And when the moderate silent majorities take ownership of their own futures, we win.  When they won’t, when we want them to compromise more than they do, we lose.  The locals sense they have us over a barrel, so they exploit our naïve goodwill and presence to loot their countries and to defeat their internal foes. 

That’s how I see Afghanistan today.  I see no moderate spark.  I see our secretary of state pleading with President Hamid Karzai to re-do an election that he blatantly stole.  I also see us begging Israelis to stop building more crazy settlements or Palestinians to come to negotiations.  It is time to stop subsidizing their nonsense.  Let them all start paying retail for their extremism, not wholesale.  Then you’ll see movement. 

What if we shrink our presence in Afghanistan?  Won’t Al Qaeda return, the Taliban be energized and Pakistan collapse?  Maybe.  Maybe not.  This gets to my second principle: In the Middle East, all politics  everything that matters  happens the morning after the morning after.  Be patient.  Yes, the morning after we shrink down in Afghanistan, the Taliban will celebrate, Pakistan will quake and bin Laden will issue an exultant video. 

And the morning after the morning after, the Taliban factions will start fighting each other, the Pakistani Army will have to destroy their Taliban, or be destroyed by them, Afghanistan’s warlords will carve up the country, and, if bin Laden comes out of his cave, he’ll get zapped by a drone. 

My last guiding principle: We are the world.  A strong, healthy and self-confident America is what holds the world together and on a decent path.  A weak America would be a disaster for us and the world.  China, Russia and Al Qaeda all love the idea of America doing a long, slow bleed in Afghanistan.  I don’t. 

The U.S. military has given its assessment.  It said that stabilizing Afghanistan and removing it as a threat requires rebuilding that whole country.  Unfortunately, that is a 20-year project at best, and we can’t afford it.  So our political leadership needs to insist on a strategy that will get the most security for less money and less presence.  We simply don’t have the surplus we had when we started the war on terrorism after 9/11  and we desperately need nation-building at home.  We have to be smarter.  Let’s finish Iraq, because a decent outcome there really could positively impact the whole Arab-Muslim world, and limit our exposure elsewhere.  Iraq matters. 

Yes, shrinking down in Afghanistan will create new threats, but expanding there will, too.  I’d rather deal with the new threats with a stronger America.