from Treves \cite{Tre}, which is a requirement in Mitoma's hypotheses. \medskip\noindent Finally, letting $\phi_i={\cal C}^0 h_i$, $i=1,\ldots,k$, (D) is proved by computing\\ ${\mathbb{E}}\left[ \exp\II \left(\langle Y_{t_1},\phi_1\rangle+\ldots+ \langle Y_{t_k},\phi_k\rangle\right)\right]$, $0\le t_k\le \ldots\le t_1\le T$ by induction on $k$ using the assumed martingale property of the limit(s) and solving in terms of the time-evolved functions $h_i(t)$, $i=1,\ldots,k$. For $k=2$ we obtain (\ref{eq:Gaussian}). \bigskip \noindent So everything boils down to the proof of the above lemma. \medskip \noindent {\bf Proof of Lemma \ref{lem:fundamental-estimate}.} Let $\phi\in C_c^{\infty}$. Consider its standard Stieltjes decomposition of order 5, $\phi={\cal C}^5 h$ (take $b_{max}=\half$). Then (using (\ref{eq:Stieltjes-decomposition}) and Cauchy-Schwarz's inequaity) \BEQ |\langle Y_t^N,\phi\rangle|^2 \le ||h||^2_{L^2(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \int_{\Pi_{b_{max}}} da\, db\, b^{12} (N |M_t(z)-M_t^N(z)|)^2 \label{eq:bound-YtNphi2} \EEQ and $||h||_{L^2(\Pi_{b_{max}})}=O(||\phi||_{H^7})$ (as follows from the kernel representation (\ref{eq:calK-kappa-even}) of the standard Stieltjes decomposition, together with Parseval-Bessel's formula). Hence (\ref{eq:fundamental-estimate}) follows if we can show that \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[|N(M_T^N(z)-M_T(z))|^2]={\mathbb{E}}[|\langle Y_T^N,{\mathfrak{f}}_z\rangle|^2] \le C b^{-12} \label{eq:4.14} \EEQ for $0<b:=\Im z\le \half$; compare with Israelsson \cite{Isr}, Proposition 1, where a much better bound in $O((\ln(1+1/b)/b)^2)$ is proved. Note, however, that there is, to the best of our understanding, a flaw in Israelsson's proof, see below (\ref{eq:Ii}), whence (despite some efforts) we find in fact a bound in $O(b^{-12})$ in the harmonic case too. Further, introducing the stopping time \BEQ \tau:=\inf\{0<t\le T: \sup_{1\le i\le N} |\lambda_t^i|>R(T)\},\EEQ (and letting by convention $\tau\equiv T$ if $\sup_{0\le t\le T} \sup_{1\le i\le N} |\lambda^i_t|\le R(T)$), see Lemma \ref{lem:support}, we have, using the large deviation bound of section 5, and the obvious deterministic bound $M_t^N(z)\le |\Im(z)|^{-1}$, \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[|N(M_T^N(z)-M_T(z))|^2] \le {\mathbb{E}}[|N(M_{\tau}^N(z)-M_{\tau}(z))|^2] + Ce^{-cN} N^2 |\Im z|^{-2}.\EEQ So (\ref{eq:4.14}) holds provided we show that \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[|N(M_{\tau}^N(z)-M_{\tau}(z))|^2] \le C b^{-12} \label{eq:4.14bis} \EEQ where now by construction $\sup_i |\lambda_t^{N,i}|\le R(T)$ for all $t\le \tau$, a support condition which is essential for the subsequent computations. \bigskip\noindent Before we can do that, however, we need a long preliminary discussion. Indeed, Israelsson's proof of this fact in his Proposition 1 does not carry through immediately to the case of a general $V$, because it relies in an essential way on the bounds on characteristics. As explained in the Introduction though, the deterministic characteristics due to the $\left(\frac{1}{x}\right)$-potential, see \S 3.1, to which we can safely add the other transport generators without much change, yield the most singular contribution, so our strategy is to treat the non-local term ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}$ as a {\em perturbation} of ${\cal H}_{transport}$, by using a Green function expansion. Note however the {\em twist} here: the operators ${\cal H}_{transport}^{\kappa}$ and ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{\kappa}$ are endomorphisms of $L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, but ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}$ intertwines in some sense {\em two different copies} of $L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, with different mappings, ${\cal C}^{\kappa}$, vs. ${\cal C}^{\kappa+1}$ to $L^1(\mathbb{R})$. The intertwining is not trivial, in the sense that $b{\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}\not={\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{\kappa}$. This leads us to introduce the following operator-valued matrices. \begin{Definition} \label{def:eps} \begin{enumerate} \item Let $L^1[\eps](\Pi_{b_{max}}):=(\mathbb{R}[\eps]/\eps^3)\otimes L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\simeq \eps^0\otimes L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \oplus \eps^1\otimes L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \oplus \eps^2 \otimes L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}}).$ \item Let ${\cal H}[\eps]: L^1[\eps](\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1[\eps](\Pi_{b_{max}})$ be represented by the operator-valued matrix ${\cal H}[\eps]:= \left(\begin{array}{ccc} {\cal H}_{transport}^0 & 0 & 0 \\ {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0} & {\cal H}_{transport}^1 & 0 \\ 0 & {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{2,1} & {\cal H}^2 \end{array}\right).$ \item Let {\em Ev:} $L^1[\eps](\Pi_{b_{max}}) \to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$ be the {\em evaluation mapping}, \BEQ {\mathrm{Ev}}(\eps^0 \otimes h^0 + \eps^1\otimes h^1 + \eps^2 \otimes h^2)(a,b)= h^0(a,b)+bh^1(a,b)+b^2 h^2(a,b).\EEQ \end{enumerate} \end{Definition} The $(2,2)$-coefficient ${\cal H}^2$ -- the sum ${\cal H}^2_{transport}+{\cal H}^2_{nonlocal}$ -- is coherent with the truncation. Another possibility (also coherent with Lemma \ref{lem:eps} below, but introducing pointless complications) would be to consider the un-truncated infinite-dimensional matrix $\tilde{\cal H}[\eps]:=\left(\begin{array}{ccccc} {\cal H}_{transport}^0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \cdots \\ {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0} & {\cal H}_{transport}^1 & 0 & 0 & \cdots \\ 0 & {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{2,1} & {\cal H}^2 & 0 & \cdots \\ 0 & 0 & {\cal H}^{3,2}_{nonlocal} & {\cal H}^3_{transport} & 0 \\ \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \vdots \end{array}\right)$ acting on $\tilde{L}^1[\eps](\Pi_{b_{max}})\equiv \mathbb{R}[\eps]\otimes L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, with evaluation mapping Ev$(\sum_{j\ge 0} \eps^j\otimes h^j)(a,b)=\sum_{j\ge 0} b^j h^j$. \begin{Lemma} \label{lem:eps} Let $(h_t)_{0\le t\le T}\in L^1[\eps](\Pi_{b_{max}})$ be the solution of the time-evolution problem $\frac{dh_t}{dt}={\cal H}[\eps](t)h_t$ with terminal condition $h_T\equiv \eps^0\otimes h_T$. \noindent Then $f_t:={\cal C}^0\circ {\mathrm{Ev}}(h_t)$ solves (\ref{eq:PDE-f}) with initial condition ${\cal C}^0(h_T)$. \end{Lemma} \noindent {\bf Proof.} By definition. \hfill \eop \medskip\noindent Thus {\em our time-evolution operator is ${\cal H}[\eps]$}. Let ${\cal H}_{transport}[\eps]:=\left(\begin{array}{ccc} {\cal H}_{transport}^0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & {\cal H}_{transport}^1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & {\cal H}_{transport}^2 \end{array}\right)$ and ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}[\eps]:=\left(\begin{array}{ccc} 0 & 0 & 0 \\ {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0} & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{2,1} &{\cal H}^2_{nonlocal} \end{array}\right)$. The Green function first-order expansion then reads as follows, \BEQ U[\eps](t,T)=U_{transport}[\eps](t,T)-\int_t^T ds\, U[\eps](t,s) {\cal H}_{nonlocal}[\eps](s) U_{transport}[\eps](s,T), \label{eq:Green-function-expansion} \EEQ $U[\eps](t,T)$, resp. $U_{transport}[\eps](t,T)$ being the Green kernels (or evolution operators) obtained by integrating the time-inhomogeneous evolution systems generated by ${\cal H}[\eps]$, resp. ${\cal H}_{transport}[\eps]$, i.e. $u(t)=U[\eps](t,T)u(T)$, resp. $u_{transport}(t)=U_{transport}[\eps](t,T)u_{transport}(T)$, solves the linear equation $\frac{du(t)}{dt}={\cal H}[\eps](t)u(t)$, resp. $\frac{du_{transport}}{dt}={\cal H}_{transport}[\eps](t)u_{transport}(t)$. We shall actually require a {\em second-order} expansion of the Green kernel, obtained by iterating (\ref{eq:Green-function-expansion}), \begin{eqnarray} && U[\eps](t,T)=U_{transport}[\eps](t,T)-\int_t^T ds\, U_{transport}[\eps](t,s) {\cal H}_{nonlocal}[\eps](s) U_{transport}[\eps](s,T) \nonumber\\ && \qquad + \int_t^T ds \int_t^s ds'\, U[\eps](t,s'){\cal H}_{nonlocal}[\eps](s') U_{transport}[\eps](s,'s){\cal H}_{nonlocal}[\eps](s)U_{transport}[\eps](s,T) \label{eq:2Nd-Green-function-expansion-eps} \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} Thus (considering a terminal condition $h_T\equiv \eps^0\otimes h_T$) \begin{eqnarray} && ({\mathrm{Ev}}\circ U[\eps](t,T))(h_T)(a,b)=U^0 _{transport}(t,T)h_T(a,b) \nonumber\\ && \qquad - b \int_t^T ds\, U_{transport}^1(t,s) {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0}(s) U_{transport}^0(s,T) h_T(a,b) \nonumber\\ && \qquad + b^2\int_t^T ds \int_t^s ds'\, U^2(t,s'){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{2,1}(s') U_{transport}^1(s,'s){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0}(s)U_{transport}^0(s,T)h_T(a,b). \label{eq:2Nd-Green-function-expansion} \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} \medskip\noindent {\em Define \BEQ ||f||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max})}}:=\sup\left( ||f||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} , ||f||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \right) \EEQ and, for an operator ${\cal H}:(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \to (L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})$, \BEQ |||{\cal H}|||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})}:= \sup_{ ||f||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})}=1} ||{\cal H}f|| _{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})}.\EEQ } From the estimates proved in section 3, that is, from Lemma \ref{lem:U-transport} on the one hand, and Lemmas \ref{lem:S8}, \ref{lem:S3}, \ref{lem:S9} on the other, we know that, for all $\kappa\in\mathbb{N}$ and $0\le t\le s$: \BEQ |||U^{\kappa}_{transport}(t,s)|||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})}, |||U^{\kappa}_{transport}(t,s)|||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})\to L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\le 1; \EEQ \BEQ |||{\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{\kappa+1;\kappa}|||_{ (L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \to (L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})} = O( ||V'||_{8+\kappa,[-3R,3R]} ),\EEQ \BEQ |||{\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{\kappa}|||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \to (L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})} = O(||V'||_{7+\kappa,[-3R,3R]} ) \label{eq:Green-estimates-H-kappa} \EEQ \noindent Hence \begin{Lemma} \label{lem:L1Linfty-norm} Let $T>0$ fixed, and $0\le t\le s\le T$. Then \BEQ |||U^{\kappa}(t,s)|||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}}) \to (L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\le e^{c||V'||_{7+\kappa,[-3R,3R]} t} \EEQ for some constant $c>0$. \end{Lemma} \noindent{\bf Proof.} Results from (\ref{eq:Green-estimates-H-kappa}), Tanabe \cite{Tan}, Theorem 4.4.1 (construction of fundamental solutions of temporally inhomogeneous equations) and Proposition 4.3.3 (bounded perturbations of generators of "stable" strongly continuous semi-groups, here of ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_{transport}$ by ${\cal H}^{\kappa}_{nonlocal}$). \hfill \eop \bigskip \noindent {\em Proof of (\ref{eq:4.14bis}).} We start from It\^o's formula (\ref{eq:Ito}), \BEQ d\langle Y_t^N,f_t\rangle=\half(1-\frac{\beta}{2}) \langle X_t^N,f''_t\rangle dt + \frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N f'_t(\lambda_t^i)dW_t^i\EEQ where \BEQ f_{\tau}(x)=\frac{\chi_R(x)}{x-z_{\tau}}, \qquad z_{\tau}\equiv z, \EEQ represented as $({\cal C}^{\kappa} h_{\tau})(x)$ for some $\kappa$ (to be chosen later), with $h_{\tau}\ge 0 $ defined as in (\ref{eq:fz=Ch}), and $f_t$ satisfies the finite-$N$ evolution equation (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}). Recall (see (\ref{eq:hL1b-1},\ref{eq:hLinftyb-3})) that $||h_{\tau}||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\approx 1/b_{\tau}^{1+\kappa}$, $||h_{\tau}||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\approx 1/b_{\tau}^{3+\kappa}$. \medskip\noindent Integrating, we must bound three terms: \begin{itemize} \item[(1)] (initial condition) ${\mathbb{E}}|\langle Y_0^N,f_0\rangle|^2$; \item[(2)] (drift term) ${\mathbb{E}} \left(\int_0^{\tau} dt\, |\langle X_t^N, f''_t\rangle| \right)^{2}$; \item[(3)] ("martingale term") ${\mathbb{E}}\left( \frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \int_0^{\tau} dt\, \sum_{i=1}^N f'_t(\lambda_t^i) dW^i_t \right)^2$. \end{itemize} where $f_t={\cal C}^{\kappa} h_t$. \bigskip \noindent Bounding (1) is easy. We use the $0$-th order Stieltjes decomposition, \\ $f_0(x)=({\cal C}^0 h_0)(x)=\int da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b)\, db\, {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x) \ h_0(a,b)$, together with the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality, and obtain as in (\ref{eq:bound-YtNphi2}) \BEQ |\langle Y_0^N,f_0\rangle|^2 \le ||h_0||^2_{L^2(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \int_{\Pi_{b_{max}}} da\, db\, b^2 (N |M_0(z)-M_0^N(z)|)^2 \label{eq:bound-(1)} \EEQ We use the obvious $L^1-L^{\infty}$-bound, $||h_0||^2_{L^2(\Pi_{b_{max}})}\le ||h_0||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} ||h_0||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})}$, and Lemma \ref{lem:L1Linfty-norm}, \BEQ ||h_0||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} ||h_0||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \le C ||h_{\tau}||^2_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \le C'/b_{\tau}^{6} \label{eq:b8} \EEQ with $C,C'$ are constants depending on $T$, $R\equiv R(T)$ and $||V'||_{7,[-3R,3R]}$. \medskip\noindent There remains to bound the integral in the r.-h.s. of (\ref{eq:bound-(1)}), using our Assumption (iii) on the initial measure, see (\ref{hyp:initial-measure}). We split $\int_{\Pi_{b_{max}}}(\cdots)$ into $\int_{[-2R,2R]\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]}(\cdots)+\int_{(\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R])\times [-b_{max},b_{max}]}(\cdots)$. The integral over $[-2R,2R]\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]$ is $O(1)$. As for the integral over $z\in(\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R])\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]$, we first remark that \BEQ N|M_0^N(z)-M_0(z)|= \langle Y_0^N,\chi_R {\mathfrak{f}}_z\rangle \EEQ and \BEQ \chi_R(x){\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)=\int da' \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} (-\II b')\, db'\, \frac{1}{x-z'} {\cal K}^0_{b_{max}}(\chi_R {\mathfrak{f}}_z)(a') \EEQ with (see (\ref{eq:calK-kappa-even})) ${\cal K}^0_{b_{max}}(\chi_R {\mathfrak{f}}_z)(a')=O(\frac{1}{|a|}) O(\frac{1}{1+ |a'|^2})$. Hence (using Cauchy-Schwarz's inequality and (\ref{hyp:initial-measure}) once again) \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathbb{E}}\ \int_{|a|>2R} da \, \int_{|b|<b_{max}} db\, b^2\ \Big( N|M_0^N(z)-M_0(z)| \Big)^2 \nonumber\\ && \le C\ {\mathbb{E}} \int_{(\mathbb{R}\setminus[-2R,2R])\times[-b_{max},b_{max}]} \frac{b^2\, da\, db}{|a|^2} \left| \int da' \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db'\, \, \frac{N|b'|\ |M_0^N(z')-M_0(z')|}{1+|a'|^2} \right|^2 \nonumber\\ &&\le C' \int \frac{da'}{1+|a'|^2} \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db'\, {\mathbb{E}}[( N|b'| \ |M_0^N(z')-M_0(z')|)^2] = O(1).\end{eqnarray} All together we have proved: ${\mathbb{E}}|\langle Y_0^N,f_0\rangle|^2=O(b_T^{-6}).$ \bigskip\noindent The bound for (2) is essentially pathwise, but more subtle and relies on our perturbative expansion for the Green kernel, which yields the optimal exponent of $1/b_{\tau}$. {\em Main term} is obtained by replacing $f''_t$ in (2) with $({\cal C}^0 u_t)''$, where $u_t:=U_{transport}(t,\tau)h_{\tau}$. By assumption $h_{\tau}\ge 0$, so (see (\ref{eq:utilde})) $\tilde{u}_t:=\tilde{U}_{transport}(t,{\tau})h_{\tau}= |u_t|\ge 0$ for $0\le t\le {\tau}$, and these terms may be bounded as in Israelsson in a probabilistic way, by using the characteristic estimates proved in section 3. \medskip\noindent First (using $|({\mathfrak{f}}_z)''(x)|\le \frac{2}{|x-z|^3}\le \frac{2}{|b|} \frac{1}{|x-z|^2}$), we have pathwise \begin{eqnarray} && \int_0^{\tau} dt\, |\langle X_t^N, ({\cal C}^0 u_t)''\rangle| \le \int_0^{\tau} dt\, \left| \Big\langle X_t^N, \int da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, |b| |({\mathfrak{f}}_z)''(x)| \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \Big\rangle \right| \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\le 2 \int_0^{\tau} dt \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \frac{1}{b} \Im( M_t^N(z)) \, \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\le 2 \int_0^{\tau} dt \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \frac{1}{b} \Im \Big[(M_t^N+M_t)(z)\Big] \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad= 2 \int_0^{\tau} dt \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \partial_b\Big[ \Im \Big[(M_t^N+M_t)(z)\big] \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \Big] \ln(1/|b|) + {\mathrm{bdry}}_1 \nonumber\\ \label{eq:(2)}\end{eqnarray} where \BEQ {\mathrm{bdry}}_1:=-2\int_0^{\tau} dt\int_{-3R}^{3R} da \, \left[\Im(M_t^N+M_t)(a+\II b_{max}) \tilde{u}_t(a,b_{max}) - (b_{max}\leftrightarrow -b_{max}) \right] \ln(1/|b_{max}|)\EEQ is a boundary term. \medskip\noindent Now, we compare the first term in the r.-h.s. of (\ref{eq:(2)}) to \BEQ \frac{8}{\beta}\int_{-3R}^{3R} da\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (\tilde{u}_{\tau}(a,b)-\tilde{u}_0(a,b)) \ln(1/|b|) \equiv \frac{8}{\beta}\int_0^{\tau} dt\, \frac{d}{dt} \left( \int_{-3R}^{3R} da\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \ln(1/|b|) \right). \label{eq:8/beta1} \EEQ The main terms in $\frac{8}{\beta}\frac{d}{dt} \tilde{u}_t(a,b)$ are those due to the $(\frac{1}{x})$-kernel, $$2\left[ \partial_a\left( \Re(M^N_t+M_t)(z)\tilde{u}_t(a,b) \right) + \partial_b\left( \Im(M^N_t+M_t)(z) \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \right) \right].$$ The horizontal drift term $\partial_a \, \Re(M^N_t+M_t)$ vanishes by integration by parts up to a boundary term, \BEQ {\mathrm{bdry}}_2:= 2\int_0^{\tau} dt \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \ln(1/|b|) \left[\Re(M_t^N+M_t)(3R+\II b)\tilde{u}_t(3R+\II b) - (R\leftrightarrow -R) \right] \EEQ (note that $\Re(M_t^N+M_t)(\pm 3R+\II b)=O(1/R)$ is bounded), while the vertical drift term is identical to (\ref{eq:(2)}). The other terms in ${\cal H}_{transport}(t)$, see (\ref{eq:da(tau)/dtau}), (\ref{eq:db(tau)/dtau}), \BEQ \partial_a \left( (V'(a)-\half V'''(a)b^2)\tilde{u}_t(a,b)\right)+ \left(\partial_b \left( V''(a)b \tilde{u}_t(a,b)\right)\right) + {\mathrm{bdry}} \label{eq:4.24} \EEQ contribute respectively: yet another boundary term, \BEQ {\mathrm{bdry}}_3:=\frac{8}{\beta} \int_0^{\tau} dt \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \ln(1/|b|) \left[ (V'(3R)-\half V'''(3R)b^2)\tilde{u}_t(3R,b) - (R\leftrightarrow -R) \right];\EEQ and \begin{eqnarray} && \frac{8}{\beta} \int_0^{\tau} dt\, \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \, V''(a) \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \nonumber\\ && \qquad \qquad\qquad=O\left(\sup_{[-3R,3R]} |V''|\right) \ e^{c||V'||_{7,[-3R,3R]} T} ||u_T||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \end{eqnarray} by Lemma \ref{lem:L1Linfty-norm}, plus a boundary term, \BEQ {\mathrm{bdry}}_4:=\frac{8}{\beta} \int_0^{\tau} dt \int_{-3R}^{3R} da\, V''(a) \left[ b_{max} \ln(1/|b_{max}|) \tilde{u}_t(a,b_{max}) - (b_{max}\leftrightarrow -b_{max}) \right],\EEQ and also the integral over the domain $[-3R,3R] \times [-b_{max},b_{max}]$ of ($\frac{8}{\beta} \ln(1/|b|)$ times the boundary terms of \S 3.9. Finally, the contribution of the $\tilde{c}$-characteristic is known from the contraction property to be of the form $\frac{8}{\beta}\int_0^{\tau} dt\, \int_{3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \sigma_t(a,b) \tilde{u}_t(a,b) \ln(1/|b|)\ge 0$ with $\sigma_t(\cdot,\cdot)\ge 0$, hence positive. \medskip\noindent Using the $(L^1\cap L^{\infty})$-bound of $\tilde{u}_t$, one sees that all boundary terms are\\ $O(1) ||u_{\tau}||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})}= O(|b_{\tau}|^{-3})$, times some derivative of $V$, $||V^{(j)}||_{0,[-3R,3R]}$, $j=1,2,3$, times possibly $\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \ln(1/|b|)=O(1)$. But, actually, we have a much better bound {\em for $T$ small enough}: because $h_{\tau}(z)$ is $O(1)$, independent of $b_{\tau}$, far from the support $[-R,R]\times\{0\}$, say, on $\Pi_{b_{max}}\setminus\Big( [-2R,2R]\times[-\half b_{max},\half b_{max}]\Big)$, we shall have \BEQ ||u_t||_{L^{\infty}(\partial_R \Pi_{b_{max}})}=O(1) \label{eq:bd-bdry} \EEQ for all $t\in[0,\tau]$, as explained in the side remark before Lemma \ref{lem:U-transport}. Anticipating on the next terms featuring in the second-order expansion of the Green kernel (see below (\ref{eq:4.43})), it is easy to see that ${\cal H}^{1,0}_{nonlocal} (s)u_s$, whence $U^1_{transport}(t,s)(|{\cal H}^{1,0}_{nonlocal} (s)u_s|)$ and $U^2(t,s'){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{2,1}(s') (U^1_{transport}(s',s){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0}(s) u_s$ too, enjoy the same property (\ref{eq:bd-bdry}). Incidentally, this implies $||h_0||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} ||h_0||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \le C ||h_{\tau}||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})} ||h_{\tau}||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})} \le C'/b_{\tau}^4$ instead of $C'/b_{\tau}^6$ in (\ref{eq:b8}). \medskip\noindent Consider now the {\em left-hand side} of (\ref{eq:8/beta1}). Considering the {\em adjoint evolution}, we get a time-reversed sub-Markov process $(\tilde{A}_t,\tilde{B}_t)$ with kernel $p(s,\tilde{a}_s;t,\tilde{z}_t)$, $s\le t$ (see \S 3.6). Since $t\mapsto |\tilde{B}_t|$ {\em decreases}, we obtain \begin{eqnarray} && \left| \int da\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \tilde{u}_0(a,b) \ln(1/|b|)\right| = \int da_{\tau} \int db_{\tau}\, u_{\tau}(a_{\tau},b_{\tau}) \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad \int da_0 \int db_0\, p(0,\tilde{a}_0,\tilde{b}_0;{\tau},a_{\tau},b_{\tau}) \ln(1/|\tilde{b}_0|) \nonumber\\ &&\le \int da_{\tau} \int db_{\tau}\, \ln(1/|b_{\tau}|) u_{\tau}(a_{\tau},b_{\tau}) = O(\ln(1/|b_{\tau}|)b_{\tau}^{-1}) \nonumber\\ \label{eq:4.43} \end{eqnarray} by the log-estimate (\ref{eq:log-estimate}). So much for the contribution of $U^0_{transport}$ to (2), which we have shown to be overall $O((b_{\tau}^{-3})^2)=O(b_{\tau}^{-6})$, and even $O((\ln(1+1/b_{\tau})/b_{\tau})^2)$ for $T$ small enough, as in \cite{Isr}. \bigskip\noindent We now use the second-order expansion of the Green kernel (\ref{eq:2Nd-Green-function-expansion}). The {\em second term} in the expansion, \BEQ v(a,b):= \int_t^{\tau} ds\, U_{transport}^1(t,s) {\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0}(s) U_{transport}^0(s,\tau) h_{\tau}(a,b) \EEQ leads to a development similar to (\ref{eq:(2)}): \begin{eqnarray} &&\int_0^{\tau} dt\, |\langle X_t^N, ({\cal C}^0 v_t)''\rangle| \nonumber\\ &&\qquad \le \int_0^{\tau} dt\, \left| \langle X_t^N, \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, b^2 |({\mathfrak{f}}_z)''(x)|\int_t^{\tau} ds (U^1_{transport}(t,s)|{\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0}(s) u_s|)(a,b)\rangle \right| \nonumber\\ && \qquad \le 2 \int_0^{\tau} ds \left[ \int_0^s dt \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, |\Im (M_t^N+M_t)(z)| \tilde{u}^s_t(a,b) \right] \nonumber\\ &&\qquad = -2 \int_0^{\tau} ds \left[ \int_0^s dt \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \partial_b\left[ \Im (M_t^N+M_t)(z) \tilde{u}^s_t(a,b) \right] b \right] + {\mathrm{bdry}}'_1 \nonumber\\ \label{eq:(2)bis}\end{eqnarray} where $\tilde{u}^s_t(a,b):=\tilde{U}^1_{transport}(t,s) (|{\cal H}^{1,0}_{nonlocal}(s)u_s|)(a,b)$ $(\ge 0)$, which we compare to \begin{eqnarray} && \int_0^{\tau} ds \left[ \frac{8}{\beta}\int_{-3R}^{3R} da\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (\tilde{u}_s^s(a,b)-\tilde{u}_0^s(a,b)) b \right] \nonumber\\ && \qquad \equiv \int_0^{\tau} ds \left[ \frac{8}{\beta}\int_0^s dt\, \frac{d}{dt} \left( \int_{-3R}^{3R} da\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \tilde{u}_t^s(a,b) b \right) \right]. \label{eq:8/beta1bis} \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} The right-hand side in (\ref{eq:8/beta1bis}) decomposes in the same way as explained below (\ref{eq:4.24}) -- but with $\kappa=1$ now --. Compared to the main term studied in the previous two pages, $\ln(b)$ has been replaced with $b$ (which may simply be bounded by a constant, $b\le \half$), so logarithms disappear in the estimates, while the replacement of $u_s$ by $|{\cal H}^{1,0}_{nonlocal}(s)u_s|$ produces the supplementary factor $|||{\cal H}^{1,0}_{nonlocal}(s)|||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})} =O(1)$. The total contribution to (2) is therefore $O(b_{\tau}^{-6})$ or even $O((\ln(1+1/b)/b)^2)$ as for the main term. \medskip\noindent The {\em last} term in the Green kernel expansion, \BEQ w(a,b):= \int_t^{\tau} ds \int_t^s ds'\, U^2(t,s'){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{2,1}(s') U_{transport}^1(s,'s){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0}(s)U_{transport}^0(s,{\tau})h_{\tau}(a,b),\EEQ leads now to a third contribution which is bounded in a very simple way, \begin{eqnarray} &&\int_0^{\tau} dt\, \Big| \langle X_t^N, ({\cal C}^0 w_t)''\rangle \Big| \le \int_0^{\tau} dt\, \left| \langle X_t^N, \int_{-3R}^{3R} da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, |b|^3 |( {\mathfrak{f}}_z)''(x)| \right. \nonumber\\ && \qquad\qquad\qquad \left. \int_t^{\tau} ds \int_t^s ds'\, \left|U^2(t,s'){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{2,1}(s') (U^1_{transport}(s',s){\cal H}_{nonlocal}^{1,0}(s) u_s)(a,b)\right| \big{\rangle} \right| \label{eq:4.41} \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} Since $|b|^3 |({\mathfrak{f}}_z)''(x)|=O(1)$, (\ref{eq:4.41}) is simply bounded in the end for arbitrary $T$ by\\ $||u_{\tau}||_{(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})}=O(|b_{\tau}^{-3}|)$, times the product of the $(L^1\cap L^{\infty})(\Pi_{b_{max}})$- operator norms $|||U^i_{transport}(\cdot,\cdot)|||, |||{\cal H}^{i+1,i}_{nonlocal}(\cdot)|||$ ($i=0,1$) figuring in the integral, yielding once again a total contribution $O(b_{\tau}^{-6})$, or (for $T$ short enough) $O((\ln(1+1/b)/b)^2)$ to (2). \vskip 2cm \bigskip\noindent We finally proceed to bound the "martingale term" (3). \medskip\noindent A caveat is required here: for finite $N$, $f_t(\cdot)$ is {\em not} ${\cal F}_t$-measurable, since it is obtained by integrating the ordinary differential equation with {\em random coefficients} (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}) {\em backwards} from time $\tau$ to time $t$. Hence \BEQ {\mathbb{E}} \Big[ \Big(\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N I_i(\tau)\Big)^2\Big], \qquad I_i(\tau):=\int_0^{\tau} dt \, f'_t(\lambda_t^i) dW_t^i \label{eq:Ii} \EEQ {\em cannot} be bounded by ${\mathbb{E}} \int_0^{\tau} dt\, (f'_t(\lambda_t^i))^2 $ using standard tools of stochastic calculus. By the way, this points out to a mistake in the proof of the estimate for ${\mathbb{E}}[|N(M_T^N(z)-M_T(z))|^2]$ given in Proposition 1 of Israelsson's article. Our arguments below yield a bound in $O(1/b^{12})$ independently of $V$ -- in particular in the harmonic case, instead of the bound in $O((\ln(1+1/b)/b)^2)$ found by Israelsson. See remark at the end of this section for some after-thoughts. \medskip\noindent The correct way to cope with the stochastic integral $I_i(\tau)$ (\ref{eq:Ii}) is the following. Since $s\mapsto f'_s(\lambda)$ is $C^1$ for $\lambda$ {\em fixed}, it can be considered as the {\em non-adapted} finite variation part of a semi-martingale, in the extended definition briefly mentioned below Definition (1.17) of \cite{RY}, Chapter 4. Hence the integration-by-parts lemma of standard differential calculus holds, and we can rewrite $I_i(\tau)$ as $\int_0^{\tau} ds\, f'_0(\lambda_s^i) dW_s^i -\int_0^{\tau} dt \, J_i(t)$, where \BEQ J_i(t):=\int_t^{\tau} \frac{\partial f'_t}{\partial t}(\lambda_s^i) dW_s^i.\EEQ Then, {\em considering the standard Stieltjes decomposition of $h_t$ of order $\kappa=3$ this time} (which turns out in the end of the ensuing computations to be the minimum possible order yielding finite results in the neighbourhood of the real axis), \BEQ f'_t(\lambda_s^i)= \frac{\partial}{\partial x} {\cal C}^3(h_t)(x)=\int da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} \, db\, (-\II b)\, |b|^3 ({\mathfrak{f}}_z)'(\lambda_s^i) h_t(a,b) \EEQ and \BEQ J_i(t)=\int da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, (-\II b)\, |b|^3 ({\cal H}(t) h_t)(a,b) J_i^z(t), \label{eq:Ji} \EEQ where the stochastic integral \BEQ J_i^z(t):=\int_t^{\tau} ( {\mathfrak{f}}_z)'(\lambda_s^i) dW_s^i \EEQ is now a standard (i.e. non-anticipative) It\^o integral, whence (using primed integration variables $t',a',b'$ for $I_{i'}(\tau)$ in the averaged squared quantity ${\mathbb{E}}\Big[ (\int_0^{\tau} dt\, \sum_i J_i(t)) (\int_0^{\tau} dt'\, \sum_{i'} J_{i'}(t')) \Big]$) \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}[ J_i^z(t) J_j^{z'}(t')]=\delta_{i,j} \int_{\max(t,t')}^{\tau} ds\, ( {\mathfrak{f}}_z)'(\lambda_s^i) ( {\mathfrak{f}}_{z'})'(\lambda_s^i) . \label{eq:JJ} \EEQ \medskip\noindent The first step consists in transferring to the $\mathfrak{f}'_z$-factors the derivatives $\partial_a,\partial_b$ coming from the action of ${\cal H}_{transport}(t)$ on $h_t$. We concentrate on the most singular terms coming from ${\cal H}_0^{\kappa}(t)$, namely, $({\cal H}_0^{\kappa}(t)h_t)(a,b)= \frac{\beta}{4} \Big[ \partial_a (\Re (M_t+M_t^N)(z))h(t;a,b)) + \partial_b (\Im (M_t+M_t^N)(z))h(t;a,b)) \Big]+\cdots$, where the missing order 0 part $(\cdots)$ is as in (\ref{eq:H0}). Integrating these two terms w.r. to the measure $\int da\, db\, (-\II b) |b|^3 \, {\mathfrak{f}}'_z(\lambda_s^i)$ yields by integration by parts $-\frac{\beta}{4} \int da\, (-\II db)\, h_t(a,b) \Big( \pm b^4 \Re (M_t+M_t^N)(z) {\mathfrak{f}}''_z(\lambda_s^i) \pm \II \Im(M_t+M_t^N)(z) \partial_b \Big( b^4 {\mathfrak{f}}'_z(\lambda_s^i) \Big) \Big)$. \medskip\noindent For finite $N$, ${\cal H}(t)h_t(\cdot)$ is random and not ${\cal F}_t$-measurable, hence\\ ${\mathbb{E}}\Big[ ({\cal H}(t)h_t(a,b) {\cal H}(t')h_{t'}(a',b')) (J_i^z(t) J_{i'}^{z'}(t')) \Big]$ may not directly be bounded using (\ref{eq:JJ}) (see Remark below). Instead, we use the bounds \BEQ |h_t(a,b)|,|h_{t'}(a',b')|=O(||h_{\tau}||_{L^{\infty}(\Pi_{b_{max}})})=O(b_{\tau}^{-3-\kappa})=O(b_{\tau}^{-6}) \EEQ \BEQ |b^4 \Re(M_t+M_t^N)(z)|=O(|b|^{3}) , \qquad ||{\mathfrak{f}}''_z||_{\infty}\le |b|^{-3} \EEQ and \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathbb{E}} \Big| \sum_{i,i'} \int_t^{\tau} {\mathfrak{f}}''_z(\lambda_s^i) dW_s^i \ \int_{t'}^{\tau} {\mathfrak{f}}''_{z'}(\lambda_s^{i'}) dW_s^{i'} \Big| \nonumber\\ &&\le \Big[{\mathbb{E}} \Big( \sum_i \int_t^{\tau} {\mathfrak{f}}''_z(\lambda_s^i) dW_s^i \Big)^2 \Big]^{1/2} \Big[{\mathbb{E}} \Big( \sum_{i'} \int_{t'}^{\tau} {\mathfrak{f}}''_{z'}(\lambda_s^{i'}) dW_s^{i'} \Big)^2 \Big]^{1/2} \nonumber\\ &&= \Big[ \sum_i {\mathbb{E}} \int_t^{\tau} ds\, |{\mathfrak{f}}''_z(\lambda_s^i)|^2 \Big]^{1/2} \Big[\sum_{i'} {\mathbb{E}} \int_{t'}^{\tau}ds\, |{\mathfrak{f}}''_{z'}(\lambda_s^{i'}|^2 \Big]^{1/2} \nonumber\\ &&\le \half {\mathbb{E}}\Big[ \left(\frac{b}{b'}\right)^3 \sum_i \int_t^{\tau} ds\, |{\mathfrak{f}}''_z(\lambda_s^i)|^2 + \left(\frac{b'}{b}\right)^3 \sum_i \int_{t'}^{\tau} ds\, |{\mathfrak{f}}''_{z'}(\lambda_s^i)|^2 \Big] \nonumber\\ &&= \frac{N}{2} {\mathbb{E}}\Big[ \left(\frac{b}{b'}\right)^3 \int_t^{\tau} ds\, \langle X_s^N,({\mathfrak{f}}''_z)^2\rangle + \left(\frac{b'}{b}\right)^3 \int_t^{\tau} ds\, \langle X_s^N,({\mathfrak{f}}''_{z'})^2\rangle \Big] \nonumber\\ &&= O(N (|bb'|)^{-3}) \end{eqnarray} Considering instead the terms of the type $4b^3 {\mathfrak{f}}'_z(\lambda_s^i)$ coming from $\partial_b(b^4 {\mathfrak{f}}'_z(\lambda_s^i))$, or those coming from the missing order 0 part $(\cdots)$ above, leads to the same scaling in $b,b'$ when $b,b'\to 0$, as can easily be seen, while terms coming from the bounded operator ${\cal H}_{nonlocal}$ or from the time $0$ contribution $\int_0^{\tau} ds\, f'_0(\lambda^i_s)dW^i_s$ are less singular. Thus we finally find, as expected: \BEQ {\mathbb{E}} \Big[ \Big(\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N I_i(\tau)\Big)^2\Big] \le \Big(\int_{-3R}^{3R} da\, \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, O(b_{\tau}^{-6}) \Big)^2 = O(b_{\tau}^{-12}), \label{eq:poor-estimates} \EEQ plus an $O(1)$-contribution coming from $({\cal H}(t)h_t)_{ext}$. \hfill \eop \bigskip\noindent {\bf Remark.} Israelsson's bounds in $O((\ln(1+1/b)/b)^2)$ are recovered if one (somewhat carelessly and out of the blue!) {\em replaces} $f_t$, solution of the finite-N evolution equation (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f}), with the {\em deterministic} solution $f^{\infty}_t$ of the asymptotic evolution equation (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f-asymptotic}). Namely, in that case, It\^o's formula applies, see (\ref{eq:Ii}). Using $|({\mathfrak{f}}_z)'(x)|\le \frac{1}{|b|} \frac{1}{|x-z|}$ and (\ref{eq:Im-rho-infty}), we get, letting $f^{\infty}_t={\cal C}^0 (h^{\infty}_t)$ and $I_i^{\infty}(\tau):=\int_0^{\tau} dt\, (f_t^{\infty})'(\lambda_t^i) dW_t^i$ : \begin{eqnarray} && {\mathbb{E}} \Big[ \Big(\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} \sum_{i=1}^N I_i^{\infty} (\tau)\Big)^2\Big]= \int_0^{\tau} dt |\langle X_t^N, (({\cal C}^0 h^{\infty}_t)')^2\rangle| dt \nonumber\\ &&\le \int_0^{\tau} dt \, \int da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \ \cdot\ \int da'\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db'\, |h_t(a,b)| |h_t(a',b')|\ |\langle X_t^N, |b f'_z(\cdot)|\ |b'f'_{z'}|(\cdot)\rangle | \nonumber\\ &&\le \int_0^{\tau} dt \, \int da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \ \cdot\ \int da'\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db'\, |h_t(a,b)| |h_t(a',b')| \langle X_t^N, b^2 |(f'_z(\cdot))|^2\rangle \nonumber\\ &&\le \sup_{0\le t\le {\tau}} \left( \int da'\int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db'\, |h_t(a',b')|\right) \ \cdot\ \int_0^{\tau} dt\, \left( \int da \int_{-b_{max}}^{b_{max}} db\, \frac{1}{b} \Im M_t^N(z) |h_t(a,b)| \right) . \nonumber\\ \label{eq:4.23} \end{eqnarray} The second factor in (\ref{eq:4.23}) is bounded exactly like the drift term (2), while the first one is just $||h_t||_{L^1(\Pi_{b_{max}})}$. All together, $I^{\infty}(\tau)$ is bounded by $ O(b_{\tau}^{-6})$, or even by $O(\ln(1+1/b_{\tau})/b_{\tau}^2)$ for $T$ small enough. \medskip\noindent A way to improve our poor estimates (\ref{eq:poor-estimates}) would be to separate $h_t$ into $h_t^{\infty}$ plus a $O(1/N)$ fluctuation $\delta h_t^{\infty}$, whose contribution to (\ref{eq:4.14bis}) would be hopefully $O(1/N)$ times some inverse power of $b$, and would therefore vanish when $N\to\infty$. However, the time-evolution of $\delta h_t^{\infty}$ is a priori governed by the Jacobian of (\ref{eq:intro-PDE-f-asymptotic}) around $h_t^{\infty}$, whose characteristics are obtained by linearizing those of the transport operator ${\cal H}_{transport}$. Alas, the linearization of the already singular characteristics of ${\cal H}_0$, see Proposition \ref{prop:Israelsson}, leads to an exponential factor of the type $\exp\Big(c\int dt\, ((M_t^N)''(Z_t)+(M''_t(Z_t)) \Big)$, which is exponentially large for small $|b|$ near the points $x$ of the real axis at which $M_t(x\pm\II 0)$ is not differentiable, e.g. near the end points of the support for a standard density of the semi-circle type $\frac{1}{\pi} \sqrt{2-x^2}$ ($a>0$), with associated Stieltjes transform $M_t(z)=-z+\sqrt{z^2-2}$, see (\ref{eq:cut-eq2}). \section{Large deviation bound for the support of the measure} \label{sec:entropy} As a key technical argument required for the convergence of our scheme, we prove in this section the following bound for the probability that the support of the measure is large. Since the number $N$ of eigenvalues varies in this section, we emphasize the $N$-dependence of the process when we judge it necessary by writing $\lambda_t^{N,i}$ instead of $\lambda_t^i$. \begin{Lemma}[large deviation bound] \label{lem:support} Assume the large deviation estimate (\ref{eq:support-bound0}) for the initial support holds, namely, ${\mathbb{P}}[ \max_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\lambda_0^{N,i}| > R_0] \le C_0 e^{-c_0 N} $ for some constants $R_0,c_0,C_0>0$. Let $T>0$. There exists some radius $R=R(T)$ and constant $c$, depending on $V$ and $R_0,c_0$ but uniform in $N$, such that \BEQ {\mathbb{P}}\left[ \sup_{0\le t\le T} \sup_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\lambda_t^{N,i}| > R\right] \le C e^{-cN}. \EEQ \end{Lemma} \noindent The principle of the proof was obligingly provided by a referee. It relies on uniform-in-time moment bounds for the empirical measure, and on a comparison principle for sde's. \medskip\noindent First, we use as an input moment bounds proved {\em in the case $V=0$} by induction on $p=1,2,\ldots,\eps N$ in Anderson-Guionnet-Zeitouni \cite{And}. Let $(\tilde{\lambda}_t^{N,i})_{t\ge 0}, i=1,\ldots,N$ be the solution of the modified system of coupled stochastic differential equations with {\em zero potential}, \BEQ d\tilde{\lambda}_t^{N,i}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{N}} dW_t^i+ \frac{\beta}{2N} \sum_{j\not=i} \frac{dt}{\tilde{\lambda}^{N,i}_t-\tilde{\lambda}^{N,j}_t}, \qquad i=1,\ldots,N \label{eq:SDE0} \EEQ with initial condition $\tilde{\lambda}^{N,i}_0\equiv \lambda^{N,i}_0$ coinciding with that of (\ref{eq:SDE}), and $\tilde{X}_t^N:=\frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^N \delta_{\tilde{\lambda}^{N,i}_t}$ be the corresponding random point process. Under $\Omega_0 : \left( \max_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\lambda_0^{N,i}| \le R_0 \right)$, an event of proability $1-C_0 e^{-c_0 N}$, eq. (4.3.45) in \cite{And} holds, namely, \BEQ {\mathbb{E}}\left[ {\bf 1}_{\Omega_0}\ \sup_{0\le t\le T} \int \tilde{X}^N_t(dx)\, |x|^p \right] \le R_1(T)^p. \EEQ (An explicit expression for the constants $\eps$ and $R_1(T)$, depending on $R_0$, can be obtained by following computations on p. 274, as a consequence of Lemma 4.3.17.) The above bound implies ${\mathbb{E}}\left[{\bf 1}_{\Omega_0}\ \sup_{0\le t\le T} \sup_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\tilde{\lambda}_t^{N,i}|^p\right]\le N R_1(T)^p$ and then (by Markov's inequality), letting $R_2(t):=eR_1(t)$, \BEQ {\mathbb{P}}[{\bf 1}_{\Omega_0}\ \sup_{0\le t\le T} \sup_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\tilde{\lambda}_t^{N,i}|> R_2(T)]\le Ne^{-\eps N}. \label{eq:LDB-R2} \EEQ \medskip\noindent Then, one compares the two eigenvalue processes $(\lambda^i_t)_{0\le t\le T}$ and $(\bar{\lambda}^i_t)_{0\le t\le T}$, adapting the argument given in \cite{And}, Lemma 4.3.6. Let $E_t^{N,i}:=\lambda^{N,i}_t- \bar{\lambda}^{N,i}_t-\alpha t$ $(\alpha >0)$. Subtracting the sde's for the two processes, one gets \BEQ \frac{dE_t^{N,i}}{dt}=-\frac{\beta}{2N} \sum_{j\not=i} \frac{E_t^{N,i}-E_t^{N,j}}{(\lambda^{N,i}_t-\lambda^{N,j}_t)(\bar{\lambda}^{N,i}_t-\bar{\lambda}^{N,j}_t)} - (V'(\lambda^{N,i}_t)- V'(\bar{\lambda}^{N,i}_t)) - V'(\bar{\lambda}^{N,i}_t)-\alpha . \label{eq:LDB-E} \EEQ Whatever the ordering chosen for the eigenvalues, the denominator in (\ref{eq:LDB-E}) is always $>0$ because eigenvalues never cross. We assume that the event $\Omega: \left( \max_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\lambda_0^{N,i}| \le R_0 \right) \cap \left(\sup_{0\le t\le T} \sup_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\bar{\lambda}_t^{N,i}|\le R_2(T) \right)$ is realized, an event of probability $1- e^{-c_1 N}$; then $|V'(\bar{\lambda}^{N,i}_t)|$ is bounded uniformly in $N$, $i$, and $t\le T$ by some constant $C_2$ depending on $V$; we assume $\alpha>C_2$. Initially, $E_0^{N,i}\le R_0+R_2(T)$, $i=1,\ldots,N$ by construction. {\em Assume} that there exists some $t<T$ and $i$ such that $E_t^{N,i}\ge R_3(T):=R_0+R_2(T)+1$, and let $t_{min}>0$ be the first time at which one such inequality holds, so that $E_{t_{min}}^{N,i}=R_3(T)$ for some $i$, while $E_t^{N,j}<R_3(T)$ for $t<t_{min}$ and $j=1,\ldots,N$. But then $E_{t_{min}}^{N,i}-E_{t_{min}}^{N,j}\ge 0$ for all $j\not=i$, and (by convexity of $V$) $V'(\lambda_{t_{min}}^{N,i})- V'(\bar{\lambda}_{t_{min}}^{N,i})\ge 0$. Hence $\frac{dE_{t_{min}}^{N,i}}{dt}<0$: a contradiction. Reversing the signs of the inequalities, one proves similarly that $\tilde{\lambda}_t^{N,i}-\lambda_t^{N,i}-\alpha t\le R_3(T)$. Concluding: with high probability, $\sup_{0\le t\le T} \sup_{i=1,\ldots,N} |\lambda_t^{N,i}|\le R_0+2R_2(T)+ C_2 T+1$. \hfill \eop \section{Appendix. Generalized transport operators} \label{sec:transport} Many operators in this article are of the following type, \BEQ {\cal H}_tf(x)=\sum_k v_k(t,x)\partial_{x_k}f(x)+ \tau(t,x) f(x) \EEQ with $f:\Omega\to \mathbb{R}$, where $\Omega$ is a domain in $\mathbb{R}^d$ (in practice, we need only consider $\Omega=\Pi^{\pm}$), and $\vec{v}(t,\cdot)$ a vector field, resp. $\tau(t,\cdot)$ a function, on $\Omega$. Let us call such operators {\em generalized transport operators}. It is well-known how to solve PDEs generated by generalized transport operators, i.e. of the type \BEQ \frac{\partial f_t}{\partial t}(x)={\cal H}_t f_t(x) \label{eq:transport-PDE} \EEQ with terminal condition $f_T\equiv f$. Namely, let $y_t\equiv \Phi_t^T(y)$ (called: {\em characteristics of (\ref{eq:transport-PDE})}) be the solution of the ode $\frac{dy_t}{dt}=\vec{v}(t,y_t)$ with terminal condition $y_T=y$. One checks immediately that \BEQ f_t(y)=c_t f(\Phi_t^T(y)), \qquad c_t:=\exp\left(-\int_t^T \tau(y_s)\, ds\right) \EEQ is a solution. In particular, ${\mathrm{supp}}(f_t), t\le T$ is the inverse image of ${\mathrm{supp}}(f)$ by $\Phi_t^T$; so, if $\vec{v}\big|_{\partial\Omega}$ is {\em inward on the boundary of some domain $\Omega$ containing the support of $f_T$, then ${\mathrm{supp}}(f_T)\subset\Omega$ for all $t\le T$.} In the article we actually refer either to the basis trajectory $y_{\cdot}=a_{\cdot}+\II b_{\cdot}$ or to the "extended" trajectory $(a_{\cdot}+\II b_{\cdot},c_{\cdot})$ as characteristics. \medskip The {\em Jacobian} of the ode, $J_t:=\frac{dy_t}{dy}$, solves the linearized ode $\frac{dJ_t}{dt}=\nabla \vec{v}(t,y_t)J_t$ with terminal condition $J_T={\mathrm{Id}}$. In particular (letting $|\, \cdot\, |$ denote the determinant), $\frac{d}{dt}\big|_{t=T} |J_t|={\mathrm{Tr}} (\nabla \vec{v}(T,y))=\nabla\cdot \vec{v}(T,y).$ The time-variation of the $L^1$-norm of $f_t$ is \begin{eqnarray} \frac{d}{dt}\big|_{t=T} \int dy\, |f_t(y)| &=& \int dy\, \left(\Re \frac{d}{dt} c_t(y) \right)|f(y)| - \int dy\, \left(\frac{d}{dt}\big|_{t=T} |J_t|\right) |f(y)| \nonumber\\ &=& \int dy \left(\Re \tau(T,y)-{\mathrm{Tr}} (\nabla \vec{v}(T,y))\right) |f(y)|; \label{eq:time-variation-L1-norm} \end{eqnarray} it vanishes when $\Re c={\mathrm{Tr}} (\nabla \vec{v})$, in particular when \BEQ {\cal H}_t=\left( \sum_k v_k(t,x)\partial_{x_k}\right)^{\dagger}=-\sum_k v_k(t,x)\partial_{x_k}-\nabla\cdot \vec{v}(t,x) \EEQ is in {\em divergence form}, i.e. is the {\em adjoint} of a transport operator. Thus ${\cal H}_t$ is the generator of a strongly continuous semi-group of contractions of $L^1(\mathbb{R})$, see e.g. \cite{Paz}, chapter 1. The latter observation extends to the case when ${\cal H}_t=\left( \sum_k v_k(t,x)\partial_{x_k}\right)^{\dagger} - \tau(t,x) $ with $\tau(t,\cdot)\le 0$, in the sense that $\int dy\, |f_t(y)|\le \int dy\, |f_T(y)|$ for $0\le t\le T$. \bigskip \section{Appendix. Stieltjes transforms} \label{sec:Stieltjes} We collect in this section some definitions and elementary properties concerning Stieltjes transforms. We make use of the Fourier transform normalized as follows, \BEQ {\cal F}(f)(s)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} f(x) e^{-\II xs}\, dx \label{Fourier} \EEQ with inverse ${\cal F}^{-1}(g)(x)=\frac{1}{2\pi} \int g(s) e^{\II xs}\, ds$. \medskip \noindent Let, for $z=a+\II b\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\mathbb{R}$ \BEQ {\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)=\frac{1}{x-z}, \qquad x\in\mathbb{R}.\EEQ For fixed $b\not=0$, ${\mathfrak{f}}_z(x)$ may be seen as a convolution kernel $K_b$, \BEQ K_b(x-a)=\frac{1}{(x-a)-\II b}. \EEQ Note that \BEQ \Im({\mathfrak{f}}_z)(x)=\frac{b}{|x-z|^2}=\frac{b}{(x-a)^2+b^2}, \qquad \Re({\mathfrak{f}}_z)(x)=\frac{x-a}{(x-a)^2+b^2}. \label{eq:8.4} \EEQ In particular, \BEQ \Im({\mathfrak{f}}_z)(x)\ge 0 \qquad (b>0). \label{eq:Im-fz>0} \EEQ Many estimates are based on the simple remark that \BEQ \int \frac{b}{(x-a)^2+b^2} \, dx=\pi \qquad (b>0) \EEQ is a constant. The Plemelj formula, \BEQ \frac{1}{x-\II 0}=p.v.\left(\frac{1}{x}\right)+\II \pi \delta_0 \EEQ implies the following boundary value equations for $K_b$, \BEQ \lim_{b\to 0^+} \int dy\, K_b(x-y) \phi(y) \ -\ \lim_{b\to 0^-} \int dy\, K_b(x-y) \phi(y)= 2\II \pi \phi(x) \label{eq:bv-} \EEQ \BEQ \lim_{b\to 0^+} \int dy\, K_b(x-y) \phi(y) \ +\ \lim_{b\to 0^-} \int dy\, K_b(x-y) \phi(y)= 2\ p.v.\ \int \frac{dy}{x-y} \phi(y) \label{eq:bv+} \EEQ \medskip \noindent Then: \BEQ {\cal F} {\mathfrak{f}}_z(s)=2\II\pi e^{-b|s|-\II as} {\bf 1}_{s<0} \qquad (b>0), \qquad -2\II\pi e^{b|s|-\II as} {\bf 1}_{s>0} \qquad (b<0) \label{eq:8.10} \EEQ hence (for $b>0$) \BEQ {\cal F}(\Im({\mathfrak{f}}_z))(s)=\pi e^{-b|s|-\II as}, \qquad {\cal F}(\Re({\mathfrak{f}}_z))=-\II\pi \ {\mathrm{sgn}}(s) e^{-b|s|-\II as}. \label{eq:8.11} \EEQ \bigskip \noindent{\bf Properties of the Stieltjes transform of $\rho_t$.} \bigskip \noindent Let $M_t(z):=\langle X_t,{\mathfrak{f}}_z\rangle$ ($b:=\Im z>0$). Then: \BEQ \Im(M_t(z))=\langle X_t,\frac{b}{(x-a)^2+b^2}\rangle; \label{eq:Im-rho-infty} \EEQ \BEQ |M_t(z)|=|\langle X_t,\frac{1}{(x-a)-\II b} \rangle|\le 1/b; \label{eq:1st-bound-Mt} \EEQ \BEQ |M'_t(z)|=|\langle X_t,\frac{1}{((x-a)-\II b)^2}\rangle| \le \frac{1}{b} \langle X_t,\frac{b}{(x-a)^2+b^2}\rangle =\frac{1}{b} \Im(M_t(z)). \label{eq:M'M} \EEQ When $|a|\gg R$, we get much better estimates, e.g. \BEQ |M_t(z)|\le 2/|a|, \qquad |a|\ge 2R. \label{eq:2Nd-bound-Mt} \EEQ On the other hand, if $b\to 0$ and $a\in {\mathrm{supp}}(X_t)$, then $M_t(z)$ may diverge in general. In particular, \BEQ |\Re (M_t(z))|\le C||\rho_t||_{\infty} \ln(R/b) \qquad (b\le \frac{R}{2}, |a|\le 2R), \label{eq:log-bound} \EEQ However, if $\rho_t$ is bounded then $\Im( M_t(z)) \in [0,\pi||\rho_t||_{\infty}]$; and $\Re( M_t(z))=O(1)$ if the space derivative of the density, $\rho'_t$, is bounded. \bigskip \noindent{\bf Some distributions.} \medskip\noindent Let $\phi\in C_c^{\infty}$ be a smooth function supported on $[-r,r]$, and $b>0$. Let \BEQ \langle {\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b},\phi\rangle:=\int dy\, \frac{\phi(y)}{y-\II b} \EEQ Then \BEQ \langle {\mathfrak{f}}_{\II b},\phi\rangle=\phi(0) \int_{-r}^r \frac{dy}{y-\II b} + \II \int_{-r}^r dy\, (\phi(y)-\phi(0)) \frac{b}{y^2+|b_T|^2} + \int_{-r}^r dy\, \frac{y(\phi(y)-\phi(0))}{y^2+b^2} \EEQ is $O(||\phi||_{\infty}+r||\phi'||_{\infty})$ since: $|\int_{-r}^r \frac{dy}{y-\II b}|\le \int dy\, \frac{b}{y^2+b^2}=O(1)$, and $|\frac{y(\phi(y)-\phi(0))}{y^2+b^2}|\le ||\phi'||_{\infty}$. Hence (as seen by integration by parts), $y\mapsto (y-\II b)^{-n}$ ($n\ge 1$) is a distribution of order $n$, namely, \BEQ \left|\int dy \frac{\phi(y)}{(y-\II b)^n} \right|=O(||\phi^{(n-1)}||_{\infty}+ r||\phi^{(n)}||_{\infty}). \label{eq:phi-ib-n} \EEQ \bigskip \noindent {\bf The $\left(\frac{1}{x}\right)$-kernel and its family.} \medskip\noindent It is known that \BEQ {\cal F}^{-1}(s\mapsto {\mathrm{sgn}}(s){\cal F}f(s))(x)=\II Hf(x):=\frac{\II}{\pi} p.v. \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} \frac{1}{x-y} f(y)\, dy \label{eq:C1} \EEQ defined for a compactly supported $f\in C^1$ either as $\frac{\II}{\pi} \lim_{\eps\to 0^+} \int_{|x-y|>\eps} \frac{1}{x-y}f(y)\, dy$ or as $\frac{\II}{\pi} \int \frac{f(y)-f(x)}{x-y} \, dy$, from which by differentiating \BEQ {\cal F}^{-1}(s\mapsto |s|{\cal F}f(s))(x)=-\frac{1}{\pi} p.v. \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} \frac{1}{(x-y)^2} f(y)\, dy \label{eq:C2} \EEQ For a function $f$ supported on $[-R,R]$, we have the following bounds: \begin{eqnarray} \left|p.v. \int \frac{1}{x-y}f(y)\, dy\right| &=& {\bf 1}_{|x|\le 2R} \left| \int_{x-3R}^{x+3R} \frac{f(y)-f(x)}{x-y}\, dy \right| + {\bf 1}_{|x|> 2R} \left| \int_{-R}^R \frac{f(y)}{x-y}\, dy\right| \nonumber\\ &=& {\bf 1}_{|x|\le 2R}\ O(R||f'||_{\infty}) + {\bf 1}_{|x|>2R}\ O(||f||_{\infty} R/|x|), \label{eq:bound-vp} \end{eqnarray} and similarly \begin{eqnarray} \left|p.v. \int \frac{1}{(x-y)^2}f(y)\, dy\right| &=& {\bf 1}_{|x|\le 2R} \left| \int_{x-3R}^{x+3R} \frac{f'(y)-f'(x)}{x-y}\, dy \right| + {\bf 1}_{|x|> 2R} \left| \int_{-R}^R \frac{f(y)}{(x-y)^2}\, dy\right| \nonumber\\ &=& {\bf 1}_{|x|\le 2R}\ O(R||f''||_{\infty}) + {\bf 1}_{|x|>2R}\ O(||f||_{\infty}R/x^2). \label{eq:bound-vp2} \end{eqnarray} \bigskip \noindent { \bf {\em Acknowledgements.}} The author had the opportunity and the pleasure to discuss this project at several occasions and places with N. Simm (Univ. of Warwick), to whom he therefore wishes to express his gratitude. Referees helped greatly simplify section 5, pointed out the difficulty with the "martingale term" of section 4, and contributed to the readability of the manuscript. \bigskip

\section{Introduction} \label{sec:introduction} Currently, there is great interest in developing theory and techniques to understand and construct (rooted) \emph{phylogenetic networks}. Generally speaking, for a set of species, such a network consists of a rooted, directed acyclic graph and a bijective map from the species to the set of sinks of the graph (in case the graph is a tree, the network is called a (rooted) \emph{phylogenetic tree}). Phylogenetic networks are important as they can be used to represent the evolutionary history of species that cross with one another (through evolutionary processes such as hybridization and recombination). To date, much of the research on phylogenetic networks has focused on understanding the structure of special types of networks and ways to build them (see \cite{S16a} for a recent overview of the area). More recently, however, as the theory for phylogenetic networks has developed, there has been growing interest in understanding how to equip collections of phylogenetic networks with suitable metrics, giving rise to so-called \emph{network spaces}. As has been demonstrated for the intensively studied spaces of phylogenetic trees (cf. e.g. \cite{BHV01,GD16}, and the review \cite{st2017shape}), or \emph{tree-spaces}, this point of view is valuable as it provides insights into statistical approaches to analyze and systematically compare networks. Network spaces essentially come in two types: discrete and continuous. In \emph{discrete} spaces, the elements of the space are distinct, non-isomorphic networks, and a metric is commonly given by defining the distance between two networks to be the length of a minimal sequence of local network operations that converts one network into the other. In \emph{continuous} spaces, the arcs in the networks have non-negative, real-valued lengths and one network can be converted into the other by shrinking or lengthening arcs in a continuous manner. To date, nearly all results on network spaces have concerned discrete spaces (see, for example, \cite{BSC17a,GVJ17a,JJEIS18a}, for related results on discrete spaces of unrooted networks see e.g. \cite{HMW16a}). Indeed, to the best of our knowledge, very few results have been presented on continuous network spaces except for the recently introduced spaces of (unrooted) circular split networks\footnote{Strictly speaking, these spaces should probably be thought of as ``spaces of circular split collections''.} \cite{DP17a}. This is probably in part because the study of phylogenetic networks with arc lengths is somewhat less developed than the study of those without. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{network_transformation.pdf} \caption{(a) An \(X\)-cactus for \(X = \{a,b,c,d,e,f\}\) with root~\(\rho\) that is equidistant since every directed path from~\(\rho\) to a sink has the same length, namely~\(13\). All incoming arcs at vertices with indegree~2 have length~0 and are drawn horizontally. (b) The rooted \(X\)-cactus obtained by lengthening the incoming arc and shrinking the outgoing arcs at vertex~\(v\) by~1. (c) The rooted \(X\)-cactus obtained by continuing the lengthening and shrinking of the arcs at vertex~\(v\) until both outgoing arcs have length~0, contracting the cycle below~\(v\) completely.} \label{fig:example:x:cactus:introduction} \end{figure} In this paper, we introduce a new continuous space of phylogenetic networks that can be regarded as a generalization of the \(\tau\)-\emph{space} of ultrametric trees that was introduced in \cite{GD16}. For a set~$X$ of species, our network space $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ is comprised of \emph{equidistant} \(X\)-\emph{cactuses} (see Figure~\ref{fig:example:x:cactus:introduction}(a) for an example of such a network). A rooted $X$-cactus is essentially a rooted phylogenetic network in which no two distinct cycles in the underlying graph have an arc in common. Note that if all vertices of a rooted \(X\)-cactus have indegree at most~1 the network is just a \emph{rooted phylogenetic} \(X\)-\emph{tree}. The extensively studied class of (rooted) \emph{level-1 networks} (see e.g. \cite{RV09a}) also provides examples of rooted $X$-cactuses. Assigning a non-negative real-valued length to each of the arcs in a rooted phylogenetic network, then such a network~\(\mathcal{N}\) is called \emph{equidistant} if, for any fixed vertex~\(v\) of~\(\mathcal{N}\), all directed paths from~\(v\) to any sink of~\(\mathcal{N}\) have the same length. Algorithms for constructing equidistant phylogenetic networks have been studied in, e.g.,~\cite{BT16a} and \cite{CJLY06a}. Following one of the common approaches used to construct tree-spaces, we define equidistant-cactus space $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ in terms of an \emph{orthant space} (see e.g.~\cite{MOP15a}). Basically, an orthant space is a collection of real orthants that are glued together along their boundaries and that is equipped with the metric induced by using the Euclidean metric within each orthant. That is, the distance between two points in the same orthant is the Euclidean distance between these points, and the distance between two points in different orthants is the length of a shortest path, or \emph{geodesic path}, between these points. The length of such a path is computed by summing the Euclidean lengths of the restrictions of the path to each orthant. In particular, each pair of points in~$\mathfrak{N}(X)$ represents two equidistant \(X\)-cactuses, and moving along a geodesic path between the points continuously converts one \(X\)-cactus into the other by shrinking and lengthening arcs (see Figure~\ref{fig:example:x:cactus:introduction}(b) and~(c)), which may also result in a change of the length of the paths from the root to the sinks. Note that the points of \(\tau\)-space correspond bijectively to equidistant $X$-trees and that it can be constructed by gluing together orthants indexed by \emph{ranked phylogenetic trees}. We take a similar approach to define $\mathfrak{N}(X)$, indexing orthants instead by \emph{ranked} \(X\)-\emph{cactuses}, in which a ranking of the vertices that respects the direction of the arcs in the rooted \(X\)-cactus is given. We remark that ranked phylogenetic networks have been recently introduced and that research has focused on counting and enumerating certain classes of such networks (see e.g. \cite{BLS20a,CFY21a} and the references therein). A critical aspect that influenced our construction of $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ was that -- as has been shown for \(\tau\)-space \cite{GD16} -- we wanted it to be a \emph{\text{CAT}(0)-metric space}. Being \text{CAT}(0) is an important geometrical property that has been exploited in various applications within phylogenetics and beyond (see e.g. \cite{AM20a}). A space being \text{CAT}(0) immediately implies that there is a \emph{unique} geodesic path between any two points, a property that underpins many useful computations that can be performed for tree- and orthant-spaces. More specifically, approximations of the median as well as of the Fr\'echet mean and variance can be computed in complete \text{CAT}(0)-metric spaces, which include \text{CAT}(0)-orthant spaces \cite{MOP15a,bacak2014computing}; a central limit theorem holds for \text{CAT}(0)-orthant spaces \cite{barden2018logarithm}; and methods for computing confidence sets \cite{willis2019confidence} and an analogue of partial principal component analysis \cite{nye2017principal,nye2014algorithm} can be directly extended from the unrooted tree space presented in \cite{BHV01} to \text{CAT}(0)-orthant spaces. Most of this paper is devoted to proving a crucial combinatorial result concerning rooted $X$-cactuses (Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1}) which implies, via a classical result of Gromov for orthant spaces, that $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ is~\text{CAT}(0). In passing, we remark that the space of networks described in~\cite{DP17a} is not a \text{CAT}(0)-metric space. The rest of this paper is structured as follows. In Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries}, we formally define rooted \(X\)-cactuses as well as some related concepts. In Section~\ref{sub:sec:rankings}, we then introduce rankings of rooted \(X\)-cactuses and equidistant $X$-cactuses, which are both defined in terms of so-called time-stamp functions. As well as characterizing when a rooted \(X\)-cactus admits a ranking of its vertices that is consistent with the direction of its arcs, we make an important observation concerning ranked $X$-cactuses (Lemma~\ref{lem:size:ranking}), which implies that the maximal chains in a certain poset mentioned in the next paragraph all have the same length, i.\,e.\, $\lvert X \rvert-1$. In Section~\ref{sec:equidistant:x:trees}, we use the simpler case of equidistant \(X\)-trees to outline our approach for the construction of a network space that is~\text{CAT}(0), including a new proof that \(\tau\)-space is~\text{CAT}(0). In Section~\ref{sec:encoding}, we describe how ranked \(X\)-cactuses give rise to \emph{set pair systems} as defined in \cite{HMS21a} and present the properties that characterize set pair systems that arise from ranked \(X\)-cactuses. We also define a binary relation on general set pair systems, and, in Section~\ref{sec:poset:p:x}, we establish that this relation yields a bounded graded poset on the set pair systems that arise from ranked \(X\)-cactuses. In Section~\ref{sec:encoding:ranked:x:network}, we establish our main combinatorial result (Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1}), namely that chains in this poset encode ranked \(X\)-cactuses. In simpler terms, this can be regarded as a ``pairwise compatibility" result for set pair systems, which is analogous to the well-known \emph{Splits Equivalence Theorem} for unrooted phylogenetic trees (see e.g. \cite[Theorem 3.1.4]{SS03a}). Using our encoding for ranked \(X\)-cactuses, in Section~\ref{sec:network:space} we construct the space $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ of equidistant $X$-cactuses and show that it is a \text{CAT}(0)-metric space. We conclude in Section~\ref{sec:conclusion} by mentioning some directions for future work. \section{Preliminaries} \label{sec:preliminaries} In this section, we define rooted $X$-cactuses and some related concepts that we use later. We begin by recalling some standard concepts from graph theory. A \emph{directed graph} \(N=(V,A)\) consists of a finite non-empty set \(V\) and a subset \(A \subseteq V \times V\). The elements of \(V\) and \(A\) are referred to as \emph{vertices} and \emph{arcs} of~\(N\), respectively. A directed graph~\(N\) is \emph{acyclic} if there is no directed cycle in~\(N\). Moreover, a directed acyclic graph (DAG) \(N\)~is \emph{rooted} if there exists a vertex \(\rho \in V\) with indegree~\(0\), called the \emph{root} of \(N\), such that for every \(u \in V\) there is a directed path from \(\rho\) to \(u\). In a rooted DAG, a \emph{leaf} is a vertex with outdegree~0, an \emph{internal vertex} is a vertex with outdegree at least~1, a \emph{tree vertex} is a vertex with indegree at most~1 and a \emph{reticulation vertex} is a vertex with indegree at least~2. Note that, by definition, the root of a rooted DAG is a tree vertex. Moreover, in a rooted DAG~\(N\), we call a vertex \(v\) a \emph{child} of a vertex \(u\) and, similarly, \(u\) a \emph{parent} of \(v\) if \((u,v)\) is an arc of~\(N\). The set of children of a vertex~\(u\) is denoted by \(ch(u)\). A \emph{reticulation cycle} \(\{P,P'\}\) in a rooted DAG consists of two distinct directed paths \(P\) and \(P'\) such that \(P\) and \(P'\) have the same start vertex and the same end vertex but no other vertices in common. Let \(X\) be a finite non-empty set. A \emph{rooted} \(X\)-\emph{cactus} \(\mathcal{N} = (N,\varphi)\) is a rooted DAG \(N=(V,A)\) together with a map \(\varphi: X \rightarrow V\) such that \begin{itemize} \setlength{\itemindent}{15pt} \item[(RC1)] all vertices of~\(N\) have indegree at most~2, \item[(RC2)] no two distinct reticulation cycles in \(N\) have an arc in common, and \item[(RC3)] the image \(\varphi(X)\) contains all leaves and all tree vertices of~\(N\) with outdegree~\(1\) of~\(N\). \end{itemize} In Figure~\ref{fig:one:nested:x:networks}(a) we give an example of a rooted \(X\)-cactus. We remark that if \(\lvert X \rvert = 1\) a rooted \(X\)-cactus consists of a single vertex only. For better readability, we will often refer to the vertices and arcs of~\(N\) as the vertices and arcs of~\(\mathcal{N}\). A rooted \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) is \emph{phylogenetic}\footnote{A phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus is also known as a rooted 2-hybrid, 1-nested phylogenetic network~\cite{RV09a}, but for simplicity we prefer to call it a rooted \(X\)-cactus since if the root and directions are ignored we obtain an unrooted $X$-cactus \cite{HHMM20a}.} if \(\varphi\) is a bijection between~\(X\) and the set of leaves of~\(\mathcal{N}\). Note that a rooted phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus may contain leaves that are reticulation vertices. A rooted \(X\)-cactus is \emph{binary} if it is phylogenetic, all leaves of~\(\mathcal{N}\) are tree vertices, the root has outdegree~2 and every other internal vertex has either indegree~1 and outdegree~2 or indegree~2 and outdegree~1. A rooted \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) is \emph{compressed} if \(\varphi(X)\) also contains all reticulation vertices with outdegree~1 (see~\cite[p.~251]{S16a} for the concept of compression in more general phylogenetic networks). Rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactuses as defined here correspond to 1-nested phylogenetic networks as defined in~\cite{HMS21a}. Note that a rooted, binary \(X\)-cactus that contains at least one reticulation vertex cannot be compressed. A rooted \(X\)-cactus without any reticulation vertices is called a \emph{rooted} \(X\)-\emph{tree}. Note that rooted \(X\)-trees as defined here are in one-to-one correspondence with the rooted \(X\)-trees as defined in~\cite{SS03a} where the root is required to have outdegree~1. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.9]{one_nested_x_networks.pdf} \caption{(a) A rooted \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) for \(X=\{a,b,c,\dots,j\}\) (b) The rooted, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus~\(\widehat{\mathcal{N}}\). (c) The rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus~\(\widehat{\mathcal{N}}^*\).} \label{fig:one:nested:x:networks} \end{figure} In Section~\ref{sec:encoding:ranked:x:network}, we will need to associate with every rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)\) a rooted, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus \(\widehat{\mathcal{N}} = ((\widehat{V},\widehat{A}),\widehat{\varphi})\) as follows: For every \(x \in X\) such that \(\varphi(x)\) is not a leaf of \(\mathcal{N}\) or such that there exists some \(y \in X \setminus \{x\}\) with \(\varphi(y) = \varphi(x)\) we add a new vertex~\(u\) to~\(V\), add the arc \((\varphi(x),u)\) to \(A\), and put \(\widehat{\varphi}(x) = u\). For all other \(x \in X\) we put \(\widehat{\varphi}(x) = \varphi(x)\). The resulting set of vertices and arcs, respectively, are denoted by \(\widehat{V}\) and \(\widehat{A}\) (see Figure~\ref{fig:one:nested:x:networks}(b)). In addition, we associate with the resulting rooted, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus \(\widehat{\mathcal{N}}\) the rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus \(\widehat{\mathcal{N}}^* = ((\widehat{V}^*,\widehat{A}^*),\widehat{\varphi}^*)\) obtained by contracting all arcs \((u,v)\) where \(u\) has outdegree~1 (see Figure~\ref{fig:one:nested:x:networks}(c)). \section{Rankings, time-stamp functions and equidistant $X$-cactuses} \label{sub:sec:rankings} In this section, we consider rankings of the vertices of rooted $X$-cactuses, which are an important part of defining equidistant-cactus space. It is convenient to start with the more general concept of time-stamp functions, which also naturally leads to the definition of equidistant $X$-cactuses. A \emph{time-stamp function} on the vertices in a rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)\) is a map \(t : V \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}\) such that \begin{itemize} \setlength{\itemindent}{15pt} \item[(TS1)] \(t(v)=0\) for all \(v \in \varphi(X)\), \item[(TS2)] \(t(u) > t(v)\) for all arcs \((u,v)\) of \(\mathcal{N}\) with \(v\) not a reticulation vertex, and \item[(TS3)] \(t(v) = t(p_1) = t(p_2)\) for all reticulation vertices \(v\) of \(\mathcal{N}\) and its two parents \(p_1\) and \(p_2\). \end{itemize} An example of a time-stamp function on the vertices of a rooted \(X\)-cactus is given in Figure~\ref{fig:equidistant:network}. Integer-valued time-stamp functions are also known as \emph{temporal labelings} (see e.g.~\cite{BSS06}). We call a rooted \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) \emph{temporal} if there exists a time-stamp function on the vertices of~\(\mathcal{N}\). Note that not every rooted \(X\)-cactus is temporal (for example, the rooted \(X\)-cactus in Figure~\ref{fig:one:nested:x:networks}(a) is not temporal because \(\varphi(X)\) contains an internal vertex that is not a parent of a reticulation vertex). The following lemma characterizes rooted \(X\)-cactuses that are temporal (see also~\cite[Theorem~3]{BSS06} for a characterization that applies to general rooted phylogenetic networks). \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.9]{equidistant_network.pdf} \caption{A rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}\) on \(X=\{a,b,c,d,e\}\) with a time-stamp function \(t\) on its vertices. For all vertices~\(v\) the value~\(t(v)\) is given by the real number to the left of the horizontal line through~\(v\). In addition, for each arc of \(\mathcal{N}\), the length of the arc induced by~\(t\) is given.} \label{fig:equidistant:network} \end{figure} \begin{lemma} A rooted \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)\) is temporal if and only if for all vertices \(u \in V\) the following properties hold: \begin{itemize} \item[(a)] If \(u \in \varphi(X)\) then either \(u\) is a leaf or a parent of a reticulation vertex that is a leaf. \item[(b)] If \(u\) has outdegree at least~2 then \(u\) is not the parent of a reticulation vertex that is a leaf. \item[(c)] If \(u\) is the parent of a reticulation vertex \(v\) in a reticulation cycle \(\{P,P'\}\) then neither of the directed paths \(P\), \(P'\) consists of the single arc \((u,v)\). \end{itemize} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} First assume that \(\mathcal{N}\) is temporal. Consider a time-stamp function \(t\) on the vertices of~\(\mathcal{N}\). Assuming that~\(\mathcal{N}\) contains a vertex~\(u\) that violates one of~(a)-(c) immediately yields a contradiction because then~\(t\) would violate at least one of~(TS1)-(TS3). Now assume that~(a)-(c) hold for all vertices of \(\mathcal{N}\). We construct a time-stamp function \(t\) on the vertices of \(\mathcal{N}\) by first putting \(t(v) = 0\) for all \(v \in \varphi(X)\). In view of~(a) and~(b), this does not violate~(TS1)-(TS3). Next, consider an internal vertex \(u\) that is not a reticulation vertex and also not the parent of a reticulation vertex. Assume that all children~\(w\) of~\(u\) have been assigned time-stamps~\(t(w)\). Then we put \(t(u) = 1 + \max_{w \in ch(u)} t(w)\). Since \(\mathcal{N}\) is acyclic this does not violate~(TS1)-(TS3). Finally, consider an internal vertex \(u\) that is a reticulation vertex. Let \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) denote the two parents of \(u\) and assume that all vertices~\(w\) in \[M = (ch(u) \cup ch(p_1) \cup ch(p_2)) \setminus \{u\}\] have been assigned time-stamps~\(t(w)\). Then we put \(t(u) = t(p_1) = t(p_2) = 1 + \max_{w \in M} t(w)\). Since \(\mathcal{N}\) is acyclic and in view of~(c) this does not violate~(TS1)-(TS3). Thus, our inductive construction yields a map \(t : V \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}\) for which~(TS1)-(TS3) hold. \end{proof} As indicated in Figure~\ref{fig:equidistant:network}, a time-stamp function \(t\) on the vertices of a rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)\) induces non-negative lengths on the arcs of~\(\mathcal{N}\) by putting the length of arc \((u,v)\) to be \(t(u)-t(v)\). With these arc lengths, all directed paths from a fixed vertex~\(u\) to a vertex \(w \in \varphi(X)\) have the same length, namely~\(t(u)\). In view of this, we call an ordered pair \((\mathcal{N},t)\) consisting of a rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) and a time-stamp function~\(t\) on the vertices of~\(\mathcal{N}\) an \emph{equidistant} \(X\)-cactus. Thus, an equidistant \(X\)-cactus can be thought of as a rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactus with specific arc lengths assigned, whereas a rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactus does not have any specific arc lengths assigned. We conclude this section by shedding some more light on the combinatorial structure of rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactuses. The \emph{size}~\(\sigma(t)\) of a time-stamp function~\(t\) on the vertices of a rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)\) is $\lvert t(V) \rvert - 1$. A \emph{ranking} of a rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)\) is a time-stamp function \(r\) on the vertices of \(\mathcal{N}\) with \(r(V) = \{0,1,2,\dots,\sigma(r)\}\). See Figure~\ref{fig:rankable:network}(a) for an example. Note that rankings as defined here are a particular type of temporal labeling and are more general than the rankings considered in~\cite{BLS20a}. The value \(r(v)\) assigned to vertex \(v\) by the ranking~\(r\) will also be referred to as the \emph{rank} of vertex~\(v\) if the ranking referred to is clear from the context. A \emph{ranked} \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N},r)\) consists of a rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) and a ranking~\(r\) of the vertices of~\(\mathcal{N}\). The following lemma gives tight bounds on the size of rankings of rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactuses (see Figure~\ref{fig:rankable:network}(b) for an example). For its proof, we will use the fact that any rooted binary \(X\)-cactus can be transformed into a rooted binary \(X\)-tree by deleting, for every reticulation vertex~\(v\), one of the arcs \((p,v)\) from a parent~\(p\) of \(v\) to \(v\) and then suppressing the two internal vertices \(v\) and \(p\). \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.9]{rankable_network.pdf} \caption{(a) A ranking of size~4 of a rooted \(X\)-cactus with \(X=\{a,b,c,\dots,j\}\). Vertices of the same rank are drawn on the same horizontal line. (b) A ranking of a rooted, binary \(X\)-cactus with \(X=\{a,b,c,d,e\}\). The ranking has size~4 which is the maximum size over all rooted, temporal \(X\)-cactuses with $\lvert X \rvert = 5$.} \label{fig:rankable:network} \end{figure} \begin{lemma} \label{lem:size:ranking} Let \((\mathcal{N},r)\) be a ranked \(X\)-cactus. Then we have \(0 \leq \sigma(r) \leq \lvert X \rvert - 1\). Moreover, \begin{itemize} \item[(a)] \(\sigma(r) = 0\) if and only if~\(\mathcal{N}\) consists of a single vertex. \item[(b)] \(\sigma(r) = \lvert X \rvert -1\) if and only if~\(\mathcal{N}\) is a rooted, binary \(X\)-cactus and \(r(u) \neq r(v)\) for all distinct vertices \(u\) and \(v\) unless \(u\) and \(v\) are both leaves of~\(\mathcal{N}\), \(u\) is a parent of a reticulation vertex~\(v\), or \(u\) and \(v\) are parents of the same reticulation vertex. \end{itemize} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By definition, \(\sigma(r) \geq 0\). Moreover, if the size of the ranking~\(r\) is precisely~0 then \(\mathcal{N}\) must consist of a single leaf~\(v\) with \(r(v) = 0\) and all elements of \(X\) are mapped by~\(\varphi\) to~\(v\). To establish the upper bound, let \(i\) and \(k\) denote the number of internal and reticulation vertices, respectively, of the ranked \(X\)-cactus~\((\mathcal{N},r)\). By definition, \(\sigma(r) \leq (i - 2k)\). Note that, for fixed~\(X\), this expression can only be maximum if~\(\mathcal{N}\) is a rooted, binary \(X\)-cactus, because otherwise we can always increase~\(i\) without increasing~\(k\). Hence, it suffices to show that for all rooted, binary \(X\)-cactuses we have \(i - 2k = \lvert X \rvert - 1\). Since, as described above, we can transform any such \(X\)-cactus into a rooted binary \(X\)-tree, we immediately obtain this equation as a consequence of the well-known fact that a rooted binary \(X\)-tree has $\lvert X \rvert - 1$ internal vertices (see e.g. \cite[Sec.~2.1]{SS03a}). \end{proof} \section{Equidistant $X$-trees and $\tau$-space} \label{sec:equidistant:x:trees} In this section, we shall briefly recall the concept of an orthant space (see e.g.~\cite[Sec.~6]{MOP15a}) and related concepts. To illustrate the basic idea for constructing our orthant space of equidistant-cactuses, we also consider the simpler case of equidistant-trees (often called ultrametric trees) and explain how the \(\tau\)-space of ultrametric trees mentioned in the introduction arises as an orthant space. This also yields an alternative proof to the one presented in \cite{GD16} for the fact that $\tau$-space is a \text{CAT}(0)-metric space. \subsection{Orthant spaces} \label{sub:sec:orthant:spaces} An ordered pair \((M,\mathcal{F})\) consisting of a family \(\mathcal{F}\) of non-empty subsets of a finite non-empty set~\(M\) is called an \emph{abstract simplicial complex} if \(A \in \mathcal{F}\) implies that all non-empty subsets of~\(A\) are also contained in~\(\mathcal{F}\). An abstract simplicial complex is a \emph{flag complex} if, for all non-empty subsets \(A \subseteq M\) such that all 2-element subsets of \(A\) are contained in \(\mathcal{F}\), we have \(A \in \mathcal{F}\). For every map \(\omega : M \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}\) we put \(\text{supp}(\omega) = \{x \in M : \omega(x) > 0\}\). The \emph{orthant space} associated with the abstract simplicial complex \((M,\mathcal{F})\) is \[\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})} = \{\omega \in \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}^M : \text{supp}(\omega) \in \mathcal{F} \cup \{\emptyset\}\}.\] A \emph{metric} \(D\) on a non-empty set~\(B\) is a map \(D : B \times B \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}\) such that \begin{itemize} \item \(D(x,y) = 0\) if and only if \(x=y\), \item \(D(x,y) = D(y,x)\), and \item \(D(x,z) \leq D(x,y) + D(y,z)\) \end{itemize} hold for all \(x,y,z \in B\). The ordered pair \((B,D)\) is called a \emph{metric space} and the elements of \(B\) are called the \emph{points} of the metric space. A metric \(D_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) on the orthant space \(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) associated with the abstract simplicial complex \((M,\mathcal{F})\) can be constructed as follows. For every \(A \in \mathcal{F}\), the set \[\mathfrak{O}(A) = \{\omega \in \mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})} : \text{supp}(\omega) \subseteq A\}\] is called an \emph{orthant} of~\(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\). For all \(\omega,\omega' \in \mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) such that there exists an orthant \(\mathfrak{O}\) of~\(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) with \(\{\omega,\omega'\} \subseteq \mathfrak{O}\) we put \[D_{(M,\mathcal{F})}(\omega,\omega') = \sqrt{\sum_{x \in M} (\omega(x) - \omega'(x))^2}.\] Then, for all \(\omega,\omega' \in \mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) such that there is no orthant \(\mathfrak{O}\) of~\(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) that contains both \(\omega\) and \(\omega'\) we consider finite \emph{segmented paths} from \(\omega\) to \(\omega'\). These are sequences \(\omega_0,\omega_1,\omega_2,\dots,\omega_k\) of elements in \(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) such that \(\omega=\omega_0\), \(\omega'=\omega_k\) and, for all \(i \in \{1,2,\dots,k\}\), there exists some orthant \(\mathfrak{O}_i\) of \(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) that contains both \(\omega_{i-1}\) and \(\omega_i\). The \emph{length} of such a segmented path is \(\sum_{i=1}^k D_{(M,\mathcal{F})}(\omega_{i-1},\omega_{i})\). Note that at least one such segmented path always exists in view of the fact that all orthants of~\(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\) contain the point \(\omega\) with \(\text{supp}(\omega) = \emptyset\), called the \emph{origin} of~\(\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})}\). We define \(D_{(M,\mathcal{F})}(\omega,\omega')\) to be the infimum of the length of all segmented paths from~\(\omega\) to~\(\omega'\). It is known (see \cite[Sec.~6]{MOP15a}) that this construction yields a metric space~\((\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})},D_{(M,\mathcal{F})})\). Next, we describe a useful property that the metric space~\((\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})},D_{(M,\mathcal{F})})\) may have. A \emph{geodesic path} between the points \(p\) and \(q\) in a metric space \((B,D)\) is a map \(\gamma : [0,\ell] \rightarrow B\), for some \(\ell \geq 0\), with \(\gamma(0)=p\), \(\gamma(\ell) = q\) and \(D(\gamma(t_1),\gamma(t_2)) = \vert t_1 - t_2 \rvert\) for all \(t_1,t_2 \in [0,\ell]\). A metric space \((B,D)\) is \emph{geodesic} if there exists a geodesic path between~\(p\) and~\(q\) for all \(p,q \in B\). A geodesic metric space \((B,D)\) is a \(\text{CAT}(0)\)-metric space if and only if (see e.g.~\cite[p.~163]{BH99a}) \[(D(p,q))^2 + (D(p,r))^2 \geq 2(D(m,p))^2 + (D(q,r))^2/2\] holds for all \(p,q,r \in B\) and all \(m \in B\) with \(D(q,m) = D(r,m) = D(q,r)/2\). \(\text{CAT}(0)\)-metric spaces arise in many applications (see e.g.~\cite{AM20a}). They have the important property that geodesic paths are unique~\cite[Proposition~1.4, p.~160]{BH99a}. It follows from a result in \cite{gromov1987hyperbolic} that the orthant space \((\mathfrak{M}_{(M,\mathcal{F})},D_{(M,\mathcal{F})})\) is a \(\text{CAT}(0)\)-metric space if and only if~\(\mathcal{F}\) is a flag complex (see also \cite[Proposition~6.14]{MOP15a}). Furthermore, geodesic paths can be computed in polynomial time in \(\text{CAT}(0)\)-orthant spaces \cite[Corollary~6.19]{MOP15a}. \subsection{$\tau$-space revisited} \label{sub:sec:tree:space} To describe how the \(\tau\)-space of ultrametric trees arises as an orthant space, we start with a suitably defined abstract simplicial complex. A \emph{partition} of~\(X\) is a set~\(\mathcal{P}\) of non-empty and pairwise disjoint subsets of~\(X\) with \(X = \bigcup_{A \in \mathcal{P}} A\). We denote the set of all partitions of~\(X\) by~\(\mathfrak{B}(X)\) and define a binary relation~\(\sqsubseteq\) on~\(\mathfrak{B}(X)\) by putting \(\mathcal{P}_1 \sqsubseteq \mathcal{P}_2\) if for all \(A_1 \in \mathcal{P}_1 \) there exists some \(A_2 \in \mathcal{P}_2\) with \(A_1 \subseteq A_2\). Intuitively, this means that the partition~\(\mathcal{P}_1\) refines the partition~\(\mathcal{P}_2\). It is well-known that~\(\sqsubseteq\) is a partial ordering. Note that the partial ordering~\(\sqsubseteq\) is induced by the partial ordering~\(\subseteq\) on the subsets of~\(X\). \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{examples_trees.pdf} \caption{(a) A ranked \(X\)-tree with \(X=\{a,b,c,d\}\). Any cut along one of the dotted horizontal lines yields a partition of \(X\) (for example, the dotted line labeled with~1 yields the partition $\{\{a,b\},\{c\},\{d\}\}$). (b) An equidistant \(X\)-tree with \(X=\{a,b,c\}\).} \label{fig:examples:trees} \end{figure} Every ranked \(X\)-tree with a ranking of size~\(\sigma\) gives rise to a sequence \[\mathcal{P}_0 \sqsubseteq \mathcal{P}_1 \sqsubseteq \dots \sqsubseteq \mathcal{P}_{\sigma} = \{X\}\] of partitions of~\(X\). In Figure~\ref{fig:examples:trees}(a) we depict a rooted \(X\)-tree with a ranking of size \(\sigma = 3\) that gives rise to the sequence \[\{\{a\},\{b\},\{c\},\{d\}\} \sqsubseteq \{\{a,b\},\{c\},\{d\}\} \sqsubseteq \{\{a,b\},\{c,d\}\} \sqsubseteq \{\{a,b,c,d\}\}\] (see also Section~\ref{sec:set:pair:systems} where we formally define how the partitions arise more generally for ranked \(X\)-cactuses). The crucial fact is that this sequence encodes the ranked $X$-tree. More formally, as we shall prove as a consequence of our results for general ranked \(X\)-cactuses in Corollary~\ref{cor:chains:rooted:x:trees}, we have: \begin{theorem} \label{prop:pairwise:trees} There is a one-to-one correspondence between (isomorphism classes of) ranked \(X\)-trees and subsets of \(\mathfrak{B}(X)\) that contain~\(\{X\}\) and that consist of partitions of~\(X\) which are pairwise comparable with respect to the partial ordering~\(\sqsubseteq\). \end{theorem} To obtain \(\tau\)-space as an orthant space, we consider the abstract simplicial complex \((\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))\) with \(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X) = \mathfrak{B}(X) - \{X\}\) and \(\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq)\) containing all non-empty subsets of \(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X)\) whose elements are pairwise comparable with respect to~\(\sqsubseteq\). It follows immediately that \((\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))\) is a flag complex. Note that, more generally, we can associate an abstract simplicial complex that is a flag complex to any partial ordering in an analogous way; for this reason such a complex is known as an \emph{order complex} (see e.g.~\cite[p.~248]{WW92a}). \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.9]{orthants_trees_3_elements.pdf} \caption{The orthant space \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\) for \(X=\{a,b,c\}\). By construction, each axis represents a partition of \(X\) distinct from~\(\{X\}\). The axes labeled~\(\omega_1\) and~\(\omega_2\), for example, represent the partitions \(\{\{a\},\{b\},\{c\}\}\) and \(\{\{a,b\},\{c\}\}\), respectively. The three 2-dimensional orthants are drawn shaded. All points in the interior of these 2-dimensional orthants correspond to the same isomorphism class of binary ranked \(X\)-trees. The rankings for them are not shown because they are unique. Points on the axes correspond to non-binary ranked \(X\)-trees. The origin corresponds to the ranked \(X\)-tree that consists of a single vertex.} \label{fig:orthants:trees:3:elements} \end{figure} In Figure~\ref{fig:orthants:trees:3:elements}, we illustrate the orthant space \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\) of equidistant $X$-trees for $X=\{a,b,c\}$ (see Figure~\ref{fig:orthants:networks:3:elements} for an analogous drawing of the resulting orthant space of equidistant \(X\)-cactuses). Note that, by construction, the coordinates of a point in any orthant are obtained as differences between consecutive time stamps in the equidistant $X$-tree that corresponds to the point. The equidistant \(X\)-tree in Figure~\ref{fig:examples:trees}(b), for example, corresponds to the point \((\omega_1,\omega_2,\omega_3,\omega_4) = (0.8,1.3,0,0)\). More generally, it follows by Theorem~\ref{prop:pairwise:trees} that the elements in \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\) are in one-to-one correspondence with equidistant $X$-trees. Moreover, since \((\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))\) is a flag complex, it follows, as mentioned in Section~\ref{sub:sec:tree:space}, that the resulting metric space \((\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))},D_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))})\) is~\text{CAT}(0). We remark that, by construction, \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\) is precisely $\tau$-space, and so we obtain an alternative proof to the one presented in \cite{GD16} that $\tau$-space is a \text{CAT}(0)-metric space. Before proceeding, we note that in \cite{HSS21a} the problem of when a partition of~\(X\) is compatible with a rooted phylogenetic \(X\)-tree is studied. This includes, as a special case, the situation where the vertices of the tree can be ranked in such a way that the partition is among those associated with the resulting ranked \(X\)-tree. In addition, in \cite{AK06a} a space, called the \emph{Bergman fan} of the matroid of the complete graph with vertex set~\(X\) is studied. This space is a polyhedral fan ans its points are also in one-to-one correspondence with equidistant \(X\)-trees. Although not an orthant space, its cones are in one-to-one correspondence with the orthants of \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\). \section{An encoding for ranked $X$-cactuses}\label{sec:encoding} To help the reader navigate the remaining sections of this paper, we now briefly summarize how we shall construct the equidistant-cactus space $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ by applying an analogue of the process described in Section~\ref{sub:sec:tree:space}. We shall begin by introducing the concept of a \emph{polestar system} on the set~$X$, which is a collection of ordered pairs of subsets of~\(X\), or set pair system for short, with certain properties. As we shall see in Section~\ref{sec:partition:like:set:pair:systems}, polestar systems can be associated to ranked $X$-cactuses in a similar way how partitions can be associated to ranked $X$-trees. We shall also define a binary relation \(\preceq\) on general set pair systems, and, in Section~\ref{sec:poset:p:x}, we will show that \(\preceq\) yields a partial ordering on the set $\mathfrak{P}(X)$ of polestar systems on $X$. In Section~\ref{sec:encoding:ranked:x:network}, we then prove an analogue of Theorem~\ref{prop:pairwise:trees}, namely, we show that ranked $X$-cactuses are in one-to-one correspondence with subsets of $\mathfrak{P}(X)$ that contain the maximum element relative to the ordering $\preceq$ and that are pairwise comparable with respect to~\(\preceq\). In other words, we obtain an encoding of ranked \(X\)-cactuses in terms of certain collections of polestar systems. In Section~\ref{sec:conclusion}, we conclude by constructing the network space $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ as the orthant space associated to the order complex of the poset $(\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)$. \subsection{Set pair systems} \label{sec:set:pair:systems} Before introducing polestar systems, we recall the concept of a set pair system introduced in~\cite{HMS21a}. To this end, we say that a vertex $u$ in a rooted DAG~\(N\) is a \emph{descendant} of a vertex $v$ if there exists a directed path from the root of \(N\) to \(u\) that contains \(v\). A descendant \(u\) of \(v\) is a \emph{strict descendant} if every directed path from the root to $u$ contains $v$. Otherwise \(u\) is called a \emph{non-strict descendant} of \(v\). Now, given a rooted \(X\)-cactus $\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)$ and a vertex $u \in V$, let \(C(u)\) be the set of those \(x \in X\) with \(\varphi(x)\) a descendant of $u$, $S(u)$ the set of those \(x \in X\) with \(\varphi(x)\) a strict descendant of $u$ and $H(u)$ the set of those \(x \in X\) with \(\varphi(x)\) a non-strict descendant of $u$ in $X$. For every vertex \(u\) of \(\mathcal{N}\) we call \((S(u),H(u))\) the \emph{set pair} associated to~\(u\) and put \[\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N}) = \{(S(u),H(u)) : u \in V\}.\] For later reference, we state some immediate consequences of the definition of the set pairs in \(\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N})\) for a rooted \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) (see also~\cite{HMS21a} where these properties have been considered in the context of the slightly more restrictive 1-nested phylogenetic networks): \begin{itemize} \setlength{\itemindent}{15pt} \item[(SH1)] For all vertices \(u\) of \(\mathcal{N}\), we have \(S(u) \cap H(u) = \emptyset\), \(S(u) \cup H(u) = C(u)\) and $S(u)$ is always non-empty while $H(u)$ may be empty. \item[(SH2)] If \((S(u),H(u)) = (S(v),H(v))\) for two distinct vertices \(u\) and \(v\) of \(\mathcal{N}\) then one of these vertices, say~\(u\), is a reticulation vertex with outdegree~1 and \(v\) is the single child of~\(u\). Note that this situation cannot occur if~\(\mathcal{N}\) is compressed. \item[(SH3)] Let \(C\) be the set of vertices in a reticulation cycle of \(\mathcal{N}\) where \(u\) and \(v\) are the common start and end vertex, respectively, of the two directed paths that form the reticulation cycle. Then we have \(H(w) = S(v)\) if \(w \in C - \{u,v\}\) and, for all other vertices \(w'\) of \(\mathcal{N}\), we have \(H(w') \neq S(v)\). \end{itemize} Now, given a ranked \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N}=((V,A),\varphi),r)\) we collect, for every \(i \in \{0,1,2,\dots,\sigma(r)\}\), in \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) first those set pairs from~\(\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N})\) that correspond to vertices of rank at most~\(i\) and whose parents (if any) have rank strictly larger than~\(i\). We then add some further set pairs that essentially help to keep track of the fact that some of the vertices involved are in a reticulation cycle. More formally, we define \(V_i\) to be the set that consists of all vertices \(u \in V\) with \(r(u) \leq i\) and \(r(p) > i\) for all parents~\(p\) of~\(u\). Note that, in view of~(TS3), \(V_i\)~does not contain any reticulation vertices. Thus, all \(u \in V_i\) have at most one parent. Then we put \[\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}) = \{(S(u),H(u)) : u \in V_i\} \cup \{(H(u),\emptyset) : u \in V_i, \ H(u) \neq \emptyset\}.\] Note that we always have \(\mathcal{S}_{\sigma(r)} = \{(X,\emptyset)\}\). For the rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}\) in Figure~\ref{fig:rankable:network}(a), for example, we obtain: {\small \begin{align*} \mathcal{S}_4(\mathcal{N}) &= \{(\{a,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j\},\emptyset)\}\\ \mathcal{S}_3(\mathcal{N}) &= \{(\{a,b,c,d,e\},\emptyset),(\{f,g,h,i,j\},\emptyset)\}\\ \mathcal{S}_2(\mathcal{N}) &= \{(\{a\},\{b,c,d\}),(\{b,c,d\},\emptyset),(\{e\},\{b,c,d\}), (\{f,g,h\},\emptyset),(\{i\},\emptyset),(\{j\},\emptyset)\}\\ \mathcal{S}_1(\mathcal{N}) &= \{(\{a\},\emptyset),(\{b,c,d\},\emptyset),(\{e\},\emptyset), (\{f,g,h\},\emptyset),(\{i\},\emptyset),(\{j\},\emptyset)\}\\ \mathcal{S}_0(\mathcal{N}) &= \{(\{x\},\emptyset): x \in \{a,b,c,d,e,g,i,j\}\} \cup \{(\{f\},\{g\}),(\{h\},\{g\})\} \end{align*}} A collection of ordered pairs $(S,H)$ of subsets of \(X\) such that \(S \neq \emptyset\) and \(S \cap H = \emptyset\) is called a \emph{set pair system} on~\(X\). Note that, by construction, the sets \(\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N})\) and \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\), \(0 \leq i \leq \sigma(r)\), associated with a ranked \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N},r)\) are non-empty set-pair systems. It is shown in \cite{HMS21a} that, for any set pair system \(\mathcal{S}\) on \(X\), we obtain a partial ordering \(\leq\) on the set pairs in \(\mathcal{S}\) by putting \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2)\) if either \((S_1,H_1) = (S_2,H_2)\) or \((S_1,H_1) \neq (S_2,H_2)\) and one the following holds: \begin{itemize} \item \(S_1 \cup H_1 \subseteq S_2\) \item \(S_1 \cup H_1 \subseteq H_2\) \item \(S_1 \subsetneq S_2\) and \(H_1 = H_2 \neq \emptyset\) \end{itemize} We write \((S_1,H_1) < (S_2,H_2)\) if \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2)\) and the set pairs \((S_1,H_1)\) and \((S_2,H_2)\) are distinct. The partial ordering \(\leq\) on set pairs was defined in such a way that we have \((S(u),H(u)) \leq (S(v),H(v))\) for two vertices~\(u\) and~\(v\) in a rooted \(X\)-cactus if and only if \(u\) is a descendant of \(v\) (see the proof Theorem~5 in \cite{HMS21a}). We use the partial ordering \(\leq\) on set pairs to define a binary relation~\(\preceq\) on set pair systems. More precisely, for set pair systems~\(\mathcal{S}_1\) and~\(\mathcal{S}_2\) on~\(X\) we put \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2\) if \begin{itemize} \setlength{\itemindent}{15pt} \item[(SP1)] for all \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) there exists some \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2)\), and \item[(SP2)] for all \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \(H_2 \neq \emptyset\), if there exists some \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) with \(H_1 = H_2\), then there exists such a \((S_1,H_1)\) with \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2)\). \end{itemize} Again, we write \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\) if \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2\) and \(\mathcal{S}_1 \neq \mathcal{S}_2\). We remark that~(SP1) captures the basic idea from Section~\ref{sub:sec:tree:space} that the partial ordering \(\leq\) on set pairs induces a suitable binary relation on set pair systems (in analogy to how the partial ordering \(\subseteq\) induced the binary relation~\(\sqsubseteq\)). (SP2) is an additional technical requirement that will be crucial in our encoding of ranked \(X\)-cactuses. The relation \(\preceq\) is, in general, not a partial ordering on the set pair systems on a fixed set \(X\) because it might neither be antisymmetric nor transitive. For the set pair systems associated with a ranked \(X\)-cactus, however, the following holds. \begin{lemma} \label{lem:ranking:equals:partial:ordering} Let \((\mathcal{N},r)\) be a ranked \(X\)-cactus. Then we have \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}) \prec \mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\) for all \(0 \leq i < j \leq \sigma(r)\) and \(\mathcal{S}_{\sigma(r)}(\mathcal{N}) = \{(\{X\},\emptyset)\}\). \end{lemma} \begin{proof} As noted earlier in this section, \(\mathcal{S}_{\sigma(r)}(\mathcal{N}) = \{(\{X\},\emptyset)\}\) follows immediately from the definition of the set pair system \(\mathcal{S}_{\sigma(r)}(\mathcal{N})\). Consider \(0 \leq i < j \leq \sigma(r)\). We first show that \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}) \preceq \mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\). So, consider \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\). By definition of \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\), there must exist a vertex \(v\) in \(\mathcal{N}\) with \(r(v) \leq i\), \(r(p) > i\) for all parents~\(p\) of~\(v\), and either \((S,H) = (S(v),H(v))\) or \((S,H) = (H(v),\emptyset)\). Consider a directed path from the root of \(\mathcal{N}\) to~\(v\). On this path there must exist a vertex \(u\) with \(r(u) \leq j\) and \(r(p) > j\) for all parents~\(p\) of \(u\). This implies that \((S(u),H(u)) \in \mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\). Moreover, in view of the fact that \(u\) lies on a directed path from the root of \(\mathcal{N}\) to~\(v\), we must have \((S,H) \leq (S(v),H(v)) \leq (S(u),H(u))\), as required by~(SP1). To establish that also~(SP2) is satisfied for \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) and \(\mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\), consider \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\) with \(H \neq \emptyset\). By definition of \(\mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\), there must exist a vertex \(u\) in \(\mathcal{N}\) with \((S,H) = (S(u),H(u))\), \(r(u) \leq j\) and \(r(p) > j\) for all parents~\(p\) of~\(u\). Now, if there exists some \((S',H') \in \mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) with \(H'=H\) then there exists some vertex \(v\) in \(\mathcal{N}\) with \((S',H') = (S',H) = (S(v),H(v))\), \(r(v) \leq i\) and \(r(p) > i\) for all parents~\(p\) of~\(v\). This implies that \(u\) and \(v\) must be vertices in the same reticulation cycle of \(\mathcal{N}\). Moreover, we can choose \(v\) such that \(v\) is a descendant of \(u\), implying that \((S',H') = (S(v),H(v)) \leq (S(u),H(u)) = (S,H)\), as required. It remains to show that \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}) \neq \mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\). By the definition of a ranked \(X\)-cactus, there must exist a vertex \(u \in V\) with \(r(u) = j\). Without loss of generality we may assume that \(u\) is not a reticulation vertex. If \((S(u),H(u)) \not \in \mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) we are done. So, assume for a contradiction that \((S(u),H(u)) \in \mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\). In view of \(i < j\) we have \(u \not \in V_i\). Thus, there exists some \(v \neq u\) in \(V_i\) such that either (i) \(H(v) \neq \emptyset\) and \((S(u),H(u)) = (H(v),\emptyset)\) or (ii) \((S(u),H(u)) = (S(v),H(v))\). If Case~(i) holds then, in view of (SH3), \(v\) must be a vertex in a reticulation cycle with end vertex~\(u'\) and \((S(u'),H(u')) = (H(v),\emptyset) = (S(u),H(u))\). Since \(u\) is not a reticulation vertex, it follows, by (SH2), that \(u\) is the single child of \(u'\). Consequently, \(i=r(v) > r(u) = j\), a contradiction. Similarly, if Case~(ii) holds then, again by (SH2), it follows that \(u\) is a reticulation vertex and~\(v\) is the single child of~\(u\), a contradiction. \end{proof} \subsection{Polestar systems} \label{sec:partition:like:set:pair:systems} A set pair system \(\mathcal{S}\) on \(X\) is \emph{partition-like}~if \begin{itemize} \setlength{\itemindent}{15pt} \item[(PL1)] \(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}) = \{S : (S,H) \in \mathcal{S}\}\) is a partition of~\(X\), \item[(PL2)] for all \((S,H),(S',H') \in \mathcal{S}\) with \((S,H) \neq (S',H')\) we have \(S \neq S'\), and \item[(PL3)] for all \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}\) with \(H \neq \emptyset\) we have \((H,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}\) and there exists precisely one \((S',H') \in \mathcal{S}\) with \((S',H') \neq (S,H)\) and \(H=H'\). \end{itemize} A \underline{p}artiti\underline{o}n-\underline{l}ik\underline{e} \underline{s}e\underline{t} p\underline{a}i\underline{r} system is called a \emph{polestar system}, for short. In addition, we define \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) = \{H : (S,H) \in \mathcal{S}, H \neq \emptyset\}\). Note that~(PL2) implies that $\lvert \mathcal{S} \rvert = \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}) \rvert$. \begin{lemma} \label{lem:ranked:networks:yield:partition:like} Let \((\mathcal{N},r)\) be a ranked \(X\)-cactus. Then \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) is a polestar system for all \(0 \leq i \leq \sigma(r)\). \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Fix some \(i \in \{0,1,\dots,\sigma(r)\}\) and consider two distinct vertices \(u_1, u_2 \in V_i\). Put \((S_k,H_k) = (S(u_k),H(u_k))\), \(k \in \{1,2\}\). Recall from the definition of the set~\(V_i\) that both \(u_1\) and \(u_2\) have rank at most~\(i\) while the ranks of their parents are strictly larger than~\(i\). Thus, up to switching the roles of \(u_1\) and \(u_2\), one of the following must hold: \begin{itemize} \item Neither of \(u_1\) and \(u_2\) is a descendant of the other and there is no reticulation cycle in \(\mathcal{N}\) that contains both \(u_1\) and \(u_2\). Consequently, \((S(u_1) \cup H(u_1)) \cap (S(u_2) \cup H(u_2)) = \emptyset\). Thus, the sets \(S(u_1)\), \(H(u_1)\), \(S(u_2)\) and \(H(u_2)\) are pairwise disjoint. \item Both \(u_1\) and \(u_2\) are contained in the same reticulation cycle in \(\mathcal{N}\) but neither is a descendant of the other. Consequently, \(H(u_1) = H(u_2) = H \neq \emptyset\) and the sets \(S(u_1)\), \(S(u_2)\) and \(H\) are pairwise disjoint. \end{itemize} It follows from this case analysis that (PL1) and (PL2) hold for \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\). To see that also (PL3) holds, consider a set pair \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) with \(H \neq \emptyset\). By the definition of \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) there must exist a vertex \(u\) in \(\mathcal{N}\) with \((S(u),H(u)) = (S,H)\) such that \(r(u) \leq i\) and \(r(p) > i\) for all parents \(p\) of~\(u\). In view of \(H(u) = H \neq \emptyset\), vertex \(u\) must be contained in a reticulation cycle~\(\mathcal{C}\) but cannot be the common start or the common end vertex of the two directed paths that form~\(\mathcal{C}\). Note that~\(\mathcal{C}\) contains a unique vertex \(v \neq u\) with \(r(v) \leq i\) and \(r(p) > i\) for all parents~\(p\) of \(v\). Moreover, \(v\) cannot be the common start or the common end vertex of the two directed paths that form~\(\mathcal{C}\). Since \(u\) and \(v\) are both contained in~\(\mathcal{C}\), we have \(H(u) = H(v) = H\). Moreover, by (SH3), there are no other vertices \(w\) in \(\mathcal{N}\) with \(H(w) = H\), \(r(w) \leq i\) and \(r(p) > i\) for all parents \(p\) of~\(w\). Finally, by construction, we also have \((H,\emptyset) = (H(u),\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\). \end{proof} We denote by~\(\mathfrak{P}(X)\) the set of polestar systems on the set~\(X\). Note that, even for the set pair systems in~\(\mathfrak{P}(X)\), (SP1)~in the definition of the binary relation~\(\preceq\) does not imply~(SP2), as can be seen from the set pair systems \begin{align*} \mathcal{S}_1 &= \{(\{a\},\{b\}),(\{b\},\emptyset),(\{c\},\{b\}),(\{d\},\emptyset)\} \ \text{and}\\ \mathcal{S}_2 &= \{(\{a,c\},\{b\}),(\{b\},\emptyset),(\{d\},\{b\})\} \end{align*} on \(X=\{a,b,c,d\}\) which satisfy (PL1)-(PL3) and (SP1) but not~(SP2). We conclude this section with two technical lemmas stating some properties of the relations \(\leq\) and \(\preceq\) that will be used in Sections~\ref{sec:poset:p:x} and~\ref{sec:encoding:ranked:x:network}. In particular, Lemma~\ref{lem:technical:ordering:consistent} establishes that, up to a specific exception, distinct set pairs within a single polestar system are incomparable with respect to the partial ordering \(\leq\) and the binary relations \(\leq\) and \(\preceq\) are consistent. In our encoding of ranked \(X\)-cactuses this exception corresponds to the set pairs associated with reticulation vertices. \begin{lemma} \label{lem:technical:ordering:consistent} Let \(\mathcal{S}_1,\mathcal{S}_2 \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2\). Then, for all \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) and \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\), \((S_2,H_2) < (S_1,H_1)\) implies \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_1\), \(H_2 = \emptyset\) and \(H_1 = S_2\). \end{lemma} \begin{proof} First, consider the case \(\mathcal{S}_1 = \mathcal{S}_2 = \mathcal{S}\). Let \((S_1,H_1), (S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}\) with \((S_2,H_2) < (S_1,H_1)\). Assume for a contradiction that \(H_2 \neq \emptyset\). Then, in view of (PL1)-(PL3), none of \(S_2 \cup H_2 \subseteq S_1\), \(S_2 \cup H_2 \subseteq H_1\) and \(S_2 \subsetneq S_1\) can hold, in contradiction to \((S_2,H_2) < (S_1,H_1)\). Thus, we must have \(H_2 = \emptyset\). Consequently, \(S_2 \subseteq H_1\), and, therefore, \(S_2=H_1\), as required. Next consider the case \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\). Let \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) and \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \((S_2,H_2) < (S_1,H_1)\). In view of \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\), there must exist some \((S_2',H_2') \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2',H_2')\). By the transitivity of \(\leq\), we obtain \((S_2,H_2) < (S_2',H_2')\). In view of the first case considered in this proof, this implies \(S_2 = H_2'\) and \(H_2 = \emptyset\). Thus, by the definition of a set pair, we have \(S_2 \cap S_2' = \emptyset\). Moreover, \((S_2,H_2) < (S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2',H_2') \) simplifies to \((S_2,\emptyset) < (S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2',S_2)\). In view of the definition of \(\leq\), the latter can only hold if \(S_2 = H_1 \neq \emptyset\). By (PL3), this implies \((H_1,\emptyset) = (S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_1\), as required. \end{proof} \begin{lemma} \label{lem:technical:rank:function:graded:poset} Let \(\mathcal{S}_1,\mathcal{S}_2 \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\). Then \[1 \leq \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert < \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert - \vert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert \leq \lvert X \rvert.\] If \((\lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert) - (\lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert) \geq 2\) then there exists \(\mathcal{S}_3 \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_3 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\). \end{lemma} \begin{proof} In view of (PL1), we have \(1 \leq \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}) \rvert \leq \lvert X \rvert\) for all \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\). Moreover, in view of (PL3), we have $\lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}) \rvert \geq 3 \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) \rvert$. This implies \(1 \leq \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) \rvert \leq \lvert X \rvert\). Next consider \(\mathcal{S}_1,\mathcal{S}_2 \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\). We first show that, for all \(S' \in \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1)\), there exists a unique \(S'' \in \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\) with \(S' \subseteq S''\). In view of (PL2), there exists a unique set pair \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) with \(S' = S_1\) and, in view of \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\), there must exist a set pair \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2)\). Therefore, by the definition of~\(\leq\), one of the following must hold: \begin{itemize} \item \(S_1 \cup H_1 \subseteq S_2\). Then we put \(S''=S_2\). \item \(S_1 \cup H_1 \subseteq H_2\). This implies \(H_2 \neq \emptyset\) and thus, by (PL3), \(H_2 \in \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\). We put \(S'' = H_2\). \item \(S_1 \subsetneq S_2\) and \(H_1 = H_2 \neq \emptyset\). Then we put \(S'' = S_2\). \end{itemize} In each case, we have \(S' \subseteq S''\) for some \(S'' \in \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\) and, in view of~(PL1), \(S''\) is unique, as claimed. This implies that we obtain a map \(q : \mathcal{S}_1 \rightarrow \mathcal{S}_2\) by assigning to each \((S',H') \in \mathcal{S}_1\) the unique \((S'',H'') \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \(S' \subseteq S''\). In particular, we have $\lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert \geq \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert$. To establish $\lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert < \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert$, put \(k = \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert - \rvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\rvert\). Let~\(\ell_1\) denote the number of \(H' \in \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1)\) with \(H' \not \in \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2)\). Note that, in view of (PL3), for each such \(H'\), there exist precisely two set pairs \((S_1',H_1'),(S_2',H_2') \in \mathcal{S}_1\) with \(H_1' = H_2' = H'\) and, in view of \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\), there must exist some \(S'' \in \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\) with \(S_1' \cup S_2' \cup H' \subseteq S''\). This implies \(k \geq 2\ell_1\). Thus, letting \(\ell_2\) denote the number of \(H'' \in \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2)\) with \(H'' \not \in \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1)\), we have \begin{align*} \lvert\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert &= \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert + \ell_1 - \ell_2\\ &= \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert + \ell_1 - \ell_2 - k\\ &\leq \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert - \ell_1 - \ell_2. \end{align*} Thus, if \(\ell_1 + \ell_2 > 0\) we immediately have $\lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2) \rvert < \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1) \rvert$. If \(\ell_1 + \ell_2 = 0\) we have \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1) = \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2)\). This implies, in view of \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\), that we cannot have \(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1) = \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\), that is, we must have \(k > 0\) and, thus, we also obtain $\lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\rvert - \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2)\rvert < \lvert\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert - \lvert\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert$, as required. Now assume that \((\lvert\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert - \lvert\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1)\rvert) - (\lvert\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\rvert - \lvert\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2)\rvert) \geq 2\). First consider the case that there exist two distinct \((S_1'',H_1''),(S_2'',H_2'') \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with $\lvert q^{-1}(S_i'',H_i'')\rvert \geq 2$, \(i \in \{1,2\}\). Then we put \[\mathcal{S}_3 = (\mathcal{S}_1 - q^{-1}(S_1'',H_1'')) \cup \{(S_1'',H_1'')\}.\] Next consider the case that there exists \((S'',H'') \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with $\lvert q^{-1}(S'',H'')\rvert \geq 3$ and \(H' = \emptyset\) for all \((S',H') \in q^{-1}(S'',H'')\). Then we select two distinct \((S_1',\emptyset),(S_2',\emptyset) \in q^{-1}(S'',H'')\) and put \[\mathcal{S}_3 = (\mathcal{S}_1 - \{(S_1',\emptyset),(S_2',\emptyset)\}) \cup \{(S_1' \cup S_2',\emptyset)\}.\] The remaining case to consider is that there exists \((S'',H'') \in \mathcal{S}_2\) such that $\lvert q^{-1}(S'',H'')\rvert \geq 4$ and there are three distinct \((S_1',H_1'),(S_2',H_2'),(S_3',H_3') \in q^{-1}(S'',H'')\) with \(H_1' = \emptyset\) and \(H_2'=H_3'=S_1'\). Then we put \[\mathcal{S}_3 = (\mathcal{S}_1 - \{(S_1',H_1'),(S_2',H_2'),(S_3',H_3')\}) \cup \{(S_1' \cup S_2' \cup S_3',\emptyset)\}.\] In each case, by construction, we immediately have \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_3 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\). \end{proof} \section{The poset $(\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)$} \label{sec:poset:p:x} In this section, we prove that~\(\preceq\) is a partial ordering on~\(\mathfrak{P}(X)\). We also give a formula for counting the number of elements in the resulting poset $(\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)$. We first recall some standard poset concepts (see e.g.~\cite{T95a}). A (finite) \emph{poset} \((M,R)\) consists of a finite non-empty set \(M\) and a binary relation~\(R \subseteq M \times M\) on~\(M\) that is reflexive, transitive and antisymmetric. An element \(m \in M\) is \emph{minimum} (\emph{maximum}) if \((m,a) \in R\) (\((a,m) \in R\)) holds for all \(a \in M\). A poset is \emph{bounded} if it has a minimum and a maximum element and these elements are then necessarily unique. Two elements \(a,b \in M\) are \emph{comparable} if \((a,b) \in R\) or \((b,a) \in R\). A \emph{chain}~\(C\) is a non-empty subset of~\(M\) of pairwise comparable elements. The \emph{length} of a chain~\(C\) is $\lvert C \rvert - 1$. A chain is \emph{maximal} if it is not contained in some strictly longer chain. A poset is \emph{graded} if every maximal chain has the same length. The \emph{height function}\footnote{Usually called \emph{rank function} of the graded poset. We use height function instead to avoid confusion with the rankings of rooted \(X\)-cactuses.} \(h\) of a graded poset \((M,R)\) assigns to every element \(a \in M\) the length \(h(a)\) of a longest chain \(C\) with \((b,a) \in R\) for all \(b \in C\). \begin{proposition} \label{prop:poset:p:x} \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) is a bounded graded poset with minimum element \(\{(\{x\},\emptyset) : x \in X\}\) and maximum element \(\{(X,\emptyset)\}\). The height function of this poset is \(h : \mathfrak{P}(X) \rightarrow \{0,1,\dots,\lvert X \rvert-1\}\) with \(h(\mathcal{S}) = \lvert X \rvert - \lvert \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S})\rvert + \lvert \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S})\rvert\). \end{proposition} \begin{proof} We first show that \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) is a poset. It follows immediately from the definition of the binary relation~\(\preceq\) that it is reflexive. Moreover, in view of Lemma~\ref{lem:technical:rank:function:graded:poset}, we cannot have two distinct \(\mathcal{S}_1,\mathcal{S}_2 \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2\) and \(\mathcal{S}_2 \preceq \mathcal{S}_1\), implying that~\(\preceq\) is also antisymmetric. It remains to show that \(\preceq\) is transitive. Consider set pair systems \(\mathcal{S}_1\), \(\mathcal{S}_2\) and \(\mathcal{S}_3\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2 \preceq \mathcal{S}_3\). Then, in view of (SP1), for all \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\), there exists some \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2)\) and, again in view of (SP1), there also exists some \((S_3,H_3) \in \mathcal{S}_3\) with \((S_2,H_2) \leq (S_3,H_3)\). By the transitivity of \(\leq\), we obtain \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_3,H_3)\), as required. Next consider some \((S_3,H_3) \in \mathcal{S}_3\) with \(H_3 \neq \emptyset\). First assume that there exists some \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \(H_2=H_3\). Then, by (SP2), there also exists \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \(H_2=H_3\) and \((S_2,H_2) \leq (S_3,H_3)\). Now, if there exists some \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) with \(H_1 = H_2 = H_3\), then, by (SP2), there also exists such a set pair in \(\mathcal{S}_1\) with \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2) \leq (S_3,H_3)\). Hence, by the transitivity of \(\leq\), we have \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_3,H_3)\), as required. Next assume that there exists no \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \(H_2=H_3\). It suffices to show that this implies that there exists no \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) with \(H_1=H_3\). So, assume for a contradiction that there exists some \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) with \(H_1=H_3\neq \emptyset\). Put \(H=H_1\). In view of \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2\), there must exist some \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \((S_1,H) \leq (S_2,H_2)\). Note that \(H_2 \neq H\) combined with the definition of \(\leq\) implies \(S_1 \cup H \subseteq S_2\) or \(S_1 \cup H \subseteq H_2\). Moreover, in view of \(\mathcal{S}_2 \preceq \mathcal{S}_3\), there must exist some \((S_3',H_3') \in \mathcal{S}_3\) with \((S_2,H_2) \leq (S_3',H_3')\). This implies that \(S_1 \cup H \subseteq S_3'\) or \(S_1 \cup H \subseteq H_3'\). But then, \(H \subsetneq S_3'\) or \(H \subsetneq H_3'\) must hold in contradiction to (PL1). Thus \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_3\) holds, establishing that \(\preceq\) is transitive and, thus, \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) is a poset. Next we show that \(\{(\{x\},\emptyset) : x \in X\}\) and \(\{(X,\emptyset)\}\) are the minimum and maximum element, respectively, in \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\). Clearly, \(\{(\{x\},\emptyset) : x \in X\}\) and \(\{(X,\emptyset)\}\) are both polestar systems and, thus, elements of \(\mathfrak{P}(X)\). Consider any \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\). Then, for all \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}\), we have \(S \cup H \subseteq X\), implying \((S,H) \leq (X,\emptyset)\) and, thus, \(\mathcal{S} \preceq \{(X,\emptyset)\}\). Similarly, in view of (PL1), for all \(x \in X\), there must exist some \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}\) with \(x \in S\), implying that \((\{x\},\emptyset) \leq (S,H)\). Thus, \(\{(\{x\},\emptyset) : x \in X\} \preceq \mathcal{S}\). It follows that \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) is a bounded poset. That \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) is a graded poset with height function~\(h\) is now an immediate consequence of Lemma~\ref{lem:technical:rank:function:graded:poset} in view of \(h(\{(\{x\},\emptyset) : x \in X\}) = 0\) and \(h(\{(X,\emptyset)\}) = \lvert X \rvert -1\). \end{proof} The next corollary describes the relationship between~\((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) and the poset \((\mathfrak{B}(X),\sqsubseteq)\) of partitions of~\(X\). Two posets \((M_1,R_1)\) and \((M_2,R_2)\) are \emph{isomorphic} if there exists a bijective map \(f: M_1 \rightarrow M_2\) such that, for all \(a,b \in M_1\), \((a,b) \in R_1\) if and only if \((f(a),f(b)) \in R_2\). \begin{corollary} \label{cor:poset:partitions} The restriction of the poset~\((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) to those \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) = \emptyset\) is isomorphic to the poset \((\mathfrak{B}(X),\sqsubseteq)\) of partitions of~\(X\). \end{corollary} \begin{proof} We map any \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) = \emptyset\) to the partition \(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}) \in \mathfrak{B}(X)\). This map is bijective. Moreover, for \(\mathcal{S}_1,\mathcal{S}_2 \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1) = \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2) = \emptyset\) we have \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2\) if and only if for all \(A_1 \in \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_1)\) there exists some \(A_2 \in \mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}_2)\) with \(A_1 \subseteq A_2\), as required. \end{proof} In the remaining part of this section, we give a formula for the number~\(\lambda_n = \lvert\mathfrak{P}(X)\rvert\) of polestar systems on a set \(X\) with \(n \geq 1\) elements. The values of \(\lambda_n\) for \(n = 1,2,\dots,8\) are 1, 2, 8, 45, 277, 1853, 14065, 122118. For \(k \in \{1,2,\dots,n\}\), we denote by \(\alpha_{n,k}\) the \emph{Stirling number} of the second kind, that is, the number of partitions of~\(X\) into~\(k\) subsets. In addition, for \(\ell \in \{0,1,\dots,\lfloor \frac{k}{3} \rfloor\}\), we denote by \(\beta_{k,\ell}\) the number of partitions of a set with~\(k\) elements into \(\ell\) subsets with three elements and \(k-3\ell\) subsets with one element. It is known~\cite{OEISa} that \[\beta_{k,\ell} = \frac{k!}{6^{\ell} \cdot \ell! \cdot (k-3\ell)!}.\] \begin{proposition} \label{prop:size:px} For all \(n \geq 1\) we have \begin{equation} \label{eq:number:polestar} \lambda_n = \sum_{k=1}^n \alpha_{n,k} \cdot \left (\sum_{\ell=0}^{\lfloor \frac{k}{3} \rfloor} \beta_{k,\ell} \cdot 3^{\ell} \right ). \end{equation} \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Let \(X\) be a set with \(n \geq 1\) elements. Consider \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{P}(X)\) and put \(k =\lvert\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S})\rvert\). By the definition of a polestar system, \(\mathcal{S}\) arises from \(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S})\) by forming, for some \(\ell \in \{0,1,\dots,\lfloor \frac{k}{3} \rfloor\}\), a partition \(\Pi(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}))\) of \(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S})\) into \(\ell\) subsets with three elements and \(k-3\ell\) subsets with one element. Each 1-element set \(\{S\} \in \Pi(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}))\) yields the set pair \((S,\emptyset)\). For each 3-element set \(\{S_1,S_2,S_3\} \in \Pi(\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{S}))\) we select \(i \in \{1,2,3\}\) and obtain the three set pairs \((S_i,\emptyset)\), \((S_j,S_i)\), \(j \in \{1,2,3\} - \{i\}\). Formula~(\ref{eq:number:polestar}) directly reflects the process described above for obtaining a polestar system from a fixed partition of \(X\) into \(k\) subsets. In view of the fact that every partition of~\(X\) yields a different collection of polestar systems on~\(X\), we form the outer sum over the values of~\(k\). The inner sum then accounts for the number of polestar systems that arise from any fixed partition of \(X\) into~\(k\) subsets. \end{proof} \section{Encoding ranked $X$-cactuses} \label{sec:encoding:ranked:x:network} In this section, we show in~Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1} that we can encode (isomorphism classes) of ranked \(X\)-cactuses in terms of the chains in the poset \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\). We begin by giving a precise statement of this result. We call two equidistant \(X\)-cactuses \((\mathcal{N}'=((V',A'),\varphi'),t')\) and \((\mathcal{N}''=((V'',A''),\varphi''),t'')\) \emph{isomorphic} if there exists a DAG-isomorphism \(f:V' \rightarrow V''\) such that \begin{itemize} \setlength{\itemindent}{15pt} \item[(IC1)] \(f(\varphi'(x)) = \varphi''(x)\) for all \(x \in X\) and \item[(IC2)] \(t'(v) = t''(f(v))\) for all \(v \in V'\). \end{itemize} Note that this definition includes isomorphisms between ranked \(X\)-cactuses as a special case. For rooted \(X\)-cactuses without a time-stamp function to be isomorphic, condition~(IC2) is not required. We now state the aforementioned result. \begin{theorem} \label{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1} There is a one-to-one correspondence between chains in the poset \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) that contain the maximum element \(\{(X,\emptyset)\}\) and (isomorphism classes of) ranked \(X\)-cactuses. The length of the chain equals the size of the ranking of the corresponding ranked \(X\)-cactus. Maximal chains correspond to binary ranked \(X\)-cactuses with rankings of size $\lvert X \rvert-1$. \end{theorem} To prove this theorem, note that by Lemmas~\ref{lem:ranking:equals:partial:ordering} and~\ref{lem:ranked:networks:yield:partition:like}, every ranked \(X\)-cactus corresponds to a chain~\(\mathfrak{C}\) in \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) with \(\{(X,\emptyset)\} \in \mathfrak{C}\). Moreover, by~Lemma~\ref{lem:size:ranking}, we have $\lvert\mathfrak{C}\rvert \leq \lvert X \rvert - 1$ for such a chain with equality holding if and only if the ranked \(X\)-cactus is binary. Thus, to prove Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1}, it suffices to show that for all chains \(\mathfrak{C}\) in \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) with \(\{(X,\emptyset)\} \in \mathfrak{C}\) there exists, up to isomorphism, a unique ranked \(X\)-cactus~\((\mathcal{N},r)\) with \(\mathfrak{C} = \{\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}) : 0 \leq i \leq \sigma(r)\}\). This follows immediately from Lemmas~\ref{lem:set:pairs:compressed:network} and~\ref{lem:modify:and:rank} below, and will be done in two steps. First, for any chain \(\mathfrak{C} \subseteq \mathfrak{P}(X)\) with \(\{(X,\emptyset)\} \in \mathfrak{C}\), we form the set pair system \(\mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C}) = \bigcup_{\mathcal{S}' \in \mathfrak{C}} \mathcal{S}'\) consisting of all set pairs that occur in the polestar systems in~\(\mathfrak{C}\) and construct a suitable rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})\) (see Lemma~\ref{lem:set:pairs:compressed:network}). Second, we perform some technical modifications on \(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})\), if necessary, to obtain \(\mathcal{N}\) and then construct a suitable ranking~\(r\) (see Lemma~\ref{lem:modify:and:rank}). \begin{lemma} \label{lem:set:pairs:compressed:network} For all chains \(\mathfrak{C}\) in \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) with \(\{(X,\emptyset)\} \in \mathfrak{C}\) there exists, up to isomorphism, a unique rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})\) with \(\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})) = \mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C}) \cup \{(\{x\},\emptyset) : x \in X\}\). \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Put \(\mathcal{S} = \mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C}) \cup \{(\{x\},\emptyset) : x \in X\}\). We show below that \(\mathcal{S}\) satisfies certain properties~(NC1)-(NC5). We do this to then apply~\cite[Theorem~5]{HMS21a}, which states that if a set pair system \(\mathcal{S}'\) on \(X\) has these properties there exists, up to isomorphism, a unique rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}(\mathcal{S}')\) with \(\mathcal{S}' = \mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N}(\mathcal{S}'))\), as required. In the following we first state each of the properties~(NC1)-(NC5) and then verify that \(\mathcal{S}\) has this property. (NC1) -- \((X,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}\):\\ This is clearly the case. (NC2) -- \((\{x\},\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}\), for all \(x \in X\):\\ By construction of \(\mathcal{S}\), this is the case. (NC3) -- For every \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}\) with \(H \neq \emptyset\), we have \((H,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}\):\\ Consider any \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}\) with \(H \neq \emptyset\). Then, by construction, there must exist some \(\mathcal{S}' \in \mathfrak{C}\) with \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}'\). In view of (PL3) we must have \((H,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}'\). Thus, by the definition of \(\mathcal{S}\), it follows that \((H,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}\), as required. (NC4) -- For any two distinct \((S_1,H_1), (S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}\) one of (i)~\((S_1,H_1) < (S_2,H_2)\), (ii)~\((S_2,H_2) < (S_1,H_1)\), (iii)~\((S_1 \cup H_1) \cap (S_2 \cup H_2) = \emptyset\), or (iv)~\(S_1 \cap S_2 = \emptyset\) and \(H_1 = H_2 \neq \emptyset\) holds:\\ Consider \((S_1,H_1), (S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}\) with \((S_1,H_1) \neq (S_2,H_2)\). By construction, there must exist \(\mathcal{S}_1,\mathcal{S}_2 \in \mathfrak{C}\) with \((S_1,H_1) \in \mathcal{S}_1\) and \((S_2,H_2) \in \mathcal{S}_2\). Without loss of generality we may assume that \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2\). First we consider the case~\(\mathcal{S}_1 = \mathcal{S}_2\). Then, in view of (PL1) and (PL2), we have \(S_1 \cap S_2 = \emptyset\). Thus, if \(H_1 = H_2 \neq \emptyset\), we are done. Otherwise, in view of (PL3) and (PL1), we must have \(H_1 \cap H_2 = \emptyset\) and, thus, \((S_1 \cup H_1) \cap (S_2 \cup H_2) = \emptyset\), as required. Next consider the case~\(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\). Then there must exist some \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) with \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S,H)\). If \((S,H) = (S_2,H_2)\) we immediately have \((S_1,H_1) \leq (S_2,H_2)\) and are done. So assume \((S,H) \neq (S_2,H_2)\). In view (PL2), this implies \(S \cap S_2 = \emptyset\). Thus, by the definition of~\(\leq\) one of the following must hold: \begin{itemize} \item \(S_1 \cup H_1 \subseteq S\): Then, by the definition of set pairs, \((S_1 \cup H_1) \cap H = \emptyset\) and, in view of \(S \cap S_2 = \emptyset\), also \((S_1 \cup H_1) \cap S_2 = \emptyset\). Thus, if \(S \cap H_2 = \emptyset\) we have \((S_1 \cup H_1) \cap (S_2 \cup H_2) = \emptyset\). So, assume that \(S=H_2\). Then we have \(S_1 \cup H_1 \subseteq H_2\) implying \((S_1,H_1) < (S_2,H_2)\). \item \(S_1 \cup H_1 \subseteq H\): Then, if \(H=H_2\) or \(H=S_2\), we immediately have \((S_1,H_1) < (S_2,H_2)\). Otherwise we must have \(H \cap H_2 = \emptyset\) and \(H \cap S_2 = \emptyset\) and, thus, \((S_1 \cup H_1) \cap (S_2 \cup H_2) = \emptyset\). \item \(S_1 \subsetneq S\) and \(H_1 = H \neq \emptyset\): First note that this implies \(S \cap H_2 = \emptyset\) because otherwise we would have \((S,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) in view of (PL3), which is impossible in view of \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) and (PL2). Also note that if \(H=S_2\) we must have \((S_2,H_2) = (H,\emptyset)\) in view of (PL2), implying that \((S_1,H_1) < (S_2,H_2)\). Finally, if \(H \cap S_2 = \emptyset\) we obtain \((S_1 \cup H_1) \cap (S_2 \cup H_2) = \emptyset\). \end{itemize} This establishes that \(\mathcal{S}\) satisfies~(NC4). (NC5) -- There are no three distinct \((S_1,H_1)\), \((S_2,H_2)\), \((S_3,H_3) \in \mathcal{S}\) with \(H_1 = H_2 = H_3 \neq \emptyset\), \(S_1 \cap S_2 = \emptyset\) and either \(S_1 \cup S_2 \subseteq S_3\) or \((S_1 \cup S_2) \cap S_3 = \emptyset\):\\ Consider \(\mathcal{S}_1, \mathcal{S}_2, \mathcal{S}_3 \in \mathfrak{C}\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \preceq \mathcal{S}_2 \preceq \mathcal{S}_3\). Assume that there exist set pairs \((S_1',H),(S_1'',H) \in \mathcal{S}_1\), \((S_2',H),(S_2'',H) \in \mathcal{S}_2\) and \((S_3',H),(S_3'',H) \in \mathcal{S}_3\) with \(H \neq \emptyset\). By~(PL3), there are precisely these two set pairs contained in each of \(\mathcal{S}_1\), \(\mathcal{S}_2\) and \(\mathcal{S}_3\) for the fixed set~\(H\). In view of (SP2), we may assume without loss of generality that \((S_1',H) \leq (S_2',H) \leq (S_3',H)\) and \((S_1'',H) \leq (S_2'',H) \leq (S_3'',H)\), implying that we have \(S_1' \subseteq S_2' \subseteq S_3'\) and \(S_1'' \subseteq S_2'' \subseteq S_3''\). But then it is impossible to select three distinct set pairs \((S_1,H), (S_2,H), (S_3,H)\) from among \[(S_1',H),(S_1'',H),(S_2',H),(S_2'',H),(S_3',H),(S_3'',H)\] with \(S_1 \cap S_2 = \emptyset\) and either \(S_1 \cup S_2 \subseteq S_3\) or \((S_1 \cup S_2) \cap S_3 = \emptyset\). This establishes that \(\mathcal{S}\) satisfies~(NC5). \end{proof} Recall from Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries} that, for every rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}\), we denote by~\(\widehat{\mathcal{N}}^*\) the associated rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus. \begin{lemma} \label{lem:modify:and:rank} For all chains \(\mathfrak{C}\) in \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) with \(\{(X,\emptyset)\} \in \mathfrak{C}\) there exists, up to isomorphism, a unique ranked \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N},r)\) such that \(\widehat{\mathcal{N}}^* = \mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})\) and \(\mathfrak{C} = \{\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}) : 0 \leq i \leq \sigma(r)\}\). \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Consider the rooted, compressed, phylogenetic \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C}) = ((\widehat{V}^*,\widehat{A}^*),\widehat{\varphi}^*)\) that exists by Lemma~\ref{lem:set:pairs:compressed:network}. To obtain a suitable rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N} = ((V,A),\varphi)\) with \(\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N}) = \mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C})\), we take \(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})\) and modify it. The first modification applies to all \(x \in X\) with \((\{x\},\emptyset) \not \in \mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C})\) and corresponds to reversing the addition of leaves that was illustrated in Figure~\ref{fig:one:nested:x:networks}(b). For each such \(x\), we contract the arc \((u,v) \in \widehat{A}^*\) with \(v = \widehat{\varphi}^*(x)\) and put \(\varphi(x) = u\). The second modification applies to all set pairs \((S,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C})\) such that \((S,\emptyset) \in \mathcal{S}_1 \cap \mathcal{S}_2\) for \(\mathcal{S}_1, \mathcal{S}_2 \in \mathfrak{C}\) with \(\mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2\), \(S \not \in \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_1)\) and \(S \in \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_2)\). This implies, in view of the definition of the polestar systems \(\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\), \(0 \leq i \leq \lvert X \rvert-1\), that we need to modify~\(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})\) to ensure that \(\mathcal{N}\) contains two distinct vertices \(u\) and \(v\) with \((S(u),H(u)) = (S(v),H(v)) = (S,\emptyset)\). This corresponds to reversing the compression that was illustrated in Figure~\ref{fig:one:nested:x:networks}(c). Thus, in view of~(SH2), for each such set pair \((S,H)\), we locate the vertex \(u \in \widehat{V}^*\) with \((S(u),H(u)) = (S,\emptyset)\) and then expand the vertex \(u\) into an arc \((u,v)\) such that the outgoing arcs of \(u\) become the outgoing arcs of \(v\) and, for all \(x \in X\) with \(u=\widehat{\varphi}^*(x)\), we put \(\varphi(x) = v\). Note that the resulting rooted \(X\)-cactus~\(\mathcal{N}\) need no longer be phylogenetic or compressed and that for all ranked \(X\)-cactuses \((\mathcal{N}',r')\) with \(\mathfrak{C} = \{\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}') : 0 \leq i \leq \sigma(r)'\}\) we necessarily have that \(\mathcal{N}'\) is isomorphic to \(\mathcal{N}\) in view of the fact that \(\widehat{\mathcal{N}'}^*\) and \(\widehat{\mathcal{N}}^*\) must be isomorphic by Lemma~\ref{lem:set:pairs:compressed:network}. Thus, it remains to show that there exists a unique ranking~\(r\) of the vertices of \(\mathcal{N}\) to obtain a ranked \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N},r)\) with \(\mathfrak{C} = \{\mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N}) : 0 \leq i \leq \sigma(r)\}\). Let \(c\) denote the length of \(\mathfrak{C}\) and consider the sequence \(\mathcal{S}_0 \prec \mathcal{S}_1 \prec \dots \prec \mathcal{S}_c\) of the polestar systems in~\(\mathfrak{C}\). The value \(r(u)\) for a vertex \(u \in V\) that is not a reticulation vertex is defined by considering the set pair \((S(u),H(u))\) and putting \(r(u)\) to be the smallest index \(0 \leq i \leq c\) with \((S(u),H(u)) \in \mathcal{S}_i\). Note that this is the only available choice for the rank of~\(u\). The value \(r(u)\) of a reticulation vertex \(u\) is defined to be equal to the rank of the parents of \(u\), which, since \(\mathcal{N}\) is an rooted \(X\)-cactus, cannot be reticulation vertices and have been assigned a rank already. Next, we show that the map \(r: V \rightarrow \{0,1,\dots,c\}\) defined above is a ranking of the vertices of~\(\mathcal{N}\). First note that the value \(r(u)\) of a reticulation vertex \(u\) is well-defined. Indeed, in view of~(SH3), we must have \(r(p_1) = r(p_2)\) for the two parents~\(p_1\) and~\(p_2\) of~\(u\), that is, the set pairs \((S(p_1),H(p_1))\) and \((S(p_2),H(p_2))\) with \(H(p_1) = H(p_2) = H\) are both contained in the polestar system \(\mathcal{S}_i\) with the smallest index~\(i\) such that \(H \in \mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}_i)\). This establishes~(TS3). To establish~(TS1), consider any \(x \in X\). By (PL1) there exists a unique set pair \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}_0\) with \(x \in S\). Then, by Lemma~\ref{lem:technical:ordering:consistent}, it suffices to consider the following two cases: \begin{itemize} \item There is precisely one \((S',H') \in \mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C})\) with \((S',H') < (S,H)\). Then we must have \((S',H') \in \mathcal{S}_0\), \(H' = \emptyset\) and \(H=S'\). This implies that there exists a reticulation vertex \(u\) in \(\mathcal{N}\) that is a leaf with \((S(u),H(u)) = (S',H')\) and that \(u\) is the single child of a vertex \(p\) with \((S(p),H(p)) = (S,H)\). Since \(x \in S\) and \(S \cap S' = \emptyset\), we have \(\varphi(x) = p\). By construction, we have \(r(p) = 0\), as required. \item There is no \((S',H') \in \mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C})\) with \((S',H') < (S,H)\). Then there exists a leaf \(u\) of \(\mathcal{N}\) with \((S(u),H(u)) = (S,H)\) and we must have \(\varphi(x) = u\). Again, by construction, we have \(r(u) = 0\), as required. \end{itemize} Now, we turn to~(TS2). Consider an arc \((u,v)\) of \(\mathcal{N}\) such that \(v\) is not a reticulation vertex. As mentioned in Section~\ref{sec:set:pair:systems}, since~\(v\) is a descendant of~\(u\), we have \((S(v),H(v)) \leq (S(u),H(u))\). If \((S(v),H(v)) = (S(u),H(u))\) then, by the construction of \(\mathcal{N}\) from \(\mathcal{N}(\mathfrak{C})\), \(u\) is a reticulation vertex whose single child is \(v\) and there exist \(0 \leq i < j \leq c\) with \(r(v) = i\) and \(r(u) = r(p_1) = r(p_2) = j\), where~\(p_1\) and~\(p_2\) are the two parents of~\(u\). Similarly, in view of Lemma~\ref{lem:technical:ordering:consistent}, if \((S(v),H(v)) < (S(u),H(u))\) there also exist \(0 \leq i < j \leq c\) with \(r(v) = i\) and \(r(u) = j\). This establishes~(TS2). The last property required for the map \(r\) to be a ranking is that, for all \(j \in \{0,1,\dots,c\}\), there exists a vertex \(u\) of \(\mathcal{N}\) with \(r(u) = j\). (TS1)~implies that this is the case for \(j=0\). So, consider \(j \geq 1\). Then, in view of Lemma~\ref{lem:technical:rank:function:graded:poset}, there exists some \((S,H) \in \mathcal{S}_j\) with \((S,H) \not \in \mathcal{S}_i\) for all \(i < j\). Let \(u\) be a vertex of \(\mathcal{N}\) with \((S(u),H(u)) = (S,H)\). If \(u\) is not a reticulation vertex, we have \(r(u) = j\). If \(u\) is a reticulation vertex, we have \(r(u) = r(p_1) = r(p_2) = j\) for the two parents \(p_1\) and \(p_2\) of \(u\) since, by (PL3), \((S(p_1),H(p_1))\) and \((S(p_2),H(p_2))\) are also both contained in \(\mathcal{S}_j\) but not in \(\mathcal{S}_i\) for all \(i < j\). To finish the proof of the lemma, we show that \(\mathcal{S}_j = \mathcal{S}_j(\mathcal{N})\) for all \(j \in \{0,1,\dots,c\}\). We clearly have \(\mathcal{S}_c = \{(X,\emptyset)\} = \mathcal{S}_c(\mathcal{N})\). Consider \(j < c\). In view of Lemma~\ref{lem:ranked:networks:yield:partition:like}, (PL1) and (PL2) it suffices to show that, for all \(u \in V_j\), we have \((S(u),H(u)) \in \mathcal{S}_j\). Let \(p\) be the unique parent of \(u\). By the definition of \(V_j\) given in Section~\ref{sec:set:pair:systems}, we have \(r(u) = i \leq j\) and \(r(p) = k > j\). In particular, we have \((S(u),H(u)) \in \mathcal{S}_i\) and \((S(p),H(p)) \in \mathcal{S}_k\). In view of \(\mathcal{S}_i \preceq \mathcal{S}_j \prec \mathcal{S}_k\) there must exist \((S',H') \in \mathcal{S}_j\) with \((S(u),H(u)) \leq (S',H')\) and also some \((S'',H'') \in \mathcal{S}_k\) with \((S',H') \leq (S'',H'')\). Since \(p\) is the parent of \(u\) we have \((S(u),H(u)) \leq (S(p),H(p))\) and, since all set pairs in \(\mathcal{S}(\mathfrak{C})\) correspond to at least one vertex of \(\mathcal{N}\), we must necessarily have \((S'',H'') = (S(p),H(p))\). It follows that either \((S(u),H(u)) = (S',H') = (S(p),H(p))\) or \((S(u),H(u)) = (S',H') < (S(p),H(p))\) holds, implying \((S(u),H(u)) \in \mathcal{S}_j\), as required. \end{proof} As an immediate consequence of Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1} we obtain Theorem~\ref{prop:pairwise:trees}, which we restate in the following corollary using poset terminology. \begin{corollary} \label{cor:chains:rooted:x:trees} There is a one-to-one correspondence between chains in the graded poset \((\mathfrak{B}(X),\sqsubseteq)\) that contain~\(\{X\}\) and isomorphism classes of ranked \(X\)-trees. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} In view of the fact that a rooted \(X\)-cactus \(\mathcal{N}\) is a rooted \(X\)-tree if and only if the associated set pair system \(\mathcal{S}(\mathcal{N})\) does not contain a set pair \((S,H)\) with \(H \neq \emptyset\), it follows by Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1} that ranked \(X\)-trees correspond to chains \(\mathfrak{C}\) in the poset \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\) with \(\{(X,\emptyset)\} \in \mathfrak{C}\) and \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S})=\emptyset\) for all \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{C}\). This implies, by Corollary~\ref{cor:poset:partitions}, that ranked \(X\)-trees correspond to chains in the poset~\((\mathfrak{B}(X),\sqsubseteq)\) that contain the partition~\(\{X\}\). \end{proof} \section{The space of equidistant $X$-cactuses} \label{sec:network:space} We now define equidistant-cactus space, $\mathfrak{N}(X)$, and show that it is a \text{CAT}(0)-metric space. The construction of $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ follows the outline presented at the start of Section~\ref{sec:encoding}. More specifically, we put \(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X) = \mathfrak{P}(X) - \{\{(X,\emptyset)\}\}\) and let \(\mathcal{F}(\preceq)\) denote the set of chains in the subposet \((\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\preceq)\) of the poset \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\). We then define $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ to be the orthant space of the order complex of \((\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\preceq)\). Figure~\ref{fig:orthants:networks:3:elements} gives an example of the structure of $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ for $X=\{a,b,c\}$. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.9]{orthants_networks_3_elements.pdf} \caption{The structure of \(\mathfrak{N}(X)\) for \(X=\{a,b,c\}\). The six 2-dimensional orthants are drawn shaded. Each of these 2-dimensional orthants corresponds to an isomorphism class of binary ranked \(X\)-cactuses. Each axis corresponds to the indicated polestar system on \(X\).} \label{fig:orthants:networks:3:elements} \end{figure} \begin{theorem} \label{theo:metric:network:space} \(\mathfrak{N}(X) = (\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))},D_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))})\) is a \(\text{CAT}(0)\)-metric space whose points are in one-to-one correspondence with isomorphism classes of equidistant \(X\)-cactuses. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} As an immediate consequence of the definition of a chain as a set of pairwise comparable elements in a poset, we have that \((\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))\) is a flag complex (cf. Section~\ref{sub:sec:orthant:spaces}). Hence, \((\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))},D_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))})\) is a \(\text{CAT}(0)\)-metric space. It remains to show that the points of \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) are in one-to-one correspondence with isomorphism classes of equidistant \(X\)-cactuses. Every \(\omega \in \mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) corresponds, up to isomorphism, to a unique equidistant \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N},t)\) as follows. Put \(\sigma = \lvert \text{supp}(\omega) \rvert\) and \(\mathfrak{C} = \text{supp}(\omega) \cup \{\{(X,\emptyset)\}\}\). Note that \(\mathfrak{C}\) is a chain in the poset \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\). Consider the sequence \[\mathcal{S}_0 \prec \mathcal{S}_1 \prec \mathcal{S}_2 \prec \dots \prec \mathcal{S}_{\sigma} = \{(X,\emptyset)\}\] of the set pair systems in \(\mathfrak{C}\). By~Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1}, there exists, up to isomorphism, a unique ranked \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N}=((V,A),\varphi),r)\) with \(\sigma(r) = \sigma\) and \(\mathcal{S}_i = \mathcal{S}_i(\mathcal{N})\) for all \(i \in \{0,1,2,\dots,\sigma\}\). The time-stamp function~\(t\) on the vertices of \(\mathcal{N}\) is then defined by putting \[t(v) = \begin{cases} 0 &\text{if} \ r(v) = 0\\ \sum_{i=0}^{r(v)-1} \omega(\mathcal{S}_i) &\text{if} \ r(v) > 0 \end{cases}\] for all \(v \in V\). Note that every \(\omega' \in \mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) with \(\omega' \neq \omega\) and \(\text{supp}(\omega') = \text{supp}(\omega)\) yields the same ranked \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N},r)\) but a time-stamp function~\(t' \neq t\) on the vertices of~\(\mathcal{N}\). Also note that every equidistant \(X\)-cactus~\((\mathcal{N},t)\) arises from some \(\omega \in \mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) as described above. \end{proof} To illustrate the proof of Theorem~\ref{theo:metric:network:space}, consider the equidistant \(X\)-cactus \((\mathcal{N},t)\) on \(X=\{a,b,c,d,e\}\) in Figure~\ref{fig:equidistant:network}, which arises from the point \(\omega \in \mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) with \(\text{supp}(\omega) = \{\mathcal{S}_0,\mathcal{S}_1,\mathcal{S}_2,\mathcal{S}_3\}\), where \begin{align*} \mathcal{S}_3 &= \{(\{a\},\{b\}),(\{b\},\emptyset),(\{c,d,e\},\{b\})\}\\ \mathcal{S}_2 &= \{(\{a\},\{b\}),(\{b\},\emptyset),(\{c\},\{b\}),(\{d,e\},\emptyset)\}\\ \mathcal{S}_1 &= \{(\{a\},\{b\}),(\{b\},\emptyset),(\{c\},\{b\}),(\{d\},\emptyset),(\{e\},\emptyset)\}\\ \mathcal{S}_0 &= \{(\{a\},\emptyset),(\{b\},\emptyset),(\{c\},\emptyset),(\{d\},\emptyset),(\{e\},\emptyset)\}, \end{align*} and \(\omega(\mathcal{S}_0) = 0.8\), \(\omega(\mathcal{S}_1) = 0.4\), \(\omega(\mathcal{S}_2) = 1.2\), \(\omega(\mathcal{S}_3) = 0.6\). In general, as equidistant-cactus space is high-dimensional, for $\lvert X \rvert \geq 4$ its structure is not easy to visualize. However, to get some insights it can be useful to consider the so-called \emph{link of the origin} \[\mathfrak{L}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))} = \{\omega \in \mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))} : \sum_{\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X)} \omega(\mathcal{S}) = 1\},\] a geometric realization of the abstract simplicial complex~\((\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))\). Since \((\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))\) is a flag complex, the structure of \(\mathfrak{L}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) is completely determined by the graph with vertex set \(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X)\) in which two distinct vertices are connected by an edge if and only if they are comparable by~\(\preceq\). In Figure~\ref{figure:link:n:4} we present the link of the origin of $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ for $\lvert X \rvert=4$. Note that, for this case, we have $\lvert\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X)\rvert = 44$ and that there are 14~vertices that correspond to rooted \(X\)-trees. The shaded vertices in Figure~\ref{figure:link:n:4} together with the oval vertex induce a subgraph that is isomorphic to the graph corresponding to the link of the origin of $\tau$-space (i.e. \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\)), which is isomorphic to a subdivision of the Petersen graph (see also \cite[Fig.~3]{GD16}). \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.43]{link_n_4.pdf} \caption{The graph that determines the structure of the link of the origin \(\mathfrak{L}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) for \(X=\{a,b,c,d\}\). The oval vertex is adjacent to all other vertices. The ranked \(X\)-cactus displayed for each vertex corresponds to the chain \(\{\mathcal{S},\{(X,\emptyset)\}\}\) for each \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X)\).} \label{figure:link:n:4} \end{figure} We conclude this section with a corollary of Theorem~\ref{theo:metric:network:space} that describes a relationship between $\tau$-space and equidistant-cactus space. \begin{corollary} \label{cor:tau:space} The orthants of \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\) are in one-to-one correspondence with the orthants \(\mathfrak{O}(A)\) of \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) for those \(A \in \mathcal{F}(\preceq)\) with \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) = \emptyset\) for all \(\mathcal{S} \in A\). \end{corollary} \begin{proof} By definition, the orthants of \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))}\) are in one-to-one correspondence with chains in \((\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\sqsubseteq)\). By Corollary~\ref{cor:poset:partitions} and the definition of \(\mathcal{F}(\preceq)\), such chains are in one-to-one correspondence with chains \(\mathfrak{C}\) in \((\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\preceq)\) for which \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) = \emptyset\) for all \(\mathcal{S} \in \mathfrak{C}\). Again by definition, the latter chains are in one-to-one correspondence with the orthants \(\mathfrak{O}(A)\) of \(\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))}\) for those \(A \in \mathcal{F}(\preceq)\) with \(\mathcal{H}(\mathcal{S}) = \emptyset\) for all \(\mathcal{S} \in A\). \end{proof} We remark that the characterization of geodesic paths in \text{CAT}(0)-orthant spaces in \cite[Corollary~6.19]{MOP15a} holds for equidistant-cactus space~\(\mathfrak{N}(X)\). This implies that, for any two points in \(\mathfrak{N}(X)\) that correspond to equidistant \(X\)-trees, all points on the unique geodesic path between these two points also correspond to equidistant \(X\)-trees. In other words, \((\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{B}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\sqsubseteq))},D_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))})\) is a convex subspace of \(\mathfrak{N}(X) = (\mathfrak{M}_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))},D_{(\mathfrak{P}^{\circ}(X),\mathcal{F}(\preceq))})\). \section{Conclusion} \label{sec:conclusion} We have introduced the space $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ of equidistant $X$-cactuses. By deriving an encoding for ranked $X$-cactuses, we obtained $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ as an orthant space and proved that it is a \text{CAT}(0)-metric space. Thus, we can compute the distance in $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ between any two equidistant $X$-cactuses and the unique geodesic path between them in polynomial time \cite{MOP15a}, compute approximations of the Fr\'echet mean and variance as well as of the median of a set of equidistant \(X\)-cactuses \cite{bacak2014computing,MOP15a}, and a central limit theorem holds \cite{barden2018logarithm}. There are several directions for future research and open questions including: \begin{itemize} \item It would be interesting to count the number~\(\nu_n\) of isomorphism classes of binary ranked \(X\)-cactuses with rankings of size~$\lvert X \rvert-1$. In view of Theorem~\ref{theo:chains:networks:1:to:1}, this is equivalent to counting the number of maximal chains in the graded poset \((\mathfrak{P}(X),\preceq)\). Counting chains in certain types of posets is a well-studied problem (see e.g. \cite{S94a}). The values of \(\nu_n\) for \(n = 1,2,3,4\) are~1, 1, 6, 72. \item It is known that the link of the origin of phylogenetic tree space as defined in \cite{BHV01} has the homotopy type of the wedge of spheres. It would be interesting to work out the homotopy type of the link of the origin of $\mathfrak{N}(X)$, and also what other properties it might enjoy (for example, is it Cohen-Macaulay as with the tree-space defined in \cite{BHV01}?) \item As was pointed out in~\cite{DDF19a}, there is a connection between the space of circular split collections defined in \cite{DP17a} and a certain type of unrooted phylogenetic networks called level-1 networks. Since these unrooted level-1 networks can be regarded as unrooted $X$-cactuses, it would be interesting to investigate if there are some connections between $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ and the space of circular split collections. \item It would be interesting to define and understand the geometry of spaces of more complicated phylogenetic networks with arc lengths. Two obvious candidates for such an investigation are rooted level-2 networks and tree-child, time consistent networks (see \cite[Chapter 10]{S16a} for definitions). Moreover, one could try to relax the requirement that the phylogenetic networks are equidistant. \item How does the distance between equidistant \(X\)-cactuses in $\mathfrak{N}(X)$ compare to other distance measures between phylogenetic networks? For example, it was shown in \cite{amenta2007approximating} that the weighted Robinson-Foulds distance between phylogenetic trees \cite{robinson1979comparison} is a $\sqrt{2}$-approximation of the distance between phylogenetic trees in the tree space defined in \cite{BHV01}. \end{itemize} \subsubsection*{Acknowledgments} KTH and VM thank the Department of Mathematics at City College of New York (City University of New York) and the American Museum of Natural History for their hospitality. MO is partially supported by the US National Science Foundation (DMS 1847271). This work was supported by a grant from the Simons Foundation (\#355824, Megan Owen). KAS thanks the Simons Foundation (\#316124) and the US National Science Foundation (\#1461094) for research and travel support. \bibliographystyle{plain}

1. Introduction {#sec1-sensors-19-03333} =============== Detonation velocity is the propagation speed of a shockwave that is continuously driven through an explosive medium via exothermic chemical reactions \[[@B1-sensors-19-03333]\]. For researchers concerned with the characterisation and assessment of explosive materials, detonation velocity can be a particularly elucidative parameter \[[@B2-sensors-19-03333]\]. In order to measure detonation velocity accurately, methods should be as non-invasive as possible, with fast read-out speeds and reliable calibration. Throughout many decades, several detonation velocity measurement techniques have been demonstrated. Long established techniques include ionisation or piezoelectric timing pins \[[@B1-sensors-19-03333]\], streak and framing cameras \[[@B1-sensors-19-03333]\], and continuous resistance electrical probes \[[@B3-sensors-19-03333]\]. More recent methods, often employing optical fibres, include fibre-coupled light detection \[[@B4-sensors-19-03333]\], drilled fibre probes \[[@B5-sensors-19-03333]\] and aluminium coated fibres (as timing pins) \[[@B6-sensors-19-03333]\]. In recent years, embedded chirped fibre Bragg gratings (CFBG) have attracted significant attention in the industry \[[@B7-sensors-19-03333],[@B8-sensors-19-03333],[@B9-sensors-19-03333],[@B10-sensors-19-03333]\]. Due to their small size, simple setup and continuous measurement capabilities, they are a convenient alternative to many of the aforementioned techniques, which are discrete, too bulky to embed, not immune to electromagnetic interference or require a direct optical sight-line. Whilst the CFBG method of measuring detonation velocity has been successfully demonstrated a number of times, it has not yet undergone optimization to determine the optimal CFBG design parameters. In particular, spurious effects towards the end of the grating erasure can sometimes arise which are not representative of the behaviour of the detonation front and can be minimised through appropriate grating design. In this paper, we discuss and demonstrate the effects of CFBG bandwidth and reflectivity on measurement linearity during detonation. It is shown through simulations and explosive tests that high bandwidth and low reflectivity CFBGs are less susceptible to these spurious non-linear end effects. We also show, through simulation, that CFBG apodisation is unlikely to be beneficial for detonation velocity measurements. As a further demonstration of these findings, we measure detonation velocity with a 24 cm optimised CFBG; the longest CFBG test of this kind so far. 2. CFBG Concept and Simulation {#sec2-sensors-19-03333} ============================== 2.1. Basic Concept {#sec2dot1-sensors-19-03333} ------------------ A chirped fibre Bragg grating (CFBG) is a highly dispersive optical filtering device, where stop-band wavelength components are spatially distributed along a length of optical fibre. This is achieved via inscription of a periodic refractive index change in the core of the fibre, where the periodicity is monotonically increased or decreased along the fibre length \[[@B11-sensors-19-03333]\]. Since the CFBG bandwidth and length are coupled by the *chirp-rate* of the grating, any event which results in the physical destruction of a part of the CFBG will also result in a proportional drop in the reflection bandwidth. This change in bandwidth can be monitored as a change in the total reflected power, using the setup shown in [Figure 1](#sensors-19-03333-f001){ref-type="fig"}. In this case, a CFBG is illuminated with a broadband signal, such as that from an amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) source, which exceeds the bandwidth of the grating. The reflected light from within the CFBG bandwidth is then collected using a circulator and measured on a photodetector. Due to the significant peak-pressures involved, if a CFBG were mounted on/in a detonating explosive device, the traversing detonation-front would progressively consume it and its reflection bandwidth would decrease accordingly. By monitoring the total reflected power during detonation, with a sufficiently fast detector and oscilloscope, a continuous detonation-front position vs. time can be recorded and used to infer the detonation velocity \[[@B7-sensors-19-03333],[@B8-sensors-19-03333],[@B9-sensors-19-03333],[@B10-sensors-19-03333]\]. In an ideal case, the change in reflected power would be linearly proportional to the CFBG length, i.e., when the power has dropped by half, the shock-front is halfway through the grating. This is rarely the case for real measurements---primarily due to spectral variations in the source power and CFBG reflectivity---but also because of intrinsic non-linearities owed to the specific design of the grating. Simulations demonstrating these intrinsic non-linearities are shown in the following section. 2.2. Bandwidth Non-Linearity {#sec2dot2-sensors-19-03333} ---------------------------- Whilst a particular CFBG may have a linearly increasing resonance wavelength, it is not necessarily the case that this linear chirp-rate corresponds to a linearity between length and bandwidth. On this basis, when the grating has been cut-down to its terminal grating plane, the reflected bandwidth would become extremely narrow. This contradicts the behaviour of un-chirped, uniform fibre Bragg gratings (UFBGs), whose terminal grating plane will offer very little in the way of wavelength selectivity and be extremely broadband. A simulation in [Figure 2](#sensors-19-03333-f002){ref-type="fig"} shows how the reflected power scales with length for a 10 mm, $99\%$ reflectivity, 10 nm bandwidth, unapodised CFBG. This simulation was carried out using the transfer-matrix (T-matrix) method \[[@B12-sensors-19-03333],[@B13-sensors-19-03333]\], where the CFBG spectrum was constructed, one sub-grating at a time, and integrated to give an accurate reflected power vs. length relationship. It can be seen that, when the CFBG reaches a certain length (\~1.5 mm), the reflected power begins to scale non-linearly. This is accompanied by an 8.7% offset in the gradient when compared to the ideal linear case. The non-linearity shown here occurs when the CFBG bandwidth approaches the bandwidth of a UFBG with the same refractive index modulation. At this point, the CFBG ceases to behave as a chirped grating and transitions into the regime of a uniform grating. The corresponding gradient deflection occurs due to depletion of the signal power reaching beyond the uniform grating regime at the launch end. This is a relatively extreme case, but the effect it demonstrates could become a limiting factor where detonation velocity measurements are required to a high degree of accuracy. Whilst a simple two-point measurement of average detonation velocity could still be inferred from this data, as long as the start and end can be identified accurately (akin to the red dashed line in [Figure 2](#sensors-19-03333-f002){ref-type="fig"}b), non-steady-state regimes would require this gradient offset and nonlinearity to be decoupled. In order for the CFBG reflected power to scale as linearly as possible, there are two important properties which require optimisation:The length over which this non-linearity occurs (primarily affected by CFBG bandwidth)The degree of non-linearity over this region, equivalent to the gradient deflection (primarily affected by refractive index modulation i.e., CFBG reflectivity) For an unapodised uniform grating with an effective refractive index change of $\delta n$, the full bandwidth is given by:$$\Delta\lambda_{uniform} = \frac{\lambda_{B}^{2}}{\pi n_{eff}}\sqrt{\left( \frac{\pi\delta n}{\lambda_{B}} \right)^{2} + \left( \frac{\pi}{L} \right)^{2}}$$ where $\lambda_{B}$ is the Bragg wavelength, $n_{eff}$ is the effective index of the fibre and *L* is the grating length \[[@B14-sensors-19-03333]\]. For a chirped grating with constant chirp-rate ($CR$), the bandwidth is approximated as:$$\Delta\lambda_{chirped} = L \times CR.$$ By plotting these formulas as a function of grating length, it is possible to see the point at which a chirped grating will begin to behave as a uniform grating. [Figure 3](#sensors-19-03333-f003){ref-type="fig"} shows the length--bandwidth relationship of UFBGs and CFBGs over a range of chirp-rates and index modulations. The intersecting region shows possible solutions, where the CFBG bandwidth is equal to the UFBG bandwidth and hence the length at which the CFBG reflected power will begin to scale non-linearly with length. For clarity, this analysis is only shown over a 10 mm length range. However, it should be noted that these bandwidth characteristics are general for any CFBG length since it is the chirp-rate and index modulation that are the primary determinants. It is seen here that the longest non-linear region (\~4.7 mm on this plot) corresponds to a low chirp-rate and a high index-modulation CFBG. In contrast, the shortest non-linear region (\~1.1 mm in this plot) corresponds to a high chirp-rate, low index-modulation CFBG. Therefore, for a chirped grating of a given length, the uniform grating region is minimised by choosing a *low-reflectivity*, *high-bandwidth* design. Once the CFBG is in the uniform bandwidth regime, the reflected power scales non-linearly with length because the signal power is not being evenly distributed throughout the grating. For uniform gratings with a very high refractive index modulation, the penetration depth is short and only a small fraction of signal light is able to interact with the back-end. However, a uniform FBG with a very low refractive index modulation will distribute an almost equal share of signal light across the entire grating length. [Figure 4](#sensors-19-03333-f004){ref-type="fig"} shows a simulated plot of reflected power vs. grating length for a range of UFBG reflectivities. This is indicative of the CFBG reflected power over the non-linear end region. It can be seen that for low-reflectivity uniform gratings the power scales more linearly than for high-reflectivity gratings, where the reflected power distribution becomes increasingly front-loaded. This signal depletion mechanism is also responsible for the total gradient offset seen in [Figure 2](#sensors-19-03333-f002){ref-type="fig"}. Since a disproportionate amount of signal light is reflected from the uniform grating region, power contributions from the rest of the grating are reduced. This means that, when half the grating has been consumed, the total reflected power will still be greater than half the initial power. Clearly, for any CFBG, the extent of non-linearity and gradient offset is minimised with a *low-reflectivity* design. To demonstrate the impact of reflectivity and chirp-rate on erasure linearity, the simulation shown in [Figure 2](#sensors-19-03333-f002){ref-type="fig"} was repeated for two different CFBG designs. One, plotted in [Figure 5](#sensors-19-03333-f005){ref-type="fig"}a, shows a 10 mm long, 99% reflectivity, 20 nm bandwidth CFBG. The other, plotted in [Figure 5](#sensors-19-03333-f005){ref-type="fig"}b, shows a 10 mm long, 20% reflectivity, 10 nm bandwidth CFBG. It is apparent, especially in the case of the low-reflectivity CFBG, that the non-linear region is drastically reduced in comparison to [Figure 2](#sensors-19-03333-f002){ref-type="fig"}, which shows a 10 mm long, 99% reflectivity, 10 nm bandwidth grating. As a quantitative measure of the reduced non-linear effect, a gradient offset has been measured for all three simulations and can be compared. In this case, the high-reflectivity, low chirp-rate CFBG in [Figure 2](#sensors-19-03333-f002){ref-type="fig"} shows a gradient offset of 8.7%, the higher chirp-rate grating in [Figure 5](#sensors-19-03333-f005){ref-type="fig"}a shows a gradient offset of approximately 6.2% and the low-reflectivity CFBG in [Figure 5](#sensors-19-03333-f005){ref-type="fig"}b shows a gradient offset of less than 0.1%. These design considerations are also pertinent to the more recent implementations of the CFBG system, which use dispersion techniques to resolve the CFBG spectrum at high speed \[[@B15-sensors-19-03333]\]. In this instance, it should be recognised that, particularly for high reflectivity CFBGs, the percentage bandwidth change is not directly equivalent to the percentage length change of the grating. Instead, limitations on the minimum bandwidth of a coherent section of the grating (Equation ([1](#FD1-sensors-19-03333){ref-type="disp-formula"})) cause a billowing out of the reflection spectrum at either end. This is illustrated in [Figure 6](#sensors-19-03333-f006){ref-type="fig"}. 2.3. Apodisation {#sec2dot3-sensors-19-03333} ---------------- Many applications of CFBGs require low group-delay-ripple characteristics. This is often achieved by tapering the refractive index modulation at either end of the grating, known as apodisation \[[@B16-sensors-19-03333]\]. The ubiquity of apodisation, especially in the telecoms sphere, means that CFBG suppliers may apodise their gratings by default. For this reason, the effects of apodisation for detonation velocity sensing are worth considering. [Figure 7](#sensors-19-03333-f007){ref-type="fig"} shows a simulation of how the reflected power scales with grating length for a 10 mm long, 10 nm bandwidth, $20\%$ reflectivity CFBG with a $10\%$ sine-apodisation at each end. This low-reflectivity design was chosen so that the effects of apodisation could be isolated from any bandwidth non-linearities. In this plot, the effect of the sine-apodisation is seen as a roll-in/roll-off of the reflected power as the grating ends are consumed. This is because the tapered refractive index modulation at the each end of the grating contributes proportionally less to the total reflected power. If these end-effects are left unaccounted for, then the predicted detonation velocity could be erroneous. This can be seen in [Figure 7](#sensors-19-03333-f007){ref-type="fig"} by comparing the solid blue line from the apodised CFBG, with the dashed red line which connects the *true* start and end points of the grating. The difference in gradient of the two lines demonstrates how the loss of information at the apodised ends can lead to a misinterpretation of the event duration and yield a velocity which is higher than the real value. Furthermore, any potentially favourable spectral characteristics are lost when the first apodised end is destroyed and the group-delay-ripples reappear. For this reason, apodisation is unnecessary for CFBGs in detonation velocity measurements and should be avoided. 3. Experimental Procedure {#sec3-sensors-19-03333} ========================= 3.1. Setup {#sec3dot1-sensors-19-03333} ---------- In order to demonstrate optimal CFBG parameters for detonation velocity measurements, an explosive trial was set up. In these tests, various CFBGs were immersed in a liquid explosive---sensitised nitromethane---which was contained in a 31.75 mm outside-diameter copper cylinder and initiated from underneath via a plastic-explosive booster. The height of the cylinder was \~300 mm and the wall thickness was 3.18 mm. A nylon lid at the top of the cylinder was drilled to accommodate a number of CFBGs, which had each been spliced onto a sacrificial length of fibre. Inside the copper cylinder, the CFBGs were hanging freely and were fully exposed to the nitromethane. To help the gratings hang straight (to within an estimated uncertainty of $\pm 2^{{^\circ}}$), the polymer coating was removed prior to insertion into the cylinder---this drastically reduces the tendency of the fibres to bend. A photograph of the setup is shown in [Figure 8](#sensors-19-03333-f008){ref-type="fig"}. These experiments were designed to test the CFBG probes in an ideal environment:Choosing a liquid explosive allowed the probes to be easily embedded without invasive adhesion techniques.Nitromethane is well-characterised and is known to have detonation velocity above the acoustic velocity of fused-silica \[[@B17-sensors-19-03333],[@B18-sensors-19-03333]\].CFBGs were mounted to hang in the top half of the cylinder---a region which is expected to maintain a steady-state detonation (constant detonation velocity). All of these factors combined to make a confirmatory test, where the detonation velocity can be compared against expected values and any intrinsic non-linearities from the CFBG design would be evident. To provide a comparative velocity measurement, each CFBG test was done in conjunction with a photonic doppler velocimetry test (PDV) \[[@B19-sensors-19-03333]\]. PDV is a well-established measurement technique which is typically used to measure surface velocities, but can be used to measure detonation velocity in this idealised scenario \[[@B20-sensors-19-03333]\]. 3.2. Equipment and CFBG Details {#sec3dot2-sensors-19-03333} ------------------------------- The interrogation system used to measure the CFBG reflected power during detonation is shown in [Figure 1](#sensors-19-03333-f001){ref-type="fig"}. In this case, a non-gain-flattened ASE source was used to illuminate the CFBG, with the reflected light collected on a 150 MHz InGaAs Thorlabs PDA10CF detector. The voltage from the detector was monitored using a 10-bit National Instruments PXIe-5160 DAQ (Data Acquisition) card, which was set to a sample rate of $1.25$ GSamples/s. Many of the data were subsequently low-pass filtered with a 20 MHz cutoff frequency. This was done to remove unwanted high-frequency noise and still observe non-linearities that occur over sub-mm length scales. A piezo-electric disk was fixed to the copper cylinder and provided a trigger impulse for the DAQ card. When necessary, an optical attenuator was used prior to the grating to keep the initial reflected power below the detector saturation. Nine CFBGs were tested in nine separate experiments. Each CFBG was designed to have a 5 nm, 10 nm or 20 nm bandwidth and a \<40%, 60--70% or \>95% peak reflectivity. All gratings were \~120 mm long. The spectrum of each CFBG is shown in [Figure 9](#sensors-19-03333-f009){ref-type="fig"}, along with the design specification of each. As a final demonstration of the optimised CFBG, a 240 mm, $37\%$ reflectivity, 20 nm bandwidth grating, was tested. The long length of the grating meant that the detonation velocity could be measured throughout the majority of the event, with the CFBG hanging just \~10 mm above the booster. All of these gratings were fabricated using a continuous writing technique, which employs a 1-m-range translation stage and interferometric position monitoring to achieve a high spatial precision \[[@B21-sensors-19-03333]\]. 4. Results and Discussion {#sec4-sensors-19-03333} ========================= The raw data from a 20 nm bandwidth, 96% reflectivity, 115 mm CFBG test are shown in [Figure 10](#sensors-19-03333-f010){ref-type="fig"}. In this plot, which is typical of all the CFBG test data, the presence of optical signal noise is clear. At the start of recording, when the grating is fully intact, the standard deviation of this noise is \~1% of the full signal range. It is our speculation that this noise is the result of an incoherent ASE source interacting with a structure which is prone to phase errors and time-delay fluctuations \[[@B22-sensors-19-03333]\]. Since the ASE source was not gain-flattened, the raw data are S-shaped in correspondence with the variations in the power spectral density (PSD). To calibrate these data, the ASE illuminated CFBG reflection spectrum was integrated as sections of the bandwidth were digitally removed. A simulation of this process is shown in [Figure 11](#sensors-19-03333-f011){ref-type="fig"}a. For a CFBG with a known chirp-rate, this calibration data can be compared with the experimental data to get a distance vs. time plot of the detonation shock-front. Based on the discussions in [Section 2.2](#sec2dot2-sensors-19-03333){ref-type="sec"}, it is clear that this is a crude calibration technique. For a more accurate calibration curve, the spectrum of the grating should be reconstructed in a simulation and then integrated as chunks of the simulated grating (not bandwidth) are removed. This concept is demonstrated in [Figure 11](#sensors-19-03333-f011){ref-type="fig"}b. However, the reconstruction of a grating based on a reflection spectrum is not straight forward---instead, we intend to keep the former, cruder calibration method and show that it is a reasonable approximation for the optimised CFBG design cases demonstrated here. [Figure 12](#sensors-19-03333-f012){ref-type="fig"} shows the calibrated data from three 20 nm CFBG tests with a range of reflectivities. Each dataset has undergone a linear regression fit, with the residuals plotted underneath and the non-linear region highlighted. To better visualise the underlying response of the grating, a 20 MHz low-pass filter was also applied. Accompanying the plots is [Table 1](#sensors-19-03333-t001){ref-type="table"}, which shows a numerical comparison of each CFBG based on analysis of the residuals. The "*Fluctuation over Highlighted Region*" column shows the peak-to-peak height of the length residuals over the non-linear region (relative to the total length). This is equivalent to the extent of gradient offset in the original data. The "Relative Length of Highlighted Region" column shows the percentage of the end of the grating that appears to be operating in the uniform grating regime. Based on the power depletion argument in [Section 2.2](#sec2dot2-sensors-19-03333){ref-type="sec"}, the extent of the gradient fluctuation was anticipated to be greater for higher reflectivity gratings. This trend is noticeable in [Table 1](#sensors-19-03333-t001){ref-type="table"}, where a $2.01 \pm 0.04\%$ fluctuation in the 96% reflectivity grating drops down to just $0.48 \pm 0.09\%$ in the 59% reflectivity grating. Beyond this, there is no measurable difference between the 22% and 59% reflectivity CFBGs, which is likely to be a result of the fluctuations becoming comparable in magnitude to the total noise levels. In [Figure 3](#sensors-19-03333-f003){ref-type="fig"}, it is clear that the length of the CFBG non-linear region is relatively insensitive to changes in the effective index (reflectivity). This is reflected in [Table 1](#sensors-19-03333-t001){ref-type="table"}, which shows a modest decline of $0.87 \pm 0.63\%$ from 96% to 22% reflectivity. The average velocities, gathered from each linear regression of the data, also agree well with the velocities obtained from the PDV results. The 96% reflectivity grating appears to yield the least accurate results, showing a velocity discrepancy of 1.6% (below the PDV result), whereas the 22% reflectivity grating is within 0.01%, measuring a velocity of 6.212 km/s (to 3 d.p.). A similar comparison for CFBGs with different bandwidths is shown in [Figure 13](#sensors-19-03333-f013){ref-type="fig"} and [Table 2](#sensors-19-03333-t002){ref-type="table"}. In this case, each grating has a reflectivity of 59--68%, and the bandwidths are 5 nm, 10 nm and 20 nm. Due to the bandwidth argument demonstrated in [Figure 3](#sensors-19-03333-f003){ref-type="fig"}, it was expected that a higher bandwidth (higher chirp-rate) CFBG would exhibit non-linear behaviour over a shorter distance. This concept is reinforced by the data in [Table 2](#sensors-19-03333-t002){ref-type="table"}, which show a decline in the non-linear length by more than a factor of two from 5 to 20 nm bandwidths. Interestingly, there is also a noticeable decrease in the fluctuation amplitude from 1.44% to 0.48% for broader bandwidths. This is because the power depletion effect scales proportionally as the uniform grating region becomes enlarged i.e., for narrower bandwidths. This results in an increased *absolute* residual fluctuation. When the average velocity data is compared to the PDV results for each of the various bandwidth CFBGs, there is little to tell them apart. All three gratings measured a velocity that was within 0.35% of the PDV results---a total average of 6.238 km/s. As a final demonstration of this system, a 240 mm CFBG, was tested, which had a 20 nm bandwidth and a $37\%$ reflectivity. This design was chosen to further demonstrate an optimised CFBG---with low-reflectivity and broad-bandwidth---as well as to demonstrate the scalability of the CFBG technique to longer lengths. The results are shown in [Figure 14](#sensors-19-03333-f014){ref-type="fig"}, with the numerical analysis shown in [Table 3](#sensors-19-03333-t003){ref-type="table"}. The fluctuation of $0.26 \pm 0.04\%$ is consistent with the other low-reflectivity CFBGs shown in [Figure 12](#sensors-19-03333-f012){ref-type="fig"} and [Table 1](#sensors-19-03333-t001){ref-type="table"}, but is a factor of two smaller due to the approximately double-length grating. It should also be noticed that the relative length of the non-linear region is half that of the previously tested 10 nm bandwidth grating. This is because the 240 mm long, 20 nm bandwidth grating has an identical chirp-rate to the 120 mm long, 10 nm bandwidth CFBG. It should be expected, therefore, that the *relative* non-linear length in the 240 mm case, 1.60 ± 0.12%, is half as long as the 120 mm case, 3.22 ± 0.24%. CFBGs for Detonation Velocity Measurements: Optimal Design Summary ------------------------------------------------------------------ It is established in the previous sections that. for increased linearity, CFBG detonation velocity probes should be designed to have a low-reflectivity and broad-bandwidth (high chirp-rate). Based on the system setup shown here, a good reflectivity range is around 20--60%. The chirp-rate of the gratings should be as high as possible, whilst considering the available source bandwidth and detector responsivity. This design should also be relatively simple to implement from a practical standpoint. For high chirp-rate CFBGs, it can be difficult to achieve a high reflectivity because the required refractive index modulation is too great \[[@B23-sensors-19-03333]\]. Where a low-reflectivity grating is desired, the fabrication would tend to be easier, allowing for more flexibility in the design. Furthermore, for many of the high-reflectivity CFBG designs, an attenuator was required in order to prevent detector saturation. When the grating reflectivity was dropped, the attenuator was no longer required and the setup was simpler. It is also shown in [Figure 7](#sensors-19-03333-f007){ref-type="fig"} that apodisation will de-linearise the ends of the grating erasure, making calibration more difficult without any discernible benefits. For certain detonation velocity measurements, researchers may decide to apply a second CFBG filter prior to the detector with the aim of removing out-of-band Fresnel reflections and coupled explosive light. From the results shown here, it appears that the interaction of the ASE source with the CFBG is contributing to the optical signal noise. It is, therefore, our speculation that any additional CFBG filtering is likely to contaminate the signal with an additional background noise-level. However, in experiments where there may be considerable explosive radiation coupled into the fibre, an additional filter could contribute to a net gain in the signal quality. This should be considered on a case by case basis. Lastly, it should be noted that CFBGs generally need to be implemented with the source signal entering via the short wavelength end so that the long wavelength end is destroyed first. This is to prevent cladding-modes leaching signal power from the short wavelengths and leaving the grating spectrum lop-sided \[[@B24-sensors-19-03333]\]. A summary of our optimised system is shown in [Table 4](#sensors-19-03333-t004){ref-type="table"}. 5. Conclusions {#sec5-sensors-19-03333} ============== As CFBG methods of measuring detonation velocity are becoming more wide spread, it is crucial that subtleties in the optical setup are considered in order to maximise precision and mitigate errors. This is particularly pertinent when attempting to measure dynamic effects and changes in velocity. It is demonstrated here that broad bandwidth, low-reflectivity CFBGs are optimally linear in their response to length changes and do not require apodisation. From here on, prospective explosives engineers and researchers should be able to optimise their measurement systems for various test scenarios. For a desired measurement length, the considerations could be:What is the maximum chirp-rate available---how does the full bandwidth compare to the source bandwidth and detector responsivity?What is the detector saturation level---what CFBG reflectivity will ensure that the reflected power does not exceed it?How much residual explosive light is likely to couple into the fibre---will the noise be reduced or exacerbated by an additional CFBG filter? These consideration should go someway to helping improve the quality and reliability of CFBG detonation velocity measurements in the future. The authors wish to acknowledge Chris Stennett and Callum Pryer for useful discussions and the technical support staff at the University of Southampton and Cranfield University. *©* British Crown Owned Copyright 2019/AWE. Conceptualization, J.P., M.I., J.W.F. and E.P.; methodology, J.P. and M.I.; formal analysis, J.P.; investigation, J.P., M.I., J.W.F. and E.P.; writing---original draft preparation, J.P.; writing---review and editing, J.P., M.I., J.W.F. and E.P.; and supervision, M.I. and E.P. This research was funded by the Atomic Weapons Establishment (30331012). The authors declare no conflict of interest. The contributions from AWE employees, E.P. and J.W.F., are stated in the Author Contributions. The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript: ASE Amplified Spontaneous Emission CFBG Chirped Fibre Bragg Grating CR Chirp-Rate DAQ Data Acquisition PDV Photonic Doppler Velocimetry PSD Power Spectral Density UFBG Uniform Fibre Bragg Grating {#sensors-19-03333-f001} {#sensors-19-03333-f002} {#sensors-19-03333-f003} {#sensors-19-03333-f004} {#sensors-19-03333-f005} {#sensors-19-03333-f006} {#sensors-19-03333-f007} {#sensors-19-03333-f008} {#sensors-19-03333-f009} {#sensors-19-03333-f010} {#sensors-19-03333-f011} {#sensors-19-03333-f012} {#sensors-19-03333-f013} {#sensors-19-03333-f014} sensors-19-03333-t001_Table 1 ###### The properties of the non-linear region for different reflectivity (96%, 59%, and 22%), 20 nm bandwidth CFBG tests. CFBG Reflectivity (%) Fluctuation over Highlighted Region (%) Relative Length of Highlighted Region (%) Average Velocity (km/s) PDV Velocity (km/s) ----------------------- ----------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------- ------------------------- --------------------- 96 2.01 ± 0.04 2.87 ± 0.32 6.150 6.248 59 0.48 ± 0.09 2.12 ± 0.65 6.259 6.238 22 0.48 ± 0.13 2.00 ± 0.54 6.212 6.212 sensors-19-03333-t002_Table 2 ###### The properties of the non-linear region for different bandwidth (5 nm, 10 nm, and 20 nm) CFBG tests, with reflectivities in the range 59--68%. CFBG Bandwidth (nm) Fluctuation over Highlighted Region (%) Relative Length of Highlighted Region (%) Average Velocity (km/s) PDV Velocity (km/s) --------------------- ----------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------- ------------------------- --------------------- 5 1.44 ± 0.08 4.88 ± 0.67 6.234 6.247 10 1.03 ± 0.04 3.22 ± 0.24 6.223 6.244 20 0.48 ± 0.09 2.12 ± 0.65 6.259 6.238 sensors-19-03333-t003_Table 3 ###### The properties of the non-linear region for a 24 cm, 20 nm bandwidth, 37% reflectivity CFBG test. Fluctuation over Highlighted Region (%) Relative Length of Highlighted Region (%) Average Velocity (km/s) ----------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------- ------------------------- 0.26 ± 0.04 1.60 ± 0.12 6.227 sensors-19-03333-t004_Table 4 ###### A summary of design considerations for CFBG detonation velocity tests. Design Parameter Optimal Implementation Explanation --------------------------- ------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CFBG Chirp-Rate/Bandwidth ✓ High Chirp Rate A high chirp-rate minimises the length of the non-linear region. CFBG Reflectivity ✓ Low Reflectivity A low reflectivity reduces the severity of the non-linear region and simplifies fabrication of high chirp-rate gratings. Signal Input/Output End ✓ Short Wavelength End Source light should enter and leave the grating from the short wavelength end to avoid cladding-mode loss. Additional CFBGFiltering ━ Apply with Caution Some applications may require additional filters, but in other cases the extra CFBG could contribute more noise than it filters out. Source Attenuation ━ Can be Avoided Attenuation can be avoided by designing CFBGs whose reflected power is below the detector saturation level. CFBG Apodisation ✗ No Apodisation Apodisation will tend to de-linearise the length vs. reflected power at each end of the grating.

\section{Introduction} The purpose of this paper is to introduce the free Banach lattice generated by a Banach space and investigate its properties. The free Banach lattice generated by a set $A$ with no extra structure, which is denoted by $FBL(A)$, has been recently introduced and analyzed by B.~de Pagter and A.W.~Wickstead in \cite{dePW}. Namely, $FBL(A)$ is a Banach lattice together with a bounded map $u:A \to FBL(A)$ having the following universal property: for every Banach lattice $Y$ and every bounded map $v:A \to Y$ there is a unique lattice homomorphism $S: FBL(A)\to Y$ such that $S\circ u=v$ and $\|S\|=\sup\{\|v(a)\|:a\in A\}$. Our aim here is to provide an analogous construction replacing the set $A$ by a Banach space $E$, in a way that the resulting free Banach lattice behaves well with respect to the Banach space structure of $E$. In the absense of topology, the free vector lattice generated by a set $A$ was previously considered in \cite{Baker,Bleier} and can be characterized as certain sublattice of~$\mathbb R^{\mathbb R^A}$. Constructing the free Banach lattice $FBL(A)$ becomes tantamount to finding the largest possible lattice norm that the free vector lattice over $A$ can carry. Among other things, the existence of such a norm is proved in \cite{dePW}. However, one can provide an explicit form of the norm of $FBL(A)$ (see Corollary \ref{c:FBL(A)}). Loosely speaking, the free Banach lattice $FBL[E]$ generated by a Banach space~$E$ is a Banach lattice which contains a subspace linearly isometric to~$E$ in a way that its elements work as lattice-free generators. In other words, the subspace of generators has two properties: first, the generators carry no lattice relation among them (except for the linear and metric ones coming from~$E$), and second, the sublattice spanned by these generators is dense in the free Banach lattice. To be more precise, if $\phi_E$ stands for the canonical isometric embedding of~$E$ into~$FBL[E]$, then the universal property of~$FBL[E]$ reads as follows: for every Banach lattice $X$ and every operator $T:E\rightarrow X$ there exists a unique lattice homomorphism $\hat T:FBL[E]\rightarrow X$ such that $\|\hat T\|=\|T\|$ and $\hat T\circ \phi_E=T$, i.e. the following diagram commutes: $$ \xymatrix{E\ar_{\phi_E}[d]\ar[rr]^T&&X\\ FBL[E]\ar_{\hat{T}}[urr]&& } $$ Section~\ref{section:description} is devoted to constructing the free Banach lattice~$FBL[E]$ generated by a Banach space $E$. The construction will be achieved by defining a norm on a sublattice of~$\mathbb R^{E^*}$. This explicit description of the norm in the free Banach lattice is a helpful tool to tackle some questions that were raised in~\cite{dePW}. It should come as no great surprise that as~$\ell_1(A)$ is the free Banach space over the set~$A$, then $FBL(A)=FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ (see Corollary \ref{c:FBL(A)}). In particular, the free Banach lattice generated by a Banach space can be thought of as a generalization of the free Banach lattices of the form~$FBL(A)$. In Sections~\ref{s:OrderIntervals} and~\ref{s:nakano} we discuss further properties of the free Banach lattice generated by a Banach space. In \cite[Theorem 8.3]{dePW} the authors show that, given any infinite set~$A$, the smallest cardinal $\mathfrak a$ such that every order interval in $FBL(A)$ has density character at most $\mathfrak a$ is $|A|$ (the cardinality of~$A$). They ask whether all non-degenerate order intervals in $FBL(A)$ must have the same density character (that would necessarily be equal to~$|A|$). We will see that this is indeed the case and, more generally, that for any Banach space~$E$, every non-degenerate order interval in $FBL[E]$ has the same density character as~$E$ (Theorem~\ref{t:orderintervals}). Another intriguing question raised in~\cite{dePW} is whether the norm of a free Banach lattice of the form~$FBL(A)$ must be Fatou, or even Nakano. We will show that this is indeed the case (Theorem~\ref{thm:Nakano}), while this property is not shared by all free Banach lattices generated by a Banach space (Theorem~\ref{t:nofatou}). Finally, in Section~\ref{s:wcg} we revisit a question that J. Diestel raised during the conference ``Integration, Vector Measures and Related Topics IV'' held in La Manga del Mar Menor, Spain, 2011. A Banach lattice $X$ is said to be {\em lattice weakly compactly generated} (LWCG for short) if there is a weakly compact set $L\subseteq X$ such that the sublattice generated by~$L$ is dense in~$X$. This is formally weaker than being weakly compactly generated (WCG for short) as a Banach space, which means that there is a weakly compact set $K \subseteq X$ such that $X=\overline{{\rm span}}(K)$. \begin{prob}[Diestel]\label{problem:Diestel} Is every LWCG Banach lattice WCG? \end{prob} This and related questions have been recently investigated in~\cite{AGLRT}, where Problem~\ref{problem:Diestel} is solved affirmatively for Banach lattices which are order continuous or have weakly sequentially continuous lattice operations. Here we will provide a negative answer to Diestel's question by showing that the free Banach lattice $FBL[\ell_2(\Gamma)]$ is LWCG but not WCG as long as $\Gamma$ is uncountable (Corollary~\ref{c:Diestel}). \subsection*{Terminology} We only consider linear spaces over the real field. Given a Banach space~$E$, its norm is denoted by $\|\cdot\|_E$ or simply $\|\cdot\|$ if no confussion arises. The closed unit ball and the unit sphere of~$E$ are denoted by~$B_E$ and~$S_E$, respectively. The linear subspace generated by a set $S \subseteq E$ is denoted by~${\rm span}(S)$ and its closure is denoted by $\overline{{\rm span}}(S)$. The symbol $E^*$ stands for the (topological) dual of~$E$. Given a Banach lattice~$X$, we write $X_+=\{x\in X: x\geq 0\}$. By an {\em operator} between Banach spaces we mean a linear continuous map. \section{A description of the free Banach lattice}\label{section:description} Throughout this section $E$ is a Banach space. Our first aim is to show that the free Banach lattice generated by $E$ exists and provide an explicit description (Theorem~\ref{t:fblb}). We denote by $H[E]$ the linear subspace of $\mathbb R^{E^*}$ consisting of all positively homogeneous functions $f:E^\ast \to \mathbb{R}$. For any $f\in H[E]$ we define $$ \|f\|_{FBL[E]} := \sup\left\{\sum_{k=1}^n |f(x_k^\ast)| : \, n\in\mathbb N, \, x_1^*,\dots,x_n^*\in E^*, \, \sup_{x\in B_E} \sum_{k=1}^n |x_k^\ast(x)|\leq 1\right\}. $$ \begin{rem}\label{rem:PointwiseBounded} If $f\in H[E]$, then $$ \|f\|_\infty:=\sup\big\{|f(x^*)|: \, x^*\in B_{E^*}\big\} \leq \|f\|_{FBL[E]}. $$ \end{rem} It is routine to check that $H_0[E]:=\{f\in H[E]: \|f\|_{FBL[E]}<\infty\}$ is a Banach lattice when equipped with the norm~$\|\cdot\|_{FBL[E]}$ and the pointwise lattice operations. \begin{defn}\label{definition:FBL} Given any $x\in E$, let $\delta_x\in H_0[E]$ be defined by $$ \delta_x(x^\ast):= x^\ast(x) \quad\mbox{for all }x^*\in E^*. $$ We define $FBL[E]$ to be the closed sublattice of $H_0[E]$ generated by $\{\delta_x:x\in E\}$. \end{defn} The following lemma is straightforward. \begin{lem}\label{l:isometry} The mapping $\phi_E: E\rightarrow FBL[E]$ given by $\phi_E(x):=\delta_x$ defines a linear isometry between $E$ and its image in $FBL[E]$. \end{lem} \begin{thm}\label{t:fblb} Let $X$ be a Banach lattice and $T:E\rightarrow X$ an operator. There is a unique lattice homomorphism $\hat T:FBL[E]\rightarrow X$ extending $T$ (in the sense that $\hat T \circ \phi_E=T$). Moreover, $\|\hat T\|=\|T\|$. \end{thm} \begin{proof} Recall that the {\em free vector lattice} over the set~$E$, denoted by~$FVL(E)$, is the vector sublattice of~$\mathbb R^{\mathbb R^E}$ generated by the family $\{\eta_{x}: x\in E\}$, where $$ \eta_x(f):=f(x) \quad\mbox{for all }f\in \mathbb R^E $$ (\cite{Bleier}, cf. \cite[Theorem 3.6]{dePW}). Thus, the mapping $\phi_E:E \to FBL[E]$ of Lemma~\ref{l:isometry} induces a lattice homomorphism $\varphi: FVL(E) \to FBL[E]$ such that $\varphi(\eta_x)=\delta_x$ for all $x \in E$. In particular, $\varphi$ has dense range. The universal property of~$FVL(E)$ can be used again to obtain a lattice homomorphism $\tilde T:FVL(E)\rightarrow X$ such that $\tilde T(\eta_{x})=T(x)$ for all $x\in E$. {\em Claim.} For every $f\in FVL(E)$ we have \begin{equation}\label{eqn:Domination} \|\tilde T(f)\|_X \leq \| T\| \|\varphi(f)\|_{FBL[E]}. \end{equation} Once the claim is proved the proof of the theorem finishes as follows. Inequality~\eqref{eqn:Domination} and the density of $\varphi(FVL(E))$ in~$FBL[E]$ allow us to define an operator $\hat T: FBL[E] \to X$ with $\|\hat T\|\leq \|T\|$ such that $\hat T \circ \varphi =\tilde T$. Since $\varphi$ and~$\tilde T$ are lattice homomorphisms, so is $\hat T$. Clearly, $\hat T \circ \phi_E=T$. Moreover, we have $\|\hat T\|=\|T\|$, because $\|T(x)\| =\|\hat T(\delta_x)\| \leq \|\hat T\| \|\delta_x\|_{FBL[E]}=\|\hat T\|\|x\|$ for every $x\in E$. For the uniqueness of~$\hat T$, bear in mind that any lattice homomorphism from~$FBL[E]$ to a Banach lattice is uniquely determined by its values in $\{\delta_x:x\in E\}$. {\em Proof of Claim.} The case $T=0$ is trivial, so we assume that $T\neq 0$. Fix $f\in FVL(E)$. Actually, $f$ belongs to the sublattice of~$FVL(E)$ generated by $\{\eta_{x_1},\dots, \eta_{x_n}\}$ for some finite set $\{x_1,\ldots, x_n\}\subseteq E$. By \cite[Ex. 8, p. 204]{AB}, we can write $$ f=\bigvee_{i=1}^m f_i-\bigvee_{j=1}^p g_j $$ for some $f_1,\dots,f_m, g_1,\dots,g_p$ in ${\rm span}(\{\eta_{x_1},\ldots,\eta_{x_n}\})$. Write $f_i=\sum_{l=1}^{n}\lambda_l^i\eta_{x_l}$ and $g_j= \sum_{l=1}^{n}\mu_l^j\eta_{x_l}$ for some $\lambda_l^i,\mu_l^j \in \mathbb R$. Since $\tilde T$ is a lattice homomorphism, we have \begin{equation}\label{eqn:Ttilde} \tilde T(f)=\bigvee_{i=1}^m u_i-\bigvee_{j=1}^p v_j \end{equation} where $u_i:=\sum_{l=1}^{n}\lambda_l^iT(x_l)$ and $v_j:=\sum_{l=1}^{n}\mu_l^jT(x_l)$. Since $\tilde T$ and $\varphi$ are lattice homomorphisms, it suffices to check~\eqref{eqn:Domination} in the particular case that $f\geq 0$. In this case, \eqref{eqn:Domination} is equivalent to the fact that $y^*(\tilde T(f)) \leq \|T\|\|\varphi(f)\|_{FBL[E]}$ for every $y^* \in B_{X^*}\cap (X^*)_+$ (bear in mind that $\tilde{T}(f)\geq 0$). Fix $y^* \in B_{X^*}\cap (X^*)_+$. Take an arbitrary decomposition $y^*=\sum_{k=1}^m y_k^*$ where $y_1^*,\dots,y_m^*\in (X^*)_+$. Let us define $x_k^*:=\|T\|^{-1} T^*(y_k^*)\in E^*$ for every $k\in \{1,\dots,m\}$, which satisfy $$ \sup_{x\in B_E} \sum_{k=1}^m |x_k^*(x)| \leq \sup_{x\in B_E} \sum_{k=1}^m y_k^*\Big(\frac{1}{\|T\|}|T(x)|\Big) = \sup_{x\in B_E} y^*\Big(\frac{1}{\|T\|}|T(x)|\Big)\leq\|y^*\|\leq1. $$ Hence, \begin{eqnarray*} \|\varphi(f)\|_{FBL[E]}&\geq&\sum_{k=1}^m \varphi(f)(x^*_k)=\sum_{k=1}^m \Bigg(\bigvee_{i=1}^m \varphi(f_i)(x_k^*)-\bigvee_{j=1}^p \varphi(g_j)(x_k^*)\Bigg)\\ &=&\frac1{\|T\|}\sum_{k=1}^m \Bigg(\bigvee_{i=1}^m y^*_k(u_i)-\bigvee_{j=1}^p y^*_k(v_j)\Bigg)\\ &\geq&\frac1{\|T\|}\sum_{k=1}^m \Bigg(y^*_k(u_k)- y^*_k\Big(\bigvee_{j=1}^pv_j\Big)\Bigg)\\ &=&\frac1{\|T\|}\Bigg(\sum_{k=1}^m y^*_k(u_k)- y^*\Big(\bigvee_{j=1}^pv_j\Big)\Bigg). \end{eqnarray*} By the classical Riesz-Kantorovich formulas (cf. \cite[Theorem 1.18]{AB}) we have $$ y^*\Big(\bigvee_{k=1}^m u_k\Big)=\sup\Big\{\sum_{k=1}^m y^*_k(u_k): \, y_k^*\in (X^*)_+, \,y^*=\sum_{k=1}^m y^*_k\Big\}. $$ Hence, by taking supremum over all such decompositions of~$y^*$, the above inequalities yield \begin{equation}\label{eqn:final} y^*(\tilde T(f))\stackrel{\eqref{eqn:Ttilde}}{=}y^*\Big(\bigvee_{i=1}^m u_i-\bigvee_{j=1}^p v_j\Big)\leq \|T\|\|\varphi(f)\|_{FBL[E]}, \end{equation} as desired. The proof is complete. \end{proof} \begin{cor}\label{cor:FBLofBanachLattice} If $E$ is a Banach lattice, then it is the range of a lattice projection $P:FBL[E]\rightarrow E$. \end{cor} \begin{proof} Apply Theorem \ref{t:fblb} to the identity $T:E\rightarrow E$ to get $P:=\hat T$. \end{proof} \begin{cor}\label{cor:RealHomomorphisms} A functional $\varphi\in FBL[E]^*$ is a lattice homomorphism if and only if there is $x^*\in E^*$ such that $\varphi(f)= f(x^*)$ for all $f\in FBL[E]$. \end{cor} \begin{proof} Given any $x^*\in E^*$, the evaluation functional $$ \varphi_{x^*}:FBL[E]\to \mathbb R, \quad \varphi_{x^*}(f):=f(x^*), $$ is obviously a lattice homomorphism. Conversely, suppose $\varphi\in FBL[E]^*$ is a lattice homomorphism. Then $x^*:=\varphi\circ \phi_E$ belongs to $E^*$. Since $\varphi$ and $\varphi_{x^*}$ are lattice homomorphisms such that $\varphi\circ \phi_E=\varphi_{x^*}\circ \phi_E$, the uniqueness part of Theorem~\ref{t:fblb} yields that $\varphi=\varphi_{x^*}$. \end{proof} In the spirit of \cite[Corollary 4.10]{dePW}, we have the following: \begin{cor}\label{cor:subspace} Let $F\subseteq E$ be a closed subspace which is complemented by a contractive projection. Then: \begin{enumerate} \item[(i)] $FBL[F]$ is isometrically order isomorphic to a closed sublattice of~$FBL[E]$. \item[(ii)] $FBL[F]^*$ is isometrically order isomorphic to a $w^*$-closed band of $FBL[E]^*$. \end{enumerate} \end{cor} \begin{proof} Let $P:E\rightarrow F$ be a contractive projection. Consider $$ T:=\phi_F\circ P:E\rightarrow FBL[F] $$ and let $\hat T:FBL[E]\rightarrow FBL[F]$ be the unique lattice homomorphism extending~$T$, which satisfies $\|\hat T\|=\|T\|=\|P\|=1$ (Theorem~\ref{t:fblb}). Let $i:F \to E$ be the canonical inclusion, consider $$ S:=\phi_E\circ i:F\rightarrow FBL[E] $$ and let $\hat S: FBL[F] \to FBL[E]$ be the unique lattice homomorphism extending~$S$, which also satisfies $\|\hat S\|=\|S\|=\|i\|=1$ (Theorem~\ref{t:fblb}). For every $x\in F$ we have $$ \hat S(\delta_x)=\phi_E(i(x))=\delta_x \quad\mbox{and}\quad \hat{T}(\delta_x)=\phi_F(P(x))=\phi_F(x)=\delta_x, $$ so $\hat T \circ \hat S$ is the identity on~$FBL[F]$. It follows that $\hat S$ is an isometric embedding (which yields statement~(i)) and that $\hat{T}$ is a contrative projection onto $FBL[F]$. Statement~(ii) now follows from \cite[Proposition 4.9]{dePW}. \end{proof} In the particular case $E=\ell_1(A)$ the space $FBL[E]$ turns out to be the free Banach lattice generated by the set~$A$ (in the sense of~\cite{dePW}), as we next show. \begin{cor}\label{c:FBL(A)} Let $A$ be a non-empty set. Then: \begin{enumerate} \item[(i)] For every $f\in H[\ell_1(A)]$ we have $$ \|f\|_{FBL(A)}=\sup\left\{\sum_{k=1}^n |f(x^*_k)| : \, n\in\mathbb N, \, x_1^*,\dots,x_n^* \in\ell_\infty(A), \, \sup_{a\in A} \sum_{k=1}^n |x_k^*(a)|\leq 1\right\}. $$ \item[(ii)] $FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ is the closed sublattice of $H_0[\ell_1(A)]$ generated by the family $\{\delta_{e_a}:a\in A\}$, where $(e_a)_{a\in A}$ is the unit vector basis of~$\ell_1(A)$. \item[(iii)] The pair $(FBL[\ell_1(A)],i)$ is the free Banach lattice generated by~$A$, where $i:A\rightarrow FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ is the bounded map given by $i(a):=\delta_{e_a}$ for all $a\in A$. \end{enumerate} \end{cor} \begin{proof} (i) is elementary, while (ii) is an immediate consequence of~Lemma~\ref{l:isometry} and the fact that $\ell_1(A)=\overline{{\rm span}}(\{e_a:a\in A\})$. In order to check (iii), fix a Banach lattice $Y$ and a bounded map $\kappa:A\rightarrow Y$. Consider the operator $T:\ell_1(A)\rightarrow Y$ satisfying $T(e_a)=\kappa(a)$ for all $a\in A$. By Theorem~\ref{t:fblb}, there is a lattice homomorphism $\hat T: FBL[\ell_1(A)]\rightarrow Y$ such that $\hat T \circ \phi_{\ell_1(A)}=T$ (hence $\hat T \circ i=\kappa$), with $$ \|\hat T\|=\|T\|=\sup\{\|\kappa(a)\|: \, a\in A\}. $$ Moreover, by~(ii), any lattice homomorphism $S: FBL[\ell_1(A)]\rightarrow Y$ such that $S \circ i=\kappa$ must coincide with~$\hat T$. \end{proof} The following examples show that $H[\ell_1] \supsetneq H_0[\ell_1] \supsetneq FBL[\ell_1]$. \begin{example} Let $f\in H[\ell_1]$ be defined by $f(x) := \sup\big\{\frac{|x(a)|}{a} : a\in \mathbb{N}\big\}$ for all $x\in \ell_\infty$. Then $\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1]} = \infty$. Indeed, let $(e^*_n)_{n\in \mathbb{N}}$ be the unit vector basis of~$c_0$. For each $n\in \mathbb{N}$ we have $\sup_{a\in \mathbb{N}}\sum_{k=1}^n|e^*_k(a)| \leq 1$, so Corollary~\ref{c:FBL(A)}(i) yields $$ \|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1]}\geq \sum_{k=1}^n f(e^*_k)= \sum_{k=1}^n \frac{1}{k}. $$ By taking limits when $n\to \infty$ we get $\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1]} = \infty$. \qed \end{example} \begin{example}(A function in $H_0[\ell_1]\setminus FBL[\ell_1]$.)\label{s:examples} Define a positively homogeneous function $f:\ell_\infty \to \mathbb R$ by $$ f(x) := \min\left(|x(1)|, \, \sup\left\{\frac{|x(a)|}{a} :\, a\geq 2\right\}\right) \quad\mbox{for all }x\in \ell_\infty. $$ The fact that $0 \leq f(x) \leq |x(1)|$ for all $x\in \ell_\infty$ implies that $\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1]} \leq 1$. We will prove that $f\not\in FBL[\ell_1]$ by showing that $\|f-g\|_{FBL[\ell_1]} \geq \frac{1}{4}$ for every $g\in H_0[\ell_1]$ which belongs to the sublattice generated by~$\{\delta_{e_a}:a\in \mathbb{N}\}$ (bear in mind Corollary~\ref{c:FBL(A)}(ii)). To this end, note first that such $g$ belongs to the sublattice generated by $\{\delta_{e_1},\dots,\delta_{e_n}\}$ for some~$n\in \mathbb{N}$. For each $k\in \{1,\dots,n\}$, we define $x^*_k,y^*_k\in \ell_\infty$ by declaring $x^*_k(1) = y^*_k(1) := \frac{1}{n}$, $x^*_k(n+k) := 1$, and all other coordinates of $x^*_k$ and $y^*_k$ are zero. Clearly, we have $\sum_{k=1}^n |x^*_k(a)| \leq 1$ and $\sum_{k=1}^n |y^*_k(a)| \leq 1$ for all $a\in \mathbb{N}$, so Corollary~\ref{c:FBL(A)}(i) yields $$ \|f-g\|_{FBL[\ell_1]}\geq \max\left(\sum_{k=1}^n |f(x_k^*)-g(x_k^*)|, \,\sum_{k=1}^n |f(y_k^*)-g(y_k^*)|\right). $$ But $g(x^*_k) = g(y^*_k)$ for every $k\in \{1,\dots,n\}$, because $g$ belongs to the sublattice generated by $\{\delta_{e_1},\dots,\delta_{e_n}\}$ and $x_k^*(a)=y_k^*(a)$ for every $a\in \{1,\dots,n\}$. Hence $$ \|f-g\|_{FBL[\ell_1]}\geq \frac{1}{2} \sum_{k=1}^n |f(x_k^*)-f(y_k^*)|. $$ By the definition of~$f$, we have $f(x^*_k)=\frac{1}{n+k}$ and $f(y^*_k) = 0$ for every $k\in\{1,\dots,n\}$, so $$ \|f-g\|_{FBL[\ell_1]}\geq \frac{1}{2} \sum_{k=1}^n \frac{1}{n+k}\geq \frac{1}{4}, $$ as we wanted to show. \qed \end{example} Let $\mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})$ denote the set of regular Borel probabilities on $(B_{E^{**}},w^*)$. Then $\mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})$ is a convex $w^*$-compact subset of the dual of $C(B_{E^{**}},w^*)$. Note that each $\mu\in \mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})$ induces a function $f_\mu:E^*\to \mathbb R_+$ by $$ f_\mu(x^*):=\int_{B_{E^{**}}} |x^*(\cdot)| \, d\mu \quad \mbox{for all }x^*\in E^*. $$ This provides a link between $H_0[E]_+$ and $\mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})$, as we next explain. \begin{prop}\label{prop:fmu} If $\mu\in \mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})$, then $f_\mu\in H_0[E]_+$ and $\|f_\mu\|_{FBL[E]}\leq 1$. \end{prop} \begin{proof} Clearly, $f_\mu$ is positively homogeneous. Given $x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*\in E^*$ we have $$ \sum_{i=1}^n f_\mu (x^*_i)= \int_{B_{E^{**}}} \sum_{i=1}^n |x_i^*(\cdot)| \, d\mu \leq \sup_{x^{**}\in B_{E^{**}}}\sum_{i=1}^n|x_i^*(x^{**})|= \sup_{x\in B_{E}}\sum_{i=1}^n|x_i^*(x)|, $$ where the last equality holds because $B_E$ is $w^*$-dense in~$B_{E^{**}}$. It follows that $\|f_\mu\|_{FBL[E]} \leq 1$. \end{proof} \begin{prop}\label{l:kyfan} For every $f\in H_0[E]_+$ there is $\mu \in \mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})$ such that $$ f(x^*) \leq \|f\|_{FBL[E]} \, f_\mu(x^*) \quad \mbox{for all }x^*\in E^*. $$ \end{prop} \begin{proof} Assume without loss of generality that $\|f\|_{FBL[E]}=1$. Given any finite collection $x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*\in E^*$, let $$ \begin{array}{cccl} \varphi_{x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*}:&\mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})&\longrightarrow&\mathbb R\\ &\mu&\longmapsto& \displaystyle \sum_{i=1}^n \Big(f(x_i^*)-\int_{B_{E^{**}}}|x_i^*(\cdot)| \, d\mu\Big). \end{array} $$ It is clear that the function $\varphi_{x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*}$ is convex and $w^*$-continuous. Moreover, since $\|f\|_{FBL[E]}=1$ and $B_E$ is $w^*$-dense in~$B_{E^{**}}$, we have $$ \sum_{i=1}^n f(x_i^*)\leq \sup_{x\in B_E}\sum_{i=1}^n|x_i^*(x)|= \sup_{x^{**}\in B_{E^{**}}} \sum_{i=1}^n|x_i^*(x^{**})|. $$ The last supremum is attained at some $x^{**}_0\in B_{E^{**}}$ because $(B_{E^{**}},w^*)$ is compact and the map $\sum_{i=1}^n|x_i^*(\cdot)|$ is $w^*$-continuous. This means that the value of $\varphi_{x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*}$ at the probability measure concentrated on~$x^{**}_0$ is less than or igual to~$0$. By using that $f$ is positively homogeneous, it is easy to check that the collection of all functions of the form $\varphi_{x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*}$ is a convex cone of~$\mathbb R^{\mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})}$. From Ky Fan's lemma (see e.g. \cite[9.10]{DJT}) it follows that there is $\mu\in \mathfrak P(B_{E^{**}})$ such that $\varphi_{x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*}(\mu)\leq0$ for every $n\in \mathbb{N}$ and $x_1^*,\ldots, x_n^*\in E^*$. In particular, this yields that for every $x^*\in E^*$ we have $\varphi_{x^*}(\mu)\leq 0$, that is, $$ f(x^*)\leq \int_{B_{E^{**}}}|x^*(\cdot)|\, d\mu=f_\mu(x^*). $$ The proof is complete. \end{proof} \section{Density character of order intervals}\label{s:OrderIntervals} Recall that the {\em density character} of a topological space~$T$, denoted by~${\rm dens}(T)$, is the least cardinality of a dense subset. Given any Banach space~$E$, we have $$ {\rm dens}(E)={\rm dens}(FBL[E]) $$ since the sublattice generated by~$\phi_E(E)=\{\delta_x:x\in E\}$ is dense in $FBL[E]$. In \cite[Question 12.5]{dePW}, the authors ask whether every non-degenerate order interval in $FBL(A)$ (for an arbitrary non-empty set~$A$) has the same density character. Theorem~\ref{t:orderintervals} below shows that this is indeed the case, even in the more general setting of $FBL[E]$. The proof requires the following lemma, which might be known. \begin{lem}\label{l:separation} Let $E$ be an infinite-dimensional Banach space with ${\rm dens}(E)=\kappa$. Then there exist $\delta>0$ and a linearly independent set $S \subseteq S_E$ with $|S|=\kappa$ such that $\|x-\lambda x'\|\geq\delta$ for every distinct $x,x'\in S$ and every $\lambda\in\mathbb R$. \end{lem} \begin{proof} Fix $x^*\in S_{E^*}$ and $0<\varepsilon<1$. Define $S_0:=\{x\in S_E: x^*(x) >\varepsilon\}$. We will first check that $S_0$ is infinite. To this end, note that $$ W := \{x \in E :\, \|x\|<1,\ x^*(x)>\varepsilon\} $$ is open and non-empty, hence there exist $x_0\in W$ and $r>0$ in such a way that $x_0+rB_E \subseteq W$. Since $T := \{x \in x_0+rB_E : x^*(x)=x^*(x_0)\}$ is infinite (because it is a closed ball of the affine hyperplane $x_0 + \ker(x^*)$) and the map $h: T \to S_0$ given by $h(x) := \| x \|^{-1} \, x$ is one-to-one, we conclude that $S_0$ is infinite. We next show that ${\rm dens}(S_0)=\kappa$. Indeed, take any dense set $D \subseteq S_0$. Then $D$ is infinite and so it has the same cardinality as $\tilde{D}:=\{\lambda x: x\in D, \lambda\in \mathbb{Q}, \lambda>0\}$, which is dense in $$ G:=\{\lambda x: \, x\in S_0, \, \lambda\in \mathbb{R}, \, \lambda>0\}=\{x\in E: \, x^*(x)>\varepsilon\|x\|\}. $$ Since $G$ is open and non-empty, we have $\kappa={\rm dens}(G)\leq |\tilde{D}|=|D|$. This proves that ${\rm dens}(S_0)=\kappa$. So, there exist $0<\delta<\varepsilon$ and a set $S_1 \subseteq S_0$ with $|S_1|=\kappa$ such that $\|x-x'\|\geq 2\delta$ for every distinct $x,x'\in S_1$. Let $S \subseteq S_1$ be a maximal linearly independent subset. We shall check that $S$ satisfies the required properties. By maximality, we have $S_1 \subseteq {\rm span}(S)$ and therefore \begin{enumerate} \item[(i)] $S$ is infinite (bear in mind that the closed unit ball of a finite-dimensional Banach space is compact); \item[(ii)] ${\rm dens}({\rm span}(S))=\kappa$. \end{enumerate} From (i) and (ii) it follows that $|S|=\kappa$. Now, fix $x,x'\in S$ with $x\neq x'$ and take any $\lambda \in \mathbb R$. We next show that $\|x-\lambda x'\| \geq \delta$ by considering several cases: \begin{itemize} \item If $|1+\lambda| < \delta$, then $\|(x-\lambda x')-(x+x')\|<\delta$ and so $$ \|x-\lambda x'\| > \|x+x'\|-\delta\geq x^*(x+x')-\delta>2\varepsilon-\delta>\delta. $$ \item If $|1-\lambda| < \delta$, then $$ \|x-\lambda x'\| \geq \|x-x'\| - \|x'-\lambda x'\|>\|x-x'\|-\delta \geq \delta. $$ \item If $|\lambda|\leq 1-\delta$, then $$ \|x-\lambda x'\| \geq \|x\|-|\lambda|\|x'\|=1-|\lambda| \geq \delta. $$ \item If $|\lambda|\geq 1+\delta$, then $$ \|x-\lambda x'\| \geq |\lambda|\|x'\|-\|x\|=|\lambda|-1 \geq \delta. $$ \end{itemize} The proof is finished. \end{proof} \begin{thm}\label{t:orderintervals} Let $E$ be a Banach space. Then every non-degenerate order interval in $FBL[E]$ has the same density character as~$E$. \end{thm} \begin{proof} If $E$ is separable, then so is $FBL[E]$ and, in particular, every order interval in $FBL[E]$ is separable. Let us assume now that $E$ is non-separable with ${\rm dens}(E)=\kappa$. Pick $f\leq g$ in $FBL[E]$ with $f\neq g$. Rescaling, we can suppose that $f$ and $g$ belong to~$B_{FBL[E]}$. There is a {\em separable} closed subspace $F\subseteq E$ such that $f$ and $g$ belong to the closed sublattice of~$FBL[E]$ generated by $\{\delta_{x}:x \in F\}$. Bearing in mind that ${\rm dens}(E/F)=\kappa$, we can apply Lemma~\ref{l:separation} to~$E/F$ in order to find $\delta>0$ and a set $S \subseteq S_{E/F}$ with $|S|=\kappa$, consisting of linearly independent vectors, such that $\|s-\lambda t\|\geq\delta$ for every distinct $s,t \in S$ and every $\lambda\in\mathbb R$. Let $\pi:E\rightarrow E/F$ denote the quotient operator. For each $s\in S$, we take $u_s\in \pi^{-1}(s)$ with $\|u_s\|\leq 2$ and we define $$ z_s := (\delta_{u_s}\vee f)\wedge g\in [f,g] \subseteq FBL[E]. $$ To finish the proof it is enough to prove that there is a constant $c>0$ such that $\|z_s - z_t\| \geq c$ for every $s,t \in S$ with $s\neq t$. Fix $x^*\in B_{E^*}$ such that $f(x^*)<g(x^*)$ and consider the evaluation functional $\varphi_{x^*}\in B_{FBL[E]^*}$ given by~$\varphi_{x^*}(h):=h(x^*)$ for all $h\in FBL[E]$ (see Corollary~\ref{cor:RealHomomorphisms}). Set $C:=6\|\pi\|/\delta+1$ and fix $s\neq t$ in~$S$. {\em Claim.} The inequality \begin{equation}\label{eqn:Pedro} \|x\|+|\alpha|+|\beta|\leq C\|x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\| \end{equation} holds for every $x\in F$ and every $\alpha,\beta \in\mathbb R$. Indeed, by the choice of~$S$ we have $$ \|\pi\|\, \|x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\|\geq \|\alpha s+\beta t\| \geq \delta \, \max\{|\alpha|,|\beta|\} \geq \delta\, \frac{|\alpha|+|\beta|}{2}. $$ On the other hand, since $\|u_s\|\leq 2$ and $\|u_t\|\leq 2$, we have $$ \|x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\| \geq \|x\|-\|\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\| \geq \|x\|-2\big(|\alpha|+|\beta|\big). $$ Therefore \begin{multline*} C \|x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\|=\frac{6\|\pi\|}{\delta} \|x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\| + \|x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\| \\ \geq 3\big(|\alpha|+|\beta|\big)+\|x\|-2\big(|\alpha|+|\beta|\big)=\|x\|+|\alpha|+|\beta|, \end{multline*} which finishes the proof of the claim. Note that $u_s$ and $u_t$ are linearly independent vectors in~$E\setminus F$. Let $$ \xi: {\rm span}(F\cup\{u_s,u_t\})\rightarrow \mathbb R $$ be the linear functional given by \begin{multline*} \xi(x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t):=\varphi_{x^*}(\delta_x+\alpha f+\beta g) \\ =x^*(x)+\alpha f(x^*)+\beta g(x^*) \quad \mbox{for all }x\in F \mbox{ and } \alpha,\beta\in \mathbb R. \end{multline*} Bearing in mind~\eqref{eqn:Pedro}, we get $$ |\xi(x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t)|\leq \| \delta_x+\alpha f+\beta g\|_{FBL[E]} \leq \|x\|+|\alpha|+|\beta|\leq C\|x+\alpha u_s+\beta u_t\| $$ for every $x\in F$ and $\alpha,\beta\in \mathbb R$. By the Hahn-Banach theorem, $\xi$ can be extended to an element of~$E^*$, still denoted by~$\xi$, with $\|\xi\|\leq C$. Now, let $\hat{\xi}\in FBL[E]^*$ be the lattice homomorphism satisfying $\hat \xi \circ \phi_E=\xi$ and $\|\hat{\xi}\|=\|\xi\|\leq C$ (Theorem~\ref{t:fblb}). Note that $$ \hat{\xi}(\delta_x)=\xi(x)=\varphi_{x^*}(\delta_x)=x^*(x)\quad \mbox{for every }x\in F. $$ Since $\hat\xi$ and $\varphi_{x^*}$ are lattice homomorphisms and $f$ and~$g$ belong to the closed sublattice generated by $\{\delta_x:x\in F\}$, it follows that $\hat{\xi}(f)=\varphi_{x^*}(f)=f(x^*)$ and $\hat{\xi}(g)=\varphi_{x^*}(g)=g(x^*)$. In particular, we have $$ C\|z_s - z_t\| \geq\Big|\hat{\xi}\Big((\delta_{u_s}\vee f)\wedge g-(\delta_{u_t}\vee f)\wedge g\Big)\Big|=g(x^*)-f(x^*). $$ This shows that $\|z_s - z_t\|\geq C^{-1}(g(x^*)-f(x^*))$ for every $s\neq t$ in~$S$. The proof is finished. \end{proof} \section{The Nakano property}\label{s:nakano} The norm of a Banach lattice $X$ is said to have the \emph{Nakano property} if for every upwards directed order bounded set $\mathcal{F}\subseteq X_+$ we have $$ \sup\{\|x\|: \, x\in\mathcal F\}=\inf\{\|y\|: \, y \in X \mbox{ is an upper bound of } \mathcal{F}\}. $$ This property was introduced in \cite{N} (see also \cite{W}) and is stronger than the \emph{Fatou property}, which simply states that whenever an upwards directed set $\mathcal{F}\subseteq X_+$ has a supremum $y \in X$, then $$ \sup\{\|x\|:\, x\in\mathcal F\}=\|y\|. $$ In \cite[Question 12.1]{dePW}, it was asked whether the norm of $FBL(A)$ has the Nakano property. We will show in Theorem~\ref{thm:Nakano} that this is the case. In fact, a stronger property holds: \begin{defn} We say that the norm of a Banach lattice $X$ has the \emph{strong Nakano property} if for every upwards directed norm bounded set $\mathcal{F}\subseteq X_{+}$ there exists an upper bound $y_0$ of~$\mathcal{F}$ in~$X$ such that $$ \sup\{\|x\|: \, x\in\mathcal F\}=\|y_0\|. $$ \end{defn} The supremum norm of a $C(K)$ space ($K$ being a compact Hausdorff topological space) has the strong Nakano property, because we can take $y_0$ as the constant function equal to $\sup\{\|x\|_\infty :x\in\mathcal F\}$. In a sense, we shall see that the free Banach lattices $FBL(A)=FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ have an analogous structure, the role of the positive constant functions being played by the elements of the form $|\delta_{e_a}|$ for $a\in A$. Our proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Nakano} requires some preliminary lemmas. \begin{lem}\label{lem:PointwiseSupremum} Let $E$ be a Banach space and let $\mathcal{F}\subseteq H[E]_+$ be upwards directed and pointwise bounded. Define $g: E^*\to \mathbb R_+$ by $g(x^*):=\sup\{f(x^*):f\in \mathcal{F}\}$ for all $x^*\in E^*$. Then $g\in H[E]_+$ and $$ \|g\|_{FBL[E]} = \sup \{\|f\|_{FBL[E]} : \, f\in\mathcal{F}\}. $$ \end{lem} \begin{proof} Clearly, $g$ is positively homogeneous and $\|g\|_{FBL[E]} \geq \|f\|_{FBL[E]}$ for every $f\in\mathcal{F}$. To prove that $\|g\|_{FBL[E]} \leq \sup \{\|f\|_{FBL[E]} : \, f\in\mathcal{F}\}:=\alpha$ we can assume that the supremum is finite. Fix $\varepsilon>0$. Take any $x_1^*,\dots,x_n^* \in E^*$ such that $\sum_{k=1}^n |x_k^*(x)|\leq 1$ for every $x\in B_E$. Since $\mathcal{F}$ is upwards directed, we can find $f\in \mathcal{F}$ such that $g(x_k^*)-\frac{\varepsilon}{n} \leq f(x_k^*)$ for all $k\in \{1\dots,n\}$, therefore $$ \sum_{k=1}^n g(x^*_k) \leq \varepsilon+\sum_{k=1}^n f(x^*_k) \leq \varepsilon+\alpha. $$ It follows that $\|g\|_{FBL[E]} \leq \varepsilon+\alpha$. As $\varepsilon>0$ is arbitrary, $\|g\|_{FBL[E]} \leq \alpha$. \end{proof} \begin{defn} Let $E$ be a Banach space. We say that $f\in H_0[E]_+$ is {\em maximal} if $$ \big\{g\in H_0[E]_+: \, g \geq f, \, \|g\|_{FBL[E]} = \|f\|_{FBL[E]} \big\}=\{f\}. $$ \end{defn} \begin{lem}\label{lem:Zorn} Let $E$ be a Banach space and $f\in H_0[E]_+$. Then there exists a maximal $\tilde{f} \in H_0[E]_+$ such that $f\leq \tilde{f}$ and $\|f\|_{FBL[E]} = \|\tilde{f}\|_{FBL[E]}$. \end{lem} \begin{proof} The set $\mathcal{G}:=\{g\in H_0[E]_+: \, g\geq f, \, \|g\|_{FBL[E]}=\|f\|_{FBL[E]}\}$ is pointwise bounded by Remark~\ref{rem:PointwiseBounded}. Note that every upwards directed subset of~$\mathcal{G}$ has an upper bound in~$\mathcal{G}$ (by Lemma~\ref{lem:PointwiseSupremum}). Thus, Zorn's lemma ensures the existence of an element of~$\mathcal{G}$ which is maximal for the pointwise ordering. \end{proof} Our next aim is to identify the maximal elements in $H_0[\ell_1(A)]_+$ for an arbitrary non-empty set~$A$. We shall use without explicit mention the formula to compute the norm $\|\cdot\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}$ given in Corollary~\ref{c:FBL(A)}(i). \begin{lem}\label{lem:PropertiesMaximal} Let $A$ be a non-empty set and let $f\in H_0[\ell_1(A)]_+$ be maximal. \begin{enumerate} \item[(i)] $f(x^*)\leq f(y^*)$ whenever $x^*,y^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ satisfy $|x^*|\leq |y^*|$. \item[(ii)] $\sum_{k=1}^n f(x^*_k) \leq f(\sum_{k=1}^n x^*_k)$ for every $n\in\mathbb N$ and $x_1^*,\dots,x_n^*\in \ell_\infty(A)_+$. \item[(iii)] $\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} = \|f\|_\infty$. \end{enumerate} \end{lem} \begin{proof} For any $z^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ we write $R(z^*):=\{\lambda z^*: \lambda>0\}\subseteq \ell_\infty(A)$. (i): By contradiction, suppose that $f(x^*)>f(y^*)$. Define $g:\ell_\infty(A)\to \mathbb R_+$ by $$ \begin{cases} g(\lambda y^*):=f(\lambda x^*) & \text{for all $\lambda>0$}, \\ g(z^*):=f(z^*) & \text{for all $z^*\in \ell_\infty(A) \setminus R(y^*)$}. \end{cases} $$ It is easy to check that $g$ is positively homogeneous. Since $f(x^*)>f(y^*)$, we have $f\leq g$ and $f\neq g$. Bearing in mind that $f$ is maximal, in order to get a contradiction it suffices to check that $\|g\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}=\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}$. To this end, take any $x_1^*,\dots,x_n^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ such that $\sum_{k=1}^n |x_k^*(a)|\leq 1$ for all $a\in A$. Let $I$ be the set of those $k\in \{1,\dots,n\}$ such that $x_k^*\not\in R(y^*)$ and let $J:=\{1,\dots,n\}\setminus I$, so that for each $k\in J$ we have $x_k^*=\lambda_k y^*$ for some $\lambda_k>0$. Note that \begin{multline*} \sum_{k\in I} |x_k^*(a)|+\sum_{k\in J} |\lambda_k x^*(a)|= \sum_{k\in I} |x_k^*(a)|+|x^*(a)|\sum_{k\in J} \lambda_k \\ \leq \sum_{k\in I} |x_k^*(a)|+|y^*(a)|\sum_{k\in J} \lambda_k= \sum_{k=1}^n |x_k^*(a)| \leq 1 \quad\mbox{for all }a\in A, \end{multline*} hence $$ \sum_{k=1}^n g(x_k^*)= \sum_{k\in I} f(x_k^*)+\sum_{k\in J} f(\lambda_k x^*) \leq \|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}. $$ This shows that $\|g\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} \leq \|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}$, a contradiction. (ii): Set $x^*:=\sum_{k=1}^n x^*_k$. By contradiction, suppose that $f(x^*)<\sum_{k=1}^n f(x_k^*)$. Define $g:\ell_\infty(A)\to \mathbb R_+$ by $$ \begin{cases} g(\lambda x^*):=\lambda \sum_{k=1}^n f(x_k^*) & \text{for all $\lambda>0$}, \\ g(z^*):=f(z^*) & \text{for all $z^*\in \ell_\infty(A) \setminus R(x^*)$}. \end{cases} $$ Clearly, $g$ is positively homogeneous, $f\leq g$ and $f\neq g$. Again by the maximality of~$f$, to get a contradiction it suffices to show that $\|g\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}=\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}$. Take $y_1^*,\dots,y_m^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ such that $\sum_{j=1}^m |y_j^*(a)|\leq 1$ for all $a\in A$. Let $I$ denote the set of all $j\in \{1,\dots,m\}$ for which $y_j^*\not\in R(x^*)$ and let $J:=\{1,\dots,m\}\setminus I$, so that for each $j\in J$ we can write $y_j^*=\lambda_j x^*$ for some $\lambda_j>0$. Set $\mu:=\sum_{j\in J}\lambda_j$. Since \begin{multline*} \sum_{j\in I}|y_j^*(a)|+\sum_{k=1}^n|\mu x_k^*(a)|= \sum_{j\in I}|y_j^*(a)|+\mu x^*(a) \\ = \sum_{j\in I}|y_j^*(a)|+\sum_{j\in J} \lambda_j x^*(a) = \sum_{j=1}^m|y_j^*(a)| \leq 1 \quad\mbox{for all }a\in A, \end{multline*} we obtain \begin{multline*} \sum_{j=1}^m g(y_j^*) =\sum_{j\in I}f(y_j^*) + \sum_{j\in J}\lambda_j\Big(\sum_{k=1}^n f(x_k^*)\Big) \\ =\sum_{j\in I} f(y_j^*)+\sum_{k=1}^n f(\mu x_k^*) \leq \|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}. \end{multline*} It follows that $\|g\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} \leq \|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}$, which is a contradiction. (iii): By Remark~\ref{rem:PointwiseBounded} we have $\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} \geq \|f\|_\infty$. To prove the equality, take finitely many $x_1^*,\dots,x_n^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ such that $\sum_{k=1}^n |x_k^*(a)|\leq 1$ for every $a\in A$. Then $x^*:=\sum_{k=1}^n |x_k^*|\in B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$ and $$ \sum_{k=1}^n f(x^*_k) \stackrel{{\rm (i)}}{\leq} \sum_{k=1}^n f(|x^*_k|) \stackrel{{\rm (ii)}}{\leq} f(x^*) \leq \|f\|_\infty. $$ This shows that $\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} \leq \|f\|_\infty$ and finishes the proof. \end{proof} \begin{lem}\label{lem:normoflinear} Let $A$ be a non-empty set and let $\phi:\ell_\infty(A) \to \mathbb{R}$ be a linear functional. Define $g_\phi:\ell_\infty(A) \to \mathbb R_+$ by $$ g_\phi(x^*) := |\phi(|x^*|)| \quad\mbox{ for all }x^*\in \ell_\infty(A). $$ Then $g_\phi\in H[\ell_1(A)]_+$ and $$ \|g_\phi\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} = \sup\big\{|\phi(x^*)|: \, x^*\in B_{\ell_\infty(A)}\big\}. $$ \end{lem} \begin{proof} Clearly, $g_\phi$ is positively homogeneous. Take any $x^*_1,\ldots,x^*_n\in \ell_\infty(A)$ such that $\sum_{k=1}^n|x^*_k(a)|\leq 1$ for all $a\in A$. For each $k\in \{1,\dots,n\}$, let $\varepsilon_k \in \{-1,1\}$ be the sign of $\phi(|x^*_k|)$. Then $\sum_{k=1}^n \varepsilon_k|x^*_k| \in B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$ and so $$ \sum_{k=1}^n g_\phi(x^*_k) = \sum_{k=1}^n \varepsilon_k \phi(|x^*_k|) = \phi\left(\sum_{k=1}^n \varepsilon_k|x^*_k|\right) \leq \sup\big\{|\phi(x^*)|: \, x^*\in B_{\ell_\infty(A)}\big\}=:\alpha. $$ This immediately shows that $\|g_\phi\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}\leq \alpha$. For the converse, pick $x^*\in B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$ and write it as $x^* = (x^*)^+ - (x^*)^-$, the difference of its positive and negative parts. Since $|(x^*)^+(a)| + |(x^*)^-(a)|=|x^*(a)|\leq 1$ for all $a\in A$, we have $$ |\phi(x^*)| \leq |\phi((x^*)^+)| + |\phi((x^*)^-)| = g_\phi((x^*)^+) + g_\phi((x^*)^-) \leq \|g_\phi\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}. $$ This proves that $\alpha\leq \|g_\phi\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}$. \end{proof} \begin{lem}\label{lem:MaximalNecessaryCondition} Let $A$ be a non-empty set and let $f \in H_0[\ell_1(A)]_+$ be maximal. Then there exists $\phi\in\ell_\infty(A)^*$ such that $f=g_\phi$. \end{lem} \begin{proof} The case $f=0$ being trivial, we can suppose without loss of generality that $\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} = 1$. The set $$ C:= \{x^*\in \ell_\infty(A)_+ :\, f(x^*)>1\} $$ is convex as a consequence of Lemma~\ref{lem:PropertiesMaximal}(ii). Let $U$ be the open unit ball of~$\ell_\infty(A)$. Since $\|f\|_\infty = \|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} = 1$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:PropertiesMaximal}(iii)), we have $C\cap U=\emptyset$. As an application of the Hahn-Banach separation theorem (cf. \cite[Proposition~2.13(ii)]{fab-ultimo}), there is $\phi\in \ell_\infty(A)^*$ such that \begin{equation}\label{eqn:HB} \phi(y^*) < \inf \{\phi(x^*) :\, x^* \in C\} \quad\mbox{for all }y^*\in U. \end{equation} We can suppose that $\|\phi\|=1$ and so $\|g_\phi\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}=1$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:normoflinear}). We claim that $f=g_\phi$. Indeed, since $f$ is maximal, it suffices to prove that $f(x^*)\leq g_\phi(x^*)$ for every $x^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ with $f(x^*)>0$. Fix $t>1$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:PropertiesMaximal}(i), we have $f(|x^*|)\geq f(x^*)>0$ and so $$ f\left(\frac{t}{f(|x^*|)}|x^*|\right) = t > 1. $$ Therefore, \eqref{eqn:HB} yields $$ \phi\left(\frac{t}{f(|x^*|)}|x^*|\right) \geq \sup \{|\phi(y^*)|:\, y^*\in U\}=\|\phi\|=1. $$ We conclude that $t\phi(|x^*|) \geq f(|x^*|) $ for any $t>1$, so $g_\phi(|x^*|)=\phi(|x^*|)\geq f(x^*)$. The proof is complete. \end{proof} Given any non-empty set~$A$, it is well-known that every $\phi\in \ell_\infty(A)^*$ can be written in a unique way as $\phi = \phi_0 + \phi_1$, where \begin{itemize} \item $\phi_0 \in \ell_1(A)$ (identified as a subspace of~$\ell_\infty(A)^*$), \item $\phi_1 \in \ell_\infty(A)^*$ vanishes on all finitely supported elements of~$\ell_\infty(A)$. \end{itemize} Moreover, $\|\phi\| = \|\phi_0\| + \|\phi_1\|$. \begin{lem}\label{lem:CountableSum} Let $A$ be a non-empty set and $\phi\in \ell_1(A)$. Then $g_\phi \in FBL[\ell_1(A)]$. \end{lem} \begin{proof} Let $(e_a)_{a\in A}$ be the unit vector basis of~$\ell_1(A)$. The series $\sum_{a\in A} \phi(a) |\delta_{e_a}|$ is summable in $FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ because $\phi\in \ell_1(A)$ and $\|\delta_{e_a}\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}=1$ for every $a\in A$. Let $h \in FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ be its sum. By Remark~\ref{rem:PointwiseBounded}, we have $$ h(x^*) = \sum_{a\in A} \phi(a) |x^*(a)| \quad\mbox{for all }x^*\in \ell_\infty(A). $$ Therefore, $|h(x^*)|=g_\phi(x^*)$ for all $x^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ and so $g_\phi\in FBL[\ell_1(A)]$. \end{proof} \begin{lem}\label{lem:continuity} Let $A$ be a non-empty set, $\xi: B_{\ell_\infty(A)} \to \mathbb R$ a $w^*$-continuous function and $\phi\in \ell_\infty(A)^*$. If $\xi \leq g_\phi$ on~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$, then $\xi \leq g_{\phi_0}$ on~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$ as well. \end{lem} \begin{proof} The $w^*$-topology on~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}=[-1,1]^A$ agrees with the pointwise topology. Since the map $x^* \mapsto |x^*|$ is $w^*$-$w^*$-continuous when restricted to~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$ and $\phi_0$ is $w^*$-continuous, we have that $g_{\phi_0}$ is $w^*$-continuous on~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$. On the other hand, if $x^*\in B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$ is finitely supported, then $\phi_1(|x^*|) = 0$ and, therefore, we have $\xi(x^*) \leq g_{\phi}(x^*) = |\phi_0(|x^*|)|=g_{\phi_0}(x^*)$. Since the finitely supported elements of~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$ are $w^*$-dense and the functions $\xi$ and $g_{\phi_0}$ are $w^*$-continuous on~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$, we conclude that $\xi \leq g_{\phi_0}$ on~$B_{\ell_\infty(A)}$. \end{proof} \begin{lem}\label{lem:continuity2} Let $E$ be a Banach space. Then for every $f\in FBL[E]$ the restriction $f|_{B_{E^{*}}}$ is $w^*$-continuous. \end{lem} \begin{proof} The set $S$ consisting of all $f\in FBL[E]$ for which $f|_{B_{E^{*}}}$ is $w^*$-continuous is clearly a sublattice of~$FBL[E]$ containing $\{\delta_x:x\in E\}$. Moreover, $S$ is closed in $FBL[E]$ (by Remark~\ref{rem:PointwiseBounded}), so $FBL[E]=S$. \end{proof} We arrive at the main result of this section: \begin{thm}\label{thm:Nakano} The norm of $FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ has the strong Nakano property for any non-empty set~$A$. \end{thm} \begin{proof} Let $\mathcal{F} \subseteq FBL[\ell_1(A)]_+$ be an upwards directed family such that $$ \sup\{\|f\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} : \, f\in\mathcal{F}\} = 1. $$ We are going to show that $\mathcal{F}$ has an upper bound of norm 1. Note that $\mathcal{F}$ is pointwise bounded (Remark~\ref{rem:PointwiseBounded}) and let $h:\ell_\infty(A)\to \mathbb R_+$ be defined as $h(x^*):=\sup\{f(x^*):f\in \mathcal{F}\}$ for all $x^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$. Lemma~\ref{lem:PointwiseSupremum} ensures that $h\in H_0[\ell_1(A)]_+$ and $\|h\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]} = 1$. Now let $g\in H_0[\ell_1(A)]_+$ be maximal such that $g\geq h$ and $\|g\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}=1$ (apply Lemma~\ref{lem:Zorn}). Then $g=g_\phi$ for some $\phi \in \ell_\infty(A)^*$ with $\|\phi\|=1$ (combine Lemmas~\ref{lem:MaximalNecessaryCondition} and~\ref{lem:normoflinear}). Given any $f\in \mathcal{F} \subseteq FBL[\ell_1(A)]$, we have $f\leq g_\phi$ and the restriction $f|_{B_{\ell_\infty(A)}}$ is $w^*$-continuous (Lemma~\ref{lem:continuity2}), hence Lemma~\ref{lem:continuity} yields $f(x^*)\leq g_{\phi_0}(x^*)$ for every $x^*\in \ell_\infty(A)$ (bear in mind that both $f$ and $g_{\phi_0}$ are positively homogeneous). Since $g_{\phi_0} \in FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:CountableSum}) and $1=\|\phi\| \geq \|\phi_0\|=\|g_{\phi_0}\|_{FBL[\ell_1(A)]}$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:normoflinear}), it turns out that $g_{\phi_0}$ is the upper bound of~$\mathcal{F}$ in $FBL[\ell_1(A)]$ that we were looking for. The proof is finished. \end{proof} It is natural to wonder whether the norm of $FBL[E]$ also has the (strong) Nakano property for an arbitrary Banach space~$E$. We will next show that the norm of $FBL[L_1]$ is not even Fatou, where $L_1$ denotes the space $L_1([0,1],\mu)$ and $\mu$ is the Lebesgue measure. The following auxiliary lemma belongs to the folklore and we include its proof for the sake of completeness. \begin{lem}\label{l:fn} For each $n\in\mathbb N$, define $f_n: L_1 \to \mathbb R_+$ by $$ f_n(h):=\sum_{j=1}^{2^n} \Big|\int_{I_{n,j}} h \, d\mu\Big| \quad \mbox{for every }h\in L_1, $$ where $I_{n,j}:=[\frac{j-1}{2^n},\frac{j}{2^n}]$ for all $j\in \{1,\dots,2^n\}$. The following properties hold: \begin{enumerate} \item[(i)] $f_n(h)\leq f_{n+1}(h)$ for every $n\in\mathbb N$ and $h\in L_1$. \item[(ii)] $\lim_{n\to \infty} f_n(h)=\int_0^1|h| \, d\mu$ for every $h\in L_1$. \end{enumerate} \end{lem} \begin{proof} Part~(i) is straightforward. To prove (ii), note first that for every $h\in L_1$ we have $f_n(h)\leq\int_0^1|h| \, d\mu$ for all $n\in \mathbb{N}$, so the increasing sequence $(f_n(h))$ is bounded and converges to its supremum. Let us denote $$ \phi(h):=\sup_{n\in \mathbb{N}} f_n(h)=\lim_{n\to \infty}f_n(h) \quad\mbox{for }h\in L_1. $$ We want to show that $\phi(h)=\int_0^1|h| \, d\mu$ for every $h\in L_1$. Observe first that this equality is clear whenever $h$ is of the form \begin{equation}\label{eqn:simple} \sum_{j=1}^{2^n} a_j \chi_{I_{n,j}} \end{equation} for some $n\in \mathbb{N}$ and some $a_1,\dots,a_{2^n}\in \mathbb R$. To prove the equality for arbitrary $h\in L_1$ it is enough to show that $\phi: L_1\to \mathbb R$ is $\|\cdot\|_1$-continuous (because simple functions as in~\eqref{eqn:simple} are dense in~$L_1$). In fact, we will check that \begin{equation}\label{eqn:continuity} |\phi(h)-\phi(h')|\leq \|h-h'\|_1 \quad\mbox{for every }h,h'\in L_1. \end{equation} Indeed, given any $n\in \mathbb{N}$, we have \begin{eqnarray*} |f_n(h)-f_n(h')| &=& \left| \sum_{j=1}^{2^n} \left( \Big|\int_{I_{n,j}} h \, d\mu\Big| -\Big|\int_{I_{n,j}} h' \, d\mu\Big| \right) \right| \\ &\leq& \sum_{j=1}^{2^n} \left| \Big|\int_{I_{n,j}} h \, d\mu\Big| -\Big|\int_{I_{n,j}} h' \, d\mu\Big| \right| \\ &\leq& \sum_{j=1}^{2^n} \left| \int_{I_{n,j}} h \, d\mu -\int_{I_{n,j}} h' \, d\mu \right| \\ &\leq& \sum_{j=1}^{2^n} \int_{I_{n,j}} |h-h'| \, d\mu=\|h-h'\|_1. \end{eqnarray*} As $n\in\mathbb{N}$ is arbitrary, \eqref{eqn:continuity} holds and the proof is finished. \end{proof} \begin{thm}\label{t:nofatou} The norm of $FBL[L_1]$ fails the Fatou property. \end{thm} \begin{proof} We use the notation of Lemma~\ref{l:fn}. By considering the natural inclusion of~$L_\infty=L_1^*$ in~$L_1$, each $f_n$ can be seen as an element of $H[L_1]_+$. In fact, we have $f_n\in FBL[L_1]_+$ and $\|f_n\|_{FBL[L_1]}=1$, because $$ f_n=\sum_{j=1}^{2^n}|\delta_{\chi_{I_{n,j}}}| $$ and $$ 1=f_n(\chi_{[0,1]}) \leq \|f_n\|_\infty \leq \|f_n\|_{FBL[L_1]} \leq \sum_{j=1}^{2^n}\|\delta_{\chi_{I_{n,j}}}\|_{FBL[L_1]}= \sum_{j=1}^{2^n}\|\chi_{I_{n,j}}\|_{1} = 1. $$ Fix any $g\in FBL[L_1]_+$ with $\|g\|_{FBL[L_1]}>1$, and let $\tilde{f}_n:=g\wedge f_n \in FBL[L_1]_+$ for all $n\in \mathbb{N}$. The sequence $(\tilde f_n)$ is increasing (by Lemma \ref{l:fn}), bounded above by~$g$ and $$ \sup_{n\in \mathbb{N}}\|\tilde f_n\|_{FBL[L_1]}\leq \sup_{n\in \mathbb{N}}\| f_n\|_{FBL[L_1]} =1. $$ We claim that $\sup_{n\in \mathbb{N}} \tilde f_n= g$ in $FBL[L_1]$. Indeed, fix $h\in L_\infty$ and let $$ K:=\|g\|_{FBL[L_1]}\|h\|_\infty+\|h\|_1+1. $$ Define $$ h_j:=h+K r_j \in L_\infty \quad\mbox{for all }j\in \mathbb{N} $$ (where $r_j$ denotes the $j$-th Rademacher function) and observe that the sequence $(h_j)$ is $w^*$-convergent to~$h$ (as $(r_j)$ is $w^*$-null in~$L_\infty$). Since $g:L_\infty \to \mathbb R_+$ is $w^*$-continuous on bounded sets (Lemma~\ref{lem:continuity2}), we have $g(h_j)\to g(h)$ as $j\to \infty$, so in particular there is $j_0\in \mathbb{N}$ such that for every $j\geq j_0$ we have \begin{multline}\label{eqn:K} g(h_j)\leq g(h)+1 \leq \|g\|_{FBL[L_1]}\|h\|_\infty+1= K-\|h\|_1\leq\int_0^1|h_j|d\mu. \end{multline} (the second inequality being a consequence of Remark~\ref{rem:PointwiseBounded}). Now take any $\varphi\in FBL[L_1]$ satisfying $\varphi\geq \tilde f_n$ for every $n\in\mathbb N$. By Lemma \ref{l:fn}, for every $j\geq j_0$ we have $$ \varphi(h_j)\geq \sup_{n\in \mathbb{N}} \tilde f_n(h_j)=g(h_j)\wedge\int_0^1|h_j|d\mu\stackrel{\eqref{eqn:K}}{=}g(h_j). $$ Since $\varphi$ and $g$ are $w^*$-continuous on bounded sets (Lemma~\ref{lem:continuity2}), it follows that $\varphi(h)\geq g(h)$. Therefore, we have $\sup_{n\in \mathbb{N}} \tilde f_n= g$ in $FBL[L_1]$. Since $\sup_{n\in \mathbb{N}}\|\tilde f_n\|_{FBL[L_1]}\leq 1$ and $\|g\|_{FBL[L_1]}>1$, the Fatou property cannot hold. \end{proof} \section{An application to weakly compactly generated Banach lattices}\label{s:wcg} The purpose of this section is to give a negative answer to Diestel's question mentioned in the introduction (Problem~\ref{problem:Diestel}). Interestingly enough, that question can be equivalently rephrased by asking: \begin{prob}\label{problem:AntonioPedro} If $E$ is a WCG Banach space, is $FBL[E]$ WCG as well? \end{prob} The equivalence of Problems~\ref{problem:Diestel} and~\ref{problem:AntonioPedro} follows at once from the following remarks: \begin{rem}\label{r:E-WCG-implies-FBL-LWCG} If $E$ is a WCG Banach space, then $FBL[E]$ is LWCG. \end{rem} \begin{proof} Let $K \subseteq E$ be a weakly compact set such that $E=\overline{{\rm span}}(K)$. Then the sublattice generated by the weakly compact set $\phi_E(K)=\{\delta_x:x\in K\}$ is dense in~$FBL[E]$. \end{proof} \begin{rem}\label{r:} Let $X$ be an LWCG Banach lattice. Then there exist a WCG Banach space $E$ and an operator $\hat T:FBL[E] \to X$ with dense range. \end{rem} \begin{proof} Let $K \subseteq X$ be a weakly compact set such that the sublattice generated by~$K$ is dense in~$X$. Define $E:=\overline{{\rm span}}(K) \subseteq X$. Then there is a lattice homomorphism $\hat T:FBL[E]\to X$ such that $\hat T\circ \phi_E$ is the identity on~$E$ (Theorem~\ref{t:fblb}). The sublattice generated by $E$ in~$X$ is contained in the range of~$\hat T$, hence the range of $\hat T$ is dense in $X$. \end{proof} So we might ask whether $FBL[c_0(\Gamma)]$ or $FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]$ ($1<p<\infty$) are WCG for uncountable~$\Gamma$. We will next see that $FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]$ is not WCG whenever $\Gamma$ is uncountable and $1<p\leq 2$, hence answering in the negative Diestel's question. \begin{thm}\label{l2wcg} Let $\Gamma$ be a non-empty set and $1< p\leq 2$. Then $FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]$ contains a subspace isomorphic to~$\ell_1(\Gamma)$. \end{thm} \begin{proof} Let $(e_\gamma)_{\gamma\in\Gamma}$ denote the unit vector basis of $\ell_p(\Gamma)$. We will prove that the family $\{|\delta_{e_\gamma}|:\gamma\in \Gamma\} \subseteq S_{FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]}$ is equivalent to the unit vector basis of $\ell_1(\Gamma)$. Let $i: \ell_p \to \ell_2$ be the formal inclusion operator (so that $\|i\|=1$) and let $j: \ell_2 \to L_1$ be the isomorphic embedding satisfying $\|j\|=1$ and $j(e_n)=r_n$ for all $n\in \mathbb{N}$, where $(e_n)$ is the unit vector basis of~$\ell_2$ and $r_n$ denotes the $n$-th Rademacher function (see e.g. \cite[Theorem~6.2.3]{alb-kal}). Given any finite set $A=\{\gamma_1,\dots,\gamma_n\} \subseteq \Gamma$, let $P_A:\ell_p(\Gamma)\to \ell_p$ be the operator defined by $$ P_A((x_\gamma)_{\gamma\in \Gamma}):=(x_{\gamma_1},x_{\gamma_2},\dots,x_{\gamma_n},0,0,\dots) $$ (for $A=\emptyset$ we define $P_\emptyset:=0$) and consider $$ T_A:=j\circ i \circ P_A: \ell_p(\Gamma)\rightarrow L_1, $$ so that $\|T_A\| \leq 1$. Let $\hat{T}_A:FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]\to L_1$ be the unique lattice homomorphism extending $T_A$, which satisfies $\|\hat{T}_A\|=\|T_A\|$ (Theorem~\ref{t:fblb}). Define $\xi_A^*:=(\hat{T}_A)^*(\chi_{[0,1]})\in FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]^*$ and note that $\|\xi_A^*\|\leq 1$. Moreover, for each $\gamma\in \Gamma$ we have \begin{equation}\label{eqn:TA} \big\langle \xi_A^*,|\delta_{e_\gamma}|\big\rangle= \big\langle \chi_{[0,1]},\hat{T}_A(|\delta_{e_\gamma}|)\big\rangle= \big\langle \chi_{[0,1]},|T_A(e_\gamma)|\big\rangle =\left\{ \begin{array}{ccc} 1 & & \textrm{ if }\gamma\in A \\ & & \\ 0 & & \textrm{ if }\gamma\not\in A. \end{array} \right. \end{equation} Finally, take any finite non-empty set $B \subseteq \Gamma$ and pick $a_\gamma\in \mathbb R$ for each $\gamma\in B$. Write $B_+:=\{\gamma\in B: a_\gamma>0\}$ and $B_-:=\{\gamma\in B: a_\gamma<0\}$. From~\eqref{eqn:TA} it follows that $$ 2\Big\|\sum_{\gamma\in B} a_\gamma|\delta_{e_\gamma}|\Big\|_{FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]} \geq \xi_{B_+}^*\Big(\sum_{\gamma \in B} a_\gamma|\delta_{e_\gamma}|\Big) - \xi_{B_-}^*\Big(\sum_{\gamma \in B} a_\gamma|\delta_{e_\gamma}|\Big)=\sum_{\gamma\in B} |a_\gamma|. $$ This shows that $\{|\delta_{e_\gamma}|:\gamma\in \Gamma\}$ is equivalent to the unit vector basis of $\ell_1(\Gamma)$, hence $\overline{{\rm span}}(\{|\delta_{e_\gamma}|:\gamma\in \Gamma\})$ is isomorphic to~$\ell_1(\Gamma)$. \end{proof} \begin{cor}\label{c:Diestel} Let $\Gamma$ be an uncountable set and $1 < p \leq 2$. Then $FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]$ is LWCG but it is not isomorphic to a subspace of a WCG Banach space. \end{cor} \begin{proof} Bear in mind that $\ell_1(\Gamma)$ does not embed isomorphically into any WCG Banach space. This can be deduced, for instance, from the fact that subspaces of WCG Banach spaces are weakly Lindel\"of (see e.g. \cite[Theorem 14.31]{fab-ultimo}), while $\ell_1(\Gamma)$ is not weakly Lindel\"of (see e.g. \cite[Proposition~5.11]{edgar2}). \end{proof} We do not know whether the spaces $FBL[c_0(\Gamma)]$ or $FBL[\ell_p(\Gamma)]$ for $2<p<\infty$ and uncountable~$\Gamma$ are WCG. In fact, we do not know any non-separable Banach space $E$ for which $FBL[E]$ is WCG. \section*{Acknowledgements} The research of A.~Avil\'{e}s and J.~Rodr\'{i}guez was supported by Ministerio de Econom\'{i}a y Competitividad and FEDER (project MTM2014-54182-P) and Fundaci\'{o}n S\'{e}neca (project 19275/PI/14). The research of P.~Tradacete was supported by Ministerio de Econom\'{i}a y Competitividad (projects MTM2016-75196-P and MTM2016-76808-P) and Grupo UCM 910346. \def$'${$'$} \providecommand{\MR}{\relax\ifhmode\unskip\space\fi MR }

Introduction ============ One out of eight Korean children under the age of 18 lived in relative poverty in 2008 \[[@B1]\]. Many factors can influence the growth of children, but poverty can have a particularly profound effect on it. Poverty has been linked to under-nutrition and nutrient deficiencies, especially in children \[[@B2],[@B3]\]. In Korea, the study regarding the diet of children from low-income families started in the 1970s \[[@B4]\]. More than 20 precedent studies since then have suggested that the diet intake status children differ according to socioeconomic status; children from low-income families have greater possibility to lead to poorer nutritional status than those from higher-income families. According to the study having analyzed the data from the 2001 National Health and Nutrition Survey, the average energy intake level of children from low-income families was lower than those from higher-income families \[[@B5]\]. The children from low-income families were reported to be lack of such nutrients as protein, calcium, phosphorus, riboflavin as well as energy in the study with elementary students \[[@B6]\]. The school-aged children from low-income families were found to have consumed less milk·dairy products, fruits, and meat·fish·egg·beans than those from higher-income families \[[@B7]\]. The needy children in Korea are provided with free school lunches. They could also get meal support under the government-funded program during holidays and vacation. As of August 2010, 483,567 children have received meal support from local governments by Meal Box Delivery (13.1%), Institutional Foodservice (20.1%), Restaurant Foodservice (28.0%), Food Delivery (14.6%), or other ways (24.1%) \[[@B8]\]. In USA, children from low-income families also could eat free meals through the National School Lunch Program, the School Breakfast Program, and the Summer Food Service Program (SFSP). Among them, SFSP is quite similar to the government-funded meal support program in Korea in that both of the programs are operated during vacation. The nutritional analysis of SFSP menus revealed that the supported lunch meals, on average, met one-third of the Recommended Daily Allowance or Adequate Intake in terms of examined nutrients such as protein, vitamin A, vitamin C, and calcium \[[@B9],[@B10]\]. In Korea, there was a study having reported physical development and dietary behaviors of children supported by Institutional foodservice \[[@B11]\]. However, no studies have been found to report the dietary intake of children under the government-funded meal support program during summer vacation. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to investigate the nutritional adequacy and food variety of the children\'s diet under the government-funded meal support program during summer vacation. Subjects and Methods ==================== Dietary recall and survey ------------------------- ### Data collection The subjects of the study were 143 4^th^-6^th^ elementary school students receiving free lunches from the government and living in Gwanak-gu, Seoul, Korea. Gwanak-gu was selected as the study site because the number of the children under the government-funded meal support program was the highest in Seoul at the time of the study \[[@B12]\]. The subjects consisted of four groups supported by Meal Box Delivery (n = 26), Institutional Foodservice (n = 53), Restaurant Foodservice (n = 27), or Food Delivery (n = 37). The purpose and procedure of the study were explained to each subject or their guardians. The data were collected during summer vacation of 2007. Three-day 24-hour dietary recall data were collected to analyze nutritional adequacy and food variety of the children\'s diet. The trained interviewers recorded the diet consumed by the children for two days and made a follow-up phone call to collect the third day recall day. The children\'s opinions on meals supported by local governments were collected by a self-administered survey. The children\'s heights and weights were also measured. ### Data analysis Nutrient intakes were calculated by CAN-PRO \[[@B13]\], a computer-aided nutritional analysis software program developed by the Korean Nutrition Society. The nutrient intakes were compared to the Dietary Reference Intakes for Koreans \[[@B14]\]. To examine nutritional adequacy, the percentages of the children not meeting the dietary recommendations were calculated for selected nutrients; the dietary recommendations for energy and nutrient intake were based on Estimated Energy Requirement (EER) and Estimated Average Requirement (EAR), respectively. The percentages of each nutrient intake out of Recommended Intake (RI) were also analyzed. To assess dietary variety, the mean numbers of consumed dishes and food items were calculated. The scores for the children\'s opinions on the meals supported by local governments were 1 point for strongly disagree, 2 points for disagree, 3 points for neutral, 4 points for agree, and 5 points for strongly agree. The scores for the degree of general satisfaction were 1 point for very unsatisfied, 2 points for unsatisfied, 3 points for satisfied, and 4 points for very satisfied. The data were analyzed using SAS software \[[@B15]\]. Means, standard deviation, and frequencies were calculated. The significance of difference among groups was analyzed by Chi-square test and one-way ANOVA followed by Duncan\'s multiple-range test. Drawing ------- ### Data collection We collected the qualitative data for this study through the children\'s drawings. Children often better express their feelings or opinions though their drawings than they are willing or able to do verbally. We asked children to draw the scene of their lunch time and provided them with 48 kinds of crayons and 21 kinds of color pens with a sketch book. To help them with the drawing task, we asked the children questions such as: \"How was your feeling when you ate the lunch?\", \"What did you eat for lunch?\", and \"Who did you eat lunch with?\". A total of 15 children recruited among the 143 children participating in the survey completed drawing. ### Data analysis We investigated emotional, dietary, and human aspects of the children by counting the numbers of colors, dishes, and accompanying persons appearing in the drawings. Results ======= General characteristics ----------------------- The split between boys and girls was almost even. On average, the subjects were 11 years old, with a height of 146 cm, and a weight of 40.6 kg. The height and weight of the children did not significantly differ by meal support method ([Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}). Nutritional adequacy -------------------- The daily nutrient intakes were presented in [Table 2](#T2){ref-type="table"}. On average, the children consumed 1,400 kcal per day. Significant differences were found in fat and vitamin A consumption by meal support method. The children supported by Meal Box Delivery consumed more fat than the other groups. Additionally, children supported by Meal Box Delivery had a lower percentage of carbohydrate consumption and a higher percentage of fat consumption than the other groups. The percentages of the children with inadequate daily intake of the examined nutrients were depicted in [Fig. 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. The majority of the children, ranging from 89% of those supported by Food Delivery to 100% of those supported by Meal Box Delivery, consumed less energy than EER. The results also showed inadequate intake of all the examined nutrients; of particular concern was the extremely low intake of calcium. At most, only 12% of the children supported by Meal Box Delivery consumed the amount of EAR or more for calcium. The percentage of the children with inadequate daily intake of protein was the lowest among all the examined nutrients. Additionally, the percentage of the children with inadequate daily intake of vitamin C was significantly different among the four groups by meal support method. The children supported by Meal Box Delivery tended to have more nutritional lunches than the other groups; they consumed significantly more protein and niacin than the other groups. There were significantly different percentages of energy intake from carbohydrate, protein, and fat by meal support method. The children supported by Meal Box Delivery also had a lower percentage of carbohydrate consumption than the other groups ([Table 3](#T3){ref-type="table"}). The energy and nutrient intakes from lunches were assessed as percentages of EER or RI ([Fig. 2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}). The children consumed about 21% to 25% of EER at lunch. Even though the overall intakes from Meal Box Delivery were still low, children supported by Meal Box Delivery consumed significantly more protein and niacin than the other groups. As noted earlier, the percentage of RI was the lowest in calcium intake among all the examined nutrients. Dietary variety --------------- The numbers of dishes and food items were summarized in [Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}. On average, children consumed eight dishes and 25 food items per day. The children supported by Meal Box Delivery consumed 14 food items at lunch. That number was more than twice for those supported by Food Delivery. Opinions on meals ----------------- The children\'s opinions on meals under the government-funded meal support program were represented in [Table 5](#T5){ref-type="table"}. The children supported by Meal Box Delivery tended to strongly agree on the \'I look forward to lunch time\' questions. The majority of the children, except those supported by Restaurant Foodservice, wanted to receive the same type of meal support as the current method during the next vacation. The percentage of children preferring their current support method was the highest in those supported by Meal Box Delivery and the lowest in those supported by Food Delivery ([Table 6](#T6){ref-type="table"}). Drawing of lunch time scene --------------------------- On average, the children supported by Meal Box Delivery or Institutional Foodservice used more than ten colors whereas those supported by Restaurant Foodservice used only six colors in their drawings. The average number of dishes appearing in the children\'s drawings was four. The children supported by Food Delivery or Restaurant Foodservice drew only one accompanying person on average. However, the children supported by Institutional Foodservice featured eight persons in the drawings on average ([Table 7](#T7){ref-type="table"}). Examples of the drawings were shown in [Fig. 3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. Discussion ========== This study investigated the diet of 143 children under the government-funded meal support program in Korea during the summer vacation of 2007. On average, the subjects were 11 years old, with a height of 146 cm, and a weight of 40.6 kg. These figures were less than those of the 2005 National Health and Nutrition Survey of the pertinent age group, which reported that an average height for boys was 150.3 cm and 151.3 cm for girls, while the average weight for boys was 46.2 kg and 43.3 kg for girls \[[@B16]\]. On average, the energy intake was 1,400 kcal per day, which means the children consumed less than EER, which is 1,900 kcal for boys and 1,700 kcal for girls in the pertinent age group \[[@B14]\]. This amount of energy consumption was a little bit higher than that (1,348 kcal) reported by a previous study dealing with students of ages and socio-economic status similar to those of this study \[[@B17]\]. The results showed inadequate intake of all the examined nutrients. Especially, calcium intake seemed to be the biggest problem. Previous studies have also shown low calcium intake of children living in both urban \[[@B6]\] and rural areas \[[@B18]\]. A US study reported that 93% of urban children from low-income families had failed to meet Adequate Intake levels of calcium \[[@B19]\]. According to the previous studies, milk and dairy products, which are the main sources of calcium, were available less frequently in low-income families compared with higher-income families \[[@B6],[@B7],[@B20]\]. Calcium is a vital element for healthy bones and teeth. Inadequate calcium intake during the growth period leads children to growth delay \[[@B21]\]. Therefore, the meal support program needs to pay attention to calcium supply in the meals or snacks for the children from low-income families. The percentages of energy intake at lunch from carbohydrates, proteins, and fats were 61.2%, 15.8%, and 23.0%, respectively in this study. In a study evaluating the nutrient intakes of children living in urban areas \[[@B22]\], the result showed a lower percentage of energy from carbohydrate and a higher percentage of energy from fat than those of this study; the percentage of those was 54.9%, 15.7%, and 31.0%, respectively. However, our findings were similar to the results of another previous study conducted with low-income children living in rural areas \[[@B17]\], which reported that the percentage of energy intake from carbohydrates, proteins, and fats was 60.8%, 15.9%, and 23.4%, respectively. The association of percentage of energy intake from carbohydrate, protein, and fat with socioeconomic status was shown in other studies conducted in other countries. It was reported that the children from low-income families in Northeastern Thailand consumed lower percentage of energy from fat and a higher percentage of energy from carbohydrate than the children from high-income families \[[@B23]\]. In Taipei, Lyu et al. \[[@B20]\] also reported that sons from low-income families had lower percentage from protein as part of their energy intake than sons from higher-income families. The results from this study showed that the percentages of energy intake from carbohydrate, protein, and fat were different by meal support method. Children supported by Institutional Foodservice, Restaurant Foodservice, and Food Delivery consumed higher percentage of energy from carbohydrate than children supported by Meal Box Delivery. In order to assess the food variety of the meals, the numbers of dishes and food items were calculated. On average, the children consumed eight dishes and 25 food items per day. Especially, those supported by Food Delivery showed lack of variety in food items. Although our findings showed a remarkably lower number than that reported in elementary school children (32 food items) \[[@B24]\], the numbers of food items were higher in children supported by Meal Box Delivery or Institutional Foodservice than the other groups. This kind of difference might have been caused by the fact that the menus of Institutional Foodservices (17.4%) \[[@B25]\] or Meal Box Delivery (32.0%) \[[@B26]\] were planned more frequently by a specialist than the other groups. The drawings by the children appeared to be a useful method for identifying their underlying feelings or opinions. Several studies \[[@B27],[@B28]\] have suggested that the proper method to collect qualitative information about children\'s feelings or opinions are their drawings. Although drawing has not been used widely in food and nutrition research in Korea, the drawing method has been used in food education in Japan \[[@B29]\]. The atmosphere of each drawing was very different by meal support method. The children supported by Institutional Foodservice were thought to eat lunches with excitement among friends. However, the drawing of children supported by Food Delivery did not show many accompanying persons. According to a previous study \[[@B29]\], children eating alone ate less-balanced meals, mainly only with staple dishes. They were also less likely to have an appetite before meals, to enjoy eating their meals, and to be healthy. A previous study also indicated that the children eating meals with friends or family were more satisfied than those eating meals alone \[[@B25]\]. The drawings of the children supported by Institutional Foodservice showed more positive scenes than the other groups, especially in terms of human aspect. Although the sample size of this study was small, it was the first reported study to investigate the diet of children under the government-funded meal support program in Korea. The results of this study could be used as useful and important information to develop and plan nutritional policy and programs for children from low-income families under the government-funded meal support program. Further studies about dietary patterns and food-related behaviors are needed to improve low-income children\'s nutrition status in Korea. This research was supported by the 2007 research fund from the Happy Foundation. {#F1} {#F2} {#F3} ###### General characteristics of children in this study  ^1)^Others included grandfathers and relatives. ^2)^BMI (Body Mass Index) = Weight (kg)/Height (m^2^) ###### Children\'s daily nutrient intakes  ^1)^*P*-value by ANOVA ^abc^Different superscript letters in the same row mean significant difference among groups by Duncan\'s multiple range test at α = 0.05. ###### Children\'s nutrient intakes at lunch  ^1)^The number was 142, one less than the number in the result of daily intake, because one child supported by Food Delivery had not eaten lunch at all during the data collection period. ^2)^*P*-value by ANOVA ^abc^Different superscript in the same row mean significant difference among groups by Duncan\'s multiple range test at α = 0.05. ###### Food variety of children\'s diet  ^1)^*P*-value by ANOVA ^2)^The number was 142, one less than the number in the result of daily intake, because one child supported by Food Delivery had not eaten lunch at all during the data collection period. ^abc^Different superscript letters in the same row mean significant difference among groups by Duncan\'s multiple range test at α = 0.05. ###### Children\'s opinions on meals under the government-funded meal support program  ^1)^*P*-value by ANOVA ^2)^Scale of 1 = strongly disagree, 2 = disagree, 3 = neutral, 4 = agree, 5 = strongly agree ^3)^Scale of 1 = very unsatisfied, 2 = unsatisfied, 3 = satisfied, 4 = very satisfied ###### Children\'s preference of meal support methods  ^1)^*P*-value by Chi-square test ^2)^Others included \'the food which a mother made\' and \'no preference\'. ###### Analysis results of children\'s drawings 

1. Introduction {#sec1-sensors-18-04302} =============== Pesticides have been widely used worldwide to protect crops from insects and increase the quantity and quality of agricultural products \[[@B1-sensors-18-04302],[@B2-sensors-18-04302],[@B3-sensors-18-04302]\]. Pesticide use, however, can affect ecosystems, nontarget organisms, agricultural product safety, and human health \[[@B4-sensors-18-04302]\]. Organophosphates (OPs) are a class of pesticides designed to affect the insect nervous system \[[@B5-sensors-18-04302],[@B6-sensors-18-04302],[@B7-sensors-18-04302],[@B8-sensors-18-04302],[@B9-sensors-18-04302],[@B10-sensors-18-04302]\]. OPs irreversibly inactivate acetylcholinesterase, an enzyme that degrades the neurotransmitter acetylcholine at cholinergic synapses and that is essential to nerve function \[[@B11-sensors-18-04302],[@B12-sensors-18-04302]\]. OP residues in agricultural products and water are a potential source of toxicity to bees, wildlife, and humans \[[@B13-sensors-18-04302],[@B14-sensors-18-04302]\]. It is therefore imperative to develop highly sensitive and reliable methods to determine pesticide content in environmental samples. Multiple methods to assay OPs have been developed, including gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, liquid chromatography, enzyme inhibition, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), and electrochemical analysis \[[@B15-sensors-18-04302],[@B16-sensors-18-04302],[@B17-sensors-18-04302],[@B18-sensors-18-04302],[@B19-sensors-18-04302],[@B20-sensors-18-04302],[@B21-sensors-18-04302]\]. Chromatography is typically used for assaying pesticides, and liquid or gas chromatography-mass spectrometry is the most common method. Whereas chromatography methods provide adequate selectivity and sensitivity, they require multistep sample pretreatment, detailed experimental conditions, and adept operators and sophisticated instruments. The enzyme inhibition method is a fast and simple low-cost technique, but its specificity is low. ELISA uses antibodies and color changes to identify a substance with good repeatability, sensitivity, and specificity, but the poor stability of enzymes or antibodies in practical performance and the low specificity limit its use. None of the conventional methods are suitable for on-site detection with sensitivity and specificity. Significant challenges remain in exploiting fast, specific, low-cost, and easy-to-manipulate OP assays. Gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) possess unique optical properties related to their size, surrounding environment, and dispersion state \[[@B22-sensors-18-04302],[@B23-sensors-18-04302]\]. AuNP-based colorimetric and fluorescent assays have been used for chemical and biological applications with versatility and simplicity \[[@B24-sensors-18-04302],[@B25-sensors-18-04302],[@B26-sensors-18-04302],[@B27-sensors-18-04302],[@B28-sensors-18-04302],[@B29-sensors-18-04302],[@B30-sensors-18-04302]\]. These assays are based on AuNP dispersion and aggregation states in response to a specific analyte and certain recognition mechanisms. The surface energy of AuNPs tends to decrease, leading to aggregation and sedimentation of the colloidal system. Citric acid-modified AuNPs can be easily aggregated by the addition of sulfur-containing OPs because of the strong Au-S bond. In recent years, this AuNP aggregation mechanism has drawn considerable attention in OP research \[[@B31-sensors-18-04302],[@B32-sensors-18-04302],[@B33-sensors-18-04302],[@B34-sensors-18-04302]\]. Although these methods are accurate, fast, sensitive, and easy to perform, they commonly lack specificity to some OPs because of the sensitive, strong Au-S bond, as many OPs contain sulfur. In theory, electrostatic and steric repulsion are the two main stabilizing mechanisms against AuNP aggregation, and the strong Au-S bond can destroy AuNP electrostatic stabilization and result in aggregation, depending on the OPs' sulfur energy and capping agents. In this paper, we discuss the possibility of identifying and quantifying specific sulfur-containing OPs by controlling the Au-S bond and capping agent. We established a specific dual-readout assay for the OP ethoprophos by adding adenosine triphosphate (ATP) to AuNPs and controlling the ratio of ATP to AuNPs. This method was validated in tap water sample analysis. 2. Materials and Methods {#sec2-sensors-18-04302} ======================== 2.1. Chemicals and Instruments {#sec2dot1-sensors-18-04302} ------------------------------ Chlorpyrifos (CP), ethoprophos (EP), profenofos (PF), trichlorfon (TC), omethoate (OT), monocrotophos (MC), isocarbophos (IC), and malathion (MT) were purchased from Honeywell Fluka (Morris Plains, NJ, USA). Adenosine 5′-triphosphate disodium salt hydrate (ATP) was obtained from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO, USA). Gold(III) chloride trihydrate (49.0% Au) and sodium citrate tribasic dihydrate were purchased from J&K Scientific (Beijing, China). All commercial chemicals were used directly without any purification. The color changes caused by AuNP aggregation were measured by ultraviolet-visible light spectroscopy absorption (400--900 nm) using a Shimadzu 2600 spectrophotometer (Shimadzu Corp., Kyoto, Japan). Because the AuNP solution was highly concentrated, we double-diluted the solution and set the corresponding absorption band to 520 nm. The fluorescence intensity of the spectra was recorded at a range of 540--700 nm, operating at an excitation wavelength of 520 nm using a Hitachi F7000 fluorescence spectrophotometer (Hitachi, Tokyo, Japan). The weak fluorescence intensity of rhodamine B-AuNP (RB-AuNP) solutions at approximately 565 nm indicated that the fluorescence of the rhodamine B molecules was completely quenched by the AuNPs, confirming that nearly all rhodamine B molecules were adsorbed onto the surfaces of the AuNPs. The excitation and emission slit widths were both 10 nm. Fluorescence intensities were captured using an inverted fluorescence microscope (Olympus, Tokyo, Japan). The diameter and morphology of AuNPs were imaged by transmission electron microscope (Hitachi HT7700), and hydrodynamic size distribution was measured using a particle size analyzer (Nano-ES90, Malvern Instruments, Malvern, UK). 2.2. Preparation of Stock Solutions {#sec2dot2-sensors-18-04302} ----------------------------------- Stock solutions of the pesticides (10.0 mM) were prepared in absolute ethanol and used within one month. The pesticide stock solutions were diluted 10-fold with absolute ethanol, to obtain 1.0 mM solutions. The standard serial solution of ethoprophos was one milliliter of 1.0 mM ethoprophos solution transferred to a 50-mL volumetric flask and diluted with deionized water to a specific volume, then fully mixed. The final concentration was 20.0 μM. Aliquots (1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, and 7.5 mL) of the pre-prepared ethoprophos (20.0 μM) solution were transferred to 10.0-mL volumetric flasks, diluted with deionized water to a specific volume, and fully mixed. The corresponding concentrations of these serial solutions were 2.0, 4.0, 6.0, 8.0, 10.0, and 15.0 μM. ATP (10.0 mM) and rhodamine B (10.0 mM) were prepared in deionized water and used within one week. For lower concentrations of solutions used in later experiments, the ATP and rhodamine B stock solutions were diluted with deionized water and used within 8 h. 2.3. Preparation of AuNPs {#sec2dot3-sensors-18-04302} ------------------------- The AuNPs used in this experiment were water-soluble and had diameters of approximately 13 nm, as determined by transmission electron microscopy. The sodium citrate solution preparation described by Hauser and Lynn was used to synthesize citrate-capped hydrophilic AuNPs \[[@B35-sensors-18-04302]\]. By varying the citrate/Au^3+^ molar ratio according to the modification by Turkevich and Frens \[[@B36-sensors-18-04302]\], the diameters of the AuNPs were tuned to a range of 10--150 nm. 2.4. Citrate-Capped Hydrophilic AuNPs {#sec2dot4-sensors-18-04302} ------------------------------------- HAuCl~4~ (40.2 mg, 49.0% Au) was dissolved in 100.0 mL deionized water and heated to boiling. The HAuCl~4~ solution appeared yellow. Ten milliliters of trisodium citrate solution (38.8 mmol/L) were then added slowly to the HAuCl~4~ solution with stirring. Color changes accompanied the reaction, from yellow to dark blue to a final transparent wine-red. The solution was heated for another 10.0 min. After cooling to room temperature, the obtained aqueous citrate-capped AuNP solution was filtered through a 0.22-μm hydrophilic membrane to remove insoluble residues and large solid particles. 2.5. Preparation of ATP-Modified AuNPs and Rhodamine B-Coated AuNPs {#sec2dot5-sensors-18-04302} ------------------------------------------------------------------- AuNPs were protected by ATP before coating with rhodamine B. First, a stock solution of ATP (1.0 mM, 1.0 mL) was added to the citrate-capped hydrophilic AuNPs solutions (50.0 mL). The mixed solutions were vortexed for 30.0 min at room temperature. Next, 1.5 mL rhodamine B solutions (1.0 μM) were slowly added to the ATP-protected AuNPs solutions and vortexed lightly in the dark at room temperature for 30.0 min. The resulting RB-AuNPs solutions were stored at 4.0 °C as stock solutions for later use. The particle size of the RB-AuNPs was approximately 15 nm, and the particles were mono-dispersed in the solution. 2.6. Citrate-Capped AuNPs Pesticide Assay {#sec2dot6-sensors-18-04302} ----------------------------------------- Citrate-capped AuNPs were first double-diluted for this experiment. The pesticide solutions (50.0 μL, 1.0 mM) were added to the double-diluted citrate-capped AuNPs solutions (5.0 mL). Ethanol (50.0 μL) was added to the citrate-capped AuNPs solution (5.0 mL) as a blank, which eliminated interference and improved the precision of analysis. The blank test was repeated for 12 replicates to calculate the limit of detection (LOD). The mixtures were vortexed for 1.0 min and kept in the dark for 15.0 min before being imaged, and the ultraviolet-visible light absorption spectra (400--900 nm) were collected. All measurements were repeated for at least three replicates. 2.7. ATP-Protected AuNPs Pesticide Assay {#sec2dot7-sensors-18-04302} ---------------------------------------- The experimental procedure and conditions for the citrate-capped AuNPs assay were repeated, replacing citrate-capped AuNPs with RB-AuNPs. The solutions were imaged and the ultraviolet-visible light absorption spectra (400--900 nm) were collected. All measurements were repeated for at least three replicates. 2.8. Experimental Procedure for Ethoprophos Detection Sensitivity {#sec2dot8-sensors-18-04302} ----------------------------------------------------------------- The standard ethoprophos serial solutions (0.5--100.0 μM) were mixed with the RB-AuNPs in a ratio of 1:1 in ultramicro cells (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA), vortexed for 20 s, and the ultraviolet-visible light absorption spectra (400--900 nm) were recorded every 1 min 30 times. The LOD was calculated as 3σ/*k*, where σ is the standard deviation of the 12 blank tests, and *k* is the slope of the linear fitting equation. 3. Results and Discussion {#sec3-sensors-18-04302} ========================= 3.1. Aggregation-Inducing Effect of OPs on Citrate-Capped AuNPs {#sec3dot1-sensors-18-04302} --------------------------------------------------------------- We first analyzed the aggregation-inducing effect of the OPs ([Figure 1](#sensors-18-04302-f001){ref-type="fig"}) on citrate-capped AuNPs ([Figure 2](#sensors-18-04302-f002){ref-type="fig"}a). We calculated the absorption change at 520 nm (Δ*A*~520~) by setting the blank value as zero. The corresponding LOD was also adjusted by deducting the blank value. We found that ethoprophos, profenofos, and chlorpyrifos induced aggregation of citrate-capped AuNPs. This was confirmed by the AuNPs' color changes from red to purple and blue. The Δ*A*~520~ was 0.809 (ethoprophos, 10.0 μM), 0.399 (profenofos, 10.0 μM), and 0.129 (chlorpyrifos, 10.0 μM). The AuNP solutions did not change color in the presence of the other pesticides (1.0 mM) or ethanol. The Δ*A*~520~ for malathion could not be determined. The Δ*A*~520~ values of trichlorfon, omethoate, monocrotophos, isocarbophos, and malathion were determined to be much smaller than those of ethoprophos and profenofos ([Figure 2](#sensors-18-04302-f002){ref-type="fig"}). These findings indicated that although a visible aggregation of citrate-capped AuNPs was not observed, these four pesticides could cause a slight aggregation of citrate-capped AuNPs. 3.2. C.olorimetric and Fluorescent Detection of OPs by RB-AuNPs {#sec3dot2-sensors-18-04302} --------------------------------------------------------------- To improve the detection specificity of AuNPs for OPs, we measured the effects of OPs on RB-AuNPs, which were capped with ATP on the surface. ATP has a greater affinity for AuNPs than citric acid, because both adenine and triphosphate show some binding to AuNPs. This binding affinity is ATP concentration-dependent. We envisioned that AuNPs capped with a specific concentration could show specific assays for OPs based on the displacement of ATP and OPs. To selectively assay for ethoprophos, an ATP concentration was optimized to be 1.2 mM (a detailed discussion is presented in the next section). As expected, only ethoprophos caused a color change in RB-AuNPs, from wine-red to a pink color within 15.0 min ([Figure 3](#sensors-18-04302-f003){ref-type="fig"}a), indicating improved specificity for ethoprophos compared to findings from citrate-capped AuNPs ([Figure 3](#sensors-18-04302-f003){ref-type="fig"}b). The absorption responses of RB-AuNPs to ethoprophos were concentration-dependent ([Figure 3](#sensors-18-04302-f003){ref-type="fig"}c). Ethoprophos yielded a relatively large positive Δ*A*~520~ of 0.205, and the color of the RB-AuNPs changed: The change was correlated with the concentration of ethoprophos ([Figure 3](#sensors-18-04302-f003){ref-type="fig"}c). The absorption at 520 nm decreased along with an increase at 600 nm, and the curve of the ratio of absorption at 600 nm and 520 nm (ROA~600/520~) versus ethoprophos concentration was plotted ([Figure 3](#sensors-18-04302-f003){ref-type="fig"}d). These results were indicative of RB-AuNPs' aggregation, which was confirmed by transmission electron microscopy ([Figure 4](#sensors-18-04302-f004){ref-type="fig"}). Profenofos (10.0 μM) had a rather low Δ*A*~520~ of 0.028, without a color change. The Δ*A*~520~ values of the other six OPs pesticides (1.0 mM) were very small, and the color of the AuNPs did not change. In addition, the competition experiments were studied by measuring ROA~600/520~ in the presence of ethoprophos (4.0 μM) and interfering analytes with a specific concentration (4.0 μM). Very few changes in ROA~600/520~ were observed in the combination of ethoprophos and interfering pesticides, indicating that this simple assay for ethoprophos could be applicable in the complex samples. It is well known that AuNPs quench fluorophore fluorescence almost completely. Here, rhodamine B molecules were tightly adsorbed to the surface of AuNPs via electrostatic attraction to ATP, which was confirmed by the negligible fluorescence intensity of the RB-AuNPs. The fluorescent results showed that RB-AuNPs had a strong, concentration-dependent fluorescence recovery response to ethoprophos ([Figure 5](#sensors-18-04302-f005){ref-type="fig"}) and a negligible response to the other OPs. 3.3. The Effect of ATP Concentration on OP Detection by RB-AuNPs {#sec3dot3-sensors-18-04302} ---------------------------------------------------------------- We found that after modification of the AuNPs with ATP, OP-induced aggregation of the NPs was inhibited to some extent. In the first experiment, using citrate-capped AuNPs, the OPs ethoprophos, profenofos, and chlorpyrifos caused notable aggregation of AuNPs, visualized by the color change from wine-red to dark blue after 15 min. Added ATP, however, replaced citric acid as the stabilizing agent, as ATP has a greater affinity to AuNPs \[[@B37-sensors-18-04302],[@B38-sensors-18-04302],[@B39-sensors-18-04302]\]. RB-AuNPs were not induced to aggregate by profenofos or chlorpyrifos, but only by ethoprophos. The corresponding Δ*A*~520~ change in ultraviolet-visible light absorption declined markedly from 0.809 to 0.205, indicating that ATP enhanced AuNPs' stability and reduced the tendency to aggregate. Citrate-capped AuNPs had slight absorption responses to the other pesticides, whereas RB-AuNPs were not responsive. These findings suggest that ATP is protective of AuNPs and reduces OP-induced aggregation. ATP concentrations and the detection reaction time were determining factors in this assay. Changes in the absorption spectra and color of RB-AuNPs were negligible for chlorpyrifos, trichlorfon, omethoate, monocrotophos, isocarbophos, and malathion, even at a high concentration of 50.0 mM. In the case of profenofos, slight variations in the absorption spectra and color of the RB-AuNPs were observed at low ATP concentrations or short reaction times of detection, suggesting that it may interfere with detecting ethoprophos. By optimizing the amount of ATP, we further tested various concentration of ATP. The results showed that the response to ethoprophos was in the range of 0.8--1.4 mM. At low concentrations of ATP, the sensitivity of the assay for ethoprophos was high. However, the RB-AuNPs showed some response to profenofos. At high concentrations of ATP, the sensitivity of the assay for ethoprophos was low, as there was no response to profenofos. As a result, the RB-AuNPs showed some response to profenofos in the low concentrations, and it took a long time to assay ethoprophos in the high concentrations. Given specificity and quickness, 1.0--1.2 mM ATP was optimized as a final concentration range. This established a method for detecting ethoprophos exclusively. The detailed data are summarized in [Table 1](#sensors-18-04302-t001){ref-type="table"}. For the reported AuNPs-based OP sensors ([Table 2](#sensors-18-04302-t002){ref-type="table"}), most of them were based on the inactivation of acetylcholinesterase and presented a lack of selectivity. Compared with them, this assay exhibited much more specificity and simplicity in the detection of ethoprophos. 3.4. The pH Effect on the Colorimetric Assay for Ethoprophos {#sec3dot4-sensors-18-04302} ------------------------------------------------------------ Usually, pH shows a great effect on AuNP-based colorimetric sensors. The pH effect on this assay was studied in detail. [Figure 6](#sensors-18-04302-f006){ref-type="fig"} reveals the Δ*A*~520~ of RB-AuNPs with 10.0 μM ethoprophos at various pH values (from 3.0 to 10.0). The Δ*A*~520~ of RB-AuNPs in the presence of ethoprophos was stable (around 0.8) under acidic and weakly basic conditions. However, it dramatically changed to 0.04 at pH 10.0, probably due to the decomposition of ethoprophos under basic conditions. These results suggest that this assay is practical and applicable under broad pH conditions. 3.5. Mechanism for Ethoprophos Detection {#sec3dot5-sensors-18-04302} ---------------------------------------- Sulfur-containing OPs can replace citric acid and lead to aggregation of AuNPs because of a strong Au-S binding tendency. ATP has high affinity for AuNPs, and can be considered a good stabilizing agent: ATP molecules adsorbed to the surface of RB-AuNPs can compete with sulfur-containing OPs, depending on the ATP concentration. Therefore, a specific assay for detecting sulfur-containing OPs could be refined by ATP concentration. Ethoprophos has a great affinity for AuNPs because it contains two sulfur atoms and forms stronger Au-S bonds than other OPs. It can demolish the frameworks of RB-AuNPs to cause nanoparticles aggregation, affording colorimetric change and fluorescence recovery ([Scheme 1](#sensors-18-04302-sch001){ref-type="scheme"}). An assay for ethoprophos could therefore be established if the ATP concentration was appropriate. 3.6. Ethoprophos LOD in RB-AuNPs {#sec3dot6-sensors-18-04302} -------------------------------- We used various concentrations of ethoprophos (0--20.0 μM) to study the absorption spectra of RB-AuNPs, and found that the decrease of adsorption at 520 nm and the increase of adsorption at 600 nm correlated with ethoprophos concentration ([Figure 7](#sensors-18-04302-f007){ref-type="fig"}b). The variations in absorption spectra indicated the extent of RB-AuNPs' aggregation. The colorimetric variation was observed in this range ([Figure 7](#sensors-18-04302-f007){ref-type="fig"}a). The ratio of the absorption value at 600 nm to the absorption value at 520 nm at various ethoprophos concentrations was plotted to calculate the LOD, which was determined to be 0.089 mg/L (37.0 nM) at 3σ/*k*. The quantitative range was 4.0--15.0 μM. 3.7. Ethoprophos Detection in Real Samples {#sec3dot7-sensors-18-04302} ------------------------------------------ Ethoprophos is commonly used for nematode control, and off-target spraying pollutes the surrounding environment and sources of drinking water. We used our RB-AuNPs assay to detect ethoprophos in tap water, anticipating that the complex matrices in a real sample would not interfere with accurate detection. A certain amount of ethoprophos was sprayed into tap water, and the obtained solution was concentrated to a specific volume and applied to RB-AuNPs. [Table 3](#sensors-18-04302-t003){ref-type="table"} shows that the ethoprophos recoveries were 102.4%, 105.4%, and 1.3.6%, based on the ratio of the absorption value at 600 nm to the absorption value at 520 nm. These findings confirmed that this method is applicable for detecting ethoprophos in real samples. 4. Conclusions {#sec4-sensors-18-04302} ============== In this study, a simple colorimetric and fluorometric assay for detecting ethoprophos with high sensitivity and specificity using RB-AuNPs was established. The assay relied on ligand replacement on the surface of AuNPs, resulting in AuNP aggregation. This aggregation, in turn, permitted colorimetric visualization and fluorescence enhancement. The linear range of detection was calculated at the submicromolar level, and the LOD was determined to be 37.0 nM. This simple method was successfully applied to detect ethoprophos in tap water with high reliability. It is believed that this simple assay can be useful in monitoring ethoprophos on-site, especially in combination with other methods such as lab-on-chip techniques. Z.Z. and H.C. designed the experiments; X.L. carried out the experiments and analyzed the experimental results. Z.Z., H.C. and X.L. wrote the manuscript. This work was funded by the National Key R&D Program of China (2017YFD0200900), Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences and National Key Basic Research Program of China (973 Program, 2014CB932200). The authors declare no conflict of interest. Figures, Scheme and Tables ========================== {#sensors-18-04302-f001} {#sensors-18-04302-f002} ###### (**a**) The color changes of rhodamine B (RB)-AuNPs (3.0 nM) added with various pesticides (10.0 μM for ethoprophos, profenofos, and chlorpyrifos; 1.0 mM for others). (**b**) The Δ*A*~520~ values changes of RB-AuNPs (3.0 nM) added with various OP pesticides (10.0 μM for ethoprophos, profenofos, and chlorpyrifos; 1.0 mM for others). (**c**) The absorption spectra changes and (**d**) corresponding fitting curve plot of RB-AuNPs (3.0 nM) in the presence of different concentrations of ethoprophos. (**e**) Selectivity studies of RB-AuNPs by measuring ROA~600/520~ versus interference analytes with a specific concentration.   {#sensors-18-04302-f004} {#sensors-18-04302-f005} {#sensors-18-04302-f006} {#sensors-18-04302-sch001} {#sensors-18-04302-f007} sensors-18-04302-t001_Table 1 ###### The Δ*A*~520~ of RB-AuNPs with ethoprophos (10.0 μM) and profenofos (10.0 μM) in the various concentrations of adenosine triphosphate (ATP). Δ*A*~520~ 5 min 10 min 15 min 20 min 25 min 30 min ------------- ------------ ------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- Ethoprophos 0.8 mM ATP 0.154 0.257 0.366 0.427 0.459 0.499 1.0 mM ATP 0.051 0.107 0.205 0.289 0.366 0.472 1.2 mM ATP 0.026 0.077 0.140 0.196 0.244 0.304 1.4mM ATP 0.012 0.058 0.119 0.172 0.220 0.284 Profenofos 0.8 mM ATP ND 0.025 0.039 0.048 0.056 0.061 1.0 mM ATP ND 0.018 0.021 0.035 0.042 0.049 1.2 mM ATP ND ND ND 0.015 0.023 0.030 1.4 mM ATP ND ND ND ND ND ND ND means not detected. sensors-18-04302-t002_Table 2 ###### The reported AuNP-based OP sensors. Target Analyte Detection Technique Linear Range Detection Limit References ------------------------ --------------------------- --------------- ----------------- ----------------------------- OPs Colorimetric/fluorescence ND ND \[[@B31-sensors-18-04302]\] OPs Fluorescence ND 0.05 ng/mL \[[@B40-sensors-18-04302]\] OPs Electrochemistry 0.001--5 μM 0.5 nM \[[@B41-sensors-18-04302]\] OPs Colorimetric ND 2 ppm \[[@B42-sensors-18-04302]\] Chlorpyrifos/malathion Colorimetric 100--250 ppb 20 ppb \[[@B43-sensors-18-04302]\] OPs Colorimetric 80--400 ng/mL 30 ng/mL \[[@B32-sensors-18-04302]\] OPs Colorimetric 15--65 ppb 0.7 ppb \[[@B34-sensors-18-04302]\] Paraoxon Electrochemistry ND 0.1 pM \[[@B44-sensors-18-04302]\] Monocrotophos Electrochemistry ND 2.7 nM \[[@B45-sensors-18-04302]\] Ethoprophos Colorimetric/fluorescence 4--15 μM 37 nM This work ND means not detected. sensors-18-04302-t003_Table 3 ###### The determination of ethoprophos in tap water samples based on this assay. Samples Spike (µM) Found (µM) Recovery (%) RSD (*n* = 5) *^a^* --------- ------------ ------------ -------------- --------------------- 1 4.0 4.1 102.6% 3.45% 2 8.0 8.4 105.4% 0.60% 3 10.0 10.4 103.6% 0.24% *^a^* RSD = relative standard deviation.

1.. Introduction {#s0001} ================ Unfortunately, irreversible rejection constitutes a high proportion (34%) of the reasons for graft failure, especially for penetrating keratoplasty, which is performed for visual improvement (Williams et al., [@CIT0038]). Notably, tacrolimus has been widely used to prevent organ rejection after transplantation because it has better clinical activity than CsA and is extensively applied to patients who resist corticosteroids or have secondary complications induced by steroids (Kino et al., [@CIT0017]; Scott et al., [@CIT0029]). However, challenges still exist in the application of tacrolimus because of its limited aqueous solubility and low corneal penetrability (Tamura et al., [@CIT0032]). Therefore, transplant recipients require higher drug dosages or frequencies to maintain an effective concentration in the ocular region, which potentiate side effects and economic burden. Over the past few decades, numerous pharmaceutical technologies, including nanomedicine, have been explored to overcome the deficiencies of tacrolimus (Duncan & Gaspar, [@CIT0005]; Moghassemi & Hadjizadeh, [@CIT0022]). Drugs can be absorbed onto the nanoparticle (NP) surface or entrapped inside to enhance their stability, solubility, and cellular penetration. Popular NP systems include liposomes (Honda et al., [@CIT0013]; Immordino et al., [@CIT0014]), surfactants (Kagayama et al., [@CIT0015]), and polymeric NPs (Torchilin [@CIT0033]; Maeda et al., [@CIT0019]; Wang et al., [@CIT0036]), among which polymeric NPs have emerged as one of the most promising drug delivery systems due to their biocompatibility and amphipathy (Barbu et al., [@CIT0001]; Mandal et al., [@CIT0020]). Polymeric carriers also have the capacity to maintain therapeutic doses and release drugs in a controlled manner with low toxicity and biodegradability. One of the most attractive polymeric NP for biomedicine applications is poly (lactic-*co*-glycolic acid) (PLGA) (Honda et al., [@CIT0013]), which does not exhibit electrophysiological or histological toxicity (Moritera et al., [@CIT0023]; Giordano et al., [@CIT0007]). Recent comparative studies have indicated that PLGA can nonenzymatically hydrolyze and degrade faster than corresponding homopolymers *in vivo* (Yasukawa et al., [@CIT0039]) and can thus be formulated as implants, microspheres, and nanocapsules for biomedical applications. In previous studies, Shin et al. ([@CIT0030]) prepared TAC-PLGA NPs with a poly (ethylene glycol) (PEG) surface modification and then administered the prepared NPs to rats intravenously. TAC-PLGA and TAC-PEG-PLGA showed significantly higher targeting efficiencies than conventional tacrolimus. In summary, this study aimed to develop a nano-sized and biocompatible drug delivery system for tacrolimus, based on an amphiphilic copolymer consisting of methoxy PEG (mPEG) and PLGA. We optimized tacrolimus-loaded mPEG-*b*-PLGA nanoparticles (TAC-NPs) to exhibit higher bioavailability and stability, then topically applied the TAC-NPs to inhibit corneal immunologic rejection after keratoplasty for the first time. The immunosuppressive effect of TAC-NPs dispersion drops was investigated in a rat high-risk allogenic corneal transplantation model, compared with conventional 0.1% TAC drops. Moreover, we also investigated the immune depressive efficacies of two forms of administration involving TAC-NPs eye drops and TAC-NPs subconjunctival injection. This work offers a strategy to prepare small-sized TAC-NPs with biocompatible property, sustained release behavior and better immunosuppressive effects to the treatment of corneal immunologic rejection in rats, which provides promising applications for ocular drug delivery. 2.. Material and methods {#s0002} ======================== 2.1.. Materials {#s0003} --------------- Poly (ethylene glycol)-*block*-poly ([d]{.smallcaps}, [l]{.smallcaps})-lactic-*co*-glycolic acid (mPEG-*b*-PLGA, PEG 2000 Da, PLGA 8000 Da, LA/GA = 75/25) was provided by the laboratory of Professor Fangming Zhu at the School of Chemistry, Sun Yat-sen University, and tacrolimus was obtained from Selleck Chemicals (Shanghai, China). Dialysis bags were purchased from Spectrapor (MWCO 14000, Waltham, MA, USA). Isoflurane inhaled anesthesia (Yipin pharmaceutical Co., LTD, Hebei, China) and 3% sodium pentobarbital solution (Merck, Darmstadt, German) were used to anesthesia animals. Proparacaine hydrochloride eye drops (S.A. ALCON, Fort Worth, TX, USA), Iviz (Bausch Lomb, Shandong, China), and 10-0 black mono nylon sutures (Alcon, Fort Worth, TX, USA) were used in corneal transplantation of rats. Tobramycin eye ointment purchased from Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center (Guangzhou, China). 0.1% tacrolimus eye drops were purchased from Senju Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. (Osaka, Japan). Rabbit polyclonal anti-CD4/CD8 antibody and horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG H&L were purchased from Abcam (Cambridge, MA, USA), the Milliplex^®^ xMAP Rat Cytokine/Chemokine kit was purchased from EMD Millipore Corporation (Billerica, MA, USA). 2.2.. Animals {#s0004} ------------- All research and animal experiments described herein were carried out in accordance with the Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology (ARVO) Statement Regarding the Use of Animals in Ophthalmic and Vision Research and abided by the guidelines stipulated by the Animal Experimental Ethics Committee of Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center at Sun Yat-sen University (ethical number: 2017-029). New Zealand albino rabbits (male and female, weighing 2--2.5 kg) were provided by the Huadong Xinhua experimental animal breeding facility (Guangzhou, China) and housed under conventional standard conditions. In addition, Wistar rats (male and female, weighing 200--250) and Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats (male and female, weighing 200--250 g) were specific pathogen-free (SPF) grade and purchased from Jinan Pengyue Experimental Animal Breeding Co., Ltd. (Shandong, China). The rats were housed under SPF standard conditions at the Animal Experimental Center of Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center of Sun Yat-sen University and free fed a standard sterile pellet diet and water. 2.3.. Preparation and characterization of TAC-NPs {#s0005} ------------------------------------------------- ### 2.3.1.. Preparation of TAC-NPs and size measurements {#s0006} The preparation of TAC-NPs was based on the solvent evaporation method. Briefly, the mPEG-*b*-PLGA copolymers and tacrolimus (mass ratio of 9:1) were dissolved in acetone, and the aqueous solution was added during ultrasonic stirring. After vacuum evaporation and dialysis, the resulting solution was filtered through a 0.22-μm filter to obtain homogeneous NPs at a concentration of 2.5 mg/ml. Blank NPs without tacrolimus were prepared by the same method. The mean particle size and size distribution were recorded by dynamic light scattering (Brookhaven BI-2005M, USA) with a scattering angle of 90 degrees at 25 °C. Each sample was measured in triplicate. ### 2.3.2.. Determination of encapsulation efficiency and drug loading ability {#s0007} The encapsulation efficiency (EE) and drug loading (DL) were determined by HPLC with a C18 column at 40 °C, with a flow rate of 1 ml/min and a mobile phase comprising a mixture of acetonitrile and 0.05 M phosphoric acid (75: 25, *v*/*v*). EE and DL were calculated using the following equations: $$\text{EE}\,\text{(\%)} = \frac{\text{mass}\ \text{of}\ \text{FK506}\ \text{in}\ \text{NPs}}{\text{mass}\ \text{of}\ \text{initial}\ \text{FK506}} \times 100\%$$  DL \% = mass of FK506 in NPs mass of NPs × 100 \% ### 2.3.3.. Morphology studies {#s0008} Transmission electron microscopy (TEM, JEM-1400 Plus, Japan) was used to observe the morphological structure of the TAC-NPs. Briefly, the TAC-NPs were dispensed onto a copper mesh, to which a drop of phosphotungstic acid (1%, *w*/*v*) was applied for staining. After 30 s, the extra dye liquor was absorbed by filter paper and then dried at room temperature. ### 2.3.4.. In vitro release behavior of drug {#s0009} In vitro release behavior of TAC-NPs was performed using the dialysis method. The TAC-NPs dispersion (1 ml) and 0.1% TAC suspension (1 ml) were respectively placed in dialysis bags. The dialysis bags were both incubated in 25% ethanol/artificial tears (*v*/*v*) to maintain sink conditions at 37 °C and shaken at 90 rpm. At every time intervals, 1 ml of the release medium was removed and replaced by 1 ml of fresh medium. The amount of the TAC was analyzed by HPLC. All the assays were performed in triplicate and results were expressed as a mean value ± SD. 2.4.. Single-dose pharmacokinetics study {#s0010} ---------------------------------------- A 25-μl drop of the TAC-NPs dispersion was instilled into the right conjunctival sacs of rabbits. Then, aqueous humor and cornea samples were collected from the right eyes of the rabbits at 0.25, 0.5, 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 12, and 24 h. A 25-μl TAC-NPs dispersion was subconjunctivally injected into the right eyes of rabbits, and aqueous humor and cornea samples were collected at 0.5, 1, 2, 6, 12, 24, 48, 72, 96, and 120 h. There were three rabbits at each time point, and specimens were immediately placed in liquid nitrogen and stored at −80 °C until HPLC-MS/MS analysis. 2.5.. High-risk corneal transplantation in rats and postoperative treatment {#s0011} --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Only the right eyes of SD and Wistar rats were used in the allogenic grafting experiments (SD to Wistar). Prior to the surgical procedures, all rats were anesthetized by an intraperitoneal injection of 3% sodium pentobarbital solution (1.0--1.5 ml/kg) assistant with isoflurane inhaled anesthesia (1.5--2%) and proparacaine hydrochloride eye drops were used for topical anesthesia. Donor corneas 3.25 mm in diameter were excised with Vannas scissors. The recipient cornea was outlined with 3.0-mm trephine, and then removed. Throughout the entire operation, Iviz was applied to the anterior chamber to maintain stability and protect corneal endothelial cells. Sequentially, the donor buttons were sewn onto the recipient bed with eight interrupted 10-0 sutures and then indwelled in place to aggravate neovascularization and the occurrence of immune rejection. Finally, the anterior chamber was irrigated with sterile physiological saline and restored by sterile small bubbles. All transplanted rats received tobramycin eye ointment postoperatively were randomly distributed into four groups (12 rats of each group). Group 1 rats, serving as the blank control, received blank mPEG-*b*-PLGA dispersion drops without tacrolimus (25 μl, 2.5 mg/ml) twice a day. Group 2 rats received a subconjunctival injection of TAC-NPs dispersion (25 μl, 2.5 mg/ml, loaded with 0.2 mg/ml TAC) every two days. Group 3 rats were treated with TAC-NPs dispersion drops (25 μl, 2.5 mg/ml, loaded with 0.2 mg/ml TAC) twice a day, and group 4 rats received the conventional 0.1% tacrolimus eye drops (25 μl, 1 mg/ml) twice a day as the positive control. All the treatments described above were administered to the grafted eyes from the 1st to the 28th day after surgery. 2.6.. Clinical evaluation of corneal transplantation rats {#s0012} --------------------------------------------------------- Grafts in each group were observed every other day via a slit-lamp microscope digital system (Topcon, SL-D7/DC-3/IMAGEnet, Japan) with diffuse light and cobalt-blue light examination (after fluorescein staining) until day 28 (six rats of each group). In addition, Holland's grade (Holland et al., [@CIT0012]) was used to evaluate corneal graft survival (Herbort et al., [@CIT0009]), for which the indicators consisted of transparency, edema, and neovascularization. Graft rejection was defined as an opacity score ≥3 or a total score ≥5. Rats with complications, including hemorrhage, cataract, or infection, were eliminated from the study. *2.7. HPLC-MS*/*MS assay to determine the tacrolimus concentration in tissues* {#s0013} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ In the single-dose pharmacokinetics study, rabbit aqueous humor (30 μl each) and cornea samples were collected as described above. In addition, in corneal transplantation rats, the aqueous humor and corneas of each group were collected on day 14 and day 28 after surgery with three rats at each time point. Aqueous humor (10 μl each) and cornea samples, which had been ground into a powder, were spiked with diazepam (10 ng/ml) as the internal standard and mixed with acetonitrile to precipitate tacrolimus. All the mixtures were vortexed and then centrifuged at 13,000 rpm for 15 min. The upper organic solvent was dried with nitrogen. Then, the residue was redissolved in acetonitrile and injected into the HPLC-MS/MS system for analysis. 2.8.. Hematoxylin-eosin (HE) and immunohistochemical staining {#s0014} ------------------------------------------------------------- Rats were randomly executed via narcotic overdose on the 14th and 28th days after the operation. The paraffin-embedded cornea sections were stained with HE. For the immunohistochemistry assay, after incubation with a rabbit polyclonal anti-CD4/CD8 antibody overnight at 4 °C, the sections were incubated with HRP-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG H&L and then examined under a microscope (Axioplan2 Imaging, Zeiss). 2.9.. Luminex^®^ xMAP^®^ technology assay to quantitatively measure immune factors {#s0015} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- On the 14th and 28th days after the operation with three rats at each time point, the aqueous humors of each group were aspirated via a 33-gauge needle attached to a microliter syringe (Hamilton, USA) while the rats were anesthetized. Then, the corneas were carefully enucleated, and proteins were extracted using cell lysis buffer (Cell Signaling Technology, USA) supplemented with protease inhibitors (Roche, USA). In this study, Luminex^®^ xMAP^®^ technology (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc., USA) and the Milliplex^®^ xMAP Rat Cytokine/Chemokine Magnetic Bead Panel 96-well plate assay (\#RECYTMAG-65K) were used to quantify the total protein levels of rat interleukin-2 (IL-2), IL-17, interferon gamma (IFN-γ), and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), and MILLIPLEX^®^ Analyst 5.1 software-1 seat license (MXMSM, Merck, USA) was then used to analyze the data. 2.10.. Statistical analysis {#s0016} --------------------------- Results of the Luminex^®^ xMAP^®^ technology and HPLC-MS/MS assays were analyzed by Permutation test using the software R (version 3.5.2, Bell Laboratories, USA), *p*-values less than .05 indicated statistically significant differences. The pharmacokinetic parameters were analyzed using DAS (ver2.1.1). 3.. Results {#s0017} =========== 3.1.. Preparation and characterization of TAC-NPs {#s0018} ------------------------------------------------- TAC-NPs were prepared through the solvent evaporation method assisted with ultrasonication that self-assembled into the core-shell nanostructure in aqueous solution. The hydrophobic drug encapsulated into the lyophobic core and hydrophilic shell enhanced the water solubility and stability. The TAC-NPs were 82.9 ± 1.3 nm in size and had a polydispersity index (PI) of 0.090 ± 0.014 and a zeta potential of −18.90 ± 2.45 mV. The narrow particle size range and high zeta potential value indicated the stability of TAC-NPs in physiological fluids. The particle size also demonstrated enhanced drug permeability, which is the major goal of ocular drug targeting (Sahoo et al., [@CIT0028]). In addition, morphological analysis of the TAC-NPs, displayed in [Figure 1(a)](#F0001){ref-type="fig"}, demonstrated TAC-NPs were distributed uniformly without aggregation, and the diameter of particles was in nanometer range. {#F0001} According to HPLC analysis, the TAC-NP DL and EE values, two important properties of drug-loaded polymeric NPs, were 8.01 ± 0.23% and 80.10 ± 2.33%, which were higher than the typical drug capacity (∼\<5%) (Lv et al., [@CIT0018]). As observed in [Figure 1(b)](#F0001){ref-type="fig"}, the release profiles for TAC from the TAC-NPs and 0.1% TAC suspension were presented. Compared with the non-encapsulated drug formulations, the drug release behavior of TAC-NPs showed a pronounced sustained property. For 0.1% TAC suspension, more than 85% of TAC was released during 12 h, but only 64% of TAC was released from the TAC-NPs after 48 h. This sustained release behavior might be attributed to the NPs with core/shell structure, where the drug was encapsulated in the hydrophobic core and consistently released via diffusion and the polymeric matrix degradation (Gajendiran et al., [@CIT0008]; Panyam et al., [@CIT0025]; Choudhury et al., [@CIT0003]). On account of its release behavior, TAC-NPs could reduce the administration frequency. 3.2.. Single-dose pharmacokinetics study {#s0019} ---------------------------------------- The HPLC-MS/MS method was successfully applied to analyze TAC concentration in corneas and aqueous humor of rabbits after single-dose topical administration of TAC-NPs dispersion (25 μl, containing 5 µg TAC). At 12 h and 24 h, TAC concentrations in cornea tissues were 1.35 ± 0.06 ng/mg and 0.96 ± 0.07 ng/mg after a drop of TAC-NPs, and 2.45 ± 0.17 ng/mg and 0.17 ± 0.04 ng/mg after subconjunctival injection of TAC-NPs. The curves for the mean tacrolimus concentration versus time in the aqueous humor after single-dose topical administration are depicted in [Figure 1(c,d)](#F0001){ref-type="fig"}. Additionally, concentration-time curves for the TAC-NPs drops administration revealed a maximum concentration of tacrolimus of 6.96 ± 0.59 ng/ml ([Figure 1(c)](#F0001){ref-type="fig"}). In addition, concentration-time curves for the TAC-NP subconjunctival injection group revealed a maximum concentration of tacrolimus of 20.80 ± 1.59 ng/ml ([Figure 1(d)](#F0001){ref-type="fig"}). [Table 1](#t0001){ref-type="table"} shows the pharmacokinetic parameters. In the aqueous humor, the AUC~0--24h~, AUC~0--∞~, *T*~1/2~, *T*~max~, and *C*~max~ of TAC-NPs drops were 25.86 ± 1.05 ng h/ml, 26.38 ± 1.14 ng h/ml, 1.20 ± 0.48 h, 1.67 ± 0.58 h, and 6.96 ± 0.59 ng/ml, and those of TAC-NPs subconjunctival injections were 78.61 ± 3.33 ng h/ml, 79.98 ± 1.12 ng h/ml, 11.51 ± 9.94 h, 2.00 h, and 20.80 ± 1.59 ng/ml, respectively. ###### The pharmacokinetic parameters of TAC-NPs in the rabbit aqueous humor after single-dose topical administration of TAC-NPs[\*](#TF1){ref-type="table-fn"}. Parameters TAC-NP subconjunctival injection TAC-NP dispersion drops ------------------------- ---------------------------------- ------------------------- AUC~0--t~ (ng h ml^−1^) 78.61 ± 3.33 25.86 ± 1.05 AUC~0--∞~ (ng h ml^−1^) 79.98 ± 1.12 26.38 ± 1.14 *T*~1/2~ (h) 11.51 ± 9.94 1.20 ± 0.48 *T*~max~ (h) 2.00 1.67 ± 0.58 *C*~max~ (ng mL^−1^) 20.80 ± 1.59 6.96 ± 0.59 TAC-NPs dispersion (25 μl, 2.5 mg/ml, containing 5 µg TAC). 3.3.. Clinical evaluation of high-risk corneal transplantation in rats {#s0020} ---------------------------------------------------------------------- As shown in [Figure 2(a)](#F0002){ref-type="fig"}, the grafted corneas treated with blank mPEG-*b*-PLGA NPs dispersion drops (blank control) showed pronounced rejection with obvious corneal edema, opacity, thickening, and neovascularization of the grafts. Conversely, the corneas were clear in the other three groups treated with TAC-NPs and 0.1% tacrolimus drops. Additionally, no significant corneal epithelial deficiency was observed upon fluorescein staining in any of the groups as determined by cobalt-blue light examination under a slit-lamp microscope. According to Holland's grade results, the survival curves are summarized in [Figure 2(c)](#F0002){ref-type="fig"}. The subconjunctival injection of TAC-NPs dispersion, TAC-NPs drops, and 0.1% tacrolimus drop groups exhibited distinctly prolonged graft survival times compared with those of the blank control group (*p* \< .001, *N* = 6). {#F0002} *3.4. Tacrolimus concentrations in corneal transplantation rats as determined by HPLC-MS*/*MS* {#s0021} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The tacrolimus concentrations in aqueous humor and cornea samples from all groups were measured by HPLC-MS/MS on postoperative day 14 ([Figure 2(c)](#F0002){ref-type="fig"}) and day 28 ([Figure 2(d)](#F0002){ref-type="fig"}). In detail, on postoperative day 14, tacrolimus concentrations of TAC-NPs subconjunctival injection group were 0.95 ± 0.10 ng/mg in cornea and 1.83 ± 0.14 ng/ml in aqueous humor; that of TAC-NPs drops group were 1.19 ± 0.10 ng/mg in cornea and 0.49 ± 0.05 ng/ml in aqueous humor; but that of 0.1% tacrolimus drops group were 0.47 ± 0.09 ng/mg in cornea and 0.17 ± 0.05 ng/ml in aqueous humor. On postoperative day 28, tacrolimus concentrations of TAC-NPs subconjunctival injection group were 1.68 ± 0.16 ng/mg in cornea and 2.29 ± 0.20 ng/ml in aqueous humor; that of TAC-NPs drops group were 1.95 ± 0.11 ng/mg in cornea and 1.58 ± 0.09 ng/ml in aqueous humor; however that of 0.1% tacrolimus drops group were 1.08 ± 0.18 ng/mg in cornea and 0.48 ± 0.08 ng/ml in aqueous humor. Because the drug loading (DL) of TAC-NPs was 8.01 ± 0.23%, 2.5 mg/ml TAC-NPs loaded nearly 0.2 mg/ml tacrolimus, which was lower than conventional 0.1% tacrolimus drops (1 mg/ml). However, the tacrolimus concentration in the cornea and aqueous humor of TAC-NPs treated groups were significantly higher than in the 0.1% tacrolimus drops group (*p* \< .05). Therefore, mPEG-b-PLGA NPs noticeably improve the penetrability and bioavailability of tacrolimus in ocular. 3.5.. Histopathological analysis {#s0022} -------------------------------- The histopathological analysis of corneas, including HE and immunohistochemical staining, revealed signs of immune-mediated graft rejection in all groups ([Figure 3](#F0003){ref-type="fig"}). As shown by the HE staining, the allografts in the blank control group exhibited substantial inflammatory cell accumulation, thickening, stroma fibrosis, and edema on postoperative day 14 and 28. By contrast, the drug-treated groups exhibited fewer inflammatory cells as well as less fibrosis, thickening, and edema. In addition, immunohistochemical staining of the corneal grafts showed reduced numbers of CD4^+^ T cells and CD8^+^ T cells, which are closely related to T cell immune responses, in the groups receiving the subconjunctival injection of the TAC-NPs dispersion, TAC-NPs drops, and 0.1% tacrolimus drops on days 14 and 28. {#F0003} 3.6.. Quantitative measurement of immune factors using Luminex^®^ xMAP^®^ technology {#s0023} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The levels of IL-2, IL-17 and VEGF were detected in the aqueous humors and corneas of all groups on postoperative day 14 ([Figure 4(a,b)](#F0004){ref-type="fig"}) and 28 ([Figure 4(c,d)](#F0004){ref-type="fig"}) with three rats at each time point. In the cornea and aqueous humor, the expression levels of IL-2, IL-17, and VEGF in the blank control group were significantly higher than those in the TAC-NPs-treated and 0.1% tacrolimus drops groups on postoperative days 14 and 28. Furthermore, both TAC-NPs subconjunctival injection group and TAC-NPs drops group inhibited IL-2, IL-17 and angiogenesis to a greater extent than the 0.1% tacrolimus drops (*p* \< .05). Additionally, IFN-γ expression was only detected in the corneas of the blank control group (18.64 ± 0.85 ng/mg) on postoperative day 14 (below the limit of detection in the other groups). {#F0004} 4.. Discussions {#s0024} =============== Conventional immunosuppressive drugs (particularly tacrolimus) have low bioavailability when applied topically for ophthalmology purposes, not only because of their limited corneal penetration ability but also because of elimination by tear irrigation and drainage of the nasolacrimal duct. Accordingly, a new topical ophthalmic agent, which could overcome the deficiencies of tacrolimus, is particularly important for ocular drug delivery systems. The use of nanomedicine for diagnosis and therapy has rapidly advanced in recent years. Polymeric NPs greatly improve the tissue penetrability of hydrophobic drugs, due to their mucoadhesive nature and retention abilities (Qiu & Bae [@CIT0027]; Honda et al., [@CIT0013]), which enhance the contact between drugs and ocular surfaces, and amphiphilicity that generates stability of hydrophobic drugs in aqueous solutions. Comparative studies showed that PEG and PLGA are commonly applied in biomedicine with low toxicity, Souza and Kalam both suggested that TAC-PLGA could prolong drug release with no evidence of toxic effects in the rabbits' eye (Souza et al., [@CIT0031]; Kalam and Alshamsan, [@CIT0016]). Chen et al. ([@CIT0002]) proved that PLGA-PEG-PLGA loaded with US597 enhanced its effects and bioavailability in cancer therapy. Therefore, for the first time, we present the application of biocompatible TAC-NPs in high-risk corneal transplantation rats and demonstrate TAC-NPs positively improve the immune inhibition effects of TAC. Notably, we investigated the immunosuppressive effect of TAC-NPs dispersion drops in a rat high-risk allogenic corneal transplantation model, compared with conventional 0.1% TAC drops, which was commonly used in clinical treatment of corneal rejection. According to our postoperative clinical observations in keratoplasty rats, diffused light and cobalt-blue light analysis showed no signs of conjunctival congestion, edema, cornea epithelial deficiency, or other ocular toxic reactions in the TAC-NPs-treated groups, which was due to the biodegradability of the mPEG-*b*-PLGA copolymer. Furthermore, the degradation products lactic acid and glycolic acid of mPEG-*b*-PLGA were able to be metabolized by the body (Hideya and Yuichiro, [@CIT0011]). In addition, immunological rejection was generally detectable at 10--14 days after surgery in the blank control group, whereas the TAC-NPs-treated groups exhibited better transparency, slight edema and neovascularization reductions of the cornea until the end of the observation period. Based on the TAC concentrations detected by HPLC-MS/MS in cornea and aqueous humor samples from the corneal transplantation rats, TAC-NPs drops (0.2 mg/ml TAC) group exhibited significantly higher (*p* \< .05) drug concentrations in ocular tissues than the conventional 0.1% tacrolimus drops group. Therefore, mPEG-*b*-PLGA NPs greatly improved the trans-corneal permeation and absorption of TAC. These significantly high TAC concentrations in ocular related to the smaller size and stability of the mPEG-*b*-PLGA NPs, which could prolong the TAC retention on the corneal surface and further enhanced drug trans-corneal uptake. Furthermore, upon reaching the intraocular tissues, the TAC-NPs sustained tacrolimus release via drug diffusion and polymer degradation. However, the conventional TAC drops are commonly in suspension form and easily drained from the ocular surface with poorly ability to penetrate the cornea (Zeng et al., [@CIT0040]). Tacrolimus inhibits allograft rejection primarily by activating T cells after binding to the cellular receptors (FKBP12), thus blocking the activity of calcineurin and regulating the transcription of lymphokine IL-2. Therefore, IL-2 is a vital target for the activation of a TCR-mediated signaling transmission pathway (Scott et al., [@CIT0029]). Besides, inflammatory cytokine (such as IFN-γ and IL-17) also possess immunoregulatory. VEGF participates in the neovascularization process and promotes the contact between donor antigens and recipient blood lymphocytes, which enhances cornea immunological rejection (Williams et al., [@CIT0038]; Qazi et al., [@CIT0026]; Di Tommaso et al., [@CIT0034]). Therefore, to analyze the immunosuppressive effects of TAC-NPs, we performed biochemical experiments to measure the expression levels of IL-2, IFN-γ, IL-17, and VEGF in anterior segment of rats using Luminex^®^ xMAP^®^ technology. Here, the levels of immune factors (including IL-2, IL-17, and VEGF) in TAC-NPs drops group were all significantly lower than 0.1% tacrolimus drops group (*p* \< .05). Additionally, IFN-γ is one of the acute immune rejection indicators, produced by reactive regulatory T cells. About 14 days later, in the blank control group, the degree of inflammatory cells infiltration and cornea edema were reduced instead of a large number of fibroblasts and graft scarring (Tanaka et al., [@CIT0035]). Besides, TAC-NPs and 0.1% tacrolimus drops persistently inhibited allograft rejection. Therefore, IFN-γ expression was only detected in the corneas of the blank control group on postoperative day 14. Consequently, topical TAC-NPs treatments displayed better and more stable curative effects and resulted in higher corneal drug concentrations than conventional 0.1% tacrolimus drops in a high-risk corneal allograft transplantation rat model. Furthermore, we also compared two different topical administration methods (including eye drop and subconjunctival injection) to maximize the sustained release characteristic of TAC-NPs dispersion, because subconjunctival injection could prolong corneal allograft survival than eye drops (Mills et al., [@CIT0021]; Hikita et al., [@CIT0010]; Dickey et al., [@CIT0004]; Okada et al., [@CIT0024]; Fei et al., [@CIT0006]). The efficacy of TAC-NPs subconjunctival injection (25 µl, every other day) was proven to be stable and better than TAC-NPs eye drop (25 µl, twice a day), possibly due to the route of ocular administration. First, the subconjunctival space may contain larger aqueous solution volumes than conjunctival sac. Additionally, the drug can follow the anterior pathway, transscleral pathway, and systemic circulation via the choroid, thus reaching ocular tissues at therapeutic concentrations (Mandal et al., [@CIT0020]). Above all, based on the advantages mentioned above, subconjunctival administration facilitated the retention of TAC-NPs and sustained release of TAC. 5.. Conclusions {#s0025} =============== The present study optimized TAC-NPs, which were nano-sized and biocompatible. We further confirmed the drug release behavior of TAC-NPs showed a pronounced sustained property in vitro, and we also analyzed the pharmacokinetic parameters of TAC-NPs after single-dose topical administration in rabbits. Furthermore, in rats with allogenic penetrating keratoplasty, TAC-NPs sustained released TAC at the targets and delivered higher drug concentrations into the cornea and aqueous humor than the conventional 0.1% tacrolimus drops. Moreover, TAC-NPs efficiently inhibited corneal allograft rejection in rats, as they reduced the IL-2, IL-17, and VEGF expression levels in the cornea and aqueous humor, which was more effective than 0.1% tacrolimus drops. Therefore, due to their better biocompatibility and sustained drug release, mPEG-*b*-PLGA NPs have great potential for improving the clinical therapy efficacy of hydrophobic drugs for ocular diseases. Disclosure statement {#s0026} ==================== No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Background {#Sec1} ========== In 2013, over half a million people died in England and Wales, mostly from long-term conditions such as cancer (29%) and circulatory (28%) and respiratory (15%) diseases that are known to be life limiting \[[@CR1]\]. For deaths that can be anticipated, providing excellent care at the end-of-life that is responsive to need is critically important. Compassionate support in the last year of life cannot be the responsibility of health and social care professionals alone and requires a public health response involving the wider community \[[@CR2], [@CR3]\], recognising the importance of social networks and social capital \[[@CR4]\]. Proponents of these approaches argue that a primary focus on biomedical and physical aspects of end-of-life care ignores the social context within which dying takes place. Social relationships and networks can buffer the effects of crisis associated with dying, provide a framework that may prevent family carer burn out, and demonstrate the importance of supporting social contexts \[[@CR5]--[@CR7]\]. Effective personal network support can substitute for formal care and reduce health service utilisation costs \[[@CR8]\]. Individual and community networks and relations of support can, however, be inadequate to meet care needs \[[@CR5]\]. Demographic changes such as increased female employment, delayed childbearing, geographical mobility, divorce rates, and longer working lives all potentially impact on the availability of traditional family support. Social isolation on itself also has a major influence on health, comparable with well-established risk factors for mortality \[[@CR9]\]. To supplement both clinical and community care many services are using volunteers as a critical part of the multi-disciplinary care offered at the end of life \[[@CR10], [@CR11]\]. Volunteers are important to care, and indeed 42% of the adult population volunteer formally \[[@CR12]\], with an estimated 3 million in health and social care \[[@CR13]\] and 125,000 within hospices \[[@CR14]\]. The Department of Health commitment to end-of-life care specifically recognises that such care is not simply 'medical issues with medical solutions', and pledges to developing the work of end-of-life care volunteer networks \[[@CR15]\]. It is known that people are happy with volunteer support at the end of life \[[@CR16]--[@CR20]\], but there is little evidence of their effect on care outcomes. Evaluation in well-designed comparative studies is therefore recommended \[[@CR11]\]. This is particularly apt in palliative and end-of-life care, where the effectiveness of many interventions are not evaluated using robust designs; this is potentially wasteful of resources and could lead to poorer or unintended outcomes. This is the first randomised trial of volunteer delivered support services at the end of life to evaluate the effectiveness of such interventions. Methods {#Sec2} ======= Design {#Sec3} ------ This study was a pragmatic, randomised, prospective open wait-list trial. The protocol for the study is published \[[@CR21]\]. The trial used a wait-list design to randomly allocate participants on a 1:1 basis to receive the intervention either immediately or after a 4 week wait \[[@CR22]--[@CR24]\]. A wait-list approach, where consented participants are allocated to either receive an intervention immediately or after a defined period on a waiting list during which they receive usual care is regarded as more ethically defensible in end-of-life care, and allows a valid comparison between the experimental and control arms at the time when the delayed intervention starts \[[@CR23]--[@CR27]\]. Participants and setting {#Sec4} ------------------------ Participants in the trial include people anticipated to be in their last year of life and their self-identified informal carer. Very low numbers of carers were recruited and there is insufficient data to report. Inclusion criteria were broad to include typical participants of such services. Patient inclusion criteria:Those eligible to be referred to an end-of-life care service determined by the referring organisation/individual. They should be able to answer 'no' to the 'surprise question': 'Would you be surprised if the patient dies within a year?'Able to give informed consent. Patient exclusion criteria:Age \< 18 years.Those who only understand or speak a language in which our main outcome measure (the World Health Organization Quality of Life Brief Scale (WHOQOL-BREF)) is unavailable.Those with an anticipated prognosis of \< 4 weeks. Setting {#Sec5} ------- Eleven English providers of end-of-life home care services (nine hospices, one alcohol and substance use charity, one NHS Trust), funded to provide the intervention through competitive tender with the UK Cabinet Office. The intervention was provided in community settings, primarily in participant's own homes. Intervention {#Sec6} ------------ Volunteers provided face-to-face individual support to people anticipated to be in their last year of life. Volunteer-provided services are a mode of support hypothesised to be distinctive from, but supplementary to, usual forms of health and social care, with an effect on domains of quality of life, loneliness and social support. In this pragmatic trial services had flexibility to deliver the intervention in a locally responsive manner within agreed parameters. Key elements of the volunteer-provided support intervention include its delivery by trained volunteers who were matched to individuals by a volunteer co-ordinator, and provided care tailored to the needs of the individual but offered from a suite of options including befriending, practical support and signposting, which could differ at each visit. Volunteer support was typically provided face-to-face, one-to-one, in the home, but telephone contact and meeting outside the home were possible. Most contacts were befriending visits in the home. The frequency and length of contact was individually determined according to negotiated participant preference and service availability, but was typically a visit once a week for 1--3 hours. The service could continue as required after the study, but study participants were followed up for 8 weeks post intervention commencement. Volunteers could be any age (18+), sex or ethnicity, and all received basic training on boundaries, communication skills and organisational policies according to the requirements of the organisation providing the intervention at each site. Data captured the type, length and frequency of each contact between participant and volunteer. Participants continued to receive all usual care during the study. Objectives {#Sec7} ---------- The primary aim of the study was to evaluate the effectiveness of receiving care from a social action volunteer befriending service plus usual care at 4 weeks at improving quality of life compared to usual care alone for adults in the last year of life. The secondary aims were to:Explore whether the social action volunteer befriending service affects quality of life at 8 weeks.Explore whether the social action volunteer befriending service reduces loneliness and affects the perception of social support for adults at 4 and 8 weeks.Examine whether informal carers for those receiving care from a social action volunteer befriending service experience less carer burden at 4 and 8 weeks.Determine whether receiving care from a social action volunteer befriending service can affect participant's use of other health and social care services at 4 and 8 weeks. Trial outcome measures:Quality of life: WHOQOL-BREF Scale, a short (26 item) non-disease-specific, validated measure of quality of life and wellbeing, having wide breadth and available in many languages \[[@CR28]\]. Data are reported across the physical, psychological, environment and social relationship domains which were considered likely to be important outcomes for this intervention. Cronbach's Alpha (α) (Physical 0.714, Psychological 0.776, Environment 0.712, Social Relationships 0.461). The low Cronbach's Alpha for social relationships reflects that this is a 3-item subscale, with an item which had many missing values in this study.Loneliness: De Jong Gierveld 6-item Loneliness Scale, a short, well-used, reliable and valid measurement instrument for overall (α 0.374), emotional (α 0.678), and social loneliness (α 0.846) \[[@CR29]\].Social Support: 8-item modified Medical Outcomes Study Social Support Survey (mMOS-SS), a short validated scale covering two domains (emotional (α 0.859) and instrumental (α 0.892) social support, total α 0.910) designed to identify potentially modifiable social support deficits \[[@CR30]\].Self-reported contact with health and social care services over the previous 2 weeks. The primary outcome was rate of change of quality of life at 4 weeks. Secondary outcomes were the rate of change of quality of life at 8 weeks, and loneliness, social support and reported use of health and social care services at 4 and 8 weeks. A short time period was chosen for the primary outcome as any end-of-life care intervention needs to work rapidly to be worthwhile. No data were available to predetermine intervention length, but follow-up for 8 weeks facilitates understanding of any persistence of effect. Socio-demographic data (age, sex, disease diagnosis, education, marital status, living status, spirituality and ethnicity) in the form of a self-completed questionnaire was collected from both patients and informal carers at baseline. At baseline and subsequent time points, patient participants were asked to indicate the number, type and frequency of contact they have with networks of others. The schedule of data collection is presented in Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}. Time periods were necessarily short to reflect the possible prognosis of participants.Table 1End of Life Social Action Study (ELSA): Schedule of enrolment, interventions and assessments(X) indicates that week 12 data are only collected for those in the wait-list arm of the trial (8 weeks after commencement of intervention) Sample size {#Sec8} ----------- Trial power was estimated using a worst case scenario assuming 5% attrition at primary outcome measure. With 350 or more participants per arm power exceeded 0.80 to detect difference in change over time corresponding to an effect size of f = 0.10 between the intervention and wait-list groups. This power model uses alpha = 0.05, two tailed, and uses a conservative correlation of r = 0.6 for scores lagged 4 weeks, and r = 0.5 for 12 weeks. Randomisation and study procedures {#Sec9} ---------------------------------- Participants were those referred to participating services following eligibility, information and informed consent procedures. Baseline data were collected and participants randomly allocated (1:1 allocation ratio) to either the intervention or the wait-list arm of the trial. Site coordinators contacted a randomisation line at Lancaster University, and the next sequence in the allocation (stored in sequentially numbered sealed opaque envelopes) was revealed. The randomisation sequence was computer generated, with rebalance in the arms after 10 randomisations. Blinding of site staff and patient participants was not possible due to the nature of the intervention. Data collected at 4, 8 and 12 weeks were coordinated by the research team and sent by post to patient and carer participants for self-completion. Data were returned directly to the research team. Statistical analysis {#Sec10} -------------------- All analyses were conducted using SPSS version 22. The primary outcome was rate of change of quality of life at 4 weeks (WHOQOL-BREF). Basic exploratory and descriptive statistical tests (e.g. *t* and χ^2^ tests) were conducted at the α = 0.05 individual level of significance. Confidence intervals were reported at the 95% level. Hierarchical Linear Models (HLM) used the full intention-to-treat sample over all available assessments with the aim of differentiating treatment effects from natural trajectories. The HLMs compared primary and secondary outcome scores (e.g. WHOQOL-BREF) between the immediate and wait-list groups. A piecewise model was specified to index change from baseline to week 4 (Phase 1), and change from week 4 to week 12 (Phase 2). Restricted maximum likelihood estimation was used, and fixed slopes and random effects of each time predictor were assessed to determine the most appropriate model. Final models were specified with intercepts as random effects to account for correlations among observations at different time points from the same participant. Treatment condition, time and interactions between treatment condition × time were specified as fixed effects. With the interaction term, we tested whether there was a significant difference in rate of change between treatment groups before and after week 4. Secondary analyses were conducted by testing the same HLMs described with treatment completers. In the immediate arm, treatment completers were those who received any intervention before 4 weeks, and who returned baseline and week 4 data. In the wait-list arm, treatment completers were those who did not receive any intervention before the return of week 4 data. Finally, sensitivity analyses on primary outcomes were conducted to consider of the amount of volunteer input people received in the initial 4-week period. Models were therefore specified using hours of input and controlling for site. Results {#Sec11} ======= Recruitment and flow through trial {#Sec12} ---------------------------------- Figure [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"} outlines the flow of participants in the trial. Recruitment took place from June 2015 to January 2016, with data collection to March 2016. Of 329 eligible people approached to participate, 196 consented. Reasons for the 133 not participating included not wishing to receive the service (*n* = 46), they died or moved away (*n* = 38), or they did not wish to take part in research (*n* = 30). One participant died between consent procedures and randomisation, thus 195 were randomised, 100 to receive the intervention immediately and 95 to the wait-list control group. At each time point, missing data were noted, but participants continued to be enrolled in the study unless advised otherwise, as data sets could be and often were returned at subsequent time points. Around 40% of those in the immediate arm received no volunteer intervention before week 4 assessment due to lack of volunteer availability and matching, and some in the wait-list arm received the intervention at or after 4 weeks, but prior to completing their week 4 assessment. Few carers (n = 33) entered the study and hence their data are not given here. A total of 20% of enrolled participants (39 of 196) died during the study.Fig. 1CONSORT diagram of participant flow through the study Baseline characteristics {#Sec13} ------------------------ Participants were recruited from all 11 sites (range 3--40 participants per site). Participant mean age was 72 (range 37--92), and 60% were female. No significant differences on demographic aspects between randomised groups were observed (Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}). No adverse events were reported.Table 2Baseline and demographic data. Values are numbers (percentages) unless specified otherwiseDemographicsImmediate\ *n* = 92Wait\ *n* = 87Age, mean ± SD72 ± 12.0372 ± 12.50Sex, female n (%)56 (61)53 (61)Education, standard n (%)62 (76)54 (70)Marital status, single n (%)54 (61)61 (72)Living status, living alone n (%)47 (53)54 (64)Occupation, retired n (%)74 (86)70 (82)Ethnicity, white British n (%)81 (92)76 (89)Spirituality, religious n (%)58 (71)51 (69)Cancer diagnosis, n (%)37 (41)47 (55)Baseline quality of life Quality of life, poor or very poor n (%)38 (44)37 (44) Are you dissatisfied with your health? n (%)62 (70)65 (76)Quality of life, mean ± SD QoL Physical32.09 ± 15.2134.95 ± 17.42 QoL Psychological46.52 ± 19.1045.74 ± 17.01 QoL Environment58.75 ± 16.2357.05 ± 14.76 QoL Social relationships55.47 ± 23.2652.88 ± 26.41Loneliness, mean ± SD Social loneliness1.51 ± 1.211.69 ± 1.25 Emotional loneliness1.70 ± 1.112.12 ± 0.87 Total loneliness score3.17 ± 1.893.77 ± 1.66Social support, mean ± SD mMOSS instrumental3.27 ± 1.313.00 ± 1.28 mMOSS emotional3.25 ± 1.103.98 ± 1.09 mMOSS total3.27 ± 1.083.01 ± 1.07Contacts Number of people in contact with over last 2 weeks, mean ± SD4.39 ± 2.414.41 ± 2.56 Overall number of contacts (visits, phone calls) over last 2 weeks, mean ± SD39.85 ± 31.0346.29 ± 45.33The WHOQOL-BREF comprises four individually scored domains. Domain scores are calculated by computing the mean scores within the domain, noting that negatively phrased questions are reverse scored. Domain scores are transformed to a 0--100 scale according to the formula in the WHOQOL Manual. Lower scores indicate a worse quality of life*QoL* quality of life, *mMOSS* Medical Outcomes Study Social Support Survey Primary outcome {#Sec14} --------------- The greater estimated difference in slopes between treatment conditions was 3.98 points on the WHOQOL-BREF Physical subscale at week 4 (95% CI, --0.38 to 0.34). While this difference was not statistically significant, a clear trend was observed, showing that those in the immediate group did not deteriorate at the same rate as those in the wait-list group (*b* = 0.84, 95% CI, --2.24 to 3.92 vs. *b* = --3.14, 95% CI, --6.23 to --0.05) (Table [3](#Tab3){ref-type="table"}). Furthermore, after the wait-list group received the intervention following week 4, it was observed that the difference in rate of change between groups over the follow-up period was reduced from 3.98 to 1.12 (95% CI, --2.93 to 5.19), mainly explained by a reduction in the rate of deterioration previously observed in the wait-list group (from --3.14 to --0.15; 95% CI, --2.22 to 1.92). Estimated means are presented in Table [4](#Tab4){ref-type="table"}.Table 3Estimated rate of change from baseline to week 4 (Phase 1) and 4--12 weeks follow-up (Phase 2)MeasureImmediate\ *b* (95% CI)Wait\ *b* (95% CI)Immediate vs. Wait\ *b* (95% CI)*QoL Physical domain*Phase 10.84 (--2.24 to 3.92)--3.14 (--6.23 to --0.05)3.98 (--0.38 to 8.34)Phase 20.97 (--2.51 to 4.47)--0.15 (--2.22 to 1.92)1.12 (--2.93 to 5.19)*QoL Psychological domain*Phase 10.27 (--3.11 to 3.66)--2.32 (--5.77 to 1.13)2.59 (--2.24 to 7.43)Phase 20.61 (--3.22 to 4.44)--1.21 (--3.49 to 1.07)1.82 (--2.63 to 6.28)*QoL Environmental domain*Phase 1--3.34 (--6.53 to --0.16)--3.14 (--6.23 to --0.05)0.39 (--4.13 to 4.91)Phase 22.95 (--0.70 to 6.61)0.46 (--1.69 to 2.61)2.50 (--1.75 to 6.73)*QoL* quality of life, *CI* confidence interval Table 4Estimated means and 95% confidence intervals at each time point for immediate and wait-list groupsMeasure and time pointImmediate\ Estimated mean (CI)Wait\ Estimated mean (CI)*QoL Physical domain* Baseline32.46 (28.99--35.92)34.95 (31.40--38.50) Week 433.29 (29.40--37.18)31.81 (27.85--35.77) Week 834.27 (30.22--38.31)31.65 (27.96--35.35) Week 1235.24 (28.77--41.71)31.50 (27.02--35.99)*QoL Psychological domain* Baseline46.60 (42.87--50.33)46.06 (42.23--49.90) Week 446.87 (42.68--51.07)43.74 (39.44--48.04) Week 847.49 (43.12--51.85)42.53 (38.54--46.52) Week 1248.10 (41.04--55.15)41.32 (36.46--46.17)*QoL Environmental domain* Baseline58.95 (55.81--62.09)56.88 (53.64--60.12) Week 455.61 (51.99--59.23)53.15 (49.47--56.83) Week 858.56 (54.74--62.38)53.61 (50.25--56.98) Week 1261.52 (54.97--68.06)54.07 (49.80--58.34)*QoL* quality of life, *CI* confidence interval Similar reductions from Phase 1 to Phase 2 were observed in the wait-list group when WHOQOL-BREF Psychological and Environmental subscales were primary outcomes. Per protocol analyses showed no difference to intention-to-treat analyses and were therefore not reported. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to take into account the amount of volunteer input people received ("number of hours of contact") in the initial 4-week period. After controlling for site, the estimated difference in slopes between treatment conditions was 4.43 points on the WHOQOL-BREF Physical subscale at week 4 (95% CI, 0.10 to 8.76). This significant difference reflects that those in the immediate group did not deteriorate at the same rate as those in the wait-list group (Cohen d effect size = 0.27) (Table [5](#Tab5){ref-type="table"}, Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In terms of trajectories over the follow-up period, the pattern described above was replicated, where a reduction in the deterioration of WHOQOL-BREF subscales in the wait-list group between Phase 1 and 2 were observed.Fig. 2Estimated rate of change from baseline to week 4 (Phase 1) and 4--12 weeks follow-up (Phase 2) for WHOQOL-BREF Physical Domain -- controlling for site and number of hours before week 4 Table 5Estimated rate of change from baseline to week 4 (Phase 1) and 4--12 weeks follow-up (Phase 2) -- controlling for site and number of hours before week 4Measure and slopeImmediate\ *b* (95% CI)Wait\ *b* (95% CI)Immediate vs. Wait\ *b* (95% CI)*QoL Physical domain*Phase 11.36 (--1.72 to 4.43)--3.08 (--6.12 to --0.03)4.43 (0.10 to 8.76)Phase 21.04 (--2.43 to 4.51)--0.15 (--2.19 to 1.89)1.19 (--2.83 to 5.22)*QoL Psychological domain*Phase 10.52 (--2.88 to 3.92)--2.21 (--5.63 to 1.19)2.74 (--2.08 to 7.55)Phase 20.61 (--3.21 to 4.43)--1.20 (--3.45 to 1.05)1.81 (--2.62 to 6.24)*QoL Environmental domain*Phase 1--3.25 (--6.50 to --0.009)--3.65 (--6.87 to --0.43)0.40 (--4.17 to 4.96)Phase 23.32 (--0.37 to 7.02)0.46 (--1.68 to 2.61)2.86 (--1.41 to 7.14)*QoL* quality of life, *CI* confidence interval Secondary outcomes {#Sec15} ------------------ Loneliness (De Jong Gierveld Scale \[[@CR29]\]), social support (mMOS-SS \[[@CR30]\]), and contacts with health and social care professionals were assessed as outcomes, where treatment effect was evaluated testing the interaction between treatment and time. No significant differences between treatment groups were found (Table [6](#Tab6){ref-type="table"}).Table 6Loneliness, social support and reported contacts with health and social care professionalsVariablesEmotional Loneliness\ bEmotional loneliness\ 95% CISocial Loneliness bSocial Loneliness\ 95% CISocial Support, Instrumental\ b95% CISocial Support, Emotional\ b95% CISocial Support, Total\ b95% CIHealth and social care professional contact\ b95% CIIntercept1.71(1.43 to 1.98)2.08(1.85 to 2.30)3.04(2.75 to 3.32)3.03(2.80 to 3.26)3.05(2.81 to 3.28)1.07(0.77 to 1.37)Treatment condition, Immediate--0.20(--0.58 to 0.17)--0.39(--0.71 to --0.08)^a^0.23(--0.17 to 0.63)0.16(--0.16 to 0.49)0.19(--0.14 to 0.52)0.11(--0.31 to 0.53)Phase 1, until week 40.02(--0.29 to 0.32)0.10(--0.17 to 0.37)0.14(--0.10 to 0.38)--0.07(--0.28 to 0.15)0.02(--0.16 to 0.21)0.16(--0.22 to 0.55)Treatment condition × Time 1--0.08(--0.52 to 0.35)--0.20(--0.58 to 0.18)0.02(--0.31 to 0.36)0.19(--0.10 to 0.49)0.13(--0.13 to 0.39)--0.21(--0.75 to 0.34)Phase 2, after week 40.02(--0.20 to 0.23)--0.04(--0.22 to 0.14)--0.08(--0.25 to 0.09)0.08(--0.07 to 0.22)0.01(--0.12 to 0.14)0.01(--0.27 to 0.29)Treatment condition × Time 20.07(0.34 to 0.47)0.22(--0.13 to 0.57)0.03(--0.28 to 0.35)--0.06(--0.35 to 0.22)--0.01(--0.26 to 0.23)--0.11(--0.64 to 0.42)^a^Sensitivity analyses controlling for social loneliness at baseline and week 4 did not show a different result pattern (data available upon request)*CI* confidence interval Discussion {#Sec16} ========== This study found no statistically significant difference in effectiveness between volunteer provided support and treatment as usual in people anticipated to be in their last year of life. We saw that the rate of reduction of quality of life, loneliness and perceived social support was less steep in the intervention group, but this did not reach statistical significance. When we controlled for the amount of volunteer support that people received we found that there was a statistically significant difference on the physical domain of quality of life, but not in other domains. There was a pattern of deteriorating levels of quality of life in the wait-list group, a decrease not observed in the immediate group, and which tends to disappear when all receive the intervention. Trends in the data are in favour of the intervention, but the effect is small, and related to reducing the rate of decline rather than improving outcomes. Strengths and limitations of the study {#Sec17} -------------------------------------- This is the first reported trial of volunteer support at the end of life, and provides important information on the outcomes of these commonly provided services, effect size and study parameters. Its particular strength is its pragmatic design, particularly as the intervention design and participants reflect the ways these services are provided and used in clinical practice rather than artificially constraining or limiting the way the intervention was provided. Limitations include study power, blinding, missing data, attrition and intervention fidelity. Fewer service referrals were received than sites expected, although recruitment was steady over the trial period, and required numbers would have been reached with a longer recruitment period. The recruitment period was constrained by governance and contractual delays and time limited funding, which also meant alternate designs such as stepped-wedge would not be feasible \[[@CR31], [@CR32]\]. Our planned effect size was small, and the effectiveness of volunteer services remain unknown because of these issues with study power, and questions about choice of outcome measures. The WHOQOL-BREF was specifically chosen for its wide usage, relevance and cultural appropriateness \[[@CR33]--[@CR35]\], but there were issues with completion of the short social subscale. It may be that end of life specific quality of life scales could be appropriate and well completed \[[@CR36], [@CR37]\], but these were not chosen because many are disease specific, focus more on physical symptoms, flag serious illness in a way which may not be appropriate, and are not available in the same range of languages as the chosen measure. The lack of blinding could be viewed as a limitation, but it was not practical to blind patients, volunteers or site staff to treatment allocation. The amount of missing data and attrition were as expected for a study with participants at the end of life \[[@CR38]\], and robust arrangements were in place for data cleaning and error checking (error rate 0.56%). Whilst the intervention was flexible and data were collected on its provision, not all participants received the intervention as planned. Whilst per protocol analyses revealed no difference to intention-to-treat analyses, greater fidelity in a powered trial may be important given the apparent importance of amount of volunteer input. Comparisons with other studies {#Sec18} ------------------------------ No other trial of the outcomes of volunteer-provided support at the end of life has been conducted, although other trials are underway of volunteers building end-of-life networks \[[@CR39]\] or supporting people with advanced dementia \[[@CR40]\]. Previous studies of volunteer-provided services in the last year of life have been descriptive, addressing issues such as patient and volunteer experience, acceptability, facilitators and barriers \[[@CR10], [@CR11], [@CR16], [@CR17], [@CR19], [@CR41]--[@CR43]\]. These studies have shown that volunteer provided services are seen as complementary to clinical services, and their intuitive appeal means that services are currently recommended and increasingly commonly provided by those providing a range of end-of-life care services \[[@CR14]\]. Clinical services are known to be less accessed by those who are older, with non-malignant conditions, from ethnic minority communities or who are socio-economically disadvantaged \[[@CR44]--[@CR49]\]. Those accessing this volunteer provided service were less likely to have cancer than clinical service norms \[[@CR49]\], and volunteer services may therefore be an access point to clinical end-of-life care services, although they did not facilitate access for those who were from black and minority ethnic communities. Study participants had worse baseline scores for quality of life and loneliness when compared to studies of the general population or those with early stage disease \[[@CR50]--[@CR52]\], and comparable to those with similar disease stages or using clinical end of life care services \[[@CR53], [@CR54]\]. Together with data on deaths during the study, it is clear that those accessing a volunteer provided service are not restricted to those who are considered relatively well. Implications of the study for clinicians and policymakers {#Sec19} --------------------------------------------------------- Clinicians often deliver palliative care within and across generalist and specialist multi-disciplinary teams, although referrals between providers can appear sparse or inequitable \[[@CR44], [@CR55], [@CR56]\]. This research shows that doctors and other clinicians can confidently refer people in their last year of life to volunteer services for support which complements the clinical care offered. Clinicians should consider referring patients in the last year of life who have high social needs, and potentially those who live alone. They can expect that these services may slow a person's decline in quality of life. Policymakers should continue to promote the involvement of volunteers in end-of-life care. The most recent commitment from the UK government on end-of-life care emphasises community and voluntary involvement \[[@CR15]\], building on the recognition of volunteers within the end-of-life care strategy \[[@CR57]\], and the present research supports this policy direction. Policymakers should pay attention to making evidence-based recommendations about the amount of volunteer support provided, as a dose effect is possible. Future research {#Sec20} --------------- Further work is needed to further interrogate the effect of these interventions in powered trials, especially in determining key patient or service characteristics, and their interrelationship with services focusing on clinical needs. Important service characteristics that should be studied include the role of the volunteer as a direct supporter or in mobilising networks of support \[[@CR39], [@CR58]\], in the frequency and amount of support provided, and the type of person supported. Further work to determine the outcome measures best used to assess volunteer interventions is also recommended. Research should take account of our finding that the impact is in reducing rate of decline, and rate of change should be considered as an important outcome measure in palliative and end-of-life care research. Conclusions {#Sec21} =========== More hours or increased frequency of contact with a volunteer has a statistically significant effect on the rate of decline of physical quality of life at the end of life. Other measured outcomes of the volunteer provided support showed no statistically significant benefit over usual care, although a trend in favour of the intervention can be seen. This may have been due to the study being underpowered. This is the first trial of volunteer provided support in the last year of life and provides an emergent answer to questions of whether volunteer support should be used at the end of life; however, future trials should focus on exploring dose issues such as hours and frequency of contact as well as the type of support offered. HLM : Hierarchical Linear Models mMOS-SS : Medical Outcomes Study Social Support Survey WHOQOL-BREF : World Health Organization Quality of Life Brief Scale We acknowledge the contribution of the people who took part in this research, often at a time of great challenge in their lives, thank you. This study would not have been possible without the support of the participating sites, who were responsible for identifying participants, taking consent, and managing study participants and site-specific documentation as well as training volunteers and managing the befriending services. With thanks to Dr Evangelia (Evie) Papavasiliou, Research Associate on the project to 15.9.15, who was involved in trial initiation procedures and initial data collection and Paul Sharples, Research Intern on the project 11.1.16 to 15.4.16 who assisted with data entry and initial data analysis. Funding {#FPar1} ======= This research was funded by the UK Cabinet Office, who also provided grants to sites to cover the cost of the intervention. The views expressed are those of the authors, not necessarily those of the Cabinet Office. The funders had no role in collection, analysis or interpretation of data, or in the writing of the report. Reports are seen by them prior to submission, but they have no contribution to the writing or amendment of the report. Availability of data and materials {#FPar2} ================================== Patient level data are stored in the ELSA database developed by the study authors on a secure server maintained by Lancaster University. Presented data are fully anonymised. The corresponding author may be contacted to forward requests for data sharing. Authors' contributions {#FPar3} ====================== CW conceived the study, was the chief investigator and co-wrote the manuscript. CW, NP, SP, GPA and NO co-wrote the protocol and were involved with the conduct of the study. CW, MH and SD were responsible for study data collection and analysis. GPA was the trial statistician. All authors contributed to and approved the final manuscript. CW is the guarantor. Competing interests {#FPar4} =================== The authors declare they have no competing interests. Consent for publication {#FPar5} ======================= Not applicable. Ethics approval {#FPar6} =============== Research ethics approval was granted on 12.3.15 by NRES Committee Yorkshire & The Humber--South Yorkshire REC reference 15/YH/0090. IRAS project ID 173058. Site-specific approvals were granted by NRES Committee Yorkshire and the Humber--South Yorkshire.

\section{Introduction} Traditional supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) systems provide information regarding the system state at the order of seconds to the operator. However, such fidelity, considered appropriate in prior decades, is not sufficient to observe or predict disturbances at faster time-scales that are increasingly being observed in today's stochastic grid \cite{hossain2011investigation}. To provide more rapid measurement data, phasor measurement units (PMUs) have gained widespread deployment. PMUs \cite{pmu} are time-synchronized by GPS timestamps and collect measurements of system states (Eg. voltage, frequency, currents) multiple times per second at rates between 30 and 240 Hz. Thereby, if efficient methods for PMU analysis are developed, they can help in obtaining a more holistic understanding of the state of the power grid. Real-time detection of changes in the power system can have multiple benefits to grid security. Among others, it can enable corrective control actions by operators that can prevent grid failures from devolving into cascading blackouts \cite{ghanavati2015identifying}. Together with event-detection, the problem of event identification/classification is equally important as it helps determine probable causes and follow-up actions if necessary. Figure~\ref{fig_anom_ex} shows several voltage anomalies measured by a PMU system in a US transmission grid. While PMUs have gained increasing deployment in the modern power system, the use of their data reporting in real-time operations has not yet realized full adoption. The primary use of PMU data so far has been for offline event discovery and post-event analysis \cite{PMU_loc}. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Example Anomalies} \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{anom_small.png} \caption{Example of anomalies detected in voltage signal of a US Independent System Operator.} \label{fig_anom_ex} \end{figure} The overarching goal of this research is to create a \emph{real-time} approach for facilitating a remote analysis of individual components in the grid for monitoring, detection, and classification of anomalies. The implementation of our framework is fully automated, user-friendly and crucially \emph{interpretable}. Any time the warning flag about the system state is raised, our methods ensure that the operator is able to see quantitative details of the prediction and classification sub-tasks in real-time for validation. A principled way to achieve the interpretability of predictions consists of connecting data with the physical properties of the system. This physics-informed approach has been proven successful when a reasonable system model under given conditions is known, such as the recovery of linearized swing equations in transmission-level power grids from PMU observation \cite{lokhov2018online}. However, often even the functional form of the model is not known, or the conditions under which it holds can not be verified \emph{a priori}; hence, it becomes desirable to use a more flexible data-driven approach that is based on, but also extends the physics-based models commonly used in modeling the dynamics of power grids. The data-driven framework proposed in this work is principally based on the theory of robust statistical machine learning \cite{wainwrightjordan}. In particular, we learn the parameters of a general stochastic vector auto-regressive (VAR) process to model the effective relationship between measurements collected. This multivariate approach, updated at regular intervals, makes near-term predictions of future trajectories for the data. The anomalies are then identified based on statistically significant deviations in the incoming data from the ensuring predictions. Finally, we design a decision-tree based classification tool into our framework to distinguish the identified anomalies into different interpretable categories. In what follows, we discuss the application of our learning framework on real PMU data-feed collected from a US transmission system operator (ISO). Compared to uni-variate data analysis and other general-purpose machine learning techniques such as neural networks, our multivariate approach coupled with decision tree-based classification shows superior performance for both event detection and classification in the available data-set. Even more importantly, our approach does not involve tuning or fitting of thresholds and hyper-parameters specific to a particular system, and hence is intrinsically transferable from one real system to another. The rest of the paper is organized as follows: Section~\ref{sec-related} presents related work, Section~\ref{sec-approach} presents the implementation of our machine learning framework and the procedure for setting proper parameter values in the statistical model. In Sections~\ref{sec-anom} and ~\ref{sec-classification}, the anomaly detection and classification application using the implementation of the framework is presented and evaluated. Finally, the implications of the framework with proposed future work are discussed in Section~\ref{sec-discuss}. \section{Related Work} \label{sec-related} Real-time use of PMUs is a growing field of research, though its practical implementation has been sporadic. The approach presented in this paper provides a statistical learning framework for modeling the multivariate stream of raw data from a single PMU that measures frequency, and complex-valued voltage, current, and power measurements in real-time. This step is motivated by non-trivial dependence between single-variable measurements at the same location, as observed in later sections. Conversely, in prior work \cite{pmu_small, pmuOther}, statistical tests with sliding windows are designed to detect anomalies in single variables. In \cite{PMU_loc}, the authors use a rule-based approach for detecting changes in each data variable independently. The approach utilizes off-line analysis of data rather than the real-time approach presented in this work. In \cite{smartMeter}, the authors focus on detecting and classifying smart meter anomalies using unsupervised machine learning techniques, including neural network, and projection-based methods. The low data-rate of smart meters makes it non-trivial to extend the techniques to real-time PMU data. In \cite{PMU_ensemble}, the authors develop an ensemble-based method that combines multiple detection algorithms to create a more robust detection mechanism. In \cite{PMU_decision}, the authors use a decision tree to classify line events from PMU data. While our work utilizes decision trees as well, due to their interpretability, the detection methods used makes it different from the existing work A guide for signal processing based techniques is developed in \cite{nrel_long}. The authors use the voltage phase angle difference measured by PMUs with a reference bus to determine power system events. In contrast, we model the PMU data stream individually within its local context for use in real-time detection. In \cite{PMU_comms}, the authors use K-nearest-neighbor (KNN) and Singular Spectrum Analysis (SSA) combined with fog computing which moves processing to edge devices. In future work, we intend to evaluate our modeling methods on multiple PMU data streams and incorporate edge computing paradigms. Overall, the approach presented in this paper attempts to generalize the problem of anomaly detection: detection and scoring of anomalies in a principled manner based on an effective model that is learned on the fly; well-defined data-driven approach to selecting hyper-parameters; capturing the interaction of variables due to underlying system properties; and working in the invariant spaces of probabilistic scores which ensures transferrability of methods. \section{Approach} \label{sec-approach} To analyze the PMU measurements collected from the grid during normal ambient operation, we model the observed values using a dynamical model. Once a suitable effective descriptive model is obtained, we can gain insight into the state of the system and changes made in it. We start by describing the measurements available from a US ISO for analysis. \subsection{Data Description and Preliminary Analysis} To provide a foundation for our statistical model, we use time-stamped vector-valued data collected from a single PMU on the transmission system of a US ISO. In this study, we use $87$ days of data, collected at 30Hz. Due to the underlying physics of the grid, there is an inherent relationship between the power variables useful to power operators in the data-stream. \if 0 \begin{table}[ht] \centering \caption{Data stream variables inferred from the PMU measurements.} \begin{tabular}{|l|l|} \hline Voltage Magnitude & Measured in volts \\ \hline Voltage Angle & Measured in degrees \\ \hline Current Magnitude & Measured in Amperes \\ \hline Current Angle & Measured in degrees \\ \hline P & Real or active power in Megawatts (MW) \\ \hline Q & Reactive power in megavolt-amperes (MVAR)\\ \hline S & Complex Power in megavolt-amperes (MVA), \\ & Apparent Power is magnitude of (S) \\ \hline PF & Power factor is the ratio of real power to \\ & apparent power\\ \hline Frequency & Measured in Hertz\\ \hline \end{tabular} \label{tab:my_label} \end{table} \fi The power triangle relates active power (P), reactive power (Q), Complex Power (S), and phase angle difference $\phi$. Coupling with voltage, current and frequency, there are many potential variables at hand to model the system. Using all the information available is not optimal from the information storage and real-time data processing points of view; additionally, exact strong correlation relations between some of the variables may artificially complicate the learning of an effective model. Therefore, we limit the data variables used in our model to voltage, current, the sine of the angle difference of voltage and current and frequency. All other quantities can be straightforwardly estimated from these four if required. Figure~\ref{fig_corr_some} shows the empirical correlation between the variables used in our model. On the diagonal of the figure, the histograms of the data for each plot are shown. The plots below the diagonal contain the bivariate distribution ellipses to 95\% confidence of the values along with their locally estimated scatter plot smoothing (LOESS) lines. Above the diagonal, the Pearson correlation coefficients are listed. \if 0 \begin{equation} \rho_{X,Y} = \frac{\texttt{cov}(X,Y)}{\sigma_X\sigma_Y } \label{fomula_corr} \end{equation} \fi A simple exploratory analysis of the Figure~\ref{fig_corr_some} indicates that the sine of the angle difference is correlated to the magnitude of current and that voltage magnitude is correlated to the frequency of the system. This observation motivates the need to take the multivariate nature of the signal into account when constructing the effective dynamical model of the system, which is one of the main features of our method. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Correlation of PMU Data Stream Variables} \includegraphics[scale=0.56]{correlationSome.pdf} \caption{Correlation of variables over 90 minutes of stable operation. Bivariate scatter plots are shown below the diagonal as LOESS lines, histograms of the distribution of values on the diagonal, and the Pearson correlations above. \label{fig_corr_some} \end{figure} \subsection{Data Modeling} To model the PMU data stream, we design a multivariate approach for capturing the interaction between variables. The interaction is expected due to the underlying physics of the electric power grid. In general, the dynamics may have an arbitrary non-linear functional complexity; however, a common approach consists of considering a liner effective model linearized around a current operating point, which is typically valid over short time scales. Hence, in what follows we use the four identified variables in a vector autoregressive model (VAR) which relates the system's current state to time-lagged values of previous states via dynamical state matrices and an error term. A VAR(p)-process is defined consisting of $K$ endogenous variables $y_t = (y_{1t},...,y_{kt},...,y_{Kt})$ for $k = 1,...,K$ as: \begin{equation} y_t = c + A_1y_{t-1} + ... + A_py_{t-p} + u_t \ , \label{formula_var} \end{equation} with $A_i$ as $K \times K$ coefficient matrices for $i = 1,...,p$ and $u_t$ is a $K$-dimensional random noise process with expected mean, E$(u_t) = 0$ and time invariant white noise positive definite covariance matrix $E(u_tu_t^\top) = \Sigma_u$ \cite{vars2}. In the case of an independent Gaussian noise, the coefficients of a VAR model can be optimally estimated using least-squares applied to the rewritten equations for each $k \in K$ variable separately \cite{lokhov2018online,lokhov2018cdc}. Since different variables have different scales, it is convenient to first pre-process and adequately format the data for the statistical learning model. First, each signal is individually de-trended over the period the model learns on. To normalize, we then divide the data interval by the standard deviation, $\sigma_k$ for each variable $k \in K$. Thus our transformed data is measured in standard deviations from the linear trend-line and original units such as volts, amperes are removed. Figure~\ref{fig_raw_30sec} shows an example of regular raw data signals next to the standardized signals. A VAR process is then fitted to the pre-processed data. The R language VAR implementation is used \cite{vars1} for analysis. Notice that it is immediate to transform the standardized data back to physical scale and dimension using the saved values of the linear trend and value of the standard deviation. The standardization parameters are constantly adjusted to incorporate new incoming data in real-time. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{PMU Data Stream and Standardization} \includegraphics[scale=0.45]{sstand.pdf} \caption{The PMU data stream is shown in red for each variable over 30 seconds, with scale on left y axis. The standardized signals are shown in blue using the right side y axis. The standardization is achieved by linear de-trending and dividing by the standard deviation of the population over a chosen period of time, the training data size for the VAR model. \label{fig_raw_30sec} \end{figure} \subsection{Hyper-parameter selection in VAR} The VAR estimation process includes the following input hyper-parameters: (a) the time resolution we want to model; (b) $\tau$, the length of the time period over which the VAR coefficients are trained; and (c) $p$, the number of lag terms included in the model. Below, we describe a principled empirical procedure for selecting the right values of each of the hyper-parameters for a given data set. \paragraph{Model resolution} The time resolution hyper-parameter is not data-related, but instead is intrinsically tied to the time scale of the application of interest. For example, detection of forced oscillations occurring at the scale of seconds would require much high data resolution compared to slow-moving changes such as transformer aging \cite{transformers} which is the process that may take weeks or even months. In this study, we are interested in real-time detection of anomalies on the maximum scale of seconds; we use a 0.5-second prediction interval that enables detection of real-time changes in the system. To fit the model using this resolution, the data should be appropriately coarse-grained to scale. In the case of a given data set, the data is processed by taking the rate of data transmission, i.e., 30 Hertz and dividing by the granularity (0.5) seconds and taking the mean of those points. \paragraph{Training data size} Next, we determine the selection of training data length, $\tau$. For a stable model, more data (larger $\tau$) leads to a better model fit. However, the physical parameters in an electric power grid tend to change throughout the day due to changing weather, control settings, or consumption and generation. Hence, we do not expect our model to be stable for very long periods of time; the effective description should drift with time as well. Moreover, our requirement of real-time data processing means that we would like to minimize the number of data points to construct a model on the fly. Hence, an ideal amount of training data $\tau$ will balance the training error caused by a finite number of learning samples and the model misspecification error due to the naturally changing effective model of the system, at the same time keeping the computational complexity of the learning procedure low. Below, we describe a self-consistent data-driven approach to set the value of $\tau$ that would satisfy these requirements. How can one estimate the training error given that the ground truth model is unknown? To tackle this challenge, we propose to learn a trial VAR(1) model from data and then use it to synthesize data; this model will then serve as ground truth in this synthetic experiment. From the synthesized data, we then retrain a VAR(1) model and calculate the difference between the original and the inferred models. A larger difference would show that there is an insufficient amount of data to accurately reconfigure the VAR model. In Figure~\ref{fig_retrain}, data is synthesized from VAR(1) models trained on PMU data from $\tau = [0.5, 20]$ minutes at half-minute intervals. VAR(1) models are then retrained on the synthesized data. The error is computed using the following relation defined by the average absolute per-element difference $D_1$: \begin{equation} D_1 = \frac{\sum_{ij} |\hat A_{ij} - A_{ij}|} {K^2} \label{formula_l1} \end{equation} Here, $A$ is a reference VAR(1) coefficient matrix and $\hat A$ is the VAR(1) coefficient matrix fitted on data simulated using $A$. Figure~\ref{fig_retrain} shows that the error rapidly decreases to an average of about 0.005 at about 8 minutes, after which the decay becomes gradual. This illustrates that the typical dynamic state matrix for the VAR(1) model is reconstructed to an acceptable accuracy using the data equivalent of 8-12 minutes. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Accuracy of Fitting VAR(1) Model} \includegraphics[scale=0.77625]{TA01.pdf} \caption{Estimation of the training error. Data is synthesized from VAR(1) models trained on the available PMU data. VAR(1) models are then fit on the same amount of synthesized data. Plotted is the average difference between the trained $A$ state matrix and the re-trained $\hat A$ coefficient matrix. Their distributions are plotted for training times varying from 0.5 minutes to 20 minutes over 50 independent data intervals. } \label{fig_retrain} \end{figure} In order to evaluate the mis-specification error arising from the natural change of the effective model, we compare the coefficient matrices estimated using two consecutive intervals: \begin{equation} D_2 = \frac{\sum_{ij} |A_{ij} - B_{ij}|} {K^2} \label{formula_l2} \end{equation} Similarly to Eq.~\ref{formula_l1}, Eq.~\ref{formula_l2} computes the average absolute per-unit difference of $K \times K$ $A$ and $B$ where $A$ is the coefficient matrix from the VAR(1) model trained from $[t,t+\tau)$ and $B$ is the coefficient matrix fitted from the VAR(1) model trained from $[t+\tau, t+2\tau)$ for $\tau$ ranging from 0.5 to 20 minutes. Figure~\ref{fig_mod_change} illustrates the stability of the model when $\tau$, the size of the training set, increases. As expected, over short intervals i.e., 1 minute, the model remains very stable with less than 0.025 per element change in the coefficient matrices. As the length of the model increases, the similarity of the coefficient matrices decreases. After about 10 minutes, the error plateaus around 0.05. Based on our similarity metric, it can be concluded that beyond 10 minutes, the difference in matrices encompasses the error due to the change in the effective model. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Change in Model Over Data Stream} \includegraphics[scale=0.775]{TB01.pdf} \caption{The error is plotted over various $\tau$ values ranging from 0.5 to 25 minutes. The error is computed by Equation~\ref{formula_l2}. The error increases and then levels off at about 10 minutes. } \label{fig_mod_change} \end{figure} \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Error in VAR(1) and VAR(2) Models} \includegraphics[scale=0.65]{var_comp.pdf} \caption{Retraining accuracy of a VAR(1) model trained over 10 minutes of PMU data with a VAR(2) model trained over 20 minutes of PMU data. The VAR(1) model has an average per-element error of the coefficient matrix of 0.0039 when retrained on 10 minutes, while the VAR(2) model retrained on 20 minutes has an average error of 0.0087. } \label{fig_lags} \end{figure} The analysis of the two sources of error depicted in Figures~\ref{fig_retrain} and~\ref{fig_mod_change} shows that an increase in error due to model misspecification will take over the reduction of error due to statistical estimation. In what follows, we fix $\tau = 10$ minutes as an acceptable choice for the length of training data in the current data set. \paragraph{Depth of the model} The final parameter of the VAR model is the number of lag terms $p$, that are used to predict the next state. The benefit of including more time lags which increases the expressivity of the model can be hampered by the decrease of the accuracy of the recovered model due to the final amount of data. In order to determine an appropriate number of lag terms to include, we analyze the impact of the number of lags on a model's retraining error using Eq.~\ref{formula_l1}. For the case of 2 lags, we compute the average per-element absolute error over both coefficient matrices $A_1$ and $A_2$. Figure~\ref{fig_lags} illustrates the error over 50 runs where $\tau$ increases from 0.5 minutes to 25 minutes. It can be seen that a VAR(2) model with $\tau = $ 20 minutes has over twice the per-element error as a VAR(1) model with $\tau = $ 10 minutes. Therefore, we can conclude that to minimize errors associated with the selected $\tau$, the inclusion of two lags is prohibitive and instead one lag is sufficient for the VAR model on the current data set. To summarize, for the data set analyzed in this study, we utilize a VAR(1) model with a training data length of $\tau = 10$ minutes, and a 0.5-second prediction scale. The variables included in the VAR(1) model are voltage magnitude, current magnitude, sine of the phasor angle differences, and the frequency. In the next section, we use this VAR(1) model for anomaly detection and subsequent classification. For other systems and data sets, the operator may use the procedure described above to set the optimal hyperparameters of our learning framework. \section{Anomaly Detection} \label{sec-anom} Under normal control operations as well as external perturbations, the measurements recorded in the PMU measurements change gradually. However brief or extended large changes are observed from time to time and qualified as anomalies. These include both operational changes such as load tap changes, as well as external perturbations such as lightning strikes. Figure~\ref{fig_anom_ex} shows a few examples of anomalies in the voltage signal of the available PMU. While large anomalies can be visually seen by the human eye in individual measurement streams, we propose a statistical approach that enables early detection of anomalies when they begin or less severe or subtle anomalies that can only be detected by considering multiple measured variables in the VAR(1) model. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Residual Distance Scores} \includegraphics[scale=0.65]{Tscores.pdf} \caption{90 Minutes of raw data and corresponding residual distance scores. The scores are measured in standard deviations. Some anomalies are seen in the data stream by multiple variables, some by single variables, and some anomalies the model detects illustrate instability periods.} \label{fig_transform} \end{figure} \paragraph{Probabilistic scoring of the incoming data} As described in the previous section, we use a VAR(1) model with 4 variables, scaled to 0.5-second granularity, with training data $\tau$ of 10 minutes for modeling the PMU data-stream. The VAR(1) model is retrained in real-time every 0.5 second and used to predict the next data point in the time series. Once the next data-point is received, a vector-valued error/residual $r_t$ is computed as \begin{equation} r_t = AX_{t-1} - X_t, \label{eq_residual} \end{equation} where $AX_{t-1}$ is the prediction based on $X_{t-1}$ and $X_{t}$ is the observed measurement. The residuals $r_t$ can then be scored according to the Mahalanobis distance \cite{mah-dist} using noise covariance matrix $\Sigma$ which is learned during the VAR(1) training: \begin{equation} D_M(\vec{r_t}) = \sqrt{\vec{r_t}^T \ \Sigma^{-1} \ \vec{r_t}} \label{eq_dist} \end{equation} The distance of the residuals from the model's noise distribution are unitless and hence transferable across PMU streams and different operating conditions. This metric (given here in the zero-mean case due to de-trending) generalizes the distance in terms of standard deviations for one-dimensional case to the case of multivariate Gaussian distributions. The analysis of the multivariate distribution can also provide a distance metric related to an individual variable $y_{kt}$ (e.g. voltage alone), but \emph{informed} by the state of other variables. Indeed, a conditional distribution of $y_{kt}$ given the other variables is a Gaussian distribution itself: \begin{equation} r^{k}_{t} \sim N(\Bar{\mu}_{k}, \bar{\sigma}_{k}), \label{eq_conditionalDist} \end{equation} with mean $\Bar{\mu}_{k} = \Sigma_{k, k^c} \Sigma^{-1}_{k^c, k^c} r^{k^c}_{t}$ and standard deviation $\bar{\sigma}_{k} = \Sigma_{k, k} - \Sigma_{k, k^c} \Sigma^{-1}_{k^c, k^c} \Sigma_{k^c, k}$ that are computed for each variable $k$ and the state of the remaining variables $k^c$. The incoming data points are provided with the score $S$ equal to the Mahalanobis distance $D_M$ in the case of full multivariate distribution, or to the distance to the mean $\Bar{\mu}_{k}$ measured in standard deviations $\bar{\sigma}_{k}$ for an individual variable $k$. Examples of distances of the individual residuals using the VAR(1) model on the available PMU data is shown in Figure~\ref{fig_transform}. Notice that most of the points lie within the $S=5$ ``$\sigma$'' score, which means that they are considered normal for the current effective model. On the other hand, the larger the value of $S$, the more likely it is to be a severe event. To identify anomalies, we compare the relative score $S$ against a user-specified threshold $T$. When a score larger than the threshold $T$ is found, the VAR(1) model retraining is stopped, as we know that the data set contains anomalous points, and does not describe normal behavior of the system. Our learning algorithm then scores the next $q$ streaming measurement samples by their corresponding residues based on a $q$-step forecast of the VAR(1) process given by $y_{q+t} = A(A(A \dots A(y_{t-1})))$. In our detection approach, we set $q=10$ to detect events of short duration or larger events that progress in this period of time. An example of this procedure is given in Figure~\ref{fig_compare_anomalyV} for a voltage anomaly over 10 seconds. The conditional probability is used for scoring the residuals for the 5 seconds following the anomaly. In this anomaly with $S=70$, the deviation of the voltage is over 70 standard deviations away from the expected distribution. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Anomaly in raw and in transformed} \includegraphics[scale=0.65]{TD01.pdf} \caption{A voltage spike of over 1000 volts is detected as an anomaly with a score over 70 standard deviations from the models expected value. The quick recovery is seen in the score as well as the voltage data. } \label{fig_compare_anomalyV} \end{figure} \paragraph{Multivariate vs. univariate detection} It is worth mentioning that in prior work, anomaly detection is typically based on historical data involving a single variable on a sliding window \cite{pmu_small, pmuOther}. Our approach is more general in utilizing a multivariate statistical linear model. Figure~\ref{fig_compare_anomaly} compares anomaly detection by our multivariate VAR(1) approach with that based on univariate min-max detection approach on a PMU data stream over 1 day. The min-max algorithm takes the range (maximum-minimum) of a sliding window and determines if it is some standard deviations from the mean of the whole data set. Using a 10-second sliding window, there are many overlaps in the conditional probability of VAR residuals as well as the min-max algorithm. For the multivariate approach, we use a threshold of $12$ to identify the start of the anomaly. For the min-max algorithm, the thresholds are set at 3 for voltage magnitude, 4 for current and angle difference, and 6 for frequency. This is in accordance with the National Renewable Energy Laboratory's PMU anomaly detection guidelines \cite{nrel_long} which suggest that the use of multiple techniques is useful to detect changes based on historical PMU data. It is clear from Figure~\ref{fig_compare_anomaly} that our multivariate approach is able to identify almost all anomalies that are detected in different single variable statistical analysis. Crucially, it is able to overcome the fact that certain anomalies detected by a single-variable based test are missed entirely by tests based on some other variable. This combined with the automatic re-training during normal operating regime makes our framework seamless yet accurate. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Comparison of Anomaly Detection Mechanisms} \includegraphics[scale=0.56]{comparison.pdf} \caption{This figure illustrates the comparison of the min-max sliding window statistical method applied to each data stream alongside the conditional and Mahalanobis distances of residuals for 1 day. The multivariate detection captures anomalies due to events in individual variables and due to their combined low probability under the learned model. } \label{fig_compare_anomaly} \end{figure} \paragraph{Selection of the detection threshold} To demonstrate the dependence on the threshold $T$, we consider the entire data-stream of $87$ days and report results on anomaly detection by multivariate as well as individual variables in Figure~\ref{fig_upset5} for two thresholds (a) $T= 5$, and (b) $T= 15$. In either case, each detected anomaly labeled based on the set of individual variables scores and/or multivariate score that led to its discovery. Setting a detection threshold of $T$ = 5 standard deviations results in a total of just under 8000 anomalies. Observe that the most common detection of anomalies corresponds to detection through the multivariate case. Voltage anomalies are the second most occurring anomaly type, but they are also detected by the multivariate test. A threshold corresponding to five standard deviations may be too low as in the large amount of data it would also capture the low-probability deviations that correspond to normal events under the learned model. Setting a detection threshold of $T = 15$ in Figure~\ref{fig_upset5} (b), reduces the number of false positives but may potentially miss some low impact events. The trend remains similar in both cases: the multivariate score is enough to detect the score in all other variables. In practice, a threshold selection should be done by the operator using randomized tests with labeled data of events of importance to the system. In this threshold setting scheme, one could imagine an-operator assisted procedure where a human may introduce some feedback to fine-tune the threshold since the events are detected in real-time. In the next step, we move to the crucial step of anomaly classification of detected events. \begin{figure \centering \subfloat[5 Standard Deviations]{\includegraphics[scale=0.52]{upset5.pdf}}\\ \subfloat[15 Standard Deviations]{\includegraphics[scale=0.52]{upset15.pdf}} \caption{Number and co-occurrence of anomalies in different variables detected on 87 days of historical data scored by Mahalanobis distances on data residuals. $T=5$ and $T=15$ ``standard deviations'' are used as thresholds to detect anomalies. The multivariate Mahalanobis distance shows an anomaly when the conditional probability distance for each variable does. Plots are created using UpSetR package \cite{upset}.} \label{fig_upset5} \end{figure} \section{Classification of Anomalies} \label{sec-classification} It is desirable to provide information useful for operators once an event is detected. Specifically, a tool that is able provide an automatic classification of the anomaly into predefined classes can provide quick insight into the operation of the system. This would enable the operator (or automated system) to take fast and informative control action. Another requirement for the classifier is to be as interpretable as possible: the operator should be able to look up why a certain event has been classified into a given class. From the detection results, it is clear that among single variable based detection tests, voltage anomalies are the most frequent anomaly type. To describe and demonstrate our classification task, we focus on assigning the voltage anomalies into a set of common occurrence classes. The PMU data available to us is unlabeled, and hence for the sake of illustration of our methods, we resort to shape-based but intuitive classes. We have manually labeled 750 voltage events into 4 categories using raw data of the voltage signal: voltage spikes, prolonged voltage drops, step up and step down events typically caused by load tap changes and miscellaneous oscillatory events. In real-world application, these classes should be defined based on the domain expertise of the operators. To enable automatic classification, data features are generated from the data residuals, using 5 seconds of data following anomaly detection. The extracted features include: \begin{itemize} \item Maximum distance \item Average distance \item Number of points above the threshold \item Decile Ranks 1-9 \item Index of maximum distance \item \# of oscillations around the 0.25, 0.5, and 0.75 levels \item Return from anomaly index. (Index of value such that future residuals are all below the anomaly threshold) \item The difference of indices of maximum distance and return from anomaly \end{itemize} For elucidation, a representative anomaly of length $5$ seconds with annotated features is shown in Figure~\ref{fig_features}. In practice, additional features can be generated using automatic feature extraction schemes or using domain knowledge . \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Decision Tree Voltage Classification} \includegraphics[scale=0.4367]{featuresShort2.pdf} \caption{A representative anomaly of length $5$ seconds with annotated features is shown. The detection threshold is shown in blue. The Deciles are not shown due to space constraints. } \label{fig_features} \end{figure} Our classification scheme is based on a supervised decision tree \cite{cart84} based on the above features. The decision tree partitions regressively on features using the algorithm \cite{rpart} and the R library \textit{rpart} \cite{rpart_r}. Among others, decision trees have good interpretability as they offer operators the exact sequence of feature values that led to an anomaly being classified into a particular class. In practice, this can help in the selection or removal of specific features based on the accuracy over labeled training data. The regressive partitioning algorithm in our decision tree selects a subset of features that give the most accurate classification: decile ranks 2 and 8, the maximum distance and the oscillations around the mean distance. Figure~\ref{fig_decisionTree} shows the view of the decision tree used for our data. Using 10-fold cross-validation, we present the accuracy of classification by our decision tree. To benchmark its performance, we compare it with black-box neural network and k-means clustering-based classification using both features extracted from the data and raw data in Table~\ref{tab:comp}. Despite its simplicity and interpretability, the decision tree approach has an accuracy of 93.3\%, which is on par and even higher than that of other learning schemes. \begin{figure \centering \figuretitle{Decision Tree Voltage Classification} \includegraphics[scale=0.575]{decisionTreeSmall.pdf} \caption{Decision tree using automatically selected features: decile ranks 2 and 8, the maximum distance and the oscillations around the mean distance. In each node, the top number corresponds with color to the prediction at that node. The middle number represents the accuracy of that prediction at that node and the bottom number represents the percent of training samples that fall into that node. } \label{fig_decisionTree} \end{figure} \begin{table}[ht] \centering \caption{Performance comparison of different classification methods} \begin{tabular}{| l | c | } \hline {\bf Classification Approach} & {\bf Accuracy} \\ \hline Decision Tree (features) & 93.3\% \\ \hline Neural Network 0 hidden layers (features) & 91.1\% \\ \hline Neural Network 10-100-10 hidden layers (features) & 91.7\% \\ \hline Neural Network 10 hidden layers (raw data) & 86.0\% \\ \hline K-means Clustering (features) & 90.9\% \\ \hline \end{tabular} \label{tab:comp} \end{table} \section{Discussion and conclusions} \label{sec-discuss} Large quantities of synchronized data from phasor measurement units have created a need for a statistical learning based framework to process, model and evaluate the data to gain insight and understanding of the electric power system. The requirements for such a framework include: (a) \emph{generality}: the scheme should not be system-specific and should be transferrable and deployed on a large number of infrastructure systems; (b) \emph{interpretability}: each step, be it model learned, anomaly detected, or classified, should be easily interpretable by an operator to better inform the response decisions; (c) \emph{modularity}: each of the components could potentially be replaced by other schemes if desired; (d) \emph{guarantees}: well-defined theoretical and empirical error measures provided with each step of the framework; and (e) \emph{computational efficiency}: the methods should operate on streaming data, perform real-time computations, and provide early detection, classification, and explanation of the events. This paper shows a general real-time approach that satisfies all the criteria listed above. It utilizes an effective physics-motivated linear vector autoregressive model learned from a PMU data stream. We presented the general data-driven procedure that can be used to select hyper-parameters of the learning scheme in a principled way. The value of the effective model learned is shown through two important applications: categorization of anomalies detected using well-defined probabilistic scores according to the learned model; and classification of anomalies using interpretable decision trees that also show a very good level of accuracy. One of the advantages of the designed anomaly detection scheme consists in the choice of the invariant representation of the signals in terms of probabilistic scoring according to the effective model learned on the fly. This ensures the transferability of methods to very general settings. As far as classification is concerned, given that most of the data is unlabeled, in future work it is important to move to unsupervised approaches such as clustering to be able to classify unlabeled data corresponding to different variables automatically. One important future direction is to use the full power of the learned effective model to see the signs of endogenous events or cyber attacks \cite{lokhov2016detection} before they occur. Inherently, it is impossible to predict external perturbations, but it is possible to predict the response of the system to exogenous perturbations and to take corrective actions if the response is dangerous for the stability of the system. We anticipate that for many such scenarios, the information should be contained in the dynamic state matrix of the effective model learned prior to the event. This work focused on establishing data processing, anomaly detection and classification at the level of a single PMU with multi-variable stream. Moving forward, it is important to use the inferred information for network-wide tasks, such as localization of anomalies \cite{8718345}. With the overwhelming quantity of data transmitted in modern WAMS, and limited comunication network infrastrucure, it is desirable for data to be processed locally on each PMU in the way described in this study; and that only labeled information on the detected events with time stamps could be sent to the central server for performing network-wide analysis from a partial PMU coverage \cite{lokhov2018cdc} Last, our short term goal will be to release code associated with the methods developed in this study with a visualization component, which would enhance the interpretability of the results for grid operations. \vspace{-0.15cm} \section{Acknowledgments} We are grateful to Scott Backhaus, Trevor Crawford and Alaa Moussawi for fruitful discussions and for their insights in formulating various elements of the developed framework. % \vspace{-0.15cm} \bibliographystyle{IEEEtran}

1. Introduction {#sec1} =============== DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) constitute the most cytotoxic form of DNA damage in the genome. DSBs are generated not only by exogenous sources, such as ionizing radiation, radiomimetic compounds, and topoisomerase inhibitors but also from endogenous cellular processes that generate reactive oxygen species \[[@B1], [@B2]\]. In mammalian cells, one of the major pathways for the repair of DSBs is nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) \[[@B3], [@B4]\]. The principle proteins that participate in this DNA end joining pathway both *in vitro* \[[@B5]--[@B7]\] and *in vivo* \[[@B8]--[@B10]\] are the Ku 70/80 heterodimer, DNA-PK~cs~, XRCC4, DNA ligase IV and XLF (XRCC4-like factor; also called Cernunnos) that has recently been identified as a binding partner of the DNA ligase IV-XRCC4 complex and as necessary for efficient ligation via NHEJ \[[@B11], [@B12]\]. Subsets of NHEJ may involve other factors such as Artemis \[[@B13]\]. Together with the Artemis protein, DNA-PKcs can stimulate processing of the DNA ends \[[@B14], [@B15]\]. Additional proteins, including DNA polymerases *μ* and *λ*, TDP1 (tyrosyl-DNA phosphodiesterase), PNK (polynucleotide kinase), and WRN (Werner\'s syndrome helicase) are also likely to play a role in DSB repair \[[@B16]\]. Recent reports suggest that numerous other proteins, including ATM, histones H1 and H2AX, NBS1, and Mre11 may also have some influence on the NHEJ pathway \[[@B17]--[@B19]\]. NHEJ is a complex, multistep process initiated by the binding of a heterodimeric complex composed of Ku70 and Ku80 subunits (encoded by the XRCC5 and XRCC6 genes, respectively) to both ends of the broken DNA molecule with high specificity and affinity \[[@B20]\]. Ku binds DNA DSB ends and recruits DNA-PK~cs~, which is a 460 kDa serine/threonine protein kinase, to the ends \[[@B21]\]. Ku then translocates inward, approximately 14 bp on the DNA, allowing DNA-PK~cs~ to contact DNA \[[@B22]\]. The resulting DNA-PK holoenzyme (Ku/DNA-PKcs) has a serine/threonine protein kinase activity that is necessary for efficient repair \[[@B23]\]. A current model of NHEJ suggests that inward translocation of Ku allows DNA-PKcs molecules on opposing DSB ends to interact across the DSB and form a molecular "bridge" or synapse between the two DNA ends \[[@B24]\], and end-joining may then be completed by ligation of the DNA ends by DNA ligase IV/XRCC4/XLF complex \[[@B25]\]. Therefore, DNA-PK has important roles in NHEJ that include its DNA end-bridging activity \[[@B24]\], and its function in regulating DSB end processing enzymes, such as the structure-dependent nuclease Artemis \[[@B15]\] and its requirement for the stable recruitment of the DNA ligase IV/XRCC4 complex \[[@B26]\]. In support of this DNA-PK-dependent NHEJ model, previous studies have shown that DNA-PK binds XRCC4-ligase IV \[[@B26], [@B27]\], but not the other mammalian DNA ligases (I or III) *in vitro*\[[@B28]\]. It has also been shown that wortmannin, a chemical inhibitor of DNA-PK, \[[@B29]\] inhibits NHEJ \[[@B5]\] in a way similar to that seen in cells expressing kinase deficient DNA-PK~cs~ \[[@B23]\]. However, the role of DNA-PK kinase activity in NHEJ has not yet been fully understood. Although DNA-PK~cs~ binds to Ku at DNA DSB sites, disruption of these DNA-PK complexes by autophosphorylation \[[@B30], [@B31]\] is required for subsequent ligation of the DNA ends \[[@B32], [@B33]\]. It has been established that DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) undergoes a series of autophosphorylation events that facilitate successful completion of nonhomologous end joining \[[@B32]\]. DNA-PK~cs~ is phosphorylated at multiple sites *in vivo*in response to DNA damage, including serine 2056 \[[@B34]\], a cluster of sites between residues 2609--2647 (referred to as the ABCDE or Thr-2609 cluster), and threonine 3950 \[[@B35]\]. Although DNA-PK~cs~ in which the ABCDE sites have been mutated to alanine has normal protein kinase activity, its ability to dissociate from the Ku-DNA complex is reduced *in vitro* \[[@B36]\] and *in vivo* \[[@B37]\], suggesting that phosphorylation of the ABCDE sites plays a major role in regulating disassembly of the initial DNA-PK complex. DNA-PK also phosphorylates the Ku subunits \[[@B38]\] and XRCC4 \[[@B39]\], but mutation of these phosphorylation sites does not inhibit NHEJ \[[@B26], [@B40]\]. It has been suggested that activation of the kinase may be required for mobilization of the DNA ligase IV/XRCC4 complex \[[@B41]\], but the mechanism for mobilization is unknown. It has also been suggested that phosphorylation of histone H1 by DNA-PK, which reduces the affinity of the histone for DNA is required for NHEJ \[[@B42]\]. Alternatively, it has also been proposed that DNA-PK~cs~ stimulates, but is not essential to, NHEJ \[[@B10], [@B18]\]. Recent studies have revealed the overall structural architecture of DNA-PK~cs~ and Ku with DNA under conditions that mimic DSBs and DNA-PK~cs~ autophosphorylation \[[@B43]\]. The results indicate that efficient association and dissociation of the DNA-PK~cs~ at DSBs is regulated by Ku and DNA-PK~cs~ autophosphorylation that induces dramatic conformational changes in the protein. Recently, a three-dimensional crystal structure of purified DNA-PK~cs~ in complex with C-terminal fragments of Ku80 has been determined and reveals irregular regions of repetitive structures (*α*-helical HEAT repeats) that might provide a flexible cradle to promote DNA DSB repair \[[@B44]\]. Conceivably, individual phosphorylation events have different effects on DNA-PK~cs~ structure and function, both *in vitro*and *in vivo*, which in turn influences the assembly and disassembly of the initial NHEJ complex that regulates the accessibility of the DSB to other repair factors as well as pathway progression \[[@B3], [@B33], [@B45]\]. The DNA-PK dependent pathway could thus be characterized as the principle NHEJ pathway that employs the products of DNA-PK~cs~, Ku70/80, DNA ligase IV, XRCC4, XLF, and Artemis. Defects in the components of this pathway have been implicated in genomic instability and development of cancer \[[@B46], [@B47]\]. The possibility however of the presence of alternative pathways for NHEJ was suggested by early experiments in which cells deficient in DNA-PK~cs~, Ku, DNA ligase IV, or XRCC4 showed a high potential of end joining with preferential use of microhomologies \[[@B48]\]. The presence of at least one alternate pathway was first indicated by the observation that DNA-PK mutant MO59J cells, which do not express DNA-PK~cs~, retain the ability to repair DNA DSBs \[[@B8]\] and exhibit wild-type end-joining activity *in vitro* \[[@B49]\], suggesting the involvement of a DNA-PK-independent end-joining pathway in these cells. At least two NHEJ mechanisms have also been identified in cells with DNA-PK~cs~  *in vivo*: an immediate, high-fidelity end joining that occurs within two hours, followed by an error-prone DSB repair with slower kinetics \[[@B49], [@B50]\]. A study of cell lines with and without DNA-PK~cs~, M059K, and M059J, respectively, suggests that the first, faster NHEJ pathway is DNA-PK~cs~-dependent and the second, slower NHEJ pathway is DNA-PK~cs~-independent \[[@B51], [@B52]\]. DNA-PK-dependent and -independent repair has also been indicated *in vivo* as a function of cell cycle \[[@B53]\]. Recent studies have confirmed the operation of alternative pathways of NHEJ in the absence of the DNA-PK/LigIV/XRCC4 complex, in which another ligase partially substitutes for DNA ligase IV \[[@B54], [@B55]\]. Although Pol*β*, XRCC1, PARP-1, and DNA ligase III contribute predominantly to base excision repair (BER) and SSB repair \[[@B56]\], these proteins are also considered to be candidate components for backup pathways for NHEJ in which ligase III provides the major ligation activity \[[@B57], [@B58]\]. Indeed, PARP-1 has been shown to compete with Ku for repair of DNA double-strand breaks but apparently through distinct NHEJ pathways \[[@B59]\]. These backup pathways are not typically detectable in the presence of DNA-PK~cs~, suggesting that the binding of the protein to the DNA inhibits DNA-PK-independent NHEJ \[[@B49], [@B54]\]. A more recent work has identified histone H1 as an additional putative factor that operates preferentially within these backup pathways \[[@B61]\]. Although there is a significant evidence *in vivo* and *in vitro* of a DNA-PK~cs~-independent NHEJ pathway, this DNA end-joining mechanism has only been reported *in vitro* in the absence of the kinase subunit due to the apparent inhibition of alternate pathways by DNA-PK~cs~ \[[@B54]\]. In this study, we have identified *in vitro* reaction conditions that optimize the repair of DNA DSBs via a DNA-PK-independent pathway in the presence of functional DNA-PK~cs~. We also evaluated DSB end-joining efficiency and DNA-PK activity in extracts treated with wortmannin, which is a potent and selective inhibitor of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinases (PI3K) as well as the PI3K-like DNA-PK and has a pronounced effect on DNA DSB repair \[[@B62], [@B63]\]. Under these same conditions, we have found that DNA-PK is active in the absence of wortmannin and inhibited in the presence of wortmannin but that inhibition of DNA-PK\'s kinase activity does not inhibit NHEJ. Results also confirm that under reaction conditions that favor DNA-PK-dependent NHEJ, wortmannin completely inhibits DNA end joining. We have found that the individual activities of the two NHEJ repair pathways are differentially affected by reaction conditions. Furthermore, as evidenced in earlier studies \[[@B49], [@B50]\], we have observed decreased DSB repair fidelity under reaction conditions that favor DNA-PK-independent NHEJ. 2. Materials and Methods {#sec2} ======================== 2.1. Materials {#sec2.1} -------------- T4 DNA ligase (10 U/*μ*L) was purchased from Invitrogen (Carlsbad, CA.). Wortmannin was from Sigma (St. Louis, MO). Restriction enzymes were from New England BioLabs (Beverly, MA). Vistra Green was obtained from Amersham Biosciences (Piscataway, NJ). Antibodies to Ku80, XRCC4, GAPDH, PARP-1, histone H1 (Ig*G*~2*a*~), DNA-PK~cs~, and ATM were purchased from Abcam, Inc. (Cambridge, MA). Antibodies to DNA ligase I, Mre11, Rad50, and NBS1 were from GeneTex, Inc. (San Antonio, TX). Antibodies to DNA ligase III were from Novus Biologicals (Littleton, CO). All antibodies were of isotype Ig*G*~1~ except where noted. The DNA-PK peptide substrate was purchased from Promega (Madison, WI). Plasmid pSP189 was a gift from Dr. Michael Seidman (National Institute of Aging, Baltimore, MD). 2.2. Cellular Extraction {#sec2.2} ------------------------ Unless otherwise indicated, cervical cancer (HeLa) cells, fibroblast (WI-38) cells, and malignant glioma (M059K) cells (8 × 10^7^ cells/mL) were extracted by triplicate rounds of freezing and thawing in B1 lysis buffer (10 mM HEPES pH 7.9, 60 mM KCl, 1 mM EDTA pH 8.0, 1 mM DTT, and 1 mM PMSF). Lysates were cleared by centrifugation at 16,000 × *g* for 30 min at 4°C and the supernatants constituting the WCEs were stored as aliquots at −80°C. 2.3. DSB End-Joining Assays {#sec2.3} --------------------------- Reactions (50 *μ*L; 50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.6, 5 mM MgCl~2~, 1 mM DTT, 1 *μ*g/mL aprotinin, 1 *μ*g/mL leupeptin, 10 *μ*g/mL bestatin, 1 mM pefabloc, 1 mM ATP, 100 ng StuI-cut pSP189 plasmid DNA unless otherwise indicated, and with or without 5% (w/v) polyethylene glycol, MW \~8 kDa, ((PEG) also where indicated) were initiated with the addition of 15 *μ*g WCE. Reactions were incubated at 30°C for the times indicated. Experiments with wortmannin were prepared and incubated on ice for 10 min before heating to 30°C. All reactions were stopped with the addition of SDS (0.4%) and incubation at 65°C for 15 min. DNA was recovered by phenol: chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation, separated on 1% agarose gels, and stained with Vistra Green for 1 hr. Images were digitized with a FluorImager 595 system and quantified densitometrically using GelPro v2.0 software (Media Cybernetics, Gaithersburg, MD). DSB repair fidelity experiments employed a modification of the end-joining assay described above. Repair fidelity was measured as a function of restriction enzyme recleavage efficiency for the end-joined DNA products recovered from the assay described above. Standard end-joining reactions were run with pSP189 DNA linearized with StuI, EcoRI, PvuI, or Hin1I (producing blunt, 4 nucleotide 5′-overhang, 2 nucleotide 5′-overhang, or 2 nucleotide 3′-overhang DSB ends, respectively). DNA recovered from these reactions in the ethanol precipitation step was redissolved in 20 *μ*L of the appropriate manufacturer\'s restriction enzyme reaction buffer and split into two 10 *μ*L aliquots. One aliquot was incubated at 37°C for 2 h with 2.5 U of the restriction enzyme originally used to linearize the plasmid. Following this redigestion step, both aliquots were electrophoresed and analyzed as described above for the end-joining assay. All DSB repair fidelity reactions were run in triplicate. 2.4. Kinase Assays {#sec2.4} ------------------ Kinase activity was assayed under the same conditions as DNA end joining, except for the addition of 5 *μ*g peptide substrate (EPPLSQEAFADLWKK) and 0.2 *μ*Ci \[*γ*-^32^*P*\] ATP. Reactions were incubated at 30°C for 10 min then quenched as described for the end-joining assay. The peptide substrate was isolated on 16% Tris-Tricine SDS PAGE gels and analyzed by autoradiography. 2.5. Immunodepletions {#sec2.5} --------------------- WCE (700 *μ*g) was incubated with antibody (70 *μ*g) for 1 hr on ice. Antibody-bound protein was removed by adding either Sepharose A or G in binding buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.6; 0.1 mg/mL BSA), and rotating for 1 hr at 4°C. Unbound proteins were recovered by filtration through a 0.22 *μ*m cellulose acetate membrane and stored at --80°C. Target protein depletion was confirmed by western blot, following 4--12% Tris-Glycine SDS gradient PAGE. Immunodepletion of DNA ligase IV was performed using antibodies to XRCC4 due to the lack of ligase IV-specific antibodies. It has been reported that only trace ligase IV is found unbound to XRCC4 due to the instability of free DNA ligase IV \[[@B64]\]. In our hands, immunodepletion of XRCC4 resulted in nearly complete removal of the ligase. 3. Results and Discussion {#sec3} ========================= 3.1. Determination of Preferential Reaction Conditions for DNA-PK-Dependent, and DNA-PK-Independent Nonhomologous End-Joining Pathways {#sec3.1} -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In previous studies, both DNA-PK dependent and independent NHEJ pathways have been observed *in vivo* \[[@B5], [@B49]--[@B51], [@B58]\], however, no *in vitro* reaction conditions in the presence of a functional DNA-PK~cs~ protein have been reported to date that favor DNA-PK-independent DNA end joining. Several studies have noted the role of polymers such as PEG in stabilizing and enhancing the binding of proteins to the DNA through a macromolecular crowding effect \[[@B65]\]. Earlier works had shown that in the presence of high concentrations of macromolecules such as PEG, T4 DNA ligase as well as DNA ligase preparations from rat liver nuclei or from Escherichia coli actively catalyze blunt end ligations, in contrast to the poor activity of these enzymes on such substrates under conventional assay conditions \[[@B66]\]. These and other studies have argued that such macromolecular crowding or confinement may perhaps play a more essential role in cell biology and physiology than otherwise noted and could well be a more adequate model for intracellular, *in vivo* conditions \[[@B67]\]. We observe that, in the presence of 5% polyethylene glycol (PEG), DNA end joining is insensitive to wortmannin, a potent and selective inhibitor of DNA-PK \[[@B29]\] that covalently binds to the protein. Whole cell extracts (WCE) from HeLa, WI-38, and M059K cells were assayed for DNA end-joining activity with and without 5% PEG and 10 *μ*M wortmannin. The WCEs were assayed for the ability to end-join blunt-end *Stu*I-cut plasmid DNA (which we have previously shown to be NHEJ-dependent \[[@B68]\]) and produce plasmid dimers and trimers that were detected on agarose gels stained with Vistra Green ([Figure 1(a)](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). After 2 hrs at 30°C in the absence of PEG, the WCEs generated 5 to 25% product, depending on cell type ([Figure 1(b)](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). The same reactions run with 10 *μ*M wortmannin reduced the total amount of product to between 0 to 4%, also depending on cell type. The assay was repeated in the presence of 5% PEG, resulting in 12 to 24% product in the absence of wortmannin. For HeLa and WI-38 WCEs, product yield increased up to 2-fold with the addition of PEG, while addition of 10 *μ*M wortmannin resulted in little or no decrease in product. However, an approximately 60% decrease in product was observed with M059K WCE in the presence of PEG and wortmannin, which though significantly less than the wortmannin inhibition observed with this extract in reactions without PEG still indicated that a fraction of the NHEJ was wortmannin-sensitive even in the presence of PEG. It could be argued that a residual amount of the end-joined product is due to DNA-PK-dependent NHEJ or that alternatively, DNA-PK~cs~ may be playing a structural and/or stimulatory role in the organization of the initial NHEJ complex \[[@B43]\]. The end-joining reactions were repeated with HeLa WCE, 1% DMSO, and 0.1 to 10 *μ*M wortmannin in 1% DMSO ([Figure 2(a)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Complete inhibition of DNA end joining was observed in the absence of PEG with 1.5 *μ*M wortmannin. In contrast, in the presence of 5% PEG, only a 15 to 20% reduction in product was observed with 1.5 *μ*M wortmannin. No further inhibition was observed with up to 10 *μ*M wortmannin. To determine the effective concentration of PEG required to favor wortmannin-insensitive NHEJ, the DNA end-joining assay was repeated for 1 hr at 30°C with 0 to 5% PEG with and without 10 *μ*M wortmannin ([Figure 2(b)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In the absence of wortmannin, a steady increase in product formation was observed with the addition of up to 4% PEG, after which, a trend towards a small decrease in product formation was observed. Conversely, in the presence of wortmannin, a minimum of 3% PEG was required for the generation of end-joined product and at 5% PEG, little or no wortmannin inhibition was observed. Presumably, at a concentration of 5% PEG, the product is being formed by a wortmannin-insensitive, DNA-PK-independent NHEJ pathway. It has been reported previously that blunt-ended DNA activates DNA-PK less efficiently than DNA DSBs with 3′- or 5′-overhangs \[[@B69]\]. Therefore, we wished to confirm DNA-PK activity under our end-joining reaction conditions in the absence of PEG and wortmannin and also determine whether the loss of wortmannin sensitivity in the presence of PEG was due to the operation of a DNA-PK-independent pathway or simply due to the inability of wortmannin to inhibit DNA-PK in the presence of PEG. DNA-PK kinase activity was assayed under the same reaction conditions as those used for the end-joining assays ([Figure 2(c)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Reactions were prepared in the same manner as the DNA end-joining reactions, but with the addition of 5 *μ*g of a peptide DNA-PK-phosphorylation substrate and \[*γ*-^32^P\] ATP. The reactions were prepared with and without DNA, 5% PEG, and 10 *μ*M wortmannin, and incubated at 30°C for 5 minutes. As is typical with the peptide substrate-based DNA-PK activity assay, nonspecific background kinase activity is observed for samples in the absence of added activator DNA, regardless of the presence or absence of PEG. A 2.5- to 3-fold DNA-dependent increase in kinase activity was observed following addition of the blunt-ended end-joining substrate DNA, and no difference in activity was observed between reactions with and without PEG. The addition of 10 *μ*M wortmannin inhibited all detectable kinase activity in both reactions, indicating that the PEG did not affect the ability of wortmannin to inhibit DNA-PK kinase activity. Therefore, PEG did not inhibit DNA binding, kinase activation, or wortmannin-mediated inhibition of DNA-PK. Consequently, even though DNA-PK kinase is active in the presence of PEG, DNA end joining seems to be independent of this kinase activity, since addition of 10 *μ*M wortmannin, which completely inhibits kinase activity, does not inhibit NHEJ in the presence of PEG. Thus, in the presence of 5% PEG, *in vitro* reaction conditions are established in which the NHEJ proceeds via a DNA-PK-independent pathway or at least one that is independent of the kinase activity of DNA-PK. This result argues for a much broader role for DNA-PK in the context of the structural architecture of the initial NHEJ complex in addition to the role it plays in catalyzing phosphorylation of several other repair proteins \[[@B43], [@B44]\]. 3.2. Survey of Proteins Involved in DNA-PK-Dependent and -Independent Nonhomologous End Joining {#sec3.2} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- We wished to determine the contribution of individual proteins to either of the two NHEJ pathways. To this end, a variety of proteins were individually immunodepleted from the HeLa WCE and DNA end-joining assays were conducted (with and without 5% PEG) to detect depletion-dependent reductions in end-joining activity ([Figure 3](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). Immunodepletion of Ku80 and DNA ligase IV resulted in an almost complete loss of DNA end-joining efficiency for reactions both in the presence or absence of 5% PEG. This supports our earlier observations \[[@B70]\] and indicates the indispensable role that Ku plays in the initial recognition and binding of DSB ends and that of ligase IV in the final ligation step of the NHEJ process. Immunodepletion of NBS1 and histone H1 resulted in a significant loss of DNA-PK-dependent DNA end-joining activity in reactions without PEG ([Figure 3(a)](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). In comparison, in reactions with 5% PEG, only a minimal loss of presumed DNA-PK-independent activity was observed with immunodepletion of NBS1 and histone H1 ([Figure 3(b)](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). This is an interesting result in the context of the supposed stimulatory role of NBS1 and histone H1 in the backup pathways of NHEJ, where histone H1 enhances the activity of both DNA ligase III and PARP-1 \[[@B61]\]. Immunodepletion of DNA-PK~cs~ resulted in a 30% reduction in the efficiency of the end-joining reactions without PEG, with little reduction observed in the presence of PEG. In addition, immunodepletion of Poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase 1 (PARP) and DNA ligase III consistently resulted in a trend toward increased efficiency for both the presumed DNA-PK-dependent and -independent NHEJ over the course of multiple experiments. This observation suggests the operation of backup pathways under these conditions and supports the hypothesis that these proteins may compete for repair at the DSB ends through alternate NHEJ pathways \[[@B58], [@B59]\]. Perrault et al. reported that DNA-PK independent DNA end joining is observed after immunodepletion of DNA-PK~cs~ \[[@B54]\]. To confirm that the DNA end joining observed after immunodepletion of DNA-PK~cs~ is actually DNA-PK-independent, the immunodepleted extract was assayed for activity with and without 10 *μ*M wortmannin ([Figure 3(c)](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). End joining by the WCE was inhibited in the presence of 10 *μ*M wortmannin; whereas the DNA end-joining activity of the DNA-PK~cs~ immunodepleted extract was wortmannin-insensitive, indicating that a DNA-PK-independent process formed the product. From an examination of the immunodepletion data, only Ku and ligase IV-XRCC4 complex could be specifically identified as participating in the DNA-PK-independent NHEJ in this system, while Ku, DNA-PK~cs~, ligase IV-XRCC4, NBS1, and histone H1 are implicated in the DNA-PK-dependent NHEJ. These results support a previous model proposed by Riballo et al., in which one pathway consists of Ku and ligase IV-XRCC4 that can be stimulated by DNA-PK~cs~, and a second, DNA-PK~cs~-dependent pathway that requires NBS1 \[[@B18]\]. 3.3. The In Vitro DNA-PK-Dependent and -Independent Nonhomologous End-Joining Pathways Exhibit Different Optimal Reaction Conditions {#sec3.3} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Several groups have reported *in vitro* assays for DNA DSB repair but reaction conditions differ considerably. To investigate if reaction conditions could be established for the end-joining assay that favor one pathway over the other, we tested the DNA end-joining activity of HeLa WCE with and without 5% PEG under a variety of reaction conditions. Two separate buffers were used. Buffer A is composed of 50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.6, and 75 mM KOAc along with 5 mM MgCl~2~, 1 mM DTT, and a protease inhibitor cocktail. Buffer B includes bis-tris-propane, pH 8.2, and 75 mM KCl with 5 mM MgCl~2~, 1 mM DTT, and a protease inhibitor cocktail as before (see Materials and Methods for details). DSB end joining with HeLa WCE under these two conditions were measured over time with and without 5% PEG. In the absence of PEG, buffer A produced a small but consistently higher yield of DNA end-joining products over time compared to reactions in buffer B, and under both conditions, a linear increase in product was generated during the first 5 hours (data not shown). With PEG, an increase in end joining was observed with buffer B compared to buffer A ([Figure 4(a)](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). However, under both conditions, product formation appeared to plateau after about 3 hours. Buffer A therefore, seemed to provide the most optimal reaction conditions for the DNA-PK-dependent (without PEG) end-joining whereas Buffer B seemed to provide the same for the DNA-PK-independent (with PEG) end-joining pathway in our system. This observation was also reported by Ramsden et al., who demonstrated a modest increase in Ku-dependent ligation of DNA lacking DNA-PK~cs~ on increasing the concentration of KCl from 25 mM to 120 mM \[[@B71]\]. High concentrations of chloride have been reported earlier to reduce protein-DNA interactions \[[@B72], [@B73]\]. Of the NHEJ proteins, only Ku can bind directly to DNA in 75 mM KCl \[[@B74]\]. However, since both the NHEJ-dependent and -independent pathways utilize Ku, a reduction in the number of nonspecific protein-DNA interactions competing with Ku for the DNA ends should enhance both NHEJ pathways. However, high-chloride concentrations can also inhibit protein-protein interactions and have indeed been shown to inhibit DNA-PK holoenzyme formation \[[@B73], [@B75]\]. Variable concentrations of the divalent cations Mg^2+^ and Mn^2+^ were also examined for their effect on DNA end-joining activity. Increasing MgCl~2~ concentration from its optimum at 5 mM, up to a final concentration of 10 mM (by steps of 1, 2, and 5 mM additions of MgCl~2~) had little effect on DNA end-joining activity with or without PEG (data not shown). Addition of up to 5 mM MnCl~2~ in addition to the 5 mM MgCl~2~ already in the standard reaction buffers, increased DNA-PK-dependent end-joining activity (without PEG) and reduced DNA-PK-independent end joining (with PEG) (as shown in [Figure 4(b)](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). To further study the effect of manganese on DNA end joining, various concentrations of MnCl~2~ were added to reactions with 5% PEG and 10 *μ*M wortmannin ([Figure 4(c)](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). As observed previously in the absence of MnCl~2~ and presence of PEG, a small decrease in DNA end-joining activity occurred with the addition of 10 *μ*M wortmannin. Without wortmannin, DNA end-joining activity was reduced at low MnCl~2~ concentrations but partially recovered with the addition of 0.5 to 1 mM MnCl~2~. This recovery in activity, however, was inhibited by wortmannin, indicating that even in the presence of 5% PEG, a small fraction of the observed DNA end-joining activity results from the DNA-PK-dependent pathway or at least one that is dependent on the DNA-PK kinase activity. Furthermore, the addition of MnCl~2~ increases the activity of this wortmannin-sensitive pathway. Previous studies have shown that one factor that could alter the relative influence of a particular end-joining pathway in the reaction is the concentration of divalent cations, particularly Mg^2+^ and Mn^2+^ \[[@B76]\]. We observe that the DNA-PK-dependent NHEJ activity present in our system is sensitive to the reaction concentration of Mg^2+^ and particularly, Mn^2+^. Elevated concentrations of these divalent cations stimulate overall end-joining activity and mask the requirement for DNA-PK, suggesting the involvement of a DNA-PK-independent NHEJ pathway. Thus, the relative contribution of a particular pathway to the overall end-joining activity observed in WCEs seems to depend on, and in turn reflect, the *in vitro*reaction conditions used. Taken as a whole, differential reaction buffer preference and variable responses to divalent cations observed in this study emphasize the existence of distinct biochemical differences between the DNA-PK-independent and -dependent NHEJ activities observed in the presence and absence of PEG, respectively. 3.4. Functional Changes Are Associated with DNA-PK-Dependent and -Independent Reaction Conditions {#sec3.4} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Previous studies have suggested that DNA-PK-dependent and -independent repair pathways may be functionally distinct, possibly preferentially interacting with certain subclasses of DNA DSBs and/or having different DSB repair fidelity \[[@B18], [@B49]--[@B51], [@B58]\]. We therefore chose to investigate DSB repair fidelity under our DNA-PK-dependent and -independent reaction conditions. To test DSB repair fidelity, the ability of the HeLa WCE to accurately end-join DSBs with various DSB-end overhang configurations was determined. Standard DNA end joining assays run both with and without 5% PEG were conducted using substrate plasmid DNA that had been linearized by restriction digestion with, StuI (blunt ends), EcoRI (4 nucleotide 5′-overhang), Hin1I (2 nucleotide 5′-overhang), or PvuI (2 nucleotide 3′-overhang). The products of these end-joining reactions were then subjected to redigestion with their corresponding restriction enzyme ([Figure 5](#fig5){ref-type="fig"}). Accurate DSB end-joining restores the enzyme recognition sequence at the end-joining junction sites, resulting in product DNA that is susceptible to recutting with the restriction enzyme originally used to linearize the plasmid. DSB repair fidelity is defined as the frequency with which the DNA end-joining assays accurately join DSB ends, and is reported here as the percent of total end-joined product DNA cleaved following redigestion with the appropriate restriction enzyme. As shown in [Figure 5](#fig5){ref-type="fig"}, substantial functional differences were detected between DSB repair reactions catalyzed by the DNA-PK-dependent and -independent NHEJ pathways. End joining under DNA-PK-dependent reaction conditions (without PEG) resulted in substantially higher DSB repair fidelity than reactions (with PEG) favoring the DNA-PK-independent end-joining pathway, and these results are consistent with the pathway-dependent DSB repair fidelity reported by others \[[@B51]\]. 4. Conclusion {#sec4} ============= In summary, we have demonstrated *in vitro* assay conditions that permit coincident and differential analysis of DNA-PK-dependent and -independent NHEJ activities under conditions in which functional DNA-PK~cs~ is present. Establishing and defining these reaction conditions facilitates biochemical analysis of these important subpathways of NHEJ regardless of the cellular source of enzyme activities, and irrespective of intrinsic DNA-PK~cs~ expression status. We found that reactions containing 5% PEG favored DNA-PK-independent NHEJ while reactions lacking PEG favored DNA-PK-dependent NHEJ. The biochemically distinct nature of the pathways represented by these two reaction conditions is borne out by the differential end-joining activity observed in response to the DNA-PK inhibitor wortmannin, immunodepletion of individual proteins that may participate in NHEJ, and the pathway specific responses to divalent cations, and reaction buffer composition. In addition to these results that indicate the biochemically distinct nature of the end-joining mechanisms represented by the DNA-PK-dependent and -independent NHEJ assays, we also observe functional differences between the two pathways. We find that DNA-PK-dependent DSB end joining is a higher fidelity process than DNA-PK-independent end joining. This latter finding is consistent with*in vivo* results reported by others using cell lines that lack expression of DNA-PK~cs~ \[[@B51], [@B52], [@B54]\], or following depletion of DNA-PK~cs~ from extracts of cells that do express the protein \[[@B54]\]. *In vitro* end joining of restriction enzyme-cut plasmid DNA is routinely reported as a measure of NHEJ activity, yet these reports are often conflicting with respect to what enzymes are involved in the repair of DNA DSBs. Our results indicate that multiple pathways may simultaneously contribute to the production of linear plasmid multimers *in vitro*. Consequently, the ability to selectively shift the mechanism of product formation by altering reaction conditions not only suggests the need for care when evaluating data obtained by the wide variety of *in vitro* DSB repair assays currently in use, but also provides a means by which greater control may be achieved over the repair mechanism through which this end point is reached. Application of the reaction conditions described in this report may permit concurrent investigations of the relative contributions of DNA-PK-dependent and -independent NHEJ pathways to DSB repair in any mammalian cell. This approach could be helpful in identifying proteins involved in the DNA-PK-dependent and -independent NHEJ DSB repair subpathways, and characterizing their individual roles in these multiprotein repair complexes. Information such as this is likely to be useful in identifying new and more effective approaches for manipulating cellular DSB repair activity. This research was supported in part by the Intramural Research Program of the NIH, through the Warren Grant Magnuson Clinical Center. DSB: : Double-strand break. DNA-PK: : DNA-protein kinase. DNA-PK~cs~: : DNA-protein kinase catalytic subunit. NHEJ: : nonhomologous end joining. DMSO: : dimethylsulfoxide. PEG: : polyethylene glycol. WCE: : whole cell extract. {#fig1} ![DNA end-joining activity and DNA-PK activity responses in PEG and/or wortmannin. (a) Wortmannin dose response. DNA end-joining reactions were run using HeLa WCE under standard conditions with or without 5% PEG and wortmannin for 1 hr at 30°C. Reactions contained 0 to 10 *μ*M wortmannin in 1% DMSO. Error bars indicate the standard deviation for triplicate reactions. (b) PEG dependence of wortmannin sensitivity. DNA end-joining reactions were run in triplicate with and without 10 *μ*M wortmannin at 0--5% PEG. (c) DNA-PK kinase activity under DNA end-joining reaction conditions in the presence and absence of PEG. Standard DNA end-joining reactions were run with HeLa WCE for 10 min at 30°C in the presence of a DNA-PK peptide substrate and \[*γ*-^32^P\] ATP. The peptide was isolated on a 16% PAGE gel and the intensity of the radiolabeled band, a measure of DNA-PK kinase activity, was detected by autoradiography. The presence or absence of 5% PEG during the end-joining reaction did not affect DNA-PK kinase activity, nor did it affect the ability of wortmannin to inhibit DNA-PK kinase activity. The mean activity of duplicate reactions is plotted.](JNA2010-823917.002){#fig2} {#fig3} {#fig4} {#fig5} [^1]: Academic Editor: Ashis Basu

\partial{\partial} \def\frac{\part}{\part x}{\frac{\partial}{\partial x}} \def\frac{\part}{\part t}{\frac{\partial}{\partial t}} \def\frac{d}{dt}{\frac{d}{dt}} \def{\widehat u}{{\widehat u}} \def\buildrul#1\under#2{\mathrel{\mathop{\null#2}\limits_{#1}}} \def\frac{1}{2}{\frac{1}{2}} \def\frac{3}{2}{\frac{3}{2}} \def\varepsilon{\varepsilon} \def\overline{u}{\overline{u}} \def\mathbf x{{\mathbf x}} \def\nabla_{\bx}{\nabla_{\mathbf x}} \def{x_1}{{x_1}} \def{x_2}{{x_2}} \def\pil{0} \def\pir{2\pi} \def\tpi{2\pi} \defu_N{u_N} \def\um{u_m} \def{\mathbf u}{{\mathbf u}} \def{\mathbf v}{{\mathbf v}} \def{\mathbf w}{{\mathbf w}} \def{\mathbf u}_N{{\mathbf u}_N} \def{{\mathbf u}_m}{{{\mathbf u}_m}} \def\wN{u_N} \def\mathbf x{\mathbf x} \def\mathbf k{\mathbf k} \def\boldsymbol\ell} %{\mathbf l{\boldsymbol\ell} \def\mathbf p{\mathbf p} \def\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}{\boldsymbol\nu} \def\cdot{\cdot} \def{\mathbb T}^d{{\mathbb T}^d} \def(\tpi)^d{(\tpi)^d} \def\frac{d}{2}{\frac{d}{2}} \def\quad \rule{.1in}{.1in}{\quad \rule{.1in}{.1in}} \def\Bbb{I}{\Bbb{I}} \defu^h{u^h} \def\ell{\ell} \def\frac{2}{3}{\frac{2}{3}} \newcommand* {\Lr} {{\mathbb P}} \def\partial{\partial} \newcommand{\Bbb{R}}{\Bbb{R}} \newcommand{\myr}[1]{\textcolor{red}{#1}} \newcommand{\myb}[1]{\textcolor{blue}{#1}} \newcommand{\Eitan}[1]{[\,{\bf Eitan:} \textcolor{red}{#1.}]} \newcommand{\Claude}[1]{[\,{\bf Claude:} {\textcolor{blue}{#1.}}]} \newtheorem{exm}{Example}[section] \newtheorem{thm}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{lem}[thm]{Lemma} \newtheorem{cor}[thm]{Corollary} \newtheorem{prop}[thm]{Proposition} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{defn}{Definition}[section] \theoremstyle{remark} \newtheorem{rem}[thm]{Remark} \newtheorem{rems}[thm]{Remarks} \newtheorem{example}[exm]{Example} \renewcommand{\theequation}{\thesection.\arabic{equation}} \setcounter{tocdepth}{1} \newcommand{\thmref}[1]{Theorem~\ref{#1}} \newcommand{\secref}[1]{\S\ref{#1}} \newcommand{\lemref}[1]{Lemma~\ref{#1}} \numberwithin{equation}{section} \renewcommand{\theequation}{\arabic{section}.\arabic{equation}} \renewcommand{\thefigure}{\thesection.\arabic{figure}} \newcounter{asnr} \newenvironment{Assumptions} % {\ifnum\value{asnr}=0 \stepcounter{asnr} \begin{enumerate}[label=\textbf{A}.\arabic{enumi}] \else \begin{enumerate}[label=\textbf{A}.\arabic{enumi},resume] \fi} {\end{enumerate}} \begin{document} \title[On the stability and instabilities of the Fourier method]{Stability and spectral convergence of\\Fourier method for nonlinear problems:\\On the shortcomings of the $2/3$ de-aliasing method} \author[C. Bardos]{Claude Bardos}\address[Claude Bardos]{ \newline University of Paris 7- Denis Diderot \newline Laboratory Jacques Louis Lions, University of Paris 6 \newline Paris, France} \email[]{claude.bardos@gmail.com} \author[E. Tadmor]{Eitan Tadmor}\address[Eitan Tadmor]{ \newline Department of Mathematics \newline Center of Scientific Computation and Mathematical Modeling (CSCAMM) \newline Institute for Physical sciences and Technology (IPST) \newline University of Maryland \newline MD 20742-4015, USA} \email[]{tadmor@cscamm.umd.edu} \date{\today} \subjclass{} \keywords{} \thanks{\textbf{Acknowledgment.} E. T. Research was supported in part by NSF grants DMS10-08397, RNMS11-07444 (KI-Net) and ONR grant \#N00014-1210318.} \begin{abstract} The high-order accuracy of Fourier method makes it the method of choice in many large scale simulations. We discuss here the stability of Fourier method for nonlinear evolution problems, focusing on the two prototypical cases of the inviscid Burgers' equation and the multi-dimensional incompressible Euler equations. The Fourier method for such problems with quadratic nonlinearities comes in two main flavors. One is the spectral Fourier method. The other is the $2/3$ pseudo-spectral Fourier method, where one removes the highest $1/3$ portion of the spectrum; this is often the method of choice to maintain the balance of quadratic energy and avoid aliasing errors.\newline Two main themes are discussed in this paper. First, we prove that as long as the underlying exact solution has a minimal $C^{1+\alpha}$ spatial regularity, then both the spectral and the $2/3$ pseudo-spectral Fourier methods are stable. Consequently, we prove their spectral convergence for smooth solutions of the inviscid Burgers equation and the incompressible Euler equations. On the other hand, we prove that after a critical time at which the underlying solution lacks sufficient smoothness, then both the spectral and the $2/3$ pseudo-spectral Fourier methods exhibit nonlinear instabilities which are realized through spurious oscillations. In particular, after shock formation in inviscid Burgers' equation, the total variation of bounded (pseudo-) spectral Fourier solutions \emph{must} increase with the number of increasing modes and we stipulate the analogous situation occurs with the 3D incompressible Euler equations: the limiting Fourier solution is shown to enforce $L^2$-energy conservation, and the contrast with energy dissipating Onsager solutions is reflected through spurious oscillations. \end{abstract} \maketitle \tableofcontents \section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} Spectral methods are often the methods of choice when high-resolution solvers are sought for nonlinear time-dependent problems. Here, we are concerned with the stability and convergence of Fourier method for PDEs with quadratic nonlinearities: we focus our attention on the prototypical Cauchy problems for the inviscid Burgers' equation and the incompressible Euler equations. The Fourier methods for problems involving quadratic nonlinearities come in two main flavors: the \emph{spectral Fourier method} and the 2/3 smoothing of \emph{pseudo-spectral Fourier method}. The spectral Fourier method is realized in terms of $N$-degree Fourier expansions, ${\mathbf u}_N(\mathbf x,t)=\mathop{\sum}_{|\mathbf k|\leq N} \widehat{{\mathbf u}}_{\mathbf k}(t)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}$, where $\widehat{{\mathbf u}}_{\mathbf k}(t)$ are the Fourier moments of ${\mathbf u}(\mathbf x,t)$ \[ \widehat{{\mathbf u}}_{\mathbf k}(t) = \frac{1}{(\tpi)^d}\int_{{\mathbb T}^d}\!\!{\mathbf u}(\mathbf x)e^{-i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}d\mathbf x, \quad \mathbf k :=(k_1,\ldots,k_d) \in {\mathbb Z}^d. \] The computation of these moments in nonlinear problems is carried out by convolutions. These can be avoided when the $\widehat{{\mathbf u}}_{\mathbf k}$'s are replaced by the discrete Fourier coefficients, sampled at the $(2N+1)^d$ equally spaced grid points \[ \widetilde{{\mathbf u}}_{\mathbf k}(t) = \left(\frac{1}{2N+1}\right)^d \sum_{\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}\in {\mathbb T}^d_\#} {\mathbf u}(\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}},t)e^{-i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}}, \qquad \mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}=\frac{\tpi\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}{2N+1}, \] where ${\mathbb T}^d_\#$ is the discrete torus, \[ {\mathbb T}^d_\#:=\left\{\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}\ \large| \ \mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}=\frac{\tpi\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}{2N+1}, \quad \boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}=(\nu_1,\ldots,\nu_d), \ 0\leq \nu_j\leq 2N\right\}. \] The pseudo-spectral Fourier method is realized in terms of the corresponding expansion, ${\mathbf u}_N(\mathbf x,t)=\sum_{|\mathbf k|\leq N} \widetilde{{\mathbf u}}_{\mathbf k}(t)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}$. Here, we have the advantage that nonlinearities are computed as exact pointwise quantities at the grid points $\{\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}\}_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}$, but new aliasing errors are introduced. To avoid aliasing errors and their potential instabilities, high mode smoothing is implemented, which results in the so-called $2/3$-smoothing of pseudo-spectral Fourier method: it is realized in terms of the $2N/3$-degree expansion, ${\mathbf u}_N(\mathbf x,t)=\sum_{|\mathbf k|\leq 2N/3} \sigma_{\mathbf k}\widetilde{{\mathbf u}}_{\mathbf k}(t)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}$. This is the spectral method of choice in many time-dependent problems with quadratic nonlinearities. To put our discussion into perspective we begin, in section \ref{sec:lin}, by recalling the linear setup of standard transport equation. The spectral Fourier method is $L^2$-stable. But the pseudo-spectral Fourier method is not \cite{GHT94}: it is only \emph{weakly} stable, due to amplification of aliasing errors when the underlying solution lacks sufficient smoothness. Strong $L^2$-stability is regained with the $2/3$-smoothing of pseudo-spectral Fourier method, \cite{Tad87}; in the linear setup, the de-aliasing in the $2/3$-method introduces sufficient smoothness to maintain convergence. This is one of the main two themes of our results on nonlinear problems: sufficient smoothness guarantees stability and hence spectral convergence. In section \ref{sec:burgers} we explore this issue in the context of inviscid Burgers equations, proving that as long as the solution of the inviscid Burgers equation remains smooth, $u(\cdot,t)\in C^{1+\alpha}_x$, then both the spectral and the $2/3$-pseudo-spectral Fourier approximations, $u_N(\cdot,t)$, converge to the exact solution. Moreover, they enjoy \emph{spectral convergence rate}, namely, the convergence rate grows with the increasing smoothness of $u(\cdot,t)$, \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\int |u_N(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx} \\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle \int_0^t\!\!\|u_x(\cdot,\tau)\|_{L^\infty}d\tau} \!\!\cdot \left(N^{-2s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s} + N^{\frac{3}{2}-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right)\!, \quad s>\frac{3}{2}. \end{eqnarray*} A similar statement of spectral convergence holds for the spectral and $2/3$ pseudo-spectral Fourier approximations ${\mathbf u}_N$ of the incompressible Euler equations: in section \ref{sec:smoothEuler} we prove that as long as ${\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)$ remains sufficiently smooth solution of the $d$-dimensional Euler equations, ${\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\in C^{1+\alpha}_x$, then \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2}} \\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle 2\!\int_0^t\!\!\|\nabla_{\bx}{\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)\|_{L^\infty}d\tau} \!\!\cdot \left(N^{-2s}\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s} + N^{\frac{d}{2}+1-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right)\!, \ s>\frac{d}{2}+1. \end{eqnarray*} These results support the superiority of spectral methods for problems with smooth solutions. When dealing with solutions which lack smoothness, however, both the spectral and $2/3$ pseudo-spectral Fourier methods suffer nonlinear instabilities. This is the other main theme of the paper, explored in the context of the inviscid Burgers equation and the incompressible Euler equations in the respective sections \ref{sec:2-3rd} and \ref{sec:nonsmoothEuler}. In particular, we prove that after shock formation, the spectral and $2/3$ pseudo-spectral bounded approximations of the inviscid Burgers solution \emph{must} produce spurious oscillations as their total variation must increase, $\|u_N(\cdot,t)\|_{TV} \gtrsim \sqrt[4]{N}$. This is deduced by contradiction: in theorem \ref{thm:instab} below we prove, using compensated compactness arguments, that an $L^2$-weak limit of slowly growing TV Fourier solutions, $\overline{u}=\text{w}\lim u_N$, must be an $L^2$-energy \emph{conservative} solution, which cannot hold once shocks are formed.\newline A similar scenario arises with the Euler solutions where the spectral and the ($2/3$ pseudo-)spectral approximations of Euler equations enforce conservation of the $L^2$-energy. Although there is no known energy dissipation-based selection principle to identify a unique solution of Euler equations within the class of ``rough" data (similar to the entropy dissipation selection principle for Burgers' equations), nevertheless we argue that the $L^2$-energy conservation of the (pseudo-)spectral approximations may be responsible to their unstable behavior. While $L^2$-energy conservation holds for weak solutions with a minimal degree of $1/3$-order of smoothness (Onsager's conjecture proved in \cite{Ey94,CET94,BT10}), there are experimental and numerical evidence for the other part of Onsager's conjecture that anomalous dissipation of energy shows up for ``physical-turbulent" $L^2$-solutions of Euler equations \cite{Co07}. Whether this observed anomalous dissipation of energy should be due to spontaneous appearance of singularities in smooth solutions of the Euler equation or to the fact that physical initial data may be rough is a completely open problem. However after several preliminary breakthrough \cite{Sc93} and \cite{Sh97} the following fact are now well established. Indeed, there are infinitely many initial data (which of course are not regular) leading to infinitely many weak Euler solutions with energy loss \cite{DeLS12}. In particular there are solutions which for almost every time belong to the critical regularity $C^{\frac13-\epsilon}$ \cite{Buck13}. Thus, if the numerical method captures such ``rough" solutions then the ``unphysical" conservation of energy which is enforced at the spectral level has to vanish at the limit, leading to spurious oscillations. We close this paper with two complementary results. The nonlinear instability results in sections \ref{sec:2-3rd} and \ref{sec:nonsmoothEuler} emphasize the competition between spectral convergence for smooth solutions vs. nonlinear instabilities for problems which lack sufficient smoothness. In section \ref{sec:sv} we discuss the class of \emph{spectral viscosity} (SV) methods which entertain both --- spectral convergence and nonlinear stability, \cite{Tad89,Tad93b, KK00,GP03,SS07,AX09}. This is achieved by adding a judicious amount of spectral viscosity at the high-portion of the spectrum without sacrificing the spectral accuracy at the lower portion of the spectrum. Finally, we note that the above stability and instability results are not necessarily restricted to quadratic nonlinearities: in section \ref{sec:isen} we prove the stability of Fourier method for smooth solutions of the nonlinear isentropic equations. \subsection{Spectral convergence}\label{sec:spec-convergence} Expressed in terms of the Fourier coefficients, $\widehat{w}(\mathbf k)$, the \emph{spectral} Fourier projection $\SN[w](\mathbf x)$ of $w\in L^1[{\mathbb T}^d]$ is given by \[ \SN[w](\mathbf x)=\sum_{|\mathbf k|\leq N}\widehat{w}(\mathbf k)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}, \qquad \widehat{w}(\mathbf k):=\frac{1}{(\tpi)^d}\int_{{\mathbb T}^d}\!\!w(\mathbf x)e^{-i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}d\mathbf x, \quad \mathbf k :=(k_1,\ldots,k_d) \in {\mathbb Z}^d. \] The convergence rate of the \emph{truncation error}, \begin{equation}\label{eq:tr} (I-\SN)[w]} %\TN[w](\mathbf x):=\sum_{|\mathbf k|\geq N}\widehat{w}(\mathbf k)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}, \end{equation} is as rapid as the global smoothness of $w$ permits (and observe that the degree of smoothness is allowed to be negative), \[ \|(I-\SN)[w]} %\TN[w]\|_{\dot{H}^r} \leq N^{r-s}\|w\|_{\dot{H}^s}, \qquad s>r \in {\mathbb R}; \] in particular, \begin{equation}\label{eq:maxHs} \max_\mathbf x|(I-\SN)[w](\mathbf x)| \lesssim N^{\frac{d}{2}-s}\|w\|_{H^s}, \qquad s>\frac{d}{2}. \end{equation} These are statements of \emph{spectral convergence} rate: the smoother $w$ is, the faster is the convergence rate of $(I-\SN)[w]} %\TN[w] \rightarrow 0$. In practice, one recovers exponential convergence which characterizes analytic regularity or at least root-exponential rate for typical compactly supported Gevrey-regular data, \cite{Tad07}. \subsection{Aliasing}\label{sec:aliasing} Set $h:=\frac{\tpi}{2N+1}$ as a discrete spacing. If we replace the integrals with quadrature based on sampling $w$ at the $(2N+!)^d$equi-spaced points, $\displaystyle \mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}:=\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu} h, \ \boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}:=(\nu_1,\ldots,\nu_d)\in \{0,2N\}^d$, we obtain the \emph{pseudo-spectral} Fourier projection, \[ \IN[w](\mathbf x)=\sum_{|\mathbf k|\leq N}\widetilde{w}(\mathbf k)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}, \qquad \widetilde{w}(\mathbf k):=\left(\frac{h}{\tpi}\right)^{\!\!d}\sum_{\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}} \in {\mathbb T}^d_\#}w(\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}})e^{-i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}}, \quad |\mathbf k| \leq N. \] Here, $\widetilde{w}(\mathbf k)$, are the discrete Fourier coefficients\footnote{There is a slight difference between the formulae based on an even and an odd number of points; we chose to continue with the slightly simpler notations associated with an odd number of points.}. The mapping $w\mapsto \IN[w]$ is a projection: $\IN[w](\mathbf x)$ is the unique $N$-degree \emph{trigonometric interpolant} of $w$ at the $(2N+1)$-gridpoints, $\IN[w](\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}})=w(\mathbf x_{\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}}), \ |\boldsymbol\nu} %{\underline \nu}|\leq 2N$. The dual statement of the last equalities is the Poisson summation formula, which determines the discrete $\widetilde{w}(\mathbf k)$'s in terms of the exact Fourier coefficients, $\widehat{w}(\mathbf k)$'s, \[ \widetilde{w}(\mathbf k)=\widehat{w}(\mathbf k) + \sum_{\boldsymbol\ell} %{\mathbf l\neq 0} \widehat{w}(\mathbf k+\boldsymbol\ell} %{\mathbf l(2N+1)), \qquad |\mathbf k|\leq N, \] where summation runs over all $d$-tuples, $\boldsymbol\ell} %{\mathbf l=(\ell_1,\ldots,\ell_d)\neq 0$. It shows that all the Fourier coefficients with wavenumber $\mathbf k[mod (2N+1)]$ are ``aliased" into the same discrete Fourier coefficient, $\widetilde{w}_\mathbf k$. It follows that the interpolation error consists of two main contributions, \[ (I-\IN)[w] \equiv (I-\SN)[w]} %\TN[w]+\AN[w], \] where in addition to the truncation error $(I-\SN)[w]} %\TN[w]$ in (\ref{eq:tr}), we now have the \emph{aliasing error}, \begin{equation}\label{eq:al} \AN[w](\mathbf x):=\sum_{|\mathbf k|\leq N}\Big(\sum_{|\boldsymbol\ell} %{\mathbf l|\geq 1}\widehat{w}(\mathbf k+\boldsymbol\ell} %{\mathbf l(2N+1))\Big)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}. \end{equation} Both, $(I-\SN)[w]} %\TN[w]$ and $\AN[w]$, involve high modes, $\widehat{w}(\mathbf p),\ |\mathbf p|\geq N$. Consequently, if the function $w(\cdot)$ is sufficiently smooth then they have exactly the same spectrally small size, e.g. \cite[\S2.2]{Tad94} \[ \|\AN[w]\|_{H^s} \lesssim \|(I-\SN)[w]} %\TN[w]\|_{H^s} \lesssim N^{s-r}\|w\|_{H^r}, \qquad r>s>\frac{d}{2}. \] Since the truncation error is orthogonal to the computational $N$-space whereas the aliasing error is not the situation is different if $w$ lacks smoothness. Then aliasing and truncation errors may have a completely different influence on the question of computational stability. One such case is encountered with the stability question of spectral vs. pseudo-spectral approximations of hyperbolic equations. \section{Fourier method for linear equations --- weak instability for $L^2$-data}\label{sec:lin} \subsection{The spectral approximation: stability and convergence.} We want to solve the $\tpi$-periodic scalar hyperbolic equation \begin{equation}\label{eq:pde} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u(x,t) + \frac{\partial}{\partial x}\big(q(x)u(x,t)\big)=0, \qquad x\in {\mathbb T}([0,2\pi)), \ \ q\in C^1[\pil,\pir], \end{equation} subject to prescribed initial conditions, $u(\cdot,0)$, by the spectral Fourier method. To this end we approximate the spectral projection of the exact solution, $\SN u(\cdot,t)$, using an $N$-degree polynomial, $u_N(x,t)=\sum_{|k|\leq N}\widehat{u}_k(t)e^{ikx}$, which is governed by the semi-discrete approximation, \cite{Or72,KO72,GO77} \begin{equation}\label{eq:splina} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\SN[q(x)u_N(x,t)]=0. \end{equation} The approximation is realized as a convolution in Fourier space \[ \frac{d}{dt}\widehat{u}_k(t) = ik\sum_{|j|\leq N}\widehat{q}(k-j)\widehat{u}_j(t), \qquad k=-N,\ldots,N, \] which amounts to a system of $(2N+1)$ ODEs for the computed $\widehat{\bf u}(t):= (\widehat{u}_{-N}(t),\ldots,\widehat{u}_N(t))^\top$. The $L^2$-stability of \eqref{eq:splina} is straightforward: though the truncation error which enters (\ref{eq:splina}), $\partial_x(I-\SN)[q(x)u_N(x)]$ need not be small, it is orthogonal to the $N$-space, and hence, \begin{eqnarray} \frac{1}{2}\frac{d}{dt}\|u_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2} &=& -\int_{\pil}^{\pir} u_N\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\SN[q(x)u_N]dx = \int\frac{\partial u_N}{\partial x} \SN[q(x)u_N]dx \nonumber \\ & =& \int\frac{\partial u_N}{\partial x} q(x)u_N dx = -\frac{1}{2} \int q'(x)u_N^2dx \label{eq:spstab} \\ &\leq & \frac{1}{2}\max_x|q'(x)|\times\|u_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2}. \nonumber \end{eqnarray} This yields the $L^2$-stability bound, \begin{equation}\label{eq:spl2stab} \|u_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2} \leq e^{q'_\infty t}\|u_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2}, \qquad q'_\infty:=\max_x|q'(x)|. \end{equation} To convert this stability bound into a spectral convergence rate estimate, consider the difference between the spectral method (\ref{eq:splina}) and the $\SN$ projection of the underlying equation (\ref{eq:pde}): one finds that $e_N:=u_N-\SN u$, satisfies the error equation \[ \frac{\partial}{\partial t}e_N(x,t)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\SN[q(x)e_N(x,t)]= -\frac{\part}{\part x} \SN\big[q(x)(I-\SN)[u](x,t)\big]. \] The $L^2$-stability (\ref{eq:spl2stab}) implies the error estimate, \[ \int|u_N(x,t)-\SN u(x,t)|^2dx \lesssim e^{q'_\infty t}\left(\|(I-\SN)u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2} + N^2\max_{\tau\leq t}\|(I-\SN)[u](\cdot,\tau)\|^2_{L^2}\right). \] This quantifies the \emph{spectral convergence} of the Fourier method (\ref{eq:splina}): the convergence rate increases together with the increasing order of smoothness of the solution, \begin{equation}\label{eq:rate} \|u_N(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \lesssim e^{\frac{1}{2} q'_\infty t}\left(N^{-s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|_{H^s} + N^{1-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \quad s>1. \end{equation} In practice, one recovers exponential convergence for analytic solutions (and root-exponential convergence for more general Gevrey data). \subsection{The pseudo-spectral approximation: aliasing and weak stability.} We now consider pseudo-spectral Fourier approximation of (\ref{eq:pde}). As before, we use an $N$-degree polynomial, $u_N(x,t)=\sum_{|k|\leq N}\widehat{u}_k(t)e^{ikx}$, as an approximation for $\IN u(\cdot,t)$, which is governed by the semi-discrete approximation, \cite{KO72,GO77}, \begin{equation}\label{eq:psplina} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\IN[q(x)u_N(x,t)]=0. \end{equation} This equation can be realized in physical space \[ \frac{d}{dt} u_N(x_j,t)=\!\!\!\!\sum_{k=-N}^N\!\!\!\!ik \widetilde{(qu_N)}_k e^{ikx_j}, \quad \widetilde{(qu_N)}_k\!\!=\!\!\frac{h}{\tpi}\sum_{\nu=0}^{2N}q(x_\nu)u_N(x_\nu)e^{-ikx_\nu}. \] It amounts to a system of $(2N+1)$ ODEs for the computed gridvalues ${\bf u}(t):=\big({u}(x_0,t),\ldots, {u}(x_{2N},t)\big)^\top$ \[ \frac{d}{dt}{\bf u}(t) = DQ{\bf u}(t), \qquad D_{jk}=\frac{(-1)^{j-k}}{2\sin\left(\frac{x_j-x_k}{2}\right)}, \ \ Q = \left(\begin{array}{cccc}q(x_0)& 0&\ldots&0 \\ 0 &\ddots & 0 & \vdots\\ \vdots & & \ddots & 0\\ 0 & 0 & \ldots & q(x_{2N})\end{array}\right) \] Here $D$ is the Fourier differentiation matrix and $Q$ signifies pointwise multiplication with $q(x)$. To examine the stability of (\ref{eq:psplina}) we repeat the usual $L^2$-energy argument for the spectral approximation in (\ref{eq:splina}): decompose $\IN=\SN+\AN$, to find \begin{equation}\label{eq:pspener} \frac{1}{2}\frac{d}{dt} \|u_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2} = \overbrace{\int u_N\frac{\partial}{\partial x} {\SN}[q(x)u_N]dx}^{{\rm a \ bounded \ term} - (\ref{eq:spstab})} + \overbrace{\int u_N\frac{\partial}{\partial x} \AN[q(x)u_N]dx}^{{\rm contribution \ of \ aliasing}} \end{equation} The first term on the right consists of truncation error which, by (\ref{eq:spstab}), does not exceed $\lesssim \|u_N(\cdot,t)\|^2$. Thus, the stability of the Fourier approximation (\ref{eq:psplina}) depends solely on the aliasing contributions, $\AN[q(x)u_N]$: using (\ref{eq:al}) to expand the second term on the right, we find \begin{equation}\label{eq:semi_aliasing} \int u_N\frac{\partial}{\partial x}{A_N}[q(x)u_N]dx = 2\pi i\!\!\!\!\sum_{|j|,|k|\leq N} \overline{\widehat{u}}_j(t) \widehat{u}_{k}(t) \,(j-k)\cdot\!\!\sum_{{\ell\neq 0}}\widehat{q}\left({j-k+\ell(2N+1)}\right). \end{equation} Observe that the terms on the right, $\sum_{{\ell\neq 0}}\widehat{q}\left({j-k+\ell(2N+1)}\right)$, are of order ${\mathcal O}(N)$ for $|j-k|\sim 2N, \ell=\pm 1$, and this can occur \emph{only} for high wavenumbers, $|j|\sim |k| \sim N$. Thus, there is possible ${\mathcal O}(N)$ amplification of the high Fourier modes, $|\widehat{u}_j(t)|, \ |j|\sim N$. Unfortunately, these Fourier modes need not be small due to lack of apriori smoothness, and aliasing may render the Fourier method as unstable. Indeed, when $q(x)$ changes sign, the exact solution of (\ref{eq:pde}) develops large gradients and consequently, the Fourier method does experience spurious oscillations precisely because of aliasing errors which are ignited due to lack of smoothness. To demonstrate the exact mechanism of this type of instability\footnote{To demonstrate the instability of the Fourier method (\ref{eq:psplina}), one needs to consider $q(x)$ which changes sign. Otherwise, if $q(x)$ is, say, positive, then $DQ$ is similar to the anti-symmetric matrix $ {\mathcal A}:=\sqrt{Q}D\sqrt{Q}$ and stability follows since $exp({\mathcal A}t)$ is unitary in ${\mathbb C}^{2N+1}$ for the scalar product $(QU_N,V_N)$ \cite{KO72}.}, we consider the example $q(x)=\sin(x)$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:pspsin} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\IN[\sin(x)u_N(x,t)]=0 \end{equation} The analysis follows \cite{GHT94}. Fourier transform of (\ref{eq:pspsin}) yields \[ \frac{d}{dt} \widehat{u}_k (t) = {k\over 2} [\widehat{u}_{k-1} (t) - \widehat{u}_{k+1}(t)], \quad k=-N,\dots, N, \] and its imaginary part, $b_k(t):=\Im\widetilde{u}_k(t)$, reads \begin{equation}\label{eq:pspb} \frac{d}{dt} b_k(t) = {k\over 2} \left[b_{k-1} (t) - b_{k+1}(t)\right], \ \ b_{N+1} +b_N=0. \end{equation} The last set of ODEs is at the heart of matter. A straightforward energy estimate yields the \emph{lower-bound} $\displaystyle \frac{d}{dt} \|{\bf b}(t)\|^2 \geq - \|{\bf b}(t)\|^2+ N b^2_N(t)$ for ${\bf b}(t):=(b_1(t),\ldots,b_N(t))^\top$. Does $b_N(t)$ grow? on the one hand, numerical simulations in Figure \ref{fig:a} show that it does. On the other hand, \emph{if} the solution is smooth enough, then aliasing errors are negligible: in Figure \ref{fig:b} for example, the solution subject to initial data $|\widehat{u}_k(0)| \sim |k|^{-3}$ remain smooth and the spurious mode, $|b_N(t)| \sim N^{-2}$, decay sufficiently fast so that ${\bf b}(t)$ remains bounded. \begin{figure}[ht] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{ccc} \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig3_1a.ps} & \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig3_1cb.ps} & \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig3_1dc.ps} \end{tabular} \end{center} \caption{ $b_k(t)=\Im\widehat{u}_{k}(t)$: Fourier method subject to $\hat{u}_{k}(0)=x_{k}^{3}(\pi-x_{k})^{3}/20$.\newline (a) $(t,N)=(0.1, 200)$; \ (b) $(t,N)=(1., 100)$; \ (c) $(t,N)=(1., 200)$.}\label{fig:a} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[ht] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{ccc} \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig3_2a.ps} & \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig3_2b.ps} & \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig3_2c.ps} \end{tabular} \end{center} \caption{$\Im\hat{u}_{k}(t)$ computed at $t=3$: Fourier solution of $u_t=(\sin(x)u)_{x}, \quad \widehat{u}_{k}(0)\sim{k^{-3}}$. (a) with $N=100$; \ (b) with $N=200$; \ (c) with $N=800$: $b_N(t) \sim \pm N^{-2}$.}\label{fig:b} \end{figure} In practice, however, even if the solution of (\ref{eq:pde}) remains smooth, it develops large gradients of order $|\widehat{\bf u}(t)| \sim exp(q'_\infty t)$ when $q(x)$ changes sign. These large gradients require $N\gg e^t$ modes in order to resolve these gradients; otherwise, the exact solution $u(\cdot,t)$ remains under-resolved by the pseudo-spectral Fourier approximation. Observe that the Fourier method requires an increasingly large number of modes before it can resolve the underlying solution, $u(\cdot,t)$. Without it, the under-resolved Fourier approximation contains ${\mathcal O}(1)$ high modes, $|\widehat{u}_N(t)| \sim |b_N(t)|$, amplified by a factor of order ${\mathcal O}(N)$, yielding the spurious oscillations noticeable in Figure \ref{fig:c}. Thus, aliasing errors cause the Fourier solution to grow due to \emph{lack of resolution}. The precise growth is ``encoded'' in the Fourier equations whose imaginary part is governed by (\ref{eq:pspb}). To this end, set $v_{k}(t):=(-1)^{k}b_{k}(t)$. Then (\ref{eq:pspb}) is converted into \[ \frac{d}{dt} v_{k}(t) = x_{k} \frac{v_{k+1}(t)-v_{k-1}(t)}{2\Delta x}, \quad v_{N+1}(t)=v_{N}(t), \ \ x_{k}:=k\Delta x \in [0,1], \ \Delta x:=h/\pi. \] This can be viewed as an approximation to the linear equation $ \partial_t v(x,t) = x \partial_x v(x,t), \ 0 \leq x \leq 1$ augmented with the boundary condition $\partial_x v(1,t)=0$. This is an \emph{ill-posed} problem due to the extrapolation at the inflow boundary $x=1$, and consequently, its numerical approximation grows $\|b_N(t)\|=\|v_N(t)\| \sim \sqrt{N}$, e.g., \cite{Tad83}. The detailed analysis carried out in \cite{GHT94} shows that there is a \emph{weak} instability, where $\sim 1-e^{-t}$ fraction of the highest modes experience amplification of order ${\mathcal O}(N)$, which ends with the stability estimate \[ \|u_N(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \lesssim e^{C q'_\infty t} N \|u_N(\cdot,0)\|_{L^2}. \] The corresponding error estimate for the pseudo-spectral approximation reads \cite[theorem 4.1]{GHT94} \[ \|u_N(\cdot,t)-\IN u(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \lesssim e^{{C_s}q'_\infty t}\left(N^{1-s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|_{H^s} + N^{2-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \qquad s>2, \] reflecting the loss of power on $N$ when compared with the spectral estimate (\ref{eq:rate}). \begin{figure}[ht] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{ccc} \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig4_4a1.ps}& \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig4_4b1.ps}& \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig4_4c1.ps}\\ \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig4_4a2.ps}& \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig4_4b2.ps}& \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{fig4_4c2.ps} \end{tabular} \end{center} \caption{ $\Im\hat{u}_{k}(t=0.4)$ of $u_N(\cdot,t)$ with $N=64$, $N=128$ and $N=512$ modes.}\label{fig:c} \end{figure} \subsection{De-aliasing: the $2/3$ smoothing method and strong stability} One way to regain the stability of the pseudo-spectral Fourier method in (\ref{eq:pspsin}) is to set $\widehat{u}_N(t)\equiv 0$ which prevents the growth of $b_N(t)\equiv 0$. Thus, removing the last mode stabilize the pseudospectral method in the special case of $q(x)=\sin(x)$. The hyperbolic equation (\ref{eq:pde}) with a general $q(x)$ follows along the lines of \cite{Tad87}. We return to the aliasing term (\ref{eq:semi_aliasing}), \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:alia} \lefteqn{\int u_N(x,t)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}{\AN}[q(\cdot)u_N](x,t)dx} \\ & & \qquad \qquad = 2\pi i\sum_{|j|,|k|\leq N} \overline{\widehat{u}}_j(t) \widehat{u}_{k}(t) \,(j-k)\cdot\sum_{{\ell\neq 0}}\widehat{q}\left({j-k+\ell(2N+1)}\right). \nonumber \end{eqnarray} As noted before, the ${\mathcal O}(N)$ growth of the high Fourier modes, $|\widehat{u}_j(t)|, \ |j|\sim N$, need not be small due to lack of apriori smoothness. We can circumvent this difficulty if we remove these modes by setting a fixed portion of the spectrum to be zero. For example, assume that we truncate the last $1/3$ of the modes of $u_N$ (any other fixed fraction of $N$ will do). To this end, we use a \emph{smoothing operator} $\SR$ which is activated only on the first $\frac{2}{3} N$ modes while removing the top $1/3 N$ of the modes. We up with the so-called $2/3$ pseudo-spectral Fourier method, \begin{subequations}\label{eqs:pspsmoo} \begin{equation}\label{eq:pspsmoo} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\IN[q(\cdot)\SRu_N](x,t)=0, \qquad \SRu_N:= \sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N}\sigma_k\widehat{u}_k(t)e^{ikx}; \end{equation} To retain spectral accuracy, the smoothing factors $\sigma_k \in (0,1]$ do not change a fixed portion of the lower spectrum \begin{equation}\label{eq:pspsmoob} \sigma_k \left\{\begin{array}{ll} \equiv 1, & |k|\leq \frac{1}{3}N \\ \\ \in (0,1], & \frac{1}{3}N <|k| <\frac{2}{3} N.\end{array}\right. \end{equation} \end{subequations} The $L^2$-stability of the $2/3$ method follows along the lines of the spectral stability in (\ref{eq:spstab}); integrating (\ref{eq:pspsmoo}) against $\SRu_N$ we find \begin{subequations}\label{eqs:last} \begin{equation}\label{eq:lasta} \left|\int (\SRu_N)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\SN[q(\cdot)\SRu_N]dx\right| \leq \frac{1}{2} q'_\infty \|\SRu_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2}, \qquad q'_\infty= \max_x|q'(x)|. \end{equation} The aliasing contribution in the $2/3$ method is bounded (and in fact negligible for $q\in C^s, s>1$): following (\ref{eq:alia}) \[ \int (\SRu_N)\frac{\partial}{\partial x} {A_N}[q(\cdot)(\SRu_N)]dx = 2\pi i\!\!\!\sum_{|j|\leq \frac{2}{3} N}\sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N}\sigma_k\sigma_j \overline{\widehat{u}}_j(t) \widehat{u}_{k}(t)\, (j-k)\cdot\sum_{{\ell\neq 0}}\widehat{q}\overbrace{\left({j-k+\ell(2N+1)}\right)}^{|{j-k+\ell(2N+1)}|\geq \frac{2}{3} N}; \] observe that the terms involved in the inner summation on the right are now restricted to high wavenumbers, $|j-k+\ell(2N+1)|\geq \frac{2}{3} N$ so that $|\widehat{q}\left({j-k+\ell(2N+1)}\right)| \lesssim \|q\|_{C^r}N^{-r}$. Hence \begin{equation}\label{eq:lastb} \left| \int (\SRu_N)\frac{\partial}{\partial x} {A_N}[q(\cdot)(\SRu_N)]dx \right| \lesssim \|q\|_{C^r}N^{1-r} \times \|\SRu_N\|^2, \qquad r\geq 1. \end{equation} \end{subequations} Combining the last two inequalities (\ref{eq:lasta}) and (\ref{eq:lastb}) with $r=1$, we arrive at \[ \frac{1}{2}\frac{d}{dt}\int(\SRu_N)(x,t)u_N(x,t)dx = -\int (\SRu_N)\frac{\part}{\part x} (\SN+A_N)[q(\cdot)(\SRu_N)]dx \leq C q'_\infty \|\SRu_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2}. \] Thus, by activating the smoothing operator we removed aliasing errors and the resulting $2/3$ de-aliased pseudo-spectral method (\ref{eqs:pspsmoo}) regained the \emph{weighted} $L^2$-stability \[ \|u_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2_{\SR}} \leq e^{2C q'_\infty t}\|u_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2_{\SR}}, \qquad \|w(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2_{\SR}}:=\int (\SR w)(x,t)w(x,t)dx \equiv 2\pi\!\!\!\sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \sigma_k|\widehat{w}_k(t)|^2. \] The corresponding error equation for $e_N:=\SRu_N-\SR u$ reads (we skip the details) \[ \frac{\part}{\part t} e_N + \frac{\part}{\part x} \big(\SR[q e_N]\big) = -\frac{\part}{\part x} \SR \big[q(x)(I-\SR)[u](x,t)\big], \] and the spectral convergence rate, (\ref{eq:rate}), follows: for $s>1$ there exists a constant, $C=C_s$ such that \[ \|u_N-u\|_{L_{\SR}^2} \lesssim e^{C_s q'_\infty t}\left(N^{-s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|_{H^s} + N^{1-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \quad s>1. \] \subsection{Spectral accuracy and propagation of discontinuities}\label{sec:disc} Hyperbolic equations propagates $H^s$ regularity: $ \|u(\cdot,t)\|_{H^s} \lesssim {e^{C_s t}} \|u(\cdot,0)\|_{H^s} <\infty$. Thus, the convergence statement in (\ref{eq:rate}) implies spectral convergence of the spectral Fourier method and $2/3$ Fourier method for $H^s$-smooth initial data. However, when the initial data is \emph{piecewise smooth}, the exact solution propagates discontinuities along characteristics, and the (pseudo-)spectral approximations of jump discontinuities in $u(\cdot,t)$ produces spurious Gibbs oscillations, \cite{Tad07}. Nevertheless, thanks to the $H^s$-stability of the spectral Fourier method and the $2/3$ pseudo-spectral methods, $\|u_N(\cdot,t)\|_{\dot{H}^s} \lesssim e^{{C_s}|q|_\infty t}\|u_N(\cdot,0)\|_{\dot{H}^s}$, measured in the \emph{weak} topology of $s<0$, the (pseudo-)spectral approximations still propagate accurate information of the smooth portions of the exact solution. This is realized in terms of the convergence rate (we skip the details) \[ \|u_N-u\|_{H^{r}}\lesssim e^{C_s q'_\infty t}\left(N^{r-s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|_{H^{s}} + N^{1+r-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^{s}}\right), \qquad r < s-1 <-1. \] It follows that one can pre- and post-process $u_N(\cdot,t)$ to recover the \emph{pointvalues} of $u(\cdot,t)$ within spectral accuracy, away from the singular set of the solution, \cite{MMO78,ML78,AGT86}. The point to note here is that even the Fourier projections of the exact solution, $\SN u(\cdot,t)$ and $\IN u(\cdot,t)$ are at most first-order accurate due to Gibbs oscillations; the post-processing of the computed $u_N$ is realized by its smoothing using a proper $\sigma$-mollifier (\ref{eq:pspsmoob}) (or see (\ref{eq:mollifier}) below), which does both --- retains the stability and recovers the spectrally accurate resolution content of the Fourier method. \section{Fourier method for Burgers equation: convergence for smooth solutions}\label{sec:burgers} We now turn our attention to spectral and pseudo-spectral approximations of nonlinear problems. Their spectral accuracy often make them the method of choice for simulations where the highest resolution is sought for a given number of degrees of freedom. We begin with the prototypical example for quadratic nonlinearities, the inviscid Bugers' equation, \begin{equation}\label{eq:burgers} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u(x,t) + \frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}u^2(x,t)=0, \qquad x\in {\mathbb T}([0,2\pi)), \end{equation} subject to $\tpi$-periodic boundary conditions and prescribed initial conditions, $u(x,0)$. In this section we show that as long as the solution of Burgers equation remains smooth for a time interval $t \leq T_c$, the spectral and $2/3$ de-aliased pseudo-spectral approximations converge to the exact solution with spectral accuracy. \subsection{The spectral approximation of Burgers equation}\label{sec:sp-quad-stability} The spectral approximation of (\ref{eq:burgers}), $u_N(x,t)=\sum \widehat{u}_k(t)e^{ikx}$, is governed by, \begin{equation}\label{eq:spburg} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big( \SN\left[u_N^2\right](x,t) \Big)=0, \qquad \pil\leq x \leq \pir. \end{equation} The evaluation of the quadratic term on the right is carried out using convolution and (\ref{eq:spburg}) amounts to a nonlinear system of $(2N+1)$ ODEs for $\widehat{\mathbf u}(t)=(\widehat{u}_{-N}(t),\ldots, \widehat{u}_N(t))^\top$. \begin{theorem}[{\bf Spectral convergence for smooth solutions of Burgers' equations}]\label{thm:spsmooth} Assume that for $0<t\leq T_c$, the solution of the Burgers equation \eqref{eq:pde} is smooth, $u(\cdot,t)\in L^\infty\left([0,T_c], C^{1+\alpha}(\pil,\pir]\right)$. Then, the spectral method \eqref{eq:spburg} converges in $L^\infty\left([0,T_c], L^2(0,2\pi]\right)$, \[ \|u_N(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0, \qquad 0\leq t \leq T_c. \] Moreover, the following spectral convergence rate estimate holds for all $s>\frac{3}{2}$, \[ \|u_N(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2} \lesssim e^{{\displaystyle \int_0^t \!\!|u_x(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}} \left(N^{-2s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s} + N^{\frac{3}{2}-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right)\!, \ s>\frac{3}{2}. \] \end{theorem} \begin{proof} We rewrite the spectral approximation (\ref{eq:burgers}) in the form \[ \frac{\part}{\part t} u_N + \frac{\part}{\part x} \frac{u_N^2}2=\frac12\frac{\part}{\part x}(I-\SN)[u_N^2]. \] The corresponding energy equation reads \begin{equation}\label{eq:spener} \frac{\part}{\part t} \frac{u_N^2}{2} +\frac{\part}{\part x} \frac{u_N^3}{6}= \frac{u_N}{2}\frac{\part}{\part x}(I-\SN)[u_N^2]. \end{equation} Integration yields the energy balance \[ \frac12\frac{d}{dt}\int u_N^2(x,t)dx = \frac12\int u_N\partial_x(I-\SN)[u_N^2]dx =: {\mathcal I}_1. \] The term on the right vanishes by orthogonality, $\displaystyle {\mathcal I}_1=-\frac12\int\frac{\partial u_N}{\partial x} (I-\SN)[u_N^2]dx =0$, and hence the solution is $L^2$-conservative, \begin{equation}\label{eq:spL2consv} \|u_N(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2}= \|u_N(\cdot,0)\|_{L^2}. \end{equation} \medskip Next, we integrate $ (u_N-u)^2\equiv{|u_N|^2}-{|u|^2} - 2u(u_N-u)$: after discarding all terms which are in divergence form, we are left with \begin{eqnarray*} \frac12\frac{d}{dt}\int (u_N-u)^2dx&=& \frac{d}{dt}\int \Bigg(\frac{|u_N|^2}2-\frac{|u|^2}2- u(u_N-u)\Bigg)dx\\ &= &\frac12\intu_N\partial_x(I-\SN)[u_N^2]dx -\int \partial_t(u(u_N-u))dx =:{\mathcal I}_1+{\mathcal I}_2. \end{eqnarray*} Recall that ${\mathcal I}_1$ vanishes. As for the second term ${\mathcal I}_2$, we decompose it into two terms, \begin{equation*} {\mathcal I}_2=\int \partial_t\big(u(u_N-u)\big)dx \equiv \int u_t (u_N-u)dx+\int u (\partial_t u_N-\partial_t u)dx, \end{equation*} and using (\ref{eq:burgers}), (\ref{eq:spburg}) and (\ref{eq:spener}) to convert time derivatives to spatial ones, we find \begin{eqnarray*} {\mathcal I}_2&= &-\int u u_x (u_N-u)dx - \int u \partial_{x}\!\!\left(\frac{u_N^2}2-\frac{u^2}2\right)dx +\frac12\int u\partial_x (I-\SN) [u_N^2]dx\\ &=& -\int u u_x (u_N-u)dx + \int u_x\left(\frac{u_N^2}2- \frac{u^2}2\right)dx -\frac12\int u_x(I-\SN) [u_N^2]dx\\ &=&\int u_x \left( \frac{u_N^2}2-\frac{u^2}2-u (u_N-u)\right)dx-\frac12\int u_x (I-\SN)[u_N^2]dx. \end{eqnarray*} Eventually, we end up with \begin{subequations}\label{eqs:gron} \begin{equation}\label{eq:grona} \frac12\frac{d}{dt}\int |u_N(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx \leq \frac{|u_x(\cdot,t)|_{L^\infty}}{2} \int |u_N(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx-\frac12 e_N, \end{equation} where the error term, $e_N$, is given by \begin{equation}\label{eq:gronb} e_N:=\int u_N^2(I-\SN)[u_x] dx \end{equation} \end{subequations} Observe that under the hypothesis $u_x\in L_t^\infty C^{0,\alpha}_x$, and hence by Jackson's bound \cite{DL93} and the $L^2$-bound (\ref{eq:spL2consv}) one has \[ |e_N(t)|\lesssim \max_x|(I-\SN)[u_x(x,t)]|\cdot\|u_N\|^2_{L^2} \lesssim \frac{\ln N}{N^\alpha}\|u_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2} \rightarrow 0. \] With (\ref{eqs:gron}) one obtains, \begin{eqnarray*} \int |u_N(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx & \le & e^{{U'_\infty(t;0)}} \int |u_N(x,0)-u(x,0)|^2dx\\ & + & \int_0^t e^{{U'_\infty(t;\tau)}} |e_N(\tau)|d\tau, \qquad {U'_\infty(t;\tau):=\int_{s=\tau}^t|u_x(\cdot,s)|_\infty ds}. \end{eqnarray*} and convergence follows. Moreover, with $u_N(\cdot,0)=\SN u(\cdot,0)$ we end up with spectral convergence rate estimate \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\int |u_N(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx} \\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle {\int_0^t |u_x(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}} \left(N^{-2s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s}+ N^{\frac{3}{2}-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \qquad s> \frac{3}{2}. \end{eqnarray*} \end{proof} \subsection{The $2/3$ de-aliasing pseudo-spectral approximation of Burgers equation}\label{sec:ps-quad-stability} Convolutions can be avoided using the pseudo-spectral Fourier method, \cite{KO72,GO77}, \[ \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big( \IN\left[u_N^2\right](x,t) \Big)=0, \qquad x\in {\mathbb T}([0,2\pi)). \] Observe that (\ref{eq:burgers}) is satisfied \emph{exactly} at the gridpoints $x_\nu$, \[ \frac{d}{dt}u_N(x_\nu,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big( \IN\left[u_N^2\right](x,t) \Big)_{\big|x=x_\nu}=0, \qquad \nu=0, 1, \ldots, 2N. \] The resulting system of $(2N+1)$ nonlinear equations for ${\bf u}(t)=(u(x_0,t),\ldots,u(x_{2N},t))^\top$ can be then integrated in time by standard ODE solvers. The pseudo-spectral approximation introduces aliasing errors. To eliminate these errors, we consider the $2/3$ de-aliasing Fourier method, consult (\ref{eq:pspsmoo}) \begin{subequations}\label{eqs:fourier} \begin{equation}\label{eq:fourier} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big( \IN\left[(\SRu_N)^2\right](x,t) \Big)=0, \quad x\in {\mathbb T}([0,2\pi)), \end{equation} where $\SRu_N$ denotes a \emph{smoothing} operator of the form \begin{equation}\label{eq:fourierb} \SRu_N:= \sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N}\sigma_k\widehat{u}_k(t) e^{ikx}, \qquad \widehat{u}_k(t)=\frac{h}{\tpi}\sum_{\nu=0}^{2N}u_N(x_\nu,t)e^{-ikx_\nu}. \end{equation} The smoothing operator $\SR$ is dictated by the smoothing factors, $\{\sigma_k\}_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N}$, which truncates modes with wavenumbers $|k|>\frac{2}{3} N$ while leaving a fixed portion --- say, the first 1/3 of the spectrum, viscous-free. This is the same smoothing operator $\SRu_N$ we considered already in the \emph{linear} $2/3$ method (\ref{eq:pspsmoo}). In typical cases, one may employ a smoothing mollifier, $\sigma(\cdot) \in C^\infty(0,1)$, setting \begin{equation}\label{eq:mollifier} \sigma_k= \sigma\left(\frac{|k|}{N}\right), \quad \sigma(\xi) \left\{\begin{array}{ll} \equiv 1, & \xi\leq \frac{1}{3}, \\ \\ \in (0,1), & \frac{1}{3} < \xi < \frac{2}{3}, \\ \\ \equiv 0, & \frac{2}{3} \leq \xi \leq 1.\end{array}\right. \end{equation} \end{subequations} This is the $2/3$ de-aliasing Fourier method which is often advocated for spectral computations,in particular those involving quadratic nonlinearities, \cite{HL07,OHFS10,Kerr93,Kerr05}. \medskip In what sense does the $2/3$ method remove aliasing errors? to make precise the de-aliasing aspect of (\ref{eqs:fourier}), consider the $2/3$ truncated solution $\um:=\SRu_N$. Here we emphasize that we are dealing with the smoothed solution, $\um$, of degree $m:= \frac{2}{3} N$. Observing that truncation commute with differentiation, we find \begin{equation}\label{eq:jN} \frac{\partial }{\partial t}\um(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\SR\left(\IN[\um^2]\right)(x,t)=0, \qquad deg(\um)= m:=\frac{2}{3} N. \end{equation} We now come to the key point behind the removal of aliasing in quadratic nonlinearities: since $\widehat{u}_m(k)=0$ for $|k|> \frac{2}{3} N$ then $\widehat{\um^2}(k)=0$ for $|k|> \frac{4}{3}N$ hence $\widehat{\um^2}({k+\ell(2N+1)})=0$ for $|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N, \ell\neq 0$; consequently, since the smoothing operator $\mathcal{S}$ acts only on the first $\frac{2}{3} N$ mode, $\mathcal{S}\left({\AN}\um^2\right)\equiv 0$, and we conclude \[ \SR \big(\IN [\um^2]\big)(x,\cdot) \equiv \SR \big(\left(\SN+{\AN}\right)[\um^2]\big)(x,\cdot) = \SR \left(\SN[\um^2]\right)(x,\cdot) \equiv \SR \um^2(x,\cdot). \] We summarize by stating the following. \begin{corollary}\label{cor:special} Consider the $2/3$ de-aliasing Fourier method \eqref{eqs:fourier} then its $2/3$ smoothed solution, $\um:=\SRu_N$, satisfies \begin{equation}\label{eq:23} \frac{\partial }{\partial t}\um(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\SR[\um^2](x,t)=0, \qquad \SR w= \sum_{|k|\leq m} \sigma_k\widehat{w}_k e^{ikx}, \ m= \frac{2}{3} N. \end{equation} \end{corollary} \noindent Thus, by truncating the top $1/3$ of the modes, we de-aliased the Fourier method, (\ref{eq:fourier}), in the sense that (\ref{eq:23}) does \emph{not} involve any aliasing errors: only truncation errors, $(I-\SR)[\um^2]$ are involved. Indeed, the formulation of $2/3$ method in (\ref{eq:23}) resembles the $m$-mode spectral method (\ref{eq:spburg}). The only difference is due to the fact that unless $\sigma_k \equiv 1$, the smoothing operator ${\mathcal S}$ is not a projection\footnote{When $\sigma_k \equiv 1$, then ${\mathcal S}=P_{\frac{2}{3} N}$ and the $2/3$ method coincides with the spectral Fourier method (\ref{eq:spburg}) with $ m= \frac{2}{3} N$ modes, \[ \frac{\partial}{\partial t}\um(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}P_{m}[\um^2](x,t)=0, \qquad \ |k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N. \]} \medskip The following theorem shows that as long as the Burgers solution remains smooth, the $2/3$ de-aliasing Fourier method is stable and enjoys spectral convergence. \begin{theorem}[{\bf Spectral convergence of the $2/3$ method for smooth solutions}]\label{thm:pspsmooth} Assume that for $0<t\leq T_c$, the solution of the Burgers equation \eqref{eq:pde} is smooth, $u(\cdot,t)\in L^\infty\left([0,T_c], C^{1+\alpha}(\pil,\pir]\right)$. Then, the $2/3$ de-aliasing method \eqref{eqs:fourier} converges in $L^\infty\left([0,T_c], L^2(0,2\pi]\right)$, \[ \|\um(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0, \qquad 0\leq t \leq T_c, \] and the following spectral convergence rate estimate holds \[ \|u_N(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2} \lesssim e^{\displaystyle {\int_0^t |u_x(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}} \!\!\!\left(N^{-2s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s}+ N^{\frac{3}{2}-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \ s> \frac{3}{2}. \] \end{theorem} \begin{proof} We start with (\ref{eq:23}) \[ \frac{\partial }{\partial t}\um(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big(\SR[\um^2](x,t)\Big)=0. \] Since $\SR$ need not be a projection, there is no $L^2$-energy conservation for the $2/3$ smoothed solution $\um$. Instead, we integrate against $u_N$ to find that the corresponding energy balance reads \begin{eqnarray*} \frac{1}{2} \frac{d}{dt}\intu_N(x,t)\um(x,t)dx & = & -\frac12\int u_N\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\SR[\um^2](x,t)dx \\ & = & \quad \frac12\int \frac{\part}{\part x}(\SRu_N) \um^2(x,t)dx =\frac{1}{6}\int \frac{\part}{\part x} \um^3 dx =0, \end{eqnarray*} and hence the solution conserve the weighted $L^2_{\SR}$-norm, \begin{equation}\label{eq:pspl2cons} \|\um(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2_\SR}= \|u_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2_\SR}, \qquad \|u_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2_\SR}:= \int (\SRu_N) u_N dx = 2\pi \!\!\!\sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \sigma_k|\widehat{u}_k(t)|^2. \end{equation} We proceed along the lines of the spectral proof in theorem \ref{thm:spsmooth}, integrating $|\um-u|^2\equiv |\um|^2-|u|^2 -2u(\um-u)$: after discarding all terms which are in divergence form, we are left with \begin{eqnarray*} \frac12\frac{d}{dt}\int (\um-u)^2dx&=& \frac{d}{dt}\int \Bigg(\frac{|\um|^2}2-\frac{|u|^2}2- u(\um-u)\Bigg)dx\\ &= &\frac12\frac{d}{dt} \int |\um|^2dx -\int \partial_t(u(\um-u))dx =:{\mathcal I}_1+{\mathcal I}_2. \end{eqnarray*} Unlike the $L^2$ conservation of the spectral solution $u_N$, consult (\ref{eq:spL2consv}), there is no $L^2$-energy conservation for the $2/3$ smoothed solution $\um$ and we therefore leave ${\mathcal I}_1$ is left as perfect time derivative. As for the second term \begin{equation*} {\mathcal I}_2=\int \partial_t\big(u(\um-u)\big)dx \equiv \int \partial_t u (\um-u)dx+\int u (\partial_t \um-\partial_t u)dx, \end{equation*} we reproduce the same steps we had in the spectral case: using (\ref{eq:burgers}) and (\ref{eq:23}) to convert time derivatives to spatial ones, we find \begin{eqnarray*} {\mathcal I}_2&= &-\int u u_x (\um-u)dx - \int u \partial_x\left(\frac{\um^2}2- \frac{u^2}2\right)dx +\int u\partial_x (I-\SR) [\um^2]dx\\ &=& -\int u u_x (\um-u)dx + \int u_x\left(\frac{\um^2}2- \frac{u^2}2\right)dx -\frac12\int u_x(I-\SR) [\um^2]dx\\ &=&\int u_x \left( \frac{\um^2}2-\frac{u^2}2-u (\um-u)\right)dx-\frac12\int u_x (I-\SR)[\um^2]dx. \end{eqnarray*} Eventually, we end up with \[ \frac12\frac{d}{dt}\int |\um(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx \leq \frac{|u_x|_\infty}{2} \int |\um(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx+\frac12 e_N(t) + \frac12 \frac{d}{dt}\int |\um(x,t)|^2dx, \] where the error term, $e_N$ is given by $\displaystyle e_N(t):=-\int \um^2 (I-\SR)[u_x] dx$. Integrating in time we find \begin{eqnarray} \hspace*{1.4cm} \lefteqn {\int_x|\um(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx -\int_x|\um(x,0)-u(x,0)|^2dx} \label{eq:pspgron} \\ & & \ \ \ \ \ \leq |u_x|_\infty \int_{\tau=0}^t \int |\um(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dxd\tau + \int_0^t e_N(\tau)d\tau + f_N(t), \nonumber \end{eqnarray} with the additional error term, $f_N(t)$, given by \[ f_N(t) := \int |\um(x,t)|^2dx - \int |\um(x,0)|^2dx. \] The error term $e_N(t)$ can be estimated as before: observe that under the hypothesis $u_x\in L_t^\infty C^{0,\alpha}_x$, one has \begin{equation}\label{eq:xyz} |e_N(t)|\lesssim \max_x|(I-\SR)[u_x(x,t)]|\cdot\|\um\|^2_{L^2} \lesssim \frac{\ln N}{N^\alpha}\|u_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2} \rightarrow 0. \end{equation} To address the new error term, $f_N(t)$, we observe by the $L^2_{\SR}$-energy conservation (\ref{eq:pspl2cons}), \begin{eqnarray*} \int |\um(x,t)|^2dx & = & \sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \sigma_k^2 |\widehat{u}_k(t)|^2 \leq \sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \sigma_k |\widehat{u}_k(t)|^2 = \sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \sigma_k |\widehat{u}_k(0)|^2 \\ & = & \sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \sigma^2_k|\widehat{u}_k(0)|^2 + (\sigma_k-\sigma^2_k)|\widehat{u}_k(0)|^2 \\ &= & \int |\um(x,0)|^2 + \sum_{|k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \left(\sigma_k-\sigma^2_k\right) |\widehat{u}_k(0)|^2. \end{eqnarray*} Since $\sigma_k\equiv 1$ for $|k|< N/3$, consult (\ref{eq:mollifier}), we conclude \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:abc} f_N(t) &:= & \int |\um(x,t)|^2 -\int |\um(x,0)|^2 \\ & \leq & \sum_{\frac{1}{3}N \leq |k|\leq \frac{2}{3} N} \left(\sigma_k-\sigma^2_k\right) |\widehat{u}_k(0)|^2 \leq \big\|\big(P_{\frac{2}{3} N}-P_{\frac{1}{3}N}\big)u(\cdot,0)\big\|_{L^2}^2 \rightarrow 0. \nonumber \end{eqnarray} With (\ref{eq:pspgron}), (\ref{eq:abc}) and (\ref{eq:xyz}) in place, one obtains an estimate on the error integrated in space-time \[ \frac12 \frac{d}{dt} E_m(t) \leq \frac{|u_x|_\infty}{2}E_m(t) + \frac12\int_0^t e_N(\tau)d\tau + \frac12 f_N(t), \quad E_m(t):=\int_0^t \int |\um(x,\tau)-u(x,\tau)|^2dxd\tau. \] Convergence follows by Gronwall's inequality, \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\int |\um(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2dx} \\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle{\int_0^t \!\!|u_x(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}} \!\!\Big(\|\um(\cdot,0)-u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2} \\ & & \hspace*{3.2cm} \left. + \max_{x, \tau\leq t} |(I-\SR)u_x(x,\tau)| + \big\|\big(P_{\frac{2}{3} N}-P_{\frac{1}{3}N}\big)u(\cdot,0)\big\|_{L^2}^2\right). \end{eqnarray*} Moreover, with $u_N(\cdot,0)=\SN u(\cdot,0)$ we end up with spectral convergence rate estimate \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\int |\um(x,t)-u(x,t)|^2 dx} \\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle{\int_0^t |u_x(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}} \left(N^{-2s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s}+ N^{\frac{3}{2}-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \quad s>\frac{3}{2}. \end{eqnarray*} \end{proof} \section{Fourier method for Burgers equation: instability for weak solutions}\label{sec:2-3rd} In this section we discuss the spectral and the $2/3$ de-aliased pseudo-spectral Fourier approximations of Burgers' equation, (\ref{eq:burgers}), after the formation of shock discontinuities. We show that both methods are unstable after the critical time, $t>T_c$. Recall that the spectral method is a special case of the $2/3$ de-aliased method when we set the smoothing factors $\sigma_k\equiv 1$, see corollary \ref{cor:special}. It will therefore suffice to consider the $2/3$ de-aliasing pseudo-spectral Fourier method (\ref{eq:23}). We begin with its $L^2_{\SR}$-conservation (\ref{eq:pspl2cons}), which we express as \begin{equation}\label{eq:l2energy} \|\SR^{1/2}u_N(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2}= \| \SR^{1/2}u_N(\cdot,0)\|_{L^2}, \qquad \SR^{1/2}u_N:=\sum_{|k|\leq m} \sqrt{\sigma_k}\,\widehat{u}_k(t). \end{equation} Since the quadratic energy associated with $\SR^{1/2}u_N$ is bounded, it follows that, after extracting a subsequence if necessary\footnote{Here and below we continue to label such subsequences as $u_N$.} that $\SR^{1/2}u_N(\cdot,t)$ and hence $\um=\SRu_N$ has a $L^2$-weak limit, $\overline{u}(x,t)$. But $\overline{u}$ \emph{cannot} be the physically relevant entropy solution of (\ref{eq:pde}). Our next result quantifies what can go wrong. \begin{theorem}[{\bf The $2/3$ method must admit spurious oscillations}]\label{thm:instab} Let $T_c$ be the critical time of shock formation in Burgers' equation \eqref{eq:burgers}. Let $\um=\SRu_N$ denote the smoothed $2/3$ de-aliasing Fourier method, \eqref{eqs:fourier}. Assume the $L^6$-bound, $\|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{L^6} \leq Const$ holds. Then, for $t>T_c$, there exists a constant $c_0>0$ (independent of $N$) such that\footnote{$\|\um\|_{TV}$ denotes the total variation of $\um$.} \begin{equation}\label{eq:instab} \max_{x}|\um(x,t)|\times\|\um(\cdot,t)\|^2_{TV} \geq c_0 \sqrt{m}. \end{equation} \end{theorem} Theorem \ref{thm:instab} implies that either the solution of the $2/3$ de-aliasing Fourier method, $\um=\SRu_N$, grows unboundedly, \[ \lim_{N\rightarrow \infty} \|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{L^\infty} \longrightarrow \infty, \] or it has an unbounded total variation of order $\geq {\mathcal O}(\sqrt[4]{N})$. Each one of these scenarios implies that $\um$ contains spurious oscillations which are noticeable \emph{throughout} the computational domain, in agreement with the numerical evidence observed in \cite{Tad89}. We note that this type of nonlinear instability applies to both, the $2/3$ method and in particular, the spectral Fourier method and we refer in this context to the recent detailed study in \cite{RFNM11,PNFS13} and the refernces therein. \begin{proof} We begin with (\ref{eq:23}) \begin{equation}\label{eq:23res} \frac{\part}{\part t}\um(x,t)+\frac{1}{2} \frac{\part}{\part x}\um^2(x,t)= \frac{1}{2} \frac{\partial}{\partial x}(\Id-\SR)[\um^2](x,t). \end{equation} Observe that the residual on the right tends to zero in $H^{-1}$, \begin{eqnarray*} \Big|\int\frac{\part}{\part x}\varphi(x)(\Id-\SR)[\um^2](x,t)dx \Big| & = & \Big|\int\Big((\Id-\SR)\frac{\part}{\part x} \varphi(x)\Big)\um^2(x,t)dx\Big| \\ & \leq & \|\um(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^4}\times \|(I-\SR)\varphi_x(\cdot)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0, \qquad \forall \varphi \in H^1. \end{eqnarray*} Next, we consider the $L^2$-energy balance associated with (\ref{eq:23res}). Multiplication by $\um$ yields \begin{equation}\label{eq:entropy} \frac{1}{2} \frac{\part}{\part t} \um^2(x,t) +\frac{1}{3}\frac{\part}{\part x} \um^3(x,t)= \frac{1}{2} \um(x,t) \frac{\part}{\part x}(\Id-\SR)[\um^2](x,t). \end{equation} We continue our argument by claiming that if (\ref{eq:instab}) fails, then the energy production on the right of (\ref{eq:entropy}) also tends weakly to zero in $H^{-1}$. To this end, we examine the weak form of the expression on the right which we rewrite as \[ \int\varphi(x)\um(x,t)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}(P_{2m}-\SR)[\um^2](x,t)dx = \int (P_{2m}-\SR)\Big(\varphi(x)\um(x,t)\Big) \frac{\part}{\part x}\um^2(x,t)dx. \] It does not exceed \begin{subequations}\label{sub:eqs} \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{\Big|\int\varphi(x)\um \frac{\part}{\part x}(\Id-\SR)[\um^2](x,t)dx\Big|} \nonumber \\ & & = \Big|\int(P_{2m}-\SR)\Big(\varphi(x)\um(x,t)\Big) \um(x,t)\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\um(x,t)dx\Big| \\ & & \leq \big\|(P_{2m}-\SR)\big(\varphi(x)\um(x,t)\big)\big\|_{L^\infty}\times \|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{TV}\times\|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{L^\infty}. \nonumber \end{eqnarray} To upper bound the first term we use standard decay estimate, $|\sigma_j\widehat{u}_N(j)(t)|\lesssim {\|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{TV}}/(1+|j|)$. Noting that $P_{2m}-\SR$ annihilates the first $m/2$ modes, namely, the multipliers $\widehat{P_{2m}\!\!-\!\!\SR}(k)=0, \ |k|\leq m/2=N/3$, we find \begin{align} \big\|(P_{2m}&-\SR)\Big(\varphi(x)\um(x,t)\Big)\big\|_{L^\infty} \nonumber \\ & \leq \sum_{\frac{m}{2} \leq |k|\leq 2m} (1-\sigma_k)\Big| \sum_{|j|\leq m}\widehat{\varphi}(k-j)\sigma_j\widehat{u}_N(j,t)\Big| \nonumber \\ & \lesssim \sum_{\frac{m}{2} \leq |k|\leq 2m} \sqrt{\sum_{|j|\leq m} (1+|k-j|^2)|\widehat{\varphi}(k-j)|^2} \cdot \sqrt{\sum_{|j|\leq m} \frac{1}{(1+|k-j|^2)(1+|j|^2)}} \times \|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{TV} \\ & \lesssim \|\varphi\|_{H^1}\|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{TV} \times \frac{1}{\sqrt{m}}. \nonumber \end{align} \end{subequations} The last two inequalities (\ref{sub:eqs}) give us, \[ \Big|\int\varphi(x)\um(x,t) \frac{\partial}{\partial x}(\Id-\SR)[\um^2](x,t)dx\Big| \lesssim \frac{1}{\sqrt{m}}\|\um(\cdot,t)\|^2_{TV}\times \|\um(\cdot,t)\|_{L^\infty} \times \|\varphi\|_{H^1}. \] We claim that (\ref{eq:instab}) holds by contradiction. If it fails, then we can choose a subsequence, $u_{m_k}$, such that \[ \frac{1}{m_k}\|u_{m_k}(\cdot,t)\|^2_{TV}\times \|u_{m_k}(\cdot,t)\|_{L^\infty} \leq c_k, \qquad c_k \downarrow 0, \] and the energy production on the right of (\ref{eq:entropy}) vanishes in $H^{-1}$. By assumption $\um^r(\cdot,t) \in L^2$ for $r=1,2,3$ and the div-curl lemma, \cite{Mu78,Tar79,Tar87} applies: it follows that $\overline{u}$ is in fact a \emph{strong} $L^2$-limit, $u_{m_k} \rightarrow \overline{u}$. Passing to the weak limit in (\ref{eq:23res})${}_{m_k}$ we have that $\overline{u}$ is weak solution of Burgers' equation (\ref{eq:burgers}), \[ \frac{\partial}{\partial t}\overline{u}(x,t)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big(\frac{\overline{u}^2(x,t)}{2}\Big)=0. \] Moreover, passing to the weak limit in the energy balance (\ref{eq:entropy})${}_{m_k}$, we conclude that $\overline{u}$ satisfies the quadratic entropy \emph{equality} \[ \frac{\partial}{\partial t}\Big(\frac{\overline{u}^2(x,t)}{2}\Big)+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big(\frac{\overline{u}^3(x,t)}{3}\Big)=0. \] But, due to the uniqueness enforced with by the single entropy -- in this case, the $L^2$ energy, \cite{Pan94}, there exists no energy \emph{conservative} weak solution of Burgers equation (\ref{eq:burgers}) after the critical time of shock formation. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:smoo} The same result of instability holds if we employ the pseudo-spectral Fourier method with a general smoothing operator beyond just the $2/3$ smoothing, namely $\SRu_N= \sum_{|k|\leq N} \sigma_k \hat{u}_ke^{ikx}$ and smoothing factors $\sigma_k$ decay too fast as $|k|\uparrow N$. \end{remark} \section{Fourier method for Euler equations: convergence for smooth solutions}\label{sec:smoothEuler} Convergence of the spectral and pseudo-spectral approximation for the Burgers equation made use of its quadratic flux, ${u^2}/2$. The same approach can be pursued for the Euler equations, \begin{equation}\label{eq:euler} \frac{\part}{\part t} {\mathbf u} +\Lr\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf u}\otimes {\mathbf u})=0, \qquad \mathbf x \in {\mathbb T}^d, \end{equation} where $\Lr:=Id- \nabla_{\bx}\Delta^{-1}\text{div}_\mathbf x$ is the Leray projection into divergence free vector fields. \subsection{Convergence of spectral Fourier approximation for Euler equations} The spectral method for the Euler equations reads \begin{equation}\label{eq:Eulerapp} \frac{\part}{\part t} {\mathbf u}_N +\Lr\nabla_{\bx} \SN({\mathbf u}_N\otimes {\mathbf u}_N)=0. \end{equation} Convergence for smooth solutions in this case, is in fact even simpler than in Burgers' equation. Observe that for any divergence free vectors fields, ${\mathbf v}$ and ${\mathbf u}$, the following identity holds \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:identity} \int \left\langle \big({\mathbf v}\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf v}\otimes {\mathbf v})-{\mathbf v}\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf u}\otimes {\mathbf u})\big), {\mathbf v}-{\mathbf u}\right\rangle d\mathbf x \equiv \int \left\langle ({\mathbf v}-{\mathbf u}), \text{S}[{\mathbf u}]\,({\mathbf v}-{\mathbf u})\right\rangle d\mathbf x, \nonumber \end{eqnarray} where $\text{S}[{\mathbf u}]$ is the symmetric part of the stress tensor $\text{S}[{\mathbf u}]:= \frac12 (\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u} +\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}^\top)$. We therefore have, \[ \left|\int \left\langle \Lr\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf u}_N\otimes {\mathbf u}_N)-\Lr\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf u}\otimes {\mathbf u}),({\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf u})\right\rangle d\mathbf x\right|\le |\!|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}|\!|_{L^\infty}|\!|{\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf u}|\!|_{L^2}^2, \] The error equation \[ \frac{\part}{\part t} ({\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf u}) + \Lr\nabla_{\bx}({\mathbf u}_N\otimes {\mathbf u}_N) - \Lr\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf u}\otimes {\mathbf u}) = (I-\SN) \Lr\nabla_{\bx}({\mathbf u}_N\otimes {\mathbf u}_N), \] implies \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{\frac12\frac{d}{dt}|\!|{\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf u}|\!|_{L^2}^2} \nonumber \\ & &\le |\!|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}|\!|_{L^\infty}|\!|{\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf u}|\!|_{L^2}^2 +\left|\int \left\langle (I-\SN) [\Lr\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf u}_N\otimes {\mathbf u}_N)],{\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf u}\right\rangle d\mathbf x\right| \label{eq:Eulerl2} \\ & & \le |\!|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}|\!|_{L^\infty}|\!|{\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf u}|\!|_{L^2}^2 +\left|\int \left\langle \left((I-\SN)\nabla{\mathbf u}\right){\mathbf u}_N,{\mathbf u}_N\right\rangle d\mathbf x\right|. \nonumber \end{eqnarray} Arguing along the lines of our convergence statement for Burgers equations we conclude that the following result holds. \begin{theorem}[{\bf Spectral convergence for smooth solutions of Euler equations}]\label{thm:Euler_spectral} Assume that for $0<t<T_c$, the solution of the Euler equations \eqref{eq:euler} is smooth, ${\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\in L^\infty\left([0,T_c), C^{1+\alpha}(\pil,\pir]\right)$. Then its spectral Fourier approximation \eqref{eq:Eulerapp} converges in $L^\infty\left([0,T_c], L^2({\mathbb T}^d)\right)$, \[ \|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0, \qquad 0\leq t < T_c, \] and the following spectral convergence rate estimate holds \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|^2} \\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle {2\!\!\int_0^t|\nabla {\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}}\!\!\!\left(N^{-2s}\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s} + N^{\frac{d}{2}+1-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right)\!, \ \ s>\frac{d}{2}+1. \end{eqnarray*} \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Integrating (\ref{eq:Eulerapp}) against ${\mathbf u}_N$ we find the usual statement of $L^2$ energy conservation, \[ \|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2}= \|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2}. \] Using (\ref{eq:Eulerl2}), we conclude \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2} \lesssim e^{2U'_\infty(t;0)} \|(I-\SN){\mathbf u}(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2}} \\ & & + \|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,0)\|_{L^2}^2\int_{0}^t e^{2U'_\infty(t;\tau)}\|(I-\SN)\nabla{\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)\|_{L^\infty} d\tau, \quad U'_\infty(t;\tau):= \int_{s=\tau}^t\|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}(\cdot,s)\|_{L^\infty}ds, \end{eqnarray*} which yields the spectral convergence rate estimate \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:spEulerrate} \lefteqn{\|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2}}\\ & & \lesssim e^{2U'_\infty(t;0)} \left(N^{-2s}\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s} + N^{-s+\frac{d}{2}+1}\max_{\tau\leq t} \|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \qquad s>\frac{d}{2}+1. \nonumber \end{eqnarray} Observe that the error estimate in the case of Euler equation depends on the truncation error of $\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}$, corresponding to the dependence on the truncation error of $u_x$ in Burgers equation. The additional loss factor of $d/2$ is due to the $L^\infty({\mathbb T}^d)$-bound, $\max_\mathbf x |(I-\SN){\mathbf w}(\mathbf x)| \lesssim \|{\mathbf w}\|_{H^s}$ for $s>d/2$, consult (\ref{eq:maxHs}). \end{proof} \subsection{The $2/3$ pseudo-spectral approximation of Euler equations} The pseudo-spectral Fourier method for the Euler equations reads \[ \frac{\part}{\part t} {\mathbf u}_N +\Lr \nabla_{\bx} \IN({\mathbf u}_N\otimes {\mathbf u}_N)=0, \] Observe that since $\IN$ does not commute with $\Lr \nabla_{\bx}$, there is no $L^2$-energy conservation. We introduce the smoothing operator $\SR{\mathbf u}_N:=\sum_{|k|\leq m} \sigma_k \widehat{{\mathbf u}}_k(t)$ which acts on wavenumbers $|k|\leq m=\frac{2}{3} N$, while leaving the first $1/3$ portion of the spectrum unchanged: $\sigma_k=\sigma(|k|/N)$, where $\sigma(1-\sigma)$ is supported in $(\frac{1}{3},\frac{2}{3})$. The resulting $2/3$ de-aliasing pseudo-spectral method reads \begin{equation}\label{eq:Eulerpsapp} \frac{\part}{\part t} {\mathbf u}_N+\Lr \nabla_{\bx} \IN(\SR{\mathbf u}_N\otimes \SR{\mathbf u}_N)=0. \end{equation} It is the $2/3$ Fourier method which is being used in actual computations, e.g., \cite{OHFS10,KH89,Kerr93,Kerr05} and the references therein. Next, we act with the smoothing $\SR$: arguing along the lines of the $2/3$ method for the Burgers' equation in corollary \ref{cor:special}, we find that the ${{\mathbf u}_m}:=\SR{\mathbf u}_N$ satisfies the aliasing-free equation \begin{equation}\label{eq:Eulerpsp} \frac{\part}{\part t} {{\mathbf u}_m}+ \SR\Lr \nabla_{\bx} ({{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m})=0. \end{equation} Observe that since $\SR$ commutes with differentiation, ${{\mathbf u}_m}$ retains incompressibility, \[ \frac{\part}{\part t} {{\mathbf u}_m}+\Lr \nabla_{\bx} \SR ({{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m})=0. \] As before, we can integrate against ${\mathbf u}_N$ to find by incompressibility of ${{\mathbf u}_m}$, \[ \frac12 \frac{d}{dt} \int \langle {\mathbf u}_N(\mathbf x,t), {{\mathbf u}_m}(\mathbf x,t)\rangle d\mathbf x = -\int \left\langle \SR{\mathbf u}_N, \Lr \nabla_{\bx} ({{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m})\right\rangle d\mathbf x =0, \] which implies the weighted $L^2_{\SR}$-energy conservation, \begin{equation}\label{eq:pspsEulercons} \|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2_{\SR}} = \|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2_{\SR}}, \qquad \|{\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2_{\SR}}:=(2\pi)^d\sum \sigma_\mathbf k|\widehat{{\mathbf u}}_\mathbf k(t)|^2. \end{equation} \begin{theorem}[{\bf Spectral convergence of $2/3$ method for smooth Euler solutions}]\label{thm:Euler_pspectral} Assume that for $0<t<T_c$, the solution of the Euler equations \eqref{eq:euler} is smooth, ${\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\in L^\infty\left([0,T_c), C^{1+\alpha}(\pil,\pir]\right)$. Then, the smoothed solution ${{\mathbf u}_m}=\SR{\mathbf u}_N$ of its $2/3$ de-aliasing pseudo-spectral Fourier approximation \eqref{eq:Eulerpsapp} converges in $L^\infty\left([0,T_c],L^2({\mathbb T}^d)\right)$, \[ \|{{\mathbf u}_m}(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0, \qquad 0\leq t < T_c, \] and the following spectral convergence rate estimate holds \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\|{{\mathbf u}_m}(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2}}\\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle {2\!\!\int_0^t\!|\nabla {\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}}\left(N^{-2s}\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s} + N^{\frac{d}{2}+1-s}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right), \quad s>\frac{d}{2}+1. \end{eqnarray*} \end{theorem} \begin{proof} We rewrite (\ref{eq:Eulerpsp}) in the form \[ \frac{\part}{\part t} {{\mathbf u}_m}+ \Lr \nabla_{\bx} ({{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m})=(I-\SR)\left(\Lr \nabla_{\bx} ({{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m})\right). \] Subtract the exact equation (\ref{eq:euler}): using the identity (\ref{eq:identity}) we find, as before \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:Eulerpspl2} \lefteqn{\quad \frac12\frac{d}{dt}\|{{\mathbf u}_m}-{\mathbf u}\|_{L^2}^2} \nonumber \\ & & \leq \|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}\|_{L^\infty}\|{{\mathbf u}_m}-{\mathbf u}\|_{L^2}^2 +\left|\int \left\langle (I-\SR) [\Lr\nabla_{\bx} ({{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m})],{{\mathbf u}_m}-{\mathbf u}\right\rangle d\mathbf x\right|\\ & & \leq \|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}\|_{L^\infty}\|{{\mathbf u}_m}-{\mathbf u}\|_{L^2}^2 +\left|\int \left\langle \left((I-\SR)\nabla_{\bx}{\mathbf u}\right){{\mathbf u}_m},{{\mathbf u}_m}\right\rangle d\mathbf x\right| \nonumber \\ & & \ \ \ + \left|\int \left\langle \left((I-\SR)\nabla_{\bx}{{\mathbf u}_m}\right){{\mathbf u}_m},{{\mathbf u}_m}\right\rangle d\mathbf x\right| . \nonumber \end{eqnarray} The last term on the right is due to the fact that $(I-\SR)$ need not annihilate $\nabla_{\bx}{{\mathbf u}_m}$. However, since ${{\mathbf u}_m}$ is incompressible, we find \begin{eqnarray*} \int \left\langle \left((I-\SR)\nabla_{\bx}{{\mathbf u}_m}\right){{\mathbf u}_m},{{\mathbf u}_m}\right\rangle d\mathbf x & = & \sum_{\alpha,\beta}\int {{\mathbf u}_m}_\alpha \partial_\alpha{{\mathbf u}_m}_\beta (I-\SR){{\mathbf u}_m}_\beta d\mathbf x \\ & = & \sum_{\alpha,\beta}\int {{\mathbf u}_m}_\alpha \frac{1}{2}\partial_\alpha \left({{\mathbf u}_m}_\beta (I-\SR){{\mathbf u}_m}_\beta\right)d\mathbf x \\ & = & -\frac{1}{2} \int \sum_\alpha \partial_\alpha {{\mathbf u}_m}_\alpha \sum_\beta \left({{\mathbf u}_m}_\beta (I-\SR){{\mathbf u}_m}_\beta\right)d\mathbf x =0. \end{eqnarray*} We end up with the error bound \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\|{{\mathbf u}_m}(\cdot,t)-{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2} \lesssim e^{2{U'_\infty(t;0)}} \|(I-\SR){\mathbf u}(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2}} \\ & & + \|{{\mathbf u}_m}(\cdot,0)\|_{L_{\SR}^2}^2\int_{0}^t \!\!e^{{2U'_\infty(t;\tau)}}\|(I-\SR)\nabla_{\bx}{\mathbf u}(\cdot,\tau)\|_{L^\infty} d\tau, \quad U'_\infty(t;\tau):=\int_{s=\tau}^t\!\!\!\!\|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf u}(\cdot,s)\|_{L^\infty}ds, \end{eqnarray*} and spectral convergence rate follows. \end{proof} \if \begin{remark} \myb{We note that the $L^2$-error estimates stated in theorems \ref{thm:Euler_spectral} and \ref{thm:Euler_pspectral} do not imply the convergence in more regular norm and therefore do not exclude some oscillations. On the other hand the (pseudo-) spectral approximations conserves the energy and therefore anomalous dissipation of energy should not appears even if the exact solution $u(t)$ does not remain smooth.} \}\}\} \end{remark} \f \section{Fourier method for Euler equations: failure of convergence for weak solutions?}\label{sec:nonsmoothEuler} We now consider the convergence of the $2/3$ method (\ref{eq:Eulerpsapp}) for weak solutions of Euler equations. Its $m$-mode de-aliased solution is governed by (\ref{eq:Eulerpsp}) \begin{equation}\label{eq:Eulerpspb} \frac{\part}{\part t} {{\mathbf u}_m} + \SR\Lr\nabla_{\bx} \left({{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m}\right)=0. \end{equation} The method is energy preserving in the sense that $\SR^{1/2}{\mathbf u}_N$ is $L^2$-conservative, (\ref{eq:pspsEulercons}), and hence ${{\mathbf u}_m}=\SR{\mathbf u}_N$ has s a weak limit, $\overline{\mathbf u}$. The question is to characterize whether $\overline{\mathbf u}(x,t)$ is an energy conserving weak solution of Euler equations (\ref{eq:euler}), \begin{equation}\label{eq:cdeu} \frac{\part}{\part t} \overline{\mathbf u} +\Lr\nabla_{\bx} (\overline{\mathbf u}\otimes \overline{\mathbf u})=0. \end{equation} To this end we compare (\ref{eq:Eulerpsapp}) and (\ref{eq:cdeu}): since ${{\mathbf u}_m}$ tends weakly to $\overline{\mathbf u}$ and $\partial_t {{\mathbf u}_m} \rightharpoonup \partial_t\overline{\mathbf u}$, then comparing the remaining spatial parts of (\ref{eq:Eulerpsapp}) and (\ref{eq:cdeu}), yields that $\SR\Lr[{{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m}](x,t)$ and hence $\Lr[{{\mathbf u}_m}\otimes {{\mathbf u}_m}](x,t)$ tends weakly to $\Lr[\overline{\mathbf u}\otimes\overline{\mathbf u}](x,t)$. This, however, is not enough to imply the strong convergence of $u_N$, as shown by a simple counterexample of a 2D potential flow, ${\mathbf u}_n=\nabla_{\bx}^\perp \Phi_n$ where \[ \Phi_n(x_1,x_2) = \frac1n\Xi(x_1,x_2)(\sin n x_1+ \sin n x_2) \] with $\Xi(x_1,x_2)\in \mathcal{D} (\Bbb{R}^2)$ localized near any point (say $(0,0)$) with weak limit $\overline{\mathbf u} \equiv 0$. In this case $w\,\mbox{-}\lim_{N\rightarrow \infty} \nabla \Lr(u_N\otimes u_N)= \nabla \Lr(\overline{\mathbf u}\otimes \overline{\mathbf u}) = 0$, yet \[ w\,\mbox{-}\!\!\!\lim_{N\rightarrow \infty} ({u_N}_1)^2= w\,\mbox{-}\!\!\!\lim_{N\rightarrow \infty} ({u_N}_2)^2 = \frac{\Xi(x_1,x_2)^2}2 \neq 0. \] Although $\overline{\mathbf u}$ need not be a weak solution of Euler equations, it satisfies a weaker notion of a \emph{dissipative solution} in the sense of DiPerna-Lions \cite{Lions96} To this end, let ${\mathbf w}$ a divergence-free smooth solution of \begin{equation}\label{eq:Eulerw} \partial_t {\mathbf w} + \Lr(\nabla {\mathbf w}\otimes {\mathbf w} ) =E({\mathbf w}), \qquad \Lr E({\mathbf w})=0. \end{equation} Now, compare it with the $2/3$ solution (\ref{eq:Eulerpspb}): the same computation with Gronwall lemma leads to, \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\|({\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf w})(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2(\Omega)} \le e^{2 {W'_\infty(t;0)}} |\!|({\mathbf u}_N-{\mathbf w})(\cdot,0) |\!|^2_{L^2(\Omega)}} \\ & & \quad + 2\| {\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,0)\|^2_{L^2(\Omega)} \int_0^t \|(P_N{\mathbf w}-{\mathbf w}))(\cdot,s) \|_{W^{1,\infty}(\Omega)} \\ & & \quad + 2 \int_0^t \!\!\!e^{2 {W'_\infty(t;\tau)}} \|(E({\mathbf w}(\tau)), {\mathbf u}_N(\tau)-{\mathbf w}(\tau))\| d\tau, \quad W'_\infty(t;\tau):=\int_{s=\tau}^t\!\!\!\!\|\nabla_{\bx} {\mathbf w}(\cdot,s)\|_{L^\infty(\Omega)}ds. \end{eqnarray*} Passing to the weak limit it follows that $\overline{\mathbf u}$ is a dissipative solution, satisfying for all divergence-free smooth solution of (\ref{eq:Eulerw}), the stability estimate \begin{eqnarray*} \|(\overline{\mathbf u}-{\mathbf w})(\cdot,t)\|^2_{L^2(\Omega)} & \le & e^{2{W'_\infty(t;0)}} \|(\overline{\mathbf u} -{\mathbf w})(\cdot,0) \|^2_{L^2(\Omega)} \\ & + & 2\int_0^t e^{2 {W'_\infty(t;\tau)}}\,|(E({\mathbf w}(\tau)), \overline{\mathbf u}(\tau) -{\mathbf w}(\tau)))|d\tau. \end{eqnarray*} The notion of dissipative solution can be instrumental in the context of stability near a smooth solution, ${\mathbf w}$, or even in the context of uniqueness. However, the construction of \cite{DLSz10} does not exclude the existence of rough initial data for which the Cauchy problem associated with Euler equations (\ref{eq:euler}) have an infinite set of dissipative solutions. In fact, it is observed in \cite{DLSz10} that any weak solution with a non-increasing energy, $\|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \leq \|{\mathbf u}(\cdot,0)\|_{L^2}$, is a dissipative solution. These, so-called admissible solutions, arise as solutions of the Cauchy problem for an infinite set of (rough) initial data, and can be obtained as strong limit in $C(0,T ;L^2_{\rm{weak}}(\Omega))$ of solutions for the problem \[ \partial_t {\mathbf u}_N + \Lr(\nabla_{\bx} ({\mathbf u}_N\otimes {\mathbf u}_N)= E_N \] with $w\,\mbox{-}lim E_N = 0$, while $\displaystyle \int \langle E_N,{\mathbf u}_N \rangle dx $ does not converge to $0$. We summarize the above observations, by stating that as long as the solution of the Euler equations remains sufficiently smooth, then its spectral and de-aliased pseudo-spectral approximations converge in $L^2(\Omega)$. Indeed, in theorems \ref{thm:Euler_spectral} and \ref{thm:Euler_pspectral}, we quantified the convergence rate for $H^s$-regular solutions ${\mathbf u}$. If ${\mathbf u}$ has a minimal smoothness such that the vorticity \mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}${}_N:=\nabla \times {\mathbf u}_N$ is compactly embedded in $C([0,T],H^{-1}(\Bbb{R}^N))$, then by the div-curl lemma, ${\mathbf u}_N(\cdot,t)$ converges strongly in $L^\infty([0,T],L^2_{loc}(\Bbb{R}^N))$ to an energy-preserving limit solution $\overline{\mathbf u}$, \cite{LNT00}. \smallskip\noindent The situation is different, however, when dealing with ``rough'' solutions of the underlying Euler equations. In the absence of any information re:the smoothness of the underlying Euler solutions (--- as loss of smoothness for the $3D$ Euler equations is still a challenging open problem), energy-preserving numerical method need not shed light on the question of global regularity vs. finite-time blow-up. Recall that $L^2$-energy conservation was conjectured by Onsager \cite{On49} and verified in \cite{Ey94,CET94,BT10} under the assumption of minimal smoothness of ${\mathbf u}$, but otherwise is not supported by the energy decreasing solutions of Euler equation, \cite{Co07,DeLS12, Buck13}. \smallskip\noindent The similar scenario of quadratic entropy conservation in the context of Burgers' equations, is responsible for spurious oscillations, and its detailed analysis can be found in \cite{La86} after \cite{vN63}. Here, enforcing energy conservation at the ``critical'' time when Euler solutions seem to lose sufficient smoothness leads to nonlinear instability which manifests itself through oscillations noticeable throughout the computational domain, in agreement with the numerical evidence observed in \cite{HL07}, see Figure \ref{fig:d}(a) below. The precise large-time behavior of the (pseudo-) spectral approximations is intimately related to a proper albeit yet unclear notion of propagating smoothness for solutions of Euler equations which, even if they do not explicitly blow up, may exhibit spurious oscillations due to the amplification factor in higher norms. \begin{figure}[ht] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{cc} \includegraphics[scale=0.6, height=100pt, width=214pt]{Hou_Li_vort_cont_da_1024_18.eps} & \includegraphics[scale=0.6, height=100pt, width=214pt]{Hou_Li_vort_cont_fs36_1024_18.eps} \\ \includegraphics[scale=0.6, height=100pt, width=214pt]{Hou_Li_vort_cont_da_1024_19.eps} & \includegraphics[scale=0.6, height=100pt, width=214pt]{Hou_Li_vort_cont_fs36_1024_19.eps}\\ (a) & (b) \end{tabular} \end{center} \caption{A comparison of axial vorticity contours of 3D Euler computation \cite{HL07} at $t=18$ (top) and at $t=19$ (bottom). On left(a): the solution obtained by the energy preserving $\frac{2}{3}$ de-aliasing method; on right (b): the solution obtained by an energy decreasing smoothing of the Fourier method. The resolution is $1024\times 768\times 2048$.}\label{fig:d} \end{figure} \section{The spectral viscosity method: nonlinear stability and spectral convergence}\label{sec:sv} The nonlinear instability results in sections \ref{sec:2-3rd} and \ref{sec:nonsmoothEuler} emphasize the competition between spectral convergence for smooth solutions vs. nonlinear instabilities for problems which lack sufficient smoothness. One class of methods for nonlinear evolution equations which entertain both --- spectral convergence and nonlinear stability, is the class \emph{spectral viscosity} (SV) methods, introduced in \cite{Tad89}. We demonstrate the SV method in the context of Burgers equation, \begin{subequations}\label{eqs:SVb} \begin{equation}\label{eq:SVb} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}u_N(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\Big( \IN\left[u_N^2\right](x,t) \Big)=SV[u_N](x,t), \qquad x\in {\mathbb T}([0,2\pi)). \end{equation} On the right of (\ref{eq:SVb}) we have added a judicious amount of spectral viscosity of order $2r$: \begin{equation}\label{eq:SV} SV[u_N](x,t):= -N\sum_{|k|\leq N}\sigma\left(\frac{|k|}{N}\right)\widehat{u}_k(t)e^{ikx}, \quad \sigma(\xi)\lesssim \left(|\xi|^{2r}-\frac{1}{N}\right)_+, \qquad r\geq1 \end{equation} \end{subequations} Without it, the pseudo-spectral solution will develops spurious Gibbs oscillations after the formation of shocks. Observe that the spectral viscosity term in (\ref{eq:SV}) adds a \emph{spectrally small} amount of numerical dissipation for high modes, $k \gg 1$ (in contrast for ''standard'' finite-order amount of numerical dissipation in finite-difference methods), \[ \|SV[w]\|_{\dot{H}^\alpha} \lesssim N^{1-(\alpha-\beta)(1-\frac{1}{2r})}\|w\|_{\dot{H}^\beta}, \qquad \forall \beta \ll \alpha-1 \in {\mathbb R}. \] Indeed, the low-pass SV filter on the right of (\ref{eq:SVb}) vanishes for modes $|k|\leq {N}^{(2r-1)/2r}$, which in turn leads to spectral convergence for smooth solutions. Arguing along the lines of theorem \ref{thm:pspsmooth} we state the following. \begin{theorem}[{\bf Spectral convergence for smooth solutions of Burgers' equations}]\label{thm:svsmoothb} Consider the Burgers equation, \eqref{eq:burgers}, with a smooth solution $u(\cdot,t)\in L^\infty\left([0,T_c], C^{1+\alpha}(\pil,\pir]\right)$. Then its spectral viscosity approximation \eqref{eqs:SVb}, \[ \frac{d}{dt}u_N(x_\nu,t)+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\left( \IN\left[u_N^2\right](x,t) \right)_{\big|x=x_\nu}=SV[u_N](x_\nu,t), \qquad \nu=0, 1, \ldots, 2N. \] converges, $\|u_N(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0$ for $0\leq t \leq T_c$ and the following spectral convergence rate estimate holds for all $s>\frac{3}{2}$, \begin{eqnarray*} \lefteqn{\|u_N(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|^2}\\ & & \lesssim e^{\displaystyle {\int_0^t|u_x(\cdot,\tau)|_\infty d\tau}} \left(N^{-2s}\|u(\cdot,0)\|^2_{H^s} + N^{\frac{2r-1}{2r}(\frac{3}{2}-s)}\max_{\tau\leq t}\|u(\cdot,\tau)\|_{H^s}\right)\!, \quad s>\frac{3}{2}. \end{eqnarray*} \end{theorem} At the same time, spectral viscosity is strong enough to enforce a sufficient amount of $L^2$ energy dissipation, which in turn implies convergence after the formation of shock discontinuities. We quote below the convergence statement of the hyper-SV method. \begin{theorem}[{\bf Convergence of the hyper-SV method for Burgers equation} \cite{Tad89,Tad93b,Tad04}]\label{thm:svshockb} Let $u$ be the unique entropy solution of the inviscid Burgers equation, \eqref{eq:burgers}, subject to uniformly bounded initial data $u_0$, and let $u_N$ be the spectral viscosity approximation \eqref{eqs:SVb} subject to $L^\infty$ data $u_N(0)\approx u_0$. Then, if $u_N$ remains uniformly bounded\footnote{The question of uniform boundedness of $u_N$ was proved for the second order SV method, corresponding to $r=1$, in \cite{Tad93a}, but it remains open for the hyper SV case with $r>1$.} it converges to the unique entropy solution, $\|u_N(\cdot,t)-u(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0$. \end{theorem} \begin{remark} We note that unlike the $2/3$ de-aliasing method, the SV method does \emph{not} completely remove the high-frequencies but instead, it introduces ``just the right amount'' of smoothing for $|k|\gg1$ which enables to balance spectral accuracy with nonlinear stability. The SV method can be viewed as a proper smoothing which addresses the instability of general smoothing of the pseudo-spectral Fourier method sought in remark \ref{rem:smoo}. Moreover, even after the formation of shock discontinuities, the SV solution still contains highly accurate information of the exact entropy solution which can be extracted by post-processing, \cite{SW95}. \end{remark} Similar results of spectral convergence of SV methods hold in the context of incompressible Euler equations, \cite{KK00,SS07,AX09}, \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:sveu} \lefteqn{\frac{\part}{\part t} {\mathbf u}_N + \Lr\nabla_{\bx} \IN\left(\SR{\mathbf u}_N\otimes \SR{\mathbf u}_N\right)=SV[{\mathbf u}_N],} \\ & & \qquad \qquad SV[{\mathbf u}_N](\mathbf x,t):= -N\sum_{|\mathbf k|\leq N}\sigma\left(\frac{|\mathbf k|}{N}\right)\widehat{{\mathbf u}}_\mathbf k(t)e^{i\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf x}. \nonumber \end{eqnarray} In contrast to the spurious oscillations with the $2/3$ methods shown in figure \ref{fig:d}(a), the oscillations-free results in \ref{fig:d}(b) correspond to the proper amount of smoothing employed in \cite{HL07}. Thus, the issue of adding ``just the right amount'' of hyper-viscosity is particularly relevant in this context of Large Eddy Simulation (LES) for highly turbulent flows, when one needs to strike a balance between a sufficient amount of numerical dissipation for stability without giving up on high-order accuracy for physically relevant Euler (and Navier-Stokes solutions). The SV method in (\ref{eq:sveu}) adds this balanced amount of hyper-viscoisty, \cite{KK00,GP03,SK04,SS07,PSSBS07}. \section{Beyond quadratic nonlinearities: 1D isentropic equations}\label{sec:isen} We consider the one-dimensional isentropic equations in Lagrangian coordinate, \begin{subequations}\label{eqs:isen} \begin{eqnarray} && \frac{\part}{\part t} u +\frac{\part}{\part x} q(v)=0, \quad q'(v)>0\\ &&\frac{\part}{\part t} v+\frac{\part}{\part x} u=0, \end{eqnarray} \end{subequations} which is approximated by the spectral method \begin{subequations}\label{eqs:specisen} \begin{eqnarray} &&\frac{\part}{\part t} u_N +\frac{\part}{\part x} q(v_N)=(I-\SN)q(v_N),\\ &&\frac{\part}{\part t} v_N+\frac{\part}{\part x} u_N=0. \end{eqnarray} \end{subequations} Denote by $U$ the vector of conservative variables, $U:=(u,v)^\top$, by $F(U)$ the corresponding flux, $F(U):=(q(v),u)^\top$ and let $\eta(U)$ be the entropy $\eta(U):=\frac12|u|^2+ Q(v), \ Q'(v)=q(v)$. Multiplying the system by $\nabla_U \eta(U)$ and integrating gives: \[ \frac d{dt} \int\left(\frac{|u_N|^2}2 + u_N \partial_x q(v_N)+ q(v_N)\partial_x u_N\right)dx=\int (I-\SN)q(v_N)u_Ndx=0 \] and hence there the total entropy is conserved for both the exact an approximate solutions\footnote{This intriguing property seems specific to the isentropic equation in Lagrangian coordinate.} \[ \partial_t\int \eta(U)dx=0 \quad \hbox{and} \quad \partial_t\int \eta(U_N)dx=0. \] Continuing as in DiPerna-Chen \cite{DiP83,Ch97,Daf79}, we write \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{\partial_t\int \left(\eta(U_N)-\eta(U)-\left\langle \eta'(U),U_n-U\right\rangle \right)dx=} \nonumber \\ && \quad \int \left\langle \eta''(U)U_t, (U_N-U)\right\rangle dx- \int \left\langle \eta'(U),(U_N)_t-U_t \right\rangle dx= \label{eq:abx}\\ &&-\int \left\langle \eta''(U)F(U)_x, U_N-U\right\rangle dx-\int \left\langle \eta'(U), F(U_N))_x- F(U)_x\right\rangle dx+ \hbox{error term}\nonumber \\ & & =:{\mathcal I}_1+{\mathcal I}_2+{\mathcal I}_3\nonumber \end{eqnarray} The first two terms on the right amount to \begin{eqnarray*} |{\mathcal I}_1+{\mathcal I}_2|&= &\Big|\int \left\langle \eta''(U) F(U)_x, U_N-U \right\rangle dx+\int \left\langle \eta'(U), F(U_N)_x-F(U)_x \right\rangle dx\Big|\\ & =&\Big|\int \left\langle \eta''(U) F'(U) U_x, U_N-U\right\rangle dx -\left\langle \eta''(U)U_x, F(U_N)-F(U)\right\rangle dx\Big|\\ & = &\Big|\int \left\langle \eta''(U) F'(U) U_x, U_N-U\right\rangle dx -\left\langle \eta''(U)U_x, F'(U)U_x +{\mathcal O}\|U_N-U\|^2\right\rangle dx\Big|. \end{eqnarray*} Since the entropy Hessian symmetrize the system, one has $\eta''(U) F'(U)= F'(U) \eta''(U)$, and we conclude that the last expression does not exceed $$ |{\mathcal I}_1+{\mathcal I}_2|= \Big|\int \left\langle \eta''(U) F'(U) U_x, U_N-U\right\rangle dx -\left\langle \eta''(U) U_x, F(U_N)-F(U)\right\rangle dx\Big|\lesssim \|U\|_{C^1}\|U_N-U\|^2 $$ On the other hand $$ {\mathcal I}_3= \hbox{error term}=\int (I-\SN)q_x(v_N)(u-u_N) dx =\int \partial_x q(v_N) (I-\SN)u_xdx $$ which goes to zero for sufficiently smooth $u \in C^{1+\alpha}$. Inserting the last two bound into (\ref{eq:abx}) we find that \[ \partial_t\int \left(\eta(U_N)-\eta(U)-\left\langle \eta'(U),U_n-U\right\rangle \right)dx \lesssim \|U\|_{C^1}\|U_N-U\|^2 + {o}(1). \] By strict convexity, the integrand on the left is of order $\sim \|U_N-U\|^2$ and we conclude the following. \begin{theorem} Assume that for $0<t<T_c$, the solution of the isentropic Euler equations \eqref{eqs:isen} is smooth, $U(\cdot,t)\in L^\infty\left([0,T_c), C^{1+\alpha}(\pil,\pir]\right)$. Then, its spectral approximation \eqref{eqs:specisen} converge in $L^\infty_t L^2_x$, \[ \|U_N(\cdot,t)-U(\cdot,t)\|_{L^2} \rightarrow 0, \qquad 0\leq t < T_c. \] \end{theorem} \bibliographystyle{plain}

Introduction {#Sec1} ============ *Oropouche virus* (OROV) belongs to one of the largest and most diversified families of RNA virus, the *Orthobunyaviridae*, which include several Arboviruses responsible for many important acute but self-limiting febrile illnesses in humans and also hemorrhagic fevers and encephalitis^[@CR1],[@CR2]^. In regard to the epidemiologic aspects, a recent review reported that over the past 60 years, more than 30 outbreaks, comprising more than half a million clinical cases, have been attributed to OROV fever including affected areas in Brazil, Peru, Panama, Trinidad and Tobago. In Brazil, the Amazon region has been stricken for the largest OROV fever epidemics and is the largest endemic area for OROV^[@CR3],[@CR4]^. In fact, until recently, OROV fever was the second most frequent arboviral infection in Brazil, surpassed only by dengue. Now due the recent *Chikungunya and Zika viruses* epidemics, OROV fever is considered the 4^th^ most prevalent arbovirus disease in the country. OROV is raising public agencies concern due to its prospective to spread geographically and emerge in naïve areas, which calls to its importance at an international panorama. The OROV disease starts by an infected arthropod bite, frequently by the midge *Culicoides paraensis*, its main urban vector, allowing for viral entry and replication in the muscle cells, followed by systemic dissemination to several organs and blood that results in high viremia detected between 2--4 days of symptoms onset^[@CR4]^. Clinically, OROV fever can be characterized as acute febrile disease, with common symptoms and signs such as skin rash, headache, fever, muscle and joint pain^[@CR3]^. The virus may cause meningitis, resulting in typical clinical manifestations of meningeal irritation; then it crosses the blood-brain barrier and infects neurons, producing encephalitis in more susceptible individuals^[@CR5]^. Nevertheless, OROV fever is usually not diagnosed because of its mild and self-limited manifestations or eventually mistakenly diagnosed due to its similar clinical features with dengue, chikungunya, zika, other arboviral diseases and even malaria^[@CR4]^. Usually, serologic tests, using distinct antigens have been employed for the diagnosis of OROV infection based on the detection of specific IgG and IgM antibodies^[@CR4]^. Despite the fact that seroconversion, detected by IgG and/or IgM ELISA upon OROV infection, is the "gold standard" method in epidemiological survey, in our clinical experience a time-dependent divergence in seroconversion after disease onset has been frequently observed. Indeed, while some patients already present IgM/IgG seropositivity upon disease onset, others exhibit late seroconversion profile, which may yield false negative diagnosis of OROV infection during the acute-phase disease. Little is known on the immunological events triggered during the infection that lead to early and late seroconversion after OROV fever. The analysis of immunological biomarkers may contribute to understanding of the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon. In general, viral infections trigger the immune system resulting in activation of innate and adaptive cells toward the production of a strong inflammatory response mediated by several inflammatory cytokines and chemokines, such as type I interferon (IFN), that are essential for antiviral defense. In general, type I IFN signaling is well known to be able to trigger expression of several hundred of genes, involved in the blockage of viral entry, replication, translation and assembly, as well as modulate inflammation and adaptive immunity^[@CR6]^. Type I IFN response is triggered at early stages of virus replicative cycle and its importance has being demonstrated in the mouse model of OROV disease^[@CR7]^. Moreover, *in vitro* experiments have shown that IFN-β mRNA levels increase in the first hour post-infection and drop rapidly reaching very low levels at 24 hours post infection^[@CR7]^. However, how cytokine kinetics develops during human OROV fever has not yet been reported. Thus, the present study aimed at investigating soluble immunological biomarkers including circulating cytokines and chemokines in early and late seroconverters along days after OROV fever onset. The results show conspicuous differences in the cytokine and chemokine levels between these two groups, which suggest that the innate immune response pattern harnessed by OROV is closely associated to seroconversion. Results {#Sec2} ======= Serological status of patients with acute-phase OROV fever according to disease onset {#Sec3} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In order to identify the profile of circulating IgM/IgG anti-OROV in patients with acute infection, serum samples from patients at different days upon disease onset were evaluated by MAC ELISA. Patients who were diagnosed as positive for OROV disease by RT-qPCR were subdivided as positive (IgM/IgGPos, n = 48) or negative (IgM/IgGNeg, n = 27) according to serology at baseline (Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}, top panel). The results demonstrated a profile characteristic of early and late seroconversion. Two clusters were observed when IgM/IgG titers were evaluated: (i) patients displaying high titers since the beginning of disease onset, classified as early seroconverters and (ii) patients showing high titers around 8 days after disease onset, considered as late seroconverters (Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}, middle panels). These two clusters were again subdivided into 4 groups according to days of disease onset: 1--3, 4--7, 8--10 and ≥11. IgM/IgG titers in early seroconverters were higher than late seroconverters at 1--3 and 4--7 subgroups.Figure 1Serological profile of circulating IgM/IgG in acute-phase OROV fever patients at different days upon disease onset. IgM/IgG titers were measured by MAC-ELISA and OROV patients classified as positive (n = 48) or negative (n = 27), according to the IgM/IgG serology at baseline (top graph). Antibody titers were determined along the days after disease onset and displayed in scatter plot as the continuous-time to depict two clusters of OROV fever patients classified as early and late seroconverters (middle graphs). Bars charts represent the mean titers with standard errors (reverse of serum dilution) of 4 subgroups of early and late seroconverters, according to days of disease onset (1--3, 4--7, 8--10 and ≥11). Multiple comparisons amongst groups were carried out by Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Dunn's post-test for sequential pairwise comparisons. Asterisks underscore differences amongst subgroups. \*\*p ≤ 0.01, \*\*\*p ≤ 0.001 (bottom graphs). However, both seroconversion clusters (early and late) presented distinct and significantly different IgM/IgG titers amongst early (1--3 and 4--7) as compared to late (8--10 and ≥11) time points (Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}, bottom panels). Overall profile of circulating chemokines and cytokines of patients with OROV fever {#Sec4} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The overall chemokine and cytokine profiles were assessed by flow cytometry in plasma samples from acute-phase OROV fever patients categorized according to IgM/IgG serology results at baseline as early (IgM/IgGPos at baseline) or late (IgM/IgGNeg at baseline) seroconverters (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). The results showed that OROV fever patients presented higher levels of CXCL8 and IFN-α (pink background) and lower levels of TNF and IL-10 than HD (blue background), regardless of antibody profile at baseline. Early seroconverters showed lower levels of CCL2, CXCL10 and IFN-γ (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}, blue background). Conversely, late seroconverters presented higher levels of CCL2, CXCL10, IL-6 and IL-17A as compared to HD (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}, pink background). Moreover, higher levels of CCL2, CXCL10, IFN-α, IL-6 and IL-17 were observed in late seroconverters as compared to early seroconverters (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}, pink background).Figure 2Levels of serum chemokines and cytokines in acute-phase OROV fever- patients with early and late seroconverters. Serum biomarkers (CXCL8, CCL21, CXCL9, CXCL10, IFN-α, IL-6, IL-17, TNF, IFN-γ, IL-5 and IL-10) were measured by CBA assay, as described in methods, in acute-phase OROV fever patients classified as early (n = 48, read circles) or late (n = 27, orange circles) seroconverters during disease onset and healthy donors (HD = 60, grey circles). Data are expressed as scattering of individual values (pg/mL). Multiple comparisons amongst groups were carried out by Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Dunn's post-test for sequential pairwise comparisons and significant differences depicted as asterisks and connecting lines. Colored backgrounds highlighted increased (light pink), decreased (light blue) and unaltered (gray) levels of serum biomarkers in OROV subgroups as compared to HD, and differences are underscored by asterisks. \*p ≤ 0.05, \*\*p ≤ 0.01, \*\*\*p ≤ 0.001. Kinetics of circulating chemokines and cytokines of patients with acute-phase OROV fever {#Sec5} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The timeline kinetics of chemokine and cytokine levels were determined at 1--3, 4--7, 8--10 and ≥ 11 days after disease onset in plasma of OROV fever patients classified as early and late seroconverters (Figs. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"} and [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). Higher levels of CXCL8 were observed throughout the timeline kinetics in both groups as compared to HD (grey zone). Distinct kinetics of CCL2 production was observed in early versus late seroconverters. While early seroconverters displayed lower levels of CCL2 at 1--3 and 4--7 days and higher levels at 8--10 and ≥ 11 days after disease onset, late seroconverters displayed higher levels only at 1--3 days of disease onset as compared to both HD and the time point ≥ 11 days after disease onset. Lower levels of CXCL9 were observed in early seroconverters at ≥ 11 days after disease onset. Interestingly, lower levels of CXCL10 were observed in almost all the time points tested in patients classified as early seroconverters, while in those considered late seroconverters the CXCL10 production was augmented at 1--3 and 4--7 days of disease onset as compared to HD. Moreover, in late seroconverters, higher levels of CXCL10 were also observed at 1--3 days as compared to 8--10 and ≥ 11 days after disease onset (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}).Figure 3Kinetics of circulating chemokines in acute-phase OROV fever patients in different days upon disease onset. Levels of CXCL8, CCL2, CXCL9 and CXCL10 assessed 1--3, 4--7, 8--10 and ≥11 days upon disease onset in plasma of OROV fever patients considered as early seroconverters (n = 48, left panels) or late seroconverters (n = 27, right panel). Bars represent mean with standard errors (pg/mL) and grey boxes the reference range corresponding the 95%CI of the mean for the HD group. Multiple comparisons amongst groups were carried out by Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Dunn's post-test for sequential pairwise comparisons and significant differences depicted as asterisks and connecting lines. Differences between HD and OROV fever subgroups in different days of disease are shown as asterisks. \*p ≤ 0.05, \*\*p ≤ 0.01, \*\*\*p ≤ 0.001.Figure 4Kinetics of circulating cytokines in acute-phase OROV fever patients in different days upon disease onset. Levels of IFN-α, IL-6, IL-17, TNF, IFN-γ, IL-5 and IL-10 assessed 1--3, 4--7, 8--10 and ≥11 days upon disease onset in plasma of OROV fever patients considered as early seroconverters (n = 48, left panels) or late seroconverters (n = 27, right panel). Bars represent mean with standard errors (pg/mL) and grey boxes the reference range corresponding the 95%CI of the mean for the HD group. Multiple comparisons amongst groups were carried out by Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Dunn's post-test for sequential pairwise comparisons and significant differences depicted as asterisks and connecting lines. Differences between HD and OROV fever subgroups in different days of disease are shown as asterisks. \*p ≤ 0.05, \*\*p ≤ 0.01, \*\*\*p ≤ 0.001. In regard to cytokine production, the levels of IFN-α were higher throughout the timeline kinetics in both groups of patients when compared to HD (grey zone). In general, the production of TNF, IFN-γ and IL-10 were lower in both groups of patients as compared to HD. The levels of IL-5 were significantly increased in patients at 8--10 and ≥ 11 days after disease onset as compared to HD. On the contrary, higher levels of IL-6 and IL-17A were observed at 1--3 and 4--7 days after disease onset in late seroconverters in comparison to HD (Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). Plasmatic biomarker signatures in acute-phase OROV fever {#Sec6} -------------------------------------------------------- In order to evaluate the overall profile of soluble putative biomarkers in early and late seroconverters upon different days of disease onset, the continuous data was converted into categorical data. For that, the global median of all groups tested was calculated and applied as the cut-off point to distinguish between high and low producers of each chemokine and cytokine. This strategy allowed for generating the proportion of subjects with biomarker levels above the global median, which were assigned as high producers. The proportion of high producers was plotted in an increasing fashion, creating the ascendant signature for each and every biomarker (left to right) at each time point tested (top to bottom). The biomarkers with proportion of high producers above the 50^th^ percentile were selected in grey. Among these, three patterns of altered biomarkers were observed and highlighted with symbols as depicted in Fig. [5](#Fig5){ref-type="fig"}.Figure 5Kinetics of serum biomarker signature in acute-phase OROV fever. Signature curves were plotted using the global median of each cytokine (pg/mL) index as the cut-off mark to distinguish high and low producers of each cytokine/chemokine from early (left panel) and late seroconverters (right panel). Each line corresponds to the biomarker signatures at different days after disease onset to identify changes in the overall cytokine/chemokine profile along time of infection. Grey boxes highlight those biomarkers with levels above the global median observed in more than 50% of OROV fever patients. Geometric symbols (rectangle, diamond and bullet) depict those biomarkers considered "universal" and those exclusively found in "early seroconverters" and "late seroconverters", respectively. In general, a broader spectrum of biomarker with augmented proportion of high producers was observed in late seroconverters at 1--3 and 4--7 days after disease onset as compared to those early seroconverters. Noteworthy was that IFN-α signature was consistently high in all time points tested in both early and late seroconverters and considered as the universal biomarker of human acute-phase OROV fever. The proportion of CXCL8 and IL-5 high producers were persistently elevated throughout the timeline kinetics selectively amongst early seroconverters. Conversely, the proportion of CXCL10 and IL-17A high producers were highlighted throughout all time points tested for late seroconverters. Discussion {#Sec7} ========== Oropouche virus (OROV) stands out as the utmost prevalent *Orthobunyavirus* contagion in some northern South American countries and specially in the Amazon region. In these areas, OROV is endemic, nonetheless scarce information exists about the inflammatory response induced by OROV fever. The present study is the first comprehensive investigation on the chemokine and cytokine profile in early and late seroconverters with OROV fever. In regard to the initial responses triggered by OROV, the innate antiviral response induced by OROV is mediated by induction of type I IFN pathway through Interferon Regulatory Transcription Factors (IRF3 and IRF7), as well as interferon-α/β receptor, and Mitochondrial Antiviral Signaling Protein (MAVS), as evidenced in animal model-based studies^[@CR7]^. The OROV fever pathogenesis was in fact described as restricted by the IFN pathway-related signaling molecules MAVS, IRF-3, IRF-7 in non-myeloid cells^[@CR7]^. In line with these findings, a very elegant study demostrated that several *Orthobunyaviruses*, including: *Tacaiuma (TCMV), Guama (GMAV), Guaroa (GROV) and Caraparu (CARV)* viruses in addition to OROV are vulnerable to the antiviral attack mediated by Interferon-α in time and dose-dependent fashion^[@CR8]^. In fact, OROV fever is restrained by the IFN pathway in wild-type mice. This is exemplified by the fact that IFN-α knockout mice display increased hepatic injury, significantly superior mortality and rapid progress of the disease^[@CR7]^, as similar as previously observed into immunocompetent Syrian golden hamsters^[@CR9]^. It is important to underscore that although IFN-α is a useful universal biomarker for OROV fever, it should be considered together with other clinical and laboratorial records since several other viruses can also elicit IFN-α production. In addition to IFN-induced responses, TNF signaling components such as TNF-Receptor Associated Factor 3 (TRAF3) and Stimulator of Interferon Genes (STING) seem to be important for OROV innate immunity-mediated control. Conversely, as the infection progresses, these mediators are down-modulated in a virus-dependent manner. Possibly, the virus tries to escape the antiviral cellular pathways by increasing the expression of short non-coding cognate miRNAs^[@CR10]^. Thus, the only cytokine ever assessed during OROV fever was type I IFN and it has been demonstrated to be essential for resistance in mouse model. In agreement with these findings, OROV patients presented higher levels of IFN-α indicating strong activation and lower levels of TNF and IL-10 than those by HD, regardless of antibody profile at baseline. IFN-α was the sole cytokine presented in higher levels in both early and late converter patients, as evidenced by the biomarker signatures. In fact, IFN-α was the only mediator present in all time-points upon disease onset and in both early and late seroconverters, indicating possibly that the type I IFN-mediated antiviral responses may not be directly connected to antibody production. In the present study, we demonstrate that OROV fever patients with early and late seroconversion profile display divergent pattern of inflammatory response as assessed by measuring circulating chemokines and cytokines. The early seroconverters display high levels of CXCL8 and IL-5 in all time-points. The high production of IL-5 observed in early seroconverters is consistent with the role of this cytokine in inducing B cell activation and differentiation into antibody producing-plasma cells. This finding may suggest that these patients are ahead in the timeline of infection or this may reflect an intrinsic ability of certain hosts to mount a more robust immune response to OROV. Another possibility is that these early seroconverters may display a distinct serological pattern due to cross reactivity generated by previous infection with other *Orthobunyavirus*. The later hypothesis is less likely probable, considering that during serological screening at baseline seronegativity was observed for *Caraparu* and *Catuviruses* (titers \<1:40) for these patient subgroup and during follow up developed a strong seropositivity to OROV (titers from 1:640 to 1:1,280). High producers of CXCL10 and IL-17 were a hallmark of OROV fever late seroconverters. However, as the levels of IL-17 were particularly low in all OROV patients tested, it is a challenge to validate this molecule as a biomarker for laboratorial follow up of OROV fever. On the other hand, substantial levels of CXCL10 were observed in late but not in early soroconverters. High levels of CXCL10 have been already reported in other virus infection^[@CR11],[@CR12]^. Similar pattern of production was observed for CCL2, a chemokine associated with monocyte recruitment, essential for viral clearance^[@CR12]^. In fact, CXCL10 and CCL2 are both closely associated with innate immune events that could support type I IFN responses. Taking into account these results herein obtained, it is clear that CXCL10 and CCL2 are also closely associated with immune response after a natural acquired *Orthobunyavirus* disease and could represent complementary biomarkers for OROV fever follow up in clinical practice. The reasons for the different seroconversion profiles may be attributed to idiosyncratic events intrinsic to the divergent and miscegenated genetic background of the Brazilian population residing in the Amazon region, as well as to the abundant and diversified plethora of arboviruses, including different orthobunyaviruses with capacity to infect and cause disease in humans to which this population is under risk of exposition. It is plausible to hypothesize that preceding contact to different orthobunyavirus antigens may influence the immune response at least to acute-phase OROV fever. In fact, patients included in this study reside in an endemic area to several *Flaviviruses* such as *Dengue virus*, *Yellow fever* *virus* and *Zika virus*, and potentially also to different *Orthobunyaviruses* such as groups C, *Guamá, Anopheles A, California*, and others, which have caused several seasonal and non-seasonal outbreaks with co-circulation of different arboviruses^[@CR13]^. Viremia is an interesting biomarker that would contribute to understand the different seroconversion profiles. However, no clear association was found amongst the viremia level and neither the chemokine/cytokine profile, nor the seroconversion status observed for the samples included in the present investigation (data not shown). Aiming at determining whether the distinct seroconversion profile as well as chemokine/cytokine patterns were somehow associated with symptoms, we have performed several data mining approaches, but no association could be identified between single or combined clinical records and serum biomarkers. In fact, during OROV disease, the mechanisms underlying protection and pathogenesis have not been yet clearly defined. All in all, the present study has identified IFN-α as a universal biomarker of human OROV fever, while CXCL8 & IL-5 and CXCL10 & IL-17 were observed consistently in early and late seroconverters, respectively. Thus, our results suggest that production of IFN-α and CXCL10 precede the seroconversion bringing novel insights on disease pathogenesis i.e. the immunological events triggered by the OROV fever. Material and Methods {#Sec8} ==================== Study population {#Sec9} ---------------- The present study is a cross-sectional observational study that includes a total of 135 serum samples obtained from the blood bank at the Foundation Center of Hemotherapy and Hematology of Pará (HEMOPA) and Evandro Chagas Institute (IEC). Sixty healthy donors (HD - HEMOPA) and 75 Oropouche-exposed patients (OROV - IEC) were enrolled. HD specimens were triaged for several blood-borne pathogens and classified as fully suitable for donation of blood. OROV fever group was composed of patients clinically investigated by researchers of the Evandro Chagas Institute during the OROV fever outbreaks that occurred in 2006 at Magalhães Barata (Latitude: 0° 47′ 53″ S, Longitude: 47° 36′ 10″ W) in Pará State, and in 2009 at Mazagão (Latitude: 0° 6′ 58″ S, Longitude: 51° 17′ 10″ W) in Amapá State Brazil. OROV fever patients were enrolled upon disease onset, and symptoms were assessed according to Vasconcelos *et al*., 2009: fever (100%), headache (61%), dizziness (54%), myalgia (48%), photophobia (39%), nausea (34%), vomiting (33%), arthritis (18%), epigastric pain (8%), and exanthema (4%). Diarrhea and conjunctival congestion were not observed. All subjects included in this study signed a written informed consent. The samples stored at −80 °C were used upon signed agreement (080/2011 -- GAPRE/HEMOPA). The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee at Instituto Evandro Chagas (Plataforma Brasil, CAAE\#0008.0.72.000-10) and all methods were performed in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations. Molecular and serological IgM and IgG tests for Oropouche virus infection diagnosis {#Sec10} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sera were tested for the presence of OROV with established reference assays based on real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR). RT-qPCR showed high titer of OROV in acute-phase serum samples from febrile patients. The detection of anti-OROV IgM and IgG antibodies was performed by MAC ELISA and hemagglutination-inhibition (HI) as previously described^[@CR3],[@CR14]^. All samples were also screened for Caraparu and Catu infection and presented negative results at baseline (titer \< 1:40). Cytokine and Chemokine assessment {#Sec11} --------------------------------- The plasma levels of chemokines (CXCL8, CCL2, CXCL9, CXCL10) and cytokines (IFN-α, IL-6, IL-17A, TNF, IFN-γ, IL-5, and IL-10), of the sera from the patients selected for this research, were quantified using the Cytometric Bead Array (BD, Pharmingen, USA), which employs a mixture of polystyrene beads of discrete and distinct fluorescence intensities and coated with antibodies specific for human chemokines and cytokines. This methodology allows the simultaneous evaluation of several soluble biomarkers in the same assay using small sample volumes. Plasma and human cytokine standards were assayed according to the manufacturer's instructions and immediately acquired on a FACScalibur^TM^ flow cytometer (BD, San Jose, CA, USA). The FCAP Array software, v1.0 (San Jose, CA, USA) was used for data analysis. An adjustment model through the curve of the 4^th^ logistic parameter, which allows the adjustment of the best non-linear curve for detectable data, was employed and the results were expressed in pg/mL. Statistical analysis {#Sec12} -------------------- Conventional statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism Software v.8.0 (San Diego, CA, USA). Multiple comparisons amongst groups were carried out by Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Dunn's post-test for sequential pairwise comparisons. In all cases, the differences were considered significant if p \< 0.001 (\*\*\*), p \< 0.01 (\*\*) and p \< 0.05 (\*). The biomarker signature analysis was plotted as described previously by Luiza-Silva *et al*.^[@CR15]^. Briefly, the global median values of cytokine and chemokine plasma concentrations were calculated and employed as the threshold to identify the proportion of subjects as low (below global median) or high producers (above global median) of each biomarker. The cutoff of 50% was considered to define biomarkers, which are universal, present during early and late seroconversion. **Publisher's note** Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. This study was funded by the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico -- CNPq, Fundação Centro de Hemoterapia e Hematologia do Pará (HEMOPA), Instituto Evandro Chagas, Universidade Federal do Pará and Instituto René Rachou/FIOCRUZ-Minas. The authors thank the Program for Technological Development in Tools for Health-RPT-FIOCRUZ for using the flow cytometry facilities. PFCV, LRVA, OAMF, ATC received PQ fellowships from CNPq. P.F.C.V. designed the study, provided funding and coordinated study group selection as well as clinical data assessment and preparation. R.S.S.A. provided medical assistance and coordinated the clinical data assessment. E.O., M.S.F., A.C.C.A., M.F.C.S., L.C.M. and J.O.C. performed experiments. J.G.C.R., L.R.V.A., A.T.-C. and O.A.M.F. carried out data analysis and statistics. J.G.C.R., L.R.V.A. and O.A.M.F. prepared figures and the first draft of the manuscript. P.F.C.V. proofread the final version of manuscript. All authors revised and agreed with the final version of the manuscript. The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. The authors declare no competing interests.

As one of the most ethnically diverse countries,[@ref1] Canada is home to individuals of over 200 ethnic origins. [@ref2] Canada\'s growing diversity is due primarily to high levels of immigration. Since the 1990s, about 250 000 immigrants have arrived annually.[@ref2] The major sources of Canada\'s immigrants are Asia, Europe, the Caribbean, South and Central America, Africa, and the United States.[@ref1] In Ontario, Canada\'s largest province, the 2006 Census identified that 23% of the population belonged to an ethnic minority group, with the largest groups being South Asian, Chinese, and black.[@ref1] From 2007 to 2011, 42% of all Canadian immigrants landed in Ontario.[@ref3] The increasingly multi-ethnic nature of society in Canada and other countries is fuelling a need for ethnicity data to permit better understanding of these diverse populations. For example, in health research, ethnicity classifications can be used to better understand the etiology of disease, the respective roles of environment and genetics in health and disease, and the health status of disadvantaged groups, as well as to improve health care delivery and target specific public health interventions toward high-risk populations.[@ref4]^,^[@ref5] However, such classifications may also have associated weaknesses, such as contributing to racialized identities, a social concept denoting power inequality between ethnic or racial groups, which has been suggested to have negative health implications.[@ref6] The concept of ethnicity is complex and its definition challenging.[@ref5]^,^[@ref7]^,^[@ref8] The concepts of ethnicity and race are sometimes used synonymously, although they do not overlap completely[@ref7]: - Ethnicity has been defined as \"the social group a person belongs to, and either identifies with or is identified with by others, as a result of a mix of cultural and other factors including language, diet, religion, ancestry, and physical features traditionally associated with race.\"[@ref7] - Race has been defined \"by historical and common usage,\" as \"the group (sub-species in traditional scientific use) a person belongs to as a result of a mix of physical features such as skin colour and hair texture, which reflect ancestry and geographical origins, as identified by others or, increasingly, as self-identified.\"[@ref7] Although ethnicity has long been recognized as an important covariate in health research, individuallevel ethnicity data are rarely collected in Canadian health care data sets. Similarly, although some ethnicity data are captured in Canada\'s census, these data are restricted to Statistics Canada and therefore cannot be linked to many other administrative data sets available in Canada\'s provinces and territories. In an effort to address this gap, alternative ethnicity classifications have been used. The various methods used to define and assign ethnicity include surname-based approaches, geocoding of residential address, and classification based on country of birth, language, or a combination of these.[@ref9]^--^[@ref13] Country of birth in particular has been widely collected in many administrative and government data sets and represents an objective and potentially valuable source of ethnicity information. Given Canada\'s high immigration rate, the Permanent Resident Database of Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) may be a useful source of ethnicity data for health research. In the past decade, this database has been used for socio-economic and health studies of immigrants in various Canadian provinces.[@ref14]^--^[@ref20] The CIC data provide detailed prelanding demographic and socio-economic information, including country of birth, for all Canadian immigrants. However, this data set lacks self-reported ethnicity, and the large number of options for country of birth and mother tongue within this data set (over 200 options for each variable) can also make it challenging to use for such purposes. In an attempt to improve the practical use of this database for ethnicity-related research projects, we describe here a method for classifying Ontario CIC data records into Canada\'s 10 official visible minority ethnic groups (plus a white group) using either country of birth or country of birth plus mother tongue variables. We also report validation of this method using information from Statistics Canada\'s Canadian Community Health Survey (CCHS), a large population-based telephone survey of the Canadian population which includes self-reported ethnicity information, the current \"gold standard\" for ethnicity classification. Methods {#S1} ======= CIC Permanent Resident Database. {#S1a} -------------------------------- The CIC Permanent Resident Database provides detailed socio-demographic information for all legal immigrants to Canada, including country of birth, citizenship, country of last permanent residence, and mother tongue. For this analysis, we used the CIC data set held at the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, which pertains to Ontario immigrants who arrived between 1985 and 2010. This data set includes 267 options for country of birth and 245 options for mother tongue. The Ontario CIC database has been used as a source of ethnicity data for previous health research studies.[@ref14]^--^[@ref16] Study population. {#S1b} ----------------- The CIC data set used for this study contains records for 2.9 million immigrants who landed in Ontario over the period from 1985 to 2010. We excluded about 400 000 records because of an inability to identify a valid health card number in the Ontario Registered Persons Database; the health card number was required for record linkage to the self-reported ethnicity data that we used for validation purposes. The reasons for absence of a valid health card number are multifactorial and include immigrants\' departure from the province shortly after arrival (i.e., before registering for a health card number), as well as typographic inconsistencies in the CIC database or the Registered Persons Database (or both). Landed immigrants become eligible for health care benefits after a 3-month waiting period. Records for the remaining 2.5 million Ontario immigrants could be linked to other administrative databases available at the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences. All data were de-identified and health card numbers were encrypted to protect privacy. Classification of ethnic groups. {#S1c} -------------------------------- The CIC database lacks ethnic or visible minority group classifications. To facilitate use of the CIC data for health research, we tested 2 methods for classifying the immigrants in this data set into 11 ethnic categories, specifically the 10 official visible minority groups used by Statistics Canada (South Asian, Chinese, black, Latin American, Filipino, West Asian, Arab, Southeast Asian, Korean, and Japanese) and a white category. According to the Employment Equity Act, visible minorities are defined as \"persons, other than aboriginal peoples, who are non- Caucasian in race or non-white in colour.\"[@ref21] For this study, we first tested country of birth alone (method A) and then country of birth plus mother tongue (method B) to classify the Ontario CIC data set. Method A (country of birth). {#S1d} ---------------------------- We mapped each of the 267 country-of-birth names in the Ontario CIC data set (including previous county-of-birth names changed for political reasons) to 1 of 12 categories: the 10 visible minority groups specified by Statistics Canada, a white category, and an \"excluded\" category. We used a combination of publicly available resources for this purpose, including Statistics Canada\'s ethnic origin categories for the 2006 Census of Population (our preferred source),[@ref22] the United Nations *Standard Country or Area Codes for Statistical Use* (also known as the M49 list),[@ref23] the World Bank list of economies (as of July 2012),[@ref24] and *The World Factbook* of the US Central Intelligence Agency.[@ref25] These resources consider the ethnic mix of countries and provide additional information needed to appropriately assign each country to its predominant ethnic group. The 10 visible minority categories used by Statistics Canada are heterogeneous. Whereas some categories are associated with a single country, and classification is straightforward (e.g., the country of Japan was assigned to the Japanese category), other categories, such as South Asian and Latin American, relate to geographic regions and include multiple countries. For example, we assigned the countries in South America and most of those in Central America to the Latin American category. In contrast, categories such as black and Arab may be considered primarily ethnocultural classifications associated with overlapping geopolitical boundaries (see methodological details in online Appendix A). The white category was used for European countries and those with populations of predominantly European origin (e.g., Australia). The \"excluded\" category was created for immigrants whose countries of birth were not accounted for by the 10 major visible minority groups defined by Statistics Canada or the white category as defined above and those whose CIC data were irregular (e.g., \"country not stated\" or \"British Overseas Citizen\"). Further details are provided in online Appendix A. Method B (country of birth plus mother tongue). {#S1e} ----------------------------------------------- In an effort to further refine the classification based on country of birth, we then completed a second classification based on country of birth plus mother tongue. The ethnic makeup of many countries is heterogeneous, and there may be individuals whose ethnic background differs from the predominant ethnocultural group (or groups) of their country of birth. For instance, a person may be born to South Asian parents in a country with a predominantly white population (e.g., the United Kingdom). In such cases, a person\'s mother tongue may be more representative of his or her ethnic background than his or her country of birth. We mapped each of the 245 mother tongues in the Ontario CIC data set to 1 of 15 categories: the 10 Statistics Canada visible minority groups, a white category, and 4 additional language categories (\"world language,\" \"other,\" \"excluded,\" and \"unknown\"). Publicly available data sources, such as *Ethnologue: Languages of the World*[@ref26] and *The World Factbook*,[@ref25] were used to gather language information and assign each mother tongue to an ethnic group. For instance, Cantonese and Mandarin were categorized as Chinese, and Persian and Kurdish were categorized as West Asian. The \"world language\" category, created to account for languages spoken in multiple categories and by various visible minority groups, comprised English, French, Spanish, Portuguese, and Russian. Less specific language options were assigned to the closest category (e.g., \"other European languages\" to white) or to the \"other\" category (e.g., Hebrew) (see methodological details in online Appendix A). The \"excluded\" language category was created for 3 languages (Busan, Uzbek, Samoan) associated with the countries in the \"excluded\" category defined in method A (as described in the previous subsection). The \"unknown\" category was created for languages for which a region of origin or single ethnic group could not be identified. The number of immigrants speaking languages categorized as \"excluded\" or \"unknown\" was relatively small (\< 0.1% of total sample). We developed an algorithm to determine a final category for each individual immigrant record using both methods: country of birth (method A) and country of birth plus mother tongue (method B) (see the flow chart in online Appendix B). Validation of classification accuracy. {#S1f} -------------------------------------- For validation, we compared the ethnic group assigned by each of our 2 methods with self-reported ethnic group data in Statistics Canada\'s CCHS, a population-based cross-sectional health telephone survey of Canadians aged 12 years and older. More specifically, we used respondents\' answers to the CCHS question, \"People living in Canada come from many different cultural and racial backgrounds. Are you \[white, South Asian, etc.\]?\" We used encrypted health card numbers to link data from 4 cycles of the CCHS (2000/2001 to 2007/2008) with the CIC data set for Ontario. We calculated percent agreement and simple kappa statistics to compare classification by methods A and B with the CCHS self-reported ethnic classification (the reference standard). Overall percent agreement was defined as the number of similar ratings by the 2 methods divided by the total number of ratings. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were calculated for each visible minority category for comparisons of methods A and B with the CCHS classification. We used SAS version 9.2 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, North Carolina) for all statistical analyses. Geographic visualization. {#S1g} ------------------------- We used ArcGIS Desktop software version 10 (ESRI, Redlands, California) to create a map showing the global distribution of major ethnic groups associated with the countries of birth of Ontario immigrants, as recorded in the CIC database. A data set for world country boundaries was obtained from the website thematicmapping.org.[@ref27] Ethics approval. {#S1h} ---------------- This project received ethics approval through the Research Ethics Board of Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre. Results {#S2} ======= The study sample from the Ontario CIC data set consisted of 2 500 514 immigrants with mean age ± standard deviation (SD) of 30 ± 17 years at the time of landing, of whom 51% were female. The top 3 countries of origin were India, China, and the Philippines, and the top 3 mother tongues were English, Mandarin, and Cantonese ([Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}). ###### Top 20 countries of birth and mother tongues of immigrants recorded in the Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) Permanent Resident Database who landed in Ontario from 1985 to 2010 Rank Top 20 countries of birth Top 20 mother tongues ------ ---------------------------------- ----------------------- ------------ --------- 1 India 296 805 English 365 194 2 China, People\'s Republic of 263 450 Mandarin 170 317 3 Philippines 163 223 Cantonese 166 533 4 Pakistan 134 967 Tagalog 143 603 5 Sri Lanka 96 110 Arabic 135 219 6 Hong Kong 94 038 Punjabi 134 238 7 Poland 78 368 Urdu 129 566 8 Iran 74 957 Spanish 123 156 9 Jamaica 72 782 Tamil 96 376 10 United States of America 60 155 Russian 81 746 11 United Kingdom and Colonies 58 180 Polish 78 601 12 Guyana 50 643 Gujarati 58 070 13 Korea, Republic of 41 005 Chinese 48 702 14 Vietnam, Socialist Republic of 39 666 Portuguese 48 365 15 Romania 38 223 Hindi 45 879 16 Trinidad and Tobago, Republic of 34 819 Farsi 43 637 17 Yugoslavia 34 788 Korean 41 489 18 Russia 34 523 Romanian 37 099 19 Iraq 33 648 Bengali 37 024 20 Bangladesh 32 331 Persian 33 692 The country and language labels are as per the CIC data formats and therefore may refer to old names in some cases. [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"} displays the world distribution of the ethnic groups assigned to countries of birth in our sample. A list of all countries and mother tongues in the Ontario CIC data with the assigned ethnic categories is available by contacting the corresponding author. {#F1} The 2 methods used to classify immigrants (i.e., on the basis of country of birth alone or on the basis of country of birth plus mother tongue) resulted in some differences in categorization ([Table 2](#T2){ref-type="table"}). For instance, among 523 855 immigrants classified as white by country of birth, 8271 and 2502 individuals were classified as South Asian and Chinese, respectively, by country of birth plus mother tongue. Methods A and B showed agreement for 94% of the ratings (kappa coefficient 0.94, 95% confidence interval \[CI\] 0.93--0.94). ###### Frequency of immigrants to Ontario (1985--2010) in each ethnic category, classified by country of birth alone (method A) and country of birth plus mother tongue (method B), based on data in the Citizenship and Immigration Canada Permanent Resident Database [\*](#T2FN1){ref-type="table-fn"}[†](#T2FN2){ref-type="table-fn"} Method A (using country of birth) Method B (using country of birth plus mother tongue) ----------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------ ------------- ------------- ------------- ------------- ------------- ------------- ------------- ------------- ------------ ------------ ----------- --------------- **Excluded** **11 406** \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 11 406 **White** 1 312 **501 235** 8 271 2 502 1 785 2 007 600 2 357 3 063 310 331 82 523 855 **South Asian** 3 449 164 **547 439** 5 768 541 \< 70 94 4 538 286 1 068 \< 70 \< 70 563 361 **Chinese** 1 592 \< 70 320 **372 298** 174 \< 70 212 \< 70 \< 70 736 175 \< 70 375 670 **Black** 2 737 498 9 687 445 **249 547** \< 70 124 \< 70 8 160 233 \< 70 \< 70 271 499 **Latin American** 2 053 3 251 74 569 123 **177 111** \< 70 \< 70 156 \< 70 86 \< 70 183 491 **Filipino** 405 \< 70 548 1 699 \< 70 \< 70 **148 013** \< 70 \< 70 12 115 \< 70 \< 70 162 968 **West Asian** 4 413 1 168 1 564 \< 70 143 \< 70 \< 70 **119 945** 3 202 1 544 \< 70 \< 70 132 067 **Arab** 8 559 329 12 214 \< 70 1 766 \< 70 1 276 12 569 **122 874** \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 159 689 **Southeast Asian** 1 250 102 2 517 17 008 \< 70 \< 70 244 \< 70 \< 70 **47 556** \< 70 \< 70 68 817 **Korean** 232 \< 70 \< 70 94 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 **40 680** \< 70 41 106 **Japanese** 174 \< 70 166 329 \< 70 \< 70 217 \< 70 \< 70 \< 70 98 **5 506** 6 585 **Total** 37 582 506 882 582 812 400 771 254 189 179 118 150 898 139 608 137 842 63 652 41 452 5 708 **2 500 514** Specific data for cells with value \< 70, including cells with value 0, were suppressed to protect privacy. Row and column totals are the true sums, including the suppressed values. Values in cells along the diagonal are shown in bold to highlight similar classification by the 2 methods. From the Ontario CCHS data set (n = 134 567), we linked 6585 records to the CIC data set. Of these, 86 individuals with multiple ethnicities were excluded, leaving 6499 for the validation analysis. For these 6499 CCHS respondents, the mean age ± SD was 29 ± 15 years at the time of landing, and 52% were female. For the vast majority of the respondents, self-reported ethnicity in the CCHS data matched the ethnic group assigned by our method B ([Table 3](#T3){ref-type="table"}) or method A (see online Appendix C). ###### Frequency of immigrants to Ontario in each self-reported ethnic category (based on the Canadian Community Health Survey \[CCHS\]) and as classified using country of birth plus mother tongue (method B), based on data in the Citizenship and Immigration Canada Permanent Resident Database [\*](#T3FN1){ref-type="table-fn"}[†](#T3FN2){ref-type="table-fn"} Self-reported (CCHS) Method B (using country of birth plus mother tongue) ---------------------- ------------------------------------------------------ ---------- ---------- --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -------- -------- -------- ---------- **White** 40 **2021** \< 10 \< 10 19 91 \< 10 74 40 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 2300 **South Asian** 26 \< 10 **1105** \< 10 60 66 \< 10 13 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 1296 **Chinese** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 **720** \< 10 \< 10 12 \< 10 \< 10 22 \< 10 \< 10 769 **Black** \< 10 12 \< 10 \< 10 **586** 26 \< 10 \< 10 15 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 645 **Latin American** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 11 **364** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 389 **Filipino** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 **321** \< 10 \< 10 27 \< 10 \< 10 355 **West Asian** \< 10 \< 10 10 \< 10 16 11 \< 10 **155** 16 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 224 **Arab** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 12 **185** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 212 **Southeast Asian** \< 10 \< 10 96 12 \< 10 \< 10 12 \< 10 \< 10 **61** \< 10 \< 10 205 **Korean** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 **80** \< 10 83 **Japanese** \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 \< 10 **19** 21 **Total** 96 2059 1227 735 715 562 354 259 262 128 82 20 **6499** Specific data for cells with value \< 10, including cells with value 0, were suppressed to protect privacy. Row and column totals are the true sums, including the suppressed values. Values in cells along the diagonal are shown in bold to highlight similar classification by the 2 methods. Ethnic categorization by either method A (country of birth alone) or method B (country of birth plus mother tongue) agreed with the self-reported CCHS ethnic group for 86% of respondents (kappa coefficient 0.83, 95% CI 0.82--0.84, for both comparisons). When the classification accuracy of method B was compared with self-reported ethnicity from the CCHS, consistently high specificity and negative predictive values were found for all groups ([Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). Sensitivity for the Southeast Asian category and positive predictive values for the Latin American, Southeast Asian, and West Asian categories were relatively lower. For the majority of classification indices, method B (country of birth plus mother tongue) showed a slight improvement in categorization over method A (country of birth alone) or no change (see online Appendix D for validation results for method A). ###### Validation of ethnic classification using country of birth plus mother tongue (method B), with self-reported ethnicity (from Canadian Community Health Survey) as reference (n = 6499) Classification by method B Sensitivity (95% CI) Specificity (95% CI) Positive predictive value (95% CI) Negative predictive value (95% CI) ---------------------------- ---------------------- ---------------------- ------------------------------------ ------------------------------------ White 0.87 (0.86--0.89) 0.99 (0.98--0.99) 0.98 (0.97--0.98) 0.93 (0.92--0.94) South Asian 0.85 (0.83--0.87) 0.97 (0.97--0.98) 0.90 (0.88--0.91) 0.96 (0.95--0.96) Chinese 0.93 (0.91--0.95) 0.99 (0.99--0.99) 0.97 (0.96--0.98) 0.99 (0.98--0.99) Black 0.90 (0.88--0.92) 0.97 (0.97--0.98) 0.81 (0.78--0.84) 0.98 (0.98--0.99) Latin American 0.93 (0.90--0.95) 0.96 (0.96--0.97) 0.64 (0.60--0.68) 0.99 (0.99--0.99) Filipino 0.90 (0.86--0.93) 0.99 (0.99--0.99) 0.90 (0.87--0.93) 0.99 (0.99--0.99) West Asian 0.69 (0.62--0.75) 0.98 (0.98--0.98) 0.59 (0.53--0.65) 0.98 (0.98--0.99) Arab 0.87 (0.82--0.91) 0.98 (0.98--0.99) 0.70 (0.64--0.76) 0.99 (0.99--0.99) Southeast Asian 0.29 (0.23--0.36) 0.98 (0.98--0.99) 0.47 (0.38--0.56) 0.97 (0.97--0.98) Korean 0.96 (0.89--0.99) 0.99 (0.99--1.00) 0.97 (0.91--0.99) 0.99 (0.99--0.99) Japanese 0.90 (0.69--0.98) 0.99 (0.99--1.00) 0.95 (0.75--0.99) 0.99 (0.99--1.00) CI = confidence interval. Interpretation {#S3} ============== We used 2 methods (country of birth alone or country of birth plus mother tongue) to classify Ontario immigrants in the CIC data set into 11 predefined ethnic groups. We found a high degree of agreement between self-reported ethnic groups from CCHS data and those assigned by our 2 classification methods. Compared with country-specific or world region--specific classifications used previously, [@ref14] our classification by visible minority groups may be more practical for researchers and health policy-makers, as it is comparable to other important population statistics on visible minorities produced by Statistics Canada and other international organizations. Our methods may also prove useful (with local customization) in other countries where health-related information regarding self-reported ethnicity is not available or is not routinely collected but data on immigrants\' country of birth and/or mother tongue are available. Using country of birth to define ethnicity has been reported as a robust method for health care research in countries such as the Netherlands, where this variable was closely correlated with self-reported ethnicity.[@ref13]^,^[@ref28] Nevertheless, this method has been criticized,[@ref13]^,^[@ref29] because the definition of ethnicity is complex and may not always be determined by geography. Problems can arise with multi-ethnic countries (e.g., Australia, the United States, South Africa) or with individuals born to a family whose ethnicity is different from the predominant ethnic group of their country of residence. To further investigate this issue, we analyzed the CCHS self-reported ethnicity of a subset of the immigrants in the CIC data who had a CCHS-linked record and came from a large, multi-ethnic country (i.e., United Kingdom, United States, South Africa, or Australia, as defined by country of birth in CIC data). Among these CIC--CCHS linked records, 292 (94%) of the 310 immigrants born in the United Kingdom self-identified as white, as did 179 (87%) of the 206 immigrants born in the United States, 56 (89%) of the 63 born in South Africa, and 24 (96%) of the 25 born in Australia. These data support the validity of our ethnicity classification algorithm for immigrants from these countries. Classification methods that use additional information such as language and parents\' country of birth have been shown to improve classification accuracy over methods based on country of birth alone.[@ref13] In our study, adding mother tongue to country of birth resulted in only slight improvements in ethnicity classification, relative to country of birth alone. Methods using mother tongue alone to define ethnicity also have their limitations. Second- or third-generation immigrants in some countries (e.g., the United States) may not share the mother tongue of their ancestors. Moreover, native individuals may report their mother tongue to be a world language (originating from a predominantly white country) that is accepted as their birth country\'s official language (e.g., French in Congo, English in India). We controlled for the latter problem in our data set by recording the world languages spoken as official languages specific to such countries. Despite unanimously high specificity values, the sensitivity of our methods to detect Southeast Asian immigrants was low relative to self-reported ethnicity. Among Southeast Asians there was considerable misclassification into the South Asian category. This result may be due to individuals\' uncertainty about world geographic boundaries for South Asia and Southeast Asia (e.g., a South Asian might think that his or her country is located in Southeast Asia) or self-identification by country of residence rather than country of birth (e.g., a person born in India who lived in Malaysia for a long time before immigrating to Canada may self-identify as Southeast Asian). We also found relatively low positive predictive value for the Latin American group, despite the high sensitivity and specificity of our methods. Some immigrants from certain Latin American countries (e.g., Brazil and Argentina) are descendants of European immigrants and self-identify as white. Moreover, a large proportion of the population in Guyana, the Latin American country with the largest number of immigrants to Ontario, are members of the South Asian diaspora. Some limitations may exist for the CCHS data that we used to validate our classification methods. First, the CCHS population linked to our Ontario CIC data set may not be a representative sample of Ontario immigrants. Second, the sample size for some visible minority groups (e.g., Japanese and Koreans) was limited, which can result in less reliable estimates. Third, self-reported ethnicity, although often considered a preferred method of ethnic group classification, has some shortcomings. Self-reported ethnicity may change over time and can be influenced by psychosocial factors, such as the feeling of pride that a person attaches to his or her ethnic or national identity, uncertainty about ethnic origin, or even concern related to disclosing one\'s ethnicity.[@ref5]^,^[@ref7]^,^[@ref8]^,^[@ref13]^,^[@ref30]^,^[@ref31] For instance, 5% of the immigrants who self-reported as white in the CCHS validation data set were classified as West Asian or Arab on the basis of country of birth and mother tongue. It is likely that these CCHS participants were West Asians or Arabs who reported their ethnicity as white on the basis of skin colour. In conclusion, in a large data set of Ontario immigrants, we found close agreement between selfreported ethnic categories and ethnic categories based on country of birth alone or country of birth plus mother tongue. These findings suggest that the 2 methods of ethnic classification described are valid for categorizing most immigrants to Canada into the country\'s official visible minority groups. Use of a larger validation data set in future studies may further illuminate the external validity of these methods. None declared. This study was supported by operating grants from the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC), the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Ontario, and a Team Grant (TCA 118349) to the Cardiovascular Health in Ambulatory Care Research Team (CANHEART) from the Institute of Circulatory and Respiratory Health, Canadian Institutes of Health Research. Additional support was provided by the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences (ICES), which is funded by an annual grant from the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care (MOHLTC). The immigration data used in the study were provided to ICES by Citizenship and Immigration Canada. These data sets were held securely in a linked, de-identified form and were analyzed at ICES. Dr. Tu is supported by a Canada Research Chair in Health Services Research and a Career Investigator award from the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Ontario. The opinions, results, and conclusions reported in this paper are those of the authors and are independent from, and should not be attributed to, the funding sources. No endorsement by PHAC, ICES, the Ontario MOHLTC, or Citizenship and Immigration Canada is intended or should be inferred. [^1]: Mohammad R. Rezai and Laura C. Maclagan contributed to the literature review, drafted the first version of the manuscript, and revised it critically for important intellectual content. Mohammad R. Rezai also classified the countries and languages and performed statistical and geographic analyses. Linda R. Donovan participated in the analysis and interpretation of the data and revised the manuscript critically for important intellectual content. Jack V. Tu conceived and designed the project, contributed to data acquisition, revised the manuscript critically for important intellectual content, obtained funding, and supervised the entire project. All authors gave final approval for publication.

**Correction to**: *British Journal of Cancer* (2015) **112**, 1568--1574; doi:[10.1038/bjc.2015.89](/doifinder/10.1038/bjc.2015.89) **Updated online 26 May 2016:** This article was originally published under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license, but has now been made available under a CC BY 4.0 license. The PDF and HTML versions of the paper have been modified accordingly.

Introduction ============ Diabetes mellitus (DM) is a disease characterized by hyperglycemia resulting from defects in insulin secretion, insulin action, or the two together, and is often accompanied by hyperlipidemia. The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is a complex, intracellular membranous network, which regulates protein synthesis. If the cell suffers from adverse conditions, including overabundance of glucose, infection, hypoxia, ischemia or angiotensin-II stimulation, homeostasis in the ER is disrupted, leading to the accumulation of multiple unfolded or misfolded proteins in the ER. This results in ER stress and subsequent UPR ([@b1-mmr-13-06-5037]). There are two functions of the UPR. Initially, it induces the inhibition of protein synthesis and subsequently, when ER stress is prolonged in the presence of hyperglycemia, an apoptotic pathway is activated ([@b2-mmr-13-06-5037]) through the activation of the C/EBP homologous protein (CHOP/GADD153) ([@b3-mmr-13-06-5037]), the Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK)4 pathway ([@b4-mmr-13-06-5037]) and caspase-12 ([@b5-mmr-13-06-5037]). In mammalian cells, ER stress initially activates intracellular signaling pathways mediated by three ER-resident proteins: Protein kinase R-like ER kinase (PERK) ([@b6-mmr-13-06-5037]), activating transcription factor 6 (ATF6) and inositol-requiring kinase-1 (IRE-1) ([@b7-mmr-13-06-5037]). Under normal conditions, these molecules straddle the ER membrane, positioning their N-terminus in the lumen of the ER membranes and their C-terminus in the cytosol. The N-terminus is often associated with the chaperone, glucose regulating protein 78 (GRP78) ([@b8-mmr-13-06-5037]). When unfolded proteins aggregate in the ER, PERK dislocates from GRP78 to dimerize and autophosphorylate, and is then activated to phosphorylate eukaryotic initiation factor-α ([@b9-mmr-13-06-5037]). Initiation factor-dependent protein synthesis can be inhibited to reduce the protein load in the ER ([@b10-mmr-13-06-5037]). However, rather than the transcription of ER stress response (ERSE) genes being reduced, it increases due to their specific structures and selective advantages ([@b11-mmr-13-06-5037]). IRE1 is central to the ER stress response ([@b12-mmr-13-06-5037]). Following its activation, it functions as a kinase and an endoribonuclease, which can cleave specific exon-intron sites in the mRNA that encode the transcription factor, X-box-binding protein 1. This cleavage initiates an unconventional splicing reaction, which leads to the production of an active transcription factor and the induction of various adaptive genes, particularly ERSE ([@b13-mmr-13-06-5037]). The mechanism of activation of ATF6 differs from those of PERK and IRE1. GRP78 dissociation from ATF6 promotes its translocation to the Golgi, where it undergoes cleavage by site-1 and site-2 proteases ([@b14-mmr-13-06-5037]). The cleaved and activated N-ATF6 migrates to the nucleus and increases the expression of ERSE ([@b15-mmr-13-06-5037]). ER stress is a pathogenic mechanism associated with type 1 and type 2 diabetes. In type 2 diabetes, insulin resistance is the underlying problem, and is often associated with obesity. It is now recognized that a high-fat diet causes ER stress. If hyperglycemia is persistent, ER stress is prolonged and, when cells are not sufficiently relieved from stress, they undergo apoptosis and self-destruction ([@b16-mmr-13-06-5037]). The apoptotic course is complicated as it involves three pathways, which interact with each other to induce the apoptosis of cardiomyocytes. IRE-1 recruits tumor necrosis factor receptor associated factor 2 (TRAF2) and apoptotic signal-regulation kinase 1 (ASK-1) to form an IRE-1-TRAF2-ASK1 complex, which then activates JNK and other downstream molecules ([@b17-mmr-13-06-5037]). Additionally, PERK upregulates the translation of ATF4 and induces the transcription of CHOP/GADD153, a member of the C/EBP family of basic leucine zipper transcription factors, which potentiates apoptosis ([@b18-mmr-13-06-5037]). The caspase pathway is also commonly activated in ER stress, particularly caspase-12, although, the precise mechanism remains to be elucidated. The important mechanisms underlying ER stress in heart disease have been reported previously. For example, ischemia/reperfusion injury in the heart has been shown to induce ATF6 markers ([@b19-mmr-13-06-5037]--[@b21-mmr-13-06-5037]). Studies have also shown that ER stress is involved in the pathogenesis of various cardiovascular diseases, including as coronary heart disease, cardiac ischemia-reperfusion injury, cardiomyopathy and heart failure ([@b19-mmr-13-06-5037],[@b22-mmr-13-06-5037],[@b23-mmr-13-06-5037]). The PERK and ATF6 pathways are the major determining pathways involved in ER stress-mediated metabolic dysfunction. These pathways eventually lead to diabetic cardiomyopathy in non-obese type 2 DM rats when sacrificed at 32 weeks ([@b24-mmr-13-06-5037]). Limited investigations have been performed in animal models. In the present study, the expression levels of the predominant markers of UPR signaling proteins were examined in DM rats at different time points, to determine whether myocardial fibrosis is accompanied by ER stress-mediated apoptosis. Materials and methods ===================== Animals ------- Male Sprague-Dawley rats (n=55; age, 8 weeks; Beijing Vital River Laboratory Animal Technology Co., Ltd., SPF, Beijing, China), weighing 210--250 g were used in the present study. The animals were maintained under conditions at a temperature of 18--26°C and humidity of 40--70%, in a 12-h light cycle. The present study was approved by the ethics committee of Capital Medical University (Beijing, China). Reagents -------- Streptozocin was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO, USA). Normal fodder (crude protein, 18%; crude fat, 4%; and crude fiber, 5%) and high-glucose fodder (crude protein, 18%; crude fat, 20%; crude fiber, 5%; and sucrose, 20%) were acquired from Beijing Keao Xieli Fodder Co., Ltd. (Beijing, China) Experimental protocol --------------------- All the rats were adapted to the housing conditions and fed the same diet of normal fodder for 1 week, following which they were randomly divided into an experimental group (n=30) and a control group (n=25) with 6 rats/month. To create the type 2 DM model, the experimental rats were fed with high-glucose and high-fat fodder for 28 days, whereas the control rats were fed with normal fodder. All rats were fasted overnight with free access to water to calculate the low dose of streptozocin. Solution A (2.1 g citric acid + 100 ml distilled water) and solution B (2.94 g + 100 ml distilled water) were mixed and buffered to pH 4.2--4.5 to produce solution C. Streptozocin (1 g) was added to 100 ml solution C to produce 1% streptozocin solution. The rats were administered with a single peritoneal injection of streptozocin (30 mg/kg body weight), and the control rats received the samedose of sodium citrate/citric acid buffer. The post-injection dietary structure in the respective groups remained the same as that pre-injection. After 1 week, blood was collected via the tail vein to measure glucose levels, and a successful type 2DM model was established in 24 of the 30 rats. The blood glucose levels were between 16.8 and 29.7 mmol/l in 10 rats, and were above the upper limit of 30.5 mmol/l in 14 rats. If the blood glucose was \>16.7 mmol/l and this state was sustained for 4 weeks, construction of the model was considered to be successful. The body weights and blood glucose levels were assessed periodically following establishment of the model, and six animals were sacrificed at 1, 4, 5 and 7 months. Ultrasonography --------------- Following fasting overnight, the 6 rats in each group were anesthetized with chloral hydrate (30 mg/kg; Sigma-Aldrich), and placed on a current-conducting plate (VisualSonics, Inc., Toronto, Canada). The precordial region was shaved, and ventricular ejection fraction was measured by an experienced laboratory technician using an RMV-716 probe, Vevo 770™ microscopy and high-resolution ultrasound (VisualSonics, Inc.). Following measurement, the rats were sacrificed by administration of 2 ml gas to induce air emboli. Measurement of heart and left ventricle weights ----------------------------------------------- Following sacrifice of the animals, the hearts were rapidly removed and washed in cold 0.9% saline, with removal of connective tissue and contaminating blood, and placed on ice. The right ventricle and left ventricle were then dissected. The heart and left ventricle were weighed using a precision electronic balance (XPE105; Mettler-Toledo, Columbus, OH, USA) and the transverse diameters were measured using the same ruler. Subsequently, the heart weight index (HWI) was calculated (HWI = weight of the heart / the weight of the body) and left ventricular weight index (LVWI) were calculated (LVWI = the weight of the left ventricle / the weight of the body). The tissues were then stored at -80°C until analyzed using reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR analysis). Tissue analysis --------------- All the tissues were stained using hematoxylin and eosin (Sigma-Aldrich) to evaluate the inflammatory reaction and the deformation of myocardial cells. Masson\'s trichrome staining (Sigma-Aldrich) was used to more clearly visualize fibrosis. Apoptotic cells were detected using terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP-biotin nick end labeling (TUNEL) staining with the DeadEnd™ Fluorometric TUNEL system (Promega Corporation, Madison, WI, USA). TUNEL staining was performed according to the manufacturer\'s protocol. Briefly, the cells were fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde (Sigma-Aldrich) in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), rinsed with PBS, treated with 0.1% Triton X-100 (Sigma-Aldrich) for 2 min on ice, and incubated with TUNEL for 1 h at 37°C. The number of apoptotic cells was observed using XSZ-A08 microscope (Wuzhou Optical Instrument Factory, Wuzhou, China), expressed as the percentage of apoptotic cells of the normal cells. RT-qPCR ------- RT-qPCR was performed using the BIOER Linegene 9600 system (BIOER, Hangzhou, China) to monitor the mRNA expression levels of the ER-associated molecules. β-actin was selected as the endogenous control for relative quantification in the RT-qPCR analysis. mRNA was extracted using chloroform, Spin Column RM (Beijing Kang Century Biotechnology Co., Ltd., Beijing, China) and RLT buffer (Sangon Biotech Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China) and 80 *μ*l DNase I was administered. The RT reaction mixture containing 2 *μ*l RNA, 2 *μ*l primers and 11 *μ*l RNase was incubated for 5 min at 65°C. The RT mix (4 *μ*l; 5X) and 1 μl HiFi-MMLV enzyme mix (Beijing Kang Century Biotechmology Co., Ltd.) were added and incubated for 40 min at 37°C and subsequently at 70°C for 10 min. The PCR reaction was conducted using 10 μl UltraSYBR Mixture (Beijing Kang Century Biotechnology Co., Ltd.), 1 *μ*l forward primer, 1 *μ*l reverse primer, 2 *μ*l cDNA template and 6 *μ*l RNase-free water. The reaction conditions were as follows: Initial incubation step of 5 min at 65°C, reverse transcription of 40 min at 37°C and 70°C for 10 min, followed by 45 cycles of 15 sec at 95°C for denaturation, and 60 sec at 58°C for annealing and extension. The following primers (Beijing Central Yatai Ke Biomedical Technology Co., Ltd., Beijing, China) were used: GRP78, forward 5′-CCATGCATTGTTTGT GCC GA-3′ and reverse 3′-CTGAAGCTGTTGGGAGGGAG-5′ (139 bp); PERK, forward 5′-GTGAAGGTCGAGAGGCGTCG-3′ and reverse 3′-AATGCCGTATCCGATGTGGG-5′ (248 bp); ATF6, forward 5′-GAGGTGTCTGTTTCGGGGAA-3′ and reverse 3′-AGAACAACTGGAGGAAGCCG-5′ (309 bp); CHOP, forward 5′-GCCAGTGCCAAGCATGTA TC-3′ and reverse 3′-GTAAAGCCCCTCCTTTGG-5′ (78 bp); caspase-12, forward 5′-GGCCCATGTGGAGACAGATT-3′ and reverse 3′-AGCCACTCTTGCCTACCTTC-5′ (80 bp); JNK, forward 5′-GCTGCTTCCTGAGTCACAGT-3′ and reverse 3′-AGAATTGCTGGGGTCATGGGC-5′ (238 bp); collagen I, forward 5′-TGGTGAGACGTGGAAACCTG-3′ and reverse 3′-CTTGGGTCCCTCGACTCCTA-5′ (193 bp); collagen III, forward 5′-TTGGCACAGCAGTCCAATGTA -3′ and reverse 3′-GGGCAGTCTAGTGGCTCATC-5′ (164 bp); and β-actin, forward 5′-CCCATCTATGAGGGTTACGC-3′ and reverse, 3′-TTTAATGTCACGCACGATTTC-5′ (150 bp). The 2^−∆∆Cq^ method was used to analyze the results ([@b25-mmr-13-06-5037]). Western blotting ---------------- The cells were lysed and protein was extracted using radioimmunoprecipitation assay lysis buffer (Youkezhuoye Biotech Ltd., Beijing, China), containing 50 mM Tris (pH 7.4), 1% NP-40, 0.25% Na-deoxycholate, 150 mM NaCl, 1 mM EDTA). The protein was quantified using a BCA Protein assay kit (Beijing Kang Century Biotechnology Co., Ltd.) and 20 μg samples were resolved on 5% SDS-PAGE, wet transferred onto nitrocellulose membrane (Sigma-Aldrich) at 300 mA for 90 min and immunoblotted. The membrane was blocked with 5% bovine serum albumin in Tris-buffered saline-Tween 20 (TBST; Beijing Solarbio Science & Technology Co., Ltd., Beijing, China). The monoclonal rabbit anti-PERK (cat. no. 3192; dilution, 1:1,000) primary antibodies were obtained from Cell Signaling Technology, Inc. (Danvers, MA, USA) and polyclonal rabbit anti-caspase-12 (cat. no. ab62484; dilution, 1:1,000) primary antibodies were obtained from Abcam (Cambridge, MA, USA) and incubated with the membrane at 4°C for 12 h. The membranes were then washed three times with TBST for 10 min and incubated with horseradish peroxidase-conjugated goat anti-rabbit (dilution, 1:10,000; Jackson ImmunoResearch Laboratories, Inc., West Grove, PA, USA; cat. no. 111-035-003) or goat anti-mouse IgG (dilution, 1:10,000; Jackson ImmunoResearch Laboratories, Inc.; cat. no. 115-035-033) secondary antibodies at 25°C for 40 min. The membranes were washed again three times for 10 min. Image analysis was performed using Gelpro 3.0 software (Media Cybernetics, Inc., Rockville, MD, USA). Statistical analysis -------------------- All the data are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation. The differences in each group were evaluated using an independent-samples *t*-test. The differences between groups and between different time points were evaluated by two-way analysis of variance using IBM SPSS 19 statistical software (IBM SPSS, Armonk, NY, USA. Multiple comparison between the groups was performed using the least significant difference or Bonferroni method. P\<0.05 was considered to indicate a statistically significant difference. Results ======= Ratios of the heart and left ventricle weights to whole weight -------------------------------------------------------------- After 1 month, the weights of the heart and left ventricle were increased in the DM rats, compared with the normal rats, however, the difference was not statistically significant. The same trend was noted at months 4 and 5. After 7 months, the increases in the weight of the heart and left ventricle in the DM rats were significantly higher, compared with the control rats ([Fig. 1A and B](#f1-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). Change in ventricular EF in UCG ------------------------------- It is known that structural changes are generally followed by functional changes. This was apparent in the present study, which showed a significant decrease in EF in the DM rats, compared with the normal rats at 5 and 7 months. Despite the unexplained marginal increase in EF at 7 months, the data suggested that, overall, EF significantly decreased over time ([Fig. 2](#f2-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). Myocardial fibrosis in DM and normal rats ----------------------------------------- After 1 month, clear areas of tissue damage were noted, with loss and degeneration of cardiomyocytes, a pattern that persisted during the following months. It is well known that myocardial tissue is ultimately replaced by granulation tissue due to a deficient process of regeneration. Granulation tissue is characterized by early cellular infiltration, an increase in nuclear density and subsequently by extracellular matrix deposition. The present study used Masson\'s trichrome staining to enable clearer evaluation of granulation, and it was observed that the sizes of the blue-stained regions expanded significantly over time, ([Fig. 3A and B](#f3-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). The present study also found that the expression of collagen I remained higher in the DM rats, compared with the normal rats. This pattern of expression was different for collagen III, which was increased significantly early in the experiment, and then decreased prior to increasing again, however, this was not to the level observed at month 1 ([Fig. 3C and D](#f3-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). Changes in the mRNA levels of GRP78, ATF6 and PERK in DM rats and normal rats ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- The ER chaperone, GRP78, possesses antiapoptotic properties and is a central regulator of ER homeostasis. Its upregulation is widely used as an essential marker for ER stress under pathological conditions ([@b26-mmr-13-06-5037]). In the present study, a significant increase in GRP78 was observed in the DM rats at 1 month, followed by normalization in months 4 and 5, and subsequent reactivation, which indicated that GRP78 was activated early in the process of ER stress ([Fig. 4A](#f4-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). The activation of ATF6 is an important branch of the three pathways of ER stress ([Fig. 4B](#f4-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). The response of ATF6 to ER stress was similar to that of GRP78. PERK is an important pathway in ER stress and is associated with cellular apoptosis ([@b27-mmr-13-06-5037]). PERK increased significantly at 1 month, following which the mRNA levels reached a plateau ([Fig. 4C](#f4-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). By contrast, the present study found that the increase in protein levels was sustained, suggesting that this may reflect more rapid degradation of RNA, compared with protein. It may be that this unstable RNA does not accurately reflect the changes, or that other unknown factors may be stimulating protein expression. However, taken together, the data obtained in the present study indicated that the expression of PERK increased over time ([Fig. 4D and E](#f4-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). TUNEL staining and the mRNA expression levels of caspase-12, CHOP and JNK in DM rats and normal rats ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In the present study, TUNEL staining was used to determine the number of apoptotic nuclei, which revealed that there was a significant increase in the number of apoptotic nuclei over time ([Fig. 5A and B](#f5-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). The mRNA expression levels of JNK, CHOP and caspase-12 were also assessed ([Fig. 5C--E](#f5-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}) and were found to increase significantly in the first month. This activation occurred simultaneously with the UPR. With respect to caspase-12, the results of the mRNA and protein analyses in month 1 were consistent, with higher expression levels in the DM group, compared with the control group. However, this increase was reduced in months 5 and 7, which was followed by an increase ([Fig. 5F](#f5-mmr-13-06-5037){ref-type="fig"}). Discussion ========== In the present study, it was found that ER stress and ER stress-mediated apoptosis comprised the two phases of activation of ER stress and apoptosis, followed by myocardial fibrosis, in rats. When the rats were induced to exhibit high blood glucose for 1 month, the expression levels of the antiapoptotic markers, GRP78, PERK and ATF6, and the proapoptotic markers, JNK, CHOP and caspase-12 were all significantly higher. ER stress induced cellular apoptosis, which resulted in fibrosis and tissue remodeling. Although the present study performed extensive measurements of changes in the mRNA and protein expression levels of various molecules involved in the ER stress reaction, these are purely observational data. No evidence was presented to determine whether the changes in the ER pathway are simply associated with the progression of DM fibrosis, or whether they are involved in mediating the pathogenesis, and to what extent. The mechanisms underlying the external pathway and the mitochondrial pathway of apoptosis in the same model remain to be elucidated, and evidence of causation requires the use of specific inhibitors and/or knockout or knockin experiments of specific genes. The present study also found that the functional alterations began to appear at 7 months, rather than early in the process. The early and significant responses of ER stress and apoptosis indicated that the activation of apoptosis occurred simultaneously with anti-apoptosis, which is an early protective response to attenuate damage to the heart. Of note, under constant glucose stimulation, the expression levels of antiapototic and proapoptotic markers decreased, suggesting that the cells were developing mechanisms of adaptation. Whether this adaptation persists over time with minimal effect on function remains to be elucidated. An important pathway by which CHOP induces apoptosis is by regulating the balance between proapoptotic and antiapoptotic proteins from the B cell lymphoma-2 (Bcl-2) family. CHOP mediates the transcriptional repression and activation of proteins from the antiapoptotic Bcl-2 family ([@b28-mmr-13-06-5037]). CHOP also mediates the direct transcriptional induction of Bcl-2-interacting mediator of cell death, which is a proapoptotic protein from the Bcl-2 family ([@b29-mmr-13-06-5037]). Therefore, the Bcl-2 family may be an important factor, which determines cell survival or apoptosis. The present study did not monitor the changes in Bcl-2 family molecules. A more detailed comprehension of the signals determining the outcome of myocytes may offer potential in predicting the prognosis of patients and improve treatment programs at earlier stages. A previous study demonstrated that ER luminal proteins are released into the cytosol during ER stress-induced apoptosis in a Bcl-2 homologous antagonist killer/Bcl-2-associated X protein-dependent manner ([@b30-mmr-13-06-5037]). This provides an approach to locate apoptosis-associated molecules, rather than purely monitoring their levels of expression. The rapid increase in the protein level of PERK observed in the present study was not mirrored by the changes in mRNA expression. It is known that the PERK signaling arm is uniquely important for promoting adaptation and survival, as downstream eukaryotic initiation factor-2α can regulate transcription, and PERK is also regulated by cytokines ([@b31-mmr-13-06-5037]). This may be the reason that PERK is a central marker, as it regulates, but is also regulated, although the present study did not monitor functional phosphorylated-PERK. After 7 months, all proapoptotic markers were expressed at high levels again. This late response was associated with structural remodeling and heart failure, however, there is no evidence for this two-phase response in other models of heart disease. The present study also observed that the mRNA expression of collagen III increased significantly, and that the differences in HWI and LVWI between the DM rats, compared with the control rats, became evident at 7 months. A previous study demonstrated that, when diabetes-induced cardiac cell death is prevented by metallothionein at the early stage, a significant prevention in cardiac remodeling and dysfunction is observed at 5 or 6 months ([@b32-mmr-13-06-5037]). This finding indicates that the differences in remodeling and dysfunction begin to appear at \~6 months, and not earlier. The present study hypothesized that, if a stressful stimuli is maintained for 7 months, as in the DM rats used in the present study, the left ventricle is damaged causing irreversible changes to the structure and function of the heart. Therefore, identifying and interrupting the activation of proapoptotic markers during the early stages is important for inhibiting myocardial fibrosis. In the DM rats examined in the present study, sequential changes were described in ER stress and the ER stress-mediated apoptosis in myocardial fibrosis in rats. It was found that sustained DM induced myocardial fibrosis. The early activation of ER stress and apoptosis were observed after 1 month, and a turning point was observed after 7 months with ER stress and the presence of irreversible functional abnormality. However, the value of these findings depend, in part, on the identification of a protein, which can portend the direction of the outcome. The present study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant no. 81570220). {#f1-mmr-13-06-5037} {#f2-mmr-13-06-5037} {#f3-mmr-13-06-5037} {#f4-mmr-13-06-5037} {#f5-mmr-13-06-5037}

Introduction {#Sec1} ============ The development of secondary tumors in a part of the body that is far from the original primary cancer is termed "metastasis." Despite metastasis being the key cause of failure of cancer therapy and mortality, it remains poorly understood. In patients with cancer, large numbers of cancer cells are released in circulation daily; however, melanoma studies in animal models suggest that \<0.1% of tumor cells metastasize.^[@CR1]^ The development of metastases requires cancer cells to leave their primary site, circulate in the bloodstream, endure pressure in blood vessels, acclimate to new cellular surroundings in a secondary site, and escape deadly combat with immune cells.^[@CR2],[@CR3]^ Hanahan and Weinberg^[@CR4]^ specify that "activating invasion and metastasis" is a hallmark of cancer. Indeed, invasion of nearby tissue and seeding at distant sites to form metastases remains a central feature of cancer malignancy (Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). After all, metastasis constitutes the primary cause of death for \>90% of patients with cancer.^[@CR5]^ Understanding the dynamics of this process will help identify targets for molecular therapies that may halt or possibly reverse cancer growth and metastasis. Here, the authors review the recent advancements in the field of metastasis and highlight insights that contribute to shaping this hallmark of cancer.Fig. 1Overview of the metastatic cascade: The five key steps of metastasis include invasion, intravasation, circulation, extravasation, and colonization Dissemination and invasion {#Sec2} ========================== Chromosomal instability: the initial trigger {#Sec3} -------------------------------------------- Dissemination of cancer cells precedes the initial steps of the invasion-metastasis cascade.^[@CR6]^ The cascade is the consequence of chromosomal instability that is caused by continuous errors in chromosome segregation during mitosis (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Faults in chromosome segregation cause the rupture of micronuclei and the secretion of genomic DNA into the cytosol, which subsequently activates cytosolic DNA-sensing pathways (cyclic GMP-AMP synthase--stimulator of interferon (IFN) genes) and downstream nuclear factor κ-light-chain-enhancer of activated B (NF-κB) signaling.^[@CR7]^Fig. 2Determinants of metastasis: The activation of invasion and metastasis is triggered by epigenetic factors that are induced by environmental stimuli, such as aging and circadian disruptions; adhesive signals from extracellular matrix (ECM) components, such as collagen and fibrin; ECM mechanical pressures, including tension and compression; cell--cell interactions; soluble signals, such as growth factors and cytokines; and the intratumoral microbiota Studies suggest that the nature of the primary seeding cancer cell determines the different metastatic properties with respect to growth and response to therapy.^[@CR8],[@CR9]^ In vivo and in vitro studies show that metastatic cancer cells migrate individually.^[@CR10]^ In humans, however, it is believed that seeding requires the joint action of a cluster of tumor cells moving together,^[@CR11]^ which brings epithelial--mesenchymal transition (EMT) into the picture. Epithelial--mesenchymal transition: what is new? {#Sec4} ------------------------------------------------ EMT is the transdifferentiation process through which transformed epithelial cells develop the ability to invade, resist stress, and disseminate.^[@CR4]^ Epithelial cells are immotile and tightly bound to each other and to the neighboring extracellular matrix (ECM).^[@CR12]^ EMT governs the reversible biochemical alterations that permit a specific epithelial cell to attain a mesenchymal phenotype and confers epithelial--mesenchymal plasticity upon epithelial cells,^[@CR13]^ which is crucial for cancer progression and metastasis (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). However, not all cells that originate from the primary tumor site contribute to the development of metastasis. Studying the determinants of metastatic potential in a mouse model of breast cancer revealed that asparagine synthetase, a metabolic enzyme, is correlated with metastasis development.^[@CR14]^ Decreasing the levels of asparagine through ʟ-asparaginase treatment or through dietary restriction decreased metastatic spread. As such, asparagine availability promoted EMT.^[@CR14]^Fig. 3Epithelial--mesenchymal transition (EMT): EMT occurs through single-cell dissemination or through collective migration. The process consists of several transition stages between the initial epithelial cell and the invasive mesenchymal cell Recently, it has become broadly understood that the EMT program is a spectrum of transitional stages between the epithelial and mesenchymal phenotypes, in contrast to a progression that involves a binary choice between full-epithelial and full-mesenchymal phenotypes.^[@CR15]^ The transition of one state to another is governed by a number of growth factors^[@CR16]^ and signaling pathways.^[@CR17]^ Spontaneous EMT in primary tumor cells shifts between different intermediate stages with different invasive, metastatic, and differentiation characteristics.^[@CR18]^ Tumor cells that express a mix of epithelial and mesenchymal phenotypes are more effective in circulation, colonization at the secondary site, and the development of metastasis.^[@CR18]^ Moreover, transcriptional, chromatin, and single-cell RNA sequencing show that the various stages possess diverse cellular characteristics, chromatin landscapes, and gene expression signatures that are regulated by common and distinct transcription factors and signaling pathways. Moreover, the various EMT stages are situated in diverse microenvironments and are in contact with diverse stromal cells.^[@CR18]^ For example, metastatic cells with the most pronounced mesenchymal phenotype proliferate near endothelial and inflammatory cells. These tumor cells release large quantities of chemokines and proteins to attract immune cells and stimulate angiogenesis, thus promoting the development of a unique inflammatory and highly vascularized niche.^[@CR18]^ Cancer-associated fibroblasts have also been shown to drive and direct cancer cell migration through fibronectin alignment.^[@CR19]^ In addition, hypoxia,^[@CR20]^ metabolic stressors, and matrix stiffness^[@CR21]^ trigger the EMT program in cancer cells. Transitioning is often driven by transcription factors that are programmed to repress epithelial genes and activate mesenchymal genes.^[@CR22]^ Epigenetic and posttranslational modulators also play a vital role in controlling the EMT process.^[@CR15]^ In recent years, there has been an important debate on whether EMT has a central role in cancer metastasis and resistance to chemotherapy.^[@CR17],[@CR23]--[@CR25]^ Research in lung and pancreatic cancers shows that even though EMT might not be essential for metastasis, it does contribute to chemoresistance.^[@CR23],[@CR24]^ Nevertheless, more evidence is needed to completely and clearly elucidate the role of EMT in cancer progression and the metastatic process. Although EMT might be required for metastasis initiation, the opposite process of mesenchymal--epithelial transition (MET) is needed for metastatic progression. In bone metastasis, E-selectin in the bone vasculature induces MET and WNT activation in cancer cells to drive metastatic tumor formation.^[@CR26]^ Genetic profile of metastatic cells {#Sec5} ----------------------------------- Metastatic cancer encompasses a diverse collection of cells that possess different genetic and phenotypic characteristics, which differentially drive progression, metastasis, and drug resistance.^[@CR27]^ Hundreds of genes have been reported to determine invasive potential, suggesting that primary tumor cells exhibit a metastatic genetic signature.^[@CR28]--[@CR30]^ However, specific mutations can still promote invasion and metastasis in the context of some homozygous allelic expressions. Integrative clinical genomics showed that the most predominant genes that were somatically changed in metastasis included tumor protein p53 (*TP53*), cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor 2A (*CDKN2A*), phosphatase and tensin homolog (*PTEN*), phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate 3-kinase catalytic subunit alpha (*PIK3CA*), and retinoblastoma (*RB1*).^[@CR31],[@CR32]^ Putative pathogenic germline variants were present in 12.2% of cases, of which 75% were associated with DNA repair defects.^[@CR31]^ Markers that predict metastatic progression showed that advanced cancers arise from diverse cell types, which deeply affects the eventual genetic and epigenetic alterations that promote metastatic progression.^[@CR33]^ Metastatic small cell lung cancer (SCLC) cells differed in the genes that they expressed.^[@CR33]^ This might explain why some cancer cells respond to treatment, whereas others do not. As such, understanding intertumoral heterogeneity among different cancers can reveal the mechanisms of metastatic progression and how the cell type of origin contributes to tumor development. In colorectal cancer, cells expressing L1 cell adhesion molecule (L1CAM) confer metastasis-initiating abilities and chemoresistance. L1CAM hijacks the regenerative capacity of intestinal cells to promote metastasis.^[@CR34]^ In addition, the cytotoxic immune signature and the presence of lymphatic vessels play an important role in the generation of distant metastases, regardless of genomic instability.^[@CR35]^ Metabolic profile of metastatic cells {#Sec6} ------------------------------------- Genetic expression that is involved in different biological processes related to metastasis is also affected by oxygen homeostasis in the tumor microenvironment.^[@CR36]^ Hypoxia‐inducible factors (HIF) permit cancer cells to adapt to their cellular environment by regulating angiogenesis, EMT, invasion, metastasis, and energy metabolism.^[@CR4],[@CR37]--[@CR40]^ Furthermore, AXL, a receptor tyrosine kinase, has been identified as a vital mediator of HIF-dependent invasion and metastasis. In addition, HIF signaling drives the secretion of lysyl oxidase (LOX), LOX-like proteins, and exosomes, to establish a prometastatic environment within the lung and bones of patients with breast cancer.^[@CR20]^ Tumor hypoxia is associated with poor prognosis in clinical scenarios;^[@CR37],[@CR41]--[@CR44]^ HIF‐1α and HIF‐2α expression is linked to patient mortality.^[@CR41],[@CR42]^ In general, these hypoxic factors, along with others, are associated with tumor aggressiveness and resistance to therapy.^[@CR38]^ Moreover, tumors with more extensive hypoxic and anoxic areas exhibit higher rates of metastasis.^[@CR45]^ Metabolic differences among cancer cells lead to differences in metastatic potential. Metastatic cancer cells depend on monocarboxylate transporter 1 (MCT1) to deal with oxidative stress. MCT1 plays a major role in circulating lactate, which is a prominent energy source for metastasizing cells.^[@CR46]^ As such, highly metastatic cells have increased levels of MCT1, whereas the inhibition of MCT1 decreases lactate uptake by metastatic cells and, thus, reduces their metastatic capability.^[@CR46]^ Changes in ATP/ADP and ATP/AMP ratios also promote metastatic behavior. In pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma, ECM remodeling through cellular adhesion and compression affects these ratios.^[@CR47]^ Metabolomics shows that such alterations increase phosphocreatine production, which has a role in the invasive migration, chemotaxis, and liver metastasis of cancer cells.^[@CR47]^ Priming the premetastatic niche {#Sec7} ------------------------------- Secondary sites do not receive invading cancer cells passively. In fact, the host microenvironment, termed the premetastatic niche (PMN), is selectively primed by the primary tumor even before the initiation of metastasis.^[@CR48]^ The development of a PMN is a multistep process involving secretory factors and extracellular vesicles that induce vascular leakage, ECM remodeling, and immunosuppression.^[@CR48]^ High-definition microscopes have obtained images of cancer cells sharing biological material with less malignant cells, making these cells more cancerous.^[@CR49]^ Cancer cells release vesicles that carry messenger RNA transcribed from genes that are involved in cell migration and metastasis, which are then accepted by other cells.^[@CR49],[@CR50]^ After host cells engulf these vesicles, human cells that did not express a malignant phenotype start to migrate faster. The transferred genes also enhance the ability of cells to invade other organs.^[@CR49]^ As such, metastatic characteristics can be transferred through extracellular vesicle exchange.^[@CR49]^ Primary tumors release significant amounts of exosomes that transfer invasion-promoting factors, such as microRNAs (miRNAs), to tumorigenic cancer cells.^[@CR51]--[@CR53]^ For example, miR-10b is carried and released by exosomes and drives metastatic properties in breast cancer cells.^[@CR54]^ In addition, signaling factors mediated by exosomes activate epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) signaling to support cancer metastasis.^[@CR55]^ Exosomes that express EGFR ligands, such as amphiregulin, tissue-type plasminogen activator, and/or annexin II, considerably increase cancer cell invasion.^[@CR56]--[@CR59]^ Moreover, exosomes secrete EMT inducers that stimulate EMT progression in host epithelial cells, providing them with the ability to invade and metastasize.^[@CR60]--[@CR65]^ Furthermore, exosomes have the ability to remodel the ECM by interacting with fibroblasts, stromal cells, and endothelial cells to degrade protease-associated components such as collagen, laminin, and fibronectin.^[@CR66]^ Exosome-altered ECM exhibits increased stromal cell proliferation, cancer cell migration and survival, and tumor cell resistance to apoptotic signals. This, along with the effect of chemokines and growth factors, leads to the formation of a new microenvironment for cancer cells, immune cells, and other stromal constituents that is referred to as the PMN,^[@CR67]--[@CR70]^ where metastatic cells may arrest, extravasate, and ultimately colonize.^[@CR71]--[@CR73]^ In addition to their role in priming the PMN, exosomes exhibit properties that drive cancer cell organotropism. This metastatic bias towards certain organs stems from exosomal avidity for specific host cells.^[@CR60]^ Studying the exosomal proteomic expression of bone cancer showed different integrin patterns, whereby the exosomal integrins α6β4 and α6β1 were correlated with lung metastasis, whereas exosomal integrin αvβ5 was associated with liver metastasis.^[@CR74]^ Uptake of integrins in the secondary site led to the phosphorylation of Src and the expression of the proinflammatory gene *S100.*^[@CR74]^ Targeting those integrins decreased exosomal uptake, and lung and liver metastasis.^[@CR74]^ Other membrane proteins and lipids that are associated with ECM properties and adhesion influence the specific targeting of exosomes to their specific host cells.^[@CR74]--[@CR78]^ In addition, exosomal internalization by target host cells activates heterogeneous endocytic pathways such as clathrin, lipid raft, and caveolin-mediated uptake.^[@CR65],[@CR79],[@CR80]^ Exosome-mediated metastasis is not solely dependent upon tumor-released exosomes. In fact, astrocyte-derived exosomes mediate the intercellular transfer of miRNAs that target the *PTEN* tumor suppressor gene to metastatic cancer cells, promoting invasion and brain metastasis.^[@CR81]^ This, in turn, leads to the increased secretion of chemokine ligand 2 (CCL2), which recruits myeloid cells, enhancing the outgrowth of brain metastatic cells and reducing the effect of apoptotic signaling.^[@CR81]^ Inhibition of astrocytic exosomal release prevents PTEN loss and suppresses brain metastasis.^[@CR81]^ Can metastasis be driven by epigenetic factors? {#Sec8} ----------------------------------------------- Age-related physical changes in the ECM promote or inhibit tumor cell motility, invasion, and metastasis. Alterations in the motility of immune cells lead to changes in the immune microenvironment.^[@CR82]^ Elderly patients with melanoma tend to develop fewer metastases in proximal lymph nodes but have more distal metastases, with worse survival than that of younger cohorts.^[@CR83]^ Through in vitro analysis, increased lymphatic permeability of endothelial membranes was shown to be the reason for this phenomenon, as lymph nodes of older patients exhibited less ECM complexity in comparison with that of lymph nodes of younger patients with metastatic melanoma.^[@CR83]^ Further analysis revealed that hyaluronan and proteoglycan link protein 1 (*HAPLN1*) is responsible for controlling endothelial permeability.^[@CR82],[@CR83]^ Gene knockout increased endothelial permeability and the invasive ability of disseminating melanoma cells.^[@CR83]^ Other factors, such as decreased vascular endothelial-cadherin-dependent cell--cell adhesion and weak cell--ECM adhesion through α1 and β1 integrins, play a role in increasing lymph node permeability.^[@CR83]^ Chromatin mutations have recently come to light as important mediators of cancer development. Chromatin alterations induce cells to gain full oncogenic characteristics.^[@CR84]^ Furthermore, genetic, environmental, and metabolic conditions influence chromatin to become permissive or restrictive.^[@CR84]^ Epigenetic plasticity is exhibited when permissive chromatin induces oncogenic expression to promote metastatic development.^[@CR84]^ How does the microbiome contribute to cancer metastasis? {#Sec9} -------------------------------------------------------- The concept of the "tumor microbiome" originates from the fact that bacteria have been detected within tumors themselves. Although no links to patient outcomes and survival have been established, microbes have been reported to confer vulnerability to specific cancers.^[@CR85]^ Bacterial translocation selectively targets tumors that have rich vascular networks and chemotactic magnetism. Anaerobic and/or facultative bacteria, specifically, vigorously survive in hypoxic tumor microenvironments.^[@CR86],[@CR87]^ Tumoral bacteria are metabolically active, leading to alterations in the chemical structure of some chemotherapeutic agents and affecting the response to therapy.^[@CR88],[@CR89]^ Gammaproteobacteria located in pancreatic tumors confer resistance to gemcitabine, a commonly used drug in gastrointestinal cancers.^[@CR89]--[@CR91]^ *Fusobacterium nucleatum* also promotes resistance in colorectal cancer by initiating autophagy and activating Toll-like receptors on cancer cells.^[@CR92]^ Intratumoral bacteria further modulate the immune system. Although some bacteria stimulate antitumoral immunity, others promote immunosuppression, affecting the response to immunotherapy.^[@CR86],[@CR93]--[@CR98]^ The Fap2 protein of *Fusobacterium* prevents the activation of natural killer (NK) cells, protecting adenocarcinoma cell lines from NK cell antitumor activity.^[@CR99]^ Does the circadian cycle play a role in tumorigenesis? {#Sec10} ------------------------------------------------------ The circadian clock controls a wide spectrum of processes in cellular physiology through metabolic and gene expression pathways.^[@CR100]^ In the past decade, epidemiological studies on night-shift workers, meal timing, and exposure to light have linked alterations in circadian patterns to tumorigenesis,^[@CR101]--[@CR107]^ indicating that an active epigenetic mechanism may be responsible for wide-genome alterations. Circadian clock disruptions have been correlated with cancer initiation and progression. Further alterations in transcription complexes and cellular metabolism drive cancer progression by influencing cancer cell interactions with the microenvironment.^[@CR100]^ The MYC oncogene plays a role in cyclical metabolism in osteosarcoma cells, leading to increased consumption of glucose and glutamine.^[@CR108]^ Moreover, a number of circadian regulating genes have been linked to MYC expression. Cryptochrome circadian regulator 2, a circadian repressor, promotes MYC degradation.^[@CR109]^ Furthermore, zinc finger and BTB domain-containing protein 17 (MIZ1), a MYC-binding protein, downregulates core clock gene expression.^[@CR110]^ In addition, brain and muscle ARNT-like 1 expression is inversely correlated with MYC.^[@CR110]^ However, further research is needed to elucidate the mechanism through which other circadian inputs, such as nutrition, affect circadian metabolism and metastasis. CD36^+^ metastasis-initiating cells rely on palmitic acid, a dietary lipid, to promote metastasis. Blocking CD36 inhibits metastatic ability, suggesting that a high-fat diet specifically boosts the metastatic potential of metastasis-initiating cells.^[@CR111]^ Invasive cancer cells: remodeling the extracellular matrix {#Sec11} ---------------------------------------------------------- The ECM is a scaffold of interconnected macromolecules forming networks that encompass cells present in tissues and organs.^[@CR112]^ This specialized niche alters the phenotypic properties of cells and affects their propensity to proliferate, migrate, and survive.^[@CR113],[@CR114]^ Upon physiological and pathological triggers, ECM-degrading enzymes, called matrikines, are released to remodel the ECM, to re-establish an appropriate functional meshwork and maintain tissue homeostasis.^[@CR114],[@CR115]^ In cancer metastasis, ECM remodeling is hijacked, leading to stromal tumorigenesis.^[@CR116]--[@CR120]^ A variety of major ECM components, such as proteoglycans, collagen, laminins, fibronectin, elastin, other glycoprotein, and proteinases, are involved in the invasive and metastatic processes of cancer cells. One important step in invasion is the disassembly of the ECM and its constituents through enzymes such as matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs).^[@CR121]^ MMPs play a major role in cell proliferation, survival, immune response, and angiogenesis, in addition to invasion.^[@CR122],[@CR123]^ MMPs are elevated in most cancer types and are continuously associated with poor prognosis.^[@CR124],[@CR125]^ Cancer cells adjust the metastatic niche to drive growth by remodeling the ECM. The changes in nutrient accessibility and metabolic reactions in tissues determine the likelihood of cancer cells to metastasize. For example, metastatic breast cancer cells metabolize pyruvate, which is plentiful in the lungs, to drive collagen-based ECM remodeling in the lung metastatic niche.^[@CR126]^ Versican, a hyalectan that is present in interstitial ECM, activates EGFR signaling via its EGF-like repeats, which leads to cancer cell growth and invasion.^[@CR127],[@CR128]^ Chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan 4 (CSPG4) is another ECM component that plays an integral role in stabilizing the interactions between cells in the ECM matrix. CSPG4 interacts with integrin α2β1 upon collagen type VI binding to activate the phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) pathway in sarcoma cells.^[@CR129]^ In addition, CSPG4 forms complexes with MMP-2 and membrane type 3 MMP on the surface of melanoma cells to facilitate MMP-2 activation and eventual degradation of the ECM.^[@CR130]^ Lumican is an ECM protein that organizes fibril organization and circumferential growth. It plays a major role in corneal transparency, epithelial cell migration, and tissue repair. In cancer, lumican attenuates the proliferation, migration, and invasion of breast cancer cells. It modifies cellular junctions and promotes MET^[@CR131]^ through direct interactions with other ECM molecules or by the modulation of membrane receptors^[@CR132],[@CR133]^ and MMP-14.^[@CR134]--[@CR136]^ Glypicans are proteoglycans that participate in developmental morphogenesis. They play a dual role in fostering or suppressing tumorigenesis.^[@CR114],[@CR137]^ Glypican-3 exhibits a tumor suppressor phenotype. Decreased glypican-3 expression leads to the progression of malignancies, whereas its loss is associated with poor overall survival.^[@CR138]^ However, elevated expression of glypican-3 correlates with reduced cancer cell differentiation and the presence of lymph node metastases in lung cancer.^[@CR139],[@CR140]^ Glypican-5 overexpression also promotes tumor progression and metastasis in salivary adenoid cystic carcinoma and in rhabdosarcoma.^[@CR141]--[@CR143]^ Serglycin is an intracellular proteoglycan that is expressed by hematopoietic cells. Its expression drives cancer growth and metastasis.^[@CR144]^ Serglycin induces EMT and chemoresistance, as well as enhances the biosynthesis of proteolytic enzymes that aid in ECM remodeling.^[@CR145]^ In breast cancer, serglycin activates CD44/CREB1 signaling to enhance the secretion of transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β2) and EMT.^[@CR146]^ In non-SCLC and head-and-neck cancers, serglycin activates CD44/NF-κB/claudin-1 cells and mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK)/β-catenin signaling to drive EMT and chemoresistance.^[@CR147],[@CR148]^ Serglycin inhibition restricts the development of metastasis through decreased expression of chemokines such as CCL2.^[@CR149]^ Serglycin overexpression controls the secretion of tumor-derived exosomes and their ability to trigger cancer cell invasion and metastasis.^[@CR150]^ Hyaluronic acid (HA) is a glycosaminoglycan that is a principal constituent of the tumor stroma and cancer cell surfaces. It is an important EMT mediator and metastatic cancers express increased levels of HA, its CD44 receptor, and its synthase in the tumor cell microenvironment,^[@CR151]^ particularly in breast, oral, prostate, and ovarian cancers.^[@CR152],[@CR153]^ HA-mediated EMT enhancement is driven by the expression of zinc finger E-box-binding homeobox 1 (ZEB1) and its interaction with CD44, which in turn activates HA synthase 2 (*HAS2*) expression.^[@CR154]^ *HAS2* expression regulates TGFβ-induced EMT^[@CR155]^ through the expression of fibronectin, snail 1, and *ZEB1*. HAS2 has also been shown to be vital for the communication between cancer stem cells and tumor-associated macrophages (TAMs).^[@CR156]^ This interaction leads to enhanced secretion of platelet-derived growth factor-BB from TAMs, which activates stromal cells and rejuvenates cancer stem cells.^[@CR156]^ Inhibiting HAS2 activity via 4-methylumbelliferone limits HA synthesis and prevents metastasis in several cancer models.^[@CR156]--[@CR159]^ The striking effect of HA on tumor progression is highly associated with its molecular weight and interactions with other proteins in the ECM.^[@CR160],[@CR161]^ Low molecular weight (LMW) HA has well‐established tumorigenic proprieties.^[@CR161],[@CR162]^ In breast cancer, decreasing LMW‐HA production significantly inhibits cancer cell migration and invasion.^[@CR163]^ Moreover, excess LMW‐HA in the tumor microenvironment facilitates lymphatic metastasis via disruption of intercellular adhesion among lymphatic endothelial cells.^[@CR164]^ In addition, in the tumor interstitial fluid of colorectal cancer patients, LMW‐HA concentrations are increased and associated with lymphatic vessel invasion by cancer cells, and the development of lymph node metastases.^[@CR160]^ Altogether, the ECM is a complex and dynamic system that is composed of a wide spectrum of cells and matrikines that participate in invasion and metastasis. How does autophagy contribute to cancer cell invasion? {#Sec12} ------------------------------------------------------ Autophagy, the autophagosomal--autolysosomal process, is initiated by the advancement of various human cancers to metastasis. In vivo studies show that autophagy is involved in modulating tumor cell motility and invasion, cancer stem cell viability and differentiation, resistance to anoikis, EMT, metastatic cell dormancy, and escape from immune surveillance, with developing functions in forming the PMN and other metastatic facets.^[@CR165]^ Autophagy inhibition does not affect cell viability, proliferation, or migration but significantly reduces cellular invasion.^[@CR166]^ It was suggested that membrane-trafficking may play a critical role in the benign-to-malignant transition that is also central to the initiation of metastasis.^[@CR166]^ Can neurons initiate metastasis? {#Sec13} -------------------------------- It has always been puzzling how nerves emerge in the tumor microenvironment and what their role might be. Neural progenitors from the central nervous system that express doublecortin infiltrate prostate tumors and metastases.^[@CR167]^ These progenitors initiate neurogenesis, which is the process by which neurons are produced from neural stem cells.^[@CR168]^ These nerve fibers in the tumor microenvironment regulate cancer initiation and dissemination, providing insights into how doublecortin-expressing neurons can be targeted for therapy. Does the immune environment at the primary site play a role in metastasis? {#Sec14} -------------------------------------------------------------------------- The immune microenvironment around the tumor plays a major role in dictating the metastatic potential of the disseminating cells. A study analyzed tumors from more than 800 people with colorectal cancer, comparing people whose tumors were metastatic with those who were not.^[@CR35]^ The primary tumors from both groups had analogous mutation patterns in cancer genes; however, tumors that had metastasized had fewer cytotoxic T cells.^[@CR35]^ In addition, the invasive ends of the spread tumor cells had reduced densities of lymphatic vessels that carry immune cells.^[@CR35]^ Such changes contribute to metastasis and suggest that immunotherapies that enhance T-cell responses can stop metastasis in people with early-stage cancer.^[@CR169]^ Moreover, silencing the IFN regulatory factor (Irf)-7 pathway helps metastatic cells to escape immune surveillance.^[@CR170]^ In fact, a substantial number of genes that are suppressed in bone metastases are targets of Irf7 and restoration of Irf7 in tumor cells or administration of IFN led to decreased bone metastases and longer survival time.^[@CR170]^ In mice that are deficient in the IFN receptor or in NK and CD8(+) T-cell responses, metastasis was faster, indicating that Irf7-driven suppression of metastasis depends on IFN signaling to host immune cells.^[@CR170],[@CR171]^ Can surgical intervention contribute to metastatic dissemination? {#Sec15} ----------------------------------------------------------------- Sometimes, disseminated cancer cells survive and retain the ability to invade even after the removal of the primary tumor. Often, patients with pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma develop liver metastases following surgical excision of the primary tumor.^[@CR172]^ Metastasis possibly arises from dormant disseminated cancer cells that evade elimination by the immune system and are present at the time of surgery.^[@CR172]^ Analyzing mouse models and tissue samples from patients with pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma showed that dormant disseminated cancer cells do not express a cell surface molecule that elicits T-cell-mediated attacks.^[@CR172]^ This phenotype is related to their inability to relieve endoplasmic reticulum stress.^[@CR172]^ When this stress is lifted, disseminated cells start multiplying and invading to form metastases.^[@CR172]^ Anesthetics during surgery also have an underlying mechanism in promoting metastatic dissemination. In murine models of breast cancer, sevoflurane led to significantly increased lung metastasis compared with that of propofol.^[@CR173]^ Interestingly, sevoflurane increased interleukin (IL)-6 levels, which in turn led to signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT)-3 activation and the subsequent infiltration of myeloid cells into the lung.^[@CR173]^ By altering the tumor microenvironment through cytokines, anesthetics can promote cancer metastasis. Intravasation {#Sec16} ============= Intravasation, the dissemination of cancer cells to organs through the lumen of the vasculature, is mediated actively or passively.^[@CR12],[@CR174]^ This depends on the tumor type, microenvironment, and vasculature.^[@CR175]^ A three-dimensional microfluidic model shows that the endothelium poses a barrier to tumor cell intravasation and is regulated by factors that are present in the tumor microenvironment.^[@CR176]^ Using live-cell fluorescence microscopy and a tissue-engineered tumor-microvessel platform, a mitosis-mediated mechanism whereby tumor cells located along the vessel periphery disrupt the vessel endothelium through cell division and detach into circulation was elucidated.^[@CR177]^ Furthermore, the architectural constraints of tissue impose some mechanical pressures on invading tumor cells during intravasation.^[@CR178]^ Nuclear squeezing is particularly challenging on the integrity of the nucleus of the invaded cell. This causes genomic rearrangement to occur, which increases the metastatic potential.^[@CR178]^ Integrins are the key cellular adhesion receptors that are involved in nearly every step of cancer progression from primary tumor development to metastasis.^[@CR179]^ Altered integrin expression is frequently detected in tumors, where integrins have roles in supporting oncogenic growth factor receptor (GFR) signaling and GFR-dependent cancer cell migration and invasion.^[@CR179]^ Furthermore, integrins regulate the colonization process in metastatic locations by easing anchorage-independent survival of circulating tumor cells (CTCs). Metastatic cells use E-cadherin in metastatic sites to detach, disseminate, and seed.^[@CR180]^ This promotes metastatic cell survival and blocks reactive oxygen-mediated apoptosis.^[@CR180]^ As such, inhibiting E-cadherin in metastatic breast cancer cells may hold therapeutic potential against breast cancer.^[@CR180]^ Circulation {#Sec17} =========== How do tumor cells survive in circulation? {#Sec18} ------------------------------------------ The circulatory journey is harsh for most intravasating cancer cells. Interactions between CTCs and the microenvironmental components of circulation determine survival and the ability of CTCs to eventually extravasate in distant sites.^[@CR181]--[@CR183]^ Most CTCs circulate as single cells, whereas others travel in clusters (Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). However, circulating clusters are much more likely to form metastases.^[@CR184]^ In addition to the invading cancer cells, clusters contain stromal cells and immune components from the original microenvironment that contribute to the heterogeneity of the cluster and enhance its survival.^[@CR184]--[@CR188]^ Neutrophils participate in cluster formation and suppress leukocyte activation, which increases the chances of CTC survival.^[@CR189]^ Moreover, the interaction of CTCs with platelets leads to the formation of a coating shield of platelets around cancer cells that prevents CTC detection by immune cells and provides the structure needed to bear the physical stresses of circulation.^[@CR190]--[@CR192]^Fig. 4Cancer cells circulate as single units or in clusters. After arresting at secondary sites or becoming stuck in capillaries, circulating tumor cells (CTCs) extravasate and colonize their new niches. Some cells undergo dormancy as an adaptation mechanism to the new stressful environment An important factor in the metastatic process is the ability of CTCs to adhere and extravasate through endothelial cells and colonize the PMN.^[@CR193]^ As soon as CTCs arrest in capillaries, they either extravasate by transendothelial migration or grow within the vessel before eventual extravasation and colonization of the PMN.^[@CR194]--[@CR197]^ Do circulating tumor cells interact with immune cells? {#Sec19} ------------------------------------------------------ CTCs must adapt to the strict selective environment present in the lumen of the vasculature. The dissemination of CTCs is supported by close association with activated platelets and macrophages.^[@CR198]^ Therefore, CTCs form heteroaggregates that sustain adhesion to the endothelium and thus contribute to metastasis.^[@CR190]^ However, this belief has been challenged by showing that an increase in megakaryocytes confers some measure of protection against metastasis.^[@CR199]^ In addition, neutrophils in circulation have been found to inhibit metastasis.^[@CR6],[@CR200]^ Blood sampling in 70 women with advanced-stage breast cancer showed a CTC--immune cell association.^[@CR201]^ The white blood cells that showed the greatest interaction were neutrophils, suggesting that neutrophil clustering with CTCs increases the metastatic potential of CTCs.^[@CR201]^ The advancement of the disease in people with advanced breast cancer was faster among individuals who had CTC--neutrophil clusters when compared with that of people who lacked such clusters.^[@CR201]^ Furthermore, CTCs from both CTC--neutrophil clusters and others that had not been part of a neutrophil cluster were injected into the bloodstream of tumor-free mice. A substantially increased number of metastases were found in the mice that received CTCs from CTC--neutrophil clusters. In addition, upon the eradication of neutrophils in mice with breast tumors, the number of CTC--neutrophil clusters was markedly decreased.^[@CR201]^ These mice had delayed metastases in the lungs when compared with those of mice bearing breast tumors that did not have their neutrophils depleted.^[@CR201]^ Moreover, the complex interchange between cancer cells and white blood cells facilitates metastasis, because metastatic cells possess sugar on their cell surface that binds to galectin-3.^[@CR202]^ This enhances the ability of cells to colonize by interacting with mobilized white blood cells.^[@CR202]^ Resisting vascular forces and mechanical pressure {#Sec20} ------------------------------------------------- The journey of CTCs in the blood vessels is not easy. CTCs sense and respond to tissue mechanics and instigate brief or lasting tissue alterations, including ECM stiffening, compression and deformation, protein unfolding, proteolytic remodeling, and jamming transitions.^[@CR203]^ Mechanical pressures are likely to be found during arrest of CTCs at distant sites, when exiting vessels (extravasation), and during metastatic growth. Permissive flow regimens in vascular regions, in addition to the location and efficiency of CTC lodging at distant sites, play large roles in the distant metastasis process.^[@CR204]^ The passage of CTCs through the bloodstream is halted when their adhesive capacity becomes greater than the shear forces imposed on them by the blood flow.^[@CR204]^ Therefore, regions with low hemodynamic flow are the regions where most CTCs stabilize and engage with endothelial cells. It is in such regions that single CTCs might sequentially form intravascular clusters.^[@CR205]^ Once CTCs are fixed in the microvasculature, they are fragmented by the flow of blood. This generates immune-interacting intermediate molecules that promote extravasation and develop metastases from the surviving CTCs.^[@CR206],[@CR207]^ This hypothesis was further tested in a cohort of 100 patients with brain metastases and found that these metastases formed in regions with low cerebral blood flow.^[@CR204]^ Therefore, shear forces play an important role in hematogenous metastasis and in determining the location of the final arrest. How does the release of chemokines and cytokines help circulating tumor cells? {#Sec21} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The migration of metastatic cells in circulation often relies on a spectrum of chemokines and complement components that direct tumor cells through the vasculature^[@CR208],[@CR209]^ and metabolic factors that result in an antioxidant effect.^[@CR210]^ Granulocyte macrophage colony-stimulating factor and cytokines such as IL-5, which are induced in obesity, lead to lung neutrophilia in obese mice and aid in breast cancer metastasis.^[@CR211]^ In addition, when crowded, cancer cells boost the production of IL-6 and IL-8, two immune molecules that stimulate biochemical pathways and facilitate tumor migration.^[@CR212]^ In mouse breast cancer models, blocking IL-6 and IL-8 receptors through experimental treatments minimized metastasis at lymph nodes, lungs, and liver compared with those of the control groups.^[@CR212]^ Further data suggest that metastatic tumors induce the release of IL-1β, which induces gamma delta (γδ) T cells to release IL-17, suppressing cytotoxic CD8^+^ T lymphocytes and promoting metastasis.^[@CR213]^ In addition, the loss of *TP53* in cancer cells induces the secretion of WNT ligands that stimulate the production of IL-1β, thus driving prometastatic neutrophilic inflammation.^[@CR214]^ Is tumor cell circulation contingent on the route of the bloodstream? {#Sec22} --------------------------------------------------------------------- It is now accepted that CTCs can exploit and survive in the bloodstream during tumor metastasis.^[@CR204],[@CR207]^ However, CTCs have also been found to cause distant metastases through the lymphatic circulation.^[@CR215]--[@CR217]^ The "sequential progression model" is the basis for excision of tumor-draining lymph nodes during surgery.^[@CR215]^ Metastatic cancer cells can travel from a primary tumor to a distant site via two courses: directly through the bloodstream or through a lymph node near the primary cancer site.^[@CR218]^ The biological mechanisms by which tumor cells survive and grow within lymph nodes are not yet clear. In murine models, cancer cells acclimatize to the lymph node microenvironment by shifting their metabolism to fatty acid oxidation.^[@CR218]^ The signaling pathway on which the adaptation process is based is driven and activated by the yes-associated protein (YAP) transcription factor.^[@CR218]^ Notably, inhibition of fatty acid oxidation or YAP signaling blocked lymph node metastasis in mice.^[@CR218]^ Diagnostics in circulation: where are we now? {#Sec23} --------------------------------------------- Enrichment of CTCs allowed their classification and subsequent tumor analysis.^[@CR219]^ CTC characterization helps reflect on the molecular foundations of metastatic tumors, whereas cell-free DNA (cfDNA) offers new genetic material for further exploration in trials.^[@CR220]^ cfDNA reflects the heterogeneity of CTCs in patients with high counts of CTCs and thus enables monitoring of the metastatic burden for clinical decision-making.^[@CR221]^ In addition, cfDNA profiling tracks the subclonal nature of cancer metastasis.^[@CR222]^ As such, liquid biopsy of CTCs and/or cfDNA in the peripheral blood might have the potential to further the current understanding of metastasis biology.^[@CR219]^ However, it is worthwhile to ponder whether currently used techniques for enrichment and detection of CTCs allow us to identify actual metastasis‐initiating cells and whether liquid biopsy can be used to investigate the effectiveness of cancer treatment. Targeting circulating tumor cells: can it be done? {#Sec24} -------------------------------------------------- For a long time, the low sensitivity of CTC detection assays has halted CTC elimination. In addition, the exclusion of patients with metastasis from clinical trials prevented faster progress.^[@CR223]^ However, advancements in the field have changed the reigning paradigm and offered hope for future success. A photoacoustic method for direct use in patients with melanoma has been developed, allowing for the detection of very low numbers of CTCs in vivo and their subsequent destruction with laser pulses.^[@CR224]^ This reflects the therapeutic potential of such approaches. In addition, distinct DNA methylation profiles are present among CTC clusters from patients and murine models with breast cancer when compared with that of single CTCs.^[@CR225]^ This, along with the phenotypic differences, can be targeted in future therapeutic options. Extravasation {#Sec25} ============= How do circulating tumor cells extravasate? {#Sec26} ------------------------------------------- When CTCs pass through small capillaries, they become entrapped. This either leads to microvascular rupture or forces the cell to undergo extravasation.^[@CR3]^ As organs such as the liver and bone have highly permeable sinusoidal vessels, CTCs exhibit a high rate of metastasis in these organs.^[@CR12]^ In other organs, extravasating cells are faced with tight barriers and basement membranes that require genetic and molecular mediation to be able to transmigrate. Extravasation is a complex process that involves ligand--receptor interactions, chemokines, and circulating nontumor cells.^[@CR174],[@CR226],[@CR227]^ Integrins, again, play a vital role in determining the sites at which extravasation and colonization occur by facilitating anchorage-independent survival of CTCs.^[@CR179]^ Many have reported that cancer cell extravasation occurs in a similar fashion to leukocyte transendothelial migration.^[@CR174],[@CR228],[@CR229]^ In recent years, it has been shown that cancer cells induce programmed necrosis of endothelial cells, driving metastatic cells to extravasate. Treatment with the receptor-interacting serine/threonine-protein kinase (RIPK)-1-inhibitor necrostatin-1 or endothelial-cell-specific deletion of *RIPK3* reduced endothelial necroptosis and metastatic extravasation.^[@CR230]^ Are circulating tumor cells target-specific? {#Sec27} -------------------------------------------- Organotropism was first touched upon by Paget as part of the "seed and soil" hypothesis.^[@CR231]^ Breast cancer research has supported this hypothesis,^[@CR232],[@CR233]^ with researchers elucidating the genetic basis for cancer colonization in distant organs.^[@CR234]^ Moreover, the host microenvironment and the adaptive process that invading cancer cells undergo play a role in extravasation and colonization of cancer cells at specific sites.^[@CR235]^ For example, breast cancer most frequently metastasizes to the bone, often after long latency, suggesting that metastatic seeds are resistant to therapy and can regrow (Fig. [5](#Fig5){ref-type="fig"}). Calcium flux, for instance, has been identified as a mechanism of crosstalk between the osteogenic niche and cancer cells, which promotes the progression of bone metastasis.^[@CR236]^ Another example involves patients with postpartum breast cancer, who are at elevated risk for liver metastasis.^[@CR237]^ The identification of the "weaning-induced liver involution," which establishes a metastatic microenvironment, may account, in part, for the poor prognosis of patients with postpartum breast cancer.^[@CR237]^Fig. 5Metastastatic Organotropism: Clinical observations suggest that most cancers metastasize to specific target organs, a process known as "metastatic organotropism" Colonization {#Sec28} ============ How does the colonizing cell overcome stromal challenges? {#Sec29} --------------------------------------------------------- Circulating cells that extravasate at the target site are challenged with harsh conditions that make survival difficult.^[@CR22]^ A number of secreted tumor-derived factors and bone marrow-derived cells signal the formation of the PMN, in which the tumor cells colonize and grow.^[@CR12],[@CR238]--[@CR240]^ In addition to tumor-derived factors, exosomes play a major role (discussed earlier). Exosomes have a role in educating bone marrow progenitor cells to become metastatic.^[@CR240]^ Further research showed similar results in pancreatic cancer, whereby exosomes initiated PMN formation in the liver.^[@CR73]^ However, cancer cell--host cell interactions are also important for proper colonization. Hepatocytes control myeloid cell accumulation and fibrosis within the liver and thus increase the susceptibility of the liver to metastatic colonization. In murine models of pancreatic cancer, hepatocytes induce IL-6-mediated STAT3 signaling and increase secretion of serum amyloid A1 and A2 (SAA). Inhibition of IL-6-STAT3-SAA signaling prevents the establishment of a PMN and inhibits liver metastasis.^[@CR241]^ Establishing a vascular network is crucial for proper metastatic colonization. Vascular mimicry drives the ability of some breast cancer cells to contribute to distant metastases through the overexpression of *SERPINE2* and *SLPI.*^[@CR242]^ These two genes are overexpressed preferentially in human patients with breast cancer lung metastases, suggesting their potential for metastatic progression.^[@CR242]^ Colonizing cancer cells are also capable of utilizing neuronal signaling pathways for growth and adaptation. The proximity of breast cancer cells to neuronal synapses allows cancer cells to hijack *N*-methyl-[d]{.smallcaps}-aspartate receptor signaling to promote brain metastasis.^[@CR243]^ Protocadherin 7 is a protein that promotes the assembly of cancer cell--astrocyte gap junctions composed of connexin 43. Metastatic cancer cells use these junctions to transfer the second messenger cGAMP to astrocytes, activating the stimulator of interferon genes pathway and producing inflammatory cytokines such as IFNα and tumor necrosis factor. In turn, these factors activate STAT1 and NF-κB pathways in brain metastatic cells, thereby supporting tumor growth and chemoresistance.^[@CR244]^ Dormancy: why do cancer cells go to sleep? {#Sec30} ------------------------------------------ By definition, cancer dormancy is an arrest phase in cancer progression that occurs during the primary tumor formation phase or after invasion into secondary sites.^[@CR245]^ Metastatic dormancy specifically occurs due to the delayed acclimatization of disseminating cancer cells to their secondary niches^[@CR246]^ and affects single invading cells or cancer clusters after circulation. In many cancer survivors, dormant cancer cells are present long after radical removal of the primary tumor and are thought to be responsible for late relapses.^[@CR246]^ Dormancy constitutes quiescence, angiogenic dormancy in which an equilibrium is realized between dividing and dying (vascular-lacking) cancer cells, and immune-mediated dormancy in which the tumor mass is preserved by immune cell cytotoxicity.^[@CR12],[@CR247]^ Some believe that the target organ microenvironment instructs CTCs to enter dormancy, whereas others think that primary tumors pre-encode a dormancy signature on CTCs that only becomes evident when CTCs enter the host microenvironment. Another potential explanation is that early dissemination spawns CTCs that respond to dormancy-inducing signals and enter dormancy in target organs.^[@CR248]^ What are the mechanisms that govern dormancy? {#Sec31} --------------------------------------------- Regulation of tumor cell dormancy involves reciprocal crosstalk between the environment and mechanisms that control transcriptional programs.^[@CR249]^ Single-cell dormancy describes the reversible state of quiescence that the metastatic cell enters in response to stressful stimuli, while expressing the Ki67 proliferation marker.^[@CR245]^ Metabolic homeostasis is maintained in the dormant state through the downregulation of two of the most well-studied pathways that are activated during oncogenesis, the RAS--MEK--ERK/MAPK and PI3K-AKT signaling cascades, which play critical roles in governing cancer cell dormancy.^[@CR250]^ Factors secreted by the PMN, such as mesenchymal cell‐derived bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) and growth arrest‐specific 6 produced by osteoblasts, also shift cancer cells towards dormancy.^[@CR251],[@CR252]^ BMP7 activates the metastatic suppressor gene N‐myc downstream‐regulated gene 1 (*NDGR1*), leading to an increase in p38 MAPK activation, cell cycle inhibitor p21 expression, and cell cycle arrest.^[@CR251]^ Molecular interactions between mitogen‐ and stress‐induced signaling are vital in regulating the dormancy/activation state of metastatic cancer cells. The ratio of extracellular signal‐regulated kinase (ERK1/2) to p38 MAPK regulates the cell cycle. High levels of ERK1/2 activity favor proliferation, whereas high levels of p38 favor dormancy. Increased p38 MAPK activity triggers the activation of the unfolded protein response, which upregulates activating transcription factor 6, thus promoting cell arrest and survival.^[@CR253],[@CR254]^ These observations support the notion that the activation of stress signaling pathways induces a sustained state of quiescence that is linked to dormancy (Fig. [6](#Fig6){ref-type="fig"}).Fig. 6Dormancy and reactivation of cancer cells: The genetic and signaling pathways that govern cancer cell dormancy and subsequent reactivation involve intracellular signaling, extracellular signaling, and induction signals originating from the bone marrow niche How does dormancy occur in metastatic clusters? {#Sec32} ----------------------------------------------- Dormancy in metastatic cancer clusters occurs when the rate of cellular proliferation within the cluster is equal to the rate of apoptosis. As such, the tumor cluster does not expand into micrometastasis. This balance is achieved through suppressive gene signaling, restricted angiogenesis, and/or an active immune microenvironment.^[@CR245]^ Suppressive gene signaling can be achieved through the induction of differentially expressed in chondrocytes 2 (*DEC2*), a tumor suppressor gene. TGFβ induces DEC2, which inhibits cyclin-dependent kinase 4 and activates p27, forcing the cell to enter a state of quiescence.^[@CR255]^ Blocking blood vessel formation through activation of thrombospondin-1^[@CR256]^ or through the inhibition of chaperones, such as heat shock 27 kDa protein, pushes metastatic clusters into a dormant state.^[@CR257]^ The immune system is also a major factor in cancer antiproliferation. T cells and NK cells, in addition to macrophages, clear metastatic cells through cytolysis.^[@CR258]^ Dormant tumor cells express weak antigens to escape the immune system, which could be the reason behind relapse following immunotherapy.^[@CR249]^ From dormancy to activation: how does the dormant cell wake up? {#Sec33} --------------------------------------------------------------- Researchers have begun to understand the process that allows certain cancer cells to become dormant for periods of time and emerge later with recurring disease. These cancer cells enter a state of latency and slow division by inhibiting a WNT protein-driven signaling pathway.^[@CR246]^ In addition, these cells exhibit increased levels of the stem cell genes SRY-box (SOX)-2 and SOX9, which allow for the growth of new tumors if certain conditions exist. To reduce the ability of the immune system to identify them, these dormant cancer cells downregulate the expression of immune cell-recognizable molecules.^[@CR246]^ This allows tumor cells to evade an immune response until conditions allow the development of metastasis. Persistent host organ inflammation and the complementary establishment of neutrophilic extracellular traps may transform dormant cancer cells into aggressive metastases.^[@CR259]^ Others believe that the shift from dormancy to activation occurs with respect to organotropism,^[@CR3]^ indicating that the host microenvironment plays a role in waking the cells from their dormant state.^[@CR260]^ More importantly, it has been established that high levels of ERK1/2 with respect to p38 MAPK promote reactivation. Cancer cell plasticity and tumor progression {#Sec34} -------------------------------------------- Cancer cell plasticity facilitates the development of therapy resistance and malignant progression. Plasticity bestows upon cancer cells the ability to dynamically switch between a differentiated state, with limited tumorigenic potential, and an undifferentiated or cancer stem-like cell state, which is responsible for long-term tumor growth. However, researchers remain hopeful that cancer cell plasticity can be exploited therapeutically. Some have forced the transdifferentiation of EMT-derived breast cancer cells into post-mitotic and functional adipocytes by using a combination therapy of MEK inhibitors and the antidiabetic drug rosiglitazone, thereby inhibiting the metastatic process.^[@CR261]^ Genome-wide in vivo screens can identify novel host regulators of metastatic colonization. In vivo studies have identified multiple genes that, when disrupted, modify the ability of tumor cells to establish metastases.^[@CR262]^ Often, endovascular progenitor cells function as precursors of endothelial cells.^[@CR263]^ These progenitor cells express the transcription factor SOX18 and are thus unaffected by therapies that target vascular endothelial growth factor. By ablating Notch signaling, SOX18 is inhibited, which subsequently halts melanoma metastasis in murine models.^[@CR263]^ In many instances, glucocorticoids are used to treat patients with cancer-related complications. The progression of breast cancer is initiated by increasing stress hormone and glucocorticoid levels, which subsequently activates secondary site glucocorticoid receptors, enhances cancer colonization, and decreases survival rates.^[@CR202]^ This suggests the use of caution when treating cancer patients with glucocorticoid therapy. Despite the displayed effectiveness of cytotoxic chemotherapy in treating invasive breast cancer, it has been shown that the treatment displays prometastatic effects.^[@CR264]^ Paclitaxel and doxorubicin trigger the production of tumor-derived extracellular vesicles in models of chemoresistant breast cancer in mice.^[@CR264]^ These vesicles facilitate the colonization of tumors at metastatic sites in the lungs.^[@CR264]^ Suppressing the suppressor {#Sec35} -------------------------- Metastasis suppressors inhibit cancer growth and proliferation at the metastatic site without affecting the primary tumor.^[@CR265],[@CR266]^ They target oncogenic pathways and proteins that are involved in invasion and eventual metastatic colonization. For example, A-kinase anchor protein 8 is a splicing regulatory factor that suppresses EMT and breast cancer metastasis.^[@CR267]^ In highly metastatic cells, metastasis suppressors are usually downregulated in comparison with primary tumor cells.^[@CR265],[@CR268],[@CR269]^ In the past decade, a significant number of metastasis suppressors have been identified (Fig. [7](#Fig7){ref-type="fig"}). Most notably, miRNAs that suppress oncogenes and inhibit tumorigenic signaling have been recognized and explored as potential biomarkers and targets of metastasis.^[@CR265],[@CR270]--[@CR293]^Fig. 7Metastasis suppressor genes that have been identified in the literature: Metastasis suppressors halt metastatic proliferation at the secondary site without changing the primary cancer. They work through oncogenic signaling pathways to suppress invasion and eventual colonization Therapeutic strategies to target the pathways of metastasis {#Sec36} =========================================================== The field of metastasis research is more than 100 years old. However, metastasis remains the primary cause of cancer-related deaths. Major obstacles lie in the lack of clinical trials that target metastasis and the lack of knowledge of the biological underpinnings that govern the metastatic process.^[@CR169],[@CR171],[@CR220],[@CR223]^ Designing targeted therapies for metastatic cancer cells should take into account the genetic and phenotypic differences between parental and metastatic/circulating cells.^[@CR294]^ Today, the diagnosis of metastatic cancer continues to be associated with a terminal label. Although prevention of metastasis has been demonstrated preclinically, drug development has been hindered due to poor trial design and therapeutic strategies. Advancements in immunotherapy have improved survival and patient outcomes in metastatic melanoma.^[@CR295],[@CR296]^ In addition, the development of novel androgen receptor inhibitors extended the survival of metastatic prostate cancer.^[@CR297]^ However, long-term follow-ups have failed to demonstrate consistency in the survival benefits of patients with metastatic breast cancer.^[@CR298]^ Strategies that target pathways in the metastatic cascade have been studied and explored.^[@CR294]^ The seeding of cancer cells can be targeted by inhibiting intratumoral interactions, intercellular crosstalk through ECM adhesion molecules, the release of proteases, EMT, and intravasation. However, at the time of metastasis diagnosis, cancer cells may have already seeded in the circulatory system or colonized a distant site.^[@CR220]^ Therefore, targeting metastatic colonization seems to be the most plausible therapeutic strategy, as it correlates mostly with the clinical scene. Dormancy has also been studied as a potential target of metastatic colonization. Some have proposed therapies that help sustain the dormant state.^[@CR299]^ Others have designed combination treatments that target G0 tumor cells. Moreover, monoclonal antibodies have been developed to target single cancer cells at this stage.^[@CR300]^ In addition to CTCs (discussed earlier), the diagnostic and predictive potential of exosomes renders them key for liquid biopsies.^[@CR220],[@CR301]^ In terms of targeting tumor-secreted factors, exosome affinity plasmapheresis has been developed to trap exosomes with immunosuppressive or tumorigenic material (NCT02439008); however, the trial has been terminated due to a lack of patient accrual. The brain continues to be a special site for metastasis, as colonizing cells are offered a safe haven through the existence of the blood--brain barrier (BBB). The BBB allows the crossing of tumor cells and prevents the passage of therapeutic agents.^[@CR302]^ Therefore, agents that are known to cross the BBB must be tested in brain metastasis settings and novel agents with the ability to cross the BBB must be designed.^[@CR223]^ Overall, metastasis is a complex challenge that requires more than one therapeutic agent for effective inhibition. Therefore, embracing the combination therapy model and targeting multiple pathways simultaneously seems to be key to countering the significant genomic and phenotypic alterations presented by metastatic cancer cells.^[@CR303]^ Concluding remarks {#Sec37} ================== Metastasis is the final frontier in cancer for which more efficacious therapies are needed. However, the development of effective treatments is contingent upon understanding the underpinnings that govern the metastatic process from start to finish. As such, exploring metastatic evolution is necessary to be able to design better therapeutics in the future. The authors declare no competing interests.

\section*{Introduction}\selabel{0} In this paper, we are concerned primarily with the problem of whether epimorphisms in the category ${\rm HopfAlg}$ of Hopf algebras over a field $k$ are surjective, and the dual question of whether monomorphisms are injective. This makes sense in any concrete category; in \cite{Re}, for example, the corresponding problem (on epimorphisms) is solved for some familiar categories, such as groups, Lie algebras, $C^*$ and von Neumann algebras, compact groups, locally compact groups, etc. To our knowledge, the problem has not been treated in the literature in the context of Hopf algebras. Aside from being interesting and natural in their own right, the two questions do play a part in certain technical results on Hopf algebras. In \cite{AD}, for example, a paper concerned with exact sequences of Hopf algebras, these problems arise naturally several times. In the dual pair \cite[Lemmas 1.1.6, 1.1.10]{AD} it is shown that certain conditions on a morphism of Hopf algebras are implied by injectivity, and imply that the morphism in question is a monomorphism in ${\rm HopfAlg}$ (and similarly for surjectivity). Also, in a remark after \cite[Prop. 1.2.3]{AD}, the authors observe that in a diagram of the form \[ \begin{diagram} 0 &\rTo &\bullet &\rTo &\bullet &\rTo &\bullet &\rTo &0\\ & &\dTo<{{\rm id}} & &\dTo<{\theta} & &\dTo<{{\rm id}} & & \\ 0 &\rTo &\bullet &\rTo &\bullet &\rTo &\bullet &\rTo &0 \end{diagram} \] where the rows are what in that paper are called exact sequences of Hopf algebras (\cite [Prop. 1.2.3]{AD}), $\theta$ is both a monomorphism and an epimorphism of Hopf algebras. The authors then mention as unknown whether in this case it follows that $\theta$ is an isomorphism, or, in general, whether epimorphisms (monomorphisms) of Hopf algebras are surjective (injective). In other words, this is a direct reference to our problem. It is, however, the only such reference we could find in the literature. A much more well-documented problem, on the other hand, is the one known as Kaplansky's first conjecture. Strictly speaking, the conjecture/problem has undergone several transformations since its appearance in \cite{Ka}. It initially asked whether all Hopf algebras are (left and right) free modules over their Hopf subalgebras. At the time, this was already known to be false: Oberst and Schneider had constructed a counterexample in \cite{OSch}. There are several positive results on the problem: it holds for instance if the coradical of the large Hopf algebra is contained in the small one by a result of Nichols (this also follows from \cite[Cor. 2.3]{Ra2}), or if the large algebra is pointed (\cite{Ra1}), or in the finite dimensional case by the now famous Nichols-Zoeller theorem (\cite[Theorem 3.1.5]{Mo}). In view of the general negative answer, it makes sense to weaken the requirements: \cite[Question 3.5.4]{Mo} asks whether Hopf algebras are always (left and right) faithfully flat over their Hopf subalgebras. Again, this holds in various particular cases (commutative, or cocommutative, or even when the large algebra has cocommutative coradical; we give some references below, in \seref{2}, after \prref{halg>coalg}). In the commutative case, the problem of faithful flatness arose in the theory of affine algebraic groups, for which we refer to \cite{DG, Wa}. Indeed, faithful flatness for commutative Hopf algebras (\cite[Th. 3.1]{Ta3}) is crucial in Takeuchi's purely algebraic proof in \cite{Ta3} of the one-to-one correspondence between normal closed subgroup schemes and quotient affine group schemes of an affine group scheme. See \cite[Th. 5.2]{Ta3}, and also \cite[Chapters 13-16]{Wa} for an exposition of these results. Despite all of these positive partial results, in general, Hopf algebras are {\it not} faithfully flat over Hopf subalgebras (\cite[Remark 2.6, Cor. 2.8]{Sc}). At the end of \cite[$\S$2]{Sc}, Schauenburg asks what we refer to from now on as being the current version of Kaplansky's question (or problem): Are Hopf algebras with bijective antipode (left and right) faithfully flat over Hopf subalgebras with bijective antipode? Our interest in the question of faithful (co)flatness for Hopf algebras stems from the fact that there are strong connections between it and the problem of whether epimorphisms are surjective. These are understood by first noticing that epimorphisms of Hopf algebras can already be recognized at the level of algebras (\prref{halg>alg}) through an adjunction, and then that a faithfully flat epimorphism of algebras is an isomorphism (a well-known result, which we prove however, for the sake of completeness, in \prref{ff}). It follows that whenever we have non-surjective epimorphisms, we automatically have counterexamples to Kaplansky's question. In particular, our counterexamples to epi $\Rightarrow$ surjective in \seref{2} and \seref{3} recover those in \cite{Sc} for Kaplansky's problem, from this new point of view. On the other hand, it follows that epimorphisms {\it are} surjective when the conjecture holds (as mentioned above, for commutative or cocommutative, or pointed Hopf algebras, for instance). In the commutative case, for example, the fact that epi implies surjecivity can be translated into geometric language as follows (see \cite[Th. 5.2, (i)]{Ta3}; we are using the same notations as Takeuchi): A morphism ${\rm Sp}(H)\to{\rm Sp}(K)$ of affine groups is a monomorphism if and only if the corresponding Hopf algebra map $K\to H$ is surjective. Indeed, the category of commutative Hopf algebras is the opposite of that of affine groups, so a monomorphism in the latter is the same as an epimorphism in the former. The paper is organized as follows: In \seref{1} we introduce the notations and conventions to be used throughout. We also very briefly recall two characterizations of monomorphisms of coalgebras. \seref{2} is devoted to the questions asked above, in precisely that form. They are quickly settled in the negative by the simple observation that the antipode of a Hopf algebra $H$, regarded as a Hopf algebra map from $H$ to $H^{op,cop}$ ($H$ with the opposite multiplication and coopposite comultiplication) is both a monomorphism and an epimorphism in ${\rm HopfAlg}$. We also need the facts, known for some time, that there are Hopf algebras with non-surjective (\cite{Ni}) or non-injective (\cite{Ta2, Sc}) antipode. In this same section, we highlight the interactions between the Kaplansky conjecture and the problem of whether epimorphisms in ${\rm HopfAlg}$ (the category of Hopf algebras) are surjective, as discussed above. We also look briefly at the dual situation: the problem of whether surjective Hopf algebra maps are faithfully coflat is linked to that of whether monomorphisms of Hopf algebras are injective through \prref{halg>coalg} and \prref{ff'}. Finally, as an interesting consequence of this discussion, we show in \prref{Scorad} that the antipode of a Hopf algebra is surjective whenever its image contains the coradical. In \seref{3} we modify our question by imposing stronger hypotheses (akin to what is done in \cite{Sc} for the Kaplansky problem): we ask whether an epimorphic inclusion of Hopf algebras must be surjective if the larger Hopf algebra has bijective antipode, as well as the dual question. Again, we prove that there are counterexamples (\coref{counterex}). These are obtained through two adjunctions between the categories of Hopf algebras and of Hopf algebras with bijective antipode. One is the adjunction constructed in \cite{Sc}, where it is shown that there is a free Hopf algebra with bijective antipode (denoted here by $K^*(H)$) on every hopf algebra $H$. We prove that the universal map $H\to K^*(H)$ is {\it always} an epimorphism of Hopf algebras, thus finding our counterexamples whenever it is not surjective (and this does occur). The other adjunction we use is the ``dual'' of the previous one: we prove that there is a cofree Hopf algebra $K_*(H)$ with bijective antipode on every Hopf algebra $H$, and that the universal map $K_*(H)\to H$ is always a monomorphism of Hopf algebras. Again, this provides us with counterexamples to mono $\Rightarrow$ injective whenever such a universal map is not injective. Because we find the analogy interesting, we carry out a parallel discussion for two adjunctions between the categories of bialgebras and Hopf algebras: there exist both a free and a cofree Hopf algebra on a bialgebra $B$ (the former follows from \cite{Ta1} and is constructed explicitly in \cite{Pa}; the existence of the latter is proven in \cite{Ag1}, and we construct it here). We denote these by $H^*(B)$ and $H_*(B)$ respectively. As before, we show that the unit of the first adjunction provides us with epimorphisms $B\to H^*(B)$ of bialgebras, and the counit of the other adjunction gives us monomorphisms $H_*(B)\to B$ of bialgebras. See \thref{adjepimono}. In \seref{4} we finish with some problems for the reader. First, there are the questions parallel to Kaplansky's conjecture in its current form and its dual: we would like to know whether epimorphisms (monomorphisms) of Hopf algebras are surjective (injective) when all Hopf algebras in question have bijective antipode. Secondly, we ask for necessary and sufficient conditions on a bialgebra in order that it be a quotient or a subbialgebra of a Hopf algebra, and also for necessary and sufficient conditions on a Hopf algebra in order that it be a quotient of one with bijective antipode. These are motivated by the result (which is an immediate consequence of \cite[Prop. 2.7]{Sc}) that a Hopf algebra $H$ is a Hopf subalgebra of one with bijective antipode iff its antipode $S_H$ is injective. \section{Preliminaries}\selabel{1} Throughout this paper, $k$ will be an arbitrary field. Unless explicitly specified otherwise, homomorphisms, tensor products, algebras, coalgebras, and so on are over $k$. We work with several categories: ${\rm Alg}$, ${\rm CoAlg}$, ${\rm BiAlg}$ and ${\rm HopfAlg}$ denote the categories of $k$-algebras, coalgebras, bialgebras and Hopf algebras, respectively. ${\rm SHopfAlg}$ stands for the category of Hopf algebras with a bijective antipode (the $S$ in front is supposed to remind the reader of the usual notation $S$ for the antipode of a Hopf algebra). If $x,y$ are objects in a category $\mathcal C$, we use the notation $\mathcal C(x,y)$ for the set of morphisms from $x$ to $y$ in $\mathcal C$. We use standard notations for opposite and coopposite structures: $A^{op}$ is the opposite of the algebra $A$, and $C^{cop}$ is the coopposite of the coalgebra $C$. For an algebra $A,\ _A\mathcal M$ denotes the category of left $A$-modules, and similarly, $\mathcal M_A$ is the category of right $A$-modules. For a coalgebra $C,\ ^C\mathcal M$ and $\mathcal M^C$ are the categories of left and, respectively, right $C$-comodules. For basic notions of category theory such as limits, colimits, adjunctions, comma categories and so on, we refer mainly to \cite{MacL}, but what we need can be found in most sources. Another example is \cite[Appendix]{Pa}. We use the language and notations in \cite{MacL}. At some point we do make use of the notion of locally presentable category, but only in passing. Everything we need on the subject can be found for instance in \cite[Chapter 1]{ARo}. For the structure maps of our objects we reserve the usual notation: $\eta,\Delta,\varepsilon,S,\bar S$ denote, respectively, the unit, comultiplication, counit, antipode, and skew antipode of an appropriate object (algebra, Hopf algebra, etc.). We sometimes use subscripts to indicate the object in question: $S_H$ is the antipode of the Hopf algebra $H$, for instance. For a coalgebra $C$ and an algebra $A$, we regard ${\rm Hom}(C,A)$ as an algebra in the usual way, under the convolution $*$; in Sweedler sigma notation (\cite[1.4.2]{Mo}; we have omitted the summation symbol), we have: \[ (f*g)(c)=f(c_{(1)})g(c_{(2)}). \] Recall that when $H$ is a Hopf algebra with antipode $S,\ A$ is an algebra, and $f\in{\rm Alg}(H,A)$, the composition $fS$ is the inverse of $f$ with respect to the convolution operation $*$. Similarly, $Sf$ is the inverse of $f\in{\rm CoAlg}(C,H)$ for a coalgebra $C$ (\cite[Chapter IV, Lemma 4.0.3]{Sw}). We also require the notion of {\it faithful coflatness} over a coalgebra. The main definitions and properties regarding (faithful) coflatness can be found in \cite[Chapters 21]{BW}. Here, the notion replacing the tensor product is that of cotensor product over a coalgebra, for which we refer to \cite[Appendix 2]{Ta4} or \cite[Chapters 21,22]{BW}. We recall here a result on monomorphisms in ${\rm CoAlg}$. For a proof (of our lemma and the converses to its two statements), the reader can consult for example \cite{NT}, where quite a few characterizations of monomorphisms of coalgebras can be found; for even more such characterizations see \cite[T. 2.1]{Ag2}. As is customary in the literature, we denote by $\square_D$ the cotensor product over the coalgebra $D$. \begin{lemma}\lelabel{monocoalg} Let $f:C\to D$ be a monomorphism in ${\rm CoAlg}$. Then the scalar coresriction $\mathcal M^C\to\mathcal M^D$ is full, and the comultiplication $\Delta_C$ is a bijection of $C$ onto $C\square_DC\subseteq C\otimes C$. \end{lemma} \section{First version of the problem}\selabel{2} The most general form of the problem we are concerned with in this paper consists of the two analogous questions of whether epi(mono)morphisms in the category ${\rm HopfAlg}$ are surjective (resp. injective). Notice that a map of Hopf algebras $f:H\to K$ is an epimorphism iff the inclusion of the image of $H$ in $K$ is epi. Similarly, when we investigate monomorphisms, we can assume that they are surjective. We will sometimes do this without mentioning it explicitly. We shall see that the answers to the two questions are negative, using the following simple observation: \begin{proposition}\prlabel{Sepi} The antipode $S$ of a Hopf algebra $H$ is both an epimorphism and a monomorphism in ${\rm HopfAlg}$ from $H$ to $H^{op,cop}$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} $S$ is an epimorphism iff for any Hopf algebra $K$, the map \[ {\rm HopfAlg}(H^{op,cop},K)\to {\rm HopfAlg}(H,K) \] induced by it and defined by $f\mapsto fS$ is injective. More generally, if $A$ is an algebra and $f$ is an algebra map from $H^{op}$ to $A$, then $fS$ is the inverse of $f$ in the monoid ${\rm Hom}(H^{cop},A)$ under convolution (here, $H$ is viewed only as a coalgebra). It follows that $f$ is uniquely determined by $fS$, which is what we needed. The statement that $S$ is mono is proven similarly: we have to show that for any Hopf algebra $K$, the map \[ {\rm HopfAlg}(K,H)\to {\rm HopfAlg}(K,H^{op,cop}) \] given by $f\mapsto Sf$ is injective. Again, this holds more generally, if we replace $K$ with a coalgebra $C$ and ${\rm HopfAlg}$ with ${\rm CoAlg}$, simply by noticing that $Sf$ is the inverse of $f\in{\rm CoAlg}(C,H)$ in ${\rm Hom}(C,H)$. \end{proof} The negative answers to our two questions now follow from the fact that there exist Hopf algebras with pathological (non-surjective or non-injective) antipode. A Hopf algebra with non-bijective antipode is already constructed in \cite{Ta1}. However, we need the more specific result (\cite{Ni}) that Takeuchi's algebra has a non-surjective antipode. In fact, Nichols also shows in \cite{Ni} that the antipode is injective. The Hopf algebra in question is the free Hopf algebra $H(M_n(k)^*)$ (a construction introduced in \cite{Ta1}) on the coalgebra $M_n(k)^*$, the dual of the matrix algebra $M_n(k)$ for $n>1$. We shall have more to say about such universal constructions in the next section. As for the injectivity of the antipode, Takeuchi proves (\cite[Theorem 9]{Ta2}) that either the same free Hopf algebra $H(M_n(k)^*)$ has a non-injective antipode (as mentioned above, we know this to be false from \cite{Ni}), or some quotient of $H(M_{2n}(k)^*)$ does. Also, Schauenburg constructs in \cite{Sc} a Hopf algebra with a surjective, non-injective antipode. Given these pathological examples and the previous proposition, we get \begin{corollary} There exist (injective) non-surjective epimorphisms in ${\rm HopfAlg}$, as well as (surjective) non-injective monomorphisms. \end{corollary} In the next section we will also see examples of non-surjective epimorphisms $H\to K$ with $K$ having a bijective antipode, and of non-injective monomorphisms $H\to K$ with $H$ having a bijective antipode. We do not know if both algebras can be chosen to have bijective antipode in such counterexamples. As it turns out, the problem epi vs. surjective is linked to Kaplansky's first conjecture. The more modern version of this conjecture asked whether all Hopf algebras are (left and right) faithfully flat over their Hopf subalgebras (\cite[Question 3.5.4]{Mo}). Schauenburg gave some counterexamples in \cite{Sc}, and strengthened the hypotheses further: are Hopf algebras with bijective antipode faithfully flat over Hopf subalgebras with bijective antipode? In order to see the connection between the two problems, we need the following simple result on faithful flatness: \begin{proposition}\prlabel{ff} Let $\iota:A\to B$ be a left faithfully flat extension of algebras. If $\iota$ is an epimorphism in ${\rm Alg}$, then it is an isomorphism. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} The fact that $\iota$ is epi implies that $b\otimes_A 1=1\otimes_Ab$ in $B\otimes_AB$ for all $b\in B$ (\cite[Chapter XI, Prop. 1.1]{St}). It follows immediately from this last condition that the map $\iota\otimes_AI_B:B\to B\otimes_AB$ is an isomorphism of right $B$-modules (actually, it follows that the map is surjective; the injectivity is clear from the fact that the multiplication $B\otimes_AB\to B$ is a left inverse for $\iota\otimes_AI_B$). By faithful flatness, $\iota$ must be an isomorphism of right $A$-modules. \end{proof} The fact that the forgetful functor ${\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm Alg}$ has a right adjoint (\cite[Theorem 3.3]{Ag1}; the result is dual to Takeuchi's construction of a free Hopf algebra on a coalgebra in \cite{Ta1}), together with the easy-to-prove results that (a) left adjoints preserve epimorphisms and (b) faithful functors reflect epimorphisms, imply \begin{proposition}\prlabel{halg>alg} A morphism of Hopf algebras $f:H\to K$ is an epimorphism if and only if it is an epimorphism in ${\rm Alg}$, when viewed as a map of algebras. \end{proposition} We also record the dual statement, which follows by the dual argument: by \cite{Ta1} the forgetful functor ${\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm CoAlg}$ is a right adjoint, and hence preserves monomorphisms. \begin{proposition}\prlabel{halg>coalg} A morphism of Hopf algebras $f:H\to K$ is a monomorphism if and only if it is a monomorphism in ${\rm CoAlg}$, when viewed as a map of coalgebras. \end{proposition} \prref{ff} and \prref{halg>alg} show that epimorphisms of Hopf algebras are indeed surjective whenever Kaplansky's conjecture holds, i.e. in those stuations when we do have faithful flatness. Such situations are, for instance, the case when (same notations as in the statement of \prref{halg>alg}) $K$ is commutative, or has cocommutative coradical, or is pointed (\cite[Theorem 3.1]{Ta3} takes care of the cases when $K$ is either commutative or cocommutative, but \cite[Theorem 3.2]{Ta3} easily implies the cocommutative coradical and the pointed cases as well; later, Radford proved in \cite{Ra1} that pointed Hopf algebras are, in fact, free over their Hopf subalgebras). The contrapositive is that counterexamples to epi $\Rightarrow$ surjective are counterexamples to Kaplansky's first conjecture. In particular, by \prref{Sepi}, we recover Schauenburg's example (\cite[Remark 2.6]{Sc}) $S(H)\subset H$ of a non-faithfully flat inclusion of Hopf algebras whenever the antipode $S$ of $H$ is not surjective. The fact that epi implies surjectivity in the cocommutative case, for example, can be used, together with some adjunctions, to prove the classical results that epimorphisms are surjective in the categories of groups or Lie algebras. See also \cite[Prop. 3,4]{Re} for an interesting method of proof, using split extensions of groups and Lie algebras, respectively. The discussion above on the connection between faithful flatness over Hopf subalgebras and epimorphisms in ${\rm HopfAlg}$ can be dualized: one can ask when a surjection of Hopf algebras is faithfully coflat (see \seref{1}), and investigate the relation between this question and the problem of determining if/when monomorphisms of Hopf algebras are injective. Faithful coflatness appears in \cite{AD}, for example, along with faithful flatness, as an important technical condition (see the dual pair of results \cite[Corollaries 1.2.5, 1.2.14]{AD}). We now want to prove the dual of \prref{ff}. Together with \prref{halg>coalg}, it will establish the connection between faithful coflatness and the injectivity of monomorphisms in ${\rm HopfAlg}$: if the surjective monomorphism $H\to K$ happens to be faithfully coflat, then it is an isomorphism. Again, the contrapositive is that whenever we have a non-injective monomorphism in ${\rm HopfAlg}$ (which we may as well assume is surjective), we have an example of non-faithfully coflat surjection of Hopf algebras. \begin{proposition}\prlabel{ff'} Let $f:C\to D$ be map of coalgebras, making $C$ left faithfully coflat over $D$. If $f$ is a monomorphism in ${\rm CoAlg}$, then it is an isomorphism. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Since $f$ is a monomorphism, we know from \leref{monocoalg} that the canonical map $C\to C\square_DC$ is bijective. The map \[ f\square_DI_C:C\square_DC\to D\square_DC\cong C \] is a left inverse for $C\to C\square_DC$, so it must also be bijective. Faithful coflatness implies that $-\square_DC$ reflects isomorphisms, so $f$ must be an isomorphism. \end{proof} Finally, we end this section with a consequence of \prref{Sepi} giving a sufficient condition for the antipode of a Hopf algebra to be surjective. We do not use this result elsewhere in the paper. \begin{proposition}\prlabel{Scorad} Let $H$ be a Hopf algebra with antipode $S$. If $S(H)$ contains the coradical $H_0$ of $H$, then $S$ is surjective. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} \prref{Sepi} says that the inclusion $S(H)\to H$ is epi. On the other hand, as $S(H)$ contains the coradical $H_0$, the inclusion is faithfully flat (in fact, $H$ is even free over $S(H)$, by a result of Nichols; it is also an immediate consequence of \cite[Cor. 2.3]{Ra2}). By \prref{ff}, we are done: the inclusion of $S(H)$ in $H$ must be surjective. \end{proof} \section{Adjunctions and bijective antipodes}\selabel{3} We have seen in the previous section that one can find both non-surjective epimorphisms and non-injective monomorphisms in the category ${\rm HopfAlg}$. We now strengthen the hypotheses: for epimorphisms $H\to K$, we ask that $K$ have bijective antipode. Similarly, for monomorphisms $H\to K$, we ask that $H$ have bijective antipode. Again, we find counterexamples in these situations. I do not know what happens if {\it both} Hopf algebras are required to have bijective antipodes. The construction is as follows: In \cite{Sc}, Schauenburg constructs the left adjoint, which we denote here by $K^*$, of the inclusion $i:{\rm SHopfAlg}\to{\rm HopfAlg}$ (recall that ${\rm SHopfAlg}$ is the category of Hopf algebras with bijective antipode; we will sometimes omit the inclusion functor), and proves (\cite[Cor. 2.8]{Sc}) that the unit $H\to K^*(H)$ of the adjunction is a non-faithfully flat inclusion of Hopf algebras whenever $H$ has injective non-bijective antipode (in fact, he proves more, namely that the inclusion does not have a certain property (P), weaker that faithful flatness). We show here that the unit $H\to K^*(H)$ is always an epimorphism of Hopf algebras. We also prove that the inclusion $i$ has a right adjoint $K_*$, and that the counit $K_*(H)\to H$ of the resulting adjunction is always a monomorphism of Hopf algebras. These will be examples of non-surjective epimorphisms and non-injective monomorphisms, with our extra requirements on the antipodes, when the antipode of Hopf algebra $H$ is ``pathological''. There seems to be an interesting parallel between the pairs of categories ${\rm BiAlg},{\rm HopfAlg}$ on the one hand and ${\rm HopfAlg},{\rm SHopfAlg}$ on the other; in order to emphasize it, we also carry out the arguments outlined above for the inclusion $j:{\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm BiAlg}$. The existence of the left adjoint to this inclusion is a classical result of Takeuchi (\cite{Ta1}; even though Takeuchi passes directly from coalgebras to Hopf algebras, the intermediary adjoint from ${\rm HopfAlg}$ to ${\rm BiAlg}$ is easily deduced, and the construction is given explicitly in \cite[Theorem 2.6.3]{Pa}), and the existence of a right adjoint is proven in \cite[Theorem 3.3]{Ag1}. We state here the existence result for these adjoints: \begin{theorem}\thlabel{exadj} (a) The inclusion $j:{\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm BiAlg}$ has both a left adjoint $H^*$ and a right adjoint $H_*$. (b) The inclusion $i:{\rm SHopfAlg}\to{\rm HopfAlg}$ has both a left adjoint $K^*$ and a right adjoint $K_*$. \end{theorem} Before going into the proof (which will consist mainly of the constructions of the right adjoints to the inclusions, since the left adjoints are constructed explicitly in \cite{Ta1,Pa} and \cite{Sc} as indicated above), we state and prove the main result of this section, and derive some consequences. We keep the notations from the statement of \thref{exadj}. \begin{theorem}\thlabel{adjepimono} (a) For every bialgebra $B$, the component $B\to H^*(B)$ of the unit of the adjunction $(H^*,j)$ is an epimorphism of bialgebras, and the component $H_*(B)\to B$ of the counit of the adjunction $(j,H_*)$ is a monomorphism of bialgebras. (b) For any Hopf algebra $H$, the unit $H\to K^*(H)$ of the adjunction $(K^*,i)$ is an epimorphism of Hopf algebras, and the counit $K_*(H)\to H$ of the adjunction $(i,K_*)$ is a monomorphism of Hopf algebras. \end{theorem} For the proofs we require a category-theoretic lemma, which we state after some notations. Let $\mathcal C,\mathcal D$ be two categories, and $U:\mathcal C\to\mathcal D$ a functor with a left adjoint $F$ and a right adjoint $G$. Denote by $\alpha:I_{\mathcal D}\to UF$ and $\beta:UG\to I_{\mathcal D}$ the unit of the adjunction $(F,U)$ and the counit of the adjunction $(U,G)$, respectively. We then have: \begin{lemma}\lelabel{epi>mono} With the notations above, $\alpha_d:d\to UF(d)$ is an epimorphism for every object $d\in\mathcal D$ iff $\beta_d:UG(d)\to d$ is a monomorphism for every object $d\in\mathcal D$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} For each pair of objects $d,d'\in\mathcal D$, we have a commutative diagram \[ \begin{diagram} \mathcal D(UF(d),d') & & \\ \dTo &\rdTo & \\ \mathcal C(F(d),G(d')) & &\mathcal D(d,d')\\ \dTo &\ruTo & \\ \mathcal D(d,UG(d')) & & \end{diagram} \] where the two vertical arrows are the bijections given by the two adjunctions, and the two diagonal arrows are induced by $\alpha_d$ (the upper arrow) and $\beta_d$ (the lower arrow). The fact that $\alpha_d$ is an epimorphism for all $d$ is equivalent to the upper diagonal arrow being an injection for all pairs $d,d'$. Similarly for $\beta_d$ and the lower diagonal arrow. But since the vertical maps are bijections, the conditions that the upper and respectively lower diagonal arrow be an injection for all pairs $d,d'$ are equivalent. \end{proof} \renewcommand{\proofname}{Proof of \thref{adjepimono}} \begin{proof} By applying \leref{epi>mono} to the two situations depicted in (a) and (b) (with the functor $U$ being the inclusion $j$ and $i$ respectively), we conclude that it suffices to prove one of the two statements in each of (a) and (b). It is enough, for instance, to show that the units of the two adjunctions $(H^*,j)$ and $(K^*,i)$ are epimorphisms. (a) We want to show that $\alpha:B\to H^*(B)$ is an epimorphism in ${\rm BiAlg}$ (strictly speaking, it should be $jH^*(B)$). Let $S$ be the antipode of $H^*(B)$. The subalgebra $H$ of $H^*(B)$ generated by $S^n(\alpha(B)),\ n\ge 0$ is a Hopf subalgebra: it is an algebra by definition, it is closed under $S$ again by definition, and it's a subcoalgebra because all the $S^n(\alpha(B))$ are. This means that $B\to H$ is a subobject of the initial object $B\to H^*(B)$ in the comma category $B\downarrow{\rm HopfAlg}$ (\cite[II$\S$6]{MacL}), and hence that $H=H^*(B)$. Now consider a morphism of bialgebras $f:H^*(B)\to B'$. Then $fS\alpha$ is the inverse of $f\alpha$ in ${\rm Hom}(B,B')$ under convolution, $fS^2\alpha$ is the inverse of $fS\alpha$ in ${\rm Hom}(B^{cop},B')$, and so on. Because, as we have just seen, $H^*(B)$ is generated as an algebra by the iterations of $\alpha(B)$ under $S$, $f$ is uniquely determined by $f\alpha$. This is precisely the condition required in order that $\alpha$ be an epimorphism of bialgebras. (b) The proof runs parallel to that from (a): instead of the antipode, we now use the inverse $\bar S$ of the antipode $S$ of $K^*(H)$. Again, let $K$ be the subalgebra of $K^*(H)$ generated by $\bar S^n(\alpha(H)),\ n\ge 0$. Arguing as before, we conclude that $K=K^*(H)$, i.e. that $K^*(H)$ is generated as an algebra by the images of $\alpha(H)$ through the iterations of $\bar S$, and hence that a Hopf algebra map $f:K^*(H)\to H'$ is uniquely determined by $f\alpha:H\to H'$. \end{proof} \renewcommand{\proofname}{Proof} As a consequence, we have: \begin{corollary}\colabel{counterex} (a) If $B$ is a sub-bialgebra of a Hopf algebra such that $B$ itself is not Hopf, then $B\to H^*(B)$ is an injective, non-surjective epimorphism of bialgebras. Similarly, if the bialgebra $B$ is not Hopf but is a quotient of a Hopf algebra, then $H_*(B)\to B$ is a surjective, non-injective monomorphism of bialgebras. (b) If $H$ does not have bijective antipode but is contained in a Hopf algebra with bijective antipode, then $H\to K^*(H)$ is an injective, non-surjective epimorphism of Hopf algebras. Similarly, if $H$ does not have bijective antipode but is a quotient of a Hopf algebra with bijective antipode, then $K_*(H)\to H$ is a non-injective, surjective monomorphism. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} (a) Since the inclusion of $B$ in a Hopf algebra factors through $B\to H^*(B)$, the latter must be an injective map. The rest follows immediately from \thref{adjepimono}. For the second statement the dual argument works. (b) is entirely analogous to (a). \end{proof} Examples as in the previous corollary actually exist. Focusing on (b), the Hopf algebra case, such examples can be found in \cite{Sc}: {\it any} Hopf algebra $H$ with injective non-bijective antipode (such as the free Hopf algebra on the coalgebra $M_n(k)^*,\ n\ge 2$, according to \cite{Ni}) injects properly into $K^*(H)$, and also, an example is given of a Hopf algebra with non-bijective antipode which is a quotient of a Hopf algebra with bijective antipode: it is a quotient of the free Hopf algebra with bijective antipode on the coalgebra $M_4(k)^*$. In conclusion, we have: \begin{corollary}\colabel{main} There is an epimorphic inclusion $H\to K$ of Hopf algebras with $K$ having a bijective antipode. Similarly, there is a monomorphic surjection $H\to K$ of Hopf algebras with $H$ having a bijective antipode. \end{corollary} Next, we give explicit constructions for the right adjoints to the inclusions $j:{\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm BiAlg}$ and $i:{\rm SHopfAlg}\to{\rm HopfAlg}$. In particular, this solves \cite[Problem 2]{Ag1}, which asks for a construction for the right adjoint to $j$, shown there to exist by the Special Adjoint Functor Theorem (the dual of \cite[V$\S$8, Corollary]{MacL}). Throughout, we shall make free use of the fact that the following categories are all complete and cocomplete: ${\rm Alg},{\rm CoAlg},{\rm BiAlg},{\rm HopfAlg}$. In fact, they are locally presentable, and locally presentable categories are cocomplete (by definition: \cite[Def. 1.17]{ARo}) and complete (\cite[Remark 1.56]{ARo}). The local presentability is proven up to bialgebras in \cite{Po1} in the more general setting of monoids, comonoids and bimonoids in a symmetric monoidal category with some extra assumptions, which are all satisfied by the category of $k$-vector spaces (see Summary 4.3 in that paper); that ${\rm HopfAlg}$ is locally presentable follows from \cite[Prop. 4.3]{Po2} and the fact that by \cite{Ta1}, the forgetful functor ${\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm CoAlg}$ has a left adjoint (this is the argument used in the proof of \cite[Theorem 2.6]{Ag1}). Alternatively, one could prove the local presentability of these categories directly, but we do not go into these details here. We start the construction of adjoints with the inclusion $j:{\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm BiAlg}$. \renewcommand{\proofname}{Proof of \thref{exadj} (a)} \begin{proof} As mentioned before, we only construct the right adjoints, since explicit constructions for the left adjoints can be found in the literature, in the sources cited above. We simply dualize the construction from \cite[Theorem 2.6.3]{Pa}. As that proof is very detailed, and most arguments here are simply dualizations of those, we will only indicate how the construction goes, leaving out simple verifications. Let $B$ be a bialgebra, and let $P$ be the product (in the category ${\rm BiAlg}$) of the bialgebras $B_n,\ n\ge 0$, where $B_n=B$ if $n$ is even, and $B_n=B^{op,cop}$ if $n$ is odd. Denote by $\pi_n$ the structure maps $P\to B_n$ of the product of bialgebras, and let $\eta, \varepsilon$ be the unit and counit of $P$ respectively. By the universality of the product, there is a unique bialgebra map $S$ such that \[ \begin{diagram} P^{op,cop} &\rTo^S &P \\ \dTo<{\pi_{n+1}} & &\dTo>{\pi_n} \\ B_{n+1}^{op,cop} &\rTo^{{\rm id}} &B_n \end{diagram} \] commutes for all $n\ge 0$. Let $H_*(B)$ be the sum of all subcoalgebras $C\subseteq P$ on which $S$ behaves like an antipode. Specifically, the condition such a coalgebra $C$ is supposed to satisfy is \begin{equation}\eqlabel{antipode} c_{(1)}S(c_{(2)})=\eta\varepsilon(c)=S(c_{(1)})c_{(2)},\ \forall c\in C. \end{equation} As the notation suggests, this is the object we are looking for. $H_*(B)$ is by definition a subcoalgebra of $P$, and \equref{antipode} holds with $H_*(B)$ instead of $C$. In other words, $H_*(B)$ is the largest subcoalgebra of $P$ on which $S$ acts as an antipode. It is an easy matter now to prove that $H_*(B)$ is closed under multiplication and the action of $S$ (and it clearly contains the unit $1_P$), so it is, in fact, a Hopf subalgebra of $P$ with antipode $S$. We now want to prove that $\beta:H_*(B)\to B$, the composition of $\pi_0:P\to B$ with the inclusion $H_*(B)\to P$, is universal from a Hopf algebra to $B$. So let $f:H\to B$ be a bialgebra map from a Hopf algebra $H$ to $B$. The maps \[ f_n=f\circ S_H^n:H\to B_n,\ n\ge 0 \] are bialgebra morphisms, and so define a bialgebra map $\tilde f:H\to P$ with $\pi_0\circ \tilde f=f$. First, we want to show that $\tilde f$ intertwines $S$ and $S_H$: \[ \begin{diagram} H &\rTo^{S_H} &H \\ \dTo<{\tilde f} & &\dTo>{\tilde f}\\ P &\rTo^S &P \end{diagram} \] In turn, this follows from the universality of the product $P$ if we show that \begin{equation}\eqlabel{0} \pi_n\circ\tilde f\circ S_H=\pi_n\circ S\circ\tilde f,\ \forall n\ge 0 \end{equation} as maps from $H$ to $B$. On the one hand, from the definition of $\tilde f$, we get \begin{equation}\eqlabel{1} \pi_n\circ\tilde f\circ S_H=f_n\circ S_H=f\circ S_H^{n+1}=\pi_{n+1}\circ\tilde f, \end{equation} and on the other hand, from the definition of $S$, we have \begin{equation}\eqlabel{2} \pi_n\circ S\circ\tilde f=\pi_{n+1}\circ\tilde f, \end{equation} because $\pi_n\circ S=\pi_{n+1}$ as maps from $P$ to $B$ (we identify the underlying sets of all $B_n$). \equref{1} and \equref{2} now prove the desired equality \equref{0}. Because $\tilde f$ intertwines $S,S_H$ and $S_H$ is the antipode of $H$, it follows that $S$ is the antipode of $\tilde f(H)$. The definition of $H_*(B)$ now implies that the image of $\tilde f$ is contained in $H_*(B)$, i.e. $\tilde f$ factors through $H_*(B)\subseteq P$. In other words, we have just shown that any bialgebra map $f:H\to B$ factors as \[ \begin{diagram} H &\rTo^{\tilde f} &H_*(B) \\ &\rdTo>f &\dTo>\beta \\ & &B \end{diagram} \] It remains to prove that in such a diagram, $\tilde f$ is unique. Again, $\tilde f$ is determined by the sequence of maps $\pi_n\tilde f$ (also regarding $\pi_n$ as a map from $H_*(B)\subseteq P$ to $B_n$). But notice that, because $\tilde f$ commutes with the antipodes, we have \[ \pi_n\circ\tilde f\circ S_H=\pi_n\circ S\circ\tilde f=\pi_{n+1}\circ \tilde f. \] This means that $\pi_{n+1}\tilde f$ is the inverse of $\pi_n\tilde f$ in ${\rm Hom}(H,B_n)$ under convolution, and hence that the sequence $\pi_n\tilde f$ is uniquely determined by $\pi_0\tilde f=f$. This finishes the proof. \end{proof} \renewcommand{\proofname}{Proof} We now want to obtain the right adjoint to the inclusion $i:{\rm SHopfAlg}\to{\rm HopfAlg}$ as a direct consequence of \thref{exadj} (a) above. For this, we need \begin{lemma}\lelabel{skant} Let $B$ be a bialgebra with a skew antipode $\bar S_B$. Then, the cofree Hopf algebra $H_*(B)$ constructed above also has a skew antipode $\bar S$. Consequently, the antipode $S$ of $H_*(B)$ is bijective. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The last statement follows immediately from the first, as it is well-known that a Hopf algebra has a skew antipode iff its antipode is bijective, in which case the skew antipode is the inverse of the antipode (\cite[Lemma 1.5.11]{Mo}). We focus on showing that the antipode $S$ of $H_*(B)$ is bijective. We use the notations from the proof of \thref{exadj} (a). Recall that there are maps $\pi_n$ from $H_*(B)$ to $B_n,\ n\ge 0$, where $B_n$ is $B$ for even $n$ and $B^{op,cop}$ for odd $n$. $\pi_0$ is universal, and the maps $\pi$ satisfy \begin{equation}\eqlabel{skant} \pi_nS=\pi_{n+1},\ \forall n\ge 0. \end{equation} From the universality of $\pi_0:H_*(B)\to B$, we can find a unique Hopf algebra map $\bar S$ making the following diagram of bialgebra morphisms commutative: \[ \begin{diagram} H_*(B)^{op,cop} &\rTo^{\bar S} &H_*(B) \\ \dTo<{\pi_0} & &\dTo<{\pi_0} \\ B^{op,cop} &\rTo^{\bar S_B} &B \end{diagram} \] The aim is to show that $\bar S$ is a composition inverse to $S$. Complete this diagram to the left with another square (commutative by \equref{skant} for $n=0$): \[ \begin{diagram} H_*(B) &\rTo^S &H_*(B)^{op,cop} &\rTo^{\bar S} &H_*(B) \\ \dTo<{\pi_1} & &\dTo<{\pi_0} & &\dTo<{\pi_0} \\ B^{op,cop} &\rTo^{{\rm id}} &B^{op,cop} &\rTo^{\bar S_B} &B \end{diagram} \] Again by the universality of $\pi_0$, the composition $\bar SS$ is the unique Hopf algebra map making the outer rectangle commutative. If we prove that the identity on $H_*(B)$ also makes the outer rectangle commutative, we will have shown that $\bar S$ is a left composition inverse for $S$. In other words, we now want to show that \begin{equation}\eqlabel{inverses} \pi_0=\bar S_B\pi_1. \end{equation} Since $\bar S_B$ is an antipode for $B^{cop}$ and $\pi_1$ is in ${\rm CoAlg}(H_*(B),B^{cop})$, the composition $\bar S_B\pi_1$ is the convolution inverse of $\pi_1$ in ${\rm Hom}(H_*(B),B)$ (or ${\rm Hom}(H_*(B),B^{cop})$, the algebra structure under convolution is the same). On the other hand, \equref{skant} with $n=0$ shows that $\pi_0$ is also the convolution inverse of $\pi_1$ in ${\rm Hom}(H_*(B),B)$. This implies the desired equality \equref{inverses}. We have just shown that $\bar SS=I_{H_*(B)}$. Deducing now that $S\bar S$ is also the identity is easy: $S=S\bar SS$ is the convolution inverse of both $I_{H_*(B)}$ and of $S\bar S$ in ${\rm End}(H_*(B))$. \end{proof} We now have what we need to finish the proof of \thref{exadj}. \renewcommand{\proofname}{Proof of \thref{exadj} (b)} \begin{proof} Let $H$ be a Hopf algebra. The bialgebra $B=H^{op}$ has a skew antipode, namely $S_H$. According to \leref{skant}, the antipode of the cofree Hopf algebra $H_*(B)$ on $B$ is bijective. The universal bialgebra map \begin{equation}\eqlabel{exadj (b)} \beta:H_*(H^{op})\to H^{op} \end{equation} induces a bialgebra map denoted by the same symbol: \[ \beta:(H_*(H^{op}))^{op}\to H. \] I claim that this is universal from a Hopf algebra with bijective antipode to $H$. In other words, we have \[ K_*(H)=(H_*(H^{op}))^{op}, \] with the obvious universal map $\beta$ to $H$. To see this, let $f:K\to H$ be a Hopf algebra map, with $K$ having bijective antipode. $f$ is then also a bialgebra morphism from the Hopf algebra $K^{op}$ to $H^{op}$, and hence factors uniquely through $\beta$ by the universality of \equref{exadj (b)}. This gives a unique map $\tilde f$, say, from $K^{op}$ to $H_*(H^{op})$. $\tilde f$ will then also be the unique Hopf algebra map from $K$ to $(H_*(H^{op}))^{op}$ through which $f$ factors, and the proof is finished. \end{proof} \renewcommand{\proofname}{Proof} \begin{remark}\relabel{altadj} Although we prefer the construction used above because it shows how \thref{exadj} (b) follows directly from (a), there is more than one way of introducing the right adjoint to $i:{\rm SHopfAlg}\to{\rm HopfAlg}$. One idea, for instance, would be to dualize Schauenburg's construction from \cite[Prop. 2.7]{Sc}: $K_*(H)$ is the limit of the inverse system of Hopf algebras $u_n:H_{n+1}\to H_n,\ n\ge 0$, where all $H_n$ are $H$, and all $f_n$ are equal to the square $S_H^2$ of the antipode $S_H$. Alternatively, we could imitate the construction appearing in \thref{exadj} (a), by using a product of bialgebras $B_n$ indexed by the integers instead of the natural numbers, with $B_n=B$ for $n$ even and $B_n=B^{op,cop}$ for odd $n$ (just as before). This observation works the other way around too: the {\it left} adjoint of the inclusion $i:{\rm SHopfAlg}\to{\rm HopfAlg}$, denoted by $K^*$, can be constructed in the same manner, using the left adjoint of $j:{\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm BiAlg}$ from \thref{exadj} (a). Just as in the previous proof, we have \[ K^*(H)=(H^*(H^{op}))^{op}. \] \end{remark} \section{Some comments and problems}\selabel{4} As remarked several times before, I do not know whether counterexamples as in \coref{main} still exist if we require that {\it both} Hopf algebras $H$ and $K$ have bijective antipode. In the spirit of the connections we have noticed above between faithful flatness/coflatness and the problem of category-theoretic conditions (epimorphisms, monomorphisms) vs. set-theoretic conditions (surjectivity, injectivity), we ask: \begin{question} Is an epimorphism of Hopf algebras with bijective antipode necessarily surjective? \end{question} And its dual: \begin{question} Is a monomorphism of Hopf algebras with bijective antipode necessarily injective? \end{question} These, we believe, should go hand in hand with the aforementioned Kaplansky conjecture and its dual, regarding faithful coflatness. We now turn our attention to the adjunctions which appear in \seref{3}. It follows immediately from \thref{exadj} (a) that a bialgebra $B$ has a largest subbialgebra which is a quotient of a Hopf algebra (the image of $H_*(B)\to B$), and dually, has a largest quotient bialgebra contained in a Hopf algebra (the image of $B\to H^*(B)$). In an entirely analogous manner, \thref{exadj} (b) implies that a Hopf algebra $H$ has a largest Hopf subalgebra which is a quotient of one with bijective antipode (the image of $K_*(H)\to H$), and a largest quotient Hopf algebra contained in one with bijective antipode (the image of $H\to K^*(H)$). The natural problem arises of characterizing those bialgebras (Hopf algebras) which are quotients or subbialgebras (resp. quotients or Hopf subalgebras) of Hopf algebras (resp. Hopf algebras with bijective antipode). For one of the four adjunctions, at least, this question is settled: part of \cite[Prop. 2.7]{Sc} says, in a slightly different formulation, that a Hopf algebra is a Hopf subalgebra of one with bijective antipode iff it has injective antipode. This is a consequence of Schauenburg's construction of $K^*(H)$ as the colimit of the inductive system $u_n:H_n\to H_{n+1},\ n\ge 0$, with $H_n=H$ and $u_n=S_H^2$ for all $n\ge 0$ (see \reref{altadj}). The result just mentioned then follows from the fact that if in such a system all maps are injections, the map sending $H_0$ to the colimit is also an injection. As mentioned in \reref{altadj}, we can dualize this construction. The dual statement on inverse limits with surjective maps, however, no longer holds, in general. At least not at the level of coalgebras (and the limit appearing there is one of coalgebras, as the forgetful functor ${\rm HopfAlg}\to{\rm CoAlg}$ is a right adjoint by \cite{Ta1}, so it preserves limits): one can easily construct a sequence of surjections $C_{n+1}\to C_n$ where $C_n$ are simple coalgebras and $\dim C_n\to\infty$, in which case the resulting limit is none other than $0$. Despite such examples, can we still find simple necessary and sufficient conditions on a Hopf algebra in order that it be a quotient of a Hopf algebra with bijective antipode? \begin{problem} Characterize those Hopf algebras $H$ for which $K_*(H)\to H$ is surjective. \end{problem} More specifically, we ask \begin{question} Is it true that a Hopf algebra with surjective antipode is a quotient of one with bijective antipode? \end{question} And what can be said about the other two adjunctions, between the categories ${\rm BiAlg}$ and ${\rm HopfAlg}$? We would like to find necessary and sufficient conditions on a bialgebra, expressed intrinsically, in order that it be a subbialgebra or a quotient bialgebra of a Hopf algebra. \begin{problem} Characterize intrinsically those bialgebras $B$ for which (a) $B\to H^*(B)$ is injective, or (b) $H_*(B)\to B$ is surjective. \end{problem} We take a moment here to point out that it is by no means true that all bialgebras satisfy (a) (or (b)). In other words, $B\to H^*(B)$ is not always injective, nor is $H_*(B)\to B$ always surjective. Some examples follow. \begin{example} Let $M$ be a monoid, and $B=k[M]$ the monoid bialgebra. One sees easily that the free Hopf algebra $H^*(B)$ on $B$ is precisely the group algebra of the enveloping group $G(M)$ of $M$. If the canonical map $M\to G(M)$ happens to be non-injective (and this happens whenever $M$ is not ``cancellable''), $B\to H^*(B)$ will be non-injective as well. This implies that $B$ is not a subbialgebra of a Hopf algebra. \end{example} \begin{example} Let $H$ be a Hopf algebra with non-injective antipode. It is then clear that $H\to K^*(H)$ cannot be an embedding. In view of \reref{altadj}, $K^*(H)$ is the opposite of $H^*(H^{op})$. Consequently, $B=H^{op}$ is not a subbialgebra of a Hopf algebra. \end{example} \begin{example} The previous example can be dualized, using \reref{altadj} again: if $H$ is a Hopf algebra with non-surjecive antipode, then $B=H^{op}$ is a bialgebra which is not a quotient of a Hopf algebra. \end{example} \section*{Acknowledgements} The author would like to thank Prof. Gigel Militaru for suggesting some of the questions posed here, as well as colleagues Ana-Loredana Agore and Drago\c s Fr\u a\c til\u a for countless fruitful conversations on the topics treated in this paper. Also, we thank the referee for valuable suggestions on the improvement of this paper.

\section{Concentration of Measure for Markov Chains}\label{sec:concentration} In this section we demonstrate how the transportation cost~\eqref{eqn:transport-concentration} shows up naturally when one studies concentration of measure for Markov chains. This was first observed in the works of~\cite{Marton-96-a,Marton-96-b} about contracting Markov chains, and thereafter greatly generalized for classes of dependent random processes in terms of various mixing coefficients using the transportation-information method~\cite{Marton-98, Marton-03, Samson-00}. \cite{chazottes07} uses the martingale method combined with maximal coupling to derive concentration for dependent processes, while~\cite{kontorovich08} uses the martingale method and a linear programming inequality for the same task. For the Markovian case~\cite{Paulin15} using the martingale method establishes a concentration inequality that involves the mixing time of the chain. Let $f : S^n \to \Real{}$ be a functions which is $1$-Lipschitz with respect to the Hamming distance \[ f (x_1, \ldots, x_n) - f (x_1', \ldots, x_n') \le \sum_{k=1}^n I \{x_k \neq x_k'\}, \quad \text{for}~ x_1, \ldots, x_n, x_1', \ldots, x_n' \in S. \] Let ${\mathbf X} \sim \mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P)$, where $P$ is an irreducible and aperiodic transition kernel. We would like to study the deviation of the random variable $f (X_1, \ldots, X_n)$ from its mean $\E_{x_0}^P [f (X_1, \ldots, X_n)]$. The typical approach to do so is the martingale method. For $k = 0, \ldots, n$ we define the martingale \[ Z_k = \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_k \right), \] and for $k=1, \ldots, n$ we define the martingale differences \[ \Delta_k = Z_k - Z_{k-1}. \] Then the quantity of which we want to control the deviations can be written as a telescoping sum of the martingale differences \[ f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) - \E_{x_0}^P\left[f (X_1, \ldots, X_n)\right] = \sum_{k=1}^n \Delta_k, \] and it suffices to control the range of the martingale differences. For this we note that \[ \min_{x' \in S}\: \left\{ \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_k = x' \right) \right\} - \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_{k-1} \right) \le \Delta_k, \] and that \[ \Delta_k \le \max_{x \in S}\: \left\{ \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_k = x \right) \right\} - \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_{k-1} \right). \] Thus in order to bound the length of the range of the martingale difference, we just need to bound \begin{equation}\label{eqn:variation} \max_{x,x' \in S}\: \left\{ \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_k = x \right) - \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_k = x' \right) \right\}. \end{equation} Fix $x_1, \ldots, x_{k-1}, x, x' \in S$, and a coupling $\pi \in \Pi (\mu (\cdot \mid x_1, \ldots, x_{k-1}, x), \mu (\cdot \mid x_1, \ldots, x_{k-1}, x'))$, where $\mu = \mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P)$. Then \begin{align*} &\E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1 = x_1, \ldots, X_{k-1} = x_{k-1}, X_k = x \right) - \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1 = x_1, \ldots, X_{k-1} = x_{k-1}, X_k = x' \right) \\ &\quad = \E^\pi \left[ f (x_1, \ldots, x_{k-1}, \hat{X}_k, \ldots, \hat{X}_n) - f (x_1, \ldots, x_{k-1}, \hat{X}_k', \ldots, \hat{X}_n') \right] \\ &\quad\le \E^\pi \left[ \sum_{i=k}^n I \{\hat{X}_i \neq \hat{X}_i'\} \right] \le \E^\pi \left[ \sum_{i=k}^\infty I \{\hat{X}_i \neq \hat{X}_i'\} \right], \end{align*} where we used the Lipschitz condition for $f$. Thus minimizing over the coupling $\pi$ we obtain that \[ \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_k = x \right) - \E_{x_0}^P \left( f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) \middle| X_1, \ldots, X_k = x' \right) \le W (x, x'). \] All in all, we can bound the length of the range of the martingale difference $\Delta_k$ by $\|W\|_\infty$. Then using the standard martingale method one can obtain the concentration inequality \begin{equation}\label{eqn:concentration-ineq} \Pr_{x_0}^P \left(\left| f (X_1, \ldots, X_n) - \E_{x_0}^P [f (X_1, \ldots, X_n)] \right|\ge t\right) \le 2 \exp\left\{-\frac{2 t^2}{n \|W\|_\infty^2}\right\}. \end{equation} For a full derivation of a concentration inequality which works in more general dependent settings, than just Markovian dependence, the interested reader is refereed to Theorem 1 in~\cite{chazottes07} which uses the martingale method together with maximal coupling, and to Theorem 1.1 of~\cite{kontorovich08} which uses a linear programming inequality instead of a coupling argument. Additionally, we note that if the Markov chain is periodic and thus coupling techniques are not any more applicable one can still bound~\eqref{eqn:variation}, in the special case that the function $f$ is additive, by using hitting time arguments as it is done in~\cite{moulos20}. Clearly $\|W\|_\infty \le \|W_{bc}\|_\infty$, and thus replacing $\|W\|_\infty$ with $\|W_{bc}\|_\infty$ in~\eqref{eqn:concentration-ineq} results in a weaker inequality, although in this way the variance proxy $\|W_{bc}\|_\infty^2$ has the following interpretation: let $Q$ be an optimal Markovian coupling, then $W_{bc} (x, x')$ corresponds to the expected time to hit diagonal when we start from $(x, x')$ and we transition according $Q$, thus the variance proxy is the squared expected time required to hit the diagonal when the least favorite initialization is used. Additionally, when the transition kernel is contracting, $\delta (P) < 1$, we can apply~\autoref{lem:geometric} and further replace $\|W_{bc}\|_\infty$ by $1/(1-\delta (P))$, which results in a specialized version of Theorem 1.2 in~\cite{kontorovich08}. \section{Markovian Couplings} Among the set of all bicausal couplings, $\Pi_{bc} \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), ~\mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right)$, it suffices to turn our attention to Markovian couplings when considering the transportation problem~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport}. We will establish this in~\autoref{sec:DP} as a consequence of the dynamic programming theory. A Markovian coupling of $\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), ~\mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')$ is specified by a transition kernel $Q : (S \times S) \times ({\mathcal S} \otimes {\mathcal S}) \to [0, 1]$ such that $Q ((x, x'), (\cdot, S)) = P (x, \cdot)$, and $Q ((x, x'), (S, \cdot)) = P' (x', \cdot)$. We denote the set of all such transition kernels by \[ \Pi_M (P, P') = \left\{ Q : Q ((x, x'), (\cdot, S)) = P (x, \cdot),~ Q ((x, x'), (S, \cdot)) = P' (x', \cdot) \right\} \] The corresponding Markovian coupling is given, for every $n$, by \begin{equation}\label{eqn:markovian-coupling} \pi ((\{ x_0\}, \ldots, d x_n), (\{x_0'\}, \ldots, d x_n')) = Q ((x_0, x_0'), (d x_1, d x_1')) \cdots Q ((x_{n-1}, x_{n-1}'), (d x_n, d x_n')). \end{equation} We note that any Markovian coupling is bicausal. We now present some basic examples of Markovian couplings, for the case of a single Markov chain $P = P'$, which have been used extensively in the coupling literature, see for instance the book~\cite{thorisson00}. \begin{example} The classic coupling, initially introduced by Doeblin in order to establish the convergence theorem for Markov chains, asserts that $\hat{X}_n$ and $\hat{X}_n'$ evolve independently until they reach a common state for the first time, and afterwards they move identically. \begin{equation}\label{eqn:sticky-coupling} Q_{\mathrm{classic}} ((x, x'), (y, y')) = \begin{cases} P (x, y) P (x', y'), & \text{if}~ x \neq x', \\ P (x, y), & \text{if}~ x = x', ~\text{and}~ y = y', \\ 0, & \text{otherwise}, \end{cases} \end{equation} \end{example} \begin{example} A variant of the classic coupling asserts that $\hat{X}_n$ and $\hat{X}_n'$ evolve independently at all times, and this independent coupling can be used as well to establish the convergence theorem for Markov chains. \begin{equation}\label{eqn:ind-coupling} Q_{\mathrm{ind}} ((x, x'), (y, y')) = P (x, y) P (x', y'), \end{equation} \end{example} In both the classic and the independent coupling it is apparent that if we seek for a Markovian coupling that minimizes some cost criterion, e.g. attaining coupling at the smallest expected time, then the independent movement can be wasteful. Instead, one should coordinate the movement of the two copies in a way that optimizes the objective under consideration. A first such attempt is the following coupling attributed to Wasserstein. \begin{example} Given that $\hat{X}_{n-1} = x$ and $\hat{X}_{n-1}' = x'$, the Wassertstein coupling makes $\hat{X}_n$ and $\hat{X}_n'$ agree with as great probability as possible (which is $1 - \|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV}$), and then given that they differ they are made conditionally independent. \begin{equation}\label{eqn:w-coupling} Q_{\mathrm{W}} ((x, x'), (y, y')) = \begin{cases} 0, & \text{if} ~ x = x', ~\text{and}~ y \neq y', \\ P (x, y), & \text{if} ~ x = x', ~\text{and}~ y = y', \\ P (x, y) \land P (x', y), & \text{if} ~ x \neq x', ~\text{and}~ y = y', \\ 0, & \text{if} ~ x \neq x', ~ y \neq y', ~\text{and}~ \|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV} = 0, \\ \frac{\left(P (x, y) - P (x', y)\right)^+ \left(P (x', y') - P (x, y')\right)^+}{\|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV}}, & \text{if} ~ x \neq x', ~ y \neq y', ~\text{and}~ \|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV} \neq 0, \end{cases} \end{equation} where $a \land b = \min (a, b), ~ a^+ = - ((-a) \land 0),$ and $a^- = a \land 0$. \end{example} Making $\hat{X}_n$ and $\hat{X}_n'$ agree with as great probability as possible is a good first step towards a Markovian coupling with the smallest expected coupling time, although it might be too greedy of a choice and the conditional independence assertion surely leaves more room for improvements. It is the objective of this paper to provide a characterization of optimal Markovian couplings using the theory of dynamic programming. \section{Coupling of Markov Chains in Minimum Expected Time}\label{sec:coupling-MC} In this section we specialize the bicausal optimal transport for Markov chains to the case that we have a single irreducible and aperiodic transition kernel $P$, and the cost function ${\mathbf c}$ is the metric ${\mathbf d}_1$. So essentially we are solving for the bicausal coupling that couples two Markov chains with different initializations and the same transition kernel in the smallest expected time \begin{align*} W_{bc} (\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P)) &= \inf_{\pi \in \Pi_{bc} \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right)}\: \int {\mathbf d}_1 ({\mathbf x}, {\mathbf x}') \pi (d {\mathbf x}, d {\mathbf x}') \\ &= \inf_{\pi \in \Pi_{bc} (\left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right))}\: \E^\pi \left[ T \right]. \end{align*} Although in the general framework of negative dynamic programming the fixed point equation $V = T (V)$ is only a necessary condition for optimality, in our specialized setting we can establish that it is also sufficient, giving thus a complete set of necessary and sufficient conditions for both the optimal cost $W_{bc}$, and the optimal Markovian coupling $Q$. \begin{theorem} $W_{bc}$ is the unique solution of the equations \begin{equation}\label{eqn:optimality} 0 \le V < \infty, \quad V = T (V), \quad \text{and} \quad V (x, x) = 0 \quad \text{for $x \in S$}. \end{equation} \begin{proof} We already know from~\autoref{thm:DP} that $W_{bc} = T (W_{bc})$. Using the classic Markovian coupling,~\eqref{eqn:sticky-coupling} we see that $W_{bc} (x, x) = 0$ for all $x \in S$. Using the independent Markovian coupling,~\eqref{eqn:ind-coupling}, which induces an irreducible Markov chain on $S \times S$ we see that \[ W_{bc} (x, x') \le \min_{y \in S}\: \E_{(x, x')}^{Q_{\mathrm{ind}}} [T_{(y,y)}] < \infty, \quad \text{for all}~ x,x' \in S. \] Let $V : S \to [0, \infty)$ be any function satisfying equations~\eqref{eqn:optimality}. Let $Q$ be a Markovian coupling such that $W_{bc} = c + Q W_{bc}$. Then \begin{equation}\label{eqn:basic-ineq} V = T (V) \le c + Q V = c + Q T (V) \le c + Q c + Q^2 V \le \cdots \le \sum_{k=0}^{n-1} Q^k c + Q^n V. \end{equation} By definition of $Q$ we have that \begin{equation}\label{eqn:opt-cost} W_{bc} = \sum_{k=0}^\infty Q^k c, \end{equation} and since $W_{bc} < \infty$ we see that $\lim_{n \to \infty} Q^n c = 0$. We clearly have that $c \le V$, and because $c (x, x') = 0 \;\Rightarrow\; V (x, x') = 0$, we obtain that $c \le V \le \|V\|_\infty c$. Since $V < \infty$ we deduce that \begin{equation}\label{eqn:final-cost} \lim_{n \to \infty} Q^n V = 0. \end{equation} Combining~\eqref{eqn:basic-ineq},~\eqref{eqn:opt-cost}, and~\eqref{eqn:final-cost} we obtain that $V \le W_{bc}$, and because from~\autoref{thm:DP} $W_{bc}$ is the minimal fixed point we deduce that $V = W_{bc}$. \end{proof} \end{theorem} Next we dig in some properties of an optimal Markovian coupling. In particular, we show that an optimal Markovian coupling enjoys the `sticky' property of the classic coupling~\eqref{eqn:sticky-coupling}, i.e. under an optimal Markovian coupling the two chains evolve in the same way as soon as they meet. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:sticky} Any optimal Markovian coupling $Q$ sticks to the diagonal as soon as it hits it, i.e. \[ Q ((x, x), (y, y')) = I \{y = y'\} P (x, y). \] \begin{proof} Fix an optimal Markovian coupling $Q$. From~~\autoref{thm:DP} it satisfies the equation \[ c + Q W_{bc} = W_{bc}, \] and so in particular \[ \int Q ((x, x), (d y, d y')) W_{bc} (y, y') = 0. \] Since for $y \neq y', ~ W_{bc} (y, y') \ge 1$ we have that $Q ((x, x), (y, y')) = 0$. Then it follows from the coupling constraint that $Q ((x, x), (y, y)) = P (x, y)$. \end{proof} \end{lemma} Additionally, we show that for two state chains the Wasserstein coupling~\eqref{eqn:w-coupling} is the only optimal Markovian coupling. \begin{lemma} When $|S| = 2$ there is a unique optimal Markovian coupling which is precisely the Wasserstein coupling~\eqref{eqn:w-coupling}. \begin{proof} Let $S = \{x, x'\}$. Due to symmetry we have that that $W_{bc} (x, x') = W_{bc} (x', x)$, and in addition $W_{bc} (x, x) = W_{bc} (x', x') = 0$. So from~\autoref{thm:DP} we get that \begin{equation}\label{eqn:two-state} W_{bc} (x, x') = 1 + \min_{a \in U (x, x')}\: (1 - a (x, x) - a (x', x')) W_{bc} (x, x'). \end{equation} It is clear that in the minimization in~\eqref{eqn:two-state} we need to make $a (x, x)$, and $a (x', x')$ as large as possible. Due to the coupling constraint, $a \in U (x, x')$, those largest values are \[ a (x, x) = P (x, x) \land P (x', x), \quad\text{and}\quad a (x', x') = P (x, x') \land P (x', x'). \] Then from the coupling constraints there are unique corresponding values for $a (x, x')$, and $a (x', x)$. In particular \begin{align*} a (x, x') &= (P (x,x) - P (x', x))^+ = (P (x', x') - P (x, x'))^+, \\ a (x', x) &= (P (x', x) - P (x, x))^+ = (P (x, x') - P (x', x'))^+. \end{align*} We further note that \[ \|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV} = |P (x, x) - P (x', x)| = |P (x', x') - P (x, x')|. \] Hence in conjunction with~\autoref{lem:sticky} we conclude that there exists a unique optimal Markovian coupling and this is the Wassertstein coupling~\eqref{eqn:w-coupling}. Moreover, we have closed form expressions for both the non-causal and the bicausal optimal transport costs \begin{align*} & W (x, x') = \frac{|P (x, x') - P (x', x)|}{P (x, x') + P (x', x)} \cdot \frac{1}{1 - \|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV}} \\ & \quad < W_{bc} (x, x') = \frac{1}{1 - \|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV}}. \end{align*} \end{proof} \end{lemma} Finally, we give an easy upper bound on the bicausal optimal transport cost for contractive Markov chains. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:geometric} Let $\delta (P) = \max_{x, x' \in S}\: \|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV}$ be the Doeblin-Dobrushin contraction coefficient, and assume that $\delta (P) < 1$. Then \[ \|W_{bc}\|_\infty \le \frac{1}{1-\delta (P)}. \] \begin{proof} By definition $W_{bc} (x_0, x_0')$ is upper bounded by the cost incurred when the Wasserstein coupling~\eqref{eqn:w-coupling} is used. Under the Wasserstein coupling, $Q_W$, the probability that we hit the diagonal in one step from state $(x, x')$ is $1-\|P (x, \cdot) - P (x', \cdot)\|_{TV}$. Thus ${\mathbf d}_1 (\hat{{\mathbf X}}, \hat{{\mathbf X}}')$ under the Markovian coupling induced by $Q_W$ is stochastically dominated by $\Geom (1-\delta (P))$, and thus \[ W_{bc} (x_0, x_0') \le \E_{(x_0, x_0')}^{Q_W} [{\mathbf d}_1 (\hat{{\mathbf X}}, \hat{{\mathbf X}}')] \le \frac{1}{1-\delta (P)}, \quad \text{for any}~ x_0, x_0' \in S. \] \end{proof} \end{lemma} \section{Bicausal Optimal Transport for Markov Chains via Dynamic Programming}\label{sec:DP} We start by illustrating that the bicasual transport problem for Markov chains~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport-Markov} can be viewed as an instance of infinite horizon dynamic programming. When $\beta \in (0, 1)$ we have an instance of discounted dynamic programming, initially studied by~\cite{blackwell1965}, while when $\beta = 1$ we have an instance of negative dynamic programming, initially studied by~\cite{strauch1966}. For two Markov chains $\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), ~ \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')$ on the same state space $(S, {\mathcal S})$, and for the bicausal optimal transport problem~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport-Markov} between them, the associated underlying Markov decision process is given by the tuple $((S \times S, {\mathcal S} \otimes {\mathcal S}), (A, {\mathcal A}), U, q, \beta, c)$ where: \begin{itemize} \item $(S \times S, {\mathcal S} \otimes {\mathcal S})$ stands for the state space of the Markov decision process. \item $(A, {\mathcal A})$ is the action space, where $A = {\mathcal P} (S \times S)$ is the set of all probability distributions on $S \times S$ equipped with the subspace topology induced from the standard topology on $\Real{|S \times S|}$, and ${\mathcal A}$ stands for the corresponding Borel $\sigma$-field. \item $U (x,x') = \left\{a \in A : a (\cdot, S) = P (x, \cdot), ~ a (S, \cdot) = P' (x', \cdot)\right\}$ is the set of all allowable actions at state $(x, x')$, i.e. all the probability distributions on $S \times S$ which respect the coupling constraints. \item $q (\cdot \mid (x, x'), a) = a$ is the distribution of the state next visited by the Markov decision process if the system is currently in state $(x, x')$ and action $a \in U (x, x')$ is taken. \item $\beta \in (0, 1]$ is the discount factor. \item $c : S \times S \to [0, \infty)$ is the cost function. \end{itemize} A policy is a bicausal coupling $\mu \in \Pi_{bc} (\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P'))$, and it can be decomposed as a sequence of conditional distributions as in~\eqref{eqn:factorization} so that if the coupling $\mu$ is used, and up to time $n$ we observe the trajectory $x_0, \ldots, x_n, x_0', \ldots, x_n'$ then the action taken at time $n$ is $\mu (\cdot \mid x_0, \ldots, x_n, x_0', \ldots, x_n')$ which is also the distribution of the state visited by the Markov decision process at time $n+1$. As it turns out there exists an optimal coupling for which the conditional distributions do not depend on the whole trajectory but just on the current state, i.e. there exists an optimal coupling which is Markovian in the sense of~\eqref{eqn:markovian-coupling}. We proceed with the definition of some typical operators from the dynamic programming literature. Let $F$ be the set of all extended real valued functions $V : S \times S \to [0, \infty]$. For $Q \in \Pi_M (P, P')$ define the operator $T_Q : F \to F$ by \[ T_Q (V) (x, x') = c (x, x') + \beta \int Q \left((x, x'), (dy, dy')\right) V (y, y'), \] which we may also write in functional notation as \[ T_Q (V) = c + \beta Q V. \] Additionally, define the Bellman operator $T : F \to F$ by \[ T (V) (x, x') = c (x, x') + \beta \inf_{a \in U (x, x')}\: \int a (dy, dy') V (y, y'), \] or in functional notation as \[ T (V) = c + \beta \inf_{Q \in \Pi_M (P, P')}\: Q V. \] We note that when $\beta \in (0, 1)$ the Bellman operator $T$ is a $\beta$-contraction with respect to the $\sup$-norm on $F$, and when $\beta = 1$ the Bellman operator $T$ is an increasing mapping. In the following theorem we summarize the main results from this dynamic programming interpretation of the bicausal optimal transport problem between two Markov chains~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport-Markov}. As it is typical in dynamic programming we consider the transportation cost $W_{bc} \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right)$ as a function $W_{bc} : S \times S \to [0, \infty]$ of the initializations of the two Markov chains, and we write $W_{bc} (x_0, x_0')$ for the optimal cost. \begin{theorem}\label{thm:DP}\hfill\break \begin{enumerate} \item The transportation cost $W_{bc}$ is a solution to the fixed point equation $V = T (V)$. When $\beta \in (0, 1)$ it is the unique solution, while when $\beta = 1$ if $V \ge 0$ and $V = T (V)$ then $V \ge W_{bc}$. \item The transportation cost $W_{bc}$ can be calculated via the fixed point iteration \begin{equation}\label{eqn:value-iteration} \begin{cases} V_0 &= 0, \\ V_k &= T (V_{k-1}), \quad k = 1, 2, \ldots, \end{cases} \end{equation} If $\beta \in (0, 1)$, then $\|V_k - W_{bc}\|_\infty \le \beta^k \|W_{bc}\|_\infty$, and thus $V_k \to W_{bc}$ as $k \to \infty$ at a linear rate. If $\beta = 1$, then the convergence is monotonic, $V_k \uparrow W_{bc}$ as $k \to \infty$. \item There exists an optimal Markovian coupling. \item $Q$ is an optimal Markovian coupling if and only if $T_Q (W_{bc}) = W_{bc}$. \end{enumerate} \begin{proof} When $\beta \in (0, 1)$ parts 1, 2 and 4 follow from Proposition 1 in~\cite{bertsekas1977}. When $\beta = 1$ parts 1 and 3 follows from Propositions 5 and 7 in~\cite{bertsekas1977}. For the rest we need to note that for every $x, x' \in S, ~ \lambda \in [0, \infty)$ and $k$, the set \[ U_k ((x, x'), \lambda) = \left\{ a \in U (x, x') : c (x, x') + \beta \int a (dy, dy') V_k (y, y') \le \lambda \right\}, \] is compact as the intersection of the compact set $U (x, x')$, with a closed half-space. Then for $\beta \in (0, 1)$ part 3 follows from Proposition 14 in~\cite{bertsekas1977}, and for $\beta = 1$ parts 2 and 3 follow from Proposition 12 in~\cite{bertsekas1977}. \end{proof} \end{theorem} We note that due to the special structure of $U (x, x')$, it is a convex polytope arising from the intersection of a probability simplex with an affine space, the value iteration~\eqref{eqn:value-iteration} proceeds by solving at each iteration a linear program. Thus the value iteration~\eqref{eqn:value-iteration} in this case can be thought as sequence of finite dimensional linear programs approximating the bicausal optimal transport cost $W_{bc}$ which in~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport-Markov} is formulated as an infinite dimensional linear program. \section{Introduction} Let $S$ be a finite set equipped with the discrete topology, and let ${\mathcal S}$ be the corresponding Borel $\sigma$-field which in this case is the set of all subsets of $S$. Let $S^\infty$ be the countable infinite product space, equipped with the product topology, and let ${\mathcal S}^\infty$ be the corresponding Borel $\sigma$-field. Let ${\mathbf X} = (X_k)_{k=0}^\infty, ~{\mathbf X}' = (X_k')_{k=0}^\infty$ be two discrete time stochastic processes on the measurable space $(S^\infty, {\mathcal S}^\infty)$, governed by the probability laws $\mu, \mu'$ respectively. By a coupling of ${\mathbf X}, {\mathbf X}'$ we mean a pair of stochastic processes $(\hat{{\mathbf X}}, \hat{{\mathbf X}}')$, on the measurable space $(S^\infty \times S^\infty, {\mathcal S}^\infty \otimes {\mathcal S}^\infty)$, governed by a probability law $\pi$ such that $\pi (\cdot, S^\infty) = \mu$, and $\pi (S^\infty, \cdot ) = \mu'$. Denote the set of all couplings of $\mu, \mu'$ by \[ \Pi (\mu, \mu') = \left\{\pi \in {\mathcal P} (S^\infty \times S^\infty) : \pi (\cdot, S^\infty) = \mu, ~ \pi (S^\infty, \cdot) = \mu'\right\}, \] where ${\mathcal P} (S^\infty \times S^\infty)$ denotes the set of all probability laws on $(S^\infty \times S^\infty, {\mathcal S}^\infty \otimes {\mathcal S}^\infty)$. Let ${\mathbf c} : S^\infty \times S^\infty \to [0, \infty]$ be a ${\mathcal S}^\infty \otimes {\mathcal S}^\infty$-measurable cost function, which has the following additive form \begin{equation} {\mathbf c} ({\mathbf x}, {\mathbf x}') = \sum_{k=0}^\infty \beta^k c (x_k, y_k), \end{equation} for some $\beta \in (0, 1]$, and some $c : S \times S \to [0, \infty)$. In particular, it will be of special interest the case that the cost function ${\mathbf c}$ is the metric \begin{equation}\label{eqn:metric} {\mathbf d}_\beta ({\mathbf x}, {\mathbf x}') = \sum_{k=0}^\infty \beta^k I \{x_k \neq x_k'\}, \end{equation} which for $\beta \in (0, 1)$ induces the product topology on $S^\infty$. In a typical optimal transport problem, see for instance the book of~\cite{villani09}, we are interested in finding a coupling $\pi$ which minimizes the cost function ${\mathbf c}$ according to the following cost criterion \begin{equation}\label{eqn:classic-transport} W (\mu, \mu') = \inf_{\pi \in \Pi (\mu, \mu')}\: \int {\mathbf c} ({\mathbf x}, {\mathbf x}') \pi (d {\mathbf x}, d {\mathbf x}'). \end{equation} Such a formulation might be inadequate in the context of stochastic processes, as the evolution over time matters, and has to be accounted. In the context of finite horizon processes the works of~\cite{pflug09,pflug12} recognize this and introduce the nested distance which takes into consideration the filtrations. They are motivated by applications of the nested distance for scenario reduction in the context of multistage stochastic optimization. See also the work of~\cite{backhoff20a} for an application of the nested distance to stability in mathematical finance. The metric and topological properties of the nested distance has been recently studied in~\cite{backhoff20b}. A generalization of the nested distance is the causal optimal transport problem introduced by~\cite{lassalle15} and further developed by~\cite{backhoff17} where a dynamic programming principle is developed as well. All those works deal in great generality with processes of finite horizon. In this paper we study the bicausal optimal transport problem for Markov chains over an infinite horizon, drawing motivation by the classic theory of couplings for Markov chains where one might naturally seek for an adapted coupling, i.e. one that cannot see into the future, that couples two chains as fast as possible. To introduce the bicausal optimal transport problem we first note that any probability law $\pi$ can be factorized, for every $n$, as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:factorization} \begin{split} &\pi ((d x_0, \ldots, d x_n), (d x_0', \ldots, d x_n')) \\ &\qquad = \pi (d x_0, d x_0') \pi (d x_1, d x_1' \mid x_0, x_0') \cdots \pi (d x_n, d x_n' \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{n-1}, x_0', \ldots, x_{n-1}'), \end{split} \end{equation} where $\pi (\cdot \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{k-1}, x_0', \ldots, x_{k-1}')$ denotes the conditional probability law of $((\hat{X})_{i=k}^\infty, (\hat{X}')_{i=k}^\infty)$ given that $\hat{X}_0 = x_0, \ldots, \hat{X}_{k-1} = x_{k-1}, \hat{X}_0' = x_0', \ldots, \hat{X}_{k-1}' = x_{k-1}'$. In this work we are interested in couplings $\pi$ which are bicausal, in the sense that for every $n, ~\pi (d x_n, S \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{n-1}, x_0', \ldots, x_{n-1}') = \mu (d x_n \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{n-1})$, and $\pi (S, d x_n' \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{n-1}, x_0', \ldots, x_{n-1}') = \mu' (d x_n' \mid x_0', \ldots, x_{n-1}')$. We denote the set of all bicausal couplings of $\mu, \mu'$ by \[ \Pi_{bc} (\mu, \mu') = \left\{\pi \in {\mathcal P} (S^\infty \times S^\infty) : \begin{array}{l} \pi (d x_n, S \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{n-1}, x_0', \ldots, x_{n-1}') = \mu (d x_n \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{n-1}) \\ \pi (S, d x_n' \mid x_0, \ldots, x_{n-1}, x_0', \ldots, x_{n-1}') = \mu' (d x_n' \mid x_0', \ldots, x_{n-1}') \end{array}, ~\text{for every}~n \right\}. \] Due to the factorization~\eqref{eqn:factorization} it is clear that $\Pi_{bc} (\mu, \mu') \subseteq \Pi (\mu, \mu')$. Additionally, the product measure $\mu \otimes \mu' \in \Pi_{bc} (\mu, \mu')$, hence none of those sets is empty. The corresponding bicausal optimal transport problem can be written as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:causal-transport} W_{bc} (\mu, \mu') = \inf_{\pi \in \Pi_{bc} (\mu, \mu')}\: \int {\mathbf c} ({\mathbf x}, {\mathbf x}') \pi (d {\mathbf x}, d {\mathbf x}'). \end{equation} The bicausal optimal transport problem~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport} is particular interesting in the case that $\mu, \mu'$ are Markovian laws, i.e. $(X_k)_{k=0}^\infty, (X_k')_{k=0}^\infty$ are Markov chains. For the rest of this paper we assume that there are initial states $x_0, x_0' \in S$, and transition probability kernels $P, P' : S \times {\mathcal S} \to [0, 1]$ such that for every $n$ \begin{align*} \mu (\{x_0\}, d x_1, \ldots, d x_n) &= P (x_0, dx_1) P (x_1, dx_2) \cdots P (x_{n-1}, dx_n), \\ \mu' (\{x_0'\}, d x_1', \ldots, d x_n') &= P' (x_0', dx_1') P' (x_1', dx_2') \cdots P' (x_{n-1}', dx_n'), \end{align*} and we write \[ \mu = \mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \quad \mu' = \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P'). \] We note that using two fixed initial states $x_0, x_0'$ is as general as considering arbitrary initial distributions, since $x_0, x_0'$ can be thought of as auxiliary states inducing arbitrary initial distributions, $P (x_0, \cdot), P (x_0', \cdot)$ to $X_1, X_1'$ respectively. For extra clarity we rewrite~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport} as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:causal-transport-Markov} W_{bc} \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right) = \inf_{\pi \in \Pi_{bc} \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right)}\: \int {\mathbf c} ({\mathbf x}, {\mathbf x}') \pi (d {\mathbf x}, d {\mathbf x}'). \end{equation} We study the transportation problem~\eqref{eqn:causal-transport-Markov} in~\autoref{sec:DP} under the lens of dynamic programming, where we develop optimality conditions, as well as an iterative procedure, namely the value iteration, that solves the transportation problem. \paragraph{Motivation} In the special case that $P = P'$, and the cost function ${\mathbf c}$ is the metric ${\mathbf d}_\beta$ given in~\eqref{eqn:metric}, the transportation problem~\eqref{eqn:classic-transport} can be solved explicitly by works on maximal coupling from~\cite{griffeath1975,pitman1976,goldstein1979}. In particular \[ W \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P)\right) = \sum_{k=0}^\infty \beta^k \left\| P^k (x_0, \cdot) - P^k (x_0', \cdot) \right\|_{TV}, \] where $\|\cdot\|_{TV}$ stands for half the total variation norm of a signed measure. When $\beta = 1$ the transportation problem~\eqref{eqn:classic-transport} reduces to finding a coupling of two different initializations of the same Markov chain that couples them in the smallest expected time. By introducing the coupling time \[ T = \inf\:\left\{n \ge 0 : \hat{X}_n = \hat{X}_n' \right\}, \] the transportation problem \eqref{eqn:classic-transport} can be written as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:transport-concentration} W \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P)\right) = \inf_{\pi \in \Pi \left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P)\right)}\: \E^\pi \left[ T \right]. \end{equation} This transportation problem is particularly important because it directly leads to a bounded differences concentration inequality for Markov chains as we discuss in~\autoref{sec:concentration}. The maximal coupling of~\cite{pitman1976}, works on the space-time plane by first simulating the meeting point, and then constructing the forward and backward chains. As such the coupling `cheats' by looking into the future. \cite{rosenthal1997} initiates the discussion of faithful couplings that do not look into the future, motivated by the fact that such couplings automatically posses the `now equals forever' property which roughly speaking says that the two chains becoming equal at a single time is equivalent to having them remain equal for all future times. It is the bicausal version of the transportation problem \begin{equation}\label{eqn:casual-transport-Markov-coupling} W_{bc} (\left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right)) = \inf_{\pi \in \Pi_{bc} (\left(\mathrm{Markov} (x_0, P), \mathrm{Markov} (x_0', P')\right))}\: \E^\pi \left[ T \right], \end{equation} that seeks for faithful couplings, that do not look into the future, and minimize the expected coupling time. In~\autoref{sec:coupling-MC} we provide necessary and sufficient conditions for optimality at the transportation problem~\eqref{eqn:casual-transport-Markov-coupling}, as well as a discussion about properties of optimal couplings. \section*{Acknowledgements} We would like to thank Venkat Anantharam, Sinho Chewi, and Satish Rao for helpful discussions. This research was supported in part by the NSF grant CCF-1816861 \bibliographystyle{apalike}

Background ========== Parasites represent evolutionary hitchhikers on their hosts with evolutionary histories of each lineage often running in parallel \[e.g. \[[@B1],[@B2]\]\]. When the hosts speciate, those parasites which are host specific may also become reproductively isolated, potentially leading to co-speciation. Analysis of these host-parasite associations is analogous to reconstructing the evolution of genes tracking organisms, and organisms tracking geological and geographical changes \[[@B3],[@B4]\]. Parasites can also serve as an independent source of information when evolutionary data on the host is insufficient \[[@B5]\]. Host specific ectoparasites have proven to be good proxies for resolving host population structure \[[@B6]\]. This is particularly true when an ectoparasite\'s life-cycle is entirely bound to a host individual resulting in co-speciation \[e.g. \[[@B7]-[@B10]\]\]. Nevertheless, co-speciation cannot be assumed in all systems where there are high levels of host specificity \[e.g. \[[@B11],[@B12]\]\] and careful investigation is required to explain the complex associations between hosts and parasites. A theoretical framework relating co-phylogenetic patterns with population genetic processes was defined by Rannala and Michalakis \[[@B4]\], who formulated assumptions under which congruence between host and parasite genealogies might be expected. These include the assumption of 1) no migration events between splitting populations and 2) coalescence of both host and parasite lineages in the ancestral population. This is difficult to achieve in situations where historical host-parasite associations may have been affected by recurrent migrations or climatic oscillations \[e.g. \[[@B13],[@B14]\]\], which is common in the fauna of mainland biomes. Due to their relative isolation from mainland biota, restricted surface area and low probability of multiple colonization events, oceanic islands like Galápagos provide a convenient model to study co-phylogenetic patterns in hosts and parasites. Founding populations of island colonists are typically small in size and can only carry a limited number of gene alleles leading to rapid coalescence. Consequently the effects of selection and genetic drift quickly lead to genetic differentiation and the formation of new species \[[@B15]\]. The Galápagos islands, and Galápagos mockingbirds (*Mimus spp*.) in particular, have played a prominent role in research on island speciation. It was Charles Darwin\'s observation on the distinctiveness of Galápagos mockingbirds from their mainland relatives that provided much of the founding evidence for the idea that species evolve through time \[[@B16]\]. The geological origin of the Galápagos is very well understood \[[@B17]-[@B19]\]. This permits a detailed investigation of the impact of geographic isolation on the formation of population structure and speciation in Galápagos biota. Similar to other archipelagos that arose in the form of a successive chain of volcanic islands (e.g. Hawai\'i), it has been proposed that the pattern of speciation by endemics follow the successional origin of islands in the chain, a phenomenon sometimes called the progression rule \[[@B20]\]. Geological evidence shows a strong northwest to southeast gradient in the age of the Galápagos islands (Figure [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). The youngest rise above a volcanic mantle hotspot in the northwest of the archipelago, and as they migrate along a tectonic plate transition towards the Southeast, the islands age and shrink due to erosion \[[@B18]\]. Thus the youngest islands (Isabela and Fernandina) are less than 0.5 million years (My) old, whereas the oldest extant islands (San Cristóbal and Española) are more than 2.5 My. Submerged islands of up to 14 My are found east of Española \[[@B17],[@B21]\] suggesting a much earlier origin is possible for at least some Galápagos biota. However, only a few instances of endemic fauna older than the age of the extant islands have been confirmed, such as the *Galapaganus*weevils \[[@B22]\]. A vast majority of terrestrial species are younger than 2.5 My and also fit the progression rule pattern of colonization \[for a review see \[[@B23]\]\]. ![**Map of the Galápagos islands**. Approximate geological age of the archipelago is provided (My = million years) based on literature data \[[@B18]\]. The islands are divided into three zones bordered by a dashed line. Genovesa island is sometimes estimated to be more recent than shown here \[e.g. \[[@B89]\]\]. Abbreviations of the island names are consistent with those used across all figures.](1471-2148-11-284-1){#F1} Exceptions to the progression rule include species capable of long distance dispersal, such as Darwin\'s finches \[[@B24]\] and some species of winged insects \[[@B25],[@B26]\], both of which show complex colonization histories. Arbogast et al. \[[@B27]\] showed that the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) phylogeny of mockingbirds largely follows the progression rule. This corresponds with low levels of long-distance dispersal as detected by population genetic surveys \[[@B28]\]. Comparing the level of divergence in Galápagos mockingbirds with mutation rates commonly found for coding mtDNA genes in birds Arbogast et al. \[[@B27]\] estimated that their colonisation of the Galápagos falls well within the age of present islands, and the distribution of the clades amongst particular islands was generally congruent with patterns of island age. Arbogast et al. \[[@B27]\] also showed that the mtDNA data only partially fit the traditional taxonomy of Galápagos mockingbirds. Morphologically there are four nominal species of Galapágos mockingbirds, each with distinct geographic distributions. The Hood mockingbird (*Mimus macdonaldi*) inhabits Española, the San Cristóbal mockingbird (*M. melanotis*) is found on the island of the same name and the Floreana mockingbird *M. trifasciatus*is present on two islets adjacent to Floreana. The rest of the archipelago is populated by the Galápagos mockingbird (*M. parvulus*) (Figure [2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}). Despite belonging to three different nominal species, birds from the eastern islands of the archipelago (Española, San Cristóbal, and Genovesa) possess similar mtDNA haplotypes, while populations from Isabela in the west of the archipelago, are genetically more divergent from other *M. parvulus*populations than previously expected \[[@B27]\]. A study conducted by Hoeck et al. \[[@B28]\] shows that nuclear genetic data obtained using microsatellites largely agrees with the morphological distinction of species. Thus, at least some of the mtDNA differences are an exclusive feature of the mtDNA genealogy while other mtDNA sequences agree with the traditional taxonomy. {#F2} Discrepancies between mitochondrial and nuclear genealogies have been observed on multiple occasions in phylogeographic studies during the past two decades \[[@B29]\]. Several processes can explain these divergences, with secondary contact of previously separated lineages, ancestral allelic polymorphism and horizontal gene transfer representing the most common reasons for discordance. Typically, the age of the mtDNA lineages or alleles of nuclear genes predate the time of the population separation \[[@B30]\]. Therefore, the genetic pool of colonists may contain several copies of these haplotypes or alleles during the colonization event. Over time, random genetic drift leads to fixation of different mtDNA haplotypes and nuclear alleles in different populations. This ultimately leads to discordant genealogies amongst different loci, which hamper the interpretation of phylogeographic data based on analysis of single genes \[[@B31]\]. In this paper we reconstruct the common phylogeographic patterns shared between mockingbirds and their parasites inhabiting Galápagos islands using mtDNA and nuclear data. We evaluate the level of ancestral polymorphism affecting species phylogenies based on mtDNA data. Our analyses are partitioned by populations of all four mockingbird species and three associated parasites: an Astigmatid mite (*Analges*sp.) which has yet to be taxonomically described, an amblyceran parasitic louse (*Myrsidea nesomimi*) and an ischnoceran parasitic louse (*Brueelia galapagensis*). All three species of parasites are Galápagos endemics and are commonly associated with Galápagos mockingbirds \[\[[@B32],[@B33]\] authors\' observation\]. Despite sharing the same host spectrum, the three parasites represent three phylogenetically unrelated lineages \[[@B34],[@B35]\] that differ in their ecology. Feather mites of the genus *Analges*feed predominantly on feathers and are strictly host specific \[[@B36]\]. The two genera of chewing lice (*Myrsidea*and *Brueelia*) are known to differ in their feeding habits and in their levels of host specificity, which is strict in *Myrsidea*and more relaxed in *Brueelia*\[e.g. \[[@B32],[@B37]\]\]. This assemblage of parasitic taxa allows us to discern shared evolutionary signal from unique evolutionary events affected by varying life history traits. Methods ======= Material collection ------------------- Collection of both the host and parasite material was perfomed between 2004 and 2008 in the frame of previous research \[[@B28]\]. Mockingbird blood samples were obtained from 14 Galápagos islands and the birds were examined for ectoparasites on 11 of the 14 islands (see Figure [2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}). *Myrsidea*and *Analges*samples were found on all 11 islands, whereas *Brueelia*was found only on 6 islands. Birds were captured using mist nets or potter traps and a small blood sample was collected from a small puncture on the wing vein. Ectoparasites were collected from the plumage of the birds using dust ruffling \[[@B38]\]. Birds were ringed to prevent resampling and released immediately after sample collection. A single parasite specimen was analysed for each parasite taxon per host individual, with seven exceptions (four for *Brueelia*, two for *Analges*and one for *Myrsidea*) when the host infection rate was exceptionally low. For a complete list of analysed samples including GPS coordinates of the sampling localities and GenBank accession numbers see table in Additional file [1](#S1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. DNA extraction of parasite samples was performed using Qiagen\'s MicroDNA extraction kit following the voucher method of Cruickshank et al. \[[@B39]\]. After DNA extraction voucher specimens were either mounted on permanent slides or preserved in ethanol. MtDNA sequences of mockingbirds were amplified from DNA extractions made from blood samples previously used for a microsatellite population genetic study \[[@B28]\]. Mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequencing ---------------------------------------- We sequenced a homologous 1050 bp fragment of the Cytochrome oxidase subunit I (COI) gene in the mockingbirds and all three parasite taxa using a combination of previously described universal primers and dedicated primers based on sequences of related taxa available from GenBank (see Table [1](#T1){ref-type="table"} for primer sequences). The PCRs contained 20 μl volume of: 1 to 2 μl of extracted DNA solution, 5 pM of each primer, 15 mM MgCl~2~, 10 mM concentration of each dNTP, and 0.25 units of Taq polymerase. The PCR profile was as follows: 5 min at 95°C followed by 35 cycles of 1 min at 94°C, 45 sec at the annealing temperature specified below and 1 min 15 sec at 72°C. The final elongation step was performed for 10 min at 72°C. The annealing temperatures were 57°C for *Mimus*, 48°C for *Analges*and *Brueelia*, and 50°C for *Myrsidea*. To obtain complementary information on the population structure of ectoparasites independent of mitochondrial DNA, the Elongation factor 1 alpha (EF1α), a nuclear gene, was sequenced in two parasites, *Brueelia*and *Analges*. EF1-For3 and Cho10 primers \[[@B40]\] were used for both PCR amplification and sequencing. The PCRs contained the same concentrations of reagents as above and the PCR profile was as follows: 5 min at 95°C followed by 30 cycles of 1 min at 94°C, 40 sec at 54°C and 45 sec at 72°C. The final elongation step was performed for 10 min at 72°C. EF1-For3 and Cho10 primers did not reliably amplify in *Myrsidea*and thus the EF1α gene was not analyzed for this species. Prior to sequencing COI and EF1α PCR products were purified using Alkaline Phosphatase and Exonuclease I enzymes according to manufacturer\'s protocol (New England Biolabs). The COI PCRs were sequenced using newly designed species-specific internal primers (Table [1](#T1){ref-type="table"}) aligning from the middle part of the sequence and extending towards the ends. To check for consistency of sequence reads at the ends, approximately 15% of sequences were also sequenced from 5\' and 3\' ends using PCR primers. Sequencing was performed either on an ABI 3730 sequencer (Applied Biosystems) or using a commercial service (Macrogen Inc., South Korea). Sequence contigs were prepared in Seqman (DNAstar) and alignments were created manually in Seaview 4.2 \[[@B41]\] without need for gap adjustments. Individual sequences were collapsed into haplotypes using Collapse 1.2 \[[@B42]\]. ###### PCR primers for amplification of the COI gene. Species Primer name Direction Primer sequence Reference ------------ ------------- ----------- -------------------------------- ------------------------------------ *Mimus* BirdF1_Nes F AACCAACCACAAAGATATCGGCAC Modified from BirdF1 \[[@B87]\] COIH_Nes R GGGCTACTACGTAGTAAGTGTCATGT Modified from COI H7005 \[[@B74]\] Nes_InF F CTCACCGACCGCAACCTCAA This study Nes_InR R GGATAGTATGGCTCATACTATTCCTATGTA This study *Analges* An_F F ATATCCACTAATCACAAAGATATTG This study COI H7005 R CCGGATCCACNACRTARTANGTRTCRTG \[[@B74]\] An_InF F CCGTAATTTTAATTCTACTTTTTTTG This study An_InR R CAAACCCAGGTAAAATCAAAATATA This study *Myrsidea* Myr_F F ATATTGGYACTCTYTAYTTAATCTTTGGTT This study COI H7005 R CCGGATCCACNACRTARTANGTRTCRTG \[[@B74]\] Myr_InF F CCGAAATTTTAATACCTCTTTCTTTG This study Myr_InR R AGATTATACCAATGACCCCAAAACT This study *Brueelia* COI LCO1490 F GGTCAACAAATCATAAAGATATTGG \[[@B88]\] COI H7005 R CCGGATCCACNACRTARTANGTRTCRTG \[[@B74]\] Bru_InF F TCGTAATTTGAATTCTTCTTTTTTTG This study Bru_InR R ACCCAAAAACTTCCTTCTTTCC This study Amplification of mockingbird microsatellites -------------------------------------------- 400 *Mimus*individuals covering the spectrum of 11 islands available for parasite sampling were genotyped using microsatellites. Extraction of DNA from blood on filter paper and amplification at 26 microsatellite loci (MpAAT18, 25, 26, 45, 83 and 96, and Nes01, 03, 04, 05, 06, 07, 08, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22 and 23) were performed as described previously \[[@B43]\]. Microsatellite loci were amplified in six independent multiplex reactions (Panel A-D, Hoeck et al., \[[@B43]\]; Panel E with MpAAT18, 25, 45 and 83; Panel F with MpAAT26 and 96 under the same PCR conditions as Panel B & C). Fragment analyses were performed on a 3730 DNA Analyser using Gene-Scan-500 LIZ size standard (ABI) and Genemapper v.4 software (ABI) followed by manual proofreading of genotypes. Phylogenetic analysis of sequence data -------------------------------------- Three approaches were employed for genealogical reconstruction using COI haplotypes in *Mimus*, *Analges*and *Myrsidea*. Due to a very low level of sequence polymorphism *Brueelia*was excluded from the phylogenetic analysis. Neighbor Joining (NJ) trees of haplotypes were obtained in PAUP\*4.0b10 \[[@B44]\]. Maximum Likelihood (ML) phylogeny was reconstructed using PhyML 2.4.4 \[[@B45]\], and MrBayes 3.1 \[[@B46]\] was employed to perform Bayesian Inference (BI) from the data. In MrBayes two independent runs with 4 chains each and 30 million MCMC replications were performed for each dataset. The first 3 million replications at the beginning of the runs were discarded as burnin. The model of molecular evolution for all analyses was selected according to AIC and BIC criteria in jModeltest 12.2.0 \[[@B47]\]. HKY+I+G was selected for *Analges*, HKY+G for both *Myrsidea*and *Mimus*. Sequences of *Analges sturninus*(Genbank no.:[GQ864342](GQ864342)), *Myrsidea eisenrati*(AF545731) plus *Mimus gundlachii*(EF484222) and *M. gilvus*(EF484220), were used respectively as outgroups for the *Analges*, *Myrsidea*and *Mimus*datasets. The COI haplotype data and ML treefiles have been deposited in TreeBASE (<http://www.treebase.org>; study accession number S11770). The branch support of NJ and ML phylogenies was obtained with 1000 bootstraps of the data in PAUP and PhyML, respectively. Convergence between estimated values of model parameters obtained in independent BI runs and their effective sampling sizes were checked using Tracer 1.5 \[[@B48]\]. Convergence of inferred BI topologies was inspected using AWTY \[[@B49]\]. Due to allelic variability and frequent occurrence of heterozygotes in EF1α sequences of *Analges*, the allelic phase of specimens could not be unequivocally reconstructed from sequences obtained through direct sequencing. The heterozygous sites in the DNA sequence resulted in ambiguous nucleotides. Hence the EF1α sequences were not analysed phylogenetically. Instead each position in the alignment for each specimen was scored either as homozygous or heterozygous (when ambiguous). Then the distribution of heterozygous or homozygous states for each site within the alignment was compared across island populations. These data were contrasted with gene genealogies obtained from the COI data. A similar approach was adopted for exploring the *Brueelia*EF1α dataset, which was, on the contrary, extremely uniform and contained only one informative mutation (see Results section). Genealogy and population genetic statistics ------------------------------------------- Due to extremely low levels of genetic variability in the COI *Brueelia*sequences, this dataset was not analysed using traditional phylogenetic reconstruction. Instead genealogical information of *Brueelia*and the other taxa was extracted from a haplotype network built using the program TCS 1.2 \[[@B50]\]. Estimates of genetic divergence were performed in Mega 5.0 \[[@B51]\]. For each taxon we calculated overall mean genetic distances (p-distances) \[[@B52]\] and pairwise genetic distances between the islands. The software DNASP 5.1 \[[@B53]\] was used to calculate per island statistics of haplotype diversity and nucleotide variability, and to perform neutrality tests (Tajima\'s D, Fu and Li\'s D) for all four organisms. Significance of the values obtained in neutrality tests was tested with 10,000 coalescence simulations of the data. Microsatellite data analysis ---------------------------- To obtain an estimate of population structure in the mockingbirds that is independent of mtDNA genealogy, mockingbird microsatellite data were analysed using the Bayesian clustering algorithm in Structure 2.3.3 \[[@B54],[@B55]\]. This analysis complements the estimates of genetic variability and differentiation presented in Hoeck et al \[[@B28]\]. The Bayesian clustering analysis was performed on an extended microsatellite dataset and provides an estimate of population structure by assigning individual specimens to genetic clusters. The analysis was run using 500,000 MCMC replications as a burnin followed by 1 million replications from which posterior distributions were drawn. To test for possibility of intra-island population structure the number of clusters (K) modelled in the analysis was increased by one (to 12), compared to the 11 sampled islands. An admixture ancestry model with the assumption of correlated allele frequencies was used as a prior in the analysis. 15 independent runs of the analysis were performed to check for consistency of the results. Mean values of log likelihood, L(K), and the ΔK statistics of Evanno et al. \[[@B56]\] were used to determine the optimum number of genetic clusters. Graphic visualisation of the results was prepared in Distruct 1.1 \[[@B57]\]. MtDNA reconstruction of shared evolutionary history --------------------------------------------------- \*BEAST \[[@B58]\] is a recently introduced extension of BEAST 1.6 \[[@B59]\] and supports Bayesian analysis allowing simultaneous estimation of phylogeny and node age. \*BEAST was employed to perform comparison of mutation rates between *Mimus*and their *Analges*and *Myrsidea*ectoparasites. This software was originally developed to infer species trees from multilocus data, and was used here to reconcile the evolutionary history of the three organisms. This was achieved by inferring a multi-species tree from gene trees obtained from *Mimus*, *Analges*and *Myrsidea*, for which sampling was available on all 11 islands. Because no missing information on any of the analysed species-island combinations is allowed in the analysis, the *Brueelia*dataset containing data on only 6 islands was excluded. Datasets containing COI sequences of all available specimens (i.e. not collapsed into haplotypes) were used for all \*BEAST analyses. These were run selecting the same models of molecular evolution as in the phylogenetic analysis. In the first analysis relative evolutionary rates between the three gene trees (*Mimus*, *Analges*, *Myrsidea*) were estimated. A prior of 1.0 was set on the rate for *Mimus*, allowing relative estimation of rates for the parasites. Clock-like behaviour of the *Mimus*dataset was tested in baseml, a program from the PAML package \[[@B60]\] and it was rejected (X^2^= 39.44, df = 23, P \< = 0.02). Therefore uncorrelated lognormal relaxed clock priors were selected for rate comparisons. The analysis was run for 100 million MCMC replications and a speciation birth-death process was selected as a tree prior. Two independent runs were performed and convergence between the estimates of parameters was assessed using Tracer 1.5 \[[@B48]\]. Results of the two runs were combined in Logcombiner 1.6.1 \[[@B59]\] with 10% burnin. A separate analysis was performed to estimate the topology of the species tree and the dates of the co-speciation events. In this analysis the age of the root of the species tree was defined with a lognormal prior, using a mean set to 2.9 million years ago (Mya) and standard deviation set to 0.4. This calibration prior sets the highest probability of the age of the root to the estimated geologic age of Española, the oldest extant island of the archipelago \[[@B18]\] but also allows for an earlier origin on the submerged islands east of Española \[[@B17]\]. An uncorrelated relaxed clock with uninformative priors was selected for the three gene trees. Two independent runs were conducted with 500 million MCMC replications each. As above the convergence between runs was inspected in Tracer 1.5 \[[@B48]\] and results were combined in Logcombiner 1.6.1 \[[@B59]\]. We are aware that restricting the analysis with only one calibration point is insufficient to provide precise estimates of the node ages. However, our aim was solely to provide ordinal information on the succession of origin of the fauna in particular regions of the archipelago, rather than to provide exact dates of diversification events. Complementary to the \*BEAST analysis, the tree topologies of *Mimus*and its parasites (*Analges*and *Myrsidea*) were reconciled using the program Jane \[[@B61]\]. This program allows mapping parasite trees onto host phylogeny using a heuristic approach with the so-called Genetic Algorithm. The TreeMap costs model \[[@B62]\] was used to score the numbers of evolutionary events (co-speciations, host switches, duplications and losses). Then the statistical significance of the cost of identified co-speciations is tested using permutation analysis. Tree topologies obtained in the ML analysis and pruned to contain only the main mitochondrial lineages were supplied to the program. Mapping was run with Genetic Algorithm set to 500 generations with population size 300. The permutations were run both randomising the tips of the trees and randomising the parasite tree topology using the sample size of 1000. Geophylogenies -------------- To visualise the level of congruence between gene genealogies and incorporate information on the geographic distribution of the specimens, mtDNA phylogenies were converted to KML files, which can be viewed using the freely available Google Earth application \[[@B63]\]. The online tool GeoPhylo 2-4 \[[@B64]\] was used to convert ML phylogenies of *Mimus*, *Analges*and *Myrsidea*, and a multi-species tree into KML files. For the visualisation purposes a NJ tree of *Brueelia*was generated in PAUP\*4.0b10 \[[@B44]\] using JC distance model and converted into KML format. The root of the tree was assigned according to a mutation split identified in the EF1α sequences that divides the populations into two groups - the Española and the rest of the archipelago (see Results section). Rooting with an outgroup was not possible in *Brueelia*due to the very low genetic diversity of Brueelia samples and a lack of sequences for close relatives in GenBank. Results ======= 107 sequences of the COI gene were obtained in *Mimus*, 86 in *Analges*, 98 in *Myrsidea*, and 45 in *Brueelia*. These sequences were collapsed into 25, 71, 37 and 8 haplotypes, respectively. 51 EF1α sequences were obtained in *Analges*and 29 in *Brueelia*. The list of sequenced specimens and associated haplotype numbers are available in Additional file [1](#S1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. Genetic comparison of populations --------------------------------- COI sequence data show that *Analges*is genetically the most diverse organism, both in terms of number of haplotypes (Hd) and nucleotide diversity (Pi), followed by *Myrsidea*(Table [2](#T2){ref-type="table"}). *Mimus*shows considerably smaller levels of population variability, while *Brueelia*is the most conserved taxon with only a few mutations spread across the 1050 bp alignment and each island population made up of one to three haplotypes. This is reflected in the values of genetic divergence (p-distances) seen for the four taxa (Additional file [2](#S2){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). The overall mean genetic divergence is highest for *Analges*followed by *Myrsidea*, *Mimus*and *Brueelia*. Similarly a comparison of distances between particular islands shows that the values are in general highest for *Analges*and lowest for *Brueelia*. ###### Genetic diversity of sampled populations and neutrality test results. Island **No. Specim**. **No. Haps**. Hd Pi Tajima\'s D/Fu&Li\'s D ------------------------- ----------------- --------------- ---- ---- --- ---- ---- --- ------- ------- ------------------------ ------- -------- -------- -------- -------- ----------------- ----------------- ----------------- ------------- **Española** 7 8 9 13 4 8 7 2 0.714 1.000 0.893 0.318 0.0011 0.0090 0.0016 0.0014 **-1.43/-1.51** -0.59/0.02 -1.28/-0.13 -1.32/-0.37 **Gardner by Española** 5 6 8 5 1 5 4 1 0.000 0.933 0.714 0.000 0.0000 0.0087 0.0017 0.0000 x 0.45/0.51 0.61/-0.07 x **San Cristóbal** 8 10 10 . 2 9 2 . 0.250 0.978 0.467 . 0.0002 0.0074 0.0005 . -1.05/-1.13 -0.59/-0.67 0.82/0.80 . **Champion** 8 7 10 . 1 3 1 . 0.000 0.667 0.000 . 0.0000 0.0008 x . x 0.21/-0.06 x . **Gardner by Floreana** 8 9 9 5 1 6 3 2 0.000 0.833 0.417 0.400 0.0000 0.0025 0.0007 0.0008 x -0.43/-0.30 **-1.51/-1.68** -0.97/-0.97 **Santa Fé** 8 8 9 11 1 6 5 2 0.000 0.893 0.417 0.182 0.0000 0.0018 0.0019 0.0002 x -1.36/-1.36 -0.56/-0.37 -1.13/-1.29 **Santa Cruz** 8 10 10 . 2 10 4 . 0.250 1.000 0.583 . 0.0005 0.0115 0.0010 . -1.30/-1.41 -0.70/-0.44 -1.15/-0.28 . **Santiago** 8 3 8 . 3 3 4 . 0.464 x 0.643 . 0.0005 x 0.0007 . -1.30/-1.41 x **-1.45/-1.57** . **Rábida** 8 4 9 6 6 3 2 1 0.893 0.833 0.500 0.000 0.0060 0.0011 0.0005 0.0000 **1.76/1.53** 0.52/0.59 0.99/0.84 x **Isabela** 8 10 8 . 2 9 7 . 0.536 0.978 0.964 . 0.0005 0.0101 0.0053 . 1.17/0.89 -0.59/-0.68 0.03/0.29 . **Marchena** 8 11 8 6 4 9 4 3 0.786 0.945 0.643 0.600 0.0044 0.0038 0.0029 0.0006 -0.10/0.37 **-2.03/-2.39** -1.05/-0.88 -1.13/-1.16 **Fernandina** 7 . . . 2 . . . 0.286 . . . 0.0003 . . . -1.01/-1.05 . . . **Genovesa** 8 . . . 1 . . . 0.000 . . . 0.0000 . . . x . . . **Pinta** 8 . . . 2 . . . 0.250 . . . 0.0002 . . . -1.05/-1.13 . . . Abbreviations and comments: \"Hd\" haplotype diversity; \"Pi\" nucleotide diversity. Values of significant neutrality tests (P \< 0.05) are in bold. \".\" no sampling for a given taxon; \"x\" statistics not performed due to lack of variability (\< 2 haplotypes) or too few samples (\< 4); species abbreviations (*H*, *A*, *M*, *B*) as in Figure 2. Neutrality tests performed separately for each island population for all taxa generally show moderately negative values, and are only significantly different from expected values in a few cases. Populations showing significantly negative values of both Tajima\'s D and Fu&Li\'s D are Española in *Mimus*, Marchena in *Analges*and Santiago and Gardner by Floreana (GbF) in *Myrsidea*(Table [2](#T2){ref-type="table"}). Negative values caused by an excess of low frequency polymorphisms usually indicate population size expansion after an earlier bottleneck or a selective sweep \[[@B65]\]. Only the *Mimus*population on Rábida shows significantly positive values (again for both statistics) suggesting population shrinkage or an effect of balancing selection. These tests could only be performed for populations containing two or more haplotypes, thus many *Mimus*populations comprising single haplotypes could not be tested because they lacked variability (Hd and Pi = 0, Table [2](#T2){ref-type="table"}). The Champion and Gardner by Española (GbE) population of *Myrsidea*, and the Rábida populations of *Brueelia*similarly comprise single haplotypes. Mitochondrial phylogenies ------------------------- COI topology of the *Mimus*haplotypes (Figure [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}) is largely congruent with the earlier results of Arbogast et al \[[@B27]\], who analysed a different set of mockingbird samples using shorter fragments of the COI gene in combination with 2 other mtDNA loci. The most basal split separates mockingbird populations inhabiting the South-East islands (Española, GbE, San Cristóbal and Genovesa) from the rest of the archipelago. Isabela and Fernandina formed another monophyletic lineage followed by GbF and Champion, which comprise a single haplotype. The rest of the islands form a single lineage. This picture largely follows the traditional taxonomy of Galápagos mockingbirds with two exceptions. 1) As in Arbogast et al. \[[@B27]\] the Genovesa population (*M. parvulus*) was grouped into a single clade with the San Cristóbal (*M. melanotis*) and Española (*M. macdonaldi*) populations. 2) Due to the near basal position of Isabela and Fernandina populations, the *M. parvulus*is polyphyletic with respect to *M. trifasciatus*. These data contradict current taxonomic and nuclear DNA (microsatellite) results \[[@B28]\] that group the Genovesa population with the neighbouring *M. parvulus*populations from the North-Western islands of the archipelago. Hoeck et al. \[[@B28]\] also found that the Española and San Cristóbal populations, although closely related, form two clearly distinguishable clusters based on microsatellite distance data. {#F3} The topologies of the COI phylogenies obtained for *Myrsidea*and *Analges*sp. parasites broadly follow that of the host phylogeny. The split between populations from the Southeast islands of the archipelago are located at the root in all phylogenies (Figure [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}). Most islands or groups of islands form very well supported monophyletic lineages suggesting a deep origin for mitochondrial clades associated with island populations. A few exceptions where the bootstrap and posterior probability support is weaker are also seen. These are usually located near the base of the trees and probably reflect rapid succession of diversification events in ancestral populations of the corresponding mitochondrial lineages. Despite the general congruence of the three phylogenies, the topology of relationships between some of the clades differs both between the two parasites and with their host. Most discordant was the clustering of the Champion population of *Myrsidea*with a clade found on Santa Fé and Santa Cruz. For the other two taxa (*Mimus*and *Analges*), Champion samples were grouped with Gardner by Floreana populations, which was expected, since both islands are small islets adjacent to Floreana and host remnant populations of the endangered Floreana mockingbird that went extinct on Floreana in the late 19^th^century. This means the two populations are of recent common origin. Indeed, the mockingbird mtDNA sequences show a single haplotype for the two islets, complying with the close relationship and reduced population sizes. Population genealogies and EF1α variability ------------------------------------------- The pattern of population structure seen in the mtDNA haplotype networks shows several strongly differentiated lineages in *Mimus*, *Myrsidea*and *Analges*(Figure [4](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). In contrast, the haplotype network of *Brueelia*shows very little sequence variation (Figure [4d](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). Despite this, several *Brueelia*populations contain exclusive haplotypes (e.g. Española together with GbE and Marchena), highlighting a degree of genetic isolation between the islands. The *Brueelia*dataset of 29 EF1α sequences supports this view. The EF1α gene is almost invariable, out of the 347 bp sequenced, there were only 10 mutated sites, which were mostly singletons. Only one mutation, which was shared among multiple specimens, is informative and it differentiates Española and GbE populations from the rest. This confirms that the deepest genetic separation in *Brueelia*lies between the SE islands and the rest of the archipelago (fine red line in Figure [4b](#F4){ref-type="fig"} and [4d](#F4){ref-type="fig"}), as identified in the other three taxa using outgroup sequences (Figure [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}). {#F4} In contrast to *Brueelia*, the pattern of haplotype distribution in *Analges*shows an extreme level of diversification, with each island (with the exception of GbE) comprising an exclusive set of haplotypes (Figure [4b](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). Less population structure is seen in *Myrsidea*, where a few haplotypes are shared between Isabela and Marchena, Santa Fé and Santa Cruz, Santiago and Rábida, and one haplotype was shared between Champion and Santa Fé (Figure [4c](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). One haplotype was also shared between Champion and Santa Fé. Much lower levels of differentiation are found in *Mimus*, where several haplotypes are shared between two or three islands in the central and North-West part of the archipelago. *Analges*also shows extremely high levels of allelic variability in EF1α sequences. The distribution of genetic variation is geography dependent, showing clear structure between the South-East and North-West (Figure [4b](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). Samples from Española, GbE, San Cristóbal, Champion and GbF only contain a few heterozygous positions in the alignment, with 47 out of the total of 58 mutated sites present as fixed homozygotes. In contrast, populations from the other six islands show a much higher proportion of heterozygous sites (data not shown). Microsatellite analysis of mockingbirds --------------------------------------- The pattern of population structure in *Mimus*obtained using Structure software shows hierarchical structuring of genetic diversity (Figure [5](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). The steepest change in the ΔK statistics of Evanno et al. \[[@B56]\] was identified for K = 3 (Figure [5a](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). The three determined clusters are represented by 1) Española with GbE and San Cristóbal, 2) Champion and GbF, and 3) the rest of the archipelago (Figure [5c](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). Despite *M. melanotis*from San Cristóbal being clustered with *M. macdonaldi*, there is a slight difference in the genetic composition between the two species: The San Cristóbal population possesses partially mixed genotypes (Figure [5c](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). {#F5} The ΔK statistics are known to pick up the deepest level of genetic structure (i.e. evolutionary oldest) for datasets containing hierarchical data \[[@B56]\]. In contrast L(K) identifies much shallower divergences. The values of the mean L(K) levels off at K = 10 (Figure [5b](#F5){ref-type="fig"}), where a geographically determined pattern of population structure is seen with all but two of the islands comprising exclusive clusters (Figure [5c](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). The exception is GbE which shares the same genetic cluster with its parent island of Española. This is almost certainly due to the very small geographic distance between GbE and Española (approximately 1 km) that allows for frequent exchange of migrants. With K = 10 each *Mimus*species belongs to a separate cluster (*M. melanotis*and *M. macdonaldi*) or is split into several clusters (*M. parvulus*and *M. trifasciatus;*Figure [5c](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). Estimation of shared evolutionary signal ---------------------------------------- To reconcile the evolutionary history of the parasites and their hosts, a putative \"multi-species\" tree was reconstructed in \*BEAST. The topology of the resulting tree (Figure [6](#F6){ref-type="fig"}) is compatible with the geological history of the islands \[[@B18]\], the host microsatellite data in Hoeck et al \[[@B28]\] and the microsatellite analysis presented here. Posterior probabilities \[PP\] are above 0.95 in all but three nodes (Figure [6b](#F6){ref-type="fig"}). The branches with lower support are amongst the shortest ones on the tree. One of these branches joins Rabida with Santiago (PP = 0.89), the other two join Santa Cruz with Santa Fe (PP = 0.86) and Santa Fe with the lineage containing Champion and GbF (PP = 0.67). As is the case with the individual mitochondrial genealogies, the basal split lies between the South East (SE) islands (Española, GbE, San Cristóbal) and the rest. The clade containing SE populations is further divided separating Española with GbE from San Cristóbal. A second major clade comprising islands from the central and northern part of the archipelago shows sub-structuring into two lineages. One consists of populations from Champion, GbF, Santa Fé and Santa Cruz, while the other comprises the northern-most islands clustering Isabela together with Marchena and Rábida with Santiago (Figure [6b](#F6){ref-type="fig"}). Despite several incongruences between individual tree genealogies observed for particular taxa, the independent phylogenetic signals become evident when sequences are jointly analysed. This is best seen when individual genealogies are contrasted with the resulting species tree in Figure [6c](#F6){ref-type="fig"}, or using a Google Earth visualisation available in Additional File [3](#S3){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. \*BEAST was also used to estimate relative evolutionary rates between the host and their parasites. Results are congruent with the differences in genetic variability estimated in DNASP. *Analges*shows the fastest mutation rate and is approximately 9 times faster than *Mimus*(mean = 8.70, 95% Highest Posterior Density interval \[HDP\]: 6.81-10.00). *Myrsidea*is considerably slower than *Analges*but still significantly faster than its host (mean = 1.87, 95% HDP: 1.09-2.74). Despite the statistically significant result of the baseml test highlighting deviation from clock-like behaviour, the values of standard deviations of the uncorrelated lognormal clock obtained in \*BEAST were below 1 for all three taxa (lowest in *Analges*= 0.20, highest in *Myrsidea*= 0.69). Values below 1 indicate only moderate deviation from clock-like behaviour \[[@B66]\], thus our estimates of relative mutation rates were not significantly affected by these deviations. {#F6} Estimates of node ages from the multi-species tree have very wide confidence intervals due to the single calibration point (see below). However, observed values lie within the date ranges determined from geological data \[[@B18]\], and are indicative of the time axis for the succession of speciation events. The basal split between the SE islands and the rest of archipelago is within the prior interval, with mean value of 1.20 Mya (95% HDP: 2.22-0.39). Subsequent splits are much younger, with the age of the split between San Cristóbal and Española estimated at 0.43 Mya (95% HDP: 1.01-0.05) and 0.19 Mya (95% HDP: 0.43-0.04) for the split between the two groups of North-Western islands (see Additional file [4](#S4){ref-type="supplementary-material"} for a complete chronogram). The multi-species estimates probably reflect the final stage in the separation of faunas as opposed to estimates obtained from the same analysis of individual species genealogies that showed slightly earlier separation of mtDNA clades. For instance, the age of the basal split showed values of 1.58 Mya (95% HDP: 3.24-0.41) in *Analges*, 1.54 Mya (95% HDP: 3.14-0.38) in *Mimus*and 1.53 (95% HDP: 3.1-0.39) in the genealogy of *Myrsidea*(Additional file [4](#S4){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Results obtained in the reconciliation analysis with Jane show significant level of co-speciation in the *Mimus*-*Analges*association (P \< 0.03, in both permutation tests). 4 co-speciations, 2 duplications, 1 host switch and 1 loss were identified. In contrast only 1 co-speciation with 3 host switches and 4 duplications was found for the *Mimus*-*Myrsidea*association. This solution was did not show significant cospeciation in the permutation tests (P \< 0.87). More co-speciation events for the *Mimus-Myrsidea*dataset could be manually enforced to reflect better relative timing of splitting diversification events between the two trees. However, these adjustments would come at higher cost because they would inflate the number of losses or host switches. Figures containing mapped phylogenies for both host-parasite associations are available in Additional file [5](#S5){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. Discussion ========== We studied the co-evolutionary patterns between populations of four host and three ectoparasite species living in close ecological association on the Galápagos islands using mtDNA (COI) and nuclear loci (EF1α sequences, microsatellites). Despite varying levels of genetic variability between species and loci, reconstructed phylogeographic patterns show that the population structure between host and parasite lineages is broadly congruent and their diversification is sequentially ordered according to the geological age of each island. In all cases the deepest genetic splits occur between SE islands and the rest of the archipelago (Figures [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"} and [6](#F6){ref-type="fig"}). Most incongruent events between individual gene phylogenies are likely to be attributable to the effect of ancestral polymorphism. Assessing the contribution of stochastic processes on the evolutionary patterns obtained for each species is possible through reconciling the phylogeny of these taxa. Output from this simultaneous analysis agrees with the traditional classification of the mockingbird species and with *Mimus*microsatellite results much more closely than when the *Mimus*mtDNA data are analysed separately. Ancestral polymorphism and phylogeography ----------------------------------------- The occurrence of ancestral polymorphism followed by a process of lineage sorting creates differences in topologies between gene trees and species trees of closely related taxa. When unrecognized, this makes accurate interpretation of genealogical data extremely difficult \[e.g. \[[@B67]\]\]. Ancestral polymorphism affects both nuclear and mitochondrial genes, but is more problematic for mitochondrial data due to their haploid nature. Despite this, mtDNA remains one of the most valuable resources for phylogeographic inference, mainly due to its fast mutation rate and lack of recombination, which clusters individuals at the intra-specific level \[[@B68]\]. To obtain an unambiguous picture of species history several independent (i.e. nuclear) loci are recommended to be co-analysed with mitochondrial data \[[@B29]\]. Such nuclear loci might include sequences of nuclear genes or multilocus data like AFLP, microsatellites, and SNP\'s. Unfortunately, nuclear coding genes often do not provide sufficient resolution to detect all relationships in recently diverged taxa, and non-coding fast evolving genes like rDNA spacers (ITS1, ITS2) often create paralogues prone to stochastic evolution \[e.g. \[[@B69],[@B70]\]\]. Furthermore, developing multilocus markers *de novo*is prohibitively time consuming and expensive when required for multiple taxa. Here we show that pooling mtDNA data from several organisms, when there is reasonable *a priori*expectation of them having a shared evolutionary history, improves confidence in the inferred phylogeographic patterns. Parasites, and host specific ectoparasites in particular, can predict the population structure of their hosts \[e.g \[[@B1],[@B71]\]\], and in some cases can reveal more about the host\'s recent evolution than the host data in isolation. Whiteman et al \[[@B72]\] showed that the population structure of lice parasitizing Galápagos hawks suggests that the hawks (*Buteo galapagoensis*) colonised the archipelago very recently. This is not evident in independent studies of the hawk populations themselves because the genetic differences have not had time to fix. In the case of the mockingbird parasites, the effect of parasite isolation through host specificity is strongly enhanced by physical allopatric isolation of the host populations on different islands. Hoeck et al \[[@B28]\] measured pairwise genetic distances (Nei\'s Ds) between mockingbird populations from 15 different islands. These data show that populations of mockingbirds occupying separate islands represent distinguishable genetic pools. A similar picture of strongly isolated mockingbird populations was obtained in the present study using the Bayesian clustering algorithm in the Structure software, where populations are delimited solely by the genetic character of the individuals without prior information on their geographic distribution. This strongly indicates that mockingbirds do not regularly migrate between islands. The ecological dependencies between mockingbirds and their obligate parasites mean that the lice and mites similarly lack opportunities for frequent inter-island migration. Hence, most of the cases where parasite genealogies do not match the inferred multi-species tree (Figure [6](#F6){ref-type="fig"}) are likely to be a result of ancestral polymorphism in the distribution of haplotypic lineages across the islands, and are not due to recent migrations followed by switches to different host clades. The distribution of genetic diversity in mtDNA haplotypes between the islands strongly supports such a view. For example, nearly all incongruences between particular genealogies are observed in samples from younger North-Western islands where the processes of genetic drift followed by accumulation of mutations has had less time to act. Furthermore, there is evidence that even in the case of younger islands, population structure is not affected by recent migration. For example, *Analges*, which exhibits a remarkably high mutation rate (see discussion below), shows no haplotypes that are shared between any of the islands, including the youngest ones like Isabela, Rábida and Marchena (haplotype network in Figure [4b](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). Populations of mites on individual islands diverged from each other through mutation and the resulting population structure has not been stirred up by any migration. There is one possible exception to this general pattern. Despite the close geographic distance and putative recent common origin of Floreana mockingbirds on Champion and GbF \[[@B73]\], the populations of *Myrsidea*on the two islands are strikingly different (Figure [3c](#F3){ref-type="fig"}). The Champion population constitutes a single haplotype that is very closely related to haplotypes from Santa Fé. The Champion haplotype is even shared with one specimen from Santa Fé (see haplotype network in Figure [4c](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). This close link suggests that a recent migration event between these islands is a more probable explanation than shared ancestry. Such a migration would require an unknown louse vector since neither Floreana mockingbirds nor *Analges*mites exhibit recent links with Santa Fé. Unfortunately, unlike the other three taxa where microsatellite or EF1α data provide additional clues, no nuclear markers were available for *Myrsidea*, thus resolving this problem with confidence will require additional data. This probably also affected the position of Champion and GbF islands on the multi-species tree (Figure [6b](#F6){ref-type="fig"}). Nodes joining these islands together with Santa Fe and Santa Cruz have the lowest posterior probabilities on the multi-species tree (0.67 and 0.86 respectively) and this topology is also in conflict with the traditional taxonomy of mockingbirds. The close relationship of the Champion and GbF populations of *M. trifasciatus*with those on Santa Cruz and Santa Fé make the *M. parvulus*populations inhabiting Santa Cruz, Santa Fé and the youngest parts of the archipelago paraphyletic. This contradicts the microsatellite data, which clearly distinguish all *M. parvulus*populations from *M. trifasciatus*on Champion and GbF. Like other species tree reconciliation methods based on multi-species coalescent models \[[@B58]\], the \*BEAST algorithm assumes no horizontal gene transfer in the gene genealogies. In one instance this assumption is violated by our data through the possibility of a recent introduction of *Myrsidea*from Santa Fé to Champion island, which is analogous to a host switch in host-parasite reconciliation methods. This is the only case where the incongruence between the topologies is located on the terminal nodes. We can reasonably suppose that the deeper incongruences are caused by ancient ancestral polymorphism, which is accommodated in the \*BEAST analysis. Excluding this terminal event, other instances of incongruence do not significantly affect our interpretation of the reconciled multi-species tree. An improved fit between the genealogies of *Analges*and *Mimus*compared to the *Myrsidea*- *Mimus*association is also seen in the results produced by the Jane analysis, where only one co-speciation was inferred for the latter pair. Instead Jane identified a relatively large number of host switches or duplications. This highlights a pitfall of the multi-gene \*BEAST analysis which cannot accommodate host switching events. Nevertheless, Jane cannot incorporate ancestral polymorphism, which is critical for analysing evolutionary recent associations. For this reason we consider the reconciliation analysis via tree mapping less suitable for the Galápagos dataset. Furthermore, traditional reconciliation analysis is only as good as the supplied trees. By utilising tree topologies instead of raw sequential data for all available specimens, the analysis is limited to the solutions permitted by the tree topologies and cannot assess uncertainty in the input data in a way that is possible in the Bayesian analysis. Mockingbird conservation ------------------------ Understanding the origin of the Champion population of *Myrsidea*is also interesting with respect to the conservation of the endangered Floreana mockingbird. Floreana mockingbirds on Champion and GbF represent remnants of the bird population extinct on Floreana. Bird populations on both islets show dramaticaly low levels of genetic variability, as identified through the haplotype diversity presented here and by Arbogast et al \[[@B27]\]. Microsatellite data generated by Hoeck et al \[[@B73]\] also show very short coalescence times for the populations on the two islets. Nevertheless, both Hoeck et al \[[@B28]\] and the Structure analysis performed here group the two Floreana mockingbird populations together when compared to other Galápagos mockingbird species. More detailed knowledge about the epidemiology and evolutionary history of *Myrsidea*on Champion and GbF would provide valuable data relevant to a tentative reintroduction of mockingbirds on Floreana. Additional genetic loci and extended sampling would help to assess the level of host-parasite co-adaptation in the two populations, and help assess risks connected with uniting the populations on Floreana. Louse Taxonomy -------------- Palma and Price \[[@B33]\] identify two subspecies of *Myrsidea nesomimi*within the Galápagos based on morphological data. These subspecies comprise *M. n. nesomimi*(found on Epaňola, GbE and on the two islets of Floreana) and *M. n. borealis*(occupying the rest of the archipelago). Genetic data presented here clearly separate the Epaňola and GbE population of *Myrsidea*from the rest of the archipelago (Figure [3c](#F3){ref-type="fig"}). However, the Champion and GbF populations seem to be genetically distinct from Española and, at least in the case of GbF, also from the other Galápagos islands. Mutation rates -------------- Greater population differentiation has occurred in the parasites (excluding *Brueelia*) than in their hosts (Figure [4](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). This is congruent with the faster parasite mutation rate identified in the \*BEAST analysis. When compared to their hosts, elevated mutation rates are a common feature in lice and might be explained through the shorter louse generation time leading to quicker accumulation of new mutations \[[@B74]\]. Relative evolutionary rates of mockingbird *Myrsidea*are approximately two-fold faster than their hosts, which is in line with the rate difference commonly found in other studies of lice and their vertebrate hosts \[e.g. \[[@B74]-[@B77]\]\]. However, the nine-fold faster mutation rate of *Analges*is unexpectedly high. This remarkable difference requires further attention, not least because the length of the generation time in *Analges*is probably not different to lice. Although exact data on Analgid mites are lacking, the generation times of taxonomically related Sarcoptid mites are two to three weeks \[[@B78]\], similar to most parasitic lice \[[@B37]\]. To our knowledge, there are no studies of feather mites that provided relative mutational rate estimates for comparison. However, the fast genomic evolution in *Analges*is likely to be a lineage specific character. In addition to *Analges*, Astigmatid mites, containing many other parasitic and free-living species, have been shown to have significantly faster mutation rates than other mite groups \[[@B35]\]. Louse ecology influencing genetic patterns ------------------------------------------ As representatives of two separate louse suborders the louse species analysed in this study differ considerably with respect to their ecology and evolutionary origins. *Brueelia*, as other ischnoceran lice, feed on feathers, whereas amblyceran *Myrsidea*include host body fluids in their diet. Amblycera are therefore more exposed to the host\'s immune response than Ischnocera \[[@B37]\]. Such interaction may promote selection towards host specific forms in *Myrsidea*and might accelerate their genetic differentiation relative to ischnoceran *Brueelia*. Other ecological characters may also explain the different levels of genetic differentiation in these different suborders of parasitic lice. The pattern reported here of lower levels of intra-specific variability in Ischnocera relative to Amblycera has also been identified in other taxonomic studies of lice. For example, Bueter et al. \[[@B79]\] compared levels of intra-generic genetic diversity between *Brueelia*and *Myrsidea*parasitizing thrushes (genus *Catharus*, Passeriformes). Their data show decreased genetic diversity and lack of co-speciation in *Brueelia*when compared to their hosts. This could be explained by increased dispersal capabilities in *Brueelia*, either through direct contact of host organisms or via phoresis (transport) on hippoboscid flies parasitizing various bird hosts \[[@B80]\]. Comparative studies of genetic differences at a very low (intra-specific) evolutionary levels are rare in lice \[for exceptions see \[[@B81]-[@B83]\]\] but in these cases different dispersal capabilities have also been suggested as important factors contributing to the differences in population structure. The role of phoresis in facilitating the dispersal of lice has been documented on numerous occasions in Ischnocera with a majority of cases citing *Brueelia*attached to hippoboscid flies. In contrast, phoretic associations involving Amblycera are very rare \[[@B80]\]. Hippoboscid flies are present on Galápagos mockingbirds \[authors\' observation\] making dispersal through phoresis a possible explanation for the lack of inter-island differentiation in *Brueelia*. However, it is improbable that hippoboscids could migrate between islands without being attached to a bird. Thus any migration of *Brueelia*between islands, whether vectored by hippoboscids or not, is likely to involve another bird host. *Brueelia galapagensis*has been recorded from several other species of hosts including the Small Ground Finch (*Geospiza fuliginosa*) \[[@B32],[@B84]\] which is endemic to the Galápagos and is capable of migration between islands \[[@B24],[@B85]\]. Although records of *B. galapagensis*from non-specific hosts (i.e. other than *Mimus*) have been questioned and may be attributed to contamination \[R.L. Palma, personal communication\] it is possible that *B. galapagensis*occasionally occurs on the Small Ground Finch as stragglers. The lack of genetic structure in *B. galapagensis*might be explained by phoretic transfer to the Small Ground Finch and the inter-island migration of this species, followed by recurrent phoretic transfer back to mockingbirds. *Brueelia*also show very little intra-population variability, which is compatible with low population sizes of the parasite recovered during collecting. Despite large numbers of mockingbirds inspected for lice, *Brueelia*was absent on many islands, especially on larger islands of the archipelago and in those instances when *Brueelia*was present, its abundance and prevalence were very low in comparison to *Myrsidea*(Figure [2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}). This might suggest lower levels of adaption for *Brueelia*on mockingbirds compared to the other two parasitic taxa. We can only speculate as to why *Brueelia*is missing on larger islands. It may be the case that *Brueelia*is only capable of surviving on mockingbirds that exist in smaller, genetically depleted host populations. For instance, a similar link between host genetic diversity and the prevalence of an ischnoceran parasite, was reported in populations of a wild lesser kestrel, *Falco naumanni*and their lice, *Degeeriella rufa*\[[@B86]\]. Conclusions =========== Using mitochondrial DNA sequences and nuclear data we studied 400 samples of recently diverged Galápagos mockingbirds and 229 specimens of 3 species of their parasites (*Analges*, *Myrsidea*and *Brueelia*). We found that co-phylogeographic patterns inferred on the level of single gene genealogies (for *Mimus*, *Analges*and *Myrsidea*) are considerably impacted by differential distribution of ancestral polymorphism. In contrast, extremely low genetic variability and lack of co-phylogeographic congruence was found in *Brueelia*. These differences may be explained by life history traits in *Brueelia*such as their dispersal capabilitity, abundance, and lower levels of host specificity. A more accurate picture of the phylogeographic history of these lineages, congruent with the geological history of the islands and with available nuclear data was obtained through a joint analysis of data for the three co-evolving groups. We show that pooling genetic data for several organisms living in close ecological association improves the inference of phylogeographic histories in recently diverged species. Authors\' contributions ======================= JŠ sequenced the studied taxa, performed computional analyses and drafted the manuscript. VS concieved the idea of studying host-parasite co-evolution in mockingbirds, provided guidance with data analyses and contributed to drafting the manuscript. PH concluded fragment analysis of the mockingbird microsatellites. PH and LK collected all study material and helped with finishing the manuscript text. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Supplementary Material ====================== ###### Additional file 1 **List of samples sequenced for COI and EF1α**. ###### Click here for file ###### Additional file 2 **Matrices of mean genetic divergence (p-distances) for the COI gene**. ###### Click here for file ###### Additional file 3 **\*BEAST chronograms**. Provided are multi-species chronogram (a) and chronograms for *Mimus*(b), *Analges*(c) and *Myrsidea*(d) datasets. Tip labels on the multi-species tree are the same as in Figure [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. Tip labels on the individual species trees are abbreviations of the island names from Figure [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"} and voucher numbers from Additional file 1. Mean values of ages for major clades are provided with blue bars ranging the 95% highest posterior probability interval. ###### Click here for file ###### Additional file 4 **Zipped archive containing KML files for each of the taxon phylogenies**. These data files should be viewed in Google Earth \[<http://www.google.com/earth>\]. ###### Click here for file ###### Additional file 5 **Host-parasite phylogenies mapped with Jane software**. Results for *Mimus-Analges*(a) and *Mimus-Myrsidea*(b) associations are shown. Hollow circles mark co-speciations, solid circles mark duplications. Host switches are marked by arrows and losses by dashed lines. Host trees are in black, mapped parasite histories are in blue. Yellow nodes indicate another location of equal cost exists, red nodes mark the solution with the lowest cost. Taxon labels were assigned as species and island abbreviations as shown in Figures [1](#F1){ref-type="fig"} and [2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. ###### Click here for file Acknowledgements ================ We thank the Galápagos National Park Service for permission to conduct this research (Permit No. PC-48-10) and the Charles Darwin Foundation for assistance. The authors are grateful to Václav Hypša, Kevin Johnson and two anonymous reviewers for useful comments on the manuscript. This work was supported by Marie Curie Fellowship (project Galápagos, no. 235123, FP7-PEOPLE-IEF-2008) and by the Czech Science Foundation (project No. 206/08/1019). Part of the work was carried out by using the resources of the Computational Biology Service Unit at Cornell University.

Introduction ============ GH deficiency (GHD) in hypopituitary adults results in multiple abnormalities in terms of body composition, bone mass, and glucose and lipid metabolism [@bib1]. GH replacement normalizes most of these abnormalities in adult populations including patients of various ages [@bib1]. The response to GH replacement may, however, vary in different subgroups of patients depending on the cause and severity of disease [@bib1] as well as on whether the disease was acquired in childhood or adulthood [@bib4]. GH secretion declines with increasing age [@bib6], but there are distinct differences between normal elderly subjects and elderly adults with structural hypothalamic--pituitary disease. The elderly GHD adults have lower GH secretion [@bib8] and increased total body fat [@bib9] compared with age-matched healthy subjects, whereas there is little difference in terms of lean mass [@bib9]. The results of several studies suggest that GH replacement in elderly GHD patients has approximately similar efficacy as that in younger GHD adults in terms of quality of life, body composition, and serum lipid pattern [@bib10]. Young GHD adults have reduced bone mineral content (BMC) and bone mineral density (BMD) [@bib14]. Short-term (≤12 months) GH replacement in relatively young GHD adults results in unchanged or even decreased bone mass [@bib1], whereas long-term GH replacement improves BMC and BMD in open studies [@bib1]. Meta-analyses, mainly of randomized GH treatment trials with relatively short duration, have shown either a moderate increase in lumbar spine BMD [@bib17] or no change in BMD [@bib18], which could have been due to relatively small sample size [@bib18]. In elderly GHD adults not receiving GH replacement, bone mass and density are approximately similar to that in healthy age-matched controls [@bib13]. Little is known whether GH replacement affects BMC and BMD in elderly GHD adults. In a recent review of studies on elderly GHD adults [@bib21], no significant effect of GH replacement on BMD was observed, but previous studies have been few and of short duration and/or included relatively few patients [@bib21]. In this single-center, open-labeled, prospective study, the effect of 3-year GH replacement on bone mass and density was determined in 45 GHD patients \>65 years at the beginning of study and in 45 matched younger control GHD patients. All patients had adult-onset GHD. Patients and methods ==================== Patients -------- Forty-five GHD adults \>65 (mean age 68.7, range 65--75) years and 45 younger control GHD patients with a mean age of 39.5 (range 27--49) years were included in the period 1993--2006. The elderly and the younger patients were included contemporaneously. All patients had adult-onset disease and both groups were comparable in terms of number of anterior pituitary hormonal deficiencies, gender, body mass index (BMI), and waist:hip ratio ([Table 1](#tbl1){ref-type="table"}). All patients had known pituitary disease or other anterior pituitary hormonal deficiencies ([Table 1](#tbl1){ref-type="table"}). Patients with a history of Cushing\'s disease or acromegaly as the cause of the GHD were excluded since excess of cortisol or GH could possibly affect the baseline characteristics as well as the response to GH replacement. Thirty-eight patients in the elderly group and 35 of the younger patients had previously undergone pituitary surgery. Ten elderly and six younger patients had received radiotherapy. In 44 of both the elderly and the younger patients, the diagnosis of GHD was based on a peak GH \<3 μg/l during a stimulation test (insulin/GHRH/glucagon). From each study group, one patient was diagnosed based on three additional anterior pituitary hormonal deficiencies and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF1) SDSs \<−2 [s.d.]{.smallcaps} of predicted values. In addition, in these two patients, all plasma GH concentrations were \<0.33 μg/l during a 24-h GH profile with sampling every 30 min. When required, patients in both groups received adequate and stable therapy with glucocorticoids, thyroid hormone, gonadal steroids, and desmopressin. However, at baseline, two elderly women received estrogen replacement therapy, whereas nine women received estrogen replacement therapy in the younger group. None of the patients received treatment with calcium, vitamin D or bisphosphonates during the study period. In the elderly group, one patient died during the study period (malignant brainstem tumor after 2.9 years) and two additional patients were excluded due to other adverse events (colonic cancer (10 months) and prostate cancer (3 months)). Furthermore, in the elderly group, four patients discontinued due to lack of compliance after 6, 12, 20, and 33 months respectively and one patient moved to another part of Sweden after 27 months. In the younger group, two patients discontinued due to lack of compliance after 10 and 15 months respectively and one patient moved abroad after 14 months of GH replacement therapy. All patients were, however, retained in the statistical analysis according to the intention-to-treat approach used. Study protocol -------------- This is an ongoing, prospective, open-label treatment trial in adult GHD patients. In two patients of each group, the initial target dose of GH was 11.9 μg/kg per day (0.25 IU/kg per week). The dose in these patients was gradually lowered and individualized during the first year of treatment. In all the remaining patients, the dose of GH was individualized from the beginning with the aim of normalizing IGF1 SDS (target range, 0 to +2 [s.d.]{.smallcaps} of predicted values) and body composition in each patient [@bib22]. At baseline, and then after each year of GH replacement, physical and laboratory examinations were performed including measurements of body composition and bone mass. Dose titration and safety monitoring were performed every third month during the first year and every sixth month thereafter. Body weight was measured in the morning to the nearest 0.1 kg, and body height and sitting height were measured to the nearest 0.01 m. BMI was calculated as the weight in kilograms divided by the height in meters squared. Waist circumference was measured in the standing position with a flexible plastic tape placed midway between the lower rib margin and the iliac crest, and hip girth was measured at the widest part of the hip. No effort was made to influence the patients\' physical activity level during the study period. Ethical considerations ---------------------- Informed consent was obtained from all patients. The study was approved by the Regional Ethics Review Board at the University of Gothenburg and the Swedish Medical Products Agency (Uppsala, Sweden). Body composition, BMC, and BMD ------------------------------ Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) was used to measure lean soft tissue (LST) and body fat, as well as BMC and BMD in the total body, lumbar spine, and femur neck [@bib16]. From the beginning of the study until the end of 1999, a LUNAR DPX-L scanner was used (Scanex, Helsingborg, Sweden). Software versions were changed several times (from 1.1 to lastly 1.35), version 1.33 being used during the major part of this period of the study. In-house precision error on the scanner used, as determined from duplicate examinations in ten healthy subjects, was 1.9% for total body BMC. The relative error for LST was 1.5%. From January 2000, a LUNAR Prodigy scanner (Scanex) was used. Software versions were upgraded several times during data collection, from version 5.70 to 8.10. The precision of the scanner was estimated from repeated measurements on different days in 30 subjects with coefficients of variation (CV) of total body BMC of 1.4%. Before the change of equipment in the end of 1999, the old and new DXA machines were cross calibrated in 30 subjects. In both study groups, 31 patients were included before the end of 1999 and 14 patients after January 1, 2000. Daily quality control was performed according to manufacturer\'s protocol. A spine phantom was measured at least once a week. Every single spine phantom measurement was compared with a baseline value, based on a mean of ten repeated measurements. A maximum 1.5% deviation from the baseline value was accepted. A European phantom (COMAC-BME Quantitative Assessment of Osteoporosis Study Group) was measured once a year. BMD *z*-score, which is the difference in [s.d.]{.smallcaps} of age- and sex-matched healthy subjects, and *t*-score, which is the difference in [s.d.]{.smallcaps} of sex-matched young (20--39-year-old) healthy subjects, were determined using the Lunar DPX-L software program. The reference database used was the LUNAR USA reference population for the region examined. Biochemical analysis -------------------- Serum IGF1 concentration, until June 2004, was determined by a hydrochloric acid--ethanol extraction RIA (Nichols Institute Diagnostics, San Juan Capistrano, CA, USA). Inter-assay and intra-assay CV were 5.4 and 6.9% respectively at a mean serum IGF1 level of 126 μg/l and 4.6 and 4.7% respectively at a mean serum IGF1 level of 327 μg/l. From June 2004 to August 2006, serum IGF1 concentration was determined using a chemiluminescence immunoassay (Nichols Advantage; Nichols Institute Diagnostics) [@bib24]. From September 2006, serum IGF1 level was determined using an automated chemiluminescent assay system (IMMULITE 2500, Diagnostic Products Corp., Los Angeles, CA, USA). The individual serum IGF1 values were compared with age- and sex-adjusted values obtained from a reference population of 197 men and 195 women [@bib25]. The individual IGF1 SDSs could then be calculated [@bib26]. Statistical analysis -------------------- All the descriptive statistical results are presented as the mean and [s.e.m]{.smallcaps}. Between-group differences during the 3-year treatment period were determined using a two-way repeated measures ANOVA of the percent change from baseline at all time points of the study. Within-group *P* values were determined using a one-way ANOVA followed by Student--Newman--Keuls *post hoc* test. Between-group *P* values at baseline and at the end of study were determined using ANOVA. All analyses were performed according to the intention-to-treat principle (using the carry forward principle). A two-tailed *P*\<0.05 was considered significant. Results ======= The elderly GHD patients and the younger control GHD patients were comparable in terms of gender, body height, body weight, BMI, waist circumference, waist:hip ratio, and number of anterior pituitary hormonal deficiencies ([Table 1](#tbl1){ref-type="table"}). The elderly patients had, however, longer duration of hypopituitarism compared with the younger patients ([Table 1](#tbl1){ref-type="table"}). GH dose and serum IGF1 ---------------------- The daily dose of GH was increased during the first year of treatment and was then slightly reduced during the last year of GH replacement. At all time points of the study, the dose of GH was higher in the younger patients than in the elderly patients. Serum IGF1 levels increased during the first year of the study and then decreased slightly during the last year. The elderly patients had lower absolute level of serum IGF1 concentration than the younger patients, but there was no between-group difference in the treatment response. Mean IGF1 SDS (adjustment for age and gender) was similar in both groups at all time points and was within the normal range (±2 [s.d.]{.smallcaps}) in both study groups ([Table 2](#tbl2){ref-type="table"}). Body composition ---------------- Body height, body weight, and BMI did not change and were not significantly different between the two groups ([Table 2](#tbl2){ref-type="table"}). There were sustained reductions in waist circumference and waist:hip ratio in both groups without any between-group difference ([Table 2](#tbl2){ref-type="table"}). As measured using DXA, body fat was reduced and LST was increased throughout the 3-year GH replacement without any between-group difference ([Table 3](#tbl3){ref-type="table"}). Bone mineral content -------------------- At baseline, no differences in total body and lumbar (L2--L4) spine BMC were seen between the groups, whereas femur neck BMC was lower in the elderly compared with the younger GHD patients (*P*\<0.05). After 3 years of GH replacement, total body BMC had increased only in the younger patients, but there was no statistically significant difference in responsiveness between groups. Lumbar (L2--L4) spine BMC increased to a similar extent in both study groups. The increase in femur neck BMC was more marked in the younger patients (*P*\<0.05 vs elderly group). At the end of study, femur neck BMC was still lower in the elderly patients (*P*\<0.05; [Table 3](#tbl3){ref-type="table"}). Bone mineral density -------------------- Total body, lumbar (L2--L4) spine, and femur neck BMD are shown in [Figs 1, 2, 3](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}. At baseline, femur neck BMD and *t*-score were lower in the elderly GHD patients (*P*\<0.001 vs younger GHD controls) while total body BMD and lumbar (L2--L4) spine BMD were similar in both groups. The elderly patients had, however, a higher mean lumbar (L2--L4) spine *z*-score than the younger patients at baseline (*P*\<0.05). At baseline, the *z*-score values were ∼0 (predicted based on age and gender) in the elderly GHD group. There was no difference between groups in the responses to 3-year GH replacement in terms of BMD at all skeletal sites measured. After 3 years, total body BMD was unchanged, whereas lumbar (L2--L4) spine BMD and femur neck BMD had increased within both study groups. At the end of study, femur neck BMD and *t*-score were still lower and lumbar (L2--L4) spine *z*-score was still higher in the elderly GHD patients compared with elderly GHD controls (*P*\<0.001, *P*\<0.001, and *P*\<0.05 respectively). Analysis of covariance ---------------------- After correction for the longer duration of hypopituitarism using an analysis of covariance, the more marked reduction in the elderly patients in terms of femur neck BMC at baseline and the end of study lost statistical significance (*P*=0.18 and *P*=0.06 respectively). However, the between-group differences at baseline and the end of study in terms of femur neck BMD and *t*-score remained significant (*P*\<0.001). When the higher dose of GH in the younger GHD patients was accounted for, the between-group difference in responsiveness in terms of femur neck BMC lost statistical significance (*P*=0.22). Fractures --------- No fractures were reported during the study period in any study group. Discussion ========== This single-center, prospective, open-label treatment trial is, to our knowledge, the first study that has explored the long-term effects of GH replacement on bone mass and density specifically in elderly GHD adults. The 3-year GH replacement in patients \>65 years with adult-onset GHD improved body composition and increased lumbar (L2--L4) spine and femur neck BMC and BMD. A limitation of this study is that there was no untreated control group. However, we compared the effect of the 3-year GH replacement in elderly GHD patients with that in younger GHD adults. The use of *t*-scores and *z*-scores may also, to some extent, compensate for the lack of an untreated control group. Furthermore, at the end of 1999, the DXA machine used was changed. The new DXA was, however, calibrated to show as similar values as possible compared with the old DXA. In terms of *t*-scores and *z*-scores, the LUNAR USA reference population was used as the reference database throughout the study period. Finally, a similar number of patients in both study groups were measured using the old and the new DXA equipments. Two patients in each group started GH replacement with a fixed dose of GH based on body weight that was gradually lowered and individualized. In the remaining patients, the dose of GH was individualized from the beginning of the study. In line with some previous observations [@bib13], this individualized GH replacement resulted in a lower dose of GH in the elderly GHD patients than in the younger GHD patients [@bib13]. The 3-year GH replacement resulted in a mean IGF1 SDS within the normal physiological range (±2 [s.d.]{.smallcaps}) in both groups. However, the mean IGF1 SDSs were in the upper normal range (between +1 and +2 [s.d.]{.smallcaps} of predicted values) after 2 years of GH replacement, and in both groups, the dose of GH was slightly reduced during the last year of the study. Furthermore, although the younger patients tended to have more marked increases in serum IGF1 concentration and IGF1 SDS than the elderly patients, there were no statistical differences between groups. This supports that elderly GHD patients are sensitive to GH and that a relatively low dose of GH can produce a significant increase in serum IGF1 concentration in this group of patients. The 3-year GH replacement improved body composition in both study groups. There were sustained reductions in waist circumference, waist:hip ratio and total body fat without any between-group difference. LST was increased throughout the 3-year GH replacement in both groups. In line with this, several previous studies have demonstrated that GH replacement has approximately similar efficacy in terms of improvement of body composition in younger and elderly GHD patients [@bib10]. There was no between-group difference at baseline or in response to the 3-year GH replacement in total body and lumbar (L2--L4) spine BMC. The elderly patients had lower femur neck BMC than the younger control GHD patients at baseline and the younger patients had more marked increase in femur neck BMC in response to treatment. However, after correction for the longer duration of hypopituitarism in the elderly patients using an analysis of covariance, femur neck BMC did no longer differ between groups. Moreover, the more marked increase in femur neck BMC in the younger patients lost statistical significance when correcting for the higher dose of GH in the younger patients. Taken together, these findings indicate that BMC is approximately similar in elderly and younger GHD patients and that there is no major difference in responsiveness to GH replacement therapy. There was no significant difference between groups in terms of total body BMD, *t*-score or *z*-score at baseline. The absolute levels of femur neck BMD and *t*-score were lower in the elderly patients. However, there was no difference between groups in femur neck *z*-score (BMD corrected for gender and age). This suggests that the lower femur neck BMD in the elderly patients was explained by the normal age-related decline in BMD. In the lumbar (L2--L4) spine, there was no between-group difference in BMD or *t*-score at baseline. However, lumbar (L2--L4) spine *z*-score was higher in the elderly compared with the younger GHD patients. This confirms that BMD, after correcting for the normal age-related decline, is higher in elderly than in younger GHD patients [@bib10]. The responsiveness to the 3-year GH replacement, at all skeletal sites measured, was similar in both study groups. In both groups, total body BMD was unchanged after 3 years, whereas lumbar (L2--L4) spine and femur neck BMD were increased. This demonstrates that GH replacement improves lumbar (L2--L4) spine and femur neck BMD in younger as well as elderly GHD patients. Furthermore, the lack of significant effect of the 3-year GH replacement on total body BMD in both groups is in some accordance with the notion that GH affects bone mass and density predominantly at weight-bearing skeletal locations such as the lumbar spine and the femur neck [@bib14]. Therefore, the possibility cannot be excluded that GH indirectly increased bone mass by improving physical activity level and muscle strength. We did not record whether the 3-year GH replacement increased activity level or muscle performance, but no attempt was made to influence the patients\' physical activity levels during the study period. GHD adults not receiving GH replacement have increased risk of fractures [@bib29]. It is not fully clear whether GH replacement can reduce the risk of fractures, but data based on Pfizer International Metabolic Database (KIMS) [@bib31] as well as a Swedish multi-center study [@bib32] may suggest a lower rate of fractures after GH repletion. In this study, no fractures were reported. However, the magnitudes of the increases in lumbar (L2--L4) spine and femur neck BMD in response to the 3-year GH replacement were lower than those previously observed after bisphosphonate treatment of postmenopausal women [@bib33]. Therefore, studies with larger study populations than the present one are needed to explore whether GH therapy can reduce the risk of fractures in elderly GHD patients. GH replacement is motivated in elderly patients with impaired quality of life, body composition, and serum lipid pattern [@bib34]. In several studies, GH replacement has been shown to be similarly efficient in elderly and younger GHD adults in terms of improvement in these variables [@bib10]. The results of this study in addition show approximately similar efficacy of GH replacement in terms of increased bone mass and density. Since elderly GHD patients do not have reduced BMD compared with age-matched healthy subjects, this will not be an indication for GH therapy in most elderly GHD patients. However, BMD will increase in elderly GHD patients receiving GH replacement for other reasons. This gives further support for the notion that GH replacement is also useful in elderly GHD patients. The 3-year GH replacement increased lumbar (L2--L4) spine and femur neck BMD and BMC in elderly GHD adults. There are, however, distinct differences between elderly adults with GHD due to structural hypothalamic--pituitary disease and normal elderly subjects without severe GHD. Therefore, the extent to which long-term, low-dose GH treatment can improve bone mass in normal elderly subjects remains to be determined. In conclusion, this single-center, prospective, open-label treatment trial demonstrates that 3-year GH replacement increases lumbar (L2--L4) spine and femur neck BMC and BMD in elderly GHD patients. These increases were of similar magnitudes as those in the younger control GHD adults and give further support for the notion that GH replacement is useful in elderly GHD patients. It remains, however, to be investigated whether the increased BMC and BMD in response to GH replacement will reduce the risk of fractures in elderly GHD patients. We thank Ingrid Hansson, Annika Alklind, Ann-Charlotte Olofsson, Lena Wirén, and Sigrid Lindstrand at the Research Centre for Endocrinology and Metabolism for their skillful technical support. Declaration of interest ======================= The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported. Funding ======= This study was supported by the Swedish Research Council and the Sahlgrenska Academy at the University of Gothenburg. ![Total body (A) BMD, (B) *t*-score and (C) *z*-score during 3-year GH replacement in 45 GHD adults \>65 years and 45 younger control GHD adults. The vertical bars indicate the [s.e.m.]{.smallcaps} for the mean values shown. There were no within- or between-group differences in terms of total body BMD, *t*-score, or *z*-score.](EJE110886f01){#fig1} ![Lumbar (L2--L4) spine (A) BMD, (B) *t*-score and (C) *z*-score during 3-year GH replacement in 45 GHD adults \>65 years and 45 younger control GHD adults. The vertical bars indicate the [s.e.m.]{.smallcaps} for the mean values shown. Between-group *P* values (0--3 years) are based on an analysis of the percent change or change from baseline, whereas other *P* values are based on an analysis of the absolute values. ^a^*P*\<0.05 vs younger patients; ^b^*P*\<0.05 vs baseline; ^c^*P*\<0.01 vs baseline; ^d^*P*\<0.001 vs baseline.](EJE110886f02){#fig2} ![Femur neck (A) BMD, (B) *t*-score and (C) *z*-score during 3-year GH replacement in 45 GHD adults \>65 years and 45 younger control GHD adults. The vertical bars indicate the [s.e.m.]{.smallcaps} for the mean values shown. Between-group *P* values (0--3 years) are based on an analysis of the percent change or change from baseline, whereas other *P* values are based on an analysis of the absolute values. ^a^*P*\<0.001 vs younger patients; ^b^*P*\<0.05 vs baseline; ^c^*P*\<0.01 vs baseline; ^d^*P*\<0.001 vs baseline.](EJE110886f03){#fig3} ###### Baseline characteristics of 45 elderly GHD patients and 45 younger control GHD patients. All patients had adult-onset pituitary disease. Values are shown as the mean ([s.e.m.]{.smallcaps}). **Elderly** **Young** ***P* value** ------------------------------------------------------ ------------- ------------- --------------- *n* 45 45 Men/women 34/11 34/11 Age (years) 68.7 (0.4) 39.5 (1.1) \<0.001 Body height (cm) 174.0 (1.4) 175.9 (1.3) 0.31 Body weight (kg) 86.3 (2.4) 87.3 (2.1) 0.75 BMI (kg/m^2^) 28.5 (0.7) 28.3 (0.7) 0.84 Waist:hip ratio 0.97 (0.01) 0.95 (0.01) 0.16 Dur. of hypopituitarism (years) 6.7 (1.1) 2.1 (0.2) \<0.001 Number of additional anterior pituitary deficiencies  Isolated GH deficiency 2 3  1 Additional deficiency 5 5  2 Additional deficiencies 13 10  3 Additional deficiencies 25 27  Total number of additional  deficiencies 106 106 Cause of pituitary deficiency  Pituitary adenoma^a^ 38 32  Empty sella 2 4  Craniopharyngioma 2 3  Hypophysitis 1 2  Other causes 2 4 Dur., duration; ^a^Patients with previous acromegaly or Cushing\'s disease were excluded. ###### The dose of GH during 3-year GH replacement in 45 elderly GHD patients \>65 years and 45 younger control GHD adults and the effects of this treatment on serum IGF1 level, IGF1 SDS and anthropometric measures. All values are shown as the mean ([s.e.m.]{.smallcaps}). The statistical analyses are based on ANOVA followed by Student--Newman--Keuls *post hoc* test. **Baseline** **1 year** **2 years** **3 years** ***P* value** (0--3 years)\* -------------------------- --------- ---------------- ------------------ ------------------ ------------------ ------------------------------ Dose of GH (mg/day) Elderly 0.15 (0.01)^‡^ 0.25 (0.02)^‡,a^ 0.26 (0.02)^†,a^ 0.24 (0.02)^‡,a^ 0.52 Young 0.24 (0.02) 0.37 (0.03)^a^ 0.34 (0.02)^a^ 0.33 (0.02)^a^ Serum IGF1 (μg/l) Elderly 83 (7)^§^ 170 (12)^§,a^ 194 (12)^§,a^ 187 (12)^§,a^ 0.57 Young 143 (11) 283 (20)^a^ 281 (18)^a^ 266 (16)^a^ IGF1 SDS Elderly −1.12 (0.15) 0.69 (0.23)^a^ 1.24 (0.24)^a^ 1.12 (0.24)^a^ 0.15 Young −1.38 (0.23) 1.52 (0.41)^a^ 1.55 (0.39)^a^ 1.28 (0.35)^a^ Body height (cm) Elderly 174.0 (1.4) 173.9 (1.4) 173.8 (1.4) 173.8 (1.4) 0.29 Young 175.9 (1.3) 176.0 (1.3) 176.0 (1.2) 175.9 (1.3) Body weight (kg) Elderly 86.3 (2.4) 85.0 (2.3) 85.2 (2.5) 84.9 (2.4) 0.50 Young 87.3 (2.1) 86.5 (2.1) 87.4 (2.1) 86.9 (2.0) BMI (kg/m^2^) Elderly 28.5 (0.7) 28.1 (0.7) 28.2 (0.7) 28.1 (0.7) 0.81 Young 28.3 (0.7) 28.0 (0.7) 28.3 (0.7) 28.1 (0.6) Waist circumference (cm) Elderly 100.6 (1.9) 98.3 (1.9)^a^ 98.2 (0.011)^a^ 97.9 (0.012)^a^ 0.30 Young 97.6 (1.7) 95.5 (1.7)^¶^ 96.4 (1.7)^∥^ 95.5 (1.7)^a^ Waist:hip ratio Elderly 0.97 (0.01) 0.95 (0.01)^¶^ 0.94 (0.01)^a^ 0.94 (0.01)^a^ 0.11 Young 0.95 (0.01) 0.93 (0.01)^∥^ 0.93 (0.01) 0.92 (0.01)^a^ \*Between-group *P* values (0--3 years) are based on an analysis of the percent change or change from baseline (for the dose of GH the percent change from the dose prescribed at the baseline visit), whereas other *P* values are based on an analysis of the absolute values. ^†^*P*\<0.05 vs younger patients; ^‡^*P*\<0.01 vs younger patients; ^§^*P*\<0.001 vs younger patients; ^∥^*P*\<0.05 vs baseline; ^¶^*P*\<0.01 vs baseline; ^a^*P*\<0.001 vs baseline. ###### Effects of 3-year GH replacement in 45 GHD adults \>65 years and 45 younger control GHD adults on body composition and BMC as measured using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry. All values are shown as the mean ([s.e.m.]{.smallcaps}). The statistical analyses are based on ANOVA followed by Student--Newman--Keuls *post hoc* test. **Baseline** **1 year** **2 years** **3 years** ***P* value** (0--3 years)\* ------------------------- --------- ---------------- ---------------- ------------------ ------------------ ------------------------------ Body fat (kg) Elderly 28.6 (1.5) 26.0 (1.5)^∥^ 25.9 (1.5)^∥^ 25.5 (1.5)^∥^ 0.06 Young 28.7 (1.3) 25.9 (1.4)^∥^ 26.6 (1.4)^∥^ 26.2 (1.3)^∥^ Lean soft tissue (kg) Elderly 54.2 (1.5) 55.2 (1.4)^§^ 55.4 (1.5)^§^ 55.5 (1.5)^§^ 0.80 Young 55.3 (1.4) 56.8 (1.4)^∥^ 56.8 (1.4)^∥^ 56.9 (1.4)^∥^ Total body BMC (kg) Elderly 2.95 (0.09) 2.93 (0.09) 2.95 (0.09) 2.96 (0.09) 0.22 Young 2.99 (0.08) 3.03 (0.07) 3.09 (0.06)^§^ 3.13 (0.07)^∥^ Lumbar (L2--L4) BMC (g) Elderly 60.7 (2.0) 61.3 (2.1) 63.2 (2.3)^∥^ 64.2 (2.4)^∥^ 0.97 Young 60.8 (1.7) 62.0 (1.8) 63.8 (1.8)^∥^ 65.0 (1.8)^∥^ Femur neck BMC (g) Elderly 5.12 (0.16)^†^ 5.22 (0.15)^‡^ 5.25 (0.16)^†,‡^ 5.31 (0.15)^†,§^ \<0.05 Young 5.51 (0.11) 5.44 (0.10) 5.65 (0.12) 5.80 (0.15)^§^ \*Between-group *P* values (0--3 years) are based on an analysis of the percent change from baseline, whereas other *P* values are based on an analysis of the absolute values. ^†^*P*\<0.05 vs younger patients; ^‡^*P*\<0.05 vs baseline; ^§^*P*\<0.01 vs baseline; ^∥^*P*\<0.001 vs baseline.

Background {#Sec1} ========== The daily and seasonal geophysical variations have driven the evolution of a circadian clock system in most organisms. These biological timekeepers permit organisms to maintain near 24 h rhythms in most physiological processes and anticipate periodic changes in their environments. In mammals, the circadian system consists of a master circadian timekeeper in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) in the hypothalamus \[[@CR1]\] and several slave timekeepers distributed in multiple tissues throughout the body, such as the liver, lungs and kidney \[[@CR2], [@CR3]\]. Nevertheless, there is a common underlying mechanism producing circadian rhythms in these tissues based on transcriptional-translational feedback loops (TTFL) \[[@CR4]\]. In the TTFL, the protein products of several genes inhibits their own transcription after associated delays due to transcription, translation and post-translational modification. After the identification of the SCN master clock \[[@CR5]\], the first component of the TTFL was identified as the gene *Clock* \[[@CR6]\]. Subsequently, other "core" members of the TTFL, such as the repressors *Period* (*Per1,Per2,Per3*) and *Cryptochrome* (*Cry1*,*Cry2*,*Cry3*), activators *Arntl* (*Bma1*) and *Npas2*, and nuclear receptors *Rev-erb* (*Nr1d1*, *Nr1d2*) and *Ror* (*Rora*, *Rorb*, *Rorc*) were established. There has been continued interest in finding new members of the TTFL not only for better understanding the mammalian circadian clock, but also because mutations in these core genes have been linked to several disorders \[[@CR7]\]. While *Clock* was discovered by costly and laborious forward genetic screens by Joseph Takahashi and colleagues \[[@CR6]\], current high-throughput data from genetics, transcriptomics and proteomics and availability of the entire genome combined with system biological approaches have tremendously accelerated our ability to find new putative members of the TTFL \[[@CR8]\]. Recently, Anafi et al. used probabilistic machine learning to identify a putative clock member and subsequently experimentally verified it to discover the novel clock gene CHRONO \[[@CR9]\]. Similar bioinformatic approaches were used to identify novel circadian genes from microarray data \[[@CR10]\] and using co-expression data and text-mining \[[@CR11]\], to find circadian genes disrupted in cancer cell lines \[[@CR12]\] and to find health implications of disrupted clock genes \[[@CR13]\]. In this work, we aim to filter the list of a 1000 putative clock genes from \[[@CR9]\] to determine the strongest candidates for further experimental validation. We do this by including other sources of high-throughput data, such as chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing (ChIP-seq), proteomic and protein-protein interaction (PPI) data, not included in the original machine-learning procedure of \[[@CR9]\]. We combined metrics for different data sources using a simple scoring scheme and shortlisted P450 cytochrome oxidoreductase (*Por*), metastasis suppressor 1 (*Mtss1*), proviral integration site 3 (*Pim3*), Diacylglycerol O-acyltransferase 2 (*Dgat2*), protein phosphatase 1 regulatory sub-unit 3b (*Ppp1r3b*) and uridine phosphorylase 2 (*Upp2*). Method {#Sec2} ====== We started our meta-analysis from the list of 1000 putative clock genes identified by Anafi et al. (Table S2 in \[[@CR9]\]), henceforth referred to as the 'master list'. Anafi and colleagues compiled this master list by combining Bayesian scores representing five features necessary in a clock gene: (i) oscillating transcripts in liver, pituitary and NIH3T3 cells; (ii) a circadian phenotype in response to RNA interference (RNAi) of the gene; (iii) significant number of functional genetic interactions with an exemplar list of known "core" clock genes based on radiation hybrid mapping; (iv) ubiquity of expression of the gene across multiple tissues based on expressed sequence tags (EST); (v) phylogenic conservation across fruit flies (*Drosophila melanogaster*) and mammals. We exploit the wealth of available high-throughput genomic, transcriptomic and proteomic data (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}) on the circadian system not used by Anafi et al. to further screen the master list for putative clock genes that are most worthy of experimental validation. We restricted our attention to data on mice (*Mus musculus*), since circadian data sets are overwhelmingly based on the mouse model and therefore several time-resolved high quality circadian data sets are available (as opposed to other mammals). However, we included data from all mammals in the non-circadian PPI data sets. Our data set selection criteria was to include all ChIP-seq data on circadian TFs, circadian proteomics data and PPI data on mice that was available when this meta-analysis was conducted. Table 1Data sources used in this studyTypeSourceCharacterizedTotalCircadianHitsKoike et al. \[[@CR14]\]BMAL134953004359^ns^PER1298413815^ns^PER242553495384^ns^CRY167682923356^\*\*\*^CRY252302717318^\*\*^CLOCK28311204170^\*\*\*^ChIP-seqNPAS1597808121^ns^Rey et al. \[[@CR15]\]BMAL11273439228^\*^Cho et al. \[[@CR16]\]REV-ERB *α*3849-412REV-ERB *β*3849-412Bugge et al. \[[@CR21]\]REV-ERB *α*6256-636Feng et al. \[[@CR22]\]REV-ERB *β*6444-635Fang et al. \[[@CR23]\]ROR *α*8457-529E4BP4 (NFIL3)6147-437ProteomicsRobles et al. \[[@CR25]\]287718534^\*\*^Mauvoisin et al. \[[@CR26]\]561019335^\*\*\*^Chiang et al. \[[@CR27]\]1881476^ns^Protein-protein interactionWallach et al. \[[@CR28]\]123-25PINA mouse database \[[@CR31], [@CR32]\]467-33The source of the published data, the characterized protein or transcription factor, the total number of binding sites for the ChIP-seq data and the number of genes corresponding to the quantified proteins in the case of proteomics or protein-protein interaction data are provided. When data could be filtered to include only circadian components, the number of genes with circadian ChIP-seq or proteomic evidence is also listed. Finally, the total number of hits from each data set among the 1000 gene long master list is given. The statistically overrepresented circadian hits are marked by significance (see "[Method](#Sec2){ref-type="sec"}" section) ^∗^:*p*\<0.05,^∗∗^:*p*\<0.01,^∗∗∗^:*p*\<0.001,^*ns*^:*not significant* ChIP-seq data {#Sec3} ------------- The rhythm generation in the circadian clock is a result of a TTFL, as described earlier. Within the TTFL, clock genes acting as transcription factors mutually regulate each other. Thus, it is likely that putative clock genes are transcriptionally regulated by known clock transcription factors (TFs), such as BMAL1, CLOCK, NPAS2, E4BP4, ROR *α*, REV-ERB *α* and REV-ERB *β*. Therefore, we searched for ChIP-seq binding sites for each clock TF in the vicinity of the genes in the master list. Moreover, when time-resolved binding of the TF factor was measured in a study, we restricted our attention further to only those ChIP-seq binding sites that show circadian (cycling) binding of the TF. Koike et al. \[[@CR14]\] provide time-resolved genome-wide ChIP-seq binding sampled every four hours over one day in mouse liver for the TFs BMAL1, CLOCK, NPAS, CRY1, CRY2, PER1 and PER2 (the list of ChIP-seq peaks and associated genes for each TF were provided in Table S2 of \[[@CR14]\]). It is worth noting that PERs and CRYs do not possess DNA binding domains, but we still retain the data as we believe that they might represent regulation by a complex composed of these important circadian proteins. We used the false discovery rates (FDR) for circadian binding from the original study to filter genes with circadian TF binding using a cutoff of 0.05. Rey et al. \[[@CR15]\] similarly performed a detailed study of the genome-wide binding of activator BMAL1 in the mouse liver sampled every four hours over one day (the list of ChIP-seq peaks and associated genes for each TF were provided in Text S2 of \[[@CR15]\]). As before, we restricted our choice to gene with circadian BMAL1 binding with a FDR\<0.05, based on a Fisher test for periodicity as suggested by the authors of the study. Cho et al. \[[@CR16]\] compared the cistromes of both isoforms of the nuclear receptor repressor REV-ERB (*α* and *β*) at a single time point (Zeitgeber time (ZT) 8) and against the cistrome of BMAL1. The raw ChIP-seq (data accessible at NCBI GEO database \[[@CR17]--[@CR19]\], accession GSE34019) was processed using the TFTargetCaller \[settings: Ouyang, TFAS and closestGene methods\] package in R \[[@CR20]\] to produce an annotated list of ChIP-seq peaks. Although they discovered significant overlap between the binding sites of both isoforms, we retained the genes proximal to binding sites of each isoform, separately. Bugge et al. \[[@CR21]\] and Feng et al. \[[@CR22]\], in related studies, investigated the role of nuclear-receptor repressors REV-ERB *α* and REV-ERB *β* in metabolism in the liver. They measured binding using ChIP-seq of both TFs at two time points, 12 hours apart. As before, we processed the raw ChIP-seq data (NCBI GEO database \[[@CR17]\], accession GSE36375 and GSE26345, respectively) using the TFTargetCaller \[settings: Ouyang, TFAS and closestGene methods\] package in R \[[@CR20]\] to produce an annotated list of ChIP-seq peaks. Since circadian binding cannot be reliably determined from two time points, we pooled binding sites from both time points for both TFs. Fang et al. \[[@CR23]\], recently, measured binding of the D-box repressor E4BP4 (NFIL3) and nuclear receptor activator (ROR *α*) in the mouse liver at ZT22 as part of a study on identifying functional circadian ChIP-seq binding sites. We processed their raw data (data accessible at NCBI GEO database \[[@CR17]\], accession GSE59486) using HOMER (v4.7.2) \[[@CR24]\] for peak-calling and assigning peaks to the nearest gene. Proteomics data {#Sec4} --------------- A common feature of clock genes is that they are cycling both at the transcript as well as the protein level. The circadian nature of the former is already included in compiling the master list. Subsequently, three studies of the circadian proteome were published and we use them as another source of data for screening. Robles et al. \[[@CR25]\] quantified the circadian proteome in the liver sampled at 16 time-points over two days under light-dark conditions. They used a stable isotope labeling by amino acids in cell culture (SILAC) combined with mass spectrometry (MS) to find oscillating proteins. We included all genes whose proteins were determined to have significant oscillations with a 0.32 FDR cut-off in the original study (the statistically significant circadian proteins are listed in Table S2 in \[[@CR25]\]). Mauvoisin et al. \[[@CR26]\] performed a similar study of the liver proteome under light-dark conditions also using the SILAC-MS approach. With 16 samples over two days, we selected those gene whose proteins were deemed circadian with an FDR of 0.25 according to the analysis in the study (Dataset S1 in \[[@CR26]\] contains the list of characterized proteins with FDR values from the rhythmicity analysis). Chiang et al. \[[@CR27]\], on the other hand, quantified the mouse SCN proteome sampled at six time points over one day using SILAC combined a slightly different MS approach. The genes with time-of-day (circadian) variation in protein concentration were selected using a 0.05 FDR cut-off (the list of all characterized proteins with a *p*-value for their rhythmicity can be found in Table S2 in \[[@CR27]\]). It is interesting to note that none of the proteomics studies identified as circadian the core circadian proteins, such as the PERs and CRYs, since their levels were too low to be detected using current techniques. Protein-protein interaction data {#Sec5} -------------------------------- For a gene to be an integral part of the TTFL, it might interact at the protein level with known clock members. Therefore, we complemented the gene interaction study used by Anafi et al. with publicly available protein-protein interaction data. In particular, we searched for protein interactions with a list of 46 core circadian genes gathered by Wallach et al. \[[@CR28]\]. Note that this list of core circadian genes is longer than the exemplar list of 17 used by Anafi et al. \[[@CR9]\]. Wallach et al. \[[@CR28]\] compiled the list of all proteins interacting with the 46 core circadian genes from the Unified Human Interactome (UniHi) database \[[@CR29]\] that was mined from 14 different sources using four different approaches. We looked for evidence of interactions between genes in the master list and these 46 core clock genes (the list of interactions of the core clock genes was provided in Table S1 in \[[@CR28]\]). From the Protein Interaction Network Analysis (PINA) database \[[@CR30]--[@CR32]\], we were able to obtain complementary data on interactions identified in *M. musculus* alone that is similarly drawn from multiple public resources. As before, genes in the master list with at least one interaction with the 46 core clock genes were sought in the PINA database. Combining the sources and scoring {#Sec6} --------------------------------- We drew our data from multiple sources that are generated using different techniques, as described above, which makes integrating them a non-trivial task. It is particularly difficult to assign confidences to these different measurements. We therefore resorted to a very simple scoring scheme where the presence of a gene in a particular data set (termed a 'hit') gets a score of one and its absence, a score of zero, otherwise. Thus, we give equal weight to a data set, whether ChIP-seq, proteomic or PPI. The only exception to this weighting rule is the data set from Rey et al. \[[@CR15]\], which is given a weight of three, since it is a particularly detailed and thorough study of a central transcription factor (BMAL1). Whenever time-resolved data were available, we restricted our attention to binding, concentrations or interactions that were identified to be circadian at the appropriate statistical level (see details above). We mapped all protein data back to coding gene and assigned ChIP-seq peaks to the nearest gene, and used the ENTREZ gene ID as the common unified index for each gene (using Bioconductor annotation package org.Mm.eg.db (v3.1.2)). The final score for each gene in the master list was computed as the sum of gene score within each constituent data set and reflects simply the number of studies that provide evidence supporting the circadian nature of that gene. A gene under this scheme can receive a maximum score of 21. We were able to attach a *p*-value to the total score for each gene using the following randomized shuffling procedure. We assigned the total number of hits obtained from each data set randomly to genes in the master list. Iterating this procedure, we produced an empirical distribution of scores and the probability of achieving a more extreme total score (the *p*-value) can be thus computed. Selecting genes robust to the choice of weighting scheme {#Sec7} -------------------------------------------------------- We used a simple binary scoring scheme for each gene within a data set that resulted in a much heigher weight being assigned to the ChIP-seq data compared to the other two. We therefore tested if genes were particulary sensitive to the relative choice of weights for the different types of data sets. We therefore introduced pre-factors for each class of data: *α* for ChIP-seq, *β* for proteomic, and *γ* for protein-protein interaction (PPI), respectively. Then, the total score for a gene *g* for this choice of pre-factors is $$\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document} $$\begin{aligned} S(g)&= \!\alpha~\![\textrm{\!ChIP-seq data score}] \!+ \beta~[\!\textrm{Proteomics data score}]\\ &\quad + \gamma~[\textrm{PPI data score}] \\ &=\alpha \!\!\sum_{\substack{\textrm{ChIP-seq}\\ \text{data}~i}} I_{i}(g) + ~\beta\!\! \sum_{\substack{\text{Proteomics} \\ \text{data}~ j}} I_{j}(g) + ~\gamma \sum_{\textrm{PPI data }k} I_{k}(g), \end{aligned} $$ \end{document}$$ where *I*~*l*~(*g*) is one, if the gene *g* is present in a data set *l*, zero if it is not. We further fix *α*+*β*+*γ*=1. Our original scoring described above and in Additional file [1](#MOESM1){ref-type="media"} is equivalent to a choice of equal pre-factors for all three classes, i.e., $\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$\alpha = \beta = \gamma = \frac {1}{3}$\end{document}$. We then altered each pre-factor randomly while restricting changes to at most 50 % above or below the original equal pre-factors. In other words, we generate random (*α*,*β*,*γ*), such that 0.165\<*α*,*β*,*γ*\<0.5. Care was taken while generating these random pre-factors to ensure that the pre-factors were truly uniformly distributed over the simplex. Finally, for each random choice of pre-factors, we computed a background distribution of scores *S* using the randomized shuffling procedure while keeping the (*α*,*β*,*γ*) fixed. Significant candidate genes for that particular choice of pre-factors were those genes with a *p*-value \<0.001. Finally, we retained only genes that were found to be significant in each of 100 random choices of (*α*,*β*,*γ*). This list of genes was thus robust to variations in the choice of pre-factors and are listed in Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}. Fig. 1Data mining approach to find novel clock candidate genes. The schematic outlines the approach along with the types of data sources used to filter the master list of 1000 genes from Anafi et al. \[[@CR9]\] to the list of 11 novel candidate clock genes. Some key properties of the novel candidates genes are also indicated. The entire list of robust and non-robust candidate genes are given in Table S1 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"} Model of phase regulation of genes by combinations of transcription factors {#Sec8} --------------------------------------------------------------------------- We processed the mRNA transcript time series data from \[[@CR33]\] (data accessible at NCBI GEO database \[[@CR17]\], accession GSE54650) using JTKcycle \[[@CR34]\] to obtain phases of master list genes. We then grouped the ChIP-seq data sets (Figure S1 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}) into E-box activators (CLOCK, BMAL1 and NPAS2), D-box repressor (E4BP4), and RRE regulators (REV-ERB *α*,*β*, ROR *α*). We used the ChIP-seq components in the table of scores (Additional file [1](#MOESM1){ref-type="media"}) to construct scores for each TF group regulating a gene by summing all ChIP-seq scores for that TF group in the table of scores and normalizing each score by the maximum score attainable within that TF group. Each gene was thus associated with three scores, *S*~E~, *S*~D~ and *S*~RRE~, for the E-box, D-box and RRE TF groups, respectively, that all take values between zero and one. We fit a type of generalized linear model (GLM) for the phase of gene transcripts with the three scores as predictors. Since transcript phase is a circular dependent variable (i.e., phase CT24 is equal to CT0), we needed a link function to relate the linear predictor based on the three scores to the transcript phase. The circular variable is assumed to have a von Mises distribution whose mean is linked to the linear regressors via an '$\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$\arctan $\end{document}$' link function as suggested in \[[@CR35]\]: $$\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document} $$ E(\phi_{\text{gene}}) = \mu + 2\arctan\left\{ c_{\mathrm{E}}~S_{\mathrm{E}} + c_{\mathrm{D}}~S_{\mathrm{D}} + c_{\textrm{RRE}}~S_{\textrm{RRE}} \right\}, $$ \end{document}$$ where *ϕ*~gene~ is the wrapped gene phase in CT and the model parameters include the unregulated mean phase *μ* of the genes and the contributions of the three scores to the linear regressor (*c*~E~,*c*~D~,*c*~RRE~). The concentration parameter of the von Mises distribution *κ* is assumed to be constant and independent of the TF scores and is also estimated (this parameter behaves like the inverse of the standard deviation). The GLM was fit using iteratively-weighted least squares implemented in the *circular* package in R. Results {#Sec9} ======= candidate genes identified by the meta-analysis {#Sec10} ----------------------------------------------- The meta-analysis approach outlined in Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"} yielded a table of scores for the 1000 genes in the master list (Additional file [1](#MOESM1){ref-type="media"}), which is one of the primary results of this work. The ChIP-seq data sets contributed the largest number of hits to the master list and hence, was the largest contributor to the total score (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). The proteomic and PPI data sets had limited effect on the total score. Based on the ChIP-seq data sets, genes in the master list were mostly bound by transcription factors (TFs) via RRE and to a lesser extent at E-boxes and D-boxes (Additional file [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}: Figure S1). It must be noted, that the E-box binding TFs satisfied the stringent criteria of binding chromatin in a circadian manner, while the rest were based on experiments performed at one or two circadian phases. We tested whether the presence of a gene in any of the data sets assembled in this study is predictive of high ranks in the original evidence factor-based ranking of Anafi et al. \[[@CR9]\]. Interestingly, presence of circadian BMAL1 binding \[[@CR14]\] (*p*\<0.05), or circadian proteome according to \[[@CR26]\] (*p*\<0.01), or identified PPIs with any clock protein in mouse or humans (*p*\<0.05) were all significantly predictive of high ranks. Overall, we found a significant but weak positive association between the original ranking and a ranking based on our score (correlation = 0.12, *p*\<0.001). Thus, the data sets incorporated in this work are broadly consistent with the master list from \[[@CR9]\]. Thirty-one genes in the master list (listed in Table S1 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}) obtained statistically significant total scores based on the randomized shuffling procedure, where a total score of 13 was significant at the 0.001 level (Additional file [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}: Figure S2). We used this rather stringent threshold to compensate for the inherent correlation in the scores between data sets (for e.g., we have multiple REV-ERB and BMAL1 ChIP-seq data) that is unaccounted for in the shuffling procedure. Our simple scoring of genes results in ChIP-seq data sets contributing the most to the total score of each gene, as described above. We therefore compensated for this effect by pruning out genes from the list of 31 statistically significant scoring genes that were not robust to the choice of relative weights for the ChIP-seq, proteomic and PPI data sets (see "[Method](#Sec2){ref-type="sec"}" section). After pruning, we were left with 20 robust candidate clock-associated genes (Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}) that included nine known clock-associated genes. In fact, all the known clock-associated genes in the list of significant scorers (Table S1 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}) were robust to the weighting scheme. Further, our candidate list contained 8 out of 18 'core' clock genes defined by Ueda and colleagues \[[@CR36], [@CR37]\] (see Table S2 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}). Among the 11 novel robust candidate genes, all except *Tomm20* had a rhythmic transcript in at least one tissue \[[@CR33]\] and five genes (*Por*, *Gne*, *Upp2*, *Mtss1*, *Ppp1r3b*) had a significantly rhythmic protein product in at least one of the three proteomic studies (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}[a](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In line with the overall trends identified earlier, most novel genes were predominated by ChIP-seq binding of clock TFs with little evidence in the proteomic or PPI studies. Moreover, 9 of the 20 robust candidate genes featured in the top 200 'circadian' genes in \[[@CR9]\] including six known clock genes (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}[b](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). The novel robust candidates in the top 200 were *Por*, *Azin1*, and *Gys2*. Curiously, we observed a bimodal distribution of evidence-based ranks among these 20 robust candidates (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}[b](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}), with genes falling in the top or bottom of the Anafi et al. list. *Lima1*, *Fam20a* and *Ppp1r3b* constitute robust candidates that were indeed ranked in the bottom 200, where our meta-analysis adds novelty to the candidate list. Fig. 2Scores of the significant and robust candidate genes and their relationship to the original ranking in Anafi et al. **a** The table of individual hits within the ChIP-sequencing, proteomics and protein-protein interaction data sets (in blue, orange and green, respectively) for the 20 significant candidate genes (at the 0.001 level) based on our meta-analysis that are also robust to the choice of weighting schemes for the different data sets. The nine known clock-associated genes are marked in bold on the y-axis. **b** The distribution of the evidence-based ranks from Anafi et al. \[[@CR9]\] for the 20 significant and robust candidate genes identified in **a**. The candidate genes that obtained evidence-based ranks in the top and bottom 200 are also listed Motivated by the close association between the circadian clock and metabolism, we checked if candidate gene products catalyzed metabolic reactions using the KEGG database \[[@CR38], [@CR39]\]. *Por*, *Gne*, *Upp2*, *Gys2* and *Etnk2* were robust candidate genes with enzymatic functions, while *Dgat2*, *Pik3r1* and *Chka* were significantly high-scoring, but non-robust, genes with a metabolic role. However, only *Upp2* and *Gys2* were directly involved in catalyzing reactions with at least one substrate with circadian variation in abundance (Uracil and UDP-galactose, respectively) in the mouse liver \[[@CR40]\]. However, no substrate of candidate genes were circadian in the human metabolome in the saliva \[[@CR41]\]. Candidate gene transcripts in different tissues {#Sec11} ----------------------------------------------- We next compared our meta-analysis to the recently published high-resolution micro-array and RNA-sequencing study of the circadian transcriptome in 14 tissues \[[@CR33]\]. Recall that the original master list was compiled using an earlier microarray circadian transcriptome study in just three tissues \[[@CR42]\] and with the intention of finding genes with ubiquitously circadian transcripts. Therefore, it was surprising to find that only 728 out of the 1000 master list genes had a circadian transcript (FDR~JTK~\<0.05) in at least one tissue in \[[@CR33]\]. Nevertheless, the total score was reasonably correlated (Pearson's correlation =0.44, *p*\<0.0001) with the number of tissues in which the gene transcript was significantly circadian (FDR~JTK~\<0.05), even with the simple scoring methodology used here. When we considered individual components of the score, we found that E-box binding, circadian protein expression and PPI with clock genes to be the most significant predictors of genes transcribed in a circadian manner in multiple tissues (*p*\<0.001), though RRE binding also played a, albeit less significant, role (*p*\<0.01). Moreover, BMAL1 and REV-ERB *α*,*β* appeared to be the main E-box and RRE transcription factors, respectively, responsible for driving oscillations in many tissues. The 20 robust candidate genes were significantly over-representative of genes that were circadian in many tissues (two sample two-sided Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, *p*\<0.005) (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}[a](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). More than 50 % of the candidate genes were expressed in a circadian manner in at least four tissues, while this reduces to 13 % among the low-scoring non-robust non-significant genes (Table S3 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}). In addition, when robust candidate genes were sorted in descending order of the number of tissues in which they showed circadian transcripts, eight of the nine known clock-associated genes were at the top of this list. Interestingly, significantly high-scoring non-robust genes were also generally expressed in many tissues and exhibited similar properties to the robust candidates (Table S3 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}). Fig. 3Transcript expression of candidate genes. **a** The distributions of the number of different tissues and expression phase in those tissues compared across candidate genes (red) and the rest of the master list (green) based on \[[@CR33]\]. **b** The circadian expression profiles in fourteen different tissues (data from \[[@CR33]\]) of genes in the candidate list that were expressed in a circadian manner in at least four tissues When we consider the regulated phases of only significant circadian transcripts (we pooled data from all 14 tissues), we noticed that genes in the master list were expressed uniformly throughout the day with a slight bias towards CT23-CT24/0 (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}[a](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). However, transcript phases (time of peak expression) of robust candidate genes were strongly concentrated around CT9-13 (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}[a](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). Remarkably, the circadian transcripts of candidate genes in different tissues shared the same phase of peak expression (see Table S3 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}) with very few exceptions. In fact, candidate genes (both robust and non-robust) that were circadian in at least five tissues showed a very high degree of expression phase coherence (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}[b](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). The exceptions were mostly genes expressed in four or fewer tissues, such as *Chka* and *Mtss1*. For example, *Mtss1* and *Chka* showed distinctly different phase of expression in the heart as compared to the other three tissues in which they were expressed in a circadian manner (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}[b](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). Regulation of master list genes by circadian transcription factors {#Sec12} ------------------------------------------------------------------ In the mammalian transcriptome, few circadian TFs appear to regulate many circadian transcripts with a wide variety of expression phases throughout the circadian cycle (e.g., Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}[a](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). One hypothesis of circadian phase regulation is that different circadian genes are regulated by different subsets (combinatorial) of TFs. This results in different phases of expression of the regulated genes, since each circadian TF has its peak expression at a different time of day (phases). We examined this hypothesis of whether binding of certain TFs was indicative of phase-specific transcript regulation using the ChIP-seq data on different circadian TFs and the transcript phase of master list genes. In particular, we assumed in this analysis that ChIP-seq binding of TFs in the mouse liver is highly representative of binding of those TFs in other tissues. This allowed us to pool circadian phases of significant transcripts from all 14 tissues \[[@CR33]\] in order to get sufficient sample sizes in each combination of TFs. We grouped the ChIP data sets (Figure S1 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}) into E-box activators (CLOCK, BMAL1 and NPAS2), D-box repressor (E4BP4), and RRE regulators (REV-ERB *α*,*β*, ROR *α*). We were able to combine RRE activator and repressors, since the RRE activators and repressors were expressed 12 h apart (i.e., out-of-phase) (see Table S4 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}). In other words, the peak of the RRE activator and nadir of the RRE repressor occur approximately simultaneously and vice-versa, thus, making their effects on gene transcription similar. Based on this classification, we expect activation via each regulator group to peak when the corresponding TF peaks (see Table S4 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}). We first qualitatively compared the presence or absence of these regulatory features of genes against the phase distribution of the transcripts (Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}[a](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). Transcripts regulated by only E-box elements were likely to peak around dusk (CT10-14), while only RRE regulated transcripts peaked commonly around dawn (CT22-24/0). For reference, *Rev-erbβ* is a typical E-box gene that peaks at C10 and *Bmal1* is a typical RRE regulated gene that peaks at CT0. Genes in this list regulated by both elements showed a spread of transcripts phases throughout the day with a bias towards dusk-phased E-box genes. Few genes in the master list were regulated either by D-boxes alone or by a combination of E- and D-boxes and hence, no conclusions could be drawn on them. The confluence of repression by a dusk-phased D-box regulator and RRE regulators produced an even stronger peak of expression at CT22-0. Finally, regulation by all three groups of TFs produced two equally strong peaks of expression at dawn and dusk. Fig. 4Phase regulation of circadian transcripts. **a** The distribution of the expression phase of genes that are significantly circadian in different tissues (FDR~JTK~\<0.05) \[[@CR33]\] classified according to the combinations of transcription factors (TFs) binding their promoter based on ChIP-seq data. E-box: BMAL1 or NPAS2 or CLOCK, D-box: E4BP4, RRE: REV-ERB *α* or REV-ERB *β* or ROR *α*. The grey vertical lines represent the median phase of expression within each group of transcripts and the line width increases with increasing significance of the mean-direction (Rayleigh test). The number of transcripts in each group is also provided. **b** The estimated distribution of phases for each combination of TFs from the generalized linear model fit of the transcript phases to the normalized scores for each TF group within the ChIP-seq data in our meta-analysis. Under the model, the phase of expression within each group is assumed to follow a von Mises distribution, whose mean is linearly dependent on the normalized scores (see "[Method](#Sec2){ref-type="sec"}" section) We computed normalized scores for the regulation of each gene by the different TF groups based on the ChIP-seq data (number of hits) and then a regression between the expression phase of the gene (in CT) against a linear combination of the scores (see "[Method](#Sec2){ref-type="sec"}" section). We assumed that genes with higher scores, i.e., more consensus within the ChIP-seq data sets for a TF, also have higher affinity for the particular TF. The fitted model of phase regulation was as follows: $$\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document} $$ \begin{aligned} \textrm{Mean gene phase (in CT)} &= 17.97 + 2\arctan\left\{ -2.25~S_{\mathrm{E}}\right. \\ &\quad\left.+ 0.67~S_{\mathrm{D}} + 0.41~S_{\textrm{RRE}} \right\}, \end{aligned} $$ \end{document}$$ where *S*~E~,*S*~D~,*S*~RRE~ are the ChIP-seq scores for E-box, D-box and RRE regulators respectively. The model parameter estimates were significant at the 0.001 level and the concentration parameter of the phase distribution was estimated to be 0.58 (this parameter behaves like the inverse of the standard deviation). The predicted phase distribution for genes regulated by different combination of TFs from the fitted model in ([1](#Equ2){ref-type=""}) is shown in Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}[b](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}. The model fits are consistent with the qualitative observations in Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}[a](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}. The model Eq. [1](#Equ2){ref-type=""} reveals that the mean expression of genes unregulated by these TFs in the master list is CT18. Genes with higher E-box scores progressively decrease the gene phase from CT18, i.e., move them towards dusk. On the other hand, D-box and RRE regulation increase the gene phase from CT18, i.e., move them towards dawn. However, E-box scores have a larger effect on phase than D-box and RRE scores. Finally, the model can be used to predict the phase of expression for other genes, if ChIP-seq data are available to estimate their scores. Discussion {#Sec13} ========== We presented in this paper a meta-analysis (Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}), where we integrated circadian ChIP-seq, proteomics and protein-protein interaction (PPI) data with the recently published machine learning-based selection of putative circadian genes from transcriptomic data, small interference RNA (siRNA) screens and genomic conservation data \[[@CR9]\]. Our goal was to screen for novel candidate genes bioinformatically using publicly available data sources. This analysis produced a table of scores (Additional file [1](#MOESM1){ref-type="media"}) for the 1000 potential circadian genes from \[[@CR9]\]. Interestingly, we found no strong correlation between our ranking based on gene scores and the ranking of Anafi et al., suggesting that two sets of sources provide complementary insights into the circadian nature of the genes. The Anafi et al. ranking reflects mainly transcriptional rhythmicity and as such the ChIP-seq data would be expected to be consistent with it, since they relate to the same process of transcription. However, binding to the chromatin is not always functional and unless the activity of the TF is also circadian, binding of circadian TFs does not necessitate circadian transcription. This nevertheless represents an inherent limitation of ChIP-seq data and is a caveat to our entire study. On the other hand, proteomics and PPI are truly independent data sources, since they represent altogether different cellular processes from transcription. We therefore expect that our three data sources do provide new information as compared to \[[@CR9]\] to further filter these genes. The ChIP-seq data consisted of the largest number of different sources and predictably had the strongest influence on the scores. The three categories of TFs, E-box binding, RRE binding and D-box binding were all individually influential and gave hits in the master list (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). Although there were few genes in the master list with a circadian protein expression, they were significantly over-represented in the master list. This can be attributed to the few circadian proteins identified overall in those studies \[[@CR25], [@CR26]\], where low concentrations make quantification of most known core circadian genes difficult. The PPI with known core clock genes also provided sparse hits within the 1000 master list genes. Nevertheless, hits from PPI, BMAL1 and REV-ERB *α*,*β* ChIP-seq and circadian proteomics data sets were predictive of both original evidence-based ranking and rhythmic transcriptome in the mouse liver, pituitary and NIH3T3 cells as quantified by \[[@CR9]\]. Thus, despite the low correlation between scoring methodologies alluded to earlier, the newly integrated data appear to be consistent with the original data sources. We verified our approach against the recently published RNA-sequencing study on the circadian transcriptome in multiple tissues \[[@CR33]\], which was not used in our study. Surprisingly, only about 70 % of genes in the master list were circadian in at least one of fourteen tissues. Nevertheless, we found that high gene scores in our meta-analysis was indicative of robust circadian transcripts in multiple tissues. This supports the ability of our analysis methodology to find potential clock-associated genes, since we expect candidate clock genes to be ubiquitously circadian. Consistent with conclusions based on data of \[[@CR42]\], we found BMAL1 and REV-ERB *α*,*β* were predictive of circadian rhythms in multiple tissues along with interaction with known circadian proteins and oscillating protein expression. This suggests that E-boxes and RRE repressors might be major drivers of the circadian transcriptome in multiple tissues. We therefore compared the phases of the robust circadian transcriptome (FDR \<0.05) in multiple tissues in \[[@CR33]\] against the analyzed ChIP-seq data for E-box activators, D-box repressor and RRE regulators in order to check for characteristic patterns of phase regulation by these TFs. One remarkable feature was that the transcript phase for at least the master list genes were quite consistent across 14 tissues. Consistent with expectations, we found that genes with only RRE binding were likely to peak around dawn (CT0), whereas E-box only bound genes were likely to peak at around dusk (CT12). Those genes with binding at both E-boxes and RREs showed a mixture of phases between dawn and dusk. Moreover, we observed that the D-box repressor regulated most master list genes only in conjunction with RREs, where they enhanced dawn-phase expression, since the effect of both regulators were in-phase. Indeed, Fang et al. \[[@CR23]\] showed that this D-box repressor (E4BP4) works downstream of Rev-erb *α*,*β*. The presence of all three regulator types produces both dawn and dusk-phase expression. The amount of consensus between the different ChIP-seq sources in our meta-analysis was used to measure the affinity of TFs to particular genes as a score. The E-boxes, D-boxes and RREs scores for each gene were then used as predictors of the expression phase of the gene via a model. This model provided a statistically significant fit to the data and described how the presence of the different TFs quantitatively tuned the expression phase of a gene (Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). It must be borne in mind that for this analysis of phase regulation, we pooled all the transcript phases and assumed that ChIP-seq binding in the liver implies similar binding in all tissues. Moreover, since the master list was itself obtained from a machine-learning-based search for novel clock genes \[[@CR9]\], this list might not be representative of the entire circadian transcriptome. We found 20 candidate genes with highly significant scores in our meta-analysis that were also robust to the choice of relative weights for the ChIP-seq, proteomics and PPI data. Nine known clock-associated genes were included in these 20 genes, serving as a sanity-check for our approach. Although there were abundant ChIP-seq hits among these robust candidate genes, the few PPI hits were present only for known clock genes and circadian protein expression was restricted to *Por*, *Gne*, *Mtss1*,*Upp2* and *Ppp1r3b*. The intersection of the top 200 genes in \[[@CR9]\] and these candidate genes yielded four novel genes: *Por*, *Azin1*, and *Gys2*. Most known clock-associated robust candidates received high ranks in \[[@CR9]\], while others that received quite low ranks were the truly novel candidates identified in this study, such as *Mtss1* and *Ppp1r3b* (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}[b](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Several novel robust candidate genes had protein products that had an enzymatic role in metabolism. This is not unexpected as most of the data used in our meta-analysis were gathered from the liver, which is known to have a very important role in metabolism. However, only *Upp2* and *Gys2* catalyzed reactions with a substrate with circadian variation in abundance in the mouse liver \[[@CR40]\] and none of the substrates were circadian in humans \[[@CR41]\]. These 20 robust candidate genes were also statistically expressed in more number of tissues than other master list genes based on circadian transcriptomics data \[[@CR33]\]. Since known clock genes are generally expressed in many tissues, this is indeed a desirable feature for candidate clock-associated genes. In addition to the remarkable consistency of expression phases of gene transcripts in tissues in which they are significantly circadian, transcripts of candidate genes were enriched for peaks at dusk (CT11) suggestive of E-box regulation. The similarity in the phase of candidate genes across tissues sets them apart from circadian output genes that are suggested to be regulated in a tissue-specific manner \[[@CR43]\]. We next discuss specific candidate genes that might be the most rewarding to be studied experimentally based on a combination of factors including circadian protein expression, number of tissues in which their transcript is circadian (Table S3 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}) and their robustness to the choice of weights for the different data classes (Table S1 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"} and Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). NADPH-Cytochrome P450 oxidoreductase (*Por*) had a rhythmic transcript in nine tissues (liver, adrenal gland, brown and white adipose tissue, lung, heart, kidney, aorta and cerebellum) with an average phase of CT17 and was the only gene in our candidate gene list with a circadian protein concentration in both liver proteomic data sets. POR is a flavoprotein responsible for electron transfer from NADPH to all P450 enzymes in microsomes. While *Por* knockout in mice is embryonic lethal \[[@CR44]\], conditional knockout of *Por* in the liver affects lipid metabolism and homeostatis and results in hepatic lipidosis \[[@CR45]\]. Recently, Johnson et al. \[[@CR46]\] showed that ablation of the liver circadian clock affects the levels of *Por* expression, protein and activity, which in turn likely plays in role in regulating hepatotoxicity caused by acetaminophen. Based on the analysis of the ChIP-seq data, the *Por* promoter is bound by three types of clock TFs, E-box regulators (CLOCK/NPAS2 and BMAL1), RRE regulators (REV-ERBs and ROR *α*) and D-box repressor (E4BP4). Metastasis supressor 1 (*Mtss1*) was expressed in a circadian manner in four tissues (liver, heart, kidney and brown adipose tissue) with an average phase of CT15 and cycling protein levels in one liver study \[[@CR25]\]. *Mtss1* was identified as a potential tumor suppressor as it was not expressed in human bladder cancer cell lines \[[@CR47]\] and involved in signaling in other carcinomas. It also plays a role in cytoskeleton dynamics by interacting with actin filaments \[[@CR48]\]. Since it is strongly expressed in the liver, *Mtss1* was identified as circadian gene with different phase of expression in rats and mice based on early microarray transcriptomic studies \[[@CR10]\]. Moreover, *Mtss1* was only candidate gene that displayed significantly different phase of expression between tissues. While the *Mtss1* gene promoter certainly binds E-box regulators (CLOCK/NPAS2 and BMAL1), RRE activator (ROR *α*) and D-box repressor (E4BP4), the evidence of regulation by the RRE repressors (REV-ERB *α*,*β*) was mixed between two studies \[[@CR16], [@CR21]\]. Another oncogene, proviral integration site 3 *Pim3* was expressed with consistent phase (average of CT15) across six tissues without being detected in either proteomic study. *Pim3* encodes a kinase that is upregulated in many cancer cell lines \[[@CR49]\] and downregulation of PIM3 retarted cell proliferation in human hepatoma cell lines \[[@CR50]\]. Further, *Pim3* appears to play a role in glucose homeostatis by downregulating insulin-secretion in response to glucose, thus making *Pim3*^−/−^ mice tolerant to glucose *in vivo*. In the circadian context, *Pim3* was identified as a light-induced immediate-early gene in the SCN \[[@CR51]\] making it important also in the function of master circadian clock consistent with the bioinformatic prediction that *Pim3* has a conserved CRE element its promoter \[[@CR10]\]. The promoter of *Pim3* binds D-box repressor (E4BP4) and the RRE-regulators (REV-ERBs and ROR *α*), but there is inconsistency in the binding of E-box TF (BMAL1) between the two studies. Diacylglycerol O-acyltransferase 2 *Dgat2* did not exhibit any cycling in protein levels, but showed transcript oscillations with an average phase of CT17 in six tissues. *Dgat2* is responsible for the synthesis of triglycerides from diacylglycerol. Moreover, *Dgat2* is directly regulated by the cardiomyocyte circadian clock and participates in the response of the heart to fatty acids \[[@CR52]\]. The E-box activators (CLOCK/NPAS2 and BMAL1) and RRE repressors (REV-ERBs), but not the D-box repressor (E4BP4) or RRE activator (ROR *α*), bind the *Dgat2* promoter. The choice of *Dgat2* is also supported by an independent RNAi study \[[@CR53]\] performed by Maier and colleagues (personal communication), where a significant one hour period lengthening was observed in U2OS cells in response to the gene knockdown. This RNAi phenotype led to the choice of *Dgat2* although it was not robust to the choice of weighting scheme (Table S1 in Additional file [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}). Next, we consider a protein phosphatase (PP) regulatory subunit 3B of PP1 *Ppp1r3b* that was a robust candidate gene. PP1R3B suppresses the glycogen phosphorylase activity of PP1 and enhanced its glycogen synthase activity. Although *Ppp1r3b* was expressed in a circadian manner in fewer tissues than the previous four genes, the knockdown of the gene displayed a significant long period phenotype (2.5 h lengthening) in an independent RNAi study \[[@CR53]\] on human U2OS cells. PP1, a known clock component \[[@CR37]\], affects the period of the mammalian circadian clock \[[@CR54], [@CR55]\] and is known to target PER1 \[[@CR56]\]. Nevertheless, none of the catalytic subunits of PP1 is transcriptionally circadian in any tissue. This might indeed be novel layer of the clock regulation by PP1 by means of a circadian regulatory subunit *Ppp1r3b*. Finally, Uridine phosphorylase 2 (*Upp2*) was a robust candidate gene in our meta-analysis. *Upp2* is a particularly interesting candidate, since it is an example of a circadian protein that is also a metabolic enzyme. Eckel-Mahan et al. \[[@CR40]\] showed that *Upp2* acted on two circadian metabolites (Uridine and Uracil) and thus is one of the few known common nodes between circadian transcriptome and circadian metabolome \[[@CR41], [@CR57]\]. While *Upp2* has been shown to be a clock output gene in the liver \[[@CR40]\], our meta-analysis revealed that *Upp2* was robustly circadian in the kidney too with the same phase as in the liver (∼CT10). Interestingly, in humans, *Upp2* is expressed more in the kidney than in the liver \[[@CR58]\]. Therefore, it might be interesting to study the circadian role of *Upp2* further, in addition to the known metabolic context in the liver. Conclusion {#Sec14} ========== We combined multiple high-throughput public data sources of circadian data to filter the shortlist of 1000 potential circadian genes from \[[@CR9]\] to obtain 11 novel robust candidate genes. In particular, we suggested *Por*, *Mtss1*, *Pim3*, *Dgat2*, *Ppp1r3b* and *Upp2* for further experimental studies as potential clock genes. These genes appear to have a role in either metabolism or cancer or stress response making them a potential link between the circadian clock and these physiological processes. We also showed from the different ChIP-seq data that phase regulation of transcription of circadian genes is driven by specific transcription factors in a combinatorial manner consistent across multiple tissues. Although we focused our discussion on the significant candidate genes, we have assigned scores based on our analysis for the all 1000 shortlisted genes that can serve as a starting point to integrate additional data sources as they or tools to integrate them (for e.g., to integrate metabolomics data \[[@CR40], [@CR41], [@CR57]\]) become available. In order to keep the scoring in the meta-analysis simple we used binary scoring of hits from various data sources. A Bayesian analysis might be performed in order to consistently combine final scores from \[[@CR9]\] for a better consolidated final ranking. Meta-analyses of the ever growing publicly available data targeted at different aspects of the regulatory network has the potential to aid functional network discovery in the circadian and other contexts and utilize these data to their fullest potential. Availability of data and materials {#Sec15} ================================== The data sets supporting the results of this article are listed in Additional file [4](#MOESM4){ref-type="media"}. Additional files {#Sec16} ================ Additional file 1**Complete score table from the meta-analysis for all the 1000 master list genes with individual hits of a gene within each data set.** (XLSX 98 kb) Additional file 2**Supplementary Tables.** **Table S1.** List of core circadian genes according to Anafi et al. \[[@CR9]\], Wallach et al. \[[@CR28]\] and Ukai and Ueda \[[@CR37]\] in the master list of 1000 genes and their scores based on our meta-analysis. The shaded genes were found among the 31 candidate genes by our meta-analysis. **Table S2.** List of candidate genes robust to choice of weighting scheme. **Table S3.** Highly significant candidate clock associated genes with the number tissues in which they are known to be expressed in a circadian manner. **Table S4.** Peak protein expression phase of different circadian transcription factors. (PDF 115 kb) Additional file 3**Supplementary Figures.** **Figure S1.** The distribution of promoter elements among the master list genes. **Figure S2.** Distribution of total scores for each gene in the 1000 gene-long master list. (PDF 31 kb) Additional file 4**Sources of publicly-available data used in the meta-analysis.** (PDF 48 kb) ChIP-seq : Chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing CT : Circadian time E-box : Enhancer box FDR : False discovery rate GLM : Generalized linear model PPI : Protein-protein interaction RNAi : Ribonucleic acid interference RRE : ROR response element SCN : Suprachiasmatic nucleus SILAC : Stable isotope labeling by amino acids in cell culture siRNA : small interference RNA TF : Transcription factor TTFL : Transcriptional-translational feedback loop ZT : Zeitgeber time **Competing interests** The authors declare that they have no competing interests. **Authors' contributions** BA and HH designed the study. AB performed the analysis. BA, AB and HH interpreted the results and BA wrote the paper. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. The authors thank Robert Lehmann for reanalysis of the *Nr1d1,Nr2d2* ChIP-seq data from \[[@CR16], [@CR21], [@CR22]\] and Bert Maier for sharing phenotypes for candidate genes from his circadian RNAi screen. BA, AB and HH acknowledge the support of BMBF (T-Sys, 0316164G), DFG (SPP InKomBio) and Bernstein Center for Computational Neuroscience Berlin (grant 01GQ1001C).

All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files. Introduction {#sec005} ============ Drug-induced liver injury can cause severe hepatotoxicity and even acute liver failure. Acetaminophen (APAP) overdose is the leading cause of life-threatening acute hepatotoxicity in humans and animals \[[@pone.0166856.ref001], [@pone.0166856.ref002]\]. Acetaminophen (*N*-acetyl-*p*-aminophenol) is eliminated majorly by conjugation with glucuronide or sulfate in hepatocytes at therapeutic dosages. The remaining APAP is metabolized by the cytochrome P450 system and convert into a highly toxic intermediate, N-acetyl-p-benzoquinone imine (NAPQI). NAPQI is depleted by conjugation with glutathione (GSH) and the complex is excreted mainly into bile \[[@pone.0166856.ref003]\]. However, at toxic doses of APAP, excessive NAPQI depletes the cellular storage of GSH and binds to cellular proteins covalently, resulting in mitochondrial dysfunction and DNA damage, which leads to hepatocyte necrosis and cell death \[[@pone.0166856.ref004], [@pone.0166856.ref005]\]. Upon damage to parenchymal hepatocytes, innate immunity participates in the progression and amplification of APAP-induced liver injury. The initiation is characterized by the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines by activated Kupffer cells (resident hepatic macrophages), leading to the signal propagation characterized by the facilitation of the adhesion and transmigration of neutrophils into the hepatic vasculature, which aggravates liver injury \[[@pone.0166856.ref006]\]. There is growing evidence that interleukin-17 (IL-17) plays a pivotal role in the recruitment of inflammatory cells to injury sites and is associated with a wide range of inflammatory disorders in both mice models and human studies \[[@pone.0166856.ref007], [@pone.0166856.ref008]\]. It has been shown to exacerbate inflammatory responses. T lymphocytes infiltrated into injured tissue rapidly and regulated neutrophil recruitment via their release of IL-17 during the course of inflammation \[[@pone.0166856.ref009], [@pone.0166856.ref010]\]. IL-17 can be produced from CD4+ αβ T cells (T helper 17, Th17), γδT cells, and NK cells. Recent studies demonstrated that γδT cells are a major and potent source of IL-17 and are thought to orchestrate innate and adaptive immune function \[[@pone.0166856.ref011]\]. IL-17-producing γδT cells can exacerbate autoimmune diseases \[[@pone.0166856.ref012]\]. In addition, neutrophil recruitment to the site of inflammation is mediated by γδT cells in a sepsis model \[[@pone.0166856.ref013]\]. Previous studies also showed that, in toxin-induced liver injury, there was a significant increase in IL-17 expression and a correlation between neutrophil infiltration and IL-17--secreting cells \[[@pone.0166856.ref014], [@pone.0166856.ref015]\]. Baicalin (5,6,7-trihydroxyflavone-7-beta-D-glucuronic acid, BA) is a major flavonoid compound isolated from Scutellariae radix, an important herb used in traditional medicine. Its safety has been clinically proven, and it possesses anti-allergic, antioxidant, and anti-inflammatory properties \[[@pone.0166856.ref016], [@pone.0166856.ref017]\]. Previous studies also reported that baicalin has hepatoprotective effects on liver injury models in mice \[[@pone.0166856.ref018], [@pone.0166856.ref019]\]. In addition, baicalin inhibits IL-17-mediated lymphocyte adhesion and downregulates joint inflammation \[[@pone.0166856.ref020]\]. However, the effect of baicalin administration in APAP-induced liver injury is not yet reported. Whether IL-17 plays any role in baicalin-related hepatoprotective function is unknown. Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate the role of the IL-17 signaling pathway in hepatoprotective effects of baicalin in a mouse model of APAP-induced liver injury. Materials and Methods {#sec006} ===================== Animals {#sec007} ------- Eight weeks male C57BL/6 (B6) mice were used for this study. All strains of mice were maintained in B6 background in these studies. The mice were purchased from BioLASCO Taiwan Co., Ltd. (Taipei, Taiwan). All animal experiments were performed according to the guidelines of the *Animal Welfare Act* and the *Guide for Care and Use of Laboratory Animals* from the National Institutes of Health. All procedures and protocols were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of Chang Gung Memorial Hospital. Experimental model and drug treatment {#sec008} ------------------------------------- All animals were housed in an environmentally controlled room, under pathogen-free conditions, with a 12-hour light and 12-hour dark cycle, and allowed free access to food and clean water during the experiments. Twenty-four male mice (24--27 g) were randomly divided into 4 groups (n = 6/group). APAP (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO, USA) was dissolved in normal saline at a concentration of 20 mg/mL. The mice received an intraperitoneal hepatotoxic injection of APAP (300 mg/kg) and the control group received an equal volume of normal saline. After 30 minutes of injection, the mice were intraperitoneally injected with BA (Sigma) at a concentration of 30 mg/kg or an equal volume of phosphate-buffered saline (PBS). Then mice were sacrificed after 16 hours of APAP exposure. In another experiment for oxidative stress, mice were sacrificed 2, 6, 16 and 24 hours after the APAP exposures. Furthermore, for experimental studies into liver regenerative outcome, mice were sacrificed at 16, 24, 48, 72, and 96 hours after APAP administration. At each time point, all animals were killed by cervical dislocation under isoflurane anesthesia. Blood samples were drawn from the vena cava into syringes, and livers were harvested for further analysis. Measurement of APAP-induced hepatotoxicity {#sec009} ------------------------------------------ Blood samples were obtained at the end of the experiment (16 hours treatment) and immediately centrifuged at 12000 *g* for 5 minutes. Serum levels of alanine aminotransferase (ALT) were measured to determine hepatic injury by using a Vitros DT60 II Chemistry System (Ortho-Clinical Diagnostics; Johnson & Johnson, New York, NY). All the procedures and sample processing were according to the manufacturer's manual. Measurement of liver myeloperoxidase (MPO) activity {#sec010} --------------------------------------------------- Myeloperoxidase is released from the neutrophils into the phagosome and extracellular space. It is now recognized as an inflammatory indicator. Liver tissues of mice were homogenized with a Tekmar tissue grinder and centrifuged at 15000 *g* for 15 minutes at 4°C. The pellet was resuspended in 50 mM KPO~4~ buffer, pH 6.0, with 0.5% hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide, incubated for 2 hours and sonicated by the sonicator (QSONICA Q700). The suspension was centrifuged at 15000 *g* for 15 minutes at 4°C. Then, the supernatant was transferred to phosphate buffer containing *o*-dianisidine hydrochloride (10 mg/mL), 0.3% hydrogen peroxide, and 50 mM KPO~4~, pH 6.0. The change in light absorbance was measured at 460 nm for a period of 5 minutes. Measurement of TNF-α, IL-6, and IL-17 levels {#sec011} -------------------------------------------- The liver tissues were homogenized and centrifuged at 12000 *g* for 10 minutes at 4°C. The supernatants were collected and analyzed for TNF-α, IL-6, and IL-17 expression using the eBiosciences ELISA Kit (San Diego, CA, USA) following the manufacturer's instructions. Briefly, the 96 well plates were precoated with primary antibodies and incubated with 50 ug/100 uL sample for 2 hours. After washing several times, biotinylated secondary antibodies were added for 1 hour. Then, after incubation with HRP substrate for 30 minutes, the absorbance was measured at 450 nm using TECAN infinite 200. Flow cytometric analysis {#sec012} ------------------------ Immunophenotyping detection was done by direct immunofluorescence using multicolor flow cytometry staining of isolated total leukocytes. Livers were harvested, passed through a 70-μm cell strainer, and leukocyte fractions were isolated via Percoll density gradient. Leukocytes were isolated from mice for analysis of the γδT cell population change upon APAP and BA treatment. Cells were washed and resuspended at 2 × 10^5^ cells/mL in PBS. Cellular surface was stained with PE--conjugated anti-mouse TCRγδ (eBioscience) for 1 hour. The fluorescence intensity was measured with a cytomics FC500 flow cytometer (Beckman Coulter, Fullerton, CA). A minimum of 8000 FACS events were recoeded for each sample. An excitation wavelength of 488 nm and an emission wavelength of 575±15 nm were used for detection of PE-stained cells. Analysis was performed with FlowJo software (Tree Star, Inc.). Lipid peroxidation assay {#sec013} ------------------------ We measured the generation of malondialdehyde (MDA) as the indicator of lipid peroxidation using a Bioxytech MDA-586 Kit (OxisResearch, Portland, OR, USA). Briefly, the supernatants of liver homogenate were mixed with probucol, *N*-methyl-2-phenylindole, and hydrochloric acid to produce a stable dye. After centrifugation, the absorbance of the clear supernatant was measured using a spectrometry at 586 nm. The concentration of MDA was plotted against a standard curve and expressed in nmole per milligram of wet tissue. Superoxide dismutase (SOD) assay {#sec014} -------------------------------- SOD activity was determined according to the manufacturer's instructions (Cayman Chemical Company, MI, USA). This assay utilizes a tetrazolium salt for the detection of superoxide radicals and converts tetrazolium salt to formazan. SOD decreases the concentration of superoxide radicals and thereby reduces the rate of formazan formation. Therefore, relative SOD activity, expressed as U/mg protein, is measured by inhibition of the rate of formazan dye formation. Histology {#sec015} --------- Livers were harvested, fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS pH 7.4, and embedded in paraffin. Tissue sections (5 μm) were subjected to standard hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining for light microscopy. To measure the necrotic area, tissue sections were viewed under a light microscope (Zeiss Axioskop). Photographs were taken and adjustment with a SPOT RT camera (software version 3.3; Diagnostic Instruments). The percent of necrosis area was evaluated from five microscopic views with necrosis compared with the entire field. Immunohistochemistry on liver tissue {#sec016} ------------------------------------ Livers were harvested, fixed in a commercial fixed buffer (fineFix), and embedded in paraffin. The paraffin blocks were sliced into 4-μm serial sections and de-paraffinized. Liver samples were blocked with blocking buffer for 30 minutes, and then incubated with a specific primary antibody against IL-17 overnight. After washing for 5 minutes twice, samples were incubated with biotinylated secondary antibodies for 1 hour. The peroxidase reaction was performed following the manufacturer's protocol (Millipore IHC select kit). The reaction times for all sections from experimental animals were identical. Additional liver sections were stained for detection of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) (Cell Signaling Technology, MA, USA). Positively stained hepatocytes were quantified by randomly selecting five high power fields. Western blotting assay {#sec017} ---------------------- Liver samples were obtained at each time points and the homogenate was made with ice-cold lysis buffer. The cell lysates were separated by 10% sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel (SDS-PAGE) and transferred to polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) membrane. After blocking with 5% fat-free milk solution, the membrane was incubated overnight at 4°C with anti-PCNA primary antibody (Cell Signaling Technology, MA, USA). After washing with horseradish peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody, proteins were detected using the enhanced chemiluminescence system. Statistical analysis {#sec018} -------------------- All data were expressed as mean ± SEM. Statistical calculations were performed with GraphPad Prism 5.0 Software (GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego, USA). The results were analyzed using unpaired t tests or one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with post-hoc Tukey multiple comparison tests. Differences were considered statistically significant between groups if *p* \< 0.05. Results {#sec019} ======= Effects of treatment with baicalin on serum ALT levels {#sec020} ------------------------------------------------------ Serum levels of ALT are shown in [Fig 1](#pone.0166856.g001){ref-type="fig"}. There was no significant difference in the serum ALT enzyme activity between control and BA-only treated groups. Serum ALT levels were significantly elevated in the group receiving a single dose APAP (300 mg/kg) when compared with the control group (5566.7 ± 764.2 vs. 26.8 ± 5.5 U/L, *p* \< 0.05), which confirmed the hepatotoxicity of APAP overdose. After 30 minutes of APAP administration, treatment with BA (30 mg/kg) markedly decreased serum ALT levels. Serum ALT level was significantly attenuated in BA treatment group compared with the APAP-only group (798.7 ± 233.9 vs. 5566.7 ± 764.2 U/L, *p \<* 0.05). {#pone.0166856.g001} Effects of treatment with baicalin on hepatic MPO activity {#sec021} ---------------------------------------------------------- Liver MPO activity is a marker of inflammatory response and neutrophil accumulation. Hepatic expression of MPO is shown in [Fig 2](#pone.0166856.g002){ref-type="fig"}. There was no significant difference between control and BA-only treated groups. It was significantly elevated in the group receiving a single dose of APAP (300 mg/kg) when compared with the control animals (9.0849 ± 0.9455 vs. 2.0546 ± 0.1999 \#x00B1;OD460/g/min, *p* \< 0.05). After 30 minutes of APAP administration, treatment with BA (30 mg/kg) attenuated hepatic MPO levels. Hepatic MPO activity was significantly decreased in BA treatment group compared with the APAP-only group (3.3111 ± 0.3534 vs. 9.0849 ± 0.9455 ±OD460/g/min, *p \<* 0.05). {#pone.0166856.g002} Effects of treatment with baicalin on hepatic TNF-α and IL-6 levels {#sec022} ------------------------------------------------------------------- As shown in [Fig 3](#pone.0166856.g003){ref-type="fig"}, we investigated the levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines including TNF-α and IL-6, after APAP-induced liver injury. The results demonstrated no significant difference in hepatic TNF-α and IL-6 levels between the control and BA-only treated groups. In the APAP group, the concentrations of TNF-α and IL-6 were significantly increased after single dose administration of APAP (300 mg/kg) for 16 hours compared with the control group (466.2 ± 22.8 vs. 138.3 ± 12.0 pg/100μg protein, *p \<* 0.05; 491.6 ± 27.9 vs. 221.2 ± 15.6 pg/100μg protein, *p \<* 0.05, respectively). However, treatment with BA (30 mg/kg) after 30 minutes of APAP overdose significantly decreased elevated hepatic TNF-α and IL-6 levels compared with the APAP alone treated group (228.9 ± 17.1 vs. 466.2 ± 22.8 pg/100 μg protein, *p \<* 0.05; 322.2 ± 18.8 vs. 491.6 ± 27.9 pg/100μg protein, *p \<* 0.05, respectively). {#pone.0166856.g003} Effects of treatment with baicalin on hepatic IL-17 levels {#sec023} ---------------------------------------------------------- As shown in [Fig 4](#pone.0166856.g004){ref-type="fig"}, we investigated the immunoregulatory activity of IL-17. The results demonstrated no significant difference in hepatic IL-17 expression between the control and BA-only treated groups. In the APAP group, the levels of IL-17 were significantly increased after single dose administration of APAP (300 mg/kg) for 16 hours compared with the control group (1056.4 ± 188.6 vs. 404.5 ± 68.1 pg/50 μg protein, *p \<* 0.05). However, treatment with BA (30 mg/kg) after 30 minutes of APAP overdose markedly decreased elevated hepatic IL-17 level compared with the APAP alone treated group (507.6 ± 81.9 vs. 1056.4 ± 188.6 pg/50 μg protein, *p \<* 0.05). The IL-17 level in the APAP plus BA treated group had nearly returned to baseline values compared with the control group. {#pone.0166856.g004} Effects of treatment with baicalin on immunostaining for IL-17 {#sec024} -------------------------------------------------------------- Immunohistochemistry staining of liver tissue from the control mice displayed normal hepatic architecture as shown in [Fig 5A](#pone.0166856.g005){ref-type="fig"}. Immunohistochemical staining showed increased IL-17 staining around the area of necrosis in the liver parenchyma in APAP-only treated group compared to the APAP plus BA treated group ([Fig 5C and 5D](#pone.0166856.g005){ref-type="fig"}). The results suggested that BA treatment after APAP injection significantly decreased IL-17 expression around the inflammatory area of hepatotoxicity in the liver. Immunofluorescence staining showed similar trends in the liver parenchyma ([S1 Fig](#pone.0166856.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}.). {#pone.0166856.g005} Effects of treatment with baicalin on γδT cell recruitment {#sec025} ---------------------------------------------------------- IL-17 is produced by specific γδT cells, which induce pro-inflammatory protein expression and recruit neutrophils. Flow cytometric features and quantitative analysis of γδT cells are shown in [Fig 6A and 6B](#pone.0166856.g006){ref-type="fig"}. There were no significant differences in hepatic γδT cell accumulations between the control and BA-only treated groups. The results of flow cytometry analysis demonstrated that the infiltration of γδT cell was significantly increased in the APAP group compared with the control group after single dose of APAP administration (9.7 ± 2.3 vs. 1.6 ± 0.4, *p \<* 0.05). However, BA treatment (30 mg/kg) after 30 minutes of APAP administration significantly declined hepatic γδT cell recruitment. Hepatic γδT cell expression was significantly decreased in APAP plus BA treated group compared with the APAP-only group (2.5 ± 0.6 vs. 9.7 ± 2.3, *p \<* 0.05). {#pone.0166856.g006} Effects of treatment with baicalin on MDA and SOD activities {#sec026} ------------------------------------------------------------ APAP overdose causes the production of oxidative stress. We measured MDA levels as lipid peroxidation product ([Fig 7A](#pone.0166856.g007){ref-type="fig"}). The concentration of MDA was significantly increased at each time points in APAP-only treated group and at 16 h in APAP plus BA treated group when compared with their control group (0 hour). In addition, there were significant differences between the 2 groups at 16 hours after APAP exposure (*p* = 0.029). Next, we determined the antioxidant activity of SOD ([Fig 7B](#pone.0166856.g007){ref-type="fig"}). APAP administration significantly diminished SOD activities compared with the control group. However, at 6 hours after APAP exposure in BA treatment group, there was significantly alleviated APAP-induced SOD depletion (*p* = 0.002). {#pone.0166856.g007} Effects of treatment with baicalin on histology {#sec027} ----------------------------------------------- We compared liver injury of two groups over the time course of 16 to 96 hours by histopathological analysis ([Fig 8A and 8B](#pone.0166856.g008){ref-type="fig"}). Liver injury was characterized by centrilobular necrosis and fatty infiltration as evidenced in H&E staining. After APAP administration, liver injury markedly increased and peaked at 16 hours. There were significantly increased necrotic areas at 16, 24, and 48 hours in APAP-only group compared with the APAP plus BA treated group. The overall time course of hepatic injury showed similar trend in both groups and gradual recovery of injury after 48 hours. {#pone.0166856.g008} Effects of treatment with baicalin in liver regeneration {#sec028} -------------------------------------------------------- PCNA is a cell regeneration marker that assists in DNA replication. We compared liver regeneration of two groups over the time course of 16 to 96 hours and detected PCNA expression by immunohistochemistry staining of liver tissue as shown in [Fig 9A](#pone.0166856.g009){ref-type="fig"}. Quantitative analysis of all PCNA-positive cells ([Fig 9B](#pone.0166856.g009){ref-type="fig"}) showed that there were obviously increased proliferation responses from 24 hours after APAP exposure in both groups. The total numbers of PCNA-positive cells remain progressively elevated and peaked at 48 hours, and gradually decreased at 72 and 96 hours. Interestingly, there were significantly more cell proliferations observed at 24 and 48 hours in BA-treated group compared with the APAP-only group. Hepatic PCNA protein expressions by western blot analysis are shown in [Fig 9C](#pone.0166856.g009){ref-type="fig"}. The results further corroborated the data from immunohistochemical staining. {#pone.0166856.g009} Discussion {#sec029} ========== Acetaminophen is a widely used analgesic and antipyretic drug in clinical practice. However, its overdose can induce severe liver injury and even liver failure. In the present study, the protective effects of baicalin, a flavonoid compound purified from Scutellariae radix, on APAP-induced liver injury in a mouse model were studied. After APAP administration for 16 hours to induce liver injury, increases in serum ALT concentrations, hepatic MPO activity, pro-inflammatory cytokines, and oxidative stress parameters were observed. Treatment with baicalin after 30 minutes of APAP administration significantly displayed attenuated increase in these hepatic parameters. In addition, this protective effect may correlate with the attenuation of hepatic IL-17 expression and IL-17-producing γδT cells recruitment. These findings collectively imply that IL-17 contributes to the hepatoprotective effects of baicalin. Our results demonstrated that baicalin alleviated the process of inflammation in APAP-induced liver injury. APAP hepatotoxicity is characterized by aseptic inflammation, and innate immune mechanisms play a critical role in amplifying inflammatory responses. Excessive electrophilic NAPQI are reported to cause direct hepatocyte death, and Kupffer cells were induced in concert with subsequent activation of inflammatory cytokines and infiltration of leukocytes into the liver \[[@pone.0166856.ref021]\]. TNF-α and IL-6 play an important role in the regulation of acute inflammatory response \[[@pone.0166856.ref022]\]. Recent studies reported that neutrophils mediated direct injury and amplified hepatocytes death during APAP-induced acute liver failure \[[@pone.0166856.ref023]\]. The induction of TNF-α and IL-6, and increased neutrophil accumulation have also been well described in some drug-induced or ischemia-reperfusion liver injury models \[[@pone.0166856.ref024], [@pone.0166856.ref025]\]. Therefore, cytokines expression and neutrophil infiltration are central mediators of inflammation. On the other hand, previous evidence showed that baicalin inhibited inflammatory responses via down-regulation of cytokines in an animal model with myocardial ischemic injury \[[@pone.0166856.ref026]\]. Another report also showed that baicalin suppressed the production of cytokines and leukocyte migration in *in vitro* and *in vivo* studies \[[@pone.0166856.ref027]\]. In our study, early treatment with baicalin after APAP overdose could effectively decrease hepatic cytokine levels accompanied by MPO activity. It indicated that baicalin treatment after APAP-induced liver injury attenuated inflammatory mediators and neutrophil infiltration. NAPQI depletes the cellular storage of GSH and the formation of free radicals results in APAP toxicity \[[@pone.0166856.ref004], [@pone.0166856.ref005]\]. Previous studies have demonstrated that baicalin exerts hepatoprotective effects via inhibiting oxidative stress in alcohol-induced hepatotocixity \[[@pone.0166856.ref028]\]. Another study also showed that baicalin could attenuate cerebral ischemia/reperfusion injury by anti-oxidative pathway \[[@pone.0166856.ref029]\]. Our results confirmed that APAP overdose could increase MDA level and reduce SOD activity, indicating accumulation of reactive oxygen species and production of lipid peroxidation. These APAP-induced changes in MDA level and SOD activity was reduced in mice treated with baicalin, suggesting that baicalin directly contributed to decrease oxidative stress. Our data showed that the expression of IL-17 was markedly increased after APAP overdose. Recently, there is growing evidence that IL-17 plays an important role in enhancing immune responses in human liver diseases and in autoimmunity \[[@pone.0166856.ref007], [@pone.0166856.ref008]\]. In human alcoholic liver disease, patients had higher plasma IL-17 levels compared with healthy subjects \[[@pone.0166856.ref014]\]. In halothane-induced liver injury, the increases in plasma IL-17 levels and neutrophil infiltration were also observed. Inhibition of the IL-17 pathway might offer protection from the hepatotoxic effect \[[@pone.0166856.ref015]\]. Furthermore, it has been reported that IL-17 induced the expression of inflammation-associated genes including chemokines and C-reactive protein in hepatocytes \[[@pone.0166856.ref030]\]. A previous study also showed that IL-17 stimulated expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines/chemokines produced by liver nonparenchymal cells including monocytes, Kupffer cells, biliary epithelial cells, and stellate cells, which contributed to liver inflammation \[[@pone.0166856.ref031]\]. In addition, IL-17 exerts effects on neutrophils. During ischemia-reperfusion injury, T lymphocytes regulated hepatic neutrophil recruitment through the production of IL-17 \[[@pone.0166856.ref032]\]. IL-17 can regulate inflammation through coordinated expression of many inflammatory cytokines/chemokines in neutrophil activation and infiltration. It induced the release of neutrophil-mobilizing cytokine, including IL-6 and IL-8, to site of infection \[[@pone.0166856.ref033]\]. It was also found to mediate neutrophil chemotaxis by increasing the expression of the chemokine macrophage inflammatory protein 2 (MIP-2) in a model of peritoneal inflammation \[[@pone.0166856.ref034]\]. These data suggested an important role of IL-17 via its effects on neutrophils in immune and inflammatory responses. A recent study has demonstrated that baicalin reduced joint inflammatory injury caused by IL-17 and blocked IL-17-mediated expression of adhesion molecules in murine experimental arthritis \[[@pone.0166856.ref020]\]. Our results showed that baicalin decreased the expression of hepatic IL-17 levels and neutrophil recruitment. It implies that baicalin attenuated inflammatory response through reduced production of IL-17 in APAP-induced liver injury. IL-17 has shown to be involved in the induction and mediation of inflammatory responses. It can be produced by many types of cells including Th17, γδT, and NK cells. Th17 lymphocytes represent a newly identified T helper cell lineage and have a pro-inflammatory role in neutrophilic inflammation by IL-17 production. However, further recent studies demonstrated that γδT cells are a major and potent source of IL-17 and play an important role link between innate and adaptive immune functions \[[@pone.0166856.ref011]\]. In some previous studies, γδT cells have been shown to be more dominant and produced higher amounts of IL-17 than Th17 cells \[[@pone.0166856.ref035], [@pone.0166856.ref036]\]. Therefore, in our reports, we examined γδT cells as major IL-17-producing cells. During the course of inflammatory responses, γδT cells have innate cell-like characters that allow earlier activation and more rapid production of IL-17 than Th17 \[[@pone.0166856.ref037]\]. Even γδT cells can secrete IL-17and IL-21, which promote further IL-17 production by Th17 cells in an animal model of central nervous system autoimmunity \[[@pone.0166856.ref038]\]. Another study also showed that antibody depletion of γδT cells led to decreased IL-17 production and neutrophil infiltration after bacterial infection \[[@pone.0166856.ref039]\]. In human viral hepatitis, patients display higher numbers of γδT cells in the liver when compared to healthy subjects \[[@pone.0166856.ref040]\]. The functional role of γδT cells seemed to be associated with the progression of organ injury \[[@pone.0166856.ref041], [@pone.0166856.ref042]\]. Our results showed that the accumulation of γδT cells is increased following APAP-induced liver injury than in the control group. Treatment with baicalin decreased the infiltration of γδT cells in liver tissues. These data suggested that baicalin administration attenuated the expansion of these IL-17-producing T cells. Baicalin has been used in traditional herb medicine for many years due to its anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties. Previous studies showed that baicalin down-regulates the function of macrophages and inhibits the production of inflammatory mediators released by macrophages in a rat model \[[@pone.0166856.ref043]\]. The anti-inflammation effect of baicalin on ulcerative colitis was associated with the inhibition of TLR4/NF-κB signaling pathway \[[@pone.0166856.ref044]\]. A recent study found that the TLR4-dependent pathway in macrophages mediates the generation of IL-17-producing γδT cells and subsequent inflammation in an APAP-induced liver inflammation model \[[@pone.0166856.ref045]\]. In our study, we demonstrated that baicalin treatment effectively reduced liver injury after APAP overdose by attenuation of hepatic γδT cells and IL-17 expression. Collectively, this implied that baicalin elicits protective effects in APAP-induced liver injury through the cascading of macrophages and γδT cells. In addition, we detected significant differences in PCNA expression in the liver tissues and confirmed the effects of baicalin on liver cell regeneration. Further studies are needed to investigate the effects of baicalin on this regenerative pathway of liver. Conclusions {#sec030} =========== Our study showed that baicalin treatment could suppress accumulation of γδT cells and exert hepatoprotective effects via attenuation of IL-17-mediated inflammation. It could effectively decrease APAP-induced liver injury in part by inhibition of hepatic IL-17 expression and its effectors, including inflammatory markers and neutrophil infiltration. Taken together, these findings indicated that baicalin may potentially develop as a hepatoprotective drug and can be considered as a promising therapeutic agent for APAP-induced liver injury in humans. Further studies regarding its clinical applications are required to be explored. Supporting Information {#sec031} ====================== ###### Effects of treatment with baicalin on immunofluorescence evidence of IL-17 expression in APAP-induced liver injury. The effects of baicalin on IL-17 expression in liver tissues are demonstrated by immunofluorescence analysis. Mice received (A) control (normal saline), (B) BA (30 mg/kg) alone, (C) APAP (300 mg/kg) alone, or (D) BA (30 mg/kg) after 30 minutes of APAP injection, and were killed 16 hours after treatment for immunofluorescence staining. (DAPI: blue; IL-17: red; Macrophage: green) Representative images were chosen from each group (400× magnification). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. This work was supported in part by grants from the National Science Council (NSC103-2314-B-182-046-MY2) and Chang Gung Memorial Hospital (CMRPG3E1542 and CMRPG3F1011) to Fu-Chao Liu and Chang Gung Memorial Hospital (CMRPG3B1391) to Chia-Chih Liao. [^1]: **Competing Interests:**The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. [^2]: **Conceptualization:** CCL FCL.**Formal analysis:** CCL YJD HCL FCL.**Funding acquisition:** CCL FCL.**Investigation:** CCL FCL.**Methodology:** CCL FCL.**Project administration:** CCL FCL.**Resources:** YJD JTL AHC.**Writing -- original draft:** CCL YJD FCL.**Writing -- review & editing:** CCL YJD FCL.

\subsection{Action density} A study of the BCNW formula with respect to the action density (\ref{actdens}) can only be performed with the standard action (in case of the constraint action all contributing configurations have action $S_{\rm constraint}=0$). Figure \ref{actden2dO3} shows the values of $s$ and $s_{|Q|}$, $|Q| \leq 2$ in the range $L=32 \dots 84$. The total expectation value $s$ is stable within $0.0003$ for $L \geq 56$, while the topologically constrained results differ by ${\cal O}(10^{-3})$ even at $L=84$. Therefore $L = 56 \dots 84$ is a regime of moderate volumes, which is suitable for testing the BCNW formula. \begin{figure}[h!] \begin{center} \vspace*{-3mm} \includegraphics[width=0.53\textwidth,angle=270]{actden2dO3stan.eps} \vspace*{-1mm} \caption{The action density in the 2d O(3) model, on $L \times L$ lattices with the standard lattice action, in the sectors with topological charge $|Q| = 0$, $1$, $2$, and summed over all sectors ({\it i.e.}\ all configurations used for the numerical measurements). The latter stabilizes to $0.3$ permille for $L \geq 56$.} \vspace*{-3mm} \label{actden2dO3} \end{center} \end{figure} The fitting results, for $|Q| \leq 2$ and various ranges of $L$ are listed in Table \ref{actden2dO3tab}. The fits do not match the BCNW formula perfectly, as expected, since the latter is an approximation, and the input data have very small statistical errors of ${\cal O} (10^{-5})$.\footnote{Of course, the ratio $\chi^{2}/$d.o.f.\ could be reduced by adding more terms to the $1/V$-expansion. However, in Table \ref{2dO3tab} we are going to demonstrate that this does not improve the results for the observable and for $\chi_{\rm t}$, in qualitative agreement with Section 3.} Nevertheless, the value of $s$ is obtained correctly up to a high precision of $0.2$ permille. On the other hand, the determination of the topological susceptibility is less successful; only the fit with $L = 76$ and $84$ yields a result, which is correct within the errors. \begin{table}[ht!] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c||l|l|c|} \hline fitting range in $L$ & \multicolumn{1}{|c|}{$s$} & \multicolumn{1}{|c|}{$\chi_{\rm t}$} & $\chi^{2}/$d.o.f. \\ \hline 56 --- 64 & 1.1955(2) & 0.0035(5) & 2.66 \\ 56 --- 76 & 1.19538(6) & 0.0031(3) & 2.66 \\ 56 --- 84 & 1.19536(5) & 0.0030(3) & 2.63 \\ \hline 64 --- 76 & 1.19532(7) & 0.0031(3) & 2.65 \\ 64 --- 84 & 1.19531(5) & 0.0031(3) & 2.58 \\ 76 --- 84 & 1.1953(1) & 0.0026(3) & 2.60 \\ \hline \hline $L=84$, all sectors & 1.195089(5) & 0.002323(3) & \\ \hline \end{tabular} \caption{Fitting results for the action density $s$ and the topological susceptibility $\chi_{\rm t}$ in the 2d O(3) model. The input data in fixed topological sectors are plotted in Figure \ref{actden2dO3}.} \label{actden2dO3tab} \end{center} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{table} \subsection{Magnetic susceptibility and correlation length} We proceed to the constraint action (\ref{act2dO3}) where our choice of $\delta$ yields a shorter correlation length, which favors the stabilization of observables (measured in all sectors) at smaller $L$. This can be seen in Figure \ref{2dO3constraint}, which shows the magnetic susceptibility $\chi_{\rm m}$, analogous to eq.\ (\ref{magsus}) (again the disconnected part vanishes due to rotational symmetry), and the correlation length $\xi$. Stabilization within the errors is attained for $\chi_{\rm m}$ at $L\geq 48$ (with errors around $0.2$ permille), and for $\xi$ already at $L \geq 16$ (with errors of ${\cal O}(1) \, \%$). On the other hand, for $L = 128$ the $\chi_{{\rm m},|Q|}$-values are not distinguished anymore from $\chi_{\rm m}$ beyond the errors, and the same happens for $\xi_{|Q|}$ already at $L=96$. Finally, we have to exclude $L=16$, because here we only obtain $\langle Q^{2} \rangle \simeq 0.63$, hence its inverse is not suitable as an expansion parameter. This singles out the regime of moderate volumes, where the BCNW formula is appropriate, to the range $L= 48 \dots 96$ for $\chi_{\rm m}$, and $L= 32 \dots 64$ for $\xi$. \begin{figure}[h!] \begin{center} \includegraphics[width=0.53\textwidth,angle=270]{magsus2dO3.eps} \includegraphics[width=0.53\textwidth,angle=270]{xi2dO3b.eps} \vspace*{-2.5mm} \caption{Results for the magnetic susceptibility (above) and for the correlation length (below) in the 2d O(3) model, with the constraint action at $\delta = 0.55 \, \pi$. The windows, which are suitable for applications of the BCNW formula, are given by $L=48 \dots 96$ for $\chi_{\rm m}$, and by $L=32 \dots 64$ for $\xi$.} \vspace*{-5mm} \label{2dO3constraint} \end{center} \end{figure} Our fitting results are given in Table \ref{2dO3tab}. In the case of $\chi_{\rm m}$ we probe the BCNW formula (\ref{approx2}) (with its incomplete second order, ${\cal O}(1/V^{2})$), as well as its extensions to the second order plus an incomplete third order as given in formula (\ref{approx3}). For the latter option, the approximation is more precise, but an additional free parameter $\bar c$ hampers the fits. \begin{table}[ht!] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c||c|c||c|} \hline & fitting & BCNW & incomplete & all sectors \\ & range & formula & 3rd order & at $L_{\rm max}$ \\ \hline \hline $\chi_{\rm m}$ & \multirow{2}{*}{48 --- 64} & 36.56(4) & 36.64(11) & 36.590(9) \\ $\chi_{\rm t}$ & & 0.0026(2) & 0.0031(6) & 0.0027935(14) \\ \hline $\chi_{\rm m}$ & \multirow{2}{*}{48 --- 96} & 36.58(3) & 36.64(7) & 36.616(9) \\ $\chi_{\rm t}$ & & 0.0026(2) & 0.0032(6) & 0.0027942(11) \\ \hline $\xi$ & \multirow{2}{*}{32 --- 64} & 3.56(2) & 3.58(4) & 3.59(2) \\ $\chi_{\rm t}$ & & 0.0027(3) & 0.0034(14) & 0.0027935(14) \\ \hline \end{tabular} \caption{Fitting results based on data for $\chi_{\rm m}$ and for $\xi$ in the 2d O(3) model, in fitting ranges $L_{\rm min}$ --- $L_{\rm max}$, and sectors with $|Q| \leq 2$. In the case of $\chi_{\rm m}$, with the optimal range, we show results for the BCNW approximation (\ref{approx2}), as well as its extension to the complete second order plus one term of ${\cal O}(1/V^{3})$, according to formula (\ref{approx3}).} \label{2dO3tab} \end{center} \vspace*{-3mm} \end{table} For both fitting versions, the results for $\chi_{\rm m}$ and $\chi_{\rm t}$ are compatible with the directly measured values. We observe, however, that the inclusion of terms beyond the BCNW formula enhances the uncertainty (due to the additional fitting parameter). The uncertainty is on the permille level for $\chi_{\rm m}$, but large for $\chi_{\rm t}$, in particular with extra terms. (Without these terms it is around $ 8 \, \%$.) It turns out to be non-profitable to extend the approximation beyond the BCNW formula. The simple BCNW approximation is also superior for the fits with respect to $\xi$, where the additional terms drastically increase the uncertainty. The results in Table \ref{2dO3tab} are correct, within percent level for $\xi$, but again with a large uncertainty of the $\chi_{\rm t}$-value. We add that we also tried fits to the complete second order approximation, without the third order term that appears in formula (\ref{approx3}). However, this scenario (which also involves the fitting parameter $\bar c$) is clearly unfavorable: in this case, it often happens that the least-square fit even fails to converge to values in the correct magnitude. To conclude, this study suggests that the simple BCNW formula, with only three free parameters, is in fact optimal for extracting values for the considered observable, and for $\chi_{\rm t}$. Moreover, we confirm that the method works best for the determination of the observable; it is less successful with respect to the determination of $\chi_{\rm t}$. \section{Low temperature expansion of the magnetic susceptibility of the quantum rotor} Our point of departure is eq.\ (\ref{intchim}) for the magnetic susceptibility of the quantum rotor at fixed topology\footnote{Since this entire appendix refers to continuous Euclidean time, we skip for simplicity the subscripts of $\beta_{\rm cont}$ and $L_{\rm cont}$.} \begin{equation} \chi_{{\rm m},Q} = \int_{0}^{L/2} dt \, e^{( t^{2}/L - t)/(2 \beta)} \left[ e^{2 \pi {\rm i} Qt/L} + e^{-2 \pi {\rm i} Qt/L} \right] \ . \end{equation} By completing the squares in each term, and defining \begin{equation} z_{0} = \sqrt{\frac{L}{8 \beta}} \ \Big( 1 + \frac{4 \pi {\rm i} Q \beta}{L} \Big) \end{equation} we obtain \begin{eqnarray} \chi_{{\rm m},Q} &=& \sqrt{2 \beta L} \ e^{\frac{2 \pi^{2} \beta Q^{2}}{L} - \frac{L}{8 \beta}} (-1)^{Q} \Big[ \int_{-z_{0}}^{-\pi {\rm i} Q \sqrt{2\beta /L}} dt \, e^{t^{2}} + \int_{-z_{0}^{*}}^{\pi {\rm i} Q \sqrt{2\beta /L}} dt \, e^{t^{2}} \Big] \nonumber \\ &=& \sqrt{\frac{\pi \beta L}{2}} \ e^{\frac{2 \pi^{2} \beta Q^{2}}{L} - \frac{L}{8 \beta}} (-1)^{Q} \Big[ {\rm erfi}(z_{0}) + {\rm erfi}(z_{0}^{*}) \Big] \nonumber \\ &=& \sqrt{8 \beta L} \ {\rm Re} \ D(z_{0}) \ . \eea We have used two properties of the imaginary error function, ${\rm erfi}(z) = - {\rm erfi}(-z)$ and ${\rm erfi}(z^{*}) = ({\rm erfi}(z))^{*}$, and in the last step we inserted Dawson's function \begin{equation} D(z) = \frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{2} \, e^{-z^{2}} \, {\rm erfi}(z) = e^{-z^{2}} \int_{0}^{z} dt \, e^{t^{2}} \ . \end{equation} We are interested in the case $L \gg \beta$ where $| {\rm arg} \, ({\rm i} z_{0}) | \approx \frac{\pi}{2} < \frac{3 \pi}{4}$, so we can apply the asymptotic expansion \cite{AbSteg} \begin{equation} D(z_{0}) = \frac{1}{2z_{0}} \sum_{n \geq 0} \frac{(2n-1)!!}{(2 z_{0}^{2})^{n}} = \frac{1}{2z_{0}} \Big( 1 + \frac{1}{2 z^{2}_{0}} + \frac{3}{4 z^{4}_{0}} + \frac{15}{8 z^{6}_{0}} + {\cal O} (|z_{0}|^{-8}) \Big) \ . \end{equation} If we expand \begin{equation} \chi_{{\rm m},Q} \simeq 4 \beta \ {\rm Re} \ \Big[ \frac{1}{1 + 4 \pi {\rm i} Q \beta /L} \ \Big( 1 + \frac{1}{2 z^{2}_{0}} + \frac{3}{4 z^{4}_{0}} + \frac{15}{8 z^{6}_{0}} \Big) \Big] \end{equation} to ${\cal O} ((\beta/L)^{3})$, and insert the infinite volume limit $\chi_{\rm m} = 4 \beta$, we arrive at \begin{equation} \label{chiexpeand} \chi_{{\rm m},Q} = \chi_{\rm m} + \beta \left[ \frac{16 \beta}{L} + \frac{64 \beta^{2}}{L^{2}} \Big( 3 - (\pi Q)^{2} \Big) + \frac{768 \beta^{3}}{L^{3}} \Big( 5 - 2 (\pi Q)^{2} \Big) + {\cal O} \Big( (\frac{\beta}{L})^{4} \Big) \right] \ . \ \end{equation} By substituting $\chi_{\rm t} = \frac{1}{4 \pi^{2} \beta}$ (which only has exponentially suppressed finite size effects \cite{slab}), we confirm to each order given in eq.\ (\ref{chiexpeand}) the expansion that we anticipated in eq.\ (\ref{BCNWchim}); it is not altered by the truncation of the Gauss integrals. \subsection{Action density} We first consider the action density \begin{equation} \label{actdens} s = \langle S \rangle /V \ . \end{equation} This quantity is not directly physical, but it is suitable for testing the BCNW method, based on topologically restricted expectation values $s_{|Q|} = \langle S \rangle_{|Q|}/V$. Moreover, the corresponding fits provide a value for $\chi_{\rm t}$, which {\em is} physical. Figure \ref{actden1dO2} shows the action density for both lattice actions under consideration, measured at fixed $|Q| = 0 \dots 4$, and by including all sectors (the way the simulation samples them). The latter is constant to high accuracy for $L=150 \dots 400$, which confirms that ordinary finite size effects are negligible. On the other hand, at fixed $|Q|$ we see deviations far beyond the statistical errors, depending on $L$ and $|Q|$, so this setting is appropriate for the application of the BCNW method. \begin{figure}[h!] \begin{center} \hspace*{-6mm} \includegraphics[width=0.375\textwidth,angle=270]{actdenStan.eps} \hspace*{-8mm} \includegraphics[width=0.375\textwidth,angle=270]{actdenMant.eps} \vspace*{-4mm} \caption{The action density in the 1d O(2) model at $\beta =4$ on lattices of size $L=150 \dots 400$, with the standard action (left) and the Manton action (right). We show $s$ measured in all sectors (which is practically constant in this range of $L$), as well as the values of $s_{|Q|}$ in the sectors $|Q|= 0 \dots 4$, which strongly depend on $|Q|$ and $V$.} \vspace*{-3mm} \label{actden1dO2} \end{center} \end{figure} Table \ref{actden1dO2tab} presents our results obtained by least-square fits to the BCNW approximation (\ref{approx2}): we use data for $s_{|Q|}$ in all six volumes, and in the topological sectors $|Q|=0 \dots |Q|_{\rm max}$, where $|Q|_{\rm max}$ varies from 1 to 4. Similar results are obtained when we only involve the larger volumes, such as $L=250 \dots 400$ or $300 \dots 400$. \begin{table}[ht!] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c||c|c||c|c|} \hline & \multicolumn{2}{|c||}{standard action} & \multicolumn{2}{|c|}{Manton action} \\ \hline $|Q|_{\rm max}$ & $s$ & $\chi_{\rm t}$ & $s$ & $\chi_{\rm t}$ \\ \hline 1 & 0.545910(1) & 0.007552(4) & 0.500073(3) & 0.006135(9) \\ 2 & 0.545910(1) & 0.007555(3) & 0.500072(2) & 0.006132(8) \\ 3 & 0.545912(2) & 0.007559(5) & 0.500072(2) & 0.006132(8) \\ 4 & 0.545912(2) & 0.007559(5) & 0.500072(2) & 0.006131(7) \\ \hline all & 0.545910(1) & 0.007554\hspace*{5mm} & 0.500041(1) & 0.006333~~~~ \\ \hline \end{tabular} \caption{Results based on fits to the formula (\ref{approx2}), with input data for the action density in the range $L= 150 \dots 400$ and $|Q| \leq |Q|_{\rm max}$. The last line displays $s$ measured in all sectors at $L=400$, and the analytic value of $\chi_{\rm t}$ at $L=\infty$.} \label{actden1dO2tab} \end{center} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{table} Regarding the value of $s$, the method works perfectly (to the given precision) for the standard action, and up to a deviation of about $0.006 \, \%$ for the Manton action. For the standard action the fits yield values for $\chi_{\rm t}$, which are again compatible with the correct value, with uncertainties around $0.05 \, \%$. In case of the Manton action a systematic discrepancy of $3 \, \%$ is observed, as a consequence of the approximations in formula (\ref{approx2}). In summary, this first numerical experiment can be considered a success of the BCNW method. The good results for $s$ are highly non-trivial in view of the sizable differences in the individual sectors (shown in Figure \ref{actden1dO2}), and exactly these differences give rise to quite good estimates for $\chi_{\rm t}$. As a generic property, it is easy to measure $s_{|Q|}$ accurately (in gauge theories it is given by the mean plaquette value), so it is motivated to estimate $\chi_{\rm t}$ in this way also in higher dimensional models. \subsection{Magnetic susceptibility} In this model, the correlation function in a fixed sector of topological charge $Q$ has a peculiar form. For a continuous time variable $t$ it reads \cite{Arthur14} \begin{eqnarray} \label{corrfun} \langle \vec e (0) \cdot \vec e (t) \rangle_{Q} &=& \frac{1}{2} \exp \Big( - \frac{t (L_{\rm cont}-t)}{2 \beta_{\rm cont} L_{\rm cont}} \Big) \cos \Big( \frac{2 \pi Qt}{L_{\rm cont}} \Big) \ , \\ {\rm with} && \vec e (t) = \left( \begin{array}{c} \cos \varphi (t) \\ \sin \varphi (t) \end{array} \right) \ . \nonumber \eea The unusual last factor in eq.\ (\ref{corrfun}) obstructs the determination of a correlation length $\xi_{Q \neq 0}$, and we recall that the BCNW method does not apply to results, which are obtained in various volumes, but always at $Q=0$. By integrating over the time shift $t$, however, we obtain a quantity, which is suitable for testing this method, namely the magnetic susceptibility \begin{equation} \label{magsus} \chi_{\rm m} = \frac{\langle \vec M^{2} \rangle - \langle \vec M \rangle^{2}}{L_{\rm cont}} = \int_{0}^{L_{\rm cont}} dt \, \langle \vec e (0) \cdot \vec e (t) \rangle - \frac{1}{L_{\rm cont}} \Big( \Big\langle \int_{0}^{L_{\rm cont}} dt \, \vec e (t) \Big\rangle \Big)^{2} \ , \end{equation} where $\vec M = \int_{0}^{L_{\rm cont}} dt \, \vec e (t)$ is the magnetization. The subtracted term vanishes in our case due to the global O(2) invariance, $\langle \vec M \rangle = \vec 0$. The magnetic susceptibility is physical in the framework of statistical mechanics; we can interpret a configuration $[\vec e \, ]$ as a spin chain. Based on eq.\ (\ref{corrfun}) we obtain for its topologically restricted counterpart \begin{equation} \label{intchim} \chi_{{\rm m},|Q|} = 2 \int_{0}^{L_{\rm cont}/2} dt \, \exp \Big( - \frac{t}{2 \beta_{\rm cont}} + \frac{t^{2}}{2 \beta_{\rm cont} L_{\rm cont}} \Big) \, \cos \Big (\frac{2 \pi Q t}{L_{\rm cont}} \Big) \ . \end{equation} In each sector, the limit $L_{\rm cont} \to \infty$ leads to $\chi_{\rm m} = \chi_{{\rm m},|Q|} = 4 \beta_{\rm cont}$. If we insert the large volume expansions of $\exp (t^{2}/(2 \beta_{\rm cont} L_{\rm cont}))$ and $\cos (2 \pi Q t /L_{\rm cont})$ up to ${\cal O}(1/L_{\rm cont}^{3})$, and perform the integral, we arrive at \begin{eqnarray} \chi_{{\rm m},Q} & = & \chi_{\rm m} + \frac{4 \beta_{\rm cont}}{\pi^{2} L_{\rm cont} \chi_{\rm t}} \Big( 1 + \frac{3/ \pi^{2} - Q^{2}}{L_{\rm cont} \chi_{\rm t}} \Big) \nonumber \\ && + \frac{12 \beta_{\rm cont}}{\pi^{4} (L_{\rm cont} \chi_{\rm t})^{3}} \Big( \frac{5}{\pi^{2}} - 2 Q^{2} \Big) + {\cal O} \Big( \frac{1} {(L_{\rm cont} \chi_{\rm t})^{4}} \Big) \ , \label{BCNWchim} \eea where we substituted the infinite volume value $\chi_{\rm t} = 1/(4 \pi^{2} \beta_{\rm cont})$ \cite{rot97}, cf.\ eq.\ (\ref{contxichi}).\footnote{The finite size effects in $\chi_{\rm t}$, and those due to the upper bound of the integral in eq.\ (\ref{intchim}), are exponentially suppressed.} This is exactly the form of the BCNW approximation (\ref{approx3}), with \begin{equation} \label{ccbar} c = \frac{4 \beta_{\rm cont}}{\pi^{2}} \ , \quad \bar c = \frac{12 \beta_{\rm cont}}{\pi^{4}} \ , \end{equation} and in this case the third order is complete. If we only consider the second order and neglect its $\bar c$-term, we are left with the BCNW approximation (\ref{approx2}). A detailed derivation of the expansion (\ref{BCNWchim}) is given in Appendix A. Therefore the magnetic susceptibility is fully appropriate for numerical tests of the validity of this approximation, where we use the corresponding lattice terms, like $\vec M = \sum_{t=1}^{L} \vec e_{t}$. The sources of systematic errors (errors in the BCNW approximation) are sub-leading finite size effects and lattice artifacts. In analogy to Subsection 3.1, Figure \ref{magsus1dO2} gives an overview over the values of $\chi_{{\rm m},|Q|}$ up to $|Q|=3$, at different $L$. Again we see that the value measured in all sectors is stable in $L$, whereas the topologically restricted results strongly depend on $L$ and $|Q|$. Hence the setting is suitable for the BCNW method also with respect to the magnetic susceptibility. \begin{figure}[h!] \begin{center} \hspace*{-6mm} \includegraphics[width=0.375\textwidth,angle=270]{magsusStanQ3.eps} \hspace*{-8mm} \includegraphics[width=0.375\textwidth,angle=270]{magsusMantQ3.eps} \vspace*{-4mm} \caption{The magnetic susceptibility in the 1d O(2) model at $\beta =4$ on lattices of size $L=150 \dots 400$, with the standard action (left) and the Manton action (right). We show $\chi_{\rm m}$ measured in all sectors (practically constant in this range of $L$), as well as $\chi_{{\rm m},|Q|}$ in the sectors $|Q|= 0 \dots 3$ (well distinct).} \vspace*{-3mm} \label{magsus1dO2} \end{center} \end{figure} We proceed to the fits to search the optimal values --- according to formula (\ref{approx2}) --- for the (over-determined) susceptibilities $\chi_{\rm m}$ and $\chi_{\rm t}$. Table \ref{magsus1dO2tab} shows the results in the fitting ranges $L = L_{\rm min} \dots 400$, $L_{\rm min} = 150,$ $250$, $300$, and $|Q| = 0 \dots |Q|_{\rm max}$, with $|Q|_{\rm max} =2$ or $3$. \begin{table}[ht!] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c||l|l||l|l|} \hline & & \multicolumn{2}{|c||}{standard action} & \multicolumn{2}{c|}{Manton action} \\ \hline $L_{\rm min}$ & $|Q|_{\rm max}$ & \multicolumn{1}{|c|}{$\chi_{\rm m}$} & \multicolumn{1}{|c||}{$\chi_{\rm t}$} & \multicolumn{1}{|c|}{$\chi_{\rm m}$} & \multicolumn{1}{|c|}{$\chi_{\rm t}$} \\ \hline 150 & 2 & 13.64(16) & 0.0072(13) & 16.11(35) & 0.0054(18) \\ 150 & 3 & 13.67(22) & 0.0070(22) & 16.14(41) & 0.0050(26) \\ 250 & 2 & 13.64(5) & 0.0071(5) & 16.00(14) & 0.0060(8) \\ 250 & 3 & 13.65(13) & 0.0074(15) & 15.99(28) & 0.0064(20) \\ 300 & 2 & 13.64(5) & 0.0071(5) & 16.02(12) & 0.0058(8) \\ 300 & 3 & 13.66(13) & 0.0073(17) & 16.02(29) & 0.0061(23) \\ \hline & all & 13.6545(4) & 0.007554 & 16.0187(5) & 0.006333 \\ \hline \end{tabular} \caption{Results based on fits to formula (\ref{approx2}), with input data for the magnetic susceptibility in the range $L= L_{\rm min} \dots 400$ and $|Q| \leq |Q|_{\rm max}$. The last line displays $\chi_{\rm m}$ measured in all sectors at $L=400$, and $\chi_{\rm t}$ at $L=\infty$.} \label{magsus1dO2tab} \end{center} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{table} The fitting results for both susceptibilities are compatible with the correct values, albeit the uncertainty of $\chi_{\rm t}$ is rather large. Without knowing the exact value one could combine the results of separate fits, which reduces the uncertainty, but it leads to a $\chi_{\rm t}$-value which is somewhat too small. On the other hand, for $\chi_{\rm m}$ the values are far more precise, and the relative uncertainty is on the percent level (or below) in each case. Here a combination which reduces the uncertainty is welcome, although it has to be done with care since the partial results are not independent of each other. We add that the fitting results for the coefficient $c$ are consistent with eq.\ (\ref{ccbar}), $c \simeq 1.6$, within (considerable) uncertainties. The observed precisions for $\chi_{\rm m}$ and $\chi_{\rm t}$ can be understood if we consider the impact of the sub-leading contributions, which are missing in the BCNW formula (\ref{approx2}): taking into account the additional terms up to the incomplete third order modifies the fitting results for $\chi_{\rm m}$ only on the permille level, but those for $\chi_{\rm t}$ in ${\cal O}(10) \, \%$, both with somewhat enhanced errors. Also a variety of further fitting variants, with the terms of a complete second or complete third order of approximation (\ref{BCNWchim}), with fixed or free additional terms, leads to consistent results for $\chi_{\rm m}$ and $\chi_{\rm t}$, but with enlarged errors. In summary, there seems to be no fitting strategy which improves the results compared to the simple 3-parameter fit based on the BCNW approximation (\ref{approx2}). \subsection{\label{SEC101}Simulation setup} We finally proceed to the Schwinger model --- or 2d Quantum Electrodynamics --- as a test model with dynamical fermions. This model has the continuum Lagrangian \begin{equation} \mathcal{L}_{\rm cont}(\psi,\bar{\psi},A) = \sum_{{\rm f}=1}^{N_{\rm f}} \bar{\psi}^{\rm (f)} \Big(\gamma_{\mu}(\partial_{\mu}+{\rm i} g_{\rm cont} A_{\mu}) + m^{\rm (f)}\Big)\psi^{\rm (f)} +\frac{1}{4}F_{\mu\nu}F_{\mu\nu} \ , \end{equation} where $N_{\rm f}$ is the number of fermion flavors. It is a widely used toy model, which shares important features with QCD. In particular the U(1) gauge theory in two (spacetime) dimensions allows for topologically non-trivial gauge configurations, similar to instantons in 4d Yang-Mills theories and in QCD. The topological charge is given by \begin{equation} Q[A] = \frac{1}{\pi}\int d^{2}x\,\epsilon_{\mu\nu} F_{\mu\nu} \ . \end{equation} Moreover, for $N_{\rm f}=2$ the low lying energy eigenstates contain a light iso-triplet composed of quasi Nambu-Goldstone bosons, which we are going to denote as ``pions''. This model also exhibits fermion confinement. We simulated the Schwinger model on periodic lattices of volume $V = L \times L$ (as before we use lattice units), with $N_{\rm f}=2$ mass degenerate flavors. They are represented by Wilson fermions, and we use the standard plaquette gauge action (see {\it e.g.}\ Ref.\ \cite{Rothe}). One can approach the continuum limit by increasing $L$, while keeping the terms $g L$ and $M_{\pi} L$ fixed, where $M_{\pi}$ denotes the pion mass.\footnote{In physical units, $g$ has the dimension of a mass, so these products are both dimensionless. This also introduces a dimensional lattice spacing $a \propto g$.} This requires decreasing both $g$ and $M_{\pi}$ proportional to $1/L$ (for the latter the fermion mass has to be adjusted). It is also common to refer to $\beta = 1/g^{2}$, in analogy to the previous sections. As in Sections 3 and 4, we employ a geometric definition of the topological charge on the lattice \cite{Luescher82}, \begin{eqnarray} \label{QUP} Q[U] = \frac{1}{2\pi}\sum_{P} \phi(P) \ , \end{eqnarray} where $\sum_{P}$ denotes the sum over all plaquettes $P = e^{{\rm i} \phi(P)}$, $-\pi < \phi(P) \leq \pi$. With this definition, $Q \in \mathbb{Z}$ holds for any stochastic gauge configuration. We performed simulations at various values of $\beta$, $m$ and $L$ using the HMC algorithm of Ref.\ \cite{HMC_Urbach}, with multiple timescale integration and mass preconditioning \cite{Hasenbusch}. We started with rather short simulations ($\approx 50 \, 000 \ldots 100 \, 000$ HMC trajectories) on small lattices ($L = 8 \ldots 28$), to investigate the transition probability between topological sectors per HMC trajectory. This probability is plotted in Figure~\ref{FIG004xxx}, as a function of $g = 1/\sqrt{\beta}$ and $m / g$, while $g L = 24/\sqrt{5}$ is kept constant. (The ratio $m/g$ is proportional to the bare fermion mass in physical units.) As expected, topological transitions are frequent at large couplings $g$ (coarse lattices), whereas at weak coupling (fine lattices) topology freezing is observed. Such a freezing is also observed in QCD, which is the main motivation of this work. We see that the dependence of the transition probability on the ratio $m/ g$, and therefore on the dimensional bare fermion mass, is rather weak. \begin{figure}[htb] \vspace*{-3mm} \begin{centering} \includegraphics[scale=0.32]{TopFreezing} \par\end{centering} \centering{}\caption{\label{FIG004xxx}The transition probability to a different topological sector per HMC trajectory as a function of $g = 1/\sqrt{\beta}$ (varying the lattice spacing in physical units, $a \propto g$) and $m/ g$ (varying the bare fermion mass in physical units) at $g L = 24/\sqrt{5}$ (fixed dimensional volume and coupling constant).} \end{figure} Similarly to the previous two sections we now explore the possibility of extracting physical energy levels (the ``hadron'' masses in the Schwinger model) from simulations at fixed topology. To obtain such results with small statistical errors, we focused on a single coupling and a single ``quark'' mass, \begin{equation} \label{paramschwing} \beta=4 \ , \quad m=0.1 \ , \end{equation} and we performed long simulations ($\approx 500 \, 000$ HMC trajectories) for volumes $V = L \times L$, with $L = 40,\, 44\, ,48\, ,52\, ,56\, ,60$. \subsection{\label{SEC488}Computation of observables} We determine the topological charge $Q[U]$ for each gauge configuration $U$ according to definition (\ref{QUP}). (To measure observables at fixed topological charge $\nu$, we only use the configurations with $Q[U]=\nu$.) The hadron masses that we investigate are the static potential $\mathcal{V}_{\bar{q}q}(r)$, which has been discussed before in Yang-Mills theory (Subsection~\ref{SEC010}), and the pion mass $M_{\pi}$. A suitable pion creation operator reads \begin{eqnarray} O_{\pi} = \sum_{x}\bar{\psi}^{(u)}_{x} \gamma_{3} \psi^{(d)}_{x} \ , \end{eqnarray} where $u$ and $d$ label the two (degenerate) fermion flavors.\footnote{For an introduction about the construction of hadron creation operators, see {\it e.g.}\ Ref.\ \cite{Weber}.} For the static potential we use again \begin{equation} O_{q\bar{q}}=\bar{q}(r_{1})U(r_{1}; r_{2})q(r_{2}) \ , \quad r=| r_{1} - r_{2} | \ . \end{equation} Also here $\bar{q}$ and $q$ represent spinless static fermions and $U(r_{1}; r_{2})$ denotes the product of spatial links connecting the lattice sites $r_{1}$ and $r_{2}$ on a given time slice. Since there is only one spatial dimension, we do not apply any gauge link smearing. \subsection{Numerical results} \subsubsection{The pion mass and the static potential} Similar to eq.\ (\ref{EQN587}) one can define a pion mass at fixed topological charge $|Q|$ and volume $V$ by \begin{equation} \label{EQN587_} M_{\pi,|Q|,V} = -\frac{d}{dt} \ln\Big(\Big\langle O_\pi^\dagger(t) O_\pi(0) \Big\rangle\Big) \end{equation} for some value of $t$, where approximation (\ref{EQN003}) is quite precise. Within statistical errors, $M_{\pi,|Q|,V}$ is independent of $t$ for large $t$. Therefore, we determine $M_{\pi,|Q|,V}$ by a $\chi^2$ minimizing fit of a constant to the right-hand-side of eq.\ (\ref{EQN587_}) (with the derivative replaced by a finite difference). Figure~\ref{fig:Pion-mass-discrepnecy} shows that pion masses obtained at fixed topology in different topological sectors, $M_{\pi, |Q|}$, differ significantly at $V = 40^2$. For example $M_{\pi,0}$ and $M_{\pi,3}$ differ by more than $6 \sigma$. The physically meaningful value measured in all sectors, $M_{\pi}$, also deviates {\it e.g.}\ from $M_{\pi ,0}$ by more than $7 \sigma$. Figure~\ref{fig:Pion-mass-discrepnecy} demonstrates also here the necessity to analytically assemble fixed topology results, when the Monte Carlo algorithm is unable to generate frequent changes in $Q$. \begin{figure} \begin{centering} \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{pion5_V40} \caption{\label{fig:Pion-mass-discrepnecy}The pion masses $M_{\pi ,|Q|}$ in distinct topological sectors $|Q| = 0 \ldots 4$, and $M_{\pi}$ obtained in all sectors, in the volume $V =40^2$.} \end{centering} \end{figure} To determine the pion mass and the static potential from correlation functions evaluated in single topological sectors, $M_{\pi , |Q|}$ and ${\cal V}_{q \bar q, |Q|}$, we follow the lines of Section 5. We perform least-square fits using expansion (\ref{EQN003}) or (\ref{EQN004}) of the correlation functions. We choose a suitable fitting range $t_\textrm{min} \ldots t_\textrm{max}$, which typically leads to $\chi^2/\textrm{d.o.f.} \raisebox{-0.5ex}{$\,\stackrel{<}{\scriptstyle\sim}\,$} 1$. The stability of the resulting $M_{\pi , |Q|}$ and ${\cal V}_{q \bar q, |Q|}$ has been checked by varying $t_\textrm{min}$ and $t_\textrm{max}$ by $\pm 1$. The $t$ ranges used for the determination of the pion mass are listed in Table~\ref{tab:Temporal-fitting-ranges-schwinger}. \begin{table} \centering \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline $V$ & $t_\textrm{min}$ & $t_\textrm{max}$ & maximum $|Q|$ for & maximum $|Q|$ for \tabularnewline & & & $1/(\chi_{\rm t}V)$, $|Q|/(\chi_{\rm t}V) < 1$ & $1/(\chi_{\rm t}V)$, $|Q|/(\chi_{\rm t}V) < 0.5$ \tabularnewline \hline $40^{2}$ & $12$ & $16$ & $7$ & $3$\tabularnewline $44^{2}$ & $12$ & $18$ & $9$ & $4$\tabularnewline $48^{2}$ & $12$ & $20$ & $11$ & $5$\tabularnewline $52^{2}$ & $12$ & $22$ & $13$ & $6$\tabularnewline $56^{2}$ & $12$ & $24$ & $15$ & $7$\tabularnewline $60^{2}$ & $12$ & $24$ & $17$ & $8$\tabularnewline \hline \end{tabular} \caption{\label{tab:Temporal-fitting-ranges-schwinger}Temporal fitting ranges $t_\textrm{min} \ldots t_\textrm{max}$ and maximum topological charges $|Q|$ for the volumes $V$ under consideration.} \end{table} We perform fits in three different ways: (``c'')~a single combined fit to all five observables ($M_\pi$, $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(r = 1)$, $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(r = 2)$, $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(r = 3)$, $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(r = 4)$); (``c$\mathcal{V}$'')~a single combined fit to the four static potential observables; (``s'')~five separate fits, one to each of the five observables. The results are collected in Table~\ref{tab:Results-schwinger}, along with reference values obtained in all sectors at $V = 60^2$.\footnote{In the continuum 2-flavor Schwinger model, the pion mass is predicted as \cite{Smilga} $M_{\pi,{\rm cont}} = 2.008 \dots \times (m_{\rm cont}^{2} g_{\rm cont} )^{1/3}$. Remarkably, there is almost perfect agreement with our result for $M_{\pi}$, if we insert the bare fermion mass and $\beta$ given in eq.\ (\ref{paramschwing}), which yields $M_{\pi} \simeq 0.343$.\label{fnschwing}} The conclusions are essentially the same as for Yang-Mills theory discussed in Section 5. Results extracted indirectly, from simulations at fixed topology, are in agreement with those obtained directly. The magnitude of the errors is the same for the two expansions (\ref{EQN003}) and (\ref{EQN004}), and for the fitting methods ``c'', ``c$\mathcal{V}$'' and ``s''. They are, however, larger by factors of $\approx 2$ when we use the stringent constraint $1/(\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 0.5$, since less input data are involved compared to $1/(\chi_{\rm t} V) ,\, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$. The fits all yield uncorrelated $\chi^{2} / \textrm{d.o.f.} \raisebox{-0.5ex}{$\,\stackrel{<}{\scriptstyle\sim}\,$} 1$, indicating that the fixed topology results are well described by both formulae (\ref{EQN003}) and (\ref{EQN004}). \begin{table} \hspace*{-2.5mm} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline method & $M_\pi$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(1)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(2)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(3)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(4)$\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{6}{|c|}{all sectors,$\quad$ $V = 60^{2}$}\tabularnewline \hline & 0.3474(3) & 0.1296(2) & 0.2382(5) & 0.3288(7) & 0.4045(10)\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{6}{|c|}{fixed topology,~ $V \in\{40^{2},44^{2},48^{2},52^{2},56^{2},60^{2}\}$,~ $1/(\chi_{\rm t}V)$, $|Q|/(\chi_{\rm t}V) < 1$ }\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & 0.3466(16) & 0.1293(19) & 0.2370(23) & 0.3261(29) & 0.4022(62)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN003})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & 0.1295(10) & 0.2372(12) & 0.3386(15) & 0.4052(16)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN003})s & 0.3477(8) ~~\!\!\! & 0.1285(7) ~~\!\!\! & 0.2371(9) ~~\!\!\! & 0.3282(12) & 0.4050(16)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & 0.3467(10) & 0.1293(6) ~~\!\!\! & 0.2377(9) ~~\!\!\! & 0.3321(32) & 0.4059(69)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & 0.1295(5) ~~\!\!\! & 0.2379(11) & 0.3392(14) & 0.4049(16)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})s & 0.3477(9) ~~\!\!\! & 0.1294(5) ~~\!\!\! & 0.2374(6) ~~\!\!\! & 0.3288(12) & 0.4040(15)\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{6}{|c|}{fixed topology,~ $V \in\{40^{2},44^{2},48^{2},52^{2},56^{2},60^{2}\}$,~ $1/(\chi_{\rm t}V)$, $|Q|/(\chi_{\rm t}V) < 0.5$ }\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & 0.3454(32) & 0.1284(27) & 0.2364(28) & 0.3311(50) & 0.4049(80)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN003})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & 0.1282(12) & 0.2370(16) & 0.3312(35) & 0.4175(82)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN003})s & 0.3478(32) & 0.1292(12) & 0.2377(21) & 0.3275(61) & 0.4027(91)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & 0.3455(32) & 0.1285(16) & 0.2365(19) & 0.3310(49) & 0.4048(78)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & 0.1287(9) ~~\!\!\! & 0.2371(23) & 0.3312(36) & 0.4073(83)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})s & 0.3482(35) & 0.1291(11) & 0.2376(13) & 0.3290(22) & 0.4036(55)\tabularnewline \hline \end{tabular} \caption{\label{tab:Results-schwinger}Results for the pion mass $M_{\pi}$ and the static potential ${\mathcal{V}}_{q\bar{q}}(r)$ at separations $r=1,2,3,4$, with and without topology fixing. In the column ``method'' the equation number of the expansion is listed, ``c'' denotes one combined fit to all five observables, ``c$\mathcal{V}$'' means one combined fit to the four static potential observables, and ``s'' indicates separate fits for each of the five observables.} \end{table} For $|Q| = 0 \ldots 4$ and $V = 40^2 \dots 60^2$, the $M_{\pi,|Q|,V}$ values are plotted in Figure~\ref{fig:pion_BCNW}. Again we observe a strong dependence on the topological sector, in particular in small volumes. From the expansion (\ref{EQN003}), $M_{\pi,|Q|,V}$ is expected to behave as approximation (\ref{approx2}), \begin{equation} \label{EQN491_}M_{\pi,Q,V} = M_{\pi} + \frac{c}{V \chi_{\rm t}} \bigg(1 - \frac{Q^2}{V \chi_{\rm t}} \bigg) \ , \quad c = \frac{1}{2} M_{\pi}''(\theta )_{\pi}|_{\theta =0} \ . \end{equation} The corresponding curves for $|Q| = 0 \ldots 4$ with parameters $M_{\pi}$, $M''_{\pi}$ and $\chi_{\rm t}$, determined by the previously discussed fit ``(\ref{EQN003})s'', are also shown in Figure~\ref{fig:pion_BCNW}. One can clearly see that approximation (\ref{EQN491_}) nicely captures the lattice results for $M_{\pi,|Q|,V}$. \begin{figure}[htb] \centering \includegraphics{pion5c.ps} \caption{\label{fig:pion_BCNW}The fixed topology pion mass $M_{\pi,|Q|,V}$ for $|Q|=0 \dots 4$, as a function of $1/V$, and the curves corresponding to formula (\ref{EQN491_}).} \end{figure} We conclude, similar to our study in Yang-Mills theory, that it is possible to extract correct and accurate values for the pion mass and the static potential from correlation functions computed in a number of fixed topological sectors and volumes. The errors are somewhat larger than for direct computation, in our case by factors of $\approx 2 \ldots 7$. This is partly due to the smaller amount of gauge configurations of the fixed $Q$ ensembles at different $V$, and partly due to the extrapolation to infinite volume. \subsubsection{The topological susceptibility} Table~\ref{tab:Results-schwinger-sus} presents results for the topological susceptibility extracted from our data for $M_{\pi, |Q|}$ and ${\cal V}_{q \bar q, |Q|}$. These values for $\chi_{\rm t}$ are obtained from the same fits, which lead to the results in Table~\ref{tab:Results-schwinger}. The results for $\chi_{\rm t}$ and their interpretation are similar to those obtained in Yang-Mills theory. We observe a slight tension of $\approx 2 \sigma$ for some values, when using expansion (\ref{EQN003}) and the relaxed constraint ($1/(\chi_{\rm t} V) , |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$). This tension disappears when we apply the improved expansion (\ref{EQN004}). When imposing the strict constraint ($1/\chi_{\rm t} V , \, |Q|/\chi_{\rm t} V < 0.5$), we encounter the same problem as in Subsection~\ref{SEC588}: all results are in agreement with the directly measured $\chi_{\rm t} = \langle Q^2 \rangle / V$ (at $V=60^{2}$), but the errors are very large.\footnote{Ref.\ \cite{DuHo1} presents results for $\chi_{\rm t}$ in the 2-flavor Schwinger model with staggered and overlap fermions, with or without link smearing. The results at $\beta =4$ and $m=0.1$ (in large volume) are in the range $\chi_{\rm t} \simeq 0.044 \dots 0.064$. This agrees with our value in Table~\ref{tab:Results-schwinger-sus}, which confirms the mild renormalization of our bare fermion mass (cf.\ footnote \ref{fnschwing}).} {\small \begin{table}[htb] \hspace*{-2.5mm} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline method & $M_\pi$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(1)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(2)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(3)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(4)$\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{6}{|c|}{all sectors, $\quad$ $ V=60^{2} $}\tabularnewline \hline \multicolumn{6}{|c|}{0.0048(1)}\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{6}{|c|}{fixed topology, \ $ V \in\{ 40^{2},44^{2},48^{2},52^{2},56^{2},60^{2} \}$, \ $1/(\chi_{\rm t}V)$, $|Q|/(\chi_{t}V) < 1$}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & \multicolumn{5}{c|}{{\small{0.0038(5)}}}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{0.0042(5)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})s & 0.0041(4) & 0.0038(5) & 0.0036(7) & 0.0038(11) & 0.0044(9)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & \multicolumn{5}{c|}{{\small{0.0044(4)}}}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{0.0042(6)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})s & 0.0046(5) & 0.0043(4) & 0.0045(7) & 0.0036(12) & 0.0038(8)\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{6}{|c|}{fixed topology, \ $V \in \{40^{2},44^{2},48^{2},52^{2},56^{2},60^{2} \}$, \ $1/(\chi_{\rm t}V)$, $|Q|/(\chi_{\rm t}V)<0.5$ }\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & \multicolumn{5}{c|}{{\small{0.0065(35)}}}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{0.0017(30)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})s & 0.0014(38) & 0.0049(32) & 0.0057(31) & 0.0037(48) & 0.0032(27)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & \multicolumn{5}{c|}{{\small{0.0067(32)}}}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c$\mathcal{V}$ & & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{0.0018(33)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})s & 0.0017(32) & 0.0043(34) & 0.0022(46) & 0.0015(38) & 0.0048(52)\tabularnewline \hline \end{tabular} \caption{\label{tab:Results-schwinger-sus}Results for the topological susceptibility $\chi_{\rm t}$, directly measured (at $V=60^{2}$), and based on fixed topology computations of $M_{\pi , |Q|}$ and $\mathcal{V}_{q\bar{q}, |Q|}(r)$ for separations $r=1,2,3,4$. In the column ``method'' the equation number of the expansion is listed, ``c'' denotes a single combined fit to all five observables, ``c$\mathcal{V}$'' means a single combined fit to the four static potential observables, and ``s'' denotes a separate fit to each of the five observables.} \end{table} } We infer that a reasonably accurate determination of the topological susceptibility from $M_{\pi, |Q|}$ and $\mathcal{V}_{q\bar{q}, |Q|}$ requires extremely precise input data. The fixed topology ensembles and correlation functions of this work are not sufficient to extract an accurate and stable value for $\chi_{\rm t}$. \section{Motivation} \input{motivation3} \section{The BCNW method} \input{BCNW} \section{Tests for the quantum rotor} \input{rotor4} \section{Applications to the 2d Heisenberg model} \input{2dO3c} \section{Results in 4d SU(2) Yang-Mills theory} \input{YMb} \section{Results in the Schwinger model} \input{schwing2} \section{Conclusions} \input{conclu} \\ \input{ackno} \subsection{\label{SEC001}Simulation setup} We consider 4d SU(2) Yang-Mills theory, which has the continuum action \begin{equation} S_{\rm cont} [A] = \beta_{\rm cont} \int d^{4}x \, F_{\mu \nu}^{a} (x) F_{\mu \nu}^{a} (x) \ , \end{equation} and the topological charge \begin{equation} Q[A] = \frac{1}{16 \pi^{2}} \int d^{4}x \, \epsilon_{\mu \nu \rho \sigma} F_{\mu \nu}^a (x) F_{\rho \sigma}^a (x) \ . \end{equation} On the lattice we simulate Wilson's standard plaquette action. For the topological charge of a lattice gauge configuration $[U]$, we use an improved field-theoretic definition \cite{Forcrand97}, \begin{equation} \label{EQN001} Q[U] = \frac{1}{16 \pi^2} \sum_x \epsilon_{\mu \nu \rho \sigma} \sum_{\Box=1,2,3} \frac{c_\Box}{\Box^4} F_{x,\mu \nu}^{(\Box \times \Box)}[U] F_{x,\rho \sigma}^{(\Box \times \Box)}[U] \ , \end{equation} where $F_{x,\mu \nu}^{(\Box \times \Box)}[U]$ denotes the lattice field strength tensor, clover averaged over square-shaped loops of size $\Box \times \Box$, and $(c_{1},c_{2},c_{3}) = (1.5, -0.6, 0.1)$. Before applying eq.\ (\ref{EQN001}), we perform a number of cooling sweeps with the intention to remove local fluctuations in the gauge configurations, while preserving the topological structure. \begin{figure}[htb!] \vspace*{-2mm} \begin{center} \includegraphics[width=0.67\textwidth]{cooling2.ps} \vspace*{-2mm} \caption{\label{FIG051}Cooling and assignment of the topological charge for three typical gauge configurations, at $\beta = 2.5$, in a lattice volume $V = 18^{4}$.} \end{center} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{figure} A cooling sweep amounts to a local minimization of the action, {\it i.e.}\ a minimization with respect to each gauge link within a short range. For this minimization we use again an improved lattice Yang-Mills action, \begin{equation} \label{EQN002} S[U] = \frac{\beta}{16} \sum_x \sum_{\mu \nu} \sum_{\Box=1,2,3} \frac{c_\Box}{\Box^4} \textrm{Tr} \Big(1 \!\! 1 - W_{x,\mu \nu}^{(\Box \times \Box)}[U]\Big) \ , \end{equation} where $W_{x,\mu \nu}^{(\Box \times \Box)}[U]$ is a clover averaged loop of size $\Box \times \Box$ with the coefficients $c_\Box$ given above (for comparison, the standard plaquette action corresponds to $(c_{1},c_{2},c_{3}) = (1,0,0)$). Choosing an appropriate number of cooling sweeps is a subtle and somewhat ambiguous task, which is carried out for each gauge configuration one by one. After every cooling sweep we compute $Q[U]$ according to eq.\ (\ref{EQN001}). As soon as $Q[U]$ is stable (it varies by less than 10\,\% and is close to an integer for at least 50 cooling sweeps), the corresponding close integer is the topological charge that we assign to the gauge configuration $[U]$. Figure~\ref{FIG051} shows examples for typical cooling histories of gauge configurations with $Q = 0$, $1$ and $2$. (Details of this procedure, and a comparison to other definitions of the topological charge, are discussed in Ref.\ \cite{CichyLat14}.) Our simulations were performed with a heatbath algorithm, see {\it e.g.}\ Ref.\ \cite{Creutz}. We set $\beta = 2.5$, which corresponds to a lattice spacing $a \approx 0.073 \, \textrm{fm}$, if the scale is set with the QCD Sommer parameter $r_0 = 0.46 \, \textrm{fm}$ \cite{PhilipsenWagner}. This value is in the range of lattice spacings $0.05 \, \textrm{fm} \raisebox{-0.5ex}{$\,\stackrel{<}{\scriptstyle\sim}\,$} a \raisebox{-0.5ex}{$\,\stackrel{<}{\scriptstyle\sim}\,$} 0.15 \, \textrm{fm}$ typically used in contemporary QCD simulations. We generated gauge configurations in lattice volumes $V=L^{4}$, with $L = 12, \, 14 , \, 15 , \, 16 , \, 18$.\footnote{Unless stated otherwise, we continue using lattice units.} In each volume, observables were measured on 4000 configurations, separated by 100 heatbath sweeps. This guarantees their statistical independence; in particular, even the auto-correlation time with respect to the topological charge $Q$ is below 20 heatbath sweeps. \subsection{\label{SEC010}Computation of observables} The observable we focus on is the static quark-antiquark potential ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ for separations $r = 1, 2 \ldots 6$. This quantity can be interpreted as the mass of a static-static meson. To determine ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$, we consider temporal correlation functions of operators \begin{equation} O_{q \bar{q}} (r) = \bar{q}(\vec r_{1}) \, U^\textrm{APE} (\vec r_{1}, \vec r_{2}) \, q(\vec r_{2}) \ , \quad r = |\vec r_{1} - \vec r_{2}| \ , \end{equation} where $\bar{q}$, $q$ represent spinless static quarks, while $U^\textrm{APE}(\vec r_1 , \vec r_2 )$ denotes a product of APE smeared spatial links \cite{APE} along a straight line connecting the lattice sites $\vec r_1$ and $\vec r_2$ on a given time slice. For the quarks we use the HYP2 static action, which is designed to reduce UV fluctuations and, therefore, to improve the signal-to-noise ratio \cite{HYP2}. These temporal correlation functions can be simplified analytically resulting in Wilson loop averages $\langle W(r,t) \rangle$ with APE smeared spatial and HYP2 smeared temporal lines of length $r$ and $t$, respectively. Thus we arrive at the vacuum expectation value \begin{equation} \langle \Omega | O^\dagger_{\bar{q} q}(t) O_{\bar{q} q}(0) | \Omega \rangle \propto \Big\langle W(r,t) \Big\rangle \ . \end{equation} We chose the APE smearing parameters as $N_\textrm{APE} = 15$ and $\alpha_\textrm{APE} = 0.5$, which (roughly) optimizes the overlap of $O_{\bar{q} q} | \Omega \rangle$ with the ground state of the static potential (for details of the smearing procedure we refer to Ref.\ \cite{ETM}, where a similar setup had been used). \subsection{Numerical results} \subsubsection{\label{SEC387}The static potential} Figure~\ref{FIG001} shows results for the static potential measured in all topological sectors, {\it i.e.}\ for each $r$ and $t$ the Wilson loop average is computed on all configurations, which are available in some volume.\footnote{As usual, we determined ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ by searching for a plateau value of the effective mass $m_\textrm{eff}(r,t) = \log(\langle W(r,t+1) \rangle / \langle W(r,t) \rangle)$.} The volumes $14^4$, $15^4$, $16^4$ and $18^4$ yield identical results within statistical errors, but the static potential in the $12^4$ volume differs by several $\sigma$ for quark-antiquark separations $r \geq 3$. We conclude that $V = 12^4$ entails sizable ordinary finite volume effects (not associated with topology fixing), whereas for volumes $V \geq 14^4$ such ordinary finite volume effects are negligible. Consequently, we do not use the $12^4$ lattice in the following fixed topology studies.\footnote{We repeat that the BCNW formula can be extended by incorporating ordinary finite volume effects \cite{PolProc}.} \begin{figure}[htb] \vspace*{-2mm} \begin{center} \includegraphics[width=0.7\textwidth]{1_symb.ps} \vspace*{-2mm} \caption{\label{FIG001}The static potential ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ in a variety of lattice volumes $V = 12^{4} \dots 18^4$.} \end{center} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{figure} For $V = 15^4$, Figure~\ref{FIG002} demonstrates that static potentials obtained at fixed topology from different sectors $|Q| = 0 \ldots 5 $ (by averaging only over configurations of a fixed charge $|Q|$), ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}, |Q|}$, differ significantly.\footnote{Again we determined ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ by fitting constants to effective mass plateaux. Even though topology has been fixed, the effective masses exhibit a constant behavior (within statistical errors) at large $t$.} For example ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q},0}(r=6)$ and ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q},4}(r=6)$ differ by more than $6 \sigma$. They are also well distinct from the corresponding result in all sectors, ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|\leq 1}(6) < {\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(6) < {\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}, |Q| \geq 2}(6)$. These observations show that $V = 14^{4} \dots 18^{4}$ is in the regime that we denoted as {\em moderate volumes} (cf.\ Section 2), where the BCNW method is appropriate to extract observables from fixed topology measurements. Similar results for the static potential in SU(3) Yang-Mills theory have been reported in Ref.\ \cite{Bruck10}. \begin{figure}[htb] \vspace*{-2mm} \begin{center} \includegraphics[width=0.67\textwidth]{2.ps} \vspace*{-2mm} \caption{\label{FIG002}The static potential at separation $r=6$, ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(6)$, for fixed topological sectors $|Q| \leq 5$, and without topology fixing, in the volume $V = 15^{4}$.} \end{center} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{figure} To extract the physical static potential from Wilson loop averages, separately computed in distinct topological sectors $|Q| \leq 7$ and some volume $V$, $\langle W_{V}(r,t) \rangle_{|Q|}$, we follow the procedure discussed in Ref.\ \cite{Arthur13}. \begin{itemize} \item We perform $\chi^2$ minimizing fits of either the $1/V$ expansion of the correlation function \cite{BCNW}, \begin{eqnarray} \nonumber & & \hspace{-0.7cm} C_{Q,V}(t) = \Big\langle W_{V}(r,t) \Big\rangle_{|Q|} \\ \label{EQN003} & & \approx \alpha(r) \exp\bigg\{ -\bigg[ {\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r) + \frac{1}{2} {\mathcal V}''_{q \bar{q}}(r) \frac{1}{V \chi_{\rm t}} \bigg(1 - \frac{Q^2}{V \chi_{\rm t}}\bigg)\bigg] t\bigg\} \end{eqnarray} (cf.\ formula (\ref{approx2})), or of the improved approximation \cite{Arthur14} \begin{eqnarray} \nonumber & & \hspace{-0.7cm} C_{Q,V}(t) \simeq \frac{\alpha(r)}{\sqrt{1 + {\mathcal V}''_{q \bar{q}}(r) t / (\chi_{\rm t} V)}} \\ \label{EQN004} & & \hspace{0.675cm} \times \exp\bigg( -{\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r) t - \frac{1}{\chi_{\rm t} V} \bigg(\frac{1}{1 + {\mathcal V}''_{q \bar{q}}(r) t / (\chi_{\rm t} V)} - 1\bigg) \frac{1}{2} Q^2\bigg) \qquad \quad \end{eqnarray} with respect to the parameters ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$, ${\mathcal V}''_{q \bar{q}}(r) = \partial^{2}_{\theta}{\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r, \theta)|_{\theta = 0} $, $\alpha(r)$ ($r = 1 \ldots 6$) and $\chi_{\rm t}$ to the numerical results for $\langle W_{V}(r,t) \rangle_{|Q|}$ in the range $t_\textrm{min} \leq t \leq t_\textrm{max}$, where $t_\textrm{min}$ and $t_\textrm{max}$ are displayed in Table~\ref{TAB580}.\footnote{Again, $\theta$ is the vacuum angle that we referred to before in eq.\ (\ref{thetaeq}).} When fitting formula (\ref{EQN004}), we also study the scenario where $\chi_{\rm t}$ is fixed to $\chi_{\rm t} = 7 \times 10^{-5}$, which was obtained in Ref.\ \cite{Forcrand97} by means of a direct measurement, in agreement with the fixed topology study in Ref.\ \cite{topdense}. Moreover, we checked that the resulting fit parameters are stable within errors when we vary $t_\textrm{min}$ and $t_\textrm{max}$ by $\pm 1$. \begin{table}[htb] \centering \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline $V$ & $t_\textrm{min}$ & $t_\textrm{max}$ & maximum $|Q|$ fulfilling & maximum $|Q|$ fulfilling \\ & & & $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$ & $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 0.5$ \\ \hline $14^4$ & 5 & 7 & 2 & 1 \\ $15^4$ & 5 & 7 & 3 & 1 \\ $16^4$ & 5 & 8 & 4 & 2 \\ $18^4$ & 5 & 8 & 7 & 3 \\ \hline \end{tabular} \caption{\label{TAB580}Temporal fitting ranges $t_\textrm{min} \ldots t_\textrm{max}$, and maximum topological charges $|Q|$, for the lattice volumes $V$ under consideration.} \end{table} \item The results for $\langle W_{V}(r,t) \rangle_{|Q|}$ entering the fit are restricted to those $|Q|$ and $V$ values for which $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$ or $< 0.5$; we recall that the approximations (\ref{EQN003}) and (\ref{EQN004}) are only valid for sufficiently large $\chi_{\rm t} V = \langle Q^{2} \rangle$, and small $|Q|$. To implement this selection we insert $\chi_{\rm t} = 7 \times 10^{-5}$ \cite{Forcrand97}; Table~\ref{TAB580} gives an overview. \item We either perform a single combined fit to all considered separations $r = 1 \ldots 6$, or six separate fits, one for each $r$. In the latter case we obtain six results for $\chi_{\rm t}$, which agree within the errors in most cases, cf.\ Subsection~\ref{SEC588}. \end{itemize} Table~\ref{TAB001} collects the results for ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ from fixed topology computations (using four volumes, $V = 14^4 , \, 15^4 , \, 16^4 , \, 18^4$), and computed in all sectors at $V = 18^4$. There is agreement between most of these results within about $2 \sigma$. Only for $r=1$, and the relaxed constraint $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$, there are a few cases with discrepancies beyond $3 \sigma$, in particular for the expansion (\ref{EQN003}) (the corresponding data in Table~\ref{TAB001} are displayed in italics). The extent of the errors of the fitting results is fairly independent of the choice of the expansion ((\ref{EQN003}), or (\ref{EQN004}), or (\ref{EQN004}) with $\chi_{\rm t} = 7 \times 10^{-5}$ fixed). The errors increase, however, by factors up to $\approx 2$, when we implement the stringent constraint $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/( \chi_{\rm t} V) < 0.5$, which is expected, since less input data are involved, see Table \ref{TAB580}. All fits of the expansions (\ref{EQN003}) and (\ref{EQN004}) capture well the fixed topology results. \begin{table}[p] \hspace*{-1cm} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline method & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(1)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(2)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(3)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(4)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(5)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(6)$ \tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{7}{|c|}{all sectors,$\quad$ $V =18^4$} \tabularnewline \hline & 0.04229(1) & 0.09329(2) & 0.1646(1) & 0.2190(1) & 0.2664(2) & 0.3101(3)\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{7}{|c|}{fixed topology,$\quad$ $V \in \{ 14^4 , \, 15^4 , \, 16^4 , \, 18^4 \}$,$\quad$ $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & {\it 0.04240(3)} & 0.09343(8) & 0.1646(2) & 0.2189(3) & 0.2662(4) & 0.3097(5)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN003})s & {\it 0.04241(3)} & 0.09342(9) & 0.1646(2) & 0.2189(3) & 0.2662(4) & 0.3097(6)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & 0.04230(3) & 0.09324(8) & 0.1644(2) & 0.2187(3) & 0.2661(4) & 0.3098(6)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})s & {\it 0.04240(3)} & 0.09338(9) & 0.1645(2) & 0.2188(3) & 0.2661(4) & 0.3098(6)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c$\chi_{\rm t}$ & 0.04225(3) & 0.09326(8) & 0.1643(2) & 0.2186(3) & 0.2660(4) & 0.3097(6)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})s$\chi_{\rm t}$ & 0.04225(3) & 0.09326(8) & 0.1643(2) & 0.2186(3) & 0.2660(4) & 0.3097(6)\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{7}{|c|}{fixed topology,$\quad$ $V \in \{ 14^4 , \, 15^4 , \, 16^4 , \, 18^4 \}$,$\quad$ $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 0.5$} \tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & 0.04227(4) & 0.09326(14) & 0.1645(3) & 0.2190(5) & 0.2665(7) & 0.3103(10)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN003})s & 0.04226(4) & 0.09322(13) & 0.1644(3) & 0.2189(5) & 0.2666(8) & 0.3105(11)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & 0.04227(4) & 0.09326(14) & 0.1645(4) & 0.2190(5) & 0.2665(7) & 0.3104(10)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})s & 0.04226(4) & 0.09323(13) & 0.1645(3) & 0.2189(5) & 0.2665(8) & 0.3104(10)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c$\chi_{\rm t}$ & 0.04225(4) & 0.09317(12) & 0.1643(3) & 0.2186(4) & 0.2660(6) & 0.3096(8)\tabularnewline (\ref{EQN004})s$\chi_{\rm t}$ & 0.04225(3) & 0.09317(12) & 0.1643(3) & 0.2186(4) & 0.2660(6) & 0.3096(8)\tabularnewline \hline \end{tabular} \caption{\label{TAB001}Results for the static potential ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ for separations $r = 1 \ldots 6$ measured with and without topology fixing. In the column ``method'' the equation number of the expansion is listed, ``c'' denotes a single {\em combined} fit for all separations $r= 1 \ldots 6$, ``s'' denotes a {\em separate} fit for each separation, and $\chi_{\rm t}$ indicates that the topological susceptibility is not a fit parameter, but fixed to $\chi_{\rm t} = 7 \times 10^{-5}$. Fixed topology results, which differ by more than $3 \sigma$ from the directly computed value, are written in italics.} \end{table} For the extraction of the potential it seems essentially irrelevant whether a single combined fit or six separate fits are performed. Both the mean values and the statistical errors of ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ are in most cases very similar. A single combined fit, however, seems somewhat advantageous regarding the determination of $\chi_{\rm t}$, see Subsection~\ref{SEC588}. Figure~\ref{FIG003} compares the static potential obtained from fixed topology Wilson loops, and computed without topology fixing at $V = 18^4$. As reflected by Table~\ref{TAB001} there is excellent agreement within the errors. \begin{figure}[h!] \begin{center} \vspace*{-2mm} \includegraphics[width=0.7\textwidth]{3_new.ps} \vspace*{-2mm} \caption{\label{FIG003}Comparison of static potential obtained from fixed topology Wilson loops, in the volumes $V = 14^4 , \, 15^4 , \, 16^4 , \, 18^4$, with $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$, using expansion (\ref{EQN004}) with one combined fit, and directly measured at $V = 18^4$. (Since unfixed and fixed topology results coincide within the errors, they are shifted horizontally for better visibility.)} \end{center} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{figure} The expansion (\ref{EQN003}) of fixed topology Wilson loop averages $\langle W_{V}(r,t) \rangle_{|Q|}$ is a decaying exponential in $t$. This suggests defining a static potential at fixed topological charge $|Q|$ and volume $V$, \begin{eqnarray} \label{EQN587} \mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|,V}(r) = -\frac{d}{dt} \ln\Big(\Big\langle W_{V}(r,t) \Big\rangle_{|Q|} \Big) \end{eqnarray} for some value of $t$, where formula (\ref{EQN003}) is a rather precise approximation. Within statistical errors $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|,V}(r)$ is independent of $t$ for $t_\textrm{min} \leq t \leq t_\textrm{max}$. Therefore, we determine $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|,V}(r)$ by a $\chi^2$ minimizing fit of a constant to the right-hand-side of eq.\ (\ref{EQN587}), with the derivative replaced by a finite difference (this is the common definition of an effective mass) in the interval $t_\textrm{min} \leq t \leq t_\textrm{max}$. For $|Q| = 0 \ldots 4$ and $V = 14^4, 15^4, 16^4, 18^4$, the values for $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|,V}(r=6)$ are plotted in Figure~\ref{FIG690}. As already shown in Figure~\ref{FIG002}, there is a strong dependence on the topological sector, which becomes increasingly prominent for smaller volumes. From expansion (\ref{EQN003}) the fixed topology static potential is expected to behave as \begin{eqnarray} \label{EQN491} \mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|,V}(r) \approx {\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r) + \frac{1}{2} {\mathcal V}''_{q \bar{q}}(r) \frac{1}{V \chi_{\rm t}} \bigg(1 - \frac{Q^2}{V \chi_{\rm t}}\bigg) \ . \end{eqnarray} The corresponding curves for $|Q| = 0 \ldots 4$, with parameters ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r=6)$, ${\mathcal V}''_{q \bar{q}}(r=6)$ and $\chi_{\rm t}$ determined by the previously discussed fits ($V = 14^4 \dots 18^4$, $1 /(\chi_{\rm t} V)$,$\, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$, expansion (\ref{EQN003}) and a single combined fit), are also shown in Figure~\ref{FIG690}. One clearly sees that approximation (\ref{EQN491}) nicely describes the numerical results for $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|,V}(r=6)$. \begin{figure}[htb] \begin{center} \vspace*{-2mm} \includegraphics[width=0.90\textwidth]{4_symb_new.ps} \vspace*{-2mm} \caption{\label{FIG690}The fixed topology static potential $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q},Q,V}(r=6)$ for $|Q| = 0 \ldots 4$, as a function of $1/V$, and the curves corresponding to approximation (\ref{EQN491}).} \vspace*{-5mm} \end{center} \end{figure} We conclude that one can obtain a correct and accurate physical static potential from Wilson loops separately computed in different topological sectors. The errors are larger by factors $\approx 2 \ldots 5$ (cf.\ Table~\ref{TAB001}) for a fixed topology computation using four ensembles, compared to a corresponding direct computation using a single ensemble ($V = 18^4$). \subsubsection{\label{SEC588}The topological susceptibility} In Table~\ref{TAB003} we present results for the topological susceptibility extracted from fixed topology Wilson loops $\langle W_{V}(r,t) \rangle_{|Q|}$. Again we use the $1/V$ expansion (\ref{EQN003}) or (\ref{EQN004}), the constraints $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$ or $ < 0.5$, and either a single combined fit to all considered separations $r = 1 \ldots 6$, or six separate fits, one for each $r$. The latter yields six different results for $\chi_{\rm t}$. \begin{table}[htb] \hspace*{-8mm} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline method & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(1)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(2)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(3)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(4)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(5)$ & $\mathcal{V}_{q \bar{q}}(6)$\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{7}{|c|}{fixed topology,$\quad$ $V \in \{ 14^4 , \, 15^4 , \, 16^4 , \, 18^4 \}$,$\quad$ $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & \multicolumn{6}{c|}{8.8(0.5)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})s & 8.8(0.5) & 8.7(0.6) & 8.6(0.7) & 8.6(0.9) & 8.8(1.0) & 8.9(1.2)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & \multicolumn{6}{c|}{7.1(0.6)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})s & 8.6(0.5) & 8.2(0.7) & 7.7(0.8) & 7.3(0.9) & 7.0(1.0) & 6.7(1.1)\tabularnewline \hline \hline \multicolumn{7}{|c|}{fixed topology,$\quad$ $V \in \{ 14^4 \, , \, 15^4 \, , \, 16^4 \, , \, 18^4 \}$,$\quad$ $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 0.5$}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})c & \multicolumn{6}{c|}{11.8(5.9)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN003})s & 10.0(14.0) & 20.7(44.3) & 11.1(8.2)\phantom{0} & 11.8(16.0) & 12.8(8.7)\phantom{0} & 15.4(52.1)\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})c & \multicolumn{6}{c|}{11.9(5.4)}\tabularnewline \hline (\ref{EQN004})s & 10.2(21.8) & 10.7(12.5) & 11.3(8.7)\phantom{0} & 11.8(5.8)\phantom{0} & 13.0(9.7)\phantom{0} & 14.6(12.2)\tabularnewline \hline \end{tabular} \hspace*{1mm} \caption{\label{TAB003}Results for the topological susceptibility $\chi_{\rm t} \times 10^5$ from fixed topology computations of the static potential ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q}}(r)$ for various separations $r = 1 \ldots 6$. In the column ``method'' the equation number of the expansion is listed, ``c'' denotes a single combined fit for all separations $r=1 \ldots 6$, and ``s'' denotes a separate fit for each separation. The reference value from a direct computation is $\chi_{\rm t} \times 10^5 = (7.0 \pm 0.9)$ \cite{Forcrand97}.} \end{table} Not all of the extracted $\chi_{\rm t}$ values perfectly agree with each other or with the result $\chi_{\rm t} = (7.0 \pm 0.9) \times 10^{-5}$ from Ref.\ \cite{Forcrand97}, which we take as a reference. Using the weak constraint $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) ,\, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 1$ there seems to be a slight tension in form of $\approx 2 \sigma$ discrepancies, when performing fits with formula (\ref{EQN003}). The extended expansion (\ref{EQN004}) gives somewhat better results: no tension shows up, and most results agree with the reference value within $\sigma$. One might hope for further improvement by using the stronger constraint $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) , \, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V) < 0.5$, since then formulae (\ref{EQN003}) and (\ref{EQN004}) are more accurate. Indeed this leads to consistency with the reference value, but in most cases the errors are very large, of the order of 100\,\% or even more. For this strong constraint the available ${\mathcal V}_{q \bar{q},|Q|}$-data are not sufficient to extract a useful result for $\chi_{\rm t}$. Note that here the error for one combined fit is significantly smaller than those for the separate fits. We conclude that --- in principle --- one can extract the topological susceptibility in Yang-Mills theory from the static potential at fixed topology using formulae like (\ref{EQN003}) or (\ref{EQN004}). In practice, however, one needs precise data in several large volumes. Only when a variation of the input data ({\it e.g.}\ by using different bounds with respect to $1 / (\chi_{\rm t} V) ,\, |Q|/(\chi_{\rm t} V)$) leads to precise and stable $\chi_{\rm t}$ values, should one consider the result trustworthy. The data used in this work are not sufficient to achieve this standard. As we mentioned before, more promising methods to determine $\chi_{\rm t}$ from simulations at fixed topology using the same lattice setup have recently been explored \cite{topdense,AFHOvari,LSD,slab}.

The notion of habit has acquired an important role within studies of drug addiction and dependence. In general, classical models of addiction conceive of learned compulsive behaviors in terms of a unidirectional stimulus-response model, for which habits are behavior patterns based on studies of animals and are considered to be purely automated---that is, inflexible, highly stimulus bound and insensitive to associated outcomes (Tiffany, [@B23]; Miles et al., [@B12]; Everitt and Robbins, [@B5]). For this approach, learning converts behavior into an automatism, or what some have termed an addictive habit (for example, Hogarth et al., [@B8]; Sjoerds et al., [@B20]). Some of these models have been expanded to incorporate motivational aspects of addiction. Such models regard reinforcement (positive or negative) as the initial and central drive for drug abuse (Robinson and Berridge, [@B16]; Baker et al., [@B1]) and are situated in a context of a larger, goal-directed, decision-making framework (Cox and Klinger, [@B3]; Siegel, [@B19]; Wes, [@B29]). Within this overall picture, Sjoerds\'s team has proposed to expand the habit formation model by distinguishing between motor habits and motivational habits (Sjoerds et al., [@B21]). In the case of motor habits, behavior is based on a stimulus-response model, while motivational habits refer to compulsive behavior that is controlled by an emotional/motivational state and seems to be at least partially goal-directed. Sjoerds\'s proposal is a marked improvement over a strictly motor-habit notion of addiction, but we believe that it still falls short of the full context in which the notion of habit acquires its full significance. Let us examine this context more closely. To be sure, all existing theoretical models have contributed to the understanding of drug consumption, abuse, and addiction. Generally, they affirm that habitual addictive behaviors are related to reinforcement and are conditioned by the presence of diverse environmental and motivational factors associated with the moment of consumption. With continuous consumption, the subject gradually consolidates a behavior associated with the results of consuming and, with time (a period which some designate as the appearance of substance dependency; Peer et al., [@B13]), the behavior becomes more and more compulsive and less flexible. Studies point out that the routine behavior responsible for addiction leads to the appearance of a state of allostasis wherein individuals take drugs no longer to feel "high," but just to feel "right" (Koob and Le Moal, [@B9], [@B10], [@B11]; Piazza and Deroche-Gamonet, [@B14]). We find it interesting to note how habits are understood within this context. In studies of addiction, "habits" typically refer only to acquired behaviors that incite the subject to consume. That is, regardless of their flexibility and their relation to motivational states, habits acquired by drug addicts are considered to be those specific pathological behaviors that must be eliminated or counteracted. However, within a therapeutic framework, we find a much richer picture of habit. Basically, such therapies pursue a modification of all the behaviors that are responsible for the consumption of drugs. The principal objective of many approaches is to fight addiction by means of learned techniques for avoiding stimuli associated with the substance (e.g., substance availability, conditioning social and living places, social groups, etc.; Tucker et al., [@B24]). The problem is that techniques that focus on the elimination of addictive habits do not reinforce the essential supports for what is referred to as personal re-education. In the therapeutic-educative context, it is evident that one of the central consequences of addiction is the loss of habits that are necessary for personal and social realization and which are normally acquired over the course of a healthy life. Of course, if the only objective of the consumer is to obtain the substance so as to avoid the symptoms of withdrawal, any routine behavior that does not have this objective will be useless. But the problem---and here is the crux of the question---is not that addicts have lost or forgotten their daily routines. From a neuropsychological perspective (Robinson and Berridge, [@B17]; Verdejo-García and Bechara, [@B27]; García et al., [@B6]), it has been shown that continuous consumption of drugs deteriorates certain executive functions such that, even after abstinence has begun, cognitive flexibility in the motorization of strategies is reduced and, as a result, the capacity to organize, plan and supervise one\'s own daily behavior is diminished (Verdejo-García et al., [@B28]; Verdejo-García, [@B25]). The addict cannot effectively confront his addiction until this capacity is restored. Because in-treatment therapeutic communities (such as "Proyecto Hombre") provide a controlled environment that helps addicts to "kick the habit" and offers treatment for drug abuse, they are an ideal context for scientific research (for example, Verdejo-García, [@B26]). A quick look at these communities shows that one of the principal problems of drug addicts during the initial and voluntary rehabilitation process is the difficulty in acquiring daily basic routines (Daley, [@B4]; Verdejo-García, [@B25]; García et al., [@B6]). In the scientific literature, there are studies that suggest that rapid recovery of cognitive function during abstinence seems possible (Bates et al., [@B2]; Rapeli et al., [@B15]; Schrimsher and Parker, [@B18]). Anyway, in those therapeutic communities it is well know that It takes months before drug addicts are able to have a natural and reasonable daily routine and to freely assume everyday life activities---and this is only the basis for confronting addiction. Accordingly, the following paradox arises: while most models of addiction tend to consider habits only as pathological behaviors that push the patient toward continued consumption, many therapies aim precisely at recovering *the capacity to acquire habits*, which has been damaged by continued drug use. In short, from the addiction standpoint, habit is something that needs to be eliminated, and from a therapeutic point of view, it is something that needs to be re-established. In reality, treatment consists in a mixture of both elimination and reestablishment, and both elements are considered to be of equal importance in addiction treatment for the addict, his family and his friends (Thurgood et al., [@B22]). In light of this wider therapeutic context, it is evident that habits encompass much more than what is normally defined as the "habit" of drug addiction. Granted, to group all relevant behaviors under the rubric of habit does not correspond with the rigor usually demanded by science. Also, we recognize that scientific understanding of the biological basis of addiction has been advanced by simplified stimulus-response models based on tests with animals, and that the current use of terms like habit, grounded in this experimental context, has proved useful up to a point. However, as has been shown here, it is the actual scientific community that is beginning to notice the limitations of this notion of habit within more complex contexts relevant to human behavior. Moreover, while the motivational dimension proposed by Sjoerds constitutes a significant improvement over the notion of habit as merely stimulus-response conditioning, this expanded notion of habit could still be interpreted as merely a conditioned response to a stimulus that incorporates a motivational dimension. Our suggestion is that only by taking into account the fuller, the liberating dimension of habit that is revealed in the therapeutic context can we break free from the stimulus-response model. We believe that this liberating dimension, which regulate the disposition of the subject to facilitate certain daily routines and thereby enable the subject to take on other tasks (Güell, [@B7]), should be acknowledged in the study of drug dependencies as the characteristic and distinctive dimension of human habits. Conflict of interest statement ============================== The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest. This work was supported by Obra Social La Caixa. I am grateful to Institute for Culture and Society (Universidad de Navarra) and, specially, to Nat Barrett PhD for his suggestions. [^1]: This article was submitted to the journal Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. [^2]: Edited by: Jose Angel Lombo, Pontifical University of the Holy Cross, Italy [^3]: Reviewed by: Robert Hester, University of Melbourne, Australia

Introduction ============ Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) is characterized by blocked or distorted differentiation of hematopoietic stem cells. This malignancy emerges as the results of abnormal rearrangement and inhibition of maturation in blood cells ([@B1], [@B2]). Several studies demonstrated that the aberrant overexpression of specific genes is a common finding in patients with AML; whereas some clinically relevant biological subsets are defined, which lack other cytogenetic or molecular prognostic markers ([@B3]). The ectopic viral integration site-1 (*EVI1*) is a proto-oncogene that encodes a zinc-finger protein and controls transcription in early development ([@B4]). The gene was first identified as a common site of viral integration in retrovirus inducing murine leukemia; it suggests a role for *EVI1*in hematopoietic cells transformation ([@B5]). Further researches demonstrated that forced overexpression of *EVI1*(*EVI1*+) in hematopoietic progenitors induces myeloid differentiation block; it increases self-renewal and survival of transformed progenitors ([@B6]). Increased *EVI1*expression is mainly caused by chromosomal. rearrangements involving chromosome band 3q26, where *EVI1*is located; it is applied as a prognostic factor ([@B7]). Overexpression of the *EVI1*gene is associated with adverse prognosis ([@B8]). Aberrant *EVI1*expression is reported in 8%-10% of human AML adults and obviously up to 27% of pediatric mixed-lineage leukemia (MLL). AML accounts for 25% of all cases of children with acute leukemia; it is accountable for \>50% mortality in the mentioned populations ([@B10], [@B11]). To the best of authors\` knowledge, the prognostic value of *EVI1* expression in pediatric patients with AML is not systematically reviewed. Hence, the current study aimed at determining the prognostic value of *EVI1* expression in patients with AML in the age range of one month to fifteen years. Materials and methods ===================== **Search strategy and literature selection** The current systematic review was presented with the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses plans (PRISMA); PRISMA diagram was adapted too ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). {#F1} Conformity keywords were used in various combinations: "*EVI1*" and "AML" or "acute myeloid leukemia" and "pediatric" or "children" or "infants" and "prognosis", "*EVI1*expression" and pediatric AML" or "*EVI1*expression" and "molecular disorders" and "prediction" or "*EVI1*" and "AML" and "prognosis" or "*EVI1*" and "acute myeloid leukemia" and "forecast" or "prospects". The keywords were planned to proper MeSH terms. The following inclusion criteria were used: 1Articles published in English, which focused on patients with childhood AML; 2-Articles evaluating any prognostic outcomes including overall survival (OS), event-free survival (EFS) or both, according to *EVI1*expression status (high and low expression rates). The exclusion criteria were as follows: 1 Review articles; 2Expert opinions; 3Case reports; 4Articles with no available prognostic data; 5Papers that were a subset of article by the same authors (for multiple reports of single study, only the most recent or most complete article was considered and examined); 6Samples obtained from cell and tissue cultures; 7Studies including patients over 15 years old. A reviewer evaluated the titles and abstracts of the identified publications; potentially relevant articles were retrieved in full. After removal of duplicate studies, the data were extracted based on PRISMA guidelines Including author\`s name, year of publication, region of the study, patient information (including numbers and median white blood cell (WBC) count) ([Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}), OS, and EFS rate and prognosis. ###### Data Extracted From Studied Articles on the Effect of EVI1 Expression on ediatric AML Patients **First Author** **Publication (region/yr)** **Sample Size** **Follow-up** **Median WBC Count (10** **9** **/L)** ------------------ ----------------------------- ----------------- --------------- ---------------------------------------- BV Balgobind Netherlands, 2010 228 4 year 39.7_42.2 Phoenix A.HO USA,2013 206 5 year 15.4_35 Hidemasa Matsuo Japan, 2014 443 NR 48.4_88.7 NR : data not reported WBC, white blood cell Results ======= Totally, four articles were studied in detail shown in [Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}. All studies were retrospective articles that evaluated prognostic value of *EVI1*gene expression in pediatric AML. The studied patients were from various countries and all of them were diagnosed with AML and were in the age range of one month to fifteen years. Total population included 1007 patients, ranging 130 to 443 in the enrolled studies. *EVI1*expression was reported 12.29% to 36% with the mean of 26.57%. In all selected articles, real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RQ-PCR) method was used for *EVI1*expression evaluation. Three out of 4 papers did not report any relationships between *EVI1*expression and gender ([@B12], [@B13], [@B14]); and even one article declared no relationships between age and WBC count ([@B13]). While one study declared that *EVI1*expression mostly occurred in older patients (*P*=0.03) and it was associated with higher WBC count (*P*=0.01) ([@B12]). Another article stated that high expression of *EVI1*was more common in infants less than one year old (up to 40%); lower counts of WBC were reported in cited patients (*P*= 0.061) ([@B14]). Only one paper reported bone marrow blast mean; it was similar in patients with and without *EVI1*expression ([@B14]). Conflict was concluded from the reviewed articles by investigating the correlation between *EVI1*expression and French-American-British (FAB) classification of AM. A study reported high expression of *EVI1*in M4 and M5 FAB subtypes of AML; it was expressed that 33% and 22% in M4 and M5 patients, respectively ([@B12]). Another study declared high rate of *EVI1*expression in AML-M5 (36%) ([@B13]). Two studies observed highest expression of *EVI1*(up to 24%) in AML-M7 ([@B14],[@B15]); one of the cited studies showed high *EVI1*expression in M4/M5 subtypes of leukemia with MLL rearrangements in addition to AML-M7 ([@B15]). **Molecular disorders and EVI1 expression** Gene mutations and chromosome abnormalities such as FLT3-ITD and NPM1 mutations are assessed with cytogenetic investigations. Selected articles disagreed on FLT3-ITD muta tion and *EVI1*expression. As Hidemasa et al., stated that FLT3-ITD mutation frequency was significantly higher in patients with *EVI1*expression (*P*=0.04) (12). Balgobind et al., declared that only one patient with *EVI1*expression had FLT3-ITD mutation; 19.70% of patients with *EVI1*had FLT3-ITD mutation too (4.0% vs. 19.7%; *P*=0.05) ([@B13]). Other published papers claimed that FLT3-ITD mutations were observed in both groups, with and without *EVI1*expression, equally ([@B14]). Three of the selected papers examined the NPM1 mutation too. These three studies showed that NPM1 mutation is not correlated with *EVI1*expression ([@B12], [@B13], [@B14]). Two articles assessed monosomy7 disorder and reported higher expression of *EVI1*in all cases with monosomy7 (rate: 8%; *P*= 0.006) ([@B13], [@B14]). One article compared the changes of *EVI1*expression in CEBPA mutant individuals; the authors reported just one CEBPA mutant patient with *EVI1*overexpression ([@B14]).While other studies did not report *EVI1*expression in individuals with mutant CEBPA ([@B12]). **Cytogenetic disorders and EVI1 expression** *MDS1/EVI1*transcript is a marker to detect cryptic 3q26 aberrations. Balgobind et al., evaluated 3q26 aberration and MDS1/*EVI1*transcript; they found three of 25 patients with *EVI1*+ that lacked the MDS1/*EVI1*transcript ([@B13]). However, by combined data of the gene expression profiling and RQ-PCR in all cases with *EVI1*+, cryptic 3q26 rearrangements were not detected ([@B13]). Also, two other studies did not detect 3q26 rearrangement in EBV (Epstein-Barr virus) positive cases. In all articles, the association between *EVI1*expression and MLL type rearrangement was investigated. An article reported that *EVI1*expression was not correlated with MLL translocation partners ([@B12]). Another article declared that higher frequency of *EVI1*overexpression (27.65%) was observed in patients with MLL rearrangements ([@B13]). Also, another study detected this gene rearrangement in 40% of high expressed *EVI1*patients ([@B14]). **EVI1 expression and clinical outcome** All of the articles on OS, EFS, and patients followups were evaluated in terms of high or low *EVI1*expression. In three papers, the association between the expression status of EVI1 gene and OS was reported (*P*=0.45 to *P*\<0.001).The calculated OS, provided in two article, decreased in patients with AML and high *EVI1*expression (51%±14%; *P*=0.05) ([@B14]). A study assessed the relationship between *EVI1*expression and OS; it was negligible in cases with and without *EVI1*expression (*P*=0.45 and *P*=0.34, respectively) ([@B12], [@B13]). Also in another study, clinical outcomes were compared between *EVI1*+ and *EVI1*cases in the group of patients with MLL-AF9. The results showed significant difference in EFS (*P*\<0.0001) and OS (*P*=0.0008) ([@B12]). An article declared that there was a link between *EVI1*overexpression and EFS. Over expressed patients had lower rates of five-year OS (51%±14%; *P*= 0.015) and EFS (40%±13%; *P*= 0.042) ([@B14]). Another study showed that patients with *EVI1*overexpression had significantly a higher four-year EFS (28%±11%; P=0.04) in comparison with patients without *EVI1*overexpression ([@B13]). A study reported poor survival in patients with high *EVI1*and MEL1 expression (four-year EFS: 39%; OS: 44%); whiles survival of patients just with *EVI1*overexpression was slightly inferior in the analysis of total patient ([@B15]). Discussion ========== AML survival is influenced by factors such as age, genetic abnormalities such as gene mutations, aberrant expression of genes, etc. ([@B16]). Age is the most vital predictive factor for patients with AML; adults older than 60 years have a lower OS in comparison with younger cases ([@B17], [@B18]). Also, cytogenetic disorders dramatically influenced clinical outcomes of AML ([@B19]). *EVI1*plays an important role in upregulation of cell proliferation; it impairs cell differentiation, and induces cell transformation ([@B21]). Increased *EVI1*expression in AML mainly occurs after chromosomal rearrangements involving chromosome band 3q26, inv (3) (q21q26)/t (3; 3) (q21; q26)/t (3, 21) (q26;q22) (7). Increased *EVI1*expression is observed in *EVI1*-rearranged AML, and in patients with other cytogenetic abnormalities (22) such as monosomy7 and 11q23 rearrangements involving MLL as well as cytogenetically normal AML (CN-AML). In contrast, Groschel et al., established that overexpression of *EVI1*was mostly absent in cytogenetically favorablerisk group and in NPM1 mutated AMLs ([@B23]). Interestingly, Aria et al., reported that the specific MLL-ENL fusion triggers *EVI1*transcription in un differentiated hematopoietic cells ([@B24]). The prognostic value of high *EVI1*expression and the correlation between these markers and AML are not thoroughly evaluated in pediatric patients with AML. Furthermore, in the current systematic review four related articles to the prognostic role of *EVI1*in pediatric AML were analyzed. Matsuo et al., proposed that *EVI1*overexpression was not correlated with adverse prognostic factor; since it was associated with reduced remission duration in pediatric patients with AML and MLL-rearrangement, especially in patients with MLL-AF9 rearrangement ([@B12]). Moreover, Lugthart et al., declared that adult patients with AML and *EVI1*overexpression, irrespective of harboring 3q26 aberrations, had poor prognosis ([@B20]). In contrast to adult AML, Balgobind et al., demonstrated no correlations between chromosome 3q26 abnormality, and *EVI1*expression in pediatric AML. Also, they reported that cases with *EVI1*+ had no independent prognostic value for pediatrics; Patients with high *EVI1*expression had a significantly inferior four-year EFS compared with that of the patients with no *EVI1*overexpression. Conversely, the OS was not significantly different between EVI1+ and EVI1groups. Also, in the MLL-rearranged AML patients no significant differences were reported in terms of EFS and OS between the cited groups. They proposed an association between the types of pediatric AML and intermediate to unfavorable prognosis; for example, MLL-AF6 and monosomy7 cause poor prognosis for patients with *EVI1*expression ([@B13]). Phoenix A. Ho et al., did not detect any chromosomal rearrangements of 3q26 in pediatric patients with AML. *EVI1*overexpression mechanisms seem to be distinct in pediatric AML from *EVI1*overexpression in the setting of chromosome 3 aberrations in adult AML. They investigated that patients with high *EVI1*expression had significantly lower rates of five-year OS (51%±14%) and EFS (40%±13%). Also, favorablerisk was a strong predictor of improved OS compared with intermediate-risk. Multivariate analysis showed that high *EVI1*expression did not retain an independent prognostic significant factor for OS among other established prognostic markers ([@B14]). Jo et al., declared that patients with high *EVI1*or MEL1 expression had very poor rates of EFS and OS for a four-year period (EFS: 39%, OS: 44%); EFS and OS rates were even lower in patients without overexpression. Also, they reported no inferior survival (EFS and OS) rates in patients with M7 subtype and *EVI1*overexpression. Concomitantly, overexpression of EVI1 and MEL1 (PRDM16), an EVI1 family member, might act as an even better prognostic marker in pediatric AML compared with EVI1 overexpression alone ([@B15]). Conclusion ========== According to the results of review studies, it was observed that high *EVI1*expression was not a poor prognostic factor in pediatric patients with AML. Generally, this gene expression was a prognostic factor compatible with other factors such as MLL rearrangement, MEL1 expression, and WBC count. This study was the result of a Msc. student thesis proposal supported by the research vice chancellor of Mashhad University of Medical Sciences (MUMS). Conflict of Interest ==================== The authors declare that there was no conflict of interest.

1. Introduction {#sec0005} =============== Runoff phenomena of many rivers in tropical regions have changed markedly in the last two decades ([@bib0080]; [@bib0150]). It has been hypothesized that variability in runoff occurs mainly from climate variability and human activities ([@bib0085]; [@bib0065]; [@bib0170]; [@bib0175]). Climate change has caused increasing occurrences of extreme weather events and variability in precipitation resulting in increased runoff ([@bib0025]; [@bib0050]). Human activities such as alternate land use, deforestation, afforestation, construction of reservoirs, irrigation canals, dam construction, agriculture, mining, and domestic and industrial water usage have also led to significant changes in hydrologic processes especially runoff ([@bib0020]; [@bib0185]; [@bib0115]). Water resources managers have been making significant efforts to protect the LPRB ecosystem by quantifying the contribution of climate variability and anthropogenic activities on runoff using long-term hydrologic data. Identifying variability in long-term hydrologic time series has scientific and practical importance to water resources management for flood control, water availability, river transport, hydropower generation and tourism ([@bib0075]). The Pra River Basin is the second largest basin after the Volta basin in Ghana. The basin is of great importance due to its contribution to socio-economic activities that include agriculture, tourism and mining. The Pra River supplies fresh water to four out of the ten administrative regions of Ghana, serving over 4.2 million people. Most of the local households in the basin depend on groundwater both for domestic and commercial use as a result of unreliable supply from the Ghana Water Company Limited (GWCL). Apart from the conventional water treatment plants sourced from surface water, the GWCL has four additional water treatment plants sourced from groundwater located at New Edubiase, Dunkwa, Twifo Praso and Kibi. Thus, groundwater is considered very important by stakeholders in the basin. Recently, the lower parts of the Pra River Basin have seen increased human activity which may have impacted on the runoff. Activities such as agriculture, logging, industrial water consumption and most importantly, illegal alluvial gold mining, known as "Galamsey", are the main factors affecting the runoff change ([@bib0180]). Beginning in the late 1990s, the government of Ghana placed a ban on logging by small scale chain-saw operators due to the high rate of deforestation and started to implement intensive afforestation measures. However as one activity was banned, another −small scale mining, known in local parlance as, "galamsey" operations also begun along the Pra River. Since the beginning of the 21st century, there have been rapid increases in human activities along the river as farmers sell their lands to "galamsey" operators or "galamseyers", their accepted moniker. After mining activities are completed, though the miners are required by law to reclaim the land to about 75% of its original state, this is not done and in the instances where reclamation is done, the land is not conducive for farming. As a result, farmers are compelled to clear new forest zones for farming. This land use transformation affects surface runoff, stream flow and movement of sediment load into the Atlantic Ocean causing changes to the Pra River delta and ecosystem. Many studies have been done on the hydrologic changes in river basins and their results revealed that human activity, land cover, climate variability and other indicators have affected runoff and sediment load ([@bib0010]; [@bib0045]; [@bib0035]; [@bib0175]; [@bib0200]; [@bib0145]; [@bib0155]). [@bib0080] studied the responses of stream flow to land use changes and climate variability using the physically based distributed Precipitation Runoff Modelling System (PRMS) in the Ketar River Basin, North Africa. Their results revealed that decreasing rainfall will reduce stream flow from the catchment while increases in air temperature will result in a decrease in the catchment discharge. The results also showed that converting cultivated/grazing land to woodland in the river basin will result in decreasing discharge. Awotwi et al. [@bib0015] and [@bib0020] assessed the impact of land-cover changes and climate variability on water balance components using the SWAT model in the White Volta Basin, West Africa. The results from [@bib0020] revealed that, as savannah and grassland are converted to farmlands, green water (evapotranspiration) and blue water (surface or groundwater runoff moving above and below the ground, respectively) increased and decreased respectively whilst results from [@bib0015] revealed that increases in precipitation and temperature resulted in increases in surface runoff, base flow and evapotranspiration. Both studies support water resources managers in protesting against farming close to water bodies and improving land management practices along the Volta River. [@bib0195] assessed hydrologic responses to precipitation variability and diverse human activities in a mountainous tributary of the lower Xijiang River in China using a statistical approach. The influences of precipitation variability and human activity on water discharge and sediment load were quantified using double mass curve and linear regression methods. Zhang and Lu showed that human activities contributed to about 80% of the increase in dry-season water discharge in the period 1969--2002. The results also revealed that human activities, particularly deforestation during the period 1981--1985 and 1986--2002, contributed 43% and 114% respectively to the increasing change of sediment load. The results for water discharge and sediment load in the study highlights the importance of monthly and seasonal time series in assessing variability in hydrologic processes. [@bib0085] analyzed the impact of climate variability and human activity on stream flow in the Miyun reservoir catchment using a Geomorphology-Based Hydrological Model (GBHM) and a climate elasticity model. The results of the GBHM and climate elasticity model revealed that climate influence account for about 55% and 51% of the decrease in reservoir inflow respectively. The indirect impact of human activity accounts for an 18% decrease in reservoir inflow while the direct impact of human activity account for other percentage decreases in the reservoir inflow. Their study quantified the impact of direct and indirect human activity on river discharge, which is important in assessing stream flow. The main aim of this study is to analyze and quantify the contribution of precipitation variability and human activity on runoff by investigating the changes in monthly, seasonal and annual time series of runoff and precipitation. This study provides in-depth understanding on the runoff responses to precipitation variability and uncontrolled alluvial mining activities which is critical for effective planning, management and sustainable development of programs to ensure water availability for present and future generation. 2. Materials and methods {#sec0010} ======================== 2.1. Study Area {#sec0015} --------------- The LPRB is geographically located in the south-western part of Ghana ([Fig. 1](#fig0005){ref-type="fig"}) and has a drainage area of 6,778 km^2^. The LPRB is located within the Forest Ecological Zone of Ghana. Due to the recent increase in illegal small-scale alluvial gold mining activity, the forest has undergone rapid degradation. Mean annual runoff is estimated to be 4,200 m^3^yr^−1^ ([@bib0180]). The climate is considered to be Am, tropical monsoon climate, according to the updated Köppen-Geiger climate classification by [@bib0070]. The LPRB has two rainy seasons, April-June and September-November. The mean annual rainfall of about 1,600 mm is relatively high. It, however, varies from 1,450 mm to 1,900 mm. The spatio-temporal variability of rainfall distribution is seen to increase towards the southern part of the basin. The average minimum and maximum air temperatures are 21 °C and 32 °C respectively. Air temperatures increase toward the northern part of the LPRB.Fig. 1Location of precipitation and hydrological stations of Lower Pra River Basin, Ghana.Fig. 1 2.2. Data {#sec0020} --------- Daily precipitation data from 1970 to 2010 at seven rain gauge stations within the LPRB and surrounding areas were obtained from the Ghana Meteorological Agency (GMet). The spatial mean precipitation for the monthly, seasonal and annual precipitation data were derived using the Inverse Distance Weighting (IDW) method. This method uses the exact distances between the estimation point and the known points to weigh their influence in calculating the estimated value. IDW was used because different distances are integrated in the estimation and the distance-weighting exponent is able to precisely control the influence of the distances. Daily discharge data from 1970 to 2010 at Daboase hydrologic station on the main Pra River were obtained from the Ghana Hydrological Service Department. 2.3. Trends analysis {#sec0025} -------------------- Time series analysis of precipitation data was performed to gain an understanding of the precipitation change. Since precipitation has major influence on hydrologic variability due to climate variability, it was considered as an index of climate for this study. Annual, monthly and seasonal trends in the precipitation data were analyzed. Non-parametric Mann--Kendall statistical test ([@bib0090]; [@bib0060]), which has been widely used for assessing the significance of trends in hydro-meteorological time series, was employed for the trend analysis. This test was chosen due to its robustness for non-normally distributed data and its comparable power as parametric competitors ([@bib0135]; [@bib0040]). The test is based on the Statistic (S) given by:$$S = \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{N - 1}{\sum\limits_{J = i + 1}^{N}{{sgn}(x_{j} - x_{i}})}$$$${sgn}(x_{j} - x_{i}) = \left\{ \begin{matrix} {1,if\, x_{j} > x_{i}} \\ {0,if\, x_{j} = x_{i}} \\ {- 1,if\, x_{j} < x_{i}} \\ \end{matrix} \right.$$ where *x*~*i*~ and *x*~*j*~ are the data values at times *i* and *j*, and N the length of the observation. The positive and negative signs of the S value indicate the upward and downward trend of the datasets respectively, whilst S = 0 represents no trend. The statistical significance of the trends can be tested by comparing the standard normal variation (*i*) value in Eq. [(3)](#eq0015){ref-type="disp-formula"} with the standard normal distribution Table at required significance level α. Under two-sided trend test, the null hypothesis (*H*~*o*~) is rejected if $\left| Z \right| > \left| Z_{1 - \alpha/2} \right|$. Otherwise *H*~*o*~ is accepted. In this study, a confidence level of 95% was adopted.$$\text{Z} = \left\{ \begin{matrix} {\frac{\text{S} - 1}{\sigma},S > 0} \\ {0,S = 0} \\ {\frac{\text{S} + 1}{\sigma},S < 0} \\ \end{matrix} \right.$$$$\sigma = \sqrt{\frac{\text{N}\left( {\text{N} - 1} \right)\left( {2\text{N} + 2} \right)}{18}}$$ where σ is the standard deviation. Since the test evaluates for a statistically significant trend, it is important to remove any data having serial correlation before performing the Mann--Kendall trend test ([@bib0095]). A Trend-Free Pre-Whitening (TFPW) method proposed by [@bib0190] was adopted in the study to remove the effect of serial correlation. Autocorrelation was assessed by correcting the autocorrelation coefficients of the time series using only those with significant autocorrelation at the 0.05 significance level. The trend slope was estimated by using the Sen\'s slope estimator to investigate the stationarity of the autoregressive process. Sen\'s slope estimator is robust against non-normal distributions with missing data and extreme outliers ([@bib0130]). It estimates the trend slope (α) as the median slope between all possible pairs of observation as:$$\alpha = \text{median}\left( \frac{x_{j} - x_{i}}{j - i} \right),1 < i < j < N\,$$ where i = 1, 2... N −1 and j = 2... N. Positive and negative values of α denote increasing and decreasing trend respectively. Significant linear trend was removed from the raw times series data using Eq. [(6)](#eq0030){ref-type="disp-formula"}.$$\text{Y}_{\text{t}} = \text{X}_{\text{t}} - \alpha t$$ where Y~t~ is the detrended time series data at time t; X~t~ is the raw time series data at time t; and α is the slope estimator of the trend in the raw time series data. Lag-1 serial correlation coefficient (l~c~) was estimated using the equation proposed by [@bib0120] as follows:$$l_{c} = \frac{\frac{1}{n - 1}\sum\limits_{t = 1}^{n - 1}\left\lbrack {X_{t} - E(X_{t})} \right\rbrack\left\lbrack {X_{t + 1} - E(X_{t})} \right\rbrack}{\frac{1}{n}{\sum\limits_{t = 1}^{n - 1}\left\lbrack {X_{t} - E(X_{t})} \right\rbrack}^{2}}$$$$E(X_{t}) = \frac{1}{n}\sum\limits_{t = 1}^{n}X_{t}$$ where l~c~ is the lag-1 serial correlation coefficient of the raw time series data, X~t~; and E (X~t~) is the mean of raw time series data. The TFPW method was then used to eliminate the serial correlation from time series data using:$$\mathbf{R} = \mathbf{Y}_{\mathbf{t}} - \mathbf{l}_{\mathbf{c}}\mathbf{Y}_{\mathbf{t} - 1}$$ where R is the residual series 2.4. Change-point analysis {#sec0030} -------------------------- Identifying break points is essential for surface runoff analysis which aids in assessing the effects of climate variability and human activities. This study used Pettitt test and precipitation-runoff Double Cumulative Curve (DCC) to assess changes within hydro-meteorological series of LPRB. Pettitt's test is a nonparametric approach for determining the occurrence of a change point ([@bib0110]). It is used to reveal changes in time series data. The test is a rank-based and distribution-free test for detecting a significant change in the mean of a time series when the exact time of the change is unknown ([@bib0110]). The Pettit test is estimated by the formula:$$U_{T,N} = \sum\limits_{J = 1}^{T}{\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{N}{{sgn}(x_{j} - x_{i}})}$$ where T = 1, 2, 3..., N The DCC is an x-y scatter plot with the cumulative quantity of one variable plotted against the cumulative quantity of another for a concurrent period ([@bib0125]). The idea behind the DCC is that a plot of two cumulatively variables will produce a straight line if the variables are proportional and the slope presents the constant of proportionality between the two variables ([@bib0125]). A change in the slope of the curve reveals that the internal relations between the two variables have been changed and provides important information about the activities surrounding the two variables. DCCs have been extensively used to analyze the relationship between hydro-meteorological variables such as precipitation--runoff, precipitation--sediment (sediment production and its relationship with climatic factor) and runoff--sediment (sediment production and its relationship with hydrologic factor). These relationships help to assess the impact of human activities on surface runoff and stream flow ([@bib0160]; [@bib0205]). In this study, the DCC method was used to identify the points where human activities affected stream runoff. In the situation where the change point relates to maximum *U~T,N~*, *Pettit's* test was deployed to determine the change point of runoff series to reaffirm the change point produced by the DCC. 2.5. Quantification of climate change and human activity on runoff {#sec0035} ------------------------------------------------------------------ As changes in runoff are attributed to both climate change and human activity, the total change in runoff assumes that the effects of climate change and human activity on runoff are independent. Thus, the first-order approximation of the total change in the runoff (ΔR~total~) is estimated by the formula:$$\Delta\text{R}_{\text{total}} = \Delta\text{R}_{\text{climate}} + \Delta\text{R}_{\text{human}}$$ where ΔR~climate~ is the change in runoff due to climate variability and ΔR~human~ represents the change in runoff due to various anthropogenic activities. To quantify the impact of the climate change and human activities on runoff changes, the variability in the pre-break period and post-break period was assessed. The DCC was used to identify break periods. Consequently, the relative impact of the precipitation changes between pre-break and post-break periods on the runoff is estimated as:$$\Delta\text{R}_{\text{precipitation}} = \frac{R_{calculated} - R_{observed}}{\left( {R_{calculated} - R_{observed}} \right) + \left( {R_{obs - change} - R_{calculated}} \right)} \times 100$$ *where* ΔR~precipitation~ is the contributions of precipitation variability to changes in runoff; R~observed~ is the mean of the observed annual runoff during pre-break period; R~calculated~ is the mean of the calculated runoff; and R~obs−change~ represents the mean observed runoff during the post period. The R~calculated~ was estimated by substituting the precipitation of the dry season in post-break period into the generated pre-break period regression equation of precipitation and runoff series on the condition of the runoff yield capacity of the pre-break period. The calculation of the runoff change as a result of human activities is obtained as follows:$$\Delta R_{human} = 1 - \Delta R_{precipitation}$$ 3. Results {#sec0040} ========== 3.1. Trend analysis of precipitation {#sec0045} ------------------------------------ The LPRB has historically experienced uneven distribution of precipitation, with 77.8% of the annual precipitation recorded in the wet season. Out of this, 68.3% is recorded in April, May and June. Results from [Table 1](#tbl0005){ref-type="table"} shows that there was no statistically significant decreasing trend in annual precipitation during the period 1970--2010. The Mann-Kendall test results cannot, however, conclude that there is no statistically significant trend because trends in precipitation at the annual level may not be identifiable. Hence, monthly and seasonal trend analyses were performed. Analyzed monthly trends indicated no statistically significant trends ([Table 1](#tbl0005){ref-type="table"}) apart from February and March. The February and March precipitation exhibited decreased rate at 7.3 ×10 mm yr^−1^ and 1.08 mm yr^−1^ with their corresponding Z-values of −2.13 and − 2.61 respectively.Table 1Mann--Kendall test and Sen*\'*s slope estimator results for precipitation over the period 1970--2010.Table 1Mann-Kendall testSZTaup-valueb (mmyr^−1^)*Annual time series*Yearly-105-1.12-0.120.260-2.75*Seasonal time series*Dry-114-1.31-0.140.204-1.89Wet-22.0-0.20-0.0300.814-0.453*Monthly time series*January1001.120.120.2660.194**February-192-2.13-0.230.032-0.727March-234-2.61-0.290.009-1.08**April28.00.330.030.7620.185May22.00.230.030.8140.265June-110-1.24-0.130.221-1.469July25.00.310.030.7950.266August-2.000.000.000.991-0.013September16.00.120.020.8660.125October1461.590.180.1031.448November2.000.000.000.9910.233December-36.0-0.38-0.040.694-0.094[^1][^2] Hydrologic processes at downstream are altered by upstream actions hence an analysis was made on the annual and dry-season precipitation. Results revealed that over the period 1970--2010 (Figs. [2](#fig0010){ref-type="fig"} and [3](#fig0015){ref-type="fig"}), the annual and dry-season precipitation systematically decreased across the entire upstream of the Pra River Basin with mean slope trend of 2.49 mm yr^−1^ and 2.81 mm yr^−1^ respectively.Fig. 2Annual precipitation and runoff trend in the upstream of Pra River Basin for 1970--2010.Fig. 2Fig. 3Dry-season precipitation and runoff trend in the upstream of Pra River Basin for 1970--2010.Fig. 3 3.2. Trend analysis of the runoff {#sec0050} --------------------------------- Trend analysis was used to analyze the climatic and hydrologic variability over a 41-year period. Statistical analysis was applied to the seasonal, monthly and annual runoff data from 1970 to 2010 to study the trends ([Table 2](#tbl0010){ref-type="table"}). Annual water runoff showed a statistically significant increasing trend of 4.65×10^2^ m^3^ s^−1^ with Z-value of 2.6 at 5% significance level. Even though the annual water runoff in the catchments increased, significant trends were found in the dry months of January, February, March, July, August and December. The rate of increase of runoff is 3.09×10^2^ m^3^ s^−1^ per year. Although November is classified with the wet season, there was significant trend in the annual water runoff. This may be due to the fact that the second part of the wet and dry seasons in the study area, respectively, ends and begins in November.Table 2Mann--Kendall test and Sen*\'*s slope estimator results for runoff over the period 1970--2010.Table 2Mann-Kendall trend testSZTuap-valueb (m^3^yr^−1^)*Annual time series***Yearly3182.230.240.026383.0***Seasonal time series*Wet season1101.220.130.221151.0Dry season**2402.700.290.007284.0***Monthly time series***January2462.830.300.00624.5February2242.510.270.01220.8March2322.610.280.00940.6**April1361.500.170.12924.7May1741.920.210.05253.5June90.01.000.110.31743.1**July1182.060.220.03958.5August1522.340.250.01982.3**September18.00.230.020.84910.6October1361.510.170.12964.1**November2022.340.250.02476.4December2803.110.340.00249.0**[^3][^4] Annual runoff at the Mfensi station located at the upstream of Pra River Basin revealed an average of 1.98×10^3^ m3 s^−1^ for the 41-year study period. During the period, the annual runoff at the Mfensi station revealed decreasing trends with a rate of 3.25×10 m3 s^−1^ per year ([Fig. 2](#fig0010){ref-type="fig"}). 3.3. Break point in the precipitation {#sec0055} ------------------------------------- The change points in the time series and the significant p-value for the corresponding change point are indicated in [Table 3](#tbl0015){ref-type="table"}. The only change point occurred during the period when the country experienced severe drought in 1982 and 1983. The seasonal and annual precipitation depicted no statistical significant change point at the 0.05 significance level over the 41-year period. Significant abrupt changes for the monthly time series were detected around 1983 for February and March precipitations with p-value \< 0.05.The remaining months showed no significant change point.Table 3Pettitt test results for precipitation time series over the period 1970--2010.Table 3Pettitt test for break pointKrp-valueShiftChange point*Annual time series*Yearly1710.198-1983*Seasonal time series*Dry1460.327-1984Wet1080.742-1982*Monthly time series*January1320.455+1983**February2160.038-1983March2200.033-1983**April801.160+1988May881.040+2004June1380.396-1982July701.360+1975August741.260+1983September1100.718+1995October1460.327+1996November901.010+1980December1640.203-1982[^5][^6] 3.4. Break point in the runoff {#sec0060} ------------------------------ Based on the Pettitt test results in [Table 4](#tbl0020){ref-type="table"}, an abrupt change in the annual runoff was identified in 1985 and this is also depicted by cumulative residual in [Fig. 4](#fig0020){ref-type="fig"}. The monthly time series with significant change periods can be found in the dry season and is prevalent in 1994 ([Fig. 5](#fig0025){ref-type="fig"}). The earlier change point of the annual runoff depicted by the Pettitt test is as a result of the inability of the test to identify minor change in the beginning. The rate of runoff in the before-change periods and after-change periods were assessed to gain better understanding of the characteristics of the runoff change. The results from [Fig. 6](#fig0030){ref-type="fig"}, indicated a downward change from 1970 to 1985 and from 1986 to 2010 with annual runoff rate of −4.4 × 10^7^m^3^yr^−1^ and 1.0 × 10^8^m^3^yr^−1^ respectively. The test also showed significant change in the dry season with an upward trend in 1994. The mean change in runoff is from −0.028 × 10^9^m^3^yr^−1^ to 0.131 × 10^9^m^3^yr^−1^, which occurred in 1970--1994 and 1995--2010 respectively ([Fig. 7](#fig0035){ref-type="fig"}).Fig. 4Change point detection of annual runoff time series by cumulative residual method.Fig. 4Fig. 5Change point detection of dry-season runoff by cumulative residual method.Fig. 5Fig. 6Variation of the mean level in annual runoff of pre-break and post-break point at LBRB.Fig. 6Fig. 7Variation of the mean level in dry-season runoff pre and post change point of the study area.Fig. 7Table 4Pettitt test results for runoff time series over the period 1970--2010.Table 4Pettitt test for break pointKrp-valueShiftchange point*Annual time series***Yearly2600.006+1985***Seasonal time series*Wet season1681point+2010**Dry season2260.026+1994***Monthly time series***January1860.011+1993February1900.093+1993March2100.047+1995**April1540.267+2002May2020.062+1985June1640.203+1981July1400.378+2003**August1620.215+1993September1060.770+1994**October1580.240+1978**November2520.009+1993December2100.047+1994**[^7][^8] 3.5. Analysis anthropogenic activities {#sec0065} -------------------------------------- According to the land-use/land-cover data ([Fig. 8](#fig0040){ref-type="fig"}), the LPRB underwent various land surface changes from 1986 to 2010. The classification revealed that within the period from 1987 to 2000, there has been significant land use changes in the basin with forest, cropland and settlement increased by 16.5%, 144% and 150%, respectively, while the open forest cover reduced by 41.6%. Alluvial mining activity in the basin was identified within the period 2001--2004 to be covering 3.55% of the total study area. Conversely forest and open forest reduced by 16.3% and 15.4%, respectively, and settlement, cropland and water use increased by 66.8%, 5.9% and 10.1% respectively, during the same period. The alluvial mining activity increased by 70.7% within 4 years (2005--2008) during which time the forest and open forest recorded reduction of 11.9% and 32.1% respectively, while the settlement, cropland and water use recorded increment of 20.0%, 30.1% and 19.9% respectively ([Fig. 9](#fig0045){ref-type="fig"}).Fig. 8Land surface change of the study area for 1986, 1998, 2004, and 2008.Fig. 8Fig. 9Changes in the land cover of LPRB during the study period.Fig. 9 The trend of the land cover changes in the upstream of Pra River Basin is similar to that of the LPRB. The only difference is that there is no alluvial mining activity at the river's upstream. 4. Discussion {#sec0070} ============= 4.1. Precipitation variability and human activities impact on runoff {#sec0075} -------------------------------------------------------------------- The statistical tests results revealed significant trends and abrupt changes in the seasonal, monthly and annual runoff time series data for the LPRB from 1970 to 2010. Changes in runoff in the river basin can be attributed to the results of climate variability and anthropogenic activities. Anthropogenic activities and climate variability are widely regarded as the two main driving forces of stream flow changes ([@bib0165]). Identifying the major driving force in runoff changes is critical to the stakeholders. This helps to plan and make managerial decisions concerning water security for the present generation while assisting in making water available for the future. The declining precipitation and runoff trend upstream are expected to have an impact on the runoff downstream ([@bib0055]; [@bib0105]; [@bib0030]). Assuming land use changes and precipitation trends upstream become similar downstream, it is expected that the LPRB will exhibit decreasing runoff trends. This is however not the case as runoff trends downstream are opposite to that upstream. This may be attributed to the presence of alluvial gold mining activity at the LPRB 4.2. Contributions of precipitation and human activities to the runoff change {#sec0080} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Since significant change in trends was identified in the dry season, the DCC was adopted in the dry season ([Fig. 10](#fig0050){ref-type="fig"}). Without the influence of human activities on the hydrologic processes, the DCC exhibits a straight line which represents strong correlation between hydrologic variables and precipitation. Four change points in 1986, 2000, 2004 and 2008 were identified, according to the DCC and the t-test slopes comparison analysis ([Table 5](#tbl0025){ref-type="table"}). These change points demonstrate that the variability in hydrologic processes in the basin were not only from climate but also as a result of anthropogenic activities. The change point in 1986 is similar to the change points identified in the Pettitt test and the cumulative residual curve. The precipitation-runoff cumulative curve was classified under five periods according to the slope change characteristics; Period 1 (P1) from 1970 to 1986; Period 2 (P2) from 1987 to 2000; Period 3 (P3) from 2001 to 2004; and Period 4 (P4) from 2005 to 2010. The period P1, is the period where water discharge was not influenced by human activities. Thus, P1 was used as the reference period for the study. The change periods after the breakpoint are P2, P3 and P4. P2 recorded reduction in runoffs as compared to P1 ([Table 6](#tbl0030){ref-type="table"}), which may be due to increased forest land reclamation as a result of the restriction placed on small scale chain-saw operations and the implementation of afforestation measures. Increase in forest land leads to high rates of evapotranspiration and hence a decrease in runoff ([@bib0140]). P3 is the period when afforestation activities were intensified. Compared to P1, there should be a decrease in runoff due to evapotranspiration ([@bib0175]). The opposite is however true ([Table 6](#tbl0030){ref-type="table"}), and this can be certainly a direct result of the "galamsey" operations in the basin. The activity of "galamsey" operations leaves the topsoil clayey. This phenomenon prevents infiltration. Infiltration is impeded because the activity of surface mining as carried out by "galamsey" operators loosen the soil particles thereby creating gaps between the particles which are then filled by the clay particles of the new topsoil resulting from the mode of backfilling and gold extraction: the water used for washing the gravel which contain clay particles continuously run over the backfilled pits. Thus a surface seal is created which reduces infiltration rate. Also removal of vegetation cover (transformation of croplands and forest areas to mining area, [Fig. 8](#fig0040){ref-type="fig"}) can form surface compaction of wet soils and also mechanically ruin the surface composition which can powder the soil surface during dry period. This tends to increase the rate of formation of surface seal during washing of haul gravel and raining period. ([@bib0005]). Removal of vegetation cover also reduce evapotranspiration and increase runoff. Again according to the physical mechanism, runoff in the dry season is mainly attributed to base flow, whose rate depends on the pressure gradient between stream flow and groundwater since it affects the water movement resistance between the two hydrologic units thereby varying the intensity of the stream-aquifer water interchange ([@bib0100]). This means that as the "galamseyers" mine inside the river, the resistance will be reduced and this will increase contribution of base flow to runoff. Therefore, increase in the runoff exhibited when P4 and P1 are compared, reflects the intensification of "galamsey" activities.Fig. 10Dry-season DCC between runoff and precipitation from 1970 to 2010.Fig. 10Table 5T-test results for comparing slopes.Table 5Slope~P1andP2~Slope~P2andP3~Slope~P3andP4~**Std err**8.91×10^−4^1.59×10^−3^2.11×10^−3^**t**2.091.15×102.49**df**2.7×101.4×106.00**P-value**4.57×10^−2^1.62×10^−8^4.72×10^−2^[^9][^10][^11]Table 6Quantification of the runoff changes in response to precipitation variability and human activities.Table 6Impact of precipitation only (10^9^ m^3^yr^−1^)Impact of human activities only (10^9^ m^3^yr^−1^)Calculated (1)observed (2)Value (3)=(1) − observed of reference% = (3)/\[(3) + (4)\]Value (4)=(2)-(1)% (4)/\[(3) + (4)\]**1970-1986**4.674.72**1987-2000**4.434.02-0.29341.6-0.41158.4**2001-2004**6.028. 281.2636.52.2663.5**2005-2010**5.908.241.1833.42.3466.6**1987-2010**5.086.790.36017.41.7182.6 4.3. Estimation of climate variability and anthropogenic activities on runoff {#sec0085} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- To better understand the behavior of the changes in runoff, linear regression was used to assess the difference between the runoff during the pre-break and post-break periods in the dry season. Due to the non-monotonic nature of the runoff, linear regression equations between precipitation and runoff for the dry season were established for the various periods ([Fig. 11](#fig0055){ref-type="fig"}). These were based on the change points identified in the DCC. The fitted lines for P3 and P4 lie above the one for P1 ([Fig. 10](#fig0050){ref-type="fig"}). This implies that the runoff has recorded increments after 1986 as a result of anthropogenic activities. The position of the line of fit for P2, above and below the reference line showed both increase and decrease in runoff after 1986 due to the anthropogenic activities.Fig. 11Best-fitted lines of linear regression between dry-season runoff and dry-season precipitation.Fig. 11 The linear regression equation between dry-season water runoff (R~dry-season~) and dry-season precipitation (P~dry-season~) in the pre-break period (1970--1986) is as follows:$$(R_{dry - season} = 0.0031{\, P}_{dry - season} + 3.7315) \times 10^{9}$$ Based on the linear regression equation (Eq. [(14)](#eq0070){ref-type="disp-formula"}), the impact of precipitation variability and human activities on the alterations of runoff were estimated ([Table 6](#tbl0030){ref-type="table"}). Runoff in post-break periods was calculated by substituting the precipitation value of the post-break periods into equation 14. The difference between mean observed runoff in the pre-break period and the calculated values at each period provided the estimated runoff change caused by precipitation alone. The impact of human activities on runoff change was assessed by differencing the measured values and calculated values in each period. During period 1987--2000, human activities and precipitation variability contributed 58.4% and 41.3%, respectively, to the reduction in runoff. However, marked increase in runoff was recorded in period 2001--2004 and 2005--2010. During period 2001--2004, contributions from human activities and precipitation variability were 63.5% and 36.5%, respectively, while the proportion of these contributors in period 2005--2010 were 66.6% and 34.4%, respectively. Generally, the period 1987--2010 depicted an increasing change, with human activities and precipitation variability contributing 82.6% and 17.4% respectively. Thus, human activities are the major factors causing runoff changes in the LPRB. 5. Conclusions {#sec0090} ============== The monthly, seasonal and annual trends of the runoff in the LPRB depicted that the hydrologic processes have been greatly affected by precipitation variability and anthropogenic activity. The trends revealed that runoff is significantly increasing and has occurred mostly in the dry season. This can be attributed to the mushrooming illegal mining activity which has changed the soil structure, pressure gradient between stream flow and groundwater and vegetation cover. Abrupt change points were identified in 1986, 2000 and 2004. The period of the dry season runoff time series was divided into a reference period (1970--1986) and human-induced periods (1987--2000, 2001--2004 and 2005--2010). The result showed that precipitation variability and human activity like afforestation decreased runoff by 14.8% for the period 1987--2000. The contribution of precipitation variability and human activities to this change are 41.6% and 58.4%, respectively. For the periods 2001--2004 and 2005--2010, there was an increase in runoff at 75.4% and 74.4%, respectively. During the period 2001--2004, precipitation variability and human activities contributed 36.5% and 63.5% respectively to the change in runoff. During 2005--2010, precipitation variability and human activity contributed 33.4% and 66.6%, respectively to the change in runoff. As "galamsey" operations continue, the study area may in future experience flooding during periods of high precipitations due to the reduced infiltration rate. Therefore, reclamation activity by the "galamseyers" must be properly enforced and monitored and concurrently mining inside the river must be stopped. The adopted research method and the linear regression model can be used to investigate and quantify the impact of changing environments on runoff in areas that lack historical data. This research assumed that precipitation variability and anthropogenic activities are independent. This assumption leads to uncertainties since precipitation variability and anthropogenic activities are connected. Future studies must consider these uncertainties to improve the quantitative estimation of impact of precipitation variability and human activities on runoff in the LPRB. Declarations {#sec0095} ============ Author contribution statement {#sec0100} ----------------------------- Alfred Awotwi: Conceived and designed the experiments; Performed the experiments; Analyzed and interpreted the data; Contributed reagents, materials, analysis tools or data; Wrote the paper. Geophrey Kwame Anornu, Jonathan Quaye-Ballard: Performed the experiments; Analyzed and interpreted the data; Contributed reagents, materials, analysis tools or data. Thompson Annor, Eric Kwabena Forkuo: Analyzed and interpreted the data; Contributed reagents, materials, analysis tools or data. Funding statement {#sec0105} ----------------- This work was supported by the Ghana Government and the World Bank under the Africa Centre\'s of Excellence project. Competing interest statement {#sec0110} ---------------------------- The authors declare no conflict of interest. Additional information {#sec0115} ---------------------- No additional information is available for this paper. [^1]: Bolded row = significant trend. [^2]: \+ increasing and − decreasing. [^3]: Bolded row = significant trend. [^4]: \+ increasing and − decreasing. [^5]: Bolded row = time series data showing significant shifts (abrupt change). [^6]: \+ = upward and − = downward. [^7]: Bolded row = time series data showing significant shifts (abrupt change). [^8]: \+ = upward and − = downward. [^9]: Std err = standard error of the difference in slopes. Slope~P1andP2~ = slopes of period 1 and period 2. [^10]: t = test statistic. Slope~P2andP3~ = slopes of period 2 and period 3. [^11]: df = degree of freedom. Slope~P3andP4~ = slopes of period 3 and period 4.

\section{\label{sec1}Introduction} Recently, the diffusion equations that generalize the usual one have received considerable attention due to the broadness of their physical applications, in particular, to the anomalous diffusion. In fact, fractional diffusion equations and the nonlinear fractional diffusion equations have been successfully applied to several physical situations such as percolation of gases through porous media [1], thin saturated regions in porous media [2], standard solid-on-solid model for surface growth [3], thin liquid films spreading under gravity [4], in the transport of fluid in porous media and in viscous fingering [5], modeling of non-Markvian dynamical processes in protein folding [6], relaxation to equilibrium in system (such as polymer chains and membranes) with long temporal memory [7], and anomalous transport in disordered systems [8], diffusion on fractals [9], and the multi-physical transport in porous media, such as electroosmosis[10-11]. The properties concerning these equations have also been investigated. For instance, in [12] boundary values problems for fractional diffusion equations are studied, in [13] a fractional Fokker-Planck equation is derived from a generalized master equation, in [14] the behavior of fractional diffusion at the origin is analyzed and a connection between the Fox H functions and the fractional diffusion equations was investigated in [15]. Also a generalization of Brownian motion to multidimensional anomalous diffusion is considered by using fractional differential equation in [16], and a fractional radial diffusion was considered in [17]. In this direction, we dedicate this work to investigate a fractional diffusion equation which employs space and time fractional derivatives by taking a time-dependent diffusion coefficient, an external force and $\mathcal{N}$-dimensional into account. More precisely, we focus our attention on the following equation \begin{equation} \frac{\pa^{\gamma}}{\pa t^{\gamma}}\rho(x,t)=\int_{0}^{t}dt'\frac{1}{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}D(x,t-t')\frac{\pa^{\mu-1}}{\pa x^{\mu-1}}[\rho(x,t)]^{\nu}\}-\frac{1}{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}F(x)\rho(x,t)\}, \end{equation} where $0 <\gamma \leq1,\mu,\nu\in R$, $\mathcal{N}$ is the number of dimensions, and the diffusion coefficient is given by $D(x,t)=D(t)|x|^{-\theta}$, which is a spatial time-dependent diffusion coefficient, and $F(x)=-\frac{\pa V(x)}{\pa x}$ is an external force (drift) associated with the potential $V(x)$. Here, we use the Caputo operator for the fractional derivative with respect to time $t$ and the Riesz-Weyl operator for the fractional derivative with respect to spatial $x$ [18]. We work with the positive spatial variable $x$. Later on, we will extend the results to the entire real $x$-axis by the use of symmetry (in other words, we are working with ${\pa}/{\pa|x|}$ and ${\pa^{\mu -1}}/{\pa|x|^{\mu -1}}$). Also, we employ, in general, the initial condition $\rho(x,0)=\tilde{\rho}(x)$ ($\tilde{\rho}(x)$ is a given function), and the boundary condition $\rho(x\!\to\!\pm\infty,t)\rightarrow 0$. For Eq.(1), one can prove that $\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dx x^{\mathcal{N}-1}\rho(x,t)$ is time independent (hence, if $\rho (x,t)$ is normalized at $t=0$,it will remain so forever). Indeed,if we write Eq.(1) as $\pa_{t}^{\gamma}=-1/x^{\mathcal{N}-1}\pa_{x}(x^{\mathcal{N}-1}J)$, and, for simplicity, assume the boundary conditions $J(\pm\infty)=0$, it can be shown that $\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dx x^{\mathcal{N}-1}\rho(x,t)$ is a constant of motion (see [19] and references therein). Note that Eq.(1) recovers the usual radial diffusion equation with memory effect for $\gamma=1$. When $(\mu,\gamma,\nu)=(2,1,1)$ and $\mathcal{N}=1$, Eq.(1) recovers the standard Fokker-Planck equation in the presence of a drift taking memory effects and $\mathcal{N}$-dimensional into account. The particular case $F(x)=0$ (no drift) and $D(x,t)=D\delta(t)$ with $(\mu,\gamma)=(2,1)$ has been considered by spohn [3]. The case $D(x,t)=D\delta(t)|x|^{-\theta}$ with $(\mu,\nu)=(2,1)$ and the case $D(x,t)=D(t)$ with $(\mu,\nu)=(2,1)$ have been investigated in [20] and [21], respectively. In [22], the solution for Eq.(1) with the boundary condition $\rho(0,t)=\rho(L,t)=0$ was investigated. Explicit solutions play an important role in analyzing physical situations, since they contain, in principle, precise information about the system. In particular, they can be used as a useful guide to control the accuracy of numerical solutions. For these reasons, we dedicated to this work to investigate the solutions to Eq.(1). We consider different scenarios involving the diffusion coefficient and external force. Firstly, in the case of the absence of external force, we consider a spatial time-dependent diffusion coefficient given by $D(x,t)=D|x|^{-\theta}t^{\alpha-1}/\Gamma(\alpha)$ and $D(x,t)=D|x|^{-\theta}\delta(t)$. Secondly, the presence of external force is investigated, which is given by $F(x)\propto x|x|^{\alpha-1}$. Thirdly, a mixing between the spatial and time fractional derivatives case is investigated. Lastly, we consider a particular case as $\gamma=1$, $D(t)=D\delta(t)$, $F(x)=-\mathcal {K}x$, and $\theta$, $\mu$, $\nu$ arbitraries. In all the above situations, Eq.(1) satisfies the initial condition $\rho(x,0)=\tilde{\rho}(x)$ ($\tilde{\rho}(x)$ is a given function), and the boundary condition $\rho(\pm \infty,t)=0$.The remainder of this paper goes as follow. In Sec.2, we obtain the exact solutions for the previous cases. In Sec.3, we present our conclusions. \section{\label{sec2} Exact solutions for different case} In this section, we start our discussion by considering Eq.(1) in the absence of external force with $D(t)=Dt^{\alpha-1}/\Gamma(\alpha)$ ( $D(t)=D\delta(t)$),$(\mu,\nu)=(2,1)$ and $\gamma$, $\theta$ arbitrary. For this case, Eq.(1) reads \begin{equation} \frac{\pa^{\gamma}}{\pa t^{\gamma}}\rho(x,t)=\int_{0}^{t}dt'D(t-t')\frac{1}{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\{x^{\mathcal{N}-1-\theta}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}{\rho(x,t)}\}. \end{equation} Here, we use the Caputo operator [18] for the fractional derivative with respect to time $t$. By employing the Laplace transform in Eq.(2), we obtain \begin{equation} \frac{1}{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}}\tilde{D}(s)\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\{x^{\mathcal{N}-1-\theta}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\tilde{\rho}(x,s)\}-s^{\gamma}\tilde{\rho}(x,s)=-s^{\gamma-1}\rho(x,0), \end{equation} where $\tilde{\rho}(x,s)=\mathscr{L} \{\rho(x,t)\}$, $\tilde{D}(s)=\mathscr{L}\{D(t)\}$, and $ \mathscr{L}\{f(t)\}=\int_0^\infty dte^{-st}f(t)$ denotes the Laplace transform of the function $f$. This equation can be solved by Green function method [23]. By substituting \begin{equation} \tilde{\rho}(x,s)=\int dx'x'^{\mathcal{N}-1}\tilde{\mathcal {G}}(x-x',s)\tilde{\rho}(x') \end{equation} into Eq.(3), which yields \begin{equation} \frac{1}{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}}\tilde{D}(s)\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\{x^{\mathcal{N}-1-\theta}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\tilde{\mathcal {G}}(x,s)\}-s^{\gamma}\tilde{\mathcal {G}}(x,s)=-s^{\gamma-1}\mathcal {G}(x,0). \end{equation} In order to solve Eq.(5), it is convenient to perform the transform [24] \begin{equation}\label{6} y=A(s)x^{v},\quad \mathcal {G}(x,s)=y^{\delta}Z(y) \end{equation} to translate Eq.(5) into the second-order Bessel equation as \begin{equation}\label{7} y^2\frac{\pa^2 Z}{\pa y^2}+y\frac{\pa Z}{\pa y}-(\lambda^2+y^2)Z(y)=-\frac{y^{\delta+1/v}}{sA(s)^{(\mathcal{N}-1)/v}}\delta((\frac{y}{A(s)})^{\frac{1}{v}}) \end{equation} with parameter $\lambda^2$ under the following conditions: \begin{equation} v=\frac{2+\theta}{2},A(s)=\frac{1}{v}[\frac{s^\gamma}{\tilde{D}(s)}]^\frac{1}{2},\lambda=\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta},\delta=\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}. \end{equation} Since Eq.(5) should fit the boundary condition $\mathcal {G}(\pm\infty,t)=0$, i.e. $\tilde{\mathcal {G}}(\pm\infty,s)=0$, we get the solution of Eq.(5) \begin{equation} \tilde{\mathcal {G}}(x,s)=C(s)y^{\delta}K_{\lambda}(y), \end{equation} where $K_{n}(x)$ is the modified Bessel function of second kind, and $C(s)$ can be determined by the normalization of $\mathcal {G}(x,t)$, i.e. $\int_0^\infty dxx^{\mathcal{N}-1}\tilde{\mathcal{G}}(x,s)=\frac{1}{2s}$. After some calculations, we obtain \begin{equation} \tilde{\mathcal {G}}(x,s)=\frac{2+\theta}{\Gamma(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta})s} (\frac{1}{2+\theta}(\frac{s^{\gamma}}{\tilde{D}(s)})^\frac{1}{2})^{\frac{2+\theta+\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}}|x|^{\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2}} K_{\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}}(\frac{2}{2+\theta}(\frac{s^{\gamma}}{\tilde{D}(s)})^\frac{1}{2}|x|^{\frac{2+\theta}{2}}). \end{equation} here,we have used the formula \begin{equation} \int_0^\infty dy\cdot y^v K_\lambda(ay)=2^{v-1}a^{-v-1}\Gamma(\frac{1+v+\lambda}{2})\Gamma(\frac{1+v-\lambda}{2}). \end{equation} \textbf{ Case 1. } $D(t)=D\delta(t)$, i.e. $\tilde{D}(s)=D$. Since $K_\lambda (x)=\frac{1}{2}H_{0,2}^{2,0}\left[\frac{x^2}{4}\left|_{(-\lambda /2,1)(\lambda /2,1)} \right.\right]$, we can get the Laplace inverse of $\tilde{\mathcal {G}}(x,s)$ by applying the property of the Laplace inverse of Fox function [25], which yields \begin{equation} \mathcal {G}(x,t)=\frac{2+\theta}{2\Gamma(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta})}(\frac{1}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}})^{\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}}H_{1,2}^{2,0}\left[\frac{|x|^{2+\theta}}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}}\left|\begin{array}[c]{cr}(1-\frac{\mathcal{N}\gamma}{2+\theta},\gamma)\\(0,1),&(\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta},1)\end{array}\right.\right], \end{equation} \begin{center} \begin{figure}[thb] \scalebox{1.3}[1.1]{\includegraphics{f1.eps}} \caption{\label{Fig.1} \small{The behavior of $\rho(x,t)$ in Eq.(13) is illustrated by considering $C(\gamma,\theta,\mathcal{N})\mathcal{G}(x,t)$ versus $\frac{x^{2+\theta}}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}}$ for typical values of $\gamma$ and $\theta$, where $C(\gamma,\theta,\mathcal{N})=\frac{2\Gamma(\mathcal{N}/(2+\theta))}{2+\theta}((2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma})^{\mathcal{N}/(2+\theta)}$. Here, for simplicity, we consider $\rho(x,0)=x^{1-\mathcal{N}}\delta(x)$ }} \end{figure} \end{center} where $H_{p,q}^{m,n}\left[x\left|_{(b_1,B_1),...,(b_q,B_q)}^{(a_1,A_1),...,(a_p,A_p)}\right.\right]$ is the FOX function. Thus, we can find the solution by substituting Eq.(12) into Eq.(4), which yields (see fig.1) \begin{equation} \rho(x,t)=\frac{2+\theta}{2\Gamma(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta})}(\frac{1}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}})^{\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}}\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dx'x'^{\mathcal{N}-1}\tilde{\rho}(x')H_{1 ,2}^{2,0}\left[\frac{|x-x'|^{2+\theta}}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}}\left|\begin{array}[c]{cr}(1-\frac{\mathcal{N}\gamma}{2+\theta},\gamma)\\(0,1),&(\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta},1)\end{array}\right.\right]. \end{equation} In Fig.1, we show the behavior of the above equation by considering typical values of $\gamma$, $\mathcal{N}$ and $\theta$ with $\tilde{\rho}(x)=x^{1-\mathcal{N}}\delta(x)$. Note that the solution obtained above leads to an anomalous spreading of the initial condition due to the presence of the time fractional derivative and the spatial time-dependent diffusion coefficient. The present of Fox function in Eq.(5) may be associated to the changes produced on the probability density function for a waiting time that, for this case, has a long tailed behavior, in contrast to the usual one. At this point, it is interesting to analyze the asymptotic behavior of Eq.(13) [25]. For simplicity, we consider $\tilde{\rho}(x)=x^{1-\mathcal{N}}\delta(x)$, so $\rho(x,t)=\mathcal{G}(x,t)$ and the asymptotic behavior of $\rho(x,t)$ is $$\rho(x,t)\sim \frac{2+\theta}{2\Gamma(\mathcal{N}/(2+\theta))}(2-\gamma)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\gamma^{\frac{\mathcal{N}\gamma}{(2+\theta)(2-\gamma)}-\frac{1}{2}}(\frac{1}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}})^{\frac{\mathcal{N}}{(2+\theta)(2-\gamma)}}|x|^{\frac{\mathcal{N}(\gamma-1)}{2-\gamma}}$$ \begin{equation} \times exp(-(2-\gamma)\gamma^{\frac{\gamma}{2-\gamma}}(\frac{|x|^{2+\theta}}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}})^{\frac{1}{2-\gamma}}). \end{equation} In this direction, Eq.(14) can be considered as an extension of the asymptotic behavior of homogeneous and isotropic random walk models [26].\\ \textbf{ Case 2. } $D(t)=\frac{Dt^{\alpha-1}}{\Gamma(\alpha)}$, i.e. $\tilde{D}(s)=Ds^{-\alpha}$. Using the same method as in case 1, we obtain \begin{equation} \mathcal {G}(x,t)=\frac{2+\theta}{2\Gamma(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta})}(\frac{1}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma+\alpha}})^{\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}}H_{1,2}^{2,0}\left[\frac{|x|^{2+\theta}}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma+\alpha}}\left|\begin{array}[c]{cr}(1-\frac{\mathcal{N}(\gamma+\alpha)}{2+\theta},\gamma+\alpha)\\(0,1),&(\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta},1)\end{array}\right.\right], \end{equation} and $$ \rho(x,t)=\frac{2+\theta}{2\Gamma(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta})}(\frac{1}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma+\alpha}})^{\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}}\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dx'x'^{\mathcal{N}-1}\tilde{\rho}(x')$$ \begin{equation} \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \times H_{1,2}^{2,0}\left[\frac{|x-x'|^{2+\theta}}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma+\alpha}}\left|\begin{array}[c]{cr}(1-\frac{\mathcal{N}(\gamma+\alpha)}{2+\theta},\gamma+\alpha)\\(0,1),&(\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta},1)\end{array}\right.\right]. \end{equation} Let us go back to Eq.(1), and consider the external force $F(x)\varpropto x|x|^{\alpha-1}$,$D(x,t)=D\delta(t)|x|^{-\theta}$ and $\mu=2$, $\nu=1$. In this case ,analytical solution can not easily be obtained for a generic $\alpha$, $\theta$. However, for $\theta\neq 0$, and $\alpha+\theta+1=0$. By following the same procedure as the one in the above case, an exact solution can be obtained and it is given by \begin{equation} \rho(x,t)=\frac{2+\theta}{2\Gamma(\frac{\mathcal{N}+\mathcal{K}/D}{2+\theta})\Gamma(\frac{3+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta})}(\frac{1}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}})^{\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta}}H_{1,2}^{2,0}\left[\frac{|x|^{2+\theta}}{(2+\theta)^2 Dt^{\gamma}}\left|\begin{array}[c]{cr}(1-\frac{\mathcal{N}\gamma}{2+\theta},\gamma)\\(\frac{\mathcal{K}}{(2+\theta)D},1),(\frac{2+\theta-\mathcal{N}}{2+\theta},1)\end{array}\right.\right], \end{equation} where, for simplicity, we are considering the initial condition $\rho(x,0)=\delta(x)$, and the external force (drift) $F(x)=\mathcal{K}x|x|^{\alpha-1}$. The second moment is given by $<x^2>\varpropto t^{\frac{2\gamma}{2+\theta}}$, which scales with the exponent $\frac{2\gamma}{2+\theta}$ and clearly depends only on $\gamma$ and $\theta$. So, when $\frac{2\gamma}{2+\theta}<1$, $=1$ and $>1$, the system is sub-diffusion, normal diffusion and supper-diffusion respectively. Let us now discuss Eq.(1) in the presence of the external force by employing a mixing between the spatial and time fractional derivatives. For simplicity, we consider $(\mathcal{N},\nu,\theta)=(1,1,0)$ and $F(x)=-\mathcal{K}x$. For this case, Eq.(1) reads \begin{equation} \frac{\pa^{\gamma}}{\pa t^{\gamma}}\rho(x,t)=\int_0^t dt'D(t-t')\frac{\pa^{\mu}}{\pa x^{\mu}}\rho(x,t')-\frac{\pa}{\pa x}[F(x)\rho(x,t)]. \end{equation} Applying the Fourier and Laplace transform to Eq.(1) and employing the Riez representation for the spatial fractional derivatives, we have \begin{equation} s^{\gamma}\hat{\tilde{\rho}}(k,s)-s^{r-1}\hat{\rho}(k,0)=-\tilde{D}(s)|k|^{\mu}\hat{\tilde{\rho}}(k,s)-\mathcal{K}k\frac{d}{dk}\hat{\tilde{\rho}}(k,s), \end{equation} where $\hat{\rho}(k,t)=\mathcal{F}\{\rho(x,t)\}=\int_{-\infty} ^{+\infty} \rho(x,t)e^{-ikx}dx$ , so $\hat{\rho}(k,0)=1$. Here, we consider the diffusion coefficient given by $D(t)=\frac{Dt^{\alpha-1}}{\Gamma(\alpha)}$, i.e. $\tilde{D}(s)=Ds^{-\alpha}$ and $\rho(x,0)=\delta(x)$. So we have \begin{equation} \hat{\tilde{\rho}}(k,s)=\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n!}(\frac{\tilde{D}(s)|k|^{\mu}}{\mathcal{K}\mu})^n e^{-\frac{\tilde{D}(s)|k|^{\mu}}{\mathcal{K}\mu}}\frac{s^{\gamma-1}}{s^\gamma +n\mu \mathcal{K}}. \end{equation} In order to perform the inverse of Laplace transform on Eq.(20), we express $e^{-z}$ in terms of Fox function, i.e. $e^{-z}=H_{0,1}^{1,0}\left[z\left|_{(0,1)}\right.\right]$. Then we can get the Laplace inverse of $\tilde{\rho}(x,s)$ by applying the property of the Laplace inverse of Fox function [25] \begin{equation} \hat{\rho}(k,t)=\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n!}\int_0^t dt' \frac{1}{t'}H_{1,1}^{1,0}\left[\frac{D|k|^\mu t'^\alpha}{\mathcal{K}\mu}\left|^{(0,-\alpha)}_{(n,1)}\right.\right] E_{\alpha,1}(-n\mu\mathcal{K}(t-t')^{\gamma}), \end{equation} where, $E_{\alpha,\beta}(x)$ is the Mittage-Leffler function defined as $E_{\alpha,\beta}(x)=\sum_{n=0}^\infty \frac{x^n}{\Gamma(n\alpha+\beta)}$ [18]. Here, we used the property of the Laplace transform of convolution formula, i.e. $\mathcal{L}[f\ast g]=f\cdot g$, where $f\ast g=\int_0^t dt'f(t-t')g(t')$. Note that the solution of Eq.(18) is a stationary one given in terms of L$\acute{e}$vy distributions. This feature is a characteristic of the presence of the spatial derivatives in the diffusion equation which changes the probability for a jump length (see [27] and references therein). In order to get the solution for Eq.(18), we need to get the Fourier inverse of $\hat{\rho}(k,t)$. Therefore, we only need to perform the inverse of Fourier transform on $H_{1, 1}^{1,0}\left[\frac{D|k|^\mu t'^\alpha}{\mathcal{K}\mu}\left|_{(n,1)}^{(0,-\alpha)}\right.\right]$. By employing the procedure presented in [28], we have \begin{equation} \mathcal{F}^{-1}\{H_{1 \quad 1}^{1 \quad 0}[\frac{D|k|^\mu t'^\alpha}{\mathcal{K}\mu}|_{(n,1)}^{0,-\alpha}]\}=\frac{1}{\mu\sqrt{\pi}|x|}H_{2,2}^{1, 1}\left[\frac{|x|}{2}(\frac{\mathcal{K}\mu}{Dt'^{\alpha}})^{1/\mu}\left|\begin{array}[c]{cr}(1-n,\frac{1}{\mu}),&(0,\frac{\alpha}{\mu})\\(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}),&(1,\frac{1}{2}) \end{array}\right.\right], \end{equation} and $$ \rho(x,t)=\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\int_0^t dt'\frac{1}{n!\mu\sqrt{\pi}|x|t'}H_{2,2}^{1, 1}\left[\frac{|x|}{2}(\frac{\mathcal{K}\mu}{Dt'^{\alpha}})^{1/\mu}\left|\begin{array}[c]{cr}(1-n,\frac{1}{\mu}),&(0,\frac{\alpha}{\mu})\\(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}),&(1,\frac{1}{2}) \end{array}\right.\right] $$ \begin{equation} \times E_{\alpha,1}(-n\mu\mathcal{K}(t-t')^{\gamma}). \end{equation} Now, we consider a particular case of Eq.(1) for $\gamma=1$ and nonzero values of $\mu$ and $\theta$, and consider a linear drift,i.e. $F(x)=-\mathcal {K}x$. For simplicity, we employ $D(t)=D\delta(t)$ and the initial condition $\rho(x,0)=\delta(x)$, then Eq.(1) yields to \begin{equation} \frac{\pa}{\pa t}\rho(x,t)=\frac{D}{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}|x|^{-\theta}\frac{\pa^{\mu-1}}{\pa x^{\mu-1}}[\rho(x,t)]^{\nu}\}-\frac{1}{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}}\frac{\pa}{\pa x}\{x^{\mathcal{N}-1}F(x)\rho(x,t)\}. \end{equation} Let us investigated time dependent solutions for Eq.(24). We use similarity methods to reduce Eq.(24) to ordinary differential equations. The explicit form for these ordinary differential equations depends on the boundary conditions or restrictions in the form of conservation laws. In this direction, we restrict our analysis to find solution that can be expressed as a scaled function of the type [29] \begin{equation} \rho(x,t)=\frac{1}{\phi(t)^{\mathcal{N}}}\bar{\rho}(z),\quad z=\frac{|x|}{\phi(t)}. \end{equation} Inserting Eq.(25) into Eq.(24), we obtain \begin{equation} -(\frac{\dot{\phi(t)}}{\phi(t)^2}+\frac{\mathcal{K}}{\phi(t)})\frac{\pa}{\pa z}[z^{\mathcal{N}}\bar{\rho}(z)]=\frac{D}{\phi(t)^{\mathcal{N}(\nu-1)+\theta+\mu+1}}\frac{\pa}{\pa z}[z^{\mathcal{N}-1-\theta}\frac{\pa^{\mu-1}}{\pa z^{\mu-1}}\bar{\rho}(z)^{\nu}]. \end{equation} By choosing the ansatz \begin{equation} \frac{\dot{\phi(t)}}{\phi(t)^2}+\frac{\mathcal{K}}{\phi(t)}=\frac{kD}{\phi(t)^{\mathcal{N}(\nu-1)+\theta+\mu+1}}, \end{equation} where $k$ is an arbitrary constant which can be determined by the normalization condition. By solving Eq.(27), we have that \begin{equation} \phi(t)=[(\phi(0))^{\xi}e^{-\xi\mathcal{K}t}+\frac{Dk}{\mathcal{K}}(1-e^{\xi\mathcal{K}t})]^{\frac{1}{\xi}}, \end{equation} where $\xi=\mathcal{N}(\nu-1)+\theta+\mu$. By substituting Eq.(27) into Eq.(26), we obtain \begin{equation} \frac{\pa}{\pa z}[z^{\mathcal{N}-1-\theta}\frac{\pa^{\mu-1}}{\pa z^{\mu-1}}\bar{\rho}(z)^{\nu}]=-k\frac{\pa}{\pa z}[z^{\mathcal{N}}\bar{\rho}(z)]. \end{equation} Then, we perform an integration and the result is \begin{equation} z^{\mathcal{N}-1-\theta}\frac{\pa^{\mu-1}}{\pa z^{\mu-1}}\bar{\rho}(z)^{\nu}=-kz^{\mathcal{N}}\bar{\rho}(z)+\mathcal{C}, \end{equation} where $\mathcal{C}$ is another arbitrary constant. Also, we use the following generic result [30]: \begin{equation} D_{x}^{\delta}[x^{\alpha}(a+bx)^{\beta}]=a^{\delta}\frac{\Gamma[\alpha+1]}{\Gamma[\alpha+1-\delta]}x^{\alpha-\delta}(a+bx)^{\beta-\delta} \end{equation} with $D_{x}^{\delta}\equiv d^{\delta}/dx^{\delta}$ and $\delta=\alpha+\beta+1$. By defining $g(x)\equiv x^{\frac{\alpha}{\nu}}(a+bx)^{\frac{\beta}{\nu}}$ and $\lambda\equiv \alpha(1-\frac{1}{\nu})-\delta$, and rearranging the indices, Eq.(31) can be rewritten as follows: \begin{equation} D_{x}^{\delta}[g(x)]^{\nu}=a^{\delta}\frac{\Gamma[\alpha+1]}{\Gamma[\alpha+1-\delta]}x^{\lambda}g(x). \end{equation} For this case, we consider the ansatz $\bar{\rho}(z)=\mathcal{A}z^{\frac{\alpha}{\nu}}(1+bz)^{\frac{\beta}{\nu}}$. By using the property of Eq.(32) in Eq.(30) and ,for simplicity, choosing $\mathcal{C}=0$, we find $$\alpha=\frac{(2-\mu)(\mu+\theta)}{1-2\mu-\theta},$$ \begin{equation} \beta=-\frac{(\mu-1)(\mu-2)}{1-2\mu-\theta}, \end{equation} $$\nu=\frac{2-\mu}{1+\mu+\theta}.$$ In this case, we have \begin{equation} \rho(x,t)=\frac{\mathcal{A}}{\phi(t)^{\mathcal{N}}}[\frac{z^{(\mu+\theta)(1+\mu+\theta)}}{(1+bz)^{(1-\mu)(1+\mu+\theta)}}]^{\frac{1}{1-2\mu-\theta}}, \end{equation} where $\phi(t)$ is given above,$\mathcal{A}=[-k\frac{\Gamma(-\beta)}{\Gamma(\alpha+1)}]^{\frac{\mu+\theta+1}{1-2\mu-\theta}}$ and $b$ is an arbitrary constant (to be taken, later on, as $\pm1$ according to the specific solutions that are studied). Several regions can be analyzed. For simplicity, we illustrate two of them: $-\infty<\mu<-1-\theta$ with $\theta\geq0$, and $0<\mu<1/2$ with $0\leq\theta<1/2-\mu$. Let us start by considering the region $-\infty<\mu<-1-\theta$. Without loss of generality, we choose $b=-1$. The normalization condition implies(see Fig. 2) \begin{equation} \mathcal{A}\int_{-1}^{1}[\frac{z^{(\mu+\theta)(1+\mu+\theta)}}{(1+bz)^{(1-\mu)(1+\mu+\theta)}}]^{\frac{1}{1-2\mu-\theta}}dz=1. \end{equation} So \begin{equation} \mathcal{A}=\frac{\Gamma[1-\mu-\theta]}{2\Gamma[\frac{\mu^2+\mu\theta-2\theta-2\mu}{1-2\mu-\theta}]\Gamma[\frac{1-\mu+\mu^2+\theta^2+2\mu\theta}{1-2\mu-\theta}]}. \end{equation} \begin{center} \begin{figure}[thb] \scalebox{1.3}[1.1]{\includegraphics{f2.eps}} \caption{\label{FigII} \small{Behavior of $\phi(t)^{\mathcal{N}}\rho(x,t)$ versus $x/\phi(t)$, which illustrates Eq.(32) with typical values for $\mu$ and $\theta$ satisfying $0<\mu<-1-\theta$ and $\theta\geq0$. we notice that the distribution vanishes at the abcissa equal $\pm1$, and remains zero outside of this interval. }} \end{figure} \end{center} Let us now analyze the region $0<\mu<1/2$ with $0\leq\theta<1/2-\mu$. Again without the loss of generality, we choose $b=1$. The normalization condition implies(see Fig. 3) \begin{equation} \mathcal{A}=\frac{\Gamma[\frac{1+\theta-\mu^2-\mu\theta}{1-2\mu-\theta}]}{2\Gamma[\frac{1-\mu+\mu^2+\theta^2+2\mu\theta}{1-2\mu-\theta}]\Gamma[\mu+\theta]}. \end{equation} \begin{center} \begin{figure}[thb] \scalebox{1.3}[1.1]{\includegraphics{f3.eps}} \caption{\label{FigII} \small{Behavior of $\phi(t)^{\mathcal{N}}\rho(x,t)$ versus $x/\phi(t)$, which illustrates Eq.(32) with typical values for $\mu$ and $\theta$ satisfying $0<\mu<1/2$ and $0\leq\theta<1/2-\mu$. we notice that the distribution vanishes at the infinity. }} \end{figure} \end{center} Let us finally mention a connection between the results obtained here and the solutions that arise from the optimization of the nonextensive entropy [31]. These distributions do not coincide for arbitrary value of x. However, the comparison of the $|x|\rightarrow\infty$ asymptotic behaviors enables us to identify the type of Tails. By identifying the behavior exhibited in Eq.(34) with the asymptotic behaviors $1/|x|^{2/(q-1)}$ that appears in [31] for the entropic problem, we obtain \begin{equation} q=\frac{3+\mu+\theta}{1+\mu+\theta}. \end{equation} This relation recovers the situation for $\theta=0$. \section{\label{sec3} Summary and Conclusions} We have analyzed a generalized fractional diffusion equation which presents the spatial and time fractional derivatives, includes a linear external force $F(x)=-\mathcal{K}x$ and a spatial time-dependent diffusion coefficient $D(x,t)=D(t)|x|^{-\theta}$, also takes $\mathcal{N}$-dimensional into account. By using Laplace and Fourier transform, the Green function method and normalized scaled function, we can find the explicit solutions $\rho(x,t)$ which subjects to the natural boundary condition $\rho(\pm\infty,t)=0$ and the initial condition $\rho(x,t)=\tilde{\rho}(x)$. In a word, we have extended the results previously obtained by the other authors by inviting an linear external force, a spatial time-dependent diffusion coefficient and $\mathcal{N}$-dimensional case. We have also discussed the connection with nonextensive statistics, providing the relation between our solutions and those obtained within the maximum entropy principle by using the Tsallis entropy. Finally, we expect that the results obtained here may be useful to the discission of the anomalous diffusion systems where fractional diffusion equations play an important role. {\bf Acknowledgments:} We would like to thank Hangzhou Dianzi University for partial financial support and be grateful to the anonymous referees for useful comments and suggestions. \thebibliography{00} \baselineskip 13pt \bibitem{mur90} M.Muskat, The Flow of Homogeneous Fluid Through Porous Media, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1937. \bibitem{pol96} P.Y. Polubarinova-Kochina, Theory of Ground Water Movement, Princeton University Press,Princeton, 1962. \bibitem{spo93} H. Spohn, J. Phys. 13 (1993) 69. \bibitem{buc00} J.Buckmaster, J.Fluid Mech. 81 ( 1983) 735. \bibitem{gro06} P. Grosfils and J.P. Boon, Physica A 362 (2006) 168. \bibitem{plo04} S.S. Plotkin and P.G. Wolynes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 5015 . \bibitem{cro04} D.S.F. Crothers, D. Holland, Y.P. Kalmykov and W.T. Coffey, J. Mol. Liq. 114 (2004) 27. \bibitem{mez99} R. Metzler, E. Barkai and J. Klafter, Physica A 266 (1999) 343. \bibitem{cam04} D. Campos, V. Mendez and J. Fort, Phys. Rev. E 69 (2004) 031115. \bibitem{wan07} M. Wang and S.Y. Chen, J. Colloids Interface Sci. 314 (2007) 264. \bibitem{wan06} M. Wang, JK. Wang, S.Y. Chen and N. Pan, J. Colloids Interface Sci. 304 (2006) 246. \bibitem{met00} R.Metzler and J. Klafter, Phys. Rep. 339 (2000) 1. \bibitem{met02} R.Metzler and T.F.Nonnenmacher, Chem. Phys. 284 (2002) 67. \bibitem{wes02} B.J.West, M.Bologna and P.Grigolini, Physics of Fractal Operators, Springer, New York, 2002. \bibitem{mai05} F.Mainardi, G.Pagnini and R.K.Saxena, J.Comput.Appl.Math. 178 (2005) 321. \bibitem{uch02} V.V.Uchaikin, Chem. Phys. 284 (2002) 507. \bibitem{ach04} B.N.N.Achar and J.W.Hanneken, J. Mol. Liq. 114 (2004) 147. \bibitem{pod99} I. Podlubny, Fractional differential equations, Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1999. 54 \bibitem{lez03} E.K. Lenzi, L.C. Malacarne, R.S. Mendes and I.T. Pedron, Physica A 319 (2003) 245. \bibitem{len03} E.K. Lenzi, R.S. Mendes, Kwok Sau Fa and L.C.Malacame, J. Math. Phys. 44 (2003) 2179. \bibitem{len04} E.K. Lenzi, R.S. Mendes and Kwok Sau Fa, J. Math. Phys. 45 (2004) 3444. \bibitem{len06} E.K. Lenzi, R.S. Mendes, G. Goncalves, M.K. Lenzi and L.R. da Silva, Physica A 360 (2006) 215. \bibitem{mor53} M.P.Morse and H.Feshbach, Methods of Theoretical Physics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1953. \bibitem{ren06} F.Y. Ren, J.R. Liang, W.Y.Qiu and J.B.Xiao, J.Phys.A:Math.Gen, 39 (2006) 4911. \bibitem{mat78} A.M. Mathai and R.K.Saxtena, The H-function with Application in Statistics and Other Disciplines, Wiley Eastern, New Delhi, 1978. \bibitem{kla91} J.Klafter, G.Zumoften and A.Blumen, J.phys.A 25 (1991) 4835. \bibitem{sch07} A.Schot, M.K.Lenzi, L.R.Evangelista, etal, Phys. Lett. A 366 (2007) 346. \bibitem{lan06} T.A.M.Langlands, Physica A 367 (2006) 136. \bibitem{tsa02} C.Tsallis and E.K.Lenzi, Chemical physics, 284 (2002) 341 \bibitem{bol00} M.Bologna, C.Tsallis and P.Grigolini, Phys.Rev.E 62 (2000) 2213. \bibitem{tsa96} C.Tsallis and D.J.Bukman, Phys.Rev.E 54 (1996) R2197. \end{document}

\section{Introduction} \label{sec_introduction} The Shannon capacity of a channel characterizes the ultimate transmission efficiency limit of reliable communication over a channel \cite{Shannon1948}. It has played a fundamental role in the research of communication theory and directed the development of communication systems for decades. In many scenarios of practical interest, however, the perfect knowledge about a channel may not be available or may not be fully utilized for implementing the transceivers. Important examples include channels with uncertainty (like fading in wireless communication systems) \cite{2002Fading}, with non-ideal transceiver hardware \cite{zhang2011general}, or with constrained receiver structure \cite{salz1995com}. A commonly adopted practice of the receiver under such circumstances is to use a prescribed decoding metric, which may not be matched to the actual channel transition probability, and the mismatch capacity has been introduced to characterize the highest information rate under a prescribed decoding metric; see, e.g., \cite{1998Reliable} \cite{2020Information} and references therein. Unfortunately, the mismatch capacity is still an open problem to date \cite{1995Channel}. So instead of it, researchers have been focusing on deriving its achievable lower bounds. The generalized mutual information (GMI) is a relatively simple lower bound \cite{1993Information}, which has found extensive applications in various setups; see, e.g., \cite{2002Fading} \cite{zhang2011general} \cite{2012Nearest}. However, the LM rate \cite{Merhav1994On} is a tighter lower bound, by replacing the independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) codebook ensemble for the GMI by constant-composition codebook ensemble.\footnote{The LM rate is \textcolor{black}{still not} the tightest lower bound of the mismatch capacity. There are several ways of improving the GMI and the LM rate by considering more structured codebook ensembles \cite{2020Information}. These are beyond the scope of this paper. } From the perspective of optimization, the primal forms of the GMI and the LM rate are highly similar, except that for the LM rate there is an additional constraint on the marginal distribution of the sought-for maximizing joint probability distribution over the input and output alphabets; see, e.g., \cite[Thm. 1]{2000Mismatched}. Consequently, the dual form of the GMI is easy to compute, since it can be written as a maximization over a real number \cite[Eqn. (12)]{2000Mismatched}, which is readily solved by a one-dimensional line search. On the other hand, the dual form of the LM rate further involves a maximization over a function of the channel input \cite[Eqn. (11)]{2000Mismatched}. Consequently the computation of the LM rate is much more challenging, and there is rare work on the numerical computation of the LM rate. Interior point methods (e.g., \cite{sdpt3,2010cvx}) can be applied for computing the LM rate, but it is typically memory intensive and computationally expensive. It is therefore desirable to develop effective computation models and efficient numerical algorithms for the LM rate. In this paper, we formulate the LM rate computation as an optimal transport (OT) problem with an extra constraint, motivated by the similarity between these two optimization problems. Our contribution consists of three parts. First, we propose an OT model with an extra constraint for the LM rate. Second, \textcolor{black}{we show that} this model can be solved directly using the well-known Sinkhorn algorithm \cite{2013sinkhorn}. Since our OT model is strongly convex, no additional regularization is required. This guarantees that we only need \textcolor{black}{several hundred of} Sinkhorn iterations to converge rather than tens of thousands of iterations for classical OT problems. Last, we show that the extra constraint \textcolor{black}{in the OT problem formulation} can be efficiently handled by finding the root of a one-dimensional monotone function, and the feasibility of the extra constraint is guaranteed at each iteration. Numerical experiments show that for the case of QPSK and 16-QAM, our proposed algorithm is efficient and accurate. We also point out that our method is highly scalable and can be easily generalized to large-scale cases, such as 256-QAM. The remaining \textcolor{black}{part} of this paper is organized as follows. In Section \ref{sec_formulation_2}, after briefly reviewing the basic definition of the LM rate, we write it in the form of OT model with an extra constraint. Next, we present the numerical methods for this problem, including the Sinkhorn algorithm and the treatment of the extra constraint in Section \ref{sec_Sinkhorn_3}. In Section \ref{sec_num_4}, the simulation results demonstrate the advantages of our approach. We finally conclude the paper in Section \ref{sec_conclu_5}. \section{Problem Formulation} \label{sec_formulation_2} \subsection{The LM Rate} We consider a discrete memoryless communication channel model with transition law $W(y|x)$ over the (finite, discrete) channel input alphabet $\mathcal{X}= \{x_1,\cdots,x_M\}\subset\mbbR^2$ and the channel output alphabet $\mathcal{Y} \subset\mbbR^2$. Thus, given a probability measure $P_{X}$ on $\mathcal{X}$, we are able to define the joint probability distribution $P_{XY}$ on $\mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{Y}$ and the output distribution $P_{Y}$ on $\mathcal{Y}$ by the following: \begin{align*} & P_{XY}(x_i,B)= W(B|x_i)P_{X}(x_i), ~ \forall B\subset\mathcal{Y}, \\ & P_{Y}(B) = \sum_{i=1}^{M} W(B|x_{i})P_{X}(x_i), ~ \forall B\subset\mathcal{Y}. \end{align*} This discrete memoryless channel is in fact a mapping from the input alphabet $\mathcal{X}$ to the output alphabet $\mathcal{Y}$ with the channel transition law $W(y|x)$. \textcolor{black}{For transmission of rate $R$, a block length-$n$ codebook $\mathcal{C}$ consists of $2^{nR}$ vectors $\mathbf{x}(m) = (x^{(1)}(m),\cdots,x^{(n)}(m))\in\mathcal{X}^{n}$. The encoder maps the message $m$ uniformly randomly selected from the set $\mathcal{M} = \{1,\cdots,2^{nR}\}$ to the corresponding codeword $\mathbf{x}(m)$. After receiving the output sequence $\mathbf{y} = (y^{(1)},\cdots,y^{(n)})$, the decoder forms the estimation on the message $m$ following the decoding rule \begin{equation*} \hat{m} = \argmin_{j\in\mathcal{M}}\sum_{k=1}^{n}d(x^{(k)}(j),y^{(k)}), \end{equation*} where $d : \mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{Y}\to\mbbR$ is a non-negative function called the \textit{decoding metric}.} \textcolor{black}{With the notations defined above, the LM rate, as one of the achievable lower bound of the mismatch capacity, is defined as:} \begin{subequations}\label{IM} \begin{align} I_{LM}(P_{X}) & := \min_{\textcolor{black}{\gamma\in\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{Y})}} D(\gamma\|P_{X}P_{Y}) \label{IM_obj} \\ \textrm{s.t.}\quad \int_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}\gamma(x_i,y) \mathrm{d} y &= P_X(x_i),\ \forall x_i\in\mathcal{X}, \label{IM_Px} \\ \sum_{x_i\in\mathcal{X}}\gamma(x_i,y) &= P_Y(y),\ \forall y\in\mathcal{Y}, \label{IM_PY} \\ \int_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{x_i\in\mathcal{X}}\gamma d(x_i,y) \mathrm{d} y & \le \int_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{x_i\in\mathcal{X}}P_{XY}d(x_i,y) \mathrm{d} y. \label{IM_ineq} \end{align} \end{subequations} Here $D(\cdot\|\cdot)$ denotes the relative entropy function and \textcolor{black}{$\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{Y})$ denotes the set of all joint probability distributions on $\mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{Y}$.} \subsection{The OT Problem} In \eqref{IM}, we can see \textcolor{black}{that} the LM rate is similar to the OT problem \cite{peyre2019computational} in terms of optimization objective and constraints. Naturally, we would like to derive an equivalent OT-type problem to \eqref{IM}, which creates a prerequisite for computing the LM rate by using the Sinkhorn algorithm \cite{2013sinkhorn}. Consider a discrete probability distribution $\mu_i=P_X(x_i)$ on $\mathcal{X}$. It satisfies the following normalization and \textcolor{black}{average} power constraints: \begin{equation}\label{pc} \sum_{i=1}^{M}\mu_{i} = 1,\quad\sum_{i=1}^{M}\mu_{i}\|x_{i}\|_{2}^{2} = 1. \end{equation} \textcolor{black}{For given channel transition law $W(y|x)$ and decoding metric $d(x,y)$, the right-hand side of \eqref{IM_ineq} is a constant:} \begin{equation}\label{const_T} \begin{aligned} T&=\int_{\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{i=1}^{M} P_{XY}(x_i,y)d(x_i,y) \mathrm{d} y \\ &= \int_{\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{i=1}^{M} \mu_{i}W(y|x_i)d(x_i,y) \mathrm{d} y. \end{aligned} \end{equation} Moreover, it is easy to show that \begin{align*} & D(\gamma\|P_{X}P_{Y})=\int_{\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{i=1}^{M} \gamma(x_{i},y)\log\gamma(x_{i},y)\mathrm{d} y-C, \\ & C=\sum_{i=1}^MP_{X}(x_i)\log P_{X}(x_i) +\int_{\mathcal{Y}}P_{Y}(y)\log P_{Y}(y) \mathrm{d} y. \end{align*} By neglecting the constant $C$, minimizing the objective function $D(\gamma\|P_{X}P_{Y})$ is equivalent to maximizing the entropy \begin{equation*} -\int_{\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{i=1}^{M}\gamma(x_{i},y) \log\gamma(x_{i},y)\mathrm{d} y. \end{equation*} Thus, we have obtained the following optimal transport problem \eqref{LM_obj}-\eqref{LM_y} with an extra constraint \eqref{LM_ineq}: \begin{small} \begin{subequations} \label{LM} \begin{align} \min_{\textcolor{black}{\gamma\in\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{Y})}}&\int_{\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{i=1}^{M}\gamma(x_{i},y)\log\gamma(x_{i},y)\mathrm{d} y \label{LM_obj} \\ \textbf{s.t.}~&\int_{\mathcal{Y}}\gamma(x_{i},y) \mathrm{d} y = \mu_i,\quad i = 1,\cdots,M, \label{LM_x} \\ &\sum_{i=1}^{M}\gamma(x_{i},y) = P_{Y}(y),\quad \forall y\in \mathcal{Y}, \label{LM_y} \\ &\int_{\mathcal{Y}}\sum_{i=1}^{M}\gamma(x_{i},y) d(x_i,y)\mathrm{d} y \leq T. \label{LM_ineq} \end{align} \end{subequations} \end{small} \begin{remark} \textcolor{black}{In the classical OT theory, the cost function is only related to distance and should be independent of variables. Thus, \eqref{LM_obj}-\eqref{LM_ineq} is not a standard OT form, since the ``cost function'' $\log\gamma(x_i,y)$ in \eqref{LM_obj} is related to the variables $\gamma(x_i,y)$. However, the optimization objective function \eqref{LM_obj} is obtained by complicated and lengthy inequality scaling of the original problem (2.29) in \cite{2020Information}, which is in standard OT form. For detailed derivation, the interested readers are referred to Chapter 2 in \cite{csiszar2011information}. On the other hand, from the numerical point of view, the optimization problem \eqref{LM_obj}-\eqref{LM_ineq} can be efficiently solved by the Sinkhorn algorithm, which is well-known for its high efficiency in solving OT problems. In these senses, we might as well call \eqref{LM_obj}-\eqref{LM_ineq} an OT problem.} \end{remark} \section{THE Sinkhorn ALGORITHM} \label{sec_Sinkhorn_3} In this section, we turn to the Sinkhorn algorithm for the equivalent OT problem to the LM rate. First, we need to discretize the integral in \eqref{LM}. We might as well consider a set of uniform grid points $\{y_j\}_{j=1}^N$ in $\mathcal{Y}$, and the corresponding rectangular discretization of the integral. This leads to the discrete form of \eqref{LM}: \begin{subequations}\label{OT} \begin{align} \min_{\textcolor{black}{\gamma_{ij}}}\quad&\sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\gamma_{ij}\log \gamma_{ij} \label{OT_obj} \\ \textbf{s.t.}\quad&\sum_{j=1}^{N}\gamma_{ij} = \mu_i ,\quad i = 1,\cdots,M, \label{OT_Px} \\ &\sum_{i=1}^{M}\gamma_{ij} = \nu_j,\quad j = 1,\cdots,N, \label{OT_Py} \\ & \sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N} d_{ij}\gamma_{ij}\le T. \label{OT_ineq} \end{align} \end{subequations} Here $\gamma_{ij}=\gamma(x_i,y_j),\; \nu_j=P_Y(y_j)$ and $d_{ij}=d(x_i,y_j)$. \begin{remark} In this work, we illustrate our key idea through the rectangular \textcolor{black}{formula} with only first-order accuracy for numerical integration. The idea can be easily generalized to a higher-order numerical discretization, e.g., the trapezoid formula. \textcolor{black}{Not only that, the Sinkhorn algorithm, which we will discuss later in this section, only requires minor modifications to be suitable for higher-order discretization.} \end{remark} Introducing the dual variables $\bda\in\mbbR^{M}, \bdb\in\mbbR^{N}$ and $\lambda\in\mbbR^{+}$, the Lagrangian of \eqref{OT} \textcolor{black}{can be written as}: \begin{equation} \begin{aligned} &\mathcal{L}(\gamma; \bda, \bdb, \lambda) = \sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\gamma_{ij}\log\gamma_{ij} +\sum_{i=1}^{M}\alpha_{i}(\sum_{j=1}^{N}\gamma_{ij} - \mu_i)\\ & + \sum_{j=1}^{N}\beta_{j}(\sum_{i=1}^{M}\gamma_{ij} - \nu_j)+\lambda(\sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N}d_{ij}\gamma_{ij} - T). \end{aligned} \end{equation} Taking the derivative of $\mathcal{L}(\gamma; \bda, \bdb, \lambda)$ with respect to $\gamma_{ij}$ \textcolor{black}{leads to} \begin{equation*} \gamma_{ij} = \phi_{i}\Lambda_{ij}\psi_{j}, \end{equation*} in which \begin{equation*} \phi_{i} = \mathrm{e}^{-\alpha_{i}-1/2},\; \psi_{j} = \mathrm{e}^{-\beta_{j}-1/2},\; \Lambda_{ij} = \mathrm{e}^{-\lambda d_{ij}}. \end{equation*} Substituting the above formula into \eqref{OT_Px} and \eqref{OT_Py} yields \begin{equation*} \begin{aligned} &\phi_{i}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\Lambda_{ij}\psi_{j} = \mu_i,\quad i = 1,\cdots,M, \\ &\psi_{j}\sum_{i=1}^{M}\Lambda_{ij}\phi_{i} = \nu_j,\quad j = 1,\cdots,N. \end{aligned} \end{equation*} Since $\Lambda_{ij}>0$, we can alternatively update $\phi_i$ and $\psi_j$ as follows: \begin{subequations}\label{sink_iter} \begin{align} &\phi_{i}^{(\ell + 1)} = \mu_{i}/\sum_{j=1}^{N}\Lambda_{ij}^{(\ell)}\psi_{j}^{(\ell)},\quad i = 1,\cdots,M, \label{sink_px} \\ &\psi_{j}^{(\ell + 1)} = \nu_{j}/\sum_{i=1}^{M}\Lambda_{ij}^{(\ell)}\phi_{i}^{(\ell+1)},\quad j = 1,\cdots,N. \label{sink_py} \end{align} \end{subequations} This iterative formula is the well-known Sinkhorn algorithm \cite{sinkhorn1967diagonal}. Different from the classical OT problem, we need to deal with the extra constraint \eqref{OT_ineq}. By taking the derivative of $\mathcal{L}(\gamma; \bda, \bdb, \lambda)$ with respect to $\lambda$, we have \begin{equation}\label{G_lambda} G(\lambda)\triangleq \sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N} \phi_{i}\psi_{j} d_{ij} \mathrm{e}^{-\lambda d_{ij}} - T=0. \end{equation} Thus, we can update $\lambda$ by finding the roots of \begin{equation*} G(\lambda^{(\ell+1)})\triangleq \sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N} \phi_{i}^{(\ell+1)}\psi_{j}^{(\ell+1)} d_{ij} \mathrm{e}^{-\lambda^{(\ell+1)} d_{ij}} - T. \end{equation*} \textcolor{black}{Noticing} that \begin{equation*} G'(\lambda)= -\sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\phi_{i}\psi_{j}d_{ij}^{2}\mathrm{e}^{-\lambda d_{ij}} < 0, \end{equation*} the function $G(\lambda)$ is monotonic. Thus, The problem of finding the root of $G(\lambda)$ can be easily solved by the Newton's method. The pseudo-code \textcolor{black}{of the proposed algorithm} is present in Algorithm \ref{alg:OT}. \begin{algorithm}[H] \caption{The Sinkhorn Algorithm} \label{alg:OT} \begin{algorithmic}[1] \REQUIRE Decoding metric $d_{ij}$; Marginal distributions $\mu_i, \nu_j$; Iteration number $K$. \ENSURE Minimal value of $\sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\gamma_{ij}\log\gamma_{ij}$. \STATE \textbf{Initialization:} $\bm{\phi} = \mathbf{1}_{M}, \bm{\psi} = \mathbf{1}_{N}, \lambda = 1$; \FOR{$\ell = 1 : K$} \STATE $\Lambda_{ij} \gets \mathrm{e}^{-\lambda d_{ij}}$,\quad $i = 1,\cdots,M,\ j = 1,\cdots,N$ \FOR{$i = 1 : M$} \STATE $\phi_{i} \gets \mu_{i}/\sum_{j=1}^{N}\Lambda_{ij}\psi_{j}$ \ENDFOR \FOR{$j = 1 : N$} \STATE $\psi_{j} \gets \nu_{j}/\sum_{i=1}^{M}\Lambda_{ij}\phi_{i}$ \ENDFOR \STATE Solve $G(\lambda) = 0$ for $\lambda$ with Newton's method \ENDFOR \RETURN $\sum_{i=1}^{M}\sum_{j=1}^{N} \phi_{i}\psi_{j}\Lambda_{ij}\log\left(\phi_{i}\psi_{j} \Lambda_{ij}\right)$ \end{algorithmic} \end{algorithm} Finally, we need to discuss the feasibility of the Sinkhorn iteration, especially \textcolor{black}{under} the extra constraint \eqref{OT_ineq}. Depending on the value of $G(0)$, there are two cases: \begin{itemize} \item $G(0)>0$: In this case, $G(\lambda)=0$ has a unique solution on $(0,+\infty)$ since $G'(\lambda)<0$. Thus the extra constraint \eqref{OT_ineq} is obviously satisfied. \item $G(0)\le 0$: In this case, the extra constraint \eqref{OT_ineq} is already satisfied. We only need to set $\lambda=0$ instead of solving $G(\lambda)=0$ at line 8 of Algorithm \ref{alg:OT}. \end{itemize} % \section{NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS} \label{sec_num_4} In this section, we use the model and algorithm developed in \textcolor{black}{previous sections} to \textcolor{black}{compute} the LM rate for different modulation schemes over the additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) channels \textcolor{black}{subject to rotation and scaling} with the following transition law \begin{equation}\label{awgneq} Y = H X + Z, \ \text{with } Z\sim \mathcal{N}(0,\sigma_{Z}^{2}). \end{equation} The matrix $H\in\mbbR^{2\times 2}$ is a combination of rotation and scaling transformations as \textcolor{black}{ \begin{equation*} H = \begin{pmatrix} \eta_1 & 0 \\ 0 & \eta_2 \end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix} \cos \theta & \sin \theta\\ -\sin \theta & \cos \theta \end{pmatrix}. \end{equation*}} Here the parameters $\eta_1,\;\eta_2$ indicate the scaling of the signal, and the parameter $\theta$ indicates the degree of rotation on the signal. In this work, we consider the case of $\eta_1=1$ and $\eta_2=\eta$. \textcolor{black}{Note that}, the specific values of $\eta$ and $\theta$ can not be priorly known. The decoding metric is $d(x,y) := \|y-\hat{H}x\|_{2}^{2}$, where $\hat{H}$ is an approximation that is based on part of the information we know about $H$. We consider the scenario in which the decoder is unaware of the mismatch effect. Thus, in the decoding rule, \textcolor{black}{we have} $\hat{H}=I$. In the following simulations, we consider two classical modulation schemes: QPSK and 16-QAM. Under the power constraint \eqref{pc}, their constellation points (also known as the alphabet) are illustrated in Fig \ref{Conspoint}. For both cases, all the constellation points in $\mathcal{X}$ are restricted in the region $[-1,1]\times[-1,1]$. \begin{figure}[H] \centerline{\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{data/Constellations.png}} \caption{Constellation points under the power constraint. Left: The QPSK modulation scheme. Right: The 16-QAM modulation scheme.} \label{Conspoint} \end{figure} Meanwhile, according to the channel law \eqref{awgneq}, the channel output \textcolor{black}{alphabet} $\mathcal{Y}$ \textcolor{black}{is} $\mbbR^2$ itself. Under some reasonable assumptions, e.g. $\eta\le 1,\sigma_z^2\le \frac{1}{2}$, we are able to truncate the \textcolor{black}{alphabet} $\mathcal{Y}$ with a \textcolor{black}{sufficiently large region, e.g.} $[-8, 8]\times[-8, 8]$. Correspondingly, we can discretize the \textcolor{black}{region} by a set of uniform grid points $\{y_j\}_{j=1}^{N}$: \begin{equation*} \begin{aligned} y_{r\sqrt{N}+s} &= (-8 + r\Delta y, -8 + (s-1)\Delta y), \Delta y = \frac{16}{\sqrt{N}-1},\\ r &= 0,1,\cdots,\sqrt{N}-1, s = 1,2,\cdots,\sqrt{N}, \end{aligned} \end{equation*} In Algorithm \ref{alg:OT}, the termination condition of the Newton iteration is that the update step size of $\lambda$ is less than $10^{-14}$. Moreover, the $\text{SNR} \triangleq 1/(2\sigma_{Z}^{2})$ is used in the sequel. All the experiments are conducted on a platform with 128G RAM, and one Intel(R) Xeon(R) Gold 5117 CPU @2.00GHz with 14 cores. \subsection{Algorithm Verfication} We first study the convergence of our Sinkhorn algorithm by considering the residual errors of \eqref{sink_iter} and \eqref{G_lambda}: \begin{equation*} \begin{aligned} r_{\phi} &= \sum_{i=1}^{M}|\phi_{i}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\Lambda_{ij}\psi_{j} - \mu_{i}|,\\ r_{\psi} &= \sum_{j=1}^{N}|\psi_{j}\sum_{i=1}^{M}\Lambda_{ij}\phi_{i} - \nu_{j}|,\\ r_{\lambda} &= |G(\lambda)|. \end{aligned} \end{equation*} The parameters are set to \begin{equation} \label{expe01} (\eta,\theta) = (0.9, \pi/18), \; N = 250,000, \; \text{SNR} = 0 \textrm{dB}. \end{equation} \begin{figure}[H] \centerline{\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{data/Res.png}} \caption{The convergent trajectories of the residual error for $r_{\phi}$ (Orange), $r_{\psi}$ (Blue) and $r_{\lambda}$ (Purple). Left: The QPSK modulation scheme. Right: The 16-QAM modulation scheme.} \label{Res} \end{figure} \begin{table*}[ht]\label{compare} \renewcommand\arraystretch{1.25} \centering \caption{Comparison between the Sinkhorn algorithm and CVX. Columns 3-5 are the averaged computational time and the speed-up ratio of the Sinkhorn algorithm. Column 6 is the averaged difference of the LM rate computed by two methods.} \label{Table_cvx} \setlength{\tabcolsep}{6.5mm}{ \begin{tabular}{c|c|c|c|c|c} \toprule \multirow{2}{*}{} & \multirow{2}{*}{$N$} & \multicolumn{2}{c|}{Computational time (s)} & \multirow{2}{*}{Speed-up ratio} & \multirow{2}{*}{Average difference}\\ \cline{3-4} & & Sinkhorn & CVX & &\\%[3pt]只改一行 \hline \multirow{3}{*}{QPSK} & $100$ & $0.37\times10^{0}$ & $2.61\times10^{1}$ & $7.05\times10^{1}$ & $1.99\times10^{-7}$\\ & $225$ & $0.64\times10^{0}$ & $8.66\times10^{1}$ & $1.35\times10^{2}$ & $6.45\times10^{-7}$\\ & $400$ & $1.28\times10^{0}$ & - & - & -\\ \hline \multirow{3}{*}{16-QAM} & $100$ & $0.96\times10^{0}$ & $1.49\times10^{2}$ & $1.55\times10^{2}$ & $4.13\times10^{-7}$\\ & $225$ & $1.96\times10^{0}$ & $9.27\times10^{2}$ & $4.73\times10^{2}$ & $1.37\times10^{-6}$\\ & $400$ & $3.81\times10^{0}$ & - & - & -\\ \hline \multirow{2}{*}{256-QAM} & $100$ & $1.49\times10^{1}$ & - & - & -\\ & $1600$ & $2.24\times10^{2}$ & - & - & -\\ \bottomrule \multicolumn{6}{}{}\\[1pt] \end{tabular}} \end{table*} In Fig. \ref{Res}, we output the convergent trajectories of the residual errors with respect to iteration steps. We can see that the three curves all decrease rapidly and reach the machine accuracy near $250$ iterations. It is worth mentioning that classical OT problems usually require tens of thousands of Sinkhorn iterations to converge. This significantly illustrates the \textcolor{black}{dramatic} efficiency advantage of our OT model and Sinkhorn algorithm. To further illustrate the accuracy and efficiency of the Sinkhorn algorithm for the OT problem \eqref{OT}. We use CVX \cite{2010cvx} as the baseline. The averaged computational time and the averaged difference of the optimal values between the two methods are \textcolor{black}{listed} in Table \ref{Table_cvx}. To reduce the influence of noise, we repeat each experiment for $100$ times. Except for $N$, other parameters are the same as \eqref{expe01}. \textcolor{black}{Since it is difficult for CVX to handle large-scale problems, we restrict $N$ to small scales, e.g. $100,\;225,\;400$ and $1600$.} From the table, we can see the optimal values obtained by the two methods are almost the same. But our Sinkhorn algorithm has a significant advantage (one or two orders of magnitude) in computational speed. Moreover, for slightly larger scale problems, CVX has failed to output convergent results. \subsection{Results and Discussions} Below, we present the computational results of the LM rate under different modulation schemes, different parameters $(\eta,\theta)$, and different SNRs. For comparison, we also present the computational results of GMI \cite{zhang2011general} under the same setup. As we know, GMI is \textcolor{black}{generally lower} than the LM rate \cite{2020Information}. These results not only help us quantitatively understand the relationship between the two rates, but also help verify the correctness of our model and algorithm. In the numerical \textcolor{black}{experiments}, we consider four sets of parameters $(\eta,\theta)$, namely, \begin{equation*} (0.9, \frac{\pi}{18}),\quad (0.9, \frac{\pi}{12}),\quad (0.8, \frac{\pi}{18}), \quad (0.8, \frac{\pi}{12}). \end{equation*} We set $N=250,000$ to \textcolor{black}{ensure} the discretization accuracy. And we use $500$ iterations for each \textcolor{black}{experiment} to ensure the algorithm \textcolor{black}{convergence}. We also repeat each \textcolor{black}{experiment} for $100$ times to reduce the influence of noise. \begin{figure}[H] \centerline{\includegraphics[width=0.40\textwidth]{data/QPSK_Fin.png}} \caption{LM rate (solid) and GMI (dashed) versus SNR for the QPSK modulation scheme under different mismatched cases, including $(\eta,\theta) = (0.9, \pi/18)$ (Purple), $(\eta,\theta) = (0.8, \pi/18)$ (Blue), $(\eta,\theta) = (0.9, \pi/12)$ (Red), and $(\eta,\theta) = (0.8, \pi/12)$ (Orange).} \label{QPSK} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[H] \centerline{\includegraphics[width=0.40\textwidth]{data/16QAM_Fin.png}} \caption{LM rate (solid) and GMI (dashed) versus SNR for the 16-QAM modulation scheme under different mismatched cases, including $(\eta,\theta) = (0.9, \pi/18)$ (Purple), $(\eta,\theta) = (0.8, \pi/18)$ (Blue), $(\eta,\theta) = (0.9, \pi/12)$ (Red), and $(\eta,\theta) = (0.8, \pi/12)$ (Orange).} \label{16QAM} \end{figure} In Fig. \ref{QPSK}, we can see the comparison of the LM rate and GMI verse SNR for the QPSK modulation scheme. We observe that the LM rate is \textcolor{black}{higher} than GMI with the same parameters. Especially when $\text{SNR} > 8$dB, there is about $2\%$ gain in the LM rate. In \textcolor{black}{addition}, as $\eta$ decreases (from $0.9$ to $0.8$) or $\theta$ increases (from $\pi/18$ to $\pi/12$), both LM rate and GMI decrease accordingly. These results agree with intuition. In Fig. \ref{16QAM}, we \textcolor{black}{display} the comparison for the 16-QAM modulation scheme. From this, we can draw the same conclusions as those for Fig. \ref{QPSK}. \section{CONCLUSION} \label{sec_conclu_5} In this paper, we \textcolor{black}{studied} the computation problem of the LM rate, which is a lower bound for mismatch capacity. Our contributions are twofold. First, we showed that the computation of the LM rate \textcolor{black}{can} be reformulated into the Optimal Transport problem with an extra constraint. Second, we proposed a Sinkhorn-type algorithm to solve the above problem. For the extra constraint, we show that it is equivalent to seeking the root of a one-dimensional monotonic \textcolor{black}{function}. Numerical \textcolor{black}{experiments} show that our approach to computing the LM rate is efficient and accurate. Moreover, we can observe a \textcolor{black}{noticeable} gain in the LM rate compared to GMI. \bibliographystyle{bibliography/IEEEtran}

\section{Section Heading} \label{sec:1} Use the template \emph{chapter.tex} together with the document class SVMono (monograph-type books) or SVMult (edited books) to style the various elements of your chapter content. Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations. And please note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. \section{Section Heading} \label{sec:2} Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations. Please note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. Use the standard \verb|equation| environment to typeset your equations, e.g. \begin{equation} a \times b = c\;, \end{equation} however, for multiline equations we recommend to use the \verb|eqnarray| environment\footnote{In physics texts please activate the class option \texttt{vecphys} to depict your vectors in \textbf{\itshape boldface-italic} type - as is customary for a wide range of physical subjects}. \begin{eqnarray} \left|\nabla U_{\alpha}^{\mu}(y)\right| &\le&\frac1{d-\alpha}\int \left|\nabla\frac1{|\xi-y|^{d-\alpha}}\right|\,d\mu(\xi) = \int \frac1{|\xi-y|^{d-\alpha+1}} \,d\mu(\xi) \\ &=&(d-\alpha+1) \int\limits_{d(y)}^\infty \frac{\mu(B(y,r))}{r^{d-\alpha+2}}\,dr \le (d-\alpha+1) \int\limits_{d(y)}^\infty \frac{r^{d-\alpha}}{r^{d-\alpha+2}}\,dr \label{eq:01} \end{eqnarray} \subsection{Subsection Heading} \label{subsec:2} Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references\index{cross-references} and citations\index{citations} as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}. \begin{quotation} Please do not use quotation marks when quoting texts! Simply use the \verb|quotation| environment -- it will automatically be rendered in line with the preferred layout. \end{quotation} \subsubsection{Subsubsection Heading} Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{subsec:2}, see also Fig.~\ref{fig:1}\footnote{If you copy text passages, figures, or tables from other works, you must obtain \textit{permission} from the copyright holder (usually the original publisher). Please enclose the signed permission with the manuscript. The sources\index{permission to print} must be acknowledged either in the captions, as footnotes or in a separate section of the book.} Please note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. \begin{figure}[b] \sidecaption \includegraphics[scale=.65]{figure} \caption{If the width of the figure is less than 7.8 cm use the \texttt{sidecapion} command to flush the caption on the left side of the page. If the figure is positioned at the top of the page, align the sidecaption with the top of the figure -- to achieve this you simply need to use the optional argument \texttt{[t]} with the \texttt{sidecaption} command} \label{fig:1} \end{figure} \paragraph{Paragraph Heading} % Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}. Please note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. For typesetting numbered lists we recommend to use the \verb|enumerate| environment -- it will automatically rendered in line with the preferred layout. \begin{enumerate} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development.} \begin{enumerate} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development.} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development.} \end{enumerate} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development.} \end{enumerate} \subparagraph{Subparagraph Heading} In order to avoid simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}, see also Fig.~\ref{fig:2}. For unnumbered list we recommend to use the \verb|itemize| environment -- it will automatically be rendered in line with the preferred layout. \begin{itemize} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development, cf. Table~\ref{tab:1}.} \begin{itemize} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development.} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development.} \end{itemize} \item{Livelihood and survival mobility are oftentimes coutcomes of uneven socioeconomic development.} \end{itemize} \begin{figure}[t] \sidecaption[t] \includegraphics[scale=.65]{figure} \caption{If the width of the figure is less than 7.8 cm use the \texttt{sidecapion} command to flush the caption on the left side of the page. If the figure is positioned at the top of the page, align the sidecaption with the top of the figure -- to achieve this you simply need to use the optional argument \texttt{[t]} with the \texttt{sidecaption} command} \label{fig:2} \end{figure} \runinhead{Run-in Heading Boldface Version} Use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}. \subruninhead{Run-in Heading Boldface and Italic Version} Use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-refer\-ences and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}\index{paragraph}. \subsubruninhead{Run-in Heading Displayed Version} Use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-refer\-ences and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}\index{paragraph}. \begin{table}[!t] \caption{Please write your table caption here} \label{tab:1} \begin{tabular}{p{2cm}p{2.4cm}p{2cm}p{4.9cm}} \hline\noalign{\smallskip} Classes & Subclass & Length & Action Mechanism \\ \noalign{\smallskip}\svhline\noalign{\smallskip} Translation & mRNA$^a$ & 22 (19--25) & Translation repression, mRNA cleavage\\ Translation & mRNA cleavage & 21 & mRNA cleavage\\ Translation & mRNA & 21--22 & mRNA cleavage\\ Translation & mRNA & 24--26 & Histone and DNA Modification\\ \noalign{\smallskip}\hline\noalign{\smallskip} \end{tabular} $^a$ Table foot note (with superscript) \end{table} \section{Section Heading} \label{sec:3} Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}. Please note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. If you want to list definitions or the like we recommend to use the enhanced \verb|description| environment -- it will automatically rendered in line with the preferred layout. \begin{description}[Type 1] \item[Type 1]{That addresses central themes pertainng to migration, health, and disease. In Sect.~\ref{sec:1}, Wilson discusses the role of human migration in infectious disease distributions and patterns.} \item[Type 2]{That addresses central themes pertainng to migration, health, and disease. In Sect.~\ref{subsec:2}, Wilson discusses the role of human migration in infectious disease distributions and patterns.} \end{description} \subsection{Subsection Heading} % In order to avoid simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}. Please note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. \begin{svgraybox} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts we recommend to use the newly defined class option \verb|graybox| and the newly defined environment \verb|svgraybox|. This will produce a 15 percent screened box 'behind' your text. If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts we recommend to use the newly defined class option and environment \verb|svgraybox|. This will produce a 15 percent screened box 'behind' your text. \end{svgraybox} \subsubsection{Subsubsection Heading} Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}. Please note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. \begin{theorem} Theorem text goes here. \end{theorem} \begin{definition} Definition text goes here. \end{definition} \begin{proof} Proof text goes here. \end{proof} \paragraph{Paragraph Heading} % Instead of simply listing headings of different levels we recommend to let every heading be followed by at least a short passage of text. Further on please use the \LaTeX\ automatism for all your cross-references and citations as has already been described in Sect.~\ref{sec:2}. Note that the first line of text that follows a heading is not indented, whereas the first lines of all subsequent paragraphs are. \begin{theorem} Theorem text goes here. \end{theorem} \begin{definition} Definition text goes here. \end{definition} \begin{proof} Proof text goes here. \end{proof} \begin{trailer}{Trailer Head} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Trailer Head| we recommend to use \begin{verbatim}\begin{trailer}{Trailer Head} ... \end{trailer}\end{verbatim} \end{trailer} \begin{question}{Questions} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Questions| we recommend to use \begin{verbatim}\begin{question}{Questions} ... \end{question}\end{verbatim} \end{question} \eject% \begin{important}{Important} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Important| we recommend to use \begin{verbatim}\begin{important}{Important} ... \end{important}\end{verbatim} \end{important} \begin{warning}{Attention} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Attention| we recommend to use \begin{verbatim}\begin{warning}{Attention} ... \end{warning}\end{verbatim} \end{warning} \begin{programcode}{Program Code} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Program Code| we recommend to use \verb|\begin{programcode}{Program Code}| \verb|\begin{verbatim}...\end{verbatim}| \verb|\end{programcode}| \end{programcode} \begin{tips}{Tips} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Tips| we recommend to use \begin{verbatim}\begin{tips}{Tips} ... \end{tips}\end{verbatim} \end{tips} \eject \begin{overview}{Overview} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Overview| we recommend to use \begin{verbatim}\begin{overview}{Overview} ... \end{overview}\end{verbatim} \end{overview} \begin{backgroundinformation}{Background Information} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Background| \verb|Information| we recommend to use \verb|\begin{backgroundinformation}{Background Information}| \verb|...| \verb|\end{backgroundinformation}| \end{backgroundinformation} \begin{legaltext}{Legal Text} If you want to emphasize complete paragraphs of texts in an \verb|Legal Text| we recommend to use \begin{verbatim}\begin{legaltext}{Legal Text} ... \end{legaltext}\end{verbatim} \end{legaltext} \begin{acknowledgement} If you want to include acknowledgments of assistance and the like at the end of an individual chapter please use the \verb|acknowledgement| environment -- it will automatically be rendered in line with the preferred layout. \end{acknowledgement} \section*{Appendix} \addcontentsline{toc}{section}{Appendix} When placed at the end of a chapter or contribution (as opposed to at the end of the book), the numbering of tables, figures, and equations in the appendix section continues on from that in the main text. Hence please \textit{do not} use the \verb|appendix| command when writing an appendix at the end of your chapter or contribution. If there is only one the appendix is designated ``Appendix'', or ``Appendix 1'', or ``Appendix 2'', etc. if there is more than one. \begin{equation} a \times b = c \end{equation} \input{references} \end{document} \section{Introduction}\label{intro} People are remarkably good at remembering images and their details, even when those images do not hold personal significance or contain recognizable places~\cite{brady2008visual,konkle2010conceptual,konkle2010scene,standing1973learning}. Foundational memory studies and the follow-up computational work~\cite{isola2011understanding,isola2014what,isola2011makes} proved that images have intrinsic traits that make some of them memorable and others forgettable. The earliest computational studies quickly ruled out low-level features like color and contrast and showed that neither aesthetics nor preference explain memorability ~\cite{isola2011understanding, isola2014what, isola2011makes,khosla2015understanding}. And, interestingly, despite people being remarkably consistent in what they remembered and forgot, their subjective judgements about what was memorable versus forgettable were inaccurate~\cite{isola2014what}. Thus, memorability was found to be intrinsic to the images studied, largely independent of the observers and their opinions, and yet not easily described by previously-studied high- or low-level features \cite{rust_understanding_image_memorability}. These discoveries sparked a line of research dedicated to building computational models to understand and predict image memorability. The memorability games first introduced by Isola et al.~\cite{isola2011makes} became the gold standard for collecting objective measurements of human memorability~\cite{bainbridge2013intrinsic,borkin2013makes,bylinskii2015intrinsic,khosla2015understanding} and the basis for memorability datasets that fueled further work on memorability prediction. Driven by the promise of automatic applications for memory manipulation, assistive devices, and more effective visuals, computational models of memorability became more complex and extended to cover many types of stimuli. This chapter will provide an overview of these computational efforts. In Section~\ref{sec:datasets}, we start our discussion with the datasets that power the computational models of memorability. We mention considerations for data curation and provide a list and descriptions of the image memorability datasets available to date, how they were sourced, and which additional properties they contain. Section~\ref{sec:models} provides an overview of different model designs, from support vector machines to different types of neural networks (including CNNs, RNNs, and GANs). We discuss model design considerations, including interpretability, and provide a curated list of the top-performing published models. In Section~\ref{sec:features}, we cover our current understanding about which features of images and videos make them more or less memorable, from low-level pixel features to semantic and contextual features, including objects, saliency, motion, and emotion. We wrap up with a discussion of applications in Section~\ref{sec:applications}, future directions for research in Section~\ref{sec:future}, and our proposed unifying explanation for the ``magic sauce'' of memorability in Section~\ref{sec:conclusion}. \section{Datasets: from visual content to scores}\label{sec:datasets} Data is at the heart of most computational models. A good dataset can make a simple model shine; a poor dataset will undercut even the most apt modeling decisions. We begin this chapter with a discussion of the factors that are important for collecting a memorability dataset, followed by a brief overview of existing datasets. Memorability scores for the stimuli in all these datasets were collected using a variation on the memory game protocol from the seminal memorability paper by Isola et al.~\cite{isola2011makes}. This section will focus on the stimuli used for the memorability games. Designing datasets for memorability studies requires careful data curation, so that neither the insights obtained from the analyses nor the models trained on this data are biased due to confounding variables. The following properties should be considered: \begin{itemize} \item \textbf{Diversity}. Collecting stimuli with good variability along the relevant feature axes will facilitate spread in the human memorability scores and allow models to learn a more robust signal from the data~\cite{khosla2015understanding}. Even within a single scene category, images can vary in terms of the objects contained, the viewing angle, the amount of light, etc.~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,goetschalckx2019memcat}. \item \textbf{Quantity}. Having a large number of stimuli will have two benefits: (i) the effects of confounding variables have a larger chance of being washed out, and (ii)~larger, more powerful models can be trained when more data is available. The best performing models today are particularly data-hungry neural networks~\cite{fajtl2018amnet,khosla2015understanding,perera2019image}. Having a sufficient number of participant responses per stimuli is also important, as having too few participants can produce an artificially low split-half consistency value. The Spearman-Brown formula \cite{Spearman_1910, Brown_1910, goetschalckx2018longer} can be used to calculate an appropriate number of responses to collect in order to reach a stable value for split-half consistency. \item \textbf{Balance}. It is important to decide up front whether to explicitly balance the data by having similar numbers of exemplars per category~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,goetschalckx2019memcat} or to sample according to some natural distribution (e.g., sampling photos of faces according to names from the U.S. census~\cite{bainbridge2012establishing}). If a dataset has cluttered indoor scenes, one can consider the addition of cluttered and uncluttered outdoor as well as uncluttered indoor scenes~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic}. For specialized datasets like faces, consider genders and races~\cite{bainbridge2012establishing}; for graphic designs, figures, or visualizations, consider publication sources and design categories~\cite{borkin2013makes}. Building off prior work can help balance for visual features and semantic content that has been previously found to drive memorability (e.g., the presence of faces, emotional content, zoomed-in objects, etc.; see Section~\ref{sec:features}). \end{itemize} Further, there are a number of considerations at play when assembling the stimuli for use in memorability studies. They are outlined below. \textbf{Permissions and appropriateness}. Stimuli used in memorability datasets are often drawn from previously-curated open-source datasets used in computer vision, including the SUN scenes dataset \cite{isola2011understanding,xiao2010sun}, Aesthetic Visual Analysis (AVA) \cite{khosla2015understanding,murray2012ava}, Abnormal Objects \cite{khosla2015understanding,saleh2013object}, or Moments in Time \cite{monfort2019moments, newman2020memento}. As with any image or video dataset, it is important to take care that you have permission to use and share the stimuli before publishing your data and to filter for quality and appropriateness. \textbf{Filtering to avoid confounds}. Once sourced, some preprocessing of the data may be required, in particular to guarantee that irrelevant factors (e.g., the size, aspect ratio, image quality, or speed - in the case of videos) are held constant, to avoid confounding the results. Some of the processing, including cropping image size~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,isola2011makes} can be done automatically, while the rest may require manual curation. This type of curation can be amenable to crowdsourcing tasks (e.g., removing stimuli with undesirable properties like watermarks, special effects, etc.~\cite{newman2020memento}). \textbf{Controlling for familiarity}. Finally, the memorability studies described in this work assume that participants are seeing the stimuli for the first time. To avoid confounding familiarity effects, it may be necessary to filter the dataset ahead of time to remove landmarks, faces, artwork, and other potentially recognizable content. \subsection{Consistency across participants} Many studies have confirmed that the memorability of visual stimuli - be they natural scenes, portraits, visualizations, objects, or actions - is remarkably consistent across viewers (Figure~\ref{fig:consistency}). This level of consistency between participants is itself roughly consistent across studies with different participant groups and stimulus sets, as shown in Table~\ref{tab:datasets}. Consistency is measured as the Spearman rank correlation between memorability rankings produced by different groups of participants, and falls in the range 0.68-0.83 for image datasets and 0.57-0.73 for video datasets. Note that split-half consistency tends to increase with number of participants and levels off with sufficient data points. Early studies~\cite{isola2011understanding,isola2014what,isola2011makes} showed that indoor images with people are consistently more memorable than natural scene images, but this observation did not fully account for inter-observer consistency. Later, studies run within-category, where only indoor images of a single scene category were shown (e.g., kitchens), continued to exhibit similarly high inter-observer consistency scores~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic}. Analogous levels of consistency were observed once scene and object classes were more carefully controlled for~\cite{dubey2015makes,goetschalckx2019memcat,9025769}. Specialized image sets including face images~\cite{bainbridge2013intrinsic} and information visualizations~\cite{borkin2013makes}, as well as video datasets \cite{cohendet2019videomem, newman2020memento}, maintained high inter-observer consistency, once again validating the intrinsic nature of memorability. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[width=0.8\linewidth]{Figures/consistency.png} \caption{Consistency is evaluated by randomly splitting the participants in a memorability experiment in half, computing memorability scores based on the data from each set of participants separately, and ranking the dataset images according to those scores. The correlation between the sets of rankings is reported. This procedure is repeated for multiple splits, and the results are averaged to produce the final consistency score ($\rho$).} \label{fig:consistency} \end{figure} High inter-observer consistency means that memorability scores are eligible for automatic prediction. The rest of this section will go into greater detail about how the stimuli for these memorability studies were collected and the additional annotations that they contain, which will be useful for the computational analyses and models in the following sections. \begin{table}[!t] \caption{Image and video memorability datasets.} \label{tab:datasets} \begin{tabular}{p{3.0cm}p{1.1cm}p{1.1cm}p{6.1cm}} \hline\noalign{\smallskip} Dataset & Num. Stimuli & $\rho^*$ & Type of stimuli \\ \noalign{\smallskip}\svhline\noalign{\smallskip} SUN (2011) \cite{isola2011makes} & 2,222 & 0.75 & Mixed photographs \\ Face Mem. (2013) \cite{bainbridge2013intrinsic} & 2,222 & 0.68 & US adult faces \\ MASSVIS (2013) \cite{borkin2013makes} & 393 & 0.83 & Data visualizations and infographics \\ FIGRIM (2015) \cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic} & 1,754 & 0.74 & Scenes from 21 indoor and outdoor categories \\ Object Mem. (2015) \cite{dubey2015makes} & 850 & 0.76 & Scenes with object segmentations \\ LaMem (2015) \cite{khosla2015understanding} & 60,000 & 0.68 & Diverse images from other computer vision datasets\\ MemCat (2019) \cite{goetschalckx2019memcat} & 10,000 & 0.78 & 5 broad image categories (+ sub-categories) \\ VISCHEMA (2019) \cite{akagunduz2019defining} & 800 & - & Subset of FIGRIM with additional annotations \\ LNSIM (2020)~\cite{9025769} & 2,632 & 0.78 & Natural outdoor scenes without salient objects \\ \hline Movie Mem. (2018)~\cite{cohendet2018annotating} & 660 & 0.57 & Video clips from previously-seen films \\ VideoMem (2019)~\cite{cohendet2019videomem} & 10,000 & 0.62 & Seven-second video clips \\ Memento10k (2020)~\cite{newman2020memento} & 10,000 & 0.73 & Three-second, dynamic video clips \\ \noalign{\smallskip}\hline\noalign{\smallskip} \end{tabular} $^*$ Consistency refers to inter-observer split-half consistency in the hit rates (HR), measured with Spearman correlation, and reported as $-1 \leq \rho \leq 1$. The number of stimuli listed in the table above corresponds to those with memorability scores (on which consistency scores could be calculated). Many of the datasets above also contain a larger number of curated stimuli without memorability scores, used as fillers in the memorability games. Other studies~\cite{khosla2015understanding,newman2020memento} used the same stimuli as targets and fillers for different participants, thereby not requiring separate sets of stimuli. \end{table} \subsection{Natural scenes} The original memorability dataset by Isola et al.~\cite{isola2011makes} contains a random sampling of scene categories from the SUN dataset~\cite{xiao2010sun}, of which 2,222 images have memorability scores. The images were resized and cropped to the same size, so that neither size nor aspect ratio acted as confounding variables. They also come with human-annotated object segmentation labels \cite{russell2008labelme}, which were originally used to correlate memorability with various object classes. A follow-up work by Isola et al.~\cite{isola2014what} also collected aesthetic and interestingness judgements for each of these images, as well as subjective judgements as to whether humans consider them memorable. The FIGRIM dataset~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic} sampled scene categories in a more targeted way. It represents 21 indoor and outdoor SUN scene categories, each of which has sufficient exemplars at sufficient resolution (at least 700x700 pixels; as above, images were preprocessed to a consistent size before the experiment). Memorability scores were collected for 1,754 target images. An additional 7,674 filler images are available. LNSIM~\cite{9025769} was a dataset intended to capture the memorability of scenes without the confounding effects of salient and memorable objects. Towards this goal, the authors collected images from MIR Flickr~\cite{huiskes2008mir}, AVA~\cite{murray2012ava}, affective images~\cite{machajdik2010affective}, the image saliency datasets MIT1003~\cite{judd2009learning} and NUSEF~\cite{ramanathan2010eye}, and SUN~\cite{xiao2010sun}. They further filtered the images to ``only be composed of outdoor natural scenes not having any human, animal and man-made object''. Memorability scores for 2,632 images were measured based on an average of 80 observers per image and calculated using the same procedure as the LaMem dataset~\cite{khosla2015understanding}. The images come hand-tagged with scene category labels from 71 scene categories obtained from WordNet~\cite{miller1995wordnet}. \subsection{Diverse photographs} LaMem~\cite{khosla2015understanding} is the largest and most varied image memorability dataset collected to date (Figure~\ref{fig:lamem}). Its size--60k images with memorability scores--makes it particularly effective for training machine learning models. Its images come from MIR Flickr~\cite{huiskes2008mir}, AVA~\cite{murray2012ava}, affective images~\cite{machajdik2010affective}, the image saliency datasets MIT1003~\cite{judd2009learning} and NUSEF~\cite{ramanathan2010eye}, SUN~\cite{xiao2010sun}, an image popularity dataset~\cite{khosla2014makes}, the Abnormal Objects dataset~\cite{saleh2013object}, and PASCAL~\cite{farhadi2009describing}. Thus, these images contain a variety of object and scene types and vary in aesthetic and affective value. Since subsets of the LaMem images contain additional labels, Khosla et al.~\cite{khosla2015understanding} were able to analyze how a variety of factors correlated with memorability, including popularity scores~\cite{khosla2014makes}, eye fixations~\cite{judd2009learning}, emotions~\cite{machajdik2010affective}, and aesthetic scores~\cite{murray2012ava}. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[width=1\linewidth]{Figures/LaMem.png} \caption{LaMem~\cite{khosla2015understanding} contains 60k images sampled from different computer vision datasets varying in the types of scenes and objects portrayed, as well as in aesthetic and affective value. All images are provided with collected memorability scores.} \label{fig:lamem} \end{figure} The MemCat image set has a category-based structure, with images belonging to five broad semantic categories (animal, food, landscape, sports, and vehicle), each with at least 20 sub-categories (e.g., animal: bear, duck; food: burrito, salad; landscape: desert, lake; sports: baseball, surfing; vehicle: airplane, train). While the broad category labels explained roughly 40\% of the variance in the MemCat scores, images of the same category still differed consistently in memorability. With 2K images per category, one of MemCat's intended uses is to promote further research into within-category memorability variance. Images were taken from ImageNet \cite{deng2009imagenet}, COCO \cite{lin2014coco}, SUN \cite{xiao2010sun}, and the Open Images Dataset \cite{kuznetsova2018open}. The source data sets offer additional annotations such as bounding boxes or segmentation maps. Finally, the authors took care to account for potentially confounding influences including the presence of people in non-people categories, large readable text, oddities, etc. Dubey et al.~\cite{dubey2015makes} sampled images from the PASCAL-S dataset~\cite{li2014secrets}, a fully segmented subset of PASCAL VOC 2010~\cite{everingham2011pascal}, and cleaned up the segmentations to only contain clearly-visible, complete, and nameable objects. The resulting dataset contains 850 images with a total of 3,412 segmented objects ($\sim$4 objects per image). Rather than capturing the memorability of whole images using the set-up from prior work~\cite{isola2011makes}, whereby images presented for encoding and recognition are interspersed, Dubey et al. first showed participants whole images in an encoding stage, followed by individual objects (extracted from images) in a recognition stage to capture the memorability of individual objects~\cite{dubey2015makes}. As shown in~\cite{goetschalckx2018longer}, memorability rankings collected with an interspersed paradigm versus a paradigm with separate stages are highly correlated. \subsection{Specialized image collections} The original studies on scene memorability~\cite{isola2011understanding,isola2011makes} sparked research on specialized stimuli collections, including faces and information visualizations. The 10k US Adult Faces Database~\cite{bainbridge2012establishing,bainbridge2013intrinsic} contains 10,168 face photographs obtained by sampling the US Census for first and last names and downloading color face photographs available via Google Image Search, manually filtered to exclude celebrities, children, and low-quality or unusual images. The resulting database follows the gender, age, and race distributions of the adult US population. For 2,222 face photographs, memorability scores were collected, along with another 20 facial and personality traits (using a crowdsourcing survey). Bainbridge et al.~\cite{bainbridge2013intrinsic} then reported which of these traits were correlated with face memorability. Borkin et al.~\cite{borkin2013makes} collected a total of 2,070 data visualizations and infographics from different publication sources, which were then hand-tagged with taxonomic category (bar graph, table, diagram, map, etc.). Memorability scores were collected using the standard study setup for 393 of these visualizations, which were also hand-tagged with multiple attributes (clutter, colorfulness, etc.). Follow-up work~\cite{borkin2015beyond} segmented the visualizations into components (using LabelMe~\cite{russell2008labelme}), and obtained eye movements as well as captions about the visualizations from memory. Additional memorability scores were collected using a modified study setup and longer viewing durations (10 seconds/image), to account for the increased information content in visualizations compared to natural images. \subsection{Videos} Large-scale video memorability datasets have emerged to spur research into memorability of dynamic stimuli. The currently available datasets have focused on short video clips (<10 seconds) that are treated as discrete stimuli without audio for the purposes of continuous-recognition memorability experiments. VideoMem \cite{cohendet2019videomem} consists of 10,000 seven-second video clips taken from raw footage intended for reprocessing into advertisements or television shows. As such, the videos consist primarily of staged, professionally-shot scenes. VideoMem features a variety of content including people, animals, inanimate objects, and nature scenes. It contains memorability scores at two different delays: a short delay (a few minutes after viewing) and a longer delay (a couple days after viewing) to enable study into how memorability rankings may or may not reorder over time. Memento10k \cite{newman2020memento} contains three-second ``in-the-wild'' video clips. These videos were originally posted to media sharing sites like YouTube and Flickr. They were then manually filtered to remove objectionable content or artificial artifacts like captions, cartoons or post-processing. Like VideoMem, Memento10k contains varied semantic content, encompassing people, animals, objects, and landscapes; however, because the videos were shot by laypeople, Memento10k encompasses more variability in levels of motion and video quality. For each Memento video, five human-written captions were collected describing the contents of the clip. Earlier work on computational video memorability attempted to identify the features that contributed to memorability, but often relied on smaller datasets and paradigms that were more challenging to scale than the popular continuous-recognition experiments. Cohendet et al.~\cite{cohendet2018annotating} collected the Movie Memorability Dataset, which measures long-term memorability over weeks or years using clips from popular movies. Their experimental setup differs somewhat from the traditional memory game experiment in that the first viewing of the stimuli took place before the start of the experiment, and viewing delay was estimated by asking participants when they had watched the movie in question. The authors found that semantic features derived from video captions were most correlated with the memorability scores of these clips. Han et al.~\cite{han2015fmri} leveraged fMRI data obtained from participants viewing videos in order to produce a computational model that aligns audiovisual features with brain data. Shekhar et al.~\cite{shekhar2017show} derived memorability ratings for 100 videos using response time on a verbal recall task, and explored the contribution of deep, semantic, saliency, spatio-temporal, and color features to predict these scores. \section{Models: from pixels to features}\label{sec:models} In the last section we discussed that memorability can be treated as an image-computable measure, largely independent of the observer. In this section we review the range of computational models that have been applied to predicting image and video memorability, from the more traditional machine learning models to state-of-the-art deep neural networks. In all cases, these models have been trained on memorability datasets and evaluated on either a held-out portion of the same dataset or on a separate memorability dataset altogether. A summary of the different image memorability models is provided in Table~\ref{tab:immodels}, with the reported prediction scores taken directly out of the published papers (whenever available). Similarly, Table~\ref{tab:vidmodels} contains the prediction scores of video memorability models. \begin{table} \centering \caption{Model performance on image memorability prediction, as reported in past papers. This is the Spearman correlation between the predicted and measured memorability scores, with human upper bound defined as inter-observer consistency.} \label{tab:immodels} \begin{tabular}{llll} \hline\noalign{\smallskip} \multicolumn{1}{c}{Model} & \multicolumn{3}{c}{Dataset} \\ & LaMem~\cite{khosla2015understanding} & SUN~\cite{isola2011makes} & Figrim~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic} \\ \noalign{\smallskip}\svhline\noalign{\smallskip} Human (upper bound) & 0.68 & 0.75 & 0.74 \\ \hline MemBoost~\cite{perera2019image} & 0.67 & 0.66 & 0.57 \\ AMNet~\cite{fajtl2018amnet} & 0.68 & 0.65 & - \\ MemNet~\cite{khosla2015understanding} & 0.64 & 0.63 & - \\ CNN-MTLES~\cite{jing2016predicting} & 0.50 & - & -\\ MemoNet~\cite{baveye2016deep} & - & 0.64 & -\\ Hybrid-CNN+SVR~\cite{zarezadeh2017image} & - & 0.62 & -\\ Mancas \& Le Meur~\cite{mancas2013memorability} & - & 0.48 & -\\ Isola~\cite{isola2011makes} & - & 0.46 & - \\ \end{tabular} \end{table} \begin{table} \centering \caption{Model performance on video memorability prediction.} \label{tab:vidmodels} \begin{tabular}{lll} \hline\noalign{\smallskip} \multicolumn{1}{c}{Model} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{Dataset} \\ & VideoMem (val)~\cite{cohendet2019videomem} & Memento10k (test)~\cite{newman2020memento} \\ \noalign{\smallskip}\svhline\noalign{\smallskip} Human (upper bound) & 0.616 & 0.730 \\ \hline SemanticMemNet~\cite{newman2020memento} & 0.556 & 0.663 \\ VideoMem-Semantic~\cite{cohendet2019videomem} & 0.503 & 0.552 \\ MemNet (frames baseline) \cite{khosla2015understanding} & 0.425 & 0.485 \\ \end{tabular} \end{table} \subsection{Support Vector Machines} Before neural networks became the tool of choice for many computer vision prediction tasks, a common machine learning approach was to extract low-level feature descriptors like GIST~\cite{oliva2001modeling}, HOG~\cite{dalal2005histograms} or SIFT~\cite{lowe2004distinctive} from images, often at multiple spatial scales~\cite{lazebnik2006beyond}, and then to train a Support Vector Machine (SVM) to map from the assembled feature vectors to the target labels. For problems with real-valued labels (like memorability scores), Support Vector Regression (SVR) was used instead~\cite{drucker1996support,fan2008liblinear}. In the case of memorability, it was found that HOG2x2~\cite{khosla2012memorability,wang2010locality} was one of the most predictive automatic image features when used with a linear SVR machine~\cite{isola2014what,khosla2013modifying,khosla2012memorability}. \textbf{Differential weighting of features}: Instead of extracting image features from the image as a whole, another approach is to differentially weight features obtained from different regions of an image, if there is good reason to suppose that certain image regions should contribute more to the prediction. For instance, multiple studies have reported that not all image regions are remembered equally well~\cite{akagunduz2019defining,khosla2012image}. Akagunduz et al.~\cite{akagunduz2019defining} explicitly ask participants in a memory task to indicate which regions made them recognize an image. Pooling this information across participants results in consistent ground truth maps which the authors call Visual Memory Schemas (VMS). They report that spatially pooling and weighting image features (e.g., GIST, SIFT, HOG) by the VMS not only yields better SVR predictions than without doing spatial pooling, but also outperforms spatial pooling and weighting with eye-fixation maps or saliency maps. In later work, the authors also propose a way to predict the VMS of an image itself \cite{kyledavidson2020predicting, kyledavidson2020generating}. Inspired by the observation that visual attention is highly related to memory~\cite{hollingworth2002accurate,hollingworth2001see,wolfe2007visual}, some work has also looked at spatially pooling visual features based on computational saliency maps~\cite{celikkale2015predicting}. \begin{svgraybox} \textbf{What is SVM and SVR?} \\ \\ A Support Vector Machine (SVM) is a machine learning model that classifies data points by finding a hyperplane in feature space that separates the training data into different categories. At training time, the SVM takes in labeled training points and finds a decision boundary that correctly separates the data with the biggest possible margin, or distance between the data and the correct side of the boundary. At test time, prediction involves determining which side of the decision boundary the test points are on in order to assign them a label. Support Vector Regression (SVR) extends the formulation of SVMs to regression problems with real-valued labels, instead of class labels, by finding the hyperplane that best fits the greatest number of training points. At test time, prediction involves finding the point on the hyperplane corresponding to the test data point. \end{svgraybox} \subsection{Convolutional Neural Networks} \textbf{Deep features}: Deep representations learned by convolutional neural networks (CNNs) have proven to be the most successful computational features at approximating human memorability~\cite{dubey2015makes,khosla2015understanding,shekhar2017show}. These features are extracted from a layer (most commonly the penultimate one) of a pre-trained neural network, which has often been trained for the task of ImageNet~\cite{russakovsky2015imagenet} classification. Later layers of neural networks are known to capture image semantics, in the form of distributions of objects over the image~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,sharif2014cnn}. For instance, Dubey et al.~\cite{dubey2015makes} used features extracted from the AlexNet CNN~\cite{krizhevsky2012alexnet} trained on ImageNet to predict object memorability. Apart from using CNNs for prediction, there is a second way in which CNNs can provide insight into memorability: as a model for the way memorability emerges from neural processing in the brain \cite{rust_understanding_image_memorability, Jaegle2019}. In particular, Jaegle et al.~\cite{Jaegle2019} found that in the later layers of a CNN trained for image classification, the response magnitude of nodes in the network correlate with memorability. This is consistent with the authors' observation that population response magnitude in the IT cortex of the (monkey) brain predicts memorability. \textbf{Transfer learning}: Transfer learning is a common strategy that can increase model performance when the target task--in our case, memorability prediction--has a relatively small dataset. The simplest form of transfer learning involves pre-training a network on a task for which a large dataset is available and then fine-tuning some subset of the network's layers on the target task with the target dataset. MemNet~\cite{khosla2015understanding}, for example, is based on the AlexNet architecture~\cite{jia2014caffe,krizhevsky2012alexnet} that was pre-trained for a classification task on a 3.6-million image dataset consisting of a combination of ImageNet~\cite{russakovsky2015imagenet} and Places~\cite{zhou2014learning}. Only then was it fine-tuned on the 60k-image LaMem dataset to predict real-valued memorability scores~\cite{khosla2015understanding}. Similarly, MemoNet~\cite{baveye2016deep} is a fine-tuned GoogleNet model~\cite{szegedy2015going}. AMNet~\cite{fajtl2018amnet} includes as a backbone a fine-tuned ResNet model~\cite{he2016deep}. Perera et al.~\cite{perera2019image} found that fine-tuning the last (regression) layer performed better than fine-tuning or retraining the whole network, because this approach was less likely to suffer from over-fitting to the training set. Video models have turned to even more complex pre-training regimes. SemanticMemNet~\cite{newman2020memento}, which predicts video memorability, contains an image-based stream that was pre-trained on ImageNet and LaMem, as well as video and optical flow streams pre-trained on ImageNet and Kinetics~\cite{carreira2017kinetics}. The semantic embedding model from~\cite{cohendet2019videomem} used as its base a video captioning model~\cite{engilberge2019sodeep} that was also pre-trained on LaMem. \textbf{Size matters}: Perera et al.~\cite{perera2019image} experimentally confirmed that the more powerful classification networks performed better on memorability prediction (i.e., AlexNet performing worst, and ResNet152~\cite{he2016deep} best). As CNN architectures continue to improve, we may find that more powerful backbones contribute to improved performance on memorability prediction, particularly in the relatively new domain of video prediction. However, the amount of data available is an important factor as well. As a case in point, Khosla et al.~\cite{khosla2015understanding} found that when fine-tuning on the larger LaMem dataset, the resulting network performed better on both LaMem and SUN datasets, even compared to a network trained and tested on the SUN dataset. This is because having too little data with which to train or fine-tune can result in model over-fitting, which reduces the generalization ability of the network on held-out data, regardless of which dataset it comes from. \begin{svgraybox} \textbf{What is a CNN?} \\ \\ A Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) is a machine learning model that learns a very complex function to map an input--often an image or video--to a desired output, given a large dataset. It works by applying a sequence of linear and non-linear operations to the input. In a CNN, the linear operations are most frequently convolutions, thus giving the model its name. Each operation is defined by a set of parameters or weights, which must be learned from the training data. The learning process involves optimizing the output of the network in order to minimize some loss function (for example, a classification or regression loss) using gradient descent. Once trained, the sequence of operations with learned parameters can be applied to a new input to produce the final prediction. The sheer number of degrees of freedom in these models (due to the number of operations and parameters), as well as the sophisticated optimization algorithms used for training them, make for powerful models that are popular for a large range of tasks. \end{svgraybox} \subsection{Recurrent Neural Networks} Rather than processing an image all at once as in a standard CNN architecture, Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) allow the model to parse an image in pieces, aggregating evidence before making a prediction. Fajtl et al.~\cite{fajtl2018amnet} showed gains in performance from using an RNN-based architecture with soft attention in order to make three passes over an image, each time focusing on a different set of image regions, before predicting the final memorability score. Using a larger and more complex model than the CNN-based MemNet~\cite{khosla2015understanding} gives this model greater predictive power. Another advantage of this model is that the soft attention can be visualized as heatmaps over the image regions attended to at each of the three passes. This is useful for determining what evidence the model uses for its predictions, and which parts of the image are most informative for determining the memorability score. Newman et al.~\cite{newman2020memento} also explored using RNNs to improve memorability prediction on videos. LSTMs \cite{lstm} are a type of RNN that are frequently used for processing or generating natural language. SemanticMemNet uses an LSTM \cite{lstm} to predict verbal captions for a video. It uses the additional supervision provided by the language descriptions in Memento10k \cite{newman2018effects} to encourage learning a feature space that explicitly encodes semantic features. The authors also experimented with using an RNN to predict raw hit rates at different viewing delays. \begin{svgraybox} \textbf{What is an RNN?} \\ \\ Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) are neural networks with ``loops" in them, where the prior state of the network is fed as input to future states, allowing previously gathered information to persist. They are popular for sequential tasks, most commonly language-related tasks like translation and image captioning. However, they are also used in cases where processing an input in pieces makes sense. For instance, when combined with soft attention, they can process an image not all at once, but in a sequence of ``glimpses", where each ``glimpse" focuses the network on a particular region of an image. One of the most common types of RNNs is an LSTM (Long short-term memory)~\cite{lstm}, popular for its ability to capture long-term dependencies via a set of computational control gates specifically designed to let some information flow through unchanged, and other information to be attenuated. \end{svgraybox} \subsection{Generative Adversarial Networks} Another technique for understanding image memorability, beyond predicting memorability scores, is to directly visualize the qualities that make an image memorable. Goetschalckx et al.~\cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze}, for instance, re-purposed a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) \cite{goodfellow2014generative} to explore image perturbations that either increase or decrease the memorability of images (Figure~\ref{fig:ganexample}). They found directions in latent space that best correlated with changes in image memorability, as measured by the MemNet model \cite{khosla2015understanding}. By automatically visualizing increasingly memorable images, they could observe how the GAN modifies the composition of the image and the objects within. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[width=1\linewidth]{Figures/gan_seed_image.pdf} \caption{A GAN can be used to transform samples drawn from some latent space (for instance, samples of Gaussian noise) into samples lying in the data space that the model has been trained on - e.g., approximating natural images. Moving along various latent directions, the model can generate novel outputs, that have not otherwise been previously seen. See Jahanian et al.~\cite{gansteerability} for a discussion about the steerability of GAN models.} \label{fig:ganexample} \end{figure} Rather than using a pre-trained GAN, related work \cite{kyledavidson2020generating} trained a GAN from scratch and had it accept an additional input value (M) representing a desired memorability score for the output image. The memorability of the output was measured by an auxiliary model based on the aforementioned Visual Memory Schemas \cite{akagunduz2019defining}. By varying M while keeping the latent vector (i.e., the standard GAN input) constant, this framework also produces visualizations of images gradually increasing in memorability. \begin{svgraybox} \textbf{What is a GAN?} \\ \\ Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) \cite{goodfellow2014generative} are most commonly used to synthesize fake images that look realistic. They work by generating convincing, novel samples from a very complex, high-dimensional data distribution--in this case, the distribution of natural images. They are trained by playing off two models against each other. The Generator learns to generate samples from the target distribution by taking a random vector as input (the GAN's ``inspiration") and transforming it into a valid image. The Discriminator is then tasked with distinguishing the fake, generated samples from real samples (i.e., natural images) from the training set. As the Discriminator gets better at separating real from fake images, the Generator is forced to generate increasingly more realistic samples, and vice versa. \end{svgraybox} \subsection{Visualizations and model interpretability} Knowing that a particular image is memorable does not necessarily tell you \textit{which} information is retained. Reasoning that not all image regions contribute equally to overall memorability, Khosla et al. \cite{khosla2012memorability} proposed a probabilistic model that assigns different weights to different regions based on six locally computed image features (gradient, saliency, color, texture, shape, semantics). This can be done automatically without the need for additional human annotations. Not only did accounting for local information in addition to global features improve the prediction of overall memorability scores, it also allowed for visualizing the weights as interpretable heat maps. These heat maps often emphasized regions depicting people as contributing most to the overall memorability, and plain backgrounds contributing the least. As CNN models are particularly effective at predicting memorability, working out their internal representations yields valuable insights into which features result in high and low memorability scores. Khosla et al. \cite{khosla2015understanding} adopt different strategies to achieve this with MemNet. One is to sort the units within a layer of the network based on their correlation with the predicted memorability score, compute an average across the images that maximally activate the unit, and compare those averages. Another strategy, based on network dissection \cite{bau2017network}, is to identify image patches that highly activate individual units and then compare the activated patches from units that are positively versus negatively correlated with memorability. Finally, one can generate memorability heat maps by running the model on multiple, overlapping sub-regions of the image. Each pixel in the heat map represents the average memorability prediction across the sub-regions that contain it (Figure~\ref{fig:heatmap}). Together, these strategies revealed that MemNet tends to predict high memorability for images containing people or animals, busy images, and images with text. Open and natural scenes, landscapes and textured surfaces tend to result in lower memorability. Another approach that facilitates model interpretation is visualizing what changes in an image when its model-predicted memorability increases or decreases, as in the GANalyze framework \cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze}. For example, this framework showed that MemNet cares about the relative size of the main object in the image, with higher memorability predictions assigned to a more ``zoomed in'' image. While other techniques mostly revealed semantic features, GANalyze discovered important dimensions that are orthogonal to object class. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[width=1\linewidth]{Figures/heatmap.pdf} \caption{MemNet prediction and memorability heat map for an example image. Left: Input image of Katholieke Universiteit Leuven \copyright Rob Stevens. Right: MemNet is a convolutional neural network fine-tuned to predict memorability scores \cite{khosla2015understanding}. The heat map is created by running the network over multiple, overlapping sub-regions and assigning each pixel a color based on the average predicted memorability of the regions that contain it. Here, it highlights the bell tower and bug sculpture as memorable regions.} \label{fig:heatmap} \end{figure} \section{Memorability: from low-level to high-level features}\label{sec:features} Since the original memorability experiments of Isola et al.~\cite{isola2011makes}, follow-up work has added further evidence to the observation that memorability is a robust property of images that is not amenable to simple explanation, but instead appears multifaceted (see~\cite{rust_understanding_image_memorability} for a review). It is correlated with scene category, but remains predictable when scene category is controlled for~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,goetschalckx2019memcat}. It is correlated with the presence of certain elements - most notably, faces and people~\cite{baveye2016deep,bylinskii2015intrinsic,dubey2015makes,fajtl2018amnet,khosla2015understanding} - but remains predictable when those objects are not present~\cite{lu2018makes,9025769}. It cannot be explained by image aesthetics, popularity, or affective value either~\cite{cohendet2018annotating,goetschalckx2019ganalyze,isola2014what}. Moreover, human observers are bad at predicting what is memorable or forgettable~\cite{isola2014what}. So while no simple explanation for memorability has been proposed, in this section we will discuss some of the factors that contribute to image and video memorability, by applying the analysis tools and computational models from the previous section. In the concluding discussion (Section~\ref{sec:conclusion}), we hypothesize a unifying explanation to these results. \subsection{Low-level pixel features} Dubey et al.~\cite{dubey2015makes} have found a weak positive correlation between memorability and the brightness and high contrast of objects. Using a GAN trained for memorability, Goetschalckx et al.~\cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze} confirmed that brighter and more colorful images tend to be produced when optimizing for more memorable images. For instance, redder hues are produced when they are realistic (e.g., for ripe fruit). Lu et al.~\cite{lu2018makes} found that some HSV-based features could be used to predict the memorability of natural scene images without objects, though this predictive power is low ($\rho<0.30$). For generic photographs, however, low level features (in the form of simple pixel statistics like color and contrast) are commonly either weakly correlated or uncorrelated with memorability~\cite{dubey2015makes,isola2011understanding,isola2014what,isola2011makes,9025769}. In general, perceptual features are not retained in long term visual memory~\cite{brady2011real,konkle2010conceptual}. \subsection{Mid-level semantic features} \textbf{Objects}. Multiple studies have commented on the increased intrinsic memorability of images and videos containing people, faces, and body parts~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,dubey2015makes,khosla2015understanding,baveye2016deep,fajtl2018amnet,newman2020memento} and low memorability for landscapes~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,goetschalckx2019memcat,isola2011makes,khosla2015understanding,newman2020memento}. By using images with available semantic segmentations~\cite{li2014secrets}, i.e., images in which all or most of the objects have been delineated and annotated, Dubey et al.~\cite{dubey2015makes} showed that the memorability of an image is ``greatly affected by the memorability of its most memorable object" ($\rho=0.40$). For instance, animal, person, and vehicle were found to be the most memorable object classes, and images containing these objects were more likely to be memorable overall. These objects tend to dominate the focus and foreground of photographs, and are not commonly occluded~\cite{dubey2015makes}. In contrast, furniture was found to be the least memorable object category. The attention-based model of Fajtl et al.~\cite{fajtl2018amnet} was used to visualize regions of an image contributing most to memorability, and confirmed that these regions frequently contained people and human faces. Objects are also important in video memorability prediction. The importance of semantic features, including objects, actors, and the actions that involve them, has increasingly led to their inclusion in video memorability models \cite{newman2020memento,cohendet2019videomem,cohendet2018annotating}. The semantic embedding model from VideoMem~\cite{cohendet2019videomem} was based on a video captioning model, and SemanticMemNet~\cite{newman2020memento} includes a branch to explicitly generate video captions to encourage features that encode semantic information. \textbf{Object interactions}. Object interactions are key to the memorability of individual objects as well as the memorability of the image containing them. In particular, objects that are out of context with respect to the other items in a scene make for particularly memorable images~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,standing1973learning}. Also, as the pure number of objects in an image increases, competition for attention decreases the memorability of even the most memorable object classes, like animals and vehicles~\cite{dubey2015makes}. Interestingly, the memorability of people in images is least sensitive, compared to other object classes, to the presence of other objects in an image. \textbf{Saliency and eye fixations}. Multiple studies have explored the connection between image memorability and saliency~\cite{dubey2015makes,khosla2015understanding,mancas2013memorability,9025769,shekhar2017show,lu2018makes, celikkale2015predicting, akagunduz2019defining}. Mancas and Le Meur~\cite{mancas2013memorability} ran computational saliency models on images and found that the most memorable images have localized regions of high saliency, while the least memorable images do not. Khosla et al.~\cite{khosla2015understanding} reported that more memorable images tend to have more consistent human eye fixations. Dubey et al.~\cite{dubey2015makes} similarly found a large positive correlation ($\rho = 0.71$) between fixation count on an object in an image and that object's memorability. Part of this trend is driven by the fact that objects that are not fixated at all are not remembered. The other aspect is that images that contain more close-ups or larger objects will tend to have more consistent fixations clustered on those objects (also see \emph{image composition} below). As the number of objects in an image increases, it becomes significantly harder to predict the memorability of objects using fixation counts alone. While computational saliency is intended to simulate human attention and serve as an approximation of eye fixation patterns, they are not the same thing. Computational saliency can be used as a replacement to other low-level features in predicting memorability~\cite{mancas2013memorability}. Lu et al.~\cite{9025769} found that the performance of a saliency model on saliency tasks is not correlated with its performance on memorability prediction, affirming that computational saliency in this regard should be viewed as a pre-computed combination of other low-level features rather than an independent high-level semantic feature. Alternatively, rather than being used directly as an input feature, saliency maps can also be used to spatially pool other low-level input feature and improve memorability predictions \cite{celikkale2015predicting}. \textbf{Image composition}. More memorable images tend to focus on a key object or image region, and to center it in the photograph while maintaining a homogeneous background. For instance, a photograph of a puppy is more memorable when it is a close-up and the puppy occupies a larger portion of the photograph~\cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze}. This is similar to Dubey et al.'s~\cite{dubey2015makes} finding that if fewer objects compete for attention, then a single object becomes quite memorable, and the image as a whole becomes memorable by extension. Kim et al. \cite{kim2013relative} showed that features computed based on the relative sizes of objects, their centeredness, and the unusualness of their size given the overall semantic class are strong predictors of memorability. When GANalyze \cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze} modifies a seed image to become more memorable, it typically makes the main object larger and more centered, simplifies the image, and reduces clutter. The authors furthermore note that ``more memorable images have more interpretable semantics''. In an additional experiment, they show that when GANalyze is trained to modify object size directly, the image variants with the larger object size are indeed more likely to be remembered by participants in a memory task. However, the effect is not as strong as when memorability was targeted as a whole, indicating that memorability is more than object size alone. Simpler, more orderly shapes are more memorable than a disarray or lack of structure. Fajtl et al.'s~\cite{fajtl2018amnet} visualizations confirm that images with higher memorability display more concentrated peaks of memorable content, whereas lower memorability images tend to have memorability more distributed across the image. Finally, Mancas and Le Meur \cite{mancas2013memorability} proposed a feature to capture the presence of strong contrasted structures in an image, as opposed to small details and cluttered backgrounds, and found that it positively predicted memorability. \textbf{Motion and action features}. Using videos as stimuli has facilitated the analysis of the effects of motion on memory. Newman et al.~\cite{newman2020memento} evaluated the effectiveness of different feature extractors that did or did not explicitly encode motion for predicting video memorability. They found that a simple image-based extractor that operated only on static frames performed as well as a video-based extractor, but that combining information from static frames, video, and optical flow produced the best results. They also observed that low-memorability videos are often static compared to high-memorability videos (Figure~\ref{fig:memento}). \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[width=1\linewidth]{Figures/mem_chapter_mem_vid_examples.png} \caption{High and low memorability videos from the Memento dataset \cite{newman2020memento}. Like images, memorable videos tend to contain people, faces, and body parts, while forgettable videos are more likely to be of natural and otherwise static scenes.} \label{fig:memento} \end{figure} \subsection{High-level and contextual features} \textbf{Aesthetics}. Aesthetics is distinct from memorability, with little to no correlation in the LaMem dataset \cite{khosla2015understanding,jing2016predicting} and a weak, but negative correlation in the SUN dataset~\cite{isola2014what}. Participants tend to rate images depicting nature as most aesthetic (e.g.,~coast and lake scenes), yet natural landscapes typically score low on memorability. Modifying an image to increase its aesthetics (while keeping semantic class constant) does have a positive effect on memorability, albeit a rather small one ~\cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze}. Goetschalckx et al.~\cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze} furthermore confirmed that optimizing images for memorability and optimizing images for aesthetics leads to different image manipulations. \textbf{Emotions}. Emotionally salient objects are memorable \cite{bradley1992remembering,buchanan2002role,cahill1995novel}. Hence, different studies have considered the role of emotional features in predicting image memorability. In the LaMem dataset, images evoking negative emotions (e.g., disgust, anger, fear) were overall more memorable than those evoking positive emotions (e.g., awe, contentment), with amusement being a memorable exception \cite{khosla2015understanding}. Isola et al. \cite{isola2011understanding} found that images described as peaceful are typically not well remembered. Having a subject in a photo with more pronounced and expressive eyes, on the other hand, seems to increase the memorability of a portrait \cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze}. In \cite{jing2016predicting}, a sentiment attribute inspired by eight basic emotions was the best memorability predictor among other high-level attributes (e.g., aesthetics). Other work that included emotional features combined with other high-level features (e.g., object categories) also demonstrated a predictive ability for these features \cite{isola2011understanding, celikkale2015predicting}. Finally, Baveye et al.~\cite{baveye2016deep} recommend that memorability datasets should have the appropriate emotional feature distribution (i.e., be balanced), based on the observation that emotionally negative images have more predictable memorability than neutral or positive ones. \textbf{Popularity and interestingness}. Intuitively, one might expect memorable images to be popular or interesting. However, studies show that memorability does not reduce to either of those attributes. The top 25\% most memorable LaMem images indeed are more popular, as determined by their log-normalized view count on Flickr. This is likely because they stand out in some way. However, there is little difference between all other images \cite{khosla2015understanding}. When asking participants to judge the interestingness of an image in the SUN dataset, those judgments correlate negatively with memorability, but only weakly \cite{isola2014what, gygli2013interestingness}. \textbf{Scene category}. Perera et al.~\cite{perera2019image} empirically showed that a network originally trained on scene classification transfers more appropriate features for memorability prediction than a network trained on object classification, although a network trained on both performs best~\cite{zhou2014learning,khosla2015understanding,zhou2017places}. This seems to indicate that scene category drives a lot of the predictive power in image memorability. Indeed, Isola et al.'s original paper \cite{isola2011makes} reports that scene category alone is highly predictive of memorability ($\rho=0.37$). Lu et al.~\cite{9025769} obtain a similar result ($\rho=0.38$) across their dataset of natural outdoor scene images, LNSIM. Their images do not contain any salient objects (people, animals, man-made structures, etc.) and yet they still demonstrate high inter-observer consistency ($\rho=0.78$). Finally, 43\% of the variance in the MemCat dataset was captured by which of five broad categories an image belonged to \cite{goetschalckx2019memcat}. However, scene category is far from the whole story. Memorability scores in the MemCat dataset were still consistent across observers within each of the five categories separately \cite{goetschalckx2019memcat}. This still holds in cases where the scene category is even more strictly controlled for, and in this case, objects and their distributions help to drive memorability~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic}. Finally, GANalyze \cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze} is able to increase image memorability while keeping the scene category constant. Despite all the work showing that memorability has a strong intrinsic component, features extracted automatically from image pixels account for only about half the total variance observed in the memorability scores. The rest may be due to individual or context factors, which we can refer to as the extrinsic factors~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic}. \textbf{Observer attention}. Unlike saliency, which approximates the attention patterns of a population in aggregate, Bylinskii et al.~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic} considered whether an individual's pattern of eye movements could predict whether that individual would remember an image. The model was an SVM trained to separate eye fixation patterns on a target image from eye fixation patterns on other images. This model achieved approximately 60\% accuracy at predicting if a given image would be remembered by an individual based on their eye fixation patterns alone. Using this person-specific information was more accurate than the population-level predictor (average memorability scores), especially for the images in the mid-memorability range. \textbf{Contextual features}. Images that stand out from their image context (i.e., other images presented in the memory task) or differ from our expectations based on an internal model of the world, are more likely to be remembered. Bylinskii et al.~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic} were able to show this by operationalizing contextual distinctiveness in terms of how unlikely an image's features are in the feature distribution defined by the image context. Similarly, Lukavsk{\'{y}} and D{\v{e}}cht{\v{e}}renko \cite{lukavsky2017visual} found that people remember images better if they are far away from their nearest neighbors in a conceptual representational space. Goetschalckx et al. \cite{goetschalckx2019get} compared these two automatic distinctiveness measures with a perceived distinctiveness measure based on participants' ratings, as well as a measure of an image's atypicality for its abstract scene category. All four variables were significantly intercorrelated. Perceived distinctiveness predicted memorability scores best. Furthermore, of the 60k images in the LaMem dataset, those originally sampled from the Abnormal Objects dataset~\cite{saleh2013object} are extremely memorable \cite{khosla2012image}. Landscape images in Lu et al.'s dataset \cite{9025769} belonging to unusual categories (as indicated by the category name having a low word frequency in language) tended to be more memorable. Finally, Kim et al. \cite{kim2013relative} report that accounting for how unusual object sizes are given their class can improve memorability predictions. Lastly, another way in which context matters is through effects of image sequences and presentation order, as demonstrated by Perera et al.~\cite{perera2019image} This confirmed earlier results from \cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic}. \section{Applications: from summarization to creation}\label{sec:applications} As computational models have recently approached human-level performance at predicting what people will find memorable, the doors have opened to applications that could benefit from an estimate of human memorability. In this section, we provide a taste of some of these applications. Making more of them a reality depends on additional progress to be made along the future research directions proposed in the following section. \textbf{Filtering visual streams}. With a growing stream of information and an increase in low-cost, low-power image/video capture devices (phones, GoPros, internet of things, etc.), filtering through content to find the nuggets worth saving becomes increasingly tedious and time-consuming. Such a task could be outsourced to computational agents armed with an appropriate filtering criteria. Here, memorability can play a significant role, as a high-level image property that bundles together low-level, semantic, and contextual features. Which of the dozens of nearly-identical photos should be saved for later? Which frames or snapshots can represent the contents of a video in summary form? Current computational models of memorability could be used for ranking and effectively filtering visual content. \textbf{Assistive goggles}. Imagine an automated tutor that reminds the wearer of the identities of the most forgettable objects and people, and either coaches the user's memory or presents the labels in an augmented reality layer. Augmented Reality (AR) is a technology that integrates digital graphics and virtual objects into a display of the real world. It is already being used for training and education scenarios in medicine~\cite{barsom2016systematic}, construction~\cite{li2018critical}, driving~\cite{gabbard2014behind}, and K-12 education~\cite{holstein2018cognitive_augmentation_teachers}. As a potential tool for augmenting the human memory of the average person, it holds big promises for the future. \textbf{Photography aide}. Consumer cameras are increasingly being upgraded with machine-learning based functionalities for guiding the user towards capturing better-quality shots. These include new tools to help users automatically select a better portrait angle or orientation for a photograph~\cite{e2020adaptive,ma2019smarteye}. A more sophisticated aide could guide the photographer to select a more memorable shot during real-time capture, or to re-position, adjust, and remove elements either before or after a picture is taken, by optimizing for memorability. \textbf{Effective communication}. Key players in the education space (e.g., educational content producers, intelligent tutoring systems, etc.) could benefit students by presenting content in a more memorable way. For instance, prior work has looked at data visualizations and their ability to effectively communicate information via memorable presentations of data and title wording~\cite{newman2018effects,borkin2015beyond,xiong2019biased,kong2018frames,kong2019trust}. Armed with similar insights, a marketing or advertising effort could make use of predictions of how to arrange the objects in a scene to make the target product or message stand out in a memorable way. Along the same lines, a tourist agency could design more memorable experiences and increase re-visitations~\cite{HungTouristm,kleinlein2019predicting}. \textbf{Manipulating memorability}. What if an app could make your holiday pictures extra memorable or the picture on your resume more likely to be remembered by a recruiter? Our growing ability to predict and understand memorability has led researchers to think about the possibility of automatically manipulating an image’s memorability. For example, Khosla et al. \cite{khosla2012image} speculated that their probabilistic model of the memorability of images and their sub-regions \cite{khosla2012memorability} could offer a starting point for memorability manipulation work. Deep style transfer has also been put forward as a way to boost an image’s memorability score \cite{siarohin2017make,siarohin2019increasing}. By transferring the style of a seed image onto the original image, the modified version also tends to have a more abstract, artistic flavor to it. Furthermore, the memorability of a face image can be manipulated successfully using warping techniques, all while maintaining the identity of the face \cite{khosla2013modifying}. More recent work has turned to GANs for this purpose \cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze, Sidorov_2019_CVPR_Workshops}. While Goetschalckx et al.’s~\cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze} GAN framework successfully increased and decreased the memorability of images (Figure~\ref{fig:ganalyze}), this was only possible by using seed images that were GAN-generated to begin with - i.e., within the latent space of the GAN. However, recent success in GAN inversion (i.e., projecting a real image into a GAN’s latent space) \cite{zhu2020indomain, abdal2019image2stylegan, bau2019ganpaint, anirudh2020robust, creswell2019inverting} suggests that it might be possible to extend these results to real, user-supplied imagery. While automatically boosting an image’s memorability is an exciting possible direction, similar to automatically beautifying portraits, one must consider the potential concerns about image authenticity that it raises. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[width=1\linewidth]{Figures/ganalyze_figure.jpg} \caption{More or less memorable images generated by the GANalyze framework \cite{goetschalckx2019ganalyze} with computed memorability scores as insets. More memorable images tend to focus on a large, central key object while reducing background clutter.} \label{fig:ganalyze} \end{figure} \section{Future directions}\label{sec:future} Convolutional neural networks can now closely predict the average memorability score of an image. Perera et al.~\cite{perera2019image} present a model that is able to reach human-level performance on the LaMem dataset~\cite{khosla2015understanding}, the largest memorability dataset to date. They pose the question: is memorability prediction solved? Despite the success of computational models of image memorability, there are still aspects of memorability prediction and utilization that merit further work. We discuss some of these directions below. \textbf{Customized predictions}. Producing the average memorability score of an image overlooks possible variability in the population~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic,perera2019image}. Variability may exist among subpopulations or specialists, people from different cultures and environments (i.e., LaMem uses US crowdworkers on Amazon's Mechanical Turk platform), and among individuals. Drilling down to the individual level for customized applications of memorability is an exciting prospect. Can we predict whether a particular image will be memorable to a particular individual? While Bylinskii et al.~\cite{bylinskii2015intrinsic} and V{\~o} et al.~\cite{Vo2017} showed that eye movements and pupillometry (Figure~\ref{fig:pupilometry}), respectively, could be used for individualized memorability predictions, predictions are not yet accurate nor robust enough to be deployed in applications and devices. Deep learning based face and eye tracking technology~\cite{krafka2016eye,Zhang_2015_CVPR,park2020towards} and other automatically-collected physiological measurements~\cite{papoutsaki2016webgazer,qian2018remotion} may provide a way forward. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[width=0.8\linewidth]{Figures/pupilSize.png} \caption{Pupillometry analysis shows that at recall, images with the lowest memorability cause a dilation in pupil size relative to images with the highest memorability, on an individual basis~\cite{Vo2017}.} \label{fig:pupilometry} \end{figure} \textbf{Retention over different time intervals}. The memorability games used to create most of the available datasets (Table~\ref{tab:datasets}) typically measure memorability over intervals of a couple of minutes. By varying the number of images presented between a target image and its repeat (i.e., the ``lag''), past work has explored to what extent image memorability is stable over shorter and longer intervals \cite{isola2011makes, Vo2017}. Goetschalckx et al. \cite{goetschalckx2018longer} used a more traditional long-term memory task with a separate study and test phase that allowed them to study intervals as long as a week. In addition, different mathematical formulations have been proposed to compute memorability scores based on responses collected at varying lags \cite{khosla2015understanding, newman2020memento}. An image's memorability score naturally decays over time, but even after a few seconds, some images are already consistently more likely to be forgotten \cite{isola2011makes, Vo2017}. The decay is best described by a log-linear function \cite{isola2011makes, goetschalckx2018longer} and is slower for more memorable images \cite{Vo2017, goetschalckx2018longer}. Despite changes in raw scores over time, memorability ranks are largely conserved \cite{isola2011makes, goetschalckx2018longer}, though more substantial differences might appear when comparing intervals significantly differing in length \cite{goetschalckx2018longer}. Video memorability studies have likewise compared different intervals. Cohendet et al. \cite{cohendet2019videomem} report a significant, albeit moderate, correlation between video memorability rankings measured after a couple of minutes and after 24 to 72 hours. The correlation was likely attenuated by the low number of responses collected per video, however. Cohendet et al. \cite{cohendet2018annotating} examined even longer durations by asking study participants about well-known films that they had seen weeks to years previously. They find an inter-observer consistency score of 0.57, which is lower than the values of most memorability studies but still significant (see Table \ref{tab:datasets}). The lower consistency could be due to the long delay between initial and repeat viewing, the relatively low number of participant annotations per video, or the atypical experiment design where participants self-reported the time of their first viewing. Similar to images, the Memento10k videos \cite{newman2020memento} also showed slower decay if they had higher memorability scores to begin with. Unlike with images, the decay was best described by a linear function. Because the authors examined relatively short delays (up to ten minutes between viewings), it is possible that at longer delays, a log-linear trend may be more appropriate. The authors proposed a computational model to simultaneously capture a video's memorability and decay rate. Models that attempt to predict memorability as a function of time interval (how memorable will this image be in a day? a week? a year?) or by directly predicting the decay rate for an image or video \cite{newman2020memento} are rare. These questions deserve more attention. \textbf{Alternative media}. Much of the work in computational memorability thus far has focused on images. Compared to the number of computational models that have been proposed to predict memorability scores for images, those available for videos are much fewer \cite{cohendet2018annotating, cohendet2019videomem, newman2020memento} and they do not yet reach human-level performance (see Table \ref{tab:vidmodels}). As such, perfecting the nuances of video memorability prediction is an important future direction. Furthermore, the prior work discussed in this chapter has investigated purely visual media (images and videos without sound). Future work can explore the influence of auditory features (voices, sound effects, music, etc.) on memorability, independently of or in combination with visual features. Some work has additionally been done in the space of word memorability~\cite{mahowald2018words,madan2020exploring}, with findings that reinforce those in visual domains, in that distinct, easily-visualizable, non-ambiguous words are the most memorable~\cite{mahowald2018words}. Mahowald~\cite{mahowald2018words} found that animacy was most correlated with word memorability, and further that words that were rated as related to `danger' and `usefulness' were more memorable. The memorability of combinations of words, in the form of descriptions or titles, has yet to be studied, especially in the context of conveying information, and making messages or data ``stickier"~\cite{newman2018effects,borkin2015beyond,xiong2019biased,kong2018frames,kong2019trust}. \section{Concluding discussion}\label{sec:conclusion} Putting it all together, what is the ``magic sauce'' of memorability? What is the common thread that ties the findings from past memorability studies together, across photographs, visualizations, videos, and words? We propose that content is memorable if it has a high \textit{utility of information}. We remember that which surprises us, that which contradicts our current model of the world and of events, or that which is likely to be relevant or useful in the future. Remembering a surprising (or dangerous, untrustworthy, etc.) event or person will prepare us better for future encounters, and for adjusting our world view accordingly. This is why stimuli that are distinct, relative to their contexts, are memorable. The benefit of large, diverse memorability datasets with many observers is that they capture the robustly memorable and forgettable content. These studies tell us something about the human condition: What has the highest utility of information to any observer? Universal trends include emotional/affective stimuli, unexpected actions, social aspects, animate objects (human faces, gestures, interactions, etc.), and tangible (small, manipulable) objects. Memorability is not about aesthetics or low-level visual features like color or contrast. Rather, memorability captures the higher-level properties of semantics (objects and actions) and composition (layout and clutter) in an image or video. As a demonstrated image-computable attribute, memorability has the capability of being used as a powerful image descriptor or feature representation for downstream tasks that depend on image understanding and selection. Cognitively-inspired computation is still in its relative infancy. Memorability paints a promising path into the A.I. future. \section{Acknowledgements} We thank the Vannevar Bush Faculty Fellowship Program of the ONR (N00014-16-1-3116 to A.O.). Thank you also to Wilma Bainbridge for her insightful comments on prior versions of this chapter, as well as to the other editors of this collection. \bibliographystyle{spmpsci}

Introduction ============ Ample evidence exists that even highly educated adults can have poor numeracy skills \[[@ref1]-[@ref4]\]. As a result, patient decision aids and other patient communications that incorporate risk statistics will only be effective in improving patient decision making if they use design features that make these risk communications easier to understand. In this vein, researchers have evaluated the benefits of giving people more intuitive representations of risks by, for example, using frequencies instead of percentages \[[@ref5]-[@ref8]\] and testing a wide variety of visual displays, such as bar graphs, pie charts, and pictographs or icon arrays \[[@ref9]-[@ref14]\]. Improving risk-communication methods is also important because patients are likely to translate risk statistics into intuitive "gist" representations \[[@ref15],[@ref16]\] that may influence anxiety or worry, powerful emotions that have significant impacts on people's responses to health risks and disease \[[@ref17]-[@ref22]\]. In fact, emotional responses may mediate cognitive risk perceptions or shape behavior independently, or both \[[@ref23]-[@ref25]\]. Recently, Natter and Berry suggested that communications that force the audience to actively process risk information may be more effective than more passive displays \[[@ref26]\]. In their study, participants were better calibrated in their perceptions of medication side effects when they created a bar graph of the risk instead of just viewing one. Similarly, Ancker and colleagues found that a Web-based, game-like, interactive risk graphic in which participants clicked in a matrix until they uncovered a risk event had the effect of reducing disparities in risk perceptions between high- and low-numeracy participants \[[@ref27]\]. While such interactive graphing tasks were formerly difficult to implement, advances in the interactive capabilities of the Internet provide an opportunity to integrate interactive graphing tasks into patient decision-support materials. Such exercises could be seen as one method of increasing patients' active processing of risk information. Indeed, Ancker and colleagues also showed that their interactive risk graphics may elicit emotional responses that reflect the potential for increased understanding of actual risks and better ability to compare and contrast risks \[[@ref28]\]. We therefore hypothesized that a task designed for active processing might help patients not only to comprehend the statistics presented to them but also to integrate these facts into their decision making and thereby make better decisions. To test the hypothesis that interactive graphing tasks could improve knowledge of risk information and decision making relevant to the risks, we conducted an Internet-administered experiment in which participants read a hypothetical treatment decision-making scenario that included information about the risks of 2 possible side effects. While some study participants passively viewed the risk information in state-of-the-art static risk images, others had to actively complete an interactive graphing task that asked them to fill in an icon array to match risk statistics that were provided numerically. We assessed whether the interactive task affected survey completion rates, treatment choices, and gist knowledge about the treatment options. Methods ======= Recruitment ----------- A stratified random sample of US adults age 21 years and older was selected from a panel of Internet users administered by Survey Sampling International (Shelton, CT, USA). To ensure at least moderate demographic diversity (but not representativeness) and offset large expected variations in response rates, we drew distinct subsamples by both age and race, and dynamically adjusted the number of email invitations in each demographic subsample until all quotas were achieved. Selected panel members received email invitations to complete the online survey. Upon completing the survey, participants were entered into both an instant-win contest and a monthly drawing administered by Survey Sampling International for modest prizes. Design of the Study ------------------- Respondents read a short vignette in which they imagined being diagnosed with thyroid cancer and discussing treatment options with their doctor. The vignette discussed 2 types of radiation treatment, external beam therapy and seed therapy, which were described as being equally effective in treating the patient's type of thyroid cancer. Both therapies were described as having a chance of causing 2 side effects: (1) fatigue, and (2) mouth and throat problems. We chose thyroid cancer as the disease context because its comparative unfamiliarity (versus, for example, breast or prostate cancer) meant that few study participants would be likely to have preconceived beliefs about treatment options or their associated risks. Our primary research question was to determine whether an interactive graphing task would increase respondents' ability to recognize a better treatment option (ie, one with lower risks of side effects) when such was available. To do so, we experimentally varied the content of the 2 survey pages that presented the risk of each side effect with the two treatment options. On those pages, we varied 2 factors in a 3 (risk levels) × 2 (graphic type) between-subjects design. ###### Side-effect risks presented in the hypothetical vignette Risk of fatigue Risk of mouth or throat problems ---------------------------- ----------------- ---------------------------------- ----- ----- Trade-off condition 12% 11% 13% 15% Mild dominance condition 12% 11% 15% 15% Strong dominance condition 12% 11% 21% 15% The risk-level manipulation is summarized in [Table 1](#table1){ref-type="table"}. By varying the likelihood of experiencing mouth or throat problems with beam therapy, we created 3 distinct decision contexts: (1) a trade-off condition, in which each treatment had a higher likelihood of one side effect and a lower likelihood of the other, (2) a mild dominance condition, in which seed therapy had a very slightly lower rate of fatigue and the same rate of mouth and throat problems, and (3) a strong dominance condition in which seed therapy had a lower rate of both side effects. All risk information for the side effects was presented both numerically and in side-by-side graphics on sequential screens (first fatigue and then mouth and throat problems). Half of study participants viewed the risks displayed in static 100-unit icon arrays (also called pictographs: [Figure 1](#figure1){ref-type="fig"}), a format demonstrated to improve risk communication in a variety of medical contexts \[[@ref9],[@ref13],[@ref29]-[@ref33]\]. The remaining participants received an interactive version of the same icon array format ([Figure 2](#figure2){ref-type="fig"}), programmed in Flash (Adobe Systems Inc, San Jose, CA, USA). In the interactive exercise, the risk information was provided numerically but the graphics were initially blank (ie, all gray blocks). Participants were then instructed to use their mouse to click and/or drag in each graph to set it to the appropriate risk level. The graph continually adjusted to provide both visual and numerical feedback. (See [Multimedia Appendix 1](#app1){ref-type="app"} for a movie demonstrating the interaction.) Participants were required to interact with and set the first of the 2 graphs on the page before they were allowed to go on in the study. The specific instructions given to participants are shown in [Figure 1](#figure1){ref-type="fig"}. Note, however, that participants were not prevented from advancing if they did not set the second graph or were inaccurate in their graphing of the risks; minimal use of the interactive graphics was sufficient to allow them to continue in the study. This design received Institutional Review Board exempt status approval as anonymous survey research. {#figure1} {#figure2} Measures and Covariates ----------------------- Our primary outcome measure was the preferred treatment choice (beam or seed). We also asked respondents 2 gist knowledge questions in which they were to indicate which therapy had a higher risk of each of the side effects. In addition, we electronically tracked 2 measures of respondent burden: (1) time spent reading the static graphs pages or interacting with the interactive graphs pages, and (2) survey break-offs (to assess whether the interactive task annoyed people sufficiently to make them stop taking the survey). Because individuals vary in their numeracy (ie, their facility and comfort with quantitative health information such as risk statistics), all study participants also completed the Subjective Numeracy Scale (SNS) \[[@ref34]\]. The SNS is a validated measure of quantitative ability and of preferences for receiving information in numerical form that has previously been shown to correlate with the ability to recall and comprehend both textual and graphical risk communications \[[@ref32],[@ref35],[@ref36]\]. A participant's SNS score is calculated as his or her mean rating across the 8 SNS questions and ranges from 1 (least numerate) to 6 (most numerate). We also assessed participants' level of education, which we model for analysis purposes as a 3-level variable: high school or less, some post-high school education but no bachelor's degree, and bachelor's degree or more, as well as standard demographics measures. Statistical Analyses -------------------- We used chi-square tests of proportions to test whether graph type affected treatment choices, knowledge recall, and survey discontinuation rates across the 3 risk-level conditions and logistic regression models that included both design factors, an interaction term, SNS score, and education level to assess the impact of these covariates on treatment choices. Because time spent on a given survey page has a highly skewed distribution, we then used Wilcoxon rank-sum tests to compare the distributions of time spent reading the static risk graphics versus completing the interactive graphing task. All analyses were performed using Stata (release 11; StataCorp LP, College Station, TX, USA), and all tests of significance were 2-sided and used alpha = .05. Results ======= Recruitment ----------- In total, 3371 people age 21 years and older reached the survey website and viewed the first content page. Of these, 17 reported having been actually diagnosed with thyroid cancer and were excluded as having pre-existing knowledge of the relevant treatment options, leaving 3354 possible participants. Overall, 2426 (72%) of participants completed the entire survey, including questions on demographics that came toward the end of the survey instrument. Characteristics for those participants who answered each demographic question are reported in [Table 2](#table2){ref-type="table"}. We observed a wide range of educational achievement, with 889 participants (36.7%) having a bachelor's or higher college degree but also 441 (18.2%) having completed only high school or less education. The SNS numeracy measure showed high reliability (Cronbach alpha = .84). Mean SNS score was 4.63 (SD 1.0), with substantial variation (range 1.75--6.0). Because questions about participant demographics came at the end of the survey, we cannot know whether the demographics of those who dropped out differ from those who completed the survey. Statistical Analyses -------------------- ### Dropout Rates and Time Spent on Risk Graphic Pages As shown in [Table 3](#table3){ref-type="table"}, participants randomly assigned to complete the interactive graphics task were significantly less likely to complete the survey than those randomly assigned to view static graphs (65.5% vs 79.3%). More detailed examination confirmed that this difference was specifically due to the interactive graphics task. Over 23% of participants in the interactive graphics condition dropped out of the survey during that section of the survey, while less than 4% of participants viewing static graphics dropped out on those pages. Even among those who did progress beyond that point in the survey, it took significantly longer to complete the interactive graphing task than to view the static graphs. ###### Participanta demographic characteristics Characteristic Distribution Mean (SD) --------------------------------------------- --------------------- -------------- -- **Age (years)** 49.1 (16.3) 21--29 351 (14.5%) 30--39 448 (18.5%) 40--49 435 (18.0%) 50--59 396 (16.3%) 60--69 528 (21.8%) ≥70 266 (11.0%) **Gender** Male 1212 (50.0%) Female 1211 (50.0%) **Ethnicity** Hispanic (any race) 269 (11.2%) **Race**^b^ White 2008 (82.7%) African American 236 (9.7%) All other 213 (8.8%) **Education** ≤ High school 44 (1.8%) High school only 397 (16.4%) Some college/trade 1093 (45.1%) Bachelor's degree 593 (24.5%) Master's/doctorate 296 (12.2%) **Subjective numeracy scale (mean rating)** 4.63 (1.00) 1.00--1.99 45 (1.8%) 2.00--2.99 174 (6.8%) 3.00--3.99 500 (19.6%) 4.00--4.99 894 (35.1%) 5.00--5.99 862 (33.8%) 6.00 72 (2.8%) ^a^ Reports results only for those respondents who completed each question or measure. ^b^ Respondents could mark more than 1 race. ###### Survey completion times rates, by graphic type Static graphs Interactive graphs Significance ------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------- -------------------- ----------------------------- Discontinued survey at the risk graphic pages 58/1659 (3%) 391/1695 (23.1%) χ^2^~1~ = 277; *P* \< .001 Median time spent on the 2 pages with risk graphics (seconds)^a^ 52 155 *z* = 33.63; *P* \< .001 Completed entire survey 1316/1659 (79.3%) 1110/1695 (65.5%) χ^2^~1~ = 80.2; *P* \< .001 ^a^ Among respondents who did not discontinue at the risk graphic pages. ### Treatment Choices However problematic, the longer completion times and lower completion rates noted above for participants completing the interactive graphing task might be acceptable if it resulted in improved treatment choices among those who did complete the task. Unfortunately, such was not the case. As shown in [Figure 3](#figure3){ref-type="fig"}, selection of the best (dominant) treatment option of seed therapy in the strong dominance condition was significantly higher among those in the static graphics group than in the interactive graphics group (343/465, 73.8% vs 234/380, 61.6%, χ^2^ ~1~ = 14.3, *P* \< .001, among only those participants who answered the choice question; 343/536, 64.0% vs 234/558, 41.9%, χ^2^ ~1~ = 53.4, *P* \< .001, in an intent-to-treat analysis that included all participants, including those who dropped out of the survey). There was no significant difference in treatment choices in the mild dominance condition, and a mild trend toward less selection of seed therapy by participants viewing static graphs versus interactive graphs in the trade-off condition. In fact, across all 3 risk-level conditions, the interactive graphics condition made those participants less sensitive to variations in the risk of mouth and throat problems than were participants in the static graphs condition. A logistic regression analysis that included both experimental factors, as well as participant numeracy and education, confirmed a significant graph type × condition interaction (χ^2^ ~2~ = 18.4, *P* \< .001). In addition, participants with higher SNS scores were significantly more likely to choose the best treatment (odds ratio = 1.18 per step on the 1--6 scale, *z* = 3.78, *P* \< .001), but participant education had no effect. More complicated models found no significant interaction between participants' numeracy levels and the effect of graph type. We also examined whether those participants in the interactive graphics condition who accurately graphed the risk statistics made different treatment choices from those who had difficulty completing this task. In the strong dominance condition (the only one that showed a significant difference overall between participants who viewed interactive and static graphics), study participants who accurately graphed all 4 side-effect risks (243, 64.0%, of the 380 who answered the treatment choice question) were significantly more likely to choose the dominant option of seed therapy (164/243, 67.5% vs 70/137, 51%, χ^2^ ~1~ = 10.0, *P* = .002). We note, however, that optimal decision making remained at somewhat lower levels than observed in the static graphics condition (164/243, 67.5% vs 343/465, 73.8%, χ^2^ ~1~ = 3.1, *P* = .08), thereby providing no evidence that even completely accurate use of an interactive graphing task would improve people's treatment selections. {#figure3} ### Gist Knowledge As shown in [Table 4](#table4){ref-type="table"}, study participants who had to complete interactive graphing tasks were also less able to identify which treatment had the higher risk of mouth or throat problems in the trade-off condition (43.8% vs 51.6%). Logistic regression analysis found this effect only marginally significant (odds ratio = 0.77, *z* = --1.77, *P* = .08) when controlling for the highly significant effect of numeracy (odds ratio = 1.52 per step on the 1--6 scale, *z* = 5.17, *P* \< .001). There were no significant differences in gist knowledge about mouth and throat problems in the other 2 conditions. Nor were there any significant differences in gist knowledge about which treatment had a higher rate of fatigue (a side effect that did not vary across the 3 risk-level conditions.) ###### Percentage of participants correctly identifying which treatment had a higher rate of mouth and throat problems, by condition and graphic type Static graphs Interactive graphs Significance ---------------------------- ----------------- -------------------- -------------------------- Trade-off condition 225/436 (51.6%) 165/377 (43.8%) χ^2^~1~ = 5.0; *P* = .03 Mild dominance condition 404/502 (80.5%) 338/414 (81.6%) χ^2^~1~ = 0.2; *P* = .66 Strong dominance condition 288/452 (63.7%) 226/374 (60.4%) χ^2^~1~ = 0.9; *P* = .33 Discussion ========== Principal Results ----------------- The promise of interactivity is to potentially encourage people not just to read relevant information but also to actively process it. Such active processing might help people to remember the information and use it to make better treatment decisions. Unfortunately, the promise of interactive risk-communication exercises remained unfulfilled in our study. Our interactive task, which asked participants to graph pairs of risk statistics that were clearly presented in numerical format on the same page, increased survey dropouts and resulted in lower knowledge and poorer treatment choices than among those who viewed the information already displayed in equivalent static graphs. Limitations ----------- Our study has several key limitations. First and foremost, we tested a single type of interactive task with a particular user interface, one that did not undergo external usability testing. It is certainly possible that other tasks or more intuitive interfaces could have improved the use and user experience of the interactive task and potentially thereby improved outcomes. Second, as noted above, we asked otherwise healthy adults to answer a hypothetical scenario in an Internet survey. As a result, it is likely that these participants were considerably less motivated to work out how to do the interactive task and to think about the risk information we provided than real patients would be when reading a detailed decision aid designed to inform them and help them make their own medical decisions. Yet, we observed no advantage of the interactive task even for those participants who completed it perfectly. It is hard to imagine that even high levels of motivation would be enough to not just offset the knowledge and decision-making deficits we observed but actually accrue significant benefits from completing the interactive graphing exercise. Comparison with Prior Work -------------------------- As Natter and Berry note, although other research exists that uses interactive graphics in risk communication \[[@ref37]\], such research has not generally evaluated the interactive graphics against their passive counterparts. Accordingly, their study was the first to demonstrate the potential of interactive graphics over standard graphics by showing that people who draw a bar graph rather than simply viewed one had better recall of medication side effects \[[@ref26]\]. More recent research has suggested that interactive risk graphics in which participants explore a risk matrix until they find a risk event could also reduce numeracy disparities in risk perceptions \[[@ref27]\]. By contrast, our study showed no such positive effect. In fact, participants who were asked to interactively graph the risk information in our study did significantly worse on multiple outcome measures. This reversal may be partly accounted for by the fact that we used pictographs (icon arrays), which are less familiar to people than bar graphs, and also partly by the fact that our study was conducted online, whereas Natter and Berry's used paper booklets. We also speculate post hoc that the novelty of the interactive task may have led participants to devote a majority of their attention and cognitive resources to figuring out what they were supposed to do. This effect may therefore have prevented our participants from engaging in the type of deeper, meaning-finding processing that we were hoping to stimulate. As noted above, a more in-depth, user-centered design process might have resulted in a better interface and hence reduced this problem. Our different result may also derive from the fact that our task implemented a form of "teach-back" instructional methodology that encouraged participants to restate information they already had, whereas Ancker and colleagues' research used an exploratory task that encouraged discovery of the risk itself. In qualitative analyses of focus group transcripts, Ancker and colleagues concluded that their interactive risk graphics elicited more emotional responses than static graphics did, with more participants expressing concern about large risks and/or relief about small ones \[[@ref28]\]. Their subsequent experimental study found no overall effect of graphic type on risk estimates or risk feelings \[[@ref27]\]. While our study did not ask participants about how the graphics made them feel about their risk, we did find that people were less likely to choose the clearly optimal option after having used an interactive risk graphic than they were with a standard risk graphic. This suggests that the increased emotional response observed by Ancker et al may be an artifact of their game-like task and that more straightforward types of interactivity may not lead to improved choices. Research on other forms of interactivity in health education such as video games \[[@ref38]\] and immersive 3-dimensional environments \[[@ref39]\] has suggested caution in considering how these applications might or might not improve outcomes in health education. Our results complement these prior findings by showing that interactive approaches to risk communication should come with similar caveats. Conclusions ----------- Interactive risk graphics are intriguing, but their use may be counterproductive to the purpose of effectively communicating to patients about health risks. While the movement of patient decision aids from booklet and DVD formats to online resources has created opportunities for greater technological sophistication, our research should serve as a cautionary tale to developers and educators seeking to ensure that their materials are "cutting edge." Our teach-back interactive graphing task was intended to reinforce deeper cognitive processing of decision-relevant risk information, exactly the type of thinking most decision aids seek to promote in patients. Yet, in this case, our intervention backfired and created worse decision outcomes. More research is clearly needed to evaluate different types of interactive risk communications and to identify the design features of interactive exercises that lead to better results versus the features of those that do not. In the meantime, decision-aid designers should proceed with caution when considering the use of flashy risk graphics. This research was supported by a grant from the Foundation for Informed Medical Decision Making (IIG-0126-1) to Dr. Zikmund-Fisher. Dr. Zikmund-Fisher is supported by a career development award from the American Cancer Society (MRSG-06-130-01-CPPB). The funding agreements ensured the authors' independence in designing the study, interpreting the data, and publishing the report. The authors would like to thank Angela Fagerlin for helpful comments on an earlier draft of this manuscript, Bob Burbach and Mark Swanson for development of the Flash-based interactive graphics, and Nicole Exe for her exceptional research assistance. None declared MP4 movie of the interactive graphing task. SNS : Subjective Numeracy Scale

\section{Introduction and the Main Result} \label{sec:intr} Racah or Racah-Wigner (RW) coefficients or, as they are often called, $6j$-symbols are important objects in group representation theory. They depend on 6 irreducible representations of the group and are obtained by multiplying 4 Clebsch-Gordan coefficients and summing over the basis labels. Explicit formulas for RW coefficients are available for the case of group $\SU(2)$. They are given by a (finite) generalized hypergeometric series ${}_4 F_3(1)$ of unit argument \cite{VK-1}. RW coefficients for other compact groups, especially the unitary group ${\rm U}(n)$ and the rotation group $\SO(n)$ have also been computed. For non-compact groups these coefficients have received much less attention. This has to do with the envisaged physical application of the RW coefficients: they figure prominently in the lattice approach to QCD. As QCD concerns itself with compact gauge groups such as $\SU(n)$ there is no field theoretic motivation to compute the non-compact RW coefficients. This situation changed with the introduction of the spin foam models of quantum gravity \cite{Review}. Here of physical interest are exactly models with non-compact groups such as the Lorentz group. These models use RW and other similar coefficients in an essential way \cite{BC}. It thus became of importance to study and derive explicit expressions for the non-compact RW coefficients. Of particular interest are the Lorentz group RW coefficients. This is the problem that is considered in the present paper. Another obvious complication that arises in the non-compact case is that the unitary representations are infinite-dimensional. Sums of the compact case get replaced by integrals; the problem requires a more careful analytical treatment, including a careful analysis of the convergence of all the expressions. This paper gives such a treatment for $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ RW coefficients for type I representations, for $d>1$. Here $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ denotes the connected component of $\SO(1,d+1)$. We shall assume $d>1$ throughout the paper when not explicitly mentioned otherwise. Motivations for considering the RW coefficients for type I representations are two-fold: (i) these are the representations that are of importance for quantum gravity applications \cite{BC,FK}; (ii) RW coefficients for type I representations can be obtained from a certain integral over several copies of the hyperbolic space. As we show in this paper, these integrals and thus the RW coefficients can be given in terms of 4 Barnes-Mellin type integrals. One may be able to use this integral representation for an analytic continuation, and in this way obtain RW coefficients for other representations. We recall here some basic facts about $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ representation theory \cite{VK-2}. Representations of type I form the most degenerate series of representations. At the same time they are the simplest and the most studied ones. These irreducible unitary representations appear in the decomposition of the space $L^2(H_{d+1})$ of square integrable functions on the hyperbolic space $H_{d+1}$ into irreducible representations. Thus, type I representations can be realized in the space of $L^2(H_{d+1})$ functions. It is this realization that will be the starting point for our analysis. These representations can also be realized in the space of homogeneous functions on the light cone in Minkowski space $M^{1,d+1}$. We shall refer to minus degree of homogeneity by the conformal dimension $\Delta$ of the representation. For representations of type I: \be\label{type-1} \Delta=d/2 + i \rho, \ \ \rho \in \mathbb{R}. \end{eqnarray} There is another important series of unitary representations with real integral $\Delta$. We shall not consider them here. We shall also require a notion of the dual representation. Its conformal dimension $\bar{\Delta}$ is such that: \be\label{sum} \Delta+\bar{\Delta}=d. \end{eqnarray} The dual representation is an equivalent representation. A brief description of the logic of the paper is as follows. We represent the RW coefficient as an integral over 4 copies of the hyperbolic space of a product of 6 ``propagators'', the corresponding expression to be given in the main text. This way of representing the $6j$-symbols was proposed in \cite{FK} and later explored in papers by many authors, in particular \cite{BC} and \cite{Manuel}. In paper \cite{BC} the bulk-to-bulk propagator was represented as a composition of two ``bulk-to-boundary'' ones. This representation will be of central importance for us in this paper. The terminology ``bulk-to-boundary'' and ``bulk-to-bulk'' is that used in the AdS/CFT context \cite{Witten}. Replacing each bulk-to-bulk propagator by a composition of two bulk-to-boundary ones and using the usual field theoretic trick of Feynman parameters, all the integrals over the hyperbolic space as well as over the boundary can be taken. Moreover, as we shall see, all the integrals over the Feynman parameters can be taken as well, at the expense of introducing 4 Barnes-Mellin type integrals. The expression we end up with has these 4 integrals remaining. Our final result for the RW coefficient is: \be\label{result} (6\Delta)= K_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6} K_{\Delta_4,\bar{\Delta}_2,\bar{\Delta}_3,\bar{\Delta}_5,\bar{\Delta}_6} \\ \nonumber \int \frac{d\lambda ds}{(2\pi i)^2} \int \frac{d\lambda' ds'}{(2\pi i)^2} \Gamma(-s) \Gamma(-\lambda) \Gamma(-s') \Gamma(-\lambda') \\ \nonumber \Gamma(\gamma-s) \Gamma(\delta-\lambda) \Gamma(\alpha+s+\lambda)\Gamma(\beta+s+\lambda)\\ \nonumber \Gamma(\gamma'-s') \Gamma(\delta'-\lambda') \Gamma(\alpha'+s'+\lambda')\Gamma(\beta'+s'+\lambda')\\ \nonumber \pi^{d/2} \frac{\Upsilon_d(\lambda-s'-\lambda'-A)\Upsilon_d(\lambda'-s-\lambda+A)}{\Upsilon_d(-s-s')}, \end{eqnarray} where \be \Upsilon_d(x)=\frac{\Gamma(x)}{\Gamma(d/2-x)}. \end{eqnarray} The integration contour in each of the four variables is parallel to the imaginary axis at $\mathrm{Re}(z) = r$, where the parameter $r$ can be chosen freely in the interval $-d/8<r<0$. Various quantities that appear in \eqref{result} are defined as follows: \be\nonumber && \alpha=\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}, \qquad \alpha'=\frac{\bar{\Delta}_4+\bar{\Delta}_6-\bar{\Delta}_2}{2},\\ \nonumber && \beta=\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2}, \qquad \beta'=\frac{\bar{\Delta}_4+\bar{\Delta}_3-\bar{\Delta}_5}{2}, \\ \label{coef-res} && \gamma=\frac{\Delta_2-\Delta_3+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2}, \qquad \gamma'=\frac{\bar{\Delta}_2-\bar{\Delta}_3+\bar{\Delta}_5-\bar{\Delta}_6}{2}, \\ \nonumber && \delta=\frac{\Delta_1-\bar{\Delta}_1}{2}, \qquad \delta'=\frac{\Delta_4-\bar{\Delta}_4}{2}, \\ \nonumber && A= \frac{\Delta_1-\Delta_4+\Delta_2+\Delta_5-d}{2}, \\ \nonumber && K_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6} \\ \nonumber && \ \ = \frac{\pi^{3d/2} \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2+\Delta_3-d}{2})\Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_5+\Delta_6-d}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_5+\Delta_6-\Delta_1}{2})} {4 \Gamma^2(\Delta_1)\Gamma(\Delta_2)\Gamma(\Delta_3)\Gamma(\Delta_5)\Gamma(\Delta_6)}. \end{eqnarray} As is shown in the main text, for type I representations the Barnes-Mellin integrals in \eqref{result} converge in absolute value, so that this formula gives a well-defined representation of the RW coeffcient. The expression \eqref{result} can potentially be used for numerical study of the $6j$-symbol as well as for the study of the asymptotics. We do not consider these problems in the present paper. Given the answer \eqref{result} for the RW coefficient one may ask if it is ``as expected'' from general considerations. For instance, it can be expected that the non-compact case answer can be obtained by some ``analytic continuation'' from the one of the compact case. By ``analytic continuation'' one could mean some procedure of rather free manipulation with the compact answer by replacing the finite sums with integrals and continuing the representation labels to complex values. For example, the answer for the $\SU(2)$ RW coefficient is given by a single finite sum. Should one expect the $\SO_0(1,2)$, and more generally $\SO_0(1,d+1)$, RW coefficient to be given by a single integral? Here we would like to argue against this expectation. As is clear from the computation of the $6j$-symbol given in \cite{VK-1}, the fact that representations of $\SU(2)$ are highest weight is used in an essential way. The idea of the computation is as follows. Consider a product of 3 Clebsch-Gordan coefficients contracted to form a ``star-triangle''. When the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients are appropriately normalized, this star-triangle is proportional to a single Clebsch-Gordan coefficient with the proportionality coefficient being the $6j$-symbol: \be \sum_{m_{ij}} C^{l_1 l_{12} l_{13}}_{m_1 m_{12} m_{13}} C^{l_2 l_{23} l_{12}}_{m_2 m_{23} m_{12}} C^{l_3 l_{13} l_{23}}_{m_3 m_{13} m_{23}} = (6j) C^{l_1 l_2 l_3}_{m_1 m_2 m_3} . \end{eqnarray} Here the $m$-labels should satisfy a conservation law for each Clebsch-Gordan coefficient: \be m_1 = m_{12}+ m_{13},\, m_2= m_{23}+ m_{12},\, m_3 = m_{23} - m_{13},\, m_2 =m_1 + m_3. \end{eqnarray} Thus, there is only a single loop ``momentum'' to be summed over. Each Clebsch-Gordan coefficient is also given by a finite sum, see \cite{VK-1}. Therefore, we have 4 sums on the left hand side and one sum times the $6j$-symbol on the right hand side. What simplifies the computation considerably is that one can set the basis labels $m_1, m_2$ to be highest weight. For such values of $m$ the sum that gives the Clebsch-Gordan coefficient reduces to a single term. Thus, if we put two of the external states to be highest weight, we get only two sums remaining on the left hand side and no sum times the $6j$ on the right. One of the summations on the left hand side can be carried out explicitly using Gauss's sum. One gets an expression for the $6j$ given by a single sum. Let us now return to the non-compact case. Going to a ``momentum'' basis, analogous to the $m$-basis of $\SU(2)$, one can have momentum conserved at each vertex. One analogously will have to do only a single integral over the loop momentum. However, in the momentum basis the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients are no longer as simple as in \eqref{3j}. One should expect an integral representation with at least one integral. Now, the type I representations are not highest or lowest weight. Thus, there is no simplification of the momentum basis Clebsch-Gordan coefficients that can be used in the computation of the $6j$-symbol. The total number of integrals remains at least 4 on the right hand side and at least one on the left hand side. Thus, at the very best one expects the non-compact $6j$ symbol for type I representations to be given by 3 integrals. We have tried to further simplify our answer \eqref{result} in line with this this expectation. Unfortunately, no summation theorems for the generalized hypergeometric series seem to be applicable, and we were not able to simplify the result further. It thus remains an interesting open problem to find a simpler representation for the RW coefficient than the one given by \eqref{result}. This paper is organized as follows. We start in section \ref{sec:prop} by reviewing the bulk-to-bulk and bulk-to-boundary propagators. Section \ref{sec:rw} gives a formula for the RW coefficients in terms of bulk-to-bulk propagators, as well as another convenient representation in terms of a boundary 4-point function. In section \ref{sec:3j} we compute the 3-point function, and in section \ref{sec:norm} we discuss its normalization. An important regularization procedure is introduced here. In section \ref{sec:4-point} we compute the 4-point function. Finally, in section \ref{sec:comp} we compute the remaining sphere integrals. Certain technical results are given in two appendices. \section{Bulk-to-bulk and bulk-to-boundary propagators} \label{sec:prop} In this section we allow $d$ to be any positive integer. We consider the $d$-dimensional conformal group $\SO_0(1,d+1)$. One of the associated homogeneous spaces is the hyperbolic space $H_{d+1}=\SO_0(1,d+1)/\SO(d+1)$. The space $L^2(H_{d+1})$ of square integrable functions on $H_{d+1}$ decomposes into irreducible representations of the so-called type I series. More generally, the most degenerate series of representations of the conformal group is that in the space of homogeneous functions on the light cone in Minkowski space $M^{1,d+1}$. Functions of degree of homogeneity $-\Delta$ form an irreducible representation of ``conformal dimension'' $\Delta$. Not all of these representations are unitary. For unitary representations of type I the conformal dimension is given by \eqref{type-1}. Thoughout the paper, we label the representations by their conformal dimension~$\Delta$. While the final results will be justified only for the type I values \eqref{type-1}, several intermediate results remain valid for more general values, and we present the intermediate results in this form in view of potential extensions beyond type I representations. To proceed, we need the notions of bulk-to-bulk and bulk-to-boundary propagators \cite{Witten}. We use the upper half-space model of $H_{d+1}$. Let the coordinates in the upper half-space be $(\xi_0>0,\xi_i), i=1,\ldots,d$. The metric is then: \be ds^2 = \frac{1}{\xi_0^2}(d\xi_0^2 + \sum_i d\xi_i^2). \end{eqnarray} The boundary of $H_{d+1}$ is the set of points with $\xi_0=0$ and the point at infinity. When referring to points of the boundary we shall use a different letter $x: x_i=\xi_i$. Following \cite{Witten}, we introduce the following function of a point on the boundary $x$ and a bulk point $\xi$ in $H_{d+1}$: \be\label{bound-prop} K_\Delta(\xi,x) = \frac{\xi_0^\Delta}{(\xi_0^2+|\xi-x|^2)^\Delta}. \end{eqnarray} We refer to this function as the bulk-to-boundary propagator. Another, more familiar from mathematics literature, expression for this object is given by: \be\label{bound-prop-1} K_\Delta(\hat\xi,\hat x)=(\hat \xi \cdot \hat x)^{-\Delta}, \end{eqnarray} where the vectors $\hat\xi$ and $ \hat x$ in Minkowski space $M^{1,d+1}$ are the representatives of respectively $\xi$ and $x$ in the hyperboloid model of $H_{d+1}$ and the dot product is the Minkowski pairing. $\hat\xi$ is unit timelike and $ \hat x$ is null. The bulk-to-bulk propagator is obtained by taking a product of two propagators \eqref{bound-prop}, one for representation $\Delta$, another for the dual representation $\bar{\Delta}$, and integrating over the point on the boundary: \be\label{bulk-prop} K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \int_{S^d} d^dx\, K_\Delta(\xi_1,x) K_{\bar{\Delta}}(\xi_2,x). \end{eqnarray} We have denoted the integration domain, $x\in\mathbb{R}^d$, by $S^d$ as a reminder of the boundary topology in the Poincare ball model of $H_{d+1}$. As the integrand is asymptotic to a constant times $|x|^{-2d}$ at $|x|\to\infty$, the integral converges for all $\Delta\in\mathbb{C}$. The bulk-to-bulk propagator \eqref{bulk-prop} can be computed explicitly. To begin, assume ${\rm Re}(\Delta) >0$ and ${\rm Re}(\bar\Delta) >0$. Using the Feynman representation reviewed in Appendix~\ref{app:integrals}, we obtain: \be K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{(\xi_1^0)^\Delta (\xi_2^0)^{\bar{\Delta}}}{\Gamma(\Delta)\Gamma(\bar{\Delta})} \int_{S^d} d^dx \int dt du\,\, t^{\Delta-1} u^{\bar{\Delta}-1} \\ \nonumber e^{-t (\xi_1^0)^2 -u (\xi_2^0)^2 - t|\xi_1-x|^2 -u|\xi_2-x|^2}. \end{eqnarray} Taking the integral over $x$ yields: \be\nonumber K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{(\xi_1^0)^\Delta (\xi_2^0)^{\bar{\Delta}}}{\Gamma(\Delta)\Gamma(\bar{\Delta})} \int dt du\,\, t^{\Delta-1} u^{\bar{\Delta}-1} \\ \nonumber e^{-t (\xi_1^0)^2 -u (\xi_2^0)^2} \frac{\pi^{d/2}}{(t+u)^{d/2}} e^{-\frac{t u}{t+u} |\xi_1-\xi_2|^2}. \end{eqnarray} By construction, $K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)$ is invariant under the action of the Lorentz group and hence depends on $\xi_1$ and $\xi_2$ only through their hyperbolic distance~$l$. Using this invariance, we can choose $\xi_1 = (\xi_1^0, 0)$ and $\xi_2 = (\xi_2^0, 0)$, in which case \be l=\log{(\xi_1^0/\xi_2^0)}. \end{eqnarray} Writing $\mu=e^l$ and rescaling the integration variables, we obtain: \be K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{\pi^{d/2} \mu^\Delta}{\Gamma(\Delta)\Gamma(\bar{\Delta})} \int \frac{dt du}{(t+u)^{d/2}} \,\, t^{\Delta-1} u^{\bar{\Delta}-1} e^{-t \mu^2-u}. \end{eqnarray} The integrals over $t$ and $u$ can now be taken with the change of variables \be\label{change} \lambda = \frac{t}{t+u}, \qquad dt \, du = \frac{u d\lambda \, du}{(1-\lambda)^2}, \end{eqnarray} where $0<\lambda<1$. We get: \be K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{\pi^{d/2} \mu^\Delta}{\Gamma(\Delta)\Gamma(\bar{\Delta})} \int_0^1 \frac{d\lambda}{(1-\lambda)^{2-d/2}} \int_0^\infty \frac{du}{u^{d/2-1}}\\ \nonumber \left(\frac{\lambda u}{1-\lambda}\right)^{\Delta-1} u^{\bar{\Delta}-1} e^{-u(\frac{\lambda \mu^2}{1-\lambda}+1)}. \end{eqnarray} The integral over $u$ gives: \be K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{\pi^{d/2} \mu^\Delta \Gamma(d/2)}{\Gamma(\Delta)\Gamma(\bar{\Delta})} \int_0^1 d\lambda\, \lambda^{\Delta-1} (1-\lambda)^{d-\Delta-1} (1-\lambda(1-\mu^2))^{-d/2}. \end{eqnarray} Using the integral representation of the hypergeometric function, \be F(a,b,c;z)=\frac{\Gamma(c)}{\Gamma(b)\Gamma(c-b)} \int_0^1 dt\,\, t^{b-1} (1-t)^{c-b-1} (1-tz)^{-a}, \end{eqnarray} we finally obtain: \be \label{eq:bulk-bulk-hyper} K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{\pi^{d/2} \mu^\Delta \Gamma(d/2)}{\Gamma(d)} F(d/2,\Delta,d,1-\mu^2). \end{eqnarray} By analytic continuation, the result \eqref{eq:bulk-bulk-hyper} holds for all $\Delta\in\mathbb{C}$. Note that there is no singularity when $\Delta$ is a non-positive integer; the hypergeometric series just terminates then. We also note that, in view of the identity: \be F(c-a,c-b,c;z)=(1-z)^{a+b-c}F(a,b,c;z) \end{eqnarray} we have $K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)=K_{\bar{\Delta}}(\xi_1,\xi_2)$. Thus, the bulk-to-bulk propagator is a non-oriented one. Indeed, the change of orientation is equivalent to the replacement $\Delta\to\bar{\Delta}$, but this does not change the propagator. The result \eqref{eq:bulk-bulk-hyper} can be expressed in terms of a Legendre function~\cite{abra-stegun}. For $d=1$, the formula was given in \cite{Manuel}. For $d=2$, the result can be given in terms of an elementary function as \be K_\Delta(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{\pi}{\Delta-1} \frac{\sinh{(\Delta-1)l}}{\sinh{l}}. \end{eqnarray} For type I representations this reduces to: \be K_\rho(\xi_1,\xi_2)= \frac{\pi}{\rho} \frac{\sin{\rho l}}{\sinh{l}}. \end{eqnarray} \section{Racah-Wigner coefficients} \label{sec:rw} We shall compute the RW coefficients through an object called the $(6\Delta)$ symbol, given by an integral over 4 copies of $H_{d+1}$ of a product of 6 bulk-to-bulk propagators: \be\label{6j} (6\Delta)=\int_{H_{d+1}} d\xi_1 \ldots d\xi_4 \prod_{i<j} K_{\Delta_{ij}}(\xi_i,\xi_j). \end{eqnarray} Here $i,j=1,\ldots,4$ enumerate the points integrated over and $\Delta_{ij}$ are the 6 representations that the $(6\Delta)$ symbols depend upon. We begin formally with general $\Delta_{ij}\in\mathbb{C}$ but will eventually specialise to the type I values \eqref{type-1}. Since the non-type-I representations are not realizable in $L^2(H_{d+1})$, we do not expect that the integral \eqref{6j} can be made convergent for them even after eliminating the infinite volume factor by the procedure of section~\ref{sec:norm}. The relation between the $(6\Delta)$ symbol (\ref{6j}) and the RW coefficients has been discussed in~\cite{FK}. To make the present paper self-contained, we shall briefly recall the relation here. By definition, the representations of type I (with respect to a subgroup $H$) are those which contain a vector invariant under $H$. When $G=\SO_0(1,d+1)$, the subgroup $H$ is taken to be the maximal compact subgroup $H=\SO(d+1)$. Let $\pi^\rho$ be a type I representation, labelled by the index $\rho$, and let $\omega$ be an $H$-invariant vector. We define on $G$ the function $\phi^\rho$ as the $\omega\omega$ matrix element of $\pi^\rho$, \be \label{eq:phisuprho-def} \phi^\rho(g) := t^\rho_{\omega\omega}(g) := \langle \omega | \pi^\rho(g) |\omega \rangle. \end{eqnarray} $\phi^\rho$ is called a {\it spherical} function. Given $\phi^\rho$, we define the kernel \be \label{eq:Krho-spherdef} K_\rho(g_1,g_2) := \phi^\rho(g_1^{-1} g_2). \end{eqnarray} As $\omega$ is invariant under $H$, (\ref{eq:phisuprho-def}) shows that $\phi^\rho$ projects into a function on the double coset $H\backslash G / H$, and (\ref{eq:Krho-spherdef}) then shows that the kernel projects into a function on two copies of the homogeneous space $G/H$. In the case of $G=\SO_0(1,d+1)$ and $H=\SO(d+1)$, this homogeneous space is the hyperbolic space $H^{d+1}$, and from the explicit evaluation of the spherical function in section 9.3.1 of \cite{VK-2} it is seen that the kernel (\ref{eq:Krho-spherdef}) concides (up to a multiple that depends on the normalization of~$\omega$) with the bulk-to-bulk propagator~(\ref{eq:bulk-bulk-hyper}). Next, we recall the definition of the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients. Given two (irreducible) representations $V^{\rho_1}, V^{\rho_2}$ of $G$, one can decompose the tensor product representation $V^{\rho_1} \otimes V^{\rho_2}$ into irreducible representations $V^\rho$ as \be \label{eq:Vrho1-tensor-Vrho2} V^{\rho_1} \otimes V^{\rho_2} = \oplus_{\rho_3} n(\rho_3) V^{\rho_3}, \end{eqnarray} where $n(\rho)$ are multiplicities. The Clebsch-Gordan coefficients are the matrix elements of the intertwining map defined by this decomposition. Explicitly, if $i_1$ and $i_2$ are vectors in respectively $V^{\rho_1}$ and $V^{\rho_2}$, we have \be \label{eq:CG-def} |i_1 \rangle \otimes \,\, |i_2\rangle = \sum_{\alpha \rho_3 i_3} {}^\alpha C^{\rho_3 i_3}_{\rho_1 i_1 \rho_2 i_2}\,\, |i_3 \rangle, \end{eqnarray} where $\{i_3\}$ is a (generalised) basis in $V^{\rho_3}$, the sum on the right-hand side includes a sum over the multiplicity label $\alpha = 1\ldots n(\rho_3)$, and the sum over the other labels is understood in the sense of a sum or an integral depending on whether the labels are discrete or continuous. The $C$'s on the right-hand side are then the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients in the respective bases. We will further need the orthogonality relation for the matrix elements $t^\rho_{i_1 i_2}(g) := \langle i_1 | \pi^\rho(g) | i_2 \rangle$. This relation reads \be \label{eq:me-orthog} \int dg \,\, t^{\rho_1}_{i_1 j_1}(g) t^{\rho_2}_{i_2 j_2}(g) = \delta^{\rho_1 \rho_2} \delta_{i_1 i_2} \delta_{j_1 j_2}, \end{eqnarray} where we have used the reality of the matrix elements for $G=\SO_0(1,d+1)$, and the deltas on the right-hand side are understood as Kronecker or Dirac deltas as appropriate. For a compact group, whose representations are finite-dimensional, the right-hand side of (\ref{eq:me-orthog}) would usually be normalised to include the factor $1/{\rm dim}(j_1)$, but in our case of a noncompact group the representations are infinite-dimensional and such a normalisation is not an option. Using (\ref{eq:CG-def}) and (\ref{eq:me-orthog}), it is then possible to compute the integral of the product of three matrix elements, with the result \be \label{eq:3-prod-int} \int dg\,\, t^{\rho_1}_{i_1 j_1}(g) t^{\rho_2}_{i_2 j_2}(g) t^{\rho_3}_{i_3 j_3}(g) = \sum_{\alpha} {}^\alpha C^{\rho_3 i_3}_{\rho_1 i_1 \rho_2 i_2} {}^\alpha C^{\rho_3 j_3}_{\rho_1 j_1 \rho_2 j_2}. \end{eqnarray} Now, when the the multiplicity of type I representations in the tensor product (\ref{eq:Vrho1-tensor-Vrho2}) of two such representations is equal to one, the multiplicity label on the type I Clebsch-Gordan coefficients becomes redundant, and it can be shown from (\ref{eq:3-prod-int}) that the $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} equals the usual type I RW coefficient, constructed from the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients, multiplied by four factors of the form $C^{\rho_3 \omega}_{\rho_1 \omega \rho_2 \omega}$, one such factor coming from each $\xi$ in~\eqref{6j}. In this case one can therefore regard the $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} as the type I RW coefficient up to a certain normalisation factor. When the multiplicity of type I representations in the tensor product of two such representations is not equal to one, on the other hand, the multiplicity label on the type I Clebsch-Gordan coefficients cannot be dropped. The $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} involves then factors of the form ${}^\alpha C^{\rho_3 \omega}_{\rho_1 \omega \rho_2 \omega}$ for each~$\xi$, and there is a \emph{sum\/} over the four independent multiplicity labels. As the type I RW coefficients then have a multiplicity label corresponding to each~$\xi$, the $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} is no longer a simple multiple of the type I RW coefficients. Thus, to establish the relation of the $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} to the usual RW coefficients it remains to find the multiplicity of type I representations in the tensor product (\ref{eq:Vrho1-tensor-Vrho2}) of two such representations. For $\SO_0(1,2)$ this multiplicity is known to be 2 \cite{Puk}. The $\SO_0(1,2)$ $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} is therefore not a simple multiple of (any of the) RW coefficients. The $\SO_0(1,2)$ $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} can still be computed and used as a basis of a state sum model~\cite{Manuel}, but its group theoretic interpretation does not appear straightforward. For $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ with $d>1$, the multiplicity of type I representations in the tensor product (\ref{eq:Vrho1-tensor-Vrho2}) of two such representations is one. To see this, we recall that the principal series representations can be obtained as the induced representations of the parabolic subgroup $MAN$, where $N$ is the $d$-dimensional Abelian group of null rotations, $A$ is the one-dimensional group of dilatations and $M=\SO(d)$, and in particular the type I representations are induced from the \emph{trivial\/} representation of $M$ \cite{Dobrev}. The claim then follows from Theorem 16 of \cite{Martin} and the discussion of $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ on pages 182--183 therein. This establishes the relation of our $(6\Delta)$ symbol \eqref{6j} to the usual RW coefficients for $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ with $d>1$. To proceed with the analysis of the $(6\Delta)$ symbol, we represent four of the six bulk-to-bulk propagators in \eqref{6j} as in \eqref{bulk-prop}, while leaving the two bulk-to-bulk propagators corresponding to the opposite edges of the tetrahedron in their original form. By doing this one achieves the representation as is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig-2}. \begin{figure} \centering \epsfig{figure=4-point.eps, height=1in} \caption{Expression for the Racah-Wigner coeffient in terms of the 4-point functions.\label{fig-2}} \end{figure} Thus, let us introduce the following object: \be\label{4-point} D_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) = \\ \nonumber \int_{H_{d+1}} d\xi d\eta \,\, K_{\Delta_2}(\xi,x_2)K_{\Delta_3}(\xi,x_3) K_{\Delta_1}(\xi,\eta) K_{\Delta_5}(\eta,x_5)K_{\Delta_6}(\eta,x_6). \end{eqnarray} This quantity is a particular 4-point function on the boundary. With the help of this 4-point function, the RW coefficient can be written as: \be\label{6j-4-point} (6\Delta)=\int_{S^d} d^dx_2 d^dx_3 d^dx_5 d^dx_6 \,\, \\ \nonumber D_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) D_{\Delta_4,\bar{\Delta}_2,\bar{\Delta_6},\bar{\Delta}_5,\bar{\Delta}_3}(x_2,x_6,x_5,x_3). \end{eqnarray} This representation is much more convenient than the one given by \eqref{6j}, since the 4-point function $D_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6)$ can be computed explicitly. Computing the RW coefficient then reduces to the computation of the $S^d$ integrals in \eqref{6j-4-point}. As we shall see in section~\ref{sec:norm}, after a certain gauge fixing that is necessary to render the result finite, what one has is actually not 4 integrals but a single integral over the sphere. This makes the representation \eqref{6j-4-point} very convenient for practical applications. We note that this representation is only available in the context of non-compact conformal groups, when there is a boundary and the associated representation \eqref{bulk-prop}. For compact groups like $\SO(n)$ one can also compute the RW coefficients for type I representations by integrating over the appropriate homogeneous manifold. However, there is no analog of the representation \eqref{6j-4-point}. Thus, we would like to compute the 4-point function given by \eqref{4-point}. In order to do this, we use the representation \eqref{bulk-prop} for the remaining bulk propagator. Thus, we represent the 4-point function as: \be D_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) = \\ \nonumber \int d^dx_1\, C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}(x_1,x_2,x_3) C_{\bar{\Delta}_1,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_1,x_5,x_6), \end{eqnarray} where we have defined the 3-point function: \be\label{3-point} C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}(x_1,x_2,x_3) = \int_{H_{d+1}} d\xi K_{\Delta_1}(\xi,x_1) K_{\Delta_2}(\xi,x_2) K_{\Delta_3}(\xi,x_3). \end{eqnarray} We need to find this 3-point function. \section{3-point function} \label{sec:3j} We note in passing that the 3-point function \eqref{3-point} is the Clebsch-Gordan coefficient when the representations are realised in the space of functions on the boundary. Since $d>1$ by assumption, these Clebsch-Gordan coefficients have no multiplicity indices. The conditions for the integral in \eqref{3-point} to converge are \be\label{eq:conv1} {\rm Re}(\sum_i \Delta_i) > d \end{eqnarray} and \be\label{eq:conv2} {\rm Re}(\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3)>0,{\rm Re}(\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1)>0,{\rm Re}(\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2)>0. \end{eqnarray} These conditions can be conveniently obtained by transforming to the Poincare ball model of $H_{d+1}$: \eqref{eq:conv2} comes from neighbourhoods of the three boundary points $x_i$, and \eqref{eq:conv1} comes from the remaining part of the boundary. Note that \eqref{eq:conv2} implies ${\rm Re}(\Delta_i)>0$ for all~$i$. Note also that the convergence holds for type I representations. In order to compute the bulk integral we use the Feynman parametrization \eqref{feyn} for each of the bulk-to-boundary propagators. We get: \be\label{3j-1} C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}(x_1,x_2,x_3) = \frac{1}{\Gamma(\Delta_1)} \frac{1}{\Gamma(\Delta_2)} \frac{1}{\Gamma(\Delta_3)} \int_0^\infty dt_1 dt_2 dt_3\, t_1^{\Delta_1-1} t_2^{\Delta_2-1} t_3^{\Delta_3-1} \\ \nonumber \int_0^\infty \frac{d\xi_0}{\xi_0^{d+1}}\, \xi_0^{\sum_i \Delta_i} \int_{S^d} d^d\xi \, e^{-t_1(\xi_0^2+|\xi-x_1|^2)-t_2(\xi_0^2+|\xi-x_2|^2)-t_3(\xi_0^2+|\xi-x_3|^2)}. \end{eqnarray} We now use the formulas \eqref{1}, \eqref{2} of Appendix \ref{app:integrals} to get: \be C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}(x_1,x_2,x_3) = \frac{\pi^{d/2} \Gamma(\frac{\sum_i \Delta_i-d}{2})}{2 \Gamma(\Delta_1)\Gamma(\Delta_2)\Gamma(\Delta_3)} \int_0^\infty dt_1 dt_2 dt_3\, t_1^{\Delta_1-1} t_2^{\Delta_2-1} t_3^{\Delta_3-1} \\ \nonumber (S_t)^{-(\sum_i \Delta_i)/2} e^{-\frac{1}{S_t}(\sum_{i<j} t_i t_j |x_i-x_j|^2)}. \end{eqnarray} We now make a series of changes of variables of integration. The first change is: \be\label{change-1} t_i = (S_t)^{1/2} t_i' = (\sum_j t_j') t_i', \qquad {\rm det}\left( \frac{\partial t_i}{\partial t_j'}\right) = 2 (S_t)^{3/2}. \end{eqnarray} Removing the primes, we get: \be &{}& C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}(x_1,x_2,x_3) \\ \nonumber &=& \frac{\pi^{d/2} \Gamma(\frac{\sum_i \Delta_i-d}{2})}{\Gamma(\Delta_1)\Gamma(\Delta_2)\Gamma(\Delta_3)} \int_0^\infty dt_1 dt_2 dt_3\, t_1^{\Delta_1-1} t_2^{\Delta_2-1} t_3^{\Delta_3-1} e^{- \sum_{i<j} t_i t_j x_{ij}^2 }. \end{eqnarray} Here we have introduced: \be x_{ij}=|x_i-x_j|. \end{eqnarray} The second change of variables is: \be\label{change-2} t_1 t_2 \to \frac{t_1 t_2}{x_{12}^2}, \qquad t_1 t_3 \to \frac{t_1 t_3}{x_{13}^2}, \qquad t_2 t_3 \to \frac{t_2 t_3}{x_{23}^2}. \end{eqnarray} The integral reduces to: \be C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}(x_1,x_2,x_3)= \frac{1} {(x_{12})^{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3} (x_{13})^{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2} (x_{23})^{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1}} \\ \nonumber \frac{\pi^{d/2} \Gamma(\frac{\sum_i \Delta_i-d}{2})}{\Gamma(\Delta_1)\Gamma(\Delta_2)\Gamma(\Delta_3)} \int_0^\infty dt_1 dt_2 dt_3\, t_1^{\Delta_1-1} t_2^{\Delta_2-1} t_3^{\Delta_3-1} e^{- \sum_{i<j} t_i t_j }. \end{eqnarray} It is now possible to take the remaining integral in Feynman parameters by the following change of variables: \be\label{change-3} t_1 t_2 =u_3, \qquad t_1 t_3=u_2, \qquad t_2 t_3 = u_1, \end{eqnarray} so that: \be t_1^2 = \frac{u_2 u_3}{u_1}, \qquad t_2^2 = \frac{u_1 u_3}{u_2}, \qquad t_3^2 = \frac{u_1 u_2}{u_3}, \qquad {\rm det}\left( \frac{\partial t_i}{\partial u_j}\right) = \frac{1}{2\sqrt{u_1 u_2 u_3}}. \end{eqnarray} The integral over $t_i$ thus reduces to: \be \frac{1}{2}\int_0^\infty du_1 du_2 du_3 \, u_1^{\frac{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1-2}{2}} u_2^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2-2}{2}} u_3^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3-2}{2}} e^{-u_1-u_2-u_3} = \\ \nonumber \frac{1}{2} \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2}). \end{eqnarray} Thus, we get for the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients: \be\label{3j} C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}(x_1,x_2,x_3)=\frac{C(\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3)}{(x_{12})^{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3} (x_{13})^{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2} (x_{23})^{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1}}, \end{eqnarray} where \be\label{C} &{}& C(\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3) = \\ \nonumber &{}& \frac{\pi^{d/2} \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2+\Delta_3-d}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2})}{2 \Gamma(\Delta_1)\Gamma(\Delta_2)\Gamma(\Delta_3)}. \end{eqnarray} \section{Normalization of the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients. Gauge fixing procedure.} \label{sec:norm} In this section we introduce a certain gauge fixing procedure that is necessary to render the integrals defining the RW coefficient finite. We do this considerering as an example the question of normalization fo the Clebsch-Gordan coefficient. To this end, let us compute the so-called theta symbol given by: \be\label{theta} \theta(\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3) = \int_{H_{d+1}} d\xi_1 d\xi_2 \, K_{\Delta_1}(\xi_1,\xi_2) K_{\Delta_2}(\xi_1,\xi_2)K_{\Delta_3}(\xi_1,\xi_2). \end{eqnarray} Using the expression for the 3$j$ symbol that we have just computed, this becomes: \be\label{theta-1} \theta(\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3) = C(\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3) C(\bar{\Delta}_1,\bar{\Delta}_2,\bar{\Delta}_3) \int_{S^d} d^dx_1 d^dx_2 d^dx_3 \frac{1}{x_{12}^d x_{13}^d x_{23}^d}. \end{eqnarray} The integral over $x_1,x_2,x_3$ in \eqref{theta-1} is divergent. This divergence is a manifestation of the obvious divergence in integrating over $H_{d+1}$ a function that is invariant under the isometries: The integral is proportional to the infinite volume of $H_{d+1}$. As the volume of $H_{d+1}$ is related to the volume of the Lorentz group, the divergence ultimately comes from the fact that the Lorentz group is non-compact. In \eqref{theta}, the divergence can be removed by fixing one of the integration points and only integrating over the remaining one. To remove the divergence in \eqref{theta-1}, and in similar integrals with more integration points, we can use the action of the conformal group on the sphere to put three of the integration points to specific locations. For $d=2$ this procedure completely fixes the $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ invariance and hence eliminates the divergence \cite{Strings}. For $d>2$ this procedure fixes the $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ invariance up to the $\SO(d-1)$ subgroup that leaves the three prescribed points invariant, but as this subgroup is compact, the divergence has again been eliminated. To implement this procedure, one needs to find the Faddeev-Popov determinant that makes the result independent of the locations to which the three integration points are fixed. We shall do this in Appendix \ref{app:measure} by decomposing the Haar measure on $\SO_0(1,d+1)$ in terms of the locations of the three fixed points and the invariantly-normalised volume of the compact subgroup $\SO(d-1)$ (which is trivial for $d=2$). The result is the replacement \be\label{measure-d} \prod_i d^dx_i \to |x_A-x_B|^d |x_A-x_C|^d |x_B-x_C|^d \\ \nonumber \delta^d(x_A-x_A^0)\delta^d(x_B-x_B^0)\delta^d(x_C-x_C^0) \prod_i d^dx_i, \end{eqnarray} where $x_A$, $x_B$ and $x_C$ are the three integration points that are fixed respectively to the locations $x_A^0$, $x_B^0$ and~$x_C^0$. For $d=2$, formula \eqref{measure-d} reduces to that found in~\cite{Strings}. In the divergent integral~\eqref{theta-1}, the gauge fixing \eqref{measure-d} simply removes the integral. This gives for the normalization of the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients the formula \be \label{theta-norm} \theta(\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3) = C(\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3) C(\bar{\Delta}_1,\bar{\Delta}_2,\bar{\Delta}_3). \end{eqnarray} \section{Computation of the 4-point function} \label{sec:4-point} Using the expression \eqref{3j} for the 3-point function, the 4-point function becomes: \be\label{eq:DCC-int} D_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) = C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3} C_{\bar{\Delta}_1,\Delta_5,\Delta_6} \int_{S^d} d^dx_1 \\ \nonumber \frac{1}{(x_{12})^{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3} (x_{13})^{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2} (x_{23})^{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1}} \\ \nonumber \frac{1}{(x_{15})^{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6} (x_{16})^{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5} (x_{56})^{\Delta_5+\Delta_6-\bar{\Delta}_1}}. \end{eqnarray} In addition to the convergence conditions of section \ref{sec:3j} for each of the 3-point functions, the conditions for the integral in \eqref{eq:DCC-int} to converge are: \be {\rm Re}(\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3)<d, \qquad {\rm Re}(\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2)<d, \\ \nonumber {\rm Re}(\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6)<d, \qquad {\rm Re}(\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5)<d. \end{eqnarray} Note that these conditions are satisfied for the type I representations. We see that only 4 of the quantities in the denominator involve $x_1$. In order to take the integral, let us use the Feynman representation for them. In other words, let us consider: \be\label{func-I} I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) = \int_0^\infty dt_{12} dt_{13} dt_{15} dt_{16} \\ \nonumber t_{12}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2}-1} t_{13}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}-1} t_{15}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2}-1} t_{16}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2}-1} \\ \nonumber \int_{S^d} d^dx_1 e^{-t_{12} x_{12}^2 -t_{13} x_{13}^2 - t_{15} x_{15}^2 -t_{16} x_{16}^2}, \end{eqnarray} In terms of this function: \be\label{D-I} D_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) = \frac{I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6)} {(x_{23})^{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\Delta_1}(x_{56})^{\Delta_5+\Delta_6-\bar{\Delta}_1}} \\ \nonumber \frac{C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}C_{\bar{\Delta}_1,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}} {\Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2})\Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2})\Gamma(\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2})}. \end{eqnarray} Let us now evaluate the function \eqref{func-I}. The integral over $x_1$ is taken using \eqref{2}: \be \int_{S^d} d^dx_1 e^{-t_{12} x_{12}^2 -t_{13} x_{13}^2 - t_{15} x_{15}^2 -t_{16} x_{16}^2} = \\ \nonumber \frac{\pi^{d/2}}{(S_t^1)^{d/2}} e^{-(t_{12} t_{13} x_{23}^2 + t_{12} t_{15} x_{25}^2 + t_{12} t_{16} x_{26}^2 + t_{13} t_{15} x_{35}^2 + t_{13} t_{16} x_{36}^2 + t_{15} t_{16} x_{56}^2)/S_t^1}, \end{eqnarray} where \be S_t^1 = t_{12}+t_{13}+t_{15}+t_{16}. \end{eqnarray} Let us now make a series of changes of variables. First, let us choose: \be t_{1i}=(S_t^1)^{1/2} t_{1i}', \qquad {\rm det} \left( \frac{\partial t_{1i}}{\partial t_{1i}'} \right) = 2 (S_t^1)^2. \end{eqnarray} After this change of variables we get: \be I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) =2\pi^{d/2} \int_0^\infty dt_{12} dt_{13} dt_{15} dt_{16} \\ \nonumber t_{12}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2}-1} t_{13}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}-1} t_{15}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2}-1} t_{16}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2}-1} \\ \nonumber e^{-t_{12} t_{13} x_{23}^2 - t_{12} t_{15} x_{25}^2 - t_{12} t_{16} x_{26}^2 - t_{13} t_{15} x_{35}^2 - t_{13} t_{16} x_{36}^2 - t_{15} t_{16} x_{56}^2}. \end{eqnarray} The second change of variables is: \be t_{12} t_{13} \to \frac{t_{12} t_{13}}{x_{23}^2}, \, t_{12} t_{15} \to \frac{t_{12} t_{15}}{x_{25}^2}, \, t_{12} t_{16} \to \frac{t_{12} t_{16}}{x_{26}^2}, \, t_{13} t_{15} \to \frac{t_{13} t_{15}}{x_{35}^2}. \end{eqnarray} As the consequence we get: \be t_{13} t_{16} = \frac{t_{13} t_{15} t_{12} t_{16}}{t_{12} t_{15}} \to \frac{x_{25}^2}{x_{35}^2 x_{26}^2} t_{13} t_{16}, \, t_{15} t_{16} = \frac{t_{13} t_{15} t_{12} t_{16}}{t_{12} t_{13}} \to \frac{x_{23}^2}{x_{35}^2 x_{26}^2} t_{15} t_{16}. \end{eqnarray} Or, equivalently: \be t_{12}\to t_{12} \frac{x_{35}}{x_{23} x_{25}}, \,\, t_{13}\to t_{13} \frac{x_{25}}{x_{23} x_{35}}, \,\, t_{15}\to t_{15} \frac{x_{23}}{x_{25} x_{35}}, \,\, t_{16}\to t_{16} \frac{x_{25} x_{23}}{x_{26}^2 x_{35}}. \end{eqnarray} As the result of this transformation we get: \be\label{I-1} I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) = \qquad\qquad \\ \nonumber \frac{2\pi^{d/2}}{(x_{23})^{\Delta_1-\bar{\Delta}_1} (x_{25})^{\Delta_2-\Delta_3+\Delta_5-\Delta_6} (x_{26})^{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5} (x_{35})^{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}} \\ \nonumber \int_0^\infty dt_{12} dt_{13} dt_{15} dt_{16} \,\, e^{-t_{12} t_{13} - t_{12} t_{15} - t_{12} t_{16} - t_{13} t_{15} - t_{13} t_{16} u - t_{15} t_{16} v} \\ \nonumber t_{12}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2}-1} t_{13}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}-1} t_{15}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2}-1} t_{16}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2}-1}. \end{eqnarray} Here we have introduced the cross-ratios: \be\label{cross} u=\frac{x_{25}^2 x_{36}^2}{x_{26}^2 x_{35}^2}, \qquad v=\frac{x_{23}^2 x_{56}^2}{x_{26}^2 x_{35}^2}. \end{eqnarray} The two cross-ratios are related for $d=2$ but independent for $d>2$. We now specialize to the type I representations. To compute the integrals over the Feynman parameters we, following an analogous computation in \cite{Gleb}, use the Mellin-Barnes integral representation: \be\label{barnes} e^{-z} = \frac{1}{2\pi i} \int_{r-i\infty}^{r+i\infty} ds \, \Gamma(-s) z^s, \qquad r<0, \qquad |{\rm arg} z|<\frac{\pi}{2}. \end{eqnarray} Thus, the integral over Feynman parameters becomes: \be\label{eq:interchange} \frac{1}{2} I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(u,v):= \int \frac{d\lambda ds}{(2\pi i)^2} \Gamma(-\lambda) \Gamma(-s) u^{s} v^{\lambda}\\ \nonumber \int_0^\infty dt_{12} dt_{13} dt_{15} dt_{16}\,\, e^{-t_{12} t_{13} - t_{12} t_{15} - t_{12} t_{16} - t_{13} t_{15}} \\ \nonumber t_{12}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2}-1} t_{13}^{\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}+s-1} t_{15}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2}+\lambda-1} t_{16}^{\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2}+s+\lambda-1}. \end{eqnarray} To justify the interchange of integrals that has led to \eqref{eq:interchange}, we assume that the parameter $r$ in the two Mellin-Barnes contours is the same and satisfies $-d/8 < r < 0$. This guarantees that the exponent of each $t_{ij}$ in \eqref{eq:interchange} has real part greater than~$-1$. In the Feynman parameter integrals, we change variables by: \be t_{12} t_{13} = u_1, \,\, t_{12} t_{15} =u_2, \,\, t_{12} t_{16}=u_3, \,\, t_{13} t_{15}=u_4, \end{eqnarray} or, equivalently: \be t_{12}^2=\frac{u_1 u_2}{u_4}, \,\, t_{13}^2=\frac{u_1 u_4}{u_2}, \,\, t_{15}^2 = \frac{u_2 u_4}{u_1}, \,\, t_{16}^2 = u_3^2 \frac{u_4}{u_1 u_2}. \end{eqnarray} The Jacobian of this transformation is: \be {\rm det}\left( \frac{\partial t_{1i}}{\partial u_j} \right) = \frac{1}{2u_1 u_2}. \end{eqnarray} Therefore, we get: \be\label{I-2} I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(u,v)= \int \frac{d\lambda ds}{(2\pi i)^2} \Gamma(-\lambda) \Gamma(-s) u^{s} v^{\lambda} \\ \nonumber \Gamma(\alpha+s+\lambda)\Gamma(\beta+s+\lambda) \Gamma(\gamma-s) \Gamma(\delta-\lambda), \end{eqnarray} where we have introduced the following quantities: \be\nonumber \alpha=\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}, \\ \label{alpha-b} \beta=\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2}, \\ \nonumber \gamma=\frac{\Delta_2-\Delta_3+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2}, \\ \nonumber \delta=\frac{\Delta_1-\bar{\Delta}_1}{2}. \end{eqnarray} Combining this, and the expressions \eqref{I-1}, \eqref{D-I}, we have for the 4-point function: \be\label{D-fin} D_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(x_2,x_3,x_5,x_6) = K_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6} \frac{ I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(u,v)}{(x_{25})^{\Delta_2-\Delta_3+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}} \\ \nonumber \frac{1}{(x_{23})^{\Delta_2+\Delta_3-\bar{\Delta}_1} (x_{26})^{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5} (x_{35})^{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}(x_{56})^{\Delta_5+\Delta_6-\bar{\Delta}_1}}, \end{eqnarray} where we have introduced: \be\label{K} K_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6} = \frac{\pi^{d/2} C_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3}C_{\bar{\Delta}_1,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}} {\Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_2-\Delta_3}{2})\Gamma(\frac{\Delta_1+\Delta_3-\Delta_2}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_5-\Delta_6}{2})\Gamma(\frac{\bar{\Delta}_1+\Delta_6-\Delta_5}{2})}. \end{eqnarray} Thus, essentially all non-triviality of the 4-point function is in the dependence of the function $I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(u,v)$ given by \eqref{I-2} on the two cross-ratios $u,v$. The integral representation \eqref{I-2} that we have obtained may be used to derive power series expansions of $I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(u,v)$ in $u$ and $v$ \cite{Gleb}. \section{Computation of the Racah-Wigner coefficients} \label{sec:comp} Having obtained the 4-point function we can use this result to compute the RW coefficients. Recalling \eqref{6j-4-point}, we get: \be\label{6j-interm} (6\Delta)=K_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6} K_{\Delta_4,\bar{\Delta}_2,\bar{\Delta}_3,\bar{\Delta}_5,\bar{\Delta}_6} \int_{S^d} \frac{d^dx_2 d^dx_3 d^dx_5 d^dx_6}{x_{23}^d x_{26}^d x_{35}^d x_{56}^d} \,\, \\ \nonumber \left( \frac{1}{v}\right)^{\frac{\Delta_1-\Delta_4+\Delta_2+\Delta_5-d}{2}} I_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6}(u,v) I_{\Delta_4,\bar{\Delta}_2,\bar{\Delta}_6,\bar{\Delta}_5,\bar{\Delta}_3}(u/v,1/v). \end{eqnarray} Here we have used the fact that under the exchange of $x_3, x_6$ we have: $v\to1/v, u\to u/v$. We have also used the relation \eqref{sum} between the conformal dimension and its dual and combined all powers of $x_{ij}$. Note that the integration measure in \eqref{6j-interm} is exactly right to give an invariant expression, as this measure can be verified to be invariant under conformal transformations of the $x_i$. What remains is to compute the sphere integrals in \eqref{6j-interm}. This integral is: \be\label{int-2} I_d(a,b)=\int_{S^d} \frac{dx_2 dx_3 dx_5 dx_6}{x_{23}^d x_{56}^d x_{26}^d x_{35}^d} \left(\frac{x_{23}x_{56}}{x_{26} x_{35}}\right)^{2a} \left(\frac{x_{25}x_{36}}{x_{26} x_{35}}\right)^{2b}, \end{eqnarray} where \be\label{a-b} a=- A+\lambda-s'-\lambda', \qquad b=s+s', \qquad A= \frac{\Delta_1-\Delta_4+\Delta_2+\Delta_5-d}{2} \end{eqnarray} As it stands, the integral \eqref{int-2} still diverges because of the volume of the gauge group. We eliminate this divergence by the replacement \eqref{measure-d}, leaving $x_2$ to be integrated over but fixing the locations of the other three points. The integral becomes: \be\label{I-d-2} I_d(a,b)= |x^0_3-x^0_6|^d \left|\frac{x^0_5-x^0_6}{x^0_3-x^0_5}\right|^{2a} \left|\frac{x^0_3-x^0_6}{x^0_3-x^0_5}\right|^{2b} \tilde{I}_d(a,b), \end{eqnarray} where \be\label{eq:I-gend} \tilde{I}_d(a,b)=\int_{S^d} dx_2\,\frac{|x_2-x^0_3|^{2a-d} |x_2-x^0_5|^{2b}}{|x_2-x^0_6|^{2a+2b+d}}. \end{eqnarray} The convergence conditions in \eqref{eq:I-gend} are \be {\rm Re}(a)>0, \qquad {\rm Re}(b+d/2)>0, \qquad {\rm Re}(a+b)<0, \end{eqnarray} and they are satisfied for our Mellin-Barnes contour choice, $-d/8 < r < 0$. To compute the integral over $x_2$ we use the Feynman parametrization. We have: \be\label{I-d-1} \tilde{I}_d(a,b)= \frac{1}{\Gamma(d/2-a)\Gamma(-b)\Gamma(a+b+d/2)} \int_{S^d} dx_2\, t_3^{d/2-a-1} t_5^{-b-1} t_6^{a+b+d/2-1} \\ \nonumber e^{-t_3|x_2-x^0_3|^2 -t_5|x_2-x^0_5|^2-t_6|x_2-x^0_6|^2}. \end{eqnarray} We have already dealt with essentially the same integral in section \ref{sec:3j}, formula \eqref{3j-1}. Thus, we shall be sketchy here. One first takes the $x_2$ integral using \eqref{2}. One then makes a series of rescalings of Feynman parameters $t_i$. The powers of these parameters in \eqref{I-d-1} are such that the rescaling \eqref{change-1} completely removes the quantity $S_t$ from the integral. Rescaling \eqref{change-2} takes the differences $|x^0_i-x^0_j|$ out of the integral, and their resulting powers are exactly such that they cancel the similar quantities in \eqref{I-d-2}. The last change of variables \eqref{change-3} reduces all the integrals to those giving $\Gamma$-functions. The final result is: \be\label{I-d-3} I_d(a,b)=\frac{\pi^{d/2} \Gamma(a)\Gamma(d/2+b)\Gamma(-a-b)}{\Gamma(d/2-a)\Gamma(-b)\Gamma(a+b+d/2)}= \frac{\pi^{d/2} \Upsilon_d(a) \Upsilon_d(-a-b)}{\Upsilon_d(-b)}, \end{eqnarray} where we have introduced a dimension-dependent $\Upsilon$-function given by: \be \Upsilon_d(x)=\frac{\Gamma(x)}{\Gamma(d/2-x)}. \end{eqnarray} Substituting the values \eqref{a-b} of the parameters $a$ and~$b$, our final result for the $(6\Delta)$ symbol is: \be\label{6j-d} (6\Delta)= K_{\Delta_1,\Delta_2,\Delta_3,\Delta_5,\Delta_6} K_{\Delta_4,\bar{\Delta}_2,\bar{\Delta}_3,\bar{\Delta}_5,\bar{\Delta}_6} \\ \nonumber \pi^{d/2} \int \frac{d\lambda ds}{(2\pi i)^2} \int \frac{d\lambda' ds'}{(2\pi i)^2} \Gamma(-s) \Gamma(-\lambda) \Gamma(-s') \Gamma(-\lambda') \\ \nonumber \Gamma(\gamma-s) \Gamma(\delta-\lambda) \Gamma(\alpha+s+\lambda)\Gamma(\beta+s+\lambda)\\ \nonumber \Gamma(\gamma'-s') \Gamma(\delta'-\lambda') \Gamma(\alpha'+s'+\lambda')\Gamma(\beta'+s'+\lambda')\\ \nonumber \frac{\Upsilon_d(\lambda-s'-\lambda'-A)\Upsilon_d(\lambda'-s-\lambda+A)}{\Upsilon_d(-s-s')}. \end{eqnarray} Using Stirling's formula and the assumption $-d/8<r<0$ for the Mellin-Barnes contours, it can be verified that the quadruple integral in \eqref{6j-d} is convergent in absolute value. Equation \eqref{6j-d} therefore gives a manifestly well-defined expression for the $(6\Delta)$ symbol. \section*{Acknowledgments} We thank John Barrett and Eli Hawkins for insightful discussions and an anonymous referee for pointing out the presence of a multiplicity label for $d=1$. KK is supported by an EPSRC Advanced Fellowship.

Introduction ============ Hot ambient temperatures and elevated humidity are known to negatively impact endurance exercise performance ([@B58]; [@B41]). Heat acclimation is an effective strategy to drive favorable physiological adaptations, thereby reducing athletic performance impairments caused by these challenging environments ([@B53]; [@B42]; [@B48]). Heat acclimation typically consists of repeated daily heat stress exposures, with exposure durations commonly lasting between 60 and 90 min. Traditionally, 10 days of heat exposure are undertaken to elicit the heat acclimation phenotype and improve endurance performance in the heat ([@B1]; [@B34]; [@B53]), though 75--80% of physiological adaptations occur in the first 4--7 days of heat acclimation in male cohorts ([@B39]; [@B56]). Based on this, [@B16] first demonstrate meaningful performance improvements following just 5 days of isothermic heat acclimation, termed "short-term heat acclimation" (STHA). STHA has since been defined as being \<7 days in length ([@B18]), and is promoted as a cost and time efficient option for athletes preparing for competition in the heat. Successful STHA lasting 4--7 days in male cohorts has been well documented ([@B43]; [@B12]; [@B7]; [@B15], [@B17]; [@B3]; [@B10]; [@B20]; [@B35]; [@B48]; [@B23]; [@B28]; [@B59]). However, few studies to date have examined STHA effects in female cohorts. It was initially shown that there were no sex differences (4 females vs. 4 males) in adaptations to 10-days heat acclimation when aerobic fitness and surface area to mass ratios were matched ([@B2]). However, [@B35] more recently reported a significant sex difference in the time course of heat acclimation (i.e., 5- vs. 10-days), challenging past assumptions. In this study [@B35] found that following STHA females did not exhibit a lower resting core temperature, or an attenuated rise in core temperature and heart rate (HR) when exercising at a fixed workload, critical requirements in demonstrating the heat acclimation adaptation. However, the male cohort successfully attained these adaptations following the same protocol. [@B36] then demonstrated that a longer daily heat exposure (achieved via 20-min of sitting in sauna suits in 50°C, 30%RH immediately before 90-min isothermic heat acclimation) successfully induced heat adaptations in a female cohort following STHA (5-days). The authors therefore concluded that females require either a longer daily heat exposure ([@B36]), or a greater number of heat exposures ([@B35]) to elicit favorable physiological adaptations. It is unclear if females can achieve meaningful performance improvements following STHA or if a longer heat acclimation period is needed. [@B57] reported a 33% improvement in distance run during a repeated shuttle run performance test following STHA in a female cohort as well as a reduced rate of rise in rectal temperature (*T*~rec~). The authors attributed performance improvements to the high-intensity intermittent exercise performed during the acclimation sessions, a strategy implemented by [@B44] to successfully induce plasma volume expansion in a female cohort following 5-days high-intensity heat acclimation. Therefore, the addition of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) may offer a means to increase effectiveness of STHA in a female cohort. However, the performance test employed by Sunderland and colleagues was a time to exhaustion trial, which is a less reliable test and subject to greater variation than self-paced performance tests ([@B25]; [@B4]). Self-paced performance outcomes and their improvements following heat acclimation have only been documented in male ([@B15]; [@B29]; [@B48]; [@B23]; [@B60]) or mostly male ([@B34]) cohorts, and remain to be investigated in females. Such information is timely for female athletes competing at upcoming international competitions in hot climates, such as the 2020 Olympic Games in Tokyo and the 2019 IAAF World Athletics Championships in Doha. Currently, female athletes must either depend on conflicting literature or fill knowledge gaps with information inferred from male cohorts. Therefore, the aim of the present study was to investigate self-paced endurance performance in hot conditions following 4-days (STHA), and 9-days of a high-intensity isothermic heat acclimation protocol in a female cohort. It was hypothesized that females would not exhibit performance improvements in self-paced exercise following STHA, as previous studies indicate that 4-days of 90-min heat acclimation is unlikely to be a sufficient stimulus for the thermoregulatory and cardiovascular adaptations necessary for performance improvements in the heat. We further hypothesized that performance improvements in power output and time trial distance would occur following 9-days heat acclimation. Materials and Methods {#s1} ===================== General Overview and Design --------------------------- This study was approved by the University of Birmingham Ethics Committee, and conformed to the standards set by the Declaration of Helsinki 2013. All participants were informed of the experimental procedures and possible risks involved in the study before their written consent was obtained. Each participant completed a general exercise questionnaire and a menstrual cycle questionnaire (detailing the day their menstrual cycle commenced, premenstrual symptoms, and contraceptive medication or devices) to ascertain what phase of their cycle they were in for each time trial. All experimental procedures were completed in the environmental chamber (TIS Services, Hampshire, United Kingdom) in the School of Sport, Exercise and Rehabilitation Sciences building at the University of Birmingham. Participants performed all heat acclimation and testing sessions at the same time of day (±2 h), and at similar times to their normal training sessions so as not to disrupt their normal circadian rhythms ([@B51]). This included mornings, afternoons, or evenings. Participants were familiarized with the 15-min time trial performance tests in cool conditions (15°C, 30% RH) on three occasions, with the final occasion 48 h prior to beginning the protocol. Participants performed a 15-min cycling time trial in hot (35°C, 30% RH) conditions pre-acclimation, following 4-days (STHA), and following 9-days isothermic heat acclimation (HA). An overview of the hot time trials and HA sessions are displayed in [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. This experiment was conducted in the United Kingdom during the months of February, April, May, and June, when mean ambient temperatures were below 20°C (exclusive of 3 days where the mean daily temperatures were 23, 24, and 27°C, respectively). The protocol was performed in addition to normal training sessions (i.e., weight training and normal conditioning such as swimming and running). Participants' activity was not restricted, except on the day prior to (no exhaustive exercise) or the day of (no other activity) time trials in hot conditions (HTTs). Participants were asked to refrain from alcohol and overly strenuous exercise outside of the laboratory 48 h before time trials. ![Schematic diagram of the time trials and heat acclimation sessions (HA). Time trials were conducted in hot conditions \[HTT; 35°C, 30% relative humidity (RH)\], before HA (HTT1), after 4-days (HTT2) and after 9-days (HTT3) HA. On days 2--4 and 7--9, participants completed 15-min of high-intensity intervals (HIIT), where maximum effort was given for 15-s, with 45-s of active recovery. Participants then undertook 75-min of isothermic heat acclimation (where exercise intensity was manipulated to increase and maintain rectal temperature at ∼38.5°C; 40°C, 30%RH) with permissive dehydration. There was one rest day following 5-days HA. Cool Time Trial refers to a 15-min cycling time trial in cool conditions (15°C, 30% RH), which was part of a larger dataset that are not reported herein.](fphys-10-00539-g001){#F1} Participants ------------ Eight recreational endurance athletes aged 21--35 years volunteered for and completed this study. An additional participant volunteered, but dropped out due to relocation after preliminary testing and was not included in the results. All participants were familiar with competitive, race-style endurance events, and trained 5 ± 1 days per week, averaging 9 ± 4 h of weekly endurance exercise training. Participants were eumenorrheic or using various forms of hormonal contraceptives ([Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}) and did not report any negative premenstrual symptoms that may have affected performance during time trials ([@B19]). Participants had not previously undergone a heat acclimation protocol and had not been in hot conditions for the past 2 months. Participants also completed an incremental (20 W ⋅ min^−1^ stages) exercise test on a cycle ergometer (Sport Excalibur, Lode, Groningen, Netherlands) to determine maximal aerobic capacity (VO~2peak~), with expired air (Vyntus CPX, Jaeger, Wuerzberg, Germany) and HR (Polar Electro, Kempele, Finland) measured continuously. Personal characteristics are summarized in [Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}. ###### Participants' personal characteristics. Participant Age (years) Height (cm) VO~2peak~ (ml ^⋅^ kg^−1^ ⋅min^−1^) Body mass (kg) Menstrual cycle/contraceptive Day of menstrual cycle or pill taking phase on HTT1 ------------- ------------- ------------- ------------------------------------ ---------------- ------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------- 1 32 168 40 54 OCP (Cilest) 15 2 28 168 45 59 Implant N/A 3 25 176 43 65 Implant N/A 4 23 165 43 55 EU 23 5 35 173 42 69 EU 17 6 32 172 53 63 IUD Coil N/A 7 23 165 53 61 OCP (Yasmin) 11 8 21 174 54 61 Implant N/A *Mean* 27 170 47 61 OCP, oral contraceptive pill user (pill brand); IUD Coil, copper coil intrauterine device; EU, eumenorrheic natural cycle. Heat Acclimation Sessions ------------------------- A combination of HIIT, permissive dehydration and isothermic heat acclimation ([@B17]; [@B57]) was used to construct a "high intensity" HA protocol. Participants voided their bladder upon arrival to the laboratory to provide a urine sample. Towel-dried, nude body mass (NBM) was recorded to 0.1 kg using digital scales (Seca 877, Seca, Hamburg, Germany) before and immediately after each session to estimate sweat loss. Conditions during HA sessions were set to 40°C, 30%RH with a fan-generated airflow of ∼3 m second^−1^ facing participants. All heat acclimation sessions and time trials were completed using a cycle ergometer (Velotron, RacerMate Inc., Seattle, WA, United States), which was calibrated according to manufacturer instructions for the chosen temperature and confirmed to exhibit \<1% deviation from calibration settings before each use. Following a 5-min, self-selected warm-up, participants completed 15-min of high-intensity intervals, where participants were asked to give maximum effort for 15-s, with 45-s of active recovery. The aim of the high-intensity intervals was to rapidly increase *T*~rec~. This was followed by an additional 75-min of continuous cycling at an intensity manipulated with the aim to further increase *T*~rec~ and maintain it at ∼38.5°C ([@B40]; [@B15]), totalling 90-min HA plus 5-min warm up. On days that hot time trials (HTT) preceded HA sessions, the HTTs were used in place of the high-intensity intervals. On these test days, the temperature of the environmental chamber was immediately increased to 40°C, 30%RH following the time trial. There was one rest day following 5-days HA. Cool Time Trial refers to a 15-min cycling time trial in cool conditions (15°C, 30% RH), which was part of a larger dataset that are not reported herein. Power output, HR, and *T*~rec~ across HA sessions during STHA (days 1--4) and days 5--9 are depicted in [Figure 2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. Ratings of perceived exertion (RPE; [@B5]), thermal sensation, and thermal comfort were recorded at 15-min intervals during HA sessions. Participants were instructed to refrain from fluid consumption as much as could be tolerated during HA sessions to induce the added stressor of dehydration (permissive dehydration; [@B17]). Fluid consumed (295 ± 235 ml each session) was recorded by weighing water bottles to 0.001 L (Oertling, United Kingdom) before and after HA sessions, and was considered in the calculations of total body sweat loss. Heat acclimation involved 9 consecutive days of HA sessions, except for 1 day of rest following STHA ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). {#F2} Hot Time Trials --------------- Time trials were performed in hot conditions (35°C, 30%RH with a fan-generated airflow of ∼3 m ⋅ second^−1^ facing participants) on the 1st day of HA (Day 1; HTT1), and following 4-days HA (Day 5; HTT2), and 9-days HA (Day 10; HTT3). Participants were instructed to maintain normal hydration before each HTT, which was verified with a urine osmolality value of ≤700 mOsm ⋅ kg^−1^ ([@B52]). Participants lay supine for 10 min of stabilization at room temperature prior to each trial to collect resting measures of *T*~rec~ and blood lactate. Participants entered the environmental chamber and commenced a 5-min warm up at a self-selected pace, before completing a 15-min, self-paced cycling time trial. Power output and distance cycled were recorded continuously by the Velotron Coaching Software. Participants were aware of the time elapsed, as displayed by a stop-clock mounted to the handles of the cycle ergometer, however, they were blinded to any other physiological or performance feedback (i.e., HR, power output, distance cycled, etc.). Participants were given equal verbal encouragement by the same researchers at similar time points during the HTT. Free drinking was permitted during HTTs. RPE, blood lactate and sweat gland activity were recorded immediately following the HTTs. Ratings of thermal comfort and thermal sensation were reported inside the environmental chamber, preceding the warm-up for HTTs, as well as immediately after. Following HTTs, participants completed 5 min of self-paced active recovery before proceeding with the acclimation session for that day. Measures -------- Urine osmolality was measured prior to each experimental session to assess hydration (Osmocheck, Vitech Scientific Ltd., West Sussex, United Kingdom). *T*~rec~ was measured using a rectal thermistor inserted 10 cm past the anal sphincter prior to beginning each experimental session (Mon-a-Therm, Covidien, Mansfield, MA, United States). Weighted mean skin temperature (*T*~sk~) was recorded using skin thermistors (Squirrel Thermal Couples, Grant Instruments, Cambridge, United Kingdom) attached to four sites: the mid-point of the right pectoralis major (*T*~chest~), midpoint of the right biceps brachii (*T*~arm~), right rectus femoris (*T*~thigh~), and right gastrocnemius lateral head (*T*~lowerleg~). Skin and rectal thermistors were connected to a Squirrel Data Logger (Squirrel 2020 series, Eltek, Ltd., United Kingdom) and were recorded at 30-s intervals throughout HA sessions and HTTs. HR (Polar Electro, Kempele, Finland) was also recorded throughout each session. Power output and distance cycled were recorded by the Velotron Coaching Software (Velotron CS 2008, RacerMate Inc., Seattle, WA, United States). Blood lactate measures were taken from a finger-tip blood sample and immediately analyzed using a Lactate Plus analyzer (Lactate Plus, Nova Biomedical, Waltham, MA, United States). Active sweat glands were quantified using a modified-iodine paper technique with computer aided analysis ([@B14]). Samples were collected from the dorsal side of the thickest segment of the forearm. Thermal sensation and thermal comfort ratings were measured using 13-point and 10-point scales, respectively, which were modified from scales used by [@B13]. Data Analysis ------------- Mean *T*~rec~ for the final 75 min of the session, which followed the 15-min high-intensity intervals, is represented by *T*~rec75~. Maximum *T*~rec~ recorded during the session (Max *T*~rec~) was used to calculate *T*~rec~ increase from rest (Δ*T*~rec~). *T*~sk~ was calculated as a weighted average according to [@B49]: T sk = 0.3 ⋅ ( T chest \+ T arm ) \+ 0.2 ⋅ ( T thigh \+ T lower leg ) Estimated sweat rate relative to body surface area (SR~BSA~) was calculated from changes in NBM pre- to post-session with considerations of water consumed body surface area \[(BSA); calculated using the formula derived by [@B11]\] and normalized for exercise time: Estimated sweat loss ( g ) = ( pre-trial NBM − post-trial NBM ) \+ ( water bottle pre-trial − water bottle post-trial ) BSA ( m 2 ) = 0.007184 ⋅ ( height 0.725 ⋅ body mass 0.425 ) SR BSA ( g ⋅ h − 1 ⋅ m − 2 ) = ( estimated sweat loss ) ⋅ ( 1 h ⋅ exercise time − 1 ) − 1 . ( BSA ) − 1 Two values were obtained for measurements of resting blood lactate and an additional two values were obtained for blood lactate immediately following HTTs. The results were averaged to yield a single value for each time point (pre- and post-trial). Extreme outliers falling outside the physiological range were excluded, and only the rational value was used ([@B21]; *n* = 3 incidences). Power output (watts) was recorded each second during HTTs, and an average of each minute's power output was used to calculate area under the curve (AUC; [@B46]). AUC was also calculated for *T*~rec~ (recorded at 30-s intervals) during HTTs. All data were analyzed using SPSS statistical software (SPSS version 24.0.0, SPSS, Chicago, IL, United States). To assess performance and physiological differences during HA days 1--4 vs. days 5--9, a mean value was calculated for each participant across the aforementioned days, and analyzed using a repeated-measures one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). Mean performance values during HTTs (i.e., power output and speed), AUC comparisons (power output and *T*~rec~), distance cycled, and physiological measures between HTT1, HTT2, and HTT3, were also analyzed using a repeated-measures one-way ANOVA. Additionally, 1 min averages of power output were analyzed using a two-way repeated-measures ANOVA (3 HTT × 15 time points). Normality of the data was assessed using Mauchly's test of sphericity, and Greenhouse--Geisser corrections were applied where assumptions of sphericity were violated. When a significant main effect was found, Bonferroni-corrected *post hoc* comparisons were made. Main effect sizes for both one-way and two-way ANOVAs were calculated using partial eta-squared ($\eta_{p}^{2}$), with $\eta_{p}^{2}$ \> 0.06 representing a moderate difference and $\eta_{p}^{2}$ \> 0.14 representing a large difference ([@B9]). To assess ordinal data (i.e., RPE, thermal sensation and thermal comfort) differences during HA days 1--4 vs. days 5--9, and between HTT1, HTT2, and HTT3, Friedman's test was performed with *post hoc* analysis by Wilcoxon sign-rank tests. Absolute data are expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD) and mean within-subject differences are presented with 95% confidence limits (mean difference, 95% CL: lower limit, upper limit). Significance was set at *p* \< 0.05 for each analysis. A power analysis indicated that eight participants were a sufficient sample size to detect an 8--10% difference in power output during time trial performance (as observed by [@B34]; [@B29]). This analysis used an accepted parameter of power (β ≥ 0.80) at an α level of 0.05. Results ======= Heat Acclimation Sessions ------------------------- Mean *T*~rec75~ (−0.2°C, \[−0.1, −0.3\]; *p* \< 0.01) peak *T*~rec~ (−0.1°C, \[−0.1, −0.2\]; *p* = 0.01), and peak *T*~sk~ (−0.4°C, \[−0.1, −0.7\]; *p* = 0.01) were lower during HA sessions on days 5--9 as compared to HA sessions on days 1--4. Mean HR and percentage of age-estimated maximum heart rate (%HR~max~) (−5 beats ⋅ minute^−1^, \[−1, −10\]; *p* = 0.03, and −3% \[−1, −5\]; *p* = 0.02, respectively) were also lower during HA sessions on days 5--9 as compared to HA sessions on days 1--4. These physiological changes were present in spite of a significantly higher workload (i.e., power output) on days 5--9 as compared to HA sessions on days 1--4 (−9 W, \[−3, −14\], *p* = 0.01). Participants' mean RPE, thermal sensation, and thermal comfort ratings across all HA sessions were not different (*p* \> 0.05) and equalled 15 ± 2 ("Hard"), 10 ± 1 ("Hot"), and 5 ± 2 ("Uncomfortable"), respectively. There were no changes in Δ*T*~rec~ or sweat loss (*p* \> 0.05). Results of HA sessions are summarized in [Table 2](#T2){ref-type="table"}. ###### Performance, physiological, and psycho-physical responses during heat acclimation sessions averaged across Days 1--4 and Days 5--9. Days 1--4 Days 5--9 ------------------------------ ------------ --------------- Mean power output (W) 108 ± 17 117 ± 21^∗^ Mean *T*~rec75~ (°C) 38.4 ± 0.2 38.2 ± 0.2^∗^ Resting *T*~rec~ (°C) 37.3 ± 0.4 37.2 ± 0.2 Peak *T*~rec~ (°C) 38.6 ± 0.2 38.5 ± 0.2^∗^ Δ*T*~rec~ (°C) 1.4 ± 0.4 1.2 ± 0.3 Peak *T*~sk~ (°C) 35.5 ± 0.9 35.0 ± 1.0^∗^ Mean HR (beats ⋅ minute^−1^) 150 ± 6 145 ± 6^∗^ Mean %HR~max~ (%) 78 ± 3 75 ± 4^∗^ SR~BSA~ (g ⋅ h^−1^ ⋅ m^−2^) 694 ± 105 705 ± 143 Sweat loss (%BM) 2.9 ± 0.5 2.9 ± 0.6 Data are presented as mean ± SD. T rec , rectal temperature; T rec75 , mean rectal temperatures recorded during the final 75-min of the session; ΔT rec , maximal change in rectal temperature during exercise from rest; HR, heart rate; %HR max , percentage of age-estimated maximum heart rate; SR BSA , estimated sweat rate relative to body surface area; %BM, percentage of body mass. ∗ Significantly different from Days 1--4 (p \< 0.05). Hot Time Trials --------------- There was a large ($\eta_{p}^{2}$ = 0.55) and significant (*p* \< 0.01) main effect of acclimation on distance cycled during time trials in hot conditions ([Figure 3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}). *Post hoc* analysis indicated that distance increased by 3.2% (+240 m, \[+70, +420\]; *p* = 0.01) from HTT1 to HTT3, and by 1.8% (+140 m, \[+10, +270\]; *p* = 0.04) from HTT2 to HTT3 ([Table 3](#T3){ref-type="table"}). There was no difference in distance cycled from HTT1 to HTT2 (+100 m, \[−100, +300\]; *p* = 0.47). {#F3} ###### Performance measures during time trials in the heat (35°C, 30% RH). HTT1 HTT2 HTT3 ------------------------- ------------- ------------- ----------------- Distance (km) 7.96 ± 0.58 8.06 ± 0.55 8.20 ± 0.59^∗†^ Mean power (W) 180 ± 34 185 ± 32 195 ± 36^∗†^ Mean speed (km ⋅ h^−1^) 31.9 ± 2.3 32.3 ± 2.2 32.8 ± 2.4^∗†^ Data are presented as mean ± SD. HTT1, time trial pre-acclimation; HTT2, time trial following 4-days heat acclimation; HTT3, time trial following 9-days heat acclimation. ∗ Significant increase from HTT1; † Significant increase from HTT2, (p \< 0.05). These results were matched by the comparison of minute averages of power output. A two-way ANOVA yielded a large ($\eta_{p}^{2}$ = 0.59) and significant main effect of acclimation (*p* \< 0.01), but no significant time--condition interaction (*p* = 0.20; [Figure 4](#F4){ref-type="fig"}). *Post hoc* analysis of condition indicated that mean power output across 15-min increased by 8.1% (+14 W, \[+4, +24\]; *p* = 0.01) from HTT1 to HTT3, and by 4.8% (+9 W, \[0, +18\]; *p* = 0.05) from HTT2 to HTT3 ([Table 3](#T3){ref-type="table"}). There was no difference in mean power output from HTT1 to HTT2 (+5 W, \[−6, +16\]; *p* = 0.55). Additionally, AUC calculated from minute averages of power output yielded a large ($\eta_{p}^{2}$ = 0.58) and significant (*p* \< 0.01) main effect of acclimation. *Post hoc* comparisons revealed that power output AUC during HTT3 was greater than in HTT1 (+7.6%, \[+2.1, +12.8\]; *p* = 0.01) and showed a trend toward increases from HTT2 (+4.4%, \[−0.4, +7.7\]; *p* = 0.07). Power output AUC was not different between HTT1 and HTT2 (+3.2%, \[−3.0, +7.0\]; *p* = 0.53). {#F4} There was a large ($\eta_{p}^{2}$ = 0.57) and significant (*p* \< 0.01) main effect of acclimation on mean cycling speed during time trials in hot conditions. *Post hoc* analysis indicated that mean cycling speed increased by 3.0% (+0.9 km ^⋅^ h^−1^, \[+0.2, +1.7\]; *p* = 0.01) from HTT1 to HTT3, and by 1.6% (+0.5 km ^⋅^ h^−1^, \[0, +1.1\]; *p* = 0.05) from HTT2 to HTT3 ([Table 3](#T3){ref-type="table"}). There was no difference in distance cycled from HTT1 to HTT2 (+0.4 km ^⋅^ h^−1^, \[−0.4, +1.2\]; *p* = 0.44). Mean (*p* = 0.63), peak (*p* = 0.97), and change (*p* = 0.46) in *T*~rec~ during the HTTs were not affected by HA ([Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). A two-way ANOVA showed no significant main effect of condition (*p* = 0.36) or condition-time interaction (*p* = 0.65) for *T*~rec~ measured each minute of HTTs ([Figure 5](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). There was an average reduction in *T*~rec~ at rest, although this was not significant (*p* = 0.07; [Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). AUC for *T*~rec~ during HTTs (calculated from minute averages) was not significantly different between HTTs (*p* = 0.39). Mean (*p* = 0.26) and peak (*p* = 0.13) skin temperatures (*T*~sk~) during HTTs were not affected by HA ([Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"} and [Figure 5](#F5){ref-type="fig"}). Mean HR (*p* = 0.48; [Figure 5](#F5){ref-type="fig"}) and mean (*p* = 0.45) and peak (*p* = 0.38) percentage of age-estimated HR maximum (%HR~max~) during HTTs was not different between HTTs ([Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). ###### Physiological and psychophysical measures recorded during time trials in hot conditions. HTT1 HTT2 HTT3 ---------------------------------------- ------------ ------------ ------------ **Thermoregulatory** Resting *T*~rec~ (°C) 37.2 ± 0.4 37.2 ± 0.3 37.0 ± 0.4 Mean *T*~rec~ (°C) 37.7 ± 0.2 37.7 ± 0.3 37.6 ± 0.3 Peak *T*~rec~ (°C) 38.1 ± 0.3 38.1 ± 0.3 38.1 ± 0.4 Δ*T*~rec~ (°C) 0.9 ± 0.5 0.9 ± 0.3 1.0 ± 0.6 Mean *T*~sk~ (°C) 34.6 ± 0.6 34.1 ± 0.7 34.5 ± 0.9 Peak *T*~sk~ (°C) 35.0 ± 0.5 34.5 ± 0.5 35.0 ± 0.5 **Cardiovascular** Mean HR (beats ⋅ minute^−1^) 168 ± 14 165 ± 9 168 ± 12 Mean %HR~max~ (%) 87 ± 7 86 ± 4 87 ± 6 Peak %HR~max~ (%) 94 ± 5 93 ± 5 95 ± 4 **Sudomotor response** Active sweat glands per cm^2^ 58 ± 23 63 ± 24 75 ± 25^†^ **Blood lactate** Pre-test (mmol ⋅ L^−1^) 1.2 ± 0.7 1.0 ± 0.4 1.0 ± 0.5 Post-test (mmol ⋅ L^−1^) 11.1 ± 4.1 11.3 ± 1.7 12.8 ± 2.7 **Thermal comfort (10-point scale)** Pre-test 3 ± 2 3 ± 1 2 ± 1 Post-test 5 ± 1 5 ± 2 5 ± 2 **Thermal sensation (13-point scale)** Pre-test 9 ± 1 9 ± 1 8 ± 0^∗^ Post-test 10 ± 1 10 ± 1 10 ± 1 Data are presented as mean ± SD. HTT1, pre-acclimation time trial; HTT2, time trial following 4-days heat acclimation; HTT3, time trial following 9-days heat acclimation. T rec , rectal temperature; ΔT rec , change in rectal temperature during time trial; T sk , weighted mean skin temperature; HR, heart rate; %HR max , percentage of age-estimated maximum heart rate. ∗ Significant difference from HTT1, † significant difference from HTT2, (p \< 0.05). {#F5} There was a significant change in number of active sweat glands immediately following HTTs (main effect: *p* = 0.01, $\eta_{p}^{2}$ = 0.64). *Post hoc* analysis indicated that number of active sweat glands increased by 33% (+17 active sweat glands per cm^2^, \[+3, +30\]; *p* = 0.02) from HTT1 to HTT3, and by 22% (+12 active sweat glands per cm^2^, \[+6, +17\]; *p* \< 0.01) from HTT2 to HTT3 ([Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). There was no difference in number of active sweat glands from HTT1 to HTT2 (+5 active sweat glands per cm^2^, \[−7, +17\]; *p* = 0.62). An example of sweat gland activity recorded following HTTs is depicted in [Figure 6](#F6){ref-type="fig"}. ![Example of sweat gland activity measured immediately following time trials **(A)** pre-acclimation (HTT1), **(B)** following 4-days heat acclimation (HTT2), and **(C)** following 9-days heat acclimation (HTT3). Bottom row images are scanned copies of iodine-cotton paper applied to participant's forearm. Top row of images are the same images following computer processing (ImageJ; [@B14]).](fphys-10-00539-g006){#F6} There was no significant difference in SR~BSA~ during HTTs and including the 75 min of HA that followed (main effect: *p* = 0.08). There were no differences in blood lactate at rest (immediately preceding HTTs; *p* = 0.34) or immediately following HTTs (*p* = 0.41; [Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). Ratings of thermal sensation taken in the environmental chamber immediately before exercise were significantly different between the HTTs (main effect: *p* = 0.02; [Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}), and on average, corresponded to "Warm" (HTT1), "Warm" (HTT2) and "Slightly Warm" (HTT3). *Post hoc* pairwise comparisons indicated that differences were between HTT1 and HTT3 (*p* = 0.03). There were no significant differences between HTT1 and HTT2 (*p* = 0.10) or between HTT2 and HTT3 (*p* = 0.08). Ratings of thermal comfort taken in the environmental chamber immediately before exercise were not significantly different between HTTs (average ratings corresponded to ratings between "Comfortable" and "Slightly Uncomfortable"; *p* = 0.39; [Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). Ratings of thermal sensation and thermal comfort taken at the end of HTTs were not significantly different between HTTs ("Hot" \[*p* = 0.25\] and "Uncomfortable" \[*p* = 0.53\], respectively; [Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). Discussion ========== This study was designed to determine whether STHA (4-days) is sufficient to improve self-paced endurance performance in hot conditions in females, as has been observed in males, or whether a longer heat acclimation stimulus (i.e., 9-days) is required. In this study's female cohort, STHA did not significantly improve time-trial performance in the heat; however, 9-days HA did. These results were consistent with the study hypothesis, which predicted that STHA would be insufficient to improve self-paced performance in females, and that a longer heat acclimation stimulus would be required to induce the physiological adaptations needed for performance improvements in the heat. Self-Paced Endurance Performance -------------------------------- Following STHA, female participants showed no significant performance improvements in distance cycled, mean power output, or speed during HTT2, as compared to HTT1. This is in direct contrast to a number of studies in male cohorts, where males have shown meaningful physiological adaptions *and* improved endurance performance in the heat following STHA ([@B16], [@B15]; [@B7]; [@B48]; [@B23]; [@B28]; [@B59]; [@B60]). Thus, it appears that STHA using 90 min of daily exercise heat stress is insufficient to improve endurance performance in females, reflecting the lack of physiological adaptation to heat acclimation previously demonstrated in females following STHA ([@B35]). The current study's performance results following STHA differ from those observed by [@B57], who reported a 33% improvement in distance run during a repeated shuttle run performance test (Loughborough Intermittent Shuttle Test) following STHA (4-days) in a female cohort. Of note, time to exhaustion is the main outcome measure of the Loughborough Intermittent Shuttle Test. This outcome is influenced by technique (i.e., ability to change direction and accelerate; [@B37]), making it less reliable and subject to greater variation than the self-paced performance trial used in the current study ([@B24]; [@B22]; [@B4]). Furthermore, the behavioral regulation of performance possible in a self-paced time trial is not available in a time to exhaustion protocol ([@B54]). Indeed, the lower pre-exercise thermal sensation reported by participants after 9-days HA may be an indication of perceptual changes contributing to behavioral regulation (i.e., pacing). Thus, the self-paced performance test used in the current study is a more reliable and holistic assessment of performance than a time to exhaustion test. Despite efforts in the current study to create an "intense" heat stimulus by combining isothermic heat acclimation, HIIT, and permissive dehydration, it still appears that females require either a longer daily heat exposure ([@B36]), or a greater number of heat exposures (as observed in the current study and by [@B35]) to improve exercise performance in the heat. This is the first study to quantify improvements in self-paced time trial performance following a longer (i.e., 9-days) heat acclimation stimulus in a female cohort. The ∼8% mean improvement in mean power output in HTT3 as compared to HTT1 is comparable to performance improvements observed in male, or mostly male cohorts following similar heat acclimation protocols. [@B29] showed that male participants experienced a ∼10% improvement in power output during a 30-min self-paced time trial following 10-days heat acclimation (daily bouts: 90-min cycling at 50% VO~2max~ in 38°C, 30%RH). [@B34] also found that participants (10 males and 2 females) had an 8% mean improvement in power output during their 1-h self-paced time trial following 10-days heat acclimation (daily bouts: 90-min cycling at 50% VO~2max~ in 40°C, 30%RH). In the current study, improvements in mean power output coincided with improvements in mean cycling speed and distance covered from HTT1 to HTT3. These data demonstrate that 9-, but not 4-days heat acclimation, improves endurance performance outcomes in females. Physiological Measures ---------------------- Participants exhibited reduced markers of physiological strain (i.e., *T*~rec~, *T*~sk~ and HR) during days 5--9 of HA, as compared to days 1--4. These physiological changes occurred in spite of an increased mean power output during days 5--9 of HA. Although these data indicate a reduction in the desired stimulus across the heat acclimation protocol, it also indicates that the greatest heat stimulus was administered during STHA. Furthermore, the improved performance in HTT3 as compared to the previous HTTs indicates that this reduced stimulus during days 5--9 was still effective in producing HA-related performance improvements. Also, this HA protocol produced a sufficient dehydration stimulus, as the ∼3% body mass loss achieved across HA days 1--4 and 5--9 in addition to permissive dehydration presumably exceeded the osmotic threshold required for compensatory fluid regulatory responses (i.e., 2% body mass loss; [@B8]). However, as we did not measure changes in plasma volume, it is unknown whether participants experienced the fluid regulatory responses typically associated with heat acclimation. There was a trend for a lower *T*~rec~ at rest before HTT3, which appeared to influence *T*~rec~ during the initial minutes of HTT3 (albeit not significantly). Menstrual cycle phase and associated changes in female sex hormones influence resting *T*~rec~ ([@B27]) and the overall thermoregulatory set point range ([@B6]). This may have contributed to the non-significant change in resting *T*~rec~ observed in the current study. By the end of each HTT, *T*~rec~ reached similar values (∼38.1°C). This is perhaps unsurprising as a previous study has shown that heat acclimation does not change the maximal *T*~rec~ reached (40.1--40.2°C) during a 43.4-km time trial in the heat, despite a lower *T*~rec~ for the first 80% of the post-acclimation time trial ([@B48]). In the current study, there was an observed increase of active sweat glands at the end of HTT3 ([Table 4](#T4){ref-type="table"}). This contrasts findings in male cohorts, where sweat gland activation did not increase following 8--10-days heat acclimation ([@B26]; [@B31]; [@B45]). In the current study, the number of active sweat glands (75 ± 25 per cm^2^) at the end of HTT3 were lower than values previously reported in acclimated males (∼96--108 per cm^2^; [@B26]; [@B31]; [@B45]) and unacclimated females (∼93 per cm^2^; [@B30]). Therefore, changes observed following a 15-min HTT may not indicate improved maximal sweat gland activation *per se*, but rather earlier activation of the sweat glands. Although there is large intra-subject coefficient variation associated with this measure, the 33 and 22% mean improvements following HTT3 in comparison to HTT1 and HTT2, respectively, surpass the ∼11% coefficient of variation reported by [@B14]. Perspectives ------------ These results contribute to the limited research that informs the expected performance outcomes of heat acclimation for female athletes. The results of this study indicate that while heat acclimation can be an effective training component in preparation for competition in the heat, female athletes may require up to 9 days of 90-min heat acclimation sessions before experiencing performance improvements. However, there will be individual variation in how athletes (male or female) respond to heat acclimation ([@B47]). In the current study, three participants' performance deteriorated in HTT2 as compared to HTT1, whereas four participants showed improvements and one participant showed no change. Thus, some female athletes may achieve meaningful performance benefits after 4-days heat acclimation, while others could require longer than 9-days. A heat acclimation protocol lasting longer than 9-days has yet to be initiated in a female cohort, which would be hypothesized to further stabilize adaptions and improve performance ([@B48]). It is also unclear how different phases of the menstrual cycle/contraception may affect heat adaption during acclimation. Future research is also needed to clarify the impact of mixed-intensity heat acclimation on longer performance tests in both male and female athletes. Considerations -------------- Despite the absence of a control group, it is unlikely that performance improvements in HTT3 were due to learning or training effects. After preliminary testing and familiarizations, HTT1 was the fourth time that participants would have completed the 15-min time trial, minimizing learning effects. Furthermore, performance improvements in the current study are similar to previous studies ([@B34]; [@B29]), where control groups showed no improvements. It is possible that the high-intensity heat acclimation protocol used in the current study may have caused a general fatigue that impaired performance during HTT2 and HTT3 ([@B55]; [@B50]). However, this is a negative bias as fatigue-related performance impacts would presumably have been greatest at HTT3. A further consideration is that heat acclimation adaptions are specific to the type/intensity of exercise employed ([@B60]). Therefore, the 15-min of HIIT undertaken at the beginning of each HA session may have facilitated specific adaptations. Whether this type of mixed-intensity heat acclimation (15-min HIIT + 75-min isothermic HA) would be equally or more effective than steady-state isothermic heat acclimation protocols typically reported in the literature remains unknown. This study did not control for menstrual cycle. Recent data has shown that performance under heat stress is not affected by menstrual cycle or oral contraceptive pill (OCP) use in trained female athletes ([@B33], [@B32]), nor does menstrual cycle affect whole-body heat loss ([@B38]). Eumenorrheic participants and OCP users did not cross over phases between HTT1 and HTT2. Participants were counterbalanced in their phases in HTT3, with both eumenorrheic participants being in opposite phases and both OCP users being in opposite phases (i.e., pill-taking, or non-pill-taking). None of the other four participants \[contraceptive implant or copper intrauterine device (IUD)\] were menstruating during the protocol, mitigating concerns of premenstrual symptoms that could affect performance ([@B19]). Despite this, variable hormonal states may have affected the degree of relative heat stimulus administered when targeting an absolute core temperature of 38.5°C during heat acclimation sessions. Finally, it should be noted that measures of sweat gland activity were taken from sites on the forearm and are not a precise indication of whole-body sweat gland adaptations given the regional heterogeneity of sweat gland activity. While an increased sweat gland activity may imply a better use of body surface area to dissipate heat, sweat gland activation is not directly proportional to local sweat output of the area ([@B45]). In future, measures of local sweat output should be combined with measures of sweat gland activation to fully understand sex differences in peripheral sudomotor adaptations. Conclusion ========== This study was the first to document performance outcomes during self-paced time trials in a female cohort following STHA (4-days) and 9-days high-intensity, isothermic HA. In the current study, females did not show an improvement in self-paced endurance performance following STHA. This differs from the well-documented performance improvements previously observed in male cohorts following STHA. However, following 9-days HA, females achieved meaningful improvements in self-paced endurance performance. These improvements included an ∼8% increase in mean power output, a ∼3% increase in distance cycled, and a ∼3% increase in speed when performing a 15-min self-paced time trial in hot conditions (HTT). These data offer a reference for the changes which female athletes can expect when undergoing heat acclimation with the aim of improving self-paced endurance exercise performance in hot conditions, and provides further evidence that STHA may be insufficient for female athletes. Ethics Statement ================ This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of the University of Birmingham Ethics Committee with written informed consent from all subjects. Author Contributions ==================== NK, SL, and RL contributed to the conception and design of the study, acquisition, analysis, and interpretation of the data, drafted, revised, and approved the final version of the manuscript. Conflict of Interest Statement ============================== The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest. **Funding.** The study was funded by the University of Birmingham. The authors would like to thank all the participants for their time and effort in the completion of this study. %HR~max~ : percentage of age-estimated maximum heart rate $\eta_{p}^{2}$ : partial eta-squared AUC : area under the curve BSA : body surface area HA : heat acclimation sessions HIIT : high-intensity interval training HR : heart rate HTT : time trial in hot conditions IUD : intrauterine device NBM : nude body mass OCP : oral contraceptive pill SR~BSA~ : estimated sweat rate relative to body surface area STHA : short-term heat acclimation Sweat Loss~%BM~ : estimated sweat loss as a percentage of body mass *T*~rec~ : rectal temperature *T*~sk~ : weighted mean skin temperature VO~2peak~ : maximal aerobic capacity W : watts. [^1]: Edited by: Toby Mündel, Massey University, New Zealand [^2]: Reviewed by: Sean R. Notley, University of Ottawa, Canada; Jessica Anne Mee, Bangor University, United Kingdom; Daniel Gagnon, Université de Montréal, Canada [^3]: This article was submitted to Exercise Physiology, a section of the journal Frontiers in Physiology

\section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} \input{intro.tex} \section{Partially composite light quark partners}\label{sec:model} \input{model.tex} \section{Searching for light quark partners at the LHC Run II}\label{sec:results} \input{results.tex} \section{Conclusions}\label{sec:conclusions} \input{conclusions.tex} \bigskip \emph{Acknowledgements:} \\ The authors would like to thank the Weizmann theory group for the hospitality during the initial stages of this project. SL acknowledges the Galileo Galilei Institute for Theoretical Physics in Florence, Italy, where part of this work was completed. This work was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea(NRF) grant funded by the Korea government(MEST) (No. 2012R1A2A2A01045722), and Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea(NRF) funded by the ministry of Education, Science and Technology (No. 2013R1A1A1062597). This work is also supported by HTCaaS group of KISTI (Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information). SL and TF are also supported by Korea-ERC researcher visiting program through the National Research Foundation of Korea(NRF) (No. 2014K2a7B044399 and No. 2014K2a7A1044408). JH is supported by the IBS Center for Theoretical Physics of the Universe. \bigskip \subsection{Data Generation and Pre-Selection Cuts} \label{sec:Basic} \begin{figure}[t] \begin{center} \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{Signal_Diagram.pdf} \end{center} \caption{The pair production channel of the $U_h$ up quark partners. Note that for $M_{U_h} \sim 1 $ TeV, the Higgs bosons are boosted, resulting in a 2 ``fat jet'' - 2 light jet event topology. } \label{fig:channels} \end{figure} We generate all events using leading order \verb|MadGraph 5| \cite{Maltoni:2002qb} at a $\sqrt{s} = 14$ TeV $pp$ collider, assuming a CTEQ6L \cite{Nadolsky:2008zw} set of parton distribution functions. At the hard process level, we require that all final state partons pass cuts of $p_T > 15$~GeV,~$| \eta |< 5$. Next, we shower the events with \verb|PYTHIA 6| \cite{Sjostrand:2006za} using the MLM-matching scheme \cite{Artoisenet:2010cn} with \verb|xqcut|~$> 20$~GeV and \verb|qcut|~$> 30$~GeV. We match the multi-jet events up to four jets, while the $t\bar{t}$ and $b\bar{b}$ samples are matched up to two extra jets. We cluster all showered events with the \verb|fastjet| \cite{Cacciari:2011ma} implementation of the anti-$k_T$ algorithm \cite{Cacciari:2008gp}. In order to perform the analysis with a manageable number of events in the background channels ($i.e. \, \sim 10^6 $), we impose a generator level cut on $H_T$, a scalar sum of all final state parton transverse momenta. The motivation for the generator level $H_T$ cut comes from the fact that pair produced light quark partner events contain two objects of mass $\sim 1 $ TeV, implying that the signal will be characterized by $H_T$ of roughly 2 TeV. In order to avoid possible biases on the background data by increasing the $H_T$ cut too much, we hence require $ H_T > 1.6$ TeV on all generated backgrounds. We summarize the cross sections for the signal parameter point of $M_{Uh} = 1 {\rm\ TeV}$ and the most dominant backgrounds in Table~\ref{tab:HT1600}. For completeness, we show the $U_h$ pair production cross section as function of $M_{Uh}$ in Fig.\ref{fig:Partonic2}, where we assume ${\rm Br}(U_h \rightarrow hu) = 1$ and the branching ratio of Higgs to a pair of $b$ quarks is included. Notice that the total production cross section for partner masses above 1.3 TeV goes into the sub-femtobarn region which will be challenging to probe at the Run II of the LHC with $35 {\rm\ fb}^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity. A closer look at the numerical values of the signal and background cross sections suggests that a total improvement in $S/B$ of $\mathcal{O} (10^5)$ is desired to reach $S/B \sim 1$. For that purpose, we will introduce a new cut scheme in Section~\ref{sec:cutflow}, which exploits the characteristic topology and kinematic features of the signal events. \begin{figure}[t] \includegraphics[scale=0.5]{Xsection_MUh.pdf} \includegraphics[scale=0.5]{SigmaRatio_HTcut3_New.pdf} \caption{Left: The cross section of the signal events as a function of $M_{U_h}$ with the basic pre-selection cuts, $p_T > 15$~GeV, $|\eta| < 5$ and $H_T > 0$ GeV. \newline Right: Signal and background cross sections as a function of $H_T$ cut. The plot is normalized to NLO as in Table \ref{tab:HT1600}.} \label{fig:Partonic2} \end{figure} \vspace{1cm} \begin{table}[h] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|} \hline $\sigma^{\rm LO}_{s}$ [pb] & $\sigma^{\rm NLO}_{t\bar{t}}$ [pb] & $\sigma^{\rm NLO}_{b\bar{b}}$ [pb] & $\sigma^{\rm NLO}_{\mathrm{multi-jet}}$ [pb] \\ \hline $6.8 \times 10^{-3}$ & $4.6 \times 10^{-1}$ & 8.4 & 282.2 \\ \hline \end{tabular}\par \end{center} \caption{Cross sections for the $U_h \bar{U}_h$ pair production (assuming $M_{U_h} = 1 {\rm\ TeV}$) and backgrounds (assuming $H_T > 1600$ GeV), at 14 TeV LHC. We normalize the `` $t \bar{t}$ +0,1,2 jets " to the NNLO + NNLL result of Ref. \cite{Czakon:2013goa}, while for the rest of the backgrounds we use a conservative estimate for the NLO K-factor of 2.0.} \label{tab:HT1600} \end{table} \subsection{Tagging of Boosted Higgs Jets} \label{sec:TOM} The decay products of a boosted Higgs are collimated into a cone of $R \sim 2m_h / p_T$, where $p_T$ is the transverse momentum of the Higgs boson. Since we consider light quark partners of mass $\sim 1 {\rm\ TeV}$, the resulting Higgs bosons will have $p_T \sim 500$ GeV, and hence will decay into a cone of roughly $R \sim 0.5$. Clustering the decay products of a boosted Higgs into a large cone ($e.g. \, R=0.7$), will typically result in a single ``fat jet'' of mass $\sim m_h$. However, traditional jet observables such as jet $p_T$ and $m$ are inadequate to efficiently distinguish between Higgs, top and QCD ``fat jets'', and a further consideration of Higgs ``jet substructure,'' is needed to reduce the enormous QCD backgrounds. Many methods designed to tag the characteristic ``two prong'' substructure of the hadronically decaying Higgs exist in the literature \cite{Butterworth:2008iy, Almeida:2011aa, Backovic:2012jj, Schlaffer:2014osa, Soper:2011cr}. Here we will use the \verb| TemplateTagger v.1.0 |\cite{Backovic:2012jk} implementation of the Template Overlap Method \cite{Almeida:2010pa, Almeida:2011aa, Backovic:2012jj, Backovic:2013bga}. The Template Overlap algorithm for boosted jet tagging attempts to match a parton level model (template) for a boosted jet decay ($i.e.$ the $b \bar{b}$ system with the constraint of $( p_1 + p_2 )^2= m_h^2 $ ) to the energy distribution of a boosted jet. The procedure is performed by minimizing the difference between the calorimeter energy depositions within small angular regions around the template patrons and the parton energies, over the allowed phase space of the template four-momenta. Refs. \cite{Almeida:2010pa, Almeida:2011aa, Backovic:2012jj} studied the use of TOM to tag boosted Higgs decays in the context of the Standard Model. To our knowledge, our current effort is the first attempt to utilize TOM for boosted Higgs studies in a BSM scenario. An attractive feature of TOM is a relatively weak susceptibility to pileup contamination \cite{Backovic:2013bga}. The overlap analysis is affected only by the calorimeter depositions which land in angular regions of typically $ r \sim 0.1$ from the template patrons. The rest of the jet energy distribution does not contribute to the estimates of the likelihood that a particular template matches the jet energy distribution. As pileup contamination scales as $R^2$, where $R$ is the jet cone, the effects of pileup on the TOM analysis will be of order few percent, compared to (say) the $p_T$ of a typical fat jet of $R \sim 1.0.$ Ideally, in order to maximize the information extracted from jet substructure, one would perform TOM analysis for all heavy standard model decays on each candidate fat jet. Such analysis would result in a vector of overlap scores \begin{equation} \overrightarrow{Ov} = (Ov_2^i; Ov_3^i)\,, \end{equation} where $i = W, Z, h, t$. Various correlations within the multi-dimensional overlap space could then be exploited to fully maximize the ability of TOM to tag the desired heavy particles. The full multi-dimensional TOM analysis is beyond the scope of our current effort and we find it sufficient to use only a combination of two body Higgs as well as three body top template analysis (in order to further suppress the large $t\bar{t}$ background) \footnote{Note that the addition of a three body (NLO) Higgs template analysis could further suppress the multi-jet and $b\bar{b}$ backgrounds, but would not significantly help in suppression of the $t\bar{t}$ background \cite{Backovic:2012jj}.}. As the three prong decay of a boosted top is more complex of an object than the typical two prong decay of a boosted Higgs, it is possible for a top fat jet to pass the two-body Higgs template tagging procedure. On the other hand, it is difficult for a Higgs to appear as a fake top \cite{Backovic:2012jj}. We hence require all Higgs candidate jets to pass the requirement \begin{equation} Ov_2^h > 0.4, \,\,\,\,\, Ov_3^t <0.4 \,. \end{equation} As we will show in the following sections, the combined requirement on $Ov_2^h$ and $Ov_3^t$ is very efficient at removing the $t\bar{t}$ fake rate. For the purpose of this analysis, we generate 17 sets of both two body Higgs and three body top templates at fixed $p_T$, starting from $p_T = 425 {\rm\ GeV}$ in steps of $50 {\rm\ GeV}$, while we use a template resolution parameter $\sigma = p_T /3$ and scale the template subcones according to the rule of Ref. \cite{Backovic:2012jj}. \subsection{$b$-tagging} \label{sec:b-tagging} The signal final states we consider contain four $b$-jets from two Higgses, which can be extremely useful in disentangling the signal events from the background channels. However, requiring four $b$-tags in a boosted configuration comes at a severe cost of the signal efficiency as even in the optimistic scenario of a single $b$-tag efficiency of 75\%, $b$-tagging four jets alone would cut out about 70\% of the signal events. Instead, here we will consider two $b$-tags, and require that they are contained within the two Higgs candidate jets. A full analysis of $b$-tagging requires a detailed detector study which is beyond the scope of our work. Here we adopt a simplified, semi-realistic $b$-tagging procedure, whereby we assign to each $r=0.4$ jet a $b$-tag if there is a parton level $b$ or $c$ quark within $\Delta r=0.4$ from the jet axis. We then weight each event by the benchmark $b$-tagging efficiencies: \begin{equation} \epsilon_b = 0.75, \,\,\,\, \epsilon_c = 0.18, \,\,\,\,\, \epsilon_j = 0.01\,, \end{equation} where $\epsilon_{b, c, j}$ are the efficiencies that a $b$, $c$ or a light jet will be tagged as a $b$-jet. For a Higgs fat jet to be $b$-tagged, we then require that a $b$-tagged $r=0.4$ jet lands within $\Delta R=0.7$ from the fat jet axis. Furthermore, we take special care of the fact that more than one $b$-jet might land inside the fat jet and reweigh the $b$-tagging efficiencies according to the rule of Table \ref{tab:btag}. \vspace{1cm} \begin{table}[h] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|} \hline $b$-tag scores of a fat jet & Efficiency & values \\ \hline 0 (jet: u,d,s,g) & $\epsilon_j$ & 0.01 \\ \hline 1 (1c) & $\epsilon_c$ & 0.18 \\ \hline 2 (2c) & $2\, \epsilon_c (1-\epsilon_c)+ {\epsilon_c}^2$ & 0.33 \\ \hline 3 (1b) & $\epsilon_b$ & 0.75 \\ \hline 4 (1b+1c) & $\epsilon_b (1-\epsilon_c) + \epsilon_c (1-\epsilon_b)+\epsilon_b \epsilon_c$ & 0.80 \\ \hline 5 (1b+2c) & $\epsilon_b (1-\epsilon_c)^2 + 2 (1-\epsilon_b) (1-\epsilon_c) \epsilon_c + \epsilon_b {\epsilon_c}^2$ & 0.60 \\ \hline 6 (2b) & $2 \epsilon_b (1-\epsilon_b)+ {\epsilon_b}^2$ & 0.94 \\ \hline 7 (2b+1c) & $1 - (1-\epsilon_c) (1-\epsilon_b)^2$ & 0.95 \\ \hline 8 (2b+2c) & $1 - (1-\epsilon_c)^2 (1-\epsilon_b)^2$ & 0.96 \\ \hline 9 (3b) & $1 - (1-\epsilon_b)^3$ & 0.98 \\ \hline \end{tabular}\par \end{center} \caption{Efficiency that a Higgs fat jet will be $b$-tagged assuming that it contains a specific number of light, $c$ or $b$ jets within $\Delta R = 0.7$ from the jet axis. $\epsilon_j$, $\epsilon_c$ and $\epsilon_b$ are $b$-tagging efficiencies for light, $c$ and $b$ jets respectively. We neglect the possibilities beyond three proper $b$-tagged jets within a fat jet as they occur at too low of a rate to be significant. } \label{tab:btag} \end{table} \subsection{Event Selection and Reconstruction of the $U_h$ Pair}\label{sec:cutflow} We proceed to discuss in detail the cut scheme we propose for the all-hadronic searches for pair produced $U_h$ partners. For the convenience of the reader, we outline the event selection in Table \ref{tab:Cuts1}, while a detailed description and definition of the observables can be found in the following text. \begin{table}[h] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|} \hline \multirow{9}{*}{Cut Scheme} & \multirow{7}{*}{Basic Cuts} & Demand at least four fat jets ($R = 0.7$) with \\ & & $p_T > 300$ GeV, $| \eta |< 2.5$ \\ \cline{3-3} & & Declare the two highest $p_T$ fat jets \\ & & satisfying $Ov_{2}^h > 0.4$ and $Ov_{3}^t < 0.4$\\ & & to be Higgs candidate jets. \\ & & At least 1$b$-tag on both Higgs candidate jets. \\ \cline{3-3} & & Select the two highest $p_T$ light jets ($r=0.4$) \\ & & with $p_T > 25 {\rm\ GeV}$ to be the $u$ quark candidates. \\ \cline{2-3} & \multirow{4}{*}{Complex Cuts} & $|\Delta_{h} | < 0.1$ \\ & & $| \Delta_{U_h} | < 0.1$ \\ & & $m_{U_{h1,2}} > 800$ GeV \\ \hline \end{tabular}\par \end{center} \caption{Summary of the Event Selection Cut Scheme. } \label{tab:Cuts1} \end{table} \begin{figure}[h] \includegraphics[scale=0.35]{2D_signal_hard1_r01_R07_sigma033_ColorBlue.pdf} \includegraphics[scale=0.35]{2D_signal_hard2_r01_R07_sigma033_ColorBlue.pdf} \includegraphics[scale=0.35]{2D_ttbar_hard1_r01_R07_sigma033_ColorBlue.pdf} \includegraphics[scale=0.35]{2D_ttbar_hard2_r01_R07_sigma033_ColorBlue.pdf} \caption{Two dimensional distributions of peak template overlap scores for the two highest $p_T$ fat jets in the event. The top panels show the events from pair produced $U_h$, while the bottom shows the $t\bar{t}$ background. Here we omit showing $b\bar{b}$ and multi-jet backgrounds, as their overlap distributions are trivial and simply peak at $Ov_2^h \approx Ov_3^t\approx 0$.} \label{fig:Overlaps2d} \end{figure} We begin by requiring at least four anti-$k_T$, $R=0.7$ jets with \begin{equation} p_T^{R=0.7} > 300 {\rm\ GeV}, \,\,\,\,\,\,\, |y^{R=0.7}| < 2.5\,. \end{equation} The requirement on the presence of four fat jets pre-selects signal event candidates, as we expect two pairs of boosted Higgs-light jets to appear in the final state \footnote{Selecting 4 $R=0.7$ fat jets also simplifies the TOM jet substructure analysis. }. In order to determine which of the four jets are the Higgs candidates, we select the two highest $p_T$ fat jets which satisfy the TOM requirement of \begin{equation} Ov_2^h > 0.4, \,\,\,\,\,\,\,\, Ov_3^t < 0.4 \,, \label{eq:tom_reqs} \end{equation} of Section \ref{sec:TOM}. The requirement on peak template overlap is designed to select the two Higgs candidate jets in the event, while ensuring that the jets are not fake tops. If less than two fat jets pass the overlap requirement, the event is rejected. The overlap selections in Eq.~\eqref{eq:tom_reqs} deserve more attention. Figure \ref{fig:Overlaps2d} illustrates how utilizing multi-dimensional TOM analysis ($i.e. \, Ov_2^h$ and $Ov_3^t$) can help in reducing the background contamination of signal events. If we consider only $Ov_2^h$ (dashed line), a significant fraction of $t\bar{t}$ would pass any reasonable overlap cut. However, in a two dimensional distribution, it is clear that many of the $t\bar{t}$ events which obtain a high $Ov_2^h$ also obtain a high $Ov_3^t$ score. Contrary to $t\bar{t}$ events, the signal events almost never get tagged with a high $Ov_3^t$ score, as it is difficult for a proper Higgs fat jet to fake a top. Hence, an upper cut on $Ov_3^t$ (solid line) efficiently eliminates a significant fraction of $t\bar{t}$ events, at a minor cost of signal efficiency. Note that the peak at $Ov_2^h \approx Ov_3^h \approx 0$ in the signal distributions corresponds to events where the hardest/second hardest fat jet is likely a light jet. \begin{figure}[b] \begin{tabular}{cc} \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{mh_hard1_BeforeOv.pdf}& \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{mh_Higgs1_AfterOv.pdf}\\ \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{mh_hard2_BeforeOv.pdf}& \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{mh_Higgs2_AfterOv.pdf} \end{tabular} \caption{The invariant mass of the two highest $p_T$ fat jets ($R=0.7$) (labeled $h_{1, 2}$) before (left panels) and after (right panels) the boosted Higgs selection criteria. Notice that TOM selection filters out well both the high mass and low mass background events.} \label{fig:MassPlotsh} \end{figure} Figure \ref{fig:MassPlotsh} illustrates the effects of $Ov$ cuts on the mass distribution of the two highest $p_T$ jets. Note that the intrinsic mass filtering property of TOM can be clearly seen in the results. The mass resolution of the Higgs fat jets improves upon the cut on the overlap, while the contributions from both high mass and low mass background regions are significantly diminished. In addition to jet substructure requirements for Higgs tagging, we require both Higgs candidate jets to contain at least one $b$-tagged $r=0.4$ jet within the fat jet, as prescribed in Section \ref{sec:b-tagging}. In order to pick out the light jets, we re-cluster each event with $r=0.4$ (also necessary for $b$-tagging) and select the two highest $p_T$ jets which pass the requirement of \begin{equation} p^{r=0.4}_T > 25 {\rm\ GeV}, \,\,\,\,\, |y^{r=0.4}| < 2.5, \,\,\,\,\,\, \Delta R_{uh} > 1.1\,, \end{equation} where $\Delta R_{uh}$ stands for the plain distance in $\eta, \phi$ between the $r=0.4$ jet ($i.e.$ the up type quark) and each of the Higgs candidate fat jets. We declare these jets to be the $u$ quark candidates. Since we expect two Higgs fat jets in the final state, a comparison between the masses of the two hardest fat jets which pass the overlap criteria provides a useful handle on the background channels. In order to exploit this feature, we construct a mass asymmetry \begin{equation} \Delta_{h} \equiv \frac{m_{h1} - m_{h2}}{m_{h1} + m_{h2}}\,, \end{equation} where $m_{h_{1,2}}$ are the masses of the two Higgs candidate jets. Figure \ref{fig:MassPlotsDeltas} (left panel) shows the distribution of $\Delta_{h}$ for signal events and relevant backgrounds. Even after the overlap selections, the background distributions are significantly wider than the signal. Hence, in order to further suppress the background channels, we impose a cut of \begin{equation} |\Delta_{h}| < 0.1\,. \end{equation} \begin{figure}[b] \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{Delta_mh_Ex.pdf} \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{Delta_mU_Ex.pdf} \caption{Left panel: mass asymmetry $\Delta_h$ between the two highest $p_T$ fat jets which pass the Higgs tagging requirement. Right panel: minimized mass asymmetry $\Delta_{U_h}$ of the reconstructed $U_h$ pair. } \label{fig:MassPlotsDeltas} \end{figure} Upon identifying the $u$ and Higgs jets, we proceed with the reconstruction of the $U_h$ partner. The signal events are characterized by a distinct ``2 fat jet 2 light jet'' topology, a final state which represents somewhat of a combinatorial challenge (for each fat jet, two combinations with a light jet are possible). In order to find the correct Higgs-light jet pairs, we construct four different combinations of invariant masses \begin{equation} m^{U_h}_{ij}= \sqrt{(p^{h}_i + p^u_j)^2}\,, \end{equation} where $p^{h}_i$ are the four momenta of the two $R=0.7$ jets which pass the Higgs tagging requirements and $p^u_j$ are the four momenta of the two hardest $r=0.4$ isolated from the Higgs jets by $\Delta R_{uh} > 1.1.$ A correct Higgs-light jet pair then minimizes the value of \begin{equation} \Delta_{U_h} = \mathrm{min} \left[ |m^{U_h}_{11} -m^{U_h}_{22}|, |m^{U_h}_{12} - m^{U_h}_{21}|\right]\,. \end{equation} \begin{figure}[b] \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{m_Uh1.pdf} \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{m_Uh2.pdf} \caption{Reconstructed mass of the $U_h$ partner for true mass $M_{U_h} = 1 {\rm\ TeV}$. Left panel shows the mass reconstruction from the hardest Higgs candidate jet and the light jet which minimized $\Delta_{U_h}$, while the right panel shows the corresponding distribution assuming the second hardest Higgs candidate.} \label{fig:MassPlotsUh} \end{figure} Consequently, we take the configuration of Higgs - light jet pair which minimizes $\Delta_{U_h}$ to construct $m_{U_{h1,2}}$, the masses of the two $U_h$ partners in the event. Figure \ref{fig:MassPlotsUh} shows the reconstructed invariant mass distribution of the $U_h$ pair (assuming $M_{U_h} = 1 {\rm\ TeV}$) and the background distributions. The signal events show a prominent peak at the correct partner mass for both $U_h$ partners in the event, while the background distributions are smeared over a wide range of mass values. The results of Figure \ref{fig:MassPlotsUh} illustrate well the degree to which our proposal is able to resolve the mass of the $U_h$ partners. The value of $\Delta_{U_h}$ represents the minimum of a mass asymmetry between the two reconstructed objets and hence utilizes the fact that the $U_h$ partners are pair produced. In addition to allowing us to overcome the combinatorial issues when reconstructing the $U_h$ partners, $\Delta_{U_h}$ provides another handle on the background channels. Because the $U_h$ partners are pair produced, we expect the value of $\Delta_{U_h}$ to peak at 0 for signal events, while we expect the background channels to be characterized by wider distributions of $\Delta_{U_h}$ as there is no kinematic feature in the background channels which would lead to a reconstruction of two same mass resonances. Figure \ref{fig:MassPlotsDeltas} (right panel) shows $\Delta_{U_h}$ distributions for signal and relevant backgrounds. As in the case of $\Delta_{h}$, the background distributions of $\Delta_{U_h}$ are significantly broader compared to the signal, hence providing another unique handle on the background channels. In order to exploit this feature, we impose a cut on \begin{equation} |\Delta_{U_h}| < 0.1\,, \end{equation} as a part of our event selection. Finally, since we are interested in $U_h$ partners with mass $O(1 {\rm\ TeV})$, we require that both Higgs-light jet pairs pass the requirement \begin{equation} m_{U_{h1,2}} > 800, 1000 {\rm\ GeV}, \end{equation} for the benchmark values of $M_{U_h} = 1, 1.2 {\rm\ TeV}$ respectively, where we construct the mass of $U_{h1}$ and $U_{h2}$ from Higgs-light jet pairs which minimize $\Delta U_h$. \subsection{LHC Run II Sensitivity to $U_h$ Partners of Mass $\sim 1{\rm\ TeV}$} \label{sec:CutScheme} In this section we investigate the ability of our cutflow proposal to detect $\sim 1 {\rm\ TeV}$ light quark partners which decay to a Higgs-light jet pairs at the Run II of the LHC. Table~\ref{tab:1TeVBC1}~and~\ref{tab:12TeVBC1} show the main results, with respect to the initial cross section values in Table~\ref{tab:HT1600}. For all results on significance we assume a nominal integrated luminosity of $35 {\rm\ fb}^{-1}$. \setlength{\tabcolsep}{4pt} \vspace{.5cm} \begin{table}[h] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline & $\sigma_{s}$ [fb] &$\sigma_{t\bar{t}}$ [fb] &$\sigma_{b\bar{b}}$ [fb] &$\sigma_{\rm multi-jet}$ [fb] & $S/B$ & $S/ \sqrt{B}$ \\ \hline Preselection Cuts & 6.8\phantom{0} & 4.6 $ \times 10^{2}$ & 8.4 $ \times 10^{3}$ & 2.8 $ \times 10^{5}$ & $2.4 \times 10^{-5}$ & 7.5 $ \times 10^{-2}$ \\ \hline Basic Cuts & 1.2\phantom{0} & 4.6 & 16.0 & 6.8 $ \times 10^{2}$ & 1.7 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 2.7 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $| \Delta_{h} | < 0.1$ & 0.82 & 1.7 & 6.5 & 2.8 $ \times 10^{2}$ & 2.9 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 2.9 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $| \Delta_{U_h} | < 0.1$ & 0.56 & 5.5 $\times 10^{-1}$ & 2.0 & 87.0 & 6.3 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 3.5 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $m_{U_{h1,2}} > 800$ GeV & 0.50 & 3.6 $\times 10^{-1}$ & 1.6 & 67.0 & 7.3 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 3.6 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $b$-tag & 0.34 & 4.4 $\times 10^{-2}$ & 1.1 $\times 10^{-2}$ & 1.5 $\times 10^{-2}$ & \textbf{4.8} & \textbf{7.5} \\ \hline \end{tabular}\par \end{center} \caption{ $M_{U_{h}} = 1$ TeV , $\sigma_s = 6.8 {\rm\ fb}$ , $\mathcal{L }= 35 {\rm\ fb}^{-1}$} \label{tab:1TeVBC1} \end{table} \vspace{.5cm} \begin{table}[h] \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|} \hline &$\sigma_{s}$ [fb] &$\sigma_{t\bar{t}}$ [fb] &$\sigma_{b\bar{b}}$ [fb] &$\sigma_{\rm multi-jet}$ [fb] & $S/B$ & $S/ \sqrt{B}$ \\ \hline Preselection Cuts & 2.4\phantom{00} & 4.6 $ \times 10^{2}$ & 8.4 $ \times 10^{3}$ & 2.8 $ \times 10^{5}$ & $8.15 \times 10^{-6}$ & 2.6 $ \times 10^{-2}$ \\ \hline Basic Cuts & 0.60\phantom{0} & 4.6 & 16.0 & 6.8 $ \times 10^{2}$ & 8.6 $ \times 10^{-4}$ & 1.4 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $| \Delta_{h} | < 0.1$ & 0.39\phantom{0} & 1.7 & 6.5 & 2.8 $ \times 10^{2}$ & 1.4 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 1.4 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $| \Delta_{U_h} | < 0.1$ & 0.27\phantom{0} & 5.5 $ \times 10^{-1}$ & 2.0 & 87.0 & 3.0 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 1.7 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $m_{U_{h1,2}} > 1$ TeV & 0.22\phantom{0} & 1.9 $ \times 10^{-1}$ & 1.0 & 45.0 & 4.8 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 1.9 $ \times 10^{-1}$ \\ \hline $b$-tag & 0.134 & 2.2 $ \times 10^{-2}$ & 8.5 $ \times 10^{-3}$ & 1.2 $ \times 10^{-2}$ & \textbf{3.1} & \textbf{3.8} \\ \hline \end{tabular}\par \end{center} \caption{ $M_{U_{h}} = 1.2$ TeV , $\sigma_s = 2.4 {\rm\ fb}$ , $\mathcal{L }= 35 {\rm\ fb}^{-1}$} \label{tab:12TeVBC1} \end{table} \setlength{\tabcolsep}{6pt} Our results show that boosted jet techniques combined with fat jet $b$-tagging and kinematic constraints of pair produced heavy particles can achieve $S/B > 1$ with signal significance of $\sim 7 \sigma$ at $35 {\rm\ fb}^{-1}$, assuming light quark partners of $ M_{U_h} =1 {\rm\ TeV}.$ The significance we obtain is sufficient to claim a discovery of $1 {\rm\ TeV}$ light quark partners. In addition, we find that probing masses higher than $1 {\rm\ TeV}$ will require more luminosity and will be challenging at Run II of the LHC. However, even with $35 {\rm\ fb}^{-1}$ signal significance of more than $3\sigma$ is achievable for $M_{U_h} = 1.2 {\rm\ TeV}$, enough to rule out the model point. Requiring that there exist four fat jets with $p_T >300 {\rm\ GeV}$ in an event, together with our boosted Higgs tagging procedure result in an improvement of $S/B$ by roughly a factor of 70-100 at $\sim 20\%$ signal efficiency relative to the pre-selection cuts. Additional cuts on mass asymmetries improve $S/B$ by roughly of factor a 3 in total. \begin{figure}[t] \begin{tabular}{cc} \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{bTable_signal.pdf}& \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{bTable_ttbar.pdf}\\ \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{bTable_bbbar.pdf}& \includegraphics[scale=0.37]{bTable_multi.pdf} \end{tabular} \caption{$b$-tag score tables for the signal (top panel, left), `` $t \bar{t}$ +0,1,2 jets " (top panel, right), `` $b \bar{b}$ +0,1,2 jets" (bottom panel, left) and ``multi(2,3,4)-jet" (bottom panel, right), following the simplified $b$-tagging procedure of Section \ref{sec:b-tagging}. $h_{1,2}$ are the two highest $p_T$ fat jets which pass the Higgs tagging criteria of Section \ref{sec:TOM}. No $b$-tagging efficiencies have been applied to the results displayed in the plots.} \label{fig:btagscores} \end{figure} The greatest improvement in both $S/B$ and $S/\sqrt{B}$ comes from fat jet $b$-tagging, where we find an enhancement by a factor of $\sim 500 -600 $ in $S/B$ and $15-20$ in signal significance. The improvement is largely due to the enormous suppression double fat-jet $b$-tagging exerts on the multi-jet and $b\bar{b}$ backgrounds, with the signal efficiency of $\sim 50\%$. The high rejection power of $b$-tagging can be understood well from results presented in Figure \ref{fig:btagscores}. The signal events almost always contain at least one $b$ quark in each of the fat jets which pass the boosted Higgs tagging criteria. Conversely, almost no multi-jet and $b\bar{b}$ events contain two ``Higgs like'' fat jets with each of the tagged heavy boosted objects containing a $b$-jet. The only background channel which seems to contain a significant fraction of events with both fat jets containing a proper $b$-tag is Standard Model $t\bar{t}$. Still, we find that only about $10\%$ of the $t\bar{t}$ events survive the double $b$-tagging criteria.

Background {#Sec1} ========== *Novirhabdovirus* genus includes two of the most important viruses affecting teleost fish and causing devastating epizootics to wild and farmed fish stocks in Europe, North America, and Asia \[[@CR1], [@CR2]\]. Viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV), the *Piscine novirhabdovirus*, can infect over 90 species of marine and freshwater fishes across highly divergent teleost families \[[@CR3]--[@CR5]\]. VHSV is geographically distributed with 4 major genotypes and many sub-lineages and quasispecies strains \[[@CR6]\]. Infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV), the *Salmonid novirhabdovirus*, more specifically infects salmonid species \[[@CR2]\]. IHNV is widespread with 5 major genogroups \[[@CR7], [@CR8]\] and is enzootic to western areas of North America \[[@CR7], [@CR9]\]. Even with different evolutionary dynamics, with IHNV evolving faster than VHSV \[[@CR10]\], these viruses and their genogroups are co-circulating and often co-infecting hosts \[[@CR10]--[@CR14]\]. They also share a similar tropism, entering the host via epithelial surfaces, mainly through the gills and fins \[[@CR15], [@CR16]\]. Thereafter, they replicate in endothelial and hematopoietic tissues and induce similar symptomatology, characterized by hemorrhagic patterns \[[@CR2], [@CR17]\]. Novirhabdoviruses cause highly contagious and lethal diseases that are difficult to eradicate. Thus, both IHNV and VHSV are World Organization for Animal Health (OIE)-notifiable pathogens \[[@CR4]\]. Despite eradication programs and decades of research to develop and test efficient control strategies \[[@CR18], [@CR19]\], the use of available vaccines is hampered by safety concerns and restrictions in commercial use \[[@CR20], [@CR21]\]. Comparative studies across viral types and hosts can enhance the ability to identify common features of virulence that may inform the development of targeted therapeutics. VHSV and IHNV share the same cohort of genes, but the diversity of VHSV strains isolated and sequenced vastly outnumbers available information on IHNV, and the host responses to pathogen challenge vary widely. Given the presence of VHSV-IVb throughout the Great Lakes watershed there is tangible risk to all farmed fish in the region \[[@CR22], [@CR23]\]. VHSV-IVa/b are reported to cause mild to modest disease in rainbow trout (*Oncorhynchus mykiss*) \[[@CR24], [@CR25]\], but disease kinetics and mortalities may be comparable to those seen in yellow perch (*Perca flavescens*) and round gobies (*Neogobius melanostomus*), which are highly susceptible to this pathogen \[[@CR26]--[@CR28]\]. Additional challenge studies show that VHSV-IVb can cause significant morbidity and mortality in rainbow trout \[[@CR29], [@CR30]\]. Given differences in the reported susceptibility of trout to VHSV-IVb, the documented rapid evolution of this pathogen in the Great Lakes may allow for adaptation towards increased virulence in rainbow trout, that could parallel what occurred with IHNV \[[@CR7], [@CR23], [@CR31]\]. This could enable the disease to go undetected in a production setting. Therefore, although VHSV is not considered an immediate threat to trout aquaculture industry in North America, it is critical to understand the infectious capacity of VHSV-IVb in rainbow trout in parallel with IHNV, as a means to dissect the host-virus interaction during *Novirhabdovirus* pathobiology. Thus, comparative immunogenicity assessments can shed light on host- or strain-specific mechanistic differences with useful indications for therapeutic purposes. Novirhabdoviruses are bullet-shaped enveloped viruses, with non-segmented negative-sense single-stranded RNA genomes of 11,131 bases for IHNV \[[@CR32]\] and 11,158 bases for VHSV \[[@CR33]\]. Six open reading frames, separated by conserved gene junctions, encode for 5 structural and one non-structural components: Nucleocapsid protein (N), polymerase-associated Phosphoprotein (P), Matrix protein (M), surface Glycoprotein (G), NonVirion (NV) and a large RNA polymerase (L). The Matrix gene is known as the most powerful inducer of apoptotic changes, inhibiting the host-directed gene expression by blocking nascent cellular RNA synthesis, thus efficiently suppressing host antiviral responses \[[@CR34], [@CR35]\]. The transmembrane G protein, key for virus entry and recognition, has been the main target for vaccine development, possessing major antigenic properties \[[@CR36]--[@CR38]\]. The NV gene is unique in Novirhabdoviruses, distinguishing them from Rhabdoviruses of non-fish hosts, and genetically diverging between them \[[@CR39]\]. NV protein's precise functions remain unknown. NV is a small, non-structural protein \[12 and 14 kDa, respectively in IHNV and VHSV\], shown to be essential for viral growth \[[@CR40]\], replication \[[@CR41]\] and pathogenicity \[[@CR42]\]. Previous work suggested that NV might play a role in suppressing host IFN-1 and MX-1 through inhibiting NF-κB activity \[[@CR41], [@CR43], [@CR44]\]. Salmonids can mount a complex antiviral response, with either secreted or intracellular Type I IFN orchestrating interferon-stimulated gene (ISG) transcription at early infection stages \[[@CR45]--[@CR47]\]. Type I IFN transcripts strongly correlate with viral burden and with the transcription of marker genes encoding for effectors of the IFN antiviral cascade \[[@CR48], [@CR49]\]. The sustained expression of IGSs, viz MX proteins, ISG-15 or VIPERIN, is a common hallmark adopted in fish immunology as a measure of the antiviral state induced upon viral infections \[[@CR50]--[@CR54]\], and heterogeneous co-infections \[[@CR55], [@CR56]\]. As such, a potential role for NV in suppressing host innate immunity would represent a novel function unique to *Novirhabdovirus*. The aims of this study were to utilize specific reporter plasmids to characterize the impact of individual IHNV genes on constitutive transcription on innate antiviral transcriptional responses. Transfection protocols were improved, achieving adequate transient transfection efficiency in EPC, BF-2, RTG-2 and RTgill-W1 cell lines, to compare results between two epithelial (EPC and RTgill-W1) and two fibroblastic (BF-2 and RTG-2) cell types. Comparative studies on the actions of *Novirhabdovirus* proteins will enable identification of specific anti-host activities of these proteins in varying host cell-lines, with the aim of identifying genetic viral regulators that interfere with general cell transcription, or selectively with the host innate immunity signaling. Such information could identify key viral factors to be targeted for development of more efficient vaccines to combat these pathogens. Methods {#Sec2} ======= Cell cultures {#Sec3} ------------- Epithelial and fibroblastic cell lines were retrieved from American Type Culture Collection (ATCC), including: Fathead minnow (*Pimephales promelas*) *Epithelioma papulosum cyprini* (EPC) (ATCC: CRL-2872); Bluegill (*Lepomis macrochirus*) fry (BF-2) (ATCC: CCL-91); Rainbow trout (*Oncorhynchus mykiss*) gonad (RTG-2) (ATCC: CCL-55); and Rainbow trout gill (RTgill-W1) (ATCC: CRL-2523). Cell cultures were maintained in 25 cm^2^ tissue culture flasks (CytoOne) at 20 °C, with L-15 Leibovitz media (HyClone) supplemented respectively with 1% Penicillin-Streptomycin (PS) solution (Corning), and with 2% (L15-2PS) or 10% (L15--10PS) fetal bovine serum (Corning). Before using, media were filtered through a 0.2 μm cellulose nitrate membrane (Nalgene). Confluent cell monolayers were split 1:2 or 1:3 to seed 5 × 10^5^ cells to each well of the 12-wells plate (CytoOne) in L15--10PS and grown for 72 h in standard conditions before each transfection experiment. Plasmids and luciferase reporters {#Sec4} --------------------------------- To investigate the transcriptional modulatory effects of selected IHNV proteins, including N, P, M, G (structural) and NV (non-structural), specific genes from M genogroup were cloned into expression plasmids for transient co-transfections experiments. Only the L gene, encoding for the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, was not included in this screening due to its much larger size (respectively of 6091 nt in IHNV and 5954 nt in VHSV). Target coding sequences were PCR-amplified using cDNA from archive viral stocks with specific primers (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). PCR fragments were cloned into EcoRI and KpnI sites of pcDNA3.1(−)Myc/His A plasmid (Invitrogen). Plasmids were amplified in *E. coli* DH5α cells and plasmid DNA (pDNA) was purified using PureLink Fast Low-Endotoxin Midi Plasmid Purification Kit™ (Invitrogen), following the manufacturer's instructions. All expression plasmids were confirmed by sequencing before use in transfection experiments. The construction of other expression plasmids was previously reported \[[@CR35]\]. Luciferase reporter constructs, harboring *Renilla reniformis* luciferase gene under the transcriptional control of the promoter of each testing gene, were reported previously, including: simian virus 40 early promoter (SV40)/luc, Type I IFN/luc and MX-1/luc \[[@CR35], [@CR57], [@CR58]\]. The CMV enhancer/chicken β-Actin promoter, pCAG/luc plasmid \[[@CR59]\], was purchased from Addgene (Plasmid \#55764). Table 1Oligonucleotides used for the construction of plasmidsPrimerSequence (5′ → 3′)Restriction SitePrimer SourceSequence SourceIHNV-M N seAG**GAATTC**ATGACAGCGACACTCAGAGEcoRIHM461966 (AEH95651)IHNV-M N asAG**GGTACC**GTGGAATGAGTCGGAGTCKpnIIHNV-M P seAG**GAATTC**ATGTCGATGGAGAAGGAGEcoRIHM461966 (AEH95652)IHNV-M P asAG**GGTACC**TTGACTTGCTTCATGCGCKpnIIHNV-M M seAC**GAATTC**ATGTCTATTTTCAAGAGAGCEcoRIKe et al.*,* 2017 \[[@CR35]\]HM461966 (AEH95653)IHNV-M M asCTT**GGTACC**TTTTTCCTTCCCCCGCTTTTCGGKpnIIHNV-M G seA**GAATTC**GAGATGGACCATGATCACCACEcoRIHM461966 (AEH95654)IHNV-M G asA**GGTACC**TTGGACCGGTTTGCCAGGTGKpnIIHNV-M NV seAC**GAATTC**ATGGACCACCGCGACATAAACACEcoRIHM461966 (AEH95655)IHNV-M NV asAC**GGTACC**TCTGGGATAAGCAAGAAAGTCTTCKpnIVHSV-IVb N seCA**GAATTC**ATGGAAGGAGGAATCEcoRIKe et al.*,* 2017 \[[@CR35]\]KY359357 (ASZ84902)VHSV-IVb N asGT**GGTACC**ATCAGAGTCCTCGKpnIVHSV-IVb P seCA**GAATTC**ATGACTGATATTGAGATEcoRIKe et al.*,* 2017 \[[@CR35]\]KY359357 (ASZ84903)VHSV-IVb P asGT**GGTACC**CTCTAACTTGTCCAKpnIVHSV-IVb M seAC**GAATTC**ATGGCTCTATTCAAAAGAAAGCGCACCATCCTGEcoRIKe et al.*,* 2017 \[[@CR35]\]KY359357 (ASZ84904)VHSV-IVb M asAC**GGTACC**CCGGGGTCGGACAGAGKpnIVHSV-IVb G seAC**GAATTG**ATGGAATGGAATACTTEcoRIKe et al.*,* 2017 \[[@CR35]\]KY359357 (ASZ84905)VHSV-IVb G asGT**GGTACC**GACCATCTGGCTKpnIVHSV-IVb NV seAC**GAATTC**ATGACGACCCAGTCGGCACEcoRIKe et al.*,* 2017 \[[@CR35]\]KY359357 (ASZ84906)VHSV-IVb NV asAC**GGTACC**TGGGGGAGATTCGGAGCCAKpnIThe restriction enzyme recognition sites are shown in bold. Sequence source is provided for both the full viral genome and for specific genes (in parenthesis) Transient cell transfection {#Sec5} --------------------------- Cell transfection was performed in L15--10, without addition of antibiotics, using the suitable transfection reagent for each cell line at a final 3:1 reagent volume to total DNA ratio. EPC and BF-2 cells were transfected using FuGENE™ HD Transfection Reagent (Promega), while RTgill-W1 and RTG-2 using ViaFect™ Transfection Reagent (Promega). Plasmid concentrations in all transfection experiments were equalized between samples by the inclusion of closed circular empty vector pcDNA3.1, which was also used in negative control groups. DNA mixtures were complexed with the respective transfection reagents in 37 °C pre-warmed Opti-MEM™ I reduced serum medium (Gibco), then incubated for 15 min at 37 °C. 100 μl transfection doses were added to each confluent cell monolayer with 500 μl L15--10 in each well. 12-well plates (Greiner Bio-One) were incubated at 20 °C, without any further medium replacement or manipulation until the indicated sampling points. Cell viability assay {#Sec6} -------------------- Cell viability was quantified by staining cell monolayers with Sulforhodamine B (SRB) (Invitrogen) \[[@CR60]\]. Cells seeded in 96-well plates (Greiner Bio-One) were transfected as described above, thereafter fixed with 10% (w/v) trichloroacetic acid solution for 15 min and stained with 0.4% (w/v) SRB/1% (v/v) acetic acid solution for 20 min. Plates were washed four times with 1% (v/v) acetic acid and dried at RT. Dye was eluted in 10 mM unbuffered Tris-Base by incubating on a shaker for 5 min at RT. Absorbance was read using a microplate reader (Synergy H1, BioTek) at 550 nm, with values averaged between replicates. Cell viability was assessed 48 h after viral gene transfection using variable plasmid concentrations, thus excluding cytotoxic effects due to the transient transfection processes (Supp. Fig. [1](#MOESM1){ref-type="media"}). Immunoblotting {#Sec7} -------------- The expression of viral plasmids transfected in fish cells was assessed by Western blotting. Cell lysate prepared and separated by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE), as previously described \[[@CR61]\]. Samples were electrophoretically transferred to Immobilon^®^-P PVDF membrane (MilliporeSigma) and membranes were blocked with 5% (w/v) BSA/TBST (P-753, Boston Bioproducts) for 1 h at RT. Primary antibodies, anti-Myc monoclonal antibody (Myc, Invitrogen) and anti-β-Actin (Sigma) were diluted in TBST at 1:5000 and incubated overnight at 4 °C. Membranes were incubated with the secondary antibody for 1 h at RT, using horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-conjugated Goat anti-mouse IgG1 (Invitrogen) at 1:10,000 dilution in TBST. Immunoreactive bands were visualized with SuperSignal™ West Pico PLUS chemiluminescent substrate (Thermo Scientific) using Amersham Imager 600 (General Electric). Following exposure with anti-Myc antibodies, membranes were stripped using Restore™ PLUS western blot stripping buffer (Thermo Scientific) for 10 min at RT, thereafter, blocked with 5% (w/v) BSA/TBST for 30 min at RT, and re-probed with the anti β-Actin antibody. Luciferase reporter assay {#Sec8} ------------------------- After the designated time post-transfection, cell monolayers in each well were gently washed with 1X PBS at 20 °C, then lysed for 15 min at RT in 120 μl of luciferase cell culture lysis reagent (Promega), used at 1.5X in molecular grade water (HyClone). Sampled 12-well plates were kept at −20 °C until assays were performed. From each cell lysate sample, 75 μl was collected for Luciferase reporter assay in 96-well white solid flat bottom opaque microplates (Greiner Bio-One), and 10 μl for Bradford assay in 96-well clear flat bottom microplates (Greiner Bio-One). The luciferase reporter assay was performed by adding to each sample 100 μl of a mixture containing: 51 μl of Luciferase assay ATP assay buffer \[3.83 mM EGTA (MP Biomedicals), 14.4 mM Magnesium sulphate (Fisher Chemical), 23.9 mM Glycylglycine (ICN Biomedicals), 14.4 mM Potassium phosphate dibasic (Fisher BioReagents), 0.98 mM DTT (Dithiothreitol, Fisher BioReagents), 1.97 mM ATP (MP Biomedicals), 0.33 mM Coenzyme-A (MP Biomedicals), in Milli-Q water\], and 49 μl of Luciferin solution \[1 mM DTT, 25.1 mM Glycylglycine, 0.27 mM D-Luciferin (Pierce), in autoclaved Milli-Q water\]. Luminescence light emission was measured with a microplate reader (Synergy H1, BioTek), setting top optics reading and luminescence spectral scanning gain/sensitivity to 135. The total protein load was measured by adding 10 μl of each cell lysate to 90 μl of Pierce™ Coomassie Plus (Bradford) solution (diluted 50% in autoclaved Milli-Q water). Light absorbance values were immediately read at 595 nm with a Synergy H1 microplate reader. Data analysis {#Sec9} ------------- Luminescence data, expressed as Relative Light Units (RLU), were normalized to lysate protein concentrations. The Relative Luciferase Activity (RLA) was calculated as the % ratio between stimulated (co-transfected with testing plasmids) and unstimulated (pcDNA3.1 alone) samples. RLA ratio was analyzed using one-way ANOVA and LSD post hoc test for comparison of group means. Statistical analyses were performed and graphically represented using GraphPad Prism version 6 (GraphPad Software Inc.). All data shown are representatives of at least three independent experiments and presented as group means (±SEM). Changes relative to the control sample were considered statistically significant when *p* \< 0.05. Experimental design {#Sec10} ------------------- ### Constitutive cellular transcription experiments {#Sec11} The impact of single IHNV genes on host constitutive transcription was initially measured using a constitutively active SV40-luciferase reporter plasmid construct. This approach aimed to corroborate results from a previous assessment of VHSV genes in EPC cells \[[@CR35]\]. Fish cell lines EPC, BF-2, RTG-2 and RTgill-W1, were co-transfected with SV40/luc and two doses of each IHNV gene (Supp Fig. [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}). The endpoint for this experiment was set at 48 hpt, coincident with the time post-infection when IHNV and VHSV begin to induce morphological changes in infected cells, including initial cytopathic effects \[[@CR37], [@CR62]\]. To confirm and extend these observations, the approach was repeated with a different reporter construct, pCAG-luciferase (pCAG/luc). The pCAG promoter is a hybrid CMV/β-Actin promoter that yields high-level constitutive expression in different cell lines \[[@CR63]\]. The experimental set-up was unchanged, with pDNA amounts experimentally optimized for each cell line, and assessment performed with both VHSV and IHNV plasmid constructs. ### Antiviral response modulation experiments {#Sec12} To assess the impact of single IHNV genes on the host innate immune response we targeted two sequential stages of the IFN response pathway. The first approach was to measure the modulation of Type I IFN promoter activity. IHNV genes were co-transfected in fish cell lines, together with a luciferase construct regulated by the rainbow trout Type I IFN-a promoter (IFN/luc), along with MAVS, co-transfected to activate the IFN promoter \[[@CR57], [@CR64]\]. Fish cell lines were co-transfected with IFN/luc and MAVS along with two doses of each IHNV plasmid gene construct. pDNA amounts were again experimentally optimized for each cell line. IFNs signal through conserved JAK/STAT pathways to upregulate the expression of ISGs, thus playing a crucial role in the innate immune response to *Novirhabdovirus* infection \[[@CR45], [@CR47]\]. To measure ISG induction, the MX-1 promoter was used as a marker for assessing IFN activation in the presence or absence of IHNV genes. Cell lines were co-transfected with MX-1/luc and MAVS, and with two doses of each IHNV gene. pDNA construct amounts were experimentally optimized for each cell line (specified in Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}) to achieve readable RLU from all cell lines. IFN and MX-1 experiments proceeded for 72 hpt, to provide enough time for MAVS to efficiently stimulate the IFN pathway and its downstream effectors. Results {#Sec13} ======= Studies aimed at identifying the roles of VHSV and IHNV genes on host responses were carried out in several fish cell lines. The use of two commercial reagents allowed us to optimize transfection efficiency for the cell lines used, allowing for reproducibility between comparative experiments performed in parallel. Transfection efficiency was optimized by directly adding FuGENE HD (Promega)- or ViaFect (Promega)-DNA mixtures (doses prepared in OptiMEM) to each cell monolayer (in fresh L15--10 medium, without PS). Preliminary studies identified FuGENE HD as the best reagent for EPC and BF-2, while ViaFect as optimal for the RTG-2 and RTgill-W1 cell-lines, in terms of readable RLU values obtained and lack of cytotoxicity for cell monolayers upon transfection. The most reproducible results were obtained transfecting confluent monolayers at 72 h post seeding (incubating cells at 20 °C in standard conditions). The expression of each INHV and VHSV gene was checked at 48 hpt by Western Blotting (Supp. Fig. [2](#MOESM2){ref-type="media"}). All pDNA doses were experimentally determined for each cell type and used throughout these studies; see each figure legend for specific amounts. Comparative analysis of constitutive transcription modulation {#Sec14} ------------------------------------------------------------- Analysis of constitutive transcriptional modulation by individual IHNV genes was initially performed using SV40/luc as a reporter plasmid in transiently transfected teleost cell lines. IHNV N elicited a slight dose-dependent downregulation of luciferase activity in both epithelial cell lines (Supp Fig. [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}A and B). Interestingly, the opposite trend was observed in fibroblastic cells, including a mild stimulatory effect in BF-2, but a strong dose-dependent induction in RTG-2 (Supp Fig. [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}C and D). IHNV P and IHNV G mediated modest effects or had no impact on SV40/luc expression in the cell lines tested. IHNV M protein consistently inhibited general transcription in all cell lines tested. IHNV NV generally augmented expression, particularly in EPC (Supp Fig. [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}A) and BF-2 (Supp Fig. [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}C). NV stimulatory effects were less marked in both rainbow trout cell lines, although data from the latter experiments require careful interpretation: RLU values obtained upon SV40/luc transient transfection were strongly elevated in EPC cells (\~ 75,000 RLU in control) and BF-2 cells (\~ 2000 RLU in control), but RTgill-W1 (\~ 1200 RLU in control) and RTG-2 (\~ 200 RLU in control) barely rose above background. Because of the poor activity of SV40/luc in rainbow trout cells, we investigated the use of another constitutively active promoter for analysis (see below). In contrast to the limitations observed with SV40/luc, a modified β-Actin promoter luciferase reporter plasmid (pCAG/luc) gave reliably higher and more consistent RLU values in all the fish cell lines tested, thus providing improved sensitivity of host constitutive transcriptional regulation. RLU values obtained upon pCAG/luc transient transfection were much higher in EPC (\~ 330,000 RLU in control), BF-2 and RTG-2 (\~ 30,000 RLU in control), and lower but still much improved in the RTgill-W1 cell line (\~ 16,000 RLU in control). Experiments were therefore performed as in Supp Fig. [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}, but this time using pCAG/luc to better determine how VHSV and IHNV genes impacted constitutive expression in heterogeneous fish cell lines. With few exceptions, M from both viruses significantly inhibited pCAG/luc expression in all cells (Figs. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"} and [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In the few instances where VHSV or IHNV M effects were not statistically significant (in BF-2 and RTG-2, respectively) the trend was toward reduced expression as compared with controls. In contrast, NV from both viruses significantly augmented pCAG/luc expression, particularly in BF-2 where augmentation was as much as 6 to 7 fold over control values (Figs. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"} and [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). The other genes exhibited variable effects that were sometimes contradictory across cells or viruses of origin. VHSV P, for example, only rarely impacted luciferase expression to a significant extent (in BF-2, and at only one dose; Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}), whereas IHNV P augmented pCAG/luc expression in all cell types at one or both doses tested (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Similarly, VHSV G suppressed luciferase expression in the non-rainbow trout cells but had no effect in RTG-2 and RTgill-W1 (Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). IHNV G had the opposite impact, augmenting pCAG/luc expression in the rainbow trout cell lines (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}b, d), but it had no effect in EPC or BF-2 cells (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}a, b). These data highlight ways in which genes from these related rhabdoviruses can differentially impact transcription in different host backgrounds. Fig. 1Comparative modulation of host constitutive transcription by single VHSV genes. Epithelial (**a** EPC; **b** RTgill-W1) and fibroblastic (**c** BF-2; **d** RTG-2) cell lines were co-transfected with pCAG/luc plus two doses of each VHSV gene plasmid. Closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and baseline control. Luciferase activity was analyzed at 48 hpt and RLU normalized to total protein concentration in each sample. Data are representative of three independent experiments. Values are group means ±SEM. \**p* \< 0.05; \*\**p* \< 0.01; \*\*\**p* \< 0.001 indicate significant differences from pcDNA control values as determined by one-way ANOVA and Fisher's LSD test Modulation of type I IFN transcription in teleost cell lines {#Sec15} ------------------------------------------------------------ Our previous studies had implicated VHSV genes in the modulation of Type I IFN regulatory pathways in EPC cells \[[@CR35]\]. To determine whether IHNV genes similarly impacted IFN gene transcription, each of the fish cell lines was transfected with a rainbow trout IFN promoter/luciferase construct (RT-IFN/luc) along with MAVS to upregulate its expression. MAVS, alone, upregulated RT-IFN/luc by 3 to 20 fold, depending on the cell type, and in all cases IHNV NV co-transfection augmented RT-IFN induction by an additional 2 to 4 fold (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}). M, on the other hand, suppressed RT-IFN/luc expression to background levels in all cells at both doses tested, indicating a more potent transcriptional suppressive effect as compared to its impact on pCAG/luc, particularly in RTG-2 cells (compare to Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Interestingly, IHNV G exhibited a slight but significant suppression of RT-IFN/luc in all cells at one or both doses assessed, but P was more selective, inhibiting the pathway only in the non-rainbow trout cells (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}a, c). IHNV N exhibited the most clearly differential effects on IFN transcription, as compared to its effects on constitutive transcription. In all cells tested, IHNV N inhibited IFN promoter expression at one or both doses, as compared to having no effect on the pCAG/luc plasmid (compare Figs. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"} to [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). IHNV P only modestly altered the expression of RT-IFN/luc in EPC and BF-2. Fig. 2Comparative modulation of host constitutive transcription by single IHNV genes**.** Epithelial (**a** EPC; **b** RTgill-W1) and fibroblastic (**c** BF-2; **d** RTG-2) cell lines were co-transfected with pCAG/luc plus two doses of each IHNV gene plasmid. Closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and baseline control. Luciferase activity was analyzed at 48 hpt and RLU normalized to total protein concentration in each sample. Data are representative of three independent experiments. Values are group means ±SEM. \**p* \< 0.05; \*\**p* \< 0.01; \*\*\**p* \< 0.001 indicate significant differences from pcDNA control values as determined by one-way ANOVA and Fisher's LSD testFig. 3Comparative modulation of host innate antiviral response by single IHNV genes. Epithelial (**a** EPC; **b** RTgill-W1) and fibroblastic (**c** BF-2; **d** RTG-2) cell lines were co-transfected with rainbow trout Type I IFN/luc, with MAVS as a basal IFN expression stimulator, plus two doses of each IHNV gene plasmid. Closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and baseline control. Luciferase activity was analyzed at 72 hpt and RLU normalized to total protein concentration in each sample. Data are representative of three independent experiments. Values are group means ±SEM. \**p* \< 0.05; \*\**p* \< 0.01; \*\*\**p* \< 0.001 indicate significant differences from pcDNA control values as determined by one-way ANOVA and Fisher's LSD test Comparative analysis of ISG transcription modulation {#Sec16} ---------------------------------------------------- Once produced, IFNs upregulate the expression of hundreds of effector genes, generally referred to as ISGs. To assess the impact of IHNV genes on ISG regulation, IFNs were activated by MAVS transfection as in Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}, and then downstream ISG regulation assessed using the RT-MX1/luc reporter plasmid. MX-1 is potently regulated by IFNs and was transcriptionally activated in these studies by using MAVS co-transfection to upregulate endogenous IFN. The two strongest effects observed were with IHNV M and NV co-transfection with the RT-MX-1/luc plasmid (Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). As with the RT-IFN/luc plasmid, IHNV M potently suppressed transcription from the induced RT-MX-1/luc plasmid, while IHNV NV potently augmented luciferase activity in three of the four cells types (4 to 9 fold), and less robustly but still significantly in the fourth (2 fold; Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). Few other genes produced dramatic effects, although both P and N suppressed MX-1 promoter activity in EPC cells. The action of IHNV NV and VHSV NV plasmids was further confirmed by disrupting the coding sequences upon restriction enzyme cleavage (using Kpn1/EcoRI), which resulted in the evident loss of any stimulatory activity on MX-1 (Supp Fig. [4](#MOESM4){ref-type="media"}). Overall, these data suggest that the IFN response was less susceptible to IHNV proteins, except for NV and M. Fig. 4Comparative modulation of host innate antiviral response by single IHNV genes. Epithelial (**a** EPC; **b** RTgill-W1) and fibroblastic (**c** BF-2; **d** RTG-2) cell lines were co-transfected with rainbow trout MX-1/luc, with MAVS as a basal IFN expression stimulator, plus two doses of each IHNV gene plasmid. Closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and baseline control. Luciferase activity was analyzed at 72 hpt and RLU normalized to total protein concentration in each sample. Data are representative of three independent experiments. Values are group means ±SEM. \**p* \< 0.05; \*\**p* \< 0.01; \*\*\**p* \< 0.001 indicate significant differences from pcDNA control values as determined by one-way ANOVA and Fisher's LSD test Discussion {#Sec17} ========== Successful viral infection and shedding relies on evolutionarily conserved strategies to selectively counteract innate immune defenses in susceptible host species. In many instances, one or more viral proteins must block or attenuate specific cellular pathways to allow efficient virus replication and to propagate the infection. Differential effects of *Novirhabdovirus* genes on general cellular transcription, or targeted transcription of antiviral effector genes, were investigated in this study using a comparative approach involving use of different teleost cell lines. By measuring differences in viral protein alteration of host transcriptional responses across epithelial (EPC and RTgill-W1) and fibroblastic cell types (RTG-2 and BF-2), representing different fish species, we sought to identify functional differences that might correlate with host transcriptional responses to each virus species. We focused on Novirhabdoviruses of economic or ecological importance in North America: VHSV-IVb and IHNV-M genotypes. VHSV-IVb is of significant ecological concern in the Laurentian Great Lakes region where sporadic outbreaks have occurred over the past 17 years \[[@CR31], [@CR65], [@CR66]\], thus there is tangible risk to all farmed fish in the region. But to date, VHSV-IVb has shown limited pathogenicity toward rainbow and brown trout \[[@CR24], [@CR54]\], this could enable the disease to go undetected in a production setting. In contrast, IHNV is highly pathogenic to many salmonid species, inducing potent innate immune response including upregulation of Type I IFN and MX-1 \[[@CR67]\] and leading to outbreaks of significant economic consequence in the trout aquaculture industry \[[@CR2], [@CR68]\]. Cell line susceptibility is generally consistent with the disease susceptibility of originating host sources \[[@CR69]\], with VHSV-IVa being more pathogenic than VHSV-IVb towards RTgill-W1 cells \[[@CR70]\]. By testing the effects of four of the major structural (N, P, M, G), and the sole nonstructural (NV), genes from VHSV-IVb and IHNV-M in a series of transient transfection studies, we were able to gain insight into the comparative efficacy of each genes ability to modulate general or innate immune gene transcription in different teleost host backgrounds. Our data suggest that the effects of the *Novirhabdovirus* M and NV proteins remain the most robust modulators of host response measures in the teleost cell lines used in this study. Beyond these two genes, the potential roles of other viral components have not been thoroughly assessed across a range of host cells using optimized transfection-plasmid construct procedures. As such, we feel that these studies add to our understanding of host-virus interactions in this important family of fish viruses and pave the way forward for further comparative studies using optimized in vitro procedures. As mentioned, previous work had focused on M protein's anti-host actions. Long known to perturb transcription \[[@CR34]\], recent studies have focused on the mechanism of action of the *Novirhabdovirus* M gene, confirming that VHSV M potently suppressed transcription in a manner reminiscent of M from mammalian Rhabdoviruses \[[@CR35], [@CR71]\]. The studies also demonstrated that M protein's viral packaging function could be separated genetically from its anti-host actions \[[@CR35]\], similar to vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) M protein \[[@CR72]\]. Consistent with the above body of literature, M significantly reduced host transcription in most cells tested and under most conditions in our studies. Although some variability was observed across cell types tested, which is as expected, the most consistent effects were obtained with VHSV and IHNV M proteins. Interestingly, M from these two related novirhabdoviruses elicited similar effects on transcription across different host types. M from both IHNV and VHSV-IVb suppressed both constitutive transcription and transcription associated with the Type I IFN pathway. Although a few experiments failed to discern a significant impact of M on transcription (VHSV M in BF-2 and IHNV M in RTG-2), these were associated more with the post-transfection sampling time point (e.g. 48 hpt) than the biology, since later time points routinely showed potent suppression (data not shown). Although the observed transcriptional inhibition by VHSV and IHNV M were predicted based on prior reports, these new data demonstrate the broad spectrum of conditions under which the effect can be observed, including both natural and unnatural hosts (salmonid and non-salmonid cell lines). Rhabdoviral G protein is a critical determinant of cellular engagement, immunogenicity and in some cases host specificity \[[@CR20], [@CR73]--[@CR75]\]. In this study, VHSV G protein had no effect on constitutive transcription within epithelial (RTgill-W1) and fibroblastic (RTG-2) rainbow trout cell lines. IHNV G, in contrast, showed mild suppression of constitutive, and innate immune regulated, transcription in gill epithelial cells but strongly stimulatory in gonad fibroblastic cells. Furthermore, IHNV G induced dose-dependent inhibition to either Type I IFN and MX-1, more marked in both rainbow trout cell lines. G uniquely interferes with multiple host cell functions, including translation through the endoplasmic reticulum, which may activate negative feedback loops that impact IFN responses over the 72 hpt studies reported herein. This action looks indeed less marked on the general transcription at 48 hpt, and in EPC and BF-2 cells transfected with rainbow trout-specific IFN pathway reporters, but the explanation for this remains unclear at this point in time. The novirhabdoviral N gene is a determinant for virulence variability \[[@CR76], [@CR77]\]. N is implicated in the innate immune response activation, by cytotoxic T cells specifically recognizing N-derived peptides presented in MHC class I \[[@CR75]\]. The development of experimental vaccines with rearranged gene order showed that the position of IHNV N plays the most critical role in determining the level of viral attenuation \[[@CR78]\]. VHSV N did not modulate the IFN pathway in EPC cells at 48 hpt \[[@CR35]\]. In our studies at 72 hpt, the impact of N was dependent not only on the viral source, but also on the reporter gene used. IHNV N suppressed the IFN promoter-luciferase reporter construct (Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}) but had minimal effects on the MX-1 promoter (Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). This interesting distinction between Type I IFN and MX-1 might lead to future work on those aspects of the innate immune response that are impacted by the novirhabdoviral N protein. The P gene is another viral component critical for virus replication, and in some mammalian rhabdoviruses the P protein is implicated in the modulation of innate immune signaling, particularly through IRF3 phosphorylation \[[@CR79]\]. N and P genes have been implicated in determining virulence of VHSV genotypes/strains in rainbow trout \[[@CR77]\]. In this study, P had no consistent effects on the assessed signaling pathways in the cell lines examined. IHNV P positively regulated the constitutive pCAG/luc plasmid at one or more doses in all cells tested, but more consistently in fibroblastic cell types (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In contrast, IHNV P either had no effect, or inhibited only slightly the other reporter constructs. Our previous studies had failed to identify an impact of VHSV P in EPC cells using a wide array of reporter constructs \[[@CR35]\]. It thus seems that fish rhabdoviruses may either be distinct from their mammalian counterparts, or that we simply have not identified an appropriate gene (reporter construct), cell line, or timeframe to monitor for anti-host activity of P in teleost cell lines. While the functions of IHNV and VHSV structural genes in viral replication are generally well characterized, the function of the NV gene is still not fully understood. Previous studies identified NV protein anti-apoptotic activity \[[@CR80]\]. NV nuclear localization in RTG-2 cells was deemed necessary for optimal IHNV growth and pathogenicity \[[@CR43]\]. NV may support viral replication through inhibition of the IFN system, based on work in that same report \[[@CR43]\]. rVHSV-ΔNV was highly attenuated in EPC cells \[[@CR81]\] as compared to wild type rVHSV. Reverse genetics with interactomic analysis recently identified PPM1Bb (a member of the PP2C family of Ser/Thr protein phosphatases) as a cellular partner of the VHSV NV protein. PPM1Bb recruitment by NV induces a strong inhibition of both RIG-I- and TBK1-mediated IRF-3-dependent IFN and ISG promoter activities \[[@CR82]\]. Overall, however, no uniform picture of NV function has yet emerged. In all our studies, NV consistently augmented luciferase expression (host transcription) for both VHSV and IHNV (\~ 2 to \~ 8 fold-increases; Figs. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"} and [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}, Supp Fig. [3](#MOESM3){ref-type="media"}). IHNV NV was particularly robust in inducing the IFN pathway in four heterogeneous teleost cell lines. An IHNV NV plasmid in which the coding sequence was excised by restriction enzyme cleavage (Kpn1/EcoRI) resulted in the loss of any stimulatory activity (Supp Fig. [4](#MOESM4){ref-type="media"}). It is well-known that Novirhabdoviruses are highly susceptible to Type I IFN responses \[[@CR83], [@CR84]\], and so this novel NV effect requires further investigation. Additionally, a recent study has also provided evidence that VHSV NV plays a role in the mediation of the PKR-like endoplasmic reticulum kinase (PERK)-eukaryotic initiation factor 2α (eIF2α) pathway through increased levels of phosphorylated eIF2α and viral-mediated host translational shutoff, leading to efficient viral protein synthesis and decreased IFN production during infection \[[@CR61]\]. It appears that the conserved abilities of M protein to broadly suppress host transcription, and NV to stimulate antiviral responses, should be considered as a potential coordination nexus for teleost *Novirhabdovirus* pathobiology. Their combined action could give the virus enough time for replication, followed by release of mature viral particles. Further study is needed to describe NV immune-enhancing features and the relative activities across different hosts and viral strains. The available literature dealing with the impact of viral gene components on host transcription often rely on sub-optimal transfection methods and conditions. The development of optimized transfection protocols for fish cell lines, notoriously difficult to transfect, is an important challenge in the field, and limits basic research on teleost virology and related diagnostic applications. The availability of new transfection reagents allowed the selection for the best method to retrieve robust and comparable data from heterogenous cell types, using consistent treatment conditions and post-transfection time points. Newer generation commercial reagents, including ViaFect and a new version of Fugene, have drastically increased the transfection efficiency for fish cell lines. Importantly, when paired with the use of a stabilized cell culture medium (L-15, with a stable pH and without CO~2~ supplementation), these newer transfection reagents were used under identical conditions allowing the use of a more simplified and consistent set of conditions. Cell monolayers can be maintained under consistent conditions and receive minimal manipulation as compared to prior methods. Our efforts enabled refinement of experimental conditions, including timing for transfecting cells post plating and the optimal dose of plasmids being used. Together, these validated transfection protocols augmented our ability to answer comparative questions on the function of *Novirhabdovirus* genes. Conclusions {#Sec18} =========== This study analyzed the relative individual abilities of *Novirhabdovirus* genes to interfere with general host cell transcription and demonstrated the modulatory effects of IHNV genes the Type I IFN pathway in various teleost cell lines. A consistent transcriptional inhibitory action was observed for M, with less robust suppression observed for N. NV exhibited a novel consistent stimulatory effect on constitutive transcription and antiviral immunity across a variety of cell types. Other viral genes studied, P and G, showed some more specific induction patterns, linked to the cell type or plasmid dose. This study provides novel insights on the viral regulators of the innate signaling, thus suggesting further studies are required to discover the mechanistic interaction eliciting the stimulatory effect seen for NV. In support of this, the comparative approach used in this study allowed a glimpse into a more comprehensive picture of the novirhabdoviral pathogenetic strategy across a variety of cells and teleost hosts. This was enabled by optimization of multiple cell transfection methods, treatment times and reporter genes tested. These results underscore the value of comparative in vitro immunological assessments involving use of more than a single virus or host cell type/line and optimized transfection techniques. Results from this study will be helpful in identifying novel viral targets, such as NV, that modulate the host-pathogen interaction and immunogenicity, thus informing more efficient vaccination and vaccine development strategies. Supplementary information ========================= {#Sec19} ###### **Additional file 1: Supp. Fig. 1.** Confirmation of cell viability after transient transfection. EPC cells (5 × 10^3^) were grown for 72 h and thereafter transfected with various concentrations of plasmids encoding IHNV genes. Closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and baseline control. At 48 h post transfection sulforhodamine B (SRB) viability assays were performed to determine the cytotoxicity of the overexpressed viral proteins. pcDNA sample values were normalized to an additional non-transfected average value; thus, all viral gene samples were further normalized to the new pcDNA value, creating a relative viability. Data were plotted as an average with standard deviation (*N* = 4). ###### **Additional file 2: Supp. Fig. 2.** Confirmation of transient transfection in EPC cells. EPC cells (1 × 10^6^) were grown for 72 h and thereafter transfected with 2 μg of each plasmids, respectively encoding for IHNV (**a**) or VHSV (**b**) genes in frame with a C-terminal Myc epitope tag. Cell transfection was achieved using FuGENE™ HD transfection reagent (Promega) in Opti-MEM™ I (Gibco). A non-transfected (NT) sample was included for control. The closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and for negative control. Cell lysates were sampled at 48 h post transfection and separated by SDS-PAGE and immunoblotted for protein expression with an anti-Myc antibody. Afterwards, blots were stripped and re-probed with an anti-β-Actin antibody to show loading controls. ###### **Additional file3: Supp. Fig. 3.** Comparative modulation of host constitutive transcription by single IHNV genes. Epithelial (**a** EPC; **b** RTgill-W1) and fibroblastic (**c** BF-2; **d** RTG-2) cell lines were co-transfected with SV40/luc plus two doses of each IHNV gene plasmid. Closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and baseline control. Luciferase activity was analyzed at 48 hpt and RLU normalized to total protein concentration in each sample. Data are representative of three independent experiments. Values are group means ±SEM. \**p* \< 0.05; \*\**p* \< 0.01; \*\*\**p* \< 0.001 indicate significant differences from pcDNA control values as determined by one-way ANOVA and Fisher's LSD test. ###### **Additional file 4: Supp. Fig. 4.** Confirmation of Novirhabdoviruses modulation of the host innate antiviral response operated by NV gene. Epithelial (**a** EPC) and fibroblastic (**b** BF-2) cell lines were co-transfected with rainbow trout MX-1/luc, with MAVS as a basal IFN expression stimulator, plus 0.1 μg of intact of destroyed IHNV or VHSV NV gene plasmid. NV plasmids were destroyed upon restriction enzyme cleavage (using Kpn1/EcoRI). Closed circular empty pcDNA3.1 plasmid vector was used for transfection balancing and baseline control. Luciferase activity was analyzed at 72 hpt and RLU normalized to total protein concentration in each sample. Data are representative of three independent experiments. Values are group means ±SEM. \**p* \< 0.05; \*\**p* \< 0.01; \*\*\**p* \< 0.001 indicate significant differences from pcDNA control values as determined by one-way ANOVA and Fisher's LSD test. **Publisher's Note** Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Supplementary information ========================= **Supplementary information** accompanies this paper at 10.1186/s12985-020-01372-4 The authors thank Malathi Krishnamurthy, Shelby Kesterson, Adam Pore and Wade Weaver for contributing to the approaches and observations underlying the design of these studies. DWL and BG conceived and designed the experiments and BSS contributed to overall project planning. BG performed the experiments, analysed results and wrote the manuscript. LP and JLR contributed to the performance of the experiments. DWL, BG, JLR and BSS edited the final version of the manuscript. BG presented part of this work during the 8^th^ International Symposium on Aquatic Animal Health, Charlottetown, Canada . The authors read and approved the final manuscript. This work was supported by NSF-IOS grant award \#DBI-1354806/1354684 and USDA/ARS CRIS project number 5090--31320-004-00D under cooperative agreement number 58--5090--6-057. All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article, and its supplementary information files. The views contained in this document are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies, either expressed or implied, of the U.S. Government. Mention of trade name, proprietary product, or specific equipment does not constitute a guarantee or warranty by the USDA and does not imply its approval to the exclusion of other products that may be suitable. The USDA is an Equal Opportunity Employer. This manuscript is submitted for publication with the understanding that the US Government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for governmental purposes. The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

\section{Cosmological Constant as the dark energy} \subsection{The cosmological paradigm} A host of different observations, which became available in the last couple of decades, have thrusted upon us a preposterous composition for the energy density of different components in the universe which defies any simple explanation. The energy densities of the different species which drive the expansion of the universe, can be measured in terms of a \textit{critical energy density} $\rho_c=3H^2_0/8\pi G$ where $H_0=(\dot a/a)_0$ is the rate of expansion of the universe at present. The variables $\Omega_i=\rho_i/\rho_c$ will then give the fractional contribution of different components of the universe ($i$ denoting baryons, dark matter, radiation, etc.) to the critical density required to close the universe. Observations suggest that the universe has $0.98\lesssim\Omega_{tot}\lesssim1.08$ with radiation (R), baryons (B), dark matter, made of weakly interacting massive particles (DM) and dark energy (DE) contributing $\Omega_R\simeq 5\times 10^{-5},\Omega_B\simeq 0.04,\Omega_{DM}\simeq 0.26,\Omega_{DE}\simeq 0.7,$ respectively. All known observations \cite{cmbr,baryon,h} are consistent with such an --- admittedly weird --- composition for the universe. The conventional cosmological paradigm --- which is remarkably successful --- is based on these numbers and can be summarised \cite{adcos} as follows: The key idea is that if there existed small fluctuations in the energy density in the early universe, then gravitational instability can amplify them in a well-understood manner leading to structures like galaxies etc. today. The most popular model for generating these fluctuations is based on the idea that if the very early universe went through an inflationary phase \cite{inflation}, then the quantum fluctuations of the field driving the inflation can lead to energy density fluctuations \cite{genofpert,tplp}. It is possible to construct models of inflation such that these fluctuations are described by a Gaussian random field and are characterized by a power spectrum of the form $P(k)=A k^n$ with $n\simeq 1$. The inflationary models cannot predict the value of the amplitude $A$ in an unambiguous manner. But it can be determined from CMBR observations and the inflationary model parameters can be fine-tuned to reproduce the observed value. The CMBR observations are consistent with the inflationary model for the generation of perturbations and gives $A\simeq (28.3 h^{-1} Mpc)^4$ and $n\lesssim 1$. (The first results were from COBE \cite{cobeanaly} and WMAP has re-confirmed them with far greater accuracy). When the perturbation is small, one can use well defined linear perturbation theory to study its growth. But when $\delta\approx(\delta\rho/\rho)$ is comparable to unity the perturbation theory breaks down. Since there is more power at small scales, smaller scales go non-linear first and structure forms hierarchically. The non linear evolution of the \textit{dark matter halos} can be understood by simulations as well as theoretical models based on approximate ansatz \cite{nlapprox} and nonlinear scaling relations \cite{nsr}. The baryons in the halo will cool and undergo collapse in a fairly complex manner because of gas dynamical processes. It seems unlikely that the baryonic collapse and galaxy formation can be understood by analytic approximations; one needs to do high resolution computer simulations to make any progress \cite{baryonsimulations}. The results obtained from all these attempts are broadly consistent with observations but the summary given above demonstrates that modeling the universe and comparing the theory with observations is a rather involved affair. So, to the zeroth order, the universe is characterized by just seven numbers: $h\approx 0.7$ describing the current rate of expansion; $\Omega_{DE}\simeq 0.7,\Omega_{DM}\simeq 0.26,\Omega_B\simeq 0.04,\Omega_R\simeq 5\times 10^{-5}$ giving the composition of the universe; the amplitude $A\simeq (28.3 h^{-1} Mpc)^4$ and the index $n\simeq 1$ of the initial perturbations. The remaining challenge, of course, is to make some sense out of these numbers themselves from a more fundamental point of view. Among all these components, the dark energy, which exerts negative pressure, is probably the weirdest and --- since non-cosmologists often wonder how strong is the evidence for it --- it is useful keep the following points in mind: \begin{itemize} \item The rapid acceptance of dark energy by the community is partially due to the fact that --- even before the supernova data came up --- there were strong indications for the existence of dark energy. Early analysis of several observations \cite{earlyde} indicated that this component is unclustered and has negative pressure. This is, of course, confirmed dramatically by the supernova observations\cite{sn,snls}. (For a critical look at the current data, see \cite{tptirthsn1}; a sample of recent SN data analysis papers can be found in ref. \cite{sndataanalysis}.) \item The WMAP-CMBR data with a reasonable prior on Hubble constant implies $\Omega_{tot}\approx 1$ while a host of other astronomical observations show that the clustered matter contributes only about $\Omega_{DM}\approx 0.25-0.4$. Together, they require a unclustered (negative pressure) component in the universe independent of SN data. \textit{It, therefore, seems very unlikely that dark energy will ``go away".} \end{itemize} The key observational feature of dark energy is that --- treated as a fluid with a stress tensor $T^a_b=$ dia $(\rho, -p, -p,-p)$ --- it has an equation state $p=w\rho$ with $w \lesssim -0.8$ at the present epoch. The spatial part ${\bf g}$ of the geodesic acceleration (which measures the relative acceleration of two geodesics in the spacetime) satisfies an \textit{exact} equation in general relativity given by: \begin{equation} \nabla \cdot {\bf g} = - 4\pi G (\rho + 3p) \label{nextnine} \end{equation} This shows that the source of geodesic acceleration is $(\rho + 3p)$ and not $\rho$. As long as $(\rho + 3p) > 0$, gravity remains attractive while $(\rho + 3p) <0$ can lead to `repulsive' gravitational effects. In other words, dark energy with sufficiently negative pressure will accelerate the expansion of the universe, once it starts dominating over the normal matter. This is precisely what is established from the study of high redshift supernova, which can be used to determine the expansion rate of the universe in the past \cite{sn,snls}. The simplest model for a fluid with negative pressure is the cosmological constant (for a sample of recent reviews, see ref. \cite{cc}) with $w=-1,\rho =-p=$ constant. If dark energy is indeed the cosmological constant, then it introduces a fundamental length scale in the theory $L_\Lambda\equiv H_\Lambda^{-1}$, related to the constant dark energy density $\rho_{_{\rm DE}}$ by $H_\Lambda^2\equiv (8\pi G\rho_{_{\rm DE}}/3)$. In classical general relativity, based on $G, c $ and $L_\Lambda$, it is not possible to construct any dimensionless combination from these constants. But when one introduces the Planck constant, $\hbar$, it is possible to form the dimensionless combination $H^2_\Lambda(G\hbar/c^3) \equiv (L_P^2/L_\Lambda^2)$. Observations then require $(L_P^2/L_\Lambda^2) \lesssim 10^{-123}$. This will require enormous fine tuning. What is more, in the past, the energy density of normal matter and radiation would have been higher while the energy density contributed by the cosmological constant does not change. Hence we need to adjust the energy densities of normal matter and cosmological constant in the early epoch very carefully so that $\rho_\Lambda\gtrsim \rho_{\rm NR}$ around the current epoch. This raises the second of the two cosmological constant problems: Why is $(\rho_\Lambda/ \rho_{\rm NR}) = \mathcal{O} (1)$ at the {\it current} phase of the universe ? These are the two conventional conceptual difficulties associated with the cosmological constant\ and have been discussed extensively in literature. \subsection{The `denial' approach to the cosmological constant} Because of these conceptual problems associated with the cosmological constant, people have explored a large variety of alternative possibilities. The most popular among them uses a scalar field $\phi$ with a suitably chosen potential $V(\phi)$ so as to make the vacuum energy vary with time. The hope then is that, one can find a model in which the current value can be explained naturally without any fine tuning. A simple form of the source with variable $w$ are scalar fields with Lagrangians of different forms, of which we will discuss two possibilities: \begin{equation} \mathcal{L}_{\rm quin} = \frac{1}{2} \partial_a \phi \partial^a \phi - V(\phi); \quad \mathcal{L}_{\rm tach} = -V(\phi) [1-\partial_a\phi\partial^a\phi]^{1/2} \label{lquineq} \end{equation} Both these Lagrangians involve one arbitrary function $V(\phi)$. The first one, $\mathcal{L}_{\rm quin}$, which is a natural generalization of the Lagrangian for a non-relativistic particle, $L=(1/2)\dot q^2 -V(q)$, is usually called quintessence (for a small sample of models, see \cite{phiindustry}). When it acts as a source in Friedman universe, it is characterized by a time dependent $w(t)$ with \begin{equation} \rho_q(t) = \frac{1}{2} \dot\phi^2 + V; \quad p_q(t) = \frac{1}{2} \dot\phi^2 - V; \quad w_q = \frac{1-(2V/\dot\phi^2)}{1+ (2V/\dot\phi^2)} \label{quintdetail} \end{equation} The structure of the second Lagrangian in Eq.~(\ref{lquineq}) (which arises in string theory) can be understood by a simple analogy from special relativity. A relativistic particle with (one dimensional) position $q(t)$ and mass $m$ is described by the Lagrangian $L = -m \sqrt{1-\dot q^2}$. It has the energy $E = m/ \sqrt{1-\dot q^2}$ and momentum $k = m \dot q/\sqrt{1-\dot q^2} $ which are related by $E^2 = k^2 + m^2$. As is well known, this allows the possibility of having \textit{massless} particles with finite energy for which $E^2=k^2$. This is achieved by taking the limit of $m \to 0$ and $\dot q \to 1$, while keeping the ratio in $E = m/ \sqrt{1-\dot q^2}$ finite. The momentum acquires a life of its own, unconnected with the velocity $\dot q$, and the energy is expressed in terms of the momentum (rather than in terms of $\dot q$) in the Hamiltonian formulation. We can now construct a field theory by upgrading $q(t)$ to a field $\phi$. Relativistic invariance now requires $\phi $ to depend on both space and time [$\phi = \phi(t, {\bf x})$] and $\dot q^2$ to be replaced by $\partial_i \phi \partial^i \phi$. It is also possible now to treat the mass parameter $m$ as a function of $\phi$, say, $V(\phi)$ thereby obtaining a field theoretic Lagrangian $L =- V(\phi) \sqrt{1 - \partial^i \phi \partial_i \phi}$. The Hamiltonian structure of this theory is algebraically very similar to the special relativistic example we started with. In particular, the theory allows solutions in which $V\to 0$, $\partial_i \phi \partial^i \phi \to 1$ simultaneously, keeping the energy (density) finite. Such solutions will have finite momentum density (analogous to a massless particle with finite momentum $k$) and energy density. Since the solutions can now depend on both space and time (unlike the special relativistic example in which $q$ depended only on time), the momentum density can be an arbitrary function of the spatial coordinate. The structure of this Lagrangian is similar to those analyzed in a wide class of models called {\it K-essence} \cite{kessence} and provides a rich gamut of possibilities in the context of cosmology \cite{tptachyon,tachyon}. Since the quintessence field (or the tachyonic field) has an undetermined free function $V(\phi)$, it is possible to choose this function in order to produce a given expansion history of the universe characterized by the function $H(a)=\dot a/a$ expressed in terms of $a$. To see this explicitly, let us assume that the universe has two forms of energy density with $\rho(a) =\rho_{\rm known} (a) + \rho_\phi(a)$ where $\rho_{\rm known}(a)$ arises from any known forms of source (matter, radiation, ...) and $\rho_\phi(a) $ is due to a scalar field. Let us first consider quintessence. Here, the potential is given implicitly by the form \cite{ellis,tptachyon} \begin{equation} V(a) = \frac{1}{16\pi G} H (1-Q)\left[6H + 2aH' - \frac{aH Q'}{1-Q}\right] \label{voft} \end{equation} \begin{equation} \phi (a) = \left[ \frac{1}{8\pi G}\right]^{1/2} \int \frac{da}{a} \left[ aQ' - (1-Q)\frac{d \ln H^2}{d\ln a}\right]^{1/2} \label{phioft} \end{equation} where $Q (a) \equiv [8\pi G \rho_{\rm known}(a) / 3H^2(a)]$ and prime denotes differentiation with respect to $a$. Given any $H(a),Q(a)$, these equations determine $V(a)$ and $\phi(a)$ and thus the potential $V(\phi)$. \textit{Every quintessence model studied in the literature can be obtained from these equations.} Similar results exists for the tachyonic scalar field as well \cite{tptachyon}. For example, given any $H(a)$, one can construct a tachyonic potential $V(\phi)$ so that the scalar field is the source for the cosmology. The equations determining $V(\phi)$ are now given by: \begin{equation} \phi(a) = \int \frac{da}{aH} \left(\frac{aQ'}{3(1-Q)} -{2\over 3}{a H'\over H}\right)^{1/2} \label{finalone} \end{equation} \begin{equation} V(a) = {3H^2 \over 8\pi G}(1-Q) \left( 1 + {2\over 3}{a H'\over H}-\frac{aQ'}{3(1-Q)}\right)^{1/2} \label{finaltwo} \end{equation} Equations (\ref{finalone}) and (\ref{finaltwo}) completely solve the problem. Given any $H(a)$, these equations determine $V(a)$ and $\phi(a)$ and thus the potential $V(\phi)$. A wide variety of phenomenological models with time dependent cosmological constant\ have been considered in the literature; all of these can be mapped to a scalar field model with a suitable $V(\phi)$. While the scalar field models enjoy considerable popularity (one reason being they are easy to construct!) it is very doubtful whether they have helped us to understand the nature of the dark energy at any deeper level. These models, viewed objectively, suffer from several shortcomings: \begin{figure}[ht] \includegraphics[scale=0.5]{fig1.ps} \caption{ The observational constraints on the variation of dark energy density as a function of redshift from WMAP and SNLS data (see \cite{jbp}). The green/hatched region is excluded at $68\%$ confidence limit, red/cross-hatched region at $95\%$ confidence level and the blue/solid region at $99\%$ confidence limit. The white region shows the allowed range of variation of dark energy at $68\%$ confidence limit. } \label{fig:bjp2ps} \end{figure} \begin{itemize} \item They have no predictive power. As explicitly demonstrated above, virtually every form of $a(t)$ can be modeled by a suitable ``designer" $V(\phi)$. \item These models are degenerate in another sense. The previous discussion illustrates that even when $w(a)$ is known/specified, it is not possible to proceed further and determine the nature of the scalar field Lagrangian. The explicit examples given above show that there are {\em at least} two different forms of scalar field Lagrangians --- corresponding to the quintessence or the tachyonic field --- which could lead to the same $w(a)$. (See the first paper in ref.\cite{tptirthsn1} for an explicit example of such a construction.) \item By and large, the potentials used in the literature have no natural field theoretical justification. All of them are non-renormalisable in the conventional sense and have to be interpreted as a low energy effective potential in an ad hoc manner. \item One key difference between cosmological constant\ and scalar field models is that the latter lead to a $w(a)$ which varies with time. If observations have demanded this, or even if observations have ruled out $w=-1$ at the present epoch, then one would have been forced to take alternative models seriously. However, all available observations are consistent with cosmological constant\ ($w=-1$) and --- in fact --- the possible variation of $w$ is strongly constrained \cite{jbp} as shown in Figure \ref{fig:bjp2ps}. \item While on the topic of observational constraints on $w(t)$, the following point needs to be stressed: One should be careful about the hidden assumptions in the statistical analysis of these data. Claims regarding the value of $w$ depends crucially on the data sets used, priors which are assumed and possible parameterizations which are adopted. (For more details related to these issues, see the last reference in \cite{jbp}.) It is fair to say that all currently available data is consistent with $w=-1$. Further, there is some amount of tension between WMAP and SN-Gold data with the recent SNLS data \cite{snls} being more concordant with WMAP than the SN Gold data. \item The most serious problem with the scalar field models is the following: All the scalar field potentials require fine tuning of the parameters in order to be viable. This is obvious in the quintessence models in which adding a constant to the potential is the same as invoking a cosmological constant. So to make the quintessence models work, \textit{we first need to assume the cosmological constant\ is zero.} These models, therefore, merely push the cosmological constant problem to another level, making it somebody else's problem!. \end{itemize} The last point makes clear that if we shift $\mathcal{L}\to \mathcal{L}_{\rm matt} - 2\lambda_m$ in an otherwise successful scalar field model for dark energy, we end up `switching on' the cosmological constant and raising the problems again. It is therefore important to address this issue, which we will discuss in Part 3. Given this situation, we shall first take a more serious look at the cosmological constant\ as the source of dark energy in the universe. \section{Aspects of the Cosmological Constant} \subsection{Facing up to the Challenge} The observational and theoretical features described above suggests that one should consider cosmological constant\ as the most natural candidate for dark energy. Though it leads to well known problems, it is also the most economical [just one number] and simplest explanation for all the observations. Once we invoke the cosmological constant, classical gravity will be described by the three constants $G,c$ and $\Lambda\equiv L_\Lambda^{-2}$. Since $\Lambda(G\hbar/c^3)\equiv (L_P/L_\Lambda)^2\approx 10^{-123}$, it is obvious that the cosmological constant\ is telling us something regarding \textit{quantum gravity}, indicated by the combination $G\hbar$. \textit{An acid test for any quantum gravity model will be its ability to explain this value;} needless to say, all the currently available models --- strings, loops etc. --- flunk this test. Even assuming that this is more of an issue in semiclassical gravity rather than quantum gravity, one cannot help noticing that several different approaches to semiclassical gravity \cite{semicgrav} are silent about cosmological constant. In terms of the energy scales, the cosmological constant\ problem is an infra red problem \textit{par excellence}. At the same time, the occurrence of $\hbar$ in $\Lambda(G\hbar/c^3)$ shows that it is a relic of a quantum gravitational effect (or principle) of unknown nature. One is envisaging here a somewhat unusual possibility of a high energy phenomenon leaving a low energy relic and an analogy will be helpful to illustrate this idea \cite{choices}. Suppose we solve the Schrodinger equation for the Helium atom for the quantum states of the two electrons $\psi(x_1,x_2)$. When the result is compared with observations, we will find that only half the states --- those in which $\psi(x_1,x_2)$ is antisymmetric under $x_1\longleftrightarrow x_2$ interchange --- are realized in nature. But the low energy Hamiltonian for electrons in the Helium atom has no information about this effect! Here is a low energy (IR) effect which is a relic of relativistic quantum field theory (spin-statistics theorem) that is totally non perturbative, in the sense that writing corrections to the Hamiltonian of the Helium atom in some $(1/c)$ expansion will {\it not} reproduce this result. I suspect the current value of cosmological constant\ is related to quantum gravity in a similar spirit. There must exist a deep principle in quantum gravity which leaves its non-perturbative trace even in the low energy limit that appears as the cosmological constant. \subsubsection{Cosmology with two length scales} Given the two length scales $L_P$ and $L_\Lambda$, one can construct two energy scales $\rho_{_{\rm UV}}=1/L_P^4$ and $\rho_{_{\rm IR}}=1/L_\Lambda^4$ in natural units ($c=\hbar=1$). There is sufficient amount of justification from different theoretical perspectives to treat $L_P$ as the zero point length of spacetime \cite{zeropoint}, giving a natural interpretation to $\rho_{_{\rm UV}}$. The second one, $\rho_{_{\rm IR}}$ also has a natural interpretation. Since the universe dominated by a cosmological constant\ at late times will be asymptotically DeSitter with $a(t)\propto \exp (t/L_\Lambda) $ at late times, it will have a horizon and associated thermodynamics \cite{ghds} with a temperature $T=H_\Lambda/2\pi$. The corresponding thermal energy density is $\rho_{thermal}\propto T^4\propto 1/L_\Lambda^4= \rho_{_{\rm IR}}$. Thus $L_P$ determines the \textit{highest} possible energy density in the universe while $L_\Lambda$ determines the {\it lowest} possible energy density in this universe. As the energy density of normal matter drops below this value, $\rho_{IR}$, the thermal ambience of the DeSitter phase will remain constant and provide the irreducible `vacuum noise'. The observed dark energy density is the the geometric mean \begin{equation} \rho_{_{\rm DE}}=\sqrt{\rho_{_{\rm IR}}\rho_{_{\rm UV}}}=\frac{1}{L_P^2L_\Lambda^2} \label{geomean} \end{equation} of these two energy densities. If we define a dark energy length scale $L_{DE}$ such that $\rho_{_{\rm DE}}=1/L_{DE}^4$ then $L_{DE}=\sqrt{L_PL_\Lambda}$ is the geometric mean of the two length scales in the universe \cite{note1}. \begin{figure}[!] \begin{center} \includegraphics[angle=-90,scale=0.5]{fig2} \end{center} \caption{The geometrical structure of a universe with two length scales $L_P$ and $L_\Lambda$ corresponding to the Planck length and the cosmological constant \cite{plumian,bjorken}. Such a universe spends most of its time in two DeSitter phases which are (approximately) time translation invariant. The first DeSitter phase corresponds to the inflation and the second corresponds to the accelerated expansion arising from the cosmological constant. Most of the perturbations generated during the inflation will leave the Hubble radius (at some A, say) and re-enter (at B). However, perturbations which exit the Hubble radius earlier than C will never re-enter the Hubble radius, thereby introducing a specific dynamic range CE during the inflationary phase. The epoch F is characterized by the redshifted CMB temperature becoming equal to the DeSitter temperature $(H_\Lambda / 2\pi)$ which introduces another dynamic range DF in the accelerated expansion after which the universe is dominated by vacuum noise of the DeSitter spacetime.} \label{fig:tpplumian} \end{figure} Figure \ref{fig:tpplumian} describes some peculiar features in such a universe \cite{plumian,bjorken}. Using the characteristic length scale of expansion, the Hubble radius $d_H\equiv (\dot a/a)^{-1}$, we can distinguish between three different phases of such a universe. The first phase is when the universe went through a inflationary expansion with $d_H=$ constant; the second phase is the radiation/matter dominated phase in which most of the standard cosmology operates and $d_H$ increases monotonically; the third phase is that of re-inflation (or accelerated expansion) governed by the cosmological constant in which $d_H$ is again a constant. The first and last phases are time translation invariant; that is, $t\to t+$ constant is an (approximate) invariance for the universe in these two phases. The universe satisfies the perfect cosmological principle and is in steady state during these phases! In the most natural scenario, the two DeSitter phases (first and last) can be of arbitrarily long duration \cite{plumian}. If $\Omega_\Lambda\approx 0.7, \Omega_{DM}\approx 0.3$ the final DeSitter phase \textit{does} last forever; as regards the inflationary phase, nothing prevents it from lasting for arbitrarily long duration. Viewed from this perspective, the in between phase --- in which most of the `interesting' cosmological phenomena occur --- is of negligible measure in the span of time. It merely connects two steady state phases of the universe. The figure \ref{fig:tpplumian} also shows the variation of $L_{DE}$ by broken horizontal lines. While the two DeSitter phases can last forever in principle, there is a natural cut off length scale in both of them which makes the region of physical relevance to be finite \cite{plumian}. Let us first discuss the case of re-inflation in the late universe. As the universe grows exponentially in the phase 3, the wavelength of CMBR photons are being redshifted rapidly. When the temperature of the CMBR radiation drops below the DeSitter temperature (which happens when the wavelength of the typical CMBR photon is stretched to the $L_\Lambda$.) the universe will be essentially dominated by the vacuum thermal noise of the DeSitter phase. This happens at the point marked F when the expansion factor is $a=a_F$ determined by the equation $T_0 (a_0/a_{F}) = (1/2\pi L_\Lambda)$. Let $a=a_\Lambda$ be the epoch at which cosmological constant started dominating over matter, so that $(a_\Lambda/a_0)^3= (\Omega_{DM}/\Omega_\Lambda)$. Then we find that the dynamic range of DF is \begin{equation} \frac{a_F}{a_\Lambda} = 2\pi T_0 L_\Lambda \left( \frac{\Omega_\Lambda}{\Omega_{DM}}\right)^{1/3} \approx 3\times 10^{30} \end{equation} One can also impose a similar bound on the physically relevant duration of inflation. We know that the quantum fluctuations generated during this inflationary phase could act as seeds of structure formation in the universe \cite{genofpert}. Consider a perturbation at some given wavelength scale which is stretched with the expansion of the universe as $\lambda\propto a(t)$. (See the line marked AB in Figure \ref{fig:tpplumian}.) During the inflationary phase, the Hubble radius remains constant while the wavelength increases, so that the perturbation will `exit' the Hubble radius at some time (the point A in Figure \ref{fig:tpplumian}). In the radiation dominated phase, the Hubble radius $d_H\propto t\propto a^2$ grows faster than the wavelength $ \lambda\propto a(t)$. Hence, normally, the perturbation will `re-enter' the Hubble radius at some time (the point B in Figure \ref{fig:tpplumian}). If there was no re-inflation, this will make {\it all} wavelengths re-enter the Hubble radius sooner or later. But if the universe undergoes re-inflation, then the Hubble radius `flattens out' at late times and some of the perturbations will {\it never} reenter the Hubble radius. The limiting perturbation which just `grazes' the Hubble radius as the universe enters the re-inflationary phase is shown by the line marked CD in Figure \ref{fig:tpplumian}. If we use the criterion that we need the perturbation to reenter the Hubble radius, we get a natural bound on the duration of inflation which is of direct astrophysical relevance. This portion of the inflationary regime is marked by CE and its dynamic range can be calculated to be: \begin{equation} \frab{a_{\rm end} }{a_i} = \left( \frac{T_0 L_\Lambda}{T_{\rm reheat} H_{in}^{-1}}\right) \left( \frac{\Omega_\Lambda}{\Omega_{DM}}\right)^{1/3}= \frab{a_F}{a_\Lambda}(2\pi T_{\rm reheat} H_{in}^{-1})^{-1} \cong 10^{25} \end{equation} for a GUTs scale inflation with $E_{GUT}=10^{14} GeV,T_{\rm reheat}=E_{GUT},\rho_{in}=E_{GUT}^4$ we have $2\pi H^{-1}_{in}T_{\rm reheat}\approx 10^5$. If we consider a quantum gravitational, Planck scale, inflation with $2\pi H_{in}^{-1} T_{\rm reheat} = \mathcal{O} (1)$, the phases CE and DF are approximately equal. The region in the quadrilateral CEDF is the most relevant part of standard cosmology, though the evolution of the universe can extend to arbitrarily large stretches in both directions in time. This figure is telling us something regarding the duality between Planck scale and Hubble scale or between the infrared and ultraviolet limits of the theory and is closely related to the fact that $\rho_{DE}^2=\rho_{UV}\rho_{IR}$. \subsubsection{Area scaling for energy fluctuations}\label{sec:ccnatural} The the geometrical mean relation described above can also be presented in a different manner which allows us to learn something significant. Consider a 3-dimensional region of size $L$ with a bounding area which scales as $L^2$. Let us assume that we associate with this region $N$ microscopic cells of size $L_P$ each having a Poissonian fluctuation in energy of amount $E_P\approx 1/L_P$. Then the mean square fluctuation of energy in this region will be $(\Delta E)^2\approx NL_P^{-2}$ corresponding to the energy density $\rho=\Delta E/L^3=\sqrt{N}/L_PL^3$. If we make the usual assumption that $N=N_{vol}\approx (L/L_P)^3$, this will give \begin{equation} \rho=\frac{\sqrt{N_{vol}}}{L_PL^3}=\frac{1}{L_P^4}\frab{L_P}{L}^{3/2} \quad \text {(bulk\ fluctuations)} \end{equation} On the other hand, if we assume that (for reasons which are unknown), the relevant degrees of freedom scale as the surface area of the region, then $N=N_{sur}\approx (L/L_P)^2$ and the relevant energy density is \begin{equation} \rho=\frac{\sqrt{N_{sur}}}{L_PL^3}=\frac{1}{L_P^4}\frab{L_P}{L}^2=\frac{1}{L_P^2L^2} \quad \text {(surface\ fluctuations)} \label{sur} \end{equation} If we take $L\approx L_\Lambda$, the surface fluctuations in \eq{sur} give precisely the geometric mean in \eq{geomean} which is observed. On the other hand, the bulk \textit{fluctuations} lead to an energy density which is larger by a factor $(L/L_P)^{1/2}$. Of course, if we do not take fluctuations in energy but coherently add them, we will get $N/L_PL^3$ which is $1/L_P^4$ for the bulk and $(1/L_P)^4(L_P/L)$ for the surface. In summary, we have the hierarchy: \begin{equation} \rho=\frac{1}{L_P^4}\times \left[1,\frab{L_P}{L}, \frab{L_P}{L}^{3/2}, \frab{L_P}{L}^2, \frab{L_P}{L}^4 .....\right] \end{equation} in which the first one arises by coherently adding energies $(1/L_P)$ per cell with $N_{vol}=(L/L_P)^3$ cells; the second arises from coherently adding energies $(1/L_P)$ per cell with $N_{sur}=(L/L_P)^2$ cells; the third one is obtained by taking \textit{fluctuations} in energy and using $N_{vol}$ cells; the fourth from energy fluctuations with $N_{sur}$ cells; and finally the last one is the thermal energy of the DeSitter space if we take $L\approx L_\Lambda$ and clearly the further terms are irrelevant due to this vacuum noise. Of all these, the only viable possibility is the one that is obtained if we assume that \begin{itemize} \item The number of active degrees of freedom in a region of size $L$ scales as $N_{sur}=(L/L_P)^2$. \item It is the \textit{fluctuations} in the energy that contributes to the cosmological constant \cite{cc1,cc2} and the bulk energy does not gravitate. \end{itemize} Recently, it has been shown --- in a series of papers, see ref.\cite{tpholo} --- that it is possible to obtain classical relativity from purely thermodynamic considerations in which the surface term of the gravitational actions play a crucial role. The area scaling is familiar from the usual result that entropy of horizons scale as area. In fact, one can argue from general considerations that the entropy associated with \textit{any} null surface should be $(1/4)$ per unit area and will be observer dependent. Further, in cases like Schwarzschild black hole, one cannot even properly define the volume inside a horizon. A null surface, obtained as a limit of a sequence of timelike surfaces (like the $r=2M$ obtained from $r=2M+k$ surfaces with $k\to 0^+$), `loses' one dimension in the process (e.g., $r=2M+k$ is 3-dimensional and timelike for $k>0$ but is 2-dimensional and null for $k=0$) suggesting that the scaling of degrees of freedom has to change appropriately. It is difficult to imagine that these features are unconnected and accidental and we will discuss these ideas further in Part 3. \subsection{Attempts on the life of $\Lambda$} Let us now turn our attention to few of the many attempts to understand the cosmological constant\ with the choice dictated by personal bias. A host of other approaches exist in literature, some of which can be found in \cite{catchall}. \subsubsection{Conservative explanations of dark energy} One of the \textit{least} esoteric ideas regarding the dark energy is that the cosmological constant term in the FRW equations arises because we have not calculated the energy density driving the expansion of the universe correctly. The motivation for such a suggestion arises from the following fact: The energy momentum tensor of the real universe, $T_{ab}(t,{\bf x})$ is inhomogeneous and anisotropic and will lead to a complicated metric $g_{ab}$ if only we could solve the exact Einstein's equations $G_{ab}[g]=\kappa T_{ab}$. The metric describing the large scale structure of the universe should be obtained by averaging this exact solution over a large enough scale, to get $\langle g_{ab}\rangle $. But what we actually do is to average the stress tensor {\it first} to get $\langle T_{ab}\rangle $ and {\it then} solve Einstein's equations. But since $G_{ab}[g]$ is nonlinear function of the metric, $\langle G_{ab}[g]\rangle \neq G_{ab}[\langle g\rangle ]$ and there is a discrepancy. This is most easily seen by writing \begin{equation} G_{ab}[\langle g\rangle ]=\kappa [\langle T_{ab}\rangle + \kappa^{-1}(G_{ab}[\langle g\rangle ]-\langle G_{ab}[g]\rangle )]\equiv \kappa [\langle T_{ab}\rangle + T_{ab}^{corr}] \end{equation} If --- based on observations --- we take the $\langle g_{ab}\rangle $ to be the standard Friedman metric, this equation shows that it has, as its source, \textit{two} terms: The first is the standard average stress tensor and the second is a purely geometrical correction term $T_{ab}^{corr}=\kappa^{-1}(G_{ab}[\langle g\rangle ]-\langle G_{ab}[g]\rangle )$ which arises because of nonlinearities in the Einstein's theory that leads to $\langle G_{ab}[g]\rangle \neq G_{ab}[\langle g\rangle ]$. If this term can mimic the cosmological constant\ at large scales there will be no need for dark energy and --- as a bonus --- one will solve the coincidence problem! The approach requires us to identify an effective expansion factor $a_{eff}(t)$ of an inhomogeneous universe after suitable averaging, to be sourced by terms which will lead to $\ddot a_{eff}(t)>0$ while the standard matter [with $(\rho + 3p)>0$] leads to deceleration of standard expansion factor $a(t)$. Since correct averaging of positive quantities in $(\rho + 3p)$ will not lead to a negative quantity, the real hope is in defining $a_{eff}(t)$ and obtaining its dynamical equation such that $\ddot a_{eff}(t)>0$. In spite of some recent attention this idea has received \cite{flucde} it is doubtful whether it will lead to the correct result when implemented properly. The reasons for my skepticism are the following: \begin{itemize} \item Any calculation in linear theory or any calculation in which special symmetries are invoked are inconclusive in settling the issue. The key question, of identifying a suitable analogue of expansion factor from an averaged geometry, is nontrivial and it is not clear that the answer will be unique. To stress the point by an extreme (and a bit silly) example, suppose we decide to call $a(t)^n$ with, say $n>2$ as the effective expansion factor $a_{eff}(t)=a(t)^n$; obviously $\ddot a_{eff}$ can be positive (`accelerating universe') even with $\ddot a$ being negative. So, unless one has a \textit{unique} procedure to identify the expansion factor of the average universe, it is difficult to settle the issue. \item It is obvious that $T_{ab}^{corr}$ is non-zero (for an explicit example, in a completely different context of electromagnetic plane wave, see \cite{gofemw}); the question that needs to be settled is how big is it compared to $T_{ab}$. It seems unlikely that when properly done, we will get a large effect for the simple reason that the amount of mass which is contained in the nonlinear regimes in the universe today is subdominant. \item This approach is too strongly linked to explaining the acceleration as observed by SN. Even if we decide to completely ignore all SN data, we still have reasonable evidence for dark energy and it is not clear how this approach can tackle such evidence. \end{itemize} Another equally conservative explanation of the cosmic acceleration will be that we are located in a large underdense region in the universe; so that, locally, the underdensity acts like negative mass and produces a repulsive force. While there has been some discussion in the literature \cite{Hbubble} as to whether observations indicate such a local `Hubble bubble', this does not seem to be a tenable explanation that one can take seriously at this stage. Again, CMBR observations indicating dark energy, for example, will not be directly affected by this feature though one does need to take into account the effect of the local void. Finally, one should not forget that a \textit{vanishing} cosmological constant\ is still a problem that needs an explanation. So even if all the evidence for dark energy disappears within a decade, we still need to understand why cosmological constant\ is zero and much of what I have to say in the sequel will remain relevant. I stress this because there is a recent tendency to forget the fact that the problem of the cosmological constant\ existed (and was recognized as a problem) long before the observational evidence for dark energy, accelerating universe etc cropped up. In this sense, cosmological constant\ problem has an important theoretical dimension which is distinct from what has been introduced by the observational evidence for dark energy. \subsubsection{Cosmic Lenz law} The second simplest possibility which has been attempted in the literature several times in different guises is to try and ''cancel out'' the cosmological constant\ by some process, usually quantum mechanical in origin. One can, for example, ask whether switching on a cosmological constant\ will lead to a vacuum polarization with an effective energy momentum tensor that will tend to cancel out the cosmological constant. A less subtle way of doing this is to invoke another scalar field (here we go again!) such that it can couple to cosmological constant\ and reduce its effective value \cite{lenz}. Unfortunately, none of this could be made to work properly. By and large, these approaches lead to an energy density which is either $\rho_{_{\rm UV}}\propto L_P^{-4}$ or to $\rho_{_{\rm IR}}\propto L_\Lambda^{-4}$. The first one is too large while the second one is too small! \subsubsection{Unimodular Gravity} One possible way of addressing the issue of cosmological constant\ is to simply eliminate from the gravitational theory those modes which couple to cosmological constant. If, for example, we have a theory in which the source in Eq. (\ref{nextnine}) is $(\rho +p)$ rather than $(\rho +3p)$, then cosmological constant\ will not couple to gravity at all. Unfortunately it is not possible to develop a covariant theory of gravity using $(\rho +p)$ as the source. But we can probably gain some insight from the following considerations. Any metric $g_{ab}$ can be expressed in the form $g_{ab}=f^2(x)q_{ab}$ such that ${\rm det}\, q=1$ so that ${\rm det}\, g=f^4$. From the action functional for gravity \begin{equation} A=\frac{1}{16\pi G}\int \sqrt{-g}\, d^4x\, (R -2\Lambda) =\frac{1}{16\pi G}\int \sqrt{-g} \, d^4x\, R -\frac{\Lambda}{8\pi G}\int d^4x f^4(x) \label{oneone} \end{equation} it is obvious that the cosmological constant\ couples {\it only} to the conformal factor $f$. So if we consider a theory of gravity in which $f^4=\sqrt{-g}$ is kept constant and only $q_{ab}$ is varied, then such a model will be oblivious of direct coupling to cosmological constant. If the action (without the $\Lambda$ term) is varied, keeping ${\rm det}\, g=-1$, say, then one is lead to a {\it unimodular theory of gravity} that has the equations of motion \begin{equation} R_{ab}-(1/4)g_{ab}R=\kappa(T_{ab}-(1/4)g_{ab}T) \label{tracefree} \end{equation} with zero trace on both sides. Using the Bianchi identity, it is now easy to show that this is equivalent to the usual theory with an {\it arbitrary} cosmological constant. That is, cosmological constant\ arises as an undetermined integration constant in this model \cite{unimod}. While this is all very interesting, we still need an extra physical principle to fix the value (even the sign) of cosmological constant\ . One possible way of doing this, suggested by \eq{oneone}, is to interpret the $\Lambda$ term in the action as a Lagrange multiplier for the proper volume of the spacetime. Then it is reasonable to choose the cosmological constant\ such that the total proper volume of the universe is equal to a specified number. While this will lead to a cosmological constant\ which has the correct order of magnitude, it has an obvious problem because the proper four volume of the universe is infinite unless we make the spatial sections compact and restrict the range of time integration. Amongst all approaches, this one has some valuable ingredients for a solution to the cosmological constant\ problem because it directly eliminates the coupling between gravity and bulk cosmological constant. But it needs to be remodelled considerably to be made viable. We will discuss in the next section how this can be done in a completely different approach to gravity which holds promise. \section{Gravity as an emergent phenomenon and the cosmological constant} \subsection{The necessary ingredients of a new perspective} In conventional approach to gravity, one derives the equations of motion from a Lagrangian $\mathcal{L}_{\rm tot} = \mathcal{L}_{\rm grav}(g) + \mathcal{L}_{\rm matt}(g,\phi)$ where $\mathcal{L}_{\rm grav}$ is the gravitational Lagrangian dependent on the metric and its derivative and $\mathcal{L}_{\rm matt}$ is the matter Lagrangian which depends on both the metric and the matter fields, symbolically denoted as $\phi$. This total Lagrangian is integrated over the spacetime volume with the covariant measure $\sqrt{-g} d^4x$ to obtain the action. In such an approach, the cosmological constant can be introduced via two different routes which are conceptually different but operationally the same. First, one may decide to take the gravitational Lagrangian to be $\mathcal{L}_{\rm grav} =(2\kappa)^{-1}(R-2\Lambda_g)$ where $\Lambda_g$ is a parameter in the (low energy effective) action just like the Newtonian gravitational constant $\kappa$. This is equivalent to assuming that, even in the absence of matter, flat spacetime is \textit{not} a solution to the field equations. The second route through which the cosmological constant can be introduced is by shifting the matter Lagrangian by $\mathcal{L}_{\rm matt}\to \mathcal{L}_{\rm matt} - 2\lambda_m$. The equations of motion for matter are invariant under such a transformation which implies that --- in the absence of gravity --- we cannot determine the value of $\lambda_m$. But such a shift is clearly equivalent to adding a cosmological constant $2\kappa\lambda_m$ to the $\mathcal{L}_{\rm grav}$. In general, what can be observed through gravitational interaction is the combination $\Lambda_{\rm tot} = \Lambda_g + 2\kappa\lambda_m$. It is clear that there are two distinct aspects to the so called cosmological constant problem. The first question is why $\Lambda_{\rm tot} $ is very small when expressed in natural units. Second, since $\Lambda_{\rm tot}$ could have had two separate contributions from the gravitational and matter sectors, why does the \textit{sum} remain so fine tuned? This question is particularly relevant because it is believed that our universe went through several phase transitions in the course of its evolution, each of which shifts the energy momentum tensor of matter by $T^a_b\to T^a_b+L^{-4}\delta^a_b$ where $L$ is the scale characterizing the transition. For example, the GUT and Weak Interaction scales are about $L_{GUT}\approx 10^{-29}$ cm, $L_{SW}\approx 10^{-16}$ cm respectively which are tiny compared to $L_{\Lambda}$. Even if we take a more pragmatic approach, the observation of Casimir effect in the lab sets a bound that $L<\mathcal{O}(1)$ nanometer, leading to a $\rho$ which is about $10^{12}$ times the observed value \cite{gaurang}. Given all these, it seems reasonable to assume that gravity is quite successful in ignoring most of the energy density in the vacuum. The transformation $\mathcal{L}\to \mathcal{L}_{\rm matt} - 2\lambda_m$ is a symmetry of the matter sector (at least at scales below the scale of supersymmetry breaking; we shall ignore supersymmetry in what follows). The matter equations of motion do not care about constant $\lambda_m$. In the conventional approach, gravity breaks this symmetry. \textit{This is the root cause of the so called cosmological constant problem.} As long as gravitational field equations are of the form $E_{ab} = \kappa T_{ab}$ where $E_{ab}$ is some geometrical quantity (which is $G_{ab}$ in Einstein's theory) the theory cannot be invariant under the shifts of the form $T^a_b \to T^a_b +\rho \delta^a_b$. Since such shifts are allowed by the matter sector, it is very difficult to imagine a definitive solution to cosmological constant problem within the conventional approach to gravity. If metric represents the gravitational degree of freedom that is varied in the action and we demand full general covariance (unlike in the unimodular theory of gravity), we cannot avoid $\mathcal{L}_{matter}\sqrt{-g}$ coupling and cannot obtain of the equations of motion which are invariant under the shift $T_{ab}\to T_{ab}+\Lambda g_{ab}$. Clearly a new, drastically different, approach to gravity is required. Even if we manage to obtain a theory in which gravitational action is invariant under the shift $T_{ab}\to T_{ab}+\Lambda g_{ab}$, we would have only succeeded in making gravity is decouple from the bulk vacuum energy. While this is considerable progress, there still remains the second issue of explaining the observed value of the cosmological constant. Once the bulk value of the cosmological constant\ (or vacuum energy) decouples from gravity, classical gravity becomes immune to cosmological constant; that is, the bulk classical cosmological constant\ can be gauged away. Any observed value of the cosmological constant\ has to be necessarily a quantum phenomenon arising as a relic of microscopic spacetime fluctuations. This is a nontrivial issue to address at least for two reasons: First, even the structure of \textit{matter} vacuum in the presence of nontrivial metric is far from simple; for example, it is well known that the vacuum state depends on the class of observers we are considering \cite{probe} and it is not clear whether this aspect has any fundamental significance. Second, and more important, we have no clue as to what is the substructure from which the spacetime arises as an excitation. The concept of gravitons is fairly useless \cite{gravitonmyth} in providing an answer to this --- inherently non-perturbative --- question. Nevertheless, in an approach in which the surface degrees of freedom play the dominant role, rather than bulk degrees of freedom, we have a hope for obtaining the correct value for the cosmological constant. We have already seen that, in this case one obtains the correct result if the relevant degrees of freedom are scales as the surface area of a region rather as volume. Hence, to be considered plausible, any model should single out surface degrees of freedom in some suitable manner. To summarise the above discussion, we are looking for an approach which has the following ingredients \cite{gr06}: \begin{itemize} \item The field equations must remain invariant under the shift $\mathcal{L}_{matt}\to \mathcal{L}_{matt}+\lambda_m$ of the matter Lagrangian $\mathcal{L}_{matt}$ by a constant $\lambda_m$. That is, we need to have some kind of `gauge freedom' to absorb any $\lambda_m$. Once we have succeeded in decoupling gravity from bulk vacuum energy, we have won more than half the battle. \item General covariance requires using the integration measure $\sqrt{-g}d^Dx$ in actions. Since we do not want to restrict general covariance but at the same time do not want this coupling to metric tensor via $\sqrt{-g}$, it follows that \textit{metric cannot be the dynamical variable in our theory.} \item The discussion in section \ref{sec:ccnatural}, especially Eq.~(\ref{sur}), shows that the relevant degrees of freedom should be linked to surfaces in spacetime rather than bulk regions. This is important because --- after we eliminate the coupling between the bulk cosmological constant\ and gravity --- we still need to address the observed value of cosmological constant. This is a relic of quantum gravitational physics and should arise from degrees of freedom which scale as the surface area. \item In such a approach, one should naturally obtain a theory of gravity which is more general than Einstein's theory with the latter emerging as a low energy approximation. \end{itemize} We will now describe how this can be achieved in a model in which gravity arises as an emergent phenomenon like elasticity. \subsection{Micro-structure of the spacetime} For reasons described above, we abandon the usual picture of treating the metric as the fundamental dynamical degrees of freedom of the theory and treat it as providing a coarse grained description of the spacetime at macroscopic scales, somewhat like the density of a solid --- which has no meaning at atomic scales \cite{elastic}. The unknown, microscopic degrees of freedom of spacetime (which should be analogous to the atoms in the case of solids), will play a role only when spacetime is probed at Planck scales (which would be analogous to the lattice spacing of a solid \cite{zeropoint}). Moreover, in the study of ordinary solids, one can distinguish between three levels of description. At the macroscopic level, we have the theory of elasticity which has a life of its own and can be developed purely phenomenologically. At the other extreme, the microscopic description of a solid will be in terms of the statistical mechanics of a lattice of atoms and their interaction. Both of these are well known; but interpolating between these two limits is the thermodynamic description of a solid at finite temperature \textit{which provides a crucial window into the existence of the corpuscular substructure of solids.} As Boltzmann taught us, heat is a form of motion and we will not have the thermodynamic layer of description if matter is a continuum all the way to the finest scales and atoms did not exist! \textit{The mere existence of a thermodynamic layer in the description is proof enough that there are microscopic degrees of freedom. } Move on from a solid to the spacetime. Again we should have three levels of description. The macroscopic level is the smooth spacetime continuum with a metric tensor $g_{ab}(x^i)$ and the equations governing the metric have the same status as the phenomenological equations of elasticity. At the microscopic level, we expect a quantum description in terms of the `atoms of spacetime' and some associated degrees of freedom $q_A$ which are still elusive. But what is crucial is the existence of an interpolating layer of thermal phenomenon associated with null surfaces in the spacetime. Just as a solid cannot exhibit thermal phenomenon if it does not have microstructure, \textit{thermal nature of horizon, for example, cannot arise without the spacetime having a microstructure. } In such a picture, we normally expect the microscopic structure of spacetime to manifest itself only at Planck scales or near singularities of the classical theory. However, in a manner which is not fully understood, the horizons --- which block information from certain classes of observers --- link \cite{magglass} certain aspects of microscopic physics with the bulk dynamics, just as thermodynamics can provide a link between statistical mechanics and (zero temperature) dynamics of a solid. The reason is probably related to the fact that horizons lead to infinite redshift, which probes \textit{virtual} high energy processes; it is, however, difficult to establish this claim in mathematical terms. The above paradigm, in which the gravity is an emergent phenomenon, is anchored on a fundamental relationship between the dynamics of gravity and thermodynamics of horizons \cite{paddy1} and the following three results are strongly supportive of the above point of view: \begin{itemize} \item There is a deep connection between the dynamical equations governing the metric and the thermodynamics of horizons. An explicit example was provided in ref. \cite{paddy2}, in the case of spherically symmetric horizons in four dimensions in which it was shown that, Einstein's equations can be interpreted as a thermodynamic relation $TdS=dE+PdV$ arising out of virtual radial displacements of the horizon. Further work showed that this result is valid in \textit{all} the cases for which explicit computation can be carried out --- like in the Friedmann models \cite{rongencai} as well as for rotating and time dependent horizons in Einstein's theory \cite{dawood-sudipta-tp}. \item The Hilbert Lagrangian has the structure $\mathcal{L}_{EH}\propto R\sim (\partial g)^2+ {\partial^2g}$. In the usual approach the surface term arising from $\mathcal{L}_{sur}\propto \partial^2g$ has to be ignored or canceled to get Einstein's equations from $\mathcal{L}_{bulk}\propto (\partial g)^2$. But there is a peculiar (unexplained) relationship between $\mathcal{L}_{bulk}$ and $\mathcal{L}_{sur}$: \begin{equation} \sqrt{-g}\mathcal{L}_{sur}=-\partial_a\left(g_{ij} \frac{\partial \sqrt{-g}\mathcal{L}_{bulk}}{\partial(\partial_ag_{ij})}\right) \end{equation} This shows that the gravitational action is `holographic' with the same information being coded in both the bulk and surface terms and one of them is sufficient. One can indeed obtain Einstein's equations from an action principle which uses \textit{only} the surface term and the virtual displacements of horizons \cite{paris,gr06}. Since the surface term has the thermodynamic interpretation as the entropy of horizons, this establishes a direct connection between spacetime dynamics and horizon thermodynamics. \item Most importantly, recent work has shown that \textit{all the above results extend far beyond Einstein's theory.} The connection between field equations and the thermodynamic relation $TdS=dE+PdV$ is not restricted to Einstein's theory alone, but is in fact true for the case of the generalized, higher derivative Lanczos-Lovelock gravitational theory in $D$ dimensions as well \cite{aseem-sudipta, cai2}. The same is true \cite{ayan} for the holographic structure of the action functional: the Lanczos-Lovelock action has the same structure and --- again --- the entropy of the horizons is related to the surface term of the action. \textit{These results show that the thermodynamic description is far more general than just Einstein's theory} and occurs in a wide class of theories in which the metric determines the structure of the light cones and null surfaces exist blocking the information. \end{itemize} The conventional approach to gravity fails to provide any clue on these results just as Newtonian continuum mechanics --- without corpuscular, discrete, substructure for matter --- cannot explain thermodynamic phenomena. A natural explanation for these results requires a different approach to spacetime dynamics which I will now outline. \subsection{Gravity from normalised vector fields} Suppose there are certain microscopic --- as yet unknown --- degrees of freedom $q_A$, analogous to the atoms in the case of solids, described by some microscopic action functional $A_{micro}[q_A]$. In the case of a solid, the relevant long-wavelength elastic dynamics is captured by the \textit{displacement vector field} which occurs in the equation $x^a\to x^a+\xi^a(x)$. In the case of spacetime, we no longer want to use metric as a dynamical variable; so we need to introduce some other degrees of freedom, analogous to $\xi^a$ in the case of elasticity, and an effective action functional based on it. Normally, varying an action functional with respect certain degrees of freedom will lead to equations of motion determining \textit{those} degrees of freedom. But we now make an unusual demand that varying our action principle with respect to some (non-metric) degrees of freedom should lead to an equation of motion \textit{determining the background metric} which remains non-dynamical. Based on the role expected to be played by surfaces in spacetime, we shall take the relevant degrees of freedom to be the normalised vector fields $n_i(x)$ in the spacetime \cite{aseementropy} with a norm which is fixed at every event but might vary from event to event: (i.e., $n_in^i\equiv\epsilon(x)$ with $\epsilon(x)$ being a fixed function; one can choose the norm to be $0,\pm1$ at each event by our choice of the vector fields but its nature can vary from event to event.). That is, just as the displacement vector $\xi^a$ captures the macro-description in case of solids, the normalised vectors (e.g., normals to surfaces) capture the essential macro-description in case of gravity in terms of an effective action $S[n^a]$. More formally, we expect the coarse graining of microscopic degrees of freedom to lead to an effective action in the long wavelength limit: \begin{equation} \sum_{q_A}\exp (-A_{micro}[q_A])\longrightarrow \exp(-S[n^a]) \label{microtomac} \end{equation} To proceed further we need to determine the nature of $S[n^a]$. The general form of $S[n^a]$ in such an effective description, at the quadratic order, will be: \begin{equation} S[n^a]=\int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}} \left(4P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd} \ensuremath{\nabla}_cn^a\ensuremath{\nabla}_dn^b - T_{ab}n^an^b\right) \,, \label{ent-func-2} \end{equation} where $P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ and $T_{ab}$ are two tensors and the signs, notation etc. are chosen with hindsight. We will see that $T_{ab}$ can be identified with the matter stress-tensor. The full action for gravity plus matter will be taken to be $S_{tot}=S[n^a]+S_{matt}$ with: \begin{equation} S_{tot}=\int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}} \left(4P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd} \ensuremath{\nabla}_cn^a\ensuremath{\nabla}_dn^b - T_{ab}n^an^b\right)+\int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}} \mathcal{L}_{matter} \end{equation} with an important extra prescription: Since the gravitational sector is related to spacetime microstructure, we must \textit{first} vary the $n^a$ and \textit{then} vary the matter degrees of freedom. (In the language of path integrals, we should integrate out the gravitational degrees of freedom $n^a$ first and use the resulting action for the matter sector.) We shall comment more fully on this point at the end of this section. We next address the crucial conceptual difference between the dynamics in gravity and elasticity, say, which we mentioned earlier. In the case of solids, one will write a similar functional [say, for entropy or free energy] in terms of the displacement vector $\xi^a$ and extremising it will lead to an equation \textit{which determines} $\xi^a$. In the case of spacetime, we expect the variational principle to hold for all vectors $n^a$ with constant norm and lead to a condition on the \textit{background metric.} Obviously, the action functional in \eq{ent-func-2} must be rather special to accomplish this and one need to impose two restrictions on the coefficients $P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ and $T_{ab}$ to achieve this. First, the tensor $P_{abcd}$ should have the algebraic symmetries similar to the Riemann tensor $R_{abcd}$ of the $D$-dimensional spacetime. Second, we need: \begin{equation} \ensuremath{\nabla}_{a}P^{abcd}=0=\ensuremath{\nabla}_{a}T^{ab}\,. \label{ent-func-1} \end{equation} In a complete theory, the explicit form of $P^{abcd}$ will be determined by the long wavelength limit of the microscopic theory just as the elastic constants can --- in principle --- be determined from the microscopic theory of the lattice. In the absence of such a theory, we can take a cue from the renormalization group theory and expand $P^{abcd}$ in powers of derivatives of the metric \cite{paris,aseementropy}. That is, we expect, \begin{equation} P^{abcd} (g_{ij},R_{ijkl}) = c_1\,\overset{(1)}{P}{}^{abcd} (g_{ij}) + c_2\, \overset{(2)}{P}{}^{abcd} (g_{ij},R_{ijkl}) + \cdots \,, \label{derexp} \end{equation} where $c_1, c_2, \cdots$ are coupling constants and the successive terms progressively probe smaller and smaller scales. The lowest order term must clearly depend only on the metric with no derivatives. The next term depends (in addition to metric) linearly on curvature tensor and the next one will be quadratic in curvature etc. It can be shown that the m-th order term which satisfies our constraints is \textit{unique} and is given by \begin{equation} \overset{(m)}{P}{}_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}\propto \AltC{c}{d}{a_3}{a_{2m}}{a}{b}{b_3}{b_{2m}} \Riem{b_3}{b_4}{a_3}{a_3} \cdots \Riem{b_{2m-1}}{b_{2m}}{a_{2m-1}}{a_{2m}} = \frac{\partial\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}}{\partial R^{ab}_{{\ph{ab}cd}}}\,. \label{LL03} \end{equation} where $\AltC{c}{d}{a_3}{a_{2m}}{a}{b}{b_3}{b_{2m}}$ is the alternating tensor and the last equality shows that it can be expressed as a derivative of the m th order Lanczos-Lovelock Lagrangian \cite{paris,lovelock}, given by \begin{equation} \Cal{L}^{(D)} = \sD{c_m\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}}\,~;~\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m = \frac{1}{16\pi} 2^{-m} \Alt{a_1}{a_2}{a_{2m}}{b_1}{b_2}{b_{2m}} \Riem{b_1}{b_2}{a_1}{a_2} \Riem{b_{2m-1}}{b_{2m}}{a_{2m-1}}{a_{2m}} \,, \label{LL222} \end{equation} where the $c_m$ are arbitrary constants and \ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}\ is the $m$-th order Lanczos-Lovelock term and we assume $D\geq2K+1$. (See Appendix for a brief description of Lanczos-Lovelock gravity.) The lowest order term (which leads to Einstein's theory) is \begin{equation} \overset{(1)}{P}{}^{ab}_{cd}=\frac{1}{16\pi} \frac{1}{2} \delta^{a_1a_2}_{b_1b_2} =\frac{1}{32\pi} (\delta^a_c \delta^b_d-\delta^a_d \delta^b_c) \,. \label{pforeh} \end{equation} while the first order term (which gives the Gauss-Bonnet correction) is: \begin{equation} \overset{(2)}{P}{}^{ab}_{cd}= \frac{1}{16\pi} \frac{1}{2} \delta^{a_1a_2a_3a_4}_{b_1\,b_2\,b_3\,b_4} R^{b_3b_4}_{a_3a_4} =\frac{1}{8\pi} \left(R^{ab}_{cd} - G^a_c\delta^b_d+ G^b_c \delta^a_d + R^a_d \delta^b_c - R^b_d \delta^a_c\right) \label{ping} \end{equation} where the fourth order alternating tensor is \begin{equation} \delta^{a_1a_2a_3a_4}_{b_1\,b_2\,b_3\,b_4} = \frac{-1}{(D-4)!} \epsilon^{c_1\cdots c_{D-4}a_1a_2a_3a_4}\epsilon_{c_1\cdots c_{D-4}b_1b_2b_3b_4} \,, \label{alteps} \end{equation} The alternating tensors are totally antisymmetric in both sets of indices and take values $+1$, $-1$ and $0$. They can be written in any dimension as an appropriate contraction of the Levi-Civita tensor density with itself. All higher orders terms are obtained in a similar manner (see Appendix). In our paradigm based on \eqn{microtomac}, the field equations for gravity arises from extremising $S$ with respect to variations of the vector field $n^a$, with the constraint $\delta (n_an^a)=0$, and demanding that the resulting condition holds for \textit{all normalized vector fields}. Varying the normal vector field $ n^a$ after adding a Lagrange multiplier function $\lambda(x)$ for imposing the constant norm condition $ n_a\delta n^a=0$, we get \begin{equation} \delta S = 2\int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g} \left(4P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}\ensuremath{\nabla}_c n^a\left(\ensuremath{\nabla}_d\delta n^b\right) - T_{ab} n^a\delta n^b - \lambda(x) g_{ab} n^a\delta n^b\right)} \label{ent-func-3} \end{equation} where we have used the symmetries of $P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ and $T_{ab}$. An integration by parts and the condition $\ensuremath{\nabla}_dP_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}=0$, leads to \begin{equation} \delta S=2\int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}\left[-4P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd} \left(\ensuremath{\nabla}_d\ensuremath{\nabla}_c n^a\right) - ( T_{ab}+ \lambda g_{ab}) n^a\right]\delta n^b} +8\int_{\ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}}{d^{D-1}x\sqrt{h}\left[k_d P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}\left(\ensuremath{\nabla}_c n^a\right)\right]\delta n^b} \,, \label{ent-func-4} \end{equation} where $k^a$ is the $D$-vector field normal to the boundary \ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}\ and $h$ is the determinant of the intrinsic metric on \ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}. As usual, in order for the variational principle to be well defined, we require that the variation $\delta n^a$ of the vector field should vanish on the boundary. The second term in \eqn{ent-func-4} therefore vanishes, and the condition that $S[ n^a]$ be an extremum for arbitrary variations of $ n^a$ then becomes \begin{equation} 2P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}\left(\ensuremath{\nabla}_c\ensuremath{\nabla}_d-\ensuremath{\nabla}_d\ensuremath{\nabla}_c\right) n^a -( T_{ab}+\lambda g_{ab}) n^a = 0\,, \label{ent-func-5} \end{equation} where we used the antisymmetry of $P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ in its upper two indices to write the first term. The definition of the Riemann tensor in terms of the commutator of covariant derivatives reduces the above expression to \begin{equation} \left(2P_b^{\ph{b}ijk}R^a_{\ph{a}ijk} - T{}^a_b+\lambda \delta^a_b\right) n_a=0\,, \label{ent-func-6} \end{equation} and we see that the equations of motion \emph{do not contain} derivatives with respect to $n^a$ which is, of course, the crucial point. This peculiar feature arose because of the symmetry requirements we imposed on the tensor $P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$. We further require that the condition in \eqn{ent-func-6} hold for \emph{arbitrary} vector fields $ n^a$. A simple argument based on local Lorentz invariance then implies that \begin{equation} 2P_{b}^{\ph{b}ijk}R^{a}_{\ph{a}ijk} - T{}_b^a = -\lambda \delta{}_b^a\,, \label{ent-func-7} \end{equation} The scalar $\lambda$ is arbitrary so far and we will now show how it can be determined in the physically interesting cases. To see what is involved, consider the lowest order approximation (viz. Einstein gravity) in which we take $P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ to be given by \eq{pforeh} so that the above equation reduces to: \begin{equation} \frac{1}{8\pi}R^a_b - T^a_b=-\lambda\delta^a_b \label{likeuni} \end{equation} where $-\lambda$ can be an arbitrary function of the metric. Writing this equation as $(G^a_b - 8\pi T^a_b ) = Q(g) \delta^a_b $ with $Q= -8\pi\lambda - (1/2) R$ and using $\nabla_a G^a_b = 0 , \nabla_a T^a_b =0$ we get $\partial_bQ=\partial_b [ -8\pi \lambda - (1/2) R] =0$; so that $Q$ is an undetermined integration constant, say $\Lambda$, and $\lambda$ must have the form $8\pi \lambda=-(1/2)R-\Lambda$. The resulting equation is \begin{equation} R^a_b-(1/2)R\delta^a_b=8\pi T^a_b+\Lambda\delta^a_b \label{eom} \end{equation} which leads to Einstein's theory if we identify $T_{ab}$ as the matter energy momentum tensor using the standard Newtonian limit of the theory. \textit{Clearly, the cosmological constant appears as an integration constant}. The mathematical similarity with unimodular gravity is apparent; keeping the function $n_an^a=\epsilon(x)$ fixed while varying $n_a$ is equivalent to keeping $\sqrt{-g}$ fixed in unimodular gravity. Taking the trace of \eq{likeuni} will lead, for example, to \eq{tracefree} etc. But the conceptual structure is quite different and we maintain full general covariance. The crucial feature of the coupling between matter and gravity through $T_{ab}n^an^b$ is that, under the shift $T_{ab}\to T_{ab}+\rho_0g_{ab}$ the $\rho_0$ term in the action in \eq{ent-func-2} decouples from $n^a$ and becomes irrelevant: \begin{equation} \int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}}T_{ab}n^an^b \to \int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}} T_{ab}n^an^b + \int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}}\epsilon\rho_0 \end{equation} Since $\epsilon$ is not varied when $n_a$ is varied there is no coupling between $\rho_0$ and the dynamical variables $n_a$ the theory is invariant under the shift $T_{ab}\to T_{ab}+\rho_0g_{ab}$. We see that the condition $n_an^a=$ constant on the dynamical variables have led to a `gauge freedom' which allows an arbitrary integration constant to appear in the theory which can absorb the bulk cosmological constant. This was our key objective. The same procedure works with the more general structure in the family of theories starting with Einstein's GR, Gauss-Bonnet gravity etc and --- in the general case --- one obtains the field equations: \begin{equation} 16\pi\left[ P_{b}^{\ph{b}ijk}R^{a}_{\ph{a}ijk}-\frac{1}{2}\delta^a_b\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}\right]= 8\pi T{}_b^a +\Lambda\delta^a_b \label{ent-func-71} \end{equation} These are identical to the field equations for Lanczos-Lovelock gravity with a cosmological constant arising as an undetermined integration constant. To the lowest order, when we use \eqn{pforeh} for $P_{b}^{\ph{b}ijk}$, the \eqn{ent-func-71} reproduces Einstein's theory. More generally, we get Einstein's equations with higher order corrections which are to be interpreted as emerging from the derivative expansion of the action functional as we probe smaller and smaller scales. Remarkably enough, we can derive not only Einstein's theory but even Lanczos-Lovelock theory from a dual description in terms on the normalised vectors in spacetime, \textit{without varying $g_{ab}$ in an action functional!} To gain a bit more insight into what is going on, let us consider the on-shell value of the action functional. Manipulating the covariant derivatives in \eqn{ent-func-2} and using the field equation \eq{ent-func-71} we can write \begin{eqnarray} S_{tot}|_{\rm on-shell}&=&S[n]+S_{mat}=\int_\Cal{V}{d^Dx\sqrt{-g}\left[ 4\ensuremath{\nabla}_d\left(P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}\left( \ensuremath{\nabla}_c n^a\right) n^b\right) - 4P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}\left(\ensuremath{\nabla}_d\ensuremath{\nabla}_c n^a\right) n^b -T_{ab} n^a n^b \right]} +S_{mat} \nonumber\\ &=&4\int_{\ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}}{d^{D-1}x\sqrt{h} k_d\left(P_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd} n^b\ensuremath{\nabla}_c n^a\right)} + \int_\Cal{V} {d^Dx\sqrt{-g}\epsilon\left( \ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m} +\frac{\Lambda}{8\pi} \right) } + \int_\Cal{V}d^Dx\sqrt{-g}\mathcal{L}_{matter} \label{on-shell-1} \end{eqnarray} where $\epsilon\equiv n_an^a$. We see that, on shell, the only dependence on $n_a$ is through a surface term. Since the metric tensor is not dynamical, second term is irrelevant and we can now vary the matter Lagrangian with respect to matter variables to determine the behaviour of matter in a given curved spacetime, which, of course is sourced by the matter stress tensor through \eq{ent-func-71} obtained earlier. The key new feature, which survives and depends on our original variables $n_a$ is the surface term which we shall now explore further. Explicitly, this surface term is given by: \begin{eqnarray} S|_{\rm on-shell}&=&4\int_{\ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}}{d^{D-1}x\sqrt{h}\,k_a\left(P^{abcd} n_c\ensuremath{\nabla}_b n_d\right)}\nonumber\\ &\longrightarrow&\frac{1}{8\pi}\int_{\ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}}d^{D-1}x\sqrt{h}\,k_a\left( n^a\ensuremath{\nabla}_b n^b- n^b\ensuremath{\nabla}_b n^a\right) =-\frac{1}{8\pi}\int_{\ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}}d^{D-1}x\sqrt{h}\,k_i\left(n^iK+a^i\right) \label{on-shell-2} \end{eqnarray} where we have manipulated a few indices using the symmetries of $P^{abcd}$. The expression in the second line, after the arrow, is the result for general relativity. Note that the integrand has the familiar structure of $k_i( n^iK+a^i)$ where $a^i= n^b\ensuremath{\nabla}_b n^i$ is the acceleration associated with the vector field $ n^a$ and $K\equiv -\ensuremath{\nabla}_b n^b$ is the trace of extrinsic curvature in the standard context. If we restrict to a series of surfaces foliating the spacetime with $n_i$ representing their unit normals and take the boundary to be one of them, we can identify $k_i$ with $n_i$; then $a_in^i=0$ and the surface term is just \begin{equation} S|_{\rm on-shell}=\mp\frac{1}{8\pi}\int_{\ensuremath{\partial\Cal{V}}}d^{D-1}x\sqrt{h} K \label{ygh} \end{equation} which is the York-Gibbons-Hawking boundary term in general relativity \cite{gh} if we normalise $\epsilon$ to $\pm1$ depending on the nature of the surface. It is now obvious that this term in the on-shell action will lead to the entropy of the horizons (which will be 1/4 per unit transverse area) in the case of general relativity. More formally, we treat the horizon surface as a limit of a sequence of timelike surfaces; for example, in the case of Schwarschild metric we consider surfaces with $r=2M+\delta$ with $\delta\to0$. In fact, the result is far more general. Even in the case of of a more general $P^{ab}_{cd}$ it can be shown that the on-shell value of the action reduces to \cite{aseementropy} the entropy of the horizons. The general expression is: \begin{equation} S|_{\Cal{H}} = \sD{4\pi m c_m \int_{\Cal{H}}{d^{D-2}x_{\perp} \sqrt{\sigma}\Cal{L}^{(D-2)}_{(m-1)}}} =\frac{1}{4}[{\rm Area}]_\perp +{\rm corrections} \label{ent-limit-2} \end{equation} where $x_{\perp}$ denotes the transverse coordinates on the horizon \Cal{H}, $\sigma$ is the determinant of the intrinsic metric on \Cal{H} and we have restored a summation over $m$ thereby giving the result for the most general Lanczos-Lovelock case obtained as a sum of individual Lanczos-Lovelock lagrangians. The expression in \eqn{ent-limit-2} \emph{is precisely the entropy of a general Killing horizon in Lanczos-Lovelock gravity} based on the general prescription given by Wald and others \cite{noether} and computed by several authors. Further, in any spacetime, if we take a local Rindler frame around any event we will obtain an entropy for the locally defined Rindler horizon. In the case of GR, this entropy per unit transverse area is just 1/4 as expected. This result shows that, in the semiclassical limit in which the action can possibly be related to entropy, we reproduce the conventional entropy which scales as the area in Einstein's theory. Since the entropy counts the relevant degrees of freedom, this shows that the degrees of freedom which survives and contributes in the long wave length limit scales as the area. The quantum fluctuations in these degrees of freedom can then lead to the correct, observed, value of the cosmological constant. The last aspect can be made more quantitative and we will briefly describe in the next section how this can be done. Our action principle is somewhat peculiar compared to the usual action principles in the sense that we have varied $n_a$ and demanded that the resulting equations hold for \textit{all} vector fields of constant norm. Our action principle actually stands for an infinite number of action principles, one for each vector field of constant norm! This class of \textit{all} $n^i$ allows an effective, coarse grained, description of some (unknown) aspects of spacetime micro physics. This is why we need to first vary $n_a$, obtain the equations constraining the background metric and then use the action in \eq{on-shell-1} to obtain the equations of motion for matter. (If, instead, we vary matter terms first the coupling $T_{ab}n^an^b$ will couple matter to $n^a$ which will remain undetermined since we have no equation for $n_a$.) Of course, in most contexts, $\nabla_a T^a_b=0$ will take care of the dynamical equations for matter and these issues are irrelevant \cite{note3}. At this stage, it is not possible to proceed further and relate $n^i$ to some microscopic degrees of freedom $q^A$. This issue is conceptually similar to asking one to identify the atomic degrees of freedom, given the description of an elastic solid in terms of a displacement field $\xi^a$ --- which we know is impossible. However, the same analogy tells us that the relevant degree of freedom in the long wavelength limit (viz. $\xi^a$ or $n^i$) can be completely different from the microscopic degrees of freedom and it is best to proceed phenomenologically. \subsection{Gravity as detector of the vacuum fluctuations} The description of gravity using the action principle given above provides a natural back drop for gauging away the bulk value of the cosmological constant since it decouples from the dynamical degrees of freedom in the theory. Once the bulk term is eliminated, what is observable through gravitational effects, in the correct theory of quantum gravity, should be the \textit{fluctuations} in the vacuum energy. These fluctuations will be non-zero if the universe has a DeSitter horizon which provides a confining volume. In this paradigm the vacuum structure can readjust to gauge away the bulk energy density $\rho_{_{\rm UV}}\simeq L_P^{-4}$ while quantum \textit{fluctuations} can generate the observed value $\rho_{\rm DE}$. The role of energy fluctuations contributing to gravity also arises, more formally, when we study the question of \emph{detecting} the energy density using gravitational field as a probe. Recall that an Unruh-DeWitt detector with a local coupling $\mathcal{L}_I=M(\tau)\phi[x(\tau)]$ to the {\it field} $\phi$ actually responds to $\langle 0|\phi(x)\phi(y)|0\rangle$ rather than to the field itself \cite{probe}. Similarly, one can use the gravitational field as a natural ``detector" of energy momentum tensor $T_{ab}$ with the standard coupling $L=\kappa h_{ab}T^{ab}$. Such a model was analyzed in detail in ref.~\cite{tptptmunu} and it was shown that the gravitational field responds to the two point function $\langle 0|T_{ab}(x)T_{cd}(y)|0\rangle $. In fact, it is essentially this fluctuations in the energy density which is computed in the inflationary models \cite{inflation} as the {\it source} for gravitational field, as stressed in ref.~\cite{tplp}. All these suggest treating the energy fluctuations as the physical quantity ``detected" by gravity, when one incorporates quantum effects. If the cosmological constant\ arises due to the fluctuations in the energy density of the vacuum, then one needs to understand the structure of the quantum gravitational vacuum at cosmological scales. Quantum theory, especially the paradigm of renormalization group has taught us that the concept of the vacuum state depends on the scale at which it is probed. The vacuum state which we use to study the lattice vibrations in a solid, say, is not the same as vacuum state of the QED and it is not appropriate to ask questions about the vacuum without specifying the scale. If the spacetime has a cosmological horizon which blocks information, the natural scale is provided by the size of the horizon, $L_\Lambda$, and we should use observables defined within the accessible region. The operator $H(<L_\Lambda)$, corresponding to the total energy inside a region bounded by a cosmological horizon, will exhibit fluctuations $\Delta E$ since vacuum state is not an eigenstate of {\it this} operator. The corresponding fluctuations in the energy density, $\Delta\rho\propto (\Delta E)/L_\Lambda^3=f(L_P,L_\Lambda)$ will now depend on both the ultraviolet cutoff $L_P$ as well as $L_\Lambda$. To obtain $\Delta \rho_{\rm vac} \propto \Delta E/L_\Lambda^3$ which scales as $(L_P L_\Lambda)^{-2}$ we need to have $(\Delta E)^2\propto L_P^{-4} L_\Lambda^2$; that is, the square of the energy fluctuations should scale as the surface area of the bounding surface which is provided by the cosmic horizon. Remarkably enough, a rigorous calculation \cite{cc2} of the dispersion in the energy shows that for $L_\Lambda \gg L_P$, the final result indeed has the scaling \begin{equation} (\Delta E )^2 = c_1 \frac{L_\Lambda^2}{L_P^4} \label{deltae} \end{equation} where the constant $c_1$ depends on the manner in which ultra violet cutoff is imposed. Similar calculations have been done (with a completely different motivation, in the context of entanglement entropy) by several people and it is known that the area scaling found in Eq.~(\ref{deltae}), proportional to $ L_\Lambda^2$, is a generic feature \cite{area}. For a simple exponential UV-cutoff, $c_1 = (1/30\pi^2)$ but cannot be computed reliably without knowing the full theory. We thus find that the fluctuations in the energy density of the vacuum in a sphere of radius $L_\Lambda$ is given by \begin{equation} \Delta \rho_{\rm vac} = \frac{\Delta E}{L_\Lambda^3} \propto L_P^{-2}L_\Lambda^{-2} \propto \frac{H_\Lambda^2}{G} \label{final} \end{equation} The numerical coefficient will depend on $c_1$ as well as the precise nature of infrared cutoff radius; but it is a fact of life that a fluctuation of magnitude $\Delta\rho_{vac}\simeq H_\Lambda^2/G$ will exist in the energy density inside a sphere of radius $H_\Lambda^{-1}$ if Planck length is the UV cut off. On the other hand, since observations suggest that there is a $\rho_{vac}$ of similar magnitude in the universe it seems natural to identify the two. Our approach explains why there is a \textit{surviving} cosmological constant which satisfies $\rho_{_{\rm DE}}=\sqrt{\rho_{_{\rm IR}}\rho_{_{\rm UV}}}$. We stress that the computation of energy fluctuations is completely meaningless in the conventional models of gravity in which the metric couples to the bulk energy density. Once a UV cut-off at Planck scale is imposed, one will always get a bulk contribution $\rho_{UV}\approx L_P^{-4}$ with the usual problems. It is only because we have a way of decoupling the bulk term from contributing to the dynamical equations that, we have a right to look at the subdominant term $L_P^{-4}(L_P/L_\Lambda)^2$. Approaches in which the sub-dominant term is introduced by an ad hoc manner are technically flawed since the bulk term cannot be ignored in these usual approaches to gravity. Getting the correct value of the cosmological constant from the energy fluctuations is not as difficult as understanding why the bulk value (which is larger by $10^{120}$!) can be ignored. Our approach provides a natural backdrop for ignoring the bulk term --- and as a bonus --- we get the right value for the cosmological constant from the fluctuations. It is small because it is a purely quantum effect. \section{Conclusions} It is obvious that the existence of a component with negative pressure constitutes a major challenge in theoretical physics. The simplest choice for this component is the cosmological constant; other models based on scalar fields [as well as those based on branes etc. which I have not discussed] do not alleviate the difficulties faced by cosmological constant\ and --- in fact --- makes them worse. The key point I want to stress is that the cosmological constant is most likely to be a low energy relic of a quantum gravitational effect or principle and its explanation will require a radical shift in our current paradigm. I have tried to advertise a new approach to gravity as a possible broad paradigm to understand the cosmological constant. On the negative side, there are some very obvious difficulties with the ideas that I have outlined. The most serious objections are the following: \begin{itemize} \item The normalised vectors $n_i$ were introduced in a totally ad hoc manner and does not relate to anything we know about gravity and hence the motivation for the condition the $n_in^i=$ constant is unclear. The unusual nature of this variable and the action $S[n_a]$ makes it difficult to construct a quantum theory via path integrals. \item While we have fairly attractive scheme to eliminate the bulk cosmological constant\ term, the arguments given in the last section to obtain the observed value is, at best, tentative. The area scaling for surviving degrees of freedom emerges naturally but it is unclear how to connect up the energy fluctuations in these degrees of freedom to the source of gravity. \end{itemize} Against this, one should compare the attractive features of the approach in a broader context. The conceptual basis for this approach rests on the following logical ingredients. \begin{enumerate} \item It is impossible to solve the cosmological constant problem unless the gravitational sector of the theory is invariant under the shift $T_{ab}\to T_{ab}+\lambda_mg_{ab}$. Any approach which does not address this issue cannot provide a comprehensive solution to the cosmological constant\ problem. \item General covariance requires us to use the measure $\sqrt{-g}d^Dx$ in D-dimensions in the action. This will couple the metric (through its determinant) to the matter sector. Hence, as long as we insist on metric as the fundamental variable describing gravity, one cannot address the issue in (1) above. So we need to introduce some other degrees of freedom and an effective action which, however, is capable of constraining the background metric. \item We found an action principle, based on the normalised vector fields in spacetime, that satisfies all these criteria mentioned above. The new action does not couple to the bulk energy density and maintains invariance under the shift $T_{ab}\to T_{ab}+\lambda_mg_{ab}$. What is more, the on shell value of the action is related to the entropy of horizons showing the relevant degrees of freedom scales as the area of the bounding surface. \item Since our formalism ensures that the bulk energy density does not contribute to gravity --- and only because of that --- it makes sense to compute the next order correction due to fluctuations in the energy density. This is impossible to do rigorously with the machinery available but a plausible case can be made as how this will lead to the correct, observed, value of the cosmological constant. \item In the long wavelength limit, the relevant physics is captured in terms of an effective theory related to the degrees of freedom contained in the fluctuations of the normalised vectors. The resulting theory is far more general than Einstein gravity since the thermodynamic interpretations should transcend classical considerations and incorporate some of the microscopic corrections. Einstein's equations provide the lowest order description of the dynamics and \textit{calculable}, higher order, corrections arise as we probe smaller scales. The mechanism for ignoring the bulk cosmological constant\ is likely to survive quantum gravitational corrections which are likely to bring in additional, higher derivative, terms to the action. \end{enumerate} Taking stock, I strongly believe there is no way out of the points mentioned in (1) and (2) above and a tenable description of gravity must be based on variables other than the metric. Such a theory is very likely to have most of the ingredients I have outlined here. \section{Acknowledgements} I thank A.Paranjape and K.Subramanian for useful comments on first draft of the review. \section*{Appendix: A primer on Lanczos-Lovelock gravity} The Lanczos-Lovelock Lagrangian is a specific example from a general class of Lagrangians which describes a (possibly semiclassical) theory of gravity and are given by \begin{equation} \Cal{L}=Q_a^{\ph{a}bcd}R^a_{\ph{a}bcd}\,, \label{LL1} \end{equation} where $Q_a^{\ph{a}bcd}$ is the most general fourth rank tensor sharing the algebraic symmetries of the Riemann tensor $R^a_{\ph{a}bcd}$ and further satisfying the criterion $\ensuremath{\nabla}_bQ_a^{\ph{a}bcd}=0$ (Several general properties of this class of Lagrangians are discussed in Ref. \cite{ayan}). It can be shown that (see e.g., \cite{ayan}) the equations of motion for a general theory of gravity derived from the Lagrangian in \eqn{LL1} using the standard variational principle with $g^{ab}$ as the dynamical variables, are given by \begin{equation} E_{ab}=\frac{1}{2}T_{ab} ~~;~~ E_{ab}\equiv\frac{1}{\sqrt{-g}}\frac{\partial}{\partial g^{ab}}\left(\sqrt{-g}\Cal{L}\right) -2\ensuremath{\nabla}^m\ensuremath{\nabla}^nP_{amnb}\,. \label{LL4} \end{equation} Here $T_{ab}$ is the energy-momentum tensor for the matter fields. The tensor $P_{abcd}$ defined through $P_a^{\ph{a}bcd}\equiv(\partial\Cal{L}/\partial R^a_{\ph{a}bcd})$. The partial derivatives are taken treating $g^{ab}$, $\Gamma^a_{\ph{a}bc}$ and $R^a_{\ph{a}bcd}$ as independent quantities. The $D$-dimensional Lanczos-Lovelock Lagrangian is given by \cite{lovelock} a polynomial in the curvature tensor: \begin{equation} \Cal{L}^{(D)} = \sD{c_m\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}}\,~;~\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m = \frac{1}{16\pi} 2^{-m} \Alt{a_1}{a_2}{a_{2m}}{b_1}{b_2}{b_{2m}} \Riem{b_1}{b_2}{a_1}{a_2} \Riem{b_{2m-1}}{b_{2m}}{a_{2m-1}}{a_{2m}} \,, \label{LL2} \end{equation} where the $c_m$ are arbitrary constants and \ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}\ is the $m$-th order Lanczos-Lovelock term. Here the generalised alternating tensor $\delta^{\cdots}_{\cdots}$ is the natural extension of the one defined in \eqn{alteps} for $2m$ indices, and we assume $D\geq2K+1$. The $m$-th order Lanczos-Lovelock term $\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m$ given in \eqn{LL2} is a homogeneous function of the Riemann tensor of degree $m$. For each such term, the tensor $Q_a^{\ph{a}bcd}$ defined in \eqn{LL1} carries a label $m$ and becomes \begin{equation} {}^{(m)}Q_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}= \frac{1}{16\pi}2^{-m} \AltC{c}{d}{a_3}{a_{2m}}{a}{b}{b_3}{b_{2m}} \Riem{b_3}{b_4}{a_3}{a_3}\cdots\Riem{b_{2m-1}}{b_{2m}}{a_{2m-1}}{a_{2m}} \,. \label{LL3} \end{equation} The full tensor $Q_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ is a linear combination of the ${}^{(m)}Q_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ with the coefficients $c_m$. Einstein's GR is a special case of Lanczos-Lovelock gravity in which only the coefficient $c_1$ is non-zero. Since the tensors ${}^{(m)}Q_{ab}^{\ph{a}\ph{b}cd}$ appear linearly in the Lanczos-Lovelock Lagrangian and consequently in all other tensors constructed from it, for most applications it is sufficient to concentrate on the case where a single coefficient $c_m$ is non-zero. All the results that follow can be easily extended to the case where more than one of the $c_m$ are non-zero, by taking suitable linear combinations of the tensors involved. For the $m$-th order Lanczos-Lovelock Lagrangian $\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}$, since $P^{abcd}$ is divergence-free, the expression for the tensor $E_{ab}$ in \eqn{LL4} becomes \begin{equation} E_{ab}=\frac{\partial\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}}{\partial g^{ab}}-\frac{1}{2}\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m} g_{ab}\,, \label{LL5} \end{equation} where we have used the relation $\partial(\sqrt{-g})/\partial g^{ab}=-(1/2)\sqrt{-g}g_{ab}$. The first term in the expression for $E_{ab}$ in \eqn{LL5} can be simplified to give \begin{equation} \frac{\partial\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}}{\partial g^{ab}}=mQ_{a}^{\ph{a}ijk}R_{bijk}= P_a^{\ph{a}ijk}R_{bijk} \,, \label{LL6} \end{equation} where the expressions in \eqn{LL6} can be verified by direct computation, or by noting that \ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}\ is a homogeneous function of the Riemann tensor $R^a_{\ph{a}bcd}$ of degree $m$. To summarize, the Lanczos-Lovelock field equations are given by \begin{equation} 16\pi\left[ P_{b}^{\ph{b}ijk}R^{a}_{\ph{a}ijk}-\frac{1}{2}\delta^a_b\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}\right]= 8\pi T{}_b^a, \label{ent-func-711} \end{equation} where we have included a possible cosmological constant in the defintion of $T^a_b$. Taking the trace of this equation, we find that that $\ensuremath{\Cal{L}^{(D)}_m}=(2m-D)^{-1}T$. In other words, the on-shell value of the Lagrangian is proportional to the trace of the stress tensor in all Lanczos-Lovelock theories, just like in GR. .

1. Background {#sec1} ============= Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) is an essential part of the health care system in several Asian countries, and is considered a complementary or alternative medical system in most western countries \[[@B1]\]. The TCM pattern (also called Zheng or Syndrome differentiation) is the basic unit in the diagnostic system of TCM. The pattern is determined by analyzing the patient\'s overall signs and symptoms, including tongue appearance and pulse manifestation \[[@B2], [@B3]\]. Currently, diagnoses based on the TCM pattern are integrated with biomedical diagnosis, and the integrative medicine model has become common in clinical practice \[[@B4]\]. TCM pattern classification has proven to be an effective method in patient stratification integrated with biomedical diagnostic method. Our previous study has reported that the molecular networks of major TCM patterns, cold and hot pattern in rheumatoid arthritis (RA), has been built-up by network analysis \[[@B5]\]. Also we reported that, in an RCT clinical trial, biomedicine therapy was better than the Chinese herbal therapy in the treatment of RA with regard to the ACR responsive rate \[[@B6]\]. We presume that the effectiveness of the two interventions would be different if the RA patients were divided into TCM cold and hot patterns, and the molecular mechanism about the different effectiveness of the two interventions can be explored by network pharmacology method based on the molecular networks of TCM cold and hot pattern in RA \[[@B7]\]. In this paper, randomized clinical data were re-analyzed with focus on the comparison of effectiveness of two interventions (a TCM therapy and a biomedicine therapy) in treating RA patients who were classified into TCM cold and hot patterns, and the molecular mechanism involved in the different effectiveness of two interventions was explored by merging the network pharmacology of the interventions and the molecular networks of TCM patterns in RA. The pharmacological networks of the interventions can be built-up as previously reported \[[@B8]\], and the molecular networks of cold and hot patterns in RA have been built-up previously \[[@B5]\]. 2. Materials and Methods {#sec2} ======================== 2.1. Briefings about the Reported Clinical Trial {#sec2.1} ------------------------------------------------ A randomized, controlled clinical trial at 9 centers throughout China was conducted according to the guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki and the principles of Good Clinical Practice. Details about the clinical trial have been reported previously \[[@B9]\]. Patients were randomly assigned in a 1 : 1 ratio to receive a biomedical combination therapy or TCM therapy. Patients, men and women, aged from 18 to 70 years old were eligible to participate if they met the American College of Rheumatology (ACR) criteria for RA, had disease duration of at least one year, and were categorized as Class I, II, or III under ACR guidelines \[[@B10]\]. Patients receiving nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs, corticosteroids (up to 10 mg per day), or both were allowed to participate in the trial if they had been on stable doses for at least four weeks prior to randomization. Patients with severe cardiovascular, lung, liver, kidney, hematologic, or mental diseases and women who were pregnant, breast-feeding or planning to become pregnant in the next 8 months were excluded. An Institutional Review Board approved the protocol at each center. Each patient gave the written informed consent prior to any study-related procedures. Biomedical combination therapy included use of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) and disease modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs). Diclofenac (extended action 75 mg tablet), the NSAID given, was taken once a day orally after a meal but was discontinued after the acute inflammation was controlled. The DMARDs used were methotrexate and sulfasalazine. Methotrexate (MTX) was taken orally once a week at a starting dosage of 5 mg with addition of 2.5 mg each week up to 15 mg, and a maintenance dosage from 2.5 mg to 7.5 mg. Sulfasalazine (SSZ) was taken orally twice a day from a starting dosage of 0.25 g with the addition of 0.25 g each week, to a maintenance dosage of 0.5 g to 1 g, four times a day. Chinese herbal medicine therapy (TCM therapy) was recommended by Chinese Association of Traditional Chinese Medicine and clinical reports \[[@B11]\], and all patients took Glucosidorum Tripterygll Totorum (produced by GMP certificated Hubei Huangshi Pharmaceuticals of China), which contains the Chloroform extract (mainly glycosides) of Glucosidorum Tripterygll Totorum, 10 mg each time, three times a day, and Yishen Juanbi Tablet (produced by GMP certificated Qingjiang Pharmaceuticals of China), which contains the water extracts of herbs including Radix Rehmanniae, Radix *Angelicae sinensis*, *Herba epimedii*, Rhizoma drynariae, *lumbricus*, Nidus vespae, *Eupolyphaga seu steleophaga*, 8 g (equal to 50 g raw herbal materials) each time, three times a day, taken orally after meals. Within 14 days before randomization, a complete physical examination, medical history, and assessment of the symptoms typically evaluated by TCM physicians were performed and recorded. After treatment for 24 weeks, the ACR 20 response was evaluated as the efficacy \[[@B10]\], and the evaluation was done by a third party (rheumatologists at each center) who did not know the therapy. An ACR 20 response is defined as a reduction of at least 20 percent of the number of tender joints and swollen joints plus an improvement of at least 20 percent in at least three of the following five criteria: patient\'s assessment of pain, patient\'s assessment of disease activity, physician\'s assessment of disease activity, patient\'s assessment of physical function, and serum C-reactive protein concentration. Data pertaining to the symptoms used to determine TCM were recorded at the patient\'s entry into the study and every two weeks thereafter until week 24 \[[@B6]\]. The 13 symptoms, which are commonly used for TCM pattern classification for RA patients \[[@B6]\], were assessed, and they are cold feeling in whole body, cold feeling in joints, cold feeling in limbs, lassitude, heavy feeling in limbs, numbness in limbs, vexation, feverish joint, thirst, nocturia, dizziness, turbid yellow colored urine, and fever. The symptoms were scored at four strength levels by patients as none, slight, medium, or severe and were recorded as 0, 1, 2, or 3, respectively. In addition, tongue appearance such as the color of tongue body and tongue fur was also recorded. In this paper, the RA patients were divided into TCM cold and hot patterns with latent class analysis (LCA) method, which can divide the RA patients into different classes based on the symptoms collected. 2.2. Pharmacological Network Building-Up for the Interventions {#sec2.2} -------------------------------------------------------------- The pharmacological networks of the interventions were built-up as previously reported \[[@B8]\]. In brief, the information about all herbs (in the TCM intervention) related genes, diseases, TCM effects, and TCM ingredients automatically were mined by using TCMGeneDIT \[[@B12]\], a database system containing a vast amount of biomedical literature. The information on human protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks of biomedical combination (MTX and SSZ combination) and the TCM therapy, and PPI network information about RA were obtained from databases, including PubMed, BIND (Biomolecular Interaction Network Database), BioGRID (The General Repository for Interaction Datasets), DIP (Database of Interacting Proteins), HPRD (Human Protein Reference Database), IntAct (Database system and analysis tools for protein interaction data) and MINT (Molecular Interactions Database), and complemented with curated relationships parsed from Literature using Agilent Literature Search. The *t* value was calculated according to the previously reported \[[@B12], [@B13]\] and a *t* value greater than 95% was taken as significant information. If the *t* value is larger than 2.576, 2.326, 1.960, or 1.645, we can reject the null hypothesis with 99.5%, 99%, 97.5%, or 95% confidence, respectively. The PPI network was visualized using cytoscape software \[[@B14]\]. The IPCA algorithm was employed to analyze the characteristics of the network, which can detect densely connected regions in the interactome network \[[@B15]\]. Interactomes with a score greater than 2.0 and at least four nodes were taken as significant predictions. In order to identify the function of each cluster generated by IPCA individually, GO clustering analysis was performed with the proteins described in all subnetworks. For this purpose, the latest version of Biological Network Gene Ontology (BiNGO) tool \[[@B16]\] was used to statistically evaluate groups of proteins with respect to the existing annotations of the Gene Ontology Consortium. The degree of functional enrichment for a given cluster was quantitatively assessed (*P* value) by hypergeometric distribution and implemented in the BiNGO tool. BiNGO currently provides statistical tests for assessing the enrichment of a GO term in the test set, and also provides an approximate *P* value \[[@B16]\]. We selected the 5 GO biological categories with the smallest *P* values as significant. 2.3. Merging of Pharmacological Networks of the Interventions with the Molecular Networks of TCM Cold and Hot Patterns in RA {#sec2.3} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The molecular networks of cold and hot patterns in RA were reported previously \[[@B5]\], and the networks were used to be merged with the pharmacological networks of interventions built-up in this paper. Graph was used merge tool to find the union, intersection, and difference of networks based on node identifiers/IDs. The nodes were matched according to ID mappings, that is, the nodes whose IDs were mapped to each other were considered as the same node when the value of their selected attribute(s) matchs, and then the attribute of source networks is merged into attributes in the resulting network. 2.4. Statistics {#sec2.4} --------------- All data were analyzed on a SAS9.1.3 statistical package (order no. 195557). TCM pattern was defined by factor analysis based on the loadings on all collected 13 symptoms, and the effective rates in patients with TCM pattern changes were analyzed with the Chi-square method. LCA was employed to explore the exact indications of the interventions. LCA was obtained at <http://methodology.psu.edu/index.php/ra/lcalta>. In LCA, the latent variable is discrete, and a population is divided into mutually exclusive and exhaustive categories. 3. Results {#sec3} ========== 3.1. ACR 20 Response (Effectiveness) Evaluation {#sec3.1} ----------------------------------------------- In this clinical trial, 194 patients treated with biomedical combination therapy and 204 cases treated with TCM therapy finished a whole 24 week treatment, and the ACR 20 responsive rates of biomedical combination therapy and TCM therapy at 24 weeks were 69.59% and 53.20%, respectively. Biomedical combination therapy was more effective than TCM therapy (*P* \< 0.05). In the patient classification into TCM cold and hot patterns, an LCA model was established and the TCM information was divided into 2 latent classes according to the clinical responses. class 1 patients had clinical manifestations similar to the cold pattern, including less probability of fever, feverish joints, lassitude, thirst, red tongue, yellow tongue fur and turbid yellow colored urine. Class 2 patients had clinical manifestations similar to the hot pattern, with higher probability of the aforementioned symptoms ([Figure 1(a)](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). ACR 20 responsive rates of interventions in each latent class patients are presented in [Figure 1(b)](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}. The ACR 20 responsive rate of TCM therapy in hot pattern RA patients was 72.09%, yet the responsive rate of biomedicine therapy was only 51.11% (*P* = 0.043 \< 0.05), while the responsive rate of biomedicine therapy in cold pattern RA patients was 82.61%, and the responsive rate of TCM therapy was only 51.06% (*P* \< 0.0001). The LCA results indicated that biomedicine therapy was promising in cold-pattern whereas TCM therapy was preferable in hot-pattern RA. 3.2. Network Based Molecular Mechanism of Biomedicine Therapy in Treating RA Patients {#sec3.2} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Pharmacological network of the biomedical combination therapy was built up by integrating text mining and protein-protein interaction (PPI) approaches. Text mining results indicated that MTX and SSZ associated with 66 and 77 genes, respectively (data not shown). The intersection network between MTX and SSZ networks was obtained using the graph merge tool ([Figure 2(a)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}, left). Eleven highly connected regions were detected by IPCA algorithm, allowing the inference of significant complexes or pathways in this network ([Figure 2(a)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}, right). The most relevant functions and pathways extracted from these subnetworks by the Biological Network Gene Ontology tool were related to the ATP biosynthetic process, RNA metabolic process, and regulation of the immune response to viruses, regulation of cell cycle, ATP synthesis, and coupled electron transport ([Table 1](#tab1){ref-type="table"}). This suggests that synergistic mechanisms of MTX + SSZ are involved in regulation of the immune response to viruses, proliferation and apoptosis of T and B cells, and cAMP and NF-*κ*B signaling pathway. Then we combined the cold- and hot-pattern RA networks, which have been built-up previously \[[@B5]\], and the pharmacological networks of biomedicine therapy by using a graph merge tool ([Figure 2(b)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In [Figure 2(b)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}, all nodes and lines in background represent RA molecular networks. Nodes represent proteins and edges denote interactions. The left part shows the network of the cold pattern of RA, the right part shows that of the the hot pattern. The blue nodes represent the proteins that are targeted by either MTX or SSZ, and the green nodes represent the proteins that are targeted by both MTX and SSZ, or by the interaction between MTX and SSZ. Obviously, biomedicine therapy targets parts of all four cold-pattern clusters (left of [Figure 2(b)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}): regulation of translation, protein ubiquitination pathway, JAK-STAT cascade, and RNA splicing. However, only parts of 2 hot-pattern clusters (right of [Figure 2(b)](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}): I-kappa B kinase/NF-kappa B and mRNA splicing were targeted by MTX and SSZ, and fatty acid metabolism involved in hot-pattern RA cannot be targeted by MTX and SSZ, and splicing of mRNA in hot-pattern RA was also targeted only on 2 nodes. The results suggest that the involved pathways in the cold or hot pattern of RA can partly explain why biomedicine therapy appeared to be more effective in treating cold-pattern RA patients from the view of molecular networks. 3.3. Molecular Mechanism of the TCM Therapy in Treating RA {#sec3.3} ---------------------------------------------------------- The pharmacological networks of TCM therapy were built up by a similar method to biomedicine therapy. In [Figure 3(a)](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}, eight highly connected regions were detected by the IPCA algorithm, allowing the detection of significant complexes or pathways in the network. The most relevant functions and pathways extracted from these subnetworks by the Biological Network Gene Ontology tool were related to ATP biosynthetic processes, RNA metabolic processes, regulation of the cell cycle, ATP synthesis, fibroblast growth factor receptor signaling pathway, and Ras protein signal transduction ([Table 2](#tab2){ref-type="table"}). Then we used the graph merge tool to merge the TCM pharmacologic networks with the RA pattern networks ([Figure 3(b)](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). In [Figure 3(b)](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}, all nodes and lines in the background represent RA molecular networks. Nodes represent proteins and edges represent interactions. The cold pattern of RA is shown on the left, and the hot pattern is shown on the right. The red and green nodes represent the proteins that may be targeted by one herbal product in the TCM therapy, and the yellow nodes represent proteins that could be targeted by both herbal products in the TCM therapy or by the interaction between the two herbal products in the TCM therapy. Clearly, TCM therapy could target all three hot-pattern clusters (shown on the right side: I-kappa B kinase/NF-kappa B, and mRNA splicing), and a small part of the 4 cold-pattern clusters (shown on the left side: regulation of translation, protein ubiquitination pathway, JAK-STAT cascade, and RNA splicing), as well as a majority of nodes in the intersection region. The results suggest that the involved pathways in the TCM therapy may partly explain why the TCM therapy was more effective in treating hot-pattern RA patients. 3.4. Effectiveness of the Interventions on the Patients with TCM Pattern Change {#sec3.4} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- TCM pattern can vary following the changes of symptoms. The 13 TCM symptoms in all patients were analyzed with factor analysis to define the TCM pattern changes. In [Table 3](#tab3){ref-type="table"}, Cold feeling in the whole body, cold feeling in the limbs, and cold feeling in the joints were classified as factor 1. Thirst, feverish joints, turbid yellow colored urine, and fever were classified as factor 2. Then the factor scores for each patient were calculated according to the factor loadings of symptoms. Based on the cluster of symptoms for TCM pattern classification, if the patient\'s factor 1 score was \>1 and factor 2 score was \<1, the patient was classified as factor 1 pattern (similar to typical hot pattern in TCM), and if the patient\'s factor 1 score was \<1 and factor 2 score was \>1, the patient would be classified as factor 2 pattern (similar to typical cold pattern in TCM). In this study, in order to simplify the TCM pattern and easily analyze the TCM pattern change during the therapeutic process, if the patient\'s factor 1 score was \> or =1, the patient was classified as factor 1 pattern (cold dominant pattern, or cold mixed with hot pattern), and other patients with factor 1 score \<1 would be classified as noncold dominant pattern (they might be or might not be with hot pattern). Based on the criteria for TCM pattern classification, 115 patients were identified as having TCM cold dominant pattern and 99 patients as noncold dominant pattern in TCM treated patients, and 87 patients were identified as having TCM cold dominant pattern and 107 patients as noncold dominant pattern in biomedicine treated patients. Six months after the treatment, the TCM pattern changed in some patients ([Table 4](#tab4){ref-type="table"}). [Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"} shows the ACR 20 response (effective rate) change following the TCM pattern change in TCM and biomedicine group. The upper part of [Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"} shows that, after treatment for 24 weeks, the effective rate of the TCM therapy in the patients who showed TCM pattern changes from cold dominant pattern to noncold dominant pattern was higher (*P* \< 0.05). The effective rate in the patients who showed TCM noncold dominant pattern to cold dominant pattern was lower (*P* \< 0.05). The Lower part of [Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"} shows that, after treatment for 24 weeks, the effective rate in the patients who showed TCM cold dominant pattern to noncold dominant pattern was similar to those continuing with cold dominant pattern (*P* \> 0.05), though the effective rate of the biomedical combination therapy in the patients who showed TCM pattern changes from noncold dominant pattern to cold dominant pattern was lower (*P* \< 0.05); the sample size was too small (23 cases) to yield the conclusion. 3.5. Molecular Mechanism for the Effect of Two Interventions in RA Patients with TCM Pattern Changes {#sec3.5} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Firstly the intersection (b)etween the cold and hot patterns was further analyzed ([Figure 5](#fig5){ref-type="fig"}) and the major pathways involved in the intersections included the protein ubiquitin pathway ([Table 5](#tab5){ref-type="table"}). Then, we checked back the major pathways induced by the biomedical combination therapy and the TCM therapy (Tables [1](#tab1){ref-type="table"} and [2](#tab2){ref-type="table"}). It was found that the regulation of ubiquitin-protein ligase activity during mitotic cell cycle was the pathway affected by MTX + SSZ combination therapy ([Table 1](#tab1){ref-type="table"}), and no similar pathway can be affected with the TCM therapy ([Table 2](#tab2){ref-type="table"}). These results suggest that the efficacy of biomedical intervention was less likely influenced by TCM pattern changes, while the efficacy of the TCM therapy was most likely influenced by TCM pattern change. The explanations were supported in our clinical data ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). However, TCM pattern transition is complicated, and more data are warranted for further clarification. 4. Discussion {#sec4} ============= The major finding in this paper is that it is the first time to clarify the molecular mechanism of interventions in treating RA patients with corresponding TCM cold and hot patterns. This study further suggests that TCM pattern classification can help stratify and tailor the patients for a specific intervention and thus improve the effectiveness of the intervention. Pattern differentiation in TCM is based primarily on the patient\'s symptoms \[[@B4], [@B17]\]. TCM symptoms assessed in RA patients include those unrelated to the musculoskeletal system. TCM pattern would determine the selection of herbal formula, and previous study also showed that the effective rate of biomedical intervention was higher in treating RA patients with TCM cold pattern \[[@B18]\], which indicates that TCM pattern classification can be regarded as a complementary diagnostic method for patient stratification. A full understanding of the mechanism of TCM pattern expression could aid in our elucidation of the pathogenesis of disease and facilitate the development of improved therapeutic regimens. However, it is very difficult to conduct studies on TCM pattern expression using existing conventional methods \[[@B4]\], because TCM pattern expression is a complicated system, consisting of various manifestations that are seemingly independent from currently accepted biomedical mechanisms. Recent advances in the "-omics" (proteomics, genomics, etc.), bioinformatics, and systems biology have provided us an opportunity to integrate multidimensional data. Bioinformatics and systems biology approaches may open the way to a new convergence of TCM and biomedical approaches in both concept and methodology. Our previous studies have shown the biological networks of RA patients with TCM cold or hot pattern \[[@B5]\], and the network of TCM pattern would be helpful for elucidating the mechanism of intervention in treating RA patients with corresponding TCM patterns. The therapeutic mechanism of an intervention is in fact a biological network comprising hundreds or even thousands of gene expressions, which vary between different tissues and effector cells. Systems biology approaches predict biological networks and can lead to a superior insight of biological systems as a whole. Our previous results about the analysis on *Salvia miltiorrhiza* (SM) and *Panax notoginseng* (PN) in combination (SMPN) demonstrated that the therapeutic mechanism of SMPN was likely to associate with proliferation and apoptosis of endothelial cell, apoptosis of arterial smooth muscle cell, apoptosis and regulation of the immune system process within macrophages during foam cell formation, and cardiocyte apoptosis \[[@B7]\]. For other herbal formulae, the pharmacological networks were established with similar methods \[[@B20], [@B21]\]. In regard to even a pure compound, its pharmacological activity could be explained with a molecular network, and a study showed that Integrin *α*2*β*1 might be one of the direct target proteins of salvianolic acid B (SB) in platelets; the signal cascades network of SB after binding with integrin *α*2*β*1 might include regulation of intracellular Ca²^+^ level, cytoskeleton-related proteins such as coronin-1B, and cytoskeleton structure of platelets \[[@B22]\]. In this study, we built up the networks of TCM herbal formula and the biomedical combination therapy, and merged them with the TCM pattern networks in RA patients. The results at least clarify partially the molecular mechanism on the two interventions in treating RA patients with TCM cold or hot pattern. Symptoms vary during the treatment; therefore, TCM patterns in RA patients might change over time. In the clinical trial, all therapies were fixed for the RA patients who met the inclusion criteria. The data in this paper is analyzed retrospectively, and statistical factor analysis was used to divide the RA patients into different groups based on their symptoms obtained at the beginning of the trial, then the patients were classified into two groups with cold or hot pattern for the general ACR 20 responsive rate calculation. Similarly we identified those patients into TCM patterns based on the information before and after the treatment, and pattern changes in some cases. In order to explore the mechanism underlying the efficacy changes of the interventions followed by the TCM pattern changes, the intersection (b)etween TCM cold and hot patterns in RA patients was analyzed with PPI method in the view of molecular network, and then the pathways involved in the intersection network were compared with the pathways involved in the pharmacological network of the two interventions for the mechanism exploration. All together, the results suggest that molecular network analysis can be used to clarify the underlying molecular mechanism of intervention in treating RA patients with different TCM patterns, and also the results further support that TCM pattern classification (including pattern change) could be useful in stratifying RA patients for the improvement of the intervention. Further RCTs with TCM pattern identification at beginning were needed. Molecular network medicine becomes a hot topic, and the molecular networks of some diseases have been built up with text mining and bioinformatic approaches \[[@B23]\]. These molecular networks could be useful for therapeutic mechanism elucidation or new drug discovery \[[@B24], [@B25]\]. However there was not enough information about the patients with TCM pattern expression for building up the molecular network of the TCM pattern in certain diseases; more data from clinical trials are urgently needed in future studies. The major limitation in this report is that only two patterns in RA (cold and hot) were discussed, due to their highly representative features of TCM patterns in RA. However, TCM patterns are diverse and complicated even in a well-established disease such as RA. For example, deficiency pattern is another common TCM pattern in RA. Deficiency pattern has a high incidence rate in elderly patients and among those with late-stage RA. Though the molecular network of the RA deficiency pattern is under construction, TCM pattern diagnosis is complicated allowing for the variety of patterns which exist and the fact that patients often present with a mixture of patterns. Designing an efficient way to study such complex TCM patterns remains an interesting and urgent issue. 5. Conclusions {#sec5} ============== The biomedical combination therapy and TCM therapy were more effective in treating RA patients with TCM cold and hot patterns, respectively, and the mechanisms were partially in affecting the different pathways of the TCM pattern molecular networks in RA patients targeted by the pharmacological molecular networks of the interventions. All together, our results suggest that the mechanism in treating some diseases with corresponding TCM patterns could be explored by merging molecular pharmacological networks of the interventions and the networks of the disease with TCM corresponding patterns. M. Jiang, C. Lu and G. Chen equally contributed to this work. This study was supported jointly by the National Science Foundation of China (nos. 30825047 and 30902003), and China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences (nos. Z0195 and Z0218). ACR: : American College of Rheumatology ATP: : Adenosine triphosphate BIND: : Biomolecular Interaction Network Database BiNGO: : Biological Network Gene Ontology BioGRID: : The General Repository for Interaction Datasets DIP: : Database of Interacting Proteins DMARDs: : Disease modifying antirheumatic drugs GMP: : Good Manufacturing Practice GO: : Gene ontology HPRD: : Human Protein Reference Database IntAct: : Database system and analysis tools for protein interaction data IPA: : Ingenuity pathways analysis LCA: : Latent class analysis MINT: : Molecular Interactions Database MTX: : Methotrexate NSAIDs: : Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs PN: : Panax notoginseng PPI: : Protein-protein interaction RA: : Rheumatoid arthritis RNA: : Ribonucleic acid SB: : Salvianolic acid B SMPN: : *Salvia miltiorrhiza* and *Panax notoginseng* in combination SM: : *Salvia miltiorrhiza* SSZ: : Sulfasalazine TCM: : Traditional Chinese medicine. {#fig1} {ref-type="table"}. The green nodes represent the proteins which could be targeted by either MTX or SSZ, or by the interaction between MTX and SSZ. (b) shows the merged networks of MTX + SSZ pharmacological networks and RA pattern networks. Node represents protein; edge represents interaction. Left part is for cold pattern, and right part for hot pattern. The dots between cold and hot pattern are the intersection between the two TCM patterns. The green nodes represent the proteins which could be targeted by either MTX or SSZ, or by the interaction between MTX and SSZ.](ECAM2012-129452.002){#fig2} {ref-type="table"}. Greed colored nodes represent nodes affected by either Glucosidorum Tripterygll Totorum tablet or Yishen Juanbi Tablet, yellow nodes represent nodes affected by the interaction of Glucosidorum Tripterygll Totorum tablet and Yishen Juanbi Tablet. Red colored nodes represent nonaffected nodes. (b) shows the merged networks of TCM intervention pharmacological networks and RA pattern networks. Node represents protein, and edge represents interaction. Left part is for cold pattern, and right part is for hot pattern. The dots between cold and hot patterns are the intersection between the two TCM patterns. The red and green colored nodes represent the proteins which could be targeted by one of the TCM products, and the yellow nodes represent the proteins which could be targeted by both TCM products, or by the interaction between the two TCM products.](ECAM2012-129452.003){#fig3} {#fig4} {#fig5} ###### Most related pathways affected by MTX + SZZ combination. ID Description *P* value ------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------- 6395 RNA splicing 2.15*E* − 196 6119 Oxidative phosphorylation 2.98*E* − 132 7165 Signal transduction 6.364*E* − 24 7264 Small GTPase mediated signal transduction 2.695*E* − 23 42773 ATP synthesis coupled electron transport 0.0005551 51436 Regulation of ubiquitin-protein ligase activity during mitotic cell cycle 3.178*E* − 19 9607 Response to biotic stimulus 2.927*E* − 05 7596 Blood coagulation 1.858*E* − 23 12501 Programmed cell death 4.023*E* − 11 7169 Transmembrane receptor protein tyrosine kinase signaling pathway 2.405*E* − 23 19 Regulation of mitotic recombination 3.914*E* − 11 ###### Most related pathways affected by TCM intervention. ID Description *P* value ------- ----------------------------------------------------- -------------- 6260 DNA replication 8.87*E* − 33 8543 Fibroblast growth factor receptor signaling pathway 4.35*E* − 34 8633 Activation of proapoptotic gene products 4.39*E* − 15 12501 Programmed cell death 5.5*E* − 09 44249 Cellular biosynthetic process 6.15*E* − 11 7265 Ras protein signal transduction 1.27*E* − 08 7242 Intracellular signaling cascade 3.18*E* − 14 51242 Positive regulation of cellular process 3.42*E* − 13 51244 Regulation of cellular process 3.1*E* − 12 51252 Regulation of RNA metabolic process 7.83*E* − 09 ###### Two factors obtained in factor analysis after oblique PROMAX rotation\*. Symptoms Factor 1 Factor 2 ----------------------------- ---------- ---------- Cold feeling in whole body 0.710   Cold feeling in joints 0.645   Cold feeling in limbs 0.600   Lassitude 0.580 0.280 Heavy feeling in limbs 0.514 0.445 Numbness in limbs 0.359 0.220 Vexation 0.334 0.544 Feverish joint   0.510 Thirst   0.457 Nocturia 0.260 0.358 Dizziness 0.240 0.347 Turbid yellow colored urine   0.331 Fever   0.297 \*The data in the table are factor loadings obtained after oblique PROMAX rotation. The factor loading indicates the correlation power of the symptom with the factor. A loading value of more than 0.20 manifests a definite correlation of the symptom with the factor. ###### TCM pattern changes after treatment for 24 week treatment.   Pattern change Case no. ----------------------------------- ----------------------- ---------- TCM group Cold dominant remains 49 Cold dominant to noncold dominant 56 Noncold dominant remains 75 Noncold dominant to cold dominant 33 Biomedicine group Cold dominant remains 57 Cold dominant to noncold dominant 30 Noncold dominant remains 84 Noncold dominant to cold dominant 23 ###### Pathways involved in the intersection between TCM cold and hot patterns in RA. ID Description *P* value ------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------- 51436 Negative regulation of ubiquitin-protein ligase activity during mitotic cell cycle 3.14*E* − 78 31145 Anaphase-promoting complex-dependent proteasomal ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process 3.14*E* − 78 51352 Negative regulation of ligase activity 8.96*E* − 78 51444 Positive regulation of ubiquitin-protein ligase activity 8.96*E* − 78 51437 Positive regulation of ubiquitin-protein ligase activity during mitotic cell cycle 6.7*E* − 77 51443 Positive regulation of ubiquitin-protein ligase activity 1.76*E* − 76 51439 Regulation of ubiquitin-protein ligase activity during mitotic cell cycle 1.14*E* − 75 51351 Positive regulation of ligase activity 2.79*E* − 75 51438 Regulation of ubiquitin-prtein ligase activity 8.31*E* − 74 51340 Regulation of ligase activity 8.83*E* − 73 [^1]: Academic Editor: Zhaoxiang Bian

\section{Introduction} \label{sec:intro} In-situ production of radioactive isotopes by cosmic muon interactions constitutes a non-negligible background for rare event searches and may define a minimum depth for experiments aiming for ultra-low backgrounds \cite{MeiHime}. In \cite{NIMA} the muon induced background for the \textsc{Gerda} (GErmanium Detector Array) experiment \cite{GerdaEPJC} at \textsc{Lngs} (Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso) of \textsc{Infn} was studied. The delayed decays of {$^{77}$Ge} and its isomeric state {$^{77m}$Ge} were identified as dominant cosmogenic background in \textsc{Gerda}'s search for neutrinoless double beta ({$0\nu\beta\beta$}) decay of {$^{76}$Ge}. {$^{77(m)}$Ge} is formed by neutron capture on the double beta isotope {$^{76}$Ge} itself.\footnote{The notation {$^{77(m)}$Ge} represents {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge}.} A background contribution of (1.1$\pm$0.2)$\cdot10^{-4}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr) at {$0\nu\beta\beta$} relevant energies before active background rejection cuts was reported. This is well below the background of \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II, but might constitute a significant fraction of the background budget for the next generation experiment \textsc{Legend} (Large Enriched Germanium Experiment for Neutrinoless $\beta\beta$ Decay) \cite{LegendMedex}. \textsc{Legend} is aiming to perform a background-free search for {$0\nu\beta\beta$} decay with increased {$^{76}$Ge} mass. In this work a re-evaluation of the {$^{77(m)}$Ge} background in \textsc{Gerda} is carried out by a set of Monte Carlo simulations. They use the actual Phase\,II geometry and up-to-date {$^{76}$Ge} neutron capture cross section data. A description of the \textsc{Gerda} setup and its Monte Carlo implementation can be found in Section~\ref{sec:gerda}. Results from {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} decay simulations and the impact of active background suppression techniques are shown in Section~\ref{sec:ge77}. The production of {$^{77(m)}$Ge} by cosmic muon induced neutrons is discussed in Section~\ref{sec:ncapture}. Prospects for reduction by delayed coincidence cuts are described in Section~\ref{sec:cuts}. In Section~\ref{sec:others} minor cosmogenic background contributions from other sources are discussed briefly. Final conclusions on the feasibility of a next generation {$^{76}$Ge} experiment at \textsc{Lngs} exploiting the \textsc{Gerda} passive and active shielding approach are drawn in Section~\ref{sec:concl}. \section{\textsc{Gerda}} \label{sec:gerda} \textsc{Gerda} is searching for the $0\nu\beta\beta$ decay of {$^{76}$Ge}. High purity germanium (HPGe) detectors enriched in {$^{76}$Ge} constitute simultaneously source and detector for the search of the mono-energetic line at the Q-value of 2039~keV ({$Q_{\beta\beta}$}). \textsc{Gerda} is situated in Hall A of the \textsc{Lngs} underground laboratory of \textsc{Infn} in Italy. \textsc{Lngs} provides an overburden of 3500~m.w.e. and a residual muon flux of $\sim$1.25~m$^{-2}$h$^{-1}$. The outermost part of the experiment is a 590~m$^3$ water tank. The water efficiently acts as neutron absorber and is equipped with photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) to serve as Cherenkov veto for cosmic muons. The muon veto system is completed by plastic scintillator panels on top of the experiment. The water tank surrounds a cryostat filled with 64~m$^3$ of liquid argon (LAr). The instrumentation is lowered into this cryostat from a clean room on top of the experiment via an air-tight lock system. The first phase of \textsc{Gerda} (Phase\,I) was performed between 2011 and 2013 \cite{GerdaPRL}. In Phase\,II 40 HPGe detectors are operated in a 7 string array configuration. 37 of them are made from isotopically enriched germanium material with an enrichment fraction of 87\% {$^{76}$Ge}. They constitute a detector mass of 35.6~kg. The 3 remaining detectors feature natural isotopic composition. The LAr volume around the array is instrumented with wavelength shifting fibers coupled to silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) \cite{Fiber1,Fiber2} and low-activity PMTs. The ability to detect scintillation light allows to reject backgrounds with coincident energy release in HPGe detectors and LAr \cite{LArGe}. Results from Phase\,II were published in \cite{GerdaNature,GerdaPRL2}. A detailed description of the \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II setup can be found in \cite{upgrade}. \subsection{Monte Carlo implementation} \label{subsec:mc} The Monte Carlo simulations for this work were carried out by the \textsc{Geant4}-based \cite{geant4_1,geant4_2,geant4_3} \textsc{MaGe} framework \cite{MaGe}. It is jointly developed and maintained by the \textsc{Gerda} and \textsc{Majorana} \cite{Mjd} collaborations. The \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II implementation includes all relevant components of the experiment as well as the rock surroundings of Hall A at \textsc{Lngs}. The simulations in this work are performed with \textsc{MaGe} built against \textsc{Geant4} 10.3. The default physics list of \textsc{MaGe} is used.\footnote{Simulations with the reference Shielding physics list provided by \textsc{Geant4} produced equal results.} It corresponds to the reference physics list QGSP\_BERT\_HP of \textsc{Geant4}. Inelastic interactions of nucleons and pions are simulated according to the theory-driven quark-gluon string (QGS) model above 20~GeV; according to the Fritiof (FTF) model between 10 and 20~GeV; and according to the Bertini cascade (BERT) model below~10 GeV. Interactions of neutrons below 20~MeV and down to thermal energies are described accurately by the high-precision data-driven models (NeutronHP) based on the evaluated ENDF/B-VII data libraries \cite{endf}. The specialized low-energy models based on the Livermore data library are used for the electromagnetic interactions of electrons and $\gamma$ rays. The model for muon-nuclear interaction is G4MuNuclearInteraction. This physics list has been shown to provide good performance in handling low-energy electromagnetic interactions as well as hadronic showers initiated by high-energy cosmic muons \cite{MaGe}. The production of isotopes in muon induced cascades can be either due to the hadronic (or lepton-nuclear) interactions within the hadronic shower, or to secondary neutrons emerging from the shower. The former is the dominant mechanism for the production of nuclei (A,Z) "far away'' with respect to the target nucleus (e.g. {$^{60}$Co} production from Ge). The production of "nearby'' nuclei is mostly ascribed to secondary neutron interactions, as radiative capture (n,$\gamma$) and inelastic scattering (n,X), e.g. (n,p). This is the case of the most relevant species discussed in this paper, namely {$^{77(m)}$Ge} from {$^{76}$Ge}, {$^{41}$Ar} and {$^{40}$Cl} from {$^{40}$Ar}. The evaluation of the neutron-mediated production yield involves two ingredients, namely the generation of neutrons from the muon induced showers and the neutron tracking down to their capture/interaction, which may happen at thermal energies. The capability of \textsc{Geant4} to provide a realistic estimate of the muon induced neutron production in underground sites has been widely discussed in the literature (see e.g. \cite{Araujo:2004rv,Kudryavtsev:2008fi,Reichhart:2013xkd}). The neutron yield predicted by \textsc{Geant4} for muon induced interactions in a low-A target, as organic liquid scintillator, was found to agree with the experimental results from KamLAND within 10\% \cite{Abe:2009aa}. As for neutron production in high-A materials, the recent work of \cite{Abt:2016nor,Du:2018mzh} reports that \textsc{Geant4} under-estimates it by a factor of 3-4 in Pb for cosmic muons at shallow depth ($\langle E_{\mu} \rangle$=7~GeV). However, \cite{Reichhart:2013xkd} shows that \textsc{Geant4} slightly over-estimates the neutron production in Pb in a deep underground laboratory ($\langle E_{\mu} \rangle$=~260 GeV) by 25\% and that the choice of the physics list has a <~5\% impact. The weak dependency on the physics list was also observed in \cite{MaGe}: the differences in neutron yield from high-energy muons in metallic germanium were found to be within 15\%. As the configuration in \cite{Reichhart:2013xkd} is more representative of the muon energy spectrum at \textsc{Lngs} ($\langle E_{\mu} \rangle$=270 GeV) than in \cite{Du:2018mzh}, the systematic uncertainty on the muon-induced neutron production is taken to be 25\%. This is also reasonably conservative, as the \textsc{Gerda} setup is composed entirely by low-A materials, with water and argon being the most relevant. \begin{figure*}[t] \centering \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig1} \caption{ Left: Simplified decay scheme for {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge}. Both isotopes undergo $\beta$-decay to {$^{77}$As}. {$^{77m}$Ge} undergoes mainly pure ground-state decay without the release of coincident $\gamma$'s. Middle/Right: Spectra for {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} decays in enriched detectors of \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II. The reduction by consecutive application of active background rejection techniques is shown. The spectra are normalized to represent the spectral contribution per decay, the binning is 20 keV. The inset shows the R$_{90}$ distribution for events around {$Q_{\beta\beta}$}. It is used to model the multi-site event rejection by PSD. } \label{fig:decay} \end{figure*} As mentioned above, the data-driven NeutronHP models based on the ENDF/B-VII data libraries are used for the tracking of neutrons below 20~MeV. The error due to the interpolation of adjacent data points is smaller than a few percent \cite{geant_manual}. It has been shown in \cite{Lemrani:2006dq} that the agreement for the neutron propagation between Geant4 and the MCNPX code \cite{mcnpx}, which uses tabulated data from the alternative JENDL database \cite{jendl}, is better than 20\%, and often within 10\%. Taking also into account the study of \cite{Pritychenko:2014ida}, the global uncertainty for neutron propagation due to the \textsc{Geant4} NeutronHP models is estimated here to be 20\%. When combining the two terms in quadrature, the global systematic uncertainty for isotope production mediated by muon induced neutrons results to be 35\%, provided that the cross sections for the relevant isotopes are included in the ENDF/B-VII library.\footnote{The uncertainty is slightly smaller than used in \cite{NIMA}, given the additional studies on muon induced neutron yields of \cite{Abe:2009aa,Reichhart:2013xkd}.} The systematic uncertainty on the production yield is substantially larger for those nuclei that are mostly produced by other mechanisms which do not involve neutrons, as lepto-nuclear reactions, direct spallation or high-energy proton scattering. This can be up to a factor of four for germanium targets and for the product nuclei of interest for this work \cite{Wei:2017hkq,Cebrian:2017oft}. \subsection{Active background rejection} \label{subsec:vetos} Apart from passive background reduction in terms of graded passive shielding and extensive material selection efforts, active background rejection is a key feature of the \textsc{Gerda} experimental approach. The electrons released in {$^{76}$Ge} double beta decay will deposit their energy within short range in one single site in one HPGe detector. Background events exhibiting a different topology can be efficiently rejected by the means of active background rejection techniques \cite{NeutrinoProceedings}. Events with simultaneous energy depositions in multiple HPGe detectors are rejected by detector anti-coincidence (AC). A realistic offline trigger threshold of 10~keV in the AC condition of simulated data is used. Analogously events with coincident energy deposition in the LAr surroundings are suppressed by the Phase\,II scintillation light read-out system (LAr veto). For the sake of computing power a simplified effective model is used. Events are rejected if a coincident energy deposition in the LAr volume contained by the light instrumentation exceeds 150~keV. The finite drift time of charge carriers in HPGe detectors allows to discriminate events differing from single-site bulk energy depositions by pulse shape discrimination (PSD) \cite{PSD}. The multi-site event rejection of PSD is modeled by a simple post-simulation parametrization described in \cite{R90}. The parameter R$_{90}$, defined as the radius from the barycenter of energy depositions containing 90\% of the deposited energy, is calculated per HPGe detector. Energy depositions exceeding a size of 2~mm in R$_{90}$ are classified as rejected. The signal acceptance for simulated {$0\nu\beta\beta$} events with energy deposition at {$Q_{\beta\beta}$} is 97.3\% (see inset in Figure~\ref{fig:decay}). This approximative model allows to draw fast and simple conclusions on the multi-site rejection performance by PSD without the need for sophisticated pulse shape simulations. The parameters used in this simplified modeling of the active background rejection are chosen to represent a conservative estimate in comparison to experiences with the \textsc{Gerda} setup. Ongoing efforts for next generation of experiments aim for improved background suppression performance by e.g. increased LAr light yield, improved photon detection and low threshold/low noise HPGe detector read-out electronics. The obtained results hence represent a conservative baseline for future experiments. \section{Active suppression of {$^{77(m)}$Ge} decays} \label{sec:ge77} With a Q-value of about 2.7 MeV both the $\beta$-decays of {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} contribute to the background of experiments searching for $0\nu\beta\beta$ decay with {$^{76}$Ge}. The simplified decay scheme is depicted in Figure~\ref{fig:decay}. The half-life is 11.2~h for {$^{77}$Ge} and 53.7~s for {$^{77m}$Ge} \cite{Ge77}. With a probability of (19$\pm$2)\% {$^{77m}$Ge} undergoes internal transition to {$^{77}$Ge} and emits a $\gamma$ with 160~keV. The direct transition between the ground states of {$^{77}$Ge} and of its daughter nucleus {$^{77}$As} is spin-suppressed. All {$^{77}$Ge} $\beta$-decays are followed by $\gamma$ emission from de-excitation of {$^{77}$As} excited states. A minimum of 195 keV corresponding to the first excited state of {$^{77}$As} is released in coincidence. This results in a high chance to reduce this background by state-of-the-art active background rejection techniques. Vice-versa {$^{77m}$Ge} decays in (58$\pm$4)\% via pure ground-state decay without emitting additional $\gamma$'s. A single $\beta$ released in the bulk of a HPGe detector represents a similar topology as double beta events. Hence, a large fraction of this background is expected to be irreducible by the current background rejection techniques based on prompt coincidences. Nevertheless, the comparably short half-life of {$^{77m}$Ge} opens up the possibility for rejection by delayed coincidence cuts as discussed in Section~\ref{sec:cuts}. {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} decays have been simulated in enriched HPGe detectors of the \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II array. The obtained spectra are shown in Figure~\ref{fig:decay}. The inset shows the R$_{90}$ distribution in comparison with the single-site dominated distribution for $0\nu\beta\beta$ decays. As expected from decay scheme considerations, the suppression by active background rejection is large for {$^{77}$Ge} only. The shape of the final spectrum after application of AC, LAr veto and PSD multi-site rejection reveals the contributions from $\beta$'s to different levels of the {$^{77}$As} daughter nucleus. Different $\gamma$ emissions from subsequent de-excitations are visible in the unsuppressed spectrum prior cuts. Only minor suppression is achieved for {$^{77m}$Ge}. It is driven by a subdominant transition via the 215~keV state of {$^{77}$As}. The unsuppressed 160~keV peak corresponds to the internal transition, the subsequent decay is taken into account in the {$^{77}$Ge} spectrum. The resulting spectral contributions at $Q_{\beta\beta}\pm$100~keV are summarized in Table~\ref{tab:param}. Generally $\beta$'s are contained in a single detector. The dominance of $\beta$'s in the {$^{77m}$Ge} energy release manifests in a larger initial contribution at {$Q_{\beta\beta}$} and less rejection power by active background suppression based on prompt coincidences. \begin{table} \centering \caption{ Spectral contribution of {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} decays at $Q_{\beta\beta}\pm$100~keV before and after application of detector anti-coincidence (AC), liquid argon (LAr) veto and PSD multi-site rejection (R$_{90}).$ } \label{tab:param} \begin{tabular*}{\columnwidth}{@{\extracolsep{\fill}}lcc@{}} \hline & {$^{77}$Ge} & {$^{77m}$Ge} \\ & [10$^{-5}$ keV$^{-1}$] & [10$^{-5}$ keV$^{-1}$] \\ \hline prior cuts & 12.6 & 23.3 \\ after AC & 10.5 & 22.4 \\ after AC and LAr veto & 7.5 & 21.2 \\ after AC, LAr veto and R$_{90}$ cut & 1.2 & 17.0 \\ \hline \end{tabular*} \end{table} \section{Cosmic muon induced {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production} \label{sec:ncapture} The cosmic muon induced production of radioactive isotopes was studied by the Monte Carlo simulation of muons impinging the \textsc{Gerda} setup. Their distribution in energy and direction was simulated with the \textsc{Musun} \cite{Musun} Monte Carlo code and is shown in Figure~\ref{fig:muons}. The mean energy of the muons is 270~GeV. The azimuth and zenith angle distributions follow the profile of the Gran Sasso mountain. The code has been validated against measurements by the LVD experiment \cite{lvd} situated next to \textsc{Gerda} in Hall A of the \textsc{Lngs} underground laboratory. In total 1$\cdot$10$^8$ muons were released from a 12x12x13~m$^3$ sized box around the \textsc{Gerda} setup.\footnote{No sufficient range to generate hadronic showers in the surrounding Gran Sasso rock is included (see Figure~\ref{fig:neutrons}). Simulations including additional meters of rock led to similar results, but less statistics due to increased CPU time.} This corresponds to a lifetime of 43.4~yr or 1544~kg$\cdot$yr of \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II exposure. \begin{figure}[bt] \centering \includegraphics[width=\columnwidth]{fig2} \caption{ Energy spectrum and azimuth/zenith angle correlation of muons produced by the \textsc{Musun} \cite{Musun} code to imping the \textsc{Gerda} setup. } \label{fig:muons} \end{figure} Among other particles, neutrons are produced in various processes induced by cosmic muons. The main production channels are photon nuclear interactions and the production of secondary neutrons from inelastic neutron interactions. Figure~\ref{fig:neutrons} shows the spatial distribution of neutron production vertices. The muon induced neutron flux at the position of the HPGe detector array is 1.6~m$^{-2}$h$^{-1}$. This is less than the 5.7~m$^{-2}$h$^{-1}$ obtained in \cite{NIMA}. The difference can be attributed to the updated \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II setup with respect to the original design (notably, the different shape, dimensions and material of the cryostat) and to changes in \textsc{Geant4}. After scattering down in energy, neutrons end up to be absorbed in materials of the \textsc{Gerda} setup. The production vertices of neutrons eventually forming {$^{77(m)}$Ge} in the germanium detectors are highlighted in Figure~\ref{fig:neutrons}. Mainly neutrons generated in the LAr cryostat walls or in the LAr volume contribute to the {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production. The water tank efficiently shields the detector array from other neutrons. All muons initiating the production of {$^{77(m)}$Ge} point towards the cryostat volume. Proper tracking capability for muons might allow to identify muons associated with neutron production in the inner part of the experiment. \begin{figure}[bt] \centering \includegraphics[width=\columnwidth]{fig3} \caption{ Cosmic muon induced neutron production in the \textsc{Gerda} geometry. The production vertices for neutrons being captured by {$^{76}$Ge} and the corresponding muons are highlighted. } \label{fig:neutrons} \end{figure} The cross section for neutron capture on {$^{76}$Ge} has been recently measured at different energies \cite{Meierhofer, Marganiec, Bhike}. The evaluations are based on the determination of $\gamma$ intensities involved in the {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} decay. The directly accessible quantities are $\sigma$ and $\sigma_m$. The cross section $\sigma$ includes the direct {$^{77}$Ge} production cross section $\sigma_d$ and (19$\pm$2)\% of internal transitions from {$^{77m}$Ge}, whereas $\sigma_m$ describes the {$^{77m}$Ge} production only. The G4NDL library responsible for neutron capture on {$^{76}$Ge} in \textsc{Geant4} is based on ENDF/B-VII-1 tabulated data, which does not provide $\sigma_d$~+~$\sigma_m$ for total {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production. The ratio of $\sigma_m$ to $\sigma_d$~+~$\sigma_m$ measured at different neutron energies is shown in Figure~\ref{fig:capture}. With increasing neutron energy the cross sections favor {$^{77}$Ge} over {$^{77m}$Ge} production, as higher neutron energies may result in higher excited states \cite{Bhike}. Considering the neutron energies involved in the in-situ {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production a constant ratio for $\sigma_m$ to $\sigma_d$~+~$\sigma_m$ of (50$\pm$10)\% is used in this analysis. This implies that the plain \textsc{Geant4} cross section underestimates {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production by 68\%. The Monte Carlo cross section $\sigma_{MC}$ was artificially increased in the performed simulation to account for this. It is depicted in Figure~\ref{fig:capture}. Measurements representing $\sigma_d$~+~$\sigma_m$ agree reasonably well. \begin{figure*}[t] \centering \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig4} \caption{ Left: Recent cross section data for {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} production by neutron capture on {$^{76}$Ge}. To account for full {$^{77m}$Ge} production the cross section used in the simulation was increased by 68\% compared to the plain ENDF-based one. Middle: Ratio of $\sigma_m$ to total $\sigma_d$~+~$\sigma_m$ cross section. An estimate of (50$\pm$10)\% was used in the analysis. The error bars are used to indicate the range of continuous neutron energies. Right: Muon induced {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production rate over neutron energy and time. The Monte Carlo realization corresponds to 1544~kg$\cdot$yr of \textsc{Gerda} Phase\,II exposure. } \label{fig:capture} \end{figure*} Neutron interaction cross-sections of materials in the germanium array vicinity define the spatial and temporal distribution of muon induced neutrons entering the array, especially at low neutron energies where the cross section for neutron capture on $^{40}$Ar dominates. Folding the neutron distribution with the neutron capture on {$^{76}$Ge} cross section the {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production rate was obtained. Figure~\ref{fig:capture} shows the resulting capture rate in neutron energy vs. time. A large fraction of the {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production appears to be prompt (<~10~$\mu$s) after the muon hits the experiment. Only the resonance at 550~eV has strong contribution to delayed captures. The cross section at thermal energies plays a minor role. The simulation yields a production rate of muon induced {$^{77(m)}$Ge} in \textsc{Gerda} of (0.21$\pm$0.01)~nuclei/(kg$\cdot$yr). It represents the main production channel\footnote{Non-cosmogenic {$^{77m}$Ge} production by radiogenic neutrons was found to be one order of magnitude lower.} and allows verification in \textsc{Gerda} and next generation germanium experiments.\footnote{The comparably short half-life of {$^{77m}$Ge} and the presence of a metastable state of {$^{77}$As} at 475~keV with a half-life of 116~$\mu$s in the {$^{77}$Ge} decay open up possibilities to separately measure the {$^{77}$Ge} and {$^{77m}$Ge} production rate.} In combination with the results from Section~\ref{sec:ge77} this leads to a background contribution of (1.5$\pm$0.2)$\cdot10^{-6}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr) from {$^{77}$Ge} and (1.8$\pm$0.4)$\cdot10^{-5}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr) from {$^{77m}$Ge}.\footnote{Internal transitions from {$^{77m}$Ge} to {$^{77}$Ge} are taken into account.} \section{{$^{77m}$Ge} rejection by delayed coincidence} \label{sec:cuts} \begin{figure*}[t] \centering \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig5} \caption{ Left: Prompt germanium detector multiplicity for events tagged as muon event and events with {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production. Only (15$\pm$2)\% of the {$^{77(m)}$Ge} events do not show prompt coincidence between muon veto and germanium detectors. Middle: Timing of {$^{41}$Ar} production. The inset shows the number of accompanying {$^{41}$Ar} siblings for {$^{77(m)}$Ge} events. Right: Delayed (>~10~$\mu$s) multiplicity for events not showing prompt coincidences in the first place. } \label{fig:rejection} \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig6} \caption{ Sequence of the delayed coincidence cut based on tagging by prompt and delayed coincidences between muon veto and germanium detector signals. The delayed signals are mainly provided by capture of thermalized neutrons in the surrounding LAr. The comparably short half-life of {$^{77m}$Ge} allows for suppression by a delayed coincidence cut after receiving either a prompt or delayed tagging signal. The accompanying $\gamma$'s in the subsequent decay are essential in the suppression by standard background rejection techniques based on prompt coincidences. } \label{fig:scheme} \end{figure*} The strong single beta component of {$^{77m}$Ge} is irreducible with background rejection techniques based on prompt coincidences. However, the comparably short half-life of 53.7~s opens up possibilities to reduce this background by delayed coincidence cuts. Neutron capture leaves the daughter nucleus in a highly excited state, according to the available nuclear binding energy and level scheme. Its de-excitation results in the release of $\gamma$'s. In \textsc{Geant4} this is represented by tabulated $\gamma$ emission data \cite{geant_manual}. According to Figure~\ref{fig:capture} most captures on {$^{76}$Ge} appear shortly after the actual muon is detected by the \textsc{Gerda} muon veto system. The read-out scheme will not allow to register separate events in muon veto and germanium detectors if within <~10~$\mu$s. Figure~\ref{fig:rejection} shows the prompt single event multiplicity registered in the germanium detector array for muon events and for muon events with {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production. In addition to the prompt signal from the muon induced shower itself, the $\gamma$ emission from inelastic neutron interactions in and around the array contributes to the enhanced multiplicity for the latter one. The efficiency to tag events with {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production by prompt coincidences (multiplicity $\geq$~1) between muon veto and germanium array is (85$\pm$2)\%. General muon events show this signature with a rate of 1$\cdot$10$^{-4}$~s$^{-1}$. This allows to suppress the {$^{77m}$Ge} background by implementing a delayed coincidence cut that removes several {$^{77m}$Ge} half-lives of data after a prompt tagging signal. A dead-time of 6~min results in a reduction of the {$^{77m}$Ge} background to (3.0$\pm$0.7)$\cdot10^{-6}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr) at an acceptable life time reduction of <~4\%.\footnote{The efficiency of the \textsc{Gerda} muon veto system is (99.2$^{+0.3}_{-0.4}$)\% \cite{MuVeto}.} The number of events featuring a prompt coincidence is larger than the prompt {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production itself. Part of the registered signals originate from other processes triggered by the same incident muon, including accompanying neutron captures in the array surroundings. These sibling captures can be used to improve the tagging efficiency for muon events with accompanying isotope production. {$^{41}$Ar} constitutes the majority of these sibling isotopes. A significant fraction of it is formed by capture of thermalized neutrons. The timing for its production is shown in Figure~\ref{fig:rejection}. It is predominantly described by a capture time of about 271~$\mu$s of thermalized neutrons in LAr. The inset shows the number of {$^{41}$Ar} siblings for {$^{77(m)}$Ge} events, in some cases up to several hundreds of siblings are formed. Their production significantly contributes to prompt and especially delayed signals seen in the germanium array. (60$\pm$7)\% of {$^{77(m)}$Ge} events not showing the prompt signature still exhibit a germanium signal at >~10~$\mu$s. Figure~\ref{fig:rejection} shows the single event multiplicity of these delayed events. This delayed coincidence can be used as further signature to tag muon events with accompanying isotope production. Again the implementation of 6~min dead-time after a delayed tagging coincidence allows to further reduce the {$^{77m}$Ge} background to (1.2$\pm$0.5)$\cdot10^{-6}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr) with negligible life time reduction.\footnote{For a coincidence window of about 1~ms the introduced dead-time is at ${O}(0.1)$\%.} The sequence of processes producing prompt and delayed coincidences between muon veto and germanium detectors is depicted in Figure~\ref{fig:scheme}. In many cases the prompt signal in the germanium detectors is supported by the neutron capture on {$^{76}$Ge} itself, while for the delayed tagging capture of thermalized neutrons in the surrounding LAr is essential. A systematically underestimated isotope production rate by muon induced neutrons as discussed in Section~\ref{subsec:mc} could partly compensate. Larger production rates would manifest in an increased chance to tag {$^{77(m)}$Ge} events. Additional reduction could be achieved by facilitating the LAr instrumentation to increase the efficiency to detect muon events with accompanying isotope production by observation of sibling captures. Due to the much longer life-time delayed coincidence cuts will almost not affect the background by ground state {$^{77}$Ge}. The combined {$^{77(m)}$Ge} background after cuts is (2.7$\pm$0.3)$\cdot10^{-6}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr). However, any improvement in active background suppression based on prompt coincidences like PSD and LAr veto will result in a reduction of the {$^{77}$Ge} contribution to this number. \section{Other muon induced backgrounds} \label{sec:others} Other radioisotopes formed in cosmic muon interactions have only a minor contribution to the background in the search for {$0\nu\beta\beta$} decay of {$^{76}$Ge}. Different backgrounds due to internal and external occurring subsequent decays were studied in \cite{NIMA}. Only sources exceeding $10^{-6}$~cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr) were reported. Simple decay scheme considerations allow to draw qualitative predictions concerning a further suppression of these backgrounds by the \textsc{Gerda} active background rejection strategy and the proposed delayed coincidence cuts. Internal decays of the Ga isotopes {$^{74}$Ga} and {$^{76}$Ga} will face a strong suppression from coincident $\gamma$'s of more than 500~keV released in their $\beta$-decays \cite{Ga74, Ga76}.\footnote{The emission of $\gamma$'s with 2040.7~keV from {$^{76}$Ga} $\beta$-decay mentioned in \cite{Tornow} will face strong suppression by multiple means. The internal $\beta$-decay as well as $\gamma$'s released in the cascade are able to provide prompt coincidences.} Due to its non-negligible ground state $\beta$ transition probability {$^{75}$Ga} will exhibit only marginal suppression. Nevertheless, the short half-lifes of both {$^{75}$Ga} of 126~s and {$^{76}$Ga} of 33~s allow reduction by delayed coincidence. Background originating from {$^{68}$Ge}/{$^{68}$Ga} and {$^{69}$Ge} electron capture/$\beta^{+}$ decays will be suppressed by coincidences in the surrounding LAr or other HPGe detectors \cite{GeGa68, Ge69}. $\beta$-decays of Ar and Cl isotopes in the surrounding LAr are negligible compared to contributions by naturally present background from e.g. {$^{42}$K} decays \cite{minishroud}. The high energy $\gamma$'s from {$^{38}$Cl} and {$^{40}$Cl} decays will be largely suppressed by the coincident energy deposit of the initial $\beta$ in the LAr \cite{Cl38, Cl40}. The prompt muon induced background for the \textsc{Gerda} experiment has been studied in \cite{NIMA} and \cite{MuVeto}. In addition to the muon veto, the active background rejection by AC, LAr veto and PSD further reduces this background. \section{Conclusions and prospects for future experiments} \label{sec:concl} Distinct features in the production and the decay of radioactive isotopes from cosmic muon interactions allow for a strong reduction of these backgrounds in experiments exploiting an active background rejection strategy. The initial {$^{77(m)}$Ge} background is (4.0$\pm$0.4)$\cdot10^{-5}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr). State-of-the-art active background rejection techniques in combination with a simple delayed coincidence cut based on tagging muon events with accompanying isotope production by prompt and delayed coincidences between muon veto and germanium array will allow a reduction by more than one order of magnitude to (2.7$\pm$0.3)$\cdot10^{-6}$ cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr) at an acceptable life-time loss of <~4\%. The systematic uncertainty on this number is 35~\% related to the muon induced isotope production in \textsc{Geant4}. The reduction obtained by the proposed strategy is based on conservative parameters for germanium detector and LAr scintillation light read-out. It amounts to a reduction in muon flux of more than one order of magnitude, which is usually provided by deeper underground laboratories. Taking the equivalent vertical depth definition of \cite{MeiHime} and attributing the reduction linearly to a decrease in muon flux, this corresponds to a Gran Sasso depth exceeding 5000~m.w.e. for {$^{77(m)}$Ge}. In a first stage the next generation experiment \textsc{Legend} will operate about 200~kg of enriched germanium detectors in the \textsc{Gerda} infrastructure at \textsc{Lngs} \cite{LegendMedex}. Similar or better background rejection capabilities will result in a background contribution comparable to the one described in this paper. This is well below the background goal of the \textsc{Legend}-200 phase at about $10^{-4}$~cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr). With a design exposure of about 1~ton$\cdot$yr for \textsc{Legend}-200 will give the unique opportunity to determine the muon induced {$^{77(m)}$Ge} production in-situ at \textsc{Lngs} and thereby verify the predicted rate of 0.21~nuclei/(kg$\cdot$yr). For the following \textsc{Legend}-1k phase a new facility holding up to 1~ton of HPGe detectors is conceived. Already the {$^{77(m)}$Ge} background obtained for the \textsc{Gerda} setup, exploiting the current active background rejection techniques and a simple delayed coincidence cut, is below the aspired background index goal of about $10^{-5}$~cts/(keV$\cdot$kg$\cdot$yr). Further reduction can be achieved provided that rigorous measures are taken during the design stage by geometry optimization and material selection with respect to neutron production and propagation. The possibilities to actively reduce the muon induced background described in this paper equals a virtual increase in \textsc{Lngs} depth and opens the way for next generation experiments with ultra low background requirements. \begin{acknowledgements} The authors would like to thank all members of the \textsc{Gerda} collaboration, and especially R.~Brugnera, P.~Grabmayr, Y.~Kerma\"idic, A.~Lazzaro and A.J.~Zsigmond for their helpful comments and the prolific discussions. We gratefully acknowledge the support by the Collaborative Research Center "Neutrinos and Dark Matter in Astro- and Particle Physics'' (SFB 1258). \end{acknowledgements} \bibliographystyle{plain}

\section{Introduction} Emission from hot ($\sim$ 1500K) dust is so characteristic of AGNs and quasars (e.g. Suganuma et al. 2006) that the strong 1--3$\mu m$ emission from this dust has often been used to select AGN samples (e.g. Miley et al. 1985, Lacy et al. 2004, 2007, Stern et al. 2005, Donley et al. 2008). However, we recently reported (Hao et al. 2010) that, for 6\% (at $z<2$) to 20\% (at $2<z<3.5$) of the quasars in the XMM-COSMOS type 1 AGN sample (Brusa et al. 2010; Elvis et al. 2011), their $1-3\mu m$ emission are two to four times weaker than typical type 1 AGN (e.g., Elvis et al. 1994), although they have normal optical `big-blue-bump' slopes indicative of standard accretion disk emission. We dubbed these `hot-dust-poor' (HDP) quasars. Their implied dust `torus' covering factor is $\sim$2\% to 30\%, well below the 75\% predicted by the unified model (e.g. Krolik \& Begelman 1988). These sources lie at one extreme of the distribution of AGN SEDs found in the XMM-COSMOS sample. Their lack of hot dust emission uncovers a continuum that appears to be the continuation of the accretion disk, which implies a disk size of $\sim 10^4$ Schwarzschild radii, an order of magnitude beyond the gravitational instability radius. The study of Hao et al. (2010) used an X-ray selected sample. To check whether weak dust emission is a property of quasars in general, as opposed to X-ray selected quasars, in this paper we examine a large optical/infrared (IR) selected sample, that of Richards et al. (2006; hereafter R06). As shown in Figure~\ref{zLbol}, R06 also covers a different part of the luminosity/redshift (L,z) plane from the COSMOS-XMM sample, which will help us to test the preliminary claim of Hao et al. (2010) that the HDP fraction changes with redshift but not with luminosity. We also examine the Elvis et al. (1994) sample of low-redshift quasars (hereafter E94). Figure~\ref{zLbol} shows that the three samples together have a good coverage of the (L,z) plane. \begin{figure} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f1.ps} \caption{The bolometric luminosity and redshift of the XMM-COSMOS (squares), R06 (circles) and E94 (triangles) sample. The red solid points are the HDP quasars from these samples. The E94 quasars show a narrow distribution, as they are chosen to be the very brightest quasars in the sky. $L_{bol}$ is calculated as in Hao et al. (2010) by integrating from rest frame 24 $\mu m$ to the Lyman limit (912\AA) and using the WMAP 5-year cosmology: $H_0=71 ~~km~s^{-1}Mpc^{-1}$, $\Omega_M=0.26$ and $\Omega_\Lambda=0.74$ (Komatsu et al., 2009). \label{zLbol}} \end{figure} \section{Type 1 AGN samples} Hao et al. (2010) selected HDP quasars by their position in a plot of optical (OPT, 0.3--1$\mu m$) versus near-infrared (NIR, 1--3$\mu m$) slopes. In this paper, we use the samples of R06 and E94 supplemented by new near-IR UKIDSS data, which gives good enough photometry to define these slopes. \subsection{R06 sample} The R06 sample consists of 259 {\it Spitzer} sources identified with SDSS quasars in four discrete degree-scale fields, and is, therefore, mid-IR and optically selected. We also considered the similar Hatziminaoglou et al. (2008) sample of 278 quasars and found that all but 65 are also in R06 and only 39 of these 65 have Spitzer photometry. We therefore only use R06. The redshift range covered is $z=0.14 - 5.2$ with 93\% being at $z<3$ (Figure~\ref{zLbol}). Most of the data in R06 paper is from SDSS, Spitzer, and 2MASS photometry. These data were not corrected for host galaxy contributions. As R06 is an IR and optically selected sample, the host galaxy contribution should typically be small. As the galaxy SED in the IR and optical is completely different from the typical quasar SED, and IR and optical color selection picks out sources with spectral indices similar to those of a typical quasar, sources with more galaxy contribution are selected against (e.g. Gregg et al. 2002, Richards et al. 2003). Most (215/259) of the R06 sources did not have 2MASS J H K photometry. These bands are essential to make reliable NIR slope estimates for quasars at $z\lesssim0.65$, and to make reliable OPT slope estimates for quasars at $z\gtrsim1.3$. We therefore cross-matched the R06 sample with the UKIDSS database using the online WFCAM science archive. We found additional data for 98 quasars at K and for 45 quasars at J, producing a final subset of 195 R06 quasars that we can use for this study. The UKIDSS data come from the Deep Extragalactic Survey (DXS) fields covering the Lockman Hole and ELAIS-N1. The UKIDSS survey is defined in Lawrence et al (2007). It uses the UKIRT Wide Field Camera (WFCAM; Casali et al, 2007). The photometric system is described in Hewett et al (2006), and the calibration is described in Hodgkin et al. (2009). The pipeline processing and science archive are described in Irwin et al (2010, in prep) and Hambly et al (2008). The magnitudes we use here are ``aper3'' magnitudes, which come from a measurement through a 2 \asec software aperture, corrected to a total magnitude using the point spread function measured in the field. We have not corrected these magnitudes for host galaxy contribution, but we could see that nearly all of these objects only have small extended source contribution, because the UKIDSS database provides a wide range of aperture magnitudes. The magnitudes we use come from stacked observations spreading over several years. From individual epochs, we can see that most of these quasars vary only by a small amount (0.05 mag) within the UKIDSS data, such that it does not seriously affect our analysis. \subsection{E94 sample} The E94 quasar sample consists of both optically-selected quasars from the bright quasar survey (BQS, PG, Schmidt \& Green, 1983) and radio-selected (mainly 3C and PKS) quasars. These quasars were selected to have good signal-to-noise ratio {\it Einstein} X-ray observations and obtainable IUE UV spectra, hence E94 is biased towards X-ray bright and blue quasars. E94 contains 42 quasars in the redshift range $z= 0.025 - 0.94$, with 80\% being at $z<0.3$. The optical photometry were obtained at the FLWO (F. L. Whipple Observatory) 24 inch telescope within one week of the MMT FOGS (Faint Object Grism Spectrograph) observations. The NIR data were obtained with MMT and IRTF. More details on the observation can be found in Elvis et al. (1994). As E94 is mainly a local quasar sample, the E94 SEDs have been corrected for host galaxy contamination by subtracting the host galaxy template SED based on the Sbc galaxy model of Coleman, Wu \& Weedman (1980). The normalization of the galaxy template was calculated by direct measurements of the host galaxy luminosities. \section{Mixing Diagram} To select HDP quasars, we use the mixing diagram technique of Hao et al. (2010), where we select objects that lie outside the region formed by mixing a typical quasar SED with a host galaxy SED, combined with reddening. We use the slope on either side of the 1$\mu$m inflection point, which is where the black-body emission of the hottest dust rises above that of the accretion disk. We build the mixing diagram by plotting two rest frame slopes in $log~\nu L_{\nu}$ versus $log~\nu$ space: $\alpha_{NIR}$ ($3\mu m - 1\mu m$) versus $\alpha_{OPT}$ ($1\mu m - 3000$\AA). These slopes are derived from linear fits to the SEDs in these wavelength ranges. The errors on the slopes are the 1$\sigma$ standard error. We required that at least three photometry points are used to fit the slopes. 88\% of R06 quasars have more than the minimum of three photometry points in the optical and 71\% have more than three points in the near-infrared. The measurement error on the photometry is used in the fitting. For both R06 and E94, all these slopes are measured in the same rest frame wavelength range as the XMM-COSMOS sample. The mixing diagram is equivalent to a color-color plot, but utilizes more photometric points and adapts well to a wide range of redshifts. The mixing diagram is more robust than the normal color-color plot, because it is less affected by one bad photometry point and is built in the rest frame without any need for assumptions about the intrinsic SED shape (k-correction). \subsection{Robustness of Linear Fitting} \label{s:robust} We performed two tests to check if the requirement to have three or more photometry band is adequate to ensure robust slope measurements. \begin{figure*} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.4\textwidth]{f2.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.4\textwidth]{f3.ps} \caption{Histogram of the E94 slopes with the SDSS-Spitzer sampling for the R06 quasars: {\em Left:} $\alpha_{OPT}$; {\em Right:} $\alpha_{NIR}$. The blue dashed lines are the Gaussian fit of the histogram. \label{slphist}} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f4.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f5.ps} \caption{Comparison of the simulated SDSS photometry slopes with the XMM-COSMOS photometry slopes for the XMM-COSMOS quasars: {\em Left:} $\alpha_{OPT}$; {\em Right:} $\alpha_{NIR}$. The red solid line is the equal slope line. The green line is the linear fit of the black points. The two red dashed lines are at the $3\sigma_d$ distance to the equal slope line. The error bars of the slope measurement are shown as yellow.\label{slpcp}} \end{figure*} \begin{description} \item [(1)]~~We use the E94 mean SED as a template. This SED has $\alpha_{OPT}=0.95$ and $\alpha_{NIR}=-0.72$. We made a Monte Carlo sampling of the E94 SED, with the same sampling and error bars as the observed SEDs for each R06 quasar. We then measured the simulated slopes, as we did for the observed ones. We show the histogram of the simulated slopes in Figure~\ref{slphist}. For the simulated optical slopes, the mean is $\langle\alpha_{OPT,MC,E94}\rangle=1.07$ ($\sigma_{OPT,MC,E94}=0.19$). The E94 optical slope ($\alpha_{OPT}=0.95$) is within 1$\sigma_{OPT,MC,E94}$ of the mean value. However, when considering the errors ($\sigma$) on each Monte Carlo optical slope, we find that only 75\% of the simulated quasars lie within 3$\sigma$ of the E94 optical slope, implying significant outliers. In fact, a tail toward steep slopes is evident in Figure~\ref{slphist} (left). This tail is cause by the curvature in the E94 SED in the 0.3-1$\mu$m range. The steepest part of E94 reaches a slope of $\sim1.5$ between 0.3--0.45$\mu$m ($14.8\lesssim log\nu \lesssim 15$). If the simulated photometry points happen to lie only in this region, then the simulated slope will have a larger value than the $\alpha_{OPT}=0.95$ calculated over the full 0.3-1$\mu$m range. This is a limitation of using just the E94 template, which we will address next. For the corresponding simulated infrared slopes, the mean is $\langle\alpha_{NIR,MC,E94}\rangle=-0.70$ ($\sigma_{NIR,MC,E94}=0.17$). The E94 infrared slope ($\alpha_{NIR}=-0.72$) is within 1$\sigma_{NIR,MC,E94}$ of the mean value. When considering the errors ($\sigma$) on each Monte Carlo infrared slope, we find that 91\% of the simulated quasars lie within 3$\sigma$ of the E94 infrared slope. The histogram of the simulated infrared slopes shows two peaks. One peak is located at $\sim -0.72$, which is the E94 infrared slope. The other peak is located at $\sim -0.85$. As for the tail in $\alpha_{OPT,MC,E94}$, this second peak is due to curvature in the E94 SED in the 1-3$\mu$m range. The steepest part of E94 reaches a slope of $\sim -0.9$ at 1.2--2.4$\mu$m ($14.1\lesssim log\nu \lesssim 14.4$). If the simulated photometry points happen to lie only in this region, the simulated slope will have a large value compared to the E94 infrared slope calculated over the full 1-3$\mu$m range. \end{description} While the mean of the simulated slopes are same as the E94 values, the offsets are a cause of concern as they may falsely indicate an HDP object. Therefore, we performed a second Monte Carlo test using the measured slopes of the COSMOS sources with good photometry coverage. This method avoids the systematic errors from using a single template SED. \begin{figure} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f6.ps} \caption{The distance of the near-infrared slopes (Figure~\ref{slpcp}, right) to the equal slope line versus redshift. The red squares represent the Monte Carlo slope measured with 3 points. The black cross represent the Monte Carlo slope measured with more than 3 points \label{dz}} \end{figure} \begin{description} \item[(2)]~~To test if the slope measurement is robust for the range of SED shapes seen in the XMM-COSMOS type 1 AGN sample, we used the XMM-COSMOS SEDs as the template SEDs. The photometry coverage for these SEDs is rich in the NIR to OPT range, giving robust slope measurements (Elvis et al. 2011, Hao et al. 2010). We selected 398 (97\%) XMM-COSMOS type 1 AGNs, that lie within $\Delta z=0.1$ of a corresponding quasar in R06 sample. We used these 398 quasars to perform a Monte Carlo sampling, matching the photometry and error bars to those observed in the corresponding R06 quasar. We then measured the resulting $\alpha_{OPT,MC}$ and $\alpha_{NIR,MC}$, and compared them with the original measurements from COSMOS. The results are shown in Figure~\ref{slpcp}. A linear fit to $\alpha_{OPT,MC}$ versus $\alpha_{OPT}$ has a slope of 0.98$\pm$0.0004. The linear fit of $\alpha_{NIR,MC}$ versus $\alpha_{NIR}$ has a slope of 1.005$\pm$0.0003. Both slopes are very close to 1. However there are outliers that emulate HDP quasars. To investigate these outliers, we defined the distance of each data point to the equal slope line as $d_w=(\alpha_{w,MC}-\alpha_w)/\sqrt{2}$ where $w=OPT, NIR$. A positive value means that the point lies above the equal slope line. For the simulated optical slopes, the mean of $d_{OPT}$ is 0.015 ($\sigma_{d,OPT}=0.20$), consistent with 0 in $1\sigma_{d, OPT}$. For the simulated near-infrared slopes, the mean of $d_{NIR}$ is 0.067 ($\sigma_{d,OPT}=0.15$), consistent with 0 in $1\sigma_{d, NIR}$. We use these $\sigma_{d,w}$ to isolate 16 sources that lie outside the $3\sigma_{d, NIR}$ lines (red dashed lines), 4\% of the total sample. These sources have 3 points in the NIR slope estimation and at redshift $0.92\lesssim z\lesssim1.3$ (see example in Figure~\ref{egSED}, right). We plotted the $d_{NIR}$ versus redshift, shown in Figure~\ref{dz}. For an E94-like SED shape, the three IRAC bands in this redshift range would lie at $>2\mu$m, in the upper part of the infrared bump. The lack of a K band measurement would then lead to a larger slope estimate. For galaxy-like SED shape in this redshift range, lack of K band would lead to a much smaller slope estimate. For a mixing of E94 and galaxy SED, which is quite flat, the lacking of K band will not affect the slope measurement. The total number of simulated sources with 3 points in the NIR slope estimation is 95. Thus for the majority (83\%) of the sources with 3 photometry points in the NIR slope estimation, the slope estimates are still robust. In all, for the 96\% simulated sources with 3 or more photometry points in NIR, the slope estimation is robust. The NIR slope estimate is not quite reliable for sources with only 3 photometry points and at redshift $0.92\lesssim z\lesssim1.3$. \end{description} In general, for majority of quasars in R06 sample, the slope measurement we applied is robust for E94 like SED shape or a variety of SED shapes as in XMM-COSMOS sample, even for quasars with limited photometry coverage as in R06. Figure~\ref{dz} also shows that the systematic error on $\alpha_{NIR}$ is 0.07 for sources using 4 or more photometry points, which is small compared to the measurment errors. For sources using only 3 photometry points in the redshift range 0.92--1.3, the systematic error on $\alpha_{NIR}$ is 0.3, which is comparable in some cases to the measurement errors. We added this errors to the measurement error when plotting the mixing diagram of R06. \subsection{Corrections to the SED} We need to consider the following several factors, which might affect the measurement of the slopes. \subsubsection{Emission Lines} The major emission lines in the rest frame wavelength range $0.3-3\mu m$ are the Balmer series, the Paschen series, and the Fe II complex. As the photometry points in the SED are all broad-band, even for the strongest line, H$\alpha$ (mean equivalent width 257\AA\ for SDSS DR6 quasars, Elvis et al. 2011), the upward bias of the observed photometry from the continuum reaches only 0.1 dex in the z band (filter FWHM=1000\AA). For weaker lines, such as H$\beta$ and Fe II, the bias would be $\sim$0.02 dex, which is negligible for the slope measurements reported here. For consistency, we correct the R06 photometry for the emission lines as we did for the XMM-COSMOS sample (Elvis et al. 2011). For the E94 sample, the emission line contribution has already been corrected for in the reported SEDs (details in Elvis et al. 1994). \subsubsection{Variability} Most AGNs vary in their optical continuum flux by $\sim$10\% on timescales of months to years (Vanden Berk et al. 2004). The photometry used to build the SEDs in the R06 sample were taken over different time periods, which may affect the estimation of slopes. For the R06 sample, the IRAC detections were made around 2004 (Lacy et al. 2005, Surace et al. 2005). The SDSS-DR3 photometry including the optical SDSS bands were taken from 1998 to 2003 and the NIR 2MASS bands were taken from 1997 to 2001 (Schneider et al. 2005). The UKIDSS NIR photometry has been taken since 2005. We should be careful in using the UKIDSS data and the rest of the data to measure the slopes. For the $\alpha_{NIR}$ estimation, we need to consider sources in the following redshift ranges respectively: \begin{enumerate} \item $z>1.15$: only the IRAC bands lie in the 1--3$\mu$m range. Thus the $\alpha_{NIR}$ estimation is robust, for the 109 out of the 195 R06 quasars; \item $0.65<z<1.15$: K and IRAC bands lie in the 1--3$\mu$m range. 16 sources have UKIDSS K-band detection. In no case does the K-band point appear significantly discontinuous with the IRAC bands. \item $0.24<z<0.65$: H, K and IRAC bands lie in the 1--3$\mu$m range. 17 sources have 2MASS H band detections. 8 sources have UKIDSS K-band detection. In no case does the H-band and K-band point appear significant discontinuous with the IRAC bands. \item $z<0.24$: All of the J, H, K and IRAC1 bands lie in the 1--3$\mu$m range. 2 of the 3 sources at $z<0.24$ have UKIDSS J and K band detections. The SEDs of these 2 sources show no discontinuity in the SED to cause errors in the slope measurement. \end{enumerate} We thus consider the estimates of $\alpha_{NIR}$ to be robust. For $\alpha_{OPT}$ estimation, similarly, the 3 low redshift ($z<0.24$) sources have only the SDSS data in the 0.3--1$\mu$m range. Thus for these quasars the $\alpha_{OPT}$ estimation is robust. For sources at $0.24<z<1.15$, only the J band and SDSS data lie in the range. 12 sources have UKIDSS J band detection, for which the effect of J band on the slope measurement is small. For the 109 high redshift ($z>1.15$) sources, the situation is more complicated, because the UKIDSS J K band and the SDSS or 2MASS H band could be in the 0.3--1$\mu$m range. However, the effect of variability on the $\alpha_{OPT}$ does not affect the selection of the HDP quasars, since the most significant difference of the HDP quasars from the normal quasars are the $\alpha_{NIR}$. For the E94 sample, the optical and the ground-based IR data were generally obtained within about 1 month (Elvis et al. 1994), so that the variability does not affect the slope measurement in the optical and IR range used in the mixing diagram. \begin{figure*} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f7.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f8.ps} \caption{Mixing Diagram: {\em Left:} R06 sample; {\em Right:} E94 sample. Red cross and red circle show the E94 mean SED and the $1\sigma$ dispersion of the E94 sources. The blue triangles show 16 different SWIRE galaxy templates (Polletta et al. 2007). The purple lines connecting the E94 and the galaxy templates are mixing curves showing the slopes of different fraction of galaxy and AGN. The straight purple arrow shows the reddening vector of E94. The straight red solid line shows the $\alpha_{OPT}=\alpha_{NIR}$ line. Different colors of the points show different class of the HDP sources (I--blue, II--green, see text for details). The black symbols show all the other type 1 AGN in the samples. For R06, the error bars are adjusted for possible systematic errors due to limit photometry. The 6 magenta dots in the mixing diagram of R06 sample show the $z\sim6$ quasars in Jiang et al. (2010) Figure 1. \label{md}} \end{figure*} \subsection{R06 and E94 Mixing Diagram} Figure \ref{md} shows the Hao et al. (2010) ``mixing diagram'' for the R06 and E94 samples. For the sources that have galaxy fraction larger than 0.6 in the mixing diagram, we check the inferred host galaxy luminosity. Only one quasar in R06 sample has $M<-23$ (-23.8) at $1\mu$m. Thus the inferred host luminosity is reasonable. There is clearly a continuous distribution of objects in $\alpha_{NIR}$, so to select quasars in the HDP region, we need to examine the dispersion in ``normal'' objects. We consider all R06 quasars with $0.2<\alpha_{OPT}<1.6$ in order to exclude the few galaxy- or reddening-dominated sources. They have mean slopes $\bar{\alpha}_{OPT}=0.76$ (standard deviation $\sigma_{OPT}=0.25$), and $\bar{\alpha}_{NIR}=-0.53$ (standard deviation $\sigma_{NIR}=0.37$). The mean of the measurement error of $\alpha_{OPT}$ is $Err_{OPT}=0.10$, which indicates the intrinsic dispersion is $\sigma_{INT, OPT}=\sqrt{\sigma_{OPT}^2-Err_{OPT}^2}=0.23$. The mean of the measurement error of $\alpha_{NIR}$ is $Err_{NIR}=0.08$, which indicates the intrinsic dispersion is $\sigma_{INT, NIR}=\sqrt{\sigma_{NIR}^2-Err_{NIR}^2}=0.36$. The intrinsic dispersion of the SED shape is substantial. The E94 sources, which were corrected for host galaxy contribution, are, by construction, clustered around the E94 mean in the AGN-dominated region located at the bottom right corner of the mixing diagram. For the 42 E94 sources, the mean slopes are $\bar{\alpha}_{OPT}=0.96$ (standard deviation $\sigma_{OPT}=0.27$) and $\bar{\alpha}_{NIR}=-0.50$ (standard deviation $\sigma_{NIR}=0.38$). The mean of the measurement error of $\alpha_{OPT}$ is $Err_{OPT}=0.1$, which indicates the intrinsic dispersion is $\sigma_{INT, OPT}=\sqrt{\sigma_{OPT}^2-Err_{OPT}^2}=0.25$. The mean of the measurement error of $\alpha_{NIR}$ is $Err_{NIR}=0.2$, which indicates the intrinsic dispersion is $\sigma_{INT, NIR}=\sqrt{\sigma_{NIR}^2-Err_{NIR}^2}=0.32$. To compare the intrinsic dispersion of these two samples, we performed an F-test, ignoring the effects of the measurement error and assuming the intrinsic slope distribution is normally distributed. For $\alpha_{OPT}$, the F statistic is 1.09, and the cumulative distribution function (CDF) probablity is 65\%, implying that the difference between the $\alpha_{OPT}$ intrinsic dispersions of R06 and E94 is not significant. For $\alpha_{NIR}$, the F statistic is 1.13, the CDF probability is 66\%, implying the difference between the $\alpha_{NIR}$ intrinsic dispersions of R06 and E94 is not significant. A more detailed statistical comparison between the intrinsic dispersion in different samples is reported in Hao et al. (2011). \subsection{Selection of the HDP quasars} In the mixing diagram, we define a circle with a radius of 0.6 to approximate the 1.5$\sigma$ intrinsic dispersion region of the E94 mean SED template. We then use this region to classify outliers. As the distribution of the quasars is continuous in $\alpha_{NIR}$, different sized circles define different outlier populations. Here we simply apply the same criterion as in Hao et al. (2010) to enable ready comparison of their properties. The Hao et al. (2010) mixing diagram readily distinguishes among the AGN-dominated, galaxy-dominated and reddening-dominated SEDs. The AGNs with SED slopes in the triangular region defined by the mixing curve and the reddening vector can be explained by the combinations of the E94 mean SED, host galaxy contamination and reddening. AGNs which lie at least $1\sigma$ above the mixing curve and the dispersion circle in the upper right corner of the mixing diagram, are defined as HDP quasars. Note that we do not suggest that HDP quasars are a distinct class. As the distribution of the quasars on the mixing diagram is continuous and the definition of the dispersion circle is somewhat arbitrary, the HDP quasars represent one extreme of the distribution of the AGN SEDs. We further divide the HDP quasars into three classes by their positions relative to the equal slope line as in Hao et al. (2010). Class I sources (blue points) have $\alpha_{OPT}>\alpha_{NIR}$ within measurement error. These sources have a normal blue bump but flat NIR emission. Class II sources (green points) lie on the equal slope line, which indicates that the NIR emission might be the continuation of the optical accretion disk, although this turns out to be not true for all cases judging from SED fitting in the XMM-COSMOS sample (Hao et al. 2010). We find 17 HDP quasars in the R06 sample. Most (15) of which belong to Class I, with the remainder (2) belonging to Class II. The fraction of the HDP quasars in R06 is $8.7\%\pm2.2\%$. For 3/4 of these HDP quasars, more than 3 photometry points are used in the near-infrared for slope estimation. The two Class II HDP quasars, however, have only 3 NIR data points in their estimates. Four sources out of the 42 quasars in the E94 sample qualify as HDP (Table \ref{t:e94hdp}): 2 optically selected and 2 radio selected. Their SEDs are shown in Figure \ref{e94sed}. They are all Class I HDP quasars. \section{HDP quasar properties} \subsection{HDP Quasars in R06} \label{s:r06hdp} \begin{deluxetable}{ccccc} \tabletypesize{\scriptsize} \tablecaption{HDP Quasars in R06 \label{t:r06hdp}} \tablehead{\colhead {Name (SDSS J)} & \colhead{redshift} & \colhead{log$L_{bol}$} & \colhead{Class} & \colhead{$N_{NIR}$\tablenotemark{a}}\\ & & \colhead {erg$\cdot$s$^{-1}$} & & }\startdata 105308.24+590522.2 & 0.430 & 45.16 & I & 4\\ 160341.44+541501.5 & 0.581 & 45.27 & I & 4\\ 104857.92+560112.3 & 0.800 & 45.70 & I & 3\\\hline 103525.05+580335.6 & 0.964 & 46.02 & I & 4\\ 163306.12+401747.4 & 0.974 & 45.87 & I & 4\\ 160913.18+535429.6 & 0.992 & 46.32 & I & 4\\ 104935.76+554950.5 & 1.056 & 46.26 & II & 3\tablenotemark{b}\\ 104114.18+590219.4 & 1.093 & 45.93 & I & 4\\ 104921.49+575036.6 & 1.106 & 46.08 & I & 4\\\hline 171441.11+601342.9 & 1.456 & 46.05 & I & 4\\ 104948.86+592620.7 & 2.000 & 46.22 & I & 4\\ 103905.24+591209.1 & 2.115 & 46.50 & I & 4\\ 104226.20+585925.8 & 2.560 & 46.48 & I & 4\\ 160828.33+535251.9 & 2.960 & 46.61 & II & 3\\ 164238.08+412104.7 & 3.123 & 46.76 & I & 4\\ 104810.81+575526.9 & 3.171 & 46.71 & I & 4\\ 105654.96+583712.4 & 3.856 & 46.81 & I & 3\\ \enddata \tablenotetext{a}{Number of photometry points used in the $\alpha_{NIR}$ estimates.} \tablenotetext{b}{$\alpha_{NIR}$ may be overestimated (see section~\ref{s:robust}, Figure~\ref{dz}). Detailed discussion about this source is in section~\ref{s:r06hdp}.} \end{deluxetable} \begin{figure*} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f9.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f10.ps} \caption{Examples of HDP SEDs in R06: {\em Left:} Class I; {\em Right:} Class II ($\alpha_{OPT}$ and $\alpha_{NIR}$ less reliable see section~\ref{s:robust}). The red dashed line is the E94 radio quiet mean SED.\label{egSED}} \end{figure*} \begin{figure} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f11.ps} \caption{The redshift distribution (top) and fraction of the HDP AGN in R06 sample as function of redshift (middle) and $L_{bol}$ (bottom). In the top panel, the black histogram shows the redshift distribution of the R06 sample. The blue shaded histogram shows the distribution of the HDP quasar in R06 sample. The two histogram are scaled to have the same integral area. In the middle panel, the red solid line shows the fitting of the XMM-COSMOS HDP fraction versus redshift in the same bin ($f_{HDP}=(0.031\pm0.002)(1+z)^{(1.2\pm0.1)}$) and the red dashed line show the 1$\sigma$ range of the fitting. \label{frac}} \end{figure} Representative R06 SEDs (Class I: top, Class II: bottom) are shown in Figure~\ref{egSED}. The Class I source (SDSS J104114.18+590219.4) by definition show a flat near infrared SED, similar to the Class I HDP quasars found in XMM-COSMOS quasar sample (Hao et al. 2010). The Class II source (SDSS J104935.76+554950.5) has only 3 points in both slope estimates and is at $z=1.056$, in the range where $\alpha_{NIR}$ can be overestimated by up to $\sim 0.5$ (Figure \ref{dz} in section~\ref{s:robust}). However it is hard to fit the SED with an E94 mean SED and some host. The NIR SED of this source shows an unusual discontinuous, 0.1 dex arise from the IRAC2 to IRAC1 points at $\sim2\mu m$ (rest). This feature cannot be caused by the emission from hot dust, because a black-body, at any temperature below the maximum dust sublimation temperature of 1900 K, does not fit the feature well. The Paschen $\alpha$ line lies in the IRAC 1 band but is unlikely to produce this feature, as to produce the IRAC1 rise would require an equivalent width of $\sim$2000\AA, which is 30 times the typical value of 70\AA\ (Landt et al. 2008). As $\alpha_{OPT}$ is within the range of those for E94 quasars (section~\ref{s:e94hdp}), it could be that the IRAC1 point is dominated by the continuation of the accretion disk. NIR photometry or spectra are needed to understand the emission in this range. As reported in Hao et al. (2010), the fraction of the HDP quasars in the XMM-COSMOS sample evolves with redshift but not with other parameters (e.g., $L_{bol}$). The fraction increases from 6\% at low redshift ($z<2$) to 20\% at moderate high redshift ($2<z<3.5$). We checked if similar evolution behavior can be found in the R06 sample. We plotted the HDP fraction in R06 versus $z$ and $L_{bol}$ in Figure \ref{frac}. The HDP quasars in the R06 sample have redshifts from 0.43 to 3.86. The range of $L_{bol}$ for the HDP AGNs (45.1$<$log$L_{bol}<$46.8) is almost the same as for the whole sample (44.8$<$log$L_{bol}<$47.4). The Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test shows that the distributions of z and $L_{bol}$ for the R06 HDP quasars are indistinguishable from the rest of the R06 sample (KS probabilities of 0.25 and 0.88). As the XMM-COSMOS sample, the HDP quasars in R06 do not show a different $L_{bol}$ distribution to the other quasars in R06. However, the HDP quasars in R06 do not show redshift evolution, unlike XMM-COSMOS sample. This result might be affected by the 64 sources we have excluded due to limited photometry coverage. At redshifts $z<0.5$, the 5 sources with no J H K photometry have fewer than three photometry points in the rest frame $1\mu m - 3\mu m$ band, as do the 6 quasars at high redshifts $z>3.7$. At redshifts $1.5<z\leqslant3.7$, 53 quasars also have fewer than three photometry points in the rest frame $0.3-1\mu m$. So quasars at low and high redshifts have more chance of being excluded from consideration, which might lead to the lack of an increase in HDP fraction in R06 at $z\sim 2$, though $\alpha_{OPT}$ only has a small influence on HDP definition. The XMM-COSMOS sample has no such incompleteness bias, since the COSMOS photometry coverage is more complete and uniform. In the XMM-COSMOS sample, the HDP fraction jumps at $z=2$ from $\sim 6\%$ to $\sim 20\%$. So we re-binned the R06 sample and find that the HDP fraction is $6.3\%\pm2.1\%$ at $z<2$, and $19.4\%\pm8.0\%$ at $z\geqslant2$ respectively, a $1.6\sigma$ difference, which is consistent with the results in the XMM-COSMOS sample. We over-plot XMM-COSMOS fit of the HDP fraction versus $z$ (red lines, $f_{HDP}=(0.031\pm0.002)(1+z)^{(1.2\pm0.1)}$, Hao et al. 2010). The HDP fraction versus $z$ relationship in the two samples do not disagree. Because of the poorly sampled SED at $\sim 1 \mu m$ due to limited NIR photometry in the R06 sample, we could not make robust estimates of the dust covering factor ($f_c$) or the outer edge of the accretion disk ($r_{out}$). \subsection{HDP Quasars in E94} \label{s:e94hdp} \begin{deluxetable}{lclcccccccccc} \tabletypesize{\scriptsize} \tablecaption{HDP Quasars in E94 \label{t:e94hdp}} \tablehead{\colhead{Object} & \colhead {Name} & \colhead{redshift} & \colhead{log$L_{bol}$} & \colhead{log($M_{BH}$)} & \colhead{$\lambda_E$} & \colhead {$T_d$} & \colhead{$A_d$} & \colhead {$f_c$} & \colhead{$T_{out}$} & \colhead {$R_{out}$} & \colhead {$R_{out}/$} & \colhead {$R_{out}/$}\\ & & & \colhead {erg$\cdot$s$^{-1}$} & \colhead {$M_{\bigodot}$}& & \colhead {K} &\colhead{pc$^2$} & \colhead{\%} & \colhead{K} & \colhead{pc} &\colhead {$r_s$} & \colhead {$r_{grav}$}}\startdata Q0003+158 & PHL 658 & 0.45 & 46.5 & 9.3\tablenotemark{1} & 0.13 & 1200 & 8.00 & 6 & 3700 & 0.6 & 3200 & 11 \\ Q0049+171 & PG 0049+171 & 0.064 & 44.8 & 8.3\tablenotemark{1} & 0.03 & 1300 & 0.13 & 11 & 4000 & 0.06 & 2700 & 11 \\ Q0414-060 & 3C110 & 0.78 & 47.0 & 9.9\tablenotemark{2} & 0.10 & 1900 & 3.80 & 18 & 3600 & 0.4 & 370 & 13 \\ Q1635+119 & MC2 1635+119 & 0.146 & 45.4 & 8.1\tablenotemark{3} & 0.16 & 1900 & 0.15 & 21 & 4800 & 0.08 & 6300 & 9 \\ \enddata \tablenotetext{1}{Reference: Vestergaard \& Peterson (2006)} \tablenotetext{2}{Reference: Marziani et al. (2010)} \tablenotetext{3}{Reference: Woo et al. (2002)} \end{deluxetable} \begin{figure*} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.24\textwidth]{f12.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.24\textwidth]{f13.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.24\textwidth]{f14.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.24\textwidth]{f15.ps} \caption{HDP AGN in E94 sample: {\em Left:} Q0003+158 (PHL 658, redshift z=0.45); {\em Middle left:} Q0049+171 (PG0049+171, z=0.064); {\em Middle right:} Q0414-060(3C110, z=0.78); {\em Right:} Q1635+119(MC2 1635+119, z=0.146). The SEDs are fitted with the accretion disk component (red dashed line) and a hot dust component (magenta dashed line). The sum of the two component is showed as black dotted line. The blue dashed line (a single temperature black body) shows the fitting of the outer edge of the accretion disk. The green dot-dashed line is the spectrum from a steady optically thick accretion disk ($\nu F_\nu \varpropto \nu^{4/3}$). \label{e94sed}} \end{figure*} The fraction of HDP AGNs in E94 is $9.5\%\pm 5.0\%$. Because the sample size of E94 is 10 times smaller than that of the XMM-COSMOS type 1 AGN sample, the error on the fraction is much larger. A KS test shows that the distributions of $z$ and $L_{bol}$ for these HDP quasars are indistinguishable from the rest of the E94 sample (with KS probabilities of 0.5 and 0.6 respectively). These results agrees with the XMM-COSMOS sample that for low redshift quasars, the fraction of the HDP do not evolve with $z$ and $L_{bol}$. As the E94 SEDs are all corrected for host galaxy contributions, we fit the SED with just two components: an accretion disk (using a standard Schwarzschild $\alpha$-disk model, with electron scattering and Comptonization; Siemiginowska et al. 1995), and a hot dust component (using a single temperature black-body). The black hole masses for these four quasars, reported in Vestergaard \& Peterson (2006), Marziani et al. (2010) and Woo et al. (2002), is listed in Table \ref{t:e94hdp}. Their accretion rates (expressed as their Eddington ratios, $\lambda_E$) are calculated from $L_{bol}$ and $M_{BH}$. We use the accretion disk model (Siemiginowska et al. 1995) for the particular black hole masses and the accretion rates for each quasar and show the results in Figure \ref{e94sed}. \subsubsection{Covering Factors of E94 HDP Quasars} Following the same method as in Hao et al. (2010), the dust covering factor ($f_c$) was estimated as the ratio of the dust emission area ($A_d$) to the area at the dust evaporation radius ($A_e=4\pi r_e^2$). $A_d$ comes from the normalization of the black-body fit. The dust evaporation radius ($r_e$) is estimated from $r_e=1.3L_{uv, 46}^{1/2}T_{1500}^{-2.8} pc$ (Barvainis 1987), where $L_{uv,46}$ is the total ultraviolet (1$\mu$m--912\AA) luminosity in units of $10^{46}$ erg s$^{-1}$, and $T_{1500}$ is the maximum dust temperature allowed by the SED, in units of 1500~K. The typical errors on the E94 photometry in the near-infrared are $\sim 0.1$ dex. This produces an error on the dust temperature estimation, $\Delta T_d/T_d\sim8\%$, and an error on the normalization, $\Delta A_d/A_d\sim4\%$. The error on $f_c$ is thus $\Delta f_c/f_c\sim5\%$. \subsubsection{Accretion Disk Outer Radii of E94 HDP Quasars} The outer accretion disk radius is estimated from the standard $\alpha$--disk model formula (Frank, King \& Raine, 2002) $$R_{out}=1.1\times 10^4 T_c^{-\frac43}\alpha^{-\frac{4}{15}} \eta^{-\frac25}M_8^{\frac{11}{15}}\lambda_E^{\frac25}f^{\frac85}~~~pc$$ where $M_8=M/(10^8 M_{\bigodot})$, $\lambda_E=L_{bol}/(\frac{4\pi Gcm_p}{\sigma_e}M)$, and $f=\left [1-\left (\frac{6GM}{R~c^2}\right )^{\frac{1}{2}}\right ]^{\frac{1}{4}}$. We assume $\alpha=0.1$, $\eta=0.1$. Thus $R_{out,pc}\propto T_{out}^{-\frac43}M^{\frac{11}{15}}\lambda_E^{\frac25}\propto T_{out}^{-\frac43}M^{\frac13}$. The error in the disk temperature estimates from the E94 photometric errors is $\Delta T_{out}/T_{out}\sim5\%$. Unfortunately, black hole mass estimates from mass scaling relationships have an error $\Delta M_{BH}/M_{BH}\sim40\%$ (Vestergaard \& Peterson 2006, Peterson 2010), so $\Delta R_{out, pc}/R_{out, pc}\sim 20\%$. In terms of Schwarzschild radii ($r_s=2GM/c^2$), $\Delta R_{out, r_s}/R_{out, r_s} \sim 33\%$. We can also express this radius in terms of the gravitational instability radius of the accretion disk ($r_{grav}$, Goodman 2003), which is the radius beyond which the disk is unstable to self-gravity and should break up. As $r_{grav}\propto M^{-\frac29}\lambda_E^{\frac49}\propto M^{-\frac23}$, $R_{out, r_{grav}}\propto T_{out}^{-\frac43}$. Hence, $\Delta R_{out, r_{grav}}/R_{out, r_{grav}}\sim 7\%$. The results are reported in Table \ref{t:e94hdp}. They turn out to be comparable to the HDP quasars in the XMM-COSMOS sample in that $R_{out} \sim 10 r_{grav}$, a surprisingly large value. \section{Discussion and Conclusions} \subsection{Comparison with COSMOS HDP Quasars} We find a similar fraction of HDP quasars in the optically selected R06 and E94 samples as in the X-ray selected XMM-COSMOS sample of Hao et al. (2010): $8.7\%\pm2.2\%$ in the R06 sample and $9.5\%\pm 5.0\%$ in E94 sample. This similarity indicates that these extreme AGNs are fairly common even in optically selected samples, though they were not previously recognized. The XMM-COSMOS quasar sample and the R06 sample have similar redshift coverage. In contrast to the XMM-COSMOS sample, however, the fraction of the HDP in R06 does not show significant evolution with redshift according to the KS test result. This difference might be caused by the exclusion of the 64 sources in certain redshift range due to the limit near-IR photometry. The evolution of the HDP fraction in R06 sample is ill-determined but generally agrees with the HDP of XMM-COSMOS sample (Figure \ref{frac}). In the small E94 sample at low $z$, the redshifts and luminosities of the HDP quasars are indistinguishable from the normal type 1 AGNs. This is consistent with the XMM-COSMOS sample, as for low redshift sources ($z<2$), the HDP fraction does not evolve with redshift and luminosity. All of the HDP quasars in R06 are Class I and II. In comparison, the XMM-COSMOS sample has 27\% (11 out of 41) Class III HDP quasars. We compare the Class III distribution versus Class I and II in the R06 HDP and XMM-COSMOS HDP samples using the Fisher exact test (Wall \& Jenkins 2003). The probability that the two HDP samples have the same class distribution is 1.4\%. The SEDs of the Class III HDP quasars have stronger galaxy contribution than Class I and II. So R06 includes fewer sources with strong galaxy contribution than XMM-COSMOS. This is expected, as the R06 sample is selected by optical colors, and will exclude low AGN-to-galaxy contrast objects. The XMM-COSMOS sample, instead, is X-ray selected, and includes sources with strong galaxy contributions. In E94, the dust covering factor of the HDP quasars ranges from 6\% to 21\%, similar to the XMM-COSMOS HDP quasars (Hao et al. 2010). A small dust covering factor was proposed long ago in several quasars. For example, the spectropolarimetry analysis of the quasar OI 287 showed that the broad Balmer lines are polarized the same way as the continuum, while the forbidden lines have zero intrinsic polarization, suggesting a thin `torus' (Goodrich \& Miller, 1988). The outer edge of the accretion disk in E94 (Table~\ref{t:e94hdp}) ranges from 0.06pc to 0.6pc and from 370$r_s$ to 6300$r_s$, which are $\sim$ 10 times greater than the gravitational instability radius (Goodman 2003). A similar extension of the disk spectrum into the NIR uncovered by polarized light, was found by Kishimoto et al. (2008). The outer radius of the accretion disk is further out than expected by simple $\alpha$-disk theory. For the R06 sample, the limitations of the photometry prevents the accurate estimation of these quantities. \begin{figure} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f16.ps} \caption{Position in Lacy et al. (2004) color-space of the XMM-COSMOS (square), R06 (circle) and E94(triangle) samples. The red solid points are the HDP quasars from these samples. Small sets of symbols are for sources with $\alpha_{OPT}<0.2$, that is galaxy- or reddening-dominated sources. \label{lacy}} \end{figure} \begin{figure*} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f17.ps} \includegraphics[angle=0,width=0.48\textwidth]{f18.ps} \caption{Luminosity and redshift dependence of the hot-dust abundance introduced in Jiang et al. (2010) of the XMM-COSMOS (square), R06 (circle) and E94(triangle) samples. The red solid points are the HDP quasars from these samples. The magenta points are the three $z\sim6$ quasars in Figure 1 of Jiang et al. (2010) that is HDP. Small sets of symbols are for sources with $\alpha_{OPT}<0.2$, that is galaxy- or reddening-dominated sources. The magenta dashed lines are the linear fit and $3\sigma$ range of the sample in Jiang et al. (2010). The black solid lines are the linear fit and $3\sigma$ range of the XMM-COSMOS, R06 and E94 samples. \label{jiang}} \end{figure*} \subsection{HDP Quasars and IR Quasar Selection} We checked whether the HDP quasars lie within the Lacy et al. (2004) color-selection region for quasars (Figure \ref{lacy}). Most of the HDP quasars lie in the bottom left of the quasar region. Although their hot dust emission is weak, it is still sufficient to differentiate them from starburst galaxies. The HDP quasars are one of the extreme of the variety of the AGN SEDs. AGNs with galaxy-dominated SEDs lie in the same region. The Lacy et al. (2004) color-color plot does not distinguish the HDP quasars from galaxy-dominated quasars. \subsection{Comparison with Jiang et al. Hot-Dust-Free Quasars} Jiang et al. (2010) introduced the rest-frame 3.5$\mu$m to 5100\AA\ luminosity ratio as an indicator of the hot-dust abundance. They concluded that there are no low redshift counterparts to the two $z\sim 6$ hot-dust-free quasars J0005-0006 and J0303-0019. We reproduce the Jiang et al. (2010) plot in Figure \ref{jiang} for the XMM-COSMOS, R06 and E94 samples. The HDP quasars from COSMOS, R06 and E94 (red points) do lie at the bottom edge of the distribution, but are not as extreme as the two Jiang et al. `hot-dust-free' quasars. However, the $L(3.5\mu m/L(5100\AA)$ ratio alone cannot distinguish the HDP from the galaxy -dominated SED shape (e.g., small black points), because they have similar rest frame 3.5 $\mu$m to 5100\AA\ luminosity ratios. We plot the 6 quasars from Jiang et al. (2010) on the mixing diagram (Figure~\ref{md}, magenta dots). We find that three of the 6 Jiang et al. (2010) $z\sim6$ quasars (J0005-0006, J0303-0019 and J1411+1217) qualify as HDP quasars. This $\sim 50\%$ HDP fraction at $z\sim6$ suggests, at low significance, that HDP quasars fraction continue to grow with redshift. All three are class II, i.e. their NIR emission may be a continuation of the accretion disk. J1411+1217, which was classified as a normal quasar in Jiang et al. (2010), is actually HDP by our criteria. One difficulty with $\nu L_{\nu}(3.5\mu m)/\nu L_{\nu}(5100\AA)$ is that this ratio does not allow for a range in optical slope, such as would be induced by moderate reddening. The slope for the rest frame optical SED of J0303-0019 ($\alpha_{OPT}\sim0.6$) is flatter than a standard accretion disk, so that a continuation of the power law to the rest frame infrared underestimates the hot dust contribution. De-reddening the optical SED leads to a requirement for a host dust excess. So this quasar should be counted as ``hot-dust-poor'' rather than ``hot-dust-free''. Another difficulty with $\nu L_{\nu}(3.5\mu m)/\nu L_{\nu}(5100\AA)$ is that sources with weak hot dust emission but some cool dust emission are not selected by this parameter (e.g. XMM-COSMOS HDP quasar XID=96, Hao et al. 2010). Defining an index based on only two rest-frame wavelength band is not so effective at low redshift. The mixing diagram of Figure~\ref{md} is more useful in selecting the outliers. \subsection{Origin of the HDP Quasars} The origin of HDP quasars is unknown. As for the COSMOS HDP quasars discussed in Hao et al. (2010), the E94 and R06 HDP quasars are at $z<4$, when the universe is more than 2 Gyr old. They have more than 1 Gyr from reionization to form a torus. So they cannot be the first generation of quasars. They are also luminous enough, and have high enough accretion rates, to support a dusty torus (Elitzur \& Ho 2009). Either the hot dust is destroyed (dynamically or by radiation), or the dust is not centered on the SMBH, i.e., an off-nuclear AGN (Blecha et al. 2011, 2008, Guedes et al. 2010, Volonteri \& Madau 2008). When an SMBH recoils (or is kicked-out), it is possible bring along the adjacent broad line region, but not the dusty torus which, being further out, is less tightly bound to the SMBH (Loeb 2007). The dust is thus not centered on the SMBH, i.e. an off-nuclear AGN. A good candidate for a recoiling BH has been found in the COSMOS sample (Civano et al. 2010), although it is not included in the XMM-COSMOS HDP sample due to the galaxy-dominated NIR--OPT SED shape. Volonteri \& Madau (2008) estimated the cumulative number of off-nuclear AGNs (offset$>0.2$\asec) per square degree versus redshift. Their lower limit on the number of off-nuclear AGNs is $\sim2~deg^{-2}$ at $z<1$, $\sim8~deg^{-2}$ at $z<2$, and $\sim11~deg^{-2}$ at $z<3$. Considering the COSMOS field is $2~deg^2$, the Volonteri \& Madau (2008) prediction is consistent with the cumulative number of XMM-COSMOS HDP AGNs ($2.5~deg^{-2}$ at $z<1$, $8~deg^{-2}$ at $z<2$, $18.5~deg^{-2}$ at $z<3$). A detailed comparison between the theoretical distribution and the HDP evolution will be reported in a following paper. We could not make similar estimates for the R06 and E94 samples, because the survey areas are not well defined. Alternatively, the existence of HDP quasars in samples with different selection methods and the continuous distribution of dust covering factor imply that the origin of HDP quasars could be related to the AGN structure. Misaligned disks will result from discrete isotropic accretion events (Volonteri et al. 2007), which will lead to a wide range of covering factors (Lawrence \& Elvis 2010). For disks with tilt-only warps (i.e. with no rotation of the line of nodes), $\sim 14\%$ of the type 1 AGNs will have covering factors less than 20\% (Lawrence \& Elvis 2010). This agrees with the HDP fraction in all three samples. \subsection{Prospects} The ongoing UKIDSS and WISE surveys will expand the available HDP samples greatly, especially in the $z>1.5$ range, where evolution can then be sought with high sensitivity. The Hao et al. (2010) mixing diagram is a useful tool for selecting non-standard quasar SEDs. \section{Acknowledgments} We thank Michael Strauss and Brandon Kelly for suggestions that greatly improved the paper. This work was supported by NASA Chandra grant number GO7-8136A (HH, ME, FC). This work is based in part on data obtained as part of the UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey.

\section{Introduction} Although evaluation of the total effect of a given exposure on an outcome of interest remains the goal of many empirical studies, there has been considerable interest in recent years to gain deeper understanding of causal mechanisms by teasing apart the direct exposure effect and the indirect effect operating through a given post-exposure mediating variable \citep{vanderweele2015explanation}. While mediation analysis has a longstanding tradition primarily in the context of linear structural modeling \citep{ctx8536838640005154, bentler1980multivariate, baron1986moderator}, the concepts of natural direct and indirect effects have since been formalized under the potential outcomes framework by the seminal works of \cite{robins1992identifiability} and \cite{pearl2001direct}, which disentangles the identification assumptions from parametric constraints and allows semiparametric identification and inference for these causal estimands of interest \citep{imai2010identification, tchetgen2012semiparametric,tchetgen2014estimation, vanderweele2015explanation,hines2020robust}. Identifcation of natural direct and indirect effects generally requires no unmeasured confounding of the exposure-mediator, exposure-outcome and mediator-outcome relationships \citep{robins1992identifiability, pearl2001direct}. While the no unmeasured exposure-mediator and exposure-outcome confounding assumptions hold by design when the exposure is randomly assigned by the investigator, it is often infeasible to also intervene on the post-exposure mediator. As a result, one can rarely rule out unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding in empirical settings and sensitivity analysis methods have been developed to assess the impact of departures from this assumption \citep{imai2010general,vanderweele2010bias, tchetgen2012semiparametric, ding2016sharp,zhang2022interpretable}. A growing literature has likewise emerged on the development of identification strategies in the presence of potential unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding, typically by leveraging an instrumental variable for the effect of the mediator on the outcome \citep{ten2007causal,doi:10.1002/sim.2891, albert2008mediation,small2012mediation, imai2013experimental,burgess2015network,zheng2015causal,doi:10.1111/rssb.12232,tai2021identification}. While most of the aforementioned literature has been restricted to the setting of a single mediator, researchers often focus on multiple mediators, either to assess the joint mediation effects through multiple mediators or address concerns about mediator-outcome confounding by exposure-induced intermediates \citep{vanderweele2014mediation,vanderweele2014effect}. Identification of such joint mediation effects require no unmeasured confounding of the outcome with respect to the whole set of mediators \citep{vanderweele2014mediation}. This key assumption is arguably more likely to be violated as the number of mediators under consideration grows, and the development of methodology to adequately address this issue remains a priority in mediation analysis. Nonetheless, extension of the instrumental variable identification approach to the multiple mediator setting presents some practical challenges as it generally requires as many instrumental variables as there are mediators. Recently, \cite{fulcher2019estimation} proposed an alternative identification approach by using higher order moment conditions which does not require ancillary variables such as instrumental variables \citep{rigobon2003identification, klein2010estimating, lewbel2012using, tchetgen2021genius}. In this paper, we build upon and extend the works of \cite{vanderweele2014mediation} and \cite{fulcher2019estimation} to the multiple mediator setting in the presence of potential unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. We introduce notation and assumptions in Section \ref{sec:notation} and delineate the conditions for identification of mediation effects with multiple mediators simultaneously in Section \ref{sec:identification}. For estimation and inference, we propose a simple two-step method of moments procedure in Section \ref{sec:estimation}. We investigate the empirical performance of the proposed estimator through extensive simulation studies in Section \ref{sec:sim} and an application to evaluate the effect of self-efficacy on fatigue among health care workers during the COVID-19 outbreak in Section \ref{sec:app}, before concluding with a brief discussion about possible extensions in Section \ref{sec:discussion}. \section{Notation and assumptions} \label{sec:notation} Suppose that $(O_1, \ldots, O_n)$ are independent and identically distributed observations of $O=(Y,A,\bm{M},X)$ from a population of interest, where $Y$ is the outcome, $A$ is the exposure, $\bm{M}=(M_1,...,M_K)^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} $ is a vector of $K$ mediators of interest for some $K\in \mathbb{Z}^+$ and $X$ is a vector of measured baseline covariates not affected by the exposure. \cite{robins1992identifiability} and \cite{pearl2001direct} defined what are now often called natural direct and indirect effects. To formalize these causal effects under potential outcomes framework \citep{neyman1923applications,rubin1974estimating}, let $Y({a,\mathbf{m}})$ denote the potential outcome that would be observed if $A=a$ and $\bm{M}=\mathbf{m}$. Similarly, let $\bm{M}(a)$ denote the potential mediator values that would be observed when exposure takes value $A=a$. Comparing any two values $a$, $a^{\prime}$ of the exposure, the population average natural direct and indirect effects through the $K$ mediators jointly are given by \begin{align} NDE(a, a^{\prime})=E[Y(a,\bm{M}(a^{\prime}))-Y(a^{\prime},\bm{M}(a^{\prime}))],\quad NIE(a, a^{\prime})=E[Y(a,\bm{M}(a))-Y(a,\bm{M}(a^{\prime}))], \end{align} respectively \citep{vanderweele2014mediation}. The average natural direct and indirect effects are particularly relevant for describing the underlying mechanism by which the exposure operates, as their sum $NDE(a, a^{\prime})+NIE(a,a^{\prime})=E[Y(a,\bm{M}(a))-Y(a^{\prime},\bm{M}(a^{\prime}))]$ recovers the average total effect comparing any two values $a$, $a^{\prime}$ of the exposure. \cite{vanderweele2014mediation} proposed a parametric regression-based identification approach under the following assumptions that for any values $a$, $a^{\prime}$ of the exposure and $\mathbf{m}$ of the mediators, \begin{itemize} \item[A1$^\ast$.] $\bm{M}(a) \perp A \rvert X$; \item[A2$^\ast$.] $Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) \perp A \rvert X$; \item[A3$^\ast$.] $Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) \perp \bm{M} \rvert A, X$; \item[A4$^\ast$.] $Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) \perp \bm{M}(a^{\prime}) \rvert X$; \item[A5$^\ast$.] $Y=Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) $ if $A=a$ and $\bm{M}=\mathbf{m}$, and $\bm{M}=\bm{M}(a)$ if $A=a$; \item[A6$^\ast$.] $E(Y|A,\bm{M},X)=\bar{\theta}_0+\bar{\theta}_1 A +\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M}+ \bar{\theta}^{ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} }_{3} X$ and $E({M}_j|A,X)=\bar{\beta}_{0,j}+\bar{\beta}_{1,j}A+\bar{\beta}^{ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} }_{2,j} X$ for $j=1,...,K$. \end{itemize} Assumptions (A1$^\ast$)--(A3$^\ast$) state that the vector of measured covariates $X$ is sufficiently rich to capture all confounding effects of the exposure-mediator, exposure-outcome and mediator-outcome relationships. Assumption (A4$^\ast$) is a cross-world independence assumption which, in conjunction with Assumption (A3$^\ast$), is equivalent to the absence of exposure-induced mediator-outcome confounders $L$ on a causal diagram interpreted as a nonparametric structural equation model with independent errors \citep{pearl2009causality}. If the variables in $L$ are measured then we can treat them as additional mediators in $\bm{M}$ and assess the mediation effects jointly \citep{vanderweele2014effect}. The potential outcomes are related to the observed data via the consistency Assumption (A5$^\ast$). Lastly, \cite{vanderweele2014mediation} considered the parametric outcome and mediator regressions in Assumption (A6$^\ast$) for simplicity and ease of estimation. Under Assumptions (A1$^\ast$)--(A6$^\ast$), \cite{vanderweele2014mediation} showed that the natural direct and indirect effects are encoded by the parameters \begin{align} \label{eq:param} NDE(a, a^{\prime})=\bar{\theta}_1(a-a^{\prime}),\quad NIE(a, a^{\prime})=\bar{\beta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{1}\bar{\theta}_{2}(a-a^{\prime}), \end{align} respectively, where $\bar{\beta}_1=(\bar{\beta}_{1,1},...,\bar{\beta}_{1,K})^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} $. Although Assumptions (A1$^\ast$) and (A2$^\ast$) generally hold when the exposure is randomly assigned, in practical settings Assumption (A3$^\ast$) may be violated as it is often infeasible to also randomize or intervene on any of the $K$ mediators. To develop the identification framework which allows for unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding, we follow \cite{ding2016sharp} and incorporate an additional set of unmeasured baseline covariates $U$ not affected by the exposure in the assumptions: \begin{itemize} \item[A1.] $\bm{M}(a) \perp A \rvert X,U$; \item[A2.] $Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) \perp A \rvert X,U$; \item[A3.] $Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) \perp \bm{M} \rvert A,X,U$; \item[A4.] $Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) \perp \bm{M}(a^{\prime}) \rvert X,U$; \item[A5.] $Y=Y({a,\mathbf{m}}) $ if $A=a$ and $\bm{M}=\mathbf{m}$, and $\bm{M}=\bm{M}(a)$ if $A=a$; \item[A6.] $E(Y|A,\bm{M},X,U)=\bar{\theta}_1 A +\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M}+H(X,U)$ and $E({M}_j|A,X,U)=\bar{\beta}_{1,j}A+G_j(X,U)$ for $j=1,...,K$; \item[A7.] $U \perp A \rvert X$. \end{itemize} Assumptions (A1)--(A4) are analogues of Assumptions (A1$^\ast$)--(A4$^\ast$) conditional on $(X,U)$. The partially linear regression models in Assumption (A6) extend the models in Assumption (A6$^\ast$) to incorporate $U$, where $H(X,U)$ and $G_j(X,U)$ are arbitrary functions of $(X,U)$ encoding their confounding effects on the outcome and $j$-th mediator, respectively. Assumption (A7) states that the exposure is essentially randomized within strata of $X$, either by design or through some natural experiments \citep{hernan2006instruments}. This scenario is depicted in Figure \ref{fig1} with two mediators. Based on the derivation in \cite{vanderweele2014mediation}, it is straightforward to show that under Assumptions (A1)--(A6) the natural direct and indirect effects are again given by (\ref{eq:param}). However, it is now more challenging to identify the parameters indexing the regressions in Assumption (A6) as they depend on unmeasured variables $U$. In the next section, we discuss how identification may be achieved in conjunction with Assumption (A7). \begin{figure}[!htbp] \vspace*{10pt} \centering \begin{tikzpicture}[->,>=stealth',node distance=1cm, auto,] \node[est] (A) {$A$}; \node[est, right=of A] (M1) {$M_1$}; \node[est, right = of M1] (M2) { $M_2$}; \node[est, right=of M2] (Y) {$Y$}; \node[est, below=2cm of M2] (U) {$U$}; \path[pil] (A) edgenode {} (M1); \path[pil] (A) edge [bend right=45] node {} (Y); \path[pil] (A) edge [bend right=45] node {} (M2); \path[pil] (M1) edgenode {} (M2); \path[pil] (M1) edge [bend left=45] node {} (Y); \path[pil] (M2) edgenode {} (Y); \path[pil] (U) edgenode {} (M1); \path[pil] (U) edgenode {} (M2); \path[pil] (U) edgenode {} (Y); \end{tikzpicture} \caption{Causal diagram with unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding for two mediators within strata of $X$.} \label{fig1} \end{figure} \section{Identification} \label{sec:identification} Under Assumptions (A6) and (A7), the observed data mediator regression models are \begin{equation} \begin{split} \label{eq:mediator} E(M_j|A,X)=\bar{\beta}_{1,j} A+\bar{G}_{j}(X),\quad j=1,...,K, \end{split} \end{equation} where $\bar{G}_{j}(X)=E\{G_{j}(X,U)|A,X\}=E\{G_{j}(X,U)|X\}$ is an arbitrary function of the measured baseline covariates for $j=1,...,K$. The $K$ separate mediator partially linear regression curves and hence the parameters $\bar{\beta}_{1}$ and $\bar{G}=(\bar{G}_{1},...,\bar{G}_{K})$ are identified from the observed data. It remains to identify the parameters $\bar{\theta}=(\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _2,\bar{\theta}_1)^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} $ indexing the outcome regression. \cite{fulcher2019estimation} proposed a higher moment condition to identify the natural indirect effect, which can be extended under Assumptions (A6) and (A7) to yield the following $K$ conditional mean independence conditions, \begin{equation} \begin{split} \label{eq:ind1} E\{(M_j-\bar{\beta}_{1,j}A -\bar{G}_{j}(X))(Y-\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M})|A,X\}=\text{Cov}\{G_{j},H|A,X\}=\text{Cov}\{G_{j},H|X\},\quad j=1,...,K, \end{split} \end{equation} where the dependencies of $G_j$, $H$ on $(X,U)$ for $j=1,...,K$ have been suppressed for brevity. While (\ref{eq:ind1}) suffices for identification of $\bar{\theta}_2$, it is generally insufficient for identification of $\bar{\theta}$. For example, when there are no measured baseline covariates and $A$ is binary, (\ref{eq:ind1}) places $K$ restrictions on the observed data law, but there are $K+1$ parameters in $\bar{\theta}$. As a remedy, we propose the following additional conditional mean independence condition under Assumptions (A6) and (A7), \begin{equation} \begin{split} \label{eq:ind2} E(Y-\bar{\theta}_1 A -\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M}|A,X)=E\{H(X,U)|A,X\}=E\{H(X,U)|X\}. \end{split} \end{equation} The moment conditions in (\ref{eq:ind1}) and (\ref{eq:ind2}) can be summarized as \begin{equation} \begin{split} \label{eq:ind3} E\{\psi(O;\bar{\beta}_1,\bar{\theta},\bar{G})|A,X\}=E\{\psi(O;\bar{\beta}_1,\bar{\theta},\bar{G})|X\}, \end{split} \end{equation} where \begin{equation*} \psi(O;\bar{\beta}_1,\bar{\theta},\bar{G})=\begin{Bmatrix} (M_1-\bar{\beta}_{1,1} A-\bar{G}_{1}(X))(Y-\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M})\\ \vdots \\ (M_K-\bar{\beta}_{1,K} A-\bar{G}_{K}(X))(Y-\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M})\\ Y-\bar{\theta}_1 A-\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M} \end{Bmatrix}=\begin{Bmatrix} (\bm{M}-E[ \bm{M}|A,X;\bar{\beta}_{1},\bar{G} ])(Y-\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M})\\ Y-\bar{\theta}_1 A-\bar{\theta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{2} \bm{M} \end{Bmatrix}. \end{equation*} Following the G-estimation approach of \cite{robins1994correcting}, we consider the unconditional form of (\ref{eq:ind3}) for identification and estimation, \begin{equation} \begin{split} \label{eq:g} E[\{A-\bar{\pi}(X)\}\psi(O;\bar{\beta}_1,\bar{\theta},\bar{G})]=E[{\Psi}(O;\bar{\pi},\bar{\beta}_1,\bar{\theta},\bar{G})]=0, \end{split} \end{equation} where $\bar{\pi}(X)=E(A|X)$ denotes the propensity score \citep{rosenbaum1983central} which is either known by design or identified from observed data. To ensure that the solution to (\ref{eq:g}) is unique, we also require the following rank condition to hold \citep{rothenberg1971identification}: \begin{itemize} \item[A8. ] The matrix $G={\partial E[{\Psi}(O;\bar{\pi},\bar{\beta}_1,{\theta},\bar{G})]}/{\partial \theta}$ is non-singular for all values of $\theta$. \end{itemize} By iterated expectations, $\text{det}(G)=(-1)^{K+1}G_{1} \text{det}(G_{2})$ where $G_{1}=E[\text{Var}(A|X)]$ and $G_{2}=E[\{A-\bar{\pi}(X)\}\text{Var}(\bm{M}|A,X)]$. This decomposition shows that $\text{det}(G)=0$ if either $\text{Var}(A|X)=0$ or $\text{Var}(\bm{M}|A,X)=\text{Var}(\bm{M}|X)$ almost surely. Therefore two necessary conditions for Assumption (A8) to hold are (1) $\text{Var}(A|X=x)>0$ for at least one value $x$ of the measured covariates and (2) $\text{Var}(\bm{M}|A=a,X=x^{\prime})\neq \text{Var}(\bm{M}|A=a^{\prime},X=x^{\prime})$ for at least one pair of exposure values $a\neq a^{\prime}$ and a value $x^{\prime}$ of the measured covariates. Condition (1) for identification of the natural direct effect parameter $\bar{\theta}_1$ is akin to the positivity assumption for a binary exposure in causal inference under unconfoundedness conditions and typically holds when the exposure is randomly assigned by the investigator. Condition (2) leverages heteroscedasticity of the mediators with respect to the exposure for identification of $\bar{\theta}_2$, which is plausible under a variety of settings in the health and social sciences due to heterogeneity in the exposure's effect on the mediators. For example, consider the following mediator structural equation models \citep{pearl2009causality} $$M_j =\beta_{1,j}(\varepsilon_j)A+G_{j}(X,U) ,\quad j=1,...,K,$$ where $\varepsilon_j\perp A,X,U$ represents heterogeneity in the effect of $A$ on $M_j$. \cite{tchetgen2021genius} showed that $\text{Var}(M_j|A,X)$ remains a function of $A$ provided that the distribution of $\varepsilon_j$ is non-degenerate, for $j=1,...,K$. \begin{lemma} \label{lem:1} Under Assumptions (A6)--(A8), the parameters $\bar{\beta}_1$ and $\bar{\theta}$ are identified from the observed data. \end{lemma} \section{A two-step method of moments estimation approach} \label{sec:estimation} The semiparametric identification result in Lemma \ref{lem:1} involves the nonparametric nuisance components $\bar{\pi}$ and $\bar{G}$. In principle it is possible to estimate these components nonparametrically under sufficient smoothness conditions. However, if $X$ contains numerous continuous variables, the resulting estimators may exhibit poor finite sample behavior in moderately sized samples as the data are too sparse to conduct stratified estimation \citep{robins1997toward}. For this reason as well as simplicity and ease of implementation, in this paper we propose a two-step method of moments approach in which $\bar{\pi}$ and $\bar{G}$ are estimated under the following parametric assumptions in the first step, \begin{itemize} \item[A9.] $\bar{\pi}(X)=\pi(C;\bar{\gamma})$ and $\bar{G}_j(X)={G}_j(X;\bar{\alpha}_j)$ for $j=1,...,K$, where $\pi(C;\gamma)$ and ${G}_j(X;{\alpha}_j)$ are known functions smooth in the finite-dimensional parameters $\gamma$ and ${\alpha}_j$ respectively. \end{itemize} Throughout let $ \widehat{E}_n\{g(O)\}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^n g(O_i)$ denote the empirical mean operator and ${\alpha}=(\alpha^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _1,...,\alpha^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _K)^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} $. \subsection{ First step} Let $S(A,C;\gamma)$ and $S(M,A,X;\alpha,\beta_1)$ denote some user-specified unbiased estimating functions for the parameters $\bar{\gamma}$, $\bar{\alpha}$ and $\bar{\beta}_1$ respectively based on Assumption (A9). For example, typically a logistic regression model is used for binary $A$, say $\pi(X;\gamma)=\{1+\exp(-\gamma^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} X)\}^{-1}$, in which case the score function of $\gamma$ is \begin{equation} \label{eq:s1} S(A,X;\gamma)=X\{A-\pi(X;\gamma)\}. \end{equation} In addition, if we specify the linear model $G_j(X;\alpha_j)=\alpha_{j}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} X$ for the $j$-th mediator regression, $j=1,...,K$, then \begin{equation} \label{eq:s2} S(M,A,X;\alpha,\beta_1)=\begin{Bmatrix} (A,X^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} )^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} (M_1-\beta_{1,1} A-\alpha_{1}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} X)\\ \vdots \\ (A,X^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} )^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} (M_K-\beta_{1,K} A-\alpha_{K}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} X) \end{Bmatrix}. \end{equation} Let $\widehat{\gamma}$, $\widehat{\alpha}$ and $\widehat{\beta}_1$ denote the estimators which jointly solve the empirical moment condition $$ \widehat{E}_n\{S^{ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} }(A,C;\gamma),S^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} (M,A,X;\alpha,\beta_1)\}^{ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} }=0,$$ and let $\widehat{\pi}(X)=\pi(X;\widehat{\gamma})$ and $\widehat{G}(X)=\{G_1(X;\widehat{\alpha}_1),...,G_K(X;\widehat{\alpha}_K)\}$. \subsection{ Second step} In the second stage, we obtain $\widehat{{\theta}}$ which solves the following empirical version of moment condition (\ref{eq:g}), $$ \widehat{E}_n[{\Psi}(O;\widehat{\pi},\widehat{\beta}_1,{\theta},\widehat{G})]=0.$$ An appealing feature of the two-step procedure is that the nuisance components $\bar{\pi}$ and $\bar{G}$ can be estimated before the second stage involving the outcome data, and therefore mitigates potential for "data-dredging" exercises that comes with a fully specified outcome model \citep{rubin2007design}. \subsection{ Inference} For inference, the empirical moments involved in the two-step procedure can be ``stacked'' to account for the variability associated with the first-step estimation of nuisance parameters \citep{newey1994large}. Specifically, let $\varphi=({\gamma}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} ,{\alpha}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} ,{\beta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _1,\theta^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} )^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} $. Then the estimator $\widehat{{\varphi}}$ may be viewed as solving the joint empirical moment condition $\widehat{E}_n\{\Phi(O;{\varphi})\}=0$, where $$\Phi(O;{\varphi})= \{S^{ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} }(A,C;\gamma),S^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} (M,A,X;\alpha,\beta_1),{\Psi}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} (O;\pi(\gamma),{\beta}_1,{\theta},G(\alpha))\}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} .$$ The following result on asymptotic normality of $\widehat{{\varphi}}$ follows from standard M-estimation theory \citep{newey1994large}. \begin{lemma} Suppose Assumptions (A6)--(A9) hold. Then under standard regularity conditions and as $n\to\infty$, $$\sqrt{n}(\widehat{{\varphi}}-\bar{{\varphi}}) \xrightarrow{D} N\left(0, \left[\frac{\partial E\{\Phi(O;{\varphi})\}}{\partial \varphi}\biggr \rvert_{\varphi=\bar{\varphi}}\right]^{-1} E\{\Phi(O;\bar{\varphi})\Phi^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} (O;\bar{\varphi})\}\left[\frac{\partial E\{\Phi(O;{\varphi})\}}{\partial \varphi}\biggr \rvert_{\varphi=\bar{\varphi}}\right]^{-1 {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} }\right).$$ \end{lemma} \noindent It follows that, in conjunction with Assumptions (A1)--(A5), the estimators of the natural direct and indirect effects per unit change in the exposure are given by \begin{align} \label{eq:param2} \widehat{NDE}=\widehat{\theta}_1,\quad \widehat{NIE}=\widehat{\beta}^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} _{1}\widehat{\theta}_{2}, \end{align} respectively, and their limiting variances can be derived using the multivariate delta method. Alternatively, nonparametric bootstrap may also be used to perform inference. \section{Simulation study} \label{sec:sim} In order to investigate the numerical performance of the proposed estimators, we perform Monte Carlo simulations involving independent and identically distributed data $(Y,A,\bm{M},X,U)$ with three mediators $\bm{M}=(M_1,M_2,M_3)^ {\mathrm{\scriptscriptstyle T}} $ generated as follows: \begin{align*} &X\sim N(0,1);\quad U\mid X \sim N(1+0.5 X,1),\\ &A\mid X,U \sim {Bernoulli}\left\{p=\frac{1}{1+\exp(-0.8-1.2 X)}\right\},\\ &\bm{M}\mid A,X,U \sim N \begin{Bmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} 1.2+1.5 A+1.1 X+\eta U \\ 0.5+1.2 A+1.8 X+\eta U \\ 1.3+1.0 A+0.5 X+\eta U \end{pmatrix} , \bm{\Sigma} \end{Bmatrix},\\ & Y \mid A,\bm{M},X,U \sim N(1.3+2.5 A +1.2 M_1+0.8 M_2 +M_3+1.5 X +\eta U,1), \end{align*} where $\bm{\Sigma}$ has the Toeplitz covariance structure $\text{Cov}(M_i,M_j)=2^{-|i-j|}(1+\delta A)$ for $1\leq i,j\leq 3$. Under this data generating mechanism, we vary (i) the sample size $n=400$ or $800$, (ii) the degree of unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding encoded by $\eta=0$ or $0.5$ as well as (iii) the magnitude of heteroscedasticity encoded by $\delta=2.0$ or $5.0$. We compare the proposed estimators $\widehat{NDE}$ and $\widehat{NIE}$ implemented using the correctly specified models (\ref{eq:s1}) and (\ref{eq:s2}) with the regression-based estimators $\widehat{NDE}_{reg}$ and $\widehat{NIE}_{reg}$ of \cite{vanderweele2014mediation}. Standard errors are obtained using the empirical sandwich estimator \citep{newey1994large}. The following remarks can be made based on the results of 1000 simulation replicates summarized in Tables \ref{tab:1} and \ref{tab:2}. The proposed estimators $\widehat{NDE}$ and $\widehat{NIE}$ show negligible bias and coverage proportion close to the nominal level of $0.95$ once sample size reaches $n=800$ across all simulation settings, but with substantially higher variance than $\widehat{NDE}_{reg}$ and $\widehat{NIE}_{reg}$. In agreement with theory, $\widehat{NDE}_{reg}$ and $\widehat{NIE}_{reg}$ perform well in the absence of unmeasured outcome-mediator confounding but exhibit noticeable bias and undercoverage otherwise. The variance of the proposed estimators generally decreases when sample size or the magnitude of mediator heteroscedasticity increases. \begin{table} \begin{center} \caption{Comparison of methods for estimation of the natural direct and indirect effects in the absence of unmeasured outcome-mediator confounding $(\eta=0)$. The two rows of results for each estimator correspond to sample sizes of $n = 400$ and $n = 800$ respectively.} \label{tab:1} \bigskip \begin{tabular}{cccccccccccc} \toprule & $\widehat{NDE}$ & $\widehat{NIE}$ & $\widehat{NDE}_{reg}$ &$\widehat{NIE}_{reg}$\\ \hline\noalign{\smallskip} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{$\delta=2.0$}\\ $|\text{Bias}|$ & 0.014 & 0.021& 0.007 & 0.000 \\ & 0.008 & 0.008 & 0.001 & 0.000 \\ $\sqrt{\text{Var}}$ & 0.268 & 0.415 & 0.134 & 0.378 \\ &0.178 & 0.267 & 0.095 & 0.253 \\ $\sqrt{\text{EVar}}$ & 0.422 & 0.422 & 0.375 & 0.375 \\ & 0.177 & 0.287 & 0.091 & 0.265 \\ Cov95 & 0.959 & 0.947 & 0.937 & 0.945 \\ & 0.956 & 0.962 & 0.941 & 0.956\\ & \multicolumn{4}{c}{$\delta=5.0$}\\ $|\text{Bias}|$ & 0.005 & 0.010& 0.007 & 0.001 \\ & 0.005 & 0.005 & 0.001 & 0.000 \\ $\sqrt{\text{Var}}$ & 0.167 & 0.471 & 0.129 & 0.483 \\ &0.116 & 0.316 & 0.091 & 0.328 \\ $\sqrt{\text{EVar}}$ & 0.164 & 0.471 & 0.124 & 0.482 \\ & 0.113 & 0.332 & 0.088 & 0.340 \\ Cov95 & 0.948 & 0.947 & 0.938 & 0.945 \\ & 0.950 & 0.962 & 0.941 & 0.954\\ \hline \end{tabular} \begin{tablenotes} \item{\noindent \small Note: $|\text{Bias}|$ and $\sqrt{\text{Var}}$ are the Monte Carlo absolute bias and standard deviation of the point estimates, $\sqrt{\text{EVar}}$ is the square root of the mean of the variance estimates and Cov95 is the coverage proportion of the 95\% confidence intervals, based on 1000 repeated simulations. Zeros denote values smaller than $0.0005$.} \end{tablenotes} \end{center} \end{table} \begin{table} \begin{center} \caption{Comparison of methods for estimation of the natural direct and indirect effects in the presence of unmeasured outcome-mediator confounding $(\eta=0.5)$. The two rows of results for each estimator correspond to sample sizes of $n = 400$ and $n = 800$ respectively.} \label{tab:2} \bigskip \begin{tabular}{cccccccccccc} \toprule & $\widehat{NDE}$ & $\widehat{NIE}$ & $\widehat{NDE}_{reg}$ &$\widehat{NIE}_{reg}$\\ \hline\noalign{\smallskip} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{$\delta=2.0$}\\ $|\text{Bias}|$ & 0.053 & 1.195& 0.198 & 1.446 \\ & 0.016 & 0.034 & 0.194 & 0.176 \\ $\sqrt{\text{Var}}$ & 0.384 & 0.511 & 0.146 & 0.434 \\ &0.230 & 0.318 & 0.101 & 0.296 \\ $\sqrt{\text{EVar}}$ & 0.454 & 0.574 & 0.140 & 0.434 \\ & 0.231 & 0.340 & 0.099 & 0.307 \\ Cov95 & 0.962 & 0.953 & 0.697 & 0.926 \\ & 0.955 & 0.961 & 0.496 & 0.923\\ & \multicolumn{4}{c}{$\delta=5.0$}\\ $|\text{Bias}|$ & 0.012 & 1.238& 0.119 & 1.368 \\ & 0.003 & 0.021 & 0.115 & 0.097 \\ $\sqrt{\text{Var}}$ & 0.194 & 0.501 & 0.142 & 0.526 \\ &0.136 & 0.339 & 0.099 & 0.361 \\ $\sqrt{\text{EVar}}$ & 0.194 & 0.506 & 0.136 & 0.528 \\ & 0.133 & 0.356 & 0.096 & 0.373 \\ Cov95 & 0.948 & 0.952 & 0.839 & 0.943 \\ & 0.951 & 0.952 & 0.763 & 0.947\\ \hline \end{tabular} \begin{tablenotes} \item{\noindent \small Note: See the footnote of Table \ref{tab:1}.} \end{tablenotes} \end{center} \end{table} \section{Application} \label{sec:app} We apply the proposed methods in reanalysing an observational dataset from \cite{Houdata} on $n=527$ healthcare workers from Anhui Province, China during the COVID-19 outbreak in March 2020 to evaluate the mediating effects of post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms in the association between self-efficacy and fatigue. We refer interested readers to \cite{hou2020self} for further details on the study design. The binary exposure $A$ is the total score on the General Self-Efficacy Scale dichotomized at the sample median while the outcome of interest $Y$ is the standardized total score on the 14-item Fatigue Scale. The three mediators under consideration ($M_1,M_2,M_3$) are standardized scores in post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms reported in three categories; re-experiencing, avoidance and hyperarousal. The vector of measured baseline variables $X$ include age, level of negative coping, gender, marital status, education level, years of working experience and technical title. We implement the proposed estimators $\widehat{NDE}$ and $\widehat{NIE}$ using generalized linear models (\ref{eq:s1}) and (\ref{eq:s2}) together with the regression-based estimators $\widehat{NDE}_{reg}$ and $\widehat{NIE}_{reg}$ of \cite{vanderweele2014mediation} to estimate the natural direct and indirect effects of self-efficacy on fatigue mediated though the three categories of post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms jointly. Table \ref{tab3} shows the analysis results. The regression-based estimators of \cite{vanderweele2014mediation} have noticeably smaller standard errors than the proposed estimators, in agreement with the Monte Carlo results, and yield statistically significant natural direct and indirect effects at $\alpha$-level of 0.05. On the other hand, the point estimate of $\widehat{NIE}$ is close to zero and statistically insignificant at the same $\alpha$-level. This result suggests that we cannot rule out a null joint indirect effect after accounting for potential unmeasured confounding of the mediator-outcome relationship. \begin{table} \centering \caption{Estimates of direct and indirect effects of self-efficacy on fatigue mediated though three post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms jointly.}{% \begin{tabular}{ccccccccccccc} \toprule $\widehat{NDE}$ & $\widehat{NIE}$ & $\widehat{NDE}_{reg}$ &$\widehat{NIE}_{reg}$ \\ \midrule $-0.735\pm 0.486$ & $0.040\pm 0.474$& $-0.405\pm 0.145$ & $-0.289\pm 0.088$\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular}} \label{tab3} \begin{tablenotes} \small \item Note: Estimate $\pm$ $1.96\times$standard error. \end{tablenotes} \end{table} \section{Discussions} \label{sec:discussion} One of the main concerns with causal mediation analysis with multiple mediators is the inability to categorically rule out the existence of unmeasured mediator-outcome confounders, as it is generally infeasible to randomize any of the mediators under consideration. In this paper, we build upon the works of \cite{vanderweele2014mediation} and \cite{fulcher2019estimation} to develop a simple two-step method of moments estimation procedure to assess the joint mediation effects of multiple mediators in the presence of potential unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding. Our work can be extended in several important directions, including identification and estimation of path-specific effects \citep{10.5555/1642293.1642350,albert2011generalized,daniel2015causal} or their interventional analogues \citep{vansteelandt2017interventional,lin2017interventional,loh2020heterogeneous} as well as causal mediation analysis of survival outcome with multiple mediators \citep{huang2017causal,lin2017mediation}, which we plan to pursue in future research. \section*{Acknowledgement} Baoluo Sun is supported by the National University of Singapore Start-Up Grant (R-155-000-203-133). \thispagestyle{empty} \bibliographystyle{apalike}

\section{Duality in Maxwell theory} It is well known that the action for a free Maxwell field $A_m(x)$ ($m$=0,1,2,3) \begin{equation}\label{max} S=-\int d^4x{1\over 4}F_{mn}F^{mn}={1\over 2}\int d^4x({\bf E}^2-{\bf B}^2) \end{equation} is not invariant under duality transformations of the electric and magnetic strength vectors ${\bf E}~\rightarrow~{\bf B},~{\bf B}~\rightarrow~-{\bf E}$, while the free Maxwell equations are invariant: \begin{equation}\label{me} \nabla\times{\bf E}=-{{\partial{\bf B}}\over{\partial t}}, \qquad \nabla\times{\bf B}={{\partial{\bf E}}\over{\partial t}}, \qquad \nabla{\bf E}=\nabla{\bf B}=0. \end{equation} To have duality symmetry at the level of action one has to double the number of gauge fields ($A^\alpha_m$, $\alpha=1,2$) \cite{z,ko,ss2} and construct an action in such a way that one of the gauge fields becomes an auxiliary field upon solving equations of motion \cite{ss2}. An alternative duality symmetric version of Maxwell action was considered in \cite{d}. The duality symmetric action of refs. \cite{z,ss2} can be written in the following form: \begin{equation}\label{ss} S=\int d^4x(-{1\over 8}F^\alpha_{mn}F^{mn\alpha} +{1\over 4}{\cal F}^\alpha_{0i}{\cal F}^{\alpha}_{i0}),\qquad (i=1,2,3) \end{equation} where \begin{equation}\label{sd} {\cal F}^\alpha_{mn}={\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}F^\beta_{mn}-{1\over 2}\epsilon_{mnlp}F^{lp\alpha}={1\over 2}\epsilon_{mnlp} {\cal F}^{lp\beta}{\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}, \end{equation} (${\cal L}^{12}=-{\cal L}^{21}=1$). Duality symmetry is a discrete subgroup of $SO(2)$ rotations of $A^\alpha_m$ $(A^\alpha_m~\rightarrow~{\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}A^\beta_m)$. Note that ${\cal F}^\alpha_{mn}{\cal F}^{\alpha mn}=0$ due to the self--duality property, and the second term in \p{ss} breaks manifest Lorentz invariance. However, beside the manifest spacial rotations the action \p{ss} is invariant under the following modified space--time transformations of $A^\alpha_i$ (in the gauge $A^\alpha_0=0$) \begin{equation}\label{st} \d A^\alpha_i=x^0v^k\partial_kA^\alpha_i+v^kx^k\partial_0A^\alpha_i+ v^kx^k{\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}{\cal F}^\beta_{0i}, \end{equation} where the first two terms describe the ordinary Lorentz boosts along a constant velocity $v^i$ and the third term vanishes on the mass shell since an additional local symmetry of the action \p{ss} \begin{equation}\label{ad} \d A^a_0=\varphi^\alpha(x) \end{equation} allows one to reduce the equations of motion \begin{equation}\label{em} {{\d S}\over{\d A^\alpha_i}}=\e^{ijk}\partial_i{\cal F}^\alpha_{k0}=0 \end{equation} to a duality condition \begin{equation}\label{9} {\cal F}^\alpha_{mn}={\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}F^\beta_{mn}-{1\over 2}\epsilon_{mnlp}F^{lp\alpha}=0 \end{equation} which, on the one hand, leads to the Maxwell equations \begin{equation}\label{ma} \partial_m{\cal F}^{mn\alpha}=\partial_mF^{mn\alpha}=0 \end{equation} and, on the other hand, completely determines one of the gauge fields through another one. For instance, using the relation $$ {1\over 2}\epsilon_{mnlp}F^{2mn}=F^1_{mn} $$ we can exclude $A^2_m(x)$ from the action \p{ss} and get the conventional Maxwell action. \bigskip {\bf Covariantization}. One can admit that the action \p{ss} arose as a result of some gauge fixing which specifies time direction in a Lorentz covariant action \cite{pst,pst1}. \footnote{An attempt to construct this action was undertaken by Khoudeir and Pantoja \cite{l}. Unfortunately, they did not manage to find a consistent formulation of the model.} The first step is to covariantize the self--dual part of the action \p{ss}. The simplest possible way to do this is to introduce an auxiliary vector field $u_m(x)$ and write the action as follows: \begin{equation}\label{11} S_A=\int d^4x (-{1\over 8}F^\alpha_{mn}F^{\alpha mn} +{1\over{4(-u_lu^l)}}u^m{\cal F}^\alpha_{mn}{\cal F}^{\alpha np}u_p). \end{equation} The main problem is to find a local symmetry which would permit to choose a gauge where $u_m$ is a constant vector, in particular, \begin{equation}\label{g} u_m(x)=\d^0_m. \end{equation} Then the action \p{11} can reduce to \p{ss}. Note that we have introduced the norm of $u_m$ $(u^lu_l=u^2)$ into the action \p{11}. This is necessary for ensuring the symmetry we are looking for. When $u_m$ is a constant vector, it corresponds to the frozen straight Dirac string \cite{z}, while when $u_m(x)$ depends on space--time coordinates, one can regard the Dirac string to be curved. The search for this symmetry turns out to be connected with another problem, namely, the problem of preserving a local symmetry under \p{ad}. In the covariant version this transformation should be replaced by \begin{equation}\label{adc} \d A^\alpha_m=u_m\varphi^\alpha. \end{equation} To keep this symmetry is important (as we have already seen) for getting the duality condition \p{9}. To have the invariance under transformations \p{adc} one should add to the Lorentz invariant action \p{11} another term \begin{equation}\label{B} S_B=-\int d^4x\e^{mnpq}u_m\partial_nB_{pq}, \end{equation} where $B_{mn}(x)$ is an antisymmetric tensor field. Then the variation of \p{11} under \p{adc} is canceled by the variation of \p{B} under \begin{equation}\label{bv} \d B_{mn}=-{{\varphi^\alpha}\over{u^2}}({\cal F}^\alpha_{mp}u^pu_n- {\cal F}^\alpha_{np}u^pu_m). \end{equation} Note that \p{B} is also invariant under \begin{equation}\label{b} \delta B_{mn}=\partial_{[m}b_{n]}(x). \end{equation} As in the case of action \p{ss}, the local symmetry \p{adc} allows one to fix a gauge on the mass shell in such a way that the duality condition \p{9} takes place. Thus, we again remain with only one independent Maxwell field and get the duality between its electric and magnetic strength vector. In view of the vanishing condition for the self--dual strength tensor the equations of motion of $u_m$ reduce to: \begin{equation}\label{u} {{\d(S_A+S_B)}\over{\d u_m}}=\e^{mnlp}\partial_nB_{lp}=0 ~~\rightarrow~~ B_{mn}=\partial_{[m}b_{n]}, \end{equation} which means that $B_{mn}$ is completely auxiliary and can be eliminated by use of the corresponding local transformations \p{b}. The only thing which has remained to show is that $u_m$ itself does not carry physical degrees of freedom and can be gauge fixed to $u_m=\d^0_m$. For this we have to find a corresponding local symmetry. The form of the action \p{B} prompts that $S_A+S_B$ (\p{11}, \p{B}) can be invariant under the following transformations of $u_m$: \begin{equation}\label{pc} \d u_m(x)=\partial_m\varphi(x). \end{equation} This is indeed the case provided $A^\alpha_m$ and $B_{mn}$ transform as follows \begin{equation}\label{12} \d A^\alpha_m= {{\varphi(x)}\over{u^2}}{\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}{\cal F}^\beta_{mn}u^n, \qquad \d B_{mn}={{\varphi(x)}\over{(u^2)^2}}{\cal F}^{\alpha r}_{m} u_r{\cal F}^{\beta s}_nu_s{\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}. \end{equation} Then, taking into account that the equations of motion of $B_{mn}$ give \begin{equation}\label{ue} \partial_{[m}u_{n]}=0~~~\rightarrow~~~u_m(x)=\partial_m\hat\varphi(x) \end{equation} and requiring that $u^2\not= 0$ (to escape singularities), we can use this local transformation to put $u_m=\d^0_m$. In this gauge the manifestly Lorentz invariant duality symmetric action \begin{equation}\label{lo} S=\int d^4x (-{1\over 8}F^\alpha_{mn}F^{\alpha mn} +{1\over{4(-u_lu^l)}}u^m{\cal F}^\alpha_{mn}{\cal F}^{\alpha np}u_p -\epsilon^{mnpq}u_m\partial_nB_{pq}). \end{equation} reduces to \p{ss}, and the local transformations of $A_m^\alpha$ \p{12} (with $\varphi(x)=x^iv^i$) are combined with the corresponding Lorentz transformations and produce the modified space--time symmetry \p{st} of the action \p{ss}. It seems of interest to understand the origin of the fields $u_m(x)$ and $B_{mn}(x)$ and of the local transformations \p{pc}. The form of the term in the action \p{lo} containing $B_{mn}$ reminds a term one encounters in a formulation of a pseudoscalar (`axion') field (see, for the details \cite{o,bo,nt,k,q} and references therein) \begin{equation}\label{1} S=\int d^4x \left( -{1\over 2}(\partial_m a(x)-u_m(x))(\partial^m a(x)-u^m(x)) -\e^{pqmn}u_p\partial_qB_{mn} \right). \end{equation} The action \p{1} is invariant under local Peccei--Quinn transformations \begin{equation}\label{pct} \d a(x)=\varphi(x),\qquad \d u_m=\partial_m\varphi(x), \end{equation} ($u_m$ being the corresponding gauge field) and produces dual versions of the axion action: $$ L=-{1\over 2}\partial_ma(x)\partial^ma(x), $$ \begin{equation}\label{a} L={1\over{3!}}\partial_{[m}B_{np]}\partial^{[m}B^{np]}. \end{equation} The duality relation between the pseudoscalar field $a(x)$ and the antisymmetric tensor field $B_{mn}$ \begin{equation}\label{5} \partial_la(x)=\epsilon_{lmnp}\partial^mB^{np} \end{equation} is a consequence of the equations of motion of $u_m$ obtained from \p{1}. Thus, one may treat the origin of the duality symmetric Maxwell action as a result of a specific coupling of the two Maxwell fields to the auxiliary gauge field $u_m$ from the axionic sector of the theory. \bigskip {\bf $SL(2,{\bf R})$ invariant axion--dilaton coupling and coupling to gravity}.\\ The duality symmetric model considered above admits axion--dilaton coupling which respects global $SL(2,{\bf R})$ invariance as well as coupling to gravity \cite{ss2,pst,pst1}. To do this we introduce a $2\times 2$ matrix dilaton--axion field \begin{equation}\label{calm} {\cal M} = {1\over \lambda_2(x)}\pmatrix{1 & \lambda_1(x)\cr \lambda_1(x) & \lambda^2_1+\lambda^2_2\cr}, \qquad {\cal M}^T={\cal M}, \qquad {\cal{MLM}}^T={\cal L}, \end{equation} and define the global $SL(2,{\bf R})$ transformations as follows: \begin{equation}\label{om} {\cal M}~~\rightarrow~~\omega^T{\cal M}\omega, \qquad \omega{\cal L}\omega^T={\cal L}, \qquad A_m=\omega^TA_m. \end{equation} The coupling is carried out by the modification of the self--dual tensor \p{sd} in the following way \begin{equation}\label{sdm} {\cal F}^{\alpha}_{mn}={\cal L}^{\alpha\beta}F^{\beta}_{mn} -{1\over{2\sqrt{-g}}}\epsilon_{mnlp} ({\cal L}^T{\cal {ML}})^{\alpha\b}F^{lp\beta} \equiv {\sqrt{-g}\over 2} ({\cal L}{\cal M})^{\alpha\beta} \epsilon_{mnpq}{\cal F}^{\beta pq}, \end{equation} where $g=\det g_{mn}(x)$ is the determinant of a gravitational field metric. In the most simple form the $SL(2,{\bf R})$ invariant action is written as follows: \begin{equation}\label{a2} S=\int d^4x\sqrt{-g}( {1\over {2u^2}}u^mF^{*\alpha,a}_{mn} {\cal F}^{\alpha,a~ np}u_p -{1\over 4}g^{mn}tr(\partial_m{\cal {ML}}\partial_n{\cal{ML}}) +{1\over{\sqrt{-g}}}\e^{pqmn}u_p\partial_qB_{mn}+R). \end{equation} Upon fixing the gauge $u_m={1\over{\sqrt{-g^{00}}}}\delta^0_m$, $B_{mn}=0$, the action \p{a2} directly reduces to a corresponding Schwarz--Sen action \cite{ss2}. Note that we would like to identify the field $a(x)$ with $\l_1(x)$ from the axion--dilaton matrix \p{calm}, then, due to the specific coupling of the scalars to the abelian gauge fields the local Peccei--Quinn transformations of the axion field are broken down to the global shifts which are part of the $SL(2,{\bf R})$ group. This is reflected in the structure of the kinetic term for the scalar fields in \p{a2} which does not contain the auxiliary gauge field $u_m$. However, the action is still invariant under the local transformations of $u_m$, $A^\alpha_m$ and $B_{mn}$ \p{pc}, \p{12}. One can go even further and eliminate from the action \p{a2} the term containing $B_{mn}$ by substituting into \p{a2} $u_m=\partial_m\hat\varphi(x)$. The action \p{a2} can be extended to include $O(6,22)$ scalar fields corresponding to a low energy bosonic sector of a toroidally compactified heterotic string in a straightforward way \cite{ss2,pst1}. \bigskip {\bf Adding fermions and supersymmetry}.\\ The kinetic term for neutral fermions is added to the duality symmetric action of a free Maxwell field without any problems: \begin{equation}\label{sus} S=\int d^4x(-{1\over 8}F^\alpha_{mn}F^{\alpha mn} +{1\over{4(-u_lu^l)}}u^m{\cal F}^\alpha}\def\b{\beta_{mn}{\cal F}^{\alpha}\def\b{\beta np}u_p -\e^{mnpq}u_m\partial_nB_{pq}-i\overline{\psi}\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon^m\partial_m\psi). \end{equation} This action is supersymmetric \cite{ss2,pst,pst1} \footnote{A superfield generalization of the non--covariant action \p{ss} was considered earlier in \cite{sal}.} under the following transformations with odd constant parameters $\e^\alpha}\def\b{\beta=i\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_5{\cal L}^{\alpha}\def\b{\beta\b}\e^\b$: $$ \d A^\alpha}\def\b{\beta_m=i{\overline{\psi}}\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_m\e^\alpha}\def\b{\beta, $$ \begin{equation}\label{susy} \d{\psi}={1\over 8}F^{\alpha}\def\b{\beta mn}\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_m\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_n\e^\alpha}\def\b{\beta- {1\over{4u^2}}{\cal L}^{\alpha}\def\b{\beta\b}u_p{\cal F}^{\alpha}\def\b{\beta pm}u^n\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_m\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_n\e^\b, \end{equation} all other fields being inert under the supersymmetry transformations. We see that the supersymmetric transformation law for the fermion $\psi(x)$ (\ref{susy}) is non--conventional and reduces to the ordinary SUSY transformations of the vector supermultiplet $(A^1_m(x),~\psi(x))$ only on the mass shell (\ref{9}) upon excluding $A^2_m$: \begin{equation}\label{su} \d A^1_m=i\bar\psi\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_m\e^1;\qquad \d\psi={1\over 4}F^{1mn}\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_m\gamma}\def\d{\delta}\def\e{\epsilon_n\e^1. \end{equation} This is analogous to the problem with the Lorentz transformations (\ref{st}) which we have just solved. Using the same reasoning as lead us to introducing $u_m(x)$ one may try to find a superpartner of $u_m(x)$ whose presence in the theory gives rise to a local fermionic symmetry (being a counterpart of (\ref{pc}, \ref{12})) which involves $\psi(x)$ and leads to (\ref{susy}) upon gauge fixing the local fermionic symmetry. We shall demonstrate the existence of such local fermionic symmetry in a simpler model for supersymmetric chiral fields in two space--time dimensions. \section{Chiral bosons and fermions in D=2} For comparison let us consider a formulation of the dynamics of the simplest possible self--dual field, namely a chiral boson $\phi(x)$, in two--dimensional space--time. On the mass shell $\phi(x)$ satisfies a self--duality (chirality) condition: \begin{equation}\label{b1} {\cal F}_m\equiv\partial_m\phi-\e_{mn}\partial^n\phi=0= (\partial_0-\partial_1)\phi=\partial_{--}\phi \end{equation} and describes right--moving modes. ${\cal F}_m=\e_{mn}{\cal F}^n$, and $(--,++)$ denote the light--cone vector components. There are several (classically equivalent) versions of the chiral boson action \cite{si,j,bar} from which the chirality condition \p{b1} is obtained. A Lorentz covariant action proposed by Siegel \cite{si} contains the square of the condition $\partial_{--}\phi=0$ with a corresponding Lagrange multiplier $\lambda_{++++}(x)$: \begin{equation}\label{b2} S=\int d^2x{1\over 2}(\partial_{++}\phi\partial_{--}\phi- \lambda_{++++}(\partial_{--}\phi)^2). \end{equation} The system described by the action \p{b2} turns out to be anomalous at the quantum level (because of the constraint $(\partial_{--}\phi)^2=0$) and requires an additional Wess--Zumino term to cancel the anomaly \cite{im}. By putting $\l_{++++}=1$, which breaks manifest Lorentz invariance, one gets the Floreanini--Jackiw action \cite{j} \begin{equation}\label{b3} S=\int d^2x{1\over 2}(\partial_{++}\phi\partial_{--}\phi- (\partial_{--}\phi)^2), \end{equation} which describes a quantum mechanically consistent chiral boson system (provided, appropriate boundary conditions on $\phi$ are imposed) \cite{j,g}, since the constraint $(\partial_{--}\phi)^2=0$ does not directly follow from \p{b3}. The ordinary Lorentz transformations of $\phi(x)$ are replaced by: \begin{equation}\label{b31} \d\phi=vx_m\e^{mn}\partial_n\phi-vx^1\partial_{--}\phi, \end{equation} where $v$ is a constant parameter, and the first term is the ordinary Lorentz boost. The sum of the actions \p{b3}, one for left--movers and one for right--movers, describes a duality symmetric model being a ground for duality symmetric formulation of bosonic string theory \cite{ts}. As in the case of Maxwell theory we can restore the manifest Lorentz invariance by introducing into \p{b3} an auxiliary vector field $u_m(x)$. Because of peculiar properties of the two--dimensional model, this can be carried out in two classically equivalent ways. The first possibility is to consider $u_m(x)$ as a unit--norm time--like vector and to write the action in the form \begin{equation}\label{b4} S=\int d^2x{1\over 2}(\partial_{++}\phi\partial_{--}\phi- u^m{\cal F}_mu^n{\cal F}_n). \end{equation} Then, because $u_m$ was required to satisfy $u_mu^m=-1$, it contains only one independent component, and one can show that \p{b4} reduces to the Siegel action \p{b2}. Another possibility, which seems to be more appropriate from the quantum point of view, is to construct a Lorentz covariant action by analogy with the action \p{lo}: \begin{equation}\label{b5} S=\int d^2x{1\over 2}\left(\partial_{++}\phi\partial_{--}\phi+{1\over u^2} u^m{\cal F}_mu^n{\cal F}_n -\e^{mn}u_m\partial_nB\right), \end{equation} where $B(x)$ is an auxiliary scalar field. The action \p{b5} is invariant under the following local transformations: \begin{equation}\label{b6} \d u_m=\partial_m\varphi,\qquad \d\phi={\varphi\over{u^2}}u^m{\cal F}_m, \qquad \d B=\varphi\left({{u^m{\cal F}_m}\over{u^2}}\right)^2, \end{equation} which permit to choose the gauge $u_m=\d^0_m$ on the mass shell, where: \begin{equation}\label{b7} {{\d S}\over{\d B}}=0 ~~\rightarrow~~u_m=\partial_m\hat\varphi(x), \end{equation} and reduce \p{b5} to \p{b3}. One can simplify \p{b5} by substituting into the action the expression \p{b7} for $u_m$. Then \p{b5} takes the following form: \begin{equation}\label{b8} S=\int d^2x{1\over 2}\left(\partial_{++}\phi\partial_{--}\phi- {{\partial_{++}\hat\varphi}\over{\partial_{--}\hat\varphi}} (\partial_{--}\phi)^2\right), \end{equation} and the transformations \p{b6} reduce to \begin{equation}\label{b9} \d\hat\varphi=\varphi(x),\qquad\d\phi={{\varphi(x)}\over {\partial_{--}\hat\varphi}}\partial_{--}\phi. \end{equation} Note that in contrast to the Siegel case \p{b2} the variation of \p{b8} with respect to the auxiliary field $\hat\varphi(x)$ does not produce the anomalous constraint $(\partial_{--}\phi)^2=0$, since $\hat\varphi$ enters \p{b8} under the derivative. Adding to \p{b5} or \p{b8} the analogous action (containing the same field $u_m$) for left--movers and taking an appropriate number of the left-- and right--moving scalar fields one obtains the duality symmetric formulation of a string \cite{ts,ss1} with manifest space--time symmetries. The Lorentz invariant form \p{b8} of the chiral boson action is directly generalized to a supersymmetric case. Let us consider bosonic superfields $\Phi(x,^{--},x^{++},\th^+)=\phi(x)$ + $i\th^+\psi_+(x)$ and $\Lambda}\def\s{\sigma}\def\S{\Sigma(x^{--},x^{++},\th^+)$ = $\hat\varphi(x)+i\th^+\chi_+(x)$, which obey the conventional transformation law under global shifts $\d\th^+=\e^+$, $\d x^{++}=i\th^+\e^+$ and $\d x^{--}=0$ in $n=(1,0)$ flat superspace. Then the superfield generalization of \p{b8} is \begin{equation}\label{b10} S=\int d^2xd\th^+{1\over 2}\left(D_+\Phi\partial_{--}\Phi- {{D_+\Lambda}\def\s{\sigma}\def\S{\Sigma}\over{\partial_{--}\Lambda}\def\s{\sigma}\def\S{\Sigma}}(\partial_{--}\Phi)^2\right) \end{equation} and that of \p{b9} is \begin{equation}\label{b11} \d\Lambda}\def\s{\sigma}\def\S{\Sigma=C(x^-,x^+,\th^+),\qquad \d\Phi= {{C(x^-,x^+,\th^+)}\over{\partial_{--}\Lambda}\def\s{\sigma}\def\S{\Sigma}}\partial_{--}\Phi, \end{equation} where $D_+={\partial\over{\partial\th^+}}+i\th^+\partial_{++}$, $D_+^2=i\partial_{++}$ is the supercovariant derivative. Using the transformations \p{b11} one can gauge fix all components of $\Lambda}\def\s{\sigma}\def\S{\Sigma(x,\th)$, except $\Lambda}\def\s{\sigma}\def\S{\Sigma|_{\th=0}=\hat\varphi(x)$, to zero and identify the latter with the time coordinate $x^0={1\over 2}(x^{++}+x^{--})$. Then, upon integrating over $\th^+$ one gets a component action (considered in \cite{ali} as part of a duality invariant string action with non--manifest supersymmetry): \begin{equation}\label{b12} S=\int d^2x\left({1\over 2}(\partial_{++}\phi\partial_{--}\phi- (\partial_{--}\phi)^2) - i\psi_+\partial_{--}\psi_+\right), \end{equation} which is invariant under the modified Lorentz transformations for the bosonic field $\phi(x)$ \p{b31} and modified supersymmetry transformations: \begin{equation}\label{b13} \d\phi=i\e^+\psi_+;\qquad \d\psi=i\e^+\partial_{++}\phi- i\e^+\partial_{--}\phi \end{equation} for the fermionic field $\psi_+$ analogous to \p{susy}. {}From \p{b12} one gets that on the mass shell $\phi(x)$ and $\psi_+(x)$ are chiral: $$ \partial_{--}\phi=0,~~~~~ \partial_{--}\psi_+=0. $$ \section{Discussion} The models considered above represent examples of duality symmetric models with manifest space--time symmetries. We have seen that in D=4 duality between two abelian gauge fields arose as a result of their coupling to the auxiliary vector field which can be treated as the gauge field of local Peccei--Quinn symmetry. The structure of the action admits space--time invariant $SL(2,{\bf R})$ axion--dilaton coupling, coupling to gravity and supersymmetrization. The example of chiral (self--dual) fields in two space--time dimensions demonstrates the possibility of constructing duality symmetric models in the form which respects both the conventional Lorentz invariance and conventional global supersymmetry. The generalization of the results obtained to duality symmetric actions for abelian gauge fields in other dimensions \cite{j}--\cite{ss2} is rather straightforward. As far as supersymmetry is concerned, it would be of interest to construct a superfield supergravity generalization of the duality symmetric models. The field content of the bosonic sector considered above points to the possible existence of such supergravity though its consistent formulation may turn out to be not an easy problem. Other challenging problems are the extension of the class of duality symmetric actions with that describing non--abelian gauge fields, and involving into the consideration charged matter. The discussion of problems of coupling electrically and magnetically charged matter fields to duality symmetric electro--magnetic fields the reader may find in \cite{yu} and references therein. \bigskip {\bf Acknowledgements}. The authors would like to thank N. Berkovits, P. Howe, C. Imbimbo, B. Nilsson, P. van Nieuwenhuizen, C. Preitschopf, E. Sezgin and A. Tseytlin for interest to this work and discussion.

\section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} In moving object tracking, it is not uncommon to work with sensors that can provide only direction to the object in question. The measurement and estimation state space have a specific geometry of their own, which is different from the geometry of the true trajectory space. The problem is challenging, because, although the motion of the object resides either in 3D or 2D Euclidean space, corresponding measurements reside either on the sphere or the circle, respectively. Namely, if we are measuring and estimating only the direction to the object in 2D, i.e., the azimuth, the state and measurements will bear the non-Euclidean properties of angles. However, if we are to extend the state space so that it includes both the angular velocity and acceleration (which are Euclidean variables), so that we can apply a higher-order dynamic motion model, we are faced with constructing a `hybrid' state space consisting of both the non-Euclidean and Euclidean variables. There exist Bayesian methods based on the principle of assumed density filtering with directional distributions on the circle, namely the von Mises distribution, the wrapped Gaussian distribution and the Bingham distribution (which actually models variables with $180^{\circ}$ symmetry), that capture intrinsically the non-Euclidean nature of angular random variables \cite{Azmani2009a,Markovic2010a,Markovic2012a,Kurz2013a,Kurz2013c,Stienne2014}. The benefit of these approaches is that they take globally into account the geometry of the state space. For example, in the case of the von Mises distribution it has been shown that the filter outperforms the naive Kalman filter, which treats angles like regular Euclidean variables, and the modified Kalman filter, which takes into account the nature of angles by wrapping them on the circle \cite{Kurz2013a,Markovic2015}. However, extending the state space with additional variables of different geometry, e.g., to analytically model the azimuth with the von Mises distribution and the range or the angular velocity with the Gaussian distribution and capture correctly the cross-correlations, remains a challenge. The $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ group is a set of orthogonal matrices with determinant one, whose elements geometrically represent rotations. This makes it an interesting candidate for estimation with angular variables. Furthermore, a filter could be derived not just for $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$, but also for combinations of $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ with $\R$. This would enable us to create the aforementioned `hybrid' state vector that would join both non-Euclidean and Euclidean variables within the same filter and enable a seamless utilization of higher-order system models with constant angular velocity or acceleration. An extended Kalman filter on matrix Lie groups was recently proposed in \cite{Bourmaud2014}. It provides us with a mathematical framework for solving the `hybrid' state space problem. Indeed, the filter can be applied directly for any state that is a combination of Lie groups, since a Cartesian product of Lie groups is a Lie group \cite{Bourmaud2014}. However, it should be noted that the LG-EKF is a local approach, in the sense that it does not take globally the geometry of the state space into account, but locally captures the geometry of state space via exponential mapping. Another approach would be to model the whole state space as a Euclidean vector within the `classical' Kalman filter framework, and wrap the operations involving angular variables. Indeed, this was performed in \cite{Kurz2013a} to modify the unscented Kalman filter for angular state estimation, in \cite{Crouse2015} to take idiosyncrasies of directional statistics when using polar or spherical coordinates in the cubature Kalman filter, and in \cite{Markovic2015} to modify the Gaussian mixture probabilistic hypothesis density filter for multitarget tracking on a circle. In this paper we propose to analyze the LG-EKF for directional tracking of moving objects in 2D. First, we look into deriving the LG-EKF on the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$, which also serves as a gentle introduction to the subject matter since the LG-EKF introduces non-trivial notation. Second, we model the directional moving object tracking in 2D as an estimation problem on the Lie group composed of the direct product $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$, i.e., a group that represents the moving object azimuth, angular velocity and angular acceleration. For the motion model, we use the constant angular acceleration model. In the end, we show that the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ LG-EKF filter derivation based on the mathematically grounded framework of filtering on Lie groups yields the same result as heuristically wrapping the angular variables within the extended Kalman filter (EKF) framework. Since for the case of $\R^n$ the LG-EKF evaluates to EKF \cite{Bourmaud2014}, this results also extends to $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$ LG-EKF and an $\R^3$ EKF when wrapping the angular component. Please note that this result \emph{applies only} to the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ filter and is not intended to be extended to other Lie groups or combinations thereof. Indeed, given that $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ is abelian, i.e., commutative, the result does not seem unexpected, but we assert that it gives interesting theoretical perspective on estimation and tracking with the heuristically modified EKF. Before we proceed with the filter derivation, we introduce some necessary formal definitions and operators for working with matrix Lie groups. \section{Mathematical background} \subsection{Wrapping the Kalman filter} In this section we shall assume that wrapping operation amounts to enforcing the angular variable to be in the $[-\pi, \pi]$ interval, and we designate this operation as follows \begin{equation}\label{eq:wrapToPi} \wPi(x) = \mmod(x + \pi, 2\pi) - \pi. \end{equation} Note that when computing the difference between two angular variables, the wrapping effect of the circle should be taken into account, e.g., the difference between $178^{\circ}$ and $-178^{\circ}$ should evaluate to $4^{\circ}$. This is also achieved by \eqref{eq:wrapToPi} when the difference is given as the argument, i.e., difference between two angles $x$ and $y$ is computed as $\wPi(x-y)$. Let us assume the following system model \begin{equation}\label{eq:kf_state_prediction} x_{k+1|k} = f_k(x_k, u_k) + n_k, \quad n_k \sim \mathcal{N} (0, Q) \end{equation} where $x_k$ is the system state, $u_k$ is the control input, $n_k$ is process noise, and $f_k(\,\cdot\,)$ is the non-linear system state equation. In the EKF the idiosyncrasies of angular data appear most prominently in the correction step when calculating the innovation, which should be computed as \begin{equation}\label{eq:kf_state_correction} x_{k+1} = x_{k+1|k} + K_k \wPi(z_k - h_k(x_{k+1|k})), \end{equation} where $K_k$ is the Kalman gain, $z_k$ is the measurement, and $h_k(\,\cdot\,)$ is the non-linear measurement equation. To demonstrate this, let us take a simple example of having an identity measurement equation, $x_{k+1|k} = 358^{\circ}$, $z_k = 2^{\circ}$ and $K_k = 0.5$. If we would not wrap the innovation, the updated state would yield a clearly incorrect result of $x_{k+1} = 180^{\circ}$ inlieu of $x_{k+1} = 360^{\circ}$. For practical purposes, after correction and prediction the system state can be checked to the required interval by computing $x_{k+1} \leftarrow \wPi(x_{k+1})$. In the sequel when we refer to the modified Kalman filter, it entails treating angular variables with the previously introduced operation. Furthermore, we assume that the reader is familiar with EKF equations, which we will not present or derive explicitly in order to keep the brevity of the paper. \subsection{Lie Groups}\label{sec:filtering_matrix_lie_groups} A Lie group $\text{G}\xspace$ is a group which is also a smooth manifold and the group composition and inverse are smooth functions on the manifold $\text{G}\xspace$. A manifold is an object that looks locally like a piece of $\R^n$ and $\text{G}\xspace$ is `smooth' in the sense that is has a tangent space, of the appropriate dimension, at each point. Take for example the circle, a curve in $\R^2$ which looks locally (but not globally) like $\R^1$. For a matrix Lie group the composition and inverse are simply matrix multiplication and inversion, with the identity element $\mathbf{I}\xspace^{n \times n}$ \cite{Chirikjian2012b}. A Lie Algebra $\mathfrak{g}\xspace$ is an open neighborhood of $\boldsymbol{0}^{n \times n}$ in the tangent space of $\text{G}\xspace$ at the identity $\mathbf{I}\xspace^{n \times n}$. The matrix exponential $\exp_{\text{G}\xspace}$ and matrix logarithm $\log_{\text{G}\xspace}$ establish a local diffeomorphism between Lie groups and Lie algebras \cite{Bourmaud2014} \begin{align} \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} : \mathfrak{g}\xspace \rightarrow \text{G}\xspace, \quad \log_{\text{G}\xspace} : \text{G}\xspace \rightarrow \mathfrak{g}\xspace. \end{align} The Lie Algebra $\mathfrak{g}\xspace$ associated to a $p$-dimensional matrix Lie group $\text{G}\xspace \subset \R^{n \times n}$ is a $p$-dimensional vector space% \cite{Chirikjian2012b}. A linear isomorphism between $\mathfrak{g}\xspace$ and $\R^p$ is given by \begin{align} [\cdot]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace} : \mathfrak{g}\xspace \rightarrow \R^p, \quad [\cdot]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} : \R^p \rightarrow \mathfrak{g}\xspace. \end{align} Lie Groups are not necessarily commutative. The following two operators capture this property \begin{itemize} \item the adjoint representation of $\text{G}\xspace$ on $\R^p$ \begin{align} \Ad_{\text{G}\xspace} : \Ad_{\text{G}\xspace}(X) x = \left[ X [x]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} X^{-1} \right]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace} \end{align} \item the adjoint representation of $\R^p$ on $\R^p$ \begin{align} \ad_{\text{G}\xspace} : \ad_{\text{G}\xspace}(x) y = \left[ [x]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} [y]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} - [y]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} [x]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace}\right]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace} \end{align} \end{itemize} where $x,y\in \R^p$. In the sequel, these operators, the exponential and logarithmic mapping are given concrete form for the pertinent Lie groups. \subsection{The $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ group} In this example our system state (azimuth of the tracked object) is modeled as the group $G=\text{SO}\xspace(2)$, i.e., as the rotation matrix $X_k=R_{\theta_k}$ \begin{equation} R_{\theta_k} = \begin{bmatrix} \cos\theta_k & -\sin\theta_k\\ \sin\theta_k & \cos\theta_k \end{bmatrix}. \end{equation} The composition and inverse in $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ are simply evaluated as $X_1X_2 = R_1R_2, X^{-1} = R^{\text{T}}$. For this case the associated Lie algebra which bridges $X_k\in\text{G}\xspace$ and $x_k = \theta_k\in\R^1$ is $\mathfrak{g}\xspace=\mathfrak{so}\xspace(2)$, and the following holds \begin{equation}\label{eq:so2_hat_operator} [\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} = \begin{bmatrix} 0 & -\theta_k\\ \theta_k & 0 \end{bmatrix}. \end{equation} The link between $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ and $\mathfrak{so}\xspace(2)$ is given by the exponential and logarithmic mapping \begin{align} &\exp_{\text{G}\xspace}([\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace}) = R_{\theta_k} \,:\, \mathfrak{so}\xspace(2)\rightarrow\text{SO}\xspace(2),\\ &\log_{\text{G}\xspace}(R_{\theta_k}) = [\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace}\, : \,\text{SO}\xspace(2)\rightarrow\mathfrak{so}\xspace(2). \end{align} Due to the commutativity of $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$, the adjoint operators are \begin{equation}\label{eq:adjoint_operators} \ad_{\text{G}\xspace}(\theta_k) = 0, \quad \Ad_{\text{G}\xspace}\left( \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right) \right) = 1. \end{equation} These properties greatly simplify the LG-EKG formulae for the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ group which will become evident in the sequel. \subsection{The $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times \R^2$ group} \noindent In this section we propose to model the system state as the Cartesian product of groups $\text{G}\xspace=\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$. This is a slight abuse of notation intended for clarity, since when talking about $\R$ within the group or algebra, we are actually referring to the group of algebra representation of $\R$, for which the explicit representation is given further in the paper. The moving object state $X_k$ will represent the azimuth of the target as a rotation matrix $R_{\theta_k}\in\text{SO}\xspace(2)$, angular velocity as a real number $\omega_k\in\R$, and angular acceleration also as a real number $\alpha_k\in\R$. The system state $X_k$ can be symbolically represented as \begin{align} X_k = \begin{bmatrix} R_k & & \\ & \begin{bmatrix} 1 & \omega_k\\ 0 & 1 \end{bmatrix} & \\ & & \begin{bmatrix} 1 & \alpha_k\\ 0 & 1 \end{bmatrix} \end{bmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} R_k\\ \omega_k\\ \alpha_k \end{pmatrix}_{\text{G}\xspace} \,. \end{align} Note that composition and inverse on such a group is evaluated as follows \begin{equation} X_1X_2 = \begin{pmatrix} R_1R_2\\ \omega_1 + \omega_2\\ \alpha_1 + \alpha_2 \end{pmatrix}_{\text{G}\xspace}, \quad X^{-1} = \begin{pmatrix} R^{\text{T}}\\ -\omega\\ -\alpha \end{pmatrix}_{\text{G}\xspace}. \end{equation} The associated Lie algebra is $\mathfrak{g}\xspace=\mathfrak{so}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$ which bridges the state on the Lie group $X_k \in \text{G}\xspace$ with the vector $x_k = [\theta_k \ \omega_k \ \alpha_k]^{\text{T}} \in \R^3$, and the following holds \begin{align} [x_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} = \begin{bmatrix} [\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)} & & \\ & [\omega_k]^{\wedge}_{\R} & \\ & & [\alpha_k]^{\wedge}_{\R} \end{bmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} [\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)}\\ \omega_k\\ \alpha_k \end{pmatrix}_{\mathfrak{g}\xspace} \,, \end{align} where $[\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)}$ is given by \eqref{eq:so2_hat_operator}, while \begin{equation} \begin{split} [\omega_k]^{\wedge}_{\R} &= \begin{bmatrix} 0 & \omega_k\\ 0 & 0 \end{bmatrix} \quad \text{and} \quad [\alpha_k]^{\wedge}_{\R} = \begin{bmatrix} 0 & \alpha_k\\ 0 & 0 \end{bmatrix}. \end{split} \end{equation} The link between the group $\text{G}\xspace$ and the associated algebra $\mathfrak{g}\xspace$ is defined by the exponential mapping \begin{align} \exp_{\text{G}\xspace}\left( [x_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right) &= \begin{pmatrix} \exp_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)}\left( [\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)} \right)\\ \omega_k\\ \alpha_k \end{pmatrix}_{\text{G}\xspace} = \begin{pmatrix} R_k\\ \omega_k\\ \alpha_k \end{pmatrix}_{\text{G}\xspace}, \end{align} and logarithmic mapping \begin{align}\label{eq:log_mapping} \log_{\text{G}\xspace}\left( X_k \right) = \begin{pmatrix} \log_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)}\left(R_k\right)\\ \omega_k\\ \alpha_k \end{pmatrix}_{\mathfrak{g}\xspace} = \begin{pmatrix} [\theta_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)}\\ \omega_k\\ \alpha_k \end{pmatrix}_{\mathfrak{g}\xspace}. \end{align} Furthermore, since $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ and $\R$ are abelian and the Cartesian product of abelian groups is abelian, the adjoint operators are again trivial \begin{equation}\label{eq:adjoint_operators_so2rr} \ad_{\text{G}\xspace}(x_k) = \boldsymbol{0}^{3\times 3}, \quad \Ad_{\text{G}\xspace}\left( \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [x_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right) \right) = \mathbf{I}\xspace^{3\times 3}. \end{equation} \section{The EKF on Matrix Lie Groups} As in the case of classical Kalman filtering, we need to begin by defining a motion model by which we will calculate the prediction. For general filtering on matrix Lie groups, the system model is defined by the following equation \cite{Bourmaud2014} \begin{equation}\label{eq:lgekf_system_model} \begin{split} X_{k+1} = f(X_{k},u_k, n_{k}) = X_{k} \, \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [\hat{\Omega}_k + n_{k}]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right) \,, \end{split} \end{equation} where $X_k \in \text{G}\xspace$ is the system state at time $k$, $\text{G}\xspace$ is a $p$-dimensional Lie Group, $n_k \sim \mathcal{N}_{\R^p}(\boldsymbol{0}^{p \times 1},Q_k)$ is white Gaussian noise and $\hat{\Omega}_k=\Omega(X_{k},u_k):\text{G}\xspace\times\R^w \rightarrow \R^p$ is the system state equation which describes how the model acts on the state and control input in order to calculate the displacement. Note that the function of $\hat{\Omega}_k$ is to take the system state which resides on \text{G}\xspace and the control input which resides on $\R^w$, calculate the displacement by applying the system model, and then transfer the displacement to the vector space $\R^p$ where additive noise is added. This displacement is then transferred to the associated Lie algebra by the $[\,.\,]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace}$ operator and then exponentially mapped back to the Lie group to be added by way of composition to the system state $X_k$. Given that, a question arises how to implement a specific system model, since in LG-EKF it operates through a displacement? That is, how to construct $\hat{\Omega}_k$ from $f_k(x_k, u_k)$? The first step would be to write the system equation as $f_k(x_k, u_k) = x_k + \hat{f}_k(x_k, u_k)$ which can then be practically `translated' to appropriate $\hat{\Omega}_k$. Note that generality is not lost here since $-x_k$ can be included within $\hat{f}_k(x_k, u_k)$, The prediction step of the LG-EKF is governed by the following formulae \cite{Bourmaud2014} \begin{align} \mu_{k+1|k} & = \mu_{k} \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [\hat{\Omega}_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right)\label{eq:lgekf_mu_prediction}\\ P_{k+1|k} & = \mathcal{F}\xspace_{k} P_k \mathcal{F}\xspace_{k}^T + \Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}(\hat{\Omega}_{k}) Q_k \Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}(\hat{\Omega}_{k})^T \,,\label{eq:lgekf_cov_prediction} \end{align} where $\mu_{k}\in\text{G}\xspace$ is the estimated mean value of the system state $X_k$, $P_k\in\R^{p\times p}$ is the estimated covariance matrix, while other terms are non-trivially calculated matrices \begin{align} \mathcal{F}\xspace_k & = \text{Ad}_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left([-\hat{\Omega}_k]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right) \right) + \Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}(\hat{\Omega}_{k}) \mathscr{C}_{k}\label{eq:lgekf_Fk_matrix},\\ \Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}({\nu}) &= \sum_{m=0}^{\infty} \frac{(-1)^m}{(m+1)!}\ad_{\text{G}\xspace}( {\nu} )^m, \quad {\nu}\in\R^{p}\label{eq:lgekf_PhiG_matrix},\\ \mathscr{C}_{k} & = \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} \Omega \left( \mu_{k} \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [\epsilon]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right), u_{k-1} \right)_{|\epsilon=0}\,.\label{eq:lgekf_Ck_matrix} \end{align} The parameter $\epsilon\in\R^p$ can be seen as a \emph{Lie algebraic error} which is approximated as being distributed according to a classical Euclidean Gaussian distribution $\epsilon \sim \mathcal{N}_{\R^p}(\boldsymbol{0}^{p\times 1}, P_k)$. It is interesting to note that the mean value $\mu_k$ resides on the Lie group $\text{G}\xspace$, while the covariance matrix $P_k$ describes uncertainty in $\R^p$. Although at first this appears peculiar, it is a consequence of modeling the uncertainty of states on Lie groups by the assumption of the concentrated Gaussian distribution $X_k \sim \mathcal{G}(\mu_k, P_k)$. In essence, the state resides on the group, but its uncertainty resides on the tangential vector space. For a more formal introduction of this concept, please confer \cite{Bourmaud2014}. The discrete measurement model on the matrix Lie Group is given as follows \begin{align} z_{k+1} = h(X_{k+1}) \, \exp_{\text{G}\xspace'} \left( [m_{k+1}]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace'} \right) \,, \end{align} where $z_{k+1} \in \text{G}\xspace'$, $h:\text{G}\xspace \rightarrow \text{G}\xspace'$, and $m_{k+1}\sim \mathcal{N}_{\R^q}(\boldsymbol{0}^{q \times 1},R_k)$ is white Gaussian noise. Note that here a different group $\text{G}\xspace'$ is used since the system state and measurements might belong to different groups. Having the measurement model defined, we can proceed now to the update step which will first constitute the calculation of the Kalman gain \begin{align} K_{k+1} = P_{k+1|k} \H_{k+1}^T \left( \H_{k+1} P_{k+1|k} \H_{k+1}^T + R_{k+1} \right)^{-1} \,, \end{align} where the measurement matrix $\H_{k+1}$ is calculated via \begin{equation}\label{eq:calH} \begin{split} \H_{k+1} = \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} &\left[ \log_{\text{G}\xspace'} \left( h(\mu_{k+1|k})^{-1}\right.\right.\\ &\left.\left. h \left( \mu_{k+1|k} \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [\epsilon]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right) \right) \right) \right]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace \ | \epsilon=0} \,. \end{split} \end{equation} Furthermore, the innovation vector multiplied by Kalman gain is computed as \begin{align} \nu_{k+1} = K_{k+1} \left[ \log_{\text{G}\xspace'} \left( h(\mu_{k+1|k})^{-1}z_{k+1} \right) \right]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace'}\,. \end{align} % Finally, the update of the system state and covariance matrix can be evaluated as \cite{Bourmaud2014} \begin{align} \mu_{k+1} & = \mu_{k+1|k} \exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [\nu_{k+1}]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right) \label{eq:lgekf_mu_update}\\ P_{k+1} & = \Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}(\nu_{k+1}) \left( \mathbf{I}\xspace^{p \times p} - K_{k+1} \H_{k+1} \right) P_{k+1|k} \Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}(\nu_{k+1})^T \,.\label{eq:lgekf_cov_update} \end{align} We can notice similarities between the LG-EKF and EKF equations and, indeed, when $\text{G}\xspace$ and $\text{G}\xspace'$ are Euclidean spaces the LG-EKF reduces to EKF \cite{Bourmaud2014}. Furthermore, due to the results \eqref{eq:adjoint_operators} and \eqref{eq:adjoint_operators_so2rr}, matrices $\mathcal{F}\xspace_k$ and $\Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}(\nu)$ for both $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ and $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$ evaluate to \begin{equation}\label{eq:lgekd_PhiG_Fk_SO2} \Phi_{\text{G}\xspace}(\nu) = \mathbf{I}\xspace, \quad \mathcal{F}\xspace_k = \mathbf{I}\xspace + \mathscr{C}_k. \end{equation} In the sequel we derive the LG-EKF for the groups which we propose to utilize for tracking of moving objects with angular measurements and show that in this special case the LG-EKF reduces to the heuristically modified EKF. \subsection{LG-EKF on $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$} In this section we derive the LG-EKF filter for state estimation on $\text{G}\xspace=\text{SO}\xspace(2)$. For this group, mathematically dense LG-EKF equations are simplified and serve well to intuitively grasp the mechanics of the filter. \subsubsection{Prediction} Let us take two examples of system models. In the first we assume a stationary process, i.e., in the prediction the mean value will remain unchanged except for the uncertainty that is added through the process noise (this is similar to the von Mises filter \cite{Azmani2009a}) \begin{equation}\label{eq:ekf_brown_system_model} x_{k+1|k} = x_k + n_k, \quad n_k \sim \mathcal{N}_{\R^1} (0, \sigma_{Q}^2). \end{equation} This yields the LG-EKF system model $\Omega(X_k) = 0$ with the same process noise $n_k$, which when inserted in \eqref{eq:lgekf_mu_prediction} will evaluate through the exponential as an identity matrix, thus leaving the mean value unperturbed. In order to compute the prediction of the covariance matrix via \eqref{eq:lgekf_cov_prediction}, given the result in \eqref{eq:lgekd_PhiG_Fk_SO2}, we only need to determine $\mathscr{C}_k$. In this case the Lie algebraic error is $\epsilon\in\R^1$ and due to the system model the matrix $\mathscr{C}_k$ evaluates to zero, thus leaving $\mathcal{F}\xspace_k = 1$, and the prediction equations ar \begin{align} \mu_{k+1|k} = \mu_{k}, \quad P_{k+1|k} = P_k + Q_k. \end{align} As we can see, these are the same formulae that an EKF prediction would yield with \eqref{eq:ekf_brown_system_model} as the system model. As the second example, we take the non-linear system \cite{Kurz2013a} where the robot rotary joint angle was estimated \begin{align}\label{eq:ekf_2_system_model} x_{k+1|k} = x_k + c_1 \sin(x_k) + c_2 + n_k, \end{align} where second and third term account for gravity and velocity, while the final term is again one-dimensional white Gaussian noise. This yields the following LG-EKF system model \begin{align}\label{eq:so2_2_system_model} \Omega(X_k) &= c_1 \sin([\log(X_k)]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace}) + c_2 \end{align} Note that $[\log(X_k)]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace}$ is necessary to bring the rotation matrix with parameter $\mu_k$ to a scalar angle in $\R^1$. The Lie algebraic error is again $\epsilon\in\R^1$ and given the system model \eqref{eq:so2_2_system_model} matrix $\mathscr{C}_k$ evaluates to \begin{align}\label{eq:lgekf_Ck_matrix_SO2} \mathscr{C}_k &= \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} \Omega \left( \begin{bmatrix} \cos\mu_k & -\sin\mu_k\\ \sin\mu_k & \cos\mu_k \end{bmatrix} \begin{bmatrix} \cos\epsilon & -\sin\epsilon\nonumber\\ \sin\epsilon & \cos\epsilon \end{bmatrix} \right)_{|\epsilon=0}\\ &= \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} \Omega \left( \begin{bmatrix} \cos(\mu_k + \epsilon) & -\sin(\mu_k + \epsilon)\\ \sin(\mu_k + \epsilon) & \cos(\mu_k + \epsilon) \end{bmatrix} \right)_{|\epsilon=0}\nonumber\\ &= \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} \left( c_1 \sin(\mu_k + \epsilon) + c_2 \right)_{|\epsilon=0}= c_1 \cos\mu_k \end{align} This means that $\mathcal{F}\xspace_k = 1 + c_1 \cos\mu_k $, and that the LG-EKF prediction equations are \begin{align} \mu_{k+1|k} &= \mu_{k}\exp_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( [c_1 \sin([\log(X_k)]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace}) + c_2]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right)\nonumber\\ P_{k+1|k} &= P_k (1 + c_1 \cos\mu_k )^2 + Q_k. \end{align} We can see that the covariance prediction formula is identical to the EKF covariance prediction. More generally, to demonstrate the equivalence of the modified EKF and $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ LG-EKF prediction steps we need to show that $\mathcal{F}\xspace_k = 1 + \mathscr{C}_k$ is equal to \begin{align} F_k = \dfrac{\partial f_k(x_k, u_k)}{\partial x_k}_{|x_k = \mu_k}, \end{align} where $F_k$ is the state transition matrix, i.e., the EKF system state Jacobian of \eqref{eq:kf_state_prediction}. By inspecting \eqref{eq:lgekf_Ck_matrix_SO2} we can notice that for $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ the argument within $\Omega$ will always be the sum of the mean value and the Lie algebraic error $\mu_k + \epsilon$. This gives \begin{align} \mathcal{F}\xspace_k &= 1 + \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} \Omega(\exp_{\text{G}\xspace}([\mu_k + \epsilon]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace}), u_k)_{|\epsilon=0}\nonumber\\ &= 1 + \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} \hat{f}_k(\mu_k + \epsilon, u_k)_{|\epsilon=0}\nonumber\\ &= 1 + \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} (f_k(\mu_k + \epsilon, u_k) - (\mu_k + \epsilon_{\theta}))_{|\epsilon=0}\nonumber\\ &= \dfrac{\partial f_k(\mu_k + \epsilon, u_k)}{\partial \epsilon}_{|\epsilon=0} = \dfrac{\partial f_k(\xi_k, u_k)}{\partial \xi_k}_{|\xi_k=\mu_k}, \end{align} where variable substitution was performed in the last step: $\xi_k \leftarrow \mu_k + \epsilon, \partial \xi_k \leftarrow \partial \epsilon$. In the end $\mathcal{F}\xspace_k$ evaluates to the EKF Jacobian $F_k$ when the underlying group is $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$. \subsubsection{Correction} Since we are measuring angles, we define the measurement Lie group as $\text{G}\xspace'=\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ and the measurement function $h : \text{SO}\xspace(2)\rightarrow\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ \begin{equation} h(X_{k+1}) = R_{k+1}, \quad m_{k+1}\sim\mathcal{N}_{\R^1}(0, \sigma_R^2), \end{equation} which is trivial since the measurement and state group are the same, while the measurement noise is a one-dimensional white Gaussian noise. As in the prediction step, the associated Lie algebra is $\mathfrak{g}\xspace'=\mathfrak{so}\xspace(2)$. To compute the correction step, we need to evaluate \eqref{eq:calH} for the LG-EKF on $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$. The composition of the predicted mean $\mu_{k+1|k}$ and the Lie algebraic error yields \begin{equation}\label{eq:lie_error_composition_prediction} \begin{split} h(\mu_{k+1|k}&\exp_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)}([\epsilon]^{\wedge}_{\text{SO}\xspace(2)})) =\\ &\begin{bmatrix} \cos(\mu_{k+1|k} + \epsilon) & -\sin(\mu_{k+1|k} + \epsilon)\\ \sin(\mu_{k+1|k} + \epsilon) & \cos(\mu_{k+1|k} + \epsilon) \end{bmatrix}. \end{split} \end{equation} Since $h(\mu_{k+1|k})^{-1}$ is the transpose of the corresponding rotation matrix, by inserting these results in \eqref{eq:calH} we can calculate the measurement matrix \begin{align} \H_{k+1} &= \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon}\left( \left[ \log_{\text{G}\xspace} \left( \begin{bmatrix} \cos\epsilon & -\sin\epsilon\\ \sin\epsilon & \cos\epsilon \end{bmatrix} \right) \right]^{\vee}_{\text{G}\xspace} \right)_{|\epsilon=0} = 1 \end{align} Given this results it is straightforward to see that Kalman gain and covariance update equation of $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ LG-EKF are equal to the EKF equations. The state correction equations yield the same result, except that the LG-EKF takes wrapping into account by composition of rotation matrices, while the modified EKF computes everything in $\R^1$ and would need to wrap the corrected state with $\wPi(\,\cdot\,)$. \subsection{LG-EKF on $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$} \noindent In this section we derive the LG-EKF filter for state estimation on $\text{G}\xspace=\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$. Given the demonstrated equality of the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ LG-EKF and the modified EKF and that LG-EKF reduces to EKF for Euclidean spaces, it is intuitive to expect that this result would extend to groups derived by composing $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ with Euclidean spaces. In the sequel we illustrate this property by deriving a constant angular acceleration model for tracking with angle-only measurements. \subsubsection{Prediction} \noindent Given the state representation, we can now define the system model. For this purpose, we use the constant angular acceleration model $\hat{\Omega}_k = \Omega(X_k):G\rightarrow\R^3$ \begin{equation}\label{eq:motion_model_so2rr} \Omega(X_k) = \begin{bmatrix} T\omega_{k} + \frac12 T^2 \alpha_k\\ T\alpha_k\\ 0 \end{bmatrix}, \quad n_k \sim \mathcal{N}_{\R^3}(0, Q). \end{equation} Note that the displacement due to motion is calculated first in $\R^3$ and then according to \eqref{eq:lgekf_mu_prediction} transferred to Lie algebra $\mathfrak{g}$, exponentially mapped to the group $\text{G}\xspace$ and then by way of composition added to the system state $X_k$. In this case, the Lie algebraic error is $\epsilon = [\epsilon_{\theta} \ \epsilon_{\omega} \ \epsilon_{\alpha}]^{\text{T}}\in\R^3$, hence the composition of the mean value $\mu_k$ and $\epsilon$ yields \begin{equation} \begin{split} \mu_k\exp_{\text{G}\xspace}([\epsilon]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace}) &= \begin{pmatrix} R_kR_{\epsilon}\\ \omega_k + \epsilon_{\omega}\\ \alpha_k + \epsilon_{\alpha} \end{pmatrix}_{\text{G}\xspace},\\ \end{split} \end{equation} with $R_kR_{\epsilon}$ has the same for as the matrix product in \eqref{eq:lie_error_composition_prediction}. By applying the motion model \eqref{eq:motion_model_so2rr} on this results we get \begin{equation}\label{eq:motion_model_so2rr_2} \Omega(\mu_k\exp_{\text{G}\xspace}([\epsilon]^{\wedge}_{\text{G}\xspace})) = \begin{bmatrix} T(\omega + \epsilon_{\omega}) + \frac12 T^2(\alpha + \epsilon_{\alpha})\\ T(\alpha + \epsilon_{\alpha})\\ 0 \end{bmatrix}. \end{equation} To compute the prediction step for the covariance matrix, we need to calculate matrix $\mathcal{F}\xspace_k$. Since adjoint operators are trivial, using \eqref{eq:motion_model_so2rr_2} we calculate \begin{align} F_k &= \mathbf{I}\xspace + \mathscr{C}_{k} = \begin{bmatrix} 1 & T & \frac12 T^2\\ 0 & 1 & T\\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{bmatrix}. \end{align} We can see that the matrix $\mathcal{F}\xspace_k$ evaluates to the well known transition matrix of the classical EKF constant acceleration motion model. \subsubsection{Correction} Since here we track moving objects by measuring angles, we define the measurement Lie group $\text{G}\xspace' = \text{SO}\xspace(2)$ and the measurement function $h:\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2 \rightarrow \text{SO}\xspace(2)$ \begin{equation}\label{eq:so2rr_measurement_model} h(X_{k+1}) = R_{k+1}, \quad m_{k+1} \sim \mathcal{N}_{\R^1}(0, \sigma_R^2) \end{equation} which in this case simply extracts the rotation matrix $R_{k+1}$ from $X_{k+1}$. Calculation of the matrix $\H_{k+1}$ is the same as in \eqref{eq:calH}, except that $\epsilon$ is now a vector \begin{equation} \begin{split} \H_{k+1} = \dfrac{\partial}{\partial \epsilon} \left( \epsilon_{\theta} \right)_{| \epsilon=0} = [1 \ 0 \ 0]. \end{split} \end{equation} Again, the same result as we would expect for the EKF measurement matrix. \section{Experiments} \begin{figure}[!t] \centering \hspace{-0.5cm} \subfloat[azimuth]{ \tikzsetnextfilename{so2rr_voice_angle} \input{figures/so2rr_voice_angle.tikz.tex}% \label{fig:so2rr_voice_angle}}\\ \hspace{-0.5cm} \subfloat[angular velocity]{ \tikzsetnextfilename{so2rr_voice_omega} \input{figures/so2rr_voice_omega.tikz.tex}% \label{fig:so2rr_voice_omega}} \caption{Performance of the LG-EKF on $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$ when tracking a moving speaker. The solid black line is the ground truth as given by the motion capture system, the green solid line is the estimated state of the speaker, while the gray circles represent measurements, i.e. outputs of the beamformer. State RMSE is given in the title of each of the subfigures. } \label{fig:so2rr_voice} \end{figure} \noindent As a practical example of an application of the studied filter we apply this on the problem of speaker tracking with a microphone array and in the present paper we test the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$ LG-EKF on real-world data. For the sound acquisition we used the ManyEars framework consisting of an 8-channel USB sound card \cite{Grondin2013}, while for obtaining measurements we used the beamforming algorithm for speaker localization \cite{Valin2007} implemented under the Robot Operating Systems \cite{Quigley2009} within the same framework. The maximum of the beamforming energy was picked as the speaker measurement. The experiments were conducted in a $120\,\text{m}^{2}$ room with parquet wooden flooring and one side covered with windows. The speaker was simulated by a loudspeaker playing an excerpt from Nature's podcast \emph{Audiophile} in English. The area in which the loudspeaker moved was covered by a motion capture system, which was used to generate ground truth data. In order to handle outliers, we used validation gating; namely, the innovation matrix $S_{k+1} = \H_{k+1}P_{k+1|k}\H^{\text{T}}_{k+1}+R_{k+1}$ was calculated and we applied the standard $\chi^2$--test \begin{equation} \nu_{k+1}S^{-1}_{k+1}\nu_{k+1}^{\text{T}} < \gamma, \end{equation} where the threshold $\gamma$ was determined from the inverse $\chi^2_{p}$ cumulative distribution at a significance level $a=0.95$ and $p$ degrees-of-freedom. Figure~\ref{fig:so2rr_voice} shows the experiment results and corroborates that the filter successfully manages to track the moving speaker in spite of the number of outliers. Note that the modified EKF would yield the same results, except that in the case of the LG-EKF the system state was defined on $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times \R^2$ and the idiosyncrasies of angular data were intrinsically taken care of. \balance \section{Conclusion} In this paper we have studied directional moving object tracking in 2D based on the extended Kalman filter on matrix Lie groups. First, we have proposed to analyze this estimation problem by modeling the state to reside on the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ group. Subsequently, we have shown that the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ filter derivation based on the mathematically grounded framework of filtering on Lie groups yields evaluates to heuristically wrapping the extended Kalman filter. We emphasize that this result \emph{applies only} to the $\text{SO}\xspace(2)$ filter and is not intended to be extended to other Lie groups or combinations thereof. Second, we have derived the constant angular velocity $\text{SO}\xspace(2)\times\R^2$ filter, where the system state consisted of azimuth, angular velocity and angular acceleration. For this filter we showcased a real-world experiment of a speaker tracking problem with a microphone array by assessing the accuracy using the ground truth obtained by a motion capture system. \section*{Acknowledgments} This work has been supported from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 688117 (SafeLog) and the Unity Through Knowledge Fund under the project Cooperative Cloud based Simultaneous Localization and Mapping in Dynamic Environments. \bibliographystyle{IEEEtran}

Schistosomiasis prevalence data used in this study are reported in Supporting Information. Introduction {#sec005} ============ Schistosomiasis is an important parasitic disease that affects more than 250 million people \[[@pntd.0006517.ref001]\]. Expressed in years lived with disability (YLDs), the impact of schistosomiasis is comparable to that of malaria (2.9 versus 3.2 million YLDs) \[[@pntd.0006517.ref002]\]. Schistosomiasis is a disease of poverty, with 97% of all infections and 85% of the global at-risk population concentrated in Africa \[[@pntd.0006517.ref003]\]. Ghana has an estimated country-wide prevalence of 23.3%, with focal, or localized, prevalence levels \>50% \[[@pntd.0006517.ref004]\]. Schistosomiasis is caused by infection with the trematode parasite of the genus *Schistosoma* \[[@pntd.0006517.ref005]\]. Of the three species that commonly infect humans (*S*. *haematobium*, *S*. *mansoni*, and *S*. *japonicum*), the former two are prevalent in Africa \[[@pntd.0006517.ref006]\]. *S*. *haematobium* is the predominant species in Ghana \[[@pntd.0006517.ref004]\] and is the focus of the present study. Schistosomiasis has a complex life cycle that involves the parasite, intermediate host snails, and definitive human host (and sometimes animal reservoir hosts). Transmission occurs in fresh surface water bodies that are contaminated with human waste, provide favorable ecologic conditions for intermediate host snails (*Bulinus* species for *S*. *haematobium*), and sustain human water contact \[[@pntd.0006517.ref006]\]. Human transmission occurs when parasite larvae (cercariae) penetrate intact skin during water-based activities and has historically been most common in rural areas with natural slow flowing streams, ponds, and lakes \[[@pntd.0006517.ref003],[@pntd.0006517.ref006]\]. To develop and implement effective control strategies against schistosomiasis, accurate data on the geographic and demographic distribution of infections are necessary. Surveillance in endemic low- and middle-income countries is inhibited by limited health infrastructure and cases evading clinical detection due to lower parasite burden and lessened symptoms that result from preventive chemotherapy with the anthelmintic drug praziquantel. Passive health facility-based surveillance and reporting systems are known to severely underestimate the number of infections \[[@pntd.0006517.ref007],[@pntd.0006517.ref008]\]. For example, a total of \~25,000 schistosomiasis cases were reported into the Ghanaian District Health Information Management System (DHIMS) in 2010 (data received from GHS, 2016). If only \~5 million children ≤15 years of age residing in rural areas (i.e., high-risk population) \[[@pntd.0006517.ref009]\] are considered at the estimated 23.3% infection rate \[[@pntd.0006517.ref004]\], \~1.15 million cases would be expected. The reported cases represent only 2.2% of this expected number. Some correction for underreporting can be accomplished by predictive modeling, aiming to complement data from surveillance systems and field-based prevalence surveys. Many schistosomiasis predictive modeling studies have been published and reviewed \[[@pntd.0006517.ref010],[@pntd.0006517.ref011]\]. Most studies utilized remote sensing (RS) and geographic information system (GIS) approaches at large spatial extents (i.e., national, regional or continental) \[[@pntd.0006517.ref012]--[@pntd.0006517.ref014]\], with fewer applications of these methods to sub-national mapping \[[@pntd.0006517.ref015]--[@pntd.0006517.ref017]\]. Because snail populations, cercarial densities, human water contact patterns, and subsequent schistosomiasis infections exhibit strong spatial heterogeneity \[[@pntd.0006517.ref010],[@pntd.0006517.ref018],[@pntd.0006517.ref019]\], further investigation of localized transmission drivers at smaller spatial extents is needed \[[@pntd.0006517.ref010],[@pntd.0006517.ref011]\]. Furthermore, most studies included relatively few RS environmental predictors, mainly normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), land surface temperature (LST), and elevation, whereas many other vegetation- and moisture-related indices and topographic variables are available and should be considered \[[@pntd.0006517.ref011],[@pntd.0006517.ref020],[@pntd.0006517.ref021]\]. Another important limitation is that most studies utilized point-prevalence data of human infections (outcome) typically measured at schools, whereas RS-based environmental data (predictors) pertain to water bodies that serve as snail habitats and potential transmission locations. Most models do not account for this spatial mismatch between exposure and outcome measures \[[@pntd.0006517.ref011]\]. A recent study used a more ecologically relevant approach, in which RS variables were extracted from geographically delineated water bodies within a buffer radius around the point-prevalence location \[[@pntd.0006517.ref022]\]. An even more promising approach would be to apply the models to the specific locations along water bodies where human water contacts occur. Further complicating the modeling approach at small spatial extents are socioeconomic and behavioral factors, including water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) conditions, known to affect individual schistosomiasis risk \[[@pntd.0006517.ref023]--[@pntd.0006517.ref025]\]. These factors may have an even greater bearing on the focal nature of disease distribution than the environment \[[@pntd.0006517.ref026],[@pntd.0006517.ref027]\], and should be considered as predictors. While the inclusion of socioeconomic status and metrics of clean water and sanitation access have been advocated \[[@pntd.0006517.ref010],[@pntd.0006517.ref011]\], to our knowledge, WASH variables have not yet been explicitly incorporated into spatial schistosomiasis predictive models. The goal of the present study was to build upon existing predictive modeling approaches using *S*. *haematobium* prevalence data from 73 rural communities in the Eastern region of Ghana. We utilized fine resolution RS data (Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2), expanded the number of predictors (15 environmental and four WASH-related variables), and explored alternatives for addressing the spatial mismatch between exposure and outcome measures. In this study, primary innovations include the use of a new RS data source (Sentinel-2), incorporation of field-mapped surface water contact sites into the RS-based environmental modeling approach, and exploration of WASH variables as additional schistosomiasis risk factors. Methods {#sec006} ======= Ethics statement {#sec007} ---------------- The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) at Tufts University in Boston, United States of America (protocol \#11688) and Noguchi Memorial Institute for Medical Research in Accra, Ghana (protocol \#1133). Letters of approval were obtained from national and regional offices of Ghana Health Service (GHS) and Ghana Education Service (GES). Written informed consent was obtained from the acting head teacher of each school that participated in the schistosomiasis prevalence survey. Verbal assent was sought from the participating children, an accepted ethical and practical approach used in similar low-risk studies \[[@pntd.0006517.ref028]\]. Study area {#sec008} ---------- The study was conducted in the tropical Eastern region ([Fig 1](#pntd.0006517.g001){ref-type="fig"}), characterized by major and minor peak rainfall periods in June and October, respectively, with dry season lasting from November to February. Four major perennial rivers (Pra, Birim, Ayensu, and Densu) drain the region, with an abundance of smaller streams and ponds. Most of these water bodies are used extensively for domestic and recreational purposes (e.g., fetching, washing, swimming, and fishing). The Pra and Birim rivers, and some of their tributaries, however, are heavily polluted by alluvial gold mining and are no longer used due to high turbidity and presence of toxic compounds \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029]\]. The region is relatively flat with some hilly areas and low mountains (Atiwa Mountain Range) reaching an elevation of approximately 750 m above sea level. The study area, spanning 10 administrative districts, was purposely selected outside of a 20-km buffer radius of Lake Volta \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029]\]. Communities situated on its shores are historically known to be endemic for schistosomiasis \[[@pntd.0006517.ref030]\]. However, little information is available about pockets of high transmission along minor rivers and streams that are not easily detected with RS technologies. {#pntd.0006517.g001} Community as a unit of analysis {#sec009} ------------------------------- Prior modeling studies mainly used point-prevalence as outcome data. Prevalence of *S*. *haematobium* eggs in urine samples (or hematuria as a proxy of infection) is typically measured at schools, while transmission may occur within some distance of this point-prevalence location. With extensive local knowledge from prior community-based studies \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029],[@pntd.0006517.ref031]--[@pntd.0006517.ref033]\], the present analysis was conducted at the "community" level. The spatial boundaries of communities were defined by Open Street Map (OSM) polygons ([Fig 2](#pntd.0006517.g002){ref-type="fig"}) abstracted using QGIS software (version 2.12.3), an approach validated in a case study \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029]\]. Subsequently, a buffer radius of 1 km was applied to each polygon. The buffer distance was chosen because nearly all known contact with water bodies occurred within 1 km of community boundaries. Throughout the manuscript, the term "community" refers to the OSM polygon + 1 km buffer area ([Fig 2](#pntd.0006517.g002){ref-type="fig"}) and is used as a unit of analysis, also referred to as grain or support \[[@pntd.0006517.ref021],[@pntd.0006517.ref034]\]. {#pntd.0006517.g002} Data sources {#sec010} ------------ Data for this study were obtained primarily from satellite RS sources and field studies, with some additional geographic features digitized from satellite imagery. Surface reflectance, thermal, and elevation data were obtained from RS sources. From these, vegetation and water indices, LST, and topographic variables were derived. WASH variables were obtained from field data available from past studies, namely global positioning system (GPS) coordinates of public water sources \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029]\] and data about groundwater quality \[[@pntd.0006517.ref032]\]. The outcome variable, *S*. *haematobium* prevalence (%) was measured in one school in each of the 73 study communities. Measures of improved and unimproved \[[@pntd.0006517.ref035]\] water access and groundwater quality (WASH variables) were combined with RS-based variables to predict schistosomiasis prevalence across the study area. Data processing and analysis steps are described below and outlined in [S1](#pntd.0006517.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"} and [S2](#pntd.0006517.s004){ref-type="supplementary-material"} Figs in Supporting Information. ### Remotely sensed data {#sec011} Surface reflectance data were obtained from two RS data sources: Landsat 8 Operational Land Imager (OLI) and Sentinel-2. Landsat 8 data were obtained from USGS Earth Explorer (<http://earthexplorer.usgs.gov/>) and included two cloud-free scenes that were mosaicked to cover the extent of the study area ([Table 1](#pntd.0006517.t001){ref-type="table"}). OLI data (bands 2--6 in [Table 1](#pntd.0006517.t001){ref-type="table"}) were downloaded as raw digital number (DN) values with a spatial resolution of 30 m and radiometrically and atmospherically corrected to obtain surface reflectance. This two-step procedure consisted of converting DN values to top-of-atmosphere (TOA) radiance, followed by an atmospheric correction using the Fast Line-of-sight Atmospheric Analysis of Hypercubes (FLAASH) module in ENVI 5.4 (Exelis Visual Information Solutions, Boulder, United States of America). Thermal data (bands 10 and 11 in [Table 1](#pntd.0006517.t001){ref-type="table"}) were downloaded from Landsat 8 Thermal InfraRed Sensor (TIRS) as level 1 (L1B) products with a spatial resolution of 100 m. 10.1371/journal.pntd.0006517.t001 ###### Summary of surface reflectance data used in the study. {#pntd.0006517.t001g} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Landsat 8 Sentinel-2 ---------------------------- -------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------- Scenes (acquisition dates) Path 193 Row 56 (December 22, 2015)\ T30NXM (December 24, 2015)\ Path 194 Row 56 (December 29, 2015) T30NXN (December 24, 2015)\ T30NYM (December 24, 2015)\ T30NYN (December 24, 2015) Bands (wavelengths) Blue--B2 (0.450--0.515 μm)\ Blue--B2 (0.490 μm)\ Green--B3 (0.525--0.600 μm)\ Green--B3 (0.560 μm)\ Red--B4 (0.630--0.680 μm)\ Red--B4 (0.665 μm)\ Near infrared--B5 (0.845--0.885 μm)\ Near infrared--B8 (0.842 μm)\ Short wavelength infrared--B6 (1.560--1.660 μm)\ Short wavelength infrared--B11 (1.610 μm)\ Long wavelength infrared--B10 (10.30--11.30 μm)\ Long wavelength infrared--B11 (11.50--12.50 μm) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sentinel-2 surface reflectance data (bands 2, 3, 4, 8, and 11 in [Table 1](#pntd.0006517.t001){ref-type="table"}) were obtained from Copernicus Data Hub (<https://scihub.copernicus.eu/>). Four cloud-free scenes were mosaicked to cover the extent of the study area ([Table 1](#pntd.0006517.t001){ref-type="table"}). TOA radiance (level 1C) products were downloaded with a spatial resolution of 10 or 20 m and converted to level 2A surface reflectance by applying the atmospheric correction using the Sen2Cor processor in open-source Sentinel Application Platform (SNAP) software (version 5.0). ASTER Global Digital Elevation Model (GDEM v2) data were obtained from USGS Global Data Explorer (gdex.cr.usgs.gov) with a spatial resolution of 30 m. A moving window (3x3) majority filter was applied to the elevation data to eliminate image artefacts \[[@pntd.0006517.ref036],[@pntd.0006517.ref037]\] using the Spatial Analyst extension in ArcGIS 10.2.2. Settlement data were obtained from the German Aerospace Center (<http://www.dlr.de>) as a new Global Urban Footprint (GUF) product. GUF is a binary raster data product of populated and unpopulated pixels produced from 2011--2012 TerraSAR-X and TanDEM-X radar images \[[@pntd.0006517.ref038]\]. GUF was chosen as a source of settlement data due to its 0.4 arcsec geometric resolution, or 12 m spatial resolution, which most closely matched the resolution of the other spatial data used in the study. ### Field data {#sec012} A cross-sectional *S*. *haematobium* prevalence survey was conducted in May and June 2016 in the largest primary school in each of the 73 study communities (population range 500--5,000). The most recent round of national school-based preventive chemotherapy had been conducted in January 2016 (six months prior to the survey); all study schools had participated, with an average treatment coverage of 78% (data provided by GHS, 2016). All children in grades 3 and 4 (age range 8--13 years) who expressed verbal assent were enrolled into the study. Upon detailed demonstrations of the specimen collection procedure, children were invited to provide a urine sample between 10:00 and 14:00 hours that was tested for microhematuria using a semi-quantitative reagent strip on-site. Samples with any blood presence, including "trace", were categorized as positive readings \[[@pntd.0006517.ref028]\]. Infected children were offered praziquantel according to their weight by a local nurse or community health worker in a private location. No identifying information about study subjects was recorded besides school/community name, sex, and grade. A total of 5,220 children (2,802 boys and 2,418 girls) were registered in grades 3 and 4 in the 73 study schools. Of these, 3,746 children (72%) were present on the day of screening. Attendance in some of the schools was as low as 46%. A total of 3,628 children (97%) were enrolled into the study, and 3,612 (\>99%) provided urine samples for analysis. Prevalence of microhematuria in the study population was 14%; school-level prevalence values ranged between 0 and 40% ([Fig 1](#pntd.0006517.g001){ref-type="fig"}; [S1 Table](#pntd.0006517.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, Supporting Information). Data processing {#sec013} --------------- Six environmental indices were calculated from Landsat 8 (OLI) and Sentinel-2 surface reflectance data ([Table 2](#pntd.0006517.t002){ref-type="table"}) in R software (version 3.3.1). In the enhanced vegetation index (EVI) equation, *L* value adjusts for canopy background and *C* values are coefficients for atmospheric resistance. These enhancements allow for index calculation as a ratio between the red and the near infrared (*nir*) band values, while reducing the background and atmospheric noise and saturation \[[@pntd.0006517.ref039]\]. The values of *C*~*1*~ = 6, *C*~*2*~ = 7.5, and *L* = 1 were obtained from the Landsat 8 product guide \[[@pntd.0006517.ref040]\]. In the soil adjusted vegetation index (SAVI) equation, *L* is the soil calibration factor that minimizes soil background conditions that affect partial canopy spectra. The *L* value of 0.5 minimizes soil brightness variation and eliminates the need for additional calibration for different soils \[[@pntd.0006517.ref041]\]. Landsat 8 (TIRS) thermal data were processed using ATCOR \[[@pntd.0006517.ref042]\] with a standard emissivity of 0.985 to detect water surface temperature, and converted from Kelvin (K) to degrees Celsius (°C) to represent LST. 10.1371/journal.pntd.0006517.t002 ###### Six environmental indices computed with Landsat 8 (OLI) and Sentinel-2 data. {#pntd.0006517.t002g} Index Equation Reference ---------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------- Normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) $\frac{\left( nir - red \right)}{\left( nir + red \right)}$ \[[@pntd.0006517.ref043]\] Enhanced vegetation index (EVI) $\frac{\left( nir - red \right)}{\left( nir + C_{1}*red - C_{2}*blue + L \right)}$ \[[@pntd.0006517.ref039]\] Soil adjusted vegetation index (SAVI) $\frac{\left( nir - red \right)}{\left( nir + red + L \right)}\left( {1 + L} \right)$ \[[@pntd.0006517.ref041]\] Modified soil adjusted vegetation index (MSAVI) $\frac{\left\lbrack 2*nir + 1 - \sqrt{\left( 2*nir + 1 \right)^{2} - 8\left( nir - red \right)\rbrack} \right.}{2}$ \[[@pntd.0006517.ref044]\] Normalized difference water index (NDWI) $\frac{\left( green - nir \right)}{\left( green + nir \right)}$ \[[@pntd.0006517.ref045]\] Modified normalized difference water index (MNDWI) $\frac{\left( green - swir \right)}{\left( green + swir \right)}$ \[[@pntd.0006517.ref046]\] Elevation data were used to derive stream order and slope. Topographic drainage lines were delineated from the digital elevation model (DEM) based on the potential flow direction from higher to lower elevation and accumulation of surface runoff according to topographic conditions using Arc Hydro Tools in ArcGIS (version 10.2.2). The resulting stream network was ordered according to Strahler \[[@pntd.0006517.ref047]\]. Slope of the terrain was derived from the DEM as a proxy indicator for potential flow velocity of surface runoff with inclination calculated in degrees. GPS coordinates of public water sources (standpipes (SPs), boreholes (BHs), protected and unprotected hand-dug wells (HDWs), and surface water access points (SWAPs)) were available from a prior study \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029]\]. SPs, BHs, and protected HDWs that were functional at the time of the study constituted functional improved water sources (FIWS) that are not capable of transmitting schistosomiasis. SWAPs constituted unimproved water sources that are capable of transmitting schistosomiasis. Two categorical raster layers were derived from the GPS data using a buffer analysis conducted in ArcGIS 10.2.2, which represented improved water access (within 100--500 m of FIWS) and surface water access (within 100--500 m of SWAP), to test the hypothesis that locations closer to FIWSs have a lower risk of schistosomiasis transmission and locations closer to SWAPs have higher risk of schistosomiasis transmission \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029]\]. Two additional raster layers of interpolated groundwater iron and total dissolved solids (TDS) concentrations (mg/l) were also obtained from a prior study \[[@pntd.0006517.ref032]\]. Groundwater quality variables were included because prior studies \[[@pntd.0006517.ref029],[@pntd.0006517.ref032],[@pntd.0006517.ref033]\] suggested that elevated iron and TDS concentrations in BHs may increase reliance on contaminated surface water bodies, thereby potentially serving as indirect risk factors for schistosomiasis transmission. Lastly, *S*. *haematobium* prevalence (% positive samples) was calculated from survey data. Prevalence was determined separately for boys and girls in each grade and then adjusted to a gender- and grade- balanced population using direct standardization \[[@pntd.0006517.ref048]\]. Standardized school-level point-prevalence values ([S1 Table](#pntd.0006517.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, Supporting Information) were taken to represent community-level prevalence based on the following validated \[[@pntd.0006517.ref049]\] assumptions: (i) microhematuria prevalence measured by reagent strip is a reasonable proxy of *S*. *haematobium* prevalence in a presumably lightly infected population due to recent preventive chemotherapy; (ii) 3^rd^ and 4^th^ grade school children are a representative study population; and (iii) where a child lives and attends school are not spatially dependent, inferring that prevalence value at one school is representative of community-level prevalence. Variable extraction and aggregation {#sec014} ----------------------------------- A total of 15 environmental and four WASH predictor variables ([Table 3](#pntd.0006517.t003){ref-type="table"}; [S3](#pntd.0006517.s005){ref-type="supplementary-material"}--[S21](#pntd.0006517.s023){ref-type="supplementary-material"} Figs, Supporting Information) were derived and resampled to a matching spatial resolution of 10 m. While *S*. *haematobium* infection prevalence was represented by point data, predictors were represented by continuous raster data ([Fig 3](#pntd.0006517.g003){ref-type="fig"}). Therefore, extraction and aggregation of the raster data within the "community" polygons were necessary. 10.1371/journal.pntd.0006517.t003 ###### Environmental (top) and WASH (bottom) predictor variables. {#pntd.0006517.t003g} Data source Variable Scale \[range\] Resolution \[m\] Mask Aggregation -------------- ----------------- ------------------------- ------------------ --------------- ------------- OLI/Sentinel Blue band Continuous \[0--1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel Green band Continuous \[0--1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel Red band Continuous \[0--1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel nir band Continuous \[0--1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel swir band Continuous \[0--1\] 30 / 20 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel NDVI Continuous \[-1-1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel EVI Continuous \[-1-1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel SAVI Continuous \[-1-1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel MSAVI Continuous \[-1-1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel NDWI Continuous \[-1-1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median OLI/Sentinel MNDWI Continuous \[-1-1\] 30 / 10 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median TIRS LST \[°C\] Continuous \[13--47\] 100 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median DEM Elevation \[m\] Continuous \[1--870\] 30 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median DEM Slope \[°\] Continuous \[0--85\] 30 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 Median DEM Stream order Categorical \[0--5\] 30 1 Max Field data FIWS access Categorical \[0--5\] \-- 3 Mode Field data SWAP access Categorical \[0--5\] \-- 3 Mode Field data Iron \[mg/l\] Continuous \[0.1--0.7\] \-- 1 Median Field data TDS \[mg/l\] Continuous \[83--616\] \-- 1 Median {#pntd.0006517.g003} A total of six methods of variable extraction (masks) were used ([Fig 3](#pntd.0006517.g003){ref-type="fig"}): none {1}--all pixels within the "community" polygon were extracted; unpopulated {2}--data were extracted only for unpopulated pixels as defined by the GUF data; populated {3}--data were extracted only for populated pixels as defined by the GUF data; all water bodies {4}--mask was derived by combining the topographic drainage lines from the DEM, supplemented with ponds, lakes, and gold mining pits that were digitized from satellite imagery; unmined water bodies {5}--mask was derived by removing water bodies that are known to be affected by mining from "all water bodies"; SWAPs {6}--defined as the single pixel GPS points of known surface water contact sites. To understand the spatial linkage between school-based prevalence and the environmental conditions, almost all environmental variables were extracted using masks {1, 2, 4, 5, and 6} ([Table 3](#pntd.0006517.t003){ref-type="table"}), listed in the order of increasing ecologic relevance. For example, the most ecologically relevant method is to match school-based schistosomiasis prevalence with environmental variables extracted from points within the "community" where known contact with water bodies occurs (m6). Method 3 (populated areas) was not relevant for environmental variable extraction because these locations are not representative of schistosomiasis transmission. Conversely, measures of safe (FIWS) and unsafe (SWAP) water access apply only to populated areas; hence only method 3 was used to extract these two WASH variables. Unmasked data (m1) were used to extract stream order, iron, and TDS concentrations ([Table 3](#pntd.0006517.t003){ref-type="table"}). For aggregation of environmental variables, primarily the median pixel values were used, except for stream order, where maximum value was used. For aggregation of WASH variables, either median (iron and TDS) or mode (FIWS and SWAP access) were used ([Table 3](#pntd.0006517.t003){ref-type="table"}). Data analysis {#sec015} ------------- Exploratory analyses included variable summaries and correlations, followed by random forest models. The random forest approach was chosen because it can deal with continuous outcome data, multicollinear predictor variables, and low numbers of training samples, it is the recommended machine learning method for generating predictions \[[@pntd.0006517.ref050]\], and it has been successfully applied in similar studies \[[@pntd.0006517.ref022]\]. Five non-parametric random forest models were conducted with 15 environmental predictor variables ([Table 3](#pntd.0006517.t003){ref-type="table"}) to determine which of the five masks presented the best method of variable extraction. Two versions of the analyses were conducted in parallel (with Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 surface reflectance values and environmental indices) to test consistency of predictive performance of RS data obtained from these two satellites with similar acquisition dates. Explanatory power of random forest models was compared using root-mean-square error (RMSE) and R^2^ values \[[@pntd.0006517.ref051]\], and relative importance of predictor variables was assessed using the increasing node purity ("IncNodePurity") metric \[[@pntd.0006517.ref052],[@pntd.0006517.ref053]\]. All models were applied back to the raster stack of predictor variables to derive continuous predicted *S*. *haematobium* prevalence surfaces. Although predicted values were available for all pixels, the same masks used to extract the explanatory variables were applied to the respective predicted prevalence surfaces. After applying the masks, the median predicted values within each "community" were plotted against observed prevalence values. The quality of prediction was assessed using Spearman's rank correlation between model predicted and observed values, and their fit was compared to the line of equality. Lastly, environmental data extracted using the best performing mask were combined with the WASH variables in a final model to assess the relative importance of the two groups of variables. Results {#sec016} ======= Comparison of five environmental variable extraction methods {#sec017} ------------------------------------------------------------ As an exploratory analysis, Spearman's rank correlations were computed between pairs of environmental indices ([S2 Table](#pntd.0006517.s002){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, Supporting Information). The correlation values were consistent across extraction masks and across RS data sources. As expected, correlations among the vegetation indices derived using both Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 data were generally very high (0.90--0.99). Lower correlation values were observed between the two water indices NDWI and MNDWI (\~0.70). Consequently, negative correlation values between NDWI and the vegetation indices were much higher than those between MNDWI and the vegetation indices (0.91 versus 0.50). To explore the potential reason for this, NDWI and MNDWI were visually compared against a map ([Fig 4](#pntd.0006517.g004){ref-type="fig"}). In the first row (A1 and B1), schematic maps of study communities are shown with populated areas indicated in gray and water bodies, comprised of rivers/streams and dug mining pits, indicated in blue. It appears that the NDWI computed with Landsat 8 data (A2 and B2) results in false detection of water bodies (i.e., misclassification of developed surfaces such as settlements and roads), essentially serving as an inverse of a vegetation index, which explains the strong negative correlation with vegetation indices. On the other hand, the MNDWI (A3 and B3) more precisely detects water bodies, particularly mining pits. Same conclusions apply to NDWI and MNDWI values derived from Sentinel-2 data ([S13](#pntd.0006517.s015){ref-type="supplementary-material"} and [S14](#pntd.0006517.s016){ref-type="supplementary-material"} Figs, Supporting Information). Neither index performed adequately at detecting the SWAPs, shown as + symbols in [Fig 4](#pntd.0006517.g004){ref-type="fig"}. {#pntd.0006517.g004} Random forest models were first run for each extraction method using environmental variables only ([Table 4](#pntd.0006517.t004){ref-type="table"}). Two versions of the environmental models were run in parallel with Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 surface reflectance and environmental indices (in addition to LST and topographic variables derived from a single source). The R^2^ values for all models were relatively low (\<0.20), indicating that environmental variables alone were not able to describe more than 15--20% of the variability in *S*. *haematobium* prevalence, regardless of RS data source or extraction mask. The predicted prevalence at the pixel level ranged from approximately 5% to 28% ([Fig 4](#pntd.0006517.g004){ref-type="fig"}). Aggregated predicted community-level prevalence ranged between 7% and 22%, as compared to the observed prevalence range of 0--40%. 10.1371/journal.pntd.0006517.t004 ###### Results of environmental models for various extraction masks showing the R^2^ value and Spearman's rank correlation value (r) between model predicted and observed prevalence values. {#pntd.0006517.t004g} Mask[\*](#t004fn001){ref-type="table-fn"} R^2^ (RMSE) r (p-value) R^2^ (RMSE) r (p-value) ------------------------------------------- ------------- ---------------- ------------- ---------------- None {1} 0.14 (9.36) 0.49 (\< 0.01) 0.14 (9.65) 0.33 (\< 0.01) Unpopulated {2} 0.17 (9.07) 0.46 (\< 0.01) 0.14 (9.80) 0.28 (\< 0.01) All WBs {4} 0.15 (9.62) 0.48 (\< 0.01) 0.14 (9.70) 0.40 (\< 0.01) Unmined WBs {5} 0.12 (9.68) 0.51 (\< 0.01) 0.12 (9.71) 0.34 (\< 0.01) SWAPs {6} 0.15 (9.47) 0.76 (\< 0.01) 0.13 (9.43) 0.67 (\< 0.01) \* The number in brackets refers to the mask in [Fig 3](#pntd.0006517.g003){ref-type="fig"} Correlations between observed and predicted prevalence values were higher on average for models produced using Landsat 8 environmental data as compared to Sentinel-2 data (both in combination with LST and topographic variables). Models derived using the SWAP mask produced the highest correlation values using both Landsat 8 (r = 0.76, p \< 0.01) and Sentinel-2 data (r = 0.67, p \< 0.01) ([Table 4](#pntd.0006517.t004){ref-type="table"}). However, scatter plots of observed versus predicted values still deviated substantially from the line of equality ([S22](#pntd.0006517.s024){ref-type="supplementary-material"} and [S23](#pntd.0006517.s025){ref-type="supplementary-material"} Figs, Supporting Information) due to the overall low R^2^ values. From a visual assessment of the predicted prevalence surfaces produced using environmental variables ([Fig 5](#pntd.0006517.g005){ref-type="fig"}; [S24](#pntd.0006517.s026){ref-type="supplementary-material"}--[S33](#pntd.0006517.s035){ref-type="supplementary-material"} Figs, Supporting Information), it appears that the SWAP mask resulted in more precise prediction, including correct delineation of water bodies as high-risk locations ([Fig 5](#pntd.0006517.g005){ref-type="fig"}, panel A6). {ref-type="fig"}.](pntd.0006517.g005){#pntd.0006517.g005} Variable importance was also explored using the IncNodePurity measure from random forest models ([S22](#pntd.0006517.s024){ref-type="supplementary-material"} and [S23](#pntd.0006517.s025){ref-type="supplementary-material"} Figs, Supporting Information). MNDWI was an important water index, particularly when environmental data were extracted without knowledge of water contact sites (masks 1, 2, 4, and 5). Vegetation indices were not commonly observed among the top five important variables in the Landsat 8 models; EVI and NDVI were the most important vegetation indices in the Sentinel-2 models. Slope and elevation were important in many models, whereas stream order was always the least important variable. Contribution of WASH variables {#sec018} ------------------------------ The final model consisted of environmental variables derived from Landsat 8 data using the SWAP mask in combination with WASH variables. The addition of WASH variables only slightly increased the R^2^ value from 0.15 to 0.17 and decreased the RMSE from 9.47 to 9.03. However, iron concentration became by far the most important variable. The importance of iron concentration was also evident in the predicted prevalence surfaces, with high values on the western side of the Atiwa Mountain Range ([Fig 6](#pntd.0006517.g006){ref-type="fig"}) coinciding with high groundwater iron content ([S21 Fig](#pntd.0006517.s023){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, Supporting Information). FIWS and SWAP access indicators were not important in the final model. Of the environmental variables, elevation remained important and stream order remained unimportant ([Fig 6](#pntd.0006517.g006){ref-type="fig"}). The correlations between predicted and observed values were not extracted for the final model because multiple masks were used in the model. {ref-type="fig"} and [5](#pntd.0006517.g005){ref-type="fig"}. Surface water access points are shown as + symbols.](pntd.0006517.g006){#pntd.0006517.g006} Discussion {#sec019} ========== In this study, we utilized publicly available environmental data from two multispectral optical sensors in combination with topographic variables and field-collected WASH variables to assess their performance in predicting *S*. *haematobium* prevalence at a sub-national spatial extent. Furthermore, we tested five methods of environmental data extraction with varying degrees of ecologic relevance. In epidemiologic literature, schistosomiasis is known as a focal disease, meaning that neighboring villages with seemingly similar conditions can have drastically different transmission profiles and disease prevalence levels \[[@pntd.0006517.ref010],[@pntd.0006517.ref018],[@pntd.0006517.ref019]\]. This study attempted to characterize some of the sources of spatial heterogeneity at small spatial extents using fine resolution RS data and WASH-related risk factors. We found that knowledge of water contact sites shows promise in schistosomiasis risk prediction at small spatial extents. According to a visual assessment, environmental data extracted using the SWAP mask more precisely delineated water bodies as high-risk locations within communities ([Fig 5](#pntd.0006517.g005){ref-type="fig"}). This mask also produced the highest correlation between model predicted and observed prevalence values, depicting heterogeneity in transmission risk among communities ([Table 4](#pntd.0006517.t004){ref-type="table"}). Of the two water indices we explored, MNDWI was the preferred index due to more accurate detection of water bodies. NDWI values were equally high for water and developed pixels (roads and settled areas), indicating false detection of water bodies. Generally, higher values of MNDWI correlated with higher schistosomiasis risk. However, even MNDWI could not detect small streams that sustained most of surface water use (i.e., SWAPs). Further investigation of these two indices and their utility in water-related disease modeling is recommended. Vegetation indices did not play a major role in prediction. This is not surprising, especially in the SWAP mask models, as these indices are likely characterizing land vegetation cover, rather than aquatic vegetation that affects intermediate host snail abundance \[[@pntd.0006517.ref011]\]. LST did not exhibit a strong influence on schistosomiasis risk, most probably due to the lack of variability in LST values (25--32 °C), all of which were well within the favorable temperature range for snail and cercariae survival \[[@pntd.0006517.ref054],[@pntd.0006517.ref055]\]. Furthermore, because the water bodies in the study area are very small, the spatial resolution of the temperature data (100 m) was likely too coarse to detect water temperature. Slope and elevation were important in prediction. Higher elevation correlated with higher schistosomiasis risk, counter to the literature, likely because the Atiwa Mountain Range is still quite low in elevation, far below the 2,000-m above sea level threshold for *S*. *haematobium* transmission \[[@pntd.0006517.ref018]\]. Higher slope correlated with lower schistosomiasis risk, potentially due to faster stream flows. At water velocities \> 0.3 m/s, snails can become dislodged and swept away \[[@pntd.0006517.ref055]\]. Surprisingly, stream order was consistently the least important variable in all models, while it demonstrated a significant positive association with schistosomiasis risk in other studies \[[@pntd.0006517.ref017],[@pntd.0006517.ref022]\]. A potential explanation for this is the abundance of small streams throughout the study communities, widespread preference of people for surface water over groundwater, and hence their uniform extensive use. In our study, variables of improved and unimproved water access were not predictive of schistosomiasis risk, consistently with the findings of Lai et al. \[[@pntd.0006517.ref004]\]. However, high iron concentration in groundwater was associated with increased schistosomiasis risk. Our prior studies have provided qualitative support for the hypothesis that unfavorable groundwater quality in improved water sources (i.e., boreholes and piped water systems) for drinking and laundry is a significant driver of increased surface water use, serving as an indirect risk factor for schistosomiasis transmission. The final model results confirmed this hypothesis, with groundwater iron content being the predominant schistosomiasis risk factor with a much higher IncNodePurity value as compared to any of the environmental variables ([Fig 6](#pntd.0006517.g006){ref-type="fig"}). Indeed, in [Fig 6](#pntd.0006517.g006){ref-type="fig"}, the area with high predicted schistosomiasis prevalence in the center of the image corresponds to the high iron concentration cluster ([S21 Fig](#pntd.0006517.s023){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, Supporting Information). Overall, the models had relatively low predictive power and predicted prevalence values deviated substantially from the observed values, indicating overprediction in the low-prevalence range and underprediction in the high-prevalence range. This is most likely due to the effects of preventive chemotherapy on prevalence measures. With increased treatment frequency, it becomes difficult to detect the effects of environmental conditions on transmission risk \[[@pntd.0006517.ref004],[@pntd.0006517.ref022]\]. It would be valuable to apply these approaches in similar geographic extents with a wider prevalence range. Exploring different methods of defining "communities" over which risk factor variables are aggregated (e.g., varying the buffer radius within which transmission occurs) in other geographic, demographic, and cultural contexts is also recommended. We also found that Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 sensors with similar radiometric resolutions (12-bit) and acquisition dates (all images were acquired within one week), on average, had similar predictive capacities. Cloud cover presented a substantial challenge in RS data acquisition from both data sources, with few cloud-free images available only in the dry season (December and January). Additionally, Landsat 8 data were more affected by haze and ocean spray, as compared to Sentinel-2 data. As RS data algorithms improve, future studies should consider repeating the same environmental models using RS data representative of both dry and rainy seasons to analyze the impact of water stability and dynamics. Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data (e.g., from Sentinel-1A) could provide additional information in this and similar cloud-affected regions. Apart from technical challenges associated with using RS data, several logistic challenges may have affected the quality of this study. First, low attendance in some of the study schools (range 46--95%) associated with sporting events and market days may have affected the prevalence measures. For example, children from agrarian families who were absent on market days are likely different in terms of socioeconomic status and schistosomiasis exposure profile from those who were present and participated in the study. In a smaller study, it would have been possible to go back and screen absentees; in the present study, this was not possible due to time and scheduling limitations and absence of identifying information about participants. Additional challenges arose from working across 10 administrative districts, especially with securing local GHS personnel to administer praziquantel. Scheduling and coordination efforts were further complicated by the community health workers being on strike in some of the districts during the study. Despite the challenges and limitations, our study makes important contributions to the modeling approaches of schistosomiasis transmission at small spatial extents. First, knowledge of human water contact sites bridges the gap between where prevalence is measured and where transmission may have occurred. This is a critical gap in models that utilize environmental data as predictors of human infection. Second, the impact of groundwater iron concentration on schistosomiasis risk. With prevalence rates up to 40% only six months after preventive chemotherapy and very high rates of fetching surface water (up to 100%) and swimming (up to 90%) \[[@pntd.0006517.ref049]\], reinfection is a major concern in the study area. Groundwater quality in improved water sources, more so than improved water access in general, plays a major role in reinfection patterns and can impede schistosomiasis control. While it is well-established that preventive chemotherapy reduces prevalence and worm burden in the short term, with rapid reinfection, it cannot have more than a temporary effect on transmission without complementary improvements in WASH \[[@pntd.0006517.ref023],[@pntd.0006517.ref024],[@pntd.0006517.ref056]\]. Our extensive experience in the Eastern region of Ghana suggests that it is not only increasing access to WASH resources that matters, but rather increasing utilization of these resources in accordance with local perceptions and preferences. Considering WASH-related risk factors in schistosomiasis prediction can help shift the focus of control strategies from treating symptoms to reducing exposure \[[@pntd.0006517.ref056]\]. Supporting information {#sec020} ====================== ###### Microhematuria prevalence survey results. (XLSX) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Spearman's rank correlations among six environmental indices (all are statistically significant; p \< 0.05); Sentinel-2 values are shown in top and Landsat 8 in bottom of the matrix. (XLSX) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Data processing steps. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Data analysis steps. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 blue band reflectance values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 green band reflectance values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 red band reflectance values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 near infrared band reflectance values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 short wavelength infrared band reflectance values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Landsat 8 land surface temperature values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 NDVI values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 EVI values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 SAVI values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 MSAVI values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 NDWI values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Sentinel-2 MNDWI values. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Elevation values (in meters) derived from GDEM. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Slope values (in degrees) derived from GDEM. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Slope values derived from GDEM. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Functional improved water source (FIWS) access values derived in ArcGIS from field data. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Perennial surface water source (SWAP) access values derived in ArcGIS from field data. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Interpolated total dissolved solids (TDS) concentration values (in mg/L) derived in ArcGIS from field data. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Interpolated iron concentration values (in mg/l) derived in ArcGIS from field data. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Scatter plots of model predicted (x-axis) vs. observed (y-axis) prevalence values as compared to the line of equality \[left\]; variable importance values \[right\] for random forest models conducted with environmental variables from Landsat 8 and topographic variables from GDEM. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Scatter plots of model predicted (x-axis) vs. observed (y-axis) prevalence values as compared to the line of equality \[left\]; variable importance values \[right\] for random forest models conducted with environmental variables from Sentinel-2 and topographic variables from GDEM. (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Landsat 8 data (mask 1). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Sentinel-2 data (mask 1). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Landsat 8 data (mask 2). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Sentinel-2 data (mask 2). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Landsat 8 data (mask 4). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Sentinel-2 data (mask 4). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Landsat 8 data (mask 5). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Sentinel-2 data (mask 5). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Landsat 8 data (mask 6). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Predicted prevalence values using Sentinel-2 data (mask 6). (TIF) ###### Click here for additional data file. We wish to acknowledge Ghana Health Service and Ghana Education Service for approval and support of the study. We thank Michael N. Adjei, Bernard O. Gyamfi, Rachel Martel, and Liliana Schmitt for assistance with data collection, and Zita Sebesvari for commenting on the manuscript. We are also thankful to members of the traditional leadership of the study communities and school administrators for allowing us to conduct the study in their communities, and to school children for their participation. [^1]: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Sir, An 8 year old male child was brought with the complaints of fever for 5 days, vomiting, abdominal pain, and progressively increasing swelling of face, abdomen, and legs since 1 day. There was no history of hematuria, rashes, loose stools, or bleeding manifestations. An epidemic of dengue fever (DEN 2) was going on in the entire north India. On examination, blood pressure was 130/90 mm Hg (\>95th centile), facial puffiness, bilateral pitting pedal edema, decreased breath sounds basal areas of the lungs, hepatomegaly (3 cm below right costal margin) and shifting dullness in the abdomen were present. His blood urea was 122 mg/dL and serum creatinine 4.3 mg/dL. Dengue serology (IgM and IgG) and NS-1 antigen tests were positive. Urinalysis showed full field red blood cells, +2 proteinuria, and no white blood cells. Ultrasonography of abdomen showed normal size kidneys with bilateral bright echotexture with accentuated corticomedullary differentiation and no obstruction. Rests of the investigations were normal. The child was treated symptomatically and antihypertensive medications were started. Acute kidney injury persisted beyond 4 weeks; hence, a renal biopsy was performed. Light microscopy showed 15 glomeruli that appeared mildly enlarged with some showing mild increase in mesangial matrix and cellularity. The basement membrane appears unremarkable on silver methenamine stain. The tubules showed necrotic debris within lumina and focal vacuolization of lining epithelium. Small blood vessels and interstitium appear unremarkable. Tissue sent for immunofluorescence showed five glomeruli that were negative for all immunoglobulins and complements. Final diagnosis of mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis and acute tubular necrosis was made \[[Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}\]. Gradually renal function tests improved and blood pressure normalized. He was discharged on a serum creatinine of 0.9 mg/dL. {#F1} Acute kidney injury is a poorly studied complication of dengue infection in children. Proteinuria and abnormal urine sediment are the most common renal manifestations in patients with dengue fever. Several types of acute kidney injury in dengue infection has been reported that include acute tubular necrosis, which may be associated with interstitial edema and mononuclear infiltration, acute glomerulonephritis, thrombotic microangiopathy, and myoglobinuric renal failure within the context of multiorgan failure.\[[@ref1]\] The most common conditions associated with acute kidney injury are prolonged shock with metabolic acidosis, and severe DIC that lead to hypoxia/ischemia and result in multiple organ dysfunctions.\[[@ref2]\] The clinical picture in the index case was atypical in that the acute kidney injury was not associated with bleeding manifestations, shock, hemolysis, or rhabdomyolysis. This patient had acute tubular necrosis (ATN) and recovered spontaneously. Review of the literature revealed six cases of dengue fever with acute kidney injury without shock or bleeding manifestation. The cause of hematuria and proteinuria in our case appear to be mild proliferative glomerulonephritis. Though uncommon, hematuria, and proteinuria has been reported in ATN.\[[@ref3]\] Histopathology in cases of the acute kidney injury due to dengue infection is scarce, and most of the diagnosis of acute tubular necrosis is made on clinical grounds. The mechanism of renal involvement in children with dengue fever without bleeding or hypotension remains unclear. It has been postulated that dengue virus can cause direct invasion of the kidneys.\[[@ref4]\] Jessie *et al*. investigated the cellular localization of dengue virus in naturally infected human tissue by applying immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridization techniques in tissue specimens obtained from serologically or virologically confirmed dengue infection. In the kidney viral antigens were detected as discrete granular deposits within the lining cells in the tubules.\[[@ref5]\]

\section{Introduction} X Persei (HD 24534) is a relatively bright variable star, detected in X-rays with $UHURU$ satellite and identified as the optical counterpart of the pulsating X-ray source 4U~0352+309 \citep{1972Natur.235..273B, 1972Natur.235..273V}. This object belongs to the class of Be/X-ray binaries which contains about 100 confirmed and suspected members in our Galaxy, see e.g. \citet{1994SSRv...69..255A} and \citet{2011Ap&SS.332....1R}. The main component of X~Per is a hot massive rapidly rotating Be star. The secondary is a slowly spinning neutron star ($P_{spin} \approx 837$~s) accreting matter from the wind of the primary component \citep{2017MNRAS.470..713M}. On the basis of data from Rossi X-Ray Timing Explorer, \citet{2001ApJ...546..455D} determined the orbital period $\sim$250~d, orbital eccentricity $e$ = 0.11, and semi-major axis $a$ = 2.2~a.u. X~Per is considered prototype of the class of Be/X-ray binaries with long orbital periods and near-circular orbits \citep{2002ApJ...574..364P}, also named "low-e BeX" \citep{2004RMxAC..20...55N}. The low orbital eccentricity may be explained by a supernova explosion at which the neutron star did not receive a large impulse, or ``kick,'' at the time of formation, and all induced eccentricity is due to mass loss. \citet{2011Natur.479..372K} suggested that it may be related to the type of the supernovae explosion which produced the neutron star, i.e. core-collapse or electron-capture supernova. X~Per is a low-luminosity persistent X-ray source and periodic X-ray outbursts are not obvious in its X-ray light curve. \citet{2007A&A...474..137L} and \citet{2012MNRAS.423.1978L} detected X-ray flares and variability in the X-ray light curve. \citet{2017MNRAS.470..713M} detected variability of the pulse profile and energy spectrum and suggested that it is a result of changes in the accretion geometry. X~Per has an unusually hard X-ray spectrum \citep{1981ApJ...247L..31W}. It is confidently detected by INTEGRAL up to more than 100 keV, which can be explained as a result of the dynamical Comptonization in the accretion flow of photons emerging from the polar cap \citep{2012A&A...540L...1D}. In the last century, the visual magnitude of X~Per varies in the range V= 6.8 to 6.2 mag. The brightness variations are accompanied by variations in the intensity of the emission lines. The optical spectrum of X~Per shows strong emission in the Balmer lines, when it is brighter than 6.5 mag \citep{1979IAUC.3352....2D, 1998MNRAS.296..785T}. The brightness variability is probably connected with various disc-rise and disc-fade events. During the last 50 years, the star exhibited two low states - probably disc-less episodes during 1974-1977 and 1990-1991. Absence of emission lines in 1977 was noted by \citet{1979A&A....78..287D}. \citet{1993A&A...270..122R} identified that the low state was during 1974-1977. Dramatic changes were observed in 1990, when X~Per lost the $H\alpha$ emission line, infrared excess, and circumstellar disc \citep{1991MNRAS.253..579N}. The emission lines disappeared and the optical spectrum was dominated by absorption lines, which is typical for normal early-type star. We present optical spectroscopic observations obtained in recent decades and discuss the radius of the circumstellar disc, outflowing velocity in the disc, disc truncation, and connection with X-ray emission. \begin{figure*} \vspace{11.0cm} \special{psfile=f.exam.1.eps hoffset=-25 voffset=-60 hscale=45 vscale=50 angle=0} \special{psfile=f.exam.2.eps hoffset=105 voffset=-60 hscale=45 vscale=50 angle=0} \special{psfile=f.exam.3.eps hoffset=255 voffset=-60 hscale=45 vscale=50 angle=0} \special{psfile=f.exam.4.eps hoffset=385 voffset=-60 hscale=45 vscale=50 angle=0} \caption[]{Variability of $H\alpha$ emission line profile of X Per. The date of observations is in format YYYYMMDD. } \label{f1.atlas} \end{figure*} \section{Observations} The optical spectra of X Per were secured with the 2.0 m telescope of the Rozhen National Astronomical Observatory, Bulgaria and with the robotic 1.2 m TIGRE telescope located is the astronomical observatory La Luz in Mexico. The Rozhen spectra were obtained with the Coude spectrograph and with the Echelle spectrograph ESpeRo \citep{2017BlgAJ..26...67B}. The Coude spectra have dispersion 0.1 \AA\ px$^{-1}$ or 0.2 \AA\ px$^{-1}$, while the Echelle spectra have 0.06 \AA\ px$^{-1}$ at 6560 \AA\ and 0.04 \AA\ px$^{-1}$ at 4800 \AA. The TIGRE spectra were obtained with the HEROS spectrograph, which provides a spectral resolution of 20000 over the visual spectral range from 3800 \AA\ to 8800 \AA\ \citep{2014AN....335..787S}. A few more spectra were downloaded from the ELODIE archive \citep{2004PASP..116..693M}. These were obtained with the 1.93 m telescope of Observatoire de Haute-Provence. The measured parameters are given in Table~\ref{tab.obs}. The variability of $H\alpha$ emission line of X Per is presented in Fig.\ref{f1.atlas} (emission line profile), Fig.\ref{f2.EW.dV} (distance between the peaks), Fig.\ref{f3.vel} (comparison between two high resolution profiles), Fig.\ref{f.hist} (histogram of the $H\alpha$ disc size), and Fig.\ref{f.HaX} (long term behaviour). During the period 1992 - 2018, the equivalent of $H\alpha$ emission line ($W\alpha$) varies from 2~\AA\ up to 40~\AA. From Fig.\ref{f1.atlas}, it is visible that the $H\alpha$ emission line, which exhibits various profile shapes, in some cases is symmetric with two peaks that are well separated, single-peak, double-peak and asymmetric profiles indicating density inhomogeneities. \section{Primary component} \label{primary} \subsection{Radius and mass of the primary} From IR observations, \citet{2017ARep...61..983T} obtained temperature $T = 26000 \pm 1000$~K and radius $R_{1} = 17.1 \pm 0.6$~\rsun\ for the donor star, adopting distance to the system $d$ = 1300~pc. GAIA Data Release 2 \citep{2016A&A...595A...1G, 2018A&A...616A...1G} gives parallax 1.234 mas, which corresponds to a distance 810 pc. With the GAIA distance the results of \citet{2017ARep...61..983T} should give $R_1 = 10.7$~R$_\odot$. The B-V and U-B colours of X Per in low state should represent the colours of the primary component. During the period JD~2448545 (1991 October 15) - JD~2449046 (1993 February 27), the brightness of X Per was low $V \approx 6.77$, and the circumstellar disc was very small. At that time the average colours were $(B-V)=0.09 \pm 0.03$ and $(U-B)=-0.68 \pm 0.03$ \citep{1995IBVS.4189....1Z}. Adopting interstellar extinction towards X~Per $E_{B-V}=0.356$ \citep{1982IAUS...98..423V, 2017BlgAJ..27...10N}, we calculate dereddened colours $(B-V)_0 = -0.26 \pm 0.03$ and $(U-B)_0 = -0.95 \pm 0.03$. Following \citet{1982lndf.book.....S}, these colours correspond to B1 III - V spectral type, which is about one spectral type later than B0 derived by \citet{1997A&A...322..139R} and \citet{1997MNRAS.286..549L}, and O9.5III by \citet{1992A&A...259..522F}. Using the well-known formula for the absolute V magnitude, we obtain $M_V=-3.86$. The bolometric magnitude is $M_{bol} = M_V + BC$, where the bolometric correction is $BC = -2.70$ \citep{1982lndf.book.....S, 2013A&A...550A..26N}. Using the solar values $T_\odot = 5780$~K and $M_{bol}^{sun} =4^m.69$, we calculate $R_1 = 9.2$~R$_\odot$, which is similar to the above value from \citet{2017ARep...61..983T}. \citet{2010AN....331..349H} give average masses for B0V and B1V stars 15.0~M$_\odot$\ and 12.0~M$_\odot$, respectively. Hereafter for the primary of X Per, we adopt radius 9.2~\rsun\ $ < R_1 < 10.7$~\rsun\ ($R_1 = 10.5 \pm 1.2$~\rsun) and mass 12.0~M$_\odot$\ $\le M_1 \le 15.0$~M$_\odot$\ ($M_1 = 13.5 \pm 1.5$~M$_\odot$). \subsection{Rotation of the primary} \citet{1986A&A...159..276D} and \citet{1989Ap&SS.161...61H} established a relation between ${\rm v} \sin i$, full width at half maximum (FWHM), and $W\alpha$ of the $H\alpha$ emission line. To calculate ${\rm v} \sin i$, we use this relation in the form \begin{equation} {\rm v} \sin i = 0.813 \; (FWHM \; 10^{0.08 \log W\alpha\ - 0.14} \; - 70 \; {\rm km \; s}^{-1}) \label{Han1} ,\end{equation} where FWHM and $ \rm {v} \sin i$ are measured in km~s$^{-1}$, W$_\alpha$ is in [\AA]. We measure FWHM and W$_\alpha$ on our spectra and obtain projected rotational velocity in the range $179 \le \rm {v} \sin i \le 217 $~km~s$^{-1}$ with average $ \rm {v} \sin i = 191 \pm 12$~km~s$^{-1}$. This value is close to that of \citet{1997MNRAS.286..549L}, who estimated projected rotational velocity $v~sin~i$ = 215 $\pm$ 10~km~s$^{-1}$ using HeI $\lambda 4026$ \AA\ absorption line. \begin{figure} \vspace{11.0cm} \special{psfile=f1.Wa_dV.eps hoffset=-10 voffset=-60 hscale=47 vscale=47 angle=0} \caption[]{Distance between the peaks normalized with stellar rotation vs. $W\alpha$. } \label{f2.EW.dV} \end{figure} \section{Be disc} \label{Disc.size} In Fig.~\ref{f2.EW.dV}, we plot $\log \Delta V \alpha / 2 $$v \: \sin \: i$ \ versus $\log W\alpha$. The black open circles are data for Be stars taken from \citet{1983A&AS...53..319A}, \citet{1986A&A...166..185H}, \citet{1988A&A...189..147H}, \citet{1992A&AS...95..437D}, \citet{1992ApJS...81..335S}, and \citet{2013A&A...550A..79C}. The blue plus signs are our measurements of X~Per. Most of the data points of X Per are in the middle of the Be star populations. The exceptions are two points obtained on 19920903 and 19920905, when the disc was small. Because these points are above the population of other Be stars, following Sect.~5.2 of Hanuschik et al. (1988), this probably indicates that the disc of X Per was denser during the early stages of its development. Later, when the disc is larger, it follows the average behaviour of other Be stars. For X~Per we have 15 spectra on which both $H\alpha$ and $H\beta$ emission lines have two peaks (see Table~\ref{tab.obs}). We calculate median value $\Delta V_\beta / \Delta V_\alpha = 1.24$ and average value $\Delta V_\beta / \Delta V_\alpha = 1.30 \pm 0.26$. The Balmer emission lines form primarily in the disc surrounding the Be star, and the total flux of the feature (measured as the line equivalent width) is closely related to the size of the disc. The discs of the Be stars are Keplerian supported by the rotation (e.g. \cite{2003PASP..115.1153P} and references therein). For a Keplerian circumstellar disc the peak separation can be regarded as a measure of the outer radius ($R_{disc}$) of the emitting disc, \begin{equation} R_{disc} = R_1 \frac{ (2\,v\,\sin{i})^2} {\Delta V ^2 }, \label{Huang} \end{equation} where $R_1$ is the radius of the primary, $v\,\sin{i}$ is its projected rotational velocity. When the two peaks are visible in the emission lines, we can estimate the disc radius using Eq.~\ref{Huang}. The disc size is also connected with $W_\alpha$, \begin{equation} R_{disc} = \; \epsilon \; R_1 \; 0.467 \; \; W_\alpha^{1.184}, \label{Rd.W2} ,\end{equation} where $\epsilon$ is a dimensionless parameter, for which we adopt $\epsilon = 0.9 \pm 0.1$ (see \citet{2016A&A...593A..97Z}, Sect. 4.3). This equation expresses the fact that $R_{disc}$ grows as $W_\alpha$ becomes larger \citep[e.g.][]{2006ApJ...651L..53G}. A slightly different expression for the relation between $R_{disc}$ and $W_\alpha$ is used in \citet{2006MNRAS.368..447C} and \citet{2017MNRAS.464..572M}. \begin{figure} \vspace{7.0cm} \special{psfile=f.2spec.eps hoffset=10 voffset=-60 hscale=50 vscale=50 angle=0} \caption[]{$H\alpha$ emission line profile of X Per in December 2015 (black solid line) and March 2017 (red dotted line). The two are spectra obtained about one year apart. The difference between the spectra is also plotted and seems to indicates slow outward motion with velocity $\approx 5.1$ km~s$^{-1}$ (see Sect.~\ref{vout}). } \label{f3.vel} \end{figure} \subsection{Radial outflow velocity} \label{vout} During the period JD~2448869 to JD~2450029 a steady increase of the H$\alpha$ emission is visible (Fig.\ref{f.HaX}). The equivalent width increased from W$\alpha = -2.0$~\AA\ to -14.9~\AA, and the distance between the peaks decreased from $\Delta V = 382$ km~s$^{-1}$\ to $\Delta V = 177$ km~s$^{-1}$. Following Eq.~\ref{Huang} this corresponds to change of the disc radius from 13~\rsun\ to 62~\rsun\ and expansion velocity of disc $V_{out} = 0.35$~km~s$^{-1}$. Using W$\alpha$ and Eq.~\ref{Rd.W2} this corresponds to change of the disc radius from 10~\rsun\ to 108~\rsun\ and expansion velocity of disc $V_{out} = 0.70$~km~s$^{-1}$. During the period JD~2452800 to JD~2455500 a steady increase of the H$\alpha$ emission is also visible (Fig.\ref{f.HaX}). The equivalent width increased from W$\alpha = -12$~\AA\ to -37~\AA. Using Eq.~\ref{Rd.W2}, this corresponds to $V_{out} = 0.67$~km~s$^{-1}$. We compared the high resolution emission line profiles obtained with the ESPERO spectrograph. An interesting result emerged when we compared the $H\alpha$ profiles obtained in December 2015 with that in March 2017 (see Fig.~\ref{f3.vel}). It seems that during this period the material that was emitting in the wings of the $H\alpha$ emission moved to the outer parts of the disc and on the later spectrum this material emits in the central part of the line. Ring-like structures in Be discs are discussed for example by \citet{1931ApJ....73...94S} and \citet{2001A&A...379..257R}. In X~Per, \cite{1995MNRAS.276L..19T} detected the appearance and development of an inner ring-like structure in the period 1993-1995, when the disc was starting to rebuilt after a disc-less phase. Supposing that the variability seen on Fig.~\ref{f3.vel} represents a ring-like structure (a ring-like density enhancement) in the disc, we calculate that the ring initially emits at $\Delta V = 220$~km~s$^{-1}$, and later at $\Delta V = 78$~km~s$^{-1}$. Applying Eq.\ref{Huang} we obtain that the material moved from 40~\rsun\ to 325~\rsun\ for 447 days, having average outflow velocity 5.0~km~s$^{-1}$. This velocity is about eight times faster than the velocity we estimated from disc build-up, and might be an indication that once the disc is developed the material can move faster inside the disc. \begin{figure} \vspace{16.0cm} \special{psfile=hist.1.eps hoffset=0 voffset=160 hscale=40 vscale=40 angle=0} \special{psfile=hist.1m2.eps hoffset=0 voffset=-60 hscale=40 vscale=40 angle=0} \caption[]{Distribution of the calculated disc radius. The red dashed lines indicate the distance between components at periastron and apastron; the green solid lines show the resonances. The upper panel show the observed values; the lower indicate 30 days binned.} \label{f.hist} \end{figure} \subsection{Disc truncation} \label{disc.trunc} The tendency for the disc emission fluxes to cluster at specified levels is related to the truncation of the disc at specific disc radii by the orbiting compact object \citep[e.g.][]{2006MNRAS.368..447C}. \citet{2001A&A...377..161O} proposed that these limiting radii are defined by the closest approach of the companion in the high-eccentricity systems and by resonances between the orbital period and disc gas rotational periods in the low-eccentricity systems. The resonance radii are given by \begin{equation} {R_{n:m}^{3/2}} = \frac{m \; (G \: M_1)^{1/2}}{2 \: \pi} \: \frac{P_{orb}}{n}, \label{eq.resona} \end{equation} where $G$ is the gravitational constant, $n$ is the integer number of disc gas rotational periods, and $m$ is the integer number of orbital periods. The important resonances are not only those with $n:1$, but can as well be $n:m$ in general. The histograms of $H\alpha$ disc size, $R_{disc}$, as calculated by Eq.~\ref{Rd.W2}, are plotted in Fig. 4. We use data for W$\alpha$ from \citet{2016A&A...590A.122R}, \citet{2007ApJ...660.1398G}, and \citet{2014AJ....148..113L}, as well as data from Table~\ref{tab.obs}. Fig.~\ref{f.hist} (the upper panel) is the histogram of the measured values of $R_{disc}$. This histogram is affected by the distribution of the observations, for example if we have many observations in one month it could produce a spurious peak in the histogram. To correct for this effect we calculate the average values for each 30 day. If there is no data for a given interval, we interpolate between the nearest values. The 30-day binned values are plotted in Fig. 4 (lower panel). The 30-day bin was used because we do not detect variability in $H\alpha$ on a timescale shorter than 10 days, but we do detect variability on 60 days. Binning with 20 and 40 days provide very similar results. The comparison between Fig.~\ref{f.hist}a and Fig.~\ref{f.hist}b shows that the spurious effects due to unequal distribution of the observations are removed. Fig.~\ref{f.hist} is based on data over the last 26 years from 1992 to 2018. We note that in three X-ray/$\gamma$-ray binaries (LSI+61~303, MWC 148, and MWC 656) the distribution of $R_{disc}$ values has one very well-pronounced peak \citep{2016A&A...593A..97Z}. In X Per we see a few peaks rather than a single peak. The most pronounced peaks correspond to 10:1, 3:1, and 2:1 resonances. In X~Per it seems that in the beginning of the disc-rise the resonance 10:1 operates, after this more disc material appears, the disc grows, and the resonance 3:1 starts to operate, and later 2:1. A more or less similar situation is in the Be/X-ray binary V725~Tau~/~1A~0535+262, where multiple resonances are discussed, i.e. 1:4, 1:5, and 1:7 \citep{2006MNRAS.368..447C}. The orbital period of V725~Tau is 111.1~days \citep{1996ApJ...459..288F}. This similarity indicates that in such wide systems different resonances can operate probably depending on the mass loss of the primary and the development of its circumstellar disc. Following \cite{2018PASJ...70...89Y}, we adopt $P_{orb}=251.0 \pm 0.2 $~d and mass of the neutron star $M_{ns}=2.03$~M$_\odot$. For the primary we assume $M_1=13.5$~M$_\odot$\ (see Sect.~\ref{primary}). With these values we calculate mass ratio $q=M_1/M_{ns} = 6.65$ and semi-major axis of the orbit $a=418$~\rsun. Using the formula by \citet{1983ApJ...268..368E}, we estimate the Roche lobe size of the primary $r_L = 228$~\rsun. The orbital eccentricity of the system is low $e \approx 0.11 $ \citep{2001ApJ...546..455D}. The distance between components at periastron is $ a \:(1-e) = 372$~\rsun\ and at apastron is $ a \: (1+e) = 464$~\rsun. The maximum disc size observed in our data is $R_{disc} = 337$~\rsun, which is smaller than the closest approach of the neutron star. However, it is larger than the size of the Roche lobe of the Be star, i.e. $r_L < R_{disc} (max) < a (1-e)$. The Be/X-ray binaries present different states of X-ray activity \citep{1986ApJ...308..669S, 1998A&A...338..505N}. X~Per does not show periodic Type I outbursts, which are common feature in the classical Be/X-ray binaries and occur when a neutron star moving along an eccentric orbit crosses the Be circumstellar disc during the periastron passage. The result that $R_{disc} (max) < a (1-e)$ demonstrates that the neutron star does not pass through the disc of the donor star even at the maximum disc size observed during the last 30 years. Periodic Type I outbursts in X~Per can be expected if $W\alpha$ achieves the level of about 45 \AA\ or above it. \begin{figure} \vspace{15.0cm} \special{psfile=f.VHaX.2.eps hoffset=-20 voffset=-90 hscale=70 vscale=70 angle=0} \caption[]{X Per - connection between $H\alpha$ and X-ray variability. Shown from top to bottom are V-band magnitude, equivalent width of $H\alpha$ emission, circumstellar disc radius, and X-ray flux. } \label{f.HaX} \end{figure} \subsection{Be disc --> X-ray flux } The mass transfer rate onto the neutron star and subsequent accretion-driven X-ray flux should depend on the changes in the radius of the disc of the Be star that we can track through the variations in H$\alpha$ emission line. The V-band magnitude, $W\alpha$, the calculated disc radius, and X-ray data are plotted in Fig. 5. The V-band data are from American Association of Variable Star Observers (AAVSO). The X-ray data are from RXTE/ASM \citep{1996SPIE.2808...59J, 1996ApJ...469L..33L} and MAXI \citep{2009PASJ...61..999M}. The RXTE/ASM X-ray light curve is rebinned with a time of 30 days and scaled relatively to the MAXI counts (binning with 25 or 35 days provide very similar light curve). In the panel $W\alpha$, the red crosses are data from the literature \citep{2016A&A...590A.122R, 2007ApJ...660.1398G, 2014AJ....148..113L}. The blue plus signs represent Rozhen, TIGRE, and ELODIE data from our Tables~\ref{tab.obs} and~2 of \cite{2001A&A...367..884Z}. \cite{2014AJ....148..113L} discussed the connection between $H\alpha$ and X-ray flux during the period JD~2451000 - JD~2455000. They pointed out the time delay between the $W\alpha$ maximum at about JD~2452000 and X-ray maximum, which is $\sim 800$ days later. They used this delay to estimate the viscosity in the outflowing disc ($\alpha$ parameter). We point that there is a similar time delay between a minimum in $W\alpha$ at JD~2452600 and a minimum in RXTE/ASM X-ray flux at JD~2453500. After JD~2454000 $W \alpha $ increases and the X-ray flux also increases, which indicates that the neutron star accretes more material and probably truncates the outer parts of the disc. Two stronger peaks are visible in $W\alpha$ at JD~2455000 and JD~2457500. Both of these peaks are also well detectable in the MAXI X-ray data. We performed correlation analysis and found moderate to strong correlation between $W\alpha$ and X-ray flux with the Pearson correlation coefficient 0.61-0.66, Spearman's (rho) correlation coefficient 0.61-0.68, and significance, $p-value$ in the range $5 \times 10^{-6}$ - $1 \times 10^{-8}$. There is no time delay between $W\alpha$ and X-ray flux after JD~2454000. If a time delay exists it is less than 40 days. A comparison between the behaviour of V brightness and $W\alpha$ shows that before JD~2453000 these parameters vary almost simultaneously -- the maxima of $W \alpha $ correspond to the maxima of the V-band brightness and have time delays $\lesssim 300$ days. After it, the behaviour is different -- the maxima of $W \alpha $ and $R_{disc}$ correspond to minima of the V-band brightness. \section{ Discussion } \label{Discussion} For Be stars, \cite{1988A&A...189..147H} found that the peak separations of $H\alpha$ and $H\beta$ emission lines follow the relation $\Delta V_\beta = 1.8 \Delta V_\alpha$. For X~Per the ratio $\Delta V_\beta / \Delta V_\alpha$ is considerably below the average value for Be stars (see Sect. \ref{Disc.size}). At this stage considerable deviation from the behaviour of the Be stars is also detected in LSI$+61^0303$ \citep{2016A&A...593A..97Z}. In both star the $H\alpha$-emitting disc is only 1.7 times larger than the $H\beta$-emitting disc, while in normal Be stars it is 3.2 times larger. This can be a result of truncation of the outer parts or different density structures in the inner parts of the Be disc. The pulse period of neutron star in X~Per shows episodic spin-ups and spin-downs. Between 1972 and 1978 the neutron star has been spinning up with a rate of $\dot{P}/P \simeq -1.5 \times 10^{-4}$~yr$^{-1}$ \citep{1983adsx.conf..393H}. Since 1978 till 2002 the neutron star has been spinning down with a rate $\dot{P}/P \simeq 1.3 \times 10^{-4}$~yr$^{-1}$. After 2002 (JD~2452000) a new episode of spin-up has began \citep{2012int..workE..26B, 2014MNRAS.444..457A}. This new spin-up began together with the increase of the X-ray brightness, and its start corresponds to the moment when $W\alpha$ achieved 20~\AA\ and $R_{disc} \approx 150$~\rsun. \cite{2018PASJ...70...89Y} analysed X-ray data and estimated for the neutron star in X Per mass $M_{ns} = 2.03 \pm 0.17$ M$_\odot$, and magnetic field $B = (4 - 25) \times 10^{13}$~G, adopting GAIA distance $d = 810$~pc. They also found that the X-ray luminosity varies in the range $2.5 \times 10^{34}$ to $1.2 \times 10^{35}$ erg s$^{-1}$. \cite{2017MNRAS.465L.119P} proposed that in the enigmatic Be star $\gamma$~Cassiopeia the elusive companion is a neutron star acting as a propeller. In this scenario, the subsequent evolutionary stage of $\gamma$~Cas and its analogues should be X Per-type binaries comprising low-luminosity slowly rotating X-ray pulsars. The corotation radius of the neutron star is \begin{equation} R_{co} = \left( \frac{G \; M_{ns} \; P_{spin} ^2}{4 \; \pi ^2} \right) ^{1/3} .\end{equation} The radius of its magnetosphere (the Alfv\'en radius) is \begin{equation} R_{m} = \frac{ \left( B \; R_{ns}^3 \right) ^{4/7}}{ \dot M_{acc}^{2/7} \; \left( 2 \; G \; M_{ns} \right) ^{1/7} } \label{eq.Rm} .\end{equation} In the standard theory of gravimagnetic rotators \citep{1987ans..book.....L, 2018A&A...610A..46C} for a neutron star to be accretor (X-ray pulsar) the condition is that the magnetosphere radius should be smaller than the corotation radius, $R_{m} \le R_{co}$. Assuming $R_{ns}=10$~km and that X-ray flux is equal to the accretion luminosity, \begin{equation} L_{acc} = G M_{ns} \dot M_{acc} R_{ns}^{-1}, \label{Eq.a1} \end{equation} we estimate that the mass accretion rate is in the range $1.47 \times 10^{-12}$ to $7.07 \times 10^{-12}$ M$_\odot$\ yr$^{-1}$ (from $9.28 \times 10^{13}$ to $4.45 \times 10^{14}$~g~s$^{-1}$). We calculate that at low accretion rate $R_{m} \approx R_{co} \approx 0.24$~\rsun, in other words at low X-ray flux the neutron star is close to the accretor-propeller transition boundary. The condition that the neutron star in X~Per is an accretor (not propeller), $R_{m} \le R_{co}$, also puts a limit on the magnetic field strength, $B \le 1.15 \times 10^{14}$~G. This value is estimated taking into account the deviation of the magnetosphere radius from the the Alfv\'en radius \citep[e.g. ][]{2018A&A...617A.126B}. If the magnetic field is above this value, the neutron star would act as a propeller, the X-ray luminosity would decrease and the X-ray pulsations would disappear (which is not observed). \cite{1993A&A...270..122R} found a clear correlation between the optical, infrared, and X-ray behaviours during the 1974-1977 low state, followed by an extended period in which the X-ray behaviour appears to be unrelated to the optical. Li et al. (2014), analysing data obtained after the disc-less episode in 1990, found a time delay of about 800 days between $W\alpha$ and X-ray flux. This time delay exists before JD~2454000. After JD~2454000 (as visible on Fig.~\ref{f.HaX}) there is no time delay, but there is a correlation between the variability of $W\alpha$ and X-ray flux. As the $W\alpha$ increases, the X-ray flux also increases. This is indicating a direct linkage between the circumstellar disc around mass donor and accretion rate onto the neutron star. This linkage is visible when $W_\alpha > 20$ \AA\ and $R_{disc} > 200$~\rsun. When the circumstellar disc around the primary increases above 200~\rsun, the quantity of the material that is captured in the accretion cylinder of the neutron star also increases. The Roche lobe size of the primary is $r_L = 227$~\rsun\ (see Sect.~\ref{disc.trunc}). When $W_\alpha \approx 25$~\AA, $R_{disc} \approx r_L$, the circumstellar disc fills the Roche lobe around the primary and the neutron star begins to accrete material from the Roche lobe overflow. In the past few years the existence of a relatively efficient mode of wind mass accretion in a binary system has been proposed, called the wind Roche lobe overflow \citep[WRLOF; ][]{2007ASPC..372..397M}, which lies in between the canonical Bondi-Hoyle-Littleton accretion and Roche lobe overflow. In case of X~Per, most probably before JD~2454000 the circumstellar disc is small, it is well inside the Roche lobe ($R_{disc} < r_L$) and wind accretion (Bondi-Hoyle-Littleton accretion) is acting. After JD~2454000 when the circumstellar disc size achieves the Roche lobe, $R_{disc} \gtrsim r_L$, the accretion mode changes to WRLOF, and the neutron star is accreting material directly from the circumstellar disc (Roche lobe overflow from the circumstellar disc) without time delay. Other possibilities include the development of spiral arms \citep{2007ApJ...660.1398G} or other large-scale perturbations \citep{1998A&A...336..251N} in the circumstellar envelope excited by tidal interaction which may lift disc gas out to radii where the accretion by the neutron star becomes more effective. \section{Conclusions} We present optical spectroscopic observations of the Be/X-ray binary X~Per, optical counterpart of the X-ray pulsar 4U~0352+309. In this work, we combine published data with our measurements. First, we estimate, that the expansion velocity of the circumstellar disc is in the range 0.4 - 0.7 km~s$^{-1}$ . Second, we find that the distribution of the disc radius from the average equivalent width suggests resonant truncation of the disc, while the maximum disc radius is smaller than the separation of the stars at periastron but larger than the Roche lobe of the primary. Third, we derive a correlation between the equivalent width of $H\alpha$ emission line and X-ray flux, which is visible since JD~2454000, when $15~\AA \: < W\alpha \le 40$ \AA. We briefly discuss possible mechanisms of mass transfer. \vskip 1.0cm \begin{acknowledgements} This work is supported by the grant K$\Pi$-06-H28/2 08.12.2018 (Bulgarian National Science Fund). It is based on observations from Rozhen National Astronomical Observatory, Bulgaria and the TIGRE telescope, located at La Luz, Mexico. TIGRE is a joint collaboration of the Hamburger Sternwarte, the University of Guanajuato and the University of Li\`ege. This research has made use of (1) the MAXI data provided by RIKEN, JAXA, and the MAXI team; (2) results provided by the ASM/RXTE teams at MIT and at the RXTE SOF and GOF at NASA's GSFC; and (3) observations from the AAVSO International Database contributed by observers worldwide. UW acknowledges funding by DLR, project 50OR1701. DM acknowledges partial support by grants DN~08/20/2017 and RD-08-112/2018. We are very grateful to the referee whose comments helped to improve considerably the original manuscript. \end{acknowledgements} \bibliographystyle{aa}

Introduction {#sec1-1} ============ Cell phones (mobile phones) have currently been transformed into an inseparable part in the life of human beings. Cell phones have many advantages, including communicating with the family, friends, and even business, playing games, and listening to music. Along with advantages that they have, cell phones have various disadvantages which are confrontation with the metals such as arsenic, lead, lithium used in cell phones manufacturing and focused on the determination of the toxic metal content of liquid crystal displays presented in various electrical and electronic equipment waste included mobile phones, all of which are toxic. Confronting with radiofrequency radiation in cell phones can also be indicated that could be effective on human health, leading to cancer diseases.\[[@ref1]\] Currently, 96.6% of the world population are using cell phones. Seventy-four percent of the population in India, 100% in the USA, 170% in Finland, and 8.3% in South Korea use cell phones.\[[@ref2]\] It is predicted that the number of smartphones in the world increase to 2380 million devices by 2017.\[[@ref3]\] Cellular phones operate in the range of microwaves, using electromagnetic and radiofrequency radiations. Electromagnetic radiations cause biological changes, both directly and indirectly.\[[@ref4]\] Biological effects for confronting with radiofrequency waves from cell phones are different in biological systems, including organic interactions, tissues, cellular and molecular levels. It is logical to presume that biological damages can be started in a molecule and in macromolecular level.\[[@ref5]\] Placing the cell phone near ear and head leads to confrontation of tissues and structures around the ear and head with radiofrequency waves. Peripheral and central neural systems that coordinate the body vital functions are also affected by these waves. The studies done on animal and human models have shown significant results for increasing headaches, changing the sleeping pattern, and changes in the cycle of neural cells.\[[@ref6]\] Reports from various studies have shown that the people holding the mobile phone near their ear canal and head are 30% more exposed to brain tumors in comparison.\[[@ref7]\] Despite their small body sizes, cell phones are altered into a complicated device with high rates of efficiency. The concentration of temperature in a peculiar section of it has been transformed into a problem in this device.\[[@ref8]\] In a study by Anderson and Rowley on the effect of increasing skin temperature due to confronting with cell phone radiofrequency waves, it was shown that skin temperature increases by 2.3°C--4.5°C with regard to the frequency in the cell phones. Increasing the skin temperature was reported to be 0.01°C due to the direct effect of cell phone radiofrequency waves.\[[@ref9]\] Absorption of radiofrequency energy by the tissues increases their temperatures, causing serious harms to human health, including cataract disease, skin burns, and testicular decline. Some experimental studies and also studies on the live tissues show the thermal effect of radiofrequency waves on blood vessels occlusion in brain, chromosomal changes, immune system, activities of neurotransmitters, brain tumors, and also the rate of cellular mutation.\[[@ref10]\] The people, who stated that they were sensitive against radiofrequency waves, often have the experience of cognitive disorders, believing that they suffer from headaches due to confrontation with radiofrequency waves. They consider it as a sign of being exposed to radio-frequency waves. Headache is an important warning sign, indicating that body temperature has increased, and it is presumed that in exposure to radiofrequency waves, the tissues biological temperatures, body temperature, and other vital physiological signs, such as blood pressure and heartbeat, to be altered.\[[@ref11]\] Very low increase in temperature of hypothalamus by 0.2°C--0.3°C, when exposed to cell phone radiofrequency waves, leads to behavioral changes in regulating the temperature.\[[@ref12]\] Rapid ever-increasing growth of communication industries, general application of mobile phones, and general worries from the effects cell phone waves, especially since it is placed near the head and ear canal during communicating with it, caused this study to be done with the aim to determine the thermal changes of cellular phones radiofrequency waves in the grey and white matters of the brain. Methods {#sec1-2} ======= The present study was an empirical study. Due to the similarities to human brain tissues, 15 cow brains were used which brain after slaughter was transferred to laboratory by a cool box. Tissue temperature during slaughter was 38.5°C which it had to be equivalent to laboratory temperature and sampling box. This temperature is the base temperature which is shown in the graph. Tissue was selected to be analyzed. Its weight was about 432 g that was immediately bought after slaughter and transferred to the laboratory. Laboratory equipment {#sec2-1} -------------------- A compartment with the height of 40 cm, length of 80 cm, and width of 30 cm was designed and made by plexiglass to increase the measuring precision and reducing errors due to temperature, humidity, and ventilation systems during the measurements, and the brain tissue was placed in it so that it was separated from contacts with environmental conditions, and its door was closed after the required adjustments. Lutron thermometer (model: MT-917) with the precision range of ±0.01 was used for measuring the tissue temperature. The thermometer has five measuring probes, and the probe "PT100" was used for the current study. This probe is used for measuring depths and thicknesses, and its temperature range was +199.99 and its material is of platinum. Lutron thermometer can measure both in "Fahrenheit" and "Celsius" grades. However, "Celsius" unit was used for this study. The thermometer was connected to a computer system by a cable (USB-01) \[[Figure 2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}\]. The temperature range of this USB cable was between 0°C and 50°C, having efficiency in humidity under 80%. Temperature changes of the thermometer were recorded by installing Lutron software. Thus, the collected data were analyzed by this method. {#F1} {#F2} Preparation and confrontation {#sec2-2} ----------------------------- The brain tissue was placed on a plate in the compartment that was separated from the compartment bottom. Then, regarding the measurement of the gray and white matters of the brain, the "PT100" probe was placed in 2 mm, 12 mm, and 22 mm thicknesses of the tissue. The first thickness was related to the gray matter of the brain with 2 mm thickness. A smartphone was used to analyze the thermal effect of cell phones radiofrequency waves, which was placed on a stand, 4 mm away from the brain tissue and on its left, exactly like the time that a person is communicating with a cell phone. After adjustments, the thermometer was turned on and connected to a computer system by a USB cable, and the related software was started \[[Figure 3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}\]. For holding heat balance between the tissue and the inner environment of the compartment and reducing errors, a contact was made between the tissue and the cell phone. The brain tissue had no confrontation with the cell phone radiofrequency waves, which took 2--3 h during the balancing period. After balancing of the compartment temperature and the tissue, the tissue temperature before confronting with the cell phone was considered as the base temperature. Then, the contact was held between the tissue and the cell phone, exactly as a person was communicating with a cell phone. The confrontation time was considered to be 15 min. By ending the confrontation time, the contact was cutoff. The tissue was kept in the compartment for 15 min in the next stage for its temperature to be reduced without exposures and the presence of radiofrequency waves. In all the previous stages, during and after exposure to cell phone radiofrequency waves, the thermometer was connected to the computer system, and the temperature changes were recorded by the software. This experiment was also done for 12 mm and 22 mm thicknesses in the brain tissue (white matter of the brain). Finally, the temperature changes relative to the obtained time were transferred to MATLAB software (2012 version, MathWorks company), and the graph related to each thickness was obtained. {#F3} Results {#sec1-3} ======= To determine the thermal changes of radio frequency waves of cell phones on the brain tissue, brain tissue of a cow was analyzed for different thicknesses of 2 mm, 12 mm, and 22 mm, during contacting with a mobile phone. It was required to balance the tissue and compartment temperatures for measuring the temperatures in different considered thicknesses of the brain tissue. This temperature was equal to 18.38 °C for the three thicknesses and after unification of the compartment temperature with the brain tissue temperature, which was considered as the base temperature (tissue temperature before confronting with the cell phone). Since the thermometer recorded temperature changes once every 5 s, and the base temperature was 18.38°C, after contact between the tissue and the cellular phone in 15 min, the temperature of the brain gray matter increased up to 18.91°C by the 2 mm thickness of the tissue (brain grey matter), and the brain tissue showed an increase of 0.53°C in comparison with the time before confronting with the cell phone. Temperature changes of the gray tissue of the brain relative to time are shown in [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. After the contact and confrontation of the tissue with a cell phone for 15 min, the tissue temperature reached to 19.37°C from 18.38°C in 12 mm thickness of the tissue, and the brain tissue had a temperature increase of 0.99°C in comparison with the time before confrontation of the tissue with a cell phone. Moreover, the base temperature of the brain tissue at the thickness of 22 mm was equal to 18.38°C after the contact and confrontation of the tissue and the cell phone for 15 min, temperature raised to 19.3°C, showing an increase of 0.92°C in comparison with the time before the confrontation. The tissue temperature changes in 12, 22 mm thickness are shown in [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. The duration of the tissue exposure to cell phone was 15 minutes, and 0.01°C increase in confrontation with the cell phone was observed in thicknesses of 12 mm and 22 mm (white matter of the brain) after 5 s and in 2 mm thickness (gray matter of the brain) after 10 s. In fact, the white matter had the temperature increase faster than the gray matter. Moreover, by the increase in the tissue thickness, the times that they reached maximum temperatures were less, such that 22 mm thickness and 2 mm thickness reached reached after 7 min and 9 min and 25 s, respectively, to maximum temperature increases, i.e., 19.3°C and 18.91°C, and the maximum temperature increases were fixed in 15 min of confronting with the cell phone. On the other hand, the time for maximum temperature reduction after stopping the exposure in higher thicknesses was less, such that maximum temperature reduction was observed in 22 mm, 12 mm, and 2 mm thicknesses after 5 min 5 s, 8 min 13 s, and 14 min, respectively, and the temperature reduction was fixed until the end of 15 min after stopping the confrontation. In general, the time that in 2 mm thickness of the brain tissue (gray matter of the brain), temperature showed an increase by 0.53°C, and in other words, in 2 mm thickness, the slope in the relevant figure showed a mild increasing trend, while in higher thicknesses (12 mm and 22 mm) (the white matter of the brain), the temperature increase was equal to 0.99°C and 0.92°C, respectively, and the slope in the figure in these thicknesses increased with higher rates. In fact, higher temperature increases were observed in 12 mm and 22 mm thicknesses. [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"} shows the comparison between increasing temperatures in the three different thicknesses of the brain tissue. Brain tissue temperatures in the three mentioned thicknesses were evaluated for the 15 min period after stopping the confrontation with the cell phone. The results showed that the base temperature in 2 mm, 12 mm, and 22 mm thicknesses (the tissue temperatures before the exposures) was equal to 18.38°C, and 15 min after stopping the required confrontation, the temperature rates were 18.58°C, 18.74°C, and 19.01°C, respectively. In other words, the temperature of the brain tissue decreased in all the three thicknesses relative to the exposure time. However, it was higher in comparison with the base temperature, such that the tissue temperatures in 2 mm, 12 mm, and 22 mm thicknesses were 0.33°C, 0.63°C, and 0.29°C higher than the base temperature, respectively. Discussion {#sec1-4} ========== The present study has analyzed the thermal changes of cell phones radiofrequency waves on the gray and white matters of the brain tissue. Results have shown that confrontation of the brain tissue for 15 min with a cell phone increases its temperature. In fact, temperature increases were observed for all the three thicknesses (2 mm, 12 mm, and 22 mm) during confrontation and relative to the base temperature (brain tissue temperature before confrontation), and this increase in the temperature was 0.53°C, 0.99°C, and 0.92°C for the mentioned thicknesses (2 mm, 12 mm, 22 mm), respectively. Rusnani *et al*. reported that in 15 min and 30 min confrontation with a cell phone, the temperature increases in the head and ear members of users, and this temperature in this parts increases by increasing the time of conversation by the cell phone. They showed that temperature by confrontation of the head with a cell phone for 15--30 min increased by 0.3°C--2.9°C.\[[@ref13]\] Tahvanainen *et al*. stated that in confronting with radio frequency waves of cell phones for 35 min, the ear canal temperatures of users increased 1.5°C.\[[@ref14]\] One of the important effects of absorbing radio frequency waves of cell phones is increasing the temperature of body tissues, such that increasing 4.5°C in the brain is reported in a study due to confronting with a cell phone for 30 min.\[[@ref15]\] In this study, the temperatures of brain tissue in different thicknesses of 2 mm, 12 mm, and 22 mm for 15 min confrontation with a cell phone show reductions in comparison with the tissue temperature during the confrontation. However, despite temperature reductions, the temperatures of the brain tissue in the three thicknesses and after confronting with a cell phone are higher in comparison with the base temperature, with the rates of 0.33°C, 0.63°C, and 0.29°C, respectively. In other words, not only temperature increase was observed during confrontation with the cell phone, in the brain tissue, but also this increase was cumulative even after the confrontation, and the temperature was higher for some time after the confrontation with the cell phone relative to the time before the confrontation. Since the cell phone antenna is located near the head and an ear of the user, most probably the brain is confronted extensively to radiofrequency waves.\[[@ref4]\] In fact, by increasing the brain temperature, the brain blood circulation is increased and lateral thermal adjustment reactions are activated. Measuring automatic responses of the brain and evaluation of brain blood flow are used as indirect evidence from blood circulation interactions and regulating temperature during confrontation with radiofrequency waves. Thus, repeating the exposure to cell phones will increase the tissue temperature during the confrontation and leads to high temperature of the tissue, even for a while after confrontation, which provides improper effects on the brain health.\[[@ref16]\] Tissue temperature in the thicknesses of 12 mm and 22 mm of the brain showed a higher increase, which indicates the effects of the brain tissue layers on the thermal balance in the considered thickness. This result shows that with more layers of the tissue, the accumulated heat in the tissue will be higher. Hence, it is possible that the effects due to using the cell phone are more in the deep tissues. On the other hand, it is possible that the deep tissues (white matter of the brain) have higher sensitivity in confronting with cell phone waves, and the sensitivity emerges by higher absorption of energy and thus, higher increase of temperature. These results can primarily be due to the differences in the fluid materials of the tissue layers, such that more fluid in the gray matter than the white matter can generally produce higher heating capacity. This phenomenon causes the gray matter to have less increase of temperature in a unit time, reaching a lower temperature by the end of the experiment. On the other hand, the difference in temperature increase can be due to the important point that the induced heating in the tissue does not necessarily have direct and linear relation with the depth of the tissue, and it is a function from physical variables of electromagnetic waves, including frequency, field flux, and intensity. Wessapan *et al*. showed in their study that due to confronting with the cell phone, the rate of the generated heat in the brain tissue is more than the skin since brain is a tissue with high metabolism in heat generation. Hence, temperature is higher in the brain tissue as compared to other tissues with low metabolism in heat generation. High blood supply of the skin tissue plays an important role for keeping the tissue temperature in low condition, while supplying blood to the brain tissue is lower as compared to skin, causing the brain tissue temperature to rise.\[[@ref12]\] In a study on forty mobile phone users, it was reported that 35 users complained about skull problems such as tingling and feeling pins and needles on ear sections, and frontal and posterior parts of the brain.\[[@ref17]\] Maximum temperature additive changes in human brain occur in the frequency of 900 MHZ to over 1800 MHZ. On the other hand, electromagnetic waves resulted from cell phones in 900 MHZ permeate to the confronted tissue, and the energy resulted from these waves is taken by the tissue. Although the transmitting device of the cell phone transmits a little force, the users\' bodies absorb this force from the transmitting device antenna, and the highest rate of exposure to radiofrequency waves is concentrated in the users\' heads. According to some studies, it is determined that the absorbed energy by the users is transformed into heat inside the biological tissues, affecting the tissues through the generated heat.\[[@ref18]\] Conclusions {#sec1-5} =========== It can be concluded that the radiated radio frequency waves from cell phones are effective on increasing the temperature of brain tissue, and the increase is cumulative in the tissue, (tissue temperature after exposure was different with its base temperature before exposure) such that the temperature remains higher, even for some time after the confrontation, as compared to the time with no confrontations. The time of increasing temperature in the white matter is lower as compared to the gray matter. Despite the advantages of cell phones that have led to increasing the number of users, their harmful effects on people are inevitable, and the related effects emerge by the passage of time and increasing use of the cell phones. This should be considered by the people who continuously use mobile phones as a communicating device. It is proposed to analyze the effects of radio-frequency waves of cell phones for different using times and considering different models. Financial support and sponsorship {#sec2-3} --------------------------------- Nil. Conflicts of interest {#sec2-4} --------------------- There are no conflicts of interest.

\subsection{Phase diagram} \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Phase diagram.} As mentioned earlier, depending on the magnitude and angle of the stress applied, the system can be BG, RG, or slides continuously. When the system is subjected to a shear stress $\pmb{\tau}=\mathbf{F}/A$, where $\mathbf{F}$ is the applied force and $A$ the area of the flake, it can be studied using the bilayer enthalpy $H(\mathbf{r}) = V(\mathbf{r}) - \pmb{\tau} \cdot \mathbf{r} A$. As we will now see, the number of minima of $H$ determines the phase the system is in, giving a stress-angle phase diagram (Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_2d}g) for multilayer graphene. In the pairwise model, if a stress $\pmb{\tau}$ is applied to the upper layer in a quasistatic transformation, then the layer below exerts all the remaining stress $-\pmb{\tau}$. The same applies to subsequent layers. Thus, for each pair of layers, their enthalpy $H$ is the same. Depending on the angle and magnitude of $\pmb{\tau}$, there are three possible situations, which correspond to the 3 colored regions of Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_2d}g:\\ (i) Blue region: 2 minima. If no stress is applied, $H=V$, and there are 2 minima $m_1$ and $m_2$ (see Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_2d}h). If shear stress is sufficiently low, $H$ still has 2 minima, and the system has $2^{N-1}$ minima. For each pair of layers, they do not escape the local minimum they are currently in. Since this holds for all layers, the full system does not escape the local minimum it is currently in. In particular, if BG is chosen as the starting structure, the system remains BG in the blue region (in the pairwise model, all stacking sequences have the same energy, but in reality BG is the most stable structure).\\ (ii) Green region: 1 minimum. As stress increases, $m_1$ disappears and $m_2$ remains close to its $\pmb{\tau}=0$ position. Barrier $b_1$ disappears, while $b_2$ remains. This occurs because the stress is more aligned with the direction in which the saddle point $b_1$ has a maximum (that is, the direction in which $b_1$ acts as a barrier) than with the corresponding direction of $b_2$ (except at $\theta=\ang{30}$, where both barriers are affected in the same way, and the system transitions directly from 2 minima to 0 minima). Since there is only one minimum, all layers are in the same position relative to the lower layer, and the resulting stacking is rhombohedral. This is a key observation of our work. From the convention in Fig.~\ref{fig:mechanical_model}a, $m_2$ corresponds to configuration AC, and layers are ACB-stacked. If stress is applied in the opposite direction, $m_1$ is the only remaining minimum, and layers are ABC-stacked.\\ (iii) Orange region: 0 minima. For larger stresses, there are 0 minima. Since there are no local minima, layers keep on sliding without reaching a stable configuration. If the stress is eventually removed, the system will not necessarily be RG. However, transformations at different angles as in Fig.~\ref{fig:force_6l} suggest that the system will still have a high degree of rhombohedral order. In particular, for small angles, the structure remains fully RG. Also, $\theta=\ang{0}$ is the angle with the largest range of stress that results in RG, of about 0.3 GPa (from 0.2 to 0.5 GPa). Thus, the armchair direction is the most robust direction to obtain RG. Fig.~\ref{fig:phase_diagram}g also shows with plus signs '+' the critical stress values. For each angle, the small critical stress corresponds to the lower value, and the big critical stress to the upper value. They coincide with the blue-green border, and green-orange border, respectively. This excellent agreement shows that the number of minima of $H$ does indeed define the stress-angle phase diagram. It is worth pointing out that when $m_1$ becomes shallow enough, it might be possible for thermal fluctuations to excite layers from $m_1$ from $m_2$. This will depend on experimental conditions, like duration of the experiment, temperature, and size of the flakes. Thus, the curve that separates multiple minima from 1 minimum is actually an upper bound. Also, BG is more stable than RG and is presumably located in a deeper (local) minima (in an analogous fashion to the two minima of the blue curve of Supplementary Fig.~\ref{fig:6layer}). So for $\theta$ close to 30$^\circ$, it might occur that the system transitions directly from BG to continuous sliding. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Pressure.} Other hydrostatic pressures were also considered. Supplementary Fig.~\ref{fig:force_pressure} shows the phase boundaries at P=0 (blue-green and green-orange borders of Fig.~\ref{fig:phase_diagram}g, or lower and upper borders) and P=2 GPa. The values of the lower and upper boundary at $\theta=0$ increase approximately linearly with pressure, at about 0.07 and 0.18 GPa of shear stress per GPa of hydrostatic pressure, respectively. Thus, the amount of stress needed to obtain RG increases, but also the range of allowed values to obtain RG (which might increase the robustness of an experiment). \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Shear in previous works and superlubricity.} The values of stress to produce RG suggested by our calculations are very similar to values already published in experimental reports. The configurations we have described, where layers are commensurate with each other, are referred to as \textit{lock-in} states in graphene literature related to friction or shear. In this type of systems, values of shear stress of the order of 0.1 GPa were measured \cite{Dienwiebel2004}, and observed to be in good agreement with previous calculations\cite{Verhoeven2004}. In another experiment\cite{Liu2012b}, a microtip of a micromanipulator was used to apply a shear force on a graphene flake to ``unlock'' it (remove it from the minima), and based on the deformation of the tip, a value of 0.14 GPa was reported, also lower than 0.20 GPa . On the other hand, when the layers are incommensurate with each other, the values of friction are 2 or 3 orders of magnitude lower. This phenomenon is referred to as superlubricity and has sparked a lot of interest. Optimal conditions for superlubricity include big flakes, low temperatures and low loads\cite{Wijn2010}. Since layers have to be moved out of the local minimum in the mechanism we have proposed, depending on the experimental conditions, care might need to be taken to avoid the upper layer to rotate into a superlubricant state. To conclude, we have described a mechanism to transform multilayer graphene into RG through shear stress, which implies that applying sufficient shear strain to graphite results in long-range RG. Also, existing experimental values of shear stress are similar to the ones suggested by our results. Our model suggests a compelling method for experimental groups trying to obtain multiple layers of rhombohedral-stacked graphene. \clearpage \small \noindent \textbf{\large Methods} \noindent \textbf{DFT calculations.} Calculations were performed in Quantum Espresso (QE) \cite{QE} using an LDA functional. The bilayer potential and the six layer first-principles transformations were obtained with a cutoff of 80 Ry, a $k$-grid of $56\times 56\times 1$ and an electronic temperature (Fermi-Dirac smearing) of 284 K. The energies considered in this work are always in meV per interface atom. This means that the total energy of the system is divided by 2, whether the number of layers is 2 or 6 (which permits a direct comparison between energies of both systems). In each system, the energy is set to 0 at the relative position where the energy is the lowest. To converge the energy differences of Supplementary Table 1 with a precision below 0.01 meV/atom, we used an energy cutoff of 120 Ry and an electronic grid of $80 \times 80 \times 1$. In the rvv10 calculations of Supplementary Fig.~\ref{fig:rvv10}, 100 Ry were used. The most important parameter in the calculations is basically the small barrier $V_\textrm{SP}$ of Fig.~\ref{fig:mechanical_model}a between the two minima, since it determines the amount of stress necessary to go from one local minimum to another. The value of $V_\textrm{SP}$ can be expected to be somewhat accurate if the curvature around the minima is accurate. The curvature is directly proportional to the frequency squared of the shear mode LO' at $\Gamma$ \cite{Mounet2005} (this is the mode in which layers move in the plane in opposite directions). Experimental values of the shear frequency vary between 42 cm$^{-1}$ and 45 cm$^{-1}$(ref. \cite{Lebedeva2011}). This is in good agreement with the value that results from fitting a parabola close to $m_1$ in Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_1d}a, 42 cm$^{-1}$. The curvature of other functionals like rvv10 (ref. \cite{Sabatini2013}), which includes van der Waals, is actually lower in our calculations, so they agree less well with experiments (see Supplementary Fig.~\ref{fig:rvv10}). In previous works, rvv10 also gives a lower frequency than LDA\cite{Grande2019}. To be confident that it is sufficient to consider the 2 layer potential in our analysis, we considered a similar calculation, but with 6 layers (dotted-blue line in Supplementary Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_1d}a) instead of 2. In each calculation, the $x_\textrm{CM}$ and $y_\textrm{CM}$ of each of the three upper layers was moved with respect to the three lower layers, and the system was relaxed. This corresponds to a generalized stacking fault energy \cite{Wang2015}. The curves are very similar, and the energy difference between the minima is about 6\% of $V_\textrm{SP}$, so the transformations could be analyzed in terms of the bilayer potential. Indeed the curves in Fig.~\ref{fig:force_6l} are almost identical. Also, the value obtained for the stacking fault energy, 1.58 meV/atom, compares well with 1.53 meV/atom obtained with RPA \cite{Zhou2015}. A detailed comparison is included in Supplementary Table 1. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Mechanical model.} Let us label L$i$ the $i$th layer from the bottom to the top, and let us consider that a force is applied to the right on the upper layer L6, as in the top part of Fig.~\ref{fig:mechanical_model}c. First, L6 moves from B to C without resistance, where it locks with L5. Then, it pushes L5 from A to B, which in turn pushes L4 from B to C. The lower layers have not moved yet. In the next step, L2 and L3 move as well. The transformation is (labeling always from bottom to top): ABABAB$\rightarrow$ABABAC$\rightarrow$ABACBA$\rightarrow$ACBACB. If the direction is reversed, the steps of the transformation are: ABABAB$\rightarrow$ABABCA$\rightarrow$ABCABC. In both cases, RG is obtained. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Transformation calculations.} In Fig.~\ref{fig:force_6l}, in addition to moving the upper layer in steps of $d/12$ along the direction $\theta$ (and fixing it, while relaxing in the perpendicular direction), where $d$ is the bond length, after each step layer $i=2,..,5$ is actually moved as well in $[(i-1)/5]d/12$ (other layers are fully relaxed), giving a configuration closer to the equilibrium position. This gives a more accurate value of the position at which the abrupt changes in the stress take place, and which particular layers slide relative to each other in $y$ or in the perpendicular direction $x$. At $\theta=\ang{0}$ there is a bifurcation of behavior when the big jump occurs (with the upper layer jumping in $-a/2$ for $\theta <0$, and $a/2$ for $\theta>0$). So the result of Fig.~\ref{fig:force_6l}a actually corresponds to $\theta= \ang{0.1}$, to avoid an artificial behavior at $\theta=\ang{0}$. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Fourier interpolation.} \label{sec:Fourier} To obtain the bilayer potential at an arbitrary $\mathbf{r}$ point as in Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_2d}b (see coordinate system there), and to then obtain the phase diagram, the potential was first calculated at a set of $N$ discrete points $\mathbf{r}_i=(x_{\textrm{CM},i},y_{\textrm{CM},i})$ of the upper layer within a primitive cell (separated by $a$/15 along the lattice vectors, with $a=2.46$ \AA\hspace{1mm} the length of the lattice vectors, totaling $N=225$). As mentioned earlier, the interlayer distance and relative coordinates were relaxed. Let $\mathbf{G}$ be a set of $N$ reciprocal lattice vectors around the origin with the symmetry of the crystal. Then, we can write \begin{equation} \begin{split} V(\mathbf{r}) = \frac{1}{N} \sum_\mathbf{G} V_\mathbf{G} e^{i \mathbf{G}.\mathbf{r}} \\ \textrm{with } V_\mathbf{G} = \sum_\mathbf{r_{i}} V(\mathbf{r_i}) e^{-i \mathbf{G}.\mathbf{r_i}} \\ \end{split} \end{equation} \noindent where $\mathbf{r}$ can take any value. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Hydrostatic pressure.} In order to obtain a phase diagram as in Fig.~\ref{fig:phase_diagram}g when there is an external pressure $P$, we have to add an additional term to the enthalpy $H$ defined earlier, resulting in the new enthalpy \begin{equation} H(\mathbf{r}) = V(\mathbf{r}) - \pmb{\tau} \cdot \mathbf{r} A + P z A, \end{equation} \noindent where $z$ is the interlayer distance of the center of mass at pressure $P$. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Acknowledgements} \noindent The authors would like to thank Stony Brook Research Computing and Cyberinfrastructure, and the Institute for Advanced Computational Science at Stony Brook University for access to the high-performance SeaWulf computing system, which was made possible by a \$1.4M National Science Foundation grant (\#1531492). We also acknowledge support from the Graphene Flagship Core 2 grant number 785219 and Agence Nationale de la Recherche under references ANR-17-CE24-0030. This work was performed using HPC resources from GENCI, TGCC, CINES, IDRIS (Grant 2019-A0050901202) and PRACE. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Author Contributions} \noindent The project was conceived by all authors. JP.N. performed the numerical calculations, prepared the figures and wrote the paper with inputs from M.C. and F.M. All authors contributed to the editing of the manuscript. \vspace{0.3cm} \noindent \textbf{Competing Interests} \noindent The authors declare no competing interests. \setcounter{figure}{0} \begin{figure*}[!ht] \begin{figCaption} \centering {\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{coord_6l_xy_both.pdf}} \caption{ \textbf{a}, Change of $y_\textrm{CM}$ and $x_\textrm{CM}$ of each layer, as a function of the center of mass position $y_\textrm{CM}$ of the upper layer (L6), for the 6 layer pairwise model calculation (see Fig.~\ref{fig:force_6l}a). Starting from ABABAB, the upper layer is ``pushed'' along the bond direction: 1/12 of the bond length $d$ is added to $y_{\textrm{CM}}$ of the upper layer in each step, and then the structure is relaxed. The relaxed coordinates are used in the subsequent calculation. In the first sliding steps, layers only move in $y$. After RG is formed, stress increases until the upper layers jumps in $x$ in $a/2$. \textbf{b}, Analogous plot, with $\theta=\ang{15}$. In this case, the structure does not remain fully rhombohedral after the jump in $x$, but is soon recovered after a sliding step in $y$.} \label{fig:coord_6l} \end{figCaption} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*}[h!] \begin{figCaption} \centering {\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{potential_1d_6l.pdf}} \caption{Full-black: Energy of the bilayer system along the armchair direction. Same as in Fig.~\ref{fig:mechanical_model}a. Dotted-blue: Similar calculation with 6 as opposed to 2 layers. The center of mass of the lower layers is fixed in the configuration ABA in all calculations, while the upper 3 layers move (the center of mass of each layer is fixed in each calculation, while other coordinates are relaxed). Labels $m_1$ and $m_2$ correspond to ABABAB and ABACBC, respectively. The energy difference corresponds to a stacking fault energy. M corresponds to ABAACA. The similarity between the curves indicates that the 2 layer potential is a good approximation to analyze how shear affects the stacking order. See Supplementary Table I for a more detailed comparison.} \label{fig:6layer} \end{figCaption} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*}[t] \begin{figCaption} \centering {\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{LDA_fix_rvv10.pdf}} \caption{Energy of the bilayer system along the armchair direction. Full-black: LDA relaxed calculation (same as Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_1d}a). Dashed-red: Fixed z (at the relaxed value of the AB configuration). Dotted-blue: Relaxed rvv10. Although in the AB-AC region the agreement is good, the disagreement between both curves increases as the configuration approaches AA. This is consistent with Supplementary Fig.~\ref{fig:dist_pressure}, which shows the variation of the interlayer distance $z_\textrm{CM}$. $z_\textrm{CM}$ at the small barrier is 3.33 \AA, while at AA is 3.60 \AA. Thus, it is important to relax the configuration. Otherwise, the potential differences are artificially high.} \label{fig:rvv10} \end{figCaption} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*}[t] \begin{figCaption} \centering {\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{zpr.pdf}} \caption{Interlayer distance of the bilayer system along the armchair direction, for various hydrostatic pressures. Full-black: $P=0$. Dotted-blue: $P=$ 1 GPa. Dashed-red: $P=$ 2 GPa. } \label{fig:dist_pressure} \end{figCaption} \end{figure*} \begin{figure* \begin{figCaption} \centering {\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{energies_pr.pdf}} \caption{Plots analogous to those of Fig.~\ref{fig:mechanical_model}a at varying pressures. Full-black: $P=0$ (same as Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_1d}a). Dotted-blue: $P=$ 1 GPa. Dashed-red: $P=$ 2 GPa. Supplementary Fig. 3 shows that fixed $z$ close to AA corresponds to artificial pressures of over 1 GPa.} \label{fig:energy_pressure} \end{figCaption} \end{figure*} \begin{figure* \begin{figCaption} \centering {\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{phase_diagram_pressure.pdf}} \caption{Phase boundaries at different hydrostatic pressures. For each color, the lower line corresponds to the border between the blue and green region of the phase diagram (Fig.~\ref{fig:phase_diagram}g), and the upper curve to the border between the green and orange regions. Blue: $P=0$ (same as in Fig.~\ref{fig:phase_diagram}f). Red: $P$= 2 GPa. In this range of pressures, the values of the curves at $\theta=\ang{0}$ increase linearly with pressure. } \label{fig:force_pressure} \end{figCaption} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*}[!ht] \begin{figCaption} \centering {\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{jumps_vs_Nl.pdf}} \caption{Shear stress on the upper layer as a function of $y_\textrm{CM}$ of the upper layer. The jump of stress, as sliding steps take place, decreases with the number of layers. The jump is also smaller after RG is formed. This can be useful to apply a less varying and more controllable stress. If for example a cantilever is used to move the upper layer, the number of layers of the sample would have to be taken into account to decide on its optimal elastic constant. It can also be seen how the position of the first jump increases linearly with the number of layers.} \end{figCaption} \label{fig:jump} \end{figure*} \newpage \begin{table*}[h] \begin{tabCaption} \caption{Comparison between the 2 layer potential and the 6 layer calculation of Fig.~\ref{fig:potential_1d}, and previous works. Ref.~\cite{Wang2015,Zhou2015} use the adiabatic-connection fluctuation-dissipation theorem within the random phase approximation (ACFDT-RPA). Ref.~\cite{Telling2003} uses anisotropic elasticity theory, revised values for the elastic constants and the experimental data of ref.~\cite{Baker1961,Amelinckx1965}, to obtain an average stacking fault energy of 0.14 meV per interface atom, the same value as the RPA calculation. The difference between the minima (stacking fault energy) is small compared to the barrier $V_\textrm{SP}$ separating them, which implies the 2 layer potential provides a good approximation to study the transformation through shear. {\begin{tabular}{cccc} \hline \hline \multicolumn{1}{l}{} & \multicolumn{3}{c}{Energy (meV/atom)} \\ \multicolumn{1}{l}{} & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}c@{}}2 layer\\ potential \end{tabular} & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}c@{}}6 layer\\ potential\end{tabular} & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}c@{}} Previous \\works \end{tabular} \\ \hline \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}c@{}} Stacking fault\\ Bernal \end{tabular} & 0 & 0.10 & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}c@{}} 0.14 (RPA) \cite{Wang2015} \\ 0.14 (Exp.)\cite{Telling2003} \end{tabular} \\ \hline \\ Small barrier $V_\textrm{SP}$ & 1.58 & 1.59 & 1.53 (RPA) \cite{Zhou2015} \\ \hline \\ Large barrier $V_\textrm{AA}$ & 9.7 & 9.5 & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}c@{}}8.8 (RPA) \cite{Zhou2015} \\ 12.4 (QMC) \cite{Mostaani2015} \end{tabular} \\ \hline \hline \\ \end{tabular}} \\ \end{tabCaption} \label{tab:energies} \end{table*} \clearpage

Despite the success of the multichannel cochlear implant in the treatment of sensorineural hearing loss, less than 10% of potential candidates have received an implant (see, for example, [@CIT0020]). Whilst the growth in demand will add many more implant recipients to the care of audiologists, the profession itself is expected to grow far slower ([@CIT0010]), and significant changes in cochlear implant fitting and management have been anticipated ([@CIT0027]). The purpose of the technology described in this article is to address this capacity challenge for cochlear implant management; that is, to increase access to standard care whilst maintaining hearing outcomes. A critical aspect of cochlear implant management---and often the most time-intensive aspect---is the fitting (or programming) of the device. Principally, the minimum and maximum electric current limits must be set for each output channel (respectively, the T- and C-levels of the 22 channels of Nucleus^®^ devices, collectively the key components of a 'program' or 'MAP'). Electric output requirements can differ markedly across individuals, making fitting all the more important. Should the current limits be set too high, sound can be uncomfortable, distorted, and can ultimately lead to the recipient\'s refusal to use the implant. Should the current limits be set too low, the recipient may fail to achieve any sound perception from the device. Unlike standard audiograms of acoustic hearing, T- and C-levels are far less uniform across cochlear implant recipients. T- and C-levels can depend on factors such as electrode array placement, neural survival differences, and subjective loudness preferences ([@CIT0033]; [@CIT0015]; [@CIT0019]). Indeed, the variability in levels across individuals is most often larger than the dynamic range within individuals. Accordingly, since no default program exists that is immediately usable, audibility is the paramount concern of cochlear implant management. Many fitting methods have been developed since the introduction of the cochlear implant, each method seeking efficacy and efficiency in the optimization of sound quality (e.g. [@CIT0038]; [@CIT0009]; [@CIT0037]; [@CIT0027]). No single method has dominated clinical practice, and clinician preferences are spread amongst various behavioural methods, objective methods (based on electrophysiological measures), and combinations thereof. The assimilation of behavioural and objective methods is evident in a description of fitting by [@CIT0009]: ʽThe decision about the final setting for comfort levels is made based on the child\'s responses, the clinicians' experience with typical levels, and any objective measures results that may be available from the day of surgery. ... The initial goal is for sound to be audible but not too loud, rather than expecting the child to have an ideal sound quality right away." ([@CIT0009], pp. 180--181). ANOVA : Analysis of variance statistical test BKB : Bench-Kowal-Bamford sentences C-level : Comfort level (behavioural) CNC : Consonant nucleus (vowel) consonant words CUNY : City University of New York sentences ECAP : Electrically evoked compound action potential NFS : Nucleus^®^ Fitting Software NRT™ : Neural Response Telemetry RAF : Remote Assistant Fitting SRT : Speech reception threshold T-level : Threshold level (behavioural) In acknowledgment of these clinical practices, the fitting applications presented in this article do not mandate a single fitting approach. The suite of tools presents multiple approaches that can be combined as needed. Since each of these approaches differs in complexity, the suite allows expert clinicians, hearing aid audiologists, recipients, and caregivers to all take part in the fitting process. At its simplest level, the fitting methodology described here uses simple volume, bass, and treble adjustments, operations familiar to users of audio players. At its advanced level, the technology integrates with Custom Sound™, the current 22-channel fitting platform for Nucleus devices. Three developments have led to this fitting design: (1) the evolution of 'streamlined' fitting methods; (2) the development of automatic ECAP threshold measurements; and (3) the development of handheld digital assistants with substantial processing and communications capability. Existing streamlined fitting methods have allowed fewer behavioural measures to be required per program, freeing clinicians and recipients from the time-intensive process of measuring 22 T- and C-levels. Unmeasured levels either take interpolated values ([@CIT0023]) or follow the contour of an ECAP threshold profile ([@CIT0005]; [@CIT0025]; [@CIT0029]). Complementing streamlined methods in Custom Sound is AutoNRT™, which measures ECAP thresholds with no subjective input ([@CIT0003], [@CIT0034]). And most recently, the Nucleus CR110 Remote Assistant has allowed bidirectional communications between a sound processor and a handheld device, providing the opportunity to take fitting to a mobile platform. Mobile health is a rapidly emerging trend in patient care, with the potential to bring concurrent health benefits and economic benefits (for a review, see [@CIT0004]). This article describes a fitting methodology that is implemented on multiple platforms. By implementing AutoNRT on the Nucleus Remote Assistant, both the fitting and surgical monitoring procedures associated with cochlear implant management can be performed on a mobile platform. This technology, *Remote Assistant Fitting*, allows Nucleus 5 recipients to make adjustments to their fittings, and allows clinicians to practise in diverse environments. The same fitting methodology is also implemented for Nucleus Freedom™ and Nucleus 5 systems in a PC application entitled *Nucleus Fitting Software*. This application gives greater functionality to clinicians than Remote Assistant Fitting, but presents a more accessible interface than Custom Sound. Additional tools for home use and surgical use are also described that support the fitting suite. The suite of applications integrates clinicians, recipients, caregivers, and surgeons into the fitting procedure. Design and methods of the fitting suite {#ss2} ======================================= A tiered fitting methodology {#ss3} ---------------------------- Different clinics and hospitals around the world have different levels of audiological capability and capacity. Some have very experienced audiologists who have little familiarity with cochlear implants. Others may have extensive experience with cochlear implants but have a desire to allocate time more efficiently to recipients in most need of care. A tiered fitting methodology allows clinicians to prioritize tasks depending on their resources and the needs of each recipient, beginning with the steps that are most important in achieving an audible program. Whilst the cochlear implant fitting procedure is often described as a number of discrete tasks, the current Nucleus software (Custom Sound) presents the possibilities as a single entity, with all 22 channels visible beside a long list of available operations. The clinician is free to perform tasks in any order. As articulated by [@CIT0009]---and applied by many---audibility is of primary concern in fitting, particularly during the initial few weeks after device activation ('switch-on'). Fine-tuning tasks, such as loudness balancing across frequencies, are often postponed until the recipient becomes more familiar with electric hearing. 'Accurate' measurements at device activation can be very different compared to measurements taken a week later ([@CIT0014]; [@CIT0012]). The tiered fitting methodology draws focus to the relative importance of each individual task. The discrete tasks of the fitting methodology introduced here are, in order: (1) AutoNRT and program initialization; (2) Master Volume; (3) Bass & Treble; (4) Thresholds; and (5) Comfort. The first two tasks provide the all-important requirement of audibility, thus comprising a first tier. The remaining tasks are fine-tuning tasks for optimizing sound quality. With this approach, a program can be created by a single volume adjustment and, over time, progressively evolve through finer, frequency-specific adjustments. ### 1. AutoNRT and program initialization ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [A & B](#F1){ref-type="fig"}) {#ss4} {#F1} Five automatic ECAP thresholds are measured postoperatively, or 22 intraoperatively. T- and C-level profiles---i.e. the shapes of the equal loudness contours of minimum audibility and maximum acceptable loudness---are then approximated by the ECAP threshold contour (cf. [@CIT0002]), measured automatically via AutoNRT. This requires no subjective interaction, initializing a program with the shape (or 'hearing profile') of the T- and C-levels automatically set. The absolute level of the C-level profile is set such that the average C-level is 120CL^[1](#fn1){ref-type="fn"}^, and the average T-level is set at 80CL. At these levels, the program is inaudible for the vast majority of recipients. The average dynamic range per-channel is thus set to 40CL, which is the average dynamic range found in the population^[2](#fn2){ref-type="fn"}^. This program is ready for volume adjustment on first use. The T- and C-level profiles do not follow the ECAP threshold profile exactly. Rather, they are calculated according to the profile scaling method ([@CIT0002]). In this method, C-level profiles are set to be flatter than T-level profiles, since equal loudness contours have been found to be flatter at higher levels of current. If ECAP thresholds cannot be obtained---whether due to the absence of ECAPs in approximately 5% of recipients ([@CIT0006]; [@CIT0034]), or if the user wishes to avoid performing AutoNRT---the ECAP threshold profile shape is replaced with the profile shape of a population mean program^[2](#fn2){ref-type="fn"}^. The population mean profile agrees with similar profiles observed by other investigators, including [@CIT0021], Spivak et al (2010), and [@CIT0035]. ### 2. Master Volume ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [C](#F1){ref-type="fig"}) {#ss5} Master Volume is a new user control that can shift both the T- and C-level profiles simultaneously. If a number of thresholds (T-levels) have been explicitly measured by the clinician elsewhere, Master Volume only shifts the C-level profile, thus respecting the behavioural thresholds. The value of the Master Volume is set to the average C-level. Adjustments are made in steps of 2CL. Furthermore, the Master Volume can only be adjusted when the audio input of the sound processor is active (i.e. the processor\'s microphone is 'live'), and increases can only be made when the processor coil is correctly positioned. Each adjustment is accompanied by a three-channel wide stimulus at C-level, centred on channel 11. Hence, since the program is initialized at low levels, and each small increment must be presented to the recipient, safety is upheld by ensuring the recipient listens to each adjustment before the level can be raised further. When performing pediatric fitting, the stimulus on each adjustment allows the clinician to synchronize the increments with their observations of the child\'s behaviour. The user interface provides guidance on the expected Master Volume level, and this is particularly relevant for pediatric fitting. On a given channel, the ECAP threshold typically lies above T-level and near C-level ([@CIT0005]; [@CIT0013], [@CIT0014]; [@CIT0011]; [@CIT0006]). Thus, in addition to providing an estimate of the equal loudness contour, ECAP thresholds indicate electric levels that are audible. The fitting methodology specifies an expected Master Volume level of 16CL on either side of the mean of the individual\'s ECAP thresholds, and where a population mean program is used, 22CL on either side of 180CL^[2](#fn2){ref-type="fn"}^. These ranges are made visible to the user. ### 3. Bass & Treble ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [D](#F1){ref-type="fig"}) {#ss6} The Bass & Treble controls apply a tilt with an emphasis at either the low frequency or high frequency levels, respectively. Once Master Volume has been set, Bass & Treble represents the first fine-tuning task in the tiered methodology. Bass & Treble adjustments begin to optimize sound quality, addressing descriptions such as 'sound is too boomy'. As with Master Volume, Bass & Treble tilts both the T- and C-level profiles simultaneously, or tilts the C-level profile only if any thresholds (T-levels) have been explicitly measured. The Bass & Treble controls are similar to those suggested by [@CIT0028]. Bass & Treble controls are initially set to zero, and can only be tilted in steps of 2CL at the extremities of the electrode array. Bass & Treble can take on positive and negative values, and are limited to ± 30CL at the extremities. Each adjustment is accompanied by a three-channel wide stimulus at C-level, centred on channel 20 for Bass and channel 3 for Treble. Sequential increases cannot occur until this stimulus is delivered. The precise calculations of the AutoNRT, Master Volume, and Bass & Treble processes are described in greater detail by [@CIT0001]. ### 4. Thresholds ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [E](#F1){ref-type="fig"}) {#ss7} Whilst a default dynamic range of 40CL is considered appropriate here for most recipients, threshold measurements can improve sound quality for those recipients who find the perception of soft sounds problematic. Threshold measurements are not mandatory, because the Master Volume and Bass & Treble controls can adjust T- and C-levels simultaneously, preserving the average per-channel dynamic range of 40CL. When thresholds are measured on specific electrodes (using a single electrode stimulus), the T-level profile is smoothly shaped^[3](#fn3){ref-type="fn"}^ to pass through the measurements. ### 5. Comfort ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [F](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). {#ss8} The Comfort task allows a quick sweep of C-levels, identifying regions of the profile contour that are too soft or too loud. The channels of the system are divided into eight frequency bands. Initiating the Comfort task results in three-channel wide stimuli at C-level across the bands. The sweep can be stopped at any stage to adjust the levels of a band within a range of ± 30CL. As for Master Volume and Bass & Treble, Comfort adjustments can affect both the T- and C-level profiles simultaneously, or adjust the C-level profile only if any thresholds (T-levels) have been explicitly measured. The Comfort task is intended to be a simple check for rare anomalies that cause significant sound distortion or discomfort. Master Volume, Bass, Treble, and Comfort adjustments observe profile scaling calculations. As such, when profiles are raised they are progressively flattened and frequency-selective adjustments (such as a Bass adjustment, or a particular Comfort band adjustment) affect T-levels greater than C-levels (by a factor of 1.25). A multiplatform design {#ss9} ---------------------- Given these five main tasks of the fitting methodology, the suite of tools spreads the fitting process across three platforms, with each platform presenting more fitting tasks to the clinician than the previous. In order, the platforms are: ### 1. Remote Assistant Fitting (RAF; [Figure 2](#F2){ref-type="fig"}) {#ss10} {#F2} Fitting is performed on the Nucleus CR110 Remote Assistant, and includes the AutoNRT, Master Volume, and Bass & Treble tasks ([Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [A--D](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). These tasks can be performed by a clinician, adult recipient, or caregiver, because they are either automated or analogous to audio player use. As a mobile fitting platform, RAF allows fitting to take place wirelessly in the recipient\'s everyday listening environment (as discussed later, this can be particularly relevant for pediatric fitting). ### 2. Nucleus Fitting Software (NFS; [Figure 3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}) {#ss11} {#F3} This PC application supports the exact same methodology as RAF, but presents it with recipient management functionality (e.g. personal information and past programs) and a more detailed user interface. NFS also includes the additional Thresholds (on three channels, [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [E](#F1){ref-type="fig"}) and Comfort tasks (on eight bands, [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, [F](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). NFS is designed to be visually and descriptively familiar to both hearing-aid audiologists and cochlear implant practitioners. ### 3. Custom Sound {#ss12} Full customization remains available via Custom Sound, allowing the small percentage of difficult-to-fit recipients access to fine-grained audiological care. Any RAF or NFS program can be viewed and modified in Custom Sound. Programs created using RAF or NFS use the existing default sound processing parameters of Custom Sound (such as a 900 Hz per-channel stimulation rate). In turn however, almost all Custom Sound programs can be adjusted with RAF and NFS^[4](#fn4){ref-type="fn"}^ using the sound processing parameters that were set in Custom Sound, even if not default. Most importantly, Master Volume and Bass & Treble adjustments can be made on these programs, both in RAF (enabled at the discretion of the clinician) and in NFS. The intention of the multiplatform tiering is to enable accessible fitting. Fitting sessions, including switch-on, can happen on both mobile and desktop platforms, whether inside or outside a clinic. After switch-on, recipients and caregivers can make simple adjustments without repeated visits to a clinic. As listening experience grows, further fine-tuning can be made in NFS or in Custom Sound as needed. Tools for home and surgical care {#ss13} -------------------------------- Completing the fitting suite are two tools: one for home use and one for surgical use. Firstly, myCochlear is a desktop application that allows recipients and caregivers to run regular Ling sound tests at home, and by connecting the Nucleus CR110 Remote Assistant to a PC, caregivers can also monitor the hours of usage of an implant system. This data can then be shared with a clinic online. Hence, clinicians can monitor usage and system alerts remotely, distributing routine checks away from the clinic. Secondly, the Nucleus CR120 Intraoperative Remote Assistant performs handheld, cable-free intraoperative AutoNRT on all 22 electrodes, and also offers a continuous electrode impedance mode. When AutoNRT is performed during surgery using the recipient\'s own sound processor, the ECAP threshold profile is ready for use at switch-on. Fitting, in this scenario, is reduced to a single Master Volume adjustment after surgery. At the time of writing, regulatory approval was being sought for the suite of products from a number of regulatory bodies worldwide. Fitting methodology trial results in summary {#ss14} ============================================ Two trials of the Remote Assistant Fitting and Nucleus Fitting Software methodologies have been completed: a clinician fit trial and a recipient fit trial. Preliminary reports of these trials have been presented by [@CIT0017], [@CIT0018]). The results from the trials to date are collated and summarized below. The subjects in both trials were all adult, postlingually deaf Nucleus CI24RE implantees, and all were experienced users of their implants (a range of between one and five years). Both trials were performed under the approval of ethics committees, and each subject signed a prior informed consent form. Clinician fit trial {#ss15} ------------------- ### Materials and Methods {#ss16} The clinician fit trial compared the speech performance outcomes of three methodologies: those of RAF, NFS, and Custom Sound. Thirteen subjects participated in the clinical evaluation. Each subject received three new programs to evaluate: (1) a program created using the RAF methodology (AutoNRT on five electrodes, Master Volume, and Bass & Treble); (2) a program created using the NFS methodology (additional Thresholds and Comfort measurements); and (3) a program created using the full 22 T- and C-levels available in Custom Sound. For all three programs, sound processing parameters such as stimulation rate were manually set to match each subject\'s everyday program, but for the Custom Sound program, the T- and C-levels were set without observing the levels of each subject\'s everyday program (hence unbiased). All three programs were fitted by an experienced cochlear implant audiologist. The order of the three fittings, and the allocation of the three programs to sound processor positions, were balanced across subjects and randomly allocated to subjects (for example, of the six permutations of fitting ordering, five permutations were randomly allocated two subjects and one permutation was randomly allocated three subjects). Both the subjects and the investigators were blind to the program positions on each sound processor. Subjects evaluated the three programs for a two week trial period, alternating between programs daily. Speech perception testing was subsequently performed, including: (1) CNC words at 60 dB SPL in quiet (100 words per program); (2) CNC words at 50 dB SPL in quiet (100 words); and (3) BKB sentences at 65 dB SPL in speech babble noise (32 sentences). The CNC lists were based on the original tests developed by [@CIT0022]. For the sentence tests, the signal-to-noise (SNR) ratio was adapted until an SNR corresponding to a score of 50% words correct was determined ([@CIT0008]). This SNR is the speech reception threshold (SRT) for each subject. Programs were tested in random order, balanced across subjects. At the end of the two week trial period, subjects were also asked to provide a preference for any of the three programs, if such a preference was held. The subjects indicated their preference by program position on the sound processor, blind to the fitting method of each program. Finally, the RAF C-level profiles and the NFS T- and C-level profiles were compared to the Custom Sound T- and C-level profiles (which are measured channel by channel). The chosen measure of a profile\'s goodness of fit was the root mean square (RMS) difference, calculated across the channels of each profile as a percentage (%DR) of the Custom Sound dynamic range at each channel (following [@CIT0023]; [@CIT0002]). The means of each profile are first offset to be zero for the comparisons. Since the RAF T-level profiles are a fixed offset from the C-level profiles, the RAF T-levels are not directly compared. ### Results {#ss17} The group mean results are shown in [Figure 4](#F4){ref-type="fig"}. One-way repeated-measures ANOVA tests showed no significant differences between the three programs in any of the test conditions (60 dB CNC words: *p* = 0.18; 50 dB CNC words: *p* = 0.89; BKB sentences: *p* = 0.34). For each of the test conditions, the confidence intervals of the mean speech perception differences between programs are shown in [Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}. {#F4} ###### Group mean differences in speech perception test results between the Remote Assistant Fitting (RAF) and Custom Sound (CS) fitting methods, and between the Nucleus Fitting Software (NFS) and Custom Sound (CS) fitting methods, all fitted by an experienced cochlear implant audiologist. The means of the differences and the 95% confidence intervals (CI) of the means of the differences are given. For the sentence tests, a lower speech reception threshold indicates better speech perception in noise. *60 dB CNC words (% correct)* *50 dB CNC words (% correct)* *65 dB BKB sentences (dB SRT)* ----------- ------------------------------- ------------------------------- -------------------------------- ---------------- ---------- ---------------- RAF -- CS 2.5% \[− 1.8, 6.9\] 1.2% \[− 5.8, 8.1\] 0.1 dB \[1.3, − 1.1\] NFS -- CS 3.5% \[− 1.0, 7.9\] 0.2% \[− 3.8, 4.3\] − 0.5 dB \[0.3, − 1.6\] Within-subject speech perception word scores were analysed using χ^2^ tests (and their associated post hoc analyses of residuals). The calculations of this approach agree with the binomial models of [@CIT0032] and [@CIT0007]. To compare SRTs, an estimate of the SRT standard deviation was made from the data, following the method of [@CIT0024]. Across the subjects and test conditions (39 combinations in total), the RAF programs were significantly better (*p* \< 0.05) in two of the 39 individual tests and significantly poorer in one (a range of + 15% to − 22%, as compared to the mean score of the other two programs); the NFS programs were significantly poorer in one individual test (− 15%) and the Custom Sound programs were significantly better in one individual test and significantly poorer in two (+ 16%, − 19% and + 5.3 dB respectively). Consistent with the speech perception testing, no statistically significant difference was found in the subjective program preferences of the subjects in a χ^2^ test. Across the 13 subjects, the median RMS difference of the RAF C-level profiles was 13%DR. The median RMS differences of both the NFS T-level profiles and the NFS C-level profiles were 12%DR. In the study of [@CIT0023], the median RMS difference of a streamlined fitting method using interpolation between three T-levels and three C-levels was found to be between 10--20%DR. The RAF and NFS results are consistent with this range. Recipient fit trial {#ss18} ------------------- ### Materials and Methods {#ss19} The recipient fit trial compared the speech perception outcomes of two methodologies: (1) a program created using the RAF methodology, *fitted by the subject*; and (2) a program created using the full 22 T- and C-levels available in Custom Sound, *fitted by an experienced cochlear implant audiologist*. For both programs, sound processing parameters such as stimulation rate were manually set to match each subject\'s everyday program, but for the Custom Sound program, the T- and C-levels were set without observing the levels of each subject\'s everyday program (hence unbiased). Before creating programs using the RAF methodology, subjects principally watched a five minute demonstration video of the method and received no clinician intervention during the fitting. As for the clinician fitted trial, the recipient fit trial was double blind and program orderings were balanced and randomized. Twenty-four subjects participated in the recipient fit trial. Depending on the time availability of each subject, 12 subjects participated in a shorter protocol consisting of fitting and acute speech perception testing in the one session (Group A), and 12 subjects participated in a longer protocol that involved two weeks of take home experience and subsequent speech perception testing (Group B). Group A completed CNC word tests at 60 dB SPL in quiet (100 words per program). Group B completed the same CNC word tests as for the clinician fit trial (60 dB and 50 dB SPL in quiet) and also completed CUNY sentence tests at 65 dB SPL in speech babble noise (60 sentences). For each subject, the noise level was manually set to avoid scores that were too high or too low. Once selected, each subject\'s noise level was held constant across the two programs, allowing comparisons of the speech perception scores. The RMS differences between the RAF C-level profiles and the Custom Sound C-level profiles were calculated for all 24 subjects. The 12 subjects of Group B also indicated a preference for either of the two programs, if such a preference was held. ### Results {#ss20} The group mean results are shown in [Figure 5](#F5){ref-type="fig"}. Paired *t*-tests showed no significant differences between the two programs in any of the test conditions (Group A 60 dB CNC words: *p* = 0.14; Group B 60 dB CNC words: *p* = 0.52; Group B 50 dB CNC words: *p* = 0.75; Group B CUNY sentences: *p* = 0.62). For each of the test conditions, the confidence intervals of the mean speech perception differences between programs are shown in [Table 2](#T2){ref-type="table"}. Across the subjects and test conditions (48 combinations in total), the RAF programs were significantly better (*p* \< 0.05 in χ^2^ tests) in five of the 48 individual tests (a range of 14--22%) and the Custom Sound programs were significantly better in three individual tests (a range of 17--23%). {#F5} ###### Group mean differences (percentage of words correct) in speech perception test results between the Remote Assistant Fitting (RAF) method, as fitted by a recipient, and the Custom Sound (CS) fitting method, as fitted by an experienced cochlear implant audiologist. The means of the differences and the 95% confidence intervals (CI) of the means of the differences are given. *60 dB CNC words (Group A)* *60 dB CNC words (Group B)* *50 dB CNC words (Group B)* *65 dB CUNY sentences (Group B)* ----------- ----------------------------- ----------------------------- ----------------------------- ---------------------------------- ------ ---------------- ------ ----------------- RAF -- CS 3.3% \[− 1.3, 7.9\] 1.4% \[− 3.2, 6.0\] 1.1% \[− 6.2, 8.4\] 1.9% \[− 6.4, 10.3\] Of the 12 Group B subjects, no statistically significant difference was found in the subjective program preferences of the subjects in a χ^2^ test. Across the 24 subjects, the median RMS difference of the RAF C-level profiles was 19% DR. Discussion {#ss21} ========== The results of both the clinician fit trial and the recipient fit trial demonstrated equivalent speech perception scores using the new fitting methodology. This was observed in the 95% confidence intervals of the speech perception differences between methodologies ([Tables 1](#T1){ref-type="table"} and [2](#T2){ref-type="table"}). The lower bounds of the mean word score differences for the CNC word and CUNY sentence test conditions ranged between − 1.0% to − 6.4%. [@CIT0016], for example, considered a − 4.6% word score difference to be clinically insignificant (without indicating a difference that would be deemed significant). Despite the lack of standards on word score differences that are important clinically, our group mean results give high confidence that the new fitting methodology does not provide diminished speech performance outcomes. In a few individual speech perception tests, Custom Sound programs delivered significantly better results in some instances and significantly poorer results in other instances. This would be expected of any given clinical trial for which the outcomes of each of the methodologies were more or less equivalent. Furthermore, no statistically significant differences were observed in the subjective program preferences of the subjects. The RMS differences in program levels of the RAF and NFS programs, as compared to the Custom Sound programs, were consistent with Plant et al\'s (2005) three-channel interpolated programs (median RMS differences between 10--20% DR). This is to be expected given the RAF and NFS fitting methodologies: they effectively use three behavioural measures (Master Volume, Bass & Treble) and, in the case of NFS, three T-levels. [@CIT0023] found no significant differences between three-channel interpolated programs and 22-channel Custom Sound programs in group speech perception scores, thus recommending the three-channel interpolated programs for clinical use. It should not be surprising that group equivalence can be achieved with an ECAP-based methodology (though the full methodology here mixes ECAP and behavioural measures). Evaluations of speech perception have been performed previously using ECAP-based programs, across numerous languages ([@CIT0026]; [@CIT0029]; [@CIT0031]; [@CIT0036]; [@CIT0021]). Across the studies, either group equivalence or small differences have been observed in each test scenario. Each study concluded that ECAP-based programs could be successfully used, particularly in pediatric fitting. The ECAP-based fitting method used in RAF and NFS differs from previous methods in three ways: (1) it combines key elements of the three Custom Sound ECAP-based methods into a single method; (2) it uses the profile scaling technique ([@CIT0002]); and (3) it automatically combines behavioural measures with ECAP measures, allowing programs to evolve as extra measures are made. RAF and NFS combine elements of the 'objective offset' method, 'progressive MAPs' method, and 'shift and tilt' methods of Custom Sound ([@CIT0005]; [@CIT0025]; [@CIT0029], respectively). By using an ECAP threshold profile and setting the Master Volume based on a C-level stimulus at each adjustment (in addition to live sound), the objective offset method is largely replicated. By using a fixed dynamic range when thresholds have not been measured, and by allowing a Master Volume control that can adjust profiles by at least 30CL, an alternative is provided to the four-program progressive MAPs method. And finally, by adjusting Master Volume and Bass & Treble controls whilst live, the shift and tilt method is replicated. The fitting suite implements the ECAP-based profile scaling improvements of [@CIT0002]. In their 42 subject study, the technique was compared to the existing objective offset method of Custom Sound. Significant improvements in program levels (as compared to behavioural levels) and subjective preferences were found. Adding to the results of [@CIT0002], the results of the present article, with profile scaling included, demonstrated equivalent speech performance outcomes using the ECAP-based fitting methodology. The additional two tasks included in NFS, Thresholds and Comfort, allow behavioural measures to be quickly overlaid upon the ECAP-based program. Essentially, the technology evolves the program, whether ECAP-based or otherwise, towards the new behavioural measures as they are taken. An audiologist even has the option to bypass the ECAP-based method and go directly to the Thresholds and Comfort tasks in NFS, fitting the recipient in a conventional streamlined fitting paradigm ([@CIT0023]). Giving the flexibility to fit in a number of ways without compromising efficacy is the foremost design principle of the suite. Another key motivation of the suite is to enable mobile cochlear implant management. By giving recipients and caregivers (at the discretion of the clinician) a greater level of program control via the mobile platform (specifically, the Master Volume and Bass & Treble controls), fewer minor adjustments are anticipated of the clinician in general. Additional studies are needed to quantify the efficiency gains of the mobile platform. Furthermore, both the (mobile) clinician and the recipient can test programs immediately in the recipient\'s normal listening environment, potentially avoiding a number of unnecessary follow-up clinic visits. The next generation of fitting distils the most salient aspects of the fitting procedure, such that it can be presented on a handheld device. This multiplatform trend is ever-present in digital technology today. Applications are routinely made available for desktop, tablet, and smartphone platforms, each with a progressively less complex interface, yet each operating on the same data. The suite of applications presented in this article follow the same architecture. As an illustration of the purpose of a mobile platform, it is worth considering the specific example of a pediatric switch-on. Many clinics make two clinicians available for switch-on: one in close proximity to the child, engaging the child in an activity, and another to operate the PC fitting application. The key objective of the switch-on is to achieve audibility: essentially the Master Volume task. Using RAF, the clinician simply presses the up button on Master Volume repeatedly. Each press gives a stimulus at C-level, allowing the one clinician to observe behavioural changes without looking at a screen, worrying about cables or being confined to any one room. In addition to its multiplatform design, the suite broadens access to the fitting procedure by using terminology that is neither cochlear implant nor hearing-aid specific. In the particular case of RAF, the terminology is analogous to that of an audio player (Master Volume, Bass & Treble). Thus, it is anticipated that RAF is readily usable by both recipients who are new to cochlear implantation and experienced recipients. Whilst the experienced subjects of the recipient fit trial had to accustom themselves to RAF\'s generic terminology, all subjects were able to do so with minimal training (a five minute video). Recipients who do not prefer self-fitting---whether experienced or not---have multiple avenues within the suite to access audiological care (including clinician use of RAF). Ultimately, the technology described in this article opens cochlear implant management to a wider community of contributors. With surgeons, caregivers and recipients able to regularly contribute data to the clinician, clinicians can have the visibility and the capacity to focus on recipients who need the most care, and to improve access to a high standard of audiological care more generally. Conclusions {#ss22} =========== The fitting methodology trials of the suite demonstrated equivalent speech perception outcomes when compared to current best practice. As such, the new technology has the potential to expand the capacity of audiological care without compromising efficacy, and may facilitate greater recipient self-care using a mobile fitting platform. By combining several behavioural and objective methods, the design of the fitting suite offers the flexibility to fit quickly or to fit in detail, beginning with the steps that are most important in achieving an audible program. Accordingly, the next generation of Nucleus fitting applications open cochlear implant management to a wider number of clinicians, recipients, caregivers and surgeons. The authors thank Jane Cockburn and Barry Alderton for their insights and suggestions on the manuscript. The authors thank the clinicians who assisted with the fitting sessions and data collection, especially: Komal Arora, Jillian Crosson, Justin Pirano, Esti Nel, Catherine Morgan, and Marian Jones. They also thank their subjects who were, as always, exceptionally generous with their time. ***Declaration of interest:*** The authors are contractors or employees of Cochlear Limited, the manufacturer of the technology described in the article. Notes ===== 1\. Levels are specified on a current level (CL) scale. For the Nucleus CI24RE and Nucleus 5 implant, *I* (μA) = 17.5 × 100^CL/255^. Each current level step (1CL) is a 0.16 dB change in current. 2\. Based on data from 659 recipients at two large cochlear implant Australian clinics. 3\. Cubic interpolation is used, rather than linear interpolation. The validity of interpolation depends upon the similarity in T- and C-levels at neighbouring electrodes, which is reasonable with broad current spread. Hence, only monopolar stimulation modes are supported by the methodology. 4\. Specifically, programs that use monopolar stimulation modes, default channel-to-electrode mappings, a single pulse width across all channels and at least 12 active electrodes.

*Dear Editor,* We have read the article published in your journal written by Sofian et al., entitled "the serum profile of Th1 and Th2 cytokines in treated and non-treated HCV infected individuals" ([@A8067R1]). Evidences well documented that the simultaneous elevation of Th1 and Th2 related cytokines during HCV infection may indicate that both (Thl and Th2) cytokine profiles are involved in the pathogenesis of the diseases ([@A8067R2]). Moreover, this activated T cell response in HCV infected patients could be regulated by treatment protocols ([@A8067R3]). Sofian et al.'s data provides some additional evidence for the involvement of cellular immune response in HCV infections arrest ([@A8067R1]). Accordingly, based on the importance of serum profile of Th1 and Th2 cytokines in HCV infected patients, the authors raised the interesting idea that there might be an association between these cytokines and HCV ([@A8067R1]). Authors of the present letter believe that Sofian and co-workers' results need to be interpreted with more cautious, because possible puzzles and limitations of their early concepts of Th1 and Th2 cytokines need to be reconsidered. It is almost widely accepted that in addition to Th2 cell type, IL-10 is produced by a broad variety of other cell types including activated macrophages as well as B and T regulatory (Treg) lymphocytes ([@A8067R4]). Similarly, IL-2 is also reported to be secreted from all lymphoid cell types in one side and is considered as a common growth factor, in an autocrine and paracrine fashion, for all lymphocytes on the other side ([@A8067R5]). Therefore, it seems that Sofian et al. cytokines classifications were not accurately defined and need to be reconsidered. Furthermore, authors used the general word \"profile\" in the title of their article, but they only analyzed two cytokines in Th1 and Th2 classes. Thus, it does not mean that they studied the whole Th1 and Th2 cytokines profiles in the study. Additionally, the authors have not discussed their results properly. Their results have demonstrated that the serum levels of both inflammatory (IFN-γ and IL-2) and anti-inflammatory (IL-4 and IL-10) cytokines were higher in HCV infected patients in comparison with controls ([@A8067R1]). It has been established that cytokines are fit in a network and alteration in expression of a cytokine can affect others ([@A8067R6]). Hence, the results of Sofial et al. may reveal that HCV induces expression of IFN-γ and IL-2 as inflammatory responses and, subsequently, the inflammatory cytokines induce expression of anti-inflammatory cytokines to regulate immune hypersensitivity ([@A8067R4]). On the other hand, treatment of HCV infected patients led to decrease of the cytokines ([@A8067R1]). Hence, it could be concluded that the declined cytokines expression may possibly be related to the following two mechanisms: 1) the effect of chemical drugs on the immune responses and 2) The decrease of immune system activation due to the Inhibition of HCV replication. **Please cite this paper as:** Noroozi Karimabad M, Hassanshahi G, Arababadi MK. Controversial Concepts Regarding T Helper 1 and T Helper 2 Cytokines in Hepatitis C Virus Infected Patients. Hepat Mon. 2013;13(5):e8067. DOI: 10.5812/hepatmon.8067 **Authors' Contribution:** All of authors were involved in all steps of the manuscript preparation. **Financial Disclosure:** There is no financial disclosure for declaration.

1. Introduction {#s1} =============== Upper limb motor function is commonly degraded with aging and is often impaired due to neurologic injuries such as stroke and spinal cord injury. Of the 658,000 stroke survivors in the U.S. annually, approximately 60% of stroke survivors experience significant impairments in hand function, requiring long-term rehabilitative therapy to regain function (Dam et al., [@B11]). There are few interventions that improve upper limb function. A lack of experimental tools and procedures has been a barrier in studying neuromodulation in response to peripheral mechanical stimulation that is analogous to physical therapy for individuals with hemiparesis. 1.1. Paired Associative Stimulation for Neural Facilitation ----------------------------------------------------------- Neural excitability of the motor cortex is essential for activating muscles, but is often compromised in hemiparetic stroke survivors, while modulation of this excitability can facilitate motor learning and recovery (Hummel and Cohen, [@B20]; Kim et al., [@B29]; Jung and Ziemann, [@B21]; Lazzaro et al., [@B37]; Teo et al., [@B61]). Excitability of the motor cortex is modulated by a repetition of electrical stimulation (Estim) to a peripheral nerve (e.g., median nerve) alone or paired with central brain stimulation known as Paired Associative Stimulation (PAS) (Stefan, [@B56]; Wolters et al., [@B65]; Meunier et al., [@B43]; Kennedy and Carson, [@B27]; Carson and Kennedy, [@B6]). Excitability of the primary motor cortex (M1) can be potentiated in the long term (approximately 1 h) after a repetition of a conventional form of PAS, i.e., application of Estim to the peripheral nerve (e.g., median nerve) with an appropriate time interval immediately (approximately 25 ms) before transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to M1 (termed Estim-PAS in this paper) in experimental studies (Stefan, [@B56]; Wolters et al., [@B65]; Meunier et al., [@B43]; Kennedy and Carson, [@B27]; Carson and Kennedy, [@B6]). In a therapeutic analogy, as an emerging effective rehabilitation for hemiparetic stroke survivors, a repetition of a manual application of mechanical stimulation (Mstim) to the target muscles (e.g., tendon tapping or rapid muscle stretch) by a therapist immediately before a contraction effort of a patient (termed Mstim-paired manual therapy in this paper) can facilitate neuromotor recovery and often lead to significantly better rehabilitation outcomes compared with the conventional rehabilitation without Mstim (Kawahira et al., [@B25], [@B23], [@B24]; Shimodozono et al., [@B53]; Kawakami et al., [@B26]; Matsumoto et al., [@B42]). One of the difficulties of stroke rehabilitation is that neurorehabilitation efficacy is variable (Langhorne et al., [@B34]; Pollock et al., [@B48]; Veerbeek et al., [@B64]). Since a repeated application of PAS can result in facilitation or inhibition of neural excitability depending on the timing interval of stimulations, determination of the appropriate inter-stimulus interval (ISI) is crucial for inducing facilitation (Poon et al., [@B49]; Kumpulainen et al., [@B31]). ISI is the period of time that separates two consecutive stimuli (Pereira et al., [@B47]). In the conventional form of PAS (i.e., Estim-PAS), ISI is the timing difference between Estim and TMS. Neural plasticity via Hebbian learning is assumed to be induced through the repetition of paired associative excitatory inputs to M1, one originating from the stimulation of the somatosensory system (afferents) and another from TMS or motor effort of an individual in response to therapist\'s instruction (Takeuchi and Izumi, [@B59]) that arrives at M1 shortly after the peripheral stimulation. The time interval between two paired inputs is critical to the consequence of PAS and likely other therapeutic techniques (Wolters et al., [@B66]; Takeuchi and Izumi, [@B59]). Since the scientific mechanisms for this promising emerging Mstim-paired manual therapy are not well understood, the time interval between the peripheral Mstim by a therapist and central motor effort by a patient is undefined and thus can be variable. Individual differences in signal transduction times due to various anatomical and physiological characteristics such as body size and composition, sex, and age (Soudmand et al., [@B55]; Buschbacher, [@B5]; Fulöp et al., [@B16]) may influence the timing-dependent profiles of neural excitability and thus the effectiveness of Mstim-paired manual therapy. Anecdotally, physical therapists skilled in this clinical practice are able to adjust the stimulation intervals by observing responses in a patient based on their experience. However, this heuristic approach is unfortunately not fully generalizable. As a result, Mstim-paired rehabilitation has been difficult to standardize. Hence, it is imperative to develop an efficient method that helps determine the appropriate range of ISI for inducing neuromodulation in Mstim-paired manual therapy or Mstim-PAS for each individual. In addition, it is reported that this neuromodulation effectiveness is dependent on the particular phase of the sleep-wake/circadian cycle (Cohen et al., [@B10]; Lee et al., [@B38]). 1.2. Characterization of Mstim-Induced Neuromodulation ------------------------------------------------------ Potentiated synaptic excitability of M1 is assessed with the amplitude of motor evoked potential (MEP) via unpaired single-pulse TMS. Induced potentiation at this motor system level is analogous to the long-term potentiation (LTP) at the synaptic level, i.e., strengthened excitatory synapses due to repetitive timing-dependent excitation of presynaptic and postsynaptic neurons (Hebbian model) (Hebb, [@B19]; Bliss and Collingridge, [@B3]; Markram, [@B41]). At the synaptic level, LTP can be induced only when the postsynaptic neurons are excited immediately after the excitation of presynaptic neurons. Similarly, the largest and most consistent facilitation of M1 via neuromodulation is induced when cortical stimulation is applied 2--5 ms after the arrival of the Estim-induced sensory signal at the somatosensory cortex (Stefan, [@B56]; Stefan et al., [@B57]; Ziemann, [@B67]; Müller et al., [@B46]). With Estim, the arrival time can be determined for each individual with the first negative peak around 20 ms latency (N20) in somatosensory evoked potentials recorded through electroencephalography (EEG) (Wolters et al., [@B65]; Müller et al., [@B46]). The critical issue is that Estim-PAS can induce inhibition if the brain is stimulated 5--10 ms before the arrival of the sensory signal (Wolters et al., [@B65]; Ziemann, [@B67]; Müller et al., [@B46]). For example, Wolters et al. previously utilized the N20-P25 somatosensory evoked potential (SSEP) complex to evaluate the effect of PAS timing on neural plasticity (Wolters et al., [@B66]). The latency of the complex is important to clinical applications of PAS, as changes of even 15 ms in timing can reverse the direction of the neuromodulation (Wolters et al., [@B66]). Hence, the consequent neuromodulation with this type of paired stimulation can be inverted due to a subtle timing deviation. Depending on stimulation intensity, Estim often causes a painful sensation. In addition, PAS with electrical stimulation requires tight synchronization between TMS and electrical nerve stimulation, needing skilled operators and long calibration time. In contrast, Mstim is more applicable and relevant to the actual clinical practice and desired muscle activity. Moreover, Mstim allows access to various muscles that cannot be individually accessed via electrical nerve stimulation. As a simpler paradigm before this combined long-term effect is investigated, however, there are few studies that examined instantaneous and transient modulation of excitability of M1 due to Mstim. In Estim, excitability of M1 is inhibited at a latency of 19--50 ms, known as short-latency afferent inhibition (Tokimura et al., [@B62]), likely due to the direct thalamocortical projections to M1 via cholinergic paramedian thalamic nuclei (Lazzaro et al., [@B35]) and the projections from the primary sensory cortex to M1 (Ferezou et al., [@B15]; Aronoff et al., [@B1]), which recruit M1 interneurons that inhibit layer V pyramidal neurons (Lazzaro et al., [@B35], [@B36]). In contrast, Mstim of the periphery in the form of muscle stretch often produces transcortical long-latency stretch reflex with 50--150 ms latencies Rothwell et al. ([@B51]); Shinohara et al. ([@B54]), suggesting the induction of long-latency facilitation of M1. Impact-based Mstim to the muscle-tendon complex can stimulate various mechanoreceptors in the skin, tendon, muscle, and joint. These afferent inputs induced by Mstim can project to various supraspinal pathways other than those with Estim, potentially leading to not only net facilitation but also net inhibition of M1 in a latency-dependent manner. While long-term neuromodulation can be induced after a repetition of Estim-PAS or Mstim-paired manual therapy with an appropriate timing interval, a single application of peripheral stimulation can also induce transient neuromodulation in a time-dependent manner. The time-dependent profiles of neuromodulation in response to impact-based Mstim of muscles have been understudied because of the absence of a versatile and reliable mechanical stimulator that allows for timing adjustment. A combination of TMS and impact-based Mstim by using a high-timing-precision robotic tendon tapping device (Lacey et al., [@B32], [@B33]; Ueda et al., [@B63]) was adopted to enable the exploration into Mstim-induced neuromodulation as shown in [Figure 1A](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. In this study, MEPs were measured via electromyogram (EMG) of the FCR muscle to observe Mstim-induced neuromodulation as shown in [Figure 1A](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. This configuration that pairs Mstim and TMS enables investigation of neuromodulation via different afferent nerve stimulation from one studied by using the conventional conditioned stimulation with Estim and TMS (Chen et al., [@B7]; Tokimura et al., [@B62]; Tamburin et al., [@B60]; Bikmullina et al., [@B2]; Devanne et al., [@B14]; Kojima et al., [@B30]). The form of mechanical tendon tapping will not induce joint motion unlike other work that utilized rapid joint extension as Mstim (Day et al., [@B12]). {#F1} 1.3. Need for Individually Adjusting Mstim and TMS Timings ---------------------------------------------------------- Due to the generally large variability in ISI windows (ISI-W) for observing Mstim-enhanced MEP in individuals, an adjustment procedure must be performed before actual neuroscientific research in every single subject. ISI-W can also vary depending on the experimental arrangement, including mechanical variability associated with the tested muscle and employed Mstim. Mstim is an indirect method to stimulate the peripheral sensory organs by applying physical perturbation in the form of transient changes in pressure, velocity and acceleration in the target peripheral tissues. These processes introduce additional dynamic factors, which lead to delayed and variable responses, such as skin and tendon stretch dynamics, muscle spindle discharge timings associated with the human sensorimotor system dynamics, in addition to air pressure propagation and development in the pneumatic system associated with the mechanical tendon tapping system. The method of evaluating all responses across the set range and interval for identifying the ISI-W requires many data samples, which is laborious to the recipient of stimulation and makes the collection of a large data set time-consuming. For example, in the authors previous study (Kim et al., [@B28]), the initial range of ISIs for Mstim sub-threshold TMS neuromodulation was uniformly given to be 250 ms for all subjects where 12 Mstim trials were applied for 5 ms increments, totaling 600 Mstim trials. Including variable rest breaks between trials, average duration to complete data collection for each individual to determine the ISI-MEP profile was approximately 2 h (see section Experimental Procedure). 1.4. Our Approach ----------------- The goal of the current work is to develop statistical sampling and regression methods to efficiently model transient neuromodulations in the motor cortex via impact-based Mstim to muscles by means of a high-timing-precision robotic mechanical stimulator and its paired cortical stimulation. An experimental identification of the exact timing and magnitude of neuromodulation in M1 of an individual usually requires many test trials at different ISIs to individualize stimulation timings. To mitigate this issue, the proposed procedure estimates individual ISI-W with sub-threshold TMS and Mstim. Statistical sampling and regression with relatively large time intervals (e.g., 5 ms) approximates the profile of Mstim-enhanced MEP with a reduced number of stimulation trials. 2. Materials and Methods {#s2} ======================== 2.1. Design and Assessment of High-Timing Precision Tendon Tapping Robot ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Msim-induced neuromodulation has not been well studied because of the absence of a basic mechanistic theory for this promising rehabilitation and a robust reliable system to implement interval-controlled Mstim. Compared with the conventional Estim, there is limited research on Mstim and its application to therapeutic exercises. To provide impact-based Mstim in a well-controlled manner, a pneumatically powered robotic tapper shown in [Figure 1B](#F1){ref-type="fig"} (Lacey et al., [@B32], [@B33]; Ueda et al., [@B63]) was utilized. The developed robotic tendon tapping device enables paired Mstim of periphery and transcranical stimulation of the cortex (Lacey et al., [@B33]; Kim et al., [@B28]). This device is operated by a pneumatic linear cylinder (Airpel E9D20U, low-friction type, Airpot Corporation, Norwalk, CT) equipped with a medical hammer to apply impact-based mechanical stimulation to the target muscle in a form of tendon tapping as shown in [Figure 1B](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. This pneumatic system creates tapping motion: the hammer linearly moves toward a target tendon, taps the tendon for 0.5 s, and retracts back to the original position. A pneumatic valve (MPYE-5-M5-010-B, Festo, Esslingen, Germany) is connected to the cylinder via a 7.5 m long pneumatic hose. A pressure sensor (SSI-P51-101, SSI Technologies, Inc., Janesville, WI, US) measures pressure in the upper chamber of the cylinder where constant pressure (60 psi) is applied from a pressure compressor. An accelerometer (MMA2202K, Freescale Semiconductor, Inc., Austin, TX, US) attached to the medical hammer detects the time when the hammer hits the tendon. The tendon-tapping robot was designed to be adjustable to different locations and dimension of subjects by rotating and translating the hammer housing structure so that the hammer can tap the tendon from an appropriate angle. To allow for the future use of this device in functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) environment to directly monitor the brain activity with robotic intervention, only MRI safe materials are used (Lacey et al., [@B33]) ([Figure 1B](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). The only major ferromagnetic component is the FESTO pneumatic valve that is placed several meters away from the subject. This configuration helps to reduce electromagnetic interference on electromyographic and electroencephalographic measurements that would have had significant artifacts (Luck, [@B39]) if a non-shielded electromagnetic motor had been used to swing a hammer. 2.2. Experimental Procedure --------------------------- Healthy adult subjects (*n* = 11) participated in this study from the pool of Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta Campus. All subjects were between 18 and 30 years and were right-handed without history of neurological disorders. The experimental procedure was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) at Georgia Institute of Technology (Protocol number: H14191). Subjects were asked to read and sign a consent form before the experiment. As shown in [Figure 1D](#F1){ref-type="fig"}, a subject was supine on a bed experiencing Mstim from the robot as well as TMS. The timing of TMS and Mstim (i.e., *t*~TMS~ and *t*~valve~, respectively) were controlled by Signal (Cambridge Electronic Design Limited, UK). The tapping device applied Mstim to the wrist tendon connected to the flexor carpi radialis (FCR) muscle as shown in [Figure 1C](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. The impact timing (i.e., *t*~hit~) was detected by the accelerometer attached on the hammer. The robotic system was configured as illustrated in [Figure 2D](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. Two timing commands, *t*~valve~ and *t*~TMS~, were sent from the host PC. Resultant MEP amplitudes were recorded from a subject. To measure peak-to-peak MEP values of the FCR muscle for different ISIs, surface EMG was used. Two Ag-AgCl electrodes (E224N, In Vivo Metric, Healdsburg, CA, US) were placed on the FCR muscle belly as shown in [Figure 1D](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. {#F2} An accelerometer mounted to the medical hammer was utilized to measure the acceleration of the hammer and detect the onset of hammer tendon impact (*t*~hit~). As shown in [Figure 2C](#F2){ref-type="fig"}, *t*~hit~ was determined by detecting the time where the acceleration crossed zero for the first time after the initiation of hammer motion. Assuming negligible variability in *t*~TMS~, ISI was calculated by *ISI* = *t*~TMS~−*t*~hit~. Note that *t*~TMS~ and *t*~valve~ were reference commands in the system. *t*~hit~ is a resultant timing point which is *t*~hit~ = *t*~valve~+*t*~delay~ as shown in [Figure 2B](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. In this paper, the acceleration was measured from five subjects out of eleven subjects. Enhanced MEP amplitudes were measured following the conventional procedure developed for Estim study. In the conventional method, the timing between *t*~TMS~ and *t*~valve~ was incrementally changed from 0 to 500 ms by 5 ms as shown in [Figure 3A](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. Once all MEP amplitudes were recorded, the data was used for ground truth for MEP modeling and ISI-W estimation. A series of ISIs where MEP measurements were above the baseline (i.e., MEP with 100% resting motor threshold TMS) indicating enhancement was used to determine the effective ISI-W with sub-threshold TMS. {#F3} Note that in the conventional incremental procedure of MEP data collection, the experimenter in general expected a single distribution of MEP across ISI, and was allowed to manually terminate date collection when little or no MEP was observed after observing a distribution before reaching the longest end of searching time range of 500 ms. Without manual termination, a maximum of 600 trials was needed to incrementally sweep the entire search time range: Each mechanical stimulation took 1 s (1 s × 12 trials) followed by a 2 min rest. Among 12 MEP measurements at a single ISI, first two measurements were discarded and last 10 measurements were recorded. The first two measurements were discarded due to potential startle response. Two 5 min long breaks were given between sessions. As a result, typical time to collect data from one subject was: (1 s × 12 repetitions + 120 s rest) × 50 intervals + 600 s long rest × 2 = 130 min. By allowing the experimenter to decide and manually terminate, average number of trials was reduced to 260, which was still almost an hour. 2.3. Evaluation of Timing Precision of Tendon Tapping ----------------------------------------------------- Mechanical impact timing delay and precision of the tendon tapping robot were evaluated previously (Kim et al., [@B28]). Two types of timing evaluation were conducted by applying mechanical impact to (1) a force sensor (LCM703-50, Omega Engineering Inc., Stamford, CT) fixed to a rigid floor and (2) the forearm of human subjects (a total of four). In the first evaluation, the force sensor was used to detect the timing location of *t*~hit~. A total of 50 trials were performed. In the second measurement of impact application on human subjects, accelerometer readings were used to detect the hitting time (*t*~hit~) as illustrated in [Figure 2C](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. Data was collected from average of 365 tapping trials per subject. As expected, the tapping delay *t*~delay~ ranged from 172 to 188 ms for different subjects primarily due to slight differences in distance between the hammer\'s initial position and the target tendon position. However, within a single subject, highly repeatability was observed. By offsetting mean time delay between the subject, timing precision of mechanical impact application was determined to be 2 ms in STD across all the trials, and judged that the tapping precision was sufficiently high with small variability to meet the timing precision of Mstim. 2.4. Statistical Regression of Enhanced MEP and ISI-W Estimation ---------------------------------------------------------------- A total of four methods have been implemented and compared to each other: (1) Nonlinear Regression with Gaussian Model (NR), (2) Support Vector Machine Regression (SVMR), (3) Gaussian Process Regression (GPR), and (4) Particle Filter (PF). NR is a widely used regression method that assumes a parametric nonlinear model of experimental data including biological data (Motulsky and Christopoulos, [@B45]). Shapiro-Wilk Test was applied to the current MEP data. This test verifies the null hypothesis that the samples came from a normally distributed population. The mean MEP values at different ISIs were applied to this test to examine whether the MEP distribution is normal or not. Measured MEP distributions from eight subjects out of eleven did not reject the null hypothesis as shown in [Figure 3B](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. Based on this normality test, a single-Gaussian Model was adopted as a parametric model to fit the measured MEP profiles for NR and PF. A two-Gaussian model was tested to see how two Gaussian peak amplitudes are determined in NR for all subjects (*n* = 11) for ten times each. In each trial, a greater amplitude was labeled as "High" and smaller amplitude was labeled as "Low" as shown in [Figure 3D](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. Amplitudes were normalized for each subject for comparison across the subjects. Amplitude of the Gaussian with a higher amplitude was 6.3 times greater on average than the other Gaussian. In addition, in 70% of the trials, the amplitude of the second Gaussian converged to zero, supporting practical usefulness of single-Gaussian modeling while it would reduce precision to some extent. SVMR is a nonparametric regression method based on support vector machine (SVM). GPR is another nonparametric regression method that utilizes certain base functions that represent uncertainties in prediction as a Gaussian distribution, and may resemble the variability of multiple MEP measurements at a single ISI (Rasmussen and Williams, [@B50]). Nonparametric algorithms may be useful to model ISI-MEP data that does not necessarily fit a Gaussian model and perform regression with no assumption on the underlying function. On the other hand, nonparametric methods require many data points and relatively long processing time. PF was previously implemented by the authors (Takemura et al., [@B58]) where 30 particles were adopted. The top row of [Figure 3A](#F3){ref-type="fig"} shows the procedure of the incremental method that incrementally changes the interval between *t*~TMS~ and *t*~Valve~ by 5 ms to sweep through the predefined searching range. PF distributed 30 particles within the search range as shown in the third figure in [Figure 3A](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. Each particle specified a certain ISI to observe MEP. Each particle\'s weight was updated based on its MEP measurement. Based on the locations and weights of particles, particles were redistributed in the next iteration to update the estimation of ISI-W. Detailed explanation on PF can be found in Takemura et al. ([@B58]). NR, GPR, and SVMR first measured MEP for predetermined initial ISIs. ISI-W was estimated in an iterative fashion as shown in the second figure in [Figure 3A](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. An acquisition function determined next ISI to observe MEP. This new observation updated the estimation of ISI-W. Detailed procedures of all four methods are given in Algorithms 1--4 in [Supplementary Material](#SM1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. [Figure 3C](#F3){ref-type="fig"} shows a representative estimation process with NR for one subject. The Gaussian model fits more closely to the measured MEP as regression progresses. In this particular trial, the initial number of observations was chosen to be 7 shown by red circles in the top plot of [Figure 3C](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. MEP amplitudes corresponding to initially chosen ISI values were recorded and stored in a form of an array. Arrays of ISI and MEP amplitudes were fed into the NR, SVMR, GPR, and PF algorithms. Next ISI to evaluate MEP was determined based on updated prediction, completing one iteration. New ISI and corresponding MEP were added to the arrays for the next iteration. This procedure continued until predefined stopping criteria were met that are given as follows: Variances at the lower and upper ends of the modeled distribution were evaluated. Iteration was terminated when variances in last five iterations of both the lower and upper ends were lower than 50, or iteration reached a maximum number of 99. The variance of 50 corresponds to 7 ms standard deviation of the last five lower and upper ends. This is slightly greater than the 5ms increment of ISI, which tolerates one interval long (5 ms) change of two ends location. The detailed procedures are explained in Algorithms 1--4 in [Supplementary Material](#SM1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. After the regression of MEP amplitude converged, a threshold method was applied to find two ends of the Gaussian model to determine its ISI-W. For a Gaussian distribution, the range within two standard deviations (i.e., two sigma, or 95%) was used as an estimation of effective ISI-W as shown in [Figure 3E](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. 0.135 is the value of a normal distribution at two ends. For the nonparametric SVMR and GPR, the same amplitude of 0.135 was applied to determine the ISI-W for consistency. The final estimated profiles from these methods had hill-shaped curves similar to Gaussian curves (see [Figure 3C](#F3){ref-type="fig"} and [Figure S1](#SM1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). [Figure 3F](#F3){ref-type="fig"} shows how estimation of ISI-W progresses with GPR. Number of observations refers to the number of MEP measurements before the algorithm stops. Cross correlation between an estimated MEP curve and measured MEP profile as the ground-truth was evaluated. A correlation coefficient was determined using Pearson\'s linear correlation coefficient. F1 score was calculated by evaluating true positive, false positive and false negative. Using the two ends of both estimated ISI-W and measured ISI-W, F1 score produced a value ranging from 0 to 1 that represented the similarity between the estimated and measured ISI-W lengths. When the two time windows exactly matched, F1 score would become 1. Otherwise, F1 score would take a value \<1. Percentage of convergence is the percentage of trials that have converged before reaching the maximum iterations of 99. For these statistical regression estimations, MEPs of corresponding ISIs were measured and recorded in advance using the conventional incremental method. During the statistical regression estimation, the estimation algorithm retrieved necessary MEP measurements from the pool of data. Five subjects out of 11 had acceleration measurement of the hammer motion which could be used to narrow the search time range. Using this acceleration reading, ISI-W estimation results were analyzed in two different groups, one without acceleration measurements (for 11 subjects) and one with acceleration measurements (for five subjects) which collected 1,895 and 824 data points, respectively. For the group without the acceleration measurements, the search range was between *t*~Valve~ and the end of the trial. For the group with the acceleration measurement, *t*~hit~ detected by the accelerometer was used as the start of the search range. 3. Results {#s3} ========== 3.1. Assessment of High-Timing Precision Tendon Tapping Robot ------------------------------------------------------------- To characterize timing-dependent transient neuromodulation due to Mstim, the mechanical tapping device must satisfy timing precision requirements. Compared with Estim, there are additional sources of time delay and variability in the developed pneumatic device, including: (1) air pressure propagation time in the pneumatic line, (2) pressure development time in the pneumatic chamber and pressure attenuation, (3) travel time of the hammer moving from its initial position to the target tendon position, and (4) non-linear mechanical interaction between the hammer material and skin/subcutaneous tissues. The sum of these factors produces a system delay between a pneumatic valve open command and resultant tendon tapping as illustrated in [Figure 2A](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. It should be noted that such delays can be compensated as long as the delay is repeatable. In other words, the speed of response of the mechanical tapping device is not important, but its timing precision is critical for the study of transient neuromodulation induced by Mstim. The developed device was designed to address this issue. A mean time delay was 195.5 ms with a standard deviation of 2 ms, which is an order of magnitude smaller than a typical ISI-W size due to Mstim (Kim et al., [@B28]), ensuring high repeatability of mechanical stimulation in time as shown in [Figure S3](#SM1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. Furthermore, the timing of the onset of Mstim can be observed by using the accelerometer attached on the pneumatic hammer. [Figure 2B](#F2){ref-type="fig"} shows all timing events. [Figure 2C](#F2){ref-type="fig"} shows representative measurements of acceleration and EMG of the procedure. Note that for Mstim-induced neuromodulation, ISI is defined as the timing difference between t~Hit~ and t~TMS~. 3.2. Effective ISI for Observing Mstim-Enhanced MEP --------------------------------------------------- Instantaneous and transient neuromodulation of M1 was explored by observing the emergence of the combined effects of sub-threshold Mstim to a wrist flexor tendon and sub-threshold TMS of M1 for a wrist flexor muscle (flexor carpi radialis) as shown in [Figure 1C](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. Sub-threshold TMS (90% of resting motor threshold) was applied targeting the muscle at various ISI from Mstim, using the tendon tapping robot (Kim et al., [@B28]). See section Experimental Procedure for details. When sub-threshold Mstim or TMS alone was applied, the absence of an evoked response was confirmed as shown in [Figure 1E](#F1){ref-type="fig"} top and bottom traces. With a combination of sub-threshold Mstim and TMS at various ISIs with 5 ms steps, evoked responses were observed (red arrows in the 2nd--14th traces) when the range of time interval from the Mstim robotic command to TMS was 60 ms (i.e., from 245 to 305 ms) in this setup. Within this 60 ms window, the combined effect of Mstim and sub-threshold TMS is substantial enough to activate the motor neurons to observe enhanced MEP. Since application of Mstim solely does not produce a long latency reflex response (Lacey et al., [@B32]), sub-threshold TMS was paired with Mstim to observe enhanced MEP due to Mstim in the muscle of interest [Figure 2E](#F2){ref-type="fig"} shows a representative plot of enhanced MEP vs. ISI with sub-threshold TMS in one subject showing an effective ISI-W of 70 ms (subject 4). The measured effective ISI-W lengths of each individual are listed in [Figure 3B](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. These lengths were determined based on MEPs measurement at ISIs using the conventional incremental method and individual ranges of ISI-W were variable as shown in the [Figure 3B](#F3){ref-type="fig"} (mean 108 ms, std 45 ms). These measured effective ISI-W were used to compare and evaluate the performance of estimation methods (i.e., F1 score). The length of effective ISI-W due to Mstim is comparable to our observation of the reflex-based latency window size in a hand muscle (50 ms) (Rothwell et al., [@B51]; Shinohara et al., [@B54]). When sub-threshold TMS was applied with sub-threshold Estim of the median nerve, however, the effective interval window size was 15--20 ms (Lacey et al., [@B32]) which is supported by previously reported work Poon et al. ([@B49]). Hence, the effective ISI-W size with Mstim appears to be larger than Estim, (i.e., more dispersed response), possibly because of desynchronized activation of mechanoreceptors (e.g., muscle spindles) in response to Mstim. Mechanical peripheral stimulus produces a dispersed afferent volley in comparison to the impulse response to electrical stimulation. While this has been known since at least 1983 (Burke et al., [@B4]), limited work investigates the mechanism for this diffuse firing or its impact on stimulation based neuromodulation. These results confirm the presence of Mstim-induced transient neuromodulation of M1 and assures the importance of determining the effect in comparison to Estim. 3.3. Optimal Number of Initial Observations ------------------------------------------- NR, SVMR, and GPR procedures require initial data points (initial observation of MEP) to begin regression that must be specified by the user. The choice of the initial number of observations, or *n*~*ini*~, impacts the performance. The nominal searching period was given as \[*t*~*valve*~ *t*~*valve*~+500 ms\]. For example, evenly distributed initial ISIs within the searching period of 500 ms would be 500, 650, 850, 1,000 ms when *n*~*ini*~ = 4. With the use of the accelerometer, the range can be reduced to \[*t*~*hit*~ *t*~*valve*~+500 ms\], which may improve the performance. [Figures 4A--C](#F4){ref-type="fig"} show comparisons of F1 score and number of total observations until convergence with *n*~*ini*~ from 2 to 9 with and without the accelerometer for NR, SVMR, and GPR. For the PF, except for the high rate of convergence as shown in [Figure 5D](#F5){ref-type="fig"}, PF did not perform better than the other methods. In particular, PF still required a significantly greater number of trials. For this reason, the figure evaluated the initial number of observations only for NR, SVMR and GPR. For PF, 30 particles were used from our previous study (Takemura et al., [@B58]) that resulted in the best estimation performance among five different numbers of particles. In each graph, statistical significance was evaluated between neighboring bar plots within the same condition: without ACC and with ACC. For NR shown in [Figure 4A](#F4){ref-type="fig"}, F1 score increased significantly from *n*~*ini*~=7 to *n*~*ini*~=8 without ACC and increased from *n*~*ini*~ = 6 to *n*~*ini*~ = 9 with ACC. Total number of observations was low for *n*~*ini*~ \< 7 without ACC and *n*~*ini*~ \< 5 with ACC. For SVMR shown in [Figure 4B](#F4){ref-type="fig"}, F1 score took the highest value for *n*~*ini*~ = 4 without ACC and for *n*~*ini*~ = 3 with ACC. Total number of observations was low between *n*~*ini*~ = 4 and *n*~*ini*~ = 8 without ACC and low after *n*~*ini*~ \> 3 for with ACC. For GPR shown in [Figure 4C](#F4){ref-type="fig"}, F1 score took the highest value for *n*~*ini*~=6 without ACC and *n*~*ini*~ \<8 with ACC. Total number of observations was low for *n*~*ini*~ \>2 with ACC and low for *n*~*ini*~ \<8 with ACC. {#F4} {#F5} Practically at least 1--2 non-zero enhanced MEP responses must be observed as initial data points for a regression algorithm to successfully progress. Given average ISI-W of 108 ms in this dataset, *n*~*ini*~= 6 or 7 would meet this requirement. 3.4. Reduction of Mstim-TMS Trials for Individual ISI Window Estimation ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Previous studies utilized a fixed ISI or a few manually-chosen ISIs (Stefan, [@B56]; Kumpulainen et al., [@B31]) to characterize neural responses associated with Estim. It should be noted that these ISIs were mostly determined based on empirical knowledge of neural conduction times. Other previous studies (Wolters et al., [@B65], [@B66]) incrementally varied the interval between TMS and Estim to identify an ISI which would achieve the highest long-term potentiation in MEP amplitude. The presented work applied statistical sampling and regression methods to reduce trials for the estimation of individual ISI-MEP profiles by applying systematically chosen ISIs between Mstim and TMS, instead of incrementally sweeping a predetermined range of ISI. In addition to individual differences, usually large variability in MEPs is observed in a single subject. ISI-W estimation methods must consider the stochastic nature of the human neuromotor system responses as shown in [Figure 2E](#F2){ref-type="fig"} where large variation in MEP amplitudes was observed. Particle filtering technique was applied earlier (Takemura et al., [@B58]) in which particles determined when to apply TMS relative to Mstim to update an estimate of the MEP profile in an iterative manner. ISI-W estimation based on particle filtering showed potential to reduce the required number of observations. Other statistical regression methods were applied for further improvement of ISI-W estimation performance as shown in [Figure 3A](#F3){ref-type="fig"}. In particular, a performance comparison was conducted between four statistical estimation methods: (1) Nonlinear Regression with Gaussian Model (NR), (2) Support Vector Machine Regression (SVMR), and (3) Gaussian Process (GP), in addition to previously reported, (4) Particle Filter (PF). Details are described in section Materials and Methods. All of the regression methods required a certain number of initial observations distributed within an initial guess of ISI-W. When the accelerometer is available, it can detect the onset of Mstim or *t*~*hit*~. The period between *t*~*valve*~ and *t*~*hit*~ can be excluded from regression as facilitation must occur after *t*~*hit*~. The use of the accelerometer helps to narrow the searching range that may improve performance. Performance was evaluated based on (1) total number of observations, (2) cross correlation, (3) F1 score, and (4) percentage of convergence. Four regression methods and the conventional method were compared using a significance level (alpha) of 0.05 with the null hypothesis that there is no significant difference between methods. Effect sizes are listed in the [Supplementary Material](#SM1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. Number of observations required for convergence is shown in [Figure 5A](#F5){ref-type="fig"}. All the regression methods significantly reduced the number of observations compared with the conventional incremental method that required an average of 272 observations when the experimenter was allowed to manually terminate data collection. While PF improved the performance, PF still required many more observations and produced greater variance than NR, SVMR, and GPR did. On average, NR, SVMR, and GPR required an order of magnitude smaller observations than PF and the conventional incremental method with smaller variance. The use of the accelerometer further improved the performance by reducing number of observations up to 56%. The result of cross correlation analysis is shown in [Figure 5B](#F5){ref-type="fig"} evaluating how much estimated MEP profiles were close to the profiles from full measurements as the ground truth. GPR\'s correlation coefficient was 31.67% higher than that of NR (*p* \< 0.05), and SVMR\'s correlation coefficient was 16.67% higher than that of NR (*p* \< 0.05). There was no statistical significance observed between SVMR and GPR. F1 score would be an appropriate evaluation metric to evaluate the accuracy of ISI-W estimation as shown in [Figure 5C](#F5){ref-type="fig"}. GPR obtained F1 score greater than 0.8. The use of the accelerometer overall improved the performance. As shown in [Figure 5D](#F5){ref-type="fig"}, only a small number of cases did not converge and reached the maximum number of iterations, showing satisfactory robustness to different data sets. 4. Discussion {#s4} ============= Individual differences in physiological characteristics (See Paired Associative Stimulation for Neural Facilitation section) may result in variability in effective ISI-W in individuals. With sub-threshold TMS and Mstim, a single distribution of MEP across ISI is expected. Parametric statistical regression methods were applied to find effective ISI-w with the expectation of single distribution. The estimation results were close to the measured ISI-W, capturing individual variability. Due to the generally large variability in effective ISI-W in individuals, an adjustment procedure must be performed before actual neuroscientific research in every single subject. The method of evaluating ISI requires many data samples and times. However, to the best of the author\'s knowledge, there is no study reporting determination of effective ISIs efficiently for individuals. These statistical regression methods would provide ways to determine effective ISIs for each individual by monitoring the subjects\' MEP with reduced number of stimulation trials. 4.1. Gaussian Modeling of Mstim-Induced MEP Enhancement ------------------------------------------------------- For Estim-induced neuromodulation in terms of conditioned stimulation, other groups reported correlations between ISI and MEP amplitudes (Chen et al., [@B7]; Tokimura et al., [@B62]; Sailer, [@B52]; Bikmullina et al., [@B2]; Kojima et al., [@B30]). Mathematical representation of MEP induced by peripheral or cortical stimulation has been reported in the literature. For example, a statistical model of MEP induced by electrical pulse trains to simulate the firing pattern of MEPs was proposed (Ma et al., [@B40]). Another work developed a regression MEP model with different TMS intensities (i.e., input-output curve) (Goetz and Peterchev, [@B18]; Goetz et al., [@B17]). Gaussian modeling was adopted to fit the ISI-MEP relationship with a different number of Gaussian functions (Delvendahl et al., [@B13]; Cirillo and Perez, [@B9]; Cirillo et al., [@B8]; Kallioniemi et al., [@B22]; Mohammadi et al., [@B44]). To the best of our knowledge, there are even fewer works that studied ISI-MEP association with Mstim and its modeling by using an automated tendon-tapping robot. The majority of MEP profiles associated with ISI reported in the literature exhibited a single MEP distribution as well as the ones collected in this paper (see [Supplementary Material](#SM1){ref-type="supplementary-material"} for raw MEP data) along ISI as shown in [Figure 2E](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. While the objectives of Gaussian curve-fitting in the past studies are different from our objective of time-efficient ISI-W estimation, the use of Gaussian models seems a reasonable choice. As far as Mstim with sub-threshold TMS for effective ISI-W estimation is concerned, a single-Gaussian model may be sufficient for parametric modeling of enhanced MEP profiles. With an oversimplified single Gaussian model, the speed of convergence would be improved and issues associated with over-fitting would be resolved. This simplified methods, PF and NR, were suitable for robust estimation of individual ISI-W as shown in [Figure 5D](#F5){ref-type="fig"}. On the other hand, nonparametric methods, SVMR and GPR, were applied, considering variability in MEP profiles. They resulted in ISI-W estimation with better precision. 4.2. Limitation of This Study ----------------------------- In this study, effective ISI-Ws were estimated for each individual using four different methods and the results were evaluated. Since this study evaluated the overall estimation performance across all subjects, potential between-subject variability may not have been fully accounted for. Four estimation methods could be further optimized by tuning parameters to improve estimation performance. 5. Conclusion {#s5} ============= In this work, a robotically enabled experimental procedure was applied for the study of neuromodulation induced by peripheral mechanical stimulation. This estimation procedure was enabled by high timing precision of the tendon tapping robot (STD \< 5 ms). The size of ISI-W that observed enhanced MEP with Mstim by means of tendon tapping was found to be larger than that with sub-threshold Estim of the median nerve, possibly due to different involvement of mechanoreceptors. A single-Gaussian model was applied to enhanced MEP profiles for parametric regression. The combination of robotic tendon tapping and statistical regression can reduce the number of observations to individually determine effective ISI to observe enhanced MEP up to 6.5 % (NR with ACC), leading to reduction of physical burden on the subject who would otherwise receive many stimulation trials with high intensity for more than 2 h. Parametric models (NR and PF) that utilized a single-Gaussian model achieved high convergence. Regarding which estimation method should be used, the presented comparison indicated that the considered estimation methods performed differently in terms of various evaluation metrics. While there was no single method that outperformed the other methods, GPR would be a reasonable choice to achieve an ISI-W length close to the measured ISI-W length, resulting in a high F1 score. If the priority is the reduction of the total number of stimulation trials while achieving a high rate of convergence, NR should be chosen. Individual estimation methods could be further optimized by tuning parameters. This line of research is expected to produce a reliable tool, which will clarify unique neuromodulations of the motor cortex with an application of robotic Mstim to muscles, in comparison to the conventional Estim of a peripheral nerve, and its paired central stimulation. The paired stimulation technique may be extended to study not only excitatory neuromodulation, but also inhibitory neuromodulation, when applied with supra-threshold TMS. This technique may also be used to evaluate neural plasticity with Mstim-TMS paired stimulation. Statistical regression methods would be able to capture individual effective ISI-W that is expected to have larger variability in individuals with neurological disorders compared with healthy individuals. The outcomes might allow for evidence-based implementation of mechanical stimulation paired with brain stimulation into individually tailored robotic rehabilitation for hemiparetic stroke survivors and possibly other disabilities. Data Availability Statement {#s6} =========================== All datasets generated for this study are included in the article/[Supplementary Material](#s9){ref-type="sec"}. Ethics Statement {#s7} ================ The studies involving human participants were reviewed and approved by Kelly A. Winn Georgia Tech\'s Central Institutional Review Board (IRB). The patients/participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study. Author Contributions {#s8} ==================== MS and JU conceived and supervised the research. EK and JU conceptualized the ideal of applying statistical sampling and regression to the characterization of transient neuromodulation with paired mechanical and sub-threshold brain stimulation. EK and WM designed the studies, implemented the hardware and software, performed the experiments, and analyzed the data. EK and JU drafted the manuscript with contributions from WM and MS. Conflict of Interest -------------------- The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest. The authors would like to thank Dr. Shin-ichi Izumi with the Tohoku University Hospital for valuable discussion and guidance, Mitchell St. Pierre with Georgia Tech School of Biological Sciences for his assistance during experimental data collection, and NITI-ON Co. LTD. for collaboration and their support for materials and student exchange with Tohoku University Hospital. **Funding.** This project was supported in part by National Science Foundation Center for Compact and Efficient Fluid Power (grant number EEC 0540834). Georgia Tech Neural Engineering Center Seed Grant, Georgia Tech Institute for Robotics and Intelligent Machines Seed Grant, and National Science Foundation Research Traineeship Program (grant number NRT 1545287) for WM. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. Supplementary Material {#s9} ====================== The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: <https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnbot.2020.00001/full#supplementary-material> ###### Measured MEP data of eleven subjects. ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### MEP regression results. ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Robotic tapping device introduction and experimental procedure. ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Click here for additional data file. [^1]: Edited by: Surjo R. Soekadar, Charité Medical University of Berlin, Germany [^2]: Reviewed by: Xiaosu Hu, University of Michigan, United States; Leonardo Abdala Elias, State University of Campinas, Brazil

Introduction {#s1} ============ As sessile organisms, plants exhibit an extraordinary phenotypic plasticity that allows them to optimize their development and metabolism according to environmental cues. Among the signals that plants perceive and respond to, light plays a fundamental role as a source of information and energy. A typical example of light as an information source that modulates plant behavior is the shade avoidance response [@pgen.1001100-Franklin1]. Because plant tissues absorb red light and reflect far red light, plants can detect the proximity of neighbors by a decrease in the red to far-red ratio (R:FR) and trigger the shade avoidance response [@pgen.1001100-Franklin2]. The molecular changes induced by shade avoidance are diverse and complex at all levels. Foliar shade is mainly perceived by the red and far-red phytochrome photoreceptors *PHYTOCHROMES D* and *E* (*PHYD* and *PHYE*; AT4G16250 and AT4G18130), and especially *PHYTOCHROME B* (*PHYB*; AT2G18790), but general decreases in intensity are sensed by the blue light photoreceptors, cryptochromes and phototropins, and can be important in response to shade [@pgen.1001100-Franklin1], [@pgen.1001100-Ballare1], [@pgen.1001100-Wollenberg1]. Phytochromes initiate the response through interaction with the phytochrome interacting factors *PHYTOCHROME INTERACTING FACTOR 4* and *5* (*PIF4* and *PIF5*; AT2G43010 and AT3G59060), and other transcription factors such as *PHYTOCHROME INTERACTING FACTOR 3-LIKE 1* (*PIL1*; AT2G46970) and *ARABIDOPSIS THALIANA HOMEOBOX PROTEIN 2* (*ATHB2*; AT4G16780) [@pgen.1001100-Steindler1]--[@pgen.1001100-Lorrain1]. The complexity of the downstream signaling cascade is a consequence of activation of negative feedback loops on these transcription factors [@pgen.1001100-Hornitschek1], [@pgen.1001100-Sessa1], activation and cross-talk between multiple hormone signaling pathways [@pgen.1001100-Alabadi1], [@pgen.1001100-Vandenbussche1], and interactions with the circadian clock [@pgen.1001100-Salter1] among many other molecular processes [@pgen.1001100-Sessa1]. Shade avoidance phenotypes include increased elongation of the hypocotyl and delay of cotyledon opening in seedlings, and increased elongation of stems and petioles, increased apical dominance and reduced developmental times in adults [@pgen.1001100-Franklin1]. Although in seedlings the shade avoidance response is necessary to allow optimal positioning and immediate access to light, in adult crop plants this response is considered detrimental due to reduced plant biomass and fruit yield. Furthermore, the shade avoidance response can have adaptive value, conferring an advantage to plants in competitive environments but being maladaptive for plants growing in constitutive shade (i.e. under a forest canopy) [@pgen.1001100-Schmitt1]. Consistent with this idea, the degree of phenotypic plasticity to shade varies in natural populations depending on the light environment [@pgen.1001100-Schmitt1]. QTL analyses in immortal plant populations allow comparison of genetically identical individuals in different environmental conditions [@pgen.1001100-Tonsor1]. QTL analyses of the shade avoidance response have been carried out using seedlings from immortal populations of Arabidopsis grown under sun versus simulated foliar shade or red versus far-red light conditions [@pgen.1001100-Botto1]--[@pgen.1001100-Botto2]. In one of these studies, the blue light photoreceptor *CRYPTOCHROME 2* (*CRY2*; AT1G04400) was identified as the main cause of the differences in cotyledon opening in response to FR light between the Ler and Cvi accessions [@pgen.1001100-Botto2]. However, genetic sources of natural variation in the shade avoidance response in adult plants remain unknown, in part due to the low resolution typical of QTL mapping experiments [@pgen.1001100-Botto1]. A common challenge in QTL analysis is identification of the causal gene(s) among typically hundreds of candidate genes in the QTL confidence interval. Recombination-based fine mapping is still the most common method to identify causative genes. However, genomic resources in Arabidopsis such as genome sequences for several accessions [@pgen.1001100-Clark1], detailed genome annotations [@pgen.1001100-Berardini1] and genome-wide expression profiling for innumerable conditions and genotypes [@pgen.1001100-Obayashi1], [@pgen.1001100-Schmid1] provide potentially useful tools to aid in QTL cloning. Worth mentioning are the available genome-wide expression profiles for full segregating populations, which allow expression-QTL (eQTL) analyses that can suggest chromosomal regions responsible for variation in expression levels across the population [@pgen.1001100-West1], [@pgen.1001100-Keurentjes1]. Compilation of genomic resources to identify QTLs has become an active and promising area of research in model organisms [@pgen.1001100-Kliebenstein1]--[@pgen.1001100-Tu1]. When successful, these approaches have the advantage of saving a significant amount of time in the laborious process of cloning a QTL, and can suggest novel candidate genes not considered *a priori*. The highly pleiotropic nature of the shade avoidance response suggests that the genes that control this response modulate multiple pathways. Therefore, the use of systems and network approaches seems an appropriate strategy to identify causative genes for QTLs affecting the shade avoidance response. In this work, we performed QTL analysis of the shade avoidance response in the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population of Arabidopsis. We combined classical mapping and a novel network analysis to identify *ELF3* as a gene that differentially regulates the response in the population. *ELF3* is a gene of unknown molecular function that plays an important role in the plant circadian clock. This work implicates *ELF3* in the shade avoidance response for the first time and describes links between the circadian clock and the shade avoidance response. Results {#s2} ======= Mapping QTL for shade avoidance response in the Bay-0 x Shahdara RILs {#s2a} --------------------------------------------------------------------- Although the shade avoidance response has typically been studied in seedlings, its effect is observable throughout the life cycle of plants. To investigate natural variation in the shade avoidance response of adult Arabidopsis plants, we grew the Bay-0 x Sha RIL population under simulated sun and shade conditions in 12 hours light, 12 hours dark (12∶12) photoperiods. All plants were phenotyped for shade avoidance using plant size and morphology traits (leaf blade width and length, petiole length and leaf angle) and developmental time traits (bolting date, rosette diameter and leaf number at bolting, and flowering time). We calculated indices for each RIL, trait and condition using mixed effect models as detailed in [Materials and Methods](#s4){ref-type="sec"}. In addition, for each RIL and trait we obtained two shade avoidance response indices: the subtraction index, by subtracting the shade indices from the sun indices; and the residual index, by regressing the simulated shade indices on to those for simulated sun and then taking the negative residuals of the regression. Most QTL analysis methods assume that trait values fit a normal distribution. We log-transformed those traits that did not meet this assumption (rosette diameter, bolting date, leaf number and flowering time, p\<0.01 by Shapiro-Wilks test, see [Materials and Methods](#s4){ref-type="sec"}). All shade avoidance response traits fit a normal distribution after transformation (Shapiro-Wilks test p\>0.05). Among the traits measured, only leaf angle did not show a significant response to shade in a mixed effect model. Leaf blade length and width showed shade responsiveness, but did not present significant variation between RILs and were removed from the analysis ([Figure S1](#pgen.1001100.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). All other traits presented significant genotype x environment interactions ([Figure S2](#pgen.1001100.s002){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). QTL analysis was performed for all trait indices in simulated sun and simulated shade, and for the shade avoidance indices. We obtained similar results using the log transformed and untransformed data, and from the subtraction and residual shade avoidance indices (data not shown). Therefore, from now on we will only detail the results from the untransformed data and the residual shade avoidance response index. In general, QTL profiles from developmental time traits could be easily distinguished from those from plant size and morphology traits, suggesting different underlying genetic mechanisms ([Figures 1](#pgen-1001100-g001){ref-type="fig"} and [S3](#pgen.1001100.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). QTL profiles in the sun and shade environments were highly similar, indicating a common genetic control mechanism of these traits in both conditions ([Figure S3](#pgen.1001100.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). However, differences between the QTLs in both environments can be highlighted by the QTL analysis of the shade avoidance response index. In this analysis we detected a major QTL in chromosome 2 affecting all developmental time traits (*Shade Avoidance Response 2*, *SAR2*, [Figure 1](#pgen-1001100-g001){ref-type="fig"}). Smaller effect QTLs for petiole length were located in chromosomes 2, 3 and 5 ([Figure 1](#pgen-1001100-g001){ref-type="fig"}). For *SAR2*, the Bay-0 allele presented a greater shade avoidance response than the Sha allele by accelerating the development of shade-grown plants that carry this allele while having a reduced effect in sun-grown plants ([Figure S4](#pgen.1001100.s004){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). *SAR2* explained between 27.6% and 30.4% of the variation in the shade avoidance response found in the population. {#pgen-1001100-g001} To characterize the effect of photoperiod in the shade avoidance response we measured developmental time traits in a subset of the RILs under 16 hours light, 8 hours dark (16∶8) photoperiods (see [Materials and Methods](#s4){ref-type="sec"}). In this experiment we observed less variance of shade avoidance indices among the RILs than in the 12∶12 experiment ([Figure S2](#pgen.1001100.s002){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). However, the positions and directions of the effects of the major QTLs in 16∶8, including *SAR2*, are in agreement with the results from the 12∶12 experiment ([Figures 1](#pgen-1001100-g001){ref-type="fig"}, [S3](#pgen.1001100.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, [S4](#pgen.1001100.s004){ref-type="supplementary-material"} and [S5](#pgen.1001100.s005){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Interestingly, the number and positions of minor QTLs differ, suggesting the existence of small effect loci with photoperiod specificity. In general, reduced effects were found in the QTLs in 16∶8 photoperiods, which could be caused by the smaller number of lines assayed in 16∶8 or by reduced phenotypic differences caused by shorter developmental time in long days. We decided to further investigate *SAR2*, the largest effect QTL affecting the shade avoidance response both in 12∶12 and 16∶8 photoperiods. For convenience, all following experiments were done in 16∶8 unless otherwise stated. QTL confirmation {#s2b} ---------------- One way to characterize *SAR2* is to compare the shade avoidance response of plants inheriting the *SAR2* chromosomal region from either Bay-0 or Sha. We obtained two heterogeneous inbred families (HIFs) heterozygous for a region that included all (HIF144) or part (HIF166) of the *SAR2* confidence interval ([Figure S6A](#pgen.1001100.s006){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). An initial screen of the progeny from both HIFs under simulated shade revealed differences in shade avoidance traits that correlated with the genotypes of the *SAR2* region, with Bay-0 alleles inducing shorter developmental times than Sha ([Figure S6B](#pgen.1001100.s006){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Since HIF166 was heterozygous for only part of *SAR2*\'s confidence interval but still segregated for developmental time traits, we focused on this line to obtain recombinants that narrowed the position of the causative gene(s). Recombinant lines descended from HIF166 uncovered the existence of at least two loci on chromosome 2 controlling the studied traits. A first locus or group of loci is located within the confidence interval of *SAR2* and a second region is downstream and outside the confidence interval ([Figure 2](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}). {ref-type="sec"}). The colored boxed area represents the 2-LOD confidence interval for *SAR2*. HIF166L, HIF166R and HIF166M are heterozygous for part of the confidence interval of *SAR2*, for a region downstream of *SAR2* or for both, respectively. (B) Phenotypes for the progeny of HIF166L, HIF166R and HIF166M. Bolting date, rosette diameter and flowering time were measured in the progeny of each HIF line both under simulated sun and shade conditions in 16∶8 photoperiods. After flowering, plants were assigned to a genotypic class using the molecular markers depicted in (A). Line plots represent averages ± standard errors for each genotype under each condition. Shaded and non-shaded areas in each plot indicate simulate shade and sun conditions respectively. Numbers indicate the plants used in the experiment. Bar plots to the right show the shade avoidance response index as the increase ± standard error of averages in simulated sun compared to simulated shade. Asterisks indicate significant differences between Bay and Sha alleles (ANOVA test p\<0.05). HIF166L and HIF166M show significant shade avoidance response differences between alleles.](pgen.1001100.g002){#pgen-1001100-g002} To investigate which one of these two regions was responsible for the shade avoidance response variation detected in our QTL analysis, we characterized the progeny of lines segregating for *SAR2* (HIF166L), the region distal of *SAR2* (HIF166R) or both regions (HIF166M) under simulated sun and shade conditions ([Figure 2A](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}). Progeny from HIF166L did not present differences attributable to the segregating alleles when grown in simulated sun but did under simulated shade ([Figure 2B](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}, line plots), resulting in significant differences in their responses to shade ([Figure 2B](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}, bar plots). The heterozygous progeny of HIF166L showed intermediate shade avoidance response phenotypes, suggesting a semi-dominant relationship between the Bay-0 and Sha alleles. The fact that Bay-0 alleles in the plants descended from HIF166L increased the response to shade in all traits is consistent with the QTL analysis and confirms the position of *SAR2* in the interval segregating in this HIF. On the other hand, the progeny of HIF166R showed differences in all traits measured both in simulated sun and shade, with the Bay-0 allele delaying flowering and increasing rosette diameter ([Figure 2B](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}, line plots). However, the similar magnitude of the effects under both light conditions implies that this downstream region is not significantly involved in the shade avoidance response ([Figure 2B](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}, bar plots). Corroborating these observations, the progeny of HIF166M, segregating both for *SAR2* and the downstream region, presented characteristics of both lines HIF166L and HIF166R: there were significant differences in the phenotypes measured in each treatment ([Figure 2B](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}, line plots), but those differences were larger under simulated shade treatment, resulting in differential shade avoidance response ([Figure 2B](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}, bar plots). It is worth mentioning that although plants descended from HIF166M presented differences in the shade avoidance response attributable to the segregating alleles as expected, these differences were not significant for bolting date measurements. This could be a secondary effect of the early bolting phenotypes caused by the region downstream of *SAR2* reducing the time that plants have to exhibit significant differences. Altogether, these results suggest the existence of at least two loci affecting developmental time related traits on the studied interval in chromosome 2. The locus or loci outside of the QTL confidence interval has similar effects on these traits in all light conditions tested here, while the effect of *SAR2* depends on the light condition and therefore alters the shade avoidance response of the plants tested. Network analysis {#s2c} ---------------- Together, the chromosomal region delimited by the *SAR2* confidence interval and the heterozygous region in HIF166L includes 363 genes, some of which are related to light signaling or response, such as several encoding F-box proteins, *ATTENUATED FAR-RED RESPONSE (AFR*; AT2G24540), *ELF3*, *CONSTANS-LIKE 3* (*COL3*; AT2G24790) and *ARABIDOPSIS RESPONSE REGULATOR 12* (*ARR12;* AT2G25180) among others [@pgen.1001100-Kipreos1]--[@pgen.1001100-Imamura1]. To help us elucidate the causative gene for *SAR2*, we constructed networks for all 363 candidates. First, since genes in the same pathways or in the same functional complexes often exhibit similar expression patterns under diverse temporal and physiological conditions, we connected each candidate gene to co-expressed genes across 1388 microarray experiments [@pgen.1001100-Obayashi1]. Next, we expect causative genes underlying *SAR2* to modulate the genes in their networks to generate the shade avoidance phenotype. For this reason, we filtered the networks to keep only co-expressed genes with an eQTL in the location of the candidate gene, indicative of a regulatory relationship [@pgen.1001100-West2]. To avoid arbitrary associations between pairs of genes, we considered only those networks that had connections between genes with similar functional classifications as determined by having similar GO categories (see [Materials and Methods](#s4){ref-type="sec"}) [@pgen.1001100-Berardini1]. Finally, since we anticipate the causative gene for *SAR2* to be polymorphic between Bay-0 and Sha, we searched the candidate genes for non-synonymous polymorphisms or for the presence of cis-eQTLs indicative of promoter or auto-regulatory changes [@pgen.1001100-Clark1], [@pgen.1001100-West2]. [Figure 3](#pgen-1001100-g003){ref-type="fig"} shows the network result for the 133 genes found in the intersection of the QTL and HIF166L intervals. We obtained similar results for the combination of these intervals ([Figure S7](#pgen.1001100.s007){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Both network analyses indicated *ELF3* as the candidate gene with the highest evidence for differential control of expression of related genes in the Bay-0 and Sha population. In addition, according to re-sequencing datasets, *ELF3* contains amino acid substitutions between Bay-0 and Sha in a conserved domain of the protein [@pgen.1001100-Clark1], [@pgen.1001100-Weigel1]. Further sequencing of the Bay-0 and Sha alleles of *ELF3* revealed the insertion in the Bay-0 allele of 8 glutamines in a tri-nucleotide repeat region that had been identified before as polymorphic among natural populations of Arabidopsis ([Figure S8](#pgen.1001100.s008){ref-type="supplementary-material"}) [@pgen.1001100-Tajima1]. Given the prominent placement of *ELF3* in the network analysis we concentrated on *ELF3* as a likely candidate for *SAR2*. {#pgen-1001100-g003} Quantitative complementation test {#s2d} --------------------------------- *ELF3* was first identified in Arabidopsis as an early flowering time mutant insensitive to photoperiod [@pgen.1001100-Zagotta1]. However, this gene has never been implicated as a regulator of the shade avoidance response. One way to investigate the effects of *ELF3* in this response is to perform a quantitative complementation test, analyzing the response in genetically similar lines carrying different dosages of *ELF3* alleles [@pgen.1001100-Long1]. We performed a quantitative complementation test by crossing both HIF166L homozygous lines to the *elf3-1* mutant and Columbia wild type plants to generate F1 plants carrying Bay-0/*elf3-1*, Sha/*elf3-1*, Bay-0/Col, or Sha/Col alleles of *ELF3* ([Figure 4](#pgen-1001100-g004){ref-type="fig"}). In terms of genotype, Col-0 *ELF3* shares the canonical allele at the non-synonymous polymorphism in the fourth exon with Bay-0 and has 7 fewer glutamines than Sha and 15 fewer than Bay-0. These hybrid plants were grown in simulated sun and shade both in 16∶8 and 12∶12 photoperiods, and measured for bolting and flowering time. In both photoperiods, plants carrying *ELF3*-Col-0 alleles presented a similar bolting and flowering response to shade regardless of the presence of *ELF3-Bay-0* or *ELF3-Sha*. On the contrary, significant differences were observed when *ELF3-Bay-0* and *ELF3-Sha* were the only functional *ELF3* alleles. In agreement with what we have shown before, plants carrying *ELF3-Bay-0* alleles present a stronger shade avoidance response than plants carrying *ELF3-Sha* alleles. {#pgen-1001100-g004} These experiments strongly suggest that Bay-0 and Sha alleles of *ELF3* induce different shade avoidance responses in Arabidopsis. HIF166L circadian rhythms {#s2e} ------------------------- *ELF3* functions as an important regulator of flowering time and light input to the circadian clock [@pgen.1001100-Liu1]. Therefore, *ELF3* alleles in HIF166L-Bay and HIF166L-Sha could be altering circadian rhythms in addition to developmental time. To test this, we transformed the homozygous HIF166L lines with a luciferase reporter gene driven by the *COLD, CIRCADIAN RHYTHM, AND RNA BINDING 2* (*CCR2*; AT2G21660) promoter (CCR2::*luc*) [@pgen.1001100-Strayer1]. Independent T1 plants were entrained in 12∶12 photoperiods for 6 days and released into constant red light, where circadian rhythms were measured by monitoring luminescence. Indeed, HIF166L lines carrying Bay-0 alleles had longer periods than the lines with the Sha allele ([Figure 5](#pgen-1001100-g005){ref-type="fig"}). Therefore, different alleles of *ELF3* affect both developmental time phenotypes and circadian rhythms, although the relationship between these two phenotypes cannot be discerned from this experiment. {#pgen-1001100-g005} *ELF3* complementation test {#s2f} --------------------------- Although *ELF3* is the strongest candidate for *SAR2*, one could argue that another of the 342 genes segregating in HIF166L could be interacting with the *elf3-1* allele to create the shade avoidance phenotypes observed in the quantitative complementation test. To rule out this possibility we cloned *ELF3-Bay* and *ELF3-Sha* alleles together with their own promoters and transformed them into *elf3-1* mutant background [@pgen.1001100-Zagotta1]. T1 plants carrying these constructs (*elf3-1* + *ELF3-Bay* and *elf3-1* + *ELF3-Sha*) were grown in simulated sun and shade environments and measured for their response to shade. [Figure 6A](#pgen-1001100-g006){ref-type="fig"} shows that *elf3-1* + *ELF3-Bay* plants present significantly greater acceleration of bolting and flowering and greater reduction of rosette diameter than *elf3-1* + *ELF3-Sha* plants, as predicted by the QTL analysis. Unexpectedly, these transgenic plants showed more similar phenotypes in simulated shade than in simulated sun, opposite to what we had seen in HIF166L ([Figure 2](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}). Interactions between the *ELF3-Bay* and *ELF3-Sha* alleles with the Col genetic background of the *elf3-1* mutants could explain these differences. {#pgen-1001100-g006} If *ELF3* is responsible for the differences in the circadian rhythms in the homozygous HIF166L we should observe similar differences in the *elf3-1* + *ELF3-Bay* and *elf3-1* + *ELF3-Sha* transgenic lines. T1 plants from these lines containing the CCR2:luc reporter gene were entrained in white light 12∶12 cycles and monitored either under constant red light (cR) or in constant red plus far red light conditions (cR+FR) to simulate sun and shade environments. We observed an overall increase in the period and a decrease in the amplitude of the oscillations of the reporter gene in plants grown in the shade ([Figures 6B and 6C](#pgen-1001100-g006){ref-type="fig"}). In concordance with the phenotypes observed in HIF166L, plants carrying *ELF3-Bay* alleles showed longer periods than plants carrying the *ELF3-Sha* allele. When comparing these period differences between alleles grown in both light conditions, we again see that plants with *ELF3-Bay* alleles have an increased response to low R:FR ratio. The ELF3-Bay alleles did not have a significant effect on the amplitude of the oscillations in response to shade ([Figures 6B and 6C](#pgen-1001100-g006){ref-type="fig"}). In summary, these transgenic experiments demonstrate that *ELF3* has an effect on the shade avoidance response and that Bay-0 and Sha alleles of this gene confer different responsiveness to the plants that carry them. Plants grown under simulated shade presented longer circadian periods and flowered earlier than plants grown under simulated sun, and the effect of Bay-0 alleles further increased circadian periodicity and shortened developmental time. Although it is temping to speculate that *ELF3* could determine the magnitude of the response to shade in the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population by modulating their circadian rhythms, we cannot discard the possibility of *ELF3* affecting both phenotypes independently. Discussion {#s3} ========== In this work we detected *SAR2*, a QTL on chromosome 2 for the shade avoidance response in the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population of Arabidopsis. We developed a network analysis that integrated genomic information available for Arabidopsis, allowing us to propose a candidate gene for the *SAR2*. We have shown that different natural alleles of *ELF3*, the gene predicted by the network analysis, differentially modulate the shade avoidance response, confirming its identity as the gene responsible for *SAR2* in the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population. Shade avoidance response in the Bay-0 x Sha RIL population {#s3a} ---------------------------------------------------------- We surveyed the shade avoidance response in adult plants grown in 12∶12 and 16∶8 photoperiods by measuring typical shade avoidance response traits [@pgen.1001100-Franklin1]. Only leaf angle, a well-established shade avoidance trait [@pgen.1001100-Mullen1], did not show significant changes across environments, probably due to the high variance of the measurements (data not shown). Leaf size traits, such as leaf blade width and length, were responsive to shade although they did not present significant variance among the Bay-0 x Sha RILs ([Figure S1](#pgen.1001100.s001){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). QTL analysis on the remaining traits resulted in distinct QTL profiles for plant size traits and developmental time traits, suggesting different underlying genetic mechanisms for each group of phenotypes ([Figures 1](#pgen-1001100-g001){ref-type="fig"} and [S3](#pgen.1001100.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Although rosette diameter may seem a measurement of plant size rather than developmental time the overlapping QTLs between this trait and other developmental time traits should not be surprising, since rosette diameter was measured at bolting time, and plants that take more time to bolt will grow bigger ([Figures 1](#pgen-1001100-g001){ref-type="fig"} and [S3](#pgen.1001100.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). The majority of QTLs were in common between the sun and the foliar shade environments, suggesting that most variation in these traits is controlled by loci that act independently of these light qualities. Previous QTL analyses on the same RIL population in high versus low density planting in natural environments resulted in the detection of a greater number of QTLs, which included *SAR2* and our developmental time QTLs in chromosome 1, 4 and 5 ([Figure S3](#pgen.1001100.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"} and [@pgen.1001100-Botto1]). It is quite possible that the effect of the natural environments and crowding in those experiments, versus our homogeneous light and temperature conditions, are responsible for the differences between these analyses. Comparison of the results from the QTL analysis performed in 16∶8 and 12∶12 photoperiods showed colocalization of the major QTLs in both photoperiods, although the size of the effects was always smaller in 16∶8 photoperiods, possibly due to the smaller number of lines assayed in 16∶8 (126) in comparison to the 12∶12 environment (253). On the other hand, the number and positions of minor QTLs differ, suggesting a number of photoperiod-specific loci affecting developmental time (see QTLs in simulated sun and shade on chromosomes 3 and 5, [Figures S3](#pgen.1001100.s003){ref-type="supplementary-material"} and [S5](#pgen.1001100.s005){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Previous analysis in the same RIL population performed in 16∶8 and 8∶16 photoperiods found similar results [@pgen.1001100-Botto1], [@pgen.1001100-Loudet1]. Network analysis {#s3b} ---------------- One of the benefits of working with Arabidopsis, and especially with the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population, is the wealth of genomic resources available [@pgen.1001100-Obayashi1], [@pgen.1001100-West1], [@pgen.1001100-1], [@pgen.1001100-Clark2]. The network analysis proposed here makes use of genome-wide datasets to identify genes potentially regulating other genes in their pathways. This analysis resulted in the identification of *ELF3* as a likely regulator of genes involved in circadian rhythms and/or flowering time such as *EARLY FLOWERING 4* (*ELF4*; AT2G40080), *CCR2* and *SNF1-RELATED PROTEIN KINASE 2-2* (*SnRK2.*2; AT3G50500) ([Figure 3](#pgen-1001100-g003){ref-type="fig"}) [@pgen.1001100-Doyle1]--[@pgen.1001100-Fujii1]. Our network method is largely based on genome-wide expression profiles (steps 1 and 3), and therefore it mainly identifies genes that exert their effect through alteration of the expression patterns in their pathways. Although one could imagine that a good number of the polymorphisms that have phenotypic consequences could directly or indirectly alter the expression of downstream genes, by no means is this always the case. The shade avoidance response is a complex process that has pleiotropic effects in the plant, therefore expression network modulation was expected. In cases where more specific phenotypes are under study, other kinds of data, such as protein-protein interaction, metabolic pathways or literature mining, can be added or used to construct the network. To illustrate this point, we applied the network analysis to *5*′*ADENYLYLPHOSPHOSULFATE REDUCTASE 2* (*APR2*; AT1G62180), a gene encoding a phosphosulfate reductase for which Sha has a reduced function allele that leads to high sulfate content [@pgen.1001100-Loudet2]. Network examination on the location of this gene did not detect *APR2* as a regulatory hub, probably due to its enzymatic function (data not shown). A major concern during the construction of our network method was the inability to identify uncharacterized genes. Since we used the functional classification of each candidate gene to identify significant connections with its partners, an uncharacterized gene will show no links. A good example illustrating this flaw is that our network analysis was not able to identify AT5G43630, a gene underlying a QTL for sulfate content in the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population [@pgen.1001100-Loudet3]. Due to its recent annotation, AT5G43630 was not included in the ATH1 microarrays and was therefore absent from the co-expression databases used in this work. As genome wide information becomes more abundant and annotation improves, this issue will be of lesser concern. Again, any kind of relational evidence can be used during this step. Although this network analysis will certainly not identify every causative polymorphism with an effect on a QTL, this methodology could be easily adapted to include any kind of relevant genome-wide datasets and may prove very useful in many QTL studies. *ELF3* and the shade avoidance response {#s3c} --------------------------------------- We have found here for the first time that ELF3 is involved in the regulation of flowering time and circadian rhythms in response to shade ([Figure 6](#pgen-1001100-g006){ref-type="fig"}). ELF3′s relation to shade could be through its interaction with the red light photoreceptor phyB [@pgen.1001100-Liu1], the main photoreceptor involved in the shade avoidance response [@pgen.1001100-Ballare1]. However, other possibilities need to be considered since ELF3 has been shown to regulate flowering time independently of phyB and to function downstream of the blue light photoreceptor CRY2 [@pgen.1001100-Liu1], [@pgen.1001100-Reed1], [@pgen.1001100-Yu1], which controls cotyledon unfolding in response to far-red light [@pgen.1001100-Botto2]. Additional photoreceptors, such as phyD and phyE, have been implicated in the shade avoidance response and could also modulate the effect of ELF3 [@pgen.1001100-Wollenberg1]. Our experiments show that natural alleles of *ELF3* differentially regulate circadian period and flowering time in response to shade ([Figure 6](#pgen-1001100-g006){ref-type="fig"}). ELF3 is a highly conserved plant specific nuclear protein that has been suggested to be part of the central clock oscillator and to act as a link between light and the circadian clock [@pgen.1001100-Liu1], [@pgen.1001100-Thines1]--[@pgen.1001100-Hicks1]. In addition, ELF3 affects flowering time in a photoperiod dependent manner through the classical *GIGANTEA* (*GI*; AT1G22770) and *CONSTANS* (CO, AT5G15840) pathway, but also through alternative pathways such as *SHORT VEGETATIVE PHASE* (SVP; AT2G22540) and *FLOWERING LOCUS C* (FLC; AT5G10140) [@pgen.1001100-Zagotta1], [@pgen.1001100-Yu1], [@pgen.1001100-Yoshida1]. Recent findings show that the shade avoidance response in flowering time is dependent of long day photoperiods and of functional *GI* and *CO* [@pgen.1001100-Wollenberg1], [@pgen.1001100-Kim2]. Wollenberg *et al*. showed that the shade treatment delays the peak expression of GI, which is in agreement with the delay in CCR2::luc rhythms that we observe under low R:FR conditions. Interestingly, we found that *ELF3-Bay-0*, which promoted stronger shade avoidance response, also promoted a larger delay in *CCR2::luc* rhythms ([Figure 6](#pgen-1001100-g006){ref-type="fig"}). It is thus possible that to accelerate flowering in response to shade, ELF3 delays the rhythmicity of GI through modulation of the circadian clock. However, it has been shown that ELF3 affects GI protein stability through direct binding, indicating that changes in circadian rhythms and flowering time could be independent from one another [@pgen.1001100-Yu1]. In fact, the promiscuous nature of ELF3 and the pleiotropic character of the shade avoidance response suggest a complex regulation of pathways in both cases. We have found that *ELF3* harbors natural polymorphisms determining its response to the shade treatment, which as an adaptive trait can affect the fitness of natural populations in their environments [@pgen.1001100-Schmitt1]. In our work the Bay-0 allele of *ELF3* conferred a greater response to the shade treatment than the Sha allele. The Arabidopsis accession Bay-0 was collected from a set-aside crop field in Germany while the Sha natural population grows at high altitude in the Pamir mountains (Tajikistan) [@pgen.1001100-Loudet1]. Stronger shade avoidance responses are expected and have been reported in plants from competitive environments such as arable land in comparison with alpine plants that grown surrounded by sparse vegetation [@pgen.1001100-Sasidharan1]. Although our findings support this hypothesis, additional experiments are needed to confirm the effect of *ELF3* under these particular environments. In summary, we have shown here that a network analysis approach utilizing multiple genomic databases can be a highly effective tool to identify causative genes in QTL analyses. Using this network approach we have identified *ELF3* as the candidate gene for a QTL affecting the shade avoidance response in the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population. We have proved that the Bay-0 and Sha alleles of *ELF3* differentially affect the shade avoidance response in circadian rhythms and developmental time traits. Materials and Methods {#s4} ===================== Plant material {#s4a} -------------- The Bay and Sha core RIL population as well as HIF144 and HIF166 were kindly provided by Dr. Olivier Loudet (INRA, Versailles, France). HIF144 and HIF166 are lines derived from F6 Bay-0 and Sha RILs that maintain residual heterozygosity in localized regions of their genomes. Luciferase expressing HIF166L-Bay and HIF166L-Sha T1 lines were obtained by *Agrobacterium tumefaciens* transformation of the homozygous HIF166L lines with CCR2::luc [@pgen.1001100-Strayer1]. The *elf3-1* mutant line has an EMS mutation in the Columbia background that causes an early stop codon and behaves like null alleles [@pgen.1001100-Zagotta1]. These plants also carry an additional mutation in *gl1* [@pgen.1001100-Reed1]. A stable *elf3-1* line with CCR2::luc was obtained from Dr. Stacey Harmer and Dr. Michael Covington. This line was transformed using *Agrobacterium tumefaciens* containing the Bay-0 and Sha alleles of *ELF3* together with 1.5 kb of their corresponding promoter region into the pJIHOON212 vector. We reciprocally crossed Col-0 and *elf3-1* plants to the HIF166L-Bay and HIF166L-Sha homozygous lines to obtain F1 lines for the quantitative complementation test. No statistically significant phenotypic differences were observed between reciprocal crosses. Plant growth {#s4b} ------------ All plants were grown in 16∶8 photoperiods unless stated. All developmental time experiments were performed by stratifying seeds for 4 days followed by planting in flats of 35 60 mm^2^ square pots using randomized block designs. After 5 days of incubation under white light, flats were positioned in Conviron chambers equipped with white and far-red fluorescent lights to simulate sun and shade environments. Red (655--665 nm) to far-red (725--735 nm) ratios in simulated sun ranged between 2.3 and 2.8 and between 0.50 and 0.58 in simulated shade. Photosynthetically active radiation ranged between 90 µmol m^−2^ s^−1^ and 97.1 µmol m^−2^ s^−1^, with an average of 94.8 µmol m^−2^ s. Temperature was kept constant at 20°C. The positions of the flats were changed in the growth chamber every 2 to 3 days to reduce light or temperature biases. To facilitate plant identification, each plant was assigned a barcoded tag indicating the genotype, position in the growth chamber, position in the flat and treatment. For the circadian rhythm experiments, T1 seedlings of the appropriate genotypes were plated on MS medium without sucrose and with the appropriate antibiotic, stratified for 4 days (4°C, dark), and entrained in 12∶12 photoperiods for 7 days. After entrainment, plants were transferred to new MS plates with antibiotics and moved to red light or red + far-red light conditions, where luminescence was recorded. Similar stratification and entrainment protocol as for the circadian rhythms experiments was followed for the transgenic experiment with rescued *elf3-1* plants, but after entrainment for 7 days resistant lines were transplanted to soil. Developmental time measurement {#s4c} ------------------------------ Petiole length, blade length and blade width were measured 38 days after germination using an electronic caliper. For leaf blade length and width the longest possible measurement was made in leaves 4 and 6. Leaf angle was measured 38 days after germination using an electronic protractor as the angle formed by the petiole of the leaf and the soil. Rosette diameter, bolting date and leaf number were measured when the rising meristem separated from the rosette. Rosette diameter was measured as the widest diameter found in the plant. This trait was not measured in the F1 plants used for the quantitative complementation test due to their increased size caused by hybrid vigor [@pgen.1001100-Meyer1]. Flowering time was recorded as the day of the first open flower. Statistical analyses {#s4d} -------------------- We obtained trait indexes for each RIL in the sun and shade environments fitting mixed effect models using the lme4 package in R [@pgen.1001100-Pinheiro1], [@pgen.1001100-R1]. These mixed effect models included treatment as a fixed effect and genotype, genotype x treatment, chamber, shelf, flat, row and column in the flat, and person measuring as random effects when significant. For each RIL, two shade avoidance response indices were calculated. For the subtraction index the indices in the shade for each RIL were subtracted to the indices in the sun. The residual indices correspond to the residuals from a regression of the trait indices in the shade on the sun indices. The signs of the residuals from this regression were reversed to obtain a more intuitive shade avoidance index in which higher values represent stronger shade avoidance responses. Phenotypic measurements whose distributions did not fit a normal distribution according to the Shapiro-Wilks test (p\<0.01) were transformed by taking the natural logarithm of each phenotype. All indices were subsequently calculated as for the untransformed traits. QTL analysis {#s4e} ------------ We performed QTL analysis of the sun and shade indexes as well as of the shade avoidance response indexes for each phenotypic trait in each of the 253 RILs. The genetic map for the Bay-0 x Sha RIL population consisted of 578 SFPs and microsatellites as described before [@pgen.1001100-West2], [@pgen.1001100-Loudet1]. QTL analysis was performed with the R/qtl package in R with the Interval Mapping (IM) and Composite Interval Mapping methods, obtaining similar results [@pgen.1001100-R1]--[@pgen.1001100-Zeng2]. LOD thresholds for significance of QTLs were estimated using 10,000 permutations of the phenotypic data. QTL analyses for the log-transformed datasets were similar to those for the non transformed datasets. QTL analyses of the subtraction and residual shade avoidance response indices also presented similar results. To select a subset of lines for repeating the QTL experiment in long days, we created a custom script in R that performed QTL analysis on 126 RILs randomly sampled from our population of 253 lines. After 25,000 permutations, the set of 126 lines that maximized the effect in *SAR2* was used in the LD experiment. Network analysis {#s4f} ---------------- Network analysis was performed separately using the 363 candidate genes included in the interval starting from gene AT2G24100 to AT2G27500 and in a subset of 133 candidate genes between AT2G25360 and AT2G26640 according to TAIR version 9 [@pgen.1001100-1]. Co-expression data for each gene was obtained from ATTED-II version c4.1 that was calculated including 1388 microarray experiments [@pgen.1001100-Obayashi1]. For each candidate gene we created an undirected network that linked each candidate gene to genes with correlation mutual ranks below 50 and over the maximum rank for that gene minus 50 [@pgen.1001100-Obayashi1]. Next, we narrowed the network and established directionality by removing co-expressed genes that did not have an eQTL in the position of the candidate gene according to the Bay-0 x Sha eQTL analysis [@pgen.1001100-West1]. Thus, we considered only those co-expressed genes whose expression levels are segregating in the Bay-0 and Sha RIL population and are differentially controlled by alleles located in the region of the candidate genes. eQTL confidence intervals were calculated as the interval where the eQTL has its maximum together with its contiguous intervals [@pgen.1001100-West1]. For each candidate gene in our network we looked for genes involved in similar processes by counting the number of co-expressed genes that shared one or more GO Slim terms with the candidate gene [@pgen.1001100-Berardini1]. GO categories describe aspects of a gene product\'s biology by assigning genes to cellular compartments, molecular functions and biological processes, and GO Slim terms are a subset of GO terms which give a broad overview of the ontology content without the detail of the specific fine grained GO terms [@pgen.1001100-Berardini1]. GO Slim terms were obtained from the GO SLIM dataset from TAIR, version of the 22nd of January 2010. Only GO terms under the relationship 'involved in', which imply biological processes, were used. Finally, we marked as polymorphic those genes that presented non-synonymous polymorphisms between Bay-0 and Sha according to [@pgen.1001100-Clark2] or had a cis-eQTL according to [@pgen.1001100-West1]. Custom R and Perl scripts carried out all these processes, and the results were plotted using Cytoscape [@pgen.1001100-Shannon1]. HIF and natural population genotyping {#s4g} ------------------------------------- Leaves from each plant in the fine mapping experiments were collected after the date of flowering and frozen at −80°C. DNA was extracted using the Promega DNA Purification System. Touchdown PCR was performed on this DNA in a MJ Research PTC-200 Thermocycler with a starting annealing temperature of 58°C, which decreased 0.5°C per cycle for 15 cycles and stayed constant at 55°C for 30 cycles. Extension time was 40 seconds and denaturizing steps were performed for 30 seconds at 96°C. PCR products were run in 3% agarose gel stained with EtBr and the genotype of the plant was assessed. The primers used for the PCRs were: MSAT2.36, F - CCAAGAACTCAAAACCGTT, R -- GATCTGCCTCTTGATCAGC; oJM88/89, F -- TCTTCACTTCCCCCAAGCGTTAC, R -- CCTTGAGGCAATGAACATCGGC; oJM29/30, F -- ATCAAGCAGAAGAAGAAACAAGAA, R -- GCAGGTGAAAACTGAATAGAACTT; oJM34/35, F -- GCAAATGAATGGACTTGATGGTT,R -- ACAGGGATTGGGCGGTGATGG; oJM40/77, F -- CCTCCTGGTAATGGCTACTTCCC, R -- ATTCTGGCAGCATTCTCACTCG; oJM41/42, F- GCTAACTCTGTGATGGCAACCG, R -- ATTAGGGCGTGAAAGCGACTG; nga1126, F -- CGCTACGCTTTTCGGTAAAG, R -- GCACAGTCCAAGTCACAACC; oJM94/95, F -- TCTTCTTCGTCTCTTTGGGCTTCG, R -- GATTTTAAGAAGAAGAATGCGGGG; oJM96/97, F -- CACACATAACAACAGACCCACTTCG, R -- CGAAGGAGGGTTTGGTTGCG; MSAT2.7, F -- CTCAAATCAAGAACGCTGAC, R -- CCCGATATAGACAACGACAA. All markers show insertion or deletion polymorphisms between Bay-0 and Sha and their positions are indicated in [Figure 2](#pgen-1001100-g002){ref-type="fig"}. Genotyping of Arabidopsis natural populations was performed using primer pair oJM40/77, which targets the tri-nucleotide polymorphism in ELF3. Circadian rhythm estimation {#s4h} --------------------------- All plants assayed for rhythmicity carried the luciferase gene driven by the circadian regulated promoter of the CCR2 gene (CCR2::luc)[@pgen.1001100-Strayer1]. In all cases plants were entrained as described above and imaged under constant conditions for 6 to 7 days. Constant red light (R, total PAR 64 uE) or constant red plus far red light (R+FR, total PAR 64uE with a R:FR ratio of 0.5) conditions were created with LED lights. Plants were monitored using a CCD camera taking pictures every 2 hours. The data collected was analyzed for rhythmicity using the luciferase activity method described in [@pgen.1001100-Plautz1]. Only rhythms with a Relative Amplitude Error below 0.5 were considered for the analysis. Circadian rhythm plots show average luminescence rhythms ± standard errors against time. Shaded regions in these graphs correspond to subjective nights. Supporting Information {#s5} ====================== ###### Phenotypic distribution for unresponsive traits. Phenotypic distributions of traits that did not show significant treatment or line by treatment shade avoidance response among the Bay-0 x Sha RILs grown in 12∶12 photoperiods. Lines plot the density of the distribution of the sun, shade and shade avoidance response residual indices calculated as detailed in [Materials and Methods](#s4){ref-type="sec"}. Closed circles and squares represent the estimated values for the Bay-0 and Sha parental strains respectively. (0.36 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Phenotypic distribution for responsive traits. Phenotypic distributions of traits that showed significant line by treatment effects among the Bay-0 x Sha RILs. Line plot the density of the distribution of the sun, shade and shade avoidance response residual indices calculated as detailed in [Materials and Methods](#s4){ref-type="sec"}. Leaf number and petiole length were measured only in 12∶12 photoperiods. (0.46 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### QTL analysis in simulated sun and simulated shade in 12_12 photoperiods. Results from the QTL analysis in simulated sun and shade under 12∶12 photoperiods. X-axis represents each of the 5 chromosomes of Arabidopsis, tick marks in the axis represent markers used in the genetic map. LOD score is represented in the y-axis. Representative estimations of the LOD thresholds are illustrated by horizontal dotted lines (Simulated sun, average  = 2.72, range  = 2.62-2.82; Simulated shade, average  = 2.67, range  = 2.53--2.80). (0.78 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Additive effect of *SAR2*. Additive effects (a, y-axis) are estimated as half the difference between the phenotypic averages of the residuals indices for the Bay-0 and Sha homozygotes. Positive numbers indicate that Bay-0 alleles increase the shade avoidance response with respect to Sha. Only chromosome 2 is represented. Additive effects ± standard errors are represented as a line enclosed in a light colored region. Blue and green lines represent additive effects in 12∶12 and 16∶8 respectively. (0.30 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### QTL analysis of the shade avoidance response in 16_8 photoperiods. QTL results for the Bay-0 and Sha RILs grown in long day photoperiods (16∶8) in simulated sun, simulated shade and for the shade avoidance response residual index. X-axis represents each of the 5 chromosomes of Arabidopsis, tick marks in the x-axis represent markers used from the genetic map. LOD score is represented in the y-axis. A representative estimation of the LOD threshold is illustrated by a horizontal dotted line. (0.70 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### HIF144 and HIF166 phenotypes under simulated shade. Phenotypes of HIF lines segregating for *SAR2*. A) HIF lines 144 and 166 are heterozygous for all or part of the confidence interval of the QTL in chromosome 2. Each horizontal line represents the region of interest in chromosome 2. Circles represent molecular markers used to genotype the plants. Numbers on top of the chromosomes indicate positions in megabases in the AGI map (TAIR 9). The colored boxed area represents the 2-LOD confidence interval for *SAR2*. B) Barplots represent bolting, flowering and rosette diameter average phenotypes measured in the progeny of the HIFs depicted in (A) grown under simulated shade. Names and numbers under each bar indicate genotype and number of plants assayed. Different letters on top of each bar represent significant differences between genotypes (p\<0.05, Tukey\'s HSD test). (0.31 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### Network analysis. Network analysis for the 363 genes located in the union of *SAR2*\'*s* confidence interval and HIF166-L heterozygous interval. Nodes represent genes. Only nodes with at least one edge are represented. Nodes with thick border are the candidate genes located in the interval. Edges connect genes that are co-expressed with the candidate gene and have an eQTL in the position of the candidate gene. Edges returning to the candidate genes represent cis eQTLs. Edges colored in red connect genes that share one or more functional category. Red color nodes are genes with polymorphisms between Bay-0 and Sha. The node representing the *ELF3* gene, which has more connections to functionally related genes than any other node in the network, is enclosed in a colored box. (3.21 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. ###### *ELF3* polymorphisms. *ELF3* polymorphic regions between Bay-0 and Sha. A) Polymorphisms found in the coding region and 1.5 kb upstream of the Bay-0 and Sha alleles of *ELF3* are indicated. Non-synonymous polymorphisms are indicated with the amino-acid changes found in parenthesis. B) Poly-Q insert size variation among natural populations of Arabidopsis. Marker bands have a size of 500 bp. 1- Kz-9, 2- est-1, 3- Bor-1, 4- NFA-10, 5- Bor 4, 6- NFA-8, 7- c24, 8- Nd-1, 9- sq-8, 10- Ler1, 11- wa-1, 12- Mz 0, 13- fer-0, 14- Van 0, 15- lp2-2, 16- Gu-0, 17- Lz-0, 18- Mr0, 19- Zdr-1, 20- ct-1, 21- Hr10, 22- Ra-0, 23- Uod-1, 24- Ws-0, 25- Col-0, 26- Ren-11, 27- An-1, 28- Wei-0, 29- Oy-0, 30- Se-0, 31- Wt-5, 32- Zdr-6, 33- Lp2-6, 34- Pu 2-7, 35- HR-5, 36- Gy-0, 37- Sorbo, 38- Nok-3, 39- Ull-2-3, 40- Pna-10, 41- Var 2-6, 42- Knox-18, 43- RRS-7, 44- RRS-10, 45- Kas 1, 46- Br-0, 47- CIBC5, 48- Kondara, 49- Ag-0, 50- Kas-1, 51- Ms-0, 52- Omo2-3, 53- CS22491, 54- Bur-0, 55- Knox-10, 56- Bor-1, 57- Kas-1, 58- CIBC-17, 59- Bill 7, 60- Wt-5, 61- Ts-5, 62- HR-5, 63- Pna 17, 64- Uod-7, 65- Var 2-1, 66- Sha, 67- Ts-1, 68- Ws-2, 69- Kin-0, 70- Rmx-A180, 71- Tsu-1, 72- Fab-4, 73- Mrk-0, 74- Lov-5, 75- Ren-1, 77- Pu 2-2-3. (0.47 MB PDF) ###### Click here for additional data file. We would like to thank Daniel Kliebenstein for giving us access the raw eQTL datasets for the Bay-0 and Sha population; to thank Olivier Loudet for providing us seeds for the Bay-0 and Sha RILs and the HIF144 and HIF166 lines and to thank Stacey Harmer and Michael Covington for providing the *elf3-1*::luc seeds. In addition, we thank Daniel Kliebenstein, Stacey Harmer, Aura Carreira, Daniel Fulop, Leonela Carriedo, and Matt Jones for their helpful comments on the manuscript. The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. This work was funded by the National Science Foundation ([www.nsf.gov](http://www.nsf.gov)) grants DBI-0227103 and DBI-0820854. The funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. [^1]: **¤:** Current address: Mendel Biotechnology, Inc., Hayward, California, United States of America [^2]: Conceived and designed the experiments: JMJG JNM. Performed the experiments: JMJG ADW. Analyzed the data: JMJG. Wrote the paper: JMJG.

Patient's Experience {#Sec1} ==================== I had a stroke 5 years ago. It was a severe hemorrhagic stroke. During the first 3 months I was not very well aware of my situation and do not remember what has happened then. I was able to move independently and to walk with support after 3 months, but my left hand did not function at all. I was determined to improve the situation! Indeed, I made progress in walking by reducing spasticity in the leg muscles, but the hand remained immovable. A few months later, I suffered from a deep achy pain in the paralyzed hand and in the leg, like muscle pain after an intense physical training. At the beginning, this pain appeared sporadically, but later it became my permanent companion. It was associated with spasticity as my doctor explained to me. The spasticity in my leg actually helped to straighten it, and I could walk more confidently with a stick without support. The situation with the hand was different: the fingers were bent into a fist and I could not straighten them, only with assistance and considerable effort. However, I did not give up and tried to continue doing exercises as it was advised earlier in the clinic. Over time the situation worsened and it became almost impossible to do exercises with my left hand and leg. Moreover, the pain became permanent. I consulted my doctor and he recommended botulinum toxin injections as a possible solution to my problem. I am not the person who gives up easily, so I agreed immediately despite the high price. At the beginning, we decided to try treatment only on the left hand. To my disappointment, I did not notice any effect of the procedure: my fist remained clenched and my wife helped me to unbend my hand to get dressed. Since it was already 2 years after the stroke, I began to despond and my hopes for recovery were disappearing. Nevertheless, I started to work again as car mechanic, which gave me additional opportunity to network with people and did not allow me to become depressed. My family was very supportive as well. Once I met an employee with the same problem at a gas station---his left hand was paralyzed, but he was able to use it to perform his duty. I asked him how he was living with this problem. He advised me to continue exercises despite everything and try to use the affected hand as much as possible. It incredibly supported and inspired me. Just a few months later I learned from my doctor about a possibility to take part in a clinical research for patients with a similar problem. The doctor explained that Cerebrolysin's ability to reduce spasticity in paralyzed limbs will be explored. One month later, after daily injections, I was able to dress myself and to raise my hand, and it became possible to unclench the fingers with assistance, which was previously impossible. I continued my exercises and my achy pain disappeared. At the end of the treatment course, I could walk without a walking stick for long distances! I continued to use my left hand as often as possible: when repairing cars, I tried to hold a wrench with my left hand, I tried to turn off lights and to take a shower without any assistance. I felt a sensation in my left hand, which was absent before; "a shape of an object in my hand" sensation returned, and coordination and accuracy of movements improved. I was especially happy that the effect was persistent and improved over time. It inspired and stimulated me to continue exercises. Now I can unbend the fingers, use my left hand at work and at home, and drive a car. Ten months have passed since the treatment course with Cerebrolysin. I still feel the effects of the treatment and plan to repeat the course. Physician's Perspective {#Sec2} ======================= The history of this patient is unusual for two reasons. First, the treatment of spasticity with Cerebrolysin is a new method, initially described by Martinez \[[@CR2]\]. Cerebrolysin has not been used previously for spasticity treatment in our practice. Secondly, it is rare that a patient remains highly motivated and continues exercises with such persistence to restore his motor functions. Usually, patients are more likely to rely on rehabilitation specialists and do not continue exercising at home properly after discharge from the clinic, and they often lose the hope for recovery. Spasticity is an important factor influencing rehabilitation progress negatively. Post-stroke spasticity causes painful sensations and the inability to use a paralyzed limb in everyday routine, which leads to the demotivation of the patient. I was intrigued to use Cerebrolysin in spasticity treatment for two reasons:Cerebrolysin intramuscular administration into a paralyzed spastic limb at a dosage of 10 ml daily over 1 month was shown to be effective and reduced spasticity symptoms in the long term \[[@CR2]\]. Furthermore, it can be combined with physical exercises within a standard rehabilitation program \[[@CR1]\].Additionally, its perceived antidepressant effect should improve the patient's general mood, increases motivation for physical activity, and improves cognitive function and motivation, which altogether may results in a significant positive outcome. The patient of this case study was male, born in 1959, and suffered from stroke on June 24th, 2013 with spasticity diagnosed on July 4th, 2013. The spasticity-related rehabilitation program was initiated on September 12th, 2017; at that time, the patient had an NIHSS score of 6. At follow-up 180 days later, the NIHSS score was 5 and the distal motor function score decreased from 2 to 0--1. In the manual muscle testing, the patient improved by approximately 70% and by 1--2 points in the Modified Ashworth Scale. Taking into account the small number of centers and insufficient number of specialists providing quality rehabilitative treatment in our country, the access to this type of care is limited. Therefore, treatment of spasticity with Cerebrolysin is an encouraging approach as it is easy to use, accessible, and affordable, and---most important---safe to use in outpatient care. However, a key factor for success in post-stroke spasticity management is the motivation of the patient and people supporting him/her to continue rehabilitation. If a rehabilitation program has a clear goal and achievable tasks that go beyond daily routine and allows patients to participate in social life again, it will make therapy more successful! **Enhanced digital features** To view enhanced digital features for this article, go to 10.6084/m9.figshare.7624022. Funding {#FPar1} ======= No funding or sponsorship was received for this study or publication of this article. Authorship {#FPar2} ========== All named authors meet the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) criteria for authorship for this article, take responsibility for the integrity of the work as a whole, and have given their approval for this version to be published. Disclosures {#FPar3} =========== Chemer Nataliia and Bilanovskyi Volodymyr have nothing to disclose. Compliance with Ethics Guidelines {#FPar4} ================================= This article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors. Open Access {#d29e279} =========== This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (<http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/>), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.

\section{INTRODUCTION} Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix is a standard candidate for the origins of $CP$ violation within a framework of the standard electroweak theory. In the minimal supersymmetric standard model (MSSM) \cite{MSSM} there appear some complex parameters if the supersymmetry (SUSY) is not an exact symmetry but is broken. So in addition to the phase of CKM matrix we have other sources of $CP$ violation in MSSM. It is well-known that these new $CP$ violating phases cause large electric dipole moments (EDMs) \cite{SusyEdm,KOPRD45,KOPRD46} which might give a denial or a signal of the existence of SUSY. Not only EDMs are the $CP$ violating phenomena expected in MSSM, but also $T$ or $CP$--odd asymmetries in the production of SUSY particles, such as neutralinos and charginos \cite{Kizukuri,Oshimo,KizuOshi}. These asymmetries are caused by tree diagrams so that they would not be too small to be tested by the future collider experiments in which the SUSY particles might be eventually produced. In this report we shall discuss first EDMs and show that SUSY particles, especially squarks and sleptons, are as heavy as a few TeV if the phases of the SUSY parameters are of order unity. Secondly we shall discuss the $T$--odd asymmetries and show that it is not impossible to observe the asymmetries as the manifestation of $CP$ violation originating from SUSY. Before closing this section, for the definiteness we show the MSSM Lagrangian, \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{ L = L_{kin} + L_{gauge} + L_F + L_S;} \nonumber \\ L_F &=& [ (E^c Y_E L)H_1 + (D^c Y_D Q)H_1 \nonumber \\ &&+ (U^c Y_UQ)H_2 + m_HH_1\times H_2 ]_F, \nonumber \\ - L_S &=& (\tilde E^c\eta_E\tilde L)\tilde H_1 + (\tilde D^c\eta_D\tilde Q)\tilde H_1 \nonumber \\ && + (\tilde U^c\eta_U\tilde Q)\tilde H_2 + \tilde M^2_H\tilde H_1\times \tilde H_2 \nonumber \\ && + {1\over 2}\sum_{i=1}^3{\tilde m}_i\lambda_i\lambda_i + \sum_{a,b}\tilde M_{ab}^2\phi_a^*\phi_b, \label{eq:MSSM} \end{eqnarray} to fix our notation of the relevant parameters. We assume the grand unification of the fundamental interactions, and relate some of these parameters in (\ref{eq:MSSM}) each other as \begin{eqnarray} \tilde M_{ab}^2 &=& |m_{3/2}|^2 \delta_{ab}, \nonumber \\ \eta_f &=& Am_{3/2} Y_f\ \ \ \ \ \ \ ( f = E, D, U ), \nonumber \\ \tilde M_H^2 &=& Bm_{3/2} m_H, \nonumber \\ {\tilde m}_i &=& M_\lambda \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ( i = 1, 2, 3 ), \label{eq:GutCondition} \end{eqnarray} to reduce the number of the parameters. The parameters $Am_{3/2}$, $Bm_{3/2}$, $m_H$, and $M_\lambda$ in (\ref{eq:GutCondition}) are complex in general, and can become sources of $CP$ violation. However, all the phases are not physical, but two of them are physical. So in this report we take $Am_{3/2}$ and $m_H$ to be complex, and $Bm_{3/2}$ and $M_\lambda$ to be real, for simplicity. \section{ELECTRIC DIPOLE MOMENTS} EDMs of the quarks ( leptons ) are given by the one-loop diagrams by exchange of the squarks $\tilde q$ ( sleptons $\tilde\ell$ ) and the charginos $\omega_i$, the neutralinos $\chi_j$, or the gluinos $\tilde g$ (not for the lepton EDM ). People think that the gluino loop gives the largest contribution to EDMs of the quarks because the strong coupling constant is much larger than the electroweak coupling constant. Its typical estimate commonly made for the $u$-quark is like \begin{eqnarray} d_u^G/e &\simeq & {2\alpha_s\over 9\pi \tilde{m_3}}{{\rm Im}(Am_{3/2})m_u \over \tilde{m_3}^2}I'(\tilde {M_q}^2/\tilde{m_3}^2), \nonumber \\ I(x) &=& {1\over (1-x)^2}(1 + x + {2x\over 1-x}{\rm ln}x). \label{eq:edmg} \end{eqnarray} Assuming that the gluino mass ($\tilde{m_3}$) and the squark masses ($\tilde {M_q}$) are 100 GeV, we would get the $u$-quark EDM of $10^{-22} e\cdot$cm. This is much larger than the present experimental upper bound of the neutron EDM, $10^{-25} e\cdot$cm \cite{edmnexp}, so we might have to assume that the SUSY parameters are almost real. However fortunately or unfortunately, the SUSY particles such as squarks and gluinos have not yet been discovered, and their masses are larger than 100 GeV. Since, the heavier they are, the smaller EDM becomes, even if the SUSY phases are of order unity, sufficiently large SUSY particle masses can reduce EDM. Thus it is not a bad question to ask how heavy the SUSY particles should be to reduce EDM to the value smaller than its experimental bound. To answer this question we calculate the EDM of the neutron arising from the gluino, chargino, and neutralino loops taking maximal $CP$ violating phases. The results are shown in Figs.~1--4. \begin{figure}[htb] \special{psfile=edmfig3.ps hscale=0.4 vscale=0.4 rotation=-90 hoffset=-28 voffset=14} \vspace{6.0cm} \caption{(i) The chargino, (ii) neutralino, and (iii) gluino contributions to the neutron EDM for $\tan\beta = 2$, $\m2 = |m_H| = 0.5 $TeV. } \label{fig:edmcng} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[htb] \special{psfile=edmfig2.ps hscale=0.4 vscale=0.4 rotation=-90 hoffset=-28 voffset=14} \vspace{6.0cm} \caption{The neutron EDM from the chargino contribution. The values of the parameters are shown in Table~1, and $\tan\beta = 2$ for (a) and $\tan\beta = 10$ for (b).} \label{fig:edmc} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[htb] \special{psfile=edmfig6a.ps hscale=0.4 vscale=0.4 rotation=-90 hoffset=-28 voffset=14} \vspace{6.0cm} \caption{The neutron EDM as a function of $|m_H|$ for $\tan\beta = 2$. The gaugino mass $\m2$ is 1 TeV for (a) and 3 TeV for (b). The squark mass $\tilde {M_q}$ is 0.2 TeV for (i) and 1 TeV for (ii).} \label{fig:edmnmH} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[htb] \special{psfile=edmfig6b.ps hscale=0.4 vscale=0.4 rotation=-90 hoffset=-28 voffset=14} \vspace{6.0cm} \caption{The neutron EDM as a function of $\m2$ for $\tan\beta = 2$. The higgsino mass $|m_H|$ is 1 TeV for (a) and 3 TeV for (b). The squark mass $\tilde {M_q}$ is 0.2 TeV for (i) and 1 TeV for (ii).} \label{fig:edmnm2} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[htb] \special{psfile=edmfig7.ps hscale=0.4 vscale=0.4 rotation=-90 hoffset=-28 voffset=14} \vspace{6.0cm} \caption{The electron EDM from the chargino contribution. The parameters are the same as in Fig.~\ref{fig:edmc}.} \label{fig:edme} \end{figure} \begin{table}[hbt] \caption{The values of $\m2$ and $|m_H|$ in Figs.~\ref{fig:edmc} and \ref{fig:edme}} \label{tab:parameter} \begin{tabular}{lcccc} \hline & (i) & (ii) & (iii) & (iv) \\ \hline $\m2$ (TeV) & $0.2$ & $1.0$ & $0.2$ & $1.0$ \\ $|m_H|$ (TeV) & $0.2$ & $0.2$ & $1.0$ & $1.0$ \\ \hline \end{tabular} \end{table} The Fig.~\ref{fig:edmcng} shows as a function of the squark mass the absolute values of EDMs by the chargino, neutralino, and gluino loops which contribute to the neutron EDM. It should be noted that EDM from the chargino is larger than EDM from the gluino in this case, which would be contrary to the naive expectation. The reason of this comes mainly from the GUT mass relation $(\alpha_2/\alpha_3) \tilde{m_3} = \m2$ which we assumed in the calculation. The large $SU(3)$ coupling $\alpha_3$, which could make (\ref{eq:edmg}) large, leads to the large gluino mass, which almost cancels the enhancement by the strong coupling. In addtion to this, since the mixing between left--handed and right--handed squarks, which is needed for the EDM operator by the gluino loop, is small, the magnitude of the gluino contribution to the neutron EDM is suppressed to be smaller than that of the chargino. The Fig.~\ref{fig:edmc} shows the chargino contribution to the neutron EDM for the different values of the parameters, $\tan\beta$, $\m2$, and $|m_H|$, as a function of the squark mass. In this parameter region the chargino contributes to the neutron EDM the most, and therefore its contribution can be taken to be approximately equal to the whole neutron EDM. From the figure it can be seen that, if the squark mass is larger than about 3 TeV for $\tan\beta =2$ and 7 TeV for $\tan\beta = 10$, the predicted value can be smaller than the present experimental upper bound of $10^{-25}e\cdot$~cm, even though the SUSY $CP$ phase is of order one. This is the light gaugino case. Can the squarks be lighter than 3 TeV? Figs.~\ref{fig:edmnmH} and \ref{fig:edmnm2} try to answer the question, and show the squarks can be really as light as 0.2 TeV if $\m2$ and $|m_H|$ are heavier than about 2 TeV. However, since EDM does not decrease as rapidly as in Fig.~\ref{fig:edmc} (even begins to increase when $|m_H|$ becomes large!), the light squark possibility would be denied if the experimental bound on the neutron EDM is reduced by one order of magnitude. The electron EDM is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:edme}. Its present experimental upper bound is $10^{-26} e\cdot$cm \cite{edmeexp}. If the slepton is heavier than about 1 TeV for $\tan\beta = 2$ and 4 TeV for $\tan\beta = 10$, the predicted value can be smaller than the present experimental limit. \section{T(CP)--ODD ASYMMETRY} In the previous section it was realized that the present experimental bounds on the neutron and electron EDMs do not exclude the possibility that the SUSY $CP$ phases are of order unity. What $CP$ violating phenomena will be expected to come out from these new phases in high energy collider experiments? One possibility is the $T$--odd asymmetry \cite{Kizukuri,Oshimo,KizuOshi} in the production and decay processes of the SUSY particles. In MSSM the asymmetry can appear at the tree level. To be definite, let us consider the production processes of two different charginos mediated by $Z$--boson, \begin{equation} e^+e^- \rightarrow \ch2^+ \ch1^-, \label{eq:epmw12} \end{equation} and two different neutralinos, \begin{equation} e^+e^- \rightarrow \chi_i \chi_j. \label{eq:epmxij} \end{equation} The charginos and the neutralinos are the mixed states of the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ gauginos and the higgsinos. To get them as the mass eigenstates, we have to diagonalize their mass matrices by unitary matrices which contain imaginary phases originating from the complex SUSY parameters. When we rewrite the gaugino and higgsino couplings to $Z$ by the mass eigenstates through the unitary transformations, there appear off-diagonal couplings of the charginos and neutralinos to $Z$. Their coupling constants are made from the complex elements of the unitary matrices. Moreover their relative phases can not be absorbed, and remain physical. Thus these off-diagonal couplings to $Z$ cause $T(CP)$ violation at the tree level, and the violation can be expected to be large enough to be observed. First we discuss the $T$--odd asymmetry in the chargino production process (\ref{eq:epmw12}). When the spin of $\ch2$, $s_2$, is summed, but the spin of $\ch1$, $s_1$ (which will be chosen such as it is perpendicular to the interaction plane), is not summed, the cross section becomes in the CM system of $e^+e^-$ as \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{\sum_{s_2}d\sigma(e^+e^- \rightarrow {\ch2}^+ {\ch1}^-)} \nonumber \\ \lefteqn{= {G_F^2\over 2\pi}{p\over \sqrt S} {M_Z^4\over (S-M_Z^2)^2 + \Gamma_Z^2M_Z^2}\times} \nonumber \\ \lefteqn{\ \times \bigl[(f_L^2 + f_R^2)( (|G_L^{12}|^2 + |G_R^{12}|^2)(E_1E_2 + p^2/3)} \nonumber \\ \lefteqn{\ + 2\Re(G_L^{12}{G_R^{12}}^*) \mw1\mw2 )} \nonumber \\ \lefteqn{\ + {\rm sign}(s_1)(f_L^2 - f_R^2)\Im(G_L^{12}{G_R^{12}}^*) {\pi\over 2}\mw2\ p \bigr],} \label{eq:CharginoCrossSection} \end{eqnarray} where $p$ is the magnitude of the momentum of the chargino, $E_{1, 2}$ are the energies of ${\ch1}_{ ,2}$, $G_{L, R}^{12}$ are the coupling constants of the charginos to $Z$ defined as \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{J^Z_{\mu} = e\bar{\ch1}\gamma_{\mu}[G_L^{11}P_- + G_R^{11}P_+]\ch1} \nonumber \\ && + e\bar{\ch2}\gamma_{\mu}[ G_L^{22}P_- + G_R^{22}P_+ ]\ch2 \nonumber \\ && + e\bar{\ch1}\gamma_{\mu}[ G_L^{12}P_- + G_R^{12}P_+ ]\ch2 \nonumber \\ && + e\bar{\ch2}\gamma_{\mu}[ G_L^{21}P_- + G_R^{21}P_+ ]\ch1, \label{eq:CharginoNeutralCurrent} \end{eqnarray} $f_{L, R}$ are the coupling constants of the electron to $Z$, and sign$(s_1)$ is defined by the three momentum of the incident electron, ${\bf p^-}$, and the three momentum of $\ch1$, ${\bf p}_1$, as sign$(s_1)$ = sign(${\bf s}_1\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_1)$). The term breaking $T$ invariance is the last term in (\ref{eq:CharginoCrossSection}). Because it depends on $s_1$, we must observe at least a spin state of either chargino to detect the $T$ violation effect. The positive sign of $s_1$ means a vector product ${\bf s}_1\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_1)$ is positive, and the negative sign of $s_1$ means ${\bf s}_1\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_1) < 0$. Since these two states are transformed to each other by time reversal, the difference of the cross section between these two states manifests $T$ violation at the first-order perturbation. The asymmetry of these two states \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{ A_T = } \label{eq:CharginoAsymmetry}\\ \lefteqn{ {d\sigma({\bf s}_1\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_1)>0) - d\sigma({\bf s}_1\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_1)<0) \over d\sigma({\bf s}_1\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_1)>0) + d\sigma({\bf s}_1\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_1)<0)},} \nonumber \end{eqnarray} may be a good observable to quantify how large the $T$ violation is. As a numerical example, we show the result of a parameter set of $\tan\beta = 2$, $\m2 = 200$ GeV, and $m_H = 200 {\rm e}^{i\pi/4}$ GeV, which leads to the chargino masses 133, 275 GeV, and the neutralino masses 83, 145, 203, 278 GeV. The neutron and electron EDMs for this parameter set is shown in Table~\ref{tab:edm} by taking the squark and slepton masses for 3 TeV. Their values are smaller than the present experimental bounds \cite{edmnexp,edmeexp}. \begin{table}[hbt] \caption{Electric dipole moments} \label{tab:edm} \begin{tabular}{lcc} \hline & Neutron & Electron \\ & [$10^{-25} e\cdot$~cm] & [$10^{-27} e\cdot$~cm] \\ \hline Gluino & $ 0.2 $ & $ / $ \\ Chargino & $ -1.0 $ & $-4.2 $ \\ Neutralino & $ 0.003$ & $ 0.04 $ \\ Exp. & $ < 1.2$ & $-2.7\pm8.3$ \\ \hline \end{tabular} \end{table} The calculated asymmetry is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:CharginoAsymmetry} as a function of the CM energy ($\sqrt S$). \begin{figure}[htb] \special{epsfile=tce.ps hscale=0.46 vscale=0.46 hoffset=-5 voffset=60} \vspace{5.5cm} \caption{The $T$--odd asymmetry in the chargino production. The solid line corresponds to unpolarized electron beam, and the dashed line corresponds to left-handedly polarized electron beam.} \label{fig:CharginoAsymmetry} \end{figure} When the incident electron beam is unpolarized, the magnitude of the asymmetry is smaller than $10^{-2}$ despite the tree level effect. This is due to the almost pure-axial coupling of the electron to $Z$. When the incident electron beam is polarized, the asymmetry is enhanced by about 6 times as large as the unpolarized case. Secondly we discuss the $T$--odd asymmetry in the neutralino production process (\ref{eq:epmxij}). As in the chargino production, by summing the spin of $\chi_j$, $s_j$, but the spin of $\chi_i$, $s_i$, is not summed, we get the cross section in the CM system of $e^+e^-$ as \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{\sum_{s_j} d\sigma(e^+e^- \rightarrow \chi_i \chi_j)} \nonumber \\ &=& {G_F^2 \over 4\pi}{p\over \sqrt S} {M_Z^4\over (S-M_Z^2)^2 + \Gamma_Z^2M_Z^2}|O_Z|^2\times \nonumber \\ &\times& \bigl[(f_L^2 + f_R^2)(E_iE_j + p^2/3 - \cos 2\delta_Z m_{\chi i} m_{\chi j}) \nonumber \\ &+& {\rm sign}(s_i)(f_L^2 - f_R^2){\pi\over 4}\sin 2\delta_Z m_{\chi j} \ p\bigr], \label{eq:NeutralinoCrossSection} \end{eqnarray} where $p$ is the magnitude of the momentum of the neutralino, $E_{i, j}$ are the energies of $\chi_{i, j}$, and sign$(s_i)$ = sign(${\bf s}_i\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_i))$. $O_Z$ is the coupling constant of the neutralinos to $Z$ defined as \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{{\cal L}_{\rm int}^Z = {\strut e\over \displaystyle \sin 2\theta_W}\bar\chi_i \gamma_{\mu}( O_Z P_- - O_Z^*P_+ )\chi_j Z^{\mu}; } \nonumber \\ &&P_{\pm} = (1 \pm \gamma_5)/2, \end{eqnarray} and $\delta_Z = \arg (O_Z)$. Again we have the $T$ violating term in (\ref{eq:NeutralinoCrossSection}), and we can define an asymmetry \begin{eqnarray} \lefteqn{ A_T = } \label{eq:NeutralinoAsymmetry}\\ \lefteqn{ {d\sigma({\bf s}_i\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_i)>0) - d\sigma({\bf s}_i\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_i)<0) \over d\sigma({\bf s}_i\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_i)>0) + d\sigma({\bf s}_i\cdot ({\bf p^-\times p}_i)<0)},} \nonumber \end{eqnarray} which quantifies how large the $T$ violation is. It should be noted that, differently from the chargino production, the final state of the process (\ref{eq:epmxij}) is an eigenstate of $CP$ because of the neutralinos being the Majorana particles, so that the asymmetry (\ref{eq:NeutralinoAsymmetry}) is a $CP$--odd asymmetry. Thus a non-vanishing value of (\ref{eq:NeutralinoAsymmetry}) directly means the violation of $CP$. The calculated asymmetry is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:NeutralinoAsymmetry} as a function of $\sqrt S$. \begin{figure}[htb] \special{epsfile=tne.ps hscale=0.46 vscale=0.46 hoffset=-5 voffset=60} \vspace{5.5cm} \caption{The $T$--odd asymmetry in the neutralino production. The solid line corresponds to unpolarized electron beam, and the dashed line corresponds to left-handedly polarized beam.} \label{fig:NeutralinoAsymmetry} \end{figure} The magnitude of the asymmetry is approximately the same as the chargino one. We also have calculated an asymmetry of the lepton pair produced by the decay of $\chi_j$, $A'_T$, which is more realistic than (\ref{eq:CharginoAsymmetry}) and (\ref{eq:NeutralinoAsymmetry}) because we only have to measure the momenta of the final state leptons, ${\bf p}_D^{\pm}$, intead of the spin of $\chi_j$ being experimentally difficult to be measured. In Fig.~\ref{fig:NeutralinoAsymmetry} the result in the left-handedly polarized electron beam case is shown by dots. The magnitude of $A'_T$ is the same order as $A_T$ near the threshold, but it rapidly decreases as $\sqrt S$ becomes large. This is because, as $\sqrt S$ becomes large, $E_i$ also becomes large so that ${\bf p}_D^+$ and ${\bf p}_D^-$ come to orient to the same direction. Since the $T$ violation term is proportional to ${\bf p^-\cdot (p}_D^+\times {\bf p}_D^-)$, $A'_T$ decreases as $\sqrt S$ gets large. Therefore, if one wishes to get a large asymmetry, the asymmetry should be measured near the threshold. \section{DISCUSSION} In this report we have viewed $CP(T)$ violation in MSSM. The present experimental bounds on the neutron and electron EDMs do not immediately rule out the possibility that the imaginary phases of the SUSY parameters have their natural values of ${\cal O}(1)$. If this is the case, the $CP$ violation originating from MSSM could lead to $T(CP)$--odd phenomena in high energy experiments. If the charginos and neutralinos are produced in $e^+e^-$ collisions, $T$--odd asymmetry would be observed in the angular distribution of the final decay products. In the $T(CP)$-odd asymmetries discussed here two different mass eigenstates of the charginos or neutralinos are involved. In the pair production of the charginos or neutralinos of the same mass eigenstate, does the asymmetry appear? The answer is 'yes' for the charginos. The electric and the weak "electric" dipole moments of the charginos, $D_{\omega}$, are generated at one-loop level, which break $T$ invariance. These dipole moment terms give rise to $T$--odd asymmetry in the same chargino pair-production processes. However, from the dimensional grounds, $A_T$ in this case can be roughly estimated as $A_T \sim {\sqrt S}D_{\omega}/e$. The main contributions to $D_{\omega}$ are given by the loop diagrams involving the top quark, the top squarks, the $W$ bosons, and/or the Higgs bosons. The top or stop contribution to $D_{\omega}$ is proportional to the large top-quark mass. However, within MSSM the magnitude of $D_{\omega}$ is strictly restricted by the upper bounds of the neutron and electron EDMs, and it would be at most $10^{-20} e\cdot$cm, if $m_t \sim 150$ GeV and unless one of the scalar quarks is accidentally much lighter than the other scalar quarks and leptons. The contributions from the $W$ bosons, and the Higgs bosons are roughly estimated to be also $10^{-20} e\cdot$cm. Thus we could expect in $e^+e^- \rightarrow \omega_i \bar{\omega_i}$ $A_T \sim 10^{-4}$ which would be too small for detection in the future $e^+e^-$ experiments.

\section{Introduction} We introduce $\delta$-viscosity solutions for the nonlinear parabolic problem \begin{equation} \label{eq:main} u_t-F(D^2u)=0 \quad \text{ in } \Omega \times (0,T). \end{equation} We prove an estimate between viscosity solutions and $\delta$-viscosity solutions of (\ref{eq:main}) under the assumption that the nonlinearity $F$ is uniformly elliptic (see (F\ref{ellipticity}) below). As a consequence, we find a rate of convergence for monotone and consistent implicit finite difference approximations to (\ref{eq:main}). Both results generalize the work of Caffarelli and Souganidis in \cite{Approx schemes} and \cite{Rates Homogen}, who consider the time-independent case. The nonlinearity $F$ is a continuous function on $\mathcal{S}_{n\times n} \times U$, where $\mathcal{S}_{n\times n}$ is the set of $n\times n$ real symmetric matrices endowed with the usual order and norm (for $X\in \mathcal{S}_{n\times n}$, $||X|| = \sup_{|v|=1}|Xv|$). We make the following assumptions: \begin{enumerate}[({F}1)] \item \label{ellipticity} $F$ is uniformly elliptic with constants $0<\lambda \leq \Lambda$, which means that for any $X \in \mathcal{S}_{n\times n}$ and for all $Y\geq 0$, \[ \lambda||Y|| \leq F(X+Y)-F(X) \leq \Lambda||Y||; \] and, \item \label{last prop of F} $F(0)=0$. \end{enumerate} We also assume: \begin{enumerate}[({U}1)] \item \label{assum U} $\Omega$ is a bounded subset of $\ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$. \end{enumerate} The main result is an error estimate between viscosity solutions and $\delta$-viscosity solutions of (\ref{eq:main}). The definition of $\delta$-viscosity solutions is in Section \ref{subsection:delta def}. Next we present a statement of our main result that has been simplified for the introduction; the full statement is in Section \ref{section: comparison}. \begin{thm} \label{thm:vague comparison} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}), (F\ref{last prop of F}) and (U1). Assume $u$ is a viscosity solution of (\ref{eq:main}) that is Lipschitz continuous in $x$ and H\"older continuous in $t$. Assume $\{u_\delta\}_{\delta>0}$ is a family of H\"older continuous $\delta$-viscosity solutions of (\ref{eq:main}) that satisfy \[ u_\delta = u \text{ on the parabolic boundary of $\Omega \times (0,T)$ } \] for all $\delta$. There exist positive constants $C$ and $\alpha$ that do not depend on $\delta$ such that for all $\delta$ small enough, \[ ||u-u_\delta||_{L^{\infty}(\Omega \times (0,T))} \leq C\delta^\alpha . \] \end{thm} We remark that if $u$ is the solution of a boundary value problem with sufficiently regular boundary data, then the regularity conditions on $u$ of Theorem \ref{thm:vague comparison} are satisfied (see Remark \ref{remAboutLips} for more details). We make this an assumption in order to avoid discussing boundary value problems and to keep the setting as simple as possible. The notion of $\delta$-viscosity solutions was introduced by Caffarelli and Souganidis in \cite{Approx schemes} as a tool for obtaining uniform estimates for viscosity solutions. In \cite{Approx schemes}, $\delta$-viscosity solutions were used to establish an error estimate for finite difference approximations of nonlinear uniformly elliptic equations. An error estimate between viscosity and $\delta$-viscosity solutions of uniformly elliptic equations was obtained by Caffarelli and Souganidis in \cite{Rates Homogen}. This was an important step in establishing a rate for homogenization in random media \cite{Rates Homogen}. The main challenge in obtaining an error estimate between viscosity and $\delta$-viscosity solutions, in both the elliptic and parabolic setting, is overcoming the lack of regularity of the viscosity solution $u$. Indeed, the proof of the error estimate in \cite{Approx schemes} is based on a regularity result \cite[Theorem A]{Approx schemes}, which says that outside of sets of small measure, solutions of uniformly elliptic equations have second-order expansions with controlled error. We prove a similar result for solutions of equation (\ref{eq:main}). This is Theorem \ref{Thm A} of this paper, and it is an essential part of our proof of Theorem \ref{thm:vague comparison}. But even once it is known that the solution $u$ of (\ref{eq:main}) has second-order expansions with controlled error, it is necessary to further regularize $u$ and the $\delta$-viscosity solution $u_\delta$ in order establish an estimate for their difference. For this we use the classical inf- and sup- convolutions, along with another regularization of inf-sup type, which we call $x$-sup- and $x$-inf- convolutions. Both of these regularizations preserve the notions of viscosity and $\delta$-viscosity solution. Moreover, we show that the regularity we establish in Theorem \ref{Thm A} for solutions $u$ of (\ref{eq:main}) is also enjoyed by the $x$-inf and $x$-sup convolutions of $u$ (Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}). In this paper we also study implicit finite difference approximations to (\ref{eq:main}) and prove an error estimate between the solution $u$ of (\ref{eq:main}) and approximate solutions to (\ref{eq:main}). We have simplified the notation in the introduction in order to state this result here; see Section \ref{section: approx} for all the details about approximation schemes and for the full statement of the error estimate. We write the finite difference approximations as \begin{equation} \label{eq:main h} \ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[u](x,t) = \delta^-_{\tau} u (x,t) - \mathcal{F}_h(\delta^2 u(x,t))=0 \text{ in } (\Omega \times (0,T))\cap E. \end{equation} Here $E=h\ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}^n \times h^2\ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}$ is the mesh of discretization, $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[u]$ is the implicit finite difference operator, and $\delta^-_{\tau} u$ and $\delta^2 u$ are finite difference quotients associated to a function $u$. We assume: \begin{enumerate}[({S}1)] \item \label{monotone} if $u_h^1$ and $u_h^2$ are solutions of (\ref{eq:main h}) with $u_h^1\leq u_h^2$ on the discrete boundary of $\Omega\times(0,T)$, then $u_h^1\leq u_h^2$ in $\Omega\times(0,T)$; and \item \label{consistent} there exists a positive constant $K$ such that for all $\phi\in C^3(\Omega\times(0,T))$ and all $h>0$, \[ \sup|\phi_t-F(D^2\phi)-\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[\phi]|\leq K(h+ h\linfty{D_x^3\phi}{\Omega\times (0,T)} + h^2\linfty{\phi_{tt}}{\Omega\times (0,T)}). \] \end{enumerate} Schemes that satisfy (S\ref{monotone}) and (S\ref{consistent}) are said to be, respectively, \emph{monotone} and \emph{consistent with an error estimate for $F$}. We prove: \begin{thm} \label{thm:mesh comparison vague} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}), (F\ref{last prop of F}) and (U1). Assume that $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ is a monotone implicit approximation scheme for (\ref{eq:main}) that is consistent with an error estimate. Assume $u$ is a viscosity solution of (\ref{eq:main}) that is Lipschitz continuous in $x$ and H\"older continuous in $t$ and that $u_h$ is a H\"older continuous solution of (\ref{eq:main h}). Assume that for each $h>0$, \[ u_h=u \text{ on the discrete boundary of $\Omega\times(0,T)$}. \] There exist positive constants $C$ and $\alpha$ that do not depend on $h$ such that for every $h$ small enough, \[ ||u-u_h||_{L^{\infty}(\Omega \times (0,T))} \leq Ch^\alpha. \] \end{thm} The convergence of monotone and consistent approximations of fully nonlinear second order PDE was first established by Barles and Souganidis \cite{BarlesSouganidis}. Kuo and Trudinger later studied the existence of monotone and consistent approximations for nonlinear elliptic and parabolic equations and the regularity of the approximate solutions $v_h$ (see \cite{KT estimates, Kuo Trudiner elliptic ops, Kuo Trudinger max princip parabolic, Kuo Trudinger parabolic diff ops}). They showed, both in the elliptic and in the parabolic cases, that if $F$ is uniformly elliptic, then there exists a monotone finite difference scheme $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ that is consistent with $F$, and that the approximate solutions $u_h$ are uniformly equicontinuous. However, obtaining an error estimate remained an open problem. The first error estimate for approximation schemes was established by Krylov in \cite{Krylov 1998} and \cite{Krylov 1999} for nonlinearities $F$ that are either convex or concave, but possibly degenerate. Krylov used stochastic control methods that apply in the convex or concave case, but not in the general setting. Barles and Jakobsen in \cite{BarlesJakobsen2002} and \cite{BarlesJakobsen2005} improved Krylov's error estimates for convex or concave equations. In \cite{Krylov2005} Krylov improved the error estimate to be of order $h^{1/2}$, but still in the convex/concave case. In addition, Jakobsen \cite{Jakobsen2004, Jakobsen2006} and Bonnans, Maroso, and Zidani \cite{Bonnans} established error estimates for special equations or for special dimensions. The first error estimate without a convexity or concavity assumption was obtained Caffarelli and Souganidis in \cite{Approx schemes} for nonlinear elliptic equations. To our knowledge, Theorem \ref{thm:mesh comparison vague} is the first error estimate for nonlinear parabolic equations that are neither convex nor concave. Our paper is structured as follows. In Section \ref{preliminaries} we establish notation, give the definition of $\delta$-viscosity solutions, and state several known results. In Section \ref{section: regularity} we prove Theorem \ref{Thm A}, the regularity result that is essential for the rest of our arguments. In Section \ref{section: Two different inf- and sup- convolutions} we discuss regularizations of inf-sup type and establish Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}, a version of Theorem \ref{Thm A} for $x$-sup and $x$-inf convolutions. In Section \ref{section: main prop} we prove a key estimate between viscosity solutions of (\ref{maineqn}) and sufficiently regular $\delta$-solutions of (\ref{maineqn}). Theorems \ref{thm:vague comparison} and \ref{thm:mesh comparison vague} are straightforward consequences of this estimate. In Section \ref{section: comparison} we give the precise statement and proof of Theorem \ref{thm:vague comparison}. Section \ref{section: approx} is devoted to introducing the necessary notation and stating known results about approximation schemes. The precise statement and proof of the error estimate for approximation schemes is in Section \ref{section:error est approx}. We also include an appendix with known results about inf- and sup- convolutions. \section{Preliminaries} \label{preliminaries} In this section we establish notation, recall the definition of viscosity solutions for parabolic equations, give the definition of $\delta$-viscosity solutions, and recall some known regularity results for solutions of (\ref{eq:main}). \subsection{Notation} Points in $\ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1}$ are denoted $(x,t)$ with $x\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$. The parabolic distance between two points is \[ d((x,t), (y,s))=(|x-y|^2+|s-t|)^{1/2}. \] We denote the usual Euclidean distance in $\ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1}$ by $d_e((x,t),(y,s))= (|x-y|^2+|s-t|^2)^{1/2}$. Throughout the argument we consider parabolic cubes, denoted by \[ Q_r(x,t)=[x-r,x+r]^n\times(t-r^2,t], \] and forward and backward cylinders, \[ Y_r(x, t)= B_{r}(x) \times (t ,t+r^2] \text{ and } Y^-_r (x, t) = B_{r}(x) \times (t - r^2 ,t], \] where $B_r(x)=\{y: |x-y|<r\}$ is the open ball in $\ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$. We write $B_r$, $Q_r$, $Y_r$ and $Y^-_r$ to mean $B_r(0)$, $Q_r(0)$, $Y_r(0)$ and $Y^-_r(0)$, respectively. For $\Omega\subset \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$, the parabolic boundary of $\Omega\times (a,b)$ is defined as \[ \bdry (\Omega \times (a,b)) = (\Omega \times \{a\}) \cup (\partial \Omega \times (a,b)). \] The time derivative of a function $u$ is denoted by $u_t$ or $\partial_t u$. The gradient of $u$ with respect to the space variable $x=(x_1,...,x_n)$ is denoted by $Du=(u_{x_1},...,u_{x_n})$, and the Hessian of $u$ with respect to $x$ is denoted by $D^2u$. We say that a constant is \emph{universal} if it is positive and depends only on $\Lambda$, $\lambda,$ and $n$. Unless otherwise indicated, all constants depend on $\Lambda$, $\lambda,$ and $n$. We introduce notation for several families of paraboloids. \begin{defn} Let $M>0$. We define: \begin{enumerate} \item the class of \emph{convex paraboloids of opening $M$}: \[ \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_M}^+ =\left\{ P(x,t)=c+l\cdot x + mt + \frac{M}{2}|x|^2 \text{ where } l\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n, c, m\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}, |m| \leq M\right\}; \] \item the class of \emph{concave paraboloids of opening $M$}: \[ \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_M}^- = \{-P(x,t) | P\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_M}^+\}; \] \item the class of paraboloids of arbitrary opening: \[ \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty} = \left\{ P(x,t)=c+l\cdot x + m t + x\cdot Qx^T \text{ where } l\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n,c,m\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}, Q\in \mathcal{S}_{n\times n} \right \}; \] \item the set of polynomials that are quadratic in $x$ and linear in $t$ with the only mixed term of the form $a\cdot xt$: \[ \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}} = \left\{ P(x,t)=c+l\cdot x + m t + a\cdot x t + x\cdot Qx^T \text{ where } l,a\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n, c, m\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}},Q\in \mathcal{S}_{n\times n} \right \}. \] \end{enumerate} \end{defn} We will make use of the following seminorms, norms, and function spaces: \begin{defn}The class of continuous functions on $U\subset \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1}$ is denoted $C(U)$. The class $C^2(U)$ is the set of functions $\phi$ that are differentiable in $t$ and twice differentiable in $x$, with $\phi_t\in C(U)$ and $D^2\phi\in C(U)$. \end{defn} \begin{defn} For $\eta\in (0,1]$ and $u\in C(\Omega\times (a,b))$, we define: \begin{align*} \etasemi{u}{\Omega\times (a,b)} &= \sup_{(x,t), (y,s)\in \Omega\times (a,b)}\frac{|u(x,t)-u(y,s)|}{d((x,t),(y,s))^\eta},\\ [u]_{C^{0,\eta}_x(\Omega\times (a,b))}&= \sup_{x,y\in \Omega; t\in (a,b)} \frac{|u(x,t)-u(y,t)|}{|x-y|^\eta},\\ \tetasemi{u}{\Omega\times (a,b)} &= \sup_{ t,s\in (a,b); x\in \Omega} \frac{|u(x,t)-u(x,s)|}{|t-s|^\eta}, \text{ and,}\\ \etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (a,b)}&= \linfty{u}{\Omega\times (a,b)}+\etasemi{u}{\Omega\times (a,b)}. \end{align*} \end{defn} \begin{defn} For $\eta\in (0,1]$, we define: \begin{align*} C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (a,b))&=\{ u\in C(\Omega\times(a,b)) :\etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (a,b)}<\infty\},\\ C^{0,\eta}_x(\Omega\times(a,b)) &= \left\{ u\in C(\Omega\times(a,b)): [u]_{C^{0,\eta}_x(\Omega\times(a,b))}+ \linfty{u}{\Omega\times (a,b)} <\infty\right\}. \end{align*} \end{defn} We will also need the following notion of differentiability: \begin{defn} For a constant $K$, we say that $u$ satisfies $D^2u(x,t)\geq KI$ (resp. $D^2u(x,t)\leq KI$) \emph{in the sense of distributions} if there exists a quadratic polynomial \[ P(y)= c+p\cdot y +\frac{K|x-y|^2}{2} \] such that $u(x,t)=P(x)$ and $u(y,t)\geq P(y)$ (resp. $u(y)\leq P(y)$) for all $y\in B_r(x)$, for some $r>0$. \end{defn} \subsection{Viscosity and $\delta$-viscosity solutions} \label{subsection:delta def} We recall the definition of viscosity solutions for parabolic equations. \begin{defn} \label{defn visc} \begin{enumerate} \item A function $u\in C(\Omega\times(0,T))$ is a \emph{viscosity supersolution} of (\ref{eq:main}) if for all $(x, t) \in \Omega\times(0,T)$, any $\phi\in C^2(\Omega\times (0,T))$ with $\phi \leq u $ on $Y^-_{\rho} (x, t)$ for some $\rho>0$ and $\phi(x,t)=u(x,t)$ satisfies \[ \phi_t(x,t) - F(D^2\phi(x,t)) \geq 0. \] \item A function $u\in C(\Omega\times(0,T))$ is a \emph{viscosity subsolution} of (\ref{eq:main}) if for all $(x, t) \in \Omega\times(0,T)$, any $\phi\in C^2(\Omega\times(0,T))$ with $\phi \geq u $ on $Y^-_{\rho} (x, t)$ for some $\rho>0$ and $\phi(x,t)=u(x,t)$ satisfies \[ \phi_t(x,t) - F(D^2\phi(x,t)) \leq 0. \] \item We say that $u\in C(\Omega\times(0,T))$ is a \emph{viscosity solution} of (\ref{eq:main}) if $u$ is both a sub- and a super- solution of (\ref{eq:main}). \end{enumerate} \end{defn} \begin{rem} In the above definitions, we require the test function $\phi$ to stay above (or below) $u$ on a backward cylinder $Y^-_\rho(x,t)$. However, this definition is equivalent to the usual one, which requires the test function to stay above (or below) $u$ on a Euclidean open set around $(x,t)$. This equivalence is proven by Crandall, Kocan, and \'{S}wi\c{e}ch \cite[Lemma 1.4]{crandallkocan} for $L^p$ viscosity solutions. Their proof carries over into our setting with no modifications. \end{rem} See Section 8 of Crandall, Ishii, and Lions' \cite{User's guide} for further discussion of viscosity solutions of parabolic equations. We now introduce $\delta$-viscosity solutions for (\ref{eq:main}), following the definition of \cite{Approx schemes} and \cite{Rates Homogen}. \begin{defn} \label{defn delta} Fix $\delta>0$. \begin{enumerate} \item A function $v\in C(\Omega\times(0,T))$ is a \emph{$\delta$-viscosity supersolution} of (\ref{eq:main}) if for all $(x, t) \in \Omega\times(0,T)$ such that $Y^-_{\delta}(x, t) \subset \Omega\times(0,T)$, any $P\in\ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ with $P \leq v $ on $Y^-_{\delta} (x, t)$ and $P(x,t)=v(x,t)$ satisfies \[ P_t - F(D^2P) \geq 0. \] \item A function $v\in C(\Omega\times(0,T))$ is a \emph{$\delta$-viscosity subsolution} of (\ref{eq:main}) if for all $(x, t) \in \Omega\times(0,T)$ such that $Y^-_{\delta}(x, t) \subset \Omega\times(0,T)$, any $P\in\ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ with $P\geq v$ on $Y^-_{\delta} (x, t)$ and $P(x,t)=v(x,t)$ satisfies \[ P_t - F(D^2P) \leq 0. \] \item We say $v$ is a \emph{$\delta$-viscosity solution} of (\ref{eq:main}) if it is both a $\delta$-viscosity sub- and super- solution. \end{enumerate} \end{defn} From now on we will say ``solution" to mean viscosity solution and ``$\delta$-solution" to mean $\delta$-viscosity solution. From the definitions, it is clear that a viscosity solution of (\ref{eq:main}) is a $\delta$-solution of (\ref{eq:main}). The main difference between the definitions of viscosity and $\delta$-viscosity solution is that for $v$ to be a $\delta$-supersolution (resp. subsolution), any test polynomial must stay below (resp. above) $v$ on a set of fixed size. \subsection{Known results} We introduce the Pucci extremal operators, which are defined for constants $0<\lambda\leq \Lambda$ and $X\in \mathcal{S}_{n\times n}$ by \begin{align*} \mathcal{M}_{\lambda, \Lambda}^-(X) &= \lambda \sum_{e_i >0} e_i +\Lambda \sum_{e_i<0} e_i,\\ \mathcal{M}_{\lambda, \Lambda}^+(X) &= \Lambda \sum_{e_i >0} e_i +\lambda \sum_{e_i<0} e_i, \end{align*} where the $e_i$ are the eigenvalues of $X$ (see Caffarelli and Cabre \cite{Cabre Caffarelli book} and Wang \cite{WangI}). We also introduce the so-called upper and lower monotone envelopes of a function, which play the role of the convex and concave envelopes in the regularity theory of elliptic equations. We follow the notes of Imbert and Silvestre in \cite[Section 4]{ImbertSilvestre} for our presentation of Definition \ref{defn env}, Lemma \ref{lem:representation} and Proposition \ref{pre ABP} below. \begin{defn} \label{defn env} Let $\Omega$ be a convex subset of $\ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$ and let $u:\Omega \times (a,b) \rightarrow \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}$ be continuous. \begin{enumerate} \item The \emph{lower monotone envelope} of $u$ is the largest function $v:\Omega \times (a,b) \rightarrow \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}$ that lies below $u$ and is non-increasing with respect to $t$ and convex with respect to $x$. It is often denoted by $\underline{\Gamma}(u)$. \item The \emph{upper monotone envelope} of $u$ is the smallest function $v:\Omega \times (a,b) \rightarrow \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}$ that lies above $u$ and is non-decreasing with respect to $t$ and concave with respect to $x$. It is often denoted by $\bar{\Gamma}(u)$. \end{enumerate} \end{defn} We have the following representation formulas for the upper and lower envelopes of $u$ (\cite[Section 4]{ImbertSilvestre}): \begin{lem} \label{lem:representation} Assume $u\in C(Y_\rho^-)$. Then \[ \underline{\Gamma}(u)(x,t) = \sup \{\zeta \cdot x +h : \ \zeta \cdot y + h \leq u(s,y) \text{ for all } s\in (a,t], y\in Y_\rho^-\} \] and \[ \bar{\Gamma}(u)(x,t) = \inf \{\zeta \cdot x +h : \ \zeta \cdot y + h \geq u(s,x) \text{ for all } s\in (a,t], y\in Y_\rho^-\}. \] \end{lem} The following fact will play a central role in our arguments. In subsection \ref{subsec:proof of pre ABP} of the Appendix, we explain how Proposition \ref{pre ABP} follows from parts of the proof of the parabolic version of the Alexandroff-Bakelman-Pucci estimate as presented in \cite[Section 4.1.2]{ImbertSilvestre}. We refer the reader to \cite[Section 4]{ImbertSilvestre} for a history of the parabolic version of the Alexandroff-Bakelman-Pucci estimate and the relevant references. \begin{prop} \label{pre ABP} Assume $u\in C(Y^-_\rho)$ is such that $u\geq 0$ on $\bdry Y^-_\rho$. Assume that there exists a constant $K$ so that $\tetasemi{u}{Y^-_\rho}\leq K$ and $D^2u(x,t)\leq KI$ in the sense of distributions for every $(x,t)\in Y^-_\rho$. Let $\Gamma$ be the lower monotone envelope of $-u^-$ in $Y^-_{2\rho}$. There exists a universal constant $C$ such that \begin{equation} \label{cons of ABPbd} \sup_{Y^-_\rho} u^- \leq C \rho^{\frac{n}{n+1}} |\{u=\Gamma\}|^{\frac{1}{n+1}}K. \end{equation} \end{prop} Next we state several regularity results. We will use the following interior H\"older gradient estimate \cite[Theorems 4.8 and 4.9]{WangII}. \begin{thm} \label{thm:Wang's c alpha thm} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}) and (F\ref{last prop of F}). There exist universal constants $\alpha\in (0,1)$ and $C$ such that if $u\in C(Q_1)$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $Q_1$, then $u_t\in C^{0,\alpha}(Q_1)$ and $Du\in C^{0,\alpha}(Q_1)$ with \[ ||Du||_{C^{0,\alpha}(Q_{1/2})} + ||u_t||_{C^{0,\alpha}(Q_{1/2})} \leq C(\linfty{u}{Q_1} + 1). \] \end{thm} The following proposition follows from Theorem \ref{thm:Wang's c alpha thm} by a standard rescaling and covering argument. \begin{prop} \label{prop:diff of soln} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}) and (F\ref{last prop of F}). Assume that $V$ is a subset of $\Omega \times (0,T)$ with $d(V, \bdry \Omega \times (0,T))>r$. There exist universal constants $\alpha\in (0,1)$ and $C$ such that if $u\in C(\Omega\times (0,T))$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $\Omega\times (0,T)$, then \begin{align*} r^{1+\alpha}\alphasemi{D u}{V} + r\linfty{D u}{V} &\leq C(\linfty{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)} + 1)\\ r^{2+\alpha}\alphasemi{u_t}{V} + r^2\linfty{u_t}{V} &\leq C(\linfty{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)} + 1). \end{align*} \end{prop} \section{The regularity result} \label{section: regularity} In this section, we establish the parabolic version of the regularity result \cite[Theorem A]{Approx schemes}, which says that outside of sets of small measure, solutions of uniformly elliptic equations have second-order expansions with controlled error. \begin{defn} Given $u\in C(Y_1)$, we define the set $\Psi_M (u,Y_1)\subset Y_1$ by \begin{align*} \Psi_M (u,Y_1) =\{ &(x,t) \in Y_1 :\text{ there exists } P\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}} \text{ such that for all }(y,s)\in Y_1\cap \{s\leq t\}, \\ & |u(y,s) - u(x,t) - P(y,s)| \leq nM (|x-y|^3 + |x-y|^2|t-s| +|t-s|^2) \}. \end{align*} \end{defn} In order to state our result, we introduce another family of subsets of $\ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1}$. We define \[ K_r(x,t)=\left[x-\frac{r}{9\sqrt{n}}, x+\frac{r}{9\sqrt{n}}\right]^n \times\left(t , t+ \frac{r^2}{81n}\right] \] We denote $K_r(0,0)$ by $K_r$. We prove the following growth estimate for $|\Psi_M(u,Y_1)|$: \begin{thm} \label{Thm A} Assume $F$ satisfies (F\ref{ellipticity}) and (F\ref{last prop of F}). Assume $u$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $Y_1$ and $Du$ and $u_t$ exist and are continuous in $Y_1$. There exist universal constants $C, M_0$ and $\sigma$ such that for every $M \geq M_0$, \begin{equation} \label{eq:size bad set} | K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus \Psi_M(u,Y_1)| \leq CM^{\sigma}\left(\linfty{D u}{Y_1}^{\sigma} +\linfty{u_t}{Y_1}^{\sigma}\right). \end{equation} \end{thm} \begin{rem} If $u$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $\Omega\times (0,T)$ and $Y_1$ is compactly contained in $\Omega\times (0,T)$, then $u$ satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem \ref{Thm A} because, according to Proposition \ref{prop:diff of soln}, $Du$ and $u_t$ exist and are continuous in $Y_1$. \end{rem} \begin{rem} Suppose $(x,t)\in \Psi_M (u,Y_1)$ and $P$ is the paraboloid given by the definition of $\Psi_M (u,Y_1)$. If $u$ is a viscosity solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $Y_1$ , then of course $P_t - F(D^2P)=0$. On the other hand, suppose $u$ is only a $\delta$-solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $Y_1$, and $(x,t)\in \Psi_M (u,Y_1)$ with $Y^-_\delta(x,t)\subset Y_1$. In this case we \emph{cannot} conclude that $P_t - F(D^2P)=0$. This is because in the definition of $\Psi_M (u,Y_1)$ we consider paraboloids $P$ in the class $\ensuremath{\mathcal{P}}$, while in the definition of $\delta$-solution we allow only paraboloids in the smaller class $\ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$. In Corollary \ref{cor} we establish a version of Theorem \ref{Thm A} with $P\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ instead of $P\in\ensuremath{\mathcal{P}}$. \end{rem} An essential element of our proof is \cite[Theorem 4.11]{WangI}, which says that solutions of uniformly parabolic equations have \emph{first} order expansions with controlled error on large sets. To state this result, we recall the following definitions: \begin{align*} \overline{G}_M (u, Y_1) = \{ &(x,t) \in Y_1 :\text{ there exists }P\in\ensuremath{\mathcal{P}}^+_M \\& \text{ with } P(x,t)=u(x,t) \text{ and $P \geq u$ on $Y_1\cap \{s \leq t\}$} \}, \\ \underline{G}_M (u, Y_1) & = \overline{G}_M (-u, Y_1), \text{ and } \\G_M(u, Y_1) &= \left. \overline{G}_M (u, Y_1) \cap \underline{G}_M(u, Y_1). \right. \end{align*} We observe that if $(x,t)\in G_M(u,Y_1)$, then there exists $p\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$ such that for all $(y,s)\in Y_1\cap \{s\leq t\}$, \begin{equation*} |u(y,s) - u(x,t) - p\cdot (y-x) | \leq \frac{1}{2}M|x-y|^2+M|t-s|. \end{equation*} We now present \cite[Theorem 4.11]{WangI}, with notation adapted for our setting: \begin{thm} \label{thm:Wang's good set thm} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}) and (F\ref{last prop of F}). Assume that $v$ is a solution of \begin{equation} \label{class S}\left\{ \begin{array}{l l} v_t- \mathcal{M}^-(D^2v) \geq 0, &\quad \\ v_t- \mathcal{M}^+(D^2v) \leq 0 &\quad \end{array}\right. \end{equation} in $Y_1$. There exist universal constants $C$, $\sigma$, and $M_0$ such that for any $M \geq M_0$, \[ |K_1 \setminus G_M(v, Y_1)| \leq C M^{-\sigma} (\linfty{v}{Y_1})^{\sigma}. \] \end{thm} The main idea of the proof of Theorem \ref{Thm A} is to apply the growth estimate of Theorem \ref{thm:Wang's good set thm} to the derivatives of $u$. Formally, upon differentiating $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$, we obtain that the derivatives $u_{x_i}$ and $u_t$ solve the linear parabolic equation $\partial_t u_{x_i} - \ensuremath{\text{tr}} (DF \cdot D^2u_{x_i})=0$. Therefore, the estimates of Theorem \ref{thm:Wang's good set thm} apply to $u_{x_i}$ and $u_t$, and from this the estimates on $u$ are deduced. To carry out this plan, we will first use the following proposition \cite[Theorem 4.6]{WangII}. \begin{prop} \label{diff eqn} Assume that $u$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $Y_1$. Then $u_t$ and $u_{x_i}$, for $i=1,..,n$, satisfy \begin{equation*}\left\{ \begin{array}{l l} v_t- \mathcal{M}^-(D^2v) \geq 0 &\\ v_t- \mathcal{M}^+(D^2v) \leq 0 & \end{array}\right. \end{equation*} in $Y_1$. \end{prop} Next we proceed with the proof of Theorem \ref{Thm A}. We remark that a result similar to \cite[Theorem A]{Approx schemes} was established later, via similar methods, by Armstrong, Silvestre and Smart \cite[Section 5]{ArmSmartSilv}. Our proof is based on the arguments in \cite[Theorem A]{Approx schemes} and our presentation follows that of \cite[Section 5]{ArmSmartSilv}. We proceed with: \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem \ref{Thm A}] By Proposition \ref{diff eqn}, the derivatives $u_{x_i}$, $i=1,..., n$ and $u_t$ satisfy (\ref{class S}). Therefore, by Theorem \ref{thm:Wang's good set thm}, for any $M\geq M_0$ the size of the ``bad sets" of the $u_{x_i}$ and of $u_t$ are controlled: we have \begin{equation} \label{bd size sets} \begin{split} |K_1 \setminus G_{M}(u_{x_i}, Y_1)| \leq C {M}^{-\sigma} \linfty{Du}{Y_1} ^{\sigma} \text{, } i=1,..,n,\\ |K_1 \setminus G_{M}(u_{t}, Y_1)| \leq C {M}^{-\sigma} \linfty{u_t}{Y_1}^{\sigma}, \end{split} \end{equation} where $C$ is a universal constant. We define $G_M$ by \[ G_M=\cap_{i=1}^{n} G_{M}(u_{x_i}, Y_1) \cap G_{M}(u_{t}, Y_1). \] We will show \[ (G_M\cap K_1)\subset (\Psi_M(u,Y_1)\cap K_1), \] so that, by (\ref{bd size sets}), \[ |K_1\setminus \Psi_M(u,Y_1)| \leq |K_1\setminus G_M|\leq C M^{-\sigma} \left(\linfty{Du}{Y_1}^{\sigma} + \linfty{u_t}{Y_1}^{\sigma}\right). \] To this end, fix $(x,t) \in G_M \cap K_1$. The goal is to show that $(x,t) \in \Psi(u,Y_1(\bar{x},\bar{t}))\cap K_1(\bar{x},\bar{t})$; in other words, to produce a polynomial $P$ that is the second order expansion of $u$ at $(x,t)$. Because $(x,t) \in G_M$, there exist $p^1,...,p^{n+1}\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$ such that for $i=1,..., n$ and for all $(y,s)\in Y_1\cap \{s\leq t\}$, \begin{equation} \label{eq:u_xi -p^i} \begin{split} |u_{x_i}(y,s) - u_{x_i} (x,t) - p^i\cdot (y-x) | &\leq \frac{1}{2}M|x-y|^2+M|t-s|, \text{ and}\\ |u_t(y,s) - u_t (x,t) - p^{n+1}\cdot (y-x) | &\leq \frac{1}{2}M|x-y|^2+M|t-s|. \end{split} \end{equation} We point out that $Du(x,t)=(p^1,...,p^n)$ and $u_t(x,t)=p^{n+1}$. We define the $n\times n$ matrix $Q$ by $Q_{ij}=p_i^j$ and define the paraboloid $P\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}}$ by \[ P(y,s) = Du(x,t)\cdot (y-x) +\frac{1}{2}(y-x)Q(y-x)^T + (s-t)u_t(x,t)+\frac{1}{2}p^{n+1}\cdot (y-x) (s-t). \] We will now show that this polynomial $P$ is the second order expansion of $u$ at $(x,t)$. We have \begin{equation*} \begin{split} u(y,s)-u(x,t) = &\int_0^1 (y-x)\cdot Du(x+\tau(y-x),t + \tau(s-t)) d\tau + \\ &\ + \int_0^1 (s-t) u_t(x+\tau(y-x),t + \tau(s-t)) d\tau. \end{split} \end{equation*} Therefore, \begin{equation*} \begin{split} u(y,s)&-u(x,t) - P(y,s)= \\ & (y-x)\cdot \int_0^1 \left(Du(x+\tau(y-x),t + \tau(s-t))-Du(x,t)-\tau Q(y-x)^T\right)d\tau + \\ &+ (s-t)\int_0^1 u_t(x+\tau(y-x),t + \tau(s-t))-u_t(x,t)-\tau p^{n+1}\cdot (y-x) d\tau. \end{split} \end{equation*} We take the absolute value both sides of the above and find \begin{equation*} \begin{split} |u(y,s)&-u(x,t) -P(y,s)|\leq \\ & |y-x| \int_0^1 \left(\sum_{i=1}^n |u_{x_i}(x+\tau(y-x),t + \tau(s-t))-u_{x_i}(x,t) - \tau p^i \cdot (y-x)|^2 d \tau \right)^{1/2}+ \\ &+ |s-t|\int_0^1 |u_t(x+\tau(y-x),t + \tau(s-t))-u_t(x,t)-\tau p^{n+1}\cdot (y-x) |d\tau. \end{split} \end{equation*} We use (\ref{eq:u_xi -p^i}) to bound each term on the right-hand side of the above, and obtain \begin{align*} |u(y,s)-P(y,s)|\leq & n |y-x|\int_0^1 \frac{1}{2}M\tau^2|x-y|^2 + M\tau|t-s| d\tau +\\& \ \ |s-t|\int_0^1 \frac{1}{2}M\tau^2|x-y|^2 + M\tau|t-s| d\tau. \end{align*} Integrating in $\tau$ and combining terms yields \[ |u(y,s)-P(y,s)|\leq nM ( |x-y|^3 + |x-y|^2|t-s| +|t-s|^2). \] \end{proof} \begin{cor} \label{cor} Assume $F$ satisfies (F\ref{ellipticity}) and (F\ref{last prop of F}). Assume $u$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $Y_r$ and $Du$ and $u_t$ exist and are continuous in $Y_r$. There exists a universal constant $C$ such that for any $(x,t)\in \Psi_M(u,Y_r)$, there exists $Q\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ with \[ Q_t-F(D^2Q)=0 \] and such that on $Y_r\cap \{s\leq t\}$, \begin{equation} \label{eq:u-p cor} \begin{split} |u(y,s) - u(x,t) - Q(y,s)| \leq \frac{nM}{r^2} &( r|x-y|^3 + |x-y|^2|t-s| +|t-s|^2) +\\&+C\frac{M+\linfty{u_t}{Y_r}}{r}|x-y|(t-s). \end{split} \end{equation} Moreover, \begin{equation} \label{better bdn on Theta_M} | K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus \Psi_M(u,Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t}))| \leq \frac{Cr^{n+2}}{M^{\sigma}}(r^{-\sigma}\linfty{Du}{Y_r}^\sigma+\linfty{u_t}{Y_r}^\sigma). \end{equation} \end{cor} \begin{proof} We prove the statement for $r=1$; the general case follows by rescaling: given $u$ that solves $u_t - F(D^2u) = 0$ in $Y_r$, the rescaled function $ \hat{u}(\hat{x},\hat{t})=\frac{1}{r^2} u(r\hat{x}, r^2 \hat{t}) $ solves the same equation in $Y_1$. We omit the details of the rescaling argument and proceed with the proof in the case $r=1$. Fix $(x,t)\in \Psi_M(u,Y_1)$. Let $Q(y,s)=P(y,s) - \frac{1}{2}p^{n+1}\cdot (y-x)(s-t)$, where $P$ and $p^{n+1}$ are as in the proof of Theorem \ref{Thm A}. It holds that for all $(y,s)\in Y_1\cap \{s\leq t\}$, \begin{equation*} |u(y,s) - u(x,t) - Q(y,s)| \leq nM( |x-y|^3 + |x-y|^2|t-s| +|t-s|^2) +\frac{1}{2}|p^{n+1}| |y-x||s-t|. \end{equation*} From (\ref{eq:u_xi -p^i}) we see that for any $(y,s) \in Y_1\cap \{s\leq t\}$, \[ |p^{n+1}\cdot (y-x)| \leq \frac{1}{2}M|x-y|^2+M|t-s|+2\linfty{u_t}{Y_1}. \] Taking $y$ such that $|x-y|=\frac{1}{2}$ and $s=t$ implies \[ |p^{n+1}|\leq \frac{1}{4}M+4\linfty{u_t}{Y_1}. \] The bound (\ref{eq:u-p cor}) follows. \end{proof} \section{Two regularizations of inf- sup- type} \label{section: Two different inf- and sup- convolutions} \subsection{Regularization in both the space and time variables} We recall the definitions of the \emph{inf-convolution} $v^-_{\theta, \theta}$ and the \emph{sup-convolution} $v^+_{\theta, \theta}$ for $v\in C(\Omega \times (0,T))$: \[ v^-_{\theta, \theta}(x,t) = \inf_{\Omega\times(0,T)} \left\{ v(y,s) + \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}+\frac{|t-s|^2}{2\theta}\right\} \] and \[ v^+_{\theta, \theta}(x,t) = \sup_{\Omega\times(0,T)} \left\{ v(y,s) - \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}-\frac{|t-s|^2}{2\theta}\right\}, \] These definitions are quite similar to those used in the regularity theory of elliptic equations, and to the regularizations of \cite[Section 4]{WangII}. We use the notation $v^-_{\theta, \theta}$, instead of the expected $v^-_{\theta}$, to distinguish these from the $x$-inf- and $x$-sup- convolutions that we introduce in the next subsection. We summarize the basic properties of inf- and sup- convolutions in Proposition \ref{properties of inf-convolution} of the appendix. \subsection{Regularization in only the space variable} In this subsection we define a regularization of inf-sup type that we call $x$-inf and $x$-sup convolutions. In the next subsection, we prove that if $u$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$, then the $x$-inf and $x$-sup convolutions of $u$ enjoy regularity properties similar to those established in Theorem \ref{Thm A} for $u$. \begin{defn} For $u\in C(\Omega \times (0,T))$ and $\theta>0$, we define the \emph{$x$-sup convolution} $u^+_{\theta}$ and \emph{$x$-inf-convolution} $u^-_{\theta}$ of $u$ by \[ u^+_{\theta}(x,t) = \sup_{y\in \Omega} \left\{ u(y,t) - \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}\right\} \text{ and } u^-_{\theta}(x,t) = \inf_{y\in \Omega} \left\{ u(y,t) + \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}\right\}. \] For $u\in C^{0,1}_x(\Omega\times (0,T))$, we define the set $U^\theta_x$ by \[ U_x^{\theta} = \left\{(x,t)\in \Omega \times (0,T) | \inf_{y\in \partial \Omega } |x-y| \geq 2\theta \xlipsemi{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)} \right\}. \] \end{defn} In the following proposition we state the facts about $x$-inf- and $x$-sup- convolutions that we will use in this paper. Their proofs are very similar to those in the elliptic case and for the standard parabolic inf- and sup- convolution (see \cite[Chapter 4]{Rates Homogen} or \cite[Proposition 5.3]{Cabre Caffarelli book}) and we omit them. \begin{prop} \label{prop:x-sup-conv} Assume $u\in C^{0,1}_x(\Omega \times (0,T))$. Then: \begin{enumerate} \item If $(x^*, t)$ is any point at which the infimum (resp. supremum) is achieved in the definition of $u^-_{\theta}(x,t)$ (resp. $u^+_{\theta}(x,t)$), then \[|x-x^*|\leq 2\theta\linfty{Du}{\Omega \times (0,T)}. \] \item \label{item: bound from above on sup conv} For $(x,t)\in U_x^\theta$, \[ u^+_{\theta}(x,t) \leq u(x,t)+ 2\theta \linfty{Du}{\Omega \times (0,T)}^2 \] and \[ u^-_{\theta}(x,t) \geq u(x,t)- 2\theta \linfty{Du}{\Omega \times (0,T)}^2 . \] \item \label{item:sup conv is semiconvex} In the sense of distributions, $D^2 u^+_{\theta}(x,t) \geq -\theta^{-1}I$ and $D^2 u^-_{\theta}(x,t) \leq \theta^{-1}I$ for all $(x,t)\in \Omega\times (0,T)$. \item \label{item: utheta is subsolution} If $u$ is a subsolution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=c$ in $\Omega \times (0,T)$, then $u^+_{\theta}$ is a subsolution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=c$ in $U_x^{\theta}$. If $u$ is a supersolution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=c$ in $\Omega \times (0,T)$, then $u^-_{\theta}$ is a supersolution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=c$ in $U_x^{\theta}$. \end{enumerate} \end{prop} \subsection{Regularity of $x$-inf and $x$-sup convolutions} Next we prove that the extra regularity established in Theorem \ref{Thm A} for a solution $u$ of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ carries over to $u^+_\theta$ and $u^-_\theta$. To state this result we introduce the following families of sets: \begin{align*} Y^{\theta}_r(\bar{x},\bar{t}) &= B(\bar{x}, r-2\theta\linfty{D u}{\Omega \times (0,T)})\times (\bar{t}, \bar{t}+r^2]\\ K^{\theta}_r (\bar{x},\bar{t}) &= \left[\bar{x}-\left(\frac{r}{9\sqrt{n}}-2\theta\linfty{D u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\right), \bar{x}+\left(\frac{r}{9\sqrt{n}}-2\theta\linfty{D u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\right)\right]^n \times\left(\bar{t}, \bar{t}+\frac{r^2}{81n}\right]. \end{align*} (Note that for these definitions to be meaningful, $r$ cannot be too small compared to $\theta$. Whenever we use this notation we make sure this is not the case.) \begin{prop} \label{prop: more regularity for convolutions} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}) and (F\ref{last prop of F}). Suppose $u\in C(\Omega\times(0,T))$ is a solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $\Omega \times(0,T)$. Assume $Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\subset\Omega\times(0,T)$ and \[ d(Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t}), \bdry(\Omega\times(0,T))) \geq \theta. \] There exist universal constants $M_0, \sigma$, and $C$ such that for every $M\geq M_0$, there exists a set $\Psi^{+,\theta}_{M} \subset K^{\theta}_r ( \bar{x},\bar{t})$ (resp. $\Psi^{-,\theta}_{M} \subset K^{\theta}_r ( \bar{x},\bar{t})$) such that for any $(x, t) \in \Psi^{+,\theta}_M$ (resp. $(x, t) \in \Psi^{-,\theta}_M$), there exists a polynomial $P \in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ such that $P(x,t)=0$, \begin{equation} \label{cond on P} P_t - F(D^2P)=0, \end{equation} and if $Y_\rho^-(x,t)\subset Y^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$, then for all $(y,s)\in Y_\rho^-(x,t)$, we have \begin{equation} \label{eq: touch utheta from below} \begin{split} u^{+}_\theta(y,s)-u^{+}_\theta(x, t) \geq P(y,s)&- \frac{c(n)}{r^2}M (\rho|x-y|^2 + \rho^2|t-s| ) \\ &-\frac{C\rho}{r}\left(M+\theta^{-1}(1+\linfty{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)})\right)(t-s). \end{split} \end{equation} \begin{equation*} \begin{split} \text{(resp. }u^{-}_\theta(y,s)-u^{-}_\theta(x, t) \leq P(y,s)&+ \frac{c(n)}{r^2}M (\rho|x-y|^2 + \rho^2|t-s| ) \\ &+\frac{C\rho}{r}\left(M+\theta^{-1}(1+\linfty{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)})\right)(t-s).) \end{split} \end{equation*} Moreover, \begin{equation} \label{eq: size of bad set theta} |K^{\theta}_r(\bar{x},\bar{t}) \setminus \Psi^{\pm,\theta}_M | \leq \frac{Cr^{n+2}}{M^{\sigma}\theta^{1+\sigma}}(r^{-\sigma}+\theta^{-\sigma})\left(\linfty{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)}+1\right)^{1+\sigma}. \end{equation} \end{prop} Although the proof of Proposition \ref{properties of inf-convolution} is quite involved, it is based on the following simple observation: if the supremum in the definition of $u^+_\theta(x,t)$ is achieved at $(x^*,t)$ and $u$ is touched from below at $(x^*,t)$ by some function $\phi$, then $u^+_\theta$ is touched by below at $(x,t)$ by a translate of $\phi$. We demonstrate this below. Let $(x^*,t)\in \Omega \times (0,T)$ be a point at which the supremum is achieved in the definition of $u^+_\theta(x,t)$, so that \[ u_\theta^+(x,t) =u(x^*,t)-\frac{|x-x^*|^2}{2\theta} . \] Suppose that $\phi\in C(\Omega\times(0,T))$ is a function with $u(x^*,t) = \phi(x^*,t)$ and $u\geq \phi$ on $\Omega \times (0,t)$. This implies \begin{equation} \label{toy touching} u_\theta^+(x,t) =\phi(x^*,t)-\frac{|x-x^*|^2}{2\theta}. \end{equation} Fix $s\leq t$. If $y\in \Omega$ is sufficiently far from the boundary of $\Omega$, then we may use $(y+ x-x^*)$ as a ``test point'' in the definition of $u_\theta^+(y,s)$ and find \[ u_\theta^+(y,s) \geq u(y+x^*-x,t)-\frac{|x-x^*|^2}{2\theta}. \] But, since $u\geq \phi$ on $\Omega \times (0,t)$, we have \[ u_\theta^+(y,s) \geq \phi(y+x^*-x,s)-\frac{|x-x^*|^2}{2\theta}. \] Subtracting (\ref{toy touching}) from the above implies \[ u_\theta^+(y,s) -u_\theta^+(x,t) \geq \phi(y+x^*-x,s)- \phi(x^*,t), \] so $u^+_\theta(y,s)$ is touched from below at $(x,t)$ by $\tilde\phi (y)=\phi(y+x^*-x,s)- \phi(x^*,t)+u^+_\theta(x,t)$. For the proof of Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}, we consider the map that takes $x^*$ to $x$ and investigate what happens to ``good set'' $\Psi_M(u)$ under this map. To do this, we need the following lemma, which says that $u$ is twice differentiable in $x$ at any point $x^*$ where the supremum or infimum is achieved in the regularizations $u^+_\theta$ or $u^-_\theta$, and gives a bound on $D^2u$ at such points. \begin{lem} \label{lem:Dxu lip} Under the assumptions of Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}, let $(x,t)\in Y^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$. If $x^*$ is any point where the supremum (resp. infimum) is achieved in the definition of $u^+_{\theta}(x,t)$ (resp. $u^-_{\theta}(x,t)$), then $u(y,t)$ is twice differentiable in $y$ at $x^*$ with \[ |D^2u(x^*, t)|\leq \frac{C}{\theta}\left(1+\frac{\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}}{\theta}\right). \] \end{lem} We postpone the proof of Lemma \ref{lem:Dxu lip} and proceed with the proof of Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}. \begin{proof}[Proof of Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}] We will give the proof for $u^+_\theta$; the arguments for $u^-_\theta$ are similar. Fix $M$ and, to simplify the notation, denote $\Psi_M(u, Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t}))$ by just $\Psi_M$. We define the set $\mathcal{C}$ by \begin{align*} \mathcal{C}=&\left\{(x^*,t)\text{: $x^*$ is a point at which the supremum in the definition of $u^+_\theta(x,t)$ } \right. \\& \ \ \ \left. \text{is achieved, for some $(x,t)\in Y^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$}\right\}. \end{align*} We remark that $\mathcal{C}\subset Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$: if $(x^*,t)\in \mathcal{C}$, then there exists a corresponding $(x,t)\in Y^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$, and, by Proposition \ref{prop:x-sup-conv}, we have $|x-x^*|\leq 2\theta \linfty{Du}{\Omega\times (0,T)}$. The definition of $ Y^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$ thus implies that $(x,t)\in Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$. By Lemma \ref{lem:Dxu lip}, $Du$ is Lipschitz on $\mathcal{C}$ with \begin{equation} \label{du on c} \linfty{D^2u}{\mathcal{C}} \leq \frac{C}{\theta}\left(1+\frac{\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}}{\theta}\right). \end{equation} For any $(x^*,t)\in \mathcal{C}$, the map \[ y \mapsto \left( u(y,t)-\frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}\right) \] has a local maximum at $x^*$. Therefore, \[ Du(x^*, t)+\frac{(x-x^*)}{\theta}=0, \] so $x=x^*-\theta Du(x^*,t)$. We define the map $T$ by \[ T(y,t) = (y-\theta Du(y,t),t). \] Since $Du$ is Lipschitz on $ \mathcal{C}$, $T$ is too, and (\ref{du on c}) implies that for all $(y,t)\in \mathcal{C}$, \[ |\det DT(y,t)|\leq C\left(\frac{\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}+1}{\theta}\right). \] We define the set $A$ by \[ A=T( \mathcal{C}\cap (K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus \Psi_M)). \] By the Area Formula (\cite[Chapter 3]{Evans Gariepy}), we have \[ |A|\leq \int_{\mathcal{C}\cap (K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus \Psi_M)} |\det DT(y,t)|\ dy \ dt . \] The above bound on $|\det DT(y,t)|$ and the bound (\ref{better bdn on Theta_M}) on $|K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus \Psi_M|$ therefore imply \begin{equation} \label{size A} |A|\leq \frac{Cr^{n+2}}{M^{\sigma}}(r^{-\sigma}\linfty{Du}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}^\sigma+\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}^\sigma)\left(\frac{\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}+1}{\theta}\right). \end{equation} We define the set $\Psi_M^\theta$ by \[ \Psi_M^\theta:=K^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus A. \] Fix $(x,t)\in K^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus A$. We will now show that there exists a polynomial $Q\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ satisfying (\ref{cond on P}) and (\ref{eq: touch utheta from below}). To this end, let $(x^*, t)$ be any point at which the supremum in the definition of $u^+_\theta(x,t)$ is achieved, so that $(x,t)=T(x^*,t)$. First we note that since, by Proposition \ref{prop:x-sup-conv}, $|x-x^*|\leq 2\theta \linfty{Du}{\Omega\times (0,T)}$ and $(x,t)\in K^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$, we have $(x^*, t)\in K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$. Next we observe that $(x^*,t) \in \Psi_M$. Indeed, if $(x^*,t) \notin \Psi_M$, then $(x^*,t)\in \mathcal{C}\cap (K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus \Psi_M)$, so $(x,t)=T(x^*,t)\subset T(\mathcal{C}\cap (K_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus \Psi_M))=A$. However, this is impossible, as we chose $(x,t)\in \Psi_M^\theta =K^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})\setminus A$. Therefore, $(x^*,t) \in \Psi_M$. Since $(x^*,t) \in \Psi_M$, there exists a polynomial $Q\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ with $Q_t-F(D^2Q)=0$ such that on $Y_r(\ensuremath{\bar{x}},\ensuremath{\bar{t}})\cap \{s\leq t\}$, \begin{equation*} \begin{split} |u(y,s) - u(x^*,t) - Q(y,s)| \leq \frac{nM}{r^2} &( r|x-y|^3 + |x-y|^2|t-s| +|t-s|^2) +\\&+C\frac{M+\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}}{r}|x-y|(t-s). \end{split} \end{equation*} It is easy to check that since $x^*$ is a point where the supremum is achieved in the definition of $u^+_\theta(x,t)$, we have, for all $(y,s)\in Y^\theta_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})$, \begin{align*} u^+_\theta (y,s)-u^+_\theta (x,t)\geq \tilde{Q}(y,s) -\frac{nM}{r^2} &( r|x-y|^3 + |x-y|^2|t-s| +|t-s|^2) \\&-C\frac{M+\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}}{r}|x-y|(t-s), \end{align*} where $\tilde{Q}\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ is a paraboloid of the same opening as $Q$. Finally, if $Y_\rho^-(x,t) \subset Y^\theta_r(\ensuremath{\bar{x}}, \ensuremath{\bar{t}})$, then for any $(y,s)\in Y_\rho^-(x,t)$, \begin{equation} \label{touch below no bd} \begin{split} u^+_\theta (y,s)-u^+_\theta (x,t)\geq \tilde{Q}(y,s) -\frac{nM}{r^2} &( \rho |x-y|^2 +\rho^2|t-s|) \\&-C\rho\frac{M+\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}}{r}(t-s). \end{split} \end{equation} Since $d(Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t}), \bdry \Omega\times(0,T))\geq \theta$, Proposition \ref{thm:Wang's c alpha thm} implies \[ \linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})} \leq \theta^{-2}(\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}+1) \] and \[ \linfty{Du}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})} \leq \theta^{-1}(\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}+1). \] We use these bounds in (\ref{size A}) and (\ref{touch below no bd}) to complete the proof. \end{proof} For the proof of Lemma \ref{lem:Dxu lip}, we first need to establish the following basic fact about how parabolic viscosity solutions relate to viscosity solutions in only $x$: \begin{lem} \label{lem: visc soln in t and x} If $u$ is a Lipschitz in $t$ viscosity solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $Y_r$, then for any $t\in (0,r^2)$, \begin{align*} \mathcal{M}^-(D^2u(\cdot, t)) &\leq \linfty{u_t}{Y_r} \text{ in }B_r,\\ \mathcal{M}^+(D^2u(\cdot, t)) &\geq -\linfty{u_t}{Y_r} \text{ in }B_r. \end{align*} \end{lem} \begin{proof} We will check that $u(\cdot, t)$ is a subsolution; checking that $u(\cdot, t)$ is a supersolution is analogous. Assume that $P(y)$ touches $u(y, t)$ from above at $x\in B_r$. Let $(y,s)\in B_r\times (0,t]$. Since $u$ is Lipschitz in $t$, we have \[ u(y,s)\leq u(y,t)+ \linfty{u_t}{Y_r} |t-s| . \] Therefore, $P(y)+ \linfty{u_t}{Y_r} (t-s)$ touches $u$ from above in $B_r\times (0,t]$. Because $u$ is a viscosity solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$, we obtain \[ -\linfty{u_t}{Y_r} -F(D^2P) \leq 0. \] The uniform ellipticity of $F$ implies \[ 0\geq -\linfty{u_t}{Y_r} -\mathcal{M}^-(D^2P), \] as desired. \end{proof} We also recall the Harnack inequality for \emph{elliptic} equations (see \cite[Theorem 4.3]{Cabre Caffarelli book}). \begin{thm} Assume that $u:B_s(0)\subset \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n\rightarrow \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}$ satisfies $u\geq 0 $ in $B_s(0)$ and, for some positive constant $c$, \begin{align*} \mathcal{M}^-(D^2u) &\leq c \text{ in }B_s(0)\\ \mathcal{M}^+(D^2u) &\geq -c \text{ in }B_s(0). \end{align*} There exits a universal constant $C$ so that \[ \inf_{B_{s/2}(0)} u \geq C\left(\sup_{B_{s/2}(0)} u - s^2c\right). \] \end{thm} We are now ready to proceed with: \begin{proof}[Proof of Lemma \ref{lem:Dxu lip}] We will give the proof for $u^+_{\theta}(x,t)$; the argument for $u^-_{\theta}(x,t)$ is very similar. Let $x^*$ be a point at which the supremum in the definition of $u^-_\theta(x,t)$ is achieved, so that \begin{equation} \label{eq:diff at x*} u(x^*,t) - \frac{|x-x^*|^2}{2\theta} \geq u(y,t) - \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta} \text{ for all } y\in \Omega. \end{equation} Therefore, as a function of $y$, $u(y,t)$ is touched from above at $x^*$ by the convex paraboloid $Q(y)$, where \[ Q(y)=u(x^*,t) - \frac{|x-x^*|^2}{2\theta} + \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}. \] Thus, we have \begin{equation} \label{d^2 bound below} D^2u(x^*,t) \leq \theta^{-1}I. \end{equation} Next we will show, using the Harnack inequality, that $u(\cdot, t)$ is also touched from below at $x^*$ by a paraboloid with bounded opening, thus obtaining a bound from below on $D^2u(x^*, t)$. There exists an affine function $l(y)$ with $l(x^*)=u(x^*, t)$ and such that \[ Q(y)= l(y)+\frac{|y-x^*|^2}{2\theta}. \] There exists $\rho>0$ such that $B_\rho(x^*)\subset B_r(\bar{x})$. We fix any $0<s<\rho$ and define the function $w(y)$ by \[ w(y)=u(y,t)-l(y)-\frac{s^2}{2\theta}. \] For $y\in B_s(x^*)$, \[ w(y)\geq Q(y)-l(y)-\frac{s^2}{2\theta} = \frac{|y-x^*|^2}{2\theta} - \frac{s^2}{2\theta} \geq 0. \] And, by Lemma \ref{lem: visc soln in t and x}, $w$ is a viscosity solution of \begin{align*} \mathcal{M}^-(D^2w(\cdot, t)) &\leq \linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}\text{ in }B_s(x^*)\\ \mathcal{M}^+(D^2w(\cdot, t)) &\geq -\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})} \text{ in }B_s(x^*). \end{align*} Therefore, the Harnack inequality implies that there exists a universal constant $C$ such that \[ \inf_{B_{s/2}(x^*)}w \geq C\left(\sup_{B_{s/2}(x)}w - s^2\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}\right). \] Since $\sup_{B_{s/2}(x)}w \geq w(x^*)=u(x^*,t)-l(x^*)-\frac{s^2}{2\theta}=-\frac{s^2}{2\theta}$, we obtain \[ \inf_{B_{s/2}(x^*)}w \geq -Cs^2(\theta^{-1} +\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}). \] Thus, for all $y\in B_{s/2}(x^*)$, \[ u(y,t)-Q(y) = u(y)-l(y)-\frac{|y-x^*|^2}{2\theta}\geq w(y) \geq -Cs^2(\theta^{-1} +\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}). \] Since this holds for all $0<s<\rho$, we have that $(u(\cdot,t)-Q(\cdot))$ is touched from below at $x^*$ by a paraboloid of opening $C(\theta^{-1} +\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})})$. Therefore, \[ D^2u(x^*, t) \geq (\theta^{-1}+C(\theta^{-1} +\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}))I. \] Together with (\ref{d^2 bound below}), this implies \[ |D^2u(x^*, t)| \leq C(\theta^{-1} +\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}). \] Finally, we use Proposition \ref{prop:diff of soln} to bound $\linfty{u_t}{Y_r(\bar{x},\bar{t})}$ and obtain the desired bound. \end{proof} \section{A key estimate between solutions and sufficiently regular $\delta$-solutions} \label{section: main prop} In this section we prove a proposition that is a key part of the proofs of the two main results, Theorems \ref{thm:vague comparison} and \ref{thm:mesh comparison vague}. Once we have proven Proposition \ref{main lemma}, we will only need to use the basic properties of inf- and sup- convolutions to verify its hypotheses and establish the two main results. We define the constant $\zeta$ by \begin{equation} \label{constants} \zeta = \frac{\sigma}{2(3n+4+2\sigma)}, \end{equation} where $\sigma$ is the constant from Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}. We remark that since $\sigma$ is universal, so is $\zeta$. \begin{prop} \label{main lemma} Assume (F1), (F2) and (U1) and that $u\in C^{0,1}_x(\Omega\times (0,T))$ is a solution of \begin{equation} \label{eqn:mainLemma} u_t-F(D^2u)=0 \end{equation} in $\Omega \times (0,T)$. For $\delta\in (0,1)$, define the quantity $r_\delta$ by \[ r_\delta = 9\sqrt{n}(1+2\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)})\delta^{\zeta} \] and the set $\tilde{U}$ by \[ \tilde{U} = \left\{(x,t)\in \Omega\times (0,T) :\ \ t\leq T-r_\delta^2 \text{ and } d((x,t),\bdry \Omega \times (0,T)) > 2r_\delta \right\}. \] \begin{enumerate} \item Assume $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (0,T))$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of (\ref{eqn:mainLemma}) in $\Omega \times (0,T)$ that satisfies \begin{enumerate} \item \label{assump:d2v} $D^2v\leq \delta^{-\zeta}I$ in the sense of distributions, and \item \label{assump:vt} $\tetasemi{v}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\leq 3T\delta^{-\zeta}$. \end{enumerate} There exists a universal constant $\tilde{\alpha}$, a positive constant $\tilde{c}$ that depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $diam\Omega$, $T$, $\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$ and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$, and a positive constant $\tilde{\delta}$ that depends only on $n$, such that, for all $\delta\leq \tilde{\delta}$, \[ \sup_{\tilde{U}} (u-v)\leq \tilde{c} \delta^{\tilde{\alpha}} +\sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}( u-v) . \] \item Assume $w\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (0,T))$ is a $\delta$-subsolution of (\ref{eqn:mainLemma}) in $\Omega \times (0,T)$ that is twice differentiable almost everywhere in $\Omega\times(0,T)$, with $D^2w\geq -\delta^{-\zeta}I$ in the sense of distributions and $\tetasemi{w}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\leq 3T\delta^{-\zeta}$. Then for all $\delta\leq \tilde{\delta}$, \[ \sup_{\tilde{U}}( w-u)\leq \tilde{c} \delta^{\tilde{\alpha}}+\sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}( w-u), \] where $\tilde{\alpha}$, $\tilde{c}$ and $\tilde{\delta}$ are the same as in part 1 of this proposition. \end{enumerate} \end{prop} \begin{rem} \label{rem:where main prop holds} Proposition \ref{main lemma} holds in any set $\Omega'\times (a,b)$, where $\Omega'$ satisfies (U1). In this case, $\tilde{U}$ becomes \[ \tilde{U} =\left\{x\in \Omega'\times(a,b): t\leq b-r_\delta \text{ and } d((x,t),\bdry \Omega'\times (a,b)) >2r_\delta\right\}. \] \end{rem} \subsection{Outline} \label{subsec:outline} We seek to control $\sup (u-v)$ by the size of its contact set with its upper monotone envelope. We first regularize $u$ by $x$-sup convolution and obtain $u^+_\theta$. We then perturb $u^+_\theta$ to make it a strict sub-solution. Let us denote the resulting function by $\tilde{u}$. We choose this perturbation and the parameter $\theta$ of the $x$-sup convolution so that the difference between $u$ and $\tilde{u}$ is less than $c\delta^{\tilde{\alpha}}$. Thus it will be enough to bound $\sup (\tilde{u}-v)$. Since $\tilde{u}$ and $v$ are sufficiently regular, we are able to apply Proposition \ref{pre ABP} and find \[ \sup_{\tilde{U}} \tilde{u}-v \leq C|\{\tilde{u}-v=\bar{\Gamma}\}|^{\frac{1}{n+1}}K, \] where $\bar{\Gamma}$ is the upper monotone envelope of $\tilde{u}-v$ and $K$ is large. To complete the proof, we will show that the contact set is very small compared to $K$. The key part of our argument is Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}, which states that there exists a subset $\Psi$ of $\Omega\times (0,T)$ on which $u^+_\theta$ is very close to being a polynomial. This allows us to obtain an upper bound on the size of $\Psi \cap \{\tilde{u}-v = \bar{\Gamma}\}$. Moreover, Theorem \ref{Thm A} says that $|\Psi|$ is large, so the size of the remainder of the contact set, $\{\tilde{u}-v = \bar{\Gamma}(\tilde{u}-v)\} \cap \Psi^c$, is small. This completes the outline. \subsection{Proof of Proposition \ref{main lemma}} For the proof of Proposition \ref{main lemma} we need a lemma. \begin{lem} \label{lem:Helper2} Under the assumptions of Proposition \ref{main lemma}, assume also that $\mathcal{C}\subset \tilde{U}$ with \[ |\mathcal{C}|\geq \bar{c} \delta^{3\zeta (n+1)}. \] There exists a positive constant $\delta_1$ that depends only on $n$ and a positive constant $C_1$ that depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$, such that, if $\delta\leq \delta_1$, then there exists $(x_0,t_0)\in \mathcal{C}$ and a paraboloid $P\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ with \begin{enumerate} \item $Y^-_\delta(x_0,t_0)\subset \Omega \times (0,T)$, \item $P(x_0,t_0)=0$, \item $\displaystyle P_t-F(D^2P)=0$, and \item for all $(x, t)\in Y_{\delta}^-(x_0,t_0)$, \begin{equation} \label{touch u at x0t0} \begin{split} u_{\delta^\zeta}^{+}(x,t)-u_{\delta^\zeta}^{+}(x_0, t_0) \geq P(x,t) - C_1 \bar{c}^{-1/\sigma}\delta^{1 - \frac{\zeta}{\sigma}(3n+4+2\sigma)}(|x-x_0|^2+(t_0-t)). \end{split} \end{equation} \end{enumerate} \end{lem} We postpone the proof of Lemma \ref{lem:Helper2} and proceed with the proof of Proposition \ref{main lemma}. \begin{proof}[Proof of Proposition \ref{main lemma}] We will give the proof for part 1 of the proposition; the proof of part 2 is very similar. In addition, we assume, without loss of generality, that \begin{equation} \label{main prop wlog} \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}( u-v) \leq 0. \end{equation} For $\zeta$ as given in (\ref{constants}), we regularize $u$ by taking $x$-sup-convolution and denote $u^+_{\delta^\zeta}$ by $u^+$. We also introduce a perturbation $\tilde{u}$ of $u^+$, which we define by \[ \tilde{u}(x,t)= u^+(x,t)-\delta^{1/4}t. \] By Proposition \ref{prop:x-sup-conv}, $\tilde{u}$ is a subsolution of \[ \tilde{u}_t-F(D^2\tilde{u})\leq -\delta^{1/4} \] in $\tilde{U}$. By the definition of $\tilde{u}$, Proposition \ref{prop:x-sup-conv} and (\ref{main prop wlog}) we have \begin{equation*} \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (\tilde{u} - v)\leq \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (u^+-v )\leq \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (u-v) +2\delta^{\zeta}\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times (0,T)}\leq c_1\delta^{\zeta}, \end{equation*} where $c_1$ depends on $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. Define $w=-(\tilde{u}-v-c_1\delta^{\zeta})$. There exist $\rho>0$ and $\bar{x}$ such that $\tilde{U}\subset Y_\rho^-(\bar{x}, T-r_\delta)$. Since $w\geq 0$ on $\bdry \tilde{U}$, we may extend $w^-$ by $0$ to $Y_{2\rho}^-(\bar{x}, T)$. Let $\ensuremath{\underline{\Gamma}}$ be the lower monotone envelope of $-w^-$. We point out that $\ensuremath{\underline{\Gamma}}=-\bar\Gamma$, where $\bar\Gamma$ is the upper monotone envelope of $(\tilde{u}-v-c_1\delta^{\zeta})^+$ in $Y_{2\rho}^-(\bar{x}, T-r_\delta)$. Moreover, we have \[ \{\tilde{u}-v-c_1\delta^{\zeta}=\bar\Gamma\} = \{w=\ensuremath{\underline{\Gamma}}\} \] and \[ \sup_{Y_{2\rho}^-(\bar{x}, T-r_\delta)} (w^-)=\sup_{\tilde{U}}( \tilde{u}-v-c_1\delta^{\zeta}). \] We seek to apply Proposition \ref{pre ABP} with $w$ instead of $u$ and $Y_{2\rho}^-(\bar{x}, T)$ instead of $Y_\rho^-$. Since $d(\tilde{U}, \bdry \Omega\times (0,T)) =2r_\delta$, Proposition \ref{prop:diff of soln} implies that $u$ is differentiable in $t$ in $\tilde{U}$, with \[ \linfty{u_t}{\tilde{U}}\leq C r^{-2}_\delta (\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}+1)\leq C\delta^{-2\zeta}, \] where $C$ depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$ and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. Therefore, $\linfty{\tilde{u}_t}{\tilde{U}}\leq C\delta^{-2\zeta}$ as well. Together with assumption (\ref{assump:vt}), this implies $\tetasemi{w}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\leq C_0\delta^{-2\zeta}$, where $C_0$ depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $T$, $\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$ and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. In addition, assumption (\ref{assump:d2v}) on $v$ and the properties of $x$-sup convolutions (see item (\ref{item:sup conv is semiconvex}) of Proposition \ref{prop:x-sup-conv})) imply $D^2w=D^2(v-\tilde{u})\leq \delta^{-\zeta}I$ in the sense of distributions. Therefore, the hypotheses of Proposition \ref{pre ABP} hold with $K=C_0\delta^{-2\zeta}$, so we obtain \[ \sup_{\tilde{U}}(\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v ) \leq C|\{\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v =\bar{\Gamma}\}\cap \tilde{U}|^{\frac{1}{n+1}} \delta^{-2\zeta}, \] where $\bar{\Gamma}$ is the upper monotone envelope of $\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v $ and $C$ depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $T$, $diam \tilde{U}$, $\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$ and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. Therefore, \begin{equation} \label{bd cont set below} |\{\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v =\bar{\Gamma}\}\cap \tilde{U}|\geq C_1 \delta^{2\zeta(n+1)}\left(\sup_{\tilde{U}}(\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v) \right)^{(n+1)}, \end{equation} where $C_1$ depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $T$, $diam \tilde{U}$, $\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$ and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. We claim \begin{equation} \label{main lemma bound sup} \sup_{\tilde{U}}(\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v )\leq \left(\frac{\bar{c}}{C_1}\right)^{\frac{1}{n+1}}\delta^{\zeta}, \end{equation} where $\bar{c}$ is given by (\ref{choice o c_1}). If (\ref{main lemma bound sup}) holds, then we have \[ \sup_{\tilde{U}} (u-v) \leq \sup_{\tilde{U}} (\tilde{u}-v )+ \delta^{1/4}T \leq c_1\delta^{\zeta} +\left(\frac{\bar{c}}{C_1}\right)^{\frac{1}{n+1}}\delta^{\zeta} + \delta^{1/4}T \leq \tilde{c}\delta^{\tilde{\alpha}}, \] where $\tilde{c}= c_1+T+ \left(\frac{\bar{c}}{C_1}\right)^{\frac{1}{n+1}}$ and $\tilde{\alpha}=\min\{1/4, \zeta\}$. Therefore, to complete the proof of the lemma it will suffice to show that (\ref{main lemma bound sup}) holds. To this end, we proceed by contradiction and assume that (\ref{main lemma bound sup}) does not hold, in which case we have a lower bound for the right-hand side of (\ref{bd cont set below}) and thus obtain \[ |\{\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v =\bar{\Gamma}\}\cap \tilde{U}|\geq \bar{c}\delta^{3\zeta(n+1)}. \] We now apply Lemma \ref{lem:Helper2} with $\mathcal{C}=\{\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v =\bar{\Gamma}\}\cap \tilde{U}$ and obtain that there exists a point $(x_0, t_0)\in \{\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v =\bar{\Gamma}\}$ with \begin{equation} \label{Y^-in U} Y^-_\delta(x_0,t_0)\subset \tilde{U} \end{equation} and a paraboloid $P$ with $P(x_0,t_0)=0$, \begin{equation} \label{what P solves} P_t-F(D^2P)=0, \end{equation} and \begin{equation} \label{touch u at x0t0 used} \begin{split} u^+(x,t)-u^+(x_0, t_0) \geq P(y,s) - E\cdot (|x_0-x|^2+(t_0-t)), \end{split} \end{equation} where the error $E$ is given by \[ E=C_2 \bar{c}^{-1/\sigma}\delta^{1- \frac{\zeta}{\sigma}(3n+4+2\sigma)}, \] and $C_2$ depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. We recall the representation formula for the upper monotone envelope of a function (Lemma \ref{lem:representation}): \[ \bar{\Gamma}(w)(x_0,t_0) = \inf \{\zeta \cdot x +h : \ \zeta \cdot x + h \geq w(s,x) \text{ for all } t\in (a,t_0], x\in \Omega\}. \] Since $(x_0, t_0)$ is in the contact set of $\tilde{u}-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v $ with its upper monotone envelope, the representation formula implies that there exist $\zeta\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^n$ and $h\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}$ such that \[ \zeta \cdot x_0+h = \bar{\Gamma}(w)(x_0,t_0)=\tilde{u}(x_0,t_0)-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v (x_0,t_0) \] and \[ \zeta \cdot x +h\geq \tilde{u}(x,t)-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - v (x,t) \] for all $x$ and for all $t\leq t_0$ (so in particular, for all points in $Y^-_\delta(x_0,t_0)$). Therefore, for all $(x,t)\in Y^-_\delta(x_0,t_0)$, we have \[ v(x,t) \geq \tilde{u}(x,t)-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - \zeta \cdot x -h, \] with equality holding at $(x_0,t_0)$. By the definitions of $\tilde{u}$ and $u^+$, we find \[ v(x,t)\geq u^+(x,t) -\delta^{1/4}t-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - \zeta \cdot x -h \] holds on $Y^-_\delta(x_0,t_0)$ with equality holding at $(x_0,t_0)$. We use the bound (\ref{touch u at x0t0 used}) to find that for all $(x,t)\in Y^-_\delta(x_0, t_0)$, \[ v(x,t) \geq u^+(x_0,t_0) + P(x,t) - E\cdot(|x_0-x|^2+(t_0-t))-\delta^{1/4}t-c_1\delta^{\zeta} - \zeta \cdot x -h, \] with equality at $(x_0,t_0)$. By (\ref{Y^-in U}), $Y^-_\delta(x_0, t_0)\subset \Omega\times (0,T)$. Since $v$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of (\ref{eqn:mainLemma}) on $\Omega \times (0,T)$, we find \[ P_t+E - \delta^{1/4} - F\left(D^2P - \frac{E}{2}I\right)\geq 0. \] Since the nonlinearity $F$ is uniformly elliptic, we have \[ P_t+E - \delta^{1/4} - F(D^2P) +\lambda\frac{E}{2}\geq 0. \] But, according to (\ref{what P solves}), $P_t-F(D^2P)=0$, so we obtain \[ E+\lambda\frac{E}{2}\geq \delta^{1/4}. \] Using the definition of $E$, we find \[ C_3 \bar{c}^{-1/\sigma}\delta^{1-\frac{\zeta}{\sigma}(3n+4+2\sigma)}\geq \delta^{1/4}, \] where $C_3$ is a constant that depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. By our choice of $\zeta$, we obtain \[ C_3 \bar{c}^{-1/\sigma} \delta^{1/2}\geq \delta ^{1/4}. \] We choose \begin{equation} \label{choice o c_1} \bar{c}= C_3^{\sigma} \end{equation} and find \[ \delta^{1/2} \geq \delta^{1/4}, \] which is impossible, so (\ref{main lemma bound sup}) must hold. \end{proof} Lemma \ref{lem:Helper2} follows from Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions} and a covering argument. The covering argument is slightly more involved than in the elliptic case because of the need to avoid times $t$ that are close to the terminal time $T$. \begin{proof}[Proof of Lemma \ref{lem:Helper2}] We will denote the $x$-sup convolution $u^+_{\delta^{\zeta}}$ by simply $u^+$. We will need the sets: \begin{align*} \ensuremath{\tilde{Y}_{\rdel}}(\bar{x},\bar{t}) &:= Y^{\delta^{\zeta}}_{\ensuremath{r_{\delta}}} (\bar{x},\bar{t}) = B\left(\bar{x}, r_\delta - \delta^{\zeta} \linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\right) \times \left(\bar{t} , \bar{t}+r_\delta^2\right]\\ \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(\bar{x},\bar{t}) &:= K^{\delta^{\zeta}}_{\ensuremath{r_{\delta}}} (\bar{x},\bar{t}) =\left[ \bar{x} - \delta^{\zeta} ,\bar{x} + \delta^{\zeta}\right]^n \times \left(\bar{t} , \bar{t}+\frac{r_\delta^2}{81n}\right] \\ \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(\bar{x},\bar{t}) &:=\left[ \bar{x} - \delta^{\zeta} ,\bar{x} + \delta^{\zeta}\right]^n \times \left(\bar{t}+\frac{r_\delta^2}{162n} , \bar{t}+\frac{r_\delta^2}{81n}\right], \end{align*} where $\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(\bar{x},\bar{t})$ is the top half (in terms of $t$) of $\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(\bar{x},\bar{t})$. See Figure 1. \begin{figure} \label{sets for lemma}\caption{The sets involved in the proof of Lemma \ref{lem:Helper2}.} \centering \includegraphics[trim = 0cm 0cm 0cm 0cm , clip, scale=.35]{bdrysets.eps}\end{figure} We remark that there exists a constant $\delta_1$ that depends only on $n$ such that if $\delta\leq \delta_1$, then \begin{equation} \label{remark about sets} \text{if $(x,t)\in \tilde{U}$ and $(x_0,t_0)\in \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x,t)$, then $Y_{\delta}^-( x_0,t_0) \subset \ensuremath{\tilde{Y}_{\rdel}}(x,t)\cap \Omega \times (0,T) $.} \end{equation} (We point out that in order for (\ref{remark about sets}) to hold, it is important that $(x_0,t_0) \in \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x,t)$, and not only in $\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(x,t)$.) We take $\delta<\delta_1$. We recall that Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions} gives a lower bound on the size of $\Psi_M^{+,\delta^{2\zeta}}(u^+)$, the set where $u^+$ has second-order expansions from below. For the rest of the argument we will denote $\Psi_M^{+,\delta^{2\zeta}}(u^+)$ simply by $\Psi_M^+$. We will show that there exists a point in the intersection of $\Psi_M^+$ and $\mathcal{C}$ by using the lower bounds on the size of $\mathcal{C}$ and $\Psi_M^{+}$ (the latter is proved in Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}). Since Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions} bounds the size of the complement of $\Psi_M^{+}$ inside of sets of the form $\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(\bar{x},\bar{t})$, we first cover $\tilde{U}$ by $\{ \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x,t): \ \ (x,t)\in \tilde{U}\}$. It is clear that the finite collection $\{ \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_j,t_j): \ \ (x_j,t_j)\in \tilde{U}\}_{j=1}^s$ covers $\tilde{U}$, where $s \leq C_0 \delta^{-\zeta(n+2)}$, for $C_0$ a constant that depends on $diam \Omega$, $T$, and $n$ . Therefore, there exists an $i$ such that \[ |\mathcal{C}\cap \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_i,t_i)| \geq \frac{|\mathcal{C}|}{s} . \] The lower bound on $|\mathcal{C}|$ and the upper bound on $s$ gives \[ |\mathcal{C}\cap \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_i,t_i)| \geq \frac{\bar{c} \delta^{3\zeta (n+1)}}{C_0 \delta^{-\zeta (n+2)}} = \frac{\bar{c}}{C_0} \delta^{\zeta (4n+5) }. \] In view of the definition of $\tilde{U}$, we have $d((x_i,t_i), \bdry \Omega\times (0,T))\geq 2r_\delta$ and $t_i\leq T-r_\delta^2$; therefore, $Y_{r_\delta}(x_i,t_i)\subset \Omega\times(0,T)$ and \begin{equation*} d(Y_{r_\delta}(x_i,t_i), \bdry \Omega \times (0,T))\geq r_\delta > \delta^{\zeta}. \end{equation*} Therefore, $u$ satisfies the hypotheses of Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions} in $Y_{r_\delta}(x_i,t_i)$ with $\theta = \delta^{\zeta}$ and $r=r_\delta$. Thus there exists a set $\Psi^{+}_M$ (the ``good set" of $u^+$) with \[ |\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(x_i,t_i)\setminus\Psi^{+}_M|\leq \frac{C_1r_\delta^{n+2}}{M^{\sigma}\delta^{\zeta(1+\sigma)}}(r_\delta^{-\sigma}+\delta^{-\zeta\sigma})\left(\linfty{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)}+1\right)^{1+\sigma} \] where $C_1$ is a universal constant. We take \[ M=\left(\frac{2C_1 C_0 r_\delta^{n+2}\delta^{-\zeta(1+\sigma)}(r_\delta^{-\sigma}+\delta^{-\zeta \sigma})(\linfty{u}{\Omega\times(0,T)}+1)^{1+\sigma}}{\bar{c}\delta^{\zeta (4n+5) }}\right)^{1/\sigma}, \] so that \[ |\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(x_i,t_i)\setminus\Psi^{+}_M|< |\mathcal{C}\cap \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_i,t_i)| . \] Since $\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_i,t_i)\subset \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(x_i,t_i)$, we have \[ |\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_i,t_i)\setminus\Psi^{+}_M|<|\ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}}(x_i,t_i)\setminus\Psi^{+}_M|< |\mathcal{C}\cap \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_i,t_i)| . \] Therefore, there exists a point $(x_0,t_0)\in \mathcal{C}\cap \Psi^{+}_M\cap \ensuremath{\tilde{K}_{\rdel}^T}(x_i,t_i)$. Because of (\ref{remark about sets}), we have $Y_{\delta}^-( x_0,t_0) \subset \ensuremath{\tilde{Y}_{\rdel}}(x,t)\cap \Omega\times (0,T) $. Thus, by Proposition \ref{prop: more regularity for convolutions}, there exists a polynomial $P\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ such that \[ P_t-F(D^2P)=0 \] and, on $Y_{\delta}^-( x_0,t_0)$, \begin{equation} \label{touch u+ below} \begin{split} u^{+}(x,t)-u^{+}(x_0, t_0) \geq P(y,s)&- \frac{c(n)}{r_\delta^2}M (\delta|x-x_0|^2 + \delta^2|t-t_0| )\\ &-\frac{C\delta}{r_\delta}\left(M+\delta^{-\zeta}(1+\linfty{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)})\right)(t_0-t). \end{split} \end{equation} There exists a constant $C_2$ that depends on $n$ and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$ such that \[ \delta^\zeta\leq r_\delta \leq C_2\delta^{\zeta}. \] Therefore \[ M\leq C_3 \bar{c}^{-1/\sigma}\delta^{-\frac{\zeta}{\sigma}(3n+4+2\sigma)}, \] where $C_3$ depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$. We use this to bound the coefficients of the error terms in (\ref{touch u+ below}) and find \begin{equation*} \begin{split} u^{+}(x,t)-u^{+}(x_0, t_0) \geq P(y,s) - C_4 \bar{c}^{-1/\sigma}\delta^{1-2\zeta - \frac{\zeta}{\sigma}(3n+4+2\sigma)}(|x-x_0|^2+(t_0-t)). \end{split} \end{equation*} \end{proof} \section{Error estimate} \label{section: comparison} In this section we give the precise statement and the proof of our main result: \begin{thm} \label{main result} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}), (F\ref{last prop of F}) and (U1). Assume $u\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (0,T))\cap C_x^{0,1}(\Omega \times (0,T))$ is a solution of \begin{equation} \label{maineqn} u_t-F(D^2u)=0 \text{ in } \Omega\times (0,T) \end{equation} and assume $\{v_{\delta}\}_{\delta>0}$ is a family of $\delta$-supersolutions (resp. $\delta$-subsolutions) of (\ref{maineqn}) such that, for some $M<\infty$ and for all $\delta>0$, \[ \etanorm{v_\delta}{\Omega\times (0,T)}\leq M \] and \[ u-v_\delta\leq 0 \text{ (resp. }v_\delta-u \leq 0\text{) on }\bdry(\Omega \times (0,T)). \] There exist a constant $\bar{\delta}$ that depends only on $n$, a constant $\bar{\alpha}$ that depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$ and $\eta$, and a constant $\bar{c}$ that depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $diam\Omega$, $T$, $M$, $\etanorm{u}{\Omega \times (0,T)}$, and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$, such that for all $\delta\leq \bar{\delta}$, \begin{equation*} u-v_\delta \leq \bar{c}\delta^{\bar{\alpha}} \ \ (\text{resp. } v_\delta-u \leq \bar{c}\delta^{\bar{\alpha}}). \end{equation*} \end{thm} \begin{rem} \label{remAboutLips} The assumption $u\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (0,T))\cap C_x^{0,1}(\Omega \times (0,T))$ is satisfied in the following situation. Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}), (F\ref{last prop of F}), (U1), and that $\partial \Omega$ is regular. Take $g\in C^{1,\alpha}(\bdry \Omega\times (0,T))$. Then, according to the interior regularity estimates of Theorem \ref{thm:Wang's c alpha thm} and the boundary estimates of \cite[Section 2]{WangII}, the solution $u$ of the boundary value problem \begin{equation*}\left\{ \begin{array}{l l} u_t-F(D^2 u)=0 &\quad \text{ in }\Omega\times(0,T),\\ u=g &\quad \text{ on }\bdry \Omega, \end{array}\right. \end{equation*} is indeed Lipschitz continuous in $x$ and H\"older continuous in $t$ on all of $\Omega\times (0,T)$, with \[ \etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (0,T)}, \linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)} \leq C, \] where $C$ depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $||g||_{C^{1,\alpha}(\bdry \Omega\times (0,T))}$, $diam \Omega$ and the regularity of $\bdry \Omega$. \end{rem} Theorem \ref{main result} follows easily from Proposition \ref{main lemma}. \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem \ref{main result}] We give the proof of the bound on $\sup (u-v_\delta)$ in the case that $v_\delta$ is a $\delta$-supersolution; the proof of the other case is very similar. First we regularize $v_\delta$ by taking inf-convolution: we let \[ v(x,t) = \inf_{(y,s)\in \Omega\times(0,T)} \left\{v_\delta (y,s) + \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\delta^{\zeta}}+ \frac{|t-s|^2}{2\delta^{\zeta}}\right\} \] and define the constant \[ \nu= 2\delta^{\zeta/2} \linfty{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)}^{1/2} + \delta, \] and the set \[ U^\nu = \left\{(x,t)| d_e((x,t),\bdry(\Omega \times (0,T))) \geq 2\delta^{\zeta/2} \linfty{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)}^{1/2} + \delta\right\}. \] We point out that $U^\nu$ is of the form $\Omega'\times (a,b)$, where $\Omega'$ satisfies (U1). Therefore, Proposition \ref{main lemma} holds in $U^\nu$ instead of $\Omega \times (0,T)$ (see Remark \ref{rem:where main prop holds}). According to item (\ref{inf conv is delta soln}) of Proposition \ref{properties of inf-convolution}, $v$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of (\ref{eqn:mainLemma}) in $U^\nu$. Moreover, by items (\ref{item:inf conv is semiconcave}) and (\ref{item:lip bd on v}) of Proposition \ref{properties of inf-convolution}, $v$ satisfies the regularity assumptions of Proposition \ref{main lemma} in $U^\nu$. Therefore, according to Proposition \ref{main lemma}, \begin{equation} \label{consequence of Propo} \sup_{\tilde{U}}(u-v) \leq \tilde{c}\delta^{\tilde{\alpha}}+ \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}(u-v), \end{equation} where \[ \tilde{U} = \left\{(x,t)| d((x,t),\bdry U^\nu) \geq 2r_\delta, \text{ and }t\leq T-r_\delta^2\right\} \] and $r_\delta$ is as given in the statement of Proposition \ref{main lemma}. Since $u\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (0,T))$, $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega \times (0,T))$, and $u\leq v$ on $\bdry \Omega\times (0,T)$, there exists a constant constant $c_1>0$ that depends on $n$, $M$, and $\etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (0,T)}$ such that \begin{equation} \label{bound on bdry U} \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (u-v_\delta)\leq c_1 \delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2}} \end{equation} and \begin{equation} \label{bound on whole set} \sup_{\Omega \times (0,T)} (u- v_\delta) \leq \sup_{\tilde{U}} (u-v) +c_1 \delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2}}. \end{equation} By item (\ref{item:bound from below on inf conv}) of Proposition \ref{properties of inf-convolution}, \[ \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (u-v) \leq \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (u - v_\delta) + \etasemi{v_\delta}{\Omega \times (0,T)}(2\delta^{\zeta} \etasemi{v_\delta}{\Omega \times (0,T)})^{\frac{\eta}{2-\eta}} \leq \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (u - v_\delta) +c_2\delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2-\eta}}, \] where $c_2$ is a constant that depends on $n$ and $M$. By the above line and (\ref{bound on bdry U}) we have \[ \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}(u-v)\leq \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}(u - v_\delta) +c_2 \delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2-\eta}} \leq c_1 \delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2}}+c_2 \delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2-\eta}} \leq c_3\delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2}} , \] where $c_3$ depends on $n$, $M$ and $\etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (0,T)}$. So, by (\ref{bound on whole set}), (\ref{consequence of Propo}), and the above line, we have \[ \sup_{\Omega \times (0,T)} (u- v_\delta) \leq\tilde{c}\delta^{\tilde{\alpha}} +c_3\delta^{\frac{\zeta\eta}{2}} . \] We thus take $\bar{c}=c_3+\tilde{c}$ and $\bar{\alpha}=min\{\tilde{\alpha}, \frac{\zeta\eta}{2}\}$ to complete the proof of the theorem. \end{proof} \section{Discrete approximation schemes} \label{section: approx} We now present the error estimate for finite difference approximation schemes. First, we introduce the necessary notation and assumptions, closely following \cite{Approx schemes} and \cite{Kuo Trudinger parabolic diff ops}. In the next section we give the full statement of the error estimate and its proof. The space-time mesh is denoted by $E$: \[ E=h \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}^n \times h^2 \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}=\{(x,t)| x=(m_1,..,m_n)h, t=mh^2, \text{ where } m,m_1,...,m_n\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}^n\}. \] We fix some $N>1$ and define the subset $Y$ of $E$ by \[ Y= \{ y\in h\ensuremath{\mathbb{Z}}^n| 0<|y|<hN\}. \] Next we introduce finite difference operators for a function $u$: \begin{align*} \delta^-_{\tau} u (x,t) &= \frac{1}{h}(u(x,t) - u(x,t-h)),\\ \delta_y^2 u (x,t)&=\frac{1}{|y|^2}(u(x+y,t)+u(x-y,t)-2u(x,t)), \text{ and}\\ \delta^2u(x,t) &=\{\delta^2_y u (x,t)| y\in Y\}. \end{align*} An \emph{implicit finite difference operator} is an operator of the form \[ \ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}} [u] (x,t) = \delta^-_{\tau} u (x,t) - \mathcal{F}_h(\delta^2 u(x,t)), \] where $\mathcal{F}_h: \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^Y \rightarrow \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}$ is locally Lipschitz. We denote points in $\ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^Y$ by $r=(r_1,...,r_{|Y|})$. We say an operator is \emph{monotone} if it satisfies: \begin{enumerate}[({S}1)] \item there exists a constant $\lambda_0$ and $\Lambda_0$ such that for all $i=1,...,|Y|,$ \[ \lambda_0\leq \frac{\partial \mathcal{F}_h}{\partial r_i}\leq \Lambda_0. \] \end{enumerate} This is equivalent to the definition given in the introduction. A scheme $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ is said to be \emph{consistent with $F$} if for all $\phi \in C^3(\Omega\times(0,T))$, \[ \sup_{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}}|\phi_t-F(D^2\phi)-\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[\phi]| \rightarrow 0 \text{ as } h\rightarrow 0. \] In \cite[Section 4]{Kuo Trudinger parabolic diff ops}, it was shown that if a nonlinearity $F$ satisfies (F\ref{ellipticity}), then there exists a monotone implicit scheme $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ that is consistent with $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$, and the constants $\lambda_0$ and $\Lambda_0$ depend only on $n$, $\lambda$ and $\Lambda$. In \cite{Kuo Trudiner elliptic ops}, a monotone and consistent approximation scheme for elliptic equations is explicitly constructed, and the construction in the parabolic case is analogous. In order to obtain an error estimate, we need to make an assumption that quantifies the above rate of convergence. As in \cite{Approx schemes}, we assume: \begin{enumerate}[({S}2)] \item there exists a positive constant $K$ such that for all $\phi\in C^3(\Omega\times(0,T))$ , \[ \sup|\phi_t-F(D^2\phi)-\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[\phi]|\leq K(h+ h\linfty{D_x^3\phi}{\Omega\times (0,T)} + h^2\linfty{\phi_{tt}}{\Omega\times (0,T)}). \] \end{enumerate} Schemes that satisfy (S\ref{consistent}) are said to be \emph{consistent with an error estimate for $F$ in $\Omega\times (0,T)$ with constant $K$}. Given $\Omega\times (0,T)\subset \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1}$, we denote $ (\Omega\times (0,T)) \cap E$ by $\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}$. We divide $\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}$ into interior and boundary points relative to the operator $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$. Mainly, we define \[ \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i=\left\{p\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h} | d(p, \bdry\Omega \times (0,T))\geq Nh\right\} \] to be the interior points and \[ \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^b = \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h} \setminus \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i \] to be the boundary points. Notice that $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[u](x,t)$ depends only on $u(x+y,s)$ for $0\leq|y|<hN$ and for $t-h^2\leq s\leq t$. The discrete H\"older seminorm of a function $u$ on $\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}$ is defined to be \[ \etasemi{u}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}} = \sup_{p,q \in \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}}\frac{|u(p)-u(q)|}{d(p,q)^{\eta}} \] and the discrete H\"older norm is \[ \etanorm{u}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}} = \linfty{u}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}}+\etasemi{u}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}} . \] In \cite[Section 4]{Kuo Trudinger parabolic diff ops} it is shown that solutions of the discrete equation $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v_h] = 0$ are uniformly equicontinuous. We summarize this result: \begin{thm} \label{KTthm} Assume that $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ is an implicit monotone finite difference scheme and that $v_h$ is a solution of $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v_h] = 0$. There exists a constant $C$ that depends only on $n$, $\lambda_0$ and $\Lambda_0$ such that for all $h\in (0,1)$, \[ \etanorm{v_h}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i} \leq C. \] \end{thm} \subsection{Inf and sup convolutions for approximation schemes} For a mesh function $v: \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}\rightarrow \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}$, we define the inf- and sup- convolutions of $v$ at $(x,t)\in \Omega\times (0,T)$ by \[ \ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}(x,t) = \inf_{(y,s)\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}} \left\{ v(y,s) + \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}+\frac{|t-s|^2}{2\theta}\right\} \] and \[ v^{+}_{\theta, \theta}(x,t) = \sup_{(y,s)\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}} \left\{ v(y,s) - \frac{|x-y|^2}{2\theta}-\frac{|t-s|^2}{2\theta}\right\}, \] For $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h})$, we introduce the quantity \[ \omega(h, \theta)=nh+2\theta^{1/2}\etanorm{v}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}}(diamU)^\eta \] and the set \[ U^h_{\theta} = \{ p\in \Omega \times (0,T)| d_e(p,\bdry{\Omega \times (0,T)}) \geq \omega(h, \theta) +Nh\}. \] In the appendix we summarize the basic properties of inf- and sup- convolutions of mesh functions (see Proposition \ref{prop: inf-conv for mesh}). It is a classical fact of the theory of viscosity solutions that if $u$ is the viscosity solution of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$ in $\Omega\times (0,T)$, then the sup-convolution of $u$ is a subsolution of the same equation. In the following proposition, we establish a similar relationship between solutions $v_h$ of discrete equations and $\delta$-solutions of $u_t-F(D^2u)=0$. This is a key step in establishing an error estimate for discrete approximation schemes. \begin{prop} \label{item: mesh solves equation} Assume that $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ is a monotone and implicit scheme consistent with an error estimate for $F$ with constant $K$. Assume $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h})$. \begin{enumerate} \item If $v$ satisfies $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v] \geq 0$ in $ \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i$ then $\ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of \[ u_t - F(D^2u) = - Kh \] in $U^h_{\theta}$, with $\delta= Nh$. \item If $v$ satisfies $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v] \leq 0$ in $ \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i$, then $v^{+}_{\theta, \theta}$ is $\delta$-subsolution of \[ u_t - F(D^2u) = Kh \] in $U^h_{\theta}$, with $\delta= Nh$. \end{enumerate} \end{prop} \begin{proof} We give the proof of item (1); the proof of item (2) is analogous. Let $(x,t)\in U^h_\theta$ and let $(x^*, t^*)$ be a point at which the infimum is achieved in the definition of $v^-_{\theta,\theta}$. Assume that $P\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{P}_\infty}$ is such that $P\leq \ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}$ on $Y^-_{Nh}(x,t)$, with equality at $(x,t)$. Because $P\leq v$ on \emph{all} of $Y^-_{Nh}(x,t)$, for each $y$ with $0<|y|\leq hN$ we have \begin{equation} \label{eq:implicit} \begin{split} \delta^2_yP(x,t) &\leq \delta^2_y\ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}(x,t)\leq \delta^2_y v(x^*,t^*), \text{ and}\\ \delta^-_\tau P(x,t)& \geq \delta^-_\tau \ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}(x,t) \geq \delta^-_\tau v(x^*, t^*). \end{split} \end{equation} The definition of $U^h_\theta$ and item (1) of Proposition \ref{prop: inf-conv for mesh} yield $(x^*, t^*) \in \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i$; therefore, \[ 0\leq \ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v](x^*, t^*) = \delta^-_\tau v(x^*, t^*) - \mathcal{F}_h(\delta^2 v(x^*, t^*)) . \] Using (\ref{eq:implicit}) and the monotonicity of $\mathcal{F}_h$ to bound the right-hand side of the above yields \begin{equation} \label{eq:scheme at x*} 0\leq \delta^-_\tau P(x,t) - \mathcal{F}_h(\delta^2P(x,t)). \end{equation} That $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ is consistent with an error estimate implies that \[ |P_t(x,t) -F(D^2P(x,t))- (\delta^-_\tau P(x,t) - \mathcal{F}_h(\delta^2 P(x,t) ))| \leq Kh. \] Together with (\ref{eq:scheme at x*}), this implies \[ P_t -F(D^2P) \geq -Kh. \] \end{proof} \section{Error estimate for approximation schemes} \label{section:error est approx} We prove \begin{thm} \label{prop: convergence for approx schemes} Assume (F\ref{ellipticity}), (F\ref{last prop of F}) and (U1). Assume $u\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (0,T))\cap C_x^{0,1}(\Omega \times (0,T))$ is a solution of \begin{equation} \label{h thm main eqn} u_t-F(D^2u)=0 \end{equation} in $\Omega \times (0,T)$. Assume $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}$ is an implicit monotone scheme consistent with an error estimate for (\ref{h thm main eqn}) and that $v_h$ satisfies $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v_h] \geq 0$ (resp. $\ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v_h] \leq 0$) in $\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}$. Assume that for some constant $M<\infty$ and for all $h>0$, \[ \etasemi{v_h}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i}\leq M \] and \[ u-v_h\leq 0 \text{ (resp. } u-v_h\geq 0\text{) on }\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^b. \] There exist a constant $\bar{h}$ that depends only on $n$, a constant $\bar{\alpha}$ that depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$ and $\eta$, and a constant $\bar{c}$ that depends on $n$, $N$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$, $diam\Omega$, $T$, $M$ ,$\etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (0,T)}$, and $\linfty{Du}{\Omega\times(0,T)}$, such that for all $h\leq \bar{h}$, \begin{equation*} \sup_{\Omega \times (0,T)}u-v_h \leq \bar{c}h^{\bar{\alpha}} \ \ (\text{resp. } \sup_{\Omega \times (0,T)}v_h-u \leq \bar{c}h^{\bar{\alpha}}). \end{equation*} \end{thm} \begin{rem} Suppose that $u$ is the solution of the boundary value problem \begin{equation*}\left\{ \begin{array}{l l} u_t-F(D^2 u)=0 &\quad \text{ in }\Omega\times(0,T),\\ u=g &\quad \text{ on }\bdry \Omega, \end{array}\right. \end{equation*} and $v_h$ satisfies \begin{equation*}\left\{ \begin{array}{l l} \ensuremath{\mathcal{S}_{h}}[v_h]=0 &\quad \text{ in }\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^i,\\ v_h=g &\quad \text{ on }\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}^b, \end{array}\right. \end{equation*} where $\partial \Omega$ is sufficiently regular and $g\in C^{1,\alpha}( \Omega\times (0,T))$. Then, as explained in Remark \ref{remAboutLips}, $u$ satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem \ref{prop: convergence for approx schemes}, and $v_h$ satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem \ref{prop: convergence for approx schemes} because of Theorem \ref{KTthm}. \end{rem} \begin{rem} We do not know whether our result holds for explicit or mixed schemes. Our method cannot be used in those cases, since we are able to verify Proposition \ref{item: mesh solves equation} only for implicit schemes. \end{rem} Theorem \ref{prop: convergence for approx schemes} follows easily from Proposition \ref{main lemma}. \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem \ref{prop: convergence for approx schemes}] We give the proof of the bound on $\sup (u-v_h)$; the proof of the other case is very similar. First we regularize $v_h$ by taking inf-convolution. We denote $v^-= v^-_{h^{\zeta}, h^\zeta}$ and define \[ \nu= \omega(h,\theta)+Nh, \] and \[ U^\nu = \left\{(x,t)| d((x,t),\bdry(\Omega \times (0,T))) \geq \omega(h,\theta)+Nh\right\}. \] Then, according to Proposition (\ref{item: mesh solves equation}), $v^-$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of \[ v^-_t-F(D^2v^-)\geq -h \] in $U^\nu$, with $\delta=Nh$. We point out that $U^\nu$ is of the form $\Omega'\times (a,b)$, where $\Omega'$ satisfies (U1). Therefore, Proposition \ref{main lemma} holds in $U^\nu$ instead of $\Omega \times (0,T)$ (see Remark \ref{rem:where main prop holds}). Since we proved Proposition \ref{main lemma} for $\delta$-solutions with right-hand side $0$, we have to perturb $v^-$. We introduce \[ v(x,t)=v^-(x,t)+ht, \] so that $v$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of (\ref{h thm main eqn}) in $U^\nu$ with $\delta=Nh$. Moreover, by items (\ref{item: mesh inf conv is semiconcave}) and (\ref{item: mesh lip bd on v}) of Proposition \ref{prop: inf-conv for mesh}, $v$ satisfies the regularity assumptions of Proposition \ref{main lemma}. Therefore, according to Proposition \ref{main lemma}, \begin{equation} \label{h consequence of Propo} \sup_{\tilde{U}}(u-v) \leq \tilde{c}(Nh)^{\tilde{\alpha}}+ \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}(u-v), \end{equation} where \[ \tilde{U} = \left\{(x,t)| d((x,t),\bdry(\Omega \times (0,T))) \geq \omega(h,\theta)+Nh+2r_\delta \text{ and }t\leq T-r_\delta\right\} \] and $r_\delta$ is given in the statement of Proposition \ref{main lemma}. Since $u\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega\times (0,T))$, $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega \times (0,T))$, and $u\leq v$ on $\bdry \Omega \times(0,T)$, there exists a constant $c_1$ that depends on $n$, $N$, $T$, $\etanorm{v_h}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}}$ and $\etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (0,T)}$, and a constant $\gamma>0$ that depends on $n$, $\lambda$, $\Lambda$ and $\eta$, such that \begin{equation} \label{h bound on bdry U} \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}} (u-v_h)\leq c_1 h^{\gamma} \end{equation} and \begin{equation} \label{h bound on whole set} \sup_{\Omega \times (0,T)} (u- v_h) \leq \sup_{\tilde{U}} (u-v) +c_1 h^{\gamma}. \end{equation} By item (\ref{item: mesh: bound from below on inf conv}) of Proposition \ref{prop: inf-conv for mesh}, \[ \sup_{\tilde{U}} (u-v) \leq \sup_{\tilde{U}} (u - v_h) + \omega(h, \theta) \] so by the above line and (\ref{h bound on bdry U}) we have \[ \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}(u-v)\leq \sup_{\bdry \tilde{U}}(u - v_h) +c_2 h^{\gamma} \leq c_1 h^{\gamma}+c_2 \delta^{\gamma} \leq c_3h^\gamma , \] where $c_3$ depends on $n$, $N$, $T$, $\etanorm{v_h}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}}$ and $\etanorm{u}{\Omega\times (0,T)}$. So, by (\ref{h bound on whole set}), (\ref{h consequence of Propo}), and the above, we have \[ \sup_{\Omega \times (0,T)} (u- v_h) \leq\tilde{c}(Nh)^{\tilde{\alpha}} +c_3h^\gamma . \] We thus take $\bar{c}=c_3+\tilde{c}$ and $\bar{\alpha}=min\{\tilde{\alpha}, \gamma\}$ to complete the proof of the theorem. \end{proof} \section{Appendix} \label{Appendix} \subsection{Proof of Proposition \ref{pre ABP}} \label{subsec:proof of pre ABP} We outline the proof of Proposition \ref{pre ABP}, which is a slight modification of part of the proof of the parabolic version of the ABP estimate in \cite[Section 4.1.2]{ImbertSilvestre}. We assume $\rho=1$; the general case follows by rescaling. As in \cite[Section 4.1.2]{ImbertSilvestre}, we define the function $G\Gamma: Y_1\rightarrow \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1} $ by \[ G\Gamma(x,t)= ( \Gamma(x,t)-x\cdot D\Gamma(x,t), D\Gamma(x,t) ). \] Proposition \ref{pre ABP} follows from the following three lemmas. \begin{lem} \label{lemPreABPsup} Suppose $u\in C(Y_1^-)$ and let $M=\sup_{Y_1^-}u^-$. Then \[ \{(h,\xi)\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1} : |\xi|\leq \frac{M}{2}\leq -h\leq M\} \subset G\Gamma(Y_1^-\cap \{u=\Gamma\}). \] \end{lem} \begin{lem} \label{lemPreABPDG} If $\Gamma$ is $C^{1,1}$ with respect to $x$ and Lipschitz with respect to $t$, then $G\Gamma$ is Lipschitz in $(x,t)$ and we have \[ \det D_{x,t}G\Gamma = \partial_t\Gamma \det D^2\Gamma \] for almost every $(x,t)\in Y^-_1$. \end{lem} \begin{lem} \label{lemPreABPGamma} Suppose $u$ is as in the statement of Proposition \ref{pre ABP}. Then $\Gamma$ is $C^{1,1}$ with respect to $x$ and Lipschitz in $t$. \end{lem} Lemma \ref{lemPreABPsup} is very similar to \cite[Lemma 4.13]{ImbertSilvestre} -- the latter is stated for $u$ a supersolution of $u_t-\mathcal{M}^-(D^2u)\geq f(x)$. However, it is easy to verify that the proof of \cite[Lemma 4.13]{ImbertSilvestre} holds for general functions $u\in C(Y^-_1)$, not only supersolutions. Lemma \ref{lemPreABPDG} is exactly \cite[Lemma 4.4]{ImbertSilvestre}. The proof of Lemma \ref{lemPreABPGamma} is very similar to that of Lemma \cite[Lemma 4.11]{ImbertSilvestre}, which states that if $u$ is a supersolution of $u_t-\mathcal{M}^-(D^2u)\geq f(x)$, then $\Gamma$ is $C^{1,1}$ in $x$ and Lipschitz in $t$. We explain the modifications needed to obtain Lemma \ref{lemPreABPGamma}: \begin{proof}[Proof of Lemma \ref{lemPreABPGamma}] As in the proof of Lemma \cite[Lemma 4.11]{ImbertSilvestre}, it will suffice to show that there exists a constant $K$ such that for all $(x,t)\in Y^-_1$, the following holds: \begin{equation} \label{jet condition} \left\{ \begin{split} &\text{if $P(y,s)=c+\alpha t +p\cdot x+ x\cdot Xx^T$ satisfies $P(x,t)=\Gamma(x,t)$ and }\\ &\text{$P(y,s)\leq \Gamma(y,s)$ for all $(y,s)$ in a neighborhood of $(x,t)$,}\\&\text{then $\alpha\geq -K$ and $X\leq KI$.} \end{split} \right. \end{equation} In the proof of \cite[Lemma 4.11]{ImbertSilvestre}, the assumption that $u$ is a supersolution of $u_t-\mathcal{M}^-(D^2u)\geq f(x)$ is used only to show that (\ref{jet condition}) holds for $(x,t)\in \{u=\Gamma\}$. Thus, we need to verify (\ref{jet condition}) for such points. To this end, assume $(x,t)\in \{u=\Gamma\}$ and $P(y,s)=c+\alpha t +p\cdot x+ x\cdot M x^T$ satisfies $P(x,t)=\Gamma(x,t)$ and $P(y,s)\leq \Gamma(y,s)$ for all $(y,s)$ in a neighborhood of $(x,t)$. Since $\Gamma$ is the lower monotone envelope of $-u^-$ and $(x,t)\in \{u=\Gamma\}$, we have $P(x,t)=u(x,t)$ and $P(y,s)\leq u(y,s)$ for all $(y,s)$ in a neighborhood of $(x,t)$. Our assumption that $D^2u\leq KI$ in the sense of distributions means that there exists a paraboloid $Q(x)$ of opening $K$ that touches $u(\cdot,t)$ from above at $x$. Therefore, $Q$ touches $P(\cdot, t)$ from above at $x$. Therefore, $X\leq KI$. That $\tetasemi{u}{Y^-_\rho}\leq K$ implies $\alpha \geq -K$. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Proposition \ref{pre ABP}] Lemma \ref{lemPreABPsup}, Lemma \ref{lemPreABPDG} and the Area Formula \cite[Chapter 3]{Evans Gariepy}, which applies to $G\Gamma$ because of Lemma \ref{lemPreABPGamma}, imply \begin{equation} \label{ABP-like bd} \begin{split} CM^{n+1} &= |\{(h,\xi)\in \ensuremath{\mathbb{R}}^{n+1} : |\xi|\leq \frac{M}{2}\leq -h\leq M\} |\\ &\leq |G\Gamma(Y_1^-\cap \{u=\Gamma\})|\\ &\leq \int_{Y_1^-\cap \{u=\Gamma\}} |\det D_{x,t} G\Gamma |\\ &\leq \int_{Y_1^-\cap \{u=\Gamma\}} -\partial_t\Gamma \det D^2\Gamma . \end{split} \end{equation} Because $\Gamma$ is non-increasing in $t$ and convex in $x$, the Alexandroff theorem for functions depending on $x$ and $t$ (see Krylov \cite[Appendix 2]{Krylov book}) implies that there exists $A\subset Y_1^-$ with $|Y_1^-\setminus A|=0$ such that for every $(x,t)\in A$, \[ |\Gamma(y,s)-\Gamma(x,t)-D\Gamma(x,t)\cdot (y-x) - (y-x) \cdot D^2\Gamma(x,t)(y-x)^T-\partial_t\Gamma(x,t)(t-s)| \leq o(|x-y|^2+|t-s|) \] (in other words, $\Gamma$ is twice differentiable almost everywhere on $Y_1^-$). We claim \begin{equation} \label{claim for 2nd pt} \text{ if $(x,t)\in A\cap \{u=\Gamma\}$, then } -\partial_t\Gamma(x,t) \det D^2\Gamma(x,t) \leq K^{n+1}. \end{equation} Let us fix $(x,t)\in A\cap \{u=\Gamma\}$. We have $u(x,t)=\Gamma(x,t)$ and $u(y,s)\geq \Gamma(y,s)$ for all $(y,s)\in Y^-_1$. Our assumption that $D^2u\leq KI$ in the sense of distributions means that there exists a paraboloid $Q(x)$ of opening $K$ that touches $u(\cdot,t)$ from above at $x$. Therefore, $Q$ touches $\Gamma(\cdot, t)$ from above at $x$. Therefore, $D^2\Gamma(x,t)\leq KI$ and so \[ \det D^2\Gamma \leq K^n. \] That $\tetasemi{u}{Y^-_\rho}\leq K$ implies $\partial_t\Gamma(x,t) \geq -K$. Thus, (\ref{claim for 2nd pt}) holds. The bound (\ref{cons of ABPbd}) follows from (\ref{claim for 2nd pt}) and (\ref{ABP-like bd}). \end{proof} \subsection{Inf and sup convolutions} In the following proposition we state the facts about inf- and sup- convolutions that are used in this paper. Their proofs are very similar to those in the elliptic case (see \cite[Propositions 5.3 and 5.5]{Rates Homogen}) and we omit them. Given $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega \times (0,T))$ and $\theta>0$, we define the set \[ U^{\theta,\delta} = \left\{(x,t)| d_e((x,t),\bdry(\Omega \times (0,T))) \geq 2\theta^{1/2} \linfty{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)}^{1/2} + \delta\right\}. \] \begin{prop} \label{properties of inf-convolution} Assume $v\in C(\Omega\times (0,T))$. Then: \begin{enumerate} \item If $(x^*, t^*)$ is a point at which the supremum or infimum is achieved in the definition of $v^{\pm}_{\theta,\theta}$, then \[ d_e((x,t), (x^*, t^*))\leq 2\theta^{1/2}\linfty{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)}^{1/2}. \] \item \label{item:bound from below on inf conv} If $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\Omega \times (0,T))$, then for any $(x,t)\in U^{\theta,\delta}$, \[ v^-_{\theta, \theta}(x,t)\geq v(x,t)-\etasemi{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)}(2\theta \etasemi{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)})^{\frac{\eta}{2-\eta}} \] and \[ v^+_{\theta, \theta}(x,t)\leq v(x,t)+\etasemi{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)}(2\theta \etasemi{v}{\Omega \times (0,T)})^{\frac{\eta}{2-\eta}}. \] \item \label{item:inf conv is semiconcave} In the sense of distributions, $D^2 v^-_{\theta,\theta}(x,t) \leq \theta^{-1}I$ and $D^2 v^+_{\theta,\theta}(x,t) \geq -\theta^{-1}I$ for every $(x,t)\in U^{\theta,\delta}$. \item \label{item:lip bd on v} We have $\tetasemi{v^{\pm}_{\theta,\theta}}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\leq 3T\theta^{-1}$. \item \label{inf conv is delta soln} If $v$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of $v_t-F(D^2v)=0$ in $\Omega \times (0,T)$, then $v^-_{\theta,\theta}$ is a $\delta$-supersolution of $v_t-F(D^2v)=0$ in $U^{\theta,\delta}$. \item If $v$ is a $\delta$-subsolution of $v_t-F(D^2v)=0$ in $\Omega \times (0,T)$, then $v^+_{\theta,\theta}$ is a $\delta$-subsolution of $v_t-F(D^2v)=0$ in $U^{\theta,\delta}$. \end{enumerate} \end{prop} \subsection{Inf and sup convolutions of mesh functions} In the following proposition we summarize the facts that we need about inf and sup convolutions of mesh functions. The proof is very similar to the elliptic case (see Proposition 2.3 of \cite{Approx schemes}) so we omit it. \begin{prop} \label{prop: inf-conv for mesh} Assume $v\in C^{0,\eta}(\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h})$. Then: \begin{enumerate} \item \label{eq: d(q,p^*)} If $(x^*,t^*)$ is a point at which the infimum (resp. supremum) is achieved in the definition of $\ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}(x,t)$ (resp. $v^{+}_{\theta, \theta}(x,t) $), then \[ d_e((x^*,t^*),(x,t)) \leq \omega(h,\theta). \] \item \label{item: mesh: bound from below on inf conv} Assume $(x,t)\in \Omega \times (0,T)$ and $(y,s)\in \ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}$ is a closest mesh point to $(x,t)$. Then \[ \ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}(x,t) \geq v(y,s) - \etanorm{v}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}} \omega(h, \theta)^{\eta} \] and \[ v^{+}_{\theta, \theta} (x,t) \leq v(y,s) + \etanorm{v}{\ensuremath{\mathcal{U}_h}} \omega(h,\theta)^{\eta}. \] \item \label{item: mesh inf conv is semiconcave} In the sense of distributions, $D^2 \ensuremath{v^-_{\theta,\theta}}(x,t) \leq \theta^{-1}I$ and $D^2 v^{+}_{\theta, \theta} (x,t)\geq -\theta^{-1}I$ for every $(x,t)\in U^h_\theta$. \item \label{item: mesh lip bd on v} We have $\tetasemi{v^{\pm}_{\theta,\theta}}{\Omega\times(0,T)}\leq 3T\theta^{-1}$. \end{enumerate} \end{prop} \section*{Acknowledgements} The author thanks her thesis advisor, Professor Takis Souganidis, for suggesting this problem and for his guidance and encouragement.

Background {#Sec1} ========== The prompt delivery of cardioplegic solution to all regions of the heart during cardiac surgery is essential for successful myocardial protection \[[@CR1]\]. PMI, detected through serial measurements of specific serum biomarkers including troponin I (TnI) or T (TnT) or creatine kinase (CK)-MB, is associated with worse clinical outcomes \[[@CR2]\]-\[[@CR7]\]. Antegrade delivery of cardioplegic solution to myocardial cells is adequate when supplied by unobstructed coronary arteries but may not be equally effective in the presence of occluded or stenosed arteries as in the case of coronary artery disease (CAD), which may lead to maldistribution of cardioplegic solution \[[@CR8]\]. This might induce PMI and poor recovery of left ventricular function (LV) following revascularization \[[@CR9]\]. Limitations associated with antegrade delivery may be circumvented by the administration of cardioplegic solution in a retrograde fashion through the coronary sinus which relies on the principle that coronary venous systems free of disease and valves can serve as a conduit for the delivery of cardioplegic solution in a homogenous manner \[[@CR10]\]. With this technique, the cardioplegic solution is distributed to the cardiac microstructure through a transmural network of veins that is independent to flow-limiting lesions \[[@CR11]\]. Nevertheless, retrograde cardioplegia presents important potential limitations, which could in part explain the reason why its use remains still relatively limited:the anterior cardiac veins supplying the right ventricle (RV) are not directly connected to the coronary sinus and this may lead to a suboptimal distribution of the cardioplegic solution to the RV \[[@CR12]\],\[[@CR13]\];accurate cannulation of the coronary sinus is crucial as failure in this might lead to the distribution of the cardioplegic solution to the right atrium and not to the venous system;the perfusion pressure requires very close monitoring, as too low a pressure suggests misplacement of the cannula, and too high a pressure can cause rupture of the coronary sinus \[[@CR14]\],\[[@CR15]\]. These potential issues can generally be avoided by care and precision by the surgeon;the delay in arresting the heart due to slow retrograde perfusion if retrograde cardioplegia is used alone (lower flow rates and pressures used to prevent coronary sinus damage and myocardial oedema) \[[@CR16]\],\[[@CR17]\]. Therefore, the combination of both methods of antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia is thought to overcome limitations inherent to both techniques \[[@CR18]\]. However, although both antegrade perfusion and retrograde coronary sinus perfusion have been studied experimentally and used clinically in patients undergoing CABG surgery, there is little information comparing PMI magnitude between different methods of cardioprotection during revascularization. In this regards, we conducted a retrospective subgroup analysis to determine whether the combination of antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia is associated with improved myocardial preservation in patients undergoing CABG surgery. Methods {#Sec2} ======= Study design {#Sec3} ------------ We conducted a retrospective analysis of patients undergoing first time CABG surgery recruited between December 2010 and July 2012 as a subgroup of control patients in a large parallel single-blinded randomised controlled clinical trial carried out at the Heart Hospital, University College London Hospital (London, UK), and investigating the effects of remote ischaemic preconditioning (RIPC) \[[@CR4]\],\[[@CR5]\] in patients undergoing cardiac surgery. The surgery was carried out in accordance with the University College London Hospital NHS Trust guidelines and received local Ethics Committee approval. We obtained written informed consent from all patients recruited into the study. Inclusion and exclusion criteria {#Sec4} -------------------------------- Patients included in the current analysis were recruited within a single centre study investigating the effects of RIPC \[[@CR19]\],\[[@CR20]\] in patients undergoing CABG surgery at the Heart Hospital (UCLH London, UK): only patients receiving the control protocol were included. Patient exclusion criteria comprised:cardiogenic shock or cardiac arrest preceding surgery;positive baseline serum hsTnT;pregnancy;significant peripheral arterial disease (PAD) affecting upper and/or lower limbs;significant hepatic dysfunction (International Normalised Ratio \> 2.0);significant pulmonary disease (Forced Expiratory Volume-1 \< 40% predicted);renal failure with an estimated glomerular filtration rate \<30 mL/min/1.73 m^2^;concomitant therapy with glibenclamide or nicorandil, as these medications have been demonstrated to potentially interfere with RIPC. Surgical procedure {#Sec5} ------------------ Temazepam 10-20 mg was given one hour prior to surgery. Anaesthesia induction was obtained under cardiac monitoring with combinations of midazolam, etomidate, propofol, fentanyl and anti-nicotinic agents (rocuronium, vecuronium or pancuronium). Endotracheal intubation was achieved and mechanical ventilation commenced with oxygen with or without air. For anaesthesia maintenance volatile anaesthetic agents and propofol infusion with or without fentanyl were used. Continuous monitoring of arterial blood pressure, central venous pressure, nasopharyngeal temperature was carried out. Standard non-pulsatile cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) was initiated with the use of membrane oxygenator and cardiotomy suction, followed by the construction of all coronary artery bypass grafts, using either blood cardioplegia or intermittent cross-clamp fibrillation. *Group 1* had 1 litre of cold blood cardioplegia given once the cross clamp was placed and maintenance cold blood cardioplegia was given down the grafts in occluded arteries and also into the aortic root every 20-30 minutes. *Group 2* had coronary artery surgery with the cross clamp fibrillation technique and therefore no cardioplegic solution was given. *Group 3* had warm blood cardioplegia delivered with antegrade and retrograde techniques and was performed by one cardiothoracic surgeon, with an initial 800 ml dose of antegrade cardioplegia followed by 400 ml of retrograde cardioplegia. After this, maintenance was achieved with 100 ml of retrograde cardioplegia after each anastamosis. A hot shot of warm blood without potassium was given after the internal mammary artery (IMA) anastamosis and prior to removal of the cross clamp. All anastomoses were constructed with the single clamp technique. Systemic temperature in group 3 was 35°C. Following anastomosis of the grafts, CPB was discontinued and protamine was used to achieve heparin reversal. Objectives {#Sec6} ---------- To determine whether the addition of retrograde cardioplegia to standard antegrade cardioplegia can reduce PMI and subsequently improve short-term clinical outcomes in patients undergoing first time CABG surgery compared to patients receiving either standard antegrade cardioplegia alone or cross-clamp fibrillation. Study endpoints {#Sec7} --------------- The primary study end-point was PMI, measured by total 72 hour AUC of hsTnT. Blood samples for hsTnT were taken pre-operatively and at 6, 12, 24, 48 and 72 hours post-surgery; hsTnT was measured quantitatively by a one-step enzyme immunoassay based on electrochemiluminescence technology (Roche, Switzerland). The lower detection limit of this assay is 1 ng/L with a threshold of ≥14 ng/L indicating significant myocardial necrosis. Secondary end-points included:AKI score, classified as grade 1, 2 or 3 based on a combination of laboratory (serum creatinine levels) and clinical (urine output) parameters \[[@CR21]\]. Serum creatinine was measured pre-operatively and 24, 48 and 72 hours post-surgery.Inotrope requirement during the first 3 post-operative days, measured using the formula modified from a study by Ko et al. \[[@CR22]\]: Inotrope score = Dosages (μg/kg/min) of:Length of ICU and hospital stay;New onset of AF in the three post-operative days;Clinical outcomes at 6 weeks (death, non-fatal myocardial infarction, coronary artery revascularization, stroke). Statistical analysis {#Sec8} -------------------- Continouos data are presented as mean (standard deviation (SD)) or median (IQR). Categorical data are shown as number (percent). The exposure variable was a categorical variable with three groups corresponding to each of the cardioprotection categories. Comparison between exposure groups was made by including the exposure variable as a categorical variable in a linear regression model for approximately normally distributed endpoint variables. For very skewed endpoint variables the median T-test was used. Where continuous endpoint variables were measured over time a repeated measures linear regression model was fitted to measure the association between exposure variable and endpoint. The assumptions of the linear regression models were performed by analysis of residuals. Categorical data were analysed using Fisher's exact test. No adjustment for multiplicity has been made. Data were analysed using Stata version 12.1. Results {#Sec9} ======= Included patients were recruited into an original RIPC trial enrolling a total of 180 subjects of which 90 patients were randomised to control: 36 patients were subsequently excluded (1 patient died intra-operatively and the remaining 35 underwent CABG and valve surgery or valve surgery alone). Therefore we ultimately analysed data for 54 patients undergoing CABG surgery alone: 28 received antegrade cold blood cardioplegia (group 1), 16 patients received cross-clamp fibrillation (group 2) and 10 antegrade retrograde warm blood cardioplegia (group 3). Group 3 had a lower rate of positive family history of CAD and previous percutaneous coronary intervention (p = 0.047) whereas group 3 had a higher incidence of cerebro-vascular accidents prior to CABG surgery (p = 0.025, Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}): no other significant difference was found among the three groups with respect to baseline patient baseline characteristics (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). Expectedly, cross-clamp time was significantly lower in group 2 (p \< 0.001), however all the remaining parameters of surgery were similar amongst the 3 groups (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}).Table 1**Patient baseline characteristics**PatientsGroup 1Group 2Group 3Antegrade cardioplegiaCross-clamp fibrillationAntegrade retrograde cardioplegia(n = 28)(n = 16)(n = 10)**Age**67 ± 862 ± 1069 ± 9**Gender**Male23 (82%)12 (75%)8 (80%)Female5 (18%)4 (25%)2 (20%)**Ethnicity**Caucasian21 (75%)13 (81%)9 (90%)Afro-Caribbean1 (4%)1 (6%)1 (10%)Asian5 (18%)2 (13%)0 (0%)Chinese1 (4%)0 (0%)0 (0%)**BMI**27.6 ± 4.930.4 ± 5.027.8 ± 4.5**SBP** ***(mmHg)***131.3 ± 20.8128.3 ± 16.9128.9 ± 21.2**DBP** ***(mmHg)***70.3 ± 7.473.4 ± 10.669.1 ± 11.6**HR** ***(bpm)***66.8 ± 11.168.6 ± 10.565.7 ± 13.9**Smoking history**Smoker4 (14%)4 (25%)1 (10%)Non-smoker6 (21%)4 (25%)4 (40%)Ex-smoker18 (64%)8 (50%)5 (50%)**Family history of IHD**22 (79%)13 (81%)4 (40%)**NYHA class**02 (7%)3 (21%)2 (22%)I8 (29%)5 (34%)4 (44%)II17 (61%)5 (34%)2 (22%)III1 (4%)1 (7%)1 (11%)IV0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)**CCS Class**05 (18%)2 (14%)3 (33%)I4 (14%)5 (36%)0 (0%)II16 (57%)6 (43%)4 (44%)III2 (7%)1 (7%)1 (11%)IV1 (4%)0 (0%)1 (11%)**LVEF**\>50%19 (68%)12 (75%)7 (70%)30%-50%8 (29%)3 (19%)3 (30%)\<30%1 (4%)1 (6%)0 (0%)**Co-morbidities**Diabetes mellitus11 (39%)6 (38%)0 (0%)Hypertension25 (89%)13 (81%)7 (70%)Hypercholesterolemia25 (89%)15 (94%)8 (80%)Atrial fibrillation3 (11%)0 (0.0%)2 (20%)Previous MI13 (47%)3 (19%)6 (60%)Previous PCI8 (29%)1 (6%)0 (0%)Previous CVA/TIA3 (11%)0 (0%)3 (30%)Previous cardiac surgery0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)Peripheral arterial disease3 (11%)1 (6%)2 (20%)**Drug history**Aspirin3 (11%)2 (14%)0 (0%)Clopidogrel/Prasugrel2 (7%)0 (0%)0 (0%)Warfarin1 (4%)0 (0%)0 (0%)Beta-blocker22 (79%)11 (79%)8 (80%)Calcium channel blocker12 (43%)3 (21%)4 (40%Statin26 (93%)13 (93%)10 (100%)ACE-I/ARB20 (71%)8 (57%)6 (60%)Long acting nitrates7 (25%)2 (14%)3 (30%)AntidiabeticsInsulin4 (14%)2 (14%)0 (0%)Biguanide2 (7%)1 (7%)0 (0%)Sulphonylurea5 (18%)2 (14%)0 (0%)Diuretics7 (25%)4 (29%)2 (20% )**Indication for surgery**Angina23 (82%)13 (81%)7 (70%)Myocardial infarction5 (18%)3 (19%)3 (30%)**EuroSCORE**3.2 ± 1.92.7 ± 1.73.8 ± 1.8Additive perioperative riskLow (EuroSCORE 0-2)13 (46%)8 (50%)1 (10%)Medium (EuroSCORE 3-5)12 (43%)7 (44%)7 (70%)High (EuroSCORE \>5)3 (11%)1 (6%)2 (20%)Bypass-time (min)93.9 ± 34.677.2 ± 22.080.3 ± 12.8**Cross-clamp time (min)**62.2 ± 24.433.0 ± 7.563.7 ± 13.4**Number of grafts**One1 (4%)0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)Two9 (32%)3 (19%)1 (10.0%)Three10 (36%)10 (63%)8 (80.0%)Four8 (29%)3 (19%)1 (10.0%)**Anesthetic agents*Induction***Anti-nicotinic agentsRocuronium24 (86%)12 (92%)6 (60%)Pancuronium3 (11%)1 (7%)2 (22%)Vecuronium1 (4%)0 (0.0%)1 (11%)Midazolam12 (43%)7 (54%)6 (67%)Etomidate1 (4%)2 (14%)2 (22%)Fentanyl28 (100%)14 (100%)9 (100%)Propofol27 (96%)12 (86%)7 (78%)***Maintenance***Propofol28 (100%)14 (100%)9 (100%)Volatile anestheticsIsoflurane25 (89%)13 (93%)9 (100.%)Sevoflurane3 (11%)1 (7%)0 (0.0%)Intra-operative GTN24 (89%)14 (86%)8 (89%)BMI = body mass index; SBP = systolic blood pressure; DBP = diastolic blood pressure; HR = heart rate; IHD = ischaemic heart disease; NYHA = New York Health Association; CCS = Canadian Cardiovascular Society; LVEF = left ventricular ejection fraction; MI = Myocardial infarction; PCI = Percutaneous coronary intervention; CVA = Cerebrovascular accident; TIA = Transient ischaemic attack; ACE-I = Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor; ARB = Angiotensin receptor blocker; GTN = glyceryl trinitrate.The following parameters have missing values: BMI (Group-2 2), SBP (Group-2 2), DBP (Group-2 2) HR (Group-2 2), Cardio-pulmonary bypass time time (Group-2 2), Cross-clamp time (Group-2 3), NYHA (Group-2 2, Group-3 1), CSS (Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Aspirin (Group-2 2), Clopidogrel (Group- 2), Warfarin (Group-2 2), Beta-blockers (Group-2 2), Calcium-channel blockers (Group-2 2), Long-acting (Group-2 2), Statins (Group-2 2), ACE-I/ARB (Group-2 2), Insulin (Group-2 2), Sulphonylurea (Group-2 2), Biguanide (Group-2 2), Diuretics (Group-2 2), Anti-nicotinic agents (Group-2 3, Group-3 1), Midazolam (Group-2 3, Group-3 1), Etomidate (Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Fentanyl-induction (Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Proprofol-induction (Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Proprofol-maintanance (Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Volatile anaesthetics (Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Intra-operative GTN (Group-3 1).Significance difference: Family history of IHD: p = 0.041; Previous PCI: p = 0.047, Previous CVA/TIA: p = 0.025, Cross-clamp time: p = \<0.001. Primary endpoint {#Sec10} ---------------- Overall there was evidence that the mean total 72 hr AUC hsTnT was different among the three groups (P = 0.050). Examining the subgroup differences showed evidence of lower mean hsTnT in group 3 compared to group 1 (-16.55; 95% CI: -30.08, -3.01; P = 0.018) with slightly weaker evidence of a lower mean hsTnT in group 3 when compared to group 2 (-15.13,; 95% CI -29.87, -0.39; P = 0.044). There was no evidence of a difference when comparing group 2 to group 1 (-1.42,; 95% CI: -12.95, 10.12, P = 0.806) (Figure [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}, Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}).Figure 1**Mean hsTnT pre-operatively and at 6, 12, 24, 48 and 72 hours post-surgery in the three study groups.** ###### **Total hsTnT release and mean hsTnT at the 6 time-points** Patients Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 Comparison Difference Sub-group --------------------------- ---------------------------- ----------------- ---------------- ------------ ------------ -------------------------- ----------- Total 72 hours AUC 34.304 (20.352) 32.885 (18.771) 17.756 (7.542) P = 0.050 1 vs 2 −1.419 (-12.954, 10.115) 0.806 1 vs 3 −16.548 (-30.082, -3.014) 0.018 2 vs 3 −15.129 (-29.867, -0.390) 0.044 Pre-operatively 0.021 (0.020) 0.022 (0.022) 0.014 (0.012) P = 0.997 1 vs 2 0.000 (-0.188, 0.188) 1 vs 3 −0.008 (-0.229, 0.213) 2 vs 3 −0.008 (-0.250, 0.234) 6 hours post-operatively 0.961 (0.619) 0.696 (0.235) 0.399 (0.117) P \< 0.001 1 vs 2 −0.265 (-0.453, -0.077) 1 vs 3 −0.562 (-0.783, -0.341) 2 vs 3 −0.297 (-0.539, -0.055) 12 hours post-operatively 0.752 (0.494) 0.631 (0.195) 0.319 (0.112) P \< 0.001 1 vs 2 −0.121 (-0.309, 0.067) 1 vs 3 −0.433 (-0.654, -0.212)312 2 vs 3 (-0.557, -0.070) 24 hours post-operatively 0.508 (0.309) 0.476 (0.305) 0.266 (0.134) P = 0.100 1 vs 2 −0.032 (-0.220, 0.156) 1 vs 3 −0.241 (-0.463, -0.020) 2 vs 3 −0.209 (-0.451, 0.033) 48 hous post-operatively 0.359 (0.224) 0.410 (0.339) 0.227 (0.114) P = 0.335 1 vs 2 0.044 (-0.144, 0.233) 1 vs 3 −0.139 (-0.360, 0.083) 2 vs 3 −0.183 (-0.425, 0.059) 72 hours post-operatively 0.347 (0.231) 0.381 (0.271) 0.186 (0.119) P = 0.257 1 vs 2 0.027 (-0.161, 0.216) 1 vs 3 −0.168 (-0.390, 0.054) 2 vs 3 −0.195 (-0.437, 0.047) SD = standard deviation; hsTnT = high sensitivity Troponin T; AUC = Area under the curve. The following secondary endpoints had missing values: hsTnT 48 hours post-operatively (Group-1 1), hsTnT 72 hours post-operatively (Group-1 1), AUC (Group-1 1). Secondary endpoints {#Sec11} ------------------- Baseline pre-operative hsTnT levels were \<0.02 μg/L and not significantly different between the 3 groups (Figure [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}, Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}). Overall there was evidence that the mean hsTnT differed at 6 hours (P \< 0.001) and 12 hours (P \< 0.001). At 6 hours there was evidence that mean hsTnT was lower in group 3 than groups 1 (-0.56; 95% CI: -0.78, -0.34). Similarly at 12 hours there was some evidence that mean hsTnT was lower in group 3 than group 1 (-0.43, 95% CI: -0.65, -0.21) (Figure [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}, Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}).Figure 2**AUC of hsTnT over the 72 hours post-surgery in the three study groups.** There was no evidence of a significant difference among the three groups with regards to each of the secondary endpoints (Table [3](#Tab3){ref-type="table"}).Table 3**Summary of study secondary endpoints**PatientsGroup 1Group 2Group 3P valueAntegrade cardioplegiaCross-clamp fibrillationAntegrade retrograde cardioplegia(n = 28)(n = 16)(n = 10)(Mean \[SD\])(Mean \[SD\])(Mean \[SD\])***AKI (N)***022 (79%)11 (69%)10 (100.0%)15 (18%)2 (13%)(0.0%)20 (0.0%)2 (13%)(0.0%)31 (4%)1 (6%)(0.0%)Total number of AKI cases6 (21%)5 (31%)0 (0.0%)0.281\****Inotrope score (mg/kg/hr)***Post bypass7.24 (13.79)4.03 (11.92)3.76 (4.35)0.816\*\*24 hours post-operatively11.90 (21.32)10.11 (22.88)3.67 (4.36)0.635\*\*48 hours post-operatively8.76 (15.39)14.93 (33.57)1.94 (2.98)0.101\*\*72 hours post-operatively1.85 (5.30)13.54 (33.13)2.13 (2.95)0.015\*\*Total29.88 (49.10)42.54 (94.66)11.66 (13.79)0.545\*\*\****New onset AF (N)***6 (21%)5 (31%)4 (40.0%)0.475\****Length of ICU stay (days)***2.0 (2.0-4.0)\*\*\*\*3 (1.0-7.5)\*\*\*\*2.0 (1.0-3.0)\*\*\*\*0.802\*\*\*\*\****Length of hospital stay (days)***8.5 (7.0-11.50)\*\*\*\*8.0 (6.0-10.50)\*\*\*\*7.5 (6.0-9.00)\*\*\*\*0.523\*\*\*\*\****Clinical outcomes at 6 weeks (N)***Death3 (14%)0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)0.283\*Myocardial infarction1 (4%)0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)1.000\*Stroke0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)1.000Revascularization0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)0 (0.0%)1.000\*SD = standard deviation AKI = Acute Kidney Injury; AF = atrial fibrillation; ICU = Intensive Care Unit.\*P value for Fisher's exact test.\*\*P-value from repeated measures linear regression model.\*\*\*P-value form linear regression model.\*\*\*\*Results shown as median (inter-quartile range).\*\*\*\*\*P-value for Median T test.The following secondary endpoints had missing values: Inotrope Score post-bypass (Group-1 2, Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Inotrope Score 24 hours post-operatively (Group-1 3, Group-2 2, Group-3 1), Inotrope Score 48 hours post-operatively (Group-1 3, Group-2 2, Group-3 2), Inotrope Score 72 hours post-operatively (Group-1 3, Group-2 2, Group-3 2), Inotrope Score Total (Group-1 3 , Group-2 2, Group-3 2), Length of ICU stay (Group-2 1), Length of Hospital stay (Group-2 1), Death (Group-1 7, Group-2 3, Group-3 2), Myocardial Infarction (Group-1 7, Group-2 3, Group-3 2), Stroke (Group-1 7, Group-2 3, Group-3 2), Revascularization (Group-1 7, Group-2 3, Group-3 2). Discussion {#Sec12} ========== Myocardial preservation during cardiac surgery is certainly one of the most debated topics in this field. One method of achieving myocardial protection is by using a cardioplegic solution administered into the heart to achieve a temporary arrest of the myocardium whilst the surgeon performs the operation in a bloodless field. In the UK a variety of myocardial protection strategies are used, including cold blood antegrade cardioplegia with topical cooling, warm blood antegrade cardioplegia, warm blood antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia, cold blood antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia and cross clamp fibrillation. In current practice the route of delivery is at the surgeon's discretion and as such there is no consensus on using a specific route to supply the cardioplegia into the myocardium. The most common technique used by the majority of cardiac surgeons is the antegrade route, in which cardioplegia is delivered into the aortic root and spreads via the coronary arteries supplying the myocardium. Although significant clinical evidence favours the safety of this method, severe stenoses of coronary arteries in patients undergoing CABG may prevent the uniform distribution of cardioplegic solution through the myocardium \[[@CR23]\] and, importantly, sub-optimal or inadequate distribution to parts of the myocardium increases the risk for PMI. A proposed solution to overcome this limitation is the retrograde route of delivery, in which cardioplegia is administered through the coronary sinus and through the extensive venous network of the myocardium. Following the pioneering idea of Pratts \[[@CR24]\] who suggested that an ischemic myocardium could be revived back into its healthy form by supplying oxygenated blood through the veins, retrograde cardioplegia was applied for the first time by Blanco et al. \[[@CR25]\] in 1956 and further developed in a significant number of centres: one of the seminal works on retrograde cardioplegia was conducted by Menasche et al. \[[@CR26]\] who demonstrated that, during aortic valve replacement (AVR) surgery, post-operative haemodynamic stability, cardiac outputs and right and left ventricular stroke indices were similar in patients receiving retrograde cardioplegia compared to those receiving antegrade cardioplegia. The same authors also conducted a retrospective observational study on a relatively large group of patients undergoing isolated AVR or CABG surgery with or without concomitant valve surgery using retrograde cardioplegia alone \[[@CR27]\] and, although there was no antegrade cardioplegia group for direct comparison, they reported that the overall trend in mortality rates was either similar or less than what other studies had shown. With the knowledge that the anterior cardiac veins supplying the RV are not directly connected to the coronary sinus and thus may lead to a suboptimal distribution of the cardioplegic solution to the RV \[[@CR12]\],\[[@CR13]\] Kaukoranta et al. \[[@CR28]\] conducted a small study on patients undergoing CABG surgery and receiving either antegrade or retrograde cardioplegia and reported that, despite more significant ischaemic changes within the RV in the retrograde cardioplegia group, no post-operative complication related to the retrograde route was observed. It is therefore clear from the literature that multifactorial clinical endpoints have been used to determine a difference between myocardial protection strategies: moreover the population size in these studies was often too small to come to a meaningful conclusion on the benefit of a particular protection strategy. Importantly, many of the studies on retrograde cardioplegia used retrograde cardioplegia alone when compared to antegrade cardioplegia and only very few studies have compared the combination of antegrade and retrograde techniques against antegrade cardioplegia alone: this is one more reason to interpret current literature with caution. In the only other study similar to our retrospective analysis, Radmehr and his colleagues \[[@CR13]\] compared the combined antegrade and retrograde versus antegrade cardioplegia alone in patients undergoing CABG surgery and found that the use of combined antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia was associated with a 16.5% statistically significant decrease in inotropic requirement. Our retrospective study suggests that myocardial protection can be improved by combined antegrade and retrograde technique and, in contrast to literature already available, our patient cohort is divided into three groups (the combined technique of antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia, antegrade cardioplegia alone and cross-clamp fibrillation). We only included patients undergoing CABG surgery and excluded subjects undergoing either valve surgery alone or CABG combined with valve surgery. This enabled us to assess the drawbacks of the antegrade technique via blocked coronaries and therefore the potential benefit of retrograde cardioplegia. In addition to this, with an increase in the cross-clamp time the general understanding is that the myocardium is more prone to becoming ischaemic and damaged: our study suggests that despite longer cross-clamping times in the combined group, the total PMI was consistently lower in these patients when compared to the other two groups. This correlates with a retrospective study conducted by Bar-El et al. \[[@CR29]\] on patients undergoing CABG surgery with or without valve repair or replacement and receiving antegrade followed by retrograde cardioplegia, demonstrating that the expected mortality was lower in patients with longer aortic cross-clamping times compared to those with shorter aortic cross-clamping times, and therefore indicating that retrograde cardioplegia can enhance myocardial protection despite the longer cross-clamp times. We therefore suggest that the absolute value of the cross-clamp time may potentially be less important than the type of myocardial protection used: this could be crucial in complex patients with poor LV function or anticipated long cross-clamp times, for whom the best myocardial protection available would be warranted. Another important difference between groups 1 and 3 is the temperature employed during the cardioplegic techniques utilizing cold blood and warm blood cardioplegia respectively: the optimal temperature of cardioplegia during cardiac surgery is another crucial aspect of myocardial protection besides the actual technique used and it could be argued that the lower troponin rise in group 3 may be partially explained by the temperature difference. Cold cardioplegia is able to attenuate myocardial oxygen demand and the risk of ischaemic damage but conversely may lead to the inhibition of myocardial enzymes leading to a stunning of the metabolic and functional recovery following surgery. However warm blood cardioplegia is thought to counteract this potential deleterious effect. In a meta-analysis \[[@CR30]\] involving 8814 patients randomised to either warm cardioplegia or cold cardioplegia predominantly in the setting of CABG surgery, there was no significant difference in all-cause mortality or incidence of myocardial infarction, intra-aortic balloon pump usage, stroke, low output syndromes and post-operative AF between the two patients groups and postoperative cardiac index was significantly improved in the warm blood cardioplegia group. Similarly, Tan et al. \[[@CR31]\] compared cold to tepid cardioplegia and found no difference in mortality, peri-operative myocardial infarction, stroke or inotrope requirement. Our retrospective study has several limitations. The cohort population was small and in particular the group consisting of the combined use of retrograde cardioplegia and antegrade cardioplegia contained only 10 patients, who were operated on by one consultant, which may result in some potential bias. Typically in a study of this type strong prognostic and confounding variables would be adjusted for in the analysis. In this case the small sample size precluded detailed adjustment and we acknowledge some residual confounding bias may remain. Finally, we have not adjusted for multiplicity in our analysis and there is a possibility that the results may have arisen by chance, and therefore the clinical outcome data will need to be confirmed in future studies. In conclusion our retrospective clinical analysis suggests that the combined use of retrograde cardioplegia and antegrade cardioplegia during first time CABG surgery can be beneficial in reducing PMI. Also, importantly, to our knowledge there is no study which combines the following four factors together into one analysis on PMI: aortic cross-clamping times, combined antegrade retrograde versus antegrade alone versus no cardioplegia, hsTnT levels at 6 different time-points with AUC-hsTnT, and exclusively CABG patients. We do not suggest surgeons to change their practice for routine CABG surgery, as we have not yet demonstrated that the change in measured troponin levels may have a significant impact on clinical outcomes. However, we feel that this evidence should be available, so surgeons can choose to add retrograde cardioplegia for more complex cases in an evidence based fashion, knowing that the addition of retrograde cardioplegia may have the potential to enhance myocardial protection. Our retrospective study also suggests that larger studies are required in order to further evaluate our findings and to investigate whether the reduction of PMI in patients undergoing CABG would result in improvement of clinical outcomes. Conclusions {#Sec13} =========== Our study suggests that, compared to traditional methods of myocardial preservation, the combined use of retrograde and antegrade cardioplegia may have the potential to reduce PMI in patients undergoing first-time CABG surgery. Whether this can lead to an improvement of clinical outcomes is yet unknown and therefore larger studies are required in order to further evaluate this potential impact. Authors' original submitted files for images {#Sec14} ============================================ Below are the links to the authors' original submitted files for images.Authors' original file for figure 1Authors' original file for figure 2 CABG : Coronary artery bypass graft PMI : Peri-operative myocardial injury AUC : Area under the curve hsTnT : High-sensitivity Troponin-T AKI : Acute kidney injury ICU : Intensive care unit AF : Atrial fibrillation SD : Standard deviation CK : Creatine kinase CAD : Coronary artery disease RV : Right ventricle RIPC : Remote ischaemic preconditioning PAD : Peripheral arterial disease CPB : Cardiopulmonary bypass Luciano Candilio, Abdul Malik contributed equally to this work. **Competing interests** The authors declare that they have no competing interests. **Authors' contributions** LC and AM carried out the study, acquired, analysed and interpreted data. LC, AM. SAK, NR made substantial contributions in drafting the manuscript and/or revising it critically for important intellectual content. CA performed the statistical analysis. NR, MB, CDS, DRL, MPH, JAP, AMS, CGAM, SKK provided patients for the study. DJH, NR read and approved final manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript Maria Xenou for identification of patients for recruitment. All staff at the Heart Hospital, London.

People's perceptions of safety influence their risk taking. This phenomenon, studied under such rubrics as risk compensation ([@bibr3-0956797615620784]), risk homeostasis ([@bibr19-0956797615620784]), and risk allostasis ([@bibr11-0956797615620784]), is typified by people taking increased risks when using protective equipment ([@bibr1-0956797615620784]) or at least reducing their risk taking when protective equipment is absent ([@bibr7-0956797615620784]; [@bibr14-0956797615620784]). Behavioral adaptation in response to safety equipment has been reported in studies examining drivers operating a vehicle with and without built-in safety devices ([@bibr15-0956797615620784]), children running obstacle courses with and without safety gear ([@bibr13-0956797615620784]), and bicyclists descending a steep hill with and without helmets ([@bibr14-0956797615620784]). Work to date has been based on the assumption that people respond only to safety measures of which they are aware---an idea encapsulated in Hedlund's first rule of risk compensation: "If I don't know it's there, I won't compensate for a safety measure" ([@bibr8-0956797615620784], p. 87). Moreover, in research to date, the risk-taking behavior has been in the same domain as the safety measure (e.g., studies of seat-belt use in driving speed; [@bibr9-0956797615620784]). Here, we changed both these approaches. First, we induced people to wear a helmet without their necessarily being aware they were wearing safety equipment: Participants were (falsely) told they were taking part in an eye-tracking study so we could exploit the fact that the head-mounted eye-tracking device we employed comes with both a bicycle helmet and a baseball cap as its standard mounting solutions. At random, participants were assigned to wear one mount or the other and were simply told it was the anchor for the eye tracker. Second, we divorced risk-taking behavior from the safety device by using a computerized laboratory measure called the Balloon Analogue Risk Task (BART; [@bibr10-0956797615620784]), in which the helmet could do nothing to change risk. We also measured sensation seeking and anxiety as possible explanatory variables for any effect. Method {#section1-0956797615620784} ====== Participants {#section2-0956797615620784} ------------ Eighty participants (15 male and 24 female in the helmet condition, 19 male and 22 female in the cap condition) between the ages of 17 and 56 years (*M* = 25.26, *SD* = 6.59) took part in the study; no monetary reward was offered for participation. An a priori power analysis showed that 40 participants per condition should have 80% power to detect an effect size (Cohen's *d*) of 0.63. This was deemed sufficient, as we hoped to see relatively substantial effects of the helmet manipulation. Materials {#section3-0956797615620784} --------- State anxiety was measured using the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) Form Y-1 ([@bibr17-0956797615620784]). This form contains 40 questions, 20 that measure a person's feelings of anxiety right at the moment of response and 20 that measure his or her chronic levels of anxiety. Participants here answered the former set. In the BART ([@bibr10-0956797615620784]), which we programmed in Real Studio ([@bibr20-0956797615620784]), participants pressed a button to inflate an animated balloon on a computer screen. Each button press inflated the balloon more and increased the amount of fictional currency earned. If the balloon burst (which it would at a random point between 1 and 128 inflations), all earnings for that trial were lost. At any point, participants could choose to stop pumping and "bank" their accrued money. After the balloon burst, or after a decision to bank, the next trial began. Each participant completed 30 trials, and his or her risk-taking score was the mean number of pumps made on trials on which the balloon did not burst. This score would be higher when participants risked losses by trying to maximize their score and lower when participants avoided risk and played more conservatively. Sensation seeking was measured using the Sensation-Seeking Scale Form V ([@bibr21-0956797615620784]). This scale measures four dimensions (10 self-report items each) of sensation-seeking behavior: thrill and adventure seeking, disinhibition, experience seeking, and boredom susceptibility. Bicycling frequency was measured using a Likert scale ranging from 1 (*never*) to 6 (*five times a week or more*). If a person selected anything other than "never" on this instrument, helmet-wearing frequency was measured using a Likert scale ranging from 1 (*never*) to 6 (*always*). Either an Abus (Phoenix, AZ) HS-10 S-Force peak bicycle helmet or a Beechfield (Bury, United Kingdom) B15 five-panel baseball cap was used to support the SensoMotoric (Teltow, Germany) head-mounted iView X HED-4.5 eye-tracking device (with its delicate 45° mirror removed; see [Fig. 1](#fig1-0956797615620784){ref-type="fig"}). Participants responded to the scales using the Bristol Online Surveys Web site. All measures and the BART were completed on a 19-in. 4:3 LCD monitor. The experimenter "operated" an Applied Science Laboratories (Bedford, MA) Eye-Trac 6 desk-mounted optics system with Eye-Trac PC. A fake nine-point eye-tracking calibration program was written in Real Studio to increase the verisimilitude of the eye-tracking procedure. {#fig1-0956797615620784} Procedure {#section4-0956797615620784} --------- This study was conducted in the University of Bath Department of Psychology's eye-tracking laboratory. Participants were brought into the laboratory and told that they would complete a number of computer-based risk-taking measures while their point of gaze was measured using a head-mounted eye tracker. After reading information about the study on the computer screen and agreeing to participate, they entered their age and gender and completed the STAI Y-1. A screen then appeared saying that the eye tracker would now be set up; the experimenter placed the cap- or helmet-mounted eye tracker on the participant's head, making a show of carefully aligning everything as in a real eye-tracking procedure. The experimenter then moved to the eye-tracking computer, where he or she ran the fake calibration software and conspicuously adjusted the eye-tracking controls to make it appear to participants that their eye movements were really being tracked. Participants then completed the Sensation-Seeking Scale, the BART, and the STAI Y-1 again. Afterward, a screen appeared saying that the eye tracker was to be turned off, and the experimenter removed the apparatus from participants' heads. Participants then completed the final STAI Y-1 before being debriefed, at which point they were informed of the deception and asked not to share details of the experiment with anyone else. They then reported their bicycling frequency and, if they did cycle, their helmet-wearing frequency. Results {#section5-0956797615620784} ======= Wearing a helmet was associated with higher risk-taking scores (*M* = 40.40, *SD* = 18.18) than wearing a cap (*M* = 31.06, *SD* = 13.29), *t*(78) = 2.63, *p* = .01, *d* = 0.59 ([Fig. 2a](#fig2-0956797615620784){ref-type="fig"}). Similarly, participants who wore a helmet reported higher sensation-seeking scores (*M* = 23.23, *SD* = 7.00) than participants who wore a cap (*M* = 18.78, *SD* = 5.09), Welch's *t*(69.19) = 3.24, *p* = .002, *d* = 0.73 ([Fig. 2b](#fig2-0956797615620784){ref-type="fig"}). These effects cannot be explained by the helmet affecting anxiety, as anxiety did not change significantly as a function of condition, *F*(1, 78) = 0.19, *p* = .66, time of measurement, *F*(2, 156) = 2.37, *p* = .10, or an interaction between the two, *F*(2, 156) = 1.18, *p* = .31 ([Fig. 2c](#fig2-0956797615620784){ref-type="fig"}). Note that we used the square roots of the anxiety scores for analyses because of the skew seen in [Figure 2c](#fig2-0956797615620784){ref-type="fig"}. There was no relationship between risk taking and gender, *t*(78) = 0.45, *p* = .66, bicycling experience (ρ = .12, *p* = .27), and extent of helmet use when bicycling (ρ = .06, *p* = .60), nor, in regression modeling, interactions of any of these variables (e.g., the Condition × Bicycling Experience interaction was not significant; *t* = 0.39, *p* = .70). Prior research has shown that helmets do not affect cognitive performance in demanding laboratory tasks ([@bibr6-0956797615620784]), which means the results cannot be attributed to this factor either. {#fig2-0956797615620784} Discussion {#section6-0956797615620784} ========== Laboratory measures showed greater risk taking and sensation seeking when participants wore a helmet, rather than a baseball cap, during testing. These effects arose even though the helmet was introduced as a mount for an eye-tracking apparatus and not as safety equipment, and even though it could do nothing to alter participants' level of risk on the experimental task. Notably, the effect was an immediate shift in both risk taking and sensation seeking. This finding contrasts with those of previous work on unconscious influence, such as experiments on the persuasive effects of head movements ([@bibr18-0956797615620784]) and environmental cues on consumer behavior ([@bibr5-0956797615620784]), which looked instead at longer-term attitudinal changes from more overt signals. Our findings are plausibly related to social priming, wherein social behaviors are cued by exposure to stereotypes or concepts ([@bibr4-0956797615620784]). However, whereas social priming is generally understood in terms of behavior directed toward another person, the effects in this study were individual, focused on the risk-taking propensity of a person acting alone during exposure to a safety-related prime. [@bibr16-0956797615620784] produced computational models of social priming in which primes activate shared cultural concepts in people's minds, which in turn are associated with actions; through these links, the actions become available to the behavioral selection process. Speculatively, if what we saw in this study were to be understood through such mechanisms, with the helmet invoking concepts of protection from risk and thereby subconsciously shaping behaviors, our findings might suggest that Schröder and Thagard's social-priming framework operates even when its interaction target component (another person with whom to interact) is absent. Our findings initially appear different from those of some other studies. [@bibr7-0956797615620784]; [@bibr14-0956797615620784]) found that risk taking in downhill bicycling, measured through riding speed, did not simply increase when a helmet was worn; rather, the people who normally cycled with a helmet took fewer risks when riding without one. Why did the participants in Fyhri and Phillips's study who were not habitual helmet users not react to wearing a helmet with increased risk taking, as our experiment might suggest they would? Clearly more work is needed to definitively pin down all the mechanisms here, but for now, we speculate that the difference might be related to considerable variations between the two studies' procedures. Fyhri and Phillips greatly emphasized the physicality of their task ("to increase the difference in measures between the helmet-on and -off conditions, all participants were instructed to cycle using one-hand in both conditions"; p. 60), which provides a direct link between the action (bicycling) and the condition (helmet wearing) that was absent in our study. Moreover, that study used a repeated measures design, in which participants were aware they were riding a bicycle both with and without a helmet. This could have meant that behavior changed through mechanisms different from those seen here, where participants took part only in one condition and were not aware of any manipulation, nor even that they were specifically wearing a safety device. The practical implication of our findings, in which risk taking changed in a global way when the helmet was worn, might be to suggest more extreme unintended consequences of safety equipment in hazardous situations than has previously been thought. The idea that people might take more risks when wearing safety equipment designed to protect against those risks has a considerable ([@bibr1-0956797615620784], [@bibr2-0956797615620784]; [@bibr3-0956797615620784]; [@bibr8-0956797615620784]), although not uncontroversial ([@bibr12-0956797615620784]), history. If this laboratory demonstration of globally increased risk taking arising from localized protection were to be replicated in real settings, this could suggest that people using protective equipment against specific hazards might also be unduly inclined to take risks that such protective equipment cannot reasonably be expected to guard against. This is not to suggest that the safety equipment will necessarily have its specific utility nullified, but rather that there could be changes in behavior wider than previously envisaged. Supplementary Material ====================== ###### Supplementary material The authors thank A. Laketa and R. Posner for their work in recruiting and testing participants. **Declaration of Conflicting Interests:** The authors declared that they had no conflicts of interest with respect to their authorship or the publication of this article. **Open Practices:**  All data have been made publicly available via Open Science Framework and can be accessed at <https://osf.io/eky4s/>. The complete Open Practices Disclosure for this article can be found at <http://pss.sagepub.com/content/by/supplemental-data>. This article has received a badge for Open Data. More information about the Open Practices badges can be found at <https://osf.io/tvyxz/wiki/1.%20View%20the%20Badges/> and <http://pss.sagepub.com/content/25/1/3.full>. [^1]: **Author Contributions:** T. Gamble and I. Walker developed and designed the study, analyzed and interpreted the data, and drafted the manuscript.

Correction to: *Scientific Reports* 10.1038/s41598-019-39748-4, published online 07 March 2019 The original version of this Article contained a repeated typographical error in the Abstract and Introduction where, "*Aedes aegpyti*" now reads: "*Aedes aegypti*" This error has now been corrected in the PDF and HTML versions of the Article.

\section{Summary}\label{summary}} Gravitational waves in the sensitivity band of ground-based detectors can be emitted by a number of astrophysical sources, including not only binary coalescences, but also individual spinning neutron stars. The most promising signals from such sources, although as of 2020 not yet detected, are the long-lasting, quasi-monochromatic `Continuous Waves' (CWs). Many search methods have been developed and applied on LIGO (Aasi et al. 2015) and Virgo (Acernese et al. 2015) data. See Prix (2009), Riles (2017), and Sieniawska and Bejger (2019) for reviews of the field. The \texttt{PyFstat} package provides tools to perform a range of CW data analysis tasks. It revolves around the \(\mathcal{F}\)-statistic, first introduced by Jaranowski, Krolak, and Schutz (1998): a matched-filter detection statistic for CW signals described by a set of frequency evolution parameters and maximized over amplitude parameters. This has been one of the standard methods for LIGO-Virgo CW searches for two decades. \texttt{PyFstat} is built on top of established routines in \texttt{LALSuite} (LIGO Scientific Collaboration 2018) but through its more modern \texttt{Python} interface it enables a flexible approach to designing new search strategies. Classes for various search strategies and target signals are contained in three main submodules: \begin{itemize} \tightlist \item \texttt{core}: The basic wrappers to \texttt{LALSuite}'s \(\mathcal{F}\)-statistic algorithm. End-users should rarely need to access these directly. \item \texttt{grid\_based\_searches}: Classes to search over regular parameter-space grids. \item \texttt{mcmc\_based\_searches}: Classes to cover promising parameter-space regions through stochastic template placement with the Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampler \texttt{ptemcee} (Vousden, Farr, and Mandel 2015). \end{itemize} Besides standard CWs from isolated neutron stars, \texttt{PyFstat} can also be used to search for CWs from sources in binary systems (including the additional orbital parameters), for CWs with a discontinuity at a pulsar glitch, and for CW-like long-duration transient signals, e.g., from \emph{after} a pulsar glitch. Specialized versions of both grid-based and MCMC-based search classes are provided for these scenarios. Both fully-coherent and semi-coherent searches (where the data is split into several segments for efficiency) are covered, and an extension to the \(\mathcal{F}\)-statistic that is more robust against single-detector noise artifacts (Keitel et al. 2014) is also supported. While \texttt{PyFstat}'s grid-based searches do not compete with the sophisticated grid setups and semi-coherent algorithms implemented in various \texttt{LALSuite} programs, its main scientific use cases so far are for the MCMC exploration of interesting parameter-space regions and for the long-duration transient case. \texttt{PyFstat} was first introduced in Ashton and Prix (2018), which remains the main reference for the MCMC-based analysis implemented in the package. The extension to transient signals, which uses \texttt{PyCUDA} (Klöckner et al. 2012) for speedup, is discussed in detail in Keitel and Ashton (2018), and the glitch-robust search approaches in Ashton, Prix, and Jones (2018). Additional helper classes, utility functions, and internals are included for handling the common Short Fourier Transform (SFT) data format for LIGO data, simulating artificial data with noise and signals in them, and plotting results and diagnostics. Most of the underlying \texttt{LALSuite} functionality is accessed through SWIG wrappings (Wette 2020) though for some parts, such as the SFT handling, we still (as of the writing of this paper) call stand-alone \texttt{lalapps} executables. Completing the backend migration to pure SWIG usage is planned for the future. The source of \texttt{PyFstat} is hosted on \href{https://github.com/PyFstat/PyFstat/}{GitHub}. The repository also contains an automated test suite and a set of introductory example scripts. Issues with the software can be submitted through GitHub and pull requests are always welcome. \texttt{PyFstat} can be installed through pip, conda or docker containers. Documentation in html and pdf formats is available from \href{https://readthedocs.org/projects/pyfstat/}{readthedocs.org} and installation instructions can be found there or in the \href{https://github.com/PyFstat/PyFstat/blob/master/README.md}{README} file. PyFstat is also listed in the Astrophysics Source Code Library as \href{https://ascl.net/2102.027}{ascl:2102.027}. \hypertarget{statement-of-need}{% \section{Statement of need}\label{statement-of-need}} The sensitivity of searches for CWs and long-duration transient GWs is generally limited by computational resources, as the required number of matched-filter templates increases steeply for long observation times and wide parameter spaces. The C-based \texttt{LALSuite} library (LIGO Scientific Collaboration 2018) contains many sophisticated search methods with a long development history and high level of optimization, but is not very accessible for researchers new to the field or for students; nor is it convenient for rapid development and integration with modern technologies like GPUs or machine learning. Hence, \texttt{PyFstat} serves a dual function of (i) making \texttt{LALSuite} CW functionality more easily accessible through a \texttt{Python} interface, thus facilitating the new user experience and, for developers, the exploratory implementation of novel methods; and (ii) providing a set of production-ready search classes for use cases not yet covered by \texttt{LALSuite} itself, most notably for MCMC-based followup of promising candidates from wide-parameter-space searches. So far, \texttt{PyFstat} has been used for \begin{itemize} \tightlist \item the original proposal of MCMC followup for CW candidates (Ashton and Prix 2018); \item developing glitch-robust CW search methods (Ashton, Prix, and Jones 2018); \item speeding up long-transient searches with GPUs (Keitel and Ashton 2018); \item followup of candidates from all-sky searches for CWs from sources in binary systems, see Covas and Sintes (2020) and Abbott et al. (2021); \item studying the impact of neutron star proper motions on CW searches (Covas 2020). \end{itemize} \hypertarget{acknowledgements}{% \section{Acknowledgements}\label{acknowledgements}} We acknowledge contributions to the package from Karl Wette, Sylvia Zhu and Dan Foreman-Mackey; as well as helpful suggestions by John T. Whelan, Luca Rei, and the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Continuous Wave working group. D.K. and R.T. are supported by European Union FEDER funds; the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades and Agencia Estatal de Investigación grants PID2019-106416GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, RED2018-102661-T, RED2018-102573-E, FPA2017-90687-REDC, FPU 18/00694, and BEAGAL 18/00148 (cofinanced by the Universitat de les Illes Balears); the Comunitat Autonoma de les Illes Balears through the Direcció General de Política Universitaria i Recerca with funds from the Tourist Stay Tax Law ITS 2017-006 (PRD2018/24) and the Conselleria de Fons Europeus, Universitat i Cultura; the Generalitat Valenciana (PROMETEO/2019/071); and EU COST Actions CA18108, CA17137, CA16214, and CA16104. This paper has been assigned document number LIGO-P2100008. \hypertarget{references}{% \section*{References}\label{references}} \addcontentsline{toc}{section}{References} \hypertarget{refs}{} \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-TheLIGOScientific:2014jea}{}% Aasi, J., B. P. Abbott, R. Abbott, and others. 2015. ``Advanced LIGO.'' \emph{Class. Quant. Grav.} 32: 074001. \url{https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/32/7/074001}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Abbott:2020mev}{}% Abbott, R., T. D. Abbott, S. Abraham, and others. 2021. ``All-sky search in early O3 LIGO data for continuous gravitational-wave signals from unknown neutron stars in binary systems.'' \emph{Phys. Rev. D} 103 (6): 064017. \url{https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.103.064017}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-TheVirgo:2014hva}{}% Acernese, F., M. Agathos, K. Agatsuma, and others. 2015. ``Advanced Virgo: a second-generation interferometric gravitational wave detector.'' \emph{Class. Quant. Grav.} 32 (2): 024001. \url{https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/32/2/024001}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Ashton:2018ure}{}% Ashton, Gregory, and Reinhard Prix. 2018. ``Hierarchical multistage MCMC follow-up of continuous gravitational wave candidates.'' \emph{Phys. Rev. D} 97 (10): 103020. \url{https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.97.103020}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Ashton:2018qth}{}% Ashton, Gregory, Reinhard Prix, and D.I. Jones. 2018. ``A semicoherent glitch-robust continuous-gravitational-wave search method.'' \emph{Phys. Rev. D} 98 (6): 063011. \url{https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.98.063011}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Covas:2020hcy}{}% Covas, P. B. 2020. ``Effects of proper motion of neutron stars on continuous gravitational-wave searches.'' \emph{Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc.} 500 (4): 5167--76. \url{https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa3624}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Covas:2020nwy}{}% Covas, P. B., and Alicia M. Sintes. 2020. ``First all-sky search for continuous gravitational-wave signals from unknown neutron stars in binary systems using Advanced LIGO data.'' \emph{Phys. Rev. Lett.} 124 (19): 191102. \url{https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.124.191102}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Jaranowski:1998qm}{}% Jaranowski, Piotr, Andrzej Krolak, and Bernard F. Schutz. 1998. ``Data analysis of gravitational - wave signals from spinning neutron stars. 1. The Signal and its detection.'' \emph{Phys. Rev. D} 58: 063001. \url{https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.58.063001}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Keitel:2018pxz}{}% Keitel, David, and Gregory Ashton. 2018. ``Faster search for long gravitational-wave transients: GPU implementation of the transient \(\mathcal F\)-statistic.'' \emph{Class. Quant. Grav.} 35 (20): 205003. \url{https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6382/aade34}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Keitel:2013wga}{}% Keitel, David, Reinhard Prix, Maria Alessandra Papa, Paola Leaci, and Maham Siddiqi. 2014. ``Search for continuous gravitational waves: Improving robustness versus instrumental artifacts.'' \emph{Phys. Rev. D} 89 (6): 064023. \url{https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.89.064023}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Kloeckner:2012pyc}{}% Klöckner, Andreas, Nicolas Pinto, Yunsup Lee, B. Catanzaro, Paul Ivanov, and Ahmed Fasih. 2012. ``PyCUDA and PyOpenCL: A Scripting-Based Approach to GPU Run-Time Code Generation.'' \emph{Parallel Computing} 38 (3): 157--74. \url{https://doi.org/10.1016/j.parco.2011.09.001}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-lalsuite}{}% LIGO Scientific Collaboration. 2018. ``LIGO Algorithm Library - LALSuite.'' free software (GPL). \url{https://doi.org/10.7935/GT1W-FZ16}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Prix:2009oha}{}% Prix, Reinhard. 2009. ``Gravitational Waves from Spinning Neutron Stars.'' In \emph{Neutron Stars and Pulsars}, edited by Werner Becker, 357:651--85. Astrophys. Space Sci. Lib. Berlin Heidelberg: Springer. \url{https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-76965-1_24}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Riles:2017evm}{}% Riles, Keith. 2017. ``Recent searches for continuous gravitational waves.'' \emph{Mod. Phys. Lett. A} 32 (39): 1730035. \url{https://doi.org/10.1142/S021773231730035X}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Sieniawska:2019hmd}{}% Sieniawska, Magdalena, and Michał Bejger. 2019. ``Continuous gravitational waves from neutron stars: current status and prospects.'' \emph{Universe} 5 (11): 217. \url{https://doi.org/10.3390/universe5110217}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Vousden:2015pte}{}% Vousden, W. D., W. M. Farr, and I. Mandel. 2015. ``Dynamic temperature selection for parallel tempering in Markov chain Monte Carlo simulations.'' \emph{Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc.} 455 (2): 1919--37. \url{https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stv2422}. \leavevmode\hypertarget{ref-Wette:2020air}{}% Wette, Karl. 2020. ``SWIGLAL: Python and Octave interfaces to the LALSuite gravitational-wave data analysis libraries.'' \emph{SoftwareX} 12: 100634. \url{https://doi.org/10.1016/j.softx.2020.100634}. \end{document}

Introduction ============ The most common etiologic agents of neonatal mastitis are *Staphylococcus aureus* and, less commonly, group B Streptococcus, group A Streptococcus, *Escherichia coli*, *Bacteroides* species, *Klebsiella pneumoniae*, and *Enterococcus*\[[@B1],[@B2]\]. A recent chart review determined the prevalence of infecting organisms in 130 patients from breast abscess cultures as follows: methicillin-resistant *S. aureus* (38%), methicillin-susceptible *S. aureus* (35%), coagulase-negative *Staphylococcus* (15%), group B Streptococcus (4%) and *Enterobacter aerogenes* (2%) \[[@B3]\]. Empiric antibiotic coverage for *S. aureus*, tailored for either methicillin-resistant or methicillin-sensitive strains based on the local community prevalence, should be initiated upon diagnosis of mastitis \[[@B3]\]. We present to the best of our knowledge the first case describing *Acinetobacter baumannii* as an etiologic agent of mastitis. Case presentation ================= A 15-day-old full-term Caucasian infant presented to our emergency room with fever (maximum rectal temperature of 38.7°C/101.7°F), decreased urine output, decreased feeding, lethargy and irritability for 1 day. He was born vaginally at 41 weeks and 6 days with no complications. On physical examination, his rectal temperature was 37.6°C and he appeared well. His umbilical stump was not erythematous and had no purulent drainage. He had no rashes or vesicles. His laboratory examination in our emergency department demonstrated an elevated white blood cell count of 15,500, with 76% neutrophils and 13% lymphocytes on the differential. A urine analysis and chest X-ray were reassuring. Blood and urine cultures were obtained. A lumbar puncture was attempted twice, but was unsuccessful. He was admitted to our general pediatrics service on no antibiotics, but with the plan to obtain cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) with another lumbar puncture and initiate antibiotics if he became febrile. Within a few hours of admission, he developed right breast induration, erythema around his nipple (4cm diameter), and purulent drainage. The wound drainage was cultured. He was empirically treated with clindamycin and cefotaxime, with coverage for methicillin-resistant *S. aureus*, which is prevalent in the area. His right nipple continued to drain 2 to 3mL of purulent material over the next 24 hours. Because he remained afebrile, was otherwise healthy appearing, and had a source of infection to explain the presenting fever, no lumbar puncture was performed. His blood and urine cultures were negative after 5 days. The right breast drainage, erythema and induration improved significantly within 24 to 36 hours, and completely resolved by day 4 of admission. His right breast wound culture initially revealed Gram-negative rods on Gram stain, and ultimately grew *Acinetobacter baumannii/haemolyticus*. His isolate was susceptible to all the antibiotics tested, including amikacin, cefepime, ceftazidime, ciprofloxacin, gentamicin, levofloxacin, meropenem and tobramycin. Our pediatric infectious diseases consultant recommended 5 days of treatment with intravenous ceftazidime for mastitis secondary to *Acinetobacter baumannii/haemolyticus* infection. He tolerated this antibiotic regimen with no appreciated adverse effects and continued to breastfeed well during his admission. At discharge, he showed no clinical signs of mastitis, and was not prescribed any oral antibiotics. Conclusions =========== No cases of neonatal mastitis secondary to *Acinetobacter* species infections have been previously documented, so this finding was unexpected. *A. baumannii* is an aerobic, Gram-negative coccobacillus that is considered part of the normal human flora of the skin and mucous membranes of the pharynx, human respiratory secretions, urine and rectum \[[@B4]\]. Of interest, *Acinetobacter* species are the only Gram-negative bacteria that are considered part of the normal flora on human skin, and up to 42.5% of healthy individuals are colonized with *Acinetobacter* species \[[@B4]\]. They also colonize animals, including farm animals, birds, fish, chickens and cats \[[@B4]\]. These bacteria survive on inanimate objects, in dry conditions, in dust, and in moist conditions for several days \[[@B4]\]. The definitive source of *Acinetobacter* species infection in this case of a previously healthy full-term neonate remains unknown, although possible sources include the local environment or contact through the patient's father's employment in a veterinary office. *Acinetobacter* species are most commonly associated with opportunistic infections in war veterans, serious nosocomial infections in intensive care units, and increased resistance to multiple classes of antibiotics. In the pediatric population, most (89%) *Acinetobacter* outbreaks occur in neonatal intensive care units, and bacteremia and meningitis are the most common clinical presentations of infection \[[@B5]\]. However, invasive *Acinetobacter* infections from community settings can also occur, although mainly in warm humid climates \[[@B5]\]. In a case series of Kenyan infants admitted from the community, 10.1% of all positive blood cultures grew *Acinetobacter* species \[[@B6]\]. Skin abscesses in pediatric patients due to *Acinetobacter* have been reported in only two case reports. One described an abscess in the antecubital fossa at the site of a previous intravenous cannula in a neonate born at 26 weeks who previously grew *A. baumannii* from endotracheal tube secretions. This infant appeared well during the initial presentation of the abscess; however, almost 1 week after abscess development, the neonate developed sepsis and blood cultures grew *A. baumannii* and *Enterococcus*. He recovered with antibiotic treatment with amoxicillin-clavulanate and gentamicin \[[@B7]\]. A second case of a superficial abscess that grew *Acinetobacter* was also described in a 24-day-old female infant admitted for birth asphyxia at 2 days of life who subsequently developed an abscess at the site of intravenous scalp vein cannulation. Wound cultures from the abscess grew *Acinetobacter calcoaceticus* var. *anitratus*. This infant developed meningitis and CSF cultures grew the same organisms with the same susceptibilities. She recovered with antibiotic treatment with trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole \[[@B8]\]. Our patient had negative blood and urine cultures, but we were initially unable to obtain CSF, so no CSF culture was performed. Whether all well-appearing infants with mastitis should receive a lumbar puncture as part of a complete sepsis evaluation is debatable \[[@B3],[@B9],[@B10]\]. Multiple chart reviews have found no positive concordant cultures from urine, blood, or CSF in infants with positive breast cultures, suggesting that there is a low risk for bacteremia in otherwise well-appearing infants with mastitis \[[@B2],[@B3],[@B9]\]. However, lumbar puncture should still be considered for febrile infants \<2-months old because of the risk of serious bacterial infection \[[@B3]\]. In conclusion, although most breast abscesses are caused by *S. aureus* and empiric antibiotic coverage should include this organism, less common infections also need to be considered. This case highlights the importance of obtaining cultures from breast abscesses because of the possibility of an uncommon infecting organism and provides a brief introduction to *Acinetobacter* species infections in the pediatric population. Consent ======= Written informed consent was obtained from the patient's parent for publication of this case report. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor-in-Chief of this journal. Abbreviations ============= CSF: Cerebrospinal fluid. Competing interests =================== The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Authors' contributions ====================== EM, AB, JZ and PS participated in conception and design of this report and were involved in drafting and revising the manuscript. EM participated in final revisions of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Acknowledgements ================ We would like to thank Dr Joseph Hilinski for critical review of the manuscript.

Introduction {#s1} ============ The function of complex networks such as the human brain requires a trade-off between functional specialization and global communication ([@bib18]; [@bib45]; [@bib68]). Contemporary models of brain function suggest that this balance is manifest through dynamically changing patterns of correlated activity, constrained by the brains' structural backbone ([@bib15]; [@bib33]; [@bib70]). This in turn allows exploration of a repertoire of cortical states that balance the opposing topological properties of segregation (i.e. modular architectures with high functional specialization) and integration (i.e. inter-connection between specialist regions \[[@bib19]; [@bib28]\]). Recent work has demonstrated that the extent of integration in the brain is important for a range of cognitive functions, including effective task performance ([@bib4]; [@bib57]), episodic memory retrieval ([@bib72]) and conscious awareness ([@bib3]; [@bib29]). Furthermore, the topological properties of functional brain networks have been shown to fluctuate over time ([@bib9]; [@bib35]), both within individual neuroimaging sessions ([@bib57]; [@bib74]) and over the course of weeks to months ([@bib59]). While the extent of integration in the brain may relate to more effective inter-regional communication, perhaps via synchronous oscillatory activity ([@bib26]; [@bib42]; [@bib70]), there are also benefits related to a relatively segregated network architecture, including lower metabolic costs ([@bib8]; [@bib74]) and effective performance as a function of learning ([@bib4]). However, despite these insights, the biological mechanisms responsible for driving fluctuations between integration and segregation remain unclear. A candidate mechanism underlying flexible brain network dynamics is the global alteration in neural gain mediated by ascending neuromodulatory nuclei such as the locus coeruleus ([@bib2]; [@bib55]). This small pontine nucleus projects diffusely throughout the brain and releases noradrenaline, a potent modulatory neurotransmitter that alters the precision and responsivity of targeted neurons ([@bib71]). Alterations in this system are known to play a crucial role in cognition, as there is evidence for a nonlinear (inverted-U shaped) relationship between noradrenaline concentration and cognitive performance ([@bib48]; [Figure 1a](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). {#fig1} Mechanistically, the noradrenergic system has been shown to alter neural gain ([@bib56]) [Figure 1b](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}), increasing the signal to noise ratio of afferent input onto regions targeted by projections from the locus coeruleus. A crucial question is how these local changes in neural gain influence the configuration of the brain at the network level. Recent work has linked fluctuations in network topology to changes in pupil diameter ([@bib20]; [@bib57]; [@bib61]), an indirect measure of locus coeruleus activity ([@bib39]; [@bib44]; [@bib46], [@bib47]), providing evidence for a link between the noradrenergic system and network-level topology. However, despite these insights, the mechanisms through which alterations in neural gain mediate fluctuations in global network topology are poorly understood. Biophysical models of large-scale neuronal activity have yielded numerous insights into the dynamics of brain function, both during the resting state as well as in the context of task-driven brain function ([@bib14]; [@bib33]); for review, see [@bib7]. Whereas prior research in this area has examined the influence of local dynamics, coupling strength, structural network topology and stochastic fluctuations on functional network topology ([@bib19]; [@bib16]; [@bib17]; [@bib30]; [@bib73]), the direct influence of neural gain has not been studied. Here, we used a combination of biophysical modeling and graph theoretical analyses ([@bib64]) to characterize the effect of neural gain on emergent network topology. Based on previous work ([@bib57]; [@bib61]), we hypothesized that manipulations of neural gain would modulate the extent of integration in time-averaged patterns of functional connectivity. Results {#s2} ======= To test this hypothesis, we implemented a generic 2-dimensional neuronal oscillator model ([@bib22]; [@bib66]) within the Virtual Brain toolbox ([@bib38]; [@bib54]) to generate regional time series that were constrained by a directed white matter connectome derived from the CoCoMac database ([@bib41]) [Figure 1d](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). The simulated neuronal time series were passed through a Balloon-Windkessel model to simulate realistic BOLD data. Graph theoretical analyses were then applied to time-averaged correlations of regional BOLD data to estimate the functional topological signatures of network fluctuations (see Materials and methods for further details). To simulate the effect of ascending neuromodulatory effects on inter-regional dynamics, we systematically manipulated neural gain (σ; [Figure 1b](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}) and excitability (γ; [Figure 1c](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). These two parameters alter different aspects of a sigmoidal transfer function, which models the nonlinear relationship between presynaptic afferent inputs and local firing rates ([@bib24]). When the σ and γ parameters are both low, fluctuations in regional activity arise mainly due to noise and local feedback. As the σ and γ parameters increase, the influence of activity communicated from connected input regions also increases, leading to non-linear cross-talk and hence, changes in global brain topology and dynamics. Here, we investigated the topological signature of simulated BOLD time series across a parameter space spanned by σ and γ in order to understand the combined effect of neural gain and excitability on global brain network dynamics. Neural gain and excitability modulate network-level topological integration {#s2-1} --------------------------------------------------------------------------- We simulated BOLD time series data across a range of σ (0--1) and γ (0--1) and then subjected the time series from our simulation to graph theoretical analyses ([@bib51]). This allowed us to estimate the amount of integration in the time-averaged functional connectivity matrix across the parameter space ([Figure 2a](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Specifically, we used the mean participation coefficient (B*~A~*) of the time-averaged connectivity matrix at each combination of σ and γ. High values of mean B*~A~* suggest a relative increase in inter-modular connectivity, thus promoting the diversity of connections between modules ([@bib5]) and increasing the integrative signature of the network ([@bib57]). The converse situation (i.e., segregation) can thus be indexed by low mean B*~A~* scores, or alternatively by the modularity statistic, *Q*. We observed a complex relationship between σ, γ and B*~A~*, such that maximal integration occurred at high levels of σ but with intermediate values of γ. Outside of this zone, the time-averaged connectome was markedly less integrated. Similar patterns were observed for other topological measures of integration, such as the inverse modularity (Q^−1^) and global efficiency ([Figure 2---figure supplement 1](#fig2s1){ref-type="fig"}). {#fig2} Neural gain transitions the network across a critical boundary {#s2-2} -------------------------------------------------------------- The relative simplicity of our local neural model allows formal quantification of the inter-regional phase relationships that characterize the underlying neuronal dynamics. These fast neuronal phase dynamics compliment the view given by the slow BOLD amplitude fluctuations and give insight into their fundamental dynamic causes. We employed a phase order parameter, that quantifies the extent to which regions within the network align their oscillatory phase -- high values on this scale reflect highly ordered synchronous oscillations across the network, whereas low values reflect a relatively asynchronous system ([@bib6]; [@bib40]). Across the parameter space, we observed two clear states ([Figure 2b](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}): one associated with high (ρ ≥0.5; yellow) and one with low (ρ \<0.5; blue) mean synchrony, with a clear critical boundary demarcating the two states (dotted white line in [Figure 2a/b](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}) that was associated with a relative increase in the standard deviation of the order parameter ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2a](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"}). This strong demarcation between states is a known signature of critical behavior ([@bib10]), which can occur at both the regional and network level. We observed evidence for both regional and network criticality in our simulation, whereby small changes in parameters (here, σ and γ) facilitated an abrupt transition between qualitatively distinct states. At the regional level, this pattern is observed as a transition from input-driven fluctuations about a stable equilibrium to self-sustained oscillations ([Figure 2---figure supplement 3](#fig2s3){ref-type="fig"}). At the network level, the combined influence of increased gain and structural connections manifest as a transition to high amplitude, inter-regional phase synchrony ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2b](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"}). To further disambiguate the system-level dynamics, we studied the probability distribution of the fluctuations in the order parameter. Close to the boundary, we observed a truncated Pareto (i.e., power law) scaling regime, spanning up to two orders of magnitude ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2b](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"}). This pattern is consistent with a critical bifurcation within a complex system consisting of many components (see [@bib11] and [@bib32]Heitman and Breakspear, 2017 for further discussion). After crossing the boundary, this relationship develops a 'knee' above the power-law scaling ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2b](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"}), consistent with the emergence of a characteristic temporal scale in a super-critical system ([@bib49]). These observations suggest that the system undergoes a bifurcation across a critical boundary as the synchronization manifold loses stability. A host of contemporary neuroscientific theories hypothesize that temporal phase synchrony between regions underlies effective communication between neural regions ([@bib26]; [@bib42]; [@bib70]), which would otherwise remain isolated if not brought into temporal lockstep with one another. As such, we might expect that the changes in neural gain that integrate the brain might do so through the modulation of inter-regional phase synchrony. Our results were consistent with this hypothesis. By aligning changes in the topological signature of the network to the critical point delineating the two states, we were able to demonstrate a significant increase in integration (mean B*~A~*; T~798~ = 2.57; p=0.01) and decrease in segregation (Q; T~798~ = −17.44; p\<0.001) of network-level BOLD fluctuations in the highly phase synchronous state. Specifically, global integration demonstrated a sharp increase in the zone associated with the high amplitude synchronous oscillations, particularly for intermediate values of γ ([Figure 2c](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In contrast, the transitions associated with manipulating γ (particularly at high values of σ) led to an inverse U-shaped relationship: the network was relatively segregated at high and low levels of γ, but integrated at intermediate values of γ, albeit with a monotonic relationship when increasing σ for low levels of γ ([Figure 2d](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). In addition, increases in between-hemisphere connectivity were more pronounced than within-hemisphere connectivity in the ordered state (within: 0.010 ± 0.017; between: 0.014 ± 0.013; T~2,848~ = 7.104; p=10^−12^; see [Figure 2---figure supplement 4](#fig2s4){ref-type="fig"}). Together, these results suggest that neural gain and excitability act together to traverse a transition in network dynamics, maximizing inter-regional phase synchrony and integrating the functional connectome. Neural gain increases topological complexity and temporal variability {#s2-3} --------------------------------------------------------------------- Having identified a relationship between neural gain and network architecture, we next investigated the putative topological benefit of this trade-off. A measure that characterizes the topological balance between integration and segregation is communicability ([@bib21]), which quantifies the number of short paths that can be traversed between two regions of a network ([@bib43]). In networks with high communicability, individual regions are able to interact with a large proportion of the network through relatively short paths, which in turn may facilitate effective communication between otherwise segregated regions. In contrast to the relationship observed between neural gain and network integration, communicability was maximal at the critical boundaries between synchronous and asynchronous behavior ([Figure 3a--c](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). Thus, the topological signature of the network was most effectively balanced between integration and segregation as the system transitioned between disorder and order through the modulation of inter-regional synchrony by subtle changes in neural gain. {#fig3} Another important signature of complex systems is their flexibility over time. In previous work, we showed that the 'resting state' is characterized by significant fluctuations in network topology, in which the brain traverses between states that maximize either integration or segregation ([@bib57]). This variability was diminished during a cognitively challenging task, and the extent of integration was positively associated with improved task performance ([@bib57]). To determine whether these alterations in topological variability may have been related to changes in neural gain, we estimated the time-resolved mean participation coefficient (B*~T~*) of the simulated BOLD time series and then determined whether the variability of this measure over time changed as a function of σ and γ. We found that the variability of time-resolved integration within each trial was maximized across the critical boundary, as the network switched between disordered and ordered phase synchrony ([Figure 3d--f](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). These results support the hypothesis that changes in neural gain may control the temporal variability of network topology as a function of behavioral state. Gain-mediated integration is maximal in frontoparietal hub regions {#s2-4} ------------------------------------------------------------------ To determine whether the influence of neural gain on network dynamics was related to the underlying structural connectivity of the brain, we estimated the 'rich club' architecture of the structural connectome ([Figure 4a](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). Compared to low-degree nodes, rich club regions demonstrated an increase in 'realized' mean gain adjacent to the critical boundary ([Figure 4b](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). In short, this means that activity within frontoparietal 'hub' regions (red in [Figure 4a](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}) was more strongly affected by the interaction between neural gain and network topology than in non-hub regions (blue/green in [Figure 4a](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). Indeed, this result demonstrates that the 'realized' gain of individual regions is not simply related to the applied gain (i.e. input from the ascending noradrenergic system; ([@bib2]), but also non-linearly depends on afferent activity from topologically connected regions ([Figure 4c/d](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). The observed effect was particularly evident for intermediate values of γ, suggesting that the hub regions were differentially impacted by neural gain at the critical boundary between the asynchronous and synchronous states. Interestingly, similar dissociations were observed when comparing regions with high and low diversity ([Figure 4---figure supplement 1](#fig4s1){ref-type="fig"}), suggesting a role for future experiments to disambiguate the importance of degree and diversity in the mediation of global network topology ([@bib5]). However, given the substantial overlap between regions in the 'rich' and diverse' clubs (73% of regions were found in both groups), our results confirm a crucial role for frontoparietal regions in the control of network-level integration as a function of ascending neuromodulatory gain. {#fig4} Discussion {#s3} ========== We used a combination of computational modeling and graph theoretical analyses, quantifying the relationship between ascending neuromodulation and network-level integration in order to test a direct prediction from a previous neuroimaging study ([@bib57]). We found that increasing neural gain transitioned network dynamics across a bifurcation from disordered to ordered phase synchrony ([Figure 2b](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}) with a shift from a segregated to integrated neural architecture ([Figure 2e](#fig2){ref-type="fig"} and [Figure 2---figure supplement 1](#fig2s1){ref-type="fig"}). The critical boundary between these two states was associated with maximal communicability and temporal topological variability ([Figure 3](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}). Finally, the effect of neural gain was felt most prominently in high-degree frontoparietal network hubs ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"} and [Figure 4---figure supplement 2](#fig4s2){ref-type="fig"}). Together, these results confirm our prior hypothesis and complement an emerging view of the brain that highlights a mechanistic bridge between ascending arousal systems and cognition ([@bib57]), providing a potential mechanistic explanation for the long-standing notion that noradrenergic activity demonstrates an inverted U-shaped curve with cognitive performance ([@bib48], [Figure 1a](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). The major result from our study is that network-level fluctuations between segregation and integration in functional (BOLD) networks reflect an underlying transition in synchrony of faster neuronal oscillations, thus providing a previously unknown link between temporal scales in the brain ([Figure 2b](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). At low levels of γ and σ, the governing equations are strongly stable (damped), so that all excursions from equilibrium must be driven by local noise -- that is, regions are relatively insensitive to incoming inputs ([Figure 1b/c](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). As γ and σ increase, local activity approaches an instability, and consequently incoming activity is able to substantially influence activity in target regions. This causes changes in the emergent whole-brain dynamics evident at both the short time scale of brain oscillations and the long time scale of BOLD correlation. A stark transition occurs at a critical point in the parameter space (denoted by the boundary between blue and yellow in [Figure 2b](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}), whereby small increases in σ lead to substantial alterations in the phase relationships between regions. Specifically, the network abruptly shifts from stable equilibrium to high-amplitude synchronized oscillation, facilitating an increase in effective communication between otherwise topologically distant regions ([@bib25]; [@bib70]). This same transition point is associated with a peak in informational complexity ([Figure 3](#fig3){ref-type="fig"}), further suggesting the importance of criticality in maximizing the information processing capacity of global network topology. Notably, the transition is also accompanied by a peak in the topological variability over time: hence a dynamic instability amongst fast neuronal oscillations yields increased network fluctuations at very slow time scales, again highlighting the crucial role of criticality to multi-scale neural phenomena ([@bib11]). The effect of neural gain on topology was greatest in a bilateral network of high-degree frontoparietal cortical regions ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). This suggests that the recruitment of these hub regions at intermediate levels of excitability and neural gain shifts collective network dynamics across a bifurcation, increasing effective interactions between otherwise segregated regions. This result underlines the effective influence of the structural 'rich club' ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}), which in addition to providing topological support to the structural connectome ([@bib69]), may also facilitate the transition between distinct topological states. This relationship has been demonstrated previously in other studies, either by manipulating the excitability parameter alone ([@bib17]; [@bib75]), or through the alteration of the intrinsic dynamics of the 2d oscillator model ([@bib13]; [@bib53]), thus providing a strong conceptual link between structural topology and emergent dynamics. Crucially, the integrated states facilitated by gain-mediated hub recruitment have been shown to underlie effective cognitive performance ([@bib57]), episodic memory retrieval ([@bib72]) and conscious awareness ([@bib3]; [@bib29]), confirming the importance of ascending neuromodulatory systems for a suite of higher-level behavioral capacities. Overall, our findings broadly support the predictions of the neural gain hypothesis of noradrenergic function ([@bib2]). For instance, manipulating neural gain, a plausible instantiation of the effects of ascending noradrenergic tone in the brain ([@bib56]), led to marked alterations in network topology. Given the demonstrated links between network topology and cognitive function ([@bib12]; [@bib31]; [@bib57]; [@bib60]), our work thus provides a plausible mechanistic account of the long-standing notion of a nonlinear relationship between catecholamine levels and effective cognitive performance ([@bib48]; [@bib57]; [Figure 1a](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). However, it bears mention that our model highlighted a relationship between neural gain, excitability and network topology, in which there was an inverted-U shaped relationship observed between excitability and integration that was related to two separate bifurcations ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"}). In contrast, the effect of neural gain on topology was demonstrably more linear, particularly at intermediate levels of γ ([Figure 2](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Importantly, although noradrenaline has been directly linked to alterations in gain ([@bib56]), there is also reason to believe that noradrenergic tone should have a demonstrable effect on excitability ([@bib13]; [@bib53]; [@bib67]). Combined with our observation of the importance of the interaction between neural gain and high-degree ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}), diverse ([Figure 4---figure supplement 1](#fig4s1){ref-type="fig"}) hub regions, our results thus represent an extension of the neural gain hypothesis that integrates the ascending arousal system with the constraints imposed by multiple order parameters and structural network topology. In addition, our results also align with previous hypotheses that highlighted the importance of α2-adrenoreceptor mediated hub recruitment with increasing concentrations of noradrenaline, particularly in the frontal cortex ([@bib48]; [@bib55]). However, our findings are inconsistent with the hypothesis that neural gain mediates an increase in tightly clustered patterns of neural interactions ([@bib20]). In contrast to this prediction, our simulations showed that measures that reflect an increase in local clustering, such as modularity and the mean clustering coefficient ([Figure 4---figure supplement 2](#fig4s2){ref-type="fig"}), did not increase as a function of neural gain in the same manner as other measures, such as the mean participation coefficient. Therefore, our results suggest that an increase in functional integration (and hence, a concomitant decrease in local clustering) is a more effective indicator of the topological influence of increasing neural gain. However, it bears mention that the hypothesized relationship between clustering and neural gain was presented in the context of a focused learning paradigm ([@bib20]), whereas our data were not modeled in an explicit behavioral context. As such, future studies are required to disambiguate the relative relationship between neural gain and network topology as a function of task performance. Prior computational studies have demonstrated a link between the structural and functional connectome, with the broad repertoire of functional network dynamics bounded by structural constraints imposed by the white-matter backbone of the brain ([@bib16]; [@bib33], [@bib34]). While the targeted role of gain modulation on local neuronal dynamics have been studied ([@bib24]), the impact of gain on functional network organization has not been pursued. Here, we have demonstrated a putative mechanism by which a known biological system (namely, the ascending noradrenergic system) can mediate structural-functional changes, essentially by navigating the functional connectome across a topological landscape characterized by alterations in oscillatory synchrony. However, the direct relationship between neural gain manipulation and the ascending noradrenergic system is likely to represent an oversimplification. Indeed, given the complexity and hierarchical organization of the brain, it is almost certain that other functional systems, such as the thalamus ([@bib36]) and fast-spiking interneurons ([@bib67]), play significant roles in mediating neural gain and hence, the balance between integration and segregation. Further studies are required to interrogate these mechanisms more directly. A somewhat surprising result of our simulation is the link between phase- and amplitude-related measures of neuronal coupling. It has been known for some time that the BOLD signal is insensitive to the relative phase of underlying neural dynamics ([@bib23]), relating more closely to changes in the local oscillator frequency and fluctuations in the relative amplitude of neural firing. Indeed, each of the model parameters used in our experiment (i.e., gain and coupling) exerts a complex influence on both the oscillator frequencies (and hence, the BOLD activity) and the global synchrony (and hence, the BOLD correlations). Moreover, in coupled oscillator systems such as this, the order parameter acts as a 'mean field' that feeds back and influences local dynamics (see e.g. [@bib6]). Based on this knowledge, we can infer that estimates of connectivity using BOLD time series relate to covariance in amplitude fluctuations among pairs of regions, rather than alterations in phase synchrony. This clarification is important for modern theories of functional neuroscience, as synchronous relationships between regions in the phase domain have been used to explain effective communication between neural regions ([@bib26]; [@bib42]; [@bib63]), in which the precise timing between spiking populations determines the efficacy of information processing. Our results suggest a surprisingly robust link between these two measures, such that an integrated network with increased inter-modular amplitude correlation coincides with a peak in ordered phase synchrony between regions. In our model, the peak of network variability occurs at the critical transition between disordered and ordered phases, where the local dynamic states shows the most variability and where fast stochastic perturbations are most able to influence slow amplitude fluctuations. However, while our model provides evidence linking neural gain to functional integration, advanced models that display a broader variety of non-linear dynamics ([@bib7]) are required to test these hypotheses more directly. Together, our results suggest that the balance between integration and segregation relates to alterations in neural gain that exist within a 'zone' of maximal communicability and temporal variability. Our findings thus highlight important constraints on contemporary models of brain function, while also providing crucial implications for understanding effective brain function during task performance or as a function of neurodegenerative or psychiatric disease. Materials and methods {#s4} ===================== Dynamical network modeling {#s4-1} -------------------------- The Virtual Brain software ([@bib54]) was used to simulate neural activity across a lattice of parameter points in which we manipulated the inter-regional coupling between regions using both a gain parameter and an excitability parameter. Specifically, we used a generic 2-dimensional oscillator model ([Equations 1 and 2](#equ1 equ2){ref-type="disp-formula"}) to create time series data that represents neural activity via two variables (the membrane potential and a slow recovery variable). This equation is based upon a modal approximation ([@bib65]) of a population of Fitzhugh-Nagumo neurons ([@bib37]). The neuronal dynamics are given by,$$\overset{˙}{V_{i}}\left( t \right) = \ 20\left( {W_{i}\left( t \right) + 3V_{i}\left( t \right)^{2} - V_{i}\left( t \right)^{3} + \gamma I_{i}} \right) + \xi_{i}\left( t \right),$$$${\overset{˙}{W}}_{i}\left( t \right) = 20\left( {- W_{i}\left( t \right) - 10V_{i}\left( t \right)} \right) + \eta_{i}\left( t \right),$$where *V~i~* represents the local mean membrane potential and *Wi* represents the corresponding slow recovery variable at node *i*. Stochastic fluctuations are introduced additively through the white noise processes $\eta_{i}$ and $\xi_{i}$, drawn independently from Gaussian distributions with zero mean and unit variance. The synaptic current *I~i~* arise from time-delayed input from other regions modulated in strength by the global excitability parameter *γ*. This input arises after the mean membrane potential *V* in distant nodes is converted into a firing rate via a sigmoid-shaped activation function *S*, and then transmitted with axonal time delays through the connectivity matrix. Hence the synaptic current at node *i* is given by,$$I_{i} = {\sum\limits_{j}{A_{ij}S_{j}\left( {t - \tau_{ij}} \right)}}$$where *A~ij~* is the directed connectivity matrix derived from the 76 region CoCoMac connectome ([@bib41]), and $\tau_{ij}$ is the corresponding time delay computed from the length of fiber tracts estimated by diffusion spectrum imaging ([@bib54]). The conversion from regional membrane potential to firing rate is given by a sigmoid-shaped activation function,$$S_{i}\left( t \right) = \frac{1}{1 + e^{- \sigma{({V_{i}{(t)} - m})}}},$$where $\sigma$ is the (global) gain parameter and the sigmoid activation function is shifted to center at *m.* These equations were integrated using a stochastic Heun method ([@bib52]). The simulated neuronal data were fed through a Balloon-Windkessel model to simulate realistic Blood Oxygen Level Dependent signals ([@bib27]). The simulated BOLD time series were band-pass filtered (0.01--0.1 Hz) and the Pearson's correlation was then computed (and normalized using Fisher's r-to-Z transformation). We manipulated the inter-regional neural gain parameter σ and the regional excitability γ through a range of values (between 0--1). After aligning the sensitive region of the sigmoid function with its mean input (*m =* 1.5). Consistent with the effects of relatively diffuse projections from the locus coeruleus to cortex, all regions were given the same values of the σ and γ parameter for each trial. All code is freely available at <https://github.com/macshine/gain_topology> ([@bib62]). A copy is archived at <https://github.com/elifesciences-publications/gain_topology>. Integration and segregation {#s4-2} --------------------------- The Louvain modularity algorithm from the Brain Connectivity Toolbox ([@bib51]) was used to estimate time-averaged community structure. The Louvain algorithm iteratively maximizes the modularity statistic, *Q*, for different community assignments until the maximum possible score of *Q* has been obtained ([Equation 5](#equ5){ref-type="disp-formula"}). The modularity estimate for a given network is therefore a quantification of the extent to which the network may be subdivided into communities with stronger within-module than between-module connections. Here, we used the *Q* parameter to estimate the extent of segregation within each graph,$$Q = \frac{1}{\mathcal{v}^{+}}{\sum\limits_{ij}{\left( {w_{ij}^{+} - e_{ij}^{+}} \right)\delta_{M_{i}M_{j}}}} - \frac{1}{\mathcal{v}^{+} + \mathcal{v}^{-}}{\sum\limits_{ij}{\left( {w_{ij}^{-} - e_{ij}^{-}} \right)\delta_{M_{i}M_{j}}}}$$where *v* is the total weight of the network (sum of all negative and positive connections), *w~ij~* is the weighted and signed connection between regions *i* and *j*, *e~ij~* is the strength of a connection divided by the total weight of the network, and *δ~MiMj~* is set to one when regions are in the same community and 0 otherwise. '+' and '--' superscripts denote all positive and negative connections, respectively. Consistent with previous work ([@bib20]), the mean clustering coefficient, which reflects the proportion of closed 'triangles' in the binarized graph, was also used as a measure of segregation ([@bib51]). For each level of neural gain, the community assignment for each region was assessed 100 times and a consensus partition was identified using a fine-tuning algorithm from the Brain Connectivity Toolbox (<http://www.brain-connectivity-toolbox.net/>). All graph theoretical measures were calculated on weighted and signed connectivity matrices ([@bib51]), and weak connections were retained using a consistency thresholding technique that identifies weak, yet consistent connections by identifying edges with minimal variance across multiple iterations ([@bib50]). In order to assess global, large-scale communities, the resolution parameter was set to 1.0 (higher values tune the algorithm to detect smaller communities, which instead reflect local, rather than global, clustering). This parameter was chosen by calculating the resolution value which maximized the Surprise ([@bib1]) between the community structure of the network at each level of gain and resolution and a random network defined using a cumulative hypergeometric distribution (see \[[@bib1]\]). The participation coefficient, *B~A~* ([Equation 6](#equ6){ref-type="disp-formula"}) quantifies the extent to which a region connects across all modules (i.e. between-module strength). As such, the mean participation coefficient can be used to estimate the extent of integration within a graph. The participation coefficient, *B~Ai~*, for a given region *i* is,$$B_{Ai} = 1 - {\sum_{s = 1}^{n_{M}}\left( \frac{\kappa_{is}}{\kappa_{i}} \right)^{2}}$$where κ~is~ is the strength of the positive connections of region *i* to regions in module *s*, and κ~i~ is the sum of strengths of all positive connections of region *i*. The participation coefficient of a region is therefore close to one if its connections are uniformly distributed among all the modules and 0 if all of its links are within its own module. Finally, the global efficiency (mean inverse characteristic path length) and inverse modularity (*Q*^−1^) were estimated for each element of the parameter space as adjunct measures of integration. Phase synchrony order parameter {#s4-3} ------------------------------- To estimate the degree of phase synchrony at different points in the parameter space, we extracted the raw signal (*Vi*) from each region in the simulation and subtracted the least squares linear trend from each channel. We then computed the phase of the analytic signal for each channel using the Hilbert transform and then estimated the phase synchrony order parameter (across all channels), OP, which is given by,$$\rho = \left| {\frac{1}{N}{\sum\limits_{j = 1}^{N}e^{i\theta_{j}}}} \right|$$where *i* = $\sqrt{- 1}$ and θ*~j~* represents the oscillation phase of the *j*^th^ region. Large values of ρ denote phase alignment between regions ([@bib6]; [@bib40]). The value of ρ for each parameter combination was subsequently averaged over time and across sessions. By designating each parameter combination as resulting in either a synchronized (*ρ* ≥0.5) or unsynchronized (*ρ* \<0.5) regime, we were able to determine whether network topology changes as a function of neural gain and excitability estimated from BOLD data coincided with changes of underlying phase synchrony. Specifically, we then separately grouped topological variables and within- and between-hemisphere connectivity according to their underlying *ρ* value and then estimated an independent-samples t-test between the two groups. The standard deviation of the order parameter, ρ, was also calculated and averaged across sessions. Finally, the dwell times for regional fluctuations were estimated for a number of characteristic parameter choices and analyzed for evidence of Pareto (i.e. power law) scaling. Communicability {#s4-4} --------------- The communicability, *C*, between a pair of nodes *i* and *j* is defined as a weighted sum of the number of all walks connecting the pair of nodes (within weighted connectivity matrix, *A*) and has been shown to be equivalent to the matrix exponent of a binarized graph, *e^A^* ([@bib21]). For ease of interpretation, we calculated the log~10~-transformed mean of communicability for each graph across iterations and values of neural gain.$$C_{ij} = {\sum\limits_{k = 0}^{\infty}\frac{\left( A^{k} \right)_{ij}}{k!}} = e^{A}$$ Topological variability {#s4-5} ----------------------- To estimate time-resolved functional connectivity between the 76 nodal pairs, we used a recently described statistical technique (Multiplication of Temporal Derivatives; ([@bib58]); <http://github.com/macshine/coupling>), which is computed by calculating the point-wise product of temporal derivative of pairwise time series ([Equation 7](#equ7){ref-type="disp-formula"}). To reduce the contamination of high-frequency noise in the time-resolved connectivity data, *M~ij~* was averaged over a temporal window (*w* = 15 time points). Individual functional connectivity matrices were calculated within each temporal window, thus generating an unthresholded (signed and weighted) 3D adjacency matrix (region $\times$ region $\times$ time) for each participant. These matrices were then subjected to time-resolved topological analyses, which allowed us to estimate the participation coefficient for each region over time (*B~T~*). We used the mean regional standard deviation of this measure to estimate time-resolved topological variability in the simulated data.$$M_{ijt} = \frac{1}{w}{\sum_{t}^{t + w}\frac{\left( {{dt}_{it} \times {dt}_{jt}} \right)}{\left( {\sigma_{{dt}_{i}} \times \sigma_{{dt}_{j}}} \right)}}$$for each time point, *t*, *M~ij~* is defined according to [Equation 1](#equ1){ref-type="disp-formula"}, where *dt* is the first temporal derivative of the *i*^th^ or *j*^th^ time series at time *t*, σ is the standard deviation of the temporal derivative time series for region *i* or *j* and *w* is the window length of the simple moving average. This equation can then be calculated over the course of a time series to obtain an estimate of time-resolved connectivity between pairs of regions. Structural rich club {#s4-6} -------------------- To test whether changes associated with neural gain were mediated by highly-interconnected high-degree hubs, we identified a set of 'rich club' regions using the structural white matter connectome from the CoCoMac database ([@bib41]). Briefly, the degree of each node *i* in the network was determined by calculating the number of links that node *i* shared with *k* other nodes in the network. All nodes that showed a number of connections of ≤*k* were removed from the network. For the remaining network, the rich-club coefficient (*Φ~k~*) was computed as the ratio of connections present between the remaining nodes and the total number of possible connections that would be present when the set would be fully connected. We then normalized *Φ~k~* relative to a set of random networks with similar density and connectivity distributions. When *Φ~Z~* is greater than 1, the network can be said to display a 'rich club' architecture. Individual regions that are interconnected at the value of *k* at which the network demonstrates a 'rich club' architecture are thus designated as 'rich club' nodes (n = 22). Any nodes outside of this group but still sharing a connection are labeled as 'feeder' nodes (n = 44), and regions disconnected from the rich club are designated as 'local' nodes (n = 10). The results were projected onto a standard surface representation of the macaque cortex ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). After segmenting the network in this fashion, we were able to estimate the realized mean gain and B*~A~* across the parameter space for regions according to their structural topology. Realized neural gain {#s4-7} -------------------- While the neural gain parameter σ controls the *maximum* gain in each region within the simulation by setting the maximum slope of the sigmoid, the realized gain (mean ratio of sigmoid output to input) for each brain region depends upon the distribution of its input, and is greater when the input level is concentrated near the center of the sigmoid. We estimated the regional variation in effective or 'realized' neural gain by calculating the integral of the instantaneous sigmoid slope over its complete input range, weighted by the probability of each input level. We then compared these values as a function of nodal class (rich club vs other nodes) at each aspect of the parameter space. Reliability {#s4-8} ----------- We ran a number of subsequent tests to ensure that any observed changes in network topology were robust to the processing steps utilized in the analysis. Firstly, we re-analyzed data across a range of network thresholds (1--20%) and observed robust results (i.e. r \> 0.75) for Q, mean B*~A~*, mean communicability and the standard deviation of B*~T~* on graphs estimated between the 9--20% threshold range. Secondly, as the number of modules estimated from graphs can change as a function of network topology, we re-examined the topological characteristics of networks that were matched for the number of modules (N = 4) and found no significant differences to the topological signatures estimated on the whole group. Funding Information =================== This paper was supported by the following grant: - http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100000925National Health and Medical Research Council GNT1072403 to James M Shine. We thank the creators of the Virtual Brain for their open-source software, Peter Bell for helpful comments, Bratislav Misic for sharing code and Joke Durnez for statistical advice. Additional information {#s5} ====================== No competing interests declared. Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Validation, Investigation, Visualization, Writing---original draft, Project administration, Writing---review and editing. Resources, Data curation, Software, Formal analysis, Investigation, Visualization, Methodology, Writing---review and editing. Formal analysis, Supervision, Methodology, Writing---review and editing. Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Supervision, Methodology, Writing---review and editing. Additional files {#s6} ================ 10.7554/eLife.31130.012 10.7554/eLife.31130.016 Decision letter Deco Gustavo Reviewing Editor Universitat Pompeu Fabra Spain In the interests of transparency, eLife includes the editorial decision letter and accompanying author responses. A lightly edited version of the letter sent to the authors after peer review is shown, indicating the most substantive concerns; minor comments are not usually included. Thank you for submitting your article \"The modulation of neural gain facilitates a transition between functional segregation and integration in the brain\" for consideration by *eLife*. Your article has been favorably evaluated by a Senior Editor and three reviewers, one of whom, Gustavo Deco (Reviewer \#1), is a member of our Board of Reviewing Editors. The following individuals involved in review of your submission have agreed to reveal their identity: Tobias H Donner (Reviewer \#2); Maxwell Bertolero (Reviewer \#3). The reviewers have discussed the reviews with one another and the Reviewing Editor has drafted this decision to help you prepare a revised submission. Your paper presents a very useful integration a modeling framework and graph theoretical analysis, providing a mechanistic explanation of how neuromodulation balances the equilibrium between segregation and integration of functional information. All reviewers found the paper to be well written and the results to be relevant for the broader neuroscience community. All reviewers support the publication of the paper in *eLife*, provided that you address the following issues in your revision. 1\) Additional analyses: 1a) The participation coefficient is a great measure of integration, but it needs to be supplemented with other measures. You should test the integration hypotheses with the participation coefficient, Q (inverse), and efficiency, and more carefully lay out why these measures make sense for testing the hypotheses regarding integration and segregation. Moreover, the participation coefficient is a nodal measure, but you only report the mean -- are all nodes equally increasing their participation coefficients? Are low or high nodes increasing their participation coefficients? These analyses will give more insight into exactly what is occurring in the network as a result of neural gain. Rationale behind this request: The participation coefficient is a relative measure of the diversity a node\'s connections across communities. Thus, consider a node with strong connectivity to community A and weak connectivity to communities B-F. If the node simply decreases connectivity to community A, its participation coefficient increases. While this is likely rare, it can occur, and this might not capture the intuition of increased integration. On the other hand, perhaps it does, as the node is interacting with communities in a more equal fashion. Moreover, if other nodes from community A shift to community B, the participation coefficient of the node will increase, even if none of its connections did. Because of these ambiguities, supplementing the mean participation coefficient with Q and efficiency (the inverse of the sum of shortest paths) would be ideal. While Q is used as a measure of segregation, which is appropriate, the reasoning behind this is not laid out. It should be. 1b) You show that the profile for global phase synchrony (computed from the regional membrane potentials) is very similar to the profiles for the graph-theoretical measures that are based on the correlations of (much slower) local BOLD time series ([Figure 2A and B](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). This observation is non-trivial. It should be complemented by an analysis of a measure of the dynamics of global phase synchrony -- for instance, the standard deviation of global phase synchrony, which has been used to quantify metastability. Does this measure exhibit the same profile as those in [Figure 2A and B](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}? Along that line, please discuss *why* the similarity between BOLD correlation topology and global phase synchrony emerges. Do you have an intuition for this? 1c) The \"Gain mediated integration is maximal in frontoparietal hub regions\" findings should be complemented by analyzing the \"diverse club\" or the regions with high participation coefficients (Bertolero et al., 2017), which was found to be more highly interconnected than the rich club in the macaque. 2\) Discussion, embedding of the present results into the existing literature. 2a) The Discussion should elaborate on the facts that (i) several of the results are motivated and expected from previous work, and (ii) the excitability parameter in your model is analogous to the global coupling, which has been used as control parameter in previous studies. The main new contribution here seems to be the addition of a second control parameter, the global gain. Please note that, all reviewers appreciate the need of implementing the effects of neuromodulation effect explicitly, but they feel that the readership would benefit from a more balanced discussion of the context. Rationale behind this request: Several previous studies have shown that networks of oscillators reach a balance between integration and segregation, a maximal complexity, and the largest variability of temporal networks at the critical point separating the asynchronous and synchronous phases (e.g., Schmidt et al., 2015; Zamora-Lopez et al. 2016; Deco et al. 2017). These studies also showed that rich clubs have a leading role concerning integration/segregation and complexity. The network can be displaced from one phase to the other by changing a control parameter, which is usually chosen to be the global coupling or connectivity strength -- analogous to the excitability parameter used in your model. In addition, you manipulate a second control parameter, namely the slope of the transfer function that converts inputs into firing rates. Increasing the slope brings the system from asynchronous state to the synchronous state, and, as shown in Equation \[3\], has the same effect than a global coupling. 2b) Changes in both parameters (gain and excitability) are necessary for producing the effects of interest in your model. In particular, the graph-theoretical measures show a non-monotonic (inverted U) dependency on excitability, but not on gain. Still, the title and much of your Discussion focusses on gain only, drawing firm links to the Astone-Jones and Cohen Adaptive Gain Theory. Please discuss more explicitly the interesting effects of excitability. Specifically: How can you reconcile the predominance of inverted U patterns for excitability but not gain, with the Aston-Jones and Cohen framework. 2c) Previous work by the labs of Ken Harris and Stefano Panzeri has also used the FitzHugh-Nagumo model to characterise the effects of state/neuromodulation on cortical dynamics -- but by modulating the dynamics of the 2D-oscillator itself (Curto et al., 2009; Safaai et al., PNAS, 2015). This work should be discussed and related to your current approach. 3\) Clarifications 3a) In general, all reviewers appreciate that the paper was written for a general audience. However, please include all equations and note in the main text where they exist. For example, please include the equation for Communicability and expand the explanation -- is it all walks, or all walks that are part of all shortest walks between all nodes? It is not clear in the Results or Materials and methods section. 3b) Please unpack the rationale behind using the correspondence between structural and functional connectivity as criterion for delineating the \"plausible\" sub-space of parameter combinations. This is important because work into neuromodulation in small circuits shows that neuromodulation can reconfigure circuits, thus overriding the structural connectome (Marder, Neuron, 2012). 3c) It seems that Vi is used for the computation of phase synchrony (i.e., not the neural activity passed through the hemodynamics). This should be made explicit in the Materials and methods. (Terms like \"raw signal\" or \"neural data\" are ambiguous.) 3d) [Figure 2D](#fig2){ref-type="fig"} is described as inverted U relationship, a description that glosses over the left flank of this plot. The relationship clearly is monotonic, but not an inverted U. 3e) [Figure 2---figure supplement 3](#fig2s3){ref-type="fig"} is missing axis labels and won\'t be understandable for a broad audience. Please explain what it shows and what that means. 10.7554/eLife.31130.017 Author response > \[...\] All reviewers support the publication of the paper in eLife, provided that you address the following issues in your revision. > > 1\) Additional analyses: > > 1a) The participation coefficient is a great measure of integration, but it needs to be supplemented with other measures. You should test the integration hypotheses with the participation coefficient, Q (inverse), and efficiency, and more carefully lay out why these measures make sense for testing the hypotheses regarding integration and segregation. We thank the reviewers for their thoughtful comments regarding the potential limitations associated with the interpretation of the participation coefficient as a unitary measure to estimate topological integration. As requested, we have calculated the inverse of the modularity statistic (Q^-1^), taking care to iterate the algorithm a number of times due to stochasticity, and the global efficiency (GE) for the time-averaged connectivity matrix associated with each element of the parameter space. The expected result was apparent for both variables -- i.e., increased Q^-1^ and GE as a function of increasing α and intermediate γ. We have added these two results to the manuscript, and included a separate figure, [Figure 2---figure supplement 1](#fig2s1){ref-type="fig"}. The following text was added to the manuscript: "Similar patterns were observed for other topological measures of integration, such as the inverse modularity (Q^-1^) and global efficiency ([Figure 2---figure supplement 1](#fig2s1){ref-type="fig"})." > Moreover, the participation coefficient is a nodal measure, but you only report the mean -- are all nodes equally increasing their participation coefficients? Are low or high nodes increasing their participation coefficients? These analyses will give more insight into exactly what is occurring in the network as a result of neural gain. We thank the reviewers for this comment, and have conducted an adjunct analysis (similar to the experiment conducted for the 'rich club' regions) for the so-called 'diverse club' -- i.e., regions with elevated participation. Specifically, we calculated the mean B*~A~* across the parameter space and then identified the top 30% of nodes (to match the number of identified rich club regions) -- 16/22 regions (\~73%) were present in both the 'diverse' and 'rich' club. We then estimated the mean B*~A~* across the parameter space for regions within the 'diverse club' and contrasted their gain- and excitability-mediated alterations in B*~A~*. The results (presented in [Figure 4---figure supplement 1](#fig4s1){ref-type="fig"}) were comparable to those observed in the rich club analysis, suggesting a need for future experiments to delineate the precise topological role of degree and diversity in mediating the functional signature of brain activity over time. The following text was added to the manuscript: "Interestingly, similar dissociations were observed when comparing regions with high and low diversity ([Figure 4---figure supplement 1](#fig4s1){ref-type="fig"}), suggesting a role for future experiments to disambiguate the importance of degree and diversity in the mediation of global network topology (Bertolero et al., 2017). However, given the substantial overlap between regions in the 'rich' and diverse' clubs (73% of regions were found in both groups), our results confirm a crucial role for frontoparietal regions in the control of network-level integration as a function of ascending neuromodulatory gain." > Rationale behind this request: The participation coefficient is a relative measure of the diversity a node\'s connections across communities. Thus, consider a node with strong connectivity to community A and weak connectivity to communities B-F. If the node simply decreases connectivity to community A, its participation coefficient increases. While this is likely rare, it can occur, and this might not capture the intuition of increased integration. On the other hand, perhaps it does, as the node is interacting with communities in a more equal fashion. Moreover, if other nodes from community A shift to community B, the participation coefficient of the node will increase, even if none of its connections did. Because of these ambiguities, supplementing the mean participation coefficient with Q and efficiency (the inverse of the sum of shortest paths) would be ideal. While Q is used as a measure of segregation, which is appropriate, the reasoning behind this is not laid out. It should be. We thank the reviewers for their thoughtful comments and have added a more explicit justification of the utilization of the participation coefficient and modularity statistic as indices of integration and segregation, respectively. The following text was added to the manuscript: "This allowed us to estimate the amount of integration in the time-averaged functional connectivity matrix across the parameter space ([Figure 2A](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}\[...\] The converse situation (i.e., segregation) can thus be indexed by low mean B~A~ scores, or alternatively by the modularity statistic, Q." > 1b) You show that the profile for global phase synchrony (computed from the regional membrane potentials) is very similar to the profiles for the graph-theoretical measures that are based on the correlations of (much slower) local BOLD time series ([Figure 2A and B](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). This observation is non-trivial. It should be complemented by an analysis of a measure of the dynamics of global phase synchrony -- for instance, the standard deviation of global phase synchrony, which has been used to quantify metastability. Does this measure exhibit the same profile as those in [Figure 2A and B](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}? We appreciate the constructive suggestion to better quantify the nature of the dynamics at the critical boundary and, as suggested, have now estimated the standard deviation of the order parameter as a function of neural gain and excitability. The following text was added to the manuscript: "Across the parameter space, we observed two clear states ([Figure 2B](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}): one associated with high (ρ ≥ 0.5; yellow) and one with low (ρ \< 0.5; blue) mean synchrony, with a clear critical boundary demarcating the two states (dotted white line in [Figure 2A](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}/B) that was associated with a relative increase in the standard deviation of the order parameter ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2A](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"})." We next undertook additional analyses to better quantify the nature of the dynamics at the critical boundary. We first observed that the standard deviation of the order parameter increased around the boundary delineating the low and high ordered states ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2B](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"}). This increase in fluctuation amplitude suggests the presence of complex dynamics, such as criticality, metastability or multistability (see Cocchi et al., 2017 and Heitman and Breakspear, 2017 for further discussion). To disambiguate these possibilities, we next studied the probability distribution of the fluctuations in the order parameter ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"} and Roberts et al., 2015). Close to the boundary, we observed a truncated Pareto (power law) scaling regime spanning up to two orders of magnitude (Figure Y2---figure supplement 2B), consistent with a critical bifurcation in a complex, many-bodied system. After crossing the boundary, this relationship develops a 'knee' above the power-law scaling ([Figure 2---figure supplement 2B](#fig2s2){ref-type="fig"}), consistent with the emergence of a characteristic temporal scale in a super-critical system (Roberts et al. 2015). These observations suggest that the system undergoes a bifurcation across a critical boundary as the synchronization manifold loses stability. The following text was added to the manuscript: "To further disambiguate the system-level dynamics, we studied the probability distribution of the fluctuations in the order parameter. \[...\] These observations suggest that the system undergoes a bifurcation across a critical boundary as the synchronization manifold loses stability." The following text was also added to the manuscript: "The standard deviation of the order parameter, ρ, was also calculated and averaged across sessions. Finally, the dwell times for regional fluctuations were estimated for a number of characteristic parameter choices and analyzed for evidence of Pareto (i.e. power law) scaling." > Along that line, please discuss why the similarity between BOLD correlation topology and global phase synchrony emerges. Do you have an intuition for this? The factors mediating the relationship between the BOLD correlation topology and the global phase synchrony are quite complex. Recall that in the present model, the BOLD is simulated by driving the synaptic current through a Balloon-Windkessel model. Therefore, an increase in local neuronal activity (such as by an increase in the local oscillator frequency) will drive an increase in the local BOLD amplitude. Likewise, an increase in inter-system synchrony increases the order parameter. Therefore, to mediate the observed relationship between the BOLD topology and the global phase synchrony, there must exist a relationship between the global phase synchrony and the mean frequency of all oscillators: this is indeed the case (*r* = 0.21, *p* = 2.2x10^-09^) ([Author response image 1](#respfig1){ref-type="fig"}) {#respfig1} Moreover, this relationship is mediated in a complex manner (through the neuronal state equation) by dependence of the global synchrony on both coupling (γ) and gain (σ) ([Author response image 2](#respfig2){ref-type="fig"}). {#respfig2} In sum, both model parameters (gain and coupling) exert a complex influence on both the oscillator frequencies (and hence, the BOLD activity) and the global synchrony (and hence, the BOLD correlations). Moreover, in coupled oscillator systems such as this, the order parameter acts as a "mean field" that feeds back and influences local dynamics (see e.g. Breakspear et al., 2010). The following text was added to the manuscript: "A somewhat surprising result of our simulation is the link between phase- and amplitude-related measures of neuronal coupling. \[...\] Moreover, in coupled oscillator systems such as this, the order parameter acts as a "mean field" that feeds back and influences local dynamics (see e.g. Breakspear et al., 2010)." > 1c) The \"Gain mediated integration is maximal in frontoparietal hub regions\" findings should be complemented by analyzing the \"diverse club\" or the regions with high participation coefficients (Bertolero et al., 2017), which was found to be more highly interconnected than the rich club in the macaque. We agree that the relationship between ascending neural gain and the diversity of inter-regional connectivity is likely to be important for global integration. As such, we have conducted an adjunct analysis (similar to the experiment conducted for the 'rich club' regions) for the so-called 'diverse club' -- i.e., regions with elevated participation. Specifically, we calculated the mean B*~A~* across the parameter space and then identified the top 30% of nodes (to match the number of identified rich club regions) -- 16/22 regions (\~73%) were present in both the 'diverse' and 'rich' club. We then estimated the mean B*~A~* across the parameter space for regions within the 'diverse club' and contrasted their gain- and excitability-mediated alterations in B*~A~*. The results (presented in [Figure 4---figure supplement 1](#fig4s1){ref-type="fig"}) were comparable to those observed in the rich club analysis, suggesting a need for future experiments to delineate the precise topological role of degree and diversity in mediating the functional signature of brain activity over time. The following text was added to the manuscript: "Interestingly, similar dissociations were observed when comparing regions with high and low diversity ([Figure 4---figure supplement 1](#fig4s1){ref-type="fig"}), suggesting a role for future experiments to disambiguate the importance of degree and diversity in the mediation of global network topology (Bertolero et al., 2017). However, given the substantial overlap between regions in the 'rich' and diverse' clubs (73% of regions were found in both groups), our results confirm a crucial role for frontoparietal regions in the control of network-level integration as a function of ascending neuromodulatory gain." > 2\) Discussion, embedding of the present results into the existing literature. > > 2a) The Discussion should elaborate on the facts that (i) several of the results are motivated and expected from previous work, and (ii) the excitability parameter in your model is analogous to the global coupling, which has been used as control parameter in previous studies. The main new contribution here seems to be the addition of a second control parameter, the global gain. > > Please note that, all reviewers appreciate the need of implementing the effects of neuromodulation effect explicitly, but they feel that the readership would benefit from a more balanced discussion of the context. We thank the reviewers for their comments, and have added a discussion of this work to the manuscript. The following text was added to the manuscript: "The effect of neural gain on topology was greatest in a bilateral network of high-degree frontoparietal cortical regions ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}). \[...\] Crucially, the integrated states facilitated by gain-mediated hub recruitment have been shown to underlie effective cognitive performance (Shine et al., 2016a), episodic memory retrieval (Westphal et al., 2017) and conscious awareness (Barttfeld et al., 2015; Godwin et al., 2015), confirming the importance of ascending neuromodulatory systems for a suite of higher-level behavioral capacities." > Rationale behind this request: Several previous studies have shown that networks of oscillators reach a balance between integration and segregation, a maximal complexity, and the largest variability of temporal networks at the critical point separating the asynchronous and synchronous phases (e.g., Schmidt et al., 2015; Zamora-Lopez et al. 2016; Deco et al. 2017). These studies also showed that rich clubs have a leading role concerning integration/segregation and complexity. The network can be displaced from one phase to the other by changing a control parameter, which is usually chosen to be the global coupling or connectivity strength -- analogous to the excitability parameter used in your model. In addition, you manipulate a second control parameter, namely the slope of the transfer function that converts inputs into firing rates. Increasing the slope brings the system from asynchronous state to the synchronous state, and, as shown in Equation \[3\], has the same effect than a global coupling. We thank the reviewers for their comments, and have added a discussion of this work to the manuscript. The following text was added to the manuscript: "This relationship has been demonstrated previously in other studies, either by manipulating the excitability parameter alone (Zamora-López et al., 2016) (Deco et al., 2017), or through the alteration of the intrinsic dynamics of the 2d oscillator model (Curto et al., 2009; Safaai et al., 2015), thus providing a strong conceptual link between structural topology and emergent dynamics. Crucially, the integrated states facilitated by gain-mediated hub recruitment have been shown to underlie effective cognitive performance (Shine et al., 2016a), episodic memory retrieval (Westphal et al., 2017) and conscious awareness (Barttfeld et al., 2015; Godwin et al., 2015), confirming the importance of ascending neuromodulatory systems for a suite of higher-level behavioral capacities." > 2b) Changes in both parameters (gain and excitability) are necessary for producing the effects of interest in your model. In particular, the graph-theoretical measures show a non-monotonic (inverted U) dependency on excitability, but not on gain. Still, the title and much of your Discussion focusses on gain only, drawing firm links to the Astone-Jones and Cohen Adaptive Gain Theory. Please discuss more explicitly the interesting effects of excitability. Specifically: How can you reconcile the predominance of inverted U patterns for excitability but not gain, with the Aston-Jones and Cohen framework. We thank the reviewers for their comments, and have added a discussion of this work to the manuscript. The following text was added to the manuscript: *"*Overall, our findings broadly support the predictions of the neural gain hypothesis of noradrenergic function (Aston-Jones and Cohen, 2005b). \[...\] Combined with our observation of the importance of the interaction between neural gain and high-degree ([Figure 4](#fig4){ref-type="fig"}), diverse ([Figure 4---figure supplement 1](#fig4s1){ref-type="fig"}) hub regions, our results thus represent an extension of the neural gain hypothesis that integrates the ascending arousal system with the constraints imposed by multiple order parameters and structural network topology." > 2c) Previous work by the labs of Ken Harris and Stefano Panzeri has also used the FitzHugh-Nagumo model to characterise the effects of state/neuromodulation on cortical dynamics -- but by modulating the dynamics of the 2D-oscillator itself (Curto et al., 2009; Safaai et al., PNAS, 2015). This work should be discussed and related to your current approach. We thank the reviewers for their comments, and have added a discussion of this work to the manuscript. The following text was added to the manuscript: "This relationship has been demonstrated previously in other studies, either by manipulating the excitability parameter alone (Zamora-López et al., 2016) (Deco et al., 2017), or through the alteration of the intrinsic dynamics of the 2d oscillator model (Curto et al., 2009; Safaai et al., 2015), thus providing a strong conceptual link between structural topology and emergent dynamics. Crucially, the integrated states facilitated by gain-mediated hub recruitment have been shown to underlie effective cognitive performance (Shine et al., 2016a), episodic memory retrieval (Westphal et al., 2017) and conscious awareness (Barttfeld et al., 2015; Godwin et al., 2015), confirming the importance of ascending neuromodulatory systems for a suite of higher-level behavioral capacities." > 3\) Clarifications > > 3a) In general, all reviewers appreciate that the paper was written for a general audience. However, please include all equations and note in the main text where they exist. For example, please include the equation for Communicability and expand the explanation -- is it all walks, or all walks that are part of all shortest walks between all nodes? It is not clear in the Results or Materials and methods section. We apologize for the lack of clarity. Communicability was calculated on all walks. This information (along with the equation defining this metric) has been added to the Materials and methods section. The following text was added to the Materials and methods section: "The communicability, C, between a pair of nodes i and j is defined as a weighted sum of the number of all walks connecting the pair of nodes (within weighted connectivity matrix, A) and has been shown to be equivalent to the matrix exponent of a binarized graph, e^A^ (Estrada and Hatano, 2008). For ease of interpretation, we calculated the log~10~-transformed mean of communicability for each graph across iterations and values of neural gain." Cij=∑k=0∞Akijk!=eA\[8\] > 3b) Please unpack the rationale behind using the correspondence between structural and functional connectivity as criterion for delineating the \"plausible\" sub-space of parameter combinations. This is important because work into neuromodulation in small circuits shows that neuromodulation can reconfigure circuits, thus overriding the structural connectome (Marder, Neuron, 2012). In light of the referenced paper, we have opted to remove the constraint that the structural connectome should be similar to the functional connectome. Importantly, this does not change the interpretation of our results. > 3c) It seems that Vi is used for the computation of phase synchrony (i.e., not the neural activity passed through the hemodynamics). This should be made explicit in the Materials and methods. (Terms like \"raw signal\" or \"neural data\" are ambiguous.) We have amended each instance of these terms in the manuscript to improve clarity. > 3d) [Figure 2D](#fig2){ref-type="fig"} is described as inverted U relationship, a description that glosses over the left flank of this plot. The relationship clearly is monotonic, but not an inverted U. We have added a statement to this effect in the manuscript. > 3e) [Figure 2---figure supplement 3](#fig2s3){ref-type="fig"} is missing axis labels and won\'t be understandable for a broad audience. Please explain what it shows and what that means. The figure legends for [Figure 2---figure supplement 3](#fig2s3){ref-type="fig"} have been amended in the updated version.

Introduction {#s1} ============ Ataxia telangiectasia and RAD3-related protein (ATR) was the first identified causal defect for Seckel syndrome (SS) (SCKL1, MIM no. 210600), a disorder characterized by microcephaly and growth delay ([@DDW034C1],[@DDW034C2]). ATR is the central kinase that activates DNA damage response (DDR) signalling following replication stalling or genotoxic damage ([@DDW034C3]). ATR is activated by single-stranded regions of DNA that form during replication stalling/collapse and promotes cell cycle checkpoint arrest as well as a plethora of responses that enhance recovery from replication damage. As DNA damage is encountered during most cycles of replication, ATR is essential ([@DDW034C4]--[@DDW034C6]). Patient-derived ATR-deficient SS cell lines (ATR-SS) show an impaired response to replication damage, and studies generally attribute ATR\'s developmental role to this function ([@DDW034C2],[@DDW034C6]). In contrast to ATR, many other characterized genetic defects for SS as well as those for related disorders conferring microcephalic primordial dwarfism (MPD) are found in centrosomal proteins or those that cause centrosomal defects ([@DDW034C7]). For example, microcephalic osteodysplastic primordial (MOPD)-type II, an MPD disorder, is caused by mutations in *PCNT*, which encodes the centrosomal protein, pericentrin (PCNT) ([@DDW034C8],[@DDW034C9]). Additionally, defects in CEP152 and CENPJ also cause SS or primary microcephaly (MCPH), in which the clinical manifestation predominantly affects head size with less or no significant impact upon growth ([@DDW034C7],[@DDW034C10]--[@DDW034C12]). Indeed, causal genetic defects for MCPH, such as *MCPH1*, *CENPJ/CPAP*, *CEP213/CDK5RAP2*, *ASPM*, *WDR62*, *CEP135*, *CEP63* and *STIL*, encode centrosome or spindle-associated proteins, providing a further link between microcephaly and centrosomal-spindle function ([@DDW034C11],[@DDW034C12]). A proposed role for centrosomes is to regulate the symmetry of cell division, which is important during neurogenesis ([@DDW034C11]). However, the centrosome is also the basal body from which cilia are formed ([@DDW034C13]), providing an additional factor to consider for the basis underlying MPD disorders. Indeed, deficiency of PCNT also causes defects in cilia formation and function ([@DDW034C14]--[@DDW034C16]). Further, a recent study identified defects in PLK4, a protein required for centriole biogenesis, in additional patients with MPD ([@DDW034C17]). Cilia are antenna-like structures that emanate from a modified centriole ([@DDW034C18],[@DDW034C19]). Previously, they have been divided into primary cilia, which are mechano- and chemosensory organelles and motile cilia, which induce a fluid flow and promote motility. However, motile cilia retain some ability to sense as well as transduce molecular cues ([@DDW034C20],[@DDW034C21]). Cilia function to transmit and receive extracellular signals and are required for signalling pathways including sonic hedgehog (Shh) and Wnt signalling ([@DDW034C22],[@DDW034C23]). Shh signalling is important during development, including neuronal embryogenesis ([@DDW034C24]--[@DDW034C26]). Defects in primary cilia formation or function underlie a range of developmental disorders collectively termed 'ciliopathies' ([@DDW034C19]). Ciliopathies are clinically heterogeneous disorders with features that include respiratory complications, renal abnormalities, retinal degeneration, structural heart defects and growth retardation. Abnormalities in neuronal development have also been reported in ciliopathies ([@DDW034C19]). Indeed, mounting evidence suggests that cilia function is required for normal neuronal development and/or growth. For example, mutations in *POC1A* and *PLK4*, which encode proteins involved in centriole function, impact upon ciliogenesis and cause primordial dwarfism ([@DDW034C17],[@DDW034C27]). Significantly, we recently reported that defects in the origin licensing proteins, which cause Meier-Gorlin syndrome (MGS), dramatically impede ciliogenesis and cilia signalling ([@DDW034C16]). Zebrafish have been particularly useful for characterizing the developmental impact of deficiencies in cilia formation/signalling ([@DDW034C28],[@DDW034C29]). Such studies have revealed a role for cilia in left-right patterning ([@DDW034C30]--[@DDW034C34]). In zebrafish, primary as well as motile cilia can be readily visualized and analysed for their signalling capacity. Cilia of the left-right organizer perpetuate a counter-clockwise flow and elicit calcium spikes ([@DDW034C35]). Readouts for cilia function include the level of nodal flow, left-sided expression of nodal-related genes and cardiac looping, a measure for oriented organ morphogenesis ([@DDW034C30],[@DDW034C32]--[@DDW034C34]). We previously observed that ATR-SS cells display a modestly elevated frequency of supernumerary centrosomes, a phenotype shared with PCNT-deficient MOPD-type II cells and ORC-deficient MGS cells ([@DDW034C8],[@DDW034C16],[@DDW034C36]). Given that cilia develop from centrosomes/centrioles and the strong relationship between centrosome function and MPD, we examined whether ATR is also required for cilia formation and function. Strikingly, we show that ATR is largely dispensable for cilia formation, but has a significant role in promoting cilia-dependent signalling. Furthermore, we show that ATR deficiency in zebrafish causes an abnormality in cilia similar to that seen in human cells, but profoundly confers patterning defects reflective of ciliary dysfunction. This represents a novel and previously uncharacterized role for ATR. Finally, we provide evidence that this function of ATR is distinct to its role in promoting recovery from replication fork stalling. Results {#s2} ======= ATR-SS cells display subtle centrosome and cilia abnormalities {#s2a} -------------------------------------------------------------- We previously reported that ATR-SS patient cells harbour elevated supernumerary centrosomes ([@DDW034C36]). However, in this previous study, nocodazole, which has been reported to enhance centrosome abnormalities, was added to promote accumulation of mitotic cells. Here, we examined centrosome numbers in the absence of nocodazole in fibroblasts derived from a control and an ATR-SS patient (Fig. [1](#DDW034F1){ref-type="fig"}A). Fibroblasts from patients with mutations in *PCNT* (PCNT) were included as a control with impaired cilia function. A-T was included as a line with a distinct defect in DDR signalling, to substantiate the specificity of the findings for ATR. A-T and ATR-SS cells have a similar growth rate (data not shown), suggesting that any differences obtained cannot be attributed to differences in proliferation. Control and A-T fibroblasts showed \<1% cells with more than two centrosomes. In contrast, ATR-SS, and more markedly, PCNT-deficient MOPD-II fibroblasts, displayed an increased frequency of supernumerary centrosomes. Figure 1.ATR-SS cells show supernumerary centrosome and shortened cilia. (**A**) Exponentially growing hTERT fibroblasts from a control (1BR3) (C), an ATR-SS patient (ATR), a PCNT-MOPD type-II patient (PCNT) or an A-T patient (A-T) were analysed for centrosome numbers following staining with anti-γ-tubulin. Cells with more than two centrosomes were scored. (**B**) Patient hTERT fibroblasts \[as in (A)\] or 1BR3 hTERT cells subjected to PCNT or ATR siRNA were serum-starved for 48 h (0%) or maintained in serum (10%) and processed to identify cilia using anti-acetylated tubulin and anti-γ-tubulin antibodies, which mark the entire cilia or basal body, respectively. (**C**) Typical cells lacking cilia following siRNA PCNT. The arrow shows PCNT staining (i.e. no siRNA-mediated knockdown) and a cilium; asterisks denote cells with no PCNT or cilia. (**D**) Cilia forming in ATR-SS cells are slightly shorter than those in control cells. This is evident visually (left panel) and following quantification of length (right panel). *P* \< 0.01, Mann--Whitney rank-sum test. (**E**) Control cells exit the cell cycle 24 h after serum starvation. Similar kinetics of cell cycle exit were observed in ATR-SS and PCNT cells (data not shown). Cell cycle markers were: G1, P-Rb^+^; S phase, BrdU^+^; G2, CENPF-positive; mitosis, P-H3^+^. All results represent the mean ± SD of three experiments. Cilia formation was examined 48 h after serum starvation in patient fibroblasts. Control, ATR-SS, A-T and PCNT-patient fibroblasts form cilia efficiently under this condition (Fig. [1](#DDW034F1){ref-type="fig"}B). Cilia also formed efficiently following siRNA-mediated depletion of ATR (*ATR* siRNA). In contrast, *PCNT* siRNA ablated cilia formation (Fig. [1](#DDW034F1){ref-type="fig"}B and C), consistent with findings that PCNT is required for cilia formation, but PCNT-patient cells are hypomorphic ([@DDW034C14]--[@DDW034C16],[@DDW034C37]). Quantitative assessment of cilia length in ATR-SS cells revealed a modest but statistically significant reduction when compared with control cells (Fig. [1](#DDW034F1){ref-type="fig"}D) (*P* \< 0.01, Mann--Whitney rank-sum test). ATR-SS cells efficiently exited the cell cycle following serum starvation (Fig. [1](#DDW034F1){ref-type="fig"}E). Cilia-dependent response to PDGF is impaired in ATR-SS cells {#s2b} ------------------------------------------------------------ We examined whether ATR deficiency affects cilia function. We previously observed that S phase entry following cell cycle exit and re-entry (after serum addition) was delayed in two Sensenbrenner syndrome cells (deficient in IFT43 or WDR35), which have impaired intraflagellar transport and cilia function, and in ORC1-deficient cells, which show very delayed cilia formation ([@DDW034C16]). We proposed that cilia-dependent signalling promotes cell cycle re-entry following serum starvation. To examine ATR dependency, we monitored S phase entry by bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) labelling following cell cycle exit (48 h in low serum) and subsequent serum addition. Strikingly, both ATR-SS and PCNT fibroblasts showed delayed S phase entry when compared with control and A-T fibroblasts (Fig. [2](#DDW034F2){ref-type="fig"}A). The overlapping cellular phenotype caused by IFT43, WDR35, PCNT or ATR deficiency is consistent with the notion that ATR loss may impair cilia function ([@DDW034C16]). Figure 2.ATR-SS cells show impaired cilia-dependent growth-factor signalling. (**A**) Patient-derived hTERT fibroblasts were serum-depleted for 48 h. Following serum and BrdU addition, the percentage of BrdU^+^ S phase cells was monitored as indicated. At least 200 cells were monitored. (**B**) The indicated *hTERT* fibroblasts were serum-depleted for 48 h. PDGF-AA or -BB and BrdU were then added and the percentage of BrdU^+^ cells (i.e. cells that have entered S phase) estimated by IF 11 and 24 h later. Results are expressed as the ratio of BrdU^+^ cells following treatment with PDGF-AA versus PDGF-BB. A ratio of 1 demonstrates equal signalling from PDGF ligand isoforms (-AA or -BB) and \<1 demonstrates an impaired response to PDGF-AA. The percentage of BrdU^+^ cells after PDGF-BB treatment after all siRNA treatments is shown in [Supplementary Material, Figure S1](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1). This verifies that the indicated siRNA does not impact upon PDGF-BB signalling. Results represent the mean ± SD of three experiments. (**C** and **D**) qRT--PCR analysis of SMO and GLI1 transcript levels in the indicated cells with or without SAG at 24 h. SMO is a reference as it does not change after SAG addition. The WT and PCNT data are part of a previously published data set ([@DDW034C16]). The analysis of ATR- and A-T-deficient cells was carried in the same experiments and has not been previously published. Results represent the mean ± SD of three experiments. Platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) signalling promotes cell cycle entry from G0 ([@DDW034C38]). Two PDGF ligand isoforms and their cognate receptors have been identified: the PDGF receptor α (PDGFR α) specifically localizes to primary cilia, is upregulated in serum-starved cells and responds to the PDGF-AA ligand isoform ([@DDW034C39]) and the PDGFRβ responds to the PDGF-BB isoform and localizes predominantly on the plasma membrane. The response to PDGF-AA represents a cilia-dependent pathway promoting cell cycle entry ([@DDW034C16]). We exploited PDGF-AA and -BB isoforms to examine cilia function as it allows parallel membrane-dependent versus cilia-dependent signalling assessment. Following serum starvation for 48 h, cells were treated with PDGF-AA or -BB isoforms for 11 or 24 h (Fig. [2](#DDW034F2){ref-type="fig"}B). BrdU was added and cell cycle re-entry monitored by immunofluorescence (IF) as the percentage of BrdU^+^ cells. Control and A-T fibroblasts showed a similar ratio of BrdU^+^ cells when exposed to PDGF-AA or -BB; both ATR-SS and PCNT-deficient fibroblasts showed substantially diminished BrdU^+^ cells following PDGF-AA addition (Fig. [2](#DDW034F2){ref-type="fig"}B). ATR-deficient patient cells show impaired Shh signalling {#s2c} -------------------------------------------------------- Cilia are enriched for actively signalling receptors. They thus coordinate and transduce signals required during development such as the Shh pathway ([@DDW034C19],[@DDW034C24]--[@DDW034C26]). Cellular responses to secreted Shh are mediated by two trans-membrane proteins: patched receptor (PTCH-1) and smoothened (SMO). Shh binds to PTCH-1, alleviating suppression of SMO. SMO activation triggers GLI2 nuclear localization promoting transcriptional upregulation of Shh-pathway response genes, including *GLI1*, *PTCH1* and *HHIP.* Using quantitative reverse transcriptase--polymerase chain reaction (RT--PCR), we assessed the transcriptional activation of *GLI1*, using SMO as an internal control. Following SAG addition, an SMO-binding Shh pathway agonist, control cells showed an approximately 10-fold increase in *GLI1*, but not *SMO* transcript levels (Fig. [2](#DDW034F2){ref-type="fig"}C and D). A similar, slightly lower impact (∼8-fold) was observed in A-T fibroblasts. In contrast, *GLI1* transcript levels barely increased in either ATR or PCNT-deficient fibroblasts (Fig. [2](#DDW034F2){ref-type="fig"}C and D). This strongly suggests that ATR-deficient fibroblasts are impaired in Shh signalling, which we attribute to their abnormal cilia function. ATR is required for normal cilia formation and function in zebrafish {#s2d} -------------------------------------------------------------------- To evaluate the developmental impact of ATR\'s role in cilia signalling, we chose zebrafish following injection with antisense morpholino oligonucleotides (MOs) as assays to monitor cilia formation and function have been well described in this system ([@DDW034C40]). First, we assessed cilia formation following *Atr* depletion*.* We depleted *Atr* using a previously published *Atr*-specific antisense MO (Atr MO) ([@DDW034C41]) and labelled cilia within the Kupffer\'s vesicle (KV) through staining of acetylated tubulin. The KV consists of a limited number of monociliated cells and functions as a temporal left-right organizer. Following Atr depletion, we observed that the KV area appeared slightly smaller (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}B) and the cilia modestly shorter (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}A). Quantification of cilia and KV parameters revealed that cilia formed normally and their numbers, although slightly diminished, were not significantly different from control MO-injected embryos (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}C). Strikingly, consistent with the visual images, quantitative assessment of cilia length revealed a small but highly significant shortening of cilia following Atr depletion (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}D). Quantification of the KV area substantiated this visual observation (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}E). As the cilia number was not significantly changed and because hitherto there has not been any obvious correlation between cilia length and KV area, we suggest that the smaller KV area in Atr MO embryos reflects the overall smaller embryos. Figure 3.Atr depletion confers shorter cilia in zebrafish. (**A**) Representative images of cilia in the KV of zebrafish embryos. Cilia were stained with an antibody against acetylated tubulin. Outlines of the KV were visualized by counterstaining with an antibody against atypical PKC (PKCζ). Scale bars: 5 µm. (**B**) Overlay of KV outlines of CTRL MO- or Atr MO-injected embryos \[eight somite stage (ss)\]. Depletion of Atr results in slightly smaller KVs. (**C**) Cilia number was not significantly altered upon Atr depletion. Three independent experiments with 31 embryos per condition. *P* = 0.0770, Student\'s *t*-test. (**D**) KV cilia were short in embryos depleted for Atr. *n* = 7. About 10--831 cilia from 29 to 31 embryos. *P* \< 0.0001, Student\'s *t*-test. (**E**) KV area measurements of CTRL- and Atr MO-injected embryos at eight ss. Three independent experiments with 31 embryos in total. *P* = 0.0166, Student\'s *t*-test. (**F**) *gli1* expression at 24 hpf after injection of either CTRL MO or Atr MO. Four independent experiments. *P* = 0.0008, Student\'s *t*-test. (**G**) Relative expression of *puma* in injected embryos (24 hpf). *n* = 4, *P* \< 0.0001, Student\'s *t*-test. (**H**) p21 expression in 24 hpf embryos summarizing four independent experiments. *P* \< 0.0001, Student\'s *t*-test. (**I**) Representative images of KV cilia in a zebrafish mutant for Smo (*smu^hi1640^*). Scale bars: 5 µm. (**J**) Average cilia length in *smu^hi1640^* mutants and wild-type littermates. *n* = 1094--1826 cilia from 20 to 27 singly genotyped embryos. *P* \< 0.0001, Student\'s *t*-test. Intrigued by this result, we examined whether primary cilia were similarly affected by Atr loss. Analysis of Hedgehog pathway activity by qPCR revealed lower levels of *gli1* in Atr MO-injected embryos when compared with Ctrl MO-injected embryos (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}F). Moreover, Atr depletion significantly increased *puma* and *p21* levels (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}G and H), which have been reported to be negatively regulated by the Hedgehog pathway ([@DDW034C42]). Finally, comparison with a well-characterized mutant for *Smoothened* (*smu^hu1640^*) ([@DDW034C43]) revealed a similar reduction in the length of cilia (Fig. [3](#DDW034F3){ref-type="fig"}I and J). Together these findings demonstrate that the impact of Atr on cilia size is evolutionarily conserved, being observed in zebrafish as well as in human cells. Morphological changes caused by Atr depletion in zebrafish {#s2e} ---------------------------------------------------------- To assess whether Atr depletion causes an SS-like phenotype in zebrafish, we examined head and eye size of Atr MO-injected embryos. Following injection with the previously characterized Atr MO or a second MO interfering with splicing of *atr* pre-mRNA (Atr splMO), we observed that a large percentage of embryos had an underdeveloped head (Fig. [4](#DDW034F4){ref-type="fig"}A and B). SS is furthermore characterized by a reduction of anterior neural structures and consistent with that, we observed smaller eyes in embryos depleted of Atr (Fig. [4](#DDW034F4){ref-type="fig"}C). As the phenotype obtained with the splice blocking MO was milder than that with the translation blocking MO, we assessed its ability to interfere with splicing. RT--PCR demonstrated that splicing of exon 3 was only partially inhibited when compared with the greater impact conferred by the translation blocking MO (Fig. [4](#DDW034F4){ref-type="fig"}D). Atr loss-of-function embryos also appeared smaller than control embryos, consistent with the characteristic primordial dwarfism (intrauterine and postnatal) of the patients ([@DDW034C16]). Figure 4.Morphological changes caused by Atr depletion in zebrafish. (**A**) Live images of 48 hpf zebrafish embryos. As controls, zebrafish were either left uninjected (NI) or control injected (CTRL) with a standard control MO (CTRL MO) or a 5 base mismatch MO (splCTRL MO), respectively. To generate Atr loss of function, injections with a translation blocking MO against Atr (Atr MO) or an MO interfering with Atr splicing (Atr splMO) were performed. Scale bars: 500 µm. (**B**) The percentage of embryos with an underdeveloped head. Graph displays mean values ± SEM, and *n* = 111--193 embryos in 5--11 experiments. \*\*\*\**P* \< 0.0001, one-way ANOVA. (**C**) Loss of Atr interferes with regular eye development. Graph displays means ± SEM, and *n* = 93--113 embryos in 5--11 experiments. \*\*\*\**P* \< 0.0001, one-way ANOVA. (**D**) Representative images of RT--PCR experiments assessing splice blocking efficiency of Atr splMO compared with controls. Left panel shows PCR of exons 2--4 of *atr* with a weaker band at the expected size and an additional smaller band representing the mis-spliced product upon Atr splMO injection. Right panel shows a PCR fragment of β*Actin* as loading control. (**E**) Live images of zebrafish embryos (48 hpf) treated with either 1% DMSO or 10 µ[m]{.smallcaps} Atr inhibitor (ATRi-1) from the tailbud stage on. Scale bars: 500 µm. (**F**) Inhibition of Atr by chemical means (ATRi-1) results in a similar reduction of the head size of 48 hpf embryos. Graph displays mean values ± SEM, and *n* = 95--217 embryos in five experiments. *P* \< 0.0001, Student\'s *t*-test. (**G**) The percentage of embryos developing smaller eyes upon Atr inhibition. Results show the mean values ± SEM, and *n* = 95--217 embryos in five experiments. *P* \< 0.0001, Student\'s *t*-test. To substantiate that these observations are a consequence of Atr deficiency, we exploited a recently generated small molecule inhibitor of Atr, ATR kinase inhibitor III (ATRi-1). To avoid interference with gastrulation movements and to selectively target KV cilia, zebrafish embryos were treated with ATRi-1 from the tailbud stage on, when the KV starts to form. Notably, this recreated the same phenotypes as Atr MO (Fig. [4](#DDW034F4){ref-type="fig"}E), namely, increased frequency of pinheads and small eyes (Fig. [4](#DDW034F4){ref-type="fig"}F and G). Given the abnormal cilia length observed in the zebrafish, we also examined whether Atr knockdown creates known morphological changes associated with cilia dysfunction. We observed a higher frequency of pericardiac oedema, a feature often observed in zebrafish with impaired cilia ([Supplementary Material, Fig. S2A--C](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)) ([@DDW034C44],[@DDW034C45]). Additionally, embryos depleted for functional Atr developed an increased body curvature ([Supplementary Material, Fig. S2D--F](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)), a further feature conferred by cilia dysfunction ([@DDW034C46]). Collectively, these findings show that depletion of Atr or inhibition of Atr activity in zebrafish causes a marked impact on the development of anterior or neural structures, similar to the phenotype observed in humans. Additionally, Atr-depleted zebrafish show some morphological features typical of cilia dysfunction. Atr depletion causes left-right patterning defects in zebrafish {#s2f} --------------------------------------------------------------- To gain further insight into the consequence of Atr depletion in zebrafish, we next examined aspects of left-right patterning, which are frequently abnormal when cilia are dysfunctional. First, we assessed the expression pattern of *southpaw* (*spaw*), a nodal-related gene, which is expressed selectively in the left lateral plate mesoderm ([@DDW034C47]). When cilia function is impaired, *spaw* expression becomes randomized resulting in embryos that display right-sided or ambiguous expression (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}A). Although both uninjected and control-injected wild-type embryos predominantly expressed *spaw* on the left side, we counted a significant number of embryos with an aberrant *spaw* expression domain following Atr depletion using the translation blocking MO (Atr MO) (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}A and B) and the splice blocking MO (Atr splMO) ([Supplementary Material, Fig. S3B](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)). Rescue experiments showed further that the kinase activity of ATR is required to mediate proper cilia function as co-injection of wild-type *ATR* mRNA could partially rescue the lateralization defect in contrast to RNA encoding kinase-dead *Atr* ([Supplementary Material, Fig. S3A](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)). Finally, inhibition of Atr activity also randomized the expression of this laterality gene (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}C). Figure 5.Loss of Atr impairs cilia function in zebrafish. (**A**) WMISH of 22 ss embryos illustrating *southpaw* (*spaw*) expression in the left lateral plate mesoderm (left panel). Ambiguous (middle panel) or right-sided expression (right panel) indicates aberrant left-right asymmetry. Scale bar: 200 µm. (**B**) Percentage of embryos with left-sided (L), right-sided (R), ambiguous (B) or no *spaw* expression upon Atr MO. *n*= 93--125 embryos; four experiments. *P* \< 0.0001. (**C**) Chemical inhibition of Atr (ATRi-1) randomizes *spaw* expression. *n* = 124--197 embryos; six experiments. *P* \< 0.0001. (**D**) Representative images of WMISH for *cardiac myosin light chain 2* (*cmlc2*) showing heart looping in 48 hpf embryos. Left panel, a correctly looped heart (D-loop); middle panel, a heart with no looping (no loop); right panel, an inversely looped heart (L-loop). A, atrium; V, ventricle. Scale bar: 100 µm. (**E**) Atr depletion impedes heart looping (48 hpf). Stacked bar graph displaying the percentage of embryos with a properly looped heart (D), an unlooped heart (N) or an inversely looped heart (L). *n* = 94--108; four experiments. *P* \< 0.0001. (**F**) ATRi-1 inhibitor treatment randomizes cardiac looping similar to that observed in knockdown embryos. *n* = 106--243; seven experiments. *P* = 0.009. (**G**) WMISH for *insulin* (*ins*) labelling of pancreatic cells to assess abdominal situs development. Left panel, a dorsal view of a control. The *ins* expression domain is right of the midline (dashed line). Right panel, pancreas located left of the midline. Embryos were 48 hpf. Scale bar: 200 µm. (**H**) Stacked bar graph summarizing correct (R) or wrong-sided (L) expression of *ins* in injected embryos. *n* = 94--105 embryos; four experiments. *P* = 0.001. (**I**) Aberrant pancreas placement after Atr depletion (48 hpf). *n* = 118--245 embryos; seven experiments. *P* = 0.008. (**J**) Flat mounts of four and eight ss embryos after WMISH for *Atr*. Note the stronger staining and higher *Atr* expression in the tailbud region, where the KV forms. Anterior to the left. Scale bars: 150 µm (four ss) and 200 µm (eight ss). (**K**) KV-specific Atr knockdown randomizes cardiac looping. Stacked bar graph of embryos processed for *cmlc2* WMISH. *n* = 66--67 embryos; three experiments. *P* \< 0.0001. Significance was assessed using Fisher\'s exact test. Next, we analysed heart looping after Atr depletion. Under normal conditions, zebrafish hearts undergo looping to allow the ventricle to lie left from the atrium (D-loop). Inversely looped hearts (L-loop) or hearts that fail to loop (N-loops) are commonly associated with disturbed cilia formation or function. We thus used whole-mount *in situ* hybridization (WMISH) against *cardiac myosin light chain 2* (*cmlc2*) (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}D) to visualize heart loops after Atr depletion (Atr MO and Atr splMO, respectively) or inhibition (ATRi-1). Similar to the results obtained for *spaw*, we observed a reduction of correctly looped hearts (D-loops) at the gain of irregularly looping hearts when embryos lacked functional Atr, either via Atr depletion or Atr inhibition (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}E and F and [Supplementary Material, Fig. S3C](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)). Finally, we assessed pancreas localization through WMISH for *insulin* (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}G). This analysis demonstrated that embryos lacking functional Atr following depletion or kinase inhibition also experienced randomization of other abdominal organs as the pancreas was often located on the wrong side of the embryo (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}H and I and [Supplementary Material, Fig. S3D](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)). These assays raise the possibility that Atr functions directly on or in cilia. We hypothesized that depletion of Atr specifically within the ciliated KV cells would lead to randomization of asymmetry development as the KV functions as a temporal left-right organizer. Consistent with this, we observed that *atr* mRNA is expressed in the tailbud region of zebrafish embryos at a time and position where the KV is found (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}J). Injection of Atr MO at the 1k cell stage to target the MO to the KV effectively interfered with normal heart looping (Fig. [5](#DDW034F5){ref-type="fig"}K). Collectively, these results reveal an important function of Atr in cilia biology. ATR is required for SMO localization in cilia {#s2g} --------------------------------------------- The findings mentioned earlier provide strong evidence that ATR deficiency has a small impact on cilia length, but a strong impact on cilia signalling and function during development. Finally, we aimed to gain insight into how ATR affects cilia function. To examine steps during Shh signalling, we used SAG, a direct agonist of SMO. When cells are treated with SAG, SMO accumulates in the cilium ([@DDW034C48],[@DDW034C49]). As ATR depletion did not dramatically impact upon cilia formation, we examined whether it affected SMO accumulation in cilia in the presence of SAG. At 72 h after serum starvation without SAG, we observed that ∼80% of the control fibroblasts formed cilia (Fig. [6](#DDW034F6){ref-type="fig"}A) with SMO localized in a diffuse pan nuclear manner (Fig. [6](#DDW034F6){ref-type="fig"}B). Addition of SAG for the final 24 h resulted in SMO concentration at the cilia, with ∼50% of the control cells showing co-localized acetylated tubulin and SMO (Fig. [6](#DDW034F6){ref-type="fig"}C). PCNT fibroblasts formed cilia at a level similar to control cells, but co-localization of SMO and acetylated tubulin was reduced and/or abnormal (Fig. [6](#DDW034F6){ref-type="fig"}A--D). Strikingly, ATR-SS cells showed almost no localization of SMO at the cilia either with or without SAG (Fig. [6](#DDW034F6){ref-type="fig"}E). Additionally, we observed that a subset of ATR-SS cells showed disordered staining and localization of acetyl tubulin following SAG addition (Fig. [6](#DDW034F6){ref-type="fig"}B). In summary, although SMO localized at the cilia in PCNT cells, it was frequently abnormal; in contrast, ATR-SS cells showed almost no SMO localization at the cilia, suggesting that Shh signalling depends on ATR-mediated translocation of SMO to the cilium. To substantiate a causal relationship, we verified that the defect in SMO localization could be complemented by *ATR* cDNA. Following transfection of ATR-SS cells with *ATR* cDNA, we observed substantial recovery of SMO localization to cilia (Fig. [6](#DDW034F6){ref-type="fig"}E). The partial recovery is likely due to the fact that only ∼50% of the hTERT immortalized fibroblasts undergo transfection. Nonetheless, the substantial recovery strongly argues that the defect is caused by defective ATR. Figure 6.ATR-SS cells show defects in SMO recruitment to cilia and GLI1 transcript activation. Patient-derived hTERT fibroblasts were serum-depleted for 48 h. SAG was then added for 24 h. (**A**) Under this prolonged condition of serum starvation (72 h), cilia form normally in all cell lines. (**B**) In control cells, in the absence of SAG, SMO localized diffusely and not specifically at cilia. In the presence of SAG, strong uniform SMO staining is observed along the cilia length (detected using acetylated tubulin). (**C**) The percentage of cells with co-localized cilia and SMO with or without SAG treatment. (**D**) The percentage of ciliated cells with abnormally localized SMO with or without SAG treatment. (**E**) SMO localization at cilia in ATR-SS cells can be restored following expression of ATR cDNA but not kinase dead ATR cDNA (KD). Results represent the mean ± SD of three experiments. WT and PCNT data are part of the data set previously published in Stiff *et al.* ([@DDW034C16]). ATR impact on SMO localization is replication-independent {#s2h} --------------------------------------------------------- Finally, we exploited the dependency of SMO localization in cilia on ATR to gain insight into whether ATR\'s role in cilia signalling is a downstream consequence of its role in promoting replication fork recovery or whether it can be uncoupled from ATR\'s canonical function during replication. To achieve this, we exploited another ATR-specific small molecular inhibitor that we have found works efficiently in human cells (data not shown) (ATRi:VE) to examine whether ATR\'s kinase activity is required for SMO localization in cilia and whether ATR\'s function necessitates ATR activity during replication. Two protocols were assessed (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}A). In the first, cells were allowed to enter G0 phase by serum starvation for 48 h in the presence of ATRi:VE and then SAG was added for 24 h (maintaining ATRi:VE addition) prior to the analysis of SMO localization (termed long-term ATRi:VE). In the second protocol (termed short-term ATRi:VE), cells were serum-starved for 48 h and then ATRi:VE and SAG added for 24 h prior to the analysis of SMO localization. In the first protocol, the completion of replication and entry into G0 phase occurred under the condition of ATR inhibition; in the second protocol, ATR was only inhibited during cilia formation once a non-replicating state had been reached. In control cells (CTRL), SAG addition resulted in ∼45% of the cilia showing SMO localization (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}B). Addition of ATRi:VE during cell cycle exit and SAG addition (ATRi-VE long time) reduced the percentage of cilia with SMO localization to ∼2% (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}B). Significantly, addition of ATRi:VE after cell cycle exit (ATRi-VE short time) also resulted in a marked defect in cilia with co-localized SMO (∼10%) (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}B). Although this is slightly higher than when ATRi:VE was added throughout the period, the findings nonetheless provide strong evidence that ATR inhibition after cells have exited the cell cycle can markedly reduce SMO localization, strongly suggesting that ATR\'s function is distinct to its direct impact on replication. To consolidate this, we also added ATRi:VE for 2 days during the cycling period; then upon serum withdrawal and during subsequent SAG addition, ATRi:VE was removed (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}A). Normal localization of SMO was observed (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}B). Figure 7.Deficiency in TOPBP1 but not inhibition of CHK1, PLK1 or Aurora A also causes defective cilia signalling. (**A**) Diagram showing the timing of ATRi:VE addition, serum withdrawal and SAG addition. (**B**) Control cells were treated with an ATR inhibitor (ATRi:VE) concurrent with serum deprivation for 72 h (long time) or deprived of serum for 48 h and ATRi:VE added for 24 h (short time). In both cases, SAG was added for the final 24 h. The percentage of cells with SMO localized at cilia was scored. Control cells were similarly treated with inhibitors against CHK1 (UCN01), Aurora A (AurAi) or PLK1 (Plk1i), concurrent with serum deprivation. For ATRi:VE when cycling, cells were treated for 48 h with the ATRi:VE before it was washed out and cells deprived of serum for 72 h as before, with SAG being added for the final 24 h. The results represent the mean ± SD of three experiments. Note that analysis of cells without SAG was not undertaken for the inhibitor experiments, as we had routinely observed that the absence of SAG led to very low numbers of cells with SMO localized at the cilia. (**C**) 1BR3 hTERT cells were treated with oligonucleotides directed against non-specific control sequences (C), ATR (siATR) or TOPBP1 (siTOPBP1). SAG was added for the final 24 h, and the percentage of cells with SMO localized at the cilia was scored as in (B). To further examine the requirement for additional factors during ATR-dependent cilia signalling, we examined the role of CHK1, which plays a critical role in ATR-dependent responses at the replication fork. In marked contrast to the addition of ATRi, addition of a CHK1 inhibitor (CHK1i) using the long-term protocol (i.e. from the point of serum starvation to analysis) did not affect SMO localization (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}B). Our previous analysis has shown that such treatment dramatically impairs other ATR-dependent endpoints such as G2/M checkpoint arrest ([@DDW034C50]). As ATR has a role at the centrosome via directly or indirectly phosphorylating Aurora A kinase or Polo kinase I (PLK1), we also added inhibitors for these two kinases (AurAi or Plki) using the long-term protocol (at the start of serum starvation) and observed normal SMO localization in the presence of SAG (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}B) ([@DDW034C51],[@DDW034C52]). Thus, ATR function in cilia signalling does not operate via any regulation of Aurora A kinase or PLK1 kinase activities. A recent study has shown that ATR can be activated at the nuclear envelope by mechanical stress in a manner independent of DNA damage and RPA, the single-strand DNA binding protein required for ATR activation during replication ([@DDW034C53],[@DDW034C54]). To test whether RPA is required for SMO localization, we depleted RPA by siRNA knockdown of the RPA-70 subunit in hTERT cells approaching confluency. This procedure allowed efficient knockdown of RPA in G0 phase cells without causing significant cell death. Interestingly, G0 phase cells had reduced RPA levels when compared with cycling cells, but RPA-70 siRNA resulted in a further reduction in RPA levels ([Supplementary Material, Fig. S4A](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)). SMO localization occurred normally in these cells, consolidating the notion that ATR\'s role in cilia function can be uncoupled from its function during replication ([Supplementary Material, Fig. S4B](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1)). Finally, ATR signalling is known to require TOPBP1, which enhances ATR activation ([@DDW034C55]). Thus, we asked whether cilia signalling also requires TOPBP1. Strikingly, and in contrast to CHK1 inhibition, *TOPBP1* siRNA conferred a defect in SMO localization similar to that observed in *ATR* siRNA cells (Fig. [7](#DDW034F7){ref-type="fig"}C). Collectively, these findings provide strong evidence that the role of ATR in cilia signalling is not a downstream consequence of its role in replication fork stability. Indeed, ATR inhibition after cell cycle exit has a marked impact on SMO localization. Further, CHK1, a transducer kinase for ATR DNA damage signalling, which is required for ATR\'s role in S phase, is dispensable for cilia signalling. RPA similarly appears to be dispensable for ATR\'s role in cilia signalling. In marked contrast, TOPBP1, which facilitates ATR activation, is required for SMO recruitment to cilia, consistent with the requirement for ATR kinase activity. Discussion {#s3} ========== ATR has a canonical function in the DDR with an essential role in promoting recovery from stalled/collapsed replication forks. Mutations in *ATR* have been identified in a subclass of SS patients, with microcephaly and severe growth delay being the pronounced phenotypes. These clinical manifestations have been attributed to the canonical function of ATR in regulating the DDR during replication ([@DDW034C2],[@DDW034C6]). Although this is a plausible model, other disorders with associated microcephaly and growth delay have mutations in genes required for centrosome function rather than for the DDR/replication ([@DDW034C7]). Provocatively, we previously reported that ATR-SS cells have supernumerary centrosomes. Previous studies have demonstrated a link between abnormal centrosome numbers and cilia dysfunction ([@DDW034C13],[@DDW034C15],[@DDW034C27]). These findings prompted us to examine whether ATR might also be required for cilia signalling. Here, we provide strong evidence that depletion or inhibition of ATR in human cells results in a subtle defect in cilia length and a more pronounced defect in cilia signalling, including Shh signalling. We demonstrate that this role of ATR is conserved in zebrafish and use this model organism to probe for a functional impact. Strikingly, zebrafish depleted for Atr display typical defects in morphology and lateralization determination, similar to that found following depletion of several other factors required for cilia formation or signalling. Collectively, these findings provide strong evidence that ATR is required for efficient cilia function during development. Significantly, ATR deficiency in patients confers marked microcephaly, reflecting a role for ATR during neuronal embryogenesis, and additional abnormalities in growth and skeletogenesis ([@DDW034C2],[@DDW034C56]). The link between centrosomal function and MPD disorders has been previously highlighted ([@DDW034C11],[@DDW034C12]). Many proteins with centrosomal functions are causal for MPD disorders ([@DDW034C7]). Of these disorders, MOPD-II and MGS also have aberrant cilia signalling. Further, a recent study also showed that mutations in *MRE11*, *ZNF423* and *CEP164*, genes which encode proteins that function within the DDR, can cause nephronophthisis, providing another link between DDR signalling and ciliopathies ([@DDW034C57]). Recent patients with mutations in *MRE11* have also been reported to have microcephaly ([@DDW034C58]). Additionally, chondrogenesis involves cilia-dependent signalling ([@DDW034C59]), and ATR-SS patients and mouse models of impaired Atr function have skeletal abnormalities ([@DDW034C6]). Interestingly, one subclass of Jeune asphyxiating thoracic dystrophy patients with the same missense mutation in CEP120, a centriolar protein, have a range of skeletal abnormalities ([@DDW034C60]). The patient cells display centriole abnormalities and reduced cilia formation. For ATR deficiency, it could be the role in cilia signalling rather than, or in addition to, its canonical function in DDR signalling that confers the clinical manifestation. Importantly, embryonic neuronal development involves Shh signalling ([@DDW034C24]--[@DDW034C26]). A marked phenotype of impaired cilia function in zebrafish is a left-right patterning defect. Strikingly, this phenotype is also observed following depletion of Atr in zebrafish, in which we detected asymmetry defects at different stages and in different organs. These phenotypes, however, have not been described as marked features of the ATR-deficient patients described to date. Furthermore, although PCNT and ORC1 deficiency also confer significant defects in cilia signalling, ATR-SS, MOPD-II nor MGS patients show the commonly described manifestations of defective ciliogenesis (e.g. renal cystic disease). However, the mutations in all of these patients are hypomorphic as *ATR*, *PCNT* and *ORC1* are essential and in each case the mutations must allow sufficient residual protein function to enable embryogenesis and patient viability. Further, ciliopathies are clinically heterogeneous and cilia dysfunction manifests in distinct ways. In this context, we note that ATR-, PCNT- and ORC1-deficient patients display skeletal abnormalities, and there is mounting evidence that cilia function during skeletogenesis, and at least one ATR-SS patient, has been described with multiple liver cysts indicative of Caroli\'s disease ([@DDW034C56]). Furthermore, we note that ATR deficiency was recently reported to cause retinal photoreceptor degeneration in mice, a process linked to cilia dysfunction ([@DDW034C61]). A role in cilia function represents a novel role for ATR. Further, we provide evidence that this is distinct to ATR\'s canonical role in recovery from replication fork stalling as diminished cilia signalling is observed when ATR is inhibited after the cessation of replication and as the process is not dependent on CHK1, an essential protein required for recovery from replication fork stalling. Our findings, moreover, cannot readily be attributed to any changes in growth rate. However, ATR\'s role in cilia signalling does require its kinase activity as well as TOPBP1, a protein that promotes ATR\'s ability to phosphorylate its substrates. Although it is difficult to entirely separate ATR\'s role as a DDR protein from its function in cilia signalling, the latter function does not necessitate treatment with exogenous DNA-damaging agents. However, whether DNA damage arises during cilia formation is unknown. Our study, therefore, raises the question of the basis underlying the role of ATR in cilia signalling. Although centrosomes are required for ciliogenesis, the cilia defect need not be a direct consequence of impaired centrosome function but may reflect dual roles for the proteins ([@DDW034C27]). Nonetheless, ATR does have a function at the centrosome, where it can regulate the phosphorylation of the kinases, PLK1 and Aurora A, albeit in a damage-dependent manner ([@DDW034C51],[@DDW034C52],[@DDW034C62]). We tentatively propose, therefore, that ATR can be activated in a manner that does not require exogenous DNA damage or replication-dependent damage at either the centrosome or the cilia. In this context, a significant recent study showed that ATR could be activated at the nuclear envelope by forces such as mechanical stretching ([@DDW034C53]). Indeed, the findings strongly suggested that signals from the cell membrane could be transmitted to the nuclear membrane. The formation of cilia is likely to impose such a force, providing a route to activate ATR. ATR has multiple substrates that could impact upon cilia signalling. However, further studies are required to untangle the precise mechanism. In summary, we demonstrate a novel function for ATR in cilia-dependent signalling in both human cells and zebrafish. Our findings provocatively raise the possibility that ATR-SS may represent a ciliopathy disorder and that impaired cilia function may contribute to their clinical manifestation. Materials and Methods {#s4} ===================== Cell culture {#s4a} ------------ hTERT-immortalized fibroblasts were control (1BR3hTERT), ATR (FO2-98hTERT), ATM (AT1BRhTERT) and PCNT (ASBhTERT). siRNA was carried out using the appropriate Smartpool (Dharmacon, Lafayette, CO, USA) and Metafectene Transfection Reagent (Biontex, Munich, Germany). The ATR inhibitor, VE-821 (Selleckchem/Stratech, Newmarket, UK), was used at 10 µ[m]{.smallcaps}. The Aurora A kinase inhibitor, MLN8237 (Selleckchem/Stratech), was used at 0.5 µ[m]{.smallcaps}. The Polo-like kinase 1 inhibitor, BI2536 (Axon Medchem, Groningen, The Netherlands), was used at 100 n[m]{.smallcaps}. The Chk1 inhibitor, UCN-01 (Merck, Kenilworth, NJ, USA), was used at 600 n[m]{.smallcaps}. Zebrafish manipulation {#s4b} ---------------------- Zebrafish eggs were collected from natural matings and were allowed to develop up to the desired stages at 28.5°C. For knockdown studies, fertilized eggs were injected in the yolk at the 1--2 cell stage or the 1000 cell stage to target dorsal forerunner cells. Antisense MOs used were the standard control MO and a translation blocking MO for Atr, which had been described before ([@DDW034C41]). In addition, MOs targeting the boundary of intron 2 and exon 3 (Atr splMO: 5′-CAGAGCAACTACAATGTGATAGAGA) and a corresponding 5 bp mismatch control MO (splCTRL MO: CAcAcCAAgTACAATcTcATAGAGA) were used. All MOs were purchased from Gene Tools Inc. (Philomath). Rescue experiments were performed by co-injection of capped RNA encoding human ATR and a kinase dead version of human ATR (p.D2494E), respectively (plasmids were a gift from Dr A.M. Carr). Capped RNA was prepared with the T7 mMessage mMachine Kit (Ambion) using linearized plasmids. Drug treatment with either dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO) (Sigma-Aldrich, St Louis, MO, USA) or the ATR Kinase Inhibitor III (CAS 1345675-02-7 Calbiochem/EMD Millipore, Watford, UK) was performed in egg water from tailbud stage on. All procedures on zebrafish adhered to current law and were approved by the local authority in Ulm, Germany. Splice blocking efficiency test (RT--PCR) {#s4c} ----------------------------------------- Splice blocking efficiency was tested using RT--PCR on RNA prepared from 24 h post fertilization (hpf) embryos with primers spanning over exon 3: Atr Fw: 5′-GGTTGAGTACAACCAGGCAGT; Atr Rev: 5′-AACAGGCTAAACACGACTGGA. This produces a 378 bp fragment under control conditions. When splicing is blocked and exon 3 is deleted, a PCR product of 225 bp is expected. To control for loading, a PCR for β-actin was performed with the following primers: β-actin Fw: 5′-GACATCAAGGAGAAGCTGTGC; β-actin Rev: 5′-CACTTCCTGTGAACGATGGAT. IF analysis {#s4d} ----------- Cells grown on cover slips were fixed with 3% formaldehyde for 7 min and then with ice cold 70% MeOH for 1 min and permeabilized in 0.5% Triton X-100. For BrdU staining, DNA was denatured in 2 N HCl for 30 min. After antibody treatment and staining with 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole, cover slips were mounted in Vectashield mounting medium (Vector Laboratories, Burlingame, CA, USA). Samples were incubated with primary antibodies for BrdU (BU20A), CenPF, PCNT, phospho-H3 (Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz, CA, USA), γ-tubulin, acetylated tubulin (Sigma, St Louis, MO, USA), phospho-Rb (Cell Signaling, Beverley, MA, USA) and Smoothened (Abcam, Cambridge, UK). Secondary antibodies were from Sigma. Fibroblasts were grown to 70--80% confluency followed by serum starvation in MEM containing 0.1% fetal calf serum (FCS) for 2--3 days to promote entry into G0. Cells were processed for IF as mentioned earlier and cilia visualized with anti-acetylated tubulin and γ-tubulin antibodies. Shh pathway assay {#s4e} ----------------- Fibroblasts were serum-starved for 2--3 days in MEM containing 0.1% FCS. An aliquot of 1 µ[m]{.smallcaps} SAG (Smoothened Agonist, Calbiochem, Billerica, MA, USA) was added for a further 24 h. Cells were processed for IF as above. Cilia or the basal body was identified by antibodies against acetylated tubulin and γ-tubulin and then Smoothened staining at the cilium was assessed. Cilia function assay {#s4f} -------------------- Fibroblasts were serum-starved for 2--3 days in MEM containing 0.1% FCS. Then MEM with FCS or with 50 ng/ml PDGF-AA, PDGF-AB or PDGF-BB (Sigma) was added. S phase cells were identified by labelling with 10 µ[m]{.smallcaps} BrdU (Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) and processed for IF as mentioned earlier. siRNA knockdown {#s4g} --------------- The protocol for siRNA-mediated knockdown of PCNT and ATR was as described previously ([@DDW034C8],[@DDW034C63]). These references include an analysis of knockdown efficiency using an identical procedure, and a similar level of knockdown was obtained in this study. RPA knockdown of RPA-70 was achieved using an RNAi SMARTpool from Dharmacon. Knockdown efficiency for RPA-70 was assessed by western blot using mouse-anti-RPA (Calbiochem cat. no. NA13) and mouse-anti-β-actin (Abcam cat. no. Ab40864). qPCR analysis {#s4h} ------------- qRT--PCR for Smoothened and Gli1 analysis was carried out using the QuantiFast SYBR Green PCR Kit (Qiagen, Venlo, The Netherlands). SDHA was used for internal normalization, and the *Pfaffl* analysis method was applied*.* The primer sets used were Qiagen Quantitect primers for SMO and SDHA (QT00050701 and QT00059486) and for GLI1: (F) CCAGCCAGAGAGACCAACA and (R) ATCCGACAGAGGTGAGATGG. In brief, reactions containing 12.5 µl SYBR Green PCR Master Mix (Qiagen), 2.5 µl 10× Primer assay mix, 5 µl RNAse-free water and 5 µl template cDNA to a final volume of 25 µl were prepared in duplicate. Cycling was carried out using the Stratagene Mx3005P QPCR System. Cycling conditions were: 95°C for 5 min, followed by 40 cycles of 95°C for 10 s and 60°C for 30 s. Reactions were then heated to 95°C for 1 min and incubated at 55°C for 30 s. qPCR analysis of zebrafish was performed as described previously ([@DDW034C45]) using the Absolute qPCR ROX Mix (Thermo Scientific, UK) and the Roche Universal Probe System (Roche Applied Science, Mannheim, Germany) in a Lightcycler 480 instrument (Roche). All levels were normalized to *beta-2-microglobulin* (*b2m*) (GenBank no. BC062841.1). The following primers and probes (UP) were used: *gli1* Fw: 5′-GGTCTCGATGCCAGTGGA, *gli1* Rev: 5′-CACTGACGGAGCCAGTCC, UP no. 5; *puma* Fw: 5′-CGAGATGAACGCTGTCTTCC, *puma* Rev: 5′-CCTCTCCAGTTCTGCCAGTG, UP no. 6; *p21* Fw: 5′-AAGCGCAAACAGACCAACAT, *p21* Rev: 5′-TCAGCTACTGGCCGGATTT, UP no. 142; *b2m* Fw: 5′-ACATCACTGTACAGGGGAAAGTC, *b2m* Rev: 5′-TCCGTTCTTCAGCAGTTCAA, UP no. 65. Centrosome analysis {#s4i} ------------------- Cycling fibroblasts were processed for IF as mentioned earlier and centrosomes visualized with anti-γ-tubulin and PCNT antibodies. Microscopy {#s4j} ---------- Living zebrafish and those processed by WMISH were imaged using a Leica M125 upright microscope equipped with a Leica IC80 HD camera. KVs and cilia were assessed by confocal microscopy with a Leica TCS SP5II confocal microscope. Cilia length in *z*-stacks was measured with the help of ImageJ ([@DDW034C64]). WMISH {#s4k} ----- WMISH was performed according to standard protocols ([@DDW034C65]). The DIG-labelled probes for *cmlc2*, *ins* and *spaw* have been described before ([@DDW034C45]). The probe for *atr* was generated by *in vitro* transcription from a linearized plasmid containing a 1001 bp fragment of the Atr coding sequence (GenBank no. XM_691071). IF analysis for zebrafish work {#s4l} ------------------------------ IF analysis was as described earlier. Zebrafish cilia were labelled according to the protocol of Jaffe *et al*. ([@DDW034C66]) using a mouse-anti-acetylated tubulin antibody (1:500, clone 6-11B-1, Sigma-Aldrich) and an Alexa 488-labelled secondary antibody. KV outlines were visualized through immunostaining with an antibody against atypical PKC (1:500, clone C-20, Santa Cruz Biotechnologies). Statistical analysis {#s4m} -------------------- All statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism 6. When three conditions were analysed, a one-way analysis of variance with a Bonferroni post-test was applied. Analyses including only two experimental conditions (i.e. DMSO versus Atri) were scrutinized with one- or two-tailed Student\'s *t*-tests. Stacked bar graphs were tested for statistical significance using a Fisher\'s exact test. Supplementary Material {#s5} ====================== [Supplementary Material is available at *HMG* online.](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1) Authors' Contribution {#s6} ===================== T.S., M.P., M.O.\'D. and P.A.J. conceived the study. T.S., T.C.T. and M.P. did the laboratory work. M.P., M.O.\'D. and P.A.J. wrote the manuscript. Funding {#s7} ======= All data are provided in full in the results section of this paper or in the [supplementary material](http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1093/hmg/ddw034/-/DC1). The PAJ laboratory was supported by Medical Research Council Grants (G000050 and G0500897) for this work. The M.O.\'D. laboratory is supported by the Cancer Research UK and the Medical Research Council. The M.P. laboratory is supported by grants from the German Research Foundation (DFG, PH 144-1) and the Boehringer Ingelheim Ulm University BioCenter. T.C.T. is a fellow of the International Graduate School in Molecular Medicine at Ulm University. Funding to pay the Open Access publication charges for this article was provided by the Medical Research Council, grant numbers, G000050 and G0500897. Supplementary Material ====================== ###### Supplementary Data We thank Sabrina Matysik and Sandra Burczyk for excellent fish care. *Conflict of Interest statement.* The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest. [^1]: The authors wish it to be known that, in their opinion, the first two authors should be regarded as joint First Authors.

Scientific Reports 5: Article number: 1354510.1038/srep13545; published online: 08272015; updated: 02092016 In the Supplementary Information file originally published with this Article, parameter k6 was omitted from Table 2. This error has been corrected in the Supplementary Information that now accompanies the Article. In addition, the model source codes were omitted. There was also an error in Fig. 1, where reaction 'k5' now reads '2\*k5'. The correct [Fig. 1](#f1){ref-type="fig"} appears below. These errors have now been corrected in both the PDF and HTML versions of the Article. {#f1}

\section{Introduction} \setcounter{equation}{0} The discovery of the Lax pairs \cite{PDL} for nonlinear evolutionary equations and the inverse scattering transform (IST) method for solving initial-value problems on the whole line, which is one of the most important developments in the study of nonlinear systems, pioneered at 1967 by Kruskal et al \cite{CSG} in researching the Korteweg-de Vries equation, turn out to be very successful. After decades of development, Fokas \cite{F1,F2} has developed a new powerful approach in 1997 which generalizes the IST formalism from initial-value to initial-boundary value (IBV) problems such that the soliton theory achieves an important development. This approach combines the main insights of the IST with elements of the theory of Riemann--Hilbert problems, and uses essentially complex analytic properties to eliminate unknown boundary values from the solution representation. Since then there have been a wide range of explorations on the analysis of boundary value problems for several of the most important integrable equations with $2\times2$ Lax pairs, such as the modified Korteweg-de Vries equation \cite{AB}, the nonlinear Schr\"oinger (NLS) equation \cite{F3}, the derivative Schr\"odinger equation \cite{JLe}. In this paper, we use the general method for solving the IBV problem announced in \cite{F1,F2} to study the Kundu--Eckhaus (KE) equation \cite{AK}, which contains quintic nonlinearity and the Raman effect in nonlinear optics \begin{equation}\label{1.1} \text{i} u_t+u_{xx}-2|u|^2u+4\beta^2|u|^4u+4\text{i}\beta(|u|^2)_xu=0,~~\beta\in{\Bbb R}\setminus\{0\}. \end{equation} on the half-line, where $u(x,t)$ is the complex smooth envelop function. $\beta$ is a real constant, $\beta^2$ is the quintic nonlinear coefficient, and the last term represents the Raman effect, which is responsible for the self-frequency shift. For equation \eqref{1.1}, a series of important results have been obtained, such as the gauge connections between equation \eqref{1.1} and other soliton equations \cite{AK}, the Lax pair and the Hamiltonian structure \cite{GXG}, the higher-order rogue wave solutions\cite{WX}, and soliton solutions through the Darboux transformation \cite{DQ}. It is noted that the Riemann--Hilbert (RH) problem and long-time asymptotics for equation \eqref{1.1} with decaying initial value on the line was studied in \cite{ZQZ}, which motivates our present analysis. Our purpose here is to consider the IBV problem for the KE equation \eqref{1.1} via the Fokas method on the half-line, that is, in the domain $$\Omega=\{0<x<\infty,~0<t<T\}$$ and $T\leq\infty$ is a given positive constant. We will denote the initial data, Dirichlet and Neumann boundary values of \eqref{1.1} as follows: \begin{eqnarray} u(x,0)=u_0(x),~u(0,t)=g_0(t),~u_x(0,t)=g_1(t). \end{eqnarray} Assuming that the solution $u(x,t)$ exists, we show that it can be represented in terms of the solution of a matrix RH problem formulated in the plane of the complex spectral parameter $k$, with jump matrices given in terms of spectral functions $a(k)$, $b(k)$ (obtained from the initial data $u(x,0)=u_0(x)$) and $A(k)$, $B(k)$ (obtained from the boundary values $u(0,t)=g_0(t)$ and $u_x(0,t)=g_1(t)$). An important advantage of this representation obtained is that it yields precise information about the long-time asymptotics of the solution by using the nonlinearization of the steepest descent method. The nonlinear steepest descent method was first introduced by Deift and Zhou in \cite{PD}, which was inspired by earlier works of Manakov and Its. The method has since then proved successful in determining asymptotic formulas for a large range of other initial-value problems for various integrable equations \cite{AB1,AB2,AB3,PD1,RB,XJ,HL,ZQZ}. By combining the ideas of \cite{PD} with the unified transform formalism of \cite{F1}, it is also possible to study asymptotics of solutions of IBV problems for nonlinear integrable PDEs \cite{JL1,JL2}. Developing and extending the methods using in \cite{JL1,JL2}, we will further derive the long-time asymptotics of the solution $u(x,t)$ on the half-line by performing a nonlinear steepest descent analysis of the associated RH problem. Compared with the analysis of the initial problem considered in \cite{ZQZ}, the half-line problem is more involved. For example, the relevant RH problem for the Cauchy problem \eqref{1.1} only has a jump across ${\Bbb R}$, whereas the RH problem for the IBV problem also has jump across $\text{i}{\Bbb R}$, and the jump across this line involves the spectral function $\Gamma(k)$. Moreover, during the asymptotic analysis, one should find an analytic approximation $\Gamma_a(t,k)$ of $\Gamma(k)$ and deform the contour to eliminate the part of the jump that involves $\Gamma_a(t,k)$. The outline of the paper is following. In Section 2, we study the direct spectral problem formulated in terms of the simultaneous spectral analysis of the associated Lax pair: we define appropriate eigenfunctions and spectral functions and study their properties. We formulate the main RH problem in Section 3 and show that $u(x,t)$ can be expressed in terms of the solution of this $2\times2$ matrix RH problem. In section 4, we present the detailed derivation of the long-time asymptotics for the solution of KE equation. \section{Spectral theory} \setcounter{equation}{0} \setcounter{lemma}{0} \setcounter{theorem}{0} \subsection{The Lax pair} Let \be\label{2.1} \sigma_3={\left( \begin{array}{cc} 1 & 0 \\[4pt] 0 & -1\\ \end{array} \right )},\quad Q(x,t)={\left( \begin{array}{cc} 0 & u(x,t) \\[4pt] \bar{u}(x,t) & 0 \\ \end{array} \right )}. \ee The KE equation \eqref{1.1} is the condition of compatibility of \cite{WX} \begin{equation}\label{2.2} \begin{aligned} &\phi_x+\text{i} k\sigma_3\phi=Q_1\phi,\\ &\phi_t+2\text{i} k^2\sigma_3\phi=Q_2\phi,\\ \end{aligned} \end{equation} where $\phi(x,t;k)$ is a $2\times2$ matrix-valued function and $k\in{\Bbb C}$ is the spectral parameter, \begin{eqnarray} Q_1&=&Q-\text{i}\beta Q^2\sigma_3={\left( \begin{array}{cc} -\text{i}\beta|u|^2 & u \\[4pt] \bar{u} & \text{i}\beta|u|^2\\ \end{array} \right )},\label{2.3}\\ Q_2&=&4\text{i}\beta^2Q^4\sigma_3-2\beta Q^3-\text{i} Q^2\sigma_3+2kQ-\text{i} Q_x\sigma_3+\beta(Q_xQ-QQ_x)\\ &=&{\left( \begin{array}{cc} 4\text{i}\beta^2|u|^4-\text{i}|u|^2+\beta(u_x\bar{u}-u\bar{u}_x) & 2ku-2\beta |u|^2u+\text{i} u_x\\[4pt] 2k\bar{u}-2\beta |u|^2\bar{u}-\text{i}\bar{u}_x & -4\text{i}\beta^2|u|^4+\text{i}|u|^2-\beta(u_x\bar{u}-u\bar{u}_x) \nonumber\\ \end{array} \right )}.\label{2.4} \end{eqnarray} Starting with this Lax pair and following steps similar to the ones used in \cite{JLe}, we find that in order to have a function satisfying, within its region of boundedness, \be \mu=I+O\bigg(\frac{1}{k}\bigg),\quad k\rightarrow\infty,\label{2.5} \ee we introduce a new eigenfunction $\mu(x,t;k)$ by \begin{equation}\label{2.6} \phi(x,t;k)=\text{e}^{\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta\sigma_3}\mu(x,t;k)\text{e}^{\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(\infty,0)}\Delta\sigma_3}\text{e}^{-\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\sigma_3}, \end{equation} where $\Delta$ is the closed real-valued one-form \be\label{2.7} \Delta(x,t)=-\beta|u|^2\text{d} x+\bigg(4\beta^2|u|^4-\text{i}\beta(u_x\bar{u}-u\bar{u}_x)\bigg)\text{d} t. \ee Then we obtain the equivalent Lax pair \begin{equation}\label{2.8} \begin{aligned} &\mu_x+\text{i} k[\sigma_3,\mu]=U_1\mu,\\ &\mu_t+2\text{i} k^2[\sigma_3,\mu]=U_2\mu,\\ \end{aligned} \end{equation} where the matrices $U_1$ and $U_2$ are defined respectively by \begin{eqnarray} U_1&=&\begin{pmatrix} 0 & u\text{e}^{-2\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta}\\[4pt] \bar{u}\text{e}^{2\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta} & 0 \end{pmatrix},\label{2.9}\\ U_2&=&\begin{pmatrix} -\text{i}|u|^2 & \big(2ku+\text{i} u_x-2\beta|u|^2u\big)\text{e}^{-2\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta}\\[4pt] \big(2k\bar{u}-\text{i}\bar{u}_x-2\beta|u|^2\bar{u}\big)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta} & \text{i}|u|^2 \end{pmatrix}.\label{2.10} \end{eqnarray} Equations \eqref{2.8} can be written in differential form as \be\label{2.11} \text{d}\big(\text{e}^{\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\hat{\sigma}_3}\mu(x,t;k)\big)=w(x,t;k), \ee where \be\label{2.12} w(x,t;k)=\text{e}^{\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\hat{\sigma}_3}\big(U_1(x,t)\text{d} x+U_2(x,t;k)\text{d} t\big)\mu(x,t;k), \ee and $\hat{\sigma}_3$ denote the operator which act on a $2\times2$ matrix $X$ by $\hat{\sigma}_3X=[\sigma_3,X]$, then $\text{e}^{\hat{\sigma}_3}X=\text{e}^{\sigma_3} X\text{e}^{-\sigma_3}$. \subsection{Bounded and analytic eigenfunctions} Let equation \eqref{1.1} be valid for the half-line domain $\Omega=\{0<x<\infty,0<t<T\}$. Assume that $u(x,t)$ is sufficiently smooth functions of $(x,t)$ in the half-line domain $\Omega$ which decay as $x\rightarrow\infty$. \begin{figure}[htbp] \begin{minipage}[t]{0.3\linewidth} \centering \includegraphics[width=2.15in]{RH1-eps-converted-to.pdf} \label{fig:side:a} \end{minipage}% \begin{minipage}[t]{0.3\linewidth} \centering \includegraphics[width=2.15in]{RH2-eps-converted-to.pdf} \label{fig:side:b} \end{minipage} \begin{minipage}[t]{0.3\linewidth} \centering \includegraphics[width=2.15in]{RH3-eps-converted-to.pdf} \label{fig:side:c} \end{minipage} \caption{The contours $\gamma_1$, $\gamma_2$ and $\gamma_3$ in the $(x,t)$-plane.}\label{fig1} \end{figure} Three eigenfunctions $\{\mu_j\}_1^3$ of equation \eqref{2.11} are defined by the following Volterra integral equations \be\label{2.13} \mu_j(x,t;k)=I+\int_{\gamma_j}\text{e}^{-\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\hat{\sigma}_3}w_j(x',t';k),~j=1,2,3, \ee where $w_j$ is given by \eqref{2.12} with $\mu$ replaced with $\mu_j$, and the contours $\{\gamma_j\}^3_1$ denote the smooth curves from $(x_j,t_j)$ to $(x,t)$, and $(x_1,t_1)=(0,T)$, $(x_2,t_2)=(0,0)$, $(x_3,t_3)=(\infty,t)$. Since the one-form $w$ is exact, the integral on the right-hand side of equation \eqref{2.13} is independent of the path of integration. We choose the particular contours shown in Fig. \ref{fig1}. This choice implies the following inequalities on the contours: \begin{eqnarray}\label{2.14} &&\gamma_1:~x'-x\leq0,\quad t'-t\geq0,\nonumber\\ &&\gamma_2:~x'-x\leq0,\quad t'-t\leq0,\\ &&\gamma_3:~x'-x\geq0.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} The second column of the matrix equation \eqref{2.13} involve the exponential $\text{e}^{2\text{i}[k(x'-x)+2k^2(t'-t)]}$. Using the above inequalities it follows that this exponential is bounded in the following regions of the complex $k$-plane: \begin{eqnarray}\label{2.15} &&\mu_1:\{\text{Im}k\leq0\cap\text{Im}k^2\geq0\},\nonumber\\ &&\mu_2:\{\text{Im}k\leq0\cap\text{Im}k^2\leq0\},\\ &&\mu_3:\{\text{Im}k\geq0\}.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} These boundedness properties imply that $[\mu_1]_2$, $[\mu_2]_2$, and $[\mu_3]_2$ are bounded and analytic for $k\in D_3, D_4$ and ${\Bbb C}_+$, respectively. Similar conditions are valid for the first column vectors. Thus, the functions $\{\mu_j\}^3_1$ are bounded and analytical for $k\in{\Bbb C}$ while $k$ belongs to \begin{eqnarray}\label{2.16} &&\mu_1:~(D_2,D_3),\nonumber\\ &&\mu_2:~(D_1,D_4),\\ &&\mu_3:~({\Bbb C}_-,{\Bbb C}_+),\nonumber \end{eqnarray} where $D_n$ denotes $n$th quadrant, $1\leq n\leq4$, ${\Bbb C}_+$ and ${\Bbb C}_-$ denote the upper and lower half complex $k$-plane, respectively. In fact, for $x=0$, $\mu_1(0,t;k)$ has enlarged the domain of boundedness: $(D_2\cup D_4,D_1\cup D_3)$, $\mu_2(0,t;k)$ have enlarged the domain of boundedness: $(D_1\cup D_3,D_2\cup D_4)$, and $\mu_2(x,0;k)$ have enlarged the domain of boundedness: $(D_1\cup D_2,D_3\cup D_4)$. We also note that the functions $\mu_1(x,t;k)$ ($T<\infty$) and $\mu_2(x,t;k)$ are entire functions of $k$. Moreover, in their corresponding regions of boundedness, $$\mu_j(x,t;k)=I+O\bigg(\frac{1}{k}\bigg),\quad k\rightarrow\infty,\quad j=1,2,3.$$ \subsection{Spectral functions} Any two solutions $\mu$ and $\tilde{\mu}$ of \eqref{2.11} are related by an equation of the form \be\label{1} \mu(x,t;k)=\tilde{\mu}(x,t;k)\text{e}^{-\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\hat{\sigma}_3}C_0(k), \ee where $C_0(k)$ is a $2\times2$ matrix independent of $x$ and $t$. Indeed, let $\phi$ and $\tilde{\phi}$ be the solutions of equation \eqref{2.2} corresponding to $\mu$ and $\tilde{\mu}$ according to \eqref{2.6}. Then, since the first and second columns of a solution of \eqref{2.2} satisfy the same equation, there exists a $2\times2$ matrix $C_1(k)$ independent of $x$ and $t$ such that \berr \phi(x,t;k)=\tilde{\phi}(x,t;k)C_1(k). \eerr It follows that \eqref{1} is satisfies with $C_0(k)=\text{e}^{-\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(\infty,0)}\Delta\hat{\sigma}_3}C_1(k)$. We define $s(k)$ and $S(k)$ by the relations \begin{eqnarray} &&\mu_3(x,t;k)=\mu_2(x,t;k)\text{e}^{-\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\hat{\sigma}_3}s(k),\label{2.17}\\ &&\mu_1(x,t;k)=\mu_2(x,t;k)\text{e}^{-\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\hat{\sigma}_3}S(k).\label{2.18} \end{eqnarray} Evaluation of \eqref{2.17} and \eqref{2.18} at $(x,t)=(0,0)$ and $(x,t)=(0,T)$ gives the following expressions \be\label{2.19} s(k)=\mu_3(0,0;k),~S(k)=\mu_1(0,0;k)= \bigg(\text{e}^{2\text{i} k^2T\hat{\sigma}_3}\mu_2(0,T;k)\bigg)^{-1}. \ee Hence, the functions $s(k)$ and $S(k)$ can be obtained respectively from the evaluations at $x=0$ and at $t=T$ of the functions $\mu_3(x,0;k)$ and $\mu_2(0,t;k)$, which satisfy the linear integral equations \begin{eqnarray} \mu_3(x,0;k)&=&I-\int_x^\infty\text{e}^{\text{i} k(x'-x)\hat{\sigma_3}}(U_1\mu_3)(x',0;k)\text{d} x',\label{2.20}\\ \mu_2(0,t;k)&=&I+\int_0^t\text{e}^{2\text{i} k^2(t'-t)\hat{\sigma_3}}(U_2\mu_2)(0,t';k)\text{d} t'.\label{2.21} \end{eqnarray} By evaluating \eqref{2.9} and \eqref{2.10} at $t=0$ and $x=0$, respectively, we find that \begin{eqnarray} U_1(x,0;k)&=&\begin{pmatrix} 0 & u_0\text{e}^{2\beta\text{i}\int_0^x|u_0|^2\text{d} x'}\\[4pt] \bar{u}_0\text{e}^{-2\beta\text{i}\int_0^x|u_0|^2\text{d} x'} & 0 \end{pmatrix},\label{2.22}\\ U_2(0,t;k)&=&\begin{pmatrix} -\text{i}|g_0|^2 & \big(2kg_0+\text{i} g_1-2\beta|g_0|^2g_0\big)\text{e}^{-2\text{i}\int_{0}^{t}\Delta_2(0,t')\text{d} t'}\\[4pt] \big(2k\bar{g}_0-\text{i}\bar{g}_1-2\beta|g_0|^2\bar{g}_0\big)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\int_{0}^{t}\Delta_2(0,t')\text{d} t'} & \text{i}|g_0|^2 \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ &&\Delta_2(0,t)=4\beta^2|g_0|^4-\text{i}\beta(g_1\bar{g}_0-g_0\bar{g}_1).\label{2.23} \end{eqnarray} Furthermore, the fact that $U_1$ and $U_2$ are traceless together with $\mu_j=I+O(\frac{1}{k})$ imply that $\det\mu_j=1$. Thus, we have \be\label{2.24} \det s(k)=\det S(k)=1. \ee \subsection{The symmetry properties} \begin{proposition}\label{pro2.1} For $j=1,2,3$, the function $\mu_j(x,t;k)$ satisfies the following symmetry relations \be\label{2.25} \mu_{11}(x,t;k)=\overline{\mu_{22}(x,t;\bar{k})},~~ \mu_{21}(x,t;k)=\overline{\mu_{12}(x,t;\bar{k})}. \ee \end{proposition} \begin{proof} For~a~$2\times2$~matrix~A, we define a operator $T$ as follows: $$TA=\begin{pmatrix} \bar{a}_{22} & \bar{a}_{21}\\[4pt] \bar{a}_{12} & \bar{a}_{11}\\ \end{pmatrix},~\mbox{where}~A=\begin{pmatrix} a_{11} & a_{12}\\[4pt] a_{21} & a_{22}\\ \end{pmatrix}.$$ Equation \eqref{2.25} is a consequence of the symmetries $(TU_j)(\bar{k})=U_j(k)$ valid for $j=1,2$. \end{proof} Particularly, it follows from \eqref{2.25} that the spectral matrices $s(k)$ and $S(k)$ can be written as \be\label{2.26} s(k)=\begin{pmatrix} \overline{a(\bar{k})} & b(k)\\[4pt] \overline{b(\bar{k})} & a(k)\\ \end{pmatrix},\quad S(k)=\begin{pmatrix} \overline{A(\bar{k})} & B(k)\\[4pt] \overline{B(\bar{k})} & A(k)\\ \end{pmatrix}. \ee \subsection{The global relation} The initial and boundary values of a solution of the KE equation are not independent. However, it turns out that the spectral functions $s(k)$ and $S(k)$ can be determined by the initial datum and boundary values, respectively. Thus, the spectral functions must satisfy a surprisingly simple relation. Indeed, it follows from \eqref{2.17} and \eqref{2.18} that \be\label{2.27} \mu_1(x,t;k)\text{e}^{-\text{i}(k x+2k^2t)\hat{\sigma}_3}(S^{-1}(k)s(k))=\mu_3(x,t;k). \ee Since $\mu_1(0,T;k)=I$, evaluation at $(0,T)$ yields the following relation: \be\label{2.28} -I+S^{-1}(k)s(k)+\text{e}^{2\text{i} k^2T\hat{\sigma}_3}\int_0^\infty \text{e}^{\text{i} k x'\hat{\sigma}_3}(U_1\mu_3)(x',T;k)\text{d} x'=0. \ee The (12) component of this equation is \be\label{2.29} B(k)a(k)-A(k)b(k)=\text{e}^{4\text{i} k^2T}c^+(k),~\mbox{Im}k\geq0, \ee for $T<\infty$, where $$c^+(k)=\int_0^\infty\text{e}^{2\text{i} k x'}(U_1\mu_3)_{12}(x',T;k)\text{d} x'$$ is a function analytic for Im$k>0$ which is $O(\frac{1}{k})$ as $k\rightarrow\infty$. In the case $T=\infty$, the global relation \eqref{2.29} reads \be\label{2.30} B(k)a(k)-A(k)b(k)=0,~k\in D_1. \ee \subsection{The properties of spectral functions} Let $[A]_1$ ($[A]_2$) be denoted as the first (second) column of a $2\times2$ matrix $A$. Given $u_0(x)\in \mathcal{S}([0,\infty))$, we define the map \berr \mathcal{J}:\{u_0(x)\}\mapsto\{a(k),b(k)\} \eerr by \be\label{2.31} \begin{pmatrix} b(k)\\[4pt] a(k)\\\end{pmatrix}=[\mu_3(0;k)]_2,\quad \mbox{Im}k\geq0, \ee where $$\mu_3(x;k)=I-\int_x^\infty\text{e}^{\text{i} k(x'-x)\hat{\sigma}_3}\big(U_1(x',0;k)\mu_3(x';k)\big)\text{d} x',$$ $U_1(x,0;k)$ is given in terms of $u_0(x)$ by \eqref{2.22}. The analysis of the Volterra linear integral equation gives the following properties of $a(k)$ and $b(k)$. (i) $a(k)$ and $b(k)$ are analytic for Im$k>0$, continuous, and bounded for Im$k\geq0$; (ii) $a(k)=1+O(\frac{1}{k})$, $b(k)=O(\frac{-\frac{\text{i}}{2}u_0(0)}{k})$, as $k\rightarrow\infty$; (iii) $a(k)\overline{a(\bar{k})}-b(k)\overline{b(\bar{k})}=1$; (iv) The map $\mathcal{K}:\{a(k),b(k)\}\mapsto \{u_0(x)\}$, inverse to $\mathcal{J}$, is defined as follows: \be\label{2.32} u_0(x)=2\text{i} m(x)\text{e}^{-8\beta\text{i}\int_0^x|m(x')|^2\text{d} x'},\quad m(x)=\lim_{k\rightarrow\infty}(k M^{(x)}(x;k))_{12}, \ee where $M^{(x)}(x;k)$ is the unique solution of the matrix RH problem: $\bullet$ $ M^{(x)}(x;k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &M^{(x)}_+(x;k),\quad k\in{\Bbb C}_+,\\ &M^{(x)}_-(x;k),\quad k\in{\Bbb C}_-, \end{aligned} \right. $ is a sectionally meromorphic function; $\bullet$ $M^{(x)}(x;k)$ satisfies the jump condition \be\label{2.33} M^{(x)}_+(x;k)=M^{(x)}_-(x;k)J^{(x)}(x,k),~~k\in{\Bbb R}, \ee where \be\label{2.34} J^{(x)}(x,k)=\begin{pmatrix} \frac{1}{a(k)\overline{a(\bar{k})}} ~& \frac{b(k)}{\overline{a(\bar{k})}}\text{e}^{-2\text{i} k x} \\[4pt] -\frac{\overline{b(\bar{k})}}{a(k)}\text{e}^{2\text{i} k x} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix}; \ee $\bullet$ $M^{(x)}(x;k)=I+O(\frac{1}{k}),~k\rightarrow\infty$; $\bullet$ We assume that $a(k)$ has $n$ simple zeros $\{k_j\}_{1}^{n}$ in ${\Bbb C}_+$. The associated residues of $M^{(x)}(x;k)$ satisfy the relations \begin{eqnarray} {Res}_{k=k_j}[M^{(x)}(x;k)]_1&=&\frac{e^{2\text{i} k_jx}}{\dot{a}(k_j)b(k_j)} [M^{(x)}(x;k_j)]_2;\label{2.35}\\ {Res}_{k=\bar{k}_j}[M^{(x)}(x;k)]_2&=&\frac{e^{-2\text{i}\bar{k}_jx}} {\overline{\dot{a}(k_j)b(k_j)}}[M^{(x)}(x;\bar{k}_j)]_1;\label{2.36} \end{eqnarray} (v) $\mathcal{J}^{-1}=\mathcal{K}$. We refer to the appendix of \cite{JLe} for a derivation of (iv) and (v) in the similar case of the derivative NLS equation. Let $g_0(t),g_1(t)$ be smooth functions, we define the map \berr \mathcal{\tilde{J}}:\{g_0(t),g_1(t)\}\mapsto \{A(k),B(k)\} \eerr as follows \be\label{2.37} \begin{pmatrix} B(k)\\ A(k)\\\end{pmatrix}=[\mu_1(0;k)]_2,\quad \mbox{Im}k^2\geq0, \ee where $$\mu_1(t;k)=I+\int^t_T\text{e}^{2\text{i} k^2(t'-t)\hat{\sigma}_3} \big(U_2(0,t';k)\mu_1(t';k)\big)\text{d} t'$$ with $U_2(0,t;k)$ is determined by \eqref{2.23}. The spectral function $A(k)$ and $B(k)$ have the following properties: (i) $A(k)$ and $B(k)$ are entire function and bounded for $k\in\bar{D}_1\cup \bar{D}_3$; if $T=\infty$, $A(k)$ and $B(k)$ are defined only in $\bar{D}_1\cup \bar{D}_3$. (ii) $A(k)=1+O(\frac{1}{k})$, $B(k)=O(\frac{-\frac{\text{i}}{2}g_0(0)}{k})$, $k\rightarrow\infty$; (iii) $A(k)\overline{A(\bar{k})}-B(k)\overline{B(\bar{k})}=1$; (iv) The map $\mathcal{\tilde{K}}:\{A(k),B(k)\}\mapsto \{g_0(t),g_1(t)\}$, inverse to $\mathcal{\tilde{J}}$, is defined as follows: \begin{eqnarray}\label{2.38} \begin{aligned} g_0(t)&=2\text{i} (M^{(t)}_1)_{12}(t)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\int_0^t\Delta_2(t')\text{d} t'},\\ g_1(t)&=4(M^{(t)}_2)_{12}(t)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\int_0^t\Delta_2(t')\text{d} t'}+2\text{i} g_0(t)\bigg((M^{(t)}_1)_{22}(t)-\beta|g_0(t)|^2\bigg), \end{aligned} \end{eqnarray} where \berr \Delta_2(t)=16\beta\bigg(|(M^{(t)}_1)_{12}|^2\text{Re}(M^{(t)}_1)_{22}-\text{Re}\big[(M^{(t)}_1)_{12}(\bar{M}^{(t)}_2)_{12}\big]\bigg), \eerr and \begin{eqnarray} M^{(t)}(t;k)&=&I+\frac{M^{(t)}_1(t)}{k}+\frac{M^{(t)}_2(t)}{k^2} +O(\frac{1}{k^3}),~k\rightarrow\infty\nonumber \end{eqnarray} with $M^{(t)}(t;k)$ is the unique solution of the matrix RH problem: $\bullet$ $ M^{(t)}(t;k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &M^{(t)}_+(t;k),\quad k\in D_1\cup D_3,\\ &M^{(t)}_-(t;k),\quad k\in D_2\cup D_4, \end{aligned} \right. $ is a sectionally meromorphic function; $\bullet$ $M^{(t)}(t;k)$ satisfies the jump condition \be\label{2.39} M^{(t)}_+(t;k)=M^{(t)}_-(t;k)J^{(t)}(t,k),~~\mbox{Im}k^2=0, \ee where \be\label{2.40} J^{(t)}(t,k)=\begin{pmatrix} \frac{1}{A(k)\overline{A(\bar{k})}} ~& \frac{B(k)}{\overline{A(\bar{k})}}\text{e}^{-4\text{i} k^2t} \\[4pt] -\frac{\overline{B(\bar{k})}}{A(k)}\text{e}^{4\text{i} k^2t} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix}; \ee $\bullet$ $M^{(t)}(t,k)=I+O(\frac{1}{k}),~k\rightarrow\infty$; $\bullet$ We assume that $A(k)$ has $N$ simple zeros $\{z_j\}_{1}^{N}$ in $D_1\cup D_3$. The associated residues of $M^{(t)}(t;k)$ are given by \begin{eqnarray} {Res}_{k=z_j}[M^{(t)}(t;k)]_1&=&\frac{e^{4\text{i} z_j^2t}}{\dot{A}(z_j)B(z_j)} [M^{(t)}(t;z_j)]_2;\\ {Res}_{k=\bar{z}_j}[M^{(t)}(t;k)]_2&=&\frac{e^{-4\text{i}\bar{z}_j^2t}} {\overline{\dot{A}(z_j)B(z_j)}}[M^{(t)}(t;\bar{z}_j)]_1; \end{eqnarray} (v) $\mathcal{\tilde{J}}^{-1}=\mathcal{\tilde{K}}$. \section{The Riemann--Hilbert problem} \setcounter{equation}{0} \setcounter{lemma}{0} \setcounter{theorem}{0} Equations \eqref{2.17} and \eqref{2.18} can be rewritten in a form expressing the jump condition of a $2\times2$ RH problem. By solving this RH problem, the solution of KE equations \eqref{1.1} can be recovered. In fact, by using \eqref{2.17} and \eqref{2.18} and the definitions of the spectral functions \eqref{2.26}, we find \be\label{3.1} M_+(x,t;k)=M_-(x,t;k)J(x,t,k),\quad \mbox{Im}k^2=0, \ee where the matrices $M_-,M_+$ and $J$ are defined by \begin{eqnarray}\label{3.2} M(x,t;k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\bigg(\frac{[\mu_2]_1}{a(k)}~[\mu_3]_2\bigg),\quad k\in D_1,\\ &\bigg(\frac{[\mu_1]_1}{d(k)}~[\mu_3]_2\bigg),\quad k\in D_2,\\ &\bigg([\mu_3]_1~\frac{[\mu_1]_2}{\overline{d(\bar{k})}}\bigg),\quad k\in D_3,\\ &\bigg([\mu_3]_1~\frac{[\mu_2]_2}{\overline{a(\bar{k})}}\bigg),\quad k\in D_4, \end{aligned} \right. \end{eqnarray} where \be\label{3.3} d(k)=a(k)\overline{A(\bar{k})}-b(k)\overline{B(\bar{k})},\quad k\in \bar{D}_2, \ee and \begin{eqnarray}\label{3.4} &&J_1(x,t,k)=\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0\\[4pt] \Gamma(k)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\theta(k)} & 1 \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ &&J_4(x,t,k)=\begin{pmatrix} 1-r_1(k)\overline{r_1(\bar{k})} ~& \overline{r_1(\bar{k})}\text{e}^{-2\text{i}\theta(k)} \\[4pt] -r_1(k)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\theta(k)} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix},\\ &&J_3(x,t,k)=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\overline{\Gamma(\bar{k})}\text{e}^{-2\text{i}\theta(k)}\\[4pt] 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ &&J_2(x,t,k)=(J_1J_4^{-1}J_3)(x,t,k)=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\overline{r(\bar{k})}\text{e}^{-2\text{i}\theta(k)}\\[4pt] r(k)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\theta(k)} ~& 1-r(k)\overline{r(\bar{k})} \\ \end{pmatrix},\nonumber \end{eqnarray} \be\label{3.5} r_1(k)=\frac{\overline{b(\bar{k})}}{a(k)},\quad\Gamma(k)=-\frac{\overline{B(\bar{k}})}{a(k)d(k)},\quad r(k)=r_1(k)+\Gamma(k),\quad\theta(k)=k x+2k^2t. \ee The contour for this RH problem is depicted in Fig. 2. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=4in]{KE1-eps-converted-to.pdf} \caption{The contour for the RH problem.} \end{figure} The matrix function $M(x,t;k)$ defined by \eqref{3.2} is, in general, a sectionally meromorphic function of $k$, with possible poles at the zeros of $a(k)$, $d(k)$ and at the complex conjugates of these zeros. We have assumed that $\bullet$ $a(k)$ can have $n=n_1+n_2$ simple zeros in $\{k\in{\Bbb C}|\mbox{Im}k>0\}$: $k_j\in D_1$, $j=1,\cdots,n_1$, $k_j\in D_2$, $j=n_1+1,\cdots,n$. $\bullet$ $d(k)$ can have $\Lambda$ simple zeros: $\{\lambda_j\}_1^\Lambda\in D_2$; $\bullet$ none of the zeros of $a(k)$ in $D_2$ coincide with a zero of $d(k)$; $\bullet$ none of these functions has zeros on ${\Bbb R}\cup\text{i}{\Bbb R}$.\\ The associated residue formulaes are the following: \begin{eqnarray}\label{3.6} \begin{aligned} {Res}_{k=k_j}[M(x,t;k)]_1&=\frac{e^{2\text{i}\theta(k_j)}}{\dot{a}(k_j)b(k_j)} [M(x,t;k_j)]_2,~j=1,\cdots,n_1;\\ {Res}_{k=\bar{k}_j}[M(x,t;k)]_2&=\frac{e^{-2\text{i}\theta(\bar{k}_j)}} {\overline{\dot{a}(k_j)b(k_j)}}[M(x,t;\bar{k}_j)]_1,~j=1,\cdots,n_1; \end{aligned} \end{eqnarray} and \begin{eqnarray}\label{3.7} \begin{aligned} {Res}_{k=\lambda_j}[M(x,t;k)]_1&=\frac{\overline{B(\bar{\lambda}_j)} e^{2\text{i}\theta(\lambda_j)}}{\dot{d}(\lambda_j)a(\lambda_j)}[M(x,t;\lambda_j)]_2,~j=1,\cdots,\Lambda;\\ {Res}_{k=\bar{\lambda}_j}[M(x,t;k)]_2&=\frac{B(\bar{\lambda}_j)e^{-2\text{i}\theta(\bar{\lambda}_j)}} {\overline{\dot{d}(\lambda_j)a(\lambda_j)}}[M(x,t;\bar{\lambda}_j)]_1,~j=1,\cdots,\Lambda; \end{aligned} \end{eqnarray} where $\theta(k_j)=k_jx+2k_j^2t$. The main result on the inverse spectral problem is the following. \begin{theorem}\label{th3.1} Let $u_0(x)\in \mathcal{S}([0,\infty))$, here $\mathcal{S}([0,\infty))$ is the space of Schwartz function on $[0,\infty)$, suppose that $u_0(x)$ is compatible with smooth functions $g_0(t)$ and $g_1(t)$ at $x=t=0$. The spectral functions $s(k)$ and $S(k)$ defined by \eqref{2.19} satisfy the global relation \eqref{2.29} for $T<\infty$ with $c^+(k)$ is analytic in $\{k\in{\Bbb C}|\mbox{Im}k>0\}$ and \eqref{2.30} for $T=\infty$ (in this case, it is assumed that $g_0(t), g_1(t)$ belong to $\mathcal{S}([0,\infty))$). The assumption of the possible zeros for $a(k)$ and $d(k)$ are as stated above. Let $M(x,t;k)$ as the solution of the following matrix RH problem: $\bullet$ $M(x,t;k)$ is sectionally meromorphic in ${\Bbb C}\setminus\{\mbox{Im}k^2=0\}$, $\bullet$ $M(x,t;k)$ satisfies the jump condition \eqref{3.1} with the jump matrices in \eqref{3.4}, $\bullet$ $M(x,t;k)$ has the following asymptotics: \be\label{3.8} M(x,t;k)=I+O\bigg(\frac{1}{k}\bigg),~k\rightarrow\infty, \ee $\bullet$ The associated residues of $M(x,t;k)$ satisfy the relations in \eqref{3.6}-\eqref{3.7}. Then $M(x,t;k)$ exists and is unique and $u(x,t)$ is defined by \begin{eqnarray}\label{3.9} u(x,t)&=&2\text{i} m(x,t)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta},\nonumber\\ m(x,t)&=&\lim_{k\rightarrow\infty}(k M(x,t;k))_{12},\\ \Delta(x,t)&=&-4\beta|m|^2\text{d} x+4\text{i}\beta(m\bar{m}_x-m_x\bar{m})\text{d} t,\nonumber \end{eqnarray} satisfies the KE equation \eqref{1.1}. Furthermore, $u(x,t)$ satisfies the initial and boundary conditions \berr u(x,0)=u_0(x),~u(0,t)=g_0(t),~u_x(0,t)=g_1(t). \eerr \end{theorem} \begin{proof} In the case when $a(k)$ and $d(k)$ have no zeros, the unique solvability is a consequence of an appropriate vanishing lemma as in the case of the NLS equation \cite{F3}. If $a(k)$ and $d(k)$ have zeros, this singular RH problem can be mapped to a regular one coupled with a system of algebraic equations \cite{FoI}. Moreover, it follows from standard arguments using the dressing method \cite{VEZ1,VEZ2} that if $M$ solves the above RH problem and $u(x,t)$ is defined by \eqref{3.9}, then $u(x,t)$ solves the KE equation \eqref{1.1}. The proof that $u(x,0)=u_0(x),~u(0,t)=g_0(t)$ and $u_{x}(0,t)=g_1(t)$ follows arguments similar to the ones used in \cite{JLe}. \end{proof} \section{Long-time asymptotics} \setcounter{equation}{0} \setcounter{lemma}{0} \setcounter{theorem}{0} In this section, we aim to derive the long-time asymptotics of the solution $u(x,t)$ of KE equation \eqref{1.1} on the half-line based on a nonlinear steepest descent analysis of the associated RH problem established in Section 3. Now we fix $T=\infty$, that is, we are concerned with the IBV problem for equation \eqref{1.1} posed in the quarter-plane domain $$\{(x,t)\in{\Bbb R}^2|x\geq0,t\geq0\}.$$ Furthermore, we make the following assumptions. \begin{assumption}\label{ass1} In what follows, we assume that the following conditions hold: $\bullet$ the initial and boundary values lie in the Schwartz class. $\bullet$ the spectral functions $a(k), b(k), A(k), B(k)$ defined in \eqref{2.26} satisfy the global relation \eqref{2.30}. $\bullet$ $a(k)$ and $d(k)$ have no zeros in $\bar{D}_1\cup \bar{D}_2$ and $\bar{D}_2$, respectively. $\bullet$ the initial and boundary values $u_0(x), g_0(t)$, and $g_1(t)$ are compatible with equation \eqref{1.1} to all orders at $x=t=0$, i.e., they satisfy \begin{eqnarray} g_0(0)&=&u_0(0),\quad g_1(0)=u_0'(0),\quad \nonumber\\ \text{i} g'_0(0)+u_{0}''(0)-2|u_0(0)|^2u_0(0)&+&4\beta^2|u_0(0)|^4u_0(0)+4\text{i}\beta(|u_0(0)|^2)_xu_0(0)=0,\cdots.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} \end{assumption} Let $\xi=\frac{x}{t}$, $\Sigma={\Bbb R}\cup\text{i}{\Bbb R}$ and introduce a new phase function $\Phi(\xi,k)=4\text{i} k^2+2\text{i}\xi k$. Then we can rewrite the RH problem \eqref{3.1} as \begin{eqnarray}\label{4.1} M_+(x,t;k)=M_-(x,t;k)J(x,t,k),\quad k\in\Sigma \end{eqnarray} with the jump matrix $J(x,t,k)$ is given by \be\label{4.2} J(x,t,k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0\\[4pt] \Gamma(k)\text{e}^{t\Phi(\xi,k)} & 1 \end{pmatrix},\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad~ k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\overline{r(\bar{k})}\text{e}^{-t\Phi(\xi,k)}\\[4pt] r(k)\text{e}^{t\Phi(\xi,k)} ~& 1-r(k)\overline{r(\bar{k})} \\ \end{pmatrix},\quad~ k\in{\Bbb R}_-,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\overline{\Gamma(\bar{k})}\text{e}^{-t\Phi(\xi,k)}\\[4pt] 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix},\qquad\qquad\quad~ k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_-,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1-r_1(k)\overline{r_1(\bar{k})} ~& \overline{r_1(\bar{k})}\text{e}^{-t\Phi(\xi,k)} \\[4pt] -r_1(k)\text{e}^{t\Phi(\xi,k)} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix},~~ k\in{\Bbb R}_+, \end{aligned} \right. \ee where ${\Bbb R}_+=[0,\infty)$ and ${\Bbb R}_-=(-\infty,0]$ denote the positive and negative halves of the real axis. Functions $r_1(k),\Gamma(k), r(k)$ are defined by \begin{eqnarray}\label{4.3} r_1(k)&=&\frac{\overline{b(\bar{k})}}{a(k)},~~~~~\qquad k\in{\Bbb R},\nonumber\\ \Gamma(k)&=&-\frac{\overline{B(\bar{k}})}{a(k)d(k)},~~~k\in\bar{D}_2,\\ r(k)&=&r_1(k)+\Gamma(k),~k\in{\Bbb R}_-,\nonumber \end{eqnarray} and these functions admit the following properties from the discussion in Section 2: $\bullet$ $r_1(k)$ is smooth and bounded on ${\Bbb R}$; $\bullet$ $\Gamma(k)$ is smooth and bounded on $\bar{D}_2$ and analytic in $D_2$; $\bullet$ $r(k)$ is smooth and bounded on $(-\infty, 0]$ and $\sup_{k\in(-\infty, 0]}|r(k)|<1$; $\bullet$ There exist complex constants $\{\Gamma_j\}_{j=1}^\infty$ and $\{r_j\}_{j=1}^\infty$ such that, for any $N\geq1$, \begin{eqnarray} \Gamma(k)&=&\sum_{j=1}^N\frac{\Gamma_j}{k^j}+O\bigg(\frac{1}{k^{N+1}}\bigg),~~k\rightarrow\infty,~~k\in\bar{D}_2,\label{4.4}\\ r(k)&=&\sum_{j=1}^N\frac{r_j}{k^j}+O\bigg(\frac{1}{k^{N+1}}\bigg),~~|k|\rightarrow\infty,~~k\in{\Bbb R}_-.\label{4.5} \end{eqnarray} \begin{remark} We are in a position to prove $\sup_{k\in(-\infty, 0]}|r(k)|<1$. Recalling the definitions $s(k)$ and $S(k)$ in \eqref{2.26}, we have \berr S^{-1}(k)s(k)=\begin{pmatrix} \overline{d(\bar{k})} & c(k)\\[4pt] \overline{c(\bar{k})} & d(k) \end{pmatrix} \eerr with $c(k)=b(k)A(k)-a(k)B(k)$. However, $r(k)=r_1(k)+\Gamma(k)=\frac{\overline{c(\bar{k})}}{d(k)}$, hence, the result $\sup_{k\in(-\infty, 0]}|r(k)|<1$ is a consequence of $\det s(k)=\det S(k)=1$. \end{remark} \subsection{Transformations of the RH problem} By performing a number of transformations, we can bring the RH problem \eqref{4.1} to a form suitable for determining the long-time asymptotics. Let $N>1$ be given, and let $\mathcal{I}$ denote the interval $\mathcal{I}=(0,N]$. The jump matrix $J$ defined in \eqref{4.2} involves the exponentials $\text{e}^{\pm t\Phi}$, where $\Phi(\xi,k)$ is defined by $$\Phi(\xi,k)=4\text{i} k^2+2\text{i}\xi k,\quad \xi\in\mathcal{I},\quad k\in{\Bbb C}.$$ It follows that there is a single stationary point located at the point where $\frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial k}=0$, i.e., at $k=k_0=-\frac{\xi}{4}$. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=4in]{KE2-eps-converted-to.pdf} \caption{The contour $\Sigma^{(1)}$ in the complex $k$-plane.}\label{fig3} \end{figure} The first transformation is to deform the vertical part of $\Sigma$ so that it passes through the critical point $k_0$. Letting $V_1$ and $V_2$ denote the triangular domains shown in Fig. \ref{fig3}. The first transform is : \be\label{4.6} M^{(1)}(x,t;k)=M(x,t;k)\times\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0\\[4pt] \Gamma(k)\text{e}^{t\Phi(\xi,k)} & 1 \end{pmatrix},~~~~k\in V_1,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ \overline{\Gamma(\bar{k})}\text{e}^{-t\Phi(\xi,k)}\\[4pt] 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix},~~k\in V_2,\\ &I,\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad~~ \text{elsewhere}. \end{aligned} \right. \ee Then we obtain the RH problem \be\label{4.7} M^{(1)}_+(x,t;k)=M^{(1)}_-(x,t;k)J^{(1)}(x,t,k) \ee on the contour $\Sigma^{(1)}$ depicted in Fig. \ref{fig3}. The jump matrix $J^{(1)}(x,t,k)$ is given by \begin{eqnarray} J^{(1)}_1&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0\\[4pt] \Gamma\text{e}^{t\Phi} & 1 \end{pmatrix},\qquad J^{(1)}_2=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\bar{r}\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\[4pt] r\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1-r\bar{r} \\ \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ J^{(1)}_3&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\bar{\Gamma}\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\[4pt] 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}, J^{(1)}_4=\begin{pmatrix} 1-r_1\bar{r}_1 ~& \bar{r}_1\text{e}^{-t\Phi} \\[4pt] -r_1\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix},\nonumber \end{eqnarray} where $J^{(1)}_i$ denotes the restriction of $J^{(1)}$ to the contour labeled by $i$ in Fig. \ref{fig3}. The next transformation is: \be\label{4.8} M^{(2)}(x,t;k)=M^{(1)}(x,t;k)(x,t;k)\delta^{-\sigma_3}(\xi,k), \ee where the complex-valued function $\delta(\xi,k)$ is given by \be\label{4.9} \delta(\xi,k)=\exp\bigg\{\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{-\infty}^{k_0}\frac{\ln(1-|r(s)|^2)}{s-k}\text{d} s\bigg\},\quad k\in{\Bbb C}\setminus(-\infty,k_0]. \ee The function $\delta$ satisfies the following jump condition across the real axis: \berr \delta_+(\xi,k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\frac{\delta_-(\xi,k)}{1-|r(k)|^2},~~k<k_0,\\ &\delta_-(\xi,k),\qquad k>k_0. \end{aligned} \right. \eerr Moreover, $\delta(\xi,k)\rightarrow1$ as $k\rightarrow\infty$, $\delta(\xi,k)$ and $\delta^{-1}(\xi,k)$ are bounded and analytic functions of $k\in{\Bbb C}\setminus(-\infty,k_0]$ with continuous boundary values on $(-\infty,k_0]$. Then $M^{(2)}(x,t;k)$ satisfies the following RH problem \be\label{4.10} M^{(2)}_+(x,t;k)=M^{(2)}_-(x,t;k)J^{(2)}(x,t,k) \ee with the contour $\Sigma^{(2)}=\Sigma^{(1)}$ and the jump matrix $J^{(2)}=\delta_-^{\sigma_3}J^{(1)}\delta_+^{-\sigma_3}$, namely, \begin{eqnarray} J^{(2)}_1&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0\\[4pt] \Gamma\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} & 1 \end{pmatrix},\qquad J^{(2)}_2=\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& -r_2\delta_-^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi} \\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0 \\[4pt] \bar{r}_2\delta_+^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ J^{(2)}_3&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\bar{\Gamma}\delta^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\[4pt] 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}, J^{(2)}_4=\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& \bar{r}_1\delta^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi} \\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0 \\[4pt] -r_1\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix},\nonumber \end{eqnarray} where we define $r_2(k)$ by \be\label{4.11} r_2(k)=\frac{\overline{r(\bar{k})}}{1-r(k)\overline{r(\bar{k})}}. \ee Before processing the next deformation, we follow the idea of \cite{JL1,JL2} and decompose each of the functions $\Gamma$, $r_1$, $r_2$ into an analytic part and a small remainder because the spectral functions have limited domains of analyticity. The analytic part of the jump matrix will be deformed, whereas the small remainder will be left on the original contour. In face, we have the following lemmas. \begin{lemma}\label{lem1} There exist a decomposition \berr \Gamma(k)=\Gamma_a(t,k)+\Gamma_r(t,k),\quad t>0,~~k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+, \eerr where the functions $\Gamma_a$ and $\Gamma_r$ have the following properties: (1) For each $t>0$, $\Gamma_a(t,k)$ is defined and continuous for $k\in\bar{D}_1$ and analytic for $k\in D_1.$ (2) For each $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$ and each $t>0$, the function $\Gamma_a(t,k)$ satisfies \be\label{4.12} \begin{aligned} |\Gamma_a(t,k)-\Gamma(0)|&\leq C\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},\\ |\Gamma_a(t,k)|&\leq \frac{C}{1+|k|}\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|}, \end{aligned} \ee for $k\in\bar{D}_1$, where the constant $C$ is independent of $\xi, k, t$. (3) The $L^1, L^2$ and $L^\infty$ norms of the function $\Gamma_r(t,\cdot)$ on $\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+$ are $O(t^{-3/2})$ as $t\rightarrow\infty$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Since $\Gamma(k)\in C^5(\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+)$, then there exist complex constants $\{p_j\}_0^4$ such that \be\label{4.13} \Gamma^{(n)}(k)=\frac{\text{d}^n}{\text{d} k^n}\bigg(\sum_{j=0}^4p_jk^j\bigg)+O(k^{5-n}),\quad k\rightarrow0,~k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+,~n=0,1,2. \ee In fact, $p_j=\frac{\Gamma^{(j)}(0)}{j!}$ for $j=0,1,\ldots,4$. On the other hand, we have \be\label{4.14} \Gamma^{(n)}(k)=\frac{\text{d}^n}{\text{d} k^n}\bigg(\sum_{j=1}^3\Gamma_jk^{-j}\bigg)+O(k^{-4-n}),\quad k\rightarrow\infty,~k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+,~n=0,1,2. \ee Let \be\label{4.15} f_0(k)=\sum_{j=1}^8\frac{a_j}{(k+\text{i})^j}, \ee where $\{a_j\}_1^8$ are complex such that \be\label{4.16} f_0(k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\sum_{j=0}^4p_jk^j+O(k^5),\qquad ~k\rightarrow0,\\ &\sum_{j=1}^3\Gamma_jk^{-j}+O(k^{-4}),\quad k\rightarrow\infty. \end{aligned} \right. \ee It is easy to verify that \eqref{4.16} imposes eight linearly independent conditions on the $a_j$, hence the coefficients $a_j$ exist and are unique. Letting $f=\Gamma-f_0$, it follows that \\ (i) $f_0(k)$ is a rational function of $k\in{\Bbb C}$ with no poles in $\bar{D}_1$;\\ (ii) $f_0(k)$ coincides with $\Gamma(k)$ to four order at 0 and to third order at $\infty$, more precisely, \be\label{4.17} \frac{\text{d}^n}{\text{d} k^n}f(k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &O(k^{5-n}),~\quad k\rightarrow0,\\ &O(k^{-4-n}),~~ k\rightarrow\infty, \end{aligned} \quad k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+,~n=0,1,2. \right. \ee The decomposition of $\Gamma(k)$ can be derived as follows. The map $k\mapsto\psi=\psi(k)$ defined by $\psi(k)=4k^2$ is a bijection $[0,\text{i}\infty)\mapsto(-\infty,0]$, so we may define a function $F$ : ${\Bbb R}\rightarrow{\Bbb C}$ by \be\label{4.18} F(\psi)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &(k+\text{i})^2f(k),~\psi\leq0,\\ &0,~~\qquad\qquad~ \psi>0. \end{aligned} \right. \ee $F(\psi)$ is $C^5$ for $\psi\neq0$ and \berr F^{(n)}(\psi)=\bigg(\frac{1}{8k}\frac{\partial}{\partial k}\bigg)^n\bigg((k+\text{i})^2f(k)\bigg),~~\psi\leq0. \eerr By \eqref{4.17}, $F\in C^2({\Bbb R})$ and $F^{(n)}(\psi)=O(|\psi|^{-1-n})$ as $|\psi|\rightarrow\infty$ for $n=0,1,2$. In particular, \be\label{4.19} \bigg\|\frac{\text{d}^nF}{\text{d}\psi^n}\bigg\|_{L^2({\Bbb R})}<\infty,\quad n=0,1,2, \ee that is, $F$ belongs to $H^2({\Bbb R})$. By the Fourier transform $\hat{F}(s)$ defined by \be\label{4.20} \hat{F}(s)=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{\Bbb R} F(\psi)\text{e}^{-\text{i}\psi s}\text{d}\psi \ee where \be\label{4.21} F(\psi)=\int_{\Bbb R}\hat{F}(s)\text{e}^{\text{i}\psi s}\text{d} s, \ee it follows from Plancherel theorem that $\|s^2\hat{F}(s)\|_{L^2({\Bbb R})}<\infty$. Equations \eqref{4.18} and \eqref{4.21} imply \be f(k)=\frac{1}{(k+\text{i})^2}\int_{\Bbb R}\hat{F}(s)\text{e}^{\text{i}\psi s}\text{d} s,\quad k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+. \ee Writing $$f(k)=f_a(t,k)+f_r(t,k),\quad t>0,~k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+,$$ where the functions $f_a$ and $f_r$ are defined by \begin{eqnarray} f_a(t,k)&=&\frac{1}{(k+\text{i})^2}\int_{-\frac{t}{4}}^\infty\hat{F}(s)\text{e}^{4\text{i} k^2s}\text{d} s,\quad t>0,~k\in\bar{D}_1,\\ f_r(t,k)&=&\frac{1}{(k+\text{i})^2}\int^{-\frac{t}{4}}_{-\infty}\hat{F}(s)\text{e}^{4\text{i} k^2s}\text{d} s,\quad t>0,~k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+, \end{eqnarray} we infer that $f_a(t,\cdot)$ is continuous in $\bar{D}_1$ and analytic in $D_1$. Moreover, since $|\text{Re}4\text{i} k^2|\leq|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|$ for $k\in\bar{D}_1$ and $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$, we can get \begin{eqnarray}\label{4.25} |f_a(t,k)|&\leq&\frac{1}{|k+\text{i}|^2}\|\hat{F}(s)\|_{L^1({\Bbb R})}\sup_{s\geq-\frac{t}{4}}\text{e}^{s\text{Re}4\text{i} k^2}\nonumber\\ &\leq&\frac{C}{1+|k|^2}\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},\quad t>0,~k\in\bar{D}_1,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}. \end{eqnarray} Furthermore, we have \begin{eqnarray}\label{4.26} |f_r(t,k)|&\leq&\frac{1}{|k+\text{i}|^2}\int_{-\infty}^{-\frac{t}{4}}s^2|\hat{F}(s)|s^{-2}\text{d} s\nonumber\\ &\leq&\frac{C}{1+|k|^2}\|s^2\hat{F}(s)\|_{L^2({\Bbb R})}\sqrt{\int_{-\infty}^{-\frac{t}{4}}s^{-4}\text{d} s},\\ &\leq&\frac{C}{1+|k|^2}t^{-3/2},\quad t>0,~k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} Hence, the $L^1,L^2$ and $L^\infty$ norms of $f_r$ on $\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+$ are $O(t^{-3/2})$. Letting \begin{eqnarray} \Gamma_a(t,k)&=&f_0(k)+f_a(t,k),\quad t>0,~ k\in\bar{D}_1,\\ \Gamma_r(t,k)&=&f_r(t,k),~~\qquad\qquad t>0,~ k\in\text{i}{\Bbb R}_+, \end{eqnarray} we find a decomposition of $\Gamma$ with the properties listed in the statement of the lemma. \end{proof} We introduce the open subsets $\{\Omega_j\}_1^8$, as displayed in Fig. \ref{fig4}. The following lemma describes how to decompose $r_j$, $j=1,2$ into an analytic part $r_{j,a}$ and a small remainder $r_{j,r}$. A proof can be found in \cite{JL3}. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=4in]{KE3-eps-converted-to.pdf} \caption{The contour $\Sigma^{(3)}$ and the open sets $\{\Omega_j\}_1^8$ in the complex $k$-plane.}\label{fig4} \end{figure} \begin{lemma}\label{lem2} There exist decompositions \be \begin{aligned} r_1(k)&=r_{1,a}(x,t,k)+r_{1,r}(x,t,k),\quad k>k_0,\\ r_2(k)&=r_{2,a}(x,t,k)+r_{2,r}(x,t,k),\quad k<k_0, \end{aligned} \ee where the functions $\{r_{j,a}, r_{j,r}\}^2_1$ have the following properties: (1) For each $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$ and each $t>0$, $r_{j,a}(x,t,k)$ is defined and continuous for $k\in\bar{\Omega}_j$ and analytic for $\Omega_j$, $j= 1,2$. (2) The functions $r_{1,a}$ and $r_{2,a}$ satisfy \be\label{4.30} \begin{aligned} |r_{j,a}(x,t,k)-r_j(k_0)|&\leq C|k-k_0|\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},\\ |r_{j,a}(x,t,k)|&\leq \frac{C}{1+|k|}\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|}, \end{aligned} \quad t>0,~k\in\bar{\Omega}_j,~\xi\in\mathcal{I},~j=1,2, \ee where the constant $C$ is independent of $\xi, k, t$. (3) The $L^1, L^2$ and $L^\infty$ norms of the function $r_{1,r}(x,t,\cdot)$ on $(k_0,\infty)$ are $O(t^{-3/2})$ as $t\rightarrow\infty$ uniformly with respect to $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$. (4) The $L^1, L^2$ and $L^\infty$ norms of the function $r_{2,r}(x,t,\cdot)$ on $(-\infty,k_0)$ are $O(t^{-3/2})$ as $t\rightarrow\infty$ uniformly with respect to $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$. \end{lemma} The purpose of the next transformation is to deform the contour so that the jump matrix involves the exponential factor $\text{e}^{-t\Phi}$ on the parts of the contour where Re$\Phi$ is positive and the factor $\text{e}^{t\Phi}$ on the parts where Re$\Phi$ is negative according to the signature table for Re$\Phi$ as shown in Fig. \ref{fig5}. More precisely, we put \be\label{4.31} M^{(3)}(x,t;k)=M^{(2)}(x,t;k)G(k), \ee where \be\label{4.32} G(k)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ 0\\[4pt] r_{1,a}\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad k\in\Omega_1,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& -r_{2,a}\delta^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad k\in\Omega_2,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] -\bar{r}_{2,a}\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad k\in\Omega_3,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& \bar{r}_{1,a}\delta^2\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~~\quad k\in\Omega_4,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& -\bar{\Gamma}_{a}\delta^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi} \\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad k\in\Omega_5,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] -\Gamma_{a}\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad k\in\Omega_6,\\ &I,~~~~\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad k\in\Omega_7\cup\Omega_8. \end{aligned} \right. \ee Then the matrix $M^{(3)}(x,t;k)$ satisfies the following RH problem \be\label{4.33} M_+^{(3)}(x,t;k)=M_-^{(3)}(x,t;k)J^{(3)}(x,t,k), \ee with the jump matrix $J^{(3)}=G_+^{-1}(k)J^{(2)}G_-(k)$ is given by \begin{eqnarray} J^{(3)}_1&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0\\[4pt] -(r_{1,a}+\Gamma)\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} & 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad J^{(3)}_2=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -r_{2,a}\delta^2\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\ 0~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad J^{(3)}_3=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ 0\\ \bar{r}_{2,a}\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ J^{(3)}_4&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ (\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma})\delta^2\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\ 0~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad~ J^{(3)}_5=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ (\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma}_a)\delta^2\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\ 0~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ J^{(3)}_6&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ 0\\ -(r_{1,a}+\Gamma_a)\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi}~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad J^{(3)}_7=\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& \bar{r}_{1,r}\delta^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi} \\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0 \\[4pt] -r_{1,r}\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix},\nonumber\\ J^{(3)}_8&=&\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& -r_{2,r}\delta_-^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi} \\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0 \\[4pt] \bar{r}_{2,r}\delta_+^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} ~& 1 \\ \end{pmatrix},\quad J^{(3)}_9=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ 0\\[4pt] \Gamma_r\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi} & 1 \end{pmatrix}, \quad J^{(3)}_{10}=\begin{pmatrix} 1 &~ -\bar{\Gamma}_r\delta^{2}\text{e}^{-t\Phi}\\[4pt] 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix},\nonumber \end{eqnarray} with $J^{(3)}_i$ denoting the restriction of $J^{(3)}$ to the contour labeled by $i$ in Fig. \ref{fig4}. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=3.3in]{RePhi-eps-converted-to.pdf} \caption{The signature table of Re$\Phi$.}\label{fig5} \end{figure} It is easy to check that the jump matrix $J^{(3)}$ decays to identity matrix $I$ as $t\rightarrow\infty$ everywhere except near $k_0$. Thus, the main contribution to the long-time asymptotics should come from a neighborhood of the stationary phase point $k_0$. To focus on $k_0$, we make a local change of variables for $k$ near $k_0$ and introduce the new variable $z=z(\xi,k)$ by $$z=\sqrt{8t}(k-k_0).$$ Let $D_\varepsilon(k_0)$ denote the open disk of radius $\varepsilon$ centered at $k_0$ for a small $\varepsilon>0$. Then, the map $k\mapsto z$ is a bijection from $D_\varepsilon(k_0)$ to the open disk of radius $\sqrt{8t}\varepsilon$ centered at the origin for all $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$. Integrating by parts in formula \eqref{4.9} yields, \be\label{4.34} \delta(\xi,k)=\text{e}^{\text{i}\nu\ln(k-k_0)}\text{e}^{\chi(k)}=(k-k_0)^{\text{i}\nu}\text{e}^{\chi(k)}, \ee where \begin{eqnarray} \nu&=&\nu(\xi)=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln(1-|r(k_0)|^2)>0,\label{4.35}\\ \chi(k)&=&-\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{-\infty}^{k_0}\ln(k-s)\text{d}\ln(1-|r(s)|^2).\label{4.36} \end{eqnarray} Hence we can write $\delta$ as \berr \delta(\xi,k)=z^{\text{i}\nu}\delta_0(\xi,t)\delta_1(\xi,k), \eerr with $\delta_0(\xi,t), \delta_1(\xi,k)$ defined by \be\label{4.37} \delta_0(\xi,t)=(8t)^{-\frac{\text{i}\nu}{2}}\text{e}^{\chi(k_0)},\quad \delta_1(\xi,k)=\text{e}^{\chi(k)-\chi(k_0)}. \ee Now we let \be\label{4.38} \tilde{M}(x,t;z)=M^{(3)}(x,t;k)\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\sigma_3}\delta_0^{\sigma_3}(\xi,t),\quad k\in{\Bbb C}\setminus\Sigma^{(3)}. \ee Then $\tilde{M}$ is a sectionally analytic function of $z$ which satisfies $$\tilde{M}_+(x,t;z)=\tilde{M}_-(x,t;z)\tilde{J}(x,t,z),\quad z\in X,$$ where the contour $X=X_1\cup X_2\cup X_3\cup X_4$ is the cross defined by \be\label{4.39} \begin{aligned} X_1&=\{s\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i}\pi}{4}}|0\leq s<\infty\},~~~ X_2=\{s\text{e}^{\frac{3\text{i}\pi}{4}}|0\leq s<\infty\},\\ X_3&=\{s\text{e}^{-\frac{3\text{i}\pi}{4}}|0\leq s<\infty\},~ X_4=\{s\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i}\pi}{4}}|0\leq s<\infty\}, \end{aligned} \ee and oriented as in Fig. \ref{fig6}. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=3in]{KE4-eps-converted-to.pdf} \caption{The contour $X=X_1\cup X_2\cup X_3\cup X_4$.}\label{fig6} \end{figure} The jump matrix \be\label{4.40} \tilde{J}(x,t,z)=\text{e}^{\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta_0^{-\hat{\sigma}_3}(\xi,t)J^{(3)}(x,t,k) \ee is given by \berr \tilde{J}(x,t,z)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] -(r_{1,a}+\Gamma_a)\delta_1^{-2}\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad k\in \mathcal{X}_1\cap D_1,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] -(r_{1,a}+\Gamma)\delta_1^{-2}\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad k\in \mathcal{X}_1\cap D_2,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& -r_{2,a}\delta_1^{2}\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\qquad\qquad k\in \mathcal{X}_2,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] \bar{r}_{2,a}\delta_1^{-2}\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\qquad\qquad k\in \mathcal{X}_3,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& (\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma})\delta_1^{2}\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad\quad k\in \mathcal{X}_4\cap D_3,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& (\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma}_a)\delta_1^{2}\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad\quad k\in \mathcal{X}_4\cap D_4,\\ \end{aligned} \right. \eerr where $\mathcal{X}=X+k_0$ denote the cross $X$ centered at $k_0$ and we have used the following relation $$t(\Phi(\xi,k)-\Phi(\xi,k_0))=4\text{i} t(k-k_0)^2=\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}.$$ \subsection{Model RH problem} Let $X=X_1\cup X_2\cup X_3\cup X_4\subset{\Bbb C}$ be the cross defined in \eqref{4.39} and oriented as in Fig. \ref{fig6}. Let $\mathcal{D}\subset{\Bbb C}$ denote the open unit disk, and also define the function $\nu:\mathcal{D}\rightarrow(0,\infty)$ by $\nu(q)=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln(1-|q|^2)$. We consider the following RH problems parametrized by $q\in\mathcal{D}$: \be\label{4.41}\left\{ \begin{aligned} &M^X_+(q,z)=M^X_-(q,z)J^X(q,z),~\text{for~almost~every}~z\in X,\\ &M^X(q,z)\rightarrow I,~~~~\qquad\qquad\qquad\text{as}~z\rightarrow\infty, \end{aligned} \right. \ee where the jump matrix $J^X(q,z)$ is defined by \berr J^X(q,z)=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] -q\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad\quad z\in X_1,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& -\frac{\bar{q}}{1-|q|^2}\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~~ z\in X_2,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] \frac{q}{1-|q|^2}\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad z\in X_3,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& \bar{q}\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad\qquad z\in X_4. \end{aligned} \right. \eerr Then the RH problem \eqref{4.41} can be solved explicitly in terms of parabolic cylinder functions \cite{PD,PD1}. \begin{theorem}\label{th4.1} The RH problem \eqref{4.41} has a unique solution $M^X(q,z)$ for each $q\in \mathcal{D}$. This solution satisfies \be\label{4.42} M^X(q,z)=I+\frac{\text{i}}{z}\begin{pmatrix} 0 ~& -\beta^X(q)\\[4pt] \overline{\beta^X(q)} ~& 0 \end{pmatrix}+O\bigg(\frac{1}{z^2}\bigg),\quad z\rightarrow\infty,~q\in\mathcal{D}, \ee where the error term is uniform with respect to $\arg z\in[0,2\pi]$ and the function $\beta^X(q)$ is given by \be\label{4.43} \beta^X(q)=\sqrt{\nu(q)}\text{e}^{\text{i}\big(-\frac{3\pi}{4}-\arg q+\arg\Gamma(\text{i}\nu(q))\big)},\quad q\in\mathcal{D}, \ee where $\Gamma(\cdot)$ denotes the standard Gamma function. Moreover, for each compact subset $\mathcal{D}'$ of $\mathcal{D}$, \be\label{4.44} \sup_{q\in\mathcal{D}'}\sup_{z\in{\Bbb C}\setminus X}|M^X(q,z)|<\infty. \ee \end{theorem} \begin{proof} The proof of this theorem can be analogously derived by the procedure used in \cite{PD,PD1,JL3}. \end{proof} Define $q=r(k_0)$, then $r(k)\rightarrow q$ and $\delta_1\rightarrow1$ as $t\rightarrow\infty$. This implies that the jump matrix $\tilde{J}$ tend to the matrix $J^X$ for large $t$. In other words, the jumps of $M^{(3)}$ for $k$ near $k_0$ approach those of the function $M^X\delta^{-\sigma_3}_0\text{e}^{\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\sigma_3}$ as $t\rightarrow\infty$. Therefore, we can approximate $M^{(3)}$ in the neighborhood $D_\varepsilon(k_0)$ of $k_0$ by \be\label{4.45} M^{(k_0)}(x,t;k)=\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\sigma_3}\delta^{\sigma_3}_0M^X(q,z)\delta^{-\sigma_3}_0\text{e}^{\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\sigma_3}. \ee Let $\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon$ denote the part of $\mathcal{X}$ that lies in the disk $D_\varepsilon(k_0)$, that is, $\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon=\mathcal{X}\cap D_\varepsilon(k_0)$. Then we have the following lemma about the function $M^{(k_0)}$, which will be very useful in deriving the error bound in next section. \begin{lemma}\label{lem3} For each $t>0$ and $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$, the function $M^{(k_0)}(x,t;k)$ defined in \eqref{4.45} is an analytic function of $k\in D_\varepsilon(k_0)\setminus\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon$. Furthermore, \be\label{4.46} |M^{(k_0)}(x,t;k)|\leq C,\quad t>3,~\xi\in\mathcal{I},~k\in\overline{ D_\varepsilon(k_0)}\setminus\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon. \ee On the other hand, across $\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon$, $M^{(k_0)}$ satisfied the jump condition $M_+^{(k_0)}=M_-^{(k_0)}J^{(k_0)}$ with jump matrix $$J^{(k_0)}=\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0J^X,$$ and $J^{(k_0)}$ satisfies the following estimates: \be\label{4.47} \left\{ \begin{aligned} &\|J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}\|_{L^1(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}\leq Ct^{-1}\ln t,\\ &\|J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}\|_{L^2(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}\leq Ct^{-3/4}\ln t,\\ &\|J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}\|_{L^\infty(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}\leq Ct^{-1/2}\ln t, \end{aligned} \quad t>3,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}, \right. \ee where $C>0$ is a constant independent of $t,\xi,k$. Moreover, as $t\rightarrow\infty$, \be\label{4.48} \|(M^{(k_0)})^{-1}(x,t;k)-I\|_{L^\infty(\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0))}=O(t^{-1/2}), \ee and \be\label{4.49} \frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0)}((M^{(k_0)})^{-1}(x,t;k)-I)\text{d} k=-\frac{\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0M^X_1(\xi)} {\sqrt{8t}}+O(t^{-1}), \ee where $M^X_1(\xi)$ is defined by \be\label{4.50} M^X_1(\xi)=\text{i}\begin{pmatrix} 0 ~& -\beta^X(q)\\[4pt] \overline{\beta^X(q)} ~& 0 \end{pmatrix}. \ee \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The analyticity of $M^{(k_0)}$ is obvious. Since $|\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}}|=|\delta_0(\xi,t)|=1$, thus, the estimate \eqref{4.46} follows from the definition of $M^{(k_0)}$ in \eqref{4.45} and the estimate \eqref{4.44}. A careful computation as in \cite{JL1,JL3} shows that \be\label{4.51} |\chi(k)-\chi(k_0)|\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|),\quad \xi\in\mathcal{I},~k\in\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon. \ee Therefore, we have \be\label{4.52} |\delta_1(\xi,k)-1|=|\text{e}^{\chi(k)-\chi(k_0)}-1|\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|),\quad \xi\in\mathcal{I},~k\in\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon. \ee On the other hand, for $k\in\mathcal{X}_1^\varepsilon\cap D_1$, by the estimates \eqref{4.12} and \eqref{4.30}, we can find \begin{eqnarray} |r_{1,a}(x,t,k)+\Gamma_a(t,k)-q|&=&|r_{1,a}(x,t,k)+\Gamma_a(t,k)-r_1(k_0)-\Gamma(k_0)|\nonumber\\ &\leq&|r_{1,a}(x,t,k)-r_1(k_0)|+|\Gamma_a(t,k)-\Gamma(0)|+|\Gamma(k_0)-\Gamma(0)|\nonumber\\ &\leq&C|k-k_0|\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|}.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} Then, we obtain \begin{eqnarray} |(r_{1,a}+\Gamma_a)\delta_1^{-2}-q|&\leq&|\delta_1^{-2}-1||r_{1,a}+\Gamma_a|+|r_{1,a}+\Gamma_a-q|\nonumber\\ &\leq&C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},\label{4.53} \end{eqnarray} for $k\in\mathcal{X}_1^\varepsilon\cap D_1$. Accordingly, we have \be\label{4.54} \begin{aligned} |(r_{1,a}+\Gamma)\delta_1^{-2}-q|&\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},~~k\in\mathcal{X}_1^\varepsilon\cap D_2,\\ \bigg|r_{2,a}\delta_1^{2}-\frac{\bar{q}}{1-|q|^2}\bigg|&\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},~~k\in\mathcal{X}_2^\varepsilon,\\ \bigg|\bar{r}_{2,a}\delta_1^{-2}-\frac{q}{1-|q|^2}\bigg|&\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},~~k\in\mathcal{X}_3^\varepsilon,\\ |(\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma})\delta_1^{2}-\bar{q}|&\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},~~k\in\mathcal{X}_4^\varepsilon\cap D_3,\\ |(\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma}_a)\delta_1^{2}-\bar{q}|&\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{\frac{t}{4}|\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)|},~~k\in\mathcal{X}_4^\varepsilon\cap D_4. \end{aligned} \ee Since \berr \tilde{J}-J^X=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] -((r_{1,a}+\Gamma_a)\delta_1^{-2}-q)\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad k\in\mathcal{X}_1\cap D_1,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] -((r_{1,a}+\Gamma)\delta_1^{-2}-q)\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~~\quad k\in\mathcal{X}_1\cap D_2,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& -(r_{2,a}\delta_1^{2}-\frac{\bar{q}}{1-|q|^2})\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~~~\quad\quad k\in\mathcal{X}_2,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& 0\\[4pt] (\bar{r}_{2,a}\delta_1^{-2}-\frac{q}{1-|q|^2})\text{e}^{\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{-2\text{i}\nu} ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad\quad~~~ k\in \mathcal{X}_3,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& ((\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma})\delta_1^{2}-\bar{q})\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},~\quad\quad ~~k\in \mathcal{X}_4\cap D_3,\\ &\begin{pmatrix} 1 ~& ((\bar{r}_{1,a}+\bar{\Gamma}_a)\delta_1^{2}-\bar{q})\text{e}^{-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}}z^{2\text{i}\nu}\\[4pt] 0 ~& 1 \end{pmatrix},\quad\quad ~k\in \mathcal{X}_4\cap D_4. \end{aligned} \right. \eerr Then, \eqref{4.53}, \eqref{4.54} together with the facts \begin{eqnarray} \text{Re}\bigg(\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}\bigg)&=&t\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)=4t\text{Re}[\text{i}(k-k_0)^2]=-4t|k-k_0|^2,~~\quad \text{for~}k\in \mathcal{X}_1\cup \mathcal{X}_3,\nonumber\\ \text{Re}\bigg(-\frac{\text{i} z^2}{2}\bigg)&=&-t\text{Re}\Phi(\xi,k)=-4t\text{Re}[\text{i}(k-k_0)^2]=-4t|k-k_0|^2,\quad \text{for~}k\in \mathcal{X}_2\cup \mathcal{X}_4\nonumber \end{eqnarray} and $|z^{\pm2\text{i}\nu}|=\text{e}^{\mp2\nu\arg z}$ is bounded by $0<\nu\leq\nu_{\max}=-(2\pi)^{-1}\ln(1-\sup_k|r(k)|^2)<\infty$ yield \be\label{4.55} |\tilde{J}-J^X|\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{-3t|k-k_0|^2},\quad k\in\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon. \ee However, \berr J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}=\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0(\tilde{J}-J^X),\quad k\in\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon, \eerr hence, we immediately get \be\label{4.56} |J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}|\leq C|k-k_0|(1+\big|\ln|k-k_0|\big|)\text{e}^{-3t|k-k_0|^2},\quad k\in\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon. \ee Thus, we conclude that \berr \|J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}\|_{L^\infty(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}\leq C\sup_{0\leq s\leq\varepsilon}s(1+|\ln s|)\text{e}^{-3ts^2}\leq Ct^{-1/2}\ln t,\quad t>3,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}, \eerr \berr \|J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}\|_{L^1(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}\leq C\int_0^\varepsilon s(1+|\ln s|)\text{e}^{-3ts^2}\text{d} s\leq Ct^{-1}\ln t,\quad t>3,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}, \eerr and \berr \|J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)}\|_{L^2(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}\leq C\bigg(\int_0^\varepsilon \big(s(1+|\ln s|)\text{e}^{-3ts^2}\big)^2\text{d} s\bigg)^{\frac{1}{2}}\leq Ct^{-3/4}\ln t,\quad t>3,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}. \eerr If $k\in\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0)$, the variable $z=\sqrt{8t}(k-k_0)$ tends to infinity as $t\rightarrow\infty$. It follows from \eqref{4.42} that \berr M^X(q,z)=I+\frac{M^X_1(\xi)}{\sqrt{8t}(k-k_0)}+O\bigg(\frac{1}{z^2}\bigg),\quad t\rightarrow\infty,~k\in \partial D_\varepsilon(k_0), \eerr where $M^X_1(\xi)$ is defined by \eqref{4.50}. Since the estimate \eqref{4.44} and $$M^{(k_0)}(x,t;k)=\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0M^X(q,z), ~~|\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}}\delta_0|\leq C,$$ thus we have \be\label{4.57} (M^{(k_0)})^{-1}(x,t;k)-I=-\frac{\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0M^X_1(\xi)} {\sqrt{8t}(k-k_0)}+O\bigg(\frac{1}{t}\bigg),\quad t\rightarrow\infty,~k\in \partial D_\varepsilon(k_0). \ee The estimate \eqref{4.48} immediately follows from \eqref{4.57} and $|M_1^X|\leq C$. By Cauchy's formula and \eqref{4.57}, we derive \eqref{4.49}. \end{proof} \subsection{Derivation of the asymptotics formula and error bound} We now begin to establish the explicit long-time asymptotics formula for the KE equation \eqref{1.1} on the half-line. Define the approximate solution $M^{(app)}(x,t;k)$ by \be\label{4.58} M^{(app)}=\left\{\begin{aligned} &M^{(k_0)},\quad k\in D_\varepsilon(k_0),\\ &I,\qquad ~~~{\text elsewhere}. \end{aligned} \right. \ee Let $\hat{M}(x,t;k)$ be \be\label{4.58'} \hat{M}=M^{(3)}(M^{(app)})^{-1}, \ee then $\hat{M}(x,t;k)$ satisfies the following RH problem \be\label{4.59} \hat{M}_+(x,t;k)=\hat{M}_-(x,t;k)\hat{J}(x,t,k),\quad k\in\hat{\Sigma}, \ee where the jump contour $\hat{\Sigma}=\Sigma^{(3)}\cup\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0)$ is depicted in Fig. \ref{fig7}, and the jump matrix $\hat{J}(x,t,k)$ is given by \be\label{4.60} \hat{J}=\left\{ \begin{aligned} &M^{(k_0)}_-J^{(3)}(M^{(k_0)}_+)^{-1},\quad k\in\hat{\Sigma}\cap D_\varepsilon(k_0),\\ &(M^{(k_0)})^{-1},\qquad\qquad\quad k\in\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0),\\ &J^{(3)},\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad~~ k\in\hat{\Sigma}\setminus \overline{D_\varepsilon(k_0)}. \end{aligned} \right. \ee Let $\hat{W}=\hat{J}-I.$ Then the following inequalities are valid. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=4in]{KE5-eps-converted-to.pdf} \caption{The contour $\hat{\Sigma}$.}\label{fig7} \end{figure} \begin{lemma}\label{lem4} For $t>3$ and $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$, we have \begin{eqnarray} \|\hat{W}\|_{L^1\cap L^2\cap L^\infty(\Sigma^{(3)}\setminus\mathcal{X})}&\leq Ct^{-3/2},\label{4.61}\\ \|\hat{W}\|_{L^1\cap L^2\cap L^\infty(\mathcal{X}\setminus\overline{D_\varepsilon(k_0)})}&\leq C\text{e}^{-ct},\label{4.62}\\ \|\hat{W}\|_{L^1\cap L^2\cap L^\infty(\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0))}&\leq Ct^{-1/2},\label{4.63} \end{eqnarray} and \begin{eqnarray}\label{4.64} \begin{aligned} \|\hat{W}\|_{L^\infty(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}&\leq Ct^{-1/2}\ln t,\\ \|\hat{W}\|_{L^1(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}&\leq Ct^{-1}\ln t,\\ \|\hat{W}\|_{L^2(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}&\leq Ct^{-3/4}\ln t. \end{aligned} \end{eqnarray} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Since the matrix $\hat{W}$ on $\Sigma^{(3)}\setminus\mathcal{X}$ only involves the small remainders $\Gamma_r$, $r_{1,r}$ and $r_{2,r}$, thus, by Lemmas \ref{lem1} and \ref{lem2}, the estimate \eqref{4.61} follows. For $k\in D_2\cap(\mathcal{X}_1\setminus\overline{D_\varepsilon(k_0)})$, $\hat{W}$ only has a nonzero $-(r_{1,a}+\Gamma)\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi}$ in $(21)$ entry. Hence, for $t\geq1$, by \eqref{4.30}, we get \begin{eqnarray} |\hat{W}_{21}|&=&|-(r_{1,a}+\Gamma)\delta^{-2}\text{e}^{t\Phi}|\nonumber\\ &\leq& C|r_{1,a}+\Gamma|\text{e}^{t\text{Re}\Phi}\nonumber\\ &\leq&C\text{e}^{-3|k-k_0|^2t}\leq C\text{e}^{-3\varepsilon^2t}.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} In a similar way, the estimates on $\mathcal{X}_j\setminus\overline{D_\varepsilon(k_0)}$, $j=2,3,4$ hold. This proves \eqref{4.62}. The inequality \eqref{4.63} is a consequence of \eqref{4.48} and \eqref{4.60}. For $k\in\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon$, we find $$\hat{W}=M^{(k_0)}_-(J^{(3)}-J^{(k_0)})(M^{(k_0)}_+)^{-1}.$$ Therefore, it follows from \eqref{4.46} and \eqref{4.47} that the estimate \eqref{4.64} holds. \end{proof} The results in Lemma \ref{lem4} imply that: \be\label{4.65} \begin{aligned} \|\hat{W}\|_{L^\infty(\hat{\Sigma})}&\leq Ct^{-1/2}\ln t,\\ \|\hat{W}\|_{L^1\cap L^2(\hat{\Sigma})}&\leq Ct^{-1/2}, \end{aligned} \quad t>3,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}. \ee Let $\hat{C}$ denote the Cauchy operator associated with $\hat{\Sigma}$: \berr (\hat{C}f)(k)=\int_{\hat{\Sigma}}\frac{f(\zeta)}{\zeta-k}\frac{\text{d} \zeta}{2\pi\text{i}},\quad k\in{\Bbb C}\setminus\hat{\Sigma},~f\in L^2(\hat{\Sigma}). \eerr We denote the boundary values of $\hat{C}f$ from the left and right sides of $\hat{\Sigma}$ by $\hat{C}_+f$ and $\hat{C}_-f$, respectively. As is well known, the operators $\hat{C}_\pm$ are bounded from $L^2(\hat{\Sigma})$ to $L^2(\hat{\Sigma})$, and $\hat{C}_+-\hat{C}_-=I$, here $I$ denotes the identity operator. Define the operator $\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}$: $L^2(\hat{\Sigma})+L^\infty(\hat{\Sigma})\rightarrow L^2(\hat{\Sigma})$ by $\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}f=\hat{C}_-(f\hat{W}),$ that is, $\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}$ is defined by $\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}(f)=\hat{C}_+(f\hat{W}_-)+\hat{C}_-(f\hat{W}_+)$ where we have chosen, for simplicity, $\hat{W}_+=\hat{W}$ and $\hat{W}_-=0$. Then, by \eqref{4.65}, we find \be\label{4.66} \|\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}\|_{B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))}\leq C\|\hat{W}\|_{L^\infty(\hat{\Sigma})}\leq Ct^{-1/2}\ln t, \ee where $B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))$ denotes the Banach space of bounded linear operators $L^2(\hat{\Sigma})\rightarrow L^2(\hat{\Sigma})$. Therefore, there exists a $T>0$ such that $I-\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}\in B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))$ is invertible for all $\xi\in\mathcal{I},$ $t>T$. Following this, we may define the $2\times2$ matrix-valued function $\hat{\mu}(x,t;k)$ whenever $t>T$ by \be\label{4.67} \hat{\mu}=I+\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}\hat{\mu}. \ee Then \be\label{4.68} \hat{M}(x,t;k)=I+\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{\hat{\Sigma}}\frac{(\hat{\mu}\hat{W})(x,t;\zeta)}{\zeta-k}\text{d}\zeta,\quad k\in{\Bbb C}\setminus\hat{\Sigma} \ee is the unique solution of the RH problem \eqref{4.59} for $t>T$. Moreover, the function $\hat{\mu}(x,t;k)$ satisfies \be\label{4.69} \|\hat{\mu}(x,t;\cdot)-I\|_{L^2(\hat{\Sigma})}=O(t^{-1/2}),\quad t\rightarrow\infty,~\xi\in\mathcal{I}. \ee In fact, equation \eqref{4.67} is equivalent to $\hat{\mu}=I+(I-\hat{C}_{\hat{W}})^{-1}\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}I$. Using the Neumann series, we get $$\|(I-\hat{C}_{\hat{W}})^{-1}\|_{B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))}\leq\frac{1}{1-\|\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}\|_{B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))}}$$ whenever $\|\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}\|_{B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))}<1$. thus, we find \begin{eqnarray} \|\hat{\mu}(x,t;\cdot)-I\|_{L^2(\hat{\Sigma})}&=&\|(I-\hat{C}_{\hat{W}})^{-1}\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}I\|_{L^2(\hat{\Sigma})}\nonumber\\ &\leq&\|(I-\hat{C}_{\hat{W}})^{-1}\|_{B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))}\|\hat{C}_-(\hat{W})\|_{L^2(\hat{\Sigma})}\nonumber\\ &\leq&\frac{C\|\hat{W}\|_{L^2(\hat{\Sigma})}}{1-\|\hat{C}_{\hat{W}}\|_{B(L^2(\hat{\Sigma}))}}\leq C\|\hat{W}\|_{L^2(\hat{\Sigma})}\nonumber \end{eqnarray} for all $t$ large enough and all $\xi\in\mathcal{I}$. In view of \eqref{4.65}, this gives \eqref{4.69}. It follows from \eqref{4.68} that \be\label{4.70} \lim_{k\rightarrow\infty}k(\hat{M}(x,t;k)-I)=-\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{\hat{\Sigma}}(\hat{\mu}\hat{W})(x,t;k)\text{d} k. \ee Denoting $\Sigma'=\Sigma^{(3)}\setminus\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon$, using \eqref{4.61} and \eqref{4.69}, we have \begin{eqnarray} \int_{\Sigma'}(\hat{\mu}\hat{W})(x,t;k)\text{d} k&=&\int_{\Sigma'}\hat{W}(x,t;k)\text{d} k+\int_{\Sigma'}(\hat{\mu}(x,t;k)-I)\hat{W}(x,t;k)\text{d} k\nonumber\\ &\leq&\|\hat{W}\|_{L^1(\Sigma')}+\|\hat{\mu}-I\|_{L^2(\Sigma')}\|\hat{W}\|_{L^2(\Sigma')}\nonumber\\ &\leq&Ct^{-3/2},\quad t\rightarrow\infty.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} Similarly, by \eqref{4.64} and \eqref{4.69}, the contribution from $\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon$ to the right-hand side of \eqref{4.70} is $$O(\|\hat{W}\|_{L^1(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)}+\|\hat{\mu}-I\|_{L^2(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)} \|\hat{W}\|_{L^2(\mathcal{X}^\varepsilon)})=O(t^{-1}\ln t),\quad t\rightarrow\infty.$$ Finally, by \eqref{4.49}, \eqref{4.63} and \eqref{4.69}, we can get \begin{eqnarray} &&-\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0)}(\hat{\mu}\hat{W})(x,t;k)\text{d} k\nonumber\\ &=&-\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0)}\hat{W}(x,t;k)\text{d} k-\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0)}(\hat{\mu}(x,t;k)-I)\hat{W}(x,t;k)\text{d} k\nonumber\\ &=&-\frac{1}{2\pi\text{i}}\int_{\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0)}\bigg((M^{(k_0)})^{-1}(x,t;k)-I\bigg)\text{d} k+O(\|\hat{\mu}-I\|_{L^2(\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0))} \|\hat{W}\|_{L^2(\partial D_\varepsilon(k_0))})\nonumber\\ &=&\frac{\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0M^X_1(\xi)} {\sqrt{8t}}+O(t^{-1}),\quad t\rightarrow\infty.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} Thus, we obtain the following important relation \be\label{4.71} \lim_{k\rightarrow\infty}k(\hat{M}(x,t;k)-I)=\frac{\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0M^X_1(\xi)} {\sqrt{8t}}+O(t^{-1}\ln t),\quad t\rightarrow\infty. \ee Taking into account that \eqref{3.9}, \eqref{4.6}, \eqref{4.8}, \eqref{4.31} and \eqref{4.58'}, for sufficient large $k\in{\Bbb C}\setminus\hat{\Sigma}$, we get \begin{eqnarray}\label{4.72} m(x,t)&=&\lim_{k\rightarrow\infty}(kM(x,t;k))_{12}\nonumber\\ &=&\lim_{k\rightarrow\infty}k(\hat{M}(x,t;k)-I)_{12}\nonumber\\ &=&\frac{\big(\text{e}^{-\frac{t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}{2}\hat{\sigma}_3}\delta^{\hat{\sigma}_3}_0M^X_1(\xi)\big)_{12}} {\sqrt{8t}}+O\bigg(\frac{\ln t}{t}\bigg)\\ &=&\frac{-\text{i}\beta^X\delta_0^2\text{e}^{-t\Phi(\xi,k_0)}}{\sqrt{8t}}+O\bigg(\frac{\ln t}{t}\bigg)\nonumber\\ &=&\frac{-\text{i}\beta^X(8t)^{-\text{i}\nu}\text{e}^{2\chi(k_0)}\text{e}^{4\text{i} tk_0^2}}{\sqrt{8t}}+O\bigg(\frac{\ln t}{t}\bigg),\quad t\rightarrow\infty.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} From \eqref{3.9}, we have \begin{eqnarray} u(x,t)=2\text{i} m(x,t)\text{e}^{2\text{i}\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta}.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} Recalling the definition of $\Delta(x,t)$ in \eqref{2.7}, $$\Delta(x,t)=-\beta|u|^2\text{d} x+\bigg(4\beta^2|u|^4-\text{i}\beta(u_x\bar{u}-u\bar{u}_x)\bigg)\text{d} t.$$ In order to compute the integral $\int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta$, we choose an integration contour consisting of the vertical segment from $(0,0)$ to $(0,t)$ followed by the horizontal segment from $(0,t)$ to $(x,t)$, and using the equality $|u(x,t)|^2=4|m(x,t)|^2$, we get \be\label{4.73} \int_{(0,0)}^{(x,t)}\Delta=\int_0^t\bigg(4\beta^2|g_0(t')|^4-\text{i}\beta(g_1\bar{g}_0-g_0\bar{g}_1)(t')\bigg)\text{d} t'-4\beta\int_0^x|m(x',t)|^2\text{d} x'. \ee It follows from \eqref{4.72} and the definition $\beta^X(q)$ in \eqref{4.43}, we have \begin{eqnarray} \int_0^x|m(x',t)|^2\text{d} x'&=&\int_0^x\bigg|\sqrt{\frac{\nu(x'/t)}{8t}}+O\bigg(\frac{\ln t}{t}\bigg)\bigg|^2\nonumber\\ &=&-\frac{1}{16\pi t}\int_0^x\ln\big(1-|r(-x'/(4t))|^2\big)\text{d} x'+O\bigg(\frac{\ln t}{t^{3/2}}\bigg)\\ &=&-\frac{1}{4\pi}\int_0^{|k_0|}\ln\big(1-|r(-s)|^2\big)\text{d} s+O\bigg(\frac{\ln t}{t^{3/2}}\bigg).\nonumber \end{eqnarray} Collecting the above computations, we obtain our main results stated as the following theorem. \begin{theorem}\label{the4.2} Let $u_0(x),g_0(t),g_1(t)$ lie in the Schwartz space $S([0,\infty))$. Suppose the assumption \ref{ass1} be valid. Then, for any positive constant $N$, as $t\rightarrow\infty$, the solution $u(x,t)$ of the IBV problem for KE equation \eqref{1.1} on the half-line satisfies the following asymptotic formula \be u(x,t)=\frac{u_a(x,t)}{\sqrt{t}}+O\bigg(\frac{\ln t}{t}\bigg),\quad t\rightarrow\infty,~0\leq x\leq Nt, \ee where the error term is uniform with respect to $x$ in the given range, and the leading-order coefficient $u_a(x,t)$ is defined by \be u_a(x,t)=\sqrt{\frac{\nu(\xi)}{2}}\text{e}^{\text{i}\alpha(\xi,t)}, \ee with $$\xi=\frac{x}{t},~\nu(\xi)=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln(1-|r(k_0)|^2),~k_0=-\frac{\xi}{4},$$ and \begin{eqnarray} \alpha(\xi,t)&=&-\frac{3\pi}{4}-\arg r(k_0)+\arg\Gamma(\text{i}\nu(\xi))-\nu(\xi)\ln(8t)+4k_0^2t\nonumber\\ &&+\frac{1}{\pi}\int_{-\infty}^{k_0}\ln(k_0-s)\text{d}\ln(1-|r(s)|^2)+\frac{2\beta}{\pi}\int_0^{|k_0|}\ln(1-|r(-s)|^2)\text{d} s\nonumber\\ &&+2\int_0^t\bigg(4\beta^2|g_0(t')|^4-\text{i}\beta(g_1\bar{g}_0-g_0\bar{g}_1)(t')\bigg)\text{d} t'.\nonumber \end{eqnarray} \end{theorem} \medskip \small{

It was eight years ago that the Indian Journal of psychiatry showcased to the world a well crafted volume on psychiatric research in India. Now we see another addition to the rapidly growing library of the Society. This book, a creation of the fecund mind of the editor, Dr. T.S.S. Rao is something of a potpourri of articles which holds promise of taking the older amongst us on a misty eyed journey of nostalgia and enables the blossoming and burgeoning tribe of the present day psychiatrists and students get an opportunity to have a look at our roots. I must also congratulate Dr. Alok Sarin, Dr. Sanjeev Jain and Dr. Pratima Murthy for excellent job done in this difficult area. I have had the pleasure of reading the seminal articles of the redoubtable Dr L P Verma on the history of psychiatry in India and Pakistan in the 1952 editions of our journal as well as the much treasured book on mental hospitals in India by the towering personality Prof Shridhar Sharma. This book resorts, most appropriately, to some creative indulgence by slipping in pieces on great pox, rehabilitation and RMPA which like cardamom seeds in a rice pudding tickle the taste buds of the mind. The article on Reserpine will definitely make us feel proud to know that the psychopharmacology revolution started here in India. Old timers will recall the advertisements in our journal of 1949 for products like Ralfen and BromoRaulfin! Finally a dash of future pacing -- even a phlegmatic will have his fill. Some may not agree but the history of modern psychiatry in India is the history of its mental hospitals. Quite surprisingly, Yerawada perhaps the largest institution in Asia does not find a place in the book. As a nation we somehow do not feel proud of our historical heritage, may be because of the philosophical orientation of crediting our doings to a greater doer! It is very thoughtful of Dr. T S S Rao to conceptualise the book, collect authors and deliver it to us in record time. I congratulate all the authors for putting some excellent words in all the pages. Long live Indian Psychiatric Society

\section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} Systems characterized by processes that evolve on different time-scales are often encountered in biology \cite{ChenAihara2002,HodgkinHuxley} but are also present in engineering \cite{MallociPhD,SanfeliceTeel2011}. In this case, the standard stability analysis becomes more difficult and singular perturbation theory \cite{KokotovicBook,KhalilBook} has to be used. This theory is based on Tikhonov approach that proposes to approximate the dynamics by decoupling the slow dynamical processes from the faster ones. The stability analysis is done separately for each time scale and under appropriate assumptions one can conclude on the stability of the overall system. Significant results related to stability analysis and approximation of solutions of singularly perturbed systems can be found in \cite{Balachandra,NesicAveraging2001,TeelMoreauNesic}. Another feature that characterizes many physical systems is the presence of discrete events that occur during the continuous {evolution}. \blue{These events include abrupt changes of dynamics or instantaneous state jumps, which lead to the classes of switched systems or impulsive systems, respectively. Stability analysis and stabilization of singularly perturbed linear switched systems are considered in \cite{Alwan-et-al2008,Malloci_et_al2010}. Interestingly, it is shown in~\cite{Malloci_et_al2010} that even though the switched dynamics on each time scale are stable, the overall system may be destabilized by fast switching signals. Clearly, this is in contrast with classical results on continuous singularly perturbed linear systems~\cite{KokotovicBook} and is a motivation for developing dedicated techniques for stability analysis of singularly perturbed hybrid systems. Stability analysis of singularly perturbed impulsive systems is considered in~\cite{Simeonov1988,AbdelrahimPostoyan2015}. More general singularly perturbed hybrid systems can involve both switches and impulses. A stability result for this class of systems can be found in \cite{SanfeliceTeel2011}. In these works, the slow or fast nature of the state variable does not change when an event (switch or impulse) occurs. In this paper we introduce and analyze a class of singularly perturbed linear hybrid systems in which, at switching instants, slow variables can become fast and vice-versa. Our framework also includes the analysis of singularly perturbed linear systems with or without switches and/or impulses.} \blue{ Moreover, taking advantage of the linear dynamics under study, we go beyond the results in \cite{SanfeliceTeel2011} by characterizing the required dwell-time in terms of the parameter defining the ratio between the two time-scales.} The analysis of the class of dynamical systems discussed in this paper is motivated by an industrial application. In steel production, steering control denotes strategies to guide a metal strip in a finishing mill, which is constituted by a fixed number of stands. Each stand contains a set of rolls that crush the strip. The objective in rolling mills is to reduce the thickness of a strip. This goal is reached by maintaining the strip in a straight line and close to the mill axis, avoiding sudden lateral movements of the rolled product. As long as the strip remains connected to the coilbox, which is the device used to coil the strips into the finishing train, the hot strip model is described by a set of classical non linear differential equations. Indeed, each stand is linked to the others by the strip traction and there is no discontinuity in the model. The corresponding control problem can be treated using classical linear techniques motivated by the fact that it is enough from a practical point of view to consider small deviations around an ideal operating point (see \cite{Mallocietal2010} and references therein). One has to take care of the two time scale nature of this system as there is a slow dynamics corresponding to the lateral displacement of the strip after each stand (called strip off-centre) and a fast dynamics corresponding to the angle between the strip and the mill axis. As explained in \cite{Mallocietal2010}, using singular perturbations and time-scale separation, it is possible to design an efficient robust control strategy based on the reduced model which describes only the slow dynamics. Such a control law has been validated on the industrial plant. The situation is different in the last phase of the rolling process called the tail end phase and where the strip leaves the stands one after the other. Traction is lost each time the strip leaves a stand and this increases the difficulty to guide the strip as it is free to move in all directions. There are several difficulties in this phase. The first one is related to model discontinuities. Each time the strip leaves a stand the system dynamics changes and switching occurs. Moreover, the tail end phase is very short, the switchings are very fast and stability of all subsystems is not a sufficient condition to guarantee the stability of the whole system. Without stability guarantee, these switchings may lead to a crash damaging the rolls. The second difficulty is related to the changes in the nature of the dynamics after switching. When the strip leaves the coilbox, the slow dynamics is given by the strips off-centre of the operating stands and the angle corresponding to the first active stand where the traction is lost. The angle which was a fast variable before leaving the coilbox becomes a slow variable in the tail end phase. This change occurs at each time the strip leaves a stand which means that the components and the dimension of the state vector change at each switching time. A system with this behaviour can be defined as a switched system with multiple time scales, changes in the nature of the dynamics associated to each state variable and changes in the dimension of the state vector \cite{Mallocietal2009}. \blue{ Starting from the above motivation, we analyze a general class of singularly perturbed linear hybrid systems with mode-dependent nature of the state variable. The main contributions of the current work are: \begin{itemize} \item a procedure to rewrite the general class under study as linear hybrid singularly perturbed systems where the nature of variables does not change at switching instants, both cases of fixed and variable dimensions of the slow and fast state vectors are considered; \item a new approach for stability analysis of singularly perturbed linear hybrid systems with both switches and impulses; \item the derivation of an upper bound on the minimal dwell-time between two events that ensures the stability of the singularly perturbed linear hybrid system. \end{itemize} It is noteworthy that, this bound is given as the sum of two terms. The first one corresponds to an upper bound on the minimum dwell-time ensuring the stability of the reduced order linear hybrid system describing the slow dynamics. The order of magnitude of the second term is determined by that of the parameter $\varepsilon$ defining the ratio between the two time-scales of the singularly perturbed system. In particular, it follows that when the reduced order system has a common quadratic Lyapunov function, the first term is zero and the minimum dwell-time ensuring the stability of the overall system goes to zero as fast as $\varepsilon$ or $-\varepsilon \ln (\varepsilon)$ when the time scale parameter $\varepsilon$ goes to zero.} Basically, we combine the classical singular perturbation theory \cite{KokotovicBook} with Lyapunov function arguments for hybrid systems (see \cite{Teel-book} for details). \blue{Our results clearly differ from existing ones on singularly perturbed linear hybrid systems that we mentioned previously: \cite{Malloci_et_al2010} deals with the existence of common quadratic Lyapunov functions and thus characterizes systems that are stable without dwell-time assumption; the condition on the dwell-time established in~\cite{Alwan-et-al2008} does not present a clear separation between the slow and fast dynamics of the system; and in~\cite{Simeonov1988,AbdelrahimPostoyan2015,SanfeliceTeel2011} the stability is established under a dwell-time condition where the dwell-time does not explicitly depend on the time-scale parameter.} {The paper is organized as follows : Section \ref{Problem formulation} describes the hybrid system model in the singular perturbation form and introduces the relevant notations. In this section, we also introduce a mode-dependent reordering of the state components allowing to rewrite the system in a form in which the variables preserve their nature over time. Section \ref{Preliminaries} is devoted to preliminary results concerning the stability analysis of singularly perturbed linear systems without switches or jumps. Section \ref{Sec:stability} presents the main results along with their Lyapunov-based proofs. These results give stability conditions and establish an upper-bound on the minimum dwell-time ensuring the stability of the system. An extension to the case of mode-dependent dimension of the state-vector is provided in Section \ref{extension}. To illustrate the results, we provide in Section \ref{sec:scalar} a dwell-time analysis and a numerical example in the particular case of scalar fast and slow dynamics with only two switching modes. Some concluding remarks end the paper.} \section*{Notation} Throughout this paper, $\mathbb{R}_+$ , $\mathbb{R}^n$ and $\mathbb{R}^{n\times m}$ denote respectively, the set of nonnegative real numbers, the $n$ dimensional Euclidean space and the set of all $n \times m$ real matrices. The identity matrix of dimension $n$ is denoted by ${\bf I}_n$. We also denote by ${\bf 0}_{n,m} \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times m}$ the matrix whose components are all $0$. For a matrix $A \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$, $\|A\|$ denotes the spectral norm {\it i.e. } induced 2 norm. $A \ge {\bf 0}$ $(A\le {\bf 0})$ means that $A$ is positive semidefinite (negative semidefinite). We write $A^{\top}$ and $A^{-1}$ to respectively denote the transpose and the inverse of $A$. For a symmetric matrix $A \ge {\bf 0}$, $A^{\frac{1}{2}}$ is the unique symmetric matrix $B \ge 0$ such that $B^2=A$. The matrix $A$ is said to be Hurwitz if all its eigenvalues have negative real parts. $A$ is said to be Schur if all its eigenvalues have modulus smaller than one. The matrix $A$ is said to be positive if all its coefficients are positive. We also use $x(t^-)=\displaystyle\lim_{\delta\rightarrow 0,\ \delta>0} x(t - \delta)$. Given a function $\eta:(0,\varepsilon^*)\rightarrow \mathbb{R}$, we say that $\eta(\varepsilon)=\mathcal O(\varepsilon)$ if and only if there exists $\varepsilon_0 \in (0,\varepsilon^*)$ and $c>0$, such that for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_0)$, $|\eta(\varepsilon)| \le c \varepsilon$. \section{Problem formulation}\label{Problem formulation} In this paper, we consider a general class of singularly perturbed linear hybrid (i.e. switched and impulsive) systems. This class encompasses the case in which some slow varying variables switch to fast variation and/or reversely fast varying variables switch to slow variation. In order to formalize the system dynamics, let $\varepsilon >0$ be the small parameter characterizing the time scale separation between the slow and the fast dynamics. We consider a finite set of indices $\mathcal{I}$ and we introduce the diagonal matrices ${\bf D}^i$ for all $i\in \mathcal{I}$. Precisely, the diagonal elements of each ${\bf D}^i,\ i\in\mathcal{I}$ belong to the set $\{\varepsilon,1\}$ and they are used to select the fast and slow variables as explained below. We study switched systems of the form: \begin{equation}\label{general_fast_slow_dyn} {\bf D}^{\sigma_k}\dot{{\bf X}}(t)={\bf A}^{\sigma_k}{\bf X}(t), \ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \end{equation} with impulsive dynamics : \begin{equation}\label{original_reset-map} {\bf X}(t_k)={\bf J}^{\nu_k}{\bf X}(t_k^-), \quad \forall k \ge 1 \end{equation} where ${\bf X}(t)\in\mathbb{R}^{n_{\sigma_k}},\ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N}$, and $0=t_0 < t_1 < \dots$ \blue{is the monotonically increasing and unbounded sequence of instants} of discrete events (switches or impulses), $\sigma_k\in \mathcal{I}$ and $\nu_k \in \mathcal{J}$ with $\mathcal{I}$ and $\mathcal{J}$ finite sets of indices. For all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, ${\bf A}^{\sigma_k},{\bf D}^{\sigma_k}\in\mathbb{R}^{n_{\sigma_k}\times n_{\sigma_k}}$ and ${\bf J}^{\nu_k}\in\mathbb{R}^{n_{\sigma_k}\times n_{\sigma_{k-1}}}$ are matrices defining the continuous and impulsive dynamics. For all $i\in\mathcal{I}$, the matrix ${\bf D}^i$ is used to specify the slow and fast varying variables as follows: \begin{itemize} \item the $h$-th component of ${\bf X}$ has a fast variation when $\sigma_k=i$ if the $h$-th diagonal element of ${\bf D}^i$ equals $\varepsilon$; \item the $h$-th component of ${\bf X}$ has a slow variation when $\sigma_k=i$ if the $h$-th diagonal element of ${\bf D}^i$ equals $1$. \end{itemize} In the sequel, we will mainly focus on the case where the dimension of ${\bf X}$ is time-invariant ({\it i.e. } $n_{i}=n,\ \forall i\in\mathcal{I}$) and the number of slow and fast varying variables remains constant. In other words, the number of entries of ${\bf D}^i$ equal to $\varepsilon$ is constant, denoted by $n_z\le n$ for all $i\in \mathcal{I}$. This means that ${\bf X}$ has $n_z$ fast varying components and $n_x=n-n_z$ slow varying ones. \blue{This is without loss of generality, as we shall see in Section \ref{extension} that the case of time-varying dimensions $n$, $n_z$ and $n_x$ can be reduced to the case of fixed dimensions by adding artificial stable variables.} \begin{remark} The stability analysis of \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map} encompasses the analysis of several existing classes of singularly perturbed linear hybrid systems. To illustrate that, let us suppose that ${\bf D}^i={\bf D}^j, \forall i,j\in\mathcal{I}$ and denote by $x$ and $z$ the vectors of slow and fast components of ${\bf X}$, respectively. Then, system \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map} becomes a singularly perturbed linear hybrid system of the form: \[ \left\{\begin{split} \left(\begin{array}{c} \dot {x}(t)\\ \varepsilon \dot {z}(t)\\ \end{array}\right) &={\bf A}^{\sigma_k} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t)\\ z(t) \end{array}\right), \ \ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \\ \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k)\\ z(t_k) \end{array}\right)&={\bf J}^{\nu_k} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k^-)\\ z(t_k^-) \end{array}\right)\end{split}\right. \] \blue{We can then trivially recover singularly perturbed switched systems (when there is only one jump matrix given by the identity) and singularly perturbed impulsive systems (when there is only one flow matrix), which are studied in~\cite{Alwan-et-al2008,Malloci_et_al2010} and in~\cite{Simeonov1988,AbdelrahimPostoyan2015}, respectively. We also point out that this class of systems is a subclass of singularly perturbed hybrid systems studied in \cite{SanfeliceTeel2011}. Fundamental differences between our approach and these works have been highlighted in the introduction.} \end{remark} \subsection{Variable reordering} A first step in our analysis is to rewrite \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn} in a form where slow/fast variables remain slow/fast over time, independently of switches affecting the system's dynamics. To accomplish this step, for all $i\in\mathcal{I}$ we introduce the permutation matrix $S_i$ such that \begin{equation}\label{D-transf} S_i{\bf D}^i S_i^\top=\left(\begin{array}{cc} {\bf I}_{n_x} & {\bf 0}_{n_x,n_z}\\ {\bf 0}_{n_z,n_x} & \varepsilon{\bf I}_{n_z}\end{array}\right),\quad \forall i\in\mathcal{I} \end{equation} and define the time dependent change of variable \begin{equation}\label{var-transf} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t)\\ z(t) \end{array}\right)=S_{\sigma_k}{\bf X}(t), \ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \end{equation} where $x(t)\in \mathbb{R}^{n_x}$, $z(t)\in \mathbb{R}^{n_z}$. In other words, we use the matrix $S_i$ to permute the components of ${\bf X}$ such that the first $n_x$ ones are characterized by a slow variation while the rest of $n_z$ components have a fast variation. Let us also introduce the following matrices: \blue{ \begin{equation}\label{dyn-transf} A^{i}= S_{i}{\bf A}^{i} S_{i}^\top, \ J^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}= S_{i'}{\bf J}^{j}S_{i}^\top,\; \forall i,i' \in\mathcal{I},\ j \in\mathcal{J}. \end{equation} } Using the change of variable \eqref{var-transf} and taking into account the matrices definitions \eqref{D-transf} and \eqref{dyn-transf}, the general system \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map} is rewritten in the following equivalent form: \begin{equation}\label{equation_original} \left(\begin{array}{c} \dot {x}(t)\\ \varepsilon \dot {z}(t)\\ \end{array}\right) =A^{\sigma_k} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t)\\ z(t) \end{array}\right), \ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \end{equation} with impulsive dynamics: \blue{ \begin{equation}\label{reset-map} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k)\\ z(t_k) \end{array}\right)=J^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_{k}}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k^-)\\ z(t_k^-) \end{array}\right), \quad \forall k \ge 1 \end{equation} } \begin{remark} Switches and impulses can, but need not, be concomitant. Indeed, \blue{if $\sigma_k=\sigma_{k-1}$ and $J^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_{k}}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}}\ne {\bf I}_{n}$}, then at time $t_k$ an impulse occurs but no switch. Similarly, \blue{if ${\bf I}_{n} \in \{J^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} |\; i,i'\in \mathcal{I}, j\in \mathcal{J}\}$, then if $J^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_{k}}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}}={\bf I}_{n}$ and $\sigma_k\ne \sigma_{k-1}$}, then at time $t_k$ a switch occurs but no impulse. \end{remark} In general, stability analysis of \eqref{equation_original}-\eqref{reset-map} is a difficult task as it cannot be reduced to the analysis of the associated reduced (slow) and boundary layer (fast) systems, \blue{as shown in~\cite{Malloci_et_al2010}}. \blue{In the following, we will provide a new methodology based on singular perturbation techniques to characterize an upper-bound on the minimum dwell-time ensuring stability}. \subsection{Change of variable} \blue{ For $i,i'\in \mathcal{I}$, $j\in \mathcal{J}$, let \begin{equation*} A^i =\left(\begin{array}{cc}A_{11}^{i} & A_{12}^{i}\\ A_{21}^{i} & A_{22}^{i}\end{array}\right),\; J^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} =\left(\begin{array}{cc}J_{11}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} & J_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}\\ J_{21}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} & J_{22}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}\end{array}\right), \end{equation*} where $A_{11}^{i}, J_{11}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} \in \mathbb{R}^{n_x\times n_x}$, and $A_{22}^{i}$, $A_{12}^i$, $A_{21}^i$, $J_{22}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}$, $J_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}$, $J_{21}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}$ are of appropriate dimensions. } Let us impose the following standard assumption \cite{KokotovicBook} in the singular perturbation theory framework: \begin{assumption}\label{assumption_A22} $A_{22}^{i}$ is non-singular for all $i \in \mathcal{I}$. \end{assumption} Then, we perform the following time dependent change of variable: \begin{equation}\label{y_change} \left(\begin{array}{c}x(t)\\ y(t)\end{array}\right)=P_{\sigma_k}\left(\begin{array}{c}x(t)\\ z(t)\end{array}\right) ,\; \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \end{equation} where, for all $i\in \mathcal{I}$ \begin{equation*} P_{i}=\left(\begin{array}{cc}{\bf I}_{n_x} & {\bf 0}_{n_x,n_z}\\ (A_{22}^{i})^{-1}A_{21}^{i}& {\bf I}_{n_z}\end{array}\right). \end{equation*} It is worth noting that the matrix $P_i$ is invertible and for all $i\in \mathcal{I}$ \begin{equation*} P_{i}^{-1}=\left(\begin{array}{cc}{\bf I}_{n_x} & {\bf 0}_{n_x,n_z}\\ -(A_{22}^{i})^{-1}A_{21}^{i}& {\bf I}_{n_z}\end{array}\right). \end{equation*} Using \eqref{y_change}, the continuous dynamics \eqref{equation_original} in the variables $x,y$ becomes: \begin{equation}\label{system_fast_slow} \begin{split} \left(\begin{array}{c} \dot {x}(t)\\ \varepsilon \dot {y}(t)\\ \end{array}\right) =\left(\begin{array}{cc}A_0^{\sigma_k} & B_1^{\sigma_k}\\ \varepsilon B_2^{\sigma_k} & A_{22}^{\sigma_k}+\varepsilon B_3^{\sigma_k}\end{array}\right)\left(\begin{array}{c} x(t)\\ y(t) \end{array}\right), \\ \ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \end{split} \end{equation} where for all $i\in\mathcal{I}$ one has \begin{equation*} \begin{split} & A_{0}^{i} = A_{11}^{i}-A_{12}^{i} (A_{22}^{i})^{-1} A_{21}^{i}, \ B_{1}^{i}= A_{12}^{i}, \\ & B_2^{i}=(A_{22}^{i})^{-1} A_{21}^{i} A_{0}^{i}, \ B_3^{i}= (A_{22}^{i})^{-1} A_{21}^{i} A_{12}^{i}. \end{split} \end{equation*} Similarly, the impulsive dynamics \eqref{reset-map} is rewritten in the $x,y$ variables as: \begin{equation}\label{reset-map_fast-slow} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k)\\ y(t_k) \end{array}\right)=R^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_k}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k^-)\\ y(t_k^-) \end{array}\right), \quad \forall k \ge 1 \\ \end{equation} where for all $i,i' \in \mathcal{I}$, $j\in \mathcal{J}$, \blue{ \begin{equation*} R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}=P_{i'}J^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} P_{i}^{-1} = \left(\begin{array}{cc} R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{11} & R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{12}\\ R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{21} &R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{22} \end{array}\right) \end{equation*} } with \blue{ \begin{equation*} \begin{split} R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{11} =\; & J_{11}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} -J_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}(A_{22}^{i})^{-1}A_{21}^i, \\ R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{12} =\; & J_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}, \\ R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{21} =\; & (A_{22}^{i'})^{-1}A_{21}^{i'}(J_{11}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} -J_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}(A_{22}^{i})^{-1}A_{21}^i) \\ & + J_{21}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'} -J_{22}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}(A_{22}^{i})^{-1}A_{21}^i ,\\ R^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}_{22} =\; & (A_{22}^{i'})^{-1}A_{21}^{i'}J_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}+J_{22}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}. \end{split} \end{equation*} } One can then define the reduced order model, formally given by the switched system with single time scale: \begin{equation} \label{eq:reducflow} \dot x(t) = A_0^{\sigma_k} x(t), \ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \end{equation} with impulsive dynamics: \begin{equation}\label{eq:reducjump} x(t_k)=R^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_{k}}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}}_{11} x(t_k^-), \quad \forall k \ge 1. \end{equation} The goal of the paper is to investigate the stability of the general singularly perturbed linear hybrid system \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map}, or equivalently of \eqref{equation_original}-\eqref{reset-map} or of \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow}, for small values of the parameter $\varepsilon$, and its relation to the stability of the reduced order model \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump}. In particular, we aim at characterizing an upper-bound on the minimum dwell-time ensuring stability. \section{Preliminaries} \label{Preliminaries} In this section, we \blue{provide new} results on the Lyapunov stability of singularly perturbed linear systems, which will be used in the next sections to prove the main results of the paper concerning the stability of \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map}. \blue{The proofs of these results are stated in appendix.} Let us consider the singularly perturbed linear system: \begin{equation}\label{classic_system} \left\{ \begin{split} \dot {x}(t)&=A_{11}x(t)+ A_{12}z(t)\\ \varepsilon \dot {z}(t)&=A_{21} x(t) + A_{22}z(t)\\ \end{split}\right. \end{equation} where $x(t) \in \mathbb{R}^{n_x}$, $z(t) \in \mathbb{R}^{n_z} $ and $\varepsilon >0$ is a small parameter. Let us assume that $A_{22}$ is non-singular and proceed with the change of variable \begin{equation}\label{classic_change} \left(\begin{array}{c}x(t)\\ y(t)\end{array}\right)=\left(\begin{array}{cc}{\bf I}_{n_x} & {\bf 0}_{n_x,n_z}\\ A_{22}^{-1}A_{21}& {\bf I}_{n_z}\end{array}\right)\left(\begin{array}{c}x(t)\\ z(t)\end{array}\right). \end{equation} In the variables $x,y$ the system becomes: \begin{equation}\label{equation_simple} \begin{cases} \dot {x}(t)=A_{0} x(t)+ B_{1} y(t)\\ \varepsilon \dot {y}(t)= A_{22} y(t) + \varepsilon (B_{2} x(t) + B_{3} y(t))\\ \end{cases} \end{equation} where \begin{align*} A_{0} = A_{11}-A_{12} A_{22}^{-1} A_{21}, \ B_{1}= A_{12}, \\ B_2=A_{22}^{-1} A_{21}A_{0}, \ B_3= A_{22}^{-1} A_{21}A_{12}.\end{align*} Let us make the following assumption: \begin{assumption}\label{assum:linear} $A_0$ and $A_{22}$ are Hurwitz. \end{assumption} Under the previous assumption, there exist symmetric positive definite matrices $Q_s \geq {\bf I}_{n_x}$, $Q_f \geq {\bf I}_{n_z}$ and positive numbers $\lambda_s$ and $\lambda_f$ such that: \begin{equation*} \begin{split} A_0^{\top} Q_s +Q_s A_0^{\top} &\leq -2 \lambda_s Q_s\\ A_{22}^{\top} Q_f +Q_f A_{22}^{\top} &\leq -2 \lambda_f Q_f \end{split} \end{equation*} \blue{Then, let us define $ b_1 =\big\|Q_s^{\frac{1}{2}} B_1Q_f^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\| ,\ b_2= \big\|Q_f^{\frac{1}{2}}B_2 Q_s^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|$ and $ b_3= \big\|Q_f^{\frac{1}{2}}Q_f B_3Q_f^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|$.}\\ \blue{The next results are instrumental for our development and their proofs are provided in the Appendix.} \blue{ \begin{proposition}\label{Proposition1} Under Assumption~\ref{assum:linear}, $$V(x,y) = x^{\top} Q_s x + y^{\top} Q_f y $$ is a Lyapunov function for system \eqref{equation_simple} for all $ \varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_1]$ where \begin{equation}\label{epsilon1} \varepsilon_1 = \frac{\lambda_f}{\frac{(b_1+b_2)^{2}}{4\lambda_s}+{b_3}}. \end{equation} \end{proposition}} In the following, let us denote \ $W_s(t)=\sqrt{x(t)^{\top}Q_s x(t)}$ and $W_f(t)=\sqrt{y(t)^{\top} Q_f y(t)}$. \begin{proposition}\label{Proposition2} Under Assumption~\ref{assum:linear}, let $\varepsilon_1$ be given by \eqref{epsilon1}, then for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_1]$ and $t \geq 0$ $$W_f(t)\leq W_f(0) \mbox{e}^{-\frac{\lambda_f}{\varepsilon}t}+ \varepsilon \beta_1 \sqrt{V(0)} $$ where $\beta_1 = \frac{\sqrt{b_2^2+b_3^2}}{\lambda_f}$. \end{proposition} \begin{proposition} \label{Proposition3} Under Assumption~\ref{assum:linear}, let $\varepsilon_1$ be given by \eqref{epsilon1}, and let \blue{$\varepsilon_2 \in (0, \varepsilon_1] \cap (0,\frac{\lambda_f}{\lambda_s})$} then for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_2]$ and $t \geq 0$ \begin{equation*} \begin{split} W_s(t) \leq \;& W_s(0) \mbox{e}^{-\lambda_s t}+ \varepsilon \beta_2 W_f(0) + \varepsilon \beta_3 \sqrt{V(0)} \end{split} \end{equation*} where $\beta_2=\frac{b_1}{\lambda_f-\varepsilon_2\lambda_s} $ and $\beta_3=\frac{b_1 \beta_1}{\lambda_s}$. \end{proposition} \section{Stability analysis}\label{Sec:stability} We now study the stability of system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} (or equivalently of \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map} or of \eqref{equation_original}-\eqref{reset-map}). In the rest of the paper, we impose the following additional assumption on the singularly perturbed system at hand, related to the stability of the slow and fast dynamics of each mode. \begin{assumption}\label{assumption_2} $A_0^{i}$ and $A_{22}^{i}$ are Hurwitz for all $i\in\mathcal{I}$. \end{assumption} \blue{ From the previous assumption, we can deduce that there exist symmetric positive definite matrices $Q^{i}_s\geq {\bf I}_{n_x}$, $Q_f^{i} \geq {\bf I}_{n_z} $, $i \in \mathcal{I}$, and positive numbers $\lambda^i_s$ and $\lambda^i_f$ such that for all $i \in \mathcal{I}$: \begin{equation*} \begin{split} A_0^{i^{\top}} Q^{i}_s +Q^{i}_s A_0^{i} &\leq -2 \lambda^i_s Q^{i}_s\\ A_{22}^{i^{\top}} Q^{i}_f +Q_f^{i} A_{22}^{i} &\leq -2 \lambda^i_f Q_f^{i} \end{split} \end{equation*} We denote $\lambda_s= \displaystyle \min_{i \in \mathcal{I}}\lambda_s^i$ and $\lambda_f= \displaystyle \min_{i \in \mathcal{I}}\lambda_f^i$.} For each $i \in \mathcal{I}$, let $b_1^i= \big\|(Q^i_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} B_1(Q_f^i)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\| $,\ $b_2^i= \big\|(Q^i_f)^{\frac{1}{2}}B_2 (Q^i_s)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|$,\ $b_3^i=\big\|(Q_f^i)^{\frac{1}{2}}Q_f B_3(Q_f^i)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|$ and $b_j = \displaystyle \max_{i \in \mathcal{I}}b_j^i$ , $j =1,\ldots,3$. Let $\varepsilon_1$ be given by \eqref{epsilon1}, then it follows from Proposition \ref{Proposition1} that the linear dynamics of \eqref{system_fast_slow} are all Lyapunov stable, for $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_1]$. Let \blue{$\varepsilon_2 \in (0, \varepsilon_1] \cap (0,\frac{\lambda_f}{\lambda_s})$} and $\beta_1,\ \beta_2,\ \beta_3$ be defined as in Propositions \ref{Proposition2} and \ref{Proposition3}. The stability analysis of system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is carried out using the following functions \begin{equation*} \left\{ \begin{array}{l} W_s(t)=\sqrt{x(t)^{\top}Q^{\sigma_k}_s x(t)} \\ W_f(t)=\sqrt{y(t)^{\top} Q^{\sigma_k}_f y(t)} \end{array} \right. ,\; \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}),\; k\in \mathbb{N}. \end{equation*} The next result characterizes the variation of $W_s$ and $W_f$ during the continuous dynamics between two events: \begin{lemma}\label{lemma_1} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let \blue{$\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_2]$}, and let $\uptau_k =t_{k+1}-t_k$ for a sequence $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times. Then for all $k \in \mathbb{N}$, \begin{align} \nonumber W_s(t_{k+1}^-)\leq \;& W_s(t_{k})(\mbox{e}^{-\lambda_s \uptau_{k}}+\varepsilon\beta_3) +W_f(t_{k}) \varepsilon (\beta_2+\beta_3)\\ \nonumber W_f(t_{k+1}^-)\leq \;& W_s(t_{k})\varepsilon\beta_1 + W_f(t_{k})\big(\mbox{e}^{-\frac{\lambda_f}{\varepsilon}\uptau_{k}}+\varepsilon\beta_1 \big). \end{align} \end{lemma} \begin{IEEEproof} This is straightforward from Propositions \ref{Proposition2} and \ref{Proposition3} by remarking that $\sqrt{V}\leq W_s + W_f$. \end{IEEEproof} In the following we complete the characterization of the variation of $W_s$ and $W_f$ by analyzing their behavior when an event occurs. Let $\gamma_{11}$, $\gamma_{12}$, $\gamma_{21}$, $\gamma_{22}$ be defined as: \begin{equation} \label{eq:gamma} \begin{split} \gamma_{11} = \;& \max_{i,i'\in \mathcal{I},j\in \mathcal{J}}\big\| (Q^{i'}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{11}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow}i'} (Q^{i}_s)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|, \\ \gamma_{12} = \;& \max_{i,i'\in \mathcal{I},j\in \mathcal{J}}\big\|(Q^{i'}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow}i'} (Q^{i}_f)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|, \\ \gamma_{21} = \;& \max_{i,i'\in \mathcal{I},j\in \mathcal{J}}\big\|(Q^{i'}_f)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{21}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow}i'} (Q^{i}_s)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|, \\ \gamma_{22} = \;& \max_{i,i'\in \mathcal{I},j\in \mathcal{J}}\big\|(Q^{i'}_f)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{22}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow}i'} (Q^{i}_f)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\big\|. \end{split} \end{equation} Then, we have the following result: \begin{lemma}\label{lemma_2} Let a sequence $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times, then for all $k \ge 1$, \begin{align*} W_s(t_{k})\leq \;& \gamma_{11} W_s(t_{k}^-) +\gamma_{12} W_f(t_{k}^-) \\ W_f(t_{k})\leq \;& \gamma_{21}W_s(t_{k}^-)+ \gamma_{22} W_f(t_{k}^-). \end{align*} \end{lemma} \begin{IEEEproof} We prove the first inequality: \begin{equation*} \begin{split} W_s(t_k)=\;& \sqrt{x(t_k)^{\top}Q^{\sigma_k}_s x(t_k)} = \big\| (Q^{\sigma_k}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}}x(t_k) \big\| \\ \le\; & \big\| (Q^{\sigma_k}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} \big(R_{11}^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_k}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} x(t_k^-) +R_{12}^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_k}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} y(t_k^-)\big)\big\| \\ \le \; & \big\| (Q^{\sigma_k}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{11}^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_k}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} x(t_k^-) \big\| \\ & + \big\| (Q^{\sigma_k}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{12}^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_k}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} y(t_k^-)\big)\big\| \\ \le \; & \big\| (Q^{\sigma_k}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{11}^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_k}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} (Q^{\sigma_{k-1}}_s)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \big\| W_s(t_k^-) \\ &+\big\| (Q^{\sigma_k}_s)^{\frac{1}{2}} R_{12}^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_k}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} (Q^{\sigma_{k-1}}_f)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \big\| W_f(t_k^-) \\ \le \;& \gamma_{11} W_s(t_{k}^-) +\gamma_{12} W_f(t_{k}^-). \end{split} \end{equation*} The second inequality is obtained similarly. \end{IEEEproof} In order to keep the notation simple, we introduce the positive matrix parameterized by $\uptau>0$: \begin{equation*} M_{\uptau}= \left(\begin{array}{cc} \mbox{e}^{-\lambda_s \uptau}+\varepsilon \beta_3& \varepsilon (\beta_2 +\beta_3) \\ \varepsilon \beta_1 & \mbox{e}^{-\frac{\lambda_f}{\varepsilon}\uptau}+ \varepsilon \beta_1 \end{array}\right). \end{equation*} Let us also consider the positive matrix \begin{equation*} \Gamma = \left( \begin{array}{cc} \gamma_{11} & \gamma_{12} \\ \gamma_{21} & \gamma_{22} \end{array} \right). \end{equation*} \begin{lemma}\label{lemma_3} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let \blue{$\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_2]$}, and let $\uptau_k =t_{k+1}-t_k$ for a sequence $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times. Then for all $k \in \mathbb{N}$, \begin{align*} \left(\begin{array}{c} W_s(t_{k+1})\\ W_f(t_{k+1}) \end{array}\right)& \leq \Gamma M_{\uptau_k} \left(\begin{array}{c} W_s(t_{k})\\ W_f(t_{k}) \end{array}\right). \end{align*} \end{lemma} \begin{IEEEproof} This is straightforward from Lemmas~\ref{lemma_1} and \ref{lemma_2}. \end{IEEEproof} \begin{lemma} \label{lem:stabschur} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let \blue{$\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_2]$} and let $\uptau^* \ge 0$ such that the positive matrix $\Gamma M_{\uptau^*}$ is Schur. Then, for all sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times satisfying the dwell-time property $\uptau_k\ge \uptau^*$, for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, the system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{lemma} \begin{IEEEproof} From Lemma~\ref{lemma_3}, it follows that for all $k \in \mathbb{N}$, \begin{equation*} \left(\begin{array}{c} W_s(t_{k})\\ W_f(t_{k}) \end{array}\right) \leq \Gamma M_{\uptau_{k-1}} \dots \Gamma M_{\uptau_0} \left(\begin{array}{c} W_s(t_{0})\\ W_f(t_{0})\end{array}\right). \end{equation*} Remarking that the coefficient of the positive matrix $M_\tau$ are decreasing with respect to $\uptau$, it follows that \begin{equation*} \left(\begin{array}{c} W_s(t_{k})\\ W_f(t_{k}) \end{array}\right) \leq \big(\Gamma M_{\uptau^*}\big)^k \left(\begin{array}{c} W_s(t_{0})\\ W_f(t_{0})\end{array}\right). \end{equation*} Hence, if the positive matrix $\Gamma M_{\uptau^*}$ is Schur, then both sequences $( W_s(t_{k}))_{k\geq0}$ and $(W_f(t_{k}))_{k\geq0}$ go to $0$, and the system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{IEEEproof} Hence, the stability of system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} can be investigated by studying the spectral properties of the positive matrix $\Gamma M_{\uptau^*}$. \blue{Let us remark that values $\uptau^*$ such that $\Gamma M_{\uptau^*}$ is Schur provide upper bounds on the minimal dwell-time between two events that ensures the stability of the singularly perturbed linear hybrid system. In the following, we establish sufficient conditions for deriving such values $\uptau^*$. The proofs are provided in appendix.} We consider three distinct cases depending on the value of parameter $\gamma_{11}$ defined in~\eqref{eq:gamma}. \subsection{Case 1: \blue{$\gamma_{11}>1$}} \begin{theorem} \label{theorem_final} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let $\gamma_{11}>1$. Then, there exists $\varepsilon_1^*>0$ and a function $\eta_1: (0,\varepsilon_1^*)\rightarrow \mathbb{R}^+$ with $\eta_1(\varepsilon)=\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$, such that for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_1^*)$, for all sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times satisfying a dwell-time property $\uptau_k\ge \uptau^*$, for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, with \begin{equation*} \uptau^* > \frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}+\eta_1(\varepsilon), \end{equation*} the system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{theorem} Theorem~\ref{theorem_final} shows that a dwell-time ensuring stability of the singularly perturbed switched impulsive system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} can be written as the sum of a constant part $\frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}$ and of a function $\eta_1(\varepsilon)$, which goes to $0$ as fast as $\varepsilon$ when $\varepsilon$ goes to $0$. \blue{Interestingly, the constant part only depends on $\lambda_s$ and $\gamma_{11}$, which can be determined only from the reduced order model \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump}. Moreover, we will show in Section~\ref{sec:red} that \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} is globally asymptotically stable for all switching signals with dwell-time $\tau^*>\frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}$.} \subsection{Case 2: $\gamma_{11}=1$} When $\gamma_{11}= 1$, two cases can be distinguished depending on whether $\gamma_{12}\ne 0$ or $\gamma_{12}=0$. In the latter case, this means that the slow variable $x$ is not influenced by the fast variable $y$ through jumps \blue{(i.e. $J_{12}^{i\stackrel{j}{\rightarrow} i'}=0$ for all $i,i' \in \mathcal{I}$, $j\in \mathcal{J}$)}. \begin{theorem}\label{theorem_final2} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let $\gamma_{11}= 1$ \blue{and $\gamma_{12}\neq0$.} Then, there exists $\varepsilon_2^*>0$ and a function $\eta_2: (0,\varepsilon_2^*)\rightarrow \mathbb{R}^+$ with $\eta_2(\varepsilon)=\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$, such that for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_2^*)$, for all sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times satisfying a dwell-time property $\uptau_k\ge \uptau^*$, for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, with \begin{equation*} \uptau^* > \frac{-\varepsilon}{\lambda_f}\ln(\varepsilon)+\eta_2(\varepsilon), \end{equation*} the system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{theorem} \begin{theorem}\label{theorem_final3} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let $\gamma_{11}= 1$ and $\gamma_{12}=0$. Then, there exists $\varepsilon_3^*>0$ and a function $\eta_3: (0,\varepsilon_3^*)\rightarrow \mathbb{R}^+$ with $\eta_3(\varepsilon)=\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$, such that for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_3^*)$, for all sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times satisfying a dwell-time property $\uptau_k\ge \uptau^*$, for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, with \begin{equation*} \uptau^* > \eta_3(\varepsilon), \end{equation*} the system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{theorem} The previous theorems show that when $\gamma_{11} = 1$, the minimum dwell-time ensuring stability of the singularly perturbed switched impulsive system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} goes to $0$ as fast as $-\varepsilon \ln(\varepsilon)$ or $\varepsilon$ when $\varepsilon$ goes to $0$. It is interesting to remark that in that case, as we will show in Section~\ref{sec:red}, the reduced order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} is globally asymptotically stable for all switching signals without any dwell-time condition. It is also noticeable that when $\gamma_{12}\ne 0$, the dwell-time is larger (by a factor of order $-\ln(\varepsilon)$) than when $\gamma_{12}=0$. In the former case, more time is needed to stabilize the fast variable $y$ so that it does not destabilize the slow variable through the impulsive dynamics. \subsection{Case 3: $\gamma_{11} <1$} When $\gamma_{11}<1$ one can again distinguish two cases depending on the values of other parameters $\gamma_{12}$, $\gamma_{21}$ and $\gamma_{22}$. \begin{theorem}\label{theorem_final4} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let $\gamma_{11}< 1$. Then, there exists $\varepsilon_4^*>0$ and a function $\eta_4: (0,\varepsilon_4^*)\rightarrow \mathbb{R}^+$ with $\eta_4(\varepsilon)=\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$, such that for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_4^*)$, for all sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times satisfying a dwell-time property $\uptau_k\ge \uptau^*$, for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, with \begin{equation*} \uptau^* > \eta_4(\varepsilon), \end{equation*} the system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{theorem} \begin{theorem}\label{theorem_final5} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let $\gamma_{11}< 1$, $\gamma_{22}<1$ and $\frac{\gamma_{12}\gamma_{21}}{(1-\gamma_{11})(1-\gamma_{22})}<1$. Then, there exists $\varepsilon_5^*>0$, such that for all $\varepsilon \in (0,\varepsilon_5^*)$, for all sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times, the system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{theorem} The previous theorems show that when $\gamma_{11} < 1$, the minimum dwell-time ensuring stability of the singularly perturbed switched impulsive system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} is either equal to $0$ or goes to $0$ as f ast as $\varepsilon$ when $\varepsilon$ goes to $0$. We will show in the next section that in that case, the reduced order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} is globally asymptotically stable for all switching signals without any dwell-time condition. \begin{table*}[!t] \caption{\label{tab} Summary of the main results of the paper establishing dwell-time conditions for the stability of the singularly perturbed hybrid system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} and of the the reduced order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump}.} \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|} \hline $\gamma_{11}$ & $\gamma_{12},\; \gamma_{21},\; \gamma_{22}$ & dwell-time condition for \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} & dwell-time condition for \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} \\ \hline $\gamma_{11}>1$ & -- & $\uptau^* > \frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s} + \mathcal O(\varepsilon)$& $\uptau^* > \frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}$ \\ \hline \multirow{2}*{$\gamma_{11}=1$} & -- & $\uptau^* > -\frac{\varepsilon}{\lambda_f}\ln(\varepsilon) + \mathcal O(\varepsilon)$& \multirow{4}*{$\uptau^* \ge 0$} \\ \cline{2-3} & $\gamma_{12}=0$ & \multirow{2}*{$\uptau^* > \mathcal O(\varepsilon)$} &\\ \cline{1-2} \multirow{2}*{$\gamma_{11}<1$} & -- & & \\ \cline{2-3} & $\gamma_{22}<1$, $\frac{\gamma_{12}\gamma_{21}}{(1-\gamma_{11})(1-\gamma_{22})}<1$ & $\uptau^* \ge 0$ &\\ \hline \end{tabular} \end{center} \end{table*} \subsection{Stability of reduced order system} \label{sec:red} \blue{ It is interesting to remark that in the previous results, the upper bound on the minimum dwell-time ensuring stability of system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} can be seen as the sum of two terms. The first term is independent of the parameter $\varepsilon$, its value is $0$ when $\gamma_{11}\le 1$ and $\frac{\ln{\gamma_{11}}}{\lambda_s}$ when $\gamma_{11}>1$. The second term depends on the parameter $\varepsilon$ and goes to $0$ when $\varepsilon$ goes to $0$. In this section, we show that an interpretation of the first term can be given in terms of the reduced-order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump}, since it provides an upper bound on the minimum dwell-time guaranteeing stability for that system.} \begin{proposition}\label{pro:red1} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let $\gamma_{11}>1$. Then, for all sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times satisfying a dwell-time property $\uptau_k\ge \uptau^*$ with $\uptau^* > \frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}$, for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, the reduced order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{proposition} \begin{IEEEproof} We consider the function $W_s$ given by $W_s(t)=\sqrt{x(t)^\top Q_s^{\sigma_k} x(t)}$, for all $t\in [t_k,t_{k+1})$, $k\in \mathbb{N}$. By Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, it follows that for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, $W_s(t_{k+1}^-)\le W_s(t_k) e^{-\lambda_s \uptau_k} $. Moreover, from the definition of $\gamma_{11}$ in \eqref{eq:gamma}, it follows that for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, $W_s(t_{k+1})\le W_s(t_{k+1}^-) \gamma_{11}$. Hence, \begin{equation} \label{eq:lyapred} \forall k\in \mathbb{N},\; W_s(t_{k+1})\le W_s(t_k) \gamma_{11} e^{-\lambda_s \uptau_k}. \end{equation} Then, since for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, $\uptau_k\ge \uptau^*$ with $\uptau^* > \frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}$, it follows that $W_s(t_k)$ goes to $0$ as $k$ goes to $+\infty$ and the reduced order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{IEEEproof} \begin{proposition}\label{pro:red2} Under Assumption~\ref{assumption_2}, let $\gamma_{11}\le 1$. Then, for all \blue{unbounded} sequences $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ of event times, the reduced order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{proposition} \begin{IEEEproof} From \eqref{eq:lyapred}, it follows from \blue{$\gamma_{11}\le 1$} that for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, $W_s(t_{k+1})\le W_s(t_k) e^{-\lambda_s \uptau_k}$. Therefore, for all $k\in \mathbb{N}$, $W_s(t_k) \le W_s(0) e^{-\lambda_s t_k}$. \blue{Since $(t_k)_{k\geq0} $ is unbounded}, $t_k$ goes to $+\infty$ and therefore $W_s(t_k)$ goes to $0$. Thus, the reduced order system \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump} is globally asymptotically stable. \end{IEEEproof} The previous propositions show that the dwell-time condition established for the singularly perturbed hybrid system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} in Theorems~\ref{theorem_final}, \ref{theorem_final2}, \ref{theorem_final3}, \ref{theorem_final4} and \ref{theorem_final5} coincides when $\varepsilon$ goes to $0$ with the dwell-time condition of the reduced order system given in \eqref{eq:reducflow}-\eqref{eq:reducjump}. \blue{Since $\varepsilon$ is assumed to be small, it appears that the main source of conservatism in the dwell-time estimates for the singularly perturbed hybrid system \eqref{system_fast_slow}-\eqref{reset-map_fast-slow} comes from the dwell-time estimates of the reduced order system.} Table~\ref{tab} summarizes the main results of the paper. \section{Extension to the case of time varying state's dimensions vectors}\label{extension} In this section, we briefly explain how we can use the previous results for the analysis of system \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map} in the case of time-varying dimensions of the slow and fast state vectors. We recall that for all $t\in [t_k,t_{k+1})$ the state vector ${\bf X}(t)$ of system \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn} is of dimension $n_i$ when $\sigma_k=i$. Let us also recall that matrices ${\bf D}^i,\ i\in\mathcal{I}$ were introduced in section \ref{Problem formulation} to define the dynamics \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}. For all $i\in\mathcal{I}$ we consider that $n_{zi}\in\mathbb{N}$ is the number of elements of ${\bf D}^i$ that are equal with $\varepsilon$ and $n_{xi}=n_i-n_{zi}$. In other words, when $\sigma_k=i$, $n_i, n_{zi}$ and $n_{xi}$ are the dimensions of the state vector, fast variables vector and slow variables vector, respectively. Furthermore, let us introduce $n_z=\displaystyle\max_{i\in\mathcal{I}}n_{zi}$, $n_x=\displaystyle\max_{i\in\mathcal{I}}n_{xi}$ and $n=n_x+n_z$. With the notation introduced above we define the following augmented system: \begin{equation}\label{augmented_fast_slow_dyn} \left\{\begin{split} {\bf D}^{\sigma_k}\dot{{\bf X}}(t)={\bf A}^{\sigma_k}{\bf X}(t), \\ \bar{{\bf D}}^{\sigma_k}\dot{\bar{{\bf X}}}(t)=-\lambda \bar{{\bf X}}(t) , \end{split}\right. \quad \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \end{equation} where $\bar{{\bf D}}^{i}\in\mathbb{R}^{(n-n_{i})\times (n-n_{i})}$ is defined similarly to ${\bf D}^{i}$ as a diagonal matrix with $\varepsilon$ or $1$ diagonal elements, used to select the fast and slow variable from the components of the artificial state vector $\bar{{\bf X}}$. To be precise, for all $i\in\mathcal{I}$ we consider $\bar{{\bf D}}^{i}$ having $n_z-n_{zi}$ diagonal elements equal to $\varepsilon$. Consequently, the augmented vector $\left(\begin{smallmatrix} {\bf X}(t)\\ \bar{{\bf X}}(t)\end{smallmatrix}\right)$ has an invariant number of slow and fast components which is $n_x$ and $n_z$, respectively. Therefore, \eqref{augmented_fast_slow_dyn} is of the form \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn} and the dimension of its state vector as well as the number of its slow and fast variables are constant. The parameter $\lambda$ is a positive number that can be chosen greater than $\lambda_s$ and $\lambda_f$ in order to make the continuous dynamics of the auxiliary variable $\bar {\bf X}(t)$ converge faster than that of the variable ${\bf X}(t)$. Secondly, we define a jump map for the augmented vector as follows: \begin{equation}\label{extended_jump-map} \left\{\begin{array}{lll} {\bf X}(t_k) &= &{\bf J}^{\nu_k} {\bf X}(t_k^-) \\ \bar{{\bf X}}(t_k)& =& 0 \end{array}\right. \end{equation} The auxiliary variable is set to $0$ at jumps so that the discrete dynamics of the auxiliary variable $\bar {\bf X}(t)$ converge faster than that of the variable ${\bf X}(t)$. It is clear that the augmented system \eqref{augmented_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{extended_jump-map} is globally asymptotically stable if and only if the orignal system \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{original_reset-map} is. Then, the stability analysis of \eqref{augmented_fast_slow_dyn}-\eqref{extended_jump-map} can be carried out as shown on the previous sections. \section{Illustration on stability analysis of scalar fast and slow dynamics}\label{sec:scalar} \subsection{Dwell-time analysis} This section aims to illustrate the previous analysis on a low dimensional system. We consider a linear singularly perturbed switched system with scalar slow and fast variables. Moreover, we consider that $\mathcal{I}=\{1,2\}$. The objective is to analyze the stability of the system under the assumption that after each switch the slow variable becomes fast and vice-versa. To be more precise let $0=t_0 < t_1 < \dots$ be the sequence of discrete instants where a switch takes place and consider the following dynamics: \begin{equation}\label{mode1} \left\{\begin{array}{l}\dot{u}(t)=a_1u(t)+b_1v(t)\\ \varepsilon\dot{v}(t)=c_1u(t)+d_1v(t)\end{array}\right. \ t\in[t_{2k},t_{2k+1}), k\in\mathbb{N} \end{equation} and \begin{equation}\label{mode2} \left\{\begin{array}{l} \varepsilon\dot{u}(t)=a_2u(t)+b_2v(t)\\ \dot{v}(t)=c_2u(t)+d_2v(t)\end{array}\right. \ t\in[t_{2k+1},t_{2k+2}), k\in\mathbb{N} \end{equation} The dynamics \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} above can be written in the compact form \eqref{general_fast_slow_dyn} by using ${\bf X}=(u,v)^\top$ and the matrices \[{\bf D}^1=\left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 0\\ 0 & \varepsilon\end{array}\right),\quad {\bf D}^2=\left(\begin{array}{cc}\varepsilon & 0\\ 0 & 1\end{array}\right)\] and \[{\bf A}^1=\left(\begin{array}{cc}a_1 & b_1\\ c_1 & d_1\end{array}\right),\quad {\bf A}^2=\left(\begin{array}{cc}a_2 & b_2\\ c_2 & d_2\end{array}\right).\] Introducing the permutation matrices $S_1={\bf I}_2$ and $S_2=\left(\begin{smallmatrix}0 & 1\\ 1 & 0\end{smallmatrix}\right)$ we can define the change of variable \eqref{var-transf} as \[\left\{\begin{split} (x,z)^\top&=S_1{\bf X}, \ t\in[t_{2k},t_{2k+1}), k\in\mathbb{N}, \\ (x,z)^\top&=S_2{\bf X}, \ t\in[t_{2k+1},t_{2k+2}), k\in\mathbb{N}. \end{split}\right.\] It is worth notting that no jump occurs in the ${\bf X}$ variable meaning that $\mathcal{J}=\{1\}$ and ${\bf J}^1={\bf I}_2$ in \eqref{original_reset-map}. However, it can be seen that the dynamics \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} expressed in $(x,z)^\top$ variable is an impulsive one. Precisely, $\mathcal{J}=\{1\}$ but following \eqref{dyn-transf} one obtains that \blue{$J^{1\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 2}=J^{2\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 1}=S_2$}. Summarizing we can rewrite system \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} in the form \[ \left(\begin{array}{c} \dot {x}(t)\\ \varepsilon \dot {z}(t)\\ \end{array}\right) =A^{\sigma_k} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t)\\ z(t) \end{array}\right), \ \forall t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N} \] with impulsive dynamics: \blue{ \[ \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k)\\ z(t_k) \end{array}\right)=J^{\sigma_{k-1}\stackrel{\nu_{k}}{\rightarrow} \sigma_{k}} \left(\begin{array}{c} x(t_k^-)\\ z(t_k^-) \end{array}\right), \quad \forall k \ge 1 \] } where $\sigma_k\in \mathcal{I}=\{1,2\}$, $\nu_k \in \mathcal{J}=\{1\}$, \blue{$J^{1\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 2}=J^{2\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 1}=S_2$}, $A^1=S_1{\bf A}^1S_1^\top={\bf A}^1$ and $A^2=S_2{\bf A}^2S_2^\top=\left(\begin{smallmatrix}d_2 & c_2\\ b_2 & a_2\end{smallmatrix}\right)$. The time dependent change of coordinates \eqref{y_change} is expressed as: \begin{equation}\label{y_change_scalar} \begin{split} &y(t)=z(t)+\frac{c_1}{d_1}x(t),\ t\in [t_k,t_{k+1}), \; k\in \mathbb{N},\\ &y(t)=z(t)+\frac{b_2}{a_2}x(t),\ t\in[t_{2k+1},t_{2k+2}), k\in\mathbb{N}. \end{split} \end{equation} \blue{ Assumption \ref{assumption_2} simply requires that \[\left\{\begin{split}A_0^1=a_1-\frac{b_1c_1}{d_1}<0, \quad A_{22}^1=d_1<0, \\ A_0^2=d_2-\frac{b_2c_2}{a_2}<0,\quad A_{22}^2=a_2<0.\end{split}\right.\] Then, $Q_s^i,\ Q_f^i$, $i\in \mathcal{I}$ can be chosen as any positive scalars and it is easy to check that $$ \lambda_s=\min\left(\frac{b_1c_1}{d_1}-a_1,\frac{b_2c_2}{a_2}-d_2 \right),\; \lambda_f=\min(-d_1,-a_2). $$ In our analysis, an important role is played by the values $R_{11}^{1\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 2}$ and $R_{11}^{2\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 1}$, which determine the value of $\gamma_{11}$, which in turn (see Theorems \ref{theorem_final}-\ref{theorem_final5} and Table \ref{tab}) allows concluding wether the required dwell time approaches $0$ when $\varepsilon$ goes to $0$. Therefore it is worth to explicit that: \[ R_{11}^{1\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 2}=-\frac{c_1}{d_1},\quad R_{11}^{2\stackrel{1}{\rightarrow} 1}=-\frac{b_2}{a_2}. \] Furthermore, following \eqref{eq:gamma} one has $$ \gamma_{11}=\max\left(\left| \frac{qc_1}{d_1}\right| , \left|\frac{b_2}{qa_2}\right| \right) $$ where $q=\sqrt{\frac{Q_s^2}{Q_s^1}}$. For our analysis, it is desirable to have $\gamma_{11}$ as small as possible, it is minimal when $q=\sqrt{ \frac{|d_1b_2|}{|c_1a_2|}}$ and in that case $$ \gamma_{11}=\sqrt{ \frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}}. $$ Then, $\gamma_{11}<1$ if and only if $\frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}<1$ and following Theorem \ref{theorem_final4}, a dwell-time of order $O(\varepsilon)$ is sufficient to stabilize the system. When $\varepsilon\rightarrow0$ it yields that the switching system given by the two slow manifolds of \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} is stable whatever is the considered switching rule ({\it i.e. } no dwell-time required). This result is illustrated in Fig. \ref{fig_num1} which takes into account that the two slow manifolds of \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} are the lines: \[ c_1u(t)+d_1v(t)=0 \mbox{ and } a_2u(t)+b_2v(t)=0. \] It is noteworthy that $\frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}<1$ essentially says that the slope of the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode1} is smaller than the slope of the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode2}.} \begin{figure}[h] \begin{center} \begin{tikzpicture}[scale = 0.9, transform shape, thick] \tikzstyle{fleche}=[->, >=stealth,thick,rounded corners=4pt] \draw[fleche] (-1,0) -- (6,0) node[anchor=north west] {$u$}; \draw[fleche] (0,-1) -- (0,6) node[anchor=south east] {$v$}; \draw[blue] (-1,-0.5) --(6,3); \draw[red] (-0.5,-1) --(3,6); \node[rotate=63] at (1.8,4) {$a_2u+b_2v=0$}; \node[rotate=26] at (4,1.8) {$c_1u+d_1v=0$}; \draw[fleche,blue,dashed] (3,3) -- (3,1.5); \draw[fleche,red,dashed] (3,1.5) -- (0.75,1.5); \draw[fleche,blue,dashed] (0.75,1.5) -- (0.75,0.326); \draw[fleche,red,dashed] (0.7,0.325) -- (0.1625,0.325); \node at (3,3.2) {$(u_0,v_0)$}; \end{tikzpicture} \end{center} \caption{In blue the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode1} and in red the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode2} when $\frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}<1$. The dashed lines represent the asymptotic behavior of the overall system with initial state $(u_0,v_0)$ when $\varepsilon\rightarrow0$ and no dwell-time (or $\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$ dwell-time) is imposed. It can be seen that system \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} is asymptotically stable for any switching rule.}\label{fig_num1} \end{figure} \blue{Reversely, $\gamma_{11}>1$ if and only if $\frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}>1$, meaning that the slope of the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode2} is smaller than the slope of the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode1}. In this case we use Theorem \ref{theorem_final} to deduce that a dwell-time of order $\frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}+\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$ is required. In absence of dwell-time we can see in Fig. \ref{fig_num2} that the switching system given by the two slow manifolds of \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} is unstable. } \begin{figure}[h] \begin{center} \begin{tikzpicture}[scale = 0.9, transform shape, thick] \tikzstyle{fleche}=[->, >=stealth,thick,rounded corners=4pt] \draw[fleche] (-1,0) -- (6,0) node[anchor=north west] {$u$}; \draw[fleche] (0,-1) -- (0,6) node[anchor=south east] {$v$}; \draw[red] (-1,-0.5) --(6,3); \draw[blue] (-0.5,-1) --(3,6); \node[rotate=63] at (1.8,4) {$c_1u+d_1v=0$}; \node[rotate=26] at (4,1.8) {$a_2u+b_2v=0$}; \draw[fleche,blue,dashed] (1,1) -- (1,2); \draw[fleche,red,dashed] (1,2) -- (4,2); \draw[fleche,blue,dashed] (4,2) -- (4,6); \node at (1,0.9) {$(u_0,v_0)$}; \end{tikzpicture} \end{center} \caption{In blue the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode1} and in red the slow manifold associated with \eqref{mode2} when $\frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}>1$. The dashed lines represent the asymptotic behavior of the overall system with initial state $(u_0,v_0)$ when $\varepsilon\rightarrow0$ and no dwell-time (or $\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$ dwell-time) is imposed. It is illustrated that in this case a dwell-time of order $\frac{\ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}+\mathcal O (\varepsilon)$ has to be imposed in order to guarantee the system's stability.}\label{fig_num2} \end{figure} \subsection{Numerical examples}\label{sec: example} In this section we provide a numerical illustration of the previous results. Let us reconsider system \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} when the state matrices take the following numerical values: \begin{equation}\label{num-eval}{\bf A}^1=\left(\begin{array}{cc}-1 & 0.5\\ -1 & -2\end{array}\right),\quad {\bf A}^2=\left(\begin{array}{cc}-2.5 & -2\\ 3 & 1\end{array}\right).\end{equation} \blue{ Assumption \ref{assumption_2} holds since \[\left\{\begin{split}a_1-\frac{b_1c_1}{d_1}=-1.25<0 \quad d_1=-2<0, \\ d_2-\frac{b_2c_2}{a_2}=-1.4<0 \quad a_2=-2.5<0.\end{split}\right.\] Then, $\lambda_s=1.25$ and $\lambda_f=2$ for any choice of positive scalars $Q_s^i,\ Q_f^i$, $i\in \mathcal{I}$. Letting $q=\sqrt{\frac{Q_s^2}{Q_s^1}} =\sqrt{ \frac{|d_1b_2|}{|c_1a_2|}}=2\sqrt{ \frac{2}{5}}$ we obtain $ \gamma_{11}=\sqrt{ \frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}}=\sqrt{ \frac{2}{5}}<1$. Therefore, according to Theorem \ref{theorem_final4}, the minimum stabilizing dwell time is in $\mathcal O(\varepsilon)$.} Let $\varepsilon = 10^{-3} $ and the initial condition ${\bf X}_0=(2,\ 1)$. Using Theorem \ref{theorem_final4} one deduces that the required dwell-time for the stability of system \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} is $6.16 \cdot 10^{-4} = O(\varepsilon)$. \begin{figure}[!h] \begin{center} \includegraphics[scale=0.33]{stable_1} \caption{State's trajectory for \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} with ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ defined by \eqref{num-eval} and $6.16 \cdot 10^{-4} = O(\varepsilon)$} \end{center} \end{figure} The two slow manifolds of the system are respectively: \[ \left\{\begin{split} &-u(t)-2v(t)=0\\ &-2.5 u(t)-2 v(t)=0.\end{split}\right. \] The behavior of the system's trajectory in the $(u,v)$- plane is plot in Fig. \ref{manifold3}. \vspace{-0.2cm} \begin{figure}[!h] \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.35]{manifold_1}\vspace{-0.2cm} \caption{State's trajectory in $(u,v)$- plane for \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} with ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ defined by \eqref{num-eval} and $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau = 6.16 \cdot 10^{-4} = O(\varepsilon) \ sec$}\label{manifold3} \end{figure} It is interesting to note in Fig. \ref{manifold3} that events occurs very fast and far from the origine the system's trajectory approaches the slow manifolds without reaching them. As illustrated in Fig. \ref{manifold4} and Fig. \ref{Traj2} below the system's behavior is not deteriorated when a larger dwell-time condition $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau=2\cdot10^{-3}\ sec$ or $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau=0.2\ sec$ is imposed. Moreover, increasing the dwell-time allows the system to reach the slow manifolds and eventually slide on them. \vspace{-0.2cm} \begin{figure}[!h] \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.35]{manifold_2}\vspace{-0.2cm} \caption{State's trajectory in $(u,v)$- plane for \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} with ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ defined by \eqref{num-eval} and $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau = 2 \cdot 10^{-3} \ sec$}\label{manifold4} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[!h] \begin{center} \includegraphics[scale=0.35]{manifold_22} \caption{State's trajectory in $(u,v)$- plane for \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} with ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ defined by \eqref{num-eval} and $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau = 0.2 \ sec$}\label{Traj2} \end{center} \end{figure} Let us now consider another choice for the state matrices ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ in \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2}. In the following we define: \begin{equation}\label{num-eval2} {\bf A}^1=\left(\begin{array}{cc}-1 & 0.5\\ -3 & -2\end{array}\right),\quad {\bf A}^2=\left(\begin{array}{cc}-2.5 & -4\\ 1 & 0.5\end{array}\right).\end{equation} Again, one can easily observe that Assumption \ref{assumption_2} holds: \[\left\{\begin{split}a_1-\frac{b_1c_1}{d_1}=-1.75<0, \quad d_1=-2<0, \\ d_2-\frac{b_2c_2}{a_2}=-1.1<0, \quad a_2=-2.5<0.\end{split}\right.\] \blue{ Then, $\lambda_s=1.1$ and $\lambda_f=2$ for any choice of positive scalars $Q_s^i,\ Q_f^i$, $i\in \mathcal{I}$. Letting $q=\sqrt{\frac{Q_s^2}{Q_s^1}} =\sqrt{ \frac{|d_1b_2|}{|c_1a_2|}}={ \frac{4}{\sqrt {15}}}$ we obtain $ \gamma_{11}=\sqrt{ \frac{|c_1b_2|}{|d_1a_2|}}=2\sqrt{ \frac{3}{5}}>1$. Therefore, according to Theorem \ref{theorem_final}, an upper bound on the minimum stabilizing dwell time is given by $\frac{ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}+\mathcal O(\varepsilon)$ where, in the present case, $\frac{ln(\gamma_{11})}{\lambda_s}=0.40sec$. } The two slow manifolds associated with the system are given in this case by the lines: \[\left\{\begin{split} &-3 u(t)-2v(t)=0\\ &-2.5 u(t)- 4 v(t)=0. \end{split}\right. \] As previously we consider the initial condition ${\bf X}_0=(2,\ 1)$, $\varepsilon = 10^{-3}$, simulating the system with an inter-events period given by $t_{k+1}-t_k=0.16\ sec,\ \forall k\in\mathbb{N},$ one can observe from Fig. \ref{manifold5} that system's trajectory diverges. \begin{figure}[!h] \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.33]{unstable_manif} \caption{State's trajectory in $(u,v)$- plane for \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} with ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ defined by \eqref{num-eval2} and $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau = 0.16 \ sec$}\label{manifold5} \end{figure}\vspace{-3 mm} Indeed, using Theorem \ref{theorem_final} we obtain a required dwell-time equals $0. 406\ sec$ to ensure stability. Simulating the system again with $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau = 0.406 \ sec$ we can see in Fig. \ref{Traj3} that expected stability is obtained. Fig. \ref{manifold6} shows the first part of the trajectory illustrating its behavior. \begin{figure}[!h] \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.33]{stable_3} \caption{State's trajectory for \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} with ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ defined by \eqref{num-eval2} and $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau = 0.406 \ sec$}\label{Traj3} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[!h] \centering \includegraphics[scale=0.33]{zoom} \caption{First part of the state's trajectory in $(u,v)$- plane for \eqref{mode1}-\eqref{mode2} with ${\bf A}_1, {\bf A}_2$ defined by \eqref{num-eval2} and $t_{k+1}-t_k=\tau = 0.406\ sec$}\label{manifold6} \end{figure} \section{Conclusion} Motivated by a real problem in steel production we introduced and analyzed a class of singularly perturbed switched linear systems in which the nature of the variable is mode-dependent. At switching instants, slow variables can become fast and reversely. Moreover, the state vector can loose or gain components at the switchings times. We show that the dwell-time required to ensure stability of the overall system is the sum of two terms. \blue{The first one essentially consists of a dwell-time ensuring stability of the reduced order system. The second term depends on the scale parameter defining the ratio between the two time-scales and goes to zero when the parameter goes to zero. Our results complement existing results on stability analysis of singularly perturbed linear systems by showing the correlation between the values of the stabilizing dwell-time and of the scale parameter.} A low-dimension numerical example illustrates our results. \blue{

***Cite this article as:*** Fattahi F, Geshani A, Jafari Z, Jalaie Sh, Salman Mahini M. Auditory memory function in expert chess players. Med J Islam Repub Iran 2015 (6 October). Vol. 29:275. Introduction {#s1} ============ Chess is a complex intellectual game and is considered a hard mental activity that requires sophisticated problem solving skills. During chess playing, many kinds of cognitive processes are involved, e.g., memory, working memory, attention, visuospatial perception, motivation and decision making ([@R1]-[@R3]). The involved cognitive processes in chess playing are stimulated and reinforced by practicing this game, resulting in learning-induced neuroplasticity ([@R4]). Essentially, invisible activities of the brain such as perception, memory, thinking, reasoning, learning, attention and logical performances are addressed as cognitive performances. Cognitive performance is an important aspect of a person's life ([@R5]). Memory is a part of cognitive performance that addresses the learning endurance or its resistance in a way that is recallable after a while. This ability for representing and retrieving information has a fundamental importance for all cognitive phenomena ([@R6]). Memory is categorized into two types of verbal and non-verbal according to the nature of the memorized material. The auditory-verbal memory is a type of memory that involves auditory reception of orally presented information, its processing, and storing and finally recalling what has been heard. This kind of memory is extremely important because it plays a fundamental role in developing language skills and the learning process in general; therefore, the auditory-verbal memory helps us to make sense of language and without it, language will be meaningless and void of any concept. The auditory-verbal memory is one of the basic parts of working memory, and working memory is a transitory and temporary way of keeping information that is limited in capacity and needs to be repeated ([@R7],[@R8]). In the field of higher cognitive performances including memory, planning and problem solving, there are many studies and experiences in both sports and educational domains which address the topic of chess ([@R9],[@R10]). Long term gain of skills and repeating the exercise of proficiency in chess can result in considerable changes in the neural structures that are concerned with this special skill. Neuroplasticity studies in the field of learning or exercising chess or other games that are similar to chess, using brain imaging techniques, have reported changes in the areas associated with a special skill as a result of intense and repeated activity of these areas ([@R2],[@R3],[@R11]). Duan et al. (2012), using Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (FMRI), reported the influence of long term learning and practice of chess on 4 brain networks: i.e., Central Executive Network (CEN), Dorsal Attention Network (DAN), Salience Network (SN) and Default Mode Network (DMN), which are associated with cognitive behavior. CEN is critical for working memory. Also, DAN and SN are parts of these cognitive networks. Study results have shown that during the performance of complicated cognitive tasks of chess, activation typically increases in three cognitive networks, i.e., CEN, DAN, and SN, while the activation in the DMN network decreases. Also, compared with novice players (who know the rules and simple strategies of playing chess), Grandmaster/Masters (GM/Ms) have considerably better problem solving abilities. These findings demonstrate the effect of long-term training and experience in terms of cognition on brain activity ([@R3]). Anatomical changes in the bilateral caudate nuclei have been observed in expert chess players in response to long term training in the complicated cognitive domain of chess. Local changes in the brain structure of chess masters and expert chess players are the result of experience increment in chess playing ([@R2]). So far, many studies have analyzed the brain structure of expert and novice chess players, using brain imaging techniques. The common finding of these studies is different activities of the brain structures between novice and expert chess players ([@R12]-[@R15]). For example, Wright et al. (2013) used the event-related potential test to analyze the underlying neural events when chess players made simple judgments of a chess position. They observed that the P3 and N2 amplitudes were larger in expert chess players when compared to novice players ([@R12]). Some studies have examined the influence of neuroplasticity changes on the cognitive performance that could be related to chess playing using behavioral tests. Aciego et al. (2012) empirically studied the beneficial effects of the continued practice of chess in the improvement of cognitive and socioaffective aspects in adolescents. Using the Wechsler intelligence scale for children (WICS-R), the cognitive competence variable was analyzed. The results revealed that after one year of regular chess practice, cognitive skills like attention and focus, perception organization and planning, problem solving ability and also socioaffective development of adolescents were improved. As a result, chess is recognized as a valuable educational tool for strengthening cognitive skills ([@R4]). In studies performed so far, imaging tools have been used to survey the effects of long term chess playing on brain structures. Also, a few studies have analyzed these effects on the cognitive performance of chess players using behavioral tests. To date, no study has evaluated the cognitive performance of chess players like memory using auditory tools. The goal of this study was to use auditory tools to evaluate auditory memory in expert chess players compared to non-chess players. The auditory tool used in this study was dichotic auditory verbal memory test (DAVMT). This test was first introduced by Christianson et al. (1987) ([@R16]). To reach the aim of the study, the mean scores of expert chess players were calculated using the Persian version of DAVMT; and then the mean scores of the test in this group were compared with the mean scores of a matched group of non-chess players. Moreover, the effect of the right/left ear (right advantage) and gender on the test results was surveyed in the two groups. Because auditory memory is one of the components of cognitive performance and with regards to the influence of chess on cognition skills, it is expected that gaining experience in chess results in the development of other sensory cognitive skills like auditory memory. Therefore, we expected to observe better results in the test used in this study in expert chess players with higher levels of experience. Methods {#s2} ======= The present cross- sectional study was performed on 30 expert chess players (15 males and 15 females) aged 20 to 35 years with a mean±SD age of 26.8±4.59 years, and 30 non-chess players (15 males and 15 females), without chess game experience, aged 20-35 years with a mean±SD age of 26.5±4.10 in Tehran Chess Board. The participants were selected randomly. Expert chess players were selected from those who had a rating over 2000 and were accepted in the final national tournaments of the Iranian chess federation and had more than 5 years experience of participation in national and international chess tournaments. The chess rating scale is an international measure of the skill of chess players that scores from 1200 to more than 2700 and is assigned to each player of the International Chess Federation ([@R17]). The individuals in two groups were matched in terms of age and education level (Bachelor's and Master's degree). The inclusion criteria for participants in the two groups were based on other cognitive studies performed in contexts similar to this study including being right handed, speaking Persian and being monolingual, having normal auditory (pure tone average better than or equal to 25dBHL) ([@R18]) and symmetric hearing in both ears (difference less than 10dB for each of frequencies 500, 1000, 2000 and 4000 hertz between two ears) ([@R19]), negative history of ear diseases, traumatic head injury or accident, brain surgery, epilepsy and any type of neurological or psychological diseases, and negative history of consumption of nerve or psychotropic drugs and cognitive disorders ([@R2],[@R3],[@R11],[@R12],[@R20],[@R21]). In addition, none of the members of the two groups had musical experience, formal education in music, or professional skills in other art or sport fields. The Research Deputy of Tehran University of Medical Sciences approved this study in terms of ethical considerations. In this study, to ensure that the auditory threshold was normal and symmetrical for the participants, pure-tone audiometry was performed in a silent environment without other competitive stimuli, using a clinical audiometer based on the ASHA 2004 standard. Then, using the Persian version of DAVMT, auditory memory was evaluated in the individuals who had the inclusion criteria. The Persian version of DAVMT was development by Aghamollaei et al. in 2011 and its results were reported in a group of normal adults. Based on the study results, the Persian version had a high level of content validity ([@R21]). This test was performed in the most comfortable level (MCL) of individuals by headphones binaurally. The test consists of six lists, each of which containing 10 words. The characteristics of the words and lists used in the Persian version of the test were explained thoroughly in a paper by Aghamollaei et al. In this test, when a word presents to one ear, the reverse of the word is also presented simultaneously to the other ear. The participants received the following test instructions before starting the test: "You will hear a real word in one ear and a nonsense word in the other ear; pay close attention to the real words coming from either the right or left ear and try to remember them. When the listening is over, say the words that you remember; the order in which you recall them is not important." At the end of each list presentation, words were recorded in order of remembering. To increase the reliability of the results, the test was administered to each ear three times, and each time a different list was used. To calculate the mean score of DAVMT for each individual, the average score of three lists that was presented to each ear was considered as its score, and the average score of both ears was the total score of the individual. SPSS software version 21 was used for statistical analysis, and data were interpreted at a significance level of P = 0.05. The Kolmogorov--Smirnov test was used to determine the normal distribution of the data, and the data showed a normal distribution. Then, independent samples t-test was used to compare the scores of expert chess players and non-chess players and also to compare the test scores between genders. Moreover, paired sample t-test was utilized to compare the test score between the two ears of the individuals. Results {#s3} ======= The participants' mean±SD age was 26.8±4.59 years for expert chess players and 26.5±4.10 years for non-chess players. The educational level of the individuals ranged from a Bachelor's degree to a Master's degree. The mean auditory threshold of the participants in the analyzed frequencies is shown in [Figure 1](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. {#F1} The mean±SD DAVMT score (number of remembered words) in expert chess players was 7.6±0.75 for the right ear and it was 7.4±0.75 for the left ear with a total score of 7.5±0.72. To compare the auditory memory of expert and non-chess players, the test results for the right and left ear and the total score of expert chess players were compared with the test results of non-chess players. The results of the comparison in each of three tests, using independent t-test, showed a significant difference between the two groups (p≤0.001). The mean and standard deviation of DAVMT score in each group and the result of the statistical analysis are demonstrated in [Table 1](#T1){ref-type="table"}. ###### DAVMT Results for Expert Chess Players and Non-Chess Players ----------- ------------------- ------------------- -------- Chess Player\ Non Chess Player\ p Mean (2SD) (n=30) Mean (2SD) (n=30) Right ear 7.63 (.75) 5.59 (.81) ≤0.001 Left ear 7.45 (.75) 5.31 (.60) ≤0.001 Both 7.54 (.72) 5.45 (.65) ≤0.001 ----------- ------------------- ------------------- -------- SD: standard deviation To analyze the influence of the ears in each group separately, test results of the right and left ear were compared using paired t test. The results revealed that the difference between the scores of the two ears was significant in both chess players (p=0.023) and non-chess players (p=0.013). The results of the analysis of the test scores in both genders are presented in [Table 2](#T2){ref-type="table"}. Test results between males and females in both groups were separately compared using independent t test, but no significant difference was observed (p\>0.0.5). ###### Comparison of the Two Gender Mean Test Scores in the Experimental Groups ------------------ ----------- ------------------- ------------------- ------- Female\ Male\ p Mean (2SD) (n=15) Mean (2SD) (n=15) Chess Player Right ear 7.7 (.74) 7.6 (.78) 0.814 Left ear 7.5 (.79) 7.3 (.71) 0.471 Both 7.6 (.74) 7.5 (.72) 0.618 Non Chess Player Right ear 5.7 (.69) 5.5 (.93) 0.385 Left ear 5.4 (.49) 5.2 (.70) 0.492 Both 5.6 (.51) 5.3 (.78) 0.394 ------------------ ----------- ------------------- ------------------- ------- SD: standard deviation Discussion {#s4} ========== Short-term memory and working memory are cognitive performances that are influenced by chess. Also, auditory memory, a type of memory and a part of cognitive performance, is possibly influenced by the process of strengthening following steady and long-term chess playing. Therefore, analyzing auditory memory in chess players with a professional skill level who are experienced in this game compared to the auditory memory of non-chess players was the aim of this study. DAVMT is one of the dichotic auditory and behavioral tests of the central auditory processing. DAVMT, using a dichotic method to present the stimuli, is a proper way to examine auditory memory. This test analyzes a special kind of memory that is called working memory and is considered a part of implicit short-term memory ([@R8]). Working memory plays an important role in facilitating the individual's performance in complex tasks and auditory-verbal memory is one of the main parts of this memory ([@R22]). Compared with other dichotic tests, the dichotic tests of auditory memory are associated with higher levels of cognitive performances and involve different structures of the brain ([@R8]). In this study, the auditory-verbal memory function of expert chess players was examined based on the test results, and the results showed a significant increase in the performance of auditory-verbal memory in the expert chess players compared with non-chess players. This difference showed an increase in the auditory memory function as a result of long term professional chess playing. As mentioned in the literature, to date, no study has used the behavioral auditory test to assess memory function in chess players. Studies which have used other tools to examine the influence of chess on cognition and memory scopes suggest that being skilled in chess and its long term practice can be effective in the improvement of cognitive performance and memory ([@R4],[@R9],[@R10]). Also, the functional integration of cognitive networks in the brain that are involved during the chess game increases in expert chess players ([@R3]). The results of the present study are consistent with those of other studies reporting an improvement in the cognitive performance due to playing chess for a long time and the results of these studies confirm the findings of the present study. Moreover, the brain structures that are involved during the chess game and common pathways with auditory memory pathways can be addressed to explain the influence of chess on auditory memory. Different cortical areas are activated during the chess game. Chess is a spatial-cognitive process and primarily engages the spatial cognition compared to logical and computational skills. During chess, the left hemisphere is more active than the right ([@R1],[@R20]). The activities of the bilateral posterior cingulate regions, left anterior temporal cortex, left orbitofrontal cortex and right prefrontal cortex have been reported during chess playing ([@R23],[@R24]). The observed pattern of activities in the cortex during the game is in accordance with some of the general cognitive processes that are used in the game of chess ([@R1]). Also, the activity of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) and posterior parietal cortex (PPC) increases in this game ([@R3]). With regards to the neural systems of auditory verbal memory, it should be noted that the neural systems of auditory verbal working memory include ventrolateral prefrontal cortex (VLPFC) and DLPFC, intraparietal sulcus, supramarginal gyrus and basal ganglia, which are active in the visual verbal working memory ([@R25]). Long-term auditory verbal memory includes some different cognitive processes in the neuropsychological level ([@R26],[@R27]). Some auditory memory pathways are active during a game of chess. Although chess is rather a visual-spatial exercise, with respect to the rule of working memory and CEN in the combination of information and memory of different senses to understand and achieve a single notion of experienced situation, gaining experience in chess is expected to result in the development of auditory memory, too. Considering the above mentioned notes and the results of this study, it can be stated that chess is likely to cause an improvement in the auditory memory of the chess players in the long term and with more studies on chess players with different levels of skills, it is possible to examine this improvement and the positive influence of neuroplasticity that occurs in the brain as a result of playing chess on the auditory memory. In the present study, a significant difference was observed in the DAVMT mean score between the left and right ear as the right ear score was higher in both expert chess players and non-chess players. Therefore, it was observed that the right ear advantage existed in both groups. In a study by Aghamollaei et al (2010), the influence of ear on the results of the Persian version of DAVMT in young individuals was surveyed; the results of their study and similar studies using the same version showed the higher scores of the right ear ([@R21],[@R28],[@R29]). Structural differences in the right and left hemispheres are introduced as a reason for the difference in the process of verbal stimuli in the two hemispheres. Because the left hemisphere is used for language information processing in 95% of people, opposition of the right ear to this hemisphere, stronger representation of the auditory input of each ear in the opposite hemisphere and suppression of the auditory information in ipsilateral pathways by contralateral information facilitate processing of right ear information compared with the left ear in dichotic auditory situations and result in the right ear advantage phenomenon. In dichotic presentation of the stimuli, the right ear scores advantage is a common result in normal right handed individuals ([@R30]). In the present study, the right ear scores advantage was observed in both groups, which supports the findings of the previous studies. There was no significant difference in the DAVMT score between males and females in the two groups. However, with a careful consideration of the scores, it can be seen that the scores of the female participants were higher than the males' scores in both groups. In other studies that used the Persian version of this test, significant differences in the test results were observed between genders and the results showed females dominance in this test ([@R21],[@R28]). In a study using the English version of this test, although the gender effect was not analyzed statistically, the females' scores were better than the males' ([@R31]). As yet, extensive researches have been performed on the difference of the females and males' performance, and it has been observed that there are structural and functional differences between the males and females' brains ([@R32],[@R33]). In addition, it is observed that males have a better performance in spatial skills while females have a better performance in performing verbal memory tests ([@R34]). In memory tests, the females' performance was significantly different from that of males. Nevertheless, in the present study, although the females' performance was better than the males', this difference was not significant. The limited number of the expert chess players was introduced as a reason in this context. One of the major limitations of this study was the difficult access to expert chess players of the country. Therefore, in this study, it was decided to recruit expert chess players with more than 5 years of experience by participating in national and international chess competitions. Thus, access to chess players with different levels of experience in a legitimate and objective way and categorizing them into different groups can help interpret the findings of this study. Moreover, because auditory verbal memory is connected with higher levels of cognitive performance and involves different brain structures compared to other simpler tasks which are used in the dichotic test, more studies should be conducted to determine the influence of the ear on the test results in expert chess players. Conclusion {#s5} ========== Based on the obtained results, the auditory verbal memory function showed a significant increase in expert chess players. The increase in auditory memory function was probably influenced by long term chess playing and having professional skills in this game. According to the results, ear advantage behavior was detected in expert chess players and non-chess players and although females were better than males in auditory memory function, this difference was not significant. Based on the results of the present study, chess may be considered a new method for rehabilitation of individuals that have problems as a result of memory impairment and learning difficulties and as a tool for exercising and improving cognitive performance and facilitation of cognitive treatments. Therefore, this study can provide opportunities to expand research in the field of auditory cognition and methods to strengthen them. Acknowledgements {#s6} ================ This study was a part of a Master's degree thesis in audiology that was approved and registered in Tehran University of Medical Sciences (Registration Number 93/d/360/603 on 6.28.2014). The authors wish to express their gratitude to Ms. Aghamollaei for her guidance and providing the required test materials. Also, the manager and the staff of Tehran Chess Board are appreciated for their help in conducting this thesis.

\section{\@startsection{section}{1}% \z@{.7\linespacing\@plus\linespacing}{.5\linespacing}% {\normalfont\scshape} \patchcmd{\@settitle}{\uppercasenonmath\@title}{\Large\boldmath}{}{} \patchcmd{\@settitle}{\begin{center}}{\begin{flushleft}}{}{} \patchcmd{\@settitle}{\end{center}}{\end{flushleft}}{}{} \patchcmd{\@setauthors}{\MakeUppercase}{\normalsize}{}{} \patchcmd{\@setauthors}{\centering}{\raggedright}{}{} \patchcmd{\section}{\scshape}{\large\bfseries\boldmath}{}{} \patchcmd{\subsection}{\bfseries}{\bfseries\boldmath}{}{} \renewcommand{\@secnumfont}{\bfseries} \patchcmd{\@startsection}{\@afterindenttrue}{\@afterindentfalse}{}{} \patchcmd{\abstract}{\leftmargin3pc}{\leftmargin1pc}{}{} \def\maketitle{\par \@topnum\z@ \@setcopyright \thispagestyle{empty \ifx\@empty\shortauthors \let\shortauthors\shorttitle \else \andify\shortauthors \fi \@maketitle@hook \begingroup \@maketitle \toks@\@xp{\shortauthors}\@temptokena\@xp{\shorttitle}% \toks4{\def\\{ \ignorespaces} \edef\@tempa{% \@nx\markboth{\the\toks4 \@nx\MakeUppercase{\the\toks@}}{\the\@temptokena}}% \@tempa \endgroup \c@footnote\z@ \@cleartopmattertags } \makeatother \newcommand{\overline{p}}{\overline{p}} \newcommand{\overline{P}}{\overline{P}} \newcommand{\qbinom}[2]{\begin{bmatrix}#1\\#2\end{bmatrix}} \newcommand{\oqbinom}[2]{\overline{\begin{bmatrix}#1\\#2\end{bmatrix}}} \title[Overpartitions with bounded differences]{An overpartition analogue of partitions with bounded differences between largest and smallest parts} \author[S. Chern]{Shane Chern} \address{Department of Mathematics, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA} \email{shanechern@psu.edu; chenxiaohang92@gmail.com} \date{} \begin{document} \maketitle \begin{abstract} We study the generating function for overpartitions with bounded differences between largest and smallest parts, which is analogous to a result of Breuer and Kronholm on integer partitions. We also connect this problem with over $q$-binomial coefficients introduced by Dousse and Kim. \Keywords{Overpartition, bounded difference between largest and smallest parts, over $q$-binomial coefficient.} \MSC{Primary 05A17; Secondary 11P84.} \end{abstract} \section{Introduction} A \textit{partition} of a positive integer $n$ is a non-increasing sequence of positive integers $(\lambda_1,\lambda_2,\ldots,\lambda_k)$ with $n=\lambda_1+\lambda_2+\ldots+\lambda_k$. For example, $4$ has five partitions: $4$, $3+1$, $2+2$, $2+1+1$, $1+1+1+1$. Let $p(n)$ denote the number of partitions of $n$. It is well known that its generating function is $$1+\sum_{n\ge 1}p(n)q^n=\frac{1}{(q)_\infty},$$ where, as usual, we use the standard notations $$(a)_n=(a;q)_n:=\prod_{k=0}^{n-1} (1-a q^k),$$ and $$(a)_\infty=(a;q)_\infty:=\lim_{n \to \infty}(a)_n.$$ Recently, Andrews, Beck, and Robbins \cite{ABR2015} considered partitions where the difference between largest and smallest parts is a fixed integer $t$. Let $p(n,t)$ be the number of such partitions of $n$. We have, for example, $p(4,1)=1$ since $4$ has only one such partition: $2+1+1$. In fact, Andrews \textit{et al.} showed that $p(n,0)=d(n)$ and $p(n,1)=n-d(n)$ where, and in the sequel, $d(n)$ denotes the number of divisors of $n$. For $t\ge 2$, they obtained the following generating function \begin{equation} \sum_{n\ge 1}p(n,t) q^n= \frac{q^{t-1}(1-q)}{(1-q^t)(1-q^{t-1})}-\frac{q^{t-1}(1-q)}{(1-q^t)(1-q^{t-1})(q)_t}+\frac{q^t}{(1-q^{t-1})(q)_t}. \end{equation} In a subsequent paper \cite{BK2016}, Breuer and Kronholm further considered partitions where the difference between largest and smallest parts is at most $t$. When $t=1$, the four such partitions of $4$ are: $4$, $2+2$, $2+1+1$, $1+1+1+1$. Let $p_t(n)$ be the number of such partitions of $n$. Its generating function is, in fact, even neater. Breuer and Kronholm proved in two ways (one is geometric and the other is combinatorial) that for $t\ge 1$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:BK} \sum_{n\ge 1}p_t(n) q^n=\frac{1}{1-q^t}\left(\frac{1}{(q)_t}-1\right). \end{equation} Later on, Chapman \cite{Cha2016} also provided an analytic proof which only uses elementary $q$-series manipulation as deep as the $q$-binomial theorem. In this paper, we shall study an overpartition analogue of Breuer and Kronholm's result. \section{An overpartition analogue} An \textit{overpartition} of $n$ is a partition of $n$ where the first occurrence of each distinct part may be overlined. For example, $4$ has fourteen overpartitions: $$4,\ \overline{4},\ 3+1,\ \overline{3}+1,\ 3+\overline{1},\ \overline{3}+\overline{1},\ 2+2,\ \overline{2}+2,$$ $$2+1+1,\ \overline{2}+1+1,\ 2+\overline{1}+1,\ \overline{2}+\overline{1}+1,\ 1+1+1+1,\ \overline{1}+1+1+1.$$ Overpartitions have many applications in combinatorics \cite{CL2004}, mathematical physics \cite{FJM2005}, representation theory \cite{KK2004}, and symmetric functions \cite{Ber2006}. We denote by $\overline{p}(n)$ the number of overpartitions of $n$. It is known that $$1+\sum_{n\ge 1}\overline{p}(n) q^n= \frac{(-q)_\infty}{(q)_\infty}.$$ Given a non-negative integer $t$, let $\overline{p}_t(n)$ denote the number of overpartitions of $n$ whose difference between largest and smallest parts is at most $t$. Furthermore, let $g_t(n)$ be the number of such overpartitions of $n$ with one more restriction: if the difference between largest and smallest parts is exactly $t$, then the largest parts cannot be overlined. For example, we have $\overline{p}_1(4)=10$: $$4,\ \overline{4},\ 2+2,\ \overline{2}+2,\ 2+1+1,\ \overline{2}+1+1,$$ $$2+\overline{1}+1,\ \overline{2}+\overline{1}+1,\ 1+1+1+1,\ \overline{1}+1+1+1,$$ and $g_1(4)=8$: $$4,\ \overline{4},\ 2+2,\ \overline{2}+2,\ 2+1+1,$$ $$2+\overline{1}+1,\ 1+1+1+1,\ \overline{1}+1+1+1.$$ It is clear that $\overline{p}_0(n)=2d(n)$ and $g_0(n)=d(n)$. We now write $$\overline{P}_t(q):=\sum_{n\ge 1}\overline{p}_t(n) q^n\quad \text{and}\quad G_t(q):=\sum_{n\ge 1}g_t(n) q^n.$$ \begin{theorem}\label{th:1} For $t\ge 1$, we have \begin{equation}\label{eq:th1} G_t(q)=\frac{1}{1-q^t}\left(\frac{(-q)_t}{(q)_t}-1\right). \end{equation} \end{theorem} \begin{remark} It is of interest to compare the similarity between this generating function and the result of Breuer and Kronholm (Eq. \eqref{eq:BK}). \end{remark} \begin{theorem}\label{th:2} For $t\ge 0$, we have \begin{equation}\label{eq:th2} \overline{P}_t(q)=2(-1)^t \left(\sum_{n\ge 1}d(n)q^n + \sum_{n=1}^t \frac{(-1)^n}{1-q^n}\left(\frac{(-q)_n}{(q)_n}-1\right)\right). \end{equation} \end{theorem} Before presenting our proofs, we need several $q$-series identities. At first, we introduce the ${}_r\phi_s$ functions: $${}_{r+1}\phi_s\left(\begin{matrix} a_0,a_1,a_2\ldots,a_r\\ b_1,b_2,\ldots,b_s \end{matrix}; q, z\right):=\sum_{n\ge 0}\frac{(a_0;q)_n(a_1;q)_n\cdots(a_r;q)_n}{(q;q)_n(b_1;q)_n\cdots (b_s;q)_n}\left((-1)^n q^{\binom{n}{2}}\right)^{s-r}z^n.$$ \begin{lemma}[First $q$-Chu--Vandermonde Sum {\cite[Eq. (17.6.2)]{And2010}}]\label{le:chu} We have \begin{equation}\label{eq:chu} {}_{2}\phi_{1}\left(\begin{matrix} a,q^{-n}\\ c \end{matrix}; q, cq^{n}/a\right)=\frac{(c/a;q)_n}{(c;q)_n}. \end{equation} \end{lemma} \begin{lemma}[{\cite[Eq. (17.9.6)]{And2010}}]\label{le:32} We have \begin{equation}\label{eq:32} {}_{3}\phi_{2}\left(\begin{matrix} a,b,c\\ d,e \end{matrix}; q, de/(abc)\right)=\frac{(e/a;q)_n(de/(bc);q)_n}{(e;q)_n(de/(abc);q)_n}{}_{3}\phi_{2}\left(\begin{matrix} a, d/b, d/c\\ d, de/(bc) \end{matrix}; q, e/a\right). \end{equation} \end{lemma} \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem \ref{th:1}] Fix the smallest part to be $m\ge 1$. It is easy to see that, for $t\ge 1$, the generating function for overpartitions, where the smallest part is $m$, the largest part is at most $m+t$, and if the largest part is exactly $m+t$, then the largest parts cannot be overlined, is $$\frac{2q^m}{1-q^m}\frac{1+q^{m+1}}{1-q^{m+1}}\cdots\frac{1+q^{m+t-1}}{1-q^{m+t-1}}\frac{1}{1-q^{m+t}}.$$ Hence, \begin{align*} \frac{G_t(q)}{2}&=\sum_{m\ge 1}\frac{q^m}{1-q^m}\frac{1+q^{m+1}}{1-q^{m+1}}\cdots\frac{1+q^{m+t-1}}{1-q^{m+t-1}}\frac{1}{1-q^{m+t}}\\ &=\sum_{m\ge 1}\frac{(q)_{m-1}(-q)_{m+t-1}}{(q)_{m+t}(-q)_m}q^m\\ & =q\sum_{m\ge 0}\frac{(q)_{m}(-q)_{m+t}}{(q)_{m+t+1}(-q)_{m+1}}q^m\\ &=\frac{q(-q)_{t}}{(1+q)(q)_{t+1}}\sum_{m\ge 0}\frac{(q)_{m}(q)_{m}(-q^{t+1})_{m}}{(q)_m(q^{t+2})_{m}(-q^2)_{m}}q^m\\ &=\frac{q(-q)_{t}}{(1+q)(q)_{t+1}}\ {}_{3}\phi_{2}\left(\begin{matrix} q,q,-q^{t+1}\\ -q^2,q^{t+2} \end{matrix}; q, q\right)\\ \text{(by Eq. \eqref{eq:32})}& = \frac{q(-q)_{t}}{(1+q)(q)_{t+1}}\frac{(q^{t+1})_\infty(q^2)_\infty}{(q^{t+2})_\infty(q)_\infty}\ {}_{3}\phi_{2}\left(\begin{matrix} q,-q,q^{1-t}\\ -q^2,q^{2} \end{matrix}; q, q^{t+1}\right)\\ &= \frac{q(-q)_{t}}{(1-q^2)(q)_{t}} \sum_{m\ge 0}\frac{(-q)_{m}(q^{1-t})_{m}}{(-q^2)_{m}(q^2)_m}q^{m(t+1)}\\ &= \frac{q(-q)_{t}}{(1-q^2)(q)_{t}} \sum_{m\ge 0}\frac{\frac{(-1)_{m+1}}{2}\frac{(q^{-t})_{m+1}}{1-q^{-t}}}{\frac{(-q)_{m+1}}{1+q}\frac{(q)_{m+1}}{1-q}}q^{(m+1)(t+1)}q^{-(t+1)}\\ &= -\frac{(-q)_{t}}{2(1-q^t)(q)_{t}} \left({}_{2}\phi_{1}\left(\begin{matrix} -1,q^{-t}\\ -q \end{matrix}; q, q^{t+1}\right)-1\right)\\ \text{(by Eq. \eqref{eq:chu})}&= -\frac{(-q)_{t}}{2(1-q^t)(q)_{t}} \left(\frac{(q)_t}{(-q)_t}-1\right)\\ &= \frac{1}{2(1-q^t)}\left(\frac{(-q)_t}{(q)_t}-1\right). \end{align*} We therefore have $$G_t(q)=\frac{1}{1-q^t}\left(\frac{(-q)_t}{(q)_t}-1\right).$$ This ends the proof of Theorem \ref{th:1}. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem \ref{th:2}] We first note that $$\overline{P}_0(q)=2\sum_{n\ge 1}d(n)q^n,$$ and for $t\ge 0$, $$\overline{P}_t(q)=2\sum_{m\ge 1}\frac{q^m}{1-q^m}\frac{1+q^{m+1}}{1-q^{m+1}}\cdots\frac{1+q^{m+t}}{1-q^{m+t}}.$$ We also have, for $n\ge 1$, \begin{align*} \overline{P}_n(q)+\overline{P}_{n-1}(q)&=2\sum_{m\ge 1}\frac{q^m}{1-q^m}\frac{1+q^{m+1}}{1-q^{m+1}}\cdots\frac{1+q^{m+n-1}}{1-q^{m+n-1}}\left(\frac{1+q^{m+n}}{1-q^{m+n}}+1\right)\\ &=4\sum_{m\ge 1}\frac{q^m}{1-q^m}\frac{1+q^{m+1}}{1-q^{m+1}}\cdots\frac{1+q^{m+n-1}}{1-q^{m+n-1}}\frac{1}{1-q^{m+n}}\\ &=2G_n(q). \end{align*} Hence, for any $t\ge 0$, it follows that \begin{align*} \overline{P}_t(q)&=(-1)^t\left(\overline{P}_0(q)+2\sum_{n=1}^t (-1)^n G_n(q)\right)\\ &=2(-1)^t \left(\sum_{n\ge 1}d(n)q^n + \sum_{n=1}^t \frac{(-1)^n}{1-q^n}\left(\frac{(-q)_n}{(q)_n}-1\right)\right). \end{align*} \end{proof} \begin{corollary} For any $t\ge 0$ and $n\ge 1$, $\overline{p}_t(n)$ is an even integer. Furthermore, $\overline{p}_t(n)$ is divisible by $4$ if and only if $n$ is not a perfect square. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} From the previous proof, we see that \begin{align*} \overline{P}_t(q)&=(-1)^t\left(\overline{P}_0(q)+2\sum_{n=1}^t (-1)^n G_n(q)\right)\\ &=(-1)^t \Bigg(2\sum_{n\ge 1}d(n)q^n\\ &\quad\quad\quad\quad\quad+4\sum_{n=1}^t (-1)^n \sum_{m\ge 1}\frac{q^m}{1-q^m}\frac{1+q^{m+1}}{1-q^{m+1}}\cdots\frac{1+q^{m+n-1}}{1-q^{m+n-1}}\frac{1}{1-q^{m+n}}\Bigg). \end{align*} It follows that $$\overline{p}_t(n)\equiv 2d(n) \pmod{4}.$$ We finally note that $d(n)$ is odd if and only if $n$ is a perfect square. This completes the proof. \end{proof} \section{The viewpoint of over $q$-binomial coefficients} The \textit{$q$-binomial coefficient}, also known as \textit{Gaussian polynomial}, is defined as $$\qbinom{M+N}{N}=\qbinom{M+N}{N}_q:=\frac{(q)_{M+N}}{(q)_{M}(q)_{N}}.$$ We know that it is the generating function for partitions where the largest part is at most $M$ and the number of parts is at most $N$. In a recent paper \cite{DK2017}, Dousse and Kim introduced the \textit{over $q$-binomial coefficient}, denoted by $$\oqbinom{M+N}{N}=\oqbinom{M+N}{N}_q,$$ which is an overpartition analogue of $q$-binomial coefficient defined as the generating function for overpartitions where the largest part is at most $M$ and the number of parts is at most $N$. They showed that for positive integers $M$ and $N$ $$\oqbinom{M+N}{N}=\sum_{k=0}^{\min(M,N)}q^{\binom{k+1}{2}}\frac{(q)_{M+N-k}}{(q)_k(q)_{M-k}(q)_{N-k}}.$$ Of course, if we agree that the number of such overpartitions of $0$ is one, then this identity also holds for $M=0$ or $N=0$. Over $q$-binomial coefficients have many properties similar to those of the standard $q$-binomial coefficients. For example, the following recurrence relation \begin{equation}\label{eq:ob} \oqbinom{M+N}{N}=\oqbinom{M+N-1}{N-1}+q^N \oqbinom{M+N-1}{N}+ q^N \oqbinom{M+N-2}{N-1} \end{equation} holds for any positive integers $M$ and $N$ (see \cite[Eq. (1.1)]{DK2017}). In fact, it can be proved combinatorially. Motivated by \cite{Cha2016}, we provide an alternative proof of Theorem \ref{th:1} using over $q$-binomial coefficients. It avoids the application of complicated $q$-series identities such as the $q$-Chu--Vandermonde sum. \begin{proof}[Second proof of Theorem \ref{th:1}] Here we always assume $t$ to be a positive integer. Let $\lambda=(\lambda_1,\ldots,\lambda_r)$ be an overpartition of $n$ with exactly $r$ parts, $\lambda_r=m\ge 1$, and $\lambda_1\le m+t$. Then $\mu=(\lambda_1 -m,\ldots,\lambda_{r-1}-m)$ is an overpartition of $n-rm$ with at most $r-1$ parts and greatest part $\le t$. Note that the first occurrence of the smallest part of $\lambda$ can be either overlined or not. Hence the generating function for such overpartitions is $$2q^{rm}\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t},$$ and hence $$\overline{P}_t(q)=2\sum_{r\ge 1}\sum_{m\ge 1}q^{rm}\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t}=2\sum_{r\ge 1}\frac{q^r}{1-q^r}\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t}.$$ We remark that this identity also holds for $t=0$. On the other hand, overpartitions where the difference between largest and smallest parts is at most $t$ can be divided into three disjoint cases: \begin{enumerate} \item The largest part is at most $t$; \item The largest part is greater than $t$, the difference between largest and smallest parts is exactly $t$, and the first occurrence of the smallest part is overlined; \item Otherwise. \end{enumerate} For Case (1), one readily sees the generating function is $$\frac{(-q)_t}{(q)_t}-1.$$ For Case (2), its generating function is $$2\sum_{m\ge 1} \frac{q^m}{1-q^m}\frac{1+q^{m+1}}{1-q^{m+1}}\cdots\frac{1+q^{m+t-1}}{1-q^{m+t-1}}\frac{q^{m+t}}{1-q^{m+t}}=\frac{\overline{P}_t(q)-\overline{P}_{t-1}(q)}{2}.$$ Finally, let $\lambda=(\lambda_1,\ldots,\lambda_r)$ be an overpartition of Case (3) with $\lambda_1=m+t$ (and so $m\ge 1$). We note that $\mu=(\lambda_1 -m,\ldots,\lambda_{r}-m)$ is an overpartition of $|\lambda|-rm$ with at most $r$ parts and largest part being exactly $t$. Hence the generating function is $$\sum_{r\ge 1}\sum_{m\ge 1}q^{rm}\left(\oqbinom{t+r}{t}-\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t-1}\right)=\sum_{r\ge 1}\frac{q^r}{1-q^r}\left(\oqbinom{t+r}{t}-\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t-1}\right).$$ We therefore have \begin{align*} \overline{P}_t(q)&=\left(\frac{(-q)_t}{(q)_t}-1\right)+\frac{\overline{P}_t(q)-\overline{P}_{t-1}(q)}{2}\\ &\quad+\sum_{r\ge 1}\frac{q^r}{1-q^r}\left(\oqbinom{t+r}{t}-\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t-1}\right). \end{align*} Now we take $M\to r$ and $N\to t$ in Eq. \eqref{eq:ob} and rewrite it as $$\oqbinom{t+r}{t}-\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t-1}=q^t \left(\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t}+ \oqbinom{t+r-2}{t-1}\right).$$ We then multiply both sides by $q^r/(1-q^r)$ and sum over $r$ \begin{align*} &\sum_{r\ge 1}\frac{q^r}{1-q^r}\left(\oqbinom{t+r}{t}-\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t-1}\right)\\ &\quad =q^t\left(\sum_{r\ge 1}\frac{q^r}{1-q^r}\oqbinom{t+r-1}{t}+ \sum_{r\ge 1}\frac{q^r}{1-q^r}\oqbinom{t+r-2}{t-1}\right). \end{align*} From the foregoing argument, we therefore have \begin{align*} \overline{P}_t(q)-\left(\frac{(-q)_t}{(q)_t}-1\right)-\frac{\overline{P}_t(q)-\overline{P}_{t-1}(q)}{2}=q^t \frac{\overline{P}_t(q)+\overline{P}_{t-1}(q)}{2}. \end{align*} Hence $$G_t(q)=\frac{\overline{P}_t(q)+\overline{P}_{t-1}(q)}{2}=\frac{1}{1-q^t}\left(\frac{(-q)_t}{(q)_t}-1\right).$$ \end{proof} \subsection*{Acknowledgements} I would like to thank George E. Andrews and Ae Ja Yee for some helpful discussions. \bibliographystyle{amsplain}

\section{Introduction} It is well known that the lattice local axial vector current $A_\mu^{\rm loc} = \overline{\psi}(x) \gamma_\mu\gamma_5 \psi(x)$ does not satisfy the continuum form of the axial Ward identity \begin{equation} \partial_\mu A_\mu(x) = 2mP(x), \quad P(x)=\bar{\psi}(x)\gamma_5 \psi(x)\,, \end{equation} which is due to lattice artefacts. In most cases, where Wilson like fermions are used, the corresponding improved renormalized current \begin{equation} A_\mu^{\rm loc, \overline{MS}}(x) = Z_{A^{\rm loc}}(1+b_A a m)\left[A_\mu^{\rm latt,loc}+a c_A \partial_\mu P^{\rm latt} \right] \end{equation} is taken to compute physical quantities, like the nucleon axial charge $g_A$. It turned out, however, that the resulting $g_A$ value are slightly below the experimental number and it requires a large effort to bring the lattice result into coincidence with it \cite{Horsley:2013ayv,Bali:2014nma,Alexandrou:2016xok,Bhattacharya:2016zcn,Collins:2016}. An alternative possibility is to use the point-split (ps) axial vector current \begin{equation} A^{\rm ps}_\mu(x)= \frac{1}{2}\left[\bar \psi_x \gamma_\mu \gamma_5 U_\mu(x) \psi_{x+a \hat \mu}+ \bar \psi_{x+a \hat \mu} \gamma_\mu \gamma_5 U_\mu^\dagger(x) \psi_{x} \right]\label{Aps}\,, \end{equation} which is known to fulfill the corresponding lattice axial Ward identity~\cite{Bochicchio:1985xa}. In~\cite{Horsley:2015nae} we could show that this identity is fulfilled both perturbatively (in one-loop) and nonperturbatively for the SLiNC action~\cite{Cundy:2009yy}. In this work we present implications of this nonlocal lattice form of the axial current - the renormalization and the computation of the axial charge $g_A$. \section{Renormalization} It is known that the point-split lattice vector current $V^{\rm ps}_\mu(x)$ as obtained from the lattice vector Ward identity is conserved. This leads to the renormalization factor $Z_V^{\rm ps}=1$ whereas the nonconserved local counterpart differs by a finite number from that. One could speculate what behavior $Z_A^{\rm ps}$ computed for (\ref{Aps}) shows. On the one hand $A^{\rm ps}_\mu(x)$ is also a result of the lattice axial vector Ward identity. On the other hand there appears an extra term which cannot be absorbed into a redefinition of the current. This is due to the fact that Wilson like actions break chiral symmetry. For the SLiNC action (where the fermionic part is a stout smeared version of a clover improved Wilson action) this extra term is a combination of the standard Wilson term and the clover term. We perform a nonperturbative calculation on a $32^3\times 64$ lattice at $\beta=5.50$ [$a=0.074(2)$ fm]. In order to perform the chiral limit we use five $\kappa$ values along the flavor symmetric line ($\kappa_l = \kappa_s$) corresponding to pion masses $M_\pi$ = 470, 440, 400, 340, 290 MeV. We use the nonperturbative RI$^\prime$-MOM scheme~\cite{Martinelli:1994ty} performing a linear chiral extrapolation for each $(ap)^2$ value. Afterwards we transform into the RGI and $\overline{\rm MS}$ schemes which coincide due to the lack of anomalous dimensions. The result is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:ZA}. \begin{figure}[!htb] \begin{center} \includegraphics[scale=1,clip=true]{RGI_p2_za_chiral_limit.pdf} \vspace{-3mm} \caption{$Z^{\rm RGI}_{A}$ for $\beta=5.5$ as function of $(ap)^2$ for the point-split axial current $A=A^{\rm ps}$.} \label{fig:ZA} \end{center} \end{figure} In the chosen momentum interval $Z_A$ is fitted as a linear function in $(ap)^2$. Variations of this interval determines the systematic error which dominates the fit error. We find $Z_A^{\rm ps} = 1.0212(12)_{\rm fit}(47)_{\rm sys}$ which is very near to one. This is consistent with one-loop perturbative results using, however, a different gauge action~\cite{Horsley:2015nae}. That result would mean that practically quantities computed from this point-split axial vector current alone do not need to be renormalized. It remains to check, however, that this behavior remains valid for other $\beta$ values (lattice spacings). \section{Nucleon axial charge $g_A$} The axial charge $g_A$ is an important quantity to understand the spin structure of the nucleon, but also plays a role in certain astrophysical processes. It can be measured in the $\beta$ decay of the neutron ($n \rightarrow p + e + \overline{\nu}_e$) where it determines the angular distribution of the emitted electron. The current experimental value is given in~\cite{Agashe:2014kda} as $g_A = 1.2723(23)$. On the lattice $g_A$ is calculated from the forward matrix element of the axial vector current $A_{\rm q}^\mu$ \begin{equation} \langle {\bf p},s | A_{\rm u-d}^\mu |{\bf p},s \rangle = 2\, g_A \,s^\mu \,, \label{gAlatt} \end{equation} where $ |{\bf p},s \rangle$ is a proton state with momentum ${\bf p}$ and spin $s^\mu$ and the inserted operator is $A_{\rm u-d}^\mu = A_{\rm u}^\mu - A_{\rm d}^\mu$. Being a nonsinglet quantity there are no contributions from disconnected quark lines. The relation (\ref{gAlatt}) makes this observable to a benchmark test for lattice calculations. For a review of the current status see~\cite{Collins:2016}. Despite the progress that has been made in the last years there remain a couple of challenges to be solved. Among them we mention the extrapolation to the physical point and the treatment of excited states. In this work we take the point-split axial vector current (\ref{Aps}) as the operator inserted in (\ref{gAlatt}). As lattices we use \{$32^3\times 64$, $\beta=5.50$ [$a=0.074(2)$ fm], $M_\pi$ = 470, 360, 310 MeV\} along the $\bar{m} =$ const. line and \{$48^3\times 96$, $\beta=5.80$ [$a=0.059(3)$ fm], $M_\pi$ = 427 MeV\} at the flavor symmetric point. $g_A$ has to be estimated from the ratio of the 3-point function to the 2-point function \begin{equation} R(t_i,t_f,\tau) = \frac{G_3(t_i,t_f,\tau)}{G_2(t_i,t_f)} \quad \rightarrow \quad g_A\label{ratio} \end{equation} with $(t_f-t_i)$ - the source-sink distance, $\tau$ - the source-operator insertion distance. It is clear that a meaningful determination of $g_A$ is possible only if the ratio exhibits a pronounced plateau, ideally independent on $(t_f-t_i)$ and $\tau$. One of the main challenges of this kind of computations is the handling of excited states. There are various techniques which are used to take them into account. Among them we have the summation, the multi-exponential fit and the variational methods~\cite{Capitani:2012gj,Owen:2012ts,Yoon:2016dij,Dragos:2016rtx}. It turns out that the source-sink distance determines the form and the height of the plateau of the ratio $R(t_i,t_f,\tau)$ defined in~(\ref{ratio}) (see Fig.~\ref{fig:plateaus}). \begin{figure}[!htb] \begin{center} \includegraphics[scale=1,clip=true]{plot_all_plateaux_b5p80.pdf} \vspace{-3mm} \caption{Plateaus of $R(t_i,t_f,\tau)$ for various $t_{sep}=(t_f-t_i)$ as function of operator insertion time $\tau$ for $\beta=5.80$.} \label{fig:plateaus} \end{center} \end{figure} This is directly connected to the influence of excited states which diminish the height for smaller separations. Investigations in~\cite{Dragos:2016rtx} suggest that the variational method shows very stable results. In our computation, however, we used the 3-exponential fit method which includes the first three energy levels ($t=t_{\rm sep}$). The fit to the ratio (\ref{ratio}) has the form \begin{eqnarray} F_{g_A}(t,\tau) = g_A^{\rm fit}& & \left[ 1+C_{10}\left(e^{-\tau M_{10}}+ e^{-(t-\tau) M_{10}}\right)+C_{11}e^{-t M_{10}}\right.\nonumber\\ & & +\,C_{20}\left(e^{-\tau M_{20}}+e^{-(t-\tau) M_{20}}\right)+C_{22}e^{-t M_{20}}\nonumber\\ & & \left.+\,C_{21}\left(e^{-\tau M_{21}}e^{-t M_{10}}\right)+C_{21}\left(e^{-t M_{20}}e^{-\tau M_{21}}\right)\right]\nonumber\\ & & \times \left[1+D_{10}e^{-t M_{10}}+D_{20}e^{-t M_{20}}\right]^{-1}\,, \label{FgA} \end{eqnarray} where $M_{ik}=M_i-M_k$ and the $M_i$ are the masses of the ground state ($i=0$) and the next two excited states ($i=1,2$). They can be determined rather precisely from the corresponding 2-point functions, as shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:corr}. The fit ({\ref{FgA}) is performed for the parameters $g_A^{\rm fit}, C$ and $D$ over the available data sets $(t,\tau)$ simultaneously. An example is shown in the right of Fig.~\ref{fig:corr}. \begin{figure} \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{cc} \includegraphics[scale=1,clip=true]{b5p80_plot_G2_log.pdf} & \includegraphics[scale=1,clip=true]{b5p80_plot_gA_with_fit_curves.pdf} \end{tabular} \end{center} \vspace{-2mm} \caption{Left: Three mass fit to the 2-point correlation function for $\beta=5.80$. Right: Result of the global fit (\protect\ref{FgA}) for $\beta=5.80$.} \label{fig:corr} \end{figure} where we fit over the whole data set with all available separations $t_{sep}=15 ... 23$. Our final results for $g_A$ at $\beta=5.50$ ($M_\pi$ = 470~MeV) and $\beta=5.80$ are shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:gA}. \begin{figure}[!htb] \begin{center} \includegraphics[scale=1,clip=true]{plot_all_gA_summary.pdf} \vspace{-3mm} \caption{$g_A$ values using different methods at the flavor symmetric points. $\beta=5.50$ and $M_\pi$ = 470~MeV: $g_A^{\rm var}$: local axial current (variational method), point-split axial current (plateau values at $t=t_{sep}=13,15,17,19,21$) and 3-exponential fit $g_A^{\rm fit}$; $\beta=5.80$: point-split axial current (plateau values at $t=t_{sep}=15,17,19,21,23$) and 3-exponential fit $g_A^{\rm fit}$. The experimental value is denoted as $g_A^{\rm exp}$.} \label{fig:gA} \end{center} \end{figure} We compare them for $\beta=5.50$ with the variational method~\cite{Dragos:2016rtx} which has been obtained for the local axial curent on the same lattice. It is obvious that the plateau values depend very much on the source-sink separations. The 3-exponential fit gives a higher value towards the experimental result. It can be recognized that (using the same lattice parameters) the axial charge for the point-split current is nearer to the experimental value than the value using the local current. This should be seen also in connection to the corresponding $Z$ factor ($Z_A^{\rm ps} = 1.0212$) which indicates that we are rather close to the continuum. Furthermore, we did not find a significant dependence on the three pion masses at $\beta = 5.50$. For $\beta=5.80$ the final fit $g_A^{\rm fit}$ is even larger. This shows a tendency to increase $g_A(\beta)$ with increasing $\beta$ (decreasing lattice spacing $a$) which is encouraging. However, for a sound comparison with experiment it remains to perform a careful extrapolation to the physical point. \section*{Acknowledgements} The numerical configuration generation (using the BQCD lattice QCD program~\cite{Nakamura:2010qh}) was carried out on the IBM BlueGene/Q using DIRAC 2 resources (EPCC, Edinburgh, UK) and the BlueGene/P and Q at NIC (J\"ulich, Germany). The data analysis (using the Chroma software library~\cite{Edwards:2004sx}) was performed on the SGI ICE 8200 and Cray XC30 at the HLRN (The North-German Supercomputer Alliance). HP was supported by the DFG grant SCHI 422/10-1. PELR was supported in part by the STFC under contract ST/G00062X/1 and JMZ by the Australien Research Council Grant No. FT100100005 and DP140103067. We thank all funding agencies.

Introduction ============ Background ---------- The use of information and communication technologies (ICTs) for health, referred to as eHealth \[[@ref1],[@ref2]\] represent a means to support health care delivery \[[@ref3]\]. These technologies change how nurses plan, deliver, document, and review clinical care; this will only continue as technology advances. The processes whereby nurses receive and review diagnostic information, make clinical decisions, communicate and socialize with patients and their relatives, and implement clinical interventions will be fundamentally modified with further integration of ICTs into nursing practice \[[@ref4],[@ref5]\]. There is a wide range of ICTs used for supporting and providing health care. Mair et al \[[@ref6]\] suggested four general domains of eHealth that include a variety of ICTs: management systems, communication systems, computerized decision support systems (CDSSs), and information systems. Management systems allow for the acquisition, storage, transmission, and display of administrative or clinical activities related to patients, such as electronic health records (EHRs) or electronic medical records (EMRs). Communication systems can be used for diagnostic, management, counseling, educational, or support purposes. They can be implemented to facilitate communication between health professionals or between health professionals and patients. There are a wide range of communication systems, varying from email and mobile phones to telemedicine and telecare systems. CDSSs are automated systems accessible from various devices, such as computer, mobile phone, or personal digital assistants (PDAs). They support decision-making for health professionals and assist them in practicing within clinical guidelines and care pathways. Information systems, such as Web-based resources and eHealth portals, refer to the use of Internet technology to access health-related information sources. To support complex and diversified practices and interventions in nursing, myriad ICTs can be adopted, though not without challenges. Some ICTs, such as EHRs and computerized nursing care plans, facilitate access to patient information and help to document and plan nursing care \[[@ref7]\]. However, with the use of these technologies, nurses are expected to change the way they document patient care by shifting from paper-based records to electronic systems. The features (eg, copy and paste, electronic interface, drop-down menus) of electronic nursing documentation may affect critical thinking and accuracy of documentation \[[@ref8]\]. Telehealth technologies are another example, which include a wide range of ICTs such as remote patient monitoring, videoconferencing, and computer-mediated communications \[[@ref9]\]. In the case of remote patient monitoring (telemonitoring), nurses must be able to process a large quantity of data from the system (eg, vital signs, symptoms) and then use clinical decision skills to respond properly to each patient's condition \[[@ref10]\]. In order to discern cues within the interactions via technological modalities, specific communication skills remain essential, that is, active listening, facilitating conversation, questioning, redirecting, and verifying \[[@ref11]-[@ref13]\]. ICTs are becoming an impetus for quality health care delivery by nurses. It is thus relevant to study the role of nurses in the clinical use of ICTs \[[@ref3]\] as well as the impact of ICTs on nursing practices \[[@ref14]\]. The use of any type of ICT to provide direct or indirect care to patients may transform nurses' day-to-day practice \[[@ref3]\]. In some systematic reviews, different types of ICTs have been reviewed, for instance, EHRs \[[@ref15]\], nursing computerized records systems \[[@ref16]\], or CDSSs \[[@ref17]\]. In general, nursing practice or nursing care was not well-defined in those reviews, and there was no conceptual framework enabling reflection on the way ICTs could influence indicators of nursing care. To overcome this gap, we used a broad and comprehensive conceptualization of nursing care based on the nursing care performance framework (NCPF) \[[@ref18]\] to embrace a multidimensional perspective of nursing care. The NCPF is composed of three distinct but interrelated subsystems: nursing resources, nursing services, and patients' conditions. It is defined as "the capacity demonstrated by an organization or an organizational unit to acquire the needed nursing resources and use them in a sustainable manner to produce nursing services that effectively improve patients' conditions (\[[@ref18]\], p.6)." However, an integrated body of knowledge was lacking with respect to the effects of ICTs on nursing care, because of the heterogeneity of ICTs used in the literature as well as the poor conceptualization of nursing care. We conducted an overview of systematic reviews to develop a broad picture of the indicators of nursing care that have the potential to be enhanced or constrained by the use of ICTs. The use of an overview is an interesting starting point from which to compare and contrast outcomes of separate reviews \[[@ref19]\] regarding the positive, negative, and neutral effects of ICTs on nursing care. Objectives ---------- We conducted an overview of systematic reviews to systematically summarize the evidence that comes from qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-method systematic reviews regarding the effects of ICTs on nursing care. Nursing Care Performance Framework ---------------------------------- In order to illustrate how ICTs interventions influence nursing care and impact health outcomes, an organizational model was used \[[@ref18]\]. The NCPF represents a synthesis of the most recent developments in the field and is part of leading initiatives aiming to conceptualize nursing care performance. Conceptualization of nursing care performance is based on a system perspective that builds on system theory \[[@ref20]\], Donabedian's earlier works on health care organization \[[@ref21]\], and Parsons' theory of social action \[[@ref22]\]. This model, illustrated in [Figure 1](#figure1){ref-type="fig"}, is composed of 14 dimensions and 51 indicators and shows how the interplay of three nursing subsystems (resources, processes or services, and patients' outcomes) can operate to achieve three key functions: (1) acquiring, deploying, and maintaining nursing resources; (2) transforming nursing resources into nursing services; and (3) producing changes in patients' conditions in response to the nursing services provided ("nursing-sensitive outcomes"). The first function refers to the human and material resources needed to provide effective nursing care, such as nursing staff supply, working conditions, staff maintenance, and economic sustainability. The second function encompasses nurses' practice environments (eg, nurse autonomy; collaboration), nursing processes (eg, assessment, care planning, and evaluation; problems and symptom management), nurses' professional satisfaction, and patient experience. The desirable end result of the interactions between nursing staff and nursing processes is to improve patients' conditions. The third function is then described as the positive changes that can be detected among patients (also called "nursing-sensitive outcomes"). The 51 indicators capture the content currently supported by the scientific literature and cover all major areas of nursing care performance. More than a simple list of indicators, the NCPF provides an integrative and systemic framework that has been used in recent studies to analyze various dimensions of nursing care \[[@ref23],[@ref24]\]. The NCPF has been used, for example, to structure a scoping review undertaken to identify indicators that are sensitive to ambulatory nursing \[[@ref23]\]. The results showed the capacity of NCPF to be extended and applied to ambulatory nursing care and furthermore, five new indicators have been added to the framework. The authors of the NCPF have suggested that further studies should be conducted to assess the implementation of the framework in different contexts of nursing care \[[@ref18]\]. This overview constitutes a first attempt to use and apply the NCPF to structure and analyze the indicators of nursing care that are influenced by ICTs. We expect that using the NCPF will confirm existing indicators, add new indicators specific to the context of ICTs, and eventually modify existing indicators. In this overview, our main interest was to extract data related to nurses. For instance, if results of a systematic review were exclusively on patient outcomes without describing nursing resources, services, or processes, the review was excluded. However, we considered nursing sensitive outcomes (ie, patients' outcomes) as long as they could be related to ICTs use by nurses. {#figure1} Methods ======= Overview and Eligibility Criteria --------------------------------- The protocol of this overview has been registered on PROSPERO (CRD42014014762) and published elsewhere \[[@ref25]\]. We followed the Cochrane Collaboration methodology \[[@ref26]\] and other relevant works in this domain \[[@ref19],[@ref27]\] to develop the overview. The scope was formulated using PICOS (participants, interventions, comparisons, outcomes, study design) \[[@ref28],[@ref29]\]. All types of qualitative, mixed-method, and quantitative reviews, published in French, English, or Spanish from January 1, 1995 and that aimed to evaluate the influence of ICTs (four eHealth domains) used by nurses on nursing care were eligible. The inclusion of reviews using multiple methodological approaches is justified by the possibility of broadening the understanding of the impact of ICTs on nursing care. The populations of interest were registered nurses (RN), nurses in training, nursing students, or patients receiving care from qualified RN through the medium of ICTs. The interventions targeted were the use of ICTs covered in the four eHealth domains suggested by Mair et al \[[@ref6]\]: (1) management systems; (2) communication systems; (3) CDSSs; and (4) information systems. The following ICTs were excluded: (1) nurse management systems, which are purely administrative and designed for the management of human resources and working conditions (eg, scheduling) and nursing staff maintenance (such as retention); (2) educational systems, for example, e-learning initiatives used for the training of nursing students, unless they are applied to direct patient care; and (3) telephone systems, because according to most definitions of ICTs \[[@ref30],[@ref31]\], they are not digital technologies and cannot support the electronic capture, storage, processing, and exchange of information. Further details of the inclusion criteria for the selection of systematic reviews are described in [Table 1](#table1){ref-type="table"}. ###### Inclusion criteria for the selection of systematic reviews. Criteria Description of inclusion criteria ---------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Type of reviews All types of qualitative, mixed-method, and quantitative reviews that aimed to evaluate the influence of ICTs^a^(four eHealth domains) used by nurses on nursing care, which stated a methodology (a "Methods" section) with explicit eligibility criteria, had systematic research strategies to identify selected reviews and provided a systematic presentation and summary of the characteristics and outcomes of the included reviews \[[@ref28]\]. Publication type Reviews published in French, English, or Spanish from January 1, 1995. Population RN^b^, nurses in training, nursing students, or patients receiving care from qualified RN through the medium of ICTs. Intervention: ICTs covered by four eHealth domains Four eHealth domains were considered in the overview \[[@ref6]\]: management systems, communication systems, computerized decision support systems, and information systems. ICTs embody all digital technologies that support the electronic capture, storage, processing, and exchange of information, in order to promote health, prevent illness, treat disease, manage chronic illness, and so on \[[@ref30],[@ref31]\]. Management systems Management systems are computer-based systems used for acquiring, storing, transmitting, and displaying patient administrative or health information from different sources. They can support administrative or clinical activities. Electronic health records (EHRs) and personal health records (PHRs) are examples of management systems. Communication systems Telecommunication systems are employed when users are distant in space and/or time. This kind of communication takes place in a synchronous or an asynchronous way, between health professionals, or between health professionals and patients or caregivers. It involves a targeted sharing of information between specific individuals, or individuals who play distinct roles for diagnostic, management, counseling, educational, or support purposes. There are a wide range of communication systems, from email and mobile phones to telemedicine and telecare systems. Computerized decision support systems (CDSSs) Refer to an automated computer-based system that aims to support health professionals in practicing within clinical guidelines and care pathways. These systems are usually operated in real-time and involve decision support that comes from artificial intelligence (eg, a software program). Information systems Are defined by the use of Internet technology to attain access to different information resources, such as health and lifestyle information. The information remains general, and it is not tailored to specific individual needs. Web-based resources and eHealth portals for retrieving information are some types of information systems. Comparisons Usual care, any other ICT, and other types of interventions. Outcomes The primary outcomes included nursing resources, nurses' practice environment, nursing processes or scope of practice, professional satisfaction, and nursing-sensitive outcomes (eg, patient outcomes, such as risk outcomes and safety, patient comfort, and quality of life related to care). The secondary outcomes included nurses' and patients' satisfaction or dissatisfaction with ICTs. ^a^ICTs: information and communication technologies. ^b^RN: registered nurse. Search Strategy --------------- A medical librarian developed and conducted the search strategies, drawing on other reviews of similar topics and using well-established search filters where appropriate. We searched publications in English, French, or Spanish in the following electronic databases from January 1, 1995: Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (until January 15, 2015); Epistemonikos (until December 25, 2014); PubMed (until December 8, 2014); Embase (until January 7, 2015); Web of Science (until January 9, 2015); and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) (until December 25, 2014). Structured search strategies were developed using the thesaurus terms of each database (eg, Medical subject heading (MeSH) for PubMed) and using free text, targeting the "title" and "abstract" fields. The strategies were then adapted to the other databases. The results of each database search were collected in a single reference database, and duplicate citations were removed. The specific search strategies for databases are presented in [Multimedia Appendix 1](#app1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. Selection of Reviews -------------------- Two reviewers (GR, JPG) independently screened the title and abstract of the papers in order to assess their eligibility. References that did not meet the preestablished inclusion criteria were excluded. Full-text copies of publications were retrieved and were assessed by the same two reviewers. Any discrepancies were resolved through discussion. A third reviewer was available for arbitration when consensus was not reached. Data Extraction and Management ------------------------------ Three reviewers (GR, JPG, and EH) were involved in the data extraction and management process. Information on each review was independently extracted by two of the reviewers. Any disagreement arising during the data extraction process was discussed among the two reviewers. The third reviewer was involved in case of disagreement. Characteristics of included reviews were extracted and summarized: objectives, type of review, number of included studies, search dates, population, setting, eHealth domain, types of general and specific ICTs, examples of included interventions, comparisons, primary and secondary outcomes, review limitations, and authors' conclusions. A data extraction form was developed based on the NCPF \[[@ref18]\] and the dimensions of the actual scope of nursing practice \[[@ref32]\]. The data extraction grid was modified during the extraction process by adding dimensions or categories of results. To facilitate teamwork between the three reviewers (GR, JPG, and EH) in performing the data extraction, we used a shared file in Google Sheets. Reviewers communicated with each other through Google Sheets and added comments on the extraction when needed. The three reviewers reviewed the completed data extraction grid to eliminate discrepancies and errors. Methodological Quality Assessment of Included Reviews ----------------------------------------------------- The three reviewers (GR, JPG, and EH) were involved in the methodological quality assessment of the reviews that met the eligibility criteria, using the assessment of multiple systematic reviews (AMSTAR) tool \[[@ref33],[@ref34]\]. Two reviewers assessed each review independently, and disagreements were discussed. The third reviewer was available for arbitration when needed. AMSTAR is an 11-item checklist from which reviewers assign one point when the criterion is met. AMSTAR items provide an assessment of methodological criteria such as the comprehensiveness of the search strategy and whether the quality of included studies was evaluated and accounted for \[[@ref35]\]. AMSTAR characterizes quality at three levels: 8-11 is high quality (ie, minor or no methodological limitations), 4-7 is medium quality (ie, moderate methodological limitations), and 0-3 is low quality (ie, major methodological limitations) \[[@ref36]\]. In this overview, we included different types of systematic reviews, that is, quantitative reviews (randomized and nonrandomized designs), mixed-method synthesis reviews, and qualitative reviews. AMSTAR is used primarily for quantitative reviews using randomized controlled trial (RCT) design. When undertaking an overview, challenges encountered are the assessment of limitations (risk of bias) as well as the quality of evidence in systematic reviews \[[@ref37],[@ref38]\]. There were no reporting guidelines on assessing methodological quality of mixed-method and qualitative reviews at the time of the overview. We decided to apply AMSTAR to all reviews in order to use the same criteria for quality assessment, although this had limitations (ie, inappropriateness of applying some criteria to mixed-method and qualitative reviews). Data Synthesis -------------- A statistical meta-analysis of outcomes was not possible because the included studies were too heterogeneous. We therefore conducted a narrative synthesis, which is defined as an approach of summarizing and explaining outcomes from multiple studies by employing the use of words and text \[[@ref39]\]. The core characteristic of a narrative synthesis is the adoption of a "textual approach to the process of synthesis to 'tell the story' of the outcomes from the included studies" \[[@ref39]\]. We categorized the reviews into subgroups according to the type of intervention and their effects (positive, negative, or no effect) on a specific dimension of nursing care (eg, practice environment, nursing processes, professional satisfaction, and nursing-sensitive outcomes). Results ======= Description of the Reviews -------------------------- A total of 6187 titles or abstracts were identified. After removing duplicate references, 5515 titles or abstracts were assessed for eligibility. Full-text papers of 72 articles were retrieved for detailed evaluation. It was found that 22 reviews published between 2002 and 2015 met the eligibility criteria. The list of these included reviews is presented in [Multimedia Appendix 2](#app2){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. Twelve reviews used a mixed-method synthesis approach, nine used a quantitative approach, and one used a qualitative approach (meta-ethnography). Fifty reviews were mainly excluded because they did not present primary outcomes related to nursing care (n=24), or because outcomes related to nurses were indistinguishable from other populations (n=13). In [Multimedia Appendix 3](#app3){ref-type="supplementary-material"}, details are provided regarding the primary reasons for exclusion and the full references of the excluded articles. The preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) study flow diagram \[[@ref40]\] are illustrated in [Figure 2](#figure2){ref-type="fig"} to show the overall process of review selection. The general characteristics (ie, type of reviews, search dates, target population, and health care settings) of the included reviews are presented in [Multimedia Appendix 4](#app4){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. The review objectives, limitations, and main conclusions are synthetized in [Multimedia Appendix 5](#app5){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. The eHealth domains covered were management systems (n=14), communication systems (n=7), and CDSSs (n=10). No reviews dealt with information systems. Five reviews included more than one eHealth domain \[[@ref3],[@ref41]-[@ref44]\]. Articles reviewing management systems included the following ICTs: electronic medical or health or patient records, computer-based nursing records or computerized nursing care planning, and regional health care information system. The ICTs covered in the communication systems were email, mobile phone, bedside communication tool or bedside terminals, iPod technology to assist in educational conferences, and telemedicine or telehealth with the use of videophone or videoconferencing. The CDSSs covered were medication management technology---e-prescribing, electronic medication administration record systems, computerized provider order entry (CPOE), bar-code medication administration (BCMA) ---and PDAs. These eHealth services can be categorized as belonging to more than one domain \[[@ref6]\], depending on their components. Details about eHealth domains, examples of included interventions, and comparisons are presented in [Multimedia Appendix 6](#app6){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. {#figure2} Assessment of Review Quality ---------------------------- The AMSTAR tool was used to assess the methodological quality of all reviews. Four reviews, mostly quantitative ones, were high quality (scores: 8-9); nine were medium quality (scores between 4 and 7), and nine scored low quality (between 0 and 3). AMSTAR scoring for each review is presented in [Table 2](#table2){ref-type="table"}. We adapted the interpretation of two criteria (\#7 and \#9) of the AMSTAR tool to assess the quality of mixed-method and qualitative reviews. For the criteria 7---reporting and assessment of scientific quality of the included reviews---we answered "yes" if authors mentioned having assessed and documented quality of quantitative reviews, and if they acknowledged clearly the difficulty of assessing qualitative or mixed-methods reviews. For criteria 9, entailing the inappropriateness of methods used to combine findings, we answered "yes," based on the decision rules developed by Kitsiou et al \[[@ref45]\]: "reviews' authors made a statement regarding the inappropriateness of pooling data (eg, highlighted issues about heterogeneity or variability between the studies), that is, the authors summarized and synthesized the available evidence narratively according to a defined analysis plan and/or using appropriate qualitative methods and techniques (eg, construction of common rubrics, content analysis, tabulation, groupings, and clustering)." Regarding criteria 10, about the assessment of publication bias, it seems that empirical evidence on this topic in qualitative research is very limited \[[@ref46]\]. We presume that this is the same reality regarding the mixed-method reviews. Dimensions of Nursing Care That Are Influenced by Information and Communication Technologies -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The results (see [Figure 3](#figure3){ref-type="fig"}) will be presented in association with the NCPF: the function, the dimension, and the theme (which correspond or not to a particular indicator in the framework). [Table 3](#table3){ref-type="table"} presents the frequency of extracted data per dimensions, themes, and ICTs. ###### Assessment of multiple systematic reviews (AMSTAR) scoring. References Type of reviews or designs AMSTAR score -------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------- -------------- Free \[[@ref42]\] Quantitative (RCT^a^) 9 (high) Mador \[[@ref47]\] Quantitative (various designs) 9 (high) Urquhart \[[@ref16]\] Cochrane review---quantitative (RCT+1 other design) 8 (high) McKibbon \[[@ref43]\] Mixed 8 (high) Nieuwlaat \[[@ref48]\] Quantitative (RCT) 7 (medium) Mickan \[[@ref49]\] Quantitative (RCT) 6 (medium) Finkelstein \[[@ref41]\] Mixed 6 (medium) Randell \[[@ref50]\] Quantitative (RCT) 5 (medium) Georgiou \[[@ref51]\] Quantitative (various designs) 5 (medium) Dowding \[[@ref52]\] Quantitative (various designs) 5 (medium) Poissant \[[@ref53]\] Quantitative (various designs) 4 (medium) Husebo \[[@ref54]\] Mixed (integrative) 4 (medium) Jones \[[@ref55]\] Mixed (integrative) 4 (medium) Meißner \[[@ref56]\] Qualitative (meta-ethnography) 3 (low) Bowles \[[@ref44]\] Mixed 3 (low) Anderson \[[@ref17]\] Mixed 3 (low) Maeenpa \[[@ref57]\] Mixed 2 (low) NGuyen \[[@ref58]\] Mixed 2 (low) Stevenson \[[@ref15]\] Mixed 2 (low) Bartoli \[[@ref59]\] Mixed 1 (low) Carrington \[[@ref3]\] Mixed 1 (low) Kelley \[[@ref60]\] Mixed (integrative) 0 (low) ^a^RCT: randomized controlled trial. {#figure3} ###### Frequency extracted data. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dimension Themes (Number of reviews) (Types of eHealth domain) Positive effects of ICTs^a^ Negative effects of ICTs No effect Total ---------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------- -------------------------- ----------- ------- **Time and efficiency** 20 17 7 44 \ Time management (4) (MS^b^, CS^c^, CDSS^d^) 2 1 1 4 \ Time spent for patient care (7) (MS, CS, CDSS) 4 5 3 12 \ Documentation time (7) (MS^e^) 14 11 3 28 **Nurses' practice environment** 19 5 1 25 \ Knowledge updating and utilization (3) (CS, CDSS) 3 0 1 4 \ Information quality and access (5) (MS^f^, CDSS) 11 2 0 13 \ Nurse autonomy (1) (CS^e^) 1 0 0 1 \ Intra and interprofessional collaboration (6) (MS^f^, CS, CDSS) 4 3 0 7 **Nursing processes** 30 12 3 45 \ Nurses competencies-skills (4) (MS, CDSS) 9 1 1 11 \ Nurse-patient relationship (3) (CS^e^) 4 0 0 4 \ Quality of documentation (7) (MS^f^, CS) 6 4 1 11 \ Assessment, care planning, and evaluation (10) (MS, CS, CDSS) 13 8 2 23 \ Teaching of patients and families (4) (CS^f^, CDSS) 5 0 0 5 \ Communication and care coordination (2) (CS, MS) 2 0 0 2 **Professional satisfaction** 29 18 1 48 \ Nurses' perspectives of the quality of care provided (6) (MS, CS, CDSS) 15 2 0 17 \ Satisfaction or dissatisfaction of nurses using ICTs (10) MS, CS, CDSS) 14 16 1 31 **Nursing sensitive outcomes** 28 5 5 38 \ Patient comfort and quality of life related to care (7) (CS, CDSS) 7 0 1 8 \ Empowerment (4) (CS^f^, MS) 6 0 1 7 \ Functional status (3) (CS^e^) 3 0 1 4 \ Satisfaction or dissatisfaction of patients using ICTs (5) (CS, MS) 12 5 2 19 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ^a^ICTs: information and communication technologies. ^b^MS: management systems. ^c^CS: communications systems. ^d^CDSSs: computerized decision support systems. ^e^One eHealth domain covered exclusively a particular theme. ^f^Majority of one eHealth domain covered a particular theme. Function 1: Acquiring, Deploying, and Maintaining Resources ----------------------------------------------------------- ### Time and Efficiency Overall, 11 reviews \[[@ref15],[@ref16],[@ref43],[@ref44],[@ref47],[@ref48],[@ref51],[@ref53],[@ref56],[@ref58],[@ref60]\] had results related to time: time management (time consumed or time saved resulting the use of ICTs); time spent for patient care; and documentation time. ### Time Management Four reviews \[[@ref43],[@ref44],[@ref48],[@ref53]\] targeting CDSSs, communication, and management systems had findings on "time management" in a general way: one review showed no effect \[[@ref48]\], another showed negative effects \[[@ref43]\], and two reported positive effects \[[@ref44],[@ref53]\]. In Nieuwlaat et al's \[[@ref48]\] review, results demonstrated that nurses perceived that conventional care compared with CDSSs were equally time-consuming (no effect). The other review reported that reminder systems were "time-consuming" \[[@ref43]\]. The results in the Poissant et al \[[@ref53]\] review revealed that the use of EHRs has been shown to reduce the time devoted to the verbal transmission of information at the end-of-shift. Consequently, this caused a change in the workflow, which may have been a strong incentive for nurses to become efficient users of the system. In the Bowles and Baugh \[[@ref44]\] review, the effect of telehomecare was also reported positively in terms on "saving time." ### Time Spent for Patient Care Almost one-third of the reviews (7/23) \[[@ref16],[@ref43],[@ref47],[@ref51],[@ref56],[@ref58],[@ref60]\] outlined positive \[[@ref16],[@ref47],[@ref56],[@ref58]\] and negative effects \[[@ref43],[@ref51],[@ref56],[@ref60]\], as well as no effect \[[@ref43],[@ref51],[@ref58]\] of CDSSs, management systems, and communication systems on time spent for patient care. Nurses are sometimes concerned that using electronic nursing documentation or the BCMA for documenting and for administering medication might take away or reduce time for patient care \[[@ref43],[@ref56]\]. Conversely, other reviews including communication systems (eg, telehomecare) and management systems (eg, EHRs) found that time spent for patient care has significantly improved \[[@ref16],[@ref47],[@ref56],[@ref58]\] and particularly, nurses using EHRs spent more time with patients in assessment, education, and communication \[[@ref58]\]. ### Documentation Time Nurse documentation time was reported in seven reviews \[[@ref15],[@ref16],[@ref43],[@ref47],[@ref53],[@ref56],[@ref60]\] touching on management systems, such as EHRs, e-prescribing system, and critical care information system (CCIS). Effects of these ICTs on documentation time were mixed within and across the reviews: six reviews demonstrated positive effects \[[@ref15],[@ref16],[@ref47],[@ref53],[@ref56],[@ref60]\], six demonstrated negative effects \[[@ref15],[@ref16],[@ref43],[@ref47],[@ref53],[@ref60]\], and three demonstrated no effect \[[@ref43],[@ref47],[@ref60]\]. Negative results showed that nurses spent more time documenting when they used management systems and the positive results showed the contrary: documentation time diminished with ICTs. The time saved for documenting was sometimes reallocated for patient care and had positive outcome on the improvement of health care \[[@ref15]\]. Otherwise, when the task of documenting took much more time, nurses had less time to spend with patients \[[@ref60]\]. Function 2: Transforming Resources into Services ------------------------------------------------ ### Nurses' Practice Environment #### Knowledge Updating and Utilization Three reviews found positive effects \[[@ref17],[@ref44],[@ref54]\] of CDSSs and communication systems on knowledge updating and utilization, whereas one review found no effect \[[@ref17]\]. CDSSs are useful tools to increase knowledge and information use, and translate outcomes from research into practice by improving nurses' compliance with established guidelines \[[@ref17]\]. The potential of communication systems (eg, telehomecare or telehealth) to transfer nursing knowledge was also reported \[[@ref44],[@ref54]\]. #### Information Quality and Access The eHealth domain that was the most covered in relation to information quality and access was management systems, covered in four reviews \[[@ref43],[@ref57],[@ref58],[@ref60]\], followed by CDSSs in two reviews \[[@ref17],[@ref43]\]. One review documented the improvement of information quality as perceived by doctors and nurses after the implementation of EHRs \[[@ref58]\], and the results of five reviews highlighted information access \[[@ref17],[@ref43],[@ref57],[@ref58],[@ref60]\]. Management systems and CDSSs had positive impact in three reviews \[[@ref43],[@ref57],[@ref60]\] on information access regarding patient issues, clinical data, medication information or profile, and other information (policies, guidelines, drug resources, patient files). Nurse practitioners felt that CDSSs could assist them with patient care when data is easily accessible with the use of the technology \[[@ref43]\]. The negative impact were pointed out in two reviews \[[@ref58],[@ref60]\] that cited the results of the same primary study \[[@ref61]\], that is, nurses could not retrieve the information perceived as essential for patient care within the electronic nursing documentation system. #### Nurse Autonomy Only one review mentioned nurse autonomy as a positive effect. In this review \[[@ref59]\], nurses were expected to handle most cases autonomously and to refer to doctors only in exceptional cases when using the tele-triage system designed to monitor chronic heart failure patients remotely. #### Intra- and Interprofessional Collaboration Four reviews highlighted positive \[[@ref17],[@ref42],[@ref52],[@ref59]\] effects regarding intra- and interprofessional collaboration, one showed negative effect \[[@ref43]\] and one reported no effect \[[@ref60]\] with the use of CDSSs \[[@ref17]\], communications \[[@ref42],[@ref59]\], and management systems \[[@ref43],[@ref52],[@ref60]\]. Reviews including CDSSs reported improved communication between members of the interdisciplinary team \[[@ref17]\], such as between nurses and surgeons \[[@ref42]\], better and more trustworthy relationships between nurses and doctors by using telehomecare systems \[[@ref59]\], and more frequent collaboration between members of the health care team when using management systems (ie, clinical dashboards) \[[@ref52]\]. In one review, results showed that electronic nursing documentation systems negatively affected collaborative working relationships between nurses and physicians \[[@ref60]\]. ### Nursing Processes #### Nurses' Competencies and Skills Four reviews that encompassed CDSSs and management systems showed that they had a positive influence on these domains of nurses' competencies and skills: decision support or decision-making \[[@ref17],[@ref43],[@ref56]\], observation skills \[[@ref56]\], clinical judgment \[[@ref17],[@ref56]\], and critical thinking \[[@ref60]\]. Additionally, due to some features of CDSSs and management systems (eg, readability of data, remote accessibility of data, better quality of patients' records, presence of reminders, or automatic alerts), these ICTs supported clinical judgment and decision-making \[[@ref43],[@ref56]\]. Conversely, some features of the ICTs not previously available on paper, such as copy and paste, drop-down menus, and check boxes, affected the nurses' capacity to employ critical thinking regarding their patients \[[@ref60]\]. Finally, the results presented in Anderson and Willson \[[@ref17]\] review showed no effect of CDSSs on the knowledge or clinical decision-making of nurses associated with pressure ulcer prevention. #### Quality of Documentation Positive effects on documentation quality were highlighted in six reviews \[[@ref3],[@ref15],[@ref43],[@ref56],[@ref58],[@ref60]\]; five on these reviews encompassed management systems. Negative effects were reported in three reviews \[[@ref15],[@ref56],[@ref60]\], and another review documented no effect \[[@ref41]\]. Results from the Stevenson et al \[[@ref15]\] review: nurses reported that EHRs did not reflect their practice and reported that it was "incapable of capturing much of what they believed was crucial in nursing care." With regards to psychological care, nurses also reported issues with fitting complex caring practice into systems that are not intended to accommodate it, for example, when providing emotional and psychological support. Since EPRs lack sensitivity, they cannot capture "the being there stuff," for example, caring for a dying patient by sitting on their bedside and holding their hand. Two reviews \[[@ref15],[@ref56]\] stated that when the quality of documentation is improved, quality of care and patient safety can be fostered since it allows a complete overview of the patient's situation \[[@ref56]\]. #### Nurse-Patient Relationship In three reviews, use of communication systems (virtual visits using videophones, telehomecare, telehealth) positively impacted nurse-patient relationship. Reviews mentioned the potential of ICTs to provide a pathway for communication \[[@ref55]\], create new types of bonds with patients \[[@ref44]\], establish trust through the videoconference system, and create a sense of connection (from the patients' perspective)\[[@ref54]\]. #### Assessment, Care Planning, and Evaluation Impact of CDSSs, management, and communication systems were mixed, that is, positive effects were mentioned in seven reviews \[[@ref15],[@ref17],[@ref41],[@ref44],[@ref49],[@ref55],[@ref56]\], negative effects were mentioned in five reviews \[[@ref15],[@ref16],[@ref41],[@ref42],[@ref54]\], and no effect was documented in two reviews \[[@ref16],[@ref55]\]. For example, a handheld computer-based support system for preference-based care planning led to a higher consistency between patient preferences and nursing care plan priorities \[[@ref17]\]. An "email intervention" cited in the Finkelstein et al \[[@ref41]\] review led to a more comprehensive heart failure and medication adherence assessment by nurses being recorded. EHRs contain templates that guide nurses for assessment and help them identify problems \[[@ref56]\]. The mixed review by Stevenson et al \[[@ref15]\] revealed negative impact of EHRs regarding poor care plans updates, the difficulty of individualizing care plans within the systems, and the difficulty of capturing a broad picture of the patient within the electronic personal record. Similarly, the Urquhart et al \[[@ref16]\] review showed that computerized nursing care planning compared with manual planning led to (1) no effect between groups regarding planning; and (2) negative effects, because planned tasks were not carried out as expected for nurses using ICTs. #### Teaching of Patients and Families Four reviews reported teaching benefits: three with the use of communication systems \[[@ref41],[@ref54],[@ref55]\] and one with CDSSs \[[@ref43]\]. For example, virtual visits simplified teaching and information sharing with patients and thus became a way to transfer knowledge \[[@ref54]\]. Also, patients had clearer instructions on discharge and on their medication administration at home as reported by nurse practitioners \[[@ref43]\]. #### Communication and Care Coordination Two reviews found that communication systems had positive impact on delivering continuous and coordinated care, on the prevention of preventing relapses into poor health \[[@ref54]\], and on improving communication about resident care \[[@ref56]\]. ### Professional Satisfaction #### Nurses' Perspectives of the Quality of Care Provided In six reviews, positive effects \[[@ref41],[@ref43],[@ref44],[@ref54]-[@ref56]\] of CDSSs, management, and communication systems were reported: improvement of quality of care and patient safety; nurses' perceptions that BCMA reduce medication errors and improve medication administration processes \[[@ref43]\]; and the provision of comprehensive and adaptive care related to the patients' needs with the help of telehealth used with elders \[[@ref55]\]. In four reviews \[[@ref15],[@ref43],[@ref56],[@ref58]\], negative results were discussed: EHRs do not improve patient care as perceived by nurses \[[@ref58]\]; and patients do not receive necessary care because the quality of residents' records is lacking \[[@ref56]\]. #### Satisfaction or Dissatisfaction of Nurses Using ICTs The results in ten reviews, targeting the three eHealth domains, found that nurse satisfaction was mixed: nine reviews reported positive effects \[[@ref17],[@ref41],[@ref43],[@ref44],[@ref48],[@ref54],[@ref56],[@ref58],[@ref60]\], eight reported negative effects \[[@ref15],[@ref43],[@ref44],[@ref48],[@ref54],[@ref56],[@ref58],[@ref60]\], and one reported no effect \[[@ref43]\]. Results pertained to overall acceptance of ICTs and their satisfaction was described in general ways, such as "nurses were satisfied with ICTs." There were also elements associated with ICTs, such as system navigability (eg, complexity, ease of use, user-friendliness, and flexibility), nurses' attitudes, concerns about patients' privacy, and perceived benefits or inconveniences. Some nurses found EHRs to be irrelevant for practice \[[@ref58]\]. Function 3: Producing Changes in Patients' Condition ---------------------------------------------------- ### Nursing-Sensitive Outcomes #### Patient Comfort and Quality of Life Related to Care The positive effects of CDSSs and communication systems on comfort and quality of life related to care \[[@ref3],[@ref17],[@ref41],[@ref44],[@ref50],[@ref54],[@ref55]\] were described in terms of patient outcomes: fewer number of wetting occurrences \[[@ref17]\], reduction of malnourished patients \[[@ref3],[@ref50]\], the reduction of pain and anxiety \[[@ref44]\], better quality of life \[[@ref41]\], and lower burden related to care \[[@ref55]\]. One review reported little improvement on quality of care with the use of telehomecare \[[@ref44]\]. #### Empowerment Four reviews \[[@ref16],[@ref41],[@ref44],[@ref54]\] highlighted empowerment as a positive effect of communication systems. One management system showed no effect \[[@ref16]\]. Some examples of positive impact include diabetic patients, who felt that the telehomecare empowered them \[[@ref44]\] and had positive results in terms of diabetes management with an eHealth application \[[@ref41]\]. One review also cited videoconferences for conducting nursing virtual visits as tools to increase patients' abilities to manage self-care \[[@ref54]\]. #### Functional Status In three reviews \[[@ref41],[@ref54],[@ref55]\], the results regarding the effects of communication systems on functional status (eg, physical, cognitive, psychosocial functional capacity) were discussed in a positive way. Computer use (in a telehealth context) and elders' self-esteem have been positively associated \[[@ref55]\]. In another review \[[@ref54]\], the results showed that communication systems (eg, virtual visits using videoconference) decreased loneliness and melancholia, enhanced psychosocial and social activity, and aided memory among home-dwelling elders. In the Finkelstein et al \[[@ref41]\] review, the results revealed that the health status of patients among groups did not differ with the use of communication systems. #### Satisfaction or Dissatisfaction of Patients of Using ICTs Patients' satisfaction with ICTs was documented in five reviews that demonstrated positive effects \[[@ref41],[@ref44],[@ref54],[@ref55],[@ref58]\], three that showed negative effects \[[@ref54],[@ref55],[@ref58]\], and two that showed no effect \[[@ref55],[@ref58]\]. Patient results indicated their degree of satisfaction or dissatisfaction with ICTs; their acceptance, acceptability, and receptiveness of their usage of ICTs; and their appreciation for being able to schedule videoconferences about topics of their choice \[[@ref44],[@ref54],[@ref58]\]. The results were presented in terms of usefulness (or uselessness); perceived and actual benefits or advantages, such as accessibility and flexibility \[[@ref54]\]; ease of use, usability, complexity; and the degree to which the ICTs were well-designed and functioned fully \[[@ref41],[@ref55],[@ref58]\]. Some patients were confident in using ICTs \[[@ref44]\], whereas others were concerned about the confidentiality of their health information \[[@ref58]\]. Results from the Husebo and Storm \[[@ref54]\] review indicate that patients who had visual contact with nurses through communication systems felt cared for and perceived a sense of connection. Summary Description of eHealth Domains Related to Specific Themes ----------------------------------------------------------------- On the basis of the content of [Table 3](#table3){ref-type="table"}, we propose a summary description of which eHealth domains cover specific themes of nursing care. ### Management Systems The only eHealth domain reported to influence the documentation time was management systems, such as electronic nursing documentation \[[@ref60]\], CCIS \[[@ref47]\], CPOE, eMAR \[[@ref43]\], and EHRs \[[@ref53]\]. The other themes reported with these systems were time spent on patient care; time management; information quality and access, intra and interprofessional collaboration; quality of documentation; nurses' competencies and skills; assessment, care planning, and evaluation; nurses' perspectives of the quality of care provided; empowerment; and satisfaction or dissatisfaction of nurses and patients using ICTs. ### Communication Systems Communication systems was the only eHealth domain found to be applicable to the themes of nurse-patient relationship, autonomy for nurses in their role, and patients' functional status. These themes were also discussed related to communication systems: teaching patients and families, knowledge update and utilization; intra and interprofessional collaboration; quality of documentation; assessment, care planning, and evaluation; communication and care coordination; nurses' perspectives of the quality of care provided; satisfaction or dissatisfaction of nurses and patients using ICTs; patient comfort and quality of life related to care; and patients' empowerment. ### Computerized Decision Support Systems (CDSSs) CDSSs are mentioned in nurses\' practice environment dimension (3/4): knowledge updating and utilization; information quality and access; and intra and interprofessional collaboration. Regarding the nurses' competencies and skills, CDSSs are involved with decision-making processes. Some other themes discussed in relation to CDSSs are assessment, care planning, and evaluation; teaching of patients and families; nurses' perspectives of the quality of care provided; satisfaction or dissatisfaction of nurses and patients using ICTs; and patient comfort and quality of life related to care. Discussion ========== Summary of Main Results ----------------------- This overview allowed a broad understanding of the dimensions of nursing care influenced by using ICTs for providing care. Regarding the primary outcomes of interest, the themes that were most frequently reported are documentation time; assessment, care planning, and evaluation; nurses' perspective of the quality of care provided; information quality and access; and time spent for patient care. For secondary outcomes, satisfaction or dissatisfaction of nurses and patients using ICTs was frequently mentioned. Discussion of Results With Respect to the First Function of the NCPF -------------------------------------------------------------------- In relation to the first function of the NCPF (*acquiring, deploying, and maintaining nursing resources*), many reviews outlined outcomes linked to "time." The use of ICTs affected time management, time spent for patient care, and documentation time. This theme could also refer to a dimension of the NCPF called *maintenance and economic sustainability of the nursing staff* \[[@ref18]\]. Sustainability refers to the importance of having quality resources at the lowest cost. This dimension highlights productivity and the necessity to optimize the outputs produced from a given set of inputs; in other words, to minimize the amount of nursing tasks, materials, and equipment without sacrificing the quality of nursing services. The "time" dimension can be understood in terms of how ICTs can impact staff, productivity, optimization of the staff's time management, and resources utilization. We do believe that time is an interesting outcome related to the resources of the overall structure (nursing staff), but it does not reflect directly on how ICTs can transform or support what nurses do (nursing activities or interventions) within their actual scope of practice. Considering our results, we do not believe that further research should focus on "time" in order to better understand the effects of ICTs on nursing care (and specifically, on nursing processes). This review did not explore other dimensions and indicators related to the first function of the NCPF, such as nursing staff supply. These dimensions include quantity and quality indicators. As an example, it would be interesting to explore whether the availability of ICTs in specific health care settings impacts the quantity of nurses needed to perform nursing services. Another relevant topic would be to probe whether ICTs act as facilitator or motivator to enhance nurses' working conditions, or serve as a barrier that inhibits them. To what extent can ICTs create favorable conditions that attract nurses and reinforce stability in the workforce? A systematic review was undertaken on the effect of ICTs on retention and recruitment of health care professionals \[[@ref62]\]. The results revealed that, in 9 out of the 13 studies, ICT use demonstrated a positive, though often indirect, influence on recruitment and retention. The influence of ICTs on retention of nurses was also examined in a qualitative study \[[@ref63]\]. The results highlighted various impact of ICTs on nurse retention (ie, little or no impact, unclear impact, or indirect positive impact). Discussion of Results With Respect to the Second Function of the NCPF --------------------------------------------------------------------- The three dimensions corresponding to the second function, *transforming nursing resources into nursing services*, are nurses' practice environment, nursing processes, and professional satisfaction. The themes "knowledge updating and utilization" and "communication and care coordination" were not explicitly described in the NCPF and we used them from the instrument of "actual scope of nursing practice" \[[@ref32]\]. The indicator "scope of practice" is included in the nursing processes of the NCPF, but there are no explicit underlying subindicators. The "information quality and access" theme was analyzed as an effect of ICTs on nurses' practice environment. In other words, ICTs are seen as a potential way to support nursing work by allowing them to get access to various sources of information and clinical data. The theme "quality of documentation" is not part of the nurses' practice environment because it is linked to what nurses do as activities. The capacity of nurses to deliver nursing interventions is intimately and consistently linked with organizational processes that capture the nursing practice context and mediate its outcomes \[[@ref64],[@ref65]\]. These processes, defined as interventions, support nursing work and sustain a professional environment \[[@ref66]\]. We hypothesize that, if nurses have access to a comprehensive set of information about patients, this would trickle down on nursing processes, such as quality of documentation, assessment, care planning, and evaluation. It would also impact communication and care coordination to benefit patient outcomes. A surprising result is the following: only one review mentioned nurse autonomy in relation to the use of ICTs \[[@ref59]\]. It would be interesting to know more about questions such as: How can we define "autonomy" in a context in which nurses use or are exposed to ICTs to provide nursing care? How can ICTs support or influence nurse autonomy? Can ICTs be a required training tool in nurses' practice environments to support their own autonomy? The NCPF model reflects the deployment of nurses' full scope of practice, including assessment, planning, and evaluation; problem and symptom management; health promotion and illness prevention; care coordination; and discharge planning, which are conceptualized through interventions and processes in the model. From a health care provider perspective, these processes grasp the technical elements of care and reflect the extent to which staff are capable of using and mobilizing their competencies to deploy their entire scope of practice. These processes demonstrate the capability of nurses to engage the needs of patients \[[@ref18]\]. Our results show that, in reference to the processes described in the NCPF, few such processes have been described in the studies included in this overview. However, assessment, care planning, and evaluation are the most cited themes in the nursing processes dimension, followed by teaching of patients and families and, finally, by communication and care coordination. Despite these outcomes, it would be helpful to conduct primary studies on how ICTs could influence or support other nursing processes, such as problem and symptom management, health promotion and illness prevention, and discharge planning. Nurses' professional satisfaction is conceived as the result of nursing processes. Our results revealed two facets of this satisfaction: nurses' perspective of the quality of care provided and nurses' satisfaction or dissatisfaction using ICTs. The NCPF included additional indicators that were not mentioned in the included reviews to capture the nurses' professional satisfaction: having the time to do their job and the enjoyment derived from it. Discussion of Results With Respect to the Third Function of the NCPF -------------------------------------------------------------------- We believe that nursing-sensitive outcomes, which are the "patient outcomes," are underrepresented in our overview because of our inclusion criteria that focused on reviews of the impact or effect of ICTs on nursing resources and services. Thus, patient outcomes were only considered if nursing outcomes were reported. This means that we included patients' outcomes as primary outcomes as long as they fell within the usage of ICTs by nurses, and then, when outcomes related to the second function of the NCPF (nursing services and processes) were reported. Dubois and colleagues \[[@ref67]\] undertook a systematic work including three literature reviews to identify the priority indicators in evaluating the nursing contribution to quality of care. The results revealed that the most frequently examined nursing sensitive outcomes are pressure ulcers, medication administration errors, urinary infections by catheter, and falls. These indicators are located in the "risk outcomes and safety" dimension of the NCPF. Despite this, there are several systematic reviews on the effects of ICTs on patients' outcomes \[[@ref68]-[@ref71]\]. However, these reviews do not necessarily explore the impact of ICTs on nursing services and processes (second function of the NCPF) when considering patients' outcomes. Strengths and Potential Biases ------------------------------ There are many strengths of this overview. First, it employed a comprehensive search strategy, which was developed and implemented by a medical librarian. Second, data extraction and quality assessment were conducted by three reviewers working independently. Third, the data extraction process was done with the use of the NCPF, which supported the organization and the analysis of results. This framework supported reflection on the way ICTs could influence specific aspects of nursing care. Some new, redefined, or adapted dimensions and indicators have been suggested in the framework: time management, time spent for patient care and documentation time, information quality and access, quality of documentation, knowledge updating and utilization as part of the nurses\' practice environment, communication and care coordination, and nurse and patient satisfaction or dissatisfaction regarding their use of ICTs. Fourth, one of the authors of the NCPF (CAD) challenged the analysis and interpretation of the results. Some debriefing meetings were held to discuss the way the themes were presented related to their organization in the NCPF (under specific subsystems, functions, dimensions, and indicators). There are also limitations to this overview. First, as mentioned by other authors \[[@ref27],[@ref72]\], we were limited by the information provided by the review authors. The granularity of details available was limited and some information was lacking regarding both the description of ICTs (eg, their features, components, contexts of use, and area of practice) as well as findings regarding the dimensions of nursing care influenced by ICTs. Therefore, it was not possible to make significant conclusions about how a specific ICT influenced one or many indicators (themes) of nursing care, and it was challenging to categorize these extracted findings (impact of ICTs) within the NCPF. A comprehensive description of interventions (ICTs) would have been helpful. Further research could be done to gain knowledge about how a specific ICT used in a certain area of practice can impact on one or many dimensions and indicators of nursing care. Third, the nature of the topic was not easy to capture in the reported data of systematic reviews. It was difficult to establish if nurses experienced changes in their practice with the use of ICTs, or if instead they believed that ICTs would change their practice and work environment without really experiencing these transformations. Some outcomes related to the use of ICTs are reported in terms of "barriers." However, it is not always clear if it is a barrier to use ICTs or an effect or impact of having used them. Systematic reviews on the determinants of nurses' acceptance and use of ICTs are plenty \[[@ref31],[@ref73]-[@ref75]\], but do not inform on the real effects of ICTs on nursing practice. Fourth, we used AMSTAR to assess methodological quality of qualitative and mixed-method reviews even if this tool was not developed for types of reviews other than quantitative using mainly RCT designs. The results of this work should be interpreted with caution. Although it provides a broad perspective on the phenomenon of interest, the main shortcoming of a review of systematic reviews is the heterogeneity in terms of population, interventions (types of ICTs), types of reviews, and the variety of outcomes, which might lead to the possibility of biased conclusions. For further research and methodological development in this domain, we strongly recommend a consolidated tool to evaluate the quality of different types of reviews on a common scale. The results of the assessment of methodological quality of mixed-method and qualitative reviews must be interpreted with caution, considering that AMSTAR is not used and designed for that purpose. In fact, some criteria do not fit the specificities of other types of reviews because there are no gold standards or guidelines allowing us to perform this task. Consequently, mixed-method and qualitative reviews started with a lower score, which cannot lead to a judgment about the likely bias and methodological limitations inherent in the majority of reviews summarized in [Table 2](#table2){ref-type="table"}. Finally, this overview draws a picture of the reality of ICTs that covered a period extended from 2002 to the start of 2015. The emerging or novel ICTs that have been published from 2015 until now could not be captured. Differences Between Protocol and Overview ----------------------------------------- As stated in the protocol \[[@ref25]\], one of the objectives was to explore whether specific categories of ICTs (management systems, communication systems, CDSSs, or information systems) could have an impact on nursing care. As mentioned earlier, the heterogeneity of reviews and the lack of granularity regarding extracted data or information were some reasons why we could not pursue the initial objective. When we planned this overview, we were particularly interested in the dimensions of nursing care inherent to the second and the third function of the NCPF, which are nurses' practice environment, nursing processes, professional satisfaction (second function or subsystem), and nursing-sensitive outcomes (third function or subsystem). Throughout the data extraction process, we realized that some outcomes, particularly those related to the time and efficiency, were frequently mentioned. We then decided to extract these results based on their frequency and their impact on the nursing care. Authors' Conclusions -------------------- To the best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to draw a broad understanding and a schematization of specific dimensions and indicators of nursing care influenced by ICTs. Using the NCPF was useful to illustrate the way ICTs can impact 3 subsystems (nursing resources, nursing services or processes, and nursing sensitive outcomes or patients' outcomes), 5 dimensions, and 19 themes corresponding to the NCPF indicators. Findings of this overview are a good starting point from which we could deepen our conceptualization on the way nursing care system performance can be affected by ICTs. According to a systemic perspective, it is plausible to believe that the adoption and implementation of ICTs in the nursing care system must be addressed under a multidimensional perspective, considering that the 3 subsystems are interrelated. If nurses use ICTs to support their interventions, and the impact of such ICTs are positive or negative on the work they do, this could possibly reverberate on patient outcomes. We have to keep this broad representation in mind when it will be the time to plan and to implement emerging ICTs in health care settings. Takeaway Messages ----------------- Using the NCPF was relevant to draw a broad, multidimensional, and a system-based perspective on the dimensions and indicators of nursing care that can be impacted by ICTs. ICTs have a mixed impact on 19 indicators related to nursing care: documentation time, time spent for patient care, time management, knowledge updating and utilization, information quality and access, nurse autonomy, intra and interprofessional collaboration, nurses competencies-skills, nurse-patient relationship, quality of documentation, assessment, care planning and evaluation, teaching of patients and families, communication and care coordination, nurses' perspectives of the quality of care provided, patient comfort and quality of life related to care, empowerment, functional status, and satisfaction or dissatisfaction of nurses and patients using ICTs. Management systems, including, for instance, electronic nursing documentation system, CCIS, CPOE, eMAR, and EHRs, have been discussed exclusively with the theme "documentation time" (in the included reviews). Communication systems have been described exclusively regarding nurse-patient relationship, autonomy for nurses in their role, and patients' functional status (eg, physical, cognitive, and psychosocial functional capacity). This research is funded thanks to a Knowledge Transfer (KT) Canada Student Research Stipend, awarded to GR, an initiative funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR; grant \#88368). MPG holds the Tier 2 Canadian Research Chair in Technologies and Practices in Health and JC holds the Research Chair in Innovative Nursing Practices. Special thanks to William Witteman, who planned and performed the search strategy, and Suzana Anjos for the linguistic revision of this manuscript. We acknowledge the precious work of the three reviewers: D Dowding, JM Carrington, and P Johansson. Authors\' Contributions: GR conceived and designed the overview with input from MPG and JC. GR informed the search strategy and performed the search, with the help of a health librarian. GR, JPG, and EH were responsible for data extraction. GR, MPG, JC, JPG, EH, and CAD have been involved in data analysis and interpretation of results. GR, MPG, JC, JPG, EH, and CAD were engaged in the drafting of this manuscript and they all read and approved the final manuscript. Conflicts of Interest: None declared. Search strategies. List of included reviews. Excluded articles and reasons for exclusion. General characteristics of included reviews. Review objectives, limitations, and main conclusions. eHealth domains, interventions, and comparisons. ADE : adverse drug event ADL : activities of daily living AMSTAR : assessment of multiple systematic reviews APN : advanced practice nurse BCMA : bar-coded medication administration CCIS : critical care information system CDSSs : computerized decision support systems CINAHL : Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature COPD : chronic obstructive pulmonary disease CPIS : computerized patient information systems CPOE : computerized provider order entry CS : communication systems D-RHIS : disease-specific regional health care information systems ECG : electrocardiogram ED : emergency department EHR : electronic health record eMAR : electronic medication administration record systems EMR : electronic medical record EPR : electronic personal record ES-NIS : expert system nursing information system EWS : early warning score HCPs : health care providers HIT : health information technology ICTs : information and communication technologies ICU : intensive care unit I-RHIS : integrated regional health care information systems IT : information technology LOS : length of stay MeSH : Medical subject heading MMIT : medication management health information technology MS : management systems NCPF : nursing care performance framework NHS : National Health Service ORA : organization risk analyzer PCC : patient-centered care PDA : personal digital assistant PHR : personal health record PICOs : participants, interventions, comparisons, outcomes and studies PRISMA : Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis RCT : randomized controlled trial RHIO : regional health care information organization RHIS : regional health care information system RN : registered nurse SMS : short message service TDMD : therapeutic drug monitoring and dosing WAP : wireless application protocol

\section{Introduction} The stochastic nature of turbulence introduces the necessity of a statistical description. Typical statistical descriptors are the mean velocity and the moments of the turbulent fluctuations. In isotropic turbulence the mean velocity is zero and the velocity fluctuations reduce to their geometrically simplest form. Still the interaction of a large number of lengthscales renders the description difficult. A phenomenological description of isotropic turbulence was proposed by Kolmogorov \cite{Kolmogorov}, leading to a prediction of the distribution of energy over different lengthscales in a turbulent flow assuming that high Reynolds number turbulence is locally isotropic and that mode interactions are local in scale-space. Experiments \cite{Grant1962}, presented at the famous Marseille Conference in 1961, confirmed the predicted energy distribution, proportional to $k^{-5/3}$, with $k$ the wavenumber. Deriving this description from first principles, \emph{i.e.} starting from the Navier-Stokes equations, is a formidable task. Indeed phenomenological models (\emph{e.g.} references \cite{Leith,Heisenberg}) reproduced the correct wavenumber dependence of the energy distribution, but the models did not have any direct relation to the Navier-Stokes equations. A first attempt to build a model for the multi-scale dynamics of a turbulent flow could start from the observation that the single-point velocity statistics seem close to Gaussian. If is assumed that all velocity moments behave in a Gaussian manner, one is directly led to the erroneous conclusion that all different lengthscales are independently decaying under the influence of viscosity since the interaction between modes is governed by triple correlations which are zero in a Gaussian field. Indeed, in a Gaussian field modes are statistically independent and this precludes energy transfer among scales. It is thus clear that at the level of third order moments, cumulants, defined as the differences of quantities with respect to their Gaussian values, can not be neglected. A logical attempt to obtain a correct description of turbulence would then consist in closing the hierarchy of moments by an assumption of Gaussianity at the first level which does allow the triple correlations to be non-zero, in other words, at the level of quadruple correlations. This quasi-normal assumption \cite{Millionschikov1941,Tatsumi1957,Proudman1954} is well documented in the textbook by Monin and Yaglom \cite{Monin}. Unfortunately, this approach leads to non-physical results, since the energy-spectrum predicted by the quasi-normal model becomes negative at long-times \cite{Ogura1963}, as was carefully suggested previously by Kraichnan \cite{Kraichnan1957}. A great breakthrough in the theory of turbulence was the introduction of the Direct Interaction Approximation (DIA) \cite{KraichnanDIA}. The great difference with the foregoing attempts is that it is a two-time theory, introducing a new quantity, the response function, corresponding to the response of a turbulent flow on an infinitesimal perturbation. The big difference with the quasi-normal approximation is that cumulants of all orders are allowed to be non-zero and quadruple moments are not assumed to be Gaussian. This issue was at the heart of the discussion between Ian Proudman and Robert Kraichnan at the conference in Marseille \cite{Proudman1962,Kraichnan1962} (see also \cite{Rubinstein2012}). Later works showed how these higher order cumulants can be determined within the DIA framework \cite{Chen1989,Bos2012-3}. The DIA theory suffered however from both a theoretical and a practical weakness. The theoretical weakness consists in the fact that DIA does not predict the correct inertial range behavior (\emph{i.e.} in agreement with Kolmogorov's prediction). This was traced back to the fact that its dynamical behavior is not invariant to Galilean transformations \cite{Kraichnan1964} and the defect was corrected for by reformulating the theory in a Lagrangian coordinate system \cite{Kraichnan65}. This yielded a description, called the Lagrangian History DIA which gives correct asymptotic behavior for the energy spectrum. However, the formulation becomes extremely complicated in this new set of coordinates. A simplified, or abridged, version was proposed in the same work and an even simpler description of the same type is the Lagrangian Renormalized Approximation (LRA) \cite{Kaneda81,Kaneda1986}. The practical weakness of these theories, both DIA and the Lagrangian versions, is the two-time character which precludes a computation of long-time statistics, unless the time-history is truncated at some time difference. To obtain a practical statistical model for the dynamics of turbulence, one needs a procedure called Markovianization. This procedure is based on the assumption that the statistical two-time behavior of the turbulent quantities is known, so that the theories can be simplified to a dynamical description which only depends on the current time. Kraichnan proposed such a procedure and applied it to DIA, yielding an approximation known as the Test Field Model \cite{KraichnanTFM}. The two-time quantities are in this approach assumed to be exponentially decaying with a typical time-scale which is determined by comparing the decorrelation of a fully compressible field, the test field, with the decorrelation of the advecting velocity field. A simplified version of the Test Field Model is the Eddy- Damped Quasi-Normal Markovian model \cite{Orszag}, in which this time-scale is heuristically modeled by a phenomenological straining time-scale of the Heisenberg type \cite{Heisenberg}. In a previous work \cite{Bos2006} we proposed a method to determine this time-scale self-consistently in the framework of the EDQNM theory, using the observation that this time-scale in Lagrangian History DIA is the correlation-time of a fluid particle along a trajectory. In the present article we will show how our theory is related to the DIA. This will in particular show why a certain number of terms which appeared in the original formulation have to be taken equal to zero for consistency with DIA. We will also apply the approach to the problem of the diffusion of a passive scalar. In the framework of the EDQNM theory, we will propose a model for the scalar flux spectrum, which significantly simplifies the level of complexity with respect to the models proposed in previous works \cite{Herr,Ulitsky,Bos2005,Bos2007-1}. \section{Lagrangian dynamics, Markovianization and determination of the correlation time-scale\label{sec:Lagr}} Let us introduce the spectral tensor, which is the key quantity in the statistical description of a turbulent flow. \begin{eqnarray}\label{PhiEul} \Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t,s)&=&\mathcal{F}_{(\bm r)}\left\{\overline{u_i(\bm x,t)u_j(\bm x+\bm r,s)}\right\}\\ &=&\overline{u_i(\bm k,t)u_j^*(\bm k,s)} \end{eqnarray} with $\mathcal{F}_{(\bm r)}$ a Fourier transform with respect to $\bm r$, $u_i(\bm k,t)$ the Fourier transform of the velocity and the overline denoting an ensemble average. The conjugate $u_j^*(\bm k,s)=u_j(-\bm k,s)$ since the velocity is a real quantity in physical space. In incompressible, mirror-symmetric, isotropic turbulence this quantity is entirely determined by a scalar function, $E(k,t,s)$, the energy spectrum, by the relation \begin{equation} \Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t,s)=\frac{E(k,t,s)}{4\pi k^2}P_{ij}(\bm k), \end{equation} with \begin{equation} P_{ij}(\bm k)=\delta_{ij}-\frac{k_ik_j}{k^2}. \end{equation} The goal of the present work is to obtain a statistical model for the dynamics of $E(k,t,t)\equiv E(k,t)$. The original DIA theory was based on the above quantities, or representatives, yielding a $k^{-3/2}$ inertial range scaling. This behavior was related to the fact that an Eulerian description does not distinguish between the decorrelation of the velocity modes by the effects of pressure and viscosity on one hand and the sweeping of the small scales by the large scales on the other hand. Sweeping does not contribute to the energy transfer among scales which is the physical mechanism behind the $k^{-5/3}$ prediction. Indeed an Eulerian observer would have no way to see if the decorrelation is due to sweeping or not. To correctly capture the dynamics one needs a Lagrangian description. In other words, one needs to change the representative from (\ref{PhiEul}) to a Lagrangian formulation. Kraichnan reformulated his theory in Lagrangian coordinates \cite{Kraichnan65}. Hereto he introduced the generalized velocity, $u_i(\bm x,t|s)$, defined as the velocity measured at time $s$ on the trajectory which passes at $t$ through $\bm x$. The first time argument is called the labeling time, and the second, the measuring time. This velocity is illustrated in Figure \ref{Fig:LHDIA}. \begin{figure} \begin{center} \setlength{\unitlength}{.5\textwidth} \includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{1.eps}~ \caption{\label{Fig:LHDIA} Illustration of the generalized velocity, Lagrangian position vector and displacement vector. } \end{center} \end{figure} We can associate the Lagrangian position function to this velocity, $x_i(\bm x,t|s)$, defined as the position of the fluid particle at time $s$ on the trajectory which passes through $\bm x$ at time $t$. These quantities are related to the Eulerian velocity and coordinate system by, \begin{eqnarray} \bm u(\bm x,t|t)&=&\bm u(\bm x,t),\\ \bm x(\bm x,t|t)&=&\bm x. \end{eqnarray} The key quantity that we will use in the following is the Eulerian displacement field $\bm X$ related to the generalized velocity field through the relation \begin{equation}\label{eq:Xintu} X_i(\bm x,t)=\int_0^t u_i(\bm x,t|s)ds=x_i(\bm x,t|t)-x_i(\bm x,t|0). \end{equation} The displacement field is an Eulerian field, which measures at each point $\bm x$ in a fixed, Eulerian, coordinate system the displacement with respect to its original position (at $t=0$) of the particle which is at point $\bm x$ at time $t$ (see for example the discussion in reference \cite{Corrsin1962}). The displacement vector is also illustrated in Figure \ref{Fig:LHDIA}. Its evolution is given by \begin{equation} \frac{\partial X_i(\bm x,t)}{\partial t} +u_j(\bm x,t)\frac{\partial}{\partial x_j}X_i(\bm x,t)=u_i(\bm x,t). \end{equation} Note that since the displacement field is a quantity measured in an Eulerian coordinate system, the evolution equation contains a convective derivative. Using the generalized velocity, the spectral velocity-tensor now contains four time-arguments, \begin{equation} \Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|s;t'|s')= \overline{u_i(\bm k,t|s)u_j^*(\bm k,t'|s')}. \end{equation} However, in the Lagrangian Renormalized Approximation \cite{Kaneda81} or in the Abridged Lagrangian History DIA \cite{Kraichnan65}, the resulting model equations only contain quantities of the form \begin{equation}\label{eq:Phittts} \Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|t;t|s)= \overline{u_i(\bm k,t|t)u_j^*(\bm k,t|s)}, \end{equation} \ie, one of the velocities is evaluated at a fixed point, since the labeling and measuring time coincide, and the other is moving along its Lagrangian trajectory. The resulting model thus only contains two-time quantities, like the Eulerian DIA, but the time-difference is evaluated along a particle trajectory. The difference between LRA and the Abridged Lagrangian History DIA is that in the former, time derivatives are taken with respect to the measuring time, whereas in the the latter these derivatives are taken with respect to the labeling time. We note that the Lagrangian velocity is not solenoidal. The Eulerian velocity is incompressible so that $\Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|t;t|s)$ is solenoidal in its first index $i$. Isotropy and mirror-symmetry imply then that the tensor $\Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|t;t|s)$ is proportional to $P_{ij}(\bm k)$. We can therefore define the spectrum, \begin{eqnarray} \Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|t;t|s)=\frac{E(k,t|t;t|s)}{4\pi k^2}P_{ij}(\bm k), \end{eqnarray} but this relation is not valid for $\Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|s;t'|s')$. Since only two-time quantities are used in the following, the spectral tensors and spectra will not be denoted by the four time-arguments, but will be denoted by their short-hand notation, \begin{eqnarray} \Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|s)&\equiv&\Phi_{ij}(\bm k,t|t;t|s)\\ E(k,t|s)&\equiv& E(k,t|t;t|s). \end{eqnarray} This notation should not introduce confusion, because we will only consider spectra in which three of the time-arguments are evaluated at $t$. Note that the Lagrangian and Eulerian representative coincide when $s=t$, \begin{eqnarray} E(k,t|t)=E(k,t,t)=E(k,t). \end{eqnarray} The Abridged Lagrangian History DIA constitutes a closed set of equations, yielding a $k^{-5/3}$ inertial range behavior. The equation governing the evolution of $E(k,t)$ is \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:Lin} \left[\frac{\partial }{\partial t}+2\nu k^2\right]E(k,t)=\iint_{\Delta}\int_0^t[xy+z^3]pE(q,t|s)\left[k^2 G(k,t|s)E(p,t|s)\right.\nonumber\\ \left. -p^2G(p,t|s)E(k,t|s)\right]ds\frac{dp dq}{pq}, \end{eqnarray} in which $G(k,t|s)$ is the response function measured along a trajectory. The symbol $\Delta$ indicates the domain in the $pq$-plane in which $k,p,q$ can form a triangle (in other words $|p-q|\leq k \leq|p+q|$) and $x,y,z$ are given by \begin{eqnarray} x=-p_iq_i/(pq)\nonumber\\ y=k_iq_i/(kq)\nonumber\\ z=k_ip_i/(kp).\label{eq:xyz} \end{eqnarray} The LRA equations differ from (\ref{eq:Lin}) in that the RHS contains quantities of the form $G(k,s|t)$ and $E(k,s|t)$ instead of quantities of the form $G(k,t|s)$ and $E(k,t|s)$. In other words, the labeling and measuring times are inverted in the two-time quantities. We will not consider the LRA in the following. In the Abridged Lagrangian History DIA, equation (\ref{eq:Lin}) is part of a system of three equations, the other two giving the evolution for $E(k,t|s)$ and $G(k,t|s)$, respectively. The equations, although simpler than the original Lagrangian History DIA equations, remain rather complicated and depend on the entire time-history of the flow. Our goal is to simplify the description to obtain a model that does not depend on the entire time-history of the flow, while retaining as much as possible from the original description. We will now explain how we obtain such a model. We introduce the correlation function $R(k,t|s)$ as, \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:Rkts} R(k,t|s)=\frac{E(k,t|s)}{E(k,t,t)}, \end{eqnarray} which allows to rewrite (\ref{eq:Lin}) as \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:Lin2} \left[\frac{\partial }{\partial t}+2\nu k^2\right]E(k,t)=\iint_{\Delta}[xy+z^3]pE(q,t)\left[\hat\Theta(kpq)k^2 E(p,t)\right.\nonumber\\ \left.-\hat\Theta(pkq)p^2G(p,t)E(k,t)\right]\frac{dp dq}{pq}, \end{eqnarray} with \begin{eqnarray}\label{Theta12} \hat\Theta(kpq)=\int_0^t G(k,t|s)R(p,t|s)R(q,t|s)ds \end{eqnarray} At this point we have not introduced any assumptions with respect to the Abridged Lagrangian DIA. A first assumption that we make is \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:FDT} R(k,t|s)=G(k,t|s) \textrm{~~for~~} t>s, \end{eqnarray} which is a fluctuation-dissipation hypothesis, which leads to \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:Lin3} \left[\frac{\partial }{\partial t}+2\nu k^2\right]E(k)=\iint_{\Delta}\Theta(kpq)[xy+z^3]pE(q)\left[k^2 E(p)-p^2E(k)\right]\frac{dp dq}{pq}, \end{eqnarray} with \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:Theta3} \Theta(kpq)=\int_0^t G(k,t|s)G(p,t|s)G(q,t|s)ds. \end{eqnarray} The fluctuation-dissipation theorem can be proven to hold rigorously in equilibrium thermodynamics, but in turbulence, corresponding to an out-of-equilibrium dissipative system, this is not the case \cite{Kraichnan2000}. It is observed in \cite{Kraichnan66} that in the Abridged Lagrangian History DIA, the fluctuation-dissipation relation is violated. In the Lagrangian Renormalized Approximation, however, which is different from Lagrangian History DIA with respect to the choice of the representative, the fluctuation-dissipation relation holds surprisingly \cite{Kaneda81,Kaneda1986}. The precise form of the relation between $G$ and $R$ is therefore not uniquely determined and can have important consequences for the Markovian models which result from the assumption, in particular when wave-like phenomena are considered \cite{Bowman1993}. In the above description, only the {\it triad time-scale} $\Theta(kpq)$ depends on the time-history of the flow, through the temporal dependence of the response function $G(k,t|s)$. Therefore, by modeling the time-dependence of $G(k,t|s)$, or equivalently $R(k,t|s)$, a single-time description can be obtained. It is at this point that we will proceed in simplifying the description, by introducing specific assumptions on the time-dependence of $R(k,t|s)$. A plausible assumption is that two-time correlations decay exponentially with the time-difference. This cannot be correct for very small times since the time-dependence should be differentiable at zero time difference and such a discontinuity can influence the results in the case of compressible turbulence \cite{Fauchet1999}. A Gaussian time-dependence could be assumed to get correct behavior around zero. It was however shown that in the incompressible case the results are relatively insensitive to the exact choice \cite{Kraichnan1971}, since only the integrals over the exponential are required and the exact form of the time-correlation does not appear in the final expressions. For convenience we will assume therefore an exponential time-dependence here: \begin{equation}\label{PhiMarkov} R(k,t|s)=\exp\left[-\frac{|t-s|}{\tau(k,t)}\right], \end{equation} Note that also the choice that $\tau$ is here a function of $t$ (and not of $s$) is a nontrivial assumption. We can integrate both sides of this expression with respect to $s$ to obtain an expression for $\tau(k,t)$, \begin{equation} \tau(k,t)=\int_{t_0}^{t}R(k,t|s)ds\left(1- \exp\left[-\frac{|t-t_0|}{\tau(k,t)}\right]\right)^{-1}. \end{equation} For the sake of simplicity, we will consider here the case in which the turbulence has been created a time long before we evaluate it, by taking the limit of $t_0$ tending towards $-\infty$. This gives the expression \begin{equation}\label{eq:tau5} \tau(k,t)=\int_{-\infty}^{t}R(k,t|s)ds=\int_{-\infty}^{t}\frac{E(k,t|s)}{E(k,t|t)}ds. \end{equation} The essential step to get a closed model expression for $\tau(k,t)$, which was proposed in \cite{Bos2006}, was the explicit integration of $E(k,t|s)$ with respect to $s$. Using relation (\ref{eq:Xintu}), we can evaluate the integral (\ref{eq:tau5}), \begin{eqnarray} \int_{-\infty}^{t}E(k,t|s)ds&=&2\pi k^2 \mathcal{F}_{(\bm r)}\left\{\int_{-\infty}^{t}\overline{u_i(\bm x,t|t)u_i(\bm x+\bm r,t|s)}ds\right\} \nonumber\\ &=&2\pi k^2 \mathcal{F}_{(\bm r)}\left\{\overline{u_i(\bm x,t|t)X_i(\bm x+\bm r,t)}\right\}\nonumber\\ &=&F(k,t,t), \end{eqnarray} in which we introduced a new quantity, the velocity-displacement cross-correlation spectrum $F(k,t,s)$, \begin{eqnarray}\label{SpecTensF} \overline{u_i(\bm k,t) X_j(-\bm k,s)}=\frac{F(k,t,s)}{4\pi k^2}P_{ij}(\bm k), \end{eqnarray} and we will write \begin{eqnarray} F(k,t,t)= F(k,t). \end{eqnarray} At this point we have obtained an Eulerian single-time expression for the Lagrangian time-scale, \begin{equation}\label{taubdqnm} \tau(k,t)=\frac{F(k,t)}{E(k,t)}. \end{equation} If the equation for $E(k,t)$ is completed by an equation for $F(k,t)$, we obtain a closed set of equations, if the equation for $F(k,t)$ does not introduce other unknown quantities. In \cite{Bos2006} this was accomplished within the framework of the EDQNM closure. In the next section we will obtain similar expressions, using the DIA formalism which will clarify uncertainties in the original derivation. It was observed by Kraichnan \cite{Kraichnan65} that the evolution of $E(k,t|t)$ in the Abridged Lagrangian History DIA is given by the same equation as $E(k,t)$ in the Eulerian DIA. The only difference is that the two-time quantities are now evaluated along particle trajectories. We will use this as an {\it ansatz} in the following and we will derive the Eulerian DIA expression for $F(k,t)$, in which we will evaluate the two-time correlations using Kraichnan's generalized Lagrangian description. In section \ref{sec:Num} the resulting equations will be numerically integrated and results will be presented for both the dynamics of the kinetic energy spectrum and the dynamics of a passive scalar advected by turbulent flow. \section{Derivation of the evolution equation for the velocity-displacement cross-correlation}\label{Derivation} We will focus in this section on the derivation of the evolution equation for the wavenumber spectrum of the correlation between the velocity $u_i$ and the displacement vector $X_i$ of a fluid particle. The DIA formalism will be used to evaluate the triple correlations which appear in this equation. A Markovianization procedure is applied to the resulting expressions to obtain a single-time expression. We will try to give a self-contained description of all the operations used in this derivation. However, for a justification of the assumptions in the DIA we refer to the original work \cite{KraichnanDIA} or to later works that discuss the justification of the Lagrangian variants of the DIA \cite{Kraichnan1977,Kaneda81,Kida1997,Kaneda2007}. The statistically isotropic and mirror-symmetric case will be considered but in principal this derivation could also be performed for the anisotropic case. The starting point are the equations for $u_i$ and $X_i$, \begin{eqnarray} \frac{\partial u_i(\bm x,t)}{\partial t}+u_j(\bm x,t)\frac{\partial}{\partial x_j}u_i(\bm x,t)=-\frac{\partial p(\bm x,t)}{\partial x_i}+\nu \frac{\partial^2}{ \partial x_j^2}u_i(\bm x,t)\nonumber\\ \frac{dX_i(\bm x,t)}{dt}\equiv\frac{\partial X_i(\bm x,t)}{\partial t} +u_j(\bm x,t)\frac{\partial}{\partial x_j}X_i(\bm x,t)=u_i(\bm x,t), \label{eq:XFIRST} \end{eqnarray} which in Fourier space are written as \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqNSX} [\frac{\partial}{\partial t}+\nu k^2]u_i(\bm k,t)=-\frac{i}{2}P_{ijm}(\bm k)\iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q} u_j(\bm p,t)u_m(\bm q,t)d\bm p d\bm q\nonumber\\ \frac{\partial X_i(-\bm k,t) }{\partial t} =i\bm k_j \iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q}u_j(-\bm p,t)X_i(-\bm q,t)d\bm p d\bm q+u_i(-\bm k,t), \end{eqnarray} with \begin{eqnarray} P_{ijm}(\bm k)=k_jP_{im}(\bm k)+k_mP_{ij}(\bm k). \end{eqnarray} Multiplying the first equation by $X_i(-\bm k,t)$, the second by $u_i(\bm k,t)$, summing and ensemble averaging gives \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqF01} [\frac{\partial}{\partial t}+\nu k^2]F(k,t,t)=T^u(k,t)+T^X(k,t)+E(k,t,t) \end{eqnarray} with \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqTuip} T^u(k,t)=-i\pi k^2 P_{ijm}(\bm k)\iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q}\overline{u_j(\bm p,t)u_m(\bm q,t)X_i(-\bm k,t)}d\bm p d\bm q\nonumber\\ T^X(k,t)=2i\pi k^2\bm k_j \iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q}\overline{u_i(\bm k,t) u_j(-\bm p,t)X_i(-\bm q,t)}d\bm p d\bm q. \end{eqnarray} The DIA is a perturbation method in which the small parameter is the influence of a single triad interaction on the velocity field, compared to the velocity field obtained by the interaction of all other triad interactions. In practice, DIA expressions are obtained by replacing, in the correlations that one is interested in, the velocity field by \begin{eqnarray}\label{expansion} u_i\rightarrow u_i^{(0)}+u_i^{(1)} \end{eqnarray} and using a similar expression for the displacement vector $X_i$. The part $u_i^{(0)}$ is the velocity field that would exist if all triad interactions are retained, except for one that we will call $(\bm k, \bm p, \bm q)$. Since in a homogeneous flow an infinite number of triads interact, $u_i^{(0)}$ is supposed to be close to the actual velocity field. The contribution $u_i^{(1)}$ corresponds to the velocity field induced by the interaction $(\bm k, \bm p, \bm q)$ only. The justification of this approach can be interpreted in terms of the coupling strength between the different modes that should be sufficiently small. If this coupling is weak enough and the number of modes tends to infinity, the DIA procedure should give good results. This was tested in reference \cite{Goto2002} on a toy-model in which both the coupling strength and the number of modes could be varied. After replacing all $u$'s and $X$'s in $T^u$ by (\ref{expansion}) and developing, we find that \begin{eqnarray}\label{TuExp} T^u(\bm k)=-i\pi k^2 P_{ijm}(\bm k)\iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q} \underbrace{\left[\overline{u_j^{(0)}(\bm p)u_m^{(0)}(\bm q)X_i^{(0)}(-\bm k)}\right.}_{\textrm{zeroth order}} + \nonumber\\ \underbrace{\overline{u_j^{(1)}(\bm p)u_m^{(0)}(\bm q)X_i^{(0)}(-\bm k)} +\overline{u_j^{(0)}(\bm p)u_m^{(1)}(\bm q)X_i^{(0)}(-\bm k)} +\overline{u_j^{(0)}(\bm p)u_m^{(0)}(\bm q)X_i^{(1)}(-\bm k)}}_{\textrm{first order}}\nonumber\\ \left. +\textrm{~second and higher order} \right]d\bm p d\bm q,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ \end{eqnarray} in which time-arguments were omitted to shorten the expression. A similar expression is obtained for $T^X$. In the DIA only the first non-vanishing order is retained in addition to the zeroth order contribution. Higher order contributions should contribute insignificantly if the contribution of a single triad is indeed infinitesimally small. For the triple correlations considered here, the zeroth order contribution (first term on the RHS) in the above expression is equal to zero. The first nonvanishing contribution is the first order contribution. The Direct Interaction contributions can be written for, for example $u_j(\bm p,t)$ and $X_i(\bm k,t)$, as \begin{eqnarray}\label{up'} u_j^{(1)}(\bm p,t)&=&-i P_{jab}(\bm p) \int_0^t G(\bm p,t,s)\left[u_a^{(0)}(\bm k,s)u_b^{(0)}(-\bm q,s)\right]ds \nonumber\\ X_i^{(1)}(-\bm k,t)&=&ik_a\int_0^t G^X(\bm k,t,s)\left[u_a^{(0)}(-\bm p,s)X_i^{(0)}(-\bm q,s) +u_a^{(0)}(-\bm q,s)X_i^{(0)}(-\bm p,s)\right]ds, \nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} in which $G(\bm k,t,s)$ and $G^X(\bm k,t,s)$ are the response function of the velocity and displacement field, respectively. These are unknown quantities at this point. These direct interaction contributions are substituted into expression (\ref{TuExp}). To illustrate the derivation of the final expression we take the first term on the second line of expression (\ref{TuExp}), which we will denote $T_1(k)$, and we will work out the final expression for this term. Upon substituting (\ref{up'}) in this term we obtain, \begin{eqnarray}\label{T1k} T_1(k)=- \pi k^2\int_{0}^{t}\iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q}G(\bm p,t,s)P_{ijm}(\bm k)P_{jab}(\bm p)\times\nonumber\\ \overline{ u_a^{(0)}(\bm k,s)u_b^{(0)}(-\bm q,s) u_m^{(0)}(\bm q,t)X_i^{(0)}(-\bm k,t)} d\bm p d\bm q ds. \end{eqnarray} This expression is exactly what would be obtained using the quasi-normal approach, for a particular choice of $G$, the viscous Green-function. However, DIA does not only take into account viscous decorrelation, but also non-linear decorrelation and the DIA expression for $G$ will therefore differ from the viscous Green-function. In the limit, which we will consider, in which the flow is constituted of a very large number of modes, we can write the correlation in (\ref{T1k}) as a product of double correlations (note that this is no assumption of Gaussianity of the velocity modes, as for example discussed in \cite{Goto2002}), \begin{eqnarray}\label{T1k-3} \overline{ u_a^{(0)}(\bm k,s)u_b^{(0)}(-\bm q, s) u_m^{(0)}(\bm q,t)X_i^{(0)}(-\bm k,t)}=P_{bm}(\bm q)\frac{E(q,t,s)}{4\pi q^2}P_{ai}(\bm k)\frac{F(k,s,t)}{4\pi k^2},\nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} in which we used the isotropic expressions for the velocity and velocity-displacement tensors. Introducing this in the above expression we find \begin{eqnarray} T_1(k)=- \pi k^2\int_{0}^{t}\iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q} G(\bm p,t,s)P_{ijm}(\bm k)P_{jab}(\bm p) P_{bm}(\bm q)P_{ai}(\bm k)\frac{E(q,t,s)}{4\pi q^2}\frac{F(k,s,t)}{4\pi k^2} d\bm p d\bm q ds,\nonumber\\ \label{usymm} \end{eqnarray} which can be written as \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqTabc3} T_1(k)=- \pi k^2\iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q}\int_0^t ds~ G(p,t,s)kp~f_1(k,p,q)E(q,t,s)F(k,s,t)(16\pi^2 k^2 q^2)^{-1}d\bm p d\bm q\nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} with $f_1(kpq)=(kp)^{-1}P_{ajm}(\bm k)P_{jab}(\bm p)P_{bm}(\bm q)$ in which we used that $P_{ijm}(\bm k)P_{ai}(\bm k)=P_{ajm}(\bm k)$. The convolution integral can be rewritten as a function of the wavenumber only. The details of this simplification are given in the appendix of the book by Leslie \cite{Leslie}. The resulting expression is \begin{eqnarray} \iint \delta_{\bm k-\bm p-\bm q}d\bm p d\bm q\rightarrow\iint_\Delta 2\pi pqk^{-1}dp dq \end{eqnarray} in which $\Delta$ indicates the domain in the $pq$-plane in which $k,p,q$ can form a triangle (in other words $|p-q|\leq k \leq|p+q|$). This yields \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqTabc4} T_1(k)&=&- \frac{1}{8}\int_{\Delta}\int_0^t ds~ G(p,t,s)f_1(k,p,q)p^3E(q,t,s)F(k,s,t) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}. \end{eqnarray} We see that the unknown quantities in this description are the $2$-time quantities $E(k,t,s),F(k,s,t),G(k,t,s)$. It is here that we replace these quantities by their analogues defined on Lagrangian trajectories, \begin{eqnarray} E(k,t,s)\rightarrow E(k,t|s)\nonumber\\ G(k,t,s)\rightarrow G(k,t|s)\nonumber\\ F(k,t,s)\rightarrow F'(k,t|s)\nonumber\\ F(k,s,t)\rightarrow F''(k,t|s), \end{eqnarray} with \begin{eqnarray} F'(k,t|s)=2\pi k^2\overline{u_i(\bm k,t) X_i(-\bm k,t|s)}\nonumber\\ F''(k,t|s)=2\pi k^2\overline{u_i(\bm k,t|s) X_i(-\bm k,t)} \end{eqnarray} in which the difference between $F'$ and $F''$ arises due to the asymmetric character of the velocity-scalar displacement correlation. As in section \ref{sec:Lagr}, expression (\ref{PhiMarkov}), we will use the assumption that the two-time quantities decay exponentially in time by posing \begin{eqnarray} G(k,t|s)=H(t-s)\exp[-(t-s)\eta(k)]\\ G^X(k,t|s)=H(t-s)\exp[-(t-s)\eta^X(k)]\\ E(k,t|s)=E(k,t)[G(k,t|s)+G(k,s|t)]\label{responseE}\\ F'(k,t|s) =F(k,t)[G(k,s|t)+G(k,t|s)]\label{responseF}\\ F''(k,t|s)=F(k,t)[G^X(k,s|t)+G^X(k,t|s)]\label{responseF2}. \end{eqnarray} The Heaviside functions $H(t)$ appear since the response functions correspond to the response at time $s$ to a perturbation applied at time $t$. There is obviously no response before the perturbation is applied. Note further that (\ref{responseE}), (\ref{responseF}) and (\ref{responseF2}), which link the response functions to the velocity time-correlations, are, like expression (\ref{eq:FDT}), a specific form of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. Using the above expressions, the time-integral will, in the long-time limit, yield \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqTabc5} \int_{-\infty}^t ds~ G(p,t|s)E(q,t|s)F''(k,t|s)=\Theta^F(kpq)E(q,t)F(k,t)\nonumber\\ \end{eqnarray} with \begin{eqnarray} \Theta^F(kpq)=\frac{1}{\eta^X(k)+\eta(p)+\eta(q)} \end{eqnarray} We repeat the foregoing analysis for the remaining two terms in $T^u_{ip}$ and the three terms of $T^X_{ip}$. The Direct Interaction contribution stemming from the $X_i$ in each term yields two contributions, whereas every $u_i$ yields only one contribution (\emph{c.f.} the symmetry used in expression (\ref{usymm})). The total number of terms is then eight. In the following all quantities are evaluated at time $t$ so that we will omit the time arguments. The resulting equation is \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqF10} [\frac{\partial}{\partial t}+\nu k^2]F(k)=\sum_{i=1}^8 T_i(k)+E(k) \end{eqnarray} with \begin{eqnarray} T_1(k)&=&- \frac{1}{8}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(kpq) f_1(k,p,q)p^3E(q)F(k) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}\\ T_2(k)&=&- \frac{1}{8}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(kpq) f_2(k,p,q)q^3E(p)F(k) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}\\ T_3(k)&=&+\frac{1}{8}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(kpq) f_3(k,p,q)k^3E(p)F(q) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}\\ T_4(k)&=& +\frac{1}{8}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(kpq) f_4(k,p,q)k^3E(q)F(p) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}\\ T_5(k)&=&- \frac{1}{4}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(qpk) f_5(k,p,q)p^3E(k)F(q) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}\\ T_6(k)&=&+ \frac{1}{4}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(qpk) f_6(k,p,q)k^3E(p)F(q) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}\\ T_7(k)&=&- \frac{1}{4}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(qpk) f_7(k,p,q)q^3E(k)F(p) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}\\ T_8(k)&=&- \frac{1}{4}\int_{\Delta}\Theta^F(qpk) f_8(k,p,q)q^3E(p)F(k) \frac{dp}{p}\frac{dq}{q}. \end{eqnarray} Symmetries allow to show that $T_1(k)=T_2(k)$ and $T_3(k)=T_4(k)$, which reduces the number of terms to six. The geometrical functions $f_1,..,f_8$ can be expressed as a function of the cosines $x,y,z$, defined in expressions (\ref{eq:xyz}). This yields \begin{eqnarray} f_1&=&(kp)^{-1}P_{123}(\bm k)P_{214}(\bm p)P_{34}(\bm q) = 2(xy+z^3)\\ f_2&=&(kq)^{-1}P_{123}(\bm k)P_{24}(\bm p)P_{314}(\bm q) = 2(xz+y^3)\\ f_3&=&(k)^{-2}k_1P_{234}(\bm k)P_{13}(\bm p)P_{24}(\bm q) = 1-xyz-2y^2z^2+y^2-z^2\\ f_4&=&(k)^{-2}k_1P_{234}(\bm k)P_{23}(\bm p)P_{14}(\bm q) = 1-xyz-2y^2z^2-y^2+z^2\\ f_5&=&(kp)^{-1}k_1P_{23}(\bm k)P_{124}(\bm p)P_{34}(\bm q) = xy+z^3-z+zx^2\\ f_6&=&(k)^{-2}k_1P_{234}(\bm k)P_{13}(\bm p)P_{24}(\bm q) = f_3\\ f_7&=&(kq)^{-1}k_1P_{23}(\bm k)P_{13}(\bm p)q_2 = z(x+yz)\\ f_8&=&2(kq)^{-1}k_1 P_{12}(\bm p)q_2= 2(y+xz). \end{eqnarray} Note that $f_4$ and $f_2$ are not needed when symmetry is used to show that $T_1(k)=T_2(k)$ and $T_3(k)=T_4(k)$. Since $f_6=f_3$, we eventually only need five different factors. The last step in obtaining closure is the determination of $\eta(k)$ and $\eta^X(k)$. Comparison of equation (\ref{responseE}) with (\ref{PhiMarkov}) shows that within the framework of our assumptions, \begin{equation} \eta(k)=\tau(k)^{-1}=E(k,t)/F(k,t). \end{equation} Note that the current model, as it was presented in \cite{Bos2006} defined $\eta(k)$ as \begin{eqnarray}\label{oldtau} \eta(k)=E(k,t)/F(k,t)+\nu k^2. \end{eqnarray} Indeed it is now clear that within the framework of the assumptions introduced in the derivation of the curent model, the viscous frequency should not be added. It is implicitly contained in the expression for $F(k)$. We have obtained a closed expression, if the unknown quantity $\eta^X(k)$ is specified. We note here that the displacement is a quantity which will not diffuse along a trajectory, neither by pressure, nor by molecular effects. This suggests the choice \begin{equation}\label{eq:0damp} \eta^X(k)=0, \end{equation} in analogy with Lagrangian History DIA arguments for the passive scalar. There is however a difference between the equation of the displacement vector and the passive scalar. Indeed, the equation of the displacement vector (\ref{eq:XFIRST}) contains on the RHS the velocity. This forcing is correlated with the displacement. Some analogy exists between this case and the linearly forced Burgers equation. In the latter case the triad relaxation time is directly determined by the correlation-time of the velocity, as was shown by applying the LHDIA technique to Burgers' equation \cite{Kraichnan1968-2}. In order to test the influence of this time-scale on the results, we will also perform simulations in which \begin{equation}\label{eq:TINT} \eta^X(k)=\mathcal{T}^{-1}, \end{equation} in which $\mathcal{T}$ is the integral timescale of the velocity field. It will be shown that this choice does not significantly change the results. \section{Equations for the evolution of the energy spectrum and the scalar variance spectrum} Using the above method, equations can be derived for the evolutions of the energy spectrum and of the scalar variance spectrum. The latter is defined by \begin{eqnarray} E_\theta(k,t,s)=2\pi k^2 \overline{\theta(\bm k,t)\theta(-\bm k,s)}. \end{eqnarray} The resulting equations are identical to the ones given by the EDQNM approach or the test-field model. The only difference is the specification of the time-scale. The equations are \begin{eqnarray}\label{eqEK} \left[\frac{\partial }{\partial t}+2\nu k^2\right]E(k)=\iint_{\Delta}\Theta(kpq)[xy+z^3]pE(q)\left[k^2 E(p)-p^2E(k)\right]\frac{dp dq}{pq},\\ \left[\frac{\partial }{\partial t}+2\alpha k^2\right]E_\theta(k)=\iint_{\Delta}\Theta^\theta(kpq)[1-z^2]pE_\theta(q)\left[k^2 E(p)-p^2 E(k)\right]\frac{dp dq}{pq}.\label{eqEKT} \end{eqnarray} The time-scales which appear in these expressions are \begin{eqnarray} \Theta(kpq)=\frac{1}{\eta(k)+\eta(p)+\eta(q)},\qquad \Theta^\theta(kpq)=\frac{1}{\eta^\theta(k)+\eta'(p)+\eta^{\theta}(q)} \end{eqnarray} Using the arguments from the last section, the timescale $\eta(k)^{-1}$ is given by expression (\ref{taubdqnm}). The time-scale associated to the decorrelation of a passive scalar on a Lagrangian trajectory can be inferred from the equation for the scalar, \begin{equation} \frac{d\theta}{dt}= \alpha \Delta \theta, \end{equation} which suggests that the scalar decorrelation is given by \begin{eqnarray}\label{eq:alphakk} \eta^{\theta}(k)=\alpha k^2, \end{eqnarray} since on a Lagrangian trajectory the scalar only decorrelates under the action of diffusion. We note that this choice for the scalar is inherent to the choice of the representative \cite{Kraichnan1978,Herring1979,Gotoh2000}. For example, the decorrelation time-scale for the velocity is modified if the DIA is applied to the strain-rate instead of to the velocity. However, we will use the above choice, expression (\ref{eq:alphakk}). For comparison, it is perhaps useful here to recall the expressions for the time-scales which are used in the EDQNM model \cite{Orszag}. These are \begin{eqnarray}\label{timeEDQNM} \eta(k)=\lambda\sqrt{\int_0^k s^2E(s)ds}+\nu k^2, \qquad \eta'(k)=\lambda'\sqrt{\int_0^k s^2E(s)ds}+\nu k^2, \nonumber\\ \eta^{\theta}(k)=\lambda_\theta\sqrt{\int_0^k s^2E(s)ds}+\alpha k^2. \end{eqnarray} The value of $\lambda$ was determined and given the value $0.36$ by comparison with the test-field model, the latter being calibrated by comparison with the DIA in a case in which DIA was assumed to give correct results. The value for $\lambda_\theta$ was given the value $0$ in \cite{Herring}, using similar arguments as above regarding the Lagrangian decorrelation of a scalar fluctuation. In the same work $\lambda'$ was given a value different from $\lambda$. The parameter $\lambda'$ appearing in $\Theta^\theta(kpq)$ was determined by comparison with experimental results for the turbulent Prandtl number and was given the value unity. The different values for $\lambda$ and $\lambda'$ in the two different time-scales are in contradiction with the outcome of DIA. However, a certain flexibility is allowed if one drops the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. Even more freedom is obtained if one changes the representative used in the analysis. From a practical point of view one might argue that the appearance of adjustable constants in a model allows the user to choose them in comparison with observation rather than by using physical arguments and assumptions. These expressions for the time-scales used in the EDQNM closure were only recalled here for comparison. They will not be used in the remainder of this work. \section{EDQNM expression for the spectrum of the velocity-scalar cross-correlation} It is at this point that we want to point out a possible simplification of the EDQNM model as proposed and derived in references \cite{Herr,Ulitsky,Bos2005,Bos2007-1}. In these works the EDQNM expression was derived for the spectrum of the velocity-scalar correlation spectrum. The resulting expressions contained a time-scale of the form (\ref{timeEDQNM}). However in the light of the present derivation it seems that the level of sophistication of that model was higher than the standard EDQNM model. Indeed, the considerations in the present work suggests a much simpler expression to model the scalar flux spectrum. Using the analogy between a passive scalar generated by a mean-scalar gradient and the displacement-vector, expression (\ref{taubdqnm}) suggests the following model for the scalar flux spectrum $F_{u\theta}(k)$, \begin{eqnarray} F_{u\theta}(k)&=&\Gamma E(k)/\eta_F(k)\nonumber\\ &=&\Gamma E(k)\left[\lambda_F\sqrt{\int_0^k s^2 E(s) ds} +(\nu+\alpha)k^2\right]^{-1} \label{eq:FEDQNM} \end{eqnarray} with $\Gamma$ the strength of the mean scalar gradient and $\lambda_F$ a model constant. This modeling would be of the level of approximation of the EDQNM model and would avoid having to program the lengthy evolution equations which appear in the previous works. \begin{figure} \begin{center} \setlength{\unitlength}{.5\textwidth} \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{2a.eps}}~ \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{2b.eps}} \caption{\label{FigEk1} Energy spectrum (a) and in compensated form (b) for decaying isotropic turbulence, modeled by the present closure approach.} \end{center} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \setlength{\unitlength}{.5\textwidth} \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{3a.eps}}~ \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{3b.eps}} \caption{\label{FigEk2} Velocity-displacement cross-correlation spectrum (a) and in compensated form (b) for decaying isotropic turbulence, modeled by the present closure approach.} \end{center} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \setlength{\unitlength}{.5\textwidth} \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{4a.eps}}~ \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{4b.eps}} \caption{\label{FigEk3} Energy transfer (a) and spectrum of the typical (eddy-damping) time-scale compared to a Heisenberg type time-scale, usually employed in the EDQNM model (b). } \end{center} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \setlength{\unitlength}{.5\textwidth} \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{5a.eps}}~ \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{5b.eps}} \caption{\label{FigETk} (a) Passive scalar variance spectrum corresponding to a decaying passive scalar at unity Schmidt number. The velocity field is characterized in Figure \ref{FigEk1}. (b) Compensated form.} \end{center} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \setlength{\unitlength}{.5\textwidth} \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{6a.eps}}~ \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{6b.eps}} \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{6c.eps}}~ \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{6d.eps}} \caption{\label{FigETkSc} Passive scalar variance spectrum corresponding to a stationary passive scalar, injected in the large scales at small and high Schmidt numbers. Scalar spectrum at $Sc=0.01$ (a) and in compensated form (b). $Sc =20$ (c) and in compensated form (d). } \end{center} \end{figure} \section{Numerical results\label{sec:Num}} In this section we numerically integrate equations (\ref{eqF10}), (\ref{eqEK}) and (\ref{eqEKT}). In these expressions we will insert for $\eta(k)$ and $\eta^{\theta}(k)$: \begin{eqnarray} \eta(k)=E(k,t)/F(k,t); \quad \eta^X(k)=0; \quad \eta^\theta(k)=\alpha k^2 \end{eqnarray} We will first consider decaying turbulence, starting from an initial distribution \begin{equation} E(k)=B k^4 e^{-2\left(k/k_L\right)^2} \end{equation} with $B$ chosen to normalize the energy to unity. $k_L=10$ and the first wavenumber of the domain is $k_0=1$. Wavenumber space is discretized using a geometrical discretization $k_i=k_0 r^{i-1}$. This possibility in two-point closures to use a geometrical discretization allows to attain much higher Reynolds numbers than in direct numerical simulations for a much lower cost. The discretization in the present computations is approximately $15$ wavenumbers per decade. The viscosity is equal to $\nu=8\cdot 10^{-8}$. From the initial condition we let the turbulence decay until it reaches a self-similar state in which $e/\epsilon\sim t$, with the kinetic energy and viscous dissipation respectively determined by \begin{eqnarray} e=\int E(k) dk, \qquad \epsilon=2\nu \int k^2E(k) dk. \end{eqnarray} All results are evaluated in this phase and the Reynolds number, defined as \begin{equation} R_\lambda=\sqrt{\frac{20}{3}\frac{e^2}{\nu \epsilon}} \end{equation} is at the time of evaluation $5000$. The scalar spectra are initialized to have the same shape as the kinetic energy. Mixing at three different Schmidt numbers, $Sc=\nu/\alpha$, is evaluated, $Sc=0.01,1,20$. For the computations at $Sc=0.01$ and $Sc=20$, in order to clearly produce scaling behavior, both the velocity and the scalar field are forced at the lowest wavenumbers, $k\leq 2$. For the case in which $Sc=20$, The Reynolds number is taken equal to $R_\lambda=100$ and the discretization is refined to $50$ wavenumbers per decade to more acurately capture nonlocal interactions which play an essential role in the physics of the Batchelor range. \subsection{Results for the velocity field for high Reynolds number decaying turbulence} Results for decaying isotropic turbulence at $R_\lambda=5000$ are shown in Figure \ref{FigEk1}. We observe that the Kolmogorov constant is of order $1.7$. It is observed that in the present model the bottleneck effect, that is, the increasing value of the compensated plot in the beginning of the dissipation range, is absent. Note that this bottleneck is far more pronounced in the EDQNM model \cite{Andre1977}. Indeed, the bottleneck is generated by the fact that nonlocal interactions are cut off in the dissipation range, thereby decreasing the transfer of energy so that it piles up \cite{Herring}. This effect is very sensitive to the relative value of the viscous time-scale compared to the local (in $k$-space) turbulent time-scale. For example, the bottleneck can be increased by decreasing the value of $\lambda$ in the EDQNM model. The constant in \begin{equation} F(k)=C_F\epsilon^{1/3}k^{-7/3} \end{equation} is order $C_F\approx 2.5$ as shown in Figure \ref{FigEk2}. The energy transfer spectrum is shown in Figure \ref{FigEk3} (a). In Figure \ref{FigEk3} (b) we see that if we compare the $\eta(k)$ given by our model to $\lambda\sqrt{\int_0^k s^2E(s)ds}$, there is a short range in which the two are approximately proportional, with a value of $\lambda\approx 0.5$ . \subsection{Results for the mixing of an isotropic passive scalar} In Figure \ref{FigETk} we show the spectrum of a passive scalar which is freely decaying. The initial spectrum is equal to the spectrum of the velocity field and the spectra are computed at the same time-instant as in Figure \ref{FigEk1}. A clear inertial-convective range is observed in which the scalar variance distribution is proportional to $k^{-5/3}$, in agreement with classical arguments \cite{Corrsin1951,Obukhov}. In the compensated representation it is observed that the dimensionless constant in \begin{equation} E_\theta(k)=C_\theta \epsilon_\theta\epsilon^{-1/3}k^{-5/3} \end{equation} is around $0.3$ according to our closure. This is about one half of the generally observed value in experiments and numerical simulations \cite{Sreenivasan}. This underprediction is a well-known deficiency of Lagrangian History DIA and its relatives. It can be cured for by changing the representative on which the closure is based \cite{Kraichnan1978,Herring1979,Gotoh2000}. This would constitute an interesting perspective, but is not tried in the present work. We note that EDQNM predicts a more realistic value for $C_\theta$ \cite{Herring}. We stress, however, that this value is directly related to the parameter $\lambda'$. If this value was chosen equal to $\lambda$ in the cited reference, then the value for $C_\theta$ would be of the same order as the one predicted by our theory. We further observe that a large bottleneck is observed in all these results. \subsection{Mixing of an isotropic passive scalar at small and large Schmidt number} We also carried out computations for small and large Schmidt number and the results are shown in Figure \ref{FigETkSc}. It is observed in Fig. \ref{FigETkSc} (a) and (b) that the closure manages to reproduce the inertial diffusive range \cite{Batchelor1959-2}, \begin{equation} E_\theta(k)=\frac{1}{3} C_k \epsilon_\theta \epsilon^{2/3}\alpha^{-3}k^{-17/3}. \end{equation} In Fig. \ref{FigETkSc} (c) and (d), we observe that also that the viscous-convective range is reproduced \cite{Batchelor1959}, \begin{equation} E_\theta(k)=C_\theta' \epsilon_\theta \nu^{1/2}\epsilon^{-1/2}k^{-1}. \end{equation} \subsection{Influence of the correlation time-scale of the displacement vector} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \setlength{\unitlength}{.5\textwidth} \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{7a.eps}}~ \subfigure[]{\includegraphics[width=1\unitlength]{7b.eps}} \caption{\label{Fig:TINT} Influence of the correlation time-scale of the displacement vector on the energy spectrum. Energy spectrum (a). Black corresponds to $\eta^X(k)=0$. The red graph corresponds to $\eta^X(k)=\mathcal{T}^{-1}$. Compensated spectrum (b).} \end{center} \end{figure} To test the influence of the correlation time-scale of the displacement vector on the results, we performed a simulation, in which we changed the time-scale of the displacement vector from zero ($\eta^X(k)=0$) to the integral time-scale ($\eta^X(k)=\mathcal{T}^{-1}$), as described in the last paragraph of section \ref{Derivation}. The results are shown in Figure \ref{Fig:TINT}. Clearly, the influence of this change in correlation time is not dramatic in the current application. Only in the large scales of the energy spectrum a small influence is observed. In the inertial and dissipation range the change in time-scale does not seem to influence the results. The reason for this is that in $\Theta^F(kpq)$, only one of the three wave-vectors, $\bm k$ is influenced by this change. The $\eta(p)$ and $\eta(q)$ rapidly dominate over the $\eta^X(k)$, since $\eta(k)$ is an increasing function of $k$ in the inertial range. \section{Concluding remarks} In the present work we derived a self-consistent Markovian closure starting from the DIA formalism and using the fluctuation-dissipation assumption. Closure was obtained by relating the turbulence time-scale to the spectrum of the cross-correlation of fluid-particle-displacement and velocity, $F(k,t)$. The general idea was announced in a letter \cite{Bos2006}, but the details of the idea were not given there. {\bf In the present work we show how the present closure is related to the Abridged Lagrangian History DIA, and how the introduction of the displacement vector allows to measure the Lagrangian decorrelation in an Eulerian reference frame. We want to stress that such a single-time closure could perhaps also be obtained applying a similar procedure to the two-time correlations in the Lagrangian Renormalized Approximation, which was not tried here.} The closure was numerically integrated at large Reynolds number ($R_\lambda=5000$). Results were presented for the energy spectrum and transfer spectrum. Results for the mixing of an isotropic passive scalar were shown for Schmidt numbers $0.01$, $1$ and $20$ respectively and classical scaling was reproduced. In starting from DIA it becomes clear why a certain number of terms should be neglected in previous works. These terms were present in work on the velocity-scalar cross-correlation spectrum \cite{Herr,Ulitsky,Bos2005,Bos2007-1} and correspond in these studies to nonlinear transfer terms which were linearly dependent on the mean-scalar gradient. They should be removed if consistency is required with first-order renormalized perturbation theories such as DIA. They appear as terms which are second order in the formal expansion parameter in the DIA approximation. Furthermore, a simplified model for the scalar flux spectrum was proposed (\ref{eq:FEDQNM}), with a level of complexity comparable to the standard EDQNM model for the energy spectrum. Let us finish by noting the following: during the Marseille congress 50 years ago, Kraichnan presented his DIA \cite{Kraichnan1962} to the scientific community. Many things have changed since then: computational power has increased enormously, making possible the direct numerical simulation of laboratory experiments, advanced experimental techniques allow to visualize almost every feature of a turbulent flow. However, the theoretical description of turbulence, derived from the Navier-Stokes equations, has still not advanced enormously beyond DIA related approaches. The physical insights obtained from these triadic closures are still an indispensable building block of our description of turbulent flows. \section*{Acknowledgements} Robert Rubinstein is acknowledged for many discussions on DIA and related issues. We are thankful to the organizers of the Turbulence Colloquium Marseille 2011, Marie Farge, Keith Moffatt and Kai Schneider for having organized a very stimulating scientific meeting. Two referees have significantly contributed to the improvement of the present work through their comments and suggestions. \bibliographystyle{tJOT}

All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files. Introduction {#sec001} ============ Recent advances in next generation sequencing have led to the discovery of a great diversity of viruses infecting insect populations \[[@pone.0177301.ref001], [@pone.0177301.ref002]\]. RNA viruses belonging to the family *Iflaviridae* (order *Picornavirales*) were detected during analysis of the larval transcriptome \[[@pone.0177301.ref003]\] of the beet armyworm, *Spodoptera exigua* (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), which is a major pest of horticultural crops in tropical and subtropical and regions worldwide \[[@pone.0177301.ref004]\]. This pest also attacks greenhouse grown vegetable and ornamental crops in temperate regions \[[@pone.0177301.ref005]--[@pone.0177301.ref007]\]. Iflaviruses exclusively infect arthropods \[[@pone.0177301.ref008]\] and although some can cause clear signs of disease in their hosts, such as the iflaviruses that infect *Bombyx mori* \[[@pone.0177301.ref009]\] and *Apis mellifera* \[[@pone.0177301.ref010]\], generally iflavirus infections remain unnoticed until detected using molecular tools \[[@pone.0177301.ref011]\]. Specifically, two iflaviruses were found to be prevalent in *S*. *exigua* natural populations in Spain, which were named Spodoptera exigua iflavirus-1 (SeIV-1) \[[@pone.0177301.ref012]\] and Spodoptera exigua iflavirus-2 (SeIV-2) \[[@pone.0177301.ref013]\]. SeIV-1 has a 10.3 kb genome whereas SeIV-2 has a 9.4 kb genome of ssRNA. In both cases the genomes are packaged into icosahedral capsids of 27 nm diameter. The genome consists of a single ORF which is translated as a single polyprotein that is subsequently cleaved into functional and structural proteins. Baculoviruses (*Baculoviridae*) are rod-shaped DNA viruses that are occluded in proteinaceous occlusion bodies (OBs) that have been developed as the basis for effective insecticidal products in many countries \[[@pone.0177301.ref014]\]. The Spodoptera exigua multiple nucleopolyhedrovirus (SeMNPV) has been developed for the biological control of the beet armyworm in developed and developing countries due to its high specificity, pathogenicity and virulence \[[@pone.0177301.ref015]\]. In contrast, the use of RNA viruses as insect control agents has been limited to experimental studies \[[@pone.0177301.ref016]\], mainly due to their low virulence and also because of biosecurity concerns given their phylogenetic proximity to related viruses of the order *Picornavirales* that are human and animal pathogens \[[@pone.0177301.ref017]\]. Mixed infections comprising iflavirus and other viruses have been reported in insects \[[@pone.0177301.ref018], [@pone.0177301.ref011]\], in conjunction with baculoviruses \[[@pone.0177301.ref019]--[@pone.0177301.ref021]\] and a densovirus \[[@pone.0177301.ref022]\]. Field-caught adults of *S*. *exigua* were found to be infected with both SeMNPV and two iflaviruses, and their laboratory-reared offspring also showed a high prevalence of both viruses \[[@pone.0177301.ref023], [@pone.0177301.ref024]\]. Recent studies on the association between SeMNPV and iflaviruses revealed that genomes of both types of viruses were present in the OBs of SeMNPV produced in insects that were infected by both viruses. The OB structure improved the resistance of the iflavirus to UV light and high temperatures whereas a decrease in OB pathogenicity was observed in OBs produced in co-infected insects \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. The key variables that influence the transmission of baculoviruses include the pathogenicity of OBs, measured in terms of concentration-mortality metrics, the speed of kill and the production of progeny OBs. These characteristics also determine the effectiveness of these viruses as biological insecticides \[[@pone.0177301.ref026]\]. As cell culture production results in rapid loss of auxiliary genes and reduced pathogenicity in insects, all baculovirus based insecticides are currently produced in lepidopteran larvae \[[@pone.0177301.ref027]\]. Efficient baculovirus production therefore relies on a large, productive and healthy insect colony. Viruses can cause devastating epizootics of disease in insect colonies and require continuous monitoring and disinfection processes to maintain colony health \[[@pone.0177301.ref028]--[@pone.0177301.ref030]\]. Iflaviruses are rapidly transmitted and can reach a high prevalence of infection in natural populations and laboratory insect colonies \[[@pone.0177301.ref011], [@pone.0177301.ref031], [@pone.0177301.ref032]\]. As iflaviruses are present in *S*. *exigua* populations used to produce SeMNPV as the basis for biological insecticides, we examined the consequences of coinfection with SeMNPV and SeIV-1 and SeIV-2 on the insecticidal properties of OBs produced in co-infected insects. The findings have clear relevance to the efficacy of baculovirus-based insecticides and the biosecurity and potential non-target effects of these products. Materials and methods {#sec002} ===================== Insects and virus stock {#sec003} ----------------------- *Spodoptera exigua* virus-free insects used in the experiments were obtained from Entomotech (Almería, Spain) and Andermatt Biocontrol (Switzerland) as egg masses. Insects were reared on semi-artificial diet \[[@pone.0177301.ref033]\] at 25 ± 2°C, 50 ± 10% relative humidity and 16 h:8 h light:dark photoperiod in disinfected bioclimatic chambers used exclusively for this propose. OBs of the Spanish isolate SeMNPV-SP2 were obtained from the baculovirus collection held at the Universidad Pública de Navarra since 1996 \[[@pone.0177301.ref034]\]. These OBs consistently proved negative for the presence of SeIV-1 and SeIV-2 by RT-qPCR \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. SeIV-1 and SeIV-2 particles were isolated from larvae previously found to harbor a persistent infection. For this, virus particles were purified from guts dissected from groups of ≈200 fourth instar larvae \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. The tissues were lyophilized and homogenized in 0.01 M potassium phosphate buffer (pH 7.4) with 0.45% (w/v) diethyldithiocarbamic acid (DIECA) and 0.2% (v/v) β-mercaptoethanol (2.5 ml of buffer per gram of larva), sonicated for 20 seconds and filtered through two layers of cheesecloth. The filtrate was loaded on to a 10, 30 and 60% discontinuous sucrose gradient and centrifuged 6 h at 60000 × *g*, 10°C. Fraction between 30 and 60% corresponding to the virus band, was collected and RNA was extracted using RNAzol^®^ RT (Sigma-Aldrich) following the manufacturer\'s protocol. Quantitative PCR (qPCR) was undertaken as described below to determine the prevalence of SeIV-1 and SeIV-2. Effect of iflaviruses on SeMNPV pathogenicity, virulence and adult persistence {#sec004} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ To assess the effect of iflavirus co-infection on the insecticidal properties SeMNPV OBs, larvae were inoculated with mixtures of SeMNPV and SeIV-1 or SeIV-2. For this batches of pre-molt *S*. *exigua* second instars were starved overnight and, having molted, groups of 30 second instars were allowed to drink a suspension containing one of five OB concentrations using the droplet feeding method \[[@pone.0177301.ref035]\]. The OB concentrations were 0 (control), 2.54 × 10^5^, 8.18 × 10^4^, 2.72 × 10^4^, 9.09 × 10^3^ and 3.03 × 10^3^ OB/ml, that were previously demonstrated to kill between 95% and 5% of inoculated larvae. Identical groups of larvae were inoculated with OBs suspensions that contained (i) 10^9^ SeIV-1 genomes/μl, (ii) 10^9^ SeIV-2 genomes/μl, or (iii) 1:1 mixture of 5 × 10^8^ SeIV-1 and 5 × 10^8^ SeIV-2 genomes/μl. Larvae that consumed the suspension within 10 minutes were individually placed in the wells of a 24-compartment plates with a piece of semi-synthetic diet and reared at 25 ± 1°C. Virus-induced mortality was recorded at 8 h intervals for 7 days post-inoculation by which time all lethally infected larvae had died. The entire bioassay was performed three times. OB concentration-mortality results were subjected to logit regression in GLIM 4 \[[@pone.0177301.ref036]\]. Relative potencies were estimated when a parallelism test confirmed that the regressions for each treatment could be fitted with a common slope. Time-mortality results for larvae inoculated with the highest OB concentration (2.54 × 10^5^ OB/ml) were subjected to Weibull survival analysis in GLIM 4. Larval that did not die from virus infections were not included in the analysis \[[@pone.0177301.ref037]\]. The validity of the Weibull model was determined by comparing fitted values with Kaplan--Meier survival function estimated values \[[@pone.0177301.ref038]\]. To determine the prevalence of SeMNPV infection in adults, the insects that survived in the treatment involving 2.72 × 10^4^ OB/ml were reared to the adult stage and examined by qPCR as describe bellow. Effects of iflaviruses on OB production and larval weight gain {#sec005} -------------------------------------------------------------- To examine the effect of iflaviruses on OB production, larvae were treated with OB suspensions with or without the presence of SeIV-1 or SeIV-2. For this, groups of 24 newly-molted second instars were inoculated with 2.45 × 10^5^ OB/ml (previously estimated to result in 90% mortality) and one of the following iflavirus treatments: (i) 10^9^ SeIV-1 genomes/μl; (ii) 10^9^ SeIV-2 genomes/μl; and (iii) a 1:1 mixture of 5 × 10^8^ SeIV-1 and 5 × 10^8^ SeIV-2 genomes/μl. Two additional groups of 24 insects in the second instar were inoculated with SeMNPV OBs alone or were mock-infected as controls. Larvae that consumed inoculum suspension within 10 minutes were individually placed in the wells of 24 compartment plates and reared at 25 ± 1°C, checked daily for signs of disease. The entire bioassay was performed three times. Larval weight gain, and OB production were subsequently assessed in fourth instar larvae that were co-inoculated with 5 × 10^7^ OB/ml and 10^9^ SeIV-1 genomes/μl using the droplet-feeding method described above. This concentration of OBs was estimated to kill 95% of inoculated fourth instars. Weight measurements were taken using an electronic balance (±1 mg) immediately before inoculation and then at 24 h intervals during a period of 6 days. Larvae that had been inoculated in the second or fourth instar and that showed signs of the final stages of polyhedrosis disease, were placed individually in 1.5 ml microtubes and incubated at 25 ± 1°C for 4--8 hours until death. Virus-killed larvae were then stored at 4°C for up to 7 days prior to OB counting. Ten cadavers per treatment and repetition were randomly selected for OB counting. Virus-killed larvae were homogenized individually in 1 ml distilled water. OB production was estimated by counting triplicate samples of diluted OB suspension using a Neubauer hemocytometer (Hawksley, Lancing, UK) under a phase-contrast microscope at ×400 magnification. Mean OB production values were estimated and compared by t-test (SPSS v. 21.0 2012, IBM). Weight gain data were not normally distributed and therefore subjected to the Kruskal--Wallis or Mann-Whitney non-parametric test (SPSS v. 21.0 2012, IBM). Total DNA and RNA extraction {#sec006} ---------------------------- For detection of covert infections, total DNA and RNA were isolate from insect tissues using the Master Pure Complete DNA and RNA Purification kit (Epicentre Biotechnologies). The abdomens of frozen adults were dissected and placed individually in a 2 ml microfuge tube with ceramic beads, 300 μl tissue lysis solution and 1 μl proteinase K (50 ng/μl). Samples were homogenized using MP FastPrep-24 tissue cell homogenizer at 4 m/s for 20 s and incubated at 65°C for 15 min at 1000 rpm orbital agitation. Samples were divided in two aliquots of 150 μl each. One aliquot was used for DNA extraction and treated with 1 μl RNAse at 37°C for 30 min. Tissue remains were pelleted by adding protein precipitation reagent (MPC), vortexed, and centrifuged at 10000 × *g* for 10 min. DNA was precipitated from the supernatant with isopropanol, washed twice with 70% ethanol, and the pellet was resuspended in 20 μl milli-Q water and stored at -20°C. The second aliquot was used for RNA extraction. For this, protein precipitation reagent was added to the 150 μl aliquot, centrifuged at 10000 × *g* for 10 min and DNA was precipitated with isopropanol. Nucleic acid pellets were treated with RNAse-free DNAse buffer and 5 μl of DNAse for 30 min at 37°C. A 200 μl volume of 2 × T and C lysis solution was added and vortexed for 5 s followed by 200 μl of protein precipitation reagent and vortexed for 10 s. The debris was pelleted by centrifugation and the supernatant was washed once with isopropanol and twice with 70% ethanol. Finally, RNA was resuspended in 20 μl DEPC water and stored at -20°C. Blank extraction samples containing only water were processed in parallel to detect cross-contamination during the extraction process. All equipment and reagents were previously sterilized and treated with DEPC to remove RNases. Virus detection and quantification {#sec007} ---------------------------------- In order to quantify viral loads, qPCR and reverse transcription quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) were performed for SeMNPV and the iflaviruses, respectively. Specific primers were used for the detection of SeMNPV DNA polymerase \[[@pone.0177301.ref023]\] and iflavirus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) \[[@pone.0177301.ref024]\] sequences ([Table 1](#pone.0177301.t001){ref-type="table"}). Total DNA or cDNA was used as template for amplification in order to detect SeMNPV and iflaviruses, respectively. To obtain cDNA, 1 μg of RNA was reversed transcribed to cDNA using SuperScript II Reverse Transcriptase (Promega) and Oligo (dT) primers. The reverse transcription mix consisted of 2 μl of 5× buffer (Promega), 1.2 μl MgCl~2~ (25 mM), 0.5 μl dNTP mix (10 mM), 0.8 μl DEPC water and 1 μl ImProm-II reverse transcriptase (Promega). The mixture was added to RNA samples and incubated at 25°C for 5 min, followed by 42°C for 60 min and 70°C for 15 min. qPCR based on SYBR Green fluorescence was carried out in a CFX96 Touch™ Real-Time PCR Detection System (Bio-Rad) in 96-well reaction plates. A 9 μl mastermix containing 5 μl SYBR, 0.5 μl of both primers (10 μM) and 3 μl water was added to 1 μl of DNA or cDNA template. For the construction of standard curves, the PCR products generated with specific primers for SeIV-1 and SeIV-2 were cloned into a pGEM®-T Easy cloning vector (Promega). Plasmid DNA was quantified using a spectrophotometer (Eppendorf BioPhotometer Plus) and two replicate samples were subjected to eight-fold serial dilutions in sterile MilliQ water (from 10^−1^ to 10^−7^ ng/μl) and were amplified as standards. 10.1371/journal.pone.0177301.t001 ###### Primer sequences and description of the gene region targeted. {#pone.0177301.t001g} -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Primer Sequence Description -------------- ------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- qDNApol F: 5'-CCGCTCGCCAACTACATTAC-3'\ Amplifies a 149-bp fragment within the SeMNPV DNA polymerase gene \[[@pone.0177301.ref040]\]. R: 5'-GAATCCGTGTCGCCGTATATC-3' SeIV-1q F: 5'- TGTGAAGTTAGACACGCATGGAA-3'\ Amplifies a 97-bp fragment in the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) region from SeIV-1 \[[@pone.0177301.ref012]\]. R: 5'-CGACTTGTGCTACTCTCTTCATCAA-3' SeIV-2q F: 5'-CCGCTCGCTTATTGAAACGT-3'\ Amplifies a 78-bp fragment in the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) region from SeIV-2 \[[@pone.0177301.ref013]\]. R: 5'-CATGAGACAGCTGGAATTGGAA-3' qATPsynthase F: 5'-GTTGCTGGTCTGGTGGGATT-3'\ Amplifies a 72-bp fragment in ATP-synthase subunit C gene from *S*. *exigua* \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. R: 5'-AGGCCTCAGACACCATTGAAA-3' -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The qPCR protocol consisted in an initial denaturation at 95°C for 3 min, followed by 45 amplification cycles of 95°C for 10 s, 62°C for 30 s, and finally a melting curve stage of 65°C to 95°C every 0.5°C for 5 s. Data were acquired and analyzed using Bio-Rad CFX Manager 3.1 software (Bio-Rad). The regression characteristics of the standard curves were R^2^ = 0.99 in all cases and slopes of -3.27, -3.56 and -3.30 for SeMNPV, SeIV-1 and SeIV-2, respectively, with an efficiency between 90 and 110% \[[@pone.0177301.ref039]\]. The last standard concentration, 10^−7^ ng/μl, represented the limit of detection and showed correct amplification curves and the expected melting temperatures of 83.5, 77.0 and 79.5°C for SeMNPV, SeIV-1 and SeIV-2, respectively. As a result, higher Ct values were considered to be virus-free samples. All values were normalized using a non-differentially expressed ATP-synthase subunit C gene quantification ([Table 1](#pone.0177301.t001){ref-type="table"}), following standard procedures previously described for iflaviruses \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. Results {#sec008} ======= Effect of iflavirus co-inoculation on SeMNPV insecticidal properties {#sec009} -------------------------------------------------------------------- In all cases, mortality increased significantly with log~e~ \[OB concentration\] (F~1,20~ = 108, *P*\<0.001). Overall, mixtures of SeMNPV and iflaviruses resulted in significantly increased OB pathogenicity compared to SeMNPV OB inoculum alone. The LC~50~ values were 2.4 to 3.9-fold lower in iflavirus treatments compared to SeMNPV OBs alone ([Table 2](#pone.0177301.t002){ref-type="table"}). 10.1371/journal.pone.0177301.t002 ###### LC~50~ values, relative potencies and mean time to death (MTD). For *S*. *exigua* second instars inoculated with SeMNPV OBs alone or co-infected with SeMNPV OBs and iflavirus (SeIV-1, SeIV-2 or SeIV-1+SeIV-2). {#pone.0177301.t002g} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Treatment LC~50~\ Relative\ 95% Fiducial limits *P* MTD (h) 95% Fiducial limits (×10^3^\ potency OBs/ml) ---------------------- ---------- ----------- --------------------- ------ --------- --------------------- ------ ------ SeMNPV alone 14.4 1 10.1 20.3 \- 94.9ab 92.8 97.1 SeMNPV+SeIV-1 6.1 2.4 3.4 9.1 \<0.05 94.4ab 92.1 96.8 SeMNPV+SeIV-2 3.7 3.9 1.3 6.5 \<0.05 92.4a 90.4 94.5 SeMNPV+SeIV-1+SeIV-2 5.1 2.8 3.1 7.4 \<0.05 97.1b 95 99.3 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Mean time to death values of the different SeMNPV + iflavirus treatments ranged from 92.4 to 97.1 hours post inoculation (hpi), compared to 94.9 hpi for larvae inoculated with SeMNPV OBs alone ([Table 2](#pone.0177301.t002){ref-type="table"}). MTD values only differed significantly between the SeMNPV + SeIV2 and the SeMNPV + SeIV-1 + SeIV-2 treatments (*t*-test = 3.679; df = 332; *P*\<0.001). No mortality was registered in mock-infected larvae or in those larvae infected only with SeIV-1 or SeIV-2, or their mixture. All larvae that succumbed to SeMNPV infections showed the characteristic signs of polyhedrosis disease that was confirmed by microscopic observation of OBs. OB production and weight gain {#sec010} ----------------------------- Co-infection with iflavirus significantly reduced OB production in second instar larvae treated with SeMNPV (ANOVA, F~3,116~ = 4.008; *P*\<0.001). The mean production of OBs in each SeMNPV-killed insect was similar in treatments involving SeIV-1 (1.89 × 10^7^ ± 1.96 × 10^6^), SeIV-2 (2.03 × 10^7^ ± 2.06 × 10^6^) or the mixture of SeIV-1 + SeIV-2 (1.89 × 10^7^ ± 2.10 × 10^6^) (ANOVA, F~2,87~ = 2.723; *P* = 0.07), so the results of these treatments were pooled for comparison of treatments with and without iflavirus. Overall, OB production per larva was reduced by 23% in larvae infected by SeMNPV + iflaviruses compared to larvae inoculated with SeMNPV OBs alone (*t*-test = 2.335; df = 118; *P* = 0.01) ([Fig 1](#pone.0177301.g001){ref-type="fig"}). {#pone.0177301.g001} In order to determine whether the effects of iflavirus on OB production were related to larval growth, fourth instar larvae were subjected to one of two treatments: SeMNPV OBs alone and SeMNPV OBs + SeIV-1. Larval weights from 30 larvae per repetition and treatment was registered over time. For larval weight, two additional treatments, SeIV-1 alone and mock-infected larvae (control) were used. OB production in fourth instars differed significantly between treatments (F~1,133~ = 2.23; *P* \< 0.001), with a 30% reduction in the production of OBs in insects infected by SeMNPV + SeIV-1 compared to larvae infected by SeMNPV alone ([Fig 2A](#pone.0177301.g002){ref-type="fig"}). However, OB production in relation to host weight (OB/mg body weight) was similar with or without SeIV-1 co-infection (F~1,129~ = 2.075; *P* = 0.152) ([Fig 2B](#pone.0177301.g002){ref-type="fig"}). These results can be explained by the significantly lower weight gain of larvae (27% reduction) when co-infected with SeMNPV and iflaviruses compared to larvae infected by SeMNPV alone (Kruskal-Wallis; χ^2^ = 82.03, df = 3; *P*\<0.001) ([Fig 2C](#pone.0177301.g002){ref-type="fig"}). {#pone.0177301.g002} Detection and quantification of viral loads in sublethal SeMNPV and iflavirus infections {#sec011} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Of the second instar larvae treated with a concentration of 9.09 × 10^3^ OBs/ml, 30 to 70% died of lethal polyhedrosis disease. The presence of sublethal infections was estimated by qPCR in adult survivors of this treatment. The prevalence of sublethal infection by SeMNPV was similar between larvae treated with SeMNPV with or without SeIV-1 or SeIV-2 and ranged from 70 to 88% (GLM; *P*\<0.001) ([Fig 3](#pone.0177301.g003){ref-type="fig"}, pale shaded columns). Unexpectedly, low-levels of SeMNPV were detected in the control groups, probably due to the presence of a low-level persistent infection in the insect colony, as observed in a previous study \[[@pone.0177301.ref040]\]. Co-inoculation of SeMNPV+SeIV-2, or a mixture of SeIV-1 + SeIV-2, resulted in a significant increase in the SeMNPV load, which was over three-fold higher than SeMNPV loads registered in insects treated with SeMNPV + SeIV-1 or SeMNPV alone. A similar response was registered for the group inoculated with SeMNPV + SeIV-1 + SeIV-2 (Kruskal-Wallis; χ^2^ = 23.67; df = 4; *P*\<0.001) ([Fig 3](#pone.0177301.g003){ref-type="fig"}, dark columns). {#pone.0177301.g003} Discussion {#sec012} ========== The effectiveness of baculovirus-based insecticides relies on a diversity of virus-related and environmental factors \[[@pone.0177301.ref014]\], but also on the susceptibility of the pest population to baculovirus applications, which can be altered by cryptic infections involving other types of viruses \[[@pone.0177301.ref023], [@pone.0177301.ref041]\]. Here we demonstrated that the insecticidal properties of SeMNPV OBs were altered when the baculovirus replicated in hosts that were also infected by the iflaviruses SeIV-1 or SeIV-2. Previous studies indicated that these iflaviruses could be present in 15% of field populations of *S*. *exigua* in southern Spain, in which 8.3% of individuals were simultaneously infected by both iflaviruses and SeMNPV \[[@pone.0177301.ref023]\]. As lethal disease has not been observed in insects infected by SeIV-1 or SeIV-2 to date, it appears that the co-inoculation of the iflaviruses increases the lethality of the SeMNPV infection. Similar effects on the mortality response have been observed following co-inoculation of mixtures of pathogens in lepidopteran larvae. For instance, the mixture of *Bacillus thuringiensis* (Bt) and Helicoverpa armigera nucleopolyhedrovirus (HaNPV) resulted in potentiation or additive effects on the mortality of *Plutella xylostella* that depended on the concentration of the bacteria in the mixture \[[@pone.0177301.ref042]\]. The gut microbiota of the host can also modulate baculovirus pathogenicity and speed of kill \[[@pone.0177301.ref043]\], as bacterial virulence factors seem to contribute to the success of viral infections in the insect midgut. Persistent infection by the endosymbiont *Wolbachia* also resulted in increased susceptibility to lethal nucleopolyhedrovirus infection in *Spodoptera exempta* \[[@pone.0177301.ref044]\]. These findings contrast with those involving persistent infection of *Helicoverpa armigera* larvae by a densovirus that provided resistance against both Bt and HaNPV infection \[[@pone.0177301.ref045]\]. Interestingly, densovirus infected individuals of *H*. *armigera* developed faster and had higher fecundity than healthy conspecifics \[[@pone.0177301.ref045]\], whereas in the present study, we observed lower weight gain in iflavirus infected larvae. This resulted in a reduced weight at death and a corresponding reduction in total OB production per larva compared to larvae infected with SeMNPV alone. The positive relationship between larval body weight and OB production is well established \[[@pone.0177301.ref046]\]. Our results also confirm previous findings on the reduced growth of iflavirus infected *S*. *exigua* larvae \[[@pone.0177301.ref024]\]. In a previous study on the interaction of SeMNPV OBs and SeIV-1, we observed that the inoculation of *S*. *exigua* larvae by SeIV-1-contaminated OBs resulted in a significant reduction in OB pathogenicity compared to OBs that were not contaminated by iflavirus, whereas OB production per larva and the weight gain of insects infected by SeMNPV were not significantly affected by the presence of SeIV-1 particles in the inocula \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. It is difficult to compare these studies directly due to differences in the amounts of iflavirus present and the nature of the mixed virus inocula. Specifically, in our previous study insects were infected by both SeIV-1 and SeMNPV which resulted in the production of progeny SeIV-1 particles that were intimately associated with the polyhedrin matrix of OBs. The average (±SE) number of SeIV-1 particles per OB was estimated at 18.9±2.3 particles/OB \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. In contrast, in the present study OBs and iflavirus particles were inoculated in mixtures in which the concentration of iflavirus remained fixed (10^9^ particles/μl) and the concentration of SeMNPV OBs varied. As such, the ratio of iflavirus particles to OBs varied from 4 × 10^6^ to 3.3 × 10^7^ SeIV particles per OB in the inocula consumed by second instar larvae, compared to 2 × 10^4^ SeIV-1 particles per OB in the inoculum fed to fourth instar larvae. As a result, the differences in larval weight gain and OB production are likely to be due to the higher concentrations of iflavirus particles present in inocula mixtures with OBs used in the present study compared with our previous study \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. Similarly, the apparent contradiction between the present study that detected increased SeMNPV OB pathogenicity in mixtures with iflavirus, and our previous study in which SeMNPV OB pathogenicity was reduced when in association with iflavirus, may have been due to the higher quantity of iflavirus particles per OB in the inocula used to infect insects in the present study, or related to the physical association of iflavirus with OBs in the previous study \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. Alternatively, OBs may have undergone modifications during assembly in cells co-infected by iflaviruses, which affected the physical features or number or infectivity of occlusion derived virions occluded within each OB \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. These issues can only be resolved through future studies. The concentration of iflavirus used in the present study may initially appear unrealistically high. However, recent studies on an iflavirus of *Helicoverpa armigera* revealed the presence of up to 10^6^ iflavirus genomes/μg of larval feces \[[@pone.0177301.ref047]\]. This was sufficient to assure the horizontal transmission of the iflavirus to conspecific larvae. Moreover, as quantitative studies have suggested that nucleopolyhedrovirus OBs are usually present at low densities on plant foliage in natural and agricultural ecosystems \[[@pone.0177301.ref048]\], small numbers of OBs may be consumed together with large quantities of iflavirus particles released from iflavirus-infected insects feeding on the same plant, although this has not been demonstrated empirically in field or laboratory studies. In studies performed prior to the advent of molecular techniques, ELISA was used to detect a picorna-like virus that severely stunted the growth of *Trichoplusia ni* larvae, although no virus-specific mortality was observed \[[@pone.0177301.ref019], [@pone.0177301.ref020]\]. Mixed infections of this virus with Autographa californica multiple nucleopolyhedrovirus (AcMNPV) resulted in contamination of progeny OBs with the picorna-like virus \[[@pone.0177301.ref020]\]. The molecular mechanisms by which iflaviruses and baculoviruses interact are unclear, more so because SeMNPV replicates in the cell nucleus, whereas iflaviruses replicate in the cytoplasm \[[@pone.0177301.ref011]\]. Recent advances in recognizing the regulatory role of host and viral microRNAs (miRNA) in virus pathogenesis and virulence are likely to greatly improve our understanding of the molecular mechanisms that modulate insect host-virus interactions \[[@pone.0177301.ref049]\]. Virus-encoded miRNAs have been characterized in nucleopolyhedrovirus \[[@pone.0177301.ref050], [@pone.0177301.ref051]\] and RNA virus infections \[[@pone.0177301.ref052]\], in addition to a suite of miRNA-mediated antiviral and apoptotic responses by host cells \[[@pone.0177301.ref053]--[@pone.0177301.ref055]\]. The mechanisms by which SeMNPV or iflaviruses may be able to modulate the innate immune responses of the host through miRNA-mediated suppression strategies are presently unclear although both sublethal infection and interspecific virus interference are likely to be regulated to some degree through such mechanisms \[[@pone.0177301.ref054], [@pone.0177301.ref056]\]. SeMNPV infections are transmitted both horizontally from infected to healthy larvae and vertically from parents to offspring \[[@pone.0177301.ref057]\]. The persistence of the virus in sublethally infected adults may also contribute to transgenerational pest suppression if a portion of the sublethal infections are reactivated to cause lethal disease \[[@pone.0177301.ref058], [@pone.0177301.ref059]\]. In contrast, the transmission of iflaviruses is believed to be mainly horizontal \[[@pone.0177301.ref011]\]. However, we previously observed that SeIV-1 and SeIV-2 were efficiently transmitted from field-caught infected adults to their offspring in the laboratory \[[@pone.0177301.ref023]\]. Both the prevalence of sublethal infection by SeMNPV and viral load (number of copies of SeMNPV genomes) were influenced by the presence of iflaviruses in adult insects. Notably, the abundance of SeMNPV genomes in insects from treatments involving SeIV-2 (SeMNPV + SeIV-2 and SeMNPV + SeIV-1 + SeIV-2) were several fold higher than SeMNPV loads in insects from treatments involving SeMNPV alone or SeMNPV + SeIV-1. High loads of nucleopolyhedrovirus may promote transmission either vertically to offspring \[[@pone.0177301.ref040]\] or horizontally through the activation of sublethal infections \[[@pone.0177301.ref059]\]. In either case, once established, the intimate association between iflavirus and SeMNPV would likely be maintained, either through physical association of iflavirus particles and OBs or by dual infection of host offspring through simultaneous vertical transmission by both viruses \[[@pone.0177301.ref025]\]. Cryptic infections such as those caused by iflaviruses could modulate the performance of SeMNPV-based insecticides. As both types of viruses occur in natural populations of *S*. *exigua* nucleopolyhedrovirus-iflavirus interactions are likely to be common in nature. Iflaviruses are not desirable in insect colonies used for large scale production, as they may result in diminished larval growth, reduced OB production and, depending on their host-range, potential risks to non-target Lepidoptera present in treated crops and habitats adjacent to treated areas. As such, strict colony hygiene, frequent disinfection measures, regular quality control assays on OB pathogenicity and molecular screening for the presence of iflavirus contaminants are likely to be necessary in baculovirus mass-production facilities to maintain production of an effective product with registration-compliant levels of contaminant microorganisms. Supporting information {#sec013} ====================== ###### Original data from all experiments. (XLSX) ###### Click here for additional data file. We thank Noelia Gorria for technical assistance in insect rearing. Gabriel Mercado (INECOL) provided logistical support to TW in Mexico. [^1]: **Competing Interests:**The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. [^2]: **Conceptualization:** AC SH RM AJ TW PC.**Data curation:** AC RM TW.**Formal analysis:** AC RM TW.**Funding acquisition:** PC TW.**Investigation:** AC RM AJ.**Methodology:** AC RM AJ SH TW PC.**Project administration:** RM TW PC.**Resources:** AJ SH.**Supervision:** RM TW PC.**Validation:** AC RM.**Visualization:** AC RM TW PC.**Writing -- original draft:** AC RM TW PC.**Writing -- review & editing:** AC RM TW PC. [^3]: ‡ These authors are joint senior authors on this work.

\section{Introduction} Approximate nearest neighbors (ANN) search has been widely applied to retrieve large-scale multimedia data in search engines and social networks. Due to the low storage cost and fast retrieval speed, learning to hash has been increasingly popular in the ANN research community, which transforms high-dimensional media data into compact binary codes and generates similar binary codes for similar data items. This paper will focus on data-dependent hashing schemes for efficient image retrieval, which have achieved better performance than data-independent hashing methods, e.g. Locality-Sensitive Hashing (LSH) \cite{cite:VLDB99LSH}. A rich line of hashing methods have been proposed to enable efficient ANN search using Hamming distance \cite{cite:NIPS09BRE,cite:CVPR11ITQ,cite:ICML11MLH,cite:CVPR12MIH,cite:CVPR12KSH,cite:TPAMI12SSH,cite:SIGIR14LFH}. Recently, deep hashing methods \cite{cite:AAAI14CNNH,cite:CVPR15DNNH,cite:CVPR15SDH,cite:CVPR15DH,cite:AAAI16DHN,cite:IJCAI16DPSH,cite:CVPR2016DSH,cite:ECCV16BDNN,cite:ICCV17HashNet,cite:ICCV17SSBC} have shown that both image representation and hash coding can be learned more effectively using deep neural networks, resulting in state-of-the-art results on many benchmark datasets. In particular, it proves crucial to jointly preserve similarity and control quantization error of converting continuous representations to binary codes \cite{cite:AAAI16DHN,cite:IJCAI16DPSH,cite:CVPR2016DSH,cite:ICCV17HashNet}. However, a pivotal weakness of these deep hashing methods is that they first learn continuous deep representations, and then convert them into hash codes by a separated binarization step. By \emph{continuous relaxation}, i.e. solving the original discrete optimization of hash codes with continuous optimization, the optimization problem deviates significantly from the original hashing objective. As a result, these methods cannot learn \emph{exactly} compact binary hash codes in their optimization. To address the limitation of continuous relaxation, Deep Quantization Network (DQN) \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN} and Deep Visual-Semantic Quantization (DVSQ) \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ} are proposed to integrate quantization method \cite{cite:TPAMI14OPQ,cite:ICML14CQ,cite:CVPR16SQ} and deep learning. The quantization method represents each point by a short binary code formed by the index of the nearest center, which can generate natively binary codes and empirically achieve better performance than hashing methods for ANN search. However, previous deep quantization methods are either point-wise method that relies on expensive class-label information, or pairwise method that cannot capture the \emph{relative} similarity between images, i.e. a pair of images should not be seen as \emph{absolutely} similar or dissimilar. In other words, there should be a continuous spectrum from very similar to very dissimilar relations. Recently, the \emph{triplet loss} \cite{cite:NIPS12HDML} has been studied for computer vision problems. The triplet loss captures the \emph{relative} similarity, which only brings anchor images closer to positive samples than to negative samples, hence it fits the ranking tasks naturally and achieves better performance than point-wise and pairwise losses for retrieval tasks. However, how to enable effective triplet training for deep learning to quantization with only pairwise similarity available still remains a challenge. Note that, without effective triplet selection, previous deep hashing method with triplet loss \cite{cite:CVPR15DNNH} cannot achieve superior results. Hence, how to select good triplets for effective training in deep quantization also remains an open problem. Towards these open problems, this paper presents Deep Triplet Quantization (DTQ) for efficient and effective image retrieval, which introduces a novel triplet training strategy to deep quantization, offering superior retrieval performance. The proposed solution is comprised of four main components: {1)} a novel triplet selection module, \emph{Group Hard}, to mine good triplets for effective triplet training; {2)} a standard deep convolutional neural network (CNN), e.g. AlexNet or ResNet, for learning deep representations; {3)} a well-specified triplet loss for pulling together similar pairs and pushing away dissimilar pairs; and {4)} a novel triplet quantization loss with weak orthogonality constraint for converting the deep representations of different samples (such as the anchor, positive and negative samples) in the triplets into $B$-bit compact binary codes. The weak-orthogonality reduces the redundancy of codebooks and controls the quantizability of deep representations. Comprehensive empirical evidence shows that the proposed DTQ can generate compact binary codes and yield state-of-the-art retrieval results on three image retrieval benchmarks, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO. \section{Related Work} Existing hashing methods can be categorized into unsupervised hashing and supervised hashing \cite{cite:NIPS09BRE,cite:CVPR11ITQ,cite:ICML11MLH,cite:CVPR12MIH,cite:CVPR12KSH,cite:TPAMI12SSH,cite:CVPR13HBS,cite:CVPR13BP,cite:ICML14CBE,cite:SIGIR14LFH,cite:TKDE15OCKmeans}. Please refer to \cite{cite:TPAMI2018HashSurvey} for a comprehensive survey. Unsupervised hashing methods learn hash functions to encode data points to binary codes by training from unlabeled data. Typical learning criteria include reconstruction error minimization \cite{cite:AI07SemanticHashing,cite:CVPR11ITQ,cite:TPAMI11PQ} and graph learning \cite{cite:NIPS09SH,cite:ICML11AGH}. Supervised hashing explores supervised information (e.g. given similarity or relevance feedback) to learn compact hash codes. Binary Reconstruction Embedding (BRE) \cite{cite:NIPS09BRE} pursues hash functions by minimizing the squared errors between the distances of data points and the distances of their corresponding hash codes. Minimal Loss Hashing (MLH) \cite{cite:ICML11MLH} and Hamming Distance Metric Learning \cite{cite:NIPS12HDML} learn hash codes by minimizing the triplet loss functions based on similarity of data points. Supervised Hashing with Kernels (KSH) \cite{cite:CVPR12KSH} and Supervised Discrete Hashing (SDH) \cite{cite:CVPR15SDH} build discrete binary codes by minimizing the Hamming distances across similar pairs and maximizing the Hamming distances across dissimilar pairs. As deep convolutional networks \cite{cite:NIPS12CNN,cite:CVPR16DRL} yield advantageous performance on many computer vision tasks, deep hashing methods have attracted wide attention recently. CNNH \cite{cite:AAAI14CNNH} adopts a two-stage strategy in which the first stage learns binary hash codes and the second stage learns a deep-network based hash function to fit the codes. DNNH \cite{cite:CVPR15DNNH} improved CNNH with a simultaneous feature learning and hash coding pipeline such that deep representations and hash codes are optimized by the triplet loss. DHN \cite{cite:AAAI16DHN} and HashNet \cite{cite:ICCV17HashNet} improve DNNH by jointly preserving the pairwise semantic similarity and controlling the quantization error by simultaneously optimizing the pairwise cross-entropy loss and quantization loss via a multi-task approach. Quantization methods \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN,cite:CVPR17DVSQ} represent each point by a short code formed by the index of the nearest center, have been shown to give more powerful representation ability than hashing for approximate nearest neighbor search. To our best knowledge, Deep Quantization Network (DQN) \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN} and Deep Visual-Semantic Quantization (DVSQ) \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ} are the only two prior works on deep learning to quantization. DQN jointly learns deep representations via a pairwise cosine loss and a product quantization loss \cite{cite:TPAMI11PQ} for generating compact binary codes. DVSQ proposes a pointwise adaptive-margin Hinge loss exploring class labels, and a visual-semantic quantization loss for inner-product search. There are several key differences between our work and previous deep learning to quantization methods. {1)} Our work introduces a novel triplet training strategy to deep quantization framework for efficient similarity retrieval. It is worth noting that DTQ can learn compact binary codes when only the \emph{relative} similarity information is available, which is more general than the label-based quantization method DVSQ. {2)} During the triplet learning procedure, DTQ proposes a novel triplet mining strategy, \emph{Group Hard}, resulting in faster convergence and better search accuracy. {3)} DTQ proposes a novel triplet quantization loss with weak orthogonality constraint to reduce coding redundancy. An end-to-end architecture to join the above three terms yield both efficient and effective image retrieval. \begin{figure*}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=0.99\textwidth]{DTQ-Structure.pdf} \caption{The proposed Deep Triplet Quantization (\textbf{DTQ}) model consists of four main components: \textbf{1)} a novel triplet selection module, \emph{Group Hard}, to mine good triplets for effective triplet training and faster convergence; \textbf{2)} a standard deep convolutional neural network (CNN), e.g. AlexNet, VGG or ResNet, for learning deep representations; \textbf{3)} a well-specified triplet loss for pulling together similar pairs and pushing away dissimilar pairs; and \textbf{4)} a novel triplet quantization loss with weak orthogonality constraint for converting the deep representations of different samples (the anchor, positive and negative samples) in the triplets into $B$-bit compact binary codes and controlling the quantizability of the deep representations. \textit{Best viewed in color}.} \label{fig:DTQ} \end{figure*} \section{Deep Triplet Quantization} In similarity retrieval, we are given $N$ training points $\mathcal{X} = \{{\bm x}_i\}_{i=1}^N$, where some pairs of points ${\bm x}_i$ and ${\bm x}_j$ are given with \emph{pairwise} similarity labels $s_{ij}$, where $s_{ij} = 1$ if ${\bm x}_i$ and ${\bm x}_j$ are similar while $s_{ij} = 0$ if ${\bm x}_i$ and ${\bm x}_j$ are dissimilar. The goal of deep learning to quantization is to learn a composite quantizer $q:{\bm{x}} \mapsto {\bm{b}} \in {\left\{ { 0,1} \right\}^B}$ from input space to binary coding space $\{0,1\}^B$ through deep networks, which encodes each point ${\bm x}$ into $B$-bit binary code ${\bm b} = q({\bm x})$ such that the supervision in the training data can be maximally preserved. In supervised hashing, the similarity pairs $\{({\bm x}_i, {\bm x}_j, s_{ij}): s_{ij} \in \mathcal{S}\}$ are readily available from semantic labels or relevance feedbacks from click-through data in many image search engines. We propose Deep Triplet Quantization (\textbf{DTQ}), an end-to-end architecture to join deep learning and quantization, as shown in Figure \ref{fig:DTQ}. DTQ has four key components: 1) a novel triplet selection module, \emph{Group Hard}, to mine a appropriate number of good triplets for effective triplet training; 2) a standard deep convolutional neural network (CNN), e.g. AlexNet, VGG, or ResNet, for learning deep representations; 3) a well-specified triplet loss for pulling together similar pairs and pushing away dissimilar pairs; and 4) a novel triplet quantization loss with weak orthogonality constraint for converting deep representations of different samples (the \emph{anchor}, \emph{positive} and \emph{negative} samples) in triplets into $B$-bit compact binary codes and controlling the quantizability of the deep representations. \subsection{Triplet Training} We train a convolutional network from image triplets $\mathcal{T}$=$\{{\bm t}_i\}^{N_t}_{i=1}$. Each triplet ${\bm t}_i$=$\langle{\bm x}^a_i, {\bm x}^p_i, {\bm x}^n_i\rangle$ is constructed from pairwise similarity data $\{({\bm x}_i, {\bm x}_j, s_{ij}): s_{ij} \in \mathcal{S}\}$ as follows: for each \emph{anchor} image ${\bm x}_i^a$, we find a \emph{positive} image ${\bm x}_i^p$ with $s_{ap} = 1$ (${\bm x}_i^a$ and ${\bm x}_i^p$ are similar), and a \emph{negative} image ${\bm x}_i^n$ with $s_{an} = 0$ (${\bm x}_i^a$ and ${\bm x}_i^n$ are dissimilar). Given a triplet ${\bm t}_i$=$\langle{\bm x}^a_i, {\bm x}^p_i, {\bm x}^n_i\rangle$, the deep network maps the triplet ${\bm t}_i$ into a learned feature space with $f({\bm t}_i)$=$\langle{\bm z}^a_i, {\bm z}^p_i, {\bm z}^n_i\rangle$. We ensure that an anchor image ${\bm x}^a_i$ is closer to all positive images ${\bm x}^p_i$ than to all negative images ${\bm x}^n_i$. And the \emph{relative} similarity between the images in triplets, ${\bm x}^a_i, {\bm x}^p_i, {\bm x}^n_i$, are measured by the Euclidean distances between their deep features, ${\bm z}^a_i, {\bm z}^p_i$, ${\bm z}^n_i$. Thus the triplet loss is \begin{equation}\label{eqn:L} L = \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{{N_t}} L_i = \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{{N_t}} {\max \left( {0,\delta - \left\| {{\bm{z}}_i^a - {\bm{z}}_i^n} \right\|_2^2 + \left\| {{{\bm{z}}_i^a} - {\bm{z}}_i^p} \right\|_2^2} \right)} , \end{equation} where $\delta$ is a margin that is enforced between positive and negative pairs, and $\mathcal{T}$ is the set of cardinality $N_t$ for all possible triplets in the training set. Compared to the widely-used pointwise and pairwise metric-learning losses \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN,cite:CVPR17DVSQ} in previous deep quantization methods, the triplet loss \eqref{eqn:L} only requires anchor samples to be more similar to positive samples than to negative samples, by a specifically margin. This establishes a \emph{relative} similarity relation between images, thus is much more reasonable than the \emph{absolute} similarity relation used in previous pointwise or pairwise approaches. However, as the dataset gets larger, the number of triplets grows cubically, and generating all possible triplets would result in many easy triplets with $L_i = 0$ in Eq.~\eqref{eqn:L}, which would not contribute to the training and suffer from slower convergence. Note that, without a sophisticated triplet selection procedure, previous deep hashing methods with the triplet loss \cite{cite:CVPR15DNNH} cannot achieve superior performance. Consequently, it is crucial to mine good triplets for effective triplet training and faster convergence. In this paper, we propose a novel triplet selection module, \emph{Group Hard}, to ensure the number of mined valid triplets is neither too big nor too small. The core idea is that we first randomly split the training data into several groups $\{G_i\}_{i=1}^{|G|}$, then \emph{randomly} select one \emph{hard} negative sample for each anchor-positive pair in one group. The proposed triplet selection method is formulated as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:select} {\mathcal T} = \bigcup\limits_{i = 1}^{|G|} {\bigcup\limits_{a \in {G_i}} {\bigcup\limits_{p \in G_i^p} {{\rm{rand}}\left( {G_i^n} \right)} } }, \end{equation} where $G_i^p={\left\{ {p \in {G_i}:p \ne a,{s_{ap}} = 1} \right\}}$ is the group of positive samples consisting of the samples similar to the anchor $a$ in the $i$th group, $\text{rand}( {G_i^n}$) is the random function that randomly chooses one negative sample from the group of hard negative samples $G_i^n$=${\left\{ {n \in {G_i}:\delta - \left\| {{\bm{z}}_i^a - {\bm{z}}_i^n} \right\|_2^2 + \left\| {{{\bm{z}}_i^a} - {\bm{z}}_i^p} \right\|_2^2 > 0,{s_{an}} = 0} \right\}}$. Here \emph{hard} negative sample ${\bm x}_i^n$ is defined as having non-zero loss value for a triplet ${\bm t}_i$=$\langle{\bm x}^a_i, {\bm x}^p_i, {\bm x}^n_i\rangle$. Note that, mining only the triplets with the hardest negative images would select the outliers in the dataset and make it unable to learn ground truth relative similarity. Thus in this paper, the proposed DTQ only selects the negative examples with moderate hardness, based on the random sampling $\text{rand}(G_i^n)$ instead of $\text{argmax}(G_i^n)$ in Eq.~\eqref{eqn:select}. As the training proceeds, the average of triplet loss becomes smaller and the size of the hard triplets reduces. To ensure that there are enough hard triplets each epoch for effective triplet training, we design a decay strategy for the size of groups $|G|$ as: if the actual number of valid hard triplets is lower than the minimum number of the valid hard triplets (the constant MIN$\_$TRIPLETS in Algorithm~\ref{algorithm:DTQ}), the size of the groups is halved until $|G|=1$. \textbf{Complexity:} Similar to previous work on triplet training \cite{zhao2017deeply}, we can prune the triplets with zero losses ($L_i = 0$), resulting a valid triplet set $\mathcal{T}$ whose size $|{\mathcal T}|$ is much smaller than the possible number $N^3$ of triplets. Through the proposed \emph{Group Hard} selection strategy that chooses one negative sample for each anchor-positive pair in each group, the number of the candidate triplets for training is further reduced to $|\mathcal{T}|/\left| G \right|$. Furthermore, all the selected triplets are \emph{hard} triplets ($L_i>0$ in Eq.~\eqref{eqn:L}), and the total amount can be controlled in a suitable range by adjusting the number of groups $G$, resulting in effective triplet training and higher retrieval accuracy. \subsection{Weak-Orthogonal Quantization} While triplet training with Group Hard selection enables effective image retrieval, efficient image retrieval is enabled by a novel triplet quantization model. As each batch used for training the deep neural networks is comprised of triplets, the proposed quantization model should be compatible with the triplet training. For the $i$th triplet, each image representation ${\bm{ z}}^*_i$, where ${*}\in\{a,p,n\}$, is quantized using a set of $M$ codebooks ${\bm C}^* = [{\bm C}^*_1,\ldots,{\bm C}^*_M]$, where each codebook ${\bm C}^*_m$ contains $K$ codewords ${\bm C}^*_m = [{\bm C}^*_{m1},\ldots,{\bm C}^*_{mK}]$, and each codeword ${\bm C}^*_{mk}$ is a $D$-dimensional cluster-centroid vector as in K-means. Corresponding to the $M$ codebooks, we partition the binary codewords assignment vector ${\bm b}^*_i$ into $M$ $1$-of-$K$ indicator vectors ${\bm b}^*_i = [{\bm b}^*_{1i}; \ldots; {\bm b}^*_{Mi}]$, and each indicator vector ${\bm b}^*_{mi}$ indicates which one (and only one) of the $K$ codewords in the $m$th codebook is used to approximate the $i$th data point ${\bm z}_i^\ast$. To enable knowledge sharing across the anchors, positive and negative samples in the triplets, we propose a \emph{triplet quantization} approach by sharing the codebooks $\{{\bm C}_m^* = {\bm C}_m\}_{m=1}^M$ across different samples in all triplets. To mitigate the degeneration issue of K-means, we further propose a \emph{weak orthogonality} penalty across the $M$ codebooks, which potentially reduces the redundancy of the multiple codebooks and improves the compactness of the binary codes. The proposed triplet quantization model with weak-orthogonal constraint is defined as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:Q} Q = \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{{N_t}} {\sum\limits_{* \in \{ a,p,n\} } {\left\| {{\bm{z}}_i^* - \sum\limits_{m = 1}^M {{{\bm{C}}_m}{\bm{b}}_{mi}^*} } \right\|_2^2} } + \gamma \sum\limits_{m=1}^M \sum\limits_{m'=1}^M {\left\| {{\bm{C}}_m^{\sf T}{{\bm{C}}_{m'}} - {\bm{I}}} \right\|_F^2} \end{equation} where ${\left\| {{{\bm{b}}_{{m}i}^{*}}} \right\|_0} = 1,{{\bm{b}}_{{m}i}^{*}} \in {\left\{ {0,1} \right\}^K}$, ${\left\| \cdot \right\|_0}$ is the $\ell_0$-norm that simply counts the number of the vector's nonzero elements, and $\gamma$ is the hyper-parameter that controls the degree of orthogonality. The $\ell_0$ constraint guarantees that only one codeword in each codebook can be activated to approximate the input data, which leads to compact binary codes. The underlying reason of using $M$ codebooks instead of single codebook to approximate each input data point is to further minimize the quantization error, while single codebook yields significantly lossy compression and large performance drop. \subsection{Deep Triplet Quantization} We enable efficient and effective image retrieval in an end-to-end architecture by integrating the triplet training procedure \eqref{eqn:L}, triplet selection module \eqref{eqn:select} and the weak-orthogonal quantization \eqref{eqn:Q} in a unified deep triplet quantization (DTQ) model as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:model} \mathop {\min }\limits_{{\Theta},{\bm{C}},{\bm{B}^*}} L + \lambda Q, \end{equation} where $\lambda > 0$ is a hyper-parameter between the triplet loss $L$ and the triplet quantization loss $Q$, and $\Theta$ denotes the set of learnable parameters of the deep network. Through joint optimization problem \eqref{eqn:model}, we can learn the binary codes by jointly preserving the similarity via triplet learning procedure and controlling the quantization error of binarizing continuous representations to compact binary codes. A notable advantage of joint optimization is that we can improve the \emph{quantizability} of the learned deep representations $\{{\bm z}^*_i\}$ such that they can be quantized more effectively by our weak-orthogonal quantizer \eqref{eqn:Q}, yielding more accurate binary codes. Approximate nearest neighbor (ANN) search by maximum inner-product similarity is a powerful tool for quantization methods \cite{cite:arxiv14CQIPS}. Given a database of $N$ binary codes $\{{\bm b}_n\}_{n=1}^{N}$, we follow \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN,cite:CVPR17DVSQ} to adopt \emph{Asymmetric Quantizer Distance} (AQD) as the metric, which computes the inner-product similarity between a given query ${\bm q}$ and the reconstruction of the database point ${\bm x}_{n}$ as \begin{equation}\label{eqn:AQD} \text{AQD}\left( {{{\bm q}},{{\bm x}_n}} \right) = {{\bm z}_q^{\mathsf T}} \left({\sum\limits_{m = 1}^M {{\bm C}_m{\bm b}_{mn}} }\right) , \end{equation} Given query ${\bm q}$ and the deep representation ${\bm z}_q$, these inner-products between ${\bm z}_q$ and all $M$ codebooks $\{{\bm C}_m\}_{m=1}^M$ and all $K$ possible values of ${\bm b}_{mn}$ can be pre-computed and stored in a query-specific $M \times K$ lookup table, which is used to compute AQD between the query and all database points, each entails $M$ table lookups and additions and is slightly more costly than computing the Hamming distance. \newcommand\mycommfont[1]{\footnotesize\ttfamily{#1}} \SetCommentSty{mycommfont} \begin{algorithm}[!tp] \DontPrintSemicolon \KwIn{$N$ training images $\mathcal{X} = \{{\bm x}_i\}_{i=1}^N$;} \KwIn{Similarity pairs $\mathcal{S} = \{{\bm s}_{ij}\}_{i,j=1}^N$.} \For{epoch $ = 0$ \KwTo \emph{MAX\_EPOCH}}{ Run the model to update $\{{\bm z}_i\}_{i=1}^{N}$ for $N$ training images\; \If{epoch $ == 0$}{ Initialize $\bm{B}$ and $\bm{C}$ via Product Quantization \cite{cite:TPAMI11PQ} } Split the $N$ training images to $N/|G|$ groups randomly\; $\mathcal{T} \leftarrow \emptyset$ \; \For{\emph{group} $g = 0$ \KwTo $N/|G|$}{ \ForEach{$\bm{x}^a,\bm{x}^p \in G_g$, \textbf{s.t} $s_{ap} = 1$ }{ \ForEach{$\bm{x}^n \in G_g$, \textbf{s.t} $s_{an} = 0$}{ \If{$\delta - \left\| {{\bm{z}}^a-{\bm{z}}^n} \right\|_2^2 + \left\| {{\bm{z}}^a-{\bm{z}}^p} \right\|_2^2 > 0$}{ \tcp{Triplet $<\bm{x}^a, \bm{x}^p, \bm{x}^n>$ is hard} $\mathcal{T}_{ap} \leftarrow \mathcal{T}_{ap}~\cup \{<\bm{x}^a, \bm{x}^p, \bm{x}^n>\}$\; } } \tcp{Randomly choose a hard negative sample from $\mathcal{T}_{ap}$} $\mathcal{T} \leftarrow \mathcal{T} \cup \rm{rand}(\mathcal{T}_{ap})$\; } } \For{i $ = 0$ \KwTo $|\mathcal{T}|/$\emph{BATCH\_SIZE}}{ Train the model using the $i$-th batch of triplets\; } Update $\bm{C}$ and $\bm{B}$ with Eqn. \eqref{eqn:updateC} and Eqn. \eqref{eqn:updateB}\ respectively\; \If{$|\mathcal{T}| < $ \emph{MIN\_TRIPLETS} {\bf and} $|G| > 1$}{ \tcp{Halve the size of the groups} $|G| \leftarrow \lfloor \frac{|G|}{2} \rfloor$\; } } \KwOut{The trained deep neural networks of DTQ.} \caption{Deep Triplet Quantization (DTQ) Training} \label{algorithm:DTQ} \end{algorithm} \subsection{Learning Algorithm} The DTQ optimization problem in Equation~\eqref{eqn:model} consists of three sets of variables: deep convolutional neural network parameters ${\Theta}$, shared codebook ${\bm C} = [{\bm C}_1, \ldots, {\bm C}_M]$, and binary codes ${\bm B}^*$. We adopt an alternating optimization paradigm \cite{cite:SIGIR16CCQ} which iteratively updates one variable with the remaining variables fixed. \textbf{Learning $\Theta$.} The network parameters $\Theta$ can be efficiently optimized via standard back-propagation (BP) algorithm. We adopt the automatic differentiation techniques in TensorFlow. \textbf{Learning $\bm{C}$.} We update codebook ${\bm C}$ by rewriting Equation~\eqref{eqn:model} with ${\bm C}$ as the unknown variables in matrix formulation as follows, \begin{equation} \mathop {\min }\limits_{\bm{C}} {\sum\limits_{* \in \{ a, p , n \} } \left\| {{\bm{Z}}^* - {\bm{C}} {\bm{B}}^* } \right\|_F^2 + \gamma {\left\| {{\bm{C}}^{\sf T}{{\bm{C}}} - {\bm{I}}} \right\|_F^2}}. \end{equation} We adopt the gradient descent to update ${\bm C}$, ${\bm{C}} \leftarrow {\bm{C}} - \eta \frac{{\partial Q\left( {\bm{C}} \right)}}{{\partial {\bm{C}}}}$, and \begin{equation}\label{eqn:updateC} \frac{{\partial Q\left( {\bm{C}} \right)}}{{\partial {\bm{C}}}} = 2\sum\limits_{ * \in \{ a,p,n\} } {{\bm{C}}{{\bm{B}}^ * }{{\bm{B}}^{ * {\sf T}}}} - 2\sum\limits_{ * \in \{ a,p,n\} } {{{\bm{Z}}^ * }{{\bm{B}}^{ * {\sf T}}}} + 2\gamma {\bm{C}}\left( {2{{\bm{C}}^{\sf T}}{\bm{C}} - {\bm{I}}} \right) \end{equation} where $\eta$ is a learning rate. We can further speed up computation by first solving ${\bm C}$ with $\gamma=0$, which leads to an analytic solution ${\bm{C}} = \left[ {\sum_{* \in \{ a, p , n \} } { {\bm{Z}}^* {\bm{B}}^{*\mathsf{T}} }} \right]{\left[ {\sum_{* \in \{ a, p , n \} } {{ {\bm{B}}^* {\bm{B}}^{*\mathsf{T}} }} } \right]^{ - 1}}$, then updating ${\bm C}$ with this solution as the starting point of gradient descent. \textbf{Learning $\bm{B}$.} As each ${\bm b}^*_i$ is independent on the rest of $\{{\bm b}^*_{i'}\}_{{i'} \ne i}$, the optimization for ${\bm B}^*$ can be decomposed to 3$N_t$ subproblems, \begin{equation}\label{eqn:updateB} \begin{gathered} \mathop {\min }\limits_{{\bm{b}}_i^*} {\left\| {{\bm{z}}_i^* - \sum\limits_{m = 1}^M {{{\bm{C}}_m}{\bm{b}}_{mi}^*} } \right\|^2} \\ {\text{s.t.}} \quad {\left\| {{\bm{b}}_{mi}^*} \right\|_0} = 1, {\bm{b}}_{mi}^* \in {\left\{ {0,1} \right\}^K}. \\ \end{gathered} \end{equation} This is essentially a high-order Markov Random Field (MRF) problem. As the MRF problem is generally NP-hard, we resort to the Iterated Conditional Modes (ICM) algorithm \cite{cite:ICML14CQ} that solves $M$ indicators $\{{\bm b}^*_{mi}\}_{m=1}^M$ alternatively. Specifically, given $\{{\bm b}^*_{{m'}i}\}_{{m'} \ne m}$ fixed, we update ${\bm b}^*_{mi}$ by exhaustively checking all the codewords in the codebook ${\bm C}_m$, finding the specific codeword with mimimal objective in \eqref{eqn:updateB}, and setting the corresponding entry of ${\bm b}^*_{mi}$ as $1$ and the rest as $0$. The ICM algorithm is guaranteed to converge to local minima, and can be terminated if maximum iteration is reached. And the training procedure of DTQ is summarized in Algorithm \ref{algorithm:DTQ}. \begin{table*}[!t] \centering \addtolength{\tabcolsep}{1pt} \caption{Mean Average Precision (MAP) Results for Different Number of Bits on the Three Benchmark Image Datasets} \label{table:MAP} \begin{tabular}{c|cccc|cccc|cccc} \Xhline{1.0pt} \multirow{2}{30pt}{\centering Method} & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{NUS-WIDE} & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{CIFAR-10} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{MS-COCO} \\ \cline{2-13} & 8 bits & 16 bits & 24 bits & 32 bits & 8 bits & 16 bits & 24 bits & 32 bits & 8 bits & 16 bits & 24 bits & 32 bits \\ \hline ITQ-CCA & 0.526 & 0.575 & 0.572 & 0.594 & 0.315 & 0.354 & 0.371 & 0.414 & 0.501 & 0.566 & 0.563 & 0.562 \\ BRE & 0.550 & 0.607 & 0.605 & 0.608 & 0.306 & 0.370 & 0.428 & 0.438 & 0.535 & 0.592 & 0.611 & 0.622 \\ KSH & 0.618 & 0.651 & 0.672 & 0.682 & 0.489 & 0.524 & 0.534 & 0.558 & 0.492 & 0.521 & 0.533 & 0.534 \\ SDH & 0.645 & 0.688 & 0.704 & 0.711 & 0.356 & 0.461 & 0.496 & 0.520 & 0.541 & 0.555 & 0.560 & 0.564 \\ \hline CNNH & 0.586 & 0.609 & 0.628 & 0.635 & 0.461 & 0.476 & 0.476 & 0.472 & 0.505 & 0.564 & 0.569 & 0.574 \\ DNNH & 0.638 & 0.652 & 0.667 & 0.687 & 0.525 & 0.559 & 0.566 & 0.558 & 0.551 & 0.593 & 0.601 & 0.603 \\ DHN & 0.668 & 0.702 & 0.713 & 0.716 & 0.512 & 0.568 & 0.594 & 0.603 & 0.607 & 0.677 & 0.697 & 0.701 \\ HashNet & 0.613 & 0.662 & 0.687 & 0.699 & 0.621 & 0.643 & 0.660 & 0.667 & 0.625 & 0.687 & 0.699 & 0.718 \\ DQN & 0.721 & 0.735 & 0.747 & 0.752 & 0.527 & 0.551 & 0.558 & 0.564 & 0.649 & 0.653 & 0.666 & 0.685 \\ DVSQ & \underline{0.780} & \underline{0.790} & \underline{0.792} & \underline{0.797} & \underline{0.715} & \underline{0.727} & \underline{0.730} & \underline{0.733} & \underline{0.704} & \underline{0.712} & \underline{0.717} & \underline{0.720} \\ \hline DTQ & \textbf{0.795} & \textbf{0.798} & \textbf{0.799} & \textbf{0.801} & \textbf{0.785} & \textbf{0.789} & \textbf{0.790} & \textbf{0.792} & \textbf{0.758} & \textbf{0.760} & \textbf{0.764} & \textbf{0.767} \\ \Xhline{1.0pt} \end{tabular} \end{table*} \section{Experiments} We conduct extensive experiments to evaluate the efficacy of the proposed DTQ approach against several state-of-the-art shallow and deep hashing methods on three image retrieval benchmark datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO. Project codes and detailed configurations will be available at \url{https://github.com/thuml}. \subsection{Setup} The evaluation is conducted on three widely used image retrieval benchmark xdatasets: NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO. \textbf{NUS-WIDE}\footnote{\url{http://lms.comp.nus.edu.sg/research/NUS-WIDE.htm}} \cite{cite:CIVR09NusWide} is a public image dataset which contains 269,648 images in 81 ground truth categories. We follow similar experimental protocols in \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN,cite:CVPR17DVSQ}, and randomly sample 5,000 images as query points, with the remaining images used as the database and randomly sample 10,000 images from the database for training. \textbf{CIFAR-10}\footnote{\url{http://www.cs.toronto.edu/kriz/cifar.html}} is a public dataset with 60,000 tiny images in 10 classes. We follow the protocol in \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN} to randomly select 100 images per class as the query set, 500 images per class for training, and the rest images as the database. \textbf{MS-COCO}\footnote{\url{http://mscoco.org}} \cite{cite:MSCOCO} is a dataset for image recognition, segmentation and captioning. The current release contains 82,783 training images and 40,504 validation images, where each image is labeled by some of the 80 semantic concepts. We randomly sample 5,000 images as the query points, with the rest used as the database, and randomly sample 10,000 images from the database for training. Following standard evaluation protocol as previous work \cite{cite:AAAI14CNNH,cite:CVPR15DNNH,cite:AAAI16DHN,cite:CVPR17DVSQ,cite:ICCV17HashNet}, the similarity information for hash function learning and for ground-truth evaluation is constructed from image labels: if two images $i$ and $j$ share at least one label, they are similar and $s_{ij}=1$, otherwise they are dissimilar and $s_{ij}=0$. Though we use the ground truth image labels to construct the similarity information, the proposed DTQ can learn compact binary codes when only the similarity information is available, more general than label-based hashing and quantization methods \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN,cite:CVPR17DVSQ}. We compare the retrieval performance of \textbf{DTQ} with ten state-of-the-art hashing methods, including supervised shallow hashing methods \textbf{BRE} \cite{cite:NIPS09BRE}, \textbf{ITQ-CCA} \cite{cite:CVPR11ITQ}, \textbf{KSH} \cite{cite:CVPR12KSH}, \textbf{SDH} \cite{cite:CVPR15SDH} and supervised deep hashing methods \textbf{CNNH} \cite{cite:AAAI14CNNH}, \textbf{DNNH} \cite{cite:CVPR15DNNH}, \textbf{DHN} \cite{cite:AAAI16DHN}, \textbf{DQN} \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN}, \textbf{HashNet} \cite{cite:ICCV17HashNet}, \textbf{DVSQ} \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ}. We evaluate retrieval quality based on three standard evaluation metrics: Mean Average Precision (\textbf{MAP}), Precision-Recall curves (\textbf{PR}), and Precision curves with respect to the numbers of top returned samples (\textbf{P@N}). To enable a direct comparison to the published results, all methods use identical training and test sets. We follow \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN,cite:ICCV17HashNet,cite:CVPR17DVSQ} and adopt MAP@5000 for NUS-WIDE dataset, MAP@5000 for MS-COCO dataset, and MAP@54000 for CIFAR-10 dataset. Our implementation of DTQ is based on \textbf{TensorFlow}. For shallow hashing methods, we use as image features the 4096-dimensional DeCAF$_7$ features \cite{cite:ICML14DeCAF}. For deep hashing methods, we use as input the original images, and adopt \emph{AlexNet} \cite{cite:NIPS12CNN} as the backbone architecture. We fine-tune layers \textit{conv1}--\textit{fc7} copied from the AlexNet model pre-trained on ImageNet and train the last hash layer via back-propagation. As the last layer is trained from scratch, we set its learning rate to be 10 times that of the lower layers. We use mini-batch stochastic gradient descent (SGD) with 0.9 momentum as the solver, and cross-validate the learning rate from $10^{-5}$ to $10^{-2}$ with a multiplicative step-size ${10}^{\frac{1}{2}}$. We fix $K = 256$ codewords for each codebook as \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ}. For each point, the binary code for all $M$ codebooks requires $B = M \, \log_2 \, K = 8M$ bits (i.e. $M$ bytes), where we set $M = B/8$ as $B$ is a hyper-parameters. We fix the mini-batch size of triplets as $128$ in each iteration and set the initial number of groups as $|G|=200$ for NUS-WIDE and MS-COCO, and $|G|=10$ for CIFAR-10. We select the hyper-parameters of the proposed method DTQ and all comparison methods using the three-fold cross-validation. \begin{figure*}[!thbp] \centering \subfigure[NUS-WIDE]{ \includegraphics[width=0.275\textwidth]{pr_nuswide} \label{fig:pr_nus} } \hfil \subfigure[CIFAR-10]{ \includegraphics[width=0.275\textwidth]{pr_cifar} \label{fig:pr_cifar} } \hfil \subfigure[MS-COCO]{ \includegraphics[width=0.36\textwidth]{pr_coco} \label{fig:pr_coco} } \vspace{-5pt} \caption{Precision-recall curves on the NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10 and MS-COCO datasets with binary codes @ 32 bits.} \label{fig:pr} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*}[!thbp] \centering \subfigure[NUS-WIDE]{ \includegraphics[width=0.28\textwidth]{precision_nuswide} \label{fig:prec_nus} } \hfil \subfigure[CIFAR-10]{ \includegraphics[width=0.28\textwidth]{precision_cifar} \label{fig:prec_cifar} } \hfil \subfigure[MS-COCO]{ \includegraphics[width=0.36\textwidth]{precision_coco} \label{fig:prec_coco} } \vspace{-5pt} \caption{Precision@top-N curves on the NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10 and MS-COCO datasets with binary codes @ 32 bits.} \label{fig:prec} \end{figure*} \subsection{Results} The \textbf{MAP} results of all methods are listed in Table \ref{table:MAP}, showing that the proposed DTQ substantially outperforms all the comparison methods. Specifically, compared to SDH \cite{cite:CVPR15SDH}, the best shallow hashing method with deep features as input, DTQ achieves absolute increases of \textbf{11.1\%}, \textbf{33.0\%} and {\textbf{20.7\%}} in the average MAP on NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO respectively. Compared to DVSQ \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ}, the state-of-the-art deep quantization method with class labels as supervised information, DTQ outperforms DVSQ by large margins of \textbf{0.8\%}, \textbf{6.2\%} and \textbf{4.9\%} in average MAP on the three datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO, respectively. The MAP results reveal several interesting insights. \textbf{1)} Shallow hashing methods cannot learn discriminative deep representations and hash codes through end-to-end framework, which explains the fact that they are surpassed by deep hashing methods. \textbf{2)} Deep quantization methods DQN and DVSQ learn less lossy binary codes by jointly preserving similarity information and controlling the quantization error, significantly outperforming pioneering methods CNNH and DNNH without reducing the quantization error. The proposed DTQ improves substantially from the state-of-the-art DVSQ by three important perspectives: \textbf{1)} DTQ introduces a novel triplet training strategy to deep quantization framework for efficient similarity retrieval. It is worth noting that DTQ can learn compact binary codes when only the similarity information is available, which is more general than the label-based hashing method DVSQ. \textbf{2)} During the learning of triplet loss, DTQ adopts a novel triplet mining strategy, \emph{Group Hard}, that mines appropriate amount of good triplets for each epoch, resulting in effective triplet training and better performance. \textbf{3)} DTQ is the first method to apply weak-orthogonal quantization during triplet training. And back-propagating the triplet quantization loss can remarkably enhance the quantizability of the deep representations. The retrieval performance in terms of Precision-Recall curves (PR) and Precision curves with respect to different numbers of top returned samples (\textbf{P@N}) are shown in Figures \ref{fig:pr} and \ref{fig:prec}, respectively. These metrics are widely used in deploying practical systems. The proposed DTQ significantly outperforms all the comparison methods by large margins under these two evaluation metrics. In particular, DTQ achieves much higher precision at lower recall levels or smaller number of top samples than all compared baselines. This is very desirable for precision-oriented retrieval, where people count more on the top-$N$ returned results with a small $N$. This justifies the value of our model for practical retrieval systems. \begin{table*}[!tbh] \centering \addtolength{\tabcolsep}{1.0pt} \caption{Mean Average Precision (MAP) Results of DTQ and Its Variants DTQ-H, DTQ-T, DTQ-2, and DTQ} \label{table:ablation} \begin{tabular}{c|cccc|cccc|cccc} \Xhline{1.0pt} \multirow{2}{30pt}{\centering Method} & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{NUS-WIDE} & \multicolumn{4}{c|}{CIFAR-10} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{MS-COCO} \\ \cline{2-13} & 8 bits & 16 bits & 24 bits & 32 bits & 8 bits & 16 bits & 24 bits & 32 bits & 8 bits & 16 bits & 24 bits & 32 bits \\ \hline DTQ-H & 0.753 & 0.758 & 0.763 & 0.769 & 0.741 & 0.747 & 0.751 & 0.754 & 0.708 & 0.714 & 0.722 & 0.729 \\ DTQ-T & 0.719 & 0.722 & 0.727 & 0.731 & 0.663 & 0.670 & 0.672 & 0.679 & 0.714 & 0.720 & 0.728 & 0.734 \\ DTQ-2 & 0.752 & 0.757 & 0.761 & 0.768 & 0.718 & 0.722 & 0.726 & 0.731 & 0.717 & 0.725 & 0.733 & 0.739 \\ DTQ-Q & {0.769} & {0.773} & {0.777} & {0.781} & {0.750} & {0.761} & {0.763} & {0.765} & {0.721} & {0.727} & {0.734} & {0.740} \\ DTQ-O & \underline{0.785} & \underline{0.787} & \underline{0.780} & \underline{0.788} & \underline{0.771} & \underline{0.777} & \underline{0.779} & \underline{0.781} & \underline{0.739} & \underline{0.745} & \underline{0.750} & \underline{0.758} \\ DTQ & \textbf{0.795} & \textbf{0.798} & \textbf{0.799} & \textbf{0.801} & \textbf{0.785} & \textbf{0.789} & \textbf{0.790} & \textbf{0.792} & \textbf{0.758} & \textbf{0.760} & \textbf{0.764} & \textbf{0.767} \\ \Xhline{1.0pt} \end{tabular} \end{table*} \subsection{Analysis} \subsubsection{Ablation Study} We investigate five variants of DTQ: \textbf{1) DTQ-T} is the DTQ variant by replacing the triplet loss in \eqref{eqn:L} with the widely-used pairwise cross-entropy loss \cite{cite:AAAI16DHN,cite:ICCV17HashNet}; \textbf{2) DTQ-H} is the DTQ variant without Group Hard to mine appropriate amount of good triplets for each epoch during the learning of the triplet loss as \cite{cite:CVPR15DNNH}; \textbf{3) DTQ-2} is the two-step variant of DTQ which first learns the deep representations for all images and then generates compact binary codes via the weak-orthogonal quantization. \textbf{4) DTQ-Q} is the DTQ variant which replaces the proposed Triplet Quantization to the Product Quantization \cite{cite:TPAMI11PQ} used in DQN \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN}. \textbf{5) DTQ-O} is the DTQ variant by removing the weak orthogonality penalty for redundancy reduction, i.e. $\gamma = 0$. The MAP results for DTQ and it's five variants with respect to different code lengths on three benchmark datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO are reported in Table \ref{table:ablation}. \textbf{Triplet Loss.} DTQ outperforms DTQ-T by very large margins of 7.4\%, 11.8\% and 3.8\% in the average MAP on the three datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO, respectively. DTQ-T uses the widely-used pairwise cross-entropy loss \cite{cite:AAAI16DHN,cite:ICCV17HashNet} which achieves state-of-the-art results on previous similarity retrieval tasks. It is worth noting that the triplet loss is a learning to rank method, and tries to bring the anchor and the positive samples closer while also pushing away the negative samples. The DTQ with triplet loss is actually more suitable for the similarity retrieval tasks and naturally gives rise to much better performance than DTQ-T. \textbf{Quantizability.} Another observation is that by jointly preserving similarity information in the deep representations of image triplets as well as controlling the quantization error of compact binary codes, DTQ outperforms DTQ-2 by 3.9\%, 6.4\% and 3.4\% in the average MAP on the three datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO. This shows that end-to-end quantization can improve the quantizability of deep feature representations and satisfactorily yield much more accurate retrieval results. \textbf{Triplet Quantization.} After replacing the proposed Triplet Quantization to Product Quantization \cite{cite:TPAMI11PQ} used in DQN \cite{cite:AAAI16DQN}, DTQ-Q yields significantly lossy compression and incur remarkable performance drop of 2.3\%, 2.9\%, 3.2\% in the average MAP on the three datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO datasets respectively. This proves that the proposed Triplet Quantization with weak orthogonality can effectively learn compact binary codes and enable more effective retrieval than Product Quantization. \textbf{Weak-Orthogonal Quantization.} Finally, by removing the weak orthogonality penalty, DTQ-O incurs performance drop of 1.3\%, 1.2\%, 1.4\% in the average MAP on the three datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO datasets respectively. This proves the importance of removing the codebook redundancy and improving the compactness of binary codes for efficient image retrieval. \begin{figure}[!thp] \centering \subfigure[Loss]{ \includegraphics[width=0.48\columnwidth]{loss_cifar} \label{fig:loss} }\hfil \subfigure[mAP]{ \includegraphics[width=0.48\columnwidth]{map_cifar} \label{fig:map} } \caption{Triplet Loss and MAP curves w.r.t. \#iterations.} \label{fig:loss_map} \end{figure} \subsubsection{Triplet Selection} By using the proposed triplet mining strategy, \emph{Group Hard}, DTQ outperforms DTQ-H by large margins of 3.8\%, 4.0\% and 4.4\% in the average MAP on three benchmark datasets, NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO, respectively. As shown in Figure~\ref{fig:loss_map}, without mining the appropriate amount of hard triplets, the \emph{Group All} training of triplet loss will quickly stagnate, leading to suboptimal convergence quality and MAP results. The proposed triplet mining strategy, \emph{Group Hard}, randomly samples proper amount of useful triplets with hard examples from several randomly partitioned group, resulting in effective training and faster convergence as well as more accurate retrieval performance. \begin{table}[h] \addtolength{\tabcolsep}{2pt} \centering \caption{MAP on CIFAR-10 for Different Number of Bits} \label{table:online} \begin{tabular}{c|cccc} \Xhline{1.0pt} Method & 8 bits & 16 bits & 24 bits & 32 bits \\ \hline DTQ-online & 0.703 & 0.708 & 0.710 & 0.713 \\ DTQ & \bf{0.785} & \bf{0.789} & \bf{0.790} & \bf{0.792} \\ \Xhline{1.0pt} \end{tabular} \end{table} \textbf{Online Selection.} Selecting all batch samples as negative is also known as \emph{online} triplet selection in the literature. Here we conduct a new experiment which uses online triplet selection and selects all hard negative samples in a batch (samples per batch = 192) for each anchor-positive pair. The results are reported in Table \ref{table:online}. Due to the low ratio of the valid hard triplets in each batch for triplet training, DTQ-online (with online triplet selection) fails to achieve satisfactory retrieval results compared with the proposed DTQ. \begin{figure*}[!tbh] \centering \subfigure[DVSQ]{ \includegraphics[width=0.26\textwidth]{tsne_cifar10_DVSQ} \label{fig:t-sne_dvsq} }\hfil \subfigure[DTQ-2]{ \includegraphics[width=0.26\textwidth]{tsne_cifar10_DTQ_2} \label{fig:t-sne_dtq2} }\hfil \subfigure[DTQ]{ \includegraphics[width=0.26\textwidth]{tsne_cifar10_DTQ} \label{fig:t-sne_dtq} } \vspace{-10pt} \caption{The t-SNE visualizations of deep representations learned by DVSQ, DTQ-2, and DTQ on CIFAR-10 dataset respectively.} \label{fig:tsne} \end{figure*} As online triplet selection cannot achieve satisfactory results, we adopt \emph{offline} triplet selection, which selects the valid hard triplets at the beginning of each epoch. However, the offline strategy may generate too many candidate triplets and need a huge number of batches per epoch, leading to hard triplets \emph{outdated} for training and potentially wasting most batches of each epoch. To alleviate the outdated effect of hard triplets in offline selection, we split the data into specific groups and select hard triplets within each group, reducing the training triplets from $|\mathcal{T}|$ to $|\mathcal{T}|/|G|$. We conduct an experiment to count the number of outdated hard triplets during training, shown in Figure~\ref{fig:n_part}. By splitting training data into $|G|$ specific groups, the number of outdated hard triplets is significantly reduced, leading to much better MAP results than the original offline triplet selection (i.e. $|G|=1$). This validates the effectiveness of the proposed offline selection strategy, \emph{Group Hard}. \begin{figure}[!tbh] \centering \includegraphics[width=0.46\columnwidth]{hard_ratio} \includegraphics[width=0.44\columnwidth]{n_part} \caption{(left) mAP and ratio of non-outdated hard triplets w.r.t. iterations; (right) \#groups and \#triplets w.r.t. \#epochs.} \label{fig:n_part} \vspace{-10pt} \end{figure} \subsubsection{Visualization} We show t-SNE visualization of binary codes and the illustration of top 10 returned images for better understanding the impressive performance improvement of DTQ. \textbf{Visualization of Representations.} Figure \ref{fig:tsne} shows the t-SNE visualizations \cite{cite:tsne} of the deep representations learned by DVSQ \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ}, DTQ-2, and DTQ on CIFAR-10 dataset. The deep representations of the proposed DTQ exhibit clear discriminative structures with data points in different categories well separated, while the deep representations by DVSQ \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ} exhibit relative vague structures. This validates that by introducing the triplet training to deep quantization, the deep representations generated by our DTQ are more discriminative than that generated by DVSQ, enabling more accurate image retrieval. Also, the deep representations of DTQ are more discriminative than that of the two-step variant DTQ-2, showing the efficacy of jointly preserving similarity information in the deep representations of image triplets and controlling the quantization error of compact binary codes via back-propagation. \begin{figure}[!tbh] \centering \includegraphics[width=1.0\columnwidth]{top10_returned_images.pdf} \caption{The top 10 images returned by DVSQ and DTQ.} \label{fig:top10} \vspace{-10pt} \end{figure} \textbf{Illustration of Top 10 Results.} Figure \ref{fig:top10} illustrates the top 10 returned images of DTQ and the best deep hashing baseline DVSQ \cite{cite:CVPR17DVSQ} for three query images on the three datasets NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO, respectively. DTQ yields much more relevant and user-desired retrieval results than the state-of-the-art method. \section{Conclusion} This paper proposed Deep Triplet Quantization (DTQ) for efficient image retrieval, which introduces a triplet training strategy to deep quantization framework. Through a novel triplet selection module, {Group Hard}, an appropriate number of hard triplets are selected for effective triplet training and faster convergence. To enable efficient image retrieval, DTQ can learn compact binary codes by jointly optimizing a novel triplet quantization loss with weak orthogonality. Comprehensive experiments justify that DTQ generates compact binary encoding and yields state-of-the-art retrieval performance on three benchmark datasets NUS-WIDE, CIFAR-10, and MS-COCO. \section{Acknowledgements} This work is supported by National Key R\&D Program of China (2016YFB1000701), and NSFC grants (61772299, 61672313, 71690231). { \bibliographystyle{ACM-Reference-Format}

\section{Introduction} Generative probabilistic modeling is an effective approach for understanding real-world data in many areas of science \citep{Bishop2006,Murphy2012}. A probabilistic model describes a data-generating process through a joint distribution of observed data and latent (unobserved) variables. With a model in place, the investigator uses an inference algorithm to calculate or approximate the posterior, i.e., the conditional distribution of the latent variables given the available observations. It is through the posterior that the investigator explores the latent structure in the data and forms a predictive distribution of future data. Approximating the posterior is the central algorithmic problem for probabilistic modeling. One of the most widely used methods to approximate the posterior distribution is variational inference \citep{Wainwright2008,Jordan1999}. Variational inference aims to approximate the posterior with a simpler distribution, fitting that distribution to be close to the exact posterior, where closeness is measured in terms of \gls{KL} divergence. In minimizing the \gls{KL}, variational inference converts the problem of approximating the posterior into an optimization problem. Traditional variational inference uses coordinate ascent to optimize its objective. This works well for models in which each conditional distribution is easy to compute~\citep{Ghahramani2001}, but is difficult to use in more complex models where the variational objective involves intractable expectations. Recent innovations in variational inference have addressed this with stochastic optimization, forming noisy gradients with Monte Carlo approximation. This strategy expands the scope of variational inference beyond traditional models, e.g., to non-conjugate probabilistic models \citep{Carbonetto2009,Paisley2012,Salimans2013,Ranganath2014,Titsias2014_doubly}, deep neural networks~\citep{Neal1992,Hinton1995,Mnih2014,Kingma2014,Ranganath2015}, and probabilistic programming~\citep{Wingate2013,Kucukelbir2015}. Some of these techniques find their roots in classical policy search algorithms for reinforcement learning \citep{Williams1992,vandeMeent2016}. These approaches must address a core problem with Monte Carlo estimates of the gradient, which is that they suffer from high variance. The estimated gradient can significantly differ from the truth and this leads to slow convergence of the optimization. There are several strategies to reduce the variance of the gradients, including Rao-Blackwellization~\citep{Casella1996,Ranganath2014}, control variates~\citep{Ross2002,Paisley2012,Ranganath2014,Gu2016}, reparameterization \citep{Price1958,Bonnet1964,Salimans2013,Kingma2014,Rezende2014,Kucukelbir2015}, and local expectations~\citep{Titsias2015}. In this paper we develop \gls{OBBVI}, a new method for reducing the variance of Monte Carlo gradients in variational inference. The main idea is to use importance sampling to estimate the gradient, in order to construct a good proposal distribution that is matched to the variational problem. We show that \gls{OBBVI} applies more generally than methods such as reparameterization and local expectations, and it further improves the profile of gradients that use Rao-Blackwellization and control variates. We demonstrate \gls{OBBVI} on two complex models: a non-conjugate time series model~\citep{Ranganath2014} and Poisson-based \glspl{DEF} \citep{Ranganath2015}. Our study shows that \gls{OBBVI} reduces the variance of the original \gls{BBVI} estimates \citep{Ranganath2014}, even when using only half the number of Monte Carlo samples. This provides significant savings in run-time complexity. \parhead{Technical summary.} Consider a probabilistic model $p(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{z})$, where $\mathbf{z}$ are the latent variables and $\mathbf{x}$ are the observations. Variational inference sets up a parameterized distribution of the latent variables $q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})$ and finds the parameter $\mathbb{\lambda}^\star$ that minimizes the \gls{KL} divergence between $q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})$ and the posterior $p(\mathbf{z} \, | \, \mathbf{x})$. We then use $q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda}^\star)$ as a proxy for the posterior. We build on \gls{BBVI}, which solves this problem with a stochastic optimization procedure that uses Monte Carlo estimates of the gradient~\citep{Ranganath2014}. Let $\mathcal{L}(\mathbb{\lambda})$ be the variational objective, which is the (negative) \gls{KL} divergence up to an additive constant. \gls{BBVI} uses samples from $q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})$ to approximate its gradient, \begin{align}\label{eq:reinforce} \nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}} \mathcal{L} = \E{q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})}{f(\mathbf{z})}, \end{align} where \begin{align}\label{eq:fz} f(\mathbf{z}) = \nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}} \log q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda}) \left(\log p(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{z})-\log q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})\right). \end{align} The resulting Monte Carlo estimator, based on sampling from $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$, only requires evaluating the log-joint distribution $\log p(\mathbf{z}, \mathbf{x})$, the log-variational distribution $\log q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})$, and the score function $\nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}} \log q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. Calculations about $q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})$ can be derived once and stored in a library and, as a consequence, \gls{BBVI} can be easily applied to a large class of models. However, as we mentioned above, Monte Carlo estimates of this gradient usually have high variance. \citet{Ranganath2014} correct for this with Rao-Blackwellization and control variates. We expand on this idea by approximating the gradient with importance sampling. We introduce a proposal distribution $r(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda}, \tau)$, which depends on both the variational parameters and an additional parameter. (We discuss the additional parameter below.) We then write the gradient as \begin{align} \label{eq:isgrad} \nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}} \mathcal{L} = \E{r(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda}, \tau)}{f(\mathbf{z}) \frac{q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})}{r(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda}, \tau)}}, \end{align} and form noisy estimates with samples from the proposal. The key idea behind our method is that the optimal proposal distribution (in terms of minimizing the variance of the resulting estimator) is \textit{not} the original distribution $q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})$~\citep[Chapter~9]{Owen2013}. Rather, the optimal proposal is a skewed version of that distribution with heavier tails. Unfortunately, this distribution is not available to us---it involves an intractable normalization constant. But we use this insight to set a proposal with heavier tails than the variational distribution, thus making it closer to the optimal proposal. Note this is an unconventional use of importance sampling, which is usually employed to approximate expectations of intractable distributions. Here we use importance sampling to improve the characteristics of a Monte Carlo estimator by sampling from a different distribution. In detail, we first assume that the variational distribution is in the exponential family. (This is not an assumption about the model; most applications of variational inference use exponential family variational distributions.) We then set the proposal distribution to be in the corresponding overdispersed exponential family~\citep{Jorgensen1987}, where $\tau$ is the dispersion parameter. We show that the corresponding estimator has lower variance than the \gls{BBVI} estimator, we put forward a method to adapt the dispersion parameter during optimization, and we demonstrate that this method is more efficient than \gls{BBVI}. We call our approach \emph{\acrlong{OBBVI}} (\acrshort{OBBVI}). \parhead{Organization.} The rest of the paper is organized as follows. We review \gls{BBVI} in Section~\ref{sec:bbvi}. We develop \gls{OBBVI} in Section~\ref{sec:isbbvi}, describing both the basic algorithm and its extensions to adaptive proposals and high-dimensional settings. Section~\ref{sec:experiments} reports on our empirical study of two non-conjugate models. We conclude the paper in Section~\ref{sec:conclusions}. \section{Black-Box Variational Inference}\label{sec:bbvi} Consider a probabilistic model $p(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{z})$ and a variational family $q(\mathbf{z} ; \mathbb{\lambda})$ which is in the exponential family, i.e., \begin{equation}\label{eq:exp_fam} q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})=g(\mathbf{z})\exp\left\{ \mathbb{\lambda}^\top t(\mathbf{z}) - A(\mathbb{\lambda})\right\}, \end{equation} where $g(\mathbf{z})$ is the base measure, $\mathbb{\lambda}$ are the natural parameters, $t(\mathbf{z})$ are the sufficient statistics, and $A(\mathbb{\lambda})$ is the log-normalizer. We are interested in a variational approximation to the intractable posterior $p(\mathbf{z}\, | \, \mathbf{x})$, i.e., we aim to minimize the \gls{KL} divergence $\KL{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{p(\mathbf{z}\, | \, \mathbf{x})}$ with respect to $\mathbb{\lambda}$ \citep{Jordan1999}. This is equivalent to maximizing the \gls{ELBO}, \begin{equation}\label{eq:elbo} \mathcal{L}(\mathbb{\lambda}) = \E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{\log p(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{z})-\log q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}, \end{equation} which is a lower bound on the log of the marginal probability of the observations, $\log p(\mathbf{x})$. With a tractable variational family (e.g., the mean-field family) and a conditionally conjugate model,\footnote{A conditionally conjugate model is a model for which all the complete conditionals (i.e., the posterior distribution of each hidden variable conditioned on the observations and the rest of hidden variables) are in the same exponential family as the prior.} the expectations in Eq.~\ref{eq:elbo} can be computed in closed form and we can use coordinate-ascent variational inference~\citep{Ghahramani2001}. However, many models of interest are not conditionally conjugate. For these models, we need alternative methods to optimize the \gls{ELBO}. One approach is \gls{BBVI}, which uses Monte Carlo estimates of the gradient and requires few model-specific calculations~\citep{Ranganath2014}. Thus, \gls{BBVI} is a variational inference algorithm that can be applied to a large class of models. \gls{BBVI} relies on the ``log-derivative trick,'' also called \textsc{reinforce} or score function method \citep{Williams1992,Kleijnen1996,Glynn1990}, to obtain Monte Carlo estimates of the gradient. In detail, we recover the Monte Carlo estimate driven by Eqs.~\ref{eq:reinforce} and \ref{eq:fz} by taking the gradient of \eqref{eq:elbo} with respect to the variational parameters $\mathbb{\lambda}$, and then applying the following two identities: \begin{align} & \nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}} q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda}) = q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})\nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}}\log q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda}), \\ & \E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{\nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}} \log q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})} =0 . \end{align} Eq.~\ref{eq:reinforce} enables noisy gradients of the \gls{ELBO} by taking samples from $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. However, the resulting estimator may have high variance. This is especially the case when the variational distribution $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$ is a poor fit to the posterior $p(\mathbf{z}\, | \, \mathbf{x})$, which is typical in early iterations of optimization. In order to reduce the variance of the estimator, \gls{BBVI} uses two strategies: control variates and Rao-Blackwellization. Because we will also use these ideas in our algorithm, we briefly discuss them here. \parhead{Control variates.} A control variate is a random variable that is included in the estimator, preserving its expectation but reducing its variance~\citep{Ross2002}. Although there are many possible choices for control variates, \citet{Ranganath2014} advocate for the weighted score function because it is not model-dependent. Denote the score function by $h(\mathbf{z}) = \nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}} \log q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$, and note again that its expected value is zero. With this function, each component $n$ of the gradient in \eqref{eq:reinforce} can be rewritten as $\E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{f_n(\mathbf{z})-a_n h_n(\mathbf{z})}$ where $a_n$ is a constant and $f(\mathbf{z})$ is defined in \eqref{eq:fz}. (Here, $f_n(\mathbf{z})$ and $h_n(\mathbf{z})$ denote the $n$-th component of $f(\mathbf{z})$ and $h(\mathbf{z})$, respectively.) We can set each element $a_n$ to minimize the variance of the Monte Carlo estimates of this expectation, \begin{equation}\label{eq:a_n} a_n = \frac{\textrm{Cov}(f_n(\mathbf{z}),h_n(\mathbf{z}))}{\textrm{Var}(h_n(\mathbf{z}))}. \end{equation} In \gls{BBVI}, a separate set of samples from $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$ is used to estimate $a_n$ (otherwise, the estimator would be biased). \parhead{Rao-Blackwellization.} Rao-Blackwellization~\citep{Casella1996} reduces the variance of a random variable by replacing it with its conditional expectation, given a subset of other variables. In \gls{BBVI}, each component of the gradient is Rao-Blackwellized with respect to variables outside of the Markov blanket of the involved hidden variable. More precisely, assume a mean-field\footnote{A structured variational approach is also amenable to Rao-Blackwellization, but we assume a fully factorized variational distribution for simplicity.} variational distribution $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})=\prod_n q(z_n;\lambda_n)$. We can equivalently rewrite the expectation of each element in Eq.~\ref{eq:reinforce} as \begin{align} \label{eq:rao-blackwell} \begin{split} \nabla_{\lambda_n} \mathcal{L} = \mathbb{E}_{q(\mathbf{z}_{(n)};\mathbb{\lambda}_{(n)})} \big[& \nabla_{\lambda_n} \log q(z_n;\lambda_n) \\ & \times\left(\log p_n(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{z}_{(n)})-\log q(z_n;\lambda_n)\right) \big], \end{split} \end{align} where $\mathbf{z}_{(n)}$ denotes the variable $z_n$ together with all latent variables in its Markov blanket, $q(\mathbf{z}_{(n)};\mathbb{\lambda}_{(n)})$ denotes the variational distribution on $\mathbf{z}_{(n)}$, and $\log p_n(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{z}_{(n)})$ contains all terms of the log-joint distribution that depend on $\mathbf{z}_{(n)}$. The Monte Carlo estimate based on the Rao-Blackwellized expectation has significantly smaller variance than the estimator driven by Eq.~\ref{eq:reinforce}. \section{Overdispersed Black-Box Variational Inference} \label{sec:isbbvi} We have described \gls{BBVI} and its two strategies for reducing the variance of the noisy gradient. We now describe \gls{OBBVI}, a method for further reducing the variance. The main idea is to use importance sampling~\citep{Robert2005,Rubinstein2011} to estimate the gradient. We first describe \gls{OBBVI} and the proposal distribution it uses. We then show that this reduces variance, discuss several important implementation details, and present the full algorithm. \gls{OBBVI} does not sample from the variational distribution $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$ to estimate the expectation $\E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{f(\mathbf{z})}$. Rather, it takes samples from a proposal distribution $r(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda}, \tau)$ and constructs estimates of the gradient in Eq.~\ref{eq:isgrad}, where the importance weights are $w(\mathbf{z}) = q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})/r(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda}, \tau)$. This guarantees that the resulting estimator is unbiased. The proposal distribution involves the current setting of the variational parameters $\mathbb{\lambda}$ and an additional parameter $\tau$. \parhead{The optimal proposal.} The particular proposal that \gls{OBBVI} uses is inspired by a result from the importance sampling literature~\citep{Robert2005,Owen2013}. This result states that the optimal proposal distribution, which minimizes the variance of the estimator, is \emph{not} the variational distribution $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. Rather, the optimal proposal is \begin{align} \label{eq:optimal-proposal} r_n^{\star}(\mathbf{z})\propto q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda}) |f_n(\mathbf{z})|, \end{align} for each component $n$ of the gradient. (Recall that $f(\mathbf{z})$ is a vector of the same length as $\mathbb{\lambda}$.) While interesting, the optimal proposal distribution is not tractable in general---it involves normalizing a complex product---and is not ``black box'' in the sense that it depends on the model via $f(\mathbf{z})$. In \gls{OBBVI}, we build an alternative proposal based on overdispersed exponential families~\citep{Jorgensen1987}. We will argue that this proposal is closer to the (intractable) optimal $r^*(\mathbf{z})$ than the variational distribution $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$, and that it is still practical in the context of stochastic optimization of the variational objective. \parhead{The overdispersed proposal.} Our motivation for using overdispersed exponential families is that the optimal distribution of Eq.~\ref{eq:optimal-proposal} assigns higher probability density to the tails of $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. There are two reasons for this fact. First, consider settings of the variational parameters where the variational distribution is a poor fit to the posterior. For these parameters, there are values of $\mathbf{z}$ for which the posterior is high but the variational distribution is small. While the optimal proposal would sample configurations of $\mathbf{z}$ for which $f_n(\mathbf{z})$ is large, these realizations are in the tails of the variational distribution. The second reason has to do with the score function. The score function $h_n(\mathbf{z})$ vanishes for values of $\mathbf{z}$ for which the $n$-th sufficient statistic $t_n(\mathbf{z})$ equals its expected value, and this pushes probability mass (in the optimal proposal) to the tails of $q(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda})$. To see this, recall the exponential family form of the variational distribution given in Eq.~\ref{eq:exp_fam}. For any exponential family distribution, the score function is $h_n(\mathbf{z})=t_n(\mathbf{z})-\E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{t_n(\mathbf{z})}$. (This result follows from simple properties of exponential families.\footnote{The gradient of the log-normalizer (with respect to the natural parameters) equals the first-order moment of the sufficient statistics, i.e., $\nabla_{\mathbb{\lambda}}A(\mathbb{\lambda})=\E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{t(\mathbf{z})}$.}) For values of $\mathbf{z}$ for which $t_n(\mathbf{z})$ is close to its expectation, $h_n(\mathbf{z})$ becomes very close to zero. This zeros out $f_n(\mathbf{z})$ in Eq.~\ref{eq:optimal-proposal}, which pushes mass to other parts of $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. As an example, in the case where $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$ is a Gaussian distribution, the optimal proposal distribution places zero mass on the mean of that Gaussian and hence more probability mass on its tails. Thus, we design a proposal distribution $r(\mathbf{z}; \mathbb{\lambda}, \tau)$ that assigns higher mass to the tails of $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. Specifically, we use an overdispersed distribution in the same exponential family as $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. The proposal is \begin{align} r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau) = g(\mathbf{z},\tau)\exp\left\{ \frac{\mathbb{\lambda}^\top t(\mathbf{z}) - A(\mathbb{\lambda})}{\tau}\right\}, \end{align} where $\tau\geq 1$ is the dispersion coefficient of the overdispersed distribution~\citep{Jorgensen1987}. Hence, the \gls{OBBVI} estimator of the gradient can be expressed as \begin{equation}\label{eq:est_grad_obb} \widehat{\nabla}_\mathbb{\lambda}^{\textrm{O-BB}} \mathcal{L} = \frac{1}{S}\sum_s f(\mathbf{z}^{(s)})\frac{q(\mathbf{z}^{(s)};\mathbb{\lambda})}{r(\mathbf{z}^{(s)})}, \quad \mathbf{z}^{(s)} \stackrel{\textrm{iid}}{\sim} r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau), \end{equation} where $S$ is the number of samples of the Monte Carlo approximation. This choice of $r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)$ has several desired properties for a proposal distribution. First, it is easy to sample from, since for fixed values of $\tau$ it belongs to the same exponential family as $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. Second, as for the optimal proposal, it is adaptive, since it explicitly depends on the parameters $\mathbb{\lambda}$ which we are optimizing. Finally, by definition, it assigns higher mass to the tails of $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$, which was our motivation for choosing it. The dispersion coefficient $\tau$ can be itself adaptive to better match the optimal proposal at each iteration of the variational optimization procedure. We put forward a method to update the value of $\tau$ in Section~\ref{sec:extensions}. Note that our approach differs from importance weighted autoencoders \citep{Burda2016}, which also make use of importance sampling but with the goal of deriving a tighter log-likelihood lower bound in the context of the variational autoencoder \citep{Kingma2014}. In contrast, we use importance sampling to reduce the variance of the estimator of the gradient. \subsection{Variance reduction} Here, we compare the variance of the \gls{OBBVI} estimator $\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{O-BB}}_\lambda \mathcal{L}$ given in Eq.~\ref{eq:est_grad_obb} with the variance of the original \gls{BBVI} estimator $\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{BB}}_\lambda \mathcal{L}$, which samples from $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$: \begin{align} \widehat{\nabla}_\mathbb{\lambda}^{\textrm{BB}} \mathcal{L} = \frac{1}{S}\sum_s f(\mathbf{z}^{(s)}), \qquad \mathbf{z}^{(s)}\stackrel{\textrm{iid}}{\sim} q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda}). \end{align} After some algebra, we can express the variance of the \gls{BBVI} estimator as \begin{equation} \Var{\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{BB}}_\mathbb{\lambda} \mathcal{L}} = \frac{1}{S}\E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{f^2(\mathbf{z})}-\frac{1}{S}(\nabla_\mathbb{\lambda}\mathcal{L})^2, \end{equation} and we can also express the variance of the \gls{OBBVI} estimator in terms of an expectation with respect to the variational distribution as \begin{equation}\label{eq:varL2} \begin{split} \Var{\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{O-BB}}_\mathbb{\lambda} \mathcal{L}} & = \frac{1}{S}\E{r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)}{f^2(\mathbf{z})\frac{q^2(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{r^2(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)}}-\frac{1}{S}(\nabla_\mathbb{\lambda}\mathcal{L})^2\\ & = \frac{1}{S}\E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{f^2(\mathbf{z})\frac{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)}}-\frac{1}{S}(\nabla_\mathbb{\lambda}\mathcal{L})^2. \end{split} \end{equation} Variance reduction for the \gls{OBBVI} approach is achieved when $\Var{\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{O-BB}}_\mathbb{\lambda} \mathcal{L}}\leq \Var{\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{BB}}_\mathbb{\lambda} \mathcal{L}}$ or, equivalently, \begin{equation}\label{eq:varianceReduction} \E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{f^2(\mathbf{z})\frac{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)}}\leq \E{q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})}{f^2(\mathbf{z})}. \end{equation} This inequality is trivially satisfied when we set $r(\mathbf{z})$ to the optimal proposal distribution, $r^{\star}(\mathbf{z})$. Moreover, Eq.~\ref{eq:varianceReduction} also gives us some intuition on why the use of an overdispersed proposal distribution can reduce the variance, since $r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)$ will be larger than $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$ for those values of $\mathbf{z}$ for which the product $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})f^2(\mathbf{z})$ is highest, i.e., in the tails of $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. Our experimental results in Section~\ref{sec:experiments} demonstrate that the variance is effectively reduced when we use our \gls{OBBVI}. \subsection{Implementation}\label{sec:extensions} We now discuss several extensions of \gls{OBBVI} that make it more suitable for real applications. \paragraph{High dimensionality.} Previously, we defined the proposal distribution $r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)$ as an overdispersed version of the variational distribution $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$. However, importance sampling is known to fail when the dimensionality of the hidden space is moderately high, due to the high resulting variance of the importance weights $w(\mathbf{z})=q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})/r(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda},\tau)$. To address this, we rely on the fact that hidden variable $z_n$ is the variable with the highest influence on the estimator of the $n$-th component of the gradient. We exploit this idea, which was also considered by \citet{Titsias2015} in their algorithm based on local expectations. More precisely, for the variational parameters of variable $z_n$, we first write the gradient as \begin{equation}\label{eq:isbbvi_high_dim} \begin{split} \nabla_{\lambda_n}\mathcal{L} & = \E{q(z_n;\lambda_n)}{\E{q(\mathbf{z}_{\neg n};\mathbb{\lambda}_{\neg n})}{f_n(\mathbf{z})}}\\ & = \E{r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_n)}{w(z_n)\E{q(\mathbf{z}_{\neg n};\mathbb{\lambda}_{\neg n})}{f_n(\mathbf{z})}}, \end{split} \end{equation} where $r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_n)$ is the overdispersed version of $q(z_n;\lambda_n)$ with dispersion coefficient $\tau_n$, $\mathbf{z}_{\neg n}$ denotes all hidden variables in the model except $z_n$, and similarly for $\mathbb{\lambda}_{\neg n}$. Thus, the corresponding importance weights in \eqref{eq:isbbvi_high_dim} for each component of the gradient depend only on variable $z_n$, i.e., \begin{equation} w(z_n) = \frac{q(z_n;\lambda_n)}{r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_n)}. \end{equation} We use a single sample from $q(\mathbf{z}_{\neg n};\mathbb{\lambda}_{\neg n})$ to estimate the inner expectation in \eqref{eq:isbbvi_high_dim}, and $S$ samples of $z_n$ from $r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_n)$ to estimate the outer expectation. \paragraph{Adaptation of the dispersion coefficients.} Our algorithm requires setting the value of the dispersion parameters $\tau_n$; we would like to automate this procedure. Here, we develop a method to learn these coefficients during optimization by minimizing the variance of the estimator. More precisely, we introduce stochastic gradient descent steps for $\tau_{n}$ that minimize the variance. The exact derivative of the (negative) variance with respect to $\tau_{n}$ is \begin{align}\label{eq:dvar_dtau} -\frac{\partial \Var{\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{O-BB}}_{\lambda_n} \mathcal{L}}}{\partial \tau_n} = & \frac{1}{S} \mathbb{E}_{r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_n)} \Bigg[ {\E{q(\mathbf{z}_{\neg n};\mathbb{\lambda}_{\neg n})}{f_n(\mathbf{z})}^2} \nonumber \\ & \times w^2(z_n){\frac{\partial \log r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_n)}{\partial \tau_n}}\Bigg], \end{align} where we have applied the log-derivative trick once again, as well as the extension to high dimensionality detailed above. Now a Monte Carlo estimate of this derivative can be obtained by using the same set of $S$ samples used in the update of $\lambda_n$. The resulting procedure is fast, with little extra overhead, since both $f_n(\mathbf{z})$ and $w(z_n)$ have been pre-computed. Thus, we perform gradient steps of the form \begin{equation}\label{eq:adapttau} \tau^{(t)}_{n}=\tau^{(t-1)}_{n}- \alpha_n \frac{\partial \Var{\widehat{\nabla}^{\textrm{O-BB}}_{\lambda_n}\mathcal{L}}}{\partial \tau_{n}}, \end{equation} where $\tau_n$ is constrained as $\tau_n\geq 1$ and the derivatives are estimated via Monte Carlo approximation. Since the derivatives in Eq.~\ref{eq:adapttau} can be several orders of magnitude greater than $\tau_{n}$, we opt for a simple approach to choose an appropriate step size $\alpha_n$. In particular, we ignore the magnitude of the derivative in~\eqref{eq:adapttau} and take a small gradient step in the direction given by its sign. Note that we do not need to satisfy the Robbins-Monro conditions here \citep{Robbins1951}, because the adaptation of $\tau_n$ only defines the proposal distribution and it is not part of the original stochastic optimization procedure. Eq.~\ref{eq:adapttau} can still be applied even if $\lambda_n$ is a vector; it only requires replacing the derivative of the variance with the summation of the derivatives for all components of $\lambda_n$. \paragraph{Multiple importance sampling.} It may be more stable (in terms of the variance of the importance weights) to consider a set of $J$ dispersion coefficients, $\tau_{n1},\ldots,\tau_{nJ}$, instead of a single coefficient $\tau_n$. We propose to use a mixture with equal weights to build the proposal as follows: \begin{equation} r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_{n1},\ldots,\tau_{nJ}) = \frac{1}{J}\sum_{j=1}^{J} r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_{nj}), \end{equation} where each term in the mixture is given by $r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_{nj})=g(z_n,\tau_{nj})\exp\left\{ \frac{\lambda_n^\top t(z_n)-A(\lambda_n)}{\tau_{nj}}\right\}$. In the importance sampling literature, this is known as \gls{MIS}, as multiple proposals are used \citep{Veach1995}. Within the \gls{MIS} methods, we opt for full \gls{DMIS} because it is the approach that presents lowest variance \citep{Hesterberg1995,Owen2000,Elvira2015_generalized}. In \gls{DMIS}, the number of samples $S$ of the Monte Carlo estimator must be an integer multiple of the number of mixture components $J$, and $S/J$ samples are deterministically assigned to each proposal $r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_{nj})$. However, the importance weights are obtained as if the samples had been actually drawn from the mixture, i.e., \begin{equation}\label{eq:weights_dmis} w(z_n) = \frac{q(z_n;\lambda_n)}{\frac{1}{J}\sum_{j=1}^{J} r(z_n;\lambda_n,\tau_{nj})}. \end{equation} This choice of the importance weights yields an unbiased estimator with smaller variance than the standard \gls{MIS} approach \citep{Owen2000,Elvira2015_generalized}. In the experiments in Section~\ref{sec:experiments} we investigate the performance of two-component proposal distributions, where $J=2$, and compare it against our initial algorithm that uses a unique proposal, which corresponds to $J=1$. We have also conducted some additional experiments (not shown in the paper) with mixtures with higher number of components, with no significant improvements. \subsection{Full algorithm} We now present our full algorithm for \gls{OBBVI}. It makes use of control variates, Rao-Blackwellization, and overdispersed importance sampling with adaptation of the dispersion coefficients. At each iteration, we draw a single sample $\mathbf{z}^{(0)}$ from the variational distribution, as well as $S$ samples $z_n^{(s)}$ from the overdispersed proposal for each $n$ (using \gls{DMIS} in this step). We obtain the score function as \begin{equation}\label{eq:fullalg_hd} h_n(z_n^{(s)}) = \nabla_{\lambda_n} \log q(z_n^{(s)};\lambda_n), \end{equation} and the argument of the expectation in \eqref{eq:rao-blackwell} as \begin{equation}\label{eq:fullalg_fd} f_n(\mathbf{z}^{(s)})=h_n(z_n^{(s)})(\log p_n(\mathbf{x},z_n^{(s)},\mathbf{z}_{\neg n}^{(0)})-\log q(z_n^{(s)};\lambda_n)), \end{equation} where $p_n$ indicates that we use Rao-Blackwellization. Finally, the estimator of the gradient is obtained as \begin{equation}\label{eq:fullalg_grad} \widehat{\nabla}_{\lambda_n}\mathcal{L} = \frac{1}{S}\sum_s \left(f^{\textrm{w}}_n(\mathbf{z}^{(s)})-a_n h_n^{\textrm{w}}(z_n^{(s)})\right), \end{equation} where the superscript `${\textrm{w}}$' stands for `weighted,' i.e., \begin{align} f^{\textrm{w}}_n(\mathbf{z}^{(s)})=w(z_n^{(s)})f_n(\mathbf{z}^{(s)}),\label{eq:fw}\\ h^{\textrm{w}}_n(z_n^{(s)})=w(z_n^{(s)})h_n(z_n^{(s)}).\label{eq:hw} \end{align} Following Eq.~\ref{eq:a_n}, we use a separate set of samples to estimate the optimal $a_n$ as \begin{equation}\label{eq:fullalg_optimal_ad} a_n=\frac{\widehat{\textrm{Cov}}(f^{\textrm{w}}_n,h^{\textrm{w}}_n)}{\widehat{\textrm{Var}}(h^{\textrm{w}}_n)}. \end{equation} We use AdaGrad \citep{Duchi2011} to obtain adaptive learning rates that ensure convergence of the stochastic optimization procedure, although other schedules can be used instead as long as they satisfy the standard Robbins-Monro conditions \citep{Robbins1951}. In AdaGrad, the learning rate is obtained as \begin{equation}\label{eq:fullalg_rho_t} \mathbb{\rho}_t = \eta\;\diag{\mathbf{G}_t}^{-1/2}, \end{equation} where $\mathbf{G}_t$ is a matrix that contains the sum across the first $t$ iterations of the outer products of the gradient, and $\eta$ is a constant. Thus, the stochastic gradient step is given by \begin{equation}\label{eq:fullalg_lambdanew} \mathbb{\lambda}^{(t)} = \mathbb{\lambda}^{(t-1)}+\mathbb{\rho}_t\circ\widehat{\nabla}_{\mathbb{\lambda}}\mathcal{L}, \end{equation} where `$\circ$' denotes the element-wise (Hadamard) product. Algorithm~\ref{alg:isBBVI} summarizes the full procedure. \begin{algorithm}[t] \SetAlgoLined \SetKwInOut{KwInput}{input} \SetKwInOut{KwOutput}{output} \KwInput{data $\mathbf{x}$, joint distribution $p(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{z})$, mean-field variational family $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$} \KwOutput{variational parameters $\mathbb{\lambda}$} Initialize $\mathbb{\lambda}$\; Initialize the dispersion coefficients $\tau_{nj}$\; \While{algorithm has not converged}{ \tcc{draw samples} Draw a single sample $\mathbf{z}^{(0)}\sim q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$\; \For{$n=1$ \emph{to} $N$}{ Draw $S$ samples $z_n^{(s)}\sim r(z_n;\lambda_n,\{\tau_{nj}\})$ (\acrshort{DMIS})\; Compute the importance weights $w(z_n^{(s)})$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:weights_dmis})\; } \tcc{estimate gradient} \For{$n=1$ \emph{to} $N$}{ For each sample $s$, compute $h_n(z_n^{(s)})$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:fullalg_hd})\; For each sample $s$, compute $f_n(\mathbf{z}^{(s)})$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:fullalg_fd})\; Compute the weighted $f_n^{\textrm{w}}(\mathbf{z}^{(s)})$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:fw})\; Compute the weighted $h_n^{\textrm{w}}(z_n^{(s)})$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:hw})\; Estimate the optimal $a_n$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:fullalg_optimal_ad})\; Estimate the gradient $\widehat{\nabla}_{\lambda_n}\mathcal{L}$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:fullalg_grad})\; } \tcc{update dispersion coefficients} \For{$n=1$ \emph{to} $N$}{ Estimate the derivatives $\frac{\partial \Var{\nabla_{\lambda_n}\mathcal{L}}}{\partial \tau_{nj}}$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:dvar_dtau})\; Take a gradient step for $\tau_{nj}$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:adapttau})\; } \tcc{take gradient step} Set the step size $\mathbb{\rho}_t$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:fullalg_rho_t})\; Take a gradient step for $\mathbb{\lambda}$ (Eq.~\ref{eq:fullalg_lambdanew})\; } \caption{\Acrfull{OBBVI}\label{alg:isBBVI}} \end{algorithm} \input{sec_empirical_study} \section{Conclusions}\label{sec:conclusions} \glsresetall We have developed \gls{OBBVI}, a method that relies on importance sampling to reduce the variance of the stochastic gradients in \gls{BBVI}. \gls{OBBVI} uses an importance sampling proposal distribution that has heavier tails than the actual variational distribution. In particular, we choose the proposal as an overdispersed distribution in the same exponential family as the variational distribution. Like \gls{BBVI}, our approach is amenable to mean field or structured variational inference, as well as variational models \citep{Ranganath2015_hvm,Tran2016}. We have studied the performance of our method on two complex probabilistic models. Our results show that \gls{BBVI} effectively benefits from the use of overdispersed importance sampling, and \gls{OBBVI} leads to faster convergence in the resulting stochastic optimization procedure. There are several avenues for future work. First, we can explore other proposal distributions to provide a better fit to the optimal ones while still maintaining computational efficiency. Second, we can apply quasi-Monte Carlo methods to further decrease the sampling variance, as already suggested by \citet{Ranganath2014}. Finally, we can combine the reparameterization trick with overdispersed proposals to explore whether variance is further reduced. \bibliographystyle{apa} \section{Empirical Study} \label{sec:experiments} \glsresetall{} We study our method with two non-conjugate probabilistic models: the \gls{GNTS} and the Poisson \gls{DEF}. We found that \gls{OBBVI} reduces the variance of the \gls{BBVI} estimator and leads to faster convergence. \subsection{Description of the experiments} \label{sec:descr_experiments} \parhead{Models description and datasets.} The \gls{GNTS} model \citep{Ranganath2014} is a non-conjugate state-space model for sequential data that was used to showcase \gls{BBVI}. The model is described by \begin{equation} \begin{split} & w_{kd}\sim \mathcal{N}(0,\sigma_w^2),\\ & o_{nd}\sim \mathcal{N}(0,\sigma_o^2),\\ & z_{n1k}\sim \textrm{GammaE}(\sigma_z,\sigma_z),\\ & z_{ntk}\sim \textrm{GammaE}(z_{n(t-1)k},\sigma_z),\\ & x_{ndt}\sim \mathcal{N}\left(o_{nd}+\sum_k z_{ntk}w_{kd},\sigma_x^2\right). \end{split} \end{equation} The indices $n$, $t$, $d$ and $k$ denote observations, time instants, observation dimensions, and latent factors, respectively. The distribution $\textrm{GammaE}$ denotes the expectation/variance parameterization of the gamma distribution. The model explains each datapoint $x_{ndt}$ with a latent factor model. For each time instant $t$, the mean of $x_{ndt}$ depends on the inner product $\sum_k z_{ntk}w_{kd}$, where $z_{ntk}$ varies smoothly across time. The variables $o_{nd}$ are an intercept that capture the baseline in the observations. We set the hyperparameters to be $\sigma_w^2=1$, $\sigma_o^2=1$, $\sigma_z=1$, and $\sigma^2_x=0.01$. We use a synthetic dataset of $N=900$ time sequences of length $T=30$ and dimensionality $D=20$. We use $K=30$ latent factors, leading to $828,600$ hidden variables. The Poisson \gls{DEF} \citep{Ranganath2015} is a multi-layered latent variable model of discrete data, such as text. The model is described by \begin{equation} \begin{split} & w_{kv}^{(0)} \sim \textrm{Gamma}(\alpha_w,\beta_w),\\ & w_{k k^\prime}^{(\ell)} \sim \textrm{Gamma}(\alpha_w,\beta_w),\\ & z_{dk}^{(L)} \sim \textrm{Poisson}(\lambda_z),\\ & z_{dk}^{(\ell)} \sim \textrm{Poisson}\left(\sum_{k^\prime} z_{dk^\prime}^{(\ell+1)} w_{k^\prime k}^{(\ell)}\right),\\ & x_{dv} \sim \textrm{Poisson}\left(\sum_{k^\prime} z_{dk^\prime}^{(1)} w_{k^\prime v}^{(0)}\right).\\ \end{split} \end{equation} The indices $d$, $v$, $k$ and $\ell$ denote documents, vocabulary words, latent factors, and hidden layers, respectively. This model captures a hierarchy of dependencies between latent variables similar to the hidden structure in deep neural networks. In detail, the number of times that word $v$ appears in document $d$ is $x_{dv}$. It has a Poisson distribution with rate given by an inner product of gamma-distributed weights and Poisson-distributed hidden variables from layer $1$. The Poisson-distributed hidden variables depend, in turn, on another set of weights and another layer of hidden Poisson-distributed variables. This structure repeats for a specified number of layers. We set the prior shape and rate as $\alpha_w=0.1$ and $\beta_w=0.3$, and the prior mean for the top level of the Poisson \gls{DEF} as $\lambda_z=0.1$. We use $L=3$ layers with $K=50$ latent factors each. We model the papers at the Neural Information Processing Systems (NIPS) 2011 conference. This is a data set with $D=305$ documents, $612,508$ words, and $V=5715$ vocabulary words (after removing stop words). This leads to a model with $336,500$ hidden variables. \parhead{Evaluation.} We compare \gls{OBBVI} with \gls{BBVI}~\citep{Ranganath2014}. For a fair comparison, we use the same number of samples in both methods and estimate the inner expectation in Eq.~\ref{eq:isbbvi_high_dim} with only one sample. For the outer expectation, we use $8$ samples to estimate the gradient itself and $8$ separate samples to estimate the optimal coefficient $a_n$ for the control variates. For \gls{BBVI}, we also doubled the number of samples to $16+16$; this is marked as ``\gls{BBVI} ($\times 2$)'' in the plots. For \gls{OBBVI}, we study both a single proposal and a mixture proposal with two components, respectively labeled as ``\gls{OBBVI} (single proposal)'' and ``\gls{OBBVI} (mixture).'' For the latter, we fix the dispersion coefficients $\tau_{n1}=1$ for all hidden variables and run stochastic gradient descent steps for $\tau_{n2}$. At each iteration (and for each method) we evaluate several quantities: the \gls{ELBO}, the averaged sample variance of the estimator of the gradient, and a model-specific performance metric on the test set. The estimation of the \gls{ELBO} is based on a single sample of the variational distribution $q(\mathbf{z};\mathbb{\lambda})$ for all methods. For the \gls{GNTS} model, we compute the average log-likelihood (up to a constant term) on the test set, which is generated with one additional time instant in all sequences. For the Poisson \gls{DEF}, we compute the average held-out perplexity, \begin{equation} \exp\left(\frac{-\sum_{d}\sum_{w\in \textrm{doc}(d)} \log p(w\, | \, \#\textrm{held out in } d)}{\# \textrm{held out words}}\right), \end{equation} where the held-out data contains $25\%$ randomly selected words of all documents. \parhead{Experimental setup.} For each method, we initialize the variational parameters to the same point and run each algorithm with a fixed computational budget (of CPU time). We use AdaGrad \citep{Duchi2011} for the learning rate. We set the parameter $\eta$ in Eq.~\ref{eq:fullalg_rho_t} to $\eta=0.5$ for the \gls{GNTS} model and $\eta=1$ for the Poisson \gls{DEF}. When optimizing the \gls{OBBVI} dispersion coefficients $\tau_n$, we take steps of length $0.1$ in the direction of the (negative) gradient. We initialize the dispersion coefficients as $\tau_n=2$ for the single proposal and $\tau_{n2}=3$ for the two-component mixture. We parameterize the normal distribution in terms of its mean and variance, the gamma in terms of its shape and mean, and the Poisson in terms of its mean parameter. In order to avoid constrained optimization, we apply the transformation $\lambda^\prime=\log(\exp(\lambda)-1)$ to those variational parameters that are constrained to be positive and take stochastic gradient steps with respect to $\lambda^\prime$. \parhead{Overdispersed exponential families.} For a fixed dispersion coefficient $\tau$, the overdispersed exponential family of the Gaussian distribution with mean $\mu$ and variance $\sigma^2$ is a Gaussian distribution with mean $\mu$ and variance $\tau\sigma^2$. The overdispersed gamma distribution with shape $s$ and rate $r$ is given by a new gamma distribution with shape $\frac{s+\tau-1}{\tau}$ and rate $\frac{r}{\tau}$. The overdispersed $\textrm{Poisson}(\lambda)$ distribution is a $\textrm{Poisson}(\lambda^{1/\tau})$ distribution. \subsection{Results} \label{sec:results} Figures~\ref{fig:gamNormTS} and \ref{fig:poissonDEF} show the evolution of the \gls{ELBO}, the predictive performance, and the average sample variance of the estimator for both models and all methods. We plot these metrics as a function of running time, and each method is run with the same computational budget. For the \gls{GNTS} model, Figure~\ref{fig:gamNormTS_varall_vs_t} shows that the variance of \gls{OBBVI} is significantly lower than \gls{BBVI} and \gls{BBVI} with twice the number of samples. Additionally, Figures~\ref{fig:gamNormTS_elbo_vs_t} and \ref{fig:gamNormTS_err_vs_t} show that \gls{OBBVI} outperforms vanilla \gls{BBVI} in terms of both \gls{ELBO} and held-out likelihood. According to these figures, using a single or mixture proposal does not seem to significantly affect performance. The results on the Poisson \gls{DEF} are similar (Figure~\ref{fig:poissonDEF}). Figure~\ref{fig:poissonDEF_varall_vs_t} shows the average sample variance of the estimator; again, \gls{OBBVI} outperforms both \gls{BBVI} algorithms. Figures~\ref{fig:poissonDEF_elbo_vs_t} and \ref{fig:poissonDEF_err_vs_t} show the evolution of the \gls{ELBO} and the held-out perplexity, respectively, where \gls{OBBVI} also outperforms \gls{BBVI}. Here, the two-component mixture proposal performs slightly better than the single proposal. This is consistent with Figure~\ref{fig:poissonDEF_varall_vs_t}, which indicates that the mixture proposal gives more stable estimates than the single proposal. Finally, for the \gls{GNTS} model only, we also apply the local expectations algorithm of \citet{Titsias2015}, which relies on exact or numerical integration to reduce the variance of the estimator. We form noisy gradients using numerical quadratures for the Gaussian random variables and standard \gls{BBVI} for the gamma variables (these results are not plotted in the paper). We found that local expectations accurately approximate the gradient for the Gaussian distributions. It converges slightly faster at the beginning of the run, although \gls{OBBVI} quickly reaches the same performance. (We conjecture that it is faster because the local expectations algorithm does not require the use of control variates. This saves evaluations of the log-joint probability of the model and thus it can run more iterations in the same period of time.) However, we emphasize that \gls{OBBVI} is a more general algorithm than local expectations. The local expectations of \citet{Titsias2015} are only available for discrete distributions with finite support and for continuous distributions for which numerical quadratures are accurate (such as Gaussian distributions). They fail to approximate the expectations for other exponential family distributions (e.g., gamma,\footnote{Although the univariate gamma distribution is amenable to numerical integration, we have found that the approximation of the expectations are not accurate when the shape parameter of the gamma distribution is below $1$, due to the singularity at $0$.} Poisson, and others). For example, they cannot handle the Poisson \gls{DEF}. \begin{figure}[t] \centering \subfloat[Averaged sample variance of the estimator.\label{fig:gamNormTS_varall_vs_t}]{\includegraphics[width=0.9\columnwidth]{gamNormTS_varall_vs_t.pdf}}\\ \vspace*{-7pt} \subfloat[Traceplot of the \gls{ELBO}.\label{fig:gamNormTS_elbo_vs_t}]{\includegraphics[width=0.9\columnwidth]{gamNormTS_elbo_vs_t.pdf}}\\ \vspace*{-12pt} \subfloat[Predictive performance (higher is better).\label{fig:gamNormTS_err_vs_t}]{\includegraphics[width=0.9\columnwidth]{gamNormTS_err_vs_t.pdf}}\\ \vspace*{-4pt} \caption{Results for the \gls{GNTS} model.\label{fig:gamNormTS}} \vspace*{-8pt} \end{figure} \begin{figure}[t] \centering \subfloat[Averaged sample variance of the estimator.\label{fig:poissonDEF_varall_vs_t}]{\includegraphics[width=0.9\columnwidth]{poissonDEF_varall_vs_t.pdf}}\\ \vspace*{-7pt} \subfloat[Traceplot of the \gls{ELBO}.\label{fig:poissonDEF_elbo_vs_t}]{\includegraphics[width=0.9\columnwidth]{poissonDEF_elbo_vs_t.pdf}}\\ \vspace*{-12pt} \subfloat[Predictive performance (lower is better).\label{fig:poissonDEF_err_vs_t}]{\includegraphics[width=0.9\columnwidth]{poissonDEF_err_vs_t.pdf}}\\ \vspace*{-4pt} \caption{Results for the Poisson \gls{DEF} model.\label{fig:poissonDEF}} \vspace*{-8pt} \end{figure}

BACKGROUND {#s1} ========== More than 80% of the human genome can be transcribed into RNA during homeostatic or disease-driven cellular responses. However, less than 2% of the human transcriptome is ultimately translated into proteins. The vast, untranslated fraction of the transcriptome includes a remarkable number of functional non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs) \[[@R1]\], comprising the so-called "small non-coding RNAs" (sncRNAs), made up of less than 200 nt. Four major groups of functional sncRNAs have been so far identified in mammals: micro- (miRNAs), PIWI-interacting- (piRNAs), small nucleolar- (snoRNAs) and endogenous small interfering- (endo-siRNAs) RNAs \[[@R2]--[@R5]\]. sncRNAs can exert large-scale and diverse effects on cellular processes by regulating gene expression, protein translation, and genomic organization. The best characterized sncRNAs so far are miRNAs (19--25 nt), known to be involved in post-transcriptional gene expression regulation by inducing mRNA degradation or translation inhibition. To date, more than 2000 human miRNAs have been identified, which are estimated to regulate more than 60% of coding genes \[[@R6]\]. Aberrant expression of miRNAs has been implied in numerous diseases, and miRNA-based therapies are in advanced stages of clinical trials or just starting entering clinic \[[@R7]\]. The sncRNA class defined as piRNAs have been linked to epigenetic and post-transcriptional gene silencing of retrotransposons and other genetic elements. They differ from miRNAs for size (26--31 nt vs. 19--25 nt), lack of sequence conservation and increased complexity \[[@R8]\]. Initial data indicated that PIWI proteins, with whom piRNA interact, had only germline-restricted functions but subsequent research expanded the role of these proteins in somatic tissues. Ectopic and over-expression of HIWIs (the human PIWI proteins) has been associated with several cancer types \[[@R9]--[@R12]\], and inhibition of HIWI expression can stop cancer cell growth \[[@R11]\]. Moreover, an emerging number of studies highlight the role of piRNAs or PIWI proteins in the regulation of tumorigenesis. Cheng et al. \[[@R13]\] demonstrated increased expression of piR-651 in gastric, colon, lung, and breast cancer tissues compared to normal adjacent tissues and down-regulation of piR-823 in gastric cancer tissues compared to normal tissues, suggesting its potential tumor suppressive role \[[@R13], [@R14]\]. Recently, Rizzo et al. \[[@R15]\] described cell cycle phase-specific piRNA regulation in regenerating liver, linked to regulation of growth-related genes, suggesting a role of these sncRNAs in growth control while Hashim et al. \[[@R16]\] showed evidence of an active piRNA pathway in breast cancer. The last class of sncRNA, denominated snoRNAs, are involved in processing and modification of other RNAs, such as ribosomal and small nuclear spliceosomal RNAs. snoRNAs can be divided into two major structural classes, antisense box C/D and box H/ACA snoRNAs, based on the presence of short consensus sequence motifs. Most members of the two snoRNA classes guide the 2′-O-ribose methylations and pseudouridylations, respectively, of rRNA. snoRNAs have long been believed to modify and stabilize rRNAs for ribosome production. Several recent studies demonstrate that deregulation of snoRNAs is a common molecular event in lung carcinogenesis \[[@R17]--[@R19]\]. Endometrial cancer is the most frequent malignant tumor of the female reproductive tract and the fourth (by frequency) malignancy affecting the female population in developed countries \[[@R20], [@R21]\]. Type I endometrial cancer, which is the most frequent uterine malignancy (80% of all cases), consists of tumors of endometrioid histology. Shermann \[[@R22]\] proposed a mechanism by which indolent tumors develop from hyperplastic precursors in an estrogen-rich milieu. Hysteroscopy has an estimated sensitivity of 86.4% in the diagnosis of endometrial hyperplasia or adenocarcinomas \[[@R23]\]. However, hysteroscopic endometrial biopsy had limitations in as diagnostic approach for type I endometrial carcinoma: Peterson et al. \[[@R24]\] report that only 60% of grade I endometrial adenocarcinomas diagnoses based on this method was confirmed on final histopathology. Similarly, the intraoperative evaluation performed on frozen sections showed large discrepancies with the post-operative assessment made on the resected organ, especially in regard to lymphovascular invasion \[[@R25]\]. Altered miRNA expression has been found in endometrial adenocarcinoma \[[@R26]\], including up-regulation of the miR-200 family \[[@R27]\], of miR-205 and miR-210 \[[@R28]\] and miR-135a and miR-135b \[[@R29]\] and downregulaton of miR-133a and miR-133b \[[@R30]\]. Recently, miR-194 received much attention due to its potential prognostic role \[[@R31]\]. Expression of HIWI proteins has been reported in endometrial cancer \[[@R32]\] but the role of piRNAs has not been fully investigated during carcinogenesis \[[@R33], [@R34]\]. In addition, few data are available on the involvement of the other forms of sncRNA, such as snoRNAs, in this pathological process \[[@R35]\]. Next generation sequencing (NGS) provides a high-throughput method for exploring the diverse sncRNAs populations. This approach allows unbiased and accurate identification and quantitation of known and novel miRNAs and other sncRNAs, even when expressed at very low levels, or those exhibiting small differences in expression among samples, which cannot be detected by hybridization-based methods. In the present study, coordinate analyses of sncRNAs and mRNAs expression were performed on samples of type I endometrial cancer biopsy coupled with samples of normal and hyperplastic endometrium obtained from the same patient, followed by functional analysis of the results. This represents an ideal model for the study of sncRNA role in the carcinogenesis process because it is characterized by the availability of healthy, hyperplastic and tumor tissue all taken from a single patient, allowing the comparative genetic analysis of normal and pathological tissues in the same genetic and hormonal background. In this condition it is possible to trace the changes in sncRNA expression occurring during the neoplastic transformation independently from other confounding factors to be taken into account when tissues are collected from different individuals. The changes in sncRNA pattern in a patient is then generalized by means of comparison with changes observed in other patients, making the observations of general validity even if they are carried out in a relatively limited number of cases. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION {#s2} ====================== Characterization of small non-coding RNAs deregulation in tumoral, hyperplastic and normal-adjacent endometrial tissues {#s2_1} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Genome-wide identification of sncRNAs expressed in a given tissue type in both normal and pathologic conditions allows the study of the complex small RNA-mediated regulatory networks and of the modifications imposed by the carcinogenic process. The involvement miRNAs in carcinogenesis has been under investigation since the discovery of distinct expression patterns among different tissues and that their expression changes significantly in cancer tissues compared to normal ones \[[@R36]\]. Although miRNAs are the most studied sncRNAs, the importance of other sncRNAs, in particular snoRNAs and piRNAs is increasingly being recognized but little is known about their deregulation and involvement in the carcinogenesis process. Indeed, although several studies focusing on alterations of miRNA expression in endometrial cancer are available \[[@R37], [@R38]\], genome-wide expression profiling data relative to other sncRNAs in endometrial adenocarcinoma are still missing. Identification of differentially expressed sncRNAs between normal, hyperplastic and tumor tissue is a crucial point for a comprehensive characterization of the carcinogenesis process. We analyzed sncRNAs by next-generation sequencing in type I endometrial cancer samples to evaluate their possible deregulation during carcinogenesis. To this aim, ten patients (indicated as 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 14, 15, 16 & 17) and 3 healthy controls (indicated as 2, 8 & 9) were selected, following initial characterization according to defined clinico-pathological parameters (Table [1](#T1){ref-type="table"} and [Supplementary Figure S1B](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). For each individual, three endometrial biopsies were obtained, when possible, from tumor, hyperplastic and adjacent normal tissue, by means of hysteroscopy. In total we collected ten normal (1N, 2N, 3N, 4N, 5N, 7N, 8N, 9N, 14N, 15N), six hyperplastic (1H, 3H, 4H, 5H, 6H, 7H) and ten tumor tissue samples (1T, 3T, 4T, 5T, 6T, 7T, 14T, 15T, 16T, 17T). Normal samples were collected the farthest possible from the area presenting a hyperplastic or cancerous lesion, to reduce the possibility of cross-contaminations. ###### Characteristics of patients and healthy controls of normal, hyperplastic and neoplastic tissues analyzed Characteristics N° Patients ----------------------- ---- ----------------------------------- Age \>55 7 2,3,6,7,14,15,16 ≤55 6 1,4,5,8,9,17 Tissue Categories Healthy Control 3 2N,8N,9N Normal 7 1N,3N,4N,5N,7N,14N,15N Atypical Hyperplasia 6 1H,3H,4H,5H,6H,7H Endometrioid 10 1T,3T,4T,5T,6T,7T,14T,15T,16T,17T Stage (FIGO) I--II 9 1T,3T,4T,5T,7T,14T,15T,16T,17T III--IV 1 6T Histological grade G1 5 1T,4T,14T,15T,16T G2 3 3T,7T,17T G3 2 5T,6T Lymph node metastasis Positive 1 6T Negative 4 3T,4T,5T,15T Nx 5 1T,7T,14T,16T,17T Stage (TNM) T1 and T2 9 1T,3T,4T,5T,7T,14T,15T,16T,17T T3 and T4 1 6T More than 300 million sequences were obtained by smallRNA-Seq analysis of the 26 samples sequenced, after filtering out low quality reads and trimming the adaptor, with an average of 10 million reads/sample. In all cases we observed a bimodal distribution of read length, with a major size class peaking at 22nt, corresponding to the length of miRNAs, and a smaller one at 28--34 nt, a length compatible with other sncRNAs such as piRNAs. The sequences corresponding to known miRNAs (present in miRBase Release 19) had a similar abundance independently from the tissue, ranging from 67% for the hyperplastic to 72% for the tumor samples (Figure [1A](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). About 2% of reads aligned to known piRNA sequences reported in piRNABank, in agreement with previous reports in other somatic tissues \[[@R15], [@R39]\], and 2% of sequences aligned to Rfam database entries. Overall, we identified 1,268 sncRNAs (1,019 miRNAs, 145 piRNAs and 104 snoRNAs), among which 448 (359 miRNAs, 62 piRNAs and 27 snoRNAs) were found to be expressed at significant level (showing \> 10 RPM in at least three samples). Furthermore, 60%, 66%, 53% of the total miRNAs, piRNAs and snoRNAs repertoire, respectively, was identified by detection of 10 RPM in at least one sample. Interestingly, several piRNAs, such as hsa_piR_020829_DQ598677, hsa_piR_019914_DQ597347 and hsa_piR_016735_DQ593039, displayed a very high level of expression (Mean RPM ≥ 4,500). The full list of identified sncRNAs is available in [Supplementary Table S1](#SD2){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. {#F1} To investigate whether miRNA, piRNA and snoRNA expression patterns changes during endometrial carcinogenesis, differential expression analysis was performed and a pool of sncRNAs specifically deregulated in hyperplastic and tumor tissue was identified in each patient. The results were then combined to define common patterns of sncRNAs deregulation. We identified 276 sncRNAs (239 miRNAs, 25 piRNAs and 12 snoRNAs: Figure [1B, and 1D](#F1){ref-type="fig"} respectively) differentially expressed in at least 50% of the patients, considering \|FC\| ≥1.5, *p*-value 0.05 and base mean read count ≥30. The full list of differentially expressed sncRNAs is available in [Supplementary Table S2](#SD3){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. This dataset represent, to our knowledge, the first comprehensive sncRNA profile in endometrial carcinogenesis, including less characterized classes of sncRNAS that are emerging as new players in cancer and could play important roles in carcinogenesis and tumor progression \[[@R13], [@R19], [@R40]\]. It is worth noting that the miRNA data reported here share many similarities with those previously characterized with different analytical approaches \[[@R38], [@R41]--[@R44]\]. Interestingly, in hyperplastic and neoplastic tissues we observed the over-expression of members of the miR-200 family (has-miR-141, has-miR-200a, has-miR-200b, has-miR-200c, has-miR-141, has-miR-429), which is known to be involved in epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) \[[@R41]\]. Identification of candidate novel miRNAs {#s2_2} ---------------------------------------- Since smallRNA-Seq allows to discover novel sncRNAs still not annotated in public databases, including those occurring at low frequencies \[[@R45]\], sequences not mapping to known mature miRNAs were analyzed with iMir tool (see Materials and Methods) to predict potentially novel miRNAs that could be deregulated in the carcinogenesis process. The reads that aligned against tRNAs or mRNAs (from UCSC Genome Browser), rRNAs or piRNAs (from Nucleotide NCBI database) and other known sncRNAs (from RFam datasets) were excluded prior to the analysis in order to reduce false-positive rate in predicting novel miRNAs. The remaining reads were analyzed by using miRDeep2 algorithm \[[@R45]\], which is able to identify novel miRNAs with high accuracy \[[@R45], [@R46]\]. Potential precursor sequences were then searched *in silico* and tested for their ability to form a characteristic hairpin; the resulting sequences were further analyzed to determine features such as thermodynamics stability, presence of star sequences and phylogenetic conservation \[[@R46]\]. Using these criteria, seven novel miRNAs were identified (Figure [2A, 2B](#F2){ref-type="fig"} left panel and [Supplementary Table S3](#SD4){ref-type="supplementary-material"}), all expressed with more than 30 reads in at least three samples, and, for two of them (candidate miRNA_1 and candidate miRNA_4, Figure [2A](#F2){ref-type="fig"}), with evidence of expression also of the corresponding star sequences. The predicted precursor structure and the sequence of miRNA star corresponding to the novel miRNAs are showed in Figure [2A](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. It is worth noting that the seed regions of 6 novel miRNAs matched with miRNAs of other species (one mismatch) and are broadly conserved among vertebrates, particularly mammals. Moreover, the seed sequences of candidate miRNA_2 and candidate miRNA_3 match those of human miR-886--3p family and miR-1296 family, respectively. All these evidences strongly support the possibility that these small RNAs are authentic endometrial miRNAs. Interestingly, differential expression analysis of these novel miRNA candidates shows a significantly different expression in hyperplasia and/or tumor tissues in at least three patients (\|FC\| ≥ 1.5 and *p*-value ≤ 0.05, Figure [2B](#F2){ref-type="fig"} right panel and [Supplementary Table S3](#SD4){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). {#F2} Identification of sncRNA expression signatures in endometrial carcinogenesis {#s2_3} ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- In order to recognize differential sncRNA expression profile among the three different tissue types, we applied the Kruskal--Wallis (one-way analysis of variance) test on the identified sncRNA expression profiles, including also the 7 novel miRNAs. This led to the definition of a sncRNA signature comprising 129 miRNAs, 2 of which not previously described, 10 piRNAs and 3 snoRNAs, whose expression level (RPM, [Supplementary Table S1](#SD2){ref-type="supplementary-material"}) discriminates tumour from normal endometrial tissues. Indeed, hierarchical clustering analysis (Figure [3A](#F3){ref-type="fig"}) shows a clear separation of cancers and normal tissues, with the exception of samples T1, while hyperplasia result equally distributed between the normal and tumor clusters. The fact that some hyperplastic samples appear more closely related to cancer while other to normal endometrium could relate to heterogeneity of these lesions, due to the existence of different degrees of atypical hyperplasia, undistinguishable with the standard pathological tests available. {#F3} The box plots in Figure [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"} show the behaviour of each piRNA (hsa_piR_001152_DQ571500, hsa_piR_001170_DQ571526, hsa_piR_016658_DQ59293, hsa_piR_017791_DQ594556, hsa_piR_019168_DQ596311, hsa_piR_019354_DQ596587, hsa_piR_019825_DQ597218, hsa_piR_020009_DQ597484, hsa_piR_020496_DQ598175, hsa_piR_020815_DQ598651, Figure [3B](#F3){ref-type="fig"}), snoRNA (RF00334;SNORA3;DAAB012419117.1/548--625, RF00108;SNORD116;AF017338.1/106--15, RF01299;SNORD2;AC010746.8/137147--137213, Figure [3C](#F3){ref-type="fig"}) and new miRNA (candidate miRNA_2 and \_4, Figure [3D](#F3){ref-type="fig"}) in the different sample types. The corresponding *p*-values are reported in [Supplementary Table S4](#SD5){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. Furthermore, differential expression analysis performed on paired sample groups identifies 142 differentially expressed sncRNAs (\|FC\| ≥ 1.5) (Figure [3E](#F3){ref-type="fig"} and [Supplementary Table S4](#SD5){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). In particular, 19 miRNAs, 2 piRNAs and 1 snoRNA result under-expressed and 110 miRNAs (2 new and 108 known), 8 piRNAs and 2 snoRNAs over-expressed in cancerous respect to normal tissues. We also observed some specific trends, shown in Figure [3E](#F3){ref-type="fig"} and summarized as follows: a) 75 sncRNAs over- or under-expressed in both hyperplasia and tumors (Figure [3E-a](#F3){ref-type="fig"}), but more so in the latter respect to the former; b) 28 sncRNAs showing similar differences in the two pathological tissues respect to normal endometrium (Figure [3E-b](#F3){ref-type="fig"}); c) 41 sncRNAs changing significantly only in cancer (Figure [3E-c](#F3){ref-type="fig"}). Functional analyses of the cellular pathways affected by sncRNA dysregulation in endometrial carcinogenesis {#s2_4} ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- As miRNAs modulate posttranscriptionally the targeted mRNAs by binding directly to their 3′-UTR and promoting mRNA degradation or translation inhibition, an increase in the intracellular concentration of a given miRNA may result in reduced levels of the proteins encoded by its target mRNAs. In the case of piRNA, while their main function in the germline is to silence transposons both transcriptionally and post-transcriptionally \[[@R47], [@R48]\], their roles in somatic cells is still unknown. Recently it has been shown that these small RNAs can also bind to mRNAs and thereby control their stability and translation efficiency \[[@R49], [@R50]\], similarly to miRNAs. Based on this evidence, we postulate that the changes in piRNA expression occurring in endometrial carcinogenesis may affect resident mRNA activity and influence downstream endometrial cell functions. To search for mRNA targets of both known and novel sncRNAS comprising the endometrial cancer 'signature' identified here, a gene expression profiling was generated by cDNA microarrays, focusing on the biopsies from the 5 patients for whom the three histotypes were available. An equimolar RNA pool was generated in each case, named Normal (N), Hyperplastic (H) or Tumoral (T) and used for cRNA synthesis and microarray hybridization. Overall, considering \|FC\|≥ 2.0 and *p*-value 0.001 we identified 618 transcripts ([Supplementary Figure S2](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}) which were differentially expressed in at least one paired comparison (hyperplastic *vs* normal, cancer *vs* normal and/or 3: cancer *vs* hyperplastic), out of about 18,500 RNAs detected (detection *p*-value ≤ 0.05). Among them, 302 showed changes in the hyperplastic tissue (203 over- and 99 under-expressed) and 452 the tumor tissue (164 over- and 288 under-expressed) with respect to normal endometrium of the same patients. Interestingly, down-regulated mRNAs where the majority in tumor (63%) compared to hyperplastic (33%) tissues, consistent with the greater percentage of over-expressed miRNAs in the former. Also in this case, it was possible to observe different trends ([Supplementary Figure S2](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}) summarized as follows: a) 205 mRNAs show a similar change, but at different levels, in all the three cases considered (over- or under-expressed in all three comparisons, [Supplementary Figure S2A](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}); b) 177 mRNAs are differentially expressed both in the hyperplastic and in tumor tissue, but without significant differences in the two pathological tissues (over- or under-expressed only in comparisons 1 and 2, [Supplementary Figure S2B](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}); c) 17 mRNAs show opposite behavior, respect to normal endometrium, in hyperplasia compared to tumor ([Supplementary Figure S2C](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}); d) 219 mRNAs showing different expression patterns, including 65 mRNAs differentially expressed only in the tumors and 35 only in hyperplasia ([Supplementary Figure S2D](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). The full list of these transcripts, with relevant information, is available in [Supplementary Table S5](#SD6){ref-type="supplementary-material"}. A functional analysis of transcripts whose level was altered in endometrial cancer reveals that in many cases the proteins they encode are involved in cellular processes characteristic of transformed cells, including in particular cell proliferation, survival and differentiation and cell motility, migration and adhesion. This result is in line with previous observations with similar analyses in endometrial cancer \[[@R51]--[@R53]\]. Interestingly, transcripts for PEG3 (paternally expressed 3, PW1) and SOCS2 (suppressor of cytokine signaling 2, STATI2) were down-regulated, while HOXB7 and HOXB6 mRNAs resulted up-regulated in both the hyperplastic and neoplastic stages. PEG3 is known to be underexpressed in gliomas, as well as in ovarian, breast and other gynecologic cancers \[[@R54]--[@R57]\]. The precise function of the encoded protein is not clear, but several evidences suggest that it may play a role in the p53/c-myc-mediated apoptosis pathway and in Wnt signaling pathway by binding to beta-catenin and promoting its degradation via a p53/Siah1-dependent and GSK3beta-independent proteasomal pathway. This suggests that PEG3 could function as tumor suppressor \[[@R58], [@R59]\]. Also SOCS2 is a tumor suppressor involved in the JAK/Stat signaling pathway, whose deregulation is associated with malignant progression \[[@R60], [@R61]\]. It has been shown that experimental over-expression of SOCS proteins in cancer cells reduces STAT activity, inhibits proliferation and induces apoptosis \[[@R61]--[@R64]\]. The HOX genes comprise a family of homeodomain-containing transcription factors that determine cell identity during development. Aberrant HOX genes expression has been reported to mediate oncogenesis in several human cancers, including hepatocellular \[[@R65]\] and ovarian cancer \[[@R66]\], as well as in acute myeloid leukemia (AML) \[[@R67]\]. These genes play a key role in the inhibition of apoptosis, DNA repair and enhanced cell motility \[[@R68]\]. To explore the biological and functional role exerted by the aberrantly expressed sncRNA of the 'signature' discriminating cancerous from normal endometrial tissues, their downstream mRNA targets were searched *in silico* using different computational approaches. To evaluate their involvement in biological networks, the results were then combined with the gene expression profiling data using Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) tools, as described in Materials and Methods. Putative targets of the two newly identified miRNAs were searched for with TargetScanHuman \[Release5.2, 69\]. This analysis led to the identification of 526 endometrial mRNA targets, including 65 differentially expressed (\|FC\| ≥ 1.5 and *p*-value 0.001) in hyperplastic and/or tumor tissues. Several cellular processes and canonical pathways were found to be potentially affected by these miRNAs, such as cellular development, growth and proliferation, cell cycle (G1/S checkpoint), cellular movement and cell death and survival, TGF-β, ERK/MAPKand Wnt/β-catenin signaling pathways ([Supplementary Table S6](#SD7){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). The search for the putative targets of the piRNA identified in our study was pursued applying a method based on sequence complementarity that allows the prediction of biologically relevant RNA-RNA interactions \[[@R15], [@R49]\] (Figure [3](#F3){ref-type="fig"}). By applying stringent thermodynamic parameters for RNA-RNA binding, each piRNA analyzed was found to be complementary to a number of mRNAs ranging from 28 to 308. In total, 1,526 putative mRNA targets were found among those significantly expressed in our samples, among which 170 resulted to be differentially expressed (\|FC\| ≥ 1.5 and *p*-value 0.001) in hyperplastic and/or tumor tissues. As for miRNA-targeted mRNAS, the proteins encoded by the mRNAs putatively targeted by piRNA are involved in key cellular events highly related to the carcinogenetic process, such as cell death and survival, growth and proliferation, cell to cell signaling, cell cycle and DNA replication ([Supplementary Table S7](#SD8){ref-type="supplementary-material"}), while 38 of them have been already previously associated to endometrial cancer (IPA knowledge database 2014). Finally, the known miRNA targets were searched with the microRNA Target Filter database of Ingenuity suite using experimentally validated interactions from TarBase and miRecords, as well as highly predicted miRNA-mRNA interactions from TargetScan. The 127 miRNAs of interest were grouped in 79 miRNA families (sharing the same seed region) that, combined, can potentially target 8,418 endometrial mRNAs, including 909 differentially expressed (\|FC\| ≥ 1.5 and *p*-value 0.001) in hyperplastic and/or tumor tissues, 60% of which showed FC values inversely correlated with those of the related miRNA ([Supplementary Table S8](#SD9){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Among several over-represented pathways, this analysis confirmed the potential effect of these sncRNAs on cell cycle regulation and ERK/MAPK, JAK/Stat and Wnt/β-catenin signaling pathways ([Supplementary Table S9](#SD10){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). Concerning the last pathway, it is interesting that 6 over-expressed sncRNAs (piR_020496_DQ598175, Candidate miR-4, miR-103--3p, miR-155--5p, miR-16--5p and miR-17--5p can all target the down-regulated TLE4 (transducin-like enhancer of split 4), a transcriptional corepressor that binds to a number of transcription factors in this cascade. Interestingly, 9 over-expressed miRNA families (miR-186--5p, miR-205--5p, miR-181a-5p, miR-9--5p, miR-141--3p, miR-155--5p and miR-135a-5p) target the down-regulated PEG3, which results strongly repressed in both hyperplastic and tumor tissues (see above). This finding suggests a possible role for down-regulation of this oncosuppressor in endometrioid cancers. Concerning the aforementioned down-regulated SOCS1 and SOCS2, we found that the first is targeted by miR-22--3p and hsa-miR-155--5p \[miRNAs w/seed UAAUGCU, experimentally observed target, 70\], while the second is a target of miR-30e-5p, all over-expressed in our tumoral samples. As a further example of the information provided by the present data, we found that the up regulated miR-181a-5p, miR-27a-3p and hsa-miR-107, miR-103--3p, hsa-miR-200a-3p, miR-141--3p, miR-203--3p, miR-27a-3p, miR-425--5p, miR-96--5p all target the down-regulated SEMA3B and SEMA6A mRNAs. Interestingly, these are encoded by two genes belonging to the axon-guidance family, that plays a critical role in the guidance of growth cones during neuronal development, and both have been shown to be inactivated in human cancers, where they have been proposed to act as tumor suppressor genes by inducing apoptosis \[[@R71]\]. These data reveal that miRNAs (known and novel) and piRNAs can exert a synergic modulation of several signaling pathways, such as ERK/MAPK, TGF-β and Wnt/β-catenin, whose activation is already occurring in the hyperplastic lesion but becomes more pronounced in the neoplastic tissue (Figure [4](#F4){ref-type="fig"} and [Supplementary Figure S3 A-E](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). {#F4} In conclusion, our sequencing analysis has identified a novel sncRNA signature encompassing different sub-classes of deregulated small RNAs, differentiating normal form hyperplastic and tumoral endometrium. This large dataset can provide key information on the molecular mechanisms of carcinogenesis. Furthermore, it can be exploited to identify biomarkers that may assist in the early and non-invasive diagnosis of human endometrial cancers. MATERIALS AND METHODS {#s3} ===================== Patients and tissue collection {#s3_1} ------------------------------ Patients were subjected to transvaginal ultrasound and office hysteroscopy in the Departments of Obstetrics and Gynecology of the University of Salerno (Salerno, Italy) and University of Naples Federico II (Naples, Italy). Endometrial biopsies from tumor (T), adjacent normal (N) and hyperplastic (H) tissue specimens (when available) from 10 patients and Normal endometrial tissue from 3 healthy donors were selected for this study ([Supplementary Figure S1A](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"}). As healthy donors, patients who underwent hysteroscopy for abnormal uterine bleeding (AUB) non related to cancer pathology were recruited. Median age was 58 year old (range 32--84). 9 patients had stage I--II disease and 1 had stage III disease. 8 cases were G1-G2 and 2 were G3-G4. See Table [1](#T1){ref-type="table"} and [Supplementary Figure S1B](#SD1){ref-type="supplementary-material"} for more detailed clinical characteristics of patients. The tissues were kept on dry ice at all times during tissue sampling and handling. The histology of each tumor was classified according to World Health Organization criteria, whereas surgical staging followed International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) standards (FIGO 2009). The ethics committee of Azienda Ospedaliera Ospedali Riuniti S. Giovanni e Ruggi d\'Aragona di Salerno approved this study and informed consent was obtained from all patients. RNA isolation and quality controls {#s3_2} ---------------------------------- Tissue specimens samples were distrupted and homogenaized using TissueLyser LT (Qiagen). Total RNA was extracted with miRVana RNA isolatin Kit (Ambion) according manufacturers protocol. Before use, RNA concentration in each sample was assayed with a ND-1000 spectrophotometer (NanoDrop) and its quality assessed with the Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer with Agilent RNA 6000 nano kit (Agilent Technologies). Small RNA sequencing and data analysis {#s3_3} -------------------------------------- 1 μg of total RNA was used in a library preparation according to the Illumina TruSeq small RNA sample preparation protocol (Illumina, USA). Sized smallRNA libraries were gel purified and sequenced on HiSeq 1500 (Illumina, USA) at a concentration of 10pM for 50 plus 7 additional cycles for indexes sequencing. Each library was sequenced in three technical replicate. The data obtained from the sequencer were analyzed using iMir, a modular pipeline for comprehensive analysis of small RNA-Seq data, comprising specific tools for adapter trimming, quality filtering, identification of known sncRNAs, novel miRNA prediction, differential expression analysis and target prediction \[[@R72], [@R73]\]. Reads from technical replicates were summed and normalized using reads per million method (RPM). To minimize spurious detection due to sequencing errors sncRNAs have been considered as expressed when they were detected by at least ≥ 10 RPM reads (75th percentile of RPM values) per sncRNA, corresponding approximately to 100 reads for an average library. Heatmaps showing the expression level (RPM) were generated with R software after performing one-way hierarchical clustering of sncRNAs with the Kendall rank correlation. Identification of differentially expressed sncRNAs was performed with the Bioconductor DESeq package available in iMir tool \[[@R72], [@R73]\]. A negative binomial distribution model was used to test differential expression in deep sequencing datasets. Data were filtered according to read count value (threshold: 10 reads) and those showing fold-change ≤−1.5 or ≥1.5 (\|FC\| ≥1.5), with a *p*-value ≤ 0.05 were considered as differentially expressed. The reads of the 3 patients from whom we do not have the normal tissue but only the tumoral one (6T, 16T & 17T) were pooled and compared with the read pool of the 3 healthy controls (2N, 8N & 9N) and indicated in the figures as Others. Heatmaps showing the fold-change of differentially expressed sncRNAs were generated with the Multiexperiment Viewer 4.9 software (TM4). The RPM data were statistically analyzed using the Kruskal--Wallis test (*p*-value ≤0.01). Two-way cluster analysis was carried out using R software for Kendall rank correlation. Detection of other sncRNAs and novel miRNAs prediction was performed with Module 3 of the iMir tool (miRanalyzer and miRDeep2) \[[@R72]\]. Putative piRNA target RNAs were identified by sequence complementarity between each piRNA (piRNABank, Institute of Bioinformatics and Applied Biotechnology, Bangalore, India) and the 5′-UTRs, CDSs or 3′-UTRs of all known human RNAs (RefSeq gene annotations), using miRanda v3.3a \[[@R74]\], an algorithm for detection of potential small RNA binding sites in RNAs, applying stringent alignment score (sc; ≥170) and energy threshold (en; ≤−20.0 kcal/mol). The functional analyses were generated through the use of IPA (Ingenuity Systems, <http://www.ingenuity.com>) to identify the biological processes that are significantly associated (*p*-value ≤0.05) with mRNAs targeted by piRNAs, as previously described \[[@R15]\]. Raw small non-coding RNA sequencing data have been deposited, in a format complying with the Minimum Information about a high-throughput SeQuencing Experiment (MINSEQE) guidelines in the EBI ArrayExpress database (<http://www.ebi.ac.uk/arrayexpress>) with Accession Number E-MTAB-2795. Microarray and data analysis {#s3_4} ---------------------------- 3 RNA pool were generated for each tissue type: Normal (samples: 1N, 3N, 4N, 5N, 7N), Hyperplastic (samples: 1H, 3H, 4H, 5H, 7H) and Tumoral (samples: 1T, 3T, 4T, 5T, 7T). Gene expression profiling was performed using 500 ng of each RNA Pool as described before \[[@R73]\]. For each Pool, 750 ng of cRNA were hybridized for 18 hrs at 55°C on Illumina HumanHT-12 v4.0 BeadChips (Illumina Inc.), according to the manufacturer\'s instructions and subsequently scanned with the Illumina iSCAN. Data analyses were performed with GenomeStudio software version 2011.1 (Illumina Inc.). Data was normalized with the quantile algorithm and genes were considered as detected if the detection *p*-value was lower than 0.01. Statistical significance was calculated with the Illumina DiffScore, a proprietary algorithm that uses the bead standard deviation to build an error model. Only genes with a DiffScore ≤−30 and ≥ 30, corresponding to a *p*-value of 0.001, were considered as statistically significant. Heat Maps were generated with the Multiexperiment Viewer 4.9 software (TM4) after performing one way hierarchical clustering of transcripts with the average linkage method and Euclidian distance. Raw microarray data have been deposited, in a format complying with the Minimum Information About a Microarray Gene Experiment (MIAME) guidelines of the Microarray Gene Expression Data Society (MGED), in the EBI ArrayExpress database (<http://www.ebi.ac.uk/arrayexpress>) with Accession Number E-MTAB-2796. Enriched pathways and bibliographic networks discovery {#s3_5} ------------------------------------------------------ miRNA target prediction was performed using Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA, Ingenuity Systems). The dataset was mined for significant pathways with the IPA library of canonical pathways, and networks were generated by using IPA as graphical representation of the molecular relationships between genes and gene products. The significance of the association between the list of differentially expressed genes, miRNAs and the Canonical Pathway was measured using a Fisher\'s exact test to calculate a *p*-value (*p* ≤ 0.05). Fisher\'s exact test results were also corrected for multiple testing using FDR. SUPPLEMENTARY FIGURES {#s4} ===================== Work supported by: Italian Ministry of Health (Grant Young Researcher GR-2011--02350476 to M.R.), Italian Ministry for Education, University and Research (Grants PRIN 2010LC747T to A.W. and FIRB RBFR12W5V5_003 to R.T.), Italian Association for Cancer Research (Grants IG-13176 to A.W.), National Research Council Flagship Project Interomics, University of Salerno (FARB 2012). M.R. is supported by a 'Vladimir Ashkenazy' fellowship of the Italian Association for Cancer Research, G.N. is supported by a 'Mario e Valeria Rindi' fellowship of the Italian Foundation for Cancer Research, G.B. is a PhD student of the Research Doctorate 'System Biology', University of Salerno, C.S. is a PhD student of the Research Doctorate in 'Molecular Oncology, Experimental Immunology and Innovative Therapy Development', University of Catanzaro 'Magna Graecia', A.R. is a PhD student of the Research Doctorate 'Molecular and Translational Oncology and Innovative Medical-Surgical Technologies', University of Catanzaro 'Magna Graecia'. We thank Cristiana Stellato from Department of Medicine and Surgery, University of Salerno, for her helpful comments on the manuscript. **Competing interests** The authors declare no conflict of interests.

Canine rabies globally causes an estimated 55,000 human deaths each year; 23,750 (≈43%) of which occur in Africa ([@R1]). To eliminate rabies virus in dog populations, and thus reduce the risk for human rabies, the World Health Organization (WHO) recommends dog rabies vaccination coverage of 70% ([@R2]). However, in most sub-Saharan countries, per capita expenditures on human health care are typically \<\$50/year ([@R3]), which makes securing funding to achieve the WHO target for dog vaccination challenging. One way to fund dog rabies vaccination programs is to charge owners a fee for each dog vaccinated. However, the higher the fee, the lower the compliance is likely to be. To estimate the association between the amount charged to dog owners and the probability of vaccination (i.e., vaccination coverage), we collected data from 3 observational studies (2001, 2002, 2006) and 1 survey of dog owners (2006) (*4,7*; Table). We then estimated the maximum amount that could be charged to owners (cost recovery) and still achieve a minimum of 70% of dogs vaccinated. The Study ========= We used data collected in the capital of Chad, N'Djaména, which in 2001 had a human population of ≈776,000 and a dog population of ≈23,600 ([@R4]). Dog rabies is endemic to Chad; before the vaccination campaigns, the prevalence of dog rabies was ≈1.4--1.7 cases/1,000 unvaccinated dogs ([@R5],[@R6]). We obtained direct observations of the association between compliance (i.e., percentage of dogs vaccinated) and amount charged to owners from 2 pilot dog vaccination campaigns held in N'Djaména in 2002 and 2006 (*7*; unpub. data). Both campaigns followed similar protocols. Each campaign covered the same 3 city quarters, which had high-density dog populations ([@R4]). Only owned animals were vaccinated, but owned dogs comprise 90%--99% of all dogs in N'Djaména ([@R7]). Owners brought their animals (dogs, cats, monkeys) to 1 of 10 vaccination sites. In the 2002 campaign, vaccinations were free to owners ([@R7]); in the 2006 campaign, owners were charged 2,000 CFA francs (US \$3.88)/animal vaccinated (unpub. data). (Exchange rate US \$1 = 515.71 CFA francs as of February 2007; [www.oanda.com/convert/classic](http://www.oanda.com/convert/classic)) For each campaign, the percentage of dogs vaccinated was estimated by using a capture--recapture method (*7*; unpub. data). For the 2002 free-to-owners campaign, 71%--87% (95% confidence interval \[CI\] 64%--89%; mean 79%) of all dogs (owned and unowned) were vaccinated in 2 of the zones (1 zone per quarter) included in the campaign ([@R7]). For the 2006 campaign, in which owners were charged, the mean vaccination coverage among all dogs was estimated at 24% (95% CI 0.13%--24.82%) (unpub. data). Vaccination rates for owned dogs averaged only 78% and 25% in the 2002 and 2006 campaigns, respectively (*7*; unpub. data). For this study, we used the latter estimates because we were interested in measuring owner compliance to charges for dog vaccination. Additional observational data were obtained from a household survey conducted in 2001 ([@R4]), which recorded that 19% of owned dogs were vaccinated against rabies. Such vaccinations would have been given at private clinics (i.e., without a campaign). The charge for such vaccinations at the urban government-run veterinary clinic and the 3 private veterinary practices of N'Djaména was 3,000--5,000 CFA francs (US \$5.82--\$9.69). We used the midpoint of such charges (i.e., 4,000 CFA francs). We did not inflate the 2001 charges because we encountered problems identifying an appropriate conversion factor that considered veterinary medical services. During the 2006 campaign we surveyed dog owners by using a short questionnaire ([Technical Appendix](#SD1){ref-type="local-data"}). The survey was conducted in the vaccination zones; households (containing at least 1 animal) were chosen randomly. The questions (written in French) were translated, when needed, into local languages by 4 interviewers. One question asked owners how much they were willing to pay for the vaccination of their animals. We graphed the 3 observational data points (assuming a straight-line interpolation between points) and the reverse cumulative probability of the owner-stated amounts that they would be willing to pay for their animal to be vaccinated against rabies ([Figure](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). An initial statistical (regression) analysis of the relationship between the amounts that owners said they would pay and the variables collected during the survey ([Table](#T1){ref-type="table"}) provided an adjusted *r*^2^ value of 0.07 (data not shown). We did not perform additional statistical analyses. {#F1} ###### Characteristics of 356 persons interviewed and their households, N'Djaména, Chad, 2006 Characteristic No. (%) ------------------------------------ ---------- No. persons/household 1--10 230 (65) 11--20 107 (30) 21--30 10 (3) 30--35 1 (0) Unknown 8 (2) Gender of persons interviewed\* Female 165 (46) Male 190 (53) Unknown 1 (1) No. animals/household Dogs 0 7 (2) 1 278 (78) 2 65 (18) 3 6 (2) Cats 0 341 (96) 1 14 (4) 2 1 (0) Monkeys 0 346 (97) 1 10 (3) Age of animals, y \<1 101 (22) 1--\<3 155 (34) 3--\<6 134 (30) [\>]{.ul}6 48 (11) Unknown 12 (3) Average 3.37 Sex of animals Male 346 (77) Female 101 (22) Unknown 3 (1) Animals vaccinated [\>]{.ul}1 time Yes 314 (70) Within past year† 197 (44) Vaccinated during a campaign 121 (27) No 132 (29) Unknown 4 (1) \*Mean age of persons interviewed 33.7 y (range 13--80 y).
†Confirmed by inspection of certificate of vaccination. Interviewed households provided 356 questionnaires from which we estimated owner-stated willingness-to-pay for pet vaccination and calculated the resultant reverse cumulative probability of having their animal vaccinated. When asked how much they would be willing to pay, 5 (1%) owners stated that they were against vaccination. We interpreted that response to indicate that such owners would, essentially, have to be paid to have their animals vaccinated. When the proposed cost of vaccination was [\<]{.ul}1,500 CFA francs/animal vaccinated, owners were more likely to state that they would pay to have their pet vaccinated than they were to actually do it. The stated values and observed values were closest at 2,000 CFA francs (≈25% probability of animal being vaccinated) ([Figure](#F1){ref-type="fig"}). This finding was probably because the questionnaire was administered immediately after the campaign in which owners were charged 2,000 CFA francs/animal vaccinated. For \>2,000 CFA francs, the observed values indicated that compliance would be greater than that stated by owners' responses to the willingness-to-pay question. The [Figure](#F1){ref-type="fig"} shows that to achieve a minimum of 70% of owned animals vaccinated, the maximum amount that could be charged would be ≈400 CFA francs (US \$0.78) (observed values) to ≈700 CFA francs (US \$1.36) (owner-stated values). Because the data shown in the [Figure](#F1){ref-type="fig"} reflect owned animals only, to get vaccination coverage up to 70% of all animals (owned and stray), vaccination rates among owned animals would have to be \>70%. To attain these higher rates, charges would have to be even lower than 400--700 CFA francs. Conclusions =========== Few studies have compared what members of the general public state they are willing to pay for a public health intervention with their actual observed behavior ([@R8]). Direct comparison between stated and observed behavior, as influenced by charges to owner, provides public health officials with an understanding of the reliability of owner surveys. Our study and the data used have several limitations. First, the sample sizes were quite small ([@R6],[@R7]). Furthermore, to maintain dog vaccination rates at the WHO-recommended rate of 70%, dog vaccination campaigns would have to be held every 1--6 years, which could reduce compliance. The survey was, by design, short, but a longer questionnaire may have allowed us to better identify why 75% of respondents did not wish to pay \>500 CFA francs (US \$0.97). To achieve the WHO-recommended goal, public health officials cannot charge owners more than the equivalent of 400 CFA francs (US \$0.78). Full-cost recovery concepts will not ensure that enough dogs are vaccinated in Chad (or, most likely, other African countries) to interrupt rabies transmission in dogs in urban areas. Clearly, to have [\>]{.ul}70% of all dogs vaccinated, public health officials and policy makers must consider methods to substantially subsidize dog rabies vaccinations. Supplementary Material ====================== ###### Technical Appendix Owner Valuation of Rabies Vaccination of Dogs, Chad *Suggested citation for this article*: Dürr S, Meltzer MI, Mindekem R, Zinsstag J. Dog-owner valuation of rabies vaccination, Chad. Emerg Infect Dis \[serial on the Internet\]. 2008 Oct \[*date cited*\]. Available from <http://www.cdc.gov/EID/content/14/10/1650.htm> We thank all collaborating international institutions, other collaborators, and campaign workers for successful teamwork. Many thanks are also due to the sponsors of this study: The Swiss Federal Veterinary Office, the Wolfermann-Nägeli Foundation, the Commission for Research Partnership with Developing Countries, and the Emilia Guggenheim-Schnurr Foundation. We also thank the Swiss National Centre of Competence in Research North-South for the cofunding of J.Z. Merial donated the canine antirabies vaccine, for which we are grateful. Dr Dürr is a veterinarian at the Swiss Tropical Institute of Basel. Her research interests include the epidemiology of infectious diseases, particularly zoonotic diseases.

\subsection*{Introduction} The construction of a local and Lorentz invariant field theory for interacting massive spin 2 particles has long been an interesting academic question. It is cosmologically interesting too which modifies the behavior of gravity at long distances and offer a dynamical explanation for the late time accelerated expansion of the Universe. Applying the effective field theory view on a theory of massive gravity \cite{ArkaniHamed:2002sp}, the authors of \cite{deRham:2010ik,deRham:2010kj} constructed a potential contribution to the Einstein-Hilbert action which gives graviton a mass and modifies the dynamics of General Relativity in the IR limit. This fully non-linear theory ({\it a.k.a.} dRGT theory) propagates five degrees of freedom for each polarization of massive spin 2 particle and avoids the Boulware-Deser ghost excitation \cite{Boulware:1973my} by carefully tuning interactions \cite{deRham:2010ik,deRham:2010kj,Hassan:2011hr,Hassan:2011ea}. The existence of a fiducial fixed Minkowski metric in the dRGT theory, breaks diffeomorphism invariance of the Einstein-Hilbert action and makes longitudinal/Goldstone modes dynamical. However being derivatively coupled, the Goldstone interactions grow with energy and get stronger that eventually break perturbation theory at some scale. This cut-off scale of the effective field theory is simply determined by computing the tree level scattering amplitudes and seeing when it hits the unitarity bound. Around Minkowski spacetime, the cut off is $\Lambda_3=(m^2m_{\rm Pl})^{1/3}$ which is unacceptably low about $10^{-13}$ eV for phenomenologically motivated value for the graviton mass $m\sim H_0\sim 10^{-33}$ eV. The common lore is that this low energy effective field theory must be extended at higher energies to its UV completion with possibly new degrees of freedom. On the one hand, one would wonder if the Lorentz invariant massive gravity could have a Lorentz invariant UV completion. Recently, a nice study showed that there is a region in the parameter space of the dRGT theory where it is indeed possible \cite{Cheung:2016yqr}. In fact by computing four particles forward scattering amplitudes it is shown that analyticity and unitarity conditions are satisfied within this window. On the other hand, in the case of massive non-Abelian gauge theories, the Higgs mechanism is responsible for dynamical symmetry breaking and giving mass to vector fields in a weakly coupled regime. Furthermore, it UV completes the theory by introducing a heavy extra Higgs mode. Analogously, one would wonder if there is a microscopic theory which leads to the dRGT theory through spontaneous gauge symmetry breaking and dynamically generates mass. In order to approach this idea, one first needs to formulate gravity as a gauge theory and then construct a mechanism for dynamical symmetry breaking. Gauge theory for gravity has a long history and many attempts were made to construct a model (see \cite{Utiyama:1956sy,Kibble:1961ba,Sciama:1964wt,MacDowell:1977jt,Chamseddine:1976bf,Hayashi:1979wj,Ivanov:1981wn,Ivanenko:1984vf,Hehl:1994ue}). However, a satisfactory symmetry breaking mechanism to produce massive graviton (\`{a} l{a} dRGT) in still lacking (see \cite{Percacci:1984ai,Percacci:1990wy,Kirsch:2005st,tHooft:2007rwo,Chamseddine:2010ub,Alberte:2010it,Alberte:2010qb,Dubovsky:2004sg} for previous attempts). In this note, we propose a dynamical mechanism through which the spin 2 particles receive mass. We start from a topological action which is invariant under local Poincare transformations times diffeomorphisms. The Poincare group is especially motivated as it is the symmetry of Minkowski spacetime that well approximates the visible Universe. The dynamical fields are gauge connections plus spacetime scalars in vector and singlet representations of the Lorentz group. We show that there exist a Higgs phase where scalars (and derivative of them) receive non-zero vacuum expectations values and thereby breaks the gauge symmetry to a diagonal Lorentz subgroup. In this phase we find the Einstein-Hilbert action plus the dRGT potential terms. Around this vacuum there are 5 degrees of freedom of a massive spin 2 particle, 3 of which are Goldstone modes from the extra vector, and a massive healthy heavy Higgs mode. The Boulware-Deser ghost is removed in the special form of the potential. The Higgs excitation can help to improve the UV behavior of longitudinal polarizations of the massive tensor mode. Finally, we show that the action can be derived from a simpler looking topological de Sitter invariant action. \paragraph*{The dRGT Potential Terms} Before we move on to introduce the action we briefly review the dRGT theory \cite{deRham:2010ik,deRham:2010kj}. Through careful tuning of all possible interactions, a fully non-linear theory for massive graviton has been proposed which propagates 5 healthy degrees of freedom \cite{Hassan:2011hr,Hassan:2011ea}. In terms of vierbein 1-forms $e^a=e^a_\mu {\rm d}x^\mu$ and a unit 1-form ${\bf 1}^a=\delta^a_\mu{\rm d}x^\mu$ the potential can be written into an interesting form as follows \cite{Hinterbichler:2012cn} \begin{eqnarray}\label{dRGT-potential} \frac{-V^{\rm dRGT}}{m^2m_{\rm Pl}^2} &=& \frac{b_1}{6}\epsilon^{abcd}e^a\wedge e^b\wedge e^c\wedge {\bf 1}^d\cr &+&\frac{b_2}{4}\epsilon^{abcd}e^a\wedge e^b\wedge {\bf 1}^c\wedge {\bf 1}^d\cr &+&\frac{b_3}{6}\epsilon^{abcd}e^a\wedge {\bf 1}^b\wedge {\bf 1}^c\wedge {\bf 1}^d, \end{eqnarray} where $m$ is the graviton mass given that $b_1+2b_2+b_3 = 1$. This particular form of the potential gives a constraint that projects out the ghost-like degree of freedom. The cosmological constant term can also be added to the above potential as $(b_0/4!)\epsilon_{abcd} e^a\wedge e^b\wedge e^c\wedge e^d$. \vspace*{-1mm} \subsection*{The Action} We start with a topological gauge theory which is invariant under local Poincare transformations and spacetime diffeomorphisms $ISO(1,3)\times${\it Diff}. Needless to say with no metric in the action, diffeomorphism invariance is essentially topological invariance. The Poincare group is an internal group and diffeomorphisms act over 4 dimensional base (spacetime) manifold. No metric structure on the base manifold is assumed a priori, however, it can be defined a posteriori. The action reads as \begin{eqnarray}\label{Poincare-action} S = l\epsilon_{abcd}\int_{\cal M} &c_1&\varphi R^{ab}\wedge R^{cd} \nonumber\\ +&c_2& \varphi R^{ab}\wedge({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi^d+\varphi e^d) \nonumber\\ +&c_3& \varphi({\rm D}\phi^a+\varphi e^a)\wedge({\rm D}\phi^b+\varphi e^b)\nonumber\\&&\qquad\qquad \wedge ({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\wedge({\rm D}\phi^d+\varphi e^d)\nonumber\\ -2 &c_2&R^{ab} \wedge ({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\wedge {\rm d}\varphi \phi^d \nonumber\\ -4 &c_3&({\rm D}\phi^b+\varphi e^b)\wedge({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c\big) \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad \wedge({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\wedge {\rm d}\varphi \phi^d\nonumber\\ -l\int_{\cal M}&g&(\varphi^2-v^2)^2\Lambda_4 .\end{eqnarray} The dynamical fields are Lorentz $\omega^{ab}$ and translation $e^a$ 1-form connections (gauge fields for respective transformations) as well as Lorentz vector $\phi^a$ and singlet $\varphi$ 0-forms. $R={\rm D}\omega$ is the curvature 2-form of the Lorentz connection and D = d+$\omega$ is the Lorentz covariant derivative. In the potential term, $\Lambda_4$ is a dimensionless Lagrange multiplier 4-form, $v$ is a dimensionful parameter and $g$ is a self-coupling. For simplicity we assume $\phi^a$ are dimensionless and $\varphi$ has mass dimension 1. A length scale $l$ is introduced to make $c_1$, $c_2$ $c_3$ dimensionless constants. They will later be absorbed in observables. $\epsilon$ is the totally anti-symmetric invariant of $SO(1,3)$ and little Latin indices run from 0 to 3. Furthermore, the fields transform under local Poincare transformation as follows \begin{eqnarray}\label{trans-omega} \delta\omega^a\!_b &=& {\rm D}\lambda^a\!_b,\\ \label{trans-e}\delta e^a &=& \lambda^a\!_b e^b-{\rm D}\varepsilon^a,\\ \label{trans-phi}\delta\phi^a &=& \lambda^a\!_b\phi^b -\varepsilon^a\varphi,\\ \label{trans-varphi}\delta\varphi &=& 0,\end{eqnarray} which leave the action intact. $\lambda$ and $\varepsilon$ are parameters of Lorentz transformations and translations respectively. It is useful to note that there are 45 (=24+16+4+1) degrees of freedom. There are 10+4 gauge conditions, 4 constraints and 24 on-shell conditions from equations of motion (see below) which removes 42 degrees of freedom. There remain 2+1 decoupled propagating degrees of freedom. Compared to General Relativity, there are 4 St\"{u}ckelberg fields for local translations $\phi^a$ which are total gauge redundancies and the singlet $\varphi$. \paragraph*{The Equations of Motion} The equation of motion of the scalar $\varphi$ reads as follows (group indices and $\epsilon$ are removed for brevity) \begin{eqnarray}\label{vphi-eom} 0 &=& -2g\Lambda_4\varphi(\varphi^2-v^2)\nonumber\\%-\alpha\Lambda_4\phi\phi\phi\phi\nonumber\\ &+& c_1 R\wedge R \nonumber\\ &+& c_2R\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \nonumber\\ &+& c_3 ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\nonumber\\ &+& 2 c_2 \varphi R\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge e\nonumber\\ &+& 4 c_3 \varphi ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge e,\nonumber\\ &-& 2 c_2 \phi \varphi R \wedge e \wedge {\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &-&12 c_3 \phi\varphi ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge e \wedge {\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &+& 2c_2 R\wedge (R\phi+\varphi T+{\rm d}\varphi\wedge e)\phi \nonumber\\ &+& 2c_2 R\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge {\rm D}\phi\nonumber\\ &+& 12c_3 ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge (R\phi+\varphi T+{\rm d}\varphi\wedge e)\phi\nonumber\\ &+& 4c_3 ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge {\rm D}\phi.\end{eqnarray} The equation of motion of $\phi^a$ fields is derived as \begin{eqnarray}\label{phi-eom} 0&=& -2c_2R\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge {\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &-& 4c_3 ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge {\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &-& 2c_2 \varphi R \wedge (R\phi+\varphi T + {\rm d}\varphi\wedge e)\nonumber\\ &-& 12c_3 \varphi({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge (R\phi+\varphi T + {\rm d}\varphi\wedge e)\nonumber\\ &+& 2 c_2 R\wedge {\rm d}\varphi\wedge {\rm D}\phi\nonumber\\ &+& 12 c_3 \phi ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge (R\phi+\varphi T + {\rm d}\varphi\wedge e)\wedge {\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &+& 4 c_3 ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) \wedge {\rm d}\varphi\wedge {\rm D}\phi.\end{eqnarray} The equation of motion of connection $e^a$ is computed as \begin{eqnarray}\label{e-eom} 0&=& 2c_2 \varphi\varphi R\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\nonumber\\ &+& 4c_3 \varphi\varphi ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\nonumber\\ &-& 2c_2 \varphi\phi R\wedge {\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &-& 12 c_3\varphi\phi ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge {\rm d}\varphi.\end{eqnarray} Finally, the equation of motion of the connection $\omega^{ab}$ is \begin{eqnarray}\label{omega-eom} 0&=& 2c_2\varphi\phi R\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\nonumber\\ &+& 4c_3\varphi\phi({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\nonumber\\ &-& 2c_2 \phi\phi R\wedge {\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &-& 12 c_3\phi\phi ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge{\rm d}\varphi\nonumber\\ &-&c_1{\rm d}\varphi\wedge R \nonumber\\ &-&c_2{\rm d}\varphi\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\nonumber\\ &-&2c_2\varphi({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge(R\phi+\varphi T + {\rm d}\varphi\wedge e)\nonumber\\ &+& 2c_2({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge{\rm d}\varphi\wedge{\rm D}\phi\nonumber\\ &+& 2c_2 (R\phi+\varphi T + {\rm d}\varphi\wedge e)\wedge {\rm d}\varphi\phi.\end{eqnarray} \paragraph*{The General Relativity Gauge} We can use the translational part of the gauge symmetry to choose a gauge in which $\phi^a=0$. Then, the action \eqref{Poincare-action} reduces to the Einstein-Hilbert action plus Euler term plus cosmological constant. Given that $\varphi=v$ one finds $m_{\rm Pl}^2=2lc_2v^3$ and $\Lambda_{cc} = c_3lv^4$. Now $e^a$ can be interpreted as the vierbein and the spacetime metric can be defined as $e^a_\mu e^b_\nu\eta_{ab}$. In this limit the action is invariant under the residual local Lorentz transformations and diffeomorphisms which are indeed the gauge symmetries of General Relativity. \subsection*{Masses from Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking} Now we study the vacuum solution in which the local symmetries of the action \eqref{Poincare-action} is spontaneously broken in the following pattern \begin{equation} ISO(1,3)\times {\it Diff} \rightarrow SO(1,3)_D,\end{equation} where $SO(1,3)_D$ is a diagonal subgroup of and the Lorentz group and an $SO(1,3)\subset GL(4)\subset {\it Diff}$ (Similar symmetry breaking pattern has been studied in \cite{Goon:2014paa,Gabadadze:2013ria} in the framework of non-linear realization. However, no dynamical mechanism is presented there). We are interested in solutions where $\varphi$ receives a vacuum expectation value by the potential term \begin{equation} \langle \varphi\rangle = v.\end{equation} In this vacuum, the equation of motion of $e^a$ \eqref{e-eom} implies \begin{eqnarray}\label{sol-e} c_2 R + 2c_3 ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e) &=& 0.\end{eqnarray} Using that, the equation of motion of $\omega^{ab}$ \eqref{omega-eom} gives \begin{equation}\label{sol-omega} R^{ab}\phi_b+T^a \varphi = 0.\end{equation} Given \eqref{sol-e} and \eqref{sol-omega} the equation of motion of $\phi^a$ \eqref{e-eom} is solved with no extra constraint. Finally, the equation of motion of $\varphi$ requires that \begin{equation}\label{sol-vphi} 2c_1 R + c_2 ({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)\wedge({\rm D}\phi+\varphi e)=0.\end{equation} It can be seen that \eqref{sol-e} and \eqref{sol-vphi} put a constraint on the action parameters as \begin{equation} \label{constant-relation} 4c_1c_3=c_2^2.\end{equation} Eventually, we need to solve a single equation \eqref{sol-e}. It can be seen there is a stable non-trivial solution to \eqref{sol-e} such that \begin{equation}\label{the-solution} \langle{\rm D}\phi^a \rangle = u^{(a)}\, {\bf 1}^a,\end{equation} where ${\bf 1}^a$ is a constant 1-form. For instance on torsion free spacetime $T^a=0$ (thus $\phi^a$ is a covariantly constant vector) we have ${\rm d}e^a = c^{abc}(x)e^b\wedge e^c$ so $\omega^{ab} = g^{abc}(x)e^c$ and thus $R^{ab}=f^{abcd}(x)e^c\wedge e^d$. Then, equation \eqref{sol-e} implies that $u$ has to be a constant and furthermore fixes $(c_3/c_2)=F(u,v)$. In components we can write \eqref{the-solution} as $\langle D_\mu\phi^a \rangle = u\, \delta_\mu^a$. This solutions obviously breaks Lorentz invariant and diffeomorphisms. However, the break down of Lorentz symmetry can be compensated by the rotation part of diffeomorphisms such that a diagonal subgroup survives. Now it can be seen that the dRGT potential is obtained in the following form from dynamical symmetry breaking \begin{eqnarray}\label{potential} -V = lc_3v \epsilon_{abcd}(u^{(a)}{\bf 1}^a + ve^a)&\wedge&(u^{(b)}{\bf 1}^b + ve^b) \nonumber\\ \wedge (u^{(c)}{\bf 1}^c+ ve^c)&\wedge&(u^{(d)}{\bf 1}^d+ ve^d).\end{eqnarray} This very particular antisymmetric potential removes the ghost like Boulware-Deser mode from the spectrum \cite{Hinterbichler:2012cn}. In this vacuum besides the five polarization modes of massive graviton (three of which are Goldstone modes from $\phi^a$), there is an extra scalar mode from $\varphi$. The Planck constant is defined as follows \begin{equation} m_{\rm Pl}^2 = 2 lc_2v^3 .\end{equation} Furthermore, comparing the dRGT potential \eqref{dRGT-potential} with \eqref{potential} we find that (after defining dimensionless parameters $\alpha_i$ and common $u$ as $\alpha_iu^i\equiv{\rm f}(u^{(a)})$, $i=1,2,3$) \begin{eqnarray} 24\alpha_1lc_3v^4u&=&b_1m^2m_{\rm Pl}^2,\\ 24\alpha_2lc_3v^3u^2 &=&b_2m^2m_{\rm Pl}^2,\\ 24\alpha_3lc_3v^2u^3 &=&b_3m^2m_{\rm Pl}^2.\end{eqnarray} Then the graviton mass can be read as follows \begin{equation} m^2 = 12 (c_3/c_2)(u/v)(\alpha_3u^2+2\alpha_2uv+\alpha_1v^2),\end{equation} Consistency checks (avoiding tachyonic graviton and satisfying \eqref{constant-relation}) imply that sign$(c_1,c_2,c_3,v,u)$ is either of $(---++), (+++++), (+-++-), (-+--+), (-----), (+++--)$. We remind the reader that in the dRGT theory in order that flat space is a solution one gets $b_0+3b_1+3b_2+b_3=0$. Given that one finds $b_0m^2=12(c_3/c_2)u^2$, this constraint is satisfied for $(v/u)^3+3(v/u)^2\alpha_1+3(v/u)\alpha_2+\alpha_3=0$. \subsection*{Action from Contraction} In this section we show that the action \eqref{Poincare-action} can be obtained from a topological de Sitter gauge theory (for early works on dS gauge theory see \cite{MacDowell:1977jt,Chamseddine:1976bf,Stelle:1979aj,Pagels:1983pq,Grignani:1991nj}). The theory is invariant under local de Sitter transformations and spacetime diffeomorphisms $SO(1,4)\times {\it Diff}$. It is useful to look at this as a principal fibre bundle with $SO(1,4)$-valued bundles over 4 dimensional base (spacetime) manifold on which diffeomorphisms act. The action is a functional of the the connection 1-form A$^{AB}$ and a (dimensionless) dynamical field $\phi^A$ in the vector representation. The capital latin indices run from 0 to 4. The action is \begin{eqnarray}\label{dS-action} S = \epsilon_{ABCDE}\int_{\cal M} &c_1&F^{AB}\wedge F^{CD}\phi^E\nonumber\\ + &c_2&F^{AB}\wedge{\it D}\phi^C\wedge {\it D}\phi^{\rm D}\phi^E\nonumber\\ + &c_3&{\it D}\phi^A\wedge {\it D}\phi^B\wedge {\it D}\phi^C\wedge {\it D}\phi^{\rm D}\phi^E\nonumber\\ -\int_{\cal M}&&g(\eta^{AB}\phi_A\phi_B-v^2)^2\Lambda_4.\end{eqnarray} $F$ is the curvature of the connection \begin{equation} F^{AB} = {\it D}{\rm A}^{AB} = {\rm d}{\rm A}^{AB} + {\rm A}^A\!_C\wedge{\rm A}^{CB},\end{equation} and de Sitter covariant derivative is defined as follows \begin{equation} {\it D}\phi^A = {\rm d}\phi^A + {\rm A}^A\!_B\phi^B.\end{equation} In the above action, $\Lambda_4$ is a dimensionful 4-form Lagrange multiplier, $\eta_{AB}$ is the de Sitter invariant numerical tensor and $v$ is some dimensionless constant. In the action \eqref{dS-action} all possible 4-forms are included. However, each term can be multiplied by singlet 0-form powers of $\phi^A$ that we do not study here. In order to make connection with the action \eqref{Poincare-action} we formally decompose the dynamical fields into $SO(1,3)$ representations as \begin{eqnarray} {\rm A}^{AB} &=& \left( \begin{array}{cc} \omega^{ab} &\ \ e^a\\ -e^b &\ 0 \end{array} \right),\\ \phi^A &=& \left(\phi^a\ \ \varphi\right)^T.\end{eqnarray} Accordingly, the de Sitter curvature is decomposed as \begin{equation} F^{AB} = \left( \begin{array}{cc} R^{ab} - e^a\wedge e^b&\ \ T^a\\ -T^b &\ 0 \end{array} \right), \end{equation} where $T^a$ is defined as $T^a={\rm D}e^a$. Moreover, the covariant derivative of the vector becomes \begin{equation} {\it D}\phi^A = \left({\rm D}\phi^a + \varphi e^a\quad {\rm d}\varphi-e^a\phi_a\right)^T,\end{equation} where the Lorentz covariant derivative D defined is as before. Moreover, now the gauge transformations are \begin{eqnarray}\label{gauge-trans-omega} \delta\omega^a\!_b &=& {\rm D}\lambda^a\!_b + (e^a\epsilon_b-e_b\epsilon^a),\\ \label{gauge-trans-e}\delta e^a &=& - {\rm D}\epsilon^a+\lambda^a\!_b e^b,\\ \label{gauge-trans-phi}\delta\phi^a &=& \lambda^a\!_b\phi^b+\epsilon^a\varphi,\\ \label{gauge-trans-varphi}\delta\varphi &=& - \epsilon^a\phi_a.\end{eqnarray} Finally, the de Sitter invariant action \eqref{dS-action} is found as \begin{eqnarray}\label{decomposed-action} S = &c_1&\epsilon_{abcd}\int_{\cal M}\Big[\varphi(R^{ab}-e^a\wedge e^b)\wedge (R^{cd}-e^c\wedge e^d) \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\ +2 \,(R^{ab}-e^a\wedge e^b)\wedge T^c \phi^d\Big]\nonumber\\ +&c_2&\epsilon_{abcd}\int_{\cal M}\Big[(R^{ab}-e^a\wedge e^b)\wedge ({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\wedge\nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad({\rm D}\phi^d+\varphi e^d)\varphi \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad+(R^{ab}-e^a\wedge e^b)\wedge({\rm d}\varphi - \phi^e e^e)\wedge \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad ({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\phi^d \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad+T^a\wedge ({\rm D}\phi^b+\varphi e^b)\wedge({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\phi^d\Big]\nonumber\\ +&c_3&\epsilon_{abcd}\int_{\cal M}\Big[\varphi({\rm D}\phi^a+\varphi e^a)\wedge({\rm D}\phi^b+\varphi e^b)\wedge\nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad ({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\wedge({\rm D}\phi^d+\varphi e^d) \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\ +\phi^a({\rm D}\phi^b+\varphi e^b)\wedge({\rm D}\phi^c+\varphi e^c)\wedge \nonumber\\ &&\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad({\rm D}\phi^d+\varphi e^d)\wedge({\rm d}\varphi- \phi^e e_e)\Big]\nonumber\\ &&\quad-\int_{\cal M}g(\varphi^2+\eta^{ab}\phi_a\phi_b-v^2)^2\Lambda_4.\end{eqnarray} \paragraph*{Group Contraction} The Minkowski spacetime can be viewed as infinite radius (vanishing cosmological constant) limit of the de Sitter geometry {\it a.k.a.} the Penrose limit. At the the level of algebra, the Poincare algebra can be obtained from the de Sitter algebra by rescaling some of the generators and taking a singular limit by the In\"{o}n\"{u}-Wigner contraction \cite{Inonu:1953sp}. Both algebras have the same number of generators but the structure constants are different. To apply the contraction, we introduce a length scale $l$ and rescale the de Sitter boosts $M^{a5}$ as \begin{equation} l^{-1}M^{a5} = P^a ,\end{equation} where $P^a$ has dimension mass. It can be easily seen that \begin{equation} [P^a,P^b] = l^{-2} M^{ab}\rightarrow 0,\end{equation} when $l\rightarrow\infty$. The rescaling of the generators is equivalent to the rescaling of the connection. The connection 1-form can be expanded as \begin{equation} {\rm A} = {\rm A}^{AB}M_{AB} = \omega^{ab}M_{ab} + (l^{-1}e^a) (l P_a),\end{equation} where the connection $e^a$ is now dimensionless. Similarly, the transformation parameters are rescaled as \begin{equation} \lambda = \lambda^A\!_B M_A\!^B = \lambda^a\!_b M_a\!^b + (l^{-1} \varepsilon^a)(l P_a),\end{equation} where now $\varepsilon^a$ has dimension length. Furthermore, we rescale the Lorentz scalar as $\varphi\mapsto l\varphi$ such that now it has mass dimension 1. Finally, We send $l\rightarrow\infty$ and while keeping $\varphi,e$ and $\varepsilon$ fixed. In this limit some parts of the gauge transformations \eqref{gauge-trans-omega} and \eqref{gauge-trans-varphi} change as follows \begin{eqnarray} \delta\omega^a\!_b &=& {\rm D}\lambda^a\!_b + l^{-2}(e^a\epsilon_b-e_b\epsilon^a)\rightarrow {\rm D}\lambda^a\!_b,\\ \delta\varphi &=& - l^{-2}\epsilon^a\phi_a\rightarrow 0.\end{eqnarray} Together with \eqref{gauge-trans-e} and \eqref{gauge-trans-phi} they form gauge transformations under the Poincare group given in \eqref{trans-omega} to \eqref{trans-varphi}. One would wonder what would happen at the level of the action (and to the dynamics) when $l\rightarrow\infty$. We substitute the rescaled fields into the the decomposed de Sitter invariant action \eqref{decomposed-action}. We also resale the constants $\Lambda_4\mapsto l^{-3}\Lambda_4$ and $v\mapsto lv$ so that they have dimension mass and keep them fix in the limit $l\rightarrow\infty$. The action can be organized in powers of $l$ as $S = l(\cdots)+l^{-2}(\cdots)+l^{-3}(\cdots)$. Only the terms proportional to $l$ survive in $l\rightarrow\infty$ limit and those give exactly the Poincare invariant action \eqref{Poincare-action}. \subsection*{Conclusion} In this note we argued that a Lorentz invariant massive gravity (\`{a} la dRGT) can be obtained dynamically from spontaneous symmetry breaking in a topological Poincare gauge theory. In the broken phase, besides polarization modes of massive graviton, there is a Higgs-like scalar excitation which can extend the theory of massive spin 2 into a Lorentz invariant UV completion. The explicit computations of the tree-level forward scattering of 4 longitudinal modes is studied somewhere else \cite{Torabian:2017}. \paragraph*{Acknowledgments} This work is partially supported by the School of Particles and Accelerators of Institute for Studies in Fundamental Sciences (IPM) and the Research Office of Sharif University of Technology. The author grateful to the International Centre for Theoretical Physics, Trieste for hospitality and to Seif Randjbar-Daemi for fruitful discussions. \ \\$^*$ Email: {\tt mahdi@physics.sharif.edu}

Background {#Sec1} ========== Table or hen's eggs are affordable and rich sources of animal protein. Chicken's eggs are used as ingredients in a wide variety of foods and refreshments \[[@CR1], [@CR2]\]. The rise in consumer knowledge on food safety matters has changed the general public perception of a "good egg" from mere outer shell cleanliness and physical properties to that of microbial integrity \[[@CR3]\]. The microbial flora of the hen's egg before lay is very low \[[@CR3]\], after which the shell gets contaminated during the laying process and from surfaces with which it makes contact \[[@CR4]\]. As a consequence, enteric pathogens like *Salmonella spp.* and *Escherichia coli* have been isolated from the outer shells of eggs and their internal contents \[[@CR5]\]. There are also reports of the isolation of other members of the Enterobacteriaceae, like *Citrobacter spp*., *Enterobacter* spp., *Klebsiella spp., Proteus spp. Providencia spp.* and *Stenotrophomonas maltophilia,* either from whole or cracked eggs. These pathogenic microbes are capable of causing food spoilage, and infectious diseases in consumers when introduced into the food chain \[[@CR1], [@CR5]--[@CR7]\]. There is documented evidence for the development of resistance to antimicrobial agents from an array of pathogens isolated from commercial eggs, triggering serious public health threats and adding pressure to the already overburdened antibiotic resistance crisis \[[@CR1], [@CR8]\]. A valid public health concern is that there might be limited active drugs available to treat infected humans, and horizontal transfer of resistant genes between animal and human bacteria may exacerbate the current antimicrobial resistant crisis \[[@CR9]\]. One of the measures of combating the rising rates of antimicrobial resistance is the continuous search of new, safe and effective antimicrobials as alternative agents to non-effective ones \[[@CR10]\]. Plants have been a source of medicinal agents for thousands of years and a number of contemporary drugs have been developed from natural sources. Many of these isolations were based on the uses of plant extracts in traditional medicine . In this study, we determined the potency, efficacy and selectivity acetone leaf extracts of nine South African trees with high activity against *Escherichia coli* based on the unpublished PhD thesis of Dr E Pauw \[[@CR11]\] against six Gram-negative enteric pathogens isolated from commercial eggs, sold in the Gauteng Province of South Africa. The activity of these extracts have also been examined against *Bacillus anthracis* \[[@CR12]\]. Methods {#Sec2} ======= Collection of plant material, drying and storage {#Sec3} ------------------------------------------------ Fresh leaves from nine South African medicinal plants with excellent activity against *Escherichia coli* were collected from the Lowveld National Botanical Garden, Pretoria National Botanical Garden and University of Pretoria Manie van der Schyff Botanical Garden. Voucher specimens were prepared and sent to the HGWJ Schweickerdt Herbarium of the University of Pretoria for storage and identification. Herewith are the plants with their voucher numbers. *Bolusanthus speciosus* (H. Bolus) Harms (Fabaceae, PRU 120027)*, Calpurnia aurea* (Aiton) Benth ssp. *aurea* (Fabaceae, PRU 120125)*, Maesa lanceolata* Forssk (Maesaceae PRU120125)*, Elaeodendron croceum* (Thunb.) DC (Celastraceae, PRU 120127). *Morus mesozygia* Stapf ex A. Chev (Moraceae, PRU 120128), *Hypericum roeperianum* G.W. Schimp.ex A. Rich. var. *roeperianum,* (Hypericaceae, PRU 120126)*, Cremaspora triflora* (Thonn.) K. Schum (Rubiaceae, PRU 120129)*, Heteromorpha arborescens* (Spreng.) Chan. & Schltdl (Apiaceae, PRU 120026)*, and Pittosporum viridiflorum* Sims (Pittosporaceae, PRU 120025). Extraction {#Sec4} ---------- Acetone (technical grade, Merck) was used as extractant in the assays, used in a ratio 1:10 ground dried leaf material to extractant. Acetone is the best choice as an extractant mainly due to its ability to extract compounds of a wide range of polarities \[[@CR13]\], its non-toxicity to bioassay systems \[[@CR14]\] and ease of removal from extracts. Three grams (3.0 g) of each leaf sample were extracted with 30 ml acetone. The resulting suspension was vigorously shaken in 50 ml polyester centrifuge tubes for 5 min, and centrifuged at 4000 x g for 10 min (Hettich Centrifuge, Rotofix 32A, Labotec, Johannesburg, South Africa). The extraction was repeated two more times on the marc and supernatants were decanted into preweighed glass containers after filtering through Whatman No. 1 filter paper and concentrated to dryness under a stream of cold air. The dried extracts were stored at 5 °C in tightly stoppered glass vials until use. Bacterial isolation {#Sec5} ------------------- The WHO standardised culture and isolation methods (gold standard) was used for bacterial isolation. This is dependent on four basic steps namely: (1) Pre-enrichment of samples (shell, albumin and yolk) in non-selective media-buffered peptone water (BPW-Selecta-MEDIA, South Africa). (2) Enrichment of sample-broth in selective media-tetrathionate (Selecta-MEDIA, South Africa). (3) Isolation of sample on selective solid agar media-xylose lysine deoxycholate (XLD-MERCK, South Africa) and (4) Confirmation of presumptive bacterial isolates using biochemical test and molecular techniques like MALDI-TOF and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) \[[@CR15], [@CR16]\]. Test organisms {#Sec6} -------------- Microorganisms used in this study represent pathogenic species isolated from commercial hen's eggs commonly associated with nosocomial and opportunistic infections. The bacteria were isolated from the shell, albumin and yolk, maintained in the Phytomedicine Laboratory at the Faculty of Veterinary Science, University of Pretoria. They consisted of six Gram-negative Enterobacteriaceae strains namely *Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, Escherichia coli, Enterobacter cloacae, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Proteus mirabilis,* and *Salmonella* serotype Typhimurium. All the bacterial strains were subcultured from the original culture, stored at −80 °C on ceramic beads in cryoprotective media (Pro-Lab diagnostics Microbank^@^ 20) and maintained on Müller-Hinton (MH) agar plates at 4 °C. Microdilution assay {#Sec7} ------------------- The bacterial cultures grown overnight were adjusted to McFarland standard 1, equivalent to 1.4 x 10^8^ cfu/ml (*Stenotrophomonas maltophilia*), 3.6 x10^8^ cfu/ml (*Proteus mirabilis*), 3.9 x 10^8^ cfu/ml (*Klebsiella pneumoniae*), 3.8 x 10^8^ cfu/ml (*Escherichia coli*), 3.2 x 10^8^ cfu/ml (*Salmonella serotype* Typhimurium) and 3.6 x 10^8^ cfu/ml (*Enterobacter cloacae*). The two-fold serial dilution microplate method \[[@CR17]\] was used to determine the MIC values. Briefly, aliquots (100 μl) of 10 mg/ml solutions dissolved in acetone of the crude extracts were serially diluted with distilled water in 96- well micro titre plates. A 100 μl aliquot of bacterial suspension was added to each well. Sterilised distilled water and acetone were used as negative and solvent control \[[@CR14]\], and gentamicin as a positive control against the bacteria. P-iodonitrotetrazolium (INT, 0.2 mg/ml) 40 μl was added after 24 h of incubation of the plant extracts with bacterial cultures at 37 °C and incubated for a further 30 min to 1 h until optimal colour development. The colourless tetrazolium salt acts as an electron acceptor and is reduced to formazan product by biologically active organisms. Tests were carried out in triplicate and each experiment was repeated three times. The MIC was recorded as the lowest concentration of the extract that inhibited bacterial growth \[[@CR17]\]. To compare the activity of different plants not only the MIC but also the quantity extracted from the plant should be taken into account. The total activity is calculated by dividing the quantity in mg extracted from one g of plant material by the MIC in mg/ml. Cytotoxic activity {#Sec8} ------------------ The 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2, 5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) reduction assay \[[@CR18]\] was used to determine the cytotoxicity of the extracts against Vero cells. The method used is described as follows in our previous publication un this journal (12): "Cells were seeded at a density of 1 × 105 cells/ml (100 μl) in 96-well microtitre plates and incubated at 37 °C and 5% CO2 in a humidified environment. After 24 h incubation, 100 μl each of differing extract concentrations were added to the wells containing cells. Doxorubicin was used as a positive control. A suitable blank control with equivalent concentrations of acetone was also included and the plates were incubated for 48 h in a CO2 incubator. Thereafter, the medium in each well was aspirated from the cells, cells were washed with PBS, and finally 200 μl fresh medium was added to each well. Thirty microliter of MTT (5 mg/ml in PBS) was added to each well and the plates were incubated at 37 °C for 4 h. The medium was aspirated from the wells and DMSO was added to solubilise the formed formazan crystals. The absorbance was measured using a BioTek Synergy microplate reader at 570 nm. The percentage of cell growth inhibition was calculated based on a comparison with untreated cells. The selectivity index values were calculated by dividing cytotoxicity LC50 values by the MIC values in the same units (mg/ml)." Results and Discussion {#Sec9} ====================== Activity of the nine acetone leaf extracts against the six egg Enterobacteriaceae isolates {#Sec10} ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Taking cognisance of the recurring arguments by different investigators on the appropriate cut-off points for defining the strength of antimicrobial activity of plant extracts \[[@CR19], [@CR20]\]. Several authors classified plants according to antimicrobial activity \[[@CR21]--[@CR23]\]. This study classified plant extracts with MIC values lower than 0.1 mg/ml as significantly active; those with MIC values \>0.1 to 0.625 mg/ml as moderately active, and MIC \>0.625 mg/ml with weak or negligible activity. The total activity of the extracts is a pharmacologically useful measure to compare the efficacy of different plants because it takes into account not only the antimicrobial activities but also the quantities extracted from different plants. The total activity is calculated by dividing the mass in mg obtained from 1 g of plant material by the MIC in mg/ml. The total activity of the extract is expressed in ml/g and is the volume of solvent that can added to the extract obtained from 1 g of plant material that will still inhibit the growth of the specific pathogen \[[@CR24]\]. In determining cytotoxicity, plant extracts with LC~50~ \> 20 μg/ml were considered relatively non-cytotoxic. Selectivity index values of the extracts were calculated by dividing the cytotoxicity LC~50~ (in mg/ml) by MIC (mg/ml). Plant extracts with SI values \>1 imply that the extracts are less toxic to bacteria than to the mammalian cells Plant extracts might have good activity against the test organism but if they are too cytotoxic will not be of any value. When an extract shows consistent low MIC values against different pathogens i.e. there is low selectivity, it is sensible to repeat the assays and recheck the toxicity of the extracts against different cells. If the SI value is low, it could mean that the potency observed against the organisms might be related to a general metabolic toxin in the extract that will affect both the targeted pathogens and the host cells \[[@CR25]\]. There is not much incentive for continuing investigation of an extract or isolated compound with a low selectivity index. It should however, be kept in mind that in vivo efficacy and toxicity of extracts or active compounds upon administration to animals or humans may differ substantially from their in vitro properties owing to pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamical considerations \[[@CR25]\]. Infections with Gram-negative bacteria are of imminent concern as they are more difficult to treat and outcome is poor \[[@CR26]\]. The tree leaf extracts investigated in this study were selected based on its high activity against *E. coli* \[[@CR11], [@CR22]\]. The nine acetone extracts had varying degrees of activity against the six Gram-negative enteropathogenic bacteria isolated from eggs sold in different outlets in the Gauteng province of South Africa. The sensitivity of the pathogens to the plant extracts are discussed below. *Stenotrophomonas maltophilia* {#Sec11} ------------------------------ *Stenotrophomonas maltophilia* is increasingly recognised as an important nosocomial pathogen. Treatment challenges are due to intrinsic resistance to many antibiotics as well as concerns over toxicity of the drug of choice, co-trimoxazole \[[@CR27]\]. *S. maltophilia* is recognised as the cause of skin and soft-tissue, respiratory, bloodstream and prosthetic device infections, especially in immunocompromised and critically ill patients \[[@CR27]\]. It is therefore necessary to determine how the various extracts affect *S. maltophilia* isolated from eggs. Given the endemicity of HIV infection in South Africa where the infected persons are often immunocompromised, this is a growing problem in this country \[[@CR28]\]. Ingesting improperly cooked foods from contaminated eggs could add to the disease burden, thus contributing to an increase in mortality rates. Within the limits of our literature search, this is the first report of tests carried out using the nine selected South African extracts against *S. maltophilia*. The different extracts tested against *S. maltophilia* had very promising activities with MIC values ranging from 0.08 to 0.31 mg/ml (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). *Cremaspora triflora*, *H. arborescens*, *P. viridiflorum, M. lanceolata and E. croceum* had good activity against *S. maltophilia* with MIC = 0.08 mg/ml.Table 1Minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) and total antibacterial activity (TAA) and selectivity index (SI) of the nine selected acetone leaf extracts against *Stenotrophomonas maltophilia*, *Klebsiella sp.* and *Salmonella* serotype Typhimurium (AJ 33)*Stenotrophomonas maltophiliaKlebsiella pneumoniaeSalmonella* ser. Typhimurium (AJ 33)PlantsMIC (mg/ml)TAA (ml/g)SIMIC (mg/ml)TAA (ml/g)SIMIC (mg/ml)TAA (ml/g)SI*H. roeperianum*0.16749.80.410.16749.80.410.31387.00.21*C. triflora***0.08**252.10.72**0.08**252.10.72**0.08**252.10.72*H. arborescens***0.08**325.41.010.16162.70.510.16162.70.51*P. viridiflorum***0.08**339.60.680.16169.80.340.16169.80.34*B. speciosus*0.3174.30.170.16144.00.330.6336.60.08*C. aurea*0.16179.00.09**0.08**357.90.170.16179.00.09*M. lanceolata***0.08**1390.40.030.63176.60^\*^0.16695.20.01*E. croceum***0.08**1124.60.070.31290.20.020.31290.20.02*M. mesozygia*0.16115.40.25**0.08**230.80.510.3159.60.13Mean0.13NANA0.2NANA0.25NANASD0.07NANA0.17NANA0.16NANAGentamicin0.0008NANA0.0008NANA0.006NANA*NA* Not applicable, *AJ* Alexander Jambalang, ^\*^ 0.004The SI and TAA values of the extracts was calculated from the cytotoxicity and percentage yield of the extracts results published in Elisha et al. \[[@CR12]\]Numbers in bold font MIC \< 0.1 mg/ml *Maesa lanceolata* and *E. croceum* extracts had high total antibacterial activity against *S. maltophilia* with TAA = 1390 and 1125 ml/g respectively due to their low MIC values and high percentage extract yield, but they were judged as unsuitable for further investigation due their high cytotoxicity (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). *Maesa lanceolata* extracts have high efficiency against *Bacillus anthracis* and may be a potential disinfectant, especially in poor communities where disinfectants are not readily available or affordable \[[@CR12]\]. In the same manner, the potential of the extracts as decontaminants or disinfectants in hatcheries could be explored. *Heteromorpha arborescens* had a selectivity index of 1.01, while the rest of the extracts had SI values lower than 1 (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). Although *H. arborescens* extracts had good a MIC and low cytotoxicity, selecting it for further investigation might be challenging due to low extract yield (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). Furthermore, *H. arborescens* is genotoxic, causing both DNA damage and chromosomal aberrations, and has the potential of causing long-term damage in patients when administered as a medicinal preparation \[[@CR29]\]. *Klebsiella pneumoniae* {#Sec12} ----------------------- *Klebsiella pneumoniae* is the most common Gram-negative bacteria often associated with antibiotic resistant infections \[[@CR30]\]. *Klebsiella pneumoniae* is an opportunistic pathogen that infects mostly hospitalised immunocompromised patients causing bacterial pneumonia. The nasopharynx and gastrointestinal tract are its preferred predilection sites \[[@CR30]\]. Nosocomial respiratory infections caused by *Klebsiella pneumoniae* (Enterobacteriaceae) have increased in recent years due to the emergence of carbapenemase-producing strains \[[@CR31]\]. These bacteria are capable of hydrolysing carbapenems, penicillins, cephalosporins, and aztreonam \[[@CR31], [@CR32]\], thus severely challenging antimicrobial therapy \[[@CR26]\]. Extracts tested against *K. pneumoniae* isolated from hen's eggs had MICs ranging from 0.08 mg/ml to 0.63 mg/ml respectively. Acetone extracts of *Cremaspora triflora*, *Calpurnia aurea* and *Morus mesozygia* had good MIC values against *K. pneumoniae* (MICs = 0.08 mg/ml). *Hypericum roeperianum*, *Heteromorpha arborescens*, *Pittosporum viridiflorum*, and *Bolusanthus speciosus* had moderate antibacterial activity against *K. pneumoniae* with MICs of 0.16 mg/ml for all extracts. However, *M. lanceolata* had weak activity with MIC = 0.63 mg/ml. The acetone extracts of *H. roeperianum* and *C. aurea* had total activity values of 750 ml/g and 358 ml/g respectively (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). Other extracts did not meet the benchmark of an acceptable selectivity index, ≥ 1.0, but *C. triflora* had comparatively the highest SI value of 0.72 (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). *Salmonella serotype* Typhimurium {#Sec13} --------------------------------- The majority of *Salmonella* infections are linked to the consumption of contaminated food of animal origin such as eggs, chicken, and pork. Severe *Salmonella* infections often require antimicrobial therapy to aid in the elimination of the infection. There are concerns over the past three decades regarding the global emergence of multi-drug resistant phenotypes among the *Salmonella* serotypes such as *S.* ser. Typhimurium*, S.* ser. Enteritidis and *S.* ser. Newport \[[@CR33]\]. Currently, there are concerns over the emergence of resistance to quinolones, fluoroquinolones or extended-spectrum cephalosporins such as ceftiofur and ceftriaxone. Reports on the occurrence of *Salmonella* isolates resistant to these antibiotics has increased \[[@CR33]\]. In view of these negative developments, the acetone extracts of the nine plant species were tested against *S.* ser. Typhimurium isolated from commercial hen's eggs. The extracts presented varying degrees of activities against the pathogen. The MIC ranged from 0.08 mg/ml to 0.63 mg/ml (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}). Acetone extracts of *C. triflora* had good activity against *S.* ser. *Typhimurium* compared to the eight other extracts, with MIC value of 0.08 mg/ml. *Bolusanthus speciosus* had the lowest activity with an MIC of 0.63 mg/ml. *Proteus mirabilis* {#Sec14} ------------------- The antibacterial activity of the extracts against *Proteus mirabilis* ranged from outstanding to poor (0.02 to 1.25 mg/ml). *Proteus mirabilis* had the highest and lowest sensitivity to some of the extracts (Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}). For example, the extracts of *M. lanceolata* and *E. croceum* had very good activities (MIC = 0.02 mg/ml and 0.08 mg/ml respectively), while the extracts of *M. mesozygia* had the lowest activity with an MIC of 1.25 mg/ml. *Maesa lanceolata* and *E. croceum* had good TAA, with values at 5562 ml/g and 1125 ml/g. All the extracts had low SI values. Cock and van Vuuren \[[@CR34]\], reported that methanol and water extracts of *Carpobrotus edulis*, *Lippia javanica*, *Pelargonium viridflorum*, *Ptaeroxylon obliquum*, *Syzygium cordatum* leaf and bark, *Terminalia pruinoides*, *Terminalia sericea*, *Warburgia salutaris* bark and an aqueous extract of *W. salutaris* leaf had some activity *Proteus* inhibitors, with MIC values \< 2 mg/ml. Our results are in same order as their results.Table 2Minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) and total antibacterial activity (TAA) and selectivity index (SI) of the nine selected acetone leaf extracts against *Proteus mirabilis*, *Enterobacter cloacae* and *Escherichia coliProteus mirabilisEnterobacter cloacaeEscherichia coli*PlantsMIC (mg/ml)TAA (ml/g)SIMIC (mg/ml)TAA (ml/g)SIMIC (mg/ml)TAA (ml/g)SI*H. roeperianum*0.63190.40.110.31387.00.21**0.08**1499.60.83*C. triflora*0.6332.00.09**0.08**252.10.72**0.08**252.10.72*H. arborescens*0.3184.00.260.16162.70.51**0.08**325.41.01*P. viridiflorum*0.3187.60.180.16169.80.34**0.08**339.60.68*B. speciosus*0.6336.60.08**0.08**287.90.66**0.08**287.90.66*C. aurea*0.3192.70.04**0.08**357.90.17**0.04**715.80.34*M. lanceolata***0.02**5561.70.12**0.08**1390.40.030.16695.20.01*E. croceum***0.08**1124.60.07**0.08**1124.60.07**0.08**1124.60.07*M. mesozygia*1.2514.80.030.16115.40.25**0.08**230.80.51Mean0.46NANA0.13NANA0.08NANASD0.35NANA0.07NANA0.03NANAGentamicin0.0008NANA0.0002NANA0.006NANA*NA* Not applicable.The SI and TAA values of the extracts was calculated from the cytotoxicity and percentage yield of the extracts results published in Elisha et al. \[[@CR12]\]Numbers in bold font MIC \< 0.1 mg/ml *Enterobacter cloacae* {#Sec15} ---------------------- *Enterobacter* is an increasingly important human pathogen, particularly in the hospital setting. *Enterobacter* accounts for 5 to 11*%* of all nosocomially-transmitted blood, wound, respiratory tract, and urinary tract infections \[[@CR35]\]. *Enterobacter* is responsible for between 4 and 12% of all cases of Gram-negative bacteraemia. All age groups are affected. In adults, *Enterobacter* is the third or fourth leading cause of sepsis after *Escherichia coli, Klebsiella* spp., and *Pseudomonas aeruginosa.* All the extracts had reasonable activity against *Enterobacter cloacae*, with MICs ranging between 0.08 and 0.31 mg/ml (Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}). *Maesa lanceolata* and *E. croceum* had good TAA with values at 1390 ml/g and 1125 ml/g respectively. The susceptibility of *Enterobacter cloacae* has previously been reported by Shiri et al. \[[@CR35]\] when tested against ethanol leaf extracts of *Peganum harmal* and *Myrtus communis* respectively. *Escherichia coli* {#Sec16} ------------------ All tested extracts generally, had good activity against *Escherichia coli* egg isolate. MIC values ranged between 0.08 to 0.16 mg/ml. Makhafola and Eloff \[[@CR36]\] reported a similar trend when *E. coli* (ATCC 25922) was treated with the extracts from different *Ochna spp. Hypericum roeperianum* and *E. croceum* extracts had a very good TAA, with values of 1500 ml/g and 1125 ml/g respectively. *Heteromorpha arborescens* had the best SI = 1.01 (Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}). *Maesa lanceolata* and *E. croceum* extracts had poor selectivity index values (Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}). The mean MIC values of the extracts against the egg isolates ranged from 0.14 mg/ml to 0.34 mg/ml (Tables [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"} and [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"} and Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). *Calpurnia aurea* had the lowest mean MIC value of 0.14 ± 0.09 mg/ml, and *M. mesozygia* had the highest mean value of 0.34 ± 0.41 mg/ml (Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}).Fig. 1Sensitivity of the six pathogenic egg isolates to the nine selected acetone leaf extracts. Legend: ^a,\ b,\ c,\ d^ and ^e^ = statistically significant difference in the mean MIC of the pathogens, *p* \< 0.05 In general, extracts of *C. aurea* had good activity against all the tested egg isolates, while extracts of *M. mesozygia* had the lowest activity. *Cremaspora triflora* had good activity against five out of the six pathogens with an MIC of 0.08 mg/ml each, except against *Proteus mirabilis*, were the extract had a moderate activity with (MIC 0.63 mg/ml) (Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"} and [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}). The outstanding activity of *C. triflora* extracts suggests that the plant has potential as a promising therapeutic agent against some members of the Enterobacteriaceae. Further pharmacological investigations might be required in the search for new antimicrobial leads. Also of note are the extracts of *H. arborescens* and *P. viridiflorum* with mean MIC values against all the isolates of 0.16 mg/ml (Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}); they both had similar activity against *P. mirabilis* which also makes them potential candidates for further evaluation.Fig. 2Mean minimal inhibitory concentration of the nine selected acetone leaf extracts tested against six opportunistic bacterial pathogens isolated from commercial eggs. Legend: HR = *Hypericum roeperianum*, CT = *Cremaspora triflora*, HA = *Heteromorpha arborescens*, PV = *Pittosporum viridiflorum*, BS = *Bolusanthus speciosus,* CA = *Calpurnia aurea*, ML = *Maesa lanceolata*, EC = *Elaeodendron croceum*, MM = *Morus mesozygia.* The mean difference of the nine acetone leaf extracts were not statistically significant, *p* \> 0.05 *Cremaspora triflora* is the best plant extract for investigation because very little work has been carried out on this plant species, thus giving it some novelty. Overall *E. coli* was the most sensitive pathogen to all nine extracts (mean MIC = 0.08 ± 0.08 mg/ml), while *Proteus mirabilis* was the most resistant with mean MIC values of 0.46 ± 035 mg/ml (Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"} and Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). Conclusions {#Sec17} =========== The extracts had varying degrees of activity against the pathogens isolated from commercial eggs. *Cremaspora triflora* extracts however, had exceptional activities, against all the pathogenic egg isolates except against *Proteus mirabilis.* The promising antibacterial activities and selectivity index of the extracts of *C. triflora* against all test pathogens makes it the good candidate for more detailed pharmacological and biological investigations. If products developed from *C. triflora* extracts are not harmful to humans, it could play a role in enhancing food safety for example by washing the outside of the eggs with an extract before cooking. AJ : Alexander Jambalang. MIC : Minimum inhibitory concentration NA : Not applicable TAA : Total antibacterial activity The curators of the Pretoria National Botanical Gardens, the Lowveld National Botanical Gardens in Nelspruit and the University of Pretoria Botanical Garden allowed us to collect plant material. Funding {#FPar1} ======= This manuscript is an output of a Ph. D. research project supported by the National Research Foundation of South Africa (Eloff IPPR 953991) the South African Medical Research Council and the University of Pretoria. Availability of data and materials {#FPar2} ================================== Plant material was collected in botanical gardens and materials were purchased from commercial suppliers. Authors' contributions {#FPar3} ====================== ILE carried out the research and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. ARJ isolated the pathogenic test bacteria from commercial eggs and revised the manuscript. FSB assisted in the research work and revised the manuscript. EMB assisted in identification of *Salmonella* by using PCR, LJM made substantial contributions in revising the manuscript. JNE identified the project, guided the research, finally revised and submitted the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript. Competing interests {#FPar4} =================== We declare that we have no financial or competing interests, which may have inappropriately influenced us in writing this article. Consent for publication {#FPar5} ======================= No consent for publication is involved in this study. Ethics approval and consent to participate {#FPar6} ========================================== Because no animals or humans were used in this study no ethical approval or consent to participate was required.

Introduction {#sec0001} ============ Cerebral cavernous venous malformations (or cavernous hemangioma) are common vascular malformations that are usually asymptomatic and incidentally found [@bib0001]. However, patients may present with seizures, headache or focal neurologic deficit in the relatively rare event of hemorrhage [@bib0001], [@bib0002], [@bib0003]. Most lesions are sporadic; however, if multiple lesions are present, this could indicate familial multiple cavernous malformation syndrome [@bib0004]. Eighty percent of cavernous hemangiomas are supratentorial [@bib0002]. Multiple cavernous hemangioma can also be seen following intracranial radiation therapy [@bib0005],[@bib0006]. Cavernous hemangioma are unusually large collections of blood vessels without parenchyma interceding between the sinusoidal vessels [@bib0001], [@bib0002], [@bib0003]. These vascular channels have thin walls and have no smooth muscle support. They may also be associated with adjacent developmental venous anomalies [@bib0003]. Cavernous hemangioma have fairly characteristic imaging appearances, not typically causing a diagnostic dilemma [@bib0007],[@bib0008]. However, within the context of a history of cancer with potential hemorrhagic brain metastases, neuroimagers need to be vigilant to ensure they contemplate this possibility, especially when the cavernous hemangioma have internal hemorrhage with edema, potentially obfuscating the typical lesional architecture the reader would likely anticipate [@bib0009]. In this case report, we describe a case of cavernous hemangioma, who was initially thought to have developed intracranial metastatic disease from primary papillary thyroid cancer. Case report {#sec0002} =========== A 50-year-old female with past medical history significant for papillary thyroid cancer (status postradioactive iodine ablation and resection 10 years prior to presentation), scleroderma, Raynaud\'s syndrome, polymyositis, and pericarditis presented to the emergency department following new onset seizures. She described her symptoms as right arm jerking, drooling, and encephalopathy. On examination, she was afebrile and hemodynamically stable. Physical examination, including neurologic examination, on admission, was unremarkable. Initial laboratory testing included blood workup, urine drug screen, and urine analysis which were negative. Noncontract computed tomography (CT) of the head ([Fig. 1](#fig0001){ref-type="fig"}) demonstrated multiple supratentorial and infratentorial hyperdensities measuring up to 8 mm, which were concerning for possible hemorrhagic metastases in the setting of history of malignancy. The largest lesion was in the left parietal lobe and measured approximately 8 mm ([Fig. 1](#fig0001){ref-type="fig"}A). Additional smaller hyperattenuating lesions were also seen in the right frontal lobe ([Fig. 1](#fig0001){ref-type="fig"}B) as well as in the medial right cerebellar hemisphere and left frontal centrum semiovale.Fig. 1Noncontrast computed tomography (CT) of the brain at the time of presentation. The noncontrast CT scan at the time of presentation demonstrated multiple supratentorial and infratentorial hyperdensities measuring up to 8 mm, which were concerning for possible hemorrhagic metastases in the setting of history of malignancy. The largest lesion was in the left parietal lobe and measured approximately 8 mm (A). Additional smaller hyperattenuating lesions were also seen in the right frontal lobe (B) as well as in the medial right cerebellar hemisphere and left frontal centrum semiovale (not shown on current figures).Fig 1 Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) brain with and without contrast demonstrated numerous foci of signal dropout (hypointensity) within these lesions on susceptibility-weighted imaging (SWI), including in the cerebellar hemispheres and brainstem ([Fig. 2](#fig0002){ref-type="fig"}A). Postcontrast imaging demonstrated peripheral contrast enhancement in some of these lesions, including a left parietal lesion ([Fig. 2](#fig0002){ref-type="fig"}B) which had peripheral vasogenic edema ([Fig. 2](#fig0002){ref-type="fig"}C), and internal hyperperfusion ([Fig. 2](#fig0002){ref-type="fig"}D). These imaging findings, together with the patient\'s history of thyroid carcinoma, raised concern for possible multiple hemorrhagic brain metastases.Fig. 2Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of brain with and without contrast at the time of presentation. Susceptibility-weighted imaging (SWI) demonstrated numerous foci of signal dropout (hypointensity) including in the cerebellar hemispheres and brainstem (A). Postcontrast T1-weighted imaging demonstrated peripheral contrast enhancement in some of these lesions, including a left parietal lobe lesion (B). T2-fluid attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) sequence demonstrated peripheral vasogenic edema (C) around the parietal lobe lesion. Cerebral blood volume (CBV) perfusion sequence demonstrated internal hyperperfusion (D). These imaging findings, together with the patient\'s history of thyroid carcinoma, raised concern for possible multiple hemorrhagic brain metastases.Fig 2 Following which CT chest, abdomen and pelvis was performed with no evidence of tumor recurrence or further potential metastatic disease. Inpatient colonoscopy was negative for malignancy. The patient was initiated on Levetiracetam and improved clinically over the course of the hospital stay and was discharged. She reported no further seizures at the follow-up clinic visit in 2 weeks. Three-month follow-up MRI of the brain demonstrated resolution of the previously visualized vasogenic edema surrounding some of these lesions, including the aforementioned left parietal lesion with a surrounding hemosiderin ring and heterogeneous internal signal now able to be visualized ([Fig. 3](#fig0003){ref-type="fig"}A). Contrast enhancement ([Fig. 3](#fig0003){ref-type="fig"}B) was also reduced. As such, the characteristic findings of multiple cavernous malformations became evident with the passage of time and resolution of blood products and vasogenic edema. She continues to be followed in clinic and reports no further episodes of seizures.Fig. 3Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of brain with and without contrast at 3-month follow-up. Three-month follow-up MRI of the brain demonstrated resolution of the previously visualized vasogenic edema on T2-fluid attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) sequence surrounding some of these lesions, including the aforementioned left parietal lesion with a surrounding hemosiderin ring and heterogeneous internal signal now able to be visualized (A). T1-weighted postcontrast scan demonstrated decreased peripheral enhancement (B).Fig 3 Discussion {#sec0003} ========== Cerebral cavernous venous malformations are common vascular malformations that are usually asymptomatic and incidentally found [@bib0001],[@bib0002]. However, patients may present with seizures, headache or focal neurologic deficit in the relatively rare event of hemorrhage [@bib0003]. Most lesions are sporadic; however, if multiple lesions are present, this could indicate familial multiple cavernous malformation syndrome [@bib0004],[@bib0010]. Eighty percent of cavernous hemangioma are supratentorial [@bib0002]. Cavernous hemangioma of the brain and spinal cord can present in any age group, most commonly seen in third-sixth decades of life and has no gender predisposition. Reportedly, it is present in 0.5% of the general population [@bib0003]. Multiple cavernous hemangiomas can also be seen following intracranial radiation therapy [@bib0005],[@bib0006]. Cavernous hemangiomas are unusually large collections of blood vessels without parenchyma interceding between the sinusoidal vessels. These vascular channels have thin walls and have no smooth muscle support. They may also be associated with adjacent developmental venous anomalies [@bib0001], [@bib0002], [@bib0003]. On CT, cavernous hemangiomas may not be visible. However, when seen, they appear as hyperdense lesions that may resemble hemorrhage. They may also exhibit small foci of calcification. If there has been recent hemorrhage, perilesional vasogenic edema may be evident [@bib0011]. MRI reveals a characteristic "mulberry" appearance on T2-weighted and fluid attenuation inversion recovery (FLAIR)-weighted images with varying internal signal intensity which indicates multiple stages of blood products within the cavernous hemangioma. They also will typically have a T2-weighted dark hemosiderin rim. Blood sensitive imaging (gradient echo \[GRE\] and SWI) demonstrates prominent surrounding hypointensity representing blooming secondary to internal blood products and/or calcification, if present. Cavernous hemangiomas may rarely demonstrate some degree of contrast enhancement. Perfusion imaging may show alteration in capillary permeability involving cavernous malformations which has been previously described in the literature. In addition, blood products surrounding the cavernous hemangiomas could also lead to misinterpretation of perfusion data due to susceptibility effect [@bib0005], [@bib0006], [@bib0007], [@bib0008], [@bib0009],[@bib0011]. As seen in this case, cavernous hemangiomas can mimic intracranial hemorrhagic metastatic disease. The most common other primary tumors with hemorrhagic brain metastases include thyroid carcinoma, choriocarcinoma, renal cell carcinoma, melanoma, and bronchogenic carcinoma [@bib0012]. Other, infrequent causes of intracranial hemorrhagic metastases include hepatoblastoma and osteogenic sarcoma [@bib0012]. An unusual case of cavernous hemangioma mimicking brain metastases status post-thyroidectomy and RAI in a patient with thyroid carcinoma was reported by Bulzico et al. [@bib0009]. As mentioned above, cavernous hemangiomas rarely enhance and do not exhibit surrounding vasogenic edema unless recent hemorrhage is present. Perfusion imaging may also be helpful in differentiating metastases from cavernous hemangiomas as metastases are more likely to show evidence of increased blood volume. In our case, only 1 lesion in the left parietal lobe showed surrounding edema which likely represented recent hemorrhage. Brain metastases would typically be expected to demonstrate surrounding vasogenic edema unless very small in size. Additionally, the majority of the foci of signal dropout on blood sensitive imaging did not demonstrate enhancement, which is highly atypical for metastases [@bib0007], [@bib0008], [@bib0009]. Last, as described above, subsequent follow-up showed decreased associated enhancement, resolution of edema, and no new lesions, all findings that support the diagnosis of multiple cavernous hemangiomas rather than hemorrhagic metastases. Other differential consideration would also include chronic hypertensive encephalopathy, amyloid angiopathy, diffuse axonal injury, cerebral vasculitis, hemorrhagic metastases, and Parry-Romberg syndrome [@bib0001]. In this case, the patient had no history of intracranial radiotherapy. Her history of multiple autoimmune disorders (Raynaud\'s, scleroderma and polymyositis) may potentially have contributed to the formation of multiple cerebral cavernous malformations. In addition, other possible etiologies include familial cerebral cavernous malformation syndrome which leads to the formation of multiple cavernous hemangiomas. Cerebral amyloid angiopathy may also simulate multiple cavernous malformations. In contrast to multiple cavernous hemangiomas which are usually randomly distributed, the microhemorrhages in cerebral amyloid angiopathy tend to be more superficially located near the gray white junction. Patients with cerebral amyloid angiopathy also may have sequelae of superficial siderosis, indicative of chronic subarachnoid hemorrhage [@bib0008]. Intracranial hemorrhagic metastases are a relatively common finding in patients with thyroid carcinoma. Consequently, more unusual vascular lesions may be overlooked in contemplating a differential diagnosis in this patient group. We present an example of multiple cavernous malformations masquerading as brain metastases. It is important to differentiate cerebral cavernous malformations from hemorrhagic brain metastases as this will greatly affect the treatment and care of the patient. Clinicians should be aware of the possibility of unusual intracranial hemorrhagic lesions in oncology patients which may only become evident on serial imaging evaluation. Institutional Review Board at 10.13039/100009455West Virginia University authorized the publication of case report, under IRB protocol number: 2006046810. Declaration of Competing Interest: Authors have no relevant disclosures. [^1]: Wrote the manuscript with DAL. [^2]: Wrote the manuscript with PF.

Autism spectrum disorder (hereafter autism) is a life-long condition characterised by persistent differences in social communication and interaction alongside restricted and repetitive patterns of behaviour, interests or activities ([@bibr2-1362361319898331]). Studies in Asia, Europe, and North America have identified individuals with autism with an average prevalence of between 1% and 2%, diagnosed in three to four times as many males as females ([@bibr4-1362361319898331]). The impact on the economy from intervention costs, lost earnings, and care and support for children and adults with autism is estimated at £32 billion per year in the United Kingdom and \$175 billion per year in the United States ([@bibr10-1362361319898331]). Supports developed for autism have the potential to help members of the autistic community achieve better life quality, greater autonomy and inclusion ([@bibr9-1362361319898331]). This is best achieved through participatory research approaches which critically reflect on the current status of support with the autistic and broader autism communities, in order to identify how the field can develop more inclusively ([@bibr19-1362361319898331]; [@bibr40-1362361319898331]). Reviews of the academic literature have shown that there is a growing number of digital supports for autistic individuals ([@bibr12-1362361319898331]; [@bibr22-1362361319898331]; [@bibr37-1362361319898331]; [@bibr41-1362361319898331]; [@bibr42-1362361319898331]; [@bibr43-1362361319898331]; [@bibr51-1362361319898331]; [@bibr52-1362361319898331]; [@bibr53-1362361319898331]; [@bibr54-1362361319898331]). Digital supports are defined as 'any electronic item/equipment/application/or virtual network that is used intentionally to increase/maintain, and/or improve daily living, work/productivity, and recreation/leisure capabilities' ([@bibr37-1362361319898331], p. 3806). In the past decade touchscreen, tangible and immersive digital technologies have become increasingly popular and accessible, with many autistic people and their parents/carers reporting high levels of digital technology use for supporting both leisure and academic pursuits ([@bibr30-1362361319898331]; [@bibr31-1362361319898331]; [@bibr32-1362361319898331]; [@bibr41-1362361319898331]; [@bibr49-1362361319898331]). Digital technologies have been developed to support autism in areas such as social skills and social interaction (for reviews see [@bibr11-1362361319898331]; [@bibr21-1362361319898331]; [@bibr43-1362361319898331]; [@bibr48-1362361319898331]) and emotion recognition (for review see [@bibr6-1362361319898331]). Digital technology, both in school and home settings, is being used in a variety of supportive ways such as increasing autonomy, reducing anxiety and increasing social opportunities for autistic people ([@bibr25-1362361319898331]), encapsulated by the term 'digital support'. To get an idea of how profuse development in this area is, one curated database of autism apps (<http://www.appyautism.com/en/>) lists over 400 apps for the iOS format alone. Digital supports aim to facilitate a wide range of outcomes for autistic people, across a wide variety of ages ([@bibr53-1362361319898331]). Despite the extensive use of digital supports for autism, most digital supports available to the autistic community have little or no evidence to support their effectiveness ([@bibr13-1362361319898331]; [@bibr29-1362361319898331]). Studies reporting on the effects of digital supports are often in-depth case-study reports (e.g. [@bibr14-1362361319898331]; [@bibr23-1362361319898331]; [@bibr26-1362361319898331]; [@bibr33-1362361319898331]; [@bibr34-1362361319898331]; [@bibr39-1362361319898331]). Beginning with 29,105 potential articles, [@bibr53-1362361319898331] identified 27 focused intervention practices for autism that met their inclusion criteria. An intervention practice met the level of research evidence necessary to be included if it was supported by (1) two high-quality experimental or quasi-experimental design studies conducted by two different research groups, or (2) five high-quality single case design studies conducted by three different research groups and involving a total of 20 participants across studies or (3) a combination of research designs that must include at least one high-quality experimental/quasi-experimental design, three high-quality single case designs and was conducted by more than one researcher or research group ([@bibr53-1362361319898331]). Using similar inclusion criteria for research evidence, [@bibr30-1362361319898331] identified 29 studies that met these inclusion criteria; however, of these studies only three single-subject studies and no group studies met the criteria for quality of research evidence. [@bibr22-1362361319898331] conducted a meta-analysis of digital technology supports for autism and identified only 22 out of 379 (6%) using pre-post group design studies. Studies were included based on criteria for quality of evidence that took into account participants' diagnoses, outcome measures and interaction with digital technology. Of the 22 pre-post group studies, only 10 followed a randomised controlled design (2.6% of the initial sample). The analysis of efficacy on these 10 studies provided evidence for a beneficial effect of technology-based training for autistic children overall, irrespective of age and intelligence quotient (IQ). The effect size was in the small-to-medium range, with a significant heterogeneity among studies. Together, these reviews indicate that digital supports can be effective for autism, but only a very small proportion of the research evidence from group or single case designs is of sufficient quality to permit an informed decision on whether to use the digital support. Under these circumstances, using evidence to make an informed choice about supports for members of the autistic community and broader autism community (including professionals and researchers) is challenging. The digital supports that do have published evidence of effectiveness are frequently developed in research projects, and are rarely made available to the autistic consumer ([@bibr13-1362361319898331]). [@bibr17-1362361319898331] argue that research findings and related expert opinions represent only one source of potential information influencing support-related decisions in health professions and sciences in general. Other sources of potential evidence include (1) personal (e.g. own experience and expertise as well as recommendations from peers), (2) professional practice guidelines (e.g. clinical recommendations) and (3) personal values and preferences (alongside societal values and norms). In addition, online information, from a product website to digital store reviews, may be a potential source of evidence for digital supports, especially when these are commercially available. Such sources of evidence have varying degrees of perceived independence, and relevance to the consumer's priorities. The abundance of digital supports for autism and the lack of research evidence makes it difficult for the autistic and broader autism communities to select the most appropriate digital support for their needs. A framework to evaluate the effectiveness of digital supports from multiple sources of potential evidence is urgently required to support evidence-based practice (EBP) and is the aim of this study. EBP describes the integration of the best available research, clinical expertise, patient values and circumstances and healthcare system policies ([@bibr16-1362361319898331]; [@bibr47-1362361319898331]). EBP has its origins within medicine, and clinical expertise refers to both the clinician's individual knowledge acquired through clinical experience and practice, as well as external clinical evidence based on relevant scientific research using the best available methodologies, with meta-analyses and randomised controlled trials (RCTs) being considered 'gold standard' methods ([@bibr47-1362361319898331]). This is integrated with the values and circumstances within the context of broader healthcare policy to ensure that practice is evidence-based. If a practice is not evidence-based, it risks being inapplicable to a specific patient, out of date or even potentially harmful to the patient. Efforts have been made to extend EBP to primary care and specialised clinics for autism ([@bibr3-1362361319898331]), but defining EBP is not straightforward in this context ([@bibr35-1362361319898331]). [@bibr17-1362361319898331] outline issues faced by professionals when trying to apply evidence-based practice. For instance, their routine clinical practice is often remote from the controlled circumstances in which an RCT is conducted. Specifically, patients often have specific comorbidities (e.g. attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), intellectual disabilities) that do not match the inclusion criteria for an RCT. In autism, other factors include unexpected life events occurring during the evaluation period that affect the outcome of the support and, specifically for autism, the heterogeneity of the condition ([@bibr35-1362361319898331]). Criteria for EBP in autism support have been proposed by [@bibr45-1362361319898331] which take into account both group designs and single case designs. Strong, adequate or weak judgements can be made concerning the rigour of the underlying research based on common primary quality indicators, including clear and reproducible accounts of participant characteristics, dependent measures and independent variables (in addition to secondary quality indicators including inter-observer agreement, blind raters, procedural fidelity, generalisation and maintenance and social validity). Depending on the quality and quantity of the research (e.g. see the inclusion criteria described by [@bibr53-1362361319898331], above), EBP for a support for autism can then be classified as established or promising (see [@bibr44-1362361319898331]; [@bibr45-1362361319898331]). Such criteria are particularly valuable in the context of digital supports as they are more able to take account of the range of possible uses of technology, the multitude of ways technology can be personalised and the variety of potential outcome measures for digital supports. Evaluating rapidly developing technology-based supports in RCTs is difficult, given the mismatch between the timelines of commercial and academic progress ([@bibr18-1362361319898331]). EBP is the integration of best available research and clinical expertise with patient values. Integrating the values and opinions of the autism community within the consideration of the research evidence is therefore essential to EBP (see also [@bibr19-1362361319898331]; [@bibr40-1362361319898331]). This study aimed to co-develop a framework for evaluating the evidence base for digital supports for autism, through better understanding of what constitutes evidence for the autistic and broader autism communities and what sources are being used to obtain that knowledge when considering digital supports for autism. We used an online, four-round Delphi study methodology, ideal for integrating the perspectives of multiple stakeholders ([@bibr24-1362361319898331]), with feedback managed by a moderator at all stages ([@bibr50-1362361319898331]). The Delphi study methodology was selected as it has been proposed to be more effective for group-based judgement and decision-making than traditional group meetings by both increasing a group's access to multiple interpretations and views and decreasing the negative features of group discussions such as domineering individuals and opinions ([@bibr5-1362361319898331]; [@bibr24-1362361319898331]; [@bibr46-1362361319898331]; see also [@bibr28-1362361319898331]). The Delphi methodology was therefore chosen as an ideal format for systematically capturing and integrating opinion from a diverse group of experts, who were not co-located and remained anonymous from each other ([@bibr20-1362361319898331]; [@bibr27-1362361319898331]). Since the method allows each individual to contribute anonymously and in their own time, the study allowed us to accommodate different communication preferences that do not include face-to-face communication and to avoid direct confrontation between people of differing opinions. Allowing participants to contribute at their own pace without having to manage live group discussions therefore made it easier to include autistic individuals. Methods {#section2-1362361319898331} ======= Panel members {#section3-1362361319898331} ------------- Four key groups of stakeholders were identified: (1) autistic people, (2) families of autistic people, (3) professionals who support autistic people and (4) researchers -- all with experience of using or developing digital supports for autism and advising others on the topic (see [Table 1](#table1-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}). The literature recommends between 15 and 30 panel members ([@bibr24-1362361319898331]; [@bibr38-1362361319898331]), and we aimed for 10 participants from each of our stakeholder subgroups. We contacted members of our networks directly and invited them to take part or to recommend another expert if they were unable to participate. We only contacted people that met our inclusion criteria as an 'expert' and we asked those who were referred by other people to confirm they met these criteria. We defined 'experts' as people with the necessary experience with technology for autism to advise others. All potential participants completed a brief questionnaire detailing their experience with digital interventions for autism. Experts were therefore those who reported that they had experience using and advising others on technologies for autism and could therefore be researchers, practitioners and/or members of the autism community. As the needs of the autistic community and their immediate providers of support were of primary importance to this study, researchers were not included in the first two Delphi study rounds (see [Table 1](#table1-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}), but joined at the mid-point to help refine statements on evidence. Panel members were recruited on the basis of recommendations from autism networks and associations internationally, especially those relevant to digital technology for supporting autism (e.g. [www.asdtech.ed.ac.uk](http://www.asdtech.ed.ac.uk)). Panel members were recruited through personal invitations to experts from autism-related networks in different countries for relevant experts: Asociación Española de Profesionales del Autismo AETAPI (Spain), Autism Speaks (United States), Research Autism (United Kingdom) and Centres Ressources Autisme (France). The inclusion criteria were that panel members were adults, fluent in English and that autistic panel members had formal evidence of diagnosis. As a screener, we asked all potential panel members to discuss their knowledge and experience with digital technology including (but not limited to) touchscreen tablets, smartphones, gaming devices, computers, robots and argumentative and alternative communication (AAC) devices. ###### Number of panel members per round.  Round Community members Researchers Total per round ------- ------------------- ------------- ----------------- ---- ---- 1 6 8 13 -- 27 2 6 7 11 -- 24 3 5 2 6 12 25 4 5 2 5 11 23 The age range of the community group was between 22 and 72 years (mean = 38.76 SD = 12.35) including 8 males and 17 females. In the researchers' group there were 9 males and 3 females and no information on age was given. The sample was recruited from the United Kingdom (21), France (6), United States (3), Spain (3), Israel (3) and one each from Germany, Austria and Ireland. Some panel members fulfilled the criteria for multiple groups (e.g. autistic practitioners) but are only listed in one group here -- as selected by themselves. Procedure {#section4-1362361319898331} --------- The study was conducted using an online survey software ([www.qualtrics.com](http://www.qualtrics.com)) over four rounds ([Table 2](#table2-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}). A literature review was conducted on EBP for digital supports for autism ([@bibr54-1362361319898331]) providing information about the goals of existing digital supports. These informed the design of the first round of the Delphi study, providing context for panel members to consider how they may seek sources of potential evidence. Panel members' comments and ratings in each round were collected and analysed by the moderator (first author), and used to create content for the following round. ###### Goals and panel members in each round.  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Round Description Panel members ------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------- 1 Brainstorming: open enquiry about the reasons for using digital supports and the kind of information used to select digital supports. Family members\ Professionals--practitioners\ Autistic people 2 Categorisation of evidence: organise evidence in categories, locate new types of evidence Family members\ Professionals--practitioners\ Autistic people 3 Drafting the framework: ranking and editing lists of statements about evidence Family members\ Professionals--practitioners\ Autistic people\ Researchers 4 Finalisation: ranking a selection of the statements and final modifications in wording Family members\ Professionals--practitioners\ Autistic people\ Researchers ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ### Round 1 -- Brainstorming {#section5-1362361319898331} In Round 1 the panel answered open-ended questions (see [Supplemental material, Appendix I](https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/suppl/10.1177/1362361319898331)) about their goals and sources of evidence when selecting a digital support (as defined above). They were asked to think about recent experiences when choosing or recommending a digital support intended for an autistic person (potentially including themselves). A thematic analysis was performed on panel responses, and illustrative quotes were selected ([@bibr8-1362361319898331]). This identified recurrent themes pertaining to the purpose of digital supports and the outcomes which are sought when using digital supports. We also identified potential sources of information that panel members detailed in regard to these purposes and outcomes. ### Round 2 -- categorisation {#section6-1362361319898331} The panel was asked to rate potential sources of information identified during round 1 using 5-point Likert-type scales for the following dimensions: - Relevance: whether information from this source is likely to relate to their situation; - Importance: whether information from this source is likely to be of high quality; - Usefulness: whether information from this source is likely to make a difference to their decisions/actions; - Accessibility: whether information from this source is likely to be easy to find and understand. We also aimed to refine the list of features and outcomes of digital support the panel may want evidence for and to match sources of evidence to these features/outcomes. The list of features/outcomes was derived from comments and illustrative quotes made during round 1. The panel were presented with features/outcomes beginning with the phrase 'You want to know whether . . .' (see [Table 3](#table3-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}) and asked to list the sources of information they would use to find out specifically about those features/outcomes. ###### Desired features and outcomes of a piece of technology.  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ • The product has ongoing tech support from the development team • Special interests of autistic people are taken into consideration in the product design • The product encourages original creations • The product is aesthetically pleasant • The product is easy to use • The product is customisable • The product is easy to find and order/buy • The product can be used autonomously by the autistic person • The product helps the autistic person to be more autonomous in their life • The product contributes to a better life quality for the family/carers of the autistic person • The product is amusing/entertaining • The product helps the autistic person develop new skills/improve existing skills • The product encourages social interaction between the autistic user and other people • The effects of its usage are long-lasting • The autistic user can generalise the skills they acquired via the technology in different contexts • The product achieves better results than similar products that are not technology-based • The product matches the *abilities* of the autistic user • The product matches the needs of the autistic user • The product is age-appropriate for the autistic user • There are opportunities to try out the product before buying it ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Third, in an open commentary the panel members were asked to discuss whether their personal experience was similar to specific quotes from the panel's responses in the previous round. Those were selected to match sources of information proposed in the first round ([Table 4](#table4-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}). ###### Quotes from panel members.  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 'I need a piece of technology to help me keep track of anxiety and offer suggestions and tips based on my experiences' 'I would appreciate being able to buy harder levels or aspects of a game' 'I'd look whether this technology is approved by several scientific communities specialised in autism' 'I'd only rely on my personal judgement resulting from hands on experience' 'As there were bugs in the app the person got a bit angry with it and stopped using it' 'The technology we currently have does keep him entertained and occupied' 'He uses elsewhere the things he has learnt with the app' ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Mean ratings for relevance, importance, usefulness and accessibility for each source of information were computed. Using thematic analysis, codes representing desired features and outcomes of digital supports were clustered into sub-themes and then top-level themes by two raters independently (first two authors). The themes were reviewed, validated and, if necessary, revised by two other independent raters (last two authors). In the first round, to gather input from the community we made an open-ended enquiry regarding the kind of evidence they seek when considering whether to use, or recommend that someone else use, a new technology. Specific examples of evidence were requested as illustrations of this. Analysis of these responses culminated in three high-level categories of evidence: 'engagement' (how the user experiences the product itself, its ease of use and attractiveness), 'effectiveness' (outcomes reached/directly observed changes) and 'reliability' (the technology is functional). The resulting output was composed of statements on potential sources of evidence grouped into three high-level categories: that is, evidence for reliability, evidence for engagement and evidence for effectiveness. This constituted the basis of what was used in round 3 to create the first draft of the framework. ### Round 3 -- refinement {#section7-1362361319898331} Round 3 integrated the perspectives of autistic community, families and professionals with researchers. The expanded panel were asked to rank and edit the statements that had emerged from Round 2 regarding what constitutes evidence. They were given the opportunity to remove statements that they thought were inappropriate or irrelevant. They were told that not all statements would make it to the final framework and that they should prioritise statements that they would want to see appear in the final framework. The moderator merged revisions that were similar, yielding a list of ranked statements for each category of evidence. For the framework to be easy to use, the number of statements per category was restricted. Hence, only the five most highly ranked statements in each category were maintained. ### Round 4 -- finalisation {#section8-1362361319898331} The panel was required to review and, if necessary, revise each statement in a draft framework. They were given three possibilities for each statement: (1) accept it as is, (2) make adjustments and (3) remove it from the framework. They were required to justify their edits when they chose to make adjustments or remove a statement. The panel was also asked to signal any 'words of caution' concerning the finalised framework. They ranked the five top statements from 1 to 5 with 1 being the most important source of evidence for them. The moderator merged the edits suggested by the panel when they were similar and then classified them and responded as listed below. The classification was reviewed by two independent coders (last two authors). In case of disagreement between them, consensus was achieved through discussion. 1. Amendment: This is clarification or expansion of the scope of the statement without fundamentally changing it. For each amendment, two independent coders gave a score from 1 to 3:Should be integrated into the statement;Neutral stance regarding integration in the statement;Need not to be integrated. To integrate an amendment, it had to have a mean score of less than 2. 1. 2\. Words of caution: These are important risks or constraints associated with the statement to an extent that they should be acknowledged in conjunction with the statement. These were adjoined to the statements or category of evidence they were associated with (see [Supplemental material, Appendix II](https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/suppl/10.1177/1362361319898331)). 2. 3\. Rejections: This is when a panel member opposed a statement, or criticised major aspects of it. A threshold of 90% agreement (i.e. fewer than 10% of the panel rejected a specific statement) was set for inclusion of statements in the final list, following the emerging convention in Delphi studies ([@bibr1-1362361319898331]). 3. 4\. Misunderstandings: Comments that appeared to be unrelated to the statement. The statement was double-checked and reworded for clarity if needed. Results {#section9-1362361319898331} ======= Round 1 {#section10-1362361319898331} ------- The desired outcomes of digital support for the autistic and autism communities that emerged from the panel's responses primarily related to autonomy, time awareness and management, enhanced quality of life for family/carers, better communication, social participation, fun/leisure, learning support, creativity and enhanced cognitive skills. The *features of* digital support sought by the autistic and autism communities revolved mainly around the products being reliable (bug-free, tech support and battery life) and how the products look and feel (clear instructions, scaffolding and progress awareness, customisability, attractive design, user control and reward system). [Table 5](#table5-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"} summarises the desirable features and outcomes that were derived from the thematic analysis. ###### Desirable features and outcomes for digital technology derived from thematic analysis.  Features Outcomes ------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------ Technical support Encouraging original creativity Bug-free Encouraging social interactions Aesthetically pleasing Amusing/entertaining Ease of use Autonomy Customisation Better quality of life for family/carers Accessible and affordable Generalisability of learnt skills Adapted to autistic user's special interest and needs Long-term effectiveness Age-appropriate Progressive levels of difficulty Sources of information with regard to those features and outcomes were reviews and recommendations specifically from the autism community, personal hands-on experience and direct observation, expertise of the design team, involvement of autistic users in the design, scientific evidence and non-specific online reviews. Round 2 {#section11-1362361319898331} ------- Six potential sources of information relevant to choosing and using technologies were rated for relevance, importance, usefulness and accessibility (see [Table 6](#table6-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}). ###### Ratings for source of information derived from round 1 according to four parameters, ranked from the highest to the lowest mean score over all dimensions.  Source of information Mean position (SD) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------- ------------- ------------- ------------- Positive online reviews specifically from the autistic community 4.4 (0.70) 4.5 (0.76) 4.46 (0.71) 4.29 (1.02) Expertise of the product's development/design team 3.25 (1.48) 3.75 (1.13) 3.71 (1.31) 3.96 (1.17) Observable positive changes in the autistic user's behaviour 4.25 (1.05) 4.21 (1.08) 4.13 (1.05) 4.25 (0.88) The product's development/design team specifically includes autistic people 4.04 (1.27) 4.13 (0.88) 4.08 (0.95) 3.88 (1.17) Academic research 3.88 (0.93) 3.75 (0.92) 3.79 (0.82) 3.50 (1) Positive online reviews (e.g. Amazon stars, comments on product's Facebook page) 3.00 (1.15) 3.08 (1.04) 3.04 (0.89) 3.33 (1.11) Thematic analysis of panel responses produced three high-level categories of for which evidence might be required, defined as follows: 1. *The product is reliable*: The efficacy of a product at the level of engineering. Is it technically sound/functional? How well does it work? For example, does the face recognition functionality actually work? Does the app crash often? 2. *The product is engaging*: The user perception of the technology. How usable, agreeable, pleasant and accessible a product is for the specific users? Its ease of use/look and feel. 3. *The product is effective*: The outcome of using the product. How much impact does it have for the people using it? Does it make an observable difference in the user's life/behaviour? Round 3 {#section12-1362361319898331} ------- The sources of evidence used for these three categories are summarised in [Table 7](#table7-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}, followed by descriptions that were summaries of comments that appeared across panel members and groups. ###### Statements ranked in the top five positions per category of evidence.  Reliability ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  *Try it out.* You might request a trial version from the developer, or borrow a copy/device from a friend. Take your time to explore all the functionalities. Bear in mind that a trial version might differ from the full version.  *Get an expert opinion.* Ask people you know who have skills and experience with technology, or read official documentation provided by agencies such as a government council on technology standards.  *Read online reviews*. Look on app review sites and social media. Include reviews from autistic users and their families and pay attention to long-time users. Keep in mind that reviewers' circumstances (e.g. their needs, goals or budget) may not be the same as yours.  *Seek academic opinions.* Read an academic article evaluating a product's design. You might also see scientists writing in the mainstream media or find a talk given online. Check the academic's relevant qualifications, affiliations and potential conflicts of interest when you decide how much trust to put in them.  *Consult the company's website.* While this information does not constitute independent evidence, the technical description of the product and the kind of technical support may be informative. You can also look for tech industry accreditations such as kite marks, badges, ISO norms and so on. Engagement  *Try it out.* You might request a trial version from the developer, or borrow a copy/device from a friend. Take your time to explore all the functionalities. Bear in mind that a trial version might differ from the full version  *Read online reviews.* Include reviews from autistic users and their families and pay attention to long-time users. Keep in mind that reviewers' circumstances (e.g. their needs, goals or budget) may not be the same as yours.  *Get an expert opinion.* Ask people you know who have skills and experience with technology. Talk to relevant professionals such as a teacher or speech and language therapist.  *Consult review websites.* Look for sites that compare different technologies and search for case studies.  *Seek academic opinions.* Read an academic article evaluating a product's design. You might also see scientists writing in the mainstream media or find a talk given online. Check the academic's relevant qualifications, affiliations and potential conflicts of interest when you decide how much trust to put in them. Effectiveness  *Read an academic paper*. Ideally look for a review that systematically combines the results from multiple independent studies. It may be worth checking the quality of the original studies too and the journals where they were published.  *Get an expert opinion.* Talk to relevant professionals such as a teacher or speech and language therapist. Ask people you know who have skills and experience with technology, or take the advice of reference centres. Read official documentation provided by agencies such as a government council on technology standards.  *Read online reviews.* Include reviews from autistic users and their families and pay attention to long-time users. Keep in mind that reviewers' circumstances (e.g. their needs, goals or budget) may not be the same as yours.  *Try it out.* You might request a trial version from the developer, or borrow a copy/device from a friend. Take your time to explore all the functionalities. Bear in mind that a trial version might differ from the full version.  *Search online for expert perspectives.* Read a media article on the technology written by a scientist or listen to a talk given by an academic. Check the academic's relevant qualifications, affiliations and potential conflicts of interest when you decide how much trust to put in them. Consult websites that review and compare technologies, and search for relevant case studies. Round 4 {#section13-1362361319898331} ------- In this final round the panel had to edit and rank statements in each category of sources of evidence. The statements that had the highest mean ratings as a source of evidence were similar for the three categories ([Table 8](#table8-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}). ###### Ranking of statements for all categories.  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Statements Reliability ranking\ Engagement ranking\ Effectiveness ranking\ Mean (SD) Mean (SD) Mean (SD) --------------------------------------- ---------------------- --------------------- ------------------------ Try it out 1.43 (0.82) 1.39 (0.87) 3.39 (1.69) Get an expert opinion 2.57 (0.88) 2.87 (1.08) 2.48 (1.02) Read online reviews 2.87 (1.19) 2.74 (0.85) 3.09 (1.14) Seek academic opinions 3.43 (0.97) 4.13 (1.12) *Not featured* Consult the company's website 4.70 (0.69) *Not featured* *Not featured* Consult review websites *Not featured* 3.87 (1.19) *Not featured* Read an academic paper *Not featured* *Not featured* 2.26 (1.45) Search online for expert perspectives *Not featured* *Not featured* 3.78 (1.06) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Of the 23 panel members, 3 (more than 10%) rejected the statements shown in [Table 9](#table9-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}, so they were excluded. The final framework statements reaching inclusion for consensus by the autistic and autism communities as well as researchers are listed in [Table 10](#table10-1362361319898331){ref-type="table"}, with the agreed explanatory text. ###### Statements that were removed from the framework.  Category of desirable evidence Removed statements -------------------------------- --------------------------------------- Reliability Consult the company's website Engagement Consult review websites Seek academic opinions Effectiveness Search online for expert perspectives ###### An evidence-based framework for digital supports for autism.  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- How to select digital supports for autistic users: an evidence-based framework --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  1. Try it out\ You might request a trial version from the developer, or borrow a copy/device from a friend. Take your time to explore all the functionalities. Ask how the trial version differs from the full version.  2. Get an expert opinion\ Talk to relevant professionals (e.g. a specialist teacher, speech and language therapist, specialist psychologist, etc.). Ask (autistic) people, organisations or agencies you know who have specialist skills and relevant experience with technology.  3. Read online reviews\ Look on app review websites and social media. Include reviews from autistic users and their families and pay attention to people that have been using the product for a (relatively) long time. Read and compare as many reviews as possible to improve objectivity. Keep in mind that reviewers' circumstances (e.g. their needs, age, goals or budget) may not be the same as yours and individual experiences may not be generalisable.  4. Seek academic opinions\ Read an academic article evaluating the product, or find an article/online talk in the mainstream media by a qualified scientist. Check the academic's relevant qualifications, affiliations and potential conflicts of interest when you decide how much trust to put in them. Is it engaging?  1. Try it out\ You might request a trial version from the developer, or borrow a copy / device from a friend. Explore all the functionalities and see if it might be motivating to keep using it in the medium and long term, as well as the short term. Ask how the trial version differs from the full version.  2. Read online reviews\ Include reviews from autistic users and their families and pay attention to people that have been using the product for a (relatively) long time. Keep in mind that reviewers' circumstances (e.g. their needs, age, goals or budget) may not be the same as yours and individual experiences may not be generalisable.  3. Get an expert opinion\ Ask people you know who have skills and experience with this technology and/or autistic users. Talk to relevant professionals such as a as a teacher, therapist or support worker. Ideally look for someone who also knows you as your personality has a key role in how engaging you will find it. Is it efficient?  1. Read an academic paper\ Ideally look for a review that systematically combines the results from multiple independent studies. It may be worth checking the quality and potential affiliations/bias of the original studies too and the journals where they were published.  2. Get an expert opinion\ Talk to relevant professionals (e.g. a specialist teacher, speech and language therapist, specialist psychologist, etc.). Ask (autistic) people, organisations or agencies you know who have specialist skills and relevant experience with technology.  3. Read online reviews\ Include reviews from autistic users and their families and pay attention to people that have been using the product for a (relatively) long time. Keep in mind that reviewers' circumstances (e.g. their needs, age, goals or budget) may not be the same as yours and individual experiences may not be generalisable.  4. Try it out\ You might request a trial version from the developer, or borrow a copy/device from a friend. Take your time to explore all the functionalities. Ask how the trial version differs from the full version. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Discussion {#section14-1362361319898331} ========== There is a plethora of highly accessible digital supports purporting to support the autistic community ([@bibr12-1362361319898331]; [@bibr22-1362361319898331]; [@bibr37-1362361319898331]; [@bibr41-1362361319898331]; [@bibr42-1362361319898331]; [@bibr43-1362361319898331]; [@bibr51-1362361319898331]; [@bibr52-1362361319898331]; [@bibr53-1362361319898331]; [@bibr54-1362361319898331]) but no mechanism by which consumers, practitioners or researchers can gauge the level of evidence supporting their use. This is the first study to generate a consensus from an international group made up from the autistic and broader autism communities as well as researchers as to what constitutes good evidence for digital supports for autism. Through a Delphi study methodology, consensus was achieved on a detailed framework providing the parameters for which evidence is sought and the sources of evidence perceived to be important. This novel framework allows users of digital supports to incorporate evidence into their decision-making regarding the selection and use of digital support, for themselves, or their autistic family members, pupils, clients, participants and so on. The framework can also inform those developing digital supports for the autistic community, highlighting what types of evidence are considered important. For the first time, the autistic and autism communities can incorporate EBP into the development, application and use of digital supports. Importantly, this framework has been co-developed through a participatory research approach which connects researchers with relevant autistic and broader autism communities to achieve shared goals. These methods can deliver results that are relevant to people's lives and thus likely to have a positive impact ([@bibr19-1362361319898331]; [@bibr40-1362361319898331]). The study revealed that academic evidence obtained with carefully conducted empirical research was just one of the aspects that may inform the autistic and broader autism communities when selecting appropriate digital support. This was clearly expressed by the panel from the very beginning of the study, when the importance of reliability, engagement and effectives emerged. Clinical research methodologies, such as RCTs, need to be augmented with other sources of empirical evidence, as well as hands-on experience or other users' feedback, to identify the extent to which a digital support is reliable, engaging or effective. Reliability and engagement may be particularly pertinent as features of digital support which are not present in the same way for non-technology-based supports ([@bibr35-1362361319898331]). EBP for digital supports therefore departs from non-technology-based EBP for autism, highlighting the need for a specific EBP framework. There are important similarities and differences between the proposed EBP framework for digital supports for autism and other general models of evidence provision in the field of system and software engineering. For example, the ISO/IEC 25010:2011 standard (International Organisation for Standardisation/International Electrotechnical Commission) defines a 'quality in use' model composed of five characteristics: effectiveness, efficiency, satisfaction, freedom from risk and context coverage ([@bibr7-1362361319898331]). 'Effectiveness' is a common theme between the framework co-developed with the autistic and broader autism communities and this standard, and 'engagement' maps closely to 'satisfaction'. 'Reliability', however, represents a different perspective, potentially related to (but distinct from) 'efficiency', which also takes into account task time, time efficiency, cost-effectiveness, productive time ratio, unnecessary actions and fatigue. 'Reliability' focuses more upon, 'will the app crash?', for example, reflecting the end-users experience of technology which is not captured separately by the ISO/IEC model, but is embedded within 'satisfaction' which incorporates 'proportion of users complaining, proportion of user complaints about a particular feature and user trust'. Thus, there are parallels between the requirements of the autistic and broader autism communities and international standards, but the participatory research approach ensures the relevance of the framework to those who the digital supports are being developed for. In addition, words of caution associated with the framework (see [Supplemental material, Appendix II](https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/suppl/10.1177/1362361319898331)) emphasised potential downsides of technology and thus introduced the notion of freedom from risk. Indeed, risks for health and social status were acknowledged in the word of caution related to 'engagement', which warned about possible over-engagement with technology that would monopolise the child's time, and the framework needs to be interpreted within reference to the words of caution. There were also similarities and differences in which sources of evidence were perceived to be most salient for reliability, engagement and effectiveness. While trying out the product was identified as the best source of evidence for informing reliability and engagement, academic research was viewed as the best source of evidence for effectiveness. This highlights that EBP, as informed by the broader autism community, requires multiple sources of information. Online reviews and expert opinions were also identified as key sources of evidence in all three domains. Recent accounts of fictitious online reviews ([@bibr36-1362361319898331]) and the independence of the expert are important considerations when evaluating these sources of evidence, and this is highlighted in the 'words of caution' (see [Supplemental material, Appendix II](https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/suppl/10.1177/1362361319898331)). Thus while similar sources of evidence are identified for reliability, engagement and effectiveness, they are weighted differently for each category. As noted above, EBP is informed by integrating best available evidence along with practitioner expertise and the values of recipients of the practice. Co-developing the proposed EBP framework with researchers, technology developers, practitioners and the autism community helps ensure that it will be useful for these communities (see [@bibr19-1362361319898331]; [@bibr40-1362361319898331]). However, different participant groups may have different levels of access to different kinds of evidence, which may lead to inconsistencies in the type of sources of information which will actually be used by different types of potential users. For example, researchers may have greater access to and expertise in interpreting academic papers, while educators and caregivers may have more experience supporting day-to-day use and evaluating the long-term utility of digital technologies. In addition, while the framework identified commonalities in what constitutes evidence, it is important to note that there may be additional sources of evidence that are also significant for only one of the participant groups. Finally, we found the Delphi study methodology to be an effective method for integrating potentially divergent perspectives into an agreed-upon framework. However, despite our number of participants being consistent with those proposed from previous research ([@bibr24-1362361319898331]; [@bibr38-1362361319898331]), our sample was relatively small given the heterogeneity of autism, and of stakeholder perspectives in the broader autism community. This needs to be borne in mind when considering if the framework is suitable for the entire autism community. Future work will apply this framework to digital supports for the autistic community, to identify the level of evidence available (complete, adequate, limited, none) from each source for reliability, engagement and effectiveness to highlight if the available evidence is strong, adequate or weak (after [@bibr45-1362361319898331]). An online version of the framework that enables researchers, developers and the autism community to evaluate the evidence base for any digital supports they are interested in is freely available at [beta-project.org](http://beta-project.org). Importantly, this framework identifies the strength (i.e. availability, quality) of the evidence, not the outcome of the evidence. It is possible, for example, that there could be strong evidence that an app is not engaging. For instance, [@bibr15-1362361319898331] conducted an RCT trial on a computerised support for training executive functions that yielded non-significant changes associated with high attrition rate in autistic participants, thus discouraging continuing practice. The framework developed here supports the sourcing and consideration of evidence into best practice, not necessarily what that best practice should be. Supplemental Material {#section15-1362361319898331} ===================== ###### AUT898331_Supplemental_material_Appendix_I -- Supplemental material for A framework of evidence-based practice for digital support, co-developed with and for the autism community ###### Click here for additional data file. Supplemental material, AUT898331_Supplemental_material_Appendix_I for A framework of evidence-based practice for digital support, co-developed with and for the autism community by Vanessa Zervogianni, Sue Fletcher-Watson, Gerardo Herrera, Matthew Goodwin, Patricia Pérez-Fuster, Mark Brosnan and Ouriel Grynszpan in Autism ###### AUT898331_Supplemental_material_Appendix_II -- Supplemental material for A framework of evidence-based practice for digital support, co-developed with and for the autism community ###### Click here for additional data file. Supplemental material, AUT898331_Supplemental_material_Appendix_II for A framework of evidence-based practice for digital support, co-developed with and for the autism community by Vanessa Zervogianni, Sue Fletcher-Watson, Gerardo Herrera, Matthew Goodwin, Patricia Pérez-Fuster, Mark Brosnan and Ouriel Grynszpan in Autism The authors thank all the panel members who participated in the Delphi study. Without their input, the project would not have been possible. **Declaration of conflicting interests:** The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. **Funding:** The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: We are grateful to FIRAH who funded the study (Grant: APa2016_026: <https://www.firah.org/>). **ORCID iDs:** Vanessa Zervogianni  <https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0638-4087> Sue Fletcher-Watson  <https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2688-1734> Mark Brosnan  <https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0683-1492> **Supplemental material:** Supplemental material for this article is available online.

\section{Introduction} Redundant robots---which have more \gls{DoF} than required for a task---have been widely studied and deployed due to their intrinsic flexibility. The higher dimensionality of the joint configuration space \gls{wrt} the task space makes these systems more adaptable as multiple solutions can be found. \input{figures/fig-intro.tex} However, this flexibility introduces a higher complexity for both planning and control that rapidly increases with the system and task dimensionality. For example, computing the joint configuration from a task-space pose, i.e. \gls{IK}, becomes increasingly more challenging with the increase of the redundancy dimension \cite{siciliano,d2001learning}. This problem is also encountered when dealing with the inverse dynamics problem, which is used to derive the control laws used in interaction control \cite{siciliano,xin2020,keppler2018}. To address these inverse problems in rigid systems, multiple optimization frameworks and approaches to deal with challenges arising from numerical conditioning have been developed. Currently, inverse problems for soft robots\footnote{Here, we use soft robots to refer both to systems made from non-rigid materials as well as those with compliant control, e.g., collaborative robots.} and optimization of the task-space dynamics are still open problems \cite{bruder2019}. A recent approach to robustness for achieving task-space compliance behaviors include systems for increasing the robustness of projections through software by modulating/adapting the references \cite{xin2020}. This robustness can also be achieved by exploiting more complex hardware design that embeds variable mechanical compliance directly into the robot structure and its actuation \cite{keppler2018,braun2013robots}. As an example, \textit{Keppler et al.} have proposed a control architecture that enables to retain both robustness and accurate tracking \cite{keppler2018} while related work has algorithmically optimised spatiotemporal modulation of impedance to achieve tasks more efficientl \cite{nakanishi2011stiffness}. These approaches takes advantages of hardware equipped with Variable Stiffness Actuators (VSAs) --which allows better dynamic performances from the hardware, but they also increase the complexity and cost of motion planning with these system besides the need for very accurate modelling of the VSA structures. \input{figures/fig-conceptual-overview.tex} Inverse kinematics solutions and task-space dynamics projections are required for controlling redundant robots and they share similar challenges, as analyzed in depth in \cite{dietrich2015,khatib1993,Vijayakumar-RSS-19}. In summary, both problems rely on the inversion of the Jacobian matrix, which is non-square in redundant manipulator due to the different task and joint space dimensions \cite{siciliano}. The pseudo-inverse is a transformation that solves such a problem. It separates the information regarding robot states into two orthogonal sub-spaces (task-space and null-space), which are not expected to exchange information (i.e., energy). Therefore, retaining the orthogonality between these two sub-spaces is paramount for the algorithms' stability \cite{dietrich2015,khatib1993,Vijayakumar-RSS-19}. Maintaining this orthogonality depends on both the robot kinematics and the task -- which can be quite difficult to achieve and maintain, especially during highly variable situations, such as sudden changes in contacts and dynamic interactions (\autoref{fig:intro}). As one example, the dynamically consistent inverse obtains orthogonality via the minimization of the kinetic energy projected by the null-space into the task-space \cite{Vijayakumar-RSS-19, khatib1987unified}. Passive controllers have been proposed to theoretically guarantee interaction stability under uncertain interaction conditions, using for instance virtual tanks as energy storage (i.e., path integral) for the non-conservative energy of the controller. However, their passive behavior trades-off tracking performances to retain safety of interaction, making this framework difficult to deploy in highly variable environments \cite{Dietrich2016}. The result presented in their manuscript focuses on verifying passivity and safety of interaction and does not provide a clear quantitative analysis of task-space tracking performance. However, based on the figure of the Cartesian tracking error reported for the simulation results for a 4-\gls{DoF} planar manipulator, it seems that we can expect about \SI{1}{\centi\meter} residual pose error in the best case scenario (i.e., there is energy in tank). Moreover, virtual tank impedance controllers are only passive if there is energy left in their virtual tanks. Due to passivity constraints, the tanks' energy can be only charged from external energy sources \cite{Dietrich2016}. Realising passive control is made even more difficult when dealing with null-space and task-space controllers. In fact, as they are orthogonal to each other, tracking the total energy exchanged by the manipulator is challenging \cite{babarahmati2019}. Another challenge to stability of virtual tank controllers is to maintain the orthogonality between null-space and task-spaces during highly variable tasks. Higher non-linearity in the dynamics reduces the accuracy in the computation of the orthogonal projection that, consequentially, generates unaccounted energy transfer between the two sub-spaces \cite{Vijayakumar-RSS-19,babarahmati2019}. This work investigates the possibility of using superimposition of passive task-space controllers to drive redundant manipulators rather than relying on null-space controllers, cf. \autoref{fig:conceptual_overview}. Conceptually, this follows the idea to generate task-space wrenches at multiple links and map them back to joint-level torques. To do so, the proposed solution will not need to rely on any mathematical projections (and implicitly, matrix inversions) required by the null-space projections. Virtual mechanical constraints are instead generated using a superimposition of task-space controllers to control task-space and the redundant degrees of freedom of the manipulators. However, implementing such a solution will require a controller framework that is intrinsically stable. The recently proposed \gls{FIC} \cite{babarahmati2019} is a passive controller meeting this requirement. It relies upon a non-linear stiffness behavior in the task-space to track the energy exchanged between the robot and the environment, and treats the unexpected energy flow from the null-space as an external perturbation. The controller uses the concept of fractal impedance for the implementation of a passive controller that can provide good performances in both trajectory and force tracking. Thereby, it detaches the robot stability from the postural optimization, which are currently bounded for interaction controllers relying on \gls{QP} optimization \cite{xin2020}. Furthermore, our proposed method is independent of any specific type of actuation and thus can be used in any torque/force controlled robot. In summary, our contributions are: \begin{enumerate} \item \emph{Superimposition of Passive Task-Space Controllers} to preserve the primary task by sacrificing a secondary tasks through exploitation of the mechanical redundancy. The priority of the controller is determined by the maximum force exertable by the controller, as will be explained in \autoref{sec:method}. As the framework only relies on the forward computation of kinematics and Jacobian, it is numerically stable and computationally inexpensive. Further, it can be used with uncertain and imprecise dynamics models as it only relies on the kinematics model (\ref{sec:StackOfFIC}). \item Proposal of a new force profile for a Fractal Attractor which enables a smooth transition between convergence and divergence phases (\ref{sec:SigFractImp}). \item Validation of our approach both in simulation to test contact interaction with unknown obstacles and in real hardware experiments (\ref{sec:experiments}) to evaluate reference tracking performance for fast reference motion (\ref{sec:results}). As all open parameters have a physically tractable meaning and the controller is intrinsically stable, online tuning can safely be performed. \end{enumerate} We intend to open source our implementation for simulation and hardware experiments with the publication of this manuscript. \section{Method} \label{sec:method} The null-space of a redundant manipulator is a set of joint-space configurations having the same end-effector pose. Therefore, null-space optimization frameworks identify the optimal joint-space configuration for a given task. Stack of Task optimization methods are iterative algorithms applying Null-Space optimization to a hierarchy of tasks. Their main limitation is that null-space projections are inserted in the control loop, rendering the controllers susceptible to numerical instability connected with the null-space projections. The proposed method, shown in \autoref{fig:conceptual_overview}, aims to remove null-space projections from the control loop. Null-space projections are used to account for the external interaction in the whole-body control optimization problem \cite{xin2020}. This type of formulation requires not only to make \textit{a priori} assumptions on the environmental interaction, but it also renders the controller stability dependent on their accuracy. Thus, the controller stability is highly susceptible to erroneous assumptions, which lead only to sub-optimal behaviour in the best case scenario \cite{xin2020}. The proposed method unravels the co-dependency between stability and assumptions made on the external environment by using a superimposition of task-space controllers that generates virtual force field (i.e., soft mechanical constraints) that pull the robot towards the desired configuration. This is a different approach to handling redundancy compared to the null-space approach. The superimposition of the controller will bias the robot to move towards a certain preferred posture, without guaranteeing that this particular configuration will be reached. In fact, the controller will continuously maintain a mechanical equilibrium between the virtual forces and the environmental interaction without requiring any assumption on the environmental interaction. This implies that the controller is robust to unknown environmental interaction, but is not guaranteed to be in a global optimum. However, it is likely to settle in the closest minimum in the system energetic manifold (i.e., the closest state with mechanical equilibrium). In synthesis, the relative strength of these virtual constraints will determine the trade-off between the tasks assigned to the controllers and, consequentially, the order in which the task accuracy will be sacrificed. While this method can be applied with any type of task-space controllers, using passive controllers guarantees stability by independently verifying that all the superimposed controllers are stable. Among the different passive controllers, we have chosen the Fractal Impedance Controller due to its explicit formulation of the tasks in terms of virtual mechanical constraints (i.e., desired force/displacement behavior), enabling direct control of the controllers' trade-off policies. For the scope of this paper, an optimization-based inverse kinematics algorithm was used to obtain the reference configuration (\emph{postural optimization}). Forward kinematics is subsequently used to extract the task-space references for the individual superimposed controllers. In place of this postural optimization, more comprehensive planners and frameworks could be used to provide and update the reference configurations. \subsection{Inverse Problem and Kineto-Static Duality} \label{sec:IPM} The generalized inverse of $A \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times m}$ is defined as any matrix $G\in \mathbb{R}^{m \times n}$ that satisfies the following equations: \begin{equation} \label{Ginverse} \begin{cases} \vec{a}=G \vec{b}+ (I_{n}-GA)\vec{a}_\epsilon=G \vec{b}+ P \vec{a}_\epsilon\\ AGA-A=0 \end{cases} \end{equation} where $\vec{a} \in \mathbb{R}^{n}$, $\vec{b} \in \mathbb{R}^{m}$, $\vec{a}_\epsilon \in \mathbb{R}^{n}$ and $I_n \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$ is the identity matrix. $P$ is a projection matrix that projects a generic vector $a_\epsilon$ into the null-space of $A$, $\mathcal{N}(A)$. Redundant robots are more flexible than non-redundant systems, however, they do not have a bijective transformation between generalized coordinates and task-space. Thus, control algorithms rely on numerical optimization to solve the inverse problem and identify viable strategies. This is task dependent and degenerates when $A$ drops rank (i.e., $det(A)=0$) \cite{Vijayakumar-RSS-19,xin2020}. Specifically, the rank of the inverse projection matrix drops if the robot is in a singular configuration or the task constraints are violated (e.g., unexpected sudden loss of contact) \cite{Vijayakumar-RSS-19}. The idea of taking advantage of the kineto-static duality to address the inverse problem has been introduced with the concept of Port-Hamiltonian control in \cite{hogan1985impedanceP1,hogan1985impedanceP2}. In fact, the kinematic joint-space information can be used to derive task-space behavior and task-space force interaction can be used to relate back to joint-space torques: \begin{equation} \label{kinetostatic} \begin{cases} \vec{\nu}=J \dot{\vec{q}} \\ \vec{\tau}=J^\text{T} \vec{h} \end{cases} \end{equation} where $J\in \mathbb{R}^{n \times m}$ is the geometric Jacobian matrix, $\vec{\nu} \in \mathbb{R}^n$ is the end-effector twist, $\vec{\dot{q}} \in \mathbb{R}^m$ is the joint velocities' vector and $\vec{h} \in \mathbb{R}^n$ is the end-effector wrench, $\vec{\tau} \in \mathbb{R}^m$ is the joint torques' vector. \subsection{Fractal Impedance Controller} \label{sec:FractImp} \input{figures/fig-fractal-impedance.tex} The FIC controls the robot as a non-linear mass-spring system, and generates the attractor in \autoref{fig:2b} around the desired state. The equivalent mechanical system equation is: \begin{equation*} \Lambda_c (\vec{q}) \vec{\Ddot{x}} + n(q,\dot{q}) + K(\vec{\tilde{x}}) \vec{\tilde{x}}=F_{Ext} \end{equation*} \noindent where $\Lambda_c (\vec{q})$ is the projection of the task-space inertia matrix at the end-effector, $n(q,\dot{q})$ the non-linear robot dynamics and $F_{Ext}$ is the external force. The state-dependent stiffness gain $K(\vec{\tilde{x}})$ is derived from the desired end-effector interaction properties (i.e., force/displacement), which can be regulated online without affecting stability \cite{babarahmati2019}. For completeness, we provide a proof of stability in \ref{sec:stabilityAnalysis}. The attractor is implemented using a switching behavior that introduces an additional nonlinear spring which triggers when the system starts converging (i.e., zero crossing of $\vec{\dot{x}}$). The updated impedance conserves the energy accumulated in the controller while diverging and redistributes the energy altering the trajectory during the convergence, as shown in \autoref{fig:fractal_attractor}. Therefore, the stability of the controller is guaranteed by the fractal attractor (\autoref{fig:fractal_attractor}). This determines the passivity of the controller and the online adaptability; it is independent of the chosen impedance. For each \gls{DoF} in the task-space, the \gls{FIC} is given in \autoref{alg:FIC}. The control torques ($\vec{\tau}_{\text{ctr}}$) can be calculated from $\vec{h}_e \in \mathbb{R}^6$ using \eqref{kinetostatic}. Differently from the \gls{FIC} control scheme introduced in \cite{babarahmati2019} on a sharp force/torque saturation, this manuscript introduces a more flexible force profile. The new force profile allows to independently tune the linear, non-linear and saturation behaviors of the controller wrench, making it easier to tune the controller for different tasks. \begin{algorithm} \SetAlgoLined \SetKwData{Left}{left} \SetKwData{Up}{up} \SetKwFunction{FindCompress}{FindCompress} \SetKwInOut{Input}{input} \SetKwInOut{Output}{output} \Input{Convergence$/$Divergence, $\tilde{x}$, $\tilde{x}_{\text{max}}$} \Output{$h_{\text{e}}$} \eIf{diverging from ${x_{\text{d}}}$}{ $h_{\text{e}}=f(\tilde{x})= K(\tilde{x})\tilde{x}$\\ }{ $h_{\text{e}} = \frac{4 E(\tilde{x}_{\text{max}})}{\tilde{x}_{\text{max}}^2} (0.5\tilde{x}_{\text{max}} -\tilde{x})$\\ } \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} where:\\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} ${x_{\text{d}}}$ is the desired position \\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} $h_{\text{e}}$ is the desired force at the end-effector \\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} $\tilde{x}$ is the pose error \\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} $K(\tilde{x})$ is the nonlinear stiffness\\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} $x_\text{e}$ is the end-effector position\\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} $\tilde{x}=x_\text{d}-x_\text{e}$ is the position error \\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} $\tilde{x}_{\text{max}}$ is the maximum displacement reached at the end of the divergence phase \\ \renewcommand{\nl}{\let\nl\oldnl} $E$ is the energy associated with the divergence profile of the impedance controller \\ \caption{Mono-dimensional \gls{FIC}} \label{alg:FIC} \end{algorithm} \subsection{Sigmoidal Force Profile for Fractal Impedance} \label{sec:SigFractImp} The \gls{FIC} relies on a stiffness profile. The profile proposed in \cite{babarahmati2019} results in fast changes in stiffness, and only allows limited task-dependent tuning of the profile. Therefore, we propose a sigmoidal force profile for an easier definition of the stiffness profile, allowing to better adapt the robot impedance behavior to the different task. Similarly to the profile proposed by \cite{babarahmati2019}, the sigmoidal profile is fully determined based on the maximum force ($F_{\text{Max}}$) to be exerted at a chosen position error ($|\tilde{x}|=\tilde{x}_{\text{b}}$). Here, the position error is defined as the difference between the desired end-effector pose and the current pose ($\tilde{x}=x_d-x$). We introduce an additional displacement parameter ($|\tilde{x}|=\tilde{x}_{0}$) which describes the minimum displacement to activate the nonlinear impedance, as shown in \autoref{fig:2c}. The proposed force profile thus becomes: \begin{equation} \label{ForceProf} F_{\text{K}}=\left\{ \begin{array}{ll} K_0 \tilde{x}, & |\tilde{x}|<\tilde{x}_{0}\\\\ \text{sgn} (\tilde{x}) (\Delta F (1-e^{-\frac{|\tilde{x}| - \tilde{x}_0}{b}})+& \\ + K_0 \tilde{x}_0), & \tilde{x}_{0}\le |\tilde{x}|<\tilde{x}_{b}\\\\ \text{sgn}(\tilde{x}) F_{\text{Max}}, & \text{Otherwise} \end{array}\right. \end{equation} where $b=(\tilde{x}_\text{b}-\tilde{x}_\text{0})/S$ is the characteristic length, $S$ determines the shape of the sigmoid curve and $\Delta F =(F_{\text{Max}} - K_0.\tilde{x}_0)$. In this work, we use $S=20$ to ensure force saturation before $\tilde{x}_\text{b}$. The proposed force profile can further be associated to an energy (\autoref{fig:2d}) that is an unbounded Lipschitz function. It therefore respects the requirement for Lyapunov's stability by the fractal attractor controller \cite{babarahmati2019}. For the proposed force profile, this becomes: \begin{equation} \label{EnergyProf} E_{\text{K}}=\left\{ \begin{array}{ll} 0.5 K_0 \tilde{x}^2, & |\tilde{x}|<\tilde{x}_{0}\\\\ F_{\text{Max}}|\tilde{x}| -&\\ +F_{\text{Max}}\tilde{x}_0 + (K_0\tilde{x}_0^2)/2 -&\\ +(1-e^{-\frac{|\tilde{x}| - \tilde{x}_0}{b}})b\Delta F, & \tilde{x}_{0}\le |\tilde{x}|<\tilde{x}_{b}\\\\ F_{\text{Max}}|\tilde{x}|-&\\ +F_{\text{Max}}\tilde{x}_0 + (K_0\tilde{x}_0^2)/2 -&\\ +(1-e^{-\frac{\tilde{x}_b - \tilde{x}_0}{b}})b\Delta F, & \text{Otherwise} \end{array}\right. \end{equation} \subsection{Controller Superimposition for the Control of Redundant Robots} \label{sec:StackOfFIC} We propose to implement the same solution using virtual soft mechanical constraints generated by a superimposition of task-space controllers that drive the robot to assume a commanded reference posture. The benefit of using impedance controllers based on fractal impedance is that their passivity allows for superimposition without compromising overall system stability. Therefore, the total torque vector ($\vec{\tau_{\text{tot}}}$) can be computed by the superimposition of controllers as: \begin{equation} \label{TControllerStack} \begin{array}{ll} \vec{\tau}_{\text{tot}}=\sum_{i=1}^n J_i^\text{T}h_{ei} \end{array} \end{equation} where $J_i$ and $h_{ei}$ are the Jacobian and the wrench generated by the impedance controller of the $i^{th}$-link, as depicted in \autoref{fig:conceptual_overview}. \section{Evaluation} \label{sec:experiments} We evaluate our proposed method using a 7-\gls{DoF} torque-controlled Kuka LWR3+ manipulator in both simulation and hardware experiments. We apply a superimposition of two task-space controllers: A 6-\gls{DoF} \gls{FIC} controller at the end-effector ($7^{th}$ link) and a 3-\gls{DoF} \gls{FIC} controller at the elbow ($4^{th}$ link of the KuKA URDF) for postural control. \input{figures/fig-simulation-overview.tex} \input{figures/TableI.tex} To generate pose references for each of the controllers, we perform an optimization to obtain a configuration satisfying the end-effector reference. Here, we use a one-step variant of \gls{AICO} \cite{toussaint2009robot}. Note, while the end-effector pose reference can be passed in directly to the end-effector controller, a postural optimization is used in this case to obtain a pose reference for the null-space or additional superimposed controllers. We extract the reference pose for each of the controllers using forward kinematics. \subsection{Reference Trajectories} The figure-of-8 (i.e., lemniscate) trajectory has been selected to show the dynamic behavior of the robot. The trajectory is composed of two orthogonal sinusoidal trajectories. The vertical trajectory has an amplitude of \SI{0.2}{\meter} and the transverse trajectory amplitude is \SI{0.1}{\meter}. The figure-of-8 trajectory is particularly demanding due to its multiple velocity inversions and wide joint movements range. Thus, introducing high variability of both the Jacobian and the inertial behavior of the robot. We test the figure-of-8 reference motion in both simulation and hardware experiments. In hardware experiments, we further test a sinusoidal trajectory with an amplitude of \SI{0.5}{\meter} and velocities up to about \SI{0.7}{\meter\per\second}. The straight-line experiment enabled us to test interaction and robustness at higher speeds. \subsection{Simulation Experiments} We simulate the robot using the Gazebo physics simulator and apply the Superimposition of Passive Task-Space Controllers control scheme directly without compensating for gravity, Coriolis, or other dynamic effects (in contrast to \cite{babarahmati2019}), i.e., as a model-free compliant controller. For the simulation experiments, we compare nominal tracking performance with an interaction scenario where an unsensed environment obstacle has been introduced, cf. \autoref{fig:gazebo_unsensed_force_interaction}. \subsection{Hardware Experiments} In our hardware experiments, we use a Kuka LWR3+ robot. We control the manipulator using the \gls{FRI} at \SI{333.3}{\hertz} in \emph{joint impedance} mode with all gains set to zero to enable feed-forward torque control. Note, unlike our simulation experiments the Kuka's built-in controller compensates for dynamic effects and gravity. On the real robot the tracking of the figure-of-8 trajectory has also been tested with and without a human operator applying random perturbations. The values used in the controller for the simulation and the experiments are reported in \autoref{CtrParam}. It shall also be noted that during the experiment we have kept the minimum set of controlled \gls{DoF} required to fully control the 3 \gls{DoF} of redundancy for the assigned tasks, being the task invariant to the configuration of the $7^{th}$ \gls{DoF} due to the symmetric geometry of the end-effector in the manipulator (\autoref{fig:intro}). \section{Results} \label{sec:results} \input{figures/fig-simulation-results.tex} \input{figures/fig-hw-results.tex} To complement the plots in this section, the reader is recommended to watch the supplementary video demonstrating the tracking and interaction both in simulation and hardware experiments. We also include a sequence demonstrating the safe behavior of the controller during calibration of the \gls{FIC} parameters given in \autoref{CtrParam}. The simulation results are shown in \autoref{fig:Sim_8-NOInt} for the free motion, and in \autoref{fig:Sim_8-WInt} for the interaction behavior. They show that the robot can be successfully controlled without dynamic compensation, and that it can achieve dexterous dynamic behaviors. The tracking \glspl{RMSE} at the end-effector are recorded without interaction as RMSE$_\text{x}=\SI{5.6}{\milli\meter}$, RMSE$_\text{y}=\SI{4.6}{\milli\meter}$, and RMSE$_\text{z}=\SI{6.1}{\milli\meter}$. For simulation with interaction with an obstacle: RMSE$_\text{x}=\SI{13.2}{\milli\meter}$, RMSE$_\text{y}=\SI{4.2}{\milli\meter}$, and RMSE$_\text{z}=\SI{5.5}{\milli\meter}$. I.e., the tracking performance degrades in one dimension impacted by the obstacle ($x$), while being virtually unaffected in $y$ and $z$. The experimental data for the hardware experiments of the figure-of-8 trajectory are shown in \autoref{8-NOInt} and \autoref{8-Int}. The errors recorded during free motion are: RMSE$_\text{x}=7.6$ \si{\milli\meter}, RMSE$_\text{y}=1.5$ \si{\milli\meter}, and RMSE$_\text{z}=8.6$ \si{\milli\meter}. The perturbations do not affect the tracking performance at the end-effector task, but they are fully compensated by the deflection from the secondary task target at the elbow joint, as shown in \autoref{8-Int}b. The \gls{RMSE} during interaction are RMSE$_\text{x}=20.3$ \si{\milli\meter}, RMSE$_\text{y}=7.9$ \si{\milli\meter}, and RMSE$_\text{z}=9.1$ \si{\milli \meter}. The results for the straight-line trajectory experiment (\autoref{Line-NoInt} and \autoref{line-Int}) show an ability of the controller to complete the task and reject perturbations by reducing tracking on the secondary task. The errors are RMSE$_\text{x}=6.1$ \si{\milli\meter}, RMSE$_\text{y}=4.6$ \si{\milli\meter}, and RMSE$_\text{z}=6.7$ \si{\milli \meter}. The RMSE for interaction are RMSE$_\text{x}=9.6$ \si{\milli\meter}, RMSE$_\text{y}=7.7$ \si{\milli\meter}, and RMSE$_\text{z}=7.3$ \si{\milli\meter}. It shall also be remarked how the robot remained safe to interact with despite the high joint feed-forward torques involved in the motions, which reached $\approx30$ \si{\newton\meter} for both the 8 trajectory and the linear trajectory. \section{Discussion} \label{sec:discussion} The results show the proposed method enables an intrinsically stable control framework for redundant robots which does not rely on inverse dynamics and projection matrices. The proposed method is robust to unknown environmental interactions and singularities, where safe means that the robot does not show erratic behaviors even while perturbed or when there is a sudden change in the desired task (e.g., sudden acceleration/deceleration). The RMSE data show how the robot keeps the minimum tracking accuracy (i.e., maximum error) contained under \SI{1}{\centi\meter} for the unperturbed experiments, which is in line with the task requirement set in the controller parameters $x_\text{b}=\SI{1.1}{\centi\meter}$. This results are in line with the results obtained in \cite{babarahmati2019}, and they are lower than other impedance controller frameworks that usually have error of few centimeters \cite{dietrich2015,Dietrich2016}. The introduction of significant perturbation degrades the minimum tracking accuracy to \SI{2}{\centi\meter}, but the controller remains stable and it is able to recover once the perturbation ends. It shall be remembered that the trade-off between accuracy and robustness is a known trade-off in interaction control frameworks \cite{ott2010unified}. While admittance control may provide better accuracy, it requires accurate knowledge of interaction force intensity and direction in all the points of contact with the environment. On the other hand, impedance controllers provide better safety of interaction but sacrifice tracking accuracy in favor of compliance \cite{ott2010unified,xin2020}. Variable impedance controllers have been proposed as a solution to this dilemma, but the stability requirements on the impedance updates are often very stringent and difficult to retain under highly variable environmental conditions \cite{angelini2019online,li2018force}. The proposed framework provides the better of both worlds providing good tracking accuracy while retaining the robustness typical of impedance controllers; furthermore, it enables online adjustment of the impedance profiles \cite{babarahmati2019}. The data also confirm our hypothesis that redundant robot interaction behavior can be accurately defined without any \textit{a priori} knowledge of the system dynamics model, being \autoref{TControllerStack} the control command. In our simulation experiments, we show that the tracking performance in this work is similar to the results reported in \cite{babarahmati2019} that relied on a compensation of the robot dynamics and the use of a null-space controller. This latest result is particularly important because robots' mechanical properties such as inertia and joints friction matrices are often difficult to retrieve and highly unreliable \cite{bruder2019, vasudevan2017}. The knowledge of the actuation characteristics and the kinematic structure are still necessary for the implementation of the proposed method. However, they are both normally accurate, and easier to obtain if not available. \input{figures/fig-hw-results-straight-line.tex} The FIC controller generates an asymptotically stable potential field around the target state that enables direct superimposition of multiple controllers without compromising the system stability. The controller superimposition generates a force field that acts as a trade-off cost function determining the preferred path of motion in robot's configuration space. The force upper-bound of the controllers guarantees that the loss of accuracy in the main task is contained $x_\text{b}$ until the condition are compatible with the mechanical characteristics of the system. Especially, if we consider that the proposed method is a compliant postural controller, where accurate tracking is subordinate to robustness of interaction. In other words, the controller stabilizes the robot around a desired posture relying on the non-linear stiffness profile to compensate for its non-linear and environmental interaction, sacrificing the redundancy task before degrading the end-effector task beyond the selected accuracy. This is confirmed by both the simulation and the experimental data, showing how the FIC controller tries and successfully keeps the accuracy under \SI{0.11}{\centi\meter} in unperturbed conditions. The data also describe that the controller fully sacrifices the redundancy task in the attempt of retaining the same accuracy while experiencing external perturbation that exceed its mechanical limits, as shown in \autoref{fig:Sim_8-WInt}, \autoref{8-Int} and \autoref{line-Int}. The data show that the proposed method can achieve a highly dynamic interaction using variable impedance at the controller level. The FIC also enables online tuning of the impedance behavior and is robust to reduce bandwidth in the feedback signals \cite{babarahmati2019}, allowing to switch from rigid to soft behaviors seemingly. Nevertheless, the performances are strictly related to the physical hardware capabilities, and a higher band-pass in the mechanics of the robot implies a higher stiffness to mass ratio. Therefore, it will be interesting to study these capabilities by deploying in hardware equipped with VSA to conduct a systematic experiment on these properties. Furthermore, it may also enable the switching from a model-based (e.g., the one proposed in \cite{keppler2018}) to a data-driven control of their non-linear actuators dynamics. It is worth also noting that, at the current stage, it is impossible to compare the results of these types of architectures due to their different hardware requirements. Nevertheless, we can say that both of them achieve non-linear impedance behavior and robustness to highly dynamic interactions. The fractal impedance controller hardware requirements are less stringent, and it has a simpler formulation. The results presented in \cite{keppler2018} indicate that the DLR robot can achieve a stiffer behavior. However, it is impossible to discriminate if they are connected solely to a hardware superiority or there is also a controller component in play. The superimposition of task-space controllers also opens new possibilities for improving controllability and dexterity for compliant robots, developing human motor control theory, and robust control architecture for learning algorithms. In fact, the dynamics of soft robots are even more challenging to model than rigid dynamics \cite{bruder2019}, as the dynamic modelling of robots is founded on the assumption of rigidity \cite{siciliano}. In regards to human motor control, having a framework that enables robustness and dexterity of interaction will enable to overcome the current limitation of the \gls{PMP} model, which still relies on inverse matrices for trajectory optimization \cite{tommasino2017,tiseo2018}. Finally, the learning algorithms are currently facing the challenges of performing a system identification to guarantee the stability of the learned behavior. The proposed method removes this challenge and the learning component can focus on learning how to synchronize the task-space controller to maximize the efficiency and the dexterity of the robot. \section{Conclusions} \label{sec:conclusion} The experimental results confirmed our hypothesis that it is possible to control a redundant robot with a superimposition of task-space controllers. This approach renders the architecture intrinsically robust to singularity and fully passive which guarantees stability. It is important to properly balance the strength of the controllers to guarantee that the secondary tasks do not interfere with the end-effector controller, which may result challenging under certain conditions. Nevertheless, unbalanced controllers may interfere with the action efficacy, but not with the robustness and stability of interaction. The proposed framework does not require any \textit{a priori} knowledge of the system dynamics parameters (i.e., Inertia, Friction, and Gravity). It suited for applications where the stability of interaction to unpredictable environments is more important than the tracking accuracy. Future work will focus on improving the coordination among the secondary task-space controllers to improve the tracking accuracy of the end-effector task as well as systems were coupling effects may be introduced. \section*{To do list} \begin{itemize} \item Finalise Simulations Method \item Add a figure with task-space controllers representation \item Revise Introduction to be aligned with final message \item Run Simulations and Write Results down results \item Write Discussion, Conclusion and Abstract \item (Gazebo) Check if we should add the viscous dissipation as in \cite{babarahmati2019} to account for model errors \end{itemize} \section*{Potential contributions} \begin{itemize} \item \cite{babarahmati2019} uses a fixed null-space resolution term in Alg. 1. Here, we use a Stack of FICs to get around the null-space resolution. \item "Claim increase robustness to unpredicted/unknown obstacles. Obviously, the target has to be within the reach of the terminal part of the manipulator" \item tbc: Dealing with orientations - we may want to look into this closer \item Model-free impedance controller - to the best of our knowledge the first implementation/demonstration of this [comparison to previous: Previous used a model-based gravity compensation; our work does not. It can also be used to play arbitrary trajectories] \end{itemize}

Note: Supplemental figure and tables appear at [www.ajtmh.org](http://www.ajtmh.org). Disclaimer: The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the article. INTRODUCTION {#s1} ============ In Indonesia, the greatest prevalence of malaria is in the eastern provinces of Nusa Tenggara Timur and Papua.^[@b1]^ Great progress has been made in reducing the burden of malaria with the majority (74%) of the Indonesian population residing in malaria-free areas. However, 12% of the population still reside in areas with a malaria incidence greater than one case per 1,000 per year,^[@b2]^ and these individuals are at increased risk of malaria associated anemia.^[@b3],[@b4]^ Until 2006, the first line policy was chloroquine plus sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine and a single dose of primaquine for uncomplicated *Plasmodium falciparum* malaria, and chloroquine plus primaquine (total dose 3.5 mg/kg over 14 days) for radical cure for *Plasmodium vivax* with the exception of infants less than 1 year of age and pregnant or lactating women for whom chloroquine alone was recommended.^[@b5]^ In 2005, clinical trials in Papua, Indonesia, highlighted very high levels of antimalarial drug resistance to the recommended treatment regimens with recrudescent *P. falciparum* and recurrent *P. vivax* infections exceeding 40% by day 28 after treatment.^[@b5]--[@b7]^ Dihydroartemisinin-piperaquine (DHP) was shown to be highly effective against both species.^[@b8],[@b9]^ In response, national policy was changed in March 2006 to the fixed dose artemisinin combination therapy (ACT) of DHP for uncomplicated malaria due to any species of malaria.^[@b8],[@b9]^ The recommendation of single dose primaquine for *P. falciparum* remained, whereas the dose of primaquine recommended for *P. vivax* was increased to a total of 7 mg/kg over 14 days. The policy also stipulated that antimalarial treatment should only be given after laboratory confirmation, which was not a recommendation before 2006. Before the change in policy, a cross-sectional household survey was undertaken in 2005, which documented that 42% of individuals reported having had a febrile illness in the preceding month, for which they sought treatment multiple times, often at different healthcare facilities.^[@b10]^ Only 46% of these individuals reported seeking treatment at a public provider, despite provision of treatment for free in the public sector. Most households reported a monthly income less than US\$500, hence each individual's fever episode resulted a cost of at least 11% of the household income.^[@b10]^ After policy change, the DHP was provided free of charge at public health facilities but was also available at a cost in the private sector. Changes in antimalarial policy can potentially impact the overall burden and transmission of malaria not only through the direct impact of switching to a more effective treatment but also through increasing the community's trust in the public health care system and the subsequent shifts in treatment-seeking behavior. The aim of this study was to describe the changes in treatment-seeking behavior for fever and burden of disease in Papua after policy change to ACT for all species of malaria. MATERIALS AND METHODS {#s2} ===================== Household surveys were conducted in Mimika Regency, southern Papua, Indonesia, in 2005 and 2013. The methods in 2013 were based on the 2005 survey which has been reported previously.^[@b10]^ Minor differences between the questionnaires included the collection of household income as a range rather than a specific estimate and information on bed net use by individuals rather than ownership by the household. The demographics, malaria transmission, and health services in this region have been described previously.^[@b3],[@b4],[@b11]^ In brief, the district covers an area of 21,522 km^2^ with a population of approximately 120,457 in 2005 expanding to 202,350 in 2013. Most of the population resides in 12 districts, incorporating Timika town and the surrounding villages. The area is covered with thick rain forest with both coastal and mountainous areas, inhabited by a variety of ethnic groups which are broadly categorized as lowland Papuans, highland Papuans, or non-Papuans. Malaria transmission occurs throughout the year and is restricted to the lowland area where most of the population lives. There are three mosquito vectors: *Anopheles koliensis*, *Anopheles farauti*, and *Anopheles punctulatus*. Healthcare provision is provided free of charge at public providers, which includes one hospital, 12 Government-funded Primary Health Clinics (Puskesmas), and 10 malaria control clinics provided by a local mining company. In 2008, a second hospital was opened, providing care to approximately 100,000 patients per year. Antimalarials can also be purchased in the private sector, including clinics, pharmacies, and drug stores.^[@b12]^ Diagnostic tests for malaria are available in the private sector but usually not in drug stores. The household sampling strategy was the same for both surveys with 800 households sampled using a three-stage cluster sampling procedure to identify 32 clusters of 25 households.^[@b10],[@b13]^ First, the four most populous subdistricts (Mimika Baru, Kuala Kencana, Iwaka, Kwamki Narama, and Wania) were chosen from the 12 subdistricts based on their accessibility by road from the main town of Timika and because they included the majority (80%) of the district's population. The 2013 survey took place in similar geographic areas as the 2005 survey, but during the intervening years some of the subdistricts had been renamed. Second, the number of clusters in each subdistrict was apportioned according to their relative populations. The houses were then assigned numbers based on their geographical location, and clusters of 25 houses were identified. The 2013 survey was conducted in the months of April through July, whereas the 2005 survey was conducted between the months of July and December. Household members were defined as all individuals living under one roof and who ate from one kitchen. If a selected household was empty, the interviewer returned the next day. If still unoccupied, the next occupied household was sampled instead. As the recall period for the survey was fever in the previous month, temporary migrants who had moved into the area within the preceding month were excluded from the survey. Ethics. ------- This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the National Institutes of Health research and Development, Indonesian Ministry of Health and the Human Research (KS.02.01.2.1.2684), University of Gadjah Mada (KE/FK/763/EC), and the Ethics Committee of Northern Teritorry Department of Health and Community Services and Menzies School of Health Research, Darwin, Australia (HREC 04/47 and 10-1434). Written informed consent was obtained from all adult participants and parents of enrolled children. Data collection. ---------------- The head of the household or another suitable adult was asked questions about the household and its members. Those members who were present at the time of the survey underwent a brief examination. Capillary or venous blood samples were collected for blood film examination. Symptomatic illness was defined as a history of fever in the past 24 hours or an axillary temperature of 37.5°C or higher when examined. Nearly all surveys were conducted in Bahasa Indonesian and the remaining in a local Papuan language. Individuals reporting a history of fever in the preceding 30 days were asked to complete a separate module with detailed questions on treatment-seeking if they were present. This module comprised questions on all of the places where they had sought treatment, whether they had received a blood test, whether they were prescribed antimalarials or other medicines, and any associated costs to the households. Data analysis. -------------- Data were analyzed using the STATA statistical software (version 14.2, StataCorp, College Station, TX)^[@b14]^ and R (version 3.2.3).^[@b15]^ A Discriminant Analysis of Principal Components was used to categorize households by socioeconomic status (SES) by data on reported ownership of assets.^[@b10],[@b16]^ To ensure that sufficient time had elapsed to capture treatment-seeking behavior, those individuals reporting fever starting within the preceding 2 days were excluded from the analysis of treatment seeking. For the use of diagnostics, laboratory tests, and antimalarial prescriptions, each patient--provider interaction ("visit") was analyzed for public and private healthcare providers. Frequencies and percentages were used for the descriptive data. Percentages were compared using the χ^2^ test. Differences in outcome distributions were evaluated with the Mann--Whitney test. Continuous variables were compared using the Spearman's rank for correlation. When less than five observations were seen in a category, categorical outcomes were compared using the Fisher's Exact test. Simple logistic regression adjusted for clustering by households was used to calculate odds ratios (ORs) for comparisons within the 2013 survey. For the analysis of reported fever in the past month, significant risk factors (*P* \< 0.05) in the univariate analysis were included in a multiple logistic regression model and significant interactions between age, ethnicity, and significant variables were reported. The 2005 and 2013 surveys were compared using adjusted odds ratios (AORs) for age (0--4, 5--14, 15+), gender, household SES, and ethnicity (non-Papuan, highland Papuan, and lowland Papuan). The models were adjusted for clustering by household. Costs were gathered in Indonesian rupiah converted into United States Dollars (US\$) using the average exchange rates^[@b17],[@b18]^ and then revised to the 2014 equivalent using the consumer price index for Indonesia.^[@b19]^ The mean cost and standard deviation (SD) per fever episode are reported. Direct costs included transportation for the patient and care and treatment, which included consultations, diagnosis, medication, overnight stay, and any other payments. Indirect costs included the amount of time that usual activities were reduced for the individual and any companions, caretakers, or substitute laborers. This time was valued using the mean reported wage for all. RESULTS {#s3} ======= Household characteristics. -------------------------- A total of 800 households with 4,010 individuals were included in the 2013 survey ([Figure 1](#f1){ref-type="fig"}). The baseline characteristics for both the 2005 and 2013 surveys are provided in [Table 1](#t1){ref-type="table"}. In 2013, the median household size was five individuals (interquartile range \[IQR\] = 4--6) with a maximum of 13 in one house. The median duration that heads of households reported residing at their current location was 13 years (IQR = 6--20), with 23 (3%) households reporting a move into that location within the previous year. In 2005, the household size was six individuals (IQR = 4--8) with a median duration of 9 years (IQR = 4--15). Of the 781 households in which monthly household income was reported, 52% (403) estimated US\$560 or less. The households were categorized into five SES groups, with the number of households in each group ranging from 91 to 296. While poorer households were more likely to grow their own crops and drink rain water, richer households were more likely to own motorcycles and large electrical items and drink bought water ([Supplemental Figure 1](/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0680#supplementary_data)). The poorest SES group was composed of a greater percentage of highland Papuans (32%, 47/145) compared with 19% (35/189) of lowland Papuans and 3% (15/465) of non-Papuans (*P* \< 0.001). The estimated household general health expenditure was correlated with the number of individuals reporting fever in a household (ρ = 0.488, *P* \< 0.001). {#f1} ###### Demographic characteristics of all household members and individuals present during surveys in 2005 and 2013 2005 2013 ------------------------------------------------------- ------------- ------------- ------------------------------------- --------------- Age (years)  0--4 870 (17%) 820 (21%) 629 (16%) 559 (20%)  5--14 1,101 (21%) 824 (21%) 970 (24%) 666 (24%)  15+ 3,284 (62%) 2,252 (58%) 2,404 (60%) 1,604 (57%)  Not reported -- -- 7 (0.2%) 1 (0.04%) Sex (female) 2,409 (46%) 2,019 (52%) 2,035 (51%) 1,668 (59%) Pregnant (yes) 92 (2%) 87 (2%) --[\*](#t1fn1){ref-type="table-fn"} 45/2,825 (2%) Place of birth  Highland Papuan 1,494 (28%) 1,045 (27%) 733 (18%) 539 (19%)  Lowland Papuan 1,371 (26%) 1,024 (26%) 1,039 (26%) 751 (27%)  Non-Papuan 2,390 (45%) 1,827 (47%) 2,238 (56%) 1,540 (54%) Resided in lowlands for more than 1 year? (yes) 4,969 (95%) 3,674 (94%) 3,862 (96%) 2,711 (96%) Subdistrict  Banti 152 (3%) 119 (3%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)  Harapan and Kwamki Lama 901 (17%) 576 (15%) 111 (3%) 80 (3%)  Inauga 521 (10%) 405 (10%) 383 (10%) 291 (10%)  Kamoro Jaya 354 (7%) 273 (7%) 369 (9%) 257 (9%)  Kadun Jaya, Kaugapu and Pigapu 371 (7%) 286 (7%) 267 (7%) 210 (7%)  Limau Asri, Iwaka, Mulia Kencana and Naena Muktipura 136 (3%) 112 (3%) 506 (13%) 334 (12%)  Koperapoka 957 (18%) 729 (19%) 753 (19%) 521 (18%)  Timika Jaya, Kwamki and Kwamki Baru 1,407 (27%) 1,046 (27%) 989 (25%) 696 (25%)  Wonosari Jaya and Nawaripi 122 (2%) 98 (3%) 374 (9%) 267 (9%)  Karang Senang and Bhintuka 334 (6%) 252 (6%) 258 (6%) 174 (6%) Not reported. History of fever and parasite positivity of household members. -------------------------------------------------------------- Of the 2,830 (71%) individuals present at the time of the interview in 2013, 41% (1,162) were male, 43% (1,225) were under the age of 15, and 46% (1,290) were Papuan ([Table 1](#t1){ref-type="table"}). Overall, 4% (117/2,830) of individuals reported having had a febrile illness in the preceding month compared with 42% (1,631/3,896) in 2005 (AOR = 0.06, 95% confidence interval \[CI\] = 0.05--0.08, *P* \< 0.001; [Table 2](#t2){ref-type="table"}). Non-Papuan participants were at a significantly higher risk for having had a febrile illness compared with highland Papuans (AOR = 1.84, 95% CI = 1.05--3.26, *P* = 0.035; [Supplemental Table 1](/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0680#supplementary_data)). ###### Fever reporting in those who were present during the survey in 2005 and 2013 2005 2013 ------------------------------------------------------- ------------- ----------- ------------ ----------- Age (years)  0--4 405 (25%) 205 (25%) 23 (20%) 15 (15%)  5--14 306 (19%) 148 (18%) 29 (25%) 26 (26%)  15+ 920 (56%) 481 (58%) 65 (56%) 58 (59%) Sex (female) 850 (52%) 433 (52%) 63 (54%) 55 (56%) Pregnant (yes) 39 (2%) 23 (3%) 3/116 (3%) 3/98 (3%) Place of birth  Highland Papuan 385 (24%) 172 (21%) 14 (12%) 11 (11%)  Lowland Papuan 463 (28%) 183 (22%) 28 (24%) 19 (19%)  Non-Papuan 783 (48%) 479 (57%) 75 (64%) 69 (70%) Resided in lowlands for more than 1 year? (yes) 1,547 (95%) 797 (96%) 111 (95%) 93 (94%) Subdistrict  Banti 29 (2%) 18 (2%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)  Harapan and Kwamki Lama 226 (14%) 124 (15%) 4 (3%) 2 (2%)  Inauga 183 (11%) 106 (13%) 5 (4%) 5 (5%)  Kamoro Jaya 107 (7%) 77 (9%) 12 (10%) 10 (10%)  Kadun Jaya, Kaugapu and Pigapu 108 (7%) 11 (1%) 23 (20%) 14 (14%)  Limau Asri, Iwaka, Mulia Kencana and Naena Muktipura 55 (3%) 3 (0.4%) 15 (13%) 15 (15%)  Koperapoka 396 (24%) 127 (15%) 13 (11%) 12 (12%)  Timika Jaya, Kwamki and Kwamki Baru 383 (23%) 262 (31%) 16 (14%) 14 (14%)  Wonosari Jaya and Nawaripi 49 (3%) 39 (5%) 24 (21%) 23 (23%)  Karang Senang and Bhintuka 95 (6%) 67 (8%) 5 (4%) 4 (4%) Overall, 12% (348/2,795) of individuals who consented to blood testing in 2013 were parasitemic, a slight reduction from 16% (634/3,890) in 2005 (AOR = 0.83, 95% CI = 0.69--0.99, *P* = 0.038). The change in prevalence was most apparent in individuals with symptomatic parasitemia which decreased from 5% (200/3,890) in 2005 to 1% (21/2,795) in 2013 (AOR = 0.16, 95% CI = 0.10--0.26, *P* \< 0.001), whereas the prevalence of asymptomatic parasitemia was similar in both surveys: 11% (434/3,890) in 2005 and 12% (327/2,795) in 2013 (AOR = 1.20, 95% CI = 0.98--1.45, *P* = 0.073). Individuals reporting a febrile illness in the past month were significantly more likely to be parasitemic in the 2005 survey (OR = 3.81, 95% CI = 3.10--4.68, *P* \< 0.001); however, this was not significant in the 2013 survey (OR = 1.53, 95% CI = 0.89--2.61, *P* = 0.123). The prevalence of parasitemia in each subdistrict is presented in [Supplemental Table 2](/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0680#supplementary_data). Treatment-seeking behavior. --------------------------- In 2013, treatment-seeking behavior was assessed in 98% (115/117) of participants reporting a fever in the preceding month, and in 94% (108/115) of these individuals the fever commenced at least 2 days before the survey ([Figure 1](#f1){ref-type="fig"}). Individuals were more likely to take some form of medicine for their fever in 2013 with 92% (99/108) reporting taking medication compared with 76% (834/1,104) of those whose fever commenced at least 2 days before the survey in 2005 (AOR = 2.50, 95% CI = 1.23--5.06, *P* = 0.011). Of the 99 patients who reported taking a medication, only 1% (1) did not seek treatment outside of the home, compared with 8% (70/834) in 2005 (*P* = 0.004). In 2013, 67% (66/98) of individuals seeking treatment outside of the home attended a public provider at least once compared with 46% (349/764) in 2005 (AOR = 4.30, 95% CI = 2.54--7.28, *P* \< 0.001). Furthermore, individuals in the three lower SES groups were more likely to seek treatment at a public provider at least once compared with those in the top two SES groups (OR = 6.10, 95% CI = 2.05--18.11, *P* = 0.001); this was also apparent in 2005 (OR = 2.29, 95% CI 1.59--3.32, *P* \< 0.001). Diagnosis of malaria at healthcare providers. --------------------------------------------- Of the 100 visits to healthcare providers in 2013, 95 (95%) involved a blood test for malaria compared with 48% (433/894) in 2005 (AOR = 24.42, 95% CI = 9.87--65.43, *P* \< 0.001); [Table 3](#t3){ref-type="table"}. Malaria testing was positive in 92% (87/95) of cases and in one visit the result was not reported. *Plasmodium falciparum* was diagnosed in 53% (46/87) of cases, *P. vivax* in 43% (37/87), mixed infections in 3% (3/87), and *Plasmodium malariae* in 1% (1/87). The increase in likelihood of individuals being tested for malaria was most apparent in the private sector where 29% (148/519) of individuals were tested in 2005 compared with 97% (31/32) in 2013 (*P* \< 0.001). ###### Percentage of respondents who reported receiving blood tests and antimalarials (including tablets and injections) by survey Public Private Overall ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------- ------------- --------------------- ------------------------------------ --------------- ------------- --------------------- ------------------------------------ --------------- -------------- --------------------- ------------------------------------ Percent of visits that resulted in a blood test for malaria 76% (285/375) 94% (64/68) -- \< 0.001 29% (148/519) 97% (31/32) -- \< 0.001 48% (433/894) 95% (95/100) 25.42 (9.88--65.42) \< 0.001 Percent of blood tests that were positive 75% (213/285) 94% (60/64) -- \< 0.001 84% (124/148) 87% (27/31) -- 0.790 78% (337/433) 92% (87/95) 3.11 (1.29--7.47) 0.012 Percent receiving correct antimalarial after testing positive[†](#t3fn2){ref-type="table-fn"} 32% (67/212) 85% (50/59) 15.94 (6.84--37.14) \< 0.001 9% (11/124) 52% (14/27) 12.16 (3.42--43.28) \< 0.001 23% (78/336) 74% (64/86) 15.71 (8.18--30.18) \< 0.001 Percent receiving chloroquine after testing positive 62% (133/212) 0% (0/59) -- \< 0.001 43% (53/124) 11% (3/27) -- 0.002 55% (186/336) 3% (3/86) -- \< 0.001 Percent not receiving an antimalarial after testing negative 98% (61/62) 100% (3/3) -- --[‡](#t3fn3){ref-type="table-fn"} 86% (19/22) 100% (4/4) -- --[‡](#t3fn3){ref-type="table-fn"} 95% (80/84) 100% (7/7) -- --[‡](#t3fn3){ref-type="table-fn"} Percent not receiving an antimalarial if no blood test given 64% (58/90) 100% (4/4) -- --[‡](#t3fn3){ref-type="table-fn"} 52% (192/371) 0% (0/1) -- --[‡](#t3fn3){ref-type="table-fn"} 54% (250/461) 80% (4/5) -- 0.383 AOR = adjusted odds ratio; CI = confidence interval. Multivariate logistic regression adjusted for age, sex, ethnicity, and household socioeconomic status if five or more observations. The Fisher's exact if less than five observations (no AORs). In 2005, local guidelines recommended antimalarial treatment with chloroquine plus sulphadoxine--pyramethamine for *Plasmodium falciparum* and chloroquine for *Plasmodium vivax*. In those patients with *P. vivax* (either alone or mixed) primaquine was also recommended. In 2013, correct treatment regimens were dihydoartemisinin-piperaquine for all species of malaria plus primaquine in those with *P. vivax* infections (alone or mixed). *Plasmodium malariae* infections (*N* = 2) were excluded from this analysis. 2013 data predicted the outcome perfectly. All individuals had the same level of outcome; hence, no statistical computations can be performed for the logistic regression---no statistical output is given in software. Antimalarial treatment at healthcare providers. ----------------------------------------------- In 2013, an antimalarial (alone or with other medicines) was reportedly prescribed during 88% (88/100) of visits to healthcare providers. Most of these prescriptions were given as tablets (95%, 84/88) with one (1%) injection and three (3%) for both an injection and tablets. Of the four malaria injections that were reported, two were at the public hospital and two at private providers. Ninety-nine percent (87/88) of antimalarial prescriptions followed a blood test as per clinical guidelines; all were reportedly positive. This was a significant increase compared with 2005 when only 61% (336/547) of prescriptions followed a blood test (*P* \< 0.001). In 2013, the antimalarial treatment regimen was prescribed correctly in 74% (64/86) of healthcare encounters in which *P. vivax*, *P. falciparum*, or mixed infections were diagnosed, a significant increase from 2005 when only 23% (78/336) of individuals were correctly treated according to the prevailing guidelines (AOR = 15.71, 95% CI = 8.18--30.18, *P* \< 0.001; [Table 3](#t3){ref-type="table"}). These improvements in prescribing habits were apparent in both the public (AOR = 15.93, 95% CI = 6.84--37.14, *P* \< 0.001) and private sectors (AOR = 12.16, 95% CI = 3.42--43.28, *P* \< 0.001). The reported treatments prescribed for the different species are presented in [Table 4](#t4){ref-type="table"}. In 2013, 95% (57/60) of patients diagnosed with malaria in a public facility were treated with DHP compared with 52% (14/27) of those treated at a private provider (*P* \< 0.001). Between 2005 and 2013, the percentage of individuals reportedly being treated with 14 days of primaquine for *P. vivax* infection (alone or mixed) rose from 9% (16/169) to 63% (25/40); (AOR = 37.49, 95% CI = 9.94--141.41, *P* \< 0.001). Over the same period, the percentage of patients with *P. falciparum* reporting treatment with a single dose primaquine rose from 19% (31/167) in 2005 to 50% (23/46) in 2013 (AOR = 6.27, 95% CI = 2.68--14.68, *P* \< 0.001). ###### Reported antimalarial treatment of individuals by reported diagnosis 2005 (*N* = 336) 2013 (*N* = 86) ---------------------------------------------------- ------------------ ----------------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- *Plasmodium falciparum* (*N*) 68 99 167 14 32 46  Percentage receiving any ACT 0% (0) 1% (1) 1% (1) 50% (7) 97% (31) 83% (38)  Percentage receiving any antimalarial without ACT 88% (60) 94% (93) 92% (153) 36% (5) 3% (1) 13% (6)  Percentage receiving unknown antimalarial 0% (0) 3% (3) 2% (3) 14% (2) 0% (0) 4% (2)  Percentage receiving primaquine (any dose) 62% (42) 82% (81) 74% (123) 71% (10) 59% (19) 63% (29)  Percentage receiving any treatment 94% (64) 98% (97) 96% (161) 100% (14) 100% (32) 100% (46)  Percentage receiving no treatment 6% (4) 2% (2) 4% (6) 0% (0) 0% (0) 0% (0) *Plasmodium vivax* (*N*) 51 108 159 12 25 37  Percentage receiving any ACT 0% (0) 0% (0) 0% (0) 50% (6) 96% (24) 81% (30)  Percentage receiving any antimalarial without ACT 75% (38) 94% (102) 88% (140) 25% (3) 0% (0) 8% (3)  Percentage receiving unknown antimalarial 20% (10) 5% (5) 9% (15) 25% (3) 4% (1) 11% (4)  Percentage receiving primaquine (any dose) 29% (15) 81% (88) 65% (103) 58% (7) 72% (18) 68% (25)  Percentage receiving any treatment 94% (48) 99% (107) 97% (155) 100% (12) 100% (25) 100% (37)  Percentage receiving no treatment 6% (3) 1% (1) 3% (4) 0% (0) 0% (0) 0% (0) Mixed infections (*N*) 5 5 10 1 2 3  Percentage receiving any ACT 0% (0) 0% (0) 0% (0) 100% (1) 50% (1) 67% (2)  Percentage receiving any antimalarial without ACT 80% (4) 60% (3) 70% (7) 0% (0) 0% (0) 0% (0)  Percentage receiving unknown antimalarial 0% (0) 40% (2) 20% (2) 0% (0) 50% (1) 33% (1)  Percentage receiving primaquine (any dose) 60% (3) 60% (3) 60% (6) 100% (1) 50% (1) 67% (2)  Percentage receiving any treatment 80% (4) 100% (5) 90% (9) 100% (1) 100% (2) 100% (3)  Percentage receiving no treatment 20% (1) 0% (0) 10% (1) 0% (0) 0% (0) 0% (0) ACT = antimalarial combination therapy. Cost burden of fever. --------------------- In 2013, a total of 100 visits to healthcare providers were reported by 98 individuals; hence, nearly all patients reported requiring only one visit compared with 14% (107/764) of individuals who reported seeking medical care at two or more providers before the policy change (*P* \< 0.001). In 2013, the mean total direct cost to the household per visit was US\$16.8 (SD = 19.0) at a private provider and US\$4.1 (SD = 14.4) at the public sector (*P* \< 0.001). The mean daily wage in 2013 was US\$18.2 (SD = 12.5), with a total mean indirect cost per fever episode of US\$52.5 (SD = 41.4) for adults and US\$7.3 (SD = 16.4) for children. [Table 5](#t5){ref-type="table"} shows the cost per fever episode resulting in treatment seeking in 2005 and 2013. While the direct costs were similar (*P* = 0.119), a significant decrease in indirect costs was evident from US\$44.2 (SD = 51.0) before the policy change to US\$33.8 (SD = 40.1) after the policy change (*P* = 0.006). In 2013, only 29% (29/99) of individuals reported that someone had had to cut back on their usual activities to care for them, a decrease from 77% (641/834) in 2005 (OR = 0.12, 95% CI = 0.08--0.20, *P* \< 0.001). There was also a reduction in the number of individuals requiring a substitute laborer from 8% (66/834) in 2005 to 1.0% (1/99) in 2013 (*P* = 0.007). There was no significant difference in the proportion of individuals having at least one companion accompany them to seek treatment (66% (553/834) in 2005 versus 73% (72/99) in 2013; *P* = 0.200). Overall, the mean cost per fever episode was US\$41.9 (SD = 44.3) in 2013 compared with US\$53.5 (SD = 65.3) in 2005 (*P* = 0.104). ###### Reported direct, indirect, and total costs per individual taking treatment of fever over the entire fever episode in 2014 United States dollars Category 2005 (*N* = 834) 2013 (*N* = 99) *P* value[\*](#t5fn1){ref-type="table-fn"} ------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------ ------------------- -------------------------------------------- ------------------ ---------- Total direct costs[†](#t5fn2){ref-type="table-fn"} 9.4 (27.3) 1.9 (0.4--5.6) 8.1 (17.0) 1.7 (1.0--8.1) 0.119 Total indirect costs 44.2 (51.0) 32.8 (10.9--60.1) 33.8 (40.1) 18.2 (0.0--54.6) 0.006  Total cost to the individual taking treatment due to lost wages 19.3 (30.6) 0.0 (0.0--32.8) 28.4 (38.3) 9.1 (0.0--45.5) 0.010  Total cost for companions 4.1 (6.5) 0.00 (0.0--5.5) 3.2 (7.6) 0.0 (0.0--0.0) 0.001  Total cost for caretaking 19.7 (30.5) 10.9 (0.0--27.3) 2.0 (9.1) 0.0 (0.0--0.0) \< 0.001  Total cost for substitute labor 1.1 (6.5) 0.0 (0.0--0.0) 0.2 (1.8) 0.0 (0.0--0.0) 0.072 Total costs 53.5 (65.3) 33.8 (16.4--66.7) 41.9 (44.3) 27.3 (8.1--64.7) 0.104 IQR = interquartile range; SD = standard deviation. Mann--Whitney rank test. Includes payments made by the household for all treatments including diagnostics and transport. DISCUSSION {#s4} ========== The results of the household surveys undertaken before and after the implementation of ACT after confirmed diagnosis in Papua, Indonesia, highlight several important changes in treatment-seeking behavior, diagnosis of malaria, and adherence to antimalarial drugs. Only one individual (1%) did not seek treatment outside of the home compared with 8% in 2005 when less efficacious treatments were available in both the public and private sectors. This shift in treatment seeking was associated with more individuals attending public providers at least once, rising from 46% in 2005 to 67% in 2013. Those from households with lower SES were still more likely to seek treatment at public providers than those with higher SES. Before the implementation of ACT, more than 40% of patients failed antimalarial treatment within 42 days, with almost half of these patients doing so within 7 days.^[@b5]^ The introduction of a 3-day regimen of DHP resulted in rapid parasite clearance and symptom recovery with less than 5% of patients having recurrent malaria, most of which occurred after 28 days.^[@b8]^ Hence, the observed changes in treatment-seeking behavior likely reflect community awareness of such highly effective treatments and their availability initially in the public sector and subsequently in the private sector. In parallel with the shift in where patients sought treatment, there were also significant changes in the way in which healthcare services were provided, particularly the treatment of malaria only after laboratory confirmation and adherence to antimalarial policy. Rapid diagnostic tests were introduced at public health facilities without microscopists in 2006--2007 and were used for half of the outpatient visits to one of the hospitals, whereas microscopy remained the main diagnostic for patients requiring admission to hospital. In 2013, individuals who attended healthcare facilities were almost twice as likely to have a blood test for malaria compared with those in 2005, and this was particularly prominent in the private sector where almost all patients were offered a blood test in 2013. Considering that dissatisfaction with the public sector is common^[@b20]^ and studies in Southeast Asia have shown that a large proportion of individuals seek treatment in the private sector,^[@b21],[@b22]^ improvement of both sectors is vital to ensuring public health benefits.^[@b23]^ Our findings also demonstrate that individuals diagnosed with malaria in 2013 were 3-fold more likely to receive the recommended treatment regimen. Importantly, both the public and private sectors implemented the policy change to ACT, with reductions in prescriptions of non-ACT antimalarials apparent in both sectors. This included an 8-fold decline in chloroquine prescriptions. Furthermore, better prescribing practices were also observed for primaquine, which is encouraged as a single dose for reducing the transmission potential of *P. falciparum* and as a 14-day regimen for the radical cure of *P. vivax*. The survey results also highlight a modest fall in the prevalence of parasitemia from 16% to 12%, although individuals who were parasitemic were 6-fold less likely to be symptomatic. Furthermore, a 10-fold reduction (from 42% to 4%) was observed in those reporting fever in the preceding month. Before policy change, individuals reporting a recent fever were three times more likely to be parasitemic at the time of the survey than those with no recent febrile illness. Since the risk an infected mosquito bite within 28 days in this region is low (\< 8%), the most likely explanation for this is that before 2006 treatment with partially effective treatment often failed to clear parasitemia by the time of the survey, whereas this was no longer apparent after the change in policy to highly effective treatment with ACT. By contrast, no reduction was observed in the prevalence of asymptomatic parasitemia between 2005 and 2013, a likely reflection of these patients not being unwell enough to seek treatment.^[@b24]^ The first survey was conducted between July and December, whereas the second was undertaken from April through July. While seasonal variation in either malaria or other causes of fever could therefore have influenced our observations, malaria transmission in this area occurs throughout the year with minimal seasonality.^[@b24]^ Other factors that could have affected our results include fluctuations in the demography. Between 2005 and 2013, the population grew from 120,000 to 172,000, and this was complemented with a slight increase in the proportion of non-Papuans, who are generally less immune. But this was countered by individuals reporting having lived in the area longer which would facilitate greater asymptomatic infections. In 2013, the only significant risk factor for recent febrile illness was being non-Papuan ([Supplemental Table 1](/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0680#supplementary_data)). Whereas in 2005 lowland Papuans, children less than 5 years old, and those from lower SES household were all at greater risk.^[@b10]^ The changes in treatment-seeking behavior therefore likely reflect a complex shift in population dynamics coupled with the impact of better treatment regimens and healthcare provision. The observed changes in treatment seeking had important implications for the household costs incurred by malaria. While the mean cost for each febrile episode decreased from US\$53.5 to US\$41.9, reported monthly income in households increased from 60% with less than US\$500 in 2005 to 49% with less than US\$560 in 2013. Furthermore, in 2005, households more frequently reported multiple household members with fevers in the past month and those household members reported repeat visits as compared with 2013. Considering the decrease in symptomatic individuals who were parasite positive, it is likely that many of these changes in treatment-seeking behavior are a result of effective treatment. This study has a number of limitations. First, a degree of recall bias is likely due to the time between the fever episode and the survey, although this bias would be expected to be similar for both surveys. The 8-year gap between surveys increases confounding from other changes besides the policy change including demographic dynamics, such as smaller households, greater representation of females, and duration residing in the study area. Public health and malaria control activities aimed at changing behavior remained similar over this time period. Because of differences in the phrasing of the questionnaires, we were unable to explore how the use of bed nets had changed over time. As with the previous survey, many older male household members were not present at the time of the interviews and temporary migrants were excluded. In conclusion, the policy change in March 2006 to a unified treatment of malaria with DHP has had a significant impact on treatment-seeking behavior, resulting in more patients attending healthcare facilities where better case management was being provided. These changes have had a significant impact on the burden of malaria with less patients reporting febrile illness; however, increases were seen in asymptomatic infections. Further reduction in malaria and its ultimate elimination will require implementing more effective radical cure of *P. vivax* and the implementation of active case detection or presumptive interventions. Supplementary Material ====================== [Supplemental Table and Figure.](/content/journals/10.4269/ajtmh.17-0680#supplementary_data) We are grateful to Lembaga Pengembangan Masyarakat Amungme Kamoro and the staff of PT Freeport Indonesia Public Health & Malaria Control Department and International SOS for support and technical assistance. We thank Mauritz Okeseray, Ferryanto Chalfein, Budi Prasetyorini, Peter Ebsworth, and Michael Bangs for their support and technical assistance. We are also grateful to Morrison Bethea, PT Freeport Indonesia, and International SOS for their ongoing support. We thank Dr. Mavuto Mukaka for statistical advice. [^1]: These authors contributed equally to this work. [^2]: Financial support: The study was funded by the Wellcome Trust (ICRG Wellcome Trust---ME928457MES and Senior Fellowship in Clinical Science awarded to R. N. P.---200909) and Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC \#283321). A. D. is funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (OPP1054404). The Timika Research Facility and Papuan Community Health Foundation are supported by an NHMRC Program Grant (1037304) and funding from the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. S. Y. is supported by the Tracking Resistance to Artemisinins Collaboration (TRAC) programme grant from UKAID. N. M. A. is supported by a NHMRC Practitioner Fellowship (\#1042072). [^3]: Authors' addresses: Angela Devine, Mahidol-Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand, E-mail: <angela@tropmedres.ac>. Enny Kenangalem, Faustina Helena Burdam, and Jeanne Rini Poespoprodjo, Mimika District Health Authority, Timika, Papua, Indonesia, E-mails: <enny_timika@yahoo.co.id>, <lenny_burdam@yahoo.co.id>, and <didot2266@yahoo.com>. Nicholas M. Anstey and Ric N. Price, Global and Tropical Health Division, Menzies School of Health Research and Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Australia, E-mails: <nicholas.anstey@menzies.edu.au> and <rprice@menzies.edu.au>. Shunmay Yeung, Faculty of Infectious and Tropical Disease, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom, E-mail: <shunmay.yeung@lshtm.ac.uk>.

1. Introduction {#s0005} =============== 1.1. Overview of Translation Mechanism in Animal Cells {#s0010} ------------------------------------------------------ Being obligate intracellular parasites, viruses heavily depend on host cell structures and functions to complete their life cycle, and they also use the translational apparatus of the infected cell to express their proteins. In several cases, viruses have been shown to affect and/or modulate the status of the host translational machinery to achieve efficient viral protein synthesis and replication, while cellular mRNA translation is inhibited ([@bb0215], [@bb0410], [@bb0535], [@bb0540], [@bb0545]). In eukaryotic cells, translation occurs in the cytoplasm and essentially involves four steps: initiation, elongation, termination, and recycling ([@bb0285]). The translational initiation step includes the recognition of an mRNA by the host translational machinery and assembly of the 80S complex, in which a methionyl initiator tRNA (Met-tRNA^Met^) binds at the peptidyl (P) site of the mRNA. In elongation, aminoacyl tRNAs enter the acceptor (A) site and, if the correct tRNA is bound, the ribosome catalyzes the formation of a peptide bond. After the tRNAs and mRNA are translocated such that the next codon is moved into the A site, the process is repeated. If a stop codon is encountered, the translation process is terminated, releasing the peptide from the ribosome. The recycling step involves dissociation of the ribosome and release of mRNA and deacylated tRNA, thereby setting the stage for another round of translation initiation. Translation initiation (rather than elongation or termination) is the key step in regulating protein synthesis events. Translational initiation requires at least nine eukaryotic initiation factors (eIFs) and comprises two steps: the formation of 48S initiation complexes with established codon--anticodon base pairing in the P-site of the 40S ribosomal subunits, and the joining of 60S subunits to 48S complexes to form the 80S complex. On capped mRNAs, 48S complexes are formed by the interaction of a 43S preinitiation complex (comprising a 40S subunit, the eIF2--GTP--Met-tRNA^Meti^ ternary complex, eIF3, eIF1, eIF1A, and probably eIF5) with the eIF4F complex (comprising eIF4E, a cap-binding protein, eIF4G, and eIF4A), which binds to the 5′ cap region of the mRNA. By unwinding the mRNA\'s 5′-terminal secondary structure primarily by eIF4A in the eIF4F complex, the 43S complex then scans the 5′ untranslated region (UTR) in the 5′--3′ direction to the initiation codon. After initiation codon recognition, eIF2 triggers GTP hydrolysis, which is facilitated by eIF5 and eIF5B, leading to the displacement of eIFs, and the joining of a 60S subunit to form the 80S complex ([@bb0285]). Several studies showed coronavirus (CoV)-mediated control/alteration at translational initiation step (see [Section 4](#s0085){ref-type="sec"}). In contrast, little is known as to whether CoVs also affect the elongation, termination, or recycling steps in host protein synthesis. We also do not know whether synthesis of CoV-encoded proteins is regulated at the translation termination and/or recycling steps in infected cells, while the critical role of a − 1 ribosomal frameshift event during translation elongation to produce the ORF1a/ORF1b-encoded replicase polyprotein (pp) 1ab is well established and has been extensively characterized (see [Section 2.4](#s0045){ref-type="sec"}). In addition to cap-dependent translation initiation, several viruses, such as picornaviruses (which lack a 5′-end cap structure) ([@bb0120], [@bb0370]), and some host mRNAs use cap-independent mechanisms for translation initiation. In contrast to cap-dependent translation, in which the 43S preinitiation complex binds to the 5′-terminal region of the mRNA through interaction between eIF3 in the 43S preinitiation complex and eIF4G in the eIF4F complex that is associated with the 5′-end of the mRNA, the 43S preinitiation complex (or the 40S ribosomal unit alone in some specific mRNA templates) directly binds to a specific region called internal ribosome entry site (IRES) of mRNAs that are translated by cap-independent translation mechanisms ([@bb0285]). The number and identities of translation initiation factors required for IRES-mediated translation initiation of specific mRNA species may vary significantly. For example, IRES-mediated translation of the picornavirus genome requires all translational initiation factors, except for eIF4E, 40S ribosome, and 60S ribosome subunits. However, other IRES elements, such as those present in the hepatitis C virus (HCV) genome or the cricket paralysis virus (CrPV) intergenic region, require a much smaller number of initiation factors compared to those required for cap-dependent translation. It is generally accepted that the vast majority of CoV proteins is synthesized by a cap-dependent translation mechanism and cap-independent translation initiation has only been reported for relatively few coronaviral mRNAs (see [Section 2.7](#s0060){ref-type="sec"}). 1.2. CoVs {#s0015} --------- CoVs are enveloped plus-strand RNA viruses that belong to the order *Nidovirales* in the subfamily *Coronavirinae* (family *Coronaviridae*) and are classified into four genera, *Alphacoronavirus*, *Betacoronavirus*, *Gammacoronavirus*, and *Deltacoronavirus* ([@bb0130], [@bb0190], [@bb0550], [@bb0635], [@bb0640]). CoVs cause primarily respiratory and/or enteric diseases and are found in many animal species, including wild animals, domestic animals, and humans ([@bb0625]). While most human CoVs (HCoV) cause relatively mild upper respiratory tract infections (common cold), two zoonotic viruses called severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) CoV and Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS) CoV are associated with severe lower respiratory tract infections and are major public health threats. SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and some HCoVs, including HCoV-OC43 and HCoV-HKU1, belong to the genus *Betacoronavirus*, while other HCoVs, HCoV-229E, and HCoV-NL63, belong to the genus *Alphacoronavirus*. Animal CoVs from the genera *Alpha*- and *Betacoronavirus* are mainly associated with infections in mammals, while viruses in the genera *Gamma*- and *Deltacoronavirus* primarily (but not exclusively) infect birds. There is now compelling evidence to suggest that bats are the natural reservoir involved in the evolution and spread of many mammalian CoVs, including SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV ([@bb0320], [@bb0345], [@bb0385]). The CoV particles have a spherical shape with a diameter of roughly 100 nm ([@bb0125], [@bb0620]). They carry three major structural proteins (S, M, and E) in the envelope and contain a helical nucleocapsid that is formed by the viral genomic RNA and the viral N protein. The viral S protein binds has receptor-binding and fusogenic functions ([@bb0200], [@bb0375]) and thus is essential for initiation of CoV infection. 1.3. Overview of CoV Genome Organization and Gene Expression Strategy {#s0020} --------------------------------------------------------------------- CoV genomes range between 27 and 32 kb, representing the largest RNA genome known to date. In common with typical mammalian mRNAs, the CoV genome has a 5′-terminal cap structure and a poly(A) sequence at the 3′-end ([@bb0375]) but, in contrast to most mammalian mRNAs, the CoV genome carries multiple open reading frames (ORFs) between the 5′- and 3′-terminal UTRs, both of which contain *cis*-acting signals involved in RNA replication ([@bb0045], [@bb0375]). Genome regions upstream of these ORFs contain so-called transcription regulatory sequences (TRS) that are required for CoV transcription ([@bb0045], [@bb0375]). All CoVs have two large ORFs, called ORF1a and ORF1b, that occupy the 5′-terminal two-thirds of the genome and are generally referred to as the viral replicase gene. Other ORFs located downstream of the replicase gene encode viral structural proteins and a varying number of accessory proteins, the latter being dispensable for virus replication in cell culture but involved in CoV pathogenicity ([@bb0355], [@bb0415]). Following viral entry into the cell, the viral genome RNA undergoes translation to produce the viral proteins that are required for subsequent RNA replication and transcription. eIF4F and the 43S preinitiation complex access the 5′-end of the capped viral genome and the 43S preinitiation complex scans the 5′ UTR. The 80S complex is assembled at the translation initiation codon and protein synthesis starts and proceeds until the first termination codon is encountered and the ribosome dissociates from its mRNA template, resulting in polyprotein (pp) 1a. Production of pp1ab (encoded by both ORF1a and ORF1b) requires a − 1 ribosomal frameshift before the translation stop codon is reached. This frameshift has been shown to occur in the overlap region between ORFs 1a and 1b. Viral proteins encoded downstream of ORFs 1a and 1b are not synthesized from the genome RNA but from a set of 5′-capped subgenomic mRNAs that carry the respective ORFs in their 5′-terminal regions. The two replicase polyproteins translated from ORFs 1a and 1b undergo proteolytic cleavage via viral-encoded proteinases encoded in ORF1a to generate 15--16 mature nonstructural proteins, termed nsp1 to nsp16. All of these nsps, except for nsp1 ([@bb0240]) and nsp2 ([@bb0195]), are considered essential for transcription and replication of CoV RNA ([@bb0430]). CoV RNA synthesis occurs at double membrane vesicles that are derived from endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membranes (reviewed in [@bb0430]) in the cytoplasm. Besides its role as an mRNA for replicase polyprotein expression, the genome RNA is packaged into progeny virus particles (in contrast to subgenomic mRNAs that are not packaged efficiently). The number of subgenomic mRNAs differs among CoVs. These CoV mRNAs share their 3′-terminal regions, constituting a 3′-coterminal nested set of RNAs (reviewed in [@bb0375]). The 5′-end of CoV genomic RNA carries a \~ 70-nt-long leader sequence. The same leader sequence is also found at the 5′-end of all CoV mRNAs. Subgenomic minus-strand RNAs, each of which corresponds to each subgenomic mRNA species, also accumulate in infected cells. These subgenomic minus-strand RNAs carry complement of the leader sequence (antileader) at the 3′-end. It has been proposed that subgenomic minus-strands are synthesized from intracellular genome-length RNA, in a process called discontinuous extension and involving base pairing interactions between the 3′-end of the nascent minus-strand and the leader TRS. Subsequently, these antileader-containing subgenomic minus-strand RNAs are used as templates to produce 5′ leader-containing mRNAs in which the 5′ leader sequence is fused to the mRNA body at the TRS ([@bb0375], [@bb0485], [@bb0490]). Like the genomic RNA, the CoV subgenomic mRNAs, except for the smallest mRNA, are polycistronic and, with very few exceptions, only the 5′-terminal ORF of each of these subgenomic mRNAs is translated into protein. 2. Mechanisms and Control of Translation of Coronavirus mRNAs {#s0025} ============================================================= 2.1. Evidence for Cap-Dependent Translation of CoV mRNAs {#s0030} -------------------------------------------------------- Because genomic and subgenomic CoV mRNAs have a 5′ cap structure, most CoV mRNAs are thought to undergo cap-dependent translation using eIF4F. Cencic et al. reported several compounds that inhibit eIF4F activity by preventing eIF4E--eIF4G interaction ([@bb0080]). The same group demonstrated that a molecule (4E2RCat) that prevents the interaction between eIF4E and eIF4G inhibits HCoV-229E replication ([@bb0075]), providing additional evidence to suggest that CoV mRNA translation depends on a 5′ cap structure being present on viral mRNAs. The authors also found that a certain concentration of 4E2RCat completely inhibited HCoV-229E replication, whereas it inhibited host protein synthesis by \~ 40%, indicating that HCoV-229E mRNAs show a higher dependency on eIF4F for ribosome recruitment compared to host mRNAs. To date, possible roles of eIF4F in viral mRNA translation have not reported for other CoVs. 2.2. Viral Enzymes Involved in Capping of CoV mRNAs {#s0035} --------------------------------------------------- Formation of the cap structure of eukaryotic and eukaryotic viral mRNAs generally requires three successive enzymatic reactions ([@bb0175]). First, an RNA 5′-triphosphatase (TPase) removes the γ-phosphate group from the 5′-triphosphate end (pppN) of the nascent mRNA chain to generate the diphosphate 5′-ppN. Subsequently, an RNA guanylyltransferase transfers a GMP to the 5′-diphosphate end to produce the cap core structure (GpppN). Finally, an N7 methyltransferase (N7-MTase) methylates the attached GMP (cap) at the N7 position to produce a cap-0 structure (m7GpppN). Higher eukaryotes and viruses usually further methylate the cap-0 structure at the ribose 2′-*O* position of the first and second nucleotide of the mRNA by a ribose 2′-*O*-MTase to form cap-1 and cap-2 structures, respectively ([@bb0170]). Ribose 2′-*O*-methylation of viral RNA cap provides a mechanism for viruses to escape host immune recognition ([@bb0115], [@bb0700]). The CoV genome encodes several RNA processing enzymes involved in RNA capping. The cap formation step by CoV has mainly been studied in SARS-CoV. In the first step of cap formation to generate diphosphate 5′-ppN, nsp13 may be involved because it has RNA 5′-TPase activity mediated by the NTPase active site of the nsp13-associated helicase domain ([@bb0255], [@bb0260]). The next step is the formation of the cap core structure (GpppN) by an RNA guanylyltransferase. At present, it is not clear whether or not CoVs encode this enzyme; perhaps CoVs use cellular enzymes to perform this step. The third step is the methylation of the cap guanosine at the N7 position. This reaction is mediated by the C-terminal domain of CoV nsp14 ([@bb0095]) using *S*-adenosyl methionine (SAM) as a methyl group donor. Apparently, the enzyme is not specific for viral substrate RNAs ([@bb0040]). Conversion of cap-0 to cap-1 structures involves nsp16 that acts as a 2′-*O*-MTase ([@bb0040], [@bb0140]) and forms a complex with nsp10 ([@bb0100]) that appears to be required for efficient binding to SAM and the RNA substrate. Interestingly, SARS-CoV nsp10 plays an essential role in the specific binding of nsp16 to m7GpppA-capped RNA (first nucleotide is adenine). Considering that both the genomic and subgenomic mRNAs of SARS-CoV start with an adenine, this feature appears beneficial for SARS-CoV replication. The crystal structure of the heterodimer of nsp16/nsp10 with bound methyl donor SAM showed that nsp10 may stabilize the SAM-binding pocket and extend the RNA-binding groove of nsp16 ([@bb0100]). 2.3. Changes in the Poly(A) Tail Length During CoV Replication {#s0040} -------------------------------------------------------------- CoV genomic and subgenomic mRNAs carry a poly(A) tail at their 3′ ends. Hofmann and Brian postulated that viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase or a cellular cytoplasmic poly(A) polymerase synthesizes the poly(A) tail of CoV mRNAs ([@bb0220]). Wu et al. reported that the length of the poly(A) tail of bovine CoV (BCoV) mRNAs in infected human rectal tumor-18 cells varies at various times postinfection (p.i.), ranging from \~ 45 nt immediately after virus entry to \~ 65 nt at 6--9 h p.i. and \~ 30 nt at 120--144 h p.i. ([@bb0645]). Differences in poly(A) length of viral mRNAs at different times p.i. was also observed in several other BCoV-infected cell lines and cells infected with different strains of infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) ([@bb0530]), indicating that changes in the poly(A) length during virus replication may be a common feature of CoVs. Factor and mechanisms involved in this process remain to be studied. Because the length of the poly(A) tail contributes to the efficiency of translation and replication of CoV defective interfering RNAs ([@bb0565], [@bb0645]), the regulated changes in the length of the CoV poly(A) tail may affect efficiencies of viral translation and replication over the course of infection. 2.4. Ribosomal Frameshift in CoV Gene 1 Protein Expression {#s0045} ---------------------------------------------------------- As mentioned earlier, two large polyproteins, one of which being translated from ORF1a and the other from ORFs 1a and 1b, are synthesized from the viral genome RNA. The synthesis of polyprotein 1ab involves a − 1 ribosomal frameshift during the translational elongation step and occurs in the overlap region between ORFs 1a and 1b ([@bb0035], [@bb0050], [@bb0055]). Polyprotein 1ab is thus encoded by a (functionally) fused ORF produced from the two ORFs 1a and 1b. As most of the mature nsp proteins processed from these two large polyproteins are essential for CoV RNA synthesis, translation of polyprotein 1ab via − 1 ribosomal frameshifting is an essential step in CoV replication. The signals required for − 1 ribosomal frameshifting in the ORF1a/1b overlap region were first identified in IBV ([@bb0050], [@bb0055]). Subsequently, putative ribosomal frameshift signals were also identified and characterized in other CoVs ([@bb0035]). The − 1 ribosomal frameshifting signals are composed of a slippery sequence "UUUAAAC" followed by a "stimulatory" RNA secondary structure. The − 1 frameshifting occurs at this slippery sequence, where tRNAs are supposed to dissociate from the mRNA and then shift (by 1 nucleotide) to a codon in another reading frame, ORF1b ([@bb0445]). The stimulatory structure is a complex RNA stem-loop structure RNA that varies among different CoVs. SARS-CoV's stimulatory structure contains three stem loops ([@bb0020], [@bb0450], [@bb0570]), and their disruption affects frameshift efficiency ([@bb0440], [@bb0450]). Recently, Ishimaru et al. showed that a homodimeric RNA complex formed by the SARS-CoV's stimulatory structure occurs within cells and that loop-to-loop kissing interactions involving stem3-loop2 modulate the − 1 ribosome frameshift efficiency ([@bb0250]). These reports indicate that an optimal secondary RNA structure and RNA--RNA interaction within the ribosomal frameshifting signal are important for efficient − 1 ribosomal frameshifting. Several studies showed that reduction of frameshifting efficiency affects virus infectivity and replication ([@bb0250], [@bb0455], [@bb0460]). Plant et al. showed that the ratio of ORF1a- and ORF1b-encoded proteins plays a critical role in CoV replication efficiency ([@bb0455]). The authors proposed that CoVs have evolved to produce optimal levels of − 1 ribosomal frame shift efficiency for efficient virus propagation. CoV frameshift signals characterized previously have − 1 ribosomal frameshift efficiencies in the range of 20--45% ([@bb0020], [@bb0050], [@bb0210], [@bb0445]). A recent study using ribosome profiling of mouse hepatitis virus (MHV)-infected cells suggests that the frameshift rate may be even slightly higher ([@bb0245]). 2.5. Ribosomal Shunting Mechanism of Translation in CoVs {#s0050} -------------------------------------------------------- Ribosomal shunting is a translation initiation depending on cap-dependent discontinuous scanning, whereby ribosomes are loaded onto mRNA at the 5′ cap structure and scanning is started for a short distance before bypassing the large internal leader region and initiating at a downstream start site ([@bb0155]). For some strains of transmissible gastroenteritis virus (TGEV), mRNA having ORF 3b as the first ORF is not produced and ORF 3b is present as a nonoverlapping second ORF on mRNA 3. O'Connor et al. proposed a possible ribosomal shunting in the translation of ORF 3b in TGEV ([@bb0435]). The basis for this proposal was as follows: (i) if 3b protein was translated by a leaky scanning mechanism, a modification of ORF 3a to generate a favorable Kozak sequence would be expected to diminish protein synthesis from ORF3b compared to ORF3a; however, optimization of the Kozak context for ORF 3a did not affect translation efficiency of 3b; (ii) the translation of 3b was shown to be cap dependent; and (iii) deletion analysis failed to provide evidence for an IRES within the ORF 3a sequence. In several viral mRNAs, the presence of a specific donor structure with a large stem-loop with a 5′-adjacent, short ORF appears to be required for ribosome shunting ([@bb0205], [@bb0465]), whereas TGEV ORF3b shunting does not depend on such a donor structure. Given that Sendai virus mRNA ([@bb0315]), avian orthoreovirus mRNA ([@bb0475]), and avihepadnavirus mRNA ([@bb0070]) undergo ribosomal shunting, with no apparent requirement for a donor structure, it seems reasonable to suggest that translation of the TGEV 3b protein may involve a ribosomal shunting-driven translation mechanism in the absence of a specific donor structure. 2.6. Leaky Scanning Translation Mechanism of CoV Internal ORFs {#s0055} -------------------------------------------------------------- An internal CoV ORF was initially found within the 5′ half of the BCoV N gene ORF ([@bb0310]). This internal ORF gene encodes the I protein and is likely translated by a leaky scanning mechanism in which ribosomes occasionally bypass the first AUG (the start codon for the N protein) and initiate translation from the AUG codon of the internal ORF encoding the I protein. The first AUG has a suboptimal Kozak context, while the downstream AUG (the start codon for the I protein) is in a more favorable Kozak context ([@bb0500], [@bb0510]). The N genes of MHV-A59, HCoV-HKU1, HCoV-OC43, SARS-CoV, and MERS-CoV also have an internal ORF ([@bb0010], [@bb0270], [@bb0480], [@bb0600], [@bb0630]); in HCoV-OC43, the AUG start codon of the internal ORF is changed to AUC. Because many CoVs carry the internal ORF in the N gene, it is possible that the encoded proteins may have (an) important biological function(s) for virus replication/survival, whereas our knowledge of their biological functions is limited. Fischer et al. reported that the MHV I protein is not essential for virus replication in cultured cells and its natural host ([@bb0160]). However, a MHV mutant lacking the I gene formed smaller plaques than did wild-type MHV, indicating that I protein expression could give some minor growth advantage to the virus. Shi et al. reported that the SARS-CoV internal ORF protein, called the 9b protein, which is encoded within the N gene ORF, evades host innate immunity by targeting the mitochondrial-associated adaptor molecule, MAVS ([@bb0525]), while a previous study using a SARS-CoV mutant lacking viral accessory genes, including 6, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, and 9b, showed that deletion of these genes had little effect on the pathogenicity of the virus in a mouse model ([@bb0145]). Further investigation is required to better understand the role of the SARS-CoV 9b protein in viral pathogenicity. 2.7. IRES-Mediated Translation in CoVs {#s0060} -------------------------------------- Some CoV proteins are synthesized by IRES-mediated translation. Liu and Inglis reported that mRNA 3 of IBV was functionally tricistronic, having the capacity to encode three proteins (3a, 3b, and 3c) from three ORFs ([@bb0350]). Their study showed that (i) a synthetic mRNA whose peculiar 5′-end structure prevents translation of the 5′-proximal ORFs (3a and 3b) directs efficient synthesis of 3c, (ii) translation of 3c is not affected by the absence/presence of the 5′ cap analog as well as changes in the sequence contexts for initiation of ORF 3a and 3b translation, (iii) an mRNA in which the 3a/b/c coding region was placed downstream of the influenza A virus nucleocapsid protein gene directed the efficient synthesis of only 3c and nucleocapsid protein, and (iv) expression of the 3c ORF from this mRNA was abolished when the 3a and 3b coding region was deleted, the latter indicating that 3c translation initiation depends on upstream 3a/b sequences that serve as an IRES element. Further analyses showed that the sequence prior to the initiator AUG of 3c can form an RNA secondary structure comprised of five RNA stem-loops that can be modeled into a compact superstructure formed by interactions of two predicted pseudoknot structures. The proposed structure shares structural features with IRES elements conserved in picornavirus genome RNAs, and a base pairing model between mRNA 3 and 18S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) was suggested ([@bb0325], [@bb0330]). IRES-mediated translation was also reported in MHV. The unique region of MHV mRNA 5 has two ORFs, ORF 5a, and ORF 5b. Thiel and Siddell reported that a synthetic mRNA containing both ORFs is functionally bicistronic and expression of ORF 5b, but not ORF 5a, is maintained in a tricistronic mRNA containing an additional 5′-proximal ORF. These data suggested that initiation of protein synthesis from ORF 5b may be mediated by an internal entry of ribosomes ([@bb0595]). Further studies by Jendrach et al. identified the IRES element of mRNA 5, which contains ≤ 280 nucleotides including the ORF 5b initiation codon ([@bb0265]). The authors also showed that the IRES element of mRNA 5 interacts specifically with protein factors present in an L-cell lysate ([@bb0265]). 2.8. Presence of Upstream ORF in CoV Genomic RNAs {#s0065} ------------------------------------------------- Short AUG-initiated upstream ORFs (uORF) located in the 5′ UTR of eukaryotic mRNAs are generally translated by 5′ cap-dependent ribosomal scanning, resulting in translation repression of the major downstream ORF expressed from this mRNA ([@bb0065], [@bb0560]). In CoVs, a uORF is found within the 5′ UTR of the genomic RNA, just downstream of the genomic leader sequence. Hence CoV genomic RNA, but not subgenomic mRNAs, carry a uORF in their 5′-terminal region(s) ([@bb0650]), with few exceptions ([@bb0225]). Wu et al. reported that the uORF encoding a potential polypeptide of 3 to 13 amino acids is found within the 5′ UTR of more than 75% of CoV genomes based on 38 reference strains ([@bb0650]), suggesting a functional significance for this sequence. The authors further showed by using an in vitro translation system that the MHV uORF is involved in a decreased rate of translation from the ORF1a start codon; wild-type MHV and mutants that lack the uORF showed similar growth properties in cell culture and, within 10 passages in cell culture, the uORF-disrupting mutations reverted back to the wild-type sequences or generated a new uORF sequence ([@bb0650]). These results suggest that the uORF represses ORF1a translation, yet plays a beneficial, but nonessential role in CoV replication in cell culture. 3. Host and Viral Factors That Regulate Coronavirus mRNA Translation {#s0070} ==================================================================== 3.1. Factors That Bind to Viral UTRs {#s0075} ------------------------------------ The 5′ and 3′ UTRs of CoV genomic RNA carry *cis*-acting elements that are important for viral RNA synthesis ([@bb0090]). A number of host factors have been identified to interact in vitro with *cis*-acting elements of the 5′ and 3′ UTRs; these include heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein (hnRNP) A1 and Q ([@bb0110], [@bb0335]), polypyrimidine tract-binding protein (PTB) ([@bb0340]), mitochondrial aconitase ([@bb0405]), poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) ([@bb0565]), the glutamyl-prolyl-tRNA synthetase ([@bb0185]), the arginyl-tRNA synthetase ([@bb0185]), and the p100 transcriptional coactivator ([@bb0185]). Among these, hnRNP A1, hnRNP Q, and PTB have been shown to have a role in MHV RNA synthesis ([@bb0105], [@bb0340], [@bb0515], [@bb0520]). Likewise, PABP, hnRNP Q and EPRS proteins have been shown to play a positive role in TGEV infection ([@bb0185]). Currently, it is unclear whether any of these host proteins affect translation of viral proteins. Senanayanke and Brian reported that replacement of the natural 77-nt 5′ UTR on synthetic transcripts of BCoV mRNA 7 ([@bb0505]), which encodes the N and I proteins, with the 210-nt 5′ UTR from BCoV mRNA 1 caused approximately twofold-less N protein in an in vitro translation system as well as in uninfected cells using a T7 RNA polymerase-driven transient transfection system. In infected cells, this difference became 12-fold as the result of both a stimulated translation from the 77-nt 5′ UTR and a repression of translation from the 210-nt 5′ UTR, demonstrating a differential 5′ UTR-directed regulation of translation in CoV-infected cells and suggesting that this regulation involves viral or virus-induced cellular factors that interact with *cis*-acting elements in the 5′ UTR. 3.2. N Protein-Mediated Enhancement of Viral Translation {#s0080} -------------------------------------------------------- Tahara et al. reported that capped chimeric mRNAs, in which the MHV 5′-leader sequence was positioned upstream of the human alpha-globin coding region, were translated three- to fourfold more efficiently in cell-free extracts derived from MHV-infected cells compared to extracts obtained from uninfected cells. In contrast, nonviral mRNAs were found to be translated equally efficiently in cell-free extracts derived from infected and uninfected cells ([@bb0580]). The same group subsequently demonstrated that the MHV N protein (i) stimulates translation of a reporter mRNA carrying the MHV 5′-UTR ([@bb0585]) and (ii) binds with high affinity to the leader sequence and TRS ([@bb0425]), suggesting that CoV N proteins may act as *trans*-acting factors that enhance the translation efficiency of CoV mRNAs. 4. Coronavirus-Mediated Control of Host Translation {#s0085} =================================================== CoV replication in cultured cells is often linked to an inhibition of host protein synthesis ([@bb0215], [@bb0410]), with some exceptions ([@bb0075]). MHV infection drastically inhibits host protein synthesis between 3 and 6 h p.i., while viral protein synthesis increases from 3 h p.i. and peaks at 6 h p.i. ([@bb0535], [@bb0540], [@bb0545]). An increased number of free 80S ribosomes and a shift to lighter polysomes during MHV infection suggest a potential suppression at the translation initiation phase ([@bb0005], [@bb0545]). Banerjee et al. reported that MHV infection induces degradation of 28S rRNAs as early as 4 h p.i. and almost all 28S rRNAs are degraded by 24 h p.i., while 18S rRNA remains stable ([@bb0015]). Although the biological significance of MHV-induced 28S rRNA degradation is not entirely clear, it may contribute to the virus-induced translational suppression because the 28S rRNA is an integral component of the 60S ribosomal subunit. In addition to 28S rRNA, MHV infection was reported to stimulate degradation of specific host mRNAs ([@bb0305]), thereby further limiting host protein expression. 4.1. CoV Proteins That Suppress Translation {#s0090} ------------------------------------------- One of the CoV proteins that have a role in inhibiting host translation was found to be nsp1, the most N-terminal pp1a/pp1ab-derived processing product. CoV nsp1 equivalents appear to employ divergent strategies to suppress host gene expression. For instance, SARS-CoV nsp1 inhibits mRNA translation and promotes host mRNA degradation by binding to the 40S ribosomal subunits ([@bb0280]), while nsp1 of MERS-CoV inhibits host mRNA translation and induces host mRNA cleavage without binding to the 40S ribosomal subunits ([@bb0365]). Nsp1 of TGEV uses a yet another, currently unknown mechanism to suppress host protein synthesis without binding to the 40S ribosomal subunits or inducing mRNA degradation ([@bb0230]). SARS-CoV nsp1 inhibits cap-dependent and IRES-driven translation by suppressing multiple steps of translation initiation ([@bb0360]). SARS-CoV nsp1 inhibits both 48S and 80S initiation complex formation with a stronger inhibition of the latter on cap-dependent and encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV)-IRES-driven mRNA templates. SARS-CoV nsp1 inhibits different steps of initiation on mRNA templates that use the IRES-40S binary complex to initiate translation, such as CrPV and HCV-IRES-driven mRNAs. Nsp1 inhibits binary complex formation on CrPV-IRES and 48S complex formation on HCV-IRES ([@bb0360]). In addition to the translation suppression function, SARS-CoV nsp1 promotes host mRNA degradation by inducing endonucleolytic RNA cleavage in the 5′-UTR of host mRNAs ([@bb0235]). The internally cleaved mRNAs are then degraded by the cellular Xrn1-mediated 5′--3′ exonucleolytic mRNA degradation pathway ([@bb0180], [@bb0235]). SARS-CoV nsp1-induced degradation of host mRNAs also contributes to inhibition of host gene expression in infected cells ([@bb0410]). While SARS-CoV nsp1 induces endonucleolytic cleavage of host mRNAs, viral mRNAs appear to be resistant to these cleavage mechanisms ([@bb0235], [@bb0280], [@bb0360]), most likely because the 5′ leader sequence present on these RNAs protects them from nsp1-induced endonucleolytic cleavage. SARS-CoV nsp1 was also shown to inhibit translation of viral mRNAs in cell-free extracts ([@bb0235]) as well as infected cells ([@bb0420]). In contrast, Tanaka et al. postulated that specific interaction of SARS-CoV nsp1 with the stem-loop I structure in the 5′-UTR of the SARS-CoV genome facilitates efficient viral gene expression in infected cells ([@bb0590]). Unlike SARS-CoV nsp1, which is a cytoplasmic protein ([@bb0275]), MERS-CoV nsp1 is localized in both the cytoplasm and the nucleus of cells transfected with suitable plasmid construct or virus-infected cells ([@bb0365]). Interestingly, MERS-CoV nsp1 selectively inhibits translation and induces degradation of mRNAs that are transcribed in the nucleus and transported to the cytoplasm, whereas it does not suppress the expression of exogenous mRNAs directly introduced into the cytoplasm or viral mRNAs produced in the cytoplasm of infected cells ([@bb0365]). As MERS-CoV mRNAs are of cytoplasmic origin, their expression remains unaffected by MERS-CoV-encoded nsp1 in infected cells ([@bb0365]). Xiao et al. reported that the S proteins of SARS-CoV and IBV interact with eIF3f, one of the subunits of eIF3, leading to the inhibition of host translation at a late point in the infection ([@bb0655]). The authors suggested that the interaction between CoV S protein and eIF3f may play a functional role in controlling the expression of specific host genes, especially those that are induced by the viral infection. Using a yeast two-hybrid human protein library screen, [@bb0685] found that the SARS-CoV N protein binds to eukaryotic translation elongation factor 1 alpha (eEF1α), an integral part of the translational machinery; GTP-bound EF1alpha plays a key role in recruiting aminoacyl-tRNA to the A site of the 80S translation initiation complex during translation. The authors showed that expression of SARS-CoV N protein induces the aggregation of eEF1α, resulting in the inhibition of host protein synthesis ([@bb0685]). Another CoV protein that affects host translation is the SARS-CoV 7a protein, a multifunctional protein that inhibits host translation, induces apoptosis, activates the p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase ([@bb0295]), and arrests the cell cycle at the G0/G1 phase ([@bb0675]). Accumulating evidence suggests that the 7a protein inhibits cellular gene expression at the level of translation ([@bb0295]), whereas the precise mechanism of translation inhibition by the 7a protein remains to be determined. 4.2. CoV-Mediated Induction of ER Stress and Unfolded Protein Response {#s0095} ---------------------------------------------------------------------- In eukaryotic cells, the ER plays a central role in the synthesis of secretory or transmembrane proteins, including folding of these proteins into their native conformation and mediating a range of posttranslational modifications. The ER maintains a homeostasis suitable to regulate the processing and prevent the aggregation of these proteins. If the accumulation of nascent, unfolded polypeptides exceeds the folding and processing capacity of the ER, the homeostasis is perturbed, resulting in ER stress and triggering the activation of the unfolded protein response (UPR). The latter contributes to restoring the normal function of ER or initiates apoptosis if the ER stress remains unchanged. UPR signaling activates three main branches: PKR-like ER kinase (PERK), activating transcription factor 6 (ATF6), and inositol-requiring protein-1 (IRE1). Once activated these pathways send signals to inhibit translation, degrade misfolded proteins through ER-associated degradation, express ER molecular chaperones, and expand the ER membrane to decrease the load of proteins and increase the protein-folding capacity in the ER. ER stress occurs under various conditions, such as nutrient deprivation, developmental processes, genetic changes, and invasion by pathogens, such as viruses and intracellular bacteria. Generally, in virus-infected cells, a copious amount of viral proteins is produced, often perturbing ER homeostasis and eventually causing ER stress ([@bb0495], [@bb0680]). Mounting evidence suggests that CoV replication causes ER stress that triggers UPR activation, thus possibly regulating host antiviral responses. Several studies have observed the induction of ER protein chaperones, such as the immunoglobulin heavy chain-binding protein (BiP), also known as glucose-regulated protein 94 (GRP94), which are considered indicators of ER stress, in SARS-CoV-infected cells ([@bb0085], [@bb0670]). In one of these studies, induction of luciferase reporter gene expression from BiP- or GRP94-driven promoters was observed in SARS-CoV-infected cells ([@bb0085]). Also other CoVs, such as MHV and IBV, have been shown to cause ER stress in infected cells ([@bb0165], [@bb0610]). Cells overexpressing the S protein of SARS-CoV, MHV or HCoV-HKU1 also induce ER stress, suggesting that the S protein could be the main modulator of ER stress in CoV infections ([@bb0610]). Due to its large molecular weight and extensive glycosylation, the S protein requires ER protein chaperones for proper folding and maturation. ER stress has also been observed in cells that overexpress specific CoV accessory proteins, such as the 3a, 6, and 8ab proteins of SARS-CoV ([@bb0395], [@bb0575], [@bb0665]). In addition to the contribution of viral proteins in inducing ER stress, an increased overall ER burden, the formation of double membrane vesicle, and the depletion of ER lipids may contribute to ER stress, thereby affecting cellular mRNA expression in CoV-infected cells. 4.3. Status of Stress Granules and Processing Bodies in CoV Replication {#s0100} ----------------------------------------------------------------------- In response to cellular stress caused by either environmental stimuli or viral infections, cells may reduce or even shut off their protein synthesis. Induction of translational shutoff also occurs by increased phosphorylation of eIF2α ([@bb0135]), resulting in dissociation of polysomes which, in turn, leads to stalled 43S and 48S preinitiation complexes and nontranslating mRNAs that may be incorporated into stress granules (SGs), one of the two major cytoplasmic RNA granules. SGs are reversible foci and temporary store houses for these complexes. When the stress conditions are over, stored initiation complexes are rapidly released to resume translation. Under normal conditions, processing bodies (P-bodies), another type of cytoplasmic RNA granule, are present in cells. Typically, P-bodies increase in number and size under host shutoff conditions. Both SGs and P-bodies contain translationally incompetent mRNAs, while P-bodies contain exonucleases, deadenylases, and enzymes for decapping ([@bb0005], [@bb0030], [@bb0060]). Although P-bodies are enriched with RNA decay machinery proteins, it is controversial as to whether RNA decay occurs within P-bodies. Although virus infections activate cellular stress responses, some viruses, such as poliovirus and CrPV, do not induce SGs in the course of infection. Other viruses, including the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus, rotavirus, dengue virus, and West Nile virus, may actively inhibit SG formation ([@bb0150], [@bb0290], [@bb0380], [@bb0400]). Increased formation of SGs and P-bodies has been shown to occur during replication of some CoVs. Both TGEV and MHV form SGs as the infection progresses ([@bb0470], [@bb0555]). During MHV infection, formation of SGs and P-bodies were observed concomitantly with increased eIF2α phosphorylation as early as 6 h p.i. when host translational shutoff and mRNA decay are apparent. These data led Raaben et al. to propose that MHV replication induces host translational shutoff by triggering an integrated stress response ([@bb0470]). The authors further demonstrated that, when host translational shutoff was experimentally impaired, replication of MHV was not negatively affected but rather enhanced ([@bb0470]). The appearance of SGs was also observed in TGEV infection, and these granules were not disassembled at later stages of the infection ([@bb0555]). However, when SG components were depleted, an increased replication of TGEV was observed, suggesting that SGs may restrict CoV replication. 4.4. Activation of PKR, PERK, and eIF2α Phosphorylation {#s0105} ------------------------------------------------------- Viral infections induce ER stress, thereby triggering phosphorylation of the serine residue at position 51 of eIF2α. Phosphorylation of eIF2α leads to translation inhibition. Two of the four protein kinases that are known to phosphorylate eIF2α at Ser51 are protein kinase RNA-activated (PKR) and PERK. Double-stranded RNA and ER stress activate PKR and PERK, respectively. Several studies examined the status of eIF2α phosphorylation and PKR/PERK activation in CoV-infected cells. Zorzitto et al. reported minimal transcriptional activation of PKR in MHV-1-infected cells at later time points ([@bb0695]). Ye et al. found that PKR and eIF2α are not phosphorylated in MHV-A59-infected cells ([@bb0660]). In contrast, Bechill et al. observed significant phosphorylation of eIF2α in MHV-A59-infected cells and efficient translation of MHV mRNAs in the presence of phosphorylated eIF2α ([@bb0025]). This discrepancy in the status of eIF2α phosphorylation and PKR activation in these studies could be due to the use of different cell types and virus strains. Krahling et al. reported that SARS-CoV infection not only activated PKR and PERK but also phosphorylated eIF2α at 8 and 24 h p.i. ([@bb0300]), whereas activation of PKR and PERK or eIF2α phosphorylation did not impair SARS-CoV replication. Based on these data, the authors hypothesized that SARS-CoV has evolved a mechanism to overcome the inhibitory effects of phosphorylated eIF2α on viral mRNA translation. Wang et al. reported that that phosphorylation of eIF2α was severely suppressed in human and animal cells infected with IBV ([@bb0615]). The level of phosphorylated PKR was found to be greatly reduced in IBV-infected cells, and nsp2 was a weak PKR antagonist. Also GADD34, a component of the protein phosphatase 1 (PP1) complex that dephosphorylates eIF2α, was significantly induced in IBV-infected cells. Inhibition of the PP1 activity and overexpression of wild-type and mutant GADD34, eIF2α, and PKR provided evidence to suggest that these virus-modulated pathways play a synergistic role in facilitating IBV replication. It was also postulated that IBV may employ a combination of two mechanisms, i.e., blocking PKR activation and inducing GADD34 expression, to maintain de novo protein synthesis in infected cells to enhance viral replication ([@bb0615]). 5. Concluding Remarks {#s0110} ===================== This chapter summarizes experimental studies of mechanisms that drive and control the translation of viral and host cell mRNAs in CoV-infected cells. There is now a large body of information to suggest that (i) CoV evolved a range of mechanisms to control viral gene expression at the posttranscriptional level and (ii) CoV replication results in cell stress, leading to the activation of stress-induced signaling pathways that suppress host translation. Also, recent studies have uncovered that a number of CoV-encoded proteins, such as nsp1, suppress host translation without severely affecting viral gene expression. Although studies of the posttranscriptional regulation of CoV gene expression have been making significant progress, our understanding of the translation mechanisms used by specific CoV mRNAs requires further investigation. A major question to be addressed in more detail pertains to the mechanism that is used to ensure efficient CoV mRNA translation in cells in which host protein synthesis is suppressed. Replication of some CoVs, such as SARS-CoV, induces host mRNA decay ([@bb0365], [@bb0410]). While the reduction of host mRNA levels is one of the factors involved in suppressing host translation in CoV-infected cells, it is unlikely to be the sole reason for the inhibition of host protein synthesis ([@bb0410]). CoV mRNAs and host mRNAs share important structural features (such as the 5′ cap structure and 3′ poly(A) tail), suggesting that the translation of CoV and host mRNAs may be equally sensitive to the inhibition of factors that control specific translation steps, including eIF2α and its phosphorylated form. A possible mechanism for efficient CoV translation under conditions in which host translation is suppressed may be related to the extreme abundance of CoV mRNAs that, at least in part, may counterbalance effects of translational suppression. Alternatively, CoV mRNAs and host mRNAs may use a slightly different repertoire of translation factors. It has been reported that alphaviruses can use eIF2A, instead of eIF2α, in viral translation ([@bb0605]). If CoV mRNAs have similar requirements, then eIF2α phosphorylation may not or less profoundly affect the translation of CoV mRNAs. Because CoV mRNAs are capped at the 5′-end and polyadenylated at the 3′-end, it has been postulated that most of the CoV mRNAs undergo cap-dependent translation. However, experimental data that support this hypothesis have only been provided for HCoV-229E-infected cells ([@bb0080]). Unlike many other CoVs, HCoV-229E replication does not inhibit translation of host proteins ([@bb0080]). Do mRNAs of other CoVs also undergo cap-dependent translation? Recent studies showed that m^6^A-modification in the 5′ UTR of mammalian mRNA may stimulate cap-independent translation ([@bb0390], [@bb0690]). If the 5′ UTR of some CoV mRNAs are subject to m^6^A-modification in infected cells, these CoV mRNAs might use a cap-independent mechanism of translation. Previous studies suggested that the CoV leader sequence that is attached to the 5′-end of all CoV mRNAs affects translation and stability of CoV mRNAs. For example, the MHV leader sequence was shown to promote translation in cell-free extracts from MHV-infected cells ([@bb0580]); the N protein was reported to bind to the MHV leader sequence and to facilitate translation ([@bb0425], [@bb0585]); and the SARS-CoV leader sequence was shown to mediate viral mRNA escape from SARS-CoV nsp1-induced endonucleolytic RNA cleavage ([@bb0235]). However, our understanding of the biological functions of the leader sequence of other CoVs at the posttranscriptional level remains limited. Also, it is possible that leader sequences of different CoVs have evolved to meet differential requirements imposed by specific (and different) target cells. Mechanisms that control cellular gene expression at the posttranscriptional level remains a major research field, generating surprising and exiting new discoveries at an amazing speed and, undoubtedly, will influence our future studies of the posttranscriptional regulation of CoV gene expression. The work was partially supported by Public Health Service grants, AI99107 and AI114657 from the National Institutes of Health. K.N. was supported by the James W. McLaughlin fellowship fund. [^1]: These authors contributed equally to this work.

Introduction {#s1} ============ Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have recently identified a number of genes that are related to sporadic AD \[[@B1]-[@B8]\]. These genes have implicated several molecular and cellular processes in the development of AD, including immune system functions, lipid metabolism and processes at the cell membrane such as endocytosis \[[@B4]\]. Bridging integrator 1 (BIN1) maps to the long arm of human chromosome 2 (2q14) and encodes multiple tissue-specific isoforms of the Myc-interacting adapter protein \[[@B9],[@B10]\]. BIN1 has been implicated in sporadic AD by a number of GWAS in a variety of populations \[[@B2],[@B3],[@B5]-[@B7],[@B11],[@B12]\]. BIN1 was originally implicated in sporadic AD by the association with the disease of two single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), rs744373 and rs7561528, both of which lie approximately 30 kb upstream of the BIN1 gene \[[@B3],[@B6]\], a finding subsequently replicated in a number of different cohorts \[[@B2],[@B7],[@B11]\]. In addition, a novel 3 bp insertion allele 28 kb upstream of BIN1 (rs59335482) was also recently identified \[[@B12]\]. There are several alternatively spliced variants of BIN1, the different isoforms being expressed by different tissues \[[@B10]\]. The widely expressed isoform of BIN1 is located in the nucleus and is thought to have functions relating to cell cycle regulation and cancer, whereas the brain-specific isoform is located in the axons and at the nodes of Ranvier \[[@B13]\]. One of the numerous roles of BIN1 is in endocytosis \[[@B14]-[@B16]\]. Despite the identification of BIN1 gene variants as being associated with sporadic AD, little is known about BIN1 protein expression and its involvement in AD pathogenesis. In this study we measured BIN1 protein level in frontal neocortex from cases of sporadic AD and age-matched control brain samples, the hippocampus of familial AD cases compared to age-matched controls, and in a non-dementia cohort across a range of ages. We demonstrate that BIN1 protein level is significantly decreased in sporadic AD compared to age-matched controls, but not in familial AD. Although BIN1 level tended to decline with age, this trend was not significant. As BIN1 has a function in endocytosis, we investigated its potential role in amyloid precursor protein (APP) metabolism and amyloid-β (Aβ) generation in a cell culture system. Neither knocking down endogenous BIN1 expression with targeted siRNA nor overexpression of BIN1 in a human neuroblastoma cell line had an effect on APP processing. Results {#s2} ======= BIN1 is decreased in sporadic but not familial AD and does not correlate with age {#s2.1} --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Quantitative immunoblotting was used to assess BIN1 level in the frontal cortex in sporadic AD and in age-matched non-dementia controls ([Table 1](#pone-0078806-t001){ref-type="table"}). BIN1 appears as multiple bands on immunoblot, with the bands corresponding to BIN1 spliced isoforms, the largest of which is 95kDa \[[@B9],[@B10],[@B17],[@B18]\]. BIN1 was significantly reduced in sporadic AD by a mean of 87% compared to controls (mean ± SD; controls 1.00 ± 2.13 and AD samples 0.19 ± 0.33, p = 0.007) ([Figure 1A and B](#pone-0078806-g001){ref-type="fig"}). To ensure that 3 outlying control samples were not causing disproportionate data bias, the cohort was reanalysed omitting these samples. BIN1 remained significantly reduced in sporadic AD, by a mean of 34% (mean ± SD; controls 0.29 ± 0.41 and AD samples 0.19 ± 0.33, p = 0.031) ([Figure 1B](#pone-0078806-g001){ref-type="fig"} inset). There was no significant difference in age between the sporadic AD and control cases (mean age ± SEM; 82.5 ± 1.4 years and 76.5 ± 2.7 years, respectively, p = 0.204) and the omission of the 3 outlying control samples did not significantly change the age of the control group (76.3 ± 3.1 years). In addition, there was no significant difference in the level of neuron-specific enolase (NSE) between the sporadic AD and control samples (mean ± SEM; 0.51 ± 0.05 pg/mL for each group, p = 0.992), indicating that the reduction in BIN1 in the sporadic AD samples was not caused by neuronal loss. The post-mortem delay was also not significantly different between the sporadic AD and control group (mean ± SEM; 51.08 ± 4.11 h and 38.50 ± 6.27 h, respectively, p = 0.100). 10.1371/journal.pone.0078806.t001 ###### Characteristics of the sporadic AD and control cases used in the study. **Gender** **Age (y)** **APOE ε4 allele** **Braak stage** **PM delay (h)** ----------------- ------------- -------------------- ----------------- ------------------ **Sporadic AD** M 69 4.4 5 48 F 70 3.4 6 25 M 74 3.4 5 50 F 74 4.4 5 53 F 77 3.4 4 43 F 78 4.4 6 77 F 78 3.4 5 9 F 78 3.3 6 35 M 79 3.4 6 28 M 80 3.4 6 31 F 81 3.4 6 42 F 81 3.3 4 66 F 83 3.4 5 43 M 85 3.4 4 58 M 85 3.4 6 66 F 87 3.4 5 72 F 87 2.4 5 67 F 88 3.3 6 79 F 89 3.3 5 71 F 89 3.3 5 82 F 90 4.4 4 21 F 91 3.4 4 37 F 91 2.4 5 70 F 96 2.3 4 53 **Control** F 43 \- \- 12 F 48 2.4 \- 79 M 53 3.3 \- 7 M 62 3.4 0 4 M 64 3.3 2 23 F 72 3.3 0 24 M 73 3.3 \- 36 M 77 2.3 3 10 M 78 3.3 2 12 M 79 3.3 \- 24 M 80 3.3 3 106 F 80 3.3 0 92 F 81 3.3 2 103 M 82 3.3 2 30 M 82 3.3 2 3 F 82 4.4 2 37 M 82 3.3 2 56 M 84 3.3 3 48 F 84 2.3 1 17 F 88 3.3 2 62 F 88 3.3 2 28 M 90 2.3 2 45 M 90 3.3 \- 48 F 93 3.3 2 18 {#pone-0078806-g001} To determine whether the reduction in BIN1 expression is a primary disease process or secondary to other AD-associated changes, we measured the level of BIN1 in brain tissue in familial AD and age-matched controls ([Table 2](#pone-0078806-t002){ref-type="table"}). In hippocampus from cases of familial AD there was a slight (27%) increase in BIN1 compared to the age-matched controls but this did not reach statistical significance (mean ± SD; controls 1.00 ± 0.62 and familial AD samples 1.27 ± 0.67, p = 0.488) ([Figure 1C and D](#pone-0078806-g001){ref-type="fig"}). There was no significant difference in age between the familial AD and control cases (mean age ± SEM; 61.8 ± 4.3 years and 63.2 ± 6.4 years, respectively, p = 0.866). The post-mortem delay was significantly different between the familial AD and control group (mean ± SEM; 13.3 ± 3.28 h and 40.7 ± 8.67 h, respectively, p = 0.015). We showed previously that there is no significant difference in the expression of the APP between the familial AD and control group \[[@B19]\] and there was also no significant difference in the expression of the neuronal marker MAP2 (p = 0.188), indicating that the reduction in BIN1 is not caused by neuronal loss. 10.1371/journal.pone.0078806.t002 ###### Characteristics of the Familial AD and control cases used in the study. **Gender** **Age (y)**    **Cause of death** **PM delay (h)** **Mutation** ----------------- ---------------- --------------------------------------------- ------------------ ----------------- **Familial AD** M 61 Bronchopneumonia 15 APP717(Val-Gly) F 69 Bronchopneumonia 10 APP717(Val-Ile) F 62 Bronchopneumonia 23 APP717(Val-Ile) M 42 Bronchopneumonia 6 PS1 DELTA4 F 72 Unknown 4 APP717(Val-Ile) F 65 Pneumonia 22 PS1 (E280G) **Control** F 62 Haemothorax 81 \- M 57 Left ventricular failure 45 \- F 79 Chronic obstructive airway disease 38 \- M 37 Acute necrotic pancreatitis 27 \- M 79 Septicaemia secondary to faecal peritonitis 24 \- M 65 Coronary artery occlusion 29 \- Mutation refers to the familial AD mutation identified in these individuals. We also used quantitative immunoblotting to measure the level of BIN1 in a series of non-dementia brains covering a wide spectrum of ages ([Table 3](#pone-0078806-t003){ref-type="table"}). The level of BIN1 in the hippocampus tended to decline with age but the correlation was not significant ([Figure 1E and F, r](#pone-0078806-g001){ref-type="fig"} ~s~=-0.449, p = 0.081). We showed previously that there is no significant correlation between age and the expression of APP \[[@B19]\] and there was no significant correlation between age and the expression of MAP2 (r~s~=0.322, p = 0.223). 10.1371/journal.pone.0078806.t003 ###### Characteristics of the series of non-dementia brains covering a wide spectrum of ages used in the study. **Gender** **Age (y)**   **Cause of death** **PM delay (h)** ------------ --------------- --------------------------------------------- ------------------ F 26 Carcinoma of the lung 44 M 25 Ruptured aortic arch aneurysm 18 F 20 Sudden accident 38 F 33 Pulmonary embolus 96 M 37 Acute necrotic pancreatitis 27 M 49 Pulmonary oedema 44 M 49 Coronary artery occlusion 32 M 58 Myocardial infarction 23 M 55 Syringomyelia 24 M 57 Left ventricular failure 45 F 62 Haemothorax 81 M 65 Coronary artery occlusion 29 F 76 Congestive heart failure 28 M 79 Septicaemia secondary to faecal peritonitis 24 F 80 Left ventricular failure/ bronchopneumonia 31 F 88 Carcinomatosis 43 BIN1 does not correlate with soluble or insoluble Aβ, Aβ plaque load or phospho-tau load in sporadic AD samples {#s2.2} --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- As BIN1 is decreased in sporadic AD compared to age-matched controls ([Figure 1A and B](#pone-0078806-g001){ref-type="fig"}) we investigated whether there was a correlation between BIN1 and the levels of soluble and insoluble Aβ and the Aβ plaque and phospho-tau load in the sporadic AD cases. Neither soluble nor insoluble Aβ correlated with BIN1 ([Figure 2A and B, r](#pone-0078806-g002){ref-type="fig"} ~s~=-0.084, p=0.698 and r~s~=0.237, p = 0.269, respectively). In addition, Aβ plaque load, as measured immunohistochemically, did not correlate with BIN1 (r~s~=0.063, p = 0.771, [Figure 2C](#pone-0078806-g002){ref-type="fig"}). Recently, Chapuis et al. (2013) proposed that BIN1 mediates AD risk by modulating tau pathology \[[@B12]\]. However, in our cohort the phospho-tau load, as measured immunohistochemically, did not correlate with BIN1 protein level (r~s~=-0.160, p = 0.489, [Figure 2D](#pone-0078806-g002){ref-type="fig"}). In addition BIN1 protein levels did not correlate with post-mortem delay (r~s~=0.373, p = 0.072). {#pone-0078806-g002} BIN1 overexpression has no effect on APP processing {#s2.3} --------------------------------------------------- As BIN1 is known to play a role in endocytosis \[[@B14]-[@B16]\] and the amyloidogenic processing of APP requires the endocytosis of APP \[[@B20]-[@B23]\], to investigate whether BIN1 affects the processing of APP the neuronal isoform of BIN1 was overexpressed in SH-SY5Y cells ([Figure 3A](#pone-0078806-g003){ref-type="fig"}). BIN1 overexpression did not alter the level of APP in the cell lysate ([Figure 3A and B](#pone-0078806-g003){ref-type="fig"}) nor the production of the soluble ectodomain resulting from α (sAPPα) or β (sAPPβ) cleavage ([Figure 3A and C](#pone-0078806-g003){ref-type="fig"}) in conditioned media, compared to empty vector control. BIN1 overexpression caused a small but significant 10% decrease in Aβ40 peptide in the conditioned media compared to the empty vector control (mean ± SD; control 100% and BIN1 over-expression 90.60% ± 2.68, p = 0.005); Aβ42 was also decreased, by 6% (mean ± SD; control 100% and BIN1 over-expression 94.45% ± 3.96), but this did not reach significance ([Figure 3D](#pone-0078806-g003){ref-type="fig"}). {#pone-0078806-g003} BIN1 knockdown has no effect on APP processing {#s2.4} ---------------------------------------------- To confirm the results of the BIN1 overexpression on APP processing the converse experiment was performed in which endogenous BIN1 expression was knocked down by siRNA in the SH-SY5Y cells. BIN1 knockdown caused a 65% (p \< 0.001) reduction in BIN1 protein when SH-SY5Y cells were incubated with BIN1 siRNA compared to a non-targeting siRNA control ([Figure 4A and B](#pone-0078806-g004){ref-type="fig"}). Fluorescence microscopy revealed that BIN1 was localised to the plasma membrane and cytoplasm and this staining was virtually abolished when BIN1 expression was knocked down by siRNA ([Figure 4C](#pone-0078806-g004){ref-type="fig"}). BIN1 knockdown had no significant effect on APP expression in the cell lysate ([Figure 4A and D](#pone-0078806-g004){ref-type="fig"}); on the production of sAPPα or sAPPβ ([Figure 4A and E](#pone-0078806-g004){ref-type="fig"}); or on the level of Aβ peptides ([Figure 4F](#pone-0078806-g004){ref-type="fig"}) in the conditioned media. {#pone-0078806-g004} Discussion {#s3} ========== In this study we have shown that the level of BIN1 protein is lower in the brain in sporadic AD than in non-demented age-matched controls. There was a large variation of BIN1 protein levels across the whole cohort of sporadic AD and control samples, however, this is unsurprising as protein levels are heritable molecular phenotypes that exhibit considerable variation between individuals, populations and sexes \[[@B24]\]. The observation that BIN1 protein is reduced in sporadic AD brains builds on recent observations from numerous GWAS where variants in the BIN1 gene were found to be associated with sporadic AD \[[@B2],[@B3],[@B5]-[@B7],[@B11],[@B12]\]. As the identified SNPs lie \~30kb upstream of the start of BIN1 \[[@B3],[@B6],[@B12]\], a change in expression level is unsurprising, as the primary and three dimensional structure of BIN1 would not be expected to be altered. A recent study showed that in a large cohort (64 AD and 61 control cases), BIN1 mRNA level was higher in AD cases than age-matched controls \[[@B12]\]. Although this was a robust study with an impressive cohort size, it was not specified whether the AD cases had sporadic or familial disease. Indeed we have shown that in contrast to the finding in sporadic AD, BIN1 protein expression remains unchanged in familial AD compared to age-matched controls. Notably, whereas Chapius et al. (2013) measured mRNA \[[@B12]\], we measured the level of BIN1 protein, which is likely to be more biologically and clinically meaningful. Indeed, several studies have shown that levels of mRNA transcript do not necessarily equate to protein levels \[[@B25],[@B26]\]. The levels of BIN1 protein were reduced in the frontal cortex of sporadic AD compared to age-matched non-dementia controls, but not in the hippocampus of familial AD. This implies that the alteration in BIN1 is involved in the pathogenesis of sporadic, but not familial AD and is not a consequence of AD neurodegeneration. The brain areas analysed did differ between the sporadic and familial AD cohorts, but both the frontal cortex and the hippocampus are areas known to be associated with AD \[[@B27]-[@B29]\]. Each cohort had its corresponding age-matched non dementia controls, however, we can not preclude the possibility that the difference between sporadic and familial AD in BIN1 levels is due to the different brain areas investigated. The familial AD cases used in this study all have either a mutation in APP (APP717 Val-Gly or Val-Ile) or presenilin 1 (PS1 DELTA4 or E280G). However, there are numerous mutations in APP, presenilin 1 and presenilin 2 which can cause familial AD \[[@B30]\] and our data do not preclude a change in the level of BIN1 in familial AD caused by other mutations. Ageing is the greatest risk factor for AD \[[@B31]\] but our data indicate that BIN1 expression does not change with age; suggesting that the changes in BIN1 associated with sporadic AD are not a result of ageing. Our data show that BIN1 does not correlate with the amount of tau pathology in sporadic AD. This is in contrast to a recent publication that proposed that a 3 bp insertion allele 28 kb upstream of BIN1 (rs59335482) was associated with the tau load in AD brains \[[@B12]\]. Over half (53.7 %) of the cohort in that study had at least one copy of the rs59335482 insertion allele and the insertion was associated with tau load but not with Aβ40 or Aβ42 in the brains of AD patients. Chapius et al. showed that *Amph*, the BIN1 *Drosophila* ortholog, modulates Tau neurotoxicity *in vivo* in a *Drosophila* model system, the loss of *Amph* was able to suppress Tau-induced neurotoxicity \[[@B12]\]. In addition, they showed by co-immunoprecipitation techniques that BIN1 interacts with Tau in synaptosomal fractions from mouse brain homogenates, however they did not detect any colocalisation of BIN1 with neurofibrillary tangles by immunohistochemical analysis in the brain of AD cases, suggesting that BIN1 probably does not have a role in the late stages of tangle formation although it could affect tau aggregation and/or oligomer formation in earlier stages of disease \[[@B12]\]. This may explain why we did not detect a correlation between BIN1 and tau in sporadic AD brain. One of the numerous roles of BIN1 is in endocytosis \[[@B14]-[@B16]\] . Endocytosis has an important role in AD pathology and is involved in Aβ generation \[[@B22]\], Aβ toxicity to neurons \[[@B32]\], and Aβ clearance from the brain by transport of Aβ across the blood brain barrier \[[@B33]\]. We have shown that the BIN1 level in sporadic AD does not correlate with soluble Aβ, insoluble Aβ or Aβ load in the temporal cortex, implying that decreased BIN1 is unlikely to affect endocytosis-dependent aspects of the generation or degradation of Aβ. To corroborate this, we have shown using cell line models, that BIN1 knockdown or overexpression does not alter APP processing, although there is a small but significant decrease in secreted Aβ40 when BIN1 is overexpressed in SH-SY5Y cells. Although BIN1 did not significantly and consistently affect the generation or degradation of Aβ in our experiments, compensatory mechanisms for the reduced amount of BIN1 in sporadic AD could be at play. During endocytosis BIN1 forms a heterodimer with amphiphysin 1, a BIN1 homologue \[[@B16]\]. Amphiphysin 1 is capable of forming homodimers in the absence of BIN1 \[[@B16]\], so amphiphysin 1 could compensate for decreased BIN1 in sporadic AD and upon siRNA-mediated depletion of BIN1. In conclusion our data demonstrate that BIN1 is reduced in sporadic but not familial AD, showing that the alteration in BIN1 is probably a primary contributor to the disease and not a secondary consequence of AD. Our findings are consistent with the numerous GWAS that implicate variation in the gene encoding for BIN1 in sporadic AD. Finally, we did not find evidence that a decline in BIN1 is likely to contribute to the increasing risk of AD with age. Materials and Methods {#s4} ===================== Ethics statement {#s4.1} ---------------- Brain tissue was obtained from the HTA licensed South West Dementia Brain Bank, University of Bristol, UK (sporadic AD) and from the Medical Research Council London Neurodegenerative Diseases Brain Bank, Institute of Psychiatry, King's College London, UK (familial AD and age-spectrum control cohort). The study was conducted with approval from The Cardiff Research Ethics Committee, North Somerset and South Bristol Research Ethics Committee and the Leeds Central Research Ethics Committee. Study cohorts {#s4.2} ------------- All sporadic AD cases had been subjected to detailed neuropathological examination. Sporadic AD cases had been assessed according to the criteria of the Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer\'s Disease (CERAD) \[[@B34]\]. The sporadic controls had no history of cognitive decline or dementia, showing the absence of AD (as defined by CERAD) or other neuropathological abnormalities. The levels of total soluble and total guanidine-extractable Aβ \[[@B35],[@B36]\], the Aβ plaque load (area fraction of cerebral cortex immunopositive for Aβ) \[[@B37],[@B38]\], NSE level \[[@B39]\] and phospho-tau load (area fraction of cerebral cortex immunopositive for phospho-tau) \[[@B37],[@B40]\] had previously been measured in all cases. The AD and control groups were matched as far as possible for post-mortem delay, age-at-death and gender, as presented in [Tables 1](#pone-0078806-t001){ref-type="table"}, [2](#pone-0078806-t002){ref-type="table"} and [3](#pone-0078806-t003){ref-type="table"}. Tissue preparation {#s4.3} ------------------ For measurements of BIN1 protein and NSE in sporadic AD samples, approximately 200 mg of frontal neocortex (Brodmann area 6) was homogenised in 1 ml lysis buffer (0.5% Triton X-100, 20 mM Tris/HCl pH 7.4, 10% (w/v) sucrose containing aprotinin (1 µg/ml) and phenylmethane sulfonyl fluoride (PMSF; 10 µM)) (all reagents from Sigma-Aldrich, Pool, Dorset, UK). Brain tissue was homogenised for 30 s in a Precellys 24 automated tissue homogeniser (Stretton Scientific, Derbyshire, UK) with 2.3-mm silica beads (Biospec, Thistle Scientific, Glasgow, UK) and total protein was measured using Total Protein kit (Sigma-Aldrich, Pool, Dorset, UK). The homogenates were centrifuged at 20 817 *g* for 15 min at 4°C, and aliquots of the supernatant were stored at -80°C until used. Familial AD and age-spectrum control brain tissue samples from the hippocampus were homogenised in 9 volumes of phosphate buffered saline (PBS without Ca^2+^ and Mg^2+^, Gibco), 0.5% (v/v) Nonidet P40, 0.5% (w/v) sodium deoxycholate, pH 7.4 in the presence of a complete protease inhibitor cocktail (Roche Applied Science, Burgess Hill, UK) using an electrical homogeniser. Samples were centrifuged at 14,000 *g* for 10 min. For measurements of Aβ, tissue (200 mg) was allowed to thaw to 4°C, homogenised in 5 volumes (w/v) of Tris-buffered saline (TBS) extraction buffer \[140 mM NaCl, 3 mM KCl, 25 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.4, containing 1% Nonidet P-40 (NP40), 5 mM EDTA, 2 mM 1,10-phenanthroline, 10 µM PMSF and 1 µg/ml aprotinin (all reagents from Sigma-Aldrich, Pool, Dorset, UK), as detailed in \[[@B35],[@B36]\]. The homogenate was then centrifuged at 20 817 *g* for 15 min at 4°C and the supernatant (soluble fraction) was stored at −80°C until used. The pellet was homogenised in 6.25 M guanidine HCl in 50 mM Tris/HCl, pH 8.0, incubated for 4 h at 25°C and centrifuged at 20 817 *g* for 20 min at 4°C. The resultant supernatant (guanidine-extractable fraction) was stored at −80°C until used. Immunoblotting {#s4.4} -------------- The protein content of the brain homogenate was determined using bicinchoninic acid in a microtitre plate-based assay with bovine serum albumin (BSA) standards. Samples were mixed with an equal volume of SDS dissociation buffer (125 mM Tris/HCl, pH 6.8, 2% (w/v) SDS, 20% (v/v) glycerol, 100 mM dithiothreitol, 0.002% (w/v) bromophenol blue), and boiled for 4 min. Proteins were resolved by SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis using 7% (APP) and 10% (BIN1, sAPPα and sAPPβ) polyacrylamide gels. Resolved proteins were transferred to Immobilon P polyvinylidene difluoride membrane (Amersham, Little Chalfont, UK). The membrane was blocked by incubation for 1 h with PBS containing 0.1% (v/v) Tween-20 and 5% (w/v) dried milk powder. Antibody incubations were performed in PBS Tween containing 2% (v/v) bovine serum albumin. Antibody against BIN1 (Abcam, Cambridge, UK) was used at 1:1000, anti-APP antibody 22C11 (MercMillipore, Billerica, MA, USA) was used at 1:2500, anti-sAPPα antibody 6E10 (Covance, New Jersey, USA) was used at 1:4000 and 1A9 antibody (gift from Dr I Hussain, GlaxoSmithKline, Harlow, UK) was raised against a neoepitope formed on wild type sAPPβ following β-cleavage of APP was used at 1:2500. Horseradish peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody was used at 1:4000 in the same buffer. Bound antibody was detected using the enhanced chemiluminescence detection method (Amersham Biosciences, Amersham, UK). Densitometric analysis was performed using Image J 1.44p (National Institutes of Health, USA). Quantification was in relation to total protein. Total amount of protein was determined from amido black (0.1% (w/v) amido black, 1% (v/v) acetic acid) stained membranes using Image J 1.44p. Measurement of total soluble and insoluble (guanidine-extractable) Aβ {#s4.5} --------------------------------------------------------------------- The method of ELISA measurement of total soluble and insoluble Aβ was reported previously \[[@B35],[@B36]\]. Soluble and insoluble (guanidine-HCl-extractable) fractions were analysed by sandwich ELISA in which monoclonal anti-Aβ (4G8 clone, raised against amino acids 18-22; Millipore, Watford, UK) was used for the capture step and biotinylated anti-human Aβ monoclonal antibody (10H3 clone) (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Northumberland, UK) for the detection step. Measurement of Aβ load {#s4.6} ---------------------- Parenchymal Aβ load had previously been measured in all cases \[[@B38]\]. The field fraction (percentage area occupied by Aβ) was measured in an unbiased selection of 10 areas of cortex covering 4mm^2^ with the help of Histometrix software (Kinetic Imaging, Wirral,UK) driving a Leica DM microscope with a motorised stage. Aβ-laden blood vessels were excluded from analysis. Measurement of tau load {#s4.7} ----------------------- The precentage area of cerebral cortex immunopositive for phospho-tau had also been measured previously \[[@B37],[@B40]\], using the same unbiased selection and image analysis method as that used to measure Aβ load (see above). Cell culture {#s4.8} ------------ SH-SY5Y (human neuroblastoma) cells were cultured in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM) (Lonza, Basel, Switzerland) supplemented with 10% (v/v) fetal bovine serum (FBS) (Biosera, East Sussex, UK), in a humidified incubator at 37°C with 5% (v/v) CO~2~. Plasmid and siRNA transfection {#s4.9} ------------------------------ cDNA encoding human BIN1 in expression vector pcDNA3.1(+) (Source Bioscience, Nottingham, UK) or empty vector alone (Invitrogen life sciences, Paisley, Scotland, UK) was introduced by electroporation into SH-SY5Y cells stably expressing APP~695~ in pIREShyg \[[@B41]\]. Cells were selected using 1 mg/mL G418 (Sigma-Aldrich, Pool, Dorset, UK). siRNA specific for human BIN1 and a non-targeting sequence (UGGUUUACAUGUCGACUAA UGGUUUACAUGUUGUGUGA UGGUUUACAUGUUUUCUGA UGGUUUACAUGUUUUCCUA) were obtained as smartpools from Dharmacon (Thermo Fisher Scientific Biosciences, Northumberland, UK). SH-SY5Y cells were seeded in routine culture medium and allowed to adhere overnight. Cells were transfected with 50 nM (final concentration) BIN1 or non-targeting control siRNA as a complex with Dharmafect 3 (Thermo Fisher Scientific Biosciences, Northumberland, UK) according to the manufacturer's instructions and incubated for 24 h at 37°C with 5% (v/v) CO~2~. Cell preparation {#s4.10} ---------------- Cells were incubated for 48 h in OptiMEM reduced sera medium (Invitrogen life sciences, Paisley, Scotland, UK) at 37°C with 5% CO~2~ (v/v). OptiMEM reduced sera medium was removed from the cells and centrifuged for 10 min at either 3913 *g* at 4°C. The supernatant was either stored at -20°C for Aβ ELISA or concentrated \~50 fold using Vivaspin 100,000 Da molecular weight cut off polyethersulfone membrane concentrator (Sartoris Stedim Biotech, Surrey, UK) by centrifugation at 3913 *g* at 4°C. Cells were washed and harvested in PBS (with Ca^2+^ and Mg^2+^), and pelleted by centrifugation at 3193 *g* at 4°C. Cells were lysed in RIPA lysis buffer (50 mM Tris, 150 mM NaCl, 0.5% (w/v) Sodium deoxycholate, 1% (v/v) NP-40, pH 8.0) with EDTA complete protease inhibitor cocktail (Roche Diagnostics, West Sussex, UK), incubated at 4°C for 30 min and centrifuged at 13,000 *g* for 10 min at room temperature. The subsequent supernatant was frozen at -20°C for protein analysis. Aβ ELISA {#s4.11} -------- Sandwich ELISAs for the detection of human Aβ40 and Aβ42 were performed as described previously \[[@B42]\]. Briefly, 96-well microtitre plates were coated overnight at 4°C with primary antibodies against Aβ40 (33.1.1) and Aβ42 (2.1.3.35.86) (a kind gift from C. and E. Eckman\* and P. Das, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL, USA; \*current address Atlantic Health System, Morristown, NJ, USA). Following blocking and incubation with conditioned media, bound Aβ peptides were detected with HRP-conjugated detection antibody (Aβ40, 13.1.1-HRP (C. and E. Eckman and P. Das); Aβ42, 4G8-HRP (Covance, New Jersey, USA)). Fluorescence Microscopy {#s4.12} ----------------------- Fluorescence microscopy was carried out as described previously \[[@B43]\]. Briefly, cells were cultured in normal growth medium to ^\~^60% confluence on glass coverslips and siRNA treated (see above). Post-incubation, cells were fixed with 4% (v/v) paraformaldehyde for 10 min, permeabilised using 0.2% (v/v) Triton X-100 and blocked overnight at 4 °C in PBS containing Ca^2+^ and Mg^2+^ ions with 5% (v/v) fish skin gelatin. Coverslips were then incubated for 2 h in the same buffer containing BIN1 specific antibody (Abcam, Cambridge, UK), washed, and then incubated with the appropriate fluorescent probe-conjugated secondary antibody under the same conditions. Nuclei were counterstained by washing briefly in DAPI stain, and coverslips were mounted onto glass slides using Fluoromount-G (Southern Biotech). Cells were visualised using a DeltaVision Optical Restoration Microscopy System (Applied Precision). Statistical analysis {#s4.13} -------------------- The distribution of the AD cases compared to their age-matched controls was determined by the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. Group data were compared using either an Independent T-test for parametric, or a Mann-Whitney U test for non-parametric data 2-tailed Spearman's rank correlation coefficient was used on non-parametric data to assess the correlation between BIN1 and soluble and insoluble Aβ, Aβ load, tau load and age; p ≤ 0.05 was considered significant. The data were analysed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS 17.0) program (Chicago, USA) and GraphPad Prism (version 6) (Graphpad Software Inc , California, USA). We thank C. Troakes, s Al-Sarraj, and M. Rossor of the Medical Research Council London Neurodegenerative Diseases Brain Bank for provision of samples, and Chris and Liz Eckman (Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL, USA - current address Atlantic Health System, Morristown, NJ, USA) and Pritam Das (Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL, USA) for the provision of the Aβ ELISA antibodies. [^1]: **Competing Interests:**The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. [^2]: Conceived and designed the experiments: EBCG JSM PGK SL NMH. Performed the experiments: EBCG JSM. Analyzed the data: EBCG IJW JSM SL KABK. Wrote the manuscript: IJW KABK NMH. Finalisation of the submitted manuscript: EBCG IJW JSM PGK SL KABK NMH. [^3]: Current address: Institute of Psychiatry, King's College London, London, UK

\section{Introduction} Lift-driven Vertical-Axis Wind Turbines (VAWT) exhibit interesting advantages with respect to the widespread horizontal-axis counterpart in terms of installation and operation \citep{Tjiu_2015a, Tjiu_2015b}, even though they are characterized by complex unsteady aerodynamics which eventually penalizes the energy conversion efficiency of the rotor \citep{elcheikh2018performance, Chen_2022}. Typically, VAWT operation is inherently associated with wide oscillations in Reynolds number and angle of attack during the revolution which makes the blades undergo dynamic-stall and even deep-stall \citep{Sheidani_2022, Tirandaz_2021}. As a result of such oscillations, vortices detaching from the blades are shed into the wake, making it highly unsteady and composed of multiple time/length scales. These features make VAWT wakes highly different from those of horizontal-axis rotors \citep{Hamlaoui_2022}, with important implications on the mixing rate and evolution of the flow downstream of the turbine. Owing to the unique characteristics of lift-driven VAWT such as low sensitivity to the wind direction, relatively higher power coefficient compared to that of drag-type VAWT \citep{Franchina_2020} and, more importantly, smaller dimensions, VAWTs are growing in popularity to be utilized on a large scale ranging from urban to off-shore areas \citep{stathopoulos2018urban, Franchina_2019}, following with consequent studies on the compactness and optimizing tandem configurations \citep{Silva_2021}. Therefore, the presence of the turbines in large numbers and denser configurations, heightens the strong need to gain a deeper insight into the wakes shed past a VAWT \citep{hohman2020effect, vergaerde2020experimental, posa2020dependence, posa2020influence}. As a whole, a deep inspection into the flow characteristics may be obtained by means of high-fidelity experimental and numerical methods such as Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) \citep{Lee_2016, Sim_o_Ferreira_2008, Herr_ez_2018, Ferreira_2020} and Scale Resolving Simulation (SRS). While resolving the full spectrum of turbulence by means of Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) remains out of reach due to excessive computational cost, SRS methods including Large Eddy Simulation (LES) \citep{Safari_2018, He_2021, Tang_2022} and Detached Eddy Simulation (DES) \citep{Larin_2016, Boudreau_2017, Qian_2019} and Scale-Adaptive Simulation (SAS) \citep{Toja_Silva_2018, Rezaeiha_2019b} aim to resolve only the larger scales of the turbulence with modelling the smaller ones. However, these techniques impose a great deal of computational cost to the system as well and yet they are prone to the existence of noise which requires employment of different methods to eliminate the unfavorable indeterministic signals \citep{Scherl_2020}. As a result, this study, as one of the primary objectives, is intended to investigate to what extent more economical turbulence models like Reynolds Average Navier Stokes (RANS) can be implemented to study the phenomenon of wake shed behind a VAWT. For this purpose, Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) will be utilized to extract the hidden structures of both turbulence simulation techniques to cast light deeply on this matter. The employment of POD to extract different modes of flow dynamics was first proposed by Lumely \citep{lumley1967structure}. This idea was then nurtured and developed into more robust methods in different studies namely, Sirovich \citep{Sirovich_1987} who put forward the concept of snapshot POD. Consequently, in recent years, the advances in Reduced Order Modelling (ROM) techniques have led to a great deal of studies intended to enlighten the hidden flow characteristics by employing methods like POD \citep{aroma_book,lassila2014model, _tefan_2017, Sinha_2018, Wang_2018, Chouak_2018, benner2021system, benner2020modela, benner2020modelb}. There have been several attempts to investigate wake characteristics shed behind a VAWT. In this regard, Abkar and Dabiri \citep{Abkar_2017} employed the LES method to study the wake of a Darrieus VAWT. It was shown that the wakes of the VAWT demonstrate self-similarity especially, in the central part of the wake. Tescione et al. \citep{Tescione_2014} performed an experimental study by implementing PIV technique, to study the wake characteristics of an H-shaped VAWT at a close distance from the rotor. One of the main observations in this study was that the vortical structures can be divided into two major parts mainly at a distance being equal to three times the rotor radius. Kuang et al. \citep{Kuang_2022} employed Improved Delayed Detached Eddy Simulation (IDDES) to investigate the effect of the wake of an upstream floating VAWT on a downstream one. It was reported that the pitch motion leads to a lower amount of velocity deficit in the core region of the wake area. Shamsoddin and Porté-Agel \citep{Shamsoddin_2020} studied the effect of aspect ratio on the wake shed behind a VAWT and it was shown that while the wake keeps the primary aspect ratio in the near wake region, it tends to an elliptical shape as it moves away from the rotor. Owing to the distinctive wake characteristics of VAWTs there have been several studies aiming at deriving an analytical model for the description of the VAWT wake. In this regard, Peng et al. \citep{Peng_2021} reviewed different analytical models validated by a wide range of high-fidelity methods including field test, PIV and CFD methods for this purpose. It should be noted that the change in wake characteristics behind a VAWT due to the blade geometrical alterations has been recently studied \citep{Asim_2021}. High-fidelity CFD models often contain too much information at the cost of severe computationals. However, despite the lower accuracy associated with RANS methods compared to LES, as found in the literature \citep{HijaziStabileMolaRozza2020b, Lorenzi_2016, Nakazawa_2019, Liu_2014}, the employment of POD on RANS results yet yields interpretable outcome which may be utilized to extract valuable flow characteristics. Chen et al. \citep{Chen_2020} investigated the effect of gurney flaps on the performance improvement of an H-shaped Darrieus VAWT by means of RANS turbulence models. Following this, a POD analysis on the turbine wake was implemented and it was shown that the use of gurney flaps leads to curbing the vortex strength in the wake of the turbine after the fifth POD mode. Considering the studies conducted so far on Reduced Order Modelling of flow characteristics past a wind turbine, it reveals that the modal analysis of wake shed behind a Darrieus VAWT rotor, by highly accurate methods like LES, in order to unfold the major flow structures has remained unnoticed. More importantly, with regards to the work of Asim and Islam \citep{Asim_2021} and Chen et al. \citep{Chen_2020} where the POD analysis has been separately performed on LES and RANS results of Savenious and Darrieus wind turbines simulation respectively, this study is intended to assess to what extent the RANS methods can be trusted to perform the wake study or extract the small flow structures with respect to LES modes considered as the basis for the comparison. This point is of great importance owing to the growing popularity of VAWTs in more compact configurations leading to the necessity of performing an in-depth study on the flow characteristics past a VAWT. Therefore, in this study, in order to perform an analysis on the VAWT wake, POD method will be employed to unfold the physics of flow behind a VAWT. In the beginning, the numerical methods employed in this study will be discussed. Following this, the results will be validated with respect to the experimental study of Battisti et al. \citep{Battisti_2018} and the POD method will be briefly discussed. Finally, a discussion on the LES and RANS results and the summary will be presented. \section{NUMERICAL METHODS} In order to perform the numerical simulation of the problem described in the previous section, the Unsteady Reynolds Average Navier Stokes (URANS) and the filtered form of Navier Stokes for the LES equations are numerically solved using ANSYS FLUENT 2020 software. The URANS formulation is adopted for the continuity and momentum equations of the incompressible fluid which is as follows: \begin{equation} \label{eq1} \frac{\partial \overline{U_{i}}}{\partial x_i}=0\\ \end{equation} \begin{equation} \label{eq2} \frac{\partial \rho \overline{U_i}}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial \rho \overline{U_i \bar{U}_j}}{\partial x_j}=-\frac{\partial P}{\partial x_i}+\frac{\partial}{\partial x_j}\left[\mu\left(\frac{\partial \overline{U_i}}{\partial x_j}+\frac{\partial \overline{U_j}}{\partial x_i}\right)-\rho \overline{u_{i}^{\prime} u_{j}^{\prime}}\right]\\ \end{equation} where $\overline{U_{i}}$ and $\rho \overline{u_{i}^{\prime} u_{j}^{\prime}}$ are the averaged velocity and Reynolds stress tensor, respectively. The latter can be written as: \begin{equation} \label{eq3} -\rho \overline{\boldsymbol{u}_{i}^{\prime} \boldsymbol{u}_{\boldsymbol{j}}^{\prime}}=2 \mu_t \overline{S_{ij}}-\frac{2}{3} k \rho \overline{\delta_{ij}}\\ \end{equation} where the mean strain rate tensor is: \begin{equation} \label{eq4} \overline{S_{ij}}=\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\partial \bar{U}_i}{\partial x_j}+\frac{\partial \bar{U}_j}{\partial x_i}\right)\\ \end{equation} The turbulent viscosity term, $\mu_t$, can be addressed with common one- or two- equation eddy viscosity models to provide turbulence closure. As for the LES model, filtered Navier-Stokes is utilized: \begin{equation} \label{eq5} \frac{\partial \rho \widetilde{U_i}}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial \rho \widetilde{U_i} \widetilde{U_j}}{\partial x_j}=-\frac{\partial P}{\partial x_i}+\frac{\partial}{\partial x_j}\left[\mu\left(\frac{\partial \widetilde{U_i}}{\partial x_j}+\frac{\partial \widetilde{U_j}}{\partial x_i}\right)\right]-\frac{\partial \tau_{\mathrm{ij}}}{\partial x_j}\\ \end{equation} where the last term, $\tau_{\mathrm{ij}}$, is the sub-grid scale (SGS) stress and defined as follows: \begin{equation} \label{eq6} \tau_{i j}=\rho \widetilde{u_i u_j}-\rho \widetilde{u_i} \widetilde{u_j} \end{equation} There exists couple of closure models to address SGS in terms of the local resolved flow. Selection of the appropriate turbulence closure model for RANS and LES will be discussed further on. In the following section the structure of the numerical method including the grid generation, turbulence modelling techniques, POD method, independency studies and validation results will be presented. \subsection{Problem Description} This study is aimed to perform the RANS and LES numerical simulations on a VAWT based on the experimental work of Battisti et al. \citep{Battisti_2018} at different tip speed ratios (TSR). The rotor diameter of the VAWT is equal to 1.03 (m) and it consists of three NACA0021 airfoils with a chord value of 0.086 m. The simulations will be implemented at the rated TSR being equal to 2.4 and the off-design points of operation corresponding to TSR3.3 and TSR1.5. It should be noted that as the turbine rotates at 400(rpm) the TSRs 1.5, 2.4 and 3.3 correspond to inlet velocity of $14.38 (m\slash s)$, $9.1 (m\slash s)$ and $6.5 (m\slash s)$ respectively. Also, this study is intended to perform POD analysis and investigate the wakes shed behind the rotor as shown in the box presented in Fig. \ref{FIG1} where the dimensions used in the computational domains have been designated. The inlet and outlet boundaries are respectively on the left and right sides of the domain and the upper and lower boundaries are considered to be of pressure outlet type. \begin{figure*} \centering \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{figs/1.png} \caption{Dimensions of the cell zones of the computational domain} \label{FIG1} \end{figure*} \subsection{Grid Generation} The necessity of the full-scale simulation of the turbine including blades and support structure (support arms and central hub) is dependent on the type of the wind turbine (\cite{sotoudeh2019field,mousavi2020mathematical}). Siddiqui et al. \citep{siddiqui2015quantification} concluded that for this specific type of VAWT, i.e. H-Darrieus wind turbine, effects of the upper and lower tips are negligible. Hence, employment of a 3D model composed of a portion of the blades is sufficiently accurate. To this end, 3D meshes were created by extrusion of a 2D mesh into the normal direction by means of one chord length, as recommended by \citep{xu2017delayed,li20132}, while considering the periodic boundary condition for two sides of the extrusion. In order to perform a grid independency study, three sets of meshes with $1\times 10^6$, $2.1\times 10^6$ and $3.8\times 10^6$ hexahedral elements were created, respectively, for the RANS simulations. There observed less than a 1\% difference between the results of two later meshes, and hence, the second mesh was selected to perform the post-processing. As for the LES, the model consisted of $1.1\times 10^7$ hexahedral elements with a total of 28 layers in the spanwise direction. The minimum and average orthogonal qualities of the grid were 0.3 and 0.9, respectively, which is regarded as a good quality for LES simulations \citep{yagmur2021numerical}. The minimum resolution percentage based on the Index Quality criterion proposed by Celik et al \citep{Celik_2005} was found to be 81\% (Fig. \ref{FIG3}). According to \citep{pope2000turbulent, Celik_2005} the value above 80\% corresponds to an adequate resolved portion of the turbulent kinetic energy for the LES simulation indicating an appropriate mesh density. Finally, the first element height for wall boundaries was set to $5\times 10^{-6}$ corresponding to $y^{+}\sim1$. The schematic presentation of the LES grid can be seen in Fig. \ref{FIG2}. \begin{figure*} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.21]{figs/2-1.png} \includegraphics[scale=.21]{figs/2-2.png} \includegraphics[scale=.1]{figs/2-3.png} \caption{ Overview of the LES mesh (a) around the turbine and consequent cell zones b) around the blade c) on the surface of the extruded blade.} \label{FIG2} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.2]{figs/3.png} \caption{Contour of \textit{index quality} for the LES mesh} \label{FIG3} \end{figure*} \subsection{Turbulence Modelling Techniques} As the blades during one period of rotation undergo a wide range of Reynolds number from very low to high, the suitable RANS model needs to be found. To this end several fully turbulent and transient models including $\gamma-Re_{\theta}$, $k_{t}-k_{l}-\omega$ and $k-\omega$ SST were performed at the rated TSR and it was found that the latter i.e. $k-\omega$ SST yields the most accurate results. It should be noted that this is matching the finding of Rezaeiha et al. \citep{Rezaeiha_2019}. In addition, all the spatial and temporal terms in Equation \ref{eq2} were discretized by second order method and SIMPLE algorithm was employed to solve the set of equations. Furthermore, regarding the LES equations, Wall-Adapting Local Eddy-Viscosity (WALE) Model \citep{nicoud1999subgrid} was implemented to capture the Sub-Grid Scale (SGS) structures as suggested by Ma et al. \citep{Ma_2009} to be the most suitable modelling technique for the LES computation of the flow physics of wind turbines. In addition, the convection term in Equation \ref{eq5} was discretized by Central Differencing method as suggested by Li et al. \citep{Li_2013} where, similar to the current study, a 2.5D LES of a VAWT had been implemented. Also, the time step size was set to be $10^{-4} sec$ as it corresponds to $0.24^{\circ}$ of rotation leading to a CFL number less than unity. \subsection{Proper Orthogonal Decomposition Method} Proper Orthogonal Decomposition is employed to extract the coherent structures both in spatial and temporal domain \citep{Li_2013}. It should be noted that the POD method implemented in this study is based on the work of Taira et al. \citep{Taira_2017}. In order for POD to be implemented, the Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) method was employed owing to its robustness against roundoff errors \citep{Lengani_2014}. In order to perform SVD, the 'matrix of snapshots' denoted as 'X' needs to be formed. The rows of X include the value of the variable of interest corresponding to its position in the computational domain and the columns correspond to the time instance at which the data has been extracted. Having formed the X matrix, SVD is applied as follows in Equation 3-7: \begin{equation} \boldsymbol{X}=\Phi_{\mathrm{U}} \Sigma \Phi_{\mathrm{V}}^T\\ \end{equation} Where $\Phi_{\mathrm{U}}$ and $\Phi_{\mathrm{V}}^T$ are called the left and right eigenvectors, respectively. Also, $\Sigma$ is a diagonal matrix containing the eigenvalues organized in a descending order. Therefore, each element of the $\Sigma$ matrix demonstrates the importance of each column of $\Phi_{\mathrm{U}}$. It should be noted that, the left eigenvector corresponds to the spatial coherent structures which are in other words, the modes of the flow. On the other hand, the right eigenvector indicates the evolution of each mode in time domain. \subsection{Validation Study} The RANS and LES simulations were performed at the peak power TSR 2.4 and the two extremes of off-design points i.e. TSRs 3.3 and 1.5. Following this, the results were extracted and the moment coefficient versus TSR were plotted in Fig. \ref{FIG4}. The results are in good agreement with that of the experimental study of Battisti et al. \citep{Battisti_2018} and the RANS numerical results of Franchina et al. \citep{Franchina_2019,Franchina_2020}. It should be noted that the difference between the two-dimensional RANS and the experimental results stems from the fact that in 2-D simulations the effects of tip vortices and struts are absent and the flow experiences lower drag and therefore drop in power consequently which is in agreement with the results of Franchina et al. \citep{Franchina_2019,Franchina_2020}. Moreover, the main discrepancy between LES and RANS occurs as a result of the dynamic stall characteristics (i.e. formation, growth, bursting/ shedding of the separation bubble) and trailing-edge vortex as well as their interaction specially at low tip speed ratios. More details of RANS and SRS methods' applicability for simulating VAWTs can be found in \citep{Franchina_2019,Franchina_2020}. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.55]{figs/4.png} \caption{Power coefficient validation with respect to the experimental work of \citep{Battisti_2018} and numerical results of \citep{Franchina_2019}} \label{FIG4} \end{figure} As the main purpose of the current study is to investigate the wake characteristics behind the VAWT, the velocity profile at the wake region located 3.5D behind the rotor was calculated and the results were compared against that of the experimental work of \citep{Battisti_2018} in Fig. \ref{FIG5}. Both RANS and LES approaches exhibited good agreement with the experimental data for the time-averaged velocity. However, the main shortcoming of RANS model, i.e. inability to capture unsteady and inherent fluctuations of the flow, resulted in a smoother velocity profile compared to that of LES \citep{lin2021cfd}. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.5]{figs/5.png} \includegraphics[scale=.5]{figs/6.png} \includegraphics[scale=.5]{figs/7.png} \caption{Validation in the wake region located at 3.5D behind the rotor with respect to the experimental results of \citep{Battisti_2018} a) TSR1.5, b) TSR2.4 and c) TSR3.3 } \label{FIG5} \end{figure} \section{Results and Discussion} The numerical simulation was performed at different TSRs by both RANS and LES methods and the POD modes were extracted. In the first place, the flow physics and the structures formed due to the vortex shedding past the rotor will be briefly discussed. Fig. \ref{FIG4_1} depicts the vorticity contours colored by the velocity magnitude at different sections of the rotation domain namely windward, upwind, leeward and downwind whose definition and a thorough explanation on them can be found in Tescione et al. \citep{Tescione_2014}. As long as the blade sweeps the windward section (Fig. \ref{FIG4_1}-b), it sees a relatively low angle of attack which could be clearly observed for the one on the top of the rotating domain where the vortex shedding is lower compared to the other two airfoils. This is due to the fact that at this section the rotational velocity forms a considerably low angle with the absolute velocity vector resulting in a low angle of attack and blade loading and therefore less separation. However, as the blade progresses towards the upwind section Fig. \ref{FIG4_1}-c) the vortex shedding sees a rising trend due to the increased blade loading. As the blade approaches the leeward section (Fig. \ref{FIG4_1}-d), the separation reaches its height and having entered the downwind part, the separation and the consequent vortex shedding phenomenon abates. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.15]{figs/4-1-a.png} \includegraphics[scale=.06]{figs/4-1-b.png} \includegraphics[scale=.06]{figs/4-1-c.png} \includegraphics[scale=.06]{figs/4-1-d.png} \includegraphics[scale=.1]{figs/4-1-e.png} \caption{Vorticity contours of LES simulation of TSR2.4 at different rotation sections a) vorticity contour in the entire flow domain b) vortex Shedding at windward section c) vortex Shedding at upwind section d) vortex Shedding at leeward section} \label{FIG4_1} \end{figure} The cumulative modal energy of the RANS and LES results have been presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_2}. Regarding the RANS results, the cumulative modal energy of the streamwise component of velocity proves that except for the first mode, the modal energy of the TSR2.4 and TSR 3.3 fall on top of each other. However, TSR1.5 reaches the maximum amount of the accumulative modal energy at significantly higher mode numbers suggesting that more flow structures could be excepted at lower TSRs due to the higher blade loading and high relative angle of attack which is an intrinsic characteristic of lower TSRs. Also, as shown in Fig. \ref{FIG4_2}-b, the number of effective modes increases considerably with the decrease in TSR. As a result, it is found that the vortex shedding due to separation at high relative angles of attack leads to more effective modes for transversal component of velocity rather than the streamwise component of velocity. Moreover, comparing to the streamwise component of velocity, it is observed that the largest amount of RANS modal energy accumulation for the transversal component of velocity belongs to the highest TSR, while the peak power (TSR 2.4) has the highest amount for the streamwise velocity component with respect to the other cases. Therefore, the transversal modes mainly correspond to flow structures stemming from flow separation and entrainment which is a well-known characteristic of lower TSRs. Therefore, it is observed that the number of convective modes (effective modes) is proportional to the wind velocity for the transversal component modes. In addition, due to the striking similar behavior of the cumulative energy between TSR3.3 and TSR2.4, analogous spatial modal behavior could be expected. It should be noted that this observation could be better understood by plotting the spatial POD modes. However, as for the LES results, the modes of TSR2.4 and TSR3.3 show a more noticeable difference with respect to the RANS modes, as shown in Fig. \ref{FIG4_2}-a. This is due to the fact that the LES resolves more structures compared to RANS simulation leading to more convective modes. Therefore, the observation previously made on RANS modes is confirmed suggesting that the lower TSRs are correspondent to more wake shedding which is in agreement with the aerodynamics of VAWTs. Also, it should be noted that unlike the RANS cumulative modes, where the rated TSR demonstrated the maximum energy at the first mode, the highest energy at the same mode number is observed at the highest TSR for the LES results. This observation suggests that the RANS fails to properly compute the energy of the modes at higher TSRs. In other words, the effective structures at higher TSRs cannot be distinctively captured in RANS POD modes. Moving on to Fig. \ref{FIG4_2}-b, the cumulative modal energy behavior of the transversal component of velocity reveal that both RANS and LES still follow the same trend except that the LES modes, as previously stated, demonstrate considerably a lower amount of modal energy at each mode number owing to the capability of LES method to resolve considerably more flow structures. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.5]{figs/4-2-a.png} \includegraphics[scale=.5]{figs/4-2-b.png} \caption{Cumulative POD energy curves a) streamwise component of velocity b) transversal component of velocity} \label{FIG4_2} \end{figure} Presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}, \ref{FIG4_4} and \ref{FIG4_5} are the spatial POD modes at TSR2.4, TSR3.3 and TSR1.5 respectively where the distance between the dashed lines indicates the diameter of the wind turbine as they have been placed at the two extremes of the rotor. Also, the windward and leeward sections of the wind turbine have been located at the upper and lower boundaries of the POD box, respectively. As for the mode analysis of RANS simulations, the first mode shown in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-a-1, demonstrates the mean flow behind the rotor which could be interpreted as the efficiency of the turbine in energy extraction when compared to same mode number at TSRs 3.3 and 1.5 presented respectively in Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-a-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_5}-a-1. It is evident in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-a-1 that the area affected by the presence of the wind turbine rotor, i.e. wake region, begins to collapse after about 6D, while for TSR3.3 and 1.5 the wake region collapse is observed at a distance considerably closer and far from to the rotor, respectively (Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-a-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_5}-a-1). It should be noted that this is in agreement with our knowledge of physics of fluid flow past a VAWT. To illustrate, as the higher TSRs correspond to lower blade loading and less flow momentum, the fluid flow past the VAWT rotor experiences a wake region collapse at a closer distance to the rotor compared to the lower TSRs. On the other hand, as the lower TSRs are associated with higher blade loadings and fluid momentum, a larger area behind the rotor is affected by the energy extraction from the turbine. Higher mode numbers reveal more vortical structures in smaller dimensions in both wake region and far field area. For instance, the second spatial mode shown in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-b-1, demonstrates the main flow structures at the point of wake region collapse. It should be noted that the same flow structures are observed at the same location in Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-b-1. In addition, with the further rise in the mode number, the flow structures, in the wake region collapse area, decay (Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-c-1) and the rolled-up flow structures at the edges of the wake region (shown in dashed lines) become more apparent as seen in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-d-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-e-1 for the fourth and the fifth modes respectively. The shear flow at the edges of the wake region is due to the velocity difference between the wake region and the far field, as it is evident in the first mode, which results in instabilities leading to the formation of symmetrical rolled-up structures. Further, it is evident in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-d-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-e-1 that the structures at the border of the leeward section is more pronounced than that of the windward section. This is attributed to the fact that the vortex shedding phenomenon is more considerable at leeward section due to the higher relative angle of attack the blade sees with respect to the windward section. Also, the same modal behavior is observed at TSR3.3 as it is evident in Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-d-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-e-1. Therefore, the modal behaviors at TSR2.4 and TSR3.3 are quite similar which was also shown in the modal cumulative energy plots. However, this similarity appears to be less noticeable at TSR1.5. Unlike TSR2.4 and TSR3.3 in which the wake region spans an area with almost the diameter of the wind turbine rotor, the wake region in TSR1.5 encompasses mostly the windward and parts of the downwind sections. This observation is completely in agreement with the fact that lower TSRs are associated with significantly lower amount of power coefficient as a less extensive span of the downstream flow is affected by the rotor presence compared to TSR2.4 and TSR3.3. Also, the spatial modes at TSR1.5 are prone to more vortex shedding due to the higher blade loading and angle of attack. Moreover, flow structures emanating from flow separation over the wind turbine blades are observed in all spatial modes of streamwise POD modes at TSR1.5. It should be noted that due to the fact that the flow undergoes lower velocity drop due to work extraction at TSR1.5 and consequently lower velocity difference between the wake region and the far field area, the symmetrical rolled-up structures are apparent to a lower extent at the edges of the wake region. Generally, the second and the subsequent modes correspond to the decay of the wake region collapse structures and the structures created as the result of the velocity gradient between the wake region and the far field area. Thus, the second mode depicted in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-b-1 shows the structures emanating from the wake region collapse which is the same characteristics of all the TSRs at this mode number for the streamwise component of velocity. Moreover, with the increase in the mode number, the flow structures at the wake region collapse point begin to disappear and instead the vortical structures stemming from the velocity gradient at the edge of the wake region become more pronounced which are evident in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-d-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-e-1. In Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-a-2, Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-a-2 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_5}-a-2 the first five dominant modes of LES results for TSRs2.4, 3.3 and 1.5 have been respectively presented. The first modes for all TSRs bear a resemblance with those of the RANS results which is due to the non-connectiveness nature of the first mode. In addition, comparing the first spatial modes of RANS and LES results, it reveals that both the numerical methods manage to predict the wake region collapse at approximately the same distance except that the LES suggests a further collapse position. However, the discrepancies between the RANS and LES modes begin to be more evident with the increase in the mode number which is in line with the expectations of the cumulative modes plots of both numerical methods. In this regard, as for the second LES mode at TSR2.4 presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-b-2, it is evident that in addition to the flow structures corresponding to wake region collapse which exists in the RANS mode as well, the wake shed emanating from the rotor is also observed which are bound to the boundaries of the POD box. Therefore, the LES results, contrary to the RANS modes, suggest more interpretable fluid phenomena in the wake region as expected due to the resolving the major part of the flow field. As for the third LES mode of the streamwise component of velocity at TSR2.4 presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-c-2 it is observed that firstly, unlike the third RANS mode, the structures at the edges of the POD box appear more pronouncedly near the rotor. In addition, the structures emanating from the leeward section are more noticeable which is due to the relative angle of attack at this part of rotation. The second feature of the third LES mode which is worth mentioning is that the structures shedding from the rotor in the preceding mode have decayed into smaller ones. The fourth LES mode of the streamwise component, Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-d-2, suggests that in addition to the convective structures from the preceding modes which are resultants of the turbulence decay of larger structures, the symmetrical structures near the edges of the POD box appear more prominently near the windward section. In addition, comparing the fourth RANS and LES modes it is observed that while the RANS results demonstrate the main concentration of the structures to be near the wake region collapse area, the LES mode suggests the most pronounced area of entrainment to be at the beginning of the domain. In regards with the TSR3.3 modes presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_3}-b, more similarity between the RANS and LES modes are observed. This is in agreement with the cumulative energy in Fig. \ref{FIG4_2}-a where the RANS and LES modes for TSR3.3 show closer values compared to the TSR2.4. As a result, the spatial modal behavior for RANS and LES at TSR3.3 follow a more analogous trend. To illustrate, the second LES mode of TSR3.3 in Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-b-2 demonstrates the structures in the wake region collapse position which is the main spatial modal behavior of the second RANS mode inFig. \ref{FIG4_4}-b-1. As for the third LES mode at TSR3.3 (Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-c-2), similar to the counterpart of the RANS mode as seen in Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-c-1, the structures due to the mixing in the vicinity of wake region collapse and the edges of the POD box are observed, however, of different sizes. Furthermore, the same trend in spatial modal behavior is observed between LES and RANS in the subsequent modes presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-d and Fig. \ref{FIG4_4}-e. Regarding the TSR1.5 LES modes, more discrepancies with respect to the TSRs2.4 and 3.3 are observed which is in agreement with the inference drawn from the RANS modes. In addition, it should be noted that more similarity between the RANS and the LES modes compared to the TSR2.4 can be found at TSR1.5 which was also discussed in cumulative curves for TSR3.3. Therefore, so far, we have come to this conclusion that the spatial modes at off-design points of operation can also be captured by RANS at a relatively acceptable accuracy. Also, it should be noted that unlike the spatial modes of the TSR3.3 the structures at TSR1.5 are mainly concentrated inside the wake region rather than the POD box edges which is due to the high blade loading and the lowest efficiency among the three TSRs. This trend is similarly followed in all the spatial LES and RANS modes of TSR1.5 as seen in Fig. \ref{FIG4_5}-c to Fig. \ref{FIG4_5}-e. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-3-a.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-3-b.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-3-c.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-3-d.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-3-e.jpg} \caption{POD modes for streamwise component of velocity at TSR2.4 (left RANS and right LES)} \label{FIG4_3} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-4-a.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-4-b.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-4-c.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-4-d.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-4-e.png} \caption{POD modes for streamwise component of velocity at TSR3.3 (left RANS and right LES)} \label{FIG4_4} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-5-a.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-5-b.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-5-c.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-5-d.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-5-e.png} \caption{POD modes for streamwise component of velocity at TSR1.5 (left RANS and right LES)} \label{FIG4_5} \end{figure} The spatial modes for the transversal component of velocity for TSR2.4 have been presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}. The first transversal RANS mode, unlike that of the streamwise component of velocity, shows flow structures at the beginning of the wake region collapse point which is 5D behind the rotor and the initial part of the wake region is almost free of noticeable structures. Therefore, the wake region collapse leads to entrainment between the wake region and the far field area. It should be noted that due to the direction of transversal modes, the structures associated with these modes could be interpreted as the mixing process. Similar to POD modes of the streamwise component of velocity, with the increase in the mode number the decay of the flow structures is observed which is evident in Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-b-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-c-1 for the second and the third modes of transversal component of velocity respectively. In addition, the fourth and the fifth RANS modes presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-d-1 and \ref{FIG4_6}-e-1 respectively demonstrate the rolled-up symmetrical flow structures at the edges of the wake region identical to that of the streamwise component of velocity at the same mode numbers. Contours of spatial modes for the LES simulations reveals a quite similar pattern with that of the RANS. Similarly, as the LES mode number increases, the structures near the edge of the POD box appear more prominently, while the structures at the point of wake region collapse begin to disappear. Also, as the mode number increases from the first to the second mode at TSR2.4, it is observed that the mixing structures at point of wake region collapse begin to decay into structures of lower energy. In addition, as the mode number increases the vortical structures near the edges of the wake region rise into importance, while those at the point of wake region collapse become less noticeable which could be seen in Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-c-2 to Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-e-2. While the RANS results fail to demonstrate vortex dissipation at the wake region collapse area from third to forth modes (Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-c-1 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-d-1), LES successfully succeeds in capturing the physical expected behavior of structures breakup into smaller ones (Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-c-2 and \ref{FIG4_6}-d-2). It should be noted that this is in agreement with the observation for the modes of the streamwise component of velocity where first the structures due to the wake region collapse appear and gradually the rolled symmetrical structures start to appear. However, the main difference with the RANS modes, is that in the LES modes the structures due to the wake shed and entrainment ensuing from the rotor which are near the beginning of the wake region begin to rise into importance which are absent in the RANS modes. Moreover, contrary to the first mode of the streamwise component of velocity (Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-a-2 and Fig. \ref{FIG4_6}-a-2), it is found that the first transversal mode manifests a convective behavior. This could be better understood by considering the time evolution of POD coefficients which will be discussed later on. \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-6-a.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-6-b.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-6-c.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-6-d.png} \includegraphics[scale=.7]{figs/4-6-e.png} \caption{POD modes for transversal component of velocity at TSR2.4 (left RANS and right LES)} \label{FIG4_6} \end{figure} The time evolution of POD coefficients of the streamwise and transversal components of velocity have been presented in Fig. \ref{FIG4_7}. First, the RANS time evolution of POD coefficients will be explicated. As observed in Figs. \ref{FIG4_7}-a-1, \ref{FIG4_7}-b-1 and \ref{FIG4_7}-c-1 the first RANS time evolution of POD coefficient of the streamwise component of velocity at all TSRs demonstrate a constant trend proving a non-convective behavior of the first coefficient of time evolution of POD. Therefore, the trace of the first coefficient of time evolution of POD can be hardly observed in the consecutive modes. Following this, as the mode number increases, a rise in the mode frequency is observed. As a result, the convective behavior of the POD modes will be more significant with the increase in the mode numbers which is in congruent with the spatial modal behavior. Also, the frequency of the modes increases with a decrease in TSR as it is evident in Fig. \ref{FIG4_7}. Hence, as previously observed, low TSRs correspond to more oscillatory flow structures which are attributed to the larger blade loadings at higher wind velocities. Regarding the time evolution of POD coefficients of transversal component of velocity, it is observed in Fig. \ref{FIG4_8}-a that the first mode shows a transient trend especially, at higher TSRs. Therefore, contrary to the time evolution of POD coefficient for streamwise component of velocity, the first coefficient of time evolution of POD of the transversal component of velocity demonstrates a convective characteristic. Also, after the first coefficient of time evolution of POD, a striking resemblance between time evolution of POD coefficient of the both components of velocity is observed indicating that a large portion of modes energy has been almost equally distributed between the streamwise and the transversal components of velocity. In other words, similar flow structures exist in both U and V modes and the similarities become more considerable with the rise in the modes number. Also, the behavior of time evolution of POD coefficients at TSR3.3 and TSR2.4 reveals more resemblance with respect to TSR1.5 insinuating that the vortex shedding at the most loaded sections of the wind turbine, which is typical of low TSRs, leads to a change in the trend and an increase in the connectiveness of the POD modes because of the higher frequency of each mode compared to its counterpart at higher TSRs. Also, as seen in Fig. \ref{FIG4_8}-c, it should be noted that as the time evolution of POD coefficients of the transversal component of velocity demonstrate more evident similarity compared to that of the streamwise, it is concluded that the vortex shedding at lower TSRs affects the V modes more considerably. It is also worth noting that the time evolution of POD coefficients show a similar trend to that of flow past a stationary barrier as found in the work of Lengani et al. \citep{Lengani_2014}. Therefore, similar flow structures and modal behavior especially, at lower mode numbers could be expected for these two cases. Generally, the LES and RANS time evolution of POD coefficients follow a similar trend. To illustrate, as anticipated from the spatial modes, the first time evolution of POD coefficients of the streamwise component of velocity at all TSRs reveal a non-convective behavior as seen in Fig. \ref{FIG4_7}-a-1, \ref{FIG4_7}-b-1 and \ref{FIG4_7}-c-1. In addition, with the increase in the mode number, the frequency of the time evolution of POD coefficients rises. However, at some modes some difference in phase could be observed. For instance, as seen in Fig. \ref{FIG4_7}-a, there is a $180^{\circ}$ phase difference between second LES and RANS time evolution of POD coefficient of the streamwise component of velocity at TSR2.4. Moreover, as shown in Fig. \ref{FIG4_7}-b, the RANS time evolution of POD coefficients TSR3.3 reveal the most similarity in trend to the LES results. This is attributed to the fact that at high TSRs the vortex shedding due to the lower blade loading leading to the more analogous modal behavior as also observed in spatial modes. \begin{figure*} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.3]{figs/4-7-1.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.3]{figs/4-7-2.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.3]{figs/4-7-3.jpg} \caption{Time evolution of POD coefficents of the streamwise component of velocity for (a) TSR2.4 (b) TSR3.3 (c) TSR1.5} \label{FIG4_7} \end{figure*} \begin{figure*} \centering \includegraphics[scale=.3]{figs/4-8-1.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.3]{figs/4-8-2.jpg} \includegraphics[scale=.3]{figs/4-8-3.jpg} \caption{Time evolution of POD coefficents of the transversal component of velocity for (a) TSR2.4 (b) TSR3.3 (c) TSR1.5} \label{FIG4_8} \end{figure*} \section{Conclusion} In this study the POD analysis of the wake shed behind a VAWT was performed by RANS and LES methods. To this end, WALE method, as suggested by Ma et al. \citep{Ma_2009}, was employed for SGS modelling. In addition, having examined various RANS models at the peak power, the well-known $k-\omega$ SST method was selected to perform the simulation for other TSRs. It should be noted that the LES resolution was found to be at least 82\% and the $y^{+}$ was well below unity. In the following step, the POD analysis was implemented on the wake behind the rotor. Firstly, the normalized cumulative modal energy was plotted for both LES and RANS simulations and it was shown that the RANS simulation results in higher modal energy at each mode number compared to that of the LES. Also, it was found that the RANS cumulative modal energy at all TSRs undergoes a considerably faster growth with respect to the LES energy modes. This was attributed to the capability of LES which resolves a significantly larger part of the flow domain leading to the presence of more flow structures than that of the RANS. Moreover, it was observed that the highest modal is directly related to the TSR. In other words, the highest TSR, for both the streamwise and transversal components of velocity, corresponds to the highest modal energy, while the lowest TSR leads to the lowest with respect to the other TSRs. In the second step, the spatial modes were presented and it was observed that the first spatial RANS mode for the streamwise component of velocity at all TSRs shows a resemblance to that of the LES as the first mode represents the area affected by the work extraction by the rotor. Also, with the increase in the mode number, more discrepancies among the TSR modes begin to appear which is in agreement with the trend shown in cumulative modal energy curves. Regarding the spatial modes for the transversal component of velocity, the contours revealed that both the RANS and LES first modes for TSRs 2.4 (rated) and 3.3 correspond to the flow structures due to the entrainment at the point of wake region collapse, while the first transversal and the successive modes at TSR1.5 demonstrates the vortex shedding due to the high blade loading at lower TSRs. As for the time evolution of POD coefficients, it was observed that both the RANS and LES modes demonstrate similar trends with the increase in the mode number. In this regard, it was concluded that the RANS method can capture the trend in the time evolution of POD coefficients, however, with different amounts. In conclusion, the RANS method can be employed for the purpose of the calculation of the wake region length and width or the extraction of the flow structures at the location of the wake region collapse. Nevertheless, a thorough POD analysis of the wake region cannot be performed by the RANS method as it is not capable of capturing the flow structures of smaller dimensions. As a result, for instance, as for an industrial or academic investigation of the wake region behind a VAWT, the RANS method can be employed to obtain an overall view of the wake region e.g. the wake region collapse length. In addition, the effect of the VAWT on the wake at a distance near the wake region collapse point can be accurately modelled by the RANS method. However, the internal area of the wake region especially, located near the rotor is associated with structures that RANS fails to capture indicating that at such points the employment of LES is more recommended if a deep understanding of the wake region is intended. In summary, the main findings of the paper can be listed as follows: \begin{itemize} \item The RANS results demonstrate higher modal energy at each mode number compared to those of LES. \item The first and second modes are well-captured by the RANS method owing to the fact the flow structures at these modes are mainly of the integral scale. \item Moving on to the consecutive modes, the discrepancies start to rise into importance as the RANS accuracy ebbs for flow structures of smaller dimensions, which are typical of higher mode numbers due to the lower energy and higher frequency. \item Time Evolution of the POD coefficients for RANS calculation at all TSRs demonstrate a very similar trend to that of the LES. \end{itemize} \section{Bibliography} \bibliographystyle{cas-model2-names}

1. Introduction {#sec1-ijerph-12-13251} =============== Drought has been common and widespread in the United States, with perhaps the most notable occurrence being the 1930s drought in the Great Plains, often referred to as the Dust Bowl. This was the US's most intense drought period to date, with several high-severity droughts occurring in rapid succession such that affected regions could not recover between episodes \[[@B1-ijerph-12-13251],[@B2-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The 1930s drought lead to widespread agricultural devastation and exacerbated the economic burden of the Great Depression \[[@B2-ijerph-12-13251]\]. In the 1950s the Great Plains and southwestern US suffered through another devastating drought, leading to federal drought disaster declarations in 244 of 245 Texas counties \[[@B3-ijerph-12-13251]\]. In the late 1980s, the northwestern US and northern Great Plains suffered a significant drought that became the most expensive disaster of any kind to affect the country up to that point, including agricultural damages and damages from wildfires throughout Yellowstone National Park \[[@B3-ijerph-12-13251],[@B4-ijerph-12-13251]\]. More recently at the peak of the historical drought of 2012, 61.8% of the contiguous US experienced moderate to extreme drought conditions \[[@B5-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Continuing into 2015, several West Coast, Southwest, and Southern Great Plains states experienced moderate to severe droughts that led to declared states of emergency, record low lake levels, road-closing dust storms, and wildfires \[[@B6-ijerph-12-13251],[@B7-ijerph-12-13251],[@B8-ijerph-12-13251],[@B9-ijerph-12-13251],[@B10-ijerph-12-13251],[@B11-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Conditions were particularly dire in California, where the governor issued an executive order mandating substantial water reductions in response \[[@B12-ijerph-12-13251]\]. 1.1. Climate Change and Drought {#sec1dot1-ijerph-12-13251} ------------------------------- Over the past 50 years, drought frequency and intensity has increased with rising temperatures in much of the Southeast and large parts of the West, and confidence is high that longer-term droughts are expected to intensify in large areas of the Southwest, southern Great Plains, and Southeast \[[@B13-ijerph-12-13251],[@B14-ijerph-12-13251]\]. There is evidence of shrinking glaciers, decreasing amounts of water in spring snowpack, and shifts to earlier peak flow in snow dominated rivers in western North America \[[@B15-ijerph-12-13251]\]. In the most recent assessment report, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) stated with high confidence that water resources are already strained in parts of North America; however, it is not currently possible to attribute the changes is North American drought frequency to anthropogenic climate change \[[@B16-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Even so, there is high confidence that water supplies in arid and semiarid western United States are projected to be further stressed by climate change, which will result in amplified water scarcity and drought conditions \[[@B13-ijerph-12-13251],[@B14-ijerph-12-13251],[@B16-ijerph-12-13251]\]. 1.2. Drought Health Effects {#sec1dot2-ijerph-12-13251} --------------------------- Droughts have been characterized as slow-moving disasters. Like other disasters, droughts often have significant health effects, typically mediated through complex environmental, economic and social pathways. Observed adverse impacts on livelihoods, economic activities, infrastructure, and access to services in North American urban and rural settlements over the past few decades have been at least partially attributed to droughts \[[@B16-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Furthermore, given the projections of persistent drought conditions described in both the Fifth Assessment Report of the IPCC and the US National Climate Assessment, there is concern that adverse health outcomes may become more prevalent \[[@B13-ijerph-12-13251],[@B14-ijerph-12-13251],[@B16-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The catalogue of harmful health effects associated with drought is still being assembled and is an area of active study. Several distinct health outcomes have been identified and multiple causal pathways proposed. For example, increased amounts of airborne dust and particulate air pollution can exacerbate asthma, respiratory allergies, and airway disease \[[@B17-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Drought conditions can reduce the availability of fresh water, increasing the risk for diseases associated with poor hygiene \[[@B18-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Drought can also compromise agricultural production, decreasing food security and threatening livelihoods \[[@B19-ijerph-12-13251]\]. From an economic perspective, slow-onset disasters like drought have been found to have a more extensive and destructive impact in the long term than fast-onset disasters \[[@B20-ijerph-12-13251]\]. For example, the 2012 drought and heat wave in the US is estimated to have cost approximately \$31 billion---one of the country's most expensive weather disasters \[[@B21-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Despite the magnitude of these impacts, the literature on drought health impacts remains relatively thin, particularly in the category of mental health. 1.3. Characterization of Exposure {#sec1dot3-ijerph-12-13251} --------------------------------- Exposure assessment issues complicate the study of drought health outcomes. Drought onset is difficult to determine: Several dry years in a row may or may not indicate the beginning of a long and significant drought phase \[[@B22-ijerph-12-13251],[@B23-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Furthermore, environmental changes accumulate over time and can exhibit threshold dynamics, making the consequences of drought not immediately identifiable \[[@B24-ijerph-12-13251],[@B25-ijerph-12-13251],[@B26-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Drought analyses are also complicated by discipline-specific definitions of the hazard and related issues. There are several different ways of measuring drought, including meteorological, hydrological, agricultural and socioeconomic \[[@B27-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Meteorological drought is defined based on the duration of the dry period and the degree of dryness in comparison to an average. Hydrological drought is associated with a shortfall of precipitation on surface or subsurface water supply, and is often defined on a watershed or river basin scale. Agricultural drought combines characteristics from meteorological and hydrological drought, such as precipitation shortages, soil water deficits, reduced groundwater, *etc*., and relates them to agricultural impacts. While these first three approaches measure drought in physical terms, socioeconomic drought associates meteorological, hydrological, or agricultural drought with economic measures. Socioeconomic drought occurs when deficient water supply interrupts or decreases the supply of economic goods. 1.4. Characterization of Health Outcomes {#sec1dot4-ijerph-12-13251} ---------------------------------------- Defining health outcomes associated with drought is also challenging, particularly in the area of mental health. Interpretations of mental health outcomes vary across studies, and often outcomes are not explicitly defined. Although mental health concepts are complex and vary with social, cultural, and familial norms and values, categorization of adverse mental health outcomes is a prerequisite of further study. It is important to distinguish mental health and mental disorder. According to the World Health Organization, mental health is "a state of well-being in which an individual realizes his or her own abilities, can cope with the normal stresses of life, can work productively and is able to make a contribution to his or her community" \[[@B28-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Mental health is more than just the absence of a mental illness or disorder, and it is determined by a host of socioeconomic, biological, and environmental factors. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, 5th edition, of the American Psychiatric Association (DSM-V), mental disorders are characterized by "clinically significant disturbance in an individual's cognition, emotion regulation, or behavior that reflects a dysfunction in the psychological, biological, or developmental processes underlying mental functioning" \[[@B29-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The DSM-V includes extensive diagnostic criteria and codes for mental disorders and is typically used by clinicians to assess patients and aid in developing a comprehensive case formation. Depressive and anxiety disorders are two of the most prevalent mental disorders, and are responsible for approximately 44% of the mental and behavioral health disease burden in the United States \[[@B30-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Common symptoms of depressive disorders include the presence of sad, empty, or irritable mood, accompanied by bodily and cognitive changes that significantly affect the individual's capacity to function \[[@B31-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Anxiety disorders are characterized by excessive fear and anxiety, as well as worry about any number of events or activities \[[@B32-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Suicide ideation may also be a feature of depressive and anxiety disorders \[[@B31-ijerph-12-13251],[@B32-ijerph-12-13251]\]. 1.5. Sub-Acute Disasters and Mental Health {#sec1dot5-ijerph-12-13251} ------------------------------------------ There is a paucity of quantitative epidemiological evidence relating mental health to sub-acute weather disasters like drought \[[@B33-ijerph-12-13251],[@B34-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Most of the research in the area of climate and mental health has focused primarily on the health effects of acute weather events and natural disasters, such as earthquakes, heat waves, floods, hurricanes, and other storms \[[@B35-ijerph-12-13251],[@B36-ijerph-12-13251],[@B37-ijerph-12-13251],[@B38-ijerph-12-13251]\]. While these studies demonstrate increasing attention to the mental health impacts of disasters, there is still much to be discovered about adverse health impacts of non-acute events. Droughts pose a unique threat to mental health with their slow onset, extended exposure windows, and indirect mechanisms of effects, leaving a knowledge gap to be addressed. 1.6. Objectives {#sec1dot6-ijerph-12-13251} --------------- Our aim is to examine the direct and indirect pathways linking drought to adverse mental health outcomes. Our objectives are to: Systematically review the existing literature concerning drought and mental health outcomes.Use systematic review results to develop a causal process diagram depicting the pathways linking drought and mental health outcomes.Examine risk and protective factors associated with drought exposure and mental health outcomes, including the coping mechanisms used by populations experiencing drought. Synthesizing the research and developing a framework to illustrate the role that drought has on mental health will enable a better understanding of the complexities between specific components of this relationship, as well as highlight areas in need of further research. Additionally, examining the vulnerabilities that make individuals more susceptible to negative mental health outcomes will bring attention to those who need it the most while also shedding light on possible avenues for intervention. 2. Methods {#sec2-ijerph-12-13251} ========== To address objective 1, a systematic review process was adapted from those described in Khan*, et al.* \[[@B39-ijerph-12-13251]\], Hosking and Campbell-Lendrum \[[@B40-ijerph-12-13251]\], and Hess*, et al.* \[[@B41-ijerph-12-13251]\]. To capture as many relevant citations as possible, keyword/phrase searches were conducted during January 2015 in PubMed, PsychINFO, Web of Science, and Google Scholar. Each database was searched for following terms: "drought" and ("mental health" or "suicide" or "depression" or "anxiety" or "emotional distress" or "psychological distress" or "schizophrenia" or "bipolar" or "manic depression"). Titles and abstracts of the resulting citations were first reviewed to determine relevance to the project. Only peer-reviewed journal articles about human response to aspects of extreme weather events were included in this study. Review articles were excluded unless they added novel information to the body of knowledge, such as a meta-synthesis or the new application of a theoretical framework. The full papers of the remaining citations were assessed to select for continued inclusion those studies that related to a major component of a causal pathway linking drought to a human mental health response. All determinations were made by HV in consultation with the other authors. To address objective 2, a causal process diagram using information from the systematic review was created to depict the numerous complex links in the drought/mental health relationship. Causal process diagrams are visual representations of the way in which interacting factors behave within a complex system. They are not only useful for summarizing and organizing information from interdisciplinary research, but are also logically rigorous and can help with planning data collection and analysis \[[@B42-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Our goal was to develop a causal process diagram to synthesize existing knowledge surrounding the mental health outcomes of drought and provide guidance about future research directions. The diagram was constructed following the recommended approach for developing and reporting a causal process diagram as described in Joffe and Mindell \[[@B42-ijerph-12-13251]\] and expands upon previous frameworks proposed by Perry \[[@B43-ijerph-12-13251]\] and Berry, Bowen and Kjellstrom \[[@B33-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Mental health outcomes were grouped in the diagram according to similar symptoms listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-V). To address objective 3, a table was created using information from the systematic review that focused on specific factors that may influence how susceptible a person or larger group is to the exposures detailed in the causal process diagram. We also included several coping mechanisms found in the literature. 3. Results {#sec3-ijerph-12-13251} ========== 3.1. Study Characteristics {#sec3dot1-ijerph-12-13251} -------------------------- Of the 765 studies initially identified, 82 were eligible for inclusion in the final review. [Figure 1](#ijerph-12-13251-f001){ref-type="fig"} contains a flow chart of article inclusion and exclusion. The majority of studies involved original research and were from developed nations, with Australia being the most common study locale. Eighty studies contributed information in support of links in the diagram, while two studies found no association. A full summary of the study characteristics can be found in [Table 1](#ijerph-12-13251-t001){ref-type="table"}. It is important to note that not all of the papers included in the final review specifically analyzed mental health outcomes of drought. However, articles were included if there were discussions of mental health outcomes in the context of populations who are vulnerable to drought. Oftentimes these papers looked at specific coping behaviors or protective factors related to mental health. These types of results were included in a separate table ([Table 2](#ijerph-12-13251-t002){ref-type="table"}) meant to supplement the causal process diagram. {#ijerph-12-13251-f001} 3.2. Causal Process Diagrams {#sec3dot2-ijerph-12-13251} ---------------------------- The following causal process diagrams highlight major pathways identified in the literature through which drought has been linked with adverse mental health outcomes. Some pathways have greater evidentiary support than others, as indicated by a greater number of supporting articles found through the systematic review. In each of the causal process diagrams, the number within the parenthesis indicates how many articles were found to support that step in the pathway. Of greatest support is the pathway focusing on the economic effects of drought, with a total of 33 papers of support. Drought can adversely impact individual and community economic activities, particularly those with livelihoods influenced by weather conditions and water access \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B45-ijerph-12-13251],[@B46-ijerph-12-13251],[@B47-ijerph-12-13251],[@B48-ijerph-12-13251],[@B49-ijerph-12-13251],[@B50-ijerph-12-13251],[@B51-ijerph-12-13251],[@B52-ijerph-12-13251],[@B53-ijerph-12-13251],[@B54-ijerph-12-13251],[@B55-ijerph-12-13251],[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B57-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The agricultural sector is typically hit hardest, and farmers can experience declined production, crop loss, and livestock failure \[[@B34-ijerph-12-13251],[@B58-ijerph-12-13251],[@B59-ijerph-12-13251],[@B60-ijerph-12-13251],[@B61-ijerph-12-13251],[@B62-ijerph-12-13251],[@B63-ijerph-12-13251],[@B64-ijerph-12-13251]\]. These losses can lead to financial constraints and unemployment, as well as issues associated with food availability and access \[[@B24-ijerph-12-13251],[@B61-ijerph-12-13251],[@B63-ijerph-12-13251],[@B64-ijerph-12-13251],[@B65-ijerph-12-13251],[@B66-ijerph-12-13251],[@B67-ijerph-12-13251],[@B68-ijerph-12-13251],[@B69-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Migration away from the drought prone area, often in search of better employment opportunities, is a related outcome \[[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B60-ijerph-12-13251],[@B64-ijerph-12-13251],[@B70-ijerph-12-13251],[@B71-ijerph-12-13251],[@B72-ijerph-12-13251],[@B73-ijerph-12-13251],[@B74-ijerph-12-13251],[@B75-ijerph-12-13251],[@B76-ijerph-12-13251]\]. [Figure 2](#ijerph-12-13251-f002){ref-type="fig"} highlights the direct economic effects of drought. ijerph-12-13251-t001_Table 1 ###### Summary of Characteristics of Included Studies. Characteristic No. of Eligible Studies Percent of Total Percent of Subcategory ------------------------------------ ---------------------------------- ------------------------- ------------------ ------------------------ Study Type Original research 53 65% \- *Quantitative methods* 24 \- 45% *Qualitative methods* 21 \- 40% *Mixed methods* 8 \- 15% Historic case studies 8 10% \- Program/Policy analyses 5 6% \- Review articles 16 20% \- Study Location United States 7 9% \- Other developed countries 58 71% \- *Australia* 52 \- 90% *Canada* 6 \- 10% *New Zealand* 1 \- 2% *United Kingdom* 1 \- 2% Developing countries 10 12% \- *Bolivia* 2 \- 20% *Botswana* 1 \- 10 % *Brazil* 1 \- 10% *Ethiopia* 1 \- 10% *India* 4 \- 40% *Iran* 1 \- 10% Not location specific 7 9% \- Publication Date Articles published 2005 or later 72 90% \- Articles published 1996--2004 6 7% \- Articles published 1995 or earlier 4 5% \- Percent totals may not sum to 100% due to rounding. While individuals will react to financial hardship in different ways, there is evidence that stress and social isolation may occur, as well as the possibility of increased workloads, decreased time and resources, and disruption of children's education so that they can help at home or with the family business \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B45-ijerph-12-13251],[@B48-ijerph-12-13251],[@B50-ijerph-12-13251],[@B53-ijerph-12-13251],[@B58-ijerph-12-13251],[@B67-ijerph-12-13251],[@B77-ijerph-12-13251],[@B78-ijerph-12-13251],[@B79-ijerph-12-13251],[@B80-ijerph-12-13251]\]. These stressful situations cause uncertainty about the future, increasing anxiety \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B50-ijerph-12-13251],[@B51-ijerph-12-13251],[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B58-ijerph-12-13251],[@B67-ijerph-12-13251],[@B81-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Shame and humiliation over financial struggles may also contribute to social isolation and depressive symptoms \[[@B46-ijerph-12-13251],[@B67-ijerph-12-13251],[@B82-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Additionally, there is evidence that these types of situations allow stress and tension to permeate the household, sometimes resulting in domestic abuse \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B46-ijerph-12-13251],[@B48-ijerph-12-13251],[@B50-ijerph-12-13251],[@B58-ijerph-12-13251],[@B66-ijerph-12-13251],[@B67-ijerph-12-13251],[@B70-ijerph-12-13251],[@B81-ijerph-12-13251],[@B83-ijerph-12-13251],[@B84-ijerph-12-13251]\]. These economic-related pathways overlap and interact in such a way that they may result in depression, anxiety, and suicide \[[@B53-ijerph-12-13251],[@B61-ijerph-12-13251],[@B62-ijerph-12-13251],[@B76-ijerph-12-13251],[@B78-ijerph-12-13251],[@B79-ijerph-12-13251],[@B81-ijerph-12-13251],[@B85-ijerph-12-13251],[@B86-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Evidence also shows that the more severe the drought and its impacts upon livelihoods, the larger the negative impacts upon the mental health for those affected \[[@B54-ijerph-12-13251],[@B62-ijerph-12-13251],[@B87-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The intermediary factors and outcomes associated with the economic pathway are shown in [Figure 3](#ijerph-12-13251-f003){ref-type="fig"} and [Figure 4](#ijerph-12-13251-f004){ref-type="fig"}, respectively. {#ijerph-12-13251-f002} {#ijerph-12-13251-f003} Looking at the pathway from a different angle, the migratory effects of drought also have implications for mental health that are well supported in the literature, with the systematic review identifying 28 papers related to this pathway. Migration away from drought-stricken communities with depressed economies can lead to a reduction in community resources, services, and support systems \[[@B45-ijerph-12-13251],[@B52-ijerph-12-13251],[@B54-ijerph-12-13251],[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B61-ijerph-12-13251],[@B70-ijerph-12-13251],[@B76-ijerph-12-13251],[@B88-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Altered family and community structures coupled with social and geographical isolation can also be issues for those who emigrate and those left behind, and may lead to symptoms of anxiety and depression \[[@B50-ijerph-12-13251],[@B53-ijerph-12-13251],[@B58-ijerph-12-13251],[@B67-ijerph-12-13251],[@B72-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Poor reception of immigrants by receiving communities has been observed \[[@B73-ijerph-12-13251],[@B89-ijerph-12-13251],[@B90-ijerph-12-13251],[@B91-ijerph-12-13251]\]. A feedback loop may be of particular concern in this situation, with drought spurring migration and contributing to the erosion of the resource base, which in turn amplifies the effects of drought upon the community and pushes more people to leave. In such a case, a lack of resources is not only caused by drought, but is also an issue that makes drought more difficult to cope with \[[@B56-ijerph-12-13251]\]. [Figure 5](#ijerph-12-13251-f005){ref-type="fig"} focuses on the migratory effects pathway. There is also evidence that drought can lead to environmental degradation of one's home, affecting people's ability to interact with their environment and causing additional issues related to rupture of place bonds, culture change and loss, and altered community and family dynamics \[[@B49-ijerph-12-13251],[@B70-ijerph-12-13251],[@B89-ijerph-12-13251],[@B91-ijerph-12-13251],[@B92-ijerph-12-13251],[@B93-ijerph-12-13251],[@B94-ijerph-12-13251]\]. These are particular issues for those who gain a strong sense of identity from the land and take on an environmental stewardship role \[[@B55-ijerph-12-13251],[@B69-ijerph-12-13251],[@B84-ijerph-12-13251],[@B88-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Environmental degradation can also lead to changes in local and regional plants and wildlife, which may have downstream impacts for food security \[[@B63-ijerph-12-13251],[@B69-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Such alternations in one's way of life can contribute to depression and anxiety for individuals and tension within family and social networks \[[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B69-ijerph-12-13251],[@B84-ijerph-12-13251],[@B88-ijerph-12-13251],[@B92-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The effects of environmental degradation of one's home are depicted in [Figure 6](#ijerph-12-13251-f006){ref-type="fig"}. The preceding diagrams on the economic, migratory and environmental degradation effects of drought can be combined into one overarching causal process diagram ([Figure 7](#ijerph-12-13251-f007){ref-type="fig"}) that shows how all of these individual components relate and overlap with one another. This highlights the highly interactive nature of the direct and indirect effects of drought and their resulting impact upon mental health. 3.3. Vulnerabilities, Protective Factors, and Coping Strategies {#sec3dot3-ijerph-12-13251} --------------------------------------------------------------- Certain populations experience heightened risk of adverse mental health impacts from drought, while others have distinct protective factors and potential coping strategies. Important vulnerable populations, coping mechanisms, and protective factors found in the literature are presented in [Table 2](#ijerph-12-13251-t002){ref-type="table"}. As the diagram illustrates, there are a variety of different mechanisms through which drought can affect individuals, with certain populations being more vulnerable than others. For example, rural and remote populations face a unique set of challenges that increase their vulnerability. They are thus frequently studied; the systematic review found 32 articles that focused on rural individuals and communities. The circumstances of rural communities sometimes cause health to be defined differently, often with an emphasis on one's ability to be productive and with distress seen more as a problem of daily living rather than a mental health issue \[[@B77-ijerph-12-13251],[@B95-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Research has repeatedly demonstrated a phenomenon of rural stoicism that, combined with a culture of self-reliance, can interfere with help-seeking behaviors and limit effective adaptation to changed circumstances \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B77-ijerph-12-13251],[@B96-ijerph-12-13251],[@B97-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The social visibility present in small, rural communities can exacerbate reluctance to seek assistance for mental health problems \[[@B79-ijerph-12-13251],[@B96-ijerph-12-13251],[@B97-ijerph-12-13251],[@B98-ijerph-12-13251],[@B99-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Individuals who may consider pursuing mental health services are afraid of marginalization if others find out. Finally, compounding all of these problems is the lack, or perceived lack, of community resources and infrastructure in remote areas \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B47-ijerph-12-13251],[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B71-ijerph-12-13251],[@B75-ijerph-12-13251],[@B95-ijerph-12-13251],[@B98-ijerph-12-13251],[@B100-ijerph-12-13251]\]. If individuals do not believe there are mental health services available to them, these resources will not be utilized. {#ijerph-12-13251-f004} {#ijerph-12-13251-f005} {#ijerph-12-13251-f006} ijerph-12-13251-t002_Table 2 ###### Vulnerabilities, protective factors and coping mechanisms for mental health effects of drought. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Vulnerable Characteristics Protective Factors Coping Mechanisms --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Rural or remote population (32)\ Social support, social capital and sense of community belonging (15)\ Employing practical solutions and active methods, including planning for the future (7)\ Farming or agriculture dependent population (22)\ Shared knowledge and community preparedness regarding availability and access to services (6)\ Psychological methods, including positive thinking, acceptance and reframing of the problem (4)\ Indigenous population (6)\ Mental health literacy (2)\ Utilizing social support and talking about the problem (3)\ Perceived stigma associated with mental health issues (12)\ Government assistance and initiatives in place (6) Distracting oneself from the problem; taking a break (2)\ Lack of knowledge surrounding mental health issues and availability of services (11)\ Turning to religion (3)\ Previous mental health issues or other adverse life events (5)\ Alcohol and substance use (8)\ Exposure to an extended period, more intense or severe drought (5) Denial and avoidance of the problem (3) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Number within parenthesis indicates how many articles were found in the review to support that characteristic, mechanism or factor. {#ijerph-12-13251-f007} Rural communities often include farming populations, another well-studied group. The systematic review revealed 22 articles that focused on the mental health outcomes of farmers and their families. Farming populations face many of the same challenges described for rural and remote populations, including declining population density, a lack of mental health services, and stigma surrounding mental health issues. Added to these issues is the fact that drought directly impacts the employment and economic success of agricultural communities \[[@B26-ijerph-12-13251],[@B47-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Rural male farmers, who are particularly well studied, have several distinct risk factors \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B45-ijerph-12-13251],[@B101-ijerph-12-13251],[@B102-ijerph-12-13251],[@B103-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Masculine hegemony dictates that men be emotionally tough, stoic in the face of adversity, and the breadwinners of the family \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B45-ijerph-12-13251],[@B53-ijerph-12-13251]\]. These normative stereotypes harm help-seeking behaviors. Furthermore, the stigma associated with mental health issues is reinforced by the paradigm of masculinity found in farming \[[@B47-ijerph-12-13251],[@B75-ijerph-12-13251],[@B99-ijerph-12-13251],[@B101-ijerph-12-13251],[@B103-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Similarly, some studies of women in rural and farming communities have found heightened vulnerability due to their roles as caregivers and household managers, and the additional stresses associated with those responsibilities \[[@B48-ijerph-12-13251],[@B95-ijerph-12-13251],[@B96-ijerph-12-13251]\]. However, complicating this finding are the results of two studies that found either no heath effect or declined risk of suicide for females as drought increases \[[@B87-ijerph-12-13251],[@B104-ijerph-12-13251]\]. This indicates there may be a more complex causal pathway involving gender, which modifies the effects of drought. Due to their often strong connection with the land, indigenous groups are also particularly vulnerable \[[@B47-ijerph-12-13251],[@B55-ijerph-12-13251],[@B69-ijerph-12-13251],[@B84-ijerph-12-13251],[@B95-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Sustaining a relationship with the land in the face of drought is challenging, and as the climate continues to change, individuals will likely have a harder time maintaining their way of life \[[@B84-ijerph-12-13251]\]. This can lead to acculturation by forcing people to change their traditional ways of living and make individuals more vulnerable to mental health issues \[[@B93-ijerph-12-13251]\]. While the geographic and social isolation of rural and farming communities can increase vulnerability, having a strong sense of belonging, maintaining social capital, and utilizing those connections can serve as protective factors and coping mechanisms \[[@B43-ijerph-12-13251],[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B100-ijerph-12-13251],[@B102-ijerph-12-13251],[@B103-ijerph-12-13251],[@B105-ijerph-12-13251],[@B106-ijerph-12-13251],[@B107-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Protective social interactions can be at an individual or communal level \[[@B25-ijerph-12-13251],[@B101-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Oftentimes small, rural populations are able to maintain a sense of community and informal support networks that can be utilized to address mental health issues; however, as drought conditions worsen these ties are strained and can break down due to prolonged pressure on community resources \[[@B70-ijerph-12-13251],[@B101-ijerph-12-13251],[@B108-ijerph-12-13251],[@B109-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Practical solutions like farming adaptations were often cited as a way to cope with drought difficulties. Historically, farmers have changed farming practices during times of drought, and innovations such as land diversification and farm expansion are still used today \[[@B60-ijerph-12-13251],[@B71-ijerph-12-13251],[@B108-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Economic and lifestyle planning such that retirement and future generations would not be jeopardized by a failing farm was another way individuals were able to practically cope with drought \[[@B108-ijerph-12-13251],[@B110-ijerph-12-13251]\]. However, not all coping mechanisms confer long-term advantage. In some situations avoidance and denial of the problem is common \[[@B56-ijerph-12-13251],[@B91-ijerph-12-13251],[@B108-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Although it is not always the main strategy, substance and alcohol abuse were cited in several studies as a way in which individuals dealt with the stressful situations caused by drought \[[@B44-ijerph-12-13251],[@B58-ijerph-12-13251],[@B84-ijerph-12-13251],[@B85-ijerph-12-13251],[@B107-ijerph-12-13251]\], particularly among males \[[@B81-ijerph-12-13251],[@B107-ijerph-12-13251],[@B111-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Mental health literacy has been identified as a protective factor and a way to reduce stigma by increasing knowledge and increasing help-seeking behaviors \[[@B97-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Providing information about mental health problems and services is also an important way to empower individuals to get through tough times \[[@B25-ijerph-12-13251],[@B101-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Finally, the presence of government initiatives to assist during times of drought, either financially or through mental health outreach programs, may be protective as well \[[@B25-ijerph-12-13251],[@B55-ijerph-12-13251],[@B71-ijerph-12-13251],[@B97-ijerph-12-13251],[@B112-ijerph-12-13251]\]. However, it is important for such initiatives to be easily navigable and culturally appropriate \[[@B79-ijerph-12-13251],[@B97-ijerph-12-13251]\]. 4. Discussion {#sec4-ijerph-12-13251} ============= There is a growing need for public health practitioners and researchers to understand drought's health impacts. Our review suggests several pathways for drought to adversely affect mental health, particularly among vulnerable populations. Some pathways were supported by more evidence than others. The economic effects pathway, particularly its impacts on rural farming populations, as well as the migration pathway, were well supported. The environmental degradation pathway had less support. This pathway is perhaps most relevant to indigenous populations, a potentially vulnerable group, and more research should be done to examine the strength of the postulated relationships. The retrieved literature used a variety of methodologies. Qualitative and quantitative methods were used with nearly the same frequency, while a smaller portion used a mixed methods approach. Choice of methodology is important when looking to develop a detailed understanding of a complex phenomenon. Typically, qualitative methods are able to collect rich data that provide an in-depth understanding of research issues that embrace the perspectives of the study population and the context of their specific demographics. Quantitative methods have the advantage of allowing for numeric risk estimates that can be used to perform scenario-based health impact projections, which have become a mainstay of climate-health research. There was little quantitative estimation of the risks drought poses for the incidence of adverse mental health effects in the literature identified. In trying to develop an understanding of the casual relationship between drought and mental health that can be meaningful for a wide range of individuals, mixed methods approaches offer the ability to take advantage of the strengths of both quantitative and qualitative approaches. There was a high degree of concordance among the identified literature leaving a strong impression of increased risk for adverse mental health impacts associated with drought. However, there were studies found in the systematic review that did not lend support to some of the relationships postulated in other literature. Guiney \[[@B113-ijerph-12-13251]\] examined intentional self-harm deaths of farmers in relation to prolonged droughts in Victoria, Australia and found no pattern of increasing farming suicides during the drought years. The findings of study are hampered though because it did not include a non-drought comparison to serve as a baseline for comparison. Furthermore, the paper does not account for the Australian gun control policy which was introduced at the start of the study period and is credited with reducing suicide risk by a large amount \[[@B114-ijerph-12-13251]\]. The author also acknowledges that community support programs targeting drought-affected areas may have contributed to improved outcomes during the time period in question. In another study, Powers *et al.* \[[@B104-ijerph-12-13251]\], found that adverse climate events did not appear to affect Australian women's health and well-being. This relationship has been confirmed across other studies and complicates the proposed relationship between drought and mental health \[[@B87-ijerph-12-13251],[@B115-ijerph-12-13251]\]. However, occupation is not explicitly examined in these studies, which may play an important role in the female experience of drought. Further study of the posited relationship with a focus on gender and occupation is therefore warranted. It is also worth noting that Powers *et al.* \[[@B104-ijerph-12-13251]\] suggest that the multiple resources available in high income counties, as well as tendencies for preparation and adaptation, may be responsible for mitigating some of the health impacts of adverse climate events like drought. This upholds the assertion that community support and preparedness may be able to offset the negative mental health impacts of drought. This study had several limitations. First, the systematic review may have inadvertently missed publications, particularly those in the grey literature. Second, the relationships diagrammed are limited to those identified in the literature, though there are other ways in which drought might affect mental health. Third, physical health effects and their relation to mental health are underrepresented in the diagram, leaving questions about their role in the causal process. Fourth, some of the findings may not be generalizable, particularly due to cultural differences in the definitions of mental health. Lastly, it is also possible that unexamined factors may complicate the associations posited in the diagram. One plausible example of this could be pesticide exposure, which could act as a causal intermediary or confounder depending on whether pesticides are part of the proposed causal pathway under study. Drought may increase the use of pesticides or change people's exposure to them, and these could have physical and neuroendocrine effects that could have implications for mental health \[[@B116-ijerph-12-13251],[@B117-ijerph-12-13251]\]. However, pesticide exposure was not explicitly considered in the studies collected by the systematic review. A future study looking at the mental health effects of drought among a farming population using pesticides should consider whether pesticides may be part of the causal pathway under study and, if not, treat pesticide exposure as a potential confounder. 4.1. Application of the Causal Process Diagram {#sec4dot1-ijerph-12-13251} ---------------------------------------------- A note of caution related to linear interpretation of the causal diagram is in order. Perry \[[@B43-ijerph-12-13251]\] wrote that simple, uni-causal models are not particularly useful for understanding the physiological consequences of natural disasters. Instead, disasters should be seen as a contributory cause---one of a number of factors that together determine psychological consequences. Keeping this in mind when considering the relationships between drought and mental health underlines the importance of multiple pathways and nodes as much as the linear process suggested by the different pathways. Despite its limitations, the causal process diagram has several potential applications, including prevention planning, public health programming, vulnerability and risk assessment, and research question development. ### 4.1.1. Prevention Planning {#sec4dot1dot1-ijerph-12-13251} The diagram can be used by public health practitioners or extension workers in order to look for upstream warning signs of mental health issues associated with drought. This could be particularly relevant in the case of feedback loops, where there is interplay between drought-related stressors, coping or adaptation strategies, and downstream impacts. For example, in the current California drought, farmers have taken to pumping groundwater to cope with surface water losses \[[@B118-ijerph-12-13251]\]. As groundwater levels deplete, pumping costs will increase and may be subject to limits \[[@B118-ijerph-12-13251]\]. This could further threaten agricultural production and amplify drought-related stressors. The causal diagram can help identify strategies that anticipate such feedbacks and thereby promote adaptive strategies over short-term coping efforts. ijerph-12-13251-t003_Table 3 ###### Suggested Data Sources for Future Research. Broad Category Component of Diagram/Table Data Available from ----------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Distal Exposure Drought Palmer drought severity and crop moisture indices for the US National Weather Service/NOAA Center for Weather and Climate Prediction Drought GIS and tabular data for drought severity the United States United States Drought Monitor Secondary and Intermediate Exposures Declined crop production, crop failure and livestock loss Various datasets pertaining to crop production, food prices, and farm economies United States Department of Agriculture Declined crop production, crop failure and livestock loss Agricultural data searchable by commodity, location or time period United States Department of Agriculture Migration Changing population counts in rural and urban areas United States Census Employment and financial constraints/depressed economy Unemployment and labor force statistics Bureau of Labor Statistics Employment and financial constraints/depressed economy Poverty data United States Census Children do not attend school School enrollment data United States Census Protective Factors and Coping Strategies Social support Data on available mental health treatment and levels of emotional support available Health Indicators Warehouse---Department of Health and Human Services Alcohol and Substance Use Data on alcohol and illicit drug usage Health Indicators Warehouse - Department of Health and Human Services Outcomes Mental Health Data on anxiety, depression, conduct and panic disorders National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey---Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Mental Health Data on mental health disorders, suicide attempts and deaths Health Indicators Warehouse---Department of Health and Human Services Mental Health Data on depressive disease, anxiety, suicide, domestic violence Emergency department records Mental Health Suicide as cause of death data National Violent Death Reporting System---Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ### 4.1.2. Public Health Programming {#sec4dot1dot2-ijerph-12-13251} The diagram offers a useful approach to examining interactions among stressors and impacts, which could be valuable when developing programs or interventions for communities. The literature review revealed that several mental health initiatives related to drought have already been implemented across the globe with varying degrees of success \[[@B25-ijerph-12-13251],[@B34-ijerph-12-13251],[@B43-ijerph-12-13251],[@B52-ijerph-12-13251],[@B68-ijerph-12-13251],[@B80-ijerph-12-13251],[@B85-ijerph-12-13251],[@B112-ijerph-12-13251]\]. Adapting successful interventions using the causal process diagram could be another practical use of this research. ### 4.1.3. Vulnerability and Risk Assessment {#sec4dot1dot3-ijerph-12-13251} Public health has often used environmental risk assessment to estimate human exposure to harmful or toxic substances; these methods have been expanded over recent years to estimate adverse effects of climate change, as seen in the methods used by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change \[[@B119-ijerph-12-13251]\]. This concept of analyzing possible impact from an environmental change can be applied to causal process between drought and health. The diagram and complementary table highlight areas of exposure and characteristics that make individuals particularly vulnerable to drought. This information can be used to inform vulnerability and risk assessments, allowing for the characterization of risk to the exposed populations. ### 4.1.4. Future Research {#sec4dot1dot4-ijerph-12-13251} In addition to practical applications, the diagram can be used to generate research questions exploring the mental health impacts of drought effect and potential interventions for averting or mitigating these impacts. By providing a way to conceptualize causal processes, the diagram can both inform and guide research. To assist in this approach, a list of available data sources have been compiled that can be used to quantitatively explore the posited relationships in the causal process diagram ([Table 3](#ijerph-12-13251-t003){ref-type="table"}). Much of this data is publically available, and the list is not exhaustive. The focus is primarily on data relevant to US populations, as this is the context with which the authors are most familiar, and there are likely other data sources in other regions that are worth exploring. 5. Conclusions {#sec5-ijerph-12-13251} ============== Given the current drought situation affecting parts of the United States and increasing concern over the association between climate change and drought, the linkages between drought and mental health are increasingly important. There is a substantial body of literature on the topic that allows for identification of several distinct and inter-related pathways by which drought can adversely impact mental health as well as several coping and adaptation strategies. Most of these relationships are mediated through environmental or economic pathways, and the outcomes most closely studied are mood disorders and, to a lesser degree, intimate partner violence and suicide. Few associations between drought exposure and adverse mental health outcomes have been quantified. This research is an initial step in bringing this important issue forward and outlining possible implications for prevention, mental health services, and future research. This work was supported by NOAA through the Cooperative Institute for Climate and Satellites---North Carolina under Cooperative Agreement NA14NES432003. Holly Vins and Jesse Bell conceived the study and all authors developed the approach. Holly Vins conducted the literature review and conducted preliminary analysis. Holly Vins and Jeremy Hess participated in additional data analysis. Holly Vins drafted the paper and all authors participated in revisions. The funding sponsor had no role in the design of the study; in the collection, analysis, or interpretation of data; in the writing of the manuscript; or in the decision to publish the results. Jeremy Hess and Shubhayu Saha declare that they have served as scientific consultants to the Natural Resources Defense Council. Jeremy Hess declares that he has served as a scientific consultant to Stratus Consulting. The authors have no other potential conflicts of interest to declare. The findings and conclusions in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention or the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

\section{Introduction} Kagome lattice intrinsically hosts the flat electronic band, van Hove singularities and the Dirac band~\cite{Kiesel2012,Kiesel2013,Wang2013}. Thus, when the charge degree of freedom is enabled, a kagome system provides an important platform to explore both the effect of electronic correlation and topological physics, and a rich variety of phenomena can be expected. The recently discovered kagome metals AV$_3$Sb$_5$ (A=K, Rb, Cs), in which the V atoms form a perfect kagome net, are an ideal manifestation of the diverse phenomena this structural class can offer~\cite{Ortiz2019,Ortiz2020,Du2021,Chen2021a,Li2021,Liang2021,Zhao2021,Liu2021,Hu2021,Uykur2021,Zhou2021,Jiang2021,Kang2022,Kang2022a,Wu2022,Lou2022,Yu2021b,Yang2020,Yu2021,Wulferding2022,Jiang2022,Nie2022}. Indeed, calculations and experiments have revealed several Dirac-like band crossings near the Fermi energy with a non-zero $Z_2$ topological invariant~\cite{Ortiz2020,Fu2021,Liu2021}. Furthermore, these systems exhibit interesting and intertwining electronic phases, including a charge-density-wave (CDW) phase, electronic nematicity as well as superconductivity~\cite{Ortiz2019,Ortiz2020,Du2021,Chen2021a,Li2021,Liang2021,Zhao2021,Liu2021,Hu2021,Uykur2021,Zhou2021,Jiang2021,Kang2022,Kang2022a,Wu2022,Lou2022,Yu2021b,Yang2020,Yu2021,Liu2021,Wulferding2022,Jiang2022,Nie2022}. The CDW phase of \AVSb, which sets in at $T_{\rm CDW}\sim80-100$~K, has been argued to have an unconventional origin. Chiral charge order, the absence of acoustic phonon anomaly, and time-reversal symmetry breaking (TRSB) have been observed in the CDW phase~\cite{Feng2021,Li2021,Yu2021b,Yu2021c,Hu2022,Mielke2022,Khasanov2022,Guguchia2022}. Below $T_{\rm CDW}$, a giant anomalous Hall effect (AHE) has been reported in {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, supporting the notion of TRSB~\cite{Yang2020,Yu2021b}. Given that the superconductivity, which sets in at $T_c\sim0.9-2.5$~K, arises from this unconventional metallic state, understanding the CDW phase and the phenomena associated with the CDW phase is essential for deepening the understanding of the superconducting state. Further evidence of the nontrivial interplay between the CDW state and superconductivity comes from pressure studies - while $T_{\rm CDW}$ is suppressed monotonically by pressure, $T_c$ shows an unusual double dome dependence on pressure~\cite{Yu2021,Chen2021a,Wang2021a,Du2021}. Although all three \AVSb\ compounds show similar physical properties, {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ is currently the most heavily studied, probably because it has the highest $T_c$. However, both {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ should also be investigated to build an overall picture for understanding this family of V-based kagome superconductors. For instance, a $\mu$SR experiment shows that the superconducting energy gap can be tuned from nodal at ambient pressure to nodeless under pressure in {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}~\cite{Guguchia2022}, but this tunability is absent in {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ where the gap is found to be nodeless over a large pressure range~\cite{Gupta2022a}. Whether the observed nodal gap is related to TRSB needs to be addressed. However, the anomalous Hall effect (AHE), a signature of TRSB, has not been comprehensively reported in {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, to the best of our knowledge. Detailed studies of the Fermi surface via quantum oscillations have also been lacking in {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, again in stark contrast to the progress made in {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}~\cite{Yu2021,Yu2021b,Fu2021,Ortiz2021,Gan2021,Zhang2022,Chen2022,Huang2022,Shrestha2022, Chapai2022,Broyles2022}. In the pioneering work by Yin {\it et al.}~\cite{Yin2021}, only two quantum oscillation frequencies at a single field angle are reported. In particular, these frequencies are rather small -- $F_{\alpha}=34$~T and $F_{\beta}=117$~T, indicating the detection of small Fermi surface sheets. However, much larger frequencies up to 9930~T when the magnetic field is parallel to the $c$-axis have been reported in {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}~\cite{Chapai2022}. Therefore, it is urgently needed to re-investigate the Fermi surface of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ via quantum oscillations. In this manuscript, we focus on {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}~and conduct a series of magnetotransport experiments on high-quality single crystals. We first patch the gap in the literature by reporting the observation of a large AHE in {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. Next, we analyze the magnetoresistance, uncovering quantum oscillations (the Shubnikov-de Haas (SdH) effect) with 12 frequencies. Notably, the largest frequency detected is 2235~T, nearly 20 times larger than the largest frequency reported by Yin {\it et al.}~\cite{Yin2021}. Finally, our field angle dependent data establish that these frequencies are associated with quasi-two-dimensional Fermi surface sheets. \section{Methods} \begin{figure}[!h]\centering \resizebox{8.5cm}{!}{ \includegraphics{Figure1.pdf}} \caption{\label{rhoT} (a) X-ray diffraction pattern of a {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ single crystal showing only ($00L$) peaks. (b) Temperature dependence of the resistivity of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ between 2~K and 300~K under a zero external magnetic field. The RRR is 76.6. (c) Temperature dependence of d$\rho$/d$T$, displaying a sharp peak at $T_{\rm{CDW}}$ = 96.3~K. } \end{figure} Single crystals of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ were synthesized from Rb (ingot, 99.95 $\%$), V (powder, 99.9 $\%$) and Sb (shot, 99.9999 $\%$) using self-flux method similar to Ref.~[\onlinecite{Yin2021}]. Raw materials with the molar ratio of Rb:V:Sb = 5.5:7:14 were sealed in a quartz tube. To avoid the possible influence of the ambient environment, all preparation processes were performed in an argon-filled glovebox, before the quartz tube was moved to the furnace for heat treatment. The mixture was first heated to 1000$^\circ$C with the rate of 20$^\circ$C/h. After being held at 1000~$^\circ$C for 24 h, it was cooled to 900$^\circ$C at 50~$^\circ$C/h, followed by a further cooling to 400$^\circ$C at 2~$^\circ$C/h. The excess flux was removed by distilled water and ethanol. The as-grown single crystals were millimeter-sized shinny plates. X-ray diffraction (XRD) data were collected at room temperature by using a Rigaku X-ray diffractometer with Cu$K_\alpha$ radiation. The chemical compositions were characterized by a JEOL JSM-7800F scanning electron microscope equipped with an Oxford energy-dispersive X-ray EDX spectrometer. For magnetotransport measurements, the sample was firstly exfoliated from a bulk crystal and then transferred to a diamond surface pre-patterned with Au/Ti electrodes in a standard six-probe Hall bar configuration. A polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) film were used to perform the transfer and Dupont 6838 silver paste was used to connect external leads with the electrodes. The transfer process was also performed in the glove box, and in order to protect the sample, we capped the sample with a thin layer ($\sim 500$~nm) of h-BN. The thickness of the thin flakes and h-BN was determined by a dual-beam focused ion beam system (Scios~2 DualBeam by Thermo Scientific). These steps are similar to procedures optimized by us in Refs.~\onlinecite{Xie2021,Ku2022}. Low-temperature and high-field measurements were carried out in a commercial Physical Property Measurement System (PPMS) by Quantum Design. A Stanford Research 830 lock-in amplifier was used for Shubnikov-de Haas measurements, while the standard PPMS Resistivity option was used for recording magnetoresistance and Hall effect. The rotator insert option by Quantum Design was used to tilt the angle between magnetic field and the $ab$ plane of the sample. During the rotation, the current direction is kept perpendicular to the magnetic field. \begin{figure*} \centering \setlength{\abovecaptionskip}{0cm} \resizebox{16cm}{!}{ \includegraphics[width=1\textwidth]{Figure2.pdf}} \caption{\label{AHE} (a), (b) Field dependence of Hall resistivity at various temperatures. The grey shading area represents the anomalous Hall effect (AHE) observed in the low-field region at all temperatures below $T_{\rm CDW}$. (c), (d) Anomalous Hall resistivity $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ at various temperatures after subtracting the ordinary Hall signal. The AHE shows up for all temperature below $T_{\rm CDW}$. (e) $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ in $\rm RbV_3Sb_5$, $\rm KV_3Sb_5$ and $\rm CsV_3Sb_5$ as a function of temperature. The data of $\rm KV_3Sb_5$ and $\rm CsV_3Sb_5$ are adapted from Refs.~[\onlinecite{Yang2020}] and [\onlinecite{Yu2021}], respectively. (f) Temperature dependence of electron carrier density $n_e$ and mobility $\mu_e$ in $\rm RbV_3Sb_5$ extracted from the ordinary Hall signal in the one-band regime. } \end{figure*} \section{Results} Figure~\ref{rhoT}(a) displays the XRD pattern of an as-grown single crystal of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. The data can be indexed by the (00$L$) patterns from the crystal structure of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}~(space group: $P6/mmm$) reported in previous studies \cite{Ortiz2019,Yin2021}. This shows that our sample has a preferred orientation, as expected for a single crystal of layered materials. The chemical composition of the single crystal is obtained to be Rb:V:Sb = 0.94:2.86:5 via EDX (see the Supplementary Information), which further confirms the result of XRD in Fig.~\ref{rhoT}(a). Figure~\ref{rhoT}(b) shows the temperature dependence of the electrical resistivity ($\rho(T)$) of our {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ sample. The residual resistivity ratio (RRR) (defined as $\rho(300 {\rm K})/\rho(2 {\rm K})$) is about 77, currently one of the highest reported values. The d$\rho$/d$T$ vs. $T$ relation is shown in Fig.~\ref{rhoT}(c), where an anomaly can be clearly identified at 96.3~K. We associate this anomaly with $T_{\rm CDW}$, and our value is slightly lower than the reported value for this compound ~\cite{Wang2021,Cho2021,Yin2021}. The availability of high-quality single crystals enables us to investigate the important transport phenomena in {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. We are particularly interested in anomalous Hall effect and quantum oscillations. We have performed Hall measurements over a wide range of temperatures. Figure~\ref{AHE}(a) shows the Hall response below $T_{\rm CDW}$ while Fig.~\ref{AHE}(b) shows that at temperatures higher than $T_{\rm CDW}$. The magnetic field ($B$) is parallel to the $c$-axis. At $T>T_{\rm CDW}$, the Hall resistivity ($\rho_{xy}$) is perfectly linear in $B$, with the slope of $\rho_{\rm xy}$(B) curves gradually decreases upon cooling. The linearity persists up to $\pm$14~T, as shown in Fig.~S1. At temperatures near $T_{\rm CDW}$, $\rho_{\rm xy}(B)$ starts to deviate from the linear behavior and an antisymmetric, sideway ``S" shape begins to emerge in the low-field region, as highlighted by the grey shading region in Fig.~\ref{AHE}(a). With a further cooling towards the base temperature, the ``S"-shaped feature becomes even more pronounced. The Hall response of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ is reminiscent of the observation in sister compounds {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. In particular, the emergence of the low-field ``S"-shaped region can be attributed to the development of the anomalous Hall effect on the backdrop of the ordinary Hall effect. To extract the anomalous Hall component $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$, we subtract a linear background from the total Hall signals using the data from $-2$~T to $+2$~T. The slope of the linear background is temperature-dependent, and it is derived from the locally linear region between 1~T and 2~T at all temperatures below $T_{\rm CDW}$. This analysis results in traces shown in Figs.~\ref{AHE}(c) and \ref{AHE}(d). Using the $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ at the plateau region as the benchmark, we trace the temperature dependence of the AHE (see Fig.~\ref{AHE}(e)). It is worth noticing that the magnitude of $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ monotonically decreases with an increasing temperature, and becomes significantly weakened near $T_{\rm CDW}$. In fact, the disappearance of $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ coincides with $T_{\rm CDW}$, indicating an intimate relationship between the anomalous Hall effect and the CDW phase. Also included in Fig.~\ref{AHE}(e) are $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ of {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ from Refs.~\onlinecite{Yu2021b} and \onlinecite{Yang2020}. Between $\sim$35~K and $\sim$95~K, $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}(T)$ of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ overlap almost perfectly. Furthermore, these data connect smoothly to $\rho_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ of {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ near 35~K. Finally, we extract the mobility ($\mu_e$) and the carrier density ($n_e$) for $\rho_{\rm xy}(B)$ traces that are linear over a wide field range, using a simple single band model. We find that $n_e$ exhibits a minimum right at $T_{\rm CDW}$ while $\mu_e$ is significantly enhanced upon cooling across $T_{\rm CDW}$. These temperature dependence are similar to the observation reported in {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. \begin{figure*} \centering \resizebox{16cm}{!}{ \includegraphics[width=1\textwidth]{Figure3.pdf}} \caption{\label{qo} (a, b) Oscillation signals after removing the background. (c-f) Fast Fourier transform (FFT) spectra in four different ranges: (c) 0-160 T, (d) 60-400 T, (e) 400-1200 T, (f) 1100-2400 T. The field ranges used for FFT analyses are 4-14~T, 6-14~T, 10-14~T and 10-14~T in (c), (d), (e) and (f), respectively. The data were collected at various temperatures ranging from 2~K to 30~K. The peaks are marked in the figures as $\lambda \sim17$~T, $\alpha\sim34$~T, $\beta\sim121$~T, $\omega\sim91$~T, $\epsilon\sim178$~T, $\zeta\sim322$~T, $\eta\sim461$~T, $\varsigma\sim525$~T, $\sigma\sim716$~T, $\psi\sim856$~T, $\phi\sim1461$~T and $\xi\sim2235$~T. The peaks labelled in red are newly discovered in our findings, while those labelled in black have been reported previously. (g-j) Temperature dependence of FFT amplitude of the peaks obtained in (c-f) and the corresponding Lifshitz-Kosevich fittings. The estimated effective masses are shown in the figures. } \end{figure*} We now present the second element obtained from our magnetotransport data. In Figs.~\ref{qo}(a) and \ref{qo}(b), we show the SdH oscillations collected with $B\mathbin{\!/\mkern-5mu/\!} c$ after removing the background. Two different field ranges are shown: a long field range offers a better view of low-frequency oscillations, while a narrower field range is adopted to display the finer structure in our data due to higher SdH frequencies. Fast Fourier transform (FFT) spectra are shown in Figs.~\ref{qo}(c-f). We detect a rich structure, uncovering at least 12 SdH peaks in the range of between $0$ and $3987$~T, where 3987~T is the area of the reconstructed Brillouin zone in the $k_x$-$k_y$ plane expressed as a quantum oscillation frequency. $F_\alpha$ and $F_\beta$ are consistent with the previous report by Yin {\it et al.}~\cite{Yin2021}, but the remaining peaks have never been reported. In Figs.~\ref{qo}(c-f), the new peaks are marked with red Greek symbols. Following the convention proposed for {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$},~\cite{Zhang2022} we regard the SdH frequencies lower than 500~T as belonging to the `low-frequency spectrum'. In the literature of {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, low-frequency spectrum has been presented in almost all reports, with excellent consistency. On the other hand, peaks in the mid-frequency spectrum (between 500~T and 2000~T) and the high-frequency spectrum (greater than 2000~T) of {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ are absent in many report. In {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, our $F_\alpha$ and $F_\beta$ are similarly in good agreement with the previous report~\cite{Yin2021}. However, our data additionally reveal peaks in both the mid-frequency to the high-frequency spectra (Figs.~\ref{qo}(e) and (f)). The largest frequency ($F_\xi$) reaches 2235~T. These frequencies indicate that {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ in the CDW phase hosts multiple Fermi surface sheets, and the largest cyclotron orbit encloses an area that is $\sim$56\% of the Brillouin zone area. Following the Lifshitz-Kosevich theory, we analyze the temperature dependence of the oscillation amplitudes using the thermal damping factor $R_T=X/\sinh X$ with $X = 14.693m^* T/B$, from which we can calculate the cyclotron effective mass $m^*$ of the peaks marked by the Greek symbols. As shown in Figs.~\ref{qo}(g-j), $m^*$ of the low-frequency peaks ($\lambda $, $\alpha$, $\beta$, $\omega$, $\epsilon$ and $\zeta$) are relatively small, all less than 0.1$m_e$ except for $\zeta$, which is slightly higher (0.12$m_e$). However, $m^*$ of the mid-frequency and the high-frequency peaks are comparatively larger, all greater than 0.2$m^*$ with $\psi$ having the largest value of 0.53$m_e$. Finally, we note our observation that some peaks shift at higher temperatures. We attribute this phenomenon to noise contamination. Indeed, this happens to weak peaks that are close to the noise floor, and they are excluded from our analysis. For instance, only the data between 2~K and 6~K are included for $m^*$ analysis for $\eta$ and $\sigma$ (see Figs.~\ref{qo}(e) and ~\ref{qo}(i)). \begin{figure}[!t]\centering \resizebox{8.5cm}{!}{ \includegraphics{Figure4.pdf}} \caption{\label{ang_dep} FFT spectra of SdH oscillations at different field angles ($\theta$) for frequencies ranging from (a) 0 to 200~T and (b) 200~T to 1200~T. All peaks shift towards higher frequencies as $\theta$ increases. (c, d) Angular dependence of different oscillation frequencies. The curves in all panels are the fittings based on the formula $F(\theta) = F(0^{\circ})/\cos\theta$. } \end{figure} We now explore the dimensionality of the Fermi surface. Figure~\ref{ang_dep} shows the FFT spectra at 2~K for selected magnetic field angles $\theta$, where $\theta=0^\circ$ corresponds to $B\mathbin{\!/\mkern-5mu/\!} c$ and $B$ is rotated towards the sample $ab$-plane with an increasing $\theta$. The intensities of all peaks gradually decrease with an increasing angle, especially for the peaks with relatively high frequencies ($>$ 500~T). However, we are able to follow several stronger peaks to higher angles. $F_\alpha$, $F_\beta$ and $F_\omega$, which are the more intense peaks, can be traced with ease to $\sim70^\circ$. For higher frequencies $F_\varsigma$, $F_\psi$ and $F_\zeta$, the signals are weaker but we are able to follow their angular evolution to $\sim35^\circ$. All these frequencies display $1/\cos\theta$ dependence (Fig.~\ref{ang_dep}), indicating the quasi-two-dimensional nature of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. Additionally, we recorded a peak with $F(0^\circ)=212$~T, which also exhibits a $1/\cos\theta$ dependence (see the curves labelled by asterisk in Figs.~\ref{ang_dep}(b) and (d)). However, the temperature dependence of this peak does not conform to the description of $R_T$. \begin{figure}[!t]\centering \resizebox{8.5cm}{!}{ \includegraphics{Figure5.pdf}} \caption{\label{LL_fan} (a) The oscillatory signal $\Delta V$ (proportional to oscillatory $\rho_{xx}$) of $F_\beta$ as a function of inverse magnetic field $B^{-1}$. A high pass digital filter was used to eliminate the intense $\lambda$ and $\alpha$ signals. The inset shows the FFT spectrum of the filtered signal. (b) Landau level fan diagram analysis of $F_\beta$ constructed with the filtered signal shown in (a). The closed circles denote integer indices while the open ones indicate half-integer indices. The red line is a linear fit of the data. The inset shows an enlarged view near the origin.} \end{figure} The total oscillatory signals can be decomposed into constituent components, with the $i^{th}$ component taking the form of~\cite{Jin2016,Fu2021,Shoenberg1984} \begin{equation} \Delta \rho_{xx}^i \sim A_i\cos\left(2\pi\left(\frac{F_i}{B}+\gamma_i-\delta_i+\varphi_i\right)\right), \label{LK} \end{equation} \\ where $A_i$ is the oscillation amplitude that depends on the relevant damping factors. For the phase factor, $\gamma_i=1/2-{\phi_B}_i/2\pi$ where ${\phi_B}_i$ is the Berry phase\cite{Mikitik1999}. $\delta_i$ depends on the dimensionality of the Fermi surface, and it is equal to $0$ or $\pm \frac{1}{8}$ when the Fermi surface is two-dimensional or three-dimensional, respectively. For the last term $\varphi_i$, it is zero when $\rho_{\rm xx} \ll \rho_{\rm xy}$ and equal to $\frac{1}{2}$ when $\rho_{\rm xx} \gg \rho_{\rm xy}$ according to Ref. [\onlinecite{Xiang2015}]. We construct a Landau level (LL) fan diagram for $\beta$ based on the data at 2~K, as $\beta$ is the easiest component to isolate with a digital high-pass filter. The high-pass filter removed the contribution from $\lambda$ and $\alpha$, making $\beta$ the dominant component (the components with $F>F_\beta$ makes negligible contribution.) Figure \ref{LL_fan}(a) shows the filtered signal and the inset is the corresponding FFT spectrum, showing the dominance of $\beta$ band. At $\pm14$~T, $\rho_{\rm xx}/\left|\rho_{\rm xy}\right|\sim5$ (shown in Fig.~S1) and this ratio significantly increases with a decreasing external field. As a result, $\sigma_{\rm xx} = \frac{\rho_{\rm xx}}{\rho_{\rm xx}^2+\rho_{\rm xy}^2} \approx \frac{1}{\rho_{\rm xx}}$, showing that $\rho_{\rm xx}$ reaches a local minimum when $\sigma_{\rm xx}$ reaches a local maximum and vice versa. Our oscillatory voltage $\Delta V$ is proportional to oscillatory resistivity $\Delta\rho_{xx}$. Thus, $\varphi_\beta$ is identified as $1/2$ and the LL integer indices $N$ can be safely assigned to the local maxima of the signal while the LL half-integer indices $N+1/2$ are assigned to the minima, as shown in Fig.~\ref{LL_fan}(b). We then perform the linear fitting of $N$ as a function of $1/B$. The fitted slope is 121~T, identical to the frequency of $\beta$, suggesting the reliability of our analysis. The intercept on the LL index axis is $-0.098$. Considering the two-dimensional nature of $\beta$ as shown in Fig.~\ref{ang_dep}(a), the value of $\delta_\beta$ should be zero. Finally we can obtain $\phi_B = 2\pi(1+0.098)=2.196\pi$. This value is close to $2\pi$, indicating a trivial Berry phase for $\beta$. This result shows that $\beta$ band does not contribute to $\sigma_{\rm xx}^{\rm AHE}$ intrinsically, while the topology of other bands should attract further study. \section{Discussion} The fact that {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ is also able to support the giant anomalous Hall effect brings new insights to the study of \AVSb\ compounds. One remarkable feature deserving further investigation is the good agreement across all three \AVSb\ compounds (see Fig.~\ref{AHE}(e)), considering the fact that these measurements were collected on different crystals by independent groups. This suggests similar origins of AHE. Besides, a similar scaling relation between $\sigma_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ and $\sigma_{\rm xx}$ observed in {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and the other two compounds also supports this opinion. As plotted in Fig.~S2, we can identify a region where $\sigma_{\rm xy}^{\rm AHE}$ $\propto \sigma_{\rm xx}^2$ when $\sigma_{\rm xx}$ exceeds $\sim2\times10^{5} \rm\, \Omega^{-1}cm^{-1}$. Judging from the magnitude of $\sigma_{\rm xx}$, skew scattering has been put forward to explain the observed AHE in {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ (Refs.~\onlinecite{Nagaosa2010,Yang2020,Yu2021b}). However, the mechanism giving rise to skew scattering is still under debate. In {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, it is attributed to a spin cluster model with an extra spin-orbit coupling. In {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, tiny amounts of paramagnetic impurities could cause the skew scattering. However, as pointed out by Yu {\it et al.}~\cite{Yu2021b}, it is not clear if a very low level of paramagnetic impurities is sufficient to cause the large AHE observed. When it comes to {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}, skew scattering is likely to be a dominant mechanism, as the region of $\sigma_{\rm xx}$ where the large AHE is observed is similar to {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. However, the source of the skew scattering requires more studies. Nevertheless, the possibility of an intrinsic mechanism giving rise to the AHE should still be investigated, as TRSB has been observed in the CDW state without the external magnetic field. All the evidence indicates a topological band structure could be a potential source of intrinsic anomalous Hall effect in \AVSb. Unfortunately, our LL fan diagram analysis only covers $\beta$ frequency. Further study on other frequencies is urgently needed. The observation of the AHE in the CDW state in all three \AVSb\ compounds clearly highlights the unconventional nature of this phase, demonstrating the need to understand the CDW state. In this regard, the Fermi surface of these compounds in the CDW state is an important gateway to achieve this understanding. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations performed on {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ assuming either a `star-of-David' (SoD) or a tri-hexagonal (TrH) deformation, the so-called $2\times2\times1$ distortion, can not explain our rich spectrum in {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. It has been pointed that additional interlayer complexity that involves both SoD and TrH can introduce new quantum oscillation frequencies~\cite{Broyles2022, Zhang2022}. Therefore, future DFT calculations on {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ taking into account various stacking arrangement of SD and ISD will shed light on this issue, and our quantum oscillation data will potentially be useful for settling the superlattice structure in the CDW phase of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. \section{Conclusions} To summarize, we have synthesised high-quality single crystals of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}\ and conducted the magnetotransport measurements up to 14~T. Close to the zero field, we detect the emergence of the anomalous Hall effect, while at high fields, we unravel a rich quantum oscillation spectrum. The magnitude of the anomalous Hall resistivity is large, on par with the observation in the sister compounds {CsV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}~\cite{Yu2021b} and {KV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}~\cite{Yang2020}, highlighting \AVSb\ as a suitable platform to explore the physics of anomalous Hall resistivity. Regarding quantum oscillations, we report 12 frequencies, with the largest frequency having a value of 2235~T. Angular dependencies of some of these frequencies show that they originate from two-dimensional Fermi surfaces, consistent with the layered nature of {RbV$_{3}$Sb$_{5}$}. \begin{acknowledgments} This work was supported by Research Grants Council of Hong Kong (CUHK 14301020, CUHK 14300722, A-CUHK402/19), CUHK Direct Grant (4053461, 4053408, 4053528, 4053463), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (12104384, 12174175) and the Shenzhen Basic Research Fund (JCYJ20190809173213150).\\ $^\S$L.W., W.Z. and Z.W. contributed equally to this work. \end{acknowledgments} \providecommand{\noopsort}[1]{}\providecommand{\singleletter}[1]{#1}%

\section{Introduction} \subsection{Background} Virtual knot theory was proposed by Kauffman in 1996, see \cite{KaV}. The combinatorial notion of virtual knot \footnote{In the sequel, we use the generic term ``knot'' for both knots and links, unless otherwise specified} is defined as an equivalence class of 4-valent plane diagrams (4-regular plane graphs with extra structure) where a new type of crossing (called virtual) is allowed. This theory can be regarded as a ``projection'' of knot theory in thickened surfaces $S_{g}\times {\bf R}$ (as studied in \cite{JKS}). Regarded from this point of view, virtual crossings appear as artifacts of the diagram projection from $S_g$ to ${\bf R}^{2}$. However, the rules for handling the virtual diagrams are motivated (in \cite{KaV}) by the idea that one can generalize the notion of a knot diagram to its oriented Gauss code. A Gauss code for a knot is list of crossings encountered on traversing the knot diagram, with the signs of the crossings indicated, and whether they are over or under in the course of the traverse. Each crossing is encountered twice in such a traverse, and thus the Gauss code has each crossing label appearing twice in the list. One can define Reidemeister moves on the Gauss codes, and thus abstract the knot theory from its planar diagrams. Virtual knot theory is the theory of such Gauss codes, not necessarily realizable in the plane. When one takes such a non-realizable code, and attempts to draw a planar diagram, virtual crossings are needed to complete the connections in the plane. These crossings are artifacts of the planar projection. The rules for handling virtual knot diagrams are designed to make the representation of the virtual knot independent of the particular choice of virtual crossings that realizes the diagram. It turns out that these rules describe embeddings of knots and links in thickened surfaces, stabilized by the addition and subtraction of empty handles (i.e. the addition and subtraction of thickened 1-handles from the surface that do not have any part of the knot or link embedded in them) \cite{KaV2,KaV4,Ma1,Ma8,Ma10,CKS,KUP}. \bigbreak Another approach to Gauss codes for knots and links is the use of Gauss diagrams as in \cite{GPV}). In this paper by Goussarov, Polyak and Viro, the virtual knot theory, taken as all Gauss diagrams up to Reidemeister moves, was used to analyze the structure of Vassiliev invariants for classical and virtual knots. In both \cite{KaV} and \cite{GPV} it is proved that if two classical knots are equivalent in the virtual category \cite{KUP}, then they are equivalent in the classical category. Thus classical knot theory is properly embedded in virtual knot theory. \bigbreak To date, many invariants of classical knots have been generalized for the virtual case, see \cite{GPV,KaV,KR,Ma1,Ma2,Ma8,Ma10,Saw, SW}. In many cases, a classical invariant extends to an invariant of virtuals. In some cases one has an invariant of virtuals that is an extension of ideas from classical knot theory, that vanishes or is otherwise trivial for classical knots. An example of this is the polynomial invariant studied by Sawollek \cite{Saw}, Silver and Williams \cite{SW} and by Kauffman and Radford \cite{KR}\footnote{Later, we will describe another approach that leads to the same results, \cite{Ma3}}. This invariant is produced by the methods that give the classical Alexander polynomial, but it is an example of a zeroth order Alexander polynomial, and is trivial in the classical case and non-trivial in the virtual case. Such invariants are valuable for the study of virtual knots, since they promise the possibility of distinguishing classical from virtual knots in key cases. Other examples of this phenomenon can be found in \cite{Ma2,Ma5}. On the other hand, some invariants evaluated on classical knots coincide with well known classical knot invariants (see \cite{KaV, KaV2, KaV4, Ma3} on generalizations of the Jones polynomial, fundamental group, quandle and quantum link invariants). These invariants exhibit interesting phenomena on virtual knots and links: for instance, there exists a virtual knot $K$ with ``fundamental group'' isomorphic to ${\bf Z}$ and Jones polynomial not equal to $1$. This phenomenon immediately implies that the knot $K$ is not classical, and underlines the difficulty of extracting the Jones polynomial from the fundamental group in the classical case. We know in principle that the fundamental group, plus peripheral information, determines the knot itself in the classical case. It is not known how to extract the Jones polynomial from this algebraic information. Note that, for classical knots, the quandle is a generalzation of the fundamental group with a geometric interpretation. In this paper we consider quandles of virtual knots, defined formally in terms of their diagrams. However, the formally defined fundamentaly group of a virtual knot can be interpreted as the fundamental group of the complement of the virtual knot in the one-point suspension of a thickened surface where this knot is presented. Another phenomenon that does not appear in the classical case are long knots \cite{Ma11}: if we break a virtual knot diagram at two different points and take them to the infinity, we may obtain two different long knots. We will discuss this subject later in the text. \bigbreak Beyond the fundamental group and the quandle, there are two algebraic constructions defining virtual knot invariants: the biquandle \cite{KaV2, KR, FJK} and the virtual quandle \cite{Ma2}. Each of them has a number of realizations (representations). In this paper, we bring these two ideas together, and present a combined construction that allows the extraction of new algebraic invariants of virtual knots. \bigbreak The general strategy of this paper is the following: One presents an algebraically defined invariant of knots (virtual knots, long knots, etc.) This invariant is defined axiomatically (the axioms correspond to invariance under diagrammatic moves). In this form, the invariant appears to have strength, but difficult to work with. In order to manage the invariant, we may take a representation of this invariant, say, $I$, into some category (e.g. groups) with operations defined in terms of that representation category. In this manner we can obtain for example, the knot group and its generalizations. Or one can find a finite object (or category) $G$ with operations satisfying the initial axioms. Then the set of homomorphisms $I(K)\to G$ is an invariant of the knot $K$. In particular, so is the {\bf cardinality} of the set of such homomorphisms. Such homomorphisms can also be called {\em colorings} because they correspond to colorings of the diagram arcs (generators of $I(K)$) by elements of $G$. \bigbreak In some cases, polynomial-type invariants emerge naturally from the algebra. In other cases it is useful to use algebraic and polynomial-type invariants together to extract information. \bigbreak This paper does not pretend to describe all directions of virtual knot theory. For instance, we say a little about the Jones polynomial and do not describe its generalizations, the Khovanov complex \cite{Ma12}, the surface-bracket polynomial \cite{KaV4}, and the $\Xi$-polynomial, \cite{Ma3, Ma6}. Also, we do not touch the Vassiliev invariants for virtual links, see \cite{KaV, GPV, Ma10}. All these concepts will be described in the book by the authors \cite{VBOOK}. Also, a list of unsolved problems concerning virtual knots can be found in \cite{FKM}. \subsection{Basic definitions} We begin with the definition of a virtual knot according to \cite{KaV} \begin{dfn} A {\em virtual link diagram} is a $4$--valent graph on the plane such that each crossing of it is either classical (i.e., one pair of opposite edges is selected to make an overcrossing; the other pair forms an undercrossing) or virtual (just marked by a circle). \end{dfn} \begin{dfn} A {\em virtual knot} is an equivalence class of virtual knot diagrams modulo generalized Reidemeister moves. \end{dfn} The set of virtual Reidemeister moves consist of: \begin{enumerate} \item classical Reidemeister moves: \centering\includegraphics[width=300pt]{class.eps} \item virtual versions of these moves (where all classical crossings are replaced with virtual ones) \centering\includegraphics[width=300pt]{rei1.eps} \item and the ``semivirtual'' version of the third Reidemeister move where two virtual crossing pass through a classical crossing. \centering\includegraphics[width=240pt]{rei2.eps} \end{enumerate} The analogous version with two classical crossings and one virtual crossing is forbidden. There are two versions of these forbidden moves shown in Fig. \ref{verbot}. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=180pt]{verbotene.eps} \caption{The forbidden moves} \label{verbot} \end{figure} It is proved in \cite{GPV} (see also S. Nelson \cite{Nel} and T. Kanenobu \cite{Kan}), that if we include these two moves, each knot will be equivalent to the unknot. If we add only first of them (F1), we will obtain what is called ``welded knots'', see \cite{FRR} and \cite{Satoh}. In \cite{FRR} Fenn, Rimanyi and Rourke introduced the notion of the ``welded braid group". This version of braids is the same as virtual braids with the forbidden move $F1$ added in braid form. Satoh in \cite{Satoh} showed that the concept of welded knots could be interpreted in terms of embeddings of tori in Euclidean four-space. This also leads to an interpretation of welded braids in terms of braidings of tubes in four-space. \bigbreak One can easily consider {\em oriented virtual links} by endowing diagrams with an orientation. As with classical knots, virtual knots can be obtained as closures of {\em virtual braids} first mentioned in the talk by Kauffman \cite{Kau0}, and in \cite{KaV, KaV2,Ma1,KL1,KL2}. See also Vershinin \cite{Ver} and Kamada \cite{Kam}. Virtual braids are analogues of classical braids where some crossings are allowed to be virtual (and marked by a circle). The corresponding $n$--strand group has generators $\sigma_{1},\dots,\sigma_{n-1}$ (as in the classical case) and ``virtual generators'' $\zeta_{1},\dots,\zeta_{n-1}$ with obvious relations $\zeta_{i}^{2}=1$ (more details see in \cite{Ver, KaV, KL1}). The closure procedure is quite analogous to that for classical knots. \begin{re} All virtual (and classical) knots are oriented, unless otherwise specified. \end{re} The geometric approach to virtual knots is based on the following fact: virtual knots are isotopy classes of curves in ``thickened surfaces'' $S_{g}\times I$ up to ``stabilization'', i.e. adding and removing handles. See the discussion of this viewpoint given earlier in this introduction. \section{Basic Construction} Here we are going to recall the construction of the quandle and generalize it for the case of virtual knots. \subsection{The Case of Classical Knots} For the classical case, there is a complete algebraic invariant of knots (complete up to reversed mirror images, and actually complete if one adds longitudinal information to the system) first proposed by D.Joyce \cite{Joy} and S.V.Matveev \cite{Mat}. Here is a sketch of the quandle construction. One considers a classical knot diagram, and encodes all arcs of it by letters. We use a formal algebraic structure with the operation $\circ$ for which the following condition holds. For each crossing $X$ at which the arc $a$ (we {\bf do not look at its orientation}) lies on the right hand of the overcrossing oriented arc $b$ and the arc $c$ lies on the left hand, we write the formal relation \begin{equation} a\circ b=c. \label{clasrel}\end{equation} It can be checked that the invariance of this structure (a formal algebra given by generators and relations) under the three Reidemeister moves implies the following algebraic axioms: \begin{enumerate} \item idempotence: $\forall a: a\circ a=a$ \item the existence of left inverses: $\forall b,c\; \exists ! x: x\circ b=c$. This $x$ is denoted by $c\bar \circ b$. \item right self-distributivity: $\forall a,b,c: (a\circ b)\circ c= (a\circ c)\circ (b\circ c)$. \end{enumerate} An algebraic structure satisfying these axioms is called a {\em quandle}. The quandle of an oriented knot or link is defined by generators and relations as above (plus the imposition of these axioms). Now, this can be easily generalized \cite{KaV} for the case of virtual knots: we allow arcs to pass through a virtual crossing and ignore the virtual intersections. It is straightforward to check that this ``virtualization'' of the quandle is an invariant of virtual knots. Since the quandle plus longitudinal information is a complete invariant of classical knots, and since this information is preserved under virtual equivalence, one can conclude \cite{KaV,GPV}) that two classical knot diagrams are equivalent in the virtual category if and only if they are equivalent in the classical category. \bigbreak \subsection{Biquandles and a Generalized Alexander Polynomial $G_{K}(s,t)$} The {\em biquandle} \cite{KaV2, FJK, CS} is an algebra associated with the diagram that is invariant (up to isomorphism) under the generalized Reidemeister moves for virtual knots and links. The operations in this algebra are motivated by the formation of labels for the edges of the diagram and the intended invariance under the moves. We will give the abstract definition of the biquandle after a discussion of these knot theoretic issues. View Figure \ref{f2}. In this Figure we have shown the format for the operations in a biquandle. The overcrossing arc has two labels, one on each side of the crossing. In a {\em biquandle} there is an algebra element labelling each {\em edge} of the diagram. An edge of the diagram corresponds to an edge of the underlying plane graph of that diagram. \bigbreak Let the edges oriented toward a crossing in a diagram be called the {\em input} edges for the crossing, and the edges oriented away from the crossing be called the {\em output} edges for the crossing. Let $a$ and $b$ be the input edges for a positive crossing, with $a$ the label of the undercrossing input and $b$ the label on the overcrossing input. Then in the biquandle, we label the undercrossing output by $$c=a^{b}$$ just as in the case of the quandle, but the overcrossing output is labeled $$d= b_{a}.$$ We usually read $a^{b}$ as -- the undercrossing line $a$ is acted upon by the overcrossing line $b$ to produce the output $c=a^{b}.$ In the same way, we can read $b_{a}$ as -- the overcossing line $b$ is operated on by the undercrossing line $a$ to produce the output $d= b_{a}.$ The biquandle labels for a negative crossing are similar but with an overline (denoting an operation of order two) placed on the letters. Thus in the case of the negative crossing, we would write $$c=a^{\overline{b}} \quad \mbox{and} \quad d=b_{\overline{a}}.$$ \noindent To form the biquandle, $BQ(K)$, we take one generator for each edge of the diagram and two relations at each crossing (as described above). This system of generators and relations is then regarded as encoding an algebra that is generated freely by the biquandle operations as concatenations of these symbols and subject to the biquandle algebra axioms. These axioms (which we will describe below) are a transcription in the biquandle language of the requirement that this algebra be invariant under Reidemeister moves on the diagram. \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(280,163) \thicklines \put(131,162){\line(0,-1){159}} \put(1,1){\framebox(278,161){}} \put(231,104){\makebox(21,19){$a^{\overline{b}} = a\, \UL{b}$}} \put(167,59){\makebox(20,15){$b_{\overline{a}} = b\, \LL{a}$}} \put(233,62){\makebox(20,16){$b$}} \put(212,38){\makebox(18,17){$a$}} \put(73,106){\makebox(23,23){$a^{b} = a\, \UR{b}$}} \put(77,56){\makebox(32,22){$b_{a} = b\, \LR{a}$}} \put(10,86){\makebox(20,16){$b$}} \put(52,43){\makebox(18,17){$a$}} \put(211,89){\vector(0,1){33}} \put(211,43){\vector(0,1){32}} \put(250,82){\vector(-1,0){78}} \put(51,90){\vector(0,1){33}} \put(51,43){\vector(0,1){34}} \put(11,83){\vector(1,0){80}} \end{picture} } \end{center} \caption{Biquandle Relations at a Crossing} \label{f2} \end{figure} \noindent Another way to write this formalism for the biquandle is as follows $$a^{b} = a\, \UR{b}$$ $$a_{b} = a\, \LR{b}$$ $$a^{\overline{b}} = a\, \UL{b}$$ $$a_{\overline{b}} = a\, \LL{b}.$$ \noindent We call this the {\em operator formalism} for the biquandle. The operator formalism has advantages when one is performing calculations, since it is possible to maintain the formulas on a line rather than extending them up and down the page as in the exponential notation. On the other hand the exponential notation has intuitive familiarity and is good for displaying certain results. The axioms for the biquandle, are exactly the rules needed for invariance of this structure under the Reidemeister moves. Note that in analyzing invariance under Reidemeister moves, we visualize representative parts of link diagrams with biquandle labels on their edges. The primary labeling occurs at a crossing. At a positive crossing with over input $b$ and under input $a$, the under output is labeled $a\,\UR{b}$ and the over output is labeled $b\,\LR{a}\,$. At a negative crossing with over input $b$ and under input $a$, the under output is labeled $a\,\UL{b}$ and the over output is labeled $b\,\LL{a}$. At a virtual crossing there is no change in the labeling of the lines that cross one another. \begin{re} Later, in this paper, we shall generalize the biquandle to include operations at the virtual crossings. \end{re} \begin{re} A remark is in order about the relationship of the operator notations with the usual conventions for binary algebraic operations. Let $a*b = a^{b} = a\, \UR{b}.$ We are asserting that the biquandle comes equipped with four binary operations of which one is $a*b.$ Here is how these notations are related to the usual parenthesizations: \begin{enumerate} \item $(a*b)*c = (a^{b})^{c} = a^{bc} = a\, \UR{b}\, \UR{c}$ \item $a*(b*c) = a^{b^{c}} = a\, \UR{b\, \UR{c}}$ \end{enumerate} \noindent From this the reader should see that the exponential and operator notations allow us to express biquandle equation with a minimum of parentheses. \end{re} \bigbreak In Figure \ref{f3} we illustrate the effect of these conventions and how it leads to the following algebraic transcription of the directly oriented second Reidemeister move: $$a = a\,\UR{b}\,\UL{b\,\LR{a}} \quad \mbox{or} \quad a = a^{b \overline{b_{a}}},$$ $$b = b\,\LR{a}\,\LL{a\,\UR{b}} \quad \mbox{or} \quad b= b_{a \overline{a^{b}}}.$$ \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(323,224) \thicklines \put(201,222){\makebox(121,40){$a = a\,\UR{b}\,\UL{b\,\LR{a}}$}} \put(41,123){\makebox(81,40){$a\,\UR{b}$}} \put(200,122){\makebox(82,41){$b\,\LR{a}$}} \put(201,2){\makebox(40,41){$a$}} \put(81,2){\makebox(41,41){$b$}} \put(1,222){\makebox(121,41){$b = b\,\LR{a}\,\LL{a\,\UR{b}}$}} \put(164,186){\vector(2,3){36}} \put(123,123){\vector(2,3){34}} \put(158,69){\vector(-2,3){36}} \put(201,2){\vector(-2,3){36}} \put(200,121.5){\vector(-2,3){79}} \put(121,3){\vector(2,3){79}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{Direct Two Move } \label{f3} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(242,350) \thicklines \put(41,1){\makebox(160,42){$\exists x \ni x = a\,\UR{b\,\LL{x}} \quad \mbox{,} \quad a = x\,\UL{b} \quad \mbox{and} \quad b= b\,\LL{x}\, \LR{a} $}} \put(1,281){\makebox(80,42){$b\,\LL{x}\, \LR{a}$}} \put(26,200){\makebox(78,42){$x$}} \put(141,200){\makebox(80,42){$b\,\LL{x}$}} \put(139,80){\makebox(81,42){$x\,\UL{b}$}} \put(40,82){\makebox(41,39){$b$}} \put(141,282){\makebox(40,39){$a$}} \put(125,136){\vector(2,-3){34}} \put(83,202){\vector(2,-3){32}} \put(116,255){\vector(-2,-3){33}} \put(158,321){\vector(-2,-3){33}} \put(159,204){\vector(-2,3){78}} \put(80,84){\vector(2,3){79}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{Reverse Two Move } \label{f4} \end{figure} \noindent The reverse oriented second Reidemeister move gives a different sort of identity, as shown in Figure \ref{f4}. For the reverse oriented move, we must assert that given elements $a$ and $b$ in the biquandle, then there exists an element $x$ such that \nopagebreak $$\mbox{x} = \mbox{a}\,\UR{b\,\LL{x}} \quad \mbox{,} \quad \mbox{a} = \mbox{x}\,\UL{b} \quad \mbox{and} \quad \mbox{b}= \mbox{b}\,\LL{x}\, \LR{a}\,.$$ \bigbreak By reversing the arrows in Figure \ref{f4} we obtain a second statement for invariance under the type two move, saying the same thing with the operations reversed: Given elements $a$ and $b$ in the biquandle, then there exists an element $x$ such that $$\mbox{x} = \mbox{a}\,\UL{b\,\UR{x}} \quad \mbox{,} \quad \mbox{a} = \mbox{x}\,\UR{b} \quad \mbox{and} \quad \mbox{b}= \mbox{b}\,\UR{x}\, \LL{a}\,.$$ \noindent There is no neccessary relation between the $x$ in the first statement and the $x$ in the second statement. \bigbreak \noindent These assertions about the existence of $x$ can be viewed as asserting the existence of fixed points for a certain operators. In this case such an operator is $F(x) =a\,\UR{b\,\LL{x}}\,$. It is characteristic of certain axioms in the biquandle that they demand the existence of such fixed points. Another example is the axiom corresponding to the first Reidemeister move (one of them) as illustrated in Figure \ref{f5}. This axiom states that given an element $a$ in the biquandle, then there exists an $x$ in the biquandle such that $x=a \,\LR{x}$ and that $a = x \,\UR{a}$. In this case the operator is $G(x) = a\,\LR{x}\,$. \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(323,246) \thicklines \put(82,3){\makebox(122,40){$\exists x \ni x=a \,\LR{x} \quad \mbox{and} \quad a = x \,\UR{a}$}} \put(224,162){\makebox(78,40){$x \,\UR{a}$}} \put(183,82){\makebox(79,40){$a \,\LR{x}$}} \put(61,81){\makebox(43,42){x}} \put(21,162){\makebox(41,41){a}} \put(171,148){\vector(4,3){71}} \put(83,82){\vector(4,3){74}} \put(122,43){\vector(-1,1){39}} \put(201,123){\vector(-1,-1){79}} \put(43,203){\vector(2,-1){158}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{First Move} \label{f5} \end{figure} \bigbreak It is unusual that an algebra would have axioms asserting the existence of fixed points with respect to operations involving its own elements. We plan to take up the study of this aspect of biquandles in a separate publication. For now it is worth remarking that a slight change in the axiomatic structure allows an easy definition of the free biquandle. The idea is this: Suppose that one has an axiom that states the existence of an $x$ such that $x=a \,\LR{x}$ for each $a.$ Then we change the statement of the axiom by adding a new operation (unary in this case) to the algebra, call it $Fix(a)$ such that $Fix(a) =a \,\LR{Fix(a)}.$ Existence of the fixed point follows from this property of the new operation, and we can describe the free biquandle on a set by taking all finite biquandle expressions in the elememts of the set, modulo these revised axioms for the biquandle. \bigbreak The biquandle relations for invariance under the third Reidemeister move are shown in Figure \ref{f6}. The version of the third Reidemeister move shown in this figure yields the algebraic relations: $$a\, \UR{b} \,\UR{c} = a\, \UR{c\, \LR{b}} \,\UR{b\, \UR{c}} \quad \mbox{or} \quad a^{b c} = a^{c_{b} b^{c}},$$ $$c\, \LR{b} \,\LR{a} = c\, \LR{a\, \UR{b}} \,\LR{b\, \LR{a}} \quad \mbox{or} \quad c_{b a} = c_{a^{b} b_{a}},$$ $$b\, \LR{a} \, \UR{c\, \LR{a\, \UR{b}}} = b\, \UR{c}\, \LR{a\, \UR{c\, \LR{b}}} \quad \mbox{or} \quad (b_{a})^{c_{a^{b}}} = (b^{c})_{a^{c_{b}}}.$$ \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(173,371) \thicklines \put(120,63){\vector(1,1){26}} \put(87,29){\vector(1,1){25}} \put(63,53){\vector(1,-1){24}} \put(26,92){\vector(1,-1){28}} \put(121,314){\vector(1,-1){25}} \put(84,350){\vector(1,-1){28}} \put(59,324){\vector(1,1){25}} \put(26,290){\vector(1,1){25}} \put(147,148){\vector(-1,-1){120}} \put(27,148){\vector(1,-1){56}} \put(92,82){\vector(1,-1){55}} \put(91,283){\vector(1,-1){55}} \put(26,349){\vector(1,-1){56}} \put(146,349){\vector(-1,-1){120}} \thinlines \put(196,2){\makebox(23,23){$b\, \UR{c}\, \LR{a\, \UR{c\, \LR{b}}}$}} \put(76,5){\makebox(22,21){$a\, \UR{c\, \LR{b}}$}} \put(0,1){\makebox(25,24){$c\, \LR{b} \,\LR{a}$}} \put(102,72){\makebox(26,24){$b\, \UR{c}$}} \put(48,72){\makebox(23,24){$c\, \LR{b}$}} \put(196,77){\makebox(22,24){$a\, \UR{c\, \LR{b}} \,\UR{b\, \UR{c}}$}} \put(149,138){\makebox(23,25){$c$}} \put(5,139){\makebox(21,23){$b$}} \put(4,79){\makebox(20,21){$a$}} \put(144,200){\makebox(22,23){$b\, \LR{a} \, \UR{c\, \LR{a\, \UR{b}}}$}} \put(6,203){\makebox(25,23){$c\, \LR{a\, \UR{b}} \,\LR{b\, \LR{a}}$}} \put(164,279){\makebox(22,25){$a\, \UR{b} \,\UR{c}$}} \put(104,280){\makebox(21,23){}} \put(48,281){\makebox(23,21){$b\, \LR{a}$}} \put(149,340){\makebox(22,21){c}} \put(74,349){\makebox(21,21){$a\, \UR{b}$}} \put(3,349){\makebox(23,21){$b$}} \put(1,282){\makebox(20,20){$a$}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{Third Move} \label{f6} \end{figure} \noindent The reader will note that if we replace the diagrams of Figure \ref{f6} with diagrams with all negative crossings then we will get a second triple of equations identical to the above equations but with all right operator symbols replaced by the corresponding left operator symbols (equivalently -- with all exponent literals replaced by their barred versions). Here are the operator versions of these equations. We refrain from writing the exponential versions because of the prolixity of barred variables. $$a\, \UL{b} \,\UL{c} = a\, \UL{c\, \LL{b}} \,\UL{b\, \UL{c}},$$ $$c\, \LL{b} \,\LL{a} = c\, \LL{a\, \UL{b}} \,\LL{b\, \LL{a}},$$ $$b\, \LL{a} \, \UL{c\, \LL{a\, \UL{b}}} = b\, \UL{c}\, \LL{a\, \UL{c\, \LL{b}}}.$$ \vspace{3mm} We now have a complete set of axioms, for it is a fact (see, e.g. \cite{KNOTS,Ma1}) that the third Reidemeister move with the orientation shown in Figure \ref{f6} and either all positive crossings (as shown in that Figure) or all negative crossings, is sufficient to generate all the other cases of third Reidemeister move just so long as we have both oriented forms of the second Reidemeister move. Consequently, we can now give the full definition of the biquandle. \bigbreak \noindent {\bf Definition.} A {\em biquandle} $B$ is a set with four binary operations indicated by the conventions we have explained above: $a^{b} \,\mbox{,} \, a^{\overline{b}} \, \mbox{,} \, a_{b} \,\mbox{,} \, a_{\overline{b}}.$ We shall refer to the operations with barred variables as the {\em left} operations and the operations without barred variables as the {\em right} operations. The biquandle is closed under these operations and the following axioms are satisfied:\nopagebreak \begin{enumerate} \item For any elements $a$ and $b$ in $B$ we have $$a = a^{b \overline{b_{a}}} \quad \mbox{and} \quad b= b_{a \overline{a^{b}}} \quad \mbox{and}$$ $$a = a^{\overline{b}b_{\overline{a}}} \quad \mbox{and} \quad b= b_{\overline{a} a^{\overline{b}}}.$$ \item Given elements $a$ and $b$ in $B$, then there exists an element $x$ such that $$x = a^{b_{\overline{x}}} \mbox{,} \quad a = x^{\overline{b}} \quad \mbox{and} \quad b= b_{\overline{x}a}.$$ \noindent Given elements $a$ and $b$ in $B$, then there exists an element $x$ such that $$x = a^{\overline{b_{x}}} \mbox{,} \quad a = x^{b} \quad \mbox{and} \quad b= b_{x\overline{a}}.$$ \item For any $a$ , $b$ , $c$ in $B$ the following equations hold and the same equations hold when all right operations are replaced in these equations by left operations. $$a^{b c} = a^{c_{b} b^{c}} \mbox{,} \quad c_{b a} = c_{a^{b} b_{a}} \mbox{,} \quad (b_{a})^{c_{a^{b}}} = (b^{c})_{a^{c_{b}}}.$$ \item Given an element $a$ in $B$, then there exists an $x$ in the biquandle such that $x=a_{x}$ and $a = x^{a}.$ Given an element $a$ in $B$, then there exists an $x$ in the biquandle such that $x=a^{\overline{x}}$ and $a = x_{\overline{a}}.$ \end{enumerate} These axioms are transcriptions of the Reidemeister moves. The first axiom transcribes the directly oriented second Reidemeister move. The second axiom transcribes the reverse oriented Reidemeister move. The third axiom transcribes the third Reidemeister move as we have described it in Figure \ref{f6}. The fourth axiom transcribes the first Reidemeister move. Much more work is needed in exploring these algebras and their applications to knot theory. \bigbreak \subsection{The Alexander Biquandle} \noindent In order to realize a specific example of a biquandle structure, suppose that $$a\,\UR{b} = ta + vb$$ $$a\,\LR{b} =sa + ub$$ \noindent where $a$,$b$,$c$ are elements of a module $M$ over a ring $R$ and $t$,$s$,$v$ and $u$ are in $R$. We use invariance under the Reidemeister moves to determine relations among these coefficients. \vspace{3mm} Taking the equation for the third Reidemeister move discussed above, we have $$a \UR{b} \,\UR{c} = t(ta+vb) + vc = t^{2}a + tvb +vc$$ $$a \UR{c \LR{b}} \,\UR{b \UR{c}} = t(ta + v(sc + ub)) + v(tb + vc)$$ $$= t^{2}a + tv(u+1)b + v(ts+v)c.$$ \noindent From this we see that we have a solution to the equation for the third Reidemeister move if $u=0$ and $v=1-st$. Assuming that $t$ and $s$ are invertible, it is not hard to see that the following equations not only solve this single Reideimeister move, but they give a biquandle structure, satisfying all the axioms. $$a\,\UR{b} = ta + (1-st)b \, \mbox{,} \quad a\,\LR{b} = sa$$ $$a\,\UL{b} = t^{-1}a + (1-s^{-1}t^{-1})b \, \mbox{,} \quad a\,\LL{b} = s^{-1}a.$$ \noindent Thus we have a simple generalization of the Alexander quandle and we shall refer to this structure, with the equations given above, as the {\em Alexander Biquandle}. \vspace{3mm} Just as one can define the Alexander Module of a classical knot, we have the Alexander Biquandle of a virtual knot or link, obtained by taking one generator for each {\em edge} of the knot diagram and taking the module relations in the above linear form. Let $ABQ(K)$ denote this module structure for an oriented link $K$. That is, $ABQ(K)$ is the module generated by the edges of the diagram, modulo the submodule generated by the relations. This module then has a biquandle structure specified by the operations defined above for an Alexnder Biquandle. We first construct the module and then note that it has a biquandle structure. See Figures \ref{f7},\ref{f8} and \ref{f9} for an illustration of the Alexander Biquandle labelings at a crossing. \vspace{3mm} \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(309,475) \thinlines \put(217,25){\vector(-1,1){158}} \put(58,24){\vector(1,1){71}} \put(146,114){\vector(1,1){70}} \put(83,1){\framebox(40,41){$a$}} \put(227,7){\framebox(41,40){$b$}} \put(22,188){\framebox(61,41){$s^{-1}b$}} \put(107,188){\framebox(201,41){$t^{-1}a+(1-s^{-1}t^{-1})b$}} \put(1,432){\framebox(120,42){$ta+(1-st)b$}} \put(222,414){\framebox(39,41){$sb$}} \put(16,242){\framebox(40,42){$b$}} \put(226,248){\framebox(40,42){$a$}} \put(129,354){\vector(-1,1){71}} \put(218,265){\vector(-1,1){72}} \put(57,265){\vector(1,1){161}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{Alexander Biquandle Labeling at a Crossing} \label{f7} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(344,352) \thicklines \put(286,48){\framebox(41,43){$d$}} \put(156,206){\framebox(41,42){$c$}} \put(209,102){\framebox(42,42){$b$}} \put(1,216){\framebox(40,41){$a$}} \put(154,91){\circle{30}} \put(271,198){\vector(1,-1){71}} \put(182,286){\vector(1,-1){75}} \put(80,203){\vector(-2,3){55}} \put(185,45){\vector(-2,3){86}} \put(63,2){\vector(-1,3){42}} \put(323,263){\vector(-1,-1){260}} \put(212,348){\vector(4,-3){113}} \put(25,287){\vector(3,1){186}} \put(342,125){\vector(-2,-1){157}} \put(22,125){\vector(1,1){160}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{A Virtual Knot Fully Labeled} \label{f8} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces\setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(333,352) \thicklines \put(132,205){\framebox(67,41){$s^{2}a$}} \put(204,114){\framebox(41,41){$sa$}} \put(291,165){\framebox(41,43){$d$}} \put(1,192){\framebox(40,41){$a$}} \put(138,91){\circle{30}} \put(255,198){\vector(1,-1){71}} \put(166,286){\vector(1,-1){75}} \put(64,203){\vector(-2,3){55}} \put(169,45){\vector(-2,3){86}} \put(47,2){\vector(-1,3){42}} \put(307,263){\vector(-1,-1){260}} \put(196,348){\vector(4,-3){113}} \put(9,287){\vector(3,1){186}} \put(326,125){\vector(-2,-1){157}} \put(6,125){\vector(1,1){160}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{A Virtual Knot with Lower Operations Labeled} \label{f9} \end{figure} For example, consider the virtual knot in Figure \ref{f8}. This knot gives rise to a biquandle with generators $a$,$b$,$c$,$d$ and relations $$a= d\, \UR{b} \, \mbox{,} \quad c= b\, \LR{d} \, \mbox{,} \quad d= c\, \UR{a} \, \mbox{,} \quad b= a\, \LR{c}.$$ \noindent writing these out in $ABQ(K)$, we have $$a = td + (1-st)b \, \mbox{,} \quad c=sb \, \mbox{,} \quad d=tc+(1-st)a \, \mbox{,} \quad b=sa.$$ \noindent eliminating $c$ and $b$ and rewriting, we find $$a=td+(1-st)sa$$ $$d=ts^{2}a+(1-st)a$$ Note that these relations can be written directly from the diagram as indicated in Figure \ref{f9} if we perform the lower biquandle operations directly on the diagram. This is the most convenient algorithm for producing the relations. \smallbreak \noindent We can write these as a list of relations $$(s-s^{2}t-1)a +td = 0$$ $$(s^{2}t+1-st)a -d = 0$$ \noindent for the Alexander Biquandle as a module over $Z[s,s^{-1}, t, t^{-1}].$ The relations can be expressed concisely with the matrix of coefficients of this system of equations: $$M = \left[ \begin{array}{cc} s-s^{2}t-1 & t \\ (s^{2}t+1-st) & -1 \end{array} \right]. $$ \noindent The determinant of $M$ is, up to multiples of $\pm s^{i}t^{j}$ for integers $i$ and $j$, an invariant of the virtual knot or link $K$. We shall denote this determinant by $G_{K}(s,t)$ and call it the {\em generalized Alexander polynomial for $K$}. A key fact about $G_{K}(s,t)$ is that {\em $G_{K}(s,t)=0$ if $K$ is equivalent to a classical diagram}. This is seen by noting that in a classical diagram one of the relations will be a consequence of the others. \smallbreak \noindent In this case we have $$G_{K} = (1-s) +(s^{2}-1)t + (s-s^{2})t^{2},$$ \noindent which shows that the knot in question is non-trivial and non-classical. \bigbreak Here is another example of the use of this polynomial. Let $D$ denote the diagram in Figure \ref{f10}. It is not hard to see that this virtual knot has unit Jones polynomial, and that the fundamental group is isomorphic to the integers. The biquandle does detect the knottedness of $D$. The relations are $$ a\, \UR{d} = b, \, d\, \LR{a} = e \, \mbox{,} \quad c\, \UR{e} = d, \, e\,\LR{c} = f \, \mbox{,} \quad f\, \UL{b} = a, \, b\, \LL{f} = c$$ \noindent from which we obtain the relations (eliminating $c$, $e$ and $f$). $$b = ta +(1-tv)d \, \mbox{,} \quad d = ts^{-1}b + (1-ts)sd \, \mbox{,} \quad a = t^{-1}s^{2}d + (1-t^{-1}s^{-1})b \, .$$ \noindent The determinant of this system is the generalized Alexander polynomial for $D$: $$t^{2}(s^{2}-1) + t(s^{-1}+1-s-s^{2}) + (s-s^{2}).$$ \noindent This proves that $D$ is a non-trivial virtual knot. \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(326,328) \thinlines \put(292,137){\makebox(33,41){$D$}} \thicklines \put(25,242){\vector(0,-1){161}} \put(26,85){\vector(3,2){241}} \put(65,167){\vector(1,2){79}} \put(145,326){\vector(1,-2){121}} \put(145,5){\vector(-1,2){54}} \put(80,135){\vector(-1,2){15}} \put(264,84){\vector(-3,2){111}} \put(135,169){\vector(-3,2){109}} \put(267,245){\vector(-1,-2){36}} \put(222,154){\vector(-1,-2){76}} \put(372,291){\circle{0}} \put(84,202){\circle{22}} \put(207,203){\circle{22}} \put(206,121){\circle{22}} \put(117,4){\makebox(22,24){$a$}} \put(73,144){\makebox(19,21){$b$}} \put(180,248){\makebox(22,25){$b$}} \put(249,106){\makebox(21,27){$c$}} \put(160,123){\makebox(16,25){$c$}} \put(111,181){\makebox(19,22){$d$}} \put(1,90){\makebox(21,24){$d$}} \put(116,124){\makebox(17,20){$e$}} \put(179,164){\makebox(14,17){$f$}} \put(244,177){\makebox(21,22){$f$}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{Unit Jones, Integer Fundamental Group} \label{f10} \end{figure} In fact the polynomial that we have computed is the same as the polynomial invariant of virtuals of Sawollek \cite{Saw} and defined by an alternative method by Silver and Williams \cite{SW} and, in a third way, by Manturov \cite{Ma3} and given a state sum formulation by Kauffman and Radford \cite{KR}. Sawollek defines a module structure essentially the same as our Alexander Biquandle. Silver and Williams first define a group. The Alexander Biquandle proceeds from taking the abelianization of the Silver-Williams group. Manturov uses the virtual quandle construction we shall describe in the next subsection.\vspace{3mm} We end this discussion of the Alexander Biquandle with two examples that show clearly its limitations. View Figure \ref{f11}. In this Figure we illustrate two diagrams labeled $K$ and $KI.$ It is not hard to calculate that both $G_{K}(s,t)$ and $G_{KI}(s,t)$ are equal to zero. However, The Alexander Biquandle of $K$ is non-trivial -- calculation shows that it is isomorphic to the free module over $Z[s, s^{-1},t, t^{-1}]$ generated by elements $a$ and $b$ subject to the relation $(s^{-1} - t -1)(a-b) =0.$ Thus $K$ represents a non-trivial virtual knot. This shows that it is possible for a non-trivial virtual diagram to be a connected sum of two trivial virtual diagrams, and it shows that the Alexander Biquandle can sometimes be more powerful than the polynomial invariant $G.$ However, the diagram $KI$ also has trivial Alexander Biquandle. This knot is proved to be knotted virtual by Kishino \cite{KS}, Bartholomew and Fenn \cite{BF}, Manturov \cite{Ma8}, Kadokami \cite{Kad}, Dye and Kauffman \cite{KaV4} and others (see also the first problem in \cite{FKM}. \bigbreak \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(272,368) \thicklines \put(243,64){\makebox(25,21){$KI$}} \put(244,260){\makebox(27,25){$K$}} \put(165,45){\line(-1,0){14}} \put(82,45){\line(1,0){58}} \put(163,123){\line(-1,0){14}} \put(82,123){\line(1,0){59}} \put(144,163){\line(0,-1){159}} \put(3,124){\line(1,-1){78}} \put(3,44){\line(1,1){78}} \put(163,124){\line(1,-1){79}} \put(163,44){\line(1,1){80}} \put(105,164){\line(0,-1){38}} \put(105,118){\line(0,-1){68}} \put(106,37){\line(0,-1){33}} \put(145,163){\line(5,-2){99}} \put(44,83){\circle{18}} \put(204,84){\circle{18}} \put(3,123){\line(5,2){103}} \put(2,45){\line(5,-2){105}} \put(146,5){\line(5,2){97}} \put(146,206){\line(5,2){97}} \put(2,246){\line(5,-2){105}} \put(3,324){\line(5,2){103}} \put(204,285){\circle{18}} \put(44,284){\circle{18}} \put(145,364){\line(5,-2){99}} \put(144,238){\line(0,-1){33}} \put(144,317){\line(0,-1){69}} \put(143,365){\line(0,-1){37}} \put(106,238){\line(0,-1){33}} \put(105,316){\line(0,-1){68}} \put(105,365){\line(0,-1){38}} \put(82,245){\line(1,0){81}} \put(82,324){\line(1,0){81}} \put(163,245){\line(1,1){80}} \put(163,325){\line(1,-1){79}} \put(3,245){\line(1,1){78}} \put(3,325){\line(1,-1){78}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{The Knot $K$ and the Kishino Diagram $KI$ } \label{f11} \end{figure} \subsection{Virtual Quandles} \begin{dfn} A {\em virtual quandle} is a quandle $(M,\circ)$ endowed with a unary operation $f$ such that: \begin{enumerate} \item $f$ is invertible, the inverse operation is denoted by $f^{-1}$; \item $\circ$ is distributive with respect to $f$: \begin{equation} \forall a,b\in M: f(a)\circ f(b)=f(a\circ b).\label{eqeq}\end{equation} \end{enumerate} \end{dfn} \begin{re} The equation \ref{eqeq} implies that for all $a,b\in M$: $$f^{-1}(a)\circ f^{-1}(b)=f^{-1}(a\circ b),$$ $$f(a)\bar \circ f(b)=f(a\bar \circ b),$$ and $$f^{-1}(a)\bar \circ f^{-1}(b)=f^{-1}(a\bar \circ b).$$ \end{re} Given a virtual link diagram $L$, we construct its virtual quandle $Q(L)$ as follows. We say that a diagram has {\em proper arcs} if there are no circles (circular arcs) in the diagram. See Figure 13. We can choose a diagram $L'$ in such a way that it is divided into long arcs in a proper way. (A long arc is an arc of the diagram that may contain virtual crossings.) Such diagrams are called {\em proper}. It is clear that a proper diagram with $m$ crossings has $m$ long arcs. We do need that each long arc has two different final crossing points. For some diagrams this is not true. However, this can be easily be accomplished by slight deformations of the diagram, see. Fig. \ref{deform} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \unitlength 1mm \linethickness{0.8pt} \begin{picture}(94.00,43.00) \put(26.67,14.33){\vector(1,1){0.2}} \bezier{56}(15.00,10.00)(23.33,9.67)(26.67,14.33) \bezier{100}(26.67,14.00)(35.00,19.00)(30.00,33.33) \bezier{72}(30.00,33.33)(23.00,39.67)(17.33,32.67) \bezier{92}(17.33,32.67)(11.33,25.00)(13.33,11.67) \bezier{16}(13.33,11.67)(13.33,9.67)(15.00,10.00) \bezier{52}(22.00,12.33)(18.00,16.67)(19.33,23.67) \bezier{60}(19.33,23.67)(21.33,31.00)(27.67,34.00) \bezier{96}(30.67,34.67)(38.00,36.33)(39.00,20.33) \put(24.33,10.33){\vector(-2,1){0.2}} \bezier{148}(39.00,21.67)(39.00,2.00)(24.33,10.33) \put(76.67,14.33){\vector(1,1){0.2}} \bezier{56}(65.00,10.00)(73.33,9.67)(76.67,14.33) \bezier{72}(80.00,33.33)(73.00,39.67)(67.33,32.67) \bezier{92}(67.33,32.67)(61.33,25.00)(63.33,11.67) \bezier{16}(63.33,11.67)(63.33,9.67)(65.00,10.00) \bezier{52}(72.00,12.33)(68.00,16.67)(69.33,23.67) \bezier{60}(69.33,23.67)(71.33,31.00)(77.67,34.00) \put(74.33,10.33){\vector(-2,1){0.2}} \bezier{148}(89.00,21.67)(89.00,2.00)(74.33,10.33) \bezier{80}(89.00,21.67)(89.00,36.67)(83.67,35.33) \bezier{16}(83.67,35.33)(81.67,36.00)(80.00,35.33) \bezier{52}(76.67,14.33)(80.33,18.67)(88.00,19.00) \bezier{32}(89.67,19.33)(94.00,20.00)(93.00,23.00) \bezier{20}(93.00,23.00)(91.33,26.33)(89.67,26.67) \bezier{44}(87.67,27.67)(82.33,29.33)(80.00,33.67) \put(51.33,22.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\stackrel{\Omega_2}{\to}$}} \put(22.67,38.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\downarrow$}} \put(22.67,43.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{circular long arc}} \put(77.33,40.33){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{normal diagram}} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{Reconstructing a link diagram in a proper way} \label{deform} \end{figure} \begin{dfn} An {\em arc} of $L'$ is an oriented interval in the diagram not containing undercrossings or virtual crossings. \end{dfn} \begin{ex} The knot shown in Fig. \ref{knotarcs} has 3 classical crossings, 3 arcs ($a_1$ and $a_2$; $b_1$ and $b_2$; $c$), and 5 virtual arcs ($a_{1},a_{2},b_{1},b_{2},c$). \end{ex} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \unitlength 1mm \linethickness{0.8pt} \begin{picture}(40.33,58.67) \put(30.00,17.33){\vector(1,2){0.2}} \bezier{108}(10.00,10.00)(26.00,7.00)(30.00,17.33) \bezier{52}(30.00,17.33)(28.67,25.00)(25.00,28.33) \bezier{64}(25.00,28.33)(16.67,33.67)(15.00,40.00) \bezier{36}(15.33,42.67)(14.67,47.33)(19.33,48.00) \bezier{60}(19.33,48.00)(27.00,47.33)(25.67,40.00) \bezier{36}(25.67,40.00)(24.00,36.00)(21.00,33.00) \bezier{60}(21.00,32.67)(16.00,26.33)(18.00,19.67) \bezier{44}(18.00,19.67)(19.00,13.67)(23.00,11.67) \bezier{52}(26.67,10.33)(35.00,10.00)(35.67,15.00) \bezier{152}(35.67,15.00)(40.33,38.33)(26.67,41.33) \bezier{56}(24.67,41.33)(17.00,42.00)(11.00,41.00) \bezier{72}(11.00,41.00)(4.67,38.00)(6.33,27.00) \bezier{76}(6.33,27.00)(5.33,14.67)(10.00,10.00) \put(20.33,31.67){\circle{2.00}} \put(29.33,24.67){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a_1$}} \put(25.67,36.67){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b_1$}} \put(0.00,158.67){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a_2$}} \put(15.33,35.67){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a_2$}} \put(15.67,20.33){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b_2$}} \put(38.67,20.33){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$c$}} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{A knot diagram and its arcs} \label{knotarcs} \end{figure} The invariant $Q(L)$ is now constructed as follows. Consider all arcs $a_{i},i=1,\dots, n$ of the diagram $L'$. Consider the set of formal words $X(L')$ obtained inductively from $a_{i}$ by using $\circ, \bar \circ, f, f^{-1}$. In order to construct $Q(L')$ we will factorize $X(L')$ by the equivalence relation generated by the general axioms shown below, plus the consequences of the specific relations incurred from the diagram. \bigbreak Axiomatically, for each $a,b,c\in X(L')$ we identify: $f^{-1}(f(a))\sim f(f^{-1}(a))\sim a$; $(a\circ b)\bar \circ b\sim a$; $(a\bar \circ b)\circ b\sim a$; $a\sim a\circ a$; $(a\circ b)\circ c\sim (a\circ c)\circ (b\circ c)$; $f(a\circ b)\sim f(a)\circ f(b)$. \bigbreak With the equivalence generated by these axioms, we get a ``free" virtual quandle with generators $a_{1},\dots, a_{n}$. We then add the extra equivalences from the structure of $L':$ \bigbreak For each classical crossing we write the relation (\ref{clasrel}) just as in the classical case. For each virtual crossing $V$ we also write relations. Let $a_{j_1},a_{j_2},a_{j_3},a_{j_4}$ be the four arcs incident to $V$ as it is shown in Fig. \ref{virtcross}. \begin{figure} \begin{center} \unitlength 0.6mm \begin{picture}(50,50) \put(5,5){\vector(1,1){40}} \put(45,5){\vector(-1,1){40}} \put(25,25){\circle{3}} \put(5,2){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{\tiny{$a_{j_1}$}}} \put(45,2){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{\tiny{$a_{j_4}$}}} \put(10,48){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{\tiny{$a_{j_3}=f^{-1}({a_{j_2}})$}}} \put(45,48){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{\tiny{$a_{j_2}=f(a_{j_1})$}}} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{Relation for a virtual crossing} \label{virtcross} \end{figure} Then, let us write the relations: \begin{equation} a_{j_2}= f(a_{j_1}) \label{former2}\end{equation} and \begin{equation} a_{j_3}=f(a_{j_4}) \label{former3}\end{equation} So, the virtual quandle $Q(L)$ is the quandle, generated by all arcs $a_{i},i=1,\dots, n$, all linear relations at classical vertices and all relations (\ref{former2},\ref{former3}) at virtual vertices. \begin{th}\label{INV} The quandle $Q(L)$ is a link invariant. \end{th} \begin{proof} First, note that two proper diagrams generate isotopic virtual links if and only if one can be deformed to the other by using a sequence of virtual Reidemeister. Indeed, if while isotopy a circular long link occurs, we can modify the isotopy by applying the first classical Reidemeister move to this long arc and subdividing it into two parts. We have to show that $Q(L)$ is invariant under virtual Reidemeister moves. The invariance of $Q(L)$ under all classical moves is checked in the same way as that of the ordinary quandle. Let us check now the invariance of $Q$ under purely virtual Reidemeister moves. The first virtual Reidemeister move is shown in Fig. \ref{1move}. In the initial local picture we have one local generator $a$. Here we just add a new generator $b$ and two coinciding relations: $b=f(a)$. Thus, it does not change the virtual quandle at all. \begin{figure} \unitlength 0.4mm \begin{center} \begin{picture}(100,55) \thicklines \put(10,10){\line(0,1){30}} \put(40,40){\vector(0,-1){30}} \put(25,40){\oval(30,20)[t]} \put(25,45){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(50,25){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\longrightarrow$}} \put(60,10){\line(1,1){30}} \put(60,40){\vector(1,-1){30}} \put(75,40){\oval(30,20)[t]} \put(75,25){\circle{4}} \put(55,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(75,45){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \put(95,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{Invariance of $Q$ under the $1$--st virtual move} \label{1move} \end{figure} The case of inverse orientation at the crossings gives us $b=f^{-1}(a)$ that does not change the situation. For each next relation, we will check only one case of arc orientation. The second move (see Fig. \ref{2move}) adds two generators $c$ and $d$ and two pairs of coinciding relations: $c=f(a),d=f^{-1}(b)$. Thus, the quandle $Q$ stays the same. \begin{figure} \begin{center} \begin{picture}(100,100) \put(10,10){\vector(0,1){80}} \put(40,10){\vector(0,1){80}} \put(5,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(45,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \put(50,65){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\longrightarrow$}} \put(60,10){\line(3,4){30}} \put(90,10){\line(-3,4){30}} \put(60,50){\vector(3,4){30}} \put(90,50){\vector(-3,4){30}} \put(75,30){\circle{4}} \put(75,70){\circle{4}} \put(55,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(95,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \put(55,55){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$d$}} \put(95,55){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$c$}} \put(55,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(95,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{Invariance of $Q$ under the $2$--nd virtual move} \label{2move} \end{figure} In the case of the third Reidemeister move we have six ``exterior arcs'': three incoming $(a,b,c)$ and three outgoing $(p,q,r)$, see Fig. \ref{3move}. In both cases we have $p=f^{2}(a),q=b,r=f^{-2}(c)$. The three interior arcs are expressed in $a,b,c$, and give no other relations. \begin{figure} \begin{center} \begin{picture}(200,100) \put(50,10){\vector(0,1){80}} \put(10,50){\vector(1,0){80}} \put(10,10){\line(2,1){40}} \put(50,30){\line(1,1){20}} \put(70,50){\vector(1,2){20}} \put(50,50){\circle{4}} \put(50,30){\circle{4}} \put(70,50){\circle{4}} \put(5,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(5,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \put(50,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$c$}} \put(95,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$p$}} \put(95,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$q$}} \put(50,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$r$}} \put(100,60){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\longrightarrow$}} \put(150,10){\vector(0,1){80}} \put(110,50){\vector(1,0){80}} \put(110,10){\line(1,2){20}} \put(130,50){\line(1,1){20}} \put(150,70){\vector(2,1){40}} \put(150,50){\circle{4}} \put(130,50){\circle{4}} \put(150,70){\circle{4}} \put(105,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(105,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \put(150,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$c$}} \put(195,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$p$}} \put(195,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$q$}} \put(150,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$r$}} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{Invariance of $Q$ under the $3$--rd virtual move} \label{3move} \end{figure} Finally, let us check the mixed move. We will check the only version of it, see Fig. \ref{mixed} \begin{figure} \begin{center} \begin{picture}(200,100) \put(50,10){\line(0,1){38}} \put(50,52){\vector(0,1){38}} \put(10,50){\vector(1,0){80}} \put(10,10){\line(2,1){40}} \put(50,30){\line(1,1){20}} \put(70,50){\vector(1,2){20}} \put(50,30){\circle{4}} \put(70,50){\circle{4}} \put(5,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(5,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \put(50,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$c$}} \put(95,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$p$}} \put(95,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$q$}} \put(50,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$r$}} \put(100,60){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\longrightarrow$}} \put(150,10){\line(0,1){38}} \put(150,52){\vector(0,1){38}} \put(110,50){\vector(1,0){80}} \put(110,10){\line(1,2){20}} \put(130,50){\line(1,1){20}} \put(150,70){\vector(2,1){40}} \put(130,50){\circle{4}} \put(150,70){\circle{4}} \put(105,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$a$}} \put(105,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$b$}} \put(150,5){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$c$}} \put(195,50){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$p$}} \put(195,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$q$}} \put(150,95){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$r$}} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{Invariance of $Q$ under the mixed move} \label{mixed} \end{figure} In both pictures we have three incoming edges $a,b,c$ and three outgoing edges $p,q,r$. In the first case we have relations: $p=f(a),q=b,r=f^{-1}(c)\circ a$. In the second case we have: $p=f(a), q=b, r=f^{-1}(c\circ f(a))$. The distributivity relation $f(x\circ y)=f(x)\circ f(y)$ implies $f^{-1}(c)\circ a=f^{-1}(c\circ f(a))$. Hence, two virtual quandles before the mixed move and after the mixed move coincide. The other cases of the mixed move lead to other relations all equivalent to $f(x\circ y)=f(x)\circ f(y)$. This completes the proof of the theorem. \end{proof} This leads to a construction of a polynomial invariant (the ``easier'' part of the paper \cite{Ma3}). First, we take $a\circ b$ to be $ta+(1-t)b$ and $f(a)$ to be $sa$, where $t$ and $s$ are independent commuting variables. After this, the normalized determinant of this matrix gives an invariant. It was proved recently by R.Fenn (considering virtual knots as closures of virtual braids, this idea was inspirated by H.Morton) that this polynomial in fact coincides with that proposed by Sawollek and Silver-Williams and that coming from the Alexander biquandle (up to a variable change) as discussed by Kauffman and Radford. Fenn's method also proves that we get nothing new if we try to use the linear biquandle structure at classical crossing and linear automorphism $f$ at virtual crossings. In the present paper, we will construct a more general invariant in section \ref{sec} (which works for the case of colored links). \subsection{Jones polynomial for virtual knots \\ and involutory quandles} We use a generalization of the bracket state summation model for the Jones polynomial to extend it to virtual knots and links. We call a diagram in the plane {\em purely virtual} if the only crossings in the diagram are virtual crossings. Each purely virtual diagram is equaivalent by the virtual moves to a disjoint collection of circles in the plane. Given a link diagram $K$, a state $S$ of this diagram is obtained by choosing a smoothing for each crossing in the diagram and labelling that smoothing with either $A$ or $A^{-1}$ according to the convention that a counterclockwise rotation of the overcrossing line sweeps two regions labelled $A$, and that a smoothing that connects the $A$ regions is labelled by the letter $A$, or, diagrammatically, see Fig. \ref{kf} \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=300pt]{kf.eps} \label{kf} \caption{} \end{figure} Then, given a state $S$, one has the evaluation $\langle K|S\rangle$ equal to the product of the labels at the smoothings, and one has the evaluation $||S||$ equal to the number of loops in the state (the smoothings produce purely virtual diagrams). One then has the formula \begin{equation} \langle K\rangle = \Sigma_{S}\langle K|S\rangle d^{||S||-1},\label{frm1} \end{equation} where the summation runs over the states $S$ of the diagram $K$, and $d = -A^{2} - A^{-2}.$ This state summation is invariant under all classical and virtual moves except the first Reidemeister move. The bracket polynomial is normalized to an invariant $f_{K}(A)$ of all the moves by the formula $f_{K}(A) = (-A^{3})^{-w(K)}\langle K\rangle$ where $w(K)$ is the writhe of the (now) oriented diagram $K$. The writhe is the sum of the orientation signs ($\pm 1)$ of the crossings of the diagram. The Jones polynomial, $V_{K}(t)$ is given in terms of this model by the formula \begin{equation} V_{K}(t) = f_{K}(t^{-1/4}).\label{frm2}\end{equation} The reader should note that this definition is a direct generalization to the virtual category of the state sum model for the original Jones polynomial. It is straightforward to verify the invariances stated above. In this way one has the Jones polynomial for virtual knots and links, see \cite{KaV}. In terms of the interpretation of virtual knots as stabilized classes of embeddings of circles into thickened surfaces, our definition coincides with the simplest version of the Jones polynomial for links in thickened surfaces. In that version one counts all the loops in a state the same way, with no regard for their isotopy class in the surface. It is this equal treatment that makes the invariance under handle stabilization work. With this generalized version of the Jones polynomial, one has again the problem of finding a geometric/topological interpretation of this invariant. There is no fully satisfactory topological interpretation of the original Jones polynomial and the problem is inherited by this generalization. \bigbreak In \cite{KaV2}, the following theorem was proved. \begin{th} To each non-trivial classical knot diagram of one component $K$ there is a corresponding non-trivial virtual knot diagram $Virt(K)$ with unit Jones polynomial. \end{th} This Theorem is a key ingredient in the problems involving virtual knots. Here is a sketch of its proof. The proof uses two invariants of classical knots and links that generalize to arbitrary virtual knots and links. These invariants are the {\em Jones polynomial} and the {\em involutory quandle} denoted by the notation $IQ(K)$ for a knot or link $K.$ Given a crossing $i$ in a link diagram, we define $s(i)$ to be the result of {\em switching} that crossing so that the undercrossing arc becomes an overcrossing arc and vice versa. We also define the {\em virtualization} $v(i)$ of the crossing by the local replacement indicated in Figure \ref{fj3}. In this Figure we illustrate how in the virtualization of the crossing the original crossing is replaced by a crossing that is flanked by two virtual crossings. \bigbreak Suppose that $K$ is a (virtual or classical) diagram with a classical crossing labelled $i.$ Let $K^{v(i)}$ be the diagram obtained from $K$ by virtualizing the crossing $i$ while leaving the rest of the diagram just as before. Let $K^{s(i)}$ be the diagram obtained from $K$ by switching the crossing $i$ while leaving the rest of the diagram just as before. Then it follows directly from the definition of the Jones polynomial that $$V_{K^{s(i)}}(t) = V_{K^{v(i)}}(t).$$ \noindent As far as the Jones polynomial is concerned, switching a crossing and virtualizing a crossing look the same. \bigbreak The involutory quandle \cite{KNOTS} is an algebraic invariant equivalent to the fundamental group of the double branched cover of a knot or link in the classical case. In this algebraic system one associates a generator of the algebra $IQ(K)$ to each arc of the diagram $K$ and there is a relation of the form $c = ab$ at each crossing, where $ab$ denotes the (non-associative) algebra product of $a$ and $b$ in $IQ(K).$ See Figure \ref{fj4}. In this Figure we have illustrated through the local relations the fact that $$IQ(K^{v(i)}) = IQ(K).$$ \noindent As far the involutory quandle is concerned, the original crossing and the virtualized crossing look the same. \bigbreak If a classical knot is actually knotted, then its involutory quandle is non-trivial \cite{W}. Hence if we start with a non-trivial classical knot, we can virtualize any subset of its crossings to obtain a virtual knot that is still non-trivial. There is a subset $A$ of the crossings of a classical knot $K$ such that the knot $SK$ obtained by switching these crossings is an unknot. Let $Virt(K)$ denote the virtual diagram obtained from $A$ by virtualizing the crossings in the subset $A.$ By the above discussion the Jones polynomial of $Virt(K)$ is the same as the Jones polynomial of $SK$, and this is $1$ since $SK$ is unknotted. On the other hand, the $IQ$ of $Virt(K)$ is the same as the $IQ$ of $K$, and hence if $K$ is knotted, then so is $Virt(K).$ We have shown that $Virt(K)$ is a non-trivial virtual knot with unit Jones polynomial. This completes the proof of the Theorem. \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(326,162) \thinlines \put(190,141){\line(0,-1){82}} \put(242,34){\makebox(41,41){s(i)}} \put(170,10){\makebox(41,41){v(i)}} \put(1,35){\makebox(41,42){i}} \put(292,81){\line(1,0){33}} \put(246,81){\line(1,0){35}} \put(286,161){\line(0,-1){160}} \put(143,81){\circle{16}} \put(191,80){\circle{16}} \put(190,59){\line(-1,0){25}} \put(167,22){\line(0,-1){20}} \put(144,22){\line(1,0){22}} \put(143,102){\line(0,-1){80}} \put(165,103){\line(-1,0){22}} \put(165,87){\line(0,1){15}} \put(165,59){\line(0,1){17}} \put(167,141){\line(1,0){23}} \put(166,161){\line(0,-1){20}} \put(126,81){\line(1,0){80}} \put(46,74){\line(0,-1){73}} \put(46,161){\line(0,-1){74}} \put(6,81){\line(1,0){80}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{Switching and Virtualizing a Crossing} \label{fj3} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \begin{center} {\ttorg \obeyspaces \setlength{\unitlength}{0.92pt} \begin{picture}(214,164) \thinlines \put(197,64){\makebox(16,16){b}} \put(136,144){\makebox(22,18){c =}} \put(17,143){\makebox(22,18){c =}} \put(165,143){\makebox(19,20){ab}} \put(113,64){\makebox(16,16){b}} \put(67,64){\makebox(16,16){b}} \put(43,1){\makebox(17,19){a}} \put(47,142){\makebox(19,20){ab}} \put(1,63){\makebox(16,16){b}} \put(165,1){\makebox(17,19){a}} \put(185,142){\line(0,-1){82}} \put(138,82){\circle{16}} \put(186,81){\circle{16}} \put(185,60){\line(-1,0){25}} \put(162,23){\line(0,-1){20}} \put(139,23){\line(1,0){22}} \put(138,103){\line(0,-1){80}} \put(160,104){\line(-1,0){22}} \put(160,88){\line(0,1){15}} \put(160,60){\line(0,1){17}} \put(162,142){\line(1,0){23}} \put(161,162){\line(0,-1){20}} \put(121,82){\line(1,0){80}} \put(41,75){\line(0,-1){73}} \put(41,162){\line(0,-1){74}} \put(1,82){\line(1,0){80}} \end{picture}} \end{center} \caption{$IQ(Virt(K)) = IQ(K)$} \label{fj4} \end{figure} If there exists a classical knot with unit Jones polynomial, then one of the knots $Virt(K)$ produced by this Theorem may be equivalent to a classical knot. It is an intricate task to verify that specific examples of $Virt(K)$ are not classical; very special partial case was considered in \cite{SW2}. This has led to an investigation of new invariants for virtual knots. In this investigation a number of issues appear. One can examine the combinatorial generalization of the fundamental group (or quandle) of the virtual knot and sometimes one can prove by pure algebra that the resulting group is not classical. This is related to observations by Silver and Williams \cite{SW}, Manturov \cite{Ma6,Ma8} and by Satoh \cite{Satoh} showing that the fundamental group of a virtual knot can be interpreted as the fundamental group of the complement of a torus embedded in four dimensional Euclidean space. A very fruitful line of new invariants comes about by examining the biquandles and virtual quandles. Flat virtual diagrams are seldom trivial. If we can verify that the flat knot $F(Virt(K))$ is non-trivial, then $Virt(K)$ is non-classical. In this way the search for classical knots with unit Jones polynomial expands to the exploration of the structure of the infinite collection of virtual knots with unit Jones polynomial, for a detailed description of this problem, see \cite{FKM}. Another way of putting this Theorem is as follows: In the arena of knots in thickened surfaces there are many examples of knots with unit Jones polynomial. Might one of these be equivalent via handle stabilization to a classical knot? In \cite{KUP} Kuperberg shows the uniqueness of the embedding of minimal genus in the stable class for a given virtual link. The minimal embedding genus can be strictly less than the number of virtual crossings in a diagram for the link. There are many problems associated with this phenomenon. There are generalizations of the Jones polynomial that involve the surface representation of virtual knots. To begin with, one can keep track of the isotopy classes of the curves in the state expansion of the bracket polynomial for a knot embedded in a surface. This gives a surface bracket polynomial \cite{KaV4} that can be used in tandem with Kuperberg's results \cite{KUP} to determine the minimal surface embedding genus for some virtual knots and links. In \cite{KaV4} this method is used to show that the Kishino diagram has genus two. Another approach \cite{Ma8} uses a relative of the surface bracket polynomial, and includes in the equivalence relation of the curves in the states, the stabilization of the surfaces themselves. In this way the Manturov invariant is an becomes an element of a module over the Laurent polynomial ring in one variable, and is strictly stronger than the original extension of the Jones polynomial to virtuals. We do not yet know the relative strengths of these two methods. \bigbreak \subsection{A Common Construction --- \\ The Virtual Biquandle} Consider an oriented virtual link diagram $L$ and divide it into arcs. Write down the biquandle relations at each classical crossing, and write down the virtual quandle relation at each virtual crossing. The full list of operations and axioms for this object, {\em the virtual biquandle} (making this related algebra an invariant of virtual knots and links) is as follows: \begin{enumerate} \item We have operations $\UR{}\;,\LR{}\;,\UL{}\;,\LL{}$ as above and the invertible operation $f$ acting on the whole algebra. \item Biquandle operations satisfy all conditions described previously. \item The operation $f$ ia a biquandle automorphism. Thus, for instance, $f(a\UR{b})=f(a)\UR{f(b)}$; the same statements are true for for $\LR{~},\UL{~},\LL{~}$. \end{enumerate} The object defined in this manner is called {\em the virtual biquandle of the link}. Now, we consider a larger context, admitting more general constructions at virtual crossings. Let us now give the definition of the {\em formal virtual biquandle} as some algebraic object satisfying certain axioms; in the same lines, we shall define the virtual biquandle of a link by interpreting the biquandle operations according to the crossing structure. Let us now write down the axioms in the general case, when virtual crossings are endowed with binary operations, $a.b$ and $b|a$, see Fig. \ref{bll}. \begin{figure} \unitlength 1.8pt \begin{center} \begin{picture}(50,50) \put(5,5){\vector(1,1){40}} \put(45,5){\vector(-1,1){40}} \put(25,25){\circle{3}} \put(0,0){a} \put(50,0){b} \put(50,50){a.b}\put(0,50){b|a} \end{picture} \end{center} \caption{Binary relation at a virtual crossing} \label{bll} \end{figure} The axioms for the classical case are the same as above. The axioms for purely virtual moves are: \begin{enumerate} \item The first Reidemeister move, see Fig. \ref{FRM} \begin{equation}\forall a\; \exists x: \left\{\begin{array}{c}x.a=a \cr a|x=x\end{array}\right. \end{equation} \begin{equation} \forall a\; \exists y: \left\{\begin{array}{c}a.y=y \cr y|a=a\end{array}\right. \end{equation} \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=200pt]{1rmm.eps} \caption{Relations coming from the first virtual move} \label{FRM} \end{figure} \item The second oriented Reidemeister move, see Fig. \ref{SORM}.1. \begin{equation} \forall a,b: (a.b)|(b|a)=a\mbox{ and } (b|a).(a.b)=b\end{equation} The second unoriented Reidemeister moves, see Fig. \ref{SORM}.2, \ref{SORM}.3. \begin{equation} \left\{\begin{array}{c} \forall a,b:\exists! x: b|(a|x)=x;(a|x).b=a;\cr \forall a,b:\exists! y: (y|b)=a; (b.y)|a=b. \end{array} \right. \end{equation} \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=300pt]{2rmm.eps} \caption{Relations coming from the second virtual move} \label{SORM} \end{figure} \item The third Reidemeister move, see Fig. \ref{TRM} (upper and lower pictures). The two cases are: \begin{equation} \forall a,b,c: \left\{\begin{array}{c} (a.b).c=(a.(c|b)).(b.c)\cr (b|a).(c|(a.b))=(b.c)|(a.(c|b)) \cr (c|(a.b))|(b|a)=(c|b)|a \end{array} \right. \end{equation} and \begin{equation} \forall a,b,c: \exists! x,y: \left\{\begin{array}{c} (c|(b|(a|x)))=x;\cr b.(c.(a.y))=y; \cr (a|x).b=(a.y)|c;\cr y|a=(b|(a|x)).c;\cr x.a=(c.(a.y))|b.\end{array}\right. \end{equation} \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=300pt]{3rmm.eps} \caption{Relations coming from the third virtual move} \label{TRM} \end{figure} \end{enumerate} \begin{re} In Figs. \ref{SORM} and \ref{TRM} we label only some arcs; all other arcs can be labelled according to the rule shown in Fig. \ref{bll}. \end{re} For the semivirtual move we have the following pictures in Fig. \ref{MM} and relations: \begin{equation} \forall a,b,c: \left\{\begin{array}{c} (a\UR{b})|c=(a|(c.b))\UR{b|c};\cr (b\LR{a})|(c.(a\UR{b})=(b|c)\LR{a|(c.b)};\cr c.(a\UR{b}).(b\LR{a})=(c.b).a \end{array}\right. \end{equation} and \begin{equation} \forall a,b,c: \exists! x,y:\left\{\begin{array}{c} (b|(a\LL{x})).c=x ;\cr a.(b.(c\LR{y}))=y;\cr (a\LL{x}).b=y\LL{c};\cr c|(b|(a\LL{x}))=(b.(c\UL{y}))|a ;\cr x\UL{a}=(c\UL{y})|b \end{array}\right. \end{equation} \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=300pt]{mm.eps} \caption{Relations coming from the mixed move} \label{MM} \end{figure} The proof is trivial by design. It is left to the reader. This common structure should have a lot of realizations. We indicate one of them in the following section. \section{Presentations} In this section, we will describe several explicit constructions of the virtual quandle and biquandle invariants described above, using specific algebraic structures for the representation. \subsection{A presentation for virtual biquandles} Virtual biquandles admit the following linear representation: at classical crossings we have the Alexander biquandle operations (with generators $t,s$) and set $(a.b)=(1+q b)a; (b'a)=(1-q a)b$ for some new generator $q$ that commutes with $t,s$ such that $q^{2}=(t-1)q=(s-1)q=0$. We are going to investigate other models of the virtual biquandle with binary operations at virtual crossings. We shall discuss other presentations of the virtual biquandle construction in our further publications. Later in this section, we deal with long quandles, virtual quandles, and some generalizations of them. \subsection{Formal Power Functions and Conjugation} For the virtual quandles, one can take a group together with the following two possible operations: \begin{enumerate} \item $a\circ b= b^{n}ab^{-n},$ $f(a)=qaq^{-1}$, where $q$ is a new generator for this group, and $n$ is an integer. \item $a\circ b=ba^{-1}b$, $f(a)=qaq^{-1}$ or $f(a)=qa^{-1}q$, where $q$ is a new generator for the group. \end{enumerate} In this way, we associate a group to each virtual knot in two possible ways. One can also associate a finite group $G$ with the virtual quandle operations defined as above, and look at the set of all maps $\Gamma(L)\to G$, where $\Gamma(L)$ is the virtual knot quandle, and $G$ is a finite virtual quandle. The set of such mappings is finite for any finite group (we can fix the images of generators of the quandle thus defining the map completely), so the number of ``colorings'', i.e., mappings, is finite and invariant under generalised Reidemeister moves, for more details see \cite{Ma2}. These ideas can also be used for the case of biquandles and virtual biquandles. More precisely, one can say the following: if we have an abstract knot invariant ${\cal G}$ constructed according to some axioms (quandle, virtual quandle or biquandle) and a finite object $G$ satisfying the same axioms, then the cardinality of the set of mappings ${\cal G}(L)\to G$ is a knot invariant. Thus there is a way to search for finite--valued invariants (colorings) by finding {\bf finite} sets satisfying such axioms. \subsection{The Quaternionic biquandle} It turns out that there are beautiful, explicit biquandle constructions that give powerful results. One class of such constructions come from the quaternions. This idea and the following formulae are due to R.A. Fenn and A. Bartholomew \cite{BF}. The quaternionic biquandle is defined by the following operations where $i^2 = j^2 = k^{2} = ijk = -1, ij = -ji = k,jk = -kj = i, ki = -ik =j$ in the associative, non-commutative algebra of the quaternions. The elements $a,b, \cdots$ are in a module over the ring of integer quaternions. $$a \UR{b}=j\cdot a+ (1+i)\cdot b,$$ $$a \LR{b}=-j\cdot a+ (1+i)\cdot b,$$ $$a \UL{b}=j\cdot a+ (1-i) \cdot b,$$ $$a \LL{b}=-j\cdot a+ (1-i)\cdot b.$$ Amazingly, one can verify that these operations satisfy the axioms for the biquandle. For more about quaternionic and other non-commutative buquandles, see \cite{BuF}. \bigbreak Let us look at what happens with the Kishino knot (see labeling shown in Fig. \ref{Ksl}. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=180pt]{lbl.eps} \caption{The Kishino knot} \label{Ksl} \end{figure} Let us first consider the rightmost crossings (that deal with arcs a,b,c). We have: $$c\LR{a}=-j\cdot c+(1+i)a; a\UR{c}=j\cdot a+(1+i)\cdot c.$$ Now, $$a\UR{c} \, \LL{c \, \LR{a}} = c \, \mbox{ and } c \, \LR{a} \, \UL{a \, \UR{c}} = b$$ give us \begin{equation} b=j(-jc+(1+i)a)+(1-i)(ja+(1+i)c)=3c+2(j-k)a;\label{form4}\end{equation} \begin{equation} c=-j(ja+(1+i)c)+(1-i)(-jc+(1+i)a)=3a-2(j-k)c.\label{form5}\end{equation} It follows that $3a=3b$. Now, let us write the relations for the left crossings. We have: $$b\LL{d}=-jb+(1-i)d; d\UL{b}=jd+(1-i)b.$$ Now, $$d \, \UL{b} \, \LR{b \, \LL{d}} = a \, \mbox{ and } b \, \LL{d} \, \UR{d \, \UL{b}} = d.$$ So, \begin{equation}a= -j(jd+(1-i)b)+(1+i)(-jb+(1-i)d)=3d-2(j+k)b\label{form6}\end{equation} \begin{equation}d= j (-jb+(1-i)d) +(1+i)(jd+(1-i)b)=3b+2(j+k)d\label{form7}\end{equation} From these equations we can also conclude that $3a=3b$. Let us show that the module we get is not just the module generated by $a$ where $a=b$. Indeed, by tensoring the above equations with ${\bf Z}_{3}$, we get: $b=2(j-k)a, c=-2(j-k)c;a=-2(j+k)b; d=2(j+k)d$. Thus, $b$ is out of picture, and we get: $c=-2(j-k)c; a=2 i a; d=2(j+k)d$. But this implies $(1-2i)a=0$ from which we deduce $2a=5a=(1+2i)(1-2i)a=0$, whence $a=0$. Thus we are left with $c=2(j-k)c, d=2(j+k)d$ and this is certainly a non-trivial module over ${\bf Z}_{3}$. Thus, this linear biquandle is not isomorphic to the free one--dimensional linear space over integer quaternions. From this we conclude that the Kishino diagram is a non-trivial virtual knot. The proof given above is a simplification of the method used by Fenn and Bartholomew. In any case, this proof is perhaps the most direct verification for the detection of the Kishino diagram! \bigbreak \section{Infinite-dimensional Lie algebras} Here we propose one new method to obtain quandles, biquandles, virtual quandles, etc, see \cite{Ma4}. For simplicity, we will deal with quandles. We know that quandles can be well defined on discrete groups by putting, say, $a\circ b=bab^{-1}$. The question is: is it possible to arrange a quandle operation which would act on a geometric group (Lie group)? Well, each of the relations \begin{equation} \left\{\begin{array}{ccc} a\circ b &=& bab^{-1}\cr a\circ b &=&b^{n}a b^{-n} \cr a\circ b & = & ba^{-1} b \end{array}\right.\label{qrela} \end{equation} works well in \underline{any} group (i.e. satisfies all the quandle axioms), but what we actually want to do is to construct a group by generators and relations. This problem for geometrical groups is quite difficult, so we may imagine we already have a group with such an operation, and this group $G$ is good, it is a Lie group. Thinking in this way, we see that this group should have the corresponding Lie algebra $\mathfrak{g}$ (which \underline{can} in fact be constructed by using generators and relations), and the group is connected with the algebra by the exponential mapping $exp: {\mathfrak{g}}\to G$. So, it would be nice to understand the quandle relations of type (\ref{qrela}), say, the relation $a\circ b=bab^{-1}$. In the algebra, this relation would be \begin{equation} {\mathfrak{a}}\circ{\mathfrak{b}}=log(exp({\mathfrak{a}})exp({\mathfrak{b}})exp({\mathfrak{c}})),\label{algrel}\end{equation} where $log$ is the inverse operation $G\to {\mathfrak{g}}$ to the exponential map (more precisely, this operation is defined in the vicinity of the group unit, however, we will operate with formulae and look what happens). It turns out, that the operation $a,b\mapsto log(exp(a)exp(b))$ can be defined in terms of the Lie algebra, i.e., it can be expressed in commutators. The required statement is called the {\em Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff} theorem, and the coefficients are given by a beautiful formula due to Dynkin \cite{Dyn}. \begin{equation} ln(e^{x}e^{y})\sum\frac{(-1)^{k-1}}{k}\frac{1}{{p_1}!{q_1}!\dots {p_k}!{q_k}!} (x^{p_1}y^{q_1}\dots x^{p_k}y^{q_k})^{o},\label{BKH} \end{equation} where $p_{i}q_{i}>0$ for $i\le k$; here the function ${\cdot}^{\circ}$ is defined on formal non-commutative monomials in variables $x_{j}$ by the rule \begin{equation} (x_{i_1}x_{i_2}\dots x_{i_k})^{\circ}=\frac{1}{k}[\dots[[x_{i_1},x_{i_2}],x_{i_3}],\dots,x_{i_k}]\end{equation} and extended linearly for their linear combinations. Thus, for any classical (or virtual) link $L$ we construct an infinite-dimensional Lie algebra $Li(L)$ as follows (All this can be done, if we, for instance, take into account virtual crossings as well; we can just add a new generator ${\mathfrak {q}}$ and define $f({\mathfrak{a}})=log(exp({\mathfrak{q}})exp({\mathfrak{a}})exp(-{\mathfrak{q}}))$. We take its arcs as generators of the free infinite-dimensional Lie algebra, and factorize the resulting algebra subject to the relations (\ref{algrel}) taking into account the formula (\ref{BKH}).) The obtained infinite-dimensional Lie algebra is a link invariant is not the most pleasant to work with, however, it admits a simplification. Thus, for instance, we can take just $a\circ b= a+[a,b]$. Decree $a\circ b$ to be $a+[a,b]$ (actually, one should take $a-[a,b]$, but we choose this operation for simplicity). Then, the first axiom holds by definition: $[a,a]=a+0=a$. As for the second axiom, the reverse operation exists by the formula $a\bar \circ b=a-[a,b]+[[a,b],b]-[[[a,b],b],b]+\dots$ without worrying a lot whether this formula converges. Even if it has infinitely many members, we can write all in the finite manner: namely, instead of writing $p\bar \circ q=r$, we write $r\circ q=p$. There is another way to handle the situation: we put $a\circ b=a+\varepsilon[a,b]$, where $\varepsilon$ is just a new generator in the basic ring. In this case there would be no problem with convergence. Now, for the third relation we need $$(a\circ b)\circ c=(a\circ c)\circ (b\circ c).$$ So, we have the relation $$a+[a,b]+[a,c]+[[a,b],c]=a+[a,c]+[a,b]+[a,[b,c]]+[[a,c],[b,c]]+[[a,b],b]$$ in any of these cases, with or without $\varepsilon$. Taking into account the Jacobi identity, we see that the equation above is equivalent to $$[[a,c],[b,c]]=0.$$ This means that we must factorize only by third (not second!) commutators of the form $[[a,c],[b,c]]$. Thus, we should not cut our series at some finite place. This leads to some interesting results. Denote the obtained invariant (with $a\circ b = a+\varepsilon[a,b]$ at classical crossings and no structure at virtual crossings) by $Li(K)$ Moreover, this idea together with the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula lead to many other realizations and models for quandles. Having this approach, one may search for particular representations which certainly lead to new invariants of classical and virtual knots. Let us consider the $Li(K)$ invariant (without any structure at virtual crossings). For instance, the trefoil and the figure eight knot gives us an finite-dimensional Lie algebra, whence the (5,2)-torus knot Lie algebra is finite-dimensional. Indeed, for the trefoil, we have three arcs $a,b,c$ and three vertices where we have to write down the commutators. Obviously, we get $a+\varepsilon[a,b]=c$ and two other relations obtained by permuting this one cyclically. Thus, we can express all first commutators as linear combinations of generators. So, this algebra can not be infinite-dimensional. For the figure eight knot, we have four arcs and three commutators, one of them is expressed twice. Namely, view Figure \ref{fig8}. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=180pt]{figgeight.eps} \caption{The labelled figure eight knot} \label{fig8} \end{figure} We see that the first crossing gives us $d\circ c=a$, the second one gives $b\circ d=a$, the third one gives $b\circ a=c$, and the fourth one gives $d\circ b=c$. So, we have expressions for three of six commutators. Thus we have: $\varepsilon[b,d]=a-b,\varepsilon[d,b]=c-d$, which easily leads to the finite-dimensionality of the algebra. However, if we take the $(5,2)$-torus knot, we have five generators $a_{1},a_{2},a_{3},a_{4},a_{5}$ and five cyclic relations $\varepsilon[a_{1},a_{2}]=a_{3}-a_{1}, \varepsilon[a_{2},a_{3}]=a_{4}-a_{2}, \varepsilon[a_{3},a_{4}]=a_{5}-a_{3}, \varepsilon[a_{4},a_{5}]=a_{1}-a_{4}, \varepsilon[a_{5},a_{1}]=a_{2}-a_{5}$, see Fig. \ref{a5}. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=150pt]{a5.eps} \caption{The torus (5,2) knot} \label{a5} \end{figure} The commutator $[a_{1},a_{3}]$ is not expressible in the terms of linear combinations of $a_{i}$'s. It is also easy to show that the elements $a_{1},([a_{1},a_{3}]),[[a_{1},a_{3}],a_{3}],[[[a_{1},a_{3}],a_{3}],a_{3}]$ represent linearly independent elements. Thus, we obtain a finite-dimensional algebra. \section{Colored virtual links \\ and their invariants} \label{sec} It is not difficult to show that the virtual quandle construction generalizes for the case of colored links. We will not write down all the axioms for the multicomponent virtual quandle, we are just going to represent one linear model for oriented virtual links. Here we give a generalization of the work by Manturov initiated in \cite{Ma7,Ma9}. Namely, consider an $n$-component link $L$. Let us fix $n$ generators $t_{1},\dots, t_{n}$ and $n$ generators $s_{1},\dots, s_{n}$. We are going to associate elements of module over ${\bf Z}[s_{1},\dots, s_{n},t_{1},\dots, t_{n}]$ to the arcs of the diagram, whence the module itself will be an invariant. The relations for virtual crossings look as follows: while passing through $i$-th component from the left to the right, we multiply the element associated to the arc ``before'' by $s_{i}$. If we go from the right to the left, we multiply by corresponding $s_{j}^{-1}$. At classical crossings, we do the following. Suppose we have a crossing where $i$-th component goes over, and $j$-th component goes under, see Fig. \ref{abc}. Suppose the arc going over is $b$, the arc lying on the right hand is $a$, and that on the left hand is $c$, see Fig. \ref{abc}. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=180pt]{abc.eps} \caption{Relation at a crossing for colored links} \label{abc} \end{figure} Then the relation looks like $t_{i}a+(1-t_{j})b=c$. For negative crossings we write down exactly the same relation just as in Fig. \ref{abc} with the orientation of $j$-th arc reversed. Denote the obtained module by $M(L)$. The invariance of this module under Reidemeister moves goes straightforwardly. It turns out that this leads to a polynomial invariant. This invariant is a generalization of that proposed in \cite{Ma3} (there we use one variable $t$ and many variables $s$). First, we label all arcs of the diagram by monomials in $s_{1},\dots, s_{n}$ (this will correspond to the operations at virtual crossings). We do it as follows. First, we deal only with proper diagrams. Thus, we can associate each crossing with a long arc. After that, we associate $1$ with each ``first'' arc outgoing directly from a crossing. After that, we can associate monomials in $s_{i}$'s to all arcs according to the way described above, view Fig. \ref{krug}. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=180pt]{krug.eps} \caption{Two-component link completely labelled} \label{krug} \end{figure} Now, we construct a matrix according to the relations at classical crossings. Namely, each row of our matrix represents a crossing, each column of the matrix represents a long arc. The matrix element is going to be the incidence between them. Let us be more detailed. Suppose we have positive crossing number $i$ with incoming edge number $j$ having label $P$ (this edge lies on the component $p$), and overcrossing edge number $k$ having label $Q$ (this edge lies on the component $q$). Then the $i$-th row of our matrix should consist of at most three elements, more precisely, it is equal to the sum of three rows, each of them having only one non-zero element. One of them has element $i$ equal to $1$, another one has element $j$ equal to $-t_{q}P$, and the last one has element $k$ equal to $(t_{p}-1)Q$. In the case when we have negative crossing, we will have three rows, one of them having $t_{q}$ on position $i$, another one having $-P$ on position $j$ and the last one having $(t_{p}-1)Q$ on position $k$. The determinant of the matrix does not change while renumbering crossings and long arcs correspondingly. Thus, the determinant is well defined on proper link diagrams. Let us call this function on diagrams by $\kappa$. The invariance check is quite similar to that performed in \cite{Ma3}, so we can show only the most difficult case, namely, the invariance under the third Reidemeister move. Namely, consider the two diagram shown in Fig. \ref{lb}. Here all numbers of crossings are marked by roman numbers, all numbers of arcs are marked by arabic numbers, numbers of components are encircled, and monomials corresponding to incoming arcs are marked by letters $P,Q,R$. View Fig. \ref{lb}. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=360pt]{label.eps} \caption{Labelling for the third Reidemeister move} \label{lb} \end{figure} In the first case we have the matrix $$\left( \begin{array}{ccccccc} 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & (t_{k}-1)Q & -t_{j}R & 0\dots 0\\ 0 & 1 & 0 & (t_{j}-1)P & -t_{i}Q & 0 & 0\dots 0\\ -t_{i} & 0 & 1 & (t_{k}-1)P & 0 & 0 & 0\dots 0\\ 0 \\ \vdots & & & * \\ 0 \end{array}\right).$$ The second matrix looks like: $$\left( \begin{array}{ccccccc} 1 & 0 & 0 & (t_{k}-1)P & 0 & -t_{i}R & 0\dots 0\\ 0 & 1 & 0 & (t_{j}-1)P & -t_{i}Q & 0 & 0\dots 0\\ -t_{j} & (t_{k}-1) & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\dots 0\\ 0 \\ \vdots & & & * \\ 0 \end{array}\right).$$ As we see, the second rows of these matrices coincide. So, let us look at the third rows. For the first matrix, add the first row multiplied by $t_{i}$ to the third row. For the second matrix, let us add the first row multiplied by $t_{j}$ and the second row multiplied by $(1-t_{k})$, to the third row. We will get two matrices, for which the third rows coincide. Namely, it looks like $$(0,0,1,(t_{k}-1)P,t_{i}(t_{k}-1)Q,-t_{i}t_{j}R,0,\dots,0).$$ Now, the first column of the new matrices consists of the only non-zero element, namely, $1$ on the position $(1,1)$. So, we can easily make the first rows of these matrices equal. Thus, we have proved that the determinants of these matrices coincide. As for the first Reidemeister move, it might multiply the determinant by a monomial in $t_{i}$'s. Thus, we have proved the following \begin{th} The polynomial $\kappa$ is invariant under Reidemeister moves up to multiplication by powers of $t_{i}$'s. \end{th} The colored link invariant can be used for purposes of knots (not links) as well: one should just take cabling and care about the proper normalization of the invariant. \section{Long Knots and Their Invariants} It is well known that long classical knots (non-compact knots in ${\bf R}^{3}$ lying on the straight line outside some big circle) are just the same as ordinary classical knots. Proof see in e.g. \cite{Ma1}. The present section the results main ideas of which were sketched in the book \cite{Ma1}, see also \cite{Ma11}. The two main arguments that can be taken into account in the theory of the ``long'' virtual knots and could not be used before, are the following: \begin{enumerate} \item One can indicate the {\em initial} and the {\em final} {\em arcs} (which are not compact) of the diagram representing some two fixed elements of the quandle; the elements corresponding to them are invariant under generalized Reidemeister moves. \item One can take two different quandle--like operations at vertices depending on which arc is ``before'' and which is ``after'' according to the orientation of a long knot. \end{enumerate} As shown in \cite{GPV}, the procedure of breaking virtual knot is not well defined: breaking the same knot diagram at different points, we may obtain different long knots. Moreover, a virtual unknot diagram broken at some point can generate a nontrivial long knot diagram. The aim of this section is to construct invariants of long virtual knots that ``feel'' the breaking point. \begin{re} Throughout the present section, we deal only with long virtual knots, not links. \end{re} \begin{re} We shall never indicate the orientation of the long knot assuming it to be oriented from the left to the right. \end{re} {\bf Notation}. Throughout this section, $R$ will denote the field of rational functions in one (real) variable $t$: $R={\bf Q}(t)$. Now, Let us define the virtual long knot. \begin{dfn} By a {\em long virtual knot diagram} we mean a smooth immersion $f$ of the oriented line $L_{x},x\in(-\infty,+\infty)$ in ${\bf R}^{2}$, such that: \begin{enumerate} \item outside some big circle, we have $f(t)=(t,0)$; \item each intersection point is double and transverse; \item each intersection point is endowed with classical or virtual crossing structure. \end{enumerate} \end{dfn} \begin{dfn} A {\em long virtual knot} is an equivalence class of long virtual knot diagrams modulo generalized Reidemeister moves. \end{dfn} \begin{dfn} A {\em long quandle}\index{Long quandle} is a set $Q$ equipped with two binary operations $\circ$ and $*$ and one unary operation $f(\cdot)$ such that $(Q,\circ,f)$ is a virtual quandle and $(Q,*,f)$ is a virtual quandle and the following two relations hold: The reverse operation for $\circ$ is $\bar \circ$ and the reverse operation for $*$ is $\bar *$. $$\forall a,b,c\in Q: (a\circ b)*c=(a*c)\circ(b*c),$$ $$\forall a,b,c \in Q: (a*b)\circ c=(a\circ c)*(b\circ c)$$ (new distributivity relations) and $$\forall x,a,b\in Q: x\alpha (a\circ b)=x\alpha(a*b)$$ $$\forall x,a,b\in Q: x\beta (a\bar \circ b)=x\beta (a\bar * b)$$ (strange relations) where $\alpha$ and $\beta$ are some operations from the list $\circ,*,\bar \circ,\bar *$. \end{dfn} \begin{re} It might seem that the last two relations hold only in the case when $\circ$ coincides with $*$. However, the equation $(a\circ b)=c$ has the only relation in $a$ and not in $b$! As it will be shown later, there are non--trivial algebraic presentations of the long quandle. \end{re} Consider a diagram ${\bar K}$ of a virtual knot and arcs of it. Let us fix the initial arc $a$ and the final arc $b$. Now, we construct the long quandle of it by the following rule. First, we take all arcs of it including $a$ and $b$ and consider the {\em free long quandle}: just by using formal operations $\circ,*,\bar \circ,\bar *,f$ factorized only by the quandle relations (together with the new distributivity relations and strange relations). After this, we factorize by relations at crossings. At each virtual crossing, we do just the same as in the case of virtual quandle. At each classical crossing we write the relation either with $\circ$ or with $*$, namely, if the overcrossing is passed {\bf before} the undercrossing (with respect to the orientation of the knot) then we use the operation $\circ$ (respectively, $\bar \circ$); otherwise we use $*$ (respectively, $\bar *$). After this factorization, we obtain an algebraic object $M$ equipped with the five operations $\circ,\bar \circ, *,\bar *,$ and $f$ and two selected elements $a$ and~$b$. \begin{dfn} Denote the obtained object by $Q_{L}({\bar K})$. \end{dfn} Let ${\bar K}$ be a diagram of a long knot $K$. Call $Q_{L}({\bar K})$ {\em the long quandle} of $K$. Obviously, for the {\em long unknot} $U$ (represented by a line without any crossings) we see that the elements $a,b\in Q_{L}(U)$ representing the initial and the final arc should be equal. \begin{th} The quandle $Q_{L}$ together with selected elements $a,b$ is invariant with respect to generalised Reidemeister moves. \end{th} \begin{proof} The proof is quite analogous to the invariance proof of the virtual quandle. Thus, the details will be sketched. The invariance under purely virtual moves and the semivirtual move goes as in the classical case: we deal only with $f$ and one of the operations $*$ or $\circ$. Only one of the operators $*,\circ$ appears when applying the first or the second classical Reidemeister move. So, the most interesting case is the third classical Reidemeister move. In fact, it is sufficient to consider the following four cases shown in Fig. \ref{TRiM} (a,b,c,d). In some cases this means the distributivity of the operations $\circ,*,\bar \circ,\bar *$ with respect to each other. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=360pt]{trim.eps} \caption{Checking the invariance under $\Omega_{3}$} \label{TRiM} \end{figure} In each of the four cases everything is OK with $p$ and $q$ ($p$ does not change and $q$ is affected by $p$ in the same manner on the right hand and on the left hand). So, one should only check the transformation for $r$. In each picture, at each crossing we put some operation $\alpha,\beta$ or $\gamma$. This means one of the operations $\circ,*,\bar \circ,\bar *$ (which are going to be applied to the arc below to obtain the corresponding arc above). Consider the case a. We have: each $\alpha,\beta,\gamma$ is a ``multiplications'' $\circ$ or $*$ (the operations $\bar \circ, \bar *$ are thus ``divisions''). Thus, at the upper left corner we shall have: $(r\gamma q)\alpha p$ in the left picture and $(r\alpha p)\gamma (q\beta p)$ in the right picture. But, by definition, $(r\gamma q)\alpha p=(r\alpha p)\gamma (q\alpha p)$. The latter expression equals $(r\alpha p)\gamma(q\beta p)$ according to the ``new relation'' (because both $\beta$ and $\alpha$ are ``multiplications''). Now, let us turn to the case b. Here $\gamma$ is a ``multiplication'' and $\alpha,\beta$ are ``divisions''. Thus, the same equality takes place: $(r\gamma q)\alpha p=(r\alpha p)\gamma(q\alpha p)=(r\alpha p)\gamma(q\beta p)$. The same equality holds for the cases shown in pictures c and d: the only important thing is that $\alpha$ and $\beta$ are either both multiplications (as in the case c) or both divisions (as in the case d). The remaining part of the statement follows straightforwardly. \end{proof} The (non--trivial) virtual knot represented there is the connected sum of two unknots. In particular, this means that the corresponding long virtual knots are not trivial. \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=180pt]{kimsg.eps} \caption{The Kishino knot} \label{Kimsg} \end{figure} \begin{figure} \centering\includegraphics[width=320pt]{sgk.eps} \caption{Two long virtual knots obtained by breaking the unknot} \label{sgk} \end{figure} Consider the unknots shown in Fig. \ref{sgk}, $a$ and $b$. Let us show that they are not isotopic to the trivial knot. To do it, we will use the presentation of the long virtual quandle to the module over ${\bf Z}_{16}$ by: $$a\circ b= 5 a-4 b,\; a*b=9a-8b.$$ $$f(x)=3\cdot x.$$ It can be readily checked that these relations satisfy all axioms of the long quandle. Let us show that for none of these two knots $a=b$. Indeed, for the first knot (Fig.\ref{sgk}.a), denote by $c$ the next arc after $a$. Then we have: $$9a-8\cdot(3c)=c,5b-4\cdot(3c)=c\Longrightarrow b=9a$$ For the second knot (Fig. \ref{sgk}.b), denote by $c$ the upper (shortest) arc. We have: $$5\cdot(3b)-4a=c,9\cdot (3a)-8b=c\Longrightarrow b=9a $$ As we see, in none of these cases $a=b$. Besides, the expressions of $b$ via $a$ are different. Thus, none of the two long knots shown in Fig. \ref{sgk}.a and Fig. \ref{sgk}.b is trivial. If we take another field, say, ${\bf Z}_{25}$ with the operations $a\circ b=6a-5b$ and $a*b=11a-10b$, $f(x)=3x$ we shall see that the two knots from Figures \ref{sgk}.a and \ref{sgk}.b are indeed different: in the first case we obtain $a=11b$, in the second case we obtain $a=21b$. In fact, the linear model for long quandles allows to prove even more, namely, we can show that the knots \ref{sgk}.a and \ref{sgk}.b do not commute (this implies the non-triviality and non-classicality of each of them together with their non-equivalence). Later, the same effect was established by D.Silver and S.Williams by using non-commutative structures in biquandles. \section{Long knot flat quandles} There is an interesting question to consider: virtual knots modulo classical crossing change. These objects are called virtual flats, for more details see, e.g, \cite{Ma1, Ma6}. These object are classified geometrically, moreover, they lead to powerful invariants of virtual knots \cite{Ma6,Tur}. However it is worth studying the algebraic classification and invariants of these objects (which was performed in \cite{Tur, HK}), because this may lead to the construction of skein algebras (see e.g. \cite{Ma1}) for virtual knots. It turns out that this plan can be performed somehow by using the ideas described in the previous section. As in \cite{FJK} and \cite{BF}, one can consider linear biquandles over non-commutative rings, e.g., over quaternions. Namely, having a classical crossing with two inputs, one writes down two outputs depending on the first ones linearly by means of some matrix $A$. Here we do not pay attention to virtual crossings\footnote{This is an interesting object to be discussed.} Obviously, the second (classical) Reidemeister move requires invertibility of $A$, and the third Reidemeister move requires some equation of Yang-Baxter type, namely, \begin{equation}A_{1}A_{2}A_{1}=A_{2}A_{1}A_{2},\label{eq8}\end{equation} where $A_{1}$ is $3\times 3$-matrix consisting of blocks $A$ (of size $2\times 2$) and $1$ (of size $1\times 1$), and $A_{1}$ is the matrix consisting of blocks $1$ and $A$. What have the equations got to do with {\bf long virtual knots}? It turns out, that we can use two different matrices, say, $A$ and $B$ for different types of crossings, namely, $A$ for the early overcrossing and $B$ for the late overcrossing. In this case, we get the equations (\ref{eq8}) for $A_{1},A_{2}$ and analogous ones for $B_{1}, B_{2}$ (as before). Besides this, get one more equation for the third Reidemeister move which corresponds to the ``strange relation'' in the case of long quandles. Namely, \begin{equation} A_{1}A_{2}B_{1}=B_{2}A_{1}A_{2}\label{eq9}\end{equation} Besides obvious solution $B=A$, one can also take the solution $B=A^{-1}$. It is clear that all condition described above hold (this is left to the reader as a simple exercise). What do we get in this case? Obviously, each ``bad crossing'' (with late overcrossing) is operated on by $B$ (or $B^{-1}$), so, we will have the same result as in the case of the inverse crossing ($A^{-1}$ or $A$). Finally, we get the invariant of the ``descending'' long knot with the same shadow, obtained by using simply the Fenn approach with the matrix $A$. This is going to be an invariant under generalized Reidemeister moves, so this is an invariant of flats. This agrees with the following general statement due to V.G.Turaev: the mapping associating to a flat long virtual link diagram the corresponding {\em ascending} long virtual link diagram is well define. Thus it allows to use any long virtual knot invariants for recognizing flat long virtual knots. So, we can take each of the solutions presented in \cite{BF}, and derive long virtual flat invariants from them. The question whether these flat long virtual knot invariants can be used as a basis for some skein module, is still to be discovered.

Significance {#Sec1} ============ When users look at their mobile touch device to open an app, they first have to find the right icon. We investigate whether searches can be supported by colored app icons and how users feel about such a support system. It is known that search efficiency can be manipulated by similarity grouping. However, these results are mainly based on simple stimuli and a yes/no answer format. App icons are more complex because they have many different visual features and users have to tap the icon to start the app after navigating between different screens of the mobile device. This paper aims to transfer basic knowledge from visual search for these complex stimuli by applying the theoretical foundation of visual search in the context of mobile touch devices. This includes not only similarity grouping, effects of set size, and target presence, but also motoric processes. Additionally, we aim to connect search efficiency with user experience (UX). The results give a first insight into how icons can be designed to allow grouping, which can be used in further research regarding spatial learning processes, semantic categorization of apps, and individual preferences of app organization. The results indicate how important the overall design of mobile device screens is for UX. Moreover, a color grouping scheme might be a way to further empower designers to develop devices that match the user's hedonistic and pragmatic needs. Background {#Sec2} ========== On mobile touch devices, efficiency refers to quick access to apps with a minimum of resources spent on the search. However, the increasing number of available apps forces users into a complex and inefficient visual search task. The complex search dynamic arises from factors such as the available screen size of mobile devices, similarity of app icons, the need to swipe through several smartphone pages, diverse use-environments (e.g. on a train, while walking), differing goals and use cases leading to altering target apps, and the need for complex motoric responses (e.g. touch displays with little or no haptic feedback). The search for an app icon is even further complicated because phone manufacturers often implement the possibility to adjust ("individualize") the spatial icon array. Even though personalization can allow quicker access to certain apps, most phone manufacturers limit the degrees of freedom offered to arrange app icons and personalized arrangements can be altered by updates. Hence, human-centered app icon design faces the challenge of facilitating the complex visual search task on mobile touch devices. Our goal was to transfer knowledge from basic research on visual search to the field of human--computer interaction and app icon design, with the aim of providing mobile touch device users with a fluent experience when searching for an app. We first examined visual search efficiency for app icon selection by similarity grouping with universally applicable colored icons (Study 1). Visual search efficiency was then further investigated with regard to the appeal of these colored icons and their effect on the perception of the interaction qualities in terms of UX (Study 2). Three theoretical areas were considered: basic research regarding visual search; applied research dealing with visual search of icons; and the impact of (search) efficiency on UX. Guidance of attention in visual search: Basic research {#Sec3} ------------------------------------------------------ ### Artificial visual search {#Sec4} In basic experiments, visual search requires the scanning of spatial locations to identify a target item among a field of one or more distractor items. The reaction time as function of the number of items is often referred to as search rate or slope. It is a measure of the search efficiency (Treisman & Gelade, [@CR64]). Low search rates show a more efficient search than high search rates (see Wolfe, [@CR75], for a review). The search rate is highly correlated with the target's saliency, which results from physical attributes of the stimuli (i.e. bottom-up), as well as from the amount of selective attention paid to these contrasts (i.e. top-down) (see Moran & Desimone, [@CR48]; Kastner & Ungerleider, [@CR35]). Theoretical models of visual search (e.g. Guided Search Model; Cave & Wolfe, [@CR15]; Wolfe, [@CR74]) assume that attention is driven by an overall (master) map representation of integrated---bottom-up and top-down---priority signals whose output lead to a continuum of visual search results. The Guided Search Model discriminates between a pre-attentive and an attentive stage. The pre-attentive stage determines the weights of the values represented on the saliency map. The saliency map corresponds to the space in the visual field. Its values correspond to the significance of the visual information at the matching locations (Findlay & Gilchrist, [@CR26]). At the attentive stage, attention is gradually guided to the highest points on the saliency map. Hence, the Guided Search Model describes how basic features (e.g. color) as well as internal states of the observer (e.g. goals) guide the deployment of attention via bottom-up and top-down processes. Many behavioral and neuroscientific investigations have confirmed the operation of these bottom-up and top-down processes in the guidance of attention in a variety of search tasks (e.g. Gaspar & McDonald, [@CR28]; Geng, DiQuattro, & Helm, [@CR29]; for reviews see Fecteau & Munoz, [@CR25] or Wolfe & Horowitz, [@CR76]). But what makes guidance more or less efficient? ### Guidance by similarity {#Sec5} Similarity strongly modulates the salience of a target. In the Attentional Engagement Theory, Duncan and Humphreys ([@CR23]) argued that different combinations of similarity relations between display items model the search efficiency, based on a visual grouping effect. More precisely, they describe a pre-attentive stage in which perceptually similar items (e.g. as indicated by similar orientation) form groups which can be jointly rejected or accepted for the selection process. Hence, the saliency of a target, and thereby the search efficiency, decreases with increasing target--distractor similarity (TDS) or with decreasing distractor--distractor similarity (DDS) (see Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). In the past, a wide range of similarity manipulation has been tested with regard to effective grouping (e.g. using letters: Corcoran & Jackson, [@CR18]; using lines: Treisman & Gormican, [@CR65]; using color patches: Farmer & Taylor, [@CR24]). A key finding is that similarity differs along simple dimensions such as color and orientation (e.g. using orientation: Duncan & Humphreys, [@CR23]; using color: Duncan, [@CR22]; Bundesen & Pedersen, [@CR13]).Fig. 1The search surface. Slope of the search function indicates the slope of reaction time over an increasing set size. It is plotted as a function of target--distractor similarity (TDS) and distractor--distractor similarity (DDS). Due to the grouping of similar items, high search efficiency arises in conditions with low TDS (points a and c). Here, the target visually "pops out." Low search efficiency arises on the opposite corners of the cube. It is especially pronounced when DDS is low (point d). Adapted from Duncan & Humphreys ([@CR23], p. 442) ### Lessons from these models {#Sec6} Saliency is determined by bottom-up features (e.g. color contrast) and top-down factors (e.g. the relevance of color to the task). It guides attention during visual search. Moreover, target saliency can result from similarity relations, e.g. a red bird (target) in front of green leaves (distractors) will be highly salient because the target is dissimilar from the distractor while the distractors are highly similar to each other. In other words, the Guided Search Model (based on saliency) and the Attentional Engagement Theory (based on similarity relations) predict similar results for many search conditions. However, their predictions differ when comparing points b and d of the search continuum (see Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). Due to the fact that the Guided Search Model predicts a decreasing search efficiency as more items show the same characteristic in a task-relevant feature (e.g. red fruit in a search for red apples), steeper reaction time slopes are assumed for corner b than for corner d in Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}. The opposite is predicted by Attentional Engagement Theory, according to which search rates increase with decreasing DDS and thus the requirement of the rejection of an increasing number of heterogeneously colored distractor items/groups in the process of visual search. We aim to transfer the knowledge from the above-mentioned basic research to the applied setting of visual search on mobile touch devices and to test the two predictions against each other. Hence, with the help of colored app icons, the predictions of the models were tested for four extreme points (compare corners a, c, b, and d of Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}) of the visual search continuum. Guidance of attention on mobile devices: Applied research {#Sec7} --------------------------------------------------------- Well perceivable display shapes (e.g. through well-defined perceptual groups) also enable a fluent search (see, for example, Scott, [@CR57] for a detailed review) under more realistic search environments using app icons as search elements. McDougald and Wogalter ([@CR44]) focused on the influence of color to guide the user's attention. They reported more correct descriptions of pictograms if relevant areas of the pictograms were highlighted by color than if there were no highlighting. The authors concluded that color directs the user's attention to relevant areas and consequently facilitates comprehension. However, the impact of color-highlighting was only shown in terms of correct answers rather than search time. Hence, the effect on visual search efficiency could not be elucidated. In another study, participants were asked to rank colored icons according to their noticeability (Bzostek & Wogalter, [@CR14]). The authors presented warnings at different screen locations, using different icons and colors. In line with the subjective perceptions, participants were able to notice warnings faster if they were presented with colored icons (blue and red) in comparison to black icons within a black inked text. Other factors such as icon location yielded no additional benefit in the color-present conditions. Results of both studies indicate that color effectively guided attention to relevant areas of the screen. Other studies have shown that grouping of icons facilitates visual search. Niemelä and Saarinen ([@CR51]) found a more efficient search for spatially grouped icons compared to non-grouped icons or non-icon-items (words) on a computer screen. They presented 16 icons with file names in a 4 × 4 grid. Due to arranging four items spatially close together, these items formed perceptional groups that facilitated the search in comparison to random arrangements. Likewise, Brumby and Zhuang ([@CR12]) found a facilitation of visual search in menu interfaces due to semantic order and visual grouping, depending on the group size. Semantic order was implemented by listing words of one category together. Visual grouping was realized by framing words of one category. Visual grouping was more effective for larger semantically organized groups (six icons) than for smaller ones (three icons). They also showed the importance of semantic and visual accordance. Visual grouping of semantically unrelated icons was significantly slower in comparison to no grouping. Both studies showed that visual search on a computer screen can benefit from spatial grouping in certain conditions (e.g. semantic and visual accordance). However, neither a mobile nor a touch device was tested. In sum, we know from applied research that guidance by simple features (e.g. color) and similarity grouping modulates the efficiency of visual search. Notwithstanding the evidence that color highlighting and similarity grouping are important factors of app arrangement on mobile touch devices, a systematic transfer of fundamental visual search results to this applied setting has not been done yet. A validation of results from visual search paradigms in the applied context of mobile touch devices might significantly contribute to the design of more efficient interfaces. Here, we also aim to test how users feel about applications modifying their search behavior. This aim is based on the user-centered design approach, which emphasizes the importance of including the user in the process of designing technology (ISO 9241--210, [@CR32]; Norman & Draper, [@CR52]). User experience and the efficiency of use {#Sec8} ----------------------------------------- The ISO standard on the ergonomics of human system interaction defines UX as "a person's perceptions and responses that result from the use or anticipated use of a product, system or service" (ISO 9241--210, [@CR32], p. 7). Based on this definition, the components of the UX model (CUE model, Thüring & Mahlke, [@CR63]; Minge, Thüring, Wagner, & Kuhr, [@CR47]) assumes three major components of UX: the perception of instrumental qualities; the perception of non-instrumental qualities; and the experienced emotions. Instrumental qualities describe attributes of the system that are beneficial for the task such as usability and usefulness of the product. Non-instrumental qualities are not essential for completing the task and refer to aspects of the visual attractiveness, aesthetics, and of the increase of one's own status. Emotions describe the inner state of the user that is affected by the interaction. All three components affect the consequences of the interaction with a product, such as the global UX evaluation and acceptance of the system, or the intention of reuse. Conversely, the components are also influenced by the user, the design of the product, and the context of the use. A wide range of studies found results supporting the framework of the CUE model (Aranyi & van Schaik, [@CR2]; Ben-Bassat, Meyer, & Tractinsky, [@CR5]; Hamborg, Hülsmann, & Kaspar, [@CR31]; Lee & Koubek, [@CR39]; Mahlke, Minge, & Thüring, [@CR42]; Minge & Thüring, [@CR46]; Thüring & Mahlke, [@CR63]). These studies show that usability is understood as one of the key components for the perception of instrumental qualities, while visual attractiveness is one of the key components in the perception of non-instrumental qualities. Focusing on usability, a connection between efficiency and UX appears. As usability is defined as the extent to which a product or service can be used effectively and efficiently while being satisfying to the user (ISO 9241--210, [@CR32]), it becomes clear that efficiency of use is a major component of usability. In fact, efficiency measures in terms of temporal units per successfully completed task are frequently used in order to infer the objective usability of a device (Agarwal & Meyer, [@CR1]; ISO 9241--210, [@CR32]; Hamborg et al., [@CR31]; Mahlke, [@CR41]) and its intuitiveness (Blackler, Popovic, & Mahar, [@CR6]; Blackler, Popovic, & Mahar, [@CR7]). The more efficiently an interaction can be accomplished, the higher the objective usability and the intuitiveness of that device are. Moreover, efficiency measures correspond to reaction times in the visual search paradigm, as they are also a temporal measure per correct response. Hence, reaction time measures are comparable to "total task time"---or "time on task"---measures that are frequently employed in usability and UX testing. Furthermore, they could also be seen as an indicator of the efficiency of the interaction and not only of the efficiency of the search itself. In sum, in an applied visual search paradigm on mobile touch devices, the efficiency of the search can be understood as an objective indicator of the usability. The efficiency, on the other hand, is also perceived by the user, which influences the perception of the intuitiveness and of the instrumental qualities of the device. Due to the fact that the present paper aims to optimize search screens on a mobile touch device, an increased efficiency should be reflected in a better UX and increased intuitiveness. Aim of the present paper {#Sec9} ------------------------ Our goal was to increase the efficiency of app selection on mobile touch devices by using an organization scheme of app icons based on color. More precisely, we investigated whether basic findings from the visual search paradigm also hold for a more complex search situation on app icons and how users experience the colored icon, which presumably helps to improve their search. In order to realize the first step of transfer, an artificial visual search with real app icons on a mobile touch device was conducted in Study 1, aiming to replicate effects of TDS as well as DDS. Reaction times were analyzed depending on of set size and target presence. In Study 2, the effect of the TDS and DDS was replicated and its impact on UX and intuitiveness was investigated. Additionally, further aspects of the transformation of basic research to the applied setting of app search on mobile touch devices, such as response format (touching the target) and swiping, were realized. Finally, other important impacts, such as crowding (Pelli & Tillman, [@CR55]) or guidance by memory (e.g. Chun & Jiang, [@CR17]; Geyer, Zehetleitner, & Müller, [@CR30]) were discussed as directions for future work. Study 1 {#Sec10} ======= Methods {#Sec11} ------- ### Participants {#Sec12} Eighteen participants (11 men) with a mean age of *M* = 25.6 (*SD* = 2.7) years took part in the first study. The sample size was computed with help of the pwr-package for R (Champely, [@CR16]) and adjusted upward to fit the balancing process, expected *d* = 1, *α-level* = 0.05, *power 1-β* = 0.8. All participants had normal or corrected to normal vision, with no instances of color-blindness. Fifteen 15 of the participants owned a smartphone. Participation was voluntary. Participants were offered course credits for participating. Before the beginning of the experiment, participants gave their informed consent according to the WMA Declaration of Helsinki. ### Stimuli and design {#Sec13} A total of 26 icons were used; 25 of these were retrieved from the Apple App Store or from Google Play and one was designed by the authors. All icons measured 2.5 × 2.5 cm. There was a gap of 3 mm between icons. Participants sat at a desk. The test device lay on the desk. Participants were able to move freely while seated.[1](#Fn1){ref-type="fn"} None of the icons included recognizable letters or numbers and all icons were transformed into a flat design (i.e. no color gradients) and set to black and white. Color was added to vary TDS as well as DDS between icons. To this end, 20 colors were chosen from the HSV color model. Each color belonged to one of four color groups (red, blue, yellow, and green). The colors differed in terms of their hue (red: 340°, 350°, 0°, 10°, 16°; yellow: 50°, 53°, 56°, 59°, 62°; green: 80°, 90°, 100°, 125°, 140°; blue: 210°, 216°, 222°, 228°, 234°), while saturation and value (in terms of lightness) were kept constant at 100%. The colors were chosen to provide high discriminability between color groups and high similarity within color groups. However, we ensured that the colors within one color group were still distinguishable. All icons were colored in each of the 20 colors, resulting in 520 colored icons. The icons differed in their overall luminance as well as the percentage of colored area as real-life app icons do. Colors for distractor icons were chosen to originate either from the same color group as the target (high TDS) or from another color group (low TDS) (see Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Distractor colors were chosen from the same color group (high DDS) or from three different color groups (for low DDS). Targets were always presented in a unique color (0°, 222°, 56°, or 100°) while distractor colors were chosen from the other 16 possible colors. In accordance to smartphone displays, *set size* was varied between the level 8, 16, and 24 icons. The target was present in half of the trials (*target presence*). In sum, the study was based on a four-factorial within-design (3 × 2 × 2 × 2) with the factors set size, target presence, TDS, and DDS.Fig. 2An example of search screens in the four similarity conditions (target present). The figure shows how TDS and DDS were manipulated to vary similarity between the icons. These are example icons that are highly similar to the icons used in Study 2. Commercial icons from the first study cannot be presented due to copyright protection ### Apparatus {#Sec14} The study was conducted on a 10-in. resistive touch device (Faytech) with a resolution of 1024 × 768, connected to a PC running ePrime (version 2.0). ### Procedure {#Sec15} Trials started with a fixation cross in the middle of the screen. Participants were instructed to hold their forefinger over the fixation cross and tap the screen when they were ready to start. Once tapped, a colored target icon was presented for 2 s followed by another fixation cross. Again, participants had to tap to show they were ready before the search screen was presented. Each search screen consisted of 8, 16, or 24 colored icons, arranged in rows of four, and one gray box at the bottom of the screen. Participants were instructed to tap the target or to tap the gray box if the target was absent. After the response, a feedback screen was shown with information regarding the correctness of the response, the response time (in milliseconds) and how well they were performing during the ongoing block (percentage of correct trials). The experiment was divided into 12 blocks according to set size, TDS, and DDS. Blocks with the same set size were presented consecutively while the order of set size presentation was balanced over participants. For each set size, the order of the four similarity conditions was randomized. Each block consisted of 24 randomized trials, of which 12 were target-present and 12 were target-absent trials. The total number of trials was 288 per subject (12 per condition). Before starting the main experiment, participants performed a short tutorial to become acquainted with the experimental procedure. Of the 26 icons, no icon was shown twice as a target in one block. However, an icon did reappear as a distractor. Furthermore, no icon was presented twice on a search screen. The target color (red, blue, yellow, or green), color groups, and target position were balanced for each participant. ### Data analysis {#Sec16} The data analysis was conducted with R version 3.3.2 (R Core Team, [@CR19]) and the following packages: afex (Singmann, Bolker, Westfall, & Aust, [@CR59]); car (Fox & Weisberg, [@CR27]); dplyr (Wickham & Francois, [@CR70]); ez (Lawrence, [@CR38]); ggplot2 (Wickham, [@CR68]); MASS (Venables & Ripley, [@CR67]); and tidyr (Wickham, [@CR69]). Before the data analysis, all incorrectly answered trials (4.78%) were excluded from the dataset and reaction time data were transformed using a Box-Cox power transformation ( λ= − 0.55) to correct for positive skew (Venables & Ripley, [@CR67]). The formula$$\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$ R{T}_{transformed}=\frac{R{T}^{\lambda }-1}{\lambda } $$\end{document}$$was used to compute transformed reaction time (*RT*~*transformed*~) from reaction time (*RT*) with *λ* as an exponent in the exponential transformation. This power transformation is based on a log-likelihood estimation for an optimal *λ*. With this procedure, the order of the original data is retained. Thus, high or low values in reaction time translate into high or low values in the transformed reaction time, respectively. Subsequently, an outlier analysis was conducted to exclude trials with reaction times differing by more than two standard deviations from the mean, which was calculated separately for each participant and condition.[2](#Fn2){ref-type="fn"} The remaining data (92.07%) were used to calculate slopes over set size for each participant and condition based on the variables TDS, DDS, and target presence. Hence, for each participant, there were eight slopes indicating the increase of reaction time with increasing set size. Due to the Box-Cox power transformation, these slope gradients were normally distributed. Subsequent analyses were based on slope values. All presented error bars were corrected for within-subject variance by the method suggested by Cousineau ([@CR20]). The alpha level was set at 5%. All post-hoc t-tests were corrected by Bonferroni--Holm correction. Results {#Sec17} ------- The statistical analysis was conducted with an ANOVA (type III) on slope values with the independent within factors TDS, DDS, and target presence. The results are presented in Table [1](#Tab1){ref-type="table"}.Table 1ANOVA (type III) on slopes over set sizeFdfs*p*gesIntercept183.761, 17\< 0.0010.84TDS142.591, 17\< 0.0010.46DDS1.021, 170.3280.00Target presence8.091, 17\< 0.050.07TDS: DDS39.761, 17\< 0.0010.13TDS: target presence39.231, 17\< 0.0010.08DDS: target presence1.611, 170.2220.01TDS: DDS: target presence1.001, 170.3310.00Effects of target--distractor similarity (TDS), distractor--distractor similarity (DDS), and target presence on slopes over set size. The slopes were computed based on the transformed reaction time. Generalized eta square (ges) was computed as the effect size. Based on Bakeman ([@CR4]) a ges of 0.02 can be seen as a small effect, one of 0.13 as a medium effect, and one of 0.26 as a large effect The results revealed a large main effect of TDS. As expected, the increase of reaction time over set size was much steeper (i.e. increasing slopes) when TDS was high than when it was low. DDS showed no significant impact on slope gradients. However, the expected interaction between TDS and DDS was present and revealed a medium effect size. The interaction is visualized in Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}. The graph on the right shows that slopes were smaller when TDS was low (points a and c) compared to high TDS (points b and d). However, the slopes differed significantly between DDS levels at both TDS levels. When TDS was low, slope values were significantly smaller with high DDS compared to low DDS (points a and c, respectively), *t*(17) = 5.15, *p* \< 0.001, *d* = 1.23. Conversely, when TDS was high, slope values were larger with high DDS compared to low DDS (points b and d, respectively), *t*(17) = − 4.39, *p* \< 0.001, *d* = 1.05.Fig. 3Interactions of TDS and DDS on reaction time and on slope values as a function of set size. Small slope values indicate a search that is mostly independent of set size, i.e. is very efficient. Large slope values suggest inefficient search processes. In order to compare the results to the predictions of Duncan and Humphreys ([@CR23]), depicted in Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}, the letters a to d were added to the *graph* on the *right*. All analyses were conducted on slope values based on transformed reaction time (*right graph*), although original values are also shown (*left graph*). The slope values based on the original data for low TDS condition are 13 ms/icon (low DDS) and 6 ms/icon (high DDS) and for the high TDS condition are 38 ms/icon (low DDS) and 75 ms/icon (high DDS) Regarding target presence, the ANOVA revealed a small effect: slopes were steeper if the target was absent. As expected, this effect interacted with TDS, target presence had no effect when TDS was low, *t*(17) = − 0.27, *p* = 0.787, *d* = 0.07, but a strong effect when TDS was high, *t*(17) = 5.25, *p* \< 0.001, *d* = 1.24. This is in line with expectations and suggests once again an efficient search process when TDS is low and an inefficient process when TDS is high. We reran the analysis with only those individuals who owned a smartphone. Within this subgroup, the main effect of target presence was only marginally significant and the interaction between TDS and DDS was more pronounced. However, the overall results were in line with the results of the entire group. Discussion {#Sec18} ---------- Study 1 aimed at transferring effects of TDS as well as DDS to app icons on mobile touch devices. For this purpose, reaction times were analyzed depending on similarity (between colored app icons), set size (number of app icons), and target app presence. As expected, grouping of similar app icons occurred and enabled an efficient app selection. Hence, our results mirror those from basic (laboratory) visual search studies. Regarding the different predictions of the Guided Search Model and the Attentional Engagement Theory, the results support the prediction of the Guided Search Model (compare corner b and d in Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"} to Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). When the target is highly similar to the distractors (high TDS), the Guided Search Model predicts a weaker guidance of attention by a basic attribute (e.g. color), the more distractors carry this attribute. In the same scenario, the Attentional Engagement Theory predicts more efficient grouping and rejection with increasing distractor similarity (i.e. leading to steeper reaction time slopes for corner d than b in Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"}). When realizing point b, we created an extreme variant of high TDS and high DDS in which all icons shared the same color group. Thus, grouping by color could not offer any relevant information for target--distractor discrimination. Thus, the present pattern of results is not fully compatible with the prediction of Attention Engagement Theory. Instead, the results suggest that priority map models of the search process such as Guided Search are more appropriate to predict search performance in app icon search. In accordance with basic research findings, interaction effects of TDS and target presence revealed characteristic patterns of efficient and inefficient search processes. With regard to the more applied line of research, our findings are in line with previous research recognizing the influence of color highlighting of computer pictograms (e.g. Bzostek & Wogalter, [@CR14]; McDougald & Wogalter, [@CR44]) or emphasizing the impact of grouping of icons (e.g. Brumby & Zhuang, [@CR12]; Niemelä & Saarinen, [@CR51]). Although basic research results were confirmed for a mobile touch device setting, a major limitation is that the visual search on mobile touch devices was not adequately replicated. In real life, users mentally visualize the app icon and its features before a search. The location and color of icons are learned and memorized through the interaction with the device. In Study 1, these two dimensions were excluded by randomization in order to focus on effects of similarity grouping. The impact of spatial learning and memory, the preparation of the search by learned colors, as well as the interplay of these complex cognitive processes are further addressed in the general discussion. Furthermore, icons on mobile touch devices are frequently presented on multiple screens and the user might have to swipe through several screens to find the desired app. That scenario implies an investigation of similarity grouping and learning across multiple screens. Finally, hedonic aspects of color organization schemes and of an accelerated search were not considered in Study 1. Thus, it seemed doubtful whether the increased efficiency of a visual search will be accompanied by a better UX. Study 2 aimed to extend the ecological validity of the results of Study 1 by implementing a visual search on multiple screens and investigating the impact of similarity grouping on UX. Study 2 {#Sec19} ======= The goal of Study 2 was to confirm the effect of color guidance and similarity on reaction time in a more realistic context (objective 1) and to analyze the importance of a quick search for soft dimensions like UX and intuitiveness (objective 2). To this extent, we aimed to increase the visual similarity of the search task towards a more realistic one. On this account, the icons were presented on multiple screens. Additionally, we presented each icon with a name indicating the icon's purpose to simulate the fact that users' search for an app is always based on a certain goal (e.g. checking for train connections, not for a train icon as such). Hence, the search space was enhanced and users had to swipe to navigate between the different search screens. However, in order to make Study 2 comparable with Study 1, the presentation of the exact target icon before the search display was retained in Study 2. Regarding the efficiency of the search, we expected to find similar results to those obtained in Study 1. Based on the CUE model (Thüring & Mahlke, [@CR63]; Minge et al., [@CR47]), we further expected that this efficiency correlates with UX components. Mainly, it should affect intuitiveness and perceived usability. Additionally, we expected users to notice the more efficient search if there is a pop-out effect of the target. Methods {#Sec20} ------- ### Participants {#Sec21} A study was conducted with 36 participants (19 men) with an average age of *M* = 25.1 (*SD* = 3.5) years. The required sample size was based on the balancing procedure. Based on the pwr-package (Champely, [@CR16]), the given sample size of 36 was sufficient to detect effects with a *d* \> 0.70 at an *α-level* = 0.05 and a *power* 1-β = 0.8. Thirty-four of the participants reported that they owned a mobile touch device (smartphone and/or tablet) and used it on a daily basis. All participants indicated that they had normal or corrected to normal vision and that they were not color-blind. Participation was voluntary; all participants were either offered course credit or money for participation. All participants gave their informed consent according to the WMA Declaration of Helsinki. Additionally, the ethics committee of the Technische Universität Berlin confirmed that Study 2 showed no critical aspects regarding privacy, anonymity, and other basic features before the study. ### Stimuli and task {#Sec22} To enhance the applicability of Study 2 to real-life interactions with mobile touch devices, four features of the stimuli were changed compared to Study 1. First, the presentation of the search screen was adjusted to resemble a typical smartphone. The screen showed a picture of a black iPhone 6 in its original size (13.8 × 6.7 cm) in the middle of a white screen. All icons depicted on the smartphone's white background had a size of 1 × 1 cm with an inter-icon gap of 4 mm as in iOS 10. Participants sat in front of the device, which was lying horizontally on a desk. The second adaption of the first experiment was the experimental task, which was redesigned to further approximate a real-life scenario. In everyday life, icons may be distributed on a number of screens. Thus, when searching through a screen, the icon can either be on the currently visible screen or the user has to swipe in order to look for the icon on a different screen. Therefore, we always presented two screens, each with 24 icons. Navigating between the screens was possible with a swipe movement. The target icon was always present on one of the two screens. The probability of the icon being on the first or second screen was held equal. A further aspect in which this experiment differed from the previous one was the total number of icons. In order to increase the variability of the icons and to be able to use 48 differing icons during each trial, the total number of icons was increased from 26 (Study 1) to 60 (Study 2). Similar to Study 1, all icons were transformed into a flat design and colored with the 20 colors previously described. This resulted in a total of 1200 colored icons (60 icons × 20 colors). Again, overall luminance and percentage of colored area were not controlled. In contrast to Study 1, each icon was given a name (such as "e-mail", "puzzle", "local traffic", "food delivery service", etc.) to include a dimension of functionality. A pre-study was conducted in which icons with easily distinguishable symbols were matched to application names. During this process, most icons from Study 1 were replaced by new ones. Summarizing the above-mentioned differences between both experiments, these four changes in stimuli led to a different task compared to Study 1. Owing to the added second screen, participants were confronted with a larger search space (2 × 24 icons), an additional movement was required (swipe), and they also had to be aware which screen was currently visible in order to navigate between the two screens. This awareness was supported by a sign at the bottom of each screen, similar to the "bubbles" used in the Apple iOS, indicating which screen was currently visible. The dimension of app functionality further added to the complexity of the task. Even though participants did not have to learn the names/functions of all icons, the target was always presented with its matching name/functionality. Thus, the representation of the target consisted of both a visual cue and a semantic one. ### Design and operationalization {#Sec23} The first objective of Study 2 was to replicate the similarity effect on reaction time in a more realistic context than in Study 1. Hence, Study 2 was also based on the factors TDS and DDS. Both factors were manipulated in the same fashion as in Study 1 (see Fig. [2](#Fig2){ref-type="fig"}). Set size was held constant at a level of 24 icons per search screen, leading to 48 icons per trial. Target presence was replaced as a factor by the factor target screen (i.e. the presence of the target app on the first or second screen). Although this variation did not originate from a theoretical framework but rather from a real-life scenario, the splitting of the search space into two screens was thought likely to have a systematic effect on reaction times. Therefore, Study 2 consisted of a three-factorial within-design (2 × 2 × 2) with the independent factors TDS, DDS, and target screen and the dependent variable reaction time. As a second objective, we aimed to analyze the importance of a quick search for soft dimensions such as UX and intuitiveness. To this end, for each of the four similarity conditions (TDS × DDS) we presented a paper--pencil questionnaire with variables measuring intuitiveness, perceived usability, perceived aesthetics, emotions, a global UX evaluation, and passage of time judgments, as well as a short interview with open questions. At the end of the experiment, an overall interview was conducted. All questionnaires and questions were in German. Intuitiveness and perceived usability were measured using the INTUI (Ullrich & Diefenbach, [@CR66]) which is based on a 7-point semantic differential and consists of five subscales. In this study, only two of these scales were of interest and are therefore presented: intuitiveness (originally "Bauchgefühl" = gut feeling) with four items (e.g. "When I made use of the colors in my search, I acted rationally" to "...I acted spontaneously") and perceived usability (originally "Mühelosigkeit" = effortlessness of use) with five items (e.g. During using the color scheme of the icons, I reached my goal with effort "...I reached my goal with ease"). Perceived aesthetics was measured with the VisAWI short (Moshagen & Thielsch, [@CR49]), a four-item questionnaire based on a 7-point Likert-scale with the poles "strongly disagree" and "strongly agree" (e.g. "Everything goes together on this site"). The scales for emotions and global UX evaluation were taken from the meCUE (Minge & Riedel, [@CR45]). Emotions consisted of two subscales measured on a 7-point Likert-scale from "strongly disagree" to "strongly agree." These subscales are positive emotions (e.g. "The color design of the icons makes me feel euphoric") and negative emotions (e.g. "The color design of the icons makes me tired"). A single item, based on an 11-point semantic differential ranging from "The color design of the icons was bad" to "good," was used for the global UX evaluation. On top of the UX-related constructs, we also included one item to measure the passage of time, which might reflect the participants' perception of differences in reaction time. The item was based on a 7-point semantic differential ranging from The time it took me to find an icon was "long" to "...short." All questionnaires except the item for passage of time are validated German questionnaires. The interview after each similarity condition was verbally administered. It consisted of the following questions:How did you like the color scheme?Would you like to have such a color scheme on your smartphone? The final question was always accompanied with a short description of the similarity condition. In the conditions in which TDS was low, we additionally asked how the individuals would feel about an algorithm which could predict the app the user is searching for and would color this app in order to achieve a pop-out effect of this app during the search. The final interview at the end of the experiment consisted of the following questions:Would you like to change the colors of your app icons?How would you feel about app icon colors that represent the category the app belongs to, e.g. all gaming apps are red and all communication apps are blue? Would you like to pick the colors of the categories yourself?[3](#Fn3){ref-type="fn"} ### Apparatus {#Sec24} The study was conducted on a Lenovo think pad with a capacitive touchscreen. The experimental procedure was implemented with the help of the Psychophysics Toolbox Version 3 (Brainard, [@CR11]; Kleiner, Brainard, & Pelli, [@CR36]; Pelli, [@CR54]) in Matlab 9.1 (R2016b). ### Procedure {#Sec25} Trials started with the question ("Ready?") displayed in the middle of the screen. Participants were instructed to hold their forefinger over the text and tap the screen when they were ready to start. Once tapped, a colored target icon and its matching name/function were presented for 2 s and were then followed by the search task. Each search task consisted of two screens with 24 colored icons. In accordance with the concept of a "home screen," the first screen was always presented as default and the second screen could be reached by sliding to the left. Participants could swipe between the two screens as often as they liked. Screen swipes were registered in a log-file. Participants were instructed to search the target icon and to tap it as quickly as possible. After the response, a feedback screen was shown with information regarding the correctness of the response. The experiment was divided into four blocks according to TDS and DDS. Each block consisted of 30 visual searches and was followed by the above-mentioned questionnaire and the short interview. As previously described, the target appeared an equal number of times on each of the screens. Each icon was shown twice as a target during the whole experiment but never twice in the same block. Moreover, no icon was presented twice during one trial. Similar to Study 1, target color, color groups, and target position were balanced for each participant. At the end of the experiment, a final interview was conducted. In total, the experiment took about 55 min. ### Data analysis {#Sec26} Excluding set size as a factor meant that slopes over set size could no longer be computed, so a slightly different data analysis strategy was implemented compared to Study 1. Hence, the following analysis is based on reaction time values. However, a shorter reaction time compared to a longer one can also be described as a more efficient search, so we expected to find the same interaction pattern between TDS and DDS on reaction time values as in Study 1. More precisely, we expected an increase in reaction time values as the target grew more similar to the distractors. This effect was expected to be more pronounced when DDS was high compared to low. Data analysis was conducted with R version 3.3.2 (R Core Team, [@CR19]) and the same packages as Study 1. Similar to Study 1, all incorrectly answered trials (1.6%) and all trials with unnecessary swipes (5.9%) were excluded from the data before the data analysis. Search time was defined as reaction time between the onset of the screen with the target and the correct answer. Again, reaction-time data were transformed using the Box-Cox function (*λ* = − 0.95) to correct for positive skew (Venables & Ripley, [@CR67]). Subsequently, an outlier analysis was conducted to exclude trials with reaction times differing by more than two standard deviations from the mean, calculated separately for each participant and condition.[4](#Fn4){ref-type="fn"} The remaining data (89.5%) were averaged over the eight conditions (TDS × DDS × target screen) and used for the statistical analysis with the help of an ANOVA. The questionnaire data were digitized. In accordance with the questionnaire guidelines, predefined items were reversed and mean values were computed for the scales intuitiveness, perceived usability, perceived aesthetics, positive emotions, and negative emotions. Global UX evaluation and passage of time judgments were not transformed as they were single-item scales. Most of these values, however, were not normally distributed over participants. Moreover, variances in the TDS low conditions were very small for the scales perceived usability and passage of time judgments. Overall, the skew of the data was too strong to allow a parametric analysis. Thus, as a robust test for all questionnaire data, we used the R function "wwtrim" from the WRS package (Wilcox & Schönbrodt, [@CR73]). The function calls for a robust test for a two-factorial within-design that gives an estimate of the significance of both main effects and the interaction based on trimmed means (Wilcox, [@CR72]). The percentage of trimmed means was kept at the default value of 20%. This procedure was used to analyze the effect of TDS and DDS on the questionnaire data. In addition, we also analyzed the correlation between reaction time and the scales of the questionnaire. As TDS and DDS were within-subject factors, each participant had delivered data in four conditions. Bland and Altman ([@CR8], [@CR9]) suggest two different approaches to handle dependencies due to repeated measures in correlations: one could either focus on the overall effect (e.g. do individuals with a high value of reaction time also show low usability ratings?) or focus on the within-subject correlation (e.g. does an increase of reaction time in one participant go along with a decrease in the usability rating of the same participant?). In the first case, the data need to be averaged for each individual before the correlation analysis. In the present dataset, such an averaging would not be very informative because the four data points were collected under very different conditions varying in TDS and DDS. Therefore, we chose to focus on the within-subject correlations. These are especially interesting because the questionnaire data consist of rating scales, which call the participants to compare internally their experience between the different conditions. On this account, we used the rmcorr package (Bakdash & Marusich, [@CR3]) to compute the within-subject correlation coefficient *r* based on the procedure proposed by Bland and Altman ([@CR9]). The qualitative data from the interviews were analyzed regarding keywords describing positive or negative reactions to the interaction. In other words, similar statements were clustered into key statements. Subsequently, the frequency of each key statement in the sample was computed. If a statement was too ambiguous to be assigned in one cluster, it was dropped. All presented error bars were corrected for within-subject variance by the method suggested by Cousineau ([@CR20]). All post-hoc t-tests were corrected by Bonferroni--Holm correction. Results {#Sec27} ------- ### Objective 1 {#Sec28} We conducted an ANOVA (type III) on the averaged transformed reaction times with the independent within factors TDS, DDS, and target screen. The results are presented in Table [2](#Tab2){ref-type="table"}.Table 2ANOVA (type III) on averaged values of transformed reaction timeFdfs*p*gesIntercept13.891, 35\< 0.0010.20TDS1352.371, 35\< 0.0010.79DDS1.921, 350.1740.00Target screen4.121, 350.0500.01TDS: DDS98.951, 35\< 0.0010.17TDS: target screen65.111, 35\< 0.0010.06DDS: target screen0.901, 350.3500.00TDS: DDS: target screen3.061, 350.0890.00Effects of target--distractor similarity (TDS), distractor--distractor similarity (DDS), and target screen on transformed reaction time. Generalized eta square (ges) was computed as the effect size. Based on Bakeman ([@CR4]) a ges of 0.02 can be seen as a small effect, one of 0.13 as a medium effect, and one of 0.26 as a large effect Similar to Study 1, we found a large main effect of TDS indicating that reaction times were much smaller when TDS was low compared to when it was high. Even though there was no main effect of DDS, there was a significant interaction of medium effect size between the two similarity dimensions. The interaction is visualized in Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}. The graph shows that the effect of the TDS condition was stronger when DDS was low (point c to d) compared to when it was high (point a to b). Thus, in line with slope values in Study 1, reaction times were significantly lower with high DDS compared to low DDS when TDS was low (points a and C, respectively), *t*(35) = 8.01, *p* \< 0.001, *d* = 0.96. When TDS was high, values were larger with high DDS compared to low DDS (points b resp. d), *t*(35) = − 6.68, *p* \< 0.001, *d* = 0.99. A more detailed comparison of the reaction times in Study 1 and Study 2 can be found in the [Appendix](#Sec35){ref-type="sec"}.Fig. 4Interactions of TDS and DDS on reaction time and transformed reaction time. Smaller values indicate a quicker and more efficient search. To compare the results with Fig. [1](#Fig1){ref-type="fig"} and Fig. [3](#Fig3){ref-type="fig"}, the letters a to d were added to the *graph* on the *right*. All analyses were conducted on transformed reaction times (*right graph*) but original values of reaction time are shown in the *left graph* for easier interpretation Moreover, we found an interaction between TDS and target screen: the difference between the TDS conditions was more pronounced when the target was on the second screen. That is, when TDS was low, reaction times were slightly higher for targets on the first compared to the second screen, *t*(35) = 3.53, *p* \< 0.01, *d* = 0.33. When TDS was high, reaction times were lower for targets on the first compared to the second screen), *t*(35) = − 6.49, *p* \< 0.001, *d* = 0.85. Thus, the disadvantage of high TDS was bigger on the second compared to the first screen. An analysis of the swipe data can be found in the [Appendix](#Sec35){ref-type="sec"}. We reran the analysis with only those individuals who used a smartphone on a daily basis and the results did not differ from the results described above. ### Objective 2: Quantitative data {#Sec29} We conducted a robust test for a two-factorial within-design (Wilcox, [@CR72], for more information see "[Data analysis](#Sec16){ref-type="sec"}" in the "[Methods](#Sec11){ref-type="sec"}" section) with the independent factors TDS and DDS for each of the variables of the questionnaire, i.e. intuitiveness, perceived usability, perceived aesthetics, positive and negative emotions, global UX evaluation, and passage of time judgment. The results are presented in Table [3](#Tab3){ref-type="table"}.Table 3Robust tests with the effects of TDS and DDS on intuitiveness and UX dimensionsEffect of TDS and DDS onTDSDDSTDS:DDS*QpQpQp*Intuitiveness65.71\< 0.0010.440.50522.17\< 0.001Perceived usability182.78\< 0.00111.30\< 0.00154.91\< 0.001Perceived aesthetics11.35\< 0.00113.47\< 0.0010.010.916Positive emotions15.88\< 0.0012.920.0882.850.092Negative emotions27.11\< 0.00119.02\< 0.0015.34\< 0.05Global UX evaluation22.65\< 0.00125.51\< 0.0016.94\< 0.01Passage of time judgment139.02\< 0.00113.26\< 0.00124.00\< 0.001 As a conclusion, we found a main effect of TDS on all scales indicating that participants experienced low TDS conditions as being more intuitive, more usable, and more visually attractive than high TDS conditions. Moreover, low TDS conditions elicited more positive and less negative emotions and received a higher rating on the global UX evaluation. The passage of time judgment reflected the differences in reaction time as participants perceived the time it took them to find an item as shorter when TDS was low compared to when it was high. However, for most scales there was also an interaction effect between TDS and DDS. The pattern of this interaction was very similar for intuitiveness, perceived usability, positive emotions, and passage of time judgment. In these cases, the most positively rated condition based on visual inspection was always the TDS low and DDS high condition. Compared to the reaction time data, this condition corresponds to the shortest reaction times (point a in Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). However, this was not the most positively rated condition when looking at perceived aesthetics and global UX evaluation. For these two scales, participants gave their highest rating for the TDS low--DDS low condition. The most negatively rated condition based on visual inspection in all scales was the condition with both TDS and DDS high, which also had the longest reaction times (point b in Fig. [4](#Fig4){ref-type="fig"}). These results are presented in Fig. [5](#Fig5){ref-type="fig"}.Fig. 5*Bar graphs* of the seven rating dimensions: intuitiveness, perceived usability, perceived aesthetics, emotions, global UX evaluation, and passage of time judgments. On the *y-axis*, we present the range of the scales. The first adjective (from ...) stands for low values and the second adjective (to ...) stands for high values In addition, we looked at the within-subject correlations (Bland & Altman, [@CR9]) between the reaction time data and the rating scales from the questionnaire. The within-subject correlation coefficient *r* describes how high the interrelationship between two variables is within subjects. The correlations showed that participants rated the interaction to be less intuitive, *r* = − 0.655, *p* \< 0.001, and to have a lower usability, *r* = − 0.795, *p* \< 0.001, the longer reaction times they experienced. A similar pattern was found for the global UX evaluation and the passage of time judgement: the longer the reaction time grew within individuals, the more negative the overall UX evaluation became, *r* = − 0.655, *p* \< 0.001, and the less likely it became to rate the reaction times as being short, *r* = − 0.885, *p* \< 0.001. This finding was in line with the correlations between reaction time and emotions, as there was a negative correlation between reaction time and positive emotions, *r* = − 0.468, *p* \< 0.001, and a positive correlation between reaction time and negative emotions, *r* = 0.476, *p* \< 0.001. The smallest correlation coefficient was found between reaction time and perceived aesthetics, *r* = − 0.312, *p* \< 0.001. ### Objective 2: Qualitative data {#Sec30} The responses from the interviews conducted after each condition supported the above-mentioned ratings. When asked how they liked the color scheme, most participants gave positive responses for the TDS low--DDS low condition. Typical comments, as well as the frequency of positive, neutral, or negative answers after each condition, are presented in Table [4](#Tab4){ref-type="table"}. It seems clear that participants liked TDS low conditions for their usefulness but they found them more boring, especially when DDS was high. Regarding the TDS high--DDS low condition, the results were mixed. However, participants mostly agreed in their negative comments about the TDS high--DDS high condition, calling it "not useful," "awful," or "confusing."Table 4Subjective evaluations of the similarity conditions with typical comments presented in round edgesConditionPositive answersNeutral answersNegative answersTotalTDS low--DDS low22\ (useful, convenient, nice for the search, plain, colorful)11\ (useful but ugly colors, sterile, neutral, boring)2\ (too bright, confusing)35TDS low--DDS high15\ (useful, easy to find, clear, simple, pleasant)14\ (boring but useful, search is good but colors are ugly, functional but ugly)5\ (too bright, not a nice visual picture)34TDS high--DDS low10\ (realistic, nicely messy, attractive, takes more effort)16\ (as usual, neutral, boring, monotonous)9\ (messy, long search, chaotic, unclear)35TDS high--DDS high5\ (nicely coherent, easy to recognize the icons)4\ (unexciting, monotonous)24\ (not useful, hard to discriminate between icons, exhausting, awful, confusing)33 When asked if they would like to have such a color scheme on their smartphone, the answers showed a similar pattern over the similarity condition. When TDS was low most participants reacted positively to the idea, which was independent of the DDS condition. More precisely, 78% of the participants in the TDS low--DDS low condition and 81% in the TDS low--DDS high condition indicated that they would like to have such a color scheme on their smartphone. The rate of positive reactions dropped for TDS high conditions. When TDS was high and DDS was low, 42% reacted positively to this idea. In the TDS high--DDS high condition, none of the participants reacted positively to the idea. Even though many participants had reacted positively to the idea of having a mobile touch device on which the target icon showed low similarity to the other app icons, four of the 36 participants expressed concerns about the TDS--low condition. They feared constant surveillance if their mobile touch device knew which app they were looking for. When confronting all of the participants with the idea of an algorithm that predicts the next click and supports it by creating a pop-out effect, more participants uttered concerns; 66% reacted negatively to the idea of such an algorithm, mainly citing privacy reasons. Only 33% of the participants reacted positively to this idea. In the final interview, we asked the participants whether they would like to change the colors of the app icons on their own mobile touch devices and how they would feel about color coding of apps, in order to represent certain categories with the help of a common color. Participants who did not own a mobile touch device were excluded from this analysis, leading to a sample of *N* = 34. Regarding the first question, 41% of the participants indicated that they would like to manipulate the colors of the apps on their mobile touch device, while 9% were indecisive, and 50% were opposed to the idea. The latter group mostly attributed its opposition to familiarization with current app icon or brand colors and to a lack of interest in the personalization of colors. Regarding the second question, participants showed a more positive reaction. Of the participants, 65% indicated that they would like a color-coded system on their mobile touch device in which apps of the same categories (e.g. games) share the same color. However, only half of these participants would like to pick the colors of these categories themselves. Discussion {#Sec31} ---------- The aim of Study 2 was twofold. First, we aimed to show that the effect of similarity between app icons persists when the search task is related closer to a realistic use of mobile touch devices (objective 1). This was realized by visually resembling an iPhone 6, by including different screens which were connected by a swipe and by simulating a use-case of each icon represented by a functional name of the app. Similar to Study 1, results showed that the search became more efficient the fewer icons on the screen shared the same color group. Additionally, the data indicated that the disadvantage of high TDS was even bigger when the target was on the second screen. This effect might be due to more effort on the second screen because participants knew that the target had to be there somewhere or due to fatigue because they already had been searching through one screen (24 icons). Even though the current study cannot discriminate between the two possible explanations, the finding clearly shows how important an efficient search is when searching for an app on a touch device. On touch devices, it is rather common to have two or more possible search screens. Just as portrayed in this study, this means that searching for an icon that is located on a later screen includes negative searches before the positive search. Based on the results of Study 2, we would predict that these searches on connected screens are even more sensible to bad icon design (high TDS) than single screen searches. Second, we aimed to analyze the importance of an efficient search for UX and intuitiveness (objective 2). The subjective data showed that participants were aware of the differences in efficiency between the conditions (passage of time judgments) and that it affected their UX. More precisely, we found the same effect of similarity conditions on the perception of instrumental qualities of the color scheme (usability) and on the intuitiveness of the interaction. Additionally, high within-subject correlations showed that an increase in search efficiency came with an increase in positive ratings regarding intuitiveness, usability, overall evaluation, and positive emotions. Negative emotions decreased with increasing search efficiency. However, other components of UX revealed a different pattern. Participants emphasized the importance of aesthetic aspects (e.g. visual diversity) by rating the condition with low TDS and low DDS as better and visually more attractive than the condition with the highest search efficiency (low TDS and high DDS). This conclusion is also supported by the small correlation between search efficiency and perceived aesthetics. Overall, the results support the notion that a good UX is not only elicited through high efficiency or high usability but also through aesthetical aspects (e.g. Thüring & Mahlke, [@CR63]). Another important finding concerns the discrepancy between a general (visual) preference and a specific technical solution. Even though most participants preferred the facilitation by colored icons, more than half of them reacted negatively to a technical solution which would automatically predict the user's next target icon for visual highlighting. The negative reactions were mainly attributed to privacy issues. In sum, the results of Study 2 show that users prefer a supported search as long as it is not visually too monotonous and respects their need for privacy and control over the device. Even though Study 2 approximated to a realistic use of mobile touch devices, it was still conducted under controlled laboratory conditions and shares similar limitations. Discussion {#Sec32} ========== Mobile touch devices have become an important part of daily life. "There's an app for that" has become a common phrase, showing how ubiquitous apps have become. While the growing number of apps offers users a wide range of possibilities, it also challenges them to find the desired app from all the others installed on the mobile device within a reasonable amount of time. Focusing on this challenge, we explored in two studies how users can be supported in their visual search for a specific icon by attentional guidance based on universally applicable colors. Basic research has shown that basic attributes such as color can guide the attention of observers efficiently, even if the search space is complex (e.g. Cave & Wolfe, [@CR15]; Wolfe, Võ, Evans, & Greene, [@CR77]). Moreover, efficient visual search can result from similarity relations (Duncan & Humphreys, [@CR23]). Perceptually similar items (e.g. indicated by similar colors) form groups which can be jointly rejected or accepted in the selection process. In line with the knowledge from basic research, enabling the user to visually group app icons based on their color should facilitate a more efficient search on mobile touch devices. In accordance with basic research findings, our results show that the search was more efficient the fewer icons on the screen shared the same color group. This was clear from the interaction between TDS and DDS. It indicates that grouping of icons occurred and that it facilitated a more efficient search. Also, the findings are in line with previous research showing the influence of color when highlighting important aspects of computer pictograms (Bzostek & Wogalter, [@CR14]; McDougald & Wogalter, [@CR44]) or showing the impact of icon grouping (Brumby & Zhuang, [@CR12]; Niemelä & Saarinen, [@CR51]). Study 2 incorporated a more realistic scenario by expanding the search space over two screens connected by a swipe. Also Study 2 showed that guiding attention by color similarity enhanced the search efficiency. In addition, the results of Study 2 indicated that these searches on connected screens are even more sensible to bad icon design (high TDS) than single screen searches. In sum, knowledge of basic visual search was successfully transferred to the visual search of mobile touch devices. In Study 2, we additionally investigated whether these findings correspond to the subjective evaluation. To this extent, UX and intuitiveness of the interaction were examined as a function of the similarity conditions. The subjective data showed that participants detected the facilitation due to the similarity manipulation very accurately and that it increased the perceived instrumental qualities and the perceived intuitiveness of the device. Overall, they showed a preference for a more efficient search but preferred a more diversified visual design, which can be seen as a non-instrumental quality of the device. These results are in line with the CUE model (Thüring & Mahlke, [@CR63]; Minge et al., [@CR47]) which predicts an effect of system characteristics such as efficiency on the perception of instrumental qualities (e.g. usability) and the emergence of an overall UX based not only on the perceived instrumental qualities but also based on the perceived non-instrumental qualities (e.g. aesthetics). Additionally, the qualitative data of Study 2 suggested that users' needs should not only be considered with regard to an efficient and pleasing interaction but also with regard to privacy and control issues. Even though the idea of an intelligent, adaptive system supporting their search was rather popular in our sample, most participants uttered their concern regarding data acquisition and processing within such a system. In conclusion, the results showed that search efficiency can be supported via similarity grouping with a simple color manipulation, leaving other design aspects of complex icons aside (e.g. luminance, shade, orientation, forms, and percentage of colored area). Such a color manipulation should be of interest to developers and designers of mobile operating systems, aiming to design for a better UX. To this end, an adaptive color manipulation could be implemented to create pop-out effects. In real-life, the target app constantly changes. Hence, creating a pop-out effect as portrayed here requires the system to know what the user is looking for and to change the display accordingly. A technical solution could be implemented with an algorithm predicting user behavior (based on, e.g., former use, location, time of day, information gathered from other applications). An alternative to an algorithm could be offered by allowing users to categorize their applications and to create a visible indicator for the related category. Up to now, categorization can mainly be done by creating folders, but indicating a category by color might also be of interest to users, as Study 2 showed. Designers could either provide ready-to-use color schemes or leave the categorization and the choice of color to the user. Color-coded categories could make it easier for the user to remember what the target looks like before search and to visualize the target. Overall, allowing more variability to icon design could both enhance efficiency and further empower users by offering user- and/or system-initiated personalization, as has been shown for other contexts (e.g. Sun, May, & Wang, [@CR62]). Furthermore, it offers great possibilities to meet users' needs for organization (Böhmer & Krüger, [@CR10]) and for aesthetically pleasing icon design (e.g. Luo & Zhou, [@CR40]). On the one hand, this is interesting for inexperienced users and the elderly. Böhmer and Krüger ([@CR10]) found that inexperienced smartphone users organized their apps less than experienced users did. Thus, a simple organization scheme by similarity grouping of colored icons might support inexperienced users. On the other hand, highly experienced users might also benefit from more variability and personalization in icon design. Although the bottom-up guidance of attention by color and grouping should influence experienced and inexperienced users similarly, top-down factors might moderate the guidance differently. Semantic categories build through previous interactions might override the grouping effects of color. In the present studies, only ownership and daily use of a touch device was assessed. As almost all participants owned a smartphone and used it daily, the conclusions based on an analysis with this subset remain the same. A more subtle distinction between different levels of experience might have offered divergent results and could be considered in future studies with special regard to the influence of semantic features. In addition, color is a feature which is very simple and easy to discriminate and which can easily be perceived, irrespective of language and visual acuity. In this context, negative consequences of similarity grouping should be examined in greater detail. McDougald and Wogalter ([@CR44]) have already reported a disadvantage when irrelevant areas are highlighted by colors. Likewise, an uncontrolled similarity of colored app icons (e.g. many blue social media apps such as Twitter, Facebook, Skype, etc. on one screen) could have its cost in the form of a longer search time compared to unique colors, especially for icon-congested screens. The discriminability of colors on different screen types and across diverse user groups (e.g. elderly users) are also important topics to consider in order to ensure a more efficient visual search on mobile touch devices. Limitations of present research {#Sec33} ------------------------------- Although it was a first approximation to include a second screen to the search task with swiping, an important aspect of touch device use, future work is necessary to further substantiate that colored icons improve this aspect in ecologically valid scenarios. In particular, the importance of the familiarity of app icons and their location was neglected in the present studies. In a real-life setting, the icons are not randomly distributed on a personal device and repeated interaction with the device leads to learning effects. Hence, both the context of target icons and memory of target location play a key role during icon search. In the contextual cueing paradigm, spatial configurations are associated with target position (Chun & Jiang, [@CR17]). Results consistently show that people can rapidly learn numerous target--context associations even with little attention paid to the context. Shi, Zang, Jia, Geyer, and Müller ([@CR58]) investigated the contextual cueing effect when icons are rearranged on a touch display. They rotated displays from a landscape to a portrait mode and varied which icons or rather which relationship between icons (i.e. remapping mode) changed with the display rotation. When the positional order (left to right and top to bottom) of the icons in the portrait mode was the same as that in the landscape mode, no contextual cueing gain was found. In contrast, the contextual cueing effect was replicated when only a few icons changed their position with the rotation of the display. The authors concluded that a remapping allowing a good predictability of the target position or retaining the main gist of the display facilitated the gain of contextual cueing. In line with older studies, Shi et al. ([@CR58]) also reported that the gain of context takes some time to be deployed. The question remains whether a colored icon arrangement is still beneficial for the icon search when the conditions of a memory-based search are fulfilled (i.e. the location of icons remains constant). Would the contextual gain remain observable if the search is very efficient (e.g. due to salient target features) or if semantic properties (e.g. the identity of target) are relevant during the search process? Geyer et al. ([@CR30]) have demonstrated that contextual cueing facilitates target detection on an early locus of the selection process. They conducted three studies in which they investigated the contextual cueing effect of singleton colored and singleton orientation targets, respectively. The results revealed a robust contextual cueing effect in these pop-out search situations. They concluded: "As a result, a memory-based guidance signal (contextual cueing) may reinforce bottom-up saliency computations, expediting and enhancing target pop-out." (Geyer et al., [@CR30], p. 8). In other words, repeated item locations even facilitate visual search if a "pop-out" stimulus guides attention (i.e. efficient search). Consequently, the familiarity of the icon arrangement on mobile touch devices might be also an important factor, even in search conditions which have led to a very efficient search in the present studies (e.g. high TDS). Concerning semantic features, it is not yet clear to what extent the target-defining information (*what* information, e.g. identity and semantics of the target) modulates the contextual cueing effect (related to the *where* information, Geyer et al., [@CR30]). On the one hand, the spatial domain has often been emphasized in contextual learning (e.g. Olson & Chun, [@CR53]). Consistently, the spatial configurations (*where* information) dominated the semantic properties (*what* information) of items (Jiang & Song, [@CR33]), and the gain of contextual cueing did not depend on identity information (Nabeta, Ono, & Kawahara, [@CR50]). Hence, the benefit of grouping by color similarity might fade in a situation of a fixed icon arrangement on a mobile touch device. On the other hand, semantic properties can facilitate perceptual and mnemonic processes (e.g. Konkle, Brady, Alvarez, & Oliva, [@CR37]). More recently, Makovski ([@CR43]) concluded that contextual learning was found only when spatial (*where*) information and semantic (*what*) information were repeated together. He replicated the contextual cueing effect in a visual search task for images of real-world objects. Hence, semantic properties (*what* information) might be beneficial, even if the spatial arrangement (where information) is held constant. One way that semantic features might facilitate visual search on mobile touch devices even if the spatial positions of icons remained constant is the formation of semantic groups. Such semantic groups might comprise icons for sports apps or icons for news apps (similarity by content or categorical effect, e.g. Jonides & Gleitman, [@CR34]; Schmidt & Zelinsky, [@CR56]). The perception of semantically similar items could then be supported by coloring (e.g. Duncan, [@CR21]; Smilek, Dixon, & Merikle, [@CR60]). In the presented studies, semantic information was only partially included but neither relevant for the search nor for visualizing the target before the search. In both studies, the target was presented visually, which was accompanied by an app name only in Study 2. Thus, even though an additional comparison between the reaction time patterns of Study 1 (semantic information excluded) and Study 2 (semantic information included) revealed very similar patterns for both studies (compare [Appendix](#Sec35){ref-type="sec"}), there is no conclusion to be drawn about the impact of semantic processes on the relation between color grouping and search efficiency. Moreover, other authors (Brumby & Zhuang, [@CR12]) have already been able to show that a fit between visual and semantic grouping can support search efficiency in human--computer interaction. In sum, the influence of saliency, semantic features, as well as memory determines the efficiency of target selection in complex search scenes and underline that the investigation of target memory and contextual cueing effects on mobile icon search should be one of the next approximations to a more realistic use case of the present research ideas. In regard to the present results, colored icons might be beneficial when the arrangement of icons is not yet familiar (e.g. a new device) or when conditions of a memory-based search do not exist (e.g. change of display mode). Further, it might support a memory-based or semantically based search if previous positions or semantic categories were highlighted. Then, similarity grouping might guide the attention rather indirectly. In an ongoing study, we are investigating the effect of fixed target locations and categorical learning on search efficiency and UX of a mobile icon search. The interaction with similarity grouping will also be considered. With regard to individualized app design and UX, the user might choose the mapping of app content and color (e.g. all icons representing sports activities are colored in green). It would also be interesting to transfer similarity grouping results to self-chosen groups and location arrangements. Conclusion {#Sec34} ========== A total of 1.9 billion smartphone users in 2015 (Statista, [@CR61]) and billions of app-store downloads (Wikipedia, [@CR71]) reveal a huge diversity of functional add-ons that aim at supporting users in different everyday activities. Quick and easy installation and low prices lead to a steadily increasing availability of apps. Thus, the users' intention to increase their productivity or to fulfill their (hedonistic) needs through the use of certain apps is faced with a complex and often inefficient visual search task, arising from the increasing number of apps, the mobile use environment, complex motoric responses, and from limited degrees of freedom of icon arrangement. Considering that user-centered app design is incapable of changing the first three of these factors, we tackled the dilemma by optimizing icon design to further support users during their search for a specific app icon. To this extent, we applied prior findings regarding the benefit of attentional guidance by similarity grouping in visual search to the context of mobile touch devices with the help of universally applicable colored icons. Even though typical app icons already make use of color, no phone or software provider has yet presented a color scheme that is consistent across different apps and that supports the visual search for the desired app. Our results show that the efficiency of visual search on mobile touch devices can be modeled by color-based guidance, as predicted by basic research. Thus, color made it possible to group similar stimuli even though all stimuli were as complex as typical app icons. This effect remained significant when participants had to swipe between two screens. The benefit in search efficiency was also reflected in an increased UX. However, the presented studies can only offer the first step when designing for a more supportive search environment. Future studies should consider cognitive processes when imagining the target icon, spatial learning, individual differences in organization preferences, and negative consequences of grouping. Nevertheless, the guidance of attention by color might offer a simple way to enhance interaction with mobile touch devices. Moreover, it can go along with empowering users to personalize their devices to match their hedonistic and pragmatic needs. Appendix {#Sec35} ======== Comparison of the reaction time in Study 1 and Study 2 {#Sec36} ------------------------------------------------------ Due to the fact that Study 1 and Study 2 were based on different experimental designs, a comparison between the two studies cannot easily be drawn. While there was only one search screen per trial with one of three different set sizes in Study 1 (8, 16, 24), we presented two search screens (24 icons each) connected with a swipe in Study 2. Additionally, while the target could be either present or absent in Study 1, it was always present on one of the two screens in Study 2. Hence, there are only two meaningful comparisons of reaction time between the two studies. First, we can draw a comparison between the condition "target present -- 24 icons" (Study 1) and the condition "target on 1st screen, no swipes" (Study 2) because the requested reaction (to tap the icon) and the set size was the same. Second, we can draw a comparison between reaction time in the condition "target not present -- 24 icons" (Study 1) and time until the first swipe in the condition "target on 2nd screen" (Study 2). The latter comparison is also built upon a similar requested reaction (to indicate that the target is not present by either tapping a gray box or a swiping movement) and the same set size. The reaction time in these conditions is presented in Fig. [6](#Fig6){ref-type="fig"}.Fig. 6Averaged reaction times of Study 1 and Study 2 in those conditions with 24 icons and a target on the first presented screen (*upper panel*) and in those conditions with 24 icons and the target not present on the first presented screen (*lower panel*) Figure 6 shows the similar effect of the similarity condition on reaction time in both studies. However, the reactions were slower on average in Study 2 when the target was present. When the target was not present, the reaction times were very similar but the slowest search condition was more pronounced in Study 1. These results could be due to changes in the experimental design, such as smaller icons and an overall smaller display in Study 2, a differing icon set in the two studies, or the additional presentation of a sematic feature (name) during the presentation of the target app in Study 2. Analysis of the swipe data of Study 2 {#Sec37} ------------------------------------- In Study 2, participants were confronted with icons distributed between two search screens. They were free to navigate between the two screens by swiping as often as they liked, even though they did not need to swipe at all in half of the trials to find the target icon. In the other half of the trials, one swipe was sufficient to navigate to the target icon. However, participants showed additional and unnecessary swipes in 6.1% of all the correctly answered trials and in 38.2% of the incorrectly answered trials. The unnecessary swipes were especially common in the less efficient conditions. When both TDS and DDS were high, participants performed unnecessary swipes in 13.0% of the correct trials. When TDS was high and DDS was low, the frequency of these swipes was 8.2%. In the TDS low conditions, the percentage of trials with unnecessary swipes was much smaller: 0.2% when DDS was high and 3.0% when DDS was low. Overall, the data indicate that the reaction time increases with each swipe. When using the number of swipes to predict the reaction time of all correctly answered trials in a linear regression, the slope value indicates that the reaction time increases by 2904 ms with each additional swipe, *t* = 68.41, *p* \< 0.001. However, this could be an overestimation due to the few data points with very long reaction times and many unnecessary swipes. Repeating the analysis with only those trials with up to two swipes (98.2% of all the correctly answered trials), the slope value indicates that the reaction time increases by 1579 ms with each additional swipe, *t* = 41.21, *p* \< 0.001. DDS : Distractor--distractor similarity ges : Generalized eta-square TDS : Target--distractor similarity UX : User experience Due to the fact that participants were able to move freely while seated during the trials, the distance between the participants' eyes and the device was variable (approx. 30--50 cm). Therefore, the visual degree of the icons was in the approximate range of 2.8--4.8° in the first study and 1.2--1.9° in the second study. The data analysis of Study 1 was rerun without the outlier analysis, which did not affect the conclusions. There were three additional questions in the interview regarding: (1) the search strategies during the experiment; (2) the organization strategy of apps on the personal mobile device; and (3) the attractiveness of giving apps a colored frame. The results for these questions are not presented in this paper. We reran the data analysis of Study 2 without the outlier analysis. This did not affect the conclusions. We would like to thank Thomas Geyer, an anonymous reviewer, and Jeromy Wolfe for their helpful comments during the revision process. We thank André Pohl for his effort implementing the first experiment and collecting the data during his bachelor thesis, Hans Trukenbrod for statistical advice and for implementing the balancing procedure of the first experiment, and Niklas von Kalkreuth for the first draft of the search surface and collecting the data of Study 2 together with Johanna Reibke. We thank Avner Shahal for his valuable input and Richard Holmes for language support. Availability of data and materials {#FPar1} ================================== The dataset and the analysis supporting the conclusions of this article were deposited on osf.io: osf.io/5t8sc. AKT was central to the main idea, experimental design, data analysis, and interpretation. She supervised a Bachelor thesis in which context the data were collected. Prof. Dr. CW was central to the theoretical framework and the discussion. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript. Authors' information {#FPar2} ==================== AKT is a PhD student at the chair of cognitive psychology and cognitive ergonomics at the Technische Universität of Berlin. Her research interests include applying cognitive psychology to human--computer interactions and understanding how users evaluate experiences with technical devices. CW is a professor at the University of Würzburg. She received her Ph.D. in cognitive psychology from the TU Berlin. Her main research interests include human--machine interaction, applied cognitive psychology, and social behavior in virtual reality. Ethics approval and consent to participate {#FPar3} ========================================== All participants read and signed a consent form according to the WMA Declaration of Helsinki. For the second study, we additionally answered a questionnaire by the local ethics committee. Based on our answers and the premise of our honesty, the ethics committee certified that the study showed no disagreement with ethical guidelines regarding privacy, anonymity of data, and basic ethical behavior in a scientific context. Consent for publication {#FPar4} ======================= See paragraph "Ethics approval and consent to participate". Competing interests {#FPar5} =================== The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Publisher's Note {#FPar6} ================ Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

\section{Introduction} Gravity theories in space-time dimensions greater than four have been studied extensively ever since the seminal papers of Kaluza and Klein on unification of gravity and gauge forces were published in the early twentieth century. Modern attempts at unification of forces at the quantum level, supergravity and super string theory are formulated in eleven and ten dimensions respectively. Low scale gravity models proposed by Arkani Hamed, Dimopolous and Dvali~\cite{ADD} or Randall and Sundrum ~\cite{RS1}~\cite{RS2} to explain the hierarchy problem are also formulated in dimensions greater than four. In all these models bulk extra dimensions have to be compactified or made small by warping to explain why the observed universe has only four space-time dimensions. These extra dimensional gravity models admit black hole or black brane solutions. Masses of these black objects could range from the fundamental Planck scale of the theory up to astrophysical mass scales of millions of solar masses. Microscopic black holes in these models would have sizes smaller than the scale of compactification while large astrophysical black objects would more likely be black strings or branes. Planck scales in these models could vary from standard $M_P=2.4 \times10^{15} $ TeV down to 1 TeV, in low scale gravity models. In particular, low scale gravity models admit microscopic black holes of TeV mass. Such objects could be produced in particle accelerators like the LHC \cite{dimopoulos} or in collisions of high energy cosmic rays with matter \cite{cosmic}. Most of the studies investigating black hole production at the LHC assume that the produced black holes are of the standard Schwarzschild-Tangherlini type and will decay almost instantaneously into elementary particles via Hawking radiation~\cite{production}. An exception is the recent work of Giddings and Mangano \cite{giddings}, which examines the consequences of the very conservative assumption that Hawking radiation does not exist at all and conclude that TeV scale black holes produced at the LHC would pose no risk to the Earth over its lifetime. In this paper we will investigate the fate of the black hole relics in a model, which incorporates standard Hawking radiation but in which black hole masses have a lower bound. Upon approaching the mass bound the Hawking temperature of these black holes goes to zero and they become stable in vacuum. Their cross section for collisions with elementary particles and each other would, however, stay finite, leading to observable consequences when they come into contact with matter or collide with each other inside stars or in the galaxy. If there are stable microscopic primordial black holes then one has to confront the possibility that they could have a relic density large enough to over close the universe. For this to become a serious issue the temperature of the universe at some epoch has to be comparable to the minimum stable mass of the black holes so that they could be produced in particle collisions. For the current discussion we assume that the reheating temperature of the universe after inflation is always much less than the minimum mass of the black holes. We plan to discuss the issue of the relic density of stable Lovelock black hole remnants in another publication. According to our hypothesis all primordial black holes, or black holes produced by cosmic rays, that would otherwise have decayed by the present epoch should end up in (or very close to) the minimal mass end state. Such black holes contribute to or may even dominate dark matter. Their number can only decrease in collisions with each other or by absorption by macroscopic black holes. We will discuss the passage of stable black holes through matter and point out that their interaction with matter would have a characteristic signature, detectable in underground experiments. Lovelock gravity theories admit black hole solutions with a limiting minimum mass and vanishing Hawking temperature. There is no reason known to us why in dimensions higher than four the contribution of Lovelock terms \cite{lovelock}, formed from higher powers of the curvature tensor, to the Einstein action should be suppressed. Now in odd dimensions the ADM masses of black holes are limited below by the coupling strength of Lovelock terms. Furthermore, when such black holes evaporate by Hawking radiation their Hawking temperature approaches zero when their ADM mass approaches the lower bound. The prime example of this is black holes in 5-d Einstein Gauss-Bonnet gravity. Therefore, such a scenario is not completely in the realm of phantasy. Since the world has 4 non-compact dimensions on macroscopic scales, we need to compactify all but four of the odd number of dimensions in which the stable minimum mass black holes live. If the size of a black hole is smaller than the compactification scale, then the caged black hole should still have a stable minimum mass. A systematic expansion in the inverse of the compactification scale for black holes in Einstein gravity has been studied in the past \cite{harmark} \cite{karasik}. Lovelock black holes can be embedded into a higher dimensional space, turning the black holes into black branes in those extra dimensions. While we return to the discussion of these questions in the last section of this paper we will study these and similar problems more extensively in a future publication. A simpler alternative, of trying to compactify all dimensions beyond 4 at the same scale in Gauss-Bonnet gravity has recently been attempted \cite{blackbrane}. Though a minimal mass exists in such a scenario, but the Hawking temperature does not vanish and consequently black branes are not stable at the minimal mass. The consequences of Gauss-Bonnet gravity on black hole phenomenology have already been considered by Rizzo~\cite{rizzo1}~\cite{rizzo} concentrating on the signature of TeV-scale stable black holes produced at LHC, and by Alexeyev, Barrau, Boudoul, Khovanskaya, and Sahzin \cite{alexeyev} in the framework of an ADD \cite{ADD} or Randall-Sundrum II \cite{RS2} model with limiting masses of macroscopic range (1 $g$- $10^{18}\, g)$. We would like to concentrate on models in which the minimal mass of black holes is comparable or below the 4 dimensional Planck mass. Such a mass limit would be natural for example in the framework of a Randall-Sundrum \cite{RS1} scenario, ADD theory in 9 or 11 dimensions, or Kaluza-Klein models in 11 dimensions and some string-inspired models of compactification. Though Schwarzschild-Lovelock black holes in odd dimensions are at the back of our minds, our investigations are fairly independent of specific models. They require the knowledge of a few basic parameters, namely the coupling strength of the Lovelock terms, to describe the near-minimal mass behavior of these solutions. We assume that all non-topological Lovelock terms are present in the Lagrangian and all of their couplings are in the scale of the Planck mass. It is worth mentioning that higher order corrections to heterotic string theories contribute a Gauss-Bonnet term (second order Lovelock term) to the classical action \cite{heterotic}, \cite{boulware}. When all the Lovelock coefficients are of $O(1)$, black holes or black branes with $M>>M_P$ are well described by the Schwarzschild-Tangherlini metric, their behavior is quite standard and well described by Einstein gravity. In this paper we will concentrate on black holes with masses close to the minimum mass of the order of $M_P$, when Lovelock terms play an important role leading to significant phenomenological consequences. In the current paper we have not addressed questions pertaining to detection of stable microscopic black hole remnants by direct dark matter detection experiments \cite{dama}, \cite{cdms}. On one hand, if the minimum mass of these black holes is close to 1 TeV, then we will show that their abundance must be extremely low compared to other components of dark matter to avoid a contradiction with proton decay experiments. On the other hand, if their mass is much higher it could be difficult to detect them in direct dark matter detection experiments. Finally, to close this section we list the issues we intend to address in the rest of this paper. (i) Stable minimal mass black holes aggregate in clumps under the influence of gravity. Then they will form part (or all) of dark matter. This effect was considered for macroscopic stable black holes by Alexeyev et. al. \cite{alexeyev}, and for even larger, astronomical size black holes by Frampton \cite{frampton}, as well. These black holes may accumulate inside stars depending on the parton cross section, their velocity distribution, and the gravity at the surface of the star. We will discuss the rate of heat production by the collision of accumulated black holes and compare it to that of "standard" WIMPs \cite{kouvaris}. (ii) Black holes, as part of dark matter, would collide with partons while passing through detectors in underground laboratories. These collisions would be followed by a characteristic decay that is quite different from those of Schwarzschild black holes. Using past proton decay experiments we are able to give a rough lower bound on the minimum mass of stable black holes and/or their abundance compared to other dark matter constitutents. We also propose an experimental investigation of finding stable black holes in underground laboratories. (iii) Relativistic black holes produced by cosmic rays \cite{cosmic} passing through stars or planets may evaporate to minimal size or increase in size by accretion depending on the interaction cross section. We estimate what is the lowest energy of incoming cosmic rays that allows black holes to increase in size and accrete all available matter in a star. \section{Lovelock black holes in odd dimensions} As we mentioned in the introduction our investigations are largely independent of the choice of a specific gravity model. We only assume that black holes have a minimal mass, at which the Hawking temperature vanishes. Lovelock black holes \cite{lovelock} in odd dimensions are prime examples satisfying these constraints. Gravitational theories including Lovelock terms are perfectly acceptable, as their field equations contain only second order derivatives and satisfy standard requirements on a classical theory of gravity just as much as Einstein gravity does. The langrangian of the $n$th order Lovelock term, $L_n$, is built from an antisymmetrized combination of the $n$th power of the curvature tensor. In $D$ dimensions a linear combination of Lovelock terms up to $n=(D-1)/2$, such as \begin{equation} L=R+\sum_{n=2}^{(D-1)/2} M_P^{2(n-4)}\alpha_n L_n \label{lagrangian} \end{equation} contribute non-trivially to the equations of motion. Note that $n=0$ corresponds to the cosmological constant, the $n=1$ term is Einstein gravity, and Gauss-Bonnet gravity corresponds to $n=2$. We extract an appropriate power of the Planck mass to make the coupling constants $\alpha_n$ dimensionless. Also note that we use $M_P$ as a unknown quantity, dependent on $D$, to be determined by experiments. We also keep the coupling constants, $\alpha_n$ as free parameters, but when we need to make an estimate of an observable quantity we will often consider predictions under the assumption $\alpha_n=O(1)$, or, alternatively $M_{\rm min}\simeq M_P$, where $M_{\rm min}$ is the minimal mass. We use a definition of Newton's constant in terms of the Planck mass of the "Particle Data Book" \cite{databook}, \begin{equation} 8\pi G_D=(2\pi)^{D-4}M_P^{2-D} \end{equation} With this definition the experimental lower bound on $M_P$ is $M_P\geq 1$ TeV \cite{databook}. This bound was calculated assuming Schwarzschild-Tangherlini black holes. We expect that the lower bound on the Planck mass when black holes have a minimal mass is somewhat lower. The reason for that is the small amount of radiation produced when the black holes approach the minimal mass. Since it barely radiates one could only recognize its production by the missing energy that could have been taken away by other neutral particles. Analytic spherically symmetric black hole solutions have been found for $n=2$ \cite{boulware}\cite{wiltshire}\cite{myers} and 3 \cite{dehghani} Lovelock gravity. While in even dimensions black hole masses have no lower bound, in odd dimensions the mass is limited by the Lovelock coupling $\alpha_n$, to ensure the existence of a horizon. In particular for $D=5$ and 7 \begin{equation} (\mu^{(D)}M_P)^{D-3}\geq(D-3)!\alpha_{(D-1)/2}. \label{bounds} \end{equation} In (\ref{bounds}) $\mu^{(D)}$ is the radius of horizon for the $D$-dimensional Tangherlini black hole \cite{giddings} \begin{equation} \mu^{(D)}=\frac{1}{M_P}\left(\frac{k_DM_{\rm ADM}}{M_P}\right)^{1/(D-3)}, \label{mass} \end{equation} where \begin{equation} k_D=\frac{2(2\pi)^{D-4}}{(D-2)\Omega^{(D-2)}}, \end{equation} and \begin{equation} \Omega^{(D-2)}=\frac{2\pi^{(D-1)/2}}{\Gamma[(D-1)/2]}. \end{equation} Using the latter equations the lower bounds on the ADM mass are \begin{eqnarray} M&> &M_{\rm min}^{(5)}=3\pi\alpha_2M_P,\nonumber\\ M&> &M_{\rm min}^{(7)}=\frac{15}{2}\alpha_3M_P \end{eqnarray} for $D=5$ and $D=7$, respectively. It is worth noting that the minimal mass is larger than the Planck mass if the coupling of the Lovelock terms, $\alpha_n=O(1)$. This result may be of significance if we consider the stability of minimum masses under quantum gravity. It is possible that quantum effects destabilize classically stable black holes. In what follows, we assume that even if that were true, their lifetimes are long enough to leave our classical calculations valid. The radius of horizon is \begin{eqnarray} r_h^{(5)}&=&M_P^{-1}\sqrt{(\mu^{(5)}M_P)^2-2\alpha_2},\nonumber\\ r_h^{(7)}&=&M_P^{-1}\sqrt{-6\alpha_2+\sqrt{(\mu^{(7)}M_P)^4-24\alpha_3+36\alpha_2^2}}, \label{radius} \end{eqnarray} in 5 and 7 dimensions, respectively. The Hawking temperature in 5 dimensions is \begin{equation} T_H=M_P\frac{\sqrt{(\mu^{(5)}M_P)^2-2\alpha_2}}{2\pi ((\mu^{(5)}M_P)^2+2\alpha_2)}. \label{hawking} \end{equation} In $D$=7 the expression for $T_H$ is much more complicated, but also proportional to the radius of horizon, as in $D=5$. The reason for this is simple. In odd dimensions the metric functions are even functions of the radius and the surface gravity is proportional to $dg_{tt}/dr$. Then both of these theories the radius of horizon and the Hawing temperature vanish as $\sim\sqrt{M-M_{\rm min}}$. This is a general feature of theories we consider in this paper. Strictly speaking minimum mass black holes do not exist. Scalars, like the curvature scalar, square of the Ricci tensor, and the Kretschmann scalar all diverge at zero radial coordinate, when the radius of the horizon vanishes. This state is, however, never reached in the semi-classical theory because, as is shown by (\ref{timedependence}), it takes infinite time for the mass of a black hole produced with $M>M_{\rm min}$ to reach $M_{\rm min}$ . While at sufficiently large mass, $M>M_P$, the Hawking temperature approaches its value in Einstein gravity $T_H\simeq(2\pi r_h)^{-1}$, at $M\simeq M_{\rm min}$ in Lovelock gravity it can be parametrized by the constants, $M_P$ and $\alpha_n$ as \begin{eqnarray} T_H^{(5)}&\simeq &\frac{M_P}{\sqrt{2\alpha_2}}\sqrt{\frac{M}{M_{\rm min}^{(5)}}-1}=\sqrt{\frac{3\pi}{2}}\frac{M_P^{3/2}\sqrt{M-M_{\rm min}^{(5)}}}{M_{\rm min}^{(5)}}\nonumber\\\ T_H^{(7)}&\simeq &\frac{M_P}{3}\sqrt{\frac{2\alpha_3}{\alpha_2}}\sqrt{\frac{M}{M_{\rm min}^{(7)}}-1} \end{eqnarray} In general we may parametrize the dependence of the Hawking temperature on the minimal mass by the two parameters $M_s$ and $M_P$ as \begin{equation} T_H\simeq \,M_s \sqrt{\frac{M}{M_{\rm min}}-1}, \label{hawking2} \end{equation} where $M_s ,M_{\rm min}=O(M_P)$. We will use this formula in all subsequent calculations. However, whenever we need concrete numbers for calculating a particular phenomenon related to stable black holes we will rely on the 5 dimensional formulas, which, hopefully, give a good order of magnitude estimate in higher dimensional spaces, as well. \section{Stable black holes as components of dark matter} If black holes become stable after approaching a nonzero minimal mass then their number can only be reduced by collisions with each other, when the mass of one of the black holes is converted into radiation. Therefore, most primordial black holes and those produced later by cosmic rays should still be around at the present time. For large black holes the higher dimensional Lovelock terms become irrelevant and the Schwarzschild approximation is valid. Thus, the spectrum of black holes produced after inflation is unaffected by them. Hawking and Page \cite{hawking} have shown that primordial black holes lighter than $10^{15}$ g would have decayed by now. However, in odd dimensional Lovelock theory they would have all ended up in the near-minimal mass state. These black holes, along with small black holes produced later, would form part of dark matter. In the current section we investigate the effect of such a component of dark matter and derive bounds on their minimal mass, $M_{\rm min}$, and their relative abundance compared to other components of dark matter. First we show that for a very wide range of the Planck mass, $M_P$, and of minimal mass, $M_{\rm min}$, the passage of non-relativistic black holes through matter follows a simple pattern: A minimal mass black hole accretes a parton or an electron increasing the mass and the Hawking temperature of the black hole. The accretion is followed by the rapid decay of the black hole towards the minimal mass state, very probably before the next accretion takes place. This sequence of events allows us to derive a recursion relation for the velocity distribution and an integral equation for the limiting distribution. Not surprisingly, in view of the central limit theorem, the solution of the integral equation is a Maxwell distribution. It is interesting that the average velocity in the limiting distribution, depending on $M_{\rm min},$ can be higher than average velocity of incoming dark matter particles. Using the velocity distribution we show that in neutron stars the near-stable black holes are confined to a sphere of radius $r\lesssim 100$ m where they reach an equilibrium density in a few decades after the formation of the neutron star. In equilibrium, the number of black holes annihilated in pairwise collisions is equal to the number of black holes captured by the neutron star from dark matter. We will also show that black holes cannot be captured by ordinary stars, if $M_{\rm min}=O$(1 TeV), as the velocity of most of black holes exceeds the escape velocity. However, if $M_{\rm min},\,M_P\gtrsim 100$ TeV, then their velocity is smaller and the captured black holes accumulate inside the sun, as well. At the end of this section we will investigate the experimental signature of stable black holes passing through experimental devices. The signature is quite universal. It is in large measure independent of the minimal mass, up to $M_{\rm min}\simeq10^5$ TeV, and of the velocity of the black holes. \subsection{Decay of near minimal mass black holes in vacuum} When we calculate the decay of black holes we can use the Schwarzschild metric for black holes with $M>>M_{\rm min}$, while (\ref{hawking2}) can be applied to black holes with $M\lesssim 2M_{\rm min}$. Considering that standard model particles live on a 3 brane the radiation happens mainly on the brane \cite{emparan}. Then the decay rate of near minimal black holes in vacuum is \begin{equation} \frac{dM}{dt}=-g\frac{ \pi^2 }{120}4\pi r_h^2T_H^4=-g\frac{\pi^3}{30}M_s^2\left(\frac{M}{M_{\rm min}^{(5)}}-1\right)^3 \label{decayrate} \end{equation} where $g$ is the number of effective degrees of freedom. In 7 dimensions an extra factor of 2/9 should be included on the right hand side of (\ref{decayrate}). Note that, unlike for Schwarzschild black holes, in a theory with stable black holes the contribution of emission into the bulk is negligible when $M$ is close to $M_{min}$. The contribution of bulk radiation to (\ref{decayrate}) would have higher powers of $r_h$ and $T_H$, both vanishing when $r_h\to 0$. Integrating (\ref{decayrate}) gives \begin{equation} M(t)=M_{\rm min}+\frac{\Delta M}{\sqrt{1+t\frac{\pi^3 g M_s^2}{15 M_{\rm min}^3}(\Delta M)^2 }}, \label{timedependence} \end{equation} where $\Delta M= M(0)-M_{\rm min}$ is the energy gained by the absorption of a parton. The half-time (time required to reach $M(t_{1/2})=(M(0)+M_{\rm min})/2$ is \begin{equation} t_{1/2}\simeq 0.06\frac{M_{\rm min}}{M_s^2}\left(\frac{M_{\rm min}}{\Delta M}\right)^2. \label{halftime} \end{equation} When non-relativistic black holes travel through matter they absorb partons from atomic nuclei. Since they cannot leave colored matter behind, they must pull out an antiparton from the chromosphere of the black hole, as well. Altogether, they only gain about a mass of $\Delta M=O(0.5$GeV). Note that $\Delta M$ is, in a very good approximation, independent of $M_{\rm min}$. When, following the accretion process, owing to the limited available total mass, $\Delta M$, they can only emit light degrees of freedom, mostly photons, electrons, positrons, neutrinos and antineutrinos, with an occasional muon or pion. Then the effective number of degrees of freedom, including greybody factors \cite{anchordoqui} is $g\simeq 23\, \, 2/3$. Note that for 7 dimensional black holes the prefactor in (\ref{halftime}) should be decreased to 0.03. Applied to 5 dimensional black holes we obtain the following expression for $t_{1/2}$ \begin{equation} t_{1/2}=0.013\frac{M_{\rm min}^2}{M_P^3}\left(\frac{M_{\rm min}}{\Delta M}\right)^2\simeq 5.2\times10^4\,{\rm TeV}^{-1}\frac{M_{\rm min}^4}{M_P^3} \label{fivelifetime} \end{equation} Note that here and all in subsequent equations $M_P$ and $M_{\rm min}$ are measured in units of TeV and are therefore dimensionless. As we will see below, the decay time (\ref{fivelifetime}) is much shorter than the average time between collisions. Then it follows that the passage through ordinary matter is a series of accretions of partons each followed by almost instantaneous decay back to near minimal mass. \subsection{Cross section of TeV scale black holes} For the sake of definiteness we will consider black holes in a RS I scenario. A classical calculation of the Bondi-Hoyle-Littleton accretion can be performed by considering the geodesics of pointlike incoming particles at impact parameter $b$. If the impact parameter is smaller than the compactification radius then the absorbtion cross section is defined by the maximal $\pi b_{\rm max}^2$, where $b_{\rm max}$ is the maximal impact parameter at which the projectile is captured by the black hole. For this calculation we must use the $D$ dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet metric in the neighborhood of the black hole. We obtain for $D=5$ \begin{equation} \sigma= 4\alpha_2 \pi v^{-2} M_P^{-2}\left(\frac{1}{2}+\frac{v}{\gamma}\right)=\frac{4}{3\, v^2}M_{\rm min}M_P^{-3}\left(\frac{1}{2}+\frac{v}{\gamma}\right), \label{cross} \end{equation} where $v$ is the relative velocity and $\gamma$ is the corresponding Lorentz factor. Since we are interested in order of magnitude estimates we use classical cross sections throughout this paper. The increase of $\sigma$ with decreasing $v$ is due to the increase of the maximal impact parameter at which the particle is captured. However, at large impact parameters the 5 dimensional metric is no longer applicable, because at large distances from the black hole the metric becomes effectively 4 dimensional, with standard 4 dimensional gravitation strength, which hardly causes any deflection of particles. The transition between the 5 and 4 dimensional behaviors happens at $r\simeq m_r^{-1}$ where $m_r$ is the radion mass. The largest lower bound on the radion mass, 120 GeV, has been derived in \cite{lower}. We are not aware of upper bounds. To incorporate the low velocity cutoff imposed by the radion mass we modified our calculation of the cross section by using the simple minded assumption that the metric reduces to Minkowski metric at distances larger than $r_{\rm max}=m_r^{-1}$. Then at $m_r<<M_P$ and $v<<1$ \begin{equation} \sigma\simeq\frac{\pi}{m_r^2}. \label{sigrad} \end{equation} For larger black holes the cross section can be calculated from the Schwarzschild metric. One obtains \cite{unruh} \begin{equation} \sigma=4\pi \mu_D^2, \end{equation} where $\mu_D$ is given in (\ref{mass}). In particular, for $D=5$ \begin{equation} \sigma=\frac{4}{3} M M_P^{-3} \label{largemass} \end{equation} \subsection{Mean free path of black holes} The mean free path in a medium is given by $l=(\sigma \rho)^{-1}$, where $\rho$ is the number density and $\sigma$ is the collision cross section. To get a rough estimate of the mean free path we will use the absorption cross section. We will discuss neutron stars first. Nuclear matter has the parton number density, with about 3 partons per neutron \begin{equation} \rho=4\times 10^{-12}{\rm TeV}^3. \end{equation} Then using (\ref{cross}) and (\ref{sigrad}), we obtain \begin{equation} 1.1 \times10^9 \,{\rm TeV}^{-1}\leq\ell_n =\frac{1}{\rho \sigma}\leq3.8\times 10^{11}\, {\rm TeV}^{-1}\frac{M_P^3}{M_{\rm min}} \label{nuclear} \end{equation} where the upper limit is given by the minimum of (\ref{cross}), at $\gamma\to\infty$ and the lower limit by (\ref{sigrad}) at the minimum radion mass \cite{lower} $m_r=$120 GeV. However, if $M_P > 10$ TeV, then the velocity dependent classical formula gives a larger lower bound then the one obtained using the minimum radion mass ($\langle v^2\rangle=x \,\Delta M \,M_{\rm min}^{-1}$ will be calculated in the next subsection): \begin{equation} 3.8\times 10^{11}\, {\rm TeV}^{-1}\langle v^2\rangle\frac{M_P^3}{M_{\rm min}}=2\times 10^{8}\, {\rm TeV}^{-1}x\frac{M_P^3}{M_{\rm min}^2}\leq\ell_n \label{nuclear2} \end{equation} The lower bound (\ref{nuclear2}) ensures that black holes undergo many collisions in nuclear matter (or in stars), except in the case when our mass parameters, $M_P$ and $M_{\rm min}$ are at the upper end of the range of interest, near $M_P\sim M_{\rm min}\gtrsim 10^{15}$. Then the mean free path becomes larger than a few km and most black holes undergo a small number of collisions only. Since the number of collisions inside the star largely depend on the total mass only, a similar statement applies to a star, like our sun, as well. The corresponding bounds on the mean free path in water are \begin{equation} 600\,{\rm km}\frac{M_P^3}{M_{\rm min}}\geq \ell_w \geq \begin{cases} 2.9 \,{\rm km}\\ 0.3\,{\rm km}\,\,x\,\frac{M_P^3}{M_{\rm min}^2} \end{cases} \label{water} \end{equation} where the first lower bound is obtained using cross section (\ref{sigrad}), while the second using (\ref{cross}) at low $v$. These numbers will be important when we will discuss experimental constraints on $M_{\rm min}$ and $\delta$, the fraction of dark matter in the form of microscopic stable black holes. While passing through earth black holes undergo a large number of collisions, unless $M_P>$ is very large. The limits for water, (\ref{water}), should be divided by 5.5. Even though they collide with nuclei many times inside the earth, the earth cannot capture black holes, because, as we show in the next subsection, their average velocity, $\langle v\rangle=O(10^{-2}\,c)$ is orders of magnitude higher than the escape velocity. Let us compare now the decay time of black holes with the collision time in nuclear matter. The average time between collisions is $t_c= \ell_n /v$. In the next subsection we will determine the average speed of black holes, dependent only on having a large number of collisions and largely independent of the matter density. We will obtain $v\simeq 0.5 \sqrt{\Delta M\, \rm /M_{\rm min}}\simeq0.01\,M_{\rm min}^{-1/2}$. Using (\ref{nuclear}) and taking the accreted energy $\Delta M\simeq0.5$ GeV in each collision, we obtain the following expression for the ratio of collision time and decay time in nuclear matter \begin{equation} 6.8\times 10^9 \frac{M_P^6}{M_{\rm min}^{9/2}} \geq\frac{t_c}{t_{1/2}}\geq \begin{cases}1.8\times 10^8\frac{M_P^3}{M_{\rm min}^{7/2}} \\ 3.8\times 10^7\,x\, \frac{M_P^6}{M_{\rm min}^{11/2}} \end{cases} \label{ratio} \end{equation} Taking the root of the product of the two lower limit, setting $M_P\simeq M_{\rm min}$, and using the very conservative value $x=0.2$ we obtain a lower limit that is independent of $M_P$, namely $t_c\, / t_{1/2}\geq9\times 10^{7}.$ Even in the center of the neutron star where the density is 2-3 times higher than that of nuclear matter the ratio is much larger than 1. The important message in (\ref{ratio}) is that the passage of black holes through any medium, including the core of neutron stars, follows a simple pattern. After a $M\simeq M_{\rm min}$ black hole collides with and absorbs a parton its excess mass evaporates long before the next collision to become a $M\simeq M_{\rm min}$ black hole again. This sequence will be important in the next subsection in which we investigate the velocity distribution of non-relativistic black holes close to their minimum mass in matter. \subsection{Diffusion of black holes in matter} We consider stable black holes arriving, as part of the dark matter, at a star or a planet, in which they undergo multiple collisions. For simplicity, we will consider the star as infinite matter. If the temperature of the star is low compared to the kinetic energy of incoming stable black holes one may naively think that the black holes lose velocity, until their kinetic energy reaches the ambient temperature. In fact, this is not the case at all because the inelastic collision and subsequent decay of the black holes may result in, depending on the mass of the black hole, an increase of the average velocity. The black holes are not in equilibrium with the surrounding matter, because of the long collision time compared to the decay time, as shown by (\ref{ratio}). When the black hole accretes a parton then, as an average, it slows down slightly in the star rest system. However, after accretion it decays soon approaching its minimal mass state by emitting a small number of particles and gaining extra velocity from the recoil. After multiple collisions the addition of these recoil velocities results in a random velocity distribution, which is independent of the original velocity distribution of incoming dark matter particles. The average velocity depends on $M_{\rm min}$ but as we will see below if $M_{\rm min }\lesssim 1000$ TeV then it is higher than the average velocity of dark matter particles. Let us consider the first step of the repeating two-step process, the accretion. As black holes accrete partons of energy $\Delta M$ then, as an average, their momentum is conserved in the star frame but they lose approximately the fraction $\Delta M/M_{\rm min}$ of their velocity. However, in the second step, when they subsequently radiate essentially all of the accreted $\Delta M$ energy they also gain momentum \begin{equation} p_+=- \sum_i ^nq_i, \end{equation} where $q_i$ are the momenta of emitted particles. The $n$ particles are emitted isotropically. Since the Hawking temperature $T_H>>\Delta M$ the individual particle momentum distribution can be approximated by phase space. Neglecting the mass of emitted particles the momentum gained by the black hole after the end of Hawking radiation is \begin{equation} f^{(n)}( p)=N^{-1} \int \delta\left(\vec p+\sum_i^n \vec q_i\right)\delta\left(\Delta M-\sum_i^n q_i\right)\prod_i ^nd^3q_i, \label{momentum} \end{equation} where $q_i=|\vec q_i|$ and $N$ is a normalization constant. Note that $n$, the number of particles emitted, is small, $\langle n\rangle\sim 2$, as it can be ascertained using the infinite temperature limit of the Bose-Einstein and Fermi-Dirac distributions. In particular, \begin{eqnarray} f^{(1)}(p)&=& \frac{1}{4\pi \Delta M^2}\delta(\Delta M-p),\nonumber\\ f^{(2)}(p)&=& \frac{1}{N}\left[\log\left(\frac{\Delta M+p}{\Delta M-p}\right)-\frac{p}{12\Delta M}\left(21+(p/\Delta M)^2\right)\right] \end{eqnarray} where $N=\Delta M^3\pi [\log(4096)-17]/36$. The distribution $f^{(3)}(p)$ is slightly more complicated, containing polylogarithms. Now the question is whether after successive accretions and subsequent Hawking radiations the momentum distribution approaches a limiting distribution or not. Originally the speed of the black hole is about $v\simeq 10^{- 3}c$, a typical speed for dark matter particle. The change of the speed of the black hole due to the emission of particles is $\delta v= O(p/M_{\rm min})=O(\Delta M/M_{\rm min})$. This is of the same order of magnitude as the original velocity, at least if the mass of the black hole is $M=O($1TeV). Even if the black hole has mass $M_{\rm min}>>1$TeV it loses memory of the original direction, as it undergoes a very large number of collisions. Thus, its distribution becomes isotropic (discounting the effect of the gravitational force of the star). After a few collisions the speed distribution of the black hole in homogeneous infinite matter approaches an asymptotic form determined by the integral equation \begin{equation} g(v)=\frac{1}{N} \int g\left(\vec v[1+\Delta M/M_{\rm min}]-\vec q/M_{\rm min}\right)f(q)d^3q \label{recursion} \end{equation} where the multiplier $1+m/M_{\rm min}$ is the factor by which an accretion slows down the black hole and $f(q)$ is the normalized weighted average of distributions $f^{(k)}(q)$ over $k$. As expected from the central limit theorem, the solution of (\ref{recursion}), in leading order of $\Delta M/M_{\rm min}$, is a Gaussian distribution, \begin{equation} g(v)=\left(\frac{3 \Delta M\, M_{\rm min}}{2\pi\langle q^2\rangle}\right)^{3/2} \exp\left(-\frac{3\Delta M\,M_{\rm min}\,v^2}{2\langle q^2\rangle}\right), \label{distribution} \end{equation} where \begin{equation} \langle q^2\rangle=\int q^2 f(q)d^3q = x\,\Delta M^2, \end{equation} with $x\leq1$. For massless particles the value of $x_n$ ($x$ for $n$ decay products) is $x_n=(1+3(n-1)/4)^{-1}$. The expectation value of the squared velocity is \begin{equation} \langle v^2\rangle= x \frac{\Delta M}{M_{\rm min}}\simeq 5\times 10^{-4}x\, M_{\rm min}^{-1} \label{averagevelocity} \end{equation} One would expect that the number emitted particles is small, so $1>x\gtrsim 0.2$, leading, for $M_{\rm min}\simeq$ 1 TeV, to an average velocity, $v_{\rm av}\gtrsim 10^{-2}c$. In other words, the multiple collision process {\em accelerates} the minimal mass black hole. provided $M_{\rm min}\lesssim 1000$ TeV. Eq. (\ref{distribution}) is a Maxwell distribution with $kT\lesssim 200$ MeV. It is interesting to observe that the temperature of the gas of black holes is independent of the temperature of the medium. The two different temperatures are maintained by the peculiar nature of the interaction of black holes with particles in the medium. \subsection{ Near minimum mass black holes in stars} The calculation of the average velocity in the previous section has assumed that no external forces act on the black hole. This is not true in stars and particularly in a neutron star in which the gravitational field is enormous. Using a radius of $R=$10 km, and mass of $M_n=1.5 \times M_{\rm sun}$ we obtain the gravitational potntial, $g$, as \begin{equation} g=\frac{G M_n }{R}=0.2 >> \frac{v^2}{2}\lesssim 2.5\times10^{-4}. \label{potential} \end{equation} The velocity of black holes is then much smaller than the escape velocity and the black holes start to move towards the center of the neutron star. At the center, however, the gravitational field vanishes, so the black holes rapidly reach the velocity distribution described in the previous subsection. They will be confined to a sphere the approximate radius of which is obtained from equating the average random velocity with the escape velocity on the surface of this sphere. To determine this radius we need a model for the density distribution. We choose a normalized quadratic density distribution of \begin{equation} \rho(r)=M_n\frac{30}{4\pi R^3}\left(1-\frac{r}{R}\right)^2. \end{equation} Other choices would slightly change the final result. Then near the center the gravitational potential is \begin{equation} g(r)\simeq M_n G \frac{10 \,r^2}{R^3}. \end{equation} Then using (\ref{averagevelocity}) and (\ref{potential}) we obtain the the radius, $r_c$, of the aforementioned sphere from \begin{equation} \frac{\langle v^2\rangle}{2}=g(r)=2 \frac{r^2}{R^2} \end{equation} We obtain \begin{equation} r_c=110\, {\rm m}\,\sqrt{x}\,M_{\rm min}^{-1/2}. \label{centralradius} \end{equation} Inside the sphere of radius $r_c$ black holes annihilate by colliding with each other. In an equilibrium state the number of annihilated black holes must equal the number of black holes captured by the neutron star from dark matter and from those produced by cosmic rays at the surface of the star. If minimum mass black holes constitute a fraction $\delta$ of dark matter, then using the dark matter density of 300 GeV $m^{-3}$, a radius of 10 km , and a mass of 1.5 times that of the sun we obtain the following capture rate of black holes traveling at $\sim 270$ km/s \begin{equation} N_{\rm cap}=2.5 \times 10^{16}s^{-1}\, \delta M_{\rm min}^{-1} \label{capturerate} \end{equation} The number of black holes undergoing two-body collisions in the central sphere per unit time and unit volume is \begin{equation} N_a=\rho_{\rm BH}^2 \sigma v \end{equation} Then using the Maxwell distribution (\ref{distribution}) the average relative velocity of two black holes is \begin{equation} v=4 \sqrt{\frac{x}{3\pi}}\left(\frac{\Delta M}{M_{\rm min}}\right)^{1/2} \end{equation} Now after attaining equilibrium $V N_a=N_{\rm cap}$ so the density of black holes in the central sphere is \begin{equation} \rho_{\rm BH}=\frac{N_{\rm cap}}{\sqrt{V\sigma v}}=18\, {\rm m}^{-3}\,\frac{\delta^{1/2}}{x \sqrt{\sigma /{\rm m}^2}}M_{\rm min}^{1/2} \end{equation} where $V$ is the volume of the central sphere confining the black holes. The cross section is measured in m$^2$. Now we can use our three bounds on $\sigma$ to find bounds on the density of black holes in the central region of a neutron star. Using (\ref{cross}) in the extreme relativistic limit we obtain an upper limit, while using (\ref{cross}) with $\langle v^2\rangle$ taken from (\ref{averagevelocity}) provides one of the lower bounds, and finally (\ref{sigrad}) provides another lower bound, as follows \begin{equation} 1.8\times 10^{19} \,{\rm m}^{-3}\frac{\sqrt{\delta}}{x}\,M_P^{3/2}\geq \rho_{\rm BH}\geq\begin{cases} 4\times 10^{17}\,{\rm m}^{-3}\sqrt{\frac{\delta}{x}}\,M_P^{3/2}\,M_{\rm min}^{-1/2},\\ 2.9\times 10^{18}\,{\rm m}^{-3}M_{\rm min}^{1/2}. \end{cases} \label{lower1} \end{equation} These limits can be compared with the density of partons in the central region, $\rho_p\simeq 10^{45}m^{-3}$. How long a time is needed to fill a newly created neutron star with black holes at equilibrium density? The total number of black holes in the central region divided by the rate of black hole capture provides two lower bounds on $t_{\rm fill}$, obtained from (\ref{lower1}) \begin{equation} t_{\rm fill}\geq V \frac{\rho_{\rm BH}}{N_{\rm cap}}\geq \begin{cases} 20\left(\frac{x}{\delta}\right)^{1/2}\,{\rm years}\\ 3 \frac{x}{\sqrt{\delta}}\,M_P^{3/2}\,M_{\rm min}^{-1}\,{\rm years} \end{cases} \end{equation} It is worth noting that if $M_P$ and $M_{\rm min}$ are close to $M_P^{(4)}\simeq 2.4\times 10^{15}$ TeV then the process of "filling" the neutron star with black holes, which, according to (\ref{centralradius}), are now concentrated at the very center of the neutron star, takes tens of millions of years. This would imply a change in the surface temperature on the scale of tens of millions of years, as well. An investigation of time dependence of the surface temperature and its possible observation in neutron stars has been performed assuming that WIMPs constitute dark matter \cite{kouvaris}. Black holes as components of dark matter, could effect the surface temperature of neutron stars considerably less than WIMPs. The mass of the black hole produced from the collision of two black holes may be substantially less than the sum of the masses of the colliding black holes \cite{bekenstein}. The lowest possible resultant mass is obtained from adding entropies, rather than masses. In the case of near minimal mass stable black holes that would imply a third black hole of near minimal mass, as well. The rest of the energy, $\Delta E\simeq M_{\rm min}$, would be dissipated in the form of gravitational radiation, which would escape the neutron star. In such an extreme case the annihilation of stable black holes would not lead to the heating of stars, at all. However, if the collisions are not entropy conserving then the masses of the black holes may simply add. In the latter case a large fraction of the mass would be radiated in the form of elementary particles. We intend to return to this question in a future publication. We will consider ordinary stars briefly. In a star like our sun, or in any star, for that matter, black holes undergo a large number of collisions to reach the equilibrium velocity distribution (\ref{distribution}). Owing to the large size of the sun or other ordinary stars, the surface gravity is smaller then the average squared velocity, provided the minimum mass is smaller than $M_{\rm min}< 100$ TeV, \begin{equation} g=\frac{M_{\rm sun}G}{R_{\rm sun}}=1.9\times 10^{11} ({\rm m/s})^2<< \frac{1}{2}\langle v^2\rangle\simeq 1.8 \times 10^{13} x \,M_{\rm min}^{-1}({\rm m/s})^2. \end{equation} However, if $M_{\rm min}>100$ then black holes get captured in the sun, as well. In fact, the number of black holes collected in a central sphere is much larger than those in a neutron star, owing to the sun's much larger cross section to capture dark matter. We intend to address this question along with the question of dissipation of heat produced from the annihilation of black holes from stars \cite{kouvaris} in a future publication. \subsection{Signature of stable black holes traversing matter and bounds on the minimal mass and abundance} As we pointed out in the previous subsection, stable black holes contributing to dark matter travel through visible matter in an unusual manner. Suppose at a given instant the black hole is close to its minimal mass with nearly zero Hawking temperature. Then colliding with an atomic nucleus, or an electron it can absorb a parton or an electron and increase its mass and Hawking temperature. Note that stable black holes near the minimum mass have positive specific heats. The mass of the black hole increases by the energy of the accreted object, $\Delta M<< M_{\rm min}$, while, as shown by (\ref{hawking2}), its temperature increases to $T_H\sim \sqrt{M_{\rm min} \Delta M}$. This implies that the increase in temperature is larger by at least two orders of magnitude than the increase of energy. The black hole becomes a very hot object with very low heat capacity. It is difficult to calculate the average particle number and momentum distribution in this strange system. However, owing to the fact that the total energy to be radiated isotropically is in the range of $\Delta M\simeq0.1-0.5$ GeV the decay products are restricted to light particles, mostly photons and electrons and neutrinos, with a possible muon or pion. A certain amount of gravitons are also emitted, further decreasing the missing energy \cite{graviton}. Due to phase space considerations lower multiplicity is probably preferred, so most of the events should contain 1-3 visible particles. As the recoiling black hole takes up momentum, the total momentum is not balanced even if we disregard the momentum taken away by gravitons and neutrinos. In many ways the events should be similar to the decay of a proton-like object with a mass of less than a GeV. Therefore, the ideal experiment searching for stable black holes is in large underground detectors. As in proton decay experiments, the most important background signal is the inelastic interactions of atmospheric neutrinos. In fact, the frequency of $E< 1 GeV$ $\nu_e,\, \bar\nu_e$ events serves a rough upper bound on the frequency of stable black hole collisions. In the Minnesota proton decay experiment \cite{minnesota} 69 neutrino events, resembling proton decay were found in 3300 m$^3$ fiducial volume in 80 days. As stable black hole emission events also resemble proton decay events, we may use the frequency of those neutrino events as an upper bound on black hole evaporation events. This amounts to an upper bound on the event rate of $N_e=3\times 10^{-9}$ m$^{-3}$s$^{-1}$. Compare this with the limits on the rate of predicted stable black hole events, using our lower and two upper bounds on the cross section : \begin{equation} 162 \,\delta \,M_{P}^{-3}\,{\rm m}^{-3}{\rm s}^{-1} \leq N_{\rm BH}\leq \begin{cases} 6200\,\delta \,M_{P}^{-1}{\rm m}^{-3}{\rm s}^{-1},\\ 3.7\times 10^5 \frac{\delta}{x} M_{\rm min} \,M_{P}^{-3} {\rm m}^{-3}{\rm s}^{-1} \end{cases} \label{eventrate} \end{equation} Then the lower bound on the black hole decay rate provides a lower bound on the Planck mass that must be satisfied so that we would not contradict the observed rate of neutrino events resesmbling proton decay \begin{equation} \delta \,M_{P}^{-3}<2 .\times10^{-11}. \label{lower3} \end{equation} The upper bounds on the black hole decay rate provide two further conditions. If either of these are satisfied then constraint on the event rate is certainly satisfied. The two conditions are \begin{equation} \delta \,M_{\rm min}^{-1}\leq 5 \times 10^{-13} \label{upper1} \end{equation} and \begin{equation} \frac{\delta}{x} \frac{M_{\rm min}}{M_P^3}\leq 8 \times 10^{-15} \label{upper2} \end{equation} Then (\ref{lower3}) implies that if the {\em dark matter consists solely of black holes} then $M_P\geq 3700$ TeV. The bounds (\ref{upper1}) and (\ref{upper2}) imply that the event rate is certainly low enough if $M_{\rm min}\geq 2\times 10^{12}$ TeV or $M_P^{3/2}M_{\rm min}^{-1/2}\geq 1.1\times\, \sqrt{x}\,10^7$ TeV. If $M_P\simeq M_{\rm min}$ then the lower bound on $M_{\rm min}$ is somewhere in the range \begin{equation} 3.7 \times 10^3 {\rm TeV }\leq M_{\rm min}\leq 1.1\times 10^7 {\rm TeV}. \end{equation Black holes with a minimal mass below the lower bound would surely have been detected. If the minimal mass is above the upper bound then the black hole would certainly have not been detected. {\em Unless only a small fraction of dark matter is made up from stable black holes the minimum mass of black holes must be much larger than 1 TeV.} If the mass of black holes is very large, $M_{\rm min}>10^{10}$ TeV, then the decay event is not any more localized. Using (\ref{timedependence}) in 5 dimensions we obtain for the expected remaining mass as a function of the distance, $L$, starting from the point of accretion \begin{equation} \Delta M(L)\simeq 2.4\times 10^{-12} {\rm TeV} \,(L+L_0)^{-1/2} \frac{M_{\rm min}^2}{M_{P}^{3/2}}, \end{equation} where $L$ is measured in meters and \begin{equation} L_0=2.3 10^{-17}{\rm m} \,\frac{M_{\rm min}^4}{M_{P}^3} \end{equation} Fig.1 shows the dependence of the average energy emitted by the black hole per meter on $L$ at five different choices of $M=M_{\rm min}^4/M_P^3$. The initial excess energy has been chosen to be $\Delta M=0.5$ GeV. \begin{figure}[htbp] \begin{center} \includegraphics[width=4in]{plot1} \caption{The average deposited energy per meter for $M=M_P^{(4)} $ (solid line) , $M=10^{12}$ TeV (dashed), $M=10^{10}$ TeV (dotted), $M=10^{8}$ TeV (dash-dotted),$M=10^{5}$ TeV (bottom solid line)} \label{ionization} \end{center} \end{figure} We can conclude from Fig.1. that if $M=M_P^{(4)}=2.4\times 10^{15}$ TeV there is a significant chance of observing a series of emissions of $\gamma$ rays and energetic electrons at large distances from the point of accretion. At lower values of $M$, certainly for $M<10^{10}$ TeV most of the energy is deposited within a very short distance and only some hard X-ray photons can be emitted up to approximate distance of 10 m from the point of accretion. The spatial resolution of the Super-Kamiokande detector for sub-GeV particles is around 0.3 m \cite{kamiokande}. We can see that at $M\leq10^5$ TeV the decay appears to be completely localized at the point of accretion. The Super-Kamiokande detector is eminently suitable for discovering stable microscopic black holes, provided the abundance of black holes in dark matter is large enough and $M_P$ is small enough. The approximate limits on these quantities are shown in Fig. 2. along with the upper bound on the flux (\ref{upper1}) and (\ref{upper2}). A further limitation on the mass of stable black holes comes from accelerator experiments at Fermilab or the LHC. All these limits are plotted in Fig. 2. \begin{figure}[htbp] \begin{center} \includegraphics[width=4in]{plot2} \caption{The $\delta$-$M$ plane: (1) The region left of the dotted line is excluded on the basis of accelerator experiments, (2) The region above the dash-dotted line is excluded by limits on the flux in proton decay experiments, (3) The region between the dash-dotted and dashed lines represents stable microscopic black holes that are amenable to discovery at Super-Kamiokande, (4) In the region under the dashed line the event rate is too low for discovery with currently available detectors, (5) the $\delta>1$ region above the solid line is excluded because of astronomical limits on dark matter.} \label{admissible} \end{center} \end{figure} One may consider the scenario of an eleven dimensional theory, in which there is a lower bound on the black hole mass in the presence of the Lovelock term $L_5$, compactified above the Planck scale of $M_P\lesssim 10^{15}$ TeV. Then, if the minimal mass is of the same order of magnitude, all the bounds are satisfied, even if all of dark matter is constituted from black holes. Unfortunately, using (\ref{eventrate}), if $M_{\rm min}\sim M_P\gtrsim 10^9$ TeV the event rate at Super-Kamiokande drops below 1/year and observing an accretion and decay of a black hole becomes not feasible. One may significantly increase this upper limit if one also searches for series of $\gamma$ emissions that a black hole emits after it accreted a parton in the rock outside the fiducial volume of the detector, as shown by Fig. 1. \section{ Relativistic black holes in a medium} In low scale gravity, $2.4\times 10^{15}\,{\rm TeV}=M_P^{(4)}\geq M_P\geq 1$ TeV, high energy particles can create black holes. If the primary energy is $E>> M_P^2/m_p$, such as may be in energetic cosmic rays, then the produced black holes have relativistic speed and they may or may not slow down and evaporate while passing through matter. The mass and speed of the black hole changes due to the absorption of matter particles and Hawking radiation. We will investigate below what are the conditions for the black hole, undergoing multiple collisions, to slow down and evaporate before accreting all matter available to it \cite{argyres}. Since in a brane-world scenario all particles save the graviton and Kaluza-Klein modes are confined to the brane and the Kaluza-Klein modes contribute little \cite{emparan}, despite the fact that the black holes are higher dimensional, we write the equation for the time dependence of the mass in the rest system of the black hole using 4-dimensional quantities. The change of mass of the black hole as described in the rest system of the black hole is \begin{equation} \frac{dM}{dt}=c\sigma \rho \gamma^2v-g\frac{\pi^2}{120}4\pi r_h^2T_H^4, \label{time} \end{equation} where $g=\sum_s \Gamma_s g_{\rm eff}^s$, where $\Gamma_s$ and $g_{\rm eff}^s$ are the gray body factor and effective number of degrees of freedom for particle species $s$ \cite{chamblin}. $c$ is the effectiveness of turning the energy of a parton into the mass of the black hole. Stefan's constant per massless degree of freedom is $\pi^2/120$, $\rho$ is the mass density of the medium and $\gamma$ is the time dependent Lorentz factor. $r_h$ is the radius of horizon. The multiplier $\gamma^2$ should be included in the absorption term because on one hand the black hole sees a Lorentz contracted distribution and the other hand the energy of each particle of mass $m$ absorbed is $m\gamma$. Another way of stating this is that the accretion rate in the star's rest system is \begin{equation} \left.\frac{dM}{dt}\right|_a=c\sigma\, \rho\, \Delta v, \end{equation} where $\Delta v$ is the relative speed. Now transforming into the system of the black hole while $t\rho\to \gamma^2t\rho$ and the relative speed is unchanged. We defined \begin{equation} r_h=\sqrt{\mu^2-2\alpha} . \end{equation} where $\mu$, the radius of horizon, is related to the mass as in (\ref{mass}). $T_H$ is the Hawking temperature, \begin{equation} T_H=\frac{ \sqrt{\mu^2-2\alpha} }{2\pi(\mu^2+2\alpha)}. \end{equation} Since $\gamma$ is also time dependent we need another equation to find both $\mu$ and $g$. We can readily obtain such an equation if we consider the process in the rest system of the medium. Then using momentum conservation in the rest frame of the star and assuming that there is no momentum transfer to matter not absorbed by the black hole we obtain \begin{equation} \frac{d(M\gamma v)}{dt}=-g\gamma v\frac{\pi^2}{120}4\pi r_h^2T_H^4, \label{energy} \end{equation} where we assumed that the c.m.s of evaporating particles moves with the same speed as the black hole. Combining (\ref{time}) and (\ref{energy}) we obtain an equation for the Lorentz factor \begin{equation} \frac{d\gamma}{dt}=-\frac{\sigma}{M} c\rho (\gamma^2-1)^{3/2} \label{gamma} \end{equation} In the Schwarzschild limit ($M>>\alpha M_P^3$, where $M_P$ is the Planck mass) the ratio \begin{equation} \frac{\sigma}{M}=\frac{4}{3M_P^3} \end{equation} is a constant and the equation for $\gamma$ decouples. Introducing the notation $x=4 c\rho/(3 M_P^3)$ and using the initial condition, $\gamma=\gamma_0$ at $t=0$, the solution of (\ref{gamma}) is \begin{equation} v=\frac{v^0}{1+x\, t \,v_0} \end{equation} $\mu(y)$ can be obtained as a functional of $\gamma$ from (\ref{time}) in the Schwarzschild approximation, with initial condition $\mu^2(0)=\mu_0^2=M_0\,/\,(3\pi M_P^3)$, \begin{equation} \mu^2(y)=h(y)\sqrt{\mu_0^4-2\frac{\beta}{x}\int_0^y[h(z)]^{-2}dz} \label{massequation} \end{equation} where $\beta=g\pi^{-2}M_P^{-3}/180$, $y=x\,t$, and \begin{equation} h(y)=\exp\left\{\int_0^y[\gamma(z)]^2dz\right\}=\gamma_0\sqrt{(y v_0+1)^2 -v_0^2}. \end{equation} Calculating the integrals in (\ref{massequation}) we get \begin{equation} \mu^2=\gamma_0\left[(x\,t\, v_0+1)^2-v_0^2\right]^{1/2}\left[\mu_0^4-\frac{\beta}{\gamma_0^2\,x\,v_0}\log\left(\frac{(1+v_0)(1+v_0x\,t-v_0)}{(1-v_0)(1+v_0x\,t+v_0)}\right)\right]^{1/2} \label{musquared} \end{equation} Now there are two possible scenarios. The first one is when $\mu^2\to \infty$ when $t\to \infty$, if \begin{equation} \mu_0^4>\frac{\beta}{\gamma_0^2 \,x\,v_0}\log\left(\frac{1+v_0}{1-v_0}\right)\simeq\frac{\beta}{\gamma_0 ^2\,x\,v_0}\log(4\gamma_0^2). \end{equation} In that case the mass of the black hole grows indefinitely, i.e it gobbles up all matter available. In the opposite case an Einstein black hole evaporates completely in finite time. The evaporation time can be obtained from finding the zero of the last factor of (\ref{musquared}). For a Lovelock black hole, which approaches a finite mass as $t\to\infty$, we must slightly modify (\ref{musquared}) at large times. The difference between Einstein and Lovelock black holes in no way modifies our conclusions concerning the fate of cosmic ray black holes in neutron stars. Using $M_0\gamma_0=E_0$, the primary energy, we obtain the following upper bound on the primary energy for the black hole to evaporate already in the crust of the neutron star (with density $10^9$ kg/m$^3$) \begin{equation} E_0<10^{11}{\rm TeV}\, M_P^3. \end{equation} According to current theory and experiment the cosmic ray spectrum cuts off at $E_{\rm max}=5\times 10^{7}$ TeV due to the Greisen-Kuzmin-Zatsepin effect \cite{greisen}. We estimate that a black hole created by a cosmic ray proton of $E<E_{\rm max}$ in the crust of a neutron star will lose its energy in approximately $l\simeq 1/x\simeq$ 1$\mu$m. \section{Conclusions} In more than 4 space-time dimensions Lovelock terms make a non-trivial contribution to the equations of motion. Putting it in stronger terms, there is no reason known to us why Lovelock terms should not appear in the gravitational action. Their presence significantly modifies the physics of small black holes. Some of these modifications, especially in odd dimensions, in which black holes have a lower bound on their mass, have been investigated in the past \cite{rizzo} \cite{rizzo1} \cite{alexeyev}. At the lower bound odd dimensional Lovelock black holes, just like extremal black holes, have vanishing Hawking temperature \cite{myers}\cite{wiltshire} \cite{dehghani}. At least semi-classically, at the end of their decay process, these black holes become stable in vacuum. If D is even, then after the compactification of an odd number of dimensions, we believe that small odd dimensional black holes can be caged without a substantial change of their metric and thus they retain their property of having a minimal mass and vanishing Hawking temperature. This could be ascertained in an expansion in the inverse of the compactification radius \cite{harmark} \cite{karasik}. Alternatively, in even dimensions, if the compactification radius of an odd number of dimensions is smaller than $\mu^{(D)}$ black holes become black branes. Such black branes retain the combination of properties of having a minimal mass and vanishing Hawking temperature at the minimal mass. This will be the subject of a future publication. If black holes become stable upon reaching their minimal mass then their number density can be reduced only by collisions of black holes. Then by necessity, near minimum mass black holes form a part of dark matter. One major concern of this paper has been to find upper limits on the contribution of stable microscopic (of mass between 1 TeV and the four dimensional Planck mass) black holes to dark matter. We have provided an approximate upper bound on their abundance using existing data at underground experiments. In fact, we also show that using the extreme assumption that all of dark matter is constituted from stable microscopic black holes their mass is at least $10^4$ TeV, but probably more than $10^7$ TeV. In doing so we show that stable black holes traversing through underground chambers have a very peculiar characteristic signals, especially if their minimum mass is larger then $10^5$ TeV. In the range $M_{\rm min}<10^5$ TeV their decay is local, often imitating a low energy ($E\lesssim 0.5$ GeV) neutrino interaction. However, at higher energies, especially at $M_{\rm min}>10^{10}$ TeV, after a localized partial evaporation they continue emitting lower and lower energy particles (mostly photons and possibly electrons) along a track as they progress through the detector. Unfortunately, if $M_{\rm min}\sim M_P\gtrsim10^{10}$ TeV then the event rate at the Super-Kamiokande detector becomes so low that the observation the black hole evaporation process becomes very difficult. Black holes that form part of dark matter accumulate in a central region of neutron stars. There they annihilate by colliding with each other. Eventually they reach equilibrium with the incoming flux and then they produce heat though possibly at a lower rate than other components of dark matter \cite{kouvaris}. In ordinary stars, however the surface gravity is not sufficient to keep the black holes from escaping unless the $M_{\rm min}>$100 TeV, in which case the average velocity of black holes becomes smaller than the escape velocity. However, if the $M_{\rm min}\sim M_P\gtrsim10^{15}$ TeV the mean free path in black holes and in ordinary stars becomes comparable with the size of the star and most of the black holes are not captured. Among other aspects of the physics of black holes we investigated the accretion of relativistic (cosmic ray) black holes in matter. We find that all black holes created by cosmic ray protons below the Greisen-Kuzmin-Zatsepin limit \cite{greisen} slow down and lose mass in stars, among others, in neutron stars. Finally, we return to a problem, which we already mentioned in the Introduction. Two further steps are required to complete our scenario, either of which could potentially destabilize minimum mass black holes. Suppose that $D$ is the (odd) number of dimensions of Lovelock gravity, which we have considered in this paper. Since there are only 4 non-compact dimensions in our world we still need to compactify $D-4$ dimensions. The second problem concerns the existence of dimensions beyond $D$. The total number of dimensions of the world, ${\mathfrak{D}}\geq D$. $\mathfrak{D}$ may be even or odd. We must embed black holes into the $\mathfrak{D}$ dimensional space. In the next paragraph we will sketch a possible solution to these problems. Suppose the compactification scales of $\mathfrak{D}-D$ and $D-4$ dimensions are $\mathfrak{L}$ and $L$, where $\mathfrak{L}<<L $. We assume that $D$ is odd and all Lovelock terms up to $n=(D-1)/2$ order appear in the action. The minimum mass should be small enough, such that black holes close to the minimum mass are caged in the $D-4$ compact dimensions, but at the same time it should be large enough so that black holes are extended as black branes into the extra $\mathfrak{D}-D$ dimensions. In other words, the condition for the existence of a stable minimum mass is that $\mu^{(D)}$ defined in (\ref{mass}) is in between the two scales, i.e $c_\mathfrak{L}\,\mathfrak{L} <\mu^{(D)}<c_L\, L $, where $c_\mathfrak{L}$ and $c_L$ are $O(1)$ dimensionless constants. $c_\mathfrak{L}$ is defined to be large enough to avoid the Gregory-Laflamme instability \cite{gregory}, while $c_L$ is chosen to be small enough to have the black hole safely caged in $D-4$ dimensions. The details of this scenario are left to a future publication. \section{} \begin{acknowledgments} This work is supported in part by the DOE grant \# DE-FG02-84ER40153. The authors are indebted to Philip Argyres for informing them about his study of the accretion of black holes, produced by cosmic rays, in neutron stars and for valuable discussions. L.C.R.W. thanks S.Chivukula, F. P. Esposito, P.Frampton, C.Kouvaris, R.Schnee , F.Sannino for discussions and CP3 Origins Institute in Odense and Aspen Center for Physics for their hospitality. \end{acknowledgments}

\section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} In recent years, nonlocal differential operators and equations have attracted an increasing amount of attention. In particular, the fractional Laplacian is defined for suitable functions $u(x)$, $x\in {\mathbb R^n}$, as \begin{equation}\label{eq.frlap} (-\Delta)^s u(x) = c_{n,s} \PV \int_{\mathbb R^d} \frac{u(x) - u(y)}{|x-y|^{n+2s}} \diff y, \end{equation} where $s\in(0,1)$, $c_{n,s}>0$ is a normalization constant and $\PV$ denotes that the integral is taken in the principal value sense, cf. the classical references \cite{Landkof66, Stein1970}. It appears (but for the constant factor) as the subdifferential of the fractional energy \begin{equation}\label{Js2} {\mathcal J}_{2,s}(u)= \int_{{\mathbb R^d}}\int_{{\mathbb R^d} } \frac{|u(x)-u(y)|^2}{|x-y|^{n+2s}}\,dxdy\,, \end{equation} that is related to the definition of the standard norm of the space $W^{s,2}({\mathbb R^n})$. Besides, there are several known representation formulas that have proven to be quite convenient in tackling problems involving fractional operators like \eqref{eq.frlap}, see the list in \cite{Kwa17} where a rather thorough discussion is made. Three of those representations are quite relevant and will be re-examined here in a nonlinear context. They are the so called semigroup (or Bochner's subordination) formula; the Caffarelli-Silvestre extension problem, that allows to write the nonlocal operator as in terms of a local problem in one extra dimension; and Balakrishnan's formula. \noindent \ (i) A first representation was given by S. Bochner (see \cite{Bochner1949}). In modern form, it says that for a smooth enough function $u$ the following formula holds \begin{equation}\label{eq:BochnerFor} (-\Delta)^s u(x)= \frac{1}{\Gamma(-s)} \int_{0}^\infty (e^{t \Delta}[u](x)-u(x)) \frac{\dd t}{t^{1+s}}, \end{equation} where $e^{t \Delta}$ denotes the heat semigroup, i.\,e., we take $e^{t \Delta}[u](x):=w(x,t)$, where $w$ is the solution of the problem \begin{equation*} \begin{dcases} \partial_t w(x,t)- \Delta w(x,t)=0, & x \in {\mathbb R^n} , t > 0 , \\ w (x,0) = u(x), & x \in {\mathbb R^n} . \end{dcases} \end{equation*} \noindent \ (ii) On the other hand, the fractional Laplacian can be written in local terms since L. Caffarelli and L. Silvestre showed in \cite{Caffarelli2007} that the extension problem \begin{equation*} \begin{dcases} \Delta_x v + \frac{1-2s}{y} v_y + v_{yy} = 0 & x \in {\mathbb R^n} , y > 0 , \\ v (x,0) = u(x) & x \in {\mathbb R^n} \,, \end{dcases} \end{equation*} allows to compute the fractional Laplacian $(-\Delta)^s u$ as a weighted Neumann limit of $v$ \begin{equation} \label{eq:extension} (-\Delta)^s u (x) = \frac{4^s \Gamma(s)}{\Gamma(-s)} \lim_{y \to 0} \frac{v(x,y) - v(x,0)}{y^{2s}}. \end{equation} \noindent \ (iii) A further representation for the fractional Laplacian was given by A. V. Balakrishnan whose formula reads (see \cite{Balakrishnan1960}) \begin{equation} \label{eq:Balakrishnan original} (-\Delta)^s u(x)= \frac{\sin(\pi s)}{\pi} \int_0^\infty (-\Delta)(t-\Delta)^{-1} [u](x) \frac{\dd t}{t^{1-s}}. \end{equation} The three representations have proved to be very useful both in theory and applications, and they have given rise to a wide literature. \medskip \noindent {\bf Aim and main results.} The aim of this paper is to present analogous representations in the nonlinear context of the fractional $p$-Laplacian, and we comment on their usefulness in different applications. We first recall that the fractional $p$-Laplacian is usually defined as follows \begin{equation}\label{eq.spl1} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) =C_1 \PV \int_{\mathbb R^d} \frac{\Phi_p (u(x) - u(y))}{|x-y|^{n+sp}} \diff y, \end{equation} where $p\in (1,\infty)$ and $s\in(0,1)$, we write $\Phi_p (t) = |t|^{p-2}t$, and $C_1=C_1(n,s,p)>0$ is a constant. The fractional $p$-Laplacian is the subdifferential of a convex functional called the $(s,p)$-energy (or Gagliardo seminorm) \begin{equation}\label{Jsp1} {\mathcal J}_{p,s}(u)= \frac{ C_1}{p}\int_{{\mathbb R^d}}\int_{{\mathbb R^d} } \frac{|u(x)-u(y)|^p}{|x-y|^{n+sp}}\,dxdy\,, \end{equation} defined for those functions in $L^2({\mathbb R^n})$ with finite $(s,p)$-energy, see e.g. \cite{Mazon2016, Vazquez2020}. We also recall that this operator has a dense domain in $L^2({\mathbb R^n})$ containing smooth enough functions. Actually, ${(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x)$ is well-defined in the pointwise sense for smooth functions $C_c^\infty ({\mathbb R^n})$ (assuming also that the gradient does not vanish when $p$ lies in the range $p\in(1,\frac{2}{2-s}$) (see, e.g., Section 3 in \cite{Korvenpaa2019}). Our main result is the introduction of three equivalent representation formulas for ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$, which retain the flavour of the linear case. First, we show that the fractional $p$-Laplacian can be represented by the formula \begin{equation}\label{eq:semigintro} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) = C_2 \int_0^{+\infty} e^{t \Delta} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\,, \end{equation} where $C_2 > 0$. The precise study of this nonlinear representation occupies \Cref{sec:semigrep}, see \Cref{thm:semigroup}. Second, we consider an extension operator $E_{s,p}$ related to a local problem in $ \mathbb{R}^n \times (0,\infty)$, and such that the following representation holds: \begin{equation}\label{eq:extintro} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) = C_3\, \lim_{y \to 0} \frac{ E_{s,p}\Big [\Phi_p \big (u(x)-u(\cdot) \big ) \Big ](x,y) }{y^{sp}}, \end{equation} where $C_3 > 0$. The precise study of this nonlinear representation occupies \Cref{sec:extension}, see \Cref{thm:extension}. Lastly, the fractional $p$-Laplacian is also equivalently given by the following nonlinear Balakrishnan's formula \begin{equation}\label{eq:Balaintro} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) = C_4 \int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}, \end{equation} where $C_4 > 0$. This will be studied in \Cref{sec:Balak}, see \Cref{thm:Balak}. The choice of the constant $C_1$ is indifferent in most cases and can be fixed as 1, but a precise value $C_1(n,s,p)$ can be important in writing some exact formulas or in the limit cases $s\to 0^+$, $s\to 1^-$, or $p\to 2$. In \Cref{sec:constants} we will discuss the choice of this constant and also give an explicit relation with $C_2$, $C_3$, and $C_4$, which turn out to be dimensionally free after a suitable choice of $C_1$. The three above representations succeed in replicating the linear formulas in the nonlinear setting, which was unexpected. One may wonder about the complexity introduced by the nonlinear term $\Phi_p(u(x) - u(y))$. In that sense, we have the following comments. Firstly, we note that the operator used in each case $(e^{t\Delta}$, $E_{s,p}$ and $\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1}$) is independent of the point $x$ where ${(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x)$ is computed. As a consequence of that, our representation formulas need to solve a single problem with an initial/boundary condition depending on a parameter, i.e. $f_\lambda(y)=\Phi_p(\lambda - u(y))$ where $\lambda =u(x)$. This fact is very clearly seen in the numerical application, since formula \eqref{eq:discFPL2} does not add any extra complexity with respect its linear counterpart in the computation of the coefficients. Another possible interpretation of our representations is that given a function $u:\mathbb{R}^n\to \mathbb{R}$ we build an initial/boundary condition $F(x,z):=\Phi_p(u(x)-u(z))$ and solve a problem in $\mathbb{R}^{2n+1}_+$ where the operator only acts in $n+1$ of the variables. We continue next with some further consequences. \noindent{\bf Representation in bounded domains.} As a first consequence of the above results, we remark that the first representation of the fractional $p$-Laplacian naturally suggests a version of the operator defined in bounded domains $\Omega$ of $\mathbb{R}^n$. Given $u:\Omega\to \mathbb{R}$ we define a new operator \begin{equation}\label{eq:semigdomain} (-\Delta_\Omega)_{p}^s u (x) :=C_2\int_0^{+\infty} e^{t \Delta_\Omega} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}, \end{equation} where $e^{t \Delta_\Omega} $ denotes the heat semigroup in $\Omega$ with Dirichlet boundary conditions, i.e. $w(x,t):=e^{t \Delta_\Omega}[f](x)$ is the solution of \begin{equation*} \begin{dcases} w_t(x,t)- \Delta w(x,t)=0 & x\in\Omega, t > 0, \\ w(x,t) = 0 & x \in \partial \Omega, t > 0 , \\ w(x,0) = f (x) & x \in \Omega. \end{dcases} \end{equation*} This operator is defined for any $p>1$ and generalises the Spectral Fractional Laplacian, which is the well-known case $p = 2$. In \Cref{sec:new spectral} we will show this operator is well-defined and different from the restriction of ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$. Furthermore, we suggest a generalisation for manifolds that we do not develop in full detail. Analogous variants can be constructed via \eqref{eq:extintro} and \eqref{eq:Balaintro}. \medskip \noindent{\bf Further extensions and comments.} \Cref{sec:numApp} addresses the topic of numerical analysis for the fractional $p$-Laplacian starting from our representation formulas. \Cref{sec:app} is devoted to comment on some extensions and applications of our results. In the \Cref{sec:commentandproblems}, we present some comments and open problems that we find interesting as well as a brief intuition about our results. Finally, we include an appendix with technical results. \medskip \noindent{\bf Comments on related literature.} Some references for stationary boundary value problems involving the fractional $p$-Laplace operator that we study here: Ishii and Nakamura \cite{Ishii10} treat the first boundary value problem; Lindgren and Lindqvist \cite{LindgrenLindq14, Lindgren17} establish the fractional eigenvalues, Perron's Method and Wiener's theorem. Regularity was studied in \cite{Brasco17,BrLiSc18,brasco2019,Iannizzotto16,Kuusi15,Lindgren16} among others. The equivalence of weak and viscosity solutions in boundary value problems involving the fractional $p$-Laplacian has been recently treated in \cite{Korvenpaa2019} in the homogeneous case and \cite{barrios2020} in the non-homogeneous case. The parabolic problem has been studied in bounded domains: Mazón, Rossi, and Toledo \cite{Mazon2016}, Puhst \cite{Puhst15}, and Vázquez \cite{Vazquez2016}; and also in the whole space $\mathbb{R}^n$ by M. Strömqvist \cite{Strom19} and Vázquez \cite{Vazquez2020}. We will make specific comments on the semigroup formula, the extension problem and the Balakrishnan's formula in the corresponding sections. Other applications, in particular numerical studies are mentioned in \Cref{sec:numApp} and \Cref{sec:app}. The literature contains works on other types of operators that are also known as ``nonlocal or fractional $p$-Laplacian operators''. We are not treating such versions in our paper since they lead to quite different objects, tools and results. For instance, in the book by Andreu-Vaillo, Mazón, Rossi, Toledo, \cite{Andreu2010}, the integro-differential operator is defined on the basis of integrable kernels. Cipriani and Grillo proposed in \cite{CiGr09} another type of nonlinear and nonlocal operator defined via the subordination formula applied directly to a nonlinear semigroup. We show in the last section that this method leads to an operator that is different from ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$ treated here. On the other hand, Bjorland-Caffarelli-Figalli introduce in \cite{BCF12a, BCF12b} a kind of normalized (game theoretical) fractional infinity Laplacian as well as a fractional $p$-Laplace operator in non-divergence form (see \cite{Manfredi10,Manfedi12} for the local version). They are the nonlocal counterpart of the normalized standard $p$-Laplacian in the viscosity sense. Finally, Chasseigne and Jakobsen \cite{ChaJa17} introduced a related non-normalized nonlocal $p$-Laplacian in the viscosity sense. As a final comment, we recall that the standard $p$-Laplace operator ($s=1$) has been widely studied both in the stationary and evolution equations. Let us mention some classical monographs by DiBenedetto \cite{DiBenedetto93}, Lindqvist \cite{Lindqvist06}, that contain further references. The monograph \cite[Section 11]{Vazquez2006} contains a summary of the evolution results. \section{Semigroup representation}\label{sec:semigrep} We present an interesting representation of the operator using the heat semigroup. Let us use the notation $e^{t \Delta}$ for this semigroup, i.\,e., given $f:\mathbb{R}^n\to \mathbb{R}$ we denote by $w(x,t)=e^{t \Delta}[f](x)$ the solution of \begin{equation*} \begin{dcases} \partial_t w(x,t)- \Delta w(x,t)=0, & x \in {\mathbb R^n} , t > 0 , \\ w (x,0) = f(x), & x \in {\mathbb R^n} . \end{dcases} \end{equation*} The following is our first main result. \begin{theorem} \label{thm:semigroup} Let $s \in (0,1)$ and $p \in (1,+\infty)$. Assume $u\in C^2_b({\mathbb R^n})$ and $x_0\in {\mathbb R^n}$. If $p \in (1,\frac{2}{2-s})$ assume additionally that $\nabla u(x_0)\not=0$. Then we have the following representation of the fractional $p$-Laplacian \begin{equation}\label{repr1} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x_0) = C_2 (n,s,p) \int_0^{+\infty} e^{t \Delta} [\Phi_p ( u(x_0) - u(\cdot) )](x_0) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}, \qquad \end{equation} where $ C_2 (n,s,p) = \frac {\pi^{ \frac n 2 } C_1(n,s,p)} {2^{sp} \Gamma(\frac{n+sp}2)} $. \end{theorem} Note that, when $p=2$, we have that \[ e^{t \Delta} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x)=e^{t \Delta} [ u(x) - u(\cdot) ](x)= u(x)- e^{t \Delta} [u](x). \] so that, a suitable choice of $ C_1 (n,s,p)$ allows to recover Bochner's formula \eqref{eq:BochnerFor} from \eqref{repr1}. Notice that $\Gamma(-s) < 0$ while $C_2 > 0$. \bigskip Our proof is based on the scaling properties of the representation formula \begin{equation*} e^{t \Delta} [f] (x) =\frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} {e^{-\frac{|x-y|^2}{4t}}} f(y) \diff y. \end{equation*} We use here it in combination with the nonlinearity, plus a desingularization step that is done by subtraction inside the argument of the nonlinearity. In this way we obtain the {\sl splitting representation} \eqref{repr1} of the fractional $p$-Laplacian. \begin{proof}[Proof of \Cref{thm:semigroup}] Let $\varepsilon>0$ and consider the bounded function $g_\varepsilon:\mathbb{R}^n\times \mathbb{R}^n\to 0$ given by $g_\varepsilon(x,y)= \Phi_p ( u(x) - u(y) ) \chi_{|x-y| > \varepsilon}$. Fix $x\in \mathbb{R}^n$ and consider the heat semigroup associated to $g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)$, i.e. \begin{equation*} e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x, \cdot)] (z) = \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} {e^{-\frac{|z-y|^2}{4t}}} g_\varepsilon(x,y) \diff y. \end{equation*} Taking $z = x$ we have \begin{equation*} e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x, \cdot)] (x) = \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} {e^{-\frac{|x-y|^2}{4t}}}g_\varepsilon(x, y) \diff y. \end{equation*} Let now $\delta>0$ and integrate the quantity above with respect the singular measure $\dd t/t^{1+\frac{sp}{2}}$ in the truncated domain $(\delta, +\infty)$ (we do this to avoid integrability issues around the origin due to the singular behaviour of the measure) to obtain \begin{align*} \int_\delta^{\infty} e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)] (x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} &= \int_\delta^{\infty} \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} \left( \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} {e^{-\frac{|x-y|^2}{4t}}} g_\varepsilon(x,y) \diff y\right) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &= \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \left( \int_\delta^{\infty} \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} {e^{-\frac{|x-y|^2}{4t}}}\frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\right) g_\varepsilon(x,y) \diff y \end{align*} where we have used Fubini's theorem to change the order of integration. We use now the change of variables $t = |x-y|^2 /(4\tau)$ to get \begin{align*} \int_\delta^{\infty} e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)]& (x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &=\frac {2^{sp}} {\pi^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \left( \int_{0}^{ \frac{|x-y|^2}{4\delta}} {e^{-\tau}} \frac{\diff \tau}{\tau^{ 1 - \frac{n+sp}2 }} \right) \frac{ g_\varepsilon(x,y) } { |x-y|^{ n+sp}} \diff y. \end{align*} Note that, since $g_\varepsilon(x,y)=0$ if $|x-y|<\varepsilon$, we can consider the above expression to be integrated in $\mathbb{R}^n \setminus B_\varepsilon(x)$. Now, we want to let $\delta \to 0^+$ to get \begin{align*} \int_0^{\infty} e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)] (x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} &= \frac {2^{sp}} {\pi^{ \frac n 2 }} \left( \int_{0}^{\infty} {e^{-\tau}} \tau^{ - 1 + \frac{n+sp}2 } \diff \tau \right) \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \frac{ g_\varepsilon(x,y) } { |x-y|^{ n+sp}} \diff y \\ &=\frac {2^{sp} \Gamma(\frac{n+sp}2)} {\pi^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \frac{ g_\varepsilon(x,y) } { |x-y|^{ n+sp}} \diff y. \end{align*} \noindent\textbf{Step 1:} Let either $p\in [2,\infty)$ or $p\in(1,2)$ and $\nabla u(x)\not=0$. \\ Passing to the limit in the right hand side is trivial since the integrand converges pointwise and monotonically to ${e^{-\tau}} \tau^{ - 1 + \frac{n+sp}2}$ which is an integrable function in the domain $(0,+\infty)$, which yields to the definition of the $\Gamma$ function. To pass to the limit in the left hand side, we estimate \begin{align*} \left|e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x)\right|&= \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }}\left| \int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} {e^{-\frac{|x-y|^2}{4t}}} \Phi_p ( u(x) - u(y) ) \diff y\right|\\ &\lesssim \frac{1}{ t^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{\mathbb{R}^n} {e^{-\frac{|z|^2}{4t}}} |z|^p \diff z\\ &= \frac{1}{ t^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{\mathbb{R}^n} {e^{-\frac{r^2}{4}}} t^{\frac{p}{2}} |r|^p t^{\frac{n}{2}} \diff r= t^{\frac{p}{2}} \int_{\mathbb{R}^n} {e^{-\frac{r^2}{4}}} |r|^p\diff r \lesssim t^{\frac{p}{2}}, \end{align*} where we have used either \Cref{lem:tech1} or \Cref{lem:tech3} with $$K(z)= e^{-\frac{|z|^2}{4t}} \chi_{|z| > \varepsilon}(z)$$ and the change of variables $z=t^{\frac{1}{2}}r$ i.e. $\dd z= t^{\frac{n}{2}}\dd r$. Then \[ \begin{aligned} \int_\delta^{1} |e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)] (x) | \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} &\lesssim \int_\delta^{1} t^{\frac{p}{2}} \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} = \int_\delta^{1} \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {(1-s)p} 2}} \\ & \leq \int_0^{1} \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {(1-s)p} 2}} <+\infty \end{aligned} \] where the bound comes from the fact that $(1-s)p/2>0$ since $s\in(0,1)$. Now we want to take limits as $\varepsilon\to0$. In the right hand side, we use either \Cref{lem:tech1} or \Cref{lem:tech3} with $K(z)= |z|^{-n-sp} \chi_{|z| < \varepsilon}(z)$ to get \begin{align*} &\Bigg|\textup{P.V.} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \frac{ \Phi_p(u(x)-u(y)) } { |x-y|^{ n+sp}} \diff y- \textup{P.V.} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \frac{ g_\varepsilon(x,y) } { |x-y|^{ n+sp}} \diff y\Bigg|\\ & \leq \Bigg|\textup{P.V.} \int_{|x-y|<\varepsilon} \frac{ \Phi_p(u(x)-u(y)) } { |x-y|^{ n+sp}} \diff y \Bigg|\\ &\lesssim \int_{|z|<\varepsilon} \frac{ |z|^p } { |z|^{ n+sp}} \diff z \\ &\lesssim \varepsilon^{(1-s)p} \to 0 \qquad \textup{as} \qquad \varepsilon\to0. \end{align*} While in the left hand side we use either \Cref{lem:tech1} or \Cref{lem:tech3} with $K(z)= e^{-\frac{|z|^2}{4t}} \chi_{|z| < \varepsilon}(z)$ to estimate for $t\in(0,1)$, \begin{align*} &\Bigg| \left(e^{t \Delta} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) \right)](x) - e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)] (x) \Bigg| \\ &= \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} \left|\int_{|x-y|<\varepsilon} {e^{-\frac{|x-y|^2}{4t}}} \Phi_p ( u(x) - u(y) ) \dd y\right|\\ &\lesssim \frac{1}{ t^{ \frac n 2 }} \int_{|z|<\varepsilon} {e^{-\frac{|z|^2}{4t}}} |z|^p\dd z \lesssim t^\frac{p}{2} \int_{|r|< \varepsilon t^{-\frac{1}{2}}} {e^{-\frac{r^2}{4}}} |r|^p\dd r \end{align*} and for $t\geq1$, \[\begin{split} &| e^{t \Delta} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x) - e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)] (x)| \\ &\qquad \leq \sup_{|x-y|<\varepsilon} |\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(y) )| \\ &\qquad \lesssim \sup_{|x-y|<\varepsilon} |u(x)-u(y)|^{\min\{1,p-1\}} \leq \varepsilon^{\min\{1,p-1\}} \end{split} \] Then \begin{equation} \label{eq:convergence semigroup} \begin{aligned} &\Bigg|\int_0^{+\infty}e^{t \Delta} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}- \int_0^{\infty} e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)] (x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\Bigg|\\ &\leq \int_0^1 \left(\int_{|r|< \varepsilon t^{-\frac{1}{2}}} {e^{-\frac{r^2}{4}}} |r|^p\dd r \right) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {(1-s)p} 2}} + \varepsilon^{\min\{1,p-1\}} \int_1^\infty \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}. \end{aligned} \end{equation} Clearly, the second term in the last estimate goes to zero as $\varepsilon\to0$. For the first term, let \[ f_\varepsilon(t):=\int_{|r|< \varepsilon t^{-\frac{1}{2}}} {e^{-\frac{r^2}{4}}} |r|^p\dd r. \] For the first term, clearly $f_\varepsilon \to0$ a.e in $t\in[0,\infty)$, \[ |f_\varepsilon(t)| \leq F(t) \equiv \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} {e^{-\frac{r^2}{4}}} |r|^p\dd r \] and \[ \int_0^1 F(t) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {(1-s)p} 2}} = \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} {e^{-\frac{r^2}{4}}} |r|^p\dd r \int_0^1 \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {(1-s)p} 2}} <+ \infty, \] so by the Dominated Convergence Theorem this term also converges to zero as $\varepsilon\to0$. \medskip \noindent \textbf{Step 2: } Now let $p\in(\frac{2}{2-s},2)$. We can use \Cref{lem:tech2} to get \begin{align*} \left|e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x)\right|& \lesssim t^{p-1}. \end{align*} so that \[ \int_\delta^{1} |e^{t \Delta} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)] (x) | \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \lesssim \int_0^{1} t^{p-1}\frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} <+\infty \] which is finite since $p-1>\frac{sp}{2}$ since $p>\frac{2}{2-s}$. That allow us to pass to the limit as $\delta \to0$. The limit as $\varepsilon\to0$ follows also as in Step 1 one using \Cref{lem:tech2} instead of \Cref{lem:tech1}. \end{proof} \section{The new extension problem}\label{sec:extension} The aim of this section is to write corresponding formulas in the present nonlinear setting following the ideas introduced in the linear setting by Caffarelli and Silvestre \cite{Caffarelli2007}. For $s \in (0,1)$ and $p \in (1,+\infty)$ consider the extension problem \begin{equation} \label{eq:extension2} \begin{dcases} \Delta_x U(x,y) + \frac{1-sp}{y} U_y(x,y) + U_{yy}(x,y) = 0 & x \in {\mathbb R^n} , y > 0 , \\ U (x,0) = f(x)& x \in {\mathbb R^n} , \end{dcases} \end{equation} which extends the usual theory where $p = 2$. We will show that a classical solution of this problem can be recovered by convolution with an explicit Poisson kernel \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-form2} \begin{aligned} U(x,y) &= \int_{ {\mathbb R^n} } P(x-\xi, y) f(\xi) \diff \xi\,, \\ &\text{where} \quad P(x,y) = \frac{\Gamma ( \frac {n + sp}2 )}{ \pi^{\frac n 2} \Gamma (\frac{sp}2)} \frac{y^{sp} }{(|x|^2 + y^2)^{\frac {n+sp}2}}. \end{aligned} \end{equation} Finally, let us define the extension operator $E_{s,p} [f] := U$ through formula \eqref{eq:ext-form2}. With this extension operator we can give a representation formula for the $(s,p)$-Laplacian. \begin{theorem}\label{thm:extension} Let $s \in (0,1)$ and $p \in (1,+\infty)$. Assume $u\in C^2_b({\mathbb R^n})$ and $x_0\in {\mathbb R^n}$. If $p \in (1,\frac{2}{2-s})$ assume additionally that $\nabla u(x_0)\not=0$. We have the following representation of the fractional $p$-Laplacian: \begin{equation} \label{eq:representation extension} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x_0) = C_3(n,s,p)\, \lim_{y \to 0} \frac{ E_{s,p}\Big [\Phi_p \big (u(x_0)-u(\cdot) \big ) \Big ](x_0,y) }{y^{sp}} \end{equation} where the constant is given by $C_3 (n,s,p) = \frac{ \pi^{\frac n 2} \Gamma (\frac{sp}2)} {\Gamma ( \frac {n + sp}2 )} C_1(n,s,p) $. \end{theorem} Actually, for $p=2$ we have that \[ \begin{aligned} \frac{ E_{s,p}[\Phi_p(u(x)-u(\cdot))](x,y) }{y^{sp}}&=\frac{ E_{s,2}[u(x)-u(\cdot)](x,y) }{y^{2s}}\\ &= \frac{ E_{s,2}[u](x,0)-E_{s,2}[u](x,y) }{y^{2s}} \end{aligned} \] recovering the classical result of \cite{Caffarelli2007} for the fractional Laplacian. \begin{remark} Notice that, by L'Hôpital's rule \begin{equation*} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x_0) = \frac{C_3(n,s,p)}{sp} \lim_{y \to 0} y^{1-sp} \partial_y \left(E_{s,p}[\Phi_p(u(x_0)-u(\cdot))] \right)(x_0,y). \end{equation*} \end{remark} In order to prove \Cref{thm:extension} we need an important lemma that gives an alternative representation of the extension operator based on the one by Stinga and Torrea (\cite{Stinga2010}) for fractional powers of general linear operators. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:extension} Let $s \in (0,1)$ and $p \in (1,+\infty)$. If $f\in C_b({\mathbb R^n})$ then $E_{s,p}[f]$ is a classical solution of \eqref{eq:extension2}. Furthermore, it can be alternatively represented by \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-form1} E_{s,p}[f](x,y)= \frac{y^{sp}}{2^{sp}\Gamma(\frac {sp}2)} \int_0^\infty e^{t\Delta} [f](x) \, e^{-\frac {y^2}{4t} } \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}}. \end{equation} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} We proceed in several steps. \noindent \textbf{Step 1.} We will check here that the pointwise formulas \eqref{eq:ext-form1} and \eqref{eq:ext-form2} are well defined for $y>0$. First, for \eqref{eq:ext-form1}, we use the explicit representation of $e^{t\Delta}$, and the fact that $f$ is bounded \begin{align*} &\left|\int_0^\infty e^{t\Delta}\left[f \right] (x) \, e^{-\frac {y^2}{4t} } \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}}\right|\\ &= \left|\int_0^\infty e^{-\frac {y^2}{4t} } \left(\int_{\mathbb{R}^n} \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} e^{-\frac{|x-\xi|^2}{4t}}f(\xi) \diff \xi \right) \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}}\right|\\ & \lesssim \int_0^\infty e^{-\frac {y^2}{4t} } \left(\int_{\mathbb{R}^n} \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} e^{-\frac{|\xi|^2}{4t}} \diff \xi \right) \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}} \leq \int_0^\infty e^{-\frac {y^2}{4t} } \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}}. \end{align*} The last term is clearly finite since $sp/2>0$ and $e^{-\frac {y^2}{4t} } /t^{\alpha} \to 0$ as $t\to 0$ for any $\alpha\in \mathbb{R}$ as long as $y>0$. Second, for \eqref{eq:ext-form2}, \[ \left|\int_{ {\mathbb R^n} } \frac{f(\xi) }{(|x-\xi|^2 + y^2)^{\frac {n+sp}2}} \diff \xi\right |\lesssim \int_{ {\mathbb R^n} } \frac{\dd \xi }{(|\xi|^2 + y^2)^{\frac {n+sp}2}} \] which again is finite since $K(\xi):=(|\xi|^2+y^2)^{-\frac{n+2s}{2}}$ is bounded as long as $y>0$ and $K(\xi)\leq |\xi|^{-(n+2s)}$ which is an integrable function in $\mathbb{R}^n\setminus B_1$. \textbf{Step 2.} Now we check that both pointwise formulas are equivalent. Notice that, by Step 1, all the integrals below are well defined, and they allow us to do Fubini to change the order of integration. Then \begin{align*} &\frac{y^{sp}}{2^{sp}\Gamma(\frac {sp}2)} \int_0^\infty e^{t\Delta} \left[f \right] (x) \, e^{-\frac {y^2}{4t} } \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}}\\ & = \frac{y^{sp}}{2^{sp}\Gamma(\frac {sp}2)} \int_0^\infty \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{ \frac n 2 }} e^{-\frac{|x-\xi|^2+y^2}{4t}}f(\xi)\diff \xi \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}} \\ &= \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \left( \frac{y^{sp}}{2^{n+sp} \pi^{\frac n 2}\Gamma(\frac {sp}2)} \int_0^\infty e^{-\frac{|x-\xi|^2+y^2}{4t}}\frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{n+sp}2}} \right) f(\xi) \diff \xi\\ &= \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} \left(\frac{ y^{sp}}{ \pi^{\frac n 2}\Gamma(\frac {sp}2) (|x-\xi|^2 + y^2)^{\frac{n+sp}2}} \int_{0}^{\infty} {e^{-\tau}} \tau^{ - 1 + \frac{n+sp}2 } \diff \tau\right) f(\xi) \dd \xi\\ &= \int_{{\mathbb R^n}} P(x-\xi,y) f(\xi) \dd \xi. \end{align*} \textbf{Step 3. } Now we check that formulas \eqref{eq:ext-form1} and \eqref{eq:ext-form2} satisfy  \eqref{eq:extension2}. We start with the boundary condition. To do so, it is sufficient to show that \begin{equation*} P(x,y) \to \delta_0 (x) \quad \textup{as} \quad y\to0^+. \end{equation*} For $x\not=0$ it is easy to check from \eqref{eq:ext-form2} that we have \[ P(x,y) \to 0 \quad \textup{as} \quad y\to0^+. \] It is also standard to get \begin{equation*} \begin{split} \int_{{\mathbb R^n}}P(x,y)\dd x&= \frac{y^{sp}}{2^{sp} \Gamma(\frac {sp}2)} \int_0^\infty e^{\frac{y^2}{4t}} \left( \int_{{\mathbb R^n}}\frac{1}{(4\pi t)^\frac{n}{2}} e^{-\frac{|x|^2}{4t}} \dd x \right) \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}}\\ & = \frac{y^{sp}}{2^{sp} \Gamma(\frac {sp}2)} \int_0^\infty e^{\frac{y^2}{4t}} \frac{dt}{t^{1+\frac{sp}2}}=1. \end{split} \end{equation*} Finally, it is easy to compute (see for example \cite{Caffarelli2007}) that for all $y>0$ we have \begin{align*} \Delta_x P + \frac{1 - sp} y \frac{\partial P}{\partial y} + \frac{\partial^2 P}{\partial y^2} = 0. \end{align*} We have that $U$ is a pointwise solution of the extension equation. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of \Cref{thm:extension}] We need to check \eqref{eq:representation extension}. For $y>0$ we have, from \Cref{lem:extension}, the following identity \begin{align*} &C_3\frac{ E_{s,p}\Big [\Phi_p \big (u(x_0)-u(\cdot) \big ) \Big ](x_0,y) }{y^{sp}} \\ &= C_3 \int_{ {\mathbb R^n} } \frac{ P(x_0-\xi, y) }{y^{sp}} \Phi_p (u(x_0) - u(\xi)) \diff \xi.\\ &=C_1 \int_{ {\mathbb R^n} } \frac{ \Phi_p (u(x_0) - u(\xi)) }{(|x_0-\xi|^2+y^2)^{\frac{n+sp}{2}}} \diff \xi. \end{align*} Then, \begin{align*} &\Bigg|{(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) -C_3\frac{ E_{s,p}\Big [\Phi_p \big (u(x_0)-u(\cdot) \big ) \Big ](x_0,y) }{y^{sp}} \Bigg|\\ &= C_1 \left| \int_{ {\mathbb R^n} } \Phi_p (u(x_0) - u(\xi)) \left(\frac{1}{|x_0-\xi|^{n+sp}}- \frac{1}{(|x_0-\xi|^2+y^2)^{\frac{n+sp}{2}}}\right) \diff \xi \right|. \end{align*} Let us denote \[ K_y(\eta)= \left(\frac{1}{|\eta|^{n+sp}}- \frac{1}{(|\eta|^2+y^2)^{\frac{n+sp}{2}}}\right) \] and estimate \begin{align*} &\Bigg|{(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) -C_3\frac{ E_{s,p}\Big [\Phi_p \big (u(x_0)-u(\cdot) \big ) \Big ](x_0,y) }{y^{sp}} \Bigg|\\ &\qquad \qquad \lesssim \left| \int_{ |x_0-\xi|\leq1 } \Phi_p (u(x_0) - u(\xi)) K_y(x_0-\xi) \diff \xi \right| \\ &\qquad \qquad + \left| \int_{ |x_0-\xi|>1 } K_y(x_0-\xi) \diff \xi \right|. \end{align*} Note that the last term goes to zero by the Monotone Convergence Theorem since $K_y(x-\xi)\to0$ as $y\to0$ in a monotone way. Now, from either \Cref{lem:tech1}, \Cref{lem:tech3} and \Cref{lem:tech2} we get \[ \left| \int_{ |\eta|\leq1 } \Phi_p (u(x_0) - u(\xi)) K_y(x_0-\xi) \diff \xi \right| \leq \int_{ |\xi|\leq1 } K_y(\xi)|\xi|^\alpha \diff \xi, \] for $\alpha$ either $p$ or $2p-2$ depending on the range of $p$. This term again goes to zero as $y\to0$ by the Monotone Convergence Theorem. \end{proof} \section{Nonlinear Balakrishnan's formula}\label{sec:Balak} The aim of this section is to prove the corresponding Balakrishnan-type formula for $p \ne 2$. \begin{theorem}\label{thm:Balak} Let $s \in (0,1)$ and $p \in (1,+\infty)$. Assume $u\in C^2_b({\mathbb R^n})$ and $x_0\in {\mathbb R^n}$. If $p \in (1,\frac{2}{2-s})$ assume additionally that $\nabla u(x_0)\not=0$. We have the following representation of the fractional $p$-Laplacian: \begin{equation}\label{eq:BalakSec} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x_0) = C_4(n,s,p) \int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [\Phi_p ( u(x_0) - u(\cdot) )](x_0) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}, \end{equation} where the constant is given by \ $C_4 (n,s,p) = \frac{ \pi^{\frac n 2} } {2^{sp}\Gamma(\frac{2+sp}{2})\Gamma ( \frac {n + sp}2 )} C_1(n,s,p) $. \end{theorem} Notice that, when $p = 2$ we have that \begin{align*} \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [\Phi_p ( u(x_0) - u(\cdot) )] &= \Delta (t - \Delta)^{-1} [u(x_0) ] - \Delta(t - \Delta)^{-1} [u (\cdot) ] \\ &= - \Delta(t - \Delta)^{-1} [u]. \end{align*} Hence, we recover the usual Balakrishnan's formula. To show \eqref{eq:BalakSec} in \Cref{thm:Balak} we need some preliminary results concerning the representation formulas of $ (t-\Delta)^{-1} $ and $\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} $. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:representationformBalak} Let $f\in L^1(\mathbb{R}^n)\cap L^\infty(\mathbb{R}^n)$. The following representation formulas hold for all $t\geq0$: \begin{enumerate}[{\rm (a)}] \item\label{repfor-item1} $(t-\Delta)^{-1}f=K_t*f$ with $\displaystyle K_t(x)=\int_0^\infty e^{-t\tau} G(\tau,x) \dd \tau$ where $G$ is the Gaussian Kernel, i.e., \[ G(\tau,x)=\frac{1}{(4\pi \tau)^{\frac{n}{2}}} e^{-\frac{|x|^2}{4\tau}} \] \item\label{repfor-item2} $\Delta(t-\Delta)^{-1}f= R_t*f - f $ where $R_t(x)=tK_t(x)$. Moreover, $R_t(x)=t^{\frac{n}{2}}W(t^{\frac{1}{2}}|x|)$ with $W:\mathbb{R}_+\to\mathbb{R}_+$ given by \begin{equation}\label{eq:self-similarP} W(\rho)=\frac{\rho^{2-n}}{(4\pi)^{\frac{n}{2}}}\int_0^\infty e^{-\rho^2 w} w^{-\frac{n}{2}} e^{-\frac{1}{4w}} \dd w. \end{equation} \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} First, taking the Fourier transform \begin{align*} \mathcal F [ (t - \Delta) ^{-1} f ] (\xi) &= (t + |\xi|^2)^{-1} \mathcal F [f] (\xi)= \left( \int_0^\infty e^{-t \tau} e^{-|\xi|^2 \tau} \diff\tau \right) \mathcal F [f] (\xi) \\ &= \mathcal F \left[ \left( \int_0^\infty e^{-t \tau} \mathcal F^{-1} [e^{-|\cdot|^2 \tau}] \diff\tau \right) \star f \right] (\xi) . \end{align*} Since $\mathcal F[G(t, \cdot)] (\xi) = e^{-|\xi|^2 t}$ we recover \eqref{repfor-item1}. As shown in \cite[Section 3.2]{Martinez2001} we have \begin{equation*} t K_t - \Delta K_t = \delta_0. \end{equation*} The intuition for \eqref{repfor-item2} is clear and it comes from the fact that $\partial_t G - \Delta G = \delta_0$. We can formally write \begin{align*} \Delta K_t &= \int_0^\infty e^{-t \tau} \Delta G \diff \tau = \int_0^\infty e^{-t\tau} \partial_t G \diff \tau \\ &= e^{-t\tau} G\Big|_0^\infty + t \int_0^\infty e^{-t\tau} G \diff \tau = 0 - \delta_0 + t K_t. \end{align*} Hence, \begin{equation*} \Delta (t- \Delta)^{-1} f = \Delta (K_t \star f) = (\Delta K_t ) \star f = (R_t - \delta_0 ) \star f = R_t \star f - f. \end{equation*} We check \eqref{eq:self-similarP} now. First, we note that $G(\tau,x)=\tau^{-\frac{n}{2}}F(\tau^{-\frac{1}{2}}|x|)$ with $F:\mathbb{R}_+\to\mathbb{R}_+$ given by \[ F(\rho)=\frac{1}{(4\pi)^{\frac{n}{2}}} e^{-\frac{\rho^2}{4}}. \] Then, \begin{align*} R_t(x) &=t \int_0^\infty e^{-t\tau} \tau^{-\frac{n}{2}}F(\tau^{-\frac{1}{2}}|x|) \dd \tau\\ &= t |x|^{2-n} \int_0^\infty e^{-t|x|^2 w } w^{-\frac{n}{2}}F(w^{-\frac{1}{2}})d w \\ &= t^{\frac{n}{2}} (t^{\frac{1}{2}}|x|)^{2-n} \int_0^\infty e^{-(t^{\frac{1}{2}}|x|)^2 w} w^{-\frac{n}{2}}F(w^{-\frac{1}{2}})d w. \end{align*} \end{proof} We are now ready to prove \Cref{thm:Balak}. \begin{proof}[Proof of \Cref{thm:Balak}] We proceed in several steps. \noindent \textbf{Step 1:} We will check here that given $f\in L^\infty(\mathbb{R}^n)$, $\alpha<0$ and a finite $M>0$ we have that \[ \int_0^M |\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1}f(x)| \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\alpha}}<+\infty. \] From \Cref{lem:representationformBalak} we have \[ \begin{aligned} &|\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1}f(x)|= |R_t*f(x)| +|f(x)|\\ &\qquad \leq(\|R_t\|_{L^1(\mathbb{R}^N)}+1) \|f\|_{L^\infty(\mathbb{R}^N)}= 2\|f\|_{L^\infty(\mathbb{R}^N)} \end{aligned} \] where we have used the fact that $\|G(\tau,|\cdot|)\|_{L^1(\mathbb{R}^n)}=1$, which implies \[ \|R_t\|_{L^1(\mathbb{R}^N)} = \int_{\mathbb{R}^n} \left(t\int_0^\infty e^{-t \tau}G(\tau,|x|) \dd\tau\right)\dd x= t\int_0^\infty e^{-t \tau} \dd\tau=1. \] From this observation, we trivially get \[ \int_0^M |\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1}f(x)| \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\alpha}}< 2\frac{M^\alpha}{\alpha}\|f\|_{L^\infty(\mathbb{R}^N)} <+\infty. \] \textbf{Step 2:} Now, given $\varepsilon>0$, we consider the bounded function $g_\varepsilon:\mathbb{R}^n\times \mathbb{R}^n\to \mathbb{R}$ given by $g_\varepsilon(x,y)= \Phi_p ( u(x) - u(y) ) \chi_{|x-y| > \varepsilon}$. Note that $g_\varepsilon(x,x)=0$. Here we will check that the following identity holds \begin{equation} \label{eq:Balakidentity1} \int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}= C \int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} \frac{\Phi_p(u(x)-u(y))}{|x-y|^{n+sp}}\dd y. \end{equation} where $C= \frac{2^{sp}}{\pi^{\frac{n}{2}}} \Gamma(1+\frac{sp}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{n+sp}{2})>0$. \smallskip \textbf{Step 2 (a):} First we check that \begin{equation}\label{eq:absoluteconvBalak} \int_0^M |\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x)| \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}<+\infty \end{equation} uniformly in $M$. In this way, the Dominated convergence theorem we get \begin{equation}\label{eq:limitMBalak} \begin{aligned} &\int_0^M \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &\qquad \stackrel{M\to\infty}{\longrightarrow} \int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}<+\infty. \end{aligned} \end{equation} To check \eqref{eq:absoluteconvBalak}, we assume first that $p\geq2$, and use the explicit representation of $\Delta(t-\Delta)^{-1}$ given in \Cref{lem:representationformBalak} together with \Cref{lem:tech1} to get \begin{align*} &\int_0^M |\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x)| \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &=\int_0^1 |\Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x)| \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &\qquad + \int_1^M \left|\int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} R_t (x-y) \Phi_p(u(x)-u(y))\dd y \right|\frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &\leq \frac{2}{sp}\|g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)\|_{L^\infty(\mathbb{R}^n)}+ C \int_1^\infty\left( \int_{|z|>\varepsilon} R_t (z) |z|^p \dd z\right)\frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}. \end{align*} We use now the explicit form of $R_t$ to get \begin{align*} &\int_1^\infty\left( \int_{|z|>\varepsilon} R_t (z) |z|^p \dd z\right)\frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &= \int_1^\infty\left( \int_{|z|>\varepsilon} t^{\frac{n}{2}}W(t^{\frac{1}{2}}|z|) |z|^p \dd z\right)\frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &=\int_1^\infty \left( \int_{|y|>\varepsilon t^{\frac{1}{2}}} W(|y|) |y|^pt^{-\frac{p}{2}} \dd y\right)\frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &\leq \left( \int_{|y|>\varepsilon} W(|y|) |y|^p \dd y\right) \left(\int_1^\infty \frac{\dd t}{ t^{1+\frac {(1-s)p} {2}}} \right). \end{align*} It is rather standard to check that the last two integrals are finite. Thus, \eqref{eq:limitMBalak} is proved for $p\geq2$. When $p\in(1,2)$ we use \Cref{lem:tech3} and \Cref{lem:tech2} instead and the proof follows in the same way. \smallskip \textbf{Step 2 (b):} We proceed now by direct computations: \begin{align}\label{eq:BalaklimM} &\int_0^M \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &= \int_0^M \int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} R_t (x-y) \Phi_p(u(x)-u(y))\dd y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\nonumber\\ &=\int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} \Phi_p(u(x)-u(y)) \left( \int_0^M R_t (x-y) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\right) \dd y\\ &=\int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} \frac{\Phi_p(u(x)-u(y))}{|x-y|^{n+sp}} \left( \int_0^{M|x-y|^2} W(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}}) \frac{\diff \tau}{(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}})^{2-n- {sp} }}\right) \dd y.\nonumber \end{align} For any $y \ne x$ \[ \int_0^{M|x-y|^2} W(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}}) \frac{\diff \tau}{(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}})^{2-n- {sp} }} \stackrel{M\to \infty}{\longrightarrow} \int_0^{\infty} W(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}}) \frac{\diff \tau}{(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}})^{2-n- {sp} }}=:C. \] We just need to check that $C$ is finite which will ensure we can pass to the limit in the last term of \eqref{eq:BalaklimM} (we can also do it in the first by Step 2(a)) to get \eqref{eq:Balakidentity1} by the Dominated Convergence Theorem since \[ \begin{aligned} &\int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} \frac{|\Phi_p(u(x)-u(y))|}{|x-y|^{n+sp}} \left( \int_0^{M|x-y|^2} W(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}}) \frac{\diff t}{(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}})^{2-n- {sp} }}\right) \dd y \\ &\qquad \leq C \int_{|x-y|>\varepsilon} \frac{|\Phi_p(u(x)-u(y))|}{|x-y|^{n+sp}} \dd y<+\infty. \end{aligned} \] Let us now compute $C$ explicitly: \begin{align*} C&=\int_0^{\infty} \left( \frac{\tau^{1-\frac{n}{2}}}{(4\pi)^{\frac{n}{2}}}\int_0^\infty e^{-\tau w} w^{-\frac{n}{2}} e^{-\frac{1}{4w}} \dd w \right) \frac{\diff \tau}{(\tau^{\frac{1}{2}})^{2-n- {sp} }}\\ &= \frac{1}{(4\pi)^{\frac{n}{2}}}\int_0^\infty w^{-\frac{n}{2}} e^{-\frac{1}{4w}} \left(\int_0^{\infty}e^{-\tau w} \tau^{\frac{sp}{2}} \diff \tau \right)\dd w \\ &= \frac{1}{(4\pi)^{\frac{n}{2}}}\int_0^\infty w^{-1-\frac{n}{2}-\frac{sp}{2}} e^{-\frac{1}{4w}} \left(\int_0^{\infty}e^{-\eta } \eta^{\frac{sp}{2}} \diff \eta \right)\dd w\\ &=\Gamma\left (1+\tfrac{sp}{2}\right) \frac{1}{(4\pi)^{\frac{n}{2}}}\int_0^\infty w^{-1-\frac{n}{2}-\frac{sp}{2}} e^{-\frac{1}{4w}} \dd w \\ &= \Gamma\left(1+\tfrac{sp}{2}\right) \frac{4^{\frac{sp}{2}}}{\pi^{\frac{n}{2}}}\int_0^\infty \rho^{-1+\frac{n}{2}+\frac{sp}{2}} e^{-\rho} \dd \rho \\ &= \frac{2^{sp}}{\pi^{\frac{n}{2}}} \Gamma\left(1+\tfrac{sp}{2}\right) \Gamma\left(\tfrac{n+sp}{2}\right). \end{align*} Clearly $C<+\infty$, which finishes the proof of Step 2. \textbf{Step 3.} Lastly, we pass to the limit as $\varepsilon\to0$ in \eqref{eq:Balakidentity1}. The limit of the right hand side term was already shown in Step 1 of the proof of \Cref{thm:semigroup}. For the left hand side, when $p\geq2$, we have by \Cref{lem:tech1} (we can proceed analogously with \Cref{lem:tech3} and \Cref{lem:tech2} when $p\in(1,2)$) we compute directly \begin{align*} &\Bigg|\int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [g_\varepsilon(x,\cdot)](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &\qquad - \int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [\Phi_p(u(x)-u(\cdot))](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\Bigg|\\ &\leq \int_0^\infty \left| \int_{|x-y|<\varepsilon} \Phi_p(u(x)-u(y)) R_t(x-y) \dd y \right| \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &\leq 2 \Phi_p(\|u\|_{L^\infty(\mathbb{R}^n)})\int_0^1 \left( \int_{|z|<\varepsilon} R_t(z) \dd z \right) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &\qquad + C \int_1^\infty \left( \int_{|z|<\varepsilon} R_t(z)|z|^p \dd z \right) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}. \end{align*} Clearly the left integral in the last equation goes to $0$ as $\varepsilon\to0$ since $f_\varepsilon(t):= \int_{|z|<\varepsilon} R_t(z) \dd z \to0$ pointwise as $\varepsilon \to0$ due to the fact that $\|R_t\|_{L^1(\mathbb{R}^n)}=1$. For the right integral, we have \[ \int_1^\infty \left( \int_{|z|<\varepsilon} R_t(z)|z|^p \dd z \right) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}= \int_1^\infty \left( \int_{|y|<\varepsilon t^{\frac{1}{2}}} W(|y|) |y|^p \dd y\right) \frac{\dd t}{t^{1+\frac {(1-s)p} {2}}} \] which again goes to 0 as $\varepsilon \to 0$ since $ \int_{|y|<\varepsilon t^{\frac{1}{2}}} W(|y|) |y|^p \dd y \to0$ a.e.\ in $t$ as $\varepsilon \to0$. This finishes the proof. \end{proof} \section{The choice of a suitable constant}\label{sec:constants} The choice of the constant $C_1>0$ in \eqref{eq.spl1} is indifferent in most cases and can be put to 1, but a precise value $C_1(n,s,p)$ can be important in writing some exact formulas or in the limit cases $s\to 0^+$, $s\to 1^-$, or $p\to 2$. Thus, in the linear case $p=2$ the natural value is fixed by the assumption that the Fourier transform of the operator is a power multiplier, $\mathcal F [(-\Delta)^s u] = |\xi|^{2s} \mathcal F[u]$, cf. \cite{Stein1970}. Working out the details, the literature points out the value \begin{equation}\label{const.p2} c_{n,s} = \frac{2^{2s} \Gamma \left( \frac{n+2s}{2} \right) }{ \pi^{\frac n 2} |\Gamma (-s)| }= s(1-s)\frac{2^{2s} \Gamma \left( \frac{n+2s}{2} \right) }{ \pi^{\frac n 2} \Gamma (2-s) }. \end{equation} However, this choice may not seem to be complete when $p\not=2$. One might expect the choice of $C_1$ to depend on $p$ in such a way that the expected limits are recovered: \begin{equation} \label{eq:limits} \begin{aligned} {(-\Delta)_p^s} \phi &\stackrel{s\to 1^-}{\longrightarrow} -\Delta_p\phi(x)\quad \textup{for all } p\in[2,\infty) \\ {(-\Delta)_p^s} \phi &\stackrel{p\to2^+}{\longrightarrow} (-\Delta)^s\phi(x) \quad \textup{for all } s\in(0,1). \end{aligned} \end{equation} The choice \eqref{const.p2} satisfies the second limit, but not the first one. We propose the following constant. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:constant} Consider the constant \[ C_1(n,s,p)=\frac{\frac{sp}{2}(1-s)2^{2s-1}}{\pi^{\frac{n-1}{2}}} \frac{\Gamma(\frac{n+sp}{2})}{\Gamma{(\frac{p+1}{2})}\Gamma(2-s)} \] in \eqref{eq.spl1}. Then, for $\phi \in C^2_b(\mathbb{R}^n)$ we have that \eqref{eq:limits} holds. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Consider the operator \[ \mathcal{L}^{s}_p[\phi](x)= \PV \int_{\mathbb R^d} \frac{\Phi_p (u(x) - u(y))}{|x-y|^{n+sp}} \diff y. \] We will use the following limit \begin{equation}\label{eq:lim_s} (1-s) \mathcal{L}^s_p[\phi](x)\stackrel{s\to 1^-}{\longrightarrow} - \frac{\pi^{\frac{n-1}{2}}}{p} \frac{\Gamma(\frac{p+1}{2})}{\Gamma(\frac{n+p}{2})} \Delta_p\phi(x). \end{equation} When $\nabla\phi(x)\not=0$, \eqref{eq:lim_s} is precisely \cite[Theorem 2.8]{Bucur2020}. The situation when $\nabla \phi(x)=0$ is even simpler. The case $p=2$ is classical and we omit it (see for example \cite{DiNezza2012}). When $p>2$ we rely on the following intermediate step in the proof of \cite[Theorem 2.8]{Bucur2020} (see also the proof of \cite[Theorem 6.1]{delTesoLindgren2020}): \[ (1-s) \mathcal{L}^s_p[\phi](x)\stackrel{s\to 1^-}{\longrightarrow} -\frac{p-1}{2p}\int_{\partial B_1(0)} \left|\nabla \phi(x) \cdot y \right|^{p-2} y^{T} D^2\phi(x) y \dd \sigma(y). \] Clearly the right hand side term in the equation above is zero when $\nabla \phi(x)=0$. Finally, if $\nabla \phi(x)=0$, it is straightforward to see that $-\Delta_p\phi(x)=0$ for $p>2$. This proves \eqref{eq:lim_s}. Then, \begin{align*} &C_1(n,s,p) \mathcal{L}^s_p[\phi](x) = \left(\frac{\frac{sp}{2}2^{2s-1}}{\pi^{\frac{n-1}{2}}} \frac{\Gamma(\frac{n+sp}{2})}{\Gamma{(\frac{p+1}{2})}\Gamma(2-s)} \right) \left((1-s) \mathcal{L}^s_p[\phi](x) \right)\\ &\stackrel{s\to 1^-}{\longrightarrow} \left(\frac{\frac{p}{2}2}{\pi^{\frac{n-1}{2}}} \frac{\Gamma(\frac{n+p}{2})}{\Gamma{(\frac{p+1}{2})}\Gamma(1)} \right) \left(- \frac{\pi^{\frac{n-1}{2}}}{p} \frac{\Gamma(\frac{p+1}{2})}{\Gamma(\frac{n+p}{2})} \Delta_p\phi(x)\right)=-\Delta_p\phi(x), \end{align*} where we have used the fact that $\Gamma(1)=1$. This proves the first limit in \eqref{eq:limits}. For the second limit, we just need to check that $C_1(n,s,2)$ coincides with $c_{n,s}$ given in \eqref{const.p2}. This is just a simple computation \begin{align*} C_1(n,s,2)&=\frac{s(1-s)2^{2s-1}}{\pi^{\frac{n-1}{2}}} \frac{\Gamma(\frac{n+2s}{2})}{\Gamma{(\frac{3}{2})}\Gamma(2-s)}\\ &= \frac{s(1-s)2^{2s}}{\pi^{\frac{n}{2}}} \frac{\Gamma(\frac{n+2s}{2})}{\Gamma(2-s)} \end{align*} where we have used the fact that $\Gamma(1/2)=\sqrt{\pi}$ and $z\Gamma(z)=\Gamma(z+1)$. This finished the proof. \end{proof} \begin{remark} With the choice of $C_1(n,s,p)$ given by \Cref{lem:constant} we have that \[ C_2(s,p):= C_1(n,s,p) \frac {\pi^{ \frac n 2 } } {2^{sp} \Gamma(\frac{n+sp}2)} = \pi^{ \frac 1 2 } \frac{p}{\Gamma(\frac{p+1}{2})}\frac{1}{|\Gamma(-s)|} 2^{s(2-p)-2}, \] \[ C_3(s,p)=C_1(n,s,p) \frac{ \pi^{\frac n 2} \Gamma (\frac{sp}2)} {\Gamma ( \frac {n + sp}2 )} = \pi^{\frac 1 2} \frac{p}{\Gamma{(\frac{p+1}{2})}} \frac{ \Gamma (\frac{sp}2)} {|\Gamma(-s)|} 2^{2s-2}, \] and \begin{align*} C_4(s,p)&= C_1(n,s,p) \frac{ \pi^{\frac n 2} } {2^{sp}\Gamma(\frac{2+sp}{2})\Gamma ( \frac {n + sp}2 )} \\ &= \pi^{\frac{1}{2}}\frac{p}{(\frac{p+1}{2})} \frac{ 1 } {|\Gamma(-s)|\Gamma(\frac{2+sp}{2})} 2^{s(2-p)-2}. \end{align*} An important fact is that these constants are independent of the dimension. It is also standard to check that \[ \begin{gathered} C_2(s,2)=\frac{1}{|\Gamma(-s)|}, \quad C_3(s,2)=\frac{\Gamma(s)}{|\Gamma(-s)|}4^s, \\ \textup{and} \quad C_4(s,2)= \frac{ 1 } {|\Gamma(-s)|\Gamma(1+s)}=\frac{\sin(s\pi)}{\pi} \end{gathered} \] which recover the classical constants for the semigroup formula and the extension problem (see for example \cite{Kwa17}). \end{remark} \section{A new spectral-type fractional $p$-Laplacian on domains} \label{sec:new spectral} There are many well known applications and interesting remarks of the semigroup formula and the extension problem for the fractional Laplacian. After the results that we have shown in this paper, a number of applications can be naturally proposed in the context of the fractional $p$-Laplacian. Here is a first application. Let $\Omega$ be a smooth domain (bounded or otherwise). The semigroup representation \eqref{eq:semigintro} motivates the definition of a new operator using formula \eqref{eq:semigdomain}, where we replaced $-\Delta$ by $-\Delta_{\Omega}$, the Laplacian with homogeneous Dirichlet boundary conditions. It is clear that $(-\Delta_\Omega)_p^s$ coincides with ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$ \ if \ $\Omega = \mathbb R^n$, and one can even expect some ``continuous'' dependence on $\Omega$. This is, to our knowledge, a new example of nonlocal operator when $\Omega \neq \mathbb R^n$. We will show below it does not coincide with ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$ applied to the extension of $u$ by $0$ outside $\Omega$. On the other hand, when $p = 2$ we recover the usual Spectral Fractional Laplacian, which is simply the usual spectral power of the Dirichlet Laplacian in a bounded domain as a compact operator; we refer the reader to \cite{CaTa10, Stinga2010,MR3360740} for modern references. First, we show it is well-defined for functions defined exclusively in $\Omega$, at least when they are smooth. This will allow to consider a boundary value problem with boundary conditions in $\partial \Omega$, without taking the set $\mathbb R^n \setminus \Omega$ into account. \begin{theorem} \label{lem:spectral is defined} Let $s \in (0,1)$ and assume that $u\in C^2(\overline \Omega),$ where $\Omega$ is a smooth subdomain on ${\mathbb R^n}$. If $p \ge \frac{2}{2-s}$, the following formula \begin{equation}\label{eq:semigdomain2} (-\Delta_\Omega)_{p}^s u (x_0) :=C_2\int_0^{+\infty} e^{t \Delta_\Omega} [\Phi_p ( u(x_0) - u(\cdot) )](x_0) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \end{equation} is well-defined at every $x_0 \in \Omega$. If $p$ is close to 1, more precisely $p \in (1,\frac{2}{2-s})$, we need to assume additionally that $\nabla u(x_0)\not=0$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Since $\Omega$ is smooth, we can extend $u$ to a $C_c^2(\mathbb R^n)$, via the tubular neighbourhood theorem. We will still denote the extended function by $u$. The time integral in formula \eqref{eq:semigdomain2} could be singular at both ends, $t = 0, \infty$, hence we must show the convergence of the integral at either end. The integral over the interval $[1,\infty)$ is not a problem, since $\| e^{t \Delta_\Omega} f \|_{L^\infty (\Omega)} \le C e^{-\lambda_1 t} \| f \|_{L^\infty (\Omega)}$ where $\lambda_1$ is the first eigenvalue of the Dirichlet Laplacian. Let us show that there exists \begin{equation*} \lim_{m \to \infty} \int_{1/m}^{1} e^{t \Delta_\Omega} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}. \end{equation*} We do this by following the proof done above with ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$, with suitable modifications. For convenience, we write the semigroup $e^{t \Delta_{\Omega}}$ in its kernel form $K_\Omega$, and compare with the heat kernel of the whole space $K_{\mathbb R^n}$. We define $g(x,y) = \Phi_p ( u(x) - u(y) )$. Then, \begin{equation*} e^{t \Delta_\Omega} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) )](x) = \int_\Omega K_\Omega(t,x,y) g(x,y) \diff y . \end{equation*} We write \begin{equation} \label{eq:sp lap in domain decomposition} \begin{aligned} &\int_{1/m}^1 \int_\Omega K_\Omega(t,x,y) g(x,y) \diff y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &=\int_{1/m}^1 \int_{\mathbb R^n} K_{\mathbb R^n}(t,x,y) g(x,y) \diff y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &\qquad - \int_{1/m}^1 \int_{\mathbb R^n \setminus \Omega} K_{\mathbb R^n}(t,x,y) g(x,y) \diff y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &\qquad - \int_{1/m}^1 \int_\Omega ( K_{\mathbb R^n}(t,x,y) - K_\Omega (t,x,y)) g(x,y) \diff y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} . \end{aligned} \end{equation} For the first term on the right-hand side we can compute the limit, which is well-defined by our knowledge of ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$, notice that by \eqref{eq:convergence semigroup} in the proof \Cref{thm:semigroup} we have \begin{equation*} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) = \lim_{m \to \infty} \int_{1/m} ^\infty \int_{\mathbb R^n } K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,x,y) g(x,y) \diff y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}. \end{equation*} For the other two terms in \eqref{eq:sp lap in domain decomposition}, we will show the convergence by checking they are Cauchy sequences. To this effect, we write for $k > m > 0$ that \begin{equation*} \int_{1/m}^1 f(t) \diff t - \int_{1/k}^1 f(t) \diff t = \int_{1/m}^{1/k} f(t) \diff t. \end{equation*} We need to show that the two remaining terms give Cauchy sequences, so we take $ k > m > 0$. The second term is easy to estimate \begin{align*} &\left| \int_{1/k}^{1/m} \int_{\mathbb R^n \setminus \Omega} K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,x,y) g(x,y)\dd y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \right| \\ & \le \| g(x, \cdot) \|_{L^\infty (\Omega)} \int_{1/k}^{1/m} \frac{1}{(4\pi t)^{\frac n 2} } \int_{\dist (x, \partial \Omega)}^\infty e^{-\frac{r^2}{4t}} r^{n-1}\diff r \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &= \| g(x, \cdot) \|_{L^\infty (\Omega)} \int_{1/k}^{1/m} \int_{C / t }^\infty e^{-1/\rho} p(\rho) \diff \rho \, q(t) \diff t \\ &\le C \| g(x, \cdot) \|_{L^\infty (\Omega)} \int_{0}^{1/m} e^{-D/t} q(t) \diff t\,, \end{align*} where $p$ and $q$ are bounded by positive and negative powers and $C, D > 0$. Since $e^{-D t} q(t) \in L^1(0,1)$, the second term of the right-hand side of \eqref{eq:sp lap in domain decomposition} is a Cauchy sequence. For the last term of \eqref{eq:sp lap in domain decomposition}, using the comparison principle we have that \begin{equation*} 0 \le K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,x,y) - K_\Omega (t,x,y) \le \max_{z \in \partial \Omega} K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,x,z) = \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{\frac n 2} }e^{- \frac{\dist(x, \partial \Omega)^2}{4t} }. \end{equation*} Thus, \begin{align*} &\int_{1/k}^{1/m} \left| \int_{\Omega} ( K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,x,y) - K_\Omega (t,x,y) ) g(x,y) dy \right| \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &\le \| g (x, \cdot) \|_{L^\infty (\Omega) } \int_{0}^{1/m} \frac{1}{(4 \pi t)^{\frac n 2} }e^{- \frac{\dist(x, \partial \Omega)^2}{4t} }\frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} . \end{align*} Hence, the last term of \eqref{eq:sp lap in domain decomposition} is also a Cauchy sequence. \end{proof} \begin{remark} This operator is indeed different from the usual one on domains, which uses the formula of ${(-\Delta)_p^s}$ restricted to functions $u$ defined in ${\mathbb R^n}$ such that $u = 0$ outside $\Omega$ (see, for example, \cite{Mazon2016,Vazquez2016}). Let $\Omega$ be fixed and assume without loss of generality that $0 \in \Omega$. Let $B_R (0) \subset \Omega$ and $u$ a smooth function that is positive, radially symmetric, and strictly decreasing along the radius and $0$ outside of $B_R$. Then, with the notation of the proof of \Cref{lem:spectral is defined} \begin{align*} &{(-\Delta)_p^s} u(0) - (-\Delta_\Omega)_p^s u(0) \\ &\quad = \int_0^\infty \int_\Omega (K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,0,y) - K_\Omega (t,0,y)) \Phi_p(u(0)-u(y)) \diff y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} \\ &\qquad + \int_0^\infty \int_{\mathbb R^n \setminus \Omega} K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,x,y) \Phi_p(u(0)-u(y)) \diff y \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}} > 0. \end{align*} This happens because both integrands are nonnegative functions, and $K_{\mathbb R^n} (t,x,y) - K_\Omega (t,x,y)\geq0$ for all $x,y\in\Omega$. \end{remark} \begin{remark} We can similarly define operators via the extension problem and Balakrishnan's formulas. For example, \begin{equation*} (-\Delta_\Omega)_{p}^s u (x_0) = C_4 \int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta_\Omega)^{-1} [\Phi_p ( u(x_0) - u(\cdot) )](x_0) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}}. \end{equation*} It is an interesting open problem to check whether these definitions are equivalent. Another formula can be written via the extension. \end{remark} \section{Numerical applications}\label{sec:numApp} Among the many possible applications of our representations, we want to comment next on the construction of finite-difference methods for the fractional $p$-Laplacian. We recall that monotone finite-difference discretizations for the fractional Laplacian (case $p=2$) have been established in the papers \cite{Ci-etal18} (in $\mathbb{R}$) and \cite{DelTeso2018} (in $\mathbb{R}^n$) based on the semigroup representation. The advantage of these types of discretizations is that they have a quadratic error order, independently of the fractional power of the operator (see \cite{DelTeso2018}). This is a great advantage compared to other finite difference discretizations in the literature (see discussion in \cite{DelTeso2018, DelTeso2019}). Similar ideas could be used in the case of the fractional $p$-Laplacian using the results of \Cref{thm:semigroup}. Let us explain the process at a formal level. Let $h>0$ and $\{e_i\}_{i=i}^n$ be standard basis of $\mathbb{R}^n$. Consider the discrete Laplacian given by \begin{equation}\label{eq:disclap} \Delta_h [u](x) = \sum_{i=1}^n \frac{u(x+he_i) + u(x-he_i) - 2u(x)}{h^2}. \end{equation} The already-classical theory shows that this is an ``asymptotically good'' approximation of $\Delta$ (in the sense that it produces convergent and stable schemes in many settings). In accordance to our representation ideas, we are led to define the following discrete operator \begin{equation}\label{eq:discplap} (-\Delta_h)_p^s [u] (x) := C_2 \int_0^\infty e^{t \Delta_h} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot))](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}, \end{equation} by simply replacing $\Delta$ by $\Delta_h$ in \eqref{eq:semigintro}. In this setting, $e^{t \Delta_h} [f]$ represents the uniquely-defined solution of $\partial_t w = \Delta_h w$ such that $w(x,0) = f(x)$. We will call it the \emph{discrete fractional $p$-Laplacian}. \bigskip At least formally, we have an alternative representation of $(-\Delta_h)_p^s$ given in a finite-difference form similar to \eqref{eq:disclap}. We follow here the presentation of \cite{DelTeso2018}. Let $z_\beta := \beta h$ for $\beta:=(\beta_1,\ldots,\beta_n) \in \mathbb{Z}^n$ and $\psi:\mathbb{R}^n \to \mathbb{R}$. We have that \[ e^{t \Delta_{ h}}[\psi](x) = \sum_{\beta\in \mathbb{Z}^n} \psi(x+z_\beta) G(\beta, \tfrac{t}{h^2}) \] where $G(\beta,t)=e^{-2nt} \Pi_{i=1}^n I_{|\beta_i|}(2t)$ and $I_m$ is the modified Bessel function of first kind with order $m\in \N$. From \eqref{eq:discplap} we get, at least formally, \begin{align*} (-\Delta_h)_p^s u(x)&=C_2 \int_0^\infty \left( \sum_{\beta\not=0} \Phi_p \left( u(x) - u(x+z_\beta) \right)G(\beta, \tfrac{t}{h^2}) \right) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\\ &= \sum_{\beta\not=0} \Phi_p \left( u(x) - u(x+z_\beta) \right) C_2 \int_0^\infty G(\beta, \tfrac{t}{h^2}) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}. \end{align*} Finally, the change of variables $\tau=t/h^2$ allows to write \begin{equation}\label{eq:FDpLap} \begin{aligned} &(-\Delta_h)_p^s u(x)= \sum_{\beta\not=0} \Phi_p \left( u(x) - u(x+z_\beta) \right) K_{\beta,h} \\ &\qquad \textup{with} \quad K_{\beta,h} = \frac{C_2}{h^{sp}} \int_0^\infty G(\beta,t) \frac{\dd t}{t^{1+\frac{sp}{2}}}. \end{aligned} \end{equation} This process is rigorous when $sp<2$. However, the weights $K_{\beta,h}$ are not well defined when $sp\geq2$: for example when $n=1$, we note that \[ G(1,t)=e^{-2nt} I_{1}(2t) \sim t \quad \textup{for} \quad t\ll 1, \] which is only enough to show the convergence of the integral in the mentioned range. However, when $sp\geq2$, it is easy to show that formula \eqref{eq:discplap} fails to have a finite value at a point $x$ of global strict maximum of $u$. An idea to solve this problem is introducing an extra discretization parameter $\delta >0$ and alternatively define \begin{align}\label{eq:discFPL2} (-\Delta_{h,\delta})_p^s:=& C_2 \int_\delta ^\infty\left(e^{t \Delta} [\Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) \right)](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\\\nonumber =& \sum_{\beta\not=0} \Phi_p \left( u(x) - u(x+z_\beta) \right) K_{\beta,h,\delta }, \qquad \qquad \\ \textup{with} & \quad K_{\beta,h,\delta } = \frac{C_2}{h^{sp}} \int_{\delta h^2}^\infty G_{ h}(\beta,t) \frac{\dd t}{t^{1+\frac{sp}{2}}}. \end{align} In this way, all the integral are finite and all the steps are well justified rigorously in the whole range $p\in (1,\infty)$ and $s\in(0,1)$. One should make $\delta \to 0$ as $h \to 0$ to show that the discretization is consistent in some proper sense. \begin{remark} A different finite difference discretization of the from of \eqref{eq:FDpLap} for nonlocal $p$-Laplacian type operators (in the sense of \cite{Andreu2010}) has been obtained in \cite{Perez11}. They are based on obtaining quadrature rules for a singular integral definition like \eqref{eq.frlap}. In both cases the obtained discretizations are monotone, which yields good properties of the associated schemes. \end{remark} \begin{remark} Balakrishnan's formula has been the starting point for one of the most popular numerical schemes for the fractional Laplacian. The scheme combines a quadrature for the time integral and a numerical scheme for a sequence of the spatial operators $\Delta(t-\Delta)^{-1}$. One of the main advantages of this idea is the fact that, contrary to others, it is suited for parallel computing. We refer to \cite{BoPa15} as the basic reference to the topic. \end{remark} \begin{remark} The extension problem has also been successfully used by the numerical analysis community in the context of the fractional Laplacian. We refer the reader to \cite{Teso14} for a finite difference treatment in the context of nonlocal porous medium equations and to \cite{NoOtSa15} for a finite element one in the context of boundary value problems. \end{remark} \section{Other applications}\label{sec:app} We collect here a series of directions in which our previous ideas can be developed. \subsection{Equivalent representations of the $W^{s,p}(\mathbb{R}^n)$ seminorm}\label{ssec.8.1} We can define an equivalent way of defining the $(s,p)$-energy \eqref{Jsp1}. More precisely, consider the Gagliardo semi-norm \[ [u]_{W^{s,p}(\mathbb{R}^n)}:= \left(C_1\int_{{\mathbb R^d}}\int_{{\mathbb R^d} } \frac{|u(x)-u(y)|^p}{|x-y|^{N+sp}} \dd x \dd y \right)^{\frac{1}{p}}. \] It is standard to check that we have the following alternative definition \[ [u]_{W^{s,p}(\mathbb{R}^n)}= \left(C_2\int_{\mathbb{R}^n}\int_0^{+\infty} e^{t \Delta} [ |u(x) - u(\cdot)|^p ](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\frac {sp} 2}}\dd x\right)^{\frac{1}{p}}. \] This formulation was introduced in \cite{Tai64}. We also refer to \cite{Garofalo2020} for a modern reference on the topic in the context of Carnot groups. The corresponding version with Balakrishnan's formula, is \[ [u]_{W^{s,p}(\mathbb{R}^n)}=\left(C_4\int_{\mathbb{R}^n} \int_0^\infty \Delta (t-\Delta)^{-1} [|u(x) - u(\cdot)|^p](x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1-\frac {sp} 2}} \dd x\right)^{\frac{1}{p}}. \] We have not found this expression in the literature. A similar formula can be constructed via the extension, but it comes as an awkward product of gradients. \subsection{Spectral $(s,p)$-Laplacian on manifolds} Let $(M,g)$ be a Riemannian manifold. Some authors (see, e.g. \cite{Guo2018}) have used the $(s,p)$-fractional Laplacian on manifolds given by \begin{equation*} (-\Delta)_{M,p}^s u(x) = C_3(n,s,p) \PV \int_{M} \frac{\Phi_p (u(x) - u(y))}{d_g(x,y)^{n+sp}} \diff y, \end{equation*} where $g$ is a Riemannian metric on $M$. This a regional-type operator. Following our approach for bounded domain, we propose also the spectral-type operator \begin{equation*} (-\Delta_M)_p^s u (x) = C_1 (n,s,p) \int_0^{+\infty} e^{- t \Delta_g} \Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) ) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+sp}} \end{equation*} where $\Delta_g$ is the Laplace-Beltrami operator on $M$. The change in sign with respect to the other formulas is due to the convention in Geometry, where $\Delta_g$ is the positive operator. The idea of dealing with this kind of operators has been considered in the case of the fractional versions of the heat equation and porous medium equations. The extension method was used by Banica et al. \cite{Banica2015} for the fractional heat equation on hyperbolic space or non compact manifolds. The spectral approach was used quite recently by Berchio et al. \cite{MR4150871} for the fractional porous medium equation posed in hyperbolic space. \subsection{Representation via a general parametric family of operators}\label{ssec.gen} Following the philosophy of \Cref{sec:semigrep} and \Cref{sec:Balak} we can think of more general representation formulas for the fractional $p$-Laplacian. Consider a parametric operator family $\{T_t\}_{t\geq0}$ defined via convolution with measure kernels $K(t,\cdot)$, i.e., \begin{equation*} T_t f(x) = \int_{\mathbb R^n} K(t,x-y) f(y) \diff y\,. \end{equation*} At minimum, we need to assume that \begin{equation*} \int_0^\infty K(t, y) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\alpha}} = \frac{ C_K}{|y|^{n+sp}} \quad \text{for all } y \in {\mathbb R^n}. \end{equation*} for some finite constant $C_K\ne 0$. Then, we can expect that the following formula holds \begin{equation}\label{eq:general semigroup splitting formula} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u(x) = C_T \int_0^{+\infty} T_t \left[ \Phi_p ( u(x) - u(\cdot) ) \right] (x) \frac{\diff t}{t^{1+\alpha}} \end{equation} with $C_T=C_1(n,s,p)/C_K$. These formulas have a particularly nice form if $K$ is self-similar, like for example \[ K(t,y) =t^{-\beta} F(t^{-\gamma}|y|) \quad \textup{with} \quad \gamma\not=0 \quad \textup{and} \quad \frac{\beta+\alpha}{\gamma} = n+sp, \] so that \[ C_K \vcentcolon= \frac{1}{\gamma} \int_0^\infty F(r) {r^{n+sp-1}} {\dd r}. \] In some settings, our proofs of the semigroup and the Balakrishnan's formulas can be repeated. However, if $K$ changes sign and it is not $L^1$, some estimates are likely more difficult. This can be the case, for example, when working with $T_t = (-\Delta)^k (t - \Delta)^m$. \begin{remark} Note that when we use the heat semigroup, $T_t=e^{t \Delta}$, we have \[ K(t,y)= t^{-\frac{n}{2}}F(t^{-\frac{1}{2}}|y|) \quad \textup{with} \quad F(r)=\frac{1}{(4\pi)^{\frac{n}{2}}} e^{ -\frac{r^2}{4}}. \] Here, $\gamma=1/2$, and we must take $\alpha=sp/2$. It works for all $s$ and $p$, see \eqref{repr1}. \end{remark} \begin{remark} Another option is to use a fractional heat semigroup, $T_t = e^{-t (-\Delta)^\sigma}$, with $\sigma \in (0,1)$. Then the representation \eqref{eq:general semigroup splitting formula} is correct on the condition that $ sp<2\sigma$. Let us sketch the proof. It is well known, see for instance \cite{BG60, BSV17}, that the fractional semigroup has a kernel $K$ with scaling parameters $\beta=n/2\sigma$ and $\gamma=1/2\sigma$, and a profile $F$ that decays like $F(r)\sim r^{-(n+2\sigma)}$ as $r\to\infty$. It follows that we must take $\alpha= sp/2\sigma$. In view of the decay of $F$, the integral for $C_K$ is convergent only if $sp<2\sigma$, and then the technique applies. On the contrary, the fat tail of $F$ is incompatible with this representation if $sp\ge 2$ because then we cannot find a $\sigma<1 $ such that $C_K$ is finite. \end{remark} \section{Final comments and open problems}\label{sec:commentandproblems} \noindent{\bf Intuition behind our results: splitting the formula for the fractional $p$-Laplacian.} An idea behind the representation formula \eqref{eq:semigintro} is the following simple principle: the fractional $p$-Laplacian (which is both a nonlinear and nonlocal operator) of a function $u:\mathbb{R}^n\to\mathbb{R}$ can be formally seen as the composition of a linear nonlocal operator acting on $n$ variables of a certain function $v:\mathbb{R}^{2n}\to\mathbb{R}$ which is built from $\Phi_p$ and $u$. Indeed, let $v(x,y) = \Phi_p(u(y) - u(x))$. Notice that $v(x,x) = 0$. At least formally, for $sp < 2$, and for convenient functions, we have that \begin{align*} {(-\Delta)_p^s} u (x) = C_1 \int_{ {\mathbb R^n} }\frac{v(x,x) - v(x,y)}{|x-y|^{n+sp}} \diff y = \widetilde{C}_1(-\Delta)^{\frac {sp} 2}[v(x, \cdot)] (x). \end{align*} This shows a splitting between the linear part $(-\Delta)^{\frac{sp} 2}$ and the nonlinear part $\Phi_p$. For $sp \ge 2$ one should define the operator \[ \mathcal{L}^{\frac{sp}{2}}[\psi](x)=C_1\PV \int_{|y|>0} \frac{ \psi(x) - \psi(y)}{|x-y|^{n+sp}}\dd y, \] which does not coincide with $(-\Delta)^{\frac {sp} 2 }$. Naturally, this very singular integral is only defined for special $\psi$ and $x$. A key part of our arguments are based on showing that, even though the operator $\mathcal{L}^{\frac{sp}{2}}$ is hardly ever defined, the composition works. The scaling properties of the corresponding kernels and integrals in $t$ or $z$ will be crucial. This splitting idea is also shared by the two other alternative representations \eqref{eq:extintro} and \eqref{eq:Balaintro}. \smallskip \noindent{\bf Other representation formulas.} For the case $p = 2$, other representation formulas are known (see, e.g. \cite{Kwa17}). It seems likely that some of them can be adapted for the case $p \ne 2$, but we have chosen not to deal with that issue in this paper. \smallskip \noindent{\bf Optimal domains of definition for the new formulas.} After our proofs of equivalence of the operator definitions when applied to functions with a required regularity, an interesting issue is to extend the domain of definition of the operators, as hinted in Subsection \ref{ssec.8.1} or done in reference \cite{Kwa17} for the linear case, and then to show that the equivalence still holds, at least in some weak or viscosity version. This is a delicate issue that we have decided to postpone. It could be very important for the possible applications to stationary or evolution problems. \smallskip \noindent{\bf Other operators arising from subordination for nonlinear semigroups. } In the paper \cite{CiGr09}, Cipriani and Grillo proposed another type of nonlinear and nonlocal operators defined via subordination applied directly to nonlinear semigroups. More precisely, given a nonlinear semigroup $T_t$, they define (up to a normalisation constant) \begin{equation}\label{eq:nonlinSub} A_s[u](x):= \int_{0}^\infty \left(u(x) - T_t[u](x) \right) \frac{\dd t}{t^{1+s}}. \end{equation} After our semigroup representation formula \eqref{eq:semigintro} for the fractional $p$-Laplacian $(-\Delta)_p^s$ one might wonder if $A_s$ coincides with $(-\Delta)_p^s$ for some semigroup associated to a local operator, as is happens for the case $p=2$ (the fractional Laplacian). Here the natural candidate is the semigroup $T_t^q$ associated to the $p$-Laplacian operator $\Delta_q u:=\nabla \left( |\nabla u|^{q-2} \nabla u\right)$ for $q>1$, i.e., $T_t^q[u](x):=w(x,t)$ where \begin{equation*} \begin{dcases} \partial_t w(x,t)- \Delta_q w(x,t)=0, & x \in {\mathbb R^n} , t > 0 , \\ w (x,0) = u(x), & x \in {\mathbb R^n} . \end{dcases} \end{equation*} We perform now a scaling-based argument which reveals that the operator $A_s^q$ defined by \eqref{eq:nonlinSub} for $T_t^q$ is indeed different than the operator $(-\Delta)_p^s$ for any choice of $p,q\in(1,\infty)\setminus \{2\}$. Clearly, for any $q\not=2$ and $h>0$ we have \[ \Delta_q [h u](x)= h^{q-1} \Delta_q [ u](x) \quad \textup{and} \quad \Delta_q [ u(h\cdot)](x)= h^{q} \Delta_q [ u] (hx). \] From here, it is standard to get \[ T_t^q[hu](x)=h T_{h^{p-2}t}[u](x) \quad \textup{and} \quad T_{t}^q[h^{\frac{q}{q-2}}u(h\cdot)](x) = h^{\frac{q}{q-2}} T_{t}^q[u](hx), \] so that \begin{equation}\label{eq:scalingGrillo} A_s^q[hu](x) = h^{1+(q-2)s}A_s^q[u](x) \quad \textup{and} \quad A_s^q[u(h\cdot)](x)= h^{sq} A_s^q[u](hx). \end{equation} On the other hand, direct computations show that \[ (-\Delta)_p^s[hu](x)=h^{p-1} (-\Delta)_p^s[u](x), \] and \[ (-\Delta)_p^s[u(h\cdot)](x)= h^{sp} (-\Delta)_p^s[u](hx). \] If both operators were the same, we must have $p=2+(q-2)s$ and $p=q$ which is clearly impossible for a given $s<1$ unless $p=q=2$. \smallskip \noindent{\bf Uniqueness of the extension problem \eqref{eq:extension2} for $sp\geq2$.} For $sp<2$ the uniqueness of energy solutions of \eqref{eq:extension2} is shown in \cite{Caffarelli2007}. However, for $sp \ge 2$ the diffusion becomes too singular at $y = 0$ to work properly in the energy setting. It is an open problem to show in which sense of solution $E_{s,p}[f]$ is the unique solution of the boundary value problem. \smallskip \noindent{\bf Numerical methods for the spectral-type fractional $p$-Laplacian on domains.} Following the ideas of \cite{Cusimano18}, one can implement numerical discretization of the fractional $p$-Laplacian on bounded domains proposed in \Cref{sec:new spectral}. \smallskip \noindent{\bf Regularity and well-posedness.} The extension techniques have been extensively used in the theory of regularity of nonlocal problems involving linear operators, i.e the case $p=2$ of the theory presented in this paper. We refer for example to the seminal work of Athanasopoulos and Caffarelli \cite{AtCa10} in the context of fractional porous medium and Stefan type problems. It has also been used to prove well-posedness and properties of such type of equations (see \cite{dP11, dP12}). We believe that our theory could also help to develop similar results for equations involving the fractional $p$-Laplacian.

1. Introduction: the three goals of this articles {#sec1} ================================================= [@bib107] have recently emphasized the importance of conceptually driven approaches to stress and fear circuitry disorders research. This conceptually driven article has three main purposes. The first and most important purpose is to present testable predictions which can be falsified in existing databases or in future studies. The second purpose of this article is to attempt to tackle some remaining language barriers between anxiety disorder researchers and evolutionary neurobiologists. The third purpose of this article is to look at the field\'s conventional wisdom from a new angle, and to propose useful concepts based on research from seemingly distant scientific disciplines. The article\'s title was inspired by Nesse and Williams\' "Smoke-Detector Principle" of anxiety, which introduced into psychiatry a highly useful concept based on principles of financial cost--benefit analysis in economics and principles of signal detection analysis in psychophysics. 1.1. Goal 1: twenty predictions based on hypothesized neuroevolutionary factors ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The author reviews the relevant literature, and presents over 30 empirically testable and falsifiable predictions based on hypothesized neuroevolutionary factors in the etiology of fear-circuitry-related traits. Neuroevolutionary psychiatry, like its sister specialty evolutionary psychology, is not a belief system but a research program, and each behavioral trait must be tested before neuroevolutionary etiologies are accepted ([@bib38], [@bib37]). The null hypothesis is always that a particular anxiety-related trait is not an evolved limbic circuit, but rather an evolutionary design compromise, an evolutionary by-product, a "spandrel" or a stochastic manifestation of genetic drift. Regarding the testability of clinical evolutionary hypotheses, also see [@bib95]. For clinical reviews, see [@bib96], [@bib88] and [@bib89]. It should be noted that, unlike neuroevolutionary psychiatry, evolutionary psychology defines itself as a non-clinical field and claims limited use for clinical care or for psychiatric genetics ([@bib130], [@bib38], [@bib37]). By definition, evolutionary psychology focuses on universal human traits which are species-typical in humans and thus have low heritability ([@bib130], [@bib38], [@bib37]). In contrast, neuroevolutionary psychiatry, the focus of this article, attempts to offer clinically useful predictions relevant to the research agenda for the DSM-V. Neuroevolutionary psychiatry may also be useful to psychiatric genetics and for research on the human-clade phylogenomics--ontogenomics (gene--environment) interface. The *overarching hypothesis* relevant to clinical anxiety disorders presented herein is that some vanishingly rare brain-expressed allele variants that previously had little survival value (or were deleterious) increased by two or three orders of magnitude during the mid--upper Paleolithic and Neolithic EEA due to new recurring selective pressures that had little effect on earlier hominins or on non-human simians. Several authorities have previously made related observations with regard to non-psychiatric physiological conditions ([@bib103], [@bib56], [@bib51], [@bib55], [@bib29]). 1.2. Goal 2: tackling a few of the terminological barriers ---------------------------------------------------------- The second purpose of this article is to tackle a few remaining language barriers between anxiety disorder researchers and evolutionary neurobiologists. One terminological barrier may be the lack of clarity among physicians of the technical definition of words such as "maladapted," "adapted," and "adaptation" in the evolutionary biology literature. These terms originated with Darwin, and are used in the evolution literature to refer to "evolved traits." In contrast, most clinicians use the colloquial ontological meaning of these terms (which are approximately synonymous with "maladjusted," "well-adjusted," and "adjustment," respectively). To minimize confusion, the author uses the terms "evolved fear circuits" in lieu of "fear adaptations," and "non-fitness-enhancing" in lieu of "maladaptive." Another source of confusion is that the paleoanthropological terminology has been in flux until very recently. The terminology used in this article is the new consensus terminology ([@bib40], [@bib140]) ([Table 1](#tbl1){ref-type="table"} ). Some speculations about how to incorporate the neuroevolutionary "why" and "when" questions into fear circuitry disorders research to produce a comprehensive (who, what, when, where, why, how) investigational approach are presented in [Table 2](#tbl2){ref-type="table"} . The four time-depths cited in this article (12,000 years ago \[YA\], 70,000 YA, 20 million years ago \[Mya\] and 140 Mya) are based on research recently reviewed by [@bib40].Table 1Relevant terms from the new paleo-anthropological consensus terminologyNew consensus terminology ([@bib24])DescriptionHominidsThe lineage that includes genus *Homo* and genus *Pan* but not other apesHomininsThe human lineage following the genus *Homo*/genus *Pan* divergence (split) from their most recent common ancestor (MRCA) 5 million years ago (Mya)Australopithecines \[Australopiths\]*Australopithecus afarensis* (and numerous other terms)*Homo ergaster* \[Ergasts\]African *Homo erectus* (pre-2004 terminology)Table 2Incorporating the neuroevolutionary, "why" and "when" questions into the spectrum of research approaches investigating the etiology of evolved fear-circuitry-related traitsResearch approachKey question, e.g., who, what, when, where, why, how and/or key investigational methodologyAdoption study*What?*Genetic transmissionTwin study*How?*HeritabilityGenetic linkage*Where?/Who?*Co-segregation of marker and diseaseGenetic association*How?/Who?/Where?*Allele frequenciesHuman proteomics and transcriptomics*How?/Who?/Where?*Epigenetics, gene-expression profiling, etc.Human genomics*How?/Who?/Where?*Sequencing, physical mapping, etc.Human phylogenomics and neuroevolutionary psychiatry*Why?Why* did these allele frequencies, gene-dosages and gene-regulatory regions evolve?*Why?Why* were these particular ones highly conserved?*When?When* did the these allele frequencies, gene-dosages and gene-regulatory regions evolve?Key methodology: conceptually-driven hominin phylogenomics 1.3. Goal 3: reexamining "ancestral fears" as relevant to fear circuitry disorders ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The author\'s third purpose is to reexamine terms such as "ancestral environment" and "ancestral fears" in light of: a) new research on the *Pan troglodytes* genome emerging from the Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium (CSAC) data and b) research on hominin evolution recently reviewed by Richard G. Klein (see recent review by [@bib77]). Terms such as "ancestral environment" erroneously suggest that the hominin EEA since the *Homo*/*Pan* divergence was a consistent environment. Terms such as "ancestral fears" fail to make the arguably important differentiation between limbic circuits of different time-depths (e.g., limbic circuits that extant humans share with all simians, versus limbic circuits dating back only to Neolithic and upper Paleolithic *H. sapiens*). This article, therefore, divides evolved fear circuitry traits which outlived usefulness (and are thus clinically relevant), by their neuroevolutionary time-depth into four broad subgroups ([Table 3](#tbl3){ref-type="table"} ):1)Mesozoic Era mammalian-wide evolved fear circuits2)Cenozoic Era simian-wide evolved fear circuits3)Mid and upper Paleolithic *H. sapiens*-wide evolved fear circuits4)Neolithic culture-bound-genome-specific (gene--culture co-evolution-based) fear circuits. Table 3Neuroevolutionary time-depth-driven re-clustering of fear-circuitry-related traits proposed for DSM-VHuman-species-atypical (thus often clinically-relevant) symptomPosited neuroevolutionary time-depth of circuitApproximate heritability predicted based on evolutionary reasoning aloneExtreme fear of adult non-kin males in toddlersMESOZOIC0-10%Extreme fear of high elevations in adultsMammalian-wide 140,000,000 yearsFear of snakesCENOZOIC20--40%Fear of reptiles/crocodiles/alligatorsSimian-wideFear of confined spaces20,000,000 yearsFear of darknessFear of water immersionCO~2~-induced panic attack (fear of suffocation during forest fire?)Lactate-induced panic attack (fear of muscle exhaustion while under predation?)Acute-fear-induced jaw-clenching and chronic stress-induced incisor-grindingCompulsive lock checkingUPPER PALEOLITHIC40%Compulsive stove checkingNeurally modern *H. sapiens*Compulsive washing and obsessive fear of contamination70,000 yearsCompulsive hoarding (especially of tools, weapons and leather goods)Extreme fear of insects or miceFear of scrutiny by non-kin conspecifics (Generalized Social Phobia)*UNLOCALIZED (PSEUDO-SOMATIC) SYMPTOMS IN THE CONVERSIVE-DISSOCIATIVE-SPECTRUM PROPOSED FOR DSM-V: e.g.,*NEOLITHIC40%Pseudo-cytokine-driven (pseudo-infectious) fear symptoms12,000 yearsEpidemic pseudo-cytokine-driven (pseudo-infectious) fear symptomsPrimary dissociative disorder?*PSEUDO-LOCALIZED (PSEUDONEUROLOGICAL "CONVERSIVE") SYMPTOMS:*Psychogenic non-epileptic attacks (pseudoseizures)Epidemic sociogenic illness "epidemic hysteria"Psychogenic pseudoparalysis (e.g., limping)Psychogenic imbalance (Pseudocerebellar symptoms)Psychogenic blindness The "Neuroevolutionary Time-depth Principle" presented in this paper is inspired in part by Richard G. Klein\'s theory of the emergence of culture ([@bib77]). Klein argued that hominin neuroevolution since the *Homo*/*Pan* divergence was so strongly punctuated by numerous macro-mutations (single brain expressed mutations of large effect) that the division into epochs is less arbitrary than previously believed. 2. Emerging empirical evidence {#sec2} ============================== 2.1. Experimental studies comparing evolutionarily relevant and evolutionarily neutral stimuli ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Experimental research on neuroevolutionary (distal/ultimate) etiologies of fear-circuitry-related traits is still limited. However, a good number of comprehensive reviews have been published ([@bib109], [@bib102], [@bib95], [@bib136], [@bib36], [@bib86], [@bib84]). Fear of high elevations was the first mammalian-wide (Mesozoic-era) hardwired fear-circuit empirically documented by [@bib47]. Gibson and Walk\'s "visual cliff experiment" demonstrated that both human toddlers and day-old goats will not walk on a transparent solid surface that gives the impression of walking off a cliff. Clinical studies have similarly supported the innateness of the fear of heights ([@bib111], [@bib91]). Mammalian-wide hardwired fears, such as fear of heights, are naturally of less interest to anxiety disorders researchers. These are generally considered to be "normal fears" and probably have been wired by alleles driven to fixation. Firm-wired Cenozoic era fear circuits (simian-wide prepotentiated fear traits) are somewhat more relevant to anxiety disorders research than the mammalian-wide (rational fear) circuits. Simian-wide prepotentiated fears were first empirically documented in two experiments by [@bib35]. In the first experiment, they examined whether observer rhesus monkeys would acquire fear responses to evolutionarily relevant stimuli (toy snakes) as compared to evolutionarily neutral stimuli (artificial flowers) after a single viewing of a videotape showing model conspecifics behaving fearfully. Laboratory-reared rhesus monkeys were used to control for prior ontogenetic experiences. Novel stimuli were used for evolutionarily relevant and evolutionarily neutral conditioned stimuli. In the first study, "snake observer monkeys" acquired fear of toy snakes simply through observational conditioning. By contrast, "flower observer monkeys" watching exactly the same fear performance toward brightly colored artificial flowers did not acquire a fear of flowers. In the second experiment, observational conditioning resulted in rhesus monkeys acquiring a fear of a toy crocodile but not of a toy rabbit. In both studies, this differential conditioning of fear to evolutionarily relevant objects (toy snake and toy crocodile) was maintained beyond a single laboratory session ([@bib35]). The authors concluded that differences in the associability of evolutionarily relevant and evolutionarily neutral stimuli derive primarily from phylogenetic rather than ontogenetic factors. Cook and Mineka conclude that simians, both human and non-human, may have a phylogenetically prepotentiated predisposition to acquire instantaneously fears of certain objects or situations that may once have posed a life threat to early simian ancestors. They have cogently argued that this predisposition is derived from the selective advantage that those simian ancestors who had rapidly acquired fears of such objects or situations would have had over conspecifics who had not. The scarcity of simians for behavioral research is the main impediment to further enlarging the science base in this field. Buss et al. ([@bib27], [@bib28]) list 30 examples of neuroevolutionary-relevant findings that have been empirically derived and widely replicated. Some of these include superior color vision and superior spatial location memory in females, and superior ability to detect, track and predict animate motion in males. Most of these studies were done in non-clinical settings using college students and few involve psychopathology. This is partly because such studies usually require large samples and reliable self-report. 2.2. Epidemiological evidence: toddlers' fear of adult non-kin male conspecifics -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Most psychosocial studies of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) following intra-household child abuse fail to use the standard anthropological rule of differentiating between step-child abuse and offspring abuse. In a 1988 paper in Science which used this differentiation ([@bib39]) the authors provided evidence that a toddler\'s fear of "mother\'s new boyfriend" is most likely an evolved fitness-enhancing fear circuit. Evolutionary psychologists Daly and Wilson reviewed studies of "family homicides," since they do not depend on self-report. They found that "19% of Detroit victims in 1972 were related to their killers by marriage compared to only 6% by blood, and 10% of Miami victims in 1980 were marital relatives of their killers compared to 1.8% blood relatives" ([@bib39]). In the Detroit study they reported, "Coresidents related to the killer by blood, whether spouses or not, were more than 11 times more likely to be slain than coresiding genetic relatives" ([@bib39]). It is unclear how frequently public policy implications of this research are implemented. To this author, Daly and Wilson\'s landmark studies suggest that "intrafamily child abuse" is actually a misnomer and that the term "step-child abuse" is a better description of the data. Daly and Wilson also note that, "presently available data do not reveal whether stepmother or stepfather households entail greater risks" ([@bib39]), and that there is insufficient exploration of emotional abuse and neglect of stepchildren by abusive stepmothers. Abusive stepmothers are anecdotally reported in most ethnocultural groups studied. Unfortunately, transcultural and ethnic studies rarely provide quantitative data. Among the foraging Ache of Paraguay, "of 67 children raised by a mother and stepfather after the natural father\'s death: 43% had died, of various causes, before their 15th birthdays, as compared to just 19% of those raised by two surviving parents" ([@bib39]). It is unfortunate that many clinical studies do not use the standard anthropological rule of differentiating between step-child abuse and offspring abuse, because such differentiation may clarify some contradictory findings regarding early abuse and subsequent PTSD. Throughout the mammalian class, intense fear of non-kin adult male conspecifics is widely documented in unweaned mammals. Among chimpanzees, gorillas and orangutans, a non-kin adult male conspecific is a common perpetrator of infanticide (and of "toddlericide") when encountering an unrelated female of reproductive age caring for an unweaned infant or toddler. (The observation that some toddlers also fear adult males who are blood relatives may be another example of Nesse\'s Smoke-Detector Principle, described below.) In other words, a survival enhancing Type-1 error (Brugger, personal communication). 2.3. Twin studies of fear-circuitry-related traits -------------------------------------------------- A series of landmark twin studies by [@bib67] provide empirical support for the evolutionary etiology of most phobias. These studies have been lucidly reviewed elsewhere ([@bib53], [@bib52], [@bib67], [@bib66], [@bib100]). Irrational fears examined by [@bib68] include, among others, fear of open spaces, crowds, new people, public speaking, public bathrooms, eating in public, spiders, bugs, mice, snakes, bats, other animals, tunnels, other closed spaces, bridges, airplanes, other high places, blood, needles/injection, dentist/hospitals, and diseases ([@bib68]). In their seminal paper "The etiology of phobias," which reported results from over 7500 twins, [@bib68] conclude that overall, their results "...are more consistent with nonassociative models of phobia acquisition than with traditional etiologic theories involving conditioning or social transmission." [@bib68] also note that "...a growing body of data from both retrospective and prospective studies that suggest that most phobias are acquired nonassociatively (i.e., without the involvement of learning). This theory suggests that the liability to phobias is innate, having arisen from evolutionary selection..." ([@bib68]). Neuroevolutionary psychiatry assumes that both common allele variants and subtype-specific allele variants contribute to irrational fears and phobias. Population genetics and twin studies of irrational fears and phobias conclusively demonstrate that these are polygenic or, at best, oligogenic. The study of [@bib67] in which they conducted in-person interviews with both members of 1198 male--male twin pairs (707 monozygotic and 491 dizygotic) is the most relevant in the context of this article. The only two phobias in which [@bib67] found that family environment may have an impact on risk are agoraphobia and social phobia. 3. A brief overview of ongoing hominin phylogenomic studies: the Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium ============================================================================================================== Human phylogenomics is arguably the basic science of evolutionary neuropsychiatry, and became a reality in late 2005 with the completion of the first step of the *P. troglodytes* (common chimpanzee) genome study by the Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium ([@bib33]). The CSAC study included the whole-genome shotgun sequencing of the chimpanzee genome, and more importantly, the genome-wide comparison of recent chimpanzee and human segmental duplications. No CSAC data specifically relevant to stress resilience and to fear-circuitry-related traits are published as of late 2005, but such data are expected to emerge at a rapid pace. It is arguably axiomatic that the vast majority of genomic differences between the two extant hominids (*Pan* and *Homo*) are in brain-expressed regions of the genome. Neuroevolutionary psychiatry may thus be one of the medical subspecialties that will benefit the most from the sequencing of the *P. troglodytes* genome by the [@bib33]. To date, numerous important general insights into human genomic neuroevolution emerged from the [@bib33]. For example, as expected, little evidence was found to suggest that the addition of novel gene loci was a major mechanism in human brain evolution. Also, as expected, Alu elements (short interspersed repeats \[SINEs\]) have been three-fold more active in humans since the *Homo*/*Pan* divergence. Also, some indirect support was given to the exon-deletion "less is more hypothesis" which posits that some loss-of-function mutations or deletions may have been responsible for the tripling of brain size which marked the transition from Australopiths to *H. ergaster* circa 200 Mya (conceivably by a failure of a suppressor gene which, in the Australopiths, stopped the division of cortical progenitor cells after probably 100 cell divisions and allowed a several fold increase in cortical progenitor cell divisions). Finally, paleogenomics gene-expression studies from the CSAC provide insights into pitfalls which gene-expression studies of postmortem brain tissue in PTSD may encounter ([@bib72]). 3.1. Evolution of non-protein-coding gene-regulatory regions ------------------------------------------------------------ One finding from the [@bib33] with potential future treatment implications is that non-protein-coding promoter regions responsible for complex modulation of existing alleles (e.g., at the transcriptome level) undergo changes as a result of evolutionary pressures and are probably more important than protein evolution (by amino acid substitutions) ([@bib151]). CSAC data confirm that changes in messenger RNA and protein expression levels play a much greater role in hominin evolution than the non-synonymous DNA changes that alter amino acid sequences ([@bib32], [@bib54]). Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in these gene-regulatory regions can thus be explored within a neuroevolutionary framework. Commenting on the CSAC findings regarding the evolution of the non-protein-coding promoter regions, Li and Saunders (2005) state that:"The hypothesis invoking evolution in gene-regulating regions is currently the hardest to test. Yet it may be the most promising given what we know of human biology relative to that of apes ([@bib151])." 3.2. Elevated gene dosage of harm-avoidance genes common to all irrational fear and phobia subtypes (and all anxiety disorders?): too much of a good thing ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- DSM-V is likely to conceptualize fear circuitry disorders as dimensional/continuous rather than categorical. In this context, it is arguable that the genome-wide comparison of recent chimpanzee and human segmental duplications by the CSAC is especially relevant ([@bib33]). It is axiomatic that the underlying genetic transmission of stress-triggered and fear circuitry disorders is either polygenic or, as it increasingly seems, oligogenic. The CSAC data suggest that gene dosage is an important factor in conceptualizing continuous behavioral traits. Examination of the 33% of human-duplicated segments which are human-specific found that, compared to *P. troglodytes*, it is humans who typically have the increased gene dosage. Five million indels (insertion/deletion events) and numerous large segmental duplication events (4--5 megabases per million years) have been found to have occurred in genus *Homo* since the *Homo*/*Pan* divergence 5 Mya ([@bib33]). This is consistent with the [@bib67] data on irrational fears and phobias concluding that genetic risk factors that play a role in the etiology of phobias and their associated irrational fears are partially *common across all subtypes* and partially subtype-specific. 3.3. "Phobia subtype-specific" DNA changes. Possible insights from research on abnormal-spindle-like, microcephaly-associated (*ASPM*), microcephaly primary autosomal recessive (*MCPH*), and forkhead box P2 (*FOXP2*) loci ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- More important in the context of this article is [@bib67] conclusion that any allele variants involved in irrational fears and phobias are also "partially subtype-specific" (p. 257). Additionally, there is increasing suspicion that the "smooth" rather than "lumpy" distribution of a psychiatric phenotype in the population may in some cases be accounted for by oligogenic (and not necessarily polygenic) transmission. Until very recently, Richard G. Klein\'s hypothesis ([@bib77]) that hominin neuroevolution since the *Homo*/*Pan* divergence was strongly punctuated by mutations of relatively large effect would have been objected to by some authors who have maintained that the division of a nearly continuous (albeit punctuated) process such as human evolution into epochs is completely arbitrary. Thus, it is important in the context of the time-depth principle that the Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium data ([@bib33]) provide strong support for Richard Klein\'s conclusion that post-*Homo*/*Pan* divergence neuroevolution was strongly punctuated by brain-expressed mutations of moderate or large effect in the human lineage, thus providing indirect support for the deconstruction of the "ancestral fears environment" into four somewhat distinct subgroups, as conceptualized here by the Neuroevolutionary Time-depth Principle. For example (consistent with Klein\'s hypothesis), the CSAC study has found that 73% of the affected base pairs since *Homo*/*Pan* divergence are in indels larger than 80 bp (insertable transposable elements, microsatellites, and deletions). Commenting on the CSAC data, Li and Saunders (2005) state that"Given the short time since the human--chimpanzee split, it is likely that a few mutations of large effect are responsible for part of the current physical--phenotypic-differences that separate humans from chimpanzees and the great apes." Psychiatric molecular geneticists should draw encouragement from the fact that the same conclusion is at least as likely to be drawn for phenotypic differences which are brain-expressed (i.e., cognitive and behavioral). For example, the *ASPM* and *MCPH* genes have been strongly implicated in primary microcephaly in extant humans. These are increasingly considered to be a reversal of a string of advantageous loss-of-function brain-expressed mutations of large effect which occurred circa 2 Mya and via a selective sweep, replaced the Pliocene Australopiths with the early Paleolithic Ergasts ([@bib78], [@bib42], [@bib90]). Unsurprisingly, Australopith brain size (around 400 cm^3^) is identical to that of extant microcephalic humans. Of special interest in the context of this article are the forkhead box p2 (*FOXP2*) gene mutations ([@bib101]), likely to belong among the major advantageous brain-expressed mutations of large effect responsible for the sudden appearance of the (speech enabled) neurally modern *H. sapiens* circa 70 Kya and thus ushered in the upper Paleolithic. Also of great importance in the context of this article is that the technologies developed by *MCPH*, *ASPM*, *FOXP2* and other [@bib33] are also suitable for identifying foot-prints (signatures) of positive selection in brain-expressed genome regions that occurred in the upper Paleolithic and even in the Neolithic (e.g., those leading, via recent stabilizing selections, to fear-circuitry-related balanced polymorphisms). This has been demonstrated by the studies of [@bib78], [@bib42], and [@bib90]. Due to the ongoing thawing of the Siberian, North Russian and Scandinavian permafrost, large quantities of perfectly preserved *H. sapiens* DNA (and of *H. sapiens* RNA and *H. sapiens* enzymes) from possibly hundreds of individuals are likely to be found. Molecular archeogenomic data relevant to fear circuitry disorders in general are likely to emerge and may also confirm or disconfirm (with near forensic certainty) the neuroevolutionary time-depth assignments proposed here for various evolved fear circuitry traits. For example, the techniques developed in the [@bib42] *MCPH* study demonstrating that one variant emerged circa 37 Kya can be applied to studying genomic mechanisms involved in the group of fear circuitry traits which are posited here to be of upper Paleolithic time-depth (such as compulsive hoarding and social phobia), and to genomic mechanisms involved in PTSD resilience. 4. Fear-circuitry-related traits in DSM-V and the "Neuroevolutionary Time-depth Principle" ========================================================================================== Charting the genetic architecture of fear-circuitry-related traits such as specific phobias has been an important but challenging enterprise. The Specific Phobias section in the earlier versions of DSM ([@bib3], [@bib4], [@bib5]) is neither mode-of-acquisition-based nor brain-evolution-based ([Table 4](#tbl4){ref-type="table"} ). For example, DSM-IV-TR ([@bib5]) blood-injection-injury-type-specific phobia clusters two fears arguably different in their mode of acquisition: 1) a PTSD-like ontogenetic fear overconsolidation (avoidance of hospitals) and 2) an innate ∼ 70,000 y/o fear circuit (the sight of blood or an approaching sharp object). "Animal Type Specific Phobia" clusters three irrational fears different in their mode of acquisition and/or in their time-depth: 1) an overconsolidational fear of dogs (*unlikely* to be innate considering the 15,000 year long symbiotic co-evolution of humans and dogs); 2) fear of snakes (simian-wide, thus innate for ∼ 20,000,000 years); 3) irrational fear of insects and mice (which is Neolithic and innate for ∼ 12,000 years). Similar inconsistencies exist in all phobia subtypes. [Table 4](#tbl4){ref-type="table"} lists some examples. This conceptually driven article aims to produce useful cross-fertilization by interfacing research from seemingly distant scientific disciplines and different domains of knowledge. It is partly inspired by [@bib97], [@bib98] "Smoke-Detector Principle" of anxiety which draws from principles of financial cost--benefit analysis in economics and principles of signal detection analysis in psychophysics ([@bib98], [@bib95], [@bib99]). Nesse and Williams have pointed out that fire alarms are set to produce many false positives and no false negatives because most people would rather walk down flights of stairs numerous times for a false alarm (false positive) than have a less sensitive alarm (false negative) since consequences may be grave (death by third-degree burns or by suffocation). In an attempt to obtain a similar conceptual gain by incorporating unfamiliar concepts into anxiety disorders research, the author has coined the term the "Neuroevolutionary Time-depth Principle." The principle proposed here re-clusters most DSM-IV-TR ([@bib5]) fear-related traits into four broad brain-evolution-based clusters: Mesozoic, Cenozoic, Paleolithic and Neolithic. A putative brain-evolution-based genetic architecture is outlined below as a possible target for future research ([Table 3](#tbl3){ref-type="table"}). This re-clustering of fear-circuitry-related traits is based on the Neuroevolutionary Time-depth Principle which takes into account factors such as the relative role of natural disasters and non-conspecific anthropophagic predators, versus the role of human conspecific (thus mostly non-anthropophagic) predators in driving selection of fear-circuitry-related allele variants (and possibly of relevant gene dosages) in the human genome.Table 4Inconsistencies within the phenotype-based DSM-IV-TR classification of irrational fears (in regard to the mode-of-acquisition and neuroevolutionary time-depth)DSM-IV-TR specific phobia traditional classification:Primary mode-of-acquisition and the posited neuroevolutionary time-depth if mostly innate"BLOOD/INJECTION INJURY"FEAR OF HOSPITALS: A PTSD-like overconsolidational fearBLOODLETTING/INJURY FEARS: An innate (mid-Paleolithic) *H. sapiens* 200,000-70,000 y/o fear circuit"SITUATIONAL"FEAR OF ENCLOSED SPACES: An innate (Cenozoic) simian-wide ∼ 20,000,000 y/o fear circuitFEAR OF HIGH ELEVATIONS: An innate (Mesozoic) mammalian-wide ∼ 140,000,000 y/o fear circuit"ANIMAL"FEAR OF DOGS, BIRDS AND BATS: A PTSD-like overconsolidational fear circuitFEAR OF MICE AND INSECTS: An innate (Neolithic) human ∼ 12,000 y/o fear circuitFEAR OF SNAKES: An innate (Cenozoic) simian-wide ∼ 20,000,000 y/o fear circuit 5. Mesozoic (mammalian-wide) fear circuits ========================================== Mesozoic fear circuits are those that human mammals share with many other mammals. These circuits are thus posited to be hardwired in extant humans primarily by wild-type alleles driven to fixation by Mesozoic selective sweeps with no remaining allele polymorphisms (as defined by lack of allele variants with a frequency over 1%)Neuroevolutionary Time-depth: ∼ 140 million years (Mesozoic) The first evolved fears to be recognized by Darwin and contemporaries were mammalian-wide. These fears have been extensively studied by evolutionary psychologists but are of no relevance to adult psychiatry. These fear circuits are observable in humans and other mammals and are considered "normal fears." These fear circuits are probably hardwired, most likely by the wild-type alleles nearing fixation in humans and most other mammals. Fear-circuits, which are posited to be hardwired by mammalian-wide wild-type alleles, include: 5.1. Normative fear of high elevations -------------------------------------- That fear of high elevations are hardwired has been demonstrated by [@bib47] visual cliff experiment, which documented that both human toddlers and day-old goats will not walk on a transparent solid surface that gives the impression of walking off a cliff (none of the experimental subjects has previously observed the consequences of falling off of a cliff, ruling out learning as the model of aquisition). Further evidence for the non-associativeness of fear of heights was found in undergraduate students ([@bib111]) and in clinical samples ([@bib92], [@bib91]). Unsurprisingly, it is the absence of fear of heights that is sometimes considered outside of the norm. (Interestingly, it has been widely observed that the complete absence of fear of heights such as is required of skyscraper construction worker runs in families and is difficult to acquire by non-blood relatives.) 5.2. Normative separation fears ("separation anxiety") ------------------------------------------------------ For a comprehensive discussion of the empirical clinical data on separation anxiety, see [@bib63]. [@bib13] has written about these fears from an evolutionary perspective. [@bib83] in his Triune Brain Hypothesis, pointed out that normative separation fears are the prototypical "paleo-mammalian" fears. These are the fears that placental mammals share with marsupial mammals (from which they diverged circa 130 Mya) and which do not exist in reptiles (from which all mammals diverged 140 Kya). [@bib63], [@bib13] and [@bib83] focused on fears in children. In contrast, this review article exclusively focuses on fear-circuitry-related traits in adults. The author will highlight the fear circuits which are *Homo sapiens*-specific and thus, arguably, are especially clinically relevant to young, otherwise healthy adults. Key epidemiological research studies relevant to the evolution of normative separation fears ([@bib39]) were discussed in the [Emerging empirical evidence section](#sec2){ref-type="sec"} (above). 6. Cenozoic (simian-wide) fear circuits ======================================= Cenozoic era fear circuits are posited to be those limbic circuits that humans share with most simians (higher primates). These circuits are thus posited to be firm-wired (strongly prepotentiated) in extant humans by alleles which are the major variants in a stable polymorphismNeuroevolutionary Time-depth: ∼ 20 million years (Cenozoic) Non-mammalian-wide fear circuits that humans specifically share with non-human simians (higher primates \[apes and monkeys\]) only began drawing interest since the publication of the landmark book by [@bib48], who, along with other research groups, primarily from Japan, studied African apes in their natural habitat. Recent carefully conducted studies have extended Goodall\'s work to some non-hominoid simians (e.g., baboons). This research, reviewed by [@bib115], suggests that many of the human fears listed below are firm-wired not only in the hominoid simians (apes), but also in non-hominoid simians (monkeys such as baboon). The relevant neuroevolutionary pressures involved arguably date back to early simian ancestors that humans share with all other social simians (apes, gibbons and baboons). 6.1. Fear of darkness --------------------- Many predators of simians and of the Pliocene epoch (late Cenozoic era) hominins (i.e., Australopiths) were nocturnal carnivores (e.g., hyenas and jackals). Nocturnal predators, while color blind, possess excellent low-light vision. In contrast, primates (although originally evolved from rodent-like nocturnal insectivores) have subsequently evolved to be obligatory diurnals ([@bib40]). Extensive research documents that, during simian evolution, a series of retina-expressed mutations that transformed some of the retina\'s rods into cones spread, resulting in the emergence of bi-chromatic and eventually tri-chromatic vision. The selective sweep of these retina-expressed alleles in simians is assumed to have been driven to fixation by a switch from being insectivores to being furgvores (fruit eaters). Color vision, however, came at the expense of low light vision, making fear of darkness a simian-wide fitness-enhancing trait ([@bib40]). 6.2. Fear of confined spaces ---------------------------- Twin studies (e.g., [@bib67]) have found at least a moderate heritability of (self-reported) fear of confined spaces. This is arguably another simian-wide fear circuit because entering enclosed spaces was probably associated not only with an intrusion on a potential predator, but it also limited the option of successfully invoking the unique simian (and Pliocene hominin) flight response (arboreal escape). Furthermore, simians\' forest-canopy ecological niche provided good long-distance visibility. Entering enclosed spaces diminished visibility and specifically deprived simians of their color vision advantage. It is of note that, although the human clade diverged from ancestral chimpanzees circa 5 Mya, the primary escape behavior of hominins continued to be arboreal for another 2.5 million years ([@bib40]). Thus, throughout the human arboreal EEA, fear of enclosed spaces was most likely a fitness-enhancing trait. 6.3. Fear of snakes ------------------- Strong evidence for the innate nature of the fear of snakes in humans was demonstrated by twin studies discussed above (e.g., [@bib67]). Fear of snakes in rhesus monkeys was also experimentally documented by the [@bib35] toy snake versus toy flower study described earlier ([@bib35]). Arguably, the distal etiology may be related to the fact that, like simians, snakes are both terrestrial and arboreal. Thus while the arboreal flight response protected simians and Pliocene hominins (the Australopiths) from most predators, arboreality did not protect them from snakes. Primatologists have also documented that infant simians are targets of predation by snakes. Fear of snakes is very unlikely to be pan-mammalian. Some mammals (e.g., badgers) have evolved to prey on snakes. However, snake-hunting mammals are uniformly heavily furred and thus protected from snake venom. In contrast, the sparser body hair and thinner skin of many simians (notably chimpanzees and humans) probably left them much more vulnerable to snake incisors. 6.4. Fear of reptiles --------------------- A prepotentiated fear of toy reptiles (toy crocodiles) in rhesus monkeys was demonstrated by the [@bib35] toy crocodile versus toy rabbit experiment previously described. This simian-wide fear is most likely related to the fact that the African crocodile is a major predator of simians, and most probably also of early hominins in their indigenous East African riverine-forest ecological niche. 6.5. Fear of immersion in water (typically moving water) -------------------------------------------------------- The non-associative mode of acquisition of fear of water has been well-documented ([@bib112]). Furthermore, an immunization effect suggesting desensitization and eventual extinction was noted ([@bib112]). Simians including humans require desensitizing exposure to bodies of water in order to extinguish the innate fear of drowning ([@bib112]). It may be relevant in this regard that humans have spent the majority of their EEA in the riverine-forest ecological niche of the East African highlands (initially alongside small, rapidly moving, mountain streams). Drowning or being swept away by moving water was probably a frequent cause of early life mortality for most simians and early hominins. The only simian known to have evolved to seek (hot) water immersion (presumably due to very specific climate survival pressures) is the Japanese Onsen "snow" macaque of northern Japan. 6.6. Lactate-triggered acute anxiety attacks -------------------------------------------- Lactate-triggered anxiety attacks have been demonstrated in some individuals with anxiety disorders, notably including individuals with combat-related PTSD. Evolutionarily, there is no reason to expect lactate-triggered attacks to be specific to one narrow psychiatric phenotype such as panic disorder. Some speculations based on behavioral ethology may be useful in this context. Arguably, for the obligatory-terrestrial (arboreality-impaired) large mammals (e.g., zebra, antelope, eland, wildebeest, and gazelle), whose survival is dependent on outrunning large carnivores, tolerating high lactate levels from extended periods of anaerobic metabolism is critical for enabling high terrestrial speed. Neuroevolutionary reasoning thus predicts that, unlike simians, non-domesticated ungulate herbivores (such as those listed above) are less sensitive to high lactate levels. This is an easily testable/falsifiable prediction. On the other hand, in simians (including humans), metabolically costly musculature for high terrestrial speed was arguably not fitness-enhancing for two reasons: 1) their ability to invoke the simian-specific arboreal flight response (a trait which, to the best of author\'s knowledge, has not been documented in ungulates) and 2) the larger, metabolically more costly brain of simians. Thus, during simian evolution, high lactate levels may have been a reliable signal of impending muscle exhaustion. More speculatively, with regard to other factors triggering acute anxiety and panic attacks in some individuals, it may be of interest that the East African Highlands are the indigenous ecological niche of both *Coffea arabica* (Ethiopia) and *Coffea robusta* (Kenya) as well as of *H. sapiens*. Arguably, the alleles for responding favorably to caffeine are thus the wild-type alleles and caffeine-sensitive individuals may possess recently mutated (possibly Neolithic) minor allele variants. More research may be warranted. 6.7. Carbon dioxide (CO~2~)-triggered acute anxiety attacks ----------------------------------------------------------- Extensive research has demonstrated that panic attacks have a non-associative mode of acquisition, and are most probably triggered by impaired orbitofrontal or mediofrontal governance over innate hardwired danger-detection circuits linking the locus ceruleus to the amygdala ([@bib69], [@bib49], [@bib1]). Evolutionary factors in panic disorders have been proposed and are cogently articulated elsewhere ([@bib76], [@bib75], [@bib74]). These evolutionary hypotheses are consistent with research suggesting that, unlike their prosimian ancestors, which spent rest periods in confined underground spaces with high CO~2~ levels, simians, including hominins, evolved for the forest-canopy and sub-canopy ecological niche where even slight elevations in CO~2~ levels were arguably reliable predictors of one of the most common Cenozoic threats to life, forest fires and forest-underbrush fires. As with lactate-triggered attacks, CO~2~-triggered attacks have been demonstrated in more than one anxiety disorder, notably including combat-related PTSD. Likewise, evolutionarily, there is no reason to expect CO~2~-triggered attacks to be specific to one narrow psychiatric phenotype such as panic disorder. 6.8. Acute-fear-induced jaw clenching (bite-muscle-strengthening) and chronic-stress-induced teeth grinding (incisor-sharpening) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Fear-induced jaw clenching and gnashing, as well as incisor-sharpening (bruxing), is widely documented in most simians ([@bib115], p. 104). The ability to invoke a lethal bite may have been a highly conserved trait during primate evolution since members of the order Primata lost their sharp claws in the process of evolving long prehensile fingers (to a lesser degree, this is also true for the order Rodentia, the order closest to the Primate order). As we have argued elsewhere ([@bib24]), most simians (and presumably Pliocene *Australopiths* and early-Paleolithic *Ergasts*) were probably highly dependent on a lethal bite during close combat with conspecifics. The simian-wide phenomena of fear-induced bite-muscle-strengthening (jaw clenching, gnashing) and incisor-sharpening (teeth grinding, bruxing) have been widely observed in fear circuitry disorders clinics, such as PTSD clinics. For further discussion of possible clinical implications of PTSD, see sub-section below (neuroevolution-based contributions for the forthcoming refinement of the Department of Veterans Affairs compensation and pension examination and for the forthcoming revision of PTSD Criterion-D in DSM-V). 7. *H. sapiens*-specific fear circuits ====================================== These are *H. sapiens* fear circuits posited not to have existed in the early Paleolithic genus *Homo* (*H. ergaster*). It is posited that these circuits are thus firm-wired in a small percentage of extant humans primarily by common minor alleles which spread from single ancestral copies either during the mid Paleolithic (i.e., pre-*FOXP2*) or in the upper Paleolithic (i.e., post-*FOXP2*) EEA, in both cases primarily driven by mate-choice-related stabilizing selectionNeuroevolutionary Time-depths (*H. sapiens*):∼ 200 Kya to ∼ 70 Kya (mid Paleolithic)and ∼ 70 Kya to ∼ 12 Kya (upper Paleolithic) The neuroevolutionary insights into mid and upper Paleolithic (thus human-species-specific) fear circuits have received limited attention from previous theorists, but the author argues that these are especially relevant to research on clinical stress-triggered and fear circuitry disorders. These *H. sapiens*-specific fear-circuitry-related genomic changes are the focus of this conceptually driven review. The author proposes that these can be divided into two groups which are tentatively termed: pre-*FOXP2* (mid Paleolithic) mutations, and post-*FOXP2* (upper Paleolithic) mutations. These phylogenomic terms are used here with the understanding that *FOXP2* is only one of several brain-expressed mutations that appeared (possibly in short sequence) at the transition between the mid and upper Paleolithic ([@bib143]). The pre-*FOXP2* group is probably smaller than the post-*FOXP2* group and only one example of a pre-*FOXP2* fear-circuit-related mutation will be given below. 7.1. The pre-*FOXP2* hypothesis of irrational bloodletting/injury fears (the pre-speech Paleolithic-threat-hypothesis of blood injection injury phobia) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Paleolithic threat hypothesis of irrational bloodletting fears presented in several recent articles ([@bib20], [@bib15], [@bib150]) posits that a balanced (stable) allele polymorphism predisposes some individuals to fear-triggered efferent vasovagal faints that entered the human genome via mate-choice-driven stabilizing selection in the mid Paleolithic EEA, the last preverbal (pre-*FOXP2*) stage of the *H. sapiens* EEA. The mid Paleolithic is the period during which anatomically and mitochondrially modern humans evolved into neurally modern and articulated speech-enabled humans, presumably because of a selective sweep by several brain-expressed mutations of moderate or large effect ([@bib77]). One of these is probably the mutation that produced the modern *FOXP2* locus, which has recently been shown to exist in a different form in *P. troglodytes* ([@bib33]). Furthermore, analysis of the *FOXP2* DNA sequence indicates that it has very low sequence diversity in extant humans suggesting a relatively recent selective sweep that took place after the appearance of *H. sapiens* circa 200 Kya ([@bib54]). Mutations in the *FOXP2* have been identified as the cause of a syndrome which exists in a single three-generation pedigree in which a severe speech and language disorder is transmitted as an autosomal dominant monogenic trait. This language impairment is part of a broader syndrome which includes impairment in speech comprehension, articulation, a praxic deficit that involves non-linguistic mandibular movements (brain size, however, is normal). Studies of FOXP2 locus indicate that this disorder is a consequence of haplo-insufficiency during embryological development and that the phenotype results from a reduction in gene dosage ([@bib101]). The emerging consensus in paleoanthropology is that this monogenic linguistic and articulation impairment existed not only in *H. neaderthalis* from which *H. sapiens* diverged circa 450 Kya, but also in mid Paleolithic archaic *H. sapiens* (200 Kya to 70 Kya). The paleoanthropological consensus is that the mid Paleolithic archaic *H. sapiens* was restricted to using sign language and probably had great difficulties understanding future tense and past tense. The mid Paleolithic archaic *H. sapiens* was fully anatomically modern, strongly suggesting that they possessed the modern wild-type *ASPM* and *microcephalin* genes. However, since speech emerged rather abruptly circa 70 Kya, it is likely that the advantageous *FOXP2* mutation was among those which enabled the transition from the mid Paleolithic to the upper Paleolithic. As we have argued elsewhere ([@bib15], [@bib20]), fear-induced fainting is highly likely to be part of the extensive sign language that humans needed during the mid Paleolithic in order to survive inter-group conflict. As we have previously argued, during mid Paleolithic periods of inter-group bloodshed, fear-induced faints served the function of visually (non-verbally, "non-*FOXP2*-ally") signaling to raiding conspecifics that one does not present a danger, thus increasing the odds of survival for a fainting-prone non-combatant. This hypothesis is the only one to the author\'s knowledge that can explain the age and sex pattern of bloodletting/injury fears (and of its overlapping conditions known under a wide variety of names: psychogenic fainting, the emotion-triggered "common faint," efferent-vasovagal fainting, neurogenic fainting, neurally mediated syncope, pseudocardiogenic fainting and neurovascular fainting). A large, landmark epidemiological study of blood injection injury fears (1920 subjects in the Baltimore ECA study) found an overall female-to-male ratio of 2.4:1 ([@bib11]). The hypothesis that the anthropogenomic origins of blood-injection-injury fears are not earlier than the mid Paleolithic are also consistent with the extensive evidence of widespread habitual nutritional intra-hominin anthropophagi (human cannibalism) which was practiced by early Paleolithic Ergasts. Thus, fainting at the sight of bloodshed-related stimuli is unlikely to be of greater time-depth than the mid Paleolithic. Arguably, the archaic *H. sapiens* male, which emerged only 200 Kya, was the first predator for whom some humans (primarily young women) were more valuable alive than dead. Others have made similar observations with regard to peritraumatic dissociation ([@bib106]). Finally, as many authorities have noted, evolution is "blind," and not forward-looking ([@bib37]). In this context, human brain evolution could not "anticipate" a future environment in which having a sharp object penetrate one\'s skin or seeing one\'s blood could be anything but dangerous. Epidemiological data in support of the mid Paleolithic threat hypothesis of bloodletting-related fears are accumulating (Bracha, Bienvenu, and Eaton, submitted for publication). Two of the many additional predictions based on this hypothesis are:1.In the immediate aftermath of intentionally caused disasters, such as terrorism against civilians, epidemics of pseudo-cardiological fear-induced fainting are to be expected ([@bib20], [@bib21]).2.One of the "phobia subtype-specific" ([@bib67]) loci involved in bloodletting/injury fears may carry a developmentally sensitive gene (existing in a stable polymorphism) in which the expression mechanism is gradually suppressed by pleiotropic androgens such as dehydroxyepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEA-S) and testosterone. This is likely to manifest as a decrease in gene penetrance following puberty in males (and possibly following menopause in females). The pleiotropic adrenalcortical androgen DHEA-S is especially intriguing as a possible pre-blood-drawing intervention for bloodletting fears, because, unlike testosterone which decreases, DHEA-S normally increases during extreme fear ([@bib94]). A testable hypothesis is that a brief DHEA-S course prior to blood drawing may be beneficial for susceptible individuals. Consistent with the *H. sapiens*-specific hypothesis of blood injection phobia presented above, fright-induced fainting is not uniformly fitness-enhancing, and accordingly, has not been reported when the threat is from natural disasters such as forest fires, floods, volcanic eruptions, pandemics or a threat from anthropophagic predators. 7.2. Fear circuits posited to be wired by Paleolithic mutations which are post-*FOXP2* (upper Paleolithic) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Compulsive lock checkingCompulsive stove checkingCompulsive cleaning and obsessive fear of contaminationCompulsive hoarding (especially of tools, weapons, foot coverings and leather goods)Extreme fear of insects or miceFear of simultaneous visual scrutiny by adult non-kin conspecifics (Generalized Social Phobia). 7.3. Compulsive lock checking (entry barrier checking) and stove checking (hearth checking) behaviors ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Checking behaviors have long been intuitively understood as pathological tails (high gene dosage-driven?) of fitness-enhancing fear circuitry behaviors. The heritability of obsessive-compulsive traits such as compulsive checking is demonstrated by twin studies ([@bib62]). Evolutionarily, compulsive entry-barrier checking most likely became a fitness-enhancing trait when humans began establishing semi-permanent settlements in the upper Paleolithic. Among upper Paleolithic humans, fear of a surprise attack by a predator, either conspecific or non-conspecific, was nearly constant. Similarly, compulsive checking of stoves is likely a conserved hearth checking behavior. Finally, some comorbidities between severe checking behaviors and paranoid traits (but not other psychotic symptoms) would be predicted by neuroevolutionary reasoning. This is another testable prediction. 7.4. Compulsive washing, compulsive cleaning and obsessive fear of contamination -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Fears of contamination are also intuitively understood as the pathological tail of an evolved fitness-enhancing fear circuit. Evolutionarily, "fear of public bathrooms," which in some studies is lumped with Generalized Social Phobia, may be better classified as part of OCD as fear of contamination. Although no research data are available, arguably, these patients experience intense disgust rather than "fear" in proximity to human-excrement-related stimuli (disgust circuits may be quite different from fear circuits). Human excrement unquestionably became a major factor contributing to epidemics beginning in the upper Paleolithic. An experimentally testable prediction, which follows from the above neuroevolutionary reasoning, is that, since infections are less easily transmitted from animals to humans, patients with "fear of public bathrooms" will be much less disturbed by the sight/odor of excrement of other species (e.g., rabbits or dogs) than the sight/odor of human excrement. A possible objection to the hypothesis that compulsive grooming/cleaning is of upper Paleolithic time-depth is that paw licking in some inbred domesticated canids suggests that these compulsive behaviors have a mammalian time-depth. However, the prevalence of compulsive behaviors in dogs is much lower than in humans. It is thus possible that cleanliness has been intentionally selected into the dog genome by human breeders only in the last few hundred years. Furthermore, little known paleo-archaeological research on upper Paleolithic garbage pits (middens) may be relevant in this regard (for recent reviews, see [@bib127], [@bib26]). Paleo-archaeological research strongly suggests that the domestication of wolves into dogs occurred when orphaned wolf pups began scavenging animal bones from upper Paleolithic middens and consequently became imprinted on humans ([@bib26]). The trait of paw licking may have been selected into the genome of some dogs because of the 15,000-year-long exposure to human middens. Arguably, pups with stronger grooming habits better survived the continuous exposure to infectious human waste. A falsifiable prediction which follows from the above reasoning is that paw licking and other over-grooming behaviors will not be found in undomesticated canids such as hyenas, jackals or wolves. 7.5. Male-pattern compulsive hoarding versus female-pattern compulsive hoarding ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Until the beginning of the upper Paleolithic, human foragers could only own what they could carry (on either side of their skin, i.e., as subcutaneous fat or on their person). In contrast, in the upper Paleolithic, humans became increasingly settled and food hoarding has long been understood as a behavioral trait that evolved in response to upper Paleolithic nutritional stress. The author posits that a much-neglected factor in the evolution of compulsive hoarding was upper Paleolithic warfare. Human inter-group warfare was nearly constant beginning in the upper Paleolithic (see [@bib64], [@bib81] for comprehensive reviews). Evidence for hoarding of non-food items in the upper Paleolithic is extensive. In particular, inordinately large hoards of unused stone axes (which served as both tools and weapons) have been documented ([@bib127] pp. 139). Also see [@bib81] for a review. The paleoanthropological data lead to the prediction that extant males with compulsive hoarding traits will primarily hoard tools and/or weapons. It is especially noteworthy that, unlike most fear-circuitry-driven behaviors, hoarding is *more* common in males than in females (the only other anxiety disorder with this unique sex ratio is severe clinical social phobia, as briefly discussed below). In the groundbreaking Johns-Hopkins study of 126 subjects with OCD, nearly 30% of the subjects had hoarding symptoms, and hoarding was *twice* as prevalent in males than females ([@bib114]). Importantly, [@bib114] suggest that hoarding appears to be transmitted in some OCD families and may differentiate a clinical subgroup of OCD (a conclusion consistent with a growing literature supporting the heterogenous nature of OCD). The unusual male to female ratio (2:1) reported by the Johns-Hopkins group is consistent with neuroevolutionary theory. Hoarding by upper Paleolithic males (presumably of tools and weapons) was arguably more fitness-enhancing than hoarding by females (presumably mostly of food items) since, in the Paleolithic, food storages were vulnerable to rodents, insects, or spoilage (i.e., to fungi and bacteria), or to theft by hostile conspecifics. Weapons, on the other hand, could have been used to protect food storages as well as for obtaining food by raiding neighboring groups during periods of nutritional stress ([@bib65]). A very different pattern of non-food-item hoarding is neuroevolutionarily predicted in extant females. It is posited that an important fitness-enhancing trait among upper Paleolithic females was hoarding of two survival-enhancing items: first, leather foot-coverings for extended forest foraging (boots/shoes), and second, leather containers for transporting gathered foods (bags). It may be of interest that, during foraging as well as during long-distance migrations, Paleolithic females are believed to have carried two under-arm leather bags: one containing fat/protein-rich foods and the second carrying the unweaned infant. This under-arm positioning of bags facilitated breastfeeding while mobile and easy access to the above high-energy foods. Since leather deteriorates rapidly in the ground, at present, there are no paleo-archaeological data in support of this speculation. However, ongoing paleo-archaeological digs in the Northern Eurasian permafrost (where leather remains intact) may be able to test this and related predictions. More importantly, the predicted sex differences in hoarding patterns discussed above are easily testable in extant humans. Two intriguing (and clinically important) studies by [@bib44], [@bib45] demonstrate that hoarding patterns can be studied even in severely ill clinical populations. Unfortunately, their data do not inform the issue at hand since all the subjects were combat-exposed veterans. Further research on hoarding patterns using random samples and warzone-unexposed OCD patients is needed. Finally, on a highly speculative note, evolutionary reasoning predicts that both the male-pattern hoarding (tools/weapons) and the female-pattern hoarding (shoes/under-arm bags) will be most pronounced in individuals whose geographic ancestry is in regions where foraging (a.k.a. hunting/fishing/gathering) subsistence ended most recently (northern Eurasia, the British Isles, and Japan). One of several epidemiological testable predictions that follows from the above is that significantly higher national consumption of the above hunting/gathering linked consumer goods would be found in high-per-capita-income world regions in which foraging subsistence ended first (e.g., Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, and Singapore) compared to world regions with similarly high-per-capita income in which foraging subsistence ended last (e.g., Japan and Scandinavia). The above hypothesis can also be tested in clinical populations. Elsewhere (also see below) we have argued that, for other evolutionary reasons, acute pseudoneurological manifestations of anxiety will have a higher prevalence in the above world regions in which hunting/gathering subsistence ended *first* ([@bib22]). 7.6. Irrational fear of all insects ----------------------------------- Most prosimians and simians feed on termites and other insects, and extensive research (e.g., coprolite studies) has documented that early hominins also fed on a wide variety of insects ([@bib26]). However, the fear of insects arguably became a fitness-enhancing trait in the upper Paleolithic, once humans established settlements. It has been documented that the proximity of humans, insects and garbage middens made insects significant vectors of disease in the upper Paleolithic ([@bib26]). In [@bib68] large twin study of 64 subjects with "bug phobia," 40.6% reported "trauma to self" as the mode of acquisition. On the other hand, a full 43.8% of subjects with "bug phobia" reported "no memory" of any such trauma. [@bib68] conclude that their findings are consistent with the evolutionary etiology of insect phobia. 7.7. Irrational fear of smaller murids (mice) --------------------------------------------- Unlike fear of rats, fear of mice among extant humans is irrational (and thus included in most large studies of specific phobias). The threat that mice posed to food storages in the upper Paleolithic arguably made a panic response at the sight of mice a fitness-enhancing trait. Additionally, paralleling the pattern with insects, mice likely became a major vector of disease only after the establishment of settled communities in the upper Paleolithic. 7.8. Irrational fear of simultaneous visual scrutiny by non-smiling, non-kin conspecifics (social-anxiety-related traits) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Social phobia and agoraphobia are the only two phobias in which [@bib67] found that family environment may have an impact on risk. Nevertheless, moderate heritability of social anxiety traits was demonstrated in the same study ([@bib67]). A conceptually driven landmark genomic study has documented an association between social anxiety traits and an (balanced) allele-variant polymorphism in the Beta-1 adrenergic receptor ([@bib124]). Evolutionary factors contributing to social anxiety traits are cogently articulated elsewhere ([@bib120], [@bib121], [@bib122]). Several authorities have argued that, during parts of the human EEA, being stared at by a large group of strangers was frequently associated with potential threat to life. Stated differently, for upper Paleolithic *H. sapiens*, situations in which an individual was simultaneously scrutinized by a large group of non-smiling, non-kin conspecifics were more likely than not to be followed by negative consequences. This neuroevolutionary hypothesis can be tested empirically in patients with social-phobia-related traits (e.g., by comparing autonomic nervous system response and neuroendocrine response during visual scrutiny by a large group of non-kin versus a comparably sized group of blood relatives). Previous studies and the DSM-IV-TR cluster together two innate fears of arguably different time-depths as "social-anxiety-related traits": 1) a generalized fear of "new people" --- an innate upper Paleolithic ∼ 70,000 y/o fear of non-blood-related conspecifics and 2) fear of public bathrooms --- an innate Neolithic ∼ 12,000 y/o fear of fecal contamination. Arguably, this clustering is unhelpful in charting the genetic architecture of social-anxiety-related traits. Finally, it may be of note that, with regard to the sex ratio of anxiety disorders, men are generally believed to under-report symptoms of most phobic and anxiety disorders in both epidemiological and clinical studies. Male under-reporting may partly account for the typical sex ratio of anxiety disorders. In contrast, objectively severe social anxiety (severe enough to require hospitalization) presents primarily in males (DSM-IV-TR, 2000, p. 453). In this regard, the sex ratio of severe social phobia (as well as of severe OCD) stands out among anxiety disorders. The high prevalence of clinically significant social anxiety among males is consistent with neuroevolutionary predictions since, in the mid--upper Paleolithic EEA, visual scrutiny by a large group of strangers was more likely to result in loss of life for a male than for a female. [@bib48] research on the patterns of behavior of the chimpanzees of Gombe leads us to predict that, especially in males, symptom severity during meeting "new people" will often manifest only when the "new people" encountered include three or more men. This prediction can be easily confirmed or disconfirmed in clinical samples. 8. Neolithic-culture-bound species-*atypical* fear circuits in extant culture-bound genomes (gene--culture co-evolution) ======================================================================================================================== These are species-*atypical* (psychopathological) fear circuits which are posited to have been firm-wired (prepotentiated) in a small number of extant humans by previously rare allele variants. It is likely that these allele variants spread only after the emergence of human Neolithic tribalism (cultures) and mostly by gene--culture co-evolution and by mate-choice-driven stabilizing selectionNeuroevolutionary Time-depth: ∼ 12 Kya (Neolithic) Neuroevolutionary insights into fear circuits of Neolithic time-depth have received little attention until recently and, to the best of the author\'s knowledge, were first introduced in a recent article ([@bib20], [@bib21], [@bib22], [@bib23], [@bib24]). The author argued that these are highly relevant to clinical research on some of the most puzzling fear-triggered syndromes such as acute "conversive" symptoms. They may also be relevant to clinical research on fear circuitry disorders which DSM-IV-TR considers "culture-bound" (further discussed later in this article). 8.1. Molecular phylogenetics of the lactase messenger RNA transcription-controller-gene: implications for Pseudo-neurological "conversion" disorder --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- It may not be immediately obvious that the Neolithic time-depth (circa 480 generations) is of sufficient evolutionary duration for the establishment of allele variant polymorphism via a stabilizing selection. However, the now classic molecular genetic studies of the hereditary persistence of intestinal lactase (HPIL) minor allele variant (i.e., the allele for digesting lactose past age four) are illuminating in this regard. A mutation causing inactivation of the transcription-controller-gene (TCG) that originally suppressed transcription of lactase mRNA at age four permitted consumption of large amounts of fresh milk. This lactase messenger RNA TCG mutation spread (from a Paleolithic single ancestral copy) only in the Neolithic and was probably driven by the domestication of ovine, bovine and other ungulate herbivores. The TCG mutation facilitated the emergence of pastoralism and the subsequent Neolithic expansion into previously uninhabited ecologically harsh regions of Asia ([@bib29]). A similar pattern has been documented in Europe during Neolithic expansion into the previously uninhabited Scandinavia. These studies of HPIL have shown that as little as 60 generations were sufficient for the single loss-of-function mutation (which disabled the lactase mRNA transcription-controller-gene) to increase over 90-fold ([@bib103], [@bib56], [@bib51], [@bib55], [@bib29]). Prior to the Neolithic domestication of ungulate herbivores, a trait enabling humans to digest fresh milk past the age of four would have allowed foraging-capable individuals to compete with their unweaned blood relatives for human breast milk during periods of nutritional stress. Competition with unweaned blood relatives for breast milk would have reduced the Paleolithic milk-digesters\' inclusive fitness. It is of note that the allele enabling adult humans to digest milk remains the minor allele variant in the global stable polymorphism. (Thus, the majority of extant humans cannot digest milk past age four and obtain calcium primarily from powdered fish bones.) Another relevant insight from the research on HPIL is that alleles over time often rapidly change back and forth between being harmful, then helpful, then harmful again. The allele for digesting milk in adulthood, which first turned helpful in the Neolithic expansion, turned harmful again when humans began living past their reproductive years and became vulnerable to atherosclerosis ([@bib51]). Even more relevant in the context of this article is the landmark study by [@bib90] cited above which provides evidence that important brain-expressed genes such as the ASPM can also undergo rapid evolution well within the Neolithic time-depth (5800 years). 8.2. Fear-triggered *pseudo-localized* symptoms (pseudoneurological "conversion" symptoms): Neolithic-time-depth fear of being mistaken for a combatant? -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The above HPIL and ASPM studies demonstrating that the Neolithic EEA was of sufficient time-depth to allow gene--culture co-evolution-based allele-variant polymorphism to be established by balancing/stabilizing selection, are highly relevant to pseudoneurological (a.k.a. conversive) disorders ([@bib22]). There has been almost no previous discussion of neuroevolutionary factors in the etiology of the pseudoneurological (pseudo-localized) symptoms which appear during and in the immediate aftermath of inescapable stress. As others and we have pointed out elsewhere, in light of the increasing threat of terrorist attacks against civilians, more attention is warranted to acute pseudoneurological (pseudo-localized) symptoms. Additionally, more attention is warranted to epidemic sociogenic symptoms (previously known as mass hysteria) which emerge in the immediate aftermath of large-scale disasters, especially intentionally caused disasters ([@bib22], [@bib9], [@bib137]). We have recently proposed that a firm-wired fear circuitry response resembling a severe handicap, such as pseudo-paralysis (limping), pseudo-cerebellar symptoms (staggering, astasia abasia), psychogenic loss of sight, or falling to the ground with convulsion-like paroxysms (psychogenic non-epileptic attacks, pseudo-seizures), was selected into some genotypes, specifically during the Neolithic, resulting in a balanced (stable) allele variant polymorphism ([@bib22], [@bib29]). During Neolithic periods of warfare, acute pseudoneurological symptoms may have provided a non-verbal message to predatory conspecifics (often raiders from a tribe that spoke a different language) that one is unlikely to be an immediate threat because one is severely injured or severely diseased (even, possibly infectious with an agent that the raiders immune system has not previously encountered?) ([@bib20]). This is consistent with the age and sex pattern of conversive disorders ([@bib12]). [@bib81] reviewed warfare patterns of Neolithic New Guinea cultures and reported that 25% of men, but only about 5% of women, are killed during warfare (p. 151). Similar numbers were reported in studies of other Neolithic cultures ([@bib64], p. 196). Also see [@bib65] and [@bib43]. The hypothesis that pseudoneurological symptoms are of recent (Neolithic) time-depth is also evinced by the observation that the predisposing alleles were not driven to fixation but rather remained species-*atypical*. It is especially of note that the molecular phylogenomic techniques developed in [@bib90] study on the mid-Neolithic (5800 YA) adaptive evolution of *ASPM* can easily be applied to the Neolithic Time-depth hypothesis regarding the genetic factors contributing to the spectrum of symptoms still often conceptualized in Freudian terms and presently known by the psychoanalytic term "conversion disorder", in DSM-IV-TR ([@bib5]). Elsewhere, [@bib22] present six falsifiable predictions and possible taxonomic implications for the forthcoming DSM-V ([@bib79]) and for the next edition of the International Classification of Disease (ICD, 2005). For a discussion of other anxiety disorders which are posited to be of Neolithic time-depth, see section below titled: [Towards a science-based DSM-V reconceptualization of anxiety disorders which DSM-IV-TR currently labels as 'culture-bound'](#sec3){ref-type="sec"}. 8.3. The ICD-10 (and DSM-V) Dissociative-Conversive Spectrum ------------------------------------------------------------ ICD-10 ([@bib141]) has re-categorized conversive disorders as part of the dissociative spectrum, coining the term "Dissociative-Conversive Spectrum." In a recent review, [@bib24] have argued, based on [@bib106] paper on dissociative symptoms, that the evolutionary hypothesis presented above for pseudoneurological syndromes is highly consistent with dissociation and conversion constituting a continuous spectrum as in the ICD-10 (and hopefully in the DSM-V). We have argued that some psychogenic dissociative symptoms can be conceptualized as the less severe and therefore more common variant phenotype of the Dissociative-Conversive Spectrum. Dissociative symptoms are increasingly believed to be a manifestation of various hyper-glutamatergic states. These hyper-glutamatergic states are most often stress-induced, but as we argued elsewhere ([@bib146]), some may be occassionally of other etiologies, such as supra physiological glutamate levels in the diet. Furthermore, extensive research by the West-Haven V.A. ([@bib30], [@bib6], [@bib93]) strongly suggests that dissociative symptoms may respond to glutamate release inhibitors such as lamotrigine. A clinically relevant testable prediction that follows from the continuity between dissociation and conversion is that various forms of pseudoneurological conversive symptoms may also respond to lamotrigine or other glutamate release inhibitors, especially when used at higher doses. Finally, if conversion and dissociation represent a severity continuum or variant phenotypes, it is likely that dissociative traits can be traced to fear circuits of the same time-depth as the pseudo-localized (conversive) symptoms (i.e., Neolithic time-depth). 9. Resilience to warzone-related PTSD: testable predictions and speculations based on the neuroevolutionary time-depth principle ================================================================================================================================ [@bib7], in a recent editorial about "The stress symptoms that we refer to as PTSD and ASD," has argued that DSM-V should rethink the conceptualization of the above spectrum of symptoms. Remarkable breakthroughs have been made in understanding ontogenetic and other proximate factors in the etiology of the syndrome currently known as PTSD. However, there has been little attention to possible distal factors ([@bib118]). In this article, space limitations do not permit extensive discussion of possible neuroevolutionary contributions to a DSM-V reconceptualization of PTSD. However, a few examples of the possible explanatory power of neuroevolutionary insights are provided below. 9.1. Resilience following different Criterion-A adversities (events): insights from the time-depth principle ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A widely replicated but neurobiologically unexplained finding is that different types of Criterion-A adversities (currently known as "events") have very dissimilar rates of subsequent PTSD. For example, in the NCS ([@bib71], [@bib70]), resilience following fires was found to be high and no significant sex differences were found (PTSD developed in 4% of exposed males and 5% of exposed females). In contrast, the NCS found much lower resilience to combat and to physical abuse, (subsequent PTSD was found to be 39% and 22%, respectively). Research has not yet fully explained why fires are five to ten times *less* likely to result in PTSD than physical abuse or combat. The lower rates of PTSD following fires require explanation since, of the above three Criterion-A adversities, it is arguably death in a fire (loss of life by third-degree burns or by suffocation) that is the most dreaded. [Table 5](#tbl5){ref-type="table"} below presents some speculations regarding the much lower subsequent rate of PTSD following natural adversities (e.g., forest fires). As very briefly summarized in [Table 5](#tbl5){ref-type="table"}, there may be a direct positive correlation between neuroevolutionary time-depths and the degree of stress resilience. It is posited that adversities such as forest fires, for which the human genome had at least 140,000,000 years to evolve, are less likely to result in PTSD than adversities for which the human genome has had a much shorter time to evolve. There are several valid critiques of this hypothesis, such as the subjective nature of self-report, but this hypothesis is falsifiable and these valid critiques are amenable to research. Another testable hypothesis is that, although death by drowning in a flood is arguably more dreaded than death by being shot, PTSD rates in the aftermath of floods of unprecedented size, such as those following hurricane Katrina, will be lower than those seen after warzone exposure. These rates may be more in line with those following forest fires (in the single digits).Table 5Differential resilience to PTSD following different types of Criterion-A events: possible insights from the neuroevolutionary-time-depth principleNCS term for the particular fear-circuitry-activating threatRates of subsequent lifetime PTSD in exposed extant humans (NCS data)Posited relevant criterion-A adversity during the relevant part of the human EEATime-depth (years) available for the human genome to evolve resiliency to the specific criterion-A adversityPosited frequencies of resilience-related alleles"Fire"4% (M)Natural disasters (most frequently forest fires) in the presence of which terrestrial mammals *of both sexes* were exposed throughout their evolution140,000,000 since the emergence of mammals in the MesozoicVery high (resilience-related alleles are probably the species typical wild type alleles in humans, and approaching fixation)5% (F)"Physical child-abuse" (boys) (essentially, the physical abuse of stepsons)22% (M)*Intra*-group male-male violence against non-blood-related younger male simians *in the same troop* ("stepchildren") is well documented in most simian species studied (e.g. baboons, chimpanzees, and gorillas)20,000,000 since the emergence of social simians in the CenozoicIntermediate"Combat"39% (M)*Inter*-group male-male Intra-human killings (large-scale inter-ethnic battlefield warfare) only became common after the rising of population densities in the Neolithic.12,000 since the emergence of tribalism (a.k.a "ethnic identity") in the NeolithicLow (resilience-related alleles are probably the minor alleles)[^1] 9.2. Avoidance coping of PTSD adversity reminders: a role in the Neolithic demic expansion? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Until recently, it was widely assumed that, throughout human prehistory, practically all demic expansions (population migrations) were driven exclusively by the search for new material resources. However, [@bib29] have demonstrated that nutritional-stress-driven Neolithic demic expansion progressed on average at a rate of only 1 km per generation. The well documented, sudden long-distance Neolithic demic migrations (e.g., across deserts, through icy mountain passes or to distant islands) are harder to explain merely as a search for material resources. For example, as Jared [@bib41] points out in his extensive discussion of the Polynesian Neolithic expansion, "the thought of a several-day canoe voyage across open ocean \[is\] intolerable to me, something that only a desperate need to save my life could induce me to undertake" (p. 130). Based on recent reviews ([@bib81], [@bib64], [@bib41]), it is posited here that adversity reminders played a major role in the long-distance Neolithic expansion. Individuals with highly overconsolidated trauma-memory purposely migrated long-distances in search not only of safety but also of visually dissimilar landscapes which triggered fewer trauma reminders (avoidance coping). Similar PTSD-based factors may have also played a role in some earlier documented long distance migrations e.g., across the Alps, the Khyber Pass ([@bib104]) and across Wallace\'s Line (the Java, Bali, Lombok, Sumbawa, Flores crossing). 9.3. Suboptimal dosages of harm-avoidance-related genes, and subsequent self selected warzone exposure ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A second major contribution by Nesse and Marks has been to point out numerous modern (non-EEA) threats to life that are insufficiently anxiogenic (e.g., guns, reckless driving, or crossing busy streets). The time-depth of such threats is extremely short, usually less than a few hundred years. These authors have coined the term "hypophobias" ([@bib85]). There may be some implications of the hypophobia concept to combat-related PTSD. Low-harm-avoidance individuals are over-represented among those who enlist into a full-time-active-duty warfighter career. [@bib123] twin study has demonstrated that exposure to assaultative trauma is not random, and that additive genetic effects explained part of the variance in exposure to assaultative trauma. Stein et al.\'s twin studies are also consistent with the earlier twin studies in military veterans by [@bib82] as well as the twin studies by [@bib131] which demonstrated low heritability of combat-related PTSD (i.e., compared to most specific phobias, panic disorder, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia and autism). True et al. found that:""...after adjusting for differences in combat exposure; genetic factors account for 13% to 30% of the variance in liability for symptoms in the reexperiencing cluster, 30% to 34% for symptoms in the avoidance cluster, and 28% to 32% for symptoms in the arousal cluster."" That the avoidance and arousal clusters may be more heritable than reexperiencing is not surprising. (True et al. also concluded that there is no evidence that shared environment contributes to the development of PTSD symptoms.) It may be relevant in this context that this relatively low heritability of PTSD is in the same range as the heritability of being infected with tuberculosis ([@bib34], [@bib14]), a disorder which, like PTSD (but unlike most anxiety disorders), obviously requires a major unique environment etiological component. The above twin studies suggest that the etiological complexity of combat-related PTSD may be partly due to it being an overconsolidational fear circuitry overactivity superimposed on a premorbid suboptimal dosage of harm-avoidance-related genes. Since most anxiety disorders probably require a supra-optimal dosage (or over-expression) of these harm-avoidance genes, in DSM-V, a new category of "overconsolidational spectrum disorders", anchored around PTSD, may need to be created and conceptualized as straddling (and Venn-diagramming with) the fear circuitry spectrum disorders category ([@bib31]) and the affective spectrum disorders category ([@bib58], [@bib59], [@bib60]). That PTSD may be as akin to the affective spectrum disorders as it is to fear circuitry disorders is consistent with the conclusions of [@bib142]. These authors have reviewed two large, carefully conducted studies on the response to a Criterion-A event (terrorist attack and motor vehicle accident), and concluded that major depression alone and an anxiety disorder alone were approximately as common as PTSD following the Criterion-A event. Classifying psychiatric disorders somewhat categorically, although unhelpful in research, is a clinical necessity and will exist in DSM-V. Arguably, a new DSM-V category of "Overconsolidational Disorders," anchored around PTSD, may be helpful since it can guide early prevention and treatment. For example, Friedman and Harris have cogently noted ([@bib46]) that a potential "morning after pill" may be available for the prevention of PTSD (and related post-disaster disorders) in the form of Pitman\'s secondary-prevention propranolol protocol ([@bib108], [@bib134]). Such a "morning after" prevention regimen may then be specifically indicated for all overconsolidational disorders and possibly in post disaster situations based on an individual\'s heart rate (tachycardia). Finally, it is, of course, highly likely that the over-expression, or "high-normal" expression, of otherwise fitness-enhancing common "good memory alleles" (F \> m) may also be a risk factor for overconsolidational disorders, especially among civilians diagnosed with PTSD. Arguably, these are the patients for whom a brief "therapeutic forgetting" protocol can be beneficial (and eventually specifically indicated, in lieu of the current, more lengthy psychological interventions). 9.4. 21st century warfare versus firm-wired limbic circuits for Neolithic warfare patterns ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 21st century warfighters are expected to endure warzone exposure usually lasting 6 to 12 months. Such chronic activation of a warrior\'s locus coeruleus to amygdala circuit did not exist during the EEA since actual combat during the EEA usually lasted only hours or at most a few days. For winning war parties, operational-combat stress were probably followed immediately by several days of high-vagal-tone recuperative behaviors consisting of resting, sleeping, feasting, and other forms of prehistoric male recreation. Bio-anthropological studies have documented this very specific pattern of prehistoric inter-group warfare in the Neolithic and upper Paleolithic. These patterns have been confirmed by several paleogenomic and gene-flow studies of male lineages through the Y-chromosome and of female lineages and female migration patterns through mitochondrial DNA ([@bib132], [@bib116]). These studies have also found that, in contrast to the total war patterns of the 20th century CE (and the urban warfare characterizing the early years of the 21st century), inter-group warfare in the upper Paleolithic and Neolithic EEA almost exclusively involved raiding parties of young, mate-less post-pubertal males primarily in search of reproductive resources ([@bib81], [@bib80], [@bib87], [@bib139]). One may speculate that, when estimating the risk/reward odds of initiating armed conflict, the limbic circuits of extant war planners may be firm-wired to perceive organized inter-group violence as it took place during the upper Paleolithic and Neolithic EEA (i.e., a raiding party for a low-risk attack against an unsuspecting settlement). 9.5. Fright-triggered bradycardic fainting as protection for the locus coeruleus (LC) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Clinical cardiologists consider fear-triggered vasovagal fainting "puzzling" since it is "hemodynamically paradoxical" ([@bib10], [@bib135]). However, as we have argued elsewhere ([@bib20], [@bib15]) based on the last decade of work on PTSD\'s proximal-neurobiology, it may be helpful for neurocardiologists to re-conceptualize the simultaneous bradycardia and vasodilatation which are the defining features of fainting during real or perceived inescapable threat as akin to a protective "self-administered propranolol--prazosin combination" or (more physiologically accurately) "self-administered clonidine." From the neuroevolutionary psychiatry viewpoint, a rapid switch from tachycardic effroi (fright) to bradycardic faint may prevent progression from traumatic fear to PTSD by diminishing overconsolidational amygdala-driven hippocampal "searing" of fear traces. Several landmark studies ([@bib134], [@bib133], [@bib108], [@bib117]) have demonstrated that prolonged episodes of fear-triggered ("peritraumatic") tachycardia and of peritraumatic effroi (fright) are both strong predictors of subsequent PTSD. Enhanced CNS noradrenergic post-synaptic responsiveness has been clearly shown to contribute to the pathophysiology of chronic PTSD ([@bib119]). This is consistent with the landmark study ([@bib113]) demonstrating the striking effectiveness of prazosin, a post-synaptic NE alpha-1 receptor antagonist, in the treatment of nightmares in veterans with CR-PTSD. The above is also consistent with the lower number of LC neurons we reported in a recent post-mortem study of three American WWII veterans with warzone-related PTSD compared to four control veterans ([@bib23]). Arguably, prolonged combat-related LC overactivity may lead to what may be termed "overuse-driven LC neuronal loss." The overuse-driven LC neuronal loss may eventually result in upregulation of the denervated post-synaptic noradrenergic (NE) alpha-1 receptors, e.g., in the LC-to-basolateral-nucleus-of-the-amygdala (LC-BLNA) pathway. Arguably, the evolved trait of fright-triggered efferent vasovagal faints during overwhelming inescapable stress (discussed above) may have been evolutionarily conserved as a protective fitness-enhancing trait (shutting down LC firing/sparing the LC/diminishing NE-driven overconsolidation/preventing upregulation of the denervated post-synaptic NE alpha-1 receptors and thus preventing the enhanced noradrenergic post-synaptic responsiveness in the LC-BLNA pathways and related LC efferents). 9.6. Contributions of neuroevolutionary psychiatry to the forthcoming refinement of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) PTSD Compensation and Pension (C&P) --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- As noted earlier in the section discussing Cenozoic (simian-wide) fear-circuits, two physical objective signs of anxiety, fear-induced bite-muscle-strengthening (acute jaw clenching, gnashing) and incisor-sharpening (chronic teeth grinding, bruxing), can be widely observed in fear circuitry disorder clinics, such as VA PTSD clinics ([@bib148], [@bib24], [@bib149]). We have argued elsewhere that clinicians may want to consider adding to the anxiety-disorder-specific examination (such as the VA PTSD C&P exam) the palpation of the masticatory muscles (masseter and temporalis) and the inspection of the front incisors for these two physical signs of fear circuitry activation to provide corroborating physical evidence in support of the veteran\'s self-report of severe ongoing anxiety symptoms ([@bib24]). 9.7. PTSD Criterion-D and PTSD Criterion-A2 in the forthcoming DSM-V: towards revisions based on evolutionary reasoning ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Additionally, one of the PTSD diagnostic criteria that is very likely to undergo a substantial revision in DSM-V is PTSD Criterion-D (persistent fear circuitry activation not present before the trauma). Research is needed to examine the possible incremental positive predictive value of incorporating various physical signs into DSM-V PTSD diagnostic criteria ([@bib24], [@bib25], [@bib16], [@bib15]). Grinding-induced incisor wear and clenching-induced palpable masseter tenderness may be examples of such physical signs of persistent fear circuitry activation not present before the trauma (PTSD Criterion-D) ([@bib24]). Elsewhere we have made similar arguments regarding the need to revise PTSD Criterion-A ([@bib17], [@bib19], [@bib150]). 9.8. Predictions regarding PTSD following large-scale bioevent disasters such as zoonotic pandemics --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- It may not be immediately obvious, but neuroevolutionary principles may also need to be considered during the preparation for bioevents such as zoonoses-triggered pandemics e.g. avian influenza pandemics and Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS). Strong affection for domesticated fowl and domesticated pigs evolved in humans for over 12,000 years. In contrast, the agricultural practices likely to create conditions favorable to re-assortment-triggered genomic shift, and to pandemics in general, only appeared with the emergence of cities and societies with very high population density, mostly in the last 4000 years. Thus it is posited that epizoonoses and zoonotic pandemics can be conceptualized as human-caused (rather than natural) disasters. The author predicts that both intentionally-caused large-scale bioevent-disasters, as well as natural bioevents such as SARS and avian flu pandemics, will be an exception and are likely to be followed by PTSD rates approaching those that follow warzone exposure. During bioevents, *amygdala-locus coeruleus-driven epidemic pseudosomatic symptoms* may be an order of magnitude more common than infection-caused cytokine-driven symptoms. For the above two reasons, it is critical that during pandemics and especially intentionally-caused bioevents, rapid telephone screening be conducted for acute limbic-triggered pseudosomatic symptoms as well as for predictors of PTSD (Criterion-A2, tachycardia, etc.) ([@bib144], [@bib145]). 10. Red Cross and FEMA Implications. "Seeking Safety in Numbers" is a non-survival-enhancing hardwired fear-based decision likely to occur during bioevent disasters ==================================================================================================================================================================== Neurally modern humans are hardwired to seek the company of other humans when experiencing hypervigilant fear. As we argued elsewhere (e.g., [@bib15]), unless immediately managed, hypervigilant fear is rapidly followed by an urge to flee (as part of the hardwired hypervigilance, flight, fright, faint, acute stress sequence). The "flight response" is hardwired and thus makes common sense both to bioevent victims and to federal emergency management leaders. Consequently, current emergency management practices, including those of the Red Cross and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), are almost set in stone and designed to help disaster victims flee to centralized shelters, rather than shelter themselves in-place (at home). A forceful national effort is warranted to change these engrained disaster-response practices. 11. Conserved foraging circuits and subsequent preverbal trauma in extant toddlers ================================================================================== What is termed here "foraging-circuit-driven traits" is a construct akin to novelty-seeking traits and the construct of hypophobia discussed earlier. During human toddlerhood (although surprisingly little research is available), being electrocuted is arguably the most severe Criterion-A experience possible. Two major risk factors for chronic PTSD, severe pain ([@bib61]) and extreme fright ([@bib133], [@bib134]) are simultaneously inflicted on a toddler when he or she is electrecuted. A question relevant to the evolutionary context at hand is why preverbal toddlers insert thin metal objects (e.g., screwdrivers, nails or knitting needles) into electric sockets in the first place. The mode of acquisition of inserting thin straight metal objects into electric sockets is presently unclear. These objects do not share stimulus properties with electric cords, thus observer conditioning is unlikely. However, ample chimpanzee-socioecology research on *P. troglodytes* feeding habits has found that chimpanzees engaged in "termite fishing" by inserting thin straight branches into entry points in termite mounds. Interestingly, this behavior can arguably be better defined as "foraging for termites" since it is mostly observed in female chimpanzees and sub-adult chimpanzees including sub-adult males who are still unable to participate in the hunt for small mammals (e.g., Colobus monkeys which are the main prey of adult male *P. troglodytes*). The mode of acquisition of termite foraging behavior is intensely debated, and arguably, is at the very least, prepotentiated. Insertion of metal objects into electric sockets by a still-undermyelinated human brain may be a result of activation of the evolved firm-wired termite-foraging circuits. There is a wide consensus among paleoanthropologists that, along with larvae, termites were a source of fat and high quality protein for early hominins ([@bib26]). The termite-hunting-circuit hypothesis of preverbal-electrocution trauma is safely testable in human toddlers. 12. Iatrogenic overconsolidational disorders which may need a re-taxonomization in DSM-V (hospital phobia and dental phobia) ============================================================================================================================ 12.1. Posttraumatic medical-care anxiety (hospital phobia) ---------------------------------------------------------- In their landmark Baltimore ECA follow-up study, [@bib11] reported that patients with fear of blood, injection, or injury do not have comorbid fears of medical clinics, physicians, or hospitals. [@bib11] findings are consistent with the prediction that "hospital phobia" is a PTSD-like overconsolidational fear. Arguably, the heritability of blood-injection-injury phobia (narrowly defined as fear of blood, injection or injury) may be underestimated by the misclassification of hospital avoidance, which is posited here to be mostly overconsolidational. It is difficult to envision an EEA Criterion-A adversity that remotely resembles a hospital stay. However, more research regarding the mode of acquisition of hospital avoidance is needed. 12.2. Posttraumatic Dental-care Anxiety (PTDA) ---------------------------------------------- More research is also needed on "dental phobia" since the available data are inconclusive ([@bib110]). Dental phobia most probably a heterogeneous category consisting of 1) an innate fear of sharp objects in close proximity to one\'s head and neck, 2) innate fear of drowning (choking on saliva) and 3) probably most commonly, a non-innate overconsolidational fear following a very painful dental procedure (Bracha, Vega and Vega, submitted for publication). Important recent research by [@bib61] on survivors of a bomb attack in a Paris subway in December 1996 is relevant in this regard. As [@bib61] have demonstrated, physical pain/injury during the Criterion-A adversity is a previously neglected risk factor for subsequent overconsolidational disorders such as PTSD. Bracha, Vega and Vega (submitted for publication) have argued that problem with using the term "phobia" in a dental-care context is as follows: by definition, phobias involve a fear that is "excessive or unreasonable," which the individual recognizes as such, and in which the anxiety, panic attacks and phobic avoidance are not better accounted for by another disorder, including PTSD. More research is needed, however most individuals with dental "phobia" do not recognize their symptoms as "excessive or unreasonable" and, in that sense, resemble individuals with PTSD. Our review of the dental-care literature suggests that true (innate) dental phobias (akin to unreasonable fear at the sight of blood or a syringe) probably account for a smaller percentage of cases, and that the vast majority of dental-care anxiety (DA) cases stem from aversive dental experiences. Research has documented that individuals who reported having experienced *painful* dental treatments and perceived a lack of control in the dental situation were approximately 14 times more likely to also report higher dental fear, and approximately 16 times more likely to report being less willing to return to the dental treatment. Therefore, this psychological condition may be better conceptualized as Posttraumatic Dental-care Anxiety (PTDA), and should be classified as part of the overconsolidational disorders spectrum in the forthcoming DSM-V. 13. Overconsolidational fear of animal attack: dog, bird, or bat phobia (may also need to be re-taxonomized in DSM-V) ===================================================================================================================== 13.1. Overconsolidational fear of dogs -------------------------------------- In light of the symbiotic 15,000-year-long co-evolution of humans and dogs, and humans\' long dependence on dogs for both hunting and protection, neuroevolutionary reasoning predicts that fear of dogs has an associative mode of acquisition. The anecdotally reported improved sleep achieved by a prescription of having a large dog share the patient\'s bed also suggests that the "anxiolytic effect of dogs" is innate and that, thus, fear of dogs develops overconsolidationally. There is almost no published research on this fear. However, in a study of 30 children with dog phobia, over 86% of parents "were able to attribute their child\'s phobia to one of Rachman\'s three (non-innate) conditioning pathways: direct conditioning, modeling, or transmission of information" ([@bib73]). Clinical data reviewed by [@bib84] are also consistent with an overconsolidational mode of acquisition of the fear of dogs. In most studies unfortunately, fear of dogs is grouped in the "other" animal sub-category, ([@bib68]) so it is not possible to draw conclusions from their data at this stage. 13.2. Overconsolidational fear of birds --------------------------------------- Similarly, neuroevolutionary reasoning predicts that fear of avians is also not an innate fear. Paleoanthropological studies document that, even before the development of archery technology, avians were a common human prey (presumably caught with nets) ([@bib26]). In the Kendler et al. twin study ([@bib68]), fear of birds is also grouped in the "other" animal sub-category, so it is not possible to draw conclusions from their data at this stage. 13.3. Overconsolidational fear of bats -------------------------------------- Neuroevolutionary reasoning predicts that (like fear of domesticated canids and of avians) fear of bats is overconsolidational. There is currently widespread consumption of bats, in Africa, Asia, and the Pacific Islands, especially in the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (e.g. Saipan, Tinian, and Rota), as well as among Chamorro Americans in Guam. Research has found that bats and the *H. sapiens* have shared caves at least since the beginning of the lower Paleolithic (i.e., ∼ 2 million years). The [@bib68] twin study is consistent with an associative mode of acquisition proposed herein for bat phobia. Out of 37 subjects with fear of bats, 62.2% reported "trauma to self" from bats, and only 5.4% had "no memory" (a 12:1 ratio). In contrast, as noted above, among "bug phobia" subjects, 40.6% reported "trauma to self" and a very high 43.8% reported "no memory" (a one to one ratio) ([@bib68]). These findings are consistent with the neuroevolutionary prediction that fear of bats is overconsolidational. More research is needed. 13.4. Falsifiable predictions that follow from the above reasoning on dog, bird and bat phobias ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The first falsifiable prediction that follows from the above reasoning is that the heritability of dog, bird and bat fears may be quite low and closer to that of PTSD, the prototypical overconsolidational disorder. The second prediction is that Pitman\'s propranolol anti-overconsolidation regimen ([@bib108], [@bib107], [@bib134]) will be an effective and useful addition to the standard emergency management protocol for individuals presenting with these three animal injuries. The second falsifiable prediction is based on the finding of [@bib61] (discussed above). It is predicted that painful injury will be a key risk factor for subsequent dog, bird or bat phobia. Anecdotally, facial injury from a flock of bats or birds is often seen in rural emergency departments. If dog phobia, bird phobia and bat phobia are non-innate as posited here, these fears can be clustered in a new "overconsolidational disorders" category in the DSM-V discussed above with regard to PTSD. 14. Towards a science-based DSM-V reconceptualization of anxiety disorders which DSM-IV-TR currently labels 'culture-bound' {#sec3} =========================================================================================================================== Among stress-neurobiology researchers working with Asian Americans and researchers in East Asia, there is a growing consensus that the research agenda for the DSM-V should include a major re-conceptualization of what the DSM-IV-TR terms "culture-bound syndromes." An attempt should be made to place these syndromes in a more neurobiological context in the forthcoming DSM-V. A clinical imperative for such a re-conceptualization is that a failure by primary care clinicians to assume a standard DSM diagnosis of these patients results in a failure to make a referral to psychiatric science-based interventions. Such patients are left to seek non-science-based and often harmful "alternative medicine." A re-conceptualization is also important because cross-cultural and ethnocultural research suffers from the use of unhelpful terms such as "race" rather than "geographic ancestry" ([@bib8]). Geographic ancestry (as self-reported) can easily tackle methodological problems resulting, for example, from the lumping (in research settings) of individuals of Puerto Rican, Cuban, Mexican, south American, Central American and European--Spanish ancestry as "Hispanic." Another example of a problematic social construct is "Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders" used widely in cross-cultural and ethnocultural research. The construct of "Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders" clusters Pacific Islanders (e.g., Samoans) with Americans of North Asian geographical ancestry (Japanese/Koreans). This clustering is scientifically incorrect. As [@bib8] has recently argued, at least in the U.S. and in other countries with high admixture, "geographic ancestry" (e.g., self-reported using three-generation checklists or triangular graphs) needs to replace self-reported "race," since geographic ancestry is a much better proxy of relevant allele frequencies and probably also of a person\'s culture. 15. Taijin-kyofusho =================== One of the symptom clusters that DSM-IV-TR erroneously contends is unique to the Japanese culture-bound genome is taijin-kyofusho. In the U.S., it is primarily diagnosed in Hawaii, but there are no research data suggesting that taijin-kyofusho is a useful construct. Suzuki et al. from Japan have recently criticized the conceptualization of taijin-kyofusho in DSM-IV-TR ([@bib125]). [@bib125] state that there was "an erroneous introduction of taijin-kyofusho to the West." Furthermore, these authors state, "the three subtypes of taijin kyofusho are not culturally distinctive phobias in Japan" and that "at this stage, the notion that taijin kyofusho is a culture-bound syndrome cannot be held." Suzuki et al.\'s conclusions are consistent with our suggestion that taijin-kyofusho is one of a dozen or so DSM-IV-TR terms that should not be carried over in DSM-V. Instead, taijin-kyofusho may be more coherently conceptualized as comorbidity of any two of the following evolutionarily driven anxiety traits which may be equally prevalent in the West and in Japan. These are three mostly innate and well understood disorders for which science-based treatments are available: Generalized Social Phobia, Body Dysmorphic Disorder, and an obsessive preoccupation with one\'s personal cleanliness and body odor as part of OCD. 16. "Koro," "shuk yang," "shook yong," "suo yang," "rok-joo," and "jinjinia bemar" ================================================================================== These disorders are also listed in DSM-IV-TR ([@bib5]) as culture-bound (p. 900). In the U.S., the disorders are probably most often seen in Hawaii, Guam and American Samoa. All consist of an intense acute fear that the external genitalia (in males) or nipples (in females) will retract into the body and potentially cause death. The author posits that these six syndromes are essentially identical to either panic attacks or other well-understood acute anxiety states in which the evolutionarily hardwired sympathetic (Fives F\'s) evolved acute fear response includes a fitness-enhancing and protective retraction of the external genitalia as part of the freeze--flight--fight--fright response. In women, the manifestations include a retraction of the nipples and blanching of the areola, which may be understood as fear-induced cutaneous vasoconstriction. Arguably, the reason why these signs of acute anxiety are usually reported from peri-equatorial countries may simply be that minimal clothing makes them more easily observable. Maintaining the description of these syndromes as "culture-bound" may prevent science-based treatment and may be stigmatizing. 17. "Karoshi", "gwarosa" and "Voodoo death" (a fear-induced malignant syncope?) =============================================================================== Arguably, "karoshi", "gwarosa" and "Voodoo death" are not useful constructs but rather are identical to fear-induced malignant syncope (FIMS) observed in Europe and the US. The traditional Japanese diagnosis of karoshi is a medically unexplained sudden cardiac death in a young otherwise healthy male after a public humiliation by a powerful authority figure (karoshi is often translated as "job stress death"). Voodoo death is another medically unexplained fear-triggered cardiac death usually reported in young, otherwise healthy males. It is still widely observed in countries with extremely high levels of lethal violence such as Haiti. The author posits that both karoshi and Voodoo death may be identical to FIMS. FIMS (efferent vasovagal syncope of malignant severity) is the most common indication for insertion of a pacemaker in young adults in the US. Malignant (lethal) vasovagal syncope has been perplexing to cardiologists who consider its etiology "puzzling" and a "riddle" ([@bib10], [@bib135]), but as we have argued in two recent articles ([@bib20], [@bib15]), reflex vasovagal syncope of malignant severity may simply represent the extreme pathological tail of heart rate variability described above as a key component of fear-induced fainting. FIMS is arguably the best physiological explanation not only for karoshi and for Voodoo death, but also for the historical and ethnographic reports of healthy individuals being "stricken dead" by a verbal threat. 18. Agoraphobia with and agoraphobia without a history of panic attacks: two different modes of acquisition? ============================================================================================================ The widely held view of agoraphobia is that it is invariably a post-panic-attack fear overconsolidation. If so, "phobia" is an inappropriate suffix that warrants reconsideration in DSM-V. [@bib57] have argued that the National Comorbidity Study (NCS) data and the reanalysis of ECA data are both consistent with Klein\'s conditioned-avoidance hypothesis of agoraphobia ([@bib74]). In its updated version ([@bib69], [@bib49]), this hypothesis posits an overconsolidation-based avoidance mostly secondary to previous spontaneous orbitofronto-amygdala-circuit-driven panic attacks ([@bib69]). It is noteworthy that agoraphobia and social phobia are the only two phobias in which [@bib67] found that family environment may have an impact on risk. Nevertheless, moderate heritability of agoraphobia was demonstrated in the same study ([@bib67]). The small subgroup of agoraphobia that has no history of panic attacks has been more difficult to explain (even when taking into account the likelihood of poor self-report). In the context of this article, the existence of a primary agoraphobia (with no panic attacks) is predicted by evolutionary reasoning. It is tempting to speculate that primary agoraphobia may be traced back to the fact that humans (medium sized and relatively slow mammals) were partially arboreal until about 3 Mya. Thus, early hominins arguably relied on arboreality as their primary escape response (the flight segment of their freeze, flight, fight, fright sequence). Numerous theorists (e.g., [@bib128], [@bib94]) have argued that expanding beyond the forested highland indigenous niche and moving into almost treeless wide-open savannahs increased the vulnerability of humans to predation by faster-moving carnivores, primarily large felines, and thus made fear of wide-open (treeless?) spaces a fitness-enhancing trait. A falsifiable prediction is that patients with primary agoraphobia would be less anxious in a virtual reality landscape which is not entirely treeless. Arguably, the anxiolytic effect of nearby tall trees (and affection for tree houses among prepubertal extant *H. sapiens*) may be a manifestation of these still partly conserved circuits, and may thus be over-represented among first-degree relatives of primary agoraphobia probands (this prediction is testable). 19. Brief comments regarding often-cited 1970s critiques of neuroevolutionary reasoning ======================================================================================= The severity of anxiety symptoms addressed by neuroevolutionary psychiatry is harder to explain as stochastics or spandrels. "Neuroevolutionary psychiatry" (as this term is defined in this article) attempts to offer clinically useful predictions relevant to the research agenda for the DSM-V and be useful to psychiatric genetics. It is axiomatic that "the human ability to unlearn things one has never learned" (that are innate) is commonly observed. Thus, the common social science critique that innate fears, e.g., of snakes, can often be successfully extinguished by exposure does not contradict their evolutionary-based etiology. As discussed in [Introduction](#sec1){ref-type="sec"}, evolutionary psychology focuses on universal human traits which are species-typical in humans and thus have low heritability ([@bib130], [@bib38], [@bib37]). Nevertheless, a brief discussion of and defense of the sister specialty (evolutionary psychology) may be warranted. The critique that evolutionary psychology is just a collection of untestable Lamarckian Rudyard-Kiplingian "just so stories" was raised in a widely cited theoretical paper written a quarter-century ago by two highly influential non-paleoanthropologists, [@bib50]. Interestingly, the "just so stories" critique was also made about Darwin\'s work. While neuroevolutionary hypotheses of stress and fear circuitry disorders are still speculative, they are empirically falsifiable in numerous ways as proposed in this article. It should be noted that [@bib50] write with a dualistic Cartesian mind--body dichotomy probably because their expertise is in insect and dinosaur evolution where gene--culture co-evolution does not occur. For complete lucid rebuttals of Gould and Lewontin\'s "just so stories" critique, see reviews by [@bib136], [@bib28] and [@bib129] and recent syntheses of the newer research by [@bib40]. Finally, a statistical language to express causation has yet to emerge ([@bib105]), and research into etiological factors in psychiatric disorders traditionally begun as a "just so story." The author is in full agreement with [@bib50] that, at present, an unknown percentage of differences which appear on the surface to be evolved behavioral traits (including some of the hypotheses presented in this article) will be found to be evolutionary design compromises or reflect random genetic drift. However, hidden among the brain expressed genomic differences are at least a significant percentage of functionally relevent DNA (most likely in Introns) that underlie the brain-expressed phenotypic differences between clinically symptomatic and non-clinically symptomatic humans. Gould and Lewontin\'s other claim that "behaviors do not leave fossils" may also be challenged by a wide range of emerging techniques, such as the study of fear-circuitry-related infradian fluctuations (e.g., of NE Beta-receptor activity, or vagal nucleus ambiguus firing) as reflected in human mineralized tissue ([@bib18], [@bib126], [@bib80]). More importantly, the "behaviors do not leave fossils" claim also is not supported by molecular-phylogenetic studies of human lineages via chromosome-Y and mitochondrial DNA ([@bib132], [@bib116]). Finally, if we fully adhere to Gould and Lewontin\'s forensic criteria of level of evidence, Darwin\'s 19th century theory of common ancestry for the *Homo* and *Pan* lineages was a "just so story," only proven as fact on September 1, 2005 with the publication of the paper *Initial Sequence of the Chimpanzee Genome and Comparison with the Human Genome* completed by the Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium ([@bib33]). 20. Gene--environment interactions ("ontogenomics") and caveats =============================================================== 20.1. The non-reductionistic evolutionary perspective ----------------------------------------------------- It is important to emphasize that this article espouses a non-reductionistic evolutionary perspective which is not only consistent with a key role for pleiotropic genes, and other design compromises but also does not discount the important role of epigenetic factors, psychological and physical ontogenomic (early environment) factors, the heterogeneity and multifactoriality of anxiety traits, allostatic load, social support group cohesion and horizontally transmitted (culturally learned) factors such as religiousness ([@bib147]) and lifestyle choices. This non-reductionistic clinically oriented approach emphasizes the importance of clinically treating those behavioral traits that evolved for Cenozoic, Paleolithic, or Neolithic environments, and which have outlived their usefulness in extant human adults. While evolutionary factors of anxiety traits are the sole focus of this article, the "frontal release phenomena" heuristic of clinical neuropsychiatry deserves mention since it may be helpful for a constructive fusion of distal (evolutionary) neurobiology with "clinical proximal neurobiology." [@bib69] emphasize the importance of "appropriate top--down governance by frontal cortical regions over a hypersensitive amygdala-centered fear neurocircuitry." The frontal release phenomena heuristic may help explain why some archaic fears are inversely correlated with age, between childhood and early adulthood, as the top--down governance of the frontal cortex over the amygdala increases. Additionally, the frontal release-sign heuristic may similarly explain why there is a positive correlation between late-life frontal lobe dysfunction (e.g., Alzheimer\'s disease) and the resurfacing of fears that evolved for earlier segments of the human EEA, and which may have outlived their usefulness in extant *H. sapien* adults. 21. Objections to evolutionary reconceptualizations for DSM-V are to be expected ================================================================================ Some initial ideology driven objections to any mention of evolutionary etiological factors in DSM-V are to be expected. First and foremost, for the severest psychiatric illnesses, neuroevolutionary perspectives are clinically unhelpful (schizophrenia is the best example). In contrast, it is axiomatic that a mild degree of fear is helpful and that one can have "too much of a good thing" (too high a gene dosage?). Therefore, a prudent strategy in the research agenda for DSM-V may be to focus initially on evolutionary factors in fear circuitry disorders. A second objection may stem from the sometimes overlapping language between neuroevolutionary psychiatry and psychoanalytic theory which understandably makes psychiatric researchers uneasy. However, there are obvious fundamental differences between psychoanalytic theory and neuroevolutionary psychiatry. For example, psychoanalysis focused on ontogeny while neuroevolutionary psychiatry presents hominin-phylogenetic-based hypotheses and eventually may be able to focus on phylogenomics--ontogenomics interactions (a.k.a. gene--environment interactions) at the molecular level. To some degree, hominin phylogenomics can be seen as the basic science of evolutionary psychiatry. As [Table 2](#tbl2){ref-type="table"} (above) attempts to demonstrate, phylogenomics may fit well into the spectrum of investigational methods into the etiology of fear circuitry disorders. 22. Conclusion ============== It is important to emphasize that hypotheses are by definition conjectural. At this stage, the data in support of re-clustering fear traits neuroevolutionarily or phylogenomically are still very limited and the hypotheses presented in this article are highly speculative. Epidemiological and twin studies are needed to test whether clustering fear-related traits by neuroevolutionary time-depth may be one of the useful non-phenotype-based approaches to anxiety disorders in the research agenda for the forthcoming DSM-V. As noted earlier, discussion of etiological factors in DSM-III ([@bib3]), DSM-IV ([@bib4]), DSM-IV-TR ([@bib5]) and ICD-10 ([@bib141]) has been judiciously minimized. In contrast, the research agenda for the forthcoming DSM-V has specifically highlighted the need for a more etiologically based classification ([@bib79], [@bib31]). Furthermore, as several authorities have noted ([@bib79]), examination of the usefulness of adding an Axis VI reflecting evolutionary factors can be a part of the research agenda for the forthcoming DSM-V. Early theorists such as [@bib13] and [@bib83] unfortunately focused on human-species-typical (and thus non-clinical), "basic" fear circuits which are phenotypically expressed almost exclusively in undermyelinated humans (infants and toddlers). These are the circuits that MacLean labeled "paleo-mammalian," and which in this article are termed Mesozoic. In contrast, the neuroevolutionary synthesis and re-clustering of fear-circuitry-related traits proposed here attempt to go beyond [@bib13] and [@bib83] writings by focusing exclusively on fear circuits which are species-specific in humans (and much more importantly *human-species-atypical*, and thus clinically relevant) as well as phenotypically expressed in adult clinical populations. Over 30 empirically falsifiable predictions relevant to the DSM-V research agenda on fear circuitry disorders are presented. In addition to discussing fears which are primarily innate, the author presents a dozen evolution-based testable predictions relevant to research on overconsolidational fears, especially warzone-related PTSD. Finally, to the best of the author\'s knowledge, the Neuroevolutionary Time-depth Principle (Neuroevolutionary-TDP) introduced in this review is the first to tackle the question of why extant humans are consistently found to have a much higher resilience following exposure to natural disasters than following personal engagement in lethal fighting (combat), being personally present when conspecifics engage in lethal fighting (warzone exposure) or being personally present during intentionally caused disasters such as terrorism. This material is based upon work supported in part by the Office of Research and Development, Medical Research Service, Department of Veterans Affairs, VA Pacific Islands Health Care System, Spark M. Matsunaga Medical Center. Support was also provided by a National Alliance for Research on Schizophrenia and Depression (NARSAD) Independent Investigator Award, and the VA National Center for PTSD. The author thanks Stacy Lenze, Michelle Tsang Mui Chung, Jessica Shelton, and Nicole Masukawa for outstanding editorial assistance. Views expressed in this article are those of the author and may not reflect views of the author\'s employer or related institutions. All potential clinical applications of currently marketed drugs in the United States discussed in this article are "off-label." [^1]: Approximate evolutionary time-depths available for the human genome to select resiliency alleles for different criterion-A adversities. Epidemiological data cited from the National Comorbidity Study (NCS) ([@bib71]). Time-depth approximation based on [@bib24].

\section{Introduction} In this paper, $\cX$ stands for a (projective, geometrically irreducible, nonsingular) algebraic curve of genus $\gg(\cX) \ge 2$ defined over an algebraically closed field $\K$ of odd characteristic $p$. Let $\aut(\cX)$ be the group of all automorphisms of $\cX$ which fix $\K$ element-wise. The assumption $\gg(\cX)\geq 2$ ensures that $\aut(\cX)$ is finite. However the classical Hurwitz bound $|\aut(\cX)| \leq 84(\gg(\cX)-1)$ for complex curves fails in positive characteristic, and there exist four families of curves satisfying $|\aut(\cX)|\geq 8\gg^3(\cX)$; see \cite{stichtenoth1973II}, Henn \cite{henn1978}, and also \cite[Section 11.12]{HKT}. Each of them has has $p$-rank $\gamma(\cX)$ (equivalently, its Hasse-Witt invariant) equal to zero; see for instance \cite{GKLINZ}. On the other hand, if $\cX$ is ordinary, i.e. $\gg(\cX)=\gamma(\cX)$, Guralnik and Zieve announced in 2004, as reported in \cite{GSY,KR}, that for odd $p$ there exists a sharper bound, namely $|\aut(\cX)|\leq c_p\gg(\cX)^{8/5}$ with some constant $c_p$ depending on $p$. It should be noticed that no proof of this sharper bound is available in the literature. In this paper, we concern with solvable automorphism groups $G$ of an ordinary curve $\cX$, and for odd $p$ we prove the even sharper bound: \begin{theorem} \label{princ} Let $\cX$ be an algebraic curve of genus $\gg(\cX) \ge 2$ defined over an algebraically closed field $\K$ of odd characteristic $p$. If $\cX$ is ordinary and $G$ is a solvable subgroup of $\aut(\cX)$ then \begin{equation} \label{bound} |G|\leq 34(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}. \end{equation} \end{theorem} For odd $p$, our result provides an improvement on the classical Nakajima bound $|G|\leq 84(\gg(\cX)-1)\gg(\cX)$, see \cite{N}, and, for solvable groups, on the recent Gunby-Smith-Yuan bound $|G|\leq 6(\gg(\cX)^2+12\sqrt{21}\gg(\cX)^{3/2})$ proven in \cite{GSY} under the hypothesis that $\gg(\cX)>cp^2$ for some positive constant $c$. The following example is due to Stichtenoth and it shows that (\ref{bound}) is the best possible bound apart from the constant $c$. Let $\mathbb{F}_q$ be a finite field of order $q=p^h$ and let $\mathbb{K}=\overline{\mathbb{F}_q}$ denote its algebraic closure. For a positive integer $m$ prime to $p$, let $\cY$ be the irreducible curve with affine equation \begin{equation} \label{oct6eq1} y^q+y=x^m+\frac{1}{x^m}, \end{equation} and $F=\mathbb{K}(\cY))$ its function field. Let $t=x^{m(q-1)}$. The extension $F|\mathbb{K}(t)$ is a non-Galois extension as the Galois closure of $F$ with respect to $H$ is the function field $\mathbb{K}(x,y,z)$ where $x,y,z$ are linked by (\ref{oct6eq1}) and $z^q+z=x^m$. Furthermore, $\gg(\cY)=(q-1)(qm-1)$, $\gamma(\cY)=(q-1)^2$ and $\aut(\cY)$ contains a subgroup $Q\rtimes U$ of index $2$ where $Q$ is an elementary abelian normal subgroup of order $q^2$ and the complement $U$ is a cyclic group of order $m(q-1)$. If $m=1$ then $\cY$ is an ordinary curve, and in this case $2\gg(\cY)^{3/2}=2(q-1)^3<2q^2(q-1)$ which shows indeed that (\ref{bound}) is sharp up to the constant $c$. \section{Background and Preliminary Results}\label{sec2} For a subgroup $G$ of $\aut(\cX)$, let $\bar \cX$ denote a non-singular model of $\K(\cX)^G$, that is, a (projective non-singular geometrically irreducible) algebraic curve with function field $\K(\cX)^G$, where $\K(\cX)^G$ consists of all elements of $\K(\cX)$ fixed by every element in $G$. Usually, $\bar \cX$ is called the quotient curve of $\cX$ by $G$ and denoted by $\cX/G$. The field extension $\K(\cX)|\K(\cX)^G$ is Galois of degree $|G|$. Since our approach is mostly group theoretical, we prefer to use notation and terminology from Group theory rather than from Function field theory. Let $\Phi$ be the cover of $\cX|\bar{\cX}$ where $\bar{\cX}=\cX/G$. A point $P\in\cX$ is a ramification point of $G$ if the stabilizer $G_P$ of $P$ in $G$ is nontrivial; the ramification index $e_P$ is $|G_P|$; a point $\bar{Q}\in\bar{\cX}$ is a branch point of $G$ if there is a ramification point $P\in \cX$ such that $\Phi(P)=\bar{Q}$; the ramification (branch) locus of $G$ is the set of all ramification (branch) points. The $G$-orbit of $P\in \cX$ is the subset $o=\{R\mid R=g(P),\, g\in G\}$ of $\cX$, and it is {\em long} if $|o|=|G|$, otherwise $o$ is {\em short}. For a point $\bar{Q}$, the $G$-orbit $o$ lying over $\bar{Q}$ consists of all points $P\in\cX$ such that $\Phi(P)=\bar{Q}$. If $P\in o$ then $|o|=|G|/|G_P|$ and hence $\bar{\cQ}$ is a branch point if and only if $o$ is a short $G$-orbit. It may be that $G$ has no short orbits. This is the case if and only if every non-trivial element in $G$ is fixed--point-free on $\cX$, that is, the cover $\Phi$ is unramified. On the other hand, $G$ has a finite number of short orbits. For a non-negative integer $i$, the $i$-th ramification group of $\cX$ at $P$ is denoted by $G_P^{(i)}$ (or $G_i(P)$ as in \cite[Chapter IV]{serre1979}) and defined to be $$G_P^{(i)}=\{g\mid \ord_P(g(t)-t)\geq i+1, g\in G_P\}, $$ where $t$ is a uniformizing element (local parameter) at $P$. Here $G_P^{(0)}=G_P$. Let $\bar{\gg}$ be the genus of the quotient curve $\bar{\cX}=\cX/G$. The Hurwitz genus formula gives the following equation \begin{equation} \label{eq1} 2\gg-2=|G|(2\bar{\gg}-2)+\sum_{P\in \cX} d_P. \end{equation} where the different $d_P$ at $P$ is given by \begin{equation} \label{eq1bis} d_P= \sum_{i\geq 0}(|G_P^{(i)}|-1). \end{equation} Let $\gamma$ be the $p$-rank of $\cX$, and let $\bar{\gamma}$ be the $p$-rank of the quotient curve $\bar{\cX}=\cX/S$. The Deuring-Shafarevich formula, see \cite{sullivan1975} or \cite[Theorem 11,62]{HKT}, states that \begin{equation} \label{eq2deuring} \gamma-1={|G|}(\bar{\gamma}-1)+\sum_{i=1}^k (|G|-\ell_i) \end{equation} where $\ell_1,\ldots,\ell_k$ are the sizes of the short orbits of $G$. A subgroup of $\aut(\cX)$ is a prime to $p$ group (or a $p'$-subgroup) if its order is prime to $p$. A subgroup $G$ of $\aut(\cX)$ is {\em{tame}} if the $1$-point stabilizer of any point in $G$ is $p'$-group. Otherwise, $G$ is {\em{non-tame}} (or {\em{wild}}). Obviously, every $p'$-subgroup of $\aut(\cX)$ is tame, but the converse is not always true. By a theorem of Stichtenoth, see \cite[Theorem 11.56]{HKT}, if $|G|>84(\gg(\cX)-1)$ then $G$ is non-tame. An orbit $o$ of $G$ is {\em{tame}} if $G_P$ is a $p'$-group for $P\in o$. The stabilizer $G_P$ of a point $P\in \cX$ in $G$ is a semidirect product $G_P=Q_P\rtimes U$ where the normal subgroup $Q_P$ is a $p$-group while the complement $U$ is a cyclic prime to $p$ group; see \cite[Theorem 11.49]{HKT}. By a theorem of Serre, if $\cX$ is an ordinary curve then $Q_P$ is elementary abelian and no nontrivial element of $U$ commutes with a nontrivial element of $Q_P$; see \cite[Lemma 11.75]{HKT}. In particular, $|U|$ divides $|Q_P|-1$, see \cite[Proposition 1]{N}, and $G_P$ is not abelian when either $Q_P$ or $U$ is nontrivial. The following two lemmas of independent interest play a role in our proof of Theorem \ref{princ}. \begin{lemma} \label{terrible} Let $\cX$ be an ordinary algebraic curve of genus $\gg(\cX) \ge 2$ defined over an algebraically closed field $\K$ of odd characteristic $p$. Let $H$ be a solvable automorphism group of $\aut(\cX)$ containing a normal $p$-subgroup $Q$ such that $|Q|$ and $[H:Q]$ are coprime. Suppose that a complement $U$ of $Q$ in $H$ is abelian and that \begin{equation} \label{eq22bisdic2015} |H|> \left\{ \begin{array}{lll} {\mbox{$18(\gg-1)$ for $|U|=3$}}, \\ {\mbox{$12(\gg-1)$ otherwise}}. \end{array} \right. \end{equation} Then $U$ is cyclic, and the quotient curve $\bar{\cX}=\cX/Q$ is rational. Furthermore, $Q$ has exactly two (non-tame) short orbits, say $\Omega_1, \Omega_2$. They are also the only short orbits of $H$, and $\gg(\cX)=|Q|-(|\Omega_1|+|\Omega_2|)+1.$ \end{lemma} \begin{proof} From the Schur-Zassenhaus theorem \cite[Corollary 7.5]{MA}, $H=Q\rtimes U$. Set $|Q|=p^k$, $|U|=u$. Then $p\nmid u$. Furthermore, if $u=2$ then $|H|=2|Q|>9\gg(\cX)$ whence $|Q|>4.5\gg(\cX)$. From Nakajima's bound $\cX$, see \cite[Theorem 11.84]{HKT}, has zero $p$-rank. Therefore $u\geq 3$. Three cases are treated separately according as the quotient curve $\bar{\cX}=\cX/Q$ has genus $\bar{\gg}$ at least $2$, or $\bar{\cX}$ is elliptic, or rational. If $\gg(\bar{\cX})\geq 2$, then $\aut(\bar{\cX})$ has a subgroup isomorphic to $U$, and \cite[Theorem 11.79]{HKT} yields $4\gg(\bar{\cX})+4\geq |U|.$ Furthermore, from the Hurwitz genus formula applied to $Q$, $\gg-1\geq |Q|(\gg(\bar{\cX})-1)$. Therefore, if $c=12$ or $c=18$, according as $|U|>3$ or $|U|=3$, $$(4\gg(\bar{\cX})+4)|Q|\geq |U||Q|=|H|> c(\gg-1)= 12 |Q|(\gg(\bar{\cX})-1),$$ whence $$c< 4\frac{\gg(\bar{\cX})+1}{\gg(\bar{\cX})-1} \leq 12,$$ a contradiction. If $\bar{\cX}$ is elliptic, then the cover $\cX|\bar{\cX}$ ramifies, otherwise $\cX$ itself would be elliptic. Thus, $Q$ has some short orbits. Take one of them together with its images $o_1,\ldots,o_{u_1}$ under the action of $H$. Since $Q$ is a normal subgroup of $H$, $o=o_1\cup\ldots\cup o_{u_1}$ is a $H$-orbit of size $u_1p^v$ where $p^v=|o_1|=\ldots |o_{u_1}|$. Equivalently, the stabilizer of a point $P\in o$ has order $p^{k-v}u/u_1$, and it is the semidirect product $Q_1\rtimes U_1$ where $|Q_1|=p^{k-v}$ and $|U_1|=u/u_1$ for a subgroup $Q_1$ of $Q$ and $U_1$ of $U$ respectively. The point $\bar{P}$ lying under $P$ in the cover $\cX| \bar{\cX}$ is fixed by the factor group $\bar{U_1}=U_1Q/Q$. Since $\bar{\cX}$ is elliptic, \cite[Theorem 11.94]{HKT} implies $|\bar{U}_1|\leq 12$ for $p=3$ and $|\bar{U}_1|\leq 6$ for $p>3$. As $\bar{U}_1\cong U_1$, this yields the same bound for $|U_1|$, that is, $u\leq 4 u_1$ for $p=3$ and $u\leq 6 u_1$ for $p>3$. Furthermore, $d_P\geq 2(p^{k-v}-1)\geq \textstyle\frac{4}{3} p^{k-v}$. From the Hurwitz genus formula applied to $Q$, if $p=3$ then $$2\gg-2\geq 3^v u_1d_P\geq 3^v u_1(\textstyle\frac{4}{3} 3^{k-v}) \geq \textstyle\frac{4}{3} 3^k u_1\geq \textstyle\frac{1}{3} 3^k u=\textstyle\frac{1}{3}|Q||U|=\textstyle\frac{1}{3} |H|,$$ while for $p>3$, $$2\gg-2\geq p^v u_1d_P\geq p^v u_1(\textstyle\frac{4}{3} p^{k-v}) \geq \textstyle\frac{4}{3} p^k u_1\geq \textstyle\frac{2}{9} p^ku=\textstyle\frac{2}{9}|Q||U|=\textstyle\frac{2}{9} |H|,$$ But this contradicts (\ref{eq22bisdic2015}). If $\bar{\cX}$ is rational, then $Q$ has at least one short orbit. Furthermore, $\bar{U}=UQ/Q$ is isomorphic to a subgroup of $PGL(2,\K)\cong\aut(\bar{\cX})$. Since $U\cong \bar{U}$, the classification of finite subgroups of $PGL(2,\K)$, see \cite{maddenevalentini1982}, shows that $U$ is cyclic, $\bar{U}$ fixes two points $\bar{P}_0$ and $\bar{P}_\infty$ but no nontrivial element in $\bar{U}$ fixes a point other than $\bar{P}_0$ and $\bar{P}_\infty$. Let $o_\infty$ and $o_0$ be the $Q$-orbits lying over $\bar{P}_0$ and $\bar{P}_\infty$, respectively. Obviously, $o_\infty$ and $o_0$ are short orbits of $H$. We show that $Q$ has at most two short orbits, the candidates being $o_\infty$ and $o_0$. By absurd, there is a $Q$-orbit $o$ of size $p^m$ with $m<k$ which lies over a point $\bar{P}\in \bar{\cX}$ different from both $\bar{P}_0$ and $\bar{P}_\infty$. Since the orbit of $\bar{P}$ in $\bar{U}$ has length $u$, then the $H$-orbit of a point $P\in o$ has length $up^m$. If $u>3$, the Hurwitz genus formula applied to $Q$ gives $$2\gg-2\ge -2p^k+up^m(p^{k-m}-1)\geq -2p^k+up^m\textstyle\frac{2}{3} p^{k-m}\geq -2p^k+\textstyle\frac{2}{3}up^k\geq \textstyle\frac{2}{3}(u-3)p^k \geq \textstyle\frac{1}{6}up^k = \frac{1}{6}|H|,$$ a contradiction with $|H|> 12(\gg-1)$. If $u=3$ then $p>3$, and hence $$2\gg-2\ge -2p^k+3p^m(p^{k-m}-1)=p^k-3p^m>\textstyle\frac{1}{3} p^k,$$ whence $|H|=3p^k<18(\gg-1)$, a contradiction with (\ref{eq22bisdic2015}). This proves that $H$ has exactly two short orbits. Assume that $Q$ has two short orbits. They are $o_\infty$ and $o_0$. If their lengths are $p^a$ and $p^b$ with $a,b<k$, the Deuring-Shafarevich formula applied to $Q$ gives $$\gg(\cX)-1=\gamma(\cX)-1=-p^k+(p^k-p^a)+p^k-p^b$$ whence $\gg(\cX)=p^k-(p^a+p^b)+1>0$. The same argument shows that if $Q$ has just one short orbit, then $\gamma(\cX)=0$, a contradiction. \end{proof} \begin{lemma} \label{GK61} Let $N$ be an automorphism group of an algebraic curve of even genus such that $|N|$ is even. Then any $2$-subgroup of $N$ has a cyclic subgroup of index $2$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $U$ be a subgroup of $\aut(\cX)$ of order $d=2^u\geq 2$, and $\bar{\cX}=\cX/N$ the arising quotient curve. From the Hurwitz genus formula applied to $U$, $$2\gg(\cX)-2=2(p-2)p^{n-1}=2^u(2\gg\bar{\cX}-2)+\sum_{i=1}^m(2^u-\ell_i)$$ where $\ell_1,\ldots,\ell_m$ are the short orbits of $U$ on $\cX$. Since $2(p-2)p^{n-1}\equiv 2 \pmod 4$ while $2^u(2\gg \bar{\cX}-2)\equiv 0 \pmod 4$, some $\ell_i$ ($1\le i \le m$) must be either $1$ or $2$. Therefore, $U$ or a subgroup of $U$ of index $2$ fixes a point of $\cX$ and hence is cyclic. \end{proof} \section{The proof of Theorem \ref{princ}} The assertion holds for $\gg(\cX)=2$, as $|G|\leq 48$ for any solvable automorphism group $G$ of a genus two curve; see \cite[Proposition 11.99]{HKT}. For $\gg(\cX)>2$, $\cX$ is taken by absurd for a minimal counterexample with respect the genera so that for any solvable subgroup of $\aut(\bar{\cX})$ of an ordinary curve $\bar{\cX}$ of genus $\gg(\bar{\cX})\ge 2$ we have $|\bar{G}|\leq 34(\gg+1)^{3/2}$. Two cases are treated separately. \subsection{Case I: $G$ contains a minimal normal $p$-subgroup} \label{CasoI} \begin{proposition} \label{caseI} Let $\cX$ be an ordinary algebraic curve of genus $\gg$ defined over an algebraically closed field $\mathbb{K}$ of odd characteristic $p>0$. If $G$ is a solvable subgroup of $\aut(\cX)$ containing a minimal normal $p$-subgroup $N$, then $|G|\leq 34 (\gg+1)^{3/2}$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Take the largest normal $p$-subgroup $Q$ of $G$. Let $\bar{\cX}$ be the quotient curve of $\cX$ with respect to $Q$ and let $\bar{G}=G/Q$. The quotient group $\bar{G}$ is a subgroup of $\aut(\bar{\cX})$ and it has no normal $p$-subgroup, otherwise $G$ would have a normal $p$-subgroup properly containing $Q$. For $\bar{\gg}=\gg(\bar{\cX})$ three cases may occur, namely $\bar{\gg} \geq 2$, $\bar{\gg}=1$ or $\bar{\gg}=0$. If $\bar{\gg} \geq 2$, from the Hurwitz genus formula, $$2\gg-2 \geq |Q|(2\bar{\gg}-2)=\frac{|G|}{|\bar{G}|}(2\bar{\gg}-2)$$ whence $|\bar{G}|> 34(\bar{\gg}+1)^{3/2}$. Since $\bar{\cX}$ is still ordinary, this contradicts our choice of $\cX$ to be a minimal counterexample. If $\bar{\gg}=1$ then the cover $\mathbb{K}(\cX)| \mathbb{K}(\bar{\cX})$ ramifies. Take short orbit $\Delta$ of $Q$. Let $\Gamma$ be the non-tame short orbit of $G$ that contains $\Delta$. Since $Q$ is normal in $G$, the orbit $\Gamma$ partitions into short orbits of $Q$ whose components have the same length which is equal to $|\Delta|$. Let $k$ be the number of the $Q$-orbits contained in $\Gamma$. Then, $$|G_P|= \frac{|G|}{k|\Delta|},$$ holds for every $P \in \Gamma$. Moreover, the quotient group $G_PQ/Q$ fixes a place on $\bar{\cX}$. Now, from \cite[Theorem 11.94 (ii)]{HKT}, $$\frac{|G_PQ|}{|Q|} = \frac{|G_P|}{|G_P \cap Q|} = \frac{|G_P|}{|Q_P|}\leq 12.$$ From this together with the Hurwitz genus formula and \cite[Theorem 2 (i)]{N}, $$2\gg-2 \geq 2k|\Delta|(|Q_P|-1)\geq 2k|\Delta|\frac{|Q_P|}{2} \geq \frac{k|\Delta||G_P|}{12}=\frac{|G|}{12},$$ which contradicts our hypothesis $|G| >34(\gg+1)^{3/2}$. It turns out that $\bar{\cX}$ is rational. Therefore $\bar{G}$ is isomorphic to a subgroup of $PGL(2,\mathbb{K})$ which contains no normal $p$-subgroup. From the classification of finite subgroups of $PGL(2,\K)$, see \cite{maddenevalentini1982}, $\bar{G}$ is a prime to $p$ subgroup which is either cyclic, or dihedral, or isomorphic to one of the the groups $\rm{Alt}_4,\rm{Sym}_4$. In all cases, $\bar{G}$ has a cyclic subgroup $U$ of index $\le 6$ and of order distinct from $3$. We may dismiss all cases but the cyclic one assuming that $G=Q\rtimes U$ with $|G|\geq \textstyle\frac{5}{3}(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}.$ Then $|G|> 12(\gg-1)$. Therefore, Lemma \ref{terrible} applies to $G$. Thus, $Q$ has exactly two (non-tame) orbits, say $\Omega_1$ and $\Omega_2$, and they are also the only short orbits of $G$. More precisely, \begin{equation} \label{eq1zi} \gamma-1=|Q|-(|\Omega_1|+|\Omega_2|). \end{equation} We may also observe that $G_P$ with $P\in \Omega_1$ contains a subgroup $V$ isomorphic to $U$. In fact, $|Q||U|=|G|=|G_P||\Omega_1|=|Q_P\rtimes V||\Omega_1|=|V||Q_P||\Omega_1|$ with a prime to $p$ subgroup $V$ fixing $P$, whence $|U|=|V|$. Since $V$ is cyclic the claims follows. We go on with the case where both $\Omega_1$ and $\Omega_2$ are nontrivial, that is, their lengths are at least $2$. Assume that $Q$ is non-abelian and look at the action of its center $Z(Q)$ on $\cX$. Since $Z(Q)$ is a nontrivial normal subgroup of $G$, arguing as before we get that the factor group $\cX/Z(Q)$ is rational, and hence the Galois cover $\cX|(\cX/Z(Q))$ ramifies at some points. In other words, there is a point $P\in \Omega_1$ (or $R\in \Omega_2$) such that some nontrivial subgroup $T$ of $Z(Q)$ fixes $P$ (or $Q$). Suppose that the former case occurs. Since $\Omega_1$ is a $Q$-orbit, $T$ fixes $\Omega_1$ pointwise. The group $G$ induces a permutation group on $\Omega_1$ and let $M_1$ be the kernel of this permutation representation. Obviously, $T$ is a nontrivial $p$-subgroup of $M_1$. Therefore $M$ contains some but not all elements from $Q$. Since both $M_1$ and $Q$ are normal subgroups of $G$, $N=M_1\cap Q$ is a nontrivial normal $p$-subgroup of $G$. From (ii), the quotient curve $\tilde{\cX}= \cX/N$ is rational, and hence the factor group $\tilde{G}=G/N$ is isomorphic to a subgroup of $PGL(2,\mathbb{K})$. Since $1\lvertneqq N\lvertneqq Q$, the order of $\tilde{G}$ is divisible by $p$. From the classification of subgroups of $PGL(2,\mathbb{K})$, see \cite{maddenevalentini1982}, $\tilde{G}=\tilde{Q}\rtimes \tilde{U}$ where $\tilde{Q}$ is an elementary abelian $p$-group of order $q$ and $\tilde{U}\cong UN/N\cong U$ with $|\tilde{U}|=|U|$ is a divisor of $q-1$. This shows that $Q$ acts on $\Omega_1$ as an abelian transitive permutation group. Obviously this holds true when $Q$ is abelian. Therefore, the action of $Q$ on $\Omega_1$ is sharply transitive. In terms of $1$-point stabilizers of $Q$ on $\Omega_1$, we have $Q_P=Q_{P'}$ for any $P,P'\in \Omega_1$. Moreover, $Q_P=N$, and hence $Q_P$ is a normal subgroup of $G$. Furthermore, since $\cX$ is an ordinary curve, $Q_P$ is an elementary abelian group by \cite[Theorem 2 (i)]{N} and \cite[Theorem 11.74 (iii)]{HKT}. The quotient curve $\cX/Q_P$ is rational and its automorphism group contains the factor group $Q/Q_P$. Hence, exactly one of the $Q_P$-orbits is preserved by $Q$. Since $\Omega_1$ is a $Q$-orbit consisting of fixed points of $Q_P$, $\Omega_2$ must be a $Q_P$-orbit. Similarly, if $Z(Q)\neq Q_P$, the factor group $Z(Q)Q_P/Q_P$ is an automorphism group of $\cX/Q_P$ and hence exactly one of the $Q_P$-orbits is preserved by $Z(Q)$. Either $Z(Q)$ fixes a point in $\Omega_1$ but then $Z(Q)=Q_P$, or $\Omega_2$ is a $Z(Q)$-orbit. This shows that either $Z(Q)=Q_P$ or $Z(G)$ acts transitively on $\Omega_2$. Two cases arise according as $Q_P$ is sharply transitive and faithful on $\Omega_2$ or some nontrivial element in $Q_P$ fixes $\Omega_2$ pointwise. If some nontrivial element in $Q_P$ fixes $\Omega_2$ pointwise then the kernel $M_2$ of the permutation representation of $H$ on $\Omega_2$ contains a nontrivial $p$-subgroup. Hence the above results extends from $\Omega_1$ to $\Omega_2$, and $Q_R$ is a normal subgroup of $Q$. If $Q_P$ is (sharply) transitive on $\Omega_2$ then the abelian group $Z(Q)Q_P$ acts on $\Omega_2$ as a sharply transitive permutation group, as well. Hence either $Z(Q)=Q_P$, or as before $M_2$ contains a nontrivial $p$-subgroup, and $Q_R$ is a normal subgroup of $Q$. In the former case, $Q=Q_PQ_R$ and $Q_R\cap Q_P=\{1\}$, and $Z(Q)=Q_P$ yields that \begin{equation} \label{eq4zi} Q=Q_P\times Q_R. \end{equation} This shows that $Q$ is abelian, and hence $|Q|\leq 4\gg+4$. Also, either $|Q_P|$ (or $|Q_R|$) is at most $\sqrt{4\gg+4}$. Since $\cX$ is an ordinary curve, the second ramification group $G_P^{(2)}$ at $P\in \Omega_1$ is trivial. For $G_P=Q_P\rtimes V$, \cite[Lemma 11.81]{HKT} gives $|U|=|V|\leq |Q_P|-1$. Hence $|U|<|Q_P|\leq \sqrt{|Q|}\leq \sqrt{4\gg+4}$ whence \begin{equation} \label{eq5zi} |G|=|U||Q|\leq 8 (\gg+1)^{3/2}. \end{equation} If $Q_R$ is a normal subgroup, take a point $R$ from $\Omega_2$, and look at the subgroup $Q_{P,R}$ of $Q_P$ fixing $R$. Actually, we prove that that either $Q_{P,R}=Q_P$ or $Q_{P,R}$ is trivial. Suppose that $Q_{P,R}\neq \{1\}$. Since $Q_{P,R}=Q_P\cap Q_R$ and both $Q_P$ and $Q_R$ are normal subgroups of $G$, them same holds for $Q_{P,R}$. By (ii), the quotient curve $\cX/Q_{P,R}$ is rational and hence its automorphism group $Q/Q_{P,R}$ fixes exactly one point. Furthermore, each point in $\Omega_2$ is totally ramified. Therefore, $Q_R=Q_{P,R}$, otherwise $Q_R/Q_{P,R}$ would fix any point lying under a point in $\Omega_1$ in the cover $\cX|(\cX/Q_{P,R})$. It turns out that either $Q_P=Q_R$ or $Q_P\cap Q_R=\{1\}$, whenever $P\in \Omega_1$ and $R\in \Omega_2$. In the former case, from the Deuring-Shafarevi\v{c} formula applied to $Q_P$, $$\gamma-1=-|Q_P|+|\Omega_1|(|Q_P|-1)+|\Omega_2|(|Q_{P}|-1)=-|Q_P|+|Q|-|\Omega_1|+|Q|-|\Omega_2|.$$ This together with (\ref{eq1zi}) give $Q=Q_P$, a contradiction. Therefore, the latter case must hold. Thus $Q=Q_P\times Q_R$ and $Q_P$ (and also $Q_R$) is an elementary abelian group since is isomorphic to a $p$-subgroup of $PGL(2,\mathbb{K})$. Also, $|Q_P|=|Q_R|=\sqrt{|Q|}$. Since $Q$ is abelian, this yields $|Q_P|\leq \sqrt{4\gg+4}$. Now, the argument used after (\ref{eq4zi}) can be employed to prove (\ref{eq5zi}). This ends the proof in the case where both $\Omega_1$ and $\Omega_2$ are nontrivial. Suppose next $\Omega_1=\{P\}$ and $|\Omega_2| \geq 2$. Then $G$ fixes $P$, and hence $G=Q \rtimes U$ with an elementary abelian $p$-group $Q$. Furthermore, $G$ has a permutation representation on $\Omega_2$ with kernel $K$. As $\Omega_2$ is a short orbit of $Q$, the stabilizer $Q_R$ of $R\in \Omega_2$ in $Q$ is nontrivial. Since $Q$ is abelian, this yields that $K$ is nontrivial, and hence it is a nontrivial elementary abelian normal subgroup of $G$. In other words, $Q$ is an $r$-dimensional vector space $V(r,p)$ over a finite field $\mathbb{F}_p$ with $|Q|=p^r$, the action of each nontrivial element of $U$ by conjugacy is a nontrivial automorphism of $V(r,p)$, and $K$ is a $K$-invariant subspace. By Maschke's theorem, see for instance \cite[Theorem 6.1]{MA}, $K$ has a complementary $U$-invariant subspace. Therefore, $Q$ has a subgroup $M$ such that $Q=K\times M$, and $M$ is a normal subgroup of $G$. Since $K\cap M=\{1\}$, and $\Omega_2$ is an orbit of $Q$, this yields $|M|=|\Omega_2|$. The factor group $G/M$ is an automorphism group of the quotient curve $\cX/M$, and $Q/M$ is a nontrivial $p$-subgroup of $G/M$ whereas $G/M$ fixes two points on $\cX/M$. Therefore the quotient curve $\cX/M$ is not rational since the $2$-point stabilizer in the representation of $PGL(2,\mathbb{K})$ as an automorphism group of the rational function field is a prime to $p$ (cyclic) group. We show that $\cX/M$ is neither elliptic. From the Deuring-Shafarevi\v{c} formula. $\gg(\cX)-1=\gamma(\cX)-1= -|Q| +1 + |\Omega_2|$, and so $\gg(\cX)$ is even. Since $M$ is a normal subgroup of odd order, $\gg(\cX)\equiv 0 \pmod 2$ yields that $\gg(\cX/M)\equiv 0 \pmod 2$. In particular, $\gg(\cX/M) \ne 1$. Therefore, $\gg(\cX/M) \geq 2$. At this point we may repeat our previous argument and prove $|G/M|>34(\gg(\cX/M)+1)^{3/2}$. Again, a contradiction to our choice of $\cX$ to be a minimal counterexample, which ends the proof in the case where just one of $\Omega_1$ and $\Omega_2$ is trivial. We are left with the case where both short orbits of $Q$ are trivial. Our goal is to prove a much stronger bound for this case, namely $|U|\leq 2$ whence \begin{equation} \label{eq10oct2016} |G|\leq 2(\gg(\cX)+1). \end{equation} We also show that if equality holds then $\cX$ is a hyperelliptic curve with equation \begin{equation} \label{eq010oct2016} f(U)=aT+b+cT^{-1},\,\,a,b,c\in \mathbb{K}^*, \end{equation} where $f(U)\in \mathbb{K}[U]$ is an additive polynomial of degree $|Q|$. Let $\Omega_1=\{P_1\}$ and $\Omega_2=\{P_2\}$. Then $Q$ has two fixed points $P_1$ and $P_2$ but no nontrivial element in $Q$ fixes a point of $\cX$ other than $P_1$ and $P_2$. From the Deuring-Shafarevi\v{c} formula \begin{equation} \label{eq4n} \gg(\cX)+1=\gamma(\cX)+1=|Q|. \end{equation} Therefore, $|U|\leq \gg(\cX)$. Actually, for our purpose, we need a stronger estimate, namely $|U|\le 2$. To prove the latter bound, we use some ideas from Nakajima's paper \cite{N}. regarding the Riemann-Roch spaces $\mathcal{L}(\mathbf{D})$ of certain divisors $\mathbf{D}$ of $\mathbb{K}(\cX)$. Our first step is to show \begin{enumerate} \item[(i)] $\dim_{\mathbb{K}} \mathcal{L}((|Q|-1)P_1)=1$, \item[(ii)] $\dim_{\mathbb{K}} \mathcal{L}((|Q|-1)P_1+P_2)\geq 2$. \end{enumerate} Let $\ell \geq 1$ be the smallest integer such that $\dim_{\mathbb{K}} \mathcal{L}(\ell P_1)=2$, and take $x \in \mathcal{L}(\ell P_1)$ with $v_{P_1}(x)=-\ell$. As $Q=Q_{P_1}$, the Riemann-Roch space $\mathcal{L}(\ell P_1)$ contains all $c_\sigma=\sigma(x)-x$ with $\sigma\in Q$. This yields $c_\sigma\in \mathbb{K}$ by $v_{P_1}(c_\sigma) \geq -\ell+1$ and our choice of $\ell$ to be minimal. Also, $Q=Q_{P_2}$ together with $v_{P_2}(x) \geq 0$ show $v_{P_2}(c_\sigma) \geq 1$. Therefore $c_\sigma =0$ for all $\sigma \in Q$, that is, $x$ is fixed by $Q$. From $\ell=[\mathbb{K}(\cX):\mathbb{K}(x)]=[\mathbb{K}:\mathbb{K}(\cX)^Q][\mathbb{K(\cX)}^Q:\mathbb{K}(x)]$ and $|Q|=[\mathbb{K}:\mathbb{K}(\cX)^Q]$, it turns out that $\ell$ is a multiple of $|Q|$. Thus $\ell>|Q|-1$ whence (i) follows. From the Riemann-Roch theorem, $\dim_{\mathbb{K}}\mathcal{L}((|Q|-1)P_1+P_2)\geq |Q|-g+1=2$ which proves (ii). Let $d \geq 1$ be the smallest integer such that $\dim_{\mathbb{K}} \mathcal{L}(dP_1+P_2)=2$. From (ii) \begin{equation} \label{in1} d \leq |Q|-1. \end{equation} Let $\alpha$ be a generator of the cyclic group $U$. Since $\alpha$ fixes both points $P_1$ and $P_2$, it acts on $\mathcal{L}(dP_1+P_2)$ as a $\mathbb{K}$-vector space automorphism $\bar{\alpha}$. If $\bar{\alpha}$ is trivial then $\alpha(u)=u$ for all $u\in\mathcal{L}(dP_1+P_2)$. Suppose that $\bar{\alpha}$ is nontrivial. Since $U$ is a prime to $p$ cyclic group, $\bar{\alpha}$ has two distinct eigenspaces, so that $\mathcal{L}(dP_1+P_2)=\mathbb{K}\oplus \mathbb{K}u$ where $u\in \mathcal{L}(dP_1+P_2)$ is an eigenvector of $\bar{\alpha}$ with eigenvalue $\xi\in \mathbb{K}^*$ so that $\bar{\alpha}(u)=\xi u$ with $\xi^{|U|}=1$. Therefore there is $u\in \mathcal{L}(dP_1+P_2)$ with $u\neq 0$ such that $\alpha(u)=\xi u$ with $\xi^{|U|}=1$. The pole divisor of $u$ is \begin{equation} \label{equ1} \Div(u)_\infty = dP_1+P_2. \end{equation} Since $Q=Q_{P_1}=Q_{P_2}$, the Riemann-Roch space $\mathcal{L}(dP_1+P_2)$ contains $\sigma(u)$ and hence it contains all $$\theta_\sigma=\sigma(u)-u,\,\, \sigma\in Q.$$ By our choice of $d$ to be minimal, this yields $\theta_\sigma\in \mathbb{K}$, and then defines the map $\theta$ from $Q$ into $\mathbb{K}$ that takes $\sigma$ to $\theta_\sigma$. More precisely, $\theta$ is a homomorphism from $Q$ into the additive group $(\mathbb{K},+)$ of $\mathbb{K}$ as the following computation shows: $$\theta_{\sigma_1\circ\sigma_2}=(\sigma_1\circ\sigma_2)(u)-u=\sigma_1(\sigma_2(u)-u+u)-u=\sigma_1(\theta_{\sigma_2})+\sigma_1(u)-u=\theta_{\sigma_2}+\theta_{\sigma_1}=\theta_{\sigma_1}+\theta_{\sigma_2}.$$ Also, $\theta$ is injective. In fact, if $\theta_{\sigma_0}=0$ for some $\sigma_0 \in Q \setminus \{1\}$, then $u$ is in the fixed field of $\sigma_0$, which is impossible since $v_{P_2}(u)=-1$ whereas $P_2$ is totally ramified in the cover $\cX|(\cX/\langle \sigma_p \rangle)$. The image $\theta(Q)$ of $\theta$ is an additive subgroup of $\mathbb{K}$ of order $|Q|$. The smallest subfield of $\mathbb{K}$ containing $\theta(Q)$ is a finite field $\mathbb{F}_{p^m}$ and hence $\theta(Q)$ can be viewed as a linear subspace of $\mathbb{F}_{p^m}$ considered as a vector space over $\mathbb{F}_p$. Therefore the polynomial \begin{equation} \label{eq210oct2016} f(U)=\prod_{\sigma \in Q} (U-\theta_\sigma) \end{equation} is a linearized polynomial over $\mathbb{F}_p$; see \cite[Section 4, Theorem 3.52]{LN}. In particular, $f(U)$ is an additive polynomial of degree $|Q|$; see also \cite[Chapter V, $\mathsection \ 5$]{Serre}. Also, $f(U)$ is separable as $\theta$ is injective. From (\ref{eq210oct2016}), the pole divisor of $f(u)\in \mathbb{K}(\cX)$ is \begin{equation} \label{eq310oct2016} \div(f(u))_\infty=|Q|(dP_1+P_2). \end{equation} For every $\sigma_0\in Q$, $$\sigma_0(f(u))=\prod_{\sigma\in Q} (\sigma_0(u)-\theta_{\sigma})=\prod_{\sigma\in Q}(u+\theta_{\sigma_0}-\theta_{\sigma})=\prod_{\sigma\in Q}(u-\theta_{\sigma\sigma_0^{-1}})=\prod_{\sigma\in Q}(u-\theta_{\sigma})=f(u).$$ Thus $f(u) \in \mathbb{K}(\cX)^Q$. Furthermore, from $\alpha\in N_G(Q)$, for every $\sigma\in Q$ there is $\sigma'\in Q$ such that $\alpha\sigma=\sigma'\alpha$. Therefore $$\alpha(f(u))=\prod_{\sigma\in Q}(\alpha(\sigma(u)-u))=\prod_{\sigma\in Q}(\alpha(\sigma(u))-\xi u)=\prod_{\sigma\in Q}(\sigma'(\alpha(u))-\xi u)=\prod_{\sigma\in Q}(\sigma'(\xi u)-\xi u)=\xi f(u).$$ This shows that if $R\in\cX$ is a zero of $f(u)$ then $\supp(\div(f(u)_0))$ contains the $U$-orbit of $R$ of length $|U|$. Actually, since $\sigma(f(u))=f(u)$ for $\sigma\in Q$, $\supp(\div(f(u)_0))$ contains the $G$-orbit of $R$ of length $|G|=|Q||U|$. This together with (\ref{eq310oct2016}) give \begin{equation} \label{eq410oct2016} |U|\big|(d+1). \end{equation} On the other hand, $\mathbb{K}(\cX)^Q$ is rational. Let $\bar{P_1}$ and $\bar{P_2}$ the points lying under $P_1$ and $P_2$, respectively, and let $\bar{R_1},\bar{R_2},\ldots \bar{R_k}$ with $k=(d+1)/|U|$ be the points lying under the zeros of $f(u)$ in the cover $\cX|(\cX/Q)$. We may represent $\mathbb{K}(\cX)^Q$ as the projective line $\mathbb{K}\cup \{\infty\}$ over $\mathbb{K}$ so that $\bar{P_1}=\infty$, $\bar{P_1}=0$ and $\bar{R}_i=t_i$ for $1\leq i \leq k$. Let $g(t)=t^d+t^{-1}+h(t)$ where $h(t)\in \mathbb{K}[t]$ is a polynomial of degree $k=(d+1)/|U|$ whose roots are $r_1,\ldots,r_k$. It turns out that $f(u),g(t)\in \mathbb{K}(\cX)$ have the same pole and zero divisors, and hence \begin{equation} \label{eq510oct2016} cf(u)=t^d+t^{-1}+h(t),\,\ c\in \mathbb{K}^*. \end{equation} We prove that $\mathbb{K}(\cX)=\mathbb{K}(u,t)$. From \cite{sullivan1975}, see also \cite[Remark 12.12]{HKT}, the polynomial $cTf(X)-T^{d+1}-1-h(T)T$ is irreducible, and the plane curve $\mathcal{C}$ has genus $\gg(\mathcal{C})=\ha (q-1)(d+1)$. Comparison with (\ref{eq4n}) shows $\mathbb{K}(\cX)=\mathbb{\mathcal{C}}$ and $d=1$ whence $|U|\leq 2$. If equality holds then $\deg\,h(T)=1$ and $\cX$ is a hyperelliptic curve with equation (\ref{eq010oct2016}). \end{proof} \subsection{Case II: $G$ contains no minimal normal $p$-subgroup} \label{CasoII} \begin{proposition} \label{caseII} Let $\cX$ be an ordinary algebraic curve of genus $\gg$ defined over a field $\mathbb{K}$ of odd characteristic $p>0$. If $G$ is a solvable subgroup of $\aut(\cX)$ with a minimal normal subgroup $N$ satisfying Case II, then $|G|\leq 34 (\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} From Proposition \ref{caseI}, $G$ contains no nontrivial normal $p$-subgroup. The factor group $\bar{G}=G/N$ is a subgroup of $\aut(\bar{\cX})$ where $\bar{\cX}=\cX/N$. Furthermore, $|N|\leq 4\gg(\cX)+4$ as $N$ is abelian; see \cite[Theorem 11.79]{HKT}. Arguing as in Section \ref{CasoI}, we see that $\bar{\cX}$ is either rational or elliptic, that is, $\gg(\cX)\ge 2$ is impossible. A detailed description of the arguments is given below. Assume that $\cX$ is a minimal counterexample with respect to the genus. Since $\cX$ is ordinary, any $p$-subgroup $S$ of $G$ is an elementary abelian group and it has a trivial second ramification group at any point $\cX$. The latter property remains true when $\cX$ is replaced by $\bar{\cX}$. To show this claim, take $\bar{P}\in \bar{\cX}$ and let $\bar{S}_{\bar{P}}$ the subgroup of the factor group $\bar{S}=SN/N$ fixing $\bar{P}$. Since $p\nmid |N|$ there is a point $P\in \cX$ lying over $\bar{P}$ which is fixed by $S$. Hence the stabilizer $S_P$ of $P$ in $S$ is a nontrivial normal subgroup of $G_P$. Since $N$ is a normal subgroup in $G$, so is $N_P$ in $G_P$. This yields that the product $N_PS_P$ is actually a direct product. Therefore $N_P$ is trivial, otherwise the second ramification group of $S$ in $P$ is nontrivial by a result of Serre; see \cite[Theorem 11.75]{HKT}. Actually, $N$ may be assumed to be the largest normal subgroup $N_1$ of $G$ whose order is prime to $p$. If the quotient curve $\cX_1=\cX/N_1$ is neither rational, nor elliptic then its $\mathbb{K}$-automorphism group $G_1=G/N_1$ has order bigger than $34(\gg(\cX_1)+1)^{3/2}$, by the Hurwitz genus formula applied to $N_1$. Since $G$ and hence $G_1$ is solvable, $G_1$ has a minimal normal $d$-subgroup where $d$ must be equal to $p$ by the choice of $N_1$ to be the largest normal, prime to $p$ subgroup of $G$. Take the largest normal $p$-subgroup $N_2$ of $G_1$. Observe that $N_2\lneqq G_1$, otherwise $G_1$ is an (elementary) abelian group of order bigger than $34(\gg(\cX_1)+1)^{3/2}$ contradicting the bound $4(\gg(\cX_1)+4)$; see \cite[Theorem 11.79]{HKT}. Now, define $\cX_2$ to be the quotient curve $\cX_1/N_2$. Since the second ramification group of $N_1$ at any point of $\cX_1$ is trivial, the Hurwitz genus formula together with the Deuring-Shafarevich formula give $\gg(\cX_1)-\gamma(\cX_1)=|N_2|(\gg(\cX_2)-\gamma(\cX_2))$. In particular, $\cX_2$ is neither ordinary or rational by the choice of $\cX$ to be a minimal counterexample. From the proof of Proposition \ref{caseI}, the case $\gg(\cX_2)=1$ cannot occur as $|G_1|>34(\gg(\cX_1)+1)^{3/2}$. Therefore, $\gg(\cX_2)\geq 2$ and $\gg(\cX_2)>\gamma(\cX_2)$ hold. The factor group $G_2=G_1/N_2$ is a $\mathbb{K}$-automorphism group of the quotient curve $\cX_2=\cX_1/N_2$, and it has a minimal normal $d$-subgroup with $d\neq p$, by the choice of $N_2$. Define $N_3$ to be the largest normal, prime to $p$, subgroup of $G_2$. Observe that $N_3$ must be a proper subgroup of $G_2$, otherwise $G_2$ itself would be a prime to $p$ subgroup of $\aut(\cX_2)$ of order bigger than $34(\gg(\cX_2)+1)^{3/2}$ contradicting the classical Hurwitz bound $84(\gg(\cX_2)-1)$. Therefore, there exists a (maximal) nontrivial normal $p$-subgroup $N_4$ in the factor group $G_3=G_2/N_3$. Now, the above argument remains valid whenever $G,N_1,G_1,N_2,\cX_1,\cX_2$ are replaced by $G_2,N_3,G_3,N_4,\cX_3,\cX_4$ where the quotient curves are $\cX_3=G_2/N_3$ and $\cX_4=G_3/N_4$. In particular, $\gg(\cX_4)\neq 1$ and $\gg(\cX_3)-\gamma(\cX_3)=|N_4|(\gg(\cX_4)-\gamma(\cX_4))$. Repeating the above argument a finite sharply decreasing sequence $\gg(\cX_1)>\gg(\cX_2)>\gg(\cX_3)>\gg(\cX_4),\ldots$ arises. If this sequence has $n+1$ members then $\gg(\cX_n)-\gamma(\cX_n)=|N_{n+1}|(\gg(\cX_{n+1})-\gamma(\cX_{n+1}))$ with $\gg(\cX_{n+1})=\gamma(\cX_{n+1})=0$. Therefore, for some (odd) index $m\leq n$, the curve $\cX_m$ for some $m\geq 1$ must be ordinary, a contradiction to choice of $\cX$ to be a minimal counterexample. First we investigate the elliptic case. Since $\gg(\cX)\geq 2$, the Hurwitz genus formula applied to $\bar{X}$ ensures that $N$ has a short orbit. Let $\Gamma$ be a short orbit of $G$ containing a short orbit of $N$. Since $N$ is a normal subgroup of $G$, $\Gamma$ is partitioned into short-orbits $\Sigma_1,\ldots,\Sigma_k$ of $N$ each of length $|\Sigma_1|$. Take a point $R_i$ from $\Sigma_i$ for $i=1,2,\ldots, k$, and set $\Sigma=\Sigma_1$ and $S=S_1$. With this notation, $|G|=|G_S||\Gamma|=|G_S| k|\Sigma|$, and the Hurwitz genus formula gives \begin{equation} \label{eq811oct2016} 2\gg(\cX)-2 \geq \sum_{i=1}^k |\Sigma_i|(|N_{S_i}|-1) = k |\Sigma| (|N_{S}|-1|)\geq + \ha k |\Sigma| |N_{S}|=\ha |G| \frac{|N_S|}{|G_S|}. \end{equation} Also, the factor group $G_{S}N/N$ is a subgroup of $\aut(\bar{\cX})$ fixing the the point of $\bar{\cX}$ lying under $S$ in the cover $\cX|\bar{\cX}$. From \cite[Theorem 11.94 (ii)]{HKT}, $$\frac{|G_{S}N|}{|N|} = \frac{|G_{S}|}{|G_{S} \cap N|} = \frac{|G_{S}|}{|N_{S}|}\leq 12.$$ This and (\ref{eq811oct2016}) yield $|G|\leq 48(\gg(\cX)-1)$, a contradiction with our hypothesis $34(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$. Therefore, $\bar{\cX}$ is rational. Thus $\bar{G}$ is isomorphic to a subgroup of $PGL(2,\mathbb{K})$. Since $p$ divides $|G|$ but $|N|$, $\bar{G}$ contains a nontrivial $p$-subgroup. From the classification of the finite subgroups of $PGL(2,\mathbb{K})$, see \cite{maddenevalentini1982}, either $p=3$ and $\bar{G}\cong \rm{Alt}_4, \rm{Sym}_4$, or $\bar{G}=\bar{Q}\rtimes \bar{C}$ where $\bar{Q}$ is a normal $p$-subgroup and its complement $\bar{C}$ is a cyclic prime to $p$ subgroup and $|\bar{C}|$ divides $|\bar{Q}|-1$. If $\bar{G}\cong \rm{Alt}_4, \rm{Sym}_4$ then $|\bar{G}|\leq 24$ whence $|G|\leq 24|N|\leq 96(\gg(\cX)+1)$ as $N$ is abelian. Comparison with our hypothesis $|G|\geq 34 (\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$ shows that $\gg(\cX)\leq 6$. For small genera we need a little more. If $|N|$ is prime then $|N|\leq 2\gg(\cX)+1$; see \cite[Theorem 11.108]{HKT}, and hence $|G|\leq 48(\gg(\cX)+1)$ which is inconsistent with $|G|\geq 34 (\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$. Otherwise, since $p=3$ and $|N|$ has order a power of prime distinct from $p$, the bound $|N|\leq 4(\gg(\cX)+1)$ with $\gg(\cX)\leq 6$ is only possible for $(\gg(\cX),|N|)\in\{(3,16),(4,16), (5,16),(6,16),(6,25)\}$. Comparison of $|G|\leq 24|N|$ with $|G|\geq 34 (\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$ rule out the latter three cases. Furthermore, since $N$ is an elementary abelian group of order $16$, $\gg(\cX)$ must be odd by Lemma \ref{GK61}. Finally, $\gg(\cX)=3, |N|=16,\, G/N\cong \rm{Sym}_4$ is impossible as Henn's bound $|G|\geq 8\gg(\cX)^3$ implies that $\cX$ has zero $p$-rank, see \cite[Theorem 11.127]{HKT}. Therefore, the case $\bar{G}=\bar{Q}\rtimes \bar{C}$ occurs. Also, $\bar{G}$ fixes a unique place $\bar{P} \in \bar{\cX}$. Let $\Delta$ be the $N$-orbits in $\cX$ lies over $\bar{P}$ in the cover $\cX|\bar{\cX}$. We prove that $\Delta$ is a long orbit of $N$. By absurd, the permutation representation of $G$ on $\Delta$ has a nontrivial $1$-point stabilizer containing a nontrivial subgroup $M$ of $N$. Since $N$ is abelian, $M$ is in the kernel. In particular, $M$ is a normal subgroup of $G$ contradicting our choice of $N$ to be minimal. Take a Sylow $p$-subgroup $Q$ of $G$ of order $|Q|=p^h$ with $h\geq 1$, and look at the action of $Q$ on $\Delta$. Since $|\Delta|=|N|$ is prime to $p$, $Q$ fixes a point $P\in \Delta$, that is, $Q=Q_P$. Since $\cX$ is an ordinary curve, $Q_P$ and hence $Q$ is elementary abelian; see \cite[Theorem 2 (i)]{N} or \cite[Theorem 11.74 (iii)]{HKT}. Therefore, $G_P=Q\rtimes U$ where $U$ is a prime to $p$ cyclic group. Thus \begin{equation} \label{ord1} |\bar{Q}||\bar{C}||N|=|\bar{G}||N|=|G|=|G_P||\Delta|=|Q||U||\Delta|=|Q||U||N|, \end{equation} whence $|Q|=|\bar{Q}|$ and $|U|=|\bar{C}|$. Consider the subgroup $H$ of $G$ generated by $G_P$ and $N$. Since $\Delta$ is a long $N$-orbit, $G_P \cap N =\{1\}$. As $N$ is normal in $H$ this implies that $H=N \rtimes G_P=N \rtimes (Q \rtimes U)$ and hence $|H|=|N||Q||U|$ which proves $G=H=N \rtimes (Q \rtimes U)$. Since $\bar{\cX}$ is rational and $\bar{P}$ is the unique fixed point of nontrivial elements of $\bar{Q}$, each $\bar{Q}$-orbit other than $\{\bar{P}\}$ is long. Furthermore, $\bar{C}$ fixes a point $\bar{R}$ other than $\bar{P}$ and no nontrivial element of $\bar{C}$ is fixes point distinct from $\bar{P}$ and $\bar{R}$. This shows that the $\bar{G}$-orbit $\bar{\Omega}_1$ of $\bar{R}$ has length $|Q|$. In terms of the action of $G$ on $\cX$, there exist as many as $|Q|$ orbits of $N$, say $\Delta_1 ,..., \Delta_{|Q|}$, whose union $\Lambda$ is a short $G$-orbit lying over $\bar{\Omega}_1$ in the cover $\cX|\bar{\cX}$. Obviously, if at least one of $\Delta_i$ is a short $N$-orbit then so all are. We show that this actually occur. Since the cover $\cX|\bar{\cX}$ ramifies, $N$ has some short orbits, and by absurd there exists a short $N$-orbit $\Sigma$ is not contained in $\Lambda$. Then $\Sigma$ and $\Lambda$ are disjoint. Let $\Gamma$ denote the (short) $G$-orbit containing $\Sigma$. Since $N$ is a normal subgroup of $G$, $\Gamma$ is partitioned into $N$-orbits, say $\Sigma=\Sigma_1,\ldots, \Sigma_k$, each of them of the same length $|\Sigma|$. Here $k=|Q||U|$ since the set of points of $\bar{\cX}$ lying under these $k$ short $N$-orbits is a long $\bar{G}$-orbit. Also, $|N|=|\Sigma_i||N_{R_i}|$ for $\le i \le k$ and $R_i\in \Sigma_i$. In particular, $|\Sigma_1|=\Sigma_i$ and $|N_{R_1}|=|B_{R_i}$. From the Hurwitz genus formula, $$2\gg(\cX)-2 \geq -2|N| + \sum_{i=1}^k |\Sigma_i|(|N_{R_i}|-1) =-2|N| + |Q||U||\Sigma_1|(|N_{R_1}|-1).$$ Since $N_{R_1}$ is nontrivial, $|N_{R_1}| -1 \geq \ha|N_{R_1}|$. Therefore, $$2\gg(\cX)-2 \geq -2|N| + \ha|Q||U||\Sigma_1||N_{R_1}|=-2|N|+\ha |Q||U||N|=|N|(\ha(|Q||U|-2)=\ha|N|(|Q||U|-4).$$ As $|Q||U|-4 \geq \ha |Q||U|$ by $|Q||U|\geq 4$, this gives $$2\gg(\cX)-2 \geq \qa |N||U||Q|=\qa |G|.$$ But this contradicts our hypothesis $|G|>34(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$. Therefore, the short orbits of $N$ are exactly $\Delta_1 ,..., \Delta_{|Q|}$. Take a point $S_i$ from $\Delta_i$ for $i=1,\ldots,|Q|$. Then $N_{S_1}$ and $N_{S_i}$ are conjugate in $G$, and hence $|N_{S_1}|=|N_{S_i}|$. From the Hurwitz genus formula applied to $N$, $$2\gg(\cX)-2=-2|N|+\sum_{i=1}^{|Q|} |\Delta_i|(|N_{S_i}|-1) )=-2|N|+|Q||\Delta_1|(|N_{S_1}|-1)\geq -2|N|+\ha|Q||\Delta_1||N_{S_1}|.$$ Since $|N|= |\Delta_1||N_{S_1}|$, this gives $ 2\gg(\cX)-2 \geq \ha|N|(|Q|-4)|$ whence $2\gg(\cX)-2\geq \qa |N||Q|$ provided that $|Q|\geq 5$. The missing case, $|Q|=3$, cannot actually occur since in this case $|\bar{C}|=|U|\leq |Q|-1= 2$, whence $|G|=|Q||U||N|\leq 6|N|\leq 24(\gg(\cX)+1)$, a contradiction with $|G|>34(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$. Thus \begin{equation} \label{eq611oct2016} |N||Q|\le 8(\gg(\cX)-1). \end{equation} Since $|N||U|<|N||Q|$, this also shows \begin{equation} \label{eq711oct2016} |N||U|<8(\gg(\cX)-1). \end{equation} Therefore, $$|G||N|=|N|^2|U||Q|<64(\gg(\cX)-1)^2.$$ Equations (\ref{eq611oct2016}) and (\ref{eq711oct2016}) together with our hypothesis $|G|\geq 34(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$ yield \begin{equation} \label{eq911oct2016} |N|<\frac{64}{34} \sqrt{\gg(\cX)-1}. \end{equation} From (\ref{eq911oct2016}) and $|G|=|N||Q||U|\geq 34(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$ we obtain $$|Q||U|>\frac{34^2}{64}(\gg(\cX)-1)> 18(\gg(\cX)-1)$$ which shows that Lemma \ref{terrible} applies to the subgroup $Q\rtimes U$ of $\aut(\cX)$. With the notation in Lemma \ref{terrible}, this gives that $Q \rtimes U$ and $Q$ have the same two short orbits, $\Omega_1=\{P\}$ and $\Omega_2$. In the cover $\cX/\bar{\cX}$, the point $\bar{P}\in\bar{\cX}$ lying under $P$ is fixed by $Q$. We prove that $\Omega_2$ is a subset of the $N$-orbit $\Delta$ containing $P$. For this purpose, it suffices to show that for any point $R\in\Omega_2$, the point $\bar{R}\in \bar{\cX}$ lying under $R$ in the cover $\cX|\bar{\cX}$ coincides with $\bar{P}$. Since $\Omega_2$ is a $Q$-short orbit, the stabilizer $Q_R$ is nontrivial, and hence $\bar{Q}$ fixes $\bar{R}$. Since $\bar{\cX}$ is rational, this yields $\bar{P}=\bar{R}$. Therefore, $\Omega_2\cup \{P\}$ is contained in $\Delta$, and either $\Delta=\Omega_2\cup \{P\}$ or $\Delta$ contains a long $Q$-orbit. In the latter case, $|U|<|Q|<|N|$, and hence $$|G|^2=|N||Q||N|U||Q||U|<|N||Q||N||U||N|^2\le \frac{64^2}{34} (\gg(\cX)-1)^3$$ whence $|G|< 34(\gg(\cX)+1)^{3/2}$, a contradiction with our hypothesis. Otherwise $|N|=|\Delta|=1+|\Omega_2|$. In particular, $|N|$ is even, and hence it is a power of $2$. Also, from the Deuring-Shafarevi\v{c} Formula, $\gg(\cX)-1=\gamma(\cX)-1 = -|Q|+1+|\Omega_2|$ where $|\Omega_2|\geq 1$ is a power of $p$. This implies that $\gg(\cX)$ is also even. Since $N$ is an elementary abelian $2$-group, Lemma \ref{GK61} yields that either $|N|=2$ or $|N|=4$. If $|N|=2$ then $\Omega_2$ consists of a unique point $R$ and $Q\rtimes U$ fixes both points $P$ and $R$. Since $\Delta=\{P,R\}$, and $\Delta$ is a $G$-orbit, the stabilizer $G_{P,R}$ is an index $2$ (normal) subgroup of $G$. On the other hand, $G_{P,R}=Q\rtimes U$ and hence $Q$ is the unique Sylow $p$-subgroup of $Q\rtimes U$. Thus $Q$ is a characteristic subgroup of the normal subgroup $G_{P,R}$ of $G$. But then $Q$ is a normal subgroup of $G$, a contradiction with our hypothesis. If $|N|=4$ then $|\Delta|=4$ and $p=3$. The permutation representation of $G$ of degree $4$ on $\Delta$ contains a $4$-cycle induced by $N$ but also a $3$-cycle induced by $Q$. Hence if $K=\ker$ then $G/K\cong {\rm{Sym}}_4$. On the other hand, since both $N$ and $\Ker$ are normal subgroups of $G$, their product $NK$ is normal, as well. Hence $NK/K$ is a normal subgroup of $G/K$, but this contradicts $G/K\cong {\rm{Sym}}_4$. \end{proof}

Introduction ============ Recently, the design and implementation of Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed C--H bond functionalization has led to a diverse array of structural motifs, including many that are present in drugs and natural products.[@cit1]--[@cit3] In particular, Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed C--H bond additions to polarized π-bonds[@cit3] provides convergent entry to drug relevant amines,[@cit4] amides,[@cit5] alcohols,[@cit6] and oxygen or nitrogen heterocycles.[@cit7] While a variety of methods have been developed for direct C(sp^2^)--H bond addition into polarized π-bonds, cascade addition sequences would offer an attractive strategy for rapidly building complexity into organic structures. To date, Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed cascade C--H bond functionalization has primarily been reported for 5-membered ring synthesis by additions to an alkene or alkyne followed by cyclization upon the directing group for C--H bond activation.[@cit8] However, to the best of our knowledge, Lin and coworkers have reported the only example of Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed C--H bond cascade addition to a π-bond and an electrophile other than the directing group.[@cit9] In their study, Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed C--H bond addition to enones tethered to an alkyne proceeded to give substituted tetrahydrofurans ([Fig. 1A](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}). Herein, we demonstrate the Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed cascade addition of a C--H bond across alkene and carbonyl π-bonds. When the two electrophiles are tethered together, cyclic β-hydroxy ketone products incorporating three contiguous stereocenters are produced with high diastereoselectivity ([Fig. 1B](#fig1){ref-type="fig"}).[@cit10],[@cit11] ![Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed cascade C--H bond addition across two different π-bonds.](c5sc04138d-f1){#fig1} Results and discussion ====================== For our initial exploration of this reaction we employed 2-phenylpyridine and the enone tethered aldehyde **2a** based on successful Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed hydroarylation of enones ([Table 1](#tab1){ref-type="table"}).[@cit12] After considerable optimization, we found that β-hydroxy ketone **3a** could be obtained in high yield as a single diastereomer with only 2.5 mol% of Rh precatalyst and 10 mol% of AgSbF~6~ (entry 1). A 3 : 2 dioxane/H~2~O reaction solvent at 50 °C was found to be effective. Lower conversion was observed at 30 °C (entry 2). Solvents commonly used in Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed C--H functionalization such as dichloroethane (entry 3) and dioxane (entry 4) provided lower yields, and reducing the amount of H~2~O also was detrimental (entry 5). In contrast, acetic acid as the solvent proved to be optimal,[@cit7a],[@cit12a] giving a near quantitative yield of the desired β-hydroxy ketone **3a** (entry 6). Additionally, **3a** was obtained in 57% yield when employing only the rhodium dimer \[Cp\*RhCl~2~\]~2~ in the absence of a silver halide abstractor demonstrating that a pre-formed cationic Rh catalyst is not required for this transformation (entry 7). However, when rhodium was excluded, the desired product **3a** was not obtained (entries 8 and 9). ###### Optimization conditions for the Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed cascade addition/cyclization reaction[^*a*^](#tab1fna){ref-type="fn"} [^*b*^](#tab1fnb){ref-type="fn"} {#ugr1} ------------------------------- ------------ ---------------------- ---- ---- 1 (2.5)/(10) 3 : 2 Dioxane/H~2~O 50 92 2 (2.5)/(10) 3 : 2 Dioxane/H~2~O 30 67 3 (2.5)/(10) DCE 50 58 4 (2.5)/(10) Dioxane 50 35 5 (2.5)/(10) 95 : 5 Dioxane/H~2~O 50 61 6 (2.5)/(10) Acetic acid 50 99 7 (2.5)/(0) Acetic acid 50 57 8 (0)/(10) Acetic acid 50 0 9 None Acetic acid 50 0 ^*a*^Conditions: **1a** (2.0 equiv.), **2a** (1.0 equiv.) using \[Cp\*RhCl~2~\]~2~ and AgSbF~6~ for 20 h (0.2 M). ^*b*^Determined by NMR analysis relative to 1,3,5-trimethoxybenzene as an external standard. After identifying optimal conditions for the formation of β-hydroxy ketone **3a**, we next explored the scope of the tethered electrophile substrate ([Table 2](#tab2){ref-type="table"}). Pure **3a** was isolated in near quantitative yield from the parent substrate **2a**. Substrates with electron-donating and withdrawing substituents on the phenyl ring also afforded β-hydroxy ketones **3b**, **3c**, and **3d** in high yield. X-ray structural analysis of **3b** provided rigorous confirmation of product stereochemistry. An alkyl enone, which is a weaker acceptor than the corresponding aryl enone substrates, proved to be effective giving **3e** with only a modest reduction in yield. Introduction of oxygen and nitrogen heteroatoms into the tether were also acceptable substitutions, and provided the substituted tetrahydropyran **3f** and piperidine **3g**, respectively. Additionally, the use of an aromatic tether was well-tolerated and gave indane **3h** in good yield. However, for this substrate, 3 : 2 dioxane/H~2~O as solvent, a higher catalyst loading, and a lower reaction temperature were employed to minimize β-hydroxyl group elimination, which is particularly facile for β-hydroxy ketone **3h**. ###### Scope for tethered electrophile partner[^*a*^](#tab2fna){ref-type="fn"} [^*b*^](#tab2fnb){ref-type="fn"} {#ugr2} ------------------------------- {#ugr3} ^*a*^Conditions: **1a** (2.0 equiv.), **2** (1.0 equiv.), at 0.2 M. ^*b*^Isolated yield after silica gel chromatography. ^*c*^Reaction conducted at 40 °C. ^*d*^Reaction conducted in 95 : 5 AcOH/H~2~O (0.2 M). ^*e*^Reaction conducted using 10 mol% \[RhCp\*Cl~2~\]~2~ and 20 mol% AgSbF~6~ in 3 : 2 dioxane/H~2~O (0.2 M). We next examined the scope for different C--H bond coupling partners ([Table 3](#tab3){ref-type="table"}). Derivatives of 2-phenylpyridine with electron-donating and withdrawing substituents also provided high yields of the corresponding β-hydroxy ketones **3i**, **3j**, and **3k**. Notably, the applicability of alkenyl C(sp^2^--H) functionalization to this transformation was demonstrated with 2-cyclohexenylpyridine, which gave **3l** in good yield. Deviations from the pyridyl directing group are also noteworthy. The pyrazole and pyrimidine heterocycles were quite efficient in forming products **3m** and **3n**. *N*-Pyrimidylindole provided **3o**, highlighting C--H functionalization on a heteroaryl ring. In addition, the *N*-methoxybenzamide and *O*-methyl oxime directing groups provided access to the products **3p** and **3q** in moderate yields. For these substrates, higher yields were obtained with 3 : 2 dioxane/H~2~O rather than acetic acid as solvent. ###### Scope for C--H bond partner[^*a*^](#tab3fna){ref-type="fn"} [^*b*^](#tab3fnb){ref-type="fn"} {#ugr4} ------------------------------- {#ugr5} ^*a*^Conditions: **1** (2.0 equiv.), **2a** (1.0 equiv.) at 0.2 M. ^*b*^Isolated yield after silica gel chromatography. ^*c*^Reaction conducted in 3 : 2 dioxane/H~2~O (0.5 M). ^*d*^Reaction conducted in 3 : 2 dioxane/H~2~O (0.2 M). A mechanism for the Rh-catalyzed cascade C--H bond addition/aldol reaction is depicted in [Scheme 1](#sch1){ref-type="fig"}. The first step of this process proceeds *via* concerted metalation/deprotonation of **1** to generate rhodacycle **4**, which has previously been proposed as an intermediate in other Rh-catalyzed C--H functionalization reactions.[@cit3],[@cit13] Coordination of the enone π-bond provides **5**, which undergoes conjugate addition to give rhodium enolate **6**. The rhodium enolate **6** can then undergo an intramolecular aldol reaction with the tethered aldehyde to form rhodium alkoxide **7**.[@cit14] Coordination of another equivalent of **1** to the Rh--alkoxide complex then provides **8**, which undergoes concerted metalation/deprotonation to release the alcohol product **3** and regenerate the active rhodium species **4**.[@cit15] {#sch1} To ascertain whether or not cyclization upon the aldehyde carbonyl after enone addition proceeds *via* the proposed Rh-enolate intermediate **6** ([Scheme 1](#sch1){ref-type="fig"}), the independently prepared acyclic enone addition product **9a** was subjected to the reaction conditions with and without the cationic rhodium catalyst ([Table 4](#tab4){ref-type="table"}). With dioxane/H~2~O as the solvent (entries 1 and 2), a low yield of β-hydroxy ketone **3a** was obtained even in the presence of the Rh precatalyst and AgSbF~6~ (entry 1). In addition, whether or not Rh was added, complete consumption of **9a** was observed, presumably as a result of selective formation of enolates or enols from the more acidic aldehyde functionality followed by unproductive side-reactions. These results are consistent with aldol cyclization proceeding *via* the Rh-enolate generated upon enone addition. When acetic acid was used as the solvent, a moderate yield of **3a** was obtained suggesting that acetic acid can mediate this cyclization step, although once again decomposition pathways competed with the desired cyclization pathway (entries 3 and 4). ###### Control studies on reaction intermediate **9a**[^*a*^](#tab4fna){ref-type="fn"} {#ugr6} ------------------------------- ------------ --------------------- ---- ----- 1 (2.5)/(10) 3 : 2 Dioxane/H~2~O 11 1 2 None 3 : 2 Dioxane/H~2~O 12 1 3 (2.5)/(10) Acetic acid 44 1 4 None Acetic acid 45 \<1 ^*a*^Yield determined by NMR analysis relative to 1,3,5-trimethoxybenzene as an external standard. C--H bond addition to generate a rhodium-enolate intermediate was rigorously established using the simplified enone substrate phenyl vinyl ketone ([Fig. 2](#fig2){ref-type="fig"}). To facilitate crystallization of the Rh-enolate, tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl)borate was employed as the counterion with DCE as the solvent, which for the cascade reaction is only slightly less effective than acetic acid or dioxane/water as solvent, *vide infra* (see **3r** in [Table 5](#tab5){ref-type="table"}). After only 30 min at rt, rhodacycle **10** was isolated in very high yield. The X-ray structure of **10** shows a coordinatively saturated Rh([iii]{.smallcaps}) complex with interatomic distances consistent with an η^3^-bound enolate. Although rhodium enolates have been proposed as intermediates for a number of transformations,[@cit16] very few X-ray structures have been reported.[@cit17] To our knowledge, the only published example of a Cp\*Rh([iii]{.smallcaps}) enolate is for a neutral complex with an η^1^ C-bound enolate.[@cit17a] ![Preparation, isolation and X-ray structural characterization of a cationic Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-enolate. The B(C~6~F~5~)~4~ ion has been omitted from the X-ray structure for clarity.](c5sc04138d-f2){#fig2} ###### Three-component coupling reaction[^*a*^](#tab5fna){ref-type="fn"} [^*b*^](#tab5fnb){ref-type="fn"} {#ugr7} ------------------------------- {#ugr8} ^*a*^Conditions: **1** (1.0 equiv.), **2r** (1.1 equiv.), and **11** (2.0 equiv.) at 2.0 M. ^*b*^Isolated yield after silica gel chromatography. ^*c*^Reaction conducted at 40 °C. ^*d*^Reaction conducted in DCE. ^*e*^Reaction conducted at 50 °C. ^*f*^Reaction conducted in DCE using crushed 3 Å molecular sieves. The potential for performing an intermolecular three-component C--H activation/addition/aldol reaction cascade was also evaluated ([Table 5](#tab5){ref-type="table"}). Several different directing groups provided three-component cascade addition products using enone **2r** along with either an activated aldehyde or imine. Coupling 2-phenylpyridine and *N*-phenyl pyrazole with enone **2r** and ethyl glyoxylate gave products **3r** and **3s** in good yields, respectively. Moreover, the synthetically more versatile secondary and tertiary amide directing groups provided products **3t** and **3u** in moderate to good yields. In addition, three-component coupling with the *N*-tosyl imine derived from ethyl glyoxylate efficiently provided amine **3v**, though the use of DCE as solvent was necessary to minimize the competitive imine hydrolysis that occurred in acetic acid. The complete selectivity for initial C--H bond addition to the enone rather than the aldehyde is an interesting feature of this reaction. This outcome might result from kinetic control with C--H bond addition to the enone occurring much faster than to the aldehyde. Alternatively, thermodynamic control might be operative because C(sp^2^)--H bond addition to aldehydes is known to be reversible,[@cit18] although C--H bond addition products are favored for destabilized aldehydes such as ethyl glyoxylate.[@cit6f] Conclusions =========== In summary, a Rh([iii]{.smallcaps})-catalyzed C--H bond addition/aldol cyclization cascade has been developed and represents the first C--H bond addition across an alkene π-bond and a carbonyl. This robust transformation can be carried out under mild conditions and for tethered substrates generates three contiguous stereocenters with high diastereoselectivity. An intermolecular three-component C--H bond addition/aldol reaction cascade has also been demonstrated. Preliminary mechanistic studies also provide the first X-ray structural characterization of a cationic Cp\*Rh([i]{.smallcaps}[ii]{.smallcaps}) enolate. In continuing efforts we are broadening the scope of this class of cascade reactions to include different tethered electrophilic species. We are also actively investigating stereoselective intermolecular three-component reactions with different carbon--carbon π-bonds and carbonyl/imine electrophiles. Supplementary Material ====================== Supplementary information ###### Click here for additional data file. Crystal structure data ###### Click here for additional data file. This work was supported by the NIH (GM069559). We gratefully acknowledge Dr Brandon Mercado (Yale University) for solving the crystal structure of **3b** and **10**. [^1]: †Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC [1413993](1413993) for **3b** and [1431932](1431932) for **10**. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: [10.1039/c5sc04138d](10.1039/c5sc04138d)