id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00407v1 | SHADE: Semantic Hypernym Annotator for Domain-specific Entities -- DnD Domain Use Case | 2024-06-29T11:21:40 | 2024-06-29T11:21:40 | Akila Peiris, Nisansa de Silva | cs.CE | cs.CE, cs.CL | Manual data annotation is an important NLP task but one that takes
considerable amount of resources and effort. In spite of the costs, labeling
and categorizing entities is essential for NLP tasks such as semantic
evaluation. Even though annotation can be done by non-experts in most cases,
due to the fact that this requires human labor, the process is costly. Another
major challenge encountered in data annotation is maintaining the annotation
consistency. Annotation efforts are typically carried out by teams of multiple
annotators. The annotations need to maintain the consistency in relation to
both the domain truth and annotation format while reducing human errors.
Annotating a specialized domain that deviates significantly from the general
domain, such as fantasy literature, will see a lot of human error and annotator
disagreement. So it is vital that proper guidelines and error reduction
mechanisms are enforced. One such way to enforce these constraints is using a
specialized application. Such an app can ensure that the notations are
consistent, and the labels can be pre-defined or restricted reducing the room
for errors. In this paper, we present SHADE, an annotation software that can be
used to annotate entities in the high fantasy literature domain. Specifically
in Dungeons and Dragons lore extracted from the Forgotten Realms Fandom Wiki. | [
0.0390508994,
-0.0086130006,
-0.0131748458,
0.0713322386,
0.0056300159,
0.0122209955,
0.0054864236,
-0.016317172,
-0.0066523966,
-0.0833737552,
0.0193053931,
0.0306341406,
0.0264817532,
-0.0440312214,
0.0068143969,
-0.0482322127,
0.0431185663,
-0.0168419406,
0.0032080449,
0.019037107,
0.0183112044,
0.0513823144,
-0.0362284444,
0.0499452762,
-0.0489980988,
-0.0659279153,
-0.0139828352,
0.0098145967,
0.0251910128,
-0.0734913498,
0.0054785563,
0.0094156694,
-0.0074580233,
0.0616779663,
0.0000018665,
-0.0716142207,
-0.0158262718,
0.0235027075,
-0.0096108383,
0.0021630786,
-0.0267635565,
0.0105750896,
0.0024267025,
-0.0556792654,
0.0307928286,
-0.0268160198,
0.0810566097,
-0.0006175245,
0.0715532377,
0.0165317748,
-0.0025622349,
-0.0180935916,
0.0034635938,
0.0157098416,
0.0135017456,
-0.0120000122,
-0.0100154234,
0.0644786134,
0.007758067,
-0.0084487144,
0.02311657,
0.0372883901,
-0.0464649238,
0.0090055913,
0.0101813087,
-0.0252528135,
-0.0222858656,
0.0004789243,
-0.0000546249,
0.0433263555,
0.0537062287,
0.0018195496,
0.0032858532,
0.0089494158,
-0.0298056081,
0.0575434528,
0.0046289847,
0.003196147,
-0.0300520211,
-0.0286291018,
0.0405533165,
0.0120411571,
0.0367386304,
0.0053539234,
-0.0081169335,
0.051400356,
0.0182636939,
0.0004093834,
-0.0356367268,
0.0074626235,
-0.0420776457,
-0.0854556635,
-0.0003052437,
0.0253064428,
-0.0171090607,
0.0137389386,
-0.0290321503,
-0.0297777187,
0.0549162813,
-0.0184626207,
-0.008495301,
0.0190759208,
-0.0015938197,
0.034299247,
0.0399537608,
-0.018847635,
0.0562573224,
-0.0203560982,
0.042577479,
0.0005629222,
-0.0274363719,
-0.0129379118,
-0.0735530108,
0.0308307,
-0.022836782,
0.0154755758,
-0.0269366335,
-0.0183910392,
-0.0288560949,
0.058406543,
0.033075776,
-0.0480491482,
-0.0214303862,
0.0218725391,
-0.0669779778,
-0.0233668294,
-0.0330303349,
0.0249432661,
-0.0224053934,
-0.0094076041,
0.029309541,
0.0081888139,
0.0318015218,
-0.023755243,
-0.0060400846,
0.1194307208,
0.0659100413,
-0.0025158476,
-0.0471752211,
-0.0748748332,
0.0250525959,
0.0037999332,
-0.0436375625,
-0.0647480339,
-0.0139672561,
-0.0117974998,
0.048505567,
-0.0351262204,
0.0244008601,
0.0098239202,
0.0084480485,
0.0762204081,
-0.1290899515,
-0.0076260879,
0.032379292,
-0.0100160623,
-0.0473224632,
0.0176433455,
0.085971877,
-0.031037597,
0.0503442213,
0.0183625948,
-0.0104781128,
0.0202027149,
-0.0507088713,
-0.0491454713,
0.0058762715,
-0.0281036403,
-0.0102889491,
0.0451201163,
-0.040469937,
0.0312938355,
-0.0340082943,
-0.0049964539,
0.0275676791,
0.0474349372,
0.0615766943,
0.0133682964,
0.066324763,
0.0211941563,
0.008229496,
-0.0174031872,
-0.0309623759,
0.0002571033,
0.0356405526,
0.0058225705,
-0.0270778127,
0.0092378734,
0.0447526686,
-0.0316740237,
-0.0517566055,
-0.0022946936,
-0.0260791704,
-0.015504986,
0.0229481421,
0.0042593922,
0.0268445313,
0.0641212389,
0.045498278,
-0.0194612816,
0.0208237804,
0.0408331901,
0.0283427723,
0.0891531855,
0.0351893567,
-0.0675375164,
-0.0457783677,
-0.0341685824,
-0.0191035159,
0.0429362357,
-0.0037494774,
-0.072784476,
0.0258046389,
-0.0185136944,
-0.0009207258,
-0.0265618339,
0.0099334512,
0.0290727243,
-0.0373278819,
0.0085799471,
0.002122836,
-0.0308292918,
-0.0447812378,
0.0226364173,
-0.0103743151,
-0.0354616232,
-0.0794677958,
0.0235276762,
-0.0356644206,
0.056326665,
-0.0384618379,
-0.0092792967,
0.008480886,
-0.0195675846,
-0.0164865367,
-0.0141186584,
0.0378822088,
0.0143347392,
0.0843662992,
-0.064949505,
-0.0038101017,
-0.047614187,
0.021486979,
-0.0249541551,
-0.0384484567,
-0.0134435389,
0.0320703015,
-0.002125557,
0.0100065107,
0.0098231798,
-0.0287019946,
-0.0444665067,
0.0345329046,
0.0332875811,
0.0218974035,
-0.0589681566,
-0.0244703349,
0.0387192108,
0.020244658,
-0.0340527147,
0.0030441582,
0.0124904448,
0.0269474909,
0.0121949352,
-0.0214507896,
-0.0065310681,
0.0098476205,
-0.0150472075,
0.0275662374,
0.0174543299,
0.0316190012,
-0.0178767256,
0.0046227258,
-0.0248697754,
0.005900979,
-0.0014051248,
0.0110139251,
-0.0405713692,
0.009157002,
0.0479944125,
0.026796259,
-0.0208271481,
0.0067056273,
0.0242272802,
-0.0286496058,
0.0374926105,
0.0337422937,
-0.0276333876,
-0.0399151109,
-0.0264350493,
-0.09799698,
-0.0014265215,
0.0465925708,
0.0067060473,
0.0290243812,
0.0065204203,
0.0006662543,
-0.0532049686,
-0.0331060216,
0.0161477029,
0.0536780134,
-0.0404460616,
-0.0186869334,
-0.0225692932,
0.038465254,
0.0198015142,
0.0244156774,
-0.000662233,
0.0253122188,
0.0626439154,
-0.0318449922,
-0.0037361498,
-0.0209064949,
0.0527714416,
-0.0240449179,
0.015735615,
0.0067343987,
-0.0286533702,
0.0079134861,
0.0523762964,
0.0100293085,
0.0188630689,
0.0591262169,
-0.0375523008,
0.0253304895,
-0.0012455042,
-0.0059582847,
-0.0374697298,
0.0402831919,
-0.0528342091,
0.0240730885,
0.0601198599,
-0.0545766503,
0.0098278597,
0.0517028235,
0.0837417841,
-0.0045796032,
0.0530382246,
-0.0391729251,
0.0047131297,
-0.015827952,
0.0305093415,
0.0089885546,
0.0118067767,
-0.0587160699,
-0.0153132714,
-0.0209254976,
-0.0055037206,
0.0087118549,
0.0193880126,
-0.0399019308,
0.0259945057,
0.0441666394,
-0.0184048321,
-0.0141675323,
-0.0090821236,
0.0043735434,
0.0057443827,
-0.0019720139,
0.0194740482,
0.016923314,
0.0348102115,
-0.0899882019,
-0.050883282,
-0.0098398281,
-0.0039954227,
0.014290533,
-0.0973152816,
-0.0607423745,
-0.0226503704,
-0.004291262,
-0.0824922696,
0.0414763317,
0.0790550038,
0.0468924008,
-0.0098237591,
0.0385614671,
0.0104454681,
-0.0043213894,
0.0497830622,
-0.0288754776,
-0.1695494652,
0.0013283319,
-0.0077527347,
0.0326968133,
0.0138541637,
-0.0705151707,
0.0140569843,
-0.0346988067,
-0.0146419611,
-0.0090229688,
-0.0310550146,
0.0111604081,
-0.0082848128,
0.0065995771,
-0.0245306473,
-0.0252948832,
-0.0371651314,
0.0221434943,
0.014972399,
0.010456685,
-0.0170414541,
-0.0059238179,
-0.0083615687,
-0.0746802539,
0.0538489036,
0.0336721949,
0.0624104813,
0.0352823958,
-0.0323617496,
-0.0519709848,
0.0099466033,
-0.0192100424,
-0.0103776492,
0.0423578657,
-0.0249084197,
-0.0121773314,
-0.0113778431,
-0.018095348,
-0.0112037016,
-0.0614076816,
0.0110729812,
0.0577916428,
0.0193337835,
0.0379239284,
-0.017898256,
-0.0196201596,
0.0458358377,
0.0559792183,
-0.0037681495,
0.0027278226,
-0.012012748,
-0.0420531519,
0.0135769537,
-0.0143672721,
-0.0352138355,
0.0064164125,
-0.050474301,
0.0040295338,
-0.0782397687,
-0.055358436,
0.0448870175,
0.0552003831,
0.0640926734,
0.0223299637,
-0.0031532592,
0.0169128943,
-0.0253327079,
0.0157037284,
-0.024329301,
-0.0027656178,
0.0261778552,
-0.0246840082,
0.0381241702,
0.0044186995,
0.0187609028,
0.037936572,
-0.0103837932,
-0.0142975971,
0.0106877005,
0.0071053635,
0.0239970442,
0.017984679,
-0.0235112626,
-0.0472696126,
-0.0389634781,
0.0068728002,
-0.0610955916,
-0.0255288724,
-0.0138142994,
0.056971442,
-0.0100059742,
0.0239792112,
-0.042489212,
0.0289568137,
-0.0434166677,
0.0448273309,
-0.0141292354,
-0.0339672714,
0.0064643272,
0.0114599206,
0.0078729754,
-0.0731990337,
0.0007804389,
0.0005998107,
0.0047948738,
-0.0219380111,
-0.0596679375,
0.0043290318,
0.0219980255,
-0.0293200836,
-0.0227976628,
-0.0066343327,
0.004861454,
0.0301525686,
0.0414702557,
-0.0727581754,
0.0190339964,
0.0599373281,
0.0088706277,
-0.0239199828,
0.0105341105,
-0.0100068161,
-0.0094740074,
-0.0360979922,
0.0613965429,
-0.0264467858,
-0.0174186435,
0.0233748499,
-0.0251561645,
-0.0155169517,
-0.0219570044,
0.0028339848,
0.0011321034,
0.009547458,
0.0119318636,
0.0615965798,
0.023403611,
0.0688258708,
-0.0221316963,
-0.0300137382,
0.048872754,
0.0279791113,
0.0130134933,
0.0002021328,
-0.0153282182,
0.024221167,
-0.0154679269,
-0.004194696,
0.0099896528,
-0.0121689476,
0.0442243963,
0.0167552177,
-0.0646306276,
-0.0560414009,
0.0011191228,
-0.0387836471,
0.0380905829,
-0.0245825741,
-0.0079779131,
-0.1160343736,
-0.0417694822,
0.0273593608,
0.0386298597,
-0.0029859121,
0.0069682309,
-0.0153793842,
-0.0082702003,
0.0319135562,
-0.0401236825,
-0.0186951905,
0.005952178,
-0.0342604555,
-0.0016783987,
-0.0101384372,
-5.227615865e-33,
-0.0792429,
-0.0174884945,
0.0117525328,
0.0033033071,
-0.0362299122,
-0.0201642085,
-0.0086678322,
-0.0012983787,
0.0341584012,
0.0427019857,
0.0378782339,
-0.0197196063,
0.0125707472,
-0.0359684862,
0.0244330429,
-0.0128698032,
0.0273410063,
0.0301966649,
-0.0368010029,
-0.0188756045,
0.0534067154,
-0.0250181779,
0.0858079642,
-0.1336684227,
0.0751580298,
0.0118203908,
-0.0174866412,
0.0146110337,
0.0392856933,
0.0563446395,
-0.0026026685,
0.0289628729,
-0.0087195644,
0.0255886894,
0.0052676196,
-0.0265102126,
-0.0908192992,
-0.0303060636,
0.0153095098,
0.0228346121,
0.0288034398,
-0.0487516113,
0.0100799548,
0.0004240857,
0.0204062704,
-0.0043835505,
0.0475569181,
-0.0217410531,
-0.0081815971,
-0.039027594,
-0.0879280865,
0.0283036809,
-0.0224529896,
0.0148839224,
0.0219973288,
-0.0008783658,
0.0477163978,
-0.0135346884,
-0.1025768369,
-0.0237467177,
-0.0045476826,
-0.0383145623,
0.0227374434,
0.0310534704,
-0.0158077423,
0.0853877887,
-0.0177009683,
0.02756113,
0.0273383819,
0.0825897381,
-0.0048120967,
0.0134590501,
0.0229871459,
0.0482302718,
0.0001020182,
0.0241106823,
-0.0367307365,
0.0290154163,
-0.048098702,
-0.0265466683,
0.0079311049,
0.0025457952,
-0.0393515788,
-0.0133495983,
-0.0513697155,
0.0017038216,
-0.0034843637,
-0.027859414,
-0.019733509,
-0.0645551383,
-0.0337831303,
0.1057759598,
-0.0287985913,
-0.0352963805,
-0.0556068681,
-0.0249957815,
0.0242845789,
0.0419483222,
-0.0468370058,
-0.0055760834,
0.0403957628,
0.0094854357,
0.0127280699,
0.0249981005,
0.0692844316,
0.0176591538,
0.0145817576,
0.025290871,
-0.0329743959,
-0.010840212,
0.0163066052,
0.0081195813,
-0.0431354344,
0.0153563013,
0.0548394658,
-0.0480755009,
-0.0014458902,
-0.0014911491,
0.0453897268,
-0.0248217881,
0.0065496019,
0.0374884643,
-0.0120440759,
-0.0316834599,
-0.0159782786,
-0.0029671169,
0.0001941942,
-0.0424718671,
0.0400497839,
-0.0118086915,
-0.0052246097,
-0.0436126404,
2.492e-7,
0.0358929746,
0.012577069,
0.0459417328,
0.0151449647,
-0.0012633826,
-0.0003497225,
0.0160416234,
0.0019240957,
-0.0416361913,
-0.0673664063,
-0.0102448687,
-0.0347306244,
0.0170583669,
0.0555790104,
-0.0577016138,
-0.0705970973,
0.0279544368,
0.0150441779,
-0.0606652275,
0.0354622714,
0.0641288012,
0.0119739212,
0.0576854125,
-0.0272692721,
-0.0241080411,
0.0068322667,
-0.0031514913,
-0.0153556122,
0.0311474968,
0.0648123771,
0.0170395616,
0.0252450854,
0.0184003916,
0.0093023395,
-0.0082266219,
0.0208908189,
0.0208132267,
0.0183897931,
-0.0346797071,
0.069153361,
-0.0197452679,
-0.0571837984,
0.0524929278,
-0.0339705311,
0.0170500614,
0.0351300947,
-0.0386252142,
0.0037530889,
-0.0314499699,
0.0021393308,
-0.0342246667,
-0.0218771864,
-0.0105138933,
0.0129659818,
0.0094946725,
0.0151822297,
-0.0113991788,
-0.0726602152,
-0.0122147482,
0.0612302385,
0.0143553847,
-0.0371963233,
0.0303489119,
-0.0291434284,
-0.0284267869,
-0.0577863231,
-0.0053676427,
2.138598913e-34,
-0.0404401682,
-0.0137687167,
-0.0155565441,
0.0662462935,
0.0571504608,
0.0077539189,
0.025587704,
0.0074453992,
0.0234811269,
-0.0059523871,
0.0174738206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00402v1 | Is It Really Long Context if All You Need Is Retrieval? Towards Genuinely Difficult Long Context NLP | 2024-06-29T11:09:47 | 2024-06-29T11:09:47 | Omer Goldman, Alon Jacovi, Aviv Slobodkin, Aviya Maimon, Ido Dagan, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improvements in language models' capabilities have pushed their applications
towards longer contexts, making long-context evaluation and development an
active research area. However, many disparate use-cases are grouped together
under the umbrella term of "long-context", defined simply by the total length
of the model's input, including - for example - Needle-in-a-Haystack tasks,
book summarization, and information aggregation. Given their varied difficulty,
in this position paper we argue that conflating different tasks by their
context length is unproductive. As a community, we require a more precise
vocabulary to understand what makes long-context tasks similar or different. We
propose to unpack the taxonomy of long-context based on the properties that
make them more difficult with longer contexts. We propose two orthogonal axes
of difficulty: (I) Diffusion: How hard is it to find the necessary information
in the context? (II) Scope: How much necessary information is there to find? We
survey the literature on long-context, provide justification for this taxonomy
as an informative descriptor, and situate the literature with respect to it. We
conclude that the most difficult and interesting settings, whose necessary
information is very long and highly diffused within the input, is severely
under-explored. By using a descriptive vocabulary and discussing the relevant
properties of difficulty in long-context, we can implement more informed
research in this area. We call for a careful design of tasks and benchmarks
with distinctly long context, taking into account the characteristics that make
it qualitatively different from shorter context. | [
0.0499108806,
-0.013815213,
-0.0128332358,
0.0155712422,
-0.0813289434,
0.0206585191,
0.0214131586,
-0.0227659252,
-0.0391790047,
-0.05360898,
0.0010862506,
-0.0560349151,
0.0377987064,
-0.0073258877,
-0.0074912417,
-0.0812061727,
0.0149447639,
-0.0082311863,
-0.0226389915,
0.0070650512,
0.0053610797,
-0.0154993227,
0.0413566381,
0.014271399,
-0.0081341537,
-0.0071943193,
-0.0093711354,
-0.014741566,
-0.0181482434,
-0.0223037768,
0.0130789876,
0.0108000785,
0.0369726419,
-0.0044098389,
0.0000018729,
-0.0709602386,
-0.0389379896,
0.0100385798,
-0.0284414422,
0.0049530873,
0.0638962686,
-0.0443215258,
0.0268981773,
-0.0070121707,
-0.0118335327,
-0.0085189808,
0.0134839574,
0.0346870683,
-0.0124081075,
0.047126621,
-0.0099443514,
-0.066754058,
0.0120123737,
-0.0410655215,
0.0365802608,
-0.0750935003,
0.0189533234,
0.0056411214,
0.0600717403,
0.036714267,
-0.0345490351,
0.0464202315,
0.0280508455,
0.0319035761,
0.0007383036,
0.0295682997,
-0.0219657458,
0.0252566542,
0.0216297936,
0.0445169024,
0.0191359501,
0.0011616354,
0.0029062971,
0.0282075573,
-0.0075493176,
0.0118681137,
-0.086383678,
0.0474453717,
-0.007137896,
0.0113692274,
0.0533793606,
0.0373849608,
0.0154534271,
0.0138316676,
-0.0635684729,
0.0289588962,
-0.0094157662,
-0.0509225838,
-0.0283910129,
0.004514209,
-0.0346502215,
-0.0526824333,
-0.0029742774,
0.0380289853,
-0.0038401796,
0.0337613076,
0.0013644517,
-0.0127893602,
0.051905442,
-0.0228357129,
-0.0220189318,
0.0055634915,
-0.0273478087,
0.0841490254,
-0.0263824277,
0.0202315152,
-0.0041711782,
-0.0359317511,
-0.035541106,
-0.0261456184,
-0.0511624292,
0.0043408652,
-0.0541690141,
0.0296122935,
-0.0446264483,
-0.0349515453,
-0.0178351067,
0.0112388078,
-0.0126474332,
0.0034394374,
-0.0104256868,
0.0019324278,
-0.0367322229,
0.0122698862,
-0.0027494668,
0.0070807557,
-0.0633048117,
0.0035016246,
-0.0015414383,
0.0009326108,
0.0138943344,
0.0002353812,
0.016243495,
-0.0391087271,
-0.0078097894,
0.0440812968,
0.0162560865,
-0.0485495515,
-0.0382394269,
-0.0299544893,
-0.0689328313,
-0.053842213,
-0.0146124763,
-0.0764187947,
0.0100011379,
0.0321176238,
0.0033259348,
0.0011457289,
-0.0309764333,
0.008095704,
-0.0378715396,
0.0860373899,
0.0489592031,
0.0131023331,
0.0441438928,
0.0287454575,
0.0299177151,
0.0727337524,
-0.0146135706,
0.0035241628,
0.06160089,
0.0180058833,
0.0132356696,
0.0058263629,
0.0136449859,
0.0140658962,
-0.0023978732,
0.0231483765,
0.0045434027,
-0.0183571596,
-0.0107230498,
0.068513684,
-0.0324362405,
-0.0032473705,
0.0204809401,
0.0753169358,
0.0577326678,
-0.0034751059,
0.033318907,
-0.0195854027,
-0.0403850749,
0.0748797134,
-0.0210471284,
-0.0012272091,
-0.0280282814,
0.0408316776,
0.0502214357,
0.0032862315,
-0.0309522804,
-0.0442677401,
-0.0349009857,
0.0040294095,
0.0404008217,
0.0219558813,
0.0615829676,
0.002335656,
-0.0008959871,
0.0135751795,
-0.0005521132,
-0.0522509217,
0.0379079692,
-0.0128935734,
-0.0014394325,
0.037759494,
0.0406121835,
-0.0573416725,
-0.0001900416,
0.0237761345,
0.0300165452,
-0.005654458,
0.032493066,
-0.0282473788,
0.0058122608,
-0.0103202574,
-0.038501326,
-0.019329004,
0.0143442331,
-0.0141285378,
0.0532452576,
-0.0005962792,
0.0412456766,
-0.0364957303,
0.0017294083,
0.0175125655,
-0.0581843406,
-0.0187391676,
-0.0281391218,
0.0207688361,
0.0028511456,
0.0315708965,
-0.0010072991,
0.0287299585,
0.0344936885,
-0.0695877969,
-0.0040536267,
0.0007041326,
-0.0701215044,
-0.0197753645,
0.0238652211,
-0.025735043,
0.0317420065,
-0.0264471732,
0.0126970746,
-0.0702031255,
0.0234224293,
-0.019522313,
0.0629311055,
0.0013224051,
0.0390794724,
-0.0041902345,
-0.0020204431,
-0.0866967887,
0.098233968,
0.0238749161,
0.0394861773,
0.0280322377,
0.0289897695,
-0.0048404182,
-0.0441880561,
-0.0478446893,
0.0373791568,
0.0322673582,
-0.00316969,
0.072897166,
-0.0438670218,
-0.0443841554,
-0.0258940198,
-0.1265009344,
0.0116169835,
-0.0526590496,
-0.0000192764,
0.0175268631,
0.0339639597,
-0.0045762071,
0.0041066618,
-0.0521968529,
-0.0303011555,
0.0054219197,
0.0680799335,
0.0172686148,
0.0622049756,
-0.0069201961,
-0.0490528382,
-0.0510054715,
0.0158754736,
0.0638263673,
-0.0240960997,
-0.0353789739,
-0.0314498432,
0.060251601,
0.0008712522,
-0.0030469641,
-0.0386018008,
0.0473258719,
-0.0053754267,
-0.0353637151,
0.07202553,
0.0356142446,
0.0108151296,
0.0131621035,
0.0130490763,
-0.0391816497,
-0.0265349168,
0.0039931,
-0.0342176072,
-0.028254522,
0.002032602,
-0.0094019892,
0.0175191257,
0.0132562565,
-0.0086147701,
-0.0136176515,
-0.0127711976,
0.0087345773,
-0.0663122982,
0.0192587525,
-0.0507390276,
-0.0300026778,
0.0007087476,
0.0630706325,
-0.0580507442,
-0.0154375928,
0.0454113372,
-0.0160639659,
0.025236696,
-0.0381962135,
-0.0352710262,
-0.0897493139,
0.1154443696,
-0.0175299682,
0.007833953,
-0.0201001633,
-0.0293683428,
-0.0112055093,
-0.0053610238,
0.003441893,
-0.0206489079,
0.0981323123,
-0.0156929195,
0.0393951759,
-0.0258273873,
-0.0448480099,
-0.0114678917,
-0.0123549663,
0.0065791872,
0.0219064504,
0.0326657258,
0.030790085,
-0.0152203664,
0.031449914,
0.0418460555,
0.0474476516,
-0.010658402,
-0.01358339,
-0.0037733756,
0.0543751903,
0.0293569565,
0.000287738,
0.0213279184,
-0.0367021337,
0.0234029964,
0.0364900082,
0.0527924821,
-0.0024451814,
-0.0037438807,
0.0041034315,
0.016531527,
-0.0478350893,
-0.0626910999,
-0.0017647729,
0.0495259017,
-0.0788314566,
-0.0264249649,
0.0991463214,
0.0279840864,
-0.0594668649,
0.001228616,
-0.0097971866,
0.0054369457,
0.0141812451,
-0.0067898738,
-0.0574861281,
-0.0017246663,
0.0274102651,
0.0070016263,
-0.0181804989,
-0.0338102728,
-0.011965001,
-0.0890220329,
0.0149118584,
-0.002764567,
-0.0496759787,
-0.015451828,
-0.0522200987,
0.0243555699,
0.0011243954,
0.0397766456,
0.029082628,
-0.0495039411,
-0.0057752607,
-0.0070593106,
-0.0135491295,
-0.0197851546,
0.0266974065,
-0.02255252,
0.0172355957,
0.0310207009,
-0.0008214865,
0.0092879944,
0.0360986069,
0.0559443086,
-0.0679189712,
0.0204830319,
0.0106160399,
0.0498753674,
0.0010736251,
0.0052604759,
-0.0072483439,
-0.0000473672,
-0.0292433277,
-0.0152884768,
-0.0011469526,
0.0550604351,
0.0130227841,
0.0224148445,
-0.0466006473,
-0.0248816665,
-0.0021847612,
0.0994459167,
0.0237509757,
-0.0168658756,
-0.0474897549,
0.0066981423,
0.0090160975,
-0.0203402918,
-0.0038351072,
0.0206854716,
-0.02457349,
-0.0004913989,
-0.0539727882,
-0.0776292384,
0.0285242349,
0.0397802852,
0.0036615387,
0.0608058088,
-0.0125807822,
0.0050959438,
-0.0612467714,
0.0102508115,
-0.0268048067,
0.0212459471,
-0.0269831326,
0.0259744469,
0.0469618142,
-0.0244770292,
0.0227176379,
0.0163845848,
-0.067252025,
-0.0553792305,
0.0097477334,
-0.0209203884,
0.0258553904,
0.0438461788,
0.022641981,
-0.0415046662,
0.0471877307,
-0.0102623003,
-0.0100620789,
0.0368888676,
0.0079830708,
0.0475912616,
0.0035098717,
0.0324042477,
-0.0786162615,
0.0218262076,
-0.0148346918,
0.0448892638,
-0.0454078801,
-0.0140912225,
0.0168495011,
-0.0122532025,
-0.0009581776,
0.0015313294,
-0.0249592233,
-0.01514869,
-0.0341682509,
-0.0478383601,
-0.035957396,
-0.0051084557,
0.000978891,
-0.0059596403,
0.0197784007,
0.0120404996,
0.0557959564,
0.0202675834,
0.0493272133,
-0.0868264958,
0.0324086063,
-0.0107385209,
-0.0361034647,
-0.0179953855,
0.0306584556,
-0.0354218148,
-0.0201463457,
-0.0502873249,
0.0250348803,
-0.0195911806,
0.0281943176,
0.0307674725,
-0.0006921768,
-0.0438744687,
0.018929163,
-0.1027202606,
0.0323346741,
0.0077410201,
0.0141148884,
0.0560047217,
-0.0637530014,
0.0433072113,
-0.0007649579,
-0.0199365746,
-0.0198547691,
-0.0195749942,
0.0454173498,
-0.0192032903,
-0.0228998046,
0.0708308294,
-0.0041131172,
0.0455813482,
0.0861656368,
0.0015624221,
0.0264348164,
0.0375317596,
0.0043820599,
-0.0094958236,
-0.0088477982,
0.0024070048,
0.0551705547,
0.0046741613,
-0.0204628557,
-0.0684503242,
-0.0421640128,
0.0284382645,
-0.0128096221,
-0.0093805855,
-0.0228733253,
0.0343112126,
0.0887010843,
0.0314712971,
-0.0015843121,
-0.0379271284,
0.0180718023,
-0.0220049266,
0.0147246607,
0.0036112654,
-6.0694579e-33,
-0.0152623095,
-0.0421113782,
0.0132288672,
-0.0303090159,
-0.0527383275,
0.0577350892,
-0.0246365424,
0.015352862,
-0.0106803933,
-0.0086692059,
-0.036499396,
0.0010475552,
-0.0031825891,
0.0214249138,
-0.0076547358,
0.0071555343,
0.0357437581,
0.0342807546,
-0.0034098492,
0.0176249091,
0.0737283379,
0.0099319452,
-0.0040915245,
-0.0558972694,
0.0455102324,
-0.024469452,
0.0286686048,
0.0014372711,
0.0497318432,
0.0663381815,
-0.0183349121,
0.0492437743,
0.0675791204,
-0.0824594796,
-0.0325065143,
0.0406749249,
-0.1185273752,
-0.0126187801,
0.0283735134,
-0.028355848,
-0.0233548861,
-0.0293906666,
0.0565195717,
-0.0147768939,
0.0107484134,
-0.0211581383,
0.0344112031,
-0.040753115,
-0.0481825024,
-0.020554645,
-0.037197765,
0.0259461347,
0.0112004103,
-0.0096094711,
0.0666023344,
0.0057538948,
0.0030073996,
0.0383731201,
-0.0515648313,
0.0025775258,
-0.0251682829,
0.0537938848,
0.0304724444,
0.0379367396,
0.0221875291,
0.0368327163,
0.0062743528,
0.0202805363,
-0.0314095952,
-0.062147148,
-0.002526965,
0.0072174938,
-0.0094302306,
0.0352767892,
0.0588513464,
0.0026370191,
-0.0376519673,
0.0063839923,
0.0018988148,
0.0040465035,
0.0275098309,
0.0202831775,
-0.0628467202,
-0.045833841,
-0.0419361666,
0.0277688857,
-0.018476937,
0.0026914463,
0.0225315262,
0.0426265225,
0.0053868117,
0.010180166,
0.0277601648,
-0.037791416,
-0.0178071503,
0.0296272226,
0.0125308866,
0.0360866413,
0.0006856171,
0.0056501594,
-0.0113071529,
-0.0074637798,
0.0021656882,
0.0296812728,
-0.025310969,
-0.006799168,
0.0361479037,
0.0010015728,
-0.0421553217,
-0.0245627686,
-0.0211649016,
0.0210284498,
-0.0372094139,
0.0240638033,
0.0429093316,
0.0341628231,
0.0121690137,
0.07048022,
0.0497697592,
-0.0029512455,
-0.0182974171,
-0.0174425282,
-0.0208206195,
-0.0187731907,
-0.0092842365,
-0.0068296888,
-0.0093387431,
0.0561214946,
0.0600635,
-0.0257095601,
-0.017350778,
0.0066919364,
2.524e-7,
0.0333990119,
0.0279269777,
0.0772694349,
-0.004183352,
0.0363207385,
-0.011998645,
0.0112898452,
0.0054838513,
-0.0420939326,
-0.0262789261,
0.0006792033,
0.0284405053,
0.0319426656,
0.0258076619,
-0.0600986779,
-0.0136626102,
-0.0345720798,
-0.0021947934,
-0.0469208658,
0.0291404389,
0.0596240908,
0.0842320397,
-0.0196443014,
0.0105124181,
-0.0443833061,
-0.0701558068,
0.0465535633,
-0.0640634075,
-0.013020169,
0.0107073123,
0.0045279562,
0.0541635342,
0.0191194303,
-0.0075591579,
0.0200370196,
0.0334722549,
0.0307098422,
0.0304461867,
0.0192126781,
-0.0737771913,
0.0023639465,
-0.0235392302,
-0.0176763665,
-0.0517171361,
0.0851923302,
-0.0699588656,
-0.0145633304,
-0.0177459512,
-0.0166840479,
0.0313371532,
-0.017045876,
0.06062603,
-0.0049820128,
0.0136638964,
-0.0054284916,
-0.0036255128,
-0.0167066678,
-0.1351965666,
-0.0128427614,
0.0405285135,
-0.0243263002,
-0.0316825323,
-0.0187466219,
-0.0209448338,
0.0117359459,
-0.0654767081,
-0.0120843081,
2.570690433e-34,
0.0687957704,
-0.0127850687,
-0.013776253,
-0.0149079906,
-0.0114667416,
-0.0480481498,
-0.0582381748,
-0.0083794557,
0.0241828747,
-0.0846372768,
-0.0268696025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00396v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00396v1 | A Study on Effect of Reference Knowledge Choice in Generating Technical Content Relevant to SAPPhIRE Model Using Large Language Model | 2024-06-29T10:46:01 | 2024-06-29T10:46:01 | Kausik Bhattacharya, Anubhab Majumder, Amaresh Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representation of systems using the SAPPhIRE model of causality can be an
inspirational stimulus in design. However, creating a SAPPhIRE model of a
technical or a natural system requires sourcing technical knowledge from
multiple technical documents regarding how the system works. This research
investigates how to generate technical content accurately relevant to the
SAPPhIRE model of causality using a Large Language Model, also called LLM. This
paper, which is the first part of the two-part research, presents a method for
hallucination suppression using Retrieval Augmented Generating with LLM to
generate technical content supported by the scientific information relevant to
a SAPPhIRE con-struct. The result from this research shows that the selection
of reference knowledge used in providing context to the LLM for generating the
technical content is very important. The outcome of this research is used to
build a software support tool to generate the SAPPhIRE model of a given
technical system. | [
0.0094647892,
-0.02280939,
-0.0288633201,
0.0122197783,
-0.034195099,
-0.0231462643,
-0.0342055373,
0.0115052862,
-0.0454461761,
-0.041883193,
0.0057986211,
0.063700147,
-0.032829009,
0.0196363237,
0.0294456054,
-0.0440651365,
0.0382493138,
-0.0051900367,
0.0029827484,
-0.0089375852,
-0.0063331556,
-0.0143934852,
0.0060060122,
0.0260867402,
-0.0305302683,
-0.0336741135,
0.0029390189,
0.0550710112,
0.0000383101,
-0.0554082282,
-0.0260524098,
0.0271806233,
0.0140782036,
0.0147306118,
0.0000022132,
-0.0729006752,
-0.0324828401,
0.0248238165,
-0.0111437254,
-0.0089668278,
0.0298872292,
0.0292125195,
0.0233996715,
0.0081731342,
-0.0118270479,
0.0501472466,
0.0043156408,
0.0817104504,
0.024956435,
0.0221268535,
-0.0086057149,
-0.0694747642,
0.0390993915,
0.0542462766,
0.0079480149,
0.0067102569,
-0.0104215769,
0.1235018,
0.0862712786,
0.0357791521,
0.0059122955,
0.0311206281,
0.0113109695,
-0.013248262,
0.069188714,
-0.0098390011,
-0.0300347339,
-0.0041757151,
0.0338100195,
0.0588955656,
0.0625189096,
-0.0463268198,
0.0220793486,
0.0030891495,
0.0156274866,
0.0564616844,
-0.0668606982,
0.0084062004,
-0.0124080023,
-0.0089728776,
0.0340706818,
-0.0093360981,
0.0198105257,
-0.025732033,
-0.0045443173,
0.0337811075,
0.0106863612,
-0.0350483842,
-0.0010155103,
-0.027129693,
0.0809572041,
-0.0258960463,
-0.0283450447,
0.0280852877,
-0.0662335828,
0.0023854603,
0.009715315,
0.0262715574,
0.0278618,
-0.088886857,
-0.006200444,
0.0149518289,
0.0085703256,
0.0216443352,
-0.0406344943,
0.0174223855,
-0.0226227995,
0.0239487868,
-0.0460763052,
0.0086295726,
-0.0729609802,
-0.0497499816,
-0.0419118851,
0.056216754,
-0.0408254825,
-0.0220499653,
-0.0514642186,
0.022204468,
-0.01816638,
0.0290267747,
-0.0476242118,
0.0145942084,
0.0112578534,
-0.0127709731,
-0.0255083404,
-0.0388581641,
-0.0217416231,
-0.0217873268,
-0.0111057358,
-0.0550064221,
0.0189234726,
0.0063695223,
-0.0244795512,
0.0324255899,
-0.0323253386,
0.0562321693,
0.058988601,
0.0087498454,
-0.0922688097,
-0.061968457,
0.0478942953,
-0.0401821509,
0.0166593064,
-0.0363802016,
-0.0489349104,
0.0202331915,
-0.0040034358,
0.0055845361,
0.016879892,
-0.0069093918,
0.0028269573,
0.0199956261,
-0.0683423802,
0.0170024503,
0.0399750285,
0.0171513651,
0.0134390965,
0.0314567648,
0.0117475316,
0.0115970299,
-0.0026437575,
-0.0207589362,
0.0589314215,
-0.0063688965,
-0.0406275131,
-0.0337506942,
-0.0711404532,
0.0109579107,
0.0193370543,
-0.0047487319,
-0.0353420042,
-0.0001612093,
-0.0501350984,
0.0862091631,
0.0136891343,
-0.0275806878,
0.0798671842,
0.0916286036,
0.0161568038,
0.0186194014,
0.0019863027,
0.0391293615,
-0.011137791,
0.0747748464,
-0.0204831734,
0.0281721167,
0.0402199104,
-0.014083459,
-0.0311829541,
-0.0563445948,
-0.0125732645,
0.0130549306,
-0.0464146733,
-0.0338427126,
0.0356259532,
0.0138283223,
-0.0479422547,
0.0357436277,
0.0233443249,
-0.0185748264,
-0.0121686384,
-0.005946361,
0.0343783833,
0.1006839946,
0.0612225458,
-0.0721694529,
0.0243850909,
-0.0178877711,
-0.0321289077,
0.044184614,
0.023271203,
0.0027965272,
-0.076167278,
-0.0446495228,
-0.0284711421,
-0.0468170755,
-0.0070195142,
0.0234901905,
-0.0608128272,
0.0166356545,
-0.0065969261,
0.0504793264,
-0.0752006322,
0.0030528484,
-0.0156316161,
-0.03469285,
-0.0567170568,
-0.0304483883,
0.0100495936,
0.0479811952,
-0.0377764702,
0.0667050779,
0.0535047501,
-0.0387938544,
-0.0245432314,
0.0292667784,
-0.0218532253,
0.0661103055,
0.0195870735,
-0.070548065,
0.0444242992,
-0.0087282043,
0.0386487134,
-0.0676569045,
0.0619275905,
-0.0452295989,
0.0641203523,
-0.0196230691,
0.0245117825,
-0.0015630386,
0.0008512812,
-0.0077713518,
0.0670767128,
0.0153354565,
0.033176329,
0.0291935112,
-0.0008008296,
0.0473453589,
-0.0448813401,
0.0170137864,
0.0496753268,
-0.0101996036,
0.0113212196,
0.0547193252,
-0.0744288415,
-0.0323668569,
0.0136653539,
-0.0027489739,
-0.0548747778,
0.0079326788,
-0.0089961365,
0.0149846561,
-0.0285418294,
-0.0102697266,
-0.0018072746,
0.0109785106,
0.0201475993,
0.0011052721,
-0.0193840787,
0.0138098607,
0.0015406323,
-0.0379433744,
0.0115328673,
-0.004562051,
-0.0209109094,
0.0432170071,
0.0766927525,
-0.0488196164,
-0.1276421398,
0.0493377298,
0.0003626643,
-0.034509629,
0.0042322297,
0.0254161153,
0.0024050612,
-0.02386095,
0.0432725511,
0.0087944064,
-0.0063650729,
-0.0067949514,
0.0348538458,
-0.0463677011,
-0.0400256142,
-0.0045786309,
-0.0225229245,
0.0412980914,
0.0296402611,
-0.0316292644,
0.0089390865,
-0.0265091844,
0.0006990554,
0.0202179346,
-0.0065313284,
0.0240005217,
-0.0208703335,
-0.0282569714,
0.0257330686,
-0.0595568977,
-0.011405793,
0.0452097356,
0.0008912555,
-0.0641731247,
0.0188554153,
-0.0127695622,
0.0276596621,
-0.0200795867,
0.0157613158,
-0.0142248664,
0.0082006212,
-0.0327574499,
0.0299202856,
0.0263589323,
0.000086388,
-0.0244700629,
-0.0281476639,
-0.0127972979,
-0.0083760945,
-0.0420333445,
-0.0252993964,
-0.0145319859,
0.0068862732,
0.0359467939,
-0.0475460887,
0.0199193116,
0.025360696,
0.0473270975,
0.0086975144,
0.0374834463,
-0.0541343242,
0.0154899657,
0.0563833639,
-0.0165462513,
0.0242407843,
-0.0377860367,
-0.0163137652,
-0.0035627407,
0.0152612068,
-0.0564171821,
0.0661084056,
-0.0112375272,
0.0255418997,
0.0136940889,
-0.0081744669,
0.0220554713,
-0.0338947177,
-0.0392126404,
0.0219991133,
-0.0024255039,
-0.0565389954,
0.0218060836,
-0.0295491256,
-0.0076991403,
0.014527794,
0.0422261246,
0.0217409134,
-0.0435178466,
0.0218673609,
-0.0847415999,
-0.0362162739,
0.0374369435,
0.0223161764,
-0.0722706839,
0.0564472526,
-0.0258040316,
0.0095583368,
-0.0167081878,
-0.0101621076,
-0.0102496259,
-0.0353342891,
0.0422529653,
0.0113448864,
-0.0060447431,
-0.0064497096,
-0.0070485952,
-0.0475337319,
0.0595703647,
-0.0496352799,
0.0317398161,
-0.0028082316,
-0.0195937175,
0.0301079955,
-0.0373752303,
-0.0426027216,
-0.0441634767,
0.0190029647,
-0.0004054519,
0.0621374659,
0.0415386744,
-0.0353415757,
-0.0627304614,
0.0038196573,
0.0289105456,
0.0575030707,
-0.0401496589,
-0.034932375,
0.0433997214,
0.00518989,
0.0091389148,
0.0209052563,
0.0044126483,
-0.0264381878,
-0.0090599051,
0.044550132,
-0.017924875,
-0.0252969619,
-0.0465916023,
-0.0182739608,
0.0109355757,
0.0341644138,
-0.0039849575,
0.0255231373,
-0.0291574169,
-0.0055846744,
0.0387690701,
0.0453825481,
0.0066799726,
-0.0337950252,
0.0096193198,
0.0242453646,
-0.062611714,
-0.0133539997,
-0.0390973166,
0.0448662154,
0.0150741935,
0.054575827,
-0.0116796158,
-0.0274511073,
-0.0254579335,
0.0164915565,
-0.0363340154,
-0.0058144769,
-0.0113658886,
-0.028921403,
0.0345959254,
-0.0752377138,
-0.0027145424,
0.0218993407,
0.1032028124,
-0.0389791466,
0.0009430925,
0.0605268106,
0.0360808261,
-0.0123567991,
0.0154479071,
-0.0279401168,
0.0360069834,
0.0099955648,
-0.0093168858,
0.0353355259,
-0.0317657106,
0.0295465477,
-0.0103589511,
-0.0459103212,
-0.0303176735,
-0.0068795364,
0.0061654244,
0.0198693834,
0.0110387849,
0.0017019651,
0.0182570759,
0.0572054684,
-0.0318897776,
-0.0340178013,
0.0278233904,
0.0154610723,
0.0331347957,
-0.0470180549,
-0.0079990719,
-0.0321040079,
0.0265979599,
0.0155212684,
-0.0202831589,
0.0516044386,
-0.0417737029,
-0.0465540588,
-0.052861549,
-0.0193554014,
-0.0043113334,
0.0285856165,
0.0389206931,
0.0123793064,
-0.0412048921,
-0.0175489038,
-0.0367822386,
-0.0178234577,
0.0447230898,
-0.0139610628,
0.0757331103,
0.0312376805,
-0.0031079908,
-0.0318022147,
0.0011181054,
-0.018925067,
-0.0892433077,
-0.0159325562,
-0.0088274684,
0.0352852903,
0.0257487558,
0.0092648594,
-0.0507095903,
0.0315927081,
0.0093269609,
0.0406608135,
0.0461555906,
-0.0095343404,
-0.0253350697,
0.0353947468,
-0.0269553494,
-0.0486250445,
0.0519053861,
0.0141608277,
-0.0258066151,
-0.09555161,
-0.0328531973,
-0.039077308,
-0.0118426792,
-0.0244577564,
0.0286657885,
-0.0288839936,
-0.0226518959,
-0.1192727834,
-0.0069405702,
0.042807959,
0.0050148228,
0.0281530488,
-0.0293508712,
0.0510145649,
0.0551962852,
0.0099974303,
-0.0681392252,
0.0254872628,
-0.0137096811,
-0.0112939356,
-0.0009320736,
-0.019819878,
-6.096310599e-33,
-0.0276452508,
-0.0447625555,
0.0554374494,
0.0002457546,
0.001245647,
-0.0233467314,
-0.0247297361,
-0.0117067518,
0.0126227783,
-0.0073343813,
0.0052772937,
-0.0275690034,
0.0082882345,
-0.0318239294,
0.0029419041,
0.0335962623,
0.0495921932,
0.0284085218,
-0.0278563481,
0.0454387031,
0.0517221838,
0.0115804654,
0.0342454351,
-0.1130005494,
0.0469516926,
-0.0718953386,
0.0376624241,
-0.0308999736,
0.0051606619,
0.0001853804,
-0.041664727,
0.0098534031,
0.0066915546,
-0.047488872,
-0.0257671326,
0.0190454889,
-0.019586049,
-0.0270467922,
0.0363363475,
-0.0081753973,
0.0097128768,
-0.0455042124,
0.0320965685,
-0.0111127263,
-0.0122814346,
0.0472783782,
0.0480424762,
-0.0031737646,
-0.0522196367,
-0.0107381819,
-0.103814505,
0.002681945,
-0.0199853107,
0.055545263,
0.0007323772,
0.0034952722,
-0.0235640462,
0.0103972228,
-0.0141270822,
0.0317789912,
0.0098611554,
-0.002620595,
0.0563700795,
0.0017741761,
0.0682160631,
0.0437284112,
0.0607132018,
0.021751279,
-0.0116238138,
-0.0482255071,
-0.009703638,
0.0618467517,
0.0544514209,
0.0099990685,
0.0084773814,
-0.0230013039,
-0.0524728373,
-0.0114384145,
-0.0763533115,
0.0690418109,
0.0849583298,
0.0182686914,
-0.0356358401,
-0.0320773609,
0.0247074738,
0.0346318595,
-0.009627142,
-0.0156073039,
0.0238180943,
-0.0045641251,
-0.0213919487,
0.0140344119,
-0.0008519929,
-0.0389411822,
0.0289093368,
0.0417819098,
0.0277289245,
-0.0043184748,
-0.0295449067,
-0.0431576185,
-0.0391906537,
-0.0215784181,
-0.0268025231,
-0.0064122272,
0.0411159247,
0.0217212178,
-0.0215160362,
-0.0084828567,
-0.0120202666,
0.0107754245,
-0.0222676452,
-0.0388066359,
0.0446275771,
-0.0991161838,
0.0229237713,
0.0231183674,
0.0010854092,
-0.0078977123,
0.0087767914,
0.0151442494,
0.0303572305,
-0.0220030863,
-0.0145470779,
0.0266188998,
0.0239130277,
0.0064821681,
-0.0338842794,
0.0516140014,
0.0551773682,
-0.0142596364,
-0.029564051,
0.0477254204,
3.063e-7,
-0.0252657291,
0.03112722,
0.0040119351,
0.034503296,
0.019275859,
-0.0287014339,
0.022436453,
-0.0305519383,
0.0476322137,
-0.0065841293,
-0.0086786151,
0.0052918987,
0.0221128799,
0.0150400214,
-0.0986073092,
-0.0322518572,
0.011913605,
-0.0043550846,
-0.0198977273,
0.0083788028,
0.0824505538,
-0.0398465097,
-0.0001608324,
-0.0235226788,
-0.0404043496,
-0.0587726869,
0.0486467034,
-0.0076273908,
0.0449288115,
0.0573418103,
0.0281303711,
0.027289642,
-0.0135332281,
0.0523044243,
0.0106226271,
-0.0159437768,
-0.0027446386,
-0.0266923066,
0.0046391077,
0.0103832381,
0.0513029471,
-0.029852394,
0.005821621,
-0.0382437482,
0.00277249,
0.0181875974,
-0.0013219879,
0.0581675954,
-0.0878378227,
-0.0287850574,
-0.0088723479,
-0.0123729324,
0.0433131047,
0.009317074,
-0.0486636981,
0.0159703717,
-0.0087218182,
-0.0234355628,
0.0294481236,
0.0340033695,
-0.0114004621,
-0.0616742149,
-0.0027115766,
-0.0132610369,
-0.0093444325,
-0.0275159329,
0.0273139477,
2.837190155e-34,
0.0200552177,
-0.0067198859,
0.019203892,
0.0645854697,
-0.0042531257,
-0.0002352515,
-0.0029932829,
0.0303070042,
0.026227437,
-0.0666618347,
-0.0137177808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00390v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00390v1 | Advancing Process Verification for Large Language Models via Tree-Based Preference Learning | 2024-06-29T10:09:49 | 2024-06-29T10:09:49 | Mingqian He, Yongliang Shen, Wenqi Zhang, Zeqi Tan, Weiming Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks by generating step-by-step rationales.Some
methods have proven effective in boosting accuracy by introducing extra
verifiers to assess these paths. However, existing verifiers, typically trained
on binary-labeled reasoning paths, fail to fully utilize the relative merits of
intermediate steps, thereby limiting the effectiveness of the feedback
provided. To overcome this limitation, we propose Tree-based Preference
Learning Verifier (Tree-PLV), a novel approach that constructs reasoning trees
via a best-first search algorithm and collects step-level paired data for
preference training. Compared to traditional binary classification, step-level
preferences more finely capture the nuances between reasoning steps, allowing
for a more precise evaluation of the complete reasoning path. We empirically
evaluate Tree-PLV across a range of arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks,
where it significantly outperforms existing benchmarks. For instance, Tree-PLV
achieved substantial performance gains over the Mistral-7B self-consistency
baseline on GSM8K (67.55% to 82.79%), MATH (17.00% to 26.80%), CSQA (68.14% to
72.97%), and StrategyQA (82.86% to 83.25%).Additionally, our study explores the
appropriate granularity for applying preference learning, revealing that
step-level guidance provides feedback that better aligns with the evaluation of
the reasoning process. | [
-0.0003130142,
0.0687456578,
0.0177154765,
0.0285266042,
-0.0574310943,
-0.0072347857,
-0.0226445477,
-0.0084005352,
0.0013427355,
-0.0415349156,
-0.0041082394,
-0.0326846801,
0.0012750278,
0.0075524505,
-0.0112216184,
-0.0324639529,
0.0423861556,
-0.0558692291,
0.0464361869,
-0.024955431,
-0.0283846948,
0.0432942733,
-0.0210482888,
0.0165059045,
0.0131375985,
-0.0579398982,
0.002124656,
-0.0247970838,
0.0271555223,
-0.0508902743,
-0.0054979557,
0.0522229485,
0.0152095398,
0.0461992323,
0.0000025879,
-0.0712517351,
-0.0093016922,
0.0041125151,
-0.0937915593,
-0.0024313868,
-0.0055313827,
0.0548898689,
-0.0174277294,
0.0353416689,
-0.0241841599,
-0.0146224843,
0.0235957056,
0.0270407386,
0.0720579177,
0.06321197,
0.00641162,
-0.0674776584,
-0.0099177063,
-0.0253574066,
-0.0051063253,
-0.036624793,
0.0211065691,
-0.0094865784,
0.0237142686,
0.0389573313,
0.0217266306,
-0.0184865445,
0.0397332162,
-0.0195784923,
-0.0487175509,
0.0537435785,
0.0187992789,
-0.0030873746,
0.018878324,
0.0768564194,
0.0003408853,
-0.0497256257,
-0.0247736517,
-0.0270767286,
-0.0413999446,
-0.0037144243,
-0.0272996109,
0.0342401452,
-0.0170555972,
0.0160502438,
0.0468592159,
-0.0293403491,
0.0368740372,
0.0254456662,
-0.0841194391,
0.0998256058,
-0.0075159427,
-0.0367980935,
0.0561270341,
-0.0049364101,
-0.0286575034,
-0.0827024132,
0.0024679813,
0.0160790607,
-0.0744566545,
0.0159031712,
0.0065907622,
0.0431443304,
0.0027465939,
-0.0309411399,
0.0379799642,
0.0511704572,
0.0053038783,
0.0438976623,
-0.0233024247,
0.0381762572,
-0.0018971411,
0.0441224575,
-0.0215698835,
0.0253838934,
-0.0375120118,
0.0075922348,
-0.0046981205,
0.0377663746,
-0.0360748284,
0.0124375913,
-0.0375201888,
-0.0003116756,
-0.0261943061,
0.0653721392,
0.0752332285,
-0.0196124297,
0.0353497304,
-0.0289974511,
-0.0607672036,
0.0446331054,
-0.0273876432,
0.0265647229,
0.0232529677,
0.0124482913,
-0.0039541093,
0.0019797983,
-0.0241826009,
-0.0224522855,
0.0401378721,
0.0259143319,
0.0025884295,
0.0036300221,
-0.0197748318,
-0.003117403,
0.0049804957,
-0.1054736525,
0.0007525797,
-0.0790930539,
-0.0018385838,
-0.0021832604,
0.0047173649,
0.0051685735,
0.0084003508,
0.0458143689,
-0.0021908935,
0.0756879821,
0.0279767495,
-0.0003599211,
-0.05060618,
-0.0029216877,
-0.0214882288,
0.0387015007,
0.0331817195,
0.0111814961,
0.0198881775,
-0.0313659608,
-0.0200222097,
-0.0039473302,
-0.0168056879,
-0.0372743383,
0.0018964737,
0.0286050178,
-0.0288231373,
0.0073098838,
0.0076649156,
0.0244397391,
-0.0516855158,
-0.0257323012,
0.047957141,
0.0425189734,
0.0121967355,
-0.0344261602,
0.0341187082,
0.0146606946,
0.0099039152,
-0.0119968588,
-0.0802388936,
0.0002687371,
-0.0402647033,
0.0096633499,
-0.0567187481,
0.0067135394,
-0.0061534271,
-0.0589424632,
-0.0171104837,
0.0247328449,
0.0154197635,
0.0395086184,
0.0620875582,
-0.0002033356,
-0.0578813739,
0.025850933,
0.0103916489,
-0.0509056598,
-0.0306129139,
-0.0500545092,
0.0527557433,
0.0814950839,
0.044975251,
-0.0065529486,
-0.0038398087,
-0.009855181,
-0.0112652211,
0.0039332788,
0.0240298938,
-0.0363022536,
-0.0053164102,
-0.0647305027,
-0.0320720077,
-0.0033249129,
0.0102614462,
-0.0028396235,
0.0366767459,
-0.0111018522,
-0.003160635,
-0.0382809713,
0.0063488088,
0.0177873988,
-0.0035695443,
-0.0231342148,
0.0480700582,
0.0148266992,
0.0414391086,
0.0109077953,
0.0030074085,
0.0250391271,
0.0257978439,
0.0182949286,
-0.0177273937,
0.0200119019,
-0.0696893334,
-0.0432080217,
0.0549376123,
0.0402992442,
-0.0475767888,
0.0201360956,
-0.0454420522,
-0.0160507429,
-0.0180406347,
-0.0117529752,
0.0072480142,
-0.0300502665,
0.0543791763,
-0.0013298029,
-0.0501794703,
-0.029638119,
0.0941554308,
-0.0164481532,
-0.0107921455,
-0.0232797544,
0.0024711445,
0.0194620937,
-0.0198465232,
0.0220252927,
0.0509588644,
-0.0077459668,
0.0229720883,
0.0004312736,
0.0180014558,
-0.0334635898,
0.0072593153,
-0.0710437,
0.0139606874,
-0.0167802684,
0.0532219745,
-0.0004388002,
-0.0199471861,
0.0173512679,
0.0007365132,
-0.0006939069,
0.0073022279,
0.021690039,
0.0243791509,
-0.0086940713,
0.0055357791,
-0.0171802156,
-0.0229883045,
-0.0265398156,
-0.0480135977,
0.0305341426,
-0.0385966636,
0.0525780618,
-0.0421135426,
0.0210414212,
-0.0024779218,
0.0057241609,
-0.0096706692,
0.0193506535,
0.0469176508,
-0.0309356824,
-0.01727622,
0.073480092,
-0.0088845333,
-0.0088896742,
0.0570312738,
-0.0269182175,
-0.0699318424,
0.0143087143,
-0.019758543,
0.0020444754,
-0.0167620387,
0.002483116,
-0.0227522887,
0.0864736587,
-0.0363491252,
0.0120062418,
-0.0274048913,
0.0055219363,
0.0066792015,
0.0082425587,
-0.0153596168,
-0.0263705458,
0.008139153,
0.0598576702,
-0.0264380649,
-0.0244129244,
0.0946066827,
-0.0327361561,
0.0057599409,
-0.0830397904,
-0.0010505087,
-0.0077233668,
0.0517200641,
0.0097174486,
-0.0041232076,
-0.0038401671,
0.0126779657,
-0.0346330442,
-0.0324424803,
0.0609609559,
-0.0440984406,
0.057268355,
-0.0632476285,
0.0246775784,
0.0143163474,
-0.0692496672,
-0.0528698973,
-0.0069292444,
-0.0345190391,
0.035889443,
-0.0217519291,
-0.0318831913,
0.0071745561,
0.0000103365,
0.0124956537,
0.0506663211,
0.016472755,
-0.0271476712,
-0.0199934114,
-0.0013871939,
0.0036157852,
0.004907677,
0.0661204979,
-0.0081432695,
0.0471242629,
0.0459057763,
0.0836684927,
-0.0075260592,
-0.0295174271,
-0.0014478345,
0.0220777839,
-0.0608437136,
-0.0074124583,
0.0245380886,
0.0255189836,
-0.068751134,
-0.0026086497,
0.1079763398,
0.0323768631,
-0.0184150282,
-0.0058058538,
-0.0441409759,
0.0217015408,
0.0254992582,
0.0373230539,
-0.0690781772,
-0.0402601324,
0.031233374,
0.0423810594,
0.0111312615,
-0.0315756351,
0.0176652484,
-0.1432898939,
0.0363793857,
-0.0030044222,
-0.0282037575,
0.0000732521,
-0.0814009532,
-0.0026035402,
-0.0406217687,
0.0017616892,
0.0216669999,
-0.0071505965,
-0.020548515,
0.0043912153,
-0.0122012151,
-0.0563318133,
0.079383269,
-0.024743963,
-0.0154542765,
0.081999667,
0.0074548554,
0.0249717534,
-0.0714671686,
0.0362923332,
-0.0266693737,
-0.0294480231,
-0.028022809,
-0.0150554329,
0.0001754936,
0.0150540015,
-0.0167026296,
0.0361736901,
-0.0286177043,
-0.0325075835,
0.0064915451,
0.1034483612,
-0.0106768962,
-0.0435932316,
0.022161657,
0.0078326268,
-0.024601832,
0.0499168225,
-0.0128830355,
-0.005175753,
-0.0676772445,
-0.0472543687,
-0.0317231193,
-0.0030445696,
-0.0472458526,
0.0205047913,
0.0162703972,
0.0136539359,
-0.0177116264,
-0.0058520683,
0.0532917641,
0.0642964467,
-0.0426524319,
-0.0090248585,
0.0158460755,
0.0071509699,
-0.0497311912,
0.0443164371,
-0.0565075278,
0.059350308,
-0.045286499,
0.0349957719,
0.0217670389,
0.0198460184,
-0.0284697823,
0.0097564897,
-0.025753377,
-0.0399783738,
-0.0600750856,
0.072165966,
0.0223340634,
0.066523917,
-0.0345674977,
-0.0031987929,
-0.0100938836,
-0.0129910596,
-0.0183697268,
-0.014646736,
0.0444465652,
-0.0140460152,
-0.0091978256,
0.0090556517,
-0.0031629936,
0.0059677535,
-0.004254696,
0.0638163909,
-0.0415620469,
-0.0368015841,
0.0538936034,
0.0166764967,
0.0191040821,
0.0138121704,
0.0146238729,
-0.0445951521,
0.0625353381,
-0.0250936691,
-0.0218034703,
0.0065369662,
-0.0060870671,
0.0303619467,
-0.0350407287,
-0.0055376771,
-0.0419735238,
-0.0185605157,
0.0108708031,
0.0005565873,
0.0271099415,
0.0433585495,
0.0496292338,
0.0401033424,
-0.0470961444,
-0.011390334,
-0.0455752462,
0.0390555598,
0.0611412302,
-0.0056688222,
0.0855122656,
0.0252266396,
-0.0039351201,
-0.0044278409,
-0.0067398325,
-0.01263972,
-0.0939954668,
-0.0096770525,
-0.0272556245,
0.0573930517,
-0.0149448393,
0.0218203943,
-0.0347454101,
-0.0093257912,
-0.0338746347,
0.0020153336,
0.0166664626,
-0.0219104867,
0.0005443649,
0.0481596887,
-0.0000053685,
0.0036624041,
0.0276554935,
0.0021628633,
0.0402169079,
-0.0118724611,
-0.0155291669,
-0.0363008901,
-0.0848437399,
-0.0772055089,
0.0654319674,
-0.0162620693,
-0.0216778014,
-0.0711628273,
-0.0925484151,
-0.0254046042,
0.0193354301,
0.0062362365,
-0.0084724147,
0.0251830295,
0.071368143,
-0.009999508,
-0.0286411401,
-0.0128127886,
-0.0416864082,
-0.0129814763,
-0.0033141826,
-0.0592671894,
-6.366320182e-33,
-0.0029015266,
-0.0241996367,
0.0487544015,
-0.0288344994,
-0.0016439168,
-0.0368147455,
-0.0484108403,
-0.0094965911,
-0.0100602685,
0.0369509012,
-0.0183989462,
-0.0022982708,
0.0200080369,
-0.0077189659,
0.0248814858,
0.013087092,
0.0647620559,
0.013750989,
-0.0451909006,
-0.0008393123,
0.0359290168,
-0.044338651,
0.0476496108,
-0.0684396401,
-0.0077958545,
0.0587963946,
-0.0133424159,
0.0522277243,
-0.0981898308,
0.0697427839,
0.0249608085,
0.0133315325,
0.005694652,
-0.0458861105,
0.002690196,
-0.0185111165,
-0.0822570324,
-0.018584894,
0.0206888393,
-0.0146609833,
-0.0266251713,
-0.0087196557,
0.023585109,
0.0096761975,
-0.0217536129,
-0.010755959,
-0.0121141272,
-0.0244163182,
-0.0164898783,
0.0164131764,
-0.0416514352,
0.0275738966,
-0.0011751244,
-0.0146032181,
-0.0018554215,
0.0464973859,
-0.0143237626,
0.0003192308,
-0.0702339783,
0.0304237176,
-0.0044997255,
0.0015552477,
0.0834276602,
-0.0116897253,
-0.0010100723,
0.0316678211,
0.0232921522,
-0.0197740421,
-0.0039456701,
0.0113104349,
0.0127276378,
0.0648540258,
0.0531552844,
-0.0033965243,
0.0284457952,
0.0176330823,
-0.0673674792,
0.0242185518,
0.0292483717,
0.0758208409,
0.0302928928,
0.0115098497,
-0.040106874,
-0.0287589785,
-0.0652527958,
-0.0009504134,
-0.0506895743,
-0.0156244328,
0.0274454262,
0.024288116,
-0.0200396031,
0.0070554866,
0.0185699835,
-0.0279145613,
-0.0612088442,
0.0429112054,
-0.029773403,
0.0172316488,
-0.0162557457,
0.0385836847,
-0.0640505776,
-0.0218408182,
0.0115990471,
-0.0475593768,
-0.0064434549,
0.0310841203,
0.0092701595,
-0.0055540875,
-0.0499782041,
0.0060934043,
-0.0421594791,
0.0058793146,
-0.0120618697,
0.0573443696,
0.0586385876,
0.0215850081,
0.0333496779,
0.0635994226,
-0.0117720217,
-0.0087122321,
-0.0079021528,
0.0263564605,
-0.006271027,
0.0184689183,
0.0293196533,
0.0077119018,
-0.03014897,
-0.0069814711,
-0.0221500769,
-0.0199401677,
0.0195663925,
0.0081400545,
3.116e-7,
0.0073280726,
0.0584285781,
-0.0258325264,
0.0371884108,
-0.0125975432,
0.0581794418,
-0.0078736749,
-0.0644455329,
0.0276957024,
-0.0633467659,
-0.0047825417,
0.0291726608,
0.0290702302,
0.0451343916,
-0.0606737062,
-0.019244466,
-0.0171932653,
-0.0153981587,
-0.0502851754,
-0.0179787744,
0.0240140818,
0.0709801167,
0.0352764502,
-0.013139531,
0.0243950132,
0.0227984767,
0.0499593392,
-0.0177220386,
0.0083767092,
0.0038251316,
0.0143020209,
-0.0313309617,
0.020153258,
0.0260711722,
-0.009110379,
0.040024247,
-0.0629355013,
0.0910342336,
-0.0136687327,
-0.0125545077,
-0.0080950875,
-0.0282842182,
0.0220876895,
-0.0515413247,
0.0821942538,
-0.0477623865,
-0.0308001824,
-0.0221959967,
-0.0107643204,
-0.036879696,
0.0254562795,
0.0037075577,
-0.0140526872,
0.0034548668,
-0.0000494911,
-0.0026111784,
-0.0138346115,
-0.0748343915,
-0.0134518472,
0.0298751071,
-0.0041459231,
-0.0393991619,
-0.0015208707,
0.0320385434,
0.0329249464,
-0.0311755501,
0.0041466528,
3.33733545e-34,
0.0345827192,
0.015300856,
0.0255439393,
0.0175658092,
0.0519443974,
0.0218024123,
0.0036829293,
0.0180594008,
0.0354833901,
-0.0641613603,
0.0011772277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00379v1 | GraphArena: Benchmarking Large Language Models on Graph Computational Problems | 2024-06-29T09:19:23 | 2024-06-29T09:19:23 | Jianheng Tang, Qifan Zhang, Yuhan Li, Jia Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The "arms race" of Large Language Models (LLMs) demands novel, challenging,
and diverse benchmarks to faithfully examine their progresses. We introduce
GraphArena, a benchmarking tool designed to evaluate LLMs on graph
computational problems using million-scale real-world graphs from diverse
scenarios such as knowledge graphs, social networks, and molecular structures.
GraphArena offers a suite of 10 computational tasks, encompassing four
polynomial-time (e.g., Shortest Distance) and six NP-complete challenges (e.g.,
Travelling Salesman Problem). It features a rigorous evaluation framework that
classifies LLM outputs as correct, suboptimal (feasible but not optimal), or
hallucinatory (properly formatted but infeasible). Evaluation of 10 leading
LLMs, including GPT-4o and LLaMA3-70B-Instruct, reveals that even
top-performing models struggle with larger, more complex graph problems and
exhibit hallucination issues. Despite the application of strategies such as
chain-of-thought prompting, these issues remain unresolved. GraphArena
contributes a valuable supplement to the existing LLM benchmarks and is
open-sourced at https://github.com/squareRoot3/GraphArena. | [
0.031203296,
0.052695632,
-0.0065073608,
0.0514647327,
-0.0620819665,
-0.0249543097,
-0.023230372,
0.0105393557,
0.0683572888,
-0.0089247925,
-0.001500381,
-0.0395700857,
0.0132155754,
0.0295873377,
0.0325403102,
-0.0036412003,
0.0183798485,
-0.0608581752,
0.0079902653,
-0.0284548029,
-0.0031116195,
0.0181526523,
0.0228961892,
0.0163734034,
-0.0073544611,
-0.023566246,
0.0009192435,
0.005235075,
-0.0173816364,
-0.0370829701,
-0.0258078128,
0.0430491567,
-0.0099607231,
0.0892053768,
0.000002229,
-0.0344399288,
-0.0239022672,
0.0026261047,
-0.0128329741,
0.0571809337,
0.0595559515,
-0.0003975198,
0.0278981812,
0.0362364314,
-0.0295242947,
-0.0107863639,
0.0463998914,
0.0180073623,
0.0328443162,
0.0672611147,
-0.0158994254,
-0.0136330472,
0.0491990298,
-0.0203836467,
-0.0012505028,
-0.0480908863,
0.0320600793,
0.0489514172,
0.0284372885,
-0.0246707052,
-0.0435837135,
0.0362384133,
0.0002330586,
0.0051559363,
0.0435595363,
0.0124425488,
-0.0478412993,
-0.0047039799,
0.0044517606,
0.1110766828,
-0.0068953759,
-0.0393783301,
0.0011303133,
0.0042427443,
-0.0350844078,
0.0255245361,
-0.0261051189,
-0.0257787146,
-0.0061213411,
0.0214479901,
0.0000977564,
-0.0530170128,
0.081725508,
-0.0090793511,
-0.024407262,
0.1082888693,
0.0299879722,
-0.0022275839,
0.0276957992,
-0.0144580808,
-0.0425644591,
-0.0414304845,
0.0327530205,
0.000984904,
-0.0343556963,
-0.0101297591,
0.0044726077,
0.0258821659,
0.008013729,
-0.0431978665,
0.075866051,
-0.0019155557,
0.039065633,
0.0506571196,
-0.005456429,
0.0548494607,
-0.0488387868,
0.0339817293,
-0.043359343,
-0.0146883335,
-0.0515798181,
0.0112722227,
-0.0474090166,
0.0193447676,
-0.0074630836,
-0.0437500067,
-0.028690448,
0.0330792628,
-0.0131506706,
0.0090952851,
0.0229455736,
-0.0157681946,
0.0465960465,
-0.0273365006,
-0.0090510743,
0.0287358165,
-0.0160673074,
-0.0063668685,
-0.0308619849,
-0.0156163471,
-0.008507831,
0.0050718021,
0.012622131,
-0.018697096,
0.0247682985,
0.0857735425,
0.022607686,
-0.0439603627,
0.0106193246,
0.0061584334,
-0.0241927393,
-0.0839427486,
0.0069076209,
-0.0954918787,
0.0448631458,
0.0411697999,
-0.0042201173,
-0.0546718799,
0.0217323378,
-0.0262976531,
-0.0441413857,
0.0640028864,
-0.0007381369,
0.0400719456,
0.0163964834,
-0.0157002248,
0.0037035143,
0.0155987768,
0.0473905951,
0.0102796815,
0.0313937105,
0.0063192719,
0.0199837126,
0.0638018548,
0.0245854203,
0.0174948201,
-0.0095462808,
-0.0007859448,
0.0234349873,
0.0404366069,
-0.0353008322,
0.1041622534,
-0.0245267507,
-0.0100274729,
0.0363420062,
0.0483163521,
-0.0061059496,
-0.0040846658,
-0.0098350588,
0.0263946801,
-0.0065887962,
-0.0371112861,
-0.0489767417,
0.0016308044,
-0.0427309126,
0.0170685761,
0.0412072502,
-0.0042327465,
0.0048357742,
-0.0006947778,
-0.0174512845,
-0.0102316234,
0.0473273546,
-0.0082554454,
0.0356689356,
-0.0412269719,
-0.0913338512,
0.0291849617,
0.0250793491,
-0.027595941,
-0.0273744334,
-0.0122538628,
-0.0212438777,
0.089710027,
0.05828996,
-0.0115772309,
-0.0224752296,
0.0288668815,
-0.011633453,
0.0254830644,
0.046625305,
-0.0209662449,
-0.0099348519,
-0.0526074618,
0.0005222781,
-0.0061409208,
0.0038217162,
0.0052602999,
0.0427262597,
0.0122141428,
0.016617246,
-0.0709797591,
-0.052278012,
0.0003603512,
-0.016776016,
0.0164512265,
-0.0369039103,
-0.0282115638,
0.0121522425,
0.0318022519,
-0.0263426546,
0.0358502977,
0.0165972617,
-0.0274219457,
0.0086491192,
-0.0322925039,
0.0009905787,
-0.0108928923,
0.0698800981,
-0.0320955515,
-0.012085476,
0.0537500754,
-0.0255001504,
-0.0205869209,
0.0414028801,
-0.0574356057,
0.0413781032,
0.0065018442,
0.0391183868,
-0.0380547382,
0.0187582429,
0.003428048,
0.0522858836,
-0.0115255136,
0.0270344689,
-0.0026451291,
-0.0053490819,
-0.0001867203,
-0.0301600825,
-0.0300360993,
0.0465048142,
0.0361096673,
0.02755077,
0.0367924385,
-0.007457417,
-0.0282899328,
-0.0184768457,
-0.1039102077,
0.0096540675,
0.0004142803,
0.0328394212,
-0.0136596309,
0.0102648679,
-0.0098848315,
0.0105557656,
-0.0396207869,
0.0650027469,
0.0071969717,
0.0140212793,
0.0199517142,
-0.0317495689,
-0.0656128302,
-0.0618562102,
-0.0558394529,
-0.0317827985,
0.0662832335,
-0.0024175954,
-0.0569398887,
-0.0000937257,
0.0615149103,
-0.0527138002,
0.0262320284,
-0.0176083427,
-0.015568913,
0.0066033565,
-0.0263957158,
0.0704612285,
0.0205314253,
-0.0153437098,
-0.0258765742,
0.0649634823,
-0.0276691373,
-0.0177721065,
-0.0120167322,
-0.0444310978,
-0.0094779702,
-0.0399992578,
-0.0590310581,
-0.0430669934,
0.0446685478,
-0.0000149159,
-0.0238525365,
-0.0464621037,
-0.0268586557,
-0.0450725928,
0.0157256629,
-0.0139427343,
0.00333299,
0.0187965203,
0.0176764913,
-0.0496600904,
-0.0369212329,
0.0707855597,
-0.0545680225,
-0.0001728639,
0.0344684869,
-0.0188477356,
-0.0539929792,
0.0837776586,
0.0727702305,
0.0293378141,
-0.0226811953,
0.005679368,
-0.0193175711,
-0.0058450946,
0.0155020207,
-0.0465898328,
0.0130097754,
-0.0233516209,
0.044764325,
0.0187401921,
-0.021884039,
0.0098958695,
0.0158388689,
-0.0570927635,
0.0025562781,
0.0451410674,
-0.0545368791,
-0.0044185403,
0.0224421062,
-0.0018359228,
0.0361119173,
0.0054102922,
0.020362895,
-0.0198533796,
0.0287308488,
0.0389293768,
-0.037849199,
0.0563008934,
-0.0510788262,
0.0206414964,
0.0437888987,
0.0479364134,
0.0091320444,
-0.0376822986,
-0.0011754966,
0.0038381401,
-0.010595588,
-0.0287668481,
-0.0036687399,
0.0355511047,
-0.0248878375,
0.0062668505,
0.0929197446,
0.0347330049,
-0.043707449,
0.0243114401,
-0.0115522686,
0.0357310064,
0.0292050336,
0.0226886701,
-0.1004400626,
-0.0037062019,
0.0018090488,
0.0088000158,
0.02096829,
-0.0733818188,
-0.0141936066,
-0.1065239683,
0.0066285706,
0.0458791815,
-0.008711501,
-0.0214015301,
-0.0661518797,
-0.0339564681,
-0.0064692516,
-0.0194074493,
-0.0024255209,
0.0035360781,
-0.0004063614,
-0.0102667324,
-0.026540352,
0.0058610109,
0.0607393235,
-0.0004029377,
0.0403804779,
-0.0030388527,
0.037995927,
0.0146641331,
-0.0359248966,
0.0641712397,
0.060917329,
-0.0378783792,
-0.0134454025,
0.0038529136,
0.0345092863,
-0.0056348923,
-0.024606023,
-0.0150256315,
-0.0888055861,
-0.0084723625,
-0.0074090767,
0.1048610359,
0.030268481,
-0.0616076179,
0.0183620602,
0.0041761207,
-0.0236205179,
0.0535465814,
0.0218221918,
0.0016593435,
-0.0810326487,
-0.0395390503,
0.0451255664,
-0.0277968943,
-0.0683529526,
0.0189292859,
0.0027337391,
0.022929538,
-0.0338215381,
0.0094405552,
0.0346336141,
-0.0006987597,
-0.003007533,
0.0171893351,
0.0194396637,
-0.0339667834,
-0.0677311197,
0.0003479709,
-0.0553877577,
0.0343054794,
-0.0636913702,
0.0056049,
0.0317955613,
0.0121932179,
-0.0034794877,
0.0463476926,
-0.1041165963,
-0.0919752792,
-0.0334391557,
-0.0196802076,
0.0264940094,
0.0410394222,
-0.0092001352,
-0.0305320546,
0.0307106208,
0.0119410763,
0.0033155533,
0.0209924318,
0.0004663753,
-0.0221712366,
-0.0049209571,
0.0399891473,
-0.0331378914,
0.016697716,
-0.0152213611,
0.0613046288,
-0.0099219671,
-0.0333526768,
0.0214785635,
0.0919622555,
-0.0125015993,
0.0204503573,
-0.0146685829,
-0.0298825577,
-0.0161820129,
-0.0250036474,
-0.0359009951,
-0.0440327264,
-0.0292396974,
0.0521035455,
0.00588988,
0.0128324702,
-0.043467585,
0.0256507881,
0.0358578712,
-0.0210451838,
-0.0173759703,
0.0113201905,
-0.0186005495,
0.0795281231,
-0.0230759867,
-0.0051806103,
0.0246025231,
-0.0207006354,
0.0367124639,
-0.0228922162,
0.0016011727,
0.0033398699,
-0.0177485514,
-0.046592772,
0.0084940838,
-0.0383437872,
-0.0709402114,
-0.0200188942,
0.052548483,
0.0678480864,
0.0325766839,
0.056913469,
-0.0379992574,
-0.0048925313,
-0.0419387184,
0.0243488234,
-0.0101727797,
-0.0394283608,
0.0143347159,
0.0286873858,
0.0099651106,
0.0504409187,
0.0650907159,
0.077746816,
0.041838292,
0.0459820218,
-0.0346212052,
-0.0349672213,
-0.0548475981,
-0.062864922,
0.0204165541,
-0.0209578816,
0.027530726,
-0.0552231893,
-0.0734169707,
0.0077919029,
0.0197812188,
-0.0025189407,
-0.0165909175,
0.034346018,
0.0373616554,
0.0168330055,
-0.0113637978,
-0.0421249494,
0.0255962852,
0.0068553798,
-0.0333233252,
0.0172363184,
-6.948624084e-33,
0.0019825359,
-0.0603699535,
0.0338089354,
0.0027373126,
-0.0538052656,
-0.0010263568,
-0.0861627981,
0.0234510414,
-0.0263383184,
0.0185094383,
-0.0152835073,
0.0233488008,
-0.0188096631,
0.0131525639,
-0.0255772881,
0.0241880976,
0.0148895802,
0.0073884339,
-0.0191263389,
0.0322073065,
0.0103624035,
0.0043018595,
0.0141897462,
-0.03243424,
0.0041299285,
-0.0359244645,
-0.000016949,
0.0183980018,
0.000866141,
0.0139466785,
-0.0439507589,
0.0366027802,
0.0136322407,
-0.0075035808,
0.0098562008,
-0.0252850149,
-0.0234751087,
-0.0075584436,
0.0405412242,
-0.0114427637,
-0.0616504662,
-0.0359871015,
0.039584104,
-0.0011134421,
-0.0289574396,
-0.0151843317,
-0.0006170046,
-0.0038668637,
-0.0451680087,
0.0620563999,
-0.0397969112,
0.0188547987,
-0.0158523098,
0.0071996311,
0.0478544123,
-0.0166573897,
-0.0180368442,
0.0093434397,
-0.0320679136,
0.0369486399,
-0.0045689116,
0.0064809532,
0.0485054664,
-0.0056517273,
0.0213709529,
0.0328306928,
0.0339518487,
-0.0092722205,
0.0119802663,
0.0071335342,
0.0006741547,
0.082688272,
0.0184694454,
-0.000935577,
-0.0323346443,
-0.0061520869,
-0.0710843951,
-0.0483414754,
-0.0147632807,
-0.0267675892,
0.0166807882,
0.0267190728,
-0.0411795378,
-0.0555774458,
-0.0365036018,
-0.0192656592,
-0.0348729603,
-0.0047660042,
-0.0171185657,
-0.0256212242,
-0.0159744564,
-0.0113128368,
0.0088322116,
-0.0613797717,
-0.0380173996,
0.0772417858,
-0.0375848673,
0.0465272218,
-0.005156151,
0.0671315044,
-0.0636398569,
-0.0397440083,
-0.0495137163,
-0.0133988168,
0.0157131311,
-0.0004594161,
-0.0089630233,
0.0018643589,
-0.049906183,
-0.0016436977,
-0.0325249843,
-0.0077171256,
-0.012715715,
-0.0060261781,
0.0471804142,
0.0157035775,
0.0080506373,
0.0389396213,
0.0492714606,
0.0413553827,
0.0242469348,
0.0534413122,
0.0012482954,
0.0166040659,
-0.0072750282,
0.0032168597,
-0.0637754574,
0.033929117,
0.0562461093,
-0.037610855,
-0.0422417782,
-0.024262568,
3.007e-7,
0.047743883,
0.1004913747,
0.0583088733,
0.0435824208,
0.0322377607,
0.0122267986,
-0.00815148,
0.0166702252,
-0.0165932477,
-0.0021310025,
0.0387069471,
0.0460775085,
0.0146121606,
0.0169349108,
-0.0457356237,
0.0496097244,
-0.0882198438,
-0.0226072501,
-0.0555549636,
-0.0009686241,
-0.026820356,
0.0700466707,
0.0439508855,
-0.0018890749,
-0.0406546481,
-0.0563335977,
0.0672225133,
-0.0533377938,
-0.017799804,
0.0340732709,
-0.0254396908,
-0.0016221022,
-0.0246519614,
0.0108855553,
0.0113842534,
0.001112059,
0.034754239,
0.0280816648,
0.0024776987,
0.003982502,
0.0184266996,
-0.0418963693,
-0.0132898809,
-0.0460005514,
0.0471291989,
0.0084904004,
-0.0719612166,
-0.0186522938,
-0.0092470851,
-0.0339664258,
0.034456905,
-0.0032042935,
0.0040795174,
0.0135105345,
0.0021533002,
-0.0210077576,
-0.0015910096,
-0.0214889757,
-0.0065650083,
0.0039061587,
-0.0085331202,
-0.0521039926,
-0.0388888679,
0.03392829,
0.0022989071,
-0.021816019,
0.0340761803,
3.046223815e-34,
0.0726605877,
-0.0059131365,
0.0161002334,
-0.0166520402,
0.0464253426,
-0.0292511638,
-0.0080988742,
0.0006583324,
-0.0143052153,
-0.1205556393,
-0.0165676139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00377v1 | The Factuality Tax of Diversity-Intervened Text-to-Image Generation: Benchmark and Fact-Augmented Intervention | 2024-06-29T09:09:42 | 2024-06-29T09:09:42 | Yixin Wan, Di Wu, Haoran Wang, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY | Prompt-based "diversity interventions" are commonly adopted to improve the
diversity of Text-to-Image (T2I) models depicting individuals with various
racial or gender traits. However, will this strategy result in nonfactual
demographic distribution, especially when generating real historical figures?
In this work, we propose DemOgraphic FActualIty Representation (DoFaiR), a
benchmark to systematically quantify the trade-off between using diversity
interventions and preserving demographic factuality in T2I models. DoFaiR
consists of 756 meticulously fact-checked test instances to reveal the
factuality tax of various diversity prompts through an automated
evidence-supported evaluation pipeline. Experiments on DoFaiR unveil that
diversity-oriented instructions increase the number of different gender and
racial groups in DALLE-3's generations at the cost of historically inaccurate
demographic distributions. To resolve this issue, we propose Fact-Augmented
Intervention (FAI), which instructs a Large Language Model (LLM) to reflect on
verbalized or retrieved factual information about gender and racial
compositions of generation subjects in history, and incorporate it into the
generation context of T2I models. By orienting model generations using the
reflected historical truths, FAI significantly improves the demographic
factuality under diversity interventions while preserving diversity. | [
0.0243014172,
0.0803919882,
-0.0166840442,
0.0086006653,
-0.0228827391,
0.0297124106,
0.0638500229,
-0.0166528095,
-0.0324410424,
-0.0562549904,
0.0436460897,
-0.1003287733,
0.0608151928,
0.0089515038,
0.0069925548,
-0.066675581,
0.0451599881,
0.0286909193,
0.0086235553,
-0.0116726607,
-0.0408033133,
0.0599639378,
-0.0120288106,
0.047304783,
-0.0759493411,
-0.0261489265,
0.0199524891,
0.0144730415,
0.0411818065,
-0.0026881567,
-0.0069280313,
0.0518283769,
0.0058737812,
0.0311825871,
0.0000021009,
-0.0702694282,
0.0064176521,
0.0370159224,
-0.0530360304,
0.0193412658,
0.0636142343,
0.0372114033,
-0.0267302804,
-0.0093885623,
-0.0057035089,
0.0466881469,
0.0727067739,
0.0369570218,
0.0397876948,
0.0363335162,
0.0019945693,
-0.0106546991,
0.0007112214,
-0.0045988434,
0.0289264824,
0.0619765148,
0.0039113024,
0.0129151111,
-0.0235184301,
0.0112256678,
-0.0030832873,
0.0662433505,
0.0112963924,
-0.0080135874,
0.0404192321,
0.0421202891,
0.0139554245,
-0.0387870744,
0.0309825391,
0.0364710316,
0.0555826686,
0.0446907766,
-0.0139885312,
-0.0030673097,
0.0089349952,
0.0142440116,
-0.0075441781,
0.0181163605,
-0.029476922,
-0.0156484805,
-0.0394073948,
-0.0403813496,
0.0213924013,
-0.004266595,
0.012968584,
0.054132469,
0.0132880667,
0.00910242,
-0.0306228641,
0.0296349972,
0.0485511683,
-0.048169665,
0.0139575312,
0.000264992,
-0.0137198307,
0.0087595508,
-0.0255083907,
-0.037662629,
0.0223849285,
-0.0441005751,
0.0253715497,
0.0234394409,
-0.0576258413,
-0.0066577899,
0.01567626,
0.0375399925,
0.0322932787,
-0.0106298113,
-0.0212416872,
-0.0047869263,
-0.0014676823,
-0.0128866741,
0.0043533761,
-0.0201283637,
-0.01045739,
0.0393070318,
-0.0466657728,
-0.0399463475,
-0.04206983,
-0.0022550675,
-0.0264060218,
0.0455471426,
-0.0739600062,
0.004198181,
-0.0818270594,
0.0375952348,
-0.0212337822,
-0.0001179207,
-0.0185019169,
-0.0819688141,
0.0102090267,
-0.0070667746,
0.0070645064,
-0.0355986096,
-0.0026509447,
-0.029067412,
-0.0336345285,
-0.0107270041,
-0.0646690205,
-0.0279855132,
-0.0143110612,
-0.0520156026,
0.0230763443,
-0.0879150182,
0.0326956846,
-0.0145615246,
0.0255923774,
-0.0456280336,
-0.0088395439,
0.0168492254,
-0.0305595454,
0.039289955,
0.043640431,
0.0046835649,
0.0754797161,
-0.0022021062,
-0.010359982,
0.0808122903,
0.0594413318,
-0.0139550641,
0.0185175743,
0.0051928097,
-0.019669598,
0.0051116194,
0.0109725455,
0.0264025256,
-0.0167424921,
-0.0055817645,
0.0017244099,
0.042853862,
0.082910724,
0.0303468108,
0.0226970799,
-0.0253955182,
0.0725113526,
0.0316854194,
0.0155829703,
0.0221932419,
0.0847094655,
-0.016924059,
0.0068731843,
0.0354205854,
-0.0656587854,
0.039234221,
0.0070683281,
-0.0131056644,
-0.0050169979,
0.1092895716,
-0.017454695,
-0.0220290031,
0.02091063,
0.0123311402,
0.0168811474,
-0.0003736313,
-0.0032712801,
0.0113936746,
0.0037261336,
0.0547167733,
0.0302139204,
-0.0330497026,
0.024846429,
-0.0438848212,
0.0367135145,
0.0594725423,
0.0071907523,
0.0030423212,
0.0010307111,
-0.042154111,
0.0084454175,
0.0669310689,
0.0324269198,
0.0173295438,
0.0361095108,
-0.0401689894,
-0.0191629343,
0.0066944608,
0.0108725633,
0.0596119054,
0.0757215917,
0.0161201786,
0.0288075693,
0.0074344333,
-0.0447241142,
0.0345339701,
-0.0464258716,
0.0048826593,
0.012637943,
0.0177630447,
-0.0065955836,
0.0224295743,
-0.0413831696,
-0.0096656894,
-0.0413781591,
0.0379713476,
-0.0084262742,
0.0216318071,
-0.0738250166,
-0.0202397835,
0.0115781343,
-0.086586453,
-0.0585520342,
-0.0054832054,
-0.0136041846,
0.0139764333,
0.0084592141,
-0.0505169034,
-0.0363828614,
-0.0029917445,
0.0031566417,
0.0094566606,
0.0148391789,
0.0040041464,
0.0663180798,
-0.0213007089,
-0.0595642664,
0.0157410372,
0.0030773422,
-0.042149771,
-0.0597459339,
0.0004417081,
0.0026910345,
0.0246787444,
0.0086850645,
0.0194753483,
0.0060655898,
-0.0547331348,
0.0234084595,
-0.0413156673,
0.0002566384,
-0.0061946316,
-0.0338448547,
-0.0300560016,
-0.0253774952,
-0.0032446831,
-0.0018632577,
-0.0311502889,
0.0112446584,
0.0062490897,
0.0319571421,
0.0312520079,
-0.0067542423,
0.0151270768,
-0.0123447673,
-0.0188919455,
-0.0062546339,
0.0585210361,
0.0643470958,
0.0134521881,
-0.0298566334,
-0.0371474698,
-0.0915628895,
-0.0050032171,
0.0036203095,
0.0085713537,
0.0448215157,
0.0531443022,
0.1066797972,
0.0530841798,
0.0541013107,
0.0028261074,
0.0386767238,
-0.0093679661,
-0.0221675057,
0.0046197036,
-0.0064215125,
0.0265909974,
0.0553930774,
-0.1323516816,
-0.0035961841,
-0.0168532263,
0.0144577324,
-0.0074891229,
-0.0813369825,
0.0177128706,
-0.0191664193,
-0.0656851977,
-0.0312982835,
-0.0283515826,
-0.020867385,
0.0057009272,
-0.0671918243,
-0.0292315893,
0.0576993749,
0.0133026326,
0.0194608197,
-0.010762902,
0.0127082206,
-0.0227574557,
0.0221963543,
0.0056382641,
0.0409512334,
0.0494025461,
0.0268266909,
-0.0633031428,
-0.0068459185,
0.0357113294,
-0.0529991053,
0.0956960022,
-0.0651127398,
-0.0120833442,
-0.0061547062,
-0.0067922962,
-0.0479707085,
-0.0127124898,
0.0286357198,
-0.021426402,
-0.0097390991,
-0.0113013703,
-0.057356935,
-0.0300006624,
0.0663462207,
0.0305364747,
-0.028008407,
-0.002050878,
0.0094664246,
-0.0031742973,
0.0169193931,
0.0214826409,
0.0451169014,
-0.044133611,
0.0040695537,
0.0180524178,
-0.0617852136,
-0.0170391835,
-0.0153470868,
0.0056180456,
-0.0127525236,
0.0219509974,
-0.0249362141,
0.0168940835,
0.0689558089,
-0.0293075405,
0.0104804048,
0.0529090241,
0.0205935147,
-0.0171838384,
-0.0116536021,
0.0080678705,
0.0009881685,
-0.0120736836,
-0.0131130321,
-0.0627869889,
0.0516534299,
-0.0066456194,
-0.0004535991,
-0.0552829616,
-0.0497438014,
-0.040449746,
-0.118377544,
0.0629071146,
0.024336867,
-0.0130704744,
-0.0284485593,
-0.0001054792,
0.016143376,
0.0141051607,
0.0287728906,
-0.016482152,
0.0289047081,
0.0078216521,
-0.0010911722,
-0.0264323466,
-0.0369308703,
0.0095762927,
-0.0175416525,
0.0231511481,
0.0254261289,
0.0737444162,
0.0098638907,
-0.042292431,
-0.0139356432,
0.0257497709,
0.0057001933,
-0.0044774371,
0.0688283294,
0.016180912,
-0.0043998654,
-0.0430433378,
0.0100092487,
0.0959729999,
-0.0275893249,
0.0051627872,
0.0005074611,
0.0019019671,
-0.0137676345,
-0.034942098,
0.0359508954,
0.0142261973,
0.0632770211,
0.0363106504,
-0.0146862725,
0.0428741872,
-0.0648192838,
0.0516745523,
-0.0691216514,
-0.0395570882,
0.0229757465,
-0.0464767106,
-0.0458095819,
-0.0611489639,
-0.0219535287,
-0.0066487789,
0.0147183547,
-0.016630521,
-0.0880015641,
-0.0057832636,
-0.0027740323,
-0.0064621195,
0.0770421848,
-0.054184828,
0.0350506604,
-0.0081793042,
-0.0540066175,
-0.0238672215,
-0.0523064733,
0.0201289821,
0.0094370954,
-0.0556275509,
-0.0359053686,
0.0701975599,
0.0489606783,
0.0195826609,
0.0406362191,
0.0364936665,
-0.0398921221,
0.0745556206,
0.0615167171,
0.0300781522,
0.0206505824,
-0.0392200574,
0.0215034448,
-0.0209115203,
0.0073997532,
-0.0232109055,
0.0137274694,
-0.0218716972,
-0.0129436236,
-0.0233339537,
-0.041968286,
-0.0142413368,
0.0079118023,
-0.0158344898,
-0.058123555,
-0.0182458479,
-0.038501922,
-0.0385702774,
-0.0475434251,
-0.0221295264,
-0.0155151905,
-0.0281174853,
-0.0028518464,
0.0119744465,
0.0067838873,
-0.0025094233,
-0.027803259,
0.0390196592,
-0.049732279,
-0.0215350781,
0.0077500674,
0.0594523437,
0.0109668989,
0.0283227209,
-0.0202057716,
0.050130181,
-0.0587184839,
0.0486605093,
0.0224880502,
0.0592280179,
0.0117488969,
-0.013063008,
-0.0252294727,
-0.0214088485,
-0.0410961471,
0.0241136439,
-0.0485736094,
0.0293376166,
0.037892472,
0.0060405773,
0.0542403385,
-0.0239167083,
-0.022574598,
-0.0075416812,
-0.0079928553,
0.0423962288,
-0.0183257796,
0.0267628767,
-0.0163214952,
0.0357230864,
-0.0374995396,
0.0031568282,
-0.0264911782,
0.0309883859,
-0.0117930593,
-0.0404753238,
-0.0206143595,
-0.0571067929,
-0.003424471,
-0.0576367341,
0.0037765508,
-0.0077862344,
-0.0931841284,
-0.0532703772,
0.0263187215,
0.0131003419,
0.0165314544,
-0.0191364549,
0.0187412407,
0.01035346,
-0.0215602722,
-0.0501277745,
-0.0180830937,
0.0487932041,
-0.0235345569,
0.0061207805,
-0.0185023006,
-6.581358506e-33,
-0.0617420226,
-0.0381352529,
0.0095613245,
-0.0820998922,
-0.0376493484,
0.0291974712,
-0.0219724197,
-0.0088473624,
-0.0149416039,
0.0339920372,
0.0215891823,
-0.0009701709,
0.0280243866,
-0.0019878927,
-0.0445122607,
0.0273619555,
0.0789544359,
0.0017645995,
-0.0675565228,
0.0005054067,
0.0024636635,
-0.0302667208,
0.0511115231,
-0.0278617237,
0.0507293679,
0.0003701634,
-0.0071963933,
-0.0112871798,
-0.0033171605,
0.0180360395,
0.0018669429,
0.0521560349,
0.0188389793,
-0.0484271683,
-0.0005043231,
0.0309641231,
-0.0595992543,
-0.029664997,
0.0240626987,
0.0024139311,
-0.0270405095,
-0.0461582653,
-0.0086087622,
0.013059156,
-0.0108617218,
-0.0899472088,
0.0617656,
-0.0264467373,
0.0354109854,
0.0138890808,
-0.0377618484,
0.00719313,
-0.0172216445,
0.0072763516,
-0.0432432257,
0.0413377918,
0.0140384585,
-0.01520353,
-0.0703029856,
0.0148666212,
0.0641427264,
-0.038962312,
0.0366682038,
0.0524331294,
-0.007402454,
0.0005323636,
0.0028867084,
0.0302322507,
-0.077390328,
-0.0400428362,
0.0428970084,
-0.0229175165,
0.0245112609,
0.1209627315,
0.0149972429,
-0.0156069193,
-0.024570113,
0.032615371,
0.0100902105,
0.0040703225,
0.0075213611,
-0.0333165899,
-0.0211696196,
-0.0057906564,
-0.0210994612,
-0.0216948371,
-0.0047424524,
-0.0357345566,
-0.0000241285,
-0.0154513679,
-0.050254751,
0.0212849136,
0.0355735011,
0.0254236162,
-0.0144038191,
-0.0073170811,
-0.03464384,
0.0018351247,
0.012100663,
0.0023836205,
-0.0267391298,
0.0380156338,
0.0857091546,
0.0619773306,
0.0281754695,
0.0291927438,
0.016613692,
0.0084126852,
-0.052052319,
0.0145093659,
-0.0148120588,
0.0205672532,
0.0199944545,
-0.0206392426,
0.0041778013,
0.0257791299,
-0.0320451222,
-0.0079779467,
0.023146132,
0.0270244461,
-0.0280557461,
-0.0232359543,
-0.0069424473,
0.0262547992,
-0.0369606614,
0.0249604993,
-0.010382276,
-0.0055146106,
0.0686763301,
-0.0280941781,
-0.0352164544,
-0.0311928671,
2.609e-7,
-0.0022625369,
0.004706664,
0.0235254783,
0.0222127587,
0.0112261018,
0.0280278884,
0.0077514346,
-0.0011459447,
0.0703645349,
-0.0348746851,
-0.0118845617,
0.0700467452,
0.0336185768,
0.0526962578,
-0.0080231875,
-0.0129208667,
-0.0568935648,
0.0055332975,
-0.04559578,
0.0364599861,
0.0277192723,
0.0446218848,
0.0137823643,
-0.0342905298,
-0.0119965542,
0.0325220749,
0.0458745174,
-0.0105237057,
-0.0474494137,
-0.0082258554,
0.0198452193,
-0.0288465712,
0.0338042453,
0.0261452422,
-0.002599326,
0.0014799539,
-0.0170363989,
0.0188605543,
-0.0028826757,
0.0260202084,
-0.0199424569,
0.0330403149,
-0.0326998383,
-0.058463946,
0.0476852208,
0.0404553078,
-0.0293581057,
-0.0650735125,
-0.0519940555,
0.0479688197,
0.0443070121,
-0.0387699641,
-0.0570490584,
0.0211442988,
0.0056677982,
0.0059164059,
-0.0138146924,
-0.0361894518,
-0.0254806019,
-0.0144873457,
-0.0303249881,
-0.0828171968,
-0.0067192628,
0.0124585517,
-0.0299157854,
-0.020948045,
0.054945875,
2.353760297e-34,
-0.0038870655,
0.0283902027,
0.0183544774,
-0.0741760284,
0.0241922438,
0.0022594174,
-0.0009775345,
-0.0280483365,
0.0423999801,
-0.0095000304,
-0.0188591871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00369v1 | How to Train Your Fact Verifier: Knowledge Transfer with Multimodal Open Models | 2024-06-29T08:39:07 | 2024-06-29T08:39:07 | Jaeyoung Lee, Ximing Lu, Jack Hessel, Faeze Brahman, Youngjae Yu, Yonatan Bisk, Yejin Choi, Saadia Gabriel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given the growing influx of misinformation across news and social media,
there is a critical need for systems that can provide effective real-time
verification of news claims. Large language or multimodal model based
verification has been proposed to scale up online policing mechanisms for
mitigating spread of false and harmful content. While these can potentially
reduce burden on human fact-checkers, such efforts may be hampered by
foundation model training data becoming outdated. In this work, we test the
limits of improving foundation model performance without continual updating
through an initial study of knowledge transfer using either existing intra- and
inter- domain benchmarks or explanations generated from large language models
(LLMs). We evaluate on 12 public benchmarks for fact-checking and
misinformation detection as well as two other tasks relevant to content
moderation -- toxicity and stance detection. Our results on two recent
multi-modal fact-checking benchmarks, Mocheg and Fakeddit, indicate that
knowledge transfer strategies can improve Fakeddit performance over the
state-of-the-art by up to 1.7% and Mocheg performance by up to 2.9%. | [
0.02386708,
0.0557853542,
0.0194343626,
0.0426868647,
-0.0432229079,
0.0001870279,
0.033647269,
-0.0115215788,
-0.0251420513,
-0.065647319,
-0.0032715525,
-0.0343905352,
-0.0180324409,
0.0382061079,
0.006060259,
-0.0306286514,
0.0869539678,
-0.0166160762,
0.0169941448,
-0.0145760328,
0.0413103998,
0.0317471549,
-0.0449151769,
0.0140349008,
-0.0560065508,
-0.0219163448,
0.009378274,
-0.0020918851,
0.0459262021,
-0.0176489931,
-0.0082945516,
0.0469240658,
0.0484779477,
0.0661842152,
0.0000017966,
-0.028825555,
-0.0159319192,
0.0240489542,
-0.036235977,
-0.0021991737,
0.0559915416,
-0.0418122038,
-0.0139042735,
0.0278208777,
-0.0036681667,
-0.0170039944,
0.0534025095,
0.0688522086,
0.1143212244,
0.0948948562,
-0.0083442004,
-0.0085372953,
0.0264184047,
0.009166522,
-0.0267127026,
-0.0348617882,
0.0459770598,
0.0487987995,
-0.0635981783,
0.0262720101,
-0.0132975504,
0.0293146223,
0.0087542301,
-0.0291807856,
-0.017572185,
-0.0000825259,
0.0035031082,
0.0028060847,
-0.0089603877,
0.0758024305,
0.0031311125,
-0.0278204698,
-0.0131236957,
0.0150202215,
-0.0151224136,
0.0802127495,
-0.037656974,
0.0337876938,
-0.041841872,
-0.0100998934,
-0.0036313317,
-0.0325413533,
0.051242739,
0.0478568934,
0.0175595898,
0.0280761328,
-0.0128911939,
-0.0152274696,
0.0391638801,
0.0120612588,
-0.0065921098,
-0.0634352937,
-0.007355622,
0.0029144508,
0.0007262817,
-0.0053251218,
-0.0545577407,
-0.0217557177,
0.0084669758,
-0.0737790763,
0.0172061473,
0.0140028801,
-0.053913381,
0.0719255507,
-0.0144739468,
-0.0055030375,
-0.0423688181,
0.0071818656,
0.0048151282,
-0.0180418491,
-0.0587072112,
0.0403276458,
0.000706483,
0.0114760399,
-0.0169800576,
-0.005070358,
-0.0143899247,
-0.0282594599,
-0.0210232623,
-0.0217588674,
-0.0134197837,
-0.0235935077,
-0.0144246742,
-0.0136941839,
-0.0489631332,
0.0838824585,
-0.0064579137,
0.0235655066,
0.0063850852,
-0.0482687913,
-0.0177174769,
0.0291621611,
-0.0165414903,
-0.0110557033,
0.0187652148,
0.0251276512,
-0.0048501845,
0.0221872255,
-0.045827657,
-0.0236919485,
-0.0073470217,
-0.0886876583,
0.0244044121,
-0.0760783032,
0.0095363511,
-0.0266382247,
-0.0076025818,
-0.0249062572,
-0.0097939763,
0.009573699,
-0.0384193026,
0.0614128262,
-0.0074089305,
0.0009295813,
0.026026804,
0.0260935593,
-0.0179480165,
0.0662512109,
-0.0066601108,
0.0375190899,
0.0424335115,
0.0047141169,
-0.0177751463,
0.0003671852,
0.054665491,
0.0539866835,
0.0150512215,
0.0032291035,
0.0015874417,
-0.0067712604,
0.019594457,
0.0224093422,
-0.038087301,
-0.0266406257,
0.1120068207,
-0.0540823638,
0.0045266463,
-0.0316214152,
0.052333422,
-0.0032476038,
0.0217428487,
-0.0344697721,
-0.0563741922,
0.0345804952,
-0.0512062348,
-0.0310315602,
-0.0223931987,
0.095587045,
-0.0106921745,
0.0049509509,
0.0003679514,
-0.0046598511,
0.0098832306,
-0.0088885464,
0.0260184165,
0.0222580843,
-0.0356046744,
0.045065321,
0.0635409504,
-0.0022222195,
-0.0175989456,
-0.0569522567,
0.0234074816,
0.0076493197,
0.0175881665,
0.0006628382,
-0.0253432225,
-0.0585093014,
0.0592775382,
0.0275968462,
0.0688167214,
-0.0307269227,
-0.0025026998,
-0.018755598,
-0.0176101178,
-0.0296839327,
0.0193183366,
0.0339057297,
0.0516470149,
0.0443012342,
-0.0140495952,
-0.0112836463,
-0.0060479771,
0.0129841017,
0.0175104402,
0.0125278458,
-0.0355108567,
0.0101249823,
0.0227976348,
0.007951526,
-0.0231972281,
-0.0328176357,
0.0103384964,
0.0093012778,
-0.033225961,
-0.001987136,
-0.0045867106,
-0.0014024797,
0.0356474854,
-0.0257746056,
-0.0261425767,
0.0447950102,
-0.0294535458,
0.0405907631,
0.0010379835,
-0.0115313241,
-0.0240240525,
-0.0390470624,
-0.0261236578,
-0.0204867944,
0.0216986611,
0.0233867634,
0.0752264634,
-0.0241324306,
-0.0539519265,
-0.0020837167,
-0.0265942458,
0.0153611517,
0.0006757139,
0.004459539,
0.0091504967,
0.0033418722,
0.0236784145,
0.0034973337,
-0.0278239194,
-0.0321089625,
0.0340441279,
-0.084352307,
0.0049881143,
-0.0061741578,
0.0052397023,
0.0348417573,
-0.0177647863,
0.0214960091,
0.0382456183,
-0.0113357166,
0.0137106199,
0.0164621267,
0.0310655665,
0.0038145522,
-0.0105069373,
-0.0028800431,
-0.0062747919,
0.0223358758,
-0.0057717934,
0.0497593284,
0.0056771194,
-0.0345906876,
-0.0340898111,
-0.0177646168,
-0.0613346733,
0.0240699463,
-0.0329767317,
-0.0255469121,
0.0372080542,
0.0057630264,
-0.0162605494,
0.0374901704,
0.0371787883,
0.057050664,
0.0380849652,
0.0052665458,
-0.0193069391,
-0.0078342371,
-0.0211369507,
0.0081630051,
-0.0409959741,
-0.0082969163,
-0.0080254991,
0.0358303264,
0.0075450097,
-0.004293384,
-0.0157743543,
0.0472588725,
-0.0072239279,
-0.0365951136,
-0.0053460933,
-0.025313016,
0.0154841729,
0.0135163218,
-0.0486974642,
-0.0307649989,
0.0641986504,
-0.0240766015,
0.0540151037,
-0.0060498631,
-0.0301045496,
0.0100744162,
0.0283417329,
-0.027078392,
0.0540728606,
0.0189135615,
0.0394483395,
-0.0095898611,
-0.0357836522,
0.0870055482,
-0.0231921244,
-0.0062209852,
-0.0407597534,
0.0286999289,
0.0349966995,
-0.0487048067,
-0.0374143049,
-0.0790795237,
-0.0327124223,
-0.0243146457,
-0.0517579801,
-0.0342743956,
-0.0607592762,
-0.0038410062,
0.0559810214,
0.010540369,
-0.0014185879,
-0.0009465073,
0.0306815989,
0.0130131608,
0.0266582184,
0.0333003774,
0.0612438433,
-0.0369831137,
0.0027449541,
0.0856416449,
-0.0192692596,
-0.0095180944,
-0.0603130907,
-0.0263904799,
-0.0257492363,
0.0016723773,
0.0003015174,
-0.0235037729,
0.0551415421,
-0.0440152958,
0.0254024882,
0.0595410392,
-0.0355176851,
0.0264927167,
-0.005277507,
0.0387214087,
-0.0291279759,
0.0150945121,
-0.0176181477,
-0.1034885719,
-0.0345530286,
0.0040810918,
0.0152362995,
-0.0194443483,
-0.0334685557,
-0.016161561,
-0.1086838767,
0.0408958457,
-0.0192186758,
-0.0333496779,
-0.0315592326,
-0.064814128,
0.0090132179,
-0.0102176731,
-0.0106661115,
0.0098043047,
0.0402763523,
-0.0237715188,
0.0096919555,
0.0405506864,
-0.0559678487,
0.0404366106,
-0.0384193696,
0.0432198383,
-0.0034465299,
0.0149138309,
-0.0124682644,
-0.0457901657,
0.0337772965,
0.0404692926,
-0.0073335371,
-0.0104859434,
0.093720153,
-0.0495462306,
-0.0054780142,
-0.0351608209,
0.0324991792,
0.0281694997,
-0.0193464477,
-0.0216071513,
0.0912498906,
0.0333070606,
-0.0377080925,
-0.0429114699,
0.0221608132,
0.0434147865,
0.0583759174,
-0.0085118208,
0.003085776,
0.0101755904,
-0.0049724285,
-0.0437498204,
-0.0138877993,
-0.0639487803,
0.032819543,
-0.0257723965,
-0.030881824,
-0.0676974058,
0.0215313807,
-0.0197145641,
0.0718027949,
-0.0203805491,
-0.0390777513,
0.0201675724,
0.0156937018,
-0.0205272827,
0.0489720814,
-0.0363772064,
0.0528703406,
-0.0150435138,
0.006738733,
0.0114421407,
-0.0398115516,
-0.0347809345,
0.0297952127,
-0.0866276175,
-0.0524235032,
-0.0054324064,
0.0473405905,
0.0265195873,
0.0460145846,
-0.0173005145,
-0.0096747205,
0.0031951501,
0.0425327085,
-0.0527635477,
0.0210827366,
0.0515492633,
-0.0454119444,
0.0235235393,
0.0057307989,
-0.0143292062,
0.0295132324,
0.0448940806,
-0.0304162856,
-0.0146922842,
-0.0116895186,
0.0226281062,
0.0440979153,
0.0499248467,
0.0252728797,
-0.0229696743,
-0.0342497192,
-0.0232088864,
-0.0006876757,
-0.0349785052,
-0.011041265,
0.0475386493,
0.0370522253,
-0.0038383987,
-0.0017740418,
0.0022169091,
0.0143579654,
0.029404033,
-0.0218136869,
-0.017914677,
0.0350510962,
0.0351982079,
0.0193979274,
-0.0097020352,
-0.0356581993,
-0.0147049949,
0.0033323916,
0.0042876429,
-0.019367978,
0.0495350473,
0.0340875238,
-0.0101023847,
0.0207005944,
-0.0389298238,
-0.0601799749,
-0.0173289031,
-0.0373301357,
0.0211679302,
0.0323598646,
0.0161197651,
0.0309683364,
-0.0162330605,
-0.0414513573,
-0.0011195502,
0.0144200977,
0.0023059119,
-0.0104571646,
0.0284192227,
0.0327403322,
0.0019908461,
0.0386786461,
0.0355778746,
-0.0036328326,
0.0693206117,
0.0202035364,
-0.0637760386,
-0.0259887185,
-0.0231756885,
-0.0345002785,
0.0361413695,
0.0132040838,
0.0174023081,
-0.0801432803,
-0.0654230639,
0.0189314727,
0.0045347237,
0.0144249322,
0.0323129483,
-0.0057792016,
0.0797219202,
0.03063442,
-0.0268027186,
-0.0240911692,
0.0118738832,
-0.0200283397,
-0.0016646637,
0.0473563671,
-6.359384765e-33,
-0.0008340277,
-0.029696364,
-0.0232591238,
-0.0229699165,
-0.0562689565,
0.0192347709,
0.0127047636,
-0.0111605385,
-0.0359166823,
0.0564974174,
0.0394982956,
0.0368761644,
-0.0044643185,
-0.0098858271,
-0.0693531707,
-0.0068646669,
0.0463241376,
-0.0106927268,
-0.0468916632,
-0.0006959361,
0.056047827,
-0.0073106238,
0.044947166,
-0.0961322114,
0.0247834884,
0.0056405058,
-0.0350827985,
0.0194607545,
-0.0236579999,
0.0649660975,
-0.0068775588,
0.031307511,
0.040321745,
-0.0624978319,
0.0066455677,
0.0070432732,
-0.0823154673,
0.0082738781,
0.0548950545,
-0.0202583019,
-0.0166553818,
0.0058422396,
0.0247766506,
0.0071178926,
-0.0019366428,
-0.0463402681,
-0.0015831732,
-0.0322638266,
0.0264295731,
-0.0039747907,
-0.0588600375,
0.0158787202,
-0.0096873967,
-0.0158859473,
-0.0279921722,
0.0175909381,
0.0185335707,
-0.0119490037,
-0.0581193343,
0.0207457561,
-0.046201501,
-0.0184474532,
0.038998507,
-0.0233592242,
-0.0409352705,
0.0754028782,
-0.0298292022,
0.0159906596,
-0.0638232827,
0.0345332809,
0.0044655893,
0.0772801861,
0.0541656949,
0.1310134381,
0.014945861,
-0.0403618068,
-0.1180941015,
0.0033979989,
0.0133442795,
0.0216068551,
0.0142095927,
-0.0147318663,
-0.0117228273,
0.0135935135,
-0.0467116907,
-0.0040211347,
-0.0361653417,
-0.0235037785,
0.0123330774,
0.0330243781,
-0.0519623272,
0.0163061563,
0.0165734068,
-0.0496873148,
0.0124749728,
0.0424073525,
-0.0292854421,
0.0240701213,
0.0017458578,
0.0354252383,
-0.0784447044,
0.0123029863,
0.0359970555,
0.0099109476,
0.0217331666,
-0.0049685631,
0.078738451,
0.0330878645,
-0.0478333272,
0.0174891055,
-0.0344862901,
0.0423878655,
-0.0041760253,
0.028987471,
0.0211455952,
0.0088121183,
-0.0322623439,
0.0047517065,
0.0068472004,
0.0176514555,
-0.0221613403,
-0.0106432233,
0.00818229,
0.0159513149,
-0.0267819669,
-0.0047757034,
-0.0494095534,
-0.0358534604,
-0.0158562157,
-0.1101091728,
-0.0124614686,
0.0110317552,
2.716e-7,
0.0093516801,
0.0553651825,
-0.0119006345,
0.0068447874,
0.0280952007,
0.0481216013,
0.0073831226,
0.0146333687,
-0.0109874858,
-0.1132176295,
-0.0598977171,
0.0846214667,
0.0263115149,
0.0515094288,
-0.0101149427,
-0.0236491319,
-0.0206420962,
-0.0219679046,
-0.0374582745,
0.0002297732,
0.0006673771,
0.037149176,
0.0511950478,
-0.0435968637,
0.0309006423,
-0.0083519556,
0.0753152072,
0.0493249148,
-0.0526275486,
-0.0256553032,
0.0686156452,
-0.0227584019,
-0.0102264434,
0.036769405,
-0.0021972528,
-0.0165466238,
-0.0053371419,
0.0477075689,
0.0023413175,
0.0057398994,
-0.0164852049,
-0.0284460858,
-0.0003034656,
-0.0233594459,
0.0738442764,
0.0127628166,
-0.0380956382,
-0.0960873216,
-0.0606926344,
-0.0162464846,
0.0022764064,
-0.0193072762,
-0.0054102801,
-0.0000481117,
-0.0039025333,
0.0239476245,
-0.0205375738,
-0.0317859538,
0.0010238894,
-0.0010153211,
-0.0453010611,
-0.0903430954,
0.0299700797,
-0.0433434322,
0.0698687807,
-0.0400577076,
0.0144386934,
2.119437666e-34,
0.0269831214,
-0.00395231,
0.0168863293,
-0.0680077896,
0.0515189618,
0.0250945445,
-0.0542536527,
-0.0518373437,
0.0168984234,
-0.0308985915,
-0.0003911607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00365v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00365v1 | Financial Knowledge Large Language Model | 2024-06-29T08:26:49 | 2024-06-29T08:26:49 | Cehao Yang, Chengjin Xu, Yiyan Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial intelligence is making significant strides in the finance
industry, revolutionizing how data is processed and interpreted. Among these
technologies, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated substantial
potential to transform financial services by automating complex tasks,
enhancing customer service, and providing detailed financial analysis. Firstly,
we introduce IDEA-FinBench, an evaluation benchmark specifically tailored for
assessing financial knowledge in large language models (LLMs). This benchmark
utilizes questions from two globally respected and authoritative financial
professional exams, aimimg to comprehensively evaluate the capability of LLMs
to directly address exam questions pertinent to the finance sector. Secondly,
we propose IDEA-FinKER, a Financial Knowledge Enhancement framework designed to
facilitate the rapid adaptation of general LLMs to the financial domain,
introducing a retrieval-based few-shot learning method for real-time
context-level knowledge injection, and a set of high-quality financial
knowledge instructions for fine-tuning any general LLM. Finally, we present
IDEA-FinQA, a financial question-answering system powered by LLMs. This system
is structured around a scheme of real-time knowledge injection and factual
enhancement using external knowledge. IDEA-FinQA is comprised of three main
modules: the data collector, the data querying module, and LLM-based agents
tasked with specific functions. | [
-0.004603514,
0.0398391448,
-0.0265414007,
0.0269645639,
-0.012409322,
0.0100062732,
0.0371530354,
0.0344697535,
0.0152902286,
-0.0289998632,
-0.0162772723,
-0.0063539492,
-0.0371906459,
0.0614301041,
0.0636679307,
0.0002506167,
0.0337792076,
-0.0129328277,
0.0724292994,
-0.0110946121,
0.0140295448,
-0.036561884,
-0.0047941376,
-0.0032463253,
-0.0038359347,
-0.0087441122,
-0.0299933162,
-0.033747714,
0.0121753076,
-0.0112621281,
-0.0015219408,
-0.0019439039,
0.0044955993,
0.0403702185,
0.0000021984,
-0.0689230189,
-0.0398713611,
0.0268641915,
-0.06112881,
-0.0297700539,
-0.0153113641,
0.0079869498,
0.0466658399,
0.003769961,
-0.0797894821,
0.0495005324,
0.0469701514,
0.0317695327,
0.0779264942,
0.0793453157,
0.0005505641,
-0.0526330955,
0.0189310461,
-0.0140402559,
0.0194453076,
-0.0729208589,
0.0302054323,
0.051829014,
0.0032764643,
-0.0178696923,
-0.0291166641,
0.0444123447,
0.0107667278,
0.001096326,
0.064234525,
0.0051802257,
-0.0546767376,
0.0267886017,
-0.0407728069,
0.0402202234,
0.0382064842,
0.0455517881,
0.0105998497,
-0.0203203205,
0.0110298721,
0.0381561369,
-0.0594027378,
0.0205701608,
-0.0125804041,
-0.040580146,
0.0060334406,
-0.0072704717,
0.0103834951,
0.0149058485,
-0.0481596589,
0.0502481163,
-0.018203292,
-0.043829672,
0.0409317128,
0.0075274864,
-0.0255678389,
-0.0538990833,
0.0116716959,
0.0799645185,
0.0329542793,
-0.0115033817,
0.0532902665,
-0.0536601171,
0.0122214518,
-0.0621912442,
0.0386764817,
0.0345241986,
-0.0038665636,
0.059964437,
-0.0362166241,
0.0560175888,
0.024075469,
-0.0147212939,
-0.0363045074,
0.0037210274,
-0.0860972106,
-0.0148351379,
-0.0458385609,
0.1159552857,
-0.0312213227,
-0.0200172253,
-0.0447088033,
-0.0051881322,
-0.0204408895,
0.0416536964,
-0.0113439877,
-0.0260233767,
-0.006111138,
0.0066171549,
-0.0789939538,
0.0140463412,
-0.0728195086,
0.0032435125,
-0.0009222628,
-0.0099174492,
0.0199259352,
0.0176369902,
-0.0350308679,
-0.0092602186,
0.0348224081,
0.0874749795,
0.0399847701,
-0.0279949196,
-0.0387743637,
-0.0549027622,
0.0014989213,
-0.0257336069,
-0.0381221622,
-0.0457577109,
-0.0046240017,
-0.012653891,
-0.0709199384,
0.0199759007,
0.0076521444,
0.00696168,
0.0076206867,
0.0628973022,
-0.0163414627,
-0.0201150011,
0.0460831448,
-0.035476923,
-0.0153154274,
0.0466185436,
-0.0154289408,
0.0090920646,
0.0379302278,
0.0068070241,
0.0250992067,
0.0371544324,
0.0264417101,
-0.0662312061,
0.0145594934,
0.0805544779,
0.0053917663,
-0.0010211109,
0.0129538318,
0.0151637327,
-0.0185880028,
0.0158237852,
0.0447730124,
0.0439334661,
0.06234264,
0.0060978564,
0.0136883948,
0.0414361544,
0.0555000566,
-0.0404989682,
-0.0001773824,
0.0342750624,
-0.0530424044,
0.0331102163,
-0.0328916125,
0.0220117904,
-0.0384900458,
-0.0441041924,
0.0124366628,
-0.0134688392,
-0.0474268571,
0.0488490649,
0.0431997664,
-0.0242452454,
-0.0280550271,
0.0416595675,
0.0062265205,
0.0248048473,
-0.022882266,
-0.0490528606,
0.0699680299,
0.0831763446,
0.0525183156,
-0.0444814377,
0.0050590006,
-0.0102753369,
-0.0313285589,
0.032399375,
0.0554062091,
-0.0205450039,
-0.0391296074,
-0.0290230159,
-0.0014891938,
0.0130815832,
-0.003264433,
0.0050583514,
-0.0031472631,
-0.0059404932,
-0.0224270709,
0.0032091879,
0.015739426,
0.0089256298,
-0.0068434039,
-0.0604255423,
0.005236424,
0.0026246149,
-0.0243146196,
0.0368791446,
0.0041762046,
0.0118748536,
0.0033195822,
-0.0083315289,
-0.0376868397,
-0.0244752616,
-0.0185418036,
-0.0080927806,
0.02290437,
-0.0246798843,
-0.0221589021,
-0.0023582079,
-0.0363481082,
-0.0072629703,
-0.0342373848,
-0.0202724319,
0.0066037732,
-0.0641620755,
-0.0281703845,
0.0030691251,
0.0033631811,
-0.0285680816,
0.0909271762,
0.012573598,
0.0197173636,
-0.0139624467,
0.0050520264,
0.000825581,
-0.0510370806,
0.0460713319,
-0.0307257976,
-0.0334045477,
0.0293513313,
0.0356455594,
0.0146087315,
-0.0209405236,
0.0125223799,
-0.0723328814,
-0.01604864,
0.0122980066,
0.0171937849,
-0.0102316076,
-0.0079080602,
0.0066010072,
-0.0223848466,
-0.0630916879,
0.0364270844,
0.0036398941,
0.0040579713,
0.07926476,
0.0284569375,
-0.0296594705,
-0.0400702581,
0.0042920471,
-0.0136764441,
0.0176635291,
0.0651914328,
-0.0013925148,
0.0080665248,
-0.0424570851,
-0.0319721103,
-0.0038857721,
0.0086506354,
0.0214154795,
0.0005147191,
-0.0401305109,
-0.0151348766,
0.0563600622,
-0.0044350158,
0.0312968493,
-0.0484356843,
-0.0233787224,
-0.0442288816,
0.022579696,
0.0046249367,
0.0191944689,
-0.0202772208,
0.0383285247,
0.0221603941,
0.042043563,
-0.017160669,
-0.0107069854,
-0.0488959551,
0.0978815407,
0.0066907299,
-0.036301896,
-0.0749096349,
0.0190802533,
-0.0086733941,
0.054491654,
0.0096900491,
-0.0166298095,
0.0610359386,
0.0005507847,
-0.0229015499,
0.00236013,
-0.0292964894,
-0.0478115715,
0.0332267359,
-0.04710529,
0.0268467963,
-0.0370077677,
-0.0181328878,
-0.0466789156,
-0.0315320045,
0.0438631885,
-0.0396106765,
0.043397326,
-0.0297218785,
0.0065003443,
0.0072921738,
-0.0299787298,
-0.018585518,
-0.0775119811,
-0.0290555265,
0.0236835852,
0.0202150419,
-0.0387986489,
-0.0328895412,
0.0122392625,
0.0277038254,
-0.0375355706,
-0.0081956536,
-0.056102071,
0.0090262359,
0.0461481437,
0.0494473688,
0.0122299874,
0.0383362435,
-0.0314312987,
0.0968554914,
0.0208997745,
0.0097260131,
0.0109961806,
0.0133562144,
-0.0059429212,
-0.0256130677,
-0.0628367215,
-0.0006632152,
0.0174984839,
-0.0289940685,
-0.0729793534,
-0.0272456072,
0.0988304615,
0.0272679739,
0.0285884235,
-0.0169303231,
-0.0389979146,
-0.0355969518,
-0.002138013,
0.095354706,
-0.1358807236,
-0.0115534859,
-0.0134728868,
0.0258068349,
-0.0023533718,
-0.054158885,
-0.0228070077,
-0.1370949745,
0.0499023348,
-0.0371147543,
-0.02815759,
-0.0201582164,
-0.0144808972,
-0.0303399917,
-0.0078455163,
0.0007203408,
0.0420608521,
0.0091903303,
0.0106519824,
-0.0021332121,
-0.032045912,
0.0277347416,
0.0282960292,
-0.0264625847,
-0.0098631484,
0.0406570993,
0.0107345236,
-0.0212378055,
-0.0065168836,
-0.0811996832,
-0.0036071423,
-0.0076168571,
0.0039013997,
0.044123318,
-0.0045455787,
-0.0297217034,
-0.001499405,
0.0254387427,
-0.0026121917,
0.0543696806,
0.03663335,
0.0365096927,
-0.0233920999,
-0.0059766443,
-0.01317525,
0.0097201336,
-0.0274934899,
0.0922984183,
0.0100922631,
-0.0504092574,
-0.0006293143,
-0.0325828902,
-0.0303837825,
-0.0586306602,
-0.0193722676,
-0.0058737136,
0.0200547148,
0.0310122296,
-0.1101262793,
-0.0677888617,
0.0617646985,
0.0398422256,
-0.0043899198,
-0.0066362987,
0.0475759283,
-0.0021487158,
-0.0375245921,
-0.0247475188,
-0.0671909824,
0.0270954315,
-0.0221815612,
0.0328857526,
0.0104829827,
-0.0354202762,
-0.0618385077,
0.0138563495,
-0.0468578599,
-0.0078724865,
0.0133658107,
0.0346161984,
0.0203420855,
-0.0300219227,
-0.0351070464,
0.0433269776,
0.0556683578,
0.0531920381,
-0.071841158,
-0.0143911932,
0.0290410351,
0.009833334,
-0.0034915891,
0.029099768,
-0.0748782754,
0.0227652993,
-0.0331315361,
0.0214956719,
-0.0474196225,
0.0148267001,
0.0194730666,
0.0471758023,
-0.0029521727,
0.0521197096,
-0.0453942418,
0.01356206,
-0.01007229,
-0.011360216,
-0.0182583723,
-0.0297967438,
-0.0451260582,
0.0230769813,
-0.0016688372,
0.0194251351,
0.008328082,
0.0167741515,
-0.0203104019,
-0.0083785681,
0.0004520605,
0.0255763959,
0.0351837277,
0.0071894461,
-0.0184571967,
0.022966627,
0.0090719759,
0.0464714803,
0.0312502272,
-0.0094995266,
0.037968725,
0.0133743659,
0.0061392374,
-0.0085695898,
-0.0341141447,
-0.0467442647,
-0.0615481846,
0.0154136643,
0.0450021252,
0.0081555601,
-0.0136685213,
-0.0466987118,
-0.0219326206,
-0.0025069066,
0.0158593599,
-0.020878084,
0.0201201271,
-0.0467235036,
0.0248142108,
0.0291197393,
-0.025710186,
-0.0397819057,
0.0903243646,
-0.028050147,
0.0182701088,
-0.0527315512,
-0.0062516686,
-0.0473872833,
-0.0222722609,
0.0592277199,
0.0227407645,
0.0174135827,
0.0085280808,
-0.0941560045,
-0.0432560444,
0.0073134615,
0.0129899224,
-0.0239786506,
0.0048313481,
0.0463023856,
0.0342631601,
0.0364394225,
0.0154193621,
-0.0063414914,
0.0451897494,
-0.0621928088,
-0.0178318303,
-0.0011809889,
-6.455355063e-33,
-0.033233013,
-0.0373662338,
0.0682578906,
0.0110457893,
0.0260597952,
0.0220543835,
-0.0189047288,
-0.0407045558,
-0.015872959,
0.0194396004,
-0.0071387598,
0.0313407704,
-0.0021071634,
0.0176219922,
0.0106887463,
-0.0057268199,
0.0126511445,
-0.0395864174,
-0.0017613175,
-0.0338743329,
0.0169847589,
0.0617876984,
0.0324188322,
-0.0044148029,
0.0312964804,
0.0045861155,
-0.0223218706,
0.0204891991,
0.0364509039,
0.0535946488,
0.0073454645,
0.0372409858,
0.0030706499,
-0.0907037407,
0.0003365283,
0.0053123343,
-0.045002345,
-0.0598051213,
-0.0017491834,
0.0245124809,
0.0043119243,
-0.0083004935,
0.0499625579,
-0.0367996171,
-0.0058388305,
-0.0054633263,
0.0232384205,
-0.0291902237,
0.0542707033,
-0.05319684,
-0.0496598594,
0.0251476336,
-0.0226507373,
0.0427864678,
0.0268765297,
0.0635845438,
0.0241259206,
-0.0057047196,
-0.0148499599,
0.0137289762,
0.0102246171,
0.0048403894,
0.0268995259,
-0.0114936894,
-0.0100606875,
0.0359379537,
-0.0078987572,
-0.0062450785,
0.0108367549,
0.0178498495,
0.0030840226,
0.0596251152,
0.0676618665,
0.0702645779,
0.019103976,
-0.0076245363,
-0.0432072207,
0.0408194177,
0.0473640598,
0.0292364769,
0.0009811744,
0.0115770316,
-0.0562492125,
-0.0267642643,
-0.0214077868,
0.0196792893,
-0.0422750451,
-0.0165627208,
0.0451409183,
-0.0102009689,
0.0048373817,
0.0252641886,
0.0113313198,
-0.0756252259,
-0.0184560679,
-0.0034668578,
0.0259107351,
0.0144936182,
0.0173106231,
0.0124601731,
-0.0471730642,
0.0112596164,
-0.0078983707,
0.0094796363,
0.0097442959,
0.0175524261,
0.014104642,
0.009418644,
-0.0443771183,
-0.0253446959,
-0.0031232589,
0.0077598491,
0.0046473742,
0.0039519453,
-0.0243984926,
0.0538256951,
-0.005160186,
-0.0020910841,
0.0024576504,
0.0099696219,
-0.0137212062,
-0.0238288362,
-0.004418754,
0.0344913043,
0.016630318,
0.0062381802,
-0.00689115,
0.0369781069,
0.0117727127,
-0.038330391,
-0.0120947128,
0.0822660252,
2.99e-7,
0.0464571975,
0.0767131671,
-0.0226304084,
0.0385473296,
0.0033775517,
0.0441180542,
-0.0263458863,
-0.0193376839,
0.0067559308,
0.0085905204,
0.041675549,
0.0524685904,
0.0370522402,
0.0081902714,
-0.0913281143,
-0.0748375729,
-0.0343532413,
-0.0170657746,
-0.0739390999,
0.0348078832,
0.0274708178,
0.0439683683,
-0.0048598065,
-0.0468671657,
0.0091260923,
-0.0949108452,
0.0419492535,
-0.0075179972,
-0.0374663025,
0.0040132543,
0.0207708254,
0.0316084474,
0.0146018807,
0.0292789172,
0.0029104317,
0.0166930519,
0.0087216664,
0.0276495647,
0.0253625158,
0.0125914691,
-0.0156969577,
-0.0185999237,
0.0100861406,
-0.0348126106,
0.0422011912,
-0.081514053,
-0.0386919118,
-0.0372035392,
-0.0738427192,
-0.0200642161,
0.0088788494,
0.0009012523,
-0.0188586414,
0.0004967946,
0.0173158981,
-0.0206759572,
0.0349435695,
-0.0090037789,
-0.0052162404,
0.0432764404,
-0.015386031,
0.0115110055,
-0.0392577797,
-0.010124634,
-0.0104874382,
-0.082933411,
0.0066788853,
2.679294402e-34,
0.0460173152,
-0.0320573598,
-0.0234360341,
0.0665889308,
0.067421928,
0.0168535318,
-0.0422648266,
0.02668049,
0.0274027232,
-0.0996785536,
0.0106390128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00361v1 | From RAG to RICHES: Retrieval Interlaced with Sequence Generation | 2024-06-29T08:16:58 | 2024-06-29T08:16:58 | Palak Jain, Livio Baldini Soares, Tom Kwiatkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present RICHES, a novel approach that interleaves retrieval with sequence
generation tasks. RICHES offers an alternative to conventional RAG systems by
eliminating the need for separate retriever and generator. It retrieves
documents by directly decoding their contents, constrained on the corpus.
Unifying retrieval with generation allows us to adapt to diverse new tasks via
prompting alone. RICHES can work with any Instruction-tuned model, without
additional training. It provides attributed evidence, supports multi-hop
retrievals and interleaves thoughts to plan on what to retrieve next, all
within a single decoding pass of the LLM. We demonstrate the strong performance
of RICHES across ODQA tasks including attributed and multi-hop QA. | [
-0.0015421393,
0.1087604612,
0.0288467929,
0.0044948678,
-0.0320675708,
0.0004834974,
-0.0222455673,
-0.0027730183,
-0.0095744375,
-0.0313453451,
-0.0286183618,
-0.0270194635,
-0.0330206342,
0.001888531,
0.0017920183,
-0.0099618593,
0.0627878159,
-0.0155886123,
0.0129887825,
0.0094890557,
0.0007050795,
0.0032281915,
-0.0181307625,
0.0261000358,
-0.0203645807,
-0.0138389682,
-0.0395283997,
0.0067491168,
0.0062468401,
-0.0340922177,
0.0004012283,
0.054088857,
0.0431232415,
0.0366173983,
0.0000016157,
-0.040845152,
-0.0438657403,
0.0047002817,
-0.0531550571,
-0.0266511887,
0.0303295646,
0.0367177315,
0.0103157563,
0.0247109085,
-0.0570551194,
0.006990179,
0.0087759588,
0.0739963576,
0.0318599045,
0.1087236255,
-0.0130589204,
-0.0363378599,
0.0411215648,
-0.0452278145,
0.0532797836,
-0.0530351214,
-0.0016700692,
-0.0059464448,
0.0426105633,
0.0382420048,
0.014968683,
0.0370522253,
0.0275059082,
-0.0085297413,
-0.0145331835,
0.0043891175,
-0.0311350729,
-0.029504234,
-0.0212068595,
0.0353461429,
0.0249550119,
-0.0076195248,
0.0068915519,
0.026220642,
0.0323145539,
-0.0001825287,
-0.0481116101,
0.0673640743,
-0.0310735423,
0.0169785358,
0.0153894825,
0.021698799,
0.0016487925,
0.0085040117,
-0.0375112109,
0.0195826031,
0.0044105868,
-0.0243998077,
0.0101085426,
0.034129627,
0.0211077258,
-0.0190754998,
0.0130433468,
0.0345970467,
-0.0432285294,
0.0144567778,
-0.03650406,
-0.0209971927,
0.041613508,
0.0324378833,
0.0621044971,
0.0236108936,
-0.0489563569,
0.0372177884,
-0.0229306687,
0.0071979049,
-0.0354122259,
-0.0296464376,
-0.0376707315,
-0.0000554401,
-0.0417077914,
-0.0216964316,
-0.0367914811,
0.0431909971,
-0.0851874575,
-0.026811542,
-0.001048514,
0.0088935578,
0.0299994219,
-0.0117484322,
-0.0029068298,
0.0248316303,
-0.0756810382,
0.0066934051,
-0.0062618763,
0.0192641988,
-0.0043760086,
0.04014723,
0.084651798,
-0.0534111485,
-0.0516881645,
0.01772907,
0.0203005709,
-0.0211895965,
-0.0016571858,
0.0498539731,
-0.0494231358,
-0.0579953752,
-0.0238104183,
-0.0635294244,
0.0003824385,
-0.0715656504,
0.0325673446,
-0.0480591655,
0.0071408637,
-0.0161229875,
-0.0095001608,
0.0003936658,
0.0178116877,
0.0345899872,
-0.0023891313,
0.0315404311,
0.0157820806,
-0.0418917201,
0.0150123928,
0.0274686962,
0.0227222536,
0.0610839203,
-0.0105517469,
0.066939868,
0.0450912379,
0.0377956964,
-0.0004656075,
0.0188204497,
0.0294225365,
-0.0001912228,
0.0050303531,
-0.0022429964,
0.0327663235,
0.0197430067,
0.0434905738,
0.0460147001,
-0.0640431568,
-0.0030996657,
0.0190199576,
0.0328092165,
0.0688346773,
-0.0206478648,
0.0074920841,
0.0161226932,
-0.0032712882,
0.040158432,
0.0059918193,
0.0442525186,
0.0035485721,
0.0294412561,
0.0582634509,
0.0119279651,
-0.0385467708,
-0.0240706448,
-0.0089020599,
-0.0020861882,
-0.0353872217,
-0.0009799277,
0.0141145354,
0.0596891716,
-0.062529467,
0.0047984957,
0.0015428188,
-0.0802205205,
-0.0065248171,
-0.0446227901,
0.0619588047,
0.0353827141,
0.0743084773,
-0.0177714247,
-0.0178642403,
-0.0094213923,
-0.0096893422,
0.0426447429,
0.0123970127,
-0.0141353188,
0.0158236232,
-0.0606432408,
-0.0319736935,
-0.0020429099,
0.0163040776,
0.0325379074,
0.0234844908,
-0.0032566395,
0.0187200066,
-0.0207308605,
-0.0073134578,
0.033529412,
-0.0521824658,
-0.0495544598,
0.0196950156,
-0.0164463855,
0.0377545021,
0.0432629809,
-0.0100176316,
0.0275125485,
0.0771610364,
-0.032240171,
-0.0382313803,
-0.0073665031,
-0.0523233749,
-0.0677965581,
0.0004715527,
-0.004438282,
0.0027538983,
0.0227495059,
-0.0304835085,
-0.0608408526,
-0.0154102091,
-0.0430571288,
-0.0050505046,
-0.0742306486,
-0.0271724779,
0.0813365504,
0.0232186504,
-0.0589882471,
0.0383372121,
-0.0167647321,
0.0028401753,
0.0161897745,
-0.004469974,
-0.0073633678,
-0.0788328424,
0.0310715679,
0.0126192914,
0.004392236,
0.0224169493,
0.0439762697,
0.0243480429,
-0.0339816436,
-0.0548653193,
-0.0549902767,
0.0194512438,
-0.0402190872,
0.0251109786,
-0.013831812,
-0.0027456237,
-0.0106685329,
-0.0236923061,
-0.050447382,
-0.003101215,
0.0506115332,
0.0127761504,
0.0203434639,
0.027535202,
0.0234337747,
-0.0312543176,
-0.0233570207,
0.0390560776,
0.0305249486,
-0.0022985116,
0.0080417041,
-0.047497917,
-0.0131985731,
-0.0090672625,
0.0235884488,
-0.0236979667,
0.0066828337,
0.0418948568,
-0.0537125021,
0.0494917817,
0.0455103032,
0.026382884,
0.0358082652,
0.0146556459,
-0.0225812346,
-0.054169599,
0.0222611092,
-0.0297353473,
-0.0097892098,
-0.0046269358,
0.014178141,
0.0292747486,
0.0409588628,
-0.0182274468,
0.0243370347,
-0.0151238833,
-0.0099018086,
0.0413400233,
-0.0545863099,
-0.0109697096,
-0.0290743113,
-0.020894615,
0.0466758348,
-0.0125616174,
-0.0386414342,
0.0433597453,
-0.0228073653,
-0.0258433633,
-0.0610989481,
0.0090313321,
-0.0390635841,
0.0644317046,
-0.0463173166,
0.0052707521,
-0.0218657739,
-0.0517689288,
-0.0272384435,
-0.007582387,
-0.0019469922,
-0.0582857393,
0.0128323426,
-0.0248490497,
0.0246712491,
-0.0310548935,
-0.0300407838,
-0.0579757653,
-0.001405853,
0.0436768048,
0.00534527,
-0.0247273128,
-0.0223302729,
-0.084022738,
-0.0218964815,
0.0457191244,
0.0538434684,
-0.0249205623,
0.0028231216,
-0.014327825,
0.0672815368,
0.0650567934,
0.0043521458,
0.0128116868,
-0.0226647481,
0.0055229007,
0.0661953688,
0.0530556627,
0.0086125555,
0.0324420966,
0.0075698132,
0.038598109,
-0.0270833727,
0.0011068895,
0.0258070026,
0.0254880004,
-0.0469921231,
-0.0441924892,
0.0600049756,
0.0267564338,
-0.052730523,
-0.030601738,
-0.0380058214,
0.0378048643,
0.0029719363,
0.0148974583,
-0.1283266693,
-0.0279251281,
0.0212018508,
0.061454013,
0.0252319183,
-0.012797677,
-0.0127599072,
-0.0959723741,
0.077523753,
0.0126821296,
-0.0185301322,
-0.0226737391,
-0.0425531231,
-0.0405076854,
0.0123121152,
0.0355211236,
0.0574253164,
-0.0270399172,
0.0270098951,
0.0205952954,
0.0763020962,
-0.0108127445,
-0.0038544319,
-0.0097222244,
0.0110323224,
0.0834841803,
-0.0123793585,
0.0380607247,
-0.0650532618,
-0.0146513823,
-0.0404075049,
0.0160518866,
-0.0074866423,
0.0383094549,
-0.0506716631,
-0.000369422,
-0.0601555817,
0.0444961563,
-0.0104782609,
-0.0240447782,
-0.011556902,
0.0184552651,
-0.0351153798,
0.0054829028,
-0.0479513966,
-0.0134533038,
0.0310390778,
0.0516338795,
0.0090105478,
0.0073446627,
-0.0238731578,
-0.0125536425,
0.0240576118,
-0.0667656511,
-0.0101561891,
0.0290131159,
-0.0260741543,
-0.0384504236,
-0.1030748039,
-0.0588642284,
-0.0207828879,
0.0767386928,
-0.0251458194,
-0.0171332918,
-0.0139248315,
-0.0242183879,
-0.0947713405,
0.0211885683,
-0.0351230204,
-0.0311558712,
-0.0309157316,
-0.0043920903,
0.036799632,
-0.0329966694,
-0.0031310564,
0.0327062644,
-0.0356065892,
-0.042289868,
0.0324415527,
0.0509133823,
0.0275702477,
0.0318897031,
0.0300751701,
-0.0225094613,
0.0316835195,
0.0408449396,
-0.0525347888,
0.020535823,
0.0540193208,
0.0051641902,
-0.0371880271,
0.0402710848,
-0.0482131392,
0.0438686162,
-0.0291432422,
0.0656096116,
-0.0045147506,
0.0051246327,
0.0176747143,
-0.0137747852,
0.0222414974,
0.0006358027,
0.0180714801,
-0.0232729614,
0.0289885942,
-0.0311087407,
-0.0031698591,
-0.0409194157,
0.0265255328,
0.0237491969,
-0.0352653041,
0.0177113023,
0.0221780874,
-0.0362329781,
0.0729945302,
-0.0619890988,
0.0208187066,
-0.0107276635,
0.0061976006,
-0.0129877143,
-0.0131710917,
-0.0382191688,
0.0190582369,
-0.0218815673,
0.0605883226,
-0.0151477987,
0.0369152427,
0.0370792896,
0.032348644,
0.0275616869,
0.0181378461,
-0.0667472556,
-0.0047951713,
-0.0117438361,
0.0024477062,
0.0309405979,
-0.0001429907,
0.0414622016,
-0.0017847758,
-0.0005536323,
-0.0095959334,
0.0186617319,
-0.0132940486,
-0.0222932883,
-0.0014752925,
0.0231165029,
-0.0191149469,
-0.001637564,
0.0746670887,
-0.0282732025,
0.018534774,
-0.0141512416,
-0.0068418588,
-0.0630365461,
-0.1017266288,
0.0465284176,
0.024709003,
-0.0010338635,
-0.0056842184,
-0.0067768116,
-0.0099228648,
0.0067547401,
0.0037003169,
-0.0090441424,
-0.0090883579,
0.033611916,
0.0631651804,
-0.0164799597,
-0.031204395,
-0.0336290225,
0.0105859675,
-0.049347274,
-0.0487206206,
0.0234919656,
-5.886052496e-33,
-0.0201608129,
-0.0116563104,
0.0400527641,
-0.0321065038,
-0.0380551815,
0.0023509518,
-0.0355244577,
-0.0159758367,
0.0116225351,
0.000351755,
-0.022500433,
0.0079287412,
0.0360416248,
0.0569840111,
0.0245115962,
0.030146461,
0.0553459562,
-0.0136235254,
-0.0356147029,
0.0347436033,
0.071539402,
0.0455240421,
0.0478576943,
-0.0098590897,
0.0147814406,
-0.0171168074,
0.0103799859,
-0.0219117068,
-0.0030289583,
0.036749851,
-0.0168522615,
-0.0047986391,
-0.0098206494,
-0.0345014371,
-0.0266258381,
0.0462294258,
-0.0994633809,
-0.0303328726,
0.0074462825,
-0.0191055648,
-0.0346806012,
-0.0341774486,
-0.0003716482,
-0.0316396505,
0.000064298,
0.0008828482,
-0.0127747906,
-0.0067017148,
-0.0335442796,
-0.0440834127,
-0.0281861313,
0.0235944353,
0.0209584292,
-0.0240634233,
0.0354829319,
0.0478868373,
0.0053552771,
-0.0180169251,
-0.0488327183,
0.0167972725,
-0.0322387815,
0.0743614808,
0.0099008922,
-0.0085352305,
-0.0275680814,
0.0383695774,
0.033160802,
-0.0210601166,
-0.0226956904,
0.0086859521,
-0.0027191448,
0.0579934902,
0.0011711867,
0.0218313262,
0.039652776,
-0.0014214145,
-0.0476445444,
0.0490947142,
0.0276275519,
0.0811544284,
0.0185128432,
0.0417446345,
-0.0126863942,
0.0284683108,
-0.0223920308,
0.0086451368,
-0.0105683794,
-0.0022056596,
0.0579000637,
0.068440713,
-0.002638241,
-0.0000022068,
0.0674315915,
0.0209872257,
0.0123337945,
0.0438588411,
-0.028972948,
-0.0083366139,
-0.0344587639,
0.0112884995,
-0.0720378011,
-0.0117167402,
0.0993158296,
0.0207122006,
-0.042954348,
0.0179487653,
0.0350062512,
0.0191068724,
-0.0867452547,
0.0189884156,
-0.0161181148,
0.0723266229,
-0.0056929686,
-0.0158740506,
0.0438060351,
-0.0048338003,
-0.0011052138,
0.0351751894,
-0.0301776975,
-0.0031431909,
-0.0359910093,
-0.0241146628,
0.0232909415,
0.0199007262,
-0.00811058,
0.0515367426,
-0.0214386806,
0.0284942519,
-0.0031932276,
-0.0284224804,
0.0244505703,
0.0711422935,
2.402e-7,
0.0137582868,
-0.0044148243,
0.0880322158,
0.0220093671,
-0.0135112237,
-0.0019848058,
-0.0110324547,
0.046332825,
-0.0034603307,
0.0013764619,
-0.0237550531,
0.0318659246,
0.0602445714,
0.002715105,
-0.0984812304,
-0.0395527817,
-0.0397021435,
-0.013495381,
-0.0736195743,
-0.0496199504,
0.0532079823,
0.0548331141,
-0.0265399888,
-0.0252850745,
0.0186128113,
-0.0255930312,
0.0494718403,
0.0400346331,
-0.0229337197,
-0.0317032337,
0.0536644273,
-0.0093187187,
-0.0064578527,
-0.0244248044,
-0.0052014482,
0.044951912,
-0.0257951859,
0.0392910466,
0.0220136717,
-0.1132676601,
-0.0012752051,
0.0117582669,
0.0008862318,
0.0002986352,
0.0298818704,
-0.0049193455,
-0.0273779649,
-0.0148703652,
-0.0511770397,
0.007753741,
-0.0007668461,
0.0025968661,
0.0082172444,
0.0337698795,
0.0121899815,
0.0390045159,
-0.0113251992,
-0.1070704684,
0.0093295518,
0.0054362454,
-0.0381866619,
-0.0151960906,
-0.0422375947,
0.0070596109,
-0.0241944864,
-0.112795487,
-0.0405695103,
2.320319319e-34,
0.0491082855,
0.0025649318,
-0.0016543778,
0.0554924905,
0.0158035792,
-0.0114167631,
-0.0287823938,
0.0383588634,
-0.0073719076,
-0.0922015682,
-0.0405767262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00342v1 | Korean Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis via Implicit-Feature Alignment with Corpus Filtering | 2024-06-29T07:01:51 | 2024-06-29T07:01:51 | Kibeom Nam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Investigations into Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) for Korean
restaurant reviews are notably lacking in the existing literature. Our research
proposes an intuitive and effective framework for ABSA in low-resource
languages such as Korean. It optimizes prediction labels by integrating
translated benchmark and unlabeled Korean data. Using a model fine-tuned on
translated data, we pseudo-labeled the actual Korean NLI set. Subsequently, we
applied LaBSE and MSP-based filtering to this pseudo-NLI set as implicit
feature, enhancing Aspect Category Detection and Polarity determination through
additional training. Incorporating dual filtering, this model bridged dataset
gaps, achieving positive results in Korean ABSA with minimal resources. Through
additional data injection pipelines, our approach aims to utilize high-resource
data and construct effective models within communities, whether corporate or
individual, in low-resource language countries. Compared to English ABSA, our
framework showed an approximately 3% difference in F1 scores and accuracy. We
release the dataset and our code for Korean ABSA, at this link. | [
0.0355899148,
0.06378676,
-0.0023602301,
0.0315377265,
-0.0200469419,
0.0017733152,
0.0120153446,
0.0161270034,
-0.002174563,
-0.0299518816,
-0.0587787852,
0.0017358125,
-0.0041551706,
0.0658579022,
-0.0351976715,
0.014938402,
0.0333512537,
0.0627433881,
0.0548460297,
-0.0202503894,
0.0242509209,
0.0363105461,
0.0054066698,
-0.0001644601,
-0.0220353734,
0.0026885883,
0.0009621551,
0.0157768838,
0.0309517495,
-0.0217110328,
0.0172630176,
0.0241524763,
-0.0389585756,
-0.0139469542,
0.0000019275,
-0.0031706737,
-0.0249869749,
0.0126952147,
0.0392218642,
-0.0418296568,
0.0632599443,
-0.0330697671,
0.0120344786,
-0.0094261551,
-0.0306839719,
-0.0385573171,
0.04422234,
0.0920318812,
0.0441603102,
0.0598109923,
-0.0251307804,
-0.0321115069,
-0.0644465685,
0.0267283674,
-0.066837579,
-0.0167568307,
0.0130686872,
-0.0558790602,
-0.0557206459,
0.0144600989,
0.0076866103,
-0.0061431914,
-0.0174996313,
0.001922386,
0.011968052,
0.0129755381,
0.0092818309,
-0.0244533792,
0.0310083497,
0.0184043497,
0.027578149,
-0.0240114946,
-0.0281144865,
-0.0365051404,
-0.0343852453,
0.0031846766,
0.0411206335,
-0.0307092518,
0.0048134187,
0.0586264096,
0.0311377421,
0.0325924717,
0.0144850826,
0.0170512293,
0.0520257875,
0.0577610657,
-0.0027741895,
-0.0683434308,
0.0238859281,
0.073028855,
0.0073952116,
-0.0228740573,
0.0377039574,
-0.0158566348,
0.0092203133,
0.0377390943,
0.0397471376,
0.0365668274,
0.0127306134,
-0.0673362166,
-0.0209257547,
0.0551365316,
-0.0120981364,
0.0125819175,
0.0026804702,
-0.0350439809,
0.0520113669,
-0.0230355021,
-0.049821455,
0.0273828506,
-0.0431247018,
0.0190019589,
0.0125085339,
0.0341124088,
-0.0226121899,
0.0249168668,
-0.0428667627,
-0.0203300286,
-0.0225960426,
0.0113313356,
0.0618069731,
0.0207068399,
-0.0086933244,
0.0380712226,
-0.0274643097,
0.0654407293,
-0.0471689589,
0.0512430407,
-0.0578834414,
0.0340022147,
0.0358064026,
-0.0089379707,
0.0076210909,
-0.0063584889,
0.0126475655,
-0.0162261594,
0.0307135284,
-0.0314318612,
-0.0360862948,
-0.0114158066,
-0.0313292779,
-0.0653330535,
-0.0363707095,
-0.0601870604,
0.0308642611,
0.0108594047,
0.0153342476,
0.0000317559,
0.0116750468,
0.0098660486,
0.0003995625,
0.0499056168,
0.0065130601,
0.0022230628,
-0.0240311641,
-0.0134320753,
0.0732416585,
0.0576296002,
-0.033088848,
-0.0301690605,
0.0218778104,
0.0195459574,
-0.0623141266,
-0.0086460952,
-0.0021352523,
0.0472555198,
-0.005106301,
0.0194488373,
-0.0598770529,
-0.0283689145,
-0.0194070302,
-0.0039426275,
0.0475212298,
-0.0169455986,
0.0370865092,
0.002466196,
-0.0424965508,
0.0764368922,
-0.0080744131,
0.010821715,
-0.0331459865,
-0.0334347002,
0.0356647,
0.0156448428,
-0.0307842661,
0.0186641943,
-0.0007618078,
0.0129955066,
-0.0608610287,
-0.0394826643,
-0.0475266203,
-0.0039739474,
0.0318441167,
0.0159187447,
0.0539597683,
-0.0005679259,
-0.0330024473,
0.0011729202,
0.0423735902,
-0.0303261019,
-0.0350632705,
0.0155331073,
0.0375174209,
0.0803801119,
-0.023687657,
0.0120553523,
0.0128864823,
-0.0327076018,
-0.0660365,
0.0288049858,
0.0357494205,
-0.0123741049,
-0.039804507,
-0.00774279,
-0.0288458783,
0.0434128828,
0.0435286909,
0.0054924469,
0.0038866273,
0.0660780519,
-0.0116993953,
0.0014041121,
-0.0256337803,
-0.0141007537,
-0.0132380305,
-0.0170942843,
0.0158397947,
0.0483324267,
0.0500883609,
0.1013731658,
0.0159152895,
-0.0216393918,
0.0200418569,
-0.0247068424,
-0.0573420301,
0.0225095432,
-0.0182049312,
-0.0582557209,
0.0093868813,
0.0113788024,
-0.0120833674,
0.0016674246,
-0.014260889,
-0.0244324449,
0.0063496316,
0.024340814,
-0.0000887447,
-0.0215295348,
0.0141374869,
-0.0097405314,
0.0023042231,
-0.0015044811,
0.0344617553,
-0.0190926176,
0.0457709283,
-0.0406273678,
-0.0435382426,
0.0343445204,
0.0223351698,
-0.0394131429,
0.0061798058,
0.0386359356,
0.0155226681,
0.0386196412,
0.0261150841,
-0.0175671726,
-0.0097626876,
-0.1214002892,
0.0126775131,
0.0085930312,
0.0007158515,
0.0201711413,
-0.0153123979,
0.0045189993,
0.0374761373,
-0.0314975791,
-0.0100900326,
-0.0058762021,
0.0248618498,
0.0064913696,
0.0288537983,
0.0419142023,
-0.0179108121,
-0.0121906828,
-0.0366345383,
-0.0205556303,
0.0072754505,
-0.0552307367,
-0.0179028958,
0.0494352244,
-0.0203880537,
-0.0421064757,
0.0278073773,
-0.0492424443,
-0.021183392,
0.0217069536,
-0.0447031818,
0.0028748016,
-0.023584269,
0.0041342503,
0.0457861014,
-0.0193633717,
-0.0088570844,
0.0193429198,
-0.0814008862,
-0.0061153919,
-0.0211009961,
-0.0586149469,
-0.0125218825,
0.0530250184,
0.014928516,
-0.0082719056,
-0.0715093389,
0.0055252686,
-0.0685270727,
0.0032121274,
0.0205194447,
0.0203768462,
-0.0059184693,
0.0208417326,
0.0044917371,
0.026945617,
0.0723304972,
0.0223880783,
0.0305477064,
-0.0826336667,
-0.0074388809,
-0.0436157137,
0.0246049296,
-0.0759769455,
0.0357916839,
0.0081614051,
0.0137529327,
0.0141218901,
-0.029150378,
-0.003035482,
-0.0248529464,
0.052698832,
0.0388643108,
0.0047019664,
0.0295418482,
-0.0439435057,
0.0030671696,
-0.0548878647,
-0.0366826355,
0.0169018153,
-0.0178019498,
-0.008029718,
-0.0044776197,
0.0410480276,
-0.0176677909,
-0.0622349009,
-0.0047118603,
-0.0133492695,
0.0169286225,
0.0040814127,
0.0426681377,
-0.0417435691,
-0.0133598801,
0.0060785445,
0.0257584024,
0.024506392,
-0.036483597,
-0.019696353,
0.0133205764,
-0.0069880043,
0.0466281772,
-0.00600451,
0.006505948,
-0.0380357541,
0.0606096946,
-0.0203185473,
0.0031544438,
0.0859010443,
0.0252437405,
-0.0659199953,
-0.0040575699,
0.0189156812,
-0.0159779713,
0.0477648266,
0.007563828,
-0.0103329867,
0.0005587136,
0.0123195741,
0.0257276613,
-0.0496036746,
-0.0066919411,
-0.0042962534,
-0.1343731433,
-0.0002760107,
-0.0080802003,
-0.0526792705,
-0.0874828994,
-0.0600745678,
0.0421150886,
-0.0273636803,
0.0240568928,
-0.0720979869,
0.0230852924,
-0.0089601735,
-0.0074776197,
-0.0025608828,
-0.0155993057,
0.0548000559,
-0.0102404486,
0.0128882313,
-0.0087353038,
0.0620512925,
-0.000303578,
-0.0056727738,
-0.0072869663,
-0.0981082469,
0.0006031885,
-0.0350942127,
0.0689996332,
-0.0379921086,
-0.0208977275,
-0.0085156588,
-0.0102834795,
-0.0743021891,
0.0360884964,
-0.0327672139,
0.0188595317,
0.0230246782,
-0.005481218,
0.0164210219,
0.0057557393,
0.0428378657,
0.0601917729,
-0.0434019528,
-0.0576511808,
0.0428651758,
-0.0055695018,
-0.0490672812,
0.0202249717,
-0.0518926159,
0.0088608526,
-0.059107203,
-0.0529219694,
-0.0569313355,
-0.0762879252,
-0.0283065308,
0.0379633345,
0.0251797084,
0.0094409809,
0.0020370034,
-0.0027692199,
-0.0098966109,
0.0066230921,
-0.0005918169,
0.0278961752,
0.0440677181,
-0.0235616937,
0.0489533991,
-0.019664038,
-0.0055812271,
-0.030518299,
-0.0239162389,
-0.0383007266,
-0.0015626025,
0.0184450578,
-0.0063566854,
0.0437849872,
-0.0227141492,
0.0575852618,
0.0020116032,
0.043877136,
-0.0697216392,
0.0056637661,
0.0344473086,
0.0238306373,
0.0199780371,
0.0369864069,
-0.0540765114,
0.026365824,
0.0273649469,
0.0205899458,
-0.0437578298,
-0.0769843012,
0.0236498527,
-0.0025770648,
0.0465902612,
-0.0015973334,
-0.0202278607,
-0.0537998304,
0.0000050717,
-0.0147456359,
-0.0453267843,
-0.0076444698,
-0.0483259484,
0.0274706632,
0.0057040863,
-0.0484307818,
0.068019405,
-0.0381825492,
0.0352383591,
0.0056498758,
0.0516012236,
0.0058763209,
0.0439334065,
-0.040585503,
0.0318562947,
-0.036945276,
-0.0224145278,
0.0147169763,
-0.0261273738,
-0.0129745118,
0.0518981516,
-0.0063650864,
0.0266474709,
-0.0240140501,
-0.0195568912,
0.0201572012,
0.0484456383,
-0.0477975979,
-0.033965949,
-0.0104857329,
-0.1011296287,
0.0689059049,
-0.0704692081,
0.0033106294,
-0.0112838894,
0.0204941109,
-0.0238535237,
-0.0256096274,
0.0681135058,
0.0020622255,
-0.0153092295,
0.0257421788,
0.0115882074,
-0.071565181,
0.0225675032,
0.0224772412,
-0.0337151363,
-0.0109000904,
0.0183089785,
0.0432735533,
0.0104149859,
-0.026191365,
-0.0051233075,
-0.0553249158,
-0.0461175516,
-0.0102748228,
-0.0543611422,
0.004333192,
0.0228894725,
-0.0045611267,
0.0413444154,
0.0169499852,
0.0526955761,
-0.0838440806,
-0.0060629146,
-0.0322433934,
0.0256946608,
0.0084594758,
-6.833294129e-33,
-0.0336097032,
-0.0291536637,
-0.0369591229,
0.0150407199,
-0.0106822448,
0.0091796704,
-0.0269231051,
0.0501149446,
0.0139328353,
0.0243509021,
0.0049181925,
0.0063164071,
0.013630515,
-0.0068103424,
0.0433660746,
-0.0287609454,
0.0551491939,
-0.0023982099,
0.0304425061,
0.0093358411,
0.0264285412,
0.007497842,
0.065555349,
-0.1461471468,
0.0589960292,
-0.0069852867,
-0.0344918221,
-0.011120799,
0.0415268913,
0.0557657816,
-0.0381269567,
0.0824343637,
0.033426702,
-0.0176665764,
0.0243770033,
-0.0449199565,
-0.0372062065,
0.001422029,
0.0142378798,
0.0629255027,
0.0169235319,
-0.019533053,
-0.0080763977,
0.0145672522,
-0.0303939823,
0.0203558262,
0.0334831588,
-0.0375876725,
0.0222996771,
-0.0568866134,
-0.0283344258,
0.0331950299,
-0.0031749902,
0.0169777833,
0.0617082044,
0.0419755988,
0.0122579429,
0.0038577819,
-0.0276978351,
-0.0040710624,
-0.054445181,
0.0062133265,
0.0082652513,
-0.0252850186,
0.0129467892,
0.0370330997,
0.0019463277,
0.0286750682,
0.0299088135,
0.0321789756,
0.0103098471,
0.014829088,
-0.0284738708,
0.0449879877,
0.0072419932,
-0.0436713919,
-0.0123663666,
0.0074126548,
-0.0002606907,
-0.0220389999,
0.0646547079,
0.0149374269,
-0.0852218419,
-0.0289727934,
0.0182371084,
-0.0695886388,
-0.0450394265,
-0.0441336073,
-0.0222188234,
0.031708274,
-0.0197478831,
0.0155291921,
0.0019679812,
-0.0478868224,
-0.0125778411,
0.0072258655,
-0.0419951677,
0.0171221346,
-0.0030125228,
0.0043603345,
-0.0934163332,
-0.0180267002,
-0.0729048178,
0.0323951542,
-0.0335216708,
0.0211693291,
0.0552829094,
0.0217719618,
-0.0743147954,
-0.0013285876,
-0.0015703017,
-0.0371237732,
0.0153072635,
0.0698929429,
0.0014920207,
0.018419344,
-0.0000546432,
0.1328925341,
0.0352910198,
0.0699805394,
-0.0068005905,
0.000622988,
0.0225420762,
0.006194842,
-0.0148874419,
-0.0141047081,
0.0297608431,
-0.0049100993,
-0.0043531982,
-0.0325937606,
-0.0179406442,
0.0119745694,
2.758e-7,
0.0357310288,
0.0224736724,
-0.019260427,
-0.0102287997,
-0.0090635745,
0.0622912459,
-0.0119316494,
0.0009893985,
0.0094970427,
0.0007511967,
0.057970196,
0.0024381611,
0.0136575205,
0.0754782185,
-0.0907576233,
0.0923486575,
-0.0024519623,
-0.0041538072,
-0.0280365385,
0.0527154692,
0.0320783332,
0.0915315598,
0.0341881923,
0.0270342529,
-0.0323971175,
0.0120813549,
0.0536790378,
-0.0245905071,
-0.0479699709,
-0.0066094189,
0.0051398249,
0.0126501815,
-0.0112182181,
-0.0598648712,
-0.0361891277,
0.014485213,
0.0152191035,
0.0584483929,
0.0184334554,
-0.075391382,
0.0197748002,
0.0282811299,
0.0085574007,
-0.0181225035,
0.040501941,
-0.016837202,
-0.0552595705,
-0.0655479804,
0.0019942198,
0.0464605354,
0.0226742122,
0.0165317357,
-0.0255470518,
0.042623885,
0.0065582283,
-0.0174566153,
-0.048984509,
-0.0066868099,
-0.0236161724,
0.0284784194,
-0.0059953234,
-0.0286982786,
0.0319527686,
0.0384063236,
-0.0099520693,
-0.004000694,
0.0191429835,
2.428895738e-34,
0.0337856039,
-0.0093421889,
-0.0321806073,
0.0108838929,
-0.0197722465,
-0.0333129466,
-0.0831339732,
-0.0047422596,
0.0318189263,
0.0067063374,
0.0109621249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00341v1 | Iterative Data Augmentation with Large Language Models for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-29T07:00:37 | 2024-06-29T07:00:37 | Haiyun Li, Qihuang Zhong, Ke Zhu, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is an important sentiment analysis
task, which aims to determine the sentiment polarity towards an aspect in a
sentence. Due to the expensive and limited labeled data, data augmentation (DA)
has become the standard for improving the performance of ABSA. However, current
DA methods usually have some shortcomings: 1) poor fluency and coherence, 2)
lack of diversity of generated data, and 3) reliance on some existing labeled
data, hindering its applications in real-world scenarios. In response to these
problems, we propose a systematic Iterative Data augmentation framework, namely
IterD, to boost the performance of ABSA. The core of IterD is to leverage the
powerful ability of large language models (LLMs) to iteratively generate more
fluent and diverse synthetic labeled data, starting from an unsupervised
sentence corpus. Extensive experiments on 4 widely-used ABSA benchmarks show
that IterD brings consistent and significant performance gains among 5 baseline
ABSA models. More encouragingly, the synthetic data generated by IterD can
achieve comparable or even better performance against the manually annotated
data. | [
0.0387886949,
0.093635343,
0.0091184946,
0.051453054,
-0.0255377218,
0.0039293305,
-0.0002754958,
-0.0455305167,
-0.009106881,
-0.0680320561,
-0.0416017547,
-0.014499357,
-0.0501400195,
0.0560728014,
-0.0054111108,
-0.0010585755,
0.0356844589,
0.0282080118,
0.0186929572,
-0.0203149598,
0.035418164,
0.0326489434,
0.0140327355,
-0.0011036653,
-0.0348780602,
-0.0004498024,
0.0117560811,
-0.0059070266,
0.0321832858,
-0.0310859848,
0.0336144827,
0.0230940655,
0.0133102341,
0.0064513208,
0.000002118,
-0.0169541389,
-0.0212180987,
-0.0089671789,
0.0293955617,
0.0208692402,
0.0969635025,
-0.0394454114,
0.0146831609,
0.020934036,
-0.0571260415,
-0.0416526496,
0.0424213335,
0.0744751468,
0.066797711,
0.1003328115,
-0.0283972546,
-0.0103271827,
-0.0176871829,
-0.0230865683,
-0.0486843251,
-0.007312886,
0.0190338362,
0.0138045894,
-0.0389107801,
0.0780316293,
-0.0053323698,
0.0138951382,
0.0131586744,
-0.0055028219,
0.0083839409,
0.0076620919,
0.0139091872,
0.0123952143,
-0.0012858236,
0.0363343246,
0.0368246175,
-0.0253176205,
-0.0297414567,
-0.0204134565,
-0.0271081757,
-0.0146936188,
-0.0060484023,
-0.0053312769,
0.0246581696,
0.0841175988,
0.0653258562,
0.0123809883,
0.0174112953,
0.0280388091,
-0.0001099478,
0.0815751106,
-0.0139003079,
-0.0480607226,
0.0012336193,
0.0752258524,
-0.0151965367,
-0.0248185266,
-0.0004492408,
-0.0074637262,
-0.0101709487,
0.0298159085,
-0.0176003929,
-0.0139739811,
0.0181471407,
-0.0522876084,
0.0088769468,
0.00318857,
-0.0205504354,
0.0323742628,
0.018472027,
-0.0414028242,
0.0162881054,
-0.0231505781,
-0.0590839535,
0.0083429236,
-0.040989317,
0.0172254592,
0.0185336191,
0.0344004966,
-0.0401457176,
0.0015808764,
-0.0511805378,
0.004009374,
-0.0108242854,
-0.0069552842,
0.0392437726,
-0.0253026336,
0.0104789408,
-0.0030627013,
-0.0141705796,
0.0410202593,
-0.0537979379,
0.0615675449,
-0.039211791,
-0.0040893112,
0.0125929825,
0.0345059782,
-0.0044900924,
-0.0091659352,
0.0202951357,
-0.0008076524,
0.0169168673,
-0.0476526767,
-0.0236857533,
-0.014031616,
-0.0141940545,
-0.0691743046,
-0.0120522231,
-0.0808730647,
0.0434526764,
0.0059447051,
-0.0008455659,
-0.0168836992,
0.0183869991,
-0.0095081413,
-0.0238119196,
0.0477189831,
-0.0746062547,
-0.0089633847,
-0.0410062037,
-0.00391994,
0.0825412795,
0.0694722459,
-0.0179776717,
0.0147401122,
0.0338252895,
0.0210673735,
0.0098027019,
0.0199856851,
-0.000883827,
0.0364695266,
-0.0207158681,
-0.0066723707,
-0.022695085,
-0.0514005572,
0.0177488327,
0.0280998237,
-0.0082356175,
-0.0112731019,
0.0421887822,
-0.0383561589,
-0.0414869674,
0.0552623235,
-0.0095024453,
0.0189291518,
-0.0072203572,
-0.0192580242,
-0.0021916903,
0.0124357874,
-0.00824231,
-0.0055051083,
0.021325944,
0.012274933,
-0.0307276752,
-0.0845005736,
-0.0225645881,
-0.0187649447,
0.0060816491,
0.0147291357,
0.0480852947,
0.0181825832,
-0.0138453273,
-0.0194893256,
0.0683242157,
-0.0665131658,
-0.0103463242,
0.0161205363,
0.0383797176,
0.0778590813,
0.0024385522,
-0.0380765945,
-0.026971288,
-0.0281194039,
-0.0161891859,
0.0470734425,
0.0168144591,
-0.0008738334,
-0.0091616483,
-0.0260152351,
-0.0132336048,
-0.0308555812,
0.0348677821,
0.0186573677,
0.0266745426,
0.0292962268,
-0.0148736695,
-0.0371313952,
-0.024559848,
0.0190002751,
-0.0020107983,
-0.0219643023,
0.0475010984,
0.0075548356,
0.035488762,
0.0746281892,
-0.0149633568,
-0.0204888228,
0.0385691039,
-0.0594440475,
-0.0740797967,
0.0241851136,
-0.0244726259,
-0.0480663441,
0.0345269851,
-0.0209238548,
-0.0521161258,
-0.0016999197,
-0.0606735349,
-0.029476,
0.0074821068,
-0.0191379562,
-0.0041100206,
-0.0275987498,
0.0064040506,
-0.0026590826,
0.0300746895,
-0.0092219235,
0.0525495447,
-0.0198832843,
0.0071604257,
-0.0547784008,
-0.0091147684,
0.0202867016,
0.0115942303,
-0.0368858054,
-0.023838928,
0.025483096,
0.0066461675,
0.0308010727,
0.0044182842,
-0.0145191345,
-0.0202973615,
-0.124992013,
-0.0032570229,
-0.006221686,
0.0371872187,
0.0240461584,
0.0035474943,
-0.0050641298,
0.0266945325,
-0.0427743495,
-0.0312152598,
-0.0154867144,
0.0282231327,
0.0145084197,
0.0223388951,
0.0145156942,
-0.0589342527,
0.0053357743,
-0.0167153906,
-0.0024606159,
0.0261577982,
-0.0240122583,
-0.0552446991,
0.0403409861,
-0.0087118354,
0.0244479254,
-0.0054636355,
-0.0347433574,
-0.0245658979,
-0.0089804409,
0.0058638342,
0.0082956133,
0.0044997493,
0.0088323476,
0.0528192036,
0.0163447168,
-0.0223925672,
0.0225542076,
-0.0709460676,
0.0106226718,
-0.0153878862,
-0.0517973006,
0.0161863603,
0.0540344678,
-0.0147187021,
-0.0038059924,
-0.0204562861,
0.0097796507,
-0.0192702096,
-0.0050175576,
0.0057088719,
0.0057871067,
-0.0058420016,
0.0131384693,
0.0026851008,
-0.0123799574,
0.0580797456,
-0.0067265155,
0.0063468749,
-0.0816386491,
-0.0145696374,
-0.0522450991,
0.0513623953,
-0.0126968268,
-0.0003866598,
-0.0231637117,
0.0394629426,
0.0318279862,
-0.0302544534,
-0.023537172,
-0.0071508856,
0.0472052991,
-0.0027131645,
0.0045506461,
0.0282143075,
-0.0685407966,
-0.0113144331,
-0.0588329174,
-0.0573466346,
-0.0102279447,
0.0199017972,
-0.0196922384,
0.0051524374,
-0.0175959487,
-0.013533025,
-0.0242031198,
-0.0071560275,
-0.0086474679,
0.0070947609,
0.0202541277,
0.0623660088,
-0.0378653258,
0.0053990176,
0.0220233276,
0.002706839,
0.0317203477,
-0.0366170555,
0.0055361269,
-0.0297230221,
-0.0163984876,
0.0261162147,
0.0040818648,
-0.001576621,
-0.0516762026,
0.0620989017,
-0.0258390401,
-0.0224235151,
0.1247178167,
0.0343727805,
-0.052280467,
-0.0004918905,
0.0108345374,
0.0054940521,
0.0482745543,
0.0133848609,
-0.073333852,
-0.0258248392,
-0.0296589863,
0.0184783041,
-0.0190477073,
0.0044252835,
0.0063113454,
-0.1494589448,
0.026547391,
-0.0169070903,
-0.0634713024,
-0.0691320971,
-0.0675342903,
0.0132657988,
-0.0405666903,
0.0275603496,
-0.035503231,
0.0205127075,
0.0183425602,
-0.0025559438,
-0.0119588682,
-0.0465864725,
0.0026211727,
-0.0113468189,
0.0415805764,
0.0274198819,
0.0337733887,
-0.0213380344,
-0.0298635457,
0.0389586911,
-0.026248239,
-0.0066587129,
-0.0243564826,
0.0683700368,
-0.0393174551,
-0.041586142,
-0.0235923249,
0.0430347808,
-0.0649716184,
0.0126359062,
0.0014931738,
0.0484451577,
0.0086403871,
0.0265484899,
-0.0153547889,
0.0183444917,
0.0425563604,
0.074045293,
-0.0077173379,
-0.086497277,
0.0258919504,
-0.0076784072,
-0.0067115747,
-0.0490330644,
-0.0175113901,
-0.016561972,
-0.0222893544,
-0.0304354932,
-0.0767512321,
-0.0723669901,
0.0097033624,
0.003343327,
-0.0057503856,
0.0223832726,
0.0021846311,
-0.0374378562,
-0.0362549126,
0.0277082827,
-0.0143837221,
0.0123111941,
0.0018296858,
-0.0507485606,
0.030221967,
-0.0223570559,
-0.0140681425,
0.0123038087,
-0.0243823808,
-0.0515778363,
0.0174600184,
0.0270983763,
-0.0010505773,
0.0467820615,
-0.011564781,
-0.0070352345,
-0.0070634047,
0.0853431672,
-0.0255393293,
0.0159986522,
0.0515197217,
0.0514149815,
0.0350383595,
0.0384438075,
-0.0144914631,
0.0474269874,
0.0535439514,
0.0182189811,
-0.0381988138,
-0.0497246757,
0.0157479662,
0.0148408646,
0.0807243213,
0.0086697023,
-0.0043496904,
-0.0312440824,
0.0145992637,
-0.0344420485,
-0.0533698536,
-0.0363026857,
0.0000197282,
0.0080814976,
-0.0149400486,
-0.0607945025,
0.07454779,
-0.036534179,
0.0383355878,
-0.033687897,
0.058274582,
-0.0107442541,
0.0205815621,
-0.0158975776,
0.0117722983,
-0.0173072647,
-0.0250816178,
0.0137656517,
-0.0092215547,
0.0081785284,
0.0242590308,
0.0011184008,
0.004709437,
-0.0313443318,
0.0132771628,
0.0017503649,
0.04777354,
-0.0544960052,
0.0295093227,
-0.0021899107,
-0.0568564944,
0.0846008733,
-0.058500316,
-0.0105816871,
-0.010927422,
0.0070092496,
-0.0069346004,
-0.0035841551,
0.0485052466,
0.0094141206,
-0.0500310957,
0.0121298991,
0.0416454338,
-0.0898022056,
0.0526749752,
0.0328527279,
-0.0093127331,
-0.0229336806,
-0.0114213489,
0.0404586829,
0.0001913756,
-0.0131820757,
0.0473938622,
-0.0294386987,
-0.0540884025,
0.0052304831,
-0.0199671164,
-0.0003712764,
0.0195305888,
0.0050259344,
0.021879226,
0.0000789409,
0.0666830167,
-0.0613292679,
0.0049991244,
-0.0258520264,
-0.0254021045,
-0.0114159342,
-6.922765412e-33,
-0.0123846205,
-0.0033436508,
-0.0328677483,
0.0182592552,
-0.0025155435,
0.0121925417,
-0.0076092905,
0.0518940426,
0.0165571254,
0.0685554519,
0.0178193152,
0.0330079794,
0.0097321402,
0.0557090715,
0.0090947701,
0.0121118054,
0.0532272719,
0.0133657772,
-0.0140711311,
0.0102341678,
0.0281568468,
0.0035354213,
0.0760778487,
-0.1548708975,
0.0362115838,
-0.0131727066,
-0.049072627,
0.022198014,
0.0160977636,
0.0479947776,
-0.0206158813,
0.0898796916,
0.0359404646,
-0.0495310128,
0.0202436447,
0.0206179228,
-0.0373280272,
-0.0203330331,
0.0299009606,
0.0205495451,
-0.0010624975,
-0.0301559884,
-0.010061211,
0.0040267543,
-0.0200823508,
0.0165800713,
0.0110514779,
-0.0590267293,
0.0378932618,
-0.0829108208,
-0.0579686165,
0.0255206674,
0.0066469382,
-0.0075098565,
0.0322252288,
0.0417604297,
0.0194650814,
0.0257821884,
-0.0487323962,
0.0142166438,
-0.0175954346,
0.0428247899,
0.0104524009,
-0.021057263,
0.0150028467,
0.0642418489,
-0.0243686605,
0.0184442364,
-0.0093929945,
0.0474128462,
-0.0070959805,
-0.0065235314,
0.0271528158,
0.0617177896,
0.0067952187,
-0.0086466288,
-0.0347086005,
0.0261471029,
0.0271300208,
-0.0294448677,
0.064979732,
0.0152731407,
-0.0471522398,
-0.0127727194,
-0.0044467235,
-0.0342239179,
-0.0447946191,
-0.0017751416,
-0.0024725238,
0.0367336124,
-0.0547710098,
0.0102356886,
-0.0249115601,
-0.0618832037,
-0.030252859,
0.0188812353,
-0.0558468662,
0.0243826043,
0.0007152069,
-0.0123784179,
-0.0637811497,
-0.0246939361,
-0.012257901,
0.0247149114,
-0.0110544851,
-0.012990077,
0.112510033,
0.0055680624,
-0.1047350168,
0.010460672,
-0.0094840173,
0.0401776321,
-0.0154309496,
0.0407821536,
0.0040185521,
0.0123755168,
-0.0186595749,
0.1099373624,
0.0439637862,
0.0604649708,
-0.0084044691,
-0.0431796908,
-0.0133058978,
0.0094588259,
-0.0272722077,
-0.0182151329,
0.0288262498,
-0.0344723016,
-0.0319369286,
-0.0521514826,
-0.0193070713,
0.0001645432,
2.821e-7,
0.0623566434,
0.0559545755,
-0.0122756455,
-0.0020937875,
0.0252092667,
0.0535239875,
-0.0007209746,
0.0017977498,
0.0044197333,
-0.0244884137,
0.0146704633,
0.03085717,
0.0178586785,
0.0014169366,
-0.0526234694,
0.0534559637,
-0.0041645397,
-0.0112301037,
-0.0227914713,
0.015469118,
0.0682234243,
0.1394940168,
0.047369428,
-0.0057332357,
-0.0096243676,
0.0241181906,
0.0435877666,
-0.0358094759,
-0.0667857677,
0.0437658317,
-0.010300559,
0.0334582217,
-0.0104251439,
-0.0287284702,
-0.0167307556,
0.0227026641,
-0.0131853204,
0.0594500303,
0.0349139124,
-0.0373286568,
0.0124878911,
0.0127332257,
0.0198321771,
-0.010970558,
0.0692488253,
-0.0475800373,
-0.0543938465,
-0.0945366025,
-0.0477443486,
0.0417863093,
0.01716966,
-0.0121313641,
-0.0251711048,
0.0349894539,
0.0071320669,
-0.021987943,
-0.0701912642,
-0.0589550249,
-0.0491019823,
0.0204938091,
-0.0163869336,
-0.0182989184,
0.0267893635,
0.0516205318,
-0.0141444737,
-0.0483188778,
0.0356451087,
2.544179132e-34,
0.0566794313,
0.0092622498,
-0.0090497108,
0.0111502316,
0.0214651413,
-0.0106756659,
-0.0426836498,
0.0092435833,
0.0005661547,
-0.0233437587,
0.0346145108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01626v1 | SPARKLE: Enhancing SPARQL Generation with Direct KG Integration in Decoding | 2024-06-29T06:43:11 | 2024-06-29T06:43:11 | Jaebok Lee, Hyeonjeong Shin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing KBQA methods have traditionally relied on multi-stage methodologies,
involving tasks such as entity linking, subgraph retrieval and query structure
generation. However, multi-stage approaches are dependent on the accuracy of
preceding steps, leading to cascading errors and increased inference time.
Although a few studies have explored the use of end-to-end models, they often
suffer from lower accuracy and generate inoperative query that is not supported
by the underlying data. Furthermore, most prior approaches are limited to the
static training data, potentially overlooking the evolving nature of knowledge
bases over time. To address these challenges, we present a novel end-to-end
natural language to SPARQL framework, SPARKLE. Notably SPARKLE leverages the
structure of knowledge base directly during the decoding, effectively
integrating knowledge into the query generation. Our study reveals that simply
referencing knowledge base during inference significantly reduces the
occurrence of inexecutable query generations. SPARKLE achieves new
state-of-the-art results on SimpleQuestions-Wiki and highest F1 score on LCQuAD
1.0 (among models not using gold entities), while getting slightly lower result
on the WebQSP dataset. Finally, we demonstrate SPARKLE's fast inference speed
and its ability to adapt when the knowledge base differs between the training
and inference stages. | [
0.0648437217,
0.0660207495,
0.0188949145,
0.0103840251,
-0.0046859253,
0.0299961008,
-0.0529365093,
-0.0027553709,
0.0221336801,
-0.0220249817,
0.0065965247,
0.0193327386,
-0.0194097683,
0.0450792089,
0.0182501506,
-0.006127072,
0.0051573054,
0.0003230769,
-0.0273246914,
0.0203236658,
-0.0223534554,
0.0662779957,
-0.0301826485,
0.0157996919,
-0.0269551184,
0.0048392611,
-0.0408979543,
0.0470248871,
-0.0404928587,
-0.0247188769,
0.0117508555,
0.0628684312,
0.0064844419,
0.0101294369,
0.0000019857,
-0.0611911789,
-0.0288428999,
0.0516330898,
-0.052382499,
-0.0111619085,
0.009793696,
-0.0187635291,
0.0576738492,
0.0411651582,
-0.0508543774,
-0.0302358922,
0.0458181165,
0.0570309274,
0.0330546312,
0.0629062355,
-0.013901948,
-0.0452834852,
0.0065165279,
0.0030726527,
0.0205806643,
-0.0733844265,
-0.0142533416,
-0.0145479944,
0.0473375656,
0.0058444915,
-0.0119690094,
0.0307721365,
0.0160989482,
-0.0044134804,
0.0179650038,
0.0108591057,
-0.0231952332,
0.0018728424,
-0.0092074424,
0.0631018952,
0.0549316593,
-0.0225133393,
0.0203064512,
0.0335524492,
-0.0135233747,
-0.0001271619,
-0.0021303848,
-0.019299088,
-0.0196941327,
-0.0092271548,
0.0049926736,
-0.0145022804,
0.0188339725,
-0.0203060955,
-0.0478306711,
0.0812843218,
0.0283335317,
0.0045779976,
0.018543981,
0.0328343026,
0.023995867,
-0.0219678245,
-0.0199618526,
0.0087471092,
-0.0585007668,
0.0304838549,
-0.0411228649,
0.0581848696,
-0.0040880563,
-0.0044263718,
-0.0180843938,
0.0489557907,
0.0253742207,
0.0338674262,
-0.015792748,
0.0151477437,
-0.0069498112,
-0.0311071537,
-0.0326840207,
-0.0553187951,
-0.099547483,
0.0117387194,
-0.0401866026,
0.0378073044,
-0.0817206204,
-0.0307556745,
0.0031239088,
0.0487154536,
0.0424268618,
0.0051287422,
0.0644957945,
0.0431523286,
-0.0243626647,
0.0169859901,
-0.0396269783,
0.0564283058,
-0.0081775337,
-0.0268617235,
-0.0032502913,
-0.0684637949,
0.0062359632,
0.0007641889,
0.0093252454,
-0.0384294167,
-0.0297109969,
0.0193783734,
-0.0043661869,
-0.0172990952,
-0.0770688877,
-0.0597774424,
0.0270161927,
-0.0405586585,
0.003553719,
-0.0430835299,
0.0594968498,
0.0254110601,
-0.0145977875,
-0.0706188604,
0.0108491946,
0.0149988187,
-0.0758170187,
0.059167441,
-0.0839577466,
0.0036191044,
-0.0285852831,
-0.0173292477,
0.0158657618,
0.127175644,
0.001109728,
-0.0256669037,
0.0388665386,
0.013454265,
-0.0900495201,
-0.0067362115,
0.0340727791,
0.0018151922,
0.017261032,
0.0453635566,
-0.0418384597,
0.0197388697,
0.0048915586,
0.0183895659,
-0.0070465473,
0.004133835,
0.0027954218,
0.0116531188,
0.0204002894,
0.0086800195,
0.0126438299,
0.0536185987,
-0.0119814537,
-0.0228144173,
-0.0579000786,
0.0251822583,
0.0032993436,
0.0061042784,
0.0065846723,
0.0389756747,
-0.0187542364,
-0.0235522352,
-0.0012375413,
0.0311121792,
-0.0154465036,
0.0242571738,
0.0400517918,
0.0498737171,
-0.0514711067,
0.0947626904,
0.0162993129,
-0.0484823175,
0.0255629346,
-0.0083511826,
-0.0034065954,
0.0528207384,
0.0485201329,
-0.0051433225,
-0.0361850597,
0.0157505535,
-0.0220352877,
0.0369842313,
0.0035597384,
-0.0208909158,
0.0249264259,
-0.0369522944,
-0.0710849985,
0.0091707371,
0.0386808775,
-0.0432739705,
0.0449383892,
0.023724772,
0.0179009084,
-0.0522719212,
0.026405381,
0.0184109509,
-0.0210254733,
-0.0112160482,
0.0216130354,
0.0083088828,
-0.0104566822,
0.0523291007,
0.0007421774,
0.0189258493,
0.0208803955,
-0.0055222646,
-0.0450780392,
0.0051051695,
0.066479452,
-0.1037216559,
0.004974653,
-0.0220977273,
0.0025240944,
-0.0091593005,
-0.0512182675,
-0.0277852267,
0.0061884504,
-0.023975106,
0.0666965097,
-0.0452222973,
-0.0263326596,
0.0303003527,
-0.0580611415,
-0.030527655,
0.0326308124,
-0.0064562187,
-0.0216009896,
-0.0028173262,
0.0001956145,
0.0001065084,
-0.0237413906,
-0.0160958003,
-0.0069033555,
-0.0247733817,
0.010984607,
-0.0118755829,
0.0124659669,
-0.0830212831,
0.0194502808,
-0.063135758,
0.0158873592,
-0.0160035156,
0.010647689,
0.006553777,
0.0516322032,
0.0144983772,
-0.0059234379,
-0.0267173778,
-0.0089367274,
-0.0014090625,
0.0135513898,
0.0137057807,
0.0236037672,
-0.0035519379,
0.0036024547,
0.0121966032,
-0.015415201,
0.0698704496,
-0.015671216,
0.0052187406,
0.0039616153,
0.0733751282,
-0.0561432131,
-0.0115660653,
0.0176697969,
0.0119505031,
0.0013068559,
-0.0470589772,
-0.0077298214,
0.0306256972,
-0.0064150351,
-0.0195404422,
-0.0402520373,
-0.0455265939,
-0.0649009496,
0.0185172912,
-0.0255127475,
0.0078249443,
-0.0182539746,
-0.0256998371,
0.0616572425,
0.0095319469,
-0.0069493335,
-0.0234654639,
-0.0709074289,
0.0386448689,
0.0024265917,
-0.0017000784,
-0.0387190692,
0.045465678,
0.051381737,
0.0374403149,
-0.0114322482,
0.0013026776,
0.0614102297,
-0.0036884227,
0.0067489184,
-0.0137051204,
0.02276784,
-0.0262648687,
0.0417045765,
-0.0312127843,
0.0360492803,
-0.016435083,
-0.0521316826,
-0.0293643884,
0.0093444185,
0.0053317156,
-0.017921932,
0.0221840199,
-0.0175619274,
0.0431890264,
0.0255908705,
-0.0017587023,
-0.0466643311,
0.0681178272,
-0.0212094411,
-0.000802061,
0.0159174036,
-0.0189078655,
0.0098904036,
0.0175625533,
-0.0343023986,
-0.0362189673,
-0.0161540173,
-0.0339701325,
0.0069035334,
0.0380248129,
0.0676304102,
-0.0043763751,
0.007349188,
0.0020395711,
-0.0164420307,
0.0709224269,
0.0385679603,
-0.0483659841,
0.0344366804,
0.0271444786,
0.0377182811,
-0.0338143893,
0.008184568,
0.0141357984,
-0.0013966964,
-0.0270503405,
-0.0247981418,
0.0868464783,
0.0493945852,
0.022333825,
-0.0144874919,
0.0208721757,
0.0568905622,
0.0271724183,
0.0391040966,
-0.0981893688,
-0.0616900623,
0.002762059,
0.0761525854,
0.0311261453,
-0.0770283714,
-0.0020863838,
-0.1131813303,
0.0471072346,
-0.0237601604,
-0.0471759327,
-0.0559927188,
-0.0467857532,
-0.0340703167,
-0.0327987075,
-0.0363569111,
0.0739878565,
0.000055111,
0.0109520741,
-0.008577643,
-0.0175867099,
-0.0439121425,
-0.0260839425,
-0.0623449311,
0.0232613701,
0.0124192983,
0.0408556126,
0.0616034754,
0.0191072579,
-0.072138615,
-0.0319095626,
-0.0303028431,
-0.0541861877,
0.0629156455,
-0.0189697538,
-0.0028965278,
-0.0325610414,
0.0110814683,
-0.0615775101,
0.033253517,
-0.0259280447,
0.0489845276,
0.004219729,
0.0216680355,
-0.0210756566,
-0.0221687183,
0.0171169396,
0.084975563,
0.0073804273,
0.0343972929,
-0.050300654,
-0.033791244,
-0.0092436671,
-0.0551351011,
-0.0220023543,
0.0594029576,
-0.0372165367,
-0.0296836328,
-0.0572283082,
-0.0436310321,
0.0585632622,
0.0267328005,
-0.020082999,
0.0237835236,
0.005518557,
-0.0046969457,
-0.0988011509,
0.0198323224,
-0.0281574186,
-0.0002866118,
-0.0286015272,
-0.0018033566,
0.0342887379,
-0.008679986,
-0.0218756814,
0.0255281664,
-0.0295217093,
-0.0624214523,
-0.019748183,
0.0283902008,
0.0151492506,
0.0184030086,
-0.0219806787,
-0.0058559147,
0.0323661119,
0.0382125191,
-0.0568140894,
-0.0207111463,
-0.0080628581,
-0.0128710372,
-0.0009129852,
0.0701609999,
-0.0743938014,
-0.0533541739,
-0.0537063815,
0.1001823321,
-0.0059738951,
-0.0257859007,
0.03237148,
0.055869285,
-0.0444276705,
0.0261851773,
-0.0060099834,
-0.0178054813,
0.0169007666,
-0.0155985756,
-0.0281599965,
-0.0695073977,
0.0325324051,
0.0245320778,
0.0133652324,
0.006718325,
-0.0090248929,
-0.0060875625,
0.0608663857,
-0.0003289813,
-0.030420851,
0.0436848514,
0.0065310495,
0.0705691129,
-0.0390907563,
-0.0071372068,
0.0060032718,
0.0160781648,
0.0261778273,
-0.0393442512,
-0.0017804293,
0.0249464437,
0.0059155459,
-0.0159655921,
-0.0152766882,
-0.0251875333,
-0.0570464134,
-0.000976963,
-0.0185081009,
0.0520386137,
0.0110720498,
0.0614799932,
-0.0076999404,
-0.0015816122,
0.0003800808,
0.0357784964,
-0.0000015822,
0.0016913816,
0.036540933,
0.0122037036,
0.0003543561,
-0.0241075605,
0.0620096959,
0.0269285403,
0.0652164295,
-0.018852897,
-0.0552852824,
-0.0387736782,
-0.0633438975,
0.0280783903,
0.0156870391,
-0.0274020843,
0.0087132221,
-0.0561292395,
-0.0845265016,
0.0090822978,
-0.0273196325,
-0.0310916174,
0.0009786701,
0.0565293692,
0.0283822026,
0.0638770834,
-0.0646843985,
-0.0233953428,
-0.0185412038,
-0.0392486863,
-0.044127889,
0.0042425035,
-6.384645404e-33,
-0.0378284976,
-0.028613979,
0.0404310711,
-0.0211004522,
-0.0282254275,
-0.0235476624,
-0.0020696186,
-0.0567032546,
-0.0061865528,
0.0111933481,
0.0095349941,
0.0085992562,
0.0092695924,
0.0286593661,
-0.0100642852,
-0.0307973232,
0.0357390605,
0.0052667526,
0.0158856772,
0.0214751121,
0.0803123042,
0.0615376607,
0.0208624229,
-0.0014409811,
0.0155249285,
0.0051086512,
0.015615779,
0.05591207,
0.0267824773,
0.0404884368,
0.0068962942,
0.0356194563,
-0.0024849428,
-0.0074937246,
0.0017342753,
-0.0549393035,
-0.1152343377,
-0.0283526201,
0.015915174,
0.0240503252,
0.0014526972,
0.0000519722,
0.0291160475,
-0.001278288,
0.034321595,
-0.0294356607,
0.0098350924,
-0.0033184823,
-0.0098634046,
-0.0878040791,
-0.0317015164,
0.0176518485,
0.0020826336,
-0.0032134759,
-0.014854298,
0.0151995216,
0.0205700994,
-0.0172631759,
-0.0745984539,
0.0208607838,
-0.0037131773,
0.0182213094,
0.021437183,
-0.0193288606,
0.0144729353,
-0.0299805682,
0.0304630641,
-0.0316662081,
0.0094043789,
0.0627318993,
0.0199497025,
0.073658973,
0.003062804,
0.0269142147,
0.006425445,
-0.0072311657,
-0.085805513,
0.0299484041,
-0.0115936743,
0.0404522568,
-0.0242952667,
-0.0225982741,
-0.0485054031,
-0.0466457494,
-0.0437369384,
0.0350095071,
-0.0430386141,
-0.0180493388,
0.0696349964,
0.0030374432,
-0.0203616731,
-0.0064210002,
0.0138702365,
-0.0411520079,
0.0049629947,
0.0586308166,
0.0093886731,
-0.0298928246,
-0.0104204761,
0.0360257737,
-0.0400891751,
-0.0001317145,
0.0363995656,
-0.0603955351,
-0.0388835631,
-0.0017680631,
-0.0200852007,
0.0030914531,
-0.0469781831,
0.001351362,
-0.0073415632,
0.043005567,
-0.0178309083,
0.0081804311,
0.0176241733,
0.0119644376,
0.0034644874,
0.0199788753,
0.0292163342,
0.0236785021,
-0.0294008665,
-0.0116963675,
0.0530563593,
0.0101460284,
0.0140513545,
-0.0032690426,
-0.0282738414,
-0.0395839177,
-0.0196653455,
-0.0381632932,
-0.0401866324,
0.0386434011,
2.778e-7,
0.0419577211,
0.0271092895,
0.018495189,
0.0822479352,
-0.0455248728,
0.0031066013,
0.0042111115,
0.0408583544,
0.0266806465,
-0.0090727145,
-0.012693855,
0.0402868502,
0.0159950554,
0.0450758561,
-0.0993360057,
-0.01699223,
0.0268421415,
-0.0619897507,
-0.0566679351,
-0.0143821938,
0.0485676117,
0.0196207836,
-0.0059823529,
-0.0056111757,
0.0195376184,
-0.0078777988,
0.030530747,
0.037997786,
-0.0345479511,
0.0331204571,
0.0363219082,
-0.014758504,
0.0036356987,
0.0279109441,
-0.0206857175,
0.0319319256,
-0.0179259107,
0.0322630443,
-0.0015638047,
-0.051759053,
-0.00255982,
-0.060762804,
0.0414774045,
-0.0091053816,
0.0824404284,
-0.0341016501,
0.028848825,
0.0839847028,
-0.0533626527,
-0.017505914,
-0.0299777146,
-0.0199467763,
-0.0027012762,
0.0058635427,
0.0418677814,
-0.000017823,
0.0246056411,
-0.0306169074,
0.0017016166,
0.0221856926,
0.0047687744,
-0.0538499057,
-0.0004100354,
-0.0028529956,
-0.0220296551,
-0.0126321996,
0.0018598683,
2.858170203e-34,
0.0239403229,
0.0486013927,
0.0048783747,
0.059046872,
0.0684837401,
-0.0215451587,
-0.0173203982,
-0.0143270465,
0.0223362353,
-0.0894079953,
-0.0006452354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00322v1 | LLM-Generated Natural Language Meets Scaling Laws: New Explorations and Data Augmentation Methods | 2024-06-29T05:40:17 | 2024-06-29T05:40:17 | Zhenhua Wang, Guang Xu, Ming Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the ascent of large language models (LLM), natural language processing
has witnessed enhancements, such as LLM-based data augmentation. Nonetheless,
prior research harbors two primary concerns: firstly, a lack of contemplation
regarding whether the natural language generated by LLM (LLMNL) truly aligns
with human natural language (HNL), a critical foundational question; secondly,
an oversight that augmented data is randomly generated by LLM, implying that
not all data may possess equal training value, that could impede the
performance of classifiers. To address these challenges, we introduce the
scaling laws to intrinsically calculate LLMNL and HNL. Through extensive
experiments, we reveal slight deviations (approximately 0.2 Mandelbrot
exponent) from Mandelbrot's law in LLMNL, underscore a complexity advantage in
HNL, and supplement an interpretive discussion on language style. This
establishes a solid foundation for LLM's expansion. Further, we introduce a
novel data augmentation method for few-shot text classification, termed ZGPTDA,
which leverages fuzzy computing mechanisms driven by the conformity to scaling
laws to make decisions about GPT-4 augmented data. Extensive experiments,
conducted in real-world scenarios, confirms the effectiveness (improving F1 of
Bert and RoBerta by 7-10%) and competitiveness (surpassing recent AugGPT and
GENCO methods by about 2% accuracy on DeBerta) of ZGPTDA. In addition, we
reveal some interesting insights, e.g., Hilberg's law and Taylor's law can
impart more benefits to text classification, etc. | [
0.0097481105,
0.0576277375,
-0.0168978591,
0.0331054367,
-0.0427501537,
0.0194838848,
-0.0049957125,
0.0311996937,
-0.0029511156,
-0.0829020515,
-0.0278466623,
-0.0651547611,
0.01959108,
-0.0071816714,
0.0468280949,
-0.0407176204,
0.0112240566,
-0.0101583358,
-0.0030861537,
-0.0046233176,
0.0118902065,
-0.0091893123,
0.0278588757,
0.0071235267,
0.0202971995,
0.0374375209,
0.0206896588,
0.0041708141,
0.0286842473,
-0.0271800924,
-0.023877766,
0.0401385278,
0.0354309753,
0.0608399287,
0.0000021937,
-0.0840983316,
0.0306400992,
0.0128357392,
0.000452929,
0.0506126583,
0.0619244799,
-0.0440543406,
-0.0320867747,
0.0312804207,
-0.0259420518,
-0.0500619188,
0.0045179813,
0.0651442483,
0.0210675001,
0.0936563388,
-0.0086272582,
-0.0938082114,
0.0780899152,
-0.0239991676,
0.0234384723,
-0.0075136502,
0.0561040081,
-0.0119582759,
0.0192780718,
0.0640044287,
-0.0104497653,
0.0131631661,
0.0075445678,
0.0347936563,
0.0097367959,
0.0460111424,
-0.0511911176,
0.0400568247,
0.0074693318,
0.0583691336,
-0.0052604261,
-0.0589124225,
-0.0158514567,
-0.0221475586,
-0.0003725506,
0.0083792089,
-0.0548052266,
0.0091761788,
0.0024149807,
0.0523238443,
0.0008481907,
-0.0012984086,
0.0487494767,
0.028140422,
-0.0177742597,
0.0506216288,
-0.0007508803,
-0.0588931814,
-0.0162886363,
-0.0223249234,
-0.0768554062,
-0.0353329368,
-0.0123754488,
0.0236456729,
0.0463202372,
-0.0046743322,
-0.0584798045,
-0.0392903835,
0.0663282722,
-0.0507857352,
-0.002533671,
0.0159582477,
0.0299861357,
0.032351993,
-0.034780167,
0.0472856127,
-0.0284876842,
-0.0268314835,
-0.04842503,
-0.0012158639,
-0.0651507825,
-0.0119308801,
-0.0356077589,
0.0561817512,
-0.0089738909,
-0.0167420898,
-0.0853718668,
0.0247172248,
0.0258816686,
-0.0033891411,
-0.0123328306,
-0.0007771171,
0.004796715,
0.0099277757,
-0.0198136289,
0.0365666151,
-0.0263729226,
0.0312361997,
-0.0184796397,
-0.0218702685,
0.0122773089,
0.0232656393,
0.0245155469,
-0.021682255,
0.0441394374,
0.0563612282,
0.0145604135,
-0.071854569,
-0.0684469417,
0.0125836236,
-0.0129985502,
-0.0383684412,
-0.0390460044,
-0.064969182,
-0.0048675304,
-0.0115219038,
-0.0242913775,
0.0032166212,
0.0097610755,
0.0427877493,
-0.0698435009,
0.1100983918,
-0.0653081983,
0.0085328287,
0.0513836481,
-0.0159415901,
0.0184809864,
0.0541173667,
0.0476868376,
-0.0140006132,
0.0401511677,
-0.0111024389,
0.0413349606,
0.0762135237,
0.0209631771,
0.010226652,
-0.0318830982,
-0.0112979244,
-0.0506390035,
0.0201398414,
0.0215524826,
0.0463801846,
-0.0405021422,
0.0123585695,
0.0721930936,
0.063833423,
0.019912025,
0.0574140586,
-0.0255110208,
0.0272919666,
0.0174331162,
0.0197193678,
-0.0502776317,
-0.0129359504,
-0.0706834868,
0.006318687,
0.0330491103,
0.0423046984,
-0.0320520401,
-0.0445120484,
-0.0281629469,
-0.0153895197,
0.0427413099,
-0.0429933779,
0.0587944388,
-0.0136195961,
0.0093420455,
-0.0129354671,
0.0369649157,
-0.0258554202,
-0.0227185842,
-0.0309985895,
-0.0251172148,
0.0349079594,
0.0584732704,
-0.0347338393,
-0.0066044512,
-0.0155044384,
-0.016251741,
0.0152262542,
0.0224163458,
0.0352924056,
-0.0247656945,
-0.0717002302,
-0.0157259256,
0.0141510339,
0.0244358573,
-0.0029809759,
0.0204560775,
0.0277374238,
0.0075880555,
-0.0231594276,
-0.026740415,
0.019126866,
0.0095039029,
-0.0668569207,
0.0499363169,
-0.0277557373,
0.0236719884,
0.0134616932,
-0.0445008837,
0.0062965765,
-0.0020652206,
-0.0300640576,
-0.0582853816,
-0.0221404955,
-0.0002131303,
-0.0550686195,
0.0158040691,
0.0024657738,
0.0237916112,
-0.0085769985,
-0.037723992,
-0.0315526128,
0.0097206384,
-0.0480187237,
0.02893053,
-0.0753176957,
0.0372448005,
-0.0172611307,
0.0601454377,
-0.0485476069,
0.0695897117,
-0.0088243112,
-0.009516337,
-0.0223923344,
0.0424813293,
0.0367426425,
-0.0148809655,
-0.0304546002,
0.0017424584,
0.005266706,
0.0360874236,
0.0232908949,
-0.0098745525,
-0.0150174173,
-0.0071366499,
-0.07166107,
-0.0031694472,
-0.0147721618,
0.0378308631,
-0.0065135644,
0.0220282525,
-0.024708828,
0.0125671756,
-0.031189207,
-0.0281503592,
-0.0034106709,
0.0105022276,
0.0536118187,
-0.0192250442,
-0.0227237251,
-0.0076759569,
-0.0111709042,
-0.0239631571,
0.0179166701,
0.0311315786,
-0.0043664686,
-0.0536834896,
0.0069609834,
-0.0246276967,
0.0172170643,
-0.0069579333,
-0.0273792278,
-0.0134856412,
-0.0081779575,
0.0305289254,
0.0208992921,
0.0220971163,
-0.0155691244,
0.0266822763,
0.0533554479,
-0.0348476805,
0.0060295891,
-0.0157143809,
0.0057418519,
-0.0126398094,
-0.0345375501,
0.0196206141,
0.0451084524,
-0.0314496085,
-0.0203642845,
-0.0513294302,
0.0213435311,
-0.0089355614,
0.0013266907,
-0.0006298897,
0.0116331698,
-0.0417459421,
0.0091089001,
0.0183976032,
-0.0725240558,
0.031264428,
-0.0465177,
0.0055646738,
-0.0524973944,
-0.0571555123,
-0.0505775809,
0.0444571674,
0.0441494845,
0.0117343748,
0.0159973074,
-0.0020997792,
-0.001461742,
-0.0165747032,
0.0114844507,
-0.0360127576,
0.0425059386,
-0.0330439545,
0.0301239975,
0.0017151593,
-0.0361306295,
-0.0107820071,
-0.050018616,
-0.002072531,
0.0060473382,
0.0189002436,
-0.0497180633,
-0.0234892536,
-0.0035452428,
0.0182479508,
0.045500312,
-0.0216308534,
-0.0202393979,
-0.017403625,
0.0505315512,
0.0454916656,
-0.0046534352,
0.0173074305,
0.0039687487,
-0.008041827,
0.0211643856,
0.0418642312,
0.0312452316,
-0.0411367491,
-0.015014505,
0.0115309386,
-0.0201688427,
-0.062538445,
0.0098259496,
0.014078212,
-0.0268501863,
0.0344004221,
0.1265922934,
0.0221374463,
-0.0303136706,
0.013999071,
0.0088189896,
0.0210202131,
0.0139947133,
0.0205906313,
-0.0896845162,
-0.0383777842,
-0.0188472047,
0.0188484769,
-0.0558728985,
-0.0299086981,
-0.0118065523,
-0.1333471388,
0.0290601812,
0.0258576125,
-0.0150549468,
-0.012323427,
-0.0508570112,
0.0057752342,
-0.0193924271,
0.0100037167,
-0.0268790368,
-0.0098956199,
0.00513962,
0.0165171232,
-0.0272907056,
-0.0750043318,
-0.0017690418,
-0.0484579727,
0.0601755828,
0.0302931666,
0.0311730243,
-0.0481774248,
-0.0241014231,
0.0292514917,
0.0100070443,
0.004583417,
-0.0165903326,
0.0400710888,
0.0079859458,
0.0070309392,
-0.0577551574,
0.0387860499,
0.0228451397,
-0.0084450804,
0.0142278746,
0.072543256,
-0.012412779,
-0.0330758989,
-0.0390699878,
-0.0110305222,
-0.0354360938,
0.0844749287,
0.0072271111,
-0.0478608124,
-0.0197698176,
-0.0158670377,
-0.0078630103,
0.0133984629,
-0.0285392683,
-0.0004983408,
-0.0084560392,
-0.0161790475,
-0.0637965351,
-0.021363508,
-0.0065163304,
0.0110091558,
-0.0084252311,
0.0260136593,
-0.0003433036,
0.0004790558,
-0.0065062973,
-0.0191900488,
-0.0109157199,
0.0129651772,
-0.0251386184,
-0.0037385197,
0.0525026135,
-0.0409557819,
0.0033164751,
0.0129082995,
-0.0567837916,
-0.0637036264,
-0.0151708145,
-0.003769831,
0.0227339976,
0.0425219722,
-0.0023542012,
-0.090726845,
0.0777940825,
0.1342636794,
-0.019000968,
0.0451515093,
0.0097458921,
0.0201393943,
0.0011016191,
0.0072144452,
-0.0045792186,
0.042933289,
-0.017599212,
0.0266811568,
-0.0491102077,
-0.0252705887,
0.0073390561,
0.0636187345,
0.0462521836,
-0.0264034662,
-0.0122789443,
0.0230703745,
0.0098785851,
-0.0122827496,
0.0112058436,
-0.0329248235,
-0.0390050299,
0.0521749929,
0.0052683209,
-0.0485714115,
-0.0221213009,
-0.0097428132,
0.0089784069,
-0.0318995677,
-0.0274729654,
-0.0361774974,
0.0115150865,
0.0071636778,
-0.0000838167,
0.0017610795,
0.0096484972,
0.0169312675,
0.0346188135,
-0.0202166215,
0.0525364801,
0.0045327637,
0.0019877476,
-0.029008029,
0.0381985828,
-0.0884245709,
0.0019059093,
-0.0515537038,
0.0491636433,
0.0261182524,
-0.0019524847,
0.0419394597,
-0.0490636826,
-0.0178073384,
-0.0202673711,
-0.0245081894,
-0.0237339307,
0.0169977155,
0.0184575282,
0.0307694692,
-0.041956909,
0.0109418761,
0.058742445,
0.0360479355,
0.0068614185,
0.0067684753,
-0.011732473,
-0.0156942084,
-0.025756469,
0.0447614007,
0.0288397167,
-0.0150927845,
0.024022568,
-0.072081767,
-0.0535470694,
-0.019648008,
-0.0190580655,
-0.0002605833,
-0.0396373235,
0.0406665094,
0.0169376694,
-0.0614533573,
-0.0054779835,
-0.0251336638,
0.0006263614,
-0.00396966,
0.0061744032,
0.0336012021,
-6.221096671e-33,
-0.0123275956,
0.0173648205,
0.008399318,
0.0164513476,
-0.0114210322,
-0.0212274678,
0.0448977277,
-0.0108527942,
-0.0057481453,
0.0130333668,
-0.0162378307,
0.0011252589,
0.0029343378,
0.0535346009,
-0.0095941992,
-0.0236149766,
0.0333763734,
-0.0223006513,
-0.0173211489,
0.0155783435,
0.0051458701,
0.0191423763,
0.0775177255,
-0.0466740094,
-0.0077535752,
-0.0154346908,
-0.0265482925,
0.0258038267,
0.0004973164,
0.0302058719,
-0.0286185462,
0.0761825442,
0.026944777,
-0.0524516329,
0.002450492,
-0.0002066425,
-0.0447688662,
-0.0492111817,
0.0160210114,
0.0163529422,
0.0173497386,
0.0017613211,
0.0739280134,
-0.0201992784,
-0.0537150614,
-0.0013982722,
0.0361703075,
-0.0298870858,
-0.0141309416,
-0.0179563537,
-0.0298077166,
0.0470704585,
0.0190359801,
0.0160008725,
0.0084636062,
-0.0031822098,
-0.0122842388,
0.0682633296,
-0.064967297,
0.007871706,
0.0742023736,
0.0044188499,
0.0067986907,
0.0018407223,
0.0206099376,
0.0533075668,
0.0461955145,
-0.0091469651,
-0.0617926307,
-0.033892896,
0.049343992,
0.0075237374,
0.0178577062,
0.0768485293,
0.0640770793,
0.0103838593,
-0.0503363721,
0.0557366274,
0.0538764633,
-0.0020535723,
-0.0205373969,
0.0045234389,
-0.0757588372,
-0.0424266905,
-0.008385594,
-0.0013268579,
-0.0272579025,
-0.0156571418,
-0.0053045144,
-0.0006834406,
0.0052813794,
0.0216592494,
-0.0044589746,
-0.061657656,
-0.0541017875,
-0.0035231786,
-0.0094161015,
0.0210288595,
0.0092958268,
0.0116178244,
-0.0436015241,
-0.0290909261,
0.0067704171,
0.0262751002,
0.007416266,
0.0002322877,
0.0433409289,
0.0309156328,
-0.0861933157,
-0.0012131716,
0.0007836772,
-0.0267776847,
0.0258481372,
-0.0250257179,
0.0037700729,
0.0213904455,
0.027452033,
0.0334796868,
0.0651337132,
0.0092928894,
-0.0150354197,
-0.0018509961,
-0.003982658,
0.0023418462,
-0.015576357,
0.0006989454,
0.0128550436,
0.0074172225,
0.0251698438,
-0.0895713866,
-0.0169948228,
0.0169601198,
3.011e-7,
0.0499446988,
0.0764761344,
0.0065581384,
-0.0210300628,
0.0310330968,
0.0652680695,
-0.0321694165,
0.040278323,
0.0001700837,
0.0371242426,
0.0471852981,
0.0062421137,
0.0119777583,
0.0109909205,
-0.0653914064,
0.0210315883,
-0.0756973326,
-0.0199024845,
-0.0510552637,
0.0242715962,
0.0415660851,
0.1111916527,
0.0478993431,
-0.0496861003,
0.0235695522,
-0.0600028001,
0.0740743726,
-0.0373620465,
0.0011733577,
0.0283460729,
-0.0015843388,
0.0424126685,
-0.0094612939,
0.0469285846,
-0.0014625996,
0.0490188897,
0.0126915285,
0.0433121584,
-0.0208024345,
0.0394975506,
0.0051130699,
-0.0415030569,
-0.0121719232,
-0.0899509937,
0.0883772224,
-0.0477397777,
-0.0443382151,
0.0225341916,
-0.0260903351,
-0.037724223,
0.0465644412,
-0.0126137678,
-0.0116435736,
0.0022428727,
0.0157927647,
0.0198932141,
-0.0360055491,
-0.0885876268,
-0.0017534631,
0.0235335231,
-0.0503008254,
-0.0363960713,
-0.0556007363,
0.03384744,
0.0562761463,
-0.0657473803,
0.0217315853,
3.001825256e-34,
0.039773114,
-0.0105777094,
-0.0027398788,
-0.0276567452,
-0.0061486084,
0.0223437492,
0.0357060023,
0.0303724371,
0.0138565451,
-0.1188274249,
0.0218304712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00320v1 | LiteSearch: Efficacious Tree Search for LLM | 2024-06-29T05:14:04 | 2024-06-29T05:14:04 | Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Ye Tian, Baolin Peng, Dian Yu, Haitao Mi, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent research suggests that tree search algorithms (e.g. Monte Carlo Tree
Search) can dramatically boost LLM performance on complex mathematical
reasoning tasks. However, they often require more than 10 times the
computational resources of greedy decoding due to wasteful search strategies,
making them difficult to be deployed in practical applications. This study
introduces a novel guided tree search algorithm with dynamic node selection and
node-level exploration budget (maximum number of children) calculation to
tackle this issue. By considering the search progress towards the final answer
(history) and the guidance from a value network (future) trained without any
step-wise annotations, our algorithm iteratively selects the most promising
tree node before expanding it within the boundaries of the allocated
computational budget. Experiments conducted on the GSM8K and TabMWP datasets
demonstrate that our approach not only offers competitive performance but also
enjoys significantly lower computational costs compared to baseline methods. | [
-0.0253371708,
0.0409433171,
-0.0047540418,
0.0230149664,
-0.0477391668,
-0.0164784994,
-0.0826611444,
0.0233890284,
-0.0610088967,
0.030028861,
0.0053138277,
0.0306510013,
-0.0101638343,
-0.0271441862,
-0.0347415321,
-0.0155751221,
0.0413534939,
-0.0274354089,
0.0293274466,
-0.0204368159,
-0.0525079481,
-0.0158497524,
-0.0281181112,
0.0109877503,
-0.0150748137,
-0.0287920311,
-0.0702230483,
0.0320683122,
0.0459326133,
-0.0710312501,
-0.0303919427,
-0.011895936,
0.0218844078,
0.0277529638,
0.0000023378,
-0.0094371177,
-0.0475425795,
-0.0141420104,
-0.1027888432,
-0.0119400565,
0.0027230177,
0.0555318333,
-0.0109421685,
0.0241056606,
-0.0461289771,
0.025723733,
0.0300832242,
-0.0076585049,
0.0557204224,
0.0787910223,
0.0328539908,
-0.0642983392,
0.0312783681,
-0.0049512745,
0.0784921423,
-0.100426808,
0.0036126629,
0.0432840623,
0.0052452344,
-0.0110527361,
-0.0070845196,
0.0109444242,
0.0567139573,
0.0145812063,
0.0041312124,
0.0267831273,
-0.0167630371,
0.017270308,
-0.0082713747,
0.0540392734,
-0.0130512193,
-0.0173610691,
-0.0176161509,
-0.0447930992,
-0.0460319333,
-0.0380916446,
-0.0182594433,
0.0492801964,
-0.0493675582,
0.0361858234,
0.0545238256,
0.0263636298,
0.0378683582,
0.0140954182,
-0.0370153002,
0.1088782176,
-0.0182260592,
-0.0217922796,
0.0458575003,
0.005944496,
-0.0099504199,
-0.0392272733,
0.0028123045,
0.044918295,
-0.0257504564,
0.0375033282,
0.0246034544,
0.0030041365,
-0.0447638147,
0.0013998331,
0.0267845169,
0.0562913418,
0.0243345499,
0.0018963846,
-0.0131773446,
-0.0068559907,
-0.0390682779,
0.0029850919,
-0.040717639,
-0.0026475901,
-0.033300627,
-0.0214629062,
-0.0265794415,
0.0660076439,
-0.0374350734,
0.011679356,
-0.0479182117,
0.0121865841,
0.0282124616,
-0.0082266433,
0.0296447109,
0.0101828156,
0.0107455477,
0.0104866037,
-0.0505688861,
0.0039392458,
-0.0513030179,
0.0113037266,
-0.0003849638,
0.0005516667,
-0.013416796,
0.0293373596,
-0.0285206288,
-0.0158293098,
0.0426150411,
0.0829785615,
0.0139521323,
-0.0131188901,
-0.0830495283,
-0.0196557734,
0.0269351657,
-0.0494241603,
0.0694216415,
-0.0588022843,
0.0013538403,
-0.0531979352,
-0.043071717,
0.0220870189,
0.021566255,
0.0509238318,
0.0406565219,
0.0366147198,
0.0115674594,
-0.0034768402,
0.0108115803,
-0.0215704478,
-0.0030354739,
0.0780306831,
0.0426217057,
0.0490771271,
-0.0006410991,
0.007827484,
-0.0218278673,
0.0363058485,
0.0220922921,
-0.0409099162,
0.0055895103,
-0.0009403713,
-0.0608893074,
0.0769640505,
-0.0271980558,
-0.0336805694,
-0.084871687,
-0.010943369,
0.0092087723,
0.0264447946,
0.0195160676,
-0.0333517753,
-0.0010207222,
-0.039938096,
0.0025473067,
-0.0388050415,
-0.0502628833,
0.0400798097,
-0.0670772344,
0.0098352861,
-0.0479153804,
-0.0253848545,
0.0031356351,
-0.0582658127,
-0.0021361553,
0.0202361457,
-0.0179644804,
0.0220799446,
0.0413684919,
0.0132655874,
-0.0411796421,
0.0431275405,
-0.0116865607,
0.0101118479,
-0.056624487,
-0.0484680943,
0.0283899326,
0.0045427685,
0.0592558347,
-0.0375459827,
-0.0337628163,
0.0199784245,
-0.0430628732,
0.0248822216,
0.0063095624,
-0.0161569808,
0.0215098616,
-0.0446451195,
-0.0325526893,
0.010617204,
0.0231903866,
0.0182206556,
0.0347526185,
-0.0140357222,
-0.0139007252,
-0.064429909,
0.0270869434,
0.0221356731,
0.0005407301,
-0.0293462742,
0.0624195635,
-0.0037122443,
0.0320817232,
0.0239354055,
0.015809888,
0.0183859337,
0.0257179718,
-0.0085109053,
-0.0299368277,
-0.0396738574,
-0.0784575269,
-0.0825201795,
0.0308728628,
-0.0680686831,
-0.0219838079,
0.0005143434,
-0.0547719039,
-0.0185303967,
-0.0025973774,
-0.0671025962,
0.0200957675,
-0.033953134,
0.0133897588,
-0.0050790398,
-0.0292146504,
-0.0352635048,
0.1027732044,
-0.0151288835,
-0.0176631417,
0.0331112072,
0.0058847675,
0.0415912978,
-0.0519268364,
0.0488482453,
-0.0104603106,
-0.0191213656,
-0.0079919891,
-0.0071805944,
0.0364740081,
-0.0251600351,
-0.0037299464,
-0.0295572653,
0.0432793796,
0.0035979876,
0.0695377216,
0.0053922054,
-0.0187889785,
0.0063142884,
-0.0082875853,
-0.0173546374,
0.0702807978,
-0.0212287717,
-0.034500137,
0.025912188,
-0.0071428777,
-0.016689254,
-0.0216606371,
-0.0323088691,
-0.0229315199,
0.0076653729,
-0.0317687243,
-0.0131613491,
-0.0030209837,
0.0279454906,
0.0032771823,
-0.0225620959,
0.0021030412,
0.0189492702,
0.0466112196,
-0.0430754498,
-0.0218432359,
0.0671295375,
-0.0215458367,
0.0090264324,
0.010405194,
-0.019024862,
-0.0851012394,
0.0159320701,
-0.0183061901,
0.0079875886,
-0.016309645,
-0.0363095701,
0.0419812948,
0.0667954087,
-0.0113550508,
0.0343399383,
-0.0309255049,
-0.0135159222,
0.0491732247,
-0.0333185047,
0.0106186057,
0.0447835475,
-0.0058884742,
0.0611672364,
-0.0003859223,
-0.0321255699,
0.0591519512,
0.000504524,
-0.0012892579,
-0.0529211722,
-0.0142594678,
-0.0710972324,
0.0443027616,
-0.017698599,
-0.0300237034,
0.0138837518,
-0.05868797,
-0.0215226859,
0.0212087501,
0.0567367822,
-0.0094062928,
0.0475846939,
-0.0239956658,
-0.0042049661,
-0.0176519398,
-0.014200897,
-0.0228210688,
0.0059055337,
-0.0102266436,
0.0253907014,
-0.0118811596,
-0.0018865777,
-0.0103363683,
-0.0378771387,
-0.0065172915,
0.0159577578,
-0.0324144103,
-0.0146743907,
-0.0277979691,
0.0072380831,
-0.0080101499,
0.0225064494,
0.0750815347,
-0.0205872413,
0.0489217937,
0.0342159718,
0.0249910485,
0.0198606923,
-0.0301445201,
0.0226340666,
0.0187237859,
-0.0404660329,
-0.0312281419,
0.0495876297,
0.0185517576,
-0.0872941241,
-0.0017024059,
0.0479168855,
0.0319063663,
-0.0418599322,
-0.0075513041,
-0.0960902125,
0.0294382926,
0.0100454874,
0.0396182388,
-0.0830941424,
-0.0405480452,
0.0305836741,
0.0633889958,
-0.022868244,
-0.0617383234,
0.0002010122,
-0.1259584725,
0.025142869,
0.0159926601,
-0.0009606219,
0.0023655538,
-0.0028413793,
-0.0505928323,
-0.0052220901,
-0.0006273988,
0.028253682,
0.0137636308,
-0.0081361765,
0.0170149524,
-0.0550244041,
-0.0136774909,
0.0288981888,
-0.0105095878,
0.0077453135,
0.0928337574,
0.0315822586,
-0.0105747599,
-0.0281613991,
-0.0008328157,
0.005234783,
0.0148019847,
-0.0388894379,
-0.0003588994,
0.0073019429,
0.0167288929,
-0.0032353727,
0.0261499248,
-0.0198303312,
-0.0352844633,
0.0524204411,
0.1155418083,
-0.0699336603,
-0.0048075868,
-0.0309518501,
-0.0009920878,
-0.0165504627,
0.0371845365,
0.0002130521,
0.0024897209,
-0.0571648441,
-0.056261763,
0.0179278087,
-0.0591421574,
-0.0262754392,
0.0701795593,
0.0407448597,
0.0323376432,
-0.0288545489,
-0.0055544814,
0.0271517448,
0.040857669,
-0.0359833762,
-0.0138834361,
-0.0335345976,
-0.0027868848,
-0.0441695005,
-0.011895543,
-0.0506306365,
0.0313661695,
-0.0181277469,
0.0752127394,
0.0195906553,
-0.0360131599,
-0.0008766073,
-0.0087961406,
-0.0586668625,
-0.0112227574,
-0.0423623212,
0.0340736695,
0.0207377411,
0.0375760831,
-0.0201488789,
-0.0022552002,
0.0078851962,
0.0035877093,
-0.0173221007,
0.0201979931,
0.052202601,
0.0181437582,
-0.0106895659,
0.0129074948,
-0.0313821919,
0.0253722072,
0.0029567024,
0.0713754669,
-0.0291136019,
-0.0090478295,
0.0267928466,
0.0293577388,
0.0022019467,
0.0111980485,
-0.0127326949,
0.0067485855,
0.0537786894,
-0.0051560565,
0.0288411714,
-0.0173798632,
0.008382922,
0.0073023257,
-0.0119034927,
0.0132355317,
-0.0560637861,
0.0264553502,
-0.003995968,
0.0114093963,
0.0471463092,
0.0383078791,
0.0385824256,
0.0026770851,
-0.0202661324,
-0.0064152014,
-0.0164860487,
0.0179891717,
0.0669141859,
0.0015965709,
0.0578567088,
0.0215031747,
0.0071916133,
-0.0229828879,
-0.039308846,
-0.0413459539,
-0.0850454196,
0.0002032593,
-0.0060299197,
0.0770069957,
0.0655503124,
-0.0612088144,
-0.0406065695,
0.0197803881,
0.0173496883,
-0.0090341223,
-0.0017024219,
-0.0276586264,
0.0653179213,
0.0208586119,
-0.0121947499,
-0.0378845222,
0.0180686619,
0.0268359371,
0.041267667,
-0.0337140597,
0.0302411262,
-0.0340491347,
-0.0462269224,
-0.0207140297,
0.0436687656,
0.0052203964,
-0.009896256,
-0.0667836741,
-0.0315435454,
0.0137646282,
0.0340682268,
0.0029108303,
-0.0088603534,
0.0565588437,
0.0098064207,
-0.0034053216,
-0.0281972811,
0.0062893094,
-0.0032748983,
-0.0365394503,
0.0224932395,
-0.0268825386,
-6.049975183e-33,
-0.0314451158,
-0.0357371196,
0.0685487017,
-0.0044390592,
-0.0572356433,
-0.0071743801,
-0.037913572,
-0.0112666553,
0.0040225033,
-0.0033577681,
-0.0155956456,
0.022647744,
0.0193588976,
0.0156533252,
0.0312519036,
-0.0243460033,
0.0101443008,
-0.0178764537,
-0.018863745,
-0.0235884879,
-0.0186356343,
0.0117145237,
0.0634788722,
-0.0505708344,
-0.0454778485,
0.0437530801,
-0.0068351622,
0.0585053302,
-0.0554795526,
0.0539457425,
0.0224459302,
0.013422261,
-0.0068585868,
-0.0657981932,
-0.0320258699,
-0.0291965902,
-0.0547874533,
-0.0644809306,
-0.0012900612,
0.0152588757,
-0.0661073625,
-0.0377616137,
0.0218191464,
0.0326298662,
0.0037520283,
-0.0269539449,
-0.0072607608,
-0.0508206375,
-0.043327976,
-0.0526876114,
0.0201713927,
0.0499092713,
0.0187699869,
0.0372046903,
0.021851832,
0.0285243299,
-0.0321927704,
0.0187839624,
-0.0104980841,
0.0174699705,
-0.0001803726,
0.0005108555,
0.0165768918,
0.0108984848,
0.0297550689,
0.0446180739,
0.0539330505,
-0.0510746278,
-0.0351858847,
-0.0052107614,
0.0137271229,
0.094740428,
0.0411521196,
-0.0032108014,
0.0590819083,
0.0327849798,
-0.0767054483,
0.0075506316,
0.0434784517,
0.0387506112,
0.0043079969,
0.0200468097,
-0.0000104202,
-0.0075590182,
-0.0377707034,
0.0104410499,
-0.0259156805,
-0.0388677828,
0.0237227306,
-0.0032494424,
0.0291586276,
-0.0130499918,
0.0203171633,
-0.0353056453,
0.0482125431,
0.0403326862,
0.0160494968,
0.0377746597,
0.0023081845,
0.038692195,
-0.0421214812,
-0.0258562881,
-0.0069474191,
-0.083316341,
0.0450745672,
0.004283776,
-0.0493477844,
0.0223192479,
-0.0208866559,
-0.029268479,
-0.0191688873,
-0.0087829903,
0.0076827374,
0.0371745452,
0.0538317375,
-0.0082972366,
0.0058020731,
0.0270877946,
-0.003440158,
0.0311515518,
-0.0193387475,
-0.0065160966,
0.0215980001,
0.041434966,
0.0217545554,
0.0160385836,
-0.0250578653,
-0.0127369026,
-0.0174233727,
-0.0607338175,
0.0019946939,
0.0829849765,
3.046e-7,
0.0368623249,
0.0273872465,
0.0278713107,
0.0613761656,
0.0331568383,
0.0286466479,
-0.002958107,
-0.0777262002,
-0.0201075003,
-0.0610132962,
0.0605034269,
0.0111095803,
0.0624097846,
0.0361342318,
-0.0835547373,
-0.0058421991,
-0.0001684354,
-0.0063373889,
-0.0233894326,
-0.0109849265,
0.0426361077,
0.0734538883,
0.016418973,
-0.0124816,
0.0191581994,
0.0410962477,
0.022474125,
-0.0202460531,
0.0167911611,
-0.0065506473,
-0.0044500097,
-0.0406275839,
-0.0078071714,
-0.0012338276,
0.00492719,
0.0525035709,
-0.0289586503,
0.0697550997,
0.0296824668,
-0.0810060278,
0.0085005583,
-0.0354442969,
0.0088634342,
0.021439869,
0.0627475306,
-0.0495226979,
-0.0336104184,
0.0151346084,
-0.0028917284,
-0.0201146994,
0.0129125314,
0.0072658733,
0.0415130891,
0.0052018603,
-0.015944805,
-0.0024172408,
-0.008882883,
-0.0716935173,
-0.0001068708,
0.0188396592,
-0.0519702397,
-0.0192426648,
-0.0382869318,
0.06281849,
0.0340534821,
-0.0066640601,
-0.0401527882,
3.110628508e-34,
0.034101326,
-0.0657078624,
-0.0023783424,
0.0941715017,
-0.007500594,
0.0400982052,
-0.0181215573,
0.0218458027,
0.0331469886,
-0.045505248,
-0.0279441029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00263v1 | From Local Concepts to Universals: Evaluating the Multicultural Understanding of Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-28T23:28:28 | 2024-06-28T23:28:28 | Mehar Bhatia, Sahithya Ravi, Aditya Chinchure, Eunjeong Hwang, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Despite recent advancements in vision-language models, their performance
remains suboptimal on images from non-western cultures due to
underrepresentation in training datasets. Various benchmarks have been proposed
to test models' cultural inclusivity, but they have limited coverage of
cultures and do not adequately assess cultural diversity across universal as
well as culture-specific local concepts. To address these limitations, we
introduce the GlobalRG benchmark, comprising two challenging tasks: retrieval
across universals and cultural visual grounding. The former task entails
retrieving culturally diverse images for universal concepts from 50 countries,
while the latter aims at grounding culture-specific concepts within images from
15 countries. Our evaluation across a wide range of models reveals that the
performance varies significantly across cultures -- underscoring the necessity
for enhancing multicultural understanding in vision-language models. | [
0.0061784931,
0.06095808,
-0.0201678965,
0.0582110956,
-0.0205500405,
0.0492488556,
0.043572031,
-0.0206050985,
0.0011690317,
-0.0231685173,
-0.0421308093,
-0.0853659511,
-0.001700121,
0.0196959917,
0.0206618123,
-0.0828857124,
0.0342540629,
0.0103931017,
-0.0409243517,
-0.0174704082,
-0.0128175924,
0.0096931942,
0.0375852138,
0.0524636693,
-0.0478113145,
0.0027839839,
0.0435104109,
0.0164258126,
0.0444083959,
-0.0110895745,
-0.0231902618,
0.0112922685,
0.0116827618,
0.0004486842,
0.0000019502,
-0.0173150431,
0.0151497796,
-0.0023917751,
0.0425045155,
0.0096507492,
0.0559978485,
-0.0227926429,
-0.0010952334,
-0.0263125803,
-0.032856103,
-0.0177163333,
0.0448631197,
0.0552010126,
-0.0108433878,
0.0185857154,
-0.0091614621,
-0.0310192574,
-0.0480626449,
-0.0371434838,
-0.0160593949,
-0.0320278816,
0.0346385576,
0.0614416115,
-0.0489648432,
-0.0265446529,
-0.0686396509,
0.0377897434,
0.0293807369,
0.0390447974,
-0.0028541635,
0.0273534916,
-0.0874403864,
-0.0303540006,
0.0218418445,
0.0459341928,
-0.0052074455,
0.0225882493,
-0.0157390535,
0.0136565911,
-0.0431228615,
-0.013945559,
-0.0315649323,
0.0564686619,
-0.0139153572,
0.0354583822,
-0.0606392287,
0.0369019024,
0.0188365187,
0.0071750344,
-0.0140746776,
0.031361565,
0.0268818717,
0.0145106399,
-0.0007713995,
0.0180512108,
-0.019493632,
0.0088695567,
0.0094161956,
-0.0194494016,
0.0313731655,
-0.0156158321,
-0.0103670964,
0.0320637003,
0.0201686658,
-0.0295313429,
0.0303239729,
0.0675976276,
-0.0745284036,
0.0663413331,
-0.0219275523,
0.0805598348,
-0.0233014766,
0.0178581234,
-0.0310643017,
-0.0595591515,
-0.0083682574,
0.0065458207,
0.0252751522,
-0.0469611064,
-0.0469947197,
-0.0060282522,
-0.0545948744,
-0.0156270247,
-0.0422349423,
-0.0121971965,
-0.0203650743,
0.0019751836,
-0.0433117338,
0.0023627689,
-0.0133560961,
0.0198610835,
-0.0090517383,
-0.0415020213,
-0.0435208902,
-0.091279529,
0.0405274853,
0.0043089278,
-0.0299832057,
-0.0230324697,
0.0049169795,
0.0415754355,
0.0040643774,
-0.0224732514,
-0.0487480797,
0.021971127,
-0.0102566071,
-0.0390649363,
0.0399173014,
-0.0647166818,
0.0254819971,
-0.0060147475,
0.0348489806,
-0.0336746722,
0.0008575653,
-0.0239753425,
-0.0221587401,
0.0225725174,
0.0346480049,
0.0156726409,
0.04028574,
0.0075207185,
0.0009698672,
0.1161075234,
-0.0312651843,
0.0217351373,
0.068827033,
-0.001983565,
-0.0362120979,
0.0218789782,
-0.0065970835,
0.0110373087,
-0.0630993843,
0.0043065832,
0.0343363248,
-0.016822312,
0.0440069139,
0.0240732059,
-0.0205021501,
-0.0553879105,
0.0218482185,
0.06878189,
-0.0171803981,
0.0223850347,
0.0484532155,
-0.0202685352,
-0.0192644745,
0.0099532595,
-0.0417641588,
0.0248612575,
0.0183510929,
0.0000469019,
-0.0247049909,
0.1031065732,
-0.0575057417,
0.006063682,
0.0000335724,
0.0181014352,
0.0394956879,
0.0204749741,
0.0571666397,
-0.0288287532,
0.0251025464,
0.0108738616,
0.0643338859,
-0.0398768969,
0.013432933,
-0.0215869565,
0.0183010325,
0.0085647963,
-0.0125897713,
0.0165372547,
0.0208276641,
0.0284470171,
0.0397379585,
0.0679505467,
0.0102547342,
0.0212369766,
0.0632675216,
-0.0441657491,
-0.0368322432,
0.0032987397,
0.0083075454,
0.0530571751,
0.0401194133,
0.0387212336,
0.0538377538,
-0.0290980656,
-0.0094164675,
0.0198996142,
-0.0156512875,
0.0463664606,
-0.003800859,
0.0022783272,
-0.0387698375,
0.0038781224,
-0.0595975332,
-0.0269775111,
-0.0151535515,
-0.0516358651,
0.0255546737,
0.0315671302,
-0.0659587905,
-0.0024632958,
0.0411477797,
-0.1115248352,
0.0019172837,
0.0166693702,
0.0025207982,
0.0086505301,
0.034671355,
0.0398782156,
-0.0273134336,
-0.0476642214,
-0.0215104483,
-0.0270537063,
0.0217724387,
-0.0117753064,
0.0469595343,
-0.0207149442,
0.0162115786,
-0.0453688912,
-0.025256684,
0.0510446243,
-0.0463987552,
-0.0389646403,
0.0234211758,
-0.0064474791,
-0.0007216053,
0.022185836,
0.0051218932,
-0.0237707403,
0.0253626946,
-0.1063527763,
-0.0105844764,
-0.0554095581,
-0.0595137887,
-0.0403139889,
0.0007358445,
-0.0200352501,
-0.0655473396,
-0.0292614214,
0.0113394316,
0.0206282362,
0.0459498018,
-0.0247450192,
-0.0151403164,
0.0056031123,
0.0072731874,
-0.0444390662,
0.0373916887,
0.076122649,
-0.0139272679,
-0.0391397364,
-0.0080567123,
-0.0236337911,
-0.0704995319,
0.0270148255,
-0.0527926646,
-0.0307468176,
0.0140449284,
0.0178145841,
0.0228255037,
0.0485804901,
0.0036185426,
-0.0270789731,
0.0420720354,
-0.0080713574,
-0.0105615063,
-0.0214691199,
0.0123106362,
-0.0010926024,
0.0164915603,
-0.060000889,
-0.0148040401,
0.0413940549,
-0.0058173151,
-0.0120088682,
-0.0596950315,
0.002583635,
-0.0701682568,
-0.0657170191,
-0.095380798,
0.0042897197,
0.0054537728,
0.067888096,
-0.0666697994,
-0.0593621396,
0.029207401,
-0.0070511396,
-0.0070927115,
0.0419786349,
-0.0051628184,
-0.0448410325,
0.0386908203,
-0.0013340238,
0.0405244268,
-0.0182599388,
0.0110602938,
-0.0260513071,
-0.0189123135,
0.0316230878,
-0.0332035571,
0.0867338851,
-0.0027675412,
-0.0263182577,
-0.0483936034,
-0.0288467407,
-0.0731171593,
0.050263837,
0.0162325259,
0.0187247247,
-0.0200792998,
0.0311106015,
-0.0299784951,
0.0229311101,
0.0427910425,
-0.0112340404,
-0.0035548601,
0.0370418914,
0.0416722447,
-0.0435216799,
0.0489741862,
-0.0099482564,
-0.0035502892,
-0.041676648,
-0.0114124548,
0.0191412345,
0.0367524363,
-0.0229178164,
0.0015010065,
0.0424326286,
0.0098527968,
0.0508699827,
-0.0276891533,
-0.0289641954,
0.0628382787,
-0.0033444706,
0.0119353812,
0.0342580937,
-0.0012215201,
-0.0553021245,
-0.0318389833,
-0.041918315,
-0.0061143264,
0.0537478477,
0.0181659088,
-0.0885549113,
0.0232769065,
-0.0163521897,
-0.02781111,
0.0211029351,
-0.0124398815,
-0.0029999837,
-0.0646775141,
0.0405126512,
0.0413070545,
-0.0723426715,
-0.084245272,
0.04406121,
-0.013473778,
-0.0218881667,
0.0300823916,
-0.0190903582,
0.0031467045,
-0.0130581371,
0.0029217317,
0.0006695926,
-0.0337125696,
0.012707076,
-0.0688412264,
-0.046450004,
0.0363088176,
-0.008326509,
0.0244710036,
-0.0876505002,
-0.0054689576,
-0.0344407596,
0.011382482,
-0.001438288,
0.0424618982,
-0.0079509327,
-0.0727885291,
0.0268492419,
-0.0359427631,
-0.0089625362,
-0.0091529256,
-0.018280359,
0.0021568078,
0.0255866013,
0.0112322718,
-0.0458954051,
0.0083481241,
0.0045846459,
0.0329215415,
0.0116813304,
-0.0128280455,
0.018413974,
-0.0277426764,
0.0066450811,
-0.0170602351,
-0.0620130301,
0.0470279939,
-0.032051675,
-0.0199539419,
-0.0160250645,
-0.0226266477,
0.0071117147,
0.0337473229,
0.001342551,
-0.0699173063,
-0.017475592,
0.0040042237,
-0.0646692216,
0.094349876,
-0.0424155667,
0.0085019991,
0.0136797735,
-0.0189734064,
0.0035758407,
-0.0389528945,
0.0077639599,
0.0101470174,
-0.0535361283,
-0.0158622861,
0.0384926386,
0.0561895967,
0.0083676334,
-0.0113254609,
0.0485426933,
-0.025335677,
0.0326448418,
0.003316947,
0.04128097,
0.0352551006,
-0.0045322417,
-0.0093140397,
-0.01284,
0.0367388502,
-0.0495242625,
0.0530222915,
0.0639529899,
0.0298618395,
-0.0017629177,
0.046461001,
-0.0026395801,
-0.0149467867,
0.0289749466,
-0.0304531641,
0.0092363795,
-0.0436067544,
-0.0296367202,
-0.0011118725,
-0.0140314074,
-0.0425305851,
-0.0476552472,
0.0381821804,
0.0090478398,
0.0253128279,
0.0161904842,
0.0048112115,
0.0124647198,
-0.0430943109,
-0.0193614643,
0.0284276884,
-0.0084748883,
-0.0126876412,
0.0555407405,
-0.0329818353,
0.0334825218,
-0.0287367385,
0.0279538613,
0.0065531465,
0.0693109035,
0.0160224698,
0.0094387988,
-0.0198708959,
-0.0082569066,
-0.0046364125,
-0.0516982377,
0.0307024587,
0.0308062602,
0.1105306819,
-0.0470423363,
0.0324330367,
0.0204401016,
-0.0287203137,
-0.0366983488,
0.0033099281,
0.0347356424,
-0.0388855785,
0.0383722372,
0.0113413613,
-0.0027958904,
-0.005328306,
0.0656894818,
-0.0256850235,
-0.0116104577,
0.0167926718,
-0.0144528169,
-0.0111132367,
-0.0114490455,
0.0729509741,
-0.0179870389,
0.0000071236,
0.0420575216,
-0.0599550791,
-0.0727692544,
-0.005711941,
0.0205126628,
-0.0000160074,
0.0385824032,
0.0411311649,
0.0763017237,
0.0210332442,
-0.0368910432,
-0.0318961442,
-0.0262067262,
-0.0451770686,
0.0048591401,
0.0290810913,
-6.100921843e-33,
-0.0368130319,
0.0171902385,
-0.0077374405,
-0.0151954126,
-0.0296809692,
0.0101776086,
-0.0051193824,
0.0198198594,
-0.0547503382,
0.0434973873,
0.0042192917,
0.0246345606,
0.0124282492,
0.0260304958,
-0.0136249475,
0.0169686079,
0.027989313,
0.0365859196,
-0.0016432917,
0.0002543211,
0.0322379842,
0.0372285992,
0.070203945,
-0.0623392053,
-0.029156005,
0.0331382081,
0.0223127697,
0.0042994698,
0.061538022,
0.0738052502,
-0.0661734417,
0.0699498579,
0.0270048603,
-0.0076829824,
-0.0120018264,
-0.0640581325,
-0.0719241127,
-0.0249462351,
0.003124004,
0.0503427945,
-0.0305199958,
-0.0025562071,
-0.0021904034,
-0.040082939,
-0.0051965788,
-0.0270224903,
0.0380212702,
-0.0279082209,
-0.0606036112,
0.0093909288,
-0.0237506684,
0.0401913263,
0.017361911,
0.0576028228,
0.0375053473,
0.0063144318,
0.0170788597,
0.0381920412,
-0.0163034052,
0.0091000386,
0.0082880175,
0.0205029771,
0.0678093061,
0.0491295271,
0.0440532304,
0.079535082,
0.0411867313,
0.006606699,
0.0100900596,
-0.0802157298,
0.0449730083,
-0.0067270119,
0.0070374403,
0.1284107715,
0.0381015167,
-0.0074556172,
-0.0449207872,
-0.0088306814,
-0.0134534845,
0.0357538685,
0.0230768435,
0.0139082726,
0.0027321831,
-0.0006195285,
-0.0158584658,
-0.0410596877,
-0.0308100302,
-0.0410720892,
0.0497373529,
0.0375026613,
-0.0160271842,
0.0429109409,
0.0526749045,
-0.055397138,
0.0149681959,
0.0247729514,
0.0282575656,
-0.0289905202,
0.0352122262,
-0.0083496692,
-0.0255043898,
-0.0368792489,
0.0006998807,
0.0301125739,
-0.0112056751,
-0.0091363322,
0.0141915437,
-0.0127341589,
-0.0517276898,
0.0135761006,
-0.0313110538,
-0.0140695898,
-0.0151040051,
0.0222653653,
0.0306938551,
-0.0054166559,
-0.0424264595,
0.0161078777,
0.0227973256,
-0.0360622071,
-0.0126181748,
-0.0677105337,
0.0072563807,
0.0593325496,
-0.0184278395,
-0.0026986373,
-0.052345071,
-0.0032048984,
0.0550491214,
-0.0053542284,
-0.0122265657,
0.0148236118,
2.505e-7,
0.0313879028,
-0.0257214643,
0.0112052048,
0.0198973976,
0.0076826699,
0.0076893102,
-0.0275630504,
0.0110624908,
0.0290359501,
-0.0372195207,
-0.0377277732,
0.0554721132,
0.0537566021,
0.0088401949,
-0.0305121299,
0.0304233786,
-0.0133170271,
0.0118072601,
-0.0315592438,
-0.0019843385,
-0.0283630826,
0.0846790895,
-0.0215018652,
-0.0029167791,
0.0185511317,
-0.0611070506,
0.0831754208,
-0.0762858093,
-0.0198497027,
-0.034892749,
-0.0093404725,
0.0159094371,
-0.0000842246,
0.0047366503,
0.0232446771,
0.0346325859,
0.0767483562,
0.0141431959,
-0.003226077,
0.0019486765,
-0.0215938687,
0.0446903184,
-0.0378687307,
-0.1094486192,
0.0481101871,
-0.0148945432,
-0.0124275517,
-0.0317024663,
-0.0266673211,
0.026626952,
0.0740974993,
-0.0040999241,
-0.0250871703,
-0.0017757862,
0.0232152175,
-0.007721174,
-0.0064244689,
-0.0556307919,
0.0274831261,
-0.0374353305,
-0.0101076979,
-0.0217687897,
-0.0031424968,
-0.0088370992,
-0.026178699,
0.0376807638,
-0.0111588109,
1.85338151e-34,
0.02688477,
0.013989416,
0.0177645292,
-0.0096413838,
0.0183253996,
-0.055216413,
-0.0400109477,
-0.0118910857,
-0.0440225191,
0.000157368,
0.0194634739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00256v1 | One Prompt is not Enough: Automated Construction of a Mixture-of-Expert Prompts | 2024-06-28T23:05:08 | 2024-06-28T23:05:08 | Ruochen Wang, Sohyun An, Minhao Cheng, Tianyi Zhou, Sung Ju Hwang, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML, 68T01 | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit strong generalization capabilities to
novel tasks when prompted with language instructions and in-context demos.
Since this ability sensitively depends on the quality of prompts, various
methods have been explored to automate the instruction design. While these
methods demonstrated promising results, they also restricted the searched
prompt to one instruction. Such simplification significantly limits their
capacity, as a single demo-free instruction might not be able to cover the
entire complex problem space of the targeted task. To alleviate this issue, we
adopt the Mixture-of-Expert paradigm and divide the problem space into a set of
sub-regions; Each sub-region is governed by a specialized expert, equipped with
both an instruction and a set of demos. A two-phase process is developed to
construct the specialized expert for each region: (1) demo assignment: Inspired
by the theoretical connection between in-context learning and kernel
regression, we group demos into experts based on their semantic similarity; (2)
instruction assignment: A region-based joint search of an instruction per
expert complements the demos assigned to it, yielding a synergistic effect. The
resulting method, codenamed Mixture-of-Prompts (MoP), achieves an average win
rate of 81% against prior arts across several major benchmarks. | [
0.0715809613,
0.0584036261,
-0.0270418115,
0.0217153784,
-0.0499052741,
-0.0001962302,
0.0370651409,
-0.021886019,
-0.0118464418,
-0.0482774749,
-0.0374045558,
-0.031732861,
-0.0170542523,
0.0257279482,
0.0393933095,
-0.0587085783,
0.0029415449,
-0.0604895689,
0.0159395393,
-0.0073472587,
-0.0259242114,
0.0112320101,
-0.0300480872,
0.0600035898,
-0.0198115017,
0.0120805409,
-0.0276121423,
0.0045411484,
0.0012642725,
-0.0073199105,
0.0179332849,
0.0730120465,
0.0452159978,
0.0157092214,
0.0000022127,
-0.0433522128,
-0.0113865649,
-0.0151522132,
-0.0240223166,
-0.012968923,
0.0338495895,
0.0084543303,
0.0091836806,
0.0066038682,
-0.0198950935,
-0.0217830539,
0.0452280231,
0.0294091851,
0.0776427761,
0.0923119113,
0.0065735392,
0.0026345795,
0.0237280093,
-0.0137907537,
0.0329550803,
-0.0195936169,
0.0289543439,
0.0094358968,
0.0478331521,
-0.0046469145,
-0.0219058096,
0.0498816334,
0.0092948414,
-0.0084931627,
0.026150059,
0.0113616288,
0.0051189484,
-0.0101711564,
-0.0361220874,
0.0791259557,
-0.0476805642,
0.0074914964,
0.0014516527,
-0.008072909,
0.0181223918,
0.0189497955,
-0.0486523584,
0.0329432897,
-0.0061491788,
-0.0102872849,
-0.0017560555,
0.0085368175,
0.0047871564,
0.0089805061,
-0.036425788,
0.0554260463,
0.019299278,
-0.0406992622,
0.03180217,
0.002522408,
-0.053405717,
-0.0568461828,
-0.012508437,
0.043938227,
-0.0878855735,
0.0226951241,
-0.0532735661,
-0.0389154889,
-0.0110356426,
0.033706896,
0.0501697622,
0.0574374348,
-0.040341761,
0.0602246337,
-0.0156254638,
0.0541050956,
0.00036414,
0.0321930498,
-0.074979946,
0.0077993474,
-0.0641140789,
0.0099611925,
-0.0602367669,
0.0173759498,
-0.0159854367,
-0.0122109968,
-0.0197398942,
0.0362115875,
-0.0473769158,
0.0401692055,
0.0125877494,
0.00790089,
-0.0270636268,
-0.0091331936,
-0.0148788411,
-0.00211677,
-0.0362313949,
0.017655341,
0.0006846643,
-0.0290374495,
0.0067280536,
0.0280605424,
0.0009419401,
-0.0126414932,
0.0215430688,
0.0696542189,
-0.0454973541,
-0.0461235195,
-0.0014135591,
0.0013350651,
-0.0115335947,
-0.0583993942,
-0.0139013054,
-0.0679448023,
0.0440765209,
-0.0021648712,
0.0008977578,
-0.0573692694,
-0.0025692168,
0.0021255319,
-0.0137221804,
0.0660116449,
0.0173565242,
0.0513498262,
0.0769060627,
-0.0017396125,
-0.0860316828,
0.0675653741,
-0.0115748923,
0.0474154837,
0.0051765288,
0.0256273299,
0.0278821178,
0.0546747223,
-0.0070929113,
0.0220676977,
-0.0182501804,
0.0113949999,
0.0344450586,
0.043642655,
0.0144288484,
0.0459082238,
-0.0136888837,
-0.0097137392,
0.0346428491,
0.0367814302,
-0.0252395608,
0.0047684633,
0.0929222032,
0.0468894504,
0.0298180208,
0.0057567339,
-0.0527738445,
-0.0086564468,
-0.0367283858,
-0.0136565566,
0.0214136653,
0.0274866894,
-0.0387853272,
-0.0227309205,
0.0193020534,
-0.0066752569,
-0.0379117019,
0.0549468175,
0.0633838177,
0.001128128,
-0.0496620014,
-0.019558847,
0.0095413169,
0.0236320961,
0.0220332276,
-0.0593787581,
0.0128884511,
0.060780596,
0.0371177942,
-0.0481219292,
-0.0193109438,
-0.0153870648,
0.0171896778,
-0.0026079812,
0.0295193698,
-0.0473408997,
-0.0140444143,
-0.0421025269,
-0.0533869676,
-0.0396251418,
0.0185619481,
0.0394704007,
0.0275821723,
0.0010336727,
0.011653577,
-0.0405196995,
0.0099529196,
0.0362450965,
-0.0170739908,
-0.0272010956,
0.0173778292,
0.020692829,
0.0183347147,
-0.0082925893,
-0.0277169906,
0.008967747,
-0.0034950334,
-0.0462122262,
-0.0078428145,
-0.0230119713,
-0.0471874326,
-0.0557647832,
0.0358905382,
-0.0143768657,
-0.0402689166,
-0.0075123054,
-0.0452010855,
-0.0327523984,
-0.0057932851,
-0.0336054377,
0.0363899991,
-0.0181159005,
0.0322614722,
0.0042200065,
-0.0430983938,
-0.0535441525,
0.0666746497,
-0.0069522113,
-0.0003536457,
0.060060259,
0.0193684641,
0.0127934348,
-0.0694490746,
-0.0336814895,
-0.0407881923,
-0.0116344979,
0.0393144153,
0.0067487503,
0.0165484287,
-0.0392868556,
-0.0505811609,
-0.0933248475,
-0.001225117,
-0.0337545238,
-0.0375109576,
0.0081552621,
-0.0144426432,
-0.022692116,
-0.0294553563,
-0.0488589145,
-0.0188496392,
0.003129869,
0.0202339534,
-0.0018581167,
0.0406229049,
-0.0317883566,
-0.0335838124,
-0.0278816037,
0.002732811,
0.0422908105,
-0.0038131478,
0.012783247,
-0.0600693524,
0.0215498488,
-0.0237409901,
0.0320998169,
-0.0175202452,
0.0099973232,
-0.0034712479,
-0.0499587655,
0.0392020196,
0.0564453602,
0.0000133374,
0.0312661976,
0.0669900775,
-0.0070402971,
-0.0450924672,
0.0307259839,
-0.0085776122,
-0.0379027613,
-0.000639123,
-0.0329433903,
0.0238328222,
0.0553161651,
0.0396555066,
-0.0178474355,
-0.0708870366,
-0.0126020992,
-0.0065475018,
-0.032727249,
-0.0785709843,
-0.0304472763,
0.0209381934,
0.0501192138,
-0.0307703279,
-0.0712556019,
0.109303847,
-0.0067739976,
-0.0053970097,
-0.0253945012,
-0.0534341857,
-0.0218318142,
0.0351499841,
-0.0058764415,
0.0356739014,
-0.0031194834,
-0.0244208034,
-0.0811268687,
-0.0109175192,
-0.0010577827,
-0.0315174498,
0.062906377,
-0.0583400689,
0.011907124,
0.0262265746,
-0.0347791053,
-0.0624318272,
-0.0529160947,
-0.0046488619,
0.0206516813,
0.0052482919,
-0.0117075332,
-0.0606983006,
0.0229099337,
0.0208282806,
0.0489106216,
-0.0054083164,
-0.0001570874,
-0.0145718912,
0.0258339811,
0.0584167354,
-0.0016038173,
-0.0749060437,
-0.0564650819,
0.0194451492,
-0.0138030434,
0.0586314835,
-0.0251010731,
-0.0386311077,
0.0226688683,
0.0232715234,
-0.0318215638,
-0.0073619788,
0.0392300896,
0.0397008695,
-0.0258830972,
0.0114890579,
0.1046152189,
0.0221088957,
-0.0538479276,
-0.0198477879,
0.0352709144,
0.0046555703,
0.0258216001,
0.0600256361,
-0.0431177355,
-0.004833743,
-0.0092403246,
0.0119061377,
0.026929725,
-0.0142809991,
-0.0219680723,
-0.1193661466,
0.0481494069,
0.0151278144,
-0.080908142,
-0.0297803357,
-0.0309889335,
0.0048661828,
-0.0072160047,
-0.0140679386,
-0.0004533959,
-0.0106937522,
0.0016728599,
0.0239833277,
0.022187816,
-0.0708166584,
0.0260867923,
-0.0222717132,
0.0506623574,
0.0548951887,
-0.0133272884,
-0.0003184181,
-0.0128783444,
-0.0262229964,
0.0175053533,
0.0190534536,
-0.0089864293,
0.0333272181,
-0.0316571742,
-0.009003696,
0.0269068275,
0.0302283857,
-0.0172105562,
-0.0056483317,
0.0187336337,
0.1048764065,
-0.0182422865,
-0.0075017316,
-0.0321654864,
-0.0221129153,
0.0664386079,
0.0701385513,
0.0181290936,
-0.0542348027,
0.0227881521,
-0.0270872377,
-0.0097509976,
0.0025684156,
0.0127522824,
0.0227801092,
-0.0153340371,
-0.007800756,
-0.0454724506,
0.0073108291,
0.0673818886,
0.0718764812,
0.0420454368,
-0.0015872441,
-0.0359003022,
0.0187385827,
-0.0520550683,
0.0477955267,
-0.0355245434,
0.0228452459,
-0.0808566883,
-0.0777478367,
0.0291001182,
-0.0625441,
-0.0270361099,
-0.01270587,
-0.0566006899,
-0.0646111891,
-0.031117361,
0.072586596,
0.0201730374,
0.0265523884,
-0.0092802234,
-0.0595997721,
0.1055800989,
0.0008104741,
-0.0134198973,
-0.0069184871,
0.0057899626,
-0.0131244408,
-0.0155439051,
0.0178914424,
-0.0551493429,
0.0307726264,
0.052581314,
0.0195592027,
-0.0017164116,
-0.0356820449,
0.034540005,
-0.0078254454,
0.0191888735,
-0.0288908537,
0.0099524297,
-0.0563996769,
-0.0030066909,
0.0350334831,
-0.0415284038,
-0.0530168824,
0.0013170179,
0.04691872,
-0.0040430594,
0.0390979126,
-0.011789686,
-0.0065456475,
0.0283952337,
-0.016419027,
-0.0083903708,
0.0329864919,
0.0190452039,
0.0628230572,
0.0246809702,
-0.0122097628,
0.0064534578,
-0.0036235231,
0.0132520869,
-0.0082546771,
0.0632816255,
0.0200131554,
-0.0027696365,
-0.0317636989,
0.0148239788,
-0.048285298,
-0.0866507217,
-0.0312717035,
0.0457345396,
0.0757198706,
-0.0179043245,
-0.0140922964,
-0.0312742777,
-0.0001564531,
-0.0306317322,
0.0061032772,
0.0203590468,
-0.0481640734,
0.0254891552,
0.0499992333,
0.0261064954,
0.0361517109,
0.0530472398,
-0.0108819418,
0.0519395955,
-0.0178342815,
-0.0052672266,
-0.0496889167,
0.0088871028,
0.057137236,
0.0215306859,
-0.0453437008,
0.0176010989,
-0.0266302582,
-0.0591421202,
-0.0277883168,
-0.009193683,
-0.0299083609,
0.0170362424,
0.0773879662,
0.0746808127,
-0.018556606,
0.0101117194,
-0.0364840291,
-0.0078965258,
0.0218947437,
-0.047209993,
-0.0301138032,
-6.282415599e-33,
0.0040680743,
-0.0327479541,
0.0250812341,
-0.0533372574,
0.0384028479,
-0.0006114865,
-0.0298191085,
0.0073799039,
0.0029638202,
0.0010136988,
-0.0295475218,
-0.0335730053,
0.0090438304,
0.014734135,
0.026350107,
0.0278978497,
0.0761870071,
-0.006663606,
-0.0192875285,
0.0232961234,
-0.0198205002,
0.0204617102,
0.0053238501,
-0.0541134737,
0.0191198587,
0.0039672926,
-0.0168515313,
0.0329572596,
0.0064102788,
0.0616895482,
-0.0102445688,
0.0628942624,
0.0140289422,
-0.0194181725,
-0.0220252015,
-0.0088034701,
-0.0300861001,
-0.0451364145,
-0.0205779485,
-0.0212320015,
-0.026641665,
-0.0038507921,
0.0039360989,
-0.0436931178,
-0.0050986498,
0.0150871212,
0.0643213764,
-0.0035022225,
-0.0215081535,
0.0011889497,
-0.03727635,
0.0056095663,
-0.0139145246,
-0.0479068533,
0.0302823298,
0.0249909498,
0.0259491391,
-0.0304212589,
0.0086423093,
0.0625815913,
0.0509481467,
0.0257203616,
0.0684481338,
0.0284636803,
-0.0154045643,
0.0372777842,
0.0026773461,
0.0168845672,
0.0229088254,
-0.0423839912,
0.0212431382,
0.0525639653,
-0.0020154098,
0.0129067712,
0.0371549688,
0.0096709058,
-0.0160972048,
0.0531620048,
0.0330723114,
0.013013741,
0.0297173448,
0.0189824235,
-0.0457675345,
-0.0188926924,
-0.0507371128,
0.0043464284,
-0.0379820578,
-0.050978709,
0.0443927087,
0.045932021,
-0.0056415158,
-0.027940141,
0.0313626267,
-0.0313757695,
0.0032149397,
-0.0071725817,
-0.014271508,
0.0335542411,
-0.0035152356,
0.0204517338,
-0.0484053418,
-0.084948957,
0.0445495136,
-0.037478447,
-0.0020981929,
0.0168460347,
0.0119560203,
0.0578089207,
-0.0554807857,
0.0228295363,
-0.0308839921,
-0.0073622577,
0.0104323858,
0.0201537032,
0.0243591778,
0.0156644285,
-0.0112032695,
0.0371915996,
-0.0039902376,
-0.0442862809,
-0.0054588723,
-0.0236574803,
-0.0183936022,
-0.0009200397,
-0.0297664925,
0.0219234936,
-0.0347143486,
-0.0245249029,
0.0168176945,
-0.0135973562,
0.0009085601,
-0.0229314249,
2.951e-7,
-0.0085441936,
0.0343765579,
-0.0221235752,
0.0293650907,
-0.0130388653,
0.0011569144,
-0.03993126,
0.0037952461,
0.0056032166,
-0.0408181772,
0.0507680289,
0.0440638773,
0.031939473,
0.0214065779,
-0.1110629216,
-0.0101615256,
-0.0071142069,
0.0258056428,
-0.0961182863,
0.0177216362,
0.0785042122,
0.109017089,
0.0331554413,
-0.0197390877,
-0.007682364,
-0.0340845548,
0.0478576943,
-0.0247992985,
0.0155451111,
0.0410419442,
0.0505469665,
0.0253612641,
-0.005833481,
0.0554460734,
0.0093874289,
0.0333383642,
0.0284375641,
0.0655350983,
0.0009581706,
0.0083900029,
0.0115214782,
0.0226323735,
-0.0128541971,
-0.0539329946,
0.0425806381,
-0.0496079139,
0.0013515214,
-0.0235978756,
0.0219057798,
-0.0350472592,
0.0095518017,
-0.0591246486,
-0.0184120107,
0.0151670985,
0.0200608447,
0.0012030232,
0.0029569184,
-0.0823680684,
0.0132772187,
0.0253162123,
-0.0459109768,
-0.0287628565,
-0.0272341333,
0.0058180951,
0.0266005006,
-0.0580311604,
0.0069711674,
2.883913759e-34,
0.0240813978,
-0.0094236461,
0.0197480656,
0.0241483636,
0.0334173888,
-0.0033291229,
-0.0533159077,
0.037192069,
0.0311865658,
-0.0740058944,
-0.0428157523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00250v1 | Mind the Gap: Analyzing Lacunae with Transformer-Based Transcription | 2024-06-28T22:52:39 | 2024-06-28T22:52:39 | Jaydeep Borkar, David A. Smith | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Historical documents frequently suffer from damage and inconsistencies,
including missing or illegible text resulting from issues such as holes, ink
problems, and storage damage. These missing portions or gaps are referred to as
lacunae. In this study, we employ transformer-based optical character
recognition (OCR) models trained on synthetic data containing lacunae in a
supervised manner. We demonstrate their effectiveness in detecting and
restoring lacunae, achieving a success rate of 65%, compared to a base model
lacking knowledge of lacunae, which achieves only 5% restoration. Additionally,
we investigate the mechanistic properties of the model, such as the log
probability of transcription, which can identify lacunae and other errors
(e.g., mistranscriptions due to complex writing or ink issues) in line images
without directly inspecting the image. This capability could be valuable for
scholars seeking to distinguish images containing lacunae or errors from clean
ones. Although we explore the potential of attention mechanisms in flagging
lacunae and transcription errors, our findings suggest it is not a significant
factor. Our work highlights a promising direction in utilizing
transformer-based OCR models for restoring or analyzing damaged historical
documents. | [
0.0087757343,
0.0928519666,
0.0097427759,
0.063898094,
-0.0524943024,
0.0233369432,
0.0006279712,
0.0607841238,
0.0024153942,
-0.0077742548,
0.0453909561,
-0.0192519147,
0.0736397728,
-0.0440753959,
-0.0200120285,
-0.0090864617,
0.0099550141,
-0.039470911,
-0.032806199,
0.0054253717,
-0.010732444,
-0.013347636,
0.0125310924,
0.0074351677,
-0.0151765272,
0.0003783117,
-0.026242964,
0.0403650738,
0.0281089414,
0.0450750552,
-0.0466382988,
0.0368870124,
-0.0255660955,
0.0686105043,
0.0000020598,
-0.0388730429,
-0.0597625189,
0.0243453104,
-0.0027119673,
-0.008284525,
0.0174680799,
-0.0649459437,
-0.0723175704,
-0.0333467945,
0.027590232,
-0.0085872896,
0.0656070486,
0.0841474086,
-0.0134758251,
0.0481829569,
-0.0298642851,
-0.0278953575,
0.0589986145,
0.0123287328,
0.0252810325,
0.0328332037,
0.0207680482,
0.0041809655,
-0.0307988878,
-0.0146308225,
-0.0040335134,
0.0558311865,
-0.0066005001,
-0.0870402306,
-0.047611881,
-0.0010158839,
-0.0008103961,
0.0182350352,
-0.0252276957,
0.0116309347,
-0.0511605106,
-0.0089637712,
0.0025357187,
-0.0169509668,
-0.0086470349,
0.0315148681,
0.0029372491,
0.0424291864,
-0.0499527678,
0.0100389561,
-0.031257432,
-0.0259006713,
-0.0037789459,
-0.0336621217,
-0.0093550868,
-0.0124771781,
-0.0035571556,
-0.073598735,
-0.0040695481,
0.0123215057,
-0.029717382,
0.0131866997,
0.0409658924,
0.0273201875,
0.0749909133,
-0.006082966,
-0.0570553392,
-0.0874736682,
0.0171745513,
0.0186623726,
0.0551155284,
0.0280737132,
-0.0732260123,
0.0423206948,
-0.0459363908,
0.0712350309,
-0.0013484824,
0.0245178472,
0.0024141786,
0.012827876,
-0.0106151728,
-0.0243513901,
-0.017070774,
-0.0544875674,
-0.00844019,
-0.0090387613,
0.0237944052,
-0.0528437532,
0.0341711938,
0.0010596019,
0.0262791496,
-0.0332489572,
-0.0253825262,
-0.0356074534,
0.0002334888,
0.0125947325,
0.0906843469,
0.01496277,
-0.0523564927,
-0.0635230094,
-0.0107759349,
0.052602578,
0.0411392972,
0.0042257453,
0.009579869,
0.0517140664,
-0.0498230048,
-0.0368677974,
-0.0335076414,
0.0241034757,
-0.0543271191,
-0.0337159522,
0.0173270255,
-0.019047508,
-0.011968716,
-0.013624683,
0.0235645249,
-0.0062354868,
0.0248919874,
0.0088931853,
-0.0543354377,
0.0809093118,
-0.0252994671,
-0.0146715734,
0.0578784235,
-0.0070586996,
-0.0138049498,
-0.0389941782,
0.0363667943,
0.0101988856,
0.0215940289,
0.0015647854,
0.033553496,
0.0457547344,
-0.035490036,
-0.0251611713,
-0.0014984395,
-0.062047407,
0.0214619935,
0.0005511838,
0.054113254,
0.0592750981,
-0.0252245236,
-0.0265394785,
0.0672492012,
0.0530671738,
0.0375727862,
0.0295472443,
-0.0212808978,
0.0107485596,
0.0351880416,
0.0210912749,
-0.0172658563,
-0.0096088946,
0.0461769365,
0.0222661588,
-0.0146799618,
-0.0018365846,
0.0260487366,
-0.0060813208,
-0.0194550455,
-0.0220391694,
0.0137073165,
-0.0655698031,
0.0831399485,
0.0389462747,
-0.1028100476,
0.0253009647,
-0.0233448967,
-0.051120922,
-0.0329207443,
-0.031065356,
0.0301948581,
0.0778470486,
0.1141073778,
-0.0472627506,
0.0223786812,
0.007380778,
-0.0484735779,
0.016067896,
-0.0121766441,
0.0204645116,
0.0233373027,
-0.0727626979,
-0.003170301,
0.0562208854,
0.0044461172,
0.018026622,
-0.014610243,
0.0295741633,
-0.0109367268,
-0.0167259574,
-0.0493659936,
0.0294368956,
0.0183909535,
-0.027136514,
-0.0361362658,
0.016307611,
-0.0042829295,
0.0112738283,
-0.0412702747,
-0.0052063544,
0.0507840961,
-0.0260891728,
-0.0080109602,
0.0231831651,
-0.0010562324,
0.0410417281,
0.0439418778,
-0.0505279489,
-0.0295887813,
0.0139971506,
0.0228143092,
-0.0026801298,
-0.0448872857,
-0.0641440451,
-0.0076080519,
-0.0726588443,
0.0532113761,
-0.0115174102,
-0.0121049238,
-0.0296902154,
0.0355291814,
-0.011446327,
0.006448051,
0.0159668159,
-0.0348364152,
0.0051405858,
-0.0539435111,
-0.0066492413,
-0.0323306359,
-0.0117677525,
0.0163975433,
0.0025462816,
0.0317253582,
-0.0066180183,
-0.0816198438,
-0.0332629792,
-0.0510268584,
-0.0348759815,
-0.0002018757,
-0.0147002032,
-0.0020492647,
0.0084280511,
-0.0201268084,
0.0502691567,
-0.0146040982,
0.00598425,
-0.0541872717,
0.0609897003,
-0.0247823596,
0.0008209861,
-0.0226314664,
-0.001553187,
0.0252539497,
0.0117322644,
0.0354184173,
-0.0695763901,
-0.0848723054,
0.0600400232,
0.065614298,
0.0238809288,
-0.0184265785,
-0.0265928451,
-0.0132525181,
-0.0392624438,
0.0201573055,
0.0804291144,
0.0030041614,
-0.0273979567,
-0.018087035,
-0.0263243951,
0.013668309,
-0.0041691796,
0.0052262382,
0.0221355073,
-0.0057597868,
-0.0252347831,
0.0238762237,
-0.0248241909,
-0.0243776813,
0.0622331165,
-0.0299750548,
-0.0526997931,
-0.0101923076,
0.0127708409,
0.0342615098,
-0.0314750411,
-0.0265795924,
0.0348376036,
-0.0094234142,
0.0071918266,
0.0091078803,
-0.0272563007,
-0.0062052142,
0.0018620598,
0.033516258,
-0.0210064556,
0.0241859108,
0.0185776334,
0.0129793128,
0.0475401133,
-0.0837601796,
-0.0210599843,
0.0375015587,
0.0298422836,
-0.0389714316,
0.0289953984,
-0.0119000645,
0.0420712158,
-0.0046168501,
-0.0309093837,
0.0083743874,
-0.0413146913,
0.015961431,
-0.0425056182,
-0.0110712415,
-0.0176605862,
-0.0761525556,
0.0449758582,
0.003354325,
0.0777327195,
0.0195519179,
0.012023855,
-0.0340310298,
0.0944777504,
-0.0258199926,
-0.0307310522,
0.0354914926,
-0.0747523606,
-0.0416385196,
0.0137381088,
-0.0287794266,
0.0070703859,
0.0020971836,
-0.0003387828,
0.0182364266,
0.018329449,
0.0101528801,
-0.0464706309,
0.0281226691,
-0.0432053395,
-0.0174227506,
0.0610546619,
-0.0116999159,
-0.0385244265,
-0.0505547561,
-0.0278145261,
-0.0609968714,
-0.0503328405,
-0.0233854167,
-0.0536768027,
0.0022771878,
0.037975803,
0.0451379716,
0.004808838,
0.0028685469,
0.0377850197,
-0.0470447838,
0.0323797204,
0.0279221218,
0.00452339,
-0.0671382025,
-0.0131337754,
0.0087168328,
-0.045667313,
-0.0110695632,
0.0260149352,
0.0025997963,
-0.0299362019,
-0.010289453,
0.0180174336,
-0.0150754163,
-0.0590998977,
-0.000302938,
-0.0166852679,
0.0471075177,
0.0236064382,
-0.0172880366,
-0.046094805,
0.0284464099,
0.0385020338,
0.0310145561,
-0.0045875446,
0.1082443148,
0.0610652454,
-0.0050373422,
0.0087377736,
0.0293042157,
0.0158895645,
-0.0348096229,
-0.0387962237,
-0.0413504727,
0.0047613462,
0.0264747888,
0.0316830464,
-0.0393631533,
-0.0040168432,
-0.0118761295,
0.0192799512,
-0.0151538411,
-0.0726475865,
-0.048466716,
0.0949873999,
-0.0531656779,
-0.0143873449,
0.0214973148,
0.0043652216,
-0.0900116116,
-0.0095847007,
-0.0182612631,
-0.037270423,
0.0349263437,
0.0441921726,
-0.0605588071,
0.0246297829,
0.0191161186,
-0.080483824,
-0.0034385675,
-0.0345350839,
-0.0093431119,
-0.0673754886,
0.0639389083,
-0.0535702258,
-0.0313296504,
-0.0116620436,
-0.0226302557,
-0.0868104398,
-0.0337643884,
0.0837462768,
0.0528344251,
0.0197190586,
-0.0429512337,
-0.0072089704,
-0.0452507921,
0.0028681033,
0.0423724689,
-0.0085383216,
-0.0150343394,
-0.0111683132,
-0.0552686676,
-0.0461333804,
0.0197514854,
-0.009894087,
-0.0002868201,
0.0094644343,
-0.04480654,
-0.0389072187,
-0.0519639663,
-0.0016026148,
-0.0497698337,
0.0596082546,
-0.0221377574,
0.0349071473,
-0.0079687545,
0.0186395571,
0.0138032306,
0.0087778764,
0.013321057,
-0.0155182872,
-0.0041754865,
-0.0100465855,
0.0007888455,
-0.0228594262,
-0.0307596587,
0.0152266677,
-0.0566759557,
0.0084485523,
0.0621507242,
0.0117563969,
0.031086646,
-0.0028516925,
0.0469559133,
0.04473456,
0.0139791258,
0.0494533777,
0.0427963249,
0.0260324664,
-0.01360696,
0.0272769462,
-0.0097573064,
-0.0168388877,
-0.0441787913,
0.0118888682,
-0.0415335223,
0.0070321192,
0.0850408673,
-0.0494825579,
0.0562265553,
-0.0345756374,
-0.0106649362,
-0.0378433093,
-0.0108457347,
0.0342287496,
0.0212826636,
-0.0626993179,
0.0180316977,
0.0266110338,
0.0254714973,
0.0117095886,
-0.0341872945,
0.0035172147,
-0.0128154159,
-0.0224338658,
-0.0365700796,
0.0058943415,
0.0097105876,
-0.0625258163,
-0.0105432048,
-0.0105481762,
-0.0015964063,
0.0154796466,
0.0692180991,
0.0167631488,
0.0214925352,
0.0215253048,
-0.0221024621,
0.0003262029,
-0.0300536957,
0.0040541668,
-0.018309921,
0.0279834718,
0.0167863145,
-0.0498917103,
-0.0359249935,
-5.31634622e-33,
0.0277407449,
-0.0673735663,
-0.0200434942,
0.0510212332,
-0.0156014916,
0.0224945415,
-0.0415440351,
-0.005138238,
0.0087350383,
0.011299625,
-0.0089424355,
0.0027995263,
0.0382171646,
0.0171301756,
0.0045340885,
0.0250359029,
0.0564686209,
0.032371711,
-0.0232110396,
-0.0317440778,
0.0205189884,
0.0396273322,
0.0474263132,
-0.0598477684,
0.0295970365,
-0.0253342111,
-0.0185869522,
-0.0285680909,
0.0356527716,
0.0301521495,
0.0271631274,
-0.0295636058,
0.0116884718,
-0.020089142,
-0.0018954207,
0.0357263461,
-0.0827250928,
0.0608373024,
-0.0611658394,
0.0930921063,
0.0389993675,
-0.0191513095,
0.0076009389,
-0.0195497833,
-0.01706779,
-0.0375761986,
0.0343874097,
-0.0126106143,
0.0112594236,
-0.0091956649,
-0.0232803542,
0.0291493386,
-0.0080133891,
-0.0170575902,
0.083487533,
-0.0023837683,
0.0190860685,
0.0016668302,
-0.0694223046,
0.0151307508,
0.0318299271,
0.0259078592,
-0.0186320245,
-0.0189861543,
-0.0471884757,
-0.0005402928,
0.0034958206,
0.0070697144,
-0.0037085412,
-0.0118488716,
-0.0002719651,
-0.0302321129,
0.0590660274,
0.0307692438,
0.0726493225,
0.004652251,
-0.0083377864,
-0.0056718066,
-0.069104284,
0.0632860214,
0.0364734791,
0.036226064,
0.007838537,
0.0216750819,
-0.0085585248,
-0.0441305377,
-0.0104867872,
0.04302302,
-0.0163571592,
0.0242562685,
-0.004225445,
-0.0073446785,
0.0333757699,
-0.0288309269,
0.0225183442,
-0.0609553233,
0.0030793482,
0.0706789047,
-0.0430033579,
-0.0284977052,
-0.021436017,
-0.0088370554,
0.0627379939,
0.0702885613,
-0.006800299,
0.0026059798,
0.0364354998,
0.0264672488,
-0.0666207895,
0.0159481876,
0.0548661351,
-0.0073782043,
0.0648396835,
0.0655707493,
0.0244942214,
-0.00597528,
0.0465604849,
0.0225409456,
0.0185778271,
0.0216060448,
0.0091364672,
-0.015759347,
0.0061687874,
-0.0315808877,
-0.027555516,
0.0144813387,
0.0125068026,
0.0253204666,
-0.0418148004,
-0.0229344238,
0.0015761986,
0.0247863457,
2.499e-7,
0.0705567077,
0.0627592206,
0.0730663463,
-0.0087652644,
0.0240560044,
0.0026554563,
-0.020509474,
-0.0209413841,
-0.0219974648,
-0.0077979141,
0.0547930971,
-0.0267046094,
0.1174556836,
-0.0235591512,
-0.0456968546,
-0.0184369106,
-0.0151984738,
-0.0193619523,
-0.0275895502,
0.0276435055,
0.0157657489,
0.00457909,
-0.0506607927,
-0.0492840894,
0.00787808,
-0.0147705488,
0.0229459032,
0.0044406629,
0.0201237593,
-0.0193897411,
0.0499874391,
0.0015802617,
0.0032925468,
0.0393201075,
-0.000701152,
-0.0016091918,
0.0322881006,
0.0161654484,
-0.0036907438,
0.0136506986,
0.0041869218,
0.0566205382,
0.0017524944,
-0.0499978773,
0.0115378555,
0.0722788945,
0.0328537934,
-0.0243612174,
-0.0436445661,
0.034155935,
0.0259254947,
-0.0261025745,
-0.0006189967,
0.0134001449,
0.0369927734,
0.024609264,
-0.0110093476,
-0.0167155471,
0.0018241239,
-0.0416832194,
0.0028628074,
0.0189238489,
-0.0092226667,
-0.0351948813,
0.0156230126,
-0.0562639311,
-0.0230656788,
2.492469549e-34,
0.0221572649,
-0.0421409421,
-0.0151283471,
0.0188626666,
-0.0174989253,
-0.0132062472,
0.0114432685,
-0.006711008,
-0.0484330207,
-0.0421926491,
0.0044248598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00248v1 | DiffuseDef: Improved Robustness to Adversarial Attacks | 2024-06-28T22:36:17 | 2024-06-28T22:36:17 | Zhenhao Li, Marek Rei, Lucia Specia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models have significantly advanced performance across
various natural language processing tasks. However, adversarial attacks
continue to pose a critical challenge to system built using these models, as
they can be exploited with carefully crafted adversarial texts. Inspired by the
ability of diffusion models to predict and reduce noise in computer vision, we
propose a novel and flexible adversarial defense method for language
classification tasks, DiffuseDef, which incorporates a diffusion layer as a
denoiser between the encoder and the classifier. During inference, the
adversarial hidden state is first combined with sampled noise, then denoised
iteratively and finally ensembled to produce a robust text representation. By
integrating adversarial training, denoising, and ensembling techniques, we show
that DiffuseDef improves over different existing adversarial defense methods
and achieves state-of-the-art performance against common adversarial attacks. | [
0.0191238858,
0.0552414432,
-0.0199430361,
0.0433575623,
0.009390885,
0.0093280245,
-0.0085197045,
0.0177591611,
0.0122051528,
-0.0646543875,
-0.0176643673,
-0.0151655339,
0.0243791975,
-0.0149863306,
0.0439343825,
-0.0350897349,
0.0371693149,
-0.0119584883,
-0.0032348698,
-0.0240459535,
0.0287849829,
0.0003479649,
0.0107304361,
0.0007472085,
0.0112913586,
0.0050899284,
0.0115057435,
0.0116000315,
0.018454358,
-0.0190951675,
0.052253779,
0.0321077853,
0.0438170955,
0.0561275706,
0.0000020742,
0.0059843161,
-0.0051467614,
0.0198285934,
-0.0074955402,
0.0203835573,
0.0569152534,
-0.0398679003,
0.0001937133,
0.0171776451,
-0.0144082215,
-0.0155401677,
0.0286518428,
0.0524233654,
0.0770857856,
0.1045378223,
-0.0098622004,
-0.0754253045,
0.0469979048,
-0.024497224,
-0.0436631367,
-0.0501047745,
0.0049094982,
-0.0050021904,
-0.029020451,
-0.008999506,
-0.018914992,
0.0434790216,
0.0210241023,
0.0123351486,
0.0130540431,
0.0271540228,
0.0472240783,
-0.0136994636,
0.0143085672,
0.098739773,
-0.0623163879,
-0.0202777274,
-0.0133523587,
-0.0092728203,
-0.0058356952,
0.0237471554,
-0.0133797517,
-0.021742519,
0.0291411448,
0.035003975,
-0.0148603888,
0.006922381,
0.0756525025,
0.0460060015,
0.0016376007,
-0.0058703758,
0.0092442827,
-0.0054013361,
-0.0099228602,
-0.018997347,
-0.0176454131,
-0.0516269244,
0.0422606394,
0.0056442926,
0.0046760873,
-0.0102256117,
-0.0899674147,
-0.0789029747,
0.0151938535,
-0.0411942266,
0.0190928802,
-0.0145816421,
0.0109527921,
0.0197443888,
-0.0384280123,
0.0083027259,
-0.0261974577,
0.0241890568,
-0.0236933585,
-0.0085179536,
-0.0193168372,
-0.0005555024,
-0.0079062246,
0.0281139147,
-0.041859366,
-0.017507581,
-0.0420931764,
-0.0046760328,
-0.0320323333,
0.0209414065,
0.0152692934,
0.0435233638,
-0.0332863107,
-0.0299674608,
0.02176385,
-0.0277500842,
0.0079172738,
0.006721532,
-0.0108022522,
-0.0270265583,
-0.0560985394,
0.0171518289,
-0.0172740277,
-0.0428840928,
0.0042613684,
0.0527534485,
0.0092259021,
-0.0543407351,
-0.0213312153,
-0.0077381427,
-0.0147626968,
-0.0322041363,
0.0302168224,
-0.05300951,
-0.0244884826,
-0.0189047474,
0.0001479888,
-0.1111643985,
0.0027870215,
0.0068352693,
-0.0218512304,
0.1048580334,
-0.00583799,
-0.0528935269,
0.0475142375,
0.0424693152,
0.0500034615,
0.0556459315,
-0.002251619,
0.0500801019,
0.0073323916,
0.0252443142,
0.0164644606,
0.0087203374,
0.0590614974,
0.015617731,
-0.038542971,
0.0137798861,
-0.015524948,
-0.0161285624,
0.0134741971,
0.0404486395,
-0.0376538262,
-0.0881240889,
0.1005081162,
0.017643299,
-0.0403147414,
0.0183258671,
-0.0302084051,
0.0079995571,
-0.012972164,
-0.0146227842,
-0.0429190658,
-0.0062631285,
-0.0659682453,
-0.0330053195,
0.0201352909,
0.0336209759,
-0.0288844649,
-0.0386226028,
-0.0026079232,
-0.0345897302,
0.0882027,
0.0089865141,
0.0185277294,
0.0360398591,
-0.0394052491,
0.0246623568,
0.0215633847,
0.0050326334,
-0.0189584754,
-0.0569821186,
0.0038457448,
0.0077044284,
0.0734376013,
-0.0390377827,
0.0474307649,
-0.0530660748,
0.0296183005,
0.0165635534,
0.0246367306,
0.0200392883,
0.0537327975,
-0.0507833995,
-0.0260626506,
-0.0384822898,
0.0088186488,
0.0278634522,
0.0235466659,
0.0200138688,
0.0245281532,
-0.0250585005,
-0.0385962501,
0.0407799706,
0.0273134485,
-0.0750546381,
0.0311876386,
0.0094446251,
0.0233201776,
0.0159296952,
-0.0501412116,
0.0212993138,
0.0525943078,
-0.026430672,
-0.0377813727,
-0.0449876562,
-0.0139102256,
-0.0598141775,
-0.0003477888,
-0.0143522359,
-0.017489532,
0.0501241945,
-0.0386432,
0.0169770569,
0.0492604822,
-0.0228631049,
-0.0000391617,
-0.0277344994,
-0.026116062,
-0.0092254784,
0.0600768365,
-0.0247696247,
0.0690622181,
-0.0194895193,
-0.0338034108,
-0.0431457162,
0.0311576892,
0.0090851849,
0.012337462,
-0.0327468216,
0.0169017855,
0.0027143711,
0.0088483859,
-0.0082216356,
-0.0307277758,
-0.0000868655,
0.0085093463,
-0.0197435655,
-0.0122480821,
-0.0545356274,
-0.0214556102,
0.0174611621,
-0.016558256,
0.0111042634,
-0.030973278,
-0.0070270188,
0.0134598725,
0.0109237637,
-0.0119072571,
0.0068481341,
-0.0262098536,
-0.0063148867,
-0.0205782987,
-0.0135346958,
0.0167758074,
0.0663546547,
-0.0490809456,
-0.0288509689,
-0.0092344619,
0.0221860353,
0.0192660168,
0.0790971592,
-0.0293337405,
-0.0384502634,
0.0154883964,
0.0222643949,
-0.0116346236,
0.0644329563,
0.0350152552,
0.0729929581,
0.0366107635,
0.0336924493,
0.0145990057,
-0.0156346466,
-0.0096030915,
0.0548642054,
-0.0617856719,
0.0121984482,
-0.0228792131,
0.0411100797,
0.0372296721,
-0.002906709,
-0.0190202575,
0.0394660234,
0.0066808239,
-0.0473715067,
-0.031321656,
-0.031793274,
-0.0199167486,
-0.0271288306,
-0.0504581705,
-0.0456703342,
0.0855815336,
-0.0408968106,
0.0194561426,
-0.0478270128,
-0.0834644362,
0.0717996582,
0.0486000627,
0.012616477,
0.0273355544,
0.0221658703,
-0.0030849795,
-0.0394791625,
-0.0711389482,
0.031948112,
-0.0039475095,
0.0014645217,
-0.0066855736,
0.0172850657,
0.0086286906,
0.0006130315,
-0.0723316371,
-0.0832210779,
0.0082746288,
0.0382486358,
-0.0152332652,
-0.0131652867,
-0.0626879483,
-0.0398198813,
0.001237336,
0.0173782147,
-0.0089691961,
0.0066621606,
-0.0147129577,
0.0801955536,
0.050539352,
-0.0155993532,
-0.0027354211,
-0.0418987237,
0.0165597294,
0.0695029497,
-0.0261069648,
0.0132201388,
-0.0349283852,
-0.050566718,
-0.0028598243,
0.0112514561,
0.0155350938,
0.0103961397,
0.0595474243,
-0.0413443036,
-0.0163134784,
0.0709875822,
-0.019379843,
-0.0180314407,
0.0194767509,
0.0494729951,
0.0758188814,
0.0082140435,
-0.040359281,
-0.0513013639,
-0.0381175242,
-0.0049165576,
0.0003091378,
0.0236813203,
0.0196720418,
0.0070857536,
-0.0493788086,
-0.0084565375,
0.0161315277,
-0.0085508265,
-0.0416655093,
-0.0352346748,
-0.0304660853,
0.032401178,
0.0455406755,
-0.0391171016,
0.0511782393,
-0.0018401269,
0.014351272,
0.0254399255,
-0.0886337087,
-0.0034988867,
-0.0324030705,
0.030685151,
0.0541672409,
0.0376740508,
-0.0210500769,
-0.0504536815,
0.037731491,
-0.0253903382,
-0.023891842,
0.0030146134,
0.0707261413,
-0.0136719532,
-0.0095520886,
0.0181881227,
0.0254811775,
-0.0225655567,
-0.0397902317,
-0.0142152943,
0.0074531594,
-0.0330548659,
-0.0114680063,
-0.0142506668,
-0.0204573385,
0.036150109,
0.0375906788,
0.0093240999,
-0.0284134783,
-0.0418254323,
-0.0677885339,
0.0329618193,
-0.0188829657,
-0.0621042959,
0.0259531494,
0.02050131,
-0.0542307943,
-0.0564832427,
-0.0576325245,
-0.0246493835,
0.0282010138,
-0.0100056436,
0.0142588345,
-0.028082652,
-0.0174212102,
-0.0518562049,
-0.012064728,
0.0106405923,
0.0466890782,
0.0287236087,
-0.0200924221,
-0.0257824268,
-0.0201528352,
-0.0286135636,
0.0137724727,
-0.1053406224,
-0.0816520378,
0.0125660924,
0.0438470021,
0.0081299599,
0.0106743602,
-0.0550236031,
-0.0988094509,
0.1559870243,
0.0496304296,
0.028257383,
-0.0030942129,
0.05396308,
-0.0704580769,
0.0377470516,
0.0499477684,
-0.0062974822,
0.014316407,
0.0460429266,
-0.0115350271,
-0.033707574,
0.0162380207,
-0.0175874364,
-0.0129933553,
0.0557964854,
-0.0213727467,
0.016459588,
0.0075199343,
0.0074705016,
-0.0181179848,
-0.0222306531,
-0.0064082299,
0.0188332777,
0.046418909,
0.0081309685,
-0.0076016202,
0.0366402045,
0.0215182621,
0.0104296878,
0.0009804748,
-0.0046329647,
0.0528347902,
0.0259424187,
-0.0061610057,
0.0259081852,
-0.0060291179,
0.0305957869,
0.0036245862,
0.0257007033,
-0.0173909329,
0.0357383862,
0.00957816,
-0.0117563782,
-0.0525662862,
0.0099090738,
-0.0736254007,
-0.0166636799,
-0.0270947255,
0.0235984344,
0.0592193082,
-0.0029728618,
0.0260718875,
-0.0013604801,
-0.0284590069,
-0.0209465418,
0.0049905954,
-0.0068451492,
0.0095519498,
0.0225047823,
0.0032663853,
-0.0106000239,
0.0285421871,
0.0785833746,
0.0197868049,
0.0576887056,
0.0273165256,
-0.0360946693,
-0.034597028,
-0.0654890686,
0.013461858,
0.03146917,
-0.01423347,
0.0556588024,
0.0216040276,
-0.0851411372,
-0.0402873941,
0.0081047155,
0.0283909775,
0.0058831992,
0.0112052076,
0.0243007448,
0.0237741098,
0.0145966774,
-0.0448546633,
0.0278098397,
0.0165083967,
-0.0461706668,
0.0079425434,
-6.351541279e-33,
0.0140944123,
-0.0021451127,
-0.0413074195,
-0.0930658653,
0.0167370979,
-0.0065895929,
-0.0262345448,
-0.0095605385,
-0.0377777629,
0.0337681919,
0.0201783665,
0.04104954,
-0.0234680101,
0.0385362692,
-0.0795995519,
-0.0395644642,
0.0412477516,
-0.0192337409,
-0.0222501103,
-0.0152465636,
0.0349914096,
0.0338029601,
0.0421570167,
-0.0494056307,
0.0489195064,
0.0056353332,
-0.0428165793,
-0.0184473153,
-0.0183040928,
0.022758862,
-0.0153191555,
0.0374215208,
-0.0019077224,
0.0540492013,
-0.0287841782,
-0.0003624527,
-0.0177710932,
-0.0013246285,
-0.0148888854,
0.0076757753,
-0.0536655188,
-0.0065932935,
0.0690782592,
-0.0178601798,
0.0084788948,
-0.0049603968,
0.0170805361,
-0.0009449892,
-0.0171074439,
-0.0173584837,
-0.0366383344,
0.0389838219,
-0.0157060362,
-0.0030984851,
0.0279621258,
-0.0057120561,
0.0279633924,
0.0251912437,
-0.1179096997,
-0.0248024948,
-0.0185562931,
0.0449473038,
0.028360419,
-0.0121955797,
0.00776006,
0.0722021759,
0.0234604795,
0.0195485931,
-0.0302531235,
-0.0006604464,
0.03834185,
0.0164733157,
0.0741084591,
0.060079027,
0.061816249,
-0.0434635244,
-0.0858661011,
-0.001363355,
-0.0296190437,
0.0077489885,
0.0253939666,
0.0412021689,
-0.0161643531,
-0.0138526987,
-0.0173345692,
-0.055343315,
-0.0135610672,
-0.0072800182,
0.0089292815,
0.0228383075,
-0.039032042,
-0.0075002084,
-0.0093425736,
-0.0570289604,
-0.0094888303,
0.0238126125,
-0.0136737134,
-0.0495942309,
0.0288940854,
0.0228897538,
0.0003176423,
-0.015524704,
0.0234429054,
0.0048610717,
0.009092031,
-0.0149895912,
0.0537410937,
0.0202453751,
-0.040337678,
0.0002657786,
-0.0351374112,
0.0206223615,
0.0303338468,
0.060383562,
0.0373025052,
0.0030903323,
-0.0124160405,
-0.0080651622,
0.0087041678,
0.0067705405,
-0.0020152966,
0.0252126865,
-0.0175386406,
0.0185774472,
-0.0119322976,
-0.0479030237,
-0.018273646,
0.0390888676,
0.0768597499,
-0.10036847,
0.0164212305,
-0.0353380293,
2.801e-7,
0.0173748024,
0.0507583916,
-0.0339156054,
0.0202461611,
0.0246928092,
0.0626757517,
-0.0099903513,
0.0463886373,
-0.0328637436,
-0.0674032718,
-0.0063242316,
0.0571048856,
0.0343752354,
0.0188408419,
-0.0257536694,
-0.0326420218,
-0.0557100959,
0.016551597,
-0.0115031227,
0.0114778848,
0.024454765,
0.1321490556,
0.0430388376,
-0.0284390394,
0.016732486,
-0.0385156088,
0.0504952967,
0.0011168027,
0.0359402299,
-0.0210440494,
0.0161423571,
-0.0203026608,
0.0227799639,
0.0071687344,
-0.0615751408,
0.0191549659,
0.0132291913,
0.0472281165,
-0.0375419408,
-0.0376151763,
-0.026616212,
0.0168563705,
-0.0078521445,
-0.0362238213,
0.0690127909,
0.008222321,
-0.0296424273,
-0.0089061661,
-0.0514944084,
-0.0172702558,
0.0656399727,
-0.015958881,
-0.0270866752,
0.0076021375,
0.001160818,
0.0034796891,
0.0177417826,
-0.1026904508,
-0.0254549496,
-0.0161159914,
-0.0368810892,
0.0086823227,
-0.0039346116,
-0.0048611779,
0.062154945,
0.0242264178,
0.0050849626,
2.337269167e-34,
0.0300150886,
-0.0106665799,
-0.0145612163,
0.0001623421,
0.0198265482,
-0.0133409454,
0.0013644089,
-0.0435803495,
0.0219083559,
-0.0210407525,
-0.0448490344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00242v1 | EHRmonize: A Framework for Medical Concept Abstraction from Electronic Health Records using Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T21:39:20 | 2024-06-28T21:39:20 | João Matos, Jack Gallifant, Jian Pei, A. Ian Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic health records (EHRs) contain vast amounts of complex data, but
harmonizing and processing this information remains a challenging and costly
task requiring significant clinical expertise. While large language models
(LLMs) have shown promise in various healthcare applications, their potential
for abstracting medical concepts from EHRs remains largely unexplored. We
introduce EHRmonize, a framework leveraging LLMs to abstract medical concepts
from EHR data. Our study uses medication data from two real-world EHR databases
to evaluate five LLMs on two free-text extraction and six binary classification
tasks across various prompting strategies. GPT-4o's with 10-shot prompting
achieved the highest performance in all tasks, accompanied by Claude-3.5-Sonnet
in a subset of tasks. GPT-4o achieved an accuracy of 97% in identifying generic
route names, 82% for generic drug names, and 100% in performing binary
classification of antibiotics. While EHRmonize significantly enhances
efficiency, reducing annotation time by an estimated 60%, we emphasize that
clinician oversight remains essential. Our framework, available as a Python
package, offers a promising tool to assist clinicians in EHR data abstraction,
potentially accelerating healthcare research and improving data harmonization
processes. | [
0.0297745746,
0.0702352822,
0.0062431507,
-0.0202566013,
-0.006647679,
0.053104803,
0.0270082168,
0.028190542,
0.0563120581,
-0.0360259153,
0.0219287444,
-0.0252355319,
-0.0253966656,
0.0677706525,
0.0010661297,
-0.0632341653,
0.0129013583,
0.0067114825,
0.0334748775,
0.0216202233,
-0.0151161617,
0.0072250171,
-0.0123498859,
0.0349533334,
0.041823037,
0.0049915453,
-0.0031395957,
-0.0048027555,
0.018311087,
-0.0853465125,
-0.0248868782,
0.0463041402,
-0.0223653093,
0.0272242799,
0.0000019296,
-0.0553918444,
-0.0351024531,
0.0392343551,
-0.0454770811,
-0.0583515763,
0.06194086,
-0.0755913183,
0.0019087612,
-0.0161975361,
0.001629637,
-0.0683596358,
0.0432734787,
0.0451828614,
0.0319719985,
0.0421078354,
-0.0254258402,
0.0101827979,
0.0175322909,
-0.0113587594,
0.0393122882,
-0.0223222449,
0.0686217472,
0.0007000348,
0.0433223136,
0.0023859225,
0.0223934408,
0.0328263007,
-0.0246982016,
0.0374649391,
0.0149931796,
0.0440572947,
-0.0458637364,
-0.0037706899,
-0.0239497758,
0.0472181179,
0.0003550652,
-0.0115961265,
0.059537217,
0.0007561009,
-0.0282068271,
-0.0079018688,
-0.0299748238,
0.0085377311,
-0.0365922712,
-0.0167489145,
0.0180470999,
-0.0297607146,
0.0270280465,
0.0173140317,
-0.0554639846,
0.015667608,
0.0184261091,
-0.0131656807,
0.0403792374,
-0.0285880696,
-0.0194664281,
-0.0502770729,
0.0402899161,
0.0454400033,
-0.014241009,
0.0104743699,
-0.0145817194,
-0.024553882,
0.0793716908,
-0.0149314366,
0.019171264,
-0.0029252234,
0.0311987512,
0.0546192974,
0.017987581,
-0.0126319835,
-0.021933658,
0.0133819887,
-0.0273136515,
-0.002576353,
-0.0813825056,
-0.0178700145,
-0.0375769325,
0.0423988849,
-0.0067024492,
-0.0089133838,
-0.0701339617,
0.0011484486,
-0.0285164639,
0.0295557976,
0.0089763626,
-0.0017427389,
-0.0093294457,
-0.0044284505,
-0.0184921753,
-0.0094511844,
0.0198611636,
0.0071730609,
0.007945111,
-0.042736657,
0.0370393172,
-0.0004780524,
0.0290694535,
-0.0211471058,
0.0407944284,
0.0522195399,
0.0407321677,
-0.0266255904,
0.0097122621,
-0.0536547601,
0.0077539515,
-0.0226783771,
-0.0080755306,
-0.0892952308,
0.0566587374,
0.018570859,
-0.0113306399,
-0.0523168407,
0.0002658414,
-0.0032663848,
-0.0759896412,
0.0778407678,
-0.0785835236,
-0.0202270653,
0.0353501178,
0.0188328996,
-0.0119448639,
0.000765965,
0.0034114497,
-0.0387034528,
-0.0029432636,
-0.0180994254,
0.032138709,
0.0140115609,
-0.0092507116,
-0.0621642806,
0.0251221284,
0.0135664549,
0.0167690627,
0.0524994954,
-0.0208722167,
0.0701294988,
-0.0154585093,
0.0172779225,
0.034890987,
0.0802312717,
0.01668722,
-0.0144878989,
0.011148748,
-0.0230790116,
0.0112674115,
-0.0553804711,
-0.0364940539,
-0.0087922392,
0.0297036488,
0.0060543702,
-0.0184953492,
0.0005818721,
-0.0280103162,
-0.0106400559,
-0.0423265509,
-0.0368467718,
-0.0146211321,
-0.0181751531,
0.0392221846,
-0.0326846018,
-0.0066427016,
0.0734887496,
0.0407906137,
-0.0295335855,
-0.0190300439,
-0.0315047614,
-0.0343994908,
0.0917776823,
0.0279548317,
-0.0385835357,
-0.0448964015,
-0.0372959599,
-0.0049654325,
-0.0076677999,
-0.0027999657,
-0.0372826643,
0.0029397896,
-0.0457878448,
0.0031744586,
0.0496493652,
0.0182241201,
-0.0094477106,
-0.0018566909,
0.0203963444,
-0.007158339,
-0.0367161855,
-0.0309589468,
0.0365846269,
-0.0366401561,
-0.0475165918,
-0.0105298404,
0.0203216691,
0.0082445266,
0.0466316082,
0.0004259399,
0.0326428339,
0.0471190549,
-0.0478798151,
-0.0006362062,
-0.0217700936,
0.0378971919,
0.0170255192,
0.0204625633,
-0.0038093014,
-0.0124526415,
-0.0355689898,
-0.044269897,
-0.0247358698,
-0.0411028676,
-0.0059558172,
0.0421321318,
-0.0055213077,
0.0196310226,
0.0546384938,
-0.0128398314,
-0.0409440212,
-0.0010721213,
-0.004166388,
0.0066211559,
0.0179813001,
-0.0416792482,
0.0050523574,
0.0032856588,
-0.0061155953,
0.0436146185,
0.0209905487,
0.0284492187,
-0.02353682,
-0.0057160179,
-0.0268887859,
-0.0073434091,
-0.0968460813,
0.0047293426,
0.016425591,
0.0452041887,
0.0447339863,
0.0420113988,
-0.0080919797,
-0.0176571738,
-0.0171913467,
-0.0258802529,
-0.0086787716,
0.0209158193,
0.0343158282,
0.0300845355,
-0.0335267074,
-0.0000150714,
-0.0160544943,
-0.0382032916,
0.0223804768,
-0.0133865103,
-0.0090457452,
-0.019699214,
-0.049714677,
-0.0444625281,
0.0012579612,
0.0073800688,
0.019883804,
-0.0114736427,
-0.0389929004,
0.0218875688,
0.0017811246,
-0.039874468,
0.0087731164,
0.06012927,
-0.0104266535,
0.0076949694,
-0.0077066408,
-0.0270499103,
-0.0081693847,
0.0438518301,
-0.0331835076,
0.0131800007,
0.0645980015,
0.0029340521,
0.0091537731,
-0.0189731326,
-0.001658921,
-0.0155634079,
0.0540556237,
-0.0857562274,
0.0150942635,
-0.0354577489,
0.0384123698,
-0.0052742348,
-0.0325689912,
0.0853138641,
0.0038900222,
0.0461440198,
-0.0717743337,
-0.029809976,
-0.0363144167,
0.0203949679,
-0.0060408651,
0.0245528799,
0.0295077022,
-0.054393243,
0.0172453579,
-0.0127762211,
0.010730356,
-0.0680844262,
0.0944411755,
-0.0259868354,
0.0445445813,
0.0000120146,
-0.030024685,
-0.0217645206,
0.0308977365,
-0.0318834931,
0.0231146663,
0.0191474557,
0.0082791736,
-0.0183761138,
0.0406129062,
-0.0251619704,
0.08802782,
0.0612094551,
-0.0147889685,
0.0167830996,
0.018108841,
0.0211732257,
-0.0624566972,
-0.0200293977,
-0.0092944037,
0.0533859506,
0.0506185628,
0.0253498554,
0.0014869482,
-0.0003671991,
0.0267735347,
-0.0113154966,
-0.0752598196,
-0.0044985432,
0.0241522305,
-0.0028665701,
-0.051537741,
0.0096120629,
0.1033360288,
0.0461463407,
-0.0546976887,
0.0146017196,
-0.0069280169,
-0.0306902472,
-0.0141498763,
0.0153938485,
-0.0778224021,
-0.0153495772,
-0.002050342,
0.0233930759,
0.006930246,
-0.0484784581,
0.0235842317,
-0.0281262677,
0.0191248599,
0.0171597227,
-0.0858764723,
-0.0492664687,
-0.0407387726,
0.0057662171,
-0.0078497669,
-0.0162017103,
0.0271413717,
-0.0377418548,
-0.0218189918,
0.002440887,
-0.0533274598,
-0.0522812456,
0.0131348977,
-0.0309141651,
0.0461761914,
0.040559873,
0.0243064314,
-0.0214519892,
-0.0041311467,
-0.0097692376,
-0.0377725437,
-0.0437794104,
-0.0318691917,
0.0802247897,
0.0230291858,
0.0060792365,
-0.0447948016,
0.0337512605,
-0.0508263893,
-0.0486571789,
-0.0296342392,
0.0746825486,
-0.0311051495,
-0.0272850096,
-0.0414310098,
-0.0260554794,
0.0339515507,
0.0494656265,
0.0102855079,
0.0135419387,
-0.0557552874,
0.0098531619,
-0.0011978796,
0.0115072727,
0.0117990198,
0.0386097096,
-0.0530175008,
-0.045619946,
-0.0571923368,
-0.0241980143,
0.0632162765,
-0.0209896043,
0.0102895163,
0.0430910327,
0.0356715061,
-0.0239065681,
-0.0769463852,
0.0296160225,
0.0329682082,
0.0101174591,
-0.0547446609,
-0.0765496939,
0.0429369323,
0.0235674735,
-0.0146467695,
0.0456310548,
-0.0179068632,
-0.0303348787,
0.0109158922,
-0.0003009112,
0.0279835314,
-0.0229847431,
0.015555351,
0.0031869716,
0.0430436619,
0.0522698238,
-0.0092606405,
-0.0552095063,
-0.0303286184,
0.0169470012,
-0.0163587909,
0.0140994173,
-0.0242839009,
0.0296807531,
-0.0088388333,
0.0344480462,
-0.0050076214,
0.0152873043,
0.0300315097,
0.058784999,
0.0219196957,
-0.0215779785,
-0.017733898,
-0.0349596217,
0.0195251722,
-0.0226184316,
0.0082151135,
-0.013376697,
0.0042789341,
-0.0001254523,
-0.0154214464,
-0.0156619772,
0.0321403481,
-0.0160289425,
-0.0431612432,
-0.0302417632,
0.0224528201,
-0.0322257802,
0.0161604788,
0.0768910199,
-0.0513205454,
0.0005680603,
0.0295046698,
-0.002803345,
0.0320848413,
-0.0468608066,
0.0539207831,
-0.0080979979,
0.0374130756,
-0.024145836,
0.0633858144,
-0.0297692306,
-0.0760068968,
-0.0043750233,
0.0202648584,
0.0442299061,
0.0073552197,
0.0609410964,
-0.0540570579,
-0.0290778577,
-0.0356479064,
0.0107277129,
-0.0023835199,
0.0567800067,
0.0485744774,
0.0268075299,
-0.0201364495,
-0.030087607,
0.0772468075,
-0.0312888771,
0.0786403641,
0.0031102013,
-0.0506264009,
-0.0438740663,
0.0087268297,
0.0431057028,
-0.0037276912,
-0.0952204466,
-0.0346852429,
-0.0525781177,
-0.056168709,
0.0443267673,
0.0131709259,
-0.0294954106,
0.0156549737,
0.0632880926,
0.0413897783,
0.0306461323,
-0.0269497652,
-0.0177960098,
0.0416903384,
-0.0424440615,
-0.0430302545,
0.0304733645,
-5.79532674e-33,
0.0087883975,
-0.0234637428,
0.0075371047,
-0.0038819483,
0.0250821915,
0.0277000181,
-0.0393301286,
0.0050209733,
0.0332190618,
0.0370368063,
0.0070685577,
-0.0145579958,
0.0123802181,
0.0228509158,
0.0408821404,
-0.0229904074,
0.0050475947,
0.0308145043,
-0.0024132086,
0.0299067535,
0.0200330578,
0.0544839352,
0.0226587206,
-0.0464905836,
0.0195749812,
0.0136555713,
0.0378399193,
-0.018777037,
0.003391362,
0.078114301,
-0.0547848903,
0.0456110351,
0.0315160602,
-0.0070563722,
-0.0038832016,
0.0050959587,
-0.1058345884,
-0.0234622173,
-0.0154801831,
-0.0375029556,
-0.0059476695,
-0.0504732542,
0.0533276126,
-0.0220723394,
-0.0302238651,
0.006675018,
0.0058606034,
-0.0260108821,
-0.0438366383,
-0.0467284471,
-0.0404053666,
0.046816431,
0.0071116239,
0.0220544804,
0.048643548,
-0.0187825933,
-0.0396345593,
0.0213394687,
-0.045194976,
-0.0068862536,
0.0360815264,
0.0068824743,
0.0183813181,
-0.0117901089,
-0.0139459781,
0.0509607345,
0.0131577794,
-0.0317199603,
-0.0121394861,
0.068893753,
-0.0526112095,
0.0505847074,
-0.0162540581,
-0.0312517285,
0.0348145142,
-0.0124012008,
-0.0847583339,
0.0474781543,
-0.0769200101,
0.0183172226,
0.007998107,
-0.005004664,
-0.0384591222,
-0.0008598262,
-0.0277565345,
0.0157408938,
-0.0417770408,
-0.0304690581,
0.0198393092,
-0.0201738086,
-0.0190693904,
0.0337098539,
0.0001064352,
-0.016638292,
-0.0530211702,
-0.0322760902,
0.0367165059,
0.0203221198,
-0.0335183963,
-0.0111061139,
-0.0427320302,
-0.0216407012,
0.0202066489,
-0.0102069015,
0.0325677171,
0.0318921171,
0.0155056389,
-0.0314962119,
-0.0737841427,
0.0107245212,
0.0149302967,
0.0050659031,
-0.025639439,
0.020331189,
0.0304403529,
0.0175614432,
0.0472406521,
0.0430760458,
0.0275029596,
-0.0440416671,
-0.0432894118,
0.0123920813,
0.02516599,
0.0040391944,
-0.0219167732,
0.0131714568,
-0.064079836,
0.0311343689,
0.0541340075,
-0.0044262083,
0.0008057686,
0.0119864186,
2.788e-7,
0.1132845953,
0.0398063622,
0.0376098864,
-0.009837823,
0.0139941061,
-0.0084062833,
-0.0205860026,
-0.0152590349,
-0.0300296415,
-0.0311983451,
0.0446876101,
-0.0097390926,
0.0480361171,
0.0409831256,
-0.050443545,
-0.0258895438,
-0.0501655079,
-0.062046241,
-0.0825433433,
0.0021765663,
0.084815897,
0.0471338853,
-0.0194792207,
-0.0261950232,
0.00912215,
0.0332449749,
-0.0036711108,
-0.0423507728,
0.031239491,
0.0398590975,
-0.0205040872,
-0.0052098059,
0.0024246024,
0.055156514,
-0.0038379594,
-0.0325662382,
-0.007487304,
0.1181173325,
-0.0769555941,
0.0565621145,
0.006417484,
-0.0618734136,
0.0365040302,
-0.0386287011,
0.0494401231,
-0.0262187738,
-0.047914058,
0.0045392201,
-0.0387779325,
-0.0142867602,
0.0557138063,
-0.0082489597,
-0.0362718999,
0.0429670364,
0.0229849108,
0.0365602896,
-0.0336003304,
-0.0888122916,
0.0347169116,
0.0687362626,
-0.0082796728,
-0.023391569,
0.0517208278,
-0.0196582563,
0.0010952509,
-0.0817875043,
0.0218092185,
2.739073111e-34,
0.0118459146,
0.0059346589,
0.0049237153,
0.0484236926,
0.0353256427,
-0.0151087325,
0.0182953682,
0.0158404391,
-0.0217712019,
-0.0766642466,
0.005598682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00219v1 | Evaluating Human Alignment and Model Faithfulness of LLM Rationale | 2024-06-28T20:06:30 | 2024-06-28T20:06:30 | Mohsen Fayyaz, Fan Yin, Jiao Sun, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study how well large language models (LLMs) explain their generations with
rationales -- a set of tokens extracted from the input texts that reflect the
decision process of LLMs. We examine LLM rationales extracted with two methods:
1) attribution-based methods that use attention or gradients to locate
important tokens, and 2) prompting-based methods that guide LLMs to extract
rationales using prompts. Through extensive experiments, we show that
prompting-based rationales align better with human-annotated rationales than
attribution-based rationales, and demonstrate reasonable alignment with humans
even when model performance is poor. We additionally find that the faithfulness
limitations of prompting-based methods, which are identified in previous work,
may be linked to their collapsed predictions. By fine-tuning these models on
the corresponding datasets, both prompting and attribution methods demonstrate
improved faithfulness. Our study sheds light on more rigorous and fair
evaluations of LLM rationales, especially for prompting-based ones. | [
0.028458789,
0.0895787105,
-0.0060896561,
0.0453581885,
-0.0318962,
0.0133635765,
-0.0108117023,
-0.0134115918,
-0.0247160308,
-0.0255853273,
-0.0062916139,
-0.0377346501,
0.0324054733,
-0.0026465233,
0.024702156,
-0.0397134237,
0.0283511821,
-0.0353593677,
0.0388090722,
0.0093545904,
-0.0003331717,
0.0211593062,
0.0354683958,
0.0675409883,
0.0149696907,
-0.0319775827,
-0.0177236404,
-0.0040778639,
0.0118660647,
-0.0183852408,
-0.0102824019,
0.0353543274,
0.0202424452,
0.0331482776,
0.0000021067,
-0.0691545904,
0.0126402779,
-0.0106027443,
-0.0653418601,
0.0208003353,
0.0111027192,
0.0210323688,
0.0000164196,
-0.0034669,
-0.0319706276,
0.0653639436,
0.0468225628,
0.0342937037,
0.0476850271,
0.0497112758,
0.0018048104,
-0.0242067445,
-0.0077617676,
-0.0116190771,
-0.0049399459,
-0.0374978967,
-0.0026256475,
-0.0016106575,
-0.0151968133,
0.0209628399,
0.0090423469,
0.0228097159,
0.0145002268,
-0.0575846434,
0.029647192,
0.0115911104,
-0.0022262142,
-0.0543653555,
-0.006519746,
0.0678009465,
0.0241186749,
-0.0559335202,
0.0018323673,
-0.0301300753,
0.0067407493,
0.007001868,
-0.0547873601,
0.0372599103,
0.0039396938,
0.0435635559,
0.0487200394,
-0.0084853256,
0.0472209305,
0.0284994971,
-0.0127049731,
0.0811959654,
-0.0031601412,
-0.0163770281,
-0.0120545225,
0.013159804,
-0.0143315466,
-0.0999898687,
-0.0444695763,
0.0332329236,
-0.0287884064,
0.033668045,
-0.0404196158,
0.0421616733,
0.0200243965,
-0.0121715209,
0.0294215083,
0.0491631664,
-0.0055637169,
0.0426776931,
-0.0110783158,
0.0663020611,
-0.0242161248,
0.0273100995,
-0.0153924497,
0.0141404914,
-0.0533411279,
-0.0297120921,
0.0050165015,
-0.0011677749,
-0.0299763046,
-0.0095137209,
-0.0343064032,
0.0283849221,
-0.0324586555,
0.0068155522,
0.0074850898,
0.0132591324,
-0.0015674822,
-0.0232111886,
-0.0508413203,
0.0046481881,
-0.0413841158,
0.0233892426,
0.0497775897,
-0.0384239033,
-0.0211917702,
0.0276854318,
-0.0197511297,
-0.0253999997,
-0.0286162868,
0.059691336,
-0.0007775306,
-0.0019642063,
-0.0502590351,
-0.0517648123,
-0.033118289,
-0.0600029342,
-0.0432823487,
-0.0256963111,
0.0081933839,
0.0237212889,
-0.0227016173,
-0.052375,
-0.0045360397,
0.0135702984,
-0.0461016521,
0.0591389053,
-0.0268211681,
0.0365038291,
-0.008515575,
-0.0141389789,
-0.0418277048,
0.0421168059,
0.0334722847,
0.0263160542,
0.0320001096,
-0.0099364398,
-0.0033979211,
0.0032899927,
0.0100248354,
0.00361711,
-0.0433171764,
0.0276930239,
-0.021979969,
0.0504667684,
0.0623912625,
0.0556125902,
-0.004083551,
0.0026614219,
0.0830647573,
0.0687693059,
0.0023901283,
0.0128684994,
0.0243083499,
0.0043987669,
-0.0051005548,
0.0288662706,
-0.069047302,
0.0396733023,
-0.0028173591,
0.0124909477,
0.0167846084,
0.0138350436,
0.0052377889,
-0.0517179072,
-0.0218298677,
0.0185354799,
-0.0029693379,
0.0141994683,
0.0303672813,
-0.0164857712,
-0.0408822857,
0.0343012735,
0.0195057038,
-0.0571667328,
-0.0226205476,
-0.0721284822,
0.0952386633,
0.0814460069,
0.0175687447,
0.0186116397,
-0.0100389952,
-0.0048410799,
0.0327068977,
0.0267539546,
0.0413095541,
-0.0307553504,
0.0101139164,
-0.0369430184,
-0.0326417461,
-0.0308336504,
0.0159095135,
0.0103366151,
0.0091172261,
-0.021600306,
0.0022912237,
-0.0497340597,
-0.059845455,
0.0558236651,
-0.0200005565,
-0.0185830146,
-0.0386311226,
0.0129931569,
0.0451388769,
0.0100637488,
0.0315140374,
0.0334655903,
0.0140095837,
-0.0093350625,
0.0068325019,
0.0398563258,
-0.0743406415,
0.0095114615,
0.0446222648,
0.01152902,
-0.0334618203,
-0.0163745936,
-0.0192306824,
-0.039666336,
0.0117023904,
-0.032534577,
0.0252075102,
-0.0407271609,
0.0570928492,
-0.0227807146,
-0.0224365685,
-0.0401282273,
0.0720540881,
0.0213136151,
-0.0023290357,
0.0599166565,
-0.0128959687,
0.0228325147,
-0.0544095933,
-0.0006651041,
0.0302984975,
-0.0031618075,
0.003807981,
0.0296871271,
-0.0028328062,
-0.0404297113,
0.0011692123,
-0.0494714342,
-0.0061989287,
-0.0302183572,
0.0231990386,
0.027143646,
-0.0218147114,
0.0045935181,
-0.0030360816,
-0.0233785082,
-0.021216426,
-0.0109224478,
0.0278143212,
0.0597179607,
-0.0194371063,
0.0036512162,
-0.06048958,
0.0141043756,
-0.0254880413,
0.0581848361,
0.0226617791,
0.0312798508,
-0.0766610503,
-0.0096597085,
-0.0336653106,
-0.0146871191,
-0.0105348844,
-0.0219320673,
0.0364948623,
0.0251760483,
0.0224775169,
0.0448443815,
0.0225405712,
0.0354269408,
0.0556395054,
0.0118781747,
-0.0856328681,
-0.0126999374,
-0.0163187534,
-0.0030089328,
-0.0187674332,
-0.0412628315,
0.0154820206,
0.1040391475,
-0.0020708442,
0.0083741779,
-0.0792364627,
0.0577231795,
-0.0169952232,
-0.0067049363,
-0.0450837985,
-0.0557215549,
-0.0416034237,
0.0876161903,
-0.0264173411,
-0.0883166641,
0.0868754685,
-0.0457997881,
0.0077663925,
0.0026707035,
-0.0162311494,
-0.0368586965,
0.0555525199,
-0.0394398607,
0.0009459613,
0.0377731659,
-0.0001859018,
-0.0535789169,
-0.0322301686,
0.0528229848,
-0.0022692638,
0.0797648281,
-0.0674631968,
0.0143968705,
0.0059361123,
0.001632971,
-0.0503981225,
-0.070399262,
-0.0545344278,
-0.003184048,
-0.0036766508,
-0.0209692419,
-0.0069872937,
0.0182515103,
0.0291424915,
0.0155432047,
-0.0055481913,
0.0013622524,
-0.0101081664,
-0.0096990056,
0.0451656766,
0.0426376127,
0.023710506,
-0.0392979756,
0.0678529218,
0.0203893613,
0.0036113749,
0.0195579398,
-0.0445741117,
-0.0050554094,
0.0171588082,
-0.0110806916,
-0.0169376638,
0.0387066975,
0.0972149149,
-0.0539562106,
0.0112343617,
0.1133744344,
0.0180686247,
-0.0156645402,
0.0118067442,
-0.0455738604,
0.0565377623,
0.0266118348,
-0.0052573839,
-0.0433616936,
-0.03681916,
0.02421421,
0.05335024,
0.0018567623,
-0.0083651999,
-0.010090719,
-0.1104066223,
0.0388953872,
-0.0075428039,
-0.0275507979,
0.0120307459,
-0.0554398336,
0.0139722321,
-0.0181174632,
0.0240954943,
0.028913239,
-0.0007733339,
0.00788025,
0.0342432149,
-0.041864004,
-0.0345239639,
0.0348301232,
-0.0361192524,
0.0512708463,
0.0717571005,
0.0608611628,
0.0375631563,
-0.1043186337,
0.0250922982,
-0.0076644197,
0.024605209,
-0.0055396087,
0.0221980978,
0.0178519208,
0.0054892469,
-0.0330173038,
0.0321746431,
-0.0233786795,
-0.0432113111,
0.0064402493,
0.0823280439,
-0.0336814895,
-0.038832102,
-0.0240179021,
0.0020560529,
-0.0061604851,
0.1047688499,
0.0553231761,
-0.0299839005,
-0.0467160009,
-0.0375645161,
-0.0166124441,
-0.0501649901,
-0.0285583716,
0.0068687401,
-0.0183150209,
-0.0168873463,
-0.065909341,
-0.024668036,
0.0038477636,
0.0131753981,
0.0231733471,
-0.022545943,
-0.0130304294,
-0.0132990722,
-0.0009396338,
0.0646883771,
-0.0237198658,
0.0081495233,
-0.0607623421,
0.0175135769,
-0.0125939278,
-0.0484220609,
0.0062671457,
0.0001246655,
-0.0347275659,
-0.0719273984,
-0.0212202091,
0.0288455207,
0.0359586589,
0.0529013053,
0.0024983333,
-0.0331187472,
0.0129323835,
0.0052347663,
0.0054269168,
-0.0105464766,
0.0216720793,
0.0049865278,
-0.0195717309,
0.0465003438,
-0.0291194934,
-0.023382619,
0.0205240231,
0.0491507277,
-0.0330896936,
-0.0429745167,
0.0400445834,
0.0193689074,
0.0452269167,
-0.0354369245,
-0.0414815992,
-0.054143507,
-0.0131557127,
0.0158326384,
-0.013388129,
-0.0417322554,
0.0037342226,
0.0231100898,
-0.0093487566,
-0.0019603097,
-0.045542594,
-0.0340753831,
0.0208189636,
-0.0253305268,
0.0226303041,
-0.0050506652,
0.0485447831,
0.0079989517,
0.0112248696,
-0.0235341284,
0.0116735017,
-0.0439291038,
0.0397703797,
0.0130111557,
0.0731053874,
0.0365908369,
0.0049241758,
0.0194153134,
0.0056603528,
-0.0697668046,
-0.067968674,
0.0075737527,
-0.0279033743,
0.0258249529,
-0.0376042947,
0.0748298019,
-0.0060467157,
-0.0048601967,
0.002234336,
0.07171534,
0.0329077244,
-0.0260708854,
0.0096528968,
0.0141625395,
-0.069520317,
0.004355757,
0.0472711436,
-0.0047966852,
0.0090208566,
-0.0238098744,
-0.0300319027,
-0.0169287249,
-0.0360906236,
0.0075444737,
0.0031289512,
-0.0199600495,
-0.0241481476,
-0.0871507749,
-0.0418327041,
-0.0182512514,
0.019717766,
-0.0313073471,
-0.0371832736,
0.0194232091,
0.0678024516,
-0.0234303158,
-0.016446894,
-0.0425596982,
0.0024607962,
-0.0372030027,
0.0268241428,
-0.0663454682,
-6.275574957e-33,
-0.002857489,
-0.0410063043,
0.0040089209,
-0.0291098971,
-0.0318971239,
0.0095130773,
-0.0825688988,
0.0050451648,
-0.0286800954,
0.0201394577,
-0.0142995641,
0.0001016524,
0.0139826424,
-0.0207367446,
0.0527822562,
-0.0474632978,
0.031341888,
0.0262991544,
-0.0492154919,
-0.001831193,
0.0513634235,
-0.0096650906,
0.0420329161,
-0.0522325449,
0.0977150276,
0.008723774,
-0.0197052155,
0.0140263429,
-0.0313939489,
0.0559883006,
-0.0118902344,
0.0033146609,
0.015957417,
-0.0649672225,
-0.0127415592,
0.0358776264,
-0.0277245268,
-0.0132187996,
0.0614330061,
-0.026265502,
-0.0513284802,
-0.0584563315,
0.0435161218,
0.0162109844,
-0.0169731155,
0.011309389,
0.0528698042,
-0.0171838235,
-0.0140386401,
0.0248433854,
-0.0776575282,
0.0292417053,
-0.0287954956,
-0.0264771711,
-0.0067837262,
0.0318429805,
-0.003312198,
0.0480539463,
-0.0370725095,
0.0167958029,
0.0104122385,
0.0044327527,
0.0990803689,
0.0170782972,
0.0009458839,
0.0935544372,
-0.0132707357,
0.0099190651,
-0.0543527268,
-0.0039205723,
0.0115883071,
0.0509263463,
0.0699211583,
0.0230559688,
0.0144692492,
0.0245421231,
-0.0404425114,
0.0215036143,
0.0006348321,
0.0304837078,
0.0366253704,
0.0355104208,
-0.026135616,
-0.0231556203,
-0.0303379297,
-0.0299647152,
-0.0326609612,
-0.0182875246,
0.0200271551,
-0.025716139,
-0.0460475497,
-0.0325073414,
0.020425817,
-0.0315913968,
0.0029658638,
0.0127892913,
-0.0169849414,
-0.0163722597,
0.0211831294,
0.0150080407,
-0.0559461415,
-0.0057749976,
-0.0040003597,
0.0267942399,
0.0531254411,
0.0271569807,
0.0198491067,
-0.0041602217,
-0.0396472774,
-0.0097086513,
-0.0648841709,
-0.0070690569,
-0.0431801565,
-0.0030882698,
0.0454836413,
0.0082106218,
-0.0245867204,
0.033334896,
-0.0021560453,
0.0045391838,
-0.0299378019,
0.020014748,
0.001316558,
0.011142063,
-0.0209840834,
-0.0174820609,
-0.0192157254,
0.048837319,
0.0313955061,
-0.0210788958,
-0.0262471698,
0.0286966655,
2.649e-7,
0.0318293795,
0.0269350428,
0.030469723,
-0.0211968925,
-0.0013900519,
0.0545753017,
-0.0174439065,
-0.0221034307,
0.002047712,
-0.0264267065,
0.0301634986,
0.0035814713,
0.0757744387,
0.0195269119,
-0.0769584849,
-0.0053112581,
-0.0987245739,
-0.0173544828,
-0.0275680386,
0.0222112108,
0.0593737774,
0.0438801348,
0.0237603653,
-0.0043838336,
-0.0036037578,
-0.0177954528,
0.0290153306,
-0.050413359,
0.0116043678,
0.012507976,
0.0627108589,
-0.019850513,
-0.0100700883,
-0.0178817902,
-0.0119555108,
0.0103700161,
-0.023576295,
0.0619567074,
-0.0152682476,
-0.0276786089,
-0.0631076321,
-0.0230246577,
0.0441682823,
-0.098019205,
0.0560669154,
-0.0215857457,
-0.0416306779,
-0.0519659445,
-0.0029062587,
-0.0216959547,
-0.0095326519,
0.0058191209,
0.0143237691,
0.0265687387,
-0.0071557141,
-0.0052902913,
-0.0045790006,
-0.0734234452,
-0.0541554764,
-0.0070762769,
-0.036645826,
-0.0383716002,
-0.0362110734,
0.0391694754,
0.0634477958,
-0.0606286377,
-0.000912609,
2.254782065e-34,
0.0179535709,
0.0166501626,
0.0192600433,
0.0273004975,
0.0539086759,
0.0294962451,
0.0125335073,
0.0131091718,
0.0570510142,
-0.044154346,
-0.0213516764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00211v1 | Detection and Measurement of Syntactic Templates in Generated Text | 2024-06-28T19:34:23 | 2024-06-28T19:34:23 | Chantal Shaib, Yanai Elazar, Junyi Jessy Li, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work on evaluating the diversity of text generated by LLMs has focused
on word-level features. Here we offer an analysis of syntactic features to
characterize general repetition in models, beyond frequent n-grams.
Specifically, we define syntactic templates and show that models tend to
produce templated text in downstream tasks at a higher rate than what is found
in human-reference texts. We find that most (76%) templates in model-generated
text can be found in pre-training data (compared to only 35% of human-authored
text), and are not overwritten during fine-tuning processes such as RLHF. This
connection to the pre-training data allows us to analyze syntactic templates in
models where we do not have the pre-training data. We also find that templates
as features are able to differentiate between models, tasks, and domains, and
are useful for qualitatively evaluating common model constructions. Finally, we
demonstrate the use of templates as a useful tool for analyzing style
memorization of training data in LLMs. | [
0.0165535565,
-0.0205218885,
-0.0297202747,
0.0310901422,
-0.0350704528,
0.0330142342,
-0.0315504074,
0.036266949,
-0.0212490447,
-0.0656076446,
-0.0556980893,
-0.0310136639,
0.0040914668,
-0.0247991402,
0.0767779276,
-0.0381029956,
0.0349339955,
-0.0267142374,
-0.0297875926,
0.0211367924,
0.0035779984,
0.0173975285,
0.0058931396,
0.0343486108,
-0.0118811131,
-0.038980037,
-0.0261492468,
0.0222490299,
0.0063878652,
-0.0119073316,
0.0149325896,
0.0330148563,
-0.0001785221,
-0.0083030611,
0.0000018957,
-0.0490076393,
0.0007839228,
-0.0096751694,
-0.0122824889,
0.0282672998,
0.0496018268,
0.0434984192,
-0.020007709,
0.0142979128,
-0.0278903991,
-0.0093642026,
0.0156807639,
0.0621685162,
0.0232836455,
0.0759072974,
-0.010388514,
-0.025730541,
0.0146598592,
0.0164001696,
0.0254491679,
0.0216997154,
0.0080125453,
0.0072621987,
0.0031901689,
0.0072357627,
0.0180801265,
0.0297515523,
0.0060476218,
0.0503128469,
0.0003092265,
0.0084129684,
0.0109084351,
0.0206998475,
-0.0121284537,
0.0306014419,
0.0076800231,
-0.049449753,
0.0441665761,
-0.0213730596,
0.0282053817,
0.0393364951,
-0.0607387312,
0.044520013,
-0.0411725491,
0.0163965672,
0.0303855669,
-0.0418453366,
0.0191925783,
-0.0171800926,
0.0337706171,
0.0116697634,
0.0240251478,
-0.0249524377,
-0.0136394845,
0.0007790755,
0.0203321781,
-0.0914480537,
-0.0057145357,
0.0267867763,
0.0171743724,
0.0139396694,
-0.0599413887,
-0.0331794247,
0.0571673624,
-0.0339827202,
0.1130226105,
0.0058131083,
-0.0220034495,
-0.0153124193,
-0.0676053613,
0.0651333481,
-0.025959054,
0.0152468709,
-0.0347341523,
0.0423210487,
-0.0776757151,
-0.0369975641,
-0.0439521521,
0.0347096995,
0.0617358088,
-0.0083614206,
-0.0190760028,
0.0629294068,
0.0262986887,
0.0158090107,
-0.0019388372,
-0.0103631858,
-0.0216840599,
0.0157284942,
-0.0247596595,
-0.0492464937,
-0.0114964861,
0.0080693113,
0.0195163637,
-0.0554601289,
0.0005400716,
0.0414477177,
-0.0212669224,
-0.0236540549,
-0.012994945,
0.0481976382,
-0.0209836382,
0.0054326062,
-0.0780739859,
-0.0623578876,
0.0106216948,
-0.0165807921,
0.0430860668,
-0.0874739364,
-0.0405577645,
0.0342983641,
0.0076453662,
-0.0393743701,
-0.016636584,
0.0197258703,
-0.0238273293,
0.0266237594,
0.006561812,
0.0123125548,
0.0172159672,
-0.024319483,
0.0049323076,
0.057108216,
0.0337045528,
0.0524645783,
0.0355294533,
0.0024319806,
0.0275132656,
0.0628901348,
-0.0194395091,
0.0094012115,
-0.078385748,
-0.0279292874,
0.0374826752,
0.0122305816,
0.0468487553,
0.0375636853,
-0.0305711795,
0.0126708401,
0.0509214588,
0.0494723022,
0.0684938058,
0.0411915965,
0.0878137052,
-0.0042674383,
0.0610910803,
0.0835437775,
-0.0319681354,
0.002637615,
-0.0435160436,
0.0579175204,
-0.0359514616,
0.0035623442,
-0.0181758683,
-0.0347521901,
-0.0536680967,
0.0107896868,
-0.0416798294,
-0.037251249,
0.0020083797,
0.0395281203,
-0.0253012162,
0.0752918497,
0.0031165245,
-0.0615796447,
-0.0550461374,
-0.0265328269,
-0.0012293292,
0.0750876442,
0.046959199,
-0.0182219241,
-0.0215322301,
0.0047360882,
-0.0096483966,
0.008440258,
0.0405204631,
-0.0043209395,
0.0010542131,
-0.0621109493,
-0.0158368237,
-0.0408387519,
0.0304280501,
0.0160656143,
-0.0141020119,
-0.0096930731,
0.0154965976,
-0.0494839139,
-0.050509166,
0.076182574,
-0.0522527248,
-0.0347431563,
-0.0080620926,
0.0131142223,
0.0096070068,
0.0007388615,
-0.0347519256,
0.0378936641,
0.0191846099,
-0.0306338537,
0.0311109368,
0.0023849912,
-0.0374236964,
-0.0085793072,
0.0213960689,
0.0019296951,
-0.0241026767,
-0.0044513973,
0.0175664239,
-0.0419316962,
-0.0440951139,
-0.0653031245,
0.0564095005,
-0.0474773534,
0.0285870265,
-0.0036895664,
-0.0228334609,
-0.0570540391,
0.0605030656,
0.0139040174,
0.0122330217,
0.0216118265,
-0.0176035278,
0.0425328389,
-0.0405759811,
0.0108803641,
-0.009224155,
-0.0013179452,
0.009602109,
0.0003083957,
0.0127139874,
-0.0605187081,
-0.0595621951,
-0.0732618496,
0.0090847332,
-0.0407127179,
0.0494032465,
0.0353977382,
-0.0330942571,
-0.0450515486,
0.0065166033,
-0.0339392871,
-0.0153552126,
-0.0305757094,
0.0208680294,
0.0538345911,
-0.0212965235,
-0.0205352586,
-0.0321924947,
-0.0083843917,
-0.0252112802,
0.0576012582,
-0.010655784,
-0.0071253469,
-0.066010572,
0.0808256269,
-0.0050119697,
-0.0230420344,
0.0158586819,
-0.0384024009,
0.051269833,
-0.0160125289,
0.0802859291,
0.0718218237,
0.0127862189,
0.0017816032,
0.0597699508,
-0.0001935723,
-0.0589413531,
-0.023343116,
0.0080711721,
-0.0021106901,
-0.0339003839,
-0.0511130467,
0.0285278559,
0.065815255,
0.0253592692,
0.0174906589,
-0.0125502748,
0.0025550711,
0.0238859691,
-0.0333405249,
0.0064241872,
0.0044474895,
-0.048767779,
0.0256127566,
0.0134161189,
-0.0711177513,
0.0108101089,
-0.0411631353,
0.0042845886,
0.0095422147,
-0.0195060279,
-0.0269849412,
0.0402853414,
0.0115431836,
0.015220888,
0.0473765358,
-0.0363613144,
-0.0520320386,
-0.0216829367,
0.0515767299,
-0.0078252619,
0.0434536785,
-0.0383805782,
-0.0082207788,
0.0138000166,
0.0120167146,
-0.0563061945,
0.0051828064,
-0.0205180068,
0.0120542469,
0.0004086519,
-0.0151077295,
0.0014186512,
-0.0224479102,
0.0377533026,
0.0241055917,
-0.0228178594,
-0.0280492231,
-0.0359246694,
0.0501786694,
0.0302756317,
-0.0199713297,
0.0153772887,
-0.0621071309,
-0.0237299651,
0.0229104981,
-0.0042882697,
0.0278195906,
-0.0553220585,
0.0010380162,
0.006647727,
-0.0579313785,
-0.0601339713,
0.0688031986,
0.0460545942,
-0.0447310284,
-0.0134136127,
0.106919907,
0.0363372415,
-0.0327422172,
0.0047843433,
-0.0341418087,
0.0906520411,
0.0351124182,
0.0159726609,
-0.0560911074,
-0.0225010607,
0.0244182516,
0.0044154581,
-0.0159910768,
0.0034245555,
0.003319015,
-0.0482435115,
0.0257322416,
0.0012455893,
-0.0442008115,
0.0349428654,
-0.0042496496,
-0.0079183923,
0.0190533139,
-0.0245170984,
0.010696332,
-0.0650311187,
0.0291015264,
0.0500026904,
-0.0649426058,
-0.0462056138,
-0.0446407646,
-0.0431761369,
0.0313101783,
0.064419657,
0.0147216851,
-0.0126011837,
-0.0618047304,
0.0447563343,
0.0010871779,
0.0703579113,
-0.022847183,
0.0406574421,
0.022518767,
-0.0126480786,
-0.0292928647,
0.0167875197,
-0.0230569374,
-0.0163271446,
0.0115275383,
0.0606321432,
-0.0605231188,
-0.0003079992,
-0.024243623,
-0.0230796617,
-0.0029798781,
0.0516949259,
0.1075103432,
-0.0084931711,
-0.0384796895,
-0.0669831708,
0.0216654763,
-0.0555189662,
-0.041988533,
0.006642621,
-0.0566900559,
0.0308369957,
-0.0998298749,
-0.0376898497,
0.0033721568,
0.0292459391,
0.0109787583,
0.0058071762,
-0.0134423664,
-0.0285599157,
-0.0481716208,
0.0026768588,
-0.0218679905,
0.036664445,
-0.079979904,
-0.0523823947,
0.032567136,
-0.0228650644,
-0.0010693485,
0.0200629029,
-0.084613882,
-0.047903128,
0.0026758732,
0.061281722,
0.0196102951,
0.0128568606,
0.0282723121,
-0.0426225252,
0.0323107615,
0.0420449153,
-0.0015797307,
0.0511803478,
0.0404861458,
-0.0418462157,
0.0081944112,
0.0224449113,
-0.0289840288,
-0.011421076,
0.0380175151,
0.0132998331,
0.0014657226,
-0.0360400304,
0.0281806141,
0.0401029475,
0.0111247608,
-0.0065428736,
0.0173604432,
-0.0090569807,
-0.0015656536,
-0.0137264766,
-0.0041078725,
-0.0503506698,
0.0401210785,
-0.0301398635,
0.0154394694,
-0.0003704467,
0.0112619065,
-0.0413876735,
0.0988532528,
-0.0306732841,
0.0033036985,
-0.0356597267,
0.0177233573,
-0.0136151817,
0.0162475444,
0.0043997308,
0.0425450392,
-0.0306592956,
0.0161091257,
0.018587688,
0.051963333,
0.0232065488,
0.0254631173,
-0.0501412638,
0.0464453101,
-0.0444934405,
-0.0483138449,
-0.0113502955,
-0.022902647,
0.0614305586,
-0.0499209091,
0.0731443688,
-0.0553954206,
0.0056123557,
-0.0182444677,
0.0358857624,
-0.0092376452,
0.0189897697,
-0.0035622576,
0.0259112697,
-0.0226703063,
-0.0678302944,
0.0920044631,
0.0276830755,
0.0304278266,
-0.0024755446,
-0.0262335874,
-0.0258411523,
-0.0240070913,
0.0701481849,
-0.0225334521,
0.0078869788,
-0.0576366149,
-0.0505440161,
-0.0551453419,
0.0515508279,
0.0192843135,
0.0079990607,
-0.0309123322,
0.0428922661,
0.0581153259,
-0.021233039,
-0.0210709777,
-0.0330655761,
0.0116659319,
0.0189673826,
-0.0080422452,
-0.0297779255,
-5.282610266e-33,
-0.0306159761,
-0.0472819582,
0.0118296063,
0.0095959781,
-0.0233135633,
0.0035183546,
-0.0233778544,
0.0101705249,
0.0343306139,
0.0111101335,
-0.0258106738,
-0.0305820219,
0.0079457518,
-0.0262785107,
0.0558223724,
0.0168254375,
0.0400912389,
-0.0297039319,
-0.0396370403,
0.0011794606,
0.0363578275,
0.0181710124,
0.0805843771,
-0.043160338,
-0.0098690856,
-0.0117932269,
0.0055435421,
-0.0201957375,
-0.014868726,
0.0763917342,
-0.007306145,
-0.003597768,
0.0290692691,
-0.0390711799,
-0.0743476152,
-0.0125307385,
-0.0372123756,
-0.0700220093,
0.0241860785,
-0.0077774138,
-0.0257464275,
-0.0698561296,
0.0732831359,
-0.0208133105,
-0.0274499357,
0.0079592755,
0.0461878181,
-0.0429825038,
-0.0518404208,
-0.0603832565,
-0.0280193966,
0.0154410852,
0.0074183596,
-0.0077860905,
0.0161852241,
0.0081232004,
-0.0238777697,
0.0051927483,
-0.0274701267,
0.0176461004,
0.0192578696,
0.034031976,
0.0339416824,
0.0523693785,
0.0187038016,
0.0480442531,
0.0058353026,
0.0421728082,
-0.0340644382,
0.0045309095,
0.0342684165,
0.0560949966,
0.0008026081,
0.0135494778,
0.0019886715,
0.0290460642,
0.0036795666,
0.0435506701,
-0.0076192063,
0.0410140231,
-0.0034685375,
0.0272604302,
-0.0274101384,
-0.0190218054,
-0.0490394123,
0.0215494502,
0.0008437996,
-0.023703238,
0.029519977,
-0.0262190029,
-0.0027651642,
-0.0123403808,
0.0170595087,
0.0189559702,
-0.0311763268,
-0.0152449198,
-0.0392493643,
0.0504924282,
-0.009566281,
-0.0060388544,
-0.038172856,
-0.0231797062,
0.0222582687,
-0.001280685,
0.0466223322,
0.0261523947,
0.0451899767,
0.0305354316,
-0.0802421644,
0.0038063808,
-0.0165428128,
-0.0212769024,
0.0204996858,
-0.0031925929,
0.0142540839,
-0.0221294519,
0.0090169534,
0.0659727007,
-0.010509111,
-0.0669827536,
-0.0546693876,
-0.0055738431,
-0.003495401,
0.0478228442,
-0.0278848652,
-0.0014382341,
-0.0496988855,
0.0396282524,
0.0795906335,
0.0059806895,
0.0121859387,
0.0064632953,
2.484e-7,
0.0189493392,
0.0422271639,
0.0334868282,
0.0366145074,
0.0239344724,
0.0467873812,
-0.0305207148,
0.027321754,
-0.0106680244,
-0.0235806648,
0.0219046306,
0.0263730455,
0.0612801909,
0.01891765,
-0.069150202,
0.0474069156,
-0.0579032414,
-0.0033431859,
-0.0591806881,
-0.0041360883,
0.0193304326,
0.0291203689,
-0.0081670433,
-0.003379972,
0.0000366722,
-0.0237656124,
0.0464116894,
-0.0544828363,
-0.0050766044,
0.0175790377,
0.0647538975,
-0.0153514342,
-0.0002831936,
0.0063466225,
-0.019891616,
-0.0320346765,
0.0111645358,
0.0394835956,
0.0078239543,
0.0219555721,
0.0130167957,
-0.0479052141,
-0.0037401854,
-0.0527611114,
0.0291571189,
0.0046331342,
0.01206268,
-0.0523999706,
0.0087996665,
-0.008000874,
0.0087872809,
0.0091082845,
0.0158305708,
0.0520427451,
-0.0030551823,
-0.0094473781,
-0.0145136481,
-0.0396263041,
-0.0374851301,
0.0132649336,
-0.0349983238,
-0.0350598134,
-0.0630608127,
0.0064823437,
0.0100568421,
-0.065957807,
-0.026598433,
2.486623071e-34,
0.0087736463,
-0.0086399876,
0.0376079604,
0.0727461874,
0.0274920054,
-0.0055123316,
0.0123414882,
0.0544528216,
-0.0081153968,
-0.0886287615,
-0.0052344371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00191v1 | MetaKP: On-Demand Keyphrase Generation | 2024-06-28T19:02:59 | 2024-06-28T19:02:59 | Di Wu, Xiaoxian Shen, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditional keyphrase prediction methods predict a single set of keyphrases
per document, failing to cater to the diverse needs of users and downstream
applications. To bridge the gap, we introduce on-demand keyphrase generation, a
novel paradigm that requires keyphrases that conform to specific high-level
goals or intents. For this task, we present MetaKP, a large-scale benchmark
comprising four datasets, 7500 documents, and 3760 goals across news and
biomedical domains with human-annotated keyphrases. Leveraging MetaKP, we
design both supervised and unsupervised methods, including a multi-task
fine-tuning approach and a self-consistency prompting method with large
language models. The results highlight the challenges of supervised
fine-tuning, whose performance is not robust to distribution shifts. By
contrast, the proposed self-consistency prompting approach greatly improves the
performance of large language models, enabling GPT-4o to achieve 0.548 SemF1,
surpassing the performance of a fully fine-tuned BART-base model. Finally, we
demonstrate the potential of our method to serve as a general NLP
infrastructure, exemplified by its application in epidemic event detection from
social media. | [
0.0770724267,
0.0562383868,
0.0000150641,
-0.0109810913,
-0.0289922487,
-0.0220461823,
-0.0448260754,
0.0133522367,
0.0356477238,
-0.0324729681,
0.0130117778,
0.0256910268,
-0.0530293509,
0.0700879097,
-0.0002534689,
-0.0381243229,
0.0451223552,
-0.0083537139,
0.0116928555,
-0.0145520167,
0.0186768882,
0.0540165827,
0.0065115788,
0.0643363297,
0.0248377472,
-0.0067833024,
-0.0136057464,
-0.0161072444,
0.0226488058,
-0.0402187221,
0.0561108403,
0.0499323942,
0.0376587585,
0.0253669266,
0.0000019734,
-0.0510725267,
-0.0266280361,
-0.0333730541,
-0.0003268333,
-0.0071186293,
0.0702692494,
-0.066868268,
0.0184656419,
0.0072317012,
-0.0589617603,
0.0296123195,
0.0456294268,
0.0183996018,
0.0484024547,
0.0591557547,
-0.017303437,
-0.0358147547,
0.0339383967,
-0.0350404158,
-0.0068105273,
-0.0962065384,
0.040408615,
-0.0561959855,
-0.0353369005,
0.0370690599,
0.0143884551,
0.0296780821,
-0.0412513018,
0.0293287877,
0.0893966034,
0.0192074012,
-0.0693256557,
-0.039537441,
-0.0583934374,
0.0572841913,
-0.0332187489,
-0.0127628352,
0.0557931848,
-0.0338110104,
-0.0158731621,
0.0557173975,
-0.0569339842,
-0.0036703525,
-0.0225097612,
0.0184829589,
0.0015674706,
-0.0150184119,
0.0275954995,
0.0565880276,
0.0092946794,
0.0196454991,
0.0265329052,
-0.0160727445,
-0.012243527,
0.0037061528,
-0.0816429332,
-0.0425300524,
0.0004561119,
0.005111489,
-0.0557159036,
0.0284935627,
-0.0401946604,
-0.0094452482,
0.0798164159,
-0.1222721413,
-0.0122649195,
-0.038817741,
0.0219789129,
0.0482779481,
0.012919968,
0.0000668258,
-0.030476924,
0.0050021838,
-0.0025762012,
0.002729468,
-0.0641227216,
0.0144116823,
-0.0067658508,
0.0201592222,
0.0235921536,
-0.0240375213,
-0.0773982257,
0.0133866025,
0.0373188853,
-0.0086141499,
0.0144601557,
0.0265093073,
-0.0693466514,
-0.0179039799,
0.0187251512,
-0.0083679976,
-0.0381420329,
0.017239077,
-0.0135028232,
0.0130593823,
0.0044606533,
-0.0115447808,
0.045245003,
-0.0163544528,
0.0247251336,
0.0135290148,
-0.0010421547,
-0.0197220314,
-0.0147723099,
-0.0570248142,
-0.0519264638,
-0.0198661499,
0.0047082957,
-0.0651789457,
0.0278011225,
0.0185690355,
-0.0093011102,
0.004463383,
0.0090458561,
0.0161410104,
-0.0799722522,
0.0594953075,
-0.007429231,
0.0062814075,
0.0163955912,
0.0204490107,
-0.0091900313,
0.0682259873,
0.010511714,
0.0734604299,
0.0768154189,
0.0059264866,
0.0130971549,
0.0088170199,
0.0476939827,
0.0259181093,
0.0413273536,
0.0022588319,
-0.0133197131,
0.0302193705,
-0.0247713979,
-0.0115976939,
0.0189805105,
0.0252963398,
0.0296754055,
0.0763676092,
-0.0172678754,
-0.0169516075,
0.013549814,
0.0463498719,
-0.0520438813,
-0.0197782721,
0.0166433137,
-0.0013323607,
-0.0201786086,
0.0088963397,
0.0594956838,
0.0625123754,
-0.0135870641,
0.0057879114,
-0.0376166999,
0.0300666429,
-0.0436501466,
-0.0387856737,
0.0468090326,
0.0015858917,
-0.0446890593,
0.0383352265,
-0.0045739249,
-0.0368306562,
0.0014654626,
-0.0496171489,
-0.0195858572,
0.0695977584,
0.0773940757,
-0.0083492119,
-0.0406657532,
-0.0100176614,
0.0503688417,
0.0626966879,
-0.0096035758,
0.0016352563,
0.0083019827,
-0.0554154031,
-0.0349564105,
0.00944959,
0.0262352154,
-0.0430410095,
0.0401995815,
0.0260756128,
0.0156545565,
-0.0492661186,
0.0049174931,
0.0158395953,
-0.0136230234,
-0.035490036,
-0.0251684766,
-0.0156034622,
0.0265878737,
0.0145101761,
0.0276761726,
-0.0008548701,
0.0519878156,
-0.0307900049,
-0.0567200221,
-0.0000876863,
-0.0061353669,
0.016736798,
0.0181869566,
-0.0277336463,
0.0129514663,
0.0085180616,
-0.0483849309,
-0.0276926551,
0.0342856906,
-0.0075836354,
0.0322937779,
-0.0448366031,
0.0068031037,
-0.006752654,
0.0074078771,
-0.010240728,
0.0610042401,
0.007386764,
-0.0034129049,
-0.0415849313,
-0.0566291176,
-0.0031046805,
0.0151609965,
-0.0081919059,
0.0181184169,
0.0151987905,
0.020763604,
0.0418761298,
-0.0051251743,
-0.0558505952,
-0.0209334642,
-0.0947503,
0.0283963811,
0.0114346817,
-0.006191418,
0.0219457094,
0.0435206071,
-0.0048497748,
-0.0210505594,
-0.0218419805,
-0.0070661064,
-0.0026166528,
0.0401232056,
0.0198514573,
0.0314402618,
0.0076943757,
-0.018702697,
0.0110313296,
-0.0242205132,
0.0264936332,
0.028631581,
-0.037052013,
0.013365197,
-0.0014876608,
-0.005316793,
-0.0304673128,
0.0020343792,
-0.0239235051,
0.0185345784,
-0.0178189017,
0.0596550703,
-0.0227689669,
0.0551798679,
0.0019817431,
-0.0037767764,
-0.0127208577,
-0.0526405834,
-0.009917181,
-0.0582401268,
-0.0757279992,
0.0099237738,
-0.0225579794,
0.0625092387,
0.0449161157,
0.009860781,
-0.0005007759,
-0.084035933,
0.0218488015,
-0.007253048,
0.0077081355,
-0.0618373603,
-0.0084510697,
-0.02514752,
0.0157302022,
-0.0201642253,
-0.0240578726,
0.0422570109,
0.0136449188,
0.0398495682,
-0.0379675068,
0.0058202669,
-0.0202065948,
0.0535422079,
-0.0552612022,
0.0248541273,
0.042838417,
-0.0049715643,
0.0188532211,
-0.0404220633,
0.0172774084,
-0.0479513444,
0.0451273806,
-0.0339884348,
0.0221564118,
0.0271322001,
-0.0346763879,
-0.0365210064,
-0.0813474059,
-0.0374173261,
-0.0530976355,
0.0136454152,
-0.0272469781,
0.0026112637,
0.0208197404,
-0.031130176,
0.0088440143,
-0.0078979665,
-0.0328162685,
0.0065456103,
0.016872162,
0.0853123069,
-0.0410591289,
-0.0264470801,
-0.0170779675,
0.0126509517,
0.0401356332,
0.0639096051,
0.0151956892,
-0.016680792,
0.0181401819,
0.0174218174,
-0.028067641,
-0.0028567179,
-0.0195196643,
0.0585413426,
0.0008739054,
-0.0033471023,
0.1088308766,
0.0313923061,
-0.0723444447,
0.0025146389,
-0.008263628,
-0.0059972014,
0.0049284259,
0.0124012241,
-0.0372188576,
-0.0458186604,
-0.0136976279,
0.060874477,
0.0020110731,
-0.0525525995,
-0.0181222539,
-0.042472776,
0.0423737876,
0.0100849252,
0.0189683754,
0.0096996641,
-0.0853472352,
-0.0037032312,
-0.0523231514,
-0.0384497344,
-0.0293613859,
-0.0419555791,
0.0150574604,
-0.0191286393,
-0.0364801139,
-0.0877098739,
0.0421749614,
-0.0635740533,
0.0352017172,
0.0595634803,
0.0331198014,
-0.0048357393,
0.0031174731,
0.0204107761,
0.0130279772,
-0.0189429279,
-0.005663699,
0.0413632914,
-0.0421929434,
0.0104503278,
-0.036026109,
0.0249046013,
-0.0669090375,
-0.0399150141,
0.0521952696,
0.0653691739,
0.013916282,
-0.0245411079,
-0.0320981219,
0.0185634736,
0.0215643123,
0.0881706327,
-0.0133988801,
-0.0106043098,
0.0122283995,
0.0315447152,
0.0304806773,
-0.07061515,
-0.0434432998,
-0.0386713408,
-0.0697164237,
0.0170878004,
-0.0548113994,
-0.0144318677,
0.0291167777,
-0.0233549867,
-0.0031573903,
0.0390153565,
-0.0030795357,
-0.0094128484,
-0.0601236634,
0.0230600256,
-0.0236111637,
-0.0372999087,
-0.0144406585,
-0.0285057742,
0.0421600267,
0.0068612928,
-0.0059384718,
0.0575665534,
-0.0537316874,
-0.042289257,
0.0047588283,
0.0054146233,
0.0176509991,
0.0152704893,
-0.0026577865,
0.0004678624,
0.0534380563,
0.087802954,
-0.0287684444,
-0.0218732152,
0.0180348717,
-0.0266630854,
-0.0155684724,
0.0485306866,
-0.0352046974,
0.0171114691,
-0.026485879,
0.0706931055,
-0.0267450251,
-0.0357785635,
-0.0095929969,
0.0141470116,
0.0612590164,
-0.0800042525,
-0.044497408,
-0.0614747033,
-0.0551715344,
0.0520063341,
-0.007284964,
-0.011541063,
0.0327774845,
0.0076955399,
-0.0399620421,
-0.0271106623,
0.0760926381,
-0.071263589,
-0.0022446266,
-0.0651051849,
-0.0264913402,
-0.0064360979,
0.0198176391,
0.0286418218,
-0.0130953807,
-0.0039985301,
0.0026249853,
-0.0054805204,
-0.0041259122,
-0.0189998001,
0.0073476504,
0.0050060516,
0.0065943468,
-0.0212287661,
0.0665550604,
-0.0615051761,
-0.0290376209,
-0.0471951626,
0.0176723432,
0.082564041,
-0.0067882743,
0.0115839522,
-0.0334681906,
-0.0243101846,
-0.0071155936,
0.0566520542,
-0.0107920179,
0.0149934022,
-0.0244454779,
0.0160559434,
-0.0431401767,
0.0127860121,
0.0796965808,
-0.0027698434,
0.0649582893,
0.0440952666,
-0.051381059,
-0.0155595178,
-0.0252334978,
0.0312105175,
0.0364883319,
0.0000330232,
0.0184787307,
-0.0238769818,
-0.0192995239,
0.0682422146,
-0.0419001766,
-0.0183734763,
0.0079448,
0.0417729542,
0.0847905576,
0.0071096458,
-0.0041014762,
-0.0658465326,
0.0295569971,
-0.0500917546,
-0.0269333608,
0.0217195563,
-7.123346625e-33,
0.0303174555,
-0.0192504339,
0.015456304,
0.0005770177,
0.0103555126,
0.0253879931,
-0.0183458924,
-0.0473608337,
0.0184151977,
-0.0054888511,
-0.0352652855,
0.0189952403,
0.0087160626,
-0.0065566227,
0.0551391467,
-0.0081576603,
0.0372366421,
0.0144440262,
-0.0341170654,
0.0437465012,
0.0331084728,
0.0411668271,
0.0602951795,
-0.0299056154,
0.027407147,
-0.0455779172,
-0.0226215292,
-0.0130915465,
0.0326268934,
0.0520088784,
-0.0286113601,
0.07466086,
0.0376427658,
-0.0558912903,
-0.0037901259,
0.0104113994,
-0.0146214338,
-0.026762506,
0.0096745715,
-0.0466457009,
-0.0347823501,
-0.0191567559,
0.0084479535,
-0.0136494823,
-0.0224780031,
0.0178060103,
0.0377575681,
-0.0123630827,
-0.0170026049,
-0.0138025898,
-0.0257377364,
0.0180062596,
0.0175592471,
-0.0164592396,
-0.001633801,
-0.0034170772,
0.0009413681,
0.045079533,
-0.0122965621,
0.0445839465,
0.0222006403,
0.0235410035,
0.032115493,
0.0353822,
-0.0088897962,
0.0576833002,
-0.0380991176,
-0.0169212092,
0.0064208149,
0.0257291179,
-0.0034190533,
0.057877142,
0.0298263878,
0.0788878798,
0.0450330041,
0.0077269427,
-0.0269480608,
0.0738353953,
-0.001951593,
-0.0112637971,
0.026052054,
0.0113291312,
-0.0371216461,
0.0018612959,
-0.0246711373,
0.0383540541,
-0.0283166803,
-0.0138336113,
0.0078720171,
0.0361001417,
-0.038945742,
0.0698485896,
-0.0085716117,
-0.0041551823,
-0.000281655,
0.0193481147,
0.0268936865,
-0.0247815289,
-0.005087737,
0.0508837439,
-0.0556120463,
0.00497927,
0.0276342928,
0.0256176963,
0.0050662854,
-0.0010252107,
0.0044738711,
-0.0019650334,
-0.0351539254,
-0.0008841942,
-0.0067468565,
0.010355074,
-0.0422871821,
-0.014877812,
0.0180998351,
0.0184008349,
-0.0066283313,
0.0502978973,
0.037810035,
0.0196510777,
0.0248104893,
-0.0119859092,
0.0007403558,
0.0350423716,
0.0072244266,
0.0234501939,
-0.0344089903,
-0.0207074787,
-0.0201681033,
-0.0601318143,
-0.0381342657,
-0.0324715935,
2.843e-7,
0.0277509764,
0.061731901,
0.0152420839,
0.0200908687,
-0.0207856055,
0.0393471196,
-0.0011431427,
0.0452995263,
-0.0632680133,
-0.0549778566,
0.0211585648,
0.0673555881,
0.0086337132,
0.0200145505,
-0.0866483673,
0.0155469161,
-0.0830250159,
0.0578467548,
-0.0745662749,
-0.0167154409,
0.0329840183,
0.0205867905,
0.0279874057,
-0.0303528532,
0.0077189561,
-0.0145884287,
0.0525240637,
-0.0273835696,
-0.0433972776,
0.0325707234,
-0.0356856212,
0.0540598407,
-0.0251138806,
0.0351850018,
-0.032321509,
-0.0489213727,
0.0201405399,
0.0413906425,
-0.0008332686,
-0.022393683,
0.0014192021,
-0.0133436266,
0.0191172827,
-0.0274119861,
0.074549824,
-0.0434572063,
-0.0171206631,
-0.0327171423,
-0.027022237,
0.0301337391,
-0.0048053288,
-0.0613949373,
-0.0574578419,
0.0108861811,
-0.0107100485,
0.0377943814,
-0.0513828434,
-0.065688923,
0.0501302555,
0.0157064274,
-0.0303646941,
-0.0161156915,
-0.0469637811,
0.0010554952,
-0.0015374838,
-0.1080187336,
0.043860998,
2.244478123e-34,
0.0379876047,
0.0260079298,
-0.0085483519,
-0.0128095048,
-0.0065120836,
-0.0165001489,
-0.0438591242,
0.0053213695,
0.0226935577,
-0.0126961563,
-0.0033524688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00167v1 | Can GPT-4 Help Detect Quit Vaping Intentions? An Exploration of Automatic Data Annotation Approach | 2024-06-28T18:06:48 | 2024-06-28T18:06:48 | Sai Krishna Revanth Vuruma, Dezhi Wu, Saborny Sen Gupta, Lucas Aust, Valerie Lookingbill, Wyatt Bellamy, Yang Ren, Erin Kasson, Li-Shiun Chen, Patricia Cavazos-Rehg, Dian Hu, Ming Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.HC, cs.SI | In recent years, the United States has witnessed a significant surge in the
popularity of vaping or e-cigarette use, leading to a notable rise in cases of
e-cigarette and vaping use-associated lung injury (EVALI) that caused
hospitalizations and fatalities during the EVALI outbreak in 2019, highlighting
the urgency to comprehend vaping behaviors and develop effective strategies for
cessation. Due to the ubiquity of social media platforms, over 4.7 billion
users worldwide use them for connectivity, communications, news, and
entertainment with a significant portion of the discourse related to health,
thereby establishing social media data as an invaluable organic data resource
for public health research. In this study, we extracted a sample dataset from
one vaping sub-community on Reddit to analyze users' quit-vaping intentions.
Leveraging OpenAI's latest large language model GPT-4 for sentence-level quit
vaping intention detection, this study compares the outcomes of this model
against layman and clinical expert annotations. Using different prompting
strategies such as zero-shot, one-shot, few-shot and chain-of-thought
prompting, we developed 8 prompts with varying levels of detail to explain the
task to GPT-4 and also evaluated the performance of the strategies against each
other. These preliminary findings emphasize the potential of GPT-4 in social
media data analysis, especially in identifying users' subtle intentions that
may elude human detection. | [
0.0578170605,
0.0708770454,
-0.0067694476,
-0.0525528379,
0.0148157952,
0.0400002934,
0.0117770266,
0.0125035662,
0.0176413525,
-0.0468889475,
0.0134720281,
0.0216694027,
-0.0187144801,
0.0212176815,
-0.0046325536,
-0.032668557,
0.0164853744,
0.0393442623,
0.0842001215,
0.0334615819,
0.0514999628,
0.019341616,
0.0013135213,
0.0536930487,
-0.0015196436,
-0.0358161591,
0.0048696003,
-0.0260107741,
0.0442542993,
-0.0902229771,
0.0434303842,
0.0653677061,
0.0110206753,
0.0743954405,
0.0000019814,
-0.0393988229,
-0.0171286017,
-0.0009320931,
-0.0486227982,
-0.0234233998,
0.054400418,
-0.0254370309,
0.0080460981,
0.0244072266,
-0.0808040351,
-0.0108913127,
0.0966109484,
0.0308965053,
0.054766275,
0.0662842467,
-0.0557384379,
-0.0262497179,
0.0068471273,
-0.0191241596,
0.0343484953,
0.0195889845,
0.0356982611,
-0.0370254554,
-0.0256114174,
-0.0242419224,
0.0104689728,
0.0327913277,
-0.0395466909,
0.0395564362,
-0.0076930448,
0.0427714176,
-0.0377609544,
-0.0436292887,
-0.0174546298,
0.0535675026,
0.0210800376,
0.0008020006,
0.0194834024,
-0.019311972,
-0.0172312092,
0.0437621698,
-0.0565897822,
-0.0322875232,
-0.0083305156,
0.0371516235,
0.004479121,
0.038631916,
0.0207980666,
-0.0052662729,
0.0276590008,
0.0234836601,
-0.0108067701,
-0.0287753865,
0.045993343,
0.0192780178,
-0.0079801558,
-0.0576892048,
-0.0006546111,
-0.0249374826,
-0.0518255644,
0.0289394613,
0.0097552752,
0.0141339572,
0.0757606104,
-0.0348881371,
0.0306573138,
0.0146256424,
-0.0023441769,
0.0198553018,
0.0215930827,
-0.0368375741,
-0.0041363933,
0.012481248,
-0.0213568229,
0.0326208398,
-0.0644464865,
-0.0172241181,
-0.0463330895,
-0.0436782464,
0.0149813974,
-0.0289541613,
-0.0796435848,
-0.0064516854,
-0.0351834521,
-0.0343695469,
-0.0099298917,
-0.000162884,
-0.0265272558,
0.0288108271,
-0.0211358238,
0.0766619593,
-0.0297925323,
0.0462279022,
0.0172160361,
-0.009388552,
0.0231753457,
0.0225928612,
0.0285850074,
-0.0369895287,
-0.0133983837,
-0.0065189563,
0.0372330844,
-0.0182704292,
-0.043225769,
-0.0225559473,
-0.0313288458,
-0.0354365222,
0.0155082941,
-0.0298907999,
0.0155851617,
-0.0147458762,
0.0178442728,
-0.0268894266,
0.0095405858,
0.0180904772,
-0.0156289972,
0.0676487312,
-0.0574245416,
0.0239809286,
0.0284721665,
0.0104351901,
0.0086838678,
0.0221672952,
0.0206610691,
0.0056181471,
0.0090865754,
-0.0323364511,
0.0303740855,
0.0107625555,
0.0290993061,
-0.0234415233,
0.0269779451,
-0.0175538324,
-0.046473138,
0.0140874926,
-0.0442679264,
0.0559833795,
-0.0106903082,
0.0633183867,
0.0884923041,
0.0600894615,
-0.0213212315,
-0.0364608504,
0.0202450659,
0.0317859352,
-0.0337152928,
0.0015716213,
-0.0220278874,
0.0007688648,
-0.0040584374,
-0.0147434268,
0.0249750298,
-0.0105030956,
-0.0009413198,
-0.0425823703,
-0.0363008045,
-0.0119999927,
0.0397880189,
-0.0222179312,
-0.000900762,
-0.0271629859,
-0.0383441076,
-0.019435918,
0.0079471963,
-0.0262842085,
-0.0541180968,
-0.056870576,
0.0516671799,
0.0532967597,
0.0052866903,
0.0204662364,
-0.0375558622,
-0.0604865961,
0.0272498075,
-0.0131218396,
0.0036625634,
-0.0317608304,
-0.0311087016,
-0.0223521907,
-0.0392644443,
-0.0159599818,
0.0028223635,
-0.0415294096,
0.0102998568,
0.0028062265,
0.0038462961,
-0.0041775056,
0.0231139809,
0.0324055851,
-0.0031241244,
-0.0378062017,
-0.0426236056,
0.0458335355,
0.062827453,
0.0091359401,
0.0438641682,
-0.0028042258,
0.0303628221,
-0.0140455561,
-0.0265559163,
0.0251784902,
0.0499473512,
0.0262996331,
0.0173764303,
-0.0250011068,
-0.0167874936,
0.0311456472,
-0.0395425707,
-0.0453888215,
-0.0549987555,
-0.0285684243,
0.027141111,
-0.040693745,
-0.0755424127,
0.0154663557,
0.035539683,
0.0040013059,
0.0495725311,
0.012650297,
-0.0431000739,
0.0234996788,
-0.0739988685,
0.0123929912,
-0.0189620592,
-0.0457413383,
-0.0369111449,
-0.0178560466,
-0.0005191168,
0.0444683284,
0.0192367807,
-0.0766280368,
0.0268716589,
-0.1431273669,
-0.0091955792,
-0.0193765238,
-0.0004429687,
0.0083110668,
0.0277642645,
-0.022944076,
-0.0389910117,
-0.0078818044,
0.0108025447,
0.0138489725,
0.0465303101,
0.0258393865,
0.004239663,
0.001358666,
0.0087757101,
0.0209123921,
-0.0500785336,
0.0075118924,
0.0328812115,
-0.0958215445,
0.0136601208,
-0.0100854468,
-0.0256091133,
-0.0223656073,
0.0192254633,
-0.0154557321,
0.0342120603,
0.0032657015,
0.0515495874,
0.050823424,
0.0160384905,
0.0262145996,
0.0389483646,
0.0163582284,
-0.0401703604,
0.0231500324,
-0.0445818081,
-0.0258969609,
0.0055775316,
-0.0511165485,
-0.0000921326,
0.0414159782,
0.0272153262,
0.0260706488,
-0.0370724015,
0.0516630597,
-0.0294649284,
-0.0003385322,
-0.0187508818,
-0.0083214836,
-0.0501903221,
0.0543326288,
0.0098014204,
-0.0886675492,
0.0350301899,
0.018468732,
0.0115033742,
-0.0178700015,
-0.0138179911,
0.0143161304,
0.0459625199,
0.0200730283,
-0.0016076883,
0.0608730353,
0.0195312556,
0.0347700529,
0.0092314165,
-0.0223040972,
-0.014626123,
0.0112050045,
-0.0357639976,
0.031627465,
0.028583413,
-0.0331541002,
-0.0210595634,
-0.0813706964,
-0.0866156444,
-0.0215830654,
-0.0031457213,
0.0003476936,
0.0001802309,
0.017898513,
-0.0153190335,
0.0348405764,
0.0078766076,
-0.0324410088,
0.0079732239,
0.0327251777,
0.0950523466,
-0.0364668109,
-0.0038256957,
0.0288046226,
0.0337761156,
0.062574707,
-0.0398731604,
0.0254711211,
-0.024334712,
0.0139989918,
-0.0053062802,
0.0026780888,
0.0042120246,
0.0298432633,
0.0597002432,
-0.0187846981,
-0.0030806118,
0.0922096372,
0.0216948371,
-0.0247084256,
0.0187108498,
0.0044303308,
-0.0121456757,
-0.0112087261,
0.014567635,
-0.1360614449,
-0.0351208076,
-0.0314784124,
0.0428612046,
-0.0643812269,
0.0248897262,
0.0181560945,
-0.0480798744,
0.0750693381,
-0.0065220199,
-0.0408047251,
0.0715067983,
-0.0598708875,
0.0210258868,
-0.0755132511,
0.0206387918,
-0.0822475404,
0.0233223531,
0.0065524979,
0.0367629491,
-0.0522542894,
-0.0669172481,
0.0182323977,
0.0035705788,
0.0788844079,
0.035582304,
0.0544036105,
0.0014935379,
-0.0442449488,
0.0185901634,
0.0414940268,
0.0004050467,
-0.01226159,
0.0935218409,
0.0039994926,
0.0286601726,
-0.0702129006,
0.0785088465,
-0.0550256856,
-0.0635091066,
-0.0014279711,
0.1056014672,
-0.020158587,
-0.0750896409,
-0.0226690751,
0.0466849394,
0.0439873226,
0.0583287776,
0.0347507186,
-0.0270579383,
-0.013123123,
-0.014332531,
0.041860722,
-0.0112249302,
-0.0290898327,
-0.0477339029,
0.0235180277,
-0.0489994846,
-0.0213801824,
-0.0589578971,
0.0139966644,
-0.0337179042,
0.00518151,
0.0386008695,
0.0063854069,
0.0210361108,
-0.0024912204,
0.0451866686,
0.0277049839,
0.0306594335,
-0.0333915614,
-0.0214349367,
0.0135279093,
0.0294944346,
-0.00863137,
0.0554426946,
-0.0680736452,
-0.0179138668,
0.0461113043,
0.054061871,
0.0288915988,
0.0210060123,
0.0042733792,
-0.0374523215,
0.0049701491,
0.0208352767,
-0.001774991,
-0.0252960771,
0.00749774,
0.0369910263,
0.0063619697,
0.0190563649,
0.0256161764,
0.0092748599,
-0.010033045,
0.0158790927,
-0.0887740031,
0.037635196,
0.0444656946,
0.0024651494,
0.0588352196,
-0.0420690402,
0.0323768482,
-0.0519809499,
-0.0264867581,
0.0431114547,
-0.0040350258,
-0.0245009754,
-0.0125541706,
0.022122873,
-0.022054771,
-0.0687604696,
-0.0124290325,
-0.0524341539,
-0.0253885649,
-0.092799224,
0.0052793506,
0.0431142263,
0.0611636601,
-0.0031448791,
-0.0235487297,
0.0065500853,
0.0162726305,
0.0053122928,
0.0134772528,
-0.0011398611,
0.0725869387,
-0.0117634302,
-0.024998771,
0.0320018344,
0.054631725,
-0.0257727634,
-0.0194823928,
0.0039238012,
0.033393845,
0.0100393575,
-0.0455712415,
0.0526248813,
-0.0252099261,
-0.0262219924,
-0.0084564332,
0.0555535592,
-0.0299286637,
-0.0190198049,
0.0089012953,
-0.0195764229,
-0.0468764231,
-0.0288844574,
0.0440999418,
-0.0345778987,
0.0231513511,
0.0092295809,
-0.0560729355,
-0.0391448922,
0.0132879196,
-0.0209592134,
0.0578725748,
-0.0471655764,
-0.0069533912,
-0.0613156743,
-0.0471600555,
0.003208572,
-0.0077467705,
0.0003523491,
0.0007434774,
0.012721654,
0.024218943,
-0.0265851729,
-0.0419013761,
-0.0272259545,
0.019012399,
-0.034880992,
0.0126635842,
-0.0510468073,
-5.964485519e-33,
0.003838361,
-0.0486027598,
0.0074326596,
0.0107158823,
-0.0173928682,
0.0115757231,
-0.0357572809,
0.0140760578,
0.0170419216,
0.0511039905,
-0.0039937729,
0.0019340607,
0.0222144779,
-0.0224439334,
0.0732915625,
-0.0534591712,
0.0185592957,
-0.0101707196,
-0.0402937979,
0.041100841,
0.054157719,
0.0396858379,
0.0355105363,
-0.0662746206,
0.0675766468,
0.0208527576,
-0.0098303398,
-0.0090973433,
-0.0434672497,
0.0492203608,
-0.0406695567,
0.0543560795,
0.052056063,
-0.0008079149,
0.0052327202,
0.0871947333,
-0.0253289398,
-0.0367815122,
0.0253743231,
-0.0444360711,
-0.0616059192,
-0.0217477977,
0.0167343765,
0.0019416565,
0.0095057907,
0.0287317,
0.0538667738,
-0.01760149,
0.0194844697,
0.0040033623,
-0.0511730164,
-0.0004813118,
-0.0131767355,
-0.0157583449,
-0.0056553232,
0.0691817403,
-0.0256098118,
0.0362200662,
-0.0764140189,
0.0424200818,
-0.0003378875,
-0.0037779857,
0.005549117,
0.0072154012,
-0.0058369068,
0.0450429916,
0.0082960334,
-0.0238505565,
-0.0472108349,
-0.0116198128,
-0.0153505635,
0.0188816376,
0.0146402912,
-0.0116738221,
0.0326809473,
-0.0005885892,
-0.0459243022,
0.0235326327,
-0.0030982152,
0.0050051478,
0.0092422497,
-0.0196365099,
-0.0282222591,
-0.0377762243,
0.0015633191,
-0.0447713137,
-0.0193671621,
-0.0246612914,
0.0158909522,
-0.0119714988,
0.0166605636,
0.0265030041,
-0.003767234,
-0.0321484692,
0.0001114089,
-0.0117075955,
0.0270559937,
0.0115526132,
-0.0149243902,
-0.0101442132,
-0.0485984571,
0.0357312411,
-0.0234931558,
0.0324479118,
0.0532927215,
-0.0263201408,
0.0563140102,
0.0051417584,
-0.0058373073,
-0.0280250702,
-0.0047087613,
0.0052918191,
-0.0220149811,
-0.0166073795,
0.0323472805,
0.0612855293,
0.0155878523,
0.0567130186,
0.0163298436,
0.0050472603,
-0.0298648868,
-0.056027323,
-0.0228656307,
-0.0391545594,
-0.011341474,
0.0091747604,
-0.0139397401,
0.0112781869,
0.0109764123,
-0.0654547065,
0.0141961332,
-0.0118772751,
2.66e-7,
0.0863387808,
0.0299162809,
-0.0049487748,
-0.0137827452,
-0.0229589641,
0.0006252904,
0.0057534967,
0.001133095,
0.0115245953,
0.0118061537,
0.067543596,
-0.0119111324,
0.0227550752,
0.0379248783,
-0.0609894916,
-0.0067003923,
-0.0686050951,
-0.0004940646,
-0.0720958635,
0.0411904268,
0.0597211719,
0.053970553,
0.0054665236,
-0.0327980369,
0.0121667031,
0.0449915119,
0.0315962471,
-0.0708951205,
0.0177355781,
-0.0010020371,
0.0241822284,
-0.0591700226,
-0.0117954565,
0.0079490272,
-0.0158641022,
-0.0146894595,
-0.0020384877,
0.0721392408,
-0.0066952948,
-0.0097792847,
-0.010835235,
0.0001499292,
0.0207041632,
-0.0301571917,
0.0634065941,
-0.0902621821,
-0.0441504903,
0.0023310876,
-0.0069865952,
-0.0221922603,
0.0564481877,
-0.0341800377,
-0.0396604836,
-0.0027525106,
-0.0126054361,
0.0229080692,
-0.0168128107,
-0.0187078547,
-0.0024826801,
-0.021962557,
-0.0369547419,
-0.0184556916,
-0.0189395323,
-0.0216550995,
-0.0285419151,
-0.0363022983,
0.0105165523,
1.786442731e-34,
-0.0133490684,
0.0082432777,
-0.0008044587,
-0.0404525176,
0.0311869513,
0.0105738034,
0.0336900912,
0.0177519694,
0.0081388792,
-0.0739793479,
-0.017654784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20098v1 | Web2Code: A Large-scale Webpage-to-Code Dataset and Evaluation Framework for Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:59:46 | 2024-06-28T17:59:46 | Sukmin Yun, Haokun Lin, Rusiru Thushara, Mohammad Qazim Bhat, Yongxin Wang, Zutao Jiang, Mingkai Deng, Jinhong Wang, Tianhua Tao, Junbo Li, Haonan Li, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin, Zhengzhong Liu, Eric P. Xing, Xiaodan Liang, Zhiqiang Shen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown impressive success across
modalities such as image, video, and audio in a variety of understanding and
generation tasks. However, current MLLMs are surprisingly poor at understanding
webpage screenshots and generating their corresponding HTML code. To address
this problem, we propose Web2Code, a benchmark consisting of a new large-scale
webpage-to-code dataset for instruction tuning and an evaluation framework for
the webpage understanding and HTML code translation abilities of MLLMs. For
dataset construction, we leverage pretrained LLMs to enhance existing
webpage-to-code datasets as well as generate a diverse pool of new webpages
rendered into images. Specifically, the inputs are webpage images and
instructions, while the responses are the webpage's HTML code. We further
include diverse natural language QA pairs about the webpage content in the
responses to enable a more comprehensive understanding of the web content. To
evaluate model performance in these tasks, we develop an evaluation framework
for testing MLLMs' abilities in webpage understanding and web-to-code
generation. Extensive experiments show that our proposed dataset is beneficial
not only to our proposed tasks but also in the general visual domain, while
previous datasets result in worse performance. We hope our work will contribute
to the development of general MLLMs suitable for web-based content generation
and task automation. Our data and code will be available at
https://github.com/MBZUAI-LLM/web2code. | [
0.0037844288,
0.06467776,
0.0098513663,
0.0371963196,
-0.0038021314,
0.0438879468,
0.0177648254,
0.0053312457,
0.014355775,
-0.0513300784,
-0.0563260242,
-0.0336837359,
-0.0091236429,
0.0330938287,
0.0535255633,
-0.0337887295,
-0.0099678896,
-0.0399961732,
-0.0515163355,
0.0267924666,
0.007138086,
0.032286834,
-0.0190088078,
0.030013511,
-0.0062728864,
-0.035457857,
-0.016828768,
0.0684859753,
0.0331360027,
-0.0496073812,
0.0075251008,
0.0227467045,
0.0612778515,
-0.0202020798,
0.0000017668,
-0.0156962071,
0.0101018697,
-0.0192673784,
0.0097501157,
-0.003906535,
0.0176518913,
-0.0275415797,
-0.0263179075,
0.0206635408,
-0.0561501235,
0.0295480769,
0.0533599071,
0.0133410366,
0.0948687047,
0.1018520147,
-0.0120693296,
-0.0079758354,
0.010890346,
-0.005831724,
0.0528025478,
-0.022056764,
-0.0040445374,
0.0259462148,
0.0033219093,
-0.0021035867,
-0.0186604392,
0.0215070751,
0.0153572205,
-0.0336454324,
-0.0118232705,
0.0416712724,
0.0119421547,
-0.0610353611,
-0.0280043259,
0.0933722183,
-0.043114379,
0.0116765751,
0.0031697359,
0.0079754256,
-0.0031188298,
-0.0201804899,
-0.0691983178,
0.0605733283,
-0.0197712798,
0.0219133291,
-0.0504704341,
-0.0379005335,
0.0117355203,
0.0009340719,
-0.0196369924,
-0.0109679485,
0.0156809092,
-0.0073038829,
-0.041555468,
0.0220829602,
0.0212312825,
-0.0499372408,
0.0203622002,
0.0726211593,
0.0132419514,
0.0254204068,
-0.0536105372,
-0.0317588933,
-0.0078461422,
-0.036285717,
0.0711648762,
0.020783864,
-0.055595208,
0.0410739854,
-0.0753954053,
0.048768349,
-0.0064647058,
0.0121757146,
-0.027945416,
0.0330740251,
-0.0576567836,
0.0200339686,
-0.0176380649,
0.0057657156,
-0.0336521752,
-0.0127944788,
-0.0133005083,
0.0707537979,
0.004301283,
0.0680454299,
-0.001116849,
-0.0114489319,
-0.0527464896,
0.0084005315,
0.0086470172,
0.0133202607,
0.0009007797,
-0.0008374368,
0.0199982915,
-0.0973583385,
-0.0062489165,
0.0441051647,
0.0252918378,
-0.0191908684,
0.0010688623,
0.1043677777,
-0.0330216959,
-0.0027616946,
-0.0490104742,
-0.0203475691,
-0.018990567,
-0.0170056503,
0.0473729819,
-0.0720470846,
0.0413867943,
0.0046121343,
-0.0011380119,
-0.0405988172,
0.0075043966,
0.0119018927,
0.0284099877,
0.0654282644,
-0.0320624411,
0.0030829613,
0.0212275553,
0.0170008708,
-0.0246612169,
0.0629137903,
0.0428072736,
0.0718336478,
0.0309940986,
-0.0186760277,
0.0057372502,
0.0545553975,
0.0125386007,
0.0177157689,
-0.0051022884,
0.0290223416,
0.037595395,
0.0217361301,
0.069342725,
0.0120266685,
-0.0254364181,
0.0140270665,
0.0840077251,
-0.0014687362,
0.0011278096,
0.0224276315,
0.0727838948,
0.0298563205,
0.0171784125,
0.0026193394,
-0.0503307842,
0.0599915236,
-0.0189114306,
0.0271028075,
0.0075614625,
0.0402605571,
-0.0332804397,
-0.0371622406,
-0.0045419894,
-0.0273985006,
0.0115222437,
0.0125089269,
0.0376802497,
0.0170724727,
-0.0689456612,
0.0142072672,
-0.0067824465,
-0.0619363412,
0.0319155604,
-0.0523698516,
0.0117145814,
0.0824643448,
0.0111343097,
-0.0130609516,
-0.0616854243,
-0.0210526437,
0.0249518715,
0.0369350612,
0.0137226824,
-0.0151794143,
0.0183947179,
-0.0453011468,
-0.0485430025,
-0.0653717145,
-0.0259820875,
0.0091614332,
0.0248051956,
-0.0120912073,
0.0320815556,
-0.0112307575,
-0.0194060951,
0.0513625629,
0.0141271949,
-0.0023038345,
-0.0289586391,
-0.0113126114,
0.0187984724,
-0.0186450575,
-0.0326134041,
-0.0066342112,
-0.0008606874,
-0.0353928804,
0.0057123168,
-0.0229611229,
-0.0225146282,
-0.0545347929,
0.0360318273,
-0.0672733039,
-0.0141093815,
0.038543731,
-0.0733383447,
-0.0014664939,
0.0086963875,
-0.0270517506,
-0.0049901251,
-0.0255848058,
-0.0110071478,
0.0446459092,
0.0242510308,
-0.0151172401,
0.031994354,
0.011849192,
-0.0251780674,
0.01430408,
0.0189345162,
-0.0277714022,
-0.0109469257,
-0.0045907679,
-0.0051080734,
-0.0312475264,
0.0220372137,
0.000789256,
0.0655213594,
-0.0816982836,
-0.034199547,
-0.1010591686,
0.0085144024,
-0.0084279953,
0.0188263748,
0.0370075144,
0.0196855757,
0.0021499621,
-0.0305534378,
-0.0539095029,
0.0140629401,
-0.0121396556,
0.0182327535,
0.0287228581,
-0.0096606091,
-0.0065937126,
-0.0426459946,
-0.0134547725,
0.0113985213,
0.0434031375,
0.0050943824,
0.0000123852,
-0.0557546914,
0.0480250418,
-0.0314595327,
-0.0048591397,
-0.0163524933,
-0.0440262035,
0.0334018804,
-0.0382428952,
0.0395746604,
0.0907139555,
0.0256504733,
0.0392777063,
0.0268737134,
-0.0088318009,
-0.0467497036,
0.0088121295,
0.0173899923,
-0.0563263483,
-0.0468556844,
-0.0440349691,
0.0148111852,
0.0725588053,
0.0078036198,
0.0175044984,
-0.0290978234,
0.0187466256,
-0.0013140067,
-0.0105058476,
-0.0159920678,
0.0257152878,
0.002131481,
0.055804871,
-0.0484026484,
-0.0785584152,
0.0298548825,
-0.0476660766,
-0.0198119264,
0.0235118996,
0.0157559682,
-0.0273760892,
0.0380669646,
0.0032614027,
0.044565361,
-0.0300311372,
-0.0116504878,
-0.0503499545,
0.0179223157,
0.0100718457,
-0.0298377126,
0.0541766211,
-0.0610639229,
0.0088221077,
-0.0575446822,
-0.0331136324,
-0.0365112163,
0.0302072633,
0.0079442235,
-0.0317744203,
-0.0119360071,
-0.0094158435,
0.0170297287,
0.0086313486,
0.0114879273,
0.0293020718,
-0.003208118,
-0.0307233427,
-0.0285118986,
0.0221997071,
0.0316942707,
0.0122760721,
-0.0267045237,
-0.053402178,
0.0141875613,
0.0315737016,
0.0182397477,
0.0086491378,
-0.0719439387,
0.0407192707,
0.0208906028,
0.0023592045,
-0.0075254338,
0.0508204624,
0.0693003163,
-0.068426609,
-0.0103321047,
0.0996523276,
0.017384991,
-0.0421953686,
-0.0253216419,
0.0026134814,
0.0069154929,
0.0383050255,
0.0073893159,
-0.0873808041,
-0.0346983224,
-0.0091516143,
0.0119358357,
0.0426002592,
-0.0013784691,
-0.001517833,
-0.0685875639,
0.0453145616,
0.0198810082,
0.0037428306,
-0.0357198603,
-0.0202650037,
0.002203404,
0.0169558395,
-0.0005158327,
0.024316946,
-0.0286488365,
-0.0091235982,
0.0088712936,
0.0049345889,
-0.0535961911,
-0.0034127024,
-0.0189415086,
0.0128176073,
0.0727498531,
0.0283335112,
0.0320337638,
-0.0227424968,
0.0319339186,
-0.0059727528,
-0.0006715928,
-0.0349628553,
0.0460750982,
-0.0083125122,
-0.0264226943,
0.0207866076,
0.0380556919,
-0.0436096117,
-0.0008477335,
0.0180160869,
0.0308384411,
-0.0366323069,
-0.0155477803,
-0.0393525064,
-0.0042032921,
-0.0115927774,
0.0533350855,
0.0604323037,
-0.0339441225,
-0.0585517362,
-0.0365117677,
-0.0224383734,
-0.082813181,
0.0175678805,
0.010283988,
-0.0057299612,
0.0137987752,
-0.0893298835,
-0.0241346899,
0.0296858884,
0.0322063789,
-0.0019769687,
-0.0512232184,
0.0024649168,
0.0228511468,
-0.0726093948,
0.0288293324,
-0.031934265,
0.0072941128,
-0.0499078967,
-0.029414054,
0.0407850817,
-0.0803769827,
0.0002164098,
0.024263937,
-0.120668076,
-0.0177055001,
-0.0559404381,
0.0443229824,
0.014563377,
0.0634265915,
0.0166687667,
-0.022777589,
-0.0147034423,
-0.004875164,
-0.041497197,
-0.0150657361,
0.0285898224,
0.0571517348,
0.003498594,
0.002994149,
-0.0774265602,
0.0252010338,
-0.0002632748,
0.026104439,
0.0125936614,
-0.022632692,
0.0318011083,
0.0013684329,
-0.0273003932,
-0.0168099646,
-0.0073399181,
-0.0016241197,
0.0150564965,
0.0013363528,
-0.0147381006,
-0.0721395016,
0.0091663431,
0.0405878387,
-0.0031395936,
0.0157787725,
-0.0029732157,
0.0254748501,
0.0330627002,
-0.0354800113,
0.0376545526,
0.0091794105,
-0.0016191642,
0.0436329618,
0.0097709307,
-0.0065887324,
0.0232656263,
-0.0085666953,
0.0131371478,
-0.0035790817,
0.0549315587,
0.0194173921,
-0.00186271,
0.0107035814,
0.0562189221,
-0.012211469,
-0.0454331487,
-0.0456973054,
0.006370876,
0.0618322752,
0.0410891287,
0.0712174624,
0.0022398694,
0.0052561914,
-0.023318978,
0.0598920062,
-0.0163565706,
-0.037846256,
0.0367436409,
0.0045522405,
0.0244360659,
-0.0260906462,
0.090100497,
0.0026981127,
0.0159868561,
0.0010565401,
0.0162323136,
-0.0602299385,
-0.014897476,
0.0424448252,
-0.0163675565,
0.0191131849,
-0.0347094201,
0.0367640108,
-0.0833661333,
-0.0030191552,
0.0459817499,
-0.0035000006,
0.0230763033,
0.0462088622,
0.0676536337,
-0.0033283182,
0.0061574969,
-0.0160544142,
0.0085868184,
0.0225998256,
-0.0247811098,
-0.0167100672,
-5.421562515e-33,
-0.0519614257,
-0.0302914511,
0.0417493954,
0.0208940879,
-0.0273336917,
-0.0009405935,
-0.048410669,
-0.0248663593,
0.002744084,
-0.03712653,
0.0330154113,
-0.0084011266,
0.0024568776,
0.0538469851,
0.0026093102,
-0.0218688529,
0.0470984727,
-0.0109186433,
-0.0353960879,
0.0533938073,
-0.0196459498,
0.0263668951,
0.0411043987,
0.0010850329,
-0.023503013,
-0.0098088328,
-0.0410620123,
-0.0050709895,
0.028757466,
0.0625396073,
-0.0126150232,
0.0244289339,
0.0328487419,
0.0015041339,
-0.0324919187,
0.0237642862,
-0.0882236436,
-0.0091612684,
-0.0105538694,
0.0369032808,
-0.0474015959,
-0.0390663259,
0.0638130382,
-0.0420854986,
-0.0118692378,
-0.0443332866,
0.0592116527,
-0.0298693571,
0.0136695579,
-0.0516008027,
-0.0589407831,
0.0086545572,
-0.0416728407,
-0.0477905944,
0.0232237689,
0.0658210441,
0.0111744562,
0.0345407426,
-0.033881247,
0.0259877387,
-0.0044629714,
0.0511820875,
0.1137911305,
0.0226568952,
0.007948936,
0.0390132405,
0.024365576,
-0.0214614514,
0.0031435627,
0.0241497662,
0.0482992791,
0.0695801005,
0.0117568243,
0.0089619523,
-0.0278812274,
0.0256370027,
-0.0477253236,
0.0456529893,
-0.0102267526,
0.0452555083,
0.0151336277,
0.019470159,
0.0195804778,
0.0224864911,
-0.0334378183,
0.0045038317,
-0.0379396826,
-0.0366743803,
0.0659069568,
0.0089401379,
-0.0056801043,
-0.0291034859,
0.0578819215,
-0.0340976976,
-0.0103852432,
0.0243511237,
-0.053538695,
0.0588088445,
-0.0085151261,
-0.0142064309,
0.006999495,
-0.0548687503,
0.0631725565,
-0.0176596697,
0.0357154496,
0.0135979541,
0.0179360993,
0.029831076,
-0.041171547,
-0.0056274482,
-0.088022545,
0.0138064222,
0.0037959493,
0.0424724035,
0.0358796939,
-0.0428801924,
-0.0635780096,
0.0263230503,
-0.0175338704,
-0.0216825977,
-0.0342341326,
-0.0379109867,
-0.0106548993,
0.0207433831,
-0.0708446503,
-0.002127684,
-0.0514447317,
0.0072022658,
0.0035903475,
-0.0865072757,
-0.0315030031,
0.0368425213,
2.439e-7,
0.0120090591,
0.0375182256,
0.0134911863,
0.049378369,
0.0380028598,
0.0252746772,
-0.0482262447,
0.0117344055,
0.0133772148,
-0.0400377624,
-0.0014198661,
0.0551782623,
0.0377468616,
0.0084063383,
-0.0228067059,
0.0256263986,
-0.0212739706,
0.0207458418,
-0.0469091646,
0.0304251462,
0.0676234588,
0.0585421361,
-0.0517462008,
-0.0305965859,
0.0684997886,
-0.0105488095,
0.0525023714,
-0.0281726494,
-0.0016031086,
0.0207471121,
-0.010248567,
0.030866053,
-0.0242950264,
-0.0024465309,
-0.010001855,
-0.0449898243,
0.0251953769,
0.0536056682,
0.0042519746,
-0.0012251618,
-0.004051364,
-0.0252422355,
0.0062116007,
-0.0679446161,
0.0568095706,
-0.0226819478,
-0.0140692461,
-0.018933842,
-0.0277910084,
-0.0482819267,
-0.0314965695,
-0.0485009477,
0.0221835654,
0.0160350706,
0.0217656232,
-0.0195608083,
-0.0512520298,
-0.0489415228,
-0.0299742278,
-0.0051690899,
-0.0341840088,
-0.0193832852,
-0.0821465328,
0.0203792006,
0.0195997767,
-0.02304429,
-0.0476236269,
2.034507051e-34,
0.0002909983,
-0.0326991379,
0.0097454805,
0.0194867291,
0.0357748568,
0.0096256286,
-0.0570754781,
0.0022264901,
-0.0232407898,
-0.0663948655,
-0.0163619742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20095v1 | LLaRA: Supercharging Robot Learning Data for Vision-Language Policy | 2024-06-28T17:59:12 | 2024-06-28T17:59:12 | Xiang Li, Cristina Mata, Jongwoo Park, Kumara Kahatapitiya, Yoo Sung Jang, Jinghuan Shang, Kanchana Ranasinghe, Ryan Burgert, Mu Cai, Yong Jae Lee, Michael S. Ryoo | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) equipped with extensive world knowledge and
strong reasoning skills can tackle diverse tasks across domains, often by
posing them as conversation-style instruction-response pairs. In this paper, we
propose LLaRA: Large Language and Robotics Assistant, a framework which
formulates robot action policy as conversations, and provides improved
responses when trained with auxiliary data that complements policy learning.
LLMs with visual inputs, i.e., Vision Language Models (VLMs), have the capacity
to process state information as visual-textual prompts and generate optimal
policy decisions in text. To train such action policy VLMs, we first introduce
an automated pipeline to generate diverse high-quality robotics instruction
data from existing behavior cloning data. A VLM finetuned with the resulting
collection of datasets based on a conversation-style formulation tailored for
robotics tasks, can generate meaningful robot action policy decisions. Our
experiments across multiple simulated and real-world environments demonstrate
the state-of-the-art performance of the proposed LLaRA framework. The code,
datasets, and pretrained models are available at
https://github.com/LostXine/LLaRA. | [
0.0294572413,
0.0498532094,
-0.0016918809,
0.0144192763,
-0.034154173,
0.0271615293,
-0.0056950641,
-0.0274050832,
0.0471867099,
-0.062614955,
-0.0208076481,
-0.0148283839,
-0.0130831823,
0.0671683401,
0.0166121814,
-0.0523755215,
0.0198280141,
-0.0737453178,
0.0306161866,
0.0028197095,
0.0146333724,
0.0055979122,
-0.0312301591,
0.0680586621,
-0.0231961422,
0.0177291948,
-0.0273980256,
-0.0165546499,
0.0406016447,
-0.0334845148,
-0.0063671106,
-0.0218270607,
0.0983084589,
-0.0097616492,
0.0000019033,
-0.0460355096,
0.0287368745,
-0.0264183935,
0.0291506294,
-0.0461807437,
0.0171776451,
-0.0270372182,
0.0213061403,
0.0369998068,
-0.0488490425,
-0.0082180034,
0.0401630625,
0.0328790806,
0.08688315,
0.0725272372,
-0.0076810024,
-0.0400925241,
-0.0018608391,
-0.0028638658,
0.0171172153,
-0.0292458329,
0.024889525,
0.0491561219,
0.0433013737,
-0.0109224739,
-0.0505681932,
-0.0059832898,
0.0181249157,
-0.0620768331,
-0.0489200689,
0.0455696993,
0.012219171,
-0.0471538082,
-0.0130370762,
0.0835809112,
-0.0115505653,
-0.0063196681,
0.002546377,
0.0001393336,
0.0021829945,
-0.0148014063,
-0.0271474756,
0.0584041029,
0.0053181746,
0.0170808174,
-0.0372551382,
-0.0262262691,
-0.0006930468,
-0.0020588441,
-0.0163879097,
0.0356520601,
-0.0249249507,
0.0116055654,
0.0108077824,
-0.0096088452,
0.0055419924,
-0.0692494139,
-0.0138390223,
0.0766288936,
-0.0585856922,
0.0179332718,
-0.0449340865,
0.0432219282,
-0.009469091,
0.0112715662,
0.049962841,
0.0598065555,
-0.0201261006,
0.0407445394,
-0.0066449773,
0.0901698098,
-0.0184197128,
0.0453900062,
-0.0198223069,
-0.0113188196,
-0.0696511045,
0.0120951841,
-0.0311907586,
0.0063111023,
-0.0428415723,
-0.0442637131,
-0.0053566,
0.0311866198,
-0.0368991494,
0.0396151878,
-0.0324799083,
0.0189737435,
-0.0087872213,
-0.0175805576,
-0.066295594,
-0.0005047598,
-0.0012624612,
0.0379495397,
0.0052035577,
-0.0195753407,
-0.0195678417,
0.0254729073,
0.0100048073,
0.0009644614,
0.0162717719,
0.1158510968,
-0.0174865257,
-0.0244651884,
0.0052777412,
0.020927364,
0.0182887297,
-0.0495830365,
0.0265527796,
-0.0533721931,
0.0301056318,
-0.0295662135,
-0.0055139014,
-0.0547234938,
0.0071064387,
-0.0038357805,
0.0047344649,
0.0925128162,
0.0095189055,
0.0082419096,
0.0043769283,
0.0028063389,
0.0040350808,
0.0506692156,
0.0356049351,
0.0221637432,
-0.0030880531,
0.0227107015,
0.042195417,
0.0303160809,
-0.0292402469,
0.0142847244,
-0.0295203291,
0.0094108544,
0.0158108938,
0.0342241377,
0.0517786816,
0.0125730708,
-0.0512856729,
-0.001143271,
0.0466279201,
0.0372381806,
-0.0628264397,
-0.0259223264,
0.0523866341,
0.0226409398,
0.0160157736,
-0.04951239,
-0.0539956838,
0.0437142663,
0.031320747,
0.0043309024,
-0.0525229163,
-0.0003654618,
-0.0495371409,
-0.0355423763,
0.0266885329,
-0.0205857512,
0.0350759886,
0.0283052139,
0.0164483692,
0.0233790092,
-0.0517545082,
-0.0218138713,
0.0091382666,
-0.0318874978,
-0.0176760647,
-0.0315247066,
0.0527171791,
0.070220381,
0.0174579546,
-0.0210738014,
-0.0185291842,
-0.0306622274,
0.0356381088,
0.0380169936,
-0.0258703195,
-0.0278871171,
0.0671257377,
-0.0510097332,
-0.0557733886,
-0.0181628428,
-0.0085912803,
0.0201502256,
0.0153159173,
-0.0035712321,
-0.0097888038,
0.0261060074,
-0.0260814801,
0.0559505373,
0.0033214793,
0.0124770701,
-0.0022385032,
-0.01429033,
0.0384447202,
-0.0204807185,
-0.0244000573,
-0.0203693863,
0.0332708173,
-0.0237719845,
0.0198689997,
0.0164270699,
-0.0252622757,
-0.0149316071,
0.0510249659,
-0.0376896821,
-0.0449019857,
0.048327174,
-0.0474602319,
-0.0064672227,
-0.0321752205,
-0.0334390439,
-0.0016876953,
-0.0078969998,
-0.0007042544,
0.0079299677,
-0.02700077,
-0.0232224781,
0.0048520747,
-0.016336944,
-0.0381890312,
0.0500653312,
0.0314199775,
-0.0037032401,
-0.0500726067,
0.0057303309,
0.0071605169,
0.0061607561,
-0.0010574948,
0.0316697694,
0.0657385662,
-0.042656716,
-0.001127625,
-0.0275104754,
-0.0430434644,
-0.0114072384,
-0.038826976,
-0.015157518,
-0.0258150622,
-0.0149697103,
-0.0338838883,
0.0014817459,
0.0366254151,
0.0138864284,
-0.0041906657,
0.0337402895,
0.0257092547,
-0.0364062712,
-0.0568233617,
0.0298286937,
0.0278823748,
-0.0022098429,
0.0242328998,
-0.0040274062,
-0.0692430586,
0.0551833101,
-0.0368565433,
0.0655613616,
-0.0636662096,
-0.0729893968,
0.0549807139,
-0.0434527099,
0.0277691521,
0.0937972888,
-0.0053860652,
0.0107234986,
0.0754176602,
0.0115291411,
-0.0538322888,
0.0183533039,
-0.034444198,
-0.0451745614,
-0.0702485368,
0.0211899001,
-0.0119355172,
0.0179754905,
-0.035406597,
0.0350112319,
-0.0669710636,
0.004455321,
0.0086318906,
-0.074930124,
-0.0189026315,
0.0036158729,
-0.0446802117,
0.0173696242,
-0.0366983004,
-0.073353909,
0.0341767631,
-0.0081729144,
-0.0177964885,
0.0122545725,
-0.0124400491,
-0.0017691876,
0.0852826685,
0.0539498441,
0.0116990581,
-0.0260371044,
-0.0130773326,
-0.0336814336,
-0.0465752035,
-0.001035115,
0.0147984438,
0.0267238785,
-0.0925372317,
0.0192784499,
0.004466183,
-0.0352348946,
-0.0471244901,
0.027490003,
-0.0444028713,
0.0085834526,
-0.0633327141,
-0.0597389862,
-0.0134363435,
-0.0194360651,
0.0443832092,
0.0438313223,
0.018919386,
-0.0111938603,
-0.0416413881,
-0.0264051035,
0.0873733461,
0.0341856554,
-0.0572320446,
-0.0209211037,
0.0119750844,
0.0398368984,
0.0405827127,
-0.012599837,
-0.0620986931,
0.0200193152,
0.0129292281,
0.0341881849,
0.0512189865,
0.0440910459,
0.0520417392,
-0.0329128206,
-0.0377502069,
0.0763125196,
0.0051023923,
-0.0173825733,
-0.0059775268,
0.008579541,
0.0424866118,
0.0311382115,
0.0260378607,
-0.0405396894,
-0.0410696939,
-0.0011076053,
0.004746418,
0.0043276101,
-0.0293551516,
-0.0297706593,
-0.1185308993,
0.0241036844,
-0.0123157585,
-0.0393415317,
-0.0802978799,
-0.0003913317,
0.022139512,
-0.0384275839,
-0.0319288597,
-0.0066092154,
-0.0221850835,
0.000961306,
0.0095939478,
-0.0017593212,
-0.0271441545,
0.0268285871,
-0.0292135756,
0.0149826398,
0.0562381633,
0.0129135353,
0.0003203774,
0.0022560298,
0.0028727655,
0.0287244525,
-0.0071767932,
-0.0140527785,
0.0094792536,
-0.0436670966,
-0.0311060119,
0.0213470738,
0.0685618967,
0.0012840703,
-0.0481457449,
-0.0020287894,
0.023358766,
-0.0576601811,
-0.0062677427,
-0.0108756954,
0.0100954408,
0.0483645424,
0.0518079847,
0.0102701951,
-0.0314102285,
-0.0374532714,
-0.0261886176,
-0.0703760535,
-0.0339363627,
-0.0495725945,
-0.0156850386,
0.0108459741,
0.0187950898,
-0.0568632036,
-0.0449114628,
0.0639298484,
0.0357982926,
0.0057949722,
-0.0707534403,
0.0288064275,
0.0323076881,
-0.0313977227,
0.0283384621,
-0.0524514243,
0.0317735858,
-0.0264760107,
-0.0237810872,
0.023971213,
-0.0145635772,
-0.0247742943,
0.0260905381,
-0.0362174325,
-0.0662466139,
-0.0053554298,
0.1047768444,
0.0172205996,
0.0615094937,
0.0222051591,
-0.0206604414,
0.0414585173,
0.0509020314,
0.0024442356,
0.0148716364,
0.0309303589,
0.0099549955,
0.0122120995,
0.0306893513,
-0.0399430618,
0.005550263,
-0.0076505393,
0.011660818,
-0.0267390981,
-0.0284038782,
0.0290226378,
-0.0243995171,
0.0097220782,
-0.0194206052,
0.0170718487,
-0.0357252769,
-0.0012770061,
-0.0255441871,
0.0080419425,
-0.0890413597,
0.0141832223,
0.0264123492,
-0.0014091436,
0.041237548,
0.0071638739,
-0.0124332374,
0.0326525159,
0.0148263825,
0.0115976315,
0.03645036,
0.0327282585,
0.0217930302,
0.0129743256,
0.000332825,
-0.0049976879,
-0.0201055203,
0.02812404,
0.0212422963,
0.0776672438,
0.0593530014,
-0.0063885446,
-0.014664636,
0.0318062976,
-0.0469320118,
-0.1119036898,
0.0201916732,
0.0214497987,
0.0425414443,
-0.0097185522,
0.0203152876,
-0.0802146792,
-0.0026108786,
-0.0099484278,
0.0730418637,
0.0045804144,
-0.0406935513,
0.0773408264,
0.0229590405,
-0.0025663585,
0.0025201123,
0.0682186112,
0.0247378666,
0.0626811609,
-0.0024916502,
0.0299309976,
-0.0327670723,
-0.0588182472,
0.0415753871,
-0.0004610636,
0.0223226547,
-0.0062506795,
0.008092205,
-0.0506509505,
-0.0579301305,
0.0382706076,
-0.0365183279,
0.0042272336,
0.0797209591,
0.0045623379,
0.000302208,
-0.0177097786,
-0.0288755987,
-0.0252415873,
0.0066018482,
-0.0164880194,
-0.0327850021,
-5.006291218e-33,
0.0037848197,
-0.0456253327,
0.0627796724,
-0.0059609758,
-0.0233705584,
-0.0219766647,
-0.0256346259,
-0.0298603065,
-0.0348220468,
0.0359618925,
0.0281878226,
0.0197949018,
0.0058566807,
0.0369936824,
-0.0007862347,
-0.0188305844,
0.0242492296,
-0.0013512608,
-0.0264114831,
0.0157172997,
0.0336008705,
-0.0126865711,
0.0154102892,
-0.0572076328,
-0.003267122,
0.0026737938,
-0.0413427949,
0.043732021,
0.0219633654,
0.0664964467,
-0.0043042409,
0.0074918075,
-0.0007868353,
-0.0099450154,
-0.0338262245,
0.0524455756,
-0.0503749549,
-0.0363477655,
0.0084087811,
0.0040510222,
-0.079802908,
-0.0008950856,
-0.0074343737,
-0.016794093,
-0.0035775809,
-0.0102982,
0.0250391867,
-0.017599443,
-0.0078518288,
0.0637858063,
-0.0358002111,
-0.0170707479,
-0.0182498693,
-0.0594019182,
0.0350965969,
0.0506203584,
0.0136693753,
0.0243163891,
-0.0122887772,
0.0337040871,
-0.0216851998,
-0.0084972288,
0.0568635575,
0.0355256423,
0.0484546311,
0.0654565766,
-0.0063401014,
-0.0406792238,
-0.0001915829,
0.0076163681,
0.0058046924,
0.0617768429,
0.0008361668,
0.0722587183,
-0.0452691875,
-0.0137159172,
-0.0505194217,
0.0101815788,
-0.0219018739,
0.1039994806,
-0.023828283,
0.0168403294,
-0.0098561998,
-0.0009003191,
-0.0267319847,
0.0248438474,
0.007482517,
-0.0062077725,
0.0623381436,
0.0350928567,
0.0121951373,
-0.0003642467,
0.0627045333,
-0.0327750407,
-0.0091601005,
0.0408168472,
-0.0483894721,
0.0103913592,
0.002078336,
0.0075431061,
-0.0612369068,
-0.0541792028,
0.051346764,
-0.0087184021,
0.0088616507,
0.0137092611,
0.0148385828,
0.0730683133,
-0.0353545696,
0.0041951444,
-0.0409425832,
0.0290045142,
0.0199298579,
0.0110818902,
0.0175782535,
0.0188807026,
-0.0340765044,
0.0657049343,
-0.0328224152,
-0.0570027977,
0.0000692055,
-0.0320834182,
-0.0241815485,
0.0225655567,
-0.0398887806,
-0.0001928466,
-0.0691921636,
0.0148352077,
-0.00779681,
-0.045225475,
0.0099407369,
0.016594613,
2.473e-7,
-0.0183410812,
0.0131250974,
0.0277708732,
0.0628852248,
0.0171341971,
0.0633986369,
-0.0143977562,
0.0468223169,
0.011353422,
-0.0302813184,
0.014949508,
0.0561352521,
0.0113962106,
-0.0372333378,
-0.0573927946,
0.0000233896,
-0.0150313862,
-0.0845724642,
-0.0650588647,
-0.0103135547,
0.058195658,
0.0842366219,
-0.019906709,
-0.0052206721,
0.0659679547,
-0.0469042994,
0.0598802939,
-0.0566689111,
-0.009484889,
-0.0152981803,
-0.0254940595,
0.0135475146,
-0.0011242627,
-0.0045293863,
-0.0111611811,
-0.0166772418,
-0.0452011526,
0.0703058243,
-0.0205862746,
-0.0197662152,
-0.0180597007,
0.0398368612,
-0.0135162538,
-0.0505515411,
0.0662210286,
-0.0659414232,
-0.0028287622,
-0.0010125756,
0.0087472014,
-0.0161309242,
-0.004507632,
-0.0100453356,
-0.0298867133,
0.0074283816,
0.0175702088,
-0.0031824252,
-0.002724322,
-0.0619701855,
0.0166417826,
-0.0538115911,
-0.031962242,
-0.0136842076,
-0.0217331424,
0.003666678,
0.0148742581,
-0.0359868258,
-0.0231924206,
1.663225898e-34,
-0.0108615542,
-0.0139066968,
0.0106044514,
0.0207711011,
0.0013757985,
0.0191322733,
-0.0104625504,
0.0334709994,
0.0442208238,
-0.0340246521,
-0.022693567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20094v1 | Scaling Synthetic Data Creation with 1,000,000,000 Personas | 2024-06-28T17:59:01 | 2024-06-28T17:59:01 | Xin Chan, Xiaoyang Wang, Dian Yu, Haitao Mi, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose a novel persona-driven data synthesis methodology that leverages
various perspectives within a large language model (LLM) to create diverse
synthetic data. To fully exploit this methodology at scale, we introduce
Persona Hub -- a collection of 1 billion diverse personas automatically curated
from web data. These 1 billion personas (~13% of the world's total population),
acting as distributed carriers of world knowledge, can tap into almost every
perspective encapsulated within the LLM, thereby facilitating the creation of
diverse synthetic data at scale for various scenarios. By showcasing Persona
Hub's use cases in synthesizing high-quality mathematical and logical reasoning
problems, instructions (i.e., user prompts), knowledge-rich texts, game NPCs
and tools (functions) at scale, we demonstrate persona-driven data synthesis is
versatile, scalable, flexible, and easy to use, potentially driving a paradigm
shift in synthetic data creation and applications in practice, which may have a
profound impact on LLM research and development. | [
0.0230146386,
0.0607232824,
-0.0421759449,
0.0731378868,
0.008300296,
-0.0203855615,
0.0121331876,
-0.0244044363,
0.0321000069,
-0.0010886417,
0.0109553179,
-0.0249908324,
-0.014871289,
0.0523749068,
0.0340719447,
-0.06379769,
0.0395828746,
-0.0449489988,
-0.0158263799,
-0.0135236885,
-0.0267366674,
0.0428281836,
-0.0062976191,
0.0331027918,
-0.0284578111,
-0.0318122096,
-0.0113737257,
-0.0008172499,
0.0185551774,
-0.022957135,
-0.0262884032,
0.0299996808,
0.0169036631,
0.0296808369,
0.0000020975,
-0.0483466573,
-0.0008918106,
-0.0040391604,
-0.0371590853,
-0.0214286242,
0.0174418278,
0.058880467,
-0.0166983139,
0.0008069295,
-0.0603216067,
-0.0222048163,
0.0445073731,
-0.0129317157,
0.0795833692,
0.0590008423,
-0.0118541261,
-0.0500344746,
-0.0072381706,
0.0114877904,
0.0362351425,
-0.0081568593,
-0.00761658,
0.0137735009,
0.0443879887,
0.0063813785,
0.010204779,
0.0165291913,
0.0229192451,
-0.0051509812,
0.0167432129,
0.0257669818,
-0.0268984511,
-0.0038441701,
0.0160490684,
0.0839328691,
0.0195486825,
-0.0302320626,
0.0355700068,
0.0353071466,
0.0192566533,
0.0225842223,
-0.0103901504,
0.0325906426,
-0.0172504652,
0.0027043354,
0.002312795,
0.0004510579,
0.0310542472,
-0.0180370416,
-0.0469943695,
0.0285531599,
0.015100983,
0.0016069988,
-0.0654036403,
-0.0142857078,
-0.0176280737,
-0.0634977743,
-0.0161766913,
0.0274415985,
-0.071321249,
0.0098852543,
-0.0522333272,
-0.0106600961,
-0.0059805391,
-0.0347056799,
0.0299946368,
0.0305929463,
0.0296880417,
0.0437561497,
0.0133877834,
0.002612178,
-0.0126624359,
-0.0305771679,
-0.0018041318,
-0.0279436745,
-0.050561469,
-0.0052177971,
-0.0158880204,
0.0357864201,
-0.0443279557,
0.0053619156,
-0.0065918183,
0.0613566525,
-0.042272795,
0.0472386964,
0.0035752708,
0.0172274392,
-0.0089708585,
-0.0105087077,
-0.0522754453,
-0.0060254899,
-0.0652366057,
-0.0073991506,
-0.0218235459,
-0.0549184047,
0.0344624035,
-0.0091963354,
-0.0050566588,
0.0212705303,
0.041363813,
0.0888133273,
0.0166132674,
0.0164552722,
-0.0212549269,
-0.0752944276,
0.0353765488,
-0.0738962293,
-0.034639895,
-0.1157527044,
0.0535406917,
0.01228905,
0.0067292764,
-0.0657053515,
0.0061293491,
0.0179390814,
0.0083535593,
0.0773776397,
-0.0432201326,
0.0378448032,
0.0154733416,
-0.0014854303,
0.016030049,
0.0579964742,
0.050409168,
-0.0189822838,
0.0281838719,
-0.012615242,
0.01603535,
0.0364785269,
0.0095138513,
-0.0168339349,
0.0013619481,
0.008837169,
0.0107647805,
0.0319021195,
-0.0217392948,
0.0414242558,
-0.0490269773,
0.0094063943,
0.0638354048,
0.0426236503,
-0.0056357905,
0.0687751174,
0.0856240913,
0.0193369295,
0.0287452787,
-0.0578326993,
-0.0279217456,
0.0527844913,
0.0002342314,
-0.0179782789,
-0.0279307738,
0.0584740192,
-0.0064426782,
-0.0403864421,
0.0502792448,
-0.000958484,
-0.0529901534,
0.0400214791,
0.0215456132,
0.0206636675,
-0.0137500986,
0.0693434402,
0.0183828194,
-0.0886703506,
0.0138501497,
-0.0033145887,
0.0374645218,
0.112829864,
0.0508005172,
-0.0423701033,
-0.0271962788,
0.00036284,
-0.0142114004,
0.0624517165,
0.0537281334,
-0.0439464748,
-0.0236445796,
-0.034156099,
-0.0117194941,
-0.0184338931,
-0.0117538041,
0.0377377607,
0.0538152047,
0.0000805675,
-0.0030196842,
-0.0085304715,
0.0031088153,
-0.0085447524,
-0.091063112,
-0.0226913169,
-0.0001062236,
0.0109988898,
-0.0121174278,
0.0547046773,
0.0014463583,
0.0049727242,
0.0309918094,
-0.0361538604,
-0.0225208718,
0.0096067861,
0.0036154438,
0.0025520572,
0.0648726672,
-0.0840196535,
-0.0081389304,
-0.0034073996,
-0.0155444695,
-0.0169004537,
0.0198949594,
-0.0160194952,
0.007706529,
0.0019919658,
0.0134222293,
0.0043415604,
0.0251695514,
-0.0075243469,
0.054632023,
0.0083610043,
-0.004442533,
0.0279187635,
0.0283321459,
0.0112304436,
-0.0489886478,
0.0093686245,
-0.0049524861,
-0.0058610504,
0.0278973021,
-0.0021262441,
-0.0064561763,
-0.0563659929,
-0.0207309239,
-0.1031684428,
0.0147617674,
0.0296794251,
-0.003343435,
0.01953936,
0.0251715947,
-0.0243178718,
-0.0005216005,
-0.0658295825,
-0.014179267,
0.0062455325,
-0.0122054983,
0.0309418626,
0.014479652,
-0.0205166861,
0.0143231526,
0.0044583944,
-0.026274588,
0.049527362,
-0.0001991402,
0.0192147009,
-0.0248582736,
-0.0260230657,
-0.04086845,
0.0344705023,
-0.0025999828,
0.00484356,
0.0412871465,
-0.0305774901,
0.086461097,
0.0107219601,
-0.0092400694,
0.0100582223,
0.0116207218,
-0.0502969585,
-0.0415855013,
0.0181236416,
0.0013442056,
0.0149317523,
-0.0173125267,
-0.0625481084,
0.0361711457,
0.0421579331,
-0.0097435396,
-0.0129847694,
-0.0622078031,
0.0743264854,
0.0188392606,
-0.0396586247,
0.0042978073,
0.0034171965,
-0.0005855978,
0.0235372987,
-0.017515989,
0.0133537967,
0.0452254191,
-0.0360134058,
0.0174175799,
0.0094469786,
-0.0060575875,
-0.0356375836,
0.0641467422,
-0.0058845477,
0.0235494673,
-0.0337336175,
0.0112288222,
-0.0313650183,
0.0059401179,
0.0279732775,
-0.0544602834,
0.0272830855,
-0.0642344281,
-0.0146384556,
0.021838963,
-0.0541783236,
-0.0428124033,
-0.0109140398,
-0.0193661619,
-0.0391168892,
0.0231041778,
-0.0408626311,
-0.0127097387,
-0.0436591841,
0.0175825302,
0.0279846359,
0.0027719534,
-0.0147152729,
-0.0320391059,
-0.0331715345,
0.0397800766,
0.0141434278,
0.0078616366,
-0.0486328006,
0.0371250249,
0.0414598808,
0.0018869501,
-0.0256541241,
0.0130626597,
0.0089895241,
0.0267801788,
-0.0116209779,
-0.0389777198,
0.0354216509,
0.0062990431,
-0.0469939448,
0.0021837084,
0.0941253603,
0.0169025268,
-0.0352350622,
0.00363722,
-0.0112366416,
0.0122156925,
0.0419312902,
0.0466412678,
-0.1026780233,
-0.0000808038,
-0.0076888646,
0.0197803862,
-0.0106551927,
-0.0706441328,
-0.0201901644,
-0.1203738153,
0.0341772735,
0.0106010763,
-0.0418663397,
-0.0306123942,
-0.0005649971,
-0.0097869625,
0.0241687838,
-0.0244438928,
0.0029949346,
-0.0007450635,
0.0062750415,
-0.0087297279,
-0.0194850862,
-0.0297729466,
0.0222183187,
-0.0329708159,
0.0645895153,
0.0107884519,
0.0763947219,
0.0219964366,
-0.0354929455,
-0.0552961864,
0.0769693851,
-0.0118875531,
-0.0037794453,
0.0626306534,
-0.0011923311,
-0.0288176164,
-0.0350271463,
0.0258080456,
-0.0510754921,
-0.0288716815,
0.015938025,
0.075524345,
0.0016112617,
0.0022533888,
-0.0332948044,
-0.0150500834,
0.0319156088,
0.0649539903,
-0.006271068,
-0.0515779778,
-0.0132273398,
-0.0384148657,
-0.0173910987,
-0.0738206953,
-0.0736672282,
-0.0040472774,
-0.011988759,
-0.0404968597,
-0.0719637796,
-0.0210420918,
0.05069682,
0.0497639291,
0.02470937,
-0.0152979568,
0.0130094001,
0.0054147271,
-0.0544797145,
0.0170063041,
-0.0862679109,
0.0373014323,
-0.0512319393,
-0.0516939275,
0.0049091936,
-0.0537652597,
0.0181903206,
0.0472544469,
-0.0458478294,
-0.0442769341,
0.0109042749,
0.0494632684,
0.0248465762,
0.0266631525,
0.0168121289,
-0.0407122895,
0.0490923338,
0.0625416636,
-0.0725631043,
-0.0154519919,
0.0003227889,
0.0038935549,
0.0168310441,
0.0191955902,
-0.0353628173,
-0.0009938563,
-0.0202135257,
0.0451061986,
-0.0310376752,
-0.0317796841,
0.0264104679,
0.0387992077,
-0.034584377,
-0.0210311171,
0.0115053514,
-0.0224734284,
-0.0014829937,
-0.0710915327,
-0.0552749969,
-0.0249173976,
-0.0052765799,
0.0087275347,
-0.0032708282,
0.040666461,
0.036976289,
0.0156007027,
0.0093658706,
-0.0068015549,
-0.0131136812,
0.0270628221,
0.0310289469,
0.0682937726,
-0.0201260913,
-0.002264559,
0.0053164954,
-0.0279765222,
0.0426254161,
-0.0040197433,
0.013028549,
0.0161224119,
-0.0005895279,
-0.0323850922,
0.0137424106,
-0.0341610126,
-0.0945181102,
0.0134108197,
0.0434715264,
0.0533803366,
0.0538686924,
0.0131562753,
-0.0495977774,
-0.0181725081,
0.0063297316,
-0.0153436139,
0.0422791466,
-0.0247275177,
-0.0426590256,
0.0248010214,
-0.0104121212,
-0.0572814606,
0.0593392961,
-0.025986921,
0.0419644378,
-0.0348306969,
-0.031344384,
-0.0616181567,
-0.0291933268,
-0.0012173671,
0.0200690068,
-0.0257974621,
-0.0157526098,
-0.1084227636,
-0.0481041744,
-0.0120007219,
0.0800921023,
-0.0426220931,
0.0140747167,
0.0318001136,
0.0224963743,
0.0245910976,
-0.0029784052,
-0.0425532088,
0.0739127025,
-0.0503339842,
-0.0128875691,
0.0406265818,
-5.73812498e-33,
-0.0363890678,
-0.0266150888,
0.053637825,
0.009406588,
-0.0320883989,
-0.0281814169,
-0.048373051,
0.0079832412,
0.0098451693,
0.0155727351,
-0.0078296764,
-0.0052609365,
0.0050834995,
0.0227614008,
-0.010278156,
-0.0183580853,
0.0539694019,
0.0237934198,
-0.0229331199,
0.0428338274,
0.064983815,
-0.0154817468,
0.01770363,
-0.0665390119,
0.0088241966,
-0.0188230406,
0.0017596375,
0.0294504017,
-0.0081263706,
0.0434184447,
-0.0112797245,
0.0561154857,
-0.0077455239,
-0.0023896939,
-0.0187440161,
0.010025355,
-0.048742529,
-0.0452382714,
0.0305558126,
0.0124963745,
-0.0069042207,
-0.066291824,
0.0232371353,
-0.0033500856,
0.0246325843,
-0.0045609116,
0.0482131653,
-0.0276605207,
0.026052922,
-0.0453598984,
-0.0508379042,
-0.0012058255,
-0.010064207,
0.0107877683,
-0.0044318195,
0.0230405703,
0.0090820016,
-0.018447537,
-0.0427876562,
0.0783093944,
-0.0058407523,
-0.0357845463,
0.0482374802,
0.0599802025,
0.0533626415,
0.0325825065,
0.0517043397,
0.0279176123,
-0.0620768778,
0.0355524942,
0.0241215322,
0.069319658,
0.0481340364,
0.1038507298,
-0.0204702225,
0.0023994485,
-0.0273335055,
0.0186943375,
0.0235782638,
-0.0581387244,
0.021831464,
-0.0052332082,
-0.0352135114,
-0.0128070265,
-0.0343997218,
0.0055410522,
-0.0193396229,
-0.0125988433,
0.0004859824,
-0.0275193863,
-0.0353746265,
-0.0109367473,
0.0097976262,
-0.0673211515,
-0.0252826549,
0.0321891122,
0.0015937564,
-0.002572868,
-0.0067979931,
-0.0094249323,
0.0044157668,
-0.0328215882,
0.0259037018,
-0.0206419975,
0.0221478771,
0.0507974029,
-0.0194609798,
0.0494856313,
-0.035565123,
-0.0037623164,
-0.0345553905,
0.0326180123,
0.0070159384,
0.0094313091,
0.0246109273,
0.0065048379,
-0.0136969732,
-0.0232493374,
0.0295533929,
-0.001336452,
-0.0025352605,
0.0469542779,
-0.02188549,
-0.0014947453,
-0.0058359527,
-0.0062076664,
-0.1003981233,
0.0050513442,
0.0533222482,
-0.0714632794,
-0.0283555929,
0.0010357756,
2.753e-7,
-0.0035089974,
0.0054925918,
0.0030553278,
0.0471222326,
0.0267257653,
0.0371988378,
0.0116870068,
0.0106927855,
0.025472736,
-0.0370703228,
0.0028765476,
0.0599534623,
0.0275193769,
0.0517991036,
-0.1262186766,
0.0066869855,
0.0226132236,
-0.0069460976,
-0.0872951597,
0.0237621572,
0.0557816476,
0.0230816659,
0.0683906078,
-0.0346780568,
0.0433951952,
0.020981811,
0.016979089,
-0.0320915245,
-0.0077773668,
0.0504781604,
0.0074653313,
-0.031290099,
-0.0031394949,
0.0184656531,
-0.0191907976,
0.0240843706,
-0.0002601623,
0.041011706,
0.0056523732,
0.0236311145,
-0.0082685892,
-0.0951313972,
-0.0196179468,
-0.0555273145,
0.0594865791,
-0.0116625354,
-0.010404733,
0.0237308536,
-0.043088235,
-0.0311263446,
-0.0439529866,
-0.0588387512,
-0.0211026613,
0.0096752122,
0.0040915613,
-0.0172217712,
0.017012015,
-0.0394416079,
-0.0218202099,
0.0012514706,
-0.0398950577,
-0.0407867245,
-0.0110054705,
-0.0055799652,
0.0160418749,
-0.0140872356,
0.0478282459,
2.620952459e-34,
-0.020017378,
0.0698774755,
0.0178914294,
-0.0294801109,
0.0723918229,
-0.0059576603,
-0.0156812854,
0.0284822565,
0.0340821892,
-0.0468866155,
-0.0251486972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20087v1 | ProgressGym: Alignment with a Millennium of Moral Progress | 2024-06-28T17:55:24 | 2024-06-28T17:55:24 | Tianyi Qiu, Yang Zhang, Xuchuan Huang, Jasmine Xinze Li, Jiaming Ji, Yaodong Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Frontier AI systems, including large language models (LLMs), hold increasing
influence over the epistemology of human users. Such influence can reinforce
prevailing societal values, potentially contributing to the lock-in of
misguided moral beliefs and, consequently, the perpetuation of problematic
moral practices on a broad scale. We introduce progress alignment as a
technical solution to mitigate this imminent risk. Progress alignment
algorithms learn to emulate the mechanics of human moral progress, thereby
addressing the susceptibility of existing alignment methods to contemporary
moral blindspots. To empower research in progress alignment, we introduce
ProgressGym, an experimental framework allowing the learning of moral progress
mechanics from history, in order to facilitate future progress in real-world
moral decisions. Leveraging 9 centuries of historical text and 18 historical
LLMs, ProgressGym enables codification of real-world progress alignment
challenges into concrete benchmarks. Specifically, we introduce three core
challenges: tracking evolving values (PG-Follow), preemptively anticipating
moral progress (PG-Predict), and regulating the feedback loop between human and
AI value shifts (PG-Coevolve). Alignment methods without a temporal dimension
are inapplicable to these tasks. In response, we present lifelong and
extrapolative algorithms as baseline methods of progress alignment, and build
an open leaderboard soliciting novel algorithms and challenges. The framework
and the leaderboard are available at
https://github.com/PKU-Alignment/ProgressGym and
https://huggingface.co/spaces/PKU-Alignment/ProgressGym-LeaderBoard
respectively. | [
0.0283493418,
0.1550632268,
-0.0266036037,
-0.0038148568,
-0.0813379362,
-0.001168228,
-0.0263751727,
-0.0090697091,
0.009830364,
0.0334771648,
0.0254197139,
-0.00796472,
0.0193931758,
-0.0040241252,
-0.035649091,
-0.0192589872,
0.0665406436,
0.0151833566,
0.0349490196,
-0.0031994483,
-0.0004123354,
0.0305221379,
0.0253641829,
-0.0136395739,
0.0076073571,
-0.0027814859,
-0.0367779396,
-0.0308682323,
0.07201083,
-0.0235151518,
0.0000522907,
0.0381924286,
0.0335653909,
0.0487016179,
0.0000019574,
-0.0609161779,
0.0073903045,
-0.0075765266,
0.0173915327,
0.0174800325,
0.0637146607,
-0.0176255982,
-0.0220706854,
-0.0218129773,
-0.0614960231,
0.0709036365,
0.015218664,
0.0109239537,
0.0331415571,
0.05201938,
0.0095900251,
-0.0008542697,
0.0524444655,
0.0052264715,
-0.0089791045,
-0.0272073355,
0.0319878533,
0.0485414937,
-0.0167662371,
-0.0060674027,
-0.0252021812,
0.0193319581,
-0.0050515858,
-0.00661118,
-0.0099983821,
-0.0204100255,
0.036684908,
-0.0404719152,
-0.0256947018,
0.0409747064,
0.0120889284,
-0.0420949496,
0.0436070412,
-0.0064477562,
0.0170528404,
-0.0364480056,
0.003212288,
0.0034319086,
-0.0279817339,
0.0114882896,
0.0475162491,
-0.0247967131,
0.0218794029,
0.0505112261,
0.0327278674,
0.0209065955,
-0.0010312235,
-0.0284899026,
-0.011932143,
-0.0005957466,
-0.0312748104,
-0.0404265746,
0.0126340501,
0.0226484518,
-0.0476115048,
0.0305410791,
-0.0239467379,
0.0400190987,
0.0342458412,
-0.0255178623,
0.0106405346,
0.0562284365,
0.018405769,
0.0490741357,
0.0229936,
0.0636527836,
-0.023451386,
-0.0078402692,
-0.0408650115,
0.0299372375,
0.0178046785,
0.0129035646,
0.0332048237,
0.0108326888,
0.0349479131,
0.035918504,
-0.0405604951,
0.0097866245,
-0.0580515862,
0.0350394249,
-0.0442576669,
-0.0025196865,
-0.0213475842,
-0.0250947066,
-0.0402024649,
0.0082645342,
-0.064173229,
0.0111470213,
-0.0336248279,
0.0426835306,
0.0065322886,
-0.0382904224,
-0.0243787207,
0.0073628612,
0.0407881066,
0.0734589025,
-0.003564876,
0.0157125704,
-0.0345785134,
0.0023437298,
-0.0021093697,
-0.0457852744,
-0.0212175678,
-0.0445956737,
0.0355002247,
-0.0187047385,
-0.040698126,
-0.0719015449,
0.0261888877,
0.0280830041,
-0.0271864012,
0.0288330223,
0.0082176104,
0.0121849068,
0.0196280871,
0.0073639601,
-0.0053297845,
0.0449109077,
0.0087631391,
0.0162853692,
0.0252094157,
-0.0037910999,
-0.0177855827,
0.0013390557,
0.0198122505,
0.0227970872,
-0.027899649,
0.0072822603,
0.0333216302,
0.0580625646,
-0.0147983851,
0.0313782915,
0.0156708509,
-0.0357671231,
0.0434658155,
0.1021962985,
-0.0240462441,
0.0268395673,
-0.0044501796,
-0.0467864126,
0.0133927902,
-0.0042091291,
-0.062605679,
0.0120791756,
-0.0050317147,
-0.0104697011,
-0.0572589748,
0.0991632566,
0.0077121621,
-0.0386074036,
0.0292507149,
-0.0030861532,
0.0465737991,
-0.0028168156,
-0.0026011427,
-0.0084128175,
-0.0167365056,
-0.0982222632,
0.0612132773,
-0.0451067165,
0.0128738834,
-0.035008505,
0.0884186402,
0.0634848848,
0.0755762085,
-0.0267528202,
-0.0225361157,
-0.0184816346,
-0.0007319146,
-0.0092391875,
0.0020576795,
-0.0297542214,
-0.024288604,
-0.0227020122,
-0.0435820296,
0.0240984801,
-0.0214469023,
-0.00258806,
0.0185309406,
-0.0069581852,
-0.0122715337,
0.008826104,
-0.0215315744,
0.071136862,
-0.0270002577,
0.0553236119,
-0.0569259748,
0.0040751211,
0.0259282999,
-0.0050848927,
0.010271077,
-0.0401664265,
0.0115293758,
0.0190356541,
-0.0156897176,
0.0435239002,
-0.03001271,
0.0431603827,
0.0685041249,
-0.0661359206,
-0.0406839624,
0.0181635711,
-0.0364937261,
0.0389830358,
-0.0240279119,
-0.0167365801,
0.018264031,
-0.0128886597,
0.0268103797,
-0.0807288811,
-0.0221513622,
-0.0327901617,
0.0754078925,
-0.0300886054,
-0.0037811217,
0.0139295394,
-0.0424988605,
0.0395225585,
0.0502458625,
0.0011185601,
-0.0195795707,
-0.0129595986,
0.0352047645,
0.0539460629,
0.0208194032,
-0.0498538651,
-0.0260864682,
-0.054672759,
0.0038625612,
0.0126344543,
0.0185181759,
-0.0070238067,
-0.0242402535,
0.0013745601,
0.0201285128,
-0.0314062797,
0.0211832877,
0.0068315971,
-0.0084956484,
0.0439771749,
-0.0248825178,
-0.0342587866,
-0.0539968163,
0.0249547008,
-0.0595267117,
-0.0163867027,
0.0346547775,
0.002695255,
-0.0440740958,
-0.0330441594,
-0.0645061582,
0.0087328693,
-0.0133129498,
-0.0478686355,
-0.0021196767,
0.0359735526,
0.0210993271,
0.0717416406,
0.0853096992,
0.0160747133,
0.0172072481,
0.0488276593,
-0.0418851897,
-0.0272240732,
-0.0251731202,
-0.0234948732,
-0.0368651897,
-0.0400554538,
-0.0141866235,
0.0553150848,
-0.005909442,
0.0200963281,
-0.0554503649,
0.0254823752,
-0.0412387438,
-0.0500707626,
0.0079094637,
-0.0531324707,
-0.0173978172,
0.0101201693,
-0.0458863154,
-0.0715762302,
0.0897747204,
0.0519989505,
0.0590828434,
0.0137567967,
0.0037406581,
-0.0009659158,
0.0460629351,
0.0203018915,
0.0544538647,
-0.004869624,
-0.009759468,
-0.039752394,
0.0177226979,
0.0349986106,
-0.0570096709,
0.0732077062,
-0.0486551002,
0.0044649513,
0.0288699362,
-0.0622275211,
-0.0503005572,
-0.0741369873,
-0.0120916013,
-0.0492931679,
-0.0256607775,
-0.0148013737,
0.037452165,
-0.0414434522,
0.016709758,
-0.0267104674,
0.0096489815,
0.000191755,
-0.0083001871,
-0.1088527814,
0.0556258112,
-0.0187295116,
0.0358465798,
-0.015480903,
0.0139540732,
0.0395963974,
0.0343710743,
-0.0048972387,
-0.0072935708,
0.0154309534,
0.0078795115,
-0.0183894858,
0.0352783091,
0.0285576843,
0.0167724583,
-0.0020317326,
0.0173036605,
0.0671628192,
0.0270526744,
-0.0641927198,
0.0306029208,
-0.0292603932,
-0.0136090331,
0.001346553,
0.000928717,
-0.0974783525,
0.0176197644,
-0.0153874448,
0.0182312932,
-0.0647078454,
-0.0825068206,
0.0347719416,
-0.0684256703,
-0.0090263123,
0.0675474852,
0.0249665417,
-0.0225122496,
-0.0123598194,
-0.0053322809,
-0.0320731997,
0.0041350597,
0.0192257948,
0.0228224844,
-0.037719883,
-0.0268579796,
-0.0045863432,
0.0364087448,
0.0324244611,
-0.0354476161,
0.072020106,
0.0728486255,
0.0655591935,
-0.0321110897,
-0.0535958223,
0.0114285443,
0.0347125046,
-0.0065669902,
0.0302045885,
-0.0181662925,
-0.0178198535,
0.0122527145,
-0.0481356047,
0.0388351306,
0.0248077102,
-0.0494223461,
0.0419859849,
0.0894622058,
0.0082974788,
-0.0234931167,
-0.0158281196,
-0.0036034458,
-0.0124169262,
0.0319494866,
-0.045983728,
-0.0608930588,
0.0121413898,
-0.0290544201,
-0.008512944,
0.0083690872,
-0.0746050626,
-0.0381791592,
-0.0012622483,
0.0208458714,
-0.0521584302,
-0.0395418666,
-0.0730523467,
-0.0094596073,
0.0723021477,
-0.068647407,
0.0422642082,
-0.0199867077,
-0.0588023551,
-0.0165978484,
-0.0057659987,
-0.0005825524,
0.0016764476,
0.0422094949,
-0.0144876558,
-0.0262167547,
-0.0025476625,
-0.0287306737,
-0.0358460583,
-0.0599032789,
0.0646282732,
0.0409000628,
0.0110262074,
0.0435087383,
-0.0296551287,
0.0452006608,
0.0085102255,
0.0545406118,
-0.0124397762,
0.042464789,
0.0240627378,
0.012016369,
-0.0293595232,
0.0065098139,
-0.0190917868,
-0.0201204214,
0.0096584065,
-0.0040397625,
-0.0404953398,
-0.0249948017,
0.0442032889,
-0.0011351383,
0.0052982229,
-0.0261362121,
-0.0555337742,
-0.0204441398,
-0.0378252976,
0.0235062614,
-0.0500670262,
0.0219026282,
-0.021175934,
0.0498738103,
-0.0172792934,
0.0108206607,
0.0365981534,
-0.0189196691,
-0.0056338334,
-0.0536617525,
-0.0191200934,
-0.0149847772,
0.0924637467,
-0.0206817538,
-0.0108576305,
-0.0334636644,
0.0415095687,
-0.0065236986,
0.0574583225,
-0.0229722317,
0.0663888827,
0.021993136,
0.0299333986,
0.0038637344,
0.0124260969,
-0.0879429132,
-0.0229657441,
-0.0503863543,
-0.0239211358,
0.0347280651,
0.0568493009,
0.0269566122,
-0.0085596563,
-0.0006464841,
-0.0181872454,
0.0170438103,
-0.033450868,
-0.0228646565,
-0.0384080298,
0.0146339219,
-0.0276647564,
0.021399552,
0.0027181308,
-0.1080182567,
0.0468934551,
0.0226684026,
-0.0018797491,
-0.0012846404,
-0.0744502544,
0.0218625981,
-0.0371957049,
-0.007993646,
-0.0136857573,
-0.0436649136,
-0.0103700785,
-0.0133684427,
0.0356581286,
-0.0159245003,
-0.0423623882,
-0.0260362271,
0.0367651917,
-0.0532298423,
0.0200009067,
-0.0332039036,
0.0277200919,
-0.0309955273,
0.0220341142,
-0.0496003032,
-5.453666735e-33,
-0.0333189182,
-0.0057811798,
-0.0105226142,
0.0097328341,
-0.0706365034,
-0.0513608344,
0.0129087437,
0.0288534146,
-0.0616688319,
0.0465872437,
-0.0063283262,
0.0180136766,
-0.0130022317,
-0.0445683673,
0.0528509691,
-0.04402823,
-0.0075202142,
0.0124592967,
-0.0263375491,
-0.0014648917,
-0.0136189489,
-0.0046071685,
0.0208319593,
-0.0915136039,
0.0263711158,
0.0276921093,
-0.0334328897,
-0.0011157652,
-0.0173294097,
0.0192881264,
0.0221343543,
0.0197647382,
0.00588569,
-0.0012997033,
0.0030944622,
0.0253367852,
0.0129650198,
0.0021236404,
0.0410739928,
-0.0043342286,
-0.0220599975,
-0.0226093121,
-0.0203894749,
-0.0145379407,
-0.0671792179,
0.0140783554,
0.0350587741,
-0.0202409886,
0.0207574535,
0.0202290751,
-0.0782339349,
-0.0133456877,
-0.048904907,
-0.008091175,
-0.0597269386,
0.0167037752,
0.0091877533,
0.025568638,
-0.0275179297,
0.035197489,
-0.0185513962,
-0.0164684486,
0.0395616964,
-0.020503344,
0.0530112125,
0.0680041984,
-0.0168942884,
0.008732955,
-0.0432545841,
0.0182054248,
0.0172622874,
-0.0003337943,
0.0429212824,
0.0458279587,
-0.0269323085,
-0.0435565785,
-0.0185134411,
0.0066909557,
0.0777221322,
-0.0053519132,
-0.0063623772,
0.0086946478,
-0.017902853,
0.0201788601,
-0.0433042943,
-0.0566828735,
0.0029667616,
-0.0125812488,
-0.0193583909,
-0.008691147,
-0.0049388604,
-0.0113811512,
-0.0217696559,
-0.0440887138,
0.0295707025,
0.0505956747,
-0.0219768845,
-0.0025697923,
0.0136693791,
0.0324353054,
-0.0529933125,
-0.0383309089,
-0.0310563222,
-0.0021056249,
0.0730326474,
-0.0037440327,
0.0216701571,
0.0095728468,
-0.0102940109,
-0.0057774209,
-0.0101499595,
0.0165224709,
0.0153911943,
-0.0857314616,
0.0443400592,
0.0175823625,
0.0013879574,
0.0124387518,
0.0519687794,
0.0243770946,
-0.0478125177,
0.0060065752,
0.0032016889,
0.0292667523,
-0.0155748408,
-0.0076188371,
-0.0243917368,
0.0765662789,
0.0031664534,
-0.0673081428,
-0.0276453476,
0.0362807922,
2.571e-7,
-0.012154053,
0.0141263297,
0.0424957089,
0.0280249622,
-0.0300209466,
0.0584662482,
0.0133851916,
0.0623475388,
0.0204526801,
-0.0613869801,
0.0514043793,
0.0054216292,
0.0560177378,
0.0024242352,
0.013431211,
-0.0190919302,
-0.04744431,
-0.0192891844,
-0.0719447285,
0.0608564764,
0.019476695,
0.0396422967,
0.04377212,
0.0187341273,
0.0414162204,
0.0413551927,
0.037242882,
-0.0250059403,
-0.0419223756,
0.0044782916,
-0.0597941652,
-0.0340265781,
-0.0280074049,
-0.0088232681,
0.0186968148,
0.0264914893,
-0.0105089564,
0.0649474487,
-0.0204361398,
-0.0212235507,
-0.0431451611,
0.0191030279,
0.0007459339,
0.0075124917,
0.0586839281,
0.0064521874,
-0.0025511859,
-0.0451212637,
-0.0008553343,
-0.0090240175,
0.0161298793,
0.0239016954,
-0.0127124097,
-0.0181490872,
0.0271715447,
0.0510788113,
-0.0043607876,
-0.0598181337,
0.0031394099,
0.006226657,
-0.0015711141,
-0.0628791824,
0.0245094243,
0.0653831884,
0.0160100181,
-0.0485098958,
0.0270828772,
2.151285528e-34,
0.0257317666,
-0.0678633302,
0.0418115519,
-0.011486168,
0.0266555306,
0.0363469087,
0.0286706891,
0.0163120776,
0.0463971794,
-0.0128415013,
-0.0046320977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20086v1 | Token Erasure as a Footprint of Implicit Vocabulary Items in LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:54:47 | 2024-06-28T17:54:47 | Sheridan Feucht, David Atkinson, Byron Wallace, David Bau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | LLMs process text as sequences of tokens that roughly correspond to words,
where less common words are represented by multiple tokens. However, individual
tokens are often semantically unrelated to the meanings of the words/concepts
they comprise. For example, Llama-2-7b's tokenizer splits the word
"northeastern" into the tokens ['_n', 'ort', 'he', 'astern'], none of which
correspond to semantically meaningful units like "north" or "east." Similarly,
the overall meanings of named entities like "Neil Young" and multi-word
expressions like "break a leg" cannot be directly inferred from their
constituent tokens. Mechanistically, how do LLMs convert such arbitrary groups
of tokens into useful higher-level representations? In this work, we find that
last token representations of named entities and multi-token words exhibit a
pronounced "erasure" effect, where information about previous and current
tokens is rapidly forgotten in early layers. Using this observation, we propose
a method to "read out" the implicit vocabulary of an autoregressive LLM by
examining differences in token representations across layers, and present
results of this method for Llama-2-7b and Llama-3-8B. To our knowledge, this is
the first attempt to probe the implicit vocabulary of an LLM. | [
-0.0038011463,
0.014064773,
-0.0446657836,
0.0517834313,
-0.030906368,
-0.0099924942,
-0.0196680967,
0.0454261824,
-0.0357925706,
-0.0362896286,
-0.0255103689,
-0.0275268182,
0.0270991772,
0.0124809183,
0.0448879115,
-0.0098330546,
0.0850311965,
-0.032712169,
-0.0103147198,
-0.0062902779,
-0.0109979231,
-0.0278956965,
-0.0045109722,
0.0160556976,
-0.0174345449,
-0.0143912314,
-0.0193195436,
-0.0190545283,
-0.0137903504,
-0.0414885655,
-0.0614921823,
-0.0101953736,
-0.009331244,
0.0245452113,
0.0000018469,
-0.052232597,
-0.0223755948,
-0.0330335349,
-0.0270274375,
0.0318802521,
0.0153308026,
0.0389652401,
-0.0132833449,
-0.0295413882,
-0.0095471879,
0.012768589,
0.012804159,
0.0237345099,
0.0195927955,
0.0314566679,
0.0055225585,
-0.019848451,
0.0356177837,
0.0016830564,
0.0635647401,
-0.0164645389,
0.0362650007,
-0.063001737,
-0.0288555287,
-0.0126756467,
-0.0359959342,
0.011074977,
0.0021625359,
0.0024497693,
0.0295618754,
0.0440276004,
0.0130486628,
-0.0260994378,
0.0047942996,
0.0108070252,
0.0487649329,
-0.009746165,
0.0203729793,
-0.002652612,
-0.0043774075,
0.0138333505,
-0.0444645919,
0.0255483799,
-0.0049375258,
0.031600222,
0.040258795,
-0.0255886894,
0.0332804136,
0.002364761,
-0.0576476976,
0.1073930934,
0.0200698078,
-0.0147738652,
-0.0021089208,
-0.0237826295,
0.0263403244,
-0.0638527796,
0.0420738608,
0.050922472,
0.0000021345,
0.0430367067,
0.0112343943,
0.0072344779,
0.0319310613,
-0.0197828859,
0.027664749,
0.049691774,
-0.0405558385,
0.0283794627,
-0.0725740492,
0.035416346,
-0.0116053317,
0.0161854718,
-0.0288521722,
0.0025389986,
-0.0002736289,
-0.0419145934,
-0.0093235932,
0.1041134968,
-0.0118140634,
-0.0260168537,
-0.0428543463,
0.0250227228,
0.0079875207,
-0.0282395035,
-0.0504288599,
0.0106299203,
0.0004903445,
0.0434694216,
-0.0634733588,
-0.0178959034,
-0.0378759764,
0.0211534631,
0.0084594302,
-0.033230029,
-0.025179049,
0.0010501345,
-0.007165825,
-0.0111733638,
-0.0100147529,
0.1075571403,
0.0152439997,
-0.0347185843,
-0.0489329211,
-0.0437250361,
-0.0123544671,
-0.01318176,
0.0170405172,
-0.0538229309,
-0.0014738267,
0.013142827,
-0.0002957071,
-0.031095529,
0.0143166073,
0.0133516593,
-0.0252957176,
0.0791542232,
-0.0110685593,
-0.00593042,
0.0194331277,
0.0215971507,
0.0189710893,
0.0449276604,
0.0247502178,
0.049499806,
0.0477304496,
-0.0032257722,
-0.0385522991,
0.0311128106,
0.0241107773,
-0.0315025933,
-0.0875472873,
-0.045795124,
-0.0073408172,
0.0542302355,
0.0433878191,
0.0659688264,
-0.0290650129,
-0.0284271073,
0.0084081665,
0.1234170422,
0.00965905,
0.0346916914,
0.0542130135,
-0.0657109767,
0.023966888,
0.0490254611,
-0.032662373,
0.0152805857,
0.015911784,
-0.0011950836,
0.022735199,
0.002299787,
-0.0156189818,
-0.0348197296,
-0.0313044824,
0.0145206945,
-0.0116237737,
-0.0821698532,
0.0236907545,
0.0099128336,
-0.0161114335,
0.1033428386,
0.0168773141,
-0.0355241708,
0.0273720268,
-0.0562839173,
0.0263756998,
0.0527885221,
0.0257193893,
-0.0220721196,
-0.0136686284,
0.0449636206,
-0.0075911772,
0.0421646014,
-0.0201490764,
-0.0094426405,
-0.0098355813,
-0.022218693,
-0.0106457677,
0.0123012979,
0.0293384995,
0.0411821976,
-0.0137510486,
0.0275828261,
0.0078746947,
-0.0644443035,
0.0333288349,
0.0431442074,
-0.0513035841,
-0.0192292649,
-0.0168881547,
0.0047594099,
0.0030156618,
0.0435624868,
0.0132826585,
0.0410326608,
0.0635802746,
-0.0294906888,
-0.03073119,
0.0027862978,
-0.0978469104,
0.0175766498,
0.0597174466,
0.017717123,
0.0202072896,
-0.0355209745,
0.0091348831,
-0.0417641662,
0.0120236464,
-0.051870998,
0.1084305272,
-0.0336415358,
0.0293478947,
0.0070549087,
0.0244467165,
-0.0282131452,
0.0634461939,
-0.0370953046,
0.0309864841,
-0.0027268766,
0.0119432593,
0.0171671622,
-0.0210224036,
0.0178349484,
0.0132922251,
-0.0014723019,
-0.0253395718,
-0.0123045323,
-0.0390335247,
-0.0763564259,
-0.0001634732,
-0.0669642165,
-0.0129100233,
0.0110079944,
0.0373456627,
0.0061094542,
-0.0079093939,
-0.0017553413,
0.0114826858,
0.0093742507,
0.056190595,
-0.0088021029,
0.0417284332,
0.0588677563,
-0.026859086,
-0.037491221,
-0.029498525,
-0.0054625724,
-0.0304795001,
0.0432332717,
-0.0394602343,
-0.0885149017,
-0.0340146534,
0.0019912489,
-0.0796701685,
-0.0287778825,
-0.0109541705,
-0.0272487868,
0.0481162369,
-0.0166863948,
0.0342860073,
0.0155607667,
-0.0021658125,
0.0744175464,
0.028453026,
-0.0636789873,
-0.0417377017,
-0.0239331257,
-0.0111771673,
0.0267948899,
-0.0229885746,
-0.0091795996,
-0.0270679742,
0.1058154777,
0.0250365064,
0.0135604702,
-0.00528639,
0.0206064079,
-0.0482407361,
-0.0421715751,
-0.0056185764,
-0.0039819824,
-0.0880867243,
0.0376212746,
-0.0182917863,
-0.0458899401,
0.0482902266,
-0.0307501759,
0.0257970467,
0.0324070826,
0.0015829392,
-0.0688095838,
0.0625833273,
-0.0138719017,
0.0094696628,
-0.0011921008,
-0.0853856355,
-0.0188405961,
0.0076436908,
-0.0410217047,
-0.0267443918,
0.0670716912,
-0.0309647638,
0.0021367001,
0.0092475358,
0.0131319081,
-0.0192800332,
0.0478907302,
-0.0045119044,
0.0366812386,
0.0251734648,
0.0001906821,
-0.0156906657,
-0.0257603955,
0.0138723571,
-0.0064966842,
-0.0107943537,
0.0139020374,
-0.0384711474,
0.0284865126,
0.0028599296,
0.0224782024,
0.040211793,
-0.0032990547,
0.0220662095,
0.0563809611,
0.0146965533,
-0.0384951569,
-0.0052759741,
0.0183435939,
0.0377399623,
-0.0610231757,
-0.0341847166,
0.0013378788,
0.025593875,
-0.0275667701,
-0.0262524225,
0.0967572108,
0.0365843214,
-0.04154386,
0.0409017056,
-0.0439179428,
-0.0034134255,
0.0358368494,
-0.0480546728,
-0.0768036693,
-0.0104107959,
0.0424685217,
-0.0091418196,
0.0138554731,
-0.049910292,
-0.0022632256,
-0.0840397179,
-0.0092125367,
-0.0021360146,
-0.0632455721,
0.0585792698,
-0.0445950627,
0.0150278704,
0.0307881813,
0.0487303957,
0.0228982586,
-0.0387418568,
0.01424558,
0.0270020347,
-0.0091440184,
0.029804362,
-0.0003281228,
-0.0084263496,
0.0415450223,
0.0108002638,
0.0466120765,
-0.0343444981,
-0.0510271303,
0.0939299762,
-0.0258043241,
0.0627174899,
-0.0519918315,
-0.0132005224,
0.0327463113,
0.0101540033,
0.0008599267,
-0.0039194119,
-0.014267968,
-0.0381589048,
-0.0135765765,
0.05945215,
-0.0275266077,
-0.0126101198,
-0.0344583839,
-0.018271992,
-0.0612277426,
0.0685882345,
0.0512719341,
-0.0037583897,
-0.0055854674,
-0.0231348965,
0.0214157719,
0.0182400104,
-0.0318102837,
-0.0194233246,
-0.0319169164,
-0.006958487,
-0.062078625,
-0.038706772,
0.0008459843,
0.0556518473,
0.0108801136,
0.072546944,
-0.0405546799,
-0.0520060621,
-0.0539551713,
0.0003921752,
-0.0239298139,
0.0144185657,
-0.0420087874,
-0.0016818588,
0.006561433,
-0.0095246108,
-0.0206384379,
0.0159389935,
-0.0437501781,
-0.0728197023,
0.0721302107,
-0.0044073062,
0.0321140662,
0.0083193434,
0.0322507694,
-0.0388911329,
0.0993134156,
0.0522196144,
-0.0267009437,
0.0671618432,
-0.0088894404,
0.0492419079,
-0.0021459516,
0.0405483581,
-0.0330497436,
-0.0031833856,
0.0109473215,
0.0609537326,
0.01502591,
0.0022436518,
0.005594701,
0.0167328194,
0.0586584508,
-0.004547107,
-0.0103430906,
0.004210941,
0.0145864766,
-0.0282527562,
0.0056229248,
0.0139398891,
-0.0041478495,
0.0111810276,
-0.0078038028,
-0.0285043027,
-0.0273401253,
-0.0166633856,
0.0701652914,
0.0186194219,
0.0064439047,
0.0032897594,
0.0055449139,
0.00653482,
0.0264541861,
0.0095062442,
0.0188015494,
-0.0330928527,
0.016678812,
-0.0424832366,
0.0108833946,
-0.0067074588,
0.0389937796,
-0.0720618814,
0.0246453546,
-0.0377884842,
-0.033832036,
0.0158111658,
0.0453215837,
0.0199978258,
0.0015628617,
0.0186503306,
-0.0119956341,
-0.0045583886,
0.006480176,
-0.0098781381,
-0.017629208,
-0.0127143813,
0.0330185853,
0.0200274885,
-0.0239495523,
-0.0200179107,
0.0313524753,
-0.0180496629,
0.043620009,
-0.0040883445,
0.0162819382,
-0.0104971835,
-0.019756671,
0.0285375267,
0.0292798281,
-0.0162514467,
-0.0507686324,
-0.0752992257,
-0.0562581904,
0.0546238124,
-0.0039299214,
-0.0097466288,
-0.0217894036,
0.0115177445,
0.0604177676,
0.0496398471,
-0.0099005597,
0.0002455698,
0.0278067496,
-0.0171762984,
-0.0426603183,
0.033180397,
-6.219754403e-33,
-0.0641692206,
-0.0698912218,
0.0238639638,
0.0186256506,
-0.0495578162,
0.0527081862,
-0.0379433483,
0.0020711531,
0.0400289148,
0.0035092572,
-0.0333679505,
0.0018231076,
0.0266104043,
-0.0248144306,
0.0282039121,
-0.0070548719,
0.0168357547,
-0.013472789,
-0.0175798181,
-0.0045549516,
0.0822542608,
0.0413130447,
0.0731913298,
0.0095871706,
0.0532374606,
0.0257161781,
0.0243195407,
0.02358073,
-0.0011766588,
0.0530078933,
-0.0592143722,
0.0361761898,
0.0224067941,
-0.0254587829,
-0.0321261846,
0.0034027393,
-0.1049778685,
-0.0801621079,
0.0706453621,
-0.0054314476,
-0.0243210997,
-0.0495193601,
0.068446584,
-0.0119809825,
-0.0481423698,
0.0335856676,
0.0247214921,
-0.0035304835,
-0.0465984195,
-0.011535299,
-0.0341787972,
0.0071409349,
0.0213242974,
0.0466353782,
0.0242459718,
-0.0904961675,
0.0122768283,
0.0037403961,
-0.0621116348,
0.018746268,
-0.019812787,
0.0423446484,
0.0396843776,
0.0386340581,
0.0033350033,
0.0720556006,
0.07711716,
-0.0110569578,
-0.0160040632,
0.0128882816,
0.0400699042,
0.0195705611,
-0.0117626674,
-0.0245009139,
0.0450798832,
-0.0305018257,
-0.0087186741,
-0.0006591117,
0.0166450981,
0.0657441244,
-0.0075329435,
0.0336343274,
-0.0059686755,
-0.0001415301,
-0.0226337817,
-0.0174930785,
-0.0384496003,
-0.0392552465,
0.0207999423,
-0.0164777078,
0.0201105941,
-0.0222142413,
-0.0044735293,
-0.0068651955,
-0.0653876811,
-0.0018599797,
0.0087972023,
-0.0116603281,
0.0016245324,
-0.000248792,
-0.0444480628,
-0.0553476624,
-0.0219424069,
-0.00333837,
0.0286833737,
-0.0026568079,
-0.0207511,
0.0195201524,
-0.0628881082,
0.0039512189,
-0.0362504534,
-0.0555404685,
-0.0066509121,
-0.0350236222,
0.0546050631,
-0.0217459928,
-0.004205537,
0.0064914105,
0.0558781363,
-0.0008894735,
-0.0188506749,
0.0189329367,
-0.0092270654,
0.0432320461,
-0.0438355394,
-0.0042691394,
-0.0112649715,
0.0352719687,
0.0488428622,
-0.0341000482,
-0.0005445408,
0.0152881416,
2.617e-7,
0.0396100841,
0.0514769219,
0.0680548474,
0.0105773946,
0.0333081074,
-0.0150510669,
-0.0421809368,
0.0173689295,
-0.0436457768,
-0.0269202366,
-0.0145354029,
0.0055246372,
-0.0018878464,
0.035303019,
-0.0874962434,
0.0571802557,
-0.0304277781,
0.0052960599,
-0.0583354272,
0.0184373502,
0.0144236768,
0.0437025465,
0.019474782,
-0.0376843438,
-0.0487652496,
-0.0695931092,
0.0307123736,
-0.0295105539,
0.0131493807,
0.0002856526,
0.0187490061,
0.007164231,
0.0148381405,
-0.0292001721,
0.0080820844,
0.0262293946,
0.0254127178,
0.0197182503,
-0.0230297931,
-0.0367684327,
0.0102465786,
-0.0466826111,
0.0171552226,
-0.0295165889,
0.0376836546,
0.0208363943,
-0.0247286987,
-0.030654531,
-0.0052829268,
0.0197908245,
-0.0021059718,
0.0167052373,
-0.0032824175,
0.0086647216,
-0.0098675592,
0.0137092043,
-0.0475613102,
-0.0883694664,
-0.0304976683,
-0.0167149585,
-0.0475294515,
-0.0504138693,
-0.0688740388,
0.0200255439,
-0.0120159676,
-0.0681557283,
-0.0509925894,
2.35014106e-34,
-0.0013106428,
-0.0228115749,
0.0067211105,
0.0709055066,
0.0062042084,
-0.0257538967,
0.0286465753,
0.0522923879,
-0.0095141195,
-0.067223005,
-0.0238404032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20079v1 | Molecular Facts: Desiderata for Decontextualization in LLM Fact Verification | 2024-06-28T17:43:48 | 2024-06-28T17:43:48 | Anisha Gunjal, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic factuality verification of large language model (LLM) generations
is becoming more and more widely used to combat hallucinations. A major point
of tension in the literature is the granularity of this fact-checking: larger
chunks of text are hard to fact-check, but more atomic facts like propositions
may lack context to interpret correctly. In this work, we assess the role of
context in these atomic facts. We argue that fully atomic facts are not the
right representation, and define two criteria for molecular facts:
decontextuality, or how well they can stand alone, and minimality, or how
little extra information is added to achieve decontexuality. We quantify the
impact of decontextualization on minimality, then present a baseline
methodology for generating molecular facts automatically, aiming to add the
right amount of information. We compare against various methods of
decontextualization and find that molecular facts balance minimality with fact
verification accuracy in ambiguous settings. | [
0.0020315708,
0.0234881192,
-0.0106161796,
0.0596968792,
-0.0326045677,
0.0099289091,
-0.0272256024,
0.0187410414,
-0.011605517,
-0.0511302166,
0.0058747479,
-0.0649349689,
0.0263341777,
-0.0077526644,
0.0259661674,
-0.0173391942,
0.0661578849,
-0.0281395186,
0.0227652974,
-0.0349066965,
-0.0078181215,
-0.0065904525,
-0.0059225201,
-0.016850451,
-0.0268494673,
-0.0486823246,
-0.0019739305,
0.0131879346,
0.0388899036,
-0.002506661,
-0.0580555387,
0.025161298,
-0.0043592844,
0.0101966122,
0.0000020351,
-0.0561044291,
0.0112084197,
0.00230395,
-0.0483790971,
0.0292928908,
0.0213655159,
0.0049452689,
-0.0322746262,
-0.0227473229,
-0.0243287981,
-0.0204683039,
0.0633535981,
0.0504567586,
0.0132163754,
0.0737751201,
-0.0034855807,
-0.0330373049,
0.0308544878,
0.035635259,
0.0795170516,
0.0381702296,
0.0487491526,
0.054259669,
-0.0267267525,
0.009083692,
-0.0032302437,
0.0356577374,
-0.0157506168,
0.013148726,
-0.0270525385,
0.0310308654,
-0.0292576011,
-0.0290495567,
0.0142653221,
0.0479141921,
0.0377871729,
-0.0550167263,
-0.0024452819,
0.0182658918,
-0.009260091,
-0.0017298972,
-0.0161536466,
0.0693444237,
-0.0354795083,
0.0458061434,
0.0881915987,
-0.0119408201,
0.036134392,
-0.0405825041,
-0.0450369306,
0.0705651343,
0.0153073696,
-0.0424144156,
-0.0309759509,
-0.0158831533,
-0.0558096282,
-0.0696785972,
-0.0052027344,
-0.0049957884,
0.0098887552,
0.0170053337,
-0.0298363585,
0.0032969792,
0.0502083674,
-0.1179813147,
-0.0222115181,
0.0014166977,
-0.0800066516,
0.042025324,
-0.0228404142,
0.0193320028,
-0.0081454786,
0.0133960005,
-0.0162959006,
0.0319806375,
-0.0226269476,
0.0001859625,
-0.0388556756,
0.0426652692,
0.0029714077,
0.0075188628,
-0.0277634934,
-0.001044913,
-0.0007023813,
0.0500482805,
-0.070894666,
-0.0196689349,
-0.0196584016,
0.0120117096,
-0.0229750909,
0.0216146801,
-0.021694487,
-0.0273820702,
-0.0234434009,
-0.0662328154,
-0.0188213754,
0.0243864935,
-0.0242449101,
-0.0006621853,
-0.0151785277,
0.0424492061,
0.0251483191,
0.0159492791,
-0.0449024774,
-0.0503422953,
-0.0136625413,
-0.0809578225,
0.0075532584,
-0.073845461,
-0.0016234932,
0.0187796839,
-0.0033394804,
-0.0517787002,
0.0253547393,
-0.007280027,
-0.0383925214,
0.090146713,
-0.0243239217,
-0.0215370376,
-0.0077241999,
0.0279892609,
0.0569179542,
0.0458814241,
0.0215882119,
-0.0010896042,
0.0396565758,
-0.0046022241,
0.0258453302,
-0.0207036901,
0.000113518,
-0.0215296075,
-0.0240921173,
-0.0438218042,
0.0526322201,
-0.0044772034,
0.0088377623,
0.0406506322,
-0.0065104077,
-0.0101554142,
0.0565124415,
-0.0151267778,
-0.0022752404,
0.0274600275,
0.0185298063,
0.0150232492,
0.0391031466,
0.0831914768,
-0.048005458,
0.0201856084,
-0.0371719673,
0.0469914414,
0.0067637032,
0.0659519285,
0.0046924944,
-0.0399953723,
-0.0470273457,
0.0140560614,
-0.0031080463,
-0.0299509503,
0.0110295368,
0.0009664524,
-0.0378878824,
0.0959963351,
0.0486648902,
-0.0561065935,
-0.010951994,
-0.0243695155,
0.0331679583,
0.0597058237,
0.026682362,
-0.0433147326,
-0.0114412028,
0.0153311174,
-0.0018606242,
0.0528205633,
0.025596885,
-0.0027166891,
0.0489790216,
-0.0468379743,
0.0261220802,
-0.0160874613,
0.0521266833,
-0.0112906592,
-0.0369836949,
-0.0237106457,
0.0113563752,
-0.0321858004,
0.0007679299,
0.0346311182,
0.0062665464,
-0.0384274088,
-0.0412351117,
0.0083700391,
0.0032389367,
0.0155737279,
-0.0126495464,
0.0209474452,
0.0360117182,
-0.0290009342,
0.014003817,
0.0176595021,
-0.0131293871,
-0.0568121597,
0.0565991625,
0.0208288636,
0.0234799236,
-0.0549154952,
-0.0236604773,
-0.0226251353,
0.0173324514,
-0.0274609439,
0.0512314662,
-0.0202209074,
0.0466543995,
0.027200019,
0.0484371632,
0.0048265513,
0.0987525657,
-0.0084835393,
-0.0171956588,
0.0166685227,
-0.0118296305,
0.0234654993,
-0.0337894894,
0.0087316837,
0.0082160477,
0.0165241901,
0.0184760578,
-0.0005606097,
-0.0314977914,
-0.0389583074,
0.0095488941,
-0.0524589084,
-0.009273666,
-0.0077716769,
0.0246478375,
0.0450870432,
-0.0189290252,
0.006847939,
0.0203683972,
-0.0162964277,
0.0157530941,
-0.0252720527,
0.0108978199,
0.0319072045,
-0.0215430818,
-0.0724330246,
-0.0099549973,
0.0203094166,
-0.0390506014,
0.0561030433,
-0.0269904248,
-0.0681663081,
-0.0752160251,
0.0389373489,
-0.0644471645,
0.0277753528,
0.0021127935,
-0.0282077994,
0.022839902,
0.0098079098,
0.069178924,
0.0425555184,
-0.0136837782,
0.0329038687,
0.1037695855,
-0.027534958,
-0.0059956028,
-0.0136502236,
0.0009229969,
0.0223713685,
0.0023637617,
-0.0812361985,
0.0059078457,
0.0596973449,
0.0363013856,
-0.0026282824,
-0.0498398803,
0.0148454886,
-0.0163368862,
-0.0299351495,
0.0138622038,
-0.0160643607,
-0.0282127243,
0.0212121308,
-0.0218513645,
-0.0314717405,
0.0718583167,
-0.0573629774,
0.0243260153,
-0.0292152241,
0.0035249398,
0.0248247627,
0.0269591603,
0.0153430598,
0.0366312973,
0.0237146337,
-0.0015249728,
0.0025263412,
-0.0377180912,
-0.0006291732,
-0.0232828651,
0.0590963662,
-0.07786645,
-0.006136416,
0.0202712566,
-0.0007282507,
-0.0285187718,
-0.008973225,
-0.0018728173,
0.0013671328,
-0.0017500129,
-0.0204227809,
-0.058034718,
0.0049756686,
0.0550294667,
0.0004923307,
0.0158260241,
-0.0005984672,
-0.0050973692,
0.0227804612,
0.0211736709,
-0.0068096681,
0.0652183667,
-0.0178862363,
0.0394290052,
0.0795863792,
-0.0060084313,
0.0133404164,
-0.0044741915,
-0.0090225181,
-0.0096641863,
-0.0091312518,
-0.0549962223,
0.0270624571,
0.0530834459,
-0.0464012548,
-0.0340759419,
0.0854766741,
0.0313720815,
0.0228366479,
0.0321002454,
-0.0333768465,
-0.0155035257,
0.0023120712,
0.0092135258,
-0.1311907321,
-0.0012539577,
-0.0111603849,
-0.0306365397,
-0.0257458352,
-0.0052804765,
-0.0430930592,
-0.0374936759,
0.0491378158,
0.0609940626,
-0.0427983627,
-0.0516371764,
-0.028473543,
-0.0139504932,
0.011391989,
0.0197507981,
0.0363501459,
-0.0199700482,
-0.0384817906,
0.0122331753,
-0.0116567137,
-0.0316544473,
0.0083827367,
-0.0093064494,
0.0540043041,
0.0301416311,
0.0197897926,
-0.0186135545,
-0.0526465438,
0.027618153,
-0.0291615035,
-0.0109165069,
-0.0004290021,
0.03127845,
0.0083615622,
0.000713893,
-0.0292315986,
0.0035613605,
0.0244799871,
-0.0886350572,
-0.0250528734,
0.0640908256,
-0.056375809,
-0.0706024766,
-0.0004409924,
0.0542706326,
0.0000396762,
0.1019383445,
0.0461156815,
0.0311888661,
-0.0394823812,
-0.0308513045,
0.037061695,
-0.0000913265,
-0.0142070483,
0.0048285224,
-0.0418484248,
-0.0366216116,
-0.0980524942,
-0.0046144812,
0.0211661346,
0.0191454496,
-0.0120474314,
0.0216664337,
-0.0074568605,
-0.0541181788,
-0.0305913128,
0.0249690544,
-0.0480134189,
-0.0166593809,
-0.0186937675,
-0.0192025341,
0.014059931,
-0.0273851696,
0.009781383,
0.040521834,
-0.0714806989,
-0.0624894015,
0.0472539812,
-0.0089639947,
0.034690164,
0.0381915458,
-0.0041773282,
-0.0499139912,
0.0674123093,
0.0585023575,
0.024328202,
0.0638207197,
0.0095056128,
-0.0022054869,
-0.00265028,
0.0151248723,
-0.0070743957,
0.0091973851,
-0.0113426037,
0.0382744707,
-0.0235173404,
-0.013748779,
0.0710106865,
0.065414764,
0.0112487962,
-0.0045044641,
0.0094955992,
-0.0129811047,
0.0107583664,
-0.0233103782,
-0.0161464177,
-0.0188374035,
0.0017191633,
0.0002738794,
0.0027881388,
-0.0059021628,
-0.018958915,
-0.0469125845,
0.0182704497,
0.033241,
-0.0478288718,
0.0045816447,
0.0087082712,
0.0656023324,
-0.0132346656,
-0.0452733934,
0.0364912637,
-0.0243804753,
0.051434014,
-0.0238663144,
0.0335442461,
0.0189851671,
0.0026843764,
-0.074056372,
0.001549869,
-0.038768962,
0.0128150806,
-0.0490802601,
0.0324578285,
0.0535607189,
0.0155501235,
0.0801051706,
-0.0724637955,
0.0058615231,
-0.014394979,
0.0559013709,
0.0502039418,
-0.0198234171,
0.0135861114,
0.0313021578,
-0.0298735425,
0.0018209224,
0.0783560276,
-0.0193385929,
0.0508037619,
-0.0254902653,
-0.0430807881,
-0.0321961306,
-0.0471676812,
-0.0816703662,
-0.0041849767,
-0.0493902825,
-0.0333485603,
-0.0940482765,
-0.0468175821,
-0.0000586995,
0.0490676314,
0.0454508699,
-0.0294257402,
-0.015962597,
0.0628371388,
0.0432815105,
-0.0998520553,
0.0042480784,
0.0235438515,
0.0420554355,
0.0297454949,
-0.0098952157,
-6.448911884e-33,
-0.0399476625,
-0.0316131972,
-0.0036979234,
-0.0100223674,
-0.0147223705,
0.0099348249,
-0.0544434004,
-0.0027946385,
0.0056185615,
0.0488786623,
0.0340161547,
0.0190836322,
0.0346210748,
-0.0364066437,
-0.0154407136,
0.0015523442,
0.0644331649,
0.0241664108,
-0.031741716,
-0.0070624086,
0.0627588034,
-0.026771564,
0.0885398462,
-0.0808961391,
0.0694577396,
-0.0175003707,
-0.0180627983,
0.0077804187,
-0.0724610835,
0.0261690486,
-0.0397787876,
0.0333430171,
0.0217944384,
-0.0143291662,
-0.0197113249,
-0.0129628433,
-0.0601894967,
-0.029727973,
0.0942180976,
-0.0155988606,
-0.005208761,
-0.0357723534,
0.0148853594,
-0.0032171861,
-0.0045509082,
-0.0072686835,
0.019927606,
-0.0496232733,
-0.029750023,
-0.0020023675,
-0.0754916966,
0.001989766,
0.0339351781,
0.0363089666,
0.0225559212,
-0.031912569,
-0.014394246,
-0.0611810423,
-0.0716408417,
0.0359911248,
0.0455190204,
0.0372310542,
0.0490090884,
0.0001749679,
-0.0046676984,
0.0480063595,
0.0425221957,
0.0360385776,
-0.0430929884,
0.0068781576,
0.0069580809,
0.0490257628,
0.0004561302,
0.0417821072,
0.0297488309,
0.0133976927,
-0.0612025745,
-0.0042619742,
-0.0057405746,
0.0081823766,
-0.016906444,
0.01297074,
-0.0593994074,
-0.0423073135,
-0.0069291694,
0.0387588888,
-0.0274704527,
-0.0251065399,
-0.0081316391,
-0.0482468158,
-0.0399000756,
-0.0155360019,
0.0041262824,
-0.0252653528,
0.0026262074,
-0.0025677516,
-0.0167922731,
0.024728708,
-0.01946472,
-0.0132672908,
-0.0167258307,
-0.020094404,
0.0363702066,
-0.0135579957,
0.0247769803,
0.0419680476,
0.0283808857,
0.0082141645,
-0.0315947197,
0.0243822783,
-0.0254270695,
-0.0268978942,
0.0129508032,
-0.0322852731,
0.0296608843,
0.0206548329,
0.0010335522,
0.0110744936,
0.0403227657,
0.0228023753,
-0.0032215782,
0.0523531325,
0.0095558381,
0.0457786359,
-0.0385689735,
0.0116569353,
-0.0484318882,
-0.0038268475,
0.0526872016,
-0.0309288427,
-0.0288707651,
0.0031887132,
2.839e-7,
0.0246511381,
0.0498176925,
0.0504303016,
0.0145814661,
-0.0012677428,
0.0351803638,
-0.0206150226,
-0.0140084811,
-0.0094139567,
-0.0762622207,
0.0040039592,
0.0244511906,
0.0321124494,
0.0518522225,
-0.0196184982,
0.0176825635,
-0.0242281798,
-0.0541797765,
-0.0690313429,
0.0114326579,
0.0404815637,
0.0327654295,
0.0170230921,
-0.0097821131,
0.0275506284,
-0.0340316705,
0.0357652903,
-0.0231171735,
-0.0387996286,
0.0473106019,
0.0459978729,
-0.0181838479,
0.0092599941,
0.0347910412,
-0.0162375737,
-0.0385508984,
-0.0427725203,
0.0438001156,
-0.0102720633,
-0.0116124814,
-0.0251655504,
-0.0355067663,
0.00995907,
-0.0194904897,
0.02539487,
0.0224429723,
-0.0313254073,
-0.016539311,
-0.0498990417,
0.0131775886,
-0.00472727,
0.0074048978,
-0.0277556684,
0.0175442975,
-0.0071294825,
0.0130627621,
-0.0506372303,
-0.0539565161,
-0.0496709272,
0.0587039217,
-0.0227898564,
-0.0450390577,
0.0359576941,
-0.0033639912,
0.0245127864,
-0.0885312408,
0.017497886,
3.062696807e-34,
0.0404914878,
-0.0007833901,
0.0199501105,
-0.012537159,
0.0327673182,
-0.0194205362,
-0.0244900975,
0.0196634792,
-0.0052182432,
-0.0695483759,
-0.000785994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20060v1 | Applying RLAIF for Code Generation with API-usage in Lightweight LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:16:03 | 2024-06-28T17:16:03 | Sujan Dutta, Sayantan Mahinder, Raviteja Anantha, Bortik Bandyopadhyay | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback (RLAIF) has demonstrated significant
potential across various domains, including mitigating harm in LLM outputs,
enhancing text summarization, and mathematical reasoning. This paper introduces
an RLAIF framework for improving the code generation abilities of lightweight
(<1B parameters) LLMs. We specifically focus on code generation tasks that
require writing appropriate API calls, which is challenging due to the
well-known issue of hallucination in LLMs. Our framework extracts AI feedback
from a larger LLM (e.g., GPT-3.5) through a specialized prompting strategy and
uses this data to train a reward model towards better alignment from smaller
LLMs. We run our experiments on the Gorilla dataset and meticulously assess the
quality of the model-generated code across various metrics, including AST,
ROUGE, and Code-BLEU, and develop a pipeline to compute its executability rate
accurately. Our approach significantly enhances the fine-tuned LLM baseline's
performance, achieving a 4.5% improvement in executability rate. Notably, a
smaller LLM model (780M parameters) trained with RLAIF surpasses a much larger
fine-tuned baseline with 7B parameters, achieving a 1.0% higher code
executability rate. | [
0.0002464308,
0.0502924807,
0.0079310527,
0.0045687626,
-0.0148546975,
-0.0004865722,
-0.0684028119,
0.0071899379,
0.0118538467,
-0.0278272312,
-0.0240655728,
0.0360088386,
0.0014838421,
0.0147652114,
0.0148723926,
-0.0028941352,
0.0217391439,
-0.045728799,
0.0101359906,
-0.0062027392,
-0.0148735279,
-0.0026617479,
-0.0007140754,
0.0328596421,
0.005946375,
-0.0372106172,
-0.0193847325,
0.0275978167,
0.0181052722,
-0.0308396257,
-0.0065376172,
0.0393064767,
0.0091991536,
0.0417280942,
0.0000022903,
-0.0603327788,
-0.0073468331,
0.0139357895,
-0.0190991517,
-0.0214636847,
-0.0082069384,
0.0220291279,
0.013738757,
0.0256202612,
-0.0428273752,
0.0352645256,
0.0488607399,
-0.0054547698,
0.0837305039,
0.08608073,
0.0287246071,
-0.0069164792,
0.0336063728,
0.0056885323,
0.0618128292,
-0.0113741169,
-0.0130566079,
0.0114329178,
0.0390088856,
-0.050892666,
-0.0027819707,
0.0054309624,
0.0586821511,
0.0139489053,
-0.0039086929,
0.0415284261,
-0.0569085702,
-0.0118649434,
-0.0213419329,
0.0476609133,
-0.0165784732,
-0.0371891297,
0.021775201,
-0.0222106092,
-0.0004087089,
-0.0534088947,
-0.0480496138,
0.0513878763,
-0.0208369996,
0.0283415597,
0.0193757266,
-0.031899333,
0.0388866924,
0.0054201283,
-0.0250097904,
0.0480714329,
-0.0075907139,
-0.0244917683,
-0.0231890697,
0.0133408392,
0.0150891971,
-0.0347239971,
-0.037201561,
0.0688291341,
-0.0576452836,
0.0094065936,
-0.0654153824,
-0.0135074239,
0.0128400074,
-0.0031514801,
0.0615389273,
0.0357621796,
-0.0191936586,
-0.0195486285,
-0.0632441267,
0.0645576417,
-0.019055333,
0.0646582618,
0.0078724883,
0.0355976373,
-0.0392987058,
0.0153101021,
-0.0080194566,
0.0968322381,
0.0070854719,
0.0171004198,
-0.0518198982,
0.043206837,
-0.0180547591,
0.0817002207,
-0.0149881514,
-0.0022324887,
-0.0423485115,
-0.0172723699,
-0.0228563994,
-0.0399915613,
-0.0114384284,
-0.0566869415,
0.0367608592,
-0.0729500502,
-0.0291373245,
0.0175851546,
-0.0201033074,
-0.0024880539,
0.0300423726,
0.1137666628,
0.0073975557,
0.0063447468,
-0.0607466474,
-0.0542810671,
0.0312474277,
-0.0578626208,
0.0001904649,
-0.0943477303,
0.0120275347,
-0.003613902,
-0.0300865546,
-0.051518634,
0.0330505632,
0.026226826,
0.018405417,
0.0421008728,
-0.049868755,
-0.0008545502,
0.0010062864,
0.0000627094,
-0.0654838681,
0.0768863931,
0.0857269093,
0.0493283756,
0.0075944522,
0.0084492406,
0.0254080184,
0.0178168267,
0.0235733166,
0.004851291,
-0.0002967805,
0.0177636817,
-0.0048555569,
0.0222348385,
0.0257189088,
0.0195473563,
-0.013273499,
0.0258510374,
0.0109269796,
0.0280892625,
0.0124280807,
0.012300401,
0.0472113453,
-0.0018775797,
-0.0001820141,
0.0140130324,
-0.0638558567,
0.0843584239,
-0.0307190344,
0.0581535771,
0.0614808649,
0.0282696988,
-0.0064822775,
-0.0835625827,
0.0178927481,
-0.010589689,
-0.046622362,
0.0148033192,
0.0077172234,
0.0186165068,
-0.0599139407,
0.0246321168,
0.0261961017,
-0.0613038987,
-0.0364278108,
-0.0764841586,
0.0328565501,
0.0388154238,
0.0591065064,
-0.059102539,
-0.0369918384,
-0.0291960631,
-0.0149538275,
0.0417811498,
0.0262936074,
0.0063404362,
0.0144114029,
-0.0374663807,
-0.01441471,
-0.0494476818,
-0.0064951251,
0.0224300716,
0.0339801461,
-0.0253642499,
0.0214551948,
0.0002048874,
-0.0860830396,
0.0515934713,
-0.0096841063,
-0.047378134,
0.0353470519,
-0.0072150859,
0.0432289727,
-0.0192480087,
-0.0135457171,
0.028622251,
0.0149801569,
-0.0167556293,
-0.0094668958,
-0.0463540256,
-0.0537989177,
-0.0310612489,
0.0313996449,
-0.0070800832,
-0.0304242447,
0.0160522312,
-0.051290188,
-0.0278273299,
0.0328752883,
-0.040840175,
0.028734494,
0.006356623,
0.0197445229,
0.0169677995,
-0.034310881,
-0.0115182549,
0.0517157018,
-0.0049198237,
0.0233925376,
0.0186979193,
0.0608924218,
0.0089995088,
-0.0144743342,
0.0272409804,
-0.0063009895,
-0.0210223459,
0.029060958,
-0.0008940084,
0.0617542081,
-0.0169044584,
-0.044512976,
-0.0448998734,
0.0365911275,
-0.032290481,
0.0193580613,
0.0034749024,
0.0171153005,
0.0039792936,
-0.007888807,
-0.0434387289,
-0.0170832761,
-0.0072062435,
-0.004646088,
0.0227528904,
0.0068196356,
-0.0498790033,
-0.0302383713,
0.0099897087,
-0.0128549803,
0.0073217852,
-0.0056322524,
0.0147440825,
-0.0690955669,
0.0501326844,
-0.0222236104,
0.0140518332,
-0.00976652,
-0.0050768028,
0.042711515,
-0.0499169491,
0.0295731071,
0.0710160583,
-0.0211115368,
0.0168667454,
0.0525732227,
0.0201558415,
-0.0904946402,
0.0287006255,
0.0020385811,
-0.0435622372,
-0.0055742008,
-0.0242085177,
0.0433783755,
0.0435638726,
-0.0118805366,
0.009351084,
-0.0505579449,
0.0219750721,
0.0510043167,
-0.0489954203,
0.0432078429,
0.0159216914,
-0.0497475825,
0.0631819889,
-0.0300149769,
-0.1404526383,
0.0660398975,
-0.0290597267,
-0.0213822443,
-0.0001068269,
-0.0260497034,
-0.0598100275,
0.0373259299,
0.020292772,
0.0128896441,
-0.0575531349,
-0.0358189605,
-0.0629859567,
0.0069355331,
-0.0075817234,
-0.0390711948,
0.0841860175,
-0.0514473133,
0.0003317011,
-0.0139697287,
-0.0404428877,
-0.0440710671,
0.0410422273,
-0.0085784486,
0.0031239993,
-0.0426977985,
-0.0165909305,
0.0194198247,
-0.0258080773,
0.0348381512,
0.0351013765,
-0.038415648,
-0.0421218202,
-0.0322105959,
-0.0470175557,
0.0235055666,
-0.0106448457,
0.0077225808,
-0.0359296836,
0.0083668092,
0.0187733844,
0.0463933833,
0.0343469717,
-0.0662835166,
0.0030193531,
0.013850919,
-0.0420817025,
0.0027095885,
0.060425546,
0.0463418737,
-0.0443299077,
-0.0375238024,
0.0849781409,
0.0298946705,
-0.0510914214,
0.0114111258,
-0.0461096913,
0.0848848224,
0.0475475527,
0.0590458103,
-0.0544745587,
-0.0223869625,
0.0091309948,
0.0885363147,
-0.0160702597,
-0.0145454491,
-0.0241268687,
-0.1319857538,
0.0396161117,
0.0157437194,
-0.0075770537,
-0.033609014,
-0.0138093941,
-0.0224033967,
0.0162814595,
-0.0380625501,
0.0419383235,
-0.0002548443,
0.0129175009,
0.0137280375,
-0.0268969331,
0.0172453038,
-0.0127062332,
-0.0208980795,
0.0356815979,
0.1034191549,
0.0011343294,
-0.0152634103,
-0.0031838049,
0.0132200718,
0.0287777558,
0.0078753307,
-0.0273315515,
0.0134635242,
-0.0040795421,
0.0044075963,
0.0264446996,
0.0311706606,
-0.0408390611,
-0.0246967394,
0.0480232574,
0.056316115,
-0.0442451797,
-0.0097403349,
-0.0143099222,
-0.0005566393,
-0.0227126349,
0.0272752661,
0.0264874883,
0.0040378128,
-0.047441259,
-0.0599113926,
-0.0242588408,
-0.095190309,
0.0107760839,
-0.0039436542,
-0.0103360992,
0.0218012892,
-0.0513300076,
-0.0083985431,
0.0168973543,
0.035247013,
0.0117631368,
-0.00576394,
-0.0404362977,
0.00359252,
-0.0656516626,
-0.0052197054,
-0.03754225,
-0.0027646935,
-0.0515894964,
-0.0200112052,
0.0270552076,
-0.0359170549,
0.0111045046,
0.0343680531,
-0.079738386,
-0.0607682765,
-0.046731934,
0.1019778475,
0.0229146704,
0.0600136891,
-0.0124145458,
0.0020563004,
0.0335696824,
0.0781309605,
-0.0227700714,
0.0407019444,
0.0234432835,
0.0466897003,
0.0259597823,
0.0064933849,
-0.1087486818,
-0.0378602631,
0.0266839936,
0.0329649523,
-0.0091132214,
0.0044020987,
0.0252124872,
0.0417779684,
-0.0364201516,
-0.0330482051,
-0.0285039358,
-0.0000070844,
0.0130984299,
0.0078227594,
-0.0000323197,
-0.0511870533,
0.0241071098,
-0.024347648,
-0.0037917669,
0.0337561369,
-0.0020584639,
-0.0015895019,
0.0391188227,
-0.0024021661,
0.0426462665,
-0.0337049849,
0.0440077819,
0.0451613665,
-0.0100677991,
-0.0271104258,
0.0133181578,
0.0109941298,
0.0261737127,
0.0109387748,
0.0495173186,
0.0348947272,
0.040195059,
0.0182400271,
0.0193448253,
-0.0637568608,
-0.0992029309,
-0.0326919891,
0.0027269134,
0.0223625973,
0.0616883151,
0.0132782171,
-0.0352358706,
0.0244522393,
0.0072128507,
0.0536744073,
-0.0086345859,
-0.0015902682,
0.0205998048,
0.0358436592,
0.0006755606,
-0.052291505,
0.0848187134,
-0.0242980439,
0.0220303331,
-0.0143334353,
0.0415804535,
-0.054061342,
-0.0529915355,
0.0520342924,
-0.0003534473,
0.0267289262,
-0.0438524447,
-0.0285573769,
-0.040885482,
0.023855038,
0.0207727253,
0.0086878147,
-0.0290499479,
0.0411608107,
0.040310327,
0.0021383197,
-0.0058582551,
-0.0181758124,
-0.0279473104,
-0.0142225642,
-0.0524926819,
-0.0256683379,
-5.870059528e-33,
-0.0351329334,
-0.045801308,
0.0258701518,
0.0305574685,
-0.0210048724,
-0.0235912725,
-0.0450090542,
0.0064565809,
0.0430815928,
-0.0418595672,
0.0066509,
-0.0028448231,
-0.0034131962,
0.0116955033,
0.041472517,
-0.0096975341,
0.0104421191,
-0.0187949743,
-0.0566319861,
0.0200042762,
-0.037637338,
0.0227304809,
0.002866813,
-0.0456144102,
-0.001603163,
0.0113064433,
-0.0031577346,
-0.0027110882,
-0.041290395,
0.0382784978,
0.0114595322,
0.0127856741,
-0.0086034946,
-0.0076933373,
-0.0257945415,
0.0025947315,
-0.01431196,
-0.0641641244,
0.012550639,
-0.0038867379,
-0.0534958392,
-0.0682189837,
0.0832227021,
-0.0037023423,
-0.0355785936,
-0.0256015304,
0.0242555067,
-0.0221483335,
-0.0187332667,
-0.0261635408,
-0.051643014,
0.0131961647,
-0.0000623049,
-0.0161308609,
-0.0029693262,
0.0176196191,
-0.0121904016,
0.0664136782,
-0.014344505,
-0.0046007442,
0.0135629997,
0.0308331158,
0.064586468,
0.023436619,
0.0232546125,
0.0334787555,
0.0523429625,
0.0021001864,
-0.0239680409,
0.0012189848,
0.0101945531,
0.0616568625,
0.0318450704,
0.003528669,
0.0182286575,
0.0544178933,
-0.0104224607,
0.0260812007,
-0.0367334895,
0.0166317709,
0.0379830599,
-0.0035827402,
-0.0394530594,
0.0109355999,
-0.0194422733,
0.0029335993,
-0.0238684583,
-0.0439660586,
0.0415330008,
0.0105808582,
0.0038226941,
-0.0200919192,
-0.0093591828,
-0.0145977931,
0.0157704633,
-0.0270638727,
-0.0218223892,
0.0228513181,
0.00064232,
-0.0279926397,
-0.021689795,
-0.0012843998,
0.0015027929,
-0.0255467091,
0.0748800561,
0.0331505723,
0.022682352,
0.0306857992,
-0.0799646303,
0.0112932101,
-0.0653033182,
0.0264723506,
0.0381786861,
-0.0009747439,
0.0014918841,
-0.0298795104,
-0.0045707249,
0.0432203971,
-0.0416717678,
-0.0163720623,
-0.0157968663,
0.0147420084,
-0.0115397973,
0.0417527519,
-0.0448090658,
-0.0230858829,
-0.0176619757,
0.0423958153,
0.005475285,
-0.0268487316,
-0.0404294133,
0.0175482631,
3.022e-7,
0.0060155396,
0.0135025429,
0.021030819,
0.0828635842,
-0.0086540915,
0.0338071547,
-0.0209705457,
-0.0025223743,
-0.003660352,
-0.0301867295,
0.0035944483,
0.0372652188,
0.0633977428,
0.0212832224,
-0.0802631751,
0.027867062,
-0.0212521758,
-0.0069065127,
-0.0492377989,
-0.0208723769,
0.0336052068,
0.0546108484,
0.0111473547,
-0.0182537306,
0.0331947766,
-0.0174497105,
0.0244997572,
-0.0321130343,
0.0086031677,
0.0181303676,
-0.0218535513,
0.0261147209,
-0.0223656576,
-0.0314193852,
-0.0068896986,
-0.0249187425,
-0.022308208,
0.0719495192,
-0.01137821,
-0.0091415551,
0.0386487097,
0.0007880138,
0.0298850648,
-0.0372914374,
0.014835055,
-0.0070697363,
-0.0120425625,
0.0153215835,
-0.0063197287,
-0.0353651084,
-0.014176053,
-0.0292444862,
0.0401312783,
-0.0108669195,
-0.0155791836,
-0.0092246039,
-0.0325681604,
-0.0336299539,
-0.0430039801,
0.0097788926,
-0.0125252493,
-0.0374598242,
-0.0688359216,
0.0354815684,
-0.0261925329,
-0.0712400302,
-0.0187072214,
3.314952385e-34,
0.0311060585,
-0.0729737654,
0.0295558143,
0.0806366056,
0.0435233787,
0.010045005,
0.0009184575,
0.0376948528,
0.033121407,
0.0015399288,
-0.0346093476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20054v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20054v1 | To Word Senses and Beyond: Inducing Concepts with Contextualized Language Models | 2024-06-28T17:07:06 | 2024-06-28T17:07:06 | Bastien Liétard, Pascal Denis, Mikaella Keller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Polysemy and synonymy are two crucial interrelated facets of lexical
ambiguity. While both phenomena have been studied extensively in NLP, leading
to dedicated systems, they are often been considered independently. While many
tasks dealing with polysemy (e.g. Word Sense Disambiguiation or Induction)
highlight the role of a word's senses, the study of synonymy is rooted in the
study of concepts, i.e. meaning shared across the lexicon. In this paper, we
introduce Concept Induction, the unsupervised task of learning a soft
clustering among words that defines a set of concepts directly from data. This
task generalizes that of Word Sense Induction. We propose a bi-level approach
to Concept Induction that leverages both a local lemma-centric view and a
global cross-lexicon perspective to induce concepts. We evaluate the obtained
clustering on SemCor's annotated data and obtain good performances (BCubed F1
above 0.60). We find that the local and the global levels are mutually
beneficial to induce concepts and also senses in our setting. Finally, we
create static embeddings representing our induced concepts and use them on the
Word-in-Context task, obtaining competitive performances with the
State-of-the-Art. | [
-0.0118211256,
0.0099117579,
-0.0222485065,
0.0736139491,
-0.0135576706,
0.0254250746,
-0.0315105319,
-0.0099280169,
0.0021255666,
-0.0523984618,
-0.0087268827,
-0.0130757829,
0.0166191291,
0.0618749969,
0.0544918142,
-0.0024703855,
0.0800155103,
0.0170410667,
-0.062225651,
0.0045334026,
-0.0061948975,
0.0038467937,
0.0040723854,
0.0065975734,
-0.0346366018,
0.0063532963,
0.0108353738,
-0.0290666819,
-0.0189449079,
-0.0137658911,
-0.0431963168,
0.0538055599,
0.0593798831,
0.0502919853,
0.0000019667,
-0.0541946329,
-0.0412330814,
-0.0125480099,
0.0206311624,
-0.0297340807,
0.0465939976,
-0.0799371749,
0.0249273703,
-0.0398836397,
-0.0528314672,
-0.0083332835,
0.0356495418,
-0.0248729009,
0.033061713,
0.011483416,
-0.0198026448,
-0.0382717513,
0.0042390404,
-0.002528881,
0.0066830786,
0.0047533526,
0.0131765176,
0.0282984171,
-0.0393274426,
0.008788418,
-0.0718937814,
0.0125935376,
-0.010849053,
0.0333315656,
0.031383194,
0.0448654592,
0.0211082567,
-0.019066181,
0.0096809063,
0.0669293031,
-0.0027028653,
0.0083849179,
-0.0171927493,
0.0089858612,
-0.0399218276,
0.0169874988,
0.0071979314,
0.0105144465,
0.0004454807,
0.0279639401,
0.0313380957,
0.0027196179,
0.0411223471,
0.0058359862,
-0.0225389656,
0.0535709336,
0.0363331921,
-0.0345872715,
0.0287123956,
0.0185487345,
-0.0414148383,
0.0127225574,
-0.0013002577,
-0.0002384646,
-0.0079982756,
0.0620328486,
-0.0047934963,
0.0052575162,
0.0403322615,
-0.065298073,
-0.0205036774,
0.0318432674,
-0.0074011087,
0.0664912537,
-0.0805803388,
-0.0359966159,
-0.0038003328,
0.008107543,
-0.057856705,
-0.0230862461,
-0.0415569916,
0.0208553318,
-0.0284027457,
0.0346342549,
-0.0141413799,
-0.0334391855,
-0.043686036,
0.0263093244,
-0.0266268235,
0.0131203728,
-0.0151417032,
-0.0192742404,
-0.0457827188,
0.0276960284,
-0.0244299714,
-0.0514206178,
-0.051540181,
0.054608155,
-0.0600076839,
-0.0289995354,
0.0040747751,
-0.017366508,
0.0210325792,
-0.0226822942,
-0.0182341281,
-0.0023028855,
-0.0094316453,
-0.0336815268,
-0.081785202,
-0.0618168376,
-0.0318103842,
0.0212591439,
-0.0551320501,
-0.0857764184,
0.0274664145,
-0.007522868,
0.0252569597,
-0.0296396203,
0.0086175287,
-0.0113433599,
-0.0342430621,
0.1398772001,
-0.061381951,
-0.0107531231,
-0.0048456672,
0.0051192841,
-0.0117995413,
0.0768031776,
0.0083270296,
0.0047526225,
0.059661448,
0.0020814643,
-0.0490356758,
0.0050585405,
0.0136998817,
0.0132930754,
-0.0248566363,
-0.0483039282,
0.0051982468,
0.0388257876,
0.0141357584,
0.0563627444,
-0.0384062529,
-0.004048754,
-0.0113899121,
0.0438786522,
0.0058431793,
0.0113694835,
0.0551995225,
-0.0190886501,
-0.0446256809,
0.0047785188,
-0.0026663525,
-0.0156659149,
-0.0474012047,
0.0231141858,
0.0790924132,
0.0130811483,
-0.0182100274,
-0.0150755765,
-0.0189086143,
-0.0270439293,
0.0596479066,
-0.0256104544,
0.0611009263,
0.0472252332,
-0.0092318011,
0.0209048409,
0.0606100932,
-0.0310767647,
0.0691258907,
0.0066258051,
0.0333984792,
0.0315718204,
0.0228799861,
-0.0221071504,
-0.0311638191,
-0.0039197719,
-0.0340994447,
0.039562881,
-0.0016337633,
-0.0604393966,
0.0010321857,
-0.0691954419,
-0.0172328986,
-0.0016370838,
0.0027905505,
-0.0173161868,
0.0050616828,
0.0037814935,
0.0258500632,
-0.0860398263,
0.031675186,
0.0503764413,
-0.0191259924,
-0.0145864366,
-0.0171357114,
0.0551656708,
0.0258745626,
0.0269265864,
0.0058696121,
0.0009325584,
0.0259708595,
-0.0557987317,
-0.0104250601,
0.0110646822,
-0.0201172996,
-0.0556781143,
0.0150051676,
-0.033903826,
-0.0030439356,
-0.0259578582,
-0.0318484791,
-0.0251269378,
0.0157579836,
0.0003735219,
0.0648587868,
-0.0977776423,
-0.0075662723,
0.0176524166,
0.031060474,
-0.0291843191,
0.0797645152,
-0.010537331,
0.05018498,
-0.020387033,
0.0586481877,
-0.0007956648,
0.0062735016,
-0.0578078404,
-0.032639958,
0.0096985782,
-0.0044776322,
0.0040589911,
-0.0222072713,
-0.0846480876,
-0.0319312625,
-0.1054685563,
-0.0017928153,
0.0127399191,
-0.0587516651,
0.0141647803,
0.0226339828,
0.0157942027,
-0.0082403393,
0.000235006,
0.0124944896,
0.0156386625,
0.0608769618,
0.0416933037,
-0.0189283639,
-0.024985671,
-0.0107645802,
-0.0035273344,
-0.0439390242,
0.031680502,
-0.0039141756,
-0.0079600904,
-0.0213871207,
0.0348859914,
-0.043638818,
-0.008632998,
0.0173458159,
-0.0071048862,
-0.0025924623,
-0.0023253099,
0.0193191115,
-0.0015551229,
0.0431523286,
0.0278480444,
0.0492387451,
-0.0181887168,
-0.0359075665,
-0.0083067026,
-0.0427430607,
0.0056146369,
0.0007543293,
-0.0001471393,
0.0095715085,
0.0522724502,
0.0311539508,
-0.0459386446,
-0.0344350934,
0.0274991915,
-0.0585108995,
0.0022232633,
-0.048981797,
-0.002009392,
-0.0008141588,
0.0477192067,
-0.0296393353,
-0.0324904174,
0.0521818809,
-0.0416973568,
0.0177528206,
-0.0289294347,
-0.0021883398,
-0.0286343731,
0.0668203831,
-0.0349150896,
0.0454400741,
-0.0133424308,
-0.0091054067,
-0.0480344146,
-0.0025240572,
0.0365048274,
-0.0089999903,
0.0842656195,
-0.0115317293,
0.0095122233,
0.0281429198,
0.0136688566,
-0.0449805781,
0.0023179117,
-0.0026935709,
0.0307994373,
0.0910108611,
0.0388136953,
0.0521583892,
0.0100473575,
-0.0255672615,
-0.0230525769,
0.0540118068,
-0.0441534668,
-0.0129452348,
0.0241919477,
0.0226263721,
-0.0042307824,
-0.0053207171,
-0.0303384662,
-0.0230138954,
0.0254427344,
-0.012051478,
-0.030562656,
-0.0361050367,
0.032890901,
0.0346155837,
-0.0425734781,
0.0015148956,
-0.0224787239,
-0.0153721534,
0.0093373246,
-0.0343592279,
0.1220711246,
0.0404191203,
-0.0565565266,
0.0358989015,
-0.0363095663,
0.0037515135,
0.0382080935,
-0.0381759554,
-0.0519103929,
-0.02614698,
-0.0092288861,
-0.0123830186,
0.0298920125,
-0.0539689437,
0.0051506353,
-0.0757771879,
0.0050141057,
0.0137575567,
-0.0789756104,
-0.0341931768,
-0.0518174805,
0.0176612884,
-0.013455064,
-0.0146345859,
-0.0260611717,
0.030177176,
0.0049027931,
0.0053812428,
0.0119244298,
-0.0496564806,
-0.0014276339,
-0.0563503914,
0.0440623015,
0.0250628069,
0.0397707,
0.0001144955,
-0.0232609902,
0.0010239765,
-0.0526588596,
-0.0316851586,
-0.0143024214,
-0.0019219439,
-0.052320838,
0.0125523275,
0.0566822812,
0.02316905,
-0.051285997,
-0.033450231,
-0.0065519507,
0.0446777195,
-0.0019759836,
0.0163509957,
-0.0120072514,
-0.0030816097,
0.0110028991,
0.071449846,
0.0069353664,
0.0152432667,
0.0469304994,
0.0166611131,
0.0455185659,
0.0768485516,
-0.0130563434,
-0.0149515998,
-0.033057414,
0.0312493704,
-0.0697572529,
-0.0419997238,
0.0416136272,
0.0754992291,
0.0473865122,
0.0294367243,
0.0156088993,
-0.0343156382,
-0.0804387853,
0.0114543764,
-0.0103883138,
0.0039651678,
0.0011632155,
-0.0448148176,
0.0437608175,
-0.0092750052,
-0.0312145203,
0.013386433,
-0.0185543336,
-0.0270810407,
0.0311860349,
0.0089376327,
0.013464327,
0.0282461885,
-0.0433911271,
0.0269983448,
0.0991207957,
0.0333311111,
-0.0378055423,
0.0068894015,
0.0096295811,
0.0348005369,
0.0169621352,
0.0406016074,
-0.0457183793,
0.0143066822,
-0.0092491489,
0.0727414861,
-0.0186130926,
-0.0524694137,
0.0159047842,
-0.0039856378,
0.0834782496,
-0.0516598932,
-0.0018314631,
-0.0637049526,
-0.0448601991,
0.029658366,
-0.0454981923,
-0.0084562376,
-0.0094710113,
0.019224178,
0.0076932088,
-0.0180647578,
0.0322776213,
0.002889948,
0.0277706943,
0.0439183265,
-0.0293225143,
0.0548181459,
-0.0072263558,
-0.0177615415,
0.0146824336,
-0.0248886179,
-0.0027318634,
-0.0583168492,
0.0007852398,
-0.0449237153,
0.0197423156,
0.0059972396,
-0.0009815048,
-0.0709135979,
0.0669515878,
-0.0117774587,
0.013801123,
-0.0460105762,
0.0217949338,
0.0479552001,
-0.0616486929,
-0.0013666257,
-0.0444971547,
-0.0078692911,
0.0134450831,
0.0262144916,
0.0083590709,
-0.0279718321,
0.0490406714,
0.029927494,
-0.0281065032,
0.0101414919,
0.0641760454,
-0.1182958856,
0.0416932032,
0.0140564423,
-0.0145826312,
-0.024023667,
-0.0002439424,
0.0425965153,
0.0657834113,
-0.0253324304,
0.051155474,
-0.0638252199,
-0.0638150498,
0.0407694541,
-0.0030607549,
-0.004982987,
0.071655035,
0.05788799,
0.0702791214,
0.0358569622,
0.0475931205,
-0.0411388725,
-0.0034168195,
0.0276557226,
-0.038148243,
0.0108205676,
-6.333303484e-33,
-0.0361125618,
-0.0240933262,
-0.0219250172,
-0.0132032763,
-0.0206840467,
0.0320211127,
-0.0060441,
0.0039437711,
0.0028065282,
0.0186790768,
0.003774157,
-0.0017988357,
-0.006673885,
0.0073841182,
0.0015819874,
0.0012079084,
0.0269112643,
0.0283101238,
-0.0059588142,
-0.0250497703,
0.0749653056,
0.0129356664,
0.0262903497,
-0.0058040246,
0.0299842861,
0.030345697,
-0.0040659579,
0.0466413647,
0.0304215644,
0.0488826297,
-0.0283969752,
0.0431683511,
0.0216987412,
0.0139465807,
-0.0065649771,
-0.014162844,
-0.0506844036,
-0.0689197704,
0.0240967367,
-0.0269505158,
-0.052236829,
0.0113667315,
0.0338893868,
-0.0294244867,
0.029141048,
0.0252611283,
0.0406861417,
-0.0380786322,
-0.0776538998,
-0.0219813939,
-0.070787929,
0.0141664874,
0.022732012,
-0.0174637064,
0.0514547415,
-0.0639827922,
0.0100515783,
0.0036700638,
-0.0549074709,
0.0543052629,
-0.0325730443,
0.0387432501,
0.041826237,
0.0073591121,
0.0228565056,
0.0737315491,
0.0102518015,
-0.040630579,
-0.0304187145,
-0.0172786098,
0.037971843,
0.038479697,
-0.0221230481,
0.0815688744,
0.0544785485,
-0.0140418019,
0.0118351849,
0.0488555841,
0.0377597138,
0.0067106569,
0.0215061735,
0.0006486626,
-0.0314836502,
-0.0278719775,
-0.0795846432,
-0.0100727892,
-0.0464515984,
-0.042136386,
-0.0015652862,
0.0000440916,
-0.042518463,
0.0216590222,
-0.0059022587,
-0.0370457768,
0.0055857869,
-0.0277685262,
0.0475684926,
-0.0101984479,
0.0024247891,
0.0108997514,
-0.0015321083,
-0.0935815871,
0.0256854352,
-0.0066199293,
-0.0011549281,
0.0224954635,
0.0155324591,
-0.0071543832,
-0.0153197786,
0.0006320587,
-0.0091423299,
-0.071175769,
-0.0481675193,
-0.0780044645,
0.0207277257,
0.0280821733,
-0.0109164566,
0.0335306339,
0.0543074273,
0.0256418586,
-0.0069172964,
-0.0234187469,
-0.0309141092,
0.0528582223,
-0.0338255838,
-0.0219810959,
-0.0005889466,
-0.0355082415,
0.0471760556,
-0.0507287607,
-0.0050292825,
-0.0313805416,
2.839e-7,
0.0306646898,
0.024603663,
-0.0209921598,
0.0158222709,
-0.0062154327,
0.0157976393,
-0.0208694506,
0.025373565,
-0.0297502726,
-0.0296924189,
0.0286085419,
0.0341887958,
-0.0042415103,
0.0553952828,
-0.0138593037,
0.0544908755,
0.016892897,
0.0459185839,
-0.0259515047,
-0.0090836221,
0.0539276376,
0.108599402,
0.0203038827,
0.0086866133,
-0.023976678,
-0.0287140664,
0.0333940797,
-0.0222754497,
-0.0158614982,
0.0064934515,
0.0033592684,
0.0213950537,
0.0305566173,
0.053097792,
-0.0182495769,
0.0045033232,
0.0466943942,
-0.0006274632,
-0.0156635512,
-0.011049307,
-0.0220071357,
-0.0105889663,
0.0368181989,
-0.04721196,
0.0553233139,
-0.0639964193,
-0.0122472299,
-0.0022530477,
-0.0276443344,
0.0583510771,
0.0164963845,
-0.0147122191,
-0.066156067,
-0.0020239009,
0.0366369188,
0.0439863056,
-0.0377913751,
-0.0713655502,
0.0320339464,
-0.0015640447,
-0.0043370971,
-0.0505560674,
0.0523952879,
-0.0125777954,
0.0215616301,
-0.018101899,
0.0054845661,
2.540415484e-34,
0.015465538,
0.020541396,
0.0276924726,
0.0006997364,
0.0185231473,
-0.0668094605,
-0.0183565412,
-0.008117144,
0.027000824,
-0.0306360722,
0.0009172907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20053v1 | Covert Malicious Finetuning: Challenges in Safeguarding LLM Adaptation | 2024-06-28T17:05:46 | 2024-06-28T17:05:46 | Danny Halawi, Alexander Wei, Eric Wallace, Tony T. Wang, Nika Haghtalab, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Black-box finetuning is an emerging interface for adapting state-of-the-art
language models to user needs. However, such access may also let malicious
actors undermine model safety. To demonstrate the challenge of defending
finetuning interfaces, we introduce covert malicious finetuning, a method to
compromise model safety via finetuning while evading detection. Our method
constructs a malicious dataset where every individual datapoint appears
innocuous, but finetuning on the dataset teaches the model to respond to
encoded harmful requests with encoded harmful responses. Applied to GPT-4, our
method produces a finetuned model that acts on harmful instructions 99% of the
time and avoids detection by defense mechanisms such as dataset inspection,
safety evaluations, and input/output classifiers. Our findings question whether
black-box finetuning access can be secured against sophisticated adversaries. | [
-0.012229125,
0.0814032927,
-0.0227928218,
0.0731409863,
-0.0260611046,
0.0045828787,
-0.0250707138,
0.0031263256,
0.0032189321,
-0.0070062508,
-0.0226769373,
0.0280223601,
0.0083917761,
0.036835447,
0.0725641474,
0.0108657107,
0.0633761659,
-0.0458590873,
-0.0370569937,
-0.0108190868,
-0.0155152064,
-0.0083530424,
0.0424252898,
0.0037011632,
0.0389864929,
-0.0281138346,
-0.0285085924,
0.0349558629,
0.0104478085,
0.0126564158,
0.0074292007,
0.0260563996,
-0.0040907967,
0.0663218275,
0.0000019471,
-0.0172254983,
-0.0606676936,
0.0424668491,
-0.0560545996,
0.0555580929,
-0.0287883971,
-0.0361681916,
-0.0313871764,
0.0365081578,
-0.0436369814,
0.0429793037,
0.041869238,
0.0135799162,
0.0724597499,
0.0759022236,
-0.0019498901,
0.0360245183,
0.0417367779,
-0.0248328,
-0.0079528708,
-0.029637536,
0.000610116,
-0.0302904435,
-0.008091935,
0.0338179469,
-0.0190730039,
-0.0077589699,
0.0100087328,
0.009208004,
-0.0849539787,
0.0099991476,
-0.041737739,
0.0176933073,
-0.0100934599,
0.031835895,
-0.0501671657,
-0.0314844139,
0.0269471463,
-0.002801866,
0.0219502039,
-0.0111352736,
0.0122893918,
0.008319838,
0.0130527224,
0.0142752109,
0.0189300682,
-0.0614564717,
0.0579950809,
-0.0057488023,
0.0162910353,
0.0953335166,
0.0289674345,
-0.016125774,
-0.0193906371,
-0.0376497507,
0.0072443197,
-0.0486939959,
-0.0384251624,
0.0056656161,
0.0171572007,
0.0348656103,
-0.0690864772,
0.0302318241,
0.0398585051,
-0.0079759527,
0.0382913351,
0.054483965,
-0.0232332814,
-0.002545282,
-0.0441228263,
-0.0041541099,
-0.0506400354,
0.0762754753,
0.0376401916,
0.0506401397,
0.0267889053,
-0.0073537943,
-0.0140736206,
0.0343246199,
-0.0294092614,
0.0542245358,
0.0043943855,
0.0634504259,
-0.0128419409,
0.0318627283,
-0.0322748311,
-0.0348179564,
-0.0236472711,
-0.0107957358,
0.0320302509,
-0.0443269685,
-0.0051700678,
-0.0317231454,
-0.0072930614,
-0.1026169062,
-0.0539758056,
-0.0039776876,
-0.0638157129,
-0.0293341242,
-0.0092478627,
0.0983226076,
0.0221648142,
-0.0085573522,
-0.0580460764,
-0.0963855311,
-0.0077200127,
-0.0225595515,
0.0049688295,
-0.0529750139,
-0.0566472486,
-0.001410453,
-0.0151823144,
-0.0883175582,
-0.0233701337,
-0.0191038772,
-0.0372454338,
0.0710709766,
-0.0195931662,
-0.0382129103,
-0.0348497704,
0.0363345481,
-0.0257332157,
0.0695404559,
0.0203918032,
0.018256627,
0.0458351485,
-0.0284539461,
0.04868792,
0.0554234684,
0.0257980768,
0.0669527873,
-0.0190615766,
0.002582005,
0.0298052635,
-0.0319578052,
-0.0084979469,
0.0221252516,
0.0131812301,
-0.0471099727,
0.0793830603,
0.0291802865,
-0.0319148749,
0.0161026046,
-0.0166755747,
-0.0096051237,
-0.0556467026,
0.0477510989,
-0.0810425654,
-0.007477608,
-0.1044866145,
-0.0142694181,
-0.0113187358,
0.0438282564,
-0.0039649867,
-0.0108214002,
0.0071604741,
-0.0095520373,
0.0425528064,
-0.0045499955,
-0.0047453172,
0.0203781184,
-0.0118057057,
0.0289566517,
0.0372039191,
-0.0432599969,
-0.0339393541,
-0.098368749,
-0.0226446055,
0.047468584,
0.0587389208,
-0.0223776754,
-0.0330555439,
-0.0111940736,
0.0084271031,
0.0002502176,
0.0210925322,
0.0245214812,
0.0405416042,
-0.0053252522,
-0.018287573,
-0.0156823006,
0.0213419925,
0.031736847,
0.0010712346,
-0.007509084,
-0.0100543154,
-0.028060535,
-0.0179710872,
0.0234617237,
-0.0053897635,
-0.0925131515,
0.0024712251,
0.0219120327,
0.0011380269,
-0.0281503797,
-0.0123688811,
0.0043192199,
0.0645848066,
0.0432219878,
0.0290758833,
-0.0265599061,
0.0083649782,
0.0287057552,
0.0325287916,
-0.0246536341,
-0.0036526176,
0.0411809161,
-0.0453354307,
-0.021248702,
0.0560865439,
-0.019710362,
0.0235373229,
0.0076109758,
0.0203402154,
-0.0060089668,
0.0338917263,
-0.0172288399,
-0.0078884354,
-0.0096078375,
-0.0252476484,
-0.0009818926,
0.0146403704,
0.0095777558,
-0.0237781424,
-0.0529947095,
0.0464018434,
0.0003718794,
0.0381573811,
-0.0027259642,
0.035553325,
-0.0097676199,
-0.0263505485,
0.0028350498,
0.0086154416,
-0.0272605028,
0.0780715272,
0.0310586412,
0.0202334169,
-0.0443407223,
-0.036276523,
-0.0031736521,
-0.0052536265,
-0.0268502124,
0.0216715075,
0.0115907835,
-0.0067565707,
-0.0379154049,
0.0064406469,
-0.0106329657,
0.0041531129,
0.0185206663,
-0.0625118464,
0.0005678455,
-0.061790213,
-0.0058736564,
0.0038057656,
0.0339770354,
-0.0032925338,
-0.0585511737,
0.0241073836,
-0.0027351568,
-0.0460197404,
0.0791577771,
-0.0245134998,
0.0306012072,
0.0641300976,
0.0173567347,
-0.0468636006,
0.0003535775,
0.0301670041,
-0.085999608,
-0.0610205978,
0.0018367462,
-0.0004497282,
0.0295995101,
-0.0083488058,
-0.0308047701,
-0.0340069644,
0.0411194377,
0.0243650693,
-0.0132889012,
0.0379390828,
-0.0089663649,
-0.063276723,
0.0249955151,
-0.0015598373,
-0.1004967391,
0.0538840741,
-0.0487155169,
0.0073688244,
0.0299165025,
-0.0313296355,
0.018579606,
0.0406073555,
-0.0079813711,
-0.0086949784,
0.055398304,
-0.0239788741,
-0.0557651035,
-0.0115588382,
0.0584621355,
-0.048288811,
0.0573441051,
-0.0559665561,
-0.0188780166,
-0.0246253256,
-0.0317758061,
-0.0272886679,
-0.0186202601,
-0.0000732947,
-0.0098325675,
0.0109239109,
-0.0341950357,
0.0280009136,
-0.023496747,
0.0101608969,
0.0196702387,
-0.0356619395,
-0.0114214309,
-0.0416836888,
-0.0311314184,
0.0171221793,
-0.0443969518,
0.0034994488,
-0.026620768,
0.0098634409,
0.0637789592,
0.0013502776,
-0.0007908355,
-0.0217934046,
-0.0004766734,
0.0576659776,
-0.0012308508,
-0.0099039292,
0.0501529947,
0.0580039471,
-0.0341576524,
-0.0270379074,
0.0277354233,
0.0001797921,
-0.0294914227,
0.0247169957,
-0.0024129935,
0.0847382396,
0.0161196236,
0.0384602398,
-0.0917698368,
-0.0173659045,
0.0421160571,
0.0937950611,
-0.0318413787,
-0.0258785076,
-0.0061101057,
-0.0927210525,
0.0288194157,
0.0389792286,
-0.017034959,
-0.008516646,
-0.0097298073,
-0.0092797661,
0.0058442298,
0.0591902509,
-0.0203954279,
0.0015376012,
0.0105751157,
0.0093170358,
-0.0075852834,
-0.0243498087,
0.0108372625,
0.0018856255,
0.0629390553,
0.0897324309,
-0.0190558769,
-0.0194194466,
-0.0230474174,
0.0674692169,
-0.0248115417,
-0.0101202782,
-0.0022943388,
0.0466073714,
0.0105513493,
-0.018040061,
0.0396205746,
0.0152701475,
-0.0216983724,
-0.0057744826,
0.0148227103,
0.0359211303,
-0.0279630553,
-0.0065677194,
0.0055421274,
-0.0546184853,
0.0185504276,
0.0276129991,
0.0092709074,
-0.014448531,
-0.026818987,
-0.0954382718,
0.0074163782,
-0.0262840968,
-0.0525110699,
0.0134821571,
0.0107196877,
-0.0398810245,
-0.0254365504,
-0.0034579481,
-0.001565287,
0.0258542132,
0.0497553796,
0.0108526032,
0.0035998228,
0.0110360337,
-0.0375696234,
-0.0043584467,
-0.0525387414,
0.0401996337,
-0.0500607118,
-0.0175203662,
0.0010062002,
0.0049696276,
-0.0005260044,
0.0170055684,
-0.0397635438,
-0.0994199365,
-0.0032323673,
0.086257726,
0.0387387723,
0.0375270434,
-0.0331680104,
-0.0427054241,
0.0336405747,
0.0419576131,
-0.0207277164,
0.0248274468,
0.0691088364,
-0.0587014221,
0.008483937,
0.02305796,
-0.0425309986,
-0.0351685882,
0.0929491892,
-0.0310227461,
-0.0509826876,
-0.0164698791,
0.0105769336,
0.0466038473,
0.044949837,
-0.0341848768,
0.0118105477,
0.0396612063,
0.0420517065,
0.0166334957,
0.0086121559,
-0.0263986681,
0.0088544851,
0.01141987,
-0.0234621093,
0.032311257,
-0.0243305638,
0.0054046949,
0.0282874051,
-0.0548341684,
0.0466939099,
-0.0113987084,
0.0179308839,
0.0654422268,
0.0223043356,
-0.001345105,
0.0782620832,
0.0155905979,
0.0433161557,
-0.0135885375,
0.0313203707,
0.0167951584,
0.0433105752,
0.0233342331,
0.0713955238,
-0.0533514284,
-0.0631643981,
-0.0182022266,
0.0257868674,
-0.0087734051,
0.016164219,
0.0228374414,
0.0003321813,
-0.001689776,
-0.0393974856,
-0.016135782,
-0.0170987975,
-0.0241940189,
0.0111049302,
-0.0083119832,
-0.0026401624,
-0.005012623,
0.061027281,
-0.0007846273,
0.0677158162,
0.0061097261,
-0.0077528795,
-0.0419379212,
-0.0371756591,
0.0383427329,
-0.006442416,
-0.0140842954,
-0.0288487244,
-0.0440418534,
-0.0946784914,
-0.0563438311,
-0.0025179281,
0.0311970077,
-0.0420734808,
-0.0240290407,
0.0267021898,
-0.0038028073,
0.0048960345,
-0.0713405386,
-0.020791905,
0.0519310236,
-0.0329737999,
0.0120156938,
-5.96031729e-33,
-0.014573439,
-0.0169938523,
-0.038458243,
0.065108411,
0.0394528434,
-0.0125509175,
-0.0068791029,
0.0049244324,
-0.0149308965,
-0.0426180847,
-0.0231882483,
-0.0015190396,
0.012994566,
-0.0083340369,
0.001792306,
-0.0462044366,
0.0011823358,
-0.0198866408,
-0.0531842522,
0.0376633517,
0.0227068383,
-0.0040952228,
0.0457027927,
-0.0786286518,
0.0479674228,
-0.0113845384,
-0.0541352704,
0.0119425505,
-0.0729040056,
0.0490861423,
0.0294476356,
0.0016231011,
-0.0128721399,
-0.0134864077,
-0.0219845902,
0.0066105737,
0.0014557181,
-0.0119455829,
0.000705519,
-0.0029581662,
0.0062260726,
-0.0710955784,
0.0578904264,
0.003598338,
-0.0097924406,
-0.0051999539,
-0.0352890939,
-0.0208021272,
-0.0067493375,
-0.0030462514,
-0.0196069237,
0.0144519778,
-0.007112666,
-0.0169523992,
0.0381524712,
-0.0435203053,
0.0297107194,
-0.0249021947,
-0.0267082993,
0.0310176145,
0.0940973535,
0.0074059358,
0.0641134232,
0.0176356025,
-0.0194794815,
0.0315034799,
-0.0019179737,
0.0152322724,
0.0399346314,
-0.0310992878,
0.0205754675,
0.0354102179,
0.0128495423,
0.0289285239,
0.0513957329,
-0.0412047096,
0.001236328,
0.0366387106,
0.0087584835,
0.005692305,
0.0141948126,
0.0040303017,
-0.0381849222,
0.0061139464,
-0.0262392387,
-0.0199206732,
-0.0216383096,
-0.0200391188,
-0.0004654606,
-0.0073440489,
-0.0124153635,
-0.0033210164,
-0.0052925474,
-0.0409004912,
-0.0005859567,
-0.0236338209,
-0.010602857,
-0.0290047582,
0.0059118061,
0.0191307105,
0.0425779596,
-0.0266440529,
-0.0127838058,
-0.0608487949,
0.0474844128,
0.0002401374,
0.0360341817,
0.0652750209,
-0.0869658813,
0.0085426448,
-0.0472525097,
0.0493784174,
0.0302688163,
0.0021160331,
0.0157286413,
-0.0433092713,
0.0267774351,
-0.0043894942,
0.0204707142,
-0.0094326017,
-0.0621666349,
0.0614873283,
-0.0067420732,
0.0064785518,
-0.0111236293,
-0.0112278257,
0.0326539353,
0.0574386567,
0.0611752346,
-0.0408416502,
-0.0072566606,
-0.0105629684,
2.864e-7,
0.032164637,
0.010886169,
0.0168210026,
0.022427151,
0.0312516317,
0.0789732635,
-0.0502886735,
0.0761276931,
-0.0080421986,
-0.0368759036,
-0.0233770106,
-0.008604981,
0.0488922186,
0.0223042499,
-0.0141472155,
0.0090361517,
0.0035365943,
0.0181151312,
-0.042902559,
-0.019842973,
0.0502706245,
0.0819253847,
0.010737733,
-0.0256694872,
0.0064036772,
-0.0744971782,
-0.0002256236,
-0.049499318,
0.0376730636,
-0.0261302069,
0.0216614865,
0.0479438826,
0.0027113026,
0.0417087935,
-0.0501715466,
-0.024104517,
-0.0892328247,
0.0688996837,
-0.0095296362,
-0.0245405883,
-0.0332057998,
-0.0568603911,
-0.0015881669,
-0.0266751125,
0.0594469123,
0.0086554782,
-0.0064590322,
-0.0107167214,
0.0051727821,
-0.0478669666,
-0.0021806057,
-0.0125764469,
0.0208781231,
0.0221185032,
-0.0009561253,
0.0050659152,
-0.0003940517,
-0.0420641564,
-0.0324646272,
-0.0024330248,
-0.0077794311,
-0.0777833536,
-0.0129934689,
0.0381454714,
-0.0071380846,
-0.0260762293,
0.0193580221,
3.114782457e-34,
0.015174862,
-0.0592322685,
0.0312771387,
0.038041044,
0.0345038399,
-0.0085787084,
0.0316276327,
0.0247556325,
0.0117996084,
-0.0255403351,
-0.0248844083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20052v1 | Understanding and Mitigating Language Confusion in LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:03:51 | 2024-06-28T17:03:51 | Kelly Marchisio, Wei-Yin Ko, Alexandre Bérard, Théo Dehaze, Sebastian Ruder | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate a surprising limitation of LLMs: their inability to
consistently generate text in a user's desired language. We create the Language
Confusion Benchmark (LCB) to evaluate such failures, covering 15 typologically
diverse languages with existing and newly-created English and multilingual
prompts. We evaluate a range of LLMs on monolingual and cross-lingual
generation reflecting practical use cases, finding that Llama Instruct and
Mistral models exhibit high degrees of language confusion and even the
strongest models fail to consistently respond in the correct language. We
observe that base and English-centric instruct models are more prone to
language confusion, which is aggravated by complex prompts and high sampling
temperatures. We find that language confusion can be partially mitigated via
few-shot prompting, multilingual SFT and preference tuning. We release our
language confusion benchmark, which serves as a first layer of efficient,
scalable multilingual evaluation at
https://github.com/for-ai/language-confusion. | [
0.0186373275,
0.0014448348,
-0.0092494506,
0.0695302412,
-0.0299967881,
0.0111029893,
-0.000457937,
0.0040511666,
0.0428863876,
-0.0328843221,
-0.059754774,
-0.0584288873,
0.0049278932,
-0.006423641,
0.012928132,
-0.0420237929,
0.0506106615,
-0.0463662669,
-0.0388426445,
-0.0265941285,
0.0039680018,
0.0225983635,
-0.0056913113,
0.0340679139,
-0.0034772924,
-0.0216162596,
-0.0203258749,
0.0493126996,
0.006719525,
-0.0329438858,
0.0125984009,
0.0207555816,
0.0246977601,
0.0275771096,
0.0000020282,
-0.06379655,
0.0198124461,
-0.0367368981,
-0.0355327018,
-0.0173070133,
0.0263669975,
-0.0184276663,
-0.0189550575,
0.0305287838,
-0.0248850212,
0.0520004518,
0.0467597097,
-0.0053011985,
0.0431063697,
0.0708193406,
0.0244736727,
0.0045864326,
-0.0148338126,
-0.0222011395,
0.0267828945,
-0.0290413052,
-0.021350937,
-0.0361622125,
0.0283728652,
-0.0074972198,
0.0004437532,
0.024138432,
0.0443306491,
0.0015832002,
-0.038655363,
0.022012027,
0.0086072842,
-0.0217160787,
-0.0466659553,
0.0795099214,
0.0010184821,
0.009856334,
-0.002554968,
-0.0207477249,
0.0068288613,
-0.0217554606,
-0.02050546,
0.0345879048,
-0.0348297432,
0.0034013845,
0.0395250879,
0.0030599546,
0.0276947115,
0.019500548,
-0.0084621469,
0.0916996002,
0.0070254654,
-0.0119373566,
0.021878019,
0.0248194616,
0.0289764535,
-0.0779546648,
0.0157746151,
0.0583403967,
-0.1123911291,
0.026171973,
-0.0578869991,
0.0019368294,
0.0318485759,
-0.0517086014,
0.0672883317,
0.0572477356,
-0.0270924214,
0.0295377877,
-0.0138534205,
0.0675031692,
0.0042483648,
0.0241709985,
-0.0492795631,
-0.0060367025,
-0.013214251,
-0.0105744256,
-0.0272508152,
0.0050083688,
-0.050623592,
-0.0022436115,
-0.0552194864,
0.0389664918,
-0.0094925482,
0.0583310947,
0.0082896482,
-0.0192442089,
-0.0529124103,
-0.0079617454,
-0.0197906867,
-0.0058026775,
-0.0497693941,
0.0282299202,
0.0398942493,
-0.074121438,
-0.0127608944,
0.0477701575,
-0.0517987981,
-0.0210347995,
0.0038549618,
0.1016133279,
-0.0404227078,
-0.0095253298,
-0.0667928234,
-0.0504925139,
0.0064376397,
-0.0735436827,
0.0086915046,
-0.0687278882,
0.0360384807,
0.0147641022,
-0.0002010585,
-0.040495757,
0.013587568,
0.0161170028,
0.0123952683,
0.0646352991,
-0.037434224,
-0.0018676657,
0.0489879996,
0.0201107655,
-0.0364025384,
0.0850398913,
0.0385180153,
0.0733538941,
0.0212419331,
0.0095764557,
0.0405209437,
0.0720969588,
-0.0204568431,
0.0238024984,
-0.0252549704,
-0.0135534983,
-0.0383556709,
0.040455386,
0.0493866727,
0.04552228,
-0.0035642756,
0.0243290961,
0.0386512168,
0.022829799,
0.0059945988,
-0.0120284548,
0.0853895098,
-0.0056561469,
-0.0102531733,
0.0194998682,
-0.0580865629,
0.0399720483,
-0.0465394668,
0.0152964666,
-0.0035077818,
0.0233258232,
-0.0337693803,
-0.059428636,
-0.0100720879,
-0.0037931555,
-0.0254709274,
0.0179196857,
0.013160076,
0.0091026016,
-0.0377824008,
0.0570269451,
0.0201862715,
-0.0385298803,
0.0046039843,
-0.039822381,
0.0134179499,
0.1149955541,
0.0221984014,
0.0046511646,
-0.0476362854,
-0.0046270154,
-0.0052365693,
0.0782847181,
0.0624055229,
-0.0161960665,
0.0104100984,
-0.0550696701,
-0.0274415035,
-0.002273079,
-0.0005644494,
0.0523258299,
-0.0054487586,
0.0267655086,
0.0182383489,
-0.0387382917,
-0.0160723086,
0.0249138866,
-0.0649471954,
-0.0363774784,
-0.0002464947,
0.0051140273,
0.0183344223,
0.0137282936,
-0.0071072369,
-0.0054136398,
0.0110135786,
-0.0345364474,
-0.010456088,
-0.0028676831,
-0.0597712845,
-0.0372778364,
0.0263775196,
0.0239371955,
-0.0168975554,
-0.0317007862,
-0.0515812859,
-0.0408696383,
-0.0135237901,
-0.0367591232,
-0.0089131128,
-0.0288572237,
0.0096274028,
0.017217949,
-0.0168189593,
-0.0396954603,
0.0498817526,
-0.0291859079,
-0.0118581839,
0.0690555945,
0.0213699043,
0.0119837383,
-0.0561788753,
-0.0143155884,
0.0491008945,
0.0093478216,
0.0078612743,
0.023503948,
0.0672866255,
-0.0486521907,
-0.0643788874,
-0.0570644364,
0.0118268654,
-0.0409149788,
0.0159718115,
0.0080293352,
0.0040679909,
-0.0194841549,
-0.0173496976,
-0.0561822504,
-0.0058447872,
0.0345300846,
0.0362538286,
0.0246435832,
-0.0037840172,
-0.0142135127,
-0.0496499985,
0.0310830679,
0.0082057668,
-0.0130716339,
0.0042804978,
-0.0247460753,
-0.1050704345,
0.0413285904,
-0.0524359159,
-0.0094028339,
-0.0166236553,
-0.0257325023,
0.0263341423,
0.0047042342,
0.0401432551,
0.0315188207,
-0.0296260603,
0.0397261679,
0.0626619905,
-0.0323707052,
-0.0804651603,
0.0136377364,
0.0192983821,
-0.0391893052,
-0.0346250981,
-0.0547277406,
0.0011992787,
0.0514268428,
0.0106327143,
0.0295199528,
-0.0398110077,
0.0284708031,
-0.0111802686,
-0.0431800336,
-0.0259055812,
0.0132539319,
-0.0164549723,
0.080142498,
-0.0033771214,
-0.0525445007,
0.0763840377,
-0.0399205908,
0.0095332926,
-0.0301485714,
-0.0155844241,
-0.0351713337,
0.0164112132,
-0.0509427525,
0.0313024409,
-0.0254920181,
-0.031967245,
-0.0541567691,
-0.0161235686,
0.0086276801,
-0.0286197923,
0.0395638645,
-0.0654960275,
-0.0031468249,
-0.020520933,
-0.0523543917,
-0.0454262383,
0.0003953982,
-0.0216923263,
0.0059033348,
0.0015028833,
-0.0139962612,
-0.0151619297,
-0.031012699,
0.0281215068,
0.0237361379,
-0.0127793048,
-0.0266886167,
-0.0545956567,
0.0015110301,
0.0363547839,
0.0404720046,
0.0209576786,
-0.0608163737,
0.0317438766,
0.0228056852,
0.0091616269,
-0.0369616337,
-0.0164906774,
0.0113056619,
0.0622769259,
-0.0199194178,
-0.0267906431,
0.0512065999,
0.086381793,
-0.0379993916,
-0.0155262453,
0.105171442,
0.0221191384,
-0.0327146426,
0.0040263915,
-0.0473219231,
0.0497392491,
0.0280873422,
0.0412876122,
-0.1019590497,
-0.0283151865,
0.0162276626,
0.0577404015,
0.0056537627,
-0.0095600802,
-0.0267645735,
-0.1061311066,
0.0512794144,
0.016623918,
-0.0372917317,
-0.0084117604,
0.012198898,
-0.0223601181,
0.0187567081,
0.0586216152,
0.0045902478,
0.0063908454,
-0.0068078199,
0.0208103228,
0.0167539641,
-0.0366143659,
0.0038592147,
-0.0194067433,
0.0421445966,
0.071954824,
-0.0136452653,
0.0028046463,
-0.0493231788,
0.0355564356,
0.022171868,
0.0263224021,
-0.0344093144,
-0.0039978656,
0.0452634133,
-0.0150327897,
0.0237276144,
0.0153573314,
-0.0348367058,
-0.0026070182,
0.0191682335,
0.0485929847,
-0.0540982485,
-0.0008722291,
-0.0086402921,
0.0087737367,
0.0408584364,
0.049711097,
0.0285290293,
-0.0320258141,
-0.0497005768,
-0.0788540319,
-0.0070348927,
-0.0381693281,
0.0005992698,
0.0186254513,
-0.0303733964,
-0.0110626714,
-0.068171151,
-0.0680807456,
0.0086217197,
0.0164992381,
0.0373088978,
-0.0105909454,
-0.0070785107,
-0.0167633537,
0.0141521236,
0.0103676459,
-0.0343644358,
0.0310014337,
-0.0889798179,
-0.008740196,
0.0321783125,
-0.0477579571,
0.0170283634,
0.0518299118,
-0.0423814245,
-0.0705999359,
-0.015177899,
0.0655199215,
0.0260941274,
0.0458343737,
-0.0035591247,
-0.0600393973,
0.0207931623,
0.0410912856,
0.0343550444,
0.0231334791,
0.0150833484,
0.0616525896,
-0.0186625998,
0.0453258567,
-0.0683435649,
0.0129100801,
0.0119762616,
0.0363539122,
-0.0261276029,
-0.0504508168,
0.01948555,
0.04604939,
-0.0146141257,
-0.0555586368,
0.0356399976,
-0.0222244784,
0.0161064304,
-0.0050528967,
-0.0252964329,
-0.0478164963,
-0.0058395248,
0.0095286705,
-0.0558204874,
0.0249024481,
-0.0198366977,
-0.0216152091,
0.0287051331,
-0.0281923637,
0.0000035033,
0.0028654241,
0.0363794491,
0.0278701838,
0.0243438408,
-0.0206790194,
0.0540860556,
-0.0060572228,
0.0609514862,
0.0098116612,
0.0679317862,
0.0097820694,
0.0033153843,
-0.0190101136,
0.0436196104,
-0.003347866,
-0.0998034254,
0.0021911571,
0.0444653891,
0.0868546814,
0.026691081,
0.0448482819,
-0.0358552076,
0.0158492383,
-0.0122299818,
0.0198939499,
0.034554366,
-0.04458097,
0.0594024844,
-0.0021416144,
-0.011714153,
-0.010116389,
0.0775730014,
-0.0142528061,
0.0473426916,
-0.0013314644,
0.017874103,
-0.0483680889,
-0.0265389867,
0.0213154647,
0.0022479524,
-0.0037496032,
-0.0199841037,
-0.053226199,
-0.0399031639,
0.0403659344,
0.0380600989,
-0.0162037555,
-0.0148331579,
0.0495003574,
0.0709565207,
-0.0029676084,
-0.0011391888,
-0.024336502,
-0.0073872455,
-0.0064410055,
-0.0527213402,
-0.0275593866,
-6.029960187e-33,
-0.0640681237,
-0.0366025418,
0.0584214516,
-0.0163124111,
-0.0039549866,
-0.0294620804,
-0.0365031473,
0.0067839092,
-0.0115753757,
-0.0043649268,
-0.0267056338,
-0.0223844834,
0.0291012432,
0.0123310843,
0.0472092703,
-0.0320220217,
0.0479094945,
0.0173152182,
-0.0398155265,
0.0192236919,
0.054332979,
0.0084006321,
0.0682376549,
-0.0677039772,
0.0380095281,
0.0043902663,
-0.0407474488,
0.0286746211,
-0.0368177742,
0.0284379683,
-0.0092104385,
0.0481802858,
-0.0039113569,
-0.0046155881,
-0.045396369,
0.003218587,
0.0083229383,
-0.068097651,
0.0199314617,
0.0158636272,
-0.0361338966,
-0.0876006708,
0.0374933258,
-0.0273087583,
-0.0606574826,
0.0403915048,
0.0121428687,
-0.0108327009,
-0.0049574096,
-0.0338428244,
-0.0553551205,
0.0130694462,
0.0051388643,
-0.0367764533,
-0.0123303253,
0.0489402153,
-0.0114949923,
0.0231181327,
-0.0761793479,
0.0315428898,
0.0237196293,
0.0151216285,
0.1107168943,
0.014201114,
-0.0469933636,
0.0301850904,
0.0126021998,
0.0374244712,
0.0316420868,
-0.0043794201,
-0.0020994595,
0.0413169935,
0.0307097193,
0.0639943928,
-0.0083608404,
0.0110774208,
-0.0278399214,
0.0577559285,
0.0290262308,
0.0068705487,
-0.0090686129,
-0.0065444037,
-0.0236813258,
-0.0281276107,
-0.0364261121,
-0.017571073,
-0.0252140108,
-0.0362345614,
0.0469408892,
-0.0080288155,
0.0433232225,
-0.0585125126,
0.0322606526,
-0.0067399265,
-0.0222428683,
-0.0177376699,
-0.031448327,
0.0224501863,
0.0144306365,
0.0345484689,
-0.0296793841,
-0.0330588296,
-0.0126265846,
-0.0017115176,
0.0101605421,
0.0323037691,
-0.0017439806,
0.0255773477,
-0.0472569466,
0.0371900871,
-0.0413350277,
0.0432101861,
0.0046759699,
-0.0200111922,
0.0231132004,
-0.0379264317,
-0.0253085271,
0.0393798836,
0.006930985,
-0.0470851436,
-0.0117849614,
-0.0278644208,
-0.0198026337,
0.0500142537,
-0.0370266177,
0.0259798691,
-0.0384697057,
0.0241162125,
0.0103907641,
-0.0299519841,
0.007580725,
0.0035797432,
2.711e-7,
0.0050565791,
0.0404353552,
-0.0107484059,
0.0550327152,
0.001678559,
0.0299218148,
-0.0372213162,
0.0331587866,
-0.0175022203,
-0.002671879,
-0.0032529009,
0.0046393001,
0.0508788191,
0.0326146856,
-0.0569817796,
0.0182851367,
-0.0542053618,
0.0439369306,
-0.0663367808,
-0.0017236152,
0.0504912026,
0.0416216888,
-0.0172876269,
-0.0211008191,
-0.0043004681,
-0.0261373185,
0.0554527231,
-0.0430639535,
-0.0160175003,
0.0334207229,
0.0594401769,
-0.0083934106,
0.0096760662,
-0.0141615486,
-0.0044504879,
-0.0185813066,
-0.0166834556,
0.050892666,
0.02360503,
-0.0465526432,
0.0095876185,
-0.0233522207,
0.0109985145,
-0.0556650199,
0.0227355901,
0.0033569674,
0.0066752592,
-0.013433394,
0.009256186,
-0.0278163701,
0.0429007784,
-0.0577020943,
-0.0123784328,
0.0153885586,
0.007037092,
-0.0078903073,
-0.0393883325,
-0.0091134766,
-0.0083335228,
-0.0012480514,
-0.02735167,
-0.0361942537,
-0.0559928976,
0.0402664281,
-0.0073831324,
-0.0392494835,
-0.0096478956,
2.232094106e-34,
0.0151269855,
-0.0128459092,
0.026550483,
0.0508688092,
0.0198475793,
0.0293114334,
-0.0162079707,
0.0374375246,
0.0040592882,
-0.0303841028,
-0.009383129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00146v1 | The Qiyas Benchmark: Measuring ChatGPT Mathematical and Language Understanding in Arabic | 2024-06-28T16:34:31 | 2024-06-28T16:34:31 | Shahad Al-Khalifa, Hend Al-Khalifa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the growing importance of Arabic as a global language, there is a
notable lack of language models pre-trained exclusively on Arabic data. This
shortage has led to limited benchmarks available for assessing language model
performance in Arabic. To address this gap, we introduce two novel benchmarks
designed to evaluate models' mathematical reasoning and language understanding
abilities in Arabic. These benchmarks are derived from a General Aptitude Test
(GAT) called Qiyas exam, a standardized test widely used for university
admissions in Saudi Arabia. For validation purposes, we assess the performance
of ChatGPT-3.5-trubo and ChatGPT-4 on our benchmarks. Our findings reveal that
these benchmarks pose a significant challenge, with ChatGPT-4 achieving an
overall average accuracy of 64%, while ChatGPT-3.5-trubo achieved an overall
accuracy of 49% across the various question types in the Qiyas benchmark. We
believe the release of these benchmarks will pave the way for enhancing the
mathematical reasoning and language understanding capabilities of future models
tailored for the low-resource Arabic language. | [
-0.0153652262,
0.0685134307,
-0.0123280622,
0.0400082171,
-0.0640333146,
0.0369072631,
0.0427002087,
-0.0030013467,
-0.0398926884,
-0.0228645075,
-0.0189686064,
-0.087965332,
0.0359991007,
0.0155970855,
0.0456028916,
-0.0278541986,
0.0323737971,
-0.0644716918,
-0.0073717409,
-0.0105247963,
0.0144718457,
0.009766412,
-0.0445480384,
0.018473452,
-0.0003395287,
-0.0627792776,
0.0066445153,
-0.0597270802,
-0.0068548298,
0.0052878242,
0.0086156344,
0.071234107,
-0.0067215394,
0.0299216099,
0.0000022612,
-0.0923719332,
-0.0347805507,
-0.015144486,
-0.0364079587,
0.0199418981,
0.0104583586,
-0.0323603153,
-0.0342596993,
0.0126436697,
-0.0580974296,
0.0148408348,
0.0134735871,
0.0213405211,
0.0413409658,
0.0712768957,
0.0001950016,
-0.0415977016,
0.045488961,
-0.0175920762,
0.0209011082,
-0.0626224205,
-0.0074153198,
0.0619353317,
0.0035060635,
0.0143456711,
-0.0438117497,
0.0294253696,
0.0508651175,
-0.0020078903,
-0.0380334333,
-0.0091719963,
-0.0749715194,
0.007177982,
0.0372231491,
0.0196405482,
-0.003938748,
-0.0169737488,
-0.0115674585,
0.0263055116,
-0.0026876193,
0.0311744139,
-0.0587993152,
0.0329049677,
-0.0254401583,
-0.0156059917,
0.0291432738,
-0.0191072542,
0.0108387908,
-0.0019327581,
-0.0492106751,
0.0930057764,
0.0321567059,
-0.0312127117,
0.0214077178,
-0.0210937876,
-0.0648300946,
-0.0233606752,
0.0092833098,
0.0049453089,
0.0119435908,
-0.0140364105,
0.0132211642,
-0.0166229829,
-0.0198819619,
-0.073103264,
0.0070841224,
0.1089841351,
-0.0047007664,
0.0250416156,
-0.0273098294,
0.0910592303,
0.0579245314,
0.0383807421,
-0.0527942292,
0.0280622263,
-0.0531371832,
-0.0188652538,
-0.0282202493,
0.0307784975,
-0.0340691209,
0.0322440043,
-0.0878821239,
-0.0100279404,
-0.0346644856,
0.0028363131,
0.0063189385,
-0.0370625146,
-0.0206487104,
-0.0197796337,
-0.0191805027,
-0.0122627905,
-0.0371854268,
-0.0142117953,
-0.0387109742,
-0.0830153227,
0.0161426347,
-0.0097170137,
-0.0099541964,
-0.0089426199,
-0.0015095578,
0.0596720837,
-0.0056718192,
-0.0316658355,
-0.0120332669,
0.0447711647,
-0.0019169103,
-0.0768913403,
0.0024122915,
-0.0528633446,
0.043584127,
0.0176314693,
-0.0151009047,
0.0112560326,
-0.0149383238,
0.0057697035,
0.0706058443,
0.0364346914,
0.0493646301,
-0.0084067089,
0.0524544157,
0.0351070426,
0.0014966334,
0.06905514,
0.0257057939,
-0.0550290197,
0.0187333506,
-0.0197565742,
-0.0168599952,
0.047019612,
0.0106463702,
-0.0085178809,
-0.0049414304,
0.011002033,
0.0413436629,
0.0652910918,
-0.0497248732,
0.0145437056,
-0.0221436694,
-0.0260927081,
0.0256664716,
0.0514567867,
-0.0126993135,
0.0344448574,
-0.0004609508,
0.0196185894,
0.0742073134,
-0.0079993121,
-0.0157600809,
0.002092195,
-0.0040817088,
0.0282972325,
0.0163471997,
0.0417871922,
-0.0098037571,
-0.0768494159,
-0.0181371272,
-0.01000717,
-0.0038901134,
-0.0041583618,
0.091020368,
-0.027619198,
-0.0033257485,
0.0168041978,
0.0047478355,
-0.021080751,
0.0091663562,
-0.054415334,
-0.0094021568,
-0.0131194824,
0.0123202251,
-0.0186465736,
-0.0607044473,
-0.0077565224,
0.010661928,
0.0182358772,
0.0489491858,
-0.0101206908,
-0.001130687,
-0.0280455984,
-0.0031600392,
0.0092856567,
0.0128339501,
-0.0123611642,
0.0212559327,
0.0597425066,
-0.0049900394,
-0.0500095002,
0.005346973,
0.0101306587,
-0.0730633885,
0.0004229945,
-0.021068925,
-0.0066286051,
0.0142616499,
0.0166592896,
0.0093700578,
0.0058269468,
-0.0175499897,
-0.0362348109,
-0.0230400208,
0.0001288467,
-0.0746558458,
-0.0276785139,
0.0663109869,
-0.030339634,
-0.0251499824,
0.0385866053,
-0.0337172858,
-0.0329166055,
0.0858968496,
-0.0060588825,
0.0285915136,
-0.033261776,
0.0434558578,
-0.0098665841,
0.0181861334,
-0.0088756243,
0.074358575,
-0.0030691288,
0.0311553758,
-0.0158612318,
-0.0180697516,
0.0843113959,
0.0105454763,
-0.0090595782,
0.0011776329,
-0.0207445193,
0.0221253727,
0.023092065,
0.0171236135,
-0.0410433449,
-0.0087481048,
-0.0393902436,
0.0030306228,
-0.0241250321,
0.0593433529,
-0.0041442378,
-0.0200638771,
-0.019413108,
0.0010837987,
-0.036822632,
-0.0403258055,
0.0085598333,
0.0004609606,
0.0270169303,
-0.0199613683,
0.0056275558,
-0.0443961583,
-0.0213307589,
-0.0225944929,
0.0460861661,
0.0364556201,
0.0206834842,
0.0598932095,
-0.0017549162,
-0.0427488238,
-0.0078884214,
-0.0170250144,
-0.01383672,
0.0450163558,
-0.015075122,
0.0270878691,
0.0269829407,
0.0051827016,
0.0061724163,
-0.0186499618,
-0.0077530444,
-0.0493639745,
0.0157671291,
-0.0011433053,
-0.0192521363,
-0.021954339,
-0.0422551371,
-0.0346132144,
0.0533396006,
-0.0169966556,
-0.0351376534,
-0.0400272794,
0.0489623249,
-0.0688931346,
0.0288866814,
-0.0556701794,
0.0475866608,
0.0082005356,
0.0847261995,
-0.0240447354,
-0.0267548934,
0.016447546,
-0.0109490706,
-0.0065155542,
-0.053561341,
0.0405882038,
-0.0557315089,
0.0117403204,
-0.0150794806,
-0.0036070431,
-0.0464731976,
-0.0186496209,
-0.0552394912,
-0.0185770337,
0.0366486274,
-0.0373338871,
0.0281661637,
-0.0493313111,
0.016935356,
0.0008150288,
-0.0393146016,
-0.0229865797,
0.0495506227,
-0.0199850984,
0.0232262649,
0.0010287879,
-0.0272067003,
-0.0149995303,
0.01947782,
0.0057451962,
0.025808828,
-0.0354781449,
-0.0047149616,
0.0040841359,
-0.0482104979,
0.0410030968,
0.0101841167,
0.0393308736,
-0.029977642,
0.0249599349,
0.0433005504,
0.0024489465,
0.0104071358,
-0.0315784663,
0.0358588584,
0.0250836313,
-0.042016495,
-0.0650039092,
-0.0221523289,
-0.0159589648,
-0.0489338189,
0.0007017958,
0.125390783,
0.0482971817,
0.0151194027,
0.0161291305,
-0.0588469282,
-0.0014264989,
0.0022282552,
-0.0018241755,
-0.1255669594,
-0.0001060252,
0.0219667461,
-0.0012717218,
0.0253195465,
-0.01518788,
0.0255330447,
-0.1069395319,
0.0040213903,
-0.0040016621,
-0.0679633692,
-0.0084176119,
-0.0362682007,
0.0021549072,
-0.0079638809,
0.0224831495,
0.002714105,
-0.0040294849,
0.0499728695,
0.0498189293,
-0.044825051,
-0.0472828373,
0.0556933321,
-0.0055702413,
-0.000428079,
0.0012569227,
0.0249126852,
-0.0388256647,
-0.0415159054,
0.032794714,
0.0216724612,
-0.0710421503,
0.0019771243,
-0.0148476576,
0.0079415403,
0.00042781,
-0.0215147864,
0.0069539426,
-0.0569338538,
0.0140046459,
0.0195903629,
0.0703769922,
-0.0049145035,
0.0146146035,
0.0139236832,
0.0175803304,
-0.0655469373,
0.0537300594,
0.0183979142,
-0.0250103157,
-0.0491656251,
-0.0281108338,
-0.028067302,
-0.0628435463,
-0.037805777,
-0.0024946583,
0.0478847437,
-0.0021151237,
-0.0673135966,
-0.0610693991,
0.0106837219,
0.0147610391,
0.0061397883,
-0.0009286947,
0.0033403984,
0.0118713472,
-0.0217037033,
0.0143225752,
0.0067265606,
0.0163964648,
-0.0600036606,
0.01925168,
-0.0151410205,
-0.0620599799,
-0.0489639379,
-0.0246369522,
-0.079966493,
-0.0211753566,
0.0281776078,
0.018291099,
0.0214049108,
-0.0238305461,
-0.0005083412,
0.0016755855,
-0.015244551,
-0.0286669582,
-0.0108088339,
0.0426438078,
0.0286865886,
-0.0212232098,
-0.0079333121,
0.0322016813,
0.0310611241,
0.0126304654,
-0.0017204157,
0.0166281536,
0.0026226558,
-0.009976482,
0.0159949791,
0.0220477134,
-0.0029577739,
0.0167795531,
-0.0499629006,
-0.0188037865,
0.0249027256,
-0.0237671882,
0.021025734,
-0.0379433595,
-0.0062746573,
0.0298493225,
0.0319604389,
-0.0269098822,
-0.0405693687,
0.002473617,
-0.002844566,
0.0101220189,
0.0380358323,
0.0006150854,
0.0353333242,
-0.0048326445,
-0.0062459423,
0.0208454076,
-0.0696685836,
-0.0148806144,
0.090396814,
-0.0333688147,
0.0586431995,
-0.0199311785,
0.027014479,
0.0539229102,
0.0274157412,
-0.0055276817,
-0.0660902858,
0.0100743491,
0.0646325424,
0.0298573673,
-0.0130584473,
0.007878785,
-0.0169459805,
0.0047813025,
-0.0240072645,
0.0017899813,
-0.0007359234,
-0.0193329919,
-0.0056796102,
0.0100070871,
0.0109299775,
0.0064436384,
0.0584664829,
-0.022820536,
0.0063017751,
0.0159081779,
0.0258743055,
-0.0060559963,
-0.0036476501,
-0.0106994007,
-0.010075842,
-0.0104600517,
0.0306281522,
-0.081984669,
-0.115387626,
0.0099614318,
0.0381325856,
-0.0099015785,
0.0117949452,
0.0243990831,
0.0966386423,
-0.0411505811,
-0.0092625795,
-0.0397485159,
0.0116599435,
-0.0330304243,
-0.0242484398,
0.010025626,
-6.353645414e-33,
0.0084030377,
-0.0028257717,
0.0538309626,
-0.0033042354,
0.0328858756,
-0.0216751769,
-0.0279952902,
0.0195928086,
-0.0277917851,
0.0006401984,
-0.0362436958,
0.0361354463,
0.0114621446,
0.0145807397,
0.0162231978,
-0.0238210689,
-0.0283688512,
-0.0331088454,
-0.0203227513,
0.007135137,
0.0202858448,
0.0233372524,
0.138642177,
-0.0351812951,
0.0423337482,
-0.0195694212,
-0.0073843896,
0.0211283043,
-0.0274287965,
0.1026117876,
-0.0160793085,
0.0193405803,
0.0221321452,
-0.0485906228,
0.0292280708,
-0.0468623489,
-0.0475276113,
-0.0547362752,
0.0388370715,
0.0563787185,
-0.0064223097,
-0.0169307385,
-0.0251439884,
0.0068962486,
-0.0630636811,
-0.0216049124,
0.0054924712,
-0.0199746918,
-0.0027516261,
0.0420378372,
-0.0591184422,
0.0428525023,
-0.0514344014,
0.0182986595,
0.019470755,
0.0503472835,
-0.0345967859,
-0.019662194,
-0.0128116766,
-0.0110111935,
0.0139308721,
0.0472754426,
0.0651424676,
-0.022454368,
-0.0440253466,
0.0410031714,
0.0381489135,
-0.0359521694,
0.0647416562,
-0.0022587059,
0.0642356128,
-0.0227898024,
0.0739174709,
0.0542880073,
0.0665183961,
0.0035416398,
-0.1029929146,
0.02511435,
-0.0169579778,
0.0329400077,
0.002085845,
-0.0272232909,
-0.0817283094,
-0.0082304943,
-0.0289843902,
0.0156598203,
-0.031972222,
-0.0079648951,
0.0511231236,
-0.0491095446,
0.0011690198,
0.0356686041,
0.0297346488,
-0.0146764945,
0.0183936711,
-0.0128649594,
0.0045266906,
0.0001632221,
0.0016649676,
0.0822577626,
-0.0507896654,
-0.0210367423,
-0.029946629,
0.0309610702,
0.0340956226,
0.0011080488,
0.0324041247,
0.026200667,
-0.0596722886,
-0.0037104073,
-0.0333484374,
0.0248943008,
0.0264136512,
0.0781622529,
0.0189662222,
0.0224264245,
0.0086814677,
0.0330031104,
0.0055206781,
-0.0140166031,
-0.0561616793,
0.0165725145,
-0.0322000161,
0.0003772196,
0.0174474418,
0.0097501893,
-0.0348279998,
-0.0078356015,
0.0074648717,
-0.0674808249,
0.0211099088,
0.0239744596,
2.957e-7,
0.080835931,
0.0354843885,
0.0108796693,
0.0066303052,
-0.0256173052,
0.007167357,
-0.0377669781,
-0.0272592865,
0.0463333726,
0.0524122678,
0.0080243144,
0.0322784111,
0.0620482713,
0.0085837459,
-0.0784453601,
0.0203958955,
-0.0340136364,
0.0034959889,
-0.042531956,
0.0367039442,
0.0347545594,
0.1087275892,
-0.0346876159,
-0.0144879073,
-0.0239689983,
-0.0689035803,
0.0564740635,
-0.0225978382,
-0.0198547076,
0.0496237129,
0.0427859239,
-0.0227687992,
0.0529638976,
0.0104382262,
-0.0409374945,
0.0209287107,
0.0521463156,
0.0868914053,
0.020559743,
0.0142692439,
-0.0062536197,
-0.0066119879,
-0.0092466101,
-0.0623221174,
0.0764274746,
-0.0126311257,
-0.0295007937,
-0.0008480041,
-0.0315039158,
-0.0047979299,
0.0417785533,
-0.0093372483,
0.0119826533,
0.014842906,
0.0553970076,
-0.0280730855,
0.020735953,
-0.0071299854,
0.012817692,
0.0039637601,
-0.0058274549,
-0.0390476547,
-0.0269054044,
-0.015892487,
0.0190255903,
0.0159698203,
-0.0220623948,
2.567548511e-34,
0.0394364744,
0.0029907243,
0.0398965888,
0.0185116678,
0.0483863056,
0.000677596,
0.0007296004,
0.0003647207,
0.0021349038,
-0.0268309265,
-0.0044226618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20038v1 | BioMNER: A Dataset for Biomedical Method Entity Recognition | 2024-06-28T16:34:24 | 2024-06-28T16:34:24 | Chen Tang, Bohao Yang, Kun Zhao, Bo Lv, Chenghao Xiao, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named entity recognition (NER) stands as a fundamental and pivotal task
within the realm of Natural Language Processing. Particularly within the domain
of Biomedical Method NER, this task presents notable challenges, stemming from
the continual influx of domain-specific terminologies in scholarly literature.
Current research in Biomedical Method (BioMethod) NER suffers from a scarcity
of resources, primarily attributed to the intricate nature of methodological
concepts, which necessitate a profound understanding for precise delineation.
In this study, we propose a novel dataset for biomedical method entity
recognition, employing an automated BioMethod entity recognition and
information retrieval system to assist human annotation. Furthermore, we
comprehensively explore a range of conventional and contemporary open-domain
NER methodologies, including the utilization of cutting-edge large-scale
language models (LLMs) customised to our dataset. Our empirical findings reveal
that the large parameter counts of language models surprisingly inhibit the
effective assimilation of entity extraction patterns pertaining to biomedical
methods. Remarkably, the approach, leveraging the modestly sized ALBERT model
(only 11MB), in conjunction with conditional random fields (CRF), achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. | [
0.0644002259,
0.0605381913,
0.0447045751,
-0.0066636833,
-0.0130774435,
0.0350721143,
0.0163840633,
0.0378533863,
0.0300708283,
-0.0300555117,
-0.0400233045,
-0.0551382042,
0.0004332902,
0.0013055926,
0.0292236619,
0.0017347706,
0.0230096076,
0.011626929,
0.0274347235,
0.0182425175,
-0.0232740492,
0.0031610671,
0.0040984941,
0.0275927205,
0.0737080947,
-0.00489065,
0.011266523,
-0.0026532507,
0.0742099881,
-0.076017797,
-0.0056051007,
0.0459489152,
-0.0279952325,
0.0462788157,
0.0000018677,
-0.0504906438,
-0.0396093056,
0.0725352466,
-0.0175171513,
-0.0118378801,
0.039402537,
-0.0302506462,
0.0013336256,
-0.0132548362,
-0.0057599503,
-0.0328680128,
0.0425855741,
0.046388872,
0.0103471298,
0.0465412512,
0.0023044122,
-0.0315669328,
0.0710656121,
-0.0061557605,
0.0106493058,
-0.016752664,
0.0798852965,
-0.0340182856,
0.0318624042,
0.0465435274,
0.0243953951,
0.0444499291,
-0.0471608192,
0.0415514335,
0.0510396659,
0.0403975546,
-0.0374014415,
-0.0032733588,
0.0111648487,
0.0598793514,
0.0190720204,
-0.0085042147,
0.0603406541,
0.0199532397,
-0.0653190762,
0.0390344523,
-0.060918916,
0.0118990531,
-0.0840646476,
-0.0090835709,
0.014921153,
-0.0284909122,
0.0406494811,
0.019279981,
-0.0032454447,
0.0331041552,
0.026409531,
-0.0440561995,
0.0400285646,
-0.0279278904,
-0.0382787064,
-0.0255062487,
0.0265607517,
0.0111997351,
0.0153014492,
0.0232201964,
-0.0064589977,
-0.0317817517,
0.0472433977,
-0.0588625893,
-0.0053194603,
-0.0054983557,
0.0052590775,
0.0260335654,
-0.0339729153,
-0.023165796,
-0.0462480038,
0.0256903451,
0.0222841892,
0.0138011221,
-0.067093946,
-0.0233921446,
0.0041994983,
0.0389176421,
-0.0098164901,
-0.0138865979,
-0.0791152716,
-0.0286262743,
-0.0180164631,
0.0167795662,
0.0247876644,
0.0153759783,
-0.0069876583,
0.0019282434,
-0.0278170481,
0.0259410907,
0.0329327062,
-0.0067924992,
-0.04296422,
-0.043123845,
-0.0036121779,
-0.0129514225,
0.0200067088,
-0.0530300364,
0.040708214,
0.0537421033,
0.0540617667,
-0.0753028989,
-0.0124510936,
-0.023714507,
0.0087410519,
-0.0379905626,
0.0328971371,
-0.0291450396,
0.0413427316,
0.0160412248,
0.0140531128,
-0.0548436046,
0.0287457667,
0.0318586305,
-0.076589562,
0.0931553915,
-0.0518291369,
-0.0203051697,
0.0354222655,
0.0045938548,
0.0482296497,
0.0098372586,
0.0034173434,
-0.0474702753,
0.0221321881,
0.001521158,
0.0069807344,
0.0085891979,
0.0058197672,
-0.0423675701,
-0.0265312474,
0.0285936724,
0.0036084794,
0.06167024,
0.0302505586,
0.0408217385,
0.011608351,
-0.0364746079,
0.0102968104,
0.0862693936,
-0.0155331548,
-0.0079927268,
0.0247662328,
0.0029929548,
0.0457684621,
-0.0314397439,
-0.0027176016,
-0.0160353314,
-0.0390443541,
0.033821065,
0.0217738301,
0.0270978864,
-0.0296062808,
0.0202752482,
-0.0270163231,
0.0029594623,
-0.0432052389,
-0.0031493793,
0.0672656894,
-0.017546162,
-0.0376639441,
0.0605624467,
0.0731814653,
-0.0295103751,
0.0067975461,
-0.0346394181,
-0.0255705193,
0.0318844765,
0.0565817244,
-0.0771519989,
-0.0107479086,
-0.0236742105,
-0.0210071988,
0.0406026319,
-0.0201490391,
-0.0139307715,
0.0143454764,
-0.0312565081,
-0.0116827069,
0.037808191,
0.0155105134,
-0.0096576354,
0.0379878618,
0.0228891224,
-0.0161079429,
-0.035826467,
-0.0496986322,
0.0491109081,
-0.0839594826,
-0.0520181358,
-0.0060496586,
-0.0268358123,
0.0207034312,
0.0302969497,
-0.026139643,
0.0235842634,
0.03644941,
-0.0399586819,
-0.0166487638,
-0.022333771,
0.0453560166,
-0.02912613,
0.0072074588,
0.0049838987,
0.0000203725,
-0.0055352906,
-0.0305229872,
-0.024563225,
-0.0455782861,
0.0221180934,
0.0363492407,
-0.0177641641,
0.0259328969,
0.0302128233,
0.0132033164,
-0.0398109294,
0.0124019915,
-0.0307373572,
0.0384542942,
-0.0005079677,
-0.0380395204,
-0.0061978498,
-0.0443630069,
-0.0475452617,
0.0171090122,
0.0026663076,
-0.0103083588,
-0.0140866758,
-0.0225877333,
-0.0249589253,
-0.0183864906,
-0.094295688,
0.0230315588,
0.0404487476,
0.0247967243,
-0.0094637908,
0.0234164745,
0.0036483451,
0.0152846668,
0.0155300302,
-0.0336233005,
-0.0181704834,
0.0155315846,
0.0181876943,
-0.004103119,
-0.0151217105,
-0.0260582138,
-0.0194768086,
-0.0462855287,
0.0624304898,
0.0066709165,
-0.0342834257,
-0.0321456529,
0.0427584723,
-0.028032938,
0.0108765,
-0.0165550541,
0.0204139296,
-0.0017434949,
0.0045918147,
-0.014126637,
0.0878228843,
-0.0004833379,
0.0451904461,
-0.0063284119,
0.0164971594,
-0.0071632024,
0.0040865201,
-0.042764008,
0.010545956,
0.0114248423,
-0.0556291752,
0.0260783676,
0.0565889962,
-0.0139106195,
0.0188448001,
0.0016928269,
0.0037331735,
-0.0164079592,
-0.0196032468,
-0.034010455,
0.0225601438,
-0.0693998188,
0.0075161741,
-0.0006394127,
-0.0274232905,
0.0754892081,
-0.0519348234,
0.0153728789,
-0.0269655902,
0.0219928343,
-0.0170280579,
0.0038245076,
0.0379741974,
0.0162251201,
0.0517538786,
-0.0289737135,
0.0424387604,
0.0638454258,
-0.0100102145,
-0.0722192973,
-0.0001994315,
-0.0164548643,
0.0397884883,
0.0133579904,
0.0034767292,
-0.03929241,
0.0035504047,
-0.046833612,
0.0375614576,
0.0011515658,
-0.0340213552,
-0.0264645703,
0.0750475973,
0.0214177053,
0.0271640699,
-0.0116947619,
-0.0026903257,
-0.0320590697,
0.0300687272,
0.0523575395,
-0.0223854631,
0.0058720792,
-0.0131827584,
0.0190262198,
0.0392494351,
0.0015403066,
-0.0085872291,
0.0074012396,
-0.0092531033,
0.0201139208,
-0.0734976232,
0.0263593681,
-0.0097504947,
0.0558466353,
-0.031160051,
0.0021382461,
0.1089687124,
0.0300362576,
-0.0756847858,
-0.0139274169,
0.012546557,
-0.0226602517,
0.0005408517,
0.027435394,
-0.1027606502,
-0.0208796356,
0.0135688763,
0.0232421309,
-0.0233472008,
-0.0904688388,
0.0127556724,
-0.0742827952,
0.0493485257,
-0.0207752809,
-0.0556555055,
-0.0219045654,
-0.1019703597,
0.0105851609,
-0.0399845839,
-0.0138670672,
-0.0142406402,
-0.0473333225,
0.0028204394,
0.0171671398,
-0.0364052653,
-0.0949124545,
0.013448081,
-0.0494431481,
0.0558831356,
0.0419475548,
0.0237358939,
-0.0146046076,
-0.0105169201,
0.0003062659,
-0.0095521137,
-0.0301001985,
-0.0359437801,
0.0607997663,
-0.0229386818,
-0.0117907049,
-0.0433299206,
0.0423342511,
-0.0401455238,
-0.0381848812,
-0.0135281365,
0.0540907197,
-0.0141961649,
0.0416762866,
-0.0516164787,
-0.0050203856,
0.0189369135,
0.0804469958,
0.0125940107,
-0.0324604027,
-0.0041593816,
0.0385687537,
0.0441540256,
0.0166640542,
-0.0508829318,
-0.0107185235,
-0.0698558018,
-0.0116312103,
-0.020792542,
-0.0157478638,
0.0391797014,
0.0124302423,
0.016881071,
0.0390456058,
0.0535018593,
0.0253314525,
-0.0693102255,
0.0829249173,
0.0000983698,
0.0189632867,
-0.0691637173,
-0.0476989597,
0.0391470417,
0.0288928654,
-0.0479957983,
0.0483735651,
-0.0035996169,
-0.0439174771,
-0.0088892793,
0.0274940729,
0.0169012714,
0.0027591239,
0.0151846167,
-0.0268926602,
0.0008112345,
0.0162546579,
-0.0209974386,
-0.0080251666,
-0.033873409,
0.0366189219,
-0.0209731925,
0.0130884657,
0.0223290399,
0.0366639607,
0.0188876931,
0.0638640895,
-0.0437525176,
-0.0547732376,
0.011338775,
0.0351824388,
0.0824304372,
-0.0430507734,
-0.032069955,
-0.054914318,
0.0064419773,
0.005666472,
0.0301343407,
-0.0293498132,
-0.0054451111,
0.0304301009,
0.0007429298,
-0.0460869186,
0.0339238271,
-0.0292736813,
0.0143275131,
-0.0165399946,
0.0408690758,
-0.0167554785,
0.040238589,
0.0327664241,
-0.0135346549,
0.0187318232,
0.0125621054,
0.0153055089,
0.0369708426,
-0.0188976619,
0.044045724,
-0.022992393,
0.0223741289,
-0.0315441228,
0.0218162388,
-0.056777183,
0.0066613588,
-0.0457653366,
0.0531500615,
0.0083256355,
-0.0197998583,
0.0627406463,
0.0052457512,
-0.0302010961,
-0.03601202,
0.0355383083,
-0.0402192958,
0.0616741665,
0.0607692562,
0.0399160795,
-0.0443694368,
-0.0331031047,
0.0446754843,
0.0507983565,
0.0423134156,
0.0075886878,
-0.0769112483,
-0.0223860312,
-0.0191452652,
0.0499038696,
-0.0158373937,
-0.0471497737,
-0.0034889432,
-0.0728280246,
-0.0300795622,
0.0626928136,
-0.0127138989,
-0.0397536419,
-0.004756988,
0.0054517519,
0.0029411355,
0.0103063956,
-0.0401831418,
-0.0390468575,
0.0448751412,
-0.0347062126,
-0.0728353113,
0.004996866,
-5.605375669e-33,
-0.0225549843,
-0.024963012,
0.0050622481,
-0.018050218,
-0.0139645319,
0.056464266,
-0.03793028,
-0.0132721812,
0.0269973855,
0.016717514,
-0.0288061965,
-0.0228203684,
0.0243859608,
0.0248680357,
-0.0193292946,
0.0011549833,
0.0154686831,
0.009016335,
0.027341662,
0.0167821702,
0.0265103783,
0.0759973302,
0.0518157519,
-0.0646153018,
0.0435453132,
0.0132632116,
0.0306727774,
0.0073687811,
0.0295326039,
0.0420081653,
-0.0913412496,
0.0055850949,
-0.0061260625,
-0.036982853,
0.0210268125,
-0.0094010448,
-0.1158439294,
0.0557397269,
-0.0034633554,
-0.0037067269,
-0.016525194,
-0.0304875169,
0.0472111963,
-0.0016221398,
-0.0305393059,
0.0122878132,
0.0516244806,
-0.0188881364,
-0.0420142077,
-0.0519442596,
-0.0681820512,
0.0680146441,
0.0304674748,
0.0464020893,
0.0516310818,
-0.0368035734,
-0.0131356278,
0.0359558463,
-0.0515150577,
-0.0392873138,
0.0425577909,
0.0114254579,
-0.0128126163,
0.0261676442,
0.0211097244,
0.0404012688,
0.0437160134,
-0.0283527374,
-0.0072919196,
-0.0035080842,
-0.025198888,
0.0256394539,
-0.0087044276,
0.0167322904,
0.0182583462,
0.0037132767,
-0.0647311509,
0.0382832363,
-0.0542156771,
0.0240299888,
0.0037241445,
-0.0367453471,
-0.0343150645,
0.0146129522,
-0.0140316654,
-0.0162886567,
-0.0267235953,
0.0056912168,
0.0122035835,
-0.028988665,
-0.0452518612,
0.0420015827,
0.0312057808,
-0.0605642237,
-0.0474131145,
-0.0129142506,
0.0561413728,
0.0302993748,
-0.0300266296,
0.0163365416,
-0.0759821385,
-0.0388035849,
-0.013054206,
-0.03242217,
0.0310633238,
-0.0277391933,
0.0011072356,
-0.021205537,
-0.0633363202,
-0.0206791982,
-0.0120366607,
0.0009157054,
-0.0094956206,
0.0720164776,
0.0158964563,
0.0249760114,
0.0249368045,
0.039761845,
0.031391345,
0.0114302803,
-0.0185620785,
0.0039983555,
0.0302216914,
0.0244322848,
-0.0137341563,
0.008752781,
-0.0037674175,
0.0352336504,
-0.0078384774,
-0.0490726903,
0.0216865409,
-0.0036117113,
2.651e-7,
0.0775067061,
0.0151515882,
0.0003921853,
-0.0417691432,
-0.0060314471,
-0.0150507595,
0.0084224176,
0.0205665454,
-0.0246097855,
-0.0275460146,
0.0452812985,
0.0174003989,
0.0238905456,
-0.0138914054,
-0.0847116858,
-0.0521218553,
-0.0567250736,
-0.0397842005,
-0.0329868086,
-0.0072895386,
-0.0187103283,
0.0689408332,
-0.01902413,
-0.0254761241,
-0.0086449245,
0.0081545953,
0.0566230826,
-0.0195629001,
0.0262952559,
0.0639659464,
0.0124919107,
0.0248892717,
0.0115896165,
0.025536336,
-0.0110159097,
-0.0119112181,
0.0254316963,
0.0961798579,
-0.0424684845,
-0.0019176919,
0.0203598347,
-0.0039317096,
0.0354812257,
-0.0282092765,
0.0289509986,
-0.0277170092,
-0.0329019018,
-0.0328217261,
-0.0177490823,
0.0065134098,
0.0244406331,
-0.0096862828,
0.0100302696,
0.0503302738,
0.0182969458,
-0.0237895623,
-0.0111900363,
-0.0623079464,
0.0000765892,
0.04823111,
-0.0552952252,
-0.0155303795,
0.0061460836,
-0.0468033999,
-0.024223553,
-0.0731609836,
0.0077685104,
2.658331572e-34,
0.0188639555,
0.02480698,
-0.032320682,
0.0662416443,
0.0119019253,
-0.0133293569,
-0.0285368543,
0.0214767139,
-0.0365997739,
-0.092456311,
0.011536533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20030v1 | LEMoE: Advanced Mixture of Experts Adaptor for Lifelong Model Editing of Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T16:17:41 | 2024-06-28T16:17:41 | Renzhi Wang, Piji Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) require continual knowledge updates to stay
abreast of the ever-changing world facts, prompting the formulation of lifelong
model editing task. While recent years have witnessed the development of
various techniques for single and batch editing, these methods either fail to
apply or perform sub-optimally when faced with lifelong editing. In this paper,
we introduce LEMoE, an advanced Mixture of Experts (MoE) adaptor for lifelong
model editing. We first analyze the factors influencing the effectiveness of
conventional MoE adaptor in lifelong editing, including catastrophic
forgetting, inconsistent routing and order sensitivity. Based on these
insights, we propose a tailored module insertion method to achieve lifelong
editing, incorporating a novel KV anchor routing to enhance routing consistency
between training and inference stage, along with a concise yet effective
clustering-based editing order planning. Experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method in lifelong editing, surpassing previous model
editing techniques while maintaining outstanding performance in batch editing
task. Our code will be available. | [
0.0473288596,
0.049832359,
-0.0244470071,
0.0044716503,
-0.0060253805,
0.0064928038,
0.0249069482,
-0.0602339655,
-0.0039280998,
-0.0328180231,
-0.0364757478,
-0.0144411959,
0.0094006239,
0.027131414,
0.0464187078,
-0.0738267601,
0.0663531944,
-0.0255227908,
-0.0587684438,
0.0037748886,
0.0032337662,
-0.0246574115,
0.0051870812,
0.0318540372,
-0.0026012356,
-0.0013488266,
-0.0639693066,
0.0056244535,
0.0267163068,
0.0163773485,
0.0011156645,
0.0952783674,
0.0100593176,
0.0462841615,
0.0000021375,
-0.0303208008,
-0.06223014,
0.0178070478,
-0.0324960798,
0.0149709834,
0.0259888265,
0.008176446,
-0.0635275245,
0.0018798113,
-0.0074655386,
0.0427229479,
0.0886113644,
0.0319374055,
0.0782849416,
0.0908984393,
0.0051105446,
-0.0195126217,
0.0620789193,
-0.032180395,
-0.002177835,
-0.0131515265,
0.0527625121,
0.0263707731,
-0.0444704331,
-0.0031355582,
-0.0427725129,
0.0661345944,
0.0229689199,
-0.0229093805,
0.0382499211,
0.0073341229,
0.0015282437,
-0.0172370225,
-0.0202211961,
0.0268711224,
-0.0158055052,
-0.0190923829,
-0.0103553468,
0.0259933509,
-0.0064230282,
-0.0032424971,
-0.0338932127,
-0.0055359416,
0.0227683801,
-0.0086726788,
0.0045394236,
-0.0943440348,
0.0148771172,
-0.0023598161,
-0.0779131055,
0.0395097695,
0.0412266254,
-0.0184962563,
-0.0472256616,
-0.0114938309,
-0.0212323498,
-0.0452765822,
0.0264282282,
0.0213712212,
-0.0230073426,
0.0065053483,
-0.0474668778,
-0.0208805632,
-0.0488525853,
-0.0515450351,
0.0240689497,
0.0613192283,
0.0038675843,
0.0442255847,
-0.0387648866,
0.0216021277,
-0.0010073016,
-0.0022988892,
-0.0328348055,
0.0209350009,
-0.0763643906,
-0.016805049,
-0.0304941908,
0.0120643526,
-0.0622890629,
0.0183432382,
-0.0310672503,
0.0558316484,
-0.0157291424,
0.0045656897,
0.0021944751,
-0.0049863253,
-0.0408878587,
-0.0362797864,
-0.0199253783,
0.0336824656,
0.0134422351,
-0.0029964542,
-0.0019411156,
0.0116372351,
0.0006595076,
0.0024425441,
-0.0083464347,
-0.0191409159,
-0.002329088,
0.0667928234,
-0.056705948,
-0.0100414371,
-0.0494471341,
-0.0031107275,
-0.0048734294,
-0.0356012993,
-0.0040101307,
-0.0424376912,
0.0491094999,
-0.0058894404,
-0.0243168343,
-0.0655640811,
-0.0114586018,
-0.0260708276,
-0.0428618975,
0.0543715395,
-0.0151113393,
0.0171456076,
0.0425212495,
-0.0000205438,
-0.044159051,
0.0483335704,
0.0055491216,
-0.0156830754,
0.0248369351,
0.0130002135,
0.0125776837,
0.0390389524,
-0.0331131518,
0.0076185907,
-0.0489215851,
0.0072144992,
0.0232495088,
0.0212726668,
0.0314648151,
0.0113574024,
-0.0326833427,
0.0147126084,
0.0701146126,
-0.0252277963,
0.0405722037,
0.0540332086,
0.0192873254,
-0.0433184057,
0.0015533317,
0.0152197918,
-0.0600782968,
0.0269541517,
-0.0466509126,
-0.0054959394,
0.044787474,
0.0304918308,
-0.0069413572,
-0.0250697155,
0.0217441469,
0.0340895541,
-0.0290510617,
-0.0350680985,
0.0396395177,
-0.0224657301,
-0.0164964013,
0.0264027026,
0.0196962394,
-0.0320651345,
0.0014058433,
-0.0408891141,
-0.0315159559,
0.0934832767,
0.0398707762,
-0.0489374399,
-0.1119835228,
0.0049117538,
-0.0165156238,
-0.0205827057,
0.0021486324,
-0.0185553785,
0.0047131134,
-0.0419950895,
-0.0400358252,
0.0200724099,
0.0252062064,
0.0247749873,
0.0366888121,
0.0061902292,
0.0236548334,
-0.0161083099,
-0.0299655534,
0.0191394966,
-0.062526077,
0.0244228207,
-0.0114081446,
0.0126449149,
-0.0038547909,
-0.0117094666,
-0.0441411287,
-0.025689438,
-0.0018730854,
0.0027275123,
-0.0030895693,
0.0119010322,
-0.0472399332,
-0.0612159707,
0.0565790087,
0.0027700926,
-0.0300208014,
-0.0376944244,
-0.0289362743,
-0.0453724749,
-0.0106235454,
-0.006947739,
0.0551177338,
-0.0407349467,
0.0647956282,
-0.00700797,
-0.0252498835,
-0.025839163,
0.034748219,
-0.0166768879,
-0.0365354344,
0.033103887,
0.0275470484,
-0.0324651673,
-0.0606372021,
-0.0250384007,
0.0060323491,
0.0370257571,
0.0188740399,
-0.0204120241,
0.0004444435,
-0.0385433324,
-0.086115256,
-0.0971158817,
0.0216868408,
-0.0357128382,
-0.0059660212,
0.0326946229,
0.0128952293,
-0.0340597779,
-0.0030373584,
0.0169897545,
0.0143198669,
-0.0434548445,
0.0314904563,
-0.0222954378,
0.0099150566,
-0.0338341929,
-0.0385091007,
-0.0206477772,
-0.0037020938,
0.0298757739,
-0.0376816876,
-0.0580210052,
-0.0712003335,
-0.0214951187,
-0.0485749617,
0.0289026052,
0.0062331972,
-0.0259724706,
-0.0421015769,
-0.0207394827,
0.1252626628,
0.0607567094,
-0.0082751792,
0.0286260415,
0.0963481516,
-0.041201409,
0.0146664483,
0.0191784538,
-0.0039575272,
-0.0020338278,
-0.0353434607,
0.0284648687,
-0.0190992691,
0.0290432405,
-0.0103459237,
-0.0517897494,
-0.0231781639,
-0.0011352076,
-0.001991797,
-0.0215895716,
-0.0177857447,
-0.0258629248,
-0.0253420062,
0.0100899721,
-0.0280385558,
-0.0280072875,
0.0612103976,
0.0051249554,
-0.0014545869,
-0.0418316871,
-0.0487255938,
-0.0040086117,
0.002495205,
0.0261336993,
0.036943201,
-0.0403020643,
-0.0041985428,
-0.0910402909,
0.0187089667,
0.0189177524,
0.0144842342,
0.0245878529,
-0.0545204245,
0.0052430988,
-0.0144927325,
-0.0021376468,
-0.0328625403,
0.0061643929,
-0.0194024555,
0.0301277731,
0.0268994197,
-0.0279100183,
-0.0570735112,
0.0350664854,
0.074802205,
0.0715885684,
-0.0438273549,
-0.0178747121,
-0.0155857923,
0.0133168539,
0.024264615,
0.0365417227,
0.0109852562,
-0.0416429713,
0.0273855086,
0.0412217565,
0.0289323572,
-0.0725094825,
-0.0354782417,
0.0236392599,
-0.012887625,
-0.0518611297,
-0.0145177469,
-0.0172609612,
0.0352357477,
-0.0621491745,
0.0179767441,
0.0811616853,
0.0355525352,
-0.053795144,
-0.0058658551,
-0.0394423455,
0.0398580022,
0.0213671066,
0.0566773564,
-0.0527847335,
-0.0168744512,
0.0447768196,
0.0135703059,
0.0100181829,
-0.0241823066,
0.0006092367,
-0.0521801338,
0.0387008488,
0.0320558213,
-0.0718671679,
-0.0221672095,
-0.0279625859,
0.0066645886,
-0.0204086136,
0.0320786834,
0.0668248087,
0.0082477834,
-0.0111396862,
0.0022390378,
-0.0083824648,
-0.0483580008,
-0.0106879426,
-0.0178764071,
0.0738666803,
0.0274750516,
-0.0224381741,
0.0206183642,
0.020811962,
0.0658219531,
0.0498250946,
0.0221782085,
-0.0287455134,
0.0222178083,
-0.0077391667,
0.006034655,
0.0051067397,
0.0074498272,
0.0445403457,
-0.0330100842,
0.019985145,
0.0965050533,
-0.0239303838,
0.0128698461,
-0.0064841555,
-0.0437716022,
-0.0260862783,
0.0174806081,
0.0106870774,
-0.0305993967,
0.0060064713,
-0.0414060727,
-0.0353838876,
-0.0066067954,
-0.0029396813,
-0.0133652641,
-0.0825499222,
-0.0135559589,
-0.0399029255,
-0.0048745736,
0.0654890686,
0.0723646507,
0.0600719936,
-0.0156977363,
0.0138003519,
-0.016591737,
-0.0410635322,
-0.0005870413,
-0.0432916619,
-0.025116168,
-0.0874922499,
-0.012440972,
0.040719185,
-0.0178347863,
-0.0096987765,
-0.0164861381,
-0.0032640481,
-0.0817589834,
0.0271971989,
0.0675746128,
0.0163273178,
0.0922213495,
0.017261317,
-0.0709249452,
0.0732878447,
0.0296991654,
-0.0197868366,
0.0447127186,
0.0289253276,
0.0082099335,
-0.0188732073,
0.0271883737,
-0.0293145068,
-0.0182909574,
0.0249684285,
0.0335074738,
-0.0287212115,
-0.0101792496,
-0.0066250246,
0.0082238801,
-0.002911313,
0.012648616,
0.0073534227,
-0.0914790779,
0.0843215957,
-0.007355338,
-0.0168456454,
-0.0272956621,
0.0332429521,
0.0106374547,
0.0305487588,
0.0146691818,
0.0179413967,
0.0408901908,
-0.0120361289,
0.0173813906,
-0.0070774509,
-0.0004830902,
0.0056984783,
0.0532819144,
0.0432732329,
-0.0235667247,
0.0155204711,
0.0129494229,
0.0198871158,
-0.0516313426,
0.0351347141,
0.0280828457,
-0.0345223099,
-0.0725842267,
0.0501419269,
-0.0634354502,
-0.0329234675,
-0.0469748601,
0.0525379628,
0.0783250704,
0.006175674,
0.0392469428,
-0.0243277848,
-0.029134417,
-0.0355989709,
0.0308172181,
0.0378182754,
0.0131896315,
-0.0255062636,
0.0156989247,
0.0123596536,
0.0454197265,
0.0281056222,
-0.0058330018,
0.0562264994,
-0.0028139125,
-0.0270827077,
-0.0303630456,
-0.0062545883,
0.015033327,
-0.0012465653,
-0.0279331971,
-0.0209438819,
-0.0133698732,
-0.0340935066,
-0.0065221526,
-0.0041745184,
-0.0372746661,
0.0022931446,
-0.0035756954,
0.0286549311,
-0.0185317509,
0.0286085699,
-0.0035429106,
-0.0175920222,
0.0487830602,
0.0019181116,
0.0126988357,
-6.586219175e-33,
-0.0355259404,
0.0018161685,
0.0529827699,
-0.0388735272,
-0.0533079281,
-0.0300336275,
-0.0438574888,
0.0316056646,
0.0245381761,
-0.0148159377,
-0.0209175348,
0.0066765775,
0.0021901303,
-0.0001073427,
0.0327474475,
0.053889066,
0.0674059093,
0.0341009796,
0.017717097,
0.0071071973,
0.0414666794,
0.0505408049,
0.081272766,
-0.0202868246,
0.0019203721,
0.0703025684,
0.0102110971,
0.0465292297,
-0.0351801664,
0.0486706458,
-0.0086134663,
-0.0021437816,
-0.0098280413,
-0.0227543749,
-0.0480394214,
-0.0762834772,
-0.021721866,
-0.0180429071,
-0.0200097281,
0.0132470131,
-0.0122147156,
-0.0449934043,
0.0578148514,
0.0127743231,
-0.0116863176,
-0.0114696696,
0.0341167897,
-0.0307638869,
-0.0277744066,
0.0486508161,
-0.0547917336,
0.0444176719,
-0.0083573563,
-0.0004584676,
0.0139891645,
-0.0381994434,
0.0282902084,
-0.0692009628,
-0.0749560371,
-0.0074154539,
0.0542810969,
0.0738862231,
0.0462476611,
0.0326789618,
0.011685729,
0.0389402658,
0.0480701327,
0.0194902886,
-0.0037282505,
0.0089963591,
0.0328953676,
0.0308571663,
0.0196455847,
0.0099362312,
-0.0046604439,
0.0012857675,
-0.0157736111,
0.0155730722,
-0.04239811,
0.0372947492,
0.0008062519,
0.0687591508,
0.0113071548,
-0.0092728967,
-0.0259816349,
-0.0117901806,
-0.0582897104,
-0.0154798459,
0.0302229058,
0.0267447904,
-0.0447786041,
-0.0096624233,
0.0439662002,
-0.0054250755,
0.0118142748,
-0.0136888884,
-0.0294118281,
0.0494639501,
0.0128486603,
0.0349167474,
-0.0404168554,
-0.0183137003,
0.0231012609,
-0.0209866781,
-0.0271839071,
-0.020746924,
0.0317065008,
0.0556690916,
-0.0600938387,
0.0061087562,
-0.0003679837,
-0.0181266479,
0.0238821898,
0.0158840697,
0.0024904192,
-0.0032834106,
0.0114303557,
0.0234653112,
0.052092053,
-0.0009975934,
-0.0217684843,
0.0574375615,
0.0188083667,
0.0256313272,
-0.0181911793,
0.037597701,
-0.0309413243,
0.0096813347,
0.0149604799,
-0.0650862232,
-0.008344355,
-0.0003881786,
2.874e-7,
0.0356759019,
0.0731827244,
0.0151601061,
-0.0444628634,
0.0207510665,
0.0095689232,
-0.0420692004,
-0.0193229467,
0.030910138,
0.0523233749,
0.0437595509,
0.0409104452,
0.008162058,
0.011541889,
-0.0642195493,
0.0213437527,
-0.017330464,
0.042243436,
-0.0649146363,
-0.0323253907,
-0.0003020356,
0.0879087672,
0.0123550165,
0.022929376,
-0.0102314409,
-0.0337599814,
0.0430509783,
0.0134671228,
0.0118045844,
0.0276126806,
0.0136938598,
0.0446237251,
-0.0006134168,
0.0137639632,
-0.0198997669,
0.0148484241,
-0.0158173833,
0.0818911642,
-0.0496561453,
-0.0011234307,
0.0612111688,
0.0308584608,
-0.0275566168,
-0.0476682633,
0.0634970888,
-0.040105693,
0.0269488879,
0.0102384118,
-0.0292288251,
0.000180339,
0.0107624168,
-0.0185224414,
-0.017161807,
0.0261938181,
0.0091769146,
0.0455980003,
-0.0254205074,
-0.0453029536,
-0.0052394518,
0.0074824039,
-0.0253470745,
-0.0957584605,
-0.0203238484,
-0.01903354,
0.0329754315,
-0.0266107004,
-0.0120963119,
2.940380421e-34,
0.0197347961,
0.0105599752,
0.0306515675,
0.0582592003,
0.0560488775,
-0.0493613221,
-0.0069189901,
-0.0022916477,
-0.0029290325,
-0.1013267264,
-0.0764199123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20015v1 | ToolBeHonest: A Multi-level Hallucination Diagnostic Benchmark for Tool-Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T16:03:30 | 2024-06-28T16:03:30 | Yuxiang Zhang, Jing Chen, Junjie Wang, Yaxin Liu, Cheng Yang, Chufan Shi, Xinyu Zhu, Zihao Lin, Hanwen Wan, Yujiu Yang, Tetsuya Sakai, Tian Feng, Hayato Yamana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tool-augmented large language models (LLMs) are rapidly being integrated into
real-world applications. Due to the lack of benchmarks, the community still
needs to fully understand the hallucination issues within these models. To
address this challenge, we introduce a comprehensive diagnostic benchmark,
ToolBH. Specifically, we assess the LLM's hallucinations through two
perspectives: depth and breadth. In terms of depth, we propose a multi-level
diagnostic process, including (1) solvability detection, (2) solution planning,
and (3) missing-tool analysis. For breadth, we consider three scenarios based
on the characteristics of the toolset: missing necessary tools, potential
tools, and limited functionality tools. Furthermore, we developed seven tasks
and collected 700 evaluation samples through multiple rounds of manual
annotation. The results show the significant challenges presented by the ToolBH
benchmark. The current advanced models Gemini-1.5-Pro and GPT-4o only achieve a
total score of 45.3 and 37.0, respectively, on a scale of 100. In this
benchmark, larger model parameters do not guarantee better performance; the
training data and response strategies also play a crucial role in tool-enhanced
LLM scenarios. Our diagnostic analysis indicates that the primary reason for
model errors lies in assessing task solvability. Additionally, open-weight
models suffer from performance drops with verbose replies, whereas proprietary
models excel with longer reasoning. | [
0.0364930965,
0.0067544575,
-0.0095317308,
0.036088217,
-0.0477325879,
0.0137587041,
-0.025523439,
-0.0058106063,
0.0042229788,
-0.048677776,
0.0117081348,
-0.0239092261,
-0.0456506759,
0.0026251695,
0.0056163627,
-0.0386380963,
0.0512410365,
-0.0645391122,
-0.0641994551,
-0.0003349351,
-0.0223511327,
0.015690919,
-0.0103813633,
0.0764432251,
-0.0033627872,
-0.0299342182,
-0.0211782791,
0.0104867164,
-0.0492854863,
0.004613664,
0.0187184475,
0.0740687773,
-0.0038044245,
0.0730932131,
0.0000024395,
-0.0834067166,
-0.0065670973,
0.0165913627,
-0.0468946435,
0.0153263444,
0.0371802785,
-0.0030499811,
-0.0132456999,
0.0501746871,
-0.0184082165,
-0.0059781182,
0.0487204194,
0.0438028313,
0.0554953292,
0.0549799018,
0.0006660487,
-0.0068019629,
0.0336386003,
-0.0004235172,
-0.0206418522,
-0.0137925483,
0.0078540305,
0.053526625,
0.0570802428,
-0.027087206,
0.014313818,
0.0342454314,
0.0511292219,
0.0062221047,
-0.0233721677,
0.0025032749,
-0.0541827157,
-0.0325290859,
-0.0024416605,
0.0366065241,
-0.0250379033,
-0.0222053993,
0.0004100983,
-0.0070130127,
-0.0149457939,
0.0047642537,
-0.0453073531,
-0.0080759041,
0.0005002036,
-0.0142296534,
0.0101277949,
-0.0495553948,
0.0427834578,
0.0028161567,
-0.0410505645,
0.1070315912,
0.0130711012,
-0.0293093156,
0.0067548156,
-0.0253843982,
-0.0211838838,
-0.0464579724,
-0.0064902543,
0.0543396361,
-0.0727261528,
0.0044492842,
0.0000065505,
0.0184406843,
0.0385405421,
-0.080228731,
0.0418552756,
0.0239222739,
-0.0348796807,
0.0478841998,
0.0008937673,
0.0148274964,
-0.0207865536,
0.0172620919,
-0.0289412085,
-0.0056886259,
-0.0618527234,
-0.0063627767,
-0.0340005346,
0.0012468135,
-0.0302126966,
-0.0465409532,
0.0071554286,
0.0275365654,
0.0013723751,
0.0174100697,
0.0119877756,
-0.0230413843,
0.0009548104,
-0.0383765027,
-0.0182768088,
0.0235469248,
-0.0300372988,
0.0100957807,
0.0264747515,
-0.0794008523,
0.0040470157,
0.0314098783,
-0.0334435701,
-0.0430005454,
0.0072289212,
0.0765993148,
0.0008496501,
0.019373795,
-0.0346941724,
-0.0537025668,
-0.0205611624,
-0.087080501,
-0.0055141738,
-0.0756117254,
-0.0102029294,
0.0429236852,
-0.019756265,
-0.0063148504,
-0.0004028853,
-0.0237725992,
-0.0119495392,
0.0490612984,
-0.0025607578,
0.0140879387,
0.0172049962,
0.0277851056,
-0.0239286963,
0.0795496926,
-0.0141052706,
0.0293160621,
-0.0024452393,
-0.0300005637,
0.0101804296,
0.0660363063,
-0.0396488644,
0.0260252915,
-0.0114695774,
0.0066558532,
0.0211875141,
0.0256368462,
-0.0262801871,
0.0438188836,
0.0146250632,
0.0069145919,
0.0344766155,
0.0266419854,
0.0421549752,
0.0159449857,
0.0399477333,
0.0312911607,
0.0076270802,
-0.0162018873,
-0.0746391714,
-0.0284550153,
-0.0578991212,
0.0186865553,
0.0165362488,
0.0050454168,
-0.0122217052,
-0.0432948172,
-0.0486311875,
0.0108081512,
-0.0246593133,
0.0168812349,
0.0730780289,
-0.0090258438,
-0.0650982559,
0.0425911807,
0.0084059425,
-0.0301862676,
-0.0231245644,
-0.0767202005,
0.0001735364,
0.0536196679,
0.0611605421,
-0.0387616865,
-0.0323538594,
0.0006971704,
0.0240135156,
0.0331298038,
0.058916416,
0.0122384336,
-0.0167496316,
-0.0472288877,
-0.0272043142,
0.004349689,
0.0386763513,
0.0061520673,
0.0079858508,
-0.0163137801,
0.0157788638,
-0.0504707918,
-0.0610617995,
0.0294591524,
0.0071236379,
-0.0021637592,
-0.0355107524,
-0.0161549915,
0.0460265651,
0.0045650746,
-0.0232302677,
0.0270390585,
0.0193016157,
-0.0372878686,
-0.031175999,
0.0185718741,
-0.0210004896,
0.0243442114,
0.0457080267,
0.0222228412,
-0.0000601277,
0.0414113775,
0.0018157008,
-0.0633326396,
0.0227070693,
-0.0336394049,
0.0525639392,
-0.0231638718,
0.0629199073,
-0.021422714,
0.007867177,
-0.0193978678,
0.0473283641,
-0.002179201,
0.0175198987,
-0.0135078533,
-0.0024184932,
0.0003203575,
-0.0163775757,
-0.0796706229,
0.0461690463,
-0.0084199579,
0.0159867872,
-0.0071261474,
-0.0056774602,
-0.0375105329,
-0.0303799622,
-0.1226402596,
0.0155168381,
-0.0220552087,
0.0186629891,
0.007276278,
-0.0012504603,
0.0083748857,
0.0002416804,
0.0032940526,
0.0088723311,
0.011074204,
0.0403987505,
-0.0233320501,
0.0103682242,
-0.0514162034,
-0.0253367536,
-0.019482838,
-0.0346696042,
0.0337135233,
-0.0182409305,
-0.0067278901,
-0.0462672375,
0.0848845467,
-0.0108068576,
0.0196208302,
-0.0065664626,
-0.0229214448,
0.0103546884,
-0.0288121998,
0.0328838527,
0.0491555184,
-0.0261524934,
0.0396782309,
0.0424702615,
-0.0205950588,
-0.0706922337,
0.0095157605,
0.0129293706,
-0.0537757017,
-0.02998944,
-0.036835324,
-0.0105563654,
0.0657020584,
-0.0179833192,
0.0202403888,
-0.0332823917,
-0.0070204786,
-0.038175229,
-0.0387224518,
0.0040098303,
-0.0175994541,
-0.0156578775,
0.027215749,
-0.0162625629,
-0.0543697663,
0.0520575456,
-0.0473943353,
-0.0184415095,
-0.0039397674,
-0.0193609893,
-0.0200101417,
0.0492027365,
0.0052469298,
0.0126108779,
-0.0132030565,
-0.0222947281,
-0.0169343054,
-0.0046032029,
-0.0055477978,
-0.0330536179,
0.0339703262,
-0.0595791675,
0.0276814122,
-0.0004505412,
-0.0169751775,
-0.0116671911,
-0.003978394,
-0.0440961905,
0.0327611528,
0.0245355275,
-0.0171568803,
-0.0198113527,
0.0485740937,
-0.003726634,
0.048281692,
0.0100545119,
-0.0072350199,
-0.0256167892,
-0.0124314474,
0.0217827503,
0.0255067181,
0.0610920079,
-0.0292274449,
0.0440432988,
0.0269910153,
0.0623605661,
-0.0201668292,
-0.0533948988,
0.0100225024,
0.0196564123,
-0.0296580959,
-0.0435265452,
0.0266842693,
0.0370800644,
-0.0887912884,
0.0154487118,
0.0873388574,
0.0439747758,
-0.0254574083,
0.0217611976,
-0.031344492,
0.0562128834,
0.0280478895,
0.0353159569,
-0.0837955996,
-0.0278878883,
0.0250402298,
0.0092814863,
-0.0132279024,
-0.0228143279,
0.0165154412,
-0.1218498573,
0.0499089733,
-0.0046115983,
0.0119350571,
0.0463693999,
-0.0407692678,
-0.0267229974,
0.0116331177,
0.0339760445,
0.0216785707,
0.012469776,
-0.0411591828,
0.0359084234,
-0.0663273782,
-0.0566958152,
0.059463013,
-0.0144293122,
0.0564527959,
0.0643938556,
-0.0201804098,
-0.002022706,
0.0133818276,
0.1017101109,
0.0347912498,
0.0150112864,
-0.006649598,
0.0061832387,
0.0408848859,
-0.0065031042,
-0.0117339185,
0.0039245887,
-0.0544836856,
-0.0035278101,
0.010493529,
0.1081782877,
-0.0259718951,
-0.0130595472,
0.002588256,
-0.0090987906,
-0.0067668851,
0.0760962963,
0.0064107394,
-0.0212351047,
-0.0866347775,
-0.004996988,
-0.0420610569,
-0.0269913338,
-0.045675125,
0.016102273,
0.0318435431,
-0.0053972765,
-0.0187417306,
-0.0444582999,
0.0541535877,
0.032445807,
0.0241346452,
0.0237939861,
-0.0459094383,
0.015625976,
-0.0307063665,
0.0537540801,
-0.0153664378,
0.0296831001,
-0.0848414078,
0.0287358891,
0.0021791959,
0.0096713649,
-0.0060831225,
0.0296475235,
-0.0584002957,
-0.0820420012,
0.0187586769,
0.036243543,
0.0344931148,
0.0016187818,
-0.0525139086,
-0.0899315178,
-0.0174413323,
0.0104794204,
-0.0171360895,
0.0244828686,
0.0207439661,
-0.0038999177,
0.0007033959,
0.0404252969,
-0.0308669619,
0.0041396478,
-0.0294756666,
0.0423995368,
-0.0004646507,
-0.0117762974,
0.0190578438,
0.0298759621,
-0.0282770619,
-0.0011805348,
-0.0391136259,
-0.0040660277,
0.017389968,
-0.0151300197,
-0.0207784418,
-0.0503043532,
0.0183653031,
0.0019155636,
-0.0126166185,
0.0426863022,
0.0140905418,
0.0005374618,
0.0101980511,
-0.0196827408,
0.0313360803,
0.0013088039,
-0.0309008621,
0.0526141003,
0.0025624931,
-0.0338352658,
-0.0004247655,
0.0044681029,
0.0532254055,
-0.0066796355,
0.0947805196,
-0.0155079067,
0.0026941993,
-0.0157848578,
0.0047795833,
-0.0377022736,
-0.1322742552,
-0.010090054,
0.0360601246,
0.0346548483,
-0.0130125256,
0.0644260943,
-0.0416282676,
0.0010029627,
-0.0471888632,
0.020267982,
0.0135975396,
-0.0141794048,
0.0142029542,
0.0498106703,
-0.0277878717,
0.0094986036,
0.0578460768,
0.0192512088,
0.0441608652,
0.0182900801,
-0.0076234881,
-0.0331319086,
-0.057953544,
0.0158749539,
0.0118833538,
-0.0389452688,
-0.0014403467,
-0.0852027237,
-0.0680445135,
-0.0360779576,
0.004405587,
-0.0099949902,
-0.0180997252,
0.0125023583,
0.0857785568,
-0.0096091796,
-0.0275411997,
-0.0237818044,
-0.0374429487,
-0.00992727,
0.0116000278,
0.0051566171,
-6.863072339e-33,
-0.0093099726,
-0.0122249769,
0.055482462,
-0.0485412814,
0.0014991065,
-0.0192154087,
-0.0424865037,
0.0472682267,
-0.0341902897,
0.0021708282,
-0.0012669256,
0.0049152146,
0.0185153671,
0.0053814002,
0.0275640041,
0.0310218278,
0.041127786,
0.0261038728,
-0.0211074241,
0.0062111607,
0.0327465832,
-0.0002085123,
0.0343703777,
-0.0548955984,
0.0222709067,
-0.0124902921,
-0.0107505023,
0.0362610966,
-0.0115947928,
0.0604680218,
-0.025708748,
0.0275996849,
0.0149575612,
-0.0260687806,
-0.0200041402,
-0.0250185113,
-0.0199380927,
0.0201793425,
0.0399005115,
0.0273483116,
-0.0051886356,
-0.0217699073,
0.0404833071,
0.0101723885,
-0.0302532371,
-0.004912612,
0.0124608977,
-0.0178278275,
-0.0191564616,
0.034854155,
-0.0532665104,
0.0221210476,
-0.0205581635,
-0.0487354621,
0.0127509693,
0.071509026,
-0.0236615743,
-0.0226858556,
-0.0319803283,
-0.0026204649,
0.0415844731,
0.0343322605,
0.1214282587,
0.018411465,
-0.0153829074,
0.0376568623,
0.0510830581,
-0.0026367235,
0.0077802488,
-0.0325631462,
0.0352419093,
0.0885124281,
0.0348815918,
-0.014332776,
-0.0008304513,
0.0410303399,
-0.0137388688,
0.0022283175,
0.0102487504,
0.0637733415,
0.0861018822,
0.0336088277,
-0.0766235217,
-0.0446933806,
-0.0443717763,
0.0106159626,
-0.0557546094,
-0.0450276807,
0.0616176464,
-0.0094166696,
-0.0121784555,
-0.0027684881,
0.0645619556,
-0.0377444699,
0.0059416513,
0.0050465926,
-0.0224720519,
0.0436651334,
-0.0177279748,
0.0498881228,
-0.0190717578,
-0.0150984908,
-0.0220400337,
0.0154526979,
0.0345537849,
-0.0143897561,
-0.0343163274,
-0.0008965587,
-0.0661053658,
-0.0052637015,
-0.0599306934,
0.0161423478,
-0.0001402029,
0.0352005064,
0.0650217757,
-0.0292677972,
0.0000065737,
0.0370851792,
-0.0085281348,
-0.0287815183,
-0.0209266692,
0.0053333617,
-0.0096449265,
-0.0247223955,
0.0119780665,
-0.0058000572,
-0.0260901731,
0.000964555,
0.0325302593,
-0.0060616303,
-0.0134578208,
0.002203112,
3.135e-7,
0.0311898552,
0.0257951058,
0.0063364375,
0.0073649408,
-0.0064556082,
0.0259432439,
-0.0120660029,
-0.0236532204,
0.0134361591,
-0.005494405,
-0.0171394013,
0.0325333849,
0.0816242769,
0.0199086983,
-0.0500929132,
-0.0226276126,
-0.0238453001,
-0.0033055141,
-0.0884514078,
-0.0236115456,
0.0355274938,
0.0739950091,
-0.0038456512,
0.001459163,
-0.0192809887,
-0.0749526024,
0.0263590757,
-0.0547518395,
-0.0210341383,
0.0405007116,
0.0050981478,
0.035728354,
0.0322016105,
0.0429875664,
0.0137227746,
-0.0120004537,
-0.0007278748,
0.0767999366,
0.0008467563,
-0.0300894249,
0.0043316162,
-0.0289157331,
0.0014348944,
-0.0716989711,
0.0602832921,
-0.0536987148,
-0.0529691987,
0.0048201126,
-0.0055430974,
-0.0388816707,
-0.0086359289,
-0.0124345366,
0.0092993435,
0.0107126506,
0.0001491729,
-0.0244446844,
-0.0071474547,
-0.0420609489,
-0.0229019448,
0.0625042468,
-0.0443478897,
-0.0800094083,
-0.0445519052,
0.0056026452,
-0.012346223,
-0.0467021205,
-0.006700235,
3.54260156e-34,
0.0504722036,
0.0272741225,
0.0670355782,
0.0839338079,
0.0505693518,
0.0268465709,
0.0350047499,
0.0298212003,
0.0110873487,
-0.1036224738,
-0.0039504771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19999v1 | The SIFo Benchmark: Investigating the Sequential Instruction Following Ability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T15:34:26 | 2024-06-28T15:34:26 | Xinyi Chen, Baohao Liao, Jirui Qi, Panagiotis Eustratiadis, Christof Monz, Arianna Bisazza, Maarten de Rijke | cs.CL | cs.CL | Following multiple instructions is a crucial ability for large language
models (LLMs). Evaluating this ability comes with significant challenges: (i)
limited coherence between multiple instructions, (ii) positional bias where the
order of instructions affects model performance, and (iii) a lack of
objectively verifiable tasks. To address these issues, we introduce a benchmark
designed to evaluate models' abilities to follow multiple instructions through
sequential instruction following (SIFo) tasks. In SIFo, the successful
completion of multiple instructions is verifiable by examining only the final
instruction. Our benchmark evaluates instruction following using four tasks
(text modification, question answering, mathematics, and security rule
following), each assessing different aspects of sequential instruction
following. Our evaluation of popular LLMs, both closed-source and open-source,
shows that more recent and larger models significantly outperform their older
and smaller counterparts on the SIFo tasks, validating the benchmark's
effectiveness. All models struggle with following sequences of instructions,
hinting at an important lack of robustness of today's language models. | [
0.0446118303,
0.0768607035,
-0.0013201463,
0.0237814207,
-0.0513174199,
0.0190856811,
0.0140134152,
-0.0138301374,
0.0058327443,
-0.0439671315,
-0.0078402348,
-0.0394344889,
-0.0104210563,
-0.012034623,
0.0243755411,
-0.0356026292,
0.0782240406,
-0.0826296359,
-0.025621973,
-0.0016481214,
-0.0025727572,
-0.0177773032,
-0.0035865195,
0.0318930969,
0.0352383666,
-0.0377436131,
-0.0308582895,
0.0078827012,
0.010990018,
-0.0253673624,
-0.0014121064,
0.0603125021,
0.0094470633,
0.0402469188,
0.0000020526,
-0.0412402004,
0.0036429139,
0.0213880092,
-0.0346329696,
0.0703304783,
-0.0010417643,
-0.0064582415,
-0.0206367522,
0.0225999393,
-0.0168218203,
0.0316626579,
0.0446137376,
0.0263895541,
0.0810442567,
0.0824166089,
0.0210523661,
-0.0322225131,
0.03723621,
-0.0449928567,
0.0080648037,
-0.0653967932,
0.0188656561,
0.009933209,
0.0223828368,
0.0530676283,
-0.0191253945,
0.038452737,
0.0508441702,
0.0056370967,
-0.0517636426,
0.0121918749,
-0.0079100095,
-0.0101027591,
-0.0295111034,
0.0533709042,
-0.0165994745,
0.0033308954,
-0.0020777918,
-0.006627332,
0.0104860114,
0.0035559079,
-0.0616582483,
0.0348183587,
-0.0032216224,
-0.020396227,
0.0288299602,
-0.0329427868,
0.0256957207,
-0.0005297908,
-0.0365672968,
0.1124728695,
0.0336532854,
-0.0433713496,
-0.0156427771,
-0.0196047686,
-0.0352429077,
-0.0706464052,
-0.0092404447,
0.0352879167,
-0.0545670763,
0.0471946895,
-0.0536492318,
0.0005818584,
0.0491694696,
-0.0479030423,
0.0581153072,
0.0663422421,
-0.0088071469,
0.0362748615,
-0.0208614804,
0.0950582772,
-0.0467051044,
0.0468917154,
-0.0282391459,
0.0317737274,
-0.0462725759,
-0.0093073742,
-0.010565157,
0.0637467504,
-0.031005932,
-0.0191219393,
-0.039619986,
0.0452551134,
-0.0207210649,
0.0459685586,
0.0086089121,
-0.0339488387,
0.002730483,
-0.0111364294,
-0.0064439103,
0.0014046476,
-0.0458130725,
0.0171535388,
0.0008138628,
-0.0489823334,
-0.0021952204,
-0.0080275005,
-0.0429896228,
-0.0387797318,
-0.0019249109,
0.0642317086,
-0.0007269013,
-0.0145641807,
-0.0329520702,
-0.0520907827,
-0.0016233714,
-0.0604648888,
0.0034310976,
-0.0776895359,
0.0354852378,
0.0036464806,
-0.0023397112,
-0.0136394706,
0.0267771538,
0.0594013296,
-0.0345062427,
0.0361140035,
0.04309972,
0.0044625863,
-0.0209991131,
0.0318986885,
0.0184339173,
0.0435952768,
0.0161929373,
0.0252257027,
0.0402202755,
-0.0162057951,
-0.0163895767,
0.0574027002,
-0.0011188668,
0.0191702172,
-0.0036204711,
0.0464226305,
0.0200940445,
0.0211912915,
0.01061437,
0.0841305852,
-0.0190094188,
-0.0306542274,
0.051932659,
0.042617429,
-0.0060695689,
-0.045175951,
0.0540539026,
0.017154675,
0.0212303549,
0.032171689,
-0.0951794237,
0.0246578678,
-0.0171063878,
0.0318259522,
0.004161072,
0.0121839968,
-0.030355541,
-0.0316155665,
-0.0034754409,
0.0068357084,
-0.0021342339,
0.0305326004,
0.0360870659,
-0.0113583924,
-0.0500263125,
0.0327739008,
0.0055996045,
-0.0353985354,
-0.0334604979,
-0.0789408162,
0.0188447554,
0.0733692944,
0.0401471891,
-0.0139783192,
-0.0467439927,
0.0068286229,
0.0390867479,
0.0304356348,
0.033255402,
-0.0001070115,
0.0182903185,
-0.0184279364,
-0.0316202119,
-0.0273499582,
0.0079294555,
0.0186884683,
0.048795931,
-0.0149330022,
0.0163770281,
0.0184411723,
-0.0245068073,
0.0538586602,
-0.0344239511,
-0.032703016,
-0.0315122753,
-0.0027916327,
0.0308149718,
-0.0086988825,
-0.0168408342,
0.0385617577,
0.0412417576,
0.0145936403,
0.0067226803,
-0.0225403793,
-0.0564496443,
-0.0222536959,
0.0380447209,
0.0068224878,
-0.0175922569,
0.0564195178,
-0.0521217994,
-0.0235365424,
0.016543597,
-0.0348146334,
0.0090491502,
-0.0054558488,
0.0434428081,
-0.0069631319,
-0.0203544609,
-0.0271868184,
0.040780846,
-0.0389341637,
0.0353509299,
0.0418896154,
0.0101550082,
-0.0088370042,
-0.0353931487,
-0.0255035758,
-0.0086010024,
-0.0222465396,
0.0150579391,
0.0266141463,
0.0084535088,
-0.0406981595,
-0.0547890104,
-0.0647590011,
0.0332099088,
-0.0379291251,
0.0324912556,
0.0295767058,
0.0000146129,
0.0120544452,
-0.0268944968,
-0.0133594507,
-0.0317197219,
-0.0034523278,
0.0517667904,
0.008050181,
0.0122957714,
-0.0624280944,
-0.0525600463,
-0.0440853536,
-0.0252235699,
0.0168532021,
-0.0293824412,
0.0202782508,
-0.0723400787,
0.0220360123,
-0.0281704627,
0.0309323445,
-0.0226345435,
-0.0165270772,
0.0518017001,
-0.0035842035,
0.0302136317,
0.0852704272,
0.016746914,
0.026271997,
0.0496516563,
-0.00951239,
-0.0415668413,
0.0047032274,
-0.0021945077,
-0.024453152,
-0.0510323159,
-0.0434949957,
0.0025347327,
0.0882922709,
-0.0099565238,
0.0116894571,
-0.0448157825,
-0.0120639624,
-0.029380776,
-0.0411830544,
-0.0298099443,
-0.031991832,
-0.0350797549,
0.0224078186,
-0.0566249751,
-0.0636797175,
0.0596740954,
-0.0210438389,
0.0058118473,
-0.0268380307,
0.020774005,
-0.0249268673,
0.0839349627,
0.0302203968,
0.0184726547,
-0.0078958971,
-0.0343281366,
-0.0576146431,
-0.0190773197,
0.0216605235,
-0.0405911617,
0.0489683524,
-0.0744625404,
-0.0078520654,
-0.005813696,
-0.0430665091,
-0.0553540736,
-0.0564845651,
-0.0086075692,
0.024231473,
0.0399148241,
-0.0440712571,
-0.0421849973,
-0.0173223596,
0.0559028387,
0.030702753,
-0.0181989968,
-0.009298807,
-0.0318892002,
-0.011975579,
0.0747070014,
-0.0309021417,
-0.0003119288,
-0.0618895367,
0.0389121473,
0.0752475634,
0.0696893707,
-0.0248216968,
-0.0311985482,
-0.007253604,
0.0369783528,
-0.07329496,
-0.0492464937,
0.0606583953,
0.0667219311,
-0.0725793317,
-0.0137882801,
0.1255344599,
0.0407507122,
0.0184117667,
0.0162860882,
-0.0198524594,
0.0220553316,
0.0278089866,
0.0372107625,
-0.0944728479,
-0.0188504886,
0.0237635877,
0.0233873185,
0.0033538183,
-0.011631879,
-0.0106291166,
-0.1110786051,
0.0133520914,
0.0001014763,
-0.0432559997,
-0.0052531841,
-0.0428675562,
-0.0033279529,
0.0222202614,
0.0201007891,
0.0336053818,
-0.0217376929,
-0.0305050015,
0.0123436702,
-0.0388081819,
-0.0157395229,
0.0750489086,
-0.0335898548,
0.0404925123,
0.0587609336,
-0.0310654175,
0.0015296265,
-0.0380424559,
0.0403703451,
-0.0037744779,
0.0028747488,
-0.0090571847,
0.0337067284,
-0.0136268055,
-0.0060465513,
-0.0208941437,
0.0064956588,
-0.0029200069,
-0.005720906,
0.0286874622,
0.0495615676,
-0.0253336504,
-0.0285258051,
-0.0308943707,
-0.0039112382,
-0.0244729836,
0.0605746135,
0.0120885121,
-0.0473217927,
-0.0491911694,
-0.0414187051,
-0.0541267917,
-0.0713568181,
-0.012826453,
-0.0029656484,
0.0094023347,
0.0072996668,
-0.033152815,
-0.0506016649,
-0.0027092427,
0.017561473,
0.0146657201,
0.0023456882,
0.0539337806,
-0.0353799202,
-0.0112534007,
-0.0083601465,
-0.0447854325,
0.0479251929,
-0.1022318304,
0.0039036474,
-0.0047540748,
0.0214765891,
-0.0379641429,
0.0065365466,
-0.0982013643,
-0.0668169037,
0.0175970346,
0.0879815668,
0.0215369407,
-0.0034120861,
-0.0131276604,
-0.0389889628,
-0.0210270118,
-0.0225559454,
-0.0296717398,
0.0279387757,
0.0351287574,
-0.0451338701,
0.0162912924,
0.0203426201,
-0.0328264646,
0.024940962,
0.0192401577,
0.045270741,
-0.0425637886,
-0.0436194949,
0.0199750699,
0.0235203169,
-0.0043740892,
-0.0004594779,
0.0272473469,
0.0011986956,
0.0307603013,
-0.0341081694,
-0.014033542,
-0.0123358807,
0.0104198428,
0.0439213701,
-0.0147295073,
0.0007969357,
-0.0074836402,
-0.0017118671,
0.0020396749,
-0.0327303708,
0.0114961993,
0.0033244388,
0.0384782478,
0.0310558267,
0.0034738067,
-0.0399318337,
0.02262225,
0.005758699,
0.0539467223,
-0.0070378291,
0.0557767525,
0.007202859,
0.014360114,
-0.0269329939,
0.0413690247,
-0.0942130759,
-0.0486963019,
0.0143627115,
-0.002396941,
0.0407737494,
0.0077181198,
0.0568838753,
-0.0064303894,
0.0028720133,
-0.0487562008,
0.0266985949,
0.0155635867,
-0.0541107394,
0.025014136,
0.0521187745,
0.0017924756,
0.0081349658,
0.0783062652,
0.0184063204,
0.0326986425,
0.0057685599,
-0.0020824706,
-0.0351837128,
-0.0427513309,
-0.0044946941,
0.0179407299,
-0.0550529025,
-0.0117677376,
-0.0422749035,
-0.0485954471,
-0.0115979547,
0.0180513784,
0.0170558672,
-0.0052121636,
0.0310231298,
0.0512238108,
0.0171823949,
-0.0382118262,
-0.0398177207,
-0.0156991128,
0.0107293827,
-0.0327643827,
-0.0195732638,
-6.125631836e-33,
-0.0353990681,
-0.0076896655,
0.0440486446,
-0.0128529342,
0.0008382825,
-0.017337326,
-0.053982649,
0.0215121135,
-0.0347219259,
-0.0105260098,
-0.0131359668,
0.024452202,
0.0162259489,
0.0055627134,
0.038436465,
0.0032757281,
0.0396933332,
-0.0139179807,
-0.028509574,
0.0074165296,
0.0290639549,
-0.0084334286,
0.022160314,
-0.0290124509,
0.0513789244,
-0.0062050796,
0.0063955416,
-0.0051863696,
-0.0625987798,
0.0958114639,
0.0070719239,
0.0070903441,
0.0162941609,
-0.0502646118,
-0.031711977,
0.0319809131,
-0.0396367982,
-0.0345481001,
0.0504091382,
0.004902225,
-0.0437954031,
-0.0314140543,
0.0156578533,
-0.0107678808,
-0.010965121,
-0.0279424507,
0.0092453528,
-0.0031868494,
-0.0289646816,
0.0226555616,
-0.0909089893,
0.0225847419,
-0.0079706451,
-0.0332739688,
0.0031528072,
0.048335202,
-0.003598663,
-0.0316266976,
-0.0213070586,
0.0245844815,
0.0130298343,
0.0674715117,
0.058523573,
0.017497804,
-0.0103648016,
0.0406646989,
0.0238485187,
0.008615125,
0.0033625346,
0.0135083497,
0.0303148031,
0.0518492982,
0.0468639582,
-0.0141056599,
0.0337120853,
0.0097721554,
-0.0636937097,
-0.0143243503,
0.0276634488,
0.0618704148,
0.0357527286,
0.007931916,
-0.0566068739,
0.0000780508,
-0.0542738885,
0.0676048771,
-0.0302700866,
-0.019372467,
0.0678897053,
0.0172206685,
-0.0122097684,
0.0071987542,
0.0445159413,
-0.0285963863,
-0.0318200216,
0.0097520519,
-0.0179734696,
0.0312120132,
-0.0168373864,
0.0645187944,
-0.0794819295,
-0.0352571458,
0.0083190231,
-0.0226703286,
0.0241809636,
0.0105064716,
0.018897105,
0.0186582431,
-0.0834141597,
-0.0073170261,
-0.0352524631,
0.0152992532,
0.010393478,
-0.0070764408,
0.0639327243,
-0.0036230695,
-0.0014384941,
0.0504018441,
-0.0195287336,
-0.0598053634,
-0.0355585851,
0.0006210919,
0.0056284554,
0.0190055631,
0.0008713168,
0.0199833494,
-0.0556461401,
0.0532777309,
-0.0204158314,
-0.0244706031,
-0.0148478197,
0.0412865989,
2.702e-7,
0.0336259753,
0.0213183183,
0.0357466601,
0.0844448358,
-0.0040803007,
0.0013386647,
-0.029568335,
0.0083921244,
0.0066498434,
0.0098639354,
-0.009170102,
0.0437203981,
0.0264949035,
0.0091897659,
-0.0387561433,
-0.0159591902,
-0.0646443069,
0.031865526,
-0.0549319983,
0.0080397129,
0.0215819366,
0.0759591162,
-0.002162843,
0.0155755254,
-0.0215646774,
-0.0324276537,
0.058803957,
0.0003899653,
-0.0045150444,
0.0181680992,
-0.0014611267,
0.0367434397,
0.0099310307,
0.0208598226,
-0.0009193877,
-0.0148168169,
-0.0132265426,
0.1048546359,
0.006377846,
-0.0029453146,
-0.0030015421,
-0.0430227928,
-0.0052423361,
-0.0401526466,
0.069425188,
-0.025877893,
-0.0146761099,
-0.0190222133,
-0.0218367055,
-0.0167063121,
0.0123407887,
-0.0023818254,
-0.003177712,
-0.0079584317,
0.0303617232,
-0.0185639244,
-0.0028205295,
-0.0496239327,
-0.0337730721,
0.0228967778,
-0.0123610562,
-0.0576077327,
-0.0658460259,
0.0103006102,
0.0045626084,
-0.046271991,
-0.0425994247,
2.667058699e-34,
0.0460087173,
-0.0375682712,
0.0436953939,
0.0357634984,
0.0200022198,
-0.0048294049,
-0.0524464548,
0.026362,
0.0234961864,
-0.074146159,
-0.0400923938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19995v1 | Single Parent Family: A Spectrum of Family Members from a Single Pre-Trained Foundation Model | 2024-06-28T15:27:57 | 2024-06-28T15:27:57 | Habib Hajimolahoseini, Mohammad Hassanpour, Foozhan Ataiefard, Boxing Chen, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces a novel method of Progressive Low Rank Decomposition
(PLRD) tailored for the compression of large language models. Our approach
leverages a pre-trained model, which is then incrementally decompressed to
smaller sizes using progressively lower ranks. This method allows for
significant reductions in computational overhead and energy consumption, as
subsequent models are derived from the original without the need for retraining
from scratch. We detail the implementation of PLRD, which strategically
decreases the tensor ranks, thus optimizing the trade-off between model
performance and resource usage. The efficacy of PLRD is demonstrated through
extensive experiments showing that models trained with PLRD method on only 1B
tokens maintain comparable performance with traditionally trained models while
using 0.1% of the tokens. The versatility of PLRD is highlighted by its ability
to generate multiple model sizes from a single foundational model, adapting
fluidly to varying computational and memory budgets. Our findings suggest that
PLRD could set a new standard for the efficient scaling of LLMs, making
advanced AI more feasible on diverse platforms. | [
-0.0389822759,
0.0887302384,
-0.0351403765,
0.0432913713,
-0.0148852263,
0.0266324431,
0.0145314792,
0.041888684,
-0.0371976048,
0.0072977287,
-0.0389023945,
-0.0472856015,
0.0007438148,
0.0117435157,
-0.0220582411,
-0.0123923915,
0.0190820247,
-0.0446599238,
-0.0002277928,
-0.0079436749,
-0.0299241766,
0.0322406292,
0.0198732354,
0.0356647894,
-0.009972305,
0.0017451864,
-0.0258522201,
0.0049647563,
0.0056765657,
0.0207228195,
-0.0169892181,
0.0478356294,
0.0741065666,
0.0410912707,
0.0000021669,
0.0107524442,
-0.005658363,
-0.0013400004,
-0.0247495975,
0.0181198735,
0.0486368313,
0.0205063261,
-0.0048466027,
0.0136745637,
-0.0184403732,
0.0018789071,
0.0322117582,
0.0155997602,
0.0342119895,
0.0347610041,
0.008321384,
-0.0636315271,
0.0062259859,
-0.0183883011,
-0.0499573685,
-0.0177520514,
-0.0219117925,
-0.0361558869,
-0.0409627408,
-0.0408142991,
-0.0017459188,
0.0232317504,
0.0178436581,
0.0165405758,
0.0018011627,
0.03349711,
-0.0261153001,
-0.0399414748,
0.0267855264,
0.0449064784,
-0.0228599701,
-0.0324636549,
0.0167132579,
0.0044241124,
-0.0101045715,
-0.0611805543,
-0.0378977768,
0.0643710122,
0.0137038492,
0.0466377102,
0.0329149291,
-0.0245903805,
0.0322942138,
-0.0189163424,
-0.0482100099,
0.0305557754,
0.0427606441,
-0.0230990965,
-0.0367094874,
-0.0118591655,
0.0046489281,
0.0030125163,
0.0005355569,
-0.0009448837,
-0.0216536429,
0.0082797138,
-0.0743455142,
-0.0612876415,
-0.0013376945,
-0.0119774649,
0.075435482,
0.0344838612,
0.0061697904,
0.0430052206,
-0.030007571,
0.0308947396,
-0.0060404097,
-0.0423719771,
-0.0464210473,
-0.0087031946,
-0.0090415049,
0.0017704451,
-0.051453948,
0.0548615903,
-0.0577131994,
-0.021335179,
-0.0112848459,
-0.0022940582,
0.0203700978,
0.0066574384,
0.035759747,
0.0169545561,
0.0040014917,
-0.0022384194,
0.0255940426,
0.0404033735,
-0.0124802962,
0.0036849354,
-0.0271434169,
-0.047457926,
-0.0022840528,
0.0408134572,
-0.0007375412,
0.0101727936,
0.0516711064,
0.0239977501,
-0.0109909428,
-0.0561117716,
-0.014667647,
-0.0231346302,
0.0216941759,
-0.0741686597,
0.0035876725,
-0.0253417082,
0.0551019087,
-0.0223164838,
0.0028598991,
-0.0452011265,
0.0234474707,
0.0068865316,
-0.0599852912,
0.026645951,
0.0024771453,
0.0363054797,
0.0145975361,
0.0112648923,
0.0221525915,
0.054497581,
0.0481000319,
0.0025266104,
0.0157027375,
-0.0258684587,
-0.0531600863,
0.0399451815,
0.0304954015,
-0.0061134063,
-0.0340408497,
-0.0153089808,
-0.0462088138,
0.0195602328,
0.0387883037,
0.0758794397,
-0.023000326,
-0.0081561608,
0.0545882694,
0.0966224,
0.020877406,
0.0894524232,
0.0204732921,
-0.0073841251,
0.0025359287,
-0.0220300201,
-0.037599612,
0.0124370847,
-0.0162000023,
-0.0297464076,
0.0269856043,
0.0469932295,
-0.0463903286,
-0.0156926885,
-0.0348933004,
-0.029759787,
-0.0038261428,
0.0030424157,
0.044232998,
-0.0294844173,
-0.0235971306,
0.0952816382,
0.0257145856,
-0.0858512819,
-0.0355166607,
-0.0748851746,
0.0093049761,
0.0366093218,
0.0243816338,
-0.0047021261,
-0.0171758346,
0.0171544179,
-0.0093007097,
-0.0188040379,
-0.0177826807,
0.0042740218,
0.0590725169,
-0.0608887263,
-0.0030817825,
0.0341793969,
0.0189434364,
0.0097250398,
-0.0003034166,
-0.0316076465,
0.0131572979,
-0.0278590452,
0.0271912403,
0.0382009074,
-0.0562966131,
0.0018845235,
0.0559837259,
0.0014591842,
0.0369389541,
0.0194836147,
-0.0193112791,
-0.0254617259,
0.0759546161,
-0.0649136528,
0.0246147458,
-0.0315546021,
-0.0391593464,
0.0025059178,
0.0298735779,
0.0034397452,
0.0241968501,
0.0558544248,
-0.0301284194,
-0.037532337,
0.0346011668,
-0.031118229,
0.0340464152,
-0.0528554544,
0.0023684765,
-0.0416902453,
0.0155922845,
0.0003506922,
0.0694842041,
-0.0560201257,
-0.0154496292,
0.0558341779,
-0.0274090394,
0.0012439671,
-0.0579006039,
-0.0253510661,
-0.0139382016,
-0.0006372777,
0.0122591462,
-0.0000361387,
0.022805851,
0.009526846,
-0.0250365976,
-0.1175177395,
0.018585436,
-0.0216917992,
0.0169616807,
0.0111025581,
0.0041165669,
0.018239636,
-0.0110907452,
-0.010439299,
0.0324347168,
0.0194608681,
0.0071800849,
0.0018738526,
-0.022118628,
-0.0438776202,
-0.030620344,
-0.0538035296,
0.0380606204,
0.0369878635,
-0.0474091209,
-0.0180160645,
-0.0525663644,
0.0347402133,
-0.0232072584,
0.0396520607,
-0.0130142281,
-0.0275098626,
-0.0066619394,
-0.0399278477,
0.060640756,
0.0547671877,
-0.0093172379,
0.0321670659,
0.0945471451,
0.0357197672,
-0.0179910865,
0.0073247538,
0.0064073917,
0.0044456641,
0.0007846112,
-0.0044890335,
-0.0337627754,
0.0592819564,
-0.0083124219,
-0.0031087541,
-0.0461277626,
-0.0333015583,
-0.0037187522,
-0.0426707193,
-0.0274706613,
-0.0190722235,
-0.0201004241,
0.0198578238,
0.0130915176,
-0.0418224484,
0.0267882664,
-0.0366450511,
-0.0339770019,
0.0178768784,
-0.0706824437,
-0.0362457074,
0.0641033798,
0.0186692346,
0.04106161,
-0.0515847132,
-0.0019423112,
-0.053646341,
0.0171880517,
-0.0204845462,
-0.0357082896,
0.0489780083,
-0.0382993333,
0.0015007228,
-0.0241097454,
-0.0731638223,
-0.0077589438,
0.0054402058,
0.0044988072,
0.0416402407,
0.0170971137,
-0.0484126918,
-0.0171519294,
-0.0058639059,
0.0240603462,
0.0477917865,
0.0231624991,
0.0287267137,
-0.0094612818,
0.054007709,
0.0246744081,
0.0011324453,
0.0493846834,
-0.0326110497,
0.0360252298,
0.0441330262,
0.0642454028,
0.0242462978,
-0.0414566882,
-0.0107176006,
0.0290341787,
0.0360792875,
-0.0608229861,
0.0290555805,
-0.0025979583,
-0.0518120751,
-0.0014310575,
0.1065531373,
0.014033339,
-0.0302839689,
0.0104400516,
-0.006360251,
0.0750471801,
0.0131499711,
0.0012501802,
-0.0639803559,
-0.0064877989,
0.0226452462,
0.0148131829,
0.0519206189,
-0.0355050676,
0.0008948282,
-0.0710107908,
0.0316892974,
0.0220563579,
0.0197308771,
-0.0120760938,
-0.0454623289,
-0.0107360445,
0.0011368125,
0.0159881208,
0.0419823714,
-0.01806508,
-0.0193236843,
0.0031132565,
-0.033731319,
-0.0178447589,
0.0236074608,
-0.014874219,
0.0463243611,
-0.0004771985,
0.0310095139,
-0.0022535035,
-0.0486905202,
0.0256100204,
-0.0182134937,
0.0070032431,
-0.0313120484,
-0.0267625786,
0.024349913,
0.0018359245,
-0.0004252796,
0.0200865455,
-0.0275182277,
0.0009637616,
-0.0366934948,
0.0932049006,
-0.0279415417,
-0.0516713969,
-0.0071185539,
-0.0326593146,
-0.0344042517,
0.0866001248,
0.0263551958,
-0.0351064838,
-0.02286404,
0.0570633225,
0.0110907899,
-0.0071753417,
-0.042110879,
0.0032929599,
-0.0053493339,
0.0045803757,
-0.0274935812,
0.0394637696,
0.0042268797,
0.0333644189,
-0.0259067174,
-0.0014153057,
-0.0311907046,
0.0256030317,
-0.0509495921,
0.0078832395,
-0.0335461609,
-0.0248638056,
-0.0560784861,
0.0073383548,
0.0438860618,
-0.0098893261,
-0.0204326939,
-0.0294129662,
-0.0875755847,
-0.0253802594,
-0.0153612476,
0.0449809469,
0.0228895973,
-0.0001994731,
0.0277636778,
-0.0596374609,
0.04459925,
0.0110087395,
-0.0106760198,
0.0858270526,
0.0039132689,
-0.0821884945,
-0.0044677467,
0.0570373125,
-0.0280058645,
0.0365159437,
-0.0142734414,
0.0259532779,
-0.0055554262,
-0.0296254475,
-0.0160863642,
0.0403370708,
0.032932464,
-0.0417073667,
-0.0173201803,
-0.0239533558,
0.0487200022,
-0.0278378986,
0.0154296253,
-0.0506404713,
0.0204049908,
0.0069703851,
0.0156968068,
-0.0033776478,
-0.011826111,
0.0567317195,
0.020237539,
-0.0103412038,
0.0403184295,
-0.011483537,
0.0178103056,
0.0490134321,
0.0218657609,
-0.0237111207,
0.008327106,
-0.0127750589,
0.0040324619,
-0.0473409332,
-0.0098955669,
-0.0127603328,
0.0220874716,
-0.0692896619,
0.0705721006,
-0.0131509434,
-0.0987221673,
-0.012777837,
0.0044664303,
0.0498107709,
0.0311342981,
0.036268767,
-0.0065271989,
-0.0071841315,
-0.0269725006,
0.0127302445,
0.0206519961,
-0.016809389,
0.0081403619,
-0.0005383532,
-0.0239635594,
0.0418836027,
0.0490732566,
0.0184925981,
0.05321569,
-0.0151246041,
0.0177999549,
-0.0310630072,
-0.0394885801,
-0.0181572754,
0.0155130513,
-0.0231348965,
-0.0073047136,
-0.0323037244,
-0.0235531554,
-0.0338949002,
0.0255529732,
0.0005870764,
-0.0176360346,
0.046338629,
0.03696068,
-0.0022832875,
-0.0148918303,
0.0209835898,
-0.0274447091,
-0.0067406539,
-0.0548392422,
0.0249342471,
-6.480771454e-33,
-0.0261641908,
0.0314807929,
0.0174680427,
-0.0447419398,
-0.0176847894,
0.0381896906,
-0.0075621326,
0.0067909565,
-0.017488258,
-0.0171962418,
-0.0428994931,
-0.0134756863,
-0.0061944635,
0.0236771163,
0.0119794402,
0.0196368303,
0.0719339475,
-0.0473979823,
0.0029622086,
0.0646338686,
0.0369206332,
0.0217945632,
0.0235439744,
-0.0327231847,
-0.0919477791,
-0.0280648414,
-0.0167981796,
0.036522951,
0.0153554622,
0.0416217521,
-0.0499986112,
0.0054543493,
0.0247377884,
-0.0118811997,
-0.0257281847,
0.0261561293,
-0.0910862088,
-0.01074789,
0.023871528,
-0.0373984352,
-0.0447215661,
-0.0187921263,
0.0378294513,
0.0433378443,
-0.0269589685,
-0.0234061275,
-0.0118877292,
-0.0290499963,
-0.0219515432,
-0.0327010415,
-0.046568688,
0.0014075339,
0.017251214,
0.019635886,
0.0853848159,
0.0133370645,
-0.0536722802,
0.0072043994,
-0.0416672975,
-0.0103202816,
-0.0068758419,
0.0671232343,
0.0548418649,
-0.0160929803,
-0.010520122,
0.0436493494,
0.0410982035,
-0.0117355101,
-0.03145051,
-0.0148609187,
0.0369320102,
0.101603128,
0.0280570686,
-0.0018860195,
0.021051567,
-0.005220511,
-0.0930091888,
-0.0172380768,
0.0597609319,
0.0255246628,
0.0146373548,
0.037444178,
0.0091288574,
-0.0038469259,
-0.0415087827,
-0.037386287,
-0.0320434123,
-0.0303156897,
0.0101488866,
0.0409222916,
-0.0365012437,
-0.0739120618,
0.0640873834,
-0.0522576608,
0.0298871566,
0.0539325252,
0.0155214192,
0.0144657297,
0.0290169232,
0.0245330185,
-0.0261277929,
-0.0597436987,
0.0274392609,
-0.0530434772,
0.0467263982,
-0.014261703,
0.0282870289,
0.0545412861,
-0.068074882,
-0.0078799659,
-0.0030046953,
-0.0148574663,
0.0108695403,
0.0491047241,
0.0164130311,
0.0164325032,
0.0339680463,
0.031729348,
0.0148477899,
0.0436694585,
-0.049217578,
-0.0122856777,
0.041816555,
0.0224446822,
-0.0177358612,
0.004563476,
-0.0679248944,
0.0361831784,
0.0849610344,
-0.0536335669,
-0.0397864617,
0.013240397,
2.857e-7,
0.0039357231,
0.0443918668,
-0.0147125777,
-0.0327544846,
0.0546154045,
0.025154382,
-0.0034374928,
0.0251788739,
-0.0168147236,
0.0029840635,
0.0488233007,
0.0128383478,
0.0331950001,
0.0099463677,
-0.0783218443,
0.0014580514,
-0.0792921335,
-0.0281008594,
-0.0559438094,
-0.0064372183,
-0.0060817604,
0.1248416603,
0.0308924373,
-0.0571157895,
-0.0123119857,
0.0166392867,
0.0250796657,
-0.0401379429,
0.0206711572,
-0.037328586,
-0.0154535379,
0.0007388691,
-0.0432514362,
-0.0271855108,
0.0002745737,
0.0422604829,
-0.0401135199,
0.0976045206,
-0.0344822928,
0.0113223055,
0.0486037359,
0.0159375779,
-0.0317939632,
-0.0400988609,
0.0665389672,
0.0502439588,
0.00117613,
-0.0665290207,
0.0060179704,
-0.0120791867,
-0.0146851521,
-0.0055015949,
0.0221827105,
0.0578693673,
-0.0107892966,
-0.0337608084,
-0.0051238229,
-0.1110628769,
0.0251210686,
0.023426339,
-0.0715273246,
-0.0654642954,
-0.0121150855,
0.0025863387,
0.0518108495,
-0.0511672162,
-0.0065424619,
3.010075298e-34,
0.0105683291,
-0.0229153093,
0.0182504654,
0.0746917129,
0.0058082314,
-0.0340723805,
-0.023827238,
0.0037224952,
-0.017150417,
-0.1091580912,
-0.0168518405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19967v1 | Into the Unknown: Generating Geospatial Descriptions for New Environments | 2024-06-28T14:56:21 | 2024-06-28T14:56:21 | Tzuf Paz-Argaman, John Palowitch, Sayali Kulkarni, Reut Tsarfaty, Jason Baldridge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Similar to vision-and-language navigation (VLN) tasks that focus on bridging
the gap between vision and language for embodied navigation, the new Rendezvous
(RVS) task requires reasoning over allocentric spatial relationships
(independent of the observer's viewpoint) using non-sequential navigation
instructions and maps. However, performance substantially drops in new
environments with no training data. Using opensource descriptions paired with
coordinates (e.g., Wikipedia) provides training data but suffers from limited
spatially-oriented text resulting in low geolocation resolution. We propose a
large-scale augmentation method for generating high-quality synthetic data for
new environments using readily available geospatial data. Our method constructs
a grounded knowledge-graph, capturing entity relationships. Sampled entities
and relations (`shop north of school') generate navigation instructions via (i)
generating numerous templates using context-free grammar (CFG) to embed
specific entities and relations; (ii) feeding the entities and relation into a
large language model (LLM) for instruction generation. A comprehensive
evaluation on RVS, showed that our approach improves the 100-meter accuracy by
45.83% on unseen environments. Furthermore, we demonstrate that models trained
with CFG-based augmentation achieve superior performance compared with those
trained with LLM-based augmentation, both in unseen and seen environments.
These findings suggest that the potential advantages of explicitly structuring
spatial information for text-based geospatial reasoning in previously unknown,
can unlock data-scarce scenarios. | [
0.0441830866,
0.0297207739,
0.0259537194,
0.0151462369,
0.0175551791,
0.0305513572,
-0.0147482045,
-0.0475541987,
0.0285119116,
-0.0753466859,
-0.0207730923,
-0.0158114694,
0.0150843766,
0.0169186108,
0.051925838,
-0.0659850985,
0.0352028869,
-0.0299012735,
-0.0481568575,
0.0125323841,
-0.0392447263,
0.0359396264,
-0.034893129,
0.0264957305,
-0.0244045518,
0.0254577324,
-0.0448148102,
0.0306685623,
0.0422772951,
-0.0861659124,
-0.0142734405,
0.0186995845,
0.0815035105,
0.0183052365,
0.000002041,
-0.0082376739,
0.0235243849,
-0.005550324,
-0.0180547852,
-0.023200294,
0.0009187037,
-0.0425365679,
0.0224558134,
0.0041629686,
-0.0417556912,
-0.0679982975,
0.0436759926,
0.0262960438,
0.0346918441,
0.0790424794,
-0.0177278556,
-0.0486263596,
-0.0130941672,
-0.0081510106,
0.030611597,
0.0281785056,
0.0097283851,
0.0271883793,
0.0192924924,
0.0537460782,
-0.0147227095,
0.0133715915,
0.0377964787,
0.0018283668,
0.0684686303,
0.0801726878,
-0.0116103189,
0.0141694155,
-0.0095902197,
0.0804955587,
0.0067938054,
-0.0282250531,
0.027540341,
0.0413661413,
0.0001790312,
-0.0259392932,
-0.0389644094,
0.0005115044,
-0.0065711513,
0.0373620838,
-0.0280089416,
-0.035704881,
0.0293902922,
0.0088681728,
-0.025181571,
0.0721377954,
0.0121899657,
0.0016924553,
-0.0386067517,
0.018600503,
-0.0404001698,
-0.0827760771,
-0.0105363252,
0.0648220927,
-0.0417130589,
0.0180341266,
-0.0613896213,
0.049446322,
-0.0208404791,
-0.0420427807,
0.0118013332,
0.026490083,
0.0174866058,
0.0500194654,
-0.054708764,
0.0290554855,
-0.0294867828,
0.0452035181,
-0.0327816941,
0.0060113617,
-0.0310185812,
0.0152607989,
-0.0526782684,
0.0225972869,
-0.0961006731,
-0.0200015306,
-0.0086138183,
0.0303053595,
-0.0043464238,
0.0362152457,
-0.0343667343,
0.0569975637,
-0.0448020063,
-0.0074807224,
-0.002556524,
-0.0285879429,
-0.0105078807,
0.0206209514,
-0.0035494908,
-0.0025647355,
0.0127181141,
0.0346855298,
0.0423325524,
0.0131349145,
-0.0519844927,
0.0815141201,
0.0096812565,
-0.0163235124,
-0.0592449568,
-0.0348672941,
-0.0002721538,
-0.0203037448,
0.024486471,
-0.0837389305,
0.0162226614,
-0.009466053,
-0.0549313426,
-0.0324633457,
0.0318087265,
-0.0065025981,
-0.0026908135,
0.0336083435,
-0.0506705381,
0.0223122071,
0.017112799,
-0.0094674416,
0.0477834828,
0.077562429,
0.0506430492,
0.0589556433,
0.0036736638,
0.0312752426,
-0.0138733033,
0.0095449127,
-0.0092112077,
0.0407012105,
-0.0205124766,
-0.0096863499,
0.0022965965,
0.061978288,
0.0253415648,
0.0263287462,
-0.04099641,
0.0118737388,
0.0485237651,
0.0154963108,
0.0061754556,
-0.023095021,
0.1101710573,
0.0138238566,
-0.0472301021,
-0.033674933,
-0.0898337811,
0.0166280735,
-0.0142351976,
0.0021517077,
-0.0096239848,
0.0353114419,
-0.0191170685,
-0.0196394455,
0.0071252217,
-0.0075273444,
0.0496027209,
-0.0079810061,
0.0435383581,
0.0062961215,
-0.0242964625,
0.0402991995,
0.0241100919,
-0.021034671,
0.033363983,
0.0476051494,
-0.0047525456,
0.04623634,
0.0066984459,
0.0474681892,
-0.0655065402,
-0.0174226351,
0.0444613993,
0.060002815,
0.0316844881,
-0.0071518109,
0.004787304,
-0.052960854,
-0.0604232252,
-0.0026967023,
0.0007614115,
0.0186687261,
0.0646112934,
0.0422469489,
0.0676511228,
-0.0579913296,
-0.0202640574,
0.0373353064,
0.0075582047,
-0.0232997704,
-0.0320781358,
0.006416915,
-0.0293606929,
0.0274604913,
0.0085404823,
0.0037945861,
0.0428485982,
-0.0181788858,
-0.0084930491,
0.0689852163,
-0.0517605245,
-0.0429441221,
0.018127799,
-0.0278233886,
-0.0133161284,
-0.0273179114,
-0.0234832168,
-0.0540265776,
0.0014459561,
-0.0263954662,
0.0693008527,
0.0144365588,
-0.0060079019,
0.0563936457,
-0.0147762466,
-0.0271809362,
0.0554875247,
-0.0036886802,
0.0096759479,
-0.0013318004,
0.0513219908,
0.0360044204,
0.0024893342,
0.0043146508,
-0.0363832191,
0.0153687149,
-0.0188654121,
-0.0088458657,
0.0144177917,
-0.0504808985,
-0.0047606337,
-0.1088619828,
-0.0093054324,
-0.0065968083,
0.0210127681,
0.0282681864,
-0.0377652384,
-0.0109451124,
-0.0264213365,
-0.0206329115,
0.0220883526,
0.0207114033,
-0.005149289,
0.0103386221,
0.0014463791,
-0.0126221031,
0.003368204,
0.018844258,
-0.0090631181,
0.0188754704,
0.0541110262,
-0.0207415596,
-0.0813802034,
0.0163126923,
-0.0553966165,
0.0371118188,
-0.0011799561,
-0.0389457867,
0.0304808151,
-0.0426343009,
-0.0048589734,
0.008260631,
-0.0101503385,
-0.0242569931,
0.0365065224,
-0.0474068522,
-0.0661722496,
-0.0031995464,
-0.0360260755,
0.0024799099,
-0.0527147464,
0.0008996224,
-0.0211410858,
0.0347008966,
-0.0192837361,
-0.0105816619,
-0.0408311263,
-0.0064480081,
-0.0362958647,
-0.0543490164,
-0.0343760177,
0.0324240252,
-0.0020322308,
0.0411014743,
-0.0657210127,
-0.0230213609,
0.02391815,
-0.0205946881,
-0.0053568296,
0.0032437504,
0.0178529564,
-0.0031375571,
0.0653633177,
0.0356652513,
0.0332791805,
0.0034251898,
-0.0205224101,
0.0095392903,
-0.0116910124,
-0.0392827541,
0.0173523743,
0.0121205319,
-0.0953988954,
0.0128693916,
0.015484632,
-0.0203537326,
-0.0454366691,
0.011228296,
0.005892735,
-0.005344091,
-0.0222379938,
-0.0479991399,
0.0078876,
0.0007079494,
0.0245219097,
0.0605280623,
-0.0259884801,
-0.0087835174,
-0.0318923779,
-0.0050337063,
0.0727050677,
0.0913886726,
-0.013542193,
0.0096225925,
-0.0579574965,
0.0406499878,
0.0014967936,
-0.0067928019,
-0.0368677229,
0.035096921,
0.0018226799,
0.0025319834,
-0.0293785259,
0.0167808514,
0.0559241548,
-0.0670128092,
-0.0674102381,
0.0912151858,
0.0555290245,
0.0027138388,
0.0014688433,
0.0081129549,
0.0287276693,
0.0323183239,
0.0097577022,
-0.0694918633,
0.0052565988,
0.0058873082,
-0.0170554873,
0.0397227257,
-0.0332156122,
0.0133094126,
-0.1233270988,
0.0463031419,
0.0220899805,
-0.0995880365,
-0.0447710827,
-0.0340836011,
-0.0066354503,
0.0375847332,
-0.0495738052,
-0.001894361,
-0.006397394,
0.0205619708,
0.0393407419,
-0.0076359613,
-0.0344197825,
-0.0478273034,
-0.0528248362,
0.0545127839,
0.0118325995,
0.0467312112,
0.0204003137,
-0.0662103668,
-0.0074555553,
0.0510570668,
0.0344062224,
-0.0205427222,
0.0143138766,
-0.0054276674,
-0.0119795902,
0.0382529609,
0.0360060409,
-0.0494801477,
-0.029737344,
-0.0022159428,
0.0362344757,
-0.0222790074,
0.058084134,
-0.0122596165,
0.021596238,
0.0382549427,
0.0151954228,
0.0052244635,
0.0151162818,
-0.0218820497,
-0.0471705422,
-0.0103939269,
-0.070481956,
0.0038668313,
0.0577935241,
-0.046646446,
-0.0495943092,
-0.0882915184,
-0.0461339355,
0.069338426,
0.0776104853,
0.0163029581,
-0.0383388884,
0.0071901358,
-0.0489618555,
-0.0574071482,
0.0651589707,
-0.0583639033,
0.0110455435,
-0.0095259696,
0.0079508433,
-0.0195392799,
-0.0409973338,
-0.005537943,
0.014423742,
-0.0346773751,
-0.0781382918,
0.024789609,
0.0479952879,
0.0174946766,
0.0528195016,
-0.0394311957,
0.0164341945,
0.0234849639,
0.0541840121,
-0.0389297195,
0.0592035018,
-0.0082081622,
0.0307785273,
0.0326078981,
-0.0019618361,
-0.0534618832,
0.0083445003,
0.0165967233,
0.0193866231,
-0.0361230411,
0.0132728126,
0.003659683,
0.0163913835,
0.0631614327,
-0.0351500772,
0.0418001004,
-0.0180283971,
-0.0119052501,
-0.0460317209,
-0.0002258035,
-0.039878279,
0.0247220956,
0.0138940467,
0.0489492714,
0.0402056463,
0.0137438551,
0.0074505028,
0.0314392783,
-0.0233967938,
-0.055537995,
-0.0012137375,
-0.0144849885,
0.0283320099,
0.0329889506,
-0.0296867695,
0.0233598445,
-0.0317861326,
0.0309560951,
-0.0220160801,
0.0014967325,
0.0639757365,
-0.0144735239,
-0.060341049,
0.0081780273,
-0.0294533782,
-0.0436158478,
-0.0302041136,
0.0504165404,
0.0645595938,
0.0023459694,
0.0463670194,
-0.0400003195,
-0.0046243337,
0.0249766298,
0.0044770152,
0.015740091,
-0.0750142261,
0.0386005826,
0.0105733108,
-0.0150775611,
0.0051566316,
0.0364015922,
-0.0076260739,
0.0785369277,
0.0097180959,
-0.0194376595,
-0.0372890681,
0.0028838152,
0.0072475295,
0.0066434429,
-0.0073256642,
0.0190016981,
-0.0139043164,
-0.0536733717,
-0.0082732132,
0.0586362332,
-0.0482284278,
0.0067728697,
0.0621818341,
-0.0310195033,
-0.007371359,
-0.0426841974,
-0.0288298167,
-0.0099383788,
-0.0083372286,
-0.0204808544,
-0.0016464351,
-6.006016469e-33,
-0.0465307683,
-0.065292865,
0.0715017393,
-0.024469262,
-0.0722783804,
0.0032356333,
-0.043819692,
0.0246713962,
0.0080683343,
0.0056255576,
0.0078292964,
-0.0052562589,
-0.0061159902,
0.0509009808,
-0.0063147792,
0.0148621472,
0.0150648281,
0.0315567106,
0.0001610318,
0.013721874,
0.0804493651,
0.0018572132,
0.0380041562,
-0.0857177824,
0.007078846,
-0.0042924131,
-0.0251067523,
0.0368930399,
-0.0028956612,
0.0357192867,
-0.0282296147,
0.0175762456,
-0.0007616306,
-0.0057259472,
-0.0317835733,
-0.0132838748,
-0.0639938489,
-0.0227862149,
-0.0068611377,
0.0217351411,
-0.0492766351,
-0.0330980495,
0.0469972566,
-0.0183878373,
0.0437969081,
0.0306974221,
0.0235977285,
-0.0194551088,
-0.0488848947,
0.0233279355,
-0.0606762469,
0.0149777476,
0.0169246532,
-0.0222642794,
0.0027702646,
0.0462957248,
0.0170377959,
-0.0359697007,
-0.0285264943,
0.0222088974,
0.024269145,
0.0162964854,
0.0450236686,
0.053298384,
0.0441685952,
0.0624264702,
-0.0123424493,
-0.0236894656,
-0.0991353691,
0.0220493786,
0.0369052775,
0.0346119069,
-0.0271282047,
0.0715512559,
-0.0059153358,
-0.0001851254,
-0.0283489563,
0.0329019055,
-0.0732489526,
0.0311175846,
-0.0214978997,
0.0123095848,
-0.0259069186,
-0.0267829448,
-0.0223812908,
-0.0019541339,
0.0158315469,
-0.05411084,
0.0394456089,
0.0260181949,
-0.0358546786,
0.0356191061,
0.0005672118,
-0.0046778899,
-0.0289049428,
0.0101018492,
-0.0071299672,
0.017919315,
-0.009801385,
0.0006090983,
-0.0504446141,
-0.0446770303,
0.060171783,
-0.003931121,
-0.0000167367,
0.0227895137,
-0.000516371,
0.0384929664,
-0.020888662,
0.0192529,
-0.0479079373,
-0.0151648838,
0.0066659302,
-0.0451522395,
0.068591401,
-0.0193574838,
-0.0272225235,
0.039839413,
0.0155857792,
-0.0038698877,
0.0164315496,
-0.0198097825,
0.0003097718,
0.0513490252,
-0.0167252142,
0.0173541028,
-0.0301165842,
0.001906622,
0.0140669933,
-0.0688852966,
-0.0124473842,
0.035828948,
2.894e-7,
0.0198460333,
0.0315947756,
0.0467309915,
-0.020888146,
-0.0064691864,
0.0160062835,
0.0326362066,
0.0270609949,
-0.0299004186,
-0.0300869681,
-0.0035173229,
0.0637352318,
-0.0111728339,
0.0169931408,
-0.0890467241,
0.0472012497,
-0.0145177292,
-0.0361670144,
-0.0706147775,
-0.0187669173,
0.0287239179,
0.0120430961,
0.0090699689,
0.0139720915,
0.035203021,
-0.0072102994,
0.0212754086,
-0.0258503221,
-0.0136314733,
-0.0064544221,
0.0330883898,
0.0474256836,
-0.0311657526,
-0.0178255159,
-0.0145704579,
-0.02440493,
0.0064579761,
0.030203972,
-0.0353959426,
0.0371742062,
0.007588353,
-0.0504967086,
-0.0106300665,
-0.071092777,
0.0446403176,
-0.0815780014,
0.0156252477,
0.0199755803,
-0.0339281261,
0.021727331,
-0.0463833995,
-0.0146357417,
-0.003097865,
-0.060549818,
0.0208649039,
0.0105357179,
-0.0127030285,
-0.0742643327,
-0.0176593866,
0.0533661991,
-0.0200195219,
-0.001747547,
-0.0254215375,
0.0242816657,
0.0043127751,
-0.0061765215,
-0.0391456224,
2.247614075e-34,
-0.030871518,
0.0190937463,
-0.0128266653,
-0.0284413304,
0.0273193326,
-0.0044906759,
-0.0206542239,
0.0107305953,
0.0108098518,
-0.0383003615,
-0.0181849226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19966v1 | Simulating Financial Market via Large Language Model based Agents | 2024-06-28T14:54:12 | 2024-06-28T14:54:12 | Shen Gao, Yuntao Wen, Minghang Zhu, Jianing Wei, Yuhan Cheng, Qunzi Zhang, Shuo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most economic theories typically assume that financial market participants
are fully rational individuals and use mathematical models to simulate human
behavior in financial markets. However, human behavior is often not entirely
rational and is challenging to predict accurately with mathematical models. In
this paper, we propose \textbf{A}gent-based \textbf{S}imulated
\textbf{F}inancial \textbf{M}arket (ASFM), which first constructs a simulated
stock market with a real order matching system. Then, we propose a large
language model based agent as the stock trader, which contains the profile,
observation, and tool-learning based action module. The trading agent can
comprehensively understand current market dynamics and financial policy
information, and make decisions that align with their trading strategy. In the
experiments, we first verify that the reactions of our ASFM are consistent with
the real stock market in two controllable scenarios. In addition, we also
conduct experiments in two popular economics research directions, and we find
that conclusions drawn in our \model align with the preliminary findings in
economics research. Based on these observations, we believe our proposed ASFM
provides a new paradigm for economic research. | [
-0.0005678755,
0.0285800863,
-0.055488959,
-0.039783936,
0.0057397247,
-0.0172627978,
0.0091594253,
0.0475562289,
0.0602203049,
0.0263617076,
0.0096830288,
-0.0305129122,
-0.0410826541,
0.0590122119,
0.0364197604,
-0.0268098414,
0.0106911687,
-0.0417684503,
0.0258940123,
-0.0712083206,
0.0153613351,
-0.0438776501,
0.034663938,
0.0077838418,
0.0314542279,
-0.0045179757,
-0.0517720357,
-0.0369656496,
0.0118871648,
0.0108900294,
-0.0111650759,
-0.0078490041,
0.0269040428,
0.0713718459,
0.0000020668,
-0.0186819509,
0.0184488036,
-0.0053091682,
-0.0511289835,
-0.0377055258,
0.022974534,
0.0085364031,
0.0245415512,
0.0129056806,
-0.0607148372,
0.0478352569,
0.0718225837,
0.033092197,
0.0519454591,
0.0698467493,
0.008562875,
-0.0345705748,
0.0125342626,
-0.0341564193,
-0.0216471422,
-0.0809737518,
0.0466667935,
0.0245445054,
0.03630675,
0.0142826401,
-0.0196773447,
0.0129424343,
-0.0055547738,
0.0067410357,
-0.0039232103,
0.0143415602,
-0.018512398,
-0.0025875841,
-0.0249343757,
0.0543129854,
0.0181851257,
-0.0021624046,
0.0264274385,
-0.0108208694,
-0.0143225025,
0.0558376946,
-0.0183631256,
0.0558615439,
-0.00895188,
0.0332203209,
0.0598099194,
0.0063650408,
0.0275380202,
0.0055256146,
-0.0330615602,
0.0616867244,
-0.0218495373,
-0.0218420587,
-0.0107955057,
-0.0036123386,
-0.0238246918,
-0.040316578,
-0.0249438398,
0.0031128053,
-0.0609366558,
-0.0101597635,
-0.0125742927,
-0.0034666462,
-0.0229533557,
-0.0994296521,
-0.0112220664,
0.0436278135,
0.0670226738,
0.0146500543,
-0.0317202918,
0.0734846219,
-0.0014055829,
-0.0123640103,
-0.0092766425,
0.0340057425,
-0.0713568777,
0.0056109638,
-0.0651536211,
0.0475092754,
-0.0323843881,
-0.0220382698,
-0.08331763,
0.0146182096,
-0.0558072105,
0.0491099432,
-0.0351062566,
-0.0461566262,
-0.0196571536,
0.0125761367,
-0.0847686976,
-0.0462299846,
-0.0405029468,
0.0174678415,
-0.0085661709,
-0.0121791251,
0.0251435824,
0.007832624,
-0.0547728129,
0.0128692705,
-0.002917469,
0.104702659,
0.0295375716,
0.0034008736,
-0.0187457278,
-0.0429796241,
0.0618160851,
-0.0270493403,
-0.0312367361,
-0.026907973,
0.0232225675,
-0.0523043126,
-0.0063188341,
-0.0101053352,
-0.0044679539,
-0.023373628,
-0.0295312498,
0.08335042,
0.0345827565,
-0.0230344608,
-0.0387319438,
-0.0465591438,
0.0245392472,
0.0570921786,
-0.0083912434,
0.0041931113,
0.0482784919,
0.008077791,
0.0538500883,
0.0483500734,
-0.0129359476,
-0.017077582,
0.0102249281,
0.0016217151,
0.0208410267,
0.0024286571,
0.055662889,
-0.0096568391,
-0.0351734571,
-0.0384017453,
0.0781913325,
0.0481004268,
0.0413535647,
0.0692102909,
0.0127407303,
0.0557938069,
0.0169305988,
0.0165366381,
0.0096597727,
0.0199918095,
-0.0328497849,
0.0171522796,
-0.0529619567,
0.0025129002,
-0.0789491609,
0.0000975226,
0.0440758131,
-0.0349237025,
0.0028085678,
0.004926837,
-0.0032503244,
-0.0762161091,
-0.0406399146,
0.0085704094,
0.0248476602,
0.0223679319,
-0.0299656112,
-0.0516315326,
0.0113115432,
0.0795506686,
0.0214193594,
-0.0025723858,
0.0525430962,
-0.0167740025,
-0.0591257662,
0.0676348209,
0.0371947549,
-0.0053266524,
-0.0934244618,
-0.0416302532,
-0.0371543914,
0.069184579,
-0.0136224246,
0.0553345159,
-0.0267548282,
-0.0101738628,
-0.0461599156,
0.0348400213,
0.0047190841,
-0.0073849731,
-0.0484298989,
-0.0455557145,
-0.0284634028,
-0.0342067517,
0.0548678525,
0.0018320086,
-0.001605315,
-0.0239385217,
-0.0244572386,
0.0391146056,
-0.0782557875,
0.0578528345,
-0.0529579036,
0.0491580442,
-0.0039334581,
-0.0005228248,
0.022486683,
0.0042246501,
0.0031020902,
-0.0162946396,
0.0100264344,
-0.0106147118,
0.0267878734,
-0.0347831734,
-0.0201648902,
-0.0005292524,
0.0442431793,
0.009689495,
0.0550443605,
0.0320281088,
-0.0210725088,
-0.0148550952,
0.0071405238,
-0.0218822435,
-0.0772840977,
0.0341004282,
0.0341402479,
0.0159817487,
0.07278689,
0.0427414961,
-0.0093906568,
0.0518691838,
-0.0128896888,
-0.0295414012,
-0.0170172807,
0.0371920653,
0.0081116846,
0.0216992125,
0.0010750322,
0.0019514596,
-0.0022557424,
-0.0496400632,
0.0572857447,
0.0318048224,
0.0082280897,
0.0374695361,
-0.0375689492,
-0.0443789884,
-0.0173407402,
-0.0032386943,
-0.0188690685,
0.006695678,
0.0405460037,
0.0205875151,
-0.0329332165,
-0.0032250807,
-0.0264680535,
0.0546477102,
-0.0274566878,
-0.0127236014,
0.0112551115,
-0.0238156356,
-0.0158075616,
0.0490478426,
0.0108604515,
0.0307424366,
-0.0182077345,
0.0518446453,
-0.0480047911,
0.0331828706,
-0.0181601383,
0.0148516819,
-0.0588324368,
-0.0020933428,
-0.0217267852,
0.0692325756,
-0.0302424654,
-0.0095068393,
-0.0620774627,
0.0557548031,
0.0228810702,
-0.0196772683,
-0.0625079647,
0.0076437299,
-0.0265480839,
0.0257038064,
-0.0288575459,
-0.0042205215,
0.0350750722,
0.031713184,
-0.0214781221,
-0.008280497,
0.0147814536,
-0.0212010294,
0.0206282623,
0.0073307003,
-0.0020294038,
-0.0250921119,
0.0041689333,
-0.027870452,
-0.0511278659,
0.0247442406,
-0.0075003067,
0.0096143512,
-0.0540432706,
0.0290508252,
0.0211818293,
-0.0212771725,
-0.0103878854,
-0.0641742498,
-0.037947163,
0.0273060426,
0.0395825692,
-0.0731021091,
-0.0466440208,
0.0440485664,
0.0533872321,
0.0046791038,
0.0083872266,
-0.018234754,
0.0201544017,
-0.0003875502,
0.0406730771,
0.0174104869,
0.01405547,
-0.0366078839,
0.108305566,
0.0106970202,
0.0231038146,
-0.0081618968,
-0.0067663183,
0.0032620605,
-0.0192058552,
-0.0247217007,
0.0078422558,
0.0451912247,
-0.0386020988,
-0.0235893298,
0.0167613924,
0.0826945454,
-0.0106411157,
0.0477192551,
0.0155660594,
0.0253360663,
0.0082084937,
-0.0393243954,
0.0655485094,
-0.096653156,
0.021163702,
-0.0119581716,
0.0086760148,
-0.0015271183,
-0.0436191782,
0.021352645,
-0.1234056726,
0.0532443821,
0.0117269391,
-0.0172560047,
-0.0140323015,
-0.0302430689,
-0.0044549387,
-0.0529937297,
0.0089896433,
0.0285458509,
0.023207454,
0.0176205952,
0.0048299669,
-0.0079413541,
0.019545367,
-0.0169934984,
-0.0234524105,
0.025874095,
0.0070894165,
0.0398708396,
-0.0272611193,
0.0065434515,
-0.1055499986,
0.0257491507,
-0.0150707923,
0.0166341979,
0.0096741086,
0.0323936902,
-0.0421778411,
-0.015533261,
0.0181218311,
0.0255901627,
0.0469189398,
0.0318785347,
-0.0194578245,
-0.0086559402,
-0.0846807957,
0.0145408865,
-0.006301655,
-0.0111885369,
0.0355778113,
-0.0226380154,
-0.0361411721,
-0.0410735607,
-0.0484605581,
-0.0133776525,
-0.0730109289,
-0.0882575586,
-0.0013049082,
0.0173939168,
0.0318036452,
-0.0411883444,
-0.0497272015,
-0.0490220077,
0.0305670146,
0.0255437065,
0.0201389845,
0.0827135369,
-0.0036751467,
0.0245912112,
-0.0208918191,
-0.0527444854,
0.0272356011,
-0.0041288268,
0.0062412913,
0.012466385,
-0.0959006101,
-0.0368107259,
0.009977188,
0.0035897356,
-0.0379227139,
0.0418609045,
0.0161957983,
0.0249377452,
-0.0141082704,
-0.017785402,
0.0650976449,
0.0154401017,
0.0120382048,
0.0017327348,
0.0001785163,
0.034581475,
0.0045427373,
-0.0124456491,
0.0449819192,
-0.0075185681,
0.0175900254,
-0.040300753,
0.0161933806,
-0.0757747069,
0.0141306333,
0.0036906872,
0.0335614681,
-0.0471298285,
0.0293885227,
-0.0195119176,
0.0090434197,
-0.0242915936,
-0.0072580334,
0.0043027522,
0.0062887529,
-0.0691370815,
0.0335259847,
0.0201364327,
0.0223242324,
0.0040186434,
0.0274767391,
-0.0613406822,
0.0510579981,
0.0208057705,
-0.0292800013,
0.0420996435,
0.0095006097,
-0.0098588401,
0.0264291745,
0.0168592371,
0.055022385,
0.0392840952,
-0.0031971254,
0.0333510488,
-0.0006226897,
-0.0217905119,
-0.0126233613,
-0.0555510595,
-0.019932745,
-0.0538915284,
0.0288577508,
0.0837882832,
0.0055135945,
-0.0312317703,
0.0024016488,
-0.095656544,
0.0266500209,
0.0039329752,
-0.0160280056,
-0.0173855033,
-0.0165103991,
-0.010469419,
0.0176857915,
-0.0528717265,
-0.0457746275,
0.0747365057,
0.0206308365,
0.0478753634,
-0.0584405549,
-0.0084718606,
-0.0386428274,
-0.021390425,
0.0152170714,
-0.0278541204,
0.0060755233,
0.018819483,
-0.0591062196,
-0.0126704536,
-0.0002488991,
0.0473228917,
-0.0035712223,
-0.0050158412,
0.0127425194,
0.0053118728,
-0.0311960205,
0.0565076098,
-0.0073529938,
-0.0102647291,
-0.0269892998,
0.0203719232,
-0.0829486698,
-5.610640781e-33,
-0.0220557787,
-0.0290908366,
0.0510484353,
-0.0014308944,
-0.0138790812,
-0.0188773386,
-0.0413686521,
-0.0137778549,
0.0091615068,
0.0052236249,
0.0225558653,
0.0227996632,
0.0219998211,
-0.0063293488,
0.0269483887,
0.0265367869,
0.0334499776,
-0.0488432348,
0.0044149528,
-0.0479423106,
-0.0018569481,
-0.0141427703,
0.0075965272,
0.0193654094,
-0.0028449104,
-0.0456403121,
-0.0518132225,
-0.0315187089,
-0.013846756,
0.057114318,
-0.0052219168,
0.0272773355,
-0.0084694158,
-0.0523787476,
0.0164668281,
0.0034094267,
-0.0150710931,
-0.0290653966,
-0.0073555824,
0.0250790529,
0.0360651277,
0.0010995911,
0.0397424363,
-0.021546334,
-0.0414077975,
0.0326062776,
0.0353892036,
-0.0079412088,
0.0232586693,
0.0367734991,
-0.09050446,
0.0013314881,
0.0302691013,
0.0539793149,
0.0214147959,
0.0552320406,
-0.004015638,
-0.056470219,
-0.0030820165,
0.0657128543,
0.0163136832,
-0.0086593665,
-0.0598649681,
0.0595125444,
0.0572186597,
0.0344565548,
0.0154135311,
0.0314705111,
-0.0223641433,
0.0119294506,
-0.000415138,
0.0212996155,
0.0188941862,
0.0712141469,
-0.0445821695,
-0.0297479071,
-0.0067073093,
0.0221296009,
0.0581174456,
0.0236454364,
0.0279828385,
0.0391459689,
-0.0374764539,
-0.0415335447,
-0.0052504912,
-0.0054907552,
0.014086959,
-0.0148711633,
-0.0046443995,
0.0030286948,
0.0017582701,
-0.0238662381,
0.0073910919,
-0.0322426558,
-0.0726424307,
-0.0563231409,
0.0294227097,
-0.0039543905,
0.0141670508,
-0.0280753653,
-0.044793427,
-0.0657050088,
-0.0264667794,
-0.0228890348,
-0.0039858255,
0.0182038005,
-0.0502840765,
0.015792232,
-0.0162643064,
0.0105556166,
-0.0257644635,
0.0018331694,
0.0631431788,
-0.0126574077,
0.0122826025,
-0.0041890657,
0.0070749177,
-0.0371311158,
-0.026179716,
-0.0293152891,
-0.0039136084,
-0.015136566,
-0.0057825316,
0.0297594797,
0.024146758,
0.0721381754,
-0.0540571995,
0.095632866,
-0.0153909232,
-0.0594137944,
-0.0253454633,
0.0264627803,
2.83e-7,
-0.0114245834,
0.0597451851,
0.0077077574,
0.0505412333,
0.0501932912,
0.0626888201,
-0.0487384498,
0.0087676104,
0.0197155792,
0.0027657114,
0.0712889209,
0.0539851263,
0.0392730907,
-0.018412808,
-0.0728610754,
-0.0351449698,
-0.0104008932,
0.011891447,
-0.0226982161,
-0.0057793828,
-0.0306203049,
0.0248613935,
0.0083607743,
0.0155003862,
0.0279840399,
-0.0757029876,
0.0305889733,
-0.0138509385,
-0.0222540665,
-0.0099532073,
-0.0559035018,
0.0151096797,
-0.0205553938,
0.0426444151,
0.0236197505,
0.0245356858,
-0.012488449,
0.0064888364,
-0.0059233801,
0.0269170795,
0.0091720419,
-0.0117106512,
-0.0064631556,
-0.027511213,
0.015220697,
-0.0787570253,
-0.0381867029,
-0.0207652766,
-0.0514504686,
0.0090879472,
0.0026933283,
0.013050436,
-0.0338335671,
0.0047713812,
0.0004703104,
-0.0139552392,
0.0706568658,
0.008290234,
-0.0171673968,
0.0017388621,
-0.0667280853,
-0.0394836403,
-0.0235345066,
0.0206993874,
0.0027649673,
-0.0137332128,
0.0145325866,
2.198612951e-34,
0.0702747852,
0.0311268512,
-0.0249986611,
0.0183536485,
0.0263852067,
0.0324223936,
-0.0077502136,
0.0397530347,
0.0756489635,
-0.0406637974,
-0.0464908369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19954v1 | BESTOW: Efficient and Streamable Speech Language Model with the Best of Two Worlds in GPT and T5 | 2024-06-28T14:40:03 | 2024-06-28T14:40:03 | Zhehuai Chen, He Huang, Oleksii Hrinchuk, Krishna C. Puvvada, Nithin Rao Koluguri, Piotr Żelasko, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T10, I.2.7 | Incorporating speech understanding capabilities into pretrained
large-language models has become a vital research direction (SpeechLLM). The
previous architectures can be categorized as: i) GPT-style, prepend speech
prompts to the text prompts as a sequence of LLM inputs like a decoder-only
model; ii) T5-style, introduce speech cross-attention to each layer of the
pretrained LLMs. We propose BESTOW architecture to bring the BESt features from
TwO Worlds into a single model that is highly efficient and has strong
multitask capabilities. Moreover, there is no clear streaming solution for
either style, especially considering the solution should generalize to speech
multitask. We reformulate streamable SpeechLLM as a read-write policy problem
and unifies the offline and streaming research with BESTOW architecture. Hence
we demonstrate the first open-source SpeechLLM solution that enables Streaming
and Multitask at scale (beyond ASR) at the same time. This streamable solution
achieves very strong performance on a wide range of speech tasks (ASR, AST,
SQA, unseen DynamicSuperb). It is end-to-end optimizable, with lower
training/inference cost, and demonstrates LLM knowledge transferability to
speech. | [
-0.013291453,
0.0639613643,
0.0107639562,
0.0581521355,
0.0099337325,
-0.0083385268,
0.0260046795,
-0.0380888246,
0.004948725,
-0.0225791633,
-0.0780145079,
-0.0611374341,
-0.0154221086,
0.0882192925,
0.0189123042,
-0.0333704539,
0.0474675782,
-0.0608568117,
-0.0095308637,
0.0039112396,
0.036694102,
0.0224523023,
-0.0152618382,
0.0203894153,
0.0252518337,
-0.0159188062,
-0.05156352,
0.0091198422,
-0.0021223279,
0.0013315034,
-0.0123097701,
0.0066386745,
0.0783257037,
0.0377724804,
0.0000019619,
-0.0209303834,
-0.0257152263,
0.0127075016,
-0.0544352792,
0.0006701117,
0.0118439561,
0.001414999,
-0.0217733011,
0.0330495648,
0.0083024204,
-0.0180017073,
0.0419637561,
0.0352908969,
0.0713703036,
0.0675947517,
0.0001400486,
-0.026426563,
0.0368861221,
-0.0295134373,
-0.015341308,
-0.0637102202,
-0.0004603971,
-0.0742765665,
-0.0086322464,
-0.0223855842,
-0.0322707146,
0.0415119193,
0.0231684819,
-0.0034910406,
-0.0232602246,
-0.0030700383,
-0.0090283174,
-0.043185059,
-0.0549264029,
0.0593416728,
-0.023413606,
0.009392133,
0.0501132384,
-0.013323064,
-0.0269874223,
-0.0543418899,
-0.0365467966,
0.026160419,
0.0091845235,
0.0279152375,
0.0069831479,
0.000780926,
0.0280007664,
0.0136532532,
-0.040076796,
0.0738016292,
-0.0106416298,
0.0001380235,
-0.0102457888,
0.003857624,
0.0179697406,
-0.0546335466,
0.050612051,
0.0427004471,
-0.0813738853,
0.0078670904,
-0.0571466796,
0.0092534013,
-0.0425497703,
-0.013275465,
0.0866666734,
0.050990846,
-0.0301080197,
0.0370273553,
-0.0154402154,
0.0263465531,
-0.0238074288,
-0.0034728087,
-0.0292954873,
-0.0132643841,
-0.0223529208,
0.0034659903,
-0.0293730628,
0.0407826938,
-0.071425505,
-0.0527541898,
-0.0091330502,
0.0409884639,
-0.0144741302,
-0.0270662978,
0.0429890826,
-0.0076444861,
-0.0471487939,
-0.014164038,
0.0118517047,
0.0527167283,
-0.0044545196,
0.0404911302,
0.0187977217,
-0.0797709897,
-0.021215355,
0.0297909342,
0.0218518078,
-0.0019963766,
-0.0020231635,
0.0400068313,
-0.0171656478,
-0.0276127402,
-0.0534263365,
-0.0157187507,
0.0228133481,
-0.0675510988,
0.0063581946,
-0.0117493812,
0.0630363747,
-0.0326361842,
0.0116452444,
0.0093472404,
-0.0058714082,
-0.009560246,
0.0163338222,
0.068160139,
-0.0061929491,
0.0155806337,
-0.007340976,
-0.0009369137,
-0.0168129336,
0.079112038,
0.012555006,
-0.0012982212,
-0.0013959087,
-0.0269346219,
-0.0266629457,
0.0578056723,
0.0178446509,
-0.0042678355,
0.0057439045,
0.0237746034,
-0.0058073238,
0.010091044,
0.0916854218,
0.000112596,
-0.027036814,
0.010648584,
0.0620608144,
0.0455197804,
0.0533507541,
0.0126846116,
0.026535375,
0.0562676117,
-0.0298247263,
-0.0039364039,
-0.0479177013,
0.0360890441,
0.0173331387,
0.0022432439,
0.0275940169,
0.062299531,
-0.0366465226,
-0.0197713338,
0.0108238691,
-0.0288787,
-0.0087122014,
0.0578169562,
0.0446395688,
-0.009258328,
-0.0321876854,
0.0777685568,
-0.0242856406,
-0.0565218665,
-0.0025774366,
-0.0511612445,
0.0246924907,
0.0632280633,
-0.0077378494,
-0.0356098153,
-0.0611210316,
-0.0338841528,
0.0388580747,
0.0390021726,
0.0115607148,
0.0161377508,
0.0914239436,
-0.0538230315,
-0.0231156442,
0.0210921075,
0.0130366171,
0.0759072676,
-0.0214516837,
0.0155733367,
-0.0117472038,
0.0272694267,
0.0141721014,
-0.0072144931,
-0.0053026373,
-0.0128674973,
0.0194062293,
-0.0283540394,
0.0762616619,
0.004346095,
-0.021179745,
-0.0052519781,
0.0350668281,
-0.0345682986,
-0.0012514739,
0.0412550494,
-0.091416724,
-0.0086045377,
0.0318728797,
-0.0089298477,
0.0047541489,
0.0616965517,
-0.0326876082,
-0.0907123387,
0.0116142966,
0.0030836505,
0.0565144233,
-0.0657665953,
0.0128287505,
0.024292849,
0.0080171274,
0.0362075195,
-0.0012080298,
0.0149308769,
-0.0018227637,
0.0101960236,
0.0157059394,
-0.0033061095,
-0.0683386549,
-0.0341377743,
0.0297517944,
-0.0209481325,
0.0205640811,
-0.0329268016,
0.0152355684,
-0.02348697,
-0.0081377579,
-0.0508390777,
0.0453263037,
-0.0460689776,
0.0474529378,
0.0108121699,
0.0394883379,
-0.0119090239,
-0.0205243025,
-0.038915623,
-0.0130081875,
0.017072618,
0.0077060317,
-0.0190270208,
0.0188247822,
-0.0016726318,
0.0010385661,
0.0070478814,
0.0450566486,
-0.0282072164,
-0.0241105463,
-0.0147686237,
-0.0690821782,
0.0133060943,
0.0187294129,
0.0346406326,
-0.026822079,
0.0008946723,
-0.0097215772,
-0.013671875,
0.000126607,
0.0395650528,
-0.0057614841,
0.006520228,
0.0132338041,
-0.0254503042,
-0.0274953526,
0.051413212,
0.0201918222,
-0.0084027285,
-0.024824677,
0.0591707937,
-0.0062791985,
0.0547887646,
-0.0217225645,
-0.0058335755,
-0.0486079901,
-0.0329910554,
0.0098499861,
-0.0432423055,
-0.0372777842,
-0.0363475159,
-0.0674363673,
-0.0084045399,
-0.0012458771,
-0.0253864937,
0.0386974923,
-0.061012432,
-0.0580968931,
-0.0280961804,
-0.0540303923,
-0.053230267,
0.0447042137,
-0.0224490706,
-0.0068397634,
-0.0248182863,
-0.0695292354,
-0.0161930528,
0.0340850092,
-0.0023409741,
-0.037850067,
0.0320338123,
-0.0383963995,
0.0019513604,
-0.0511153564,
-0.0442077853,
-0.0227641966,
-0.0022452408,
-0.0570327714,
-0.0019237212,
-0.0056710807,
-0.0250887387,
-0.0152712492,
0.0251775533,
0.0193690546,
0.0503350124,
-0.0177984741,
0.0409598462,
-0.0440778211,
0.0348965749,
0.039456699,
0.0674040839,
-0.0364209302,
-0.0041511529,
0.0079582063,
0.0323628485,
0.0884127244,
-0.0301720724,
-0.0166247915,
0.0201943666,
0.0732204542,
-0.0309680216,
-0.0323123522,
0.0212842487,
0.0539574809,
-0.0949551836,
0.0227412041,
0.1167467013,
-0.001405678,
-0.0210802946,
-0.0256763827,
0.0017149218,
0.0165513866,
0.012718155,
0.0171698611,
-0.0695577711,
-0.0593890771,
0.0347262844,
0.0218569003,
0.0321157128,
-0.0059567448,
-0.0456178896,
-0.081521146,
0.045853965,
0.0104160281,
-0.0241798311,
-0.0067975279,
0.0130626485,
-0.0239341296,
-0.0079998812,
0.0221962817,
0.0104622636,
0.0152486712,
-0.0051702317,
0.0207525194,
-0.0287122373,
-0.028932292,
0.0422501154,
-0.0307006743,
0.0658984482,
0.0684771091,
0.0033077814,
0.0001108585,
-0.0543314815,
0.0356103778,
-0.0488837212,
-0.0158502888,
-0.0029464953,
-0.0138634397,
-0.0438404158,
-0.0206899308,
0.0004318242,
0.0569202527,
-0.0237039644,
0.0186037421,
0.010090691,
0.0892409533,
-0.01244538,
-0.0286546443,
0.0032752613,
-0.0234719291,
0.0205419231,
0.0692884326,
0.0034563993,
-0.0198697988,
-0.0413576402,
-0.0191365555,
-0.0260952972,
-0.0322574712,
-0.0294917747,
-0.0091003515,
0.0096465768,
-0.0276916232,
0.0268325005,
-0.0039126039,
0.0202461276,
0.0397575609,
-0.0106816236,
0.047598578,
0.0280959345,
-0.0029236977,
-0.0615765527,
0.008317559,
-0.0156538915,
0.0402133055,
-0.0381060876,
-0.0179615915,
0.0828036517,
-0.0325227343,
-0.0126189487,
0.0501836427,
-0.0590948872,
-0.0542066954,
-0.005324034,
0.0075112316,
0.0286292918,
0.0732896328,
-0.0496627912,
-0.0132611012,
0.0450784042,
0.0108805122,
-0.0475728326,
0.0340450183,
0.0742985457,
0.0108525045,
0.0095764427,
0.0503968522,
-0.0623987615,
-0.0150285829,
-0.0173947643,
0.0098716095,
-0.0064553372,
0.0062224371,
-0.0303843711,
0.0351440869,
0.0300101321,
0.0025869131,
-0.0039672037,
-0.0273661707,
0.0450381674,
0.0134924259,
0.0333287343,
-0.0820821822,
0.0137256337,
0.0117321312,
-0.0427825376,
-0.0038537909,
0.0025979951,
0.0080340067,
-0.04965996,
-0.0185153019,
0.0437804908,
0.0182478093,
-0.0247381963,
0.0351902507,
-0.0075363475,
-0.0029256234,
0.0252536461,
0.0551042967,
0.0244391896,
-0.0179394521,
0.0276746303,
-0.0033512362,
0.0145199653,
0.0263640434,
0.0399078839,
-0.0773406923,
-0.0832038671,
-0.0203795396,
0.0534747876,
0.0229364857,
0.0049591186,
0.0483206958,
0.0082146442,
-0.003146281,
-0.0237397347,
0.0606488548,
-0.0226692762,
-0.0350186974,
0.0384092666,
0.0172903165,
-0.0197689775,
-0.0059146411,
0.0566136092,
0.0350050554,
0.0301632192,
0.0170879327,
0.0137062352,
-0.0475303717,
-0.0592166781,
-0.0123435194,
0.0362559371,
-0.0244686902,
-0.0092548495,
-0.017867377,
-0.0517278127,
0.0382206924,
-0.0134070423,
0.0047262879,
-0.0571294576,
0.0187092833,
0.0045548403,
-0.0280195419,
0.0065690423,
-0.0061581745,
-0.0283499695,
-0.0001878694,
-0.0135846343,
0.044307556,
-6.519958763e-33,
-0.0429739319,
0.0382828265,
0.0349095799,
-0.0162367076,
-0.0536255352,
0.0067213955,
-0.0213552024,
-0.0257427264,
-0.0253017433,
-0.0383390635,
-0.0169630442,
0.0433246344,
0.044339858,
0.0461878181,
-0.0065035876,
-0.0352096148,
0.0628180429,
-0.0438944027,
0.011405129,
0.0368559062,
0.0102878371,
0.063861914,
0.040066082,
-0.006779951,
0.001793069,
-0.0032204816,
-0.0097562745,
0.0085269818,
-0.0354613662,
0.0436118878,
-0.0244178902,
0.0230724271,
0.0038446952,
-0.0561840646,
-0.0654016882,
0.0451727994,
-0.0464859977,
-0.0020171448,
0.0232221205,
0.034156587,
-0.0506285764,
0.0017731329,
0.0202364735,
0.0508710817,
0.0142280934,
-0.0272653308,
-0.0227467343,
-0.0054651592,
-0.014290899,
-0.0261499938,
0.0156973079,
0.0122670373,
-0.0056880303,
-0.0248708781,
0.0652160943,
-0.015856171,
-0.0134491241,
0.0078371046,
-0.052206248,
0.0049069244,
0.0020752163,
0.019864101,
0.0702538714,
0.0082513755,
-0.011153833,
0.0207658391,
0.0118126394,
-0.0747187436,
-0.0088507095,
-0.0172771811,
0.0080614192,
0.0477032699,
-0.000805347,
0.0148342643,
0.0281746406,
-0.016610669,
-0.0120725771,
-0.0182594229,
0.049742464,
0.0132809114,
0.0278243832,
0.0413010158,
0.017852053,
-0.0220516957,
-0.0360517986,
-0.0305952206,
-0.0301205274,
0.019748779,
0.0666275918,
0.0335982256,
0.0328795277,
-0.0001422278,
0.0897039622,
-0.0222505126,
0.0224661827,
0.0174977351,
0.0027938373,
-0.0116040437,
0.0161834434,
0.0675841421,
-0.0515207388,
-0.0051974854,
-0.0091563407,
0.0218915474,
-0.0146903927,
-0.0233228598,
0.0010874465,
0.057316307,
-0.0496688373,
-0.0162735414,
-0.0344752967,
0.0402652882,
-0.023075385,
0.0271264706,
0.0485618189,
-0.0398362242,
0.0051514287,
0.0793297514,
-0.0477901995,
-0.0197372586,
-0.0187491495,
-0.0300096944,
0.0137167647,
0.0138459122,
-0.021907337,
0.010369706,
-0.0153534627,
-0.0096510053,
0.0341044292,
-0.0423965715,
0.0001607501,
0.0095064025,
2.778e-7,
-0.0190893635,
-0.0176431034,
0.0214369856,
0.0068744342,
0.0421748459,
0.0261918567,
-0.0313574038,
0.0366688892,
-0.0164823495,
0.0162563995,
0.002021288,
0.0179393031,
0.0820328072,
-0.0008038399,
-0.1091778949,
-0.0499882288,
-0.038637463,
0.0421976559,
-0.0282039791,
-0.0258266535,
0.0067082373,
0.0998229682,
-0.0296532996,
-0.0068733883,
0.0599176586,
0.0052207233,
0.0099453675,
-0.0174575746,
0.0199923608,
-0.025300961,
-0.0057938476,
0.0000350395,
-0.0316470526,
-0.0137718329,
-0.0409796797,
0.0272870976,
-0.0183348581,
0.1151590794,
0.0323214419,
-0.0583294816,
0.0072033014,
0.0195768587,
-0.0001341807,
-0.0080384109,
0.0686578974,
0.0038608003,
-0.004085721,
-0.0304908864,
-0.0365391225,
-0.0659187436,
-0.0380461998,
0.0073322696,
0.0170612782,
0.0180784017,
-0.0144416103,
-0.047906246,
-0.0267499741,
-0.0989073068,
0.0109801972,
-0.0415981449,
-0.0787026733,
-0.0258093886,
-0.0796259716,
0.0116314888,
0.0602011643,
-0.0677792206,
-0.0321228169,
2.498784846e-34,
0.0292529222,
-0.0064786701,
0.0324060619,
0.0377490669,
-0.0115118688,
-0.0000561041,
0.0026746751,
0.0121175731,
0.0157959219,
-0.059541095,
-0.0611649752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19951v1 | Mining Reasons For And Against Vaccination From Unstructured Data Using Nichesourcing and AI Data Augmentation | 2024-06-28T14:36:31 | 2024-06-28T14:36:31 | Damián Ariel Furman, Juan Junqueras, Z. Burçe Gümüslü, Edgar Altszyler, Joaquin Navajas, Ophelia Deroy, Justin Sulik | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Reasons For and Against Vaccination (RFAV), a dataset for
predicting reasons for and against vaccination, and scientific authorities used
to justify them, annotated through nichesourcing and augmented using GPT4 and
GPT3.5-Turbo. We show how it is possible to mine these reasons in
non-structured text, under different task definitions, despite the high level
of subjectivity involved and explore the impact of artificially augmented data
using in-context learning with GPT4 and GPT3.5-Turbo. We publish the dataset
and the trained models along with the annotation manual used to train
annotators and define the task. | [
0.0206370335,
0.0414494276,
0.00355472,
-0.0319069698,
0.0166790839,
0.01354698,
0.0078289164,
-0.0468724743,
-0.0164144877,
-0.0114156008,
0.0000139736,
0.0227100216,
0.0021594726,
0.0092616118,
-0.0123086376,
-0.0523124859,
0.0509715788,
0.0606041551,
0.0641149804,
0.0437157936,
0.0136884367,
0.0418901518,
-0.0265174415,
0.0651525334,
0.0123317754,
-0.020482013,
0.0111673353,
-0.0272210483,
0.083373934,
-0.1111796945,
0.0490967073,
-0.0391777344,
0.0481577069,
0.0128500108,
0.0000019802,
0.0147447074,
-0.044241257,
0.0438931584,
-0.0284019206,
-0.0192911569,
0.0361823849,
-0.0149601148,
0.0037252787,
0.0312562063,
-0.0571492352,
-0.0187172219,
0.0720984042,
0.0484602675,
0.0252411664,
0.0418709591,
-0.0217429698,
-0.0172760095,
0.0145732556,
-0.0204451811,
-0.0017040784,
0.0351218097,
0.0365003794,
-0.0060410206,
-0.0122635337,
0.0698681697,
0.0152469696,
0.0031789094,
-0.0119640417,
-0.0240800139,
0.0566620827,
0.0566497706,
-0.0301592462,
-0.0036992684,
-0.004808527,
0.0710950196,
0.0345028266,
-0.0264718048,
0.0287297033,
-0.0152995363,
0.0025818041,
-0.0015496288,
-0.0348537788,
-0.0083390614,
-0.0225154329,
0.0492116995,
0.0859711319,
0.0155981984,
0.0588857122,
-0.0003223718,
0.0155002326,
0.1048116386,
-0.0193700902,
-0.038117677,
0.0132009834,
-0.0104177753,
-0.0055504786,
-0.0355592258,
0.0177433416,
0.0120096626,
-0.0092164315,
0.0175178275,
0.0339241587,
-0.0095447758,
0.0578107424,
-0.0295509268,
-0.0360260606,
-0.0113646658,
-0.0247172639,
0.0011177553,
0.0372944325,
-0.0875756368,
-0.0252638962,
0.0369594358,
0.0429874882,
0.039832335,
-0.1165505424,
-0.0167129673,
-0.0120749017,
0.02294413,
-0.0157124307,
0.0576089472,
-0.0590242706,
-0.0006912386,
-0.055340033,
-0.0431283638,
-0.0287499651,
0.0127257518,
-0.0062544034,
0.0151624437,
-0.0132686906,
0.0550606661,
-0.0370056368,
0.0568472408,
0.0182709694,
-0.0039307452,
-0.0031977007,
-0.0120614152,
0.0205024146,
-0.0237960424,
-0.0214089714,
0.0330807567,
0.0369817205,
-0.0302254688,
-0.023852298,
0.0062980014,
-0.0551692694,
-0.0538381375,
-0.0418309048,
-0.0137870619,
-0.0211961698,
-0.0261866003,
0.0014341993,
-0.0415237099,
-0.0179925133,
0.0074591595,
-0.0350941122,
0.0606933646,
-0.0658800453,
-0.0349941067,
0.0682112724,
0.0204386842,
-0.0011177211,
0.0171902981,
-0.0105010029,
0.0071756383,
0.0032995711,
-0.0111694485,
0.0073260679,
-0.0741965547,
0.0430465676,
0.0302073676,
0.0517328568,
0.0092825023,
-0.0431401506,
0.008441899,
-0.0377354585,
0.0500125177,
-0.0456303358,
-0.0125847142,
0.0216981247,
0.0681754351,
0.0059408913,
-0.029842183,
-0.012527247,
0.0374806896,
-0.007749937,
0.012376369,
-0.0098832343,
0.0251846593,
-0.019661855,
-0.0299946498,
0.0259879585,
0.0004157593,
-0.0092694154,
-0.0492530726,
0.0023594811,
0.000687133,
0.0770326033,
-0.0316158272,
0.0341997519,
-0.0133328112,
-0.0177892111,
-0.0162126273,
0.0540883355,
-0.0351953283,
-0.0146205425,
-0.0569551513,
0.0527726859,
0.0328084342,
0.0185531396,
-0.0411071554,
-0.1025436744,
-0.0554005876,
-0.0159258489,
0.0019225723,
0.004533493,
-0.0482209735,
-0.0094327899,
-0.02981521,
-0.0250208974,
-0.059892863,
0.0512947142,
0.0256171674,
-0.0182922464,
0.0328747742,
-0.0016699722,
-0.0081729731,
-0.0132344421,
0.0300922319,
-0.0057665627,
-0.0235639159,
0.026390098,
0.0194070451,
0.0745543912,
0.0596680194,
0.0339663215,
0.0277304798,
0.0514924787,
-0.0313327312,
-0.0083941035,
0.0258723926,
0.0107738571,
0.0205143932,
0.0237727594,
-0.0550260358,
-0.0111100879,
0.0001620281,
-0.0541479811,
-0.0151317976,
-0.0211105663,
-0.0148941213,
0.0567124598,
-0.0247813314,
-0.0240576416,
-0.0127792004,
0.0016175123,
-0.023165796,
0.0295602866,
0.0178687871,
-0.0474753529,
0.0257879365,
-0.0601597056,
0.0234628785,
-0.0513057634,
0.0464148782,
-0.0316768289,
0.0200933665,
-0.023754131,
0.0337941498,
-0.0602117851,
-0.028453514,
0.0494380109,
-0.103523463,
0.0232588481,
-0.0037112923,
0.029106576,
0.0100455936,
-0.0304768216,
0.0250312891,
-0.0023145771,
-0.0269713365,
-0.0249418672,
-0.0174557287,
0.0410823189,
0.0405339263,
0.017643027,
0.0414858684,
-0.0605870113,
0.0026459531,
-0.0697364435,
-0.0095939739,
0.0258796904,
0.0010054053,
0.0080129839,
-0.0511549637,
-0.0091852499,
-0.0095330169,
-0.0251271836,
0.0087948516,
0.0347787067,
0.0060234303,
-0.0060718018,
0.0051896302,
0.010890469,
0.023144355,
0.0678485781,
0.0318282172,
-0.0300349891,
0.0109814806,
-0.0369881392,
0.0343156978,
0.0175213739,
-0.0060628126,
0.0343795083,
0.0448677875,
-0.0083411336,
-0.0269512497,
-0.0539983921,
0.0358490348,
-0.0156764332,
-0.0009867366,
-0.0373998843,
-0.0528373681,
0.0037088429,
0.0388888344,
-0.0069283918,
-0.038501557,
0.0656342879,
0.0391571634,
0.0257160403,
-0.0767450705,
-0.0350869484,
-0.0220843982,
-0.0327432938,
-0.0138395261,
-0.0289223064,
0.0391416028,
0.0295393132,
0.0250853319,
-0.0449779481,
-0.0229783934,
-0.0161756556,
-0.0068607363,
-0.0169745684,
0.0044921706,
0.0099385874,
-0.021430498,
-0.013676404,
-0.0404761061,
-0.0297383163,
-0.0312152002,
0.0352040008,
-0.0256548654,
-0.0055589792,
0.0221956801,
0.0083682155,
0.0474776737,
-0.010870385,
-0.0245350245,
0.0315046534,
0.0115360972,
0.0375955626,
-0.0495307483,
0.0098111862,
0.0059304787,
-0.0198057275,
0.0438275896,
-0.014950891,
-0.0117602246,
-0.0328356847,
0.0013123698,
-0.050217323,
-0.0136797084,
-0.0148296123,
-0.0004620955,
0.0150532005,
-0.038172245,
0.027921427,
0.0634392798,
0.0306958407,
-0.029104026,
0.0193784256,
-0.0011667083,
-0.0365232006,
-0.0259213559,
0.0020727026,
-0.0482868552,
0.0088425819,
-0.0208724644,
0.0179138947,
-0.0296734851,
-0.0350508764,
0.0042437925,
-0.0366274603,
0.0715532228,
0.0195153914,
-0.0529889241,
-0.0249078926,
-0.097642526,
0.0041029151,
-0.0678158477,
-0.0211714003,
-0.0334683284,
0.0366053432,
0.0196329616,
0.0375308953,
-0.0352971517,
-0.0420986898,
0.0096170558,
0.0190871917,
0.0510056466,
0.0771311224,
0.0698036402,
0.014901449,
-0.0458939672,
-0.0015578135,
0.0291836299,
-0.0441412143,
0.008660987,
0.1114455536,
0.0021423835,
0.0118791917,
-0.0276019927,
0.0572435632,
-0.0231510531,
-0.0374542885,
0.0346697345,
0.0904107243,
-0.0209927242,
0.0028737837,
-0.0660327151,
0.0191121195,
0.0233195722,
0.0452181138,
0.0201963075,
0.0074897539,
0.0130240619,
-0.0180319082,
0.0246655326,
-0.0706617907,
0.0180609394,
0.0124480966,
-0.0154184662,
-0.082731925,
-0.0458774045,
-0.009711599,
0.0193227306,
0.0039221896,
0.0150233544,
-0.0062818262,
0.0117957853,
-0.0157198329,
-0.0664151534,
0.0446105897,
0.0191729683,
-0.0172010623,
0.0078169983,
-0.0440915413,
0.042197682,
-0.0189709924,
0.0040989215,
0.0092180362,
0.0156390145,
-0.0585827455,
-0.0337397866,
0.0470439792,
0.0136966435,
0.0488342941,
0.0127780028,
0.0182828642,
0.0778020248,
0.0776006207,
-0.0270421095,
-0.0779861882,
0.0208566822,
-0.0252030268,
0.0093673049,
-0.0257323347,
0.0276234653,
-0.0023374665,
-0.0212217271,
-0.0141253751,
-0.0506715924,
0.051153902,
0.0522925295,
-0.015536177,
0.0879299417,
-0.0201349072,
-0.0311072432,
-0.0615865588,
-0.0140593965,
-0.0012656954,
-0.001864993,
0.0066950056,
-0.0042930897,
0.026547417,
-0.0422291122,
-0.0333712362,
-0.0245258473,
-0.0442954861,
0.0434780307,
-0.0364935808,
0.0518762879,
0.0130758062,
0.0366696604,
0.014458023,
0.0009253686,
-0.0150428144,
-0.0161420517,
0.0024249437,
0.0299278684,
-0.014932096,
0.0172335058,
0.0157543644,
0.0263715703,
0.0627273619,
0.0407317169,
-0.0497907735,
0.0042335666,
-0.0554005317,
0.0070315315,
-0.0208419263,
-0.0309370998,
0.0393134207,
-0.0217071548,
-0.0338387601,
-0.0400206037,
0.0489952117,
-0.0169066079,
-0.0047890623,
0.0182167403,
-0.0117326165,
-0.0483660959,
-0.0512512736,
0.0383797921,
-0.0054499563,
0.077692017,
0.0447804555,
-0.0469753034,
-0.0402940921,
-0.0022045672,
-0.0104450043,
0.085761033,
-0.0257789642,
0.0307853147,
-0.0562280864,
-0.0180845521,
0.0063527324,
-0.0305244513,
-0.0097337998,
0.0113641489,
-0.0058552581,
-0.0120575447,
-0.0251859594,
-0.0296239424,
-0.0430420339,
0.0179293007,
-0.0393519253,
-0.0041812104,
-0.0372678414,
-6.193438023e-33,
-0.0177205242,
-0.0438492373,
0.004851813,
-0.0054626078,
0.0144732334,
0.0256549492,
-0.0214423798,
-0.0281513669,
-0.0043225009,
0.0662659928,
0.0190425236,
0.026367614,
-0.0042980355,
0.0204788707,
0.0278501101,
0.0134912971,
0.0280551352,
0.0343011208,
0.0032950572,
0.043041978,
0.0118424026,
0.0046559405,
0.0372522958,
-0.1091481522,
0.0556098185,
0.0336817689,
0.0003442717,
-0.0307033565,
-0.0609710813,
0.0582474023,
-0.0087338742,
0.0450166203,
0.0213500112,
-0.0272536073,
0.0328708179,
0.0246967152,
-0.0599536188,
-0.0349847414,
0.0187868904,
-0.0639155805,
-0.0721055418,
-0.0812695995,
0.0429189727,
0.0395578519,
0.0083100265,
0.0339661278,
0.0261994246,
-0.0524338819,
-0.0103509743,
-0.0099348286,
-0.0633567497,
0.0322542861,
-0.0477757603,
0.0039666481,
0.0024592169,
0.0325020924,
-0.0082195094,
0.0939922482,
-0.0065852096,
0.0476557575,
0.0284261163,
-0.0254929047,
-0.0015551386,
-0.0087419683,
0.0174679216,
0.0343141742,
-0.0109973224,
-0.0003159892,
-0.0419818647,
-0.0331487022,
-0.0369850919,
0.0172075536,
0.0008771833,
0.0254463237,
0.0442624837,
0.0319477133,
-0.0721753463,
0.0547144599,
-0.0520429313,
-0.0009765018,
0.0165728666,
0.0230810102,
-0.0046525057,
-0.0048953514,
-0.0010373486,
-0.0274074264,
0.0022480567,
-0.0317844599,
-0.0029045187,
-0.0312878601,
-0.0354459397,
0.0563346297,
-0.0302571505,
0.0061014127,
0.0170953777,
0.0103067113,
0.027746968,
-0.0350411311,
0.0029391677,
-0.0091954246,
-0.0629316717,
0.0155477673,
0.0143655837,
0.0103898989,
0.0422716774,
0.0139293503,
0.037646465,
-0.0269043427,
-0.0509165414,
-0.0313095562,
-0.0060168197,
0.0289647505,
-0.0237607677,
0.0666799545,
0.0260406062,
0.0200591497,
0.0052320096,
0.0546365716,
0.0413502045,
0.026228413,
-0.0153012108,
-0.0583890602,
-0.0355385356,
0.0099331392,
0.0065959669,
-0.0177944228,
0.0350186191,
0.0039499514,
-0.0089966478,
-0.0919616967,
0.0096863098,
-0.0455430821,
2.789e-7,
0.0842058808,
0.0585430451,
0.021965595,
-0.0988556817,
0.0081794346,
0.0236182436,
-0.0378972031,
-0.0216271859,
-0.0385148451,
-0.0012956369,
0.0707323179,
0.0165257249,
0.0013661123,
0.0467506461,
-0.0385696478,
0.0009897035,
-0.0471567996,
-0.0316336192,
-0.0114116604,
0.0042317035,
0.0404950194,
0.059145119,
0.0258922931,
-0.0002908951,
0.0162770636,
0.0454838313,
0.0416425727,
-0.0110704284,
-0.0097110458,
0.0252941474,
0.019741293,
0.0004143802,
-0.019920554,
0.0252472684,
-0.0557931103,
-0.0510549024,
-0.0524994768,
0.0547457226,
-0.0315187983,
-0.0190359708,
0.0051210271,
0.0258763209,
0.0081567811,
-0.028771054,
0.0211987458,
-0.0423458442,
-0.0444185399,
-0.0472283028,
-0.0471679866,
0.0440341309,
0.0303639546,
0.0064279339,
-0.013441056,
0.0127131902,
-0.0365836583,
0.0218895804,
0.0000668722,
-0.0892489329,
-0.0099924691,
0.036645785,
-0.027835235,
-0.038660448,
0.0039691608,
0.0128917061,
0.02084288,
-0.0510172546,
0.0407014675,
2.052171839e-34,
0.0660505369,
0.0093076071,
-0.0015594484,
-0.0200319979,
-0.0000438438,
0.0174854267,
-0.0541244522,
-0.0088661294,
0.0413687639,
0.0022640619,
0.0122225201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19949v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19949v1 | Calibrating LLMs with Preference Optimization on Thought Trees for Generating Rationale in Science Question Scoring | 2024-06-28T14:33:05 | 2024-06-28T14:33:05 | Jiazheng Li, Hainiu Xu, Zhaoyue Sun, Yuxiang Zhou, David West, Cesare Aloisi, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating rationales that justify scoring decisions has been a promising way
to facilitate explainability in automated scoring systems. However, existing
methods do not match the accuracy of classifier-based methods. Plus, the
generated rationales often contain hallucinated information. To address these
issues, we propose a novel framework capable of generating more faithful
rationales and, more importantly, matching performance with classifier-based
black-box scoring systems. We first mimic the human assessment process by
querying Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate a thought tree. We then
summarise intermediate assessment decisions from each thought tree path for
creating synthetic rationale data and rationale preference data. Finally, we
utilise the generated synthetic data to calibrate LLMs through a two-step
training process: supervised fine-tuning and preference optimization. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate that our framework achieves a 38% assessment
performance improvement in the QWK score compared to prior work while producing
higher-quality rationales, as recognised by human evaluators and LLMs. Our work
sheds light on the effectiveness of performing preference optimization using
synthetic preference data obtained from thought tree paths. | [
0.0073491046,
0.0306120683,
0.0041716252,
0.022068562,
-0.0410177335,
0.0138589628,
-0.0073900074,
0.0062846127,
-0.0244835652,
-0.0443013795,
-0.0182626024,
-0.021154834,
-0.0120512825,
0.002512008,
0.019871626,
-0.0382423326,
0.018497752,
-0.0231964123,
0.0287196413,
-0.0143336346,
-0.0207310915,
0.0154237458,
-0.014653476,
0.0108197061,
0.0668464154,
-0.0487844311,
0.0072908406,
-0.0101372702,
0.0225182716,
-0.0468176492,
-0.0042885221,
0.0439996049,
0.0026075982,
0.0012464916,
0.0000022255,
-0.0594599731,
-0.0276509672,
-0.0104899611,
-0.0528794415,
0.0328889601,
0.0143787656,
0.0569314323,
0.0291018635,
0.022828931,
-0.033516936,
0.0284095723,
0.0131449634,
0.0075832829,
0.0603914484,
0.0488567539,
0.0246668439,
-0.0504521616,
0.0237632953,
0.0183638912,
0.0296940692,
-0.0169613697,
-0.0107403742,
0.0584762841,
-0.0080247987,
0.0351629704,
-0.0140047045,
-0.0067468649,
0.0233110506,
-0.0526507795,
0.0529389605,
0.0263624899,
-0.0117121451,
0.0030323302,
0.0395703055,
0.0812189206,
-0.0026766472,
-0.0530732721,
-0.0103884377,
-0.0305431299,
-0.0052650482,
0.0257832035,
-0.0525984727,
0.0141116101,
0.0132989036,
0.0023522277,
0.0801891685,
0.0186491366,
0.029452065,
0.0551639013,
-0.0037827657,
0.0971203595,
0.0094714817,
-0.0353249572,
0.0088142911,
0.0059975125,
-0.026152214,
-0.0806545541,
-0.0109862778,
0.0396779738,
-0.0308018327,
0.0085210437,
0.0227229279,
0.0449555069,
0.0035604727,
-0.0069137174,
0.0263437573,
0.0439616665,
0.0211389549,
0.0277208239,
-0.0049431399,
0.062596038,
0.021437645,
0.052119568,
-0.0299245622,
0.0117489342,
-0.075406082,
-0.0263479967,
0.0343986154,
0.0264667273,
-0.0240775626,
0.0304715987,
-0.0546212904,
-0.0110883489,
-0.019391844,
-0.0264680404,
0.0563178174,
0.0239216555,
0.0226547718,
-0.0098597324,
-0.0667348802,
0.0275239293,
-0.0419855192,
0.0091323862,
0.0284863506,
0.0129864626,
-0.0193413757,
0.0305507053,
0.0180359595,
0.0051313546,
0.025260685,
0.0037313271,
0.033418905,
-0.0036675141,
-0.0004984749,
-0.0382002853,
-0.0074796816,
-0.0447621942,
0.0058773654,
-0.0273277778,
-0.0269779302,
0.0145787811,
-0.0020471173,
-0.0006491642,
0.0059062243,
0.0226652957,
0.0117723607,
0.0689735115,
-0.0360284224,
-0.0028804678,
-0.0068155713,
-0.0026779135,
-0.0120996237,
0.0337456614,
0.0563146695,
-0.0156053817,
0.0464811586,
-0.065760307,
0.0177701414,
-0.0324697867,
-0.0057960618,
-0.0217098109,
-0.0100357216,
0.0503262803,
-0.0379902758,
0.0532881804,
-0.019579649,
-0.0002040642,
-0.0053886794,
0.0411248729,
0.014259275,
0.0575114228,
0.0417211503,
0.0001333579,
0.0135125723,
-0.0366517454,
0.0019547329,
0.0243741404,
-0.0171301197,
0.0600594804,
-0.04066303,
0.00440537,
-0.0012055028,
0.0172722135,
0.0026629127,
-0.079469882,
-0.0116682285,
0.0253309421,
-0.0205188412,
0.0163971428,
0.0423473604,
-0.010738113,
-0.0210131481,
0.0240448061,
0.0162844174,
-0.0504076108,
0.0297917109,
-0.0373105109,
0.0382695422,
0.0630380362,
0.0492438264,
-0.026193643,
-0.0402864292,
-0.0069754962,
-0.0142902909,
0.0126220239,
0.0383888371,
-0.0574431717,
-0.0318402462,
-0.0395350866,
-0.0400607176,
-0.0419784077,
0.0082004061,
-0.0335961357,
-0.0224297885,
-0.0138414567,
0.0191890039,
-0.067872718,
-0.0561279431,
0.0403970033,
-0.0233187452,
-0.0365416147,
0.0058892737,
-0.0321075246,
0.0470928214,
0.0229230691,
0.0186917745,
0.0538624898,
0.0212475229,
-0.0272667259,
-0.0062548267,
-0.0068018432,
-0.0472918823,
-0.0524969473,
0.0536283106,
-0.0119980872,
-0.0046101231,
0.0337305143,
-0.0221352559,
-0.0391391441,
-0.0127865728,
-0.007413228,
-0.0280686095,
-0.0373093002,
0.0414585546,
-0.0333961397,
-0.0538062565,
-0.0827560201,
0.0670673698,
0.0269250236,
0.0708553717,
-0.0061598374,
-0.0454082452,
0.0419921763,
-0.0112082837,
0.0353571214,
0.0167944096,
-0.0060720094,
-0.002297187,
0.0327419899,
0.0120168347,
-0.0734665617,
0.0154308518,
-0.0405526347,
-0.0027662069,
-0.017730508,
0.0265128929,
0.019681694,
-0.0379052423,
0.0155124934,
0.029690044,
-0.052278284,
0.0009766595,
0.0068853302,
-0.0191336535,
0.057067208,
-0.0211824514,
0.0126622794,
-0.0429975875,
-0.0082377866,
-0.0642210171,
0.0538294613,
0.0369217061,
0.0717145428,
-0.0589729138,
0.0488112085,
-0.0282596555,
-0.0616397373,
0.0046404805,
-0.0371066816,
0.0299480725,
-0.0154902171,
-0.0405607931,
0.0698936805,
0.0297147166,
-0.0209348351,
0.0658256784,
0.0152844973,
-0.0780406296,
-0.0031921673,
-0.0130330883,
0.0395659432,
-0.0128538581,
-0.0365607068,
0.0318340659,
0.0604802482,
-0.0362994261,
-0.0238655992,
-0.030381795,
0.0944361538,
-0.0395302586,
0.0034929567,
-0.0437157303,
-0.0194437932,
-0.0156108318,
0.0998256579,
0.005767982,
-0.0450637117,
0.0875017717,
-0.0321616866,
0.0094089611,
-0.0672761947,
0.0199772585,
-0.0381232873,
0.0502425097,
-0.004815252,
-0.0263726674,
0.0041148458,
0.0409951471,
-0.06009968,
-0.0241711773,
0.0352360904,
-0.0183265619,
0.0035232774,
-0.0594714992,
-0.0124990139,
0.0213926937,
-0.0249896385,
-0.0184546616,
-0.0176320449,
-0.0166740622,
0.0074989949,
0.0135151921,
-0.0170525461,
0.0154459616,
0.0037029397,
0.0409087315,
0.0074589984,
-0.0418713801,
-0.0094931815,
0.0070713325,
0.0430950187,
0.0565975383,
-0.0196231175,
0.0535186008,
-0.0298922639,
0.0456932075,
0.0157418065,
0.0309962686,
0.0444743559,
0.0127148097,
-0.0027748863,
0.0216091946,
-0.0456695035,
-0.0086977258,
0.0140904561,
0.0722209886,
-0.0402964242,
0.0049432162,
0.1408447623,
0.0623937361,
0.0087741613,
-0.0024670966,
-0.0494208857,
0.007031458,
0.019445613,
0.0272693839,
-0.0430585966,
-0.0262693781,
-0.0157604814,
0.0498550683,
-0.0102730095,
-0.0301706158,
0.0142577272,
-0.123363696,
0.0176448226,
-0.0026672271,
-0.0385012552,
0.0147219105,
-0.0650947168,
-0.0073808893,
-0.035254579,
-0.0391076915,
0.0447173938,
0.0199901406,
0.0228345748,
0.0318810791,
-0.0324179195,
-0.0361923054,
0.0639522672,
-0.0309450906,
0.0262262374,
0.0415305868,
0.060615629,
0.0073618181,
-0.0858100057,
0.0268984493,
-0.0380833037,
-0.0006430382,
-0.0179613121,
-0.0039636702,
0.024821179,
0.0118163079,
-0.0375972092,
0.0490333512,
-0.0349373259,
-0.0047517288,
-0.0049454938,
0.1146870181,
-0.0318918116,
-0.0335460007,
-0.009085292,
-0.0022292465,
-0.0420118608,
0.0857038796,
0.03759785,
-0.0302344766,
-0.0225182362,
-0.0498704612,
0.0003852603,
-0.0964223593,
-0.0765109584,
0.0078497836,
0.0025754536,
0.0028069331,
-0.0488001332,
-0.0280885417,
0.0431529507,
0.0113522708,
-0.0028999627,
-0.0046727741,
-0.028660059,
-0.0027469909,
-0.0347411782,
0.0391628966,
-0.0253311303,
0.0076866262,
-0.0089905579,
0.0012930736,
0.058218509,
-0.018960407,
-0.0469954945,
-0.0230242666,
0.0368302315,
-0.0483305752,
-0.0472920686,
0.0538492464,
0.0241198614,
0.012092947,
0.0095917955,
-0.0256994944,
0.0040704971,
0.0016397577,
-0.0154682538,
-0.034162052,
-0.0040864162,
0.0001528553,
-0.0090402849,
0.0069342065,
-0.0068020108,
0.0053479294,
0.0304766968,
0.0527549684,
-0.0284990761,
-0.0406752676,
0.0525064878,
0.0539193973,
0.0346729457,
-0.0043322276,
-0.0084643979,
-0.0231666416,
0.0128715839,
-0.022348037,
-0.0280488506,
-0.0125694694,
0.0072253803,
0.0365618765,
-0.0315160006,
-0.007748873,
-0.048648525,
-0.0661876425,
0.0353441834,
-0.0248122979,
0.0413939171,
0.0420274362,
0.0396285094,
0.0143991746,
-0.0250921715,
-0.0258199517,
-0.0661030635,
0.0035943417,
0.0487256721,
0.0062100659,
0.0669190958,
0.0206707735,
0.0288999993,
-0.0082055014,
-0.0180704128,
-0.0676317513,
-0.0407607406,
-0.0274394602,
-0.0204836205,
0.0106759695,
0.0052004531,
0.0286303572,
0.0132674733,
-0.0310673676,
-0.004336914,
0.0396060124,
0.048620034,
-0.0103732264,
0.0452546254,
0.040953327,
-0.0276793707,
-0.020987181,
0.0440692641,
-0.0176250227,
0.0080334432,
-0.0233407971,
-0.0232460238,
-0.0311753191,
-0.0118128238,
-0.0732688755,
0.031349279,
0.0155207813,
0.0199499633,
-0.0795315802,
-0.0351170525,
0.0154299289,
0.0324092917,
0.0183409676,
-0.0098090526,
0.019495137,
0.0514146201,
-0.0419798642,
-0.040650744,
-0.0149959205,
-0.0063025923,
-0.064165704,
-0.0097827613,
-0.0304582454,
-6.525025878e-33,
-0.0065846704,
-0.0663710684,
0.0162926372,
-0.0046604588,
-0.0023676513,
-0.0102082249,
-0.0366626643,
-0.0179329664,
-0.0085083945,
0.027108198,
-0.0111325029,
0.0073504308,
-0.0147967646,
0.0025119365,
0.0297818575,
-0.0189675409,
0.0217973106,
0.0152911935,
-0.0442760848,
0.0043604244,
0.0262755696,
-0.0176547077,
0.0470803902,
-0.0463315994,
0.0603822656,
0.0357691497,
0.010743022,
0.03460842,
-0.0612253696,
0.0525315963,
-0.0022716294,
0.0013175863,
0.0243430994,
-0.081406042,
0.0284129456,
-0.010976159,
-0.014599964,
-0.0170483533,
0.0418150127,
-0.0400087982,
-0.0335604697,
-0.0538921244,
0.0374513566,
0.0165311191,
-0.0407715254,
-0.0358557366,
0.0474063717,
-0.0485568233,
-0.0090827355,
-0.0214715619,
-0.0121463854,
0.0301432516,
-0.0422224104,
0.0000024436,
-0.0334895551,
0.0576662347,
-0.0079660518,
0.0788174495,
-0.0015153396,
0.0434854776,
0.035987705,
0.0138107911,
0.0665611848,
-0.0001419955,
0.0039060407,
0.0790436789,
0.0173186716,
-0.0085852388,
-0.0213063546,
-0.0022297669,
-0.0154374437,
0.0197745003,
0.1375895888,
0.0446725227,
0.0501274765,
0.0187210068,
-0.1077429503,
0.0470000356,
-0.0159737393,
0.0002146701,
0.0071529285,
-0.0015910349,
-0.0033038072,
-0.008413191,
-0.0708389431,
-0.0238057766,
-0.0337331034,
0.0064444346,
0.004154745,
-0.0548997037,
-0.0699371174,
-0.0212389976,
0.0097515853,
-0.0299739819,
0.0169408415,
0.0113970395,
-0.0173162371,
0.0292096157,
0.0038627272,
-0.0163423326,
-0.0265571829,
0.0368393026,
-0.0140993353,
-0.0038696788,
0.0509917997,
0.0339893997,
-0.0024731532,
-0.0354832672,
-0.0142256096,
-0.0209217444,
-0.0390972458,
-0.0523292795,
-0.0072833034,
0.0350209884,
0.0043066442,
0.039417658,
0.0148819918,
0.0279273503,
0.0335411243,
0.036711257,
-0.0063690799,
-0.0240572635,
-0.0138728302,
0.0242217947,
0.0185360853,
-0.0057721944,
0.0144167142,
-0.0139486147,
-0.0269807354,
-0.0407205671,
-0.0076884823,
0.0099301627,
2.807e-7,
0.0642021,
0.0746639818,
-0.0395374708,
-0.0257012844,
-0.0071102837,
0.0417712554,
0.0012095304,
-0.0550613739,
0.0546698123,
-0.0498657487,
-0.0036675886,
-0.016977394,
0.0444280952,
0.0266054459,
-0.1032533124,
-0.03547417,
-0.0280929711,
-0.0297258738,
-0.0120969294,
0.0041728164,
0.0826315433,
0.0301603191,
0.0029243217,
-0.0246858522,
0.0044990927,
-0.0136100324,
0.0343266353,
-0.0367196426,
-0.0064641028,
0.0504856519,
0.0431936197,
-0.0385540836,
0.0193560664,
0.0337282456,
-0.0243773963,
0.0095802955,
-0.0084251305,
0.0324997641,
-0.0197159629,
-0.0444033407,
-0.0032366137,
-0.0211051535,
0.0312021319,
-0.0767389238,
0.0678737164,
-0.0367004536,
-0.0249759927,
0.0075148996,
-0.0395067707,
-0.0281976536,
0.0323522687,
-0.0388463885,
0.0139347455,
0.0176204443,
-0.0479799993,
-0.0093290331,
0.0056441468,
-0.0338892676,
-0.0472322404,
0.0072950707,
0.0043651238,
-0.0497320853,
-0.0113967359,
-0.0091571715,
0.0326327868,
-0.0636229962,
-0.0075480454,
2.662409068e-34,
0.0413869545,
0.012478021,
0.0171429459,
0.0049338336,
0.0413815379,
0.0315483734,
0.0112161627,
-0.0238639377,
0.0425897799,
-0.0882495195,
-0.0123204002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19934v1 | From the Least to the Most: Building a Plug-and-Play Visual Reasoner via Data Synthesis | 2024-06-28T14:04:10 | 2024-06-28T14:04:10 | Chuanqi Cheng, Jian Guan, Wei Wu, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We explore multi-step reasoning in vision-language models (VLMs). The problem
is challenging, as reasoning data consisting of multiple steps of visual and
language processing are barely available. To overcome the challenge, we first
introduce a least-to-most visual reasoning paradigm, which interleaves steps of
decomposing a question into sub-questions and invoking external tools for
resolving sub-questions. Based on the paradigm, we further propose a novel data
synthesis approach that can automatically create questions and multi-step
reasoning paths for an image in a bottom-up manner. Our approach divides the
complex synthesis task into a few simple sub-tasks, and (almost entirely)
relies on open-sourced models to accomplish the sub-tasks. Therefore, the
entire synthesis process is reproducible and cost-efficient, and the
synthesized data is quality guaranteed. With the approach, we construct $50$k
visual reasoning examples. Then, we develop a visual reasoner through
supervised fine-tuning, which is capable of generally enhancing the reasoning
abilities of a wide range of existing VLMs in a plug-and-play fashion.
Extensive experiments indicate that the visual reasoner can consistently and
significantly improve four VLMs on four VQA benchmarks. Our code and dataset
are available at https://github.com/steven-ccq/VisualReasoner. | [
0.0073754163,
0.0625501126,
0.0029008219,
0.0626458973,
-0.0315207876,
0.0442050993,
0.0285004824,
-0.0100510921,
0.0020480754,
-0.0332615934,
0.0373047814,
0.0070061493,
-0.0065160557,
0.0475098677,
0.0170604642,
-0.0929730609,
0.0197235718,
-0.0507642925,
-0.0000105818,
0.0124851968,
0.0066535589,
0.0282324273,
-0.010527079,
0.0487315767,
-0.0133021707,
-0.0296235029,
-0.0385324247,
0.0147428736,
0.0204325728,
0.0082883723,
-0.0483323485,
0.0123934643,
0.0558435395,
-0.0117658507,
0.0000020205,
-0.0230669715,
-0.0031362581,
0.0172567666,
-0.0165142491,
-0.0380198024,
-0.0357920602,
-0.022996204,
0.0008146587,
0.0145606156,
-0.0385563001,
-0.0135000776,
0.0466873832,
0.0569122732,
0.1022560969,
0.0402883925,
-0.0130725,
-0.0492881127,
0.0086285621,
0.0132086957,
0.0425511412,
-0.0117910812,
-0.0157878567,
0.0491345078,
0.0163855627,
-0.0265410077,
-0.0334900767,
0.0425269343,
0.0597849712,
-0.0373445898,
-0.0200863332,
0.0084225554,
-0.0206185281,
-0.053560812,
-0.0207698066,
0.0706828013,
-0.0336413793,
0.0067268237,
0.0154142492,
-0.0019912403,
0.0037465438,
-0.0003113073,
-0.0369895734,
0.0352486707,
-0.0401509404,
0.0009300231,
-0.0288425535,
-0.0128748333,
-0.0097895376,
-0.0094717005,
-0.0487176888,
0.0103113418,
-0.0068265242,
0.0341562629,
-0.01078765,
0.0036465514,
-0.0360744819,
-0.065603517,
-0.0278053377,
0.068833597,
-0.0326983556,
-0.0039091031,
-0.0074050534,
0.0076513691,
-0.0407125242,
0.0000523008,
0.0271130223,
0.033857435,
-0.0504299328,
0.0803420395,
-0.0282669086,
0.0506075844,
-0.0120741315,
0.054331217,
-0.0168603957,
-0.0489808358,
-0.0415973179,
-0.007658531,
-0.0197724439,
-0.0226673819,
-0.0794608742,
-0.0368188433,
0.0209161211,
0.0173461996,
-0.0263233054,
0.0232632421,
0.0229013264,
0.0384681411,
0.0202846918,
-0.0524375401,
-0.0539393201,
0.0208864175,
-0.0527586751,
0.0066059548,
0.0149277272,
-0.0335356817,
-0.0087168133,
0.033191938,
0.0329994038,
-0.0054635061,
-0.0050719297,
0.0504212305,
-0.0324046127,
0.0196423139,
-0.0489545204,
-0.0608429536,
0.0143828895,
-0.0648205057,
0.0112175103,
-0.0656314418,
0.0124929566,
-0.0037459657,
-0.0202039257,
-0.0322873592,
0.0071102097,
0.0167396497,
-0.0321843512,
0.1066996902,
-0.0232628658,
0.0137492465,
-0.0081994385,
0.0125029543,
-0.0062222769,
0.0604018793,
0.0333076231,
0.0259194877,
0.0124213435,
-0.0055432301,
0.0202973504,
0.0018104312,
-0.0027751434,
-0.0411869995,
-0.0585845858,
0.0263895169,
-0.0516938828,
0.0016227582,
-0.0093897022,
0.0307083707,
-0.0396971107,
-0.0078716408,
0.0032921704,
0.0339505151,
0.0422842577,
-0.0235539451,
0.0509267971,
0.0073299031,
0.0011862516,
-0.0093031293,
-0.0632338226,
0.0899189785,
0.0096440902,
-0.0016806256,
-0.0128537836,
0.02828479,
-0.0270222444,
-0.0910936967,
0.005457927,
0.0099719111,
-0.0012597842,
0.0317175724,
0.0444644168,
0.0461070463,
-0.0354630016,
-0.0205077361,
0.0080972295,
-0.0391382426,
-0.0331226699,
-0.0455373302,
0.060207542,
0.0810250789,
0.0402635559,
-0.0007318287,
0.0048251874,
-0.0084434748,
0.0338445939,
0.0120808985,
-0.0078748176,
-0.0074189096,
0.0215337351,
-0.0706536174,
-0.0540837236,
-0.0368542187,
-0.0059925416,
-0.0013546805,
0.0161255039,
-0.0404532105,
0.0079756519,
-0.0366919041,
0.0307870414,
0.02576348,
0.0381408632,
0.0099036163,
-0.0254442617,
0.0336268879,
-0.020461902,
-0.001522697,
0.0085680867,
0.0015300839,
-0.0016100819,
-0.0298774187,
0.0088808322,
0.0182199534,
-0.0013672317,
-0.0584785119,
0.0212640408,
-0.0569247007,
-0.0374653712,
0.0035347941,
-0.0712929294,
-0.0274048522,
0.0253034513,
-0.0019776036,
-0.0376517624,
-0.0498171635,
-0.0310367141,
0.0305935871,
-0.0027675149,
-0.0243773945,
0.0610605404,
-0.0153888958,
-0.0430460013,
0.0108648902,
0.0149972197,
0.0284314957,
-0.0187581722,
0.0357624479,
-0.0012404192,
-0.0360491052,
0.010922268,
-0.0254594889,
-0.0085530281,
-0.0442185439,
0.0035633461,
-0.0258660931,
-0.0082665458,
-0.013094171,
-0.0477405563,
0.0042731543,
0.0020849833,
0.0258060023,
-0.0352386422,
-0.015550172,
0.0393987149,
0.028810421,
-0.0000498316,
0.0490231365,
-0.0221245307,
-0.001862435,
0.0016727945,
-0.0020372686,
0.0086937528,
0.0757215843,
0.0332414806,
0.0035346751,
-0.03042241,
-0.0184630994,
-0.0442699715,
0.027939206,
-0.0022149822,
-0.0059710382,
0.0275666825,
-0.0404474922,
0.0044989656,
0.0986273587,
-0.013343554,
0.0245143175,
0.0083347689,
-0.0086979503,
-0.0411164984,
0.0361906998,
0.0110578062,
0.002195105,
0.0140856709,
-0.0204630736,
-0.0495353043,
0.0233315565,
-0.0381640568,
0.0125181135,
-0.0798067674,
0.0857405886,
0.0413968377,
-0.0133472858,
-0.0593161322,
-0.0008301509,
0.0419982821,
0.0715647042,
-0.0642380193,
-0.072021313,
0.0553712808,
-0.0197373163,
-0.0096911658,
0.0356445722,
0.0024266047,
-0.0344910137,
0.0922615454,
0.0000931365,
0.0079521881,
-0.01100659,
0.0179089829,
-0.0494084917,
-0.034337651,
0.0386901572,
-0.0043629543,
0.0610927045,
-0.075789623,
-0.0126594249,
-0.0132784564,
-0.0162661988,
-0.034254469,
0.0242638588,
-0.0475734882,
-0.0014045527,
-0.0480961464,
-0.0094924131,
-0.0067446935,
0.0233067572,
0.0294189174,
0.0181087162,
0.0182858575,
0.0005853856,
-0.0245266035,
0.0214004163,
0.0490415916,
0.0559552088,
0.0102019804,
-0.0237314925,
0.055143442,
0.043937251,
0.0158745907,
-0.01752479,
-0.0488081798,
0.0532315373,
-0.0192379206,
0.0649353862,
0.0287406836,
0.016616594,
0.0613019913,
-0.0835145786,
0.0052502356,
0.0541420728,
0.0082916766,
0.0111412359,
-0.0313470922,
-0.021816276,
0.0239122435,
0.0499567538,
0.031182006,
-0.0813240781,
-0.0651682615,
0.0006497913,
0.0103944456,
0.0376849025,
-0.0022073479,
-0.0393179543,
-0.0634818822,
0.1073149741,
-0.0075938753,
0.0102294665,
-0.0361316241,
0.0100423936,
-0.0159070101,
0.0026013579,
-0.0487372428,
0.0064527928,
0.0182558484,
0.0145655293,
-0.0121311769,
0.0160675403,
0.0000160896,
0.0137438038,
-0.0332812816,
-0.0143780895,
0.0399007387,
0.0091894194,
0.0476351008,
-0.0697913021,
0.0154862562,
-0.011196523,
0.0189432465,
-0.0024210471,
0.0693477094,
0.0370013677,
-0.0533970334,
-0.0224698074,
0.0444913208,
-0.0228624921,
-0.0388787612,
-0.0269767847,
0.0596159585,
-0.0220323689,
-0.0189559143,
-0.0254963208,
0.0132800443,
-0.0439933762,
0.0369888321,
0.0368017107,
0.0114463745,
-0.0752437711,
-0.0369668193,
-0.0261012595,
-0.0830328539,
-0.031556014,
0.007591425,
0.0310501233,
-0.0171307214,
-0.0577120744,
0.000753451,
0.0585344881,
0.0689343363,
-0.044501964,
-0.0524117202,
-0.0016200987,
0.0075730141,
-0.0586811453,
0.0806907639,
-0.0032715856,
0.034914732,
-0.0047247633,
0.0153529393,
-0.0019143232,
-0.0576313324,
-0.0110985758,
0.0181717537,
-0.0290416144,
-0.0308905393,
-0.0358633585,
0.0842180401,
0.0220016651,
0.0444680788,
0.0070989719,
-0.0215938073,
-0.0135211051,
0.0293341596,
0.0372566618,
-0.0243152305,
0.017292928,
-0.029492097,
-0.0080891745,
0.0242824089,
-0.0171171837,
0.0262728259,
0.0159436576,
0.0194776189,
-0.0158889256,
0.0173211396,
0.0234068558,
0.0026912149,
0.0327076986,
0.0150428433,
-0.0020274925,
-0.0370693356,
0.018830264,
-0.0134522254,
-0.0282904636,
-0.0913917646,
0.0427526236,
-0.0002271022,
-0.0201346539,
0.0345354863,
-0.0212038253,
-0.0059981514,
0.0029198059,
-0.0119392378,
0.0024124368,
0.0235480405,
0.0079306923,
0.0068395762,
-0.0101264697,
0.025691364,
0.0236679632,
-0.0238235258,
0.0379121155,
-0.003493093,
0.0698529929,
0.0356460437,
-0.0081057223,
-0.0532701798,
0.0118797142,
-0.0553040318,
-0.1006308421,
0.0278452281,
0.0175749902,
0.0373070873,
0.0335930027,
0.004383829,
0.0178280268,
-0.02480435,
0.0178146381,
0.0554709509,
0.0589888096,
-0.0349306725,
0.045792494,
0.0400019139,
-0.001008703,
-0.0655837357,
0.0405214615,
-0.0211362373,
0.0199963432,
-0.0217468888,
-0.0112977568,
-0.0393030085,
-0.0541124642,
-0.0233192332,
0.0017237278,
0.0161688961,
0.0362847373,
-0.039555613,
-0.0688023418,
-0.0389256403,
0.0510920137,
-0.0195386484,
0.0419563837,
0.0251886304,
0.0350965969,
0.0324395895,
-0.0386183485,
0.0162797682,
-0.0120406654,
-0.0216901898,
-0.0134484163,
0.0295587592,
-5.755687968e-33,
-0.0135578122,
-0.0447542109,
0.0651820451,
-0.0230992697,
0.0231047105,
-0.0023362814,
-0.0482118241,
-0.0168267526,
-0.0243539065,
0.0467395,
0.0237006787,
0.0040081423,
-0.0003779592,
0.0317702219,
-0.0199989155,
-0.0090922248,
0.021038739,
0.0305992793,
-0.0288714692,
-0.0084597412,
0.0273446813,
-0.0288328528,
-0.0045344378,
-0.0243551321,
-0.0436565503,
0.0372681133,
-0.0419821888,
0.0686392039,
-0.0298351254,
0.0588669889,
0.0151168145,
-0.0235062242,
0.0295688696,
0.0012341411,
-0.0188002381,
0.0129751638,
-0.1010410413,
-0.0144550866,
0.0244172271,
-0.0017489087,
-0.1103655323,
0.0006313777,
0.0244092681,
-0.0058664982,
0.0410917588,
-0.0704060793,
0.0355323628,
-0.0327969268,
0.0060653542,
0.0068395426,
-0.0065236343,
0.0081066722,
-0.0463403352,
-0.069528535,
0.0406293906,
0.0497464538,
0.0342404731,
0.0385928601,
-0.0096150935,
0.0217650998,
0.0080385283,
-0.0421340801,
0.1038790867,
0.0213772859,
-0.003797102,
0.0359446891,
0.0323393308,
-0.0496860035,
-0.0732805133,
0.0007662964,
-0.0344883278,
0.1212189645,
0.0818483979,
0.0361696407,
0.0053836089,
0.031653855,
-0.0574258789,
0.0288788024,
-0.0732405558,
0.0603247248,
-0.0059058387,
0.0033688354,
0.0237919707,
-0.0015884455,
-0.0480905846,
-0.020588614,
-0.0532343574,
0.0100810612,
0.045989342,
0.0311297271,
-0.0465373807,
0.015167919,
0.0238670502,
-0.0364429504,
0.0280060582,
0.0233515874,
-0.0186035205,
0.0323627815,
0.0136860982,
0.0398618542,
0.0147677157,
0.0137693156,
0.0755208433,
0.0030586256,
-0.0042276033,
0.0270386487,
0.0420821272,
-0.0010532403,
-0.0356354751,
0.0130822621,
-0.0770885795,
0.0288380571,
-0.0334622525,
0.0169025455,
-0.0054922872,
0.0287082251,
-0.0508204699,
0.0079949573,
-0.0147871245,
-0.0005888349,
-0.0031100363,
-0.005298268,
-0.0137917483,
0.0231287368,
-0.0056135328,
-0.0184528865,
-0.0562267862,
-0.0258206781,
0.0234966017,
-0.033746589,
-0.0177381374,
0.055048801,
2.458e-7,
0.0159331802,
0.014196123,
0.0159716737,
0.0362992063,
0.0006188767,
0.0429368466,
-0.0136637185,
-0.0265195221,
0.0014601663,
-0.043409612,
-0.0256329197,
0.0825557485,
0.0309757125,
0.0216069743,
0.0233467184,
0.0522942282,
-0.0035309193,
-0.0598694049,
-0.0780895725,
0.0095919492,
0.0807237774,
0.0385374501,
-0.0150481183,
-0.0213829,
0.0735641792,
-0.0319896229,
0.0376499556,
-0.0219937768,
0.0076754577,
-0.0148149645,
0.0101039223,
0.0064787823,
0.0094958087,
0.0166302286,
-0.0084866239,
-0.0316799618,
0.0000502636,
0.0361688435,
-0.0192310717,
-0.0270855762,
-0.0292639509,
-0.0014418646,
0.0087903682,
-0.0591065958,
0.0946602002,
-0.0260692686,
-0.0118825668,
-0.0012908545,
-0.0148825673,
0.0069739586,
-0.0006791354,
0.0028342188,
-0.0154317394,
0.006734754,
0.0165766422,
-0.0403213948,
0.0046234978,
-0.0756289363,
-0.0270631332,
-0.0293170977,
0.006475029,
0.0078843059,
-0.038764596,
-0.0044469982,
0.0545046851,
-0.0050403359,
-0.0689189211,
2.021129834e-34,
0.0232518185,
0.0145427985,
0.0136385867,
0.0035550878,
0.0661193356,
-0.0133507401,
-0.0329848379,
-0.0078032496,
0.0006573269,
-0.0523367152,
-0.0122262454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19928v1 | Interactive Topic Models with Optimal Transport | 2024-06-28T13:57:27 | 2024-06-28T13:57:27 | Garima Dhanania, Sheshera Mysore, Chau Minh Pham, Mohit Iyyer, Hamed Zamani, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR | Topic models are widely used to analyze document collections. While they are
valuable for discovering latent topics in a corpus when analysts are unfamiliar
with the corpus, analysts also commonly start with an understanding of the
content present in a corpus. This may be through categories obtained from an
initial pass over the corpus or a desire to analyze the corpus through a
predefined set of categories derived from a high level theoretical framework
(e.g. political ideology). In these scenarios analysts desire a topic modeling
approach which incorporates their understanding of the corpus while supporting
various forms of interaction with the model. In this work, we present EdTM, as
an approach for label name supervised topic modeling. EdTM models topic
modeling as an assignment problem while leveraging LM/LLM based document-topic
affinities and using optimal transport for making globally coherent
topic-assignments. In experiments, we show the efficacy of our framework
compared to few-shot LLM classifiers, and topic models based on clustering and
LDA. Further, we show EdTM's ability to incorporate various forms of analyst
feedback and while remaining robust to noisy analyst inputs. | [
0.036438942,
0.0069059255,
-0.0178987384,
0.0062033762,
-0.0307284351,
0.016194893,
0.0277483799,
-0.0139928572,
-0.0337501802,
-0.0383481495,
0.0237020385,
0.0065334877,
-0.0444552265,
0.0252878703,
-0.021421548,
-0.0568066388,
0.0023748339,
-0.0273212809,
0.0312010646,
0.0027139471,
0.0138005028,
-0.0160707515,
-0.0098645855,
-0.0084080007,
0.0040236292,
0.0108307004,
-0.0329439156,
-0.0204337109,
-0.0104335183,
-0.0173265748,
0.001525627,
0.0497387312,
0.0184894055,
-0.0255664662,
0.0000019759,
-0.0412995294,
-0.0478948914,
-0.0310594421,
0.0461730212,
-0.0294197258,
0.1221479177,
-0.0201865528,
0.0265644398,
-0.0051894486,
0.0317726322,
0.0261535402,
0.0434085615,
0.069840759,
0.0576482043,
0.0400470085,
-0.0301191993,
-0.0347901545,
0.0209849179,
-0.0081965532,
0.0658120811,
-0.0518533513,
0.0476281755,
0.0207443405,
-0.0189663935,
0.0954266712,
-0.0100167235,
0.0162307508,
-0.0477227606,
-0.0259345006,
0.0959049314,
0.004771316,
0.0185202342,
-0.0284609124,
0.0021773467,
0.0700478256,
0.0522167347,
0.0026084317,
0.0523929894,
-0.0148741473,
-0.035691157,
0.0375612713,
-0.0405996144,
-0.0110573275,
-0.0115328357,
-0.0079261251,
0.0636795834,
-0.0182243381,
0.0118248817,
0.0306239091,
-0.0068552615,
0.0562310703,
-0.003712195,
-0.0266750995,
0.0066839173,
0.0390919261,
0.008246541,
-0.0638298243,
0.0350878462,
0.0414978527,
0.0105508659,
0.0447599404,
-0.0108418576,
-0.0332415178,
-0.0021582309,
-0.0592705384,
-0.0270732585,
-0.0040360573,
-0.0076996973,
0.0667153522,
0.0530753136,
-0.0140156187,
-0.0248659234,
-0.0305428654,
-0.0286330916,
-0.0268498119,
-0.046599146,
0.005315851,
-0.0113943182,
0.0419731177,
0.0046012746,
0.0166445058,
-0.0166701842,
0.0604434013,
0.0057740421,
-0.0099160345,
-0.0264552832,
-0.0323169157,
-0.0389510989,
-0.0064151832,
-0.0539942384,
0.0131159471,
-0.043642994,
0.0569896922,
-0.0373890996,
0.0843010545,
0.0237991642,
0.0532421581,
-0.0089632794,
-0.0109779555,
0.0047485363,
0.0431571603,
-0.0057283933,
-0.0476055034,
-0.0713650659,
0.0039541931,
-0.0129303718,
-0.0094672423,
0.0466877446,
-0.0782679766,
0.0063795173,
-0.0004436449,
0.0004316519,
-0.0284311548,
-0.0099550821,
-0.0086586708,
-0.0514043905,
0.0614096783,
-0.0010889155,
0.0238752626,
0.1178305522,
0.0112475082,
-0.0026671959,
0.0285951458,
0.0047847652,
0.0489151217,
0.0374540277,
-0.0178619642,
0.0482532084,
-0.0062693246,
0.004137218,
0.0661223903,
-0.0152144292,
0.0057313386,
-0.0429429337,
0.0264708027,
0.0372338742,
0.0204150043,
-0.0098982174,
0.0085891383,
0.0187680703,
0.0672229752,
0.0255162194,
-0.0007978394,
-0.0135054719,
0.035780482,
-0.047342971,
-0.0101260776,
0.0585256144,
0.0246600527,
-0.0002466441,
-0.0331261158,
0.0610645302,
-0.0223335195,
-0.0434249863,
-0.0372264832,
-0.0202808045,
0.0114303427,
-0.0531632639,
-0.0333230719,
0.0888294205,
-0.0228459146,
0.0325921252,
0.0559327416,
0.0503449142,
0.0015834789,
0.0068964013,
-0.0257929135,
0.0596166775,
0.0205724854,
0.0212160349,
-0.0381352007,
-0.0425674208,
-0.027893398,
0.0533412769,
0.0126556326,
-0.0071664755,
-0.022402985,
-0.0353031978,
-0.0047229403,
-0.0141039928,
0.0195362829,
0.013109033,
0.0407697782,
-0.0224026367,
0.0214994773,
-0.0044636084,
-0.0809083879,
0.0244494528,
0.064743191,
-0.0022538046,
-0.0121646654,
0.0603663437,
-0.0094370879,
0.0590709038,
0.0029964254,
0.0073951231,
-0.0385314673,
0.0343996771,
-0.0096620331,
-0.0209183265,
-0.0433967076,
0.0227435082,
0.0198282897,
0.020221334,
-0.0298106782,
0.0175161175,
-0.0459717251,
-0.0311293956,
-0.0280500483,
0.0304723382,
-0.0116118472,
-0.0478130355,
-0.0337009579,
0.0142072076,
-0.0138660809,
-0.0225873925,
-0.0617211945,
0.074011296,
0.0052832398,
0.0472036488,
0.0179969091,
-0.015182497,
-0.0029508993,
-0.0213013347,
0.0104331346,
0.0155651197,
0.028310243,
0.0260835793,
0.0137988618,
-0.0098958993,
0.0161331091,
-0.0578179881,
-0.0410593674,
0.0084027536,
-0.0058159325,
0.004396854,
-0.0009088708,
-0.0015540285,
-0.0129181864,
0.0288491212,
-0.0252998676,
-0.0200538654,
-0.0354492366,
-0.0081210379,
0.0495423451,
0.0091385329,
0.0028438312,
-0.0281867832,
0.0069086016,
-0.0123702297,
0.015125487,
0.030991964,
-0.0614508055,
-0.0301947929,
0.0115497895,
-0.0254334062,
-0.0283050071,
-0.0199975055,
0.0350070186,
-0.023320362,
-0.0262457579,
0.0311279502,
0.0057477751,
0.0113941953,
0.0490702167,
0.0519519858,
-0.0324902907,
-0.036459323,
-0.0013991776,
-0.0320854075,
0.0195050165,
-0.023484461,
-0.0635963753,
0.0630514845,
0.0897310078,
-0.0200423524,
0.0072635217,
-0.0249654613,
-0.0164490342,
-0.0374004506,
0.0095276404,
-0.083896853,
0.0057834894,
0.0034660043,
0.0250112861,
0.0023221124,
-0.0096411351,
0.0596759245,
-0.0324481428,
0.0309637599,
-0.0498436056,
-0.049969364,
-0.0745117888,
0.0342895836,
-0.0155377472,
-0.0064009032,
0.0075536883,
-0.0211230423,
0.0009523447,
0.0141881863,
0.0277802665,
0.0013294601,
0.0276014693,
-0.0320367068,
0.0374867618,
-0.0101697687,
0.0037295152,
0.0030394613,
-0.0796968192,
0.0215352494,
-0.016612662,
0.0242813956,
-0.0101453327,
-0.0450306572,
0.0753079727,
0.0583641976,
-0.0315628797,
0.0088272616,
-0.0321657583,
-0.0093805427,
0.0506971814,
0.0517111607,
-0.0506655425,
-0.0726809353,
-0.0104910908,
-0.0049372488,
0.007348232,
0.0037139771,
0.0021331608,
-0.0284896325,
0.0474602953,
0.010818013,
-0.0426678769,
-0.0344768502,
-0.0256584529,
0.0192163382,
-0.0059651127,
0.0158549249,
0.0887141749,
0.0444283113,
-0.0854812786,
-0.0381887294,
0.0020192242,
0.0055969623,
-0.0058683278,
0.0565187559,
-0.0481123179,
0.0202882327,
0.0191801712,
0.0375324488,
-0.007058966,
-0.047025986,
-0.0102640865,
-0.0449428372,
0.0310204122,
-0.007264982,
-0.0076150629,
0.0192470253,
-0.1034624502,
0.0195478853,
-0.0272461344,
-0.0541323125,
-0.0127900057,
0.004659506,
-0.0033020503,
0.0551416166,
-0.0252798107,
-0.0163770039,
-0.0102531472,
-0.0006211844,
0.0408843867,
-0.0082030036,
0.0328203626,
-0.0251404382,
-0.000236947,
-0.0015460929,
-0.0089861574,
-0.0310156792,
-0.0026983668,
0.0250691697,
-0.0383174457,
0.0048185252,
0.0087088561,
0.0088316007,
-0.0067318985,
-0.0199221428,
0.0391945243,
0.0719357133,
-0.041128695,
0.0106877368,
-0.051704675,
-0.0185984839,
0.0224774983,
0.0481142104,
-0.0021372517,
-0.0660077408,
0.041110944,
-0.0370185934,
0.0121442983,
0.0676859692,
0.0062423446,
-0.0348044783,
-0.0971656442,
-0.088792704,
-0.0694063529,
-0.0194421969,
0.0211258531,
0.0385092497,
0.0043934355,
0.0357958972,
0.0006856957,
-0.0096947886,
-0.034191668,
0.0522132069,
-0.0373494849,
-0.0052585364,
-0.0392522737,
-0.036757078,
0.0940104574,
-0.0156291034,
-0.0324677117,
-0.0220672339,
-0.0418328568,
-0.0552666783,
-0.0066295466,
-0.0406227559,
0.017052561,
-0.0000532199,
-0.0590613559,
-0.0847491845,
0.0366026387,
0.0658362806,
-0.0446748659,
0.0124763409,
-0.0133594777,
0.0077629685,
0.0000327061,
-0.0145161794,
-0.0513360985,
0.0830040276,
-0.0160391536,
0.0031984062,
-0.1144570485,
-0.0599546917,
-0.0250558183,
-0.0031087357,
0.0825153142,
0.0282106791,
-0.0533291698,
-0.0533767715,
0.003732742,
0.0271189697,
-0.0370246358,
0.002861141,
-0.0101571353,
0.0368652344,
-0.0123695396,
-0.0472333282,
0.0230215937,
-0.021517057,
0.0470575579,
0.0196393337,
0.0071289502,
0.0054451237,
0.0470749401,
-0.0297635701,
0.0353089869,
0.0006101057,
-0.0250484012,
0.0097614434,
0.0339993797,
0.0006860856,
0.0347285196,
0.0173361078,
0.0273560677,
0.0256118719,
-0.0270035248,
-0.0624491312,
0.0177195948,
-0.0378753133,
0.0847039521,
0.0110064289,
0.0281991251,
-0.016285697,
-0.0290054381,
-0.0216776561,
-0.0191805623,
0.0273931473,
0.0098858662,
-0.0109964749,
0.0501521416,
0.0367312692,
-0.0263199266,
0.0205798969,
0.0458158925,
0.0346676037,
-0.012145659,
0.0012240958,
-0.0361530147,
-0.0425756313,
0.0424682721,
0.0428005122,
-0.0172869377,
0.0090754339,
0.007811205,
-0.0304720961,
-0.0027338541,
0.0858580992,
-0.0836244971,
-0.0215329938,
-0.0129633881,
0.0367575996,
0.1003981531,
0.0008012187,
0.03349654,
-0.0706101954,
0.0035840841,
-0.0468496084,
-0.0494227596,
0.0056824437,
-6.608662301e-33,
-0.052761022,
-0.0502379611,
0.0348534174,
0.0226878189,
0.0087717231,
-0.005402063,
-0.0130340606,
0.0182122812,
0.0187929459,
0.0017197176,
-0.0137397051,
0.031770315,
0.0100580435,
-0.0032956572,
0.018061148,
-0.0056062299,
0.0103244288,
0.0147504807,
-0.0173197296,
0.0424436927,
0.0243707001,
0.0310961902,
0.0168620944,
-0.0878751129,
0.0575309172,
-0.0086284708,
-0.0190037284,
0.0048710364,
0.0833606794,
0.046078641,
-0.0418454185,
0.0174784213,
0.0293914676,
-0.0247355495,
0.0171074215,
0.0391785093,
-0.0201922152,
-0.0650606602,
-0.0233081225,
-0.0159693994,
0.0133995516,
-0.057006035,
0.0347277075,
0.040700078,
0.0053782705,
0.0298192091,
0.0930253193,
-0.0162003674,
-0.0454312414,
-0.0525328256,
-0.0045905951,
0.045557797,
-0.0241401047,
0.0293745864,
0.0319322422,
-0.0224327408,
0.0189060587,
0.0392623432,
-0.0052642268,
0.038265001,
0.0265614465,
0.0184588283,
0.0133418171,
-0.0094272718,
0.0044425433,
0.0298974998,
-0.0268216189,
0.0199770667,
-0.0301778354,
-0.006088506,
0.0202312861,
0.0349882208,
0.0248558614,
0.0296997204,
-0.0276990999,
0.0094109913,
-0.0195456762,
0.0591672212,
-0.0024133699,
-0.0086821383,
0.0016581991,
0.0245178789,
-0.0437719375,
-0.0342021398,
-0.0318402573,
0.0039311009,
-0.0282110535,
-0.0254916586,
-0.0106097059,
0.0043727448,
-0.0498449467,
-0.0064489455,
0.0192905199,
0.0083615342,
-0.0424606614,
-0.0255625434,
-0.0272936765,
0.0615915321,
0.0020870578,
0.0139782056,
-0.0958223119,
-0.0542519167,
-0.0189628154,
-0.014503465,
-0.0121940216,
-0.011770417,
-0.002434335,
-0.035031274,
-0.051534187,
-0.0192654692,
0.0113545014,
-0.025184866,
-0.0294367317,
0.0349952877,
-0.0137944715,
0.0166456159,
0.0038522219,
0.0755012929,
0.0564867072,
0.038283769,
0.0154216448,
-0.0470950902,
-0.0422975123,
0.0219061133,
-0.0261196289,
-0.0085168723,
0.0151023073,
0.0214181021,
0.0553204156,
-0.0585000776,
-0.0129465861,
-0.0337463208,
2.832e-7,
0.0420813188,
0.0610279068,
-0.0395681933,
-0.0003489154,
0.0027077445,
0.0319972821,
-0.0199258253,
0.0241829026,
-0.0016362516,
-0.0442700535,
0.0316766389,
0.0046743052,
0.0222605914,
0.0494255349,
-0.0878454819,
-0.0134377237,
-0.0240603387,
0.0165062472,
-0.0669389963,
0.0094155427,
-0.0066700876,
0.0447157361,
0.0529077463,
0.0051278812,
-0.038982898,
-0.0511447042,
0.0627011359,
-0.0567836426,
-0.0413582772,
0.0436165072,
0.069949612,
0.0238608681,
-0.0213513356,
-0.011316889,
0.0056587588,
-0.0013873195,
0.0088922679,
0.0667729005,
0.0012698327,
-0.0351693891,
-0.0288169757,
-0.0032109278,
0.0048610754,
0.0112705771,
0.0381176285,
-0.0203281827,
-0.0048047686,
-0.0254186075,
-0.0314866081,
-0.0077564912,
0.0216580257,
0.0042185565,
-0.0029928447,
-0.0012901509,
-0.0111892652,
-0.0209227689,
0.0016099324,
-0.0481028594,
0.0353601947,
0.0139088938,
-0.0179435499,
-0.0229716692,
0.0113445865,
0.036417596,
0.0386044122,
-0.051901944,
0.0271392409,
2.279128803e-34,
0.0261717327,
-0.0119055193,
-0.0694296807,
0.0032232963,
0.0031886981,
0.0180801153,
-0.0734183639,
0.0156666022,
0.0043353769,
-0.083545953,
0.0424158387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19898v1 | Paraphrase Types Elicit Prompt Engineering Capabilities | 2024-06-28T13:06:31 | 2024-06-28T13:06:31 | Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Yang Xu, Bela Gipp | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much of the success of modern language models depends on finding a suitable
prompt to instruct the model. Until now, it has been largely unknown how
variations in the linguistic expression of prompts affect these models. This
study systematically and empirically evaluates which linguistic features
influence models through paraphrase types, i.e., different linguistic changes
at particular positions. We measure behavioral changes for five models across
120 tasks and six families of paraphrases (i.e., morphology, syntax, lexicon,
lexico-syntax, discourse, and others). We also control for other prompt
engineering factors (e.g., prompt length, lexical diversity, and proximity to
training data). Our results show a potential for language models to improve
tasks when their prompts are adapted in specific paraphrase types (e.g., 6.7%
median gain in Mixtral 8x7B; 5.5% in LLaMA 3 8B). In particular, changes in
morphology and lexicon, i.e., the vocabulary used, showed promise in improving
prompts. These findings contribute to developing more robust language models
capable of handling variability in linguistic expression. | [
0.0899611041,
0.0086769629,
-0.0467295125,
0.0064961924,
-0.0767973363,
-0.0134954117,
0.0174127985,
0.0136984214,
-0.0301072933,
-0.0526134707,
-0.0211270116,
-0.0239894092,
0.0059444979,
0.0079565439,
0.0558225885,
-0.0791591257,
0.0571643859,
-0.0796894133,
0.0178460144,
-0.0012860243,
-0.0025725882,
0.0263378173,
-0.0105437664,
0.0519427955,
0.0044597518,
0.0025792993,
-0.0198694691,
0.0184385516,
-0.0248431489,
-0.0111759035,
0.0249736831,
0.0480420217,
-0.0068410691,
-0.0006557042,
0.0000018216,
-0.0763005912,
0.0237831436,
-0.0409726426,
-0.0429936498,
0.037978597,
0.0876547694,
-0.0105907973,
0.003098672,
0.0174569488,
-0.0101153236,
-0.0138532333,
0.0284043774,
0.0147610363,
0.0225662794,
0.0226239618,
0.0039739455,
0.0014397673,
-0.0147718741,
-0.0016070491,
-0.0167028774,
0.0030460714,
0.0026057437,
-0.0381662808,
0.0368193164,
0.0537917316,
-0.0195342973,
0.0522303879,
-0.0111460788,
0.0190406106,
-0.007749754,
0.0124786515,
0.0213205069,
-0.0335136913,
-0.0532396063,
0.0301223081,
0.0195198357,
-0.0177778676,
-0.0216289833,
-0.0361191221,
0.0456412099,
0.0398716331,
-0.0488260202,
0.0270668268,
0.0001984915,
-0.0029146078,
0.0276871417,
-0.0024537302,
-0.0421313047,
0.0134124905,
0.0185803454,
0.0568872169,
0.0383346751,
-0.0283787921,
-0.0102313152,
-0.0001302514,
-0.025949087,
-0.0615361817,
0.0071717366,
-0.0075729117,
-0.0375858806,
0.0413337424,
-0.0411317423,
-0.0417190157,
0.0554553121,
-0.0030884116,
0.0645994842,
0.0237956624,
-0.0296092518,
0.0107502742,
-0.0150705753,
0.0769989789,
-0.0104238223,
0.0510729812,
-0.0451173708,
-0.010034862,
-0.0353627093,
-0.0340707414,
-0.0554412119,
0.0036579405,
-0.0182396136,
-0.0129714189,
-0.0337319113,
0.0314170457,
0.0546230972,
-0.0290186163,
0.018564146,
0.0271430183,
-0.0615187734,
0.008990014,
-0.0350814052,
-0.0053165886,
-0.050118722,
0.0499949083,
0.0300976411,
-0.0780354738,
-0.0193987768,
0.0037719449,
0.0264037289,
-0.0588210151,
-0.023355823,
0.03873327,
-0.018326547,
-0.0444200672,
-0.0092235552,
-0.0207934659,
-0.0784013793,
-0.027488023,
-0.0175114535,
-0.0458011664,
0.0141549055,
0.0065692831,
-0.006167768,
-0.034679167,
-0.0025321227,
0.0146720111,
-0.0587821156,
0.0610792153,
0.0033468944,
0.0247840453,
0.0066847685,
-0.0363926925,
-0.044738695,
0.0223767031,
0.0112546841,
-0.0141946459,
0.0527143404,
0.0047392659,
-0.0157254077,
0.0382712744,
-0.003652625,
-0.0076410421,
-0.0275134239,
0.0031211409,
0.0364719145,
0.013795292,
0.0389499366,
0.0688456744,
-0.004609108,
-0.014731233,
0.0887144655,
0.0757155269,
-0.0074642161,
-0.0123205688,
0.0775526613,
0.0252547022,
0.0009857134,
0.0240898244,
-0.0425029024,
-0.0212812014,
-0.0106683169,
0.0510876887,
-0.0187336896,
0.037082646,
-0.006362468,
-0.0506538972,
-0.0630996451,
0.0085191829,
-0.0084115332,
-0.0019792421,
-0.0044177789,
0.0442658477,
-0.029735202,
0.0495947599,
0.0157961231,
-0.0623985454,
-0.0270320196,
-0.0512797609,
0.0466472581,
0.0595203154,
0.0339134,
-0.0034689566,
-0.01946868,
0.0040492513,
0.0233163647,
0.0581386387,
0.0633399263,
-0.0027070227,
0.016573308,
-0.0232394077,
0.0031299018,
-0.0299409106,
0.024395965,
-0.0165807717,
0.0196933467,
-0.0252783354,
-0.0078491271,
-0.0132216392,
-0.043393705,
0.0466699749,
-0.0327568278,
-0.0244817417,
-0.019818034,
-0.0037090154,
-0.0060742712,
0.0011419369,
0.005477929,
0.0456506833,
0.0083723851,
-0.023322925,
0.0120885968,
0.0308871176,
-0.0718038306,
-0.0342637897,
0.023400072,
0.0314905681,
0.0035519025,
-0.0155745605,
0.0263323896,
-0.0365274809,
0.0001675636,
-0.0788520202,
0.0493284687,
-0.0398186482,
0.0516430028,
-0.0394559987,
0.0068721101,
-0.0610324107,
0.0501698703,
0.0225680061,
0.0119459406,
0.0572544038,
-0.0079695182,
-0.0031822007,
-0.0247708894,
-0.0112044411,
0.0033189699,
0.0069212196,
-0.0042790994,
0.034125682,
-0.0049908031,
-0.0509406738,
-0.048068855,
-0.0844847634,
-0.0195816103,
-0.0229716618,
-0.0169836003,
0.0474276617,
0.0080055771,
-0.0220516156,
-0.0099548399,
-0.0127002886,
-0.0248272736,
-0.006159422,
0.044527892,
0.0498346239,
0.0362423509,
-0.0427378677,
-0.0699194744,
-0.0128845889,
-0.0197894052,
0.0399595089,
0.0208838806,
-0.0084819356,
-0.0456419252,
0.050694596,
0.0003965967,
-0.0223311093,
-0.0040403549,
-0.0276246238,
0.0227083992,
0.0069605117,
0.0895553753,
0.0514522679,
0.0202224348,
-0.019123707,
0.0421323702,
-0.0222273376,
-0.0694492385,
-0.0197637435,
-0.0087345429,
-0.0476744771,
-0.030312432,
-0.0661803782,
0.005692557,
0.0670566708,
0.05454107,
0.005787632,
-0.0760002509,
0.0281156655,
-0.0370709188,
-0.0434721969,
0.0004727933,
-0.0439565405,
-0.0677909851,
0.0521286763,
-0.0332060866,
-0.0411059633,
0.0802415013,
-0.0360481814,
-0.020361241,
-0.0574059412,
0.0011557324,
-0.0341445692,
0.0228004754,
-0.0327679962,
0.012827998,
0.0577820204,
-0.0531837121,
-0.0609655939,
-0.0240882114,
0.0282566249,
-0.0029489307,
0.0630878583,
-0.0875991732,
-0.0081121512,
0.0304449014,
-0.0520851873,
-0.0337669887,
-0.0605447739,
-0.0002713811,
0.0393589921,
0.0352329835,
0.022141559,
0.0260527115,
-0.0229673292,
0.013116695,
0.0518099964,
-0.0442966968,
0.0003847918,
-0.0572224036,
0.017542161,
0.0569294505,
0.0595973954,
0.0242874213,
-0.0331077613,
0.0187902227,
-0.0241473317,
0.0147630759,
-0.0000590788,
-0.0233939197,
0.0026317143,
0.033636719,
-0.0465735607,
-0.0667550191,
0.0365748703,
0.0813355371,
-0.0236461647,
-0.0210403763,
0.0990430787,
0.0359335504,
0.0046723727,
0.0234301947,
-0.0609347001,
0.0675435662,
0.0146876741,
0.0099183703,
-0.0243284479,
-0.026430333,
0.0152942101,
0.0082456833,
-0.0157604907,
-0.0002181534,
-0.0147430031,
-0.1131270975,
0.0228775833,
-0.015812885,
-0.0223046243,
0.0135739222,
-0.0020616564,
0.0292927958,
0.0184930917,
0.0464357808,
0.0151390079,
-0.0611600205,
0.0345647186,
0.0308561642,
-0.0114462879,
-0.0284768678,
-0.0152791217,
-0.0492273457,
0.0420195796,
0.0411849692,
-0.0005152433,
-0.004697883,
-0.0138775269,
0.0335026644,
-0.0079959948,
0.0348930955,
0.0032069588,
0.0379261188,
0.0183399841,
0.0016642467,
-0.0184382461,
0.0099963341,
-0.000876974,
-0.0135411881,
0.0281745363,
0.0438839905,
0.0038189788,
-0.0082435738,
-0.0174251944,
0.0048841001,
0.0011900464,
0.094701156,
0.0641400293,
-0.051285401,
-0.0382823199,
-0.0031627824,
0.0093533909,
-0.037708763,
-0.0436283089,
-0.0153092751,
-0.013671956,
0.0167349111,
-0.0867997631,
-0.0724826828,
0.0115859676,
-0.0051684878,
0.03951158,
0.027982926,
-0.0388411172,
-0.0026455547,
0.0155740324,
0.0231923182,
0.0036635981,
0.0392787866,
-0.0596997142,
-0.0146535309,
0.0449637249,
-0.0323059708,
-0.0119732423,
0.0128463898,
-0.0469073206,
-0.0643456206,
0.0346775204,
0.0429614447,
0.0235547479,
0.0244993828,
0.0089242132,
-0.0451694205,
0.0326407775,
0.0008347745,
-0.0103065241,
0.0827738792,
0.0280581415,
0.0221449621,
-0.0092098014,
0.0447316691,
-0.0129762795,
-0.0072394768,
0.0277094897,
0.0551761463,
-0.0162715148,
-0.0832457468,
0.0367639102,
0.0191567764,
0.0399448313,
-0.0115764169,
-0.0088324556,
-0.0329743773,
-0.0042429045,
-0.0003189539,
-0.0077345604,
-0.0292957183,
0.0164290387,
0.0259613823,
0.0035212687,
-0.009822512,
-0.0000722064,
-0.0607979931,
0.0612583421,
-0.038820751,
-0.0172388908,
-0.0125330174,
0.007411866,
-0.0160447247,
0.0256548487,
-0.0283652488,
0.0255478173,
-0.0630987957,
0.0243293401,
-0.006953401,
0.0627558753,
-0.015322566,
-0.0570925847,
-0.0436793305,
0.0520520993,
-0.0653930306,
-0.0251188204,
0.0319608636,
0.033102341,
0.0040438855,
-0.0359270871,
0.0565699413,
-0.0268994365,
0.0079355091,
-0.0059929644,
0.018362429,
0.025844641,
-0.0073652244,
0.0625214502,
0.021792179,
0.0052281413,
-0.0363756791,
0.0492887273,
0.0356201567,
0.0227185506,
-0.0114179011,
0.0134611344,
-0.028422419,
-0.0289831124,
0.0421386957,
0.0094923275,
-0.0173210651,
0.0200783927,
-0.0799989179,
-0.0237405617,
0.0306489058,
-0.0005083648,
0.0005193567,
-0.0500117876,
0.0597628355,
0.0617667846,
-0.0240702108,
-0.0733642653,
-0.0470118858,
0.0241997279,
0.03602143,
0.0013865893,
-0.0769152418,
-5.724146883e-33,
-0.0469981022,
0.0040635634,
-0.0005866265,
-0.028590234,
-0.0001233376,
-0.0068416069,
-0.021595113,
0.0314258859,
-0.0104759233,
-0.0174303241,
-0.0501891933,
0.0155568486,
0.0263060872,
0.0059736343,
0.0581098124,
-0.005666947,
0.0527135804,
-0.0205891039,
-0.0354890637,
-0.0277849175,
0.0191951375,
0.0077937087,
0.0414786749,
-0.0078806682,
0.0487613492,
-0.0051810015,
0.0119374134,
-0.0242744274,
-0.0258172676,
0.0634731427,
-0.0016878732,
0.0436404236,
0.0150905149,
-0.0406037606,
-0.060758587,
0.0553119294,
-0.0359238163,
-0.0316648334,
0.1021426991,
-0.0026821513,
-0.0565626882,
-0.0935042799,
-0.0031830564,
-0.053076718,
-0.0371909179,
0.0126146544,
0.0285631865,
-0.0265820231,
0.0016414996,
0.0612595938,
-0.0513377637,
-0.0177804157,
0.003744663,
-0.0143357236,
-0.0127094984,
0.0787841901,
-0.0186899472,
0.0191193186,
0.0073065199,
0.044925116,
0.0199827161,
0.0393744297,
0.0202231761,
0.0233717263,
-0.0089001628,
0.0280503128,
0.0058786627,
0.0101143857,
0.0173174813,
-0.0161819924,
0.0411442369,
0.0201898981,
0.0375017226,
0.0469249934,
-0.0037804593,
0.0246776566,
0.0152473096,
-0.0384722538,
0.0404087603,
0.0191065408,
0.0387162529,
-0.0159311201,
-0.0411999151,
-0.0345330574,
-0.0528783128,
0.0048424625,
-0.0110620381,
-0.0204911698,
0.0587730967,
0.0067597581,
-0.020404065,
-0.0124381501,
0.0426832922,
-0.0080824634,
-0.0233770795,
-0.0007243324,
-0.0266040284,
0.0387443602,
0.0127861993,
0.0320253149,
-0.0386537425,
0.0127394879,
0.0217221603,
0.0318485238,
0.0309722573,
0.0206981525,
-0.0008799924,
0.0084657324,
-0.0648640245,
0.0117243035,
-0.0239479281,
0.0011961844,
-0.0428521149,
-0.0304699633,
0.0369542912,
0.0431795083,
-0.0070181512,
0.028033467,
0.0138359582,
-0.0540444925,
-0.0462987125,
-0.0082365712,
-0.0100644846,
0.03400914,
-0.0243476462,
-0.0063151862,
-0.019761268,
0.0674658343,
-0.0010643944,
0.0092362631,
-0.0046904832,
0.0287750978,
2.553e-7,
0.0475233421,
0.0356848277,
0.0172036737,
0.0414701998,
0.012952989,
0.008015844,
0.0037444746,
0.0148589564,
0.0118214404,
-0.0128266532,
-0.0087316995,
0.0118111884,
0.0172469467,
-0.0373128578,
-0.1144269556,
-0.0067824116,
-0.0742729157,
0.0468317531,
-0.0736355707,
-0.0149252545,
0.0622956753,
0.0662719533,
-0.0261718761,
0.0021009268,
-0.0553825498,
-0.0253461078,
0.0322461762,
-0.0582566299,
-0.0186003279,
0.0265392847,
0.0229180362,
-0.0093087591,
0.0271682162,
0.0457582586,
0.0225698482,
0.0231753122,
0.0270809755,
0.0487889983,
0.0159685779,
-0.0259153191,
-0.0086248042,
-0.0203268286,
-0.024393091,
-0.0712413043,
0.0560414232,
-0.0223323405,
0.023880519,
-0.0199372731,
-0.0038667158,
0.0264223255,
0.0211004522,
-0.0584793687,
-0.0217048805,
0.0111055998,
0.0296765398,
0.0033463966,
-0.0043397676,
-0.0383980386,
-0.015444017,
0.0075923009,
-0.0173800737,
-0.0443823412,
-0.0363731086,
0.0267775748,
-0.0076818569,
-0.0803101957,
0.0030480439,
2.331519806e-34,
0.0202538185,
0.0092712743,
0.0741254613,
0.0420483015,
0.0079188664,
-0.0121533927,
0.0431760475,
0.0326140486,
0.0319699422,
-0.0665172189,
-0.0329278372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19892v1 | Untangling the Unrestricted Web: Automatic Identification of Multilingual Registers | 2024-06-28T13:00:30 | 2024-06-28T13:00:30 | Erik Henriksson, Amanda Myntti, Anni Eskelinen, Selcen Erten-Johansson, Saara Hellström, Veronika Laippala | cs.CL | cs.CL | This article explores deep learning models for the automatic identification
of registers - text varieties such as news reports and discussion forums - in
web-based datasets across 16 languages. Web register (or genre) identification
would provide a robust solution for understanding the content of web-scale
datasets, which have become crucial in computational linguistics. Despite
recent advances, the potential of register classifiers on the noisy web remains
largely unexplored, particularly in multilingual settings and when targeting
the entire unrestricted web. We experiment with a range of deep learning models
using the new Multilingual CORE corpora, which includes 16 languages annotated
using a detailed, hierarchical taxonomy of 25 registers designed to cover the
entire unrestricted web. Our models achieve state-of-the-art results, showing
that a detailed taxonomy in a hierarchical multi-label setting can yield
competitive classification performance. However, all models hit a glass ceiling
at approximately 80% F1 score, which we attribute to the non-discrete nature of
web registers and the inherent uncertainty in labeling some documents. By
pruning ambiguous examples, we improve model performance to over 90%. Finally,
multilingual models outperform monolingual ones, particularly benefiting
languages with fewer training examples and smaller registers. Although a
zero-shot setting decreases performance by an average of 7%, these drops are
not linked to specific registers or languages. Instead, registers show
surprising similarity across languages. | [
0.0256271437,
0.049826704,
-0.0133196237,
0.0475238115,
-0.0252067037,
0.0633011982,
0.0493563563,
-0.0016840885,
0.0116796205,
-0.0706995726,
-0.0344238132,
-0.0859800205,
-0.0134009505,
0.0210632719,
0.0163024813,
-0.0022980999,
0.0288556553,
-0.0295790508,
0.014367057,
0.0015841234,
0.0100175664,
0.0454190858,
-0.0015617424,
0.0231028479,
-0.0138825681,
-0.0284242257,
0.016130453,
0.0075287456,
-0.0014440569,
-0.018882202,
0.0660936162,
0.0414389744,
0.0316872112,
0.1154511347,
0.0000016405,
-0.0427375957,
-0.0138238491,
-0.036590606,
-0.0047492664,
-0.0120722596,
0.0462446101,
-0.0102655729,
-0.0119723286,
-0.0093376087,
0.0183974784,
-0.0433360636,
0.0547685623,
0.020144349,
-0.0264109932,
0.0693015158,
-0.0175845623,
-0.0517330207,
0.023224961,
-0.0052977819,
-0.0254139043,
-0.0332302712,
0.0211211462,
-0.0224195644,
-0.0271776654,
0.0024718759,
0.0094011193,
0.0117011918,
-0.0130534461,
-0.0138997482,
-0.027203694,
0.0003495891,
-0.0323334225,
-0.0341682099,
0.0144083994,
0.0835359171,
-0.0227589142,
-0.0511388257,
0.02526794,
0.0097795343,
-0.0108470991,
-0.0280716363,
-0.0221309531,
0.048771102,
-0.0209393613,
0.0031609314,
0.0501011088,
0.0187822264,
0.0455994792,
0.0350045897,
-0.0201115571,
0.0186711065,
0.0077510192,
-0.0148931583,
0.0500099361,
0.0171676017,
-0.0017003034,
-0.0413535163,
0.0208891425,
0.0091046924,
-0.0310758222,
0.033969719,
-0.0219592005,
-0.0237778332,
0.0307548605,
-0.1010917351,
-0.041213654,
-0.0077376924,
-0.0425901487,
0.066818893,
-0.0125000635,
-0.0325116292,
-0.0212703142,
0.0005387762,
0.0033685942,
-0.0386026688,
-0.0647941157,
-0.0035987613,
0.0167096406,
0.039043244,
0.0349634625,
-0.0127955396,
-0.0343947485,
0.0224697869,
-0.0154851964,
0.0285269376,
-0.0526096858,
-0.0200830176,
-0.0213552173,
0.0153035326,
0.0094309682,
0.0465323031,
-0.0191605072,
0.0143462084,
-0.0071163569,
-0.0478824526,
0.0396218896,
0.058756005,
0.0202639103,
-0.0298032705,
0.0186607931,
0.0102516217,
-0.0151538625,
-0.0139193144,
-0.04081605,
-0.017303355,
-0.0150633175,
-0.0382630974,
0.0381520875,
-0.0808693245,
0.0194201767,
0.002542323,
0.0156684462,
-0.0409299694,
-0.0022876845,
0.0098040216,
0.0028645687,
0.0571694933,
-0.0031474291,
-0.031304244,
0.0617367402,
0.0005791142,
0.006112495,
0.0829915479,
0.0001742683,
0.0331687033,
0.0820876062,
-0.0219152793,
0.0238816421,
0.0430346243,
-0.0173328742,
-0.003344194,
-0.0030209429,
-0.0262463,
-0.0086158933,
0.0056911171,
0.0165354107,
0.0275781993,
0.0035696265,
-0.0346542411,
0.025878666,
0.0508246794,
-0.0233897958,
0.0532954931,
0.0403823778,
-0.0162093695,
-0.0037517196,
0.0204379205,
0.0170735922,
-0.0281436909,
-0.003106209,
-0.0074504227,
-0.0084625473,
0.0117756072,
-0.0526553392,
-0.0182604082,
-0.0100361491,
-0.0378557257,
0.005698503,
-0.0028290483,
0.0839677826,
-0.019002568,
0.0103093004,
0.0075763753,
0.0398757495,
-0.0086647971,
0.0103327502,
-0.0376585424,
-0.0022279485,
0.0238868818,
-0.0068598017,
-0.046960149,
-0.0434030406,
-0.037716765,
0.0241790004,
0.0543050691,
0.0672991723,
-0.0286164135,
0.0147182485,
-0.0307690594,
-0.0061115841,
-0.0035224664,
0.0019726013,
0.0617278442,
-0.0324500464,
0.0296244323,
-0.0039028309,
-0.0473193377,
-0.0348278955,
0.0156912375,
-0.0185811687,
-0.0400724895,
0.0282952767,
0.0158203505,
0.0302646812,
0.0309611131,
-0.0200572386,
-0.0410974957,
0.0213289205,
-0.0322970338,
-0.0375761986,
-0.0369118378,
0.0083531989,
-0.0036739511,
0.0562170409,
-0.023288317,
-0.0279240143,
0.0264274254,
-0.0303800516,
-0.0129303942,
0.0215493962,
-0.0066431579,
0.0305447914,
-0.0262825266,
0.0004859445,
-0.0243665092,
0.0214905422,
-0.0159893762,
0.063860476,
0.0253816191,
0.0341089629,
-0.0115559287,
-0.0689172894,
0.0267522652,
-0.004326981,
-0.0333467461,
0.0267336629,
-0.0521018244,
0.0267183222,
0.0465074256,
-0.0055012349,
-0.0229255594,
0.01047807,
-0.1015851498,
-0.0076856613,
-0.0389320999,
0.0289597213,
0.001976847,
-0.011462071,
0.0127971899,
-0.0002456164,
-0.0556662045,
-0.0224547554,
-0.0393114425,
0.0330367796,
0.0274752174,
-0.0095657185,
0.0084325885,
-0.018188687,
-0.0239843354,
-0.0214284919,
0.0726990774,
-0.002455354,
-0.0646010339,
-0.0139670409,
-0.0285124108,
-0.0506947637,
-0.0004278582,
-0.0145843392,
-0.0179280601,
-0.0291398428,
0.0074633523,
-0.0317116641,
0.0164802261,
-0.0064668758,
0.0229668748,
0.0342329368,
0.0461816676,
-0.0364739895,
0.0021158135,
-0.0209608842,
0.0131352255,
-0.0241066553,
0.0026068124,
0.0292641874,
0.0600305572,
-0.0226514209,
0.0156192817,
0.0124456156,
-0.0205025785,
-0.0085070878,
0.010026617,
-0.0485355668,
0.0073212627,
0.0076940889,
0.0488118157,
0.0143840313,
0.015584995,
0.0670789629,
-0.0027799066,
0.0116419112,
-0.0669380501,
-0.0234864876,
-0.0228761118,
0.0245320089,
-0.0211679544,
0.0438320599,
0.030547224,
-0.0469986238,
-0.0181637201,
0.0234269742,
0.0139602032,
-0.027220225,
0.0212799292,
-0.0019851204,
0.0092725279,
-0.0343886688,
-0.056813471,
-0.0356308073,
-0.0357751958,
0.0009931804,
0.0122076981,
0.0285848901,
-0.0095166881,
-0.0173075311,
0.0142670479,
0.0159039479,
0.0520654134,
-0.0022674699,
0.0021019152,
-0.0051862434,
0.0786779225,
0.0405830368,
-0.0251783542,
0.0130775524,
-0.0012512802,
-0.018171031,
0.0208241418,
-0.034647394,
0.019629892,
-0.011285007,
-0.0191070493,
0.0447506718,
-0.0580269806,
-0.0374159142,
-0.0156707708,
-0.0038216081,
-0.043393027,
0.0171319935,
0.1010648608,
0.0203223303,
-0.0844695419,
-0.0181260202,
0.013197531,
0.0391170233,
0.0223403405,
0.015413899,
-0.0892766118,
-0.0049997051,
0.0173865799,
-0.0180015061,
0.0199081358,
0.0000117933,
0.0296971314,
-0.0625711605,
-0.0030404786,
-0.0202634633,
-0.0257949904,
0.0215366799,
-0.050382968,
-0.0169720817,
-0.0115238614,
-0.0109714735,
-0.0557250492,
0.0042688991,
-0.0300233569,
0.0374882184,
-0.0571225919,
-0.0856689364,
0.0367174,
-0.0132486755,
0.026089143,
0.0240158271,
0.0585821122,
-0.0561227165,
-0.0239111315,
0.0494383648,
-0.0337930061,
-0.0537934527,
-0.0320212543,
0.0654055849,
0.0039401157,
-0.0034423382,
0.0061540012,
-0.0020181155,
-0.0430237129,
0.0211977083,
-0.0091295261,
0.0609450005,
0.0077892733,
-0.0215609595,
-0.0120347664,
-0.049491886,
0.0029932673,
0.042848777,
0.0170939416,
-0.0481847972,
-0.0323793106,
-0.0477305837,
0.0054686819,
-0.0576332659,
0.0013875962,
0.022966465,
-0.0391122624,
-0.0992154777,
-0.0623355918,
-0.0478365161,
-0.0098497393,
-0.0080703134,
0.0110596344,
0.0040856516,
0.0387570225,
-0.0141652124,
-0.0696545169,
-0.0052925865,
-0.0139428843,
-0.0030844661,
-0.0469985865,
-0.0110103227,
0.0554689802,
-0.0224901866,
-0.0258575138,
-0.0198490452,
-0.0683439896,
-0.0521924458,
-0.0178084113,
-0.0215750802,
0.007660531,
0.0283594895,
-0.0163185075,
-0.0759939998,
0.0024467201,
0.0063939434,
0.0009305212,
-0.0511770919,
0.0356747098,
0.0033425211,
-0.038390547,
0.0326008014,
-0.0555833764,
0.048677586,
0.0136169801,
-0.0304262377,
-0.0458944216,
0.0114799486,
0.0043227575,
-0.0023609842,
0.0503453016,
-0.0197469369,
-0.0346302614,
-0.0408584662,
0.0023569022,
0.0534301251,
-0.0227899477,
0.0258654393,
-0.0106849158,
0.0683352947,
-0.0336039476,
-0.0252478775,
0.072844699,
0.0351650007,
0.0319274366,
-0.0389883965,
0.0075241225,
0.0416286439,
0.0330102295,
-0.0376679823,
0.0280836802,
-0.0442265645,
0.0604830384,
0.0479586311,
0.0477124155,
-0.046556402,
-0.0032249405,
0.0048538256,
0.0114360023,
0.0082180239,
0.0008034777,
-0.0065874434,
0.0081857955,
-0.0245152712,
-0.0220015887,
0.0835908651,
-0.0138430148,
0.0489971749,
-0.0059220404,
-0.0357514173,
-0.0454148799,
0.0250464603,
-0.0162836425,
-0.0270800218,
0.0073432047,
0.0052469177,
-0.0520689562,
0.032664448,
0.074304238,
0.0075200503,
0.0078223869,
0.0680876672,
-0.0413491912,
-0.0424019434,
0.0071910881,
0.0416273847,
0.0387300886,
-0.0011415679,
-0.0029023658,
-0.0102963885,
-0.059585277,
0.0257771295,
-0.048108574,
0.0143746966,
-0.0018228311,
0.0105281267,
0.0877521336,
0.0176159441,
0.0159122646,
-0.0565991215,
-0.0029807689,
0.0004764639,
-0.0151575524,
-0.0261032637,
-6.002793411e-33,
0.0303681269,
-0.010992635,
-0.0328052118,
0.0078655118,
0.0318591297,
0.008803525,
-0.0269300081,
0.0027532824,
-0.0245102756,
0.0059935073,
0.0075755105,
-0.0085594375,
0.0168962646,
0.0435834937,
0.0167128984,
-0.0357511193,
0.024327388,
0.0158577487,
0.0096663814,
0.0514084101,
0.0631960556,
0.0314953588,
0.0954252109,
-0.062107902,
0.0332947858,
-0.0075280624,
0.005688956,
-0.0321556665,
0.0495172627,
0.091862008,
-0.0481796488,
0.06246759,
0.0384477973,
0.0152395619,
0.0271621756,
0.0438722745,
-0.0721384361,
-0.0168503113,
-0.0408017151,
0.0503499173,
0.0311364345,
-0.0310326852,
0.0320444033,
0.0022127216,
0.0173642244,
-0.0093047367,
0.0812466294,
0.0043110438,
-0.0031511155,
-0.0985110924,
-0.0817649215,
0.0242385194,
-0.0220592674,
0.0003872592,
0.0606823191,
0.0682187453,
0.0172969904,
0.0312393215,
-0.1182852313,
0.027611902,
-0.0420724899,
0.0368809141,
0.0525203906,
0.0053920457,
-0.0569768921,
0.0353696048,
0.0113829458,
0.0422315225,
0.0115004713,
0.0403463282,
0.0588715225,
0.0123657845,
0.0176950283,
0.0745415986,
0.0678327829,
-0.022517534,
-0.1050442904,
0.0237326398,
0.0622291341,
-0.0376918949,
0.0169078857,
-0.0150310975,
-0.051152207,
-0.0132171502,
-0.0194008928,
-0.0053742668,
-0.0415220149,
-0.0075871958,
0.0047808532,
-0.0338150114,
-0.0155857727,
0.0349224396,
0.0264648311,
-0.0510697104,
-0.0861027539,
0.036260426,
-0.0018551929,
0.0652018711,
0.0366460718,
0.0117138913,
-0.0429829881,
-0.0539227016,
-0.0252570063,
0.0079828417,
0.0344474018,
0.0117757916,
0.0894856527,
0.0247188006,
-0.0532959215,
0.0124160722,
-0.0212904643,
-0.0294387452,
-0.0046068314,
0.0959942713,
-0.0007735961,
0.0084276674,
0.0082392255,
0.0660647079,
0.0533770733,
0.0239748601,
0.0029086825,
-0.0398078859,
-0.036831174,
0.0241794139,
-0.0311058257,
-0.0342086963,
-0.0151649397,
0.0431381911,
0.0232562665,
-0.0780003369,
0.0107468935,
-0.0259484258,
2.507e-7,
0.040529836,
0.0563027151,
-0.0127558382,
-0.023130022,
0.0338355079,
0.045329269,
0.0040898351,
0.0477357581,
-0.0355798937,
-0.0127902348,
-0.0234288946,
-0.0134089058,
0.0496040434,
0.0462158136,
-0.0839768574,
-0.0110732773,
-0.0571809933,
0.039358642,
-0.0551570728,
0.0178190582,
0.0351371653,
0.1162538528,
0.0055788942,
-0.0303387158,
0.0130198775,
-0.0009254231,
0.0484055914,
-0.0125628272,
-0.0195336714,
0.060882099,
0.0127085419,
0.041189108,
-0.0135419294,
0.0030381624,
-0.0316111408,
0.0079879686,
0.0064211143,
0.0310933962,
-0.0150752086,
0.0052680131,
-0.0019938427,
-0.0241380371,
0.0117276907,
-0.0562973246,
0.0645996779,
0.006559243,
-0.0138560236,
-0.0095222006,
0.0090447962,
-0.0103517072,
0.0610594638,
-0.0418423638,
-0.019016074,
0.031886518,
-0.0033206507,
-0.0547470711,
-0.0310832057,
-0.0695667565,
0.0207487885,
0.0471534468,
-0.0043061459,
0.0176020954,
-0.0001166897,
-0.0310543329,
0.0329442993,
-0.0658222213,
0.0489485078,
2.23174559e-34,
0.0365493521,
0.0085956901,
-0.0370350182,
0.0137410956,
-0.0054013291,
-0.0059533636,
-0.0192101225,
-0.005740114,
-0.0125671709,
-0.0041966885,
0.0238593835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19884v1 | Investigating the Timescales of Language Processing with EEG and Language Models | 2024-06-28T12:49:27 | 2024-06-28T12:49:27 | Davide Turco, Conor Houghton | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | This study explores the temporal dynamics of language processing by examining
the alignment between word representations from a pre-trained transformer-based
language model, and EEG data. Using a Temporal Response Function (TRF) model,
we investigate how neural activity corresponds to model representations across
different layers, revealing insights into the interaction between artificial
language models and brain responses during language comprehension. Our analysis
reveals patterns in TRFs from distinct layers, highlighting varying
contributions to lexical and compositional processing. Additionally, we used
linear discriminant analysis (LDA) to isolate part-of-speech (POS)
representations, offering insights into their influence on neural responses and
the underlying mechanisms of syntactic processing. These findings underscore
EEG's utility for probing language processing dynamics with high temporal
resolution. By bridging artificial language models and neural activity, this
study advances our understanding of their interaction at fine timescales. | [
0.0142321214,
0.0529170521,
-0.0301110968,
0.0175404567,
-0.0067568887,
0.0345879272,
0.0137385149,
0.0201696157,
-0.0105077187,
-0.0196885355,
-0.0054992279,
-0.0469905213,
0.0442371182,
0.0591585077,
0.0140344435,
0.0109910369,
0.0547342263,
-0.003444273,
-0.0209980886,
-0.0124880094,
-0.0042480906,
-0.0010974059,
-0.0559610128,
0.0592980087,
0.0078042601,
-0.0015910427,
-0.0242335964,
-0.0517012328,
-0.0234484803,
-0.0040156879,
-0.0538742281,
0.0555857681,
-0.0189324934,
0.0094229775,
0.0000013704,
-0.0388580076,
0.0198865347,
-0.0075421748,
-0.0401260071,
-0.0210394561,
0.006749521,
0.0217233766,
0.0051299115,
-0.0458454452,
-0.0375412367,
-0.0118600782,
0.0467031226,
0.0429608375,
-0.0266027562,
0.0462563857,
-0.0206425358,
-0.0099419989,
0.0531196222,
0.0017453231,
-0.0087971706,
0.0214183256,
0.0330668166,
-0.0537826084,
0.0152962534,
-0.031314306,
-0.0502522439,
-0.0015509437,
-0.0188641921,
0.0403767154,
0.0234743413,
0.0748138875,
0.00710497,
-0.0034154316,
-0.0144355418,
0.0466277711,
0.0234355722,
-0.0623837821,
0.0176585596,
0.0543403029,
-0.0389664993,
0.0201094411,
-0.0069766203,
-0.0020890154,
0.0227263216,
0.0284896605,
0.0365818813,
-0.061371021,
-0.012296888,
0.0114087285,
-0.0382190682,
0.0897168517,
0.0357198268,
-0.0497123823,
-0.0170828067,
-0.021584142,
0.0333248824,
-0.0278349109,
0.025312366,
0.0173486937,
-0.0156530179,
0.0035620378,
0.0003770391,
-0.0336873829,
-0.0332485884,
-0.0211611241,
0.0204802155,
0.0448536426,
0.018088948,
0.0113392137,
-0.0107469773,
0.0650115311,
-0.0147152841,
0.0412762612,
-0.0262551997,
0.0335136242,
-0.0465746857,
-0.045746889,
-0.0098133124,
0.0249548983,
-0.0466444902,
-0.0221239142,
-0.0459663458,
-0.0242076349,
-0.0048240968,
-0.0865096226,
-0.0088896742,
0.0441275463,
-0.0201242734,
0.0285984278,
-0.0389565788,
0.030339906,
0.0260992348,
0.0276648179,
-0.0185007043,
-0.0348829813,
-0.0374314897,
0.0305783246,
0.0015113818,
-0.0263070967,
-0.026954392,
0.0319905803,
-0.0110620344,
-0.0544261821,
-0.0259657074,
0.0124008683,
-0.0383089632,
0.0033313946,
0.0079701161,
-0.0556131154,
0.0276662372,
0.0352464467,
-0.0378957316,
-0.0546990074,
0.0026929644,
-0.0084427809,
-0.02766327,
0.061114382,
-0.0105494028,
0.0171910375,
0.0453856066,
0.0108595118,
0.0342343152,
-0.0058561568,
0.0582609586,
-0.0807124227,
-0.0185479578,
-0.0406223275,
-0.0259354226,
0.0621349327,
-0.0243568234,
-0.0448347107,
-0.0918936729,
-0.0392859653,
0.0014355507,
0.0125933737,
0.0578256361,
-0.0079333512,
-0.0000327032,
-0.0270416308,
0.0556607321,
0.0650011599,
-0.0080778887,
0.018881781,
0.0045958706,
0.0022799075,
0.0338834487,
-0.0208260566,
-0.0046063969,
-0.0200687423,
-0.0074999738,
-0.0113296816,
-0.0576511361,
-0.0105915256,
-0.0025392016,
0.0223864075,
0.0273307469,
-0.0101979654,
0.0456433408,
0.0171216894,
0.0415368229,
0.0063432925,
-0.0308404397,
0.0753448457,
0.0316811949,
0.0128326956,
0.041491352,
-0.0301116724,
0.0332417861,
0.0326313041,
0.024200283,
-0.0009830799,
0.0002135714,
0.0199302081,
0.0022096273,
0.0546917245,
0.0042605656,
0.0157435369,
0.0129792672,
-0.0107834022,
-0.0031968874,
0.0110068377,
-0.0172473174,
0.0055450997,
-0.0299379379,
0.0156327523,
-0.0361201726,
-0.0336571485,
-0.0284349658,
0.0519917719,
-0.0416076705,
-0.0079767574,
-0.0077550211,
-0.0095535424,
0.0049142339,
-0.0195662547,
-0.0431167036,
0.0444014706,
-0.004485412,
0.0024488473,
0.0266327541,
0.0116757983,
0.0035481614,
-0.0153304087,
0.0378038548,
0.0282620192,
-0.0048776888,
0.0565414578,
0.0695427284,
-0.0372472294,
0.0416082889,
-0.0277057756,
0.0389188714,
-0.0235402565,
0.0015847608,
-0.0223239474,
0.078777045,
-0.0720212311,
-0.0013666133,
0.008438006,
0.0201398898,
0.0129877543,
0.0097973589,
0.0229506195,
-0.0064433059,
-0.0266408976,
0.0311579388,
-0.0254163891,
-0.0351941586,
-0.035161525,
-0.0252872128,
-0.0617779456,
0.0029869839,
-0.0825859383,
-0.0381596982,
0.043384552,
0.0315497592,
0.0375471264,
-0.0183255952,
-0.0065781758,
0.0293545257,
0.0143622309,
0.0163144916,
0.026768228,
0.0325315818,
-0.0120373582,
-0.0185615849,
-0.0239921268,
-0.0300900619,
0.0001916064,
-0.0636477843,
0.085837625,
-0.0195301548,
-0.0466955937,
-0.0617891289,
0.024416361,
-0.0275956336,
0.0371370167,
0.0274154712,
-0.0222794618,
0.0477300845,
0.0021948812,
0.0976174101,
0.0499673113,
0.0380917192,
0.0666236579,
0.0488942079,
-0.0607225485,
-0.0259346981,
-0.010414728,
-0.0468132347,
0.0664158911,
-0.0491384566,
0.01353529,
0.0036459235,
0.1146052554,
0.0847826079,
-0.0166157167,
-0.0301216133,
0.008274951,
-0.0499644242,
-0.0501249656,
0.0105309011,
-0.0119011989,
-0.0870406255,
0.0487536043,
-0.0327902846,
-0.0251959376,
0.037778534,
-0.0122853573,
0.0010982358,
-0.0106534567,
0.0066618449,
0.0128410663,
0.0422768816,
0.0174087938,
0.0151918018,
-0.0364818573,
-0.0439376459,
-0.0420196019,
0.0188891441,
-0.0395192094,
-0.0463062041,
0.0392879657,
-0.0367729738,
0.006594379,
0.0393926091,
0.0379013568,
-0.0374212004,
-0.0563507415,
-0.0103555154,
-0.0048098438,
-0.0086894808,
0.0012559118,
-0.0264608935,
0.006807276,
0.0121125188,
0.0146983061,
-0.0139688542,
-0.0263330899,
0.0032579203,
0.0792736784,
0.0147828627,
0.0178211853,
0.0329879411,
-0.0036243519,
0.0416040123,
0.0101141958,
0.0130978851,
0.0281738322,
-0.0848450065,
0.0168941859,
0.0333199725,
-0.0172634274,
0.0004769421,
0.0333594531,
0.0074332226,
-0.0218671523,
-0.0502660051,
0.1133250222,
0.0299553964,
-0.0559726804,
0.0275145639,
-0.0324904881,
0.0108810412,
0.0216592681,
0.0053602816,
-0.0365388803,
0.0073496462,
-0.0246907305,
-0.0094055273,
0.0288488623,
-0.0174319223,
-0.0199788474,
-0.0448692143,
0.0165083092,
-0.0255886484,
-0.0313161463,
0.021363344,
-0.0104647176,
0.0352279805,
0.0477047227,
0.0081096003,
-0.009783553,
-0.0104301106,
0.0150712086,
0.0653330013,
-0.0058517256,
-0.0061912495,
0.0257196333,
0.0080578439,
0.0603525266,
0.0380797423,
0.0251109321,
-0.0430902541,
-0.0414526314,
0.0278421286,
-0.0105977273,
0.0051733223,
-0.0114446413,
-0.0097144898,
0.0626239181,
-0.0152291749,
-0.007942629,
-0.0123264017,
-0.0163816903,
-0.0650095865,
-0.0371709019,
0.0809537619,
-0.052159816,
-0.0292601418,
0.0304964501,
0.0458801351,
-0.0150448699,
0.0499207564,
0.0549290366,
-0.0779470205,
-0.0131681655,
0.0346158259,
0.0529974252,
-0.0190562084,
-0.0630547851,
-0.0001438289,
0.0153967869,
0.0171621423,
-0.0353035107,
-0.0014520906,
-0.0020425767,
-0.0214125421,
0.0511552468,
0.0119105848,
0.0567296222,
-0.0559031516,
-0.0130000031,
0.0545214526,
-0.0127066132,
0.0071820822,
-0.0447784141,
-0.0099459887,
-0.0120037459,
-0.0355239287,
-0.0274930447,
0.0197275952,
-0.0663278401,
-0.0627587959,
0.105206348,
-0.0571543463,
0.0197925381,
-0.0091495132,
0.0137033919,
-0.0585694537,
0.0349538624,
0.0162764508,
-0.0097834133,
0.0736236051,
-0.0390560701,
0.0076638134,
-0.0117630949,
-0.0007526435,
0.0118409395,
0.0121601094,
0.0485005416,
0.0167982895,
0.0053114295,
-0.0160546843,
0.01587037,
-0.0082949605,
0.1003441662,
-0.0092230346,
0.0169419739,
-0.0442140251,
-0.0252079014,
0.0141077004,
0.0531076901,
-0.0063306708,
-0.1236938387,
0.05014861,
0.0040911851,
-0.0253004953,
0.012471687,
-0.0191561226,
-0.02384682,
0.0004680242,
-0.007278916,
-0.0514005385,
-0.0261674244,
0.006094642,
0.0458097309,
0.0295899324,
0.0488202348,
-0.0405975804,
-0.0147175388,
0.0023643635,
0.0769116729,
0.0058476594,
-0.0082695428,
-0.0427631959,
-0.0319505073,
-0.0269194823,
-0.0276743695,
0.0831349492,
-0.0617835,
-0.0105858315,
-0.045217067,
0.0391782597,
0.0109173199,
0.0221281257,
-0.0489305407,
0.0083352178,
-0.0386038199,
0.0270038825,
0.0843657926,
-0.0121948272,
-0.0013481961,
-0.0009883322,
0.0600033514,
0.0195129924,
0.0345707871,
0.021432193,
0.0076659159,
-0.0038998073,
-0.0416449048,
-0.0413917564,
-0.0188528169,
-0.0853160173,
0.0022106119,
-0.0490207337,
-0.0286582466,
0.0324928425,
-0.031691283,
0.0387862623,
-0.0436661839,
0.0150977988,
0.0139311971,
-0.0194457527,
0.0014851267,
0.0032512485,
0.014625513,
0.0191888697,
-0.0558623374,
-0.0694389641,
-5.133362524e-33,
-0.0120623959,
-0.0639297813,
0.000663075,
0.0602104701,
-0.0380361751,
0.0328772329,
-0.0395211428,
0.0624108873,
0.0252552386,
0.0241093896,
-0.0320480056,
0.023770703,
0.0172006954,
0.024703091,
0.0261049662,
-0.0238460414,
-0.0199353211,
-0.0732886046,
0.0297333226,
-0.0197138302,
0.0326070003,
0.0605293959,
0.0841392651,
-0.0146254292,
0.0213437937,
0.034363009,
0.0190664493,
0.0018644077,
0.003231426,
0.0480016209,
-0.0834515914,
0.0596194603,
0.0480733588,
-0.0259073731,
0.0027246373,
0.0275490116,
-0.0391716361,
-0.0187401269,
0.0526662506,
0.0147916833,
-0.0326140895,
-0.0078279488,
0.0573998801,
-0.0302897263,
-0.0305227861,
0.0050747124,
0.0397484042,
-0.0231328923,
-0.010032624,
-0.0128912237,
-0.0648072436,
-0.0178511217,
-0.0360377394,
0.0136717428,
0.0389380753,
0.0176075846,
-0.0448419042,
0.0201819893,
-0.0785585269,
-0.0007029157,
-0.0436958261,
0.0170952827,
0.0328888148,
0.0124525372,
0.0296275131,
0.0501330905,
0.0554622523,
0.0227894057,
-0.0425564684,
-0.0121564325,
0.0775399655,
0.0058302358,
0.0277183633,
-0.0365623534,
0.0197827462,
-0.0331109017,
-0.0539887398,
-0.0278193858,
-0.0013582747,
0.0046169925,
0.0164750721,
-0.0600911342,
-0.0092928428,
-0.0028725485,
-0.0405098125,
0.0164116789,
-0.0525328182,
0.0018591621,
0.0511353314,
-0.0512369275,
0.0192919876,
-0.0262014102,
0.04911872,
-0.069612354,
0.0499350391,
-0.0412615277,
-0.0269730762,
-0.0018499794,
0.0423510671,
0.0075025223,
-0.0130180316,
-0.0435379595,
0.0034689598,
-0.0022395966,
0.0359018669,
-0.0234406125,
-0.0426813848,
-0.0083532296,
-0.0295836497,
0.014276538,
-0.0102191474,
-0.021451002,
0.0223810598,
0.0039023608,
0.0445376486,
-0.0148750423,
-0.0197490565,
-0.0487449281,
0.0136453798,
0.014448286,
-0.0052787266,
0.0068604494,
0.009446525,
0.0664943978,
-0.013671428,
-0.007203517,
-0.0287232418,
0.039977897,
0.0105865588,
-0.0101764398,
-0.0184300561,
0.0020184882,
2.406e-7,
0.0550034344,
0.0571519881,
0.0064380202,
0.0388157517,
0.020935392,
-0.0321971551,
0.0147144934,
0.0040919916,
0.0125614041,
0.007727772,
-0.0275771488,
0.0191436298,
0.0208481513,
-0.0236903485,
0.01049117,
-0.0509909019,
-0.029346101,
0.0740311593,
-0.0689072758,
-0.00832697,
0.0252554491,
-0.000230709,
-0.0142946616,
-0.0235988908,
-0.0348081999,
-0.0036704582,
0.1030621082,
-0.03159393,
0.0150399664,
0.0144568179,
0.0334205888,
-0.0292177666,
0.0229503755,
0.0550164878,
-0.021216549,
0.0358414985,
-0.0124602234,
-0.0141768269,
-0.032102067,
0.0080532096,
0.0390475467,
-0.0267601982,
-0.0304732211,
-0.0468219332,
0.031419225,
-0.0651715547,
-0.0652878731,
-0.0213291291,
-0.023130944,
-0.002065859,
0.0552848019,
-0.0190504659,
-0.0142278988,
-0.0270250477,
0.0160162915,
0.0074852579,
-0.0083387801,
-0.0238013119,
-0.0304683167,
0.0526999049,
-0.0506621674,
0.047316093,
-0.0193250831,
-0.0256883651,
0.0671027377,
-0.0335457996,
-0.0041643749,
1.56225851e-34,
-0.065469861,
0.008232017,
0.0044569075,
0.0357823484,
-0.0028441465,
-0.0411580913,
0.0666301101,
-0.0173224173,
0.0047147498,
-0.0948124081,
0.0035158673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19874v1 | Detecting Subtle Differences between Human and Model Languages Using Spectrum of Relative Likelihood | 2024-06-28T12:28:52 | 2024-06-28T12:28:52 | Yang Xu, Yu Wang, Hao An, Zhichen Liu, Yongyuan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Human and model-generated texts can be distinguished by examining the
magnitude of likelihood in language. However, it is becoming increasingly
difficult as language model's capabilities of generating human-like texts keep
evolving. This study provides a new perspective by using the relative
likelihood values instead of absolute ones, and extracting useful features from
the spectrum-view of likelihood for the human-model text detection task. We
propose a detection procedure with two classification methods, supervised and
heuristic-based, respectively, which results in competitive performances with
previous zero-shot detection methods and a new state-of-the-art on short-text
detection. Our method can also reveal subtle differences between human and
model languages, which find theoretical roots in psycholinguistics studies. Our
code is available at https://github.com/CLCS-SUSTech/FourierGPT | [
0.0089886971,
0.0304053966,
-0.0226568971,
0.0848494023,
-0.0382104814,
0.0291393958,
-0.0296310205,
0.0651126131,
-0.0409299769,
-0.0216819122,
-0.0497284457,
-0.0684811547,
0.0330335461,
0.0032824359,
0.0174753778,
-0.0311275162,
0.0194667801,
-0.0215852149,
0.0217299834,
0.0247853268,
0.0204413515,
-0.0140764602,
-0.0146050313,
0.0176584516,
0.0064133378,
0.0064115152,
-0.0171151739,
0.0264373031,
0.0753937438,
-0.0104678068,
-0.013782585,
0.0466494784,
-0.0093508903,
0.0856018737,
0.0000016339,
-0.0464091152,
0.0184944272,
-0.0396932401,
0.007480327,
-0.0222199373,
0.0776061788,
-0.0140631879,
-0.0435909741,
0.0039972202,
0.0029580095,
-0.0395907313,
0.0567122735,
0.0484052561,
-0.0556681678,
0.0314101689,
-0.0220103096,
-0.0106323631,
0.0046107126,
0.0157988612,
0.0433951132,
0.0020731089,
0.0101650506,
-0.0026748406,
0.0199686754,
-0.0075556319,
0.0085499128,
0.0363223702,
0.0015559867,
0.0467436127,
-0.017526798,
0.0567634441,
-0.0084595252,
-0.0306460764,
0.0031737436,
0.0461434089,
-0.0446876846,
-0.0883122161,
0.026847953,
-0.0171174929,
0.0119878473,
0.0151784308,
0.0183628276,
0.0324772075,
-0.0380265005,
0.040097408,
0.0481300056,
0.0226834733,
-0.0107340207,
-0.0022487508,
0.0054939031,
0.0370195769,
0.03902651,
-0.033685986,
-0.0142771769,
-0.0175897479,
-0.0412102714,
-0.0192242432,
0.0315305553,
0.0006752759,
0.0122851878,
-0.0160567593,
-0.0731041655,
-0.0534927659,
0.0256362986,
-0.0635161102,
0.0272321198,
0.0281212255,
-0.0516718924,
0.023823902,
-0.072703734,
0.0548808649,
0.0040999302,
-0.032469485,
-0.0499402322,
0.0268460643,
-0.032268133,
-0.0001345165,
-0.0208046455,
-0.0436926149,
-0.0425807238,
-0.0404780693,
-0.0249349568,
-0.0027980567,
0.0536849387,
-0.0024868783,
-0.0382212289,
-0.0387240462,
-0.0389820933,
0.0141834971,
0.0501416028,
-0.0229258873,
-0.0202393867,
0.0077966959,
-0.039100457,
-0.0469251163,
-0.0201799776,
0.0781674758,
0.0495580733,
-0.0076380935,
-0.0143002989,
-0.009898968,
-0.0130953817,
-0.0554764345,
-0.0221037697,
-0.0166949742,
-0.028061714,
-0.0599597134,
-0.0335354358,
-0.0837642476,
-0.0475215316,
-0.0047726762,
-0.0031210976,
-0.0039406647,
-0.0104646329,
0.0042198142,
0.0425556526,
0.0851533636,
-0.0389550962,
0.0078275967,
0.0613091476,
0.0019799117,
0.0028945715,
0.0710359886,
-0.0008177941,
0.0272213183,
0.0295447242,
0.0142100006,
0.0330459364,
0.0544493608,
-0.0517278127,
0.0133582102,
-0.0486487783,
-0.0577749573,
0.0174950548,
-0.0047815978,
0.0730998889,
0.0452731997,
-0.0367174931,
-0.031973172,
0.0419070274,
0.1088900268,
0.0143446038,
0.0143379746,
0.0563268811,
0.1026724949,
0.0196351446,
0.0663642287,
0.0146724163,
-0.036223907,
-0.0543028079,
0.0071858768,
-0.0399211124,
-0.0014992725,
-0.0094889132,
0.0265395287,
-0.0369750746,
-0.0354919657,
0.0050197518,
-0.0492607951,
0.0439754054,
-0.0216159821,
-0.0325471759,
-0.0062884497,
0.0479292125,
-0.0526629388,
-0.010454474,
-0.0642701164,
0.0271584857,
0.0176032037,
-0.0098582897,
-0.0316528305,
0.0717850104,
0.0219005644,
-0.04558203,
0.0785302594,
0.015688153,
0.021670334,
0.0275642425,
-0.0324176364,
0.0059741996,
0.0349623002,
0.0532130711,
0.0203862563,
-0.0033092035,
0.0153820552,
0.0205517821,
-0.0405043066,
-0.0267145075,
0.0438807346,
-0.0364221334,
-0.0180768948,
-0.0113082593,
0.0056789527,
-0.0205811262,
-0.0018937371,
-0.0308134332,
0.0039401506,
-0.0196702946,
-0.0475034267,
-0.0046550808,
0.0500218123,
0.0137550943,
-0.0224160664,
0.046807643,
-0.0220141914,
-0.0032282153,
0.0228008479,
0.034424834,
-0.0460668318,
0.0040782387,
-0.0433469154,
0.0033276072,
-0.0457398593,
0.0446347781,
-0.045356147,
0.0464006215,
-0.0296416469,
0.0612866059,
0.0305760838,
0.0303094666,
0.0288165472,
-0.0547357202,
0.0604878627,
-0.0643038824,
0.021871252,
0.0178446416,
-0.0156811308,
0.0051140585,
0.0090618199,
0.0071554361,
-0.0395789407,
0.0070751854,
-0.0902279168,
-0.013931822,
-0.0175548997,
0.0155669749,
0.0527338684,
-0.0455700085,
-0.0414430797,
-0.0080112377,
-0.0065152384,
0.0059440499,
-0.0014433736,
-0.0380520038,
0.0132490061,
-0.0470743068,
-0.0608880371,
-0.0338031054,
0.0088960929,
-0.0066614812,
0.0278268717,
0.014353402,
-0.0607179813,
-0.0900929347,
0.0364079028,
0.0145132532,
-0.0011174143,
0.0355944373,
-0.0540031493,
-0.0054806205,
-0.0187360328,
0.069143571,
0.0465885215,
0.0110928575,
0.0183375198,
0.0259161256,
0.0186667908,
-0.0018307219,
-0.0314828008,
0.0099283205,
0.0468624495,
-0.0360997543,
-0.0599271432,
0.0095564015,
0.0533424951,
0.0397151485,
0.0307557955,
-0.0437988713,
0.0109362938,
-0.0486910082,
-0.0516081937,
-0.0138262268,
0.0261007268,
-0.0429267734,
0.0336478353,
-0.0099118147,
-0.0254019108,
0.0523475036,
-0.0566725507,
0.0141849788,
-0.0593865663,
-0.049176421,
-0.0101144416,
-0.0048031285,
0.0084435064,
0.0319831297,
0.0409432128,
-0.0405421555,
-0.0202045478,
0.0141741894,
0.0485506505,
-0.0077831438,
0.0651660636,
-0.0285502058,
0.0071058543,
-0.0386084914,
0.0060323831,
-0.029941516,
-0.0388760641,
-0.0460874103,
-0.0005828744,
-0.0128218066,
-0.0677185357,
-0.0069898874,
0.029458195,
0.0133663919,
0.0667498857,
-0.014155061,
-0.0138229784,
-0.033283446,
0.0679861233,
0.0198859219,
-0.0668812692,
0.0268217679,
-0.0650482476,
0.0290593356,
0.0279623065,
0.0043908316,
0.0496791676,
-0.0139205419,
-0.0263069253,
0.0192262549,
0.0042955349,
-0.0188999549,
0.0157686789,
0.0859101862,
-0.0192853864,
0.0045250994,
0.1079162955,
0.013838199,
-0.0394638963,
0.019585602,
-0.0043154163,
0.0362737253,
0.0065269503,
0.0029251911,
-0.0482926406,
-0.0340007767,
0.0204894971,
0.0126106376,
-0.0180530678,
-0.0054322802,
-0.0072295903,
-0.0230613183,
0.0110383648,
0.0156950746,
-0.0242438093,
-0.0408958197,
-0.0236421581,
0.0463435687,
0.0194174815,
-0.0253245831,
0.0060257236,
-0.036084827,
-0.0066456147,
-0.0108700814,
0.0152875101,
-0.0312367044,
0.0061622062,
-0.0393782258,
0.0116253765,
0.0205676872,
0.0458687395,
-0.0219908208,
-0.0201905798,
-0.0019563907,
-0.0628406927,
-0.0113955019,
0.0064529348,
0.0285386704,
0.0516961589,
-0.0031374509,
-0.0098551782,
0.0393436812,
-0.0363493338,
-0.035402935,
0.0020554601,
0.0307728313,
-0.0092433197,
-0.0622122437,
-0.0002010415,
0.0103012584,
0.0120921917,
0.0730095208,
0.0788887292,
-0.0368018076,
-0.0319917984,
-0.0083589368,
0.0287159756,
-0.0012134378,
-0.078121312,
-0.0449713096,
0.0338157304,
-0.0618162602,
-0.0465168878,
-0.0019554032,
-0.0094457706,
0.0322825387,
-0.006958989,
0.0058273142,
0.0097270971,
-0.0186887756,
-0.0260060281,
-0.0005952466,
-0.0470769741,
0.0140980147,
-0.0736952126,
-0.020073669,
0.0127032185,
-0.0589110404,
-0.0123156728,
-0.0323932655,
-0.1461818814,
-0.0365704,
0.0149387391,
-0.0770133808,
0.0278360359,
-0.008076692,
-0.0391010977,
-0.0716557354,
0.0077845776,
0.039589636,
-0.0149915935,
0.0547394268,
0.0144167887,
-0.0250092018,
-0.0266221855,
0.0320592672,
0.0272618495,
0.0674203783,
0.0307953488,
-0.0285569821,
0.0001064602,
-0.0271547679,
0.0466622002,
0.0013760402,
0.0443199836,
-0.0341423228,
-0.0774998218,
-0.0290537011,
-0.0607889481,
0.0245295633,
0.0219566319,
-0.008710742,
-0.0314359069,
0.0246744361,
0.0264455732,
-0.0051372242,
-0.010362071,
-0.0146961603,
0.0333022326,
-0.0323967785,
0.0237344727,
0.0039818408,
0.0169540904,
0.0082713673,
-0.01215191,
0.0059642652,
0.0646975711,
-0.0160023347,
0.0515032485,
0.0049617165,
0.0707804337,
0.0043281857,
-0.041560825,
0.0077338,
0.020559743,
-0.0500588901,
-0.0346254446,
-0.0351688676,
0.0322785191,
0.0699894652,
-0.0038985417,
0.0414927788,
-0.0519707352,
0.0078250812,
-0.0460353866,
0.0350599661,
-0.0263996888,
0.0175580326,
0.0115504526,
0.0221377593,
-0.0240976997,
-0.0169111099,
0.0747639537,
0.0270427521,
0.0047885282,
0.0119385011,
-0.009884242,
-0.0206717402,
0.0004030802,
-0.0262800623,
-0.0194958877,
-0.0378220715,
0.0694445893,
-0.0495646223,
-0.0583564751,
0.0231879633,
-0.0133926095,
0.0151047045,
0.0013508856,
-0.0030502824,
0.0219714958,
-0.0180481896,
0.0080874003,
-0.0307090692,
-0.0092423614,
0.0498496965,
0.0003542031,
-0.0338735059,
-5.735993295e-33,
-0.0060410206,
-0.028206544,
-0.061160624,
-0.010245611,
0.0230562612,
0.0162831787,
-0.0282196961,
0.0315593518,
-0.0080039147,
0.0295569524,
0.0353674702,
0.0492094345,
0.0398223288,
-0.0136057595,
-0.0126805929,
-0.0211615823,
0.0502582528,
-0.0135912076,
-0.0188316833,
-0.0236475728,
0.0076209139,
-0.0001944907,
0.0642501414,
-0.0329542868,
-0.0132055972,
-0.0286060255,
-0.0032492108,
0.0121967932,
0.0011491979,
0.0702891126,
-0.0479851626,
0.0506401248,
0.0335280783,
0.0377690829,
-0.0425708033,
0.0047004553,
-0.0343450867,
-0.0133771384,
-0.0050771087,
0.0349574871,
0.0033095432,
-0.0178338811,
0.011128366,
-0.0376509503,
-0.0409111679,
0.0125329047,
0.0352908932,
-0.0444053598,
0.0213659164,
0.0099789593,
-0.0940486565,
0.060940329,
0.0117525058,
0.0159463659,
0.1056585461,
0.0589786284,
-0.035436172,
-0.0162673909,
-0.0699332878,
0.0228234176,
0.0035174144,
0.0417067036,
-0.0020978625,
0.0478718132,
-0.0104482928,
0.0522768274,
0.0789022073,
-0.014102459,
0.0295552798,
-0.0480500236,
0.0599902235,
-0.0117479702,
0.0196389332,
0.0446630269,
0.0805714503,
-0.0133299176,
0.0075253332,
-0.0267460942,
0.0376889445,
-0.0205238368,
0.0341158696,
0.0301798712,
-0.0772878304,
-0.024261795,
-0.0101871816,
-0.0648079962,
-0.0489773266,
0.0137973931,
0.023094561,
-0.001767157,
0.0017081425,
-0.0430789143,
0.0549079627,
-0.023415627,
-0.0033132483,
-0.0349210054,
-0.0179842282,
0.0421910733,
0.0141516477,
0.0186891649,
-0.0378474444,
-0.0447069257,
0.0536578484,
0.0536698103,
0.0326387212,
-0.0109164873,
0.0203596447,
0.0127233146,
-0.0434437506,
0.0142225847,
0.0004090317,
-0.0337419398,
0.0223162193,
0.0472948849,
0.0258385669,
-0.0132558495,
-0.0011024515,
0.051765129,
0.0246505458,
-0.0358989835,
-0.0248940494,
-0.000100369,
-0.0222654045,
0.0296227243,
-0.0223832186,
0.0082169287,
-0.0280228369,
-0.0035767993,
0.0633223727,
-0.0356310457,
0.0036735486,
0.0017011649,
2.494e-7,
0.0242653582,
-0.0124484282,
0.0250923093,
-0.0044359337,
0.035518337,
0.0703555718,
-0.01383169,
-0.0209010728,
0.0107561406,
0.007751212,
-0.0212177634,
0.0222829506,
0.0782241374,
-0.0027729007,
-0.0502992012,
0.0146402661,
-0.0081318067,
-0.005577418,
-0.060158547,
0.0064585209,
0.078539744,
0.069499068,
-0.0134481974,
-0.0081701642,
0.0504521653,
-0.010770035,
0.0363803208,
-0.0338872336,
0.0259250477,
0.0097193709,
0.0042843348,
-0.0034403792,
0.0289889332,
0.0379797593,
-0.0148138022,
-0.0062564984,
0.0184499361,
0.0468140803,
0.0026912808,
0.0627756044,
0.0110494653,
0.0180330481,
0.0071180495,
-0.0468113087,
0.039835304,
-0.0151218614,
-0.0335186347,
-0.0310779195,
0.016323708,
-0.0107209552,
-0.0184081458,
-0.0070771202,
-0.0496816821,
0.0267413352,
0.0174269434,
0.0067793783,
-0.0527038127,
-0.052675847,
-0.0409132577,
-0.0122935111,
-0.0480886661,
0.0220170636,
-0.0308550131,
-0.0303798467,
0.0301391948,
-0.0011262792,
0.0328610875,
2.530347099e-34,
0.0164668746,
0.041707363,
-0.0130407987,
0.031162601,
0.0122886375,
0.0025370014,
0.0182786286,
0.0183455963,
-0.0028990072,
-0.0348292664,
0.0131165516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19853v1 | YuLan: An Open-source Large Language Model | 2024-06-28T11:52:53 | 2024-06-28T11:52:53 | Yutao Zhu, Kun Zhou, Kelong Mao, Wentong Chen, Yiding Sun, Zhipeng Chen, Qian Cao, Yihan Wu, Yushuo Chen, Feng Wang, Lei Zhang, Junyi Li, Xiaolei Wang, Lei Wang, Beichen Zhang, Zican Dong, Xiaoxue Cheng, Yuhan Chen, Xinyu Tang, Yupeng Hou, Qiangqiang Ren, Xincheng Pang, Shufang Xie, Wayne Xin Zhao, Zhicheng Dou, Jiaxin Mao, Yankai Lin, Ruihua Song, Jun Xu, Xu Chen, Rui Yan, Zhewei Wei, Di Hu, Wenbing Huang, Ze-Feng Gao, Yueguo Chen, Weizheng Lu, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have become the foundation of many applications,
leveraging their extensive capabilities in processing and understanding natural
language. While many open-source LLMs have been released with technical
reports, the lack of training details hinders further research and development.
This paper presents the development of YuLan, a series of open-source LLMs with
$12$ billion parameters. The base model of YuLan is pre-trained on
approximately $1.7$T tokens derived from a diverse corpus, including massive
English, Chinese, and multilingual texts. We design a three-stage pre-training
method to enhance YuLan's overall capabilities. Subsequent phases of training
incorporate instruction-tuning and human alignment, employing a substantial
volume of high-quality synthesized data. To facilitate the learning of complex
and long-tail knowledge, we devise a curriculum-learning framework throughout
across these stages, which helps LLMs learn knowledge in an easy-to-hard
manner. YuLan's training is finished on Jan, 2024 and has achieved performance
on par with state-of-the-art LLMs across various English and Chinese
benchmarks. This paper outlines a comprehensive technical roadmap for
developing LLMs from scratch. Our model and codes are available at
https://github.com/RUC-GSAI/YuLan-Chat. | [
0.0389467217,
0.0532505326,
-0.0009495845,
0.0396323502,
-0.0183349885,
0.0287931617,
-0.0055852016,
-0.0402928703,
0.0206294153,
-0.0418636389,
-0.0632735118,
-0.0232132506,
-0.0020994125,
0.0105364798,
0.019499179,
-0.0493440889,
0.0625193641,
-0.0108080562,
0.0088558458,
-0.0071443934,
0.0233020522,
0.0268628746,
0.0040094373,
0.0408158712,
-0.0198722407,
-0.0506358184,
-0.0156378057,
0.0007621702,
0.0090782912,
0.0092127537,
0.0353826955,
0.0426111929,
0.0215894468,
0.0509808846,
0.0000020323,
-0.0586254001,
-0.0344677381,
-0.02889961,
-0.0246319529,
0.0475646183,
0.0709486231,
-0.0019174046,
-0.0180653352,
0.0418016277,
-0.0332982913,
-0.0098033231,
0.0239638779,
0.0599701889,
0.0738707706,
0.0882177949,
0.0076981387,
-0.0450587012,
0.0291200802,
-0.0204904694,
-0.0421563014,
-0.0380693525,
0.0442445613,
0.0063311704,
0.0044458359,
0.0116766598,
-0.0155823519,
0.0095929923,
0.0338205472,
0.0210036412,
0.0073496383,
0.0313096903,
-0.0494694486,
-0.0167675186,
-0.0198949203,
0.0936786756,
-0.0335880518,
-0.0354470126,
-0.0046040122,
0.0168687701,
-0.0095370021,
-0.0512361228,
-0.0449207164,
0.022397507,
0.0296556074,
0.0250772852,
0.0249137189,
-0.0437087752,
0.0264251512,
0.033370316,
-0.0297689792,
0.0099218823,
0.0127734728,
-0.0458237901,
-0.0085664783,
-0.0164216626,
-0.027082352,
-0.0376770124,
0.0133006703,
0.031119192,
-0.0260695182,
0.0205666106,
-0.0297147054,
-0.0334441289,
0.0334886387,
-0.0460329577,
-0.0160419382,
-0.0046043447,
-0.0294020232,
0.0644104183,
-0.0117523931,
0.0433405302,
-0.0050789956,
0.034633141,
-0.0564005077,
-0.0285046138,
-0.0467917062,
-0.0109097296,
-0.0403459482,
0.0153352553,
-0.0040650074,
-0.0397096202,
-0.037446443,
0.0076039629,
0.0024639412,
0.0213703308,
0.0297024213,
-0.014944125,
-0.0152026853,
-0.0287750904,
-0.0152055547,
0.0430527441,
-0.012035544,
0.0101790698,
-0.0337863043,
-0.0430905931,
-0.0085855331,
0.0276427362,
0.0061151125,
-0.0157478154,
0.0157558024,
0.0479500517,
-0.0023024909,
-0.0282693841,
-0.0397418737,
-0.0019640042,
-0.0135774752,
-0.0590162203,
-0.0265290719,
-0.0873155519,
0.0081239128,
-0.014557803,
0.0203795526,
-0.0250833072,
0.0159635097,
0.0181865301,
-0.031609375,
0.0530049428,
-0.0226698481,
0.0094701611,
-0.0133550847,
-0.0059633628,
0.012833355,
0.0526814684,
0.029146919,
0.0100078611,
0.0643688217,
-0.002855337,
-0.0273913741,
0.062967442,
0.0024843982,
-0.0137611572,
-0.0062428322,
0.0234340895,
0.045067668,
0.0328882225,
0.0226004776,
0.0522217527,
-0.0096982,
-0.0100897979,
0.0714291185,
0.0341747552,
0.0018336489,
0.0229930263,
0.0406002998,
0.0505350195,
0.018213477,
-0.0282679126,
-0.0472390242,
-0.0027265479,
-0.0035415248,
-0.004388913,
0.0261852909,
0.0407113284,
-0.049037464,
-0.0424217694,
-0.0180663075,
-0.0298628639,
-0.0185386725,
0.0009515995,
0.0484521873,
-0.0196199957,
-0.0282339901,
0.0255828444,
0.0720654428,
-0.0162389353,
0.037429858,
-0.0025751134,
0.058709614,
0.1016083062,
0.036088001,
-0.0283862427,
-0.0291610323,
-0.0211873893,
0.0204360038,
0.0513976887,
0.0448732749,
-0.0341076739,
-0.0263614301,
-0.0801390409,
-0.0043585873,
-0.006759787,
0.0068114363,
0.0218938701,
0.0407024473,
0.0148705859,
0.0055875811,
-0.0215325244,
-0.0345607474,
0.0444833264,
-0.04792035,
-0.0449318588,
-0.0175177902,
0.0095272344,
0.030454658,
0.0137698399,
-0.0230018739,
0.0094623603,
0.0269641355,
-0.0150970528,
-0.0195160471,
0.0085653486,
-0.0560986176,
-0.0436711572,
0.0663311854,
-0.0054092272,
-0.0473384336,
0.0553037785,
-0.0702555403,
-0.037092369,
0.0143718775,
0.0205574334,
0.0299158543,
-0.0591726676,
0.0266085546,
0.0080404961,
0.009400255,
-0.021325022,
0.0533356667,
0.0178415738,
0.007258161,
-0.0014025841,
0.014898384,
0.0138362171,
-0.0425926149,
-0.0440830514,
-0.0159191862,
-0.0224989597,
0.0292133689,
0.0149612566,
0.0431506522,
-0.0466458648,
-0.0252621826,
-0.1167905778,
0.0435291268,
-0.0378366038,
-0.010358532,
0.0238816161,
-0.0058578644,
-0.0267461166,
0.0076119541,
-0.0320023932,
0.0005633929,
-0.0092497421,
-0.0088593392,
0.0202866104,
-0.0267331712,
-0.0100282151,
-0.0294283908,
0.0035936434,
-0.0204062779,
0.015498573,
-0.0162670631,
0.0138287582,
-0.0103619751,
-0.0186264683,
-0.0029452478,
0.0276576653,
-0.0034264035,
-0.048145134,
-0.0306827631,
-0.0254389998,
0.0725388303,
0.0392514989,
0.0120303901,
0.0221884735,
0.0128599359,
-0.0011658049,
-0.0555565171,
0.0247001145,
-0.0192659572,
-0.0534830242,
-0.0437958352,
0.0000537927,
-0.0164013244,
0.0912768021,
-0.005923009,
-0.0217761323,
-0.076606527,
-0.0095078265,
-0.0267399456,
-0.0091693951,
-0.0369062796,
0.0311078373,
-0.0282585062,
-0.034382496,
-0.0471243002,
-0.0221581701,
0.0480480269,
-0.0384844318,
0.0099862739,
-0.0661962852,
-0.0186790451,
-0.0448214449,
0.0421289951,
0.001572315,
-0.0025845389,
0.0260726176,
-0.0176720954,
-0.0486434773,
0.0283670891,
-0.0173956919,
-0.0256421976,
0.0323484913,
-0.0301554799,
0.007034163,
-0.0056536882,
-0.0218191296,
-0.0396521986,
-0.031092152,
-0.0374863409,
0.0339954495,
0.0183636453,
-0.0048886216,
-0.0247495882,
-0.0152534433,
0.0027053808,
0.0365500003,
-0.0135311577,
0.0285929386,
-0.0392402411,
0.0015873763,
0.0577118285,
0.0009757021,
0.0147416219,
-0.0348718688,
0.0456302427,
0.0536443628,
0.0514541976,
0.0045936583,
-0.0009129682,
-0.0042300406,
0.0142245796,
-0.0597179234,
0.0152978478,
0.0125284623,
0.035394188,
-0.0358000174,
-0.0067224763,
0.1577532738,
0.0197735522,
-0.0483858921,
0.0049293186,
0.0071433401,
0.0244073048,
0.0248055551,
0.0035475157,
-0.0926220044,
-0.0301740076,
0.002151167,
-0.0035378556,
0.0229367074,
-0.0233405251,
0.0022208444,
-0.1393541247,
0.0236820802,
0.0036622656,
-0.0132874288,
-0.0173282456,
-0.0371394828,
-0.0220371801,
-0.0369810089,
0.0381157324,
0.0202483665,
-0.0340843499,
-0.0204101373,
0.0291489419,
-0.0088692931,
-0.0592212081,
0.0785318539,
-0.0629143417,
0.053261295,
0.0315612927,
0.0331762955,
-0.0088010989,
0.0042696791,
0.0044284072,
-0.0041066338,
-0.0344261415,
-0.0127244256,
0.017109191,
-0.0270290263,
-0.0127209676,
-0.0286565106,
0.0639865771,
-0.0448225997,
-0.0087444717,
0.0263856016,
0.0831301734,
0.0267442539,
-0.00724995,
-0.0061047119,
0.0100520961,
-0.0076735965,
0.1126277894,
-0.0027459867,
-0.0628063753,
-0.030396102,
0.0170851648,
-0.0473852791,
-0.0279453117,
-0.0217493307,
0.0430376455,
-0.0353114717,
-0.0112099191,
-0.0878626108,
-0.0315757357,
0.0391469225,
0.0005157366,
0.0218302179,
0.0147648305,
0.0352481343,
0.0070570987,
-0.0439229608,
0.0591796488,
-0.0498601086,
0.0226682741,
-0.0769470558,
-0.0212985296,
0.0183079261,
-0.0229034312,
-0.0120170405,
0.0176453106,
-0.0816545188,
-0.0693935528,
-0.0250524972,
0.0310374331,
0.0065506897,
0.0599131137,
-0.0255925059,
-0.0219258722,
0.0456215218,
-0.0049529183,
-0.0403391123,
-0.0089870756,
0.0194380172,
0.0021823812,
0.0057624588,
0.0327189639,
-0.0357341096,
0.0097037619,
0.0178653914,
0.040331047,
-0.023942614,
0.0121931443,
0.0344780162,
0.0024393098,
0.0470744073,
0.0052581313,
-0.0022464362,
-0.069084838,
0.0209558513,
-0.0241028573,
-0.0401811264,
-0.0278006941,
-0.015364252,
0.055941958,
-0.0049778298,
-0.0314445943,
0.0185761545,
0.0219666287,
0.0189581588,
-0.0200284626,
-0.0066576749,
-0.0108121391,
-0.0037369691,
0.0301444549,
-0.0090763532,
-0.0307178367,
0.0119022401,
-0.0116968174,
0.021179568,
-0.0364614278,
0.058992561,
-0.0017509597,
0.0065818103,
0.0151947364,
0.0063311718,
-0.0303584822,
-0.0420111828,
-0.0070792907,
0.0585513487,
0.0817574412,
-0.0369956419,
0.0408144481,
-0.0504294746,
-0.0028639522,
-0.0543296821,
0.0264278613,
-0.0309039485,
-0.0220371298,
0.0263753571,
0.0192515571,
-0.04515066,
-0.0072208843,
0.0867107585,
0.0272797141,
0.0501677543,
0.0284045227,
0.0077498583,
-0.0249852482,
-0.0244585834,
0.047370173,
0.0154604595,
-0.0479894429,
0.048325412,
-0.0238860846,
-0.0594082624,
0.0022252381,
0.0124371629,
-0.010196032,
0.0044348137,
0.0400561132,
0.067720823,
-0.0237147864,
-0.0073622456,
-0.0486921035,
0.0088168476,
0.0044085509,
-0.0352686159,
0.0059172991,
-6.78514588e-33,
-0.0187355969,
0.028522782,
0.0464724563,
0.0025403257,
-0.0117994379,
-0.0097223548,
0.011067491,
-0.0075992052,
-0.0420259461,
0.0140179265,
0.0009926663,
0.0084557086,
0.0123476563,
0.0467612781,
0.0222245883,
0.0094014667,
0.0369924195,
-0.0043258253,
0.0220477115,
0.0242769662,
0.0458755232,
0.0492250435,
0.0569683276,
-0.0346546508,
-0.0086092791,
-0.0237243064,
0.0235283095,
0.0539335012,
-0.002983507,
0.0528073646,
-0.0286237895,
0.0398349501,
0.0288408976,
-0.0175606385,
-0.0083347932,
0.03015575,
-0.1113799587,
-0.0077626691,
0.047350049,
0.0339022055,
0.0172697455,
-0.0417410061,
0.0056446777,
-0.0199147724,
0.0124417376,
-0.0009730498,
0.0529842302,
-0.0100771915,
0.0117229605,
-0.0065073376,
-0.0602017455,
0.0330914669,
-0.0233426299,
-0.0370762795,
-0.0195743609,
0.034689188,
0.0118049588,
0.0328703597,
-0.063271299,
0.0080219656,
0.011668155,
0.0398010798,
0.0490381867,
0.0078751612,
0.0269573219,
0.0551386997,
-0.0390119441,
-0.0075318315,
-0.0299457125,
0.0083754389,
0.0469135754,
0.0667418391,
0.002306253,
0.0400729477,
-0.009161504,
-0.0113666579,
-0.0967733413,
0.0064187408,
0.0532038249,
0.0711181983,
0.0069122682,
0.0033235718,
-0.0164835416,
0.0021160159,
-0.0259815138,
0.0010013109,
-0.0344560705,
-0.0116361063,
0.0277594253,
0.0291501433,
-0.0154849989,
-0.0228806566,
0.0274392888,
-0.0509373434,
-0.0136967571,
0.0380768962,
0.0062605077,
-0.0116810221,
-0.0232290924,
0.0712436959,
-0.114021562,
-0.056065619,
0.0022567022,
-0.0499897487,
-0.0141461212,
0.0272814743,
0.0687507242,
0.0092774676,
-0.0427554883,
-0.00039059,
-0.0112874079,
0.0022169002,
-0.002794873,
0.01341685,
0.0306717809,
0.0387032293,
0.0044597792,
0.0359662212,
0.035531003,
0.0068246461,
-0.0223542117,
-0.0564430617,
-0.0103428178,
-0.0043312353,
-0.0175640713,
0.0059574307,
-0.0583235621,
-0.0250236597,
0.012128938,
-0.0687920228,
-0.0068684435,
0.0044714813,
2.639e-7,
0.0150279803,
0.044524435,
0.0292619448,
0.0306995176,
0.0282134507,
0.0188390762,
-0.0448376276,
0.0619719923,
-0.0067170449,
-0.0006622834,
0.0144529538,
0.049996078,
0.0654670149,
-0.0076242262,
-0.1083981171,
-0.0071473648,
-0.0542137139,
0.0000260533,
-0.0720028207,
0.002741822,
0.0435180105,
0.1286685765,
0.0206206832,
0.0062494408,
-0.0003541131,
-0.0356924497,
0.066974327,
-0.0155845201,
-0.0354967378,
0.0532179065,
0.0137037728,
0.0350946672,
-0.0117419967,
-0.0100837806,
-0.000826893,
0.0419033356,
0.0039820108,
0.1163434833,
0.0132191628,
-0.0114205312,
0.0133200828,
-0.0269669164,
-0.0398116745,
-0.0776219219,
0.074505426,
-0.050117135,
-0.0352568664,
-0.0458621047,
-0.0039321505,
-0.0135751944,
0.0110022314,
-0.0179428067,
-0.0212427564,
0.0366859846,
0.0268643182,
-0.0174591932,
-0.0306994133,
-0.0825543478,
-0.0185627751,
0.0235672034,
-0.054066442,
-0.040395245,
-0.0057393508,
-0.0140273254,
0.0176526215,
-0.0367231444,
0.0274141971,
2.322676048e-34,
0.0423650704,
-0.0138953347,
0.0036773526,
0.0190282147,
0.0304050613,
-0.03415557,
-0.0039495439,
0.0319641083,
0.0031501397,
-0.0880296752,
-0.0126732253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19840v1 | AnomaLLMy -- Detecting anomalous tokens in black-box LLMs through low-confidence single-token predictions | 2024-06-28T11:28:44 | 2024-06-28T11:28:44 | Waligóra Witold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces AnomaLLMy, a novel technique for the automatic
detection of anomalous tokens in black-box Large Language Models (LLMs) with
API-only access. Utilizing low-confidence single-token predictions as a
cost-effective indicator, AnomaLLMy identifies irregularities in model
behavior, addressing the issue of anomalous tokens degrading the quality and
reliability of models. Validated on the cl100k_base dataset, the token set of
GPT-4, AnomaLLMy detected 413 major and 65 minor anomalies, demonstrating the
method's efficiency with just \$24.39 spent in API credits. The insights from
this research are expected to be beneficial for enhancing the robustness of and
accuracy of LLMs, particularly in the development and assessment of tokenizers. | [
0.0592544228,
0.0608728342,
-0.0202172082,
0.0702891722,
-0.0417725518,
-0.0103841592,
0.0157614946,
0.0315091014,
0.0016002898,
-0.0295658521,
0.0214962494,
-0.0502871126,
0.0013319053,
0.0647372752,
0.032083299,
0.0253975857,
0.0847343132,
-0.0428964049,
0.0279968772,
-0.0100377472,
-0.028594235,
0.0004273259,
0.0326046571,
0.0596780367,
-0.0064848494,
-0.0194420628,
0.0025005962,
-0.0017929549,
-0.035069745,
-0.038234178,
-0.0183127746,
0.0396704525,
-0.0346033126,
0.1134508848,
0.0000018589,
-0.0801845938,
-0.0464498512,
0.005935662,
-0.0201219823,
0.0409916043,
0.0099655464,
0.0112976534,
-0.0137028173,
0.0149523299,
-0.0135340365,
-0.0008031955,
0.029079821,
0.0123366024,
0.01683392,
0.0575632006,
-0.0048320792,
0.0338582359,
0.0130476961,
0.0031609018,
-0.0222226139,
0.0151783898,
0.0384410769,
-0.048750177,
-0.0084945569,
0.0012546533,
-0.0208896603,
-0.0171211753,
0.0151196402,
-0.0327589437,
-0.0224738158,
0.0052925693,
-0.071651347,
-0.0529349744,
0.0117201069,
0.006590846,
-0.0050673941,
-0.0212091878,
0.0187162329,
0.0016010259,
0.0182841215,
-0.0059635136,
-0.0343098119,
0.0387980491,
0.0017760802,
0.0191277228,
0.0619713664,
-0.04892141,
0.0350687392,
-0.0059810062,
-0.0322407782,
0.1103726625,
0.0228643399,
-0.0318198018,
-0.0389031284,
-0.0074129924,
-0.0420002341,
-0.0561131276,
0.0002614867,
0.0193616673,
-0.0547231734,
0.0075775962,
-0.0069020004,
-0.0299960468,
0.0568432175,
-0.0258904845,
-0.0251563862,
0.0187804997,
-0.0691827983,
0.0398792326,
-0.0265291426,
0.0656278804,
0.017122481,
0.0479354002,
0.0118953362,
0.0077794315,
0.0205222685,
-0.0213228203,
-0.0385571942,
0.0551038645,
-0.018388385,
-0.0014821844,
-0.0353688896,
0.0235350486,
0.0050087771,
0.0393453799,
-0.0139171612,
-0.0226214081,
0.0085184854,
-0.0160648581,
0.00731315,
-0.0347937196,
0.0147787621,
-0.0074997232,
-0.0327746123,
-0.0794331804,
-0.0260340814,
0.0301603004,
-0.0218876209,
-0.0272034071,
0.013593141,
0.0898878127,
0.0330374949,
-0.0019820083,
-0.0379123613,
-0.0500985608,
-0.0323490538,
-0.0185742564,
-0.0229644738,
-0.0596494637,
-0.0548776537,
0.0235300604,
0.0118474336,
-0.0054357019,
0.0012857319,
-0.0330980085,
-0.0373216309,
0.0282262359,
-0.0496697202,
0.0163574796,
-0.0267710444,
-0.0042430749,
-0.0053579705,
0.0860506743,
-0.004037214,
0.0173130073,
0.0800484195,
-0.0152645977,
0.0313886181,
0.0551554263,
0.0052259481,
0.0348778032,
-0.035112448,
-0.0044862526,
0.0254950412,
0.0088450322,
0.022664452,
0.0474133082,
0.0054735239,
-0.0074425503,
0.0236308854,
0.0654505938,
-0.0577804819,
0.0072485916,
0.0155659663,
-0.0433865041,
-0.0200183094,
-0.0020559567,
-0.048763521,
-0.0260621589,
-0.0120749632,
0.002663594,
0.0270067751,
0.0452431254,
0.0154307904,
-0.04272696,
-0.0534743555,
-0.0092182718,
-0.0429784395,
-0.0361472517,
0.0679782331,
-0.038663689,
-0.03252903,
0.0359318554,
0.0192077234,
-0.0299769677,
0.0104974937,
-0.0842631683,
0.0665423125,
0.0380313881,
0.0725246891,
-0.0364012495,
-0.0055778469,
-0.0119202472,
-0.0267088581,
0.0614017136,
-0.001362908,
0.0063067419,
0.016321307,
-0.0153225455,
-0.0115438662,
0.0033314324,
0.0529706404,
0.0152470563,
0.0021870018,
0.0372385792,
0.0047269184,
-0.0826528296,
-0.041334115,
0.0387978926,
0.0021243975,
-0.0241648369,
0.0028057147,
-0.0003976358,
0.03259198,
0.0269763321,
0.0053957449,
0.0147384387,
0.0305449534,
-0.020332789,
-0.0131985284,
0.0292732213,
-0.0139940158,
0.0392040648,
0.0844719708,
0.0038217143,
-0.0097576566,
0.0455529392,
-0.0237843581,
-0.0527344421,
0.0346492268,
-0.0188856907,
0.0915926173,
-0.0298562329,
0.07317774,
-0.0335423909,
0.0514168479,
-0.0064746919,
-0.0013750715,
-0.0214875303,
0.0632807016,
0.0066566723,
-0.0052633532,
0.0406918265,
-0.0074923122,
-0.0595418066,
0.0266933292,
-0.0302095842,
0.0096135521,
0.0091042686,
0.0122597516,
-0.0294287633,
-0.00576689,
-0.0628709644,
-0.0205622595,
-0.0292441305,
0.0295169298,
0.0283540804,
0.0067182006,
-0.0438578278,
-0.0065880478,
0.0249870922,
-0.0572915971,
0.0214379374,
0.0272606481,
0.0448210798,
-0.0110508725,
-0.0540284365,
-0.0220400207,
0.003686964,
-0.0307176393,
0.0539573207,
0.0180577151,
-0.0070741046,
-0.0803239271,
0.0202564579,
-0.0039043401,
0.0074408613,
-0.0010782121,
-0.0737420991,
0.000669641,
-0.0380586535,
-0.0073767123,
0.0327808931,
-0.0089568468,
0.0159350485,
0.0368338712,
-0.027811585,
-0.0602530725,
-0.0288247913,
0.0181446001,
-0.0219944417,
-0.0123128388,
-0.0343240425,
0.0376469903,
0.0410544835,
-0.0092515387,
-0.0354597159,
-0.0248880424,
0.0066321581,
-0.0355087966,
-0.0119667696,
0.0299916677,
-0.0299992468,
-0.0477919616,
0.0430066548,
0.0190168936,
-0.0674336255,
0.0342094973,
-0.0670004338,
-0.0118796276,
-0.0160207264,
-0.0093858819,
-0.0391935632,
0.0289925523,
0.010851549,
0.0141886706,
0.0025864199,
-0.0894628614,
0.0066213133,
0.0096336156,
-0.006161462,
-0.0169343539,
0.0424043499,
-0.021024758,
0.009995996,
-0.0064073806,
0.0060004559,
-0.0287963655,
-0.0213198718,
-0.0412699208,
-0.0204402842,
0.0248314962,
-0.0543453246,
-0.0229930263,
0.0468621738,
-0.0381156243,
0.0563615747,
-0.0181469359,
0.0067311195,
-0.0164224077,
-0.0115641728,
0.0150469542,
-0.0481837243,
0.0335132591,
-0.0388193056,
0.0193458963,
0.0337434374,
0.0183997564,
0.0078020273,
-0.0232392661,
-0.0383289196,
0.0265575256,
-0.0301989969,
-0.0189494826,
0.0184546616,
0.0154118277,
-0.0525438674,
-0.0421777777,
0.1352071017,
0.0292927772,
-0.0422294959,
0.0205655973,
-0.0605342537,
0.0517082475,
0.0189041868,
-0.0037879113,
-0.088597849,
-0.0003094729,
0.0333006084,
0.0406745709,
-0.032900665,
-0.0285003297,
0.0097649265,
-0.1288970709,
0.036942102,
0.0230600294,
-0.0663120076,
-0.0256142206,
-0.0359249525,
0.0050901333,
-0.0348529629,
0.0864081457,
0.0245471075,
0.0085420068,
0.0205087513,
0.0193706769,
-0.1013904288,
-0.0393283293,
0.017112162,
-0.0310807396,
0.0712975934,
0.0132311108,
-0.0103628673,
-0.0660645738,
0.0182605013,
0.058585614,
0.0561345257,
-0.008981728,
-0.0219368748,
0.0233014524,
0.0405723192,
-0.0146873482,
0.0135057839,
-0.0038003593,
-0.0775317028,
-0.0018911597,
0.0085809771,
0.084799841,
-0.0240299441,
-0.0257554632,
-0.0179002285,
-0.0281079412,
-0.0043539698,
0.0595555902,
0.0192586109,
-0.0319782235,
-0.0472142808,
-0.0187418964,
-0.0133209899,
-0.0310663301,
0.0394014157,
0.0051443046,
0.0115519073,
-0.0439341888,
-0.0576468334,
0.0011620839,
0.0137477405,
0.0304779913,
0.0244546048,
0.046360787,
-0.0472907685,
-0.0183893237,
-0.0005445906,
0.0005764584,
-0.0103084669,
0.026274208,
-0.1036458686,
0.0508465208,
0.018525552,
0.0270333011,
-0.0289586186,
0.0200495366,
-0.0748886988,
-0.0866783112,
0.0335169062,
0.0175128952,
0.0302432664,
0.0311856717,
-0.0217613894,
-0.0216968432,
0.0368769094,
0.0722942725,
-0.0167849101,
0.016907461,
0.0067853201,
-0.0164222382,
0.0100128576,
0.0120329978,
-0.0244588628,
-0.0358422957,
0.0146630257,
0.011104865,
-0.0354204811,
0.0172644537,
-0.0033609343,
0.0661952719,
0.0506286137,
-0.0376772881,
0.0066125896,
-0.0142586958,
0.0330637619,
-0.030957412,
0.0056872517,
-0.0184775498,
0.0455845743,
-0.0098075951,
-0.0132121472,
-0.0066634747,
-0.0399262086,
-0.0460052192,
0.0398680717,
-0.0056487662,
0.0171963833,
-0.0050674723,
0.0201534033,
0.0682178438,
-0.0237135459,
0.0247422047,
-0.0197313894,
0.0051765577,
0.0536133572,
-0.0113358302,
0.0056595947,
0.0039213402,
0.0106607033,
0.0206772164,
0.02756829,
-0.0301957242,
-0.0237989631,
-0.0216081496,
0.0284496844,
0.0472236313,
-0.0073475679,
0.0407900959,
-0.0369823314,
0.0051550316,
-0.0118543133,
0.0229260046,
0.0104039768,
0.0122680441,
0.0036609364,
0.0078190323,
-0.0615511946,
0.0212414041,
0.0648856834,
0.0118933665,
0.0479163192,
0.0142548718,
-0.0151073756,
-0.0093195904,
0.0027977224,
0.0374418162,
0.0013988748,
-0.0475694239,
-0.035798531,
-0.0519507714,
-0.066708371,
-0.0039002676,
0.0228132457,
-0.0125660403,
0.0076683671,
-0.04743338,
0.1015682146,
0.0230609048,
-0.015877841,
-0.0366083086,
-0.0203865841,
0.0220978484,
-0.0323597081,
-0.000755609,
-5.924999195e-33,
-0.0096717225,
-0.0765672475,
-0.0445146672,
-0.0265859347,
0.0077010854,
-0.013924065,
-0.0089720525,
-0.0114220083,
0.0246264096,
-0.001060694,
-0.0066580744,
0.0157315973,
0.0218803305,
-0.0074228477,
0.0545934625,
0.0223430023,
0.0364979766,
0.0408333316,
-0.0161389261,
0.0053526689,
0.0588617474,
0.0176685695,
0.0741675943,
-0.0346975215,
0.0472411178,
-0.0094814636,
-0.0184874106,
0.0412422828,
-0.013668431,
0.0496958718,
0.0176953431,
0.0344126001,
0.0018167435,
0.0075139147,
-0.0174287278,
-0.0624951124,
-0.0004009985,
-0.0189428199,
0.0446187519,
0.0407513864,
0.0398088805,
-0.0388588309,
0.0501305982,
0.0016526233,
-0.0132436324,
0.0213329121,
0.0142895132,
-0.0180737432,
-0.0221643839,
0.0343656689,
-0.025478797,
0.0193034057,
-0.0336253606,
0.0732386485,
0.0154112699,
-0.0197190791,
0.0203397926,
-0.0043739853,
-0.0143577494,
0.020307038,
0.0604942702,
0.0201782547,
0.0581849813,
0.0251637232,
-0.0091950307,
0.0486281738,
0.0303787235,
-0.0007433328,
0.0130718956,
0.0216500033,
0.0383315869,
0.0245663095,
0.023383582,
0.0266585052,
0.0256548356,
-0.0303847305,
-0.0471934043,
0.0222397279,
-0.0010849375,
0.0245616399,
0.0528256446,
-0.0105400551,
-0.0456695482,
-0.0195189174,
0.0060194838,
-0.038056612,
-0.0217734035,
-0.031343542,
0.0101776291,
-0.0224991534,
-0.0208825376,
-0.0376289859,
0.0184573848,
-0.0632666275,
-0.0393557064,
-0.0157127474,
-0.0197467059,
-0.0071094842,
-0.0105375051,
0.0345117301,
0.0107503524,
-0.0222435743,
-0.0028409625,
-0.0119660357,
0.0429469049,
0.0085506262,
0.0163902007,
0.0365260839,
-0.0919753611,
0.0291818231,
-0.019749932,
0.018299384,
-0.0156545341,
-0.0233722664,
0.0189134963,
-0.0572839305,
-0.0049539204,
0.0307879914,
0.0470811687,
0.030262636,
-0.0523963794,
0.050113216,
-0.0207259655,
-0.0055937711,
-0.0416693501,
-0.0295615364,
0.0080172084,
0.0244988278,
0.0758861303,
-0.0297789611,
-0.0091143902,
-0.0203822553,
2.595e-7,
0.0272135157,
0.0561559238,
0.0168678686,
-0.0070751254,
0.0197305176,
0.0335866772,
-0.0339793265,
-0.0035789956,
-0.0044027623,
0.0151354875,
0.0054222159,
-0.0512623116,
0.0370377228,
0.0398057923,
-0.0709807351,
0.0359889157,
-0.0949071571,
-0.0395461395,
-0.0952190608,
0.0042212182,
-0.0038402877,
0.0855772346,
0.0304686204,
-0.044582352,
-0.0036724606,
-0.089049004,
-0.0137691256,
-0.0163191296,
-0.0219824798,
0.0258494392,
0.0370515995,
0.0322437957,
0.0681349486,
0.0225758515,
-0.0184574779,
-0.0001984855,
-0.0182570182,
0.0192187224,
-0.0255773384,
0.0087549752,
-0.0187760424,
-0.0413535051,
0.0097830882,
-0.087360777,
0.052572839,
0.0410297289,
-0.00274089,
-0.0503604338,
-0.0222696252,
-0.0512181818,
0.0001597577,
-0.0345124267,
0.0077663106,
0.0687011331,
0.0002643964,
-0.0113147199,
0.0260954127,
-0.0335536525,
-0.033598695,
-0.0401680693,
-0.0502777919,
-0.0667568594,
0.0218465663,
0.0119808456,
-0.0103026386,
-0.0203816071,
0.027472036,
2.953013312e-34,
0.0737724602,
-0.0054645911,
0.0172259156,
0.0472446159,
0.037914332,
0.0022916347,
0.0266127829,
0.0341408774,
-0.0239127688,
-0.0342554003,
-0.0228818469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19820v1 | BeamAggR: Beam Aggregation Reasoning over Multi-source Knowledge for Multi-hop Question Answering | 2024-06-28T10:53:48 | 2024-06-28T10:53:48 | Zheng Chu, Jingchang Chen, Qianglong Chen, Haotian Wang, Kun Zhu, Xiyuan Du, Weijiang Yu, Ming Liu, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong reasoning capabilities.
Nevertheless, they still suffer from factual errors when tackling
knowledge-intensive tasks. Retrieval-augmented reasoning represents a promising
approach. However, significant challenges still persist, including inaccurate
and insufficient retrieval for complex questions, as well as difficulty in
integrating multi-source knowledge. To address this, we propose Beam
Aggregation Reasoning, BeamAggR, a reasoning framework for knowledge-intensive
multi-hop QA. BeamAggR explores and prioritizes promising answers at each hop
of question. Concretely, we parse the complex questions into trees, which
include atom and composite questions, followed by bottom-up reasoning. For
atomic questions, the LLM conducts reasoning on multi-source knowledge to get
answer candidates. For composite questions, the LLM combines beam candidates,
explores multiple reasoning paths through probabilistic aggregation, and
prioritizes the most promising trajectory. Extensive experiments on four
open-domain multi-hop reasoning datasets show that our method significantly
outperforms SOTA methods by 8.5%. Furthermore, our analysis reveals that
BeamAggR elicits better knowledge collaboration and answer aggregation. | [
0.0121922325,
0.0385868624,
0.0123899188,
0.0273642577,
-0.0490176715,
0.0056705722,
-0.0051738867,
-0.0482499674,
0.0184942186,
-0.0272452645,
-0.0102770338,
-0.0285772178,
-0.028754903,
0.0185829829,
-0.0049231802,
-0.0049185562,
0.0525910929,
-0.041669447,
0.011439316,
-0.0409317613,
0.008591665,
0.0502025485,
-0.0362103023,
0.0141491443,
-0.0081845727,
-0.0411848724,
-0.0033670068,
-0.0075545046,
0.0106173735,
-0.0038912576,
0.0078271944,
0.0228481889,
0.0139749702,
-0.0061038448,
0.0000018997,
-0.0393697843,
-0.0464720763,
0.0061185295,
-0.0284465104,
-0.0093365218,
-0.0264184717,
0.0298492722,
0.0253612157,
0.0440982506,
-0.0493159555,
0.0079773553,
0.0181793347,
0.0498080738,
0.0801350176,
0.0174927078,
0.0139444005,
-0.0441696085,
0.0336922109,
-0.0062673315,
0.0429997332,
-0.0664552748,
0.0353869461,
0.0399428569,
0.036033053,
0.0447531864,
-0.0016964378,
0.0244880449,
0.0223079231,
0.0019130377,
-0.0089394702,
0.036994908,
-0.0542370938,
0.0195621178,
-0.0146156074,
0.0903779939,
0.033726301,
-0.0088477638,
-0.0041915085,
0.0187553335,
-0.0105500342,
0.0153341657,
-0.0634387136,
0.0204951726,
-0.0402373746,
-0.0088951942,
-0.0201222673,
-0.0076150782,
0.021265924,
0.018123107,
-0.0476003885,
0.1205620319,
0.021515118,
-0.0142645966,
-0.0003616927,
0.015105403,
-0.0349582657,
-0.0364091806,
-0.0054000164,
0.0673081651,
-0.0369089618,
0.0425827317,
0.0224209279,
0.0217986722,
0.021495562,
0.0004474945,
-0.0278243404,
0.0354961976,
-0.0042258031,
0.0961728767,
-0.0174794402,
0.0121783093,
-0.0374150015,
-0.0192238148,
-0.0616038665,
-0.0779705346,
-0.0662429482,
-0.0278146528,
-0.0146370381,
0.0710036457,
-0.0532631651,
-0.014009825,
-0.0214479361,
0.014089901,
-0.018093871,
-0.0337456092,
0.0002939811,
0.0331739672,
0.0327717513,
-0.0271179657,
-0.0299756639,
0.0789464787,
-0.0723927245,
0.0231528897,
0.0228862725,
-0.0423154198,
-0.0323455743,
0.0119606843,
-0.0005008981,
-0.0214231648,
-0.0024826117,
0.0147979194,
-0.0303859189,
0.0074162832,
-0.0050386516,
-0.0623699352,
-0.0313630402,
-0.0455386527,
0.0400612317,
-0.0826876312,
0.0726256371,
0.0346844904,
-0.027664667,
-0.0180282183,
0.0105212647,
0.0351905413,
-0.040102426,
0.0488884524,
0.0182864331,
0.0072015882,
0.0460480601,
0.0375267714,
-0.0323655568,
0.0515941419,
-0.0204870049,
0.0160083007,
0.0302881058,
0.0318458267,
0.0077815754,
-0.0041217688,
0.0395448916,
0.0179544184,
0.0609483458,
0.0494931825,
-0.0286431257,
-0.0221043788,
0.0058784974,
0.0372964703,
-0.0395298079,
0.0011416241,
-0.0062267128,
0.0491901673,
0.0151803102,
-0.041815687,
-0.0103289848,
0.0198267493,
0.0183094293,
0.0037140616,
-0.0092932079,
0.0599498786,
-0.0575901344,
-0.006710506,
0.0433206521,
0.0656863376,
-0.0468695387,
-0.0150708854,
-0.0164660327,
0.0086541614,
-0.0281576812,
0.0559656993,
0.0435153209,
-0.0118220681,
-0.0132278055,
0.0881678537,
0.0484715253,
-0.0200806819,
-0.008747682,
-0.019102348,
0.0549620092,
0.0096596936,
0.0564642511,
-0.0453366004,
-0.0471014604,
0.0258693919,
0.0105662197,
-0.0214641169,
0.0320359245,
-0.0235552713,
-0.0102271102,
-0.0294387657,
-0.0303663071,
-0.0169052985,
0.0040759086,
0.0371122584,
0.0215884242,
-0.0140368007,
-0.0000319877,
0.0023226906,
0.0235224962,
0.0034638424,
-0.0168630071,
0.0153164919,
0.0097845206,
-0.028728094,
-0.0023398881,
0.0299475044,
-0.0044122082,
0.0493977629,
0.0383817181,
-0.0136304097,
-0.0717305318,
0.0026483128,
-0.0406124406,
-0.0527099073,
0.0357770398,
0.0024256189,
-0.0345458835,
-0.02226476,
-0.0552372374,
-0.0447562076,
0.0221742038,
-0.0105188312,
-0.003833717,
-0.0481150672,
-0.0194978267,
0.0487608574,
-0.0117288744,
-0.0615303442,
0.0877953842,
-0.0107845729,
0.0103032626,
-0.0259866714,
0.0146382926,
0.0273050889,
-0.0086047044,
0.0073730517,
0.0164352003,
-0.0198902134,
0.0058002421,
0.0177541655,
-0.0200800244,
-0.0714264885,
0.001452841,
-0.0734858364,
0.0241352059,
-0.0132221989,
0.0216042884,
0.0004100583,
0.0245647244,
0.0103517557,
0.0002864779,
-0.0595942475,
0.0058687222,
0.0153811835,
0.0291921292,
0.0174475871,
0.0200117864,
0.0370039232,
-0.0239673741,
-0.0138010783,
-0.051257588,
0.0409669206,
-0.0189402923,
0.0033695849,
-0.0379202217,
-0.0348172709,
-0.0819233358,
0.0211272128,
-0.0173285287,
0.003146203,
0.0109031042,
-0.0499607064,
0.0422615111,
0.0518462881,
-0.0267125797,
-0.0386664197,
0.0520089529,
-0.00719174,
-0.042370934,
0.0389360003,
-0.014067255,
0.0115112737,
0.0211278964,
0.008811878,
0.0083306413,
0.0270013493,
-0.0031070597,
-0.0256277341,
-0.0256976224,
0.0311191976,
-0.0063911243,
0.0137550477,
-0.0668412447,
-0.0253039785,
0.0359069556,
0.0407838635,
-0.0338263735,
0.0153993173,
0.0974129811,
0.003048741,
-0.0054761497,
-0.0566672124,
0.0078909909,
-0.0881473795,
0.0450217016,
-0.0361907855,
0.0135114361,
-0.0272487588,
-0.0001135074,
-0.0403916053,
-0.0039098095,
0.0100223999,
-0.0392712466,
0.0521982275,
-0.0615804121,
0.0317043401,
-0.0044476017,
-0.0433096401,
-0.0257219337,
-0.0238688458,
-0.0218738839,
0.0192438252,
-0.0204757359,
0.0021240788,
-0.0430600122,
-0.0066909548,
0.0433456525,
-0.01329384,
-0.0315278992,
0.0012890688,
0.0018975011,
0.0924252272,
0.0568883233,
0.0132751986,
0.0459196828,
-0.0080070831,
0.0182908867,
0.0916724354,
0.0551070273,
-0.008602187,
0.0179540683,
-0.012913526,
0.0264075361,
-0.0138070947,
-0.0042644157,
-0.02825973,
0.0612420924,
-0.0346194059,
0.0148221096,
0.0858332142,
0.0712331086,
-0.0123077519,
-0.0328465514,
-0.0470957607,
0.0259833932,
0.0129835475,
0.0545121953,
-0.0880868807,
-0.0482842624,
-0.0150648989,
0.004197285,
0.0373236015,
-0.0266595893,
-0.0091274381,
-0.1252833009,
0.0115069719,
-0.0046282769,
-0.0190783627,
-0.0335609615,
-0.0428353325,
0.0164132752,
0.0119271157,
-0.0453232378,
0.0377354398,
-0.0002755415,
0.0036973883,
0.0072032558,
-0.0079538859,
-0.0058993129,
0.0691771805,
-0.0099307336,
-0.0043602106,
0.0537779704,
0.0084781153,
0.0332895517,
-0.0367112905,
0.0106438268,
-0.0679886267,
0.0060591381,
-0.0292649586,
-0.0091817882,
0.0241549797,
0.0039396319,
-0.0227291603,
0.050150916,
-0.0368846804,
-0.0253077354,
0.0246355925,
0.0970758423,
-0.0195608307,
-0.0001568885,
-0.0229586214,
0.0059353015,
0.002043006,
0.070401676,
-0.0069402838,
0.0254696123,
-0.040560443,
-0.0376291685,
-0.0371572152,
-0.0070246067,
-0.0149053615,
0.0331560113,
0.0181473196,
0.0289116912,
-0.0853222758,
-0.0180539694,
0.0484107696,
0.02347764,
-0.0542626493,
0.0001600169,
-0.0002085406,
0.0269116722,
-0.0221335217,
0.0501184464,
-0.0474150255,
0.0089276312,
-0.0001364161,
0.0450709797,
0.0570384674,
-0.0165660884,
-0.0427280106,
0.0188931301,
-0.0466433577,
-0.0657304376,
-0.022043271,
0.0047881999,
0.0233701747,
0.013215973,
-0.0466810577,
-0.0308956541,
0.0131898941,
0.009531714,
-0.0586584285,
0.000364674,
0.0084867748,
-0.0115076266,
-0.0218485445,
0.0270050019,
-0.0714697689,
0.0341310017,
-0.0294777993,
0.0668362901,
-0.034700457,
-0.0064178561,
0.0218226649,
0.0172411278,
0.0050196303,
0.0345200561,
-0.0187882222,
-0.0055445507,
0.0200449061,
-0.004804187,
-0.0349915847,
-0.0070291613,
0.0157858357,
-0.004481331,
-0.0719975233,
0.0099127432,
0.003817406,
0.0166021213,
0.0404833779,
-0.03038086,
-0.0309156012,
0.0460820347,
-0.0248489119,
0.0191438682,
-0.0244049504,
0.0014115939,
-0.0108413044,
-0.0003806271,
0.0518968999,
-0.0125977732,
0.0553929508,
0.0193785541,
-0.0119158039,
-0.0267259013,
-0.000680841,
-0.1074241474,
-0.0883474723,
0.027891079,
0.0206339397,
0.045437865,
0.03776085,
0.0324554034,
-0.0011889285,
-0.0304304101,
0.0009520582,
-0.0210966654,
0.011140544,
0.0001920956,
0.0579494722,
0.066140309,
0.002886418,
0.0128200734,
0.0849606469,
-0.0593168736,
0.0193547234,
-0.0279250182,
-0.0000430722,
-0.0081794383,
-0.0494851135,
-0.0269428957,
0.0263628513,
-0.023300685,
0.000788464,
-0.0683834329,
-0.0340151154,
-0.0006644026,
0.0034983286,
-0.0223822296,
-0.0153368628,
0.0430811867,
0.0666990057,
0.0155081749,
-0.0242628101,
-0.0261038058,
-0.0000088589,
-0.0728942305,
-0.0100246295,
0.00596538,
-6.661821829e-33,
-0.0199438687,
-0.0385979898,
0.0545027368,
-0.0096528819,
-0.0278992504,
0.0103835091,
-0.0150193656,
-0.0154629126,
-0.0679979473,
-0.0032989029,
-0.0030170397,
0.0332611538,
-0.0080509894,
0.0316240303,
0.0117451288,
-0.0158013906,
-0.0145759741,
0.0204850771,
-0.0175873339,
0.0263603535,
0.0515373424,
-0.0006060763,
-0.0005346369,
-0.012913567,
0.0186015032,
-0.0087160701,
0.0073817982,
0.0470615365,
-0.0483282655,
0.0449456424,
-0.002126382,
0.0095553156,
0.0218530949,
-0.0544070341,
0.0273748599,
0.0379252955,
-0.087247178,
-0.0446044579,
0.0305215139,
-0.0526489019,
-0.0391708203,
-0.0226401724,
-0.0159313921,
0.0052620098,
0.0631108508,
-0.0482648574,
0.0053781704,
-0.0130442223,
-0.0175066702,
-0.0372112244,
-0.0098382393,
0.0274107158,
-0.0234977342,
-0.0220638383,
-0.0398411416,
0.0707870424,
0.0255337469,
0.0598476417,
-0.048344519,
0.0364929177,
-0.0273492094,
0.0174716227,
0.0434879847,
-0.017381439,
-0.0003718254,
0.0361283384,
0.0084017953,
-0.032525979,
-0.0546519458,
-0.0192615762,
-0.045475021,
0.0466069505,
0.0552290827,
0.0132883778,
0.0053474763,
0.0496542305,
-0.1004855782,
0.0376426689,
0.0267115012,
0.0634128675,
-0.0089372564,
0.0129402969,
-0.0048478777,
-0.0270749182,
-0.0462041087,
0.0545945913,
-0.0404886231,
-0.0123006348,
-0.004099078,
-0.0049825618,
-0.0173235331,
0.0311088879,
0.0190596096,
-0.0450835936,
0.0110997176,
0.0755506977,
-0.0170299225,
0.0259431303,
-0.0153324772,
0.0691343546,
-0.0522218011,
0.0305329822,
0.015717959,
-0.0415258743,
-0.0190161634,
0.0286382083,
0.0197953451,
-0.0256851055,
-0.0317695178,
-0.0077566262,
-0.0363784507,
0.0104988609,
-0.034253262,
-0.0087981764,
0.0482504889,
0.0731381848,
0.0139171872,
0.0327015854,
0.0209265817,
0.0480344594,
-0.0262597837,
-0.0023382881,
-0.0227053035,
-0.0130095147,
-0.0085317139,
0.0202419925,
-0.0337401889,
-0.0131962691,
-0.0298017506,
-0.0364068337,
-0.0340084396,
0.0450785384,
2.685e-7,
0.0490295961,
0.0189471077,
0.0132364035,
0.0640450642,
0.0086304294,
0.017329365,
-0.0200223699,
-0.00489497,
0.0458885431,
-0.0238516387,
-0.034263052,
0.0705999136,
0.0356084108,
0.0623397976,
-0.0646762997,
-0.0068332357,
-0.0444316529,
-0.0651182383,
-0.0473001003,
-0.0361140668,
0.0643593967,
0.062567845,
-0.0006555669,
-0.0230812207,
-0.0250382647,
-0.036096029,
0.0734396577,
0.0540297404,
-0.0457277559,
0.0333764292,
0.0140729723,
-0.0081901709,
-0.0029839934,
0.0203672592,
-0.0013592045,
-0.0007990306,
0.0089916019,
0.0488319509,
-0.0036201254,
-0.0680462942,
-0.0176499039,
-0.0389373899,
0.0211537201,
-0.0176756158,
0.107176058,
-0.0298564266,
-0.0037458104,
0.0085295634,
-0.0217641033,
0.00438212,
-0.003239166,
0.0085709738,
-0.0032871021,
0.0005796449,
-0.0110687446,
-0.0133208763,
0.0307782572,
-0.0917178094,
-0.0172897186,
0.034248367,
-0.0115193268,
-0.0405248925,
0.0169087518,
-0.0332617499,
0.0235633962,
-0.0674196556,
0.0065514129,
2.30440285e-34,
0.0390530638,
-0.0064257318,
0.0026181466,
0.0255544391,
0.0451455116,
-0.0211157072,
-0.0613492243,
-0.0105907246,
0.0310127307,
-0.0915189013,
0.0129147507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00134v1 | A Simple Attention-Based Mechanism for Bimodal Emotion Classification | 2024-06-28T10:43:02 | 2024-06-28T10:43:02 | Mazen Elabd, Sardar Jaf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Big data contain rich information for machine learning algorithms to utilize
when learning important features during classification tasks. Human beings
express their emotion using certain words, speech (tone, pitch, speed) or
facial expression. Artificial Intelligence approach to emotion classification
are largely based on learning from textual information. However, public
datasets containing text and speech data provide sufficient resources to train
machine learning algorithms for the tack of emotion classification. In this
paper, we present novel bimodal deep learning-based architectures enhanced with
attention mechanism trained and tested on text and speech data for emotion
classification. We report details of different deep learning based
architectures and show the performance of each architecture including rigorous
error analyses. Our finding suggests that deep learning based architectures
trained on different types of data (text and speech) outperform architectures
trained only on text or speech. Our proposed attention-based bimodal
architecture outperforms several state-of-the-art systems in emotion
classification. | [
-0.0131725604,
0.0697365105,
-0.0194140188,
0.026563948,
0.0088888407,
-0.0089832665,
0.0452176407,
-0.0247460604,
0.0091220178,
-0.0787454695,
-0.0782214552,
-0.0615233071,
-0.0137287127,
0.0355689302,
0.039898701,
-0.090488717,
0.0427132063,
0.0826205686,
0.0498278998,
0.0027216347,
0.0434312224,
0.0149032762,
-0.0205330458,
0.0153241763,
-0.0599118359,
-0.0293322094,
-0.0331548266,
0.028860921,
0.0310140066,
-0.0405323729,
0.0299309753,
0.0223775785,
0.0425610505,
0.0318201557,
0.0000018422,
-0.0113164457,
0.0345372185,
-0.0047619957,
-0.0025152038,
-0.0093711587,
0.0690780059,
0.027394833,
-0.0121095665,
-0.0090772808,
0.0074762818,
-0.0330811851,
0.066787146,
0.0694600716,
0.1121660396,
0.0561829619,
-0.0291603301,
-0.0228425078,
0.0274485834,
-0.0293527581,
0.0215595365,
0.0103068538,
-0.0010242173,
-0.0499857217,
0.0018317284,
-0.0101189381,
-0.0417944193,
0.0290613845,
-0.0147196967,
0.0296711903,
0.0430853665,
0.0127875237,
-0.0354900733,
-0.0414730236,
-0.0055265408,
0.1090970188,
-0.0519344248,
0.0013904191,
-0.0177194811,
-0.0028850927,
0.01589863,
-0.0435490459,
0.0005838845,
0.0212494507,
-0.0157856867,
0.01096192,
-0.0311954692,
-0.0138028553,
0.0116390577,
-0.0339980721,
-0.0307414178,
-0.0185065567,
-0.0543752387,
0.0069485763,
0.0493947268,
0.0006416839,
-0.0409315005,
-0.0086793844,
-0.0005386553,
-0.0355197079,
0.0201348886,
-0.0284311362,
-0.0666228086,
-0.0514580943,
-0.0160707291,
-0.0480213352,
0.0150339026,
-0.0169025604,
-0.0923902243,
0.0440980047,
-0.0090454342,
0.033114329,
-0.0398773141,
-0.0019959407,
0.0044717644,
-0.0167220533,
-0.0105582783,
0.0483897142,
0.0085313814,
0.0006089269,
-0.0343081616,
-0.082225278,
-0.0552627854,
-0.0103208283,
-0.0351452231,
0.0046926532,
0.0073744329,
0.0262801722,
0.0209770426,
0.0171720181,
0.0059080408,
0.0109122694,
-0.0308618117,
0.0482360795,
0.0046792375,
-0.0592124797,
0.0193090755,
0.0689098388,
0.0235434808,
0.000196627,
0.0262729283,
0.0620413572,
0.0006369218,
-0.0320472308,
-0.0409073345,
-0.020672325,
-0.0164000988,
-0.0429402739,
0.0721801966,
-0.0060423776,
0.0535458513,
-0.0392606035,
0.0048141284,
-0.0268982332,
0.03274462,
0.0043497733,
0.0074090357,
0.0839721784,
0.0024865363,
-0.0271080583,
0.0026330634,
-0.0190441795,
-0.0077897594,
0.0191756357,
0.0698058158,
0.030101154,
0.0582114011,
-0.0263530556,
0.0535383858,
-0.0141220968,
0.0172893349,
-0.055421643,
0.0167468339,
-0.0304488465,
-0.0140120368,
0.0460877307,
0.0647205338,
0.0338968262,
0.0172016714,
-0.0455887988,
0.0654595271,
0.0154643552,
0.019327281,
0.0894610286,
-0.0100775752,
0.0214510523,
-0.0123662259,
-0.0568329804,
-0.0565324463,
0.0852344111,
-0.0134110423,
-0.0224159826,
0.0873491764,
-0.0032511388,
-0.0510763787,
-0.0237775184,
-0.0157112908,
-0.0349026322,
0.0079771411,
-0.0034467401,
0.0299292356,
-0.0156078599,
-0.054851152,
0.0039559975,
0.0151417209,
-0.0460363552,
-0.0222524758,
0.0060663098,
-0.0114170192,
0.0282323118,
-0.0460826829,
-0.0698842853,
0.0274443347,
-0.0491705053,
0.0210525449,
-0.0073790695,
0.0058400012,
0.0528467521,
0.028167244,
-0.0552599989,
0.003370916,
-0.0290185548,
-0.0156822763,
0.0083386339,
-0.0478387289,
0.0328751914,
-0.0187019054,
0.0136023723,
0.0364762396,
0.0045693442,
0.0370129868,
-0.0094303573,
0.0155021353,
0.0566464812,
0.0527053401,
0.0119008878,
-0.0094823362,
-0.0139055345,
0.0282076802,
-0.0142841181,
-0.0069926437,
0.0047028563,
0.0058505721,
-0.043146234,
0.0095911622,
-0.0388202704,
0.0170745775,
0.0574165024,
-0.0065150047,
-0.0001801183,
0.0543215945,
-0.0591745712,
-0.0208842941,
-0.0212025382,
-0.0014223893,
0.0210921131,
0.0798531547,
0.0086653009,
0.0052266647,
-0.024075117,
-0.024611678,
-0.0456784591,
0.0061669787,
0.0053319861,
-0.0284819994,
-0.0932464153,
-0.0039099995,
-0.0198050067,
0.0364835076,
-0.0088875471,
-0.0435152836,
-0.0298210941,
-0.0211774148,
-0.0417540483,
0.008359977,
0.0026065062,
-0.0051187216,
-0.0529619306,
0.0041455617,
-0.0059885653,
-0.0038874813,
-0.0384762362,
0.0659312457,
-0.0014509733,
-0.0278586801,
0.0242633671,
-0.0266157687,
0.033904817,
-0.0427490734,
-0.0096493224,
-0.0092937704,
0.0352247022,
-0.0168621819,
-0.0030076089,
-0.0186997782,
-0.0175759178,
-0.0273381453,
0.0887414739,
0.0025569608,
-0.0876037329,
0.0169016458,
-0.0260192864,
0.0103677213,
0.0915170684,
0.0021768434,
0.040943943,
0.0296861455,
0.0013567222,
-0.0010588919,
0.0875826478,
0.0293044299,
0.0417402014,
-0.0059475317,
0.0233104192,
-0.0467423089,
0.0206760205,
-0.0053131231,
-0.0038664893,
-0.0133915888,
-0.023647232,
0.0753560439,
-0.0082549285,
0.0303281732,
0.024447754,
-0.0162140206,
-0.029530542,
-0.0056183985,
-0.027033912,
-0.0010912403,
0.0169849154,
-0.0763625577,
-0.0275183097,
0.0245287921,
-0.0059112911,
0.0400431566,
-0.0337053426,
0.0315112993,
-0.0008398868,
0.0036281291,
-0.0209728982,
-0.0223573335,
-0.0328318141,
-0.040191073,
0.0312555544,
0.0428955965,
-0.0301339645,
0.0028081439,
-0.0119300662,
-0.0291009899,
-0.022910431,
-0.034947414,
-0.0172278807,
-0.0035392656,
-0.0069539631,
-0.067602329,
-0.0396004431,
0.0758662224,
-0.0322562903,
0.0371087343,
-0.0285902359,
0.0009025012,
0.034731321,
0.0089340294,
0.0616786815,
-0.0060782661,
-0.0207578167,
-0.0117039271,
0.0177327562,
0.0288453735,
0.0159162395,
-0.0497252382,
0.0191620067,
0.0083197141,
0.0003276132,
-0.0454014204,
-0.0041714516,
0.0047089169,
-0.0422774181,
0.0609045886,
0.0596977435,
0.0039547044,
-0.0508467592,
0.0073729842,
0.016864771,
-0.0407356359,
0.0254619084,
0.0043653217,
-0.0354301073,
-0.0866141915,
-0.010996026,
0.0255258549,
0.049263712,
-0.0120039266,
-0.0115782144,
-0.0546987467,
0.0017342805,
-0.0082814544,
-0.0217356831,
-0.0542448573,
-0.0085707856,
0.0471766479,
0.002222009,
-0.0336351991,
-0.0266075786,
0.015498626,
-0.0312077533,
0.0080905184,
-0.0453105792,
-0.0242734123,
0.0324631184,
-0.0541312583,
0.0262143109,
0.0184096806,
0.0709767938,
-0.0367813222,
-0.0663773865,
-0.0097743785,
0.0068206312,
0.0164040141,
-0.0088563832,
0.0547754504,
-0.0476250201,
-0.0284713469,
-0.0181021094,
0.0269859899,
-0.0225602239,
0.0334231295,
-0.02325546,
0.109088704,
-0.0028326274,
-0.0391917191,
-0.076043345,
0.041869361,
0.0317308456,
0.0064037717,
0.0202106945,
-0.0777663365,
-0.0579722524,
-0.0151815228,
-0.0073263049,
-0.0410941392,
-0.0380627513,
0.0202192068,
0.0098224338,
-0.0298630707,
-0.0241124555,
-0.0745470002,
-0.0008981688,
0.0130130555,
-0.0354166664,
-0.027539935,
0.0057925354,
0.0005358359,
-0.0488703549,
0.0342412852,
0.0404457003,
0.0347312205,
-0.0342281461,
-0.0141626429,
0.0132915135,
-0.0126440907,
-0.0052355495,
0.0147905825,
-0.0103665115,
-0.0262622312,
-0.0035926765,
0.0251762345,
-0.0021675921,
0.0125076268,
0.0157129206,
-0.0512605011,
0.0056419466,
0.0338631496,
-0.0278272126,
-0.0086253481,
0.0923763514,
0.0271715019,
-0.0133710587,
0.0150491586,
-0.0262780041,
0.0377274454,
-0.0266568176,
-0.0280417055,
-0.0217685979,
-0.0323963016,
-0.0440426692,
0.0190509837,
0.0697159544,
0.0239455774,
-0.0317106433,
-0.0421629846,
0.0110717304,
0.0552989542,
0.0053471951,
-0.0674818978,
-0.0042681885,
-0.0173771605,
-0.0389814712,
-0.048165489,
-0.0373459943,
0.0652536228,
-0.0633550137,
-0.0019130519,
0.1016218811,
0.0325543582,
0.0314831249,
-0.0552940331,
0.0441297591,
0.0146736996,
-0.0116250552,
0.0239906125,
0.0192122627,
0.0069023371,
0.0414883271,
-0.0031183301,
-0.037252713,
-0.009879319,
0.0494128205,
0.0242784731,
0.0280766599,
0.006218601,
-0.016251592,
0.028950993,
-0.0020174026,
0.0104648424,
0.0027800421,
0.0187868178,
-0.046837464,
0.0558575653,
-0.0451053269,
-0.0360407941,
-0.0109316725,
-0.0292088203,
-0.0145120015,
-0.020690525,
0.017509969,
-0.0349164493,
0.0001391406,
-0.0077760429,
-0.0005346623,
-0.0684797466,
0.0295714773,
0.0540424101,
0.0098333647,
0.0359352157,
0.0538078956,
-0.0088700941,
-0.0496231914,
0.0144100608,
-0.0293854214,
-0.0016823635,
-0.043042507,
0.0424508937,
0.0142652374,
0.0055094077,
0.0201385543,
-0.0486066751,
0.0216901936,
-0.0191178303,
0.0063146851,
0.0203973707,
-5.209230032e-33,
0.0103338417,
0.024878785,
-0.0306116994,
-0.0326365493,
-0.0570519976,
0.0213702694,
-0.0048364787,
0.0378868505,
-0.0366883278,
0.0241970755,
-0.0000846845,
0.0131044704,
-0.0210147742,
0.0040354193,
0.0146437092,
-0.0140936291,
-0.0141992541,
-0.0081499591,
0.0106293894,
0.0466341898,
0.0635624379,
0.0309182182,
0.078509599,
-0.0618196726,
-0.007134011,
0.0236744322,
-0.0269487388,
-0.0203800257,
0.0195739605,
0.0693140477,
-0.0132283242,
0.0625376105,
0.0036666279,
-0.0104179187,
-0.007856667,
0.0668274462,
-0.0421951227,
-0.0184338987,
-0.0435604937,
0.0272393301,
-0.0920833871,
-0.0128478315,
0.0640498772,
0.0327934735,
0.0150421215,
-0.0612916723,
0.0460146032,
-0.0027220815,
0.0206479151,
-0.0349584743,
-0.0135055678,
0.0163871609,
-0.0273064803,
-0.024593398,
0.0462737381,
0.040981397,
0.0159360711,
0.0175187606,
-0.0823987275,
-0.0215131473,
-0.0394316055,
-0.0115277506,
0.009463585,
0.0072792973,
-0.0220896862,
0.0655072331,
0.0504474938,
-0.0165664759,
-0.0118227834,
0.0400628671,
0.0496303849,
0.0579804853,
0.0522805378,
0.0214737188,
0.0138468575,
-0.0098736165,
-0.0516541339,
0.0282113105,
0.0355818495,
0.0223902222,
0.0497950129,
-0.010081809,
-0.0089616617,
0.0373641364,
0.023776982,
-0.0041396078,
-0.0448337458,
0.0036367737,
0.0160066858,
-0.0226624422,
0.0304420777,
0.0188867357,
0.0271846,
-0.009936301,
0.0079061454,
0.0122669004,
0.007440506,
0.0630110726,
0.0355159193,
-0.0057838894,
-0.0293968208,
-0.0059967111,
0.0314125866,
0.01106901,
0.0615182035,
-0.0054451828,
-0.0114200944,
0.028957691,
-0.0362946466,
-0.0415345952,
0.0099999681,
0.0106448177,
-0.0071462183,
0.0296886358,
-0.0212097764,
0.0102874171,
0.0079226876,
0.0342580788,
-0.0107059488,
0.0292120129,
-0.0248234812,
-0.0653219298,
0.0095016258,
0.0213661734,
-0.0282180812,
0.0057498058,
-0.0574689917,
-0.0430541933,
-0.0179128982,
-0.0743531883,
-0.0007561211,
0.0346736237,
2.578e-7,
0.0160618294,
0.0235616118,
-0.013380968,
0.0222694464,
0.0323793478,
0.0575826988,
-0.00610008,
0.1077004969,
0.0093004405,
-0.0234431047,
0.0329147242,
0.0150452331,
0.017688999,
-0.0124325957,
-0.0429864973,
-0.0311682988,
0.013129252,
0.049610015,
-0.0163950063,
0.0270878021,
0.082024388,
0.0892555937,
0.0358106904,
-0.0066565978,
0.0321291983,
0.0277529284,
0.0091856178,
0.0103514763,
0.0448429137,
-0.0186926629,
0.0283668581,
-0.023147326,
-0.0511989966,
0.0169650465,
0.0100519685,
-0.0221476555,
0.0247597676,
-0.0094215227,
-0.0167055279,
-0.0869230703,
0.0348582901,
0.0371292457,
-0.0360026248,
0.0011844183,
0.0602287948,
-0.0282621402,
-0.0384886861,
-0.0238444284,
-0.0426927917,
-0.0055937995,
0.0360940285,
0.0073437626,
-0.0548570603,
-0.0175402481,
-0.0051903795,
-0.0302178971,
-0.0073881727,
-0.1229401529,
0.0025320519,
0.0459636711,
-0.0413580127,
0.0030067789,
-0.0516597144,
-0.0061132987,
0.0633785948,
-0.0058222138,
-0.024234347,
1.444095958e-34,
0.0083956048,
-0.0155891012,
0.0026535483,
-0.022268232,
-0.0188270714,
-0.0162006132,
-0.0300288834,
-0.0336733274,
0.0534957908,
-0.0453512631,
-0.0314118899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19803v1 | Scalable and Domain-General Abstractive Proposition Segmentation | 2024-06-28T10:24:31 | 2024-06-28T10:24:31 | Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Yang Gao, Tim Baumgärtner, Alex Fabrikant, Reinald Kim Amplayo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Segmenting text into fine-grained units of meaning is important to a wide
range of NLP applications. The default approach of segmenting text into
sentences is often insufficient, especially since sentences are usually complex
enough to include multiple units of meaning that merit separate treatment in
the downstream task. We focus on the task of abstractive proposition
segmentation: transforming text into simple, self-contained, well-formed
sentences. Several recent works have demonstrated the utility of proposition
segmentation with few-shot prompted LLMs for downstream tasks such as
retrieval-augmented grounding and fact verification. However, this approach
does not scale to large amounts of text and may not always extract all the
facts from the input text. In this paper, we first introduce evaluation metrics
for the task to measure several dimensions of quality. We then propose a
scalable, yet accurate, proposition segmentation model. We model proposition
segmentation as a supervised task by training LLMs on existing annotated
datasets and show that training yields significantly improved results. We
further show that by using the fine-tuned LLMs as teachers for annotating large
amounts of multi-domain synthetic distillation data, we can train smaller
student models with results similar to the teacher LLMs. We then demonstrate
that our technique leads to effective domain generalization, by annotating data
in two domains outside the original training data and evaluating on them.
Finally, as a key contribution of the paper, we share an easy-to-use API for
NLP practitioners to use. | [
-0.0007670619,
0.021229513,
0.0199884083,
0.0178421475,
-0.0511175618,
0.0126929237,
0.0105464254,
-0.0254728794,
0.0007598519,
-0.0452760532,
0.0202753618,
-0.0186749008,
-0.030099012,
0.0022494204,
0.0059501119,
-0.0610535666,
0.0551593043,
0.0140980193,
0.0353697501,
0.0504929647,
0.0403819643,
-0.0162913576,
-0.0092629315,
0.0122326203,
-0.0390859097,
-0.0301571116,
-0.0076449253,
-0.0189885739,
0.0395950861,
-0.0507003106,
0.0103933075,
0.0437417887,
0.0321116857,
-0.01506761,
0.0000020442,
-0.0471000448,
-0.0819924995,
-0.0000057077,
-0.0208187364,
0.011600079,
0.0121221645,
0.0057378407,
0.0269641932,
0.0040391167,
-0.0551630966,
-0.01126693,
0.0033492728,
0.0970211551,
0.1002897471,
0.0846976787,
-0.0163105726,
-0.0628773943,
0.0121492259,
-0.0099346805,
-0.0184033085,
-0.0149142062,
0.0257107243,
0.0310363695,
-0.0313775353,
0.0235343948,
0.0159746855,
0.0085784132,
0.0200477298,
0.0193384066,
-0.0107851783,
0.028481245,
-0.0736895651,
-0.0448637046,
0.0081839664,
0.0585973114,
0.042098131,
-0.0200574063,
0.0225653648,
-0.0017380283,
0.0194440279,
-0.0461162776,
-0.0282848068,
0.0340980068,
-0.0427716114,
0.0553335547,
0.0298954081,
0.0185817517,
0.0069535095,
0.0168578569,
-0.0259269476,
0.0543961413,
-0.0284837689,
-0.0569127686,
0.0271065161,
0.0524648279,
-0.064955391,
-0.0351106599,
0.0312709436,
0.0153264944,
0.0059981653,
0.0199851915,
-0.0484879799,
-0.0288473349,
0.0107215215,
-0.0400257036,
0.0263572559,
0.000892052,
-0.0196310766,
0.0448251888,
-0.0188424978,
0.0167924277,
0.0036881811,
0.0444693528,
-0.0026377267,
0.0020637522,
-0.0651368126,
0.0119403163,
-0.0436770469,
0.0772405639,
-0.0530686788,
-0.0047530825,
-0.0273905192,
-0.0196364708,
-0.0108359167,
0.0310720447,
0.0069914591,
-0.0098099606,
-0.0299315806,
0.0135498317,
-0.0435116962,
0.0276778527,
-0.078796044,
0.0183899179,
0.0504701324,
-0.042241849,
-0.0247768983,
0.0069568665,
0.0157583449,
0.0076356139,
-0.0079428898,
0.0307777915,
-0.0242413878,
-0.0532771982,
-0.0930293649,
-0.056414485,
-0.0212196093,
-0.0772455111,
0.0255119242,
-0.0756250545,
0.020098323,
-0.0054843738,
-0.0040431456,
-0.030658802,
0.0096311839,
0.011732663,
0.0532033667,
0.0696602613,
0.0107958512,
-0.0028896232,
-0.0018091239,
0.0157606862,
0.0027716754,
0.0727246627,
0.0332220159,
0.0475992784,
0.0678223446,
0.0346269347,
0.0061093168,
-0.006897103,
0.0172450989,
0.0117784757,
0.0102195786,
0.0002557458,
-0.0250596292,
0.0090969913,
-0.0060457829,
0.052062735,
-0.0262224227,
0.0292479098,
0.0562829003,
0.0241998117,
0.0048239306,
-0.000024948,
0.0503700078,
0.0415185578,
-0.0019447177,
0.0444915034,
-0.0703921393,
-0.0023103245,
0.0292669237,
0.0331084095,
0.0287592709,
0.0223832801,
-0.012583917,
-0.0866049752,
-0.0080290344,
0.0026475945,
-0.0079714805,
-0.0268083271,
0.0410847701,
0.0632671565,
-0.0350423567,
0.0854840726,
-0.0020258704,
-0.0735525563,
0.0031979731,
-0.0186075196,
0.0010086152,
0.0060540186,
0.0078012594,
-0.0585536733,
-0.0101928441,
-0.0185207017,
0.0811411142,
0.0655584037,
0.0416930057,
-0.0153221516,
0.0129781673,
-0.0519986302,
-0.0127858557,
-0.0313110091,
0.0365929194,
-0.0331501737,
0.0324489623,
-0.018629536,
0.0242487099,
-0.0877935812,
0.0127061335,
0.0522698276,
-0.012540713,
-0.0504181013,
-0.0051865843,
0.0336271636,
0.0118574034,
0.0263512451,
-0.0078715002,
-0.0059104376,
0.0152550042,
-0.0410923734,
0.002691769,
-0.0083252527,
0.0055324854,
-0.0729799345,
0.014676109,
-0.0356277078,
-0.0373537093,
-0.0287734959,
-0.0905081406,
-0.0261875521,
-0.0275018588,
0.0081209056,
0.0055088685,
-0.0375717394,
0.0011811266,
0.0534212776,
-0.0095294639,
-0.034990266,
0.0818185881,
0.0030681053,
-0.0209511369,
-0.0287099387,
-0.0547441468,
0.0198359266,
-0.0246386193,
0.0073485896,
-0.0585780181,
-0.0316410698,
0.0082026524,
0.0106638344,
0.0126509499,
-0.0660741702,
-0.0031252659,
-0.0597348027,
0.0457161479,
-0.0382537991,
0.0386101156,
0.0247567464,
-0.0005987937,
-0.0072590164,
0.0010826418,
-0.0140995421,
-0.0266677067,
-0.0081646163,
0.0073293569,
0.0725243911,
-0.002594962,
0.0013366428,
-0.0324090607,
0.0075229472,
-0.0274283662,
0.0139882294,
-0.0173005331,
-0.0151253222,
-0.0437473841,
0.0502237864,
-0.002590233,
0.0298359655,
0.0249162037,
-0.0018730211,
0.004000132,
-0.0169007275,
0.0363044627,
0.0771044269,
-0.0075724106,
0.0315941945,
0.0201655999,
-0.0109713776,
-0.0260104779,
0.0323088579,
-0.0251718517,
0.0562842302,
0.001431428,
-0.0167931896,
0.0415803865,
0.0641504675,
0.0045545846,
-0.0095867924,
-0.024460854,
-0.0182652473,
-0.0386304148,
-0.0218486581,
0.0095932409,
0.0603374243,
-0.0191234406,
0.0394841358,
-0.038064532,
-0.0418883935,
0.0819073915,
-0.0444582999,
-0.0011010626,
-0.0429061055,
-0.0445569195,
-0.0335109718,
0.0409322232,
-0.0058778375,
-0.02658871,
0.0194933489,
-0.0310465116,
-0.0368825831,
-0.0115123624,
0.0151204243,
-0.0007050355,
0.1027530953,
-0.0554132983,
0.0000271907,
-0.0186340008,
-0.0267584417,
-0.0332470909,
-0.0292658303,
-0.0227537025,
0.0255673528,
-0.0275311619,
0.0406597927,
-0.0437988043,
-0.0106925089,
0.0015034298,
0.0503397696,
-0.0210646801,
-0.0089088688,
-0.0467432216,
0.0132375192,
0.0429324843,
0.0253620204,
-0.0022518113,
-0.0244656596,
0.0433185659,
0.061322853,
0.004422632,
-0.0160590913,
-0.0203218795,
-0.0065442505,
-0.029195264,
-0.065482311,
-0.0057357722,
0.0030780626,
0.0700114071,
-0.065808624,
-0.0478610508,
0.1097179204,
0.0301797353,
0.0384628922,
-0.0170356724,
0.0332247503,
0.0273834411,
0.0200780742,
-0.0041800323,
-0.0743899792,
-0.0481744297,
-0.0132975066,
-0.0030754923,
0.0180943049,
-0.0187282469,
-0.0050919475,
-0.092288442,
0.0315267481,
-0.0070161982,
-0.0339120291,
-0.0404438823,
-0.0573191233,
0.0148308203,
-0.0178584047,
0.0093644448,
-0.0270040762,
-0.0219848529,
-0.0054022945,
0.0264736284,
-0.0080629755,
-0.0191720482,
-0.0005654083,
-0.0432812683,
-0.016354546,
0.0511106327,
0.0204796307,
0.0105919736,
-0.0219081547,
0.0255486872,
-0.0336938947,
-0.0215932,
0.0119705405,
0.0660831556,
-0.0320558771,
0.0169032421,
0.0134449359,
0.0413349643,
-0.0257186275,
-0.0263478663,
0.0225603282,
0.0543344393,
-0.0284944568,
-0.010237419,
-0.0282526314,
0.0152357407,
0.0116614457,
0.0821342841,
0.0282379389,
0.0023916112,
-0.0542685688,
-0.0123324357,
0.005994258,
-0.0569692627,
-0.0193137918,
0.0019709808,
-0.0765588433,
0.0313666575,
-0.0829846635,
-0.0100980736,
0.0632504448,
0.0551881418,
-0.0279713031,
-0.0267564934,
0.0446719341,
0.0065140682,
-0.0501124673,
0.0273989569,
-0.0425655209,
-0.0099137332,
-0.0420264788,
-0.0003710134,
0.0447021611,
-0.0104063479,
-0.0385911837,
0.0290727895,
-0.0952883139,
-0.0497502685,
0.0059911031,
0.0082211858,
0.0134414118,
0.0358782746,
-0.0244513396,
0.0233141556,
0.0467055887,
0.0443707593,
-0.0108991014,
-0.0034794896,
0.045172926,
0.0283651222,
0.0089818723,
0.0136556029,
-0.0262161195,
0.0453165323,
0.0149172274,
0.0483104549,
-0.0159100033,
0.0047246893,
0.0266039148,
0.0341358334,
0.1061046496,
0.0177150164,
-0.0069733807,
-0.0384578779,
0.0027085077,
-0.0092220856,
-0.0201929435,
-0.0246699452,
0.0423375852,
0.0004393056,
0.0097637894,
-0.0386105776,
0.0367181227,
0.0035526296,
0.0509234443,
-0.0050294134,
-0.0183998607,
0.0205278564,
-0.0322373025,
-0.0070289816,
-0.0232864637,
-0.0291359015,
-0.0149966562,
-0.0055614859,
0.033535745,
-0.0003832624,
0.0373483337,
0.0379300825,
0.0249129478,
-0.057220757,
0.0363359191,
-0.0530496314,
0.0351289473,
-0.0479435921,
0.0821455047,
0.0206302647,
-0.0159790032,
0.0297977179,
-0.0164631754,
-0.0203651786,
-0.0027913612,
0.0490227602,
0.009793981,
-0.0156859159,
0.0007389779,
0.0340678506,
-0.0376268364,
-0.0203239638,
0.033415582,
-0.0588651523,
0.0460751131,
0.0243789144,
0.0249552559,
-0.0711147562,
-0.0322107002,
-0.0519210324,
0.0341450907,
0.0127528477,
-0.0158975124,
-0.0647974983,
-0.0551680438,
0.0261886008,
0.0305286795,
-0.0035035794,
0.0097939661,
0.0199234243,
0.0787564963,
0.0001208457,
-0.0586328246,
-0.0143006826,
-0.0214759316,
0.0174159706,
-0.0333791263,
-0.0283556171,
-6.12143679e-33,
-0.0424623676,
-0.006527571,
0.0238814894,
0.0091638146,
-0.0360962562,
0.016767988,
-0.0185968317,
-0.0137684606,
0.0017204212,
0.042023059,
-0.0222209468,
0.024470564,
0.0365190357,
0.0182834435,
0.0016289245,
-0.0320096314,
0.0796393827,
0.0028941622,
-0.0369759575,
0.0017836547,
0.0473919325,
0.0002484621,
0.0592740253,
-0.0192582812,
0.0047172192,
0.0382289104,
-0.028818531,
0.0566645823,
-0.0282252245,
0.0513730384,
0.0002919898,
0.0237964951,
0.0442134887,
-0.0571297333,
-0.0254850034,
0.0179325975,
-0.1131197959,
-0.0465957783,
0.0105366809,
-0.0252088849,
-0.0389368758,
-0.0023214598,
0.040056292,
-0.0030745899,
0.0350961983,
-0.0369971134,
0.0555917099,
-0.0303126294,
0.0195215903,
-0.0638624653,
-0.0718861669,
0.0200594068,
0.0096216938,
-0.0304277986,
0.0349014737,
-0.0059324969,
0.0137309758,
0.0268599261,
-0.0423219651,
0.020747833,
0.0106557617,
0.0487408452,
0.0012267437,
-0.0083258785,
-0.0253010206,
0.0675207227,
-0.0168928318,
0.0016142762,
-0.0226297025,
0.0168160796,
0.0180905703,
0.0642972216,
0.0072750379,
0.0527443513,
0.0475415699,
0.0052733012,
-0.0451315828,
0.0344034508,
-0.0056257951,
0.021249298,
-0.0302235968,
0.006950188,
-0.0249013975,
-0.0035369587,
-0.009831232,
-0.0074032741,
0.00208751,
0.0090014134,
0.0199221894,
0.0279470067,
-0.0606946126,
0.0039571472,
0.0255732667,
-0.0293608736,
0.0017389121,
0.0049781166,
-0.0105784312,
0.0074444991,
-0.0091163926,
-0.0223732274,
-0.0654908717,
-0.0393020064,
0.0141489534,
0.0109207258,
-0.0022459123,
-0.0088626826,
0.0482093804,
-0.0298933908,
-0.0451708697,
0.0172968097,
-0.0044168863,
0.0176007636,
-0.0239324048,
0.0570870377,
0.0271177124,
0.0266947504,
-0.0198585168,
0.0623874441,
0.0065926411,
-0.0165448189,
-0.0095616151,
0.0586132854,
0.0067426935,
0.0507771559,
-0.0198511519,
0.009589388,
-0.0069619906,
-0.030567443,
0.0211404786,
-0.0614419393,
-0.0019473113,
-0.0034946511,
2.701e-7,
0.0212577265,
0.0407402776,
0.0650821403,
0.0271624979,
-0.0229776017,
0.0416339077,
0.0419885479,
0.0009288419,
0.0084887901,
-0.0945010558,
0.000328626,
0.0215866398,
0.0454493426,
0.0557045378,
-0.1204148009,
0.0286309458,
-0.0151187433,
-0.0455180146,
-0.0498694107,
-0.0252733435,
0.0747869238,
0.0748426169,
0.0462322123,
0.0101366937,
0.007605576,
-0.0327604525,
0.0003269134,
0.0086050453,
-0.0093289809,
0.0412164554,
0.0051568234,
-0.0175281148,
-0.0026171533,
0.0215283055,
-0.0224447139,
0.0015940462,
-0.0063950866,
0.0974013731,
0.0350327417,
-0.0023955328,
-0.0276874993,
-0.0214799587,
0.0165647492,
0.0160621181,
0.0419556275,
-0.0885434225,
-0.0041478691,
-0.0267443508,
-0.015524691,
-0.0161794648,
0.0077312347,
0.0208599139,
-0.0043477211,
0.0220098402,
-0.0024509579,
0.0022013208,
-0.03118423,
-0.0652916506,
-0.0204528198,
0.0049443161,
-0.0108719142,
-0.0276242476,
0.0129982224,
-0.0058997078,
-0.0120335296,
-0.0923508778,
-0.0380009748,
2.793779745e-34,
0.027207721,
-0.031768132,
0.0272727832,
0.0278104655,
0.0469740331,
0.01264155,
-0.0779797584,
-0.0232950114,
-0.0366070867,
-0.0318613127,
0.0189204812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19783v1 | NLPerturbator: Studying the Robustness of Code LLMs to Natural Language Variations | 2024-06-28T09:39:33 | 2024-06-28T09:39:33 | Junkai Chen, Zhenhao Li, Xing Hu, Xin Xia | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) achieve promising results in code generation
based on a given natural language description. They have been integrated into
open-source projects and commercial products to facilitate daily coding
activities. The natural language description in the prompt is crucial for LLMs
to comprehend users' requirements. Prior studies uncover that LLMs are
sensitive to the changes in the prompts, including slight changes that look
inconspicuous. However, the natural language descriptions often vary in
real-world scenarios (e.g., different formats, grammar, and wording). Prior
studies on the robustness of LLMs are often based on random perturbations and
such perturbations may not actually happen. In this paper, we conduct a
comprehensive study to investigate how are code LLMs robust to variations of
natural language description in real-world scenarios. We summarize 18
categories of perturbations of natural language and 3 combinations of
co-occurred categories based on our literature review and an online survey with
practitioners. We propose an automated framework, NLPerturbator, which can
perform perturbations of each category given a set of prompts. Through a series
of experiments on code generation using six code LLMs, we find that the
perturbed prompts can decrease the performance of code generation by a
considerable margin (e.g., up to 21.2%, and 4.8% to 6.1% on average). Our study
highlights the importance of enhancing the robustness of LLMs to real-world
variations in the prompts, as well as the essentiality of attentively
constructing the prompts. | [
0.0416204296,
0.0498479642,
-0.0351972878,
0.039439667,
-0.0363513418,
-0.02403716,
-0.0219602715,
0.0144517748,
0.0153977722,
-0.0218517333,
0.0142773371,
-0.0188570209,
0.0166311506,
0.0466031544,
0.02870344,
-0.0408052653,
0.05290116,
-0.0610203743,
-0.0354922414,
0.0335271917,
-0.0117106875,
0.0235948805,
-0.0061479523,
0.0672165006,
0.0393555239,
-0.0206670891,
-0.0366847888,
0.0307765193,
-0.0178295113,
-0.0315436162,
0.0242659263,
0.0785588026,
-0.0190907605,
-0.0034127473,
0.0000023486,
-0.0701131597,
-0.0037977442,
0.0009643739,
0.0068798759,
0.0422026701,
0.0338874534,
0.0163433775,
-0.0203906167,
0.0264845733,
-0.0378125943,
0.0157562457,
0.0586459674,
-0.0269910321,
0.0701729953,
0.0408202857,
0.0099385083,
0.0345070101,
-0.027197009,
0.0240103044,
0.044208087,
-0.0151138529,
-0.0039468957,
-0.0010325195,
0.0499525033,
0.0201946441,
0.0000228196,
-0.0015478935,
-0.001967848,
-0.0091099273,
0.0040862369,
0.0334721357,
-0.0293385386,
-0.0163924899,
-0.0072495793,
0.0510480367,
-0.038895987,
-0.0039221412,
0.0243625958,
-0.0388340205,
0.0123618105,
-0.0125391949,
-0.0224404782,
0.021238856,
-0.019517228,
-0.0107669076,
-0.0153210303,
-0.0122425249,
0.0018434016,
0.018445991,
-0.0153293479,
0.0336355194,
0.0126870591,
-0.009976062,
-0.0468615629,
-0.0271860864,
0.0081453696,
-0.0926586166,
0.0063322093,
0.0511745326,
-0.0361568816,
0.0162939262,
-0.0686943904,
-0.0143885333,
0.0424769521,
-0.0434820689,
0.0405534953,
0.0534861535,
-0.0346939564,
0.0044081192,
-0.0299680866,
0.0850685537,
0.0068136761,
-0.0235467777,
-0.022757655,
0.0505108535,
-0.0342114307,
-0.0253549665,
-0.0349875018,
0.0415240861,
-0.0206959583,
0.021358585,
-0.0323713869,
0.0882889777,
0.0150715774,
0.0443348512,
-0.0196798518,
-0.0126701016,
-0.0230813399,
0.0025842888,
-0.0023996131,
-0.0279122405,
-0.0094838338,
-0.0321709365,
-0.0048151189,
-0.0773845613,
0.0045514386,
0.0203498453,
-0.0073862285,
-0.0092867203,
-0.0021752552,
0.1041050628,
0.0061273719,
0.0243086126,
-0.0516313165,
-0.0539103523,
-0.0072635612,
-0.0027232994,
-0.0486555919,
-0.0948311687,
-0.0292468835,
0.0422428176,
-0.0176899936,
-0.0775129646,
0.0225820486,
0.0299317036,
-0.006431018,
0.0612636767,
-0.0773431286,
0.0262855049,
0.0236613788,
-0.0027592957,
-0.0195429157,
0.0383558832,
0.0487359092,
0.0171317961,
0.0261282101,
-0.0470766835,
0.0451971516,
0.0477248766,
-0.0638230518,
-0.0064873151,
0.0063545653,
-0.0051017813,
0.0303163603,
0.0077714832,
0.0148628578,
0.038257733,
0.0044089356,
0.0288597401,
0.0401500687,
0.049670659,
0.0031114509,
0.054536175,
0.0539646633,
0.0391550995,
-0.0141706523,
0.0134782149,
-0.0430039987,
0.0455621965,
-0.0558177754,
0.0225438159,
-0.0164814945,
0.0397969075,
0.0047746147,
-0.0651138872,
-0.0217823684,
-0.0066171288,
0.0192592591,
-0.0353382342,
0.0065058148,
-0.001771141,
-0.0541560687,
0.0418351814,
-0.002008324,
-0.0677141622,
-0.0059783584,
-0.0509435087,
-0.0151998214,
0.1010933891,
0.0449767113,
-0.035689339,
-0.0218321867,
-0.0002210046,
-0.0091576995,
0.0083081424,
0.0614906773,
0.0092734722,
-0.0007030737,
-0.0492628999,
-0.0096854353,
-0.0449516997,
-0.0062704673,
0.045274891,
0.0179745778,
-0.0289246198,
0.0422896706,
0.020169396,
-0.0554298125,
0.0346238315,
-0.0195742901,
-0.0302947517,
0.0246920362,
-0.0215405151,
-0.0092491815,
-0.0267360751,
-0.0280607529,
0.0296278,
-0.0025074347,
-0.0120683741,
-0.0130018713,
0.0010752381,
-0.0248038191,
-0.0211112946,
0.0291116778,
0.018801203,
-0.0077059534,
0.0123318471,
-0.026076192,
-0.0129615339,
0.0325609371,
-0.031410601,
0.0060991365,
0.0132430959,
0.0432953686,
-0.0161545966,
-0.0171014071,
-0.0381109118,
0.0254035741,
0.0127714174,
0.0297340397,
0.0226774961,
0.073415108,
0.0164654125,
-0.0187647343,
-0.0180993043,
0.0128873447,
-0.035194423,
0.0302108265,
0.0267391969,
0.0562739559,
0.0019423144,
-0.0614807568,
-0.0574909262,
0.0005253963,
-0.0114077115,
0.0063438341,
0.0284552462,
0.0416648574,
-0.0290282834,
-0.0003827105,
-0.0227356404,
-0.0208766665,
-0.0022627055,
0.0136017706,
0.0464841351,
-0.0247969385,
-0.0692396685,
-0.0286924094,
-0.000132353,
-0.0328854062,
0.0250879023,
0.0333249234,
-0.0445585363,
-0.1155830771,
0.0721731782,
-0.0141444067,
-0.0102303363,
0.006234712,
-0.0228671525,
-0.0035457369,
-0.008568936,
0.0886636749,
0.0513854288,
0.0113700926,
-0.0140687134,
0.0727074891,
-0.0022503217,
-0.0528418384,
0.000887753,
0.0308529753,
-0.0586776324,
0.0161753502,
-0.0807159245,
0.0709011704,
0.0666852966,
0.0289525427,
-0.0092426995,
-0.0475984551,
0.0316847935,
-0.0186487176,
0.01849287,
-0.005171515,
-0.0329460688,
-0.0435085855,
0.0834917873,
-0.0025917836,
-0.0982801393,
0.0817184448,
-0.0447560363,
-0.009460072,
-0.0102560958,
-0.0367333405,
-0.0366100594,
0.0403968319,
-0.0080316635,
0.0216427948,
0.0489988402,
-0.0448797941,
-0.0207769424,
0.0010728951,
-0.0054834392,
-0.0276218075,
0.0598750003,
-0.0869730785,
0.0108183632,
-0.0106925908,
-0.036535006,
-0.0484709628,
-0.0381241068,
-0.0133195715,
-0.010876012,
0.0361201763,
0.0081060417,
0.0379424319,
0.0113420738,
0.0105557777,
0.0563993528,
-0.0045875851,
-0.0309145451,
-0.0234102923,
-0.0101006636,
-0.0070860279,
-0.0425769314,
-0.0347253457,
-0.0080786794,
-0.0095168641,
0.0082293544,
-0.010333349,
0.0352359526,
-0.0550517254,
0.0041237744,
0.0371919796,
-0.0349968784,
-0.0414337292,
0.0894697085,
0.0443445295,
-0.0334302299,
-0.0217956193,
0.0845913216,
0.0362187214,
-0.0247139502,
0.0333693214,
-0.0336278789,
0.0565673709,
0.0681816265,
0.0462433957,
-0.0698545054,
-0.0264554899,
0.005444868,
0.0533907786,
-0.0168588702,
-0.0089169089,
-0.0534603745,
-0.0924948603,
0.0159637798,
0.0112062246,
-0.0198696498,
-0.010695735,
-0.0136369541,
-0.010526482,
0.0271354783,
-0.0127414856,
0.03814926,
0.0028392347,
0.0182231534,
0.014521637,
-0.0842086226,
-0.0351707898,
-0.0123494212,
-0.0134143187,
0.0254970528,
0.1090246812,
-0.0338656567,
0.002109536,
-0.0100572081,
0.0384749435,
0.0158304069,
0.040918164,
-0.0358936302,
0.0140232798,
0.0167784207,
-0.0147720659,
0.0010199536,
0.0051932083,
-0.0466662422,
-0.0360424034,
0.0412116274,
0.0264834147,
-0.0202943161,
-0.0177923739,
-0.0257681701,
-0.0013106724,
0.0253664069,
0.0390841253,
0.0402357616,
-0.0409791842,
-0.0266130082,
-0.0829299241,
-0.02758063,
-0.0400942639,
-0.0330918171,
-0.0368812457,
0.0095189521,
0.021367345,
-0.0486666262,
0.004007739,
-0.001466498,
0.013662775,
0.0291564073,
-0.0151551506,
0.008276362,
0.0007590025,
-0.0446624942,
0.0158599969,
-0.0201110337,
0.0284428205,
-0.0288159251,
-0.0226713568,
0.052422449,
-0.0096259508,
-0.0008375912,
0.0075892867,
-0.0720356926,
-0.078883864,
-0.0272047799,
0.0579405166,
0.0286658667,
0.0249830075,
-0.0190424733,
-0.0701651126,
-0.0425987728,
0.0368546657,
-0.0123395799,
0.0311836433,
-0.0121560739,
0.0496575274,
0.0160039011,
-0.0076422398,
-0.0757304281,
-0.0194787607,
0.0031776272,
0.0350734927,
-0.0065223752,
-0.0441938266,
0.0362209566,
0.0560281351,
-0.0125868395,
-0.0144270146,
-0.0048212367,
0.0127295554,
-0.0152938766,
0.0083366353,
-0.0479772165,
-0.040870674,
0.0191924013,
-0.0026547764,
-0.0356197208,
0.0468499437,
0.0175052844,
-0.0898417309,
0.056431897,
-0.0080830306,
0.0258473828,
-0.0203833506,
0.0393277891,
0.0715541914,
0.0012782961,
-0.0323270597,
0.0344373919,
-0.0113023343,
0.02555608,
-0.0035886324,
0.0596139096,
-0.0077225347,
0.0171125028,
-0.008728249,
0.024784755,
-0.0264057592,
-0.0542598218,
-0.0172521751,
0.0241139904,
0.0156119708,
0.0355291627,
-0.0008305157,
-0.035966523,
0.0203382242,
-0.0305300951,
0.0323338024,
0.023778988,
-0.0434470251,
0.0293386914,
0.0205355193,
-0.0158306248,
-0.0665206388,
0.089705877,
-0.0082183201,
-0.0102460645,
-0.0159263331,
-0.0110086286,
-0.0470376834,
0.0178268179,
0.0469565094,
-0.0096046124,
-0.0326356404,
-0.0257274471,
-0.0683214515,
-0.0321489424,
0.0225448776,
0.0067685661,
0.0457969308,
-0.0262597688,
0.0354871713,
0.076174885,
-0.0164259765,
-0.0182320476,
-0.0015223004,
0.016332183,
-0.0147082554,
-0.0233412292,
-0.066503033,
-5.992404245e-33,
-0.0459330902,
-0.0526340231,
-0.011827481,
0.0185162108,
0.0219179075,
-0.0278603081,
-0.0538107343,
0.0432594568,
0.0527471751,
-0.0561782941,
0.0348566957,
-0.0199773889,
-0.0052869138,
-0.03064695,
0.0469631851,
-0.0012249965,
0.0548852421,
0.0400523096,
-0.0747715682,
-0.0009931764,
-0.0355241932,
0.0000266631,
0.0065083159,
-0.0626273155,
0.0239513833,
-0.0272233784,
0.0050999727,
-0.0017506925,
0.0381424502,
0.0248933621,
0.0041332431,
0.0347035304,
-0.0006284903,
-0.0053248229,
-0.0599503405,
0.0170247182,
0.0071093081,
-0.0383003876,
0.0217440221,
0.0154244956,
0.0100555243,
-0.0889431164,
0.0723462403,
-0.0149406604,
-0.0533685461,
0.0438287333,
0.0368834399,
-0.0129216071,
-0.0092631504,
-0.0133811664,
-0.0530603901,
0.0331217647,
-0.0390216,
-0.0051754965,
-0.0486830696,
0.0462220423,
-0.0025225002,
0.0387111902,
0.0219980665,
0.0149752004,
0.0686562136,
0.0464961082,
0.0794157907,
0.010866655,
-0.006066395,
0.0161768682,
0.0333652981,
0.0469539315,
-0.0285954475,
-0.0038101773,
0.0198335815,
0.0119703617,
0.0396077894,
0.0569530204,
0.0319331959,
0.0014327209,
-0.0043335934,
0.0362363234,
-0.0307494923,
-0.0143779665,
0.0378406495,
0.0274412129,
-0.0212047752,
-0.0265470687,
-0.031373553,
0.0018869396,
-0.027303528,
-0.0536436141,
0.0399500132,
-0.0152400704,
-0.0189588908,
-0.0247542057,
-0.0095069567,
-0.0122152381,
-0.0070997318,
0.0012953287,
-0.0526723638,
0.0252642129,
-0.0196460877,
0.0178650673,
0.0306465328,
-0.0133559741,
0.0097594867,
0.0009641604,
0.0791189522,
0.0377465524,
-0.0228631292,
0.0213992652,
-0.0917093456,
0.0154218003,
-0.0312479138,
-0.0196043029,
-0.0087136142,
-0.0028937594,
0.0074761044,
-0.0466565005,
-0.0094836466,
0.0401612446,
0.0009721546,
-0.0652185082,
-0.0526354909,
-0.0051470902,
0.0146969426,
0.0301059224,
-0.044976633,
-0.0259983353,
-0.0303981639,
0.0464322455,
0.0367467925,
0.0008753297,
-0.0479287207,
-0.0003655066,
3.03e-7,
0.0046602292,
0.0659567267,
-0.0058361469,
0.0232839976,
-0.0023592403,
0.0313922353,
-0.0279790368,
0.0041755978,
0.0060012885,
-0.010961948,
-0.0428883918,
-0.0027993137,
0.020811582,
0.0233238302,
-0.0689304769,
0.024251014,
-0.0111694457,
0.0523131974,
-0.0890973732,
0.0197913758,
0.094143182,
0.0259346105,
-0.0077685975,
0.0255708452,
0.0083725005,
-0.0677604452,
0.0057093371,
-0.0290190335,
0.0298715606,
0.0333575569,
-0.01131682,
0.0008207723,
0.0025412703,
0.0022904677,
0.0008558123,
-0.0444026552,
0.0054004206,
0.0880309418,
-0.0123645831,
0.0416856147,
0.0310966428,
-0.0117960144,
-0.0003284381,
-0.0690644607,
0.0373163261,
-0.0210982766,
0.0037310552,
-0.0247232914,
-0.0001458326,
-0.0261633806,
0.0096223252,
-0.0337697379,
0.0035918695,
0.0058703781,
-0.0043617203,
0.0122234831,
-0.0400919802,
-0.0098065436,
-0.0450207926,
0.0082805892,
-0.0177308433,
-0.0544832721,
-0.0636870936,
0.038531784,
0.0268541258,
-0.0304039977,
0.0308345556,
3.190005601e-34,
0.0293408912,
0.0043727057,
0.0243170112,
0.024151206,
0.0531599745,
0.0178106632,
0.0096841287,
0.0402819254,
0.0211573895,
-0.0258535836,
-0.0385476351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19774v1 | Direct Preference Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T09:23:40 | 2024-06-28T09:23:40 | Yixing Li, Yuxian Gu, Li Dong, Dequan Wang, Yu Cheng, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of large language models (LLMs), Knowledge Distillation (KD) is
a critical technique for transferring capabilities from teacher models to
student models. However, existing KD methods face limitations and challenges in
distillation of LLMs, including efficiency and insufficient measurement
capabilities of traditional KL divergence. It is shown that LLMs can serve as
an implicit reward function, which we define as a supplement to KL divergence.
In this work, we propose Direct Preference Knowledge Distillation (DPKD) for
LLMs. DPKD utilizes distribution divergence to represent the preference loss
and implicit reward function. We re-formulate KD of LLMs into two stages: first
optimizing and objective consisting of implicit reward and reverse KL
divergence and then improving the preference probability of teacher outputs
over student outputs. We conducted experiments and analysis on various datasets
with LLM parameters ranging from 120M to 13B and demonstrate the broad
applicability and effectiveness of our DPKD approach. Meanwhile, we prove the
value and effectiveness of the introduced implicit reward and output preference
in KD through experiments and theoretical analysis. The DPKD method outperforms
the baseline method in both output response precision and exact match
percentage. Code and data are available at https://aka.ms/dpkd. | [
0.0416523181,
0.069976069,
-0.0077300803,
0.0166834127,
-0.0093139,
0.0045268321,
-0.0112383934,
-0.0114049297,
-0.0486800782,
-0.011206707,
-0.0222664904,
-0.0158311687,
-0.0014795756,
0.0190503616,
0.0118745621,
-0.0869126171,
-0.0015290994,
-0.044351276,
-0.0104454048,
-0.0318001844,
0.0148443887,
-0.0078823324,
0.0256616753,
0.020048866,
0.0628822297,
-0.0125531917,
0.0034437259,
-0.0199096017,
0.0474495478,
-0.0050234529,
0.0296655521,
0.0577935316,
0.0241855439,
0.0018835707,
0.0000024787,
-0.044087898,
-0.0170514043,
-0.0137369689,
-0.0264490191,
0.0502216183,
0.0003036098,
0.0557061285,
0.0180568192,
0.0086380374,
-0.0267099645,
0.0323537365,
0.0306628365,
-0.0048967125,
0.0070963954,
0.0234109946,
0.0175962914,
-0.0309847631,
0.0082997037,
-0.0386651307,
-0.006269204,
0.0032302539,
0.0403514989,
-0.0196198914,
-0.0430195704,
0.0055745179,
-0.0399195254,
0.0405798964,
0.0045321281,
-0.0259245243,
0.0270220395,
0.0267225429,
0.0171375312,
-0.0010059845,
0.0119133163,
0.0590509288,
0.0173576828,
0.0020440707,
0.0294125378,
-0.0327867866,
0.0000591968,
0.0269980188,
-0.0465934686,
-0.0328256898,
0.0253431667,
0.0481850877,
0.0103871226,
0.0165398531,
0.0065301456,
0.0255382098,
-0.0471516214,
0.0490928032,
0.0094054546,
-0.0484816022,
0.0190060716,
0.0240563545,
-0.0547160357,
-0.0383487046,
0.0273598339,
-0.0159823615,
-0.0009503282,
0.0090814997,
0.0250712838,
-0.0485993922,
-0.0057505392,
-0.0143181188,
0.0601779073,
0.0293529201,
-0.0007932296,
0.0109109785,
0.0084566753,
0.1033234224,
-0.010939437,
0.0505318828,
-0.0375079252,
0.0402907953,
-0.0510291755,
-0.0043962188,
0.0467022136,
0.0216067098,
-0.014728697,
0.0119673861,
-0.0428955182,
-0.0121918572,
-0.0508405715,
-0.0240789652,
0.0220876019,
0.0293896031,
-0.045031853,
0.0003472203,
-0.0738889351,
0.1286761612,
0.0012492907,
0.0106424615,
0.0321084931,
0.0291145798,
0.017425064,
0.0018063956,
-0.0038557721,
-0.0288425386,
-0.0257943664,
0.0237661377,
-0.012559806,
-0.0101433666,
0.0135859745,
-0.025794588,
-0.0591885075,
-0.0834799334,
0.0105724791,
-0.1062939912,
0.0205888487,
-0.0131715499,
-0.0126767894,
-0.0567875057,
-0.0018387593,
-0.0407925025,
-0.0058102435,
0.0098994141,
0.0594582446,
0.0192541201,
0.0147556756,
0.0158601273,
-0.0107730748,
0.0512857847,
-0.001732689,
0.0358694494,
-0.0008509883,
-0.0096661989,
-0.026089849,
0.0191600695,
0.0648326203,
0.0447719395,
-0.0786838979,
-0.0048053004,
-0.0243868884,
0.0192812663,
0.0586552545,
0.0227026585,
-0.042926006,
0.0210406464,
0.0798948035,
0.0153136756,
0.0476862788,
-0.0589586236,
-0.0199899878,
0.0301563051,
-0.0013302186,
0.0185954645,
-0.0165986791,
-0.0069545405,
0.0123993289,
0.0067340028,
0.0668271855,
0.0481684953,
-0.015987752,
-0.0598524436,
0.0392424129,
-0.0098885167,
0.0004420758,
0.051678244,
0.1045765132,
-0.0305715334,
0.0007301266,
0.0144215394,
0.0669739544,
-0.024395721,
0.0466640554,
-0.0686780885,
0.0557638556,
0.071240373,
0.0179549381,
-0.0197747704,
0.0237206239,
-0.004356558,
-0.0462301672,
0.0245157462,
0.0408593044,
-0.0330006517,
0.006638594,
-0.0336607657,
-0.0687778667,
0.0416348167,
0.0292494688,
0.0229525995,
0.0169785582,
0.0213576686,
0.0273169614,
-0.056497477,
-0.0152821317,
0.0014898297,
-0.0356809311,
-0.0253164656,
-0.0028231002,
0.0013152226,
0.0420251265,
0.0206004381,
-0.0046398821,
-0.0074089137,
0.0061908122,
0.003978482,
-0.0177556705,
-0.0589902624,
-0.0540318154,
-0.0533639751,
0.0451311953,
-0.0192838814,
0.0228060614,
0.0599301122,
-0.029190544,
-0.0392596349,
0.0202276893,
0.0394379646,
0.0810616612,
-0.0094094314,
0.0487096757,
-0.0230860487,
-0.018976653,
-0.0744127408,
0.0383483022,
-0.0300990418,
0.0100397905,
-0.0287061632,
-0.022928521,
-0.0169169754,
-0.0281026457,
-0.0457385331,
-0.0004270471,
-0.006493812,
0.0401113182,
0.0295907874,
0.0068708388,
-0.024732627,
-0.024216691,
-0.0291189793,
0.007475398,
-0.0075526852,
0.0105335647,
-0.0150536448,
0.0132977059,
0.0114226816,
0.0227019973,
-0.0245014206,
-0.0100787459,
-0.0178185757,
0.0095320158,
-0.0346606933,
0.0317234211,
0.0175676178,
-0.0579737462,
-0.046600543,
0.001987736,
0.0270227194,
-0.0141505422,
0.0576584972,
-0.0190450754,
0.0796890855,
-0.0647051632,
-0.0117869098,
-0.0078958524,
-0.0176838636,
0.0021080857,
-0.0291655287,
0.0482323579,
0.052003447,
-0.017505914,
0.0043998188,
0.0798665583,
-0.0299193896,
-0.1321868896,
-0.0131016793,
-0.0502396673,
-0.0274230409,
-0.0501396805,
-0.0243764631,
-0.0333673395,
0.0543124601,
0.0320304818,
-0.0409354605,
-0.0286915489,
-0.0054550297,
-0.0326940082,
-0.0269283578,
-0.0642568171,
0.0363711379,
-0.0324873738,
0.0496571213,
0.0006916113,
-0.054959178,
0.0600924008,
0.0039467365,
0.0660110563,
-0.0733757764,
-0.0101993987,
0.027837215,
0.0062808529,
-0.0215593483,
-0.0085793389,
-0.0219487697,
0.0191392414,
-0.0580950938,
-0.0136508374,
0.0387169793,
-0.0471634977,
0.0819846988,
-0.0488086939,
-0.017894987,
-0.0164160151,
-0.0272815712,
-0.0199347436,
-0.0384672955,
0.0218814407,
-0.0003641303,
0.0307902303,
-0.0253241621,
0.0049162805,
-0.0132922949,
0.0227250773,
0.0140345069,
-0.0242953151,
-0.0084186159,
-0.0231139008,
0.0229464844,
0.0661915541,
0.0112755578,
0.0025783719,
-0.0404395871,
-0.0136815319,
0.0342823006,
0.0442759879,
0.0122616971,
0.0096982988,
-0.0102062998,
0.0471773669,
0.0236432031,
-0.0175511781,
0.0286081582,
0.0295676719,
-0.0618050694,
0.0273624081,
0.0898472965,
0.0052386341,
-0.0604819544,
-0.0081943953,
0.0174675398,
0.06433516,
-0.0186590794,
0.0104323737,
-0.0669817254,
-0.0113133686,
-0.0085471729,
0.0472923294,
-0.0058017145,
-0.0155193545,
0.0232371427,
-0.0949338973,
-0.0012224938,
0.0135488408,
-0.0158739574,
-0.0362460539,
-0.0654195845,
0.0089650312,
-0.0335097611,
0.0108509166,
0.0092502991,
0.0113669215,
0.0091646668,
0.0278369263,
0.0314143859,
-0.0721158311,
0.0283794738,
-0.0507373773,
0.0396738425,
0.0850270316,
0.0354093462,
-0.0037017013,
-0.0043966058,
-0.0480107479,
-0.0254530516,
-0.0558605306,
0.0216749106,
0.0406109989,
0.0221094973,
0.0073302523,
-0.0135386735,
0.0250672847,
-0.0115383659,
0.0261165835,
0.0268678628,
0.0598346442,
0.0219183415,
-0.0342099182,
0.002814942,
-0.0242280625,
0.0214181542,
0.0777636841,
0.0171760228,
-0.0639125928,
-0.0101840431,
-0.043151509,
-0.0455714874,
0.0067121326,
-0.0105540967,
-0.0016667298,
-0.0301127862,
-0.0197677817,
-0.0471546352,
0.0140875559,
0.0162611827,
0.0109615708,
0.0063133677,
0.0191228874,
0.0155581329,
-0.0350426473,
-0.0313104764,
0.0127758151,
-0.0105707208,
0.0190064646,
-0.0559737757,
-0.0220871232,
-0.0211916976,
-0.0112283528,
-0.0560559183,
0.0035899773,
-0.0931784809,
-0.1076370105,
0.0089940764,
0.0344579294,
0.0212503728,
0.039067626,
0.0241848491,
-0.0456316248,
0.0908574909,
0.025517296,
0.0168183614,
0.0264698658,
0.0293680858,
0.0071652415,
0.0035094817,
0.0243844055,
-0.0379081294,
-0.0057891882,
0.0416311286,
0.0460054763,
-0.0189786665,
-0.020226704,
-0.0050143343,
0.0115892673,
0.0573436096,
-0.0232215896,
-0.0243587419,
-0.0770091191,
-0.0081329718,
-0.0154364659,
-0.00317062,
-0.0440338589,
-0.0601325966,
0.0683392063,
0.0300942771,
0.0034331521,
-0.0129642235,
0.0301134344,
-0.0038476852,
-0.0627259538,
0.0134827401,
0.0376854204,
0.0002277632,
0.094862625,
0.0133993365,
0.0094985245,
-0.0043163188,
0.0205873679,
0.0422761925,
0.0138492929,
0.0478869639,
0.0224825758,
-0.0021711125,
0.0249955617,
-0.0040160567,
-0.0267880093,
-0.0556935742,
-0.0341160111,
-0.0038466521,
0.0014484916,
-0.0177174732,
0.0686402395,
-0.0225976482,
-0.0046534035,
-0.0459845178,
0.0186496694,
-0.0341573544,
0.0182959549,
0.043972075,
-0.001057794,
0.0114088301,
0.0427210666,
0.064485386,
0.0080665676,
0.0275335573,
-0.055353377,
0.0126772476,
-0.0167760253,
-0.0053541414,
0.0443644263,
0.0551687144,
-0.0096640196,
-0.001568016,
-0.0402677953,
-0.0640463904,
-0.043458309,
0.0032937904,
-0.0092231669,
-0.0459527671,
0.0220248643,
0.0272601377,
-0.0559675507,
0.0059270654,
-0.0556268878,
-0.0311447103,
-0.0166570283,
-0.0425952822,
-0.0278643947,
-7.289449854e-33,
-0.0213340092,
0.0100854831,
-0.0091931354,
-0.0064981035,
-0.0424054302,
0.010592619,
0.0023056921,
-0.0204696897,
-0.0151844351,
0.0023057442,
0.0004697874,
0.0067280321,
0.012769511,
0.0414846316,
0.0344583355,
-0.0017731785,
0.0544662662,
0.0067590023,
-0.0194403529,
0.0221008677,
0.0559801757,
0.0098974807,
0.0623672828,
-0.043376267,
0.0426894389,
0.0071699731,
0.0068933363,
0.0035891526,
-0.040184442,
0.0569436923,
-0.0272809193,
0.0827942118,
-0.0132092303,
-0.0625333488,
-0.0375181027,
-0.0079659596,
-0.0385209508,
-0.0267444588,
0.0112894541,
-0.0243241601,
0.0189894866,
-0.0164355189,
0.0367400944,
0.0406725295,
-0.0093562892,
-0.0460806563,
0.0421682596,
0.0047949366,
-0.0229899362,
0.0144969355,
-0.0358251818,
0.0131283449,
-0.0340828709,
-0.0159848779,
0.0435387753,
0.0115619404,
-0.0136794429,
0.0288046002,
-0.0712968335,
0.0603210218,
0.0847557187,
0.0691190735,
0.0672500655,
0.050499659,
0.0094884075,
0.0476676486,
0.0146026546,
-0.0268165898,
0.0332557485,
-0.0651431903,
0.0668857619,
0.0308265518,
0.0067072469,
0.0322261564,
0.0597498752,
-0.0299104732,
-0.0381922126,
0.0108322846,
0.0093517294,
-0.0361319892,
0.0150446361,
0.0346012637,
-0.0397277437,
-0.0664250553,
-0.0507957861,
-0.0433200374,
-0.004832455,
-0.0299719796,
0.0509048589,
-0.0037417945,
-0.0236201752,
-0.0338497534,
0.0472527221,
-0.0679778084,
-0.0342400447,
0.0031234629,
-0.0374134518,
0.0293783788,
-0.0121614905,
-0.0141783869,
-0.0985217094,
0.0038892061,
0.020147521,
-0.0157782435,
-0.0224935338,
0.0399379283,
0.0049271365,
0.0040509319,
-0.0206781738,
0.0051934938,
-0.0246012509,
-0.0381480977,
0.0375816226,
0.0026091528,
0.0239616372,
-0.0174645167,
0.0075068232,
0.0025570651,
0.0459170677,
-0.0375168584,
-0.0162939765,
0.0087756282,
0.0077911792,
-0.0025060014,
-0.0204935148,
0.0109438663,
-0.0235940292,
-0.0332391001,
0.0114442343,
-0.0185931679,
-0.0260422882,
-0.0114801349,
3.044e-7,
0.0195194706,
0.0310223661,
-0.0265646055,
-0.0186866,
-0.0348914601,
0.0519663915,
0.0195903163,
-0.0101814345,
0.0748860836,
-0.0199027658,
0.0131665254,
0.0208108146,
0.0197766926,
0.0157589968,
-0.0822926238,
0.0038602559,
-0.0324092694,
-0.0352856889,
-0.0333119407,
-0.0518087968,
0.0412785187,
0.0566102155,
0.0692627877,
-0.0041733966,
-0.0024208417,
0.0445802696,
0.0212039966,
-0.0243033431,
0.0092522921,
0.0358321927,
0.017154647,
-0.0617193058,
-0.0066534625,
0.0275314227,
0.0014159036,
0.0263525769,
0.019848574,
0.0808775499,
-0.0029911683,
-0.0105330748,
-0.0100050569,
0.018655261,
0.0048522619,
-0.0907173678,
0.0412972197,
-0.0244074762,
0.0189406481,
0.0019666981,
-0.0333790816,
-0.0533161275,
0.0324140415,
-0.0120531665,
0.0077729924,
-0.0036352591,
-0.0221951157,
0.0195563901,
-0.0235862229,
-0.0384043343,
-0.0075437613,
0.0171720665,
-0.0388509072,
-0.1022398844,
-0.0298468117,
0.0244489703,
-0.0216743946,
-0.0327345617,
0.019640604,
2.903125286e-34,
0.0294412095,
0.0459509306,
0.0076638204,
-0.0391331241,
0.0138971927,
-0.0003578304,
-0.0520394072,
0.0229159351,
0.0311780199,
-0.0699857995,
-0.0229785014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19764v1 | Belief Revision: The Adaptability of Large Language Models Reasoning | 2024-06-28T09:09:36 | 2024-06-28T09:09:36 | Bryan Wilie, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Etsuko Ishii, Junxian He, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capability to reason from text is crucial for real-world NLP
applications. Real-world scenarios often involve incomplete or evolving data.
In response, individuals update their beliefs and understandings accordingly.
However, most existing evaluations assume that language models (LMs) operate
with consistent information. We introduce Belief-R, a new dataset designed to
test LMs' belief revision ability when presented with new evidence. Inspired by
how humans suppress prior inferences, this task assesses LMs within the newly
proposed delta reasoning ($\Delta R$) framework. Belief-R features sequences of
premises designed to simulate scenarios where additional information could
necessitate prior conclusions drawn by LMs. We evaluate $\sim$30 LMs across
diverse prompting strategies and found that LMs generally struggle to
appropriately revise their beliefs in response to new information. Further,
models adept at updating often underperformed in scenarios without necessary
updates, highlighting a critical trade-off. These insights underscore the
importance of improving LMs' adaptiveness to changing information, a step
toward more reliable AI systems. | [
0.0435310304,
0.0801622793,
-0.0179234874,
0.0297657959,
-0.0851612985,
0.0100109205,
-0.0266016833,
-0.0122499121,
0.0248302966,
-0.0330027938,
0.0142045869,
-0.0325330794,
0.0131958108,
0.0430698842,
-0.0108385971,
-0.0336628146,
0.0376014858,
-0.037046276,
0.0529994816,
-0.0184936263,
-0.0276207607,
0.016933823,
-0.0224084891,
0.0031155762,
-0.0034996814,
-0.0298681147,
-0.0357090421,
-0.0085174143,
0.0280665774,
-0.0459158458,
-0.0221523326,
0.0500667281,
0.0531462133,
0.0344297849,
0.000002087,
-0.0658751726,
-0.0020082216,
-0.0297275279,
-0.0775297508,
0.0125351483,
0.0304500591,
0.0089266617,
0.0014414582,
0.0120748775,
-0.0507822856,
-0.0120718572,
0.0206115916,
0.1057516187,
0.0463079661,
0.0844485313,
0.0092067057,
-0.0261084717,
-0.0028672609,
-0.017983146,
0.026204383,
-0.0308242198,
0.0651674271,
0.03668309,
-0.0046721981,
0.0171225742,
0.0026549315,
-0.0067717368,
0.0140332328,
-0.0055730161,
-0.0801396295,
0.0416838117,
-0.0242546815,
-0.0390934646,
0.0124526061,
0.0298778694,
0.054519631,
-0.0460353531,
-0.0261118263,
-0.005600539,
0.0125931576,
0.0381217785,
-0.0307027828,
0.033763919,
-0.0448516198,
0.0152970022,
0.0160830058,
-0.0336893685,
0.0471184999,
0.0320314057,
-0.0405163243,
0.1021477357,
-0.0126214502,
-0.0326018855,
0.0013661548,
-0.0140119595,
-0.057073094,
-0.0857071802,
-0.0237036515,
0.0075448668,
-0.0371964313,
0.0575016662,
-0.0449604541,
0.0388844572,
0.0278417468,
-0.0506126471,
-0.0165305603,
0.0256058201,
-0.0271643866,
0.0425045043,
-0.0333698988,
0.0234648492,
0.0059920037,
-0.0070058703,
0.0265175067,
0.0176448524,
-0.0727109313,
-0.0061886688,
0.0082456088,
0.0081028733,
0.0064786719,
-0.0014585207,
-0.0360114612,
0.0475019552,
-0.0416267514,
0.0514341444,
-0.0055836099,
0.0177462138,
0.0022824949,
-0.0307985079,
-0.110965237,
0.0202092435,
-0.0050681257,
0.0450716913,
0.0269621834,
-0.0679509416,
-0.0138772763,
-0.025125213,
-0.008829724,
0.0142050618,
0.0124382544,
0.0245842114,
0.025558915,
-0.0124416556,
-0.0585050434,
-0.0176417883,
-0.0283506606,
-0.0730665103,
-0.0375923999,
-0.0519037694,
0.0246610846,
-0.0005860585,
-0.0072017191,
-0.0454026647,
0.0112167113,
0.0256947596,
-0.0502525866,
0.0854166001,
-0.0100604296,
0.0099882567,
0.0351140276,
0.0022778516,
-0.0338555761,
0.0756407976,
0.0165281538,
0.0221507307,
0.0410068817,
0.0348967686,
-0.0060395715,
-0.0219313595,
-0.0100830505,
0.0071488218,
-0.0239876863,
0.0236054361,
-0.0265202168,
0.0258761775,
0.0118941879,
0.0391755924,
-0.019350877,
-0.053183347,
0.0760780945,
0.0094623379,
-0.0147502655,
-0.0169039406,
0.0368229151,
0.0046497881,
0.0265193786,
0.0193907171,
-0.0870076567,
-0.0067521795,
-0.0184523184,
0.0005284844,
-0.0122203426,
0.0234763026,
0.0028776312,
-0.0537430942,
-0.0441846028,
0.0219091475,
-0.0064954995,
0.0156926345,
0.0296658948,
-0.0060903225,
0.0017450588,
0.0022646906,
0.0370873846,
-0.0210032444,
-0.0249245409,
-0.0627371743,
0.0324201249,
0.0867963582,
0.0501284264,
-0.0373648889,
-0.0297235884,
-0.0024255365,
0.0177641865,
0.0365192108,
0.0756807551,
0.0160374213,
0.0068463949,
-0.0041208235,
-0.0097103845,
0.0018241887,
0.0418372676,
0.0242497586,
0.0160533991,
-0.0124439979,
-0.0065715383,
-0.0216406342,
-0.0091068875,
0.0624483526,
0.0042325859,
0.0056268629,
-0.0168533865,
-0.0140575925,
0.0123866256,
0.014000074,
0.0058352607,
-0.004648312,
0.0463956706,
0.0377727412,
-0.0237026028,
0.0443128869,
-0.0235191751,
-0.0262196362,
0.0485645533,
-0.0132370377,
-0.0280355625,
-0.0065612798,
-0.0403959937,
-0.0140026081,
0.0065807998,
-0.0028777739,
0.0384080596,
-0.0141281178,
0.0393693261,
0.0018725982,
0.004859054,
0.0050367634,
0.0782407448,
-0.0202547256,
-0.0164073762,
0.0170963816,
0.0165403113,
0.0009989121,
-0.0553979315,
0.0043687779,
-0.0107557373,
0.0106565794,
-0.0271637961,
0.0390669107,
-0.0277515221,
-0.0417871363,
-0.0098439772,
-0.0667988658,
-0.0507722385,
-0.0044758762,
-0.0004986306,
0.0166117381,
-0.0305634495,
-0.0223292056,
-0.0080688354,
-0.0112087131,
0.0114046838,
0.0108174393,
0.0513412058,
0.0231335387,
-0.038635429,
-0.0070600426,
-0.0204337277,
0.0244377069,
-0.0156583171,
0.0501150191,
0.0218098126,
-0.0004836225,
-0.0948081613,
-0.0047108494,
-0.0761971697,
0.0154638886,
-0.0158625469,
0.0067797131,
0.0196718071,
-0.0042805113,
0.0626756549,
0.032103207,
0.0156841129,
0.0103435405,
0.0916414186,
0.0246052686,
-0.0434355922,
0.0100366147,
-0.0276625156,
-0.0201691445,
-0.0325403661,
-0.0763910115,
-0.0015760643,
0.0188542549,
0.0235253144,
0.0051670223,
-0.0624284185,
0.0362563841,
0.0089594368,
-0.0399137139,
-0.0133225154,
-0.0457674339,
-0.0233183019,
0.0728488788,
-0.0408514738,
-0.0624213442,
0.1071382836,
-0.0191824157,
0.0405640118,
-0.0410399772,
0.0032068924,
-0.0079683103,
0.0636942536,
0.0209221598,
-0.0115416702,
0.0288009159,
0.0308073331,
-0.0228622388,
0.0034810146,
0.0051071197,
-0.0284543615,
0.0538750775,
-0.0911149383,
0.0016398593,
0.0434638299,
0.0066125868,
-0.0649437457,
-0.0296956189,
-0.0344920978,
-0.0270162914,
-0.0255269725,
-0.0282358918,
-0.0255340766,
-0.0275976118,
0.0431496054,
0.0310765412,
0.0122823603,
-0.0252823085,
0.0040172036,
-0.0480208434,
0.0472129099,
0.034276668,
0.0444436148,
-0.0177781582,
0.0449610278,
0.0397180617,
0.0518725254,
-0.0108513432,
-0.0408975556,
0.0027874766,
-0.0302104726,
-0.0005349817,
0.0124981301,
0.0219272524,
0.0356108919,
-0.024725927,
0.0012243483,
0.1051067337,
0.034306515,
-0.0387552902,
0.013935972,
-0.0438189879,
0.0476806238,
0.0244697966,
0.0166765805,
-0.1053901389,
-0.0294769201,
0.0169924852,
-0.0123247812,
-0.0114055118,
-0.0680306703,
-0.0310777426,
-0.0648530722,
0.0286843963,
-0.0277371816,
0.0147678955,
-0.0027698993,
-0.0793022662,
0.0334603153,
-0.0261392538,
0.0105923284,
0.0231646504,
-0.0004920122,
-0.0147067616,
-0.0019002395,
-0.0052352645,
-0.0631320775,
0.0187367797,
-0.0352491997,
0.0482854508,
0.0252161119,
-0.0015328713,
0.0060404125,
-0.0632142127,
-0.009396649,
0.0199880563,
0.0282429233,
-0.0084450692,
0.0254272614,
-0.0167580415,
0.0187109597,
0.0087866485,
-0.0072719189,
-0.038147077,
-0.0574003793,
0.0296443123,
0.085106276,
-0.0306249931,
-0.0440906249,
0.0084464112,
0.0070249061,
-0.0215216503,
0.0954700485,
0.021669738,
0.0011626245,
-0.0012870297,
-0.0424019881,
-0.0117456103,
0.0193177108,
0.0178311188,
0.0037281213,
-0.0167033952,
-0.0049375957,
-0.0726805627,
-0.0256842505,
0.011754591,
-0.0110927885,
0.0024395883,
-0.0296502355,
0.0181066766,
0.0041115968,
-0.0556560829,
0.0254560821,
-0.0379573368,
-0.0024049412,
0.0018336765,
-0.0021803654,
-0.0114226574,
-0.0282111857,
-0.0084743211,
-0.0029883718,
-0.0696624219,
-0.058580704,
0.066126667,
0.0260555223,
0.0296454262,
0.0270315334,
-0.0213749018,
-0.021731019,
0.0077172085,
-0.0180465095,
-0.005842736,
0.0533245988,
0.0261176564,
0.0337322839,
-0.0073834322,
0.0419973582,
-0.0200960934,
0.0252312478,
0.0097017996,
0.0265704934,
-0.0305331014,
-0.0834440067,
0.0481579416,
0.011344607,
0.0206289385,
0.0112718167,
-0.0260458551,
-0.0131748552,
0.0174712241,
-0.0198735278,
-0.0177489519,
0.0232273061,
0.0099878479,
-0.001652433,
-0.0105502922,
-0.0191012081,
-0.0240911134,
-0.0435489938,
0.0018037634,
0.0076436796,
-0.0339295603,
0.0615944229,
0.0426356606,
0.0047310856,
-0.0151060494,
-0.0317705534,
0.0024055871,
-0.0535213836,
0.0363760032,
0.0123276478,
0.0617410615,
0.050865259,
-0.0591145791,
-0.0270167366,
0.0052426988,
-0.0981411636,
-0.0617041029,
0.0194889475,
0.003156658,
0.0127856219,
0.0306464564,
0.0408508293,
-0.0566307008,
0.0089173578,
-0.0113441097,
-0.0014494038,
0.027505096,
-0.025810834,
0.0305661,
0.0215771422,
-0.036471013,
0.0600513034,
0.0512935743,
-0.029046433,
0.0833804607,
-0.0337796696,
-0.0407619029,
-0.0309599694,
-0.0412440635,
-0.0520780049,
0.0370076001,
-0.0227861237,
-0.0012875298,
-0.0508126989,
-0.0635440871,
0.0071637225,
0.0418966785,
0.0366481841,
-0.0312195458,
-0.0353513397,
0.096581392,
0.0190689359,
-0.0279820375,
-0.0221421588,
-0.0108417943,
0.0036495752,
0.0180248395,
-0.0472239442,
-6.561982686e-33,
0.0000067836,
-0.0272095818,
0.0159396287,
-0.0415279157,
-0.0066584796,
0.000674707,
-0.0212592557,
0.0152116287,
-0.0365258306,
0.0472829379,
-0.022686379,
0.0425399691,
0.014520905,
-0.0027404383,
0.0154514201,
-0.0276122689,
0.0465644784,
0.009502966,
-0.0380434506,
-0.0341756716,
0.0712364092,
-0.0154211521,
0.0460125431,
-0.0601329915,
0.0820783898,
0.0295721926,
-0.0268594921,
0.0418407694,
-0.0704053044,
0.0354301222,
-0.0248575825,
0.0118627958,
0.0370599441,
-0.0245790705,
-0.0011874138,
0.008841129,
-0.0340080075,
-0.0288107581,
0.0593488216,
0.0034120833,
-0.0213283822,
0.007673718,
0.0241380055,
0.0146743832,
-0.0149576468,
0.0381818898,
0.0129657481,
-0.0447050557,
0.0133910617,
0.0530926101,
-0.031367369,
0.0396206193,
0.0173374154,
0.004991285,
-0.0484992862,
0.0360972062,
-0.0248250216,
-0.0268339925,
-0.0661881268,
0.0189455003,
0.044158522,
-0.0053181364,
0.0570498481,
-0.0170829669,
-0.0004997647,
0.0977059454,
0.0255351514,
0.0232468862,
-0.0607672483,
-0.0414348133,
0.0142208012,
0.0350302644,
0.0334951915,
0.0648162812,
0.0203178134,
0.0097493939,
-0.0497531667,
0.009538441,
0.0266555995,
0.0648948699,
0.0637834296,
0.0256826822,
-0.0412210003,
0.0009132683,
-0.0736479312,
0.0121577047,
-0.0574878603,
-0.0318407901,
0.0107460711,
0.0242391974,
-0.0287160426,
0.0101535851,
-0.0051190774,
-0.0134820417,
-0.0112129729,
-0.0002997297,
-0.0039893389,
-0.024560716,
0.0030016117,
0.0014992353,
-0.0249757599,
0.0394901782,
0.0275990199,
0.0141178379,
0.0054493803,
-0.0045352289,
0.014798563,
-0.0061765481,
-0.0536012501,
0.0007416529,
-0.0381697714,
0.0112507604,
-0.020540949,
-0.0300149713,
0.0559694879,
0.0343696736,
-0.0243157428,
0.011079262,
0.0290207341,
-0.0236840378,
-0.0384531245,
0.0387574024,
0.0089754267,
0.0397984721,
-0.0023130807,
-0.016274225,
-0.0151095027,
-0.0096339546,
-0.0070571578,
-0.0395902656,
-0.0067894058,
0.0497343838,
2.855e-7,
0.0051387977,
0.0730234981,
0.0059429193,
0.0142269628,
0.0200828388,
0.037710458,
-0.0274964646,
-0.0198023859,
0.0431107022,
-0.0506414808,
-0.0063287294,
0.0424331017,
0.032046143,
0.044970829,
-0.0371791422,
-0.0540571064,
-0.0517753102,
-0.0162622575,
-0.0384114347,
0.01250167,
0.0897362754,
0.0852360278,
0.0555667616,
-0.0010023048,
-0.0044192169,
-0.0029661357,
0.0390474238,
-0.0405452475,
-0.0150163416,
-0.0219480079,
0.0462658592,
-0.0201703962,
0.017430909,
0.0361650549,
-0.0011226999,
-0.0170507152,
-0.0629528239,
0.0403852761,
-0.0071884221,
-0.0030034061,
-0.0439746007,
0.0087290369,
0.0133841652,
-0.0552618429,
0.0692128763,
-0.0409271009,
-0.0320293419,
-0.0260634329,
-0.0169867612,
-0.0379146859,
0.0055430722,
-0.0008083979,
-0.0424761698,
0.0037418576,
-0.0069130813,
0.0319428444,
-0.0320622511,
-0.0843522102,
-0.0033160413,
0.0052595171,
-0.050760746,
-0.036479,
-0.0238490514,
-0.0160499588,
0.0490126088,
-0.0640754849,
0.0335322432,
2.328111791e-34,
0.0290255677,
0.0064651803,
-0.024601208,
0.0133104632,
0.0669636503,
0.0050865686,
0.0524166301,
0.0341368765,
0.0184972398,
-0.086826697,
-0.0020283235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19760v1 | Learning Interpretable Legal Case Retrieval via Knowledge-Guided Case Reformulation | 2024-06-28T08:59:45 | 2024-06-28T08:59:45 | Chenlong Deng, Kelong Mao, Zhicheng Dou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Legal case retrieval for sourcing similar cases is critical in upholding
judicial fairness. Different from general web search, legal case retrieval
involves processing lengthy, complex, and highly specialized legal documents.
Existing methods in this domain often overlook the incorporation of legal
expert knowledge, which is crucial for accurately understanding and modeling
legal cases, leading to unsatisfactory retrieval performance. This paper
introduces KELLER, a legal knowledge-guided case reformulation approach based
on large language models (LLMs) for effective and interpretable legal case
retrieval. By incorporating professional legal knowledge about crimes and law
articles, we enable large language models to accurately reformulate the
original legal case into concise sub-facts of crimes, which contain the
essential information of the case. Extensive experiments on two legal case
retrieval benchmarks demonstrate superior retrieval performance and robustness
on complex legal case queries of KELLER over existing methods. | [
0.0574691221,
0.045387622,
-0.0259528086,
0.0266152844,
-0.0689662471,
0.0163247809,
0.004485338,
0.0305295885,
-0.0200851504,
-0.0688259304,
-0.0129657434,
0.0036646242,
-0.0411304757,
-0.0076390328,
-0.0340521447,
-0.0385043882,
0.0295131914,
0.0215365309,
0.083442308,
0.0204907395,
0.0259253234,
-0.0035359003,
0.019929396,
0.0088509312,
0.0070751826,
-0.0070714038,
-0.0172603186,
0.0159766264,
-0.0401161835,
0.0020643536,
-0.0102343196,
0.0522425994,
0.0378320701,
0.0150510343,
0.0000013689,
-0.0509159602,
-0.0237743091,
-0.0230418872,
-0.0066529238,
0.0373880602,
0.0314551592,
-0.0538701341,
-0.0013576538,
-0.0080562392,
-0.0243522227,
0.0106792292,
-0.0413778014,
0.0420758016,
0.0473366305,
0.0740532503,
0.0131404232,
-0.0804357827,
0.0234680232,
-0.0222174767,
0.0069390675,
-0.044415962,
0.0365491435,
0.0379780792,
0.0382274054,
0.0186383743,
0.0290165171,
0.0312697813,
0.0105228592,
-0.0592036769,
-0.0184183773,
-0.026244821,
-0.0536151864,
0.0177234113,
0.0652611107,
0.0565006696,
0.0487968698,
-0.0389071442,
0.0086871991,
0.0261306483,
0.0617550425,
0.037003383,
-0.0541924387,
0.0846787766,
-0.0336475596,
0.0010674287,
0.0050909924,
0.0208470728,
-0.011337053,
0.0258776248,
-0.0379511043,
0.0371313095,
-0.0011899843,
-0.0299801659,
-0.0241892431,
-0.0284561105,
0.0386795588,
-0.0037341281,
0.069946453,
0.0397922695,
-0.0040523736,
0.0293475557,
-0.0035279272,
-0.0455130301,
0.0766430423,
-0.0730294511,
-0.0002957995,
0.0007479319,
-0.0027523537,
0.0850263387,
-0.0256748851,
0.0046592969,
-0.0001072033,
-0.0249842294,
-0.0474444926,
-0.0434126295,
-0.0317073204,
-0.020541789,
-0.037403442,
0.051016029,
-0.1052202582,
0.0084382724,
0.0148957279,
0.0214549489,
-0.0049581379,
-0.0009178983,
0.0115427244,
-0.0243949685,
-0.0228020139,
-0.0525209829,
-0.0447624251,
-0.0227338541,
-0.0327418,
0.0289429333,
-0.0119888093,
0.0053273696,
-0.0158267859,
-0.0001043024,
0.0152245909,
-0.00849583,
-0.0194326099,
0.0503018536,
-0.0145764463,
-0.0122344205,
-0.0469829254,
-0.0787964687,
-0.0076084295,
-0.0286374427,
-0.0552775972,
-0.0578187034,
-0.0039957496,
-0.0231618285,
-0.0363845788,
-0.0670259669,
0.0024366013,
0.0382761136,
-0.0393552147,
0.0401105359,
0.0004669636,
-0.0125009418,
-0.000666825,
0.0479650944,
0.0309343003,
0.0208987799,
-0.0161459502,
0.0544042923,
0.0363508873,
0.0088632414,
0.0176305287,
0.0028504154,
0.0205137264,
0.0226418097,
-0.0029263657,
0.0305593647,
-0.0029351781,
0.0563940369,
0.0524212234,
0.0206877943,
-0.0065217162,
-0.0112007931,
0.02340132,
0.0502122939,
0.0656951889,
0.0443466567,
0.0032351546,
0.0217964463,
0.025180826,
-0.0045967242,
-0.0324948803,
-0.0008535801,
-0.025974052,
0.0259659048,
-0.0686479956,
-0.0033857913,
-0.0163685605,
-0.0471112952,
0.0140442327,
0.0209659915,
-0.0244243853,
0.00451027,
0.0442915969,
0.0119218947,
-0.0115029002,
0.0498598255,
0.026897721,
-0.0395532362,
0.0091120331,
-0.0387241654,
0.0016910465,
0.0555530973,
0.0474370942,
-0.0475781374,
-0.0130392825,
0.0221121516,
-0.0114561571,
0.0235765465,
0.0007812023,
-0.01396959,
-0.0338706188,
-0.033658348,
-0.0470092595,
0.0245201439,
0.0319592096,
-0.0080912467,
0.0071887802,
0.008033636,
0.0568662062,
-0.070103161,
0.0091902483,
0.009699123,
-0.0014031189,
-0.0297219213,
0.0128572285,
-0.0081876945,
-0.0024775276,
0.0242585484,
0.0205599666,
-0.0062837028,
0.0200593621,
-0.0014299571,
0.0082680956,
-0.0102702472,
0.0129774893,
-0.0147167137,
0.0361947753,
-0.0298210252,
0.0199806578,
-0.0241669938,
-0.0412831642,
0.0004153201,
-0.0139523651,
-0.010598084,
0.0220350325,
-0.0401519127,
-0.0072536115,
-0.0319293104,
-0.047439415,
-0.0657531768,
0.0579989851,
0.0122690992,
-0.0529782772,
-0.0167318899,
-0.0306663215,
0.0155290663,
-0.0294840001,
-0.0142810773,
-0.0331007577,
-0.0024317368,
0.0234177075,
0.0227657761,
-0.0379603207,
-0.0485552028,
-0.0156540535,
-0.0641664192,
0.0198258068,
-0.0318560526,
-0.012942858,
-0.0040304479,
0.0172024593,
-0.008017852,
-0.0284325555,
-0.0127257323,
-0.0496659204,
-0.0104251541,
0.0088291848,
0.0027759052,
0.0172873586,
-0.0217711553,
-0.0223892462,
-0.0359915942,
0.0062788557,
0.0566028729,
-0.0073050512,
0.00402667,
-0.0423337854,
0.0903428718,
-0.0128441099,
-0.0215127785,
-0.0452926643,
0.0137979016,
-0.0225476883,
-0.0320130549,
-0.0299734119,
0.0391726494,
0.0546912476,
0.0368367657,
0.0235402267,
-0.0111490162,
-0.0706667677,
-0.0145962117,
0.0104330871,
0.0047888868,
-0.03099069,
-0.0031043685,
0.0478607081,
-0.0032232674,
-0.0000447894,
0.0103616193,
-0.0019055557,
0.0038743087,
-0.0002151674,
-0.0164651554,
-0.0588016585,
-0.0296792593,
0.0136883399,
0.031488467,
0.00445882,
-0.0509808734,
0.0418111905,
0.0281110276,
0.1016116962,
-0.0273516662,
-0.014396077,
-0.0617557168,
0.103873767,
-0.0124356076,
0.0070575918,
-0.0538575649,
-0.0632361919,
0.0426728502,
-0.0122749871,
0.0943578556,
-0.0644089803,
0.1026984751,
-0.0259650908,
0.0410019904,
-0.0097139925,
-0.0523060299,
-0.0266932957,
-0.0553919189,
0.003057291,
0.0147602772,
0.0180007257,
0.0164684784,
-0.0590202883,
0.0136753796,
0.0272855647,
-0.0060285712,
0.0045322967,
-0.006791295,
-0.0185738541,
0.0352471508,
0.0114606954,
-0.0391805246,
-0.013243123,
0.0103052966,
0.008085575,
0.0186764207,
-0.0123823928,
-0.0176438503,
0.024632195,
0.0010043256,
0.0141124362,
-0.1046281308,
-0.0166648626,
0.0092062913,
-0.019746542,
-0.0626604408,
0.0163826868,
0.0972117186,
0.0286013,
-0.0416734889,
-0.0340110883,
-0.0212628432,
-0.0144557506,
0.0209333226,
0.0330946073,
-0.0622263476,
0.0245863125,
0.0158879906,
0.0118559878,
-0.026928518,
-0.0381533653,
-0.0101490896,
-0.0756708756,
0.0829961672,
0.0303908065,
0.0002247535,
-0.0732724741,
-0.0712509975,
-0.0068950821,
-0.0113420784,
0.0071984581,
0.0632486343,
-0.0622831285,
-0.0009571257,
-0.0079339901,
-0.0253955107,
-0.0071505941,
0.0025257296,
-0.0529864505,
0.0230167825,
-0.0078136967,
0.0234913751,
-0.0194863398,
0.0053419345,
-0.023837572,
0.0102769323,
0.0274211783,
-0.0043131714,
0.0235306714,
0.0140729798,
0.0260191336,
-0.0764860362,
0.0165713727,
0.022034429,
-0.0242744442,
0.0551799461,
0.0375536345,
-0.0396821462,
0.0045260885,
-0.0203201231,
-0.056062445,
-0.0193848629,
0.056491781,
0.0138320215,
0.0553580672,
-0.0075457827,
0.003889126,
-0.0411398821,
-0.0106853684,
-0.0313591771,
0.0217865873,
-0.0332441591,
0.0379888415,
-0.0155032249,
-0.0139460098,
0.011472607,
0.0529758558,
0.0102279373,
0.0510272756,
0.037475124,
-0.017094193,
-0.0801007301,
0.0319948457,
-0.0503178649,
-0.0107579287,
0.0004180188,
0.0421710238,
0.0321646519,
-0.0197127312,
-0.0132531691,
-0.0143448804,
0.0493754484,
0.0113312723,
-0.0109867277,
-0.0216305796,
0.0195678696,
0.0237993319,
-0.032491006,
-0.0710206702,
0.0194260571,
0.0285268966,
-0.034613844,
-0.016121326,
0.0304934513,
-0.0416468978,
-0.0212375335,
0.008588898,
-0.0302030109,
0.0312117506,
0.0101254759,
0.0228929315,
-0.0529908724,
0.0159604549,
0.043193832,
0.0637259334,
0.0256652012,
0.0249572713,
-0.0148527743,
-0.02005147,
0.0127579272,
-0.0664693415,
-0.0262421798,
0.0050298064,
0.0256079286,
0.045691058,
-0.0055659302,
-0.032419011,
0.0565691628,
-0.0142111285,
0.0014023246,
-0.0868401751,
0.0276086982,
0.0133655602,
-0.0234090202,
0.0185430292,
-0.0539413579,
-0.01652156,
0.0522284172,
-0.0274249576,
0.0663942918,
-0.0095801195,
0.0175383929,
0.0109703271,
0.0082799587,
-0.054256767,
0.0046476363,
-0.0554965101,
-0.0428259633,
-0.001521114,
0.0386250727,
0.0404770449,
-0.0270620044,
-0.006225395,
-0.0036287303,
-0.0152683593,
-0.0000054175,
0.0196334962,
0.0178403426,
-0.0253250897,
0.0321421362,
0.0342958011,
-0.0091266483,
0.0345737301,
0.0361682624,
0.0067820936,
0.0205623545,
-0.0348883048,
-0.044392556,
0.0004206277,
-0.021464508,
0.0198525488,
0.0507580042,
-0.0532972813,
-0.0681460276,
-0.0699850246,
0.0059497659,
-0.0250817984,
0.0056457212,
-0.0023432379,
0.0264010131,
0.0124676861,
0.0967014059,
0.0336852483,
-0.0245318767,
-0.0360738821,
0.0475509576,
-0.0179169569,
-0.0189789161,
0.0073822653,
-4.792386878e-33,
-0.0141586894,
-0.038902808,
0.0151305832,
0.0109668225,
-0.0214283038,
-0.0080106491,
0.0093853595,
-0.0152690094,
-0.0348446295,
0.0220906287,
-0.01071731,
0.0461042337,
0.0222582109,
-0.0209838953,
0.0051637487,
0.0086255968,
0.0255297497,
0.0367607102,
0.0064545008,
0.0252339244,
-0.0006642405,
0.0482195653,
-0.0052186889,
-0.1019376293,
0.0270163585,
0.0243417863,
0.0121284472,
0.0044768341,
-0.0124079147,
0.0563731864,
0.0138406046,
0.0247977991,
0.0442014746,
-0.0642793849,
0.0079343589,
0.0207694806,
-0.0903497413,
0.0349059291,
0.0256998297,
-0.0204517953,
0.0233514607,
-0.0387538373,
0.044384975,
0.0025330845,
0.0015080934,
0.0016281751,
0.0399687737,
-0.0523958951,
-0.0712925345,
-0.0577923805,
-0.0560593642,
0.053729292,
-0.0152137373,
0.0510571487,
0.010582868,
-0.0610068217,
0.0049186554,
0.066452533,
-0.0401505977,
-0.0066813589,
-0.0226628631,
0.0077992603,
0.0281450134,
-0.053566169,
-0.024215728,
0.0478171185,
-0.0179879796,
0.0196479801,
-0.0554949157,
-0.0177672449,
0.0263672974,
0.0852373242,
0.0219518002,
0.0621054769,
0.0153667321,
-0.0397323184,
-0.0702662617,
-0.0267392322,
0.0197848026,
0.0517508537,
0.015796965,
0.0110889617,
-0.0653156564,
0.0004765981,
-0.0420175306,
-0.0132353688,
-0.0229582414,
0.0076639601,
0.0161548667,
0.020707665,
0.0373505354,
-0.043461334,
0.0042714197,
-0.0199142341,
0.0258854609,
0.0540736616,
0.0140058696,
0.0090387659,
-0.0341319926,
0.0246049706,
-0.0087174261,
-0.0455348492,
0.0119087622,
-0.0258412641,
-0.0332849473,
-0.024421325,
0.033890266,
-0.0632753,
-0.0314365439,
-0.0057454477,
0.0163719319,
-0.0076449271,
0.0068218294,
-0.0228320025,
0.0067156218,
0.0438627861,
0.0283214189,
0.0138156414,
0.0342727639,
-0.0174371693,
-0.0144457407,
-0.0480970182,
0.0188352652,
-0.0225449819,
0.0134760197,
0.0086319437,
0.0160465818,
0.0522115603,
0.027403228,
-0.0108655794,
0.0245063398,
0.0722137094,
2.18e-7,
0.0840355679,
0.0553446822,
-0.0296690855,
0.029000489,
-0.0277125072,
0.0138516072,
0.0311570652,
0.0163504779,
0.0453045852,
-0.0287229884,
0.0265585762,
0.0290387068,
0.0228035022,
0.0246221144,
-0.0561397448,
-0.0444056094,
-0.0271777511,
-0.0755562112,
-0.0630242601,
0.0007729817,
0.0651066601,
0.081712611,
0.0176226031,
0.0016815953,
0.0085512009,
-0.0712061971,
0.0517668575,
-0.0243298095,
-0.0489366837,
0.0116082188,
0.0930871814,
-0.0002660573,
0.00047128,
0.0168153234,
0.0098453974,
0.0595160946,
-0.0106615974,
0.0503728427,
0.0121918032,
0.0751248226,
-0.0256445408,
-0.0853747204,
0.0161192529,
-0.0522449799,
0.0379281044,
0.0053300289,
0.0122699486,
0.0246951245,
-0.0381246284,
-0.0247751959,
-0.0087893046,
0.0248604082,
-0.0092046279,
-0.0082972934,
0.0227011368,
0.0014309839,
0.0340055861,
-0.0998624563,
0.0197694153,
0.0348850489,
-0.0228122696,
0.0178110804,
-0.0004458601,
-0.0264306199,
0.0664996579,
-0.0619001575,
0.0530388393,
1.494242386e-34,
0.0402799435,
0.0104527511,
0.0039142896,
0.0371776745,
0.0321999975,
0.0492156856,
-0.047825411,
0.0159293544,
-0.0122723142,
-0.102145426,
0.0356831811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19759v1 | Breaking the Script Barrier in Multilingual Pre-Trained Language Models with Transliteration-Based Post-Training Alignment | 2024-06-28T08:59:24 | 2024-06-28T08:59:24 | Orgest Xhelili, Yihong Liu, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual pre-trained models (mPLMs) have shown impressive performance on
cross-lingual transfer tasks. However, the transfer performance is often
hindered when a low-resource target language is written in a different script
than the high-resource source language, even though the two languages may be
related or share parts of their vocabularies. Inspired by recent work that uses
transliteration to address this problem, our paper proposes a
transliteration-based post-pretraining alignment (PPA) method aiming to improve
the cross-lingual alignment between languages using diverse scripts. We select
two areal language groups, $\textbf{Mediterranean-Amharic-Farsi}$ and
$\textbf{South+East Asian Languages}$, wherein the languages are mutually
influenced but use different scripts. We apply our method to these language
groups and conduct extensive experiments on a spectrum of downstream tasks. The
results show that after PPA, models consistently outperform the original model
(up to 50% for some tasks) in English-centric transfer. In addition, when we
use languages other than English as sources in transfer, our method obtains
even larger improvements. We will make our code and models publicly available
at \url{https://github.com/cisnlp/Transliteration-PPA}. | [
-0.0168744605,
0.0584661476,
-0.0068477876,
0.0184526071,
-0.0320593119,
0.0287244134,
0.0300090816,
-0.0223115869,
-0.0256840792,
0.0124313133,
-0.0769701228,
-0.0670945793,
0.0383952707,
-0.0235731136,
0.0415163822,
-0.0362671837,
0.0497613177,
-0.0309989285,
-0.0424150564,
0.0061310302,
0.0308541749,
0.0329250954,
-0.013462659,
-0.013139518,
-0.0106353415,
-0.0051362752,
0.0095175831,
-0.0053880881,
0.0616948381,
0.046172943,
-0.0235948637,
0.0394244418,
-0.0171596874,
0.022704374,
0.0000017027,
-0.0578492954,
-0.0363487676,
-0.0241610408,
-0.0127604594,
0.0114843231,
0.0507988706,
-0.0500961244,
-0.0233790074,
0.008309654,
0.024441909,
-0.0385443158,
0.0984593257,
0.0059293862,
0.0218770038,
0.0777922869,
-0.032316871,
-0.0411616601,
0.0264411177,
-0.0245903768,
-0.0225682091,
-0.0623662174,
0.0074421731,
0.011712811,
-0.0411883779,
-0.038141802,
-0.0324862599,
0.0509439968,
-0.0269219447,
0.0221703257,
-0.0230301637,
-0.0104013244,
-0.009876499,
-0.0277157091,
0.0257457588,
0.0657368451,
-0.072719492,
-0.0515371673,
-0.0268624872,
-0.004732924,
-0.0045927456,
0.0194633193,
-0.0267782453,
-0.0021171761,
0.0000837292,
0.0170832835,
0.0329024792,
0.0224563666,
0.0527915582,
-0.030558208,
-0.0408464484,
0.0034904538,
0.0808505118,
-0.0265729707,
0.0257247072,
0.0296268873,
0.0359465554,
-0.0287284963,
0.0304992143,
0.012959036,
0.0034940313,
0.0121491076,
-0.0733837858,
-0.0465618521,
-0.0252718348,
-0.0001159329,
0.0727256909,
0.0864601061,
-0.041856572,
0.0214062724,
-0.0522216223,
0.0671924204,
-0.0264522918,
0.0297563504,
-0.0433163829,
-0.0252753738,
-0.0016063773,
0.0223577823,
-0.0350385644,
-0.032921508,
-0.0017680029,
0.0209033974,
-0.026492808,
0.0184551422,
0.0124133211,
-0.0051271361,
0.0222400408,
-0.0744983479,
-0.0670519322,
-0.0432296693,
0.0193369612,
0.0738046467,
0.0034253795,
0.0267472528,
-0.0480639525,
-0.0449803732,
-0.0091505218,
0.0395502001,
0.0154242124,
-0.0214359369,
-0.014696572,
0.0677367449,
-0.0666333735,
-0.033165127,
-0.057815738,
0.05933116,
0.0032157556,
-0.0269780122,
-0.0060875406,
-0.0498954616,
0.0805912167,
-0.0069936356,
0.0138967969,
-0.0388097167,
-0.041315075,
-0.0211480986,
-0.004309447,
0.0696636289,
0.0102249915,
0.0463355668,
0.0164923593,
-0.0354914106,
0.0020140824,
0.0598799735,
0.0247766599,
-0.0145766456,
0.0236090478,
-0.0283627193,
-0.0256718267,
0.0808922276,
0.0196902994,
0.0202857945,
-0.0126958992,
-0.0152668441,
0.0640733689,
0.0473186672,
0.042136047,
0.018944215,
-0.0056637069,
0.0104093859,
0.0536108427,
0.0270773154,
0.0179986991,
0.0301622488,
0.0516102798,
-0.0025303089,
-0.0137209073,
0.0002726629,
-0.0016058519,
0.0000085215,
-0.0076029291,
0.0228061937,
0.0196797755,
0.0998644382,
-0.0449029915,
0.0313197635,
0.0187192969,
-0.0371280834,
0.0019192502,
-0.0131468475,
0.0763676837,
0.0118020913,
-0.0502136424,
0.0369571298,
0.0546864383,
-0.0558923818,
0.0572673157,
0.0047927299,
-0.0151868714,
0.0452321842,
-0.0088838525,
0.0002781627,
-0.0522017665,
0.03319408,
0.0071115536,
-0.0007290983,
0.0475862324,
-0.0161139704,
0.0436890051,
-0.0646776557,
0.009292908,
0.0274484679,
-0.0316397659,
0.0557155982,
-0.0187817942,
0.0462364294,
0.0099086734,
-0.037038669,
-0.0254813209,
0.0475685149,
-0.0978656858,
0.0390439555,
-0.0414665975,
0.0225704294,
0.0118453177,
-0.0090330141,
-0.0361445472,
-0.0114454497,
-0.0226453114,
-0.0417424664,
0.0275108572,
0.0402296409,
-0.0473650917,
-0.0197488964,
0.0511228554,
0.0079078395,
-0.004321699,
0.0429044813,
-0.0030662369,
-0.0554498211,
0.0111942831,
0.0285446979,
0.0292487815,
-0.0156535767,
0.0671917349,
-0.0077415085,
0.0057036187,
-0.022245368,
0.00259322,
0.0453325771,
0.0113177188,
0.0136683416,
-0.0331388228,
0.0280709546,
0.0154561652,
-0.0080691278,
0.0366285518,
-0.0211143438,
0.0179499015,
0.0165880863,
-0.0067139165,
-0.000829371,
-0.0246478245,
-0.0679990053,
0.0085048657,
-0.0249530282,
0.0505087599,
0.0219255146,
0.0317715108,
-0.0229390208,
-0.0215088837,
-0.0316044763,
0.0036039155,
0.0154490573,
0.0095242569,
0.0174525902,
-0.0178557821,
0.0373905413,
-0.0321520492,
-0.0115928054,
0.0155504458,
0.0470628329,
-0.0144080147,
-0.0298899598,
-0.0231709704,
0.0395688601,
-0.0194974076,
0.009923799,
-0.003661359,
-0.0342803821,
-0.0179791544,
0.0023394953,
0.0399802513,
0.0092448052,
-0.041974932,
-0.0481699519,
0.0346380584,
-0.0469380766,
-0.0288718753,
-0.0285492372,
0.0135043859,
-0.0416923985,
-0.1006816924,
-0.0206459295,
-0.0251967777,
0.0659068525,
-0.0357419029,
-0.0129917683,
-0.1072136834,
-0.0618853793,
-0.0129446965,
0.0149555905,
0.0053076637,
0.0287225563,
-0.0017050691,
0.0417704359,
-0.0413483791,
-0.0281641278,
0.0385676958,
-0.0774646699,
-0.0365955979,
-0.0351813436,
0.0143522741,
-0.0133737912,
0.0234567504,
-0.0190711338,
0.0256314203,
-0.0416122787,
-0.0377749726,
-0.0750758946,
0.0297945682,
0.0120743075,
-0.0190232415,
0.0206160583,
-0.0284970459,
0.0201294664,
-0.0287216138,
-0.0212276019,
-0.0214737002,
-0.0073920377,
-0.0035738018,
-0.008446076,
0.0102046458,
-0.0306336209,
-0.0098961974,
0.0333536044,
0.0064130118,
0.0766557232,
0.0164191686,
0.0357069932,
-0.0257344935,
-0.0087825255,
0.0177395139,
-0.0029474697,
-0.027903961,
-0.0206709709,
0.033658158,
-0.0116605861,
0.0076804445,
-0.0588019863,
-0.0377200805,
0.0004753452,
0.0600711145,
-0.0269115977,
-0.0192345995,
-0.0292787831,
0.0623488724,
0.0273953695,
0.0006398143,
0.0737477615,
-0.0142490482,
-0.027608728,
-0.0155386925,
-0.0070405658,
0.0204975922,
-0.0054848148,
0.015643334,
-0.049713131,
-0.0113754841,
0.0177457929,
-0.0112045426,
0.0601838157,
0.0006773151,
-0.0133762294,
-0.1242762432,
-0.0299096163,
0.0359360985,
-0.0912274942,
-0.0561744832,
0.0005187527,
-0.0003398067,
-0.034220852,
0.0079626143,
0.0082376767,
0.0002928748,
0.0042202896,
0.0389139242,
-0.0211737901,
-0.0489757359,
-0.0026685914,
-0.054869134,
0.0419693217,
0.034730494,
0.0048207315,
-0.0153244464,
-0.0073149828,
0.0133031746,
-0.0208516438,
-0.0570674911,
0.0329429433,
0.0231378339,
-0.0183454417,
-0.0398093238,
0.0474954732,
-0.0228383634,
-0.0697745457,
-0.0159217883,
-0.0162298251,
0.0492706411,
0.0204121117,
0.0055019022,
0.050424654,
0.0102897212,
0.0022545357,
0.0281930231,
-0.0089310473,
-0.0358758196,
0.0049351463,
0.0162821077,
0.007261306,
-0.0569652505,
-0.0142109618,
0.0336932801,
-0.060125459,
-0.0608926937,
-0.068854779,
-0.0466734394,
0.0054829745,
0.0440946445,
0.0329896174,
0.0011477667,
0.0088820094,
-0.0035993026,
0.0111301336,
-0.0026619828,
-0.0402679667,
0.0106516024,
-0.0463717431,
-0.0412458964,
0.0151601853,
-0.0433641858,
0.0072995946,
-0.021448696,
-0.0813264996,
-0.0564803742,
0.0095819049,
0.0278859641,
0.0091436282,
0.0384340025,
-0.0142964507,
-0.0157923922,
0.0236413237,
-0.0578657016,
0.0048172586,
0.0322078206,
0.0395860337,
-0.0214638133,
-0.0162035935,
0.0464252494,
-0.0148380334,
0.0130670071,
0.019712694,
0.0253565982,
-0.0315568633,
-0.0594749525,
-0.0072371713,
0.0154091241,
0.0200048462,
-0.036142651,
-0.0185077321,
-0.0668061301,
0.0151963457,
-0.0249035824,
0.0108719291,
-0.0253116433,
-0.0421689264,
0.0724708363,
0.0198284779,
0.0327987373,
0.0061982046,
0.0055346726,
-0.0328430533,
-0.0084113581,
-0.0368864983,
0.0277055521,
0.0582527891,
0.0393705256,
0.0517519005,
-0.0086003719,
-0.0038939884,
-0.0042919042,
0.0299989488,
-0.0572452247,
-0.0026925881,
0.0197377242,
0.0317884274,
0.0376089811,
0.0238128398,
0.0046029226,
-0.0451590717,
-0.0017235836,
-0.013852193,
0.0681096315,
-0.0371919088,
0.0956467316,
0.0024926518,
0.0016403202,
-0.0435559899,
0.0396033712,
-0.0248647276,
0.013232558,
-0.0054023191,
-0.0384716243,
-0.0120833274,
0.0141848596,
0.064142704,
0.0045273765,
0.0201864708,
-0.0134737967,
0.0189521741,
0.0158592183,
-0.0390722752,
0.0245396104,
-0.0374750011,
-0.0374715701,
-0.0087009929,
-0.0169160441,
-0.072014913,
0.0185999293,
-0.012447793,
-0.0214167796,
0.0176131055,
0.0273870286,
0.0841735005,
-0.0309598912,
0.0589388721,
-0.0317984521,
-0.0095055141,
0.0158838499,
-0.0008223419,
0.0069225314,
-5.573679198e-33,
-0.0368404165,
0.0638583153,
0.0234401673,
-0.0336151272,
-0.0349466428,
-0.0224294681,
-0.0211608913,
-0.0071063214,
-0.0148882475,
0.0072724978,
0.0020980497,
-0.01264528,
0.0290828757,
0.0265378747,
0.0295099393,
-0.0183055196,
0.033208143,
0.0036675751,
-0.0279381573,
0.0188288391,
0.0659916475,
0.0609696954,
0.0982553586,
-0.0273013823,
-0.0048463754,
-0.0131844068,
0.0215931777,
-0.0126791485,
0.0467261672,
0.0247376226,
0.0096015679,
0.0090515744,
0.0093741911,
-0.0134121384,
-0.0347371101,
0.0346386842,
-0.047855936,
-0.0176491719,
0.0327724218,
0.0669200197,
-0.0033266873,
-0.0333682857,
-0.0122111226,
-0.0502046458,
0.012261169,
-0.0176716819,
0.0115532326,
-0.0372951366,
0.0028714209,
-0.0186954979,
-0.1028473303,
0.0200705007,
-0.0050350572,
-0.0141240768,
0.0677286685,
0.0581051074,
0.0191888213,
0.0260304902,
-0.030625524,
0.0146250939,
-0.0431481116,
0.0607931465,
0.09924604,
0.0297440719,
-0.0530290343,
0.0058394773,
-0.0033851191,
-0.0404333696,
0.0694727078,
0.0319157541,
0.0424603708,
-0.0238375384,
-0.005525873,
0.0445226356,
-0.0024136244,
-0.0214925464,
-0.0573533736,
0.0292785577,
-0.0224340837,
0.0041709375,
-0.0196291301,
0.0109605696,
0.0090778312,
-0.0249938574,
-0.0145507827,
-0.0347176529,
0.0124013117,
-0.0233012941,
0.0151232537,
-0.0226323847,
0.0047984007,
0.0393385589,
0.0961979702,
-0.0068791071,
0.0009748177,
0.0017242697,
-0.0454806015,
0.0238282215,
-0.0463378467,
0.0711863488,
-0.0648504049,
-0.0853447169,
0.0089311181,
-0.0301342122,
0.0331599452,
0.0099942125,
0.0467923433,
0.0387397893,
-0.0651622266,
0.0115900533,
-0.0239772964,
-0.0136845298,
0.0169106182,
0.0673109591,
0.0305220671,
0.0182618368,
-0.0005742812,
0.0419543423,
0.0515662208,
-0.0122602899,
0.005671184,
-0.0139702009,
0.0154186413,
-0.0005438107,
-0.027944291,
0.013771344,
-0.0505924523,
-0.0071829101,
0.0264982581,
-0.0310209934,
-0.0125414385,
0.0092419516,
2.501e-7,
0.0753719807,
-0.0186365824,
0.0453247242,
-0.0235942919,
-0.0181211531,
-0.0053707208,
-0.0422913954,
0.047571104,
-0.0023154444,
0.0257838201,
0.0431157015,
0.0189725682,
0.0875170529,
0.0160904825,
-0.025743369,
-0.0573252775,
-0.0361079983,
0.0417390577,
-0.0361031406,
0.0260673054,
-0.0043577892,
0.1010938436,
-0.0258394014,
0.0098080914,
-0.0109037375,
-0.025469834,
0.0601309314,
-0.0512042418,
-0.0254901629,
0.0352599137,
0.0164999962,
-0.0328995101,
-0.0452191122,
0.0246733706,
-0.041612599,
0.0232092366,
0.0642889068,
0.0501634479,
-0.0112124234,
-0.0030239399,
-0.0221441798,
0.0002858973,
-0.0281023886,
-0.0289106257,
0.0366410054,
0.0006404628,
-0.0286621228,
-0.0207625479,
-0.0412674956,
0.0323415734,
0.0329068676,
-0.0072952649,
-0.0218125191,
0.0195295103,
0.0813266337,
0.0248695295,
-0.0617666803,
-0.0312533192,
-0.0114593413,
0.0383186191,
-0.0065839165,
-0.0385893099,
0.0108865714,
-0.0619551465,
0.0458630063,
0.0002484634,
0.0217966996,
2.047226497e-34,
0.0108593646,
0.0016498973,
0.0315434523,
0.0077694221,
0.0125212846,
-0.0582247749,
-0.0255710334,
0.0337325707,
-0.0478121936,
-0.0282397307,
-0.0137522854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19736v1 | MM-Instruct: Generated Visual Instructions for Large Multimodal Model Alignment | 2024-06-28T08:25:27 | 2024-06-28T08:25:27 | Jihao Liu, Xin Huang, Jinliang Zheng, Boxiao Liu, Jia Wang, Osamu Yoshie, Yu Liu, Hongsheng Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces MM-Instruct, a large-scale dataset of diverse and
high-quality visual instruction data designed to enhance the
instruction-following capabilities of large multimodal models (LMMs). While
existing visual instruction datasets often focus on question-answering, they
struggle to generalize to broader application scenarios such as creative
writing, summarization, or image analysis. To address these limitations, we
propose a novel approach to constructing MM-Instruct that leverages the strong
instruction-following capabilities of existing LLMs to generate novel visual
instruction data from large-scale but conventional image captioning datasets.
MM-Instruct first leverages ChatGPT to automatically generate diverse
instructions from a small set of seed instructions through augmenting and
summarization. It then matches these instructions with images and uses an
open-sourced large language model (LLM) to generate coherent answers to the
instruction-image pairs. The LLM is grounded by the detailed text descriptions
of images in the whole answer generation process to guarantee the alignment of
the instruction data. Moreover, we introduce a benchmark based on the generated
instruction data to evaluate the instruction-following capabilities of existing
LMMs. We demonstrate the effectiveness of MM-Instruct by training a LLaVA-1.5
model on the generated data, denoted as LLaVA-Instruct, which exhibits
significant improvements in instruction-following capabilities compared to
LLaVA-1.5 models. The MM-Instruct dataset, benchmark, and pre-trained models
are available at https://github.com/jihaonew/MM-Instruct. | [
0.0386260338,
0.0676017478,
0.0046103275,
0.0518097654,
-0.0114645334,
0.0035743348,
-0.0020612571,
-0.0238886792,
0.0086249299,
-0.0573248081,
-0.040587347,
-0.0193021484,
-0.0233724322,
0.0096569601,
0.0365286507,
-0.0472171158,
0.0257636365,
-0.0397673063,
-0.0433168933,
0.0085363025,
0.0405920148,
0.0383046828,
-0.0104975216,
0.0420991331,
-0.0157173686,
-0.0567638613,
-0.0081844721,
0.0280076396,
0.0095229987,
-0.0350439809,
0.0095638288,
0.0456920601,
0.0689829513,
0.0034372518,
0.0000017734,
-0.0076988121,
0.0205702428,
-0.0134099172,
0.0194140766,
-0.0059594698,
0.0259582214,
-0.0371181518,
0.016822638,
-0.0013962587,
-0.0144708985,
0.0169131607,
0.0742420703,
0.0388813764,
0.1233524978,
0.0725674555,
-0.0014470153,
-0.0323236473,
0.0202917587,
-0.0082268501,
0.0264699589,
-0.0047361255,
-0.0081115793,
0.0703141615,
0.0096319523,
0.0211796965,
-0.0474414714,
0.0674220398,
0.0274453387,
-0.0337628014,
0.0162733514,
0.0278635677,
0.0063840412,
-0.0221173689,
-0.0275321528,
0.1171218082,
0.0263823047,
0.0177486632,
-0.0500681847,
0.0053257816,
-0.0029501754,
0.0036185447,
-0.0804981068,
0.0535987169,
-0.0020636788,
0.0024165241,
-0.0401877202,
-0.0060572452,
-0.0252768546,
0.0003158418,
0.0483053923,
-0.0222232863,
0.0346465185,
0.00602279,
-0.0542956181,
0.0040426496,
-0.0697798282,
-0.0748363957,
-0.0306300167,
0.0568442941,
-0.0102334805,
0.010447178,
-0.0613975339,
-0.0222924091,
0.0076175509,
-0.0334827378,
0.0849597827,
0.0298145711,
-0.0446035713,
0.0455086045,
-0.0077908724,
0.0679882318,
-0.0365313403,
0.0505836643,
-0.0580279641,
0.004845032,
-0.0537115782,
-0.0215240829,
-0.0312610231,
-0.0052756025,
-0.0546489023,
-0.0503306538,
-0.028523406,
0.0424209721,
-0.0147495829,
0.0141462926,
0.003041602,
0.0142152887,
-0.0240694489,
0.0083823921,
-0.0402323939,
0.0404141769,
-0.0188916251,
0.0002223507,
-0.0054405476,
-0.0244781263,
0.0040206192,
0.0442732088,
0.0178295057,
-0.0220196228,
0.0142943002,
0.0885829702,
-0.0709296241,
-0.0151665537,
-0.0207863133,
-0.0424786992,
-0.0028923091,
-0.0562203005,
0.03045341,
-0.0571364127,
0.0313416757,
-0.0129259881,
-0.00585014,
-0.0118849566,
0.0058543836,
0.0477061346,
-0.0119450362,
0.0753355846,
-0.0040913895,
0.0036971406,
0.0287249628,
0.0146399075,
0.0172201563,
0.0576679967,
0.0315346234,
0.0373597778,
0.0506218411,
-0.0171084106,
0.0125311324,
0.0440055989,
0.0153869065,
0.0188486576,
-0.0053484561,
0.0292710662,
0.0229354165,
0.0436637774,
0.039353773,
0.0458594784,
-0.0253126994,
-0.0005529647,
0.0932473987,
0.0253884252,
-0.0131376879,
-0.0030139629,
0.0619327687,
0.015078852,
0.0154664665,
0.0280331727,
-0.0682642087,
0.0804259405,
0.0039848438,
0.0353963934,
0.0448967554,
0.0246674996,
-0.0373642109,
-0.0136721367,
-0.0050071762,
0.0044142478,
-0.0320400037,
0.0006368707,
-0.0112743527,
0.0123698367,
-0.0658907145,
0.0139426356,
-0.0010842909,
-0.0344263837,
0.0060806852,
-0.0094939368,
0.0413025022,
0.0625500232,
0.0426905826,
0.0063523776,
-0.053529948,
-0.0020427795,
0.0584673323,
0.0549475141,
-0.0060560433,
-0.0209588036,
0.0132438643,
-0.061921604,
-0.0305796191,
-0.0499916859,
-0.0200812053,
-0.0095430221,
0.0245026108,
-0.0195562206,
0.0014396092,
-0.0076418333,
-0.0385465622,
0.05292679,
0.0149979405,
-0.0383374318,
-0.0465908349,
0.0058201249,
0.006576261,
-0.0081270002,
-0.0207796749,
0.0029060191,
-0.0047139893,
-0.0241173636,
-0.0005492886,
0.0147245172,
-0.0519151092,
-0.0538598411,
0.0328815915,
-0.0652726367,
-0.0330458358,
-0.0067724688,
-0.056421306,
-0.01994518,
-0.0023425764,
-0.0439025573,
-0.0245889574,
-0.057283394,
-0.0198101196,
0.0423994064,
0.0044498965,
-0.0121829743,
0.0249008182,
-0.0084479153,
0.0015554355,
0.0277592093,
0.0099454029,
0.0016914731,
-0.0204237103,
0.0010440742,
-0.009826405,
0.016197145,
0.0295133311,
0.0027298823,
0.0565166697,
-0.0518976934,
-0.0316002816,
-0.108720459,
0.0336367413,
-0.0121909594,
-0.0124253854,
0.0337808691,
-0.0049114763,
0.0059754266,
-0.0321622193,
-0.0444714986,
-0.0009169244,
0.0307522006,
0.0150492741,
0.0518106818,
0.0097751766,
0.0022663311,
-0.0381381847,
0.0000534499,
0.006074605,
0.0374099538,
0.0157440044,
0.0329969414,
-0.036745321,
-0.0175223704,
-0.0389441289,
0.0184956659,
-0.0019697638,
-0.0465967953,
0.0272923056,
0.000393303,
0.0541809835,
0.0433605798,
0.0212307181,
0.0067244535,
0.0210260209,
-0.011589353,
-0.026924964,
0.0133586153,
0.0094995685,
-0.0648871437,
0.0102549363,
-0.0602615625,
-0.0308157019,
0.0429694057,
0.0028292602,
0.0193046592,
-0.0754296258,
0.0196872242,
0.0295711663,
-0.0186646264,
-0.0530834571,
0.0264310203,
0.006733417,
-0.0133123547,
-0.0669501871,
-0.0769430995,
0.0490341932,
-0.0603034161,
-0.0306895413,
-0.0037296833,
0.0031402493,
-0.0432390869,
0.0595757402,
0.0216793474,
0.0347227193,
-0.0115467999,
0.0135381324,
-0.064668484,
-0.0188143477,
0.0458143838,
0.0003379161,
0.0534748696,
-0.0607670024,
0.003679286,
-0.0353438966,
-0.0044089216,
-0.0298782848,
-0.0470016673,
0.0028932486,
-0.0211516842,
-0.001163136,
-0.0129331481,
-0.0053800722,
0.0109634278,
0.0297569782,
0.0134073477,
-0.0107451566,
-0.0087830909,
-0.0395092964,
0.0297268145,
0.0958087146,
0.0269450229,
-0.0479985625,
-0.074152261,
0.0305975899,
0.0354730263,
-0.0095907878,
-0.0256628711,
-0.0278397016,
0.0247744489,
0.0007569822,
0.0243205111,
0.0359758213,
0.0377581529,
0.1134271547,
-0.0323140956,
0.007611989,
0.0657976344,
0.006571624,
-0.0196333341,
-0.0298673064,
0.0342851803,
0.0467349924,
0.0311091859,
0.0210034847,
-0.0848184377,
-0.0488456711,
-0.0397801921,
0.0025918272,
0.0261890367,
0.0141424565,
-0.0525430031,
-0.084731929,
0.0547908433,
0.0073154494,
-0.0395970717,
-0.0316988453,
0.0223116241,
-0.0108770011,
0.0130980862,
-0.006801344,
-0.0018136294,
-0.0388496742,
0.0086287139,
0.0001958194,
0.0059900857,
-0.011433091,
0.0053016446,
-0.0620782785,
0.025699798,
0.0347705185,
0.0054308274,
0.0101130651,
-0.0340917595,
0.010501178,
0.0187456198,
0.002088594,
0.002424692,
0.0836911052,
-0.0271288026,
-0.0294211544,
-0.0158321634,
0.048519589,
0.0000473629,
-0.0142912036,
0.0153351426,
0.0452975556,
-0.0082832184,
0.0190910976,
-0.0394534729,
0.0484462082,
0.0117775053,
0.047467947,
0.0335802846,
-0.0326780826,
-0.0276744459,
-0.0145818302,
-0.0076175677,
-0.0753292963,
-0.0041489922,
0.0174988937,
-0.051110588,
0.0306657851,
-0.0788731053,
-0.0210923757,
0.0540410019,
0.0323023722,
0.0192922894,
-0.0106115257,
-0.0227155946,
0.0095213884,
-0.0529231317,
0.0704623759,
-0.0339995772,
0.0232382268,
-0.0580657162,
-0.0240453277,
-0.0038626553,
-0.0388912819,
-0.0080062924,
0.0371930003,
-0.0893345177,
-0.0314305089,
-0.0524466671,
0.0738133788,
0.0034792812,
0.0412295349,
0.0542777628,
-0.0245700758,
0.0048839641,
0.0059855385,
0.017245179,
0.0093647633,
0.0014045074,
-0.0004339472,
-0.0108788321,
0.0080819614,
-0.0260338187,
0.0290634055,
-0.0014820631,
0.0390131585,
0.0152184749,
-0.0303098261,
0.0146425162,
0.0211070944,
-0.0162916761,
-0.0315207317,
0.0285528265,
-0.0412252471,
-0.0006459103,
-0.0006125104,
-0.0346991383,
-0.0638455972,
0.0209807698,
0.0044227224,
-0.0067774956,
0.0046046912,
-0.0059335544,
-0.0066884407,
0.0371074304,
-0.0449349768,
0.0175294764,
0.0137603236,
-0.0012296945,
-0.0100243185,
0.0273071341,
-0.0248116106,
0.0159461629,
-0.0304841567,
0.0364742056,
-0.0039544939,
0.1025177091,
0.020604372,
-0.0060925591,
-0.0096353628,
0.0411514454,
-0.0099131726,
-0.0240933429,
-0.0464097336,
0.0399896838,
0.0795378163,
-0.0009526614,
0.012005453,
-0.0048219496,
-0.0252858121,
-0.0105588995,
0.0777017847,
-0.0240805764,
-0.0296602156,
0.0670639724,
0.017058393,
0.0185817145,
-0.0220761914,
0.0660597757,
-0.0077388291,
0.0301271472,
-0.0068831625,
-0.0009380736,
-0.0368028022,
-0.018746173,
0.0457116105,
-0.0147338789,
0.0146587314,
0.0390789695,
0.0087005608,
-0.0532250106,
-0.0107028158,
0.0361089446,
-0.0486798882,
0.016631484,
0.047864981,
0.0175165348,
0.0199481547,
-0.0343852229,
-0.0308027286,
-0.0058052125,
-0.0230605062,
0.0101750335,
-0.0026049784,
-5.607466947e-33,
-0.0478573032,
-0.0450421087,
0.058862891,
-0.0196723733,
-0.037966907,
0.0004720254,
-0.0194013231,
-0.0035159974,
0.0119455131,
-0.0044858321,
0.0468207821,
-0.0300256908,
-0.0016154987,
0.0474220291,
0.0125201056,
0.0039924732,
0.0307065025,
-0.0151335876,
-0.0233756527,
0.0163561571,
0.0263288748,
-0.0079439161,
0.0476273783,
-0.0388987735,
0.0117563615,
-0.0319717862,
-0.0248929076,
0.0194953941,
0.0016788928,
0.0759251341,
-0.030652836,
0.0147723146,
0.0115981661,
-0.0090325866,
-0.0322262906,
0.0184750445,
-0.0381180272,
-0.0083615808,
0.0490875393,
0.0029973965,
-0.0970010087,
-0.0373917446,
-0.0006068108,
-0.0635150746,
0.0141484197,
-0.0464988537,
0.0569865257,
-0.0051089069,
0.0293950774,
0.0262459498,
-0.0601116605,
-0.0094088754,
-0.022997329,
-0.0676386133,
-0.0082431249,
0.0440236032,
0.0411975607,
0.0004070353,
-0.0209655035,
0.0266174916,
0.0092017502,
0.0352758393,
0.0823486224,
0.0561378859,
0.0013715527,
0.0526870377,
-0.0105459513,
-0.0331477784,
-0.0259999912,
0.0191148538,
-0.0120466743,
0.071577698,
0.0408793166,
0.0593385063,
0.018807685,
0.0516618937,
-0.0137438206,
0.0264096297,
-0.0525918342,
0.027297629,
0.0097609404,
-0.0103349146,
0.0036087669,
0.0220259167,
-0.0263031181,
0.00155457,
-0.0309576076,
-0.0226085205,
0.0511647239,
0.0229190234,
-0.0110010011,
0.0176971555,
0.0720575675,
-0.0254049059,
-0.0030478889,
-0.0167748798,
-0.041419331,
0.0587761924,
-0.0103289494,
0.0122282775,
-0.027486762,
-0.0317094326,
0.0737419352,
-0.0338951349,
0.01678464,
0.0311483592,
0.061479792,
0.0297590755,
-0.0432922095,
0.0080586635,
-0.0326023959,
0.0153646478,
-0.0500975028,
-0.0178364888,
0.0053519481,
0.0124551039,
-0.0730455667,
0.0259430408,
-0.0080382992,
-0.0017090894,
-0.0390542522,
-0.0762302279,
-0.0033736695,
0.0225194264,
-0.0188277457,
0.05568818,
-0.0503655858,
-0.0456712767,
-0.020249933,
-0.0731246024,
-0.0144273303,
0.0573225878,
2.325e-7,
0.0311764684,
0.0108292,
0.0481211431,
0.0436621457,
0.0080914423,
0.0264190566,
-0.0566443279,
0.0103849759,
0.012325881,
-0.0338557735,
0.0168852787,
0.0484461598,
0.0461752973,
0.0035107385,
-0.0176314153,
0.0157568213,
-0.0619164035,
-0.0036723837,
-0.0622175708,
-0.0006891115,
0.0766789988,
0.0736670271,
-0.0428890809,
-0.0240110178,
0.005635228,
-0.0367165096,
0.0892144665,
-0.0177639741,
-0.0373162851,
0.0022039132,
0.0120179476,
0.007522691,
-0.0145519152,
-0.0045005297,
-0.0100630075,
-0.038246084,
0.0363048576,
0.0631816387,
-0.0060241148,
-0.0163797941,
-0.0294585656,
0.0157296024,
-0.0330316648,
-0.0290971305,
0.0547809377,
-0.0557542369,
-0.0112127392,
-0.0475117937,
-0.0336846933,
-0.002499908,
0.0134568326,
-0.038522251,
-0.0366280489,
0.0228024982,
0.0531215966,
-0.0369158499,
-0.019800825,
-0.04974778,
-0.0261854548,
0.0111231618,
-0.0395911969,
-0.024752669,
-0.0731366873,
-0.0184124522,
0.0139439944,
-0.0512736589,
-0.0473850518,
1.983854036e-34,
0.0355369449,
-0.0353544168,
0.0370865203,
0.007742126,
0.0260491613,
-0.0097917747,
-0.0295718238,
-0.0060271416,
-0.0004899138,
-0.0854462907,
-0.0269078482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19731v1 | Message du troisi{è}me type : irruption d'un tiers dans un dialogue en ligne | 2024-06-28T08:20:32 | 2024-06-28T08:20:32 | Ludovic Tanguy, Céline Poudat, Lydia-Mai Ho-Dac | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our study focuses on Wikipedia talk pages, from a global perspective
analyzing contributors' behaviors in online interactions. Using a corpus
comprising all Wikipedia talk pages in French, totaling more than 300,000
discussion threads, we examine how discussions with more than two participants
(multiparty conversation) unfold and we specifically investigate the role of a
third participant's intervention when two Wikipedians have already initiated an
exchange. In this regard, we concentrate on the sequential structure of these
interactions in terms of articulation among different participants and aim to
specify this third message by exploring its lexical particularities, while also
proposing an initial typology of the third participant's message role and how
it aligns with preceding messages. | [
0.1003698111,
0.0221858453,
-0.0260404292,
0.0346997157,
-0.0321535803,
0.001712295,
0.0176280849,
0.0197857097,
0.0232448615,
-0.0625618026,
0.0138685321,
-0.0364837758,
0.0265591927,
-0.0044650296,
0.0450518243,
-0.0373042077,
0.0078352094,
0.0153326802,
0.023685772,
-0.0046369005,
0.0650212467,
0.0309245363,
-0.0577405281,
0.0504349843,
-0.000960777,
0.0257813223,
-0.0290115047,
-0.0089407107,
0.0203187782,
-0.005598621,
0.030064119,
0.10037411,
-0.0180316828,
0.0180234592,
0.0000017552,
-0.0364008285,
0.0369192064,
-0.0363237597,
-0.0036726496,
0.0283677839,
0.0042458945,
0.0075656981,
-0.0012403285,
-0.0072513665,
-0.037704654,
0.0007803809,
0.0368154235,
0.0252877194,
0.0414084755,
0.0246116389,
-0.0155420536,
-0.00415082,
0.0016848674,
0.0021100461,
0.0300422031,
-0.0052993931,
0.030546695,
-0.0295829382,
-0.0220649373,
0.0010173777,
-0.0084267175,
0.018034894,
-0.0435146987,
-0.0726185441,
0.0329077505,
-0.0226921309,
-0.0184759386,
-0.0622562133,
0.0383013263,
0.0395648666,
0.1269192845,
0.0068464121,
0.0376834981,
0.0304838773,
0.0081950305,
0.0807107016,
-0.0484710932,
0.017371105,
-0.0072138947,
-0.0325750262,
0.017370766,
0.006213651,
-0.0034707454,
0.0126522761,
-0.028026903,
0.0634446964,
-0.0040647318,
-0.0062889904,
-0.0211770795,
0.0164838377,
0.000344354,
-0.0547446758,
0.0188271161,
0.0147092715,
0.0003736498,
0.0120948646,
0.0341103524,
-0.0147439269,
0.0417088047,
-0.096214883,
-0.0698877722,
0.010777479,
0.0284156073,
0.0255301092,
0.0691414773,
-0.0659457669,
-0.0211174134,
-0.0045889523,
0.0307401586,
0.0165281389,
-0.0363411717,
-0.0152738607,
-0.013778043,
-0.0008805708,
0.0212875642,
-0.0177347567,
-0.0044085206,
0.030920174,
-0.0081434641,
-0.0076933126,
0.0157498065,
-0.0393865332,
-0.0091371583,
0.0232655536,
-0.0278497301,
0.0445746332,
-0.0720563829,
0.0084266197,
-0.0116959922,
-0.0389490426,
0.0273491573,
0.0011999112,
0.0179626867,
-0.0233669057,
-0.0320009701,
0.0546669737,
0.0012409517,
0.0183443036,
0.0601918288,
-0.0497748107,
-0.0085637197,
-0.0171290468,
-0.0306191165,
-0.0507105663,
0.0444208942,
0.0458371043,
-0.0172325335,
-0.0168389473,
0.0155143198,
-0.0075587188,
-0.0593931824,
0.0393121578,
-0.0768264458,
0.0378093272,
0.0552416779,
0.046181988,
0.0026800658,
0.0189104136,
-0.0008696785,
-0.0559229925,
0.062026266,
0.0048372173,
-0.0176674295,
0.0465713218,
0.0109978467,
0.0094843227,
0.0637791604,
0.0120453201,
-0.0144972224,
0.0130969929,
-0.0099127246,
0.0339721553,
-0.0376394019,
-0.0184759833,
0.0297689717,
0.0868812054,
-0.0609446988,
0.0238361787,
-0.0017328791,
0.0307804029,
0.0134829264,
0.0436776914,
0.0299643129,
-0.0096985865,
0.042967461,
-0.0312174484,
0.0567206554,
-0.0180733763,
-0.0058854884,
-0.0099293683,
0.0177970156,
0.0247607846,
0.0236500334,
-0.0460705161,
-0.0076281852,
0.003649608,
0.0172992628,
0.0631763712,
0.0241333582,
-0.051485762,
0.0023626736,
-0.0062707332,
-0.0018100785,
0.0641266927,
0.0062587215,
0.022528559,
-0.0295995232,
-0.0165717378,
0.0376324356,
0.0506824516,
0.0203512684,
-0.0341702737,
-0.0446352251,
0.0025411793,
-0.0109650893,
-0.0225604102,
0.0095027778,
0.009457659,
-0.0395684503,
0.0266173091,
-0.0361880101,
0.0064137396,
0.0214693174,
-0.0198036674,
-0.0024891186,
0.0374476686,
-0.0901742801,
0.0227287617,
-0.0052773049,
0.0306539182,
-0.0317725576,
-0.019932067,
0.0267896373,
0.0028086537,
0.003188364,
0.0452654064,
0.0072512431,
-0.0003680377,
0.0197037701,
-0.0492891483,
-0.0221693367,
-0.0364243612,
0.0487732403,
-0.0112218484,
0.0823953003,
-0.0414747931,
0.060821943,
0.0130012883,
-0.0075490735,
-0.0168335661,
-0.0134563046,
-0.0057919901,
0.0063536647,
-0.0238026213,
0.0477877818,
0.0416011177,
-0.052260004,
0.0045596929,
0.0259082783,
-0.015243371,
0.0462384187,
0.0070964266,
0.0292723272,
0.0684204251,
-0.0247424468,
-0.0394004844,
-0.0139936339,
-0.0955145657,
-0.0592812859,
-0.0430597849,
0.0505784936,
0.0470566675,
0.0099322246,
0.009308259,
0.010243875,
-0.0515934639,
0.0052745189,
-0.0082911951,
0.010770495,
0.0555720367,
0.0498222373,
0.0023470244,
-0.0179245062,
-0.0034289267,
-0.018322112,
0.0425669253,
0.0585955679,
-0.1046245545,
-0.0247509871,
-0.0024772987,
-0.0842170715,
-0.0291540436,
-0.0354697444,
-0.050274726,
0.0313070007,
-0.0163021684,
0.0365351923,
0.0032641261,
0.0738819093,
0.0665127784,
-0.0364679508,
-0.0276900716,
-0.0645140111,
-0.027063977,
-0.0249708127,
0.0004389895,
-0.0739412308,
-0.0182287935,
0.0315046869,
0.0706690103,
-0.002585765,
0.0240355991,
-0.0195820034,
0.0274238493,
0.00225064,
-0.0018183907,
-0.0125014903,
-0.0608614609,
-0.0017514769,
0.05317913,
0.0098105809,
0.0105566634,
0.01294854,
0.0087454384,
-0.0195737109,
-0.0116913058,
-0.0262144934,
0.0149946623,
0.0626455843,
-0.0140099451,
0.0303631201,
0.0384818017,
-0.0673662499,
-0.0299554821,
0.0067450735,
0.0797905326,
-0.0061456454,
0.0378773138,
-0.0020907661,
0.0293682851,
-0.0001597112,
-0.0326921158,
0.0135146575,
-0.0407105982,
-0.0037749263,
-0.0405986793,
0.0368314758,
-0.0302083269,
-0.0111108767,
0.0239583869,
0.0084409025,
-0.0189554244,
0.0184837244,
-0.0015857286,
-0.0209552236,
0.047866419,
-0.0228917375,
0.016447816,
0.0042389682,
-0.0262674149,
-0.0062528616,
0.0454138145,
-0.0100315511,
-0.0276115071,
0.0505425185,
-0.051838357,
0.049609933,
-0.0392532051,
-0.0707452968,
-0.0374135338,
0.0337365754,
-0.0401474759,
0.0039347415,
0.0557217039,
0.0324451551,
-0.0817073211,
-0.0102503374,
-0.0215041488,
0.0149613386,
-0.000806843,
-0.0066088843,
-0.0907260478,
0.0584128164,
-0.0474449508,
-0.033599399,
-0.0475521423,
-0.0304530375,
-0.0153170191,
-0.053865958,
0.0259489436,
-0.004376302,
-0.0195790157,
0.0373957641,
0.0118585275,
0.019182371,
0.0204609931,
-0.0201290194,
0.0063409819,
0.0122771142,
0.0153366663,
0.0171393678,
-0.0378063507,
-0.0074795485,
-0.0515431575,
-0.032746017,
0.055512324,
-0.0415260904,
0.0422269367,
-0.0198564716,
0.0058198967,
0.0175950974,
-0.0041226237,
-0.0295927171,
0.0024665012,
0.0474148579,
-0.0190998819,
-0.0030269786,
-0.0659665763,
-0.0147796692,
0.0091923,
-0.0121075585,
0.0152672986,
0.0294815525,
-0.0184702035,
-0.015260458,
0.0182069149,
0.0379602388,
0.0464630127,
-0.001620331,
0.0396787189,
-0.0223150272,
0.0230968241,
-0.0480732769,
0.0131614432,
-0.0289678145,
-0.0907570571,
-0.0802658498,
0.0265364815,
-0.0443895757,
-0.0789589882,
-0.0529986583,
-0.0386782847,
0.0167684406,
0.024994107,
0.0359869152,
0.0345050953,
0.0070839338,
-0.0284272879,
-0.0055668731,
-0.0046699569,
-0.0193928201,
-0.0271092411,
-0.0555214733,
0.0058026314,
-0.0033973888,
-0.0097266249,
-0.0084929829,
-0.0343992561,
-0.0686767101,
-0.0108201485,
0.0356875733,
0.0321077779,
0.0170101002,
0.0034241565,
-0.0384309255,
-0.0049007502,
0.021440018,
0.0019685724,
0.0106355194,
0.0039244029,
0.0384863168,
-0.0146767078,
0.0391771831,
0.0208133273,
-0.0077889566,
-0.0558523647,
-0.0162658431,
-0.0633042455,
-0.0691661835,
-0.0303304326,
0.0000182022,
0.0121547952,
-0.0012141898,
0.0205010995,
-0.0374917425,
-0.0260895118,
-0.0146314064,
-0.0045544845,
0.0102885524,
0.000965787,
-0.0276412554,
-0.0209610742,
0.0089757787,
0.0115900151,
-0.0321376622,
0.0265363026,
-0.0380786881,
0.0354437046,
0.020094499,
-0.0170986205,
0.0188760608,
0.0211913679,
0.0164045505,
0.0119978813,
0.0480341353,
0.0213132892,
-0.0467484556,
0.0117362365,
0.0285339858,
-0.0681505799,
0.0564406849,
0.0422261655,
-0.0846735463,
-0.0664649829,
0.0385841168,
-0.0091845766,
0.0383170471,
0.0075682374,
0.1021009609,
-0.0035069352,
-0.0015970777,
-0.001515488,
0.0511987135,
-0.0083028553,
-0.0442794338,
-0.0128638297,
0.007806771,
-0.0340524428,
0.0187855978,
0.0449559577,
-0.0535558239,
0.0090818945,
0.0352878869,
-0.0222736746,
-0.0237617977,
-0.0463792756,
-0.0014634363,
0.0027609244,
-0.0206229109,
-0.0198171791,
-0.0524551868,
-0.0153823225,
-0.0378805622,
-0.0291864369,
0.0293459632,
-0.0109715164,
0.0187844839,
0.040428102,
0.04775507,
0.0133377239,
-0.0602549054,
0.0375662483,
-0.0877347738,
0.0155874277,
-0.005978927,
-5.982764457e-33,
-0.0008777372,
-0.0753198266,
-0.0168593843,
0.0744742751,
-0.0559863523,
-0.0076951687,
-0.0218588281,
0.0551672392,
-0.0160063263,
0.0074049053,
0.0035800333,
0.0478435978,
0.0129368287,
-0.0276329461,
0.0448625088,
-0.0236779079,
0.0238859225,
0.0066449158,
-0.0327241421,
0.0418242589,
0.0408913456,
-0.0083285477,
0.0538525283,
-0.0663775206,
0.1021082252,
-0.0392558128,
-0.0236147363,
-0.0034393887,
0.0486146025,
0.0175731108,
0.0072140777,
0.0547890216,
0.0306526124,
-0.0112366313,
-0.0004586733,
0.0674572513,
-0.0168937426,
-0.0449232459,
0.0503567494,
0.0276944116,
-0.0074990643,
-0.0186628662,
0.0322737098,
-0.0224442855,
-0.0356066376,
0.0329713747,
0.0538083091,
0.0424480587,
0.0224245135,
0.0254577715,
-0.0427854173,
0.0053490931,
-0.0336375125,
0.0082555581,
0.0134451054,
0.0429272279,
0.0633861423,
-0.07492093,
-0.0402901657,
0.0807678178,
-0.0763136297,
0.0230549052,
-0.0086092493,
-0.0298842173,
0.0137015479,
0.0530735888,
0.0055111134,
0.0892525688,
0.0021566974,
0.034813989,
-0.016887486,
0.0560763814,
0.0034104199,
0.0679129437,
-0.0282458868,
-0.016586246,
-0.0510100909,
-0.0061678356,
0.0562376417,
-0.0013340726,
-0.0141189229,
-0.0334757641,
-0.0112680262,
-0.0352596343,
-0.0280922595,
-0.0381304063,
-0.0134732025,
-0.0532280877,
-0.0245117228,
-0.0380439982,
0.0009537635,
-0.0002753971,
0.0236159973,
-0.0416835435,
-0.0629386082,
0.0295206401,
-0.0309636183,
0.056034103,
0.0020691168,
-0.0003801487,
-0.0087087518,
-0.005299998,
-0.0280290395,
0.0266751833,
0.0322922431,
0.0474571921,
-0.0320003815,
-0.0059580053,
-0.0292294305,
-0.0333123505,
0.0044333683,
-0.0155335059,
-0.0498605333,
-0.0021778103,
0.0262681581,
0.0057274653,
-0.0118941711,
0.0106785735,
0.0447601788,
0.0159771629,
-0.0291886795,
-0.0421278886,
-0.0403424464,
0.0117151532,
-0.0440113731,
-0.0158512872,
-0.0508407094,
0.0552712716,
0.0425772481,
0.0036279748,
-0.0134157632,
-0.0806123316,
2.619e-7,
0.0419357978,
0.0526196323,
0.0399641395,
0.033183597,
0.0532379746,
-0.0075905486,
0.0242982712,
0.0622865036,
-0.0066796262,
-0.0590904951,
0.0051060636,
-0.0020939505,
0.0077954056,
0.0197655167,
-0.0868454203,
-0.0754323453,
-0.0579558276,
-0.0108780479,
-0.0340893716,
0.0223136973,
0.0310468115,
-0.0149670737,
0.0061517898,
0.0228407159,
-0.0482847616,
-0.0090320511,
0.0457674898,
-0.0504786894,
-0.0245708395,
0.0552693531,
0.0224646982,
-0.0251410622,
0.0139250746,
0.0498047695,
0.0082839252,
-0.016438432,
0.0164349135,
0.0052944105,
0.0364730582,
0.0157576669,
-0.0163926631,
-0.0612165332,
0.0476743989,
-0.0354249626,
-0.0167256203,
-0.0081384294,
-0.0527238324,
0.0097506735,
-0.0058047138,
-0.0493856333,
0.0625781566,
-0.0343939252,
-0.02777211,
0.0319580808,
-0.0167562328,
0.0121758003,
0.0177327879,
-0.0579925999,
-0.0325655825,
-0.0339789465,
-0.0092350869,
-0.0974198505,
0.0103706792,
-0.0534391701,
0.0154829109,
0.0014119752,
0.0213178042,
1.640195048e-34,
0.0074769356,
-0.0115221599,
0.0023928944,
0.0458726138,
0.047980424,
-0.0078335749,
0.0253939796,
0.0048880214,
0.0404229872,
-0.0136683714,
-0.0245474633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19729v1 | Le sens de la famille : analyse du vocabulaire de la parent{é} par les plongements de mots | 2024-06-28T08:19:36 | 2024-06-28T08:19:36 | Ludovic Tanguy, Cécile Fabre, Nabil Hathout, Lydia-Mai Ho-Dac | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we propose a corpus analysis of an area of the French lexicon
that is both dense and highly structured: the vocabulary of family
relationships. Starting with a lexicon of 25 nouns designating the main
relationships (son, cousin, mother, grandfather, sister-in-law etc.), we
examine how these terms are positioned in relation to each other through
distributional analyses based on the use of these terms in corpora. We show
that distributional information can capture certain features that organize this
vocabulary (descent, alliance, siblings, genre), in ways that vary according to
the different corpora compared. | [
-0.0106227593,
0.0528468303,
-0.0255133621,
0.0573917702,
-0.0264291987,
-0.0001589584,
-0.0315459073,
0.0166385416,
-0.0447107367,
-0.0459009558,
0.0039573596,
-0.0818997473,
0.0490817204,
-0.0344293825,
-0.028626265,
-0.0381982066,
-0.0054725125,
0.0421168096,
0.0006773149,
-0.0214606151,
0.0303605832,
0.0328321308,
0.0100424085,
0.0107287252,
-0.0094683319,
0.0208212268,
0.0124651724,
0.0250082742,
0.0351092778,
-0.00195034,
0.006493222,
0.055975493,
0.0064220116,
-0.0212349202,
0.000001766,
-0.0315311439,
-0.033213567,
-0.0177170355,
0.0348056853,
-0.0232208148,
0.0641719103,
-0.0109899528,
-0.000667251,
-0.0312892012,
0.0172840245,
0.0140370298,
0.0738848746,
-0.0291819386,
-0.0470346026,
0.0227974765,
0.0053293039,
-0.0996126384,
-0.0098376554,
-0.0260503981,
0.0217583291,
0.0298349131,
-0.014527576,
0.0076284814,
0.0078967409,
-0.0361434072,
-0.0539995693,
0.0071509951,
-0.0386594199,
-0.0106835812,
0.0198211204,
0.0174065586,
0.0160751399,
-0.0229886025,
0.038585268,
-0.0022864756,
0.0941759497,
-0.0133856237,
0.0096842404,
0.0153205888,
-0.0325383097,
0.0957670286,
-0.0104854973,
0.022873994,
-0.0172766596,
0.0149794295,
0.042827677,
-0.0229531173,
0.0040889876,
-0.0079428013,
-0.0679927394,
0.0642738715,
-0.0136918295,
-0.0457725786,
0.014691568,
-0.0157048944,
-0.0113745742,
-0.0347216614,
0.0036187961,
-0.0482805893,
0.0178972483,
0.0398465954,
0.040828716,
-0.0163871367,
0.0249652956,
-0.0414692387,
-0.0375496782,
-0.0202167034,
0.000638622,
-0.0259656589,
0.1010427251,
-0.0096901041,
0.0062714727,
-0.0636020005,
-0.0402608663,
0.0020117851,
-0.0893438607,
0.018659832,
0.0039593582,
-0.0066837049,
-0.0479472689,
0.0100129852,
-0.0106031597,
-0.0086907884,
0.0132876616,
-0.0255874228,
0.009781667,
0.0043208315,
0.02482282,
0.0347521454,
-0.0757297054,
0.0212833267,
-0.1078250855,
0.0090739727,
-0.0432740524,
0.0023654543,
0.0474762544,
0.0062935678,
0.0174136832,
-0.031049313,
-0.0161516499,
-0.0314462557,
0.036890313,
-0.0111850547,
0.0232196227,
-0.0229901597,
-0.06969928,
-0.0518763997,
-0.0293964762,
-0.0479371659,
-0.0045834584,
0.0204382259,
0.008994814,
-0.0252071619,
0.0185204297,
-0.0196363237,
-0.0774896368,
0.0189509168,
0.0302572455,
0.0211526677,
0.0105513046,
-0.0057315701,
0.0397858843,
0.031066386,
0.0410334244,
-0.0859060138,
0.0613982752,
0.0049296003,
-0.0355063491,
-0.0161063392,
0.0097928299,
-0.0329965986,
-0.0178821832,
-0.0229224302,
-0.0584065467,
0.0192527436,
0.0313107818,
0.0560136922,
0.0069070864,
-0.0273883753,
0.0114045842,
0.0790880993,
0.0162475966,
0.024085395,
-0.0186861791,
0.008024931,
-0.0245801955,
0.0407321304,
-0.0068369764,
-0.0577786267,
0.0291084219,
-0.0334202424,
-0.0352890044,
-0.0276703667,
0.0014386169,
-0.0135731967,
-0.0311290864,
0.023560321,
0.0375089496,
-0.0130584426,
0.0030762262,
-0.0036217517,
0.0410623588,
0.0259330254,
0.0451754481,
-0.0428470783,
-0.0054687862,
0.0501445532,
0.0421309844,
0.0739310756,
0.0028076663,
0.0086384201,
-0.0256732348,
0.0600224026,
0.0202076249,
-0.0227958057,
-0.0666912869,
-0.0246293563,
0.0204692986,
-0.0050877184,
-0.0195437577,
0.0485873893,
0.0072861039,
0.0199331585,
-0.0548859984,
0.0071242922,
0.0096218903,
-0.0287153497,
0.0442032516,
0.0235236026,
-0.0118511263,
0.0177703574,
-0.0334180854,
0.0152186891,
0.0117574325,
0.037899293,
-0.040532276,
0.0024184955,
0.0845966712,
-0.0240010824,
0.0432332084,
0.0393314101,
-0.0144240465,
0.0376136117,
-0.0245007351,
-0.0741119459,
0.018432308,
-0.0313298926,
0.0239090025,
-0.0056764521,
0.047063861,
-0.0312728994,
0.064943634,
-0.0062504294,
0.0274563879,
-0.0040956466,
-0.0057284893,
-0.0079231542,
0.0797446519,
-0.0078019742,
0.0490232967,
-0.0483776368,
0.0133178895,
-0.0074616801,
-0.0123042762,
0.0351200178,
-0.0265696216,
-0.0067000766,
-0.0179157481,
0.0509425886,
-0.0004846625,
-0.0112053761,
0.0055548968,
-0.0768772811,
0.017337529,
-0.0180865973,
0.0847697407,
0.008765229,
0.0222926419,
-0.0245880038,
0.0154018309,
-0.030256303,
0.0615690313,
-0.0061548636,
0.0066985073,
0.0341034345,
0.0079479441,
-0.0245957207,
-0.0214858241,
-0.0372280031,
-0.0084106755,
0.0097971596,
0.0089416578,
-0.0065571936,
0.0140414909,
0.033369828,
-0.090995118,
0.0190023407,
-0.0272987913,
-0.0191888269,
-0.0110807577,
0.0050109983,
0.0133925052,
-0.0239010099,
0.0058332593,
0.0168386959,
0.0319667533,
-0.0223647971,
0.0124181723,
-0.0146399951,
0.0044516632,
-0.0107766204,
-0.0491568893,
-0.033130724,
-0.0185422059,
0.01921295,
0.0046818131,
-0.0053537609,
0.0202910267,
-0.0051504262,
-0.0327300094,
0.0346465781,
0.0188113637,
-0.0320787691,
-0.0296449475,
0.0634536892,
-0.0003030858,
-0.0004804466,
-0.0102544129,
-0.0047254097,
0.0192248095,
-0.0032834359,
-0.0721990913,
-0.0071717598,
0.0987411961,
0.0246628132,
0.0190957896,
0.0210144483,
-0.0699380189,
-0.0803161561,
-0.0236242469,
0.0670389459,
-0.0112811504,
0.0875821188,
-0.0337375663,
-0.0164012555,
0.0048998655,
-0.0557959862,
-0.0072669028,
-0.0311173871,
0.0165815409,
0.0176948309,
0.071582675,
-0.0554488897,
0.0470110103,
-0.0090076011,
-0.0325296707,
-0.0300451461,
0.0402830206,
-0.0086733894,
-0.005833962,
0.1162635759,
0.0150274485,
0.0107413279,
-0.0293881036,
0.01512207,
-0.068382524,
0.0165770613,
0.005264319,
0.0316824801,
0.0368830673,
-0.0222474951,
0.0158063471,
-0.0349133424,
-0.0695440024,
-0.0400685854,
0.01702163,
-0.0281281695,
0.0067881378,
0.0865519643,
0.047458116,
0.00285534,
0.0339006782,
0.0193724465,
0.0579234622,
0.0387514979,
-0.0292845964,
-0.0872324631,
0.0731419548,
0.0178352017,
-0.0162712988,
0.0019009515,
-0.0344228782,
0.000929483,
-0.0885442868,
-0.0239119101,
-0.0200750101,
-0.0313085392,
-0.021561224,
-0.0237822477,
-0.0066775018,
-0.0279602762,
-0.0247093812,
0.0202531777,
-0.0334229991,
-0.0064226454,
0.016202569,
0.0100116152,
-0.0353658646,
0.0157437343,
-0.1024848446,
-0.0244479161,
-0.0135577703,
0.0619578585,
-0.056512922,
-0.0209144782,
-0.0166930631,
-0.0803176388,
-0.0360257961,
0.0022984417,
0.0131666269,
0.0004672658,
0.0290592425,
-0.0285587162,
-0.0187692717,
0.0209049098,
0.0177803878,
0.0329518989,
-0.0079101827,
0.0004197575,
-0.01916131,
-0.0121978289,
-0.0021331171,
0.0236501284,
0.0583414137,
0.0120740598,
0.0109660188,
0.0234745871,
0.0153580271,
0.0352930352,
0.0789845809,
-0.0065038274,
0.0185664725,
-0.0397886857,
-0.0730227977,
-0.0903198719,
-0.0481984802,
-0.0230617858,
0.0779724717,
0.046787668,
-0.0089518176,
-0.0151156364,
0.0039358828,
-0.0714835003,
0.0051783631,
0.0120241344,
-0.0376961157,
0.0148563022,
-0.0589841567,
0.0214881338,
0.0405673943,
-0.0174162835,
-0.0460681915,
-0.0456431285,
-0.0233044419,
-0.0247901343,
-0.0337269269,
0.0290723834,
0.0326535292,
-0.0229106303,
-0.0464537591,
0.0426919647,
0.0113974037,
-0.0137606859,
0.0195065029,
-0.0133706685,
-0.0738268718,
0.011603279,
0.0175046176,
-0.0110560032,
0.0556121618,
-0.0376210026,
0.0349256024,
-0.0509218052,
-0.0585467294,
0.0071456027,
-0.0350533687,
0.0522771329,
-0.0780891925,
-0.0088237366,
-0.0494496413,
-0.0043295547,
-0.0380149893,
-0.0089700921,
0.0389475003,
-0.0118352752,
0.0093174148,
-0.0176660586,
-0.0414029844,
-0.0650766194,
-0.0049704765,
0.0306048561,
-0.0161394831,
0.0325630717,
0.0569166988,
-0.0116290171,
0.0118303141,
0.0554843098,
0.0171398427,
-0.0054991958,
-0.0002887352,
0.0526203439,
-0.0421539657,
-0.0104873888,
0.0141341975,
-0.029332092,
-0.0228063669,
0.019036172,
0.0096534854,
0.0198225006,
-0.0139530655,
-0.0125202797,
0.0183596369,
-0.0833404735,
0.0258687157,
-0.016036544,
0.0111778602,
-0.0362809412,
0.0264681932,
0.0005391897,
-0.0147008961,
0.0187094528,
0.0175731797,
-0.009682999,
0.039184548,
0.0061743557,
0.0011592251,
-0.0051074047,
0.0321343131,
-0.0309856869,
-0.0106160259,
0.0144183282,
0.0206569713,
-0.0039451658,
-0.0153568266,
-0.0061228019,
-0.1171090454,
-0.0230352655,
0.022211276,
-0.0312452484,
0.0443993583,
0.0012084049,
0.0379156843,
0.0332693942,
0.0196572859,
0.0118138967,
-0.0450492837,
0.0309496596,
-0.0968645215,
-0.0187387485,
0.0131165078,
-5.943704616e-33,
-0.0523688421,
-0.0552244447,
-0.0239047036,
0.0070563946,
-0.0371533781,
0.0123522934,
0.0142499087,
0.0528750382,
-0.0372839309,
0.0169430058,
-0.0062727546,
0.0018555683,
0.0154532446,
-0.0071637253,
0.0436450541,
0.0211070254,
-0.0008429481,
0.0112258242,
0.0110762138,
-0.0159198642,
0.0396810696,
0.0225574449,
0.0517388508,
-0.0338906161,
0.0251467563,
-0.0530837439,
-0.0059589967,
0.0272074863,
0.0399395414,
0.0364298932,
-0.0209655482,
0.0284109153,
0.0354462005,
0.0219261777,
0.0385880843,
0.0382772125,
-0.0696552396,
-0.0649111271,
0.0575068854,
-0.009404826,
0.030844301,
-0.0087655643,
0.0401450619,
0.0351082496,
-0.00296975,
0.02124268,
0.0481569581,
0.0008428003,
-0.0232363641,
0.004337321,
-0.0353731662,
0.0274154358,
0.0190377906,
0.0170319881,
0.082233876,
-0.0058783661,
-0.0066859354,
-0.0419104472,
-0.0091293044,
0.018130606,
-0.0293152854,
0.0807380751,
-0.0056049544,
-0.0333190635,
0.0029396438,
0.0323062837,
0.0238834433,
0.0080591738,
-0.0218173843,
0.0461007394,
0.0194231588,
0.0481646024,
-0.064924255,
0.0586546995,
0.0045875185,
-0.0054730559,
-0.0391992927,
-0.012251297,
0.0294656716,
-0.0268631075,
-0.0315177478,
0.0445836298,
-0.0209720489,
-0.0233957674,
-0.0380626246,
-0.0213949792,
0.0122876605,
-0.0300797354,
-0.0356277563,
-0.0077927513,
0.0404066481,
0.0014849334,
0.0142857265,
-0.0078829639,
-0.0754346475,
0.0122592198,
-0.0097459732,
-0.010410931,
-0.0143873515,
0.0024481334,
0.0138615379,
-0.0157024935,
0.0148111163,
0.0249543674,
0.0276566241,
0.0129123237,
0.0060644392,
-0.013618934,
-0.0401146822,
-0.0414319523,
-0.0149783744,
-0.0366257951,
-0.0558533072,
0.002201854,
0.0547815226,
0.0143923433,
0.024389714,
-0.011279664,
0.0985940248,
0.0201127548,
0.0159733407,
0.0289068315,
-0.0199816655,
-0.0298251361,
-0.0306729842,
0.0041150716,
-0.0058845468,
0.0422587916,
0.0968234316,
0.0113540655,
-0.0298177879,
-0.0480859056,
2.547e-7,
0.0890924186,
0.059855599,
0.0407938138,
0.0240715295,
0.0312567502,
-0.0246183388,
0.0099440226,
0.0361396745,
-0.0431193672,
-0.0850920081,
0.0572710261,
-0.0380100422,
0.026232332,
0.0731626451,
-0.0625536591,
0.0134077948,
-0.0220486522,
-0.0242954586,
-0.0348107666,
0.0652383715,
0.0108674616,
0.0954123288,
0.0435854271,
0.0150110954,
-0.0248248279,
-0.0108759366,
0.0019546486,
-0.0330560766,
-0.0098755751,
-0.0227029361,
-0.0288423058,
-0.013924499,
-0.005729571,
0.0108909346,
0.0135219274,
0.010750737,
-0.0127341561,
-0.0153820151,
-0.0250496175,
0.0574740916,
0.03808254,
-0.0343440659,
-0.017964758,
-0.0269247852,
0.0141370194,
0.0497679301,
-0.004240023,
-0.0154699069,
-0.0040361322,
0.0506066233,
0.0373368375,
0.0124196419,
0.0072151497,
0.0315723345,
-0.0136017613,
0.011989546,
-0.0213228911,
-0.0508418456,
0.0128808543,
0.1233279109,
0.010679286,
-0.0521337427,
0.07755889,
-0.0169229303,
-0.0110510839,
0.0296236407,
0.0039786822,
1.820964268e-34,
-0.0076041608,
-0.0031239025,
-0.0540164486,
0.0009416154,
0.0523776487,
-0.0424095728,
-0.0353469886,
-0.0012806535,
0.0112648131,
0.0048512248,
0.0079116542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19712v1 | Uncertainty Quantification in Large Language Models Through Convex Hull Analysis | 2024-06-28T07:47:34 | 2024-06-28T07:47:34 | Ferhat Ozgur Catak, Murat Kuzlu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Uncertainty quantification approaches have been more critical in large
language models (LLMs), particularly high-risk applications requiring reliable
outputs. However, traditional methods for uncertainty quantification, such as
probabilistic models and ensemble techniques, face challenges when applied to
the complex and high-dimensional nature of LLM-generated outputs. This study
proposes a novel geometric approach to uncertainty quantification using convex
hull analysis. The proposed method leverages the spatial properties of response
embeddings to measure the dispersion and variability of model outputs. The
prompts are categorized into three types, i.e., `easy', `moderate', and
`confusing', to generate multiple responses using different LLMs at varying
temperature settings. The responses are transformed into high-dimensional
embeddings via a BERT model and subsequently projected into a two-dimensional
space using Principal Component Analysis (PCA). The Density-Based Spatial
Clustering of Applications with Noise (DBSCAN) algorithm is utilized to cluster
the embeddings and compute the convex hull for each selected cluster. The
experimental results indicate that the uncertainty of the model for LLMs
depends on the prompt complexity, the model, and the temperature setting. | [
-0.0136017893,
0.0397344716,
-0.040005371,
0.0541717745,
-0.01518186,
0.0101111457,
-0.03042439,
-0.0211390555,
0.0030657111,
-0.0356388092,
0.0004484801,
-0.0650206432,
0.0528625771,
0.0147486208,
0.0445343964,
-0.0761817619,
0.0083672199,
-0.081031695,
0.0351141021,
-0.0264464375,
-0.0133696394,
-0.017578125,
-0.0136472834,
0.0502040423,
-0.0170518514,
-0.0017560348,
-0.0181700736,
0.0058416794,
0.0016140207,
-0.0465068147,
-0.0142842336,
0.0761039704,
0.0532296635,
0.0129249189,
0.0000019424,
-0.0231277794,
-0.0025466548,
0.0244211778,
-0.021018384,
0.0489050746,
0.0406888649,
0.0532227755,
-0.0160119813,
0.000021408,
0.0172902532,
-0.0139076179,
0.0794671774,
-0.0024745017,
0.008806047,
0.0077311466,
-0.015586704,
-0.0251452215,
0.0340362266,
0.0250827987,
-0.0400463268,
-0.0030167804,
0.0182376262,
-0.0173698496,
0.0162486974,
0.0364523083,
-0.0225387141,
0.0170047786,
-0.0167821497,
0.0126178917,
-0.0029042549,
0.0368669406,
0.0015339659,
0.0040356806,
-0.0399566367,
0.0459134318,
-0.0038710299,
0.0090217534,
-0.005496216,
-0.0201817919,
0.0101853348,
0.0240256041,
-0.0539732128,
-0.009529083,
0.0180516932,
0.0056536272,
-0.0536524132,
0.0028110815,
-0.0029343271,
-0.0682069361,
-0.0466423035,
0.0670362636,
0.0404703096,
-0.0380538851,
-0.0486017279,
-0.0302599259,
-0.0234041903,
-0.0107307602,
-0.01273851,
0.0094808154,
-0.0210823547,
0.0353637598,
-0.0021341564,
-0.00172945,
0.0165925864,
-0.0648281872,
0.0612805672,
-0.0029868451,
0.0170102529,
-0.0171964224,
-0.0173491482,
0.065118514,
0.0103823133,
0.0026814309,
-0.0445431545,
0.0266962778,
-0.0187433753,
-0.0180814639,
-0.010724714,
0.0360442996,
-0.0023427999,
-0.0009497302,
-0.072909452,
0.0374136716,
-0.0157263428,
0.027867917,
-0.0060308687,
0.0077962237,
0.0458492525,
0.0135880318,
-0.0023614538,
-0.0106201209,
-0.022411814,
0.0025264178,
-0.0415809453,
-0.0372867361,
0.0243666936,
0.0334240012,
-0.0043540667,
-0.0088159852,
-0.0279666558,
0.0374305137,
-0.0081417412,
-0.0243911874,
-0.0128343916,
0.0066770311,
-0.0842733532,
-0.0292860661,
-0.0138163045,
-0.0743120536,
-0.0126804113,
-0.0016652477,
-0.0200533643,
0.0079681044,
0.0030445417,
-0.027970653,
-0.047610309,
0.0745070428,
0.0335790142,
0.0483312085,
0.0670104101,
-0.0260607582,
0.0134784253,
0.0476474799,
0.0741731003,
0.0192019809,
0.0440451205,
-0.0369144566,
0.0343459845,
0.0255101901,
-0.0041534584,
0.0106135635,
-0.0656564906,
-0.0125422552,
-0.0005881062,
0.0067830924,
-0.0160696469,
0.0825072825,
-0.0197637342,
-0.0079826247,
0.0541706719,
0.0771810859,
-0.0242755692,
-0.0512232669,
0.0004898499,
0.0243258551,
0.0000901309,
-0.0017988809,
-0.0143008213,
-0.0241461694,
-0.0619810149,
0.0158827361,
0.0571960621,
0.0148068639,
-0.0149715357,
-0.0415295139,
-0.0407275744,
-0.0210528262,
-0.0175063852,
0.0031017922,
0.0725720674,
-0.071475029,
-0.035433352,
0.0184849501,
-0.0098652393,
-0.0488284864,
-0.0164633822,
-0.057551384,
0.0504468158,
0.0327092744,
0.0053298818,
-0.0515023135,
-0.0171412788,
0.015084059,
-0.0305476598,
-0.0034164381,
0.0262818113,
-0.0095940195,
-0.0039760428,
-0.0293309614,
-0.0399185903,
0.0527304262,
0.0260349102,
0.0157801677,
0.0101443874,
-0.0203700811,
-0.0165326241,
-0.0446849056,
-0.0043271431,
0.0178419799,
0.044410497,
-0.0084606474,
-0.0068122819,
0.0169222075,
0.0626554489,
0.0275562759,
-0.0227852892,
0.0303657204,
0.0637212172,
-0.0268517137,
-0.0155288074,
-0.0038733457,
0.0147397527,
0.0182983745,
0.0335241072,
0.0094737299,
-0.030348571,
-0.0135957031,
-0.0045881709,
-0.0525666624,
0.0340277217,
-0.0384502076,
0.0012329518,
-0.0191192161,
0.0456583835,
-0.0433584675,
0.020506369,
-0.0808336437,
0.0324154533,
-0.0440997928,
0.0589831173,
0.0099007254,
0.0340226069,
0.022989098,
-0.0216638446,
-0.046840135,
-0.0027696094,
-0.0239712782,
0.0131105585,
0.0346787348,
-0.0174086764,
0.0386280231,
-0.056961637,
-0.0641981885,
-0.025991844,
0.0188419912,
0.0107430536,
-0.0011419047,
-0.0410872139,
-0.017747391,
0.0164690539,
-0.0052433107,
-0.0014581165,
0.0088852514,
0.0268881898,
0.0388655514,
-0.0327674821,
-0.084460862,
-0.0313052088,
-0.0331201777,
-0.0144131873,
0.0505089536,
-0.0030522416,
-0.0170521196,
-0.0716815144,
0.0411096364,
-0.0059793903,
0.0068222648,
0.0085366461,
-0.034967009,
0.0307878684,
-0.0407320559,
0.0673768446,
0.0182765219,
0.0055704173,
0.0188612882,
0.0453399532,
-0.0418893918,
-0.0287184138,
0.0054037385,
-0.0621651672,
-0.0181651209,
-0.0060947742,
-0.0826018751,
0.0234561898,
0.0113513088,
0.0489046462,
-0.0163867064,
-0.0682903901,
0.0022474809,
-0.039850086,
-0.0299312901,
-0.0691301525,
-0.0103200413,
-0.032323923,
0.0701133907,
-0.0061898665,
-0.0733434856,
0.049050536,
-0.0687540695,
0.0412315689,
-0.0177467261,
-0.0033830358,
0.0240950678,
0.0090768123,
-0.0060545155,
0.0220678393,
-0.0381356925,
-0.0224982053,
-0.0365700126,
-0.027416436,
0.0298169665,
-0.0487876907,
0.0306496415,
-0.0512118936,
-0.0058498951,
0.0105718588,
0.0134425927,
-0.0199728701,
-0.0170452762,
0.0148053085,
0.0013760983,
0.0716298446,
-0.055003304,
0.0269283317,
0.0782824904,
0.0138980104,
-0.0229599476,
-0.0298807211,
-0.004697978,
-0.0269676577,
0.0448090695,
0.0223915521,
0.0717498064,
0.0526672006,
-0.0422291122,
-0.0391268358,
0.0004227193,
0.0036526134,
0.0375071578,
-0.0350434482,
-0.0177384466,
0.0571943112,
0.0212088171,
-0.0404241942,
0.072402142,
0.075923264,
0.0120000802,
-0.0094264559,
0.1050739735,
0.0422431342,
0.0146858823,
-0.003035885,
-0.0226081666,
0.0878906399,
0.038256593,
0.013983937,
0.0082959589,
0.031773977,
-0.0013909612,
0.0187897515,
0.0033504514,
0.0022755859,
0.0245092306,
-0.1083466485,
0.077642858,
-0.0062510376,
-0.0708442256,
-0.0766590312,
-0.0756827295,
0.0098332362,
0.0292132869,
0.0170479976,
-0.012333435,
0.0248922482,
-0.0185771808,
0.0426119119,
-0.0979641229,
-0.065955773,
-0.0035750652,
-0.0270844102,
0.1168489084,
0.0148485433,
0.0068346178,
-0.0501134992,
-0.0266516749,
-0.0214320477,
-0.0115062166,
-0.0141417189,
0.0093105091,
0.0087911924,
0.0911754221,
0.0150083145,
-0.0155487154,
-0.0100757983,
-0.0262468457,
0.0001774769,
-0.0038575791,
0.0991208404,
-0.0159330666,
-0.0023803096,
-0.0274146572,
-0.0085505676,
0.0242262408,
0.049602665,
0.0109524783,
-0.0221452489,
-0.0442438014,
-0.0279235039,
0.0157947224,
0.015941564,
0.0281385798,
0.0171210915,
-0.0182579327,
-0.0287717283,
-0.0690225661,
0.0567918643,
0.0211221166,
0.0234034769,
0.0071451613,
-0.0090754256,
0.0425333269,
-0.0161631834,
-0.0325110517,
-0.0168949924,
-0.0053572226,
0.0614827313,
-0.0398781188,
0.0640419796,
0.0199128836,
0.0003797877,
-0.0304956585,
0.0221061464,
-0.0300041251,
-0.098331593,
0.0161798801,
0.0551233962,
0.0171147194,
-0.0151163023,
-0.0214060172,
-0.0858346075,
0.0889126807,
0.008875506,
0.0181902293,
0.0264927913,
0.018768739,
0.0496700406,
-0.030716572,
-0.0078119426,
-0.0217629969,
0.0219002515,
-0.0235679131,
-0.0038748852,
-0.0435172319,
-0.1081747785,
-0.035466563,
0.0418855362,
0.0599626005,
-0.0015318078,
-0.0449759252,
-0.0539948046,
0.0098164054,
-0.0255870093,
0.0118130241,
-0.0035847086,
-0.008054385,
0.0217800606,
-0.0479518175,
-0.0312149264,
-0.0333397314,
-0.0055975178,
0.0322466791,
-0.0113881072,
-0.0110312905,
0.0293770302,
0.0139683615,
0.0256101917,
0.0189899728,
0.0157041475,
0.045165468,
-0.027561428,
-0.0085174562,
0.0339141823,
0.0156605318,
-0.0002524166,
-0.0087591093,
-0.0296592917,
0.0252915863,
-0.0448525213,
-0.0476092473,
-0.0305500068,
0.0426184349,
0.0278990809,
0.0541364439,
0.0337178297,
-0.01474657,
-0.0088350093,
-0.0460660197,
0.0337721966,
0.0308067147,
0.0248800348,
0.1005249545,
0.0262048077,
-0.0388884991,
-0.0071390392,
0.0489253923,
-0.0179863311,
0.0132189263,
-0.0436025113,
-0.0519118682,
-0.0480433665,
-0.009877013,
0.0442184955,
0.0646948144,
-0.0517739542,
0.0221876726,
-0.0484354608,
-0.057645537,
0.0161575153,
0.0421906747,
0.0059242845,
-0.0246237312,
0.013457384,
0.05656844,
0.0033039425,
0.0252842717,
-0.0257907305,
-0.0168285444,
0.0097698225,
-0.0103573259,
-0.0119787762,
-6.636473028e-33,
-0.0237152614,
-0.0439650305,
-0.0449888147,
-0.0147335902,
-0.0206758808,
-0.0205863938,
0.02072585,
0.049951043,
0.0073028863,
0.0062015997,
0.005910967,
-0.0172446743,
0.0150661627,
-0.0017521249,
0.0284402966,
0.0069857077,
0.0224762652,
-0.015116306,
-0.0024672302,
0.0220883843,
0.0581010021,
-0.007821572,
0.0101058772,
-0.0821314082,
0.0382236391,
-0.0055186441,
-0.0047501894,
0.0427762792,
-0.0015442111,
0.047817383,
-0.0372569598,
0.065971829,
-0.0104047051,
0.0131605249,
-0.0302179139,
-0.0002829057,
0.0062106918,
-0.0430429056,
0.0157113019,
0.0196979474,
0.0008536528,
-0.0176955257,
0.0387579389,
0.0120608332,
-0.0495115891,
0.0280474704,
0.0534440875,
-0.0134366136,
-0.036116343,
-0.0129653355,
-0.0234010387,
0.0211901385,
-0.0121766888,
-0.0177996196,
0.0152834831,
0.018289879,
-0.0081765307,
0.0130543504,
-0.0222515594,
0.0427251384,
0.0437853895,
0.0315433554,
0.0572721325,
0.0603707805,
0.011572862,
0.0342163481,
0.0154743586,
-0.0212494116,
-0.0224113259,
-0.0559284128,
0.0627286881,
0.0221316926,
0.0501081273,
0.0525460914,
-0.0140985306,
0.0048515731,
-0.0441300645,
0.0315216519,
-0.0006353364,
-0.0151486201,
0.0680064335,
0.0306555927,
-0.05540644,
-0.0633695275,
-0.0570060499,
-0.0053871311,
-0.0271109901,
0.0361154824,
0.023373697,
-0.0361820832,
-0.0292321555,
-0.0424837396,
0.0333682708,
-0.0368338153,
-0.0328492895,
-0.0448712967,
0.0052667041,
0.0424420014,
0.0240288414,
0.0529968441,
-0.015225607,
-0.0258263964,
0.0076457607,
-0.0109681822,
-0.006714059,
0.0042731878,
-0.0341316201,
0.0235471204,
-0.0461918786,
0.0106176846,
0.0242502876,
-0.0371480435,
-0.007398413,
0.0207088962,
0.027017206,
-0.0431836173,
0.0048127985,
0.0375357419,
0.0070650768,
0.0386019573,
0.0115737859,
-0.0003334982,
-0.0332709141,
0.0005793806,
-0.0058747404,
0.0127587328,
-0.0180691034,
-0.0004994294,
0.0503423773,
-0.0518435612,
-0.0336772166,
-0.007923496,
2.735e-7,
0.0562238097,
0.0844098106,
0.018402515,
0.0388794467,
0.0155161442,
0.0270382576,
-0.0159147847,
-0.0087950043,
-0.0010318354,
-0.048228547,
0.0041289162,
-0.0036844171,
0.0254205111,
0.0366398282,
-0.0233312026,
-0.0166914761,
-0.0356864743,
0.0565449968,
-0.0260992236,
0.0314161927,
0.1238873377,
0.0709123313,
-0.0152291106,
0.0168073811,
-0.0311731063,
0.0200927109,
0.0184536409,
-0.0597854219,
0.0063110655,
0.0375245214,
0.0507474616,
-0.0326559432,
0.0332378596,
0.0543372147,
0.0064970604,
-0.0107323378,
0.0020453092,
0.0342679061,
0.0090620779,
0.0008768739,
0.0300610065,
-0.0164778065,
-0.0208482072,
-0.0816840902,
0.0220403299,
-0.0801454559,
-0.0228454117,
-0.0483657271,
0.0083860829,
-0.0142332055,
0.0605653673,
-0.028637331,
-0.0067286398,
-0.0034951116,
-0.0072415303,
0.0025270772,
0.0576640256,
-0.0415067412,
-0.0000494729,
0.0017504806,
-0.0696350932,
-0.0460092798,
0.0053406958,
-0.0161005408,
0.02123156,
-0.0353290923,
0.0270775184,
2.886134342e-34,
0.04454799,
0.0066411048,
-0.0084246108,
0.0101596909,
0.0164146256,
-0.0295867771,
0.0117001515,
0.0109080113,
0.0216716211,
-0.0889983252,
0.0015633319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19674v1 | Less is More: Accurate Speech Recognition & Translation without Web-Scale Data | 2024-06-28T06:22:23 | 2024-06-28T06:22:23 | Krishna C. Puvvada, Piotr Żelasko, He Huang, Oleksii Hrinchuk, Nithin Rao Koluguri, Kunal Dhawan, Somshubra Majumdar, Elena Rastorgueva, Zhehuai Chen, Vitaly Lavrukhin, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent advances in speech recognition and translation rely on hundreds of
thousands of hours of Internet speech data. We argue that state-of-the art
accuracy can be reached without relying on web-scale data. Canary -
multilingual ASR and speech translation model, outperforms current
state-of-the-art models - Whisper, OWSM, and Seamless-M4T on English, French,
Spanish, and German languages, while being trained on an order of magnitude
less data than these models. Three key factors enables such data-efficient
model: (1) a FastConformer-based attention encoder-decoder architecture (2)
training on synthetic data generated with machine translation and (3) advanced
training techniques: data-balancing, dynamic data blending, dynamic bucketing
and noise-robust fine-tuning. The model, weights, and training code will be
open-sourced. | [
-0.0258230586,
0.066996634,
0.0121014202,
0.0409380309,
0.0028280104,
-0.0113382079,
0.035301432,
-0.0466548838,
-0.0270942468,
-0.0316977948,
-0.0654155165,
-0.0565935895,
0.0638683364,
0.0357066728,
0.0430969931,
-0.0213003159,
0.0130136488,
-0.0397357419,
-0.0168790016,
-0.0069026262,
0.0026269148,
-0.0062765982,
-0.0175216086,
0.0423310101,
0.0223140623,
0.0093744844,
-0.02217892,
0.0497549847,
0.0132309934,
-0.0139245288,
0.0200505983,
-0.0035163006,
0.0348440595,
0.056005165,
0.0000018475,
-0.0034685484,
-0.0116167935,
-0.010558214,
-0.0379716083,
-0.0275921226,
0.0100315753,
-0.0286433641,
-0.0291576702,
0.0806424618,
0.0064067589,
-0.0125705153,
0.0286503732,
0.0105130086,
0.0318429507,
0.0921417773,
-0.0073530087,
-0.0362936147,
0.0498210117,
-0.0155765926,
-0.0116197579,
-0.0327743553,
-0.0232263505,
-0.0345975645,
-0.0597291142,
-0.0336014591,
-0.0284277052,
0.0466709733,
0.0133555299,
0.0094660074,
0.0211873837,
-0.0061433194,
-0.0585524924,
-0.051928889,
-0.030898843,
0.0730915964,
-0.0528661087,
-0.0223600343,
0.0052876552,
0.0147289718,
-0.0266734865,
-0.0486764535,
-0.0374880917,
0.0357858576,
0.0089540379,
0.0062608374,
-0.0067643342,
0.0385941342,
0.0178384166,
-0.02249486,
-0.0376438349,
0.0094066057,
-0.0059436229,
-0.0431064591,
0.0060132071,
-0.0196084287,
0.0120351585,
-0.0179838408,
0.0604691021,
0.0296235774,
0.0044022859,
-0.0013983226,
-0.0489010811,
-0.0551346689,
-0.0091436477,
-0.061885681,
0.0224610921,
0.0701718032,
-0.0412931852,
0.0283795875,
-0.0095648505,
0.0643828064,
0.0109990789,
-0.0042119473,
-0.0342741571,
-0.0148008186,
-0.0000542071,
0.0482835099,
-0.0443136431,
0.0056689237,
-0.0444300324,
-0.0342051052,
-0.0320042819,
0.0129187685,
-0.003736503,
0.0290136263,
0.0494024158,
-0.0095235547,
-0.0812294632,
-0.010590232,
0.0287978817,
0.0555103868,
0.0288632419,
0.0270368326,
0.0234473087,
-0.1071925312,
-0.0208552778,
0.0103469472,
0.0462020263,
-0.0136592863,
-0.0017768709,
0.0837113336,
0.0010545048,
-0.0314383954,
-0.0232015494,
0.0031333952,
-0.0129761873,
-0.0482372902,
-0.0250703506,
-0.0515135378,
0.078944318,
-0.0049596811,
0.0313243419,
-0.0227818172,
0.0126995901,
-0.0079002446,
-0.0008738876,
0.0486139134,
-0.0165025834,
0.0135389492,
0.0016763526,
-0.0399962552,
-0.0163488444,
0.0591240525,
0.0600195713,
0.0144149633,
0.0065680048,
-0.0174410101,
-0.016847631,
0.0428825654,
0.0105009386,
0.0199489277,
-0.0192906894,
0.0006579568,
0.0335417911,
0.0263198819,
0.0471820273,
0.0654009134,
-0.016590843,
0.0187470727,
0.0979139879,
-0.0062692519,
0.0134650012,
0.0503562875,
0.0245295465,
0.0234503988,
-0.0055807112,
-0.0335883424,
-0.0352533609,
0.0191955436,
-0.0006590933,
0.0217367262,
0.0767994523,
0.0516642705,
-0.0396007188,
-0.0153815085,
0.0012277642,
-0.0433038026,
-0.0197251569,
0.0500914305,
0.0290277582,
-0.002917368,
-0.0537496172,
0.0455972366,
0.0098384768,
-0.0646691844,
0.0558294356,
0.0106213167,
-0.039006453,
0.0703529865,
0.0277644489,
0.0005191742,
-0.0450088717,
-0.0533527844,
0.0231047831,
0.0385614857,
0.0024621482,
0.0207157787,
0.0528412908,
-0.0826479271,
-0.0211330056,
0.0381597392,
-0.0284422338,
0.0312434267,
-0.0115937665,
0.0374780782,
0.0256695207,
-0.0201860163,
-0.0413232744,
-0.008441641,
0.0022973954,
-0.0143885082,
0.0277605597,
0.011513425,
0.0572541468,
0.0335446112,
-0.0165808275,
-0.0151095586,
0.0335784964,
-0.0448397398,
0.0069756005,
0.0345534086,
-0.0491722599,
-0.0356461555,
0.052320011,
-0.0209441036,
0.0462949686,
0.0500107482,
-0.0147309816,
-0.0828337446,
0.0096469047,
-0.0433337912,
0.0696635693,
-0.0255570021,
0.0704185516,
0.036447417,
0.0439844243,
0.0309901852,
-0.0110759418,
-0.0082381628,
0.0132795516,
-0.0308657046,
0.0022380808,
-0.0088368291,
-0.0719364658,
-0.0371586345,
0.0121918991,
-0.0314737298,
0.0364943445,
0.015424748,
-0.0086851893,
-0.021909859,
-0.0062062819,
-0.0697006807,
0.0104670823,
-0.0204769131,
0.0304197837,
0.0202589929,
0.0602735206,
0.0208621491,
-0.0367130302,
-0.03923475,
-0.019550113,
-0.017100675,
0.0057656146,
-0.0239879917,
-0.0361181237,
-0.0249008182,
-0.0110248039,
-0.0003081006,
0.019196054,
0.0072851302,
-0.0361744575,
-0.0289997775,
-0.0469886661,
0.011460118,
-0.0088668438,
0.0483052284,
-0.0063842465,
-0.0766622797,
-0.0169737563,
0.0043952004,
0.0202576462,
0.0526810996,
0.0224147439,
-0.0408559851,
0.0121536516,
-0.0083896322,
-0.0620840155,
-0.0009277262,
0.017801078,
-0.005195207,
-0.0266740695,
0.0074030454,
-0.015078336,
0.0509901904,
0.0109676765,
0.0417248756,
-0.0507410765,
-0.0455946438,
0.0127378684,
0.0102765122,
-0.0235151127,
0.0218687691,
-0.0316416956,
0.0003813939,
-0.032154303,
-0.0287204552,
0.0299171451,
-0.0706300437,
-0.0415536687,
-0.0204263162,
-0.0255373996,
-0.0090396861,
-0.0355032906,
-0.0260640718,
0.0400845632,
-0.0195854791,
-0.0441395417,
-0.0118700974,
0.0019192901,
0.0141596459,
-0.0556259677,
0.0521617271,
0.0068933787,
0.0087055378,
-0.0297750887,
-0.0379233845,
-0.0606632791,
0.0230047852,
-0.0303854886,
0.0112842312,
0.0086822677,
-0.0460357741,
-0.0529458709,
0.0190385878,
0.0334902629,
0.1032811329,
-0.0018393995,
-0.0004698803,
-0.0235652402,
0.0437734835,
0.0233861171,
0.0208966304,
0.0179597195,
-0.0226802435,
0.0324454531,
0.0240029823,
0.0807930976,
-0.0002427336,
-0.0477779806,
-0.0228233859,
0.0450563394,
0.006326755,
0.0391430594,
0.0359442532,
0.051005356,
-0.0489748791,
0.0150231328,
0.1161467135,
-0.022701703,
-0.0477427579,
-0.0150789889,
0.0212575849,
0.0036204252,
0.0203636996,
-0.0032460084,
-0.0584140904,
-0.0320095345,
0.0494142808,
0.0561446324,
0.0219688583,
0.0259778835,
-0.0191763919,
-0.0832945034,
0.012260613,
0.0414999127,
-0.0279474612,
-0.0463992171,
-0.0433400013,
-0.0238746218,
-0.0472683422,
0.0550341867,
0.0156225134,
0.0122461841,
-0.0273371954,
0.0227810815,
-0.0321444571,
-0.0922086015,
0.0008743592,
-0.0523492619,
0.0615330897,
0.0333113745,
0.0340794623,
0.0068259975,
-0.0538006835,
0.0470854342,
-0.0001593765,
-0.004180369,
-0.0019519229,
0.0341846272,
-0.0238172077,
-0.0098140892,
0.0265581999,
0.012013996,
-0.0588271543,
0.0250152014,
0.0266931895,
0.0737781376,
-0.0235312935,
0.0357396007,
0.0380104892,
-0.0352235362,
0.0195602849,
0.0528104529,
0.0212502591,
-0.0243893862,
0.0036898395,
-0.0030255851,
0.0167166442,
-0.0452239923,
0.0031945596,
0.0224343408,
0.0008671031,
-0.0820042342,
-0.0629707426,
-0.0352124013,
0.0173432343,
0.0333873406,
0.0378885418,
-0.0081886258,
0.0342544988,
0.0040240316,
-0.0509778261,
0.0205594823,
-0.0453028008,
0.0303541943,
-0.0645184442,
-0.0101962145,
0.0227734689,
-0.0612152927,
0.016930135,
0.0197044685,
-0.0962467194,
-0.0749263689,
-0.0086502247,
0.0255504996,
0.016167324,
0.0655937865,
-0.0688308403,
-0.01936079,
0.0573244616,
0.0073595666,
-0.0815041065,
-0.0179528631,
0.0774304345,
0.0009561194,
0.0041614547,
0.0297691002,
-0.0494485833,
0.0106624663,
0.0112624755,
0.030901337,
-0.0286062397,
-0.0159280356,
0.0143592926,
0.0280518271,
0.0585440695,
-0.0243534744,
-0.012833911,
-0.0169875119,
0.0606526881,
0.0311664119,
0.0293653607,
-0.0422607437,
-0.0252141841,
0.0264990944,
0.0259267502,
0.0111276638,
0.0502889231,
-0.0137576349,
-0.0993468538,
-0.0231714193,
0.027954394,
-0.0399456769,
0.0065357615,
0.0322023407,
0.0050918525,
-0.0207410157,
0.0354752578,
0.0361592025,
0.0261105467,
-0.0146510787,
-0.0139037231,
0.0029802993,
0.0266877916,
0.0115712164,
0.0274183266,
-0.0412454009,
-0.0381180458,
-0.0550300255,
0.0019640622,
0.0608835705,
-0.0013568845,
0.0764694735,
0.041210413,
0.0168637894,
-0.0434642024,
0.0391603634,
-0.0301780477,
-0.0201459527,
0.0050663818,
-0.0066177351,
-0.0041882857,
0.0344868302,
0.0622719191,
-0.0173108112,
0.0182860456,
-0.0109437471,
0.0311718863,
-0.0284135342,
-0.0177354105,
-0.0279258993,
-0.001424137,
-0.0308143906,
-0.0440797172,
0.026082132,
-0.0722778738,
0.0193859469,
-0.0124909915,
0.0156997722,
-0.0398152433,
0.0183466226,
0.0069213198,
-0.0262652412,
0.0022084094,
-0.014035291,
-0.0303351488,
0.0075357137,
-0.0209897291,
0.0041055386,
-6.178490143e-33,
0.0078209089,
0.0298718177,
-0.002931898,
-0.0162184536,
-0.0453414246,
0.0161602963,
-0.0412089191,
-0.0295409039,
-0.0268168394,
-0.0505310334,
-0.021934025,
0.0234064627,
0.0392025895,
0.043139834,
-0.012605737,
0.0058019189,
0.0887961388,
-0.0127615761,
-0.0352269262,
0.0245711971,
0.025198957,
0.0364558734,
0.0588575378,
-0.0314979777,
-0.0502335057,
0.0038866391,
-0.0143210143,
-0.009517421,
0.04167182,
0.0232342128,
0.004727494,
0.047824841,
-0.0069289738,
-0.0010043747,
-0.0304644499,
-0.0030617991,
-0.0850183368,
0.0182273611,
-0.0231679659,
0.0653513819,
0.0118873278,
-0.0285724141,
0.0658182055,
-0.0068263868,
-0.0107742734,
-0.0262362882,
0.0200077463,
-0.0566734821,
-0.0401023515,
-0.0661701113,
-0.0209315754,
0.0169831403,
-0.0178485401,
-0.0246554427,
0.0486018844,
0.0735762268,
-0.0198615473,
-0.0183078405,
-0.1027349532,
0.0468906797,
-0.0006235793,
0.0438261405,
0.0533402376,
0.047461316,
0.0058651185,
0.0225263406,
0.0443301238,
-0.0170842931,
0.0310235042,
0.0141157731,
0.0637138337,
0.0050934469,
0.0222931989,
0.0064704251,
0.0384433493,
-0.025017852,
-0.0250642654,
0.0060116244,
0.0215957873,
0.0090991948,
0.0416103154,
0.0081759281,
-0.0478570648,
0.0121969385,
-0.0240759514,
-0.0476538651,
-0.0428522378,
-0.0034807471,
0.0391620137,
0.0449345857,
-0.0014475206,
-0.0009302092,
0.0793155879,
-0.0285620801,
0.0381566323,
0.0051905825,
0.0307123959,
0.0043594823,
-0.0091902614,
0.0274399035,
-0.0391036421,
-0.0551473796,
0.0069912635,
0.0464595966,
-0.0032813393,
-0.0147732114,
0.0328897499,
0.063102223,
-0.0485980473,
0.0000083505,
-0.0366746522,
0.041174043,
-0.0014933284,
-0.0024449513,
0.0519380905,
-0.0294394884,
-0.0082504107,
0.060739208,
-0.0332024284,
0.0138467969,
-0.0224947948,
-0.0036915042,
0.0250303689,
0.0423335247,
-0.0672385618,
-0.0051632174,
-0.0357098356,
0.0067183925,
0.0286435876,
-0.0383887142,
-0.0359002948,
0.0021084785,
2.683e-7,
-0.0543813221,
0.0032340579,
0.0189757347,
0.0016323543,
0.0076147025,
-0.000293639,
-0.0098701157,
0.0119902147,
-0.0050025359,
0.0111178253,
-0.001810357,
0.024216095,
0.1107495055,
0.0277240202,
-0.0913594812,
-0.067402333,
-0.0542473346,
0.034924794,
-0.0220602993,
-0.0016319397,
-0.0109179821,
0.1125258952,
-0.0045763394,
-0.0153215686,
0.0208076816,
0.0129718883,
0.0320664011,
0.0258022416,
-0.007641491,
-0.0176565479,
-0.0047958787,
0.0150096035,
-0.0534655601,
0.001181994,
-0.0508271828,
0.0086490335,
-0.0223490521,
0.0438508727,
-0.01840044,
-0.0296044592,
-0.0001198489,
-0.0134935277,
-0.0246269479,
-0.0325391442,
0.044618953,
-0.0099282097,
-0.0004127701,
0.0106575768,
-0.0492034927,
0.0022689488,
-0.0129683465,
-0.0445944443,
-0.006155917,
-0.0021658032,
0.0324990898,
-0.0273002125,
-0.0088955862,
-0.0447553322,
-0.0052998783,
0.0112366648,
-0.0194316208,
-0.0351461843,
-0.0292910263,
-0.04078326,
0.0255606212,
0.0055853138,
0.0153164389,
2.102500216e-34,
0.0415708385,
-0.0181570761,
0.0527701415,
-0.0181669686,
0.025961969,
-0.049722638,
0.0354550481,
-0.00631426,
0.0142341163,
-0.0467380695,
-0.0472107753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19650v1 | DECOR: Improving Coherence in L2 English Writing with a Novel Benchmark for Incoherence Detection, Reasoning, and Rewriting | 2024-06-28T04:38:54 | 2024-06-28T04:38:54 | Xuanming Zhang, Anthony Diaz, Zixun Chen, Qingyang Wu, Kun Qian, Erik Voss, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coherence in writing, an aspect that second-language (L2) English learners
often struggle with, is crucial in assessing L2 English writing. Existing
automated writing evaluation systems primarily use basic surface linguistic
features to detect coherence in writing. However, little effort has been made
to correct the detected incoherence, which could significantly benefit L2
language learners seeking to improve their writing. To bridge this gap, we
introduce DECOR, a novel benchmark that includes expert annotations for
detecting incoherence in L2 English writing, identifying the underlying
reasons, and rewriting the incoherent sentences. To our knowledge, DECOR is the
first coherence assessment dataset specifically designed for improving L2
English writing, featuring pairs of original incoherent sentences alongside
their expert-rewritten counterparts. Additionally, we fine-tuned models to
automatically detect and rewrite incoherence in student essays. We find that
incorporating specific reasons for incoherence during fine-tuning consistently
improves the quality of the rewrites, achieving a result that is favored in
both automatic and human evaluations. | [
-0.0079149548,
0.0602520481,
-0.0109182354,
0.0131352004,
-0.0690482035,
-0.0156628378,
0.0146603873,
-0.0415735692,
0.0015301708,
-0.0792206675,
-0.0025181482,
-0.0146613829,
0.0415131263,
0.0160821117,
0.0024301105,
-0.0545564219,
0.0447260141,
-0.0111175524,
0.0443076901,
0.0157218371,
0.0381567813,
0.0147483349,
-0.0153877251,
0.0405702442,
-0.0092792232,
-0.0774091333,
0.0015536026,
0.0414700359,
-0.0027862301,
0.0084954333,
0.0450606942,
0.0790480748,
-0.0339549035,
0.0153761283,
0.0000019464,
-0.0381076634,
-0.0342438668,
-0.0315803289,
0.0081315199,
0.0419160984,
0.0337414034,
0.0152419657,
-0.0278139263,
0.0175907463,
-0.0192876756,
0.0431910418,
0.026153611,
0.0459271446,
0.0485750958,
0.0718541592,
-0.0134861926,
-0.0130686332,
0.0380636789,
0.0216856133,
-0.012728448,
0.0312628746,
-0.0110080233,
-0.002459819,
-0.0160015989,
-0.0422444008,
-0.0174651481,
0.0304524675,
0.0065738261,
-0.0747965351,
0.0189989414,
-0.0226113573,
-0.0432334878,
0.0023268852,
0.014911864,
0.0195912533,
-0.0172131266,
-0.0243562255,
0.0069721206,
-0.0222734138,
0.0014131501,
0.0109708579,
-0.00277684,
0.0091262637,
-0.0428915136,
0.0122219138,
0.0632286668,
-0.0427968912,
-0.0192311071,
0.0226510447,
0.0310431812,
0.068546623,
0.0098242788,
-0.021396013,
-0.0123084541,
0.046771124,
-0.0254488196,
-0.0353524908,
0.03369762,
0.0079042837,
-0.0482323356,
-0.0117379194,
-0.0441831276,
-0.0692159832,
-0.0009884809,
-0.0173737016,
0.0590390079,
0.0054928632,
-0.0297280215,
0.0054223938,
0.0157897472,
0.0395686552,
0.0487652533,
0.0407863185,
-0.0442067273,
0.0057472088,
-0.0235573687,
-0.0208783038,
-0.0483383611,
0.0256664418,
-0.0144093586,
0.0018685076,
-0.052563291,
-0.0383436456,
-0.0432537794,
0.0129956184,
-0.0300843231,
0.0046154358,
-0.0072033363,
-0.0101150982,
0.0241915826,
0.0543979518,
-0.0093973866,
0.0259290058,
0.0023738698,
-0.0263407864,
0.0085318992,
0.0449485555,
0.0196822956,
-0.0113658048,
-0.032354258,
-0.0040601618,
-0.0381919965,
-0.0045315754,
-0.0232352503,
-0.0361762121,
-0.0296406709,
-0.0376378521,
-0.0380787551,
-0.0752388686,
-0.0056660506,
-0.0074237552,
0.018513551,
-0.0994730964,
-0.0251510516,
0.0037535508,
0.0018126284,
0.0081351986,
-0.0661753938,
0.006078945,
0.0149923721,
0.0015490317,
0.0166899804,
-0.0075584338,
0.0425673835,
-0.0248173904,
0.0355922468,
0.0095554423,
0.0524280854,
0.019221684,
-0.0488428771,
-0.0361038223,
0.0092190988,
-0.0261941887,
-0.0328397974,
0.0622013398,
0.0237042811,
0.0515157394,
0.0052335477,
0.0507476516,
0.0678406283,
0.026993081,
0.0384808816,
-0.0068066237,
0.0292554833,
0.054155264,
0.0391609222,
0.0835836604,
-0.0047892146,
0.0036551708,
-0.0160088986,
0.0344254188,
0.0097731892,
0.0301386341,
0.0015645331,
-0.0883024856,
-0.0315976962,
0.0145017812,
-0.0287875589,
-0.0110668,
-0.0128471414,
0.0054663881,
-0.0241718888,
0.0052606724,
0.0099577047,
-0.0901419446,
0.0456918925,
0.0154700149,
0.0308081936,
0.1153738499,
0.0298216399,
-0.0493034199,
-0.0264006667,
-0.0365651511,
0.0355873592,
0.0503005944,
-0.0006461942,
-0.0138919307,
0.0508408882,
-0.0422251001,
0.0030308412,
-0.034129899,
0.0525672361,
-0.0275821742,
-0.0419564024,
-0.0085615199,
0.0044961418,
0.0089455759,
-0.071870476,
0.0436675884,
-0.0026988257,
0.0336918831,
0.0052547613,
0.0088346079,
-0.0190028101,
0.041438017,
-0.0306425802,
0.0145632057,
-0.0034059333,
-0.0465803705,
-0.0101691447,
0.0227536988,
-0.0292840581,
-0.0212678127,
0.0427803695,
-0.0774793848,
-0.032630194,
0.0071365768,
-0.0093495678,
-0.0497142896,
0.0091032842,
-0.0355580933,
-0.0100894077,
-0.0165563356,
0.0333273411,
-0.0269582849,
-0.0167208239,
-0.0349140503,
0.0053558513,
0.0061064227,
0.0159451589,
-0.0239966214,
-0.0400192402,
-0.003093458,
-0.008857131,
-0.0041239862,
-0.0203620344,
0.0070614819,
0.0274592359,
0.0124335485,
0.0228622258,
-0.0699488074,
-0.0771597475,
-0.0483904295,
-0.0085020736,
-0.0348749682,
0.0156553742,
0.053899724,
-0.0511543974,
-0.0077717863,
0.0265026912,
-0.0130525958,
-0.0485374592,
0.0113040544,
-0.0206242669,
0.0813031644,
-0.0441063493,
0.0095367823,
-0.0610722303,
0.0041454555,
-0.022144217,
0.0068554785,
0.0375824012,
-0.0467356145,
-0.0547485687,
0.0221329648,
-0.0006552131,
-0.0698199943,
0.040682748,
-0.0608082488,
0.0162588134,
0.0182740372,
0.0747439563,
0.0720067397,
0.0136327799,
0.031229062,
0.0587163232,
-0.0410697982,
0.0124733793,
-0.0086598825,
0.0426950641,
0.0461521596,
-0.0145118609,
-0.0644353628,
0.0165039282,
0.0415697135,
0.0105238585,
-0.0148360683,
-0.0177603383,
0.0242117494,
-0.0462771431,
0.0183045194,
-0.0382064953,
-0.0414965674,
-0.0147860264,
0.0344499089,
-0.0360827409,
-0.0015978132,
0.0493437797,
-0.0385667756,
-0.0097847963,
-0.0400053412,
0.005158829,
-0.0525791571,
0.0001900259,
-0.018002877,
0.0139737474,
-0.0023202337,
-0.0291638039,
-0.0360014588,
0.0065420377,
0.0716869533,
-0.0129017858,
0.0637861565,
-0.0707085356,
-0.0259436779,
0.0156632308,
-0.0624431446,
0.0112532331,
-0.0542474017,
-0.0149266208,
0.0054381564,
0.0021495644,
-0.023654772,
-0.0187247563,
-0.0350743085,
0.0190888569,
0.059000209,
-0.0378832296,
-0.0042339843,
-0.0156924315,
0.0350009128,
0.0344953723,
0.0436474904,
-0.0121045103,
-0.0500885658,
0.0529133193,
0.0324059315,
-0.040903721,
0.0281613339,
-0.0266702324,
0.0132778101,
0.0000849655,
-0.0291546509,
-0.0353195108,
-0.0026251043,
0.0708854571,
-0.0588417388,
-0.0073399716,
0.1231259629,
-0.0193060171,
0.0047560926,
-0.0229332335,
-0.0533006117,
0.0439775847,
0.0102167344,
0.0109718507,
-0.0331833251,
-0.0458836704,
0.0037057856,
0.0329983272,
0.0103194918,
-0.0234748144,
0.0080068577,
-0.0522009246,
0.0340884514,
0.0128495032,
-0.0266055055,
-0.0112127727,
0.0048450269,
-0.0310511049,
0.0094304811,
0.016422376,
-0.0058853114,
-0.0311686415,
0.0293742828,
0.0205717366,
-0.0785468444,
-0.0527276509,
-0.0576641336,
-0.0432229154,
0.0365394913,
-0.0054057064,
0.0480336323,
-0.0171062779,
-0.0085485764,
0.0260308888,
-0.0081475507,
-0.0068112211,
0.0004669857,
0.052924037,
0.0080627585,
0.0195327383,
-0.0405701324,
0.0457653925,
-0.0110995779,
-0.0245424248,
0.0328965187,
0.0396089181,
-0.0127572259,
-0.0046316031,
0.0080296155,
0.0371019505,
0.0224741679,
0.0676882342,
0.0799589977,
-0.0344732702,
-0.0344852991,
-0.0550262965,
0.0230997838,
-0.0417660214,
0.0006133729,
0.033429943,
0.0077531496,
0.0114459731,
-0.0743286088,
-0.1017880738,
0.0286652092,
0.0045929621,
0.0532293394,
0.0566121899,
-0.0139314635,
-0.0539861843,
-0.0282342304,
0.0239709448,
0.0111030834,
0.0327445678,
-0.0567409545,
-0.0000350215,
-0.0677785948,
-0.0096183317,
-0.0135930963,
-0.0008304216,
-0.0379474536,
-0.0564814582,
0.0818727389,
0.0160596669,
0.012018594,
0.0152155422,
-0.0044674478,
-0.0614151433,
-0.0385587588,
0.003283429,
-0.0199230257,
0.0637607351,
0.0448737964,
-0.0189139843,
-0.0070840712,
0.0536102317,
0.02690465,
-0.0086530121,
0.0163881518,
0.0209996458,
-0.011592946,
-0.0267728753,
0.0001222773,
0.0385335051,
0.0584922433,
-0.0170719177,
0.0187359415,
-0.0622329712,
0.0047814003,
-0.0349453092,
-0.0529946908,
-0.0319964737,
0.0180058144,
0.0099700009,
-0.022901414,
-0.0249114465,
0.0743784755,
-0.033781644,
0.0095013427,
-0.0136588681,
0.0465746522,
0.0129428199,
0.0375975221,
-0.0238389242,
0.0053685806,
-0.0114706727,
0.0300337058,
-0.0186739024,
0.0605197623,
0.0407887474,
0.0084467744,
0.0031684281,
0.0041661425,
0.0045412281,
0.0277439132,
-0.0299521014,
0.0015841732,
0.0053093205,
-0.0080761844,
0.0755564049,
-0.0298863314,
0.1438956261,
-0.0156783685,
0.0114416946,
-0.042602852,
0.0924709365,
0.0376614891,
-0.0343803205,
-0.032239601,
-0.0091617201,
0.0008309213,
-0.0077980245,
0.0602316633,
-0.0355603434,
-0.0272357818,
0.0211550277,
0.0003749343,
-0.0170608945,
-0.0238847509,
0.0089974301,
0.0447086133,
0.0045259632,
-0.0261085592,
-0.064141348,
0.0165014565,
0.039698828,
0.0089259502,
0.0136822136,
-0.0169329047,
-0.0095950551,
0.0376122706,
-0.0417379364,
-0.0003968015,
-0.0561572574,
-0.0076317103,
-0.0012068285,
-0.014341766,
-0.0076446156,
-6.061088747e-33,
-0.0281067714,
-0.0550367311,
-0.0123707447,
-0.0053583765,
-0.0138286529,
0.0382762067,
-0.0412332043,
0.0382768139,
0.0015424715,
0.0667983815,
-0.0085611409,
0.0344568789,
0.0119070932,
0.0404580981,
0.0323676951,
0.022972174,
0.0598932728,
0.0412409529,
-0.0329592153,
-0.0211802833,
0.0295917597,
0.014471733,
0.0849019513,
-0.0198111627,
0.0427633002,
-0.039920941,
-0.0449164845,
0.0052564992,
-0.0320935212,
0.0146542545,
0.0182718709,
0.0802690312,
0.019942103,
0.0280018114,
-0.0156453531,
-0.0136429351,
-0.0306546837,
-0.0542407893,
0.0166275799,
0.0043923389,
-0.0388795733,
-0.0631278083,
0.0313678794,
0.0007803565,
0.0038273842,
-0.018750554,
0.0706063733,
-0.0047588628,
0.0212940034,
0.0286295395,
-0.0912898853,
0.0380265452,
-0.0496139191,
-0.0113637568,
0.0031055149,
0.0141376741,
0.0111536831,
-0.0551859774,
-0.0572743341,
-0.0050417134,
0.0008795575,
0.0719899908,
0.0174834486,
-0.0426813699,
-0.0697641224,
0.0947666317,
0.0049178111,
0.0312583335,
-0.0127366157,
0.0332386196,
0.0172033813,
0.0052766395,
0.0819341093,
0.0452104621,
0.0381596647,
-0.0112578431,
-0.0247484054,
0.0269394722,
-0.0110188555,
0.0316188894,
-0.0069731683,
-0.0290843695,
-0.0230365749,
-0.0658518597,
-0.0435303114,
-0.0447450392,
-0.004702454,
0.0071588052,
0.0001713747,
-0.0381166302,
-0.003854631,
-0.0379853807,
-0.0294243749,
0.009837863,
-0.0170126408,
-0.0024727096,
-0.0537664965,
0.0682457238,
-0.0139519703,
0.0360174514,
-0.008416526,
0.0008461987,
-0.0234294813,
0.0519656762,
0.0451620258,
0.0175503492,
0.0856567249,
0.0097644879,
-0.0398552157,
0.0176064894,
-0.0076185269,
0.0148503007,
-0.0318778269,
-0.0329609029,
0.0159277748,
0.0237880852,
-0.0154576749,
0.0439919643,
0.0212318804,
0.0221778043,
-0.0298248027,
-0.0279006418,
0.0028686384,
-0.0007720293,
0.0079754228,
0.0153084546,
-0.0180982295,
-0.0212839302,
0.0074190279,
-0.0327545777,
0.0172240753,
-0.0203818083,
2.455e-7,
0.0704813749,
0.065854378,
0.0314010829,
-0.0311291367,
-0.0098708989,
0.0117497109,
-0.038983237,
0.0018576073,
-0.0187410712,
0.0459404215,
-0.0184020903,
0.0131900711,
0.0813700631,
0.0089595607,
-0.0734950677,
0.0039214813,
-0.0738702342,
0.00832179,
-0.0674966425,
0.0227330271,
0.0603128821,
0.0036944861,
0.00526855,
-0.0282871425,
-0.0040355287,
-0.0134389522,
0.0167244133,
-0.0240806174,
0.0094127599,
0.0482011102,
0.0669182986,
-0.023265576,
0.0293204449,
0.0109425001,
-0.0316378698,
-0.0333584286,
0.0141595295,
0.0684773922,
0.0095164981,
0.0443461016,
0.0059102732,
0.0194010548,
-0.0310385861,
-0.0220414307,
0.0594921857,
0.0180512052,
-0.0088962996,
-0.014172608,
-0.0104730548,
-0.0112774102,
0.0253835488,
-0.004815117,
-0.0336457379,
0.0159750208,
0.0218675677,
-0.0508368649,
-0.0197330173,
-0.0276517589,
-0.0932346657,
0.0206351243,
0.0392567515,
0.0389837474,
-0.0087362053,
0.0117977913,
0.0085763941,
-0.0940039903,
0.0091254823,
2.129776966e-34,
0.0557803437,
-0.024168117,
0.0587517619,
0.0236689784,
0.0136314882,
0.0027614189,
-0.0203129388,
0.0062113386,
-0.0327186324,
-0.0001247868,
0.0189986955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19648v1 | Designing and Evaluating Multi-Chatbot Interface for Human-AI Communication: Preliminary Findings from a Persuasion Task | 2024-06-28T04:33:41 | 2024-06-28T04:33:41 | Sion Yoon, Tae Eun Kim, Yoo Jung Oh | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | The dynamics of human-AI communication have been reshaped by language models
such as ChatGPT. However, extant research has primarily focused on dyadic
communication, leaving much to be explored regarding the dynamics of human-AI
communication in group settings. The availability of multiple language model
chatbots presents a unique opportunity for scholars to better understand the
interaction between humans and multiple chatbots. This study examines the
impact of multi-chatbot communication in a specific persuasion setting:
promoting charitable donations. We developed an online environment that enables
multi-chatbot communication and conducted a pilot experiment utilizing two
GPT-based chatbots, Save the Children and UNICEF chatbots, to promote
charitable donations. In this study, we present our development process of the
multi-chatbot interface and present preliminary findings from a pilot
experiment. Analysis of qualitative and quantitative feedback are presented,
and limitations are addressed. | [
0.1014254838,
0.0354044996,
-0.0417516194,
-0.0177464318,
-0.053474769,
-0.0037448087,
0.0460893661,
0.0131353596,
0.0696909428,
-0.0109691974,
-0.025004385,
-0.0175124314,
0.0344246179,
0.0126588885,
0.0129508441,
-0.0634968802,
0.0132404519,
-0.0169473756,
0.057631243,
-0.0235620867,
0.0738153979,
0.0487836488,
-0.0314229913,
0.0850179344,
-0.0366876014,
-0.0614746958,
-0.0284363925,
-0.004901967,
0.0080983471,
-0.0093755443,
0.0061825309,
0.029635109,
0.0366143771,
0.0317837931,
0.0000019851,
-0.0457418635,
-0.0055765319,
-0.0150082596,
-0.0714468285,
-0.0296940822,
0.0927549079,
0.0285822488,
-0.0160392057,
0.0147029171,
-0.040899381,
0.0424026214,
0.0772153065,
0.0428883322,
0.0325836428,
0.0115657374,
-0.0062411614,
0.0276396088,
-0.0042776358,
0.0210146513,
-0.0232046172,
-0.0117014106,
-0.0237573553,
-0.0093176188,
0.043422021,
-0.0018340321,
0.0277112201,
0.0144518176,
0.0013676181,
-0.0249392278,
-0.0260865875,
0.0206990577,
-0.0641025826,
-0.0625418276,
-0.0540552586,
0.0465426408,
0.0381915011,
0.0090988334,
-0.0077009122,
0.0250278078,
0.0483028889,
0.0288241338,
-0.0238628723,
0.0164778605,
-0.0137269609,
-0.0176139101,
-0.0358926766,
-0.0024215381,
-0.0073238066,
0.0093553336,
0.0349985175,
0.0014117403,
-0.0028689965,
-0.0017742161,
-0.0042242571,
0.0131017445,
-0.0319237635,
-0.0573974028,
0.0053166202,
0.0147838946,
-0.0478109829,
0.0168300234,
0.0102830073,
-0.0027502649,
0.0063310456,
-0.0717202276,
-0.004334385,
0.038514588,
-0.0229331199,
0.0107430732,
0.0661888197,
0.0484288484,
0.0165300332,
0.0197507199,
0.0203945506,
-0.0027556533,
-0.0564830489,
-0.0316242762,
-0.0232034884,
0.0488316752,
0.028296154,
-0.0182081927,
-0.0203215536,
0.0179165043,
-0.0468526706,
-0.0171938781,
-0.0028300639,
-0.0070099956,
-0.0136583066,
-0.0019029855,
-0.0064365137,
0.0255297162,
-0.0590678118,
0.0192789957,
0.0184227359,
-0.1218523607,
0.037298128,
0.0246642381,
-0.0101022506,
0.0038700199,
-0.0225519333,
0.062719807,
-0.0289746094,
-0.0300379936,
0.0511157401,
-0.0008537608,
-0.0086934399,
-0.0548693091,
-0.0137701919,
-0.0214959998,
0.0403292328,
0.0030880254,
-0.0093319109,
-0.0126400432,
0.0278741084,
-0.0276409108,
-0.025349278,
0.0502383858,
0.0040945895,
0.0118578933,
0.0468408801,
0.0486800857,
-0.0491686091,
0.0480661802,
0.0262152832,
0.0117789228,
0.0494364239,
0.0034836002,
0.0161157921,
0.0114431018,
-0.0486182868,
0.0035451357,
0.0330475494,
-0.0118001634,
-0.0382824391,
0.0276949797,
-0.0438608006,
0.041547846,
-0.0399210863,
0.0092614107,
0.067791149,
0.0833149627,
-0.0051396778,
0.0121309441,
-0.0211941767,
0.0477456525,
0.0290004537,
-0.0025594041,
0.0084721139,
0.014296107,
0.0104178777,
-0.0535759106,
0.01930511,
0.0039969189,
-0.0177269466,
-0.0169063807,
0.0054639406,
-0.0327184498,
0.1002896279,
0.0051936912,
-0.0008652604,
-0.0086855711,
0.0070338449,
-0.0661992729,
0.0101377787,
-0.0571062304,
-0.0383215062,
-0.0703237727,
0.0228099972,
0.076629743,
0.0451187901,
0.0298753139,
-0.0118184527,
-0.0273193549,
-0.0255852118,
0.0647015348,
0.0379249938,
0.007340027,
-0.015426822,
0.0139451362,
-0.0148883797,
0.0216576848,
-0.015346095,
0.0289071165,
-0.0047710137,
0.0355500579,
-0.0417499356,
0.0503070652,
0.045281522,
-0.0095946025,
0.0349754803,
0.0448366143,
-0.0912561193,
0.0070019308,
0.0409225933,
0.0448153615,
-0.0066101244,
-0.0183248147,
0.0020316327,
0.025087649,
-0.0466591306,
0.0430735573,
0.0246746764,
0.0214567557,
0.024370227,
-0.0397397019,
-0.017808497,
0.0394385532,
0.0421409905,
0.0283122808,
0.0260114539,
-0.0243212637,
0.0880567431,
-0.0021894809,
-0.0123890983,
-0.0479942225,
0.0139967976,
0.0237685591,
-0.0234790985,
0.0282168947,
-0.0455137789,
-0.0019805739,
-0.00226478,
-0.0181770921,
-0.0282335095,
0.0442595296,
0.0476454012,
0.0255024116,
0.013109168,
0.0570537746,
-0.0070440834,
-0.0393923111,
-0.0290175211,
-0.1422425807,
-0.0714997351,
0.0171272345,
-0.0275963452,
-0.0120552601,
0.0005146866,
0.0079569025,
0.0338317342,
-0.0637796894,
0.014210688,
0.0084834518,
0.0522692874,
0.0330811292,
-0.0188557953,
-0.0171033181,
-0.0160037447,
0.0501247905,
0.0083214929,
-0.006838161,
0.0895174965,
-0.089510344,
-0.0171970576,
-0.0031135387,
-0.0742942244,
0.0004997817,
-0.0048114783,
-0.0904025361,
0.0828984082,
0.0112956483,
0.0548081025,
0.0270112567,
0.0357087962,
0.08082816,
0.0068553691,
-0.0036426613,
-0.0517952107,
-0.0196901597,
0.0177849438,
0.0090480736,
-0.0270432644,
-0.0238505825,
-0.0078357505,
-0.0064325007,
0.0171528161,
0.036850892,
-0.0388076678,
0.0548151471,
0.0052183643,
-0.0557259098,
-0.0278409179,
-0.0591980815,
-0.037394233,
0.0513963327,
0.0179532822,
-0.0379062667,
0.0380483195,
-0.0112910196,
-0.0367631391,
-0.0000441943,
-0.024868235,
0.0078987228,
0.0450568758,
-0.0735849068,
0.0235146899,
0.0239653029,
-0.0139545891,
-0.0151771326,
-0.0061286199,
0.0045978874,
-0.0336941294,
-0.0350047238,
-0.0184938665,
-0.0044513033,
0.0216366239,
-0.0189941861,
-0.0025208683,
-0.038249176,
-0.0330964029,
-0.0136309331,
0.0657091588,
-0.0384605825,
-0.0394911207,
0.0095529612,
0.04525242,
-0.0021534921,
0.0202806238,
-0.0082898522,
-0.0059555271,
-0.0655862018,
-0.0095695434,
0.0503309742,
-0.0015558085,
-0.0164698251,
0.0261955708,
0.0177136622,
0.0360610671,
-0.038785059,
-0.0008534626,
-0.040930301,
0.019212544,
0.0372961834,
-0.0172980204,
-0.0154750785,
0.0490463413,
-0.0137935858,
0.0405827351,
0.0486419871,
-0.0112113031,
-0.0799429417,
0.0243191049,
-0.0559700876,
0.0098008532,
-0.0395264141,
0.0066706194,
-0.0669246241,
-0.0029217631,
0.0161886457,
-0.0240499191,
-0.0586941466,
-0.0263104681,
-0.0235190541,
-0.0397266634,
0.0193268843,
0.0019703368,
0.0068542417,
-0.0239225999,
-0.0161766149,
0.0092323432,
0.0278230328,
0.0129400864,
-0.0196005031,
0.0115070892,
-0.0122947069,
-0.0379279293,
-0.0344994664,
0.0317416862,
0.0410355479,
-0.0387923568,
0.0845817327,
0.0872081667,
0.0484279096,
-0.0029628077,
0.0137384087,
0.015914131,
0.0958591625,
-0.0092980172,
0.0320578702,
0.008548785,
-0.013987137,
0.0221407674,
-0.0325599276,
-0.0267560109,
-0.0072288373,
0.0369970165,
0.0278478283,
0.0189278387,
-0.0240223017,
-0.0224014223,
0.0135167325,
0.0281081684,
0.0423326008,
0.0486843251,
-0.0135385506,
-0.0558967777,
0.0144551769,
-0.0275308471,
0.0004608012,
0.0629774258,
-0.0690461993,
-0.0445687659,
0.0026196782,
-0.0162068326,
-0.0780745819,
-0.0781923085,
-0.0080382498,
-0.0147576304,
0.0171891507,
0.023254592,
0.0223572664,
0.0589209236,
0.1030177996,
-0.0017835536,
-0.0474264212,
0.0332475305,
-0.0264321342,
-0.0264793262,
-0.0460604802,
-0.066286847,
0.0215301681,
0.003768045,
-0.0032655504,
-0.0159814134,
0.0067279302,
-0.0002205283,
0.0255515706,
-0.0025078414,
0.008868509,
0.0008270132,
-0.0519034155,
0.0255711991,
-0.010212481,
0.0081880456,
0.042928759,
0.0735489875,
0.0070353108,
0.007358538,
-0.0107823014,
0.0213998649,
-0.0264696144,
-0.0127310855,
-0.0349282287,
-0.06874533,
0.0361137018,
0.0368684083,
0.0064958143,
-0.0027732325,
0.0155820893,
-0.0068106242,
-0.0265594069,
-0.0575426295,
0.0143340854,
-0.0579257719,
-0.0159380157,
-0.0458258577,
-0.0216101538,
0.0298292972,
-0.0133793382,
-0.0534060597,
-0.0190135632,
0.0262232516,
0.0516410507,
-0.0031843151,
0.0526763648,
-0.0130653977,
0.0133081926,
0.0072460263,
0.0625511333,
-0.0159114879,
-0.0090638231,
0.0083167609,
0.0541726425,
0.0098210992,
-0.0655212253,
0.0461308956,
0.0377761051,
-0.0189382602,
-0.0961463228,
0.0315265395,
0.0352725163,
0.0020697832,
0.0775930807,
0.0271413866,
-0.0494768135,
0.0185794234,
-0.0318692289,
0.0253998749,
0.0032724843,
-0.0118617546,
-0.0333147869,
-0.0091044931,
-0.0435662158,
0.0170427226,
0.0136771081,
-0.0767355934,
0.000916923,
-0.0181186907,
-0.0257715322,
-0.0245400649,
-0.0346656665,
0.0250235032,
-0.0027847611,
0.0030366061,
0.0099534905,
-0.0370669216,
0.0019039758,
-0.0561450534,
-0.0191239957,
-0.0127059296,
-0.0558619313,
0.0447952785,
0.0362167954,
-0.0471429415,
0.0106078628,
-0.0389235653,
-0.0029006156,
-0.046381209,
0.0135104395,
-0.0103064962,
-5.959236202e-33,
0.0201568734,
-0.0524538122,
0.0047826315,
0.0157654267,
-0.0326089971,
-0.0361381844,
-0.0126560889,
0.0469844826,
-0.0262820106,
0.0292698666,
-0.0135263782,
0.0130224405,
0.0072211511,
-0.0742951781,
0.0086836834,
-0.008731463,
0.0418456569,
-0.0223414563,
-0.0121522816,
0.0371201411,
0.0123352474,
-0.0116747692,
0.0032281105,
-0.0875671804,
0.0771909878,
-0.0156523436,
-0.0514038093,
-0.0002109815,
0.0351916589,
0.0127178598,
0.0115936389,
0.041944243,
0.002416488,
-0.0112420134,
0.0068651927,
0.0918703526,
0.0297304317,
-0.0441916734,
0.0397058688,
-0.0154087786,
-0.0461710095,
-0.0233648662,
-0.0353563428,
-0.0341992341,
-0.0202483628,
0.0352221206,
0.0119827976,
0.012807888,
0.0280572809,
0.0606260411,
-0.059659835,
-0.0149568021,
-0.0276304409,
-0.0272472426,
0.0104003027,
0.0757056326,
-0.0286736302,
0.0186249372,
-0.0102322157,
0.0469308682,
-0.0248826537,
-0.0499234498,
0.0105705345,
-0.0315457657,
0.0134372879,
0.0313329138,
0.033924453,
0.0178970695,
-0.0276684742,
-0.0326027274,
-0.0195639916,
0.0123902448,
0.0724039376,
0.0551656671,
-0.0187076535,
-0.0446557999,
0.001751808,
-0.018966442,
0.1109692827,
-0.0109466054,
-0.0017275057,
0.0234653354,
-0.0515735745,
0.0061870152,
0.0050070467,
-0.0300144181,
-0.026718596,
-0.0918799117,
0.0118218726,
-0.0177397691,
0.0097378576,
-0.036182262,
0.0236261617,
-0.0217192024,
-0.0046983864,
-0.0001652387,
0.0143657951,
0.0155537017,
0.0203099083,
-0.0206778459,
-0.0049507641,
0.0010845277,
-0.0066641802,
0.0096573858,
0.0396634229,
0.0167939216,
0.0171966664,
0.0006995067,
-0.0031900946,
-0.0197504684,
0.0054415255,
0.0097907791,
-0.0071167029,
-0.0552859753,
-0.0046134656,
-0.0172823071,
-0.0048217867,
-0.0124879964,
0.0314757228,
-0.0071960962,
-0.0371822715,
0.0144096408,
-0.0818330497,
-0.0207016226,
-0.0349879079,
-0.0164689068,
-0.0853314921,
0.0128415432,
0.0329184458,
-0.0292065106,
-0.0339350067,
-0.0713366121,
2.722e-7,
-0.0130486377,
0.0533920005,
-0.0268166978,
0.0206198264,
0.0486219451,
0.0372330807,
0.000785989,
0.028001029,
-0.017076483,
-0.0164511595,
0.0093020406,
0.0371531956,
0.0628491268,
0.011494291,
-0.0435882919,
-0.0346410945,
-0.05941597,
-0.0190100688,
-0.0202908665,
0.0567444451,
0.0610564463,
0.0061539789,
0.0383732431,
0.0055118273,
-0.0289795827,
0.0235383455,
0.0168683473,
-0.0571674593,
0.0082335463,
0.0082389088,
-0.0143299261,
-0.0259220246,
0.0034382623,
0.0394231416,
0.0306847524,
-0.0139462939,
0.0151786515,
0.0458413847,
-0.0099773165,
-0.0107988007,
0.0147078102,
0.0173357222,
-0.0196006503,
-0.0288843997,
0.0256320462,
-0.0855131522,
-0.0513870083,
-0.0332670957,
0.0219538901,
-0.0268032495,
0.0291185472,
-0.0355757549,
-0.0470839888,
0.0391859859,
-0.0242127609,
0.0073507498,
-0.0159272719,
0.0058989325,
0.0223596245,
-0.0313915573,
-0.0325082913,
-0.0959025472,
0.0022906365,
-0.020673044,
-0.0080826506,
-0.0171944536,
0.0244683567,
1.563595979e-34,
0.0142037924,
-0.0203488767,
0.000527641,
0.0483894199,
0.074922055,
0.0255696084,
0.0105808442,
-0.0028257782,
0.0380818993,
-0.0086107338,
-0.0073915953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19643v1 | Unlocking Varied Perspectives: A Persona-Based Multi-Agent Framework with Debate-Driven Text Planning for Argument Generation | 2024-06-28T04:21:20 | 2024-06-28T04:21:20 | Zhe Hu, Hou Pong Chan, Jing Li, Yu Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Writing persuasive arguments is a challenging task for both humans and
machines. It entails incorporating high-level beliefs from various perspectives
on the topic, along with deliberate reasoning and planning to construct a
coherent narrative. Current language models often generate surface tokens
autoregressively, lacking explicit integration of these underlying controls,
resulting in limited output diversity and coherence. In this work, we propose a
persona-based multi-agent framework for argument writing. Inspired by the human
debate, we first assign each agent a persona representing its high-level
beliefs from a unique perspective, and then design an agent interaction process
so that the agents can collaboratively debate and discuss the idea to form an
overall plan for argument writing. Such debate process enables fluid and
nonlinear development of ideas. We evaluate our framework on argumentative
essay writing. The results show that our framework can generate more diverse
and persuasive arguments through both automatic and human evaluations. | [
0.0436508022,
0.0394298546,
0.0070011285,
0.0018706252,
-0.0434972197,
-0.0229395945,
0.0283334125,
-0.0538154021,
0.0100518139,
-0.0454101041,
0.032025706,
-0.0401104279,
-0.0013782152,
0.0462478176,
0.0013008813,
-0.1006719247,
0.0003907603,
-0.0024198336,
0.0812642276,
-0.0174506344,
0.0304773003,
0.0061447169,
-0.0256383363,
0.0501393378,
-0.0375270881,
-0.0355383717,
-0.0333708003,
-0.0162853114,
0.0486085974,
-0.0187910832,
0.0041302941,
0.042108383,
0.0281908568,
0.0193784609,
0.0000018258,
-0.0402567759,
-0.0041352264,
-0.0119178453,
0.0062847356,
-0.0294289924,
0.0642038658,
0.058242064,
-0.0072836988,
-0.0004639488,
-0.0487761684,
0.0307825711,
0.0171646681,
0.0935844928,
0.0872324705,
0.0692316294,
-0.0084009776,
-0.0282425676,
0.0182138961,
0.000515162,
-0.0570359565,
0.0021801477,
-0.0065291515,
-0.0424445421,
0.0087416479,
0.0052886177,
0.0296966434,
-0.0147422431,
0.0115198754,
-0.062344674,
-0.0054685059,
0.0181591008,
-0.0102689443,
-0.0382801704,
-0.006653443,
0.0374281928,
0.0463920273,
-0.0073366575,
0.017736787,
-0.0293285847,
0.0326475613,
-0.0057481057,
-0.0180451218,
0.0769772381,
-0.0277599227,
0.0171041805,
0.042021215,
0.0170447081,
-0.005395473,
0.0202831384,
0.0060873572,
0.0220342819,
-0.018392235,
-0.0136342244,
0.0299698226,
-0.0021148478,
0.0272056013,
-0.089661628,
-0.0019946238,
0.0366456434,
-0.0726770759,
0.0306616817,
-0.0340741165,
0.0067915255,
0.0178895704,
-0.0563788302,
0.0509178936,
0.0095326994,
0.0540313385,
0.0183298476,
0.0217515286,
0.0040396634,
-0.0208161063,
-0.0153784277,
0.0187038127,
-0.0080093658,
-0.0594508164,
-0.0291345213,
-0.0531037487,
0.050428696,
-0.0206472073,
-0.01925404,
0.0073364964,
0.0237331185,
-0.0635819435,
0.011921593,
-0.0210579298,
0.0467267707,
-0.0196990091,
-0.0213124957,
-0.0544370748,
0.0416861512,
-0.0654177219,
-0.0061751367,
0.0491391942,
0.0009806129,
-0.0032173814,
0.03441054,
0.0023043654,
0.0039044819,
-0.0301338732,
0.0328039229,
-0.0411538258,
0.0399917364,
-0.0086805895,
-0.078198351,
-0.0167288985,
-0.0724543855,
-0.0332467034,
-0.061983753,
0.009187364,
-0.0196867399,
-0.0099723032,
-0.0627683997,
0.01996186,
0.0387823805,
0.0180809367,
0.0262250826,
-0.0061706058,
-0.0158631448,
0.0807767063,
0.0164914448,
-0.0630407184,
0.0373771377,
0.0511175208,
0.0494100153,
0.0166440792,
0.0503725708,
0.0288912021,
-0.0136393961,
-0.0082785711,
0.0028891517,
0.0783940852,
-0.0236395821,
-0.0517586321,
0.0532146618,
-0.0419357345,
0.0645508841,
-0.018963078,
-0.0181905087,
0.0562659875,
0.061900761,
-0.0226695929,
0.0102755502,
0.0580950789,
0.0272675548,
0.0119939698,
0.0199653283,
0.015934607,
0.0305097047,
0.0498331487,
-0.0248773471,
0.0053886473,
0.003688511,
-0.0208649058,
-0.061490126,
0.0106720431,
-0.0017326596,
0.0243545864,
-0.0365376696,
-0.0182459224,
-0.0018879178,
-0.0248364042,
-0.0007665522,
-0.0054603787,
-0.0656674579,
-0.0187936779,
-0.0050401785,
0.0606269017,
0.0548341908,
0.020061994,
-0.0133205028,
-0.0114677791,
-0.0356101692,
0.0816283152,
0.0987951979,
0.0809019357,
-0.0396680385,
-0.0227570143,
-0.0315173939,
-0.0293990802,
-0.0297864471,
0.003469062,
0.0490573943,
0.014569737,
-0.0066753644,
0.007366512,
0.050093241,
-0.0240888353,
0.0401385985,
-0.0202078708,
0.0457430333,
-0.000157334,
0.028022673,
0.0268675182,
0.0450612605,
-0.0190030523,
0.0240035281,
0.0299403854,
-0.0301912464,
-0.0614260621,
0.0465450361,
-0.026514085,
0.0186095312,
0.016050471,
-0.0771968067,
-0.0042469674,
-0.0476286113,
0.0264221784,
-0.0325281136,
0.0347181335,
-0.0356902406,
-0.009522751,
-0.0228529256,
-0.0175584089,
0.0134108597,
-0.0051806718,
-0.0187803917,
0.0615057573,
0.0338824056,
-0.0353815518,
0.0367592871,
0.0475533716,
0.0142475879,
-0.0759439096,
0.017441079,
0.0195604302,
0.0390229411,
0.0072861291,
0.0617411137,
-0.0348955877,
-0.0378558636,
-0.0516204163,
-0.1116804034,
-0.0157955308,
-0.0083231777,
-0.0026588915,
-0.006494794,
-0.0322578102,
0.0127755878,
0.0138319302,
-0.0624815412,
-0.0036189826,
-0.0086136628,
0.0058675944,
0.0642443895,
-0.0052976408,
0.0246277805,
-0.0156015223,
0.029754892,
-0.0304428879,
0.0133330906,
0.0788914263,
-0.0206979923,
-0.0320265256,
-0.0225742534,
-0.0329266824,
-0.0087948432,
0.0015951105,
0.0001680777,
0.0679211318,
0.0321450457,
0.0545425974,
0.0744827911,
0.0538045242,
0.0557376258,
0.014173978,
0.0116578173,
-0.0503872558,
0.0269225985,
-0.0075349268,
0.0858122483,
-0.0240244139,
-0.0156430248,
0.0389106013,
0.0493809208,
-0.0015357512,
0.0192028321,
-0.0703122243,
0.0920815989,
-0.0042990646,
-0.0251657404,
0.0462316722,
-0.0531241596,
-0.0343589708,
0.0322948992,
-0.0460714549,
-0.0009076283,
0.0880119801,
-0.006421769,
0.0229977164,
-0.0033924566,
-0.0056951907,
-0.0373473652,
0.0560406782,
-0.0138332667,
0.0207628962,
-0.0147072347,
0.0357265808,
-0.0459601767,
-0.02768627,
0.0577947684,
-0.0011990366,
0.0379452109,
-0.0667118952,
0.0058517545,
-0.0094299996,
-0.0288250986,
-0.0209415387,
-0.0364196487,
-0.0180395767,
0.0182798672,
0.0066748979,
-0.0082085803,
-0.0299303737,
-0.0112426914,
0.0220957231,
-0.0007027802,
-0.0082679372,
-0.0014021239,
-0.0263335332,
-0.026130572,
-0.0054264716,
0.0211543962,
-0.0022590959,
-0.0439400002,
0.0726709589,
0.0514601879,
-0.0158223454,
-0.0220690817,
-0.0154827386,
-0.038937632,
-0.0319164246,
-0.0368654989,
-0.0223741215,
-0.0179674681,
0.070014216,
-0.0513540469,
0.0191987492,
0.0829991177,
0.0107749961,
-0.0294043608,
-0.0014392141,
-0.0231595598,
0.0429461747,
0.0000864605,
0.0373660251,
-0.0195829496,
0.0098606478,
-0.0187082086,
0.0192851629,
-0.0487292632,
-0.054357551,
-0.0155551881,
-0.0556285754,
0.0567566156,
0.0012331252,
0.0298916344,
0.0384466536,
-0.0225551296,
-0.0100460332,
-0.0103907138,
-0.0422606729,
-0.0069858506,
0.0255619138,
0.0118798539,
0.0043529305,
-0.0147031192,
0.0355842188,
-0.0091894865,
-0.0464580171,
0.0302732065,
0.0351083167,
0.0897188932,
0.010910606,
-0.0459029749,
-0.0249403473,
0.043443244,
0.0248877425,
0.0032167633,
0.0247095507,
-0.0406631008,
0.0195028111,
-0.0350649357,
0.0460068546,
0.0019769983,
-0.078390263,
0.0406466164,
0.0527991578,
-0.0445700549,
-0.0450967439,
-0.0065463842,
0.013485889,
0.0164960474,
0.0592911988,
0.0195899289,
-0.0426708981,
-0.0755829215,
-0.0685312673,
0.0015579059,
-0.1005567312,
-0.0048118629,
-0.03855858,
-0.029152751,
0.0213250443,
-0.0742739141,
-0.074579373,
-0.0001415788,
0.0616462193,
0.0046520289,
-0.0187900178,
0.0258350782,
0.0160272717,
-0.0097983479,
-0.0329892486,
-0.0026623879,
0.0398522131,
-0.0056059118,
-0.0484720059,
-0.0237305611,
-0.0270621721,
0.0046368996,
0.016214706,
-0.0009502168,
-0.0797430351,
0.0026081349,
0.0259673148,
0.0169187561,
0.0378946997,
0.0111819012,
-0.0439656004,
0.0469191298,
-0.0280098878,
0.0240513198,
0.0298552737,
0.0091443788,
0.0213575941,
-0.0101827318,
0.0330291204,
0.0092243413,
0.0018235224,
-0.0113829775,
0.0384171158,
-0.053825777,
-0.0336193666,
0.0028613803,
-0.0070120189,
-0.0246812236,
-0.0147631448,
-0.0503380969,
-0.0520998091,
-0.0102883186,
-0.062037155,
-0.0357587636,
-0.0214073639,
0.0100307763,
-0.0323617421,
-0.0376061201,
0.045822531,
0.0051041921,
-0.0246920865,
0.0275036171,
0.0361765996,
0.0276220683,
0.0024708137,
0.0390244201,
-0.0139924707,
-0.0047158524,
-0.032008402,
0.0372704305,
-0.0589030497,
0.0464067683,
0.0020821355,
0.0539054908,
0.0273561254,
-0.0307102986,
0.0394339561,
0.0047250325,
-0.0857609659,
-0.0331995897,
0.014623899,
0.0085063661,
-0.0142958574,
0.053999275,
0.062895909,
-0.0507378094,
0.0068633645,
0.0143814776,
0.0278536752,
0.0338681974,
-0.0388089493,
-0.0130424919,
0.0083568059,
-0.0403482467,
-0.038748607,
0.0448561423,
-0.0494045019,
0.0217636656,
-0.0017919098,
-0.0259560589,
-0.0588307381,
-0.053181909,
-0.0143680247,
0.0467002466,
0.0120529672,
-0.015923785,
-0.0584705025,
0.0223563742,
0.0009290199,
0.0430901274,
0.0020587153,
-0.0098323626,
0.0054383143,
0.0384668335,
-0.0120298853,
-0.0016833289,
-0.0953736901,
0.0467165932,
-0.0242488105,
0.0099268043,
-0.0052802884,
-5.501426703e-33,
-0.0370917283,
-0.0477080569,
0.0259793214,
0.0454174913,
-0.0358672701,
-0.0144339791,
-0.0425251126,
0.0372274294,
0.0103254607,
0.0703828409,
0.0105646923,
-0.0002244641,
0.003406923,
-0.0013239222,
-0.0032286812,
0.0116260359,
0.0389226936,
-0.0016427544,
-0.0521429181,
0.0192384087,
0.0381888486,
-0.0282655377,
-0.0247925222,
-0.0342848375,
0.0570860133,
-0.0178867225,
-0.0187715739,
0.0150114121,
-0.0228459314,
0.0383207016,
0.0127049573,
0.0387516879,
0.0278119612,
-0.0220423378,
-0.0097461455,
0.0597218126,
-0.0098564401,
-0.0488612913,
0.0117935557,
-0.03477256,
-0.0389612988,
-0.074396044,
-0.0178462882,
0.0052766767,
-0.0105713503,
-0.0072063575,
0.0392168202,
0.0073648687,
0.0380145013,
0.0020475625,
-0.0659834892,
0.0237688366,
-0.0160541628,
-0.0108718583,
-0.0328444056,
0.0072792196,
0.0233364478,
0.0035361918,
-0.0651495606,
0.0529432036,
-0.0308820959,
-0.0102153681,
0.0210440364,
-0.0062929522,
0.0009427714,
0.0665369853,
0.0390583277,
0.0505115055,
-0.0833939537,
0.0129007995,
-0.0282405708,
0.0414248556,
0.0511160418,
0.1093942374,
-0.031723097,
0.0074537243,
-0.018672267,
0.0326059461,
0.048963096,
0.0150274243,
0.0301965401,
-0.0071424646,
-0.0130325537,
-0.014939554,
-0.0496406704,
-0.0485241562,
-0.0015643475,
-0.0424784906,
-0.0152469426,
0.0078294938,
-0.0109303854,
0.0193416346,
-0.0121360701,
-0.0269445051,
-0.0120157758,
0.0052481689,
-0.009803039,
0.0146956416,
-0.001131513,
-0.0110998908,
-0.0342383049,
0.0022789913,
0.0200438332,
0.0390307643,
0.0425470173,
0.0105530526,
-0.01118341,
-0.0080418913,
-0.0169625878,
-0.0134771569,
-0.0369482078,
0.0419589765,
-0.0064523867,
0.0190355852,
-0.0120562725,
0.0137452846,
-0.0243115332,
0.0126000829,
0.0001937397,
-0.0137109021,
-0.0374244228,
-0.0370611995,
0.0007076655,
-0.0004499387,
-0.0185380168,
0.0182687957,
-0.0213663951,
0.0152102411,
0.0257340278,
-0.035508845,
-0.0037400499,
0.0131953126,
2.378e-7,
0.0080758184,
0.0396269895,
0.0377352983,
-0.007502086,
0.0263421331,
0.0509493873,
-0.0001199134,
0.0273053963,
-0.0281796101,
-0.0406744331,
-0.0095960116,
0.0454759039,
0.0407917835,
0.0656818002,
-0.0923207924,
-0.047416687,
-0.0212892685,
-0.0234704856,
-0.0696913972,
0.0179976374,
0.1096022353,
0.0063587958,
0.0402734131,
-0.0021845247,
-0.0110451188,
0.0252326261,
0.0599735826,
0.0036600502,
0.0027858014,
0.0259422604,
0.0235212967,
-0.0865933672,
0.0159204695,
0.0394116864,
0.0002416523,
-0.0055363309,
-0.0237708725,
0.0550602525,
-0.0127423266,
-0.0402093716,
0.0210039876,
-0.0091603929,
0.0019007288,
-0.0444084816,
0.0190001503,
-0.0451305471,
-0.0310524087,
-0.047555685,
-0.0228783432,
-0.0035584578,
-0.011811397,
-0.0238048322,
-0.0224540923,
-0.0010873458,
-0.0117184827,
-0.0048320717,
0.0318337604,
-0.055994302,
-0.0255973656,
-0.0446501523,
-0.0361042693,
-0.0319024585,
-0.0190250278,
-0.0198812596,
0.0140516553,
-0.0499733537,
0.0103044985,
1.719082543e-34,
0.0054421974,
0.0019617467,
-0.019774681,
0.0025573256,
0.0596639179,
0.0518972129,
0.0051328507,
-0.0080955075,
0.0376067534,
-0.0354815088,
-0.025724927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19642v1 | IDT: Dual-Task Adversarial Attacks for Privacy Protection | 2024-06-28T04:14:35 | 2024-06-28T04:14:35 | Pedro Faustini, Shakila Mahjabin Tonni, Annabelle McIver, Qiongkai Xu, Mark Dras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Natural language processing (NLP) models may leak private information in
different ways, including membership inference, reconstruction or attribute
inference attacks. Sensitive information may not be explicit in the text, but
hidden in underlying writing characteristics. Methods to protect privacy can
involve using representations inside models that are demonstrated not to detect
sensitive attributes or -- for instance, in cases where users might not trust a
model, the sort of scenario of interest here -- changing the raw text before
models can have access to it. The goal is to rewrite text to prevent someone
from inferring a sensitive attribute (e.g. the gender of the author, or their
location by the writing style) whilst keeping the text useful for its original
intention (e.g. the sentiment of a product review). The few works tackling this
have focused on generative techniques. However, these often create extensively
different texts from the original ones or face problems such as mode collapse.
This paper explores a novel adaptation of adversarial attack techniques to
manipulate a text to deceive a classifier w.r.t one task (privacy) whilst
keeping the predictions of another classifier trained for another task
(utility) unchanged. We propose IDT, a method that analyses predictions made by
auxiliary and interpretable models to identify which tokens are important to
change for the privacy task, and which ones should be kept for the utility
task. We evaluate different datasets for NLP suitable for different tasks.
Automatic and human evaluations show that IDT retains the utility of text,
while also outperforming existing methods when deceiving a classifier w.r.t
privacy task. | [
0.0326201729,
0.1045609191,
-0.0419511944,
0.0502841249,
-0.0647243336,
-0.0014567027,
0.0351500101,
0.0083663352,
0.026136009,
-0.0568333976,
-0.044388134,
-0.0211105086,
0.019271981,
0.0281559695,
0.0255226474,
-0.0106523605,
0.0188511461,
0.0127432216,
0.0166268684,
-0.0150207747,
0.0094004702,
0.0123004308,
0.0205369312,
0.0339450128,
0.0273609906,
-0.0406470671,
0.0123903751,
-0.0207857899,
0.0269236453,
0.0151510844,
0.0558887832,
0.0646344796,
0.0068849977,
0.0839504227,
0.0000021014,
-0.0163085144,
-0.0423811115,
0.0573015697,
-0.0035823486,
0.0075806654,
0.0589462034,
-0.0170242172,
0.0090554208,
0.0071458672,
-0.0528902225,
0.0045024273,
0.0203280766,
0.0913041607,
0.0492990278,
0.1060875058,
-0.0256491769,
-0.0202848054,
-0.0034209206,
-0.0513060167,
-0.0029097383,
-0.0530101359,
0.0193687044,
-0.0799050778,
-0.0569033436,
0.0464615263,
0.0114575243,
0.0408060551,
0.0076703555,
0.003397573,
0.0041732793,
0.0285318978,
0.0185094792,
0.0012946532,
0.0087371869,
0.023274349,
0.0025411833,
-0.0285971519,
0.0216562133,
0.0089774886,
0.0489957891,
0.00914138,
0.0202175844,
0.0072045787,
-0.0213285796,
-0.0125123113,
-0.0149307037,
-0.0128685767,
0.0363693945,
0.0203624554,
0.0157182999,
0.0146826981,
0.0002256974,
-0.0047241747,
-0.0333482027,
-0.0137279313,
-0.0051610032,
-0.065385215,
0.0475712642,
-0.0129073681,
0.0318254046,
0.0115956767,
-0.1004884318,
-0.0684326366,
-0.0000134676,
-0.0504428335,
0.036822889,
-0.0306171551,
-0.0090419538,
0.0355248675,
-0.0198950488,
0.0359570794,
-0.0104154209,
0.0358971693,
-0.0180524625,
0.0188006405,
-0.0175328851,
-0.03714424,
0.0129654249,
0.0453505814,
-0.0621574745,
0.0168784056,
-0.0302725323,
-0.0106349485,
-0.0490539856,
0.0256409068,
-0.0039306167,
0.0321183614,
-0.0477324352,
-0.0012296927,
0.0210197661,
-0.0502876416,
0.0096535766,
0.0331935808,
-0.0063647158,
-0.020956682,
-0.0119657954,
-0.0028636707,
-0.0187400468,
-0.0003393578,
-0.0408314466,
0.0976539627,
0.0099109467,
-0.0210386068,
-0.0328300223,
-0.0638828427,
-0.0212788489,
-0.0393659025,
0.0068951952,
-0.0017659037,
0.0064644921,
-0.0281306282,
-0.0301271919,
-0.0947155505,
-0.0103378491,
0.0222137533,
-0.0248434003,
0.0941340104,
0.0441970602,
-0.0517279617,
0.0068585938,
0.0516495891,
-0.0136809964,
0.0347969271,
0.0222575068,
0.0672083795,
0.0500287004,
0.0083364835,
0.0253556371,
-0.0122247422,
0.0410981365,
0.0034171054,
0.0045269253,
0.0197674539,
-0.0176589862,
-0.0483324081,
-0.0237799678,
0.0168684069,
0.0127549283,
-0.063976787,
0.0892956927,
0.0293882713,
-0.0010374588,
0.0238290541,
-0.0140095195,
0.0486995168,
-0.0333991721,
0.0236118864,
-0.0534704998,
0.0063893613,
-0.0993955359,
-0.0649855286,
-0.0530120656,
-0.0043216902,
-0.0017805505,
-0.0432823971,
0.019217547,
-0.0349571109,
0.0760421306,
0.0226371866,
-0.0160435997,
0.0632303208,
-0.0263714734,
-0.006239288,
-0.0009635906,
-0.0318383835,
-0.0102751702,
-0.0543879978,
-0.0026634256,
0.0447251499,
0.0275817793,
-0.041304592,
0.0434837677,
-0.0559737012,
-0.0364345461,
-0.0131022157,
0.0242168084,
0.0142492205,
0.042678684,
-0.0379743986,
-0.0416425169,
-0.0603398196,
0.0247556195,
0.0475329161,
0.0200948771,
-0.0123176398,
0.0392600708,
-0.0164946225,
-0.0149804354,
0.0281992462,
0.0176250227,
-0.0573872924,
0.058881484,
0.0222049896,
0.025391914,
0.0247575082,
0.0042693154,
0.0237717517,
0.0154483691,
0.0177341737,
-0.0414328426,
0.0071063568,
0.0087408582,
-0.0266503673,
-0.049698513,
-0.0444635786,
-0.022695547,
0.0737768635,
-0.0283025485,
0.0016530317,
0.0141511848,
-0.0281056054,
0.007836706,
-0.0160486754,
-0.0096224677,
-0.0002129735,
0.0352665633,
-0.0348671712,
0.0611016825,
-0.0288970172,
-0.023130469,
-0.0572460704,
-0.0423473641,
-0.0140102841,
-0.0242193099,
-0.0070816586,
-0.0155241778,
-0.0035641168,
0.0152667137,
0.0266344007,
-0.0028415129,
0.0053347982,
-0.0438900329,
-0.0206083711,
-0.0041879723,
-0.027395159,
0.0126442863,
0.0263276156,
-0.0200821571,
0.0135440482,
-0.0144830719,
-0.0442118607,
-0.019236207,
-0.055967249,
0.025750393,
0.0274872314,
0.0016657201,
0.0091563808,
0.0146330856,
0.0078608543,
-0.0094886553,
0.0425641462,
-0.0165591668,
-0.0371317416,
-0.038235154,
0.0245814696,
0.025619803,
0.038651105,
-0.034835767,
-0.0152673144,
-0.0185466036,
0.0381390266,
-0.0185147114,
0.051917024,
0.0312301032,
0.0607802942,
0.0288053025,
0.0429451577,
0.0016670896,
-0.0155136213,
0.0069625438,
0.0478917845,
-0.0324336849,
-0.0374938548,
0.036740765,
0.0182176065,
0.0444506891,
-0.0438183844,
-0.0213080049,
0.0552561879,
-0.0259188227,
-0.0855891779,
0.0288717691,
-0.0227287281,
-0.0000282505,
-0.0050944411,
-0.0343212746,
-0.0341102481,
0.0707365721,
-0.0126856668,
0.0197779611,
-0.0435959361,
-0.0411833487,
0.0091270795,
0.0711776763,
0.0195288789,
0.0315444954,
0.0731380731,
-0.0263223313,
-0.0182220992,
0.0025188031,
0.039922405,
-0.0130000282,
0.0072902003,
-0.0086102095,
-0.0167777538,
0.0108241234,
-0.0472378694,
-0.046056252,
-0.0913334861,
0.0268086102,
-0.0093806423,
0.0130807403,
-0.0488107093,
-0.0312550738,
-0.0608630404,
0.0110036815,
0.0002585457,
-0.032197699,
0.0056539103,
-0.0352088884,
0.0386189222,
0.0156150311,
-0.0439638123,
-0.0342782028,
-0.0252485424,
-0.0224514809,
0.0823628232,
-0.0216360372,
0.0249552205,
0.0208015889,
-0.042709548,
0.0086328359,
-0.0194668155,
-0.0331939869,
-0.0153177977,
0.0453760624,
-0.0585501529,
-0.0059546567,
0.0479788296,
0.002645405,
-0.0304009151,
0.0180967208,
0.0614017695,
-0.0019101185,
-0.0173343606,
-0.0134667708,
-0.0607654899,
-0.0019912089,
0.0223919544,
0.0506320149,
-0.0440563411,
-0.023429798,
-0.0353673659,
-0.0683287606,
-0.0136790946,
-0.006061485,
-0.0154647175,
-0.030235352,
-0.0172991399,
-0.0225587934,
-0.0054662107,
-0.0050080922,
-0.0543723889,
0.0352122635,
-0.0086079538,
-0.0297183339,
-0.0040684636,
-0.030791875,
-0.0058038454,
-0.0080416035,
0.0272197779,
0.0603592061,
0.0529201031,
-0.0130823171,
-0.0081895217,
0.009797778,
0.022581704,
0.0095543936,
0.0166232567,
0.0950973034,
-0.0122776683,
0.0106930239,
-0.0218789373,
0.0790817291,
0.0507505462,
-0.0132266916,
0.0185779054,
-0.0142110651,
-0.0175687373,
-0.0422473997,
-0.0117843952,
-0.0261632092,
0.0484780222,
0.0746735483,
-0.0051866923,
-0.0425639115,
-0.019832192,
-0.0667730942,
0.0277867969,
-0.0598780364,
-0.0247918051,
0.0205383599,
0.0154662794,
-0.0501735881,
-0.0542306043,
-0.0207123272,
-0.0138410749,
-0.0190026723,
0.0358307734,
0.0177422203,
0.0159116369,
-0.0057758223,
-0.0630791709,
-0.0135249728,
-0.0440617055,
0.0239124727,
0.0177310649,
-0.0354715064,
0.0244574379,
-0.0105497297,
-0.0166021548,
0.0117946155,
-0.0574787967,
-0.0640357882,
0.028934801,
0.0295760818,
0.0070095295,
0.0658960938,
-0.05655526,
-0.0855317935,
0.0569458753,
0.0715511516,
-0.0648347288,
0.0082796672,
0.0853687301,
-0.0087954523,
-0.0053710034,
0.0324444026,
-0.0147141423,
0.0000193211,
0.0704625994,
-0.0652192011,
-0.0414444245,
-0.0045559793,
-0.0123351207,
0.0099622961,
0.0176375117,
0.0102193607,
0.0355090797,
-0.0180937387,
0.0175989605,
-0.0283592176,
-0.0119235022,
-0.0172478743,
0.0029815261,
0.0546812452,
0.0173922908,
0.0104115503,
0.0296096969,
0.014524335,
-0.0004631151,
-0.0743162557,
0.0249482729,
0.0553560033,
0.0490696616,
-0.0019629993,
0.0373719297,
-0.0078154961,
0.062005803,
0.0228536259,
0.0271557998,
-0.0011899276,
0.0218673665,
0.0186173096,
-0.0095168594,
-0.0315454751,
0.0374832898,
-0.0642069951,
0.015825076,
-0.0300667696,
0.0491844118,
-0.0244183466,
-0.0127305845,
-0.0138575276,
-0.0141516337,
-0.0031492161,
-0.0078213513,
0.035426978,
0.0035008085,
-0.0495668799,
-0.0068096765,
-0.0077702762,
-0.0065418677,
0.030875219,
0.0744979978,
0.0296492074,
0.0450755991,
-0.003442442,
-0.0419568196,
-0.0614925511,
-0.0311217327,
0.0312180445,
0.0116038546,
0.0083154468,
0.006334147,
-0.0487845205,
-0.069264248,
0.0103433309,
-0.0122290058,
0.0526108854,
-0.0122945057,
-0.0183374267,
0.0267735478,
0.0009955512,
-0.0042477562,
-0.0808408335,
0.0189618301,
0.0519900024,
-0.0238083173,
0.0024028812,
-5.601020095e-33,
0.0147868749,
-0.037345551,
-0.0584394969,
0.015494532,
0.0502653904,
0.0411988758,
-0.0012999695,
-0.0406143889,
-0.0096486192,
-0.0054275971,
-0.0266182385,
0.0265912656,
-0.0243743975,
0.0256516989,
-0.0406176709,
-0.020235274,
0.0769785643,
0.0057626036,
-0.0148755154,
0.0258683264,
0.0721097067,
0.0308483653,
0.0596047081,
-0.1002539173,
0.0888512433,
-0.0031570126,
-0.0649465248,
-0.0104499813,
-0.0692186207,
0.0229239147,
-0.0043642893,
0.0164530799,
0.0095343851,
-0.0065418147,
-0.0098034143,
0.0595578812,
-0.0504297093,
-0.0187358968,
0.0044202358,
0.0169056561,
-0.0130548039,
-0.0669089705,
0.0375241041,
-0.0324209295,
-0.0066218721,
-0.0164736696,
0.0220145378,
0.0147035327,
0.0325924903,
-0.0541936979,
-0.0295851622,
0.0041666315,
-0.0249720849,
-0.0221367013,
0.0469500013,
0.0452222414,
0.025142923,
-0.0252703298,
-0.0678346157,
0.0019067103,
0.032521978,
0.0029267368,
0.0180371013,
-0.0220229775,
0.0044585164,
0.0577959418,
0.0322253034,
0.0292260759,
-0.0321599357,
-0.0070885769,
0.0039762822,
0.0377725773,
0.0481813625,
0.0707698762,
0.0217736978,
-0.0637803897,
-0.0563053004,
0.0077962531,
0.0039300853,
-0.0317733102,
0.0465844236,
0.0176215079,
-0.0470794439,
-0.008782859,
-0.0454826802,
-0.0624101982,
-0.0343496576,
0.0156268217,
0.0012369853,
0.0069570099,
-0.0727867559,
0.0052029481,
-0.0242548119,
-0.0728626922,
-0.0242322441,
0.0323312879,
0.0125982696,
-0.0296203159,
0.0123820445,
0.0067701559,
0.0022520679,
-0.0031107524,
0.0689331889,
-0.0138565302,
0.0280262437,
0.0001471893,
0.0933578238,
0.0079149585,
-0.0428489409,
-0.0243551582,
-0.007532076,
0.0627345666,
0.0393021293,
0.0263409019,
0.0502655022,
0.0171273407,
-0.0328928605,
0.0050764927,
0.0294127874,
0.0444766879,
-0.0611439683,
0.0570155457,
-0.0171529744,
-0.0021303666,
0.0100301122,
-0.0425546914,
0.0493051782,
-0.0128716202,
0.0765027329,
-0.0399692059,
0.0023838619,
-0.0213279426,
2.83e-7,
0.0077592074,
0.0036777933,
-0.0026982864,
-0.0329859853,
0.0215545259,
0.0928499773,
0.0311511997,
0.0743088871,
0.0008852686,
-0.0188002028,
-0.0321931578,
-0.0025546472,
0.0403422192,
0.0248117913,
-0.062749967,
0.016856581,
0.0014937384,
0.0252742637,
-0.0176945087,
0.0197770763,
0.0401856974,
0.084744066,
0.0534254201,
-0.0079858759,
-0.0084983008,
-0.038741488,
0.0217974316,
-0.0337717161,
-0.0219949614,
-0.0179699603,
0.0348256864,
0.0292109102,
0.0178847034,
-0.0030790153,
-0.0503207296,
-0.0152904605,
-0.0182922035,
0.0763470903,
0.012967282,
-0.0120077692,
-0.0191327538,
-0.013949085,
-0.0101684034,
-0.0219648965,
0.0638300404,
-0.0230477359,
-0.051722236,
-0.04870224,
-0.0038216624,
-0.0194202159,
0.0295551401,
0.0108227581,
-0.0117136948,
0.0173453987,
0.0058287019,
0.0143175423,
0.0044589336,
-0.0645288005,
-0.0250676051,
-0.0285925642,
-0.0197147392,
0.0045662709,
0.0011748555,
0.0333000496,
0.0222762059,
-0.0678422973,
0.0172018558,
2.585907804e-34,
-0.00772506,
-0.0121337585,
-0.0243930668,
0.0107417814,
0.0209827125,
0.0089839688,
0.0232355036,
0.0008569944,
0.0099227438,
-0.0281906053,
-0.0374369994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19598v1 | Mixture of In-Context Experts Enhance LLMs' Long Context Awareness | 2024-06-28T01:46:41 | 2024-06-28T01:46:41 | Hongzhan Lin, Ang Lv, Yuhan Chen, Chen Zhu, Yang Song, Hengshu Zhu, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many studies have revealed that large language models (LLMs) exhibit uneven
awareness of different contextual positions.Their limited context awareness can
lead to overlooking critical information and subsequent task failures. While
several approaches have been proposed to enhance LLMs' context awareness,
achieving both effectiveness and efficiency remains challenging.In this paper,
for LLMs utilizing RoPE as position embeddings, we introduce a novel method
called ``Mixture of In-Context Experts'' (MoICE) to address this challenge.
MoICE comprises two key components: a router integrated into each attention
head within LLMs and a lightweight router-only training optimization strategy:
(1) MoICE views each RoPE angle as an `in-context' expert, demonstrated to be
capable of directing the attention of a head to specific contextual positions.
Consequently, each attention head flexibly processes tokens using multiple RoPE
angles dynamically selected by the router to attend to the needed positions.
This approach mitigates the risk of overlooking essential contextual
information. (2) The router-only training strategy entails freezing LLM
parameters and exclusively updating routers for only a few steps. When applied
to open-source LLMs including Llama and Mistral, MoICE surpasses prior methods
across multiple tasks on long context understanding and generation, all while
maintaining commendable inference efficiency. | [
0.0383203328,
0.0244986676,
0.0019609428,
0.0503567457,
-0.0234358199,
-0.0097092772,
0.008269337,
-0.0564104542,
-0.0125456918,
-0.0362771004,
-0.0601710305,
-0.007858241,
0.0068339985,
0.005508645,
0.0467481948,
-0.0484721065,
0.0372906178,
-0.0475671887,
0.0044907322,
0.0208995175,
-0.0019595085,
0.0068997303,
-0.0174496565,
0.0486429371,
-0.014212288,
-0.0081548179,
-0.0430450924,
0.0295468457,
0.0552236848,
-0.0426664501,
0.0196272209,
0.0241790842,
0.0557996035,
0.006177994,
0.0000020736,
-0.0240109898,
0.0078364601,
-0.0221791286,
-0.0262457225,
-0.0079508685,
0.0194568466,
-0.0166466553,
-0.0028926521,
0.0347158611,
-0.0117275966,
0.0375925899,
0.0262885056,
0.0110436268,
0.0423106365,
0.0804221183,
-0.0012094352,
0.0023546687,
0.0059654727,
-0.0474807583,
0.0316726938,
-0.0466393791,
0.0021556185,
0.0090137562,
0.0135636395,
0.0123558538,
-0.046886269,
0.0447954535,
0.0538428091,
0.0076384139,
0.0053270366,
0.0474705249,
-0.0038165932,
0.002754688,
-0.0313243866,
0.0637900084,
-0.0659854114,
-0.009577848,
-0.0028514448,
-0.011589176,
0.0138936639,
-0.0309860092,
-0.0586506687,
0.029589694,
-0.0105239777,
0.0133051639,
0.0200885888,
0.0277174991,
0.0316812843,
0.0179951675,
-0.0489622876,
0.049729906,
0.0000265029,
-0.0363935716,
-0.0225050896,
-0.0203662626,
-0.0362648331,
-0.0511008352,
0.0319023244,
0.0598791949,
-0.0352783389,
0.0522574112,
-0.0493195988,
-0.0072113988,
0.0024725399,
-0.0337289907,
0.0112449788,
0.0689666644,
0.0008403765,
0.0543806367,
-0.0369463637,
0.0304635987,
-0.0286955405,
-0.0058118277,
-0.0502769575,
-0.0066622118,
-0.0130287586,
-0.0203665085,
-0.0472396426,
-0.0002869596,
-0.0780667216,
-0.0636317357,
0.0132166212,
0.0769101754,
-0.0041063516,
-0.0115704872,
0.0208120737,
0.0327906013,
-0.0258285217,
-0.0082143052,
-0.0083166435,
0.0241864137,
-0.0117336707,
0.0483654216,
0.0414350629,
-0.0251365956,
-0.0342845693,
0.0475449972,
0.0031207062,
-0.0285913423,
-0.0029039045,
0.0594955124,
-0.0255666785,
-0.0315078869,
-0.0194347613,
-0.0250258967,
-0.0405872613,
-0.0623111539,
-0.0049789045,
-0.0550425239,
0.0324919187,
0.002439369,
-0.0006276791,
0.0153666437,
0.0158986971,
0.0310881771,
-0.0162270889,
0.0401052535,
0.0031207518,
0.0027735478,
0.0131988442,
0.0238213465,
-0.0108820116,
0.0847830251,
0.0284242202,
0.0703628063,
-0.0202206653,
0.0320507661,
-0.0259840395,
0.0252795201,
0.0062764683,
-0.0153960967,
-0.0300117489,
-0.0034994532,
-0.0150084654,
0.0505305007,
0.0711916238,
0.0351635516,
-0.0387893431,
0.0151465796,
0.0552623421,
0.0363211408,
0.0529867671,
-0.002953806,
0.0890543684,
-0.010909725,
-0.0239990186,
0.0084801754,
-0.0796093643,
0.0465263911,
0.0265098047,
0.0295042619,
0.0405257158,
0.016034551,
-0.0251708329,
-0.0310658533,
-0.0255380124,
0.0066733765,
-0.0553493127,
0.0318574607,
0.014872333,
0.0020475669,
-0.0571862906,
0.0384150743,
0.0017250576,
-0.0312877372,
0.0106225275,
-0.0101087205,
0.005903909,
0.1155128926,
0.0261792261,
-0.018434776,
-0.0733331665,
0.0006292146,
0.0196998753,
0.0271741226,
-0.0144724688,
-0.0084067602,
0.0287381019,
-0.0572263151,
-0.0270153154,
-0.0174051132,
0.0064026276,
0.0258800387,
0.0259915087,
0.0190236717,
0.0257485304,
-0.0276877582,
0.036701221,
0.0278035104,
-0.0430950075,
-0.0061339852,
-0.0457920581,
0.0061718496,
0.0374014229,
0.0043749167,
0.0049446966,
0.0074473042,
0.0367278717,
-0.0578807108,
0.0202781353,
0.0220492389,
-0.1346707195,
-0.0830033869,
0.0245159175,
-0.0161461849,
-0.006718378,
-0.0330158994,
-0.0388327651,
-0.0467758067,
0.0102827605,
-0.0220289007,
0.0574667379,
-0.0236597043,
0.0084912973,
0.0543445349,
0.004881518,
-0.0312884562,
0.0693093687,
-0.0419109799,
0.0039306474,
0.0542102493,
0.0531172529,
-0.0083233053,
-0.0508583933,
0.007313096,
-0.0373758413,
0.0021475924,
0.01591512,
-0.0113722859,
0.0283716135,
-0.0302064456,
-0.0803126469,
-0.1211970225,
0.0120020108,
-0.04126928,
0.02366082,
0.0344216377,
-0.0035023016,
-0.0215867497,
-0.0009608194,
-0.023340527,
-0.0014198533,
-0.0251142252,
0.0001394292,
-0.011024572,
0.013736207,
-0.0346171036,
-0.0471019708,
0.0055422871,
-0.0097671971,
0.0330895558,
-0.0191655569,
-0.0362240225,
-0.0522991642,
0.0257934611,
-0.0001977044,
0.0243355595,
-0.0401462018,
0.0006781987,
0.0108677726,
-0.0103470143,
0.1003518999,
0.0802535787,
-0.0135664372,
0.0144653637,
0.0556070507,
-0.0283356328,
-0.0544241108,
0.0379684195,
0.0008550201,
0.0147202564,
-0.0471676774,
0.0050362158,
0.0152719151,
0.0525779501,
0.0180989038,
0.0081591886,
-0.0391782522,
-0.0109406691,
0.0180780273,
-0.040691305,
-0.0234965868,
-0.0245669298,
-0.0419905819,
0.0175649934,
-0.0476888306,
-0.0398768336,
0.0390458629,
-0.0541295446,
-0.0164765809,
-0.0240129046,
-0.0234522764,
-0.0635297373,
0.0370155834,
-0.0034694267,
0.0210519005,
-0.0524317063,
-0.0400521867,
-0.0580334179,
0.0151694454,
-0.0090116095,
-0.0007466037,
0.0302719399,
-0.0265359171,
0.0111392932,
-0.0259389821,
-0.0196645409,
-0.0611255616,
0.0231116749,
-0.0223177746,
0.0343378149,
0.0345186815,
-0.0078523941,
-0.0138520207,
0.027223533,
0.0273195989,
0.0707665682,
-0.0164427347,
0.0138425622,
-0.0414643101,
0.0237577092,
0.0426402539,
0.0193440579,
0.0071742753,
-0.0450944714,
0.0026255231,
0.0358642824,
0.0380252376,
-0.0343966894,
-0.0367209613,
0.012664564,
0.0146459453,
-0.018299466,
0.0041978075,
0.0241810996,
0.0635838434,
-0.0787072703,
-0.0240648333,
0.1041208506,
0.0204653963,
-0.0755151957,
-0.0113227405,
-0.0193972755,
0.0457736365,
0.0381058976,
0.0090217544,
-0.0716509819,
-0.0302505083,
0.0238586795,
-0.0025091923,
0.0360492282,
0.0027570177,
-0.0311865006,
-0.0955155268,
0.0268549379,
0.0096037714,
-0.0495733395,
-0.0193560738,
-0.0050194766,
0.007570032,
0.02950936,
0.052749075,
0.0354947224,
-0.0183126908,
-0.0148188742,
0.018793609,
-0.0029023604,
-0.0495591797,
0.0037219662,
-0.0214123763,
0.0436704047,
0.0135044679,
-0.0032207731,
0.0406998061,
-0.0403254442,
0.0740657449,
-0.0408829041,
0.0371176265,
-0.0209053978,
0.0024917352,
-0.0464765429,
-0.0060436917,
0.0054543302,
0.0204201639,
-0.029462738,
-0.0226964559,
0.0007329615,
0.0832193568,
-0.0209357515,
0.0334301703,
-0.0263829194,
-0.0015260037,
0.0093461582,
0.0612233765,
0.0624005236,
-0.0388216749,
-0.0297580436,
-0.0146183483,
-0.0181217622,
-0.0293257423,
0.0290315058,
-0.0084615117,
0.0129180886,
-0.0269457139,
-0.0536049604,
-0.0198394507,
0.0604694299,
0.0889421031,
0.0123463608,
0.0266331229,
-0.0213694926,
-0.0211126264,
-0.056754671,
0.0284563564,
-0.0228429567,
0.0135719469,
-0.0591982044,
0.0253668707,
0.0100175682,
-0.0382316336,
0.0015788669,
0.0287845097,
-0.0955491289,
-0.0683845505,
-0.0288702641,
0.0654295757,
0.0195276253,
0.0600204878,
-0.016151106,
-0.0418530554,
0.0577580705,
0.0228261352,
-0.0182138979,
0.0340076908,
0.0267525371,
0.0523732156,
0.0161178559,
0.0309649911,
-0.0560228266,
-0.0098872408,
0.0033693078,
0.0539906621,
-0.0288594905,
-0.0252750702,
0.0037768458,
-0.0502884127,
0.0039948239,
-0.0215839501,
0.039335385,
-0.0286409035,
0.0376363881,
-0.0175581314,
-0.0000397319,
-0.0496113077,
-0.0009166705,
0.0121071329,
-0.0042409971,
0.0343687087,
0.0183766335,
0.0313631333,
0.0084537193,
-0.0055077537,
0.02396564,
-0.0023166833,
0.0063241539,
0.0182584357,
0.0235327352,
-0.0355709083,
-0.0201747268,
-0.0462311655,
0.0281264577,
-0.0162279662,
0.0480376519,
0.0169757679,
-0.0343456082,
-0.0523498841,
0.0527723543,
-0.0528495945,
-0.0294832587,
-0.0077291983,
0.0376356989,
0.0885820612,
0.0046801991,
0.0500627607,
0.0012474323,
-0.0045197993,
-0.0057178596,
0.0279506203,
-0.0163187105,
-0.029817529,
0.037880946,
0.0431012139,
0.0021269161,
0.00183501,
0.0483514145,
0.028372068,
0.017868137,
-0.016634075,
0.0095370794,
-0.0281860698,
-0.0290893558,
0.0214071199,
0.0274474826,
-0.0312998705,
0.0109201008,
-0.0445849709,
-0.0765180215,
0.0063505522,
0.0126633588,
-0.0284932051,
-0.0196568258,
0.0355662629,
0.0353711136,
-0.0122220609,
-0.026989039,
0.002799077,
-0.0282041561,
0.0327412672,
-0.0239908863,
-0.0315334722,
-6.733092786e-33,
-0.0473583862,
-0.0329682454,
0.0604241788,
-0.0485922322,
-0.0458180048,
0.0310040526,
-0.0559852719,
-0.0038379072,
-0.0062335324,
-0.020903809,
-0.0095470101,
-0.0140505787,
0.0141078075,
0.0223338492,
0.0091062477,
0.0171491187,
0.0431280509,
0.028401969,
-0.0007083518,
0.003906671,
0.0430386662,
0.030756494,
0.0576579273,
-0.0407081693,
-0.013284835,
0.026907092,
-0.0126218991,
0.0448352322,
-0.0307624005,
0.0463486202,
-0.0155945988,
0.0109244259,
0.0284568351,
-0.0179371703,
-0.0495159216,
0.013691307,
-0.0662809908,
-0.0258996394,
0.0482693352,
-0.0148804346,
-0.0343980491,
-0.0516200028,
0.071901761,
0.0037438485,
0.0087236976,
0.0004119058,
0.0239122231,
-0.0323575772,
-0.0530015938,
-0.0217936132,
-0.0449508391,
0.0024245689,
-0.0015569443,
-0.032324221,
0.0002865815,
0.0192369949,
-0.0050740689,
-0.0142144635,
-0.0675028414,
-0.0067273285,
-0.0109322853,
0.0504571088,
0.0809286833,
0.0515444987,
0.00660779,
0.0469781049,
0.0165829025,
-0.0181578733,
-0.021221349,
-0.0348388106,
0.034121573,
0.0567045771,
0.0110372193,
-0.0160599537,
0.0258273389,
0.0108146193,
-0.0487364084,
-0.0176972151,
0.0170704909,
0.0672225803,
0.0402761959,
0.031693276,
-0.0442812666,
-0.0248535667,
-0.0158121958,
-0.016975211,
-0.0229147002,
-0.0234384313,
0.074731797,
0.0671942383,
0.0209932271,
-0.0226459596,
0.073017329,
-0.0094991243,
0.0285644867,
0.0262011401,
-0.0053259907,
0.0372529179,
0.0144037409,
0.0390158519,
-0.0897814855,
-0.0281536523,
0.0219629649,
0.0150911892,
-0.003531392,
-0.0181984808,
0.0500457585,
0.0320427716,
-0.0526553318,
-0.0048596789,
-0.066746898,
0.0287212841,
-0.026491167,
0.0183371175,
0.0512521267,
-0.0205514506,
-0.0277530868,
0.0739058331,
-0.0106086191,
-0.0353217945,
0.0013365478,
0.0213409606,
-0.0217388086,
0.032032799,
-0.0384544842,
0.0021266402,
-0.0270669386,
0.0208630804,
0.003453095,
-0.0552288368,
-0.0098681794,
0.0470075309,
2.867e-7,
0.0357428156,
0.0007467064,
0.0249187723,
0.011447032,
0.0430802293,
-0.0141592063,
-0.0217532516,
0.0177992266,
-0.008668744,
-0.000283199,
0.0115278782,
0.0629451349,
0.0157332979,
-0.0189707857,
-0.1196586639,
0.0055252882,
-0.050872501,
0.0039386214,
-0.0453086458,
-0.0259132162,
0.0362876914,
0.085403733,
-0.0122799035,
0.0040585678,
0.0115528442,
-0.0474174246,
0.0506872535,
-0.0064507686,
-0.0038136691,
-0.0022082827,
0.0188807305,
0.0276948567,
-0.0200112388,
-0.0317266658,
0.0168683752,
0.0417927504,
-0.0216694996,
0.0732417852,
-0.002358177,
-0.0431626402,
0.0246819649,
-0.0063352366,
-0.0084711388,
-0.0538612418,
0.0661740452,
-0.0630868971,
0.0043702475,
-0.031936314,
0.0056841271,
0.0133903231,
-0.0244160444,
0.0038838116,
-0.0186786074,
-0.0046630073,
0.0131088058,
-0.0223774463,
-0.0312401168,
-0.1066626832,
-0.036096707,
0.0047581694,
-0.072099112,
-0.0276675038,
-0.0481981821,
-0.0072080698,
0.0473290943,
-0.027104592,
-0.0264153481,
2.825277943e-34,
0.0274719372,
-0.0333980359,
0.033396624,
0.0660069212,
0.0180838779,
-0.017084796,
-0.0341777131,
0.0157018676,
0.0403169803,
-0.0584105812,
-0.0501790904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19593v1 | SK-VQA: Synthetic Knowledge Generation at Scale for Training Context-Augmented Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-28T01:14:43 | 2024-06-28T01:14:43 | Xin Su, Man Luo, Kris W Pan, Tien Pei Chou, Vasudev Lal, Phillip Howard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Synthetic data generation has gained significant attention recently for its
utility in training large vision and language models. However, the application
of synthetic data to the training of multimodal context-augmented generation
systems has been relatively unexplored. This gap in existing work is important
because existing vision and language models (VLMs) are not trained specifically
for context-augmented generation. Resources for adapting such models are
therefore crucial for enabling their use in retrieval-augmented generation
(RAG) settings, where a retriever is used to gather relevant information that
is then subsequently provided to a generative model via context augmentation.
To address this challenging problem, we generate SK-VQA: a large synthetic
multimodal dataset containing over 2 million question-answer pairs which
require external knowledge to determine the final answer. Our dataset is both
larger and significantly more diverse than existing resources of its kind,
possessing over 11x more unique questions and containing images from a greater
variety of sources than previously-proposed datasets. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that our synthetic dataset can not only serve as a
challenging benchmark, but is also highly effective for adapting existing
generative multimodal models for context-augmented generation. | [
0.0428817645,
0.0473757721,
0.0008419058,
0.0485570356,
0.0059161959,
-0.0180636588,
0.0249546655,
-0.0094038406,
0.0041307034,
-0.0605172291,
-0.0158187207,
-0.0042538233,
-0.0502427854,
0.0448818468,
0.0635891631,
-0.0335910916,
0.0386227109,
-0.0075471094,
-0.0488183796,
0.0113044661,
0.0187785905,
0.02718997,
-0.0241901595,
0.0277727451,
-0.0670355782,
-0.0151402131,
-0.028533889,
0.0307444073,
0.0298313089,
-0.0284576863,
0.0097612645,
0.0381762609,
0.060884133,
0.0129000684,
0.000001801,
-0.0272145569,
0.003943088,
-0.020356534,
-0.0047967569,
-0.0372367799,
0.0113114957,
0.013321083,
0.0190404747,
0.0032397208,
-0.0588344708,
-0.0023281767,
0.0507083498,
0.0097251954,
0.0751836672,
0.0591123067,
-0.026891904,
-0.0322743915,
0.0045809839,
-0.01495058,
0.0813631862,
-0.0059513096,
-0.0288030207,
0.0287925862,
0.0126011549,
0.0175034069,
-0.0373151973,
0.0466603115,
0.0428705029,
-0.0280412398,
0.0321351811,
0.0366891734,
-0.018937856,
-0.0021453688,
-0.0121327341,
0.1019959152,
0.0206121411,
0.0001815828,
-0.0163012147,
0.0019698802,
0.0217377264,
0.0141401272,
-0.0401519202,
0.0322721489,
-0.0269089639,
-0.0035676197,
-0.0324029662,
-0.0017730336,
0.0028069296,
-0.0112911295,
0.0075663952,
-0.0042472421,
0.0286570042,
0.0246486943,
-0.0549905263,
0.0143909231,
-0.0482826531,
-0.039938841,
-0.04097284,
0.0382998884,
-0.0224811807,
0.0275591314,
-0.0420013629,
-0.0327739716,
0.0083004581,
0.0118187582,
0.0376427658,
0.0176482759,
-0.0582253039,
0.0253683627,
-0.0400627069,
0.0373230055,
-0.0335053205,
0.0212244298,
-0.0615484044,
-0.0020211705,
-0.0131589873,
-0.0218776371,
-0.0173496995,
-0.005048723,
-0.0960389003,
-0.0244694017,
-0.0271855984,
0.0531133339,
0.0156926159,
0.0094713261,
0.0109669417,
0.0551109947,
-0.0414048471,
0.0071656434,
-0.0554285161,
0.0240039527,
-0.0249316804,
0.0289060902,
0.0430454351,
-0.0491235591,
0.0060381857,
0.0350377969,
0.0313445702,
-0.011782215,
-0.0134085929,
0.0892935544,
-0.0590499975,
-0.0104108406,
-0.0538256504,
-0.0571171604,
-0.0269416925,
-0.0410403274,
0.0426522903,
-0.0510688163,
0.0568380915,
-0.0196876526,
-0.0248803329,
0.0083642676,
0.0166534726,
0.0335107781,
0.0234487653,
0.0702505186,
-0.0102755064,
-0.0060942415,
0.0277295578,
0.0060869786,
0.0286497902,
0.0736881271,
0.0230490994,
0.0259045847,
0.0434007123,
0.0012907188,
0.0129902354,
0.0312528163,
0.0241649654,
0.019409515,
-0.0275941249,
0.0136612067,
0.020156458,
0.0227950756,
0.0334344059,
0.032238625,
-0.0426471792,
-0.0275921617,
0.0508634187,
-0.0172724649,
0.0314749964,
-0.0047167372,
0.0624061711,
-0.0285731573,
-0.0109565454,
-0.0040811058,
-0.0172341857,
0.0844933093,
-0.0215097647,
0.0249035377,
0.0391913243,
0.0342302583,
-0.0270654149,
-0.0301107671,
0.0298530478,
0.0072198352,
-0.0173288621,
0.0129719889,
0.014628795,
0.0624420084,
-0.0586545207,
0.0123333745,
-0.0111881178,
-0.0661063641,
0.0199800506,
-0.0086039603,
0.042395588,
0.0556791686,
0.0660521016,
0.0055777654,
-0.0246924199,
-0.0077861357,
-0.0067963228,
0.0601355992,
-0.0066465605,
-0.0246632807,
0.0057641244,
-0.0603655688,
-0.0401590876,
-0.0454920419,
-0.0110344598,
0.0140943825,
0.0224460829,
0.0012970862,
0.0324642621,
-0.0328819305,
0.0256086346,
0.0263638888,
-0.0324729718,
-0.0234220233,
0.0072935242,
0.0012223679,
-0.0107982485,
0.0182007439,
0.0049406188,
0.0092286849,
0.0268408544,
-0.0557010472,
-0.0051166303,
0.0414672904,
-0.0572449379,
-0.0926784873,
0.0028925594,
-0.054606922,
0.0134866461,
-0.0145956287,
-0.066013433,
-0.0345683582,
0.007122606,
-0.0314583704,
0.0038515644,
-0.0796420127,
-0.0395324342,
0.0787140578,
0.0160215553,
-0.0307657458,
0.05917513,
-0.041647207,
-0.0067257523,
0.0127592115,
0.0697475299,
0.0208388083,
-0.0400858112,
0.0232162941,
-0.0108908834,
-0.0027108584,
0.0199365038,
0.0178427175,
0.0018800182,
-0.0755192637,
-0.0082490547,
-0.0837749094,
-0.0108545609,
-0.0004075613,
-0.0302460846,
0.0293508824,
0.0150780845,
0.0087791793,
-0.0348878801,
-0.0632100031,
0.04252363,
0.0372905508,
0.0053384351,
0.0456658974,
0.0352963954,
0.0403284356,
-0.0288170315,
0.0172452927,
0.0264786687,
0.075499095,
0.0264422446,
0.043078281,
-0.0297496244,
0.0086085163,
-0.052592583,
0.0411685258,
-0.02853797,
-0.0032088927,
0.0437774174,
-0.053222429,
0.0704180375,
0.0188335013,
0.0224664062,
-0.0042373007,
0.0119134029,
-0.0147655755,
-0.0556346886,
0.021017218,
-0.0176001452,
-0.0378043242,
-0.0033791277,
-0.0258712154,
-0.0084349047,
0.0109664751,
0.0107392827,
-0.0095797703,
-0.0528808609,
0.0478063561,
0.059146367,
-0.0530057549,
-0.0558903627,
0.0207242686,
-0.0071579162,
0.0402275175,
-0.0401991755,
-0.0410704874,
0.0219823942,
-0.0258942768,
-0.0031052341,
-0.0069761355,
0.022150455,
-0.0258099418,
0.0710948557,
0.0090728598,
0.028551029,
-0.0175391026,
0.0282812975,
-0.0634861365,
0.007298884,
0.0122568803,
-0.0310608018,
0.0289098937,
-0.0379327685,
0.013538369,
-0.0135806408,
-0.0331757255,
-0.073701188,
-0.0148293991,
0.0278450605,
-0.038977813,
-0.0160996951,
-0.0151835205,
0.0277393796,
-0.0320957266,
0.0263478886,
0.0379994139,
0.0102007696,
-0.0192552004,
-0.03105345,
0.0945017189,
0.0917737782,
0.0421924479,
-0.0127639398,
-0.0343408212,
-0.0104471203,
0.0547059402,
0.0425051413,
-0.0204703938,
-0.021682661,
0.0149728758,
0.0017540542,
0.043814376,
0.0219475515,
0.025180757,
0.054486271,
-0.0218584724,
-0.0288488455,
0.0401892476,
0.0175722018,
-0.0177371092,
-0.0057457518,
-0.002059829,
0.0148471259,
0.0370522067,
0.0283124577,
-0.1282500178,
-0.0344437249,
-0.0395602547,
-0.007668314,
0.0050815823,
-0.020460682,
-0.036835257,
-0.1257428676,
0.0530425049,
-0.0026160225,
-0.0591921322,
-0.0304708462,
0.0199227557,
-0.0240196716,
0.0236904081,
-0.019847367,
0.0385701098,
0.0023660401,
0.0253567025,
-0.0033707854,
0.0619622655,
-0.0364399999,
-0.0201982185,
-0.0295622833,
0.0151077742,
0.0493422076,
-0.0072426018,
0.0244613439,
-0.0549121611,
0.0114303501,
-0.0065113422,
0.0178087223,
-0.0015025531,
0.0432526097,
-0.0134965396,
-0.0337759256,
-0.0070044706,
0.0409335084,
-0.0168784466,
-0.0176535957,
-0.00145706,
0.0304212421,
-0.028252773,
0.0006748735,
-0.0477350578,
0.0250139683,
0.0282234773,
0.0389476456,
0.01725219,
-0.0311673544,
-0.0004051809,
-0.0171932969,
0.0022481349,
-0.0897055641,
0.0021256825,
0.0148374643,
0.0285672806,
0.0217373967,
-0.1196085289,
-0.0203748327,
0.0127941715,
0.0483962782,
-0.0212900098,
-0.0156486779,
-0.0589754656,
-0.0070108962,
-0.0743795484,
0.0358564071,
-0.0021296141,
-0.0140133211,
-0.0080379369,
-0.0167519506,
0.0263816025,
-0.0828710422,
-0.008421775,
0.0421205722,
-0.0562936477,
-0.032290563,
-0.0447543859,
0.0709531084,
0.0091003384,
0.0432263948,
0.0309091788,
-0.0082821278,
0.0471213832,
0.0851009786,
-0.0110614663,
0.006937643,
-0.0199629366,
0.0317232311,
-0.0015894725,
0.0006568827,
-0.0543236658,
0.0105718076,
-0.0120917689,
0.0612789169,
-0.0088326856,
-0.028932672,
0.0354062803,
-0.0055386513,
-0.0123325018,
-0.0491236635,
0.0226594023,
-0.044142019,
0.0039088968,
-0.0287553985,
-0.0183383245,
-0.0757371038,
0.0125275822,
0.0016047719,
-0.0096221007,
0.0225606803,
-0.025557857,
-0.0052876668,
0.0782381147,
-0.032873176,
-0.0356085412,
0.0374467187,
-0.001243639,
0.0125218797,
0.0120629258,
-0.0038089589,
0.0287684128,
-0.035375502,
0.0502485298,
-0.011054527,
0.0958256871,
0.0237923637,
-0.0319650136,
-0.0027146162,
0.0320217051,
-0.022073349,
-0.0087115588,
-0.0621111244,
0.051902622,
0.0397844836,
0.0332357399,
-0.0048328037,
-0.0186702739,
-0.0128351329,
-0.0119965132,
0.0471111499,
0.0137131624,
-0.0489018373,
0.0499681942,
0.0122642014,
0.0122736059,
-0.0131671764,
0.057410609,
-0.0110100694,
0.0506586321,
-0.0416598581,
0.0298501719,
-0.0555070601,
-0.0288568716,
0.005988467,
0.0117199151,
0.0091999173,
0.036483027,
-0.0163362045,
-0.0632846355,
-0.0098715639,
0.0568183213,
-0.0218185242,
0.0342929102,
0.0585301183,
0.0457402691,
0.0145572275,
-0.0294539966,
-0.0255026408,
0.0284023173,
-0.0448328629,
-0.0146019515,
0.0274480786,
-5.845526226e-33,
-0.0270054564,
-0.0428314321,
0.0780092254,
-0.0509208813,
-0.0273980163,
-0.0171167757,
-0.0335217714,
0.0030194144,
0.0001466302,
-0.0270745158,
0.0254753958,
-0.0270920023,
-0.0144690452,
0.0617514327,
-0.020573562,
-0.0018521484,
0.0205836147,
-0.007394704,
-0.0062275236,
0.0362899676,
0.0670187399,
0.0024601608,
0.0353259109,
-0.0274318177,
-0.0036178436,
-0.0178996772,
-0.0304591432,
0.0439121127,
-0.0164942089,
0.064961791,
-0.0421303399,
0.039598614,
0.0162394103,
-0.0147443647,
-0.0163569506,
0.0115571572,
-0.0615088716,
-0.0162153877,
0.0153926769,
-0.0098464945,
-0.1118562296,
-0.0289799068,
0.0255733356,
-0.0500719026,
0.0122160502,
-0.0163399633,
0.0242107734,
-0.0314224698,
0.0184401181,
-0.0535834245,
-0.0201562699,
-0.0212213527,
0.0008945029,
-0.0227096397,
-0.0329690129,
0.067935355,
0.0463201739,
0.0087401718,
-0.0293209217,
0.0365184434,
-0.0078877416,
0.0108245257,
0.0814945698,
0.0347549915,
0.004463491,
0.0441543013,
0.0166154262,
-0.0462919511,
-0.0417900309,
-0.0023309931,
-0.0071872333,
0.0669098869,
0.0230782889,
0.1152176186,
0.0134568345,
0.0091644078,
-0.0443833694,
0.0638368353,
-0.0381345637,
0.0030876999,
0.0112837469,
-0.0076166056,
0.0279858056,
0.0158739742,
-0.0469762608,
0.0062934239,
-0.0354334079,
-0.0092269089,
0.0463123322,
0.0466203205,
-0.0033355192,
0.0124183176,
0.0633114651,
-0.0245833211,
0.0269674268,
0.010364458,
-0.0329194888,
0.0283988286,
-0.0024013249,
0.00606114,
-0.0098392451,
-0.0002967908,
0.1048170403,
-0.0064873621,
-0.0197310653,
0.0210111309,
0.0156208677,
0.02994431,
-0.0342450328,
0.0173225868,
-0.0496104322,
0.0503576025,
-0.0225797724,
-0.0347828455,
-0.0047099544,
0.0024092726,
-0.0822266117,
-0.0020374884,
-0.0038605463,
0.0359266438,
-0.0078623788,
-0.0470800139,
-0.0027548741,
0.0394800492,
-0.0254679266,
0.0480435677,
-0.0313288681,
-0.0258185975,
0.0299388897,
-0.0449266508,
-0.0108165825,
0.040613398,
2.386e-7,
0.0295261107,
-0.0219416618,
0.0202596504,
0.0094720013,
0.030682534,
0.0198445767,
0.0066701933,
0.0477245413,
0.0116499821,
-0.0652625635,
-0.0074346629,
0.0408662483,
0.0211498477,
0.0013983323,
-0.0391385704,
0.0127392132,
-0.0239491295,
-0.0298818815,
-0.0389046147,
-0.0025635818,
0.0526919179,
0.041691374,
-0.0377157219,
-0.0495012924,
0.0506723039,
-0.0182917304,
0.0868303999,
0.0015915905,
-0.0277434792,
-0.0204690546,
0.0340089314,
0.0133515373,
0.0058802827,
-0.0074849222,
-0.008132359,
-0.0233212151,
0.0174526628,
0.0187432747,
0.0128140543,
-0.0826516151,
-0.0045382516,
0.0189798158,
-0.0055924384,
-0.0388850383,
0.0583136193,
-0.0390973687,
0.0064974949,
-0.0286411755,
-0.0506395325,
0.0044540581,
-0.0042033629,
-0.0382459313,
-0.0429737382,
0.0084462203,
0.035040319,
0.0032640744,
-0.018630147,
-0.0591211542,
-0.0449709371,
0.0037385167,
-0.0553678125,
-0.0354593433,
-0.0508195646,
-0.0330324918,
-0.0122866249,
-0.0415085107,
-0.0396801718,
1.85601363e-34,
0.0125973718,
0.0267813616,
0.0060813124,
-0.0113114547,
0.0043188743,
-0.0208666008,
-0.0257024579,
0.0030832032,
0.0177701339,
-0.0673638433,
-0.0312311836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19578v1 | PathAlign: A vision-language model for whole slide images in histopathology | 2024-06-27T23:43:36 | 2024-06-27T23:43:36 | Faruk Ahmed, Andrew Sellergren, Lin Yang, Shawn Xu, Boris Babenko, Abbi Ward, Niels Olson, Arash Mohtashamian, Yossi Matias, Greg S. Corrado, Quang Duong, Dale R. Webster, Shravya Shetty, Daniel Golden, Yun Liu, David F. Steiner, Ellery Wulczyn | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Microscopic interpretation of histopathology images underlies many important
diagnostic and treatment decisions. While advances in vision-language modeling
raise new opportunities for analysis of such images, the gigapixel-scale size
of whole slide images (WSIs) introduces unique challenges. Additionally,
pathology reports simultaneously highlight key findings from small regions
while also aggregating interpretation across multiple slides, often making it
difficult to create robust image-text pairs. As such, pathology reports remain
a largely untapped source of supervision in computational pathology, with most
efforts relying on region-of-interest annotations or self-supervision at the
patch-level. In this work, we develop a vision-language model based on the
BLIP-2 framework using WSIs paired with curated text from pathology reports.
This enables applications utilizing a shared image-text embedding space, such
as text or image retrieval for finding cases of interest, as well as
integration of the WSI encoder with a frozen large language model (LLM) for
WSI-based generative text capabilities such as report generation or
AI-in-the-loop interactions. We utilize a de-identified dataset of over 350,000
WSIs and diagnostic text pairs, spanning a wide range of diagnoses, procedure
types, and tissue types. We present pathologist evaluation of text generation
and text retrieval using WSI embeddings, as well as results for WSI
classification and workflow prioritization (slide-level triaging).
Model-generated text for WSIs was rated by pathologists as accurate, without
clinically significant error or omission, for 78% of WSIs on average. This work
demonstrates exciting potential capabilities for language-aligned WSI
embeddings. | [
0.0275827721,
0.0490168221,
0.0188150965,
-0.0046017976,
-0.0196938999,
0.0245329998,
0.0186467096,
0.0356319249,
-0.0096496269,
0.0143389767,
0.0199136715,
-0.0493765585,
-0.0191266108,
0.0973102003,
0.0091528706,
-0.0754897743,
-0.0180976801,
0.013923238,
-0.012135867,
0.0052797492,
0.0083814347,
-0.0079351356,
0.0358331315,
0.060474962,
-0.0471886396,
0.029016722,
0.0363338776,
0.0201429632,
0.0176319983,
-0.033864025,
-0.0254287161,
0.0269008558,
0.0420889072,
0.042099528,
0.0000020794,
-0.0525960177,
0.0080158459,
0.0087157786,
0.0035420372,
0.0004236904,
0.0444607362,
-0.0474814922,
-0.0352664143,
-0.0176673643,
0.0120080132,
-0.0121219968,
0.0430978574,
0.0410460047,
0.0581618659,
0.0544457287,
-0.029364977,
-0.0017509052,
0.03582922,
-0.0108811483,
0.0360050984,
-0.0021805635,
0.0224732216,
0.0261785835,
-0.0090206861,
0.0158922933,
0.014566537,
0.0733940676,
0.0384388492,
-0.0537751876,
0.0256604571,
0.0791142061,
0.0221776608,
-0.037541829,
0.0028160072,
0.0453302525,
-0.0595305599,
-0.025116222,
0.0043596122,
-0.0325432122,
-0.0112083759,
-0.0109160449,
-0.0473662727,
0.0377254076,
0.0058995998,
-0.0041496204,
-0.0139378728,
0.0102974698,
-0.0020312485,
-0.0184783172,
-0.0260480475,
0.001759944,
-0.0014028881,
-0.0020606089,
-0.0216635372,
0.0297046807,
0.0144406706,
-0.0352044329,
0.0594422109,
0.0492422841,
-0.0092474371,
0.0031636816,
-0.0328044593,
-0.0513219982,
0.0645490959,
-0.0613991842,
0.0179618839,
-0.0177987739,
-0.0783995166,
0.0802312046,
-0.0361724012,
0.0213660914,
-0.0424943157,
0.053190887,
-0.0472173803,
-0.0154452724,
0.0222959351,
-0.0199548379,
-0.0239163749,
0.0014369318,
-0.0328277014,
-0.0489410982,
-0.0550285652,
0.0178554691,
0.0032719411,
0.0423847809,
0.0534688234,
0.0297200419,
-0.0765638873,
0.0190412235,
0.0125533249,
0.0437816791,
0.0038617034,
-0.0343486816,
-0.0316509232,
0.0198929086,
0.0091701793,
0.062314555,
0.0272769518,
0.0051524281,
-0.0123330997,
0.052186925,
-0.0121900989,
-0.0105167432,
0.0409620963,
-0.0200737901,
-0.0721502379,
-0.0267971382,
0.0255181044,
-0.0700925961,
0.0192215964,
0.0201331843,
-0.0120478645,
-0.0235004388,
0.023172915,
0.0191649254,
-0.0196620636,
0.0549813844,
-0.0459327064,
-0.0261510331,
0.0280052274,
0.0117002847,
0.026701957,
0.0200672504,
0.0082223229,
0.0365176871,
0.0038520705,
0.014857647,
0.0279882699,
0.0249670427,
0.0105265202,
-0.0132774338,
-0.052451618,
0.0128535824,
0.0254102126,
0.0530813634,
0.0321882367,
0.0538349077,
-0.0069383369,
-0.0490885191,
0.0340361074,
0.1198953241,
0.0273009073,
0.0216202084,
0.0431687273,
0.0032054964,
-0.0208401699,
-0.0130446739,
0.0106822783,
0.0291187912,
0.0148719884,
0.0085081831,
-0.016093934,
0.0042776209,
-0.0264261048,
-0.0470244884,
-0.0084822671,
-0.000294802,
-0.024303304,
-0.0284876991,
0.0555025041,
-0.0273138639,
-0.030169392,
-0.0317668617,
0.0405895934,
-0.0415558927,
-0.0263622776,
-0.0661875606,
-0.0133042196,
0.1069979742,
0.0683006495,
-0.0310198758,
-0.0204343703,
0.0193747338,
0.0127933715,
0.051164031,
-0.0184183605,
0.021768,
-0.0067972904,
-0.0389470272,
-0.0352888145,
0.0286448542,
0.0039492478,
-0.0257349126,
-0.0199005492,
0.0292079337,
-0.0157751217,
-0.025299659,
-0.0449813455,
0.040904928,
-0.0128095252,
-0.0092597893,
-0.0315213948,
0.0253052525,
-0.0178173389,
-0.0324071385,
-0.0525216758,
-0.0027905954,
0.0201245174,
-0.0171670988,
-0.0534128696,
0.0206899997,
-0.0326371565,
-0.0254023261,
0.0196373779,
-0.0584982522,
-0.0262777619,
-0.053776972,
-0.0244624969,
0.002117797,
-0.0358876884,
-0.0490802303,
-0.0765186548,
-0.0096415048,
0.0065258327,
0.0357943848,
0.0015357694,
-0.0322494544,
0.0464186296,
-0.0285949446,
-0.0225357264,
-0.0047380431,
-0.0491770059,
0.0501921847,
-0.0257808436,
-0.0475650392,
0.0374309346,
0.0191067979,
0.0165187195,
0.015063893,
0.0383305512,
-0.0067382678,
-0.021684967,
-0.0623835847,
-0.0143504357,
-0.0257699136,
-0.0416850336,
0.0407789275,
0.036360722,
0.0212157946,
-0.0537273064,
-0.0523368679,
-0.011046608,
0.0654506981,
0.0129432278,
0.0782162398,
0.0198365916,
0.0188518707,
-0.0350053646,
-0.0374345109,
-0.0121365888,
0.0318770781,
0.0537969619,
-0.0717802793,
-0.0088019259,
0.0216031857,
-0.0263977852,
0.0248349905,
0.0201019254,
-0.0565594994,
0.0121565647,
-0.0303408522,
-0.028094627,
0.0952897817,
-0.0193142053,
0.0784435123,
0.0076722992,
0.0040156962,
-0.0224661697,
-0.0101656755,
-0.0533711985,
-0.0154360738,
0.0216061007,
-0.0469760075,
0.0037755508,
0.0310128778,
-0.0110504795,
0.0332502499,
-0.0702921897,
-0.0324123539,
-0.0027836324,
0.0071986131,
-0.0570841022,
-0.0210246705,
0.0040768427,
0.0084992461,
-0.0157035366,
-0.0365633294,
0.0966515094,
0.0226883292,
0.015248796,
-0.0115180509,
-0.0210440084,
-0.0242945198,
0.0687073395,
0.0167113561,
0.0227706209,
-0.0225123782,
0.0003687917,
-0.0117481053,
0.0144938687,
0.0003748084,
-0.0685366914,
0.0439980403,
-0.0131798983,
0.0291647445,
0.0087234415,
-0.0298081413,
-0.0294114538,
0.020553194,
-0.0007114885,
0.0179056153,
-0.0134325661,
-0.033525873,
-0.0944513157,
0.0451603793,
0.0215135235,
0.0642417967,
-0.0010823316,
-0.0087973205,
-0.0338039026,
0.0283847693,
0.0187587347,
-0.0052340231,
-0.0414341092,
-0.0140448678,
0.0288882721,
0.0451317355,
0.0006184534,
0.0150723429,
-0.0091504445,
0.0028067497,
0.0026722129,
0.0340655744,
0.0010726951,
0.0086195832,
0.0405405909,
-0.0606757589,
-0.0358831361,
0.094332315,
0.0238555074,
-0.0591039397,
-0.0229119156,
-0.011822192,
-0.0074926661,
-0.034935046,
0.0494310446,
-0.0519143865,
-0.0050405995,
-0.025110051,
-0.0230119228,
0.0118678277,
-0.0033889932,
0.0109590003,
-0.0067617968,
0.0921775401,
0.0374386236,
0.0213254672,
-0.0454753563,
-0.0493448265,
-0.0423415042,
-0.0170375984,
-0.0414653569,
-0.0236149207,
0.0291975085,
-0.0222585853,
-0.0114690196,
-0.0483219363,
-0.0673011765,
-0.0187597871,
-0.0300313234,
-0.074196592,
0.047953587,
0.0402635001,
-0.0382627621,
-0.0481616072,
-0.007367468,
0.0196008608,
-0.014675987,
-0.0010709058,
0.141983524,
-0.0168307666,
-0.0339205787,
-0.0558194406,
0.0235250685,
0.0096218614,
-0.0019358036,
-0.0472238101,
0.0749068856,
-0.0296982098,
-0.0239446945,
-0.0503669567,
0.0008437929,
0.0133541105,
0.0289547704,
0.0233394485,
-0.0375961326,
-0.038559705,
-0.0506284982,
0.0755927786,
0.011995947,
-0.039872814,
0.0267088991,
-0.0018838793,
-0.0216193572,
-0.0566901676,
-0.0250262264,
0.0514474623,
0.021889722,
0.0207547583,
0.0308324173,
-0.0334639959,
-0.052693069,
-0.0920051187,
0.069676213,
0.0170708857,
0.0223889742,
-0.006755712,
-0.0248186868,
0.0676434413,
-0.0096308691,
0.0020892248,
0.0522638485,
-0.0253588688,
0.0073895603,
-0.0462574735,
0.035391707,
0.025781244,
-0.0172411669,
-0.0285335239,
-0.0556186847,
0.0862661004,
0.0464138277,
0.0118633714,
-0.0076354467,
0.0021408843,
-0.024653323,
-0.0059278873,
0.0005762762,
-0.0435310751,
-0.0189217795,
0.0039843186,
0.0040390464,
-0.006755007,
-0.0330288447,
0.0147215314,
0.0033052666,
0.0339090265,
-0.012675005,
-0.046725031,
-0.0156045044,
0.0042904676,
-0.0374880582,
-0.024097532,
-0.0471536554,
0.0143823102,
0.0080224723,
0.0213528425,
-0.0128123676,
0.0314362012,
-0.0343138203,
-0.0416457951,
-0.0719122887,
0.0193955228,
0.028265005,
-0.0392259061,
0.05177534,
-0.0011949495,
-0.0106289834,
-0.0343353041,
-0.0086901225,
-0.0153650856,
0.0002565512,
-0.0042456235,
0.0362774916,
0.0291270018,
-0.0174819045,
0.0605384223,
-0.0376027934,
-0.0126111731,
-0.0385446921,
0.0184260737,
0.0683243126,
-0.0165100079,
0.0201659948,
-0.043847274,
-0.0099260528,
-0.0171403755,
0.0582283176,
-0.0274252035,
-0.0144777885,
0.0398035049,
-0.0015259918,
0.0070086014,
-0.0326504372,
0.0536044613,
0.0363650359,
0.0072660572,
-0.0199583322,
-0.0457579046,
-0.0583431311,
-0.021073807,
0.0357226171,
-0.0102730021,
-0.0266503282,
0.0295557864,
-0.0580515862,
-0.0546963885,
0.0295511782,
0.0283805169,
-0.0631383657,
-0.0026905164,
0.0571034625,
0.0400652215,
0.0195822492,
-0.0269357804,
-0.0052164826,
0.0284815393,
-0.0164480731,
-0.0663494617,
0.0227027852,
-6.251776339e-33,
-0.005790717,
-0.0538527109,
0.0482656732,
-0.0122603308,
-0.0010811056,
0.0486109331,
-0.0361457989,
-0.0077517703,
0.0346455611,
0.0620931834,
-0.0204683188,
-0.0373541117,
0.0069651641,
0.0521251112,
-0.042234689,
0.0100994427,
0.0186166316,
-0.0230509378,
-0.0226073004,
0.0246404856,
0.0031163855,
0.0395674407,
0.0227600504,
-0.0713120028,
-0.0427143648,
0.0281924065,
0.0064686313,
-0.0120937657,
0.0096323201,
0.0341609307,
-0.0422869064,
0.0341764204,
-0.0023739217,
0.0243985765,
-0.0206130482,
0.0228948444,
-0.0454850681,
-0.0266201869,
-0.0323208794,
0.027676098,
-0.1127557606,
0.003425797,
0.049394507,
-0.0481043682,
0.0167657416,
-0.0019958462,
0.0567919426,
-0.001420083,
-0.0356796123,
0.0004936226,
-0.0337716341,
0.0485721231,
0.0056775678,
-0.0166148171,
0.0523147844,
-0.0558400117,
0.0090586077,
0.0209529009,
-0.0429997034,
0.0111081693,
0.0518433526,
0.0163271762,
0.0459023565,
-0.0224831849,
-0.0009366392,
0.0785790682,
0.0334765948,
-0.0554922298,
-0.0133334203,
-0.024286937,
-0.0136719719,
0.0485995188,
0.0523240305,
-0.0352643207,
0.0071711936,
0.0118428702,
-0.0728035122,
0.0449863523,
-0.0547939949,
0.049290102,
0.0283016153,
-0.0017143514,
-0.0326813422,
0.0057764119,
-0.0014140527,
-0.0442234501,
-0.0103387749,
-0.0259974804,
0.0415130034,
0.033863876,
0.0167673007,
0.0654702857,
0.0199250542,
0.0087648416,
-0.036848966,
0.0225919746,
0.0248330254,
0.0408255681,
-0.0185690187,
-0.0014898992,
-0.0236494802,
-0.0076211188,
0.0255449302,
0.0289060995,
0.008925681,
0.0132757528,
0.0608512461,
0.0084261671,
-0.0700647682,
0.0150858406,
-0.0160687845,
-0.0097838631,
0.0003913062,
0.0144705949,
0.0421656072,
0.0166450646,
-0.0256954823,
0.0448545143,
-0.0196404848,
-0.0283059739,
-0.0061351163,
-0.0446763709,
-0.0267688781,
0.0219254363,
-0.061066445,
0.0002321681,
-0.0203407034,
0.0307933744,
0.0579474755,
-0.0340721644,
-0.0201374944,
0.0261117462,
2.862e-7,
0.0861606002,
0.0470942035,
0.0280150753,
-0.0002217699,
0.0388097353,
0.0169446692,
-0.0348948352,
-0.0088919569,
-0.0368829556,
-0.0126401791,
0.0246465448,
0.0450037643,
0.0283177141,
-0.0028996763,
-0.0184371565,
0.0698428676,
-0.0495553017,
0.0030082942,
-0.0239190925,
-0.0037855892,
0.0663811117,
0.0709479675,
-0.0348841697,
-0.0269421618,
0.0503684357,
-0.0164521504,
0.0495733991,
-0.0518890396,
0.0520633049,
-0.0160787702,
-0.0396407284,
0.0276428238,
0.0107916771,
0.0594565384,
-0.0036767663,
-0.0018703513,
0.0251262691,
0.0626698658,
-0.0319223925,
0.0163589977,
0.0261761192,
0.0207279958,
0.0216399748,
-0.0526860096,
0.0240156986,
-0.0551843606,
-0.0296135508,
-0.0072300099,
0.0460656062,
0.0121948924,
0.0658575594,
-0.0533666089,
-0.0560678877,
0.0461010635,
0.0239253398,
0.0093983291,
-0.0125381527,
-0.0744750053,
-0.0272441823,
-0.0101440502,
-0.0137081305,
-0.0043730163,
-0.0591922402,
0.0051974691,
0.0307976082,
-0.0197516773,
0.0003954347,
2.930981977e-34,
0.042279426,
0.0155497557,
-0.0085081384,
0.0288876779,
0.0027246599,
-0.0186873656,
0.0403133519,
0.0026620359,
-0.0028880907,
-0.0339215621,
-0.0187425483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19564v1 | Voices Unheard: NLP Resources and Models for Yorùbá Regional Dialects | 2024-06-27T22:38:04 | 2024-06-27T22:38:04 | Orevaoghene Ahia, Anuoluwapo Aremu, Diana Abagyan, Hila Gonen, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Daud Abolade, Noah A. Smith, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Yor\`ub\'a an African language with roughly 47 million speakers encompasses a
continuum with several dialects. Recent efforts to develop NLP technologies for
African languages have focused on their standard dialects, resulting in
disparities for dialects and varieties for which there are little to no
resources or tools. We take steps towards bridging this gap by introducing a
new high-quality parallel text and speech corpus YOR\`ULECT across three
domains and four regional Yor\`ub\'a dialects. To develop this corpus, we
engaged native speakers, travelling to communities where these dialects are
spoken, to collect text and speech data. Using our newly created corpus, we
conducted extensive experiments on (text) machine translation, automatic speech
recognition, and speech-to-text translation. Our results reveal substantial
performance disparities between standard Yor\`ub\'a and the other dialects
across all tasks. However, we also show that with dialect-adaptive finetuning,
we are able to narrow this gap. We believe our dataset and experimental
analysis will contribute greatly to developing NLP tools for Yor\`ub\'a and its
dialects, and potentially for other African languages, by improving our
understanding of existing challenges and offering a high-quality dataset for
further development. We release YOR\`ULECT dataset and models publicly under an
open license. | [
0.0535397828,
0.0620833151,
-0.0203856938,
0.014727056,
-0.0089397011,
0.0247360915,
0.0277566761,
-0.0181334857,
-0.0486669242,
-0.0043856674,
-0.0328586474,
-0.0558512136,
0.1105827764,
-0.0175630189,
0.0231540762,
-0.0727327093,
-0.0078308135,
-0.0392400213,
0.0115962205,
0.0021014989,
0.0154004898,
0.0623420291,
-0.01735425,
0.0468019508,
-0.0238644946,
0.0066312524,
-0.0064221509,
0.0340657681,
0.0131384498,
0.0131178768,
-0.0312740058,
-0.0018772975,
-0.0302660502,
0.038027171,
0.0000019929,
-0.0473792478,
-0.0272724424,
0.0067902883,
-0.0362077765,
0.0072663985,
0.0591880344,
-0.0366492607,
-0.03614299,
0.0386483595,
-0.0375331305,
0.0160039458,
0.0847689956,
-0.0024995937,
0.0408063084,
0.0696850345,
-0.013417759,
-0.0297502261,
0.0256734211,
-0.0517608747,
-0.0716776997,
-0.023941787,
-0.0097823199,
-0.0205640737,
-0.004377766,
-0.0363123119,
-0.0231098887,
0.0284585375,
-0.0307712201,
-0.0162099339,
-0.0532409213,
-0.0457222424,
-0.0495023392,
-0.0678150728,
-0.0215951223,
0.0560210384,
-0.0387976691,
-0.0081883324,
-0.0008708137,
0.0253131669,
-0.036516238,
0.0099577922,
-0.0378343686,
0.0244797822,
-0.0054861032,
0.0276097339,
-0.0026477675,
0.0373271033,
0.0348170176,
-0.0312231258,
-0.0197092332,
0.0326432064,
0.0353287049,
0.0016705712,
0.0125782425,
0.030203566,
-0.029306395,
0.0081207994,
0.0526180938,
-0.0185809135,
0.0004218603,
-0.0297394283,
0.0106975632,
-0.0412652008,
0.0218368415,
-0.0092456024,
0.0782730207,
0.0296901446,
-0.0453411117,
0.0279800333,
-0.0032218418,
0.0185732208,
-0.0120907817,
0.004032624,
-0.0166083407,
-0.0222405884,
-0.0371188335,
0.0011379682,
-0.0363189913,
-0.0150245968,
-0.0677572936,
0.0196486041,
-0.0067941034,
-0.0175331626,
0.001839653,
0.002941807,
0.0496422462,
-0.0453364328,
-0.0413642228,
-0.0524933822,
0.0337189846,
0.018197,
-0.0488069169,
0.0344424248,
-0.0261324216,
-0.1216198206,
0.020331122,
-0.00957633,
0.0017375648,
0.0075388332,
-0.0064921225,
0.0284097847,
0.0213034712,
-0.0347398743,
-0.0743215382,
-0.0181645099,
-0.0426386818,
-0.020831855,
-0.0551535971,
-0.0611706711,
0.0425427146,
0.0020541197,
0.0633391738,
-0.0310680196,
-0.0306897536,
-0.009351992,
0.0408359505,
0.0512410104,
0.0082778037,
0.018992316,
0.0631823763,
-0.0180922933,
0.0615205318,
0.051255621,
0.0336185358,
-0.0179091804,
0.0369561873,
0.0202947408,
-0.0542342216,
0.0484998226,
-0.0043642661,
0.016990453,
-0.0332401656,
-0.005687464,
0.0031721373,
0.0325014628,
0.0240337122,
0.0808834061,
0.0107328482,
-0.015545872,
0.0687723979,
0.0529561192,
0.0011797285,
0.0140911629,
0.0220466498,
0.0261745416,
-0.0219137482,
-0.0140351085,
0.0350629315,
-0.0001400985,
0.0269589312,
-0.0476946719,
0.0801030248,
0.1025870666,
-0.0145449424,
-0.0024680211,
-0.0126958434,
0.0032203924,
-0.0303936005,
-0.0081931716,
0.0166099798,
0.0144665921,
0.0059711779,
-0.0147960838,
0.0535156317,
-0.0489037186,
0.0205041561,
-0.0315219238,
-0.0087490454,
0.0097692898,
0.0244076867,
0.0342441089,
0.0280743502,
-0.0340470411,
0.021764731,
0.0463783704,
0.0654614195,
-0.021092996,
0.063200146,
-0.0645466894,
0.0344955586,
0.0391011983,
-0.0031464158,
0.0279700439,
-0.0178568978,
0.0874606594,
0.0053177099,
-0.0352484882,
-0.0014574934,
0.0269642808,
-0.0331675075,
-0.0033437263,
0.0480985343,
0.0265961252,
0.0583661087,
0.0350376479,
0.0057248636,
0.0135329012,
-0.0337451398,
-0.0412316248,
0.0352299362,
0.0763508081,
-0.0147574525,
-0.0209505986,
0.023961924,
-0.0322906412,
0.0315871537,
0.0134384977,
0.0344684124,
-0.0658613518,
0.0588865913,
-0.0226412918,
0.0224567372,
-0.0227056034,
0.0519432798,
0.0090907197,
0.0348183252,
-0.0279068481,
-0.0228359234,
0.0476212241,
-0.019520821,
0.0226736329,
-0.0288360249,
0.0667546391,
-0.0194472708,
-0.0174467787,
0.0325704217,
-0.011117707,
0.0195744187,
0.0048883273,
-0.0397851206,
-0.0135195218,
-0.0246939324,
-0.069426775,
0.0194746088,
-0.0237620212,
0.0445835665,
0.0078617325,
0.0911450014,
-0.0066844532,
0.0064634904,
-0.0000561197,
0.006317378,
-0.0177723803,
-0.0042624632,
-0.0393925607,
-0.013799428,
0.0092491815,
-0.0468262546,
-0.0051746033,
0.0523234904,
0.0307119954,
0.0103903087,
-0.0098821707,
-0.0264971685,
-0.0712339655,
0.0188172497,
0.0200368091,
0.0039092125,
-0.0318509489,
-0.008130786,
-0.0399038009,
0.0314854123,
0.0118586514,
-0.028270416,
0.0024507977,
0.0091719395,
-0.0152024459,
-0.0286081098,
-0.0128499437,
-0.0340636857,
-0.0216367282,
-0.0192571413,
-0.0145501345,
-0.0084099285,
0.0697373897,
0.0618878603,
0.0071616555,
-0.0507291965,
0.0032164508,
-0.0199756976,
-0.0051547443,
0.0327003449,
0.0289888065,
-0.0051739332,
0.0285389293,
-0.0572866872,
-0.0127534345,
0.0780071914,
-0.0379523598,
-0.0294255279,
0.003473718,
0.021218475,
-0.0400871858,
0.0357931703,
-0.0513284355,
0.0094310474,
-0.0054795835,
-0.0428671315,
-0.0087794485,
0.0593495034,
0.0619434193,
-0.0050737336,
-0.0113549484,
-0.0630044118,
0.0112864105,
-0.0003223265,
-0.0600469708,
0.0340488739,
-0.0308492891,
-0.056442745,
-0.0072872848,
0.0388429537,
-0.0089649465,
-0.0211585294,
0.0411026105,
-0.0111788763,
0.0283760242,
-0.0053377845,
0.0091294181,
0.0048472807,
0.0557705089,
-0.0057581374,
0.0381554253,
0.0137042487,
-0.0174227133,
0.0295225177,
-0.0348621309,
-0.0172554143,
-0.0108920634,
-0.0110896509,
-0.0122125568,
0.0449307114,
-0.0223711729,
-0.0212793853,
-0.0010799721,
0.0531222411,
0.004740031,
-0.0194774754,
0.0652990341,
0.0147906123,
0.000585499,
0.0215908438,
-0.0586478114,
0.0788005739,
-0.0180416573,
-0.0136858514,
-0.069914408,
-0.0480193198,
0.0208583381,
0.0475416034,
0.0215225909,
-0.0140897734,
0.009013515,
-0.0923946947,
0.0041635619,
0.0299419574,
0.0119340448,
-0.0342055149,
-0.0116918767,
-0.0291700475,
-0.0456764996,
0.0005521168,
0.0064410381,
0.0186529569,
-0.013351527,
0.057791613,
0.0055618607,
-0.0716995746,
0.0038423017,
-0.0629871339,
0.0738806352,
0.0458153635,
0.0040292125,
-0.0050525484,
-0.0109724589,
-0.0074094548,
-0.0667377561,
-0.0003012251,
-0.0137627432,
0.0021384116,
0.0482993834,
-0.0513832793,
-0.0133622205,
0.0099754753,
-0.0359067805,
0.039660491,
-0.0121582877,
0.025178019,
-0.0233113132,
0.0119504156,
0.0214749984,
-0.0075873928,
0.0274954271,
0.0175482146,
0.0192955025,
-0.0366764218,
-0.021457646,
-0.0129596936,
0.0003915343,
-0.0589891933,
-0.0226911418,
0.0329447128,
0.0428800099,
-0.0381290168,
-0.0897389948,
-0.0603423901,
0.0361876078,
-0.0023036879,
0.0518399663,
-0.008006718,
0.0329092555,
0.0042677592,
-0.0468621105,
0.0201622769,
-0.0287357718,
0.0374416746,
-0.0611226298,
-0.0000819377,
0.041728925,
-0.0290598609,
0.0238298718,
0.0118772248,
-0.1012831703,
-0.0817383975,
0.0301582776,
0.0053600431,
0.0240889359,
0.0268293489,
-0.0227853972,
-0.0716976672,
-0.0122542251,
-0.0235693008,
-0.0100040054,
-0.0013161169,
0.0205479339,
0.0023768577,
-0.0027913707,
0.0468818657,
0.0254922304,
0.0061631706,
0.005328164,
0.0166847892,
-0.0337360837,
-0.0630047694,
-0.0176890045,
-0.0334399492,
0.0277551562,
-0.0476150699,
-0.0293964706,
-0.0454606377,
-0.0016317917,
0.0426323861,
0.0435801819,
-0.0314089619,
-0.01877537,
0.0652752295,
0.0239002928,
-0.0264545903,
0.0187578071,
-0.0081326477,
-0.0179274194,
-0.0085637001,
0.0546434559,
0.0396153256,
0.0298303198,
0.0305247381,
0.0578441061,
-0.0167878103,
0.0755054206,
-0.0180532411,
0.0568503514,
-0.0396187492,
0.0038312017,
-0.0216495004,
0.0125009082,
0.0235043354,
0.0181895811,
0.0242081638,
0.0169640929,
-0.0389530994,
0.0039602127,
0.0628951564,
0.0078582922,
0.0923982561,
0.017778432,
-0.0055710762,
-0.018067874,
0.0418887399,
-0.0393781103,
0.0007541485,
-0.0100193769,
-0.0162090026,
-0.0109347822,
0.0659448728,
0.0446734652,
-0.0175682064,
0.0029545426,
0.0511865094,
0.0543859862,
0.0031370481,
-0.0289896559,
0.0056704413,
-0.0296950527,
-0.0240411386,
0.0038131746,
-0.0324763618,
-0.0427628607,
0.0137014026,
-0.0000204289,
0.0210238956,
0.0109394453,
0.0014821499,
-0.0050411797,
-0.02046673,
0.0257574823,
-0.0475069433,
-0.0297478214,
-0.0187165365,
-0.0070481575,
0.0173350647,
-6.270140499e-33,
-0.0162440352,
0.0279137511,
-0.0189001635,
-0.0503815003,
-0.0014871523,
-0.0506071858,
-0.033296898,
0.0114854863,
-0.0503428839,
-0.0032500338,
-0.0483457223,
0.001753762,
0.0347783826,
0.0240851138,
0.0442103781,
0.0312186182,
0.0573818311,
0.0039646663,
-0.0330339596,
0.0011523329,
0.0377985872,
0.0369871184,
0.0449093617,
-0.0713075623,
0.0237512048,
-0.0230312087,
-0.0494620278,
-0.0205161404,
0.0031598134,
0.0238395035,
-0.0173948351,
0.0144600216,
0.0062527787,
0.0109681403,
-0.0268097483,
0.0021120172,
-0.0968704522,
0.0232857354,
0.0306232926,
0.0703209862,
-0.0079164878,
-0.0356857851,
0.0327352211,
-0.0181236174,
-0.0223160591,
0.0173759535,
-0.0309843812,
-0.0587412193,
-0.0231165942,
-0.0037263262,
-0.0594795831,
0.0669347569,
-0.0209517442,
-0.0294088237,
0.0656285584,
0.0230528787,
-0.0584620535,
-0.0450440235,
-0.0483895913,
-0.0000336516,
0.0225891974,
0.0618845783,
0.042597618,
0.0240404382,
-0.0705399066,
-0.0172348209,
-0.0108986543,
-0.0395197943,
0.0728535205,
0.0254998207,
0.0261288621,
-0.016774701,
0.0037445331,
0.0620075874,
0.0385800153,
-0.0817918256,
-0.0107652545,
0.0154241463,
0.0413751304,
0.0014124388,
-0.0206777137,
0.0040116692,
-0.0361950994,
-0.0303424802,
-0.0284145288,
-0.045257993,
-0.0264758989,
0.0038337158,
0.0554087125,
-0.0279792957,
0.0089761792,
0.0691983998,
0.0339512751,
0.0147980247,
-0.0199339874,
-0.0375289023,
-0.0144632682,
0.0130742108,
-0.0241560321,
0.0288687572,
-0.0575013272,
-0.0067578666,
0.0021910327,
0.0342899151,
-0.0001787801,
-0.0096448483,
0.0301651619,
0.0183931161,
-0.0758925453,
0.0292746536,
-0.0190512128,
0.046027597,
-0.0198219866,
0.0491551273,
0.0088210395,
-0.0527656563,
0.0188693479,
0.0376497544,
0.0214437004,
-0.0484727211,
0.0153891025,
0.031597469,
0.0119620869,
-0.0261696167,
-0.0450518355,
0.0038663764,
-0.0061860075,
-0.0141870063,
0.0219772886,
-0.0022118527,
0.0094775185,
-0.0046075438,
2.67e-7,
-0.0214892272,
0.0235200133,
0.0569445342,
-0.0485768951,
0.0073229629,
0.0103271175,
-0.0217250399,
-0.0261651669,
0.002363123,
0.0481465943,
0.0060837204,
-0.0231314506,
0.1510314643,
0.009406223,
-0.0974028632,
-0.0293984152,
-0.0250898991,
0.0317191929,
-0.0519883409,
-0.0597339161,
0.0010337828,
0.1426789761,
-0.0288760196,
-0.0175735317,
-0.0512639396,
-0.0378681272,
0.0508854426,
-0.0083321249,
0.0243524145,
-0.0108100828,
0.0121603068,
-0.0044093067,
-0.0481080078,
-0.0291752759,
-0.0498341843,
0.0175649412,
0.0197316557,
0.0821164325,
-0.0174960215,
-0.0124297645,
0.0207751244,
-0.0217710156,
-0.0676857755,
-0.0159192774,
0.0459856279,
-0.0056179361,
-0.0474727415,
0.0020129327,
-0.0174565073,
0.018037796,
-0.0247776564,
-0.0485163517,
0.0146673974,
-0.0046371217,
0.0375795029,
-0.0481498577,
-0.0434219241,
-0.0318712741,
-0.0217161775,
0.0072811111,
-0.016900884,
-0.0034001931,
0.0100045344,
0.0397679731,
-0.0065283077,
-0.0354521573,
0.030878691,
2.176499652e-34,
0.0363077186,
0.0070961462,
0.0426246114,
0.0054340339,
-0.0033850519,
-0.0355896316,
-0.0071913446,
0.0130895292,
-0.0035656202,
-0.0216949005,
-0.0183347035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19552v1 | Rethinking harmless refusals when fine-tuning foundation models | 2024-06-27T22:08:22 | 2024-06-27T22:08:22 | Florin Pop, Judd Rosenblatt, Diogo Schwerz de Lucena, Michael Vaiana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we investigate the degree to which fine-tuning in Large
Language Models (LLMs) effectively mitigates versus merely conceals undesirable
behavior. Through the lens of semi-realistic role-playing exercises designed to
elicit such behaviors, we explore the response dynamics of LLMs post
fine-tuning interventions. Our methodology involves prompting models for
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning and analyzing the coherence between the
reasoning traces and the resultant outputs. Notably, we identify a pervasive
phenomenon we term \emph{reason-based deception}, where models either stop
producing reasoning traces or produce seemingly ethical reasoning traces that
belie the unethical nature of their final outputs. We further examine the
efficacy of response strategies (polite refusal versus explicit rebuttal) in
curbing the occurrence of undesired behavior in subsequent outputs of
multi-turn interactions. Our findings reveal that explicit rebuttals
significantly outperform polite refusals in preventing the continuation of
undesired outputs and nearly eliminate reason-based deception, challenging
current practices in model fine-tuning. Accordingly, the two key contributions
of this paper are (1) defining and studying reason-based deception, a new type
of hidden behavior, and (2) demonstrating that rebuttals provide a more robust
response model to harmful requests than refusals, thereby highlighting the need
to reconsider the response strategies in fine-tuning approaches. | [
0.0883635432,
0.0613142736,
-0.0567947328,
0.0550131127,
-0.0637316257,
-0.0068606166,
0.0097512258,
-0.0116251009,
-0.0339730233,
-0.025131721,
-0.0272520687,
-0.0245698988,
0.0284945536,
0.0339721367,
0.0389863998,
-0.0120988134,
0.0424264222,
-0.019572733,
0.0512382463,
-0.0433707312,
0.0106558967,
0.0124421772,
0.0146834226,
0.0396776088,
0.0179965757,
-0.0164717156,
-0.020047199,
0.0027956793,
0.0029202197,
-0.0285481624,
0.0118931327,
0.0465355068,
0.0318885334,
0.0397967771,
0.0000024425,
-0.0752191842,
-0.0076065552,
0.0120448461,
-0.0624390319,
0.0311521869,
0.0060235308,
0.0008227074,
0.0068290611,
0.0139358696,
-0.038559854,
0.0163032077,
0.0280048195,
0.049002111,
0.0251582824,
0.0491349474,
0.0180826746,
0.0037005332,
-0.020062279,
-0.0200684145,
-0.016887987,
-0.0452417172,
0.0197416246,
0.0054138191,
-0.00397099,
0.0174860395,
-0.0273565222,
-0.0128889596,
0.0015910839,
-0.0198582504,
-0.0559877269,
-0.0082012303,
-0.0072976486,
-0.0395033695,
0.0151863759,
0.0470046587,
0.0272844825,
-0.0153215965,
0.0052563781,
-0.0158051047,
0.0313742198,
0.0383478664,
-0.0144061055,
0.046052441,
0.0126378117,
-0.0363884903,
-0.0063026194,
-0.0069129835,
0.0292042289,
0.0295845456,
0.0398288667,
0.0346879773,
-0.0386357754,
-0.0364614539,
-0.0217465293,
-0.0078275688,
0.0367322564,
-0.0825683996,
-0.0641715229,
0.035059426,
-0.0618853271,
0.0246213954,
0.004166598,
0.0941455364,
0.059049543,
0.0034287416,
0.0094069624,
0.0373846926,
0.0320465676,
0.0279565267,
0.029444648,
0.0055969767,
-0.0495090261,
0.0412007011,
-0.0051687248,
0.0284114797,
-0.0055603473,
-0.0328584611,
-0.0144383162,
0.0256763548,
-0.0182131268,
0.0037448118,
0.0146731287,
-0.007897445,
-0.070808731,
0.0300589614,
-0.055246938,
0.0278786607,
-0.0136876628,
-0.0129684079,
-0.0493695028,
0.0223751869,
-0.0417412072,
0.0363243893,
0.0335985869,
-0.058073882,
-0.0311208665,
-0.054961212,
-0.0174244568,
0.0011412065,
0.0067410939,
0.0471639559,
0.0122597264,
-0.0063018124,
0.005411298,
-0.0476397797,
-0.0160465483,
-0.0856625587,
-0.0036663227,
-0.0391225219,
0.0005513598,
0.0247226674,
-0.0188051276,
-0.020516146,
0.0042798594,
-0.0200980902,
-0.0614615642,
0.0737242773,
0.0241086408,
0.0101861153,
-0.0038125636,
0.0530624762,
-0.0467995517,
0.0619003288,
0.0275290031,
-0.0006086802,
0.0334057473,
-0.0219742153,
0.0451195762,
0.0287574064,
0.0001574795,
0.012601993,
0.0245261416,
0.0177049115,
-0.0142594101,
0.0168620218,
0.0007550936,
0.0127759119,
-0.0401197784,
0.0230698735,
0.075725019,
0.0287311822,
-0.0264388546,
0.0222342648,
0.0186230708,
0.0172554366,
-0.0195429102,
0.045313254,
-0.0525448993,
0.0261833929,
-0.0246077757,
-0.0096911518,
-0.0557690188,
0.0281624477,
-0.0105659142,
-0.00408248,
0.0290933345,
-0.0018875666,
0.0532715246,
0.0502686799,
-0.0116390483,
0.0253820755,
-0.0272731893,
-0.0153281232,
0.0273596589,
-0.0282255746,
-0.0145099824,
-0.070698157,
0.0475241728,
0.0521265045,
0.0601612292,
0.0174353682,
0.026015399,
-0.0380937457,
-0.0043923417,
0.0488231033,
0.0635692626,
-0.0047266153,
-0.0207207315,
-0.0109150419,
-0.0312060956,
-0.0414713845,
0.0173449963,
0.0136039862,
-0.0512738302,
-0.0220628548,
-0.006946262,
0.0187452529,
0.0004514992,
-0.003488068,
-0.0010629662,
-0.0065744771,
-0.0759289414,
0.0249608029,
0.0395059101,
-0.0152193988,
-0.0007552964,
0.00961373,
0.0225483608,
0.0260900054,
0.0124248983,
-0.0030325479,
-0.0430615321,
0.0298872441,
-0.0016865318,
0.0093000056,
-0.0102233747,
-0.0191201214,
0.0056499043,
0.0145280976,
0.0434112698,
-0.0014188573,
0.0348934084,
0.005466057,
0.0189243741,
-0.0680453703,
0.0052475901,
-0.0152900973,
-0.0117149446,
-0.0078063481,
0.0080335457,
0.0038804784,
-0.0200250726,
-0.0090439897,
-0.0237379503,
0.0180885084,
0.0683059841,
-0.002750695,
0.0104907313,
0.0435865708,
0.0018338735,
-0.0293798726,
-0.0294733364,
-0.0434849635,
-0.0555319898,
0.009609716,
-0.0376345702,
0.0212691147,
-0.0238917191,
-0.0015729109,
0.0554554947,
0.0085718837,
-0.0143846981,
0.0421685502,
0.0338785574,
-0.0023704155,
-0.0096985754,
-0.0648444444,
-0.0065852902,
0.0222000889,
-0.0145913819,
0.0334986709,
-0.0116392747,
0.0280827824,
-0.0318743996,
-0.028297225,
-0.0479740985,
0.025306277,
-0.0229746513,
-0.0607843101,
0.0437379517,
0.0373733044,
-0.0273353942,
0.0492882691,
0.0339339897,
0.0449760035,
0.0674916655,
-0.0043684831,
-0.0761716142,
0.0089794043,
0.016603075,
-0.0085809631,
-0.0551915541,
-0.0677805543,
-0.0260286983,
0.0521893725,
0.0222239867,
0.0275069084,
-0.0567836873,
0.0754768997,
-0.0258056447,
-0.0593452863,
0.0331631452,
-0.0817191079,
-0.0395848081,
0.055120077,
-0.0015436147,
-0.0285174251,
0.0721112266,
-0.024803631,
-0.0127465306,
0.0317166001,
0.0398642272,
0.0127548017,
0.0892739519,
-0.0175323617,
0.0059012389,
0.0926455259,
0.0372338369,
-0.0583074838,
-0.0816793144,
0.0744098574,
-0.0453732908,
0.0218625721,
-0.0495216027,
-0.0105941463,
0.0157182384,
-0.0150335263,
-0.0288532525,
-0.0471872464,
-0.0294664763,
-0.0043016565,
0.0132484194,
-0.0079819383,
-0.0073740389,
-0.0351994485,
0.0569859296,
0.0139506469,
-0.0122145507,
-0.0026584852,
-0.0151151698,
-0.0355807841,
0.0352027677,
0.0265642218,
0.0779986382,
-0.0179722123,
0.0559275933,
0.0157824829,
-0.0414683893,
0.006110861,
0.0342635848,
0.0038615009,
0.0173966382,
0.0635606572,
-0.0091142356,
0.0515788123,
0.0369718187,
-0.0268138684,
-0.0519180857,
0.063348338,
0.0044577532,
-0.0069244006,
0.0507337339,
-0.0379792266,
0.0642133206,
0.0376819149,
-0.014224045,
-0.070714809,
0.0029859622,
0.0217852835,
0.0071408176,
-0.0815128163,
-0.0438873507,
-0.031069098,
-0.1372417957,
0.0420251898,
0.0199398585,
0.0101476349,
0.0121652344,
-0.0123042604,
-0.0091345645,
0.0259414148,
0.0266685691,
-0.0012574298,
0.0165219456,
-0.0243184324,
0.0150502324,
-0.0056228363,
-0.0210793875,
0.0292829201,
-0.0287734084,
0.0700569302,
0.0243880805,
0.0208241716,
-0.0028215316,
-0.036901556,
0.0277730748,
-0.0013113637,
-0.0017801531,
0.0157597288,
-0.0040373253,
0.0040353043,
0.0163284782,
-0.0028140654,
-0.0185049903,
0.011826721,
-0.0434035286,
0.044066187,
0.0720413476,
-0.0029789021,
-0.067054905,
0.0004276293,
0.0038162556,
0.0348490588,
0.0474677682,
0.0288205557,
-0.0501067378,
0.0328420103,
-0.036390461,
-0.0355218798,
0.0143770473,
-0.0568346083,
-0.023417389,
0.0533213317,
0.0438129045,
-0.0382202864,
-0.0628168136,
-0.0250148196,
-0.0069734608,
0.0290951934,
-0.0141065577,
0.0250417609,
0.0051826835,
0.0474665165,
-0.0056851683,
-0.0347467847,
0.0416395031,
-0.0289996378,
0.0169467963,
-0.0288262423,
-0.0759560913,
0.0266461298,
-0.0174177531,
0.0147534357,
-0.0450212508,
0.0287470408,
0.069945462,
0.041873116,
0.0544909239,
0.029344013,
-0.0042355633,
-0.0560819283,
-0.0030342392,
-0.0441241711,
0.0425773598,
0.0523121282,
-0.0161343943,
-0.0066358293,
0.0221388862,
-0.0262017269,
0.0060402243,
0.0455361977,
0.0202922411,
-0.0382295772,
-0.0482967943,
0.055414401,
-0.0084027955,
0.0092108678,
-0.0041760392,
0.0104966937,
-0.0154463267,
0.000610977,
-0.0281878076,
-0.0359213166,
-0.0288972147,
-0.0589429177,
0.0199532639,
0.0174186416,
0.0193553288,
-0.031555444,
-0.0332189389,
0.0129774781,
0.0049588555,
0.0225831922,
-0.0129936067,
0.0303501319,
0.0161469281,
0.0003914005,
-0.0148885082,
0.0506736562,
-0.0161320735,
0.0290936846,
0.0302020907,
0.1066502035,
0.0386365168,
-0.025511397,
-0.0357579477,
0.030241603,
-0.0261914339,
-0.0787207708,
0.0504589118,
-0.0171129033,
-0.0310088377,
-0.0388802998,
0.0267007854,
-0.0262845531,
0.0128324023,
0.0105498796,
0.0152861439,
0.021192776,
-0.0747988969,
0.0461059548,
0.0218269452,
-0.0319573469,
0.0088139242,
0.0219385065,
-0.0356510952,
0.04951692,
-0.0261247866,
0.0177325904,
-0.0137388501,
-0.0644809157,
-0.006491248,
-0.0041327025,
0.0010296169,
0.002395289,
-0.1400558054,
-0.0602420345,
-0.0746106654,
-0.0076194745,
0.027186906,
-0.0872494355,
-0.0186650008,
0.0417091139,
0.0072854911,
-0.0025641059,
-0.0308095049,
-0.0023102106,
0.0188918542,
0.0157320257,
-0.0318607129,
-6.656679776e-33,
0.0129660685,
-0.0440183431,
-0.002960904,
-0.0064050029,
-0.0231502075,
-0.012897986,
-0.0257948004,
0.0174634326,
-0.0600446574,
0.0030431878,
-0.0410620049,
-0.0188205056,
0.0010287514,
-0.0232946705,
-0.0046885968,
-0.0078979461,
0.0247834772,
-0.0102828834,
-0.0658167228,
-0.0111836651,
0.0038193818,
-0.0262008365,
0.016006086,
-0.0859633014,
0.0606294051,
-0.0201363694,
-0.0638519228,
0.0173334628,
-0.0906548128,
0.0035544445,
0.0152634149,
-0.0003626792,
-0.004323625,
-0.0416225754,
0.0235926826,
0.029936742,
0.0028163386,
0.0031010287,
0.0889786929,
-0.0387089811,
-0.004035979,
-0.0226921886,
-0.0124737015,
-0.0027323705,
-0.0398332626,
-0.002849957,
-0.0145800011,
-0.0098052993,
-0.0014194336,
0.0350091718,
-0.0938798189,
-0.0390622951,
-0.0402296595,
-0.0524835363,
-0.0336106569,
0.0376690887,
-0.022345107,
-0.013049365,
-0.058808919,
0.0339311808,
0.0251978859,
-0.0357151553,
0.0376771726,
0.0184195861,
0.0277298503,
0.0654724613,
0.007233636,
0.0914721116,
-0.0097115096,
-0.0429491028,
0.0262627061,
0.0273118932,
0.0567411557,
0.0529922694,
-0.0014334876,
-0.0542702675,
-0.0284496117,
-0.0515637845,
0.0133983362,
0.0501186997,
0.0406485088,
-0.0107953474,
-0.0190073885,
-0.0585904568,
-0.0423300043,
-0.0250802897,
-0.0152350711,
-0.0184684489,
0.0171649028,
0.0161083993,
-0.0248511303,
-0.0291753262,
0.0301513467,
-0.0495217443,
-0.0469236746,
0.0181497261,
0.0212207176,
-0.0075019086,
0.0127511704,
0.0078193732,
-0.0399246626,
-0.0291037038,
-0.020823352,
-0.0054203793,
0.0416417979,
0.0403768234,
0.02938026,
0.0225539915,
-0.0041637295,
0.0054445416,
-0.0320969261,
0.0542776957,
-0.0099627292,
-0.0239321049,
0.0119578037,
0.0032011406,
-0.0247909669,
-0.0144390371,
0.0208096486,
-0.0436378308,
-0.0807827935,
0.0797612295,
-0.0263579469,
0.0363549478,
-0.0250902213,
-0.0078602489,
-0.033261653,
0.0305880792,
0.079294309,
-0.0324077681,
-0.0321441554,
-0.0365975313,
3.198e-7,
-0.0408573672,
0.0273129046,
-0.0352235548,
0.0353540294,
0.0255529024,
0.0957588181,
-0.009901423,
0.0226134621,
0.0579982251,
-0.0528505035,
0.0144885955,
-0.0047036926,
0.0268311277,
0.0230268054,
-0.0355753414,
0.0176178254,
-0.0598496981,
-0.022404274,
0.0059304796,
-0.0032169009,
0.0036563873,
0.0430779904,
0.0357072689,
-0.0016386281,
-0.0222476553,
0.0084687928,
0.0299899243,
-0.0661379173,
0.0312697291,
0.0027406244,
-0.0357920788,
-0.051205188,
0.0223446935,
0.0296670832,
0.0192244407,
0.0317797549,
-0.066248253,
0.0207543261,
-0.0153108006,
-0.0088813445,
-0.0260622688,
-0.0392668098,
-0.0066701751,
-0.0966465399,
0.0269578192,
-0.0491389409,
-0.0091309343,
0.0123692956,
0.0038914464,
-0.0358141996,
-0.0008684453,
-0.0041066264,
-0.0343631692,
0.0196152385,
-0.0064484086,
0.0376689285,
0.0359336548,
-0.0306783766,
-0.0265332125,
-0.0039244392,
-0.0041896426,
-0.0677201301,
0.0183821488,
-0.0033848227,
-0.0017589008,
-0.0530171581,
0.0323387794,
2.955991537e-34,
0.0043641026,
-0.0058907582,
0.0613313839,
0.019743979,
0.0838938802,
0.0271807648,
0.0236979462,
0.0178573895,
0.0357552134,
-0.0029133817,
-0.0380026214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19545v1 | Leveraging Machine-Generated Rationales to Facilitate Social Meaning Detection in Conversations | 2024-06-27T21:47:42 | 2024-06-27T21:47:42 | Ritam Dutt, Zhen Wu, Kelly Shi, Divyanshu Sheth, Prakhar Gupta, Carolyn Penstein Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present a generalizable classification approach that leverages Large
Language Models (LLMs) to facilitate the detection of implicitly encoded social
meaning in conversations. We design a multi-faceted prompt to extract a textual
explanation of the reasoning that connects visible cues to underlying social
meanings. These extracted explanations or rationales serve as augmentations to
the conversational text to facilitate dialogue understanding and transfer. Our
empirical results over 2,340 experimental settings demonstrate the significant
positive impact of adding these rationales. Our findings hold true for
in-domain classification, zero-shot, and few-shot domain transfer for two
different social meaning detection tasks, each spanning two different corpora. | [
0.0377580598,
0.0394611955,
-0.0210264437,
0.0649315715,
-0.0123699475,
0.0193531699,
0.0153477741,
0.0114034843,
0.0087628234,
-0.0275283288,
-0.0168029461,
-0.0159518514,
0.0206274316,
0.0557514988,
-0.0014659601,
-0.0555268005,
0.0181496721,
-0.014439296,
0.0584865883,
0.0060253642,
-0.0055721719,
0.0434147306,
0.007696318,
0.0539493859,
-0.0047731288,
0.0047639497,
-0.0208442155,
0.0180069096,
0.034190543,
-0.0209190119,
-0.0339248963,
0.0087347953,
0.0747293904,
0.0169764962,
0.000001701,
-0.070973523,
-0.0090151327,
-0.0271237716,
-0.068067871,
-0.0223373361,
0.0299976524,
-0.0162429772,
0.0078350417,
0.0018392963,
-0.0563731901,
0.0511096269,
0.0325079709,
0.0553415231,
0.0434998386,
0.0429783165,
-0.0309627019,
-0.0338169709,
-0.0312273819,
-0.0236107074,
-0.0187302101,
-0.0719459876,
0.017613316,
0.0419308841,
-0.0332107954,
0.032683935,
0.008037732,
0.0119339516,
-0.0052383076,
-0.0942278057,
0.0304782502,
0.0102568101,
0.0071222442,
-0.0284220204,
0.0169211216,
0.0915624946,
0.0367867276,
0.0159969535,
0.0013907622,
-0.0130114378,
0.0198590793,
0.0121183554,
-0.0572905391,
0.0179492701,
0.0268721618,
0.0339606702,
0.0314369835,
0.019482635,
0.0288086105,
0.053805504,
-0.022488663,
0.0529462583,
-0.0131230876,
0.0304334536,
0.0311125815,
0.0184216965,
-0.0244844295,
-0.0634140149,
0.0120901847,
0.073194325,
-0.0208339617,
0.0427934267,
-0.0200444032,
0.0254850704,
-0.0041309036,
-0.0136568397,
0.0123241637,
0.0322280899,
0.0013060317,
0.082370162,
-0.0189657658,
0.016761886,
-0.0106362179,
-0.0003300463,
-0.008673328,
-0.0557803176,
-0.0533507057,
-0.019654138,
-0.0222672224,
0.0149130309,
-0.0649081469,
-0.0267627258,
-0.0122427307,
0.0388924479,
-0.0002590698,
-0.0115780579,
0.0005398274,
0.0004009934,
-0.0217700936,
-0.024048334,
-0.0195079446,
0.0404343754,
-0.0424630046,
0.0247691087,
0.001840494,
-0.0671309084,
-0.0469112284,
0.0232413262,
0.0412039645,
-0.0245852675,
-0.0282489937,
0.0498349331,
-0.0211330391,
-0.0414333232,
-0.0430036895,
-0.0344598442,
-0.0491177402,
-0.0342079289,
-0.0313299187,
0.0234858803,
0.0052233008,
-0.001598719,
-0.0001217957,
-0.0474959463,
0.0233668052,
-0.0282334145,
-0.0208659917,
0.0443817563,
-0.0224624984,
0.0303575359,
0.0209820196,
0.0391526148,
-0.0471500903,
0.0497190394,
0.0223949123,
0.0293237325,
0.0475522615,
-0.0363150872,
-0.0048862523,
-0.0072854245,
-0.000009712,
0.0143634574,
-0.0203150138,
0.0005584442,
-0.0189897269,
0.0342991725,
0.0229536928,
0.02272995,
-0.0261937696,
-0.0173258968,
0.0576237477,
0.1012927964,
0.0165777039,
0.013746798,
0.0215271227,
0.0393044055,
-0.0220490322,
-0.0130770355,
-0.0281692687,
0.0426606238,
-0.0487907603,
-0.0569513552,
0.00179219,
-0.0020515376,
-0.0095239123,
-0.0267825648,
0.0106550995,
-0.0241868645,
0.036532376,
0.0011214206,
0.051236026,
0.0057581984,
-0.0302731842,
0.0082372883,
0.0297012273,
-0.0527943745,
0.0039777867,
-0.0627070367,
0.0639424771,
0.0724365264,
-0.02016096,
-0.0009481288,
-0.0158168301,
-0.0345813744,
0.0499632694,
0.0430291519,
0.0490765236,
-0.0274541564,
0.0622472428,
-0.0504206568,
-0.0132538239,
-0.0339605287,
-0.0033025017,
0.0059350324,
-0.0067114877,
0.0288280603,
0.039055571,
-0.0323052369,
0.0061481828,
0.0222932771,
-0.0419571251,
-0.0176290497,
0.0321150012,
0.0255904999,
0.0151823089,
0.0501683354,
0.0167718753,
-0.0183364898,
-0.0043498492,
-0.0275034811,
-0.0412521139,
0.0603510961,
-0.0934169143,
-0.0235163905,
0.0096675167,
0.0024278595,
-0.0689188465,
-0.0203283932,
-0.0339672193,
-0.0355295911,
0.0398055129,
-0.0264907368,
0.0147814797,
-0.0327944085,
-0.0256073289,
-0.0201640557,
0.0498664491,
0.0084800599,
0.0527000688,
0.0438166484,
-0.0680451915,
0.0359710082,
-0.022754889,
0.0080465255,
-0.0285405498,
0.0486284345,
0.0172360633,
0.0062517999,
-0.0394620895,
-0.015558132,
-0.0201882962,
-0.0569922887,
-0.0135866432,
-0.0624733008,
-0.0073167216,
-0.0089869294,
3.31e-7,
0.0300623327,
0.0231688321,
0.0169426855,
-0.0043856748,
-0.0499108844,
0.0404390171,
-0.0204232559,
0.0001268381,
0.0362254567,
-0.0123737538,
0.0054355972,
-0.0396717452,
0.0112134647,
-0.0185263027,
0.0906337202,
0.0221709218,
0.0276402757,
-0.0619951971,
0.0157242082,
-0.0380855538,
-0.0073814136,
-0.0166768283,
-0.0339991413,
0.0191478413,
-0.0117690889,
0.0146487486,
0.0907960534,
0.0513837636,
0.0606373921,
0.0164330583,
-0.0381983407,
-0.0803464651,
-0.019223908,
-0.0073712599,
0.0213788226,
-0.0420794562,
-0.0468699224,
-0.0169693939,
0.0475735702,
-0.014784202,
0.0141483592,
-0.0763800517,
0.0311135687,
0.0082767243,
-0.0429919437,
-0.0431700274,
-0.0521468781,
0.0034744304,
0.0568615161,
0.0016030356,
-0.0202652775,
0.0770722628,
-0.0233191624,
-0.0425675996,
0.009976577,
-0.0644229949,
-0.0441821031,
0.0899807066,
-0.0695959926,
-0.0019611286,
0.0207928959,
-0.0380000733,
-0.0050807404,
-0.0628346428,
0.0175359696,
-0.0204290394,
0.0581922345,
-0.0712215677,
-0.0181016363,
0.012008084,
0.0069333948,
-0.0207111891,
-0.0662319288,
-0.0555802733,
-0.0066872854,
-0.0511204563,
-0.0199651942,
0.0343096294,
0.0095436871,
0.0157076921,
-0.0194974374,
-0.0065469192,
-0.0064373966,
-0.0028216655,
0.0078511257,
0.0455522686,
0.0488089398,
0.0135885132,
-0.0098093897,
0.0909265578,
0.0127310557,
-0.033266373,
-0.0310203731,
-0.0471654162,
0.0116162831,
0.0024370381,
0.0272105616,
-0.0304937009,
-0.0310104527,
0.1118189394,
-0.0374921858,
0.0271608047,
0.1406316757,
0.0041574212,
-0.0312793925,
0.002166661,
-0.0673452988,
0.0104521783,
0.0269281901,
-0.0042954129,
-0.0466354862,
-0.0666441023,
0.0160145648,
0.0078863166,
0.0106933462,
-0.0479208343,
-0.0188780706,
-0.1133220494,
0.0245854612,
-0.0178647842,
-0.0167408381,
-0.0060160598,
-0.0373687074,
0.0352847464,
-0.0150289275,
-0.0042415522,
-0.0500623845,
0.0095926328,
-0.0051136957,
0.0092976913,
-0.0006334433,
-0.0331721641,
0.0512470081,
0.004610125,
0.040321216,
0.0211661998,
0.0792083815,
0.0201735739,
-0.0339654461,
0.0332617722,
-0.0044524972,
0.0091417683,
-0.0182874631,
0.0573461428,
0.0008945434,
0.0052606664,
-0.0183292646,
0.0451424308,
-0.0292085372,
-0.0259420015,
0.0026381887,
0.0432846472,
-0.0027767308,
-0.0304628294,
0.0191461109,
0.0279907882,
0.0277480278,
0.0745949,
0.0591723807,
-0.0225412548,
0.01737413,
-0.0098837139,
-0.0175702237,
-0.0364551507,
-0.0305164661,
-0.0086387377,
-0.0112519404,
-0.0336397141,
-0.0421365798,
-0.0248256586,
0.0180452894,
0.0174306463,
0.014054236,
-0.0386398099,
0.0016351356,
0.0008410972,
-0.0100640394,
0.0364335477,
-0.0462391861,
0.031800583,
0.0409478731,
0.021285478,
0.0099672731,
-0.0601609088,
0.003543302,
0.0020892636,
-0.002621612,
-0.0630340055,
-0.0329676569,
0.0162761472,
0.024823077,
0.0524592698,
-0.0097819511,
-0.0248087794,
-0.0088977413,
-0.0363951996,
0.0032380263,
0.0012343661,
0.0722121894,
0.0234531891,
0.0119569357,
0.0510664061,
-0.014071472,
0.0182944033,
-0.0036753593,
0.023028357,
-0.0388152115,
-0.0483463481,
-0.0126423705,
-0.0160474274,
0.0260020662,
0.0277347416,
-0.041552864,
-0.0288487244,
-0.0082905544,
-0.0412322283,
0.0008974649,
-0.0504298583,
-0.0038642155,
0.0213178992,
-0.0453734994,
-0.0007128622,
-0.0475180149,
-0.0403319336,
0.0293242224,
0.0089483,
0.0171702765,
0.0130695477,
0.0143294996,
-0.0039327112,
0.0075199264,
-0.015330147,
0.0092032291,
-0.0089845704,
0.0184129886,
-0.0080333762,
0.0775541589,
0.0191075858,
-0.0249882955,
0.0410193987,
0.0098518776,
-0.0460943803,
-0.0505726002,
0.0550215803,
-0.0008625474,
0.0132126948,
-0.0189600401,
0.0808468983,
0.0083581572,
0.0310025383,
0.0130519746,
0.1009316966,
-0.0058665839,
-0.049791988,
0.0112071391,
0.0007129281,
-0.0364467874,
0.0196255874,
0.0485923067,
-0.0765970424,
0.0312167183,
0.0237728916,
-0.013502256,
-0.0182178877,
0.0003014921,
0.0450324677,
0.0160863008,
0.0043020444,
0.0071229073,
-0.046897281,
-0.0579698235,
-0.0036898421,
-0.0445152782,
0.0028109739,
-0.0039174701,
0.0084450636,
0.0706615821,
-0.0131949279,
-0.0213018116,
-0.0387215875,
0.0463355519,
-0.0417681746,
0.017163109,
-0.0459221266,
-5.945870097e-33,
-0.0202555805,
-0.0629386902,
-0.0204813257,
0.0060543879,
-0.0384394489,
0.0205201209,
-0.0947361365,
-0.0022466537,
-0.015374843,
0.0550241955,
0.0022823401,
0.0625986531,
0.0051438711,
0.0119718937,
-0.0137075111,
-0.0314363651,
0.0304732937,
0.0311663337,
-0.0228044037,
0.031768471,
0.0382389389,
-0.0016190493,
0.0472370908,
-0.0861979723,
0.0334546715,
0.0481727049,
0.0032329645,
0.0466549844,
0.0413278751,
0.0242348388,
-0.0135228969,
0.0462017469,
0.020628782,
-0.0292807147,
0.0028986433,
0.080605574,
-0.0587902963,
-0.0339003131,
0.0501950197,
-0.0194496568,
-0.0434350148,
-0.0594781376,
-0.0029724033,
-0.0152405966,
0.0030974306,
-0.0284583047,
0.0337940156,
-0.0167808644,
0.0053229397,
-0.0013624107,
-0.0499530174,
0.0230486207,
-0.0757426098,
-0.0448184796,
0.0236031935,
0.0253055561,
0.0384845659,
0.0104181226,
0.0074631921,
0.038537804,
-0.0321303904,
-0.0364584886,
0.0265217051,
-0.0134626096,
0.0157232024,
0.0636983439,
-0.0138349561,
0.009905112,
-0.047398638,
-0.030902911,
0.0036279364,
0.0146646714,
0.0501364246,
0.0482931174,
-0.0072075892,
0.0008324462,
-0.0795396343,
0.0125605231,
-0.0056691072,
-0.0001176008,
0.0232057814,
0.0292345788,
0.0128248241,
0.0081240125,
-0.0170638748,
0.0071248468,
-0.0196876302,
-0.0359651074,
0.0023430814,
-0.0245111138,
-0.046351064,
0.0147341657,
0.0494231582,
-0.04538,
0.007606952,
0.0260327011,
0.0066959341,
-0.0155237131,
0.0230378471,
-0.0113922292,
-0.0106462426,
-0.0245207492,
0.0418887362,
0.0133908624,
0.0437060148,
0.0069492469,
0.029948689,
-0.0155360736,
0.0063398075,
-0.0101589989,
-0.0408777595,
0.0020732447,
-0.057014659,
0.0371731594,
0.0111271637,
0.04471099,
-0.0400018506,
0.0249140002,
0.0043480657,
0.0250663776,
-0.0188331641,
-0.0251975674,
0.0262725279,
0.0185148846,
-0.0768672451,
-0.0377585478,
0.0043907147,
-0.0376463309,
0.0463523455,
-0.0217195507,
-0.0321576931,
-0.0415581316,
2.503e-7,
0.0103596784,
0.0560317039,
0.0175308492,
-0.0013689349,
0.005700157,
0.0609744862,
0.0190179124,
0.0146315424,
0.0083944127,
-0.0348173045,
0.0193362217,
0.0412798114,
0.054104358,
0.0197368171,
-0.0473330021,
-0.0265556239,
-0.0244288538,
-0.0429947264,
-0.0058718477,
0.0131167453,
0.1165254638,
0.0341876335,
0.0520140082,
-0.0076108589,
0.0060124532,
-0.0417222977,
0.0406537503,
-0.0510709211,
0.0136148911,
-0.0058653005,
0.0084521687,
-0.0323772952,
0.0114789912,
0.0104951272,
-0.0094897384,
-0.0121326922,
-0.0227319039,
0.0785508156,
-0.0416744761,
-0.0381652564,
-0.0573520362,
0.0060305013,
0.031457305,
-0.0309902318,
0.0565871112,
-0.0563511923,
-0.0833658203,
-0.0318160802,
-0.0225721672,
-0.0609425902,
0.0019718204,
0.018849479,
-0.007868452,
0.0167654343,
0.0107760057,
-0.0003975896,
-0.0002411993,
-0.1006931439,
0.0148476744,
-0.0250930209,
-0.0328806825,
-0.0185587611,
-0.016023552,
-0.0070571215,
0.0406032652,
-0.0442659631,
0.0248127356,
1.747394508e-34,
0.019783929,
0.0255610347,
0.0301639084,
0.0400351398,
0.082183443,
0.03021775,
-0.046582669,
-0.0090611065,
0.0804496631,
-0.0506027192,
0.0129644107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19543v1 | Demarked: A Strategy for Enhanced Abusive Speech Moderation through Counterspeech, Detoxification, and Message Management | 2024-06-27T21:45:33 | 2024-06-27T21:45:33 | Seid Muhie Yimam, Daryna Dementieva, Tim Fischer, Daniil Moskovskiy, Naquee Rizwan, Punyajoy Saha, Sarthak Roy, Martin Semmann, Alexander Panchenko, Chris Biemann, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Despite regulations imposed by nations and social media platforms, such as
recent EU regulations targeting digital violence, abusive content persists as a
significant challenge. Existing approaches primarily rely on binary solutions,
such as outright blocking or banning, yet fail to address the complex nature of
abusive speech. In this work, we propose a more comprehensive approach called
Demarcation scoring abusive speech based on four aspect -- (i) severity scale;
(ii) presence of a target; (iii) context scale; (iv) legal scale -- and
suggesting more options of actions like detoxification, counter speech
generation, blocking, or, as a final measure, human intervention. Through a
thorough analysis of abusive speech regulations across diverse jurisdictions,
platforms, and research papers we highlight the gap in preventing measures and
advocate for tailored proactive steps to combat its multifaceted
manifestations. Our work aims to inform future strategies for effectively
addressing abusive speech online. | [
0.0810907036,
0.0179698858,
-0.0273439921,
-0.0405091085,
-0.019175211,
-0.0075601968,
0.0776432157,
0.0165365338,
0.0109686246,
-0.042560745,
0.0135994824,
-0.0367081985,
-0.0224021487,
0.0577087402,
0.0017822324,
-0.0869085342,
0.0236478355,
0.0260671545,
0.015906496,
0.0303449687,
0.0819730386,
0.0008363592,
-0.0166269168,
0.0216955561,
-0.029060265,
0.0161416885,
0.0669409931,
-0.0350568779,
0.0120673003,
-0.0275487211,
0.0373578854,
0.0049090167,
0.0102820825,
0.0546493493,
0.0000018261,
-0.0726835802,
0.0248423889,
-0.0192881953,
0.0195789877,
-0.0151001569,
0.0399907045,
-0.0638909116,
-0.0139331277,
0.0564032458,
0.0035420966,
0.0014660713,
0.0038932748,
0.0423188023,
0.0802291781,
0.0321494862,
-0.0202901848,
-0.0446563959,
0.0342061818,
0.0184610765,
-0.0472359732,
0.0372231305,
0.0247359015,
-0.020496048,
-0.0274958573,
-0.0353923365,
0.0447202921,
0.0274188053,
0.005872007,
0.0034710299,
-0.0002373562,
-0.0390736572,
-0.0377779827,
-0.0739422143,
0.0204369463,
0.030155044,
-0.0116403298,
-0.0123897651,
0.0030487454,
-0.0097674746,
0.003061346,
0.0069127274,
-0.0291033331,
0.0334982872,
-0.0250162631,
-0.0029391879,
-0.041439686,
0.0822235048,
0.0326523371,
0.0824078843,
0.0404998474,
0.004709098,
-0.0338165201,
-0.0433581248,
-0.0070549399,
-0.0524309911,
-0.0168273523,
0.0230074562,
0.0493082069,
0.0062480611,
-0.036980059,
-0.02498555,
-0.0118348002,
-0.0868695304,
0.0319379233,
-0.0755879357,
-0.0067376993,
0.0334521867,
-0.0227688383,
-0.0301022343,
0.0130422451,
0.0223229583,
0.0096887788,
-0.0164776407,
0.0255411677,
0.0334474109,
-0.0005226783,
0.0412445925,
0.0058024703,
-0.0204005949,
-0.0000054279,
0.0463468805,
-0.0398092233,
-0.0121959411,
-0.0780296698,
-0.0216940641,
-0.0132749658,
0.0064661317,
0.0113039436,
0.0190540198,
0.0135602485,
-0.0035264089,
-0.0575188473,
0.0197764523,
-0.0574718937,
-0.0338323712,
0.0406675301,
0.0081634028,
-0.0257969964,
-0.0080594718,
0.029727323,
0.0867391974,
0.0302859098,
-0.0029752925,
-0.0061267731,
-0.0627233684,
-0.0003422507,
-0.0209520869,
0.0060359966,
-0.0433239825,
0.0025973951,
-0.0254405197,
-0.025502082,
-0.0602427796,
0.0085935565,
-0.0009287333,
-0.0182474442,
0.0218362939,
-0.0339186266,
0.0115319565,
0.0406908169,
0.0441461876,
-0.0113623152,
-0.0092986496,
-0.0034982222,
0.0172777213,
0.0529764034,
-0.0093355477,
0.0193122141,
0.031254448,
0.0223525912,
-0.0081290361,
-0.027235141,
-0.0069888271,
-0.0395298302,
-0.0589218326,
-0.0106843878,
0.0037599632,
-0.0198033117,
-0.0126708364,
0.0709834024,
0.0253074691,
-0.0395430215,
0.0080313561,
0.0064802975,
0.0057706479,
-0.0235502347,
-0.0541755036,
-0.0439740419,
-0.0582157411,
0.0014733792,
-0.0361847915,
0.0312652811,
0.0566932112,
0.0213940013,
-0.0477130972,
-0.0011357074,
0.0116375415,
0.080106467,
-0.0001918878,
0.0039616693,
0.0105645079,
0.0302793197,
0.0037286812,
0.0045853858,
0.0019749978,
0.0180162285,
-0.020682482,
0.0126489978,
0.0310361478,
-0.0023925006,
0.0183278061,
0.0081010507,
-0.0735833645,
-0.0010666366,
0.0332735777,
-0.0457580723,
0.0112249935,
0.0100969924,
-0.0180484578,
-0.0359001197,
0.0270571057,
-0.0192126688,
-0.0496597439,
0.0510489903,
-0.0171974562,
-0.017258551,
0.0622654669,
-0.0294651389,
-0.007704963,
0.0614270344,
-0.0257361382,
-0.0285770502,
0.0122196926,
0.0539900847,
0.0407857336,
-0.0203762185,
-0.030450739,
0.044760678,
-0.0034218801,
-0.0095375748,
-0.0079275472,
-0.0315317921,
0.0722995326,
0.0483353622,
-0.0323657095,
0.0036639022,
0.0333735384,
0.0298042446,
0.0616705082,
0.0627988726,
0.0017027044,
-0.0428181998,
-0.0019160721,
-0.0419715494,
-0.0559562147,
0.0046383953,
0.0231202748,
0.0320382006,
-0.0478658304,
0.0203134064,
0.0349191576,
-0.0718944594,
0.0568667017,
0.0729297549,
-0.0392630696,
-0.0346156396,
-0.0854719207,
0.0317534506,
0.0237840191,
0.0182576645,
-0.0276202746,
0.0372874737,
-0.0216317624,
-0.0156301055,
-0.0048948443,
-0.0092282724,
0.0564919747,
0.0293786898,
-0.0208477434,
0.0054968102,
0.0214056894,
-0.1152715012,
0.031778425,
0.0170278531,
0.0104170879,
-0.0345243402,
-0.0646537095,
0.000745628,
0.0089550065,
-0.0226288568,
-0.001488894,
-0.0186528787,
-0.1090833098,
0.0604193918,
0.0161789954,
-0.0493130274,
0.0156633854,
-0.013097804,
-0.025611531,
0.0458464064,
0.0240531508,
-0.0215844139,
-0.0208801702,
0.0779343769,
0.0538679622,
0.052302558,
0.0317879915,
-0.0150412526,
-0.0175781269,
-0.0064490149,
0.0324980952,
-0.0017480023,
-0.0396345817,
-0.0121957408,
0.0352985859,
0.0413223356,
0.0051828907,
-0.0080268541,
0.0147819705,
-0.0488547385,
-0.0452158675,
-0.0907698125,
-0.0502590612,
-0.0305321775,
0.0149905384,
0.0024962416,
-0.0591772161,
0.0002387972,
0.0323062316,
0.0535896681,
0.0040754261,
-0.05242889,
0.026311243,
0.0297212265,
-0.0170945469,
0.0535763577,
0.0057156798,
-0.0120569803,
0.0774365142,
-0.0537229553,
0.0818558112,
-0.0196159687,
-0.0523472875,
-0.0171000995,
-0.0039440095,
0.0104079135,
-0.03821164,
-0.0163332559,
-0.0495795496,
-0.0114827985,
0.0274638645,
0.0046215784,
0.019841237,
-0.033999905,
0.0313171186,
0.0552323088,
0.0136180539,
0.029363744,
-0.0012188669,
0.0192140881,
-0.0319154337,
-0.0290310662,
0.023613153,
0.029279314,
0.0174027439,
-0.0304792766,
0.0833686963,
-0.0538449362,
-0.0367510617,
0.0536763743,
0.0586187989,
0.0193626694,
0.0165791176,
0.0141878072,
0.0136968596,
0.029085245,
0.0036558888,
0.0054344377,
0.0386354923,
0.0225616172,
0.0125923511,
0.0011113732,
-0.0150322067,
0.0218546893,
0.0107223615,
-0.0401514992,
-0.0849569291,
0.018474767,
-0.0102742901,
0.0352583975,
-0.1012464091,
-0.0165595766,
-0.0305556208,
-0.0105279787,
0.0317835324,
-0.0025761093,
-0.0210453551,
-0.0291784666,
0.0110866288,
-0.0019481712,
0.0170529969,
0.0619020686,
-0.0460259728,
0.0068829027,
-0.0077863396,
0.0099440068,
-0.0761747435,
0.0150917992,
-0.0204407685,
-0.0662624314,
0.0596854873,
-0.0191862937,
0.0426124111,
-0.0217232928,
0.0235346258,
0.0107043777,
-0.0201416425,
-0.0207426511,
-0.0042472943,
0.009296271,
0.0258870404,
-0.0015761449,
-0.043687284,
0.0610053651,
0.0261168927,
-0.0644694641,
0.0020423126,
0.0437601134,
0.0515971221,
-0.0019639577,
-0.0336426497,
0.0429008752,
0.0200435854,
0.0421220362,
0.0216488875,
-0.0418556482,
-0.0039643347,
-0.0746012405,
-0.0120880473,
-0.004577891,
-0.0913882181,
-0.0247596409,
-0.017948417,
-0.0312535726,
-0.0148342755,
0.0286786295,
-0.041226469,
0.0111310724,
0.030475419,
-0.0185780171,
0.017814666,
-0.017148314,
-0.0120407678,
-0.0197723843,
0.0342069231,
0.0635156706,
-0.0369060375,
0.0492078625,
-0.0570555665,
0.0183439683,
-0.0397914127,
0.0474930443,
0.0058617825,
-0.0245825555,
0.0924086794,
0.0346528329,
0.0190563127,
-0.0059170462,
0.0048025646,
-0.0439964421,
0.0368317664,
0.0513893887,
-0.032976713,
-0.0147335138,
0.0897673368,
-0.0045282152,
0.0087490696,
-0.018836081,
0.0209256876,
0.0220992509,
0.0490209945,
-0.0283199642,
-0.0397333391,
0.0262982603,
-0.0147441998,
0.0022787875,
-0.0117145972,
-0.0532689318,
-0.0813847035,
0.0029227932,
-0.049193576,
0.0302570648,
-0.0371531174,
0.0103021506,
0.0287054591,
0.0032544485,
0.0007296905,
-0.0354677029,
0.0572587363,
-0.0594181754,
-0.0132919177,
-0.0736421794,
0.0028373327,
0.0010025623,
0.0085851057,
0.0034712176,
-0.016402293,
0.007848694,
0.055389002,
0.0129751405,
-0.0118873334,
-0.0212834254,
-0.0056363614,
0.0060606892,
0.0283192322,
0.0012382308,
0.0001667056,
-0.0121019753,
0.0034205916,
-0.0152336909,
-0.0226861872,
-0.019353494,
0.0112088919,
0.0534485057,
0.0650352761,
-0.011892044,
0.0322906412,
-0.0220160615,
-0.0654249862,
-0.0516788661,
-0.0272338409,
0.00752716,
-0.026281761,
0.0671185032,
-0.0023589262,
-0.0383083001,
0.0483067594,
0.0603064261,
-0.0545965433,
-0.0057560643,
-0.0180024132,
0.0058640884,
0.0433052331,
-0.0081248768,
0.0007203517,
-0.03874157,
-0.0219109505,
-0.003911349,
-0.0537416004,
0.0319851264,
-0.0269449297,
-0.0172609612,
-0.0035767353,
-0.0037458008,
-0.0262541752,
-0.0298750997,
0.0066922838,
0.0203604661,
-0.0686878189,
-0.0059750248,
-5.195153119e-33,
-0.0010388963,
-0.0112742828,
-0.0249040779,
-0.0255772695,
-0.0158854835,
-0.0487678312,
0.0344117172,
0.0135406209,
-0.0040225205,
0.0297226869,
0.013669135,
-0.0155275743,
0.0027152528,
-0.0113154342,
-0.0386848524,
-0.0305073205,
0.010824495,
-0.0450835973,
-0.0072355405,
0.0301262848,
0.0658538416,
-0.0153115438,
-0.0238087177,
-0.1219715253,
0.0452356301,
0.0294272415,
-0.0644938946,
0.0246294215,
0.0129309483,
0.0693964884,
-0.0278890152,
0.06171358,
0.025156321,
-0.0376899987,
0.0109347971,
0.0846437588,
-0.0472091585,
-0.0043123448,
0.048396986,
-0.0040006358,
0.0478932783,
0.0031334565,
0.0315770581,
0.0049040606,
-0.049897559,
-0.0101506403,
0.0051205736,
-0.0130180065,
-0.0201013051,
-0.0802904293,
-0.0452436768,
0.0018781706,
-0.063502863,
-0.0018660437,
-0.0140376883,
0.0479726531,
0.0092034293,
-0.0071836035,
-0.0789647549,
0.0512253642,
-0.005471346,
-0.0305412691,
-0.0143833207,
-0.0373776816,
0.0003369114,
0.0568792373,
-0.0066077467,
0.0168871544,
-0.0127877947,
0.0142035093,
0.0437458344,
0.0440737307,
0.0241473392,
0.0361658484,
0.0263734143,
-0.087133266,
-0.0636796057,
0.0101876007,
0.0449782722,
0.0288368035,
-0.0082560815,
-0.0216718428,
-0.0247400403,
-0.0537630692,
-0.0139926681,
-0.0851889327,
-0.0204453804,
-0.0071653579,
0.0205917954,
-0.0153591316,
-0.0126814879,
-0.0393531546,
0.0402951278,
-0.0248334631,
-0.0114245079,
0.0235417094,
-0.0091630016,
0.0393706784,
0.0636643246,
-0.005167291,
-0.0126307392,
-0.0314851627,
0.0163353756,
-0.0126181021,
0.0467448793,
-0.0466548987,
0.058425162,
0.0395337753,
-0.0366560929,
0.0057701152,
0.0163269322,
0.0924248919,
-0.0057258741,
0.0716051757,
-0.008769705,
0.0446673222,
0.0061141849,
-0.0265235305,
0.0341576338,
-0.0297976639,
0.0005590231,
0.0164281856,
-0.0182773881,
0.0025858502,
0.0092755016,
0.0143243792,
-0.0335893519,
-0.0051940242,
0.0390487686,
-0.0465142429,
-0.005381864,
-0.0595809743,
2.598e-7,
-0.0187651869,
0.0118596889,
-0.0068531586,
0.0250640605,
0.0353966616,
0.0383674391,
0.0775797591,
0.0155281126,
0.0012862675,
-0.0138862748,
-0.021677861,
0.0006688306,
0.0014530635,
0.0455739722,
0.0045126928,
-0.034299925,
-0.0753992423,
-0.0110913143,
-0.0263059158,
0.0284036156,
-0.0143842073,
0.0359008908,
0.0171063468,
-0.0271823779,
-0.0287413467,
-0.0119319316,
-0.0278918501,
-0.0711002052,
0.0072240154,
-0.0256182849,
0.0604743995,
0.0153372576,
0.0409260876,
-0.0348089002,
0.0101333559,
0.0206375979,
-0.001469981,
0.074318476,
0.0471670292,
0.0402897932,
-0.012274405,
-0.0332479142,
0.0360856988,
-0.0389864258,
0.0384550318,
0.039750021,
-0.025654858,
-0.026192829,
-0.0184597578,
-0.0530771948,
0.0576881655,
-0.0348836109,
-0.0481936075,
-0.0145942597,
0.060657423,
-0.0042553381,
-0.0032668719,
-0.0288517028,
-0.023295505,
-0.0069166874,
0.002948866,
-0.0190445911,
0.0009829036,
-0.0010241243,
-0.0070192888,
0.0275110342,
0.0576307662,
2.187733658e-34,
-0.0005821363,
-0.0265462119,
0.0125249308,
-0.0504472367,
0.0157749914,
0.0107207671,
0.0163934678,
-0.0156703182,
0.0535150841,
0.0007730148,
0.0200166609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19538v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19538v1 | Context Matters: An Empirical Study of the Impact of Contextual Information in Temporal Question Answering Systems | 2024-06-27T21:31:30 | 2024-06-27T21:31:30 | Dan Schumacher, Fatemeh Haji, Tara Grey, Niharika Bandlamudi, Nupoor Karnik, Gagana Uday Kumar, Jason Cho-Yu Chiang, Paul Rad, Nishant Vishwamitra, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with temporal reasoning, crucial
for tasks like historical event analysis and time-sensitive information
retrieval. Despite advancements, state-of-the-art models falter in handling
temporal information, especially when faced with irrelevant or noisy contexts.
This paper addresses this gap by empirically examining the robustness of
temporal question-answering (TQA) systems trained on various context types,
including relevant, irrelevant, slightly altered, and no context. Our findings
indicate that training with a mix of these contexts enhances model robustness
and accuracy. Additionally, we show that the position of context relative to
the question significantly impacts performance, with question-first positioning
yielding better results. We introduce two new context-rich TQA datasets,
ContextAQA and ContextTQE, and provide comprehensive evaluations and guidelines
for training robust TQA models. Our work lays the foundation for developing
reliable and context-aware temporal QA systems, with broader implications for
enhancing LLM robustness against diverse and potentially adversarial
information. | [
0.0437905528,
0.0528091639,
-0.0149567518,
0.0401325636,
-0.0161260702,
-0.006660413,
0.0216991007,
-0.0120365387,
-0.0228239205,
-0.0579785965,
0.0032510862,
-0.0565421171,
-0.0117961122,
0.0133752562,
-0.0144053837,
-0.0501104183,
0.0681111962,
-0.0090121981,
-0.0132533554,
0.01555603,
-0.0026838183,
-0.0058644935,
-0.0123056406,
0.0274889655,
0.0133050643,
-0.0387377255,
-0.0214230698,
-0.0309299603,
0.0449607633,
-0.0214626435,
0.02920454,
0.0334019475,
0.0225022323,
0.0386294425,
0.0000017499,
-0.0144030955,
-0.0069734668,
-0.0205230415,
-0.0329845659,
0.0376481637,
-0.0149573637,
0.0144092981,
0.0120056421,
0.0091305701,
-0.0713632926,
0.0205093883,
-0.0063000452,
0.0276265871,
0.046794273,
0.0569570214,
0.0043056663,
0.0124590928,
0.0173054356,
-0.0230478719,
0.0142747937,
-0.1023910344,
-0.0026044305,
0.0092906449,
0.0250838529,
0.036164429,
-0.0041594403,
0.0261623729,
0.0343092531,
0.0266024377,
-0.0143357515,
0.031286709,
-0.0316645987,
0.0650465712,
-0.0295880008,
0.0674733073,
0.0453704558,
-0.0261189099,
-0.0110639306,
0.0209659562,
-0.0169655196,
-0.0525590889,
-0.0516404137,
-0.022159325,
0.0131749548,
0.0001988563,
-0.0013223507,
0.040707875,
0.0132785859,
0.0427009799,
0.0037861771,
0.0773556456,
0.0039966926,
-0.0281990375,
-0.0778717175,
-0.0209869277,
-0.0113322111,
-0.0413044989,
0.0001235589,
0.0925321132,
-0.010844063,
0.0160521772,
-0.0021241643,
0.0229629017,
0.0267066564,
-0.0444746129,
-0.0670963153,
0.0416658297,
0.0007588298,
0.0642252713,
0.0114041539,
0.0482608974,
-0.0227563698,
-0.0015826666,
-0.0337283835,
-0.0291096978,
-0.029514173,
-0.0184948109,
-0.0102388347,
0.0108541595,
-0.0496399216,
0.0118421195,
-0.0457007661,
0.0660229921,
-0.0088718971,
-0.0218678061,
-0.0253418013,
0.0607468039,
-0.0201558731,
-0.00748744,
-0.032082662,
0.004269043,
-0.065267995,
0.0232677571,
-0.019284239,
-0.0616433807,
-0.0305140037,
-0.0069510522,
0.0179184303,
-0.0591274984,
-0.0215110164,
0.0479464941,
-0.0264670458,
-0.0413431115,
-0.0523318909,
-0.0158023834,
-0.0016821256,
-0.0206876472,
-0.0394477658,
-0.0268321633,
0.0203433856,
-0.0066753123,
-0.020649394,
0.0003495724,
0.002915239,
0.0345622972,
-0.0052195513,
0.0786193162,
0.0378718041,
0.0006658476,
0.0261902791,
0.0176485535,
0.0421368293,
0.0410191081,
0.0294650644,
-0.0272128936,
0.0560399815,
0.0217822101,
-0.0264288988,
0.008682711,
0.0232907329,
0.0068120332,
-0.0544065535,
0.063405551,
0.0056399899,
0.0153532848,
0.0034673116,
0.0229928829,
-0.0197594799,
-0.0531424694,
0.0325893685,
0.0161383767,
-0.016338991,
-0.0188535191,
0.0446193218,
-0.0274640471,
0.0053895842,
-0.0154494736,
-0.053523872,
0.0134402821,
-0.0521289185,
0.0169381555,
-0.0189822037,
0.0072870874,
-0.0498223007,
-0.0283502471,
-0.026120523,
0.0076755513,
0.0054371622,
0.0356048308,
0.019310711,
0.0061169523,
-0.0375601016,
0.0342920497,
-0.0101599544,
0.0163343847,
-0.0191854164,
-0.0114488127,
0.0454695188,
0.0695065111,
0.0439366624,
-0.0600212067,
-0.0462112315,
-0.0155845517,
0.0549248755,
-0.0056239786,
0.0520275049,
-0.0442778021,
0.0356456824,
-0.0105188973,
-0.0253750887,
-0.0242876131,
0.0105932485,
0.01007077,
0.0779320747,
0.0509854332,
0.0048003034,
-0.042305287,
0.0492823012,
0.03444295,
-0.0158622731,
-0.0696186721,
-0.0100917807,
0.011469081,
0.0084869266,
0.0230263304,
0.0043557142,
0.0068771178,
0.0504711643,
-0.0137923397,
-0.0007911613,
0.035733901,
-0.0668772832,
-0.0660647154,
0.0444730669,
0.0551471598,
-0.0586986654,
0.0369827822,
-0.0432529822,
-0.0177824497,
0.0396714434,
0.0105080847,
0.0252509806,
-0.0380325653,
-0.012565136,
0.0151487049,
0.020620333,
-0.0626123324,
0.0759371594,
-0.0204307772,
0.0116797118,
0.0277620014,
0.0647960901,
0.0099088773,
-0.0505560972,
-0.0140562644,
0.0000811814,
0.0030745401,
-0.0141965644,
0.0020885686,
-0.005833928,
-0.0600017346,
0.0210220646,
-0.0999262556,
0.0208066441,
-0.033548452,
0.029837681,
0.0233478919,
0.0118746804,
-0.0047245058,
-0.0503280014,
-0.0269969739,
-0.0273491405,
0.0030324841,
0.0307065658,
0.0495348312,
0.0506753586,
0.0012495518,
-0.0637722015,
-0.0301188566,
-0.0384599492,
0.0717419833,
-0.0097761936,
-0.0108003886,
0.0024006621,
-0.0145351095,
-0.0287279431,
0.0621989071,
-0.0241914932,
0.006423655,
0.0218262747,
-0.0110733556,
0.0107359057,
0.0683463812,
0.0297616012,
0.0365708023,
0.0415382683,
0.0043920907,
-0.0405876301,
0.0621438585,
-0.0260930452,
-0.0011803716,
-0.0149401594,
-0.0185675882,
-0.0216689855,
0.0528543368,
-0.0020755918,
0.0110393232,
-0.0376105011,
0.0295247845,
-0.0119670043,
-0.0035805486,
-0.0633874014,
0.0174750555,
-0.0461311787,
0.0290574729,
-0.0358147062,
-0.012736178,
0.064432852,
0.0182344224,
0.0035914439,
-0.0022600042,
-0.0382382199,
-0.0646295473,
0.0880570933,
-0.029786475,
-0.0153095527,
-0.0100147976,
-0.0233637784,
-0.0581185855,
-0.0442848764,
0.0133444229,
-0.0344083495,
0.005533387,
-0.0344258882,
0.0180387255,
-0.0080367979,
-0.026976971,
-0.0787488893,
-0.0719032437,
-0.030880332,
0.015775023,
-0.0752906576,
0.0196138471,
-0.006781748,
0.0218876321,
-0.0283901356,
0.0340508111,
-0.0312808305,
-0.0208517276,
-0.0010798734,
0.1113969386,
0.0806174502,
0.0497648381,
0.0212121848,
0.0025006493,
0.0326209888,
0.0348148979,
0.09081278,
-0.0433355793,
-0.0390826799,
-0.0001003847,
0.0047163879,
-0.0364717916,
0.0085097291,
0.0205628984,
0.0372833386,
-0.051531788,
-0.0297793318,
0.1033854187,
0.0640237257,
0.0073189116,
0.0059072035,
-0.0114889098,
-0.0011615216,
0.023546556,
0.0268268734,
-0.0828660056,
-0.0353986956,
-0.0193557553,
0.0092689022,
-0.0164931882,
-0.0309787001,
-0.0204502791,
-0.0816263929,
-0.0188452248,
-0.026513895,
-0.0520331971,
-0.0066445209,
-0.0105401017,
0.0108581018,
-0.0154995443,
0.0458148196,
0.0264757331,
-0.0115775717,
-0.004994737,
0.012329773,
-0.0055497205,
-0.0487264581,
0.0669360086,
0.0230622552,
0.0519602671,
0.0351106152,
0.0253984481,
-0.0021363683,
-0.0160130542,
0.0407780223,
-0.0460946709,
0.0035091732,
0.0071622613,
0.0139312809,
-0.0299463067,
-0.0122957276,
-0.0105187921,
0.0100606093,
-0.0048754285,
-0.0334323198,
0.0219794922,
0.0777668953,
-0.021123182,
0.018054245,
-0.0280167945,
-0.00701534,
0.0176471658,
0.0599356741,
0.0054499577,
-0.0178362634,
-0.0846702904,
-0.0081519429,
-0.0275609065,
-0.0821647048,
-0.0176596884,
-0.0130404765,
0.0131057492,
0.0278325118,
-0.0815041661,
-0.0681117177,
-0.019889731,
0.0070010363,
-0.0365029722,
0.0086658262,
-0.0435467511,
0.027642997,
-0.0732103214,
0.0535449795,
-0.0095803058,
0.0129799461,
-0.0239580777,
0.0209564008,
0.0174638107,
-0.0105336215,
-0.016776409,
0.0299171992,
-0.0920341089,
-0.037698321,
0.000181931,
0.0028011845,
0.0126484772,
0.0632762238,
-0.0293998905,
-0.0225929413,
0.0376171134,
-0.0026912154,
-0.0133432243,
0.0095602013,
0.0341397561,
0.0286827721,
-0.0082570734,
0.0385464542,
-0.07951314,
-0.003717253,
-0.007966416,
0.0623635389,
-0.0556207746,
-0.0073411283,
0.0106371436,
-0.058945138,
0.0171461906,
0.0335102156,
-0.0237003099,
0.0103544956,
0.0134458235,
-0.0321153104,
0.0058102245,
0.0084717143,
0.0242982712,
0.0015257309,
-0.02044609,
-0.0219986588,
0.000780268,
-0.00703261,
0.0438618585,
-0.0382382274,
0.0067807441,
0.020297002,
-0.0055578989,
-0.0117654586,
0.0013839279,
-0.0295835659,
0.0222571157,
-0.0067799073,
0.0458631292,
0.0038908359,
0.0320626497,
-0.0052368883,
-0.0125232888,
-0.0332567506,
-0.0013425255,
-0.1343859732,
0.028090192,
-0.0006507303,
-0.0103249988,
0.0487963781,
-0.0314642079,
0.0217246916,
0.0041735806,
-0.0174456947,
-0.000487365,
-0.023835618,
0.0423497371,
0.0004889708,
0.0439386591,
0.0470115878,
0.003036079,
0.0697274953,
0.0757045969,
0.0186780244,
0.0552433468,
0.016000323,
-0.026691556,
0.0004121675,
-0.0125776334,
-0.0484962799,
0.0238057617,
-0.0204073694,
0.013350388,
-0.0550541691,
-0.0535306782,
0.0444367081,
0.0000433387,
-0.032236252,
-0.0062906626,
0.0174381025,
0.0384347476,
0.0657924563,
-0.0240345206,
-0.0372525863,
0.0566983297,
0.028126793,
-0.025396606,
-0.0679955855,
-6.258945385e-33,
-0.0087379478,
-0.0398076437,
0.0275387745,
-0.0479238182,
-0.0257411506,
0.0394784547,
-0.0354387537,
-0.0111176418,
-0.0650628731,
-0.0230604485,
-0.0285938364,
0.0607032664,
0.011856663,
0.0038006813,
-0.0002226527,
-0.0527124852,
0.0030980904,
-0.0161830969,
0.0154801728,
0.0081138071,
0.0502073951,
0.0342824981,
0.0181548577,
-0.0283159371,
0.016601406,
-0.0026993335,
0.0219377019,
0.0501731113,
0.0020142992,
0.0923498869,
-0.0244698841,
0.0323523208,
0.0422710925,
-0.0204047263,
0.0127667096,
0.0355108269,
-0.1243404672,
-0.0451890193,
0.0114309499,
0.0118325856,
-0.0291822646,
-0.0391426831,
0.00127474,
-0.0171987042,
0.0050128135,
-0.0218060203,
0.0169223621,
-0.0279839393,
-0.0206442978,
-0.0744245499,
-0.0192978196,
0.040928185,
-0.0308169182,
-0.0087067438,
-0.0132718263,
0.0441426598,
0.0491549857,
0.0339788124,
-0.034041442,
-0.0105945682,
-0.0240741353,
0.0051475554,
0.0234164465,
0.0109949727,
-0.0210287534,
0.0131920483,
-0.0159390699,
0.0203480385,
-0.0286767874,
-0.0096016573,
-0.0176626574,
-0.0141467713,
0.0455881879,
0.0463910401,
-0.0061790035,
-0.0002781554,
-0.0745953768,
0.020147372,
0.0261828713,
0.0154007515,
0.0181165617,
-0.0079380143,
-0.0330591798,
0.023816254,
-0.0102738487,
0.0443699323,
-0.0384361707,
0.0242084302,
0.0546134301,
0.0261500701,
0.0189854912,
0.0160038844,
0.0157129318,
-0.0534449145,
0.0222202018,
0.0693692863,
-0.0280229263,
0.0062578586,
0.0160860382,
0.0637570098,
-0.0088946959,
0.0375293233,
0.0208392181,
-0.0316550918,
-0.0081322854,
-0.0237723142,
0.0185794923,
0.0092541743,
-0.0444297045,
-0.0175616685,
-0.0108595993,
0.0485236943,
-0.0175713152,
-0.0122217918,
0.0333774798,
0.0139474431,
-0.0048230514,
0.0530115515,
0.0229134131,
0.0366428569,
-0.0073183454,
-0.0159689989,
-0.0121029336,
0.030082725,
-0.0239188541,
-0.0188612305,
-0.0050197882,
0.0897429734,
-0.0152035449,
-0.0350343026,
-0.0166767277,
0.0193015505,
2.34e-7,
0.0537326075,
0.010756488,
0.039849624,
0.0372658372,
0.0259923115,
0.0008701351,
0.0175235253,
0.021412747,
-0.0275609624,
0.0318635963,
0.0281676967,
0.0269699246,
0.0301886573,
0.02881529,
-0.0239147376,
-0.0229233578,
-0.0742719695,
-0.0216914732,
-0.0475940816,
-0.0159563422,
0.0517946444,
0.0949933901,
0.018589709,
0.0121906996,
-0.0457981899,
-0.0603527166,
0.055318024,
-0.0047510159,
-0.017446408,
0.0133718988,
0.0271877628,
-0.0033362284,
0.0060642692,
-0.0146373203,
-0.0154695613,
0.0282379743,
-0.0222895946,
0.0670920834,
-0.0115457494,
-0.0971614867,
-0.0336325765,
-0.044863347,
0.0055694659,
-0.0441526659,
0.1254074574,
-0.0476767309,
-0.0054523274,
-0.0100204768,
-0.0249669254,
0.0335605964,
0.0136193288,
0.0157886427,
-0.0260238741,
-0.0040711109,
0.0067724576,
-0.0055585122,
0.0064412248,
-0.1226539984,
-0.0345814638,
0.0441307202,
-0.0303182658,
-0.0013707823,
-0.0036629571,
-0.0321282893,
0.0114646498,
-0.0321211033,
0.0062588798,
1.932901636e-34,
0.0404138044,
0.0060632671,
-0.0077673425,
0.0401500836,
0.0157219097,
-0.0064082737,
0.0193833411,
-0.0400023684,
0.067870535,
-0.0568977147,
-0.0022643914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19537v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19537v1 | Handling Ontology Gaps in Semantic Parsing | 2024-06-27T21:21:22 | 2024-06-27T21:21:22 | Andrea Bacciu, Marco Damonte, Marco Basaldella, Emilio Monti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The majority of Neural Semantic Parsing (NSP) models are developed with the
assumption that there are no concepts outside the ones such models can
represent with their target symbols (closed-world assumption). This assumption
leads to generate hallucinated outputs rather than admitting their lack of
knowledge. Hallucinations can lead to wrong or potentially offensive responses
to users. Hence, a mechanism to prevent this behavior is crucial to build
trusted NSP-based Question Answering agents. To that end, we propose the
Hallucination Simulation Framework (HSF), a general setting for stimulating and
analyzing NSP model hallucinations. The framework can be applied to any NSP
task with a closed-ontology. Using the proposed framework and KQA Pro as the
benchmark dataset, we assess state-of-the-art techniques for hallucination
detection. We then present a novel hallucination detection strategy that
exploits the computational graph of the NSP model to detect the NSP
hallucinations in the presence of ontology gaps, out-of-domain utterances, and
to recognize NSP errors, improving the F1-Score respectively by ~21, ~24% and
~1%. This is the first work in closed-ontology NSP that addresses the problem
of recognizing ontology gaps. We release our code and checkpoints at
https://github.com/amazon-science/handling-ontology-gaps-in-semantic-parsing. | [
0.0284425281,
0.0408518538,
-0.0079243258,
0.0297833662,
-0.0278540533,
0.0090827774,
-0.0315261707,
-0.0003564283,
0.0008329758,
-0.0471570678,
0.0049578594,
0.0215767492,
-0.0187737439,
-0.0156112704,
-0.0193427522,
-0.0428013019,
0.0727093592,
-0.0178648345,
-0.0349636227,
-0.0054721124,
-0.0266915001,
0.0279160086,
-0.0317023173,
0.050115563,
-0.0414992794,
-0.0720096827,
-0.0164932795,
-0.0010944876,
0.0091203721,
-0.0302992128,
0.0263253786,
0.0640556738,
-0.0330391787,
0.0705741644,
0.0000019403,
-0.0629663765,
-0.0024155553,
0.0068797679,
-0.0417614505,
-0.0411948599,
0.0185240079,
0.0193189718,
0.0206112266,
-0.0067156143,
-0.0413707942,
-0.0238545518,
0.0300803967,
0.0908927396,
0.0701852888,
0.0281263441,
0.0081394864,
-0.0295465998,
0.0434659943,
0.0495024137,
0.0475521982,
-0.0320639312,
0.0280079804,
0.002163328,
0.0145306764,
-0.0415914133,
-0.0062376093,
0.0138703389,
0.0320360735,
0.0271693282,
0.0031980511,
0.0075035114,
-0.0740374252,
-0.0401533917,
-0.0319919363,
0.0653257743,
-0.0248742923,
-0.0320357122,
0.0063752271,
0.0006585061,
0.0122511778,
-0.0190507788,
-0.0079784365,
0.0284245461,
-0.052909676,
0.0031303731,
0.0432108082,
0.0279865898,
0.0109339571,
0.0201538857,
0.0073073558,
0.1248080656,
-0.0097526535,
-0.0463595241,
0.0442192033,
0.033083681,
-0.0295817256,
-0.0081294579,
0.0383028649,
0.0198758729,
-0.0667881519,
0.0188341383,
-0.0416662246,
-0.0051579396,
0.0354897529,
-0.0449163653,
-0.0340616778,
0.0176102556,
-0.0574621484,
0.0543938391,
-0.019710172,
0.0088873636,
-0.0141054438,
0.0597619154,
-0.0059505552,
-0.0112998094,
-0.0771562979,
-0.0357092544,
-0.0685551018,
0.0440735631,
-0.0192828029,
-0.0513129309,
0.0169925727,
-0.0005600826,
-0.0643627793,
0.0228543859,
0.0007808058,
0.0549173616,
-0.0000838199,
0.0243250784,
-0.0519583113,
0.0142771574,
-0.0388647467,
-0.027828224,
0.0366404466,
-0.0908479914,
-0.0266819187,
0.0020912541,
-0.0222514607,
-0.0181672331,
-0.0132398494,
0.0682712421,
0.047595989,
0.0191736873,
-0.0254045632,
-0.08107353,
0.0024862203,
-0.0206949301,
0.0210268367,
-0.0521195233,
0.0197871812,
-0.0227501076,
-0.0059439316,
-0.0548844561,
0.0366625078,
0.0473756418,
-0.0245669112,
0.0777462795,
-0.0647280812,
-0.0228699073,
0.0310190022,
0.0235190205,
-0.0355944671,
0.0681064352,
-0.0198589917,
-0.0390137471,
0.0580335781,
0.0270710792,
-0.0127205104,
-0.0280355271,
-0.0027884794,
-0.0349816941,
-0.0311467703,
0.0023409154,
-0.0203411486,
0.048996821,
0.0077186814,
0.0308016464,
-0.0210674219,
-0.0474689454,
-0.0309366863,
0.0427479371,
-0.0290278699,
-0.0008535088,
0.0442478471,
0.0019785247,
0.015115683,
0.0110587403,
-0.0885579288,
0.0244576745,
-0.0169292558,
0.0060913698,
-0.0018067254,
-0.0124884015,
-0.0167440586,
-0.040037781,
-0.0288567469,
0.0252982304,
-0.014777598,
-0.0139991995,
-0.0046276012,
0.047578726,
-0.0351855978,
0.0923988447,
0.0166537017,
0.0037273618,
0.0379075706,
-0.0351206176,
0.000108154,
0.0980224535,
0.0474762321,
-0.0414803028,
-0.0550255589,
-0.0324985422,
-0.0191969369,
0.0813677907,
-0.0114903785,
-0.0207591746,
-0.0067581041,
-0.0292870533,
0.0097806323,
-0.0235548615,
0.0497633964,
-0.0273970366,
0.0093088029,
-0.0033858903,
0.0016464085,
-0.0347720124,
-0.0189796649,
0.0466430262,
0.0118048517,
-0.0003671176,
-0.0469213836,
-0.0191233344,
0.0263143964,
0.010837486,
-0.0028848071,
0.0280917026,
-0.0068247407,
-0.0199431051,
-0.0681314245,
0.0021787677,
-0.0501984134,
-0.0399607196,
0.0246179625,
-0.0172170065,
-0.0360505283,
0.0689574853,
-0.0445792153,
-0.0143484399,
0.0023610785,
-0.0205322485,
0.0263378937,
-0.0523665138,
0.0071192333,
0.0223074909,
0.0192035288,
-0.0238080267,
0.0884625465,
-0.0293683112,
0.0424204394,
-0.0028381345,
0.0104674473,
-0.0060223234,
-0.0266670175,
-0.0182299092,
0.0127610331,
-0.0080915159,
0.0169185158,
-0.0206379797,
-0.0245345607,
-0.0790485218,
0.0219695661,
-0.0411881283,
0.0221830141,
-0.0123473583,
0.0262586586,
0.0568813495,
-0.0125166057,
0.0030767811,
-0.0514526702,
-0.0106838588,
0.0484233946,
0.010600673,
0.0181233175,
0.0385657623,
0.0201953109,
-0.0396914855,
0.0086980173,
0.0032454007,
-0.0532076918,
0.046321284,
-0.0121569308,
-0.0120825553,
-0.0584277883,
0.0367143154,
-0.058584936,
0.0362499431,
0.0454397723,
0.0204146467,
0.0258116554,
0.0037365935,
-0.0275874715,
0.0702496246,
-0.0027693384,
0.0384482257,
0.0375462435,
-0.0197281297,
-0.0324656516,
0.0191757847,
0.0064459797,
0.0172937177,
-0.0242888331,
-0.0016566963,
0.0199099835,
0.0971351713,
-0.000556248,
0.0089078667,
-0.0391281769,
0.0280773826,
-0.0761136338,
-0.0548058748,
-0.010127753,
0.0162910726,
-0.0118441591,
0.0350497179,
-0.0344318226,
0.012967444,
0.1037520692,
0.0189772546,
0.0043398817,
-0.0419853963,
0.0070308,
-0.0211575441,
0.0441713445,
-0.0172708202,
0.0112712765,
0.0145957731,
-0.0742466375,
-0.0241185203,
-0.0294663254,
-0.0261285845,
-0.0199847538,
-0.0122782076,
-0.0184007175,
-0.0172927398,
0.0255144034,
-0.0056439568,
-0.0542637408,
0.0039408859,
-0.0529273748,
0.0172883924,
-0.0561575815,
0.036559619,
-0.0077203214,
-0.0328173079,
-0.0654063821,
0.0251577683,
0.0003259307,
-0.0343129709,
-0.0243708398,
0.0062823961,
0.0715557635,
0.0092842374,
0.0482393019,
0.0012711667,
0.0178065598,
0.0676928461,
0.0211677272,
0.0464527979,
-0.0163683016,
-0.0225285776,
0.0063953078,
-0.0519046113,
-0.0382979438,
0.0084535023,
-0.0067959391,
-0.0547420569,
-0.0392949618,
0.1074747145,
0.0861466751,
0.0173925962,
0.0324417129,
-0.0690864995,
0.0324385576,
0.0111969812,
-0.0016782985,
-0.0800512955,
-0.0406962521,
-0.0155374398,
0.0059060031,
-0.0317813382,
-0.0483983569,
0.0215661954,
-0.0956184119,
0.0275600385,
-0.0156123834,
-0.0405854248,
0.0373825617,
-0.0036997469,
0.0160076506,
-0.0363621786,
0.0357857496,
-0.0073992871,
0.0282681268,
0.0047979862,
0.0053521851,
0.0008918436,
-0.0020415518,
0.0594937839,
-0.0070181764,
0.0567725636,
0.045301035,
0.0117773777,
-0.0201458409,
-0.0744400844,
0.0350135565,
-0.026744999,
0.0155224483,
-0.0207210127,
0.0564075261,
0.0120175593,
0.010210189,
-0.0360847935,
0.0040511726,
-0.0748064518,
-0.0363699086,
-0.0016890411,
0.0889987648,
-0.0427464806,
-0.0332738906,
0.0053327666,
0.0492959656,
-0.01132139,
0.0498392843,
-0.0027851493,
-0.0223704465,
-0.1044291034,
-0.0248753689,
0.0078151915,
-0.0446784273,
-0.0153927794,
0.0818358064,
0.0568445362,
-0.0359186344,
-0.0436514243,
-0.0531612895,
0.0145587362,
0.0113692796,
-0.0362887233,
0.0066628004,
0.0010352781,
0.0090308366,
-0.0015012504,
0.0211567637,
-0.028254509,
0.0004824248,
-0.0037345707,
0.0407677479,
0.0324353352,
0.0275059603,
-0.0310465377,
0.027783934,
-0.0466856435,
-0.0411130749,
0.0581248589,
0.0188387651,
0.0261983406,
0.0344884656,
-0.0471953303,
0.0110389572,
0.0382075123,
0.0640406609,
-0.0418646447,
-0.0089525003,
0.0208294578,
0.0156669654,
0.0090185869,
0.038029857,
-0.0330397598,
-0.0150471944,
-0.0252107196,
0.0581707843,
-0.0016634694,
0.0159696043,
0.0813093334,
0.0003223526,
0.0130680855,
0.0353458785,
0.004243074,
-0.0064437552,
-0.0079518603,
-0.0154862683,
-0.0252094492,
-0.01108154,
0.0115156099,
0.0264970195,
-0.0310702119,
0.0392971039,
-0.0319935866,
-0.037169598,
0.0187851023,
0.0019856573,
-0.0408543572,
0.0805016756,
0.0029184057,
0.0071725179,
-0.0151253426,
-0.0451886207,
-0.0257626381,
-0.0058336803,
0.0531007051,
0.0102100531,
0.0558037497,
0.0169803463,
-0.0217846427,
-0.027399471,
-0.0109212706,
-0.0351968743,
-0.0671040192,
0.0193843488,
0.0119502274,
0.0231842883,
0.0203203876,
0.0362860337,
-0.0187593065,
0.0076196534,
0.0151650123,
-0.004718232,
0.0240235422,
-0.0731151775,
0.0258031003,
0.0326520652,
0.0042126989,
-0.0709759817,
0.0585716031,
-0.0290858317,
0.0395380147,
0.0089843124,
-0.01187596,
-0.0326120593,
-0.0530346446,
-0.0440105908,
0.0226267949,
-0.0349129252,
-0.0011197774,
-0.022897929,
-0.0698596984,
0.0010882361,
0.015259916,
-0.0002902234,
0.0298135541,
0.0305685475,
0.0406072661,
0.00734676,
-0.0773669556,
-0.0239852015,
-0.0065763928,
0.0054933494,
-0.0275405962,
-0.0257780571,
-6.081173538e-33,
-0.0237884931,
-0.0379277468,
0.025614569,
0.0095409583,
-0.0269210953,
-0.0355893075,
-0.0234232116,
0.0074580433,
0.01234922,
0.026879428,
0.0113510098,
0.0258364659,
0.0143912844,
0.0156582501,
0.0358798951,
-0.0671529919,
0.0373996198,
0.0078780837,
0.0072161364,
-0.0030740937,
0.0581049174,
0.0140451314,
0.0119834356,
-0.0329575762,
0.0485454239,
-0.0038592073,
-0.0189692974,
0.0514203981,
-0.0094580557,
0.0415796563,
0.0039616167,
0.0620664097,
0.0202903375,
-0.0344035402,
-0.0147375576,
-0.0220100284,
-0.0729893968,
-0.0525481552,
0.0170315132,
0.059821941,
-0.0845225304,
-0.0351050943,
0.0384217352,
-0.0188103896,
0.0432749428,
-0.0140993157,
0.0304919761,
-0.0155315613,
0.0154899443,
0.0423422828,
-0.0618932582,
0.0023410947,
0.0107603641,
0.0085094776,
-0.0348116308,
0.0522305891,
-0.0100491885,
-0.0647162497,
-0.0636326745,
-0.0137596661,
-0.0246356763,
-0.0256020594,
0.0379737653,
0.010248947,
0.0130852871,
0.0632200763,
0.0496820919,
-0.016733082,
0.0065748417,
0.0207489133,
0.0024758563,
0.0384578146,
0.0068201916,
-0.0172606967,
0.0592257604,
-0.0017266623,
-0.0115155317,
-0.0266636368,
-0.0488927737,
0.0493236594,
0.0234779529,
0.0015430065,
-0.0416261293,
-0.0066600251,
-0.0106247356,
0.024059251,
-0.0421514586,
-0.0630630404,
0.0518838055,
-0.0046890783,
0.0095207524,
0.01996658,
-0.0140579585,
-0.0458323658,
0.0479458831,
-0.0089936368,
0.028479645,
0.0015466976,
-0.0044439752,
0.0369614325,
0.0266348422,
-0.0443755873,
0.019163467,
-0.0474647246,
0.0583428517,
0.0140973339,
0.0128884288,
-0.0160385948,
-0.0369418226,
0.0173598416,
-0.0190764293,
0.0307235122,
0.013616438,
-0.0006359968,
0.0489830449,
0.0039006993,
-0.0444811955,
-0.022443749,
0.0256234463,
0.0122935148,
-0.0057170349,
0.0459159128,
-0.0268115401,
0.0015457254,
-0.0323481075,
-0.0275159664,
-0.0160258319,
-0.0663581789,
-0.0058396687,
-0.0607318357,
-0.0037324452,
-0.0101394271,
2.771e-7,
0.0205696635,
0.0239509251,
0.0224168878,
0.0233995728,
0.0254482385,
-0.0140786069,
0.0559024736,
0.0434283242,
-0.024519112,
-0.0703996867,
-0.0485755652,
0.01375545,
0.0185876098,
0.0808600336,
-0.1135332584,
-0.01793769,
0.0145539716,
-0.0050921272,
-0.0575077832,
-0.0037078259,
0.0551801175,
0.0404562391,
0.0207898393,
-0.0100211836,
-0.0200121421,
-0.0382854156,
0.0096299183,
0.0405521132,
0.0120207015,
0.0173705053,
0.0126807727,
0.0162226409,
0.0506953299,
0.0800538361,
0.0251151305,
-0.0131918406,
0.0419231839,
0.0141428038,
-0.0366590992,
-0.0291851219,
-0.018080866,
-0.0389633141,
0.0353083536,
-0.0583971143,
0.0288924221,
-0.060944166,
-0.0254535545,
0.0128797237,
-0.029475851,
-0.0052367705,
0.0352306999,
0.0009393745,
0.006501691,
-0.0176100917,
0.0195037331,
0.0099466154,
0.0151872737,
-0.0176088177,
0.0013807274,
0.0358065739,
-0.0028153944,
-0.0328004248,
0.0171052571,
0.0117969243,
0.0248458683,
-0.0687975138,
-0.0091080181,
2.352025984e-34,
0.0254342277,
0.0276796184,
0.0515956022,
0.0283122007,
0.0225465633,
0.0222863704,
0.0450141579,
-0.0037824546,
0.0132340007,
-0.0221806914,
-0.0119732451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19526v1 | TocBERT: Medical Document Structure Extraction Using Bidirectional Transformers | 2024-06-27T20:56:57 | 2024-06-27T20:56:57 | Majd Saleh, Sarra Baghdadi, Stéphane Paquelet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Text segmentation holds paramount importance in the field of Natural Language
Processing (NLP). It plays an important role in several NLP downstream tasks
like information retrieval and document summarization. In this work, we propose
a new solution, namely TocBERT, for segmenting texts using bidirectional
transformers. TocBERT represents a supervised solution trained on the detection
of titles and sub-titles from their semantic representations. This task was
formulated as a named entity recognition (NER) problem. The solution has been
applied on a medical text segmentation use-case where the Bio-ClinicalBERT
model is fine-tuned to segment discharge summaries of the MIMIC-III dataset.
The performance of TocBERT has been evaluated on a human-labeled ground truth
corpus of 250 notes. It achieved an F1-score of 84.6% when evaluated on a
linear text segmentation problem and 72.8% on a hierarchical text segmentation
problem. It outperformed a carefully designed rule-based solution, particularly
in distinguishing titles from subtitles. | [
0.0397794694,
-0.0010372571,
0.0382194407,
-0.0026925365,
-0.0322682969,
0.0594208464,
-0.0156416669,
0.0398193784,
0.006784928,
-0.0503558032,
-0.0386423394,
-0.060719952,
-0.0031170524,
0.0029317271,
0.0103812935,
-0.0894993916,
0.030501185,
0.0079789637,
0.0134507576,
0.0236316938,
-0.0023538528,
-0.0103284847,
-0.0469029397,
0.0170434657,
0.0306371991,
0.0177633818,
0.0133940279,
0.0026826044,
0.0379306823,
-0.0816230103,
0.0249841772,
-0.009462256,
-0.0402257368,
0.0013780945,
0.0000019742,
-0.0437300541,
-0.0738925859,
0.0447368436,
-0.0210997444,
-0.0677512586,
0.0770422146,
-0.0603074394,
-0.0219489168,
0.0053686812,
0.0268204473,
-0.0255936217,
-0.0079464372,
0.1112884134,
0.0349004641,
0.069003351,
-0.0284728948,
-0.0557468422,
0.0540622957,
0.000754682,
-0.0359115675,
-0.0118340673,
0.0416013822,
-0.0204825941,
0.0116262771,
-0.0252364669,
0.013637458,
-0.0105983196,
-0.0256682951,
0.0228028167,
0.0255212355,
0.0389895067,
-0.0510388128,
0.0037492414,
0.0070205834,
0.0301039424,
-0.0040307096,
0.0004857885,
0.0781211108,
-0.0098970197,
-0.0485526733,
0.0009634893,
-0.0071055549,
0.0050952779,
-0.0557022616,
-0.0091113234,
0.0516488068,
0.037522044,
-0.0242214128,
-0.030458061,
-0.0322760902,
-0.0064268271,
0.023213286,
-0.0576865934,
0.0076391208,
0.0044138837,
0.0222823881,
-0.0541803613,
0.0764908418,
0.0295527801,
0.0111484611,
0.0118326889,
-0.0165255852,
-0.0897518173,
0.0377792083,
-0.0506658778,
-0.0294226464,
-0.0166816693,
0.012318599,
0.0502344929,
-0.0367862731,
-0.0248270351,
-0.0215590745,
0.0579656586,
-0.030247556,
-0.0143361576,
-0.0147332624,
-0.0148037821,
-0.0281102415,
0.030763898,
-0.0038975575,
0.0108597307,
-0.0457627811,
-0.0195485298,
0.0249003954,
-0.004388819,
0.0269237757,
-0.0228005629,
-0.0138572576,
-0.0062893559,
0.0429090485,
-0.0008553277,
-0.0002143871,
-0.0236954093,
-0.0202612001,
0.0129081393,
0.0056760684,
0.010684072,
0.0268877782,
0.003656633,
0.0455690175,
0.0615674704,
-0.0051567135,
-0.0977565199,
-0.062545687,
-0.0331621543,
-0.0052422052,
0.014967191,
0.0212244168,
-0.0219972823,
-0.0101555316,
0.0015654544,
0.013902816,
0.0115038957,
-0.0060420432,
-0.0073407036,
-0.0236061141,
0.0423627645,
-0.0541092195,
-0.0155995218,
0.036974173,
0.0298878364,
0.0147746857,
0.0074295993,
0.0444309935,
-0.0100818155,
0.0139994929,
0.0372978188,
0.0193997156,
0.0197985154,
-0.0095648421,
-0.0745253861,
0.0388695076,
0.0059704585,
-0.0082146274,
-0.0032330609,
-0.0340520367,
0.0598215312,
0.0200100075,
-0.0019563995,
-0.0062522278,
0.0665177777,
0.0124864876,
0.0050757551,
-0.0124384854,
-0.0188172013,
0.0091894548,
0.0057203919,
0.0281283986,
-0.0348428935,
0.0189790484,
0.026766073,
-0.0227729268,
-0.0177301578,
-0.0229992829,
-0.0119063649,
-0.0071402793,
0.0105873505,
-0.0278840661,
-0.0414823033,
0.0969498307,
0.0091656046,
-0.068760708,
0.0709159374,
0.0261830389,
-0.0466966219,
0.0052675675,
-0.0582305603,
-0.0180425923,
-0.0075913356,
0.0406974927,
-0.0874626487,
-0.0499300994,
-0.0060414644,
-0.0012146747,
0.0199561529,
0.0109262271,
-0.0213753022,
-0.0041287225,
-0.0356442705,
0.0200457461,
0.0476610065,
0.0288362112,
-0.0346257538,
-0.0381151512,
0.0112498337,
-0.006107925,
-0.0354219712,
0.0007446075,
0.0698366389,
-0.0435652249,
-0.0008210269,
-0.0259534065,
0.0086493222,
0.0113437762,
0.0267280899,
0.0012624853,
0.0062523205,
0.0257078931,
-0.0278251842,
-0.0160149932,
-0.0014792342,
-0.0108032161,
-0.0326673016,
-0.0281279292,
-0.0418623574,
-0.0063399994,
-0.0064278659,
-0.0108260754,
-0.0171163101,
-0.0664877668,
-0.0222885627,
0.0305589586,
-0.0050282227,
0.0681261197,
0.054755073,
-0.0259051416,
-0.0429043062,
0.0249716062,
-0.0272228383,
0.0006730901,
0.0022499787,
-0.0782741159,
0.0032306719,
-0.0097633246,
-0.0201395247,
0.027646048,
-0.0394610688,
-0.0484551117,
-0.0129361302,
-0.0033693169,
-0.0296569113,
-0.043099165,
-0.0883831158,
0.0000633972,
-0.0231393203,
0.0726077035,
0.0563823693,
0.0180214103,
-0.0150564332,
-0.0374240093,
-0.0125901159,
-0.0463199914,
0.0200003926,
-0.0410025567,
0.0347887203,
0.0055614323,
-0.0032544346,
0.0127228182,
-0.0088297436,
-0.0535782613,
0.0234843865,
0.038937103,
-0.02656921,
-0.0319083072,
0.018888358,
0.0261276662,
0.0009736024,
-0.0093588363,
-0.0048213284,
-0.0132126966,
0.0028612805,
0.0285247937,
0.0607623495,
0.0220050942,
0.0102613373,
0.0021060368,
0.0145727284,
0.0547949933,
0.0103949355,
-0.0227019414,
0.0315736458,
0.000858226,
-0.0686306804,
0.0654877424,
0.1001075059,
0.0101355035,
-0.001564967,
0.0061832373,
-0.0663559362,
-0.0483202562,
0.0166145153,
0.0131298406,
-0.0025555512,
-0.0347589292,
0.0075803101,
0.0057642474,
0.0140839545,
0.0700938702,
-0.0374411307,
0.0111167831,
-0.0935954526,
-0.0193122718,
-0.0526292957,
0.0235771053,
0.039517872,
-0.0008550305,
0.0224979501,
-0.054864496,
0.0296261143,
0.0495843142,
-0.0145683549,
-0.0364633463,
0.0535025857,
0.0101293623,
0.0269901752,
-0.0287467688,
-0.0118271448,
-0.0201928001,
0.0102066556,
-0.0024721888,
0.0273813754,
0.0305610579,
0.0265697073,
-0.0583235249,
0.059614718,
0.0009891591,
0.1190526113,
0.0274665728,
-0.0080618961,
-0.0145238321,
0.0840528905,
0.0204216912,
-0.0217042938,
0.0018164201,
-0.0356277488,
0.0127610536,
0.0585705861,
0.0040771193,
0.0030608687,
0.0398639999,
-0.0203064922,
-0.0005371756,
-0.1137381643,
0.0073738866,
-0.0074811904,
0.0477233231,
-0.0578462593,
0.0100431331,
0.097066842,
0.0479126647,
-0.0617452376,
-0.0220830608,
-0.0032105169,
-0.0567437112,
-0.0199434739,
-0.0041116094,
-0.0145210205,
-0.0138976807,
0.0217671245,
0.0350428522,
0.0029345111,
-0.0444212183,
0.053133864,
0.0024490899,
0.0187778063,
-0.0452927612,
-0.0796790943,
0.0158061907,
-0.0672957301,
0.0089258375,
-0.046916578,
-0.0404649787,
0.002228386,
-0.05254649,
-0.0398028493,
0.015087341,
-0.062118195,
0.0107654044,
0.014800759,
-0.0327474996,
-0.0258985963,
0.0433261395,
0.0388280824,
-0.0172687415,
0.0443414673,
0.01739165,
-0.0708684027,
-0.0345070064,
0.0068746181,
0.0721491873,
-0.0117955245,
0.0222338233,
-0.041916132,
0.0432083569,
0.0070958906,
-0.0391131043,
-0.0013075119,
0.0128413048,
-0.0113432892,
-0.0111977374,
-0.0604787804,
0.0081419125,
-0.0223702248,
0.0407712124,
-0.0486490689,
0.0039924346,
-0.034294676,
0.0367348529,
0.0713954866,
-0.0173760429,
-0.0021479309,
0.0193138383,
-0.0758370459,
-0.035778854,
-0.0566255152,
-0.0011551616,
0.033923395,
-0.0180432647,
0.014879412,
-0.0304876864,
0.0559252799,
-0.0050368439,
-0.0853919238,
0.0143878218,
0.0139238629,
0.0016533367,
-0.1002047434,
-0.0444486067,
0.07933525,
-0.0005283005,
-0.050108403,
-0.0146951806,
-0.0177538451,
-0.0071362224,
0.024782205,
0.0147219282,
0.0014391163,
-0.0039806929,
0.0185645595,
0.0054688104,
0.0532545783,
0.0169161931,
-0.0372089557,
-0.0291040763,
-0.0111943446,
0.0245249905,
-0.0516290814,
0.0168845765,
-0.0191787686,
0.0544035025,
0.0070808781,
0.0186993927,
-0.016931884,
0.0349076577,
-0.0117130438,
0.0504075661,
0.0615629591,
-0.0226183329,
0.0000222911,
-0.0651137307,
0.0436856896,
0.0048638345,
0.0578198954,
0.0074737174,
0.0243203137,
-0.0089936107,
0.000613808,
-0.0316836871,
0.0650888905,
-0.0256282985,
-0.0415557288,
-0.021597812,
0.0792068541,
0.0004059833,
0.0048430567,
-0.0010948897,
-0.0317143984,
0.0238845907,
-0.0159803852,
0.0370611846,
0.0129061341,
0.0059579224,
0.0673921704,
0.0175474789,
0.0279950034,
-0.0344984494,
0.0719452277,
-0.0561934374,
0.0847157463,
-0.0412029289,
0.0513892286,
0.00173197,
-0.0281503722,
-0.0033776045,
-0.0302172471,
0.0043926514,
0.0086534107,
0.0320879482,
-0.0241566636,
0.0189723913,
0.0087645222,
0.0090095745,
0.010346638,
-0.0281448867,
0.0518041812,
-0.0040174345,
0.0148454364,
0.0374787748,
-0.0345415063,
-0.0533957072,
-0.0008691247,
0.0455656759,
-0.010520597,
-0.0553870723,
-0.002469819,
-0.0447718687,
0.0047138878,
0.0565259978,
-0.0039090887,
0.0249301121,
-0.0207454003,
0.036821831,
0.0107247634,
0.0222785212,
-0.0151837273,
-0.0262262765,
0.0109186955,
0.0037638096,
0.0002394358,
0.0364326574,
-5.763003584e-33,
-0.0042967894,
-0.03335879,
-0.0090258764,
0.0469099209,
-0.0360632017,
0.0371140353,
-0.0402517542,
-0.0116027985,
0.0058801952,
0.0049961195,
-0.0275130775,
-0.0151866125,
0.030937152,
0.0346318968,
-0.0173667651,
-0.0379395522,
0.0370758623,
0.0053179534,
-0.0217920262,
0.012577136,
0.0026163394,
0.0673901141,
0.072500594,
-0.0417424105,
0.0184523799,
-0.0140654668,
0.0319007598,
-0.0008938835,
0.0219812896,
0.0381026678,
-0.0453418046,
-0.0557179824,
0.0485823117,
-0.0280080512,
0.0318132713,
0.0120567065,
-0.1301689893,
0.0075008334,
-0.0256615635,
0.01406861,
-0.0239169057,
-0.0107646761,
0.042702727,
-0.0043088216,
0.0015281065,
-0.0055137728,
0.0461378135,
-0.0269985031,
0.0075635188,
-0.0543886647,
-0.0620674267,
0.076187253,
0.009022614,
0.0016893491,
0.0486058593,
-0.0225205049,
-0.0009204479,
0.0354259424,
-0.0343331099,
-0.0316364095,
0.0476051122,
0.0257697981,
-0.0026497254,
-0.0052152402,
-0.0329000801,
0.02443159,
0.0430946946,
-0.0060379794,
-0.031324923,
0.0197190251,
-0.0394740961,
0.0033925271,
0.023924144,
-0.0396577753,
0.0515354723,
-0.0011895337,
-0.0602904744,
0.0655771941,
-0.0430432074,
0.0227793008,
-0.0035219726,
-0.0173671264,
-0.04161584,
0.0384130403,
0.0286606103,
-0.0340682045,
-0.0055362186,
0.0136126876,
-0.0062347623,
0.0254003145,
-0.0304730944,
-0.0000530292,
0.0045721275,
0.0083075631,
0.0216531325,
-0.0459942818,
0.0390304551,
0.0459270403,
-0.0648944825,
-0.0211166739,
-0.0424732529,
-0.0162315276,
0.0062693069,
0.0182390306,
0.0213961881,
-0.0192378648,
0.0175107159,
-0.0484340601,
-0.0355853699,
0.0143944062,
0.0666463152,
0.0074922512,
-0.0357508399,
0.0937102214,
0.0120123364,
0.0051566372,
0.0256143194,
0.0590581708,
0.0067583323,
-0.0267238636,
-0.0234735422,
0.0351883061,
0.0165962409,
0.0188892912,
-0.0273631606,
0.0050128293,
-0.0003049355,
0.0372478068,
0.0044526849,
-0.0618486479,
0.0138524743,
0.0112153823,
2.665e-7,
0.0753087625,
0.0399521925,
0.0520265177,
-0.0282567553,
0.0013072365,
-0.0052540442,
-0.0048648762,
0.0207626559,
-0.0165547319,
0.0069600581,
0.0325414911,
-0.0438391417,
0.0289812852,
0.0267780926,
-0.1214733496,
-0.030132588,
-0.0457155406,
-0.0596272834,
-0.0206685346,
0.0289759655,
0.0614741668,
0.0397515185,
-0.0390206538,
-0.0154149411,
-0.033388108,
0.0166508425,
0.0046826713,
0.003475596,
0.0159555115,
0.0633274391,
0.0354420133,
0.0073898039,
-0.0203689206,
0.0368851423,
-0.0178642329,
0.0157190412,
0.031090809,
0.0701858699,
-0.033651609,
0.0305550024,
0.0450980477,
0.0296861734,
0.0246465057,
0.0085088639,
0.0520155355,
-0.0390237458,
-0.0292867366,
-0.015511984,
-0.0381028615,
0.0096366545,
0.0129550677,
0.0038525581,
-0.0265344921,
0.0689659193,
0.0096680578,
-0.0197533835,
-0.0224340465,
-0.0706666484,
0.0302586593,
0.0298107229,
-0.0104577029,
0.0086942147,
0.0271190479,
0.0267983656,
-0.0029279965,
-0.061591886,
-0.0280095991,
2.497292979e-34,
0.0355846807,
-0.0114532104,
-0.0700002015,
0.0271756966,
-0.0129998168,
-0.0300542507,
0.0025626197,
-0.0090347994,
-0.0488386601,
-0.0540602803,
0.0068289889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19512v1 | Captioning Visualizations with Large Language Models (CVLLM): A Tutorial | 2024-06-27T20:18:18 | 2024-06-27T20:18:18 | Giuseppe Carenini, Jordon Johnson, Ali Salamatian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Automatically captioning visualizations is not new, but recent advances in
large language models(LLMs) open exciting new possibilities. In this tutorial,
after providing a brief review of Information Visualization (InfoVis)
principles and past work in captioning, we introduce neural models and the
transformer architecture used in generic LLMs. We then discuss their recent
applications in InfoVis, with a focus on captioning. Additionally, we explore
promising future directions in this field. | [
0.0105806086,
0.0462545231,
-0.0128518967,
0.0511139445,
0.0014876993,
0.0200701635,
-0.0050428738,
0.0046339403,
-0.0255533718,
-0.0128717804,
-0.0531038865,
-0.0014562672,
0.0295108873,
0.0287165884,
0.0283948965,
-0.0842761397,
0.0159648005,
-0.0566676594,
-0.046053376,
0.0094319955,
-0.0227904059,
-0.0079136332,
0.0039001764,
0.0415587835,
-0.019287413,
-0.0386490002,
0.0061201169,
-0.0114509221,
0.00122094,
-0.0497064069,
-0.0588721223,
0.0714386478,
0.0682069063,
0.0309049617,
0.0000018715,
0.022172492,
0.0111413822,
-0.0075437813,
0.0213062596,
0.0272489581,
0.0269916896,
-0.0878252685,
0.0010529531,
-0.0266968738,
-0.0214810502,
-0.0548106357,
0.0742612928,
0.0729133636,
0.0895664841,
0.0077867829,
-0.0076833721,
-0.0638084412,
0.0113274213,
-0.038428098,
-0.0199763179,
-0.0094428705,
0.0024774049,
0.0726618543,
-0.0378974751,
0.0292942561,
-0.0420591384,
0.0871682316,
-0.0018580802,
-0.0633023903,
-0.0040552663,
0.0402945764,
0.0166551489,
-0.0397137329,
-0.0224979483,
0.0921141431,
-0.0059094839,
0.019367272,
-0.0423638187,
0.01439243,
0.0145784076,
0.014606257,
-0.0977927223,
0.0370984748,
0.0421664938,
0.0189589672,
0.0155428732,
0.0191198997,
0.0284099709,
-0.0230887756,
-0.0287164114,
-0.005415333,
0.0053653843,
0.0372357816,
-0.0566326044,
-0.0121159665,
-0.0379859433,
-0.0386628993,
0.0199200138,
0.0442110449,
0.0112686716,
0.0088967234,
-0.0011761574,
-0.0661082491,
-0.0053330194,
-0.0452448912,
0.0292793941,
-0.0159257911,
-0.0291376282,
0.0517415032,
-0.0145625724,
0.0720999613,
-0.025920894,
0.0317655951,
-0.0273288786,
-0.0159010813,
-0.0284209643,
-0.0105701834,
-0.0553646274,
0.0185060166,
-0.0238541905,
-0.0291198101,
-0.0278393589,
0.0121538285,
-0.0161277056,
0.02980542,
-0.0116885221,
0.0057929335,
-0.0195872933,
0.0156206107,
-0.0405644551,
0.0502200127,
0.0040651159,
-0.0379386544,
-0.0308231134,
-0.0249899644,
-0.0144855166,
0.0410000756,
-0.0058667553,
-0.0070323413,
-0.0303013343,
0.0782175213,
0.0071850638,
0.0001309418,
-0.0171120893,
-0.0103694424,
-0.0319930911,
-0.0154086566,
0.0269835163,
-0.0511032343,
0.0276607797,
-0.0036559268,
0.0456874259,
-0.0603160374,
0.0120284893,
0.0286134351,
-0.0038993219,
0.1031511649,
-0.0187468827,
0.0000712801,
0.0045616664,
-0.0269636326,
0.0073987227,
0.0556414612,
0.0701158494,
0.0299368221,
0.0097157257,
-0.054021474,
0.0466130003,
0.0690919906,
-0.0057114083,
-0.0065857712,
-0.0636447594,
-0.0436293446,
0.012595308,
0.0256381165,
0.0282425527,
0.0428480357,
-0.0247407649,
0.0178897977,
0.0790499076,
0.0679518059,
0.0295534823,
0.0590541996,
0.0341531932,
0.0173679497,
-0.008605551,
-0.0155436061,
-0.0253874268,
0.0616267063,
0.0364118703,
0.0163529925,
-0.0421515629,
0.0235924907,
-0.0186012927,
-0.0452105477,
0.0028086654,
0.0061303144,
-0.0205150079,
-0.0266243555,
0.0576384142,
0.0316077285,
-0.0210903101,
0.0601123907,
0.0137593728,
-0.0237314366,
0.0117865596,
-0.0380437709,
-0.0076874387,
0.0337734446,
0.0413744934,
-0.0024692803,
-0.0212914702,
-0.0023087903,
0.0118397195,
0.0670712665,
0.054829143,
0.0003181772,
-0.0249038842,
-0.0231335275,
-0.0157145634,
-0.0078684883,
0.002393469,
0.0220132563,
-0.0292633995,
-0.0058722766,
0.0192698482,
-0.0126002543,
-0.0913111642,
0.0261367876,
0.0248607919,
-0.0067012664,
-0.001901886,
-0.0026805669,
-0.023209285,
0.0281184763,
-0.0201041568,
0.0207885914,
0.0402212627,
-0.0359652154,
0.0001620762,
0.0365211144,
-0.0223992541,
-0.0701172799,
0.0203834791,
-0.0747539029,
-0.0180144943,
-0.0219060592,
-0.0317613371,
-0.0399396196,
0.0145798204,
-0.0581246912,
0.0068442523,
0.002762774,
0.0278745424,
-0.0137422523,
0.0182571337,
-0.0482667238,
0.0557590239,
-0.0123052141,
-0.0000293452,
0.0582605787,
-0.0040890179,
-0.0146457255,
-0.0235904343,
-0.0273553524,
0.0416891202,
0.0160768703,
0.0086794142,
-0.0023969938,
0.0197568797,
0.0034281262,
-0.0098693557,
-0.0745109469,
-0.0139182322,
-0.0075688432,
-0.0099442704,
0.0114930905,
-0.0086187646,
0.0002416388,
-0.0308143441,
-0.0435134098,
0.0198813044,
0.0152051961,
-0.0215249043,
0.0569217317,
-0.0006913692,
-0.0483461991,
-0.0192270037,
-0.0054793246,
0.0027524328,
0.0791399553,
0.0440245494,
-0.0725969225,
-0.0822567269,
-0.0101158498,
0.0023651377,
-0.0031630753,
-0.0073950654,
-0.0178775955,
0.0157209933,
-0.006387563,
0.0260489285,
0.0018947235,
-0.0009899357,
0.0519192778,
0.0624291636,
-0.0235233232,
-0.0217859261,
0.0304999091,
-0.0378539637,
-0.0291218385,
0.0019457268,
-0.0448858701,
0.0175062362,
0.061866492,
-0.0257837363,
0.0358738489,
-0.0358390994,
0.0024864899,
-0.0391501188,
-0.0063753328,
-0.0559942797,
0.0082721766,
-0.0049955919,
0.0228503644,
-0.0219778959,
-0.0500097387,
0.0085473582,
-0.0830135569,
-0.0083531663,
-0.0038784868,
-0.0154215004,
-0.0490335822,
0.1069349125,
0.0261700228,
0.0167498607,
0.0052520917,
-0.0395912156,
0.0140869785,
0.0309783053,
-0.0243948177,
-0.0248196591,
0.0817397162,
-0.0624293834,
-0.0185764208,
-0.0178040285,
0.0041765012,
-0.0243324172,
-0.0086109769,
-0.0418876372,
-0.0171373375,
0.0377320908,
-0.0456258431,
-0.0373010151,
0.0507492647,
0.057367444,
0.0231876019,
-0.0194169711,
-0.0006042538,
-0.0173432138,
0.0223679394,
0.0360351801,
0.0633120015,
-0.0234459713,
-0.0255660582,
0.0275397766,
0.0042728791,
-0.0380443633,
0.0274657719,
-0.0515439324,
0.0056926124,
0.0334239528,
0.0282357763,
-0.0145772928,
-0.0159993302,
0.0388599336,
-0.042032592,
-0.0014123073,
0.1226136237,
0.0230945852,
-0.0847279802,
0.0054241908,
0.0049160239,
0.0277536325,
0.0131125627,
0.006150845,
-0.056182716,
-0.0254385676,
-0.0226814132,
-0.0222950112,
0.0505252555,
0.0169357434,
-0.0284648035,
-0.0650414452,
0.0625409782,
0.0316233784,
-0.0532273427,
-0.076161325,
-0.0181200095,
-0.0144108217,
-0.0207751244,
0.0084332423,
-0.0323359035,
-0.0070234123,
-0.0068422058,
0.0048902184,
-0.0029659765,
-0.0213238671,
-0.0416902453,
-0.0558320694,
0.0205058176,
0.054713998,
0.0470754728,
-0.0493156724,
-0.0342784673,
0.0008062726,
0.0242475104,
0.0385668389,
-0.0134386262,
0.0896942466,
0.0187680386,
-0.0629993603,
-0.0102023296,
-0.02218806,
-0.0171311051,
-0.0219160784,
-0.0019406722,
0.0248758197,
-0.0168034565,
-0.0017366287,
-0.0069052195,
0.0413399488,
-0.0270405393,
0.0506293848,
0.0697628185,
-0.0260661095,
0.0075330897,
-0.0486932695,
0.0173160173,
-0.051678732,
-0.0616969354,
0.0270211697,
-0.0083326669,
-0.0749926195,
-0.0690091103,
-0.0084156711,
0.0592654571,
0.0205198675,
0.0555053093,
0.0023890384,
0.033993125,
-0.0159693845,
-0.0184014793,
0.0471321754,
-0.064077273,
-0.0071799061,
-0.0386364534,
-0.0140229622,
0.0645354986,
-0.0113957645,
-0.0159744993,
0.0354643799,
-0.0838538334,
-0.0192121454,
-0.0203200504,
0.0311203133,
0.0100799743,
0.0215479191,
-0.0090079261,
-0.0331495143,
0.0467775166,
0.0468360148,
0.0335547589,
-0.017094139,
-0.0278930552,
-0.006943645,
-0.0216962267,
0.010200561,
-0.009501596,
-0.0011464054,
-0.0247384794,
0.0294774398,
-0.0331520662,
-0.0192380026,
0.0219158996,
-0.0111673642,
0.0260140933,
-0.0036595662,
-0.0043672812,
-0.0256091207,
-0.0119400453,
-0.0250971634,
-0.0344949216,
-0.0200739335,
0.0067773112,
0.0462924764,
-0.0074760006,
0.0086107254,
0.0135279112,
0.0106069762,
-0.0005256459,
-0.0105263926,
0.0197323672,
0.0065246709,
-0.0388382301,
-0.0036721521,
0.0440855324,
-0.0214029159,
0.0336477049,
-0.0271727294,
0.0119695487,
0.0010174768,
0.0257746745,
0.0171879511,
-0.0307989586,
-0.0406439193,
0.0559513941,
-0.0244840235,
-0.0517881773,
-0.0087559884,
0.0461354814,
0.0711935982,
0.0189065784,
0.0795361772,
-0.0230923854,
0.010777914,
0.0257560667,
0.0338427201,
-0.0051772022,
-0.0161449425,
0.0516572036,
0.0035603535,
-0.0019747759,
-0.0582527332,
0.0532013513,
-0.0096143223,
0.0139335468,
0.0052175676,
-0.0342440307,
-0.0225529205,
0.0283546839,
-0.0292529259,
-0.0211713277,
-0.0235025212,
0.0164889488,
-0.0432159789,
-0.0591647625,
0.0138594229,
-0.0051613268,
0.0037141484,
-0.0034330615,
0.0242896285,
0.0143895196,
0.0273652077,
-0.0159921069,
-0.012416997,
0.0223411098,
-0.0025948633,
-0.0232534204,
-0.0535273515,
-5.591269002e-33,
-0.0803327039,
-0.0468277596,
0.0210216027,
0.0054808888,
-0.0390842669,
-0.0099289799,
-0.042134922,
0.0353496857,
-0.0184093434,
0.0208278839,
0.0130023314,
-0.0019964552,
0.0121569475,
0.0390528813,
-0.0145179629,
-0.0259071775,
0.0548496507,
0.018744437,
0.0069517829,
0.0229014903,
-0.0243130308,
0.0068180747,
0.0599370115,
-0.0683509782,
0.0202634726,
0.0189038347,
0.0025790681,
0.0272709988,
0.0382260382,
0.033479888,
-0.0410518609,
0.0134595204,
0.0263416376,
-0.0446820259,
-0.0296729971,
0.0266706236,
-0.0711581931,
-0.0232013538,
0.0233940072,
0.0700167194,
-0.0118772099,
-0.0432445146,
0.0622209311,
-0.0109741632,
-0.0121102501,
-0.0031011011,
0.0523756258,
-0.0142024923,
-0.0125580681,
0.0203523748,
-0.0325278342,
0.0174972601,
-0.0247342344,
-0.0219126772,
0.0512602665,
0.0068309424,
0.0012276416,
0.0379319564,
-0.0469488278,
0.0548009612,
0.0624802485,
0.0244768187,
0.1032944918,
0.0609899536,
0.012933109,
0.0647699833,
0.0071325488,
0.0047476287,
-0.0613941364,
0.024560662,
0.0330351256,
0.0583194345,
0.0824908018,
-0.0094745606,
-0.0063881208,
0.0192421358,
-0.0102657601,
0.0233166255,
-0.0744255483,
0.0307201315,
0.0309511162,
0.0078261336,
-0.0128709888,
0.0084449816,
-0.0665505901,
-0.0345006697,
-0.028744882,
-0.0050598695,
0.0149930669,
-0.0307565238,
-0.0213055108,
0.0204882436,
0.0333490781,
-0.0350823998,
-0.02804997,
0.0202978682,
0.0140710343,
0.0738493577,
-0.0264825244,
-0.0341555662,
0.0121589266,
-0.0390352793,
0.012179899,
0.0138276862,
0.0268093534,
0.0232653618,
0.0443211943,
0.0228037015,
-0.0400190055,
-0.0098882616,
-0.0334406197,
-0.0462567396,
-0.0131992046,
0.0004769523,
0.0260127168,
0.0020072667,
-0.0682582855,
0.016224144,
0.0155138616,
0.014780635,
0.0257638637,
-0.0409010686,
-0.0143687688,
0.0310701504,
-0.0211475156,
0.0087821158,
-0.0482963137,
0.013715039,
0.0563517585,
-0.071555607,
-0.0453786515,
0.0084717209,
2.41e-7,
0.0545428209,
0.0700075924,
0.0542314947,
0.0504175238,
0.0198041089,
0.0256609153,
-0.0153100053,
-0.0096177962,
-0.0006634929,
-0.0317572989,
0.0139776571,
0.0302015748,
0.0234984532,
0.0100981072,
-0.0583490171,
-0.0251097064,
-0.0351925679,
-0.0159824006,
-0.0389590785,
-0.0046436433,
0.0783277526,
0.1100045666,
-0.0224139895,
-0.022289278,
-0.0017768765,
-0.0911402702,
0.0409478322,
-0.0506100319,
-0.0064358506,
0.002028425,
0.0162722543,
0.0471335351,
-0.0371631831,
0.0285650361,
0.0048219413,
0.0100025581,
0.0357405506,
0.0045015668,
-0.0116702141,
0.0564915612,
-0.011830572,
0.0295967963,
-0.0127358763,
-0.0310701448,
0.0573433973,
-0.0846488103,
-0.0247771703,
-0.0161380284,
0.0302779321,
0.0014476684,
0.0159915127,
-0.0526362024,
-0.0347547084,
0.042278111,
0.0366249494,
-0.0110067781,
-0.0398456044,
-0.0272077583,
-0.0286144093,
0.0128918542,
-0.035831511,
-0.0171210114,
-0.0591624342,
-0.0587939657,
-0.0077764262,
0.0130820069,
-0.0000275268,
2.246978344e-34,
0.0379696302,
-0.0288332701,
-0.009909247,
0.0366501883,
0.0586077571,
-0.0081888707,
-0.0027195013,
0.0106975324,
-0.0087625319,
-0.1003001854,
-0.0136713246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19504v1 | Are Generative Language Models Multicultural? A Study on Hausa Culture and Emotions using ChatGPT | 2024-06-27T19:42:13 | 2024-06-27T19:42:13 | Ibrahim Said Ahmad, Shiran Dudy, Resmi Ramachandranpillai, Kenneth Church | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, are widely used to generate
content for various purposes and audiences. However, these models may not
reflect the cultural and emotional diversity of their users, especially for
low-resource languages. In this paper, we investigate how ChatGPT represents
Hausa's culture and emotions. We compare responses generated by ChatGPT with
those provided by native Hausa speakers on 37 culturally relevant questions. We
conducted experiments using emotion analysis and applied two similarity metrics
to measure the alignment between human and ChatGPT responses. We also collected
human participants ratings and feedback on ChatGPT responses. Our results show
that ChatGPT has some level of similarity to human responses, but also exhibits
some gaps and biases in its knowledge and awareness of the Hausa culture and
emotions. We discuss the implications and limitations of our methodology and
analysis and suggest ways to improve the performance and evaluation of LLMs for
low-resource languages. | [
0.0256635174,
0.0551975295,
-0.0435034037,
0.0096344631,
-0.0125411889,
0.0469444357,
0.0127086667,
-0.037383616,
0.0444945507,
-0.0112700146,
-0.0326882787,
-0.0853552297,
0.0016572684,
0.0211995896,
-0.0061912923,
-0.0836646706,
0.0036678039,
0.0505739488,
0.0415523276,
-0.0274978746,
0.0293719247,
0.0540924668,
0.0124581093,
0.0617300421,
-0.0564538725,
-0.0290339664,
-0.0100368904,
0.0050642868,
0.0337893367,
-0.0170447305,
0.0060025253,
0.0326843299,
-0.0230617393,
0.0136496518,
0.0000021846,
-0.0305404998,
0.0133706536,
-0.012633184,
0.0394023806,
0.0292261951,
0.1060204059,
0.0379134826,
-0.0406426452,
0.0269056577,
-0.0534670949,
-0.0267668236,
0.0675422773,
0.0324581265,
0.0570913367,
0.0525626354,
-0.0188698042,
-0.0078645414,
-0.0284894984,
-0.0187516082,
0.0222488791,
0.0347740166,
0.011401779,
0.0636438429,
0.0103836944,
-0.069456391,
-0.0494010039,
0.0243062489,
0.0081407288,
0.0018804929,
-0.0391728356,
0.003035896,
-0.0425416864,
-0.0642818362,
0.037790712,
0.0289503597,
0.0146120796,
0.0105223246,
-0.0109853121,
0.0275351219,
-0.0112041589,
0.0097865649,
-0.054502815,
0.0345762745,
0.0011922624,
0.0108749736,
0.0237603858,
0.0216746759,
0.0059929681,
0.0112874918,
0.0312381703,
0.0547399223,
0.0188128129,
0.0158477724,
-0.0432389192,
-0.0002156822,
-0.0013579761,
-0.0417343229,
0.0067761997,
0.020071866,
0.0105599687,
0.0266942475,
-0.0102105094,
-0.0044675521,
0.0045273057,
-0.0656184033,
-0.0140413754,
0.0666101724,
-0.046954602,
-0.0096059823,
0.0243355017,
0.0357459895,
0.0151172178,
-0.0341260694,
-0.0419205315,
-0.0091155823,
-0.0326499566,
-0.0191502236,
0.0074233073,
-0.0189127102,
-0.0268122684,
0.0168231186,
-0.0731963888,
0.0030892091,
-0.0299111307,
-0.0259602144,
-0.008491856,
-0.030627232,
-0.0136657301,
-0.0030808435,
-0.0122797759,
0.0508441217,
-0.0653885081,
0.0039281007,
-0.0104138004,
-0.1344823241,
0.0653846562,
0.0137333581,
-0.0421166606,
-0.0050988276,
-0.0094748922,
0.0384284221,
0.0060016336,
0.0063993442,
-0.0487599187,
-0.004338047,
-0.0134545881,
-0.0344376266,
-0.0099155167,
-0.0635421351,
0.0748234168,
0.027460875,
0.0274411663,
-0.0348908156,
0.0067930142,
0.0073756883,
0.0101562571,
0.02588851,
0.0280570649,
0.038903486,
0.06737829,
0.020113593,
0.0156604629,
0.053750053,
0.0229483619,
0.0475618392,
0.0489511751,
-0.0361430794,
-0.0094991988,
0.0241444409,
-0.0314564258,
0.0171966366,
-0.0061493781,
-0.0168926027,
0.0204454083,
0.0194951035,
0.0534987934,
0.093495138,
-0.0060194642,
0.0050162417,
0.0350036882,
0.0863198191,
-0.0200103614,
0.0680554435,
0.0656622797,
0.0267697815,
-0.0036594828,
0.0303928796,
-0.0015103569,
0.0306490734,
-0.0221579168,
-0.0121417455,
0.0291366037,
0.0870164186,
-0.0329618268,
-0.0358425193,
-0.0267254133,
0.0010859343,
0.0126729906,
0.0127647128,
0.0022798975,
-0.0241252091,
0.0187169407,
-0.0029935027,
0.0789344907,
-0.0880718902,
0.0170560163,
-0.0377254076,
0.0401317813,
0.0614405312,
0.0021379641,
0.0392056704,
0.0268751029,
-0.0108277472,
-0.0104669519,
0.0470353961,
0.0681011975,
-0.0028799293,
-0.031798657,
-0.0506457761,
0.0239812527,
0.0052696629,
-0.0008956026,
0.041464638,
-0.0027202223,
0.0576615892,
0.0127654839,
0.003993799,
-0.0235569272,
-0.0058079218,
-0.0720373392,
0.0219909567,
-0.0096049113,
-0.0181402303,
0.0554095134,
0.0323962606,
-0.0206591282,
0.0043282746,
-0.0291629564,
-0.0239878856,
-0.0136143323,
0.0738363564,
-0.0404680148,
-0.0267817676,
0.0315436386,
-0.0763552338,
-0.0042249775,
-0.0134861507,
0.0045241183,
-0.0147032579,
0.0741119087,
-0.0053763292,
-0.0057532829,
-0.0727203414,
-0.0093099633,
-0.0063962834,
0.0306633692,
-0.0269745495,
0.040560551,
-0.0093246456,
0.0093594342,
-0.0451433994,
-0.0127729364,
0.0549125746,
-0.0304123331,
-0.0711733848,
0.0534646511,
-0.0071697519,
0.007048951,
-0.0059435503,
0.0058538266,
-0.0262889285,
-0.0336220786,
-0.1230952889,
-0.0007431259,
-0.0013827945,
-0.0039835121,
0.0073352074,
0.0218562614,
-0.0575204641,
0.0198668037,
-0.069363147,
-0.0066378769,
0.0310040656,
0.0129675865,
-0.0243673045,
-0.0267587248,
0.0344101042,
-0.0458534136,
-0.0263880193,
0.0058076973,
0.0249081608,
-0.0075886729,
0.0117797619,
0.0134642962,
-0.0212772992,
-0.0859917998,
-0.0171687398,
-0.0125166951,
-0.0946299657,
0.0302898902,
0.0067448514,
0.0849397108,
0.0063986904,
0.0325617157,
0.0495848879,
0.0281924699,
-0.0089629535,
-0.0219388828,
0.0069657452,
-0.0287264213,
0.0129934605,
0.0158658288,
-0.1059998125,
0.0010073149,
0.0600689985,
0.0424903743,
-0.0109812794,
-0.069089897,
0.0164586995,
-0.0570318662,
-0.0365291499,
-0.0038820992,
-0.0142093962,
-0.0068129045,
0.0227328334,
-0.0051524621,
-0.0366237275,
0.0389779918,
0.0117769977,
-0.0111710345,
-0.0353181064,
0.0260422081,
-0.0525407642,
0.0519126132,
-0.0448549315,
0.0227255374,
-0.0145632802,
0.0132857095,
-0.0297518577,
0.0056069135,
0.0107266875,
-0.0667736158,
0.0000711681,
-0.0266930535,
-0.0415936634,
0.0024616988,
-0.0168741457,
-0.0336928181,
0.0196868405,
-0.0223038513,
-0.0112350937,
0.0479764454,
0.0360077247,
0.018473994,
0.0085893124,
0.0480925292,
-0.0604138598,
-0.0230364706,
0.0153043726,
0.0374129638,
0.0271128435,
0.0477069356,
-0.027512081,
0.0222714636,
-0.0207680427,
0.0185156185,
0.0192473643,
0.0215308294,
-0.0116543034,
0.0256959107,
0.014343272,
0.0428276137,
0.0344485156,
-0.0393825211,
-0.0024927207,
0.0376651399,
0.0140633816,
0.0556740724,
0.0975002199,
0.0372064561,
-0.0195314176,
0.0112494286,
-0.0843863711,
0.0399838276,
0.0090967268,
0.0434040613,
-0.0726232752,
0.0322574303,
-0.0114138555,
-0.0041236496,
-0.0209990516,
-0.0061125276,
-0.0012306939,
-0.1078355312,
0.0201971438,
0.0304598492,
-0.0322663933,
-0.0066163,
0.0044743875,
-0.0003496599,
0.0072943298,
0.0055978564,
-0.0217325669,
0.0165294111,
0.0158671569,
0.0298811402,
-0.0344385952,
-0.0572549105,
-0.0045491513,
-0.0016361803,
0.0634184778,
0.0306628067,
0.062280193,
-0.0128799919,
-0.0313567929,
0.0239201244,
0.0183307622,
-0.0067310212,
-0.0193281062,
-0.0438013971,
0.0300619155,
-0.0319499597,
-0.0500717908,
0.0072976798,
0.008349726,
0.0051389495,
0.005592512,
0.0480001979,
-0.0154718133,
-0.0435065888,
-0.0443070456,
0.0159562081,
0.0179955531,
0.0734975487,
0.0500534251,
-0.0546884947,
-0.0019684958,
-0.0297794025,
0.0324069709,
0.0099548521,
-0.0942983553,
0.0370457321,
-0.00823869,
-0.0545282587,
-0.0927252397,
-0.0828666985,
-0.0194897372,
-0.0087045869,
0.0035138021,
-0.0412294269,
0.0046507251,
-0.004106814,
-0.0044654999,
0.0347451679,
-0.0172721185,
0.0138884615,
-0.007278651,
-0.0206951406,
-0.0030685086,
-0.0516917929,
0.0253814012,
-0.008689031,
-0.0418340787,
-0.0348421708,
0.0554472469,
0.0410236195,
0.0112587065,
-0.0521135814,
0.037166521,
-0.0662196726,
-0.024185203,
0.0218113177,
0.0012493992,
0.0012008954,
-0.0307506528,
0.0766625628,
0.0057678274,
0.0219399016,
0.0090125063,
0.0777870268,
0.0016507978,
0.0257362537,
-0.0142639689,
-0.0213287007,
-0.026705442,
0.0163699556,
-0.0130451275,
-0.0574829243,
-0.0363583118,
-0.0367909819,
-0.0579665862,
-0.0314925164,
-0.008369253,
-0.0445780382,
-0.0560961552,
0.0190973226,
0.0280871205,
-0.0263283979,
-0.0700393245,
-0.028354222,
0.0293395817,
-0.0179399159,
0.0381810926,
0.0344297066,
0.0075277714,
-0.0088850912,
0.034832146,
-0.0209571887,
0.0193335842,
-0.0372965671,
0.0015939295,
-0.0200964008,
0.0745481178,
-0.0144051919,
-0.0287533663,
0.0704948828,
-0.0001811199,
0.0397928208,
-0.0182849318,
0.0073256604,
0.0240908805,
0.0474707484,
-0.001332421,
0.0720311925,
-0.029996695,
0.0002725928,
-0.0363639258,
0.0242248327,
0.0195566248,
-0.0685862973,
0.0295888856,
-0.0118451566,
-0.0205486845,
-0.0427905694,
0.0533004329,
-0.0539770126,
0.0205720086,
-0.0088180611,
-0.0076969112,
-0.0319500417,
-0.0089921216,
0.0420196578,
-0.0453261137,
-0.0083556483,
0.025338525,
-0.1090610623,
-0.0515210107,
-0.0436013527,
-0.000965881,
0.0182906836,
-0.008517541,
0.0261213258,
0.0449378081,
-0.0354540646,
0.0373230428,
-0.0438376367,
0.0210934803,
-0.0896878168,
-0.0229678992,
0.0259175505,
-6.821517879e-33,
-0.0253113545,
-0.010826393,
-0.0104286401,
-0.0152231054,
-0.0446131937,
-0.0331474952,
-0.0412712656,
0.0386030264,
-0.0226426609,
0.0347016156,
-0.0120623456,
-0.0210489966,
0.0102224825,
0.0206631441,
0.0218687952,
0.0265736207,
0.0186005626,
-0.0064963666,
-0.0108594447,
0.0134981135,
0.0175981428,
-0.009023766,
0.0190443248,
-0.06867221,
0.0311942864,
-0.0446603112,
-0.0159975626,
-0.0068796775,
0.0384305753,
0.0330952071,
-0.0633751228,
0.0530738048,
0.0207155272,
0.0291995332,
0.0019734332,
-0.0063014012,
-0.0074236444,
-0.0442060418,
0.0410131663,
0.0091222245,
0.0008179834,
-0.0560643487,
-0.0120767914,
-0.0053119306,
-0.0233159102,
-0.0054286392,
0.0203354433,
-0.0282506943,
0.0122587597,
-0.0443763025,
-0.0479132198,
0.0333495811,
-0.0097074071,
0.0111191357,
-0.0198997464,
0.0812625065,
-0.0322972834,
-0.0382932201,
-0.0039950954,
0.0195730291,
-0.0142434025,
0.0026130027,
0.0668245852,
-0.0206549484,
0.0089255637,
0.0533406958,
0.0289877746,
0.0137452437,
-0.020378422,
0.0269428082,
0.0466855764,
-0.0241196789,
0.0195801575,
0.1014102921,
-0.0154949334,
-0.0531988218,
0.0051423707,
0.0359093882,
0.0361347608,
0.0108628944,
0.0447392911,
0.0220081154,
-0.0284119081,
-0.0098705282,
-0.001182092,
-0.0228985902,
-0.0017665781,
-0.0671859607,
0.0176769048,
-0.0280977525,
-0.0124272797,
-0.0381775871,
0.0333302915,
-0.0092558973,
0.0187306758,
0.0100123556,
-0.0712506324,
0.00892861,
0.0153289968,
0.0171730015,
-0.0319084488,
0.0167368986,
0.0064941128,
-0.0027904105,
0.0177520346,
0.017351767,
-0.021169696,
0.0058473423,
-0.058551576,
0.0202245824,
-0.005684942,
0.0351594016,
0.0013279039,
-0.0270723272,
-0.0044909408,
-0.006822384,
-0.0134081459,
-0.0330106877,
0.0479715541,
0.0130575467,
-0.0046683811,
-0.0402706079,
-0.0312874019,
0.0153499618,
-0.0678635985,
0.0413703807,
-0.0218540821,
0.0181499775,
0.0226025265,
0.0009696395,
-0.0152926492,
-0.0071048178,
2.915e-7,
0.0015983809,
0.0249776132,
-0.0026573422,
0.002974526,
0.0288416483,
0.0093233995,
-0.0074940864,
0.003719921,
0.0682736561,
0.0102815842,
-0.001023264,
0.022088049,
0.0967432261,
0.051334925,
-0.0891211703,
0.0084869247,
-0.0297738705,
-0.0204793233,
-0.0429362543,
0.0117512429,
0.046482686,
0.0602726042,
0.005370223,
-0.0070989467,
-0.0431527011,
0.0488293655,
0.074227199,
-0.035941422,
-0.0482716784,
0.0219150353,
0.0143684838,
-0.0102495188,
0.016719019,
-0.0264972094,
0.0011290193,
-0.0125403451,
0.0414055139,
0.0409850404,
0.0094012348,
-0.0323199071,
0.0425194129,
0.043419309,
-0.0435257442,
-0.0966562554,
0.045279339,
0.0022932505,
-0.0425256193,
-0.0286915954,
0.0025732138,
-0.0064727846,
0.0450045727,
-0.0400709994,
-0.047994975,
0.040992111,
0.032540638,
-0.0475316606,
-0.0044302791,
-0.0019789517,
-0.015785994,
-0.0190045089,
-0.0454067104,
-0.0488023199,
-0.0229646526,
0.0374534242,
-0.0136868851,
0.0306794345,
0.0252261944,
1.954469891e-34,
0.0229632817,
0.0120220315,
-0.0003517664,
-0.0051879678,
0.0327666663,
0.0085925683,
0.0152489217,
0.0137284696,
0.0277648643,
-0.0179178342,
-0.0154230008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19502v1 | Investigating How Large Language Models Leverage Internal Knowledge to Perform Complex Reasoning | 2024-06-27T19:29:36 | 2024-06-27T19:29:36 | Miyoung Ko, Sue Hyun Park, Joonsuk Park, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite significant advancements, there is a limited understanding of how
large language models (LLMs) utilize knowledge for reasoning. To address this,
we propose a method that deconstructs complex real-world questions into a
graph, representing each question as a node with parent nodes of background
knowledge needed to solve the question. We develop the DepthQA dataset,
deconstructing questions into three depths: (i) recalling conceptual knowledge,
(ii) applying procedural knowledge, and (iii) analyzing strategic knowledge.
Based on a hierarchical graph, we quantify forward discrepancy, discrepancies
in LLMs' performance on simpler sub-problems versus complex questions. We also
measure backward discrepancy, where LLMs answer complex questions but struggle
with simpler ones. Our analysis shows that smaller models have more
discrepancies than larger models. Additionally, guiding models from simpler to
complex questions through multi-turn interactions improves performance across
model sizes, highlighting the importance of structured intermediate steps in
knowledge reasoning. This work enhances our understanding of LLM reasoning and
suggests ways to improve their problem-solving abilities. | [
0.0495381467,
0.0158678256,
-0.0368894152,
0.0402466357,
-0.0577831306,
0.0096429689,
-0.0042611053,
-0.0031127634,
0.0224152301,
-0.0438615493,
-0.0113986172,
-0.0163411722,
0.0063999351,
0.0314198695,
0.0371047333,
-0.0381802171,
0.0297839306,
-0.0775691792,
0.0159924291,
-0.0261615142,
-0.0429017469,
-0.0012409616,
-0.0146405408,
0.014291794,
0.0118519589,
-0.0258053988,
-0.0480221473,
-0.0036871934,
0.0154351881,
-0.0311370157,
-0.0079097878,
0.0277522393,
0.0369306654,
0.0449858755,
0.0000020449,
-0.0488195233,
0.0039211647,
-0.035629198,
-0.0653664693,
0.0246328395,
-0.0300629679,
0.0047498569,
0.0153257456,
0.0152886044,
-0.0413240418,
-0.0335140303,
0.0036168408,
0.0474060588,
0.0099139186,
0.0428598709,
0.0113700358,
-0.0267696232,
0.0020190356,
-0.0194825325,
-0.0070994901,
-0.0643646494,
0.0299967844,
0.0659898743,
0.0002003729,
-0.0135960607,
-0.0330155529,
0.0141322808,
0.037221875,
-0.0050306525,
-0.0065451623,
0.0396221578,
0.0266829506,
0.0153217185,
0.0274660308,
0.063191779,
0.0098776175,
0.0149395261,
-0.0096074697,
-0.0220424999,
0.0216855966,
0.0529831015,
-0.0641964972,
0.0228317399,
-0.0180518832,
-0.0232109427,
0.0041570268,
-0.0259200297,
0.0489404574,
-0.0209420696,
-0.0491740443,
0.0900679603,
-0.0092004333,
-0.0281295162,
0.0325327329,
-0.0205910411,
-0.0086561162,
-0.0758691654,
-0.0049598357,
0.0618064217,
-0.022187382,
0.0472347066,
0.028632734,
0.0461343788,
0.0048585758,
-0.039321769,
0.0296150483,
0.0341855399,
0.0380811542,
0.0419831648,
-0.020836696,
0.0719790906,
-0.0197645221,
0.0279827267,
-0.0219593719,
0.00198221,
-0.063870579,
-0.0403835177,
-0.0294406544,
0.0424218364,
-0.0063346685,
-0.028584769,
-0.0304502193,
0.0445331298,
-0.0095570823,
0.0170905087,
0.0177318659,
0.0088223089,
0.0135953352,
-0.0247184597,
-0.0716686547,
0.0612497404,
-0.0367924161,
0.0323025808,
0.0103289634,
-0.0315965228,
-0.0018274642,
-0.0361649804,
-0.0017384936,
-0.0394388363,
-0.0073902267,
0.066943258,
0.0004369498,
-0.0048568253,
-0.0386753976,
-0.0459902808,
-0.0113754403,
-0.0858912989,
0.0273147505,
-0.0781582519,
0.0105814999,
0.0338901132,
-0.0085378988,
-0.0099995909,
0.0241293609,
-0.0001976978,
-0.023982713,
0.0351089835,
0.0389259607,
0.0321170539,
0.026137365,
0.0194388796,
-0.0152954767,
0.0522590503,
0.015332046,
-0.007078785,
0.0120829614,
-0.0115294494,
-0.0281875692,
0.0409658216,
-0.0049031251,
-0.017832756,
-0.0129619529,
0.0268345997,
-0.0266844444,
0.0364468694,
0.0219517499,
0.0370870456,
-0.0224556606,
0.0102330344,
0.0418318622,
0.0502333269,
0.0255697481,
-0.0121445674,
0.0311801415,
-0.0081820451,
0.0233912151,
0.0156842638,
-0.0652511641,
0.0438922532,
-0.0248198397,
0.0140645327,
-0.0101694772,
0.0102438442,
-0.0239538737,
-0.0338216908,
-0.0285001397,
0.0519018099,
0.0132453023,
0.0341764539,
0.0562306829,
-0.0013678835,
-0.0125794616,
0.0286018737,
0.0073897769,
-0.0133374892,
-0.0021957825,
-0.049985826,
0.0137204733,
0.0748165995,
0.0454592071,
-0.0172654577,
-0.0419989526,
0.0354979038,
-0.0184004176,
0.0130930534,
0.0624846816,
-0.0173035748,
-0.0210830849,
-0.009575502,
-0.0359928347,
-0.0563517958,
0.0092780003,
0.0101732761,
0.0122217173,
-0.0099202991,
-0.0114528704,
-0.0564955547,
0.0117778052,
0.0063933181,
-0.0718659014,
0.0029104338,
-0.0534492321,
0.0219446011,
0.0073238714,
-0.0045818747,
0.0116210869,
0.0367644429,
0.0249084905,
-0.0201744586,
-0.0403710939,
0.0025205254,
-0.0472520031,
-0.0502670594,
0.0347616002,
-0.0213734414,
-0.0346514583,
0.0130274147,
-0.0104154386,
-0.0425979383,
0.0567115285,
-0.0336083882,
0.0747150332,
-0.009911756,
0.0323048793,
-0.0049370034,
-0.0374896489,
-0.0138231032,
0.0911540315,
-0.0200649742,
0.0313230418,
0.0086109331,
-0.0139396768,
-0.0126160262,
-0.0157756228,
0.0373593867,
0.0263379328,
0.0017690454,
-0.0299391765,
-0.0110369045,
-0.0085650142,
-0.0720684081,
0.0096678305,
-0.0705734268,
-0.013617021,
0.0118098911,
0.0200988371,
0.0439607576,
-0.0129183736,
-0.00000258,
0.0061568511,
-0.0268849675,
0.0347625092,
0.0054085669,
0.0262652505,
0.0241504889,
0.0257904027,
-0.030704489,
-0.0288692061,
-0.0221587159,
-0.0458662063,
0.0385037102,
0.0039914805,
0.0194213074,
-0.0227226783,
0.0381844714,
-0.0504624993,
0.0316605978,
-0.0499359779,
-0.0134501969,
0.0198052414,
-0.0167422537,
0.0361732244,
0.0644343644,
-0.0333456248,
0.0410370082,
0.0715062246,
-0.0707933456,
-0.0580991954,
0.0229692049,
-0.0007969837,
-0.0156052439,
-0.0679637939,
-0.0517559201,
-0.0396140181,
0.0707633495,
0.006033048,
0.0141371898,
-0.0192133673,
0.0107998755,
-0.0339526311,
-0.0089699812,
-0.048343569,
-0.015242449,
0.001940307,
0.0822199807,
-0.0240556989,
-0.0224461555,
0.0755013078,
-0.0005785332,
0.0099412408,
0.0068478528,
0.0235917587,
-0.0309554525,
0.123372227,
-0.0067110015,
0.0083965519,
-0.0198341534,
-0.0501658767,
-0.101459384,
-0.0044168783,
0.0291100722,
-0.0227700025,
0.0695760474,
-0.0606390275,
-0.003139263,
-0.0076056416,
-0.0227524638,
-0.0421564691,
0.0142920921,
-0.0345149375,
0.0314673632,
0.0307835974,
-0.0573524088,
-0.0243145674,
-0.0085760243,
0.0553538427,
-0.0071943519,
-0.0230288748,
-0.02831126,
-0.0060218386,
0.0180792902,
0.0504941605,
0.0147629743,
0.0553148836,
-0.0701028779,
0.0675266013,
0.0389357172,
0.0264829248,
-0.0361030772,
0.012354644,
-0.001802016,
0.0087384013,
-0.000613733,
-0.0258923415,
0.021820195,
0.0563445613,
-0.073445335,
-0.0284857433,
0.1160850748,
0.0377893187,
0.0001999932,
0.010537562,
-0.0685551465,
0.0334489606,
0.0579543263,
0.0355371684,
-0.0489680916,
-0.0173749421,
0.0240643993,
-0.0137461219,
-0.0170848835,
-0.0531574152,
0.0088674845,
-0.1456753612,
0.0313528478,
0.0113146091,
-0.0550544709,
-0.0335437655,
-0.0188798457,
-0.0010488039,
0.0457096733,
0.0081942994,
0.0259151608,
-0.0265757479,
-0.0352101624,
-0.0056428961,
-0.0445201509,
-0.0153590189,
0.0796901807,
-0.010139375,
0.0278195329,
-0.0091202436,
0.0183884725,
0.0064457529,
0.0106082065,
0.0485129356,
-0.0002800453,
0.0223023053,
0.0032309135,
0.0156262144,
0.0116960239,
0.0089638047,
-0.01895836,
-0.0028847943,
-0.0327324457,
-0.0045490921,
0.0123388432,
0.0793735161,
-0.0247698724,
-0.0469010137,
0.0198064037,
0.0066158338,
-0.0463308431,
0.0693559796,
0.0368141904,
0.003815783,
-0.0455373712,
-0.0341299064,
-0.0287688039,
-0.0074933213,
-0.0342841931,
0.0542646609,
0.0358665511,
0.0343134403,
-0.0267890282,
-0.0450442694,
0.073164247,
0.0032838515,
-0.0012023444,
-0.0079796212,
0.025508903,
-0.0076250378,
-0.0533154868,
0.0103194052,
-0.0262438264,
0.0349721275,
0.0002847617,
-0.0045982921,
-0.0236646179,
-0.0251220297,
-0.0104257856,
-0.0134416781,
-0.0797026157,
-0.0476820506,
0.0043845582,
0.0089256736,
0.0309437439,
0.00485268,
0.0085981796,
-0.0293694995,
0.0075863474,
-0.0283149388,
-0.0555566885,
0.0068839369,
0.0116430363,
0.0105750989,
0.0017868442,
0.0542592444,
-0.0555765331,
-0.0096366722,
0.0429775119,
0.0653018653,
-0.0416968092,
-0.0348840542,
0.0288685616,
0.0063880407,
0.0153768873,
0.042034708,
-0.0255992804,
-0.0407229066,
0.0276566483,
-0.0462406389,
-0.0250884648,
-0.0092052091,
-0.0265183505,
0.020726623,
0.0115203978,
0.0259560812,
-0.0142426593,
0.0112925032,
0.0114889489,
-0.0035302069,
-0.0072197355,
0.0446896479,
-0.0042802258,
0.0484549813,
-0.0029466245,
-0.0042741867,
0.0020640253,
-0.0101303598,
0.0293707345,
0.0215937197,
0.0697313026,
0.0117571456,
-0.0220790636,
-0.0631379262,
-0.028082205,
-0.0772253275,
-0.1092138812,
0.0650295317,
-0.0064109056,
0.0555596575,
-0.0040714522,
-0.0031177835,
-0.0320718065,
0.0063414299,
0.0016155646,
-0.00478392,
-0.0025041406,
-0.0462056957,
0.0768259317,
0.0518359207,
0.0075245625,
0.0024303596,
0.06867145,
0.0379655957,
0.0616126284,
-0.0185673814,
0.0108415717,
-0.008678915,
-0.0512355641,
0.0416703001,
0.0509672575,
-0.0214530844,
0.0280445628,
-0.0991529748,
-0.1005308032,
-0.0345467441,
0.0030645509,
-0.0145544494,
-0.0094835237,
0.0204467792,
0.0584882647,
0.0066085011,
-0.062313512,
-0.0406123698,
0.0370130986,
-0.0458591171,
-0.004679373,
-0.0085242139,
-6.551581765e-33,
-0.0297401715,
-0.0624052398,
0.0412036031,
-0.0207582861,
-0.0184405018,
0.0005875419,
-0.0539792776,
0.0355952084,
-0.0558555983,
0.0189149417,
-0.0169870518,
0.0269806683,
-0.0046587116,
-0.0141326897,
0.0464571975,
-0.0114185624,
0.0109473784,
0.0073382729,
-0.0234072488,
0.0164045878,
0.0593762435,
0.002685338,
0.0516965985,
-0.0028218948,
0.0178378709,
-0.0077671278,
0.0250512101,
0.0555593483,
-0.0539098009,
0.0445094369,
-0.0026960517,
-0.0084759863,
0.0441556014,
-0.0338476524,
-0.0108306846,
0.0052421708,
-0.0406667478,
-0.0302695278,
0.0524080582,
0.0055654417,
-0.0488552377,
-0.0294954721,
0.0193798579,
0.0155669488,
0.0064694476,
-0.0720787048,
0.0219997223,
-0.0153399818,
0.0025266027,
0.0012469533,
-0.0412794612,
0.0018152052,
-0.0392521508,
0.002306093,
-0.0300316103,
0.0325137414,
-0.0061979112,
0.0007746193,
-0.0476275347,
0.016670987,
-0.0036593482,
0.0083175022,
0.0577729642,
0.0372415893,
0.0280797798,
0.0721069723,
0.0058234562,
0.0175902806,
-0.0193664432,
-0.0092733521,
0.0129499026,
0.0886050016,
0.0158889797,
-0.008280836,
0.0281833075,
0.0218557026,
-0.0880715251,
-0.0224955175,
-0.0175050292,
0.0934484005,
0.0081267077,
-0.0007998555,
-0.0102772964,
-0.0212575905,
-0.0660608113,
0.0142902369,
-0.0367015526,
-0.0130208591,
0.0334304161,
-0.0198949222,
0.019666627,
-0.0341375545,
0.0280271564,
-0.0374969877,
-0.0086973282,
0.0233134367,
0.0027067608,
0.0450880565,
-0.0117784562,
0.0499677584,
-0.0606175885,
-0.0274543855,
-0.0203211233,
-0.0232764129,
0.0054975068,
0.0340075232,
0.0138117438,
0.0044349693,
-0.0494764224,
-0.0354759172,
-0.0672539547,
0.003251364,
-0.005822605,
-0.0219773501,
0.042271506,
0.01597137,
-0.0148909101,
0.0107128136,
0.0107432064,
-0.0242929403,
-0.0218708143,
0.048465535,
-0.0158855841,
-0.0003851413,
0.0047685215,
-0.0212062635,
-0.0554040745,
0.0181253403,
0.0391728766,
-0.0173292849,
-0.0229041036,
0.0029770974,
2.827e-7,
0.036683362,
0.061319951,
-0.0062056254,
0.0661168694,
0.0339526385,
0.0146105858,
-0.0470635146,
-0.0278158765,
0.0355552174,
-0.0255425479,
0.008072352,
0.068637833,
0.0377493836,
0.0408146754,
-0.050338801,
-0.0009830315,
-0.0518998094,
-0.0507182702,
-0.0359913372,
0.0051876218,
0.0435995087,
0.0460888669,
0.0327408649,
-0.0128209554,
-0.0256386008,
-0.0658712536,
0.0601105839,
-0.0131889917,
0.0125490976,
0.0069617536,
0.0100965984,
0.0067314669,
0.0229463745,
0.0719797537,
0.011633046,
0.0173717644,
-0.0270333849,
0.059983287,
0.0044790423,
-0.0107008796,
-0.0374122895,
-0.031540107,
0.0129202986,
-0.077049382,
0.0704436749,
-0.0815173611,
-0.0305338819,
0.0165903103,
0.028345542,
-0.0212342348,
-0.0088007115,
0.0037963924,
0.0229078662,
0.026902413,
0.0059511247,
-0.0221508704,
0.0340177789,
-0.0676909834,
-0.0103246523,
0.0260515641,
-0.0165184364,
-0.0570973903,
-0.0320292078,
-0.0231259242,
0.0138122905,
0.0216001775,
0.0014922193,
2.598425441e-34,
0.0390221588,
0.0009639265,
0.0061148009,
-0.0015606011,
0.0549637303,
-0.0461961702,
-0.0027265116,
0.0266945157,
0.0094224392,
-0.1097563207,
-0.0244662594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19501v1 | Monitoring Latent World States in Language Models with Propositional Probes | 2024-06-27T19:28:43 | 2024-06-27T19:28:43 | Jiahai Feng, Stuart Russell, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models are susceptible to bias, sycophancy, backdoors, and other
tendencies that lead to unfaithful responses to the input context. Interpreting
internal states of language models could help monitor and correct unfaithful
behavior. We hypothesize that language models represent their input contexts in
a latent world model, and seek to extract this latent world state from the
activations. We do so with 'propositional probes', which compositionally probe
tokens for lexical information and bind them into logical propositions
representing the world state. For example, given the input context ''Greg is a
nurse. Laura is a physicist.'', we decode the propositions ''WorksAs(Greg,
nurse)'' and ''WorksAs(Laura, physicist)'' from the model's activations. Key to
this is identifying a 'binding subspace' in which bound tokens have high
similarity (''Greg'' and ''nurse'') but unbound ones do not (''Greg'' and
''physicist''). We validate propositional probes in a closed-world setting with
finitely many predicates and properties. Despite being trained on simple
templated contexts, propositional probes generalize to contexts rewritten as
short stories and translated to Spanish. Moreover, we find that in three
settings where language models respond unfaithfully to the input context --
prompt injections, backdoor attacks, and gender bias -- the decoded
propositions remain faithful. This suggests that language models often encode a
faithful world model but decode it unfaithfully, which motivates the search for
better interpretability tools for monitoring LMs. | [
0.0572766848,
0.067456767,
-0.0454316884,
0.0547687598,
-0.0578996427,
0.0038223627,
0.0156553593,
0.0074672508,
0.005860291,
-0.0515846275,
-0.0277639646,
-0.0357684232,
0.0138483355,
0.0556761213,
0.055573605,
-0.0054720338,
0.079708077,
-0.0314174742,
-0.0072305691,
-0.0084382826,
-0.0303789862,
0.0035938488,
0.0119848261,
0.0610619597,
0.0198288467,
-0.0320759416,
-0.0120223286,
-0.0084385956,
0.0143974973,
0.019729713,
-0.0220505614,
0.0418608487,
0.0034647274,
0.0085719181,
0.0000020276,
-0.0697389618,
-0.0117547857,
-0.0220761076,
0.0122900372,
0.0189649295,
0.0128485095,
-0.0406924561,
-0.0147881275,
-0.0085536074,
-0.0333411098,
-0.0637408197,
0.0143261328,
0.0199973509,
0.0386151485,
0.0422390364,
-0.0021909208,
0.0398420133,
-0.0095114429,
-0.0152791375,
-0.0015678826,
-0.0531961471,
0.0471290797,
-0.0615081228,
-0.0037472439,
-0.0022291699,
-0.0528837666,
0.0092799207,
0.0035099019,
-0.0203909166,
-0.0605651923,
0.0232430249,
0.0149539094,
-0.0248272754,
0.0181810949,
0.0315253064,
-0.0007972776,
-0.037306685,
-0.0088511147,
-0.0121503351,
-0.0037564482,
0.019781597,
0.003016528,
0.023248475,
-0.0102272714,
0.0231691804,
0.0757189095,
-0.0130399195,
0.0514248461,
0.0001626543,
-0.0392460115,
0.1047064438,
0.0222197827,
-0.021958515,
-0.0234564506,
0.0062837601,
0.0124641657,
-0.0823441446,
0.0033998792,
0.0080769891,
-0.0330561325,
0.0357348286,
-0.0239992812,
0.0199054424,
0.0191767868,
-0.0334706977,
-0.0042385408,
0.0595917553,
-0.0369655564,
0.069689095,
-0.0100801252,
0.0486168079,
-0.0414717123,
0.0402214192,
-0.0386415236,
-0.0316511467,
-0.0224018749,
-0.0291116703,
0.0015364328,
-0.0031022173,
-0.000941326,
0.0161515716,
-0.0019419083,
0.0166512839,
-0.0384772383,
0.0321298428,
-0.051711563,
-0.0015560737,
-0.0248654839,
0.0085817212,
-0.0150582371,
0.0245834254,
-0.0370398089,
0.0165270753,
-0.0311323926,
-0.0929622054,
-0.036804378,
-0.0009796419,
-0.0219167322,
-0.012535166,
-0.0193895381,
0.0622390397,
0.0360919088,
-0.0302659515,
-0.0324196331,
-0.0668959171,
-0.032612294,
-0.0255873874,
0.012871461,
-0.0414433144,
0.0212290287,
0.031032227,
0.0149536561,
-0.071998693,
0.0051500238,
-0.0139328223,
-0.0335115381,
0.0846751556,
0.0368322134,
-0.0176674873,
-0.034427125,
0.0389869139,
-0.0134571297,
0.0776424929,
0.0124200918,
0.0282660872,
0.0368774161,
-0.001548684,
0.0196896791,
0.036178451,
0.0313263796,
0.0341945477,
-0.0406393781,
0.0329405256,
0.0205400977,
-0.0078592375,
0.0259284992,
0.0417550281,
-0.0070650643,
-0.0154181505,
0.030609211,
0.0405869931,
0.0254967548,
0.0175416619,
0.062007349,
-0.0423836,
-0.0196159426,
0.0626579225,
-0.0911333188,
-0.0261504836,
-0.0453170612,
-0.0422353558,
-0.0062614256,
-0.0114824921,
-0.0015930851,
-0.0282609463,
-0.0198571011,
0.0053789024,
-0.0075143464,
-0.0198466573,
0.0409458168,
0.0485453457,
0.0044274069,
0.0627562404,
0.0431140214,
-0.0527128503,
0.0373032764,
-0.0727823153,
0.0193121191,
0.0418791734,
0.0608758852,
-0.0359196998,
-0.0009198851,
-0.0248737074,
-0.0309717618,
0.0247858167,
0.0113800364,
-0.0135042332,
0.0366164334,
0.0151081821,
-0.0264413282,
-0.0000765197,
0.0329636112,
0.0296433847,
-0.0193173531,
0.0119557539,
-0.0116035063,
-0.0599813536,
0.0178017356,
0.0409599245,
-0.0142650018,
-0.0329202674,
-0.0155259445,
0.0246983785,
0.0300667975,
0.0072113383,
0.012126294,
0.0245658979,
0.01497903,
-0.0587811619,
0.0044745258,
0.0471306592,
-0.0567237139,
-0.020232331,
0.0105100069,
-0.0400638804,
-0.014635751,
0.014214999,
0.0061990344,
-0.0347211808,
0.0330454223,
-0.0263331831,
0.0725065023,
-0.0399574488,
-0.0179219916,
-0.0481587499,
-0.0001315751,
-0.0181937981,
0.0403245129,
-0.0368783809,
0.0172554702,
-0.0141585628,
0.0000987337,
0.0035651543,
-0.001759619,
-0.0164768267,
0.0199132673,
0.0110432077,
-0.0195735022,
0.0110584693,
-0.0294605494,
-0.0132819302,
-0.0442871451,
-0.0513557419,
-0.0224440619,
-0.0265719239,
-0.0051110894,
0.0378890485,
0.0127609009,
-0.0191501863,
-0.0049090525,
0.0108078914,
0.0005545223,
0.0228191167,
0.0595942214,
0.0278466046,
0.0208627339,
0.0078980792,
-0.045814231,
0.0035476098,
-0.0647490695,
0.088493064,
-0.0212141462,
0.0224763714,
-0.0963806584,
0.0255797338,
-0.0100762658,
0.0244418234,
-0.0396194197,
-0.0299874358,
0.0221539121,
0.0086465478,
0.017170066,
0.0655669048,
-0.0164535381,
0.0766821653,
0.0863051936,
-0.0051003522,
-0.0528395921,
-0.017843252,
0.0268828608,
0.0076372488,
-0.0491363853,
-0.0408657938,
0.0107381055,
0.0917106867,
0.0501739122,
-0.0520235412,
-0.0403268263,
0.0627497956,
-0.0626259446,
-0.0695278943,
-0.0187928546,
-0.0522334427,
-0.0228651538,
0.0646238625,
-0.0047614528,
-0.0348121785,
0.0899272263,
-0.0425949208,
0.0051741065,
-0.0027475494,
-0.0144582056,
-0.0448434167,
0.0738644525,
-0.0035340441,
0.0062839845,
0.0204099584,
-0.0619960688,
-0.052408576,
-0.017097773,
0.016243536,
-0.0049829744,
0.0294380896,
-0.0232466999,
-0.0155898482,
-0.0087092975,
-0.048615817,
-0.0846600756,
-0.0065318956,
-0.0172699317,
0.0060288608,
-0.0154077318,
0.0176487975,
-0.0103088981,
0.011343996,
-0.0110519296,
0.0038681407,
-0.0230909083,
0.0004154882,
-0.0700645372,
-0.0168237388,
0.030984737,
-0.0353812613,
0.0249449145,
-0.0540926494,
-0.0098117162,
0.0486236848,
-0.04642101,
0.0319567658,
-0.0119312312,
0.0348704904,
0.0396308824,
-0.0094177518,
-0.0163584575,
-0.024054423,
0.0449571796,
-0.0631001592,
-0.039507553,
0.1038126796,
0.0279441476,
-0.0714331269,
0.0269556027,
-0.040208701,
-0.0054085469,
0.0305701494,
0.0174745563,
-0.0525426865,
-0.0036529272,
0.0442317463,
-0.0040253336,
-0.0351252407,
-0.0416736417,
-0.0250840839,
-0.0713051632,
0.0135797393,
-0.0055754925,
-0.04971819,
-0.0306653809,
-0.0357709378,
0.0193935856,
-0.0017692323,
0.0545303412,
0.0071266703,
-0.0039415192,
0.022393737,
-0.0227228999,
0.0318296477,
-0.0305679366,
0.0132452669,
-0.0367724448,
0.0382936262,
0.0567437783,
0.0337496735,
-0.0169160962,
-0.0296939332,
0.0092960168,
0.0234508831,
0.0152808623,
-0.0090485858,
-0.0156200305,
-0.0307880957,
-0.0220008288,
-0.0097907241,
0.0432225913,
-0.0153858252,
-0.0174630005,
0.0077454643,
0.0752261728,
-0.0082837231,
-0.0190414898,
-0.0238083024,
-0.0149379019,
0.053894829,
0.0769147798,
0.0698160604,
-0.0473912396,
-0.016808467,
-0.0537426285,
-0.0103404718,
0.0432132371,
-0.0598153397,
-0.00954537,
0.0426971763,
-0.0167539921,
-0.0293075033,
-0.0483859628,
0.037353497,
0.0118657425,
0.0298223328,
-0.0111435037,
0.0143304011,
-0.027000891,
-0.0394563116,
0.0267844927,
-0.0462573357,
0.0221604612,
0.0107830772,
0.0281684995,
0.0161422119,
-0.018609751,
-0.0357233658,
-0.0141144292,
-0.054962188,
-0.0532929376,
0.0390428491,
0.0280074328,
0.030146936,
0.0292242002,
-0.047248777,
-0.0265593622,
0.0043370388,
0.0048433254,
-0.0334019586,
0.0462291837,
0.0458605774,
0.000801908,
0.0236623157,
0.0403802395,
-0.0291304328,
-0.0151895266,
0.0548506491,
0.0348966867,
0.0007101761,
-0.0585722551,
0.0263048448,
-0.020019995,
0.0597288385,
-0.0026150213,
-0.0157142933,
-0.038759008,
-0.0260717869,
-0.0198414624,
-0.0149427643,
-0.0068137846,
0.0285537969,
0.0283213574,
0.0056457333,
-0.0016318012,
-0.0279659089,
-0.0558681525,
0.0573804975,
-0.0042128963,
0.0273666847,
0.0465592928,
0.0384021699,
0.0232092943,
0.0122581646,
-0.0135820182,
0.0252621938,
-0.0282476395,
0.0412317738,
-0.0199900959,
0.0311659388,
0.0367364362,
-0.0033309448,
-0.039689295,
0.0259212293,
-0.0680819973,
-0.0111607276,
0.042551022,
0.0588669777,
0.0265200902,
-0.0051693865,
0.0309639014,
-0.0096076149,
0.0090932297,
0.0065873521,
-0.0034306073,
0.0354122557,
-0.0348363407,
0.0157748479,
0.0240842625,
-0.0095007066,
0.0284803174,
0.0443125479,
0.0113327252,
0.0751687661,
0.0128791146,
0.012304306,
-0.034247838,
0.0090590967,
0.009045708,
0.0462235324,
-0.0496003851,
0.0359834284,
-0.1047435924,
-0.0556698553,
0.0154821975,
0.0390106253,
-0.0152334515,
-0.0032642656,
-0.0344603769,
0.0777251497,
0.0284252483,
-0.0454389527,
-0.0532922894,
0.0222057085,
0.0493559018,
-0.0170083065,
-0.0103594065,
-6.291795309e-33,
-0.0423237421,
-0.0649596825,
-0.0103918575,
-0.0049954932,
-0.0075374697,
-0.010825553,
-0.0447823964,
0.0084212022,
0.0022213187,
0.0263852142,
-0.0205768757,
0.035431657,
0.0128510091,
-0.0147295743,
0.0051799244,
-0.0161736812,
0.0492223576,
0.0451043919,
-0.0349003486,
-0.0049551702,
0.0546868481,
0.0279162154,
0.0656446815,
-0.0463390462,
0.0734713823,
-0.0003848868,
-0.0103849825,
0.0463442169,
-0.0481900238,
0.0203556046,
-0.0304946452,
0.0280530304,
0.0216564517,
-0.0175842308,
0.0004512845,
0.0250952337,
-0.0434169099,
-0.0647725686,
0.0779278353,
0.0134218624,
-0.0305100493,
-0.0482643843,
0.0308773369,
-0.02222161,
-0.0085576195,
-0.0012331421,
0.0265518427,
0.0034052357,
0.0221737847,
0.0427054875,
-0.0675701275,
-0.0097351642,
-0.0075789546,
0.006341449,
-0.0208769869,
0.0245639253,
0.0088566653,
0.016095262,
-0.0671321973,
0.0162514988,
0.0118491342,
0.0079895584,
0.0506149679,
0.0147477407,
-0.0071656154,
0.06830924,
0.0427767634,
0.0133622261,
-0.0580690652,
-0.0212684236,
0.0597604774,
0.0178440232,
0.0308193788,
0.064863421,
-0.0031821944,
-0.007729542,
-0.0495804586,
-0.0247244369,
0.0285319034,
0.017166635,
0.0346307047,
-0.009855615,
-0.0286878161,
-0.0250410344,
-0.0648586452,
-0.0613629669,
-0.0338760875,
-0.0156613514,
0.0369249135,
-0.0167757925,
-0.0547291711,
-0.0387607068,
0.0141364057,
-0.0686080381,
-0.0192461237,
0.0020124218,
0.0167878829,
-0.0280136373,
0.0089258933,
0.0397593305,
0.0029701558,
-0.0210705716,
0.0081454748,
-0.0177028496,
0.0459887274,
0.0011240855,
0.0011692813,
0.0109101497,
-0.0488787629,
-0.0272089522,
-0.0495060682,
-0.0075814119,
-0.0350216739,
-0.0001148328,
0.0652093962,
0.0106034083,
-0.0101897102,
0.0042944597,
0.0472372137,
0.0154023962,
-0.0611951239,
0.0531188808,
-0.0291128028,
0.0602584034,
-0.0431383066,
-0.0614071675,
-0.0321034566,
0.0642994791,
0.067822434,
-0.044148352,
0.0118046394,
-0.007530354,
2.82e-7,
0.0396560431,
0.0470904112,
0.0038624664,
0.0349005833,
0.0521115921,
0.0465680584,
-0.0266441889,
0.0723969415,
0.0390646011,
-0.0365551822,
-0.0258340035,
-0.0155164432,
-0.0046603363,
0.0561230667,
-0.0708240792,
0.0585021973,
-0.0355803408,
0.0042030676,
-0.0236935019,
0.0147781111,
0.039242994,
0.0606907345,
0.0601247475,
0.0066249063,
0.0089568058,
-0.050294973,
0.0346197523,
-0.0087387934,
-0.0046875617,
0.0012131606,
0.0055220476,
0.0112470621,
0.0649613515,
0.0101871649,
0.021275023,
0.0496504456,
-0.0330341421,
0.0299583972,
0.000146851,
-0.0194791202,
-0.064459525,
-0.0247111674,
-0.0197124314,
-0.0991354585,
0.0811070576,
-0.0278330036,
-0.019531697,
-0.0492321923,
0.0439939424,
-0.0178071745,
0.0194588602,
0.0234174412,
-0.0343742482,
0.0231841039,
0.0207944643,
0.0184554216,
0.0117086805,
-0.0549102388,
-0.0331182964,
-0.0554133356,
-0.0205876101,
-0.0403021351,
0.015118733,
0.003537738,
0.0185141675,
-0.0756179467,
-0.0157689713,
2.851874421e-34,
0.0048139505,
0.001126284,
0.0445782579,
0.0120613715,
0.0189210679,
-0.0124831153,
-0.048820056,
0.0363887325,
0.0316096991,
-0.0334826559,
-0.0386107191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19500v1 | Knowledge acquisition for dialogue agents using reinforcement learning on graph representations | 2024-06-27T19:28:42 | 2024-06-27T19:28:42 | Selene Baez Santamaria, Shihan Wang, Piek Vossen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We develop an artificial agent motivated to augment its knowledge base beyond
its initial training. The agent actively participates in dialogues with other
agents, strategically acquiring new information. The agent models its knowledge
as an RDF knowledge graph, integrating new beliefs acquired through
conversation. Responses in dialogue are generated by identifying graph patterns
around these new integrated beliefs. We show that policies can be learned using
reinforcement learning to select effective graph patterns during an
interaction, without relying on explicit user feedback. Within this context,
our study is a proof of concept for leveraging users as effective sources of
information. | [
0.0635897666,
0.0259212926,
-0.0031438943,
0.0348962769,
-0.0374964923,
-0.0251053795,
-0.0477696657,
-0.0079295896,
0.0716341436,
-0.0191104878,
0.01452104,
0.0270226132,
-0.0078597562,
0.0445349403,
-0.0265056752,
-0.0536186658,
0.0133794462,
-0.0232066009,
0.048433993,
-0.0089407722,
0.0223537907,
0.0319407508,
-0.0339740403,
-0.0025547743,
-0.0599931814,
-0.0156618617,
-0.026453929,
-0.0069814818,
0.0016070417,
-0.0374020785,
-0.0181105044,
-0.0070778839,
0.0266037099,
0.0452875011,
0.0000018276,
-0.0389393605,
-0.0372411162,
-0.0157590117,
-0.0348287448,
-0.067818433,
0.0240372177,
0.0019864801,
0.0150091089,
-0.0169165414,
-0.0726141259,
-0.0022583583,
0.0339915678,
0.0647528246,
0.0275817756,
0.0600727908,
-0.0098555498,
0.0115492744,
0.0008661713,
-0.0075411797,
0.0454649217,
-0.045705054,
0.042478241,
0.066005066,
0.0459309481,
-0.0435691327,
-0.0380881354,
-0.0315052085,
0.0028328518,
-0.0245066769,
0.0194563363,
0.0278133526,
0.041070614,
-0.0104977395,
-0.0092518115,
0.1263302565,
0.0415951051,
0.0385141782,
0.012830168,
-0.010107263,
0.0062053101,
0.0830689669,
-0.0344460644,
-0.0234675109,
-0.0469353795,
0.0009651193,
-0.0424431302,
-0.0250314716,
0.0352346934,
0.0060958485,
-0.0490080938,
0.0946292803,
-0.0619395711,
-0.0307862032,
0.0306980722,
-0.025569614,
0.0223395471,
-0.037979465,
-0.0479441509,
0.0235073883,
-0.0710417405,
0.0370021202,
-0.0161663592,
0.0814354122,
-0.0059405332,
0.0153604439,
-0.0093147401,
-0.0135127157,
0.0358522907,
0.0527733788,
0.0137589024,
0.0144594107,
-0.0205809753,
0.0311083645,
-0.0104012918,
-0.0087278811,
-0.0926552415,
0.0196880046,
-0.0317127556,
0.0671475232,
0.0195018668,
-0.0699613169,
-0.0164558943,
0.077916421,
-0.0442232937,
0.0681726858,
-0.0042919302,
0.0408877134,
0.0076173572,
0.0206374284,
-0.0910401419,
0.0284606852,
-0.0314779952,
-0.0019819902,
0.0003824261,
-0.0140935201,
0.0255664103,
-0.0066469293,
0.0540809333,
0.0144888274,
-0.017558787,
0.1105529517,
0.0333265141,
-0.0053224484,
-0.0178123433,
-0.0703410879,
0.0003658612,
-0.0306372307,
0.004302159,
-0.0274286065,
0.0242743399,
-0.0245742667,
-0.0154563449,
-0.0258313082,
0.0176571142,
-0.0080696726,
-0.0545638502,
0.0583159104,
-0.0485517755,
-0.0114986133,
-0.001500309,
-0.0115844002,
-0.0765092447,
0.0368896984,
0.0296569224,
0.0320234522,
0.0503424294,
0.0148230763,
-0.0134015484,
-0.0037927057,
0.0367825665,
0.0160222836,
0.0372717679,
0.024904659,
-0.0431491397,
0.0254463218,
0.0040065367,
0.0095197903,
-0.0725324228,
-0.0021574483,
0.0397817232,
0.0578397177,
-0.0224016923,
-0.0126282452,
0.0332054272,
0.0641071647,
-0.0090643493,
0.0507411212,
-0.0097066276,
0.0186518319,
0.0478319079,
0.0114140566,
-0.0037415696,
-0.0419052877,
0.0005668759,
-0.0209982079,
0.0603041649,
-0.0029734124,
0.0927002057,
0.0517617948,
0.0442654081,
0.0257323664,
-0.0227077585,
-0.0329306759,
0.0228945035,
0.0024965268,
-0.0201825239,
-0.013772659,
0.0345318988,
0.0921057016,
0.0561840199,
-0.0278736334,
-0.0624159537,
-0.0105760982,
-0.0206263494,
0.0187009964,
0.0667183101,
-0.0432642624,
-0.0200605337,
-0.0108147999,
-0.0658173636,
-0.0073506301,
-0.0237070769,
0.0352822281,
0.0180652961,
-0.0202975608,
-0.0293174069,
-0.0049824808,
-0.0276876818,
-0.0031542683,
0.0455060564,
0.0175470244,
0.011132936,
0.0116803721,
0.0333472602,
0.0394302011,
0.0107971132,
0.0016953241,
0.0097651137,
0.0539275743,
-0.0318647139,
0.0290772226,
-0.0203561746,
-0.0307549164,
0.0409444086,
-0.0352155715,
-0.0309268627,
-0.0384145714,
-0.0208879989,
-0.0373874903,
0.0542241558,
-0.054917004,
0.0890424475,
0.0071633975,
-0.056921076,
0.0003170616,
-0.028140964,
0.0087757492,
0.0395362265,
-0.0058318805,
-0.0140095735,
0.0215382185,
-0.0156556387,
0.0125168376,
-0.0677131936,
0.0636113882,
-0.0084489696,
0.0172117334,
0.0212283395,
0.0626324639,
-0.0080647497,
-0.0357360207,
0.0226417873,
-0.0126397517,
-0.0314526148,
0.029624017,
-0.0131853111,
-0.0180962328,
0.0168304294,
0.0201880988,
-0.0705270246,
-0.0375013277,
0.0415276587,
0.0038529015,
0.0216187797,
0.0517212264,
0.0243777186,
-0.0127418991,
-0.0269061383,
-0.000284071,
-0.0023642306,
0.0234315526,
0.0408511721,
-0.00004702,
-0.003152956,
-0.016011823,
-0.0670331568,
0.0404037684,
-0.0219911486,
-0.0067740013,
0.0419096425,
-0.0427682884,
-0.0240887254,
0.0285830963,
-0.0076362267,
0.0692502633,
0.0028483206,
-0.0080040032,
-0.0678341389,
0.0195814148,
-0.0641188249,
0.0198236201,
-0.0905211195,
0.0118936375,
0.043518357,
-0.0157654025,
0.0147460317,
0.0112836231,
-0.0492334366,
0.0100257397,
0.0372493863,
-0.0307366438,
-0.0183416102,
-0.0202426817,
0.0167864077,
0.0070341011,
-0.0333408527,
-0.0217121243,
0.1056178063,
0.0296877716,
0.0088096717,
-0.0049666022,
-0.0274693687,
-0.0343683101,
0.024369169,
0.0423628427,
0.0368155017,
-0.0329468437,
-0.0277132429,
-0.0249756817,
-0.0459286645,
0.0805016533,
-0.0071437722,
-0.0084652323,
-0.0015420635,
0.0048215641,
0.0600154698,
-0.0010026331,
-0.0468156002,
0.0135047259,
-0.0073541994,
-0.0004093979,
-0.0010494113,
-0.0534084253,
0.0160671808,
-0.040655341,
0.0365945697,
-0.001778394,
-0.0065595922,
-0.0262756292,
-0.0411065072,
0.0003442036,
0.0589256287,
0.0062674643,
-0.0350978412,
-0.02926163,
0.0446056463,
0.0397835597,
0.0209494662,
-0.0527477823,
-0.0138264401,
0.0027579076,
-0.0403938107,
-0.0394818783,
0.0184207801,
0.0224904884,
-0.0124241244,
-0.0334023833,
0.0185519848,
0.051324591,
0.0244169291,
-0.0340018049,
0.0043064328,
0.0082785105,
0.0195539817,
0.0122589916,
0.0378812961,
-0.1178414971,
0.0120929331,
-0.0346041843,
0.0210337229,
0.0107844071,
-0.0862575024,
-0.0000765215,
-0.0889987126,
-0.0083895037,
-0.0036361555,
-0.0224954002,
-0.0042537628,
-0.0225901641,
-0.0017497865,
-0.0025424091,
-0.0479937121,
-0.0152567783,
-0.0131213879,
-0.0064382078,
0.0144539317,
-0.0124467509,
0.0113348057,
-0.0108585069,
-0.0120271789,
-0.0033337267,
0.0163378287,
0.052575361,
0.0216514487,
-0.0072420742,
-0.0524372905,
0.0729165599,
0.0014934037,
-0.0167116895,
0.0528088808,
-0.0166384727,
0.0145675903,
-0.0337504558,
0.0267858673,
-0.010444982,
-0.0141140381,
-0.011710884,
0.085076645,
-0.0460538752,
-0.0267133787,
0.0057157446,
0.0027965764,
0.0263544954,
0.009346745,
0.0062552881,
0.0167591646,
-0.0379943103,
-0.0437182076,
0.0076753711,
-0.0685372353,
-0.0152375856,
0.0222048648,
-0.0365989655,
0.0337224491,
-0.08968319,
-0.0425134115,
0.0207962468,
0.0155914044,
-0.0074598584,
-0.0196161661,
0.0682864338,
0.0150794908,
-0.033684276,
-0.024668619,
-0.0253831819,
0.0009988904,
-0.0025372675,
-0.0448902249,
-0.0041857488,
-0.0599821098,
-0.0104058404,
-0.0473588966,
0.0347296186,
-0.0459265374,
-0.0399020836,
0.0387680084,
0.0154409958,
0.0975647047,
0.0054892916,
0.0318288207,
0.052985467,
-0.013003353,
-0.042407915,
-0.0656395629,
0.031589672,
0.0415693671,
-0.0075636529,
0.0392704867,
-0.0671924278,
-0.0161885805,
-0.0168111287,
-0.0015175041,
-0.0611515194,
-0.0281388406,
0.0347228572,
0.0195822679,
-0.015698513,
0.0448208936,
0.0036887689,
-0.0232587736,
0.0132266041,
-0.0001632471,
-0.0247057155,
-0.0191386621,
-0.0090758083,
-0.0209297929,
-0.0257564653,
0.0243059322,
-0.0371460021,
0.0199715979,
0.031142937,
0.0038314273,
-0.0241328664,
0.0558539815,
-0.0032950419,
0.0341697782,
-0.0087166317,
0.0114009827,
0.0344840772,
0.0223400611,
0.019535739,
0.0136978393,
0.0678404644,
0.0320166685,
-0.049660515,
-0.0174372345,
-0.0073800776,
-0.0807721242,
-0.069972232,
0.050376568,
0.0028188014,
0.0475008227,
0.031962622,
0.0299014989,
-0.0523658134,
0.0276633073,
0.0186709538,
0.0491854586,
-0.0027505336,
-0.0428307988,
0.0176437926,
0.0249618106,
-0.0043485961,
0.0223928429,
0.0532748029,
0.0203431826,
0.0340537205,
-0.0352045484,
-0.0718425587,
-0.054621309,
-0.0333279967,
-0.0039106547,
0.0636874363,
-0.0087005077,
0.0200412776,
-0.0153263751,
-0.0526439548,
-0.030508481,
0.0420540534,
-0.005331473,
0.0048461608,
0.0268768817,
-0.0085653942,
0.0240858663,
-0.0150789721,
-0.0792975202,
0.0404391624,
-0.0454463996,
-0.0020922797,
0.0026289378,
-5.271890125e-33,
0.0118784299,
-0.0545482673,
0.0402079634,
0.0686127841,
-0.0538455732,
-0.0079227006,
-0.0354991704,
-0.0282072909,
-0.0099954363,
0.0489079654,
0.0122379176,
0.0083387243,
0.0097111557,
0.0058159502,
-0.0253512282,
-0.0168204065,
0.0323111676,
0.0033824064,
0.0242796633,
0.049197156,
0.0512661338,
0.0069091236,
-0.0006033802,
-0.0663573593,
0.0314733759,
0.0138925947,
0.0383067727,
0.0482671745,
0.001553519,
0.0703475922,
0.0099489335,
0.0425724387,
0.0137200821,
0.0069052214,
-0.0117293959,
0.0121314237,
-0.0900008753,
-0.0403988734,
0.0093578976,
0.0120789725,
-0.0812637359,
0.007862228,
0.0275105685,
-0.0011149306,
0.0574491136,
-0.0047721416,
0.0252164342,
0.0244064331,
-0.0344638191,
0.0440071225,
-0.0335481428,
0.0178475268,
-0.0094543863,
-0.0081114434,
0.0136378603,
-0.0246641245,
0.0452189706,
-0.0692933276,
-0.0311663579,
0.0503025502,
-0.0490060411,
-0.0246023014,
-0.0059722289,
0.0253841467,
0.0351493433,
0.0534917414,
0.0127429729,
0.0176059399,
0.0301251933,
-0.0053209104,
-0.0270156004,
0.0717711374,
-0.0577807389,
0.0453160517,
-0.0410920158,
-0.024996018,
-0.0722006559,
-0.0080400836,
0.0454904363,
0.0544172712,
-0.0153135331,
0.0022049355,
-0.0317954235,
-0.0047392366,
-0.0187147334,
0.029028086,
-0.0128468415,
-0.0488009229,
-0.0055526886,
0.019080909,
-0.0055781901,
0.0064287884,
-0.0251713358,
-0.0715252459,
-0.0317088142,
0.0516794734,
-0.0470935926,
0.008205004,
-0.0142442491,
-0.0393599458,
-0.0505498685,
-0.0128344614,
-0.0105708959,
-0.056454435,
0.0070020002,
0.0458973646,
0.0083288802,
0.0223662984,
-0.0200308245,
-0.020324111,
-0.0335723013,
0.0103017595,
-0.0228027981,
-0.0206001736,
0.0305029638,
0.0540356971,
-0.0311951637,
0.0272698645,
-0.0088870442,
0.0027738386,
-0.0129613113,
-0.0009478567,
0.0024815393,
0.0100615676,
-0.0566814318,
-0.0410585441,
-0.0274289865,
0.0133468127,
-0.0039239186,
-0.0636752844,
-0.0030583311,
-0.0168601274,
2.506e-7,
-0.0228277054,
0.0464949384,
0.0429960601,
0.044395797,
0.0387285687,
0.0251101088,
-0.0260470863,
0.018057853,
-0.0001039083,
-0.0403502807,
0.052637767,
0.0477035604,
-0.0233614407,
0.033295203,
-0.081919238,
-0.0539834797,
-0.0373407193,
-0.0680735186,
-0.0323762558,
-0.00160236,
0.0254134461,
-0.0205222685,
0.042106621,
0.0005043222,
0.0155999986,
-0.0299746674,
0.0335947126,
0.0119788228,
0.0154794194,
0.0073292996,
0.0247545484,
-0.0258039851,
-0.0320474282,
0.039996773,
-0.0117414277,
0.0265628565,
-0.0567670502,
0.0072863349,
-0.0011761546,
-0.0118910652,
-0.0079641212,
-0.0053205863,
0.0399132483,
0.0338926651,
0.0337733328,
-0.0500901714,
-0.0262693129,
0.0109796552,
-0.0278010275,
-0.0473067835,
-0.0456116721,
-0.00735691,
-0.0393112227,
0.0079751797,
0.0020882809,
0.0286296792,
0.0277905725,
-0.0305505805,
0.0452086292,
-0.0040178518,
-0.0188731737,
-0.0505827107,
-0.0010033381,
-0.0238783453,
-0.006768432,
0.0010919099,
0.022281995,
1.654636868e-34,
0.0114983423,
0.0237662625,
-0.0232192185,
-0.0114025483,
0.0339233205,
0.001959743,
-0.0176213644,
0.0028206254,
0.0889181569,
-0.0568150543,
-0.0114849191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19497v1 | Inclusivity in Large Language Models: Personality Traits and Gender Bias in Scientific Abstracts | 2024-06-27T19:26:11 | 2024-06-27T19:26:11 | Naseela Pervez, Alexander J. Titus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly utilized to assist in
scientific and academic writing, helping authors enhance the coherence of their
articles. Previous studies have highlighted stereotypes and biases present in
LLM outputs, emphasizing the need to evaluate these models for their alignment
with human narrative styles and potential gender biases. In this study, we
assess the alignment of three prominent LLMs - Claude 3 Opus, Mistral AI Large,
and Gemini 1.5 Flash - by analyzing their performance on benchmark
text-generation tasks for scientific abstracts. We employ the Linguistic
Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC) framework to extract lexical, psychological, and
social features from the generated texts. Our findings indicate that, while
these models generally produce text closely resembling human authored content,
variations in stylistic features suggest significant gender biases. This
research highlights the importance of developing LLMs that maintain a diversity
of writing styles to promote inclusivity in academic discourse. | [
0.0521606393,
0.06679333,
-0.0151730906,
-0.0037506316,
-0.0367665961,
-0.0097520864,
0.0755817965,
-0.0401129946,
-0.0066300784,
-0.0419536531,
-0.0251678284,
-0.0531036668,
0.016892653,
0.0373983793,
0.0466676466,
-0.0192557238,
0.0145434942,
0.0131057752,
0.0720492378,
-0.0284775905,
0.0259890612,
0.0412018523,
0.0338492133,
0.0386175476,
0.0596151687,
-0.0435231812,
0.0098866224,
0.0109615894,
0.010449267,
-0.0070492048,
0.0419336408,
0.0687157065,
0.0018095139,
0.0401899293,
0.0000018463,
-0.0784373358,
-0.0051366771,
0.0330265015,
0.0461706966,
0.0211503152,
0.0691686943,
0.0148197357,
-0.0143639147,
0.0457724705,
-0.0163015947,
-0.0151142972,
0.0197949447,
0.0455095172,
0.0132731218,
0.0387272611,
-0.0097415457,
-0.0060257711,
0.0087691983,
0.0042117364,
-0.0320874304,
0.0549635701,
0.0181931946,
-0.029390173,
-0.0119729117,
0.0397643074,
0.028368555,
0.0132811693,
-0.034529645,
-0.0434365757,
0.0196011681,
0.0126805771,
-0.0640158057,
-0.0391013511,
0.0249725562,
-0.0052259988,
0.0777629688,
-0.0133647062,
0.0263233222,
-0.0122854095,
0.0164958425,
0.0292284954,
-0.0488444865,
0.046839416,
-0.0140558518,
-0.0433730297,
0.0366230793,
0.0185228288,
-0.0301097594,
0.0389890298,
-0.0040126075,
0.0483429059,
0.0211583208,
-0.0390830487,
0.0042473879,
-0.0036920751,
0.0053973319,
-0.0784639046,
0.0080540655,
0.0219837837,
-0.0078513538,
0.0113264164,
-0.0206278767,
-0.0597542301,
0.0536919311,
-0.0554857068,
0.0029059788,
0.0207240563,
0.0334492512,
-0.0263885949,
0.041066587,
0.0323420689,
0.0119180372,
-0.0080467965,
-0.0139112948,
-0.0095833112,
-0.0075772665,
-0.0368370824,
-0.0114563787,
-0.0061448673,
0.0038048285,
-0.0008164913,
-0.0453540273,
-0.0250002053,
0.0035056353,
-0.0073915236,
-0.0087324036,
0.0144054266,
-0.0333959609,
0.0286545102,
0.0145983817,
0.038851399,
-0.032133732,
0.0090295384,
0.0009654587,
-0.0601382516,
0.0109779499,
0.0448580422,
-0.0150253689,
-0.056815885,
0.0044458988,
-0.0106595755,
-0.0108859343,
-0.0337861478,
0.0064140931,
-0.0402884297,
-0.004319638,
-0.0583574846,
0.0138967428,
-0.0744705424,
0.0182405449,
0.0534403324,
-0.0051183826,
-0.0673033595,
0.0074296948,
0.0464195795,
-0.000036984,
-0.0276671108,
-0.0198256392,
0.0151272453,
0.0883296132,
-0.0100194262,
0.0142827407,
0.03157942,
0.0500921942,
-0.0129121607,
0.034959469,
-0.0170089956,
0.0229753908,
0.0067491774,
0.0035416109,
0.0344114453,
-0.0103657013,
0.0179753061,
-0.0047789859,
0.0572543219,
0.0452949256,
0.0643130615,
0.0082294289,
0.0091296984,
0.0706348419,
0.0837749094,
0.0015826717,
0.0499850847,
0.0203372519,
0.0237502716,
0.0549863763,
0.0275848638,
-0.0097079361,
0.0169675127,
0.0320689343,
0.0157454275,
0.0031306797,
0.0563047379,
-0.0096679963,
-0.0464605391,
-0.0415730365,
0.0466889143,
-0.008470797,
-0.0230740048,
-0.0043736696,
-0.0077051385,
-0.0012803962,
-0.0080351215,
0.030572217,
-0.081902802,
-0.0144766159,
-0.0042390996,
0.0331296511,
0.0633092672,
0.0414023548,
-0.0114053171,
-0.0059662526,
-0.0312566347,
-0.021275606,
0.0822961405,
0.0411789976,
0.0211168714,
-0.0308550075,
-0.0401913039,
0.0075531653,
-0.0092447298,
0.0026377663,
0.016199531,
0.0261281747,
0.0444595702,
0.0183141176,
-0.0084695136,
-0.0832422078,
0.0325540043,
-0.1075631082,
-0.0230850242,
-0.0119686769,
-0.0337389819,
0.0170187037,
0.0059929229,
-0.0480241403,
0.041032996,
-0.0182687696,
-0.0236801077,
-0.0213377532,
0.049672462,
-0.0132079907,
0.0233715121,
0.0110981343,
-0.0688086897,
-0.0009559134,
0.0128303021,
0.0430745594,
-0.0098673552,
0.0425839387,
-0.0369982161,
-0.0149531867,
-0.0094530964,
0.0016916371,
-0.0287663173,
0.0170361884,
-0.0373950005,
0.0153265772,
-0.0030338566,
0.0143839931,
0.0285987984,
-0.039776314,
0.0019766393,
-0.0546247959,
-0.0312690325,
0.0165855605,
0.015525911,
-0.007058315,
0.0370604433,
-0.0345235653,
-0.0269036517,
-0.0590729378,
-0.0694450438,
0.0202531498,
-0.0014245383,
0.0112545714,
-0.0030024305,
-0.0224048812,
-0.0321387835,
0.0535829999,
-0.0302611999,
-0.0661364123,
0.0047221826,
0.0105326138,
0.0668685585,
-0.0344196558,
0.0128789991,
-0.0716375336,
-0.0226823371,
-0.0503015406,
0.0463410579,
0.0677894726,
0.0214765985,
-0.0267765597,
0.0308226421,
-0.0229897518,
-0.0567726642,
-0.0123119261,
-0.029541241,
0.0263581704,
0.0194224268,
0.0597654916,
0.0975259319,
0.0518685356,
0.0363193639,
0.0482514352,
0.0247539766,
-0.0077196136,
-0.0307855271,
0.0171679165,
0.037647821,
0.0238652322,
-0.1012214422,
0.0462586135,
0.0228150003,
0.0087904604,
-0.0147833442,
-0.0111232102,
0.0520496406,
-0.0369488113,
-0.0448226631,
0.0346578136,
-0.0267242119,
-0.0095535032,
0.0206562784,
0.0094523141,
-0.0118297311,
0.0306493565,
-0.0345321074,
0.0152110439,
-0.0632283688,
-0.0212971941,
-0.0611017197,
0.0202958286,
-0.0187293887,
0.0120920837,
0.0461361036,
0.0090333866,
-0.071309492,
-0.0378212444,
0.0141398339,
-0.0138126267,
0.0117713371,
-0.0280275904,
-0.0214261785,
-0.0126511343,
0.0052183922,
-0.0148967113,
-0.0607321523,
0.0003364584,
0.029952094,
0.0762335882,
-0.0579709336,
-0.0481731594,
-0.0023070464,
0.0624931604,
0.0328252167,
-0.0652183816,
-0.009745786,
-0.0178912599,
0.0022444872,
0.0768776461,
-0.0026286901,
0.0306234807,
-0.0809622109,
-0.0008365824,
0.0243499689,
-0.0464891568,
0.0199641194,
-0.003513573,
-0.053472694,
0.0243169591,
-0.0710338056,
-0.0513185598,
-0.0211731866,
0.0667396262,
-0.0233612489,
0.0009591486,
0.1433056295,
0.0067405812,
-0.0298041776,
-0.0157903619,
-0.0524659939,
0.0565643162,
0.026943231,
0.0515196435,
-0.0131001621,
0.0369576067,
-0.0076941294,
0.017843429,
-0.0586325079,
-0.0340345427,
-0.0378679484,
-0.0800103545,
0.020542711,
0.0215321109,
-0.028024694,
0.0262234136,
-0.0280188024,
-0.0081460252,
0.0129304258,
0.0024758142,
0.0091055091,
-0.0269650631,
0.017403625,
0.0317825042,
-0.0766973123,
-0.0309527647,
-0.0136307925,
-0.0522532202,
0.0322465338,
-0.0023165469,
0.0661279038,
-0.044971291,
-0.0065138126,
-0.0351041518,
-0.0060452027,
0.0004956142,
0.0026328138,
0.0217860173,
-0.040861547,
0.0209935121,
-0.0815912858,
0.0667789429,
0.0311662294,
0.0063253287,
0.0365972891,
0.0272897668,
0.0074096951,
-0.0263466425,
-0.0959928408,
0.0170461368,
0.0065595587,
0.0681651011,
0.0197623726,
-0.0501704514,
-0.0442451835,
-0.0175288469,
0.0215103999,
0.0289012454,
-0.0489115566,
-0.0235240664,
-0.0167922303,
-0.0156257972,
-0.0411743261,
-0.09162049,
0.0046855113,
0.0043650502,
0.005145553,
-0.0280061308,
0.0182198435,
-0.0226703305,
-0.0591236353,
0.006343869,
0.0099047329,
0.0341741517,
-0.0021699697,
-0.0160419624,
0.00371333,
-0.0290655941,
0.0000667974,
0.0298459176,
-0.0032087706,
-0.0508774593,
0.0333816782,
-0.00427619,
0.0228386484,
-0.0115434648,
0.0324291699,
-0.0481808931,
0.0079026995,
0.0164693333,
0.0277331285,
0.0538396165,
-0.0285513494,
0.0112579698,
0.0014974549,
0.0032625599,
0.0020536499,
0.0100208987,
-0.0049515585,
-0.0054577324,
-0.013125726,
-0.0550264232,
0.009920653,
0.0475259535,
-0.0381796733,
-0.0641128123,
0.0466572605,
-0.0436511151,
-0.0340309106,
-0.0844410434,
-0.0171485879,
-0.0132516176,
-0.0347269773,
-0.0014916038,
0.02815146,
-0.02089216,
0.0188822504,
-0.0649580881,
0.0122190574,
-0.0460946895,
0.0460399091,
-0.025797287,
0.0439275466,
0.0010309925,
-0.012137169,
-0.0353341512,
-0.0209437888,
-0.0626963899,
0.0434352458,
0.0461406782,
0.0361624323,
0.0019783054,
0.0138478642,
-0.0089552021,
0.0144056696,
-0.0859523043,
0.0004357795,
-0.0103789736,
0.0102044726,
-0.0350552574,
-0.0194366053,
0.0843496844,
-0.0265353173,
0.0125344954,
-0.0246242154,
0.0482605472,
0.0260972138,
0.0139020374,
0.0159339327,
-0.0016980913,
-0.0150062498,
-0.061260391,
0.0701582581,
0.0646136999,
-0.019781528,
-0.0037093088,
-0.0423313454,
-0.001777441,
-0.0196446199,
0.0239334553,
-0.0157655682,
0.0171142258,
-0.0276508331,
-0.0988936871,
-0.0252200607,
0.0491637699,
-0.0116075696,
0.0083931768,
-0.06165649,
-0.0133527396,
0.0535447858,
-0.020805195,
-0.057862509,
-0.0554498136,
0.0517148264,
-0.0370259173,
-0.0125315962,
-0.0122337053,
-6.022435554e-33,
-0.0357262865,
-0.0602619462,
0.0066393605,
0.0176635683,
-0.0495132692,
0.0025718065,
-0.0519524068,
0.0022679653,
-0.0127030276,
0.0419791117,
-0.0373729132,
0.0199597608,
-0.0015780956,
0.0117536206,
0.0316759869,
0.0582418852,
0.0508689061,
-0.0028155455,
-0.0480094701,
-0.0264520105,
0.0127094192,
-0.0145730879,
0.0092520062,
-0.0507309213,
0.0762835741,
-0.0746926963,
0.0186722558,
-0.0256703775,
-0.0043424023,
0.0078749983,
-0.0074583651,
0.0309601277,
0.010193022,
-0.0248982962,
-0.0037625022,
0.0476533026,
-0.0120842308,
-0.0352284797,
0.0378705561,
0.0091949767,
0.0281647444,
-0.0529413745,
0.0515715852,
0.002403276,
-0.0653720573,
-0.0455315746,
0.0902103111,
0.013793828,
0.0172859002,
-0.0416956805,
-0.0786886141,
0.0255329479,
-0.0203994028,
0.0446614586,
-0.0407661349,
0.0080682505,
-0.0188069679,
0.009266464,
-0.0344284251,
0.0081114341,
-0.0081692655,
-0.001035688,
-0.0020469476,
0.0084861917,
0.0180041268,
0.0477201603,
0.0486250892,
0.0837174132,
-0.0030955158,
-0.0238972157,
0.0314375982,
-0.0093245329,
0.0368964002,
0.0679343641,
-0.0006792645,
-0.0010409494,
-0.0280502811,
-0.0129932137,
0.0270947758,
-0.0132484306,
0.0388889536,
-0.0352831781,
-0.043047756,
-0.0503652506,
-0.0010819685,
-0.0184623245,
0.0211228877,
-0.0110029913,
-0.0007696326,
-0.0356292389,
-0.0273919627,
-0.0158911403,
-0.004142486,
-0.0263438672,
-0.023866849,
0.0182994418,
-0.0565523915,
0.0237102695,
-0.0112280734,
0.0286820903,
-0.0779295042,
0.0153000699,
-0.0189440344,
0.0528887287,
0.0233615469,
0.0294171963,
0.0036258604,
0.0099230586,
-0.0543927774,
-0.03727521,
0.0078120213,
0.015370518,
0.0137428874,
0.0127288913,
-0.0171658117,
0.0215980634,
0.019915672,
0.0135937538,
0.0328432247,
0.0140590081,
-0.0285734423,
-0.0269740466,
0.0155213289,
0.0044158529,
-0.0117230071,
0.0109998593,
-0.0230664089,
0.0257395506,
0.0409871377,
-0.038942758,
0.0039347121,
-0.0563168004,
2.64e-7,
0.0340891555,
0.0723451525,
-0.0030568806,
0.0279002469,
0.0283462498,
0.0269490387,
0.0157508273,
0.0578913279,
0.0434221849,
0.0315387137,
-0.0121818995,
0.0330410115,
0.0097839301,
0.0576504953,
-0.0547781102,
0.0180153195,
-0.0963125005,
-0.0185020491,
-0.0411040001,
0.0198871773,
0.0274347793,
-0.0167775247,
-0.0029272756,
0.0007412294,
-0.0342352577,
-0.0032481621,
0.0402048081,
0.0224555153,
-0.0139405904,
0.0739002302,
0.0128464578,
-0.0086220866,
0.0392167941,
0.0173966046,
0.0069011012,
0.0114562297,
0.0177795663,
0.0441066511,
-0.0141134532,
0.0395101234,
0.0708563551,
-0.0010803901,
-0.021715669,
-0.0386020653,
0.0408965982,
0.0220083296,
-0.0482860208,
-0.0812278241,
-0.0309516136,
-0.0316001438,
0.0564148724,
-0.0155706005,
-0.0049976003,
0.0390706398,
-0.0036315771,
-0.0308691896,
0.0093756644,
-0.0081963791,
-0.0277902652,
-0.009010247,
-0.0143585717,
-0.061702095,
-0.0252433252,
0.0049932767,
0.0030640466,
-0.0502322167,
0.0298336372,
2.629455278e-34,
0.0491920151,
0.0271745939,
-0.0122173987,
0.023621222,
0.0300749261,
0.0048963265,
0.0163245313,
0.0255734585,
0.0533974506,
-0.0144744702,
0.004614952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19493v1 | Development and Evaluation of a Retrieval-Augmented Generation Tool for Creating SAPPhIRE Models of Artificial Systems | 2024-06-27T19:20:09 | 2024-06-27T19:20:09 | Anubhab Majumder, Kausik Bhattacharya, Amaresh Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representing systems using the SAPPhIRE causality model is found useful in
supporting design-by-analogy. However, creating a SAPPhIRE model of artificial
or biological systems is an effort-intensive process that requires human
experts to source technical knowledge from multiple technical documents
regarding how the system works. This research investigates how to leverage
Large Language Models (LLMs) in creating structured descriptions of systems
using the SAPPhIRE model of causality. This paper, the second part of the
two-part research, presents a new Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) tool for
generating information related to SAPPhIRE constructs of artificial systems and
reports the results from a preliminary evaluation of the tool's success -
focusing on the factual accuracy and reliability of outcomes. | [
0.0210828818,
0.0327520557,
-0.0480598696,
0.0143558271,
-0.037531361,
-0.0262556635,
0.0010450516,
-0.0024212291,
-0.0295040123,
-0.0526645593,
0.0039247861,
0.0297663398,
-0.0270883497,
0.0467201807,
0.0388549864,
-0.0130062448,
0.033204034,
0.0157268215,
0.0023224063,
0.0103636188,
0.0062592616,
0.0085976543,
0.0063737407,
0.0649345294,
-0.0225634966,
-0.0019222858,
-0.0243235417,
0.0391750336,
0.0129548749,
-0.0748170689,
-0.0413122289,
0.0019600412,
0.0438512452,
0.0390018187,
0.0000019207,
-0.0898729041,
-0.0178221148,
0.0413805842,
-0.0219418108,
-0.0090195276,
0.0237636138,
-0.0040250081,
0.0225237012,
0.006268153,
0.0011721037,
-0.0104216915,
0.0493357927,
0.0084390212,
0.0254414473,
0.0334194377,
-0.0110990023,
-0.0574360378,
0.0606504343,
0.0239400342,
-0.015515158,
0.0005527068,
-0.0014483531,
0.0967665389,
0.1026656479,
0.0340443514,
0.0416578539,
0.0387193337,
0.023601301,
-0.0316066034,
0.0444814675,
-0.0133853601,
0.0102999751,
-0.0059591243,
0.0311878771,
0.0356737822,
0.0957695618,
-0.0451997891,
-0.0036855172,
-0.0082777217,
0.0062825019,
0.0705040246,
-0.0689148232,
0.0318627954,
-0.0013450725,
0.0034989126,
0.0207319614,
-0.0207959339,
0.0434129164,
-0.0152695365,
-0.0224192757,
0.0280532539,
0.0237841774,
-0.0243298467,
-0.0581247061,
-0.0380644202,
0.0598405525,
-0.015446201,
-0.0290544741,
0.0559341572,
-0.0381814949,
0.010039893,
0.0062366342,
0.0037507506,
0.0292024296,
-0.0358461924,
0.0579135641,
0.0155653367,
0.0396180041,
-0.008352627,
-0.0225176327,
0.0338750035,
-0.0193519536,
-0.0079585593,
-0.0616024099,
0.0138737056,
-0.1045044661,
-0.0557985865,
-0.0162110198,
0.0471343696,
-0.0297073666,
-0.0163011625,
-0.0335657485,
0.0522804484,
-0.0196634419,
-0.0049503548,
-0.0566040501,
-0.0063650361,
0.0148446066,
0.0170082469,
-0.0405992121,
-0.0385401584,
-0.0239781309,
0.020041842,
-0.0040443963,
-0.0698194206,
0.0055887126,
0.0137205785,
-0.0352484621,
0.0153268529,
-0.0422808267,
0.0943933204,
0.030762529,
-0.0059583574,
-0.0426657461,
-0.0583154298,
0.0381820053,
-0.024935551,
-0.0152355097,
-0.0550151803,
-0.0193615165,
0.0514231883,
-0.0010934544,
0.0136985099,
0.0251384284,
0.0070557198,
0.0063929628,
0.0258875564,
-0.0546068735,
0.0376508646,
0.014196841,
-0.0050712484,
0.037280634,
0.0279856212,
0.04879779,
-0.0020131429,
-0.0011757027,
-0.0116276583,
0.0435509905,
-0.0039966768,
-0.0462818928,
-0.0528640598,
-0.0685158074,
0.0025648596,
-0.0023391419,
0.0249857381,
-0.0245303512,
0.0069397925,
-0.0377857536,
0.0766477659,
0.0221381877,
0.0053666933,
0.0650080144,
0.0880636275,
0.0885805562,
-0.0081901662,
0.0232874434,
-0.0176560208,
0.0062404219,
0.0220053252,
-0.0290871039,
0.0397041999,
-0.0241892636,
0.0108937016,
-0.0081881899,
-0.0549061969,
-0.0300682504,
0.0096331686,
-0.0458990373,
-0.0448026061,
0.0571702495,
0.0018136827,
-0.0160228144,
0.0105429729,
-0.002199491,
-0.0343774036,
0.0000841053,
-0.0584324412,
0.0299211331,
0.1131656617,
0.0855858475,
-0.0800223276,
0.0026902193,
0.02072699,
-0.0759443566,
0.0313882828,
0.0305614732,
-0.0271232948,
-0.0841431022,
-0.02726187,
-0.0286840927,
-0.0377397649,
0.0009013438,
0.0389694534,
-0.041378174,
-0.0021012842,
0.0234991852,
0.0266599134,
-0.0773851052,
0.0099407528,
-0.0372284465,
-0.0189648196,
-0.044387117,
-0.0161954127,
0.0061376109,
0.0610212348,
-0.046563901,
0.0703557283,
0.0549906865,
-0.0454472564,
-0.0256799888,
0.0188305825,
-0.0009450043,
0.0689776242,
0.0041241506,
-0.0422608443,
0.0451389998,
0.0524979867,
0.0244902708,
-0.0748345777,
0.0558221303,
-0.0482977331,
0.052812364,
-0.0235808715,
0.0230347253,
-0.0027308154,
-0.013845996,
-0.0353259854,
0.0506719872,
0.0333610438,
0.0041084718,
0.0009848563,
-0.012122076,
0.0564358458,
-0.0453737788,
0.0059058587,
0.0288140457,
-0.0137284696,
0.0228902083,
0.0810674727,
-0.0424744971,
-0.0201549213,
0.004159939,
-0.0477137193,
-0.0493788049,
0.0244496539,
0.0141325025,
0.00896475,
-0.0164745748,
-0.0025053497,
0.0132582132,
0.0067692767,
0.0123653105,
-0.0105495714,
-0.018508926,
0.0380902663,
0.0075237877,
-0.0727048963,
-0.0249169022,
-0.0182047635,
-0.0517810583,
0.0664035976,
0.0834074467,
-0.0219278019,
-0.1017362699,
0.0188287292,
-0.004466698,
-0.027577579,
0.0074340878,
-0.0001031807,
0.0376289263,
-0.0067035444,
0.032524664,
0.0078500025,
-0.004605148,
0.0279118698,
0.0438214317,
-0.0218895078,
-0.0373150073,
-0.0068723499,
-0.0302798003,
-0.0031339594,
0.0067936452,
-0.0291031171,
-0.0051022754,
0.002763791,
-0.007666368,
-0.0114317453,
0.0017929287,
0.0373203978,
-0.0001526477,
-0.0213829223,
-0.0313494243,
-0.0680393204,
-0.0018065562,
0.0396648049,
0.0052599865,
-0.0823979005,
0.0520008989,
-0.0203256421,
0.0474090837,
-0.0161340013,
-0.0161933806,
-0.0360020846,
0.0517281294,
0.0003465429,
0.0348206833,
0.0313735791,
0.0200995393,
-0.0232633762,
-0.0278063212,
0.0054850089,
-0.0022865292,
-0.0105183674,
-0.0512320735,
0.0273127276,
0.001042685,
0.0041803578,
-0.0524333343,
0.0054674819,
-0.003390884,
0.0732760951,
0.0170579515,
0.0063827932,
-0.0611557662,
0.0416156314,
0.0722475201,
-0.0202113949,
0.0093301861,
-0.0281272177,
-0.0219199508,
0.0004290228,
0.0101224547,
-0.0651462674,
0.0547546111,
-0.0110868132,
0.0493596345,
-0.0283832587,
0.0148231061,
0.0200352222,
-0.0579858683,
-0.0167627633,
0.0147599662,
-0.006941549,
-0.028469203,
0.028699927,
-0.0314426832,
-0.0395682715,
-0.0113738906,
0.0505389385,
0.0309607424,
-0.0354575329,
0.0294912178,
-0.024894258,
-0.0573039539,
0.0527574308,
0.0444367453,
-0.0695129931,
0.0416323803,
-0.0223737452,
0.0076405131,
-0.0198537763,
-0.0035907738,
-0.0124936346,
-0.0754752681,
0.036199104,
0.0067317006,
-0.0434328951,
-0.0036725977,
-0.038994018,
-0.0358198024,
0.0480629802,
-0.0345031023,
0.0511485711,
-0.0233354736,
-0.0032382747,
0.0066172588,
-0.0259629861,
-0.0344192833,
-0.0153738335,
0.0133525385,
0.0224942211,
0.0600348487,
0.02622924,
-0.0264721084,
-0.0222929064,
0.0174041949,
0.0025550551,
0.0735886171,
-0.0264746714,
-0.0549212508,
0.0407786109,
-0.0067170435,
-0.0199816804,
-0.002986924,
-0.0009922846,
-0.0449757688,
-0.0120245721,
0.0708207265,
-0.0176942237,
0.0071450276,
-0.0733648464,
-0.0451492779,
-0.0003204059,
0.0295814406,
0.0141255669,
0.0109488647,
-0.0254588015,
0.0174105652,
-0.0087917438,
-0.0063582608,
-0.0077952147,
-0.0332588963,
-0.0343464017,
0.0103017204,
-0.0463850014,
-0.0168676246,
-0.0195666067,
0.016004784,
0.0261377096,
-0.0036634488,
0.0178939588,
-0.0301539339,
-0.0336784385,
0.0345723145,
-0.0151492422,
0.0066345097,
-0.0110152243,
-0.0512291901,
0.0392792523,
-0.0574586019,
-0.0184143353,
0.0285514928,
0.0876690969,
-0.023278147,
-0.013589262,
0.057154309,
0.0320198722,
-0.0366728157,
0.0172713548,
-0.02689269,
0.0125545794,
0.007124559,
-0.0201802738,
-0.0061375694,
-0.0363316312,
0.0041767503,
-0.0174673051,
-0.0236821286,
-0.0370930433,
0.0447344109,
-0.006982496,
0.0403858498,
0.0204099864,
-0.0295242313,
0.0356060602,
0.0551408008,
0.0026781715,
-0.0195951052,
0.0074299905,
-0.0007653447,
0.0233828016,
-0.078274034,
-0.0237077121,
-0.0457566753,
0.0247806292,
-0.0041854964,
-0.0015989135,
0.0383186638,
-0.0478464849,
-0.0336427577,
0.0036073234,
0.0047030952,
0.0229320899,
0.0246093087,
0.0416362472,
-0.001461683,
-0.0229681712,
-0.0219474044,
-0.0034911081,
-0.0517306179,
0.0201090369,
-0.0133827003,
0.0575447418,
0.0116927149,
0.0343297943,
-0.0349736102,
0.015899051,
-0.0383022465,
-0.0610163435,
-0.0132841235,
-0.0392899029,
0.0510189831,
0.0205718912,
0.0177358929,
-0.0366065688,
-0.0000810437,
-0.0079369321,
0.0457297675,
0.0176641252,
0.0004976431,
-0.0079868976,
0.0553966947,
-0.0324326754,
-0.0503363498,
0.0486251228,
0.022913022,
0.0127776694,
-0.0895661712,
-0.0448435359,
-0.0136769116,
-0.0103174653,
0.0097864196,
0.0085743116,
-0.0226166341,
-0.03662581,
-0.1259202361,
-0.0336039811,
0.0160846356,
0.0561167002,
0.018393958,
-0.0093249483,
0.0347399935,
0.0585769601,
0.0271709617,
-0.0705755353,
0.0016424267,
0.008235205,
-0.0792901888,
-0.0014023945,
-0.017364312,
-5.611605054e-33,
-0.0254614856,
-0.0407340415,
0.0626657158,
-0.0097689871,
-0.011781889,
0.0074425712,
-0.0609958284,
-0.019407412,
0.0035501425,
0.0074742008,
0.0210774839,
-0.0222638994,
-0.0042454102,
-0.0157309882,
0.0171213932,
0.0410111658,
0.0423040502,
0.0275176577,
-0.0369762965,
0.0333659463,
0.0695134401,
-0.0074280463,
0.0159828383,
-0.0669772923,
0.037123993,
-0.0344468318,
0.0191233028,
-0.0068838932,
-0.0282566492,
0.0391437933,
-0.0141491294,
0.0333245732,
0.0118905315,
-0.0243843161,
-0.00951894,
0.0232661422,
-0.0091477651,
-0.0014761004,
0.050595969,
-0.0460052788,
0.005213405,
-0.0473733768,
0.0377936512,
-0.022186419,
-0.0390567705,
0.0636678338,
0.0533716604,
-0.0367104374,
-0.0181311946,
-0.0381753445,
-0.1195446923,
0.0030160705,
-0.0308313034,
0.040515095,
0.0077314493,
0.01556304,
-0.0094577195,
0.0209048875,
0.0332887918,
0.0299164671,
0.0080547649,
0.0177591983,
0.0659110919,
0.0466578826,
0.0538051054,
0.0320295542,
0.0369735546,
0.0047218832,
0.011426826,
0.0031504519,
-0.001740537,
0.059346538,
0.0639050007,
0.0319317318,
-0.0169077106,
0.0005239005,
-0.0927908793,
0.0093773883,
-0.0530480742,
0.0653118864,
0.0545605607,
0.0164135247,
-0.0224176664,
-0.0190215837,
-0.0250524152,
0.0155415274,
-0.0352102965,
-0.0247926805,
0.018241711,
-0.0073201582,
-0.0339388475,
0.0122773629,
0.0020291756,
-0.0415602811,
0.0008568022,
0.0250489432,
0.0024712416,
-0.0062534623,
-0.0380551964,
-0.0194820743,
-0.0447736904,
-0.0344103687,
-0.0132421255,
0.0326200686,
0.0380629636,
0.0077555822,
-0.013281011,
0.0201146286,
-0.0139487498,
0.0150775481,
-0.0240987372,
-0.0467386395,
-0.0108126663,
-0.0927908644,
0.0210159011,
0.0321239419,
-0.0018365887,
0.0160254017,
0.0027430891,
0.0099595971,
0.0039532161,
-0.021858843,
-0.0142099401,
0.0289415866,
0.0187391732,
0.0143633028,
-0.0533380881,
0.0921065435,
0.0565978847,
-0.003164171,
-0.0285698753,
0.0486848988,
2.855e-7,
0.0439826995,
0.0355253331,
0.0177344289,
0.0427371077,
0.0101322504,
-0.0067194975,
-0.000668363,
-0.0193005763,
0.0231114589,
0.0224025398,
0.0144569874,
0.0127940336,
0.0238604695,
-0.0053721392,
-0.0553535111,
-0.0000427016,
-0.0309280008,
-0.0127882659,
-0.0342841856,
0.0370445289,
0.0987663195,
-0.0119439336,
-0.0008855964,
-0.0094294399,
-0.040156085,
-0.0609737225,
0.0326615758,
-0.0113060726,
0.0071731876,
0.0447435342,
-0.004020832,
0.0265523717,
-0.0054215505,
0.0256336108,
0.0098622637,
0.0055914894,
-0.0238254219,
-0.0226672236,
-0.0203088764,
0.0245459396,
0.0298226885,
-0.0359791107,
0.0138613153,
-0.0460313298,
0.0030558633,
0.0033098392,
-0.0088420855,
0.0099011119,
-0.0457550324,
0.0054770107,
-0.0288952775,
-0.0199072696,
0.031103719,
0.0262195263,
-0.0596538335,
0.0166918468,
0.0189929493,
-0.0415602103,
0.0123583758,
0.0397931822,
-0.014566957,
-0.0719908699,
-0.0304742865,
-0.0067671724,
0.0132426005,
-0.0194861609,
0.0330618843,
2.400860197e-34,
0.0267815031,
-0.007863095,
0.0066471198,
0.0358683281,
0.0313100442,
0.0016637249,
-0.0490316711,
0.0383015238,
0.0221667718,
-0.0874575302,
-0.0320186168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19486v1 | LoPT: Low-Rank Prompt Tuning for Parameter Efficient Language Models | 2024-06-27T19:02:41 | 2024-06-27T19:02:41 | Shouchang Guo, Sonam Damani, Keng-hao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.LG, eess.SP | In prompt tuning, a prefix or suffix text is added to the prompt, and the
embeddings (soft prompts) or token indices (hard prompts) of the prefix/suffix
are optimized to gain more control over language models for specific tasks.
This approach eliminates the need for hand-crafted prompt engineering or
explicit model fine-tuning. Prompt tuning is significantly more
parameter-efficient than model fine-tuning, as it involves optimizing partial
inputs of language models to produce desired outputs.
In this work, we aim to further reduce the amount of trainable parameters
required for a language model to perform well on specific tasks. We propose
Low-rank Prompt Tuning (LoPT), a low-rank model for prompts that achieves
efficient prompt optimization. The proposed method demonstrates similar
outcomes to full parameter prompt tuning while reducing the number of trainable
parameters by a factor of 5. It also provides promising results compared to the
state-of-the-art methods that would require 10 to 20 times more parameters. | [
0.0367379636,
0.0326591209,
-0.0093773287,
0.0323267654,
0.0055402536,
0.0062918114,
0.0134355053,
0.0143059567,
-0.0180890635,
-0.0297194179,
-0.0398486629,
-0.0106452042,
0.0040271236,
0.0461993702,
0.0383939929,
-0.0871533602,
0.0776734129,
-0.0376016833,
-0.0116859861,
-0.0022538644,
-0.0156214619,
-0.0012318919,
0.0022837173,
0.048987411,
0.0122544393,
-0.0115786027,
-0.0277921949,
0.0382577628,
-0.0010784168,
0.0167746171,
0.0230449736,
0.0785601586,
0.0031042912,
0.0333686396,
0.0000020295,
-0.04437631,
-0.032712739,
-0.0335736535,
-0.0422713347,
0.0315393768,
0.033871267,
-0.0025955427,
-0.0413177274,
0.0457151122,
0.0079412879,
-0.0068715992,
0.0593243055,
0.0104144858,
0.0485237539,
0.0803776383,
0.0049711,
0.0116384784,
-0.0306147803,
-0.043898236,
-0.0336027667,
-0.0233326666,
-0.006940471,
-0.0743026659,
0.0090059321,
0.0498752967,
-0.0246643331,
0.0146624213,
-0.0092688184,
-0.0090543469,
-0.0112012541,
0.0158595126,
-0.0046859067,
-0.0367811397,
-0.029322736,
0.062227428,
-0.0873738825,
-0.0363710187,
0.0060607386,
-0.0360091142,
0.0406068899,
-0.0440487638,
-0.0141613977,
0.0185367577,
0.0237064883,
0.0004367144,
0.0188067667,
-0.0047457935,
0.007930181,
-0.0044427682,
-0.0082106562,
0.0596058965,
0.0500439852,
-0.0183861777,
-0.03385254,
-0.042028591,
-0.0162748415,
-0.0551164225,
-0.0141176712,
0.0235435423,
-0.0702427104,
0.0158162136,
-0.044788003,
-0.0133423219,
0.0286117252,
0.0044008521,
0.033940874,
0.0564981848,
-0.0095347855,
0.0342325792,
-0.0525239967,
0.0645840168,
0.028391147,
0.013432838,
-0.0527600534,
0.0119213648,
-0.0000893831,
0.0044470527,
-0.081074968,
-0.021797562,
-0.0499808379,
-0.0105641969,
-0.0061272564,
0.043843966,
0.0284262225,
0.0191050097,
0.0213461034,
-0.0079948818,
-0.0502049848,
-0.0246343408,
0.0118445354,
0.0118138138,
-0.0443449058,
-0.0052437433,
0.0037612095,
-0.0379024148,
-0.0150419651,
-0.0040564737,
0.0346215628,
-0.0247983243,
0.0113016898,
0.0394196138,
-0.0170368664,
-0.0291730594,
-0.0085444637,
-0.0011982884,
0.0111481911,
-0.0405812226,
-0.0354328267,
-0.0316010863,
0.0078396425,
-0.0038947004,
0.026393488,
-0.0309177488,
-0.0182369351,
0.0075904448,
-0.0257111937,
0.0629324913,
-0.0171786994,
0.0097905872,
0.0262499247,
0.0017071641,
-0.0050400253,
0.060801357,
0.0052001425,
0.0558127426,
0.0445335284,
-0.0172457602,
-0.0209624469,
0.0563805513,
0.0112171806,
0.0152331199,
-0.0054479036,
-0.0094555533,
0.0782886073,
0.0057327668,
0.0315793082,
0.0464988723,
0.0036195093,
-0.0106167207,
0.0451922975,
0.0150415581,
0.0426939279,
-0.0105558727,
0.0767893791,
-0.0016000968,
-0.0198050272,
-0.0164995212,
-0.047194194,
-0.0038106688,
-0.0493288487,
0.021673644,
0.0092631811,
0.0467934534,
-0.034907151,
-0.0308520161,
-0.0083072074,
-0.0138817681,
-0.0068950388,
0.0124592558,
0.010157587,
0.0054085436,
-0.0789508447,
0.0321961641,
0.0223926567,
-0.0401726551,
-0.0145541728,
-0.0509379916,
0.0186633971,
0.0480657071,
0.0118525522,
-0.0129558006,
-0.0217712056,
-0.00857649,
0.0420209616,
0.0304305851,
0.0812120736,
-0.0213509835,
0.0265438817,
-0.0337065719,
-0.0303421132,
0.0158524755,
0.0238539185,
0.0606677681,
-0.0181540959,
-0.0125222206,
0.0178547222,
0.0117511218,
-0.0310424063,
0.0396560803,
-0.0242734775,
-0.032622166,
0.0120957047,
0.0314895771,
0.0115992669,
0.0002191903,
0.0054579694,
0.008173394,
0.0108911144,
-0.0120356195,
0.0433318354,
-0.0385966413,
-0.0397876799,
-0.0334660672,
0.0165054612,
0.0396490842,
0.0026663425,
0.0356702209,
-0.0379267223,
-0.0653377324,
-0.0332503282,
-0.0302270763,
0.0164519623,
-0.0341379866,
0.0541675128,
-0.0312578082,
0.0063544489,
-0.0728212595,
0.0289196391,
0.017125912,
0.0460906439,
0.0806289762,
0.0641676113,
0.0205688421,
-0.0614390932,
-0.0731984153,
0.0243681278,
-0.0065084137,
0.0076675075,
0.041808065,
0.0324552394,
-0.0014968937,
-0.0459118262,
-0.0936974064,
0.0057441061,
-0.0451183766,
-0.029092595,
0.0129315434,
0.0164175145,
-0.0304171145,
-0.0376249254,
-0.0312626585,
-0.0091528827,
0.0124190226,
0.0452674404,
0.0236622598,
0.0222554747,
-0.054840669,
-0.051760681,
-0.0192784723,
0.0020755655,
0.0201040804,
-0.0170802921,
-0.014812639,
-0.0826205835,
0.0439508744,
-0.0151615888,
0.0471021421,
-0.0047516231,
-0.0443093069,
-0.0137076061,
-0.0300490446,
0.0614187382,
0.0716541037,
0.0166571569,
-0.0044602896,
0.0532078706,
0.0168484598,
-0.0582408644,
0.0136834336,
-0.0326204747,
-0.0391851254,
0.0061770738,
-0.0067497538,
0.0156498514,
0.0675338209,
-0.003773069,
-0.0149158221,
-0.0891377404,
0.030150095,
0.0072330534,
-0.0050717667,
-0.0659892559,
-0.00122138,
-0.0276175253,
0.0444623493,
-0.0208834391,
-0.0594467856,
0.0637470782,
-0.06684497,
-0.014836356,
-0.021195583,
-0.0022468911,
-0.0199578367,
0.0120398756,
0.0111705884,
0.047275722,
0.0275991298,
-0.0487352535,
-0.0588380396,
0.0321621113,
0.0277355723,
-0.0159673952,
0.0198118165,
0.0058035003,
-0.0099040689,
-0.0415355042,
-0.0634160563,
-0.0410809889,
-0.0502908863,
0.0104206437,
0.0397565737,
0.0307228696,
-0.024450969,
0.0173127744,
0.0222705211,
-0.0043036039,
0.0767372623,
-0.0362450406,
0.0276986696,
-0.0468569435,
-0.0030298897,
0.0685526878,
0.0240065549,
0.007950508,
-0.0163107924,
0.0535965711,
-0.0170963164,
0.0247664079,
-0.0100264503,
-0.022488242,
0.0403522365,
0.0540807247,
-0.0551443137,
-0.035735976,
0.0512818657,
0.0232770722,
-0.0309427045,
-0.0090994788,
0.1226207539,
0.0338410363,
-0.0383860655,
0.0107512996,
-0.0026989111,
0.0697691888,
0.0434698686,
0.0516031794,
-0.0513882414,
-0.020087488,
0.0279958397,
0.0053870864,
0.0028891484,
0.0071957419,
-0.0306644347,
-0.1212541237,
0.0252317246,
0.0154443989,
0.0020215211,
-0.0364093594,
-0.0438396446,
-0.0088581098,
0.0132589648,
0.0380224399,
0.0512450971,
-0.021694025,
-0.0057799639,
0.020368062,
0.0042636846,
-0.0660839826,
0.0124377487,
-0.0411659926,
0.0689119101,
0.0290575773,
0.0120078716,
0.0101145282,
-0.0379842035,
0.026453983,
-0.0193819534,
0.0075810766,
-0.0248939376,
-0.0172734167,
-0.0102487626,
-0.0177667774,
0.0455479473,
0.0056936485,
0.0003270408,
0.002979514,
-0.0168557614,
0.046070803,
-0.011238724,
0.0358986408,
-0.0000307307,
-0.0250763297,
0.0319005772,
0.0615111999,
0.0423661433,
-0.0401188694,
-0.0125757558,
-0.0414496623,
-0.022529386,
-0.0235409234,
-0.0125323432,
-0.0071083196,
-0.0233130604,
-0.0086448044,
-0.0520517677,
-0.0159454271,
0.0261230748,
0.0539797954,
0.0041160518,
0.0065378132,
-0.0641124323,
0.0171165075,
-0.0195062235,
0.0473007299,
-0.0169430822,
0.0134574762,
-0.1147802398,
-0.0085781934,
0.0431752056,
-0.0378817245,
-0.0258195661,
0.0077892174,
-0.0265090205,
-0.0611075759,
-0.0186113343,
0.0635708794,
0.0192030743,
0.0351832733,
-0.0440774634,
-0.0665289834,
0.0208941698,
-0.0024229065,
0.0039302171,
0.0219922364,
0.0342466459,
0.0014629377,
-0.0234089363,
0.0393193588,
-0.0572969317,
0.0125832437,
0.0408557169,
0.0284804422,
-0.0145776374,
-0.057676062,
0.0148483608,
0.0289569236,
0.0473222919,
-0.036132656,
-0.0444540344,
-0.0681233406,
0.0336717777,
-0.0380754583,
-0.0142390234,
-0.0278674662,
0.044277072,
0.0128529537,
-0.0104513709,
0.0027814496,
-0.0305742156,
-0.0115477778,
0.0450639725,
-0.0519682541,
0.0014064922,
-0.0258463323,
0.0134573923,
0.0432688184,
0.0137474686,
-0.0209006779,
0.0481332839,
0.0115218526,
0.0014875828,
-0.0303963665,
0.0227958634,
0.028671613,
0.019451391,
-0.0709584728,
0.0808967799,
-0.0270356908,
-0.0613362342,
-0.0399695747,
0.0166728701,
0.0615710989,
0.0134297423,
0.026303431,
-0.0000713844,
-0.0238662213,
-0.0150935277,
0.0020923179,
0.0678455755,
-0.0649351329,
0.0320810191,
0.0286787245,
-0.0245712418,
-0.0041565225,
0.0499598309,
0.0299327709,
0.0358783565,
-0.0150242858,
0.019786451,
-0.044804845,
0.0227858797,
0.0142448284,
0.0286435988,
-0.0423696488,
0.023383338,
-0.0274468623,
-0.0398070626,
-0.0022644249,
0.0260492954,
-0.0274969246,
0.0195961706,
0.0442886092,
0.0458138958,
-0.0217861328,
-0.0011886476,
-0.055990085,
-0.0546152815,
0.0330131426,
-0.0393601097,
-0.0058190473,
-6.056624073e-33,
-0.0623375289,
0.0248669982,
0.0015318843,
0.0009550115,
0.0047503719,
0.0180299319,
-0.0278507844,
0.0237052739,
-0.0169846117,
-0.025505675,
-0.0538421758,
-0.0313723609,
0.0210661627,
0.0012843828,
-0.0101217665,
0.0160169173,
0.0676384792,
0.0002473391,
-0.0535616651,
0.0033308996,
0.0256042778,
0.035887178,
0.0253992416,
0.0324099623,
-0.0122290598,
0.0031221558,
-0.0585678406,
0.0355155095,
0.0154678756,
0.0531978533,
-0.0089823427,
0.0294216052,
0.012039531,
-0.0613983609,
-0.037457671,
0.0634155944,
-0.0711931363,
-0.0451957211,
0.0169960707,
0.0083895139,
-0.0154763348,
-0.0455804728,
-0.0041474798,
-0.0289171245,
-0.025251817,
0.0214170124,
0.0110916449,
-0.0226876009,
-0.0267971326,
-0.0149528077,
-0.0573133603,
-0.0007112711,
0.0169912893,
-0.0249228384,
0.0409701467,
0.0379302762,
-0.0010850783,
0.0207345579,
-0.0097020939,
0.0099823344,
0.0493069589,
0.094050616,
0.0451535247,
0.0393989086,
-0.0336591043,
0.0208669584,
0.0148277003,
0.0257228669,
0.0383660644,
0.0179491173,
0.0540532507,
0.0194358695,
0.0584128536,
0.0209510792,
-0.0186383799,
-0.0446409732,
-0.0398330986,
0.0401261449,
0.0568350926,
0.0000403816,
0.0078208614,
0.0090665054,
-0.0247441605,
-0.0297790393,
-0.0719934255,
-0.0411036164,
-0.0394091755,
-0.0121856723,
0.0439055823,
0.0347840004,
-0.0282935649,
-0.0304139648,
0.0781992376,
0.0012290524,
-0.00857733,
0.0203119945,
-0.0024237749,
0.012970956,
0.0005507971,
0.0335754231,
-0.0194884297,
-0.0656941533,
0.0428848527,
-0.0406655967,
0.0124000283,
-0.0080089271,
0.0054087285,
0.0454825088,
-0.0816885084,
0.0232825857,
-0.0213426948,
0.0226926804,
-0.0069075068,
0.0544241294,
0.0210899655,
-0.0371917672,
0.0123653887,
0.0584663413,
0.0076239556,
-0.0427118465,
-0.0170559809,
-0.0260456838,
-0.0024480249,
0.0449760221,
-0.0377670042,
0.0018420594,
-0.017399529,
0.0510719009,
0.0397297591,
-0.0274791718,
-0.0121093867,
0.011015798,
2.707e-7,
0.0122990431,
0.0432351902,
-0.0083151134,
0.023537254,
0.0055522085,
0.0150617054,
0.000655081,
0.0323634855,
0.0084122196,
0.0019817057,
0.0030711079,
-0.0170110967,
0.0162640605,
-0.0237666592,
-0.1071726456,
0.014097251,
-0.0831048042,
0.0424961075,
-0.070069842,
-0.0124511719,
0.0185521562,
0.1324454844,
-0.0058424952,
0.0064277477,
0.0009682364,
-0.001116666,
0.0008909806,
-0.0399724171,
-0.0179624967,
0.0289431568,
0.0616906211,
-0.0199725628,
0.0023842724,
0.0105269589,
-0.0280978009,
0.0445144139,
0.0091246581,
0.0843937024,
-0.0121059455,
-0.0091774985,
0.0301933177,
-0.0105160717,
-0.0231817141,
-0.076809898,
0.0748097301,
0.0031343701,
0.0250694919,
-0.0287166685,
-0.0020412356,
-0.0219249651,
0.0042332266,
-0.0621201843,
-0.0428813174,
0.0342258029,
0.0393473692,
0.0032222245,
-0.0003100827,
-0.0864464864,
-0.0202828068,
-0.0091108829,
-0.0456952937,
-0.0557238236,
-0.0127114635,
-0.0306824017,
0.0342312865,
-0.0595063642,
-0.0159020685,
2.95660408e-34,
0.0309959073,
-0.0363518558,
0.04136407,
0.0147119192,
0.0278529562,
-0.001131938,
0.0025784152,
0.0267148837,
0.0476370901,
-0.0816931576,
-0.0637592599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19482v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19482v1 | xTower: A Multilingual LLM for Explaining and Correcting Translation Errors | 2024-06-27T18:51:46 | 2024-06-27T18:51:46 | Marcos Treviso, Nuno M. Guerreiro, Sweta Agrawal, Ricardo Rei, José Pombal, Tania Vaz, Helena Wu, Beatriz Silva, Daan van Stigt, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | While machine translation (MT) systems are achieving increasingly strong
performance on benchmarks, they often produce translations with errors and
anomalies. Understanding these errors can potentially help improve the
translation quality and user experience. This paper introduces xTower, an open
large language model (LLM) built on top of TowerBase designed to provide
free-text explanations for translation errors in order to guide the generation
of a corrected translation. The quality of the generated explanations by xTower
are assessed via both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation. We ask expert
translators to evaluate the quality of the explanations across two dimensions:
relatedness towards the error span being explained and helpfulness in error
understanding and improving translation quality. Extrinsically, we test xTower
across various experimental setups in generating translation corrections,
demonstrating significant improvements in translation quality. Our findings
highlight xTower's potential towards not only producing plausible and helpful
explanations of automatic translations, but also leveraging them to suggest
corrected translations. | [
0.0418587774,
0.0138840191,
-0.020766696,
0.0523194298,
-0.0112111112,
0.0276584662,
0.0235498305,
0.0072452896,
-0.0242652241,
-0.0104516745,
-0.0111752031,
-0.0550724939,
0.058646366,
-0.0035825446,
0.0161474105,
-0.0487514511,
0.0411045775,
-0.0227864292,
-0.0121079795,
-0.0007270654,
0.0093538342,
0.0424238108,
0.0013144345,
0.0354427733,
0.0233063176,
-0.0113008041,
-0.0234802421,
0.0633113682,
0.017024992,
-0.0162385311,
-0.032226529,
0.0018355835,
-0.0032342556,
0.0606425479,
0.0000022675,
-0.0401208587,
-0.0363711938,
0.0114631755,
-0.0113276783,
0.0283639841,
0.0251500234,
-0.0429299138,
-0.0184246935,
0.018506337,
0.0063633402,
-0.0233415887,
0.0259665679,
0.0193912014,
0.0601952597,
0.0549666397,
0.0014314324,
-0.0017656473,
-0.0409800336,
-0.0195198786,
0.0302530024,
-0.0464600995,
-0.0311393719,
0.0034020043,
-0.0168791525,
0.0196948647,
0.0083179558,
0.0068694116,
0.0210568681,
-0.0436404422,
-0.0185726322,
-0.0048123533,
0.0117054237,
-0.0497123972,
-0.0188384987,
0.0715435669,
0.002826147,
-0.0084631275,
-0.0094928704,
-0.009422699,
-0.0158548634,
0.0033898356,
-0.0413497277,
0.037259616,
-0.029508695,
-0.0149152745,
0.0260700956,
0.018548103,
0.06285768,
0.0200475659,
-0.0388238765,
0.015532569,
0.0129053183,
-0.0311869718,
-0.0477706119,
0.0044631977,
-0.0156747755,
-0.0446037948,
0.0495115332,
0.0473868325,
-0.050769899,
0.0224244501,
0.0046506645,
-0.0481130518,
0.0326229595,
-0.0673931912,
0.041948773,
0.0274039898,
-0.0413279012,
0.0591151342,
-0.0049063126,
0.0714328736,
-0.0111804502,
0.0012265956,
-0.0597585738,
-0.010451694,
-0.0171334147,
0.017414188,
-0.0085686175,
-0.0327812321,
-0.0867798552,
0.0196283348,
-0.010503062,
0.023335699,
0.017844338,
0.0425946526,
0.0372371972,
-0.0207977388,
-0.0573443435,
-0.0642090738,
-0.0297176354,
0.0405202881,
-0.027429169,
-0.0203534011,
-0.0035658886,
-0.0653351322,
-0.0240831356,
0.0447842032,
-0.0407089032,
-0.0025683381,
-0.0126912631,
0.0738007873,
0.0214724336,
0.0162745789,
-0.0049633509,
-0.0380702205,
-0.0316360332,
-0.0613661669,
-0.0576417483,
-0.0695502311,
0.0433760844,
0.021187555,
0.0194706675,
-0.0192936603,
0.0255359728,
0.0088143889,
-0.0389838926,
0.0408935659,
-0.057738103,
0.0320345387,
0.0262716152,
0.0105005847,
-0.0124414042,
0.0405024067,
0.053461004,
0.021656068,
0.0482746065,
0.0040175086,
0.0413034558,
0.012022689,
-0.0164285917,
0.0227599498,
-0.0179373622,
0.0088851871,
-0.0236411951,
0.0681410432,
0.0164351724,
0.0352318734,
-0.0075854692,
0.0660320595,
0.0548414961,
0.0263855439,
0.0052214609,
0.0665625855,
0.0328028761,
-0.039569214,
-0.0099494774,
-0.0092637781,
-0.0323952399,
0.0204632841,
-0.0132921413,
0.0089639267,
0.0044469032,
0.0512549542,
-0.0058346903,
-0.0822326913,
-0.0202667471,
-0.0161718521,
-0.0215898883,
-0.0169752147,
0.0696930215,
-0.0000985002,
-0.0518079475,
0.0524559878,
0.0054796529,
-0.0700283647,
0.0261800662,
-0.0303457007,
0.0316730589,
0.1166551411,
0.0459626317,
-0.0063840789,
0.0067959274,
-0.0207464695,
-0.0032183339,
0.068755433,
0.0678714588,
0.0107446061,
0.0016885066,
-0.0635341927,
-0.0277628656,
0.014427972,
0.0383014493,
0.014871655,
-0.0253716316,
0.0242727157,
0.0438932478,
-0.0898677632,
-0.1083957851,
0.017835997,
-0.0256849993,
-0.0225290898,
0.0123779615,
-0.0037413742,
-0.0185169932,
0.0561686195,
-0.0169238765,
-0.0077096554,
-0.0005391563,
-0.0103695076,
-0.035721615,
0.0572759807,
-0.0392205566,
0.0010558772,
0.0143999988,
-0.0390444472,
-0.0065502049,
-0.0165776815,
-0.0616863854,
-0.0624346323,
-0.016702069,
-0.0356846265,
0.0101124812,
-0.045777496,
0.0493925177,
-0.0185589492,
-0.0093934778,
-0.043804992,
0.0462579317,
0.0116455657,
0.0075508528,
0.0175127648,
-0.0248199031,
0.0176537596,
-0.0103384694,
-0.0086844768,
0.0558811724,
0.0033065998,
0.0364771225,
0.0416771099,
0.0177496765,
-0.0349080265,
-0.0183831863,
-0.0773431733,
0.0398905091,
-0.0286709033,
0.0370315798,
0.0608014092,
0.0475050993,
-0.007232754,
-0.0028707294,
0.009211191,
-0.0001922888,
0.0243672244,
-0.0069148047,
0.0516039766,
-0.0112860734,
-0.0091303298,
-0.0361326113,
0.0288268719,
-0.0067443796,
0.0329433903,
0.052796375,
-0.0052091484,
-0.1059172228,
0.0414026603,
-0.0472181514,
-0.0360598452,
0.0093638916,
-0.0580448918,
-0.0049578482,
-0.0204563569,
0.017824702,
0.032875035,
-0.0153133878,
0.0384551845,
0.0300067477,
-0.0050106281,
-0.0585326701,
-0.0201913528,
-0.0227029026,
-0.0733544305,
-0.0206730701,
-0.0616565682,
-0.0065676747,
0.0469981283,
-0.0033783477,
0.0054791314,
-0.0650449544,
-0.0124733057,
-0.0338648222,
0.0046402221,
-0.0199784189,
-0.0139556266,
0.0203291737,
0.0880947262,
-0.0354357138,
-0.0627766252,
0.0631176531,
-0.0336383767,
0.0234555248,
-0.0277143568,
0.007415005,
-0.0454854928,
0.0544453338,
-0.0438632034,
0.0277173854,
-0.0374264009,
-0.0178471059,
0.0012140763,
0.0068945247,
0.0308041442,
-0.0285565387,
0.0167354606,
-0.0978841484,
-0.040487282,
-0.0056458013,
0.0190893877,
0.0025330163,
-0.0133210868,
-0.0223657843,
-0.0486457646,
0.0217571985,
-0.0347456001,
-0.0417474322,
0.0045965919,
0.0428981334,
0.0268045887,
-0.0096171927,
-0.01626518,
-0.0161542911,
-0.0285755228,
-0.0348588638,
0.0217748322,
0.0629477501,
-0.0843017399,
0.045242209,
0.0275456347,
-0.0281722117,
-0.0035161155,
-0.0097773094,
-0.0414447784,
0.0089361006,
-0.0212669633,
-0.0613561682,
-0.0082668876,
0.0644688085,
-0.0572767071,
0.0096942857,
0.123611249,
0.0331614912,
-0.0387102775,
-0.0098624425,
-0.0521363392,
0.0085799452,
0.0136818541,
0.0185577273,
-0.0960801393,
0.000581224,
0.0309002604,
0.0395685211,
0.0416062064,
0.0122234765,
0.0047122077,
-0.1027466953,
0.0329911821,
0.0560723804,
-0.0386524834,
-0.0395469442,
-0.0363910981,
-0.0264877044,
-0.0292050503,
0.032535024,
0.013660809,
0.0251431316,
0.0198135637,
0.0255874712,
-0.0123799266,
-0.0744241551,
-0.0000288303,
-0.0561830699,
0.0095849093,
0.0563116595,
0.0484381579,
0.0199638177,
-0.045387052,
0.0024700782,
-0.000185925,
0.0201801825,
-0.01163672,
0.0244263373,
0.0505822338,
-0.004426925,
-0.0218011569,
0.0016676504,
-0.0700784102,
0.0012768871,
0.0116471471,
0.0685966313,
-0.0122955134,
0.0203622896,
0.0259700492,
-0.0279783346,
0.0085181827,
0.0493003279,
0.0085799005,
-0.0165979583,
-0.0426508002,
-0.0360516869,
-0.0408965796,
-0.0482116491,
0.0021507854,
0.0397889465,
-0.0249822084,
-0.0450532138,
-0.0677870959,
-0.0609173253,
-0.0112770721,
0.0306862742,
0.0378330983,
-0.0016916709,
-0.0624331906,
0.0016967418,
0.0249053426,
0.049526155,
0.0017289459,
0.0386153534,
-0.0405598357,
0.0538997091,
-0.0025212476,
-0.0385070667,
0.0117214667,
0.0269057881,
-0.0286806002,
-0.0568234883,
-0.0116566522,
0.0525257848,
0.0298314914,
0.0359853953,
-0.0339277349,
-0.0595634542,
-0.0046854662,
0.0301446263,
-0.0286143925,
-0.0015391067,
0.0246065129,
-0.0067066108,
0.0052004438,
0.0458559431,
-0.0188052505,
-0.0164252277,
-0.0373871252,
0.0427219346,
-0.0141668711,
-0.0591700897,
0.0189717021,
0.0276558809,
0.0212460998,
-0.0403150767,
-0.0567562655,
-0.0221281331,
0.0375955775,
-0.0158858132,
-0.0192320794,
-0.0177231133,
0.021426389,
0.0460402668,
-0.0540341847,
0.0243048295,
0.0083935047,
-0.0329922102,
-0.0484521873,
-0.0128183812,
0.0364105254,
-0.0265056994,
0.0299483258,
0.0032654062,
0.0438246392,
-0.0169387925,
0.0051324032,
-0.0131414756,
0.0368409231,
-0.0082775401,
0.0587721281,
-0.0031045286,
0.0240811948,
0.0268575512,
0.0123355826,
-0.0152917085,
-0.0671072826,
-0.007492485,
0.0009662648,
0.0883442387,
0.0058244849,
0.1234616861,
0.0063724723,
-0.0193775184,
-0.0012127674,
0.0733055249,
0.0307371281,
-0.0040329238,
-0.0156076718,
0.0030143547,
-0.0110468138,
0.0128182173,
0.0527363382,
-0.0275752507,
0.0144815072,
0.0041679554,
-0.0166413654,
0.0085379807,
0.0001699399,
0.0132284816,
-0.0247490909,
-0.0256165005,
-0.045668032,
-0.0435027145,
-0.0408413857,
0.0218118485,
0.0586921088,
0.020413924,
-0.0115729859,
-0.0093696816,
0.0985529646,
-0.0235205516,
0.0189472642,
-0.0482986532,
-0.0101313069,
-0.0188783575,
0.0196912661,
-0.0280636735,
-6.263183042e-33,
-0.0141466698,
-0.0590947382,
-0.0090431925,
-0.0336267538,
-0.014944124,
-0.0224310756,
-0.0412860811,
-0.0044955588,
0.0206360947,
0.0427632704,
0.0016891938,
0.0226039048,
0.0218428597,
-0.0113060549,
0.0296027586,
0.0127978791,
0.0550396927,
0.0376874097,
-0.0345340632,
0.026574051,
0.0447692014,
0.0221977346,
0.0848712698,
-0.1155800372,
0.0912072733,
-0.0340929888,
-0.0424169078,
0.0395351835,
0.0147750713,
0.0414460376,
0.0042879242,
0.0232299138,
0.0041657388,
-0.0255370252,
-0.0192491617,
-0.0218627173,
-0.0622734986,
0.0059785102,
0.0475418344,
0.0481539443,
-0.0140232649,
-0.0301082209,
0.0066442317,
-0.0226168912,
-0.0069007557,
-0.0102389008,
0.0341922045,
-0.0652311221,
-0.0149893314,
0.0217905976,
-0.0176763721,
0.027718991,
-0.0244314428,
-0.0114731416,
-0.0089274496,
0.0318025127,
-0.0358148143,
0.013605902,
-0.0352985412,
-0.0001454443,
0.0278450325,
-0.0070194704,
0.1016374975,
-0.0266206954,
-0.0473631509,
-0.0079604387,
-0.0068424265,
0.011129681,
-0.0246354621,
-0.0077957157,
-0.0080003068,
0.0119632976,
0.0819986686,
0.0677727908,
0.0293482207,
-0.0155974012,
-0.0725801736,
0.0483527035,
-0.0392830819,
0.0372994766,
0.0116195362,
0.0089420117,
-0.0115105184,
-0.0027004266,
-0.0553525761,
-0.0281664524,
-0.0389064848,
-0.0524269156,
-0.0097135156,
0.0096832458,
-0.0228029657,
-0.042869851,
0.0306353699,
-0.031715367,
0.0054310835,
-0.0137349106,
-0.0195374284,
-0.0068008155,
-0.0237111095,
0.0141815078,
-0.0031224852,
-0.0248749163,
-0.0494910702,
0.0417051911,
0.0224120542,
0.0000962674,
0.0293503758,
0.0104347588,
-0.0434542894,
0.0402619094,
-0.0426713973,
-0.0107672103,
-0.019906396,
-0.0026657046,
0.0104167089,
-0.0060773958,
-0.0414483696,
0.060430821,
0.0284007899,
0.0273098294,
-0.0202292334,
-0.0226072986,
-0.0055916226,
0.0084659215,
-0.0293271039,
-0.0012395888,
-0.0131673524,
-0.01553657,
0.0513047278,
-0.0513089523,
-0.0279420167,
-0.0034746658,
2.871e-7,
0.0411638804,
0.0763437375,
0.0190409869,
0.0071583358,
0.0015417835,
-0.0003942791,
-0.0214333795,
0.0015265987,
-0.0262952596,
0.0097775282,
0.0423227884,
0.0273296535,
0.1002330855,
0.0324683785,
-0.029452635,
-0.015127914,
-0.0613721348,
0.0107460786,
-0.0534169935,
0.0089051602,
0.0505322218,
0.0545386299,
0.0015790879,
0.0159087088,
-0.0018627603,
-0.0367733985,
0.0732096434,
-0.0442742668,
-0.0162929464,
0.0296823196,
0.074383989,
0.041380655,
-0.0203459095,
-0.0339593962,
-0.009937631,
-0.0224347096,
0.0197298359,
0.054120522,
-0.0095350416,
0.033095099,
-0.0018365378,
-0.0529662259,
0.0050778328,
-0.0641435012,
0.0295262728,
0.0076235877,
0.0067045745,
0.0163445864,
-0.010153193,
-0.0070634945,
0.0411081202,
-0.0354696177,
-0.003803839,
0.0343044698,
0.0168193933,
0.0056900596,
-0.0186857134,
-0.0397561863,
-0.0358970426,
0.0185489282,
-0.0000162944,
-0.0218520723,
0.0027820463,
0.0102381213,
-0.0063722427,
-0.0126300603,
-0.0063553331,
2.526936099e-34,
0.046324145,
-0.0050027617,
0.0015496542,
-0.0310789105,
0.0722797513,
0.0033061213,
-0.019026408,
0.0035594488,
0.0213908982,
-0.0232424568,
-0.0085847322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19478v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19478v1 | Sparse Regression for Machine Translation | 2024-06-27T18:43:51 | 2024-06-27T18:43:51 | Ergun Biçici | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, G.3; I.2.7 | We use transductive regression techniques to learn mappings between source
and target features of given parallel corpora and use these mappings to
generate machine translation outputs. We show the effectiveness of $L_1$
regularized regression (\textit{lasso}) to learn the mappings between sparsely
observed feature sets versus $L_2$ regularized regression. Proper selection of
training instances plays an important role to learn correct feature mappings
within limited computational resources and at expected accuracy levels. We
introduce \textit{dice} instance selection method for proper selection of
training instances, which plays an important role to learn correct feature
mappings for improving the source and target coverage of the training set. We
show that $L_1$ regularized regression performs better than $L_2$ regularized
regression both in regression measurements and in the translation experiments
using graph decoding. We present encouraging results when translating from
German to English and Spanish to English. We also demonstrate results when the
phrase table of a phrase-based decoder is replaced with the mappings we find
with the regression model. | [
0.0061485642,
0.0487392917,
-0.0122532425,
0.0290239733,
-0.0119295241,
0.0057827793,
0.0387137569,
0.0505193993,
-0.0320283212,
-0.0045268754,
-0.0079646939,
-0.0114077423,
0.0550112128,
-0.0302870944,
0.0434117503,
-0.0360421836,
0.0090009682,
0.0028501705,
-0.079757385,
-0.015769098,
-0.0069103469,
0.0292075891,
0.0294538084,
0.0377605073,
-0.0401543304,
0.0650996268,
0.025116574,
0.0464141108,
-0.0098916907,
-0.0078679658,
-0.0455133133,
0.0370008834,
0.0167458877,
0.0509460755,
0.0000018125,
-0.0216484703,
-0.0487193242,
0.006556299,
0.0283879973,
-0.0361442231,
0.018751841,
-0.1366588026,
0.0208407491,
0.0142705673,
-0.0041708257,
-0.0711934716,
0.096273154,
0.0148210339,
0.0241103154,
0.0755424649,
-0.0347426869,
-0.0298448224,
-0.0099313967,
-0.0323802307,
0.0250300821,
-0.0530415215,
-0.0242319647,
0.0094035165,
-0.0368632786,
-0.0087906606,
-0.014749377,
0.0361354798,
-0.0275442377,
0.003950594,
0.0297434907,
-0.0180324633,
-0.0210064389,
-0.0387004837,
0.0014661639,
0.0500585735,
-0.0441072956,
-0.0172501076,
-0.0163679533,
0.0215788279,
-0.0223555621,
0.0260678884,
-0.0243921485,
-0.0386041924,
0.0023525804,
0.0037285602,
-0.0168172214,
-0.0100560226,
0.0261721145,
-0.0083999969,
-0.0554409474,
-0.009054793,
0.0235117953,
-0.0326187275,
0.0163181461,
0.0723691806,
-0.0160230249,
0.012760153,
0.0026829473,
-0.0194236711,
-0.0546817854,
0.0123959873,
-0.0416677631,
-0.092433095,
-0.0140093677,
-0.0005420925,
0.0587067045,
0.0406117998,
-0.0011470258,
0.0119821569,
-0.0402796455,
0.0845598727,
-0.0333001167,
0.0283756517,
-0.0835853592,
-0.0281448606,
-0.0387073308,
0.0376770794,
-0.0208321139,
0.0364655219,
0.024847826,
-0.0183166005,
-0.0342247114,
-0.0050893701,
0.0141234444,
-0.0118603194,
0.019810006,
-0.0222077835,
-0.0890240669,
-0.0051767309,
0.0363924988,
0.0711469203,
-0.0155888023,
0.0135212196,
-0.0577275716,
-0.0249098986,
-0.0312065538,
0.0137256458,
0.0225341227,
-0.0419070981,
-0.0003077403,
0.0823719352,
-0.0166026019,
-0.0072633964,
-0.0274911169,
0.0023754328,
-0.0079108831,
-0.0494671017,
-0.0126528172,
-0.0835517421,
0.0403421111,
0.03449101,
0.0560552441,
-0.079109855,
0.0056729862,
-0.0368454792,
-0.0589689501,
0.0795867294,
-0.0300318766,
-0.0107117863,
-0.0053739655,
-0.0480890237,
-0.0167880431,
0.0787079111,
0.0174465273,
0.0322142653,
-0.0124620758,
-0.0021689956,
-0.0398807488,
0.0474176817,
0.0416256785,
0.0465113744,
-0.0594309531,
-0.011063288,
0.0328641124,
0.0025975639,
-0.0035861533,
0.0533274114,
-0.0104320552,
0.0452526473,
0.0415517278,
0.0708042085,
0.0156464297,
0.0444303155,
0.0263018068,
0.025813194,
-0.0460229181,
0.046744816,
-0.0040690345,
0.007642509,
-0.0191483218,
-0.022284355,
0.0267655142,
0.0159482732,
-0.028518742,
-0.0091485111,
0.0030255995,
-0.0166037418,
0.0319442302,
-0.0365382023,
0.0636324286,
0.0249458365,
-0.0292583033,
0.0340185724,
0.0091470573,
-0.0300146937,
-0.0164697599,
-0.0168793127,
-0.033065334,
0.0199284032,
0.0233641919,
0.0120009612,
-0.0205961466,
-0.0198212992,
0.0108214039,
0.0101669692,
0.0474390462,
0.0006543011,
0.0185657945,
-0.0222851187,
-0.0396391526,
0.0581415966,
0.0024215989,
0.0524675809,
-0.0206480548,
0.0350888222,
0.0353257991,
-0.0401118398,
-0.0477293991,
0.0344933718,
-0.0021729269,
-0.0085235024,
0.0411377288,
0.0341961421,
0.0186775867,
0.0128001459,
-0.0179373622,
-0.005979883,
0.0154567007,
-0.0461460054,
-0.004958034,
0.0079713697,
0.0390975289,
-0.0519745909,
0.0184725728,
-0.0918108225,
-0.0059051644,
0.0389396548,
-0.0178623069,
-0.0473707952,
0.001335225,
-0.0735037774,
0.0009291436,
-0.0193490386,
0.0130884023,
-0.0380691104,
0.0018592643,
-0.0312019363,
0.015654387,
0.0078509161,
0.0329323411,
-0.003254157,
-0.1210921705,
0.039199058,
-0.0293838978,
-0.0140780481,
0.0292987358,
0.0097960001,
0.0549314097,
0.0643294379,
0.0284360405,
0.0220327228,
0.0005617652,
-0.045314882,
-0.0007404505,
-0.0343648307,
0.0086322464,
0.0205688179,
0.0564656742,
0.0395924672,
-0.0516276173,
-0.0146763092,
0.0167650431,
0.0292233806,
0.0069944975,
-0.0026437833,
0.0392649472,
0.0100023663,
-0.0189008452,
-0.0338338353,
0.0232711341,
0.0402710102,
0.0072511295,
-0.0316156708,
-0.0519288369,
0.0654394627,
0.0055616684,
-0.0068011247,
0.012818641,
-0.0427946933,
0.0098412223,
-0.0127383405,
-0.0202170126,
0.0049203546,
-0.0395298563,
0.0129488073,
0.0296385977,
0.040255785,
-0.0301054716,
-0.0139326649,
-0.0299423896,
-0.0442890897,
-0.0756640434,
-0.0782446489,
0.0090034511,
-0.0171277281,
0.0450234935,
-0.0247931331,
-0.0826092139,
-0.0026905078,
-0.0245997366,
-0.0232946258,
-0.0411649868,
0.0697060153,
0.0308512673,
0.03895377,
-0.014512118,
-0.0809981972,
0.0490530171,
-0.0136261983,
0.0203844849,
-0.0429843999,
-0.0098889479,
-0.0255157799,
0.0278660562,
-0.0023486384,
0.0238448121,
-0.0536726862,
-0.0282694679,
-0.0291556828,
0.0118468516,
0.0169074368,
-0.0086461203,
0.0607335269,
-0.0290632341,
0.0110874679,
-0.0086964453,
-0.0091927256,
-0.0082080001,
-0.0426945463,
0.0024364332,
-0.0104771536,
0.0675476044,
-0.02367118,
-0.0497910865,
0.0048929253,
0.0093039572,
0.0386357531,
-0.0146887247,
-0.0107572274,
-0.0045445478,
-0.0176668279,
0.0117012765,
-0.015599994,
-0.0327697434,
-0.0499963909,
0.0043630046,
-0.0199288484,
0.0096709868,
-0.0182252321,
-0.0493209772,
-0.0088011334,
0.0405055881,
0.0346520543,
-0.007433549,
-0.0268265549,
0.0425923653,
0.0054566269,
0.0293013584,
0.0887903422,
0.0124021526,
-0.0637893379,
-0.0169322547,
-0.0046153213,
0.0647646785,
0.0294380151,
0.0434273742,
-0.0526917651,
-0.0061714202,
-0.017984556,
0.0633618906,
0.0250296816,
0.0123724369,
-0.0150639471,
-0.0743822604,
-0.0036969453,
0.0589797013,
-0.029489385,
-0.0541069694,
-0.0375264362,
0.0007064195,
-0.0485115051,
-0.0040727281,
-0.0465600975,
0.0087010153,
-0.0206389688,
0.0208376832,
0.011320347,
-0.0498780645,
-0.0495079495,
-0.0434364304,
-0.0265107621,
0.0338671654,
0.0509187579,
-0.0251865312,
0.0128529547,
-0.0106626721,
0.0538345166,
0.0004888109,
-0.0477756709,
0.0528476499,
0.0322559029,
-0.0294820853,
0.0335407741,
0.0247221217,
-0.0225257184,
0.0504203364,
0.0074981833,
0.0812237933,
-0.0310824197,
0.0078156041,
0.0420514606,
-0.047991626,
0.0406881087,
0.0143519789,
-0.0066846693,
-0.0378025249,
-0.0034674478,
-0.0131442919,
-0.0277816057,
-0.0588362738,
-0.0357508883,
0.0091118403,
-0.0774970576,
-0.0369506516,
-0.065282166,
-0.0120631093,
0.0449952409,
0.0715309307,
0.0488470048,
0.0388256274,
0.0242919158,
-0.0168487746,
0.0051394454,
-0.0027064043,
0.0103258817,
0.0298606921,
0.0014684078,
-0.0316684768,
-0.0180668756,
-0.022744162,
0.0315675959,
-0.0116066206,
-0.0964764804,
-0.0646275133,
-0.056128446,
0.0174888391,
0.01633857,
0.0486500189,
-0.0299014132,
-0.0150879808,
0.0416818224,
0.0177369192,
-0.0095861787,
-0.0157418624,
0.0266562682,
-0.0769051611,
-0.0165190715,
0.0355328806,
-0.0215712655,
0.0154932095,
0.0138086686,
0.0293050911,
-0.0109099597,
-0.0284857675,
0.0334853008,
0.0314574055,
0.0385042392,
-0.0401726551,
0.0087241391,
-0.0154444939,
-0.0016742059,
0.0231440589,
-0.0035296457,
-0.0297812261,
-0.0303597376,
0.0637425259,
0.0034957309,
0.002592694,
-0.0263943654,
-0.0451915748,
0.0165957734,
-0.0563922115,
0.0233605374,
-0.00164364,
-0.018823877,
0.0390286632,
0.0657186434,
0.0039568758,
0.0203374792,
0.0374988616,
-0.0097011784,
-0.0194362309,
-0.0141423699,
0.0085046133,
0.0417509899,
-0.0224665441,
-0.0105157429,
-0.0100150406,
-0.0183511209,
0.0035349189,
-0.0180399325,
0.078341864,
-0.0279774554,
0.1165312007,
-0.0075953873,
0.0003400388,
-0.0297983512,
0.0479181185,
0.0093854126,
0.0248360522,
0.0012251597,
-0.0295418482,
0.0076561202,
0.0420169309,
0.0830792338,
0.0281232987,
-0.0044036284,
0.0016609224,
-0.0487593003,
-0.0279554147,
0.0054866411,
0.0514425598,
-0.0124334935,
-0.0200876929,
-0.0028791197,
0.0342031009,
-0.0801643953,
0.0405581184,
-0.0431663431,
0.0114757661,
-0.0038722113,
0.014037367,
0.038380146,
-0.0318304785,
0.0418366566,
-0.0444198847,
0.0013351485,
-0.0157555435,
-0.0196445733,
-0.022311274,
-5.82859176e-33,
-0.02404931,
-0.0320739336,
-0.0321317017,
-0.0294226464,
-0.0045454544,
-0.0211539064,
-0.0301110465,
0.0095493151,
-0.009145014,
0.0409222431,
0.0026812451,
-0.0035006925,
0.0196679793,
-0.0035262096,
0.0215419494,
0.0334535055,
0.0439841934,
0.0087982034,
0.0035336232,
-0.0021983483,
0.0434999429,
0.0407512672,
0.0515790433,
-0.0972460359,
0.0078099621,
0.006753874,
0.005235476,
0.0025887587,
0.0745636001,
-0.0054999599,
0.0322789066,
0.0520847365,
0.0227209534,
-0.0429751948,
-0.0245920997,
-0.014532906,
-0.0517815128,
-0.02994854,
0.0296409056,
0.0397744775,
0.0408109762,
-0.0328734331,
-0.0083624432,
-0.0566545278,
0.0070343553,
-0.0457798652,
0.0249447823,
-0.0337858498,
-0.049319312,
0.0130398208,
-0.0650226548,
0.0167569686,
-0.0186173059,
0.0072971745,
0.0583315603,
0.0634966791,
-0.0295148101,
-0.0474039316,
0.0017625924,
0.0242841206,
-0.0447217003,
0.0584949329,
0.0567928739,
0.0205375869,
-0.0235230457,
0.0134131955,
-0.0192722641,
-0.019321043,
0.0185913239,
0.0113092931,
0.023019135,
0.0275953189,
0.0438751057,
0.0274611544,
0.0289322641,
-0.069116801,
-0.0724979788,
0.0379739404,
-0.0390952416,
0.0175978504,
0.0554672703,
0.0179712586,
-0.0158058181,
-0.0232763886,
-0.0273526199,
-0.0080536697,
-0.0127038257,
-0.0526431836,
-0.0191915873,
0.0154007496,
-0.0454706661,
0.0365102254,
0.0853717923,
-0.0448540933,
0.0119974837,
0.0537032373,
-0.0466690585,
0.0156409796,
-0.0123568578,
0.0161304977,
-0.0053448793,
-0.0697304979,
0.0069772992,
0.0407822169,
0.0518734604,
-0.0080829123,
0.0651884675,
-0.0122772641,
-0.0173570141,
-0.0073271194,
-0.045450557,
-0.0443478189,
-0.0367498249,
0.0610244125,
0.0094211567,
0.0103732022,
0.0035569947,
0.0208427384,
0.0017627465,
0.0011392946,
0.0049639372,
0.0157829132,
0.0261812061,
0.0099232337,
-0.0530485138,
0.0081657059,
-0.0368851498,
-0.0005283786,
0.0446679816,
-0.0141269276,
-0.0476680733,
-0.0224909093,
2.649e-7,
0.0328690819,
0.0432805754,
-0.0160639249,
0.0345731676,
-0.0183221735,
-0.0108624594,
-0.0497075245,
0.0596921854,
-0.0121823922,
0.0081395693,
0.0567997955,
0.0027200831,
0.0924676806,
0.0520815626,
-0.0679224506,
-0.0557937957,
0.0173826758,
0.0273561906,
-0.0630640462,
0.0306251701,
0.0514785759,
0.0927002281,
-0.0110002784,
-0.0014668707,
0.0117151989,
-0.0088370945,
0.0396253765,
-0.0076159164,
-0.0080407355,
-0.0424908884,
0.0155040324,
0.022312548,
-0.038088005,
0.0213353112,
-0.0318176709,
0.0244201496,
0.0744119585,
0.0243904889,
-0.0238747895,
0.0022601557,
0.0089647584,
-0.0010943593,
-0.0164012983,
0.0058017396,
0.0263860393,
0.0032886611,
-0.0182236638,
0.0186047032,
0.015865095,
0.0287033487,
0.0274166279,
-0.0510047674,
0.0126995277,
0.0221223459,
0.0942776203,
0.0009449269,
-0.0240224078,
0.007918328,
-0.0122379251,
0.0256577209,
-0.045168221,
-0.0354075693,
0.0031435702,
0.0442387462,
-0.006515604,
0.0103170564,
0.0354655422,
2.341550768e-34,
0.0367013067,
-0.0016165224,
0.0144584812,
-0.0472354963,
0.0297102481,
-0.0463279858,
-0.0075488905,
0.0249705501,
-0.0081715072,
-0.0691649392,
0.0015199237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19470v1 | Changing Answer Order Can Decrease MMLU Accuracy | 2024-06-27T18:21:32 | 2024-06-27T18:21:32 | Vipul Gupta, David Pantoja, Candace Ross, Adina Williams, Megan Ung | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) have grown in prevalence, particular
benchmarks have become essential for the evaluation of these models and for
understanding model capabilities. Most commonly, we use test accuracy averaged
across multiple subtasks in order to rank models on leaderboards, to determine
which model is best for our purposes. In this paper, we investigate the
robustness of the accuracy measurement on a widely used multiple choice
question answering dataset, MMLU. When shuffling the answer label contents, we
find that all explored models decrease in accuracy on MMLU, but not every model
is equally sensitive. These findings suggest a possible adjustment to the
standard practice of leaderboard testing, where we additionally consider the
percentage of examples each model answers correctly by random chance. | [
0.0566956401,
0.0670613721,
-0.0051449738,
0.0553963073,
-0.0382945724,
0.010875944,
0.0183376111,
0.0056908838,
0.0319777355,
-0.0557888299,
-0.0107269222,
-0.0472689234,
-0.0058192317,
-0.0098459413,
0.0280090794,
0.0016203366,
0.0382644497,
-0.0642871112,
0.0115265418,
-0.0234900657,
-0.0342481732,
-0.0296766702,
-0.0010733302,
0.012681473,
0.0507710204,
-0.0034156798,
-0.0034838838,
-0.0147991106,
0.0105058691,
-0.0131882802,
0.019612724,
0.0905376822,
-0.0263863225,
0.048896417,
0.0000017025,
-0.03913505,
0.0084788306,
-0.0164273866,
-0.028029155,
0.0421961099,
-0.0175771322,
0.0651058927,
0.0030647174,
0.0400746092,
-0.036858581,
0.02662763,
0.0110218721,
-0.0022696275,
0.0718649179,
0.0393088274,
0.0270970631,
0.0017441988,
0.0336244218,
-0.0422998406,
0.0265220869,
-0.0392047167,
0.0297162104,
0.0321028642,
0.0063802144,
0.0100737847,
-0.038809333,
0.0350227319,
-0.0017152521,
0.0419890471,
-0.0211008806,
0.0203280225,
-0.0255106166,
-0.0013553294,
0.0132811889,
0.0710619837,
-0.0329194777,
-0.0126345223,
-0.0343613885,
-0.0259249061,
0.0155992918,
0.0368272364,
-0.0546020232,
0.017845368,
0.0029698128,
-0.028293483,
0.0318443067,
-0.0061566783,
0.016406497,
0.0068243784,
-0.0463496223,
0.1245018393,
0.0249238666,
-0.0486504212,
0.0149426898,
-0.0019390828,
-0.0276188497,
-0.0463523678,
-0.0065299654,
0.0049737133,
-0.0271864012,
0.0395422243,
-0.0077230576,
0.0010945299,
0.0569027103,
-0.0410220996,
0.0264504794,
0.0157562681,
0.0022772739,
0.052805163,
0.0034372427,
0.1040748507,
0.0055671339,
0.0509907454,
-0.0611726418,
-0.0088202432,
-0.0326529257,
-0.0295445453,
0.0276335385,
0.0271883514,
-0.0193493869,
0.0037752276,
-0.0629625022,
0.0241287146,
0.0032366228,
-0.0079141818,
0.0234146118,
0.018325055,
0.021934567,
0.0312144049,
-0.0439540111,
0.0386540852,
-0.0143283177,
0.0181677472,
0.0248703007,
-0.0579938442,
0.018916117,
-0.0257703252,
-0.0114534944,
-0.0246456228,
0.0282968841,
0.0810966417,
-0.0042828307,
-0.0323006846,
0.0357166976,
-0.0024458179,
-0.0364040174,
-0.0454010032,
-0.0034542775,
-0.0901868045,
0.0362195671,
0.0474628098,
0.0083872015,
-0.0095169228,
0.0127189523,
0.0433349386,
-0.0587246716,
0.0277832877,
0.0452826023,
0.0319532789,
0.0173947476,
-0.0119850701,
-0.0042174608,
0.0463291965,
0.0149361044,
0.0116923107,
0.0671505406,
-0.0426160246,
0.0150810862,
0.0537262671,
0.0082714781,
0.0080409134,
0.0209363438,
0.0541271642,
0.0144038545,
0.0141051803,
-0.0163690709,
0.033622779,
0.0000207488,
-0.0504187159,
0.0851330161,
0.0525177531,
-0.0008552058,
-0.0488938093,
-0.0234541502,
-0.0168439541,
0.0192794986,
0.015927311,
-0.0542872772,
-0.0013630848,
-0.0379311442,
0.0181237925,
0.0276884027,
0.0209303256,
-0.0133245718,
-0.0582664646,
-0.0328967534,
0.0117329722,
-0.0190212522,
0.0727038383,
0.0298848674,
-0.0317454413,
-0.0230996106,
0.0584927574,
-0.0012013367,
-0.0490925275,
-0.0189551525,
-0.0682988688,
0.0236286074,
0.0440006107,
0.0258274768,
-0.0068231602,
-0.0517740473,
0.0093740756,
0.0035854897,
0.0109812785,
0.0258194674,
-0.0101772277,
0.0201189574,
-0.0033818409,
-0.0017221627,
0.0068289097,
0.0110238092,
0.0253943559,
0.0199957732,
-0.0079053687,
-0.0093760509,
-0.05953978,
-0.0517878942,
0.0174102224,
-0.0216681994,
-0.027669929,
0.0033985465,
-0.0282625761,
0.0276407413,
-0.0071164495,
-0.0197346527,
0.0287768934,
0.0584776141,
-0.0066396752,
-0.0122264754,
-0.0484817214,
-0.0391444601,
-0.0297248811,
0.0545206852,
0.0019817336,
-0.0058779456,
0.1006072983,
-0.049632255,
-0.0383898504,
-0.0281744767,
-0.0112057133,
0.0080642635,
-0.0261074305,
0.036310032,
0.0048339278,
-0.0027307838,
-0.0831414312,
0.047951933,
-0.0362426303,
0.082888253,
0.0057533039,
0.0226368904,
0.0123207895,
-0.0297634993,
-0.0276473556,
0.0485549904,
-0.0179021806,
0.0227641929,
0.0326137617,
-0.0017093177,
-0.0599967241,
-0.0593457855,
-0.0884707272,
0.0022962617,
-0.0186884534,
-0.0029073637,
0.0236295052,
0.0136124631,
-0.0163800847,
-0.0336643308,
-0.0571816713,
-0.0345674679,
0.0498958975,
0.0457779951,
0.0162408389,
-0.0013215811,
-0.0102119697,
-0.0707373396,
-0.0466681235,
-0.0155142946,
0.0526048541,
-0.0230954885,
0.0208085421,
-0.0244513731,
-0.0155870095,
-0.0727130771,
0.0106340004,
-0.0078591928,
-0.0149051975,
0.0144496541,
-0.0071601076,
0.020266464,
0.0816178247,
0.0444829985,
0.003196426,
0.0602050498,
-0.0030842994,
-0.0432154201,
-0.0000278685,
-0.0080336276,
-0.0422536582,
-0.0337550193,
-0.0831801444,
0.0018643599,
0.0897795185,
0.025404375,
-0.0022012815,
-0.0138808899,
0.0173707288,
-0.0496398024,
-0.0289955772,
-0.0630556643,
0.0366946533,
-0.0312508084,
0.0592742674,
-0.0165456235,
-0.0450585969,
0.0363151506,
-0.0340392031,
0.0015536408,
-0.0371907204,
-0.0106740072,
-0.0492645353,
0.0445729494,
0.0532028601,
0.0018657232,
-0.026142709,
-0.0026416827,
-0.0631164312,
-0.0329128541,
0.0170255005,
-0.073286511,
0.0374230705,
-0.0556113981,
0.0142585048,
-0.0079678921,
-0.0410275459,
-0.0462135375,
-0.055268269,
-0.0301131289,
0.0132154841,
0.0004459403,
-0.0183060691,
-0.0092779566,
0.003247672,
0.0186282061,
0.0105675589,
-0.0540838167,
0.0113764182,
-0.0063504023,
0.08211606,
0.0808053613,
0.0325626396,
0.0235911421,
-0.0304316953,
0.0220843013,
0.0430451035,
0.0618341267,
0.0202766228,
0.0122463405,
0.0023503539,
0.0304522831,
-0.0402267985,
-0.0274520498,
0.0383736901,
0.037955001,
-0.0104634184,
-0.0071719345,
0.107633695,
0.0557202362,
0.018338671,
0.0133104846,
0.0047918004,
0.0464834124,
0.0353849567,
0.0287113674,
-0.039001178,
-0.0193557683,
-0.0188115556,
0.0444465727,
-0.005716796,
-0.0240557399,
0.0135337943,
-0.1186217144,
0.0046467436,
-0.0175556168,
-0.0652493685,
0.0104473503,
-0.0502190031,
-0.0120117413,
-0.0204913225,
0.0202595089,
0.0326395035,
-0.0000575428,
0.0135909347,
0.0312385578,
-0.053097032,
-0.0255368464,
0.0622143336,
-0.0234338008,
0.0546973683,
0.0421304889,
0.0191037133,
-0.0406128056,
-0.0350857154,
0.0246292017,
-0.0387319885,
-0.0089199757,
-0.0130551923,
0.0461980291,
0.000571536,
0.0055533,
-0.025006447,
-0.0154207516,
-0.0161442794,
0.0193353426,
0.0466445982,
0.0514451191,
0.0195828825,
-0.0278968792,
-0.0341836922,
-0.0053428407,
-0.0273753684,
0.0685834736,
0.0142120551,
-0.0603524968,
-0.0241344031,
-0.0687051862,
0.0045426819,
-0.0202302858,
-0.0460120961,
0.029228596,
0.0197834391,
0.0333882384,
-0.0595160536,
-0.0455613434,
0.0087337075,
-0.0029054023,
-0.0240980648,
0.042938415,
-0.0218784716,
0.0144028608,
-0.0296427105,
0.0019972527,
-0.0003958132,
0.0286353454,
-0.0788833424,
0.001806897,
0.0468834937,
0.0111577306,
-0.0384279713,
0.012801487,
-0.1129167452,
-0.0633911639,
0.038461104,
0.0415877439,
0.0209007021,
0.0055968184,
0.0167576987,
-0.0381900519,
0.0017297897,
-0.0367902294,
-0.0119983722,
0.0413370058,
-0.0023065887,
-0.0085802563,
-0.0175678786,
0.0033087691,
-0.0680434704,
0.0190386642,
0.0262850765,
0.0446692668,
-0.0235075504,
-0.0453907289,
0.0268320572,
0.0323528163,
0.0216474049,
0.0160710793,
-0.0184049793,
0.0128939785,
0.0555061251,
-0.0072664777,
-0.0173521135,
0.0043937834,
-0.0113881649,
0.0389907993,
-0.0221484825,
-0.0127332006,
-0.0090257972,
-0.0074758311,
0.0356888324,
-0.04094854,
-0.0107251611,
0.0068413704,
0.0032856907,
0.0011925881,
-0.0157732014,
-0.0513504185,
0.0070708413,
-0.0023170086,
0.0703079626,
0.0267350785,
0.0411833413,
-0.0185085349,
-0.0329115577,
0.0128309969,
0.040866822,
-0.1250948906,
-0.0647129193,
-0.0284938551,
0.0301458687,
0.0341075771,
-0.0034525492,
0.0343902148,
-0.0015907069,
0.0029185221,
-0.0467183031,
-0.0340253748,
0.0281196069,
-0.0003476373,
0.0343359336,
0.0278479401,
0.0085429316,
0.0274984315,
0.0685907975,
0.0934517309,
0.0074446131,
0.0161771718,
-0.0086480826,
-0.0360906944,
0.0057041352,
-0.0057435594,
0.0035898741,
-0.0171164107,
-0.0008294592,
-0.0464458801,
-0.0566834547,
0.0233651027,
0.0357888192,
0.0319722854,
-0.022568455,
-0.0014235111,
0.0836721659,
0.0055894125,
-0.0147091085,
-0.0587855242,
-0.0010833559,
-0.0333200805,
-0.0109359212,
-0.0257504266,
-5.966015499e-33,
-0.0324552171,
-0.0185605157,
0.0001351753,
-0.0296415389,
0.0337817706,
-0.0025804683,
0.0036022339,
0.0304205716,
-0.0464298837,
-0.0355255604,
-0.0426072851,
0.0025784739,
0.0122428816,
0.0302025788,
0.0295698717,
-0.0377840586,
-0.0087798517,
-0.0114589902,
-0.0357514136,
-0.0120821623,
0.0204484686,
0.0027047805,
0.0532085635,
-0.0299897566,
0.036557056,
-0.0163078401,
0.0252284016,
0.0083100935,
-0.07962396,
0.0538777262,
0.001541945,
0.0554137342,
0.0351501927,
-0.0357673094,
-0.0034909172,
-0.0074802581,
-0.0430572219,
-0.0381212831,
0.0158822313,
0.0091426102,
-0.0327076688,
0.0116965603,
0.0277509894,
-0.0024086705,
-0.0279331375,
-0.0227278341,
0.0347167701,
-0.0152609479,
-0.0415738113,
0.0073566246,
0.0083757071,
0.0210331362,
-0.0085703013,
0.0042048381,
-0.045602046,
0.0690894723,
0.0029426937,
0.0093968352,
-0.0173213892,
0.0213807076,
0.0530108064,
0.0628232285,
0.0708347782,
0.0470326878,
-0.0262038689,
0.0541279726,
0.0244705286,
0.0114010032,
0.0402008668,
-0.033146657,
0.0153101301,
0.0205432158,
0.1000501812,
0.0340492651,
0.0291380901,
0.026963871,
-0.0591705143,
0.0364333354,
0.0333405398,
-0.0235662479,
0.0214855261,
-0.0042515313,
-0.0438962132,
-0.0386833735,
-0.0668706223,
0.0299572237,
-0.0319231302,
-0.0259971898,
0.0740060508,
-0.0312866271,
-0.0121406792,
-0.0306506157,
0.0474502817,
-0.0310110636,
-0.0673299581,
0.0185214337,
0.0050841626,
0.0353933387,
0.0024571149,
0.0492316224,
-0.0535992831,
0.0256499629,
-0.0079365624,
0.0054747239,
-0.004137171,
-0.0122609204,
-0.0229304526,
-0.0134370662,
-0.0615387,
-0.0179051086,
-0.0273807272,
-0.0065730433,
-0.0098617598,
-0.0181171261,
0.0317873396,
-0.0189153478,
-0.0059899595,
0.036593169,
-0.0120294066,
-0.0312386416,
-0.0495378003,
-0.0091190692,
-0.0097466884,
0.0076722363,
-0.0215943772,
-0.0034483206,
-0.0352671929,
0.0393386632,
-0.012839729,
-0.0073376223,
-0.0039056102,
0.0263373926,
2.299e-7,
0.0691912472,
0.0573550165,
-0.0178461988,
0.0300929938,
0.0136864353,
0.0127999447,
-0.0510507859,
0.0047160066,
0.070499897,
0.0086866468,
-0.0231132749,
-0.0112098278,
0.0308109727,
0.0319683701,
-0.0598895475,
-0.030352179,
-0.0580445603,
0.0122205066,
-0.0342301354,
0.0189598594,
0.03408904,
0.0970510989,
-0.0084042894,
-0.0081309043,
-0.0495466553,
-0.0328543819,
0.0385601185,
-0.0488165431,
-0.0227137934,
-0.0056700218,
0.0236328486,
0.0053819101,
0.0283383969,
0.0422233865,
0.0021538683,
-0.012736571,
0.0387073644,
0.0215349961,
-0.0053534857,
-0.0508436412,
-0.0277502276,
-0.015623562,
0.0126775866,
-0.0875735208,
0.0851026103,
-0.0112471161,
0.0000927209,
-0.0422561131,
-0.0268977713,
-0.0127545521,
0.0407176837,
-0.0220778678,
-0.0149606699,
0.0054383315,
0.005632767,
0.0029060396,
0.0111813955,
-0.0161995944,
-0.0446693413,
0.0067417077,
-0.0310168825,
-0.0893540233,
-0.0425908491,
-0.0143549908,
-0.0186728667,
-0.0506132208,
-0.0299894046,
2.061723878e-34,
0.0280871745,
0.0176068749,
0.0290878955,
0.0234048665,
0.0324185267,
-0.0195916165,
0.0212909468,
0.0168824177,
-0.0043675886,
-0.0982307717,
-0.0146679562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19465v1 | Can Large Language Models Generate High-quality Patent Claims? | 2024-06-27T18:07:40 | 2024-06-27T18:07:40 | Lekang Jiang, Caiqi Zhang, Pascal A Scherz, Stephan Goetz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional performance across
various text generation tasks but remain under-explored in the patent domain,
which offers highly structured and precise language. This paper constructs a
dataset to investigate the performance of current LLMs in patent claim
generation. Our results demonstrate that generating claims based on patent
descriptions outperforms previous research relying on abstracts. Interestingly,
current patent-specific LLMs perform much worse than state-of-the-art general
LLMs, highlighting the necessity for future research on in-domain LLMs. We also
find that LLMs can produce high-quality first independent claims, but their
performances markedly decrease for subsequent dependent claims. Moreover,
fine-tuning can enhance the completeness of inventions' features, conceptual
clarity, and feature linkage. Among the tested LLMs, GPT-4 demonstrates the
best performance in comprehensive human evaluations by patent experts, with
better feature coverage, conceptual clarity, and technical coherence. Despite
these capabilities, comprehensive revision and modification are still necessary
to pass rigorous patent scrutiny and ensure legal robustness. | [
0.0440487042,
0.0447053686,
-0.0145114856,
0.0136938952,
-0.0599842966,
-0.0442117415,
0.0250058416,
-0.0034476565,
0.0125656938,
-0.0789218917,
0.0272186324,
-0.0650888756,
0.0164652597,
0.0176780224,
0.0543955192,
-0.0338936932,
-0.0070033767,
-0.0160699431,
0.0197504908,
-0.0164529737,
0.0079169068,
0.0179346632,
-0.0072232787,
0.040427383,
-0.011818707,
0.0156757403,
0.0207129698,
-0.0129273981,
0.0029038601,
-0.0674020797,
-0.0246175285,
0.0807628557,
-0.0024708954,
0.033063326,
0.0000016983,
-0.102737017,
0.0111350231,
0.0394343622,
0.0421987027,
0.078666456,
0.0291578509,
-0.0172825716,
-0.0165303033,
0.0275237858,
0.002037385,
0.0004176352,
0.0013434333,
0.0523348115,
0.0265184231,
0.0601026937,
-0.0155858435,
-0.0403851345,
0.0844705328,
-0.0626523048,
-0.0044451905,
-0.0494878553,
0.0153321093,
0.0313534811,
0.0631818548,
-0.0473243818,
0.0276231281,
0.0410310254,
-0.0071521867,
-0.0208468493,
0.035698276,
0.0191549789,
-0.0252535902,
0.0105522238,
0.0107634272,
0.049167376,
0.0359617993,
0.0035752838,
0.0150842955,
-0.0180227719,
0.0267423354,
-0.0002277531,
-0.0188151132,
0.0911555216,
-0.0242666844,
0.0159856156,
0.0318207629,
0.0062353606,
0.0182349645,
0.0171154812,
-0.0006984739,
0.0491600893,
0.0226192679,
-0.0429721549,
-0.029619243,
-0.0310126152,
-0.0146931391,
-0.0821165219,
0.0233479738,
-0.0078613292,
0.0482443981,
0.0457269251,
-0.0742344856,
-0.018306246,
0.0405212939,
-0.0723150447,
0.0313349999,
-0.0042146011,
-0.0080398824,
0.0427932553,
-0.0618410185,
0.056739185,
-0.0265664309,
-0.0420707464,
-0.0043674307,
-0.0293022022,
-0.0474190004,
-0.0224604905,
-0.036578998,
0.069219172,
-0.0296177045,
-0.009454255,
-0.071903713,
0.0269047227,
-0.0218488518,
0.0431715399,
-0.0033692038,
-0.0148281856,
0.0171323624,
-0.0676043555,
-0.0579525083,
-0.0283902138,
0.0063254028,
0.0138337361,
-0.0026907946,
-0.0370542444,
0.0129789282,
0.0277266651,
-0.0003130646,
-0.006482373,
-0.0165847335,
0.0289528873,
0.0255683623,
-0.0154389441,
-0.0150163155,
-0.0754749179,
0.0059924689,
-0.0349352509,
-0.0348386243,
-0.0623118319,
0.0082500419,
0.0207529794,
-0.008028917,
-0.0849564523,
-0.0006158992,
0.0099288551,
-0.0287077837,
0.0094225723,
-0.024985021,
0.0183520932,
-0.0317025855,
-0.0045037498,
0.007923997,
0.0018274961,
0.0457615256,
0.0262447465,
0.0265732333,
0.0070908754,
0.0311960056,
0.0377744213,
0.0020054867,
-0.016122181,
0.0078949761,
0.0004297374,
0.0148821399,
0.0307917017,
0.0006049959,
0.0506766886,
-0.0185880549,
0.0493806116,
0.097466819,
0.0792040452,
0.0166606884,
0.0272001326,
0.0041511497,
0.0158938859,
0.034114603,
-0.0314509273,
-0.0127047375,
-0.0074415081,
-0.0499748141,
0.0062623364,
0.0343329944,
-0.0020099429,
-0.0064938962,
-0.0392257646,
-0.0243079029,
0.0080953194,
-0.0050306185,
-0.0475115329,
0.0355288424,
-0.0019138964,
-0.0293375235,
0.0730301067,
-0.0032873158,
-0.0172892697,
-0.0274719074,
-0.0410468057,
0.007085497,
0.0439855494,
0.054479178,
0.0063662692,
0.0119522298,
-0.0020905491,
-0.0030774584,
0.0673609376,
0.0767572373,
0.0046350802,
-0.0475726053,
0.0085676117,
-0.0174301676,
-0.0272101518,
0.0224657357,
0.0204926934,
-0.0036775698,
-0.004823138,
0.0473422892,
-0.0332053974,
-0.0023677854,
-0.0034596035,
-0.049158819,
0.0031309836,
0.0392779224,
-0.0312589593,
0.0236417204,
0.0321128182,
-0.0340661705,
0.038217783,
0.0120292809,
-0.0320016481,
-0.023638865,
0.0415525027,
0.0589267388,
0.0262518972,
-0.001426152,
-0.0270711593,
0.0006730343,
-0.0173161682,
0.0086971363,
-0.0105957836,
-0.0055144578,
-0.0362432376,
0.0152248573,
-0.0457679145,
0.0160556193,
0.0089985281,
0.015233106,
-0.0150853861,
0.0502952486,
0.0301858597,
0.0013081192,
0.0063129268,
-0.0118457666,
0.029001778,
-0.0481504612,
-0.0039976821,
0.0290855095,
-0.0076281899,
0.0032753192,
0.022088781,
-0.0370334797,
0.0070166653,
-0.0119508244,
-0.0993248969,
0.0169226304,
0.0041967961,
0.0335676558,
0.0088013969,
-0.0075516733,
0.0004221619,
0.0265316013,
-0.0506456867,
-0.069651477,
0.0116733648,
-0.0122208297,
0.0428795367,
-0.0105024502,
-0.0624867193,
0.0010940911,
-0.0159509387,
-0.0103281662,
0.0097043263,
0.0637921765,
-0.0309886914,
-0.0894570574,
0.0531484298,
-0.030803347,
0.0160962418,
-0.0058879922,
0.0218727011,
-0.0205143541,
0.009789248,
-0.0433758721,
-0.019246107,
0.0100340974,
0.0165070165,
0.0243596211,
0.0239135996,
-0.0183511265,
-0.0017243308,
0.0239106771,
0.0483037047,
-0.0021296004,
-0.0053384025,
0.0429400317,
0.0202457979,
0.0118480828,
-0.0045528379,
-0.0372360013,
-0.0008366511,
-0.0302730724,
0.0117627941,
0.0223466568,
-0.0152779445,
0.0009765,
0.0718566105,
-0.0088899229,
-0.0720956177,
0.0479665361,
-0.0540352799,
0.0254727993,
-0.0447990336,
0.0110032009,
-0.0345868506,
0.0964643136,
-0.0062139556,
0.0003415894,
0.0283200499,
-0.0056242994,
0.0002213146,
0.0014491985,
0.0398548581,
-0.0265086498,
0.0499729887,
-0.0510716923,
0.0626500472,
-0.0251179859,
-0.0283387229,
-0.0179586187,
-0.0611433722,
0.0248258542,
0.0499614477,
0.0347455107,
0.0009269005,
-0.0225919988,
0.0125754289,
0.0278480425,
0.0327976905,
0.0160027817,
0.0075123631,
-0.0148545206,
0.024482578,
0.0236898623,
-0.0236581173,
0.0012093757,
-0.039899908,
-0.0017901288,
-0.0027046769,
-0.024293473,
0.0329857655,
0.0044161431,
-0.0173355117,
-0.0142303128,
-0.04559239,
-0.0463479161,
0.0335835889,
0.0452559255,
-0.0367762111,
0.0546409152,
0.0977120697,
-0.0126447883,
0.0822071955,
0.0329058617,
0.0754488334,
-0.0009337202,
0.005985402,
0.0298978817,
-0.1174493879,
0.0347703882,
-0.0492863767,
0.0012982229,
-0.0384114236,
-0.025339704,
-0.0501146391,
-0.1372909248,
0.0840831101,
0.0297796652,
-0.0200051833,
-0.0389674865,
-0.024930492,
-0.0177333504,
0.008593671,
-0.0025634039,
-0.0096159726,
-0.002915367,
-0.0272531454,
0.0000222469,
-0.0954511166,
-0.0348918438,
0.0233020689,
-0.0404601209,
0.0018253606,
0.0664322227,
0.0017227456,
-0.0086528463,
-0.0068785381,
0.0018238482,
0.0097108223,
0.0124142533,
0.0240340922,
0.0038866359,
0.0362233557,
0.0082981186,
0.0003490002,
0.0105509218,
-0.0219492652,
-0.0213031974,
0.0020609009,
0.0721436441,
-0.0315239914,
-0.0215183422,
0.0004107128,
-0.0233961288,
-0.0150129348,
0.062347047,
0.0101468209,
-0.0425276831,
-0.0547042117,
-0.0515456349,
-0.0161733329,
-0.0828513801,
0.0060105165,
-0.0143835405,
-0.0175016969,
0.0026661968,
-0.0987083167,
-0.0469668023,
-0.0015607382,
0.0334134921,
0.0292290188,
0.0429843329,
0.0339282081,
-0.0127852019,
-0.0372692123,
0.0269639082,
-0.007153546,
0.0152665675,
-0.0328138806,
-0.0142126381,
0.0353998058,
-0.0274238065,
-0.0254136976,
0.030030461,
-0.038238924,
-0.0819188803,
-0.040003594,
-0.0063343854,
0.027948495,
0.0050551305,
-0.037653096,
-0.0683688149,
0.0585940331,
0.0225680973,
0.0212847795,
0.0044891001,
-0.0037507669,
-0.0485512726,
-0.0372969434,
-0.001538469,
-0.020094566,
0.0217715502,
0.0407308899,
0.0317461975,
0.0572677553,
-0.039525114,
0.0334452614,
0.0901419222,
0.0205707327,
-0.0134356041,
0.0489162095,
-0.0233419053,
0.0094578313,
-0.0309478194,
-0.0285761952,
-0.0572151206,
-0.006853045,
0.007800065,
-0.0304021705,
-0.027111413,
0.0317538381,
-0.0121051222,
0.0278054401,
-0.0554653779,
0.0065364596,
-0.0955256298,
0.0023662099,
0.0461923219,
-0.0373481922,
-0.0007343327,
0.0127200633,
-0.0418289527,
0.0313258544,
-0.0193057116,
0.0035399243,
-0.0077519286,
0.0291468054,
-0.0214944426,
0.0189160984,
-0.0090459585,
-0.0782601461,
-0.0536417402,
0.051263608,
0.0621273071,
0.0220981631,
0.0690971017,
-0.0863059014,
-0.0004258156,
-0.0292838439,
0.0631462559,
-0.0023110053,
-0.0194183588,
0.0128277242,
0.0194925126,
-0.0137771191,
-0.026387047,
0.0530841164,
0.0425106287,
0.0371973477,
-0.0622085221,
-0.0202407725,
-0.0370600224,
-0.0399337001,
0.0185904857,
-0.0131868906,
-0.02726507,
-0.0019097788,
-0.0923009291,
-0.0206316169,
0.0226860251,
0.0004355425,
0.0470494889,
0.0111712357,
0.0034332115,
0.0625666454,
-0.0016574573,
-0.0290140267,
-0.0483577996,
-0.0274000242,
0.0070179561,
-0.0387744792,
-0.0072077624,
-5.561658299e-33,
-0.0059799571,
-0.0245074667,
0.003867469,
-0.0021346933,
0.0109575633,
-0.0247633103,
-0.0621984415,
0.0190389864,
0.0373438783,
0.0231761094,
-0.0080407383,
0.0021028323,
0.0113836741,
0.0227929559,
0.0273824558,
0.0215853751,
0.0485976785,
0.0190594774,
-0.0349796265,
0.0195460748,
0.0041025882,
-0.0039230855,
0.023282459,
-0.0496605858,
0.0408620052,
0.0071598957,
-0.0240293164,
-0.0476833582,
-0.0428236015,
0.0549654961,
0.0015450645,
0.0243973881,
0.0128597841,
-0.0575839058,
-0.0186294522,
-0.0278020836,
-0.0311731268,
0.0398873314,
0.019102715,
-0.0469221286,
0.0179671794,
-0.0243104715,
0.0554819144,
0.0086888578,
-0.0598546714,
-0.0002490651,
0.0409411937,
-0.0295769684,
-0.0131719746,
-0.0871753171,
-0.0701174811,
0.0484435521,
0.0167148076,
0.0304034594,
0.0202048793,
-0.0315576717,
-0.0252184905,
0.0397813767,
-0.0279402975,
0.0317172669,
-0.0094381319,
0.0178360809,
0.0439829491,
-0.0537508056,
0.0022567038,
0.0566627942,
0.0068649319,
0.0632813796,
0.0155187752,
0.0310756564,
-0.0315042064,
0.0848560855,
0.0280867089,
0.0079679601,
0.0375361852,
0.0100684585,
-0.0608985014,
0.0155346813,
-0.0500953533,
-0.026429059,
0.0378692076,
-0.0134540983,
-0.0159166753,
-0.0162964929,
-0.0149258478,
0.0094847633,
0.0004241147,
0.0050158394,
0.0080291191,
0.0082552806,
0.0028523854,
0.0469616726,
0.0176146328,
-0.0466357842,
-0.0540115163,
-0.0438114777,
-0.0047732107,
0.0539550297,
-0.0257422514,
-0.0313973464,
-0.0418124385,
-0.0236155093,
-0.0260032117,
0.0158542674,
0.022374684,
0.011215575,
0.0108896773,
-0.0270798896,
-0.0497212633,
0.0250773579,
-0.033437334,
0.0235975627,
0.0143770119,
-0.0058496227,
0.0092223808,
0.0134670176,
0.0268396307,
0.0215097535,
0.0010026029,
-0.0771000013,
-0.0343838111,
0.0054968065,
0.0081574759,
-0.0088662198,
0.0023078257,
0.0240400955,
0.0135206971,
0.0331304222,
0.0661085322,
-0.0002208759,
-0.022256976,
0.0164349675,
2.476e-7,
0.0343875475,
0.0715914965,
-0.0038194836,
0.0463101268,
0.0175549798,
0.0186925847,
-0.0263091065,
0.0498089828,
-0.0149114132,
-0.0393371657,
0.0078453505,
-0.0350217931,
0.0547937974,
-0.0063238922,
-0.0918065459,
-0.0219059028,
-0.0218165964,
-0.0028792068,
-0.062396571,
0.0039492152,
0.0900518447,
0.035636995,
-0.0000131477,
-0.0099838506,
-0.0169330854,
-0.0609017275,
0.0831069052,
-0.0019124941,
-0.0218431689,
0.0418864377,
0.0752731636,
-0.0302504078,
-0.0277936123,
0.0533556528,
-0.0445476137,
0.0349076204,
-0.0077102627,
0.062497668,
0.0247597247,
0.0555541217,
-0.0058233286,
-0.0380569287,
0.0033632242,
-0.0370752141,
0.0091310805,
0.0019038726,
-0.0338716619,
-0.0096881129,
0.0036937871,
0.0133540789,
-0.0195741225,
0.0194201544,
0.0272083897,
-0.0202279538,
-0.0042805956,
0.0000925384,
0.0027530752,
-0.0529559478,
-0.0132760117,
0.0185614303,
-0.0496169291,
-0.0245726649,
-0.0086940322,
0.0027249104,
0.0605799332,
-0.049737189,
0.0298840757,
2.253347365e-34,
0.0485110991,
-0.0391917005,
-0.0109422337,
0.0119680092,
0.0593597069,
0.028036423,
0.0642320663,
0.0192522518,
-0.026757231,
-0.0569585487,
-0.0025427227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19388v1 | Taming Data and Transformers for Audio Generation | 2024-06-27T17:58:54 | 2024-06-27T17:58:54 | Moayed Haji-Ali, Willi Menapace, Aliaksandr Siarohin, Guha Balakrishnan, Sergey Tulyakov, Vicente Ordonez | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM, eess.AS | Generating ambient sounds and effects is a challenging problem due to data
scarcity and often insufficient caption quality, making it difficult to employ
large-scale generative models for the task. In this work, we tackle the problem
by introducing two new models. First, we propose AutoCap, a high-quality and
efficient automatic audio captioning model. We show that by leveraging metadata
available with the audio modality, we can substantially improve the quality of
captions. AutoCap reaches CIDEr score of 83.2, marking a 3.2% improvement from
the best available captioning model at four times faster inference speed. We
then use AutoCap to caption clips from existing datasets, obtaining 761,000
audio clips with high-quality captions, forming the largest available
audio-text dataset. Second, we propose GenAu, a scalable transformer-based
audio generation architecture that we scale up to 1.25B parameters and train
with our new dataset. When compared to state-of-the-art audio generators, GenAu
obtains significant improvements of 15.7% in FAD score, 22.7% in IS, and 13.5%
in CLAP score, indicating significantly improved quality of generated audio
compared to previous works. This shows that the quality of data is often as
important as its quantity. Besides, since AutoCap is fully automatic, new audio
samples can be added to the training dataset, unlocking the training of even
larger generative models for audio synthesis. | [
-0.0085611884,
0.0589136779,
0.0023795818,
-0.0135614099,
0.0273020547,
-0.0287233796,
0.0341207907,
-0.0255160183,
-0.0733968168,
-0.0176982842,
-0.0590913221,
-0.0022492015,
0.0034690925,
0.0467230193,
0.0074782725,
-0.0860573873,
-0.0166160557,
-0.0350188613,
-0.0335795581,
-0.0223521013,
-0.0259933099,
0.0103427898,
-0.0171657968,
0.039656695,
-0.0439113788,
0.0121694142,
0.007206474,
0.0294473991,
0.0155268479,
-0.0168497264,
-0.0322688557,
0.0790537372,
0.0231278352,
0.0175655838,
0.0000018721,
0.0001559841,
-0.0039453567,
0.0214889403,
0.0443158112,
0.0221665073,
0.0288486127,
0.0054510897,
-0.0563036427,
0.0243134443,
-0.0158855747,
-0.0223766267,
0.0627425164,
0.0369256474,
0.0539854132,
0.0299988892,
-0.0212432966,
-0.0750120729,
-0.0178187899,
-0.0488355681,
0.0117191849,
0.0305058137,
-0.0139908092,
0.0388909504,
0.0070997234,
0.0015394804,
-0.0037345581,
0.0446243957,
0.016557185,
-0.0004592503,
0.0505798534,
0.0608767048,
-0.0562677644,
-0.0413287319,
-0.0017370003,
0.078231968,
0.0268008392,
0.0050134384,
-0.0072384682,
0.0310963169,
0.0091527319,
-0.0440208949,
-0.0403426215,
0.0357635505,
0.0201432779,
0.0178696215,
-0.0657664835,
0.0539998226,
0.0321732536,
-0.0581789613,
0.0222120658,
-0.0656755194,
0.0382541306,
0.006372395,
-0.0403944477,
-0.0320872813,
-0.0428666808,
-0.0311954487,
0.0136561841,
-0.0243179053,
0.0072864029,
-0.0285190791,
-0.0707526878,
-0.0411898158,
-0.0187462252,
0.0143270064,
0.003893822,
0.021154834,
-0.053278435,
0.0444413573,
-0.0077548325,
-0.0144690424,
0.0004466558,
-0.0122804372,
-0.027541576,
-0.0178880468,
-0.018575266,
-0.0035450768,
-0.0353491977,
0.0047835396,
-0.0641330853,
-0.0413250066,
-0.0597165897,
-0.0375206247,
-0.0352047272,
0.0134683428,
0.0319473222,
0.0677216798,
-0.0419445373,
-0.0099037588,
0.0338635407,
-0.0033975586,
-0.0088345138,
0.0649444833,
0.0231086425,
-0.036673896,
-0.0166595299,
0.009783648,
0.0532307923,
0.0263925474,
0.0374689288,
0.0915753394,
0.002621443,
-0.00247424,
-0.0062144389,
-0.0270859413,
-0.0357230231,
-0.0100731142,
-0.0386478044,
-0.0595938601,
0.0328859687,
-0.0211030468,
-0.0176361389,
-0.0272897296,
0.0248948652,
0.0164962653,
0.0284107681,
0.067580156,
-0.0201282892,
0.0479825363,
0.0205789376,
-0.0023506316,
-0.0151241859,
0.0177026391,
0.0950415805,
0.0167119969,
0.0108002201,
-0.0320371799,
0.0446234271,
0.0400025956,
0.0312817916,
0.0085519692,
-0.0105648618,
-0.0553975962,
-0.027486207,
0.0453661121,
0.060811799,
0.063533552,
-0.0054745981,
-0.0103125228,
0.089773871,
-0.0138547542,
0.0202618148,
0.0548262671,
0.0488591529,
0.0066267648,
-0.0214546155,
-0.0402088501,
0.0251995232,
0.0754768699,
0.0302182157,
0.0136755677,
0.0573342666,
0.0252618678,
-0.0199251082,
-0.0411320664,
0.021718571,
-0.0048081982,
-0.0308071636,
-0.0266420804,
0.0050317803,
0.0642625988,
-0.0607940704,
0.0640639588,
-0.0228922535,
-0.0880983174,
-0.0003379083,
-0.0328362882,
0.0090310052,
0.0468810834,
0.0455895923,
-0.0072617102,
0.0270708073,
-0.0438341089,
0.0043551866,
0.0783340633,
-0.0054915706,
-0.0263569336,
0.0233892817,
-0.0509985127,
-0.025043007,
-0.0111672133,
-0.0019174911,
0.0371142328,
-0.0128249219,
0.0025969071,
0.0385524966,
-0.0276452769,
-0.0288486704,
-0.0007504537,
-0.0074337502,
-0.0618415214,
0.0455398299,
0.0074449945,
0.0342628881,
0.0333008543,
-0.0607686341,
0.0121278092,
-0.0019170884,
-0.0338475257,
-0.0131182643,
0.0660026222,
-0.0731906295,
0.0080402289,
0.0166882146,
-0.080338724,
0.0155499829,
0.0135516347,
0.0074028373,
-0.057489641,
0.0467567109,
-0.0456347317,
0.0186425839,
-0.0278443769,
0.0192277413,
0.0156607702,
0.0180312004,
0.0351638682,
0.0206523798,
0.0077287299,
-0.0350079983,
0.0346238315,
0.0224957895,
0.0113013536,
-0.0109534264,
-0.0212794784,
-0.0014453154,
-0.0135889323,
0.0022514882,
-0.0026081316,
-0.0051651164,
-0.049752187,
-0.0216373634,
-0.0748536885,
-0.0017352831,
0.0018057581,
-0.0418588556,
-0.007171609,
0.0055274297,
0.0019543006,
0.0031794633,
-0.0182810444,
-0.0410900377,
-0.0105639063,
-0.0129330559,
-0.0355215296,
-0.0072380379,
-0.0489275083,
-0.0059521631,
0.0286740586,
0.0344593152,
0.0046588317,
0.0140657872,
0.0016013283,
0.006102684,
0.002101273,
-0.000990067,
0.0135741644,
0.0014716655,
-0.0288242642,
-0.0025672198,
0.0259015206,
0.0705240741,
0.0045840754,
0.0162997562,
-0.0078545138,
0.0436955802,
-0.0031028728,
-0.0168488678,
0.0120230718,
0.002097507,
-0.0103830742,
0.0141433654,
-0.0154452426,
-0.0110197132,
0.0174379349,
0.0635895357,
0.0309917629,
-0.0326889418,
0.0190004446,
-0.0220486354,
-0.0364594944,
0.0311067272,
0.0001060359,
-0.0280776899,
0.0236368049,
-0.0238413829,
-0.0506932661,
0.0107498188,
-0.0414603278,
-0.0528512746,
-0.0152063835,
-0.0069998088,
-0.0150564481,
0.0356145389,
-0.0292737279,
0.0339330919,
0.036809314,
-0.0221718121,
-0.0105408123,
0.0221650228,
0.0539981313,
-0.0743118301,
0.0047634323,
-0.0344875157,
-0.0162174776,
-0.0020793763,
-0.0366282687,
-0.031171212,
0.0086186901,
-0.0131144552,
0.0056009078,
-0.0039317743,
-0.0350007303,
-0.0217396934,
0.032460276,
0.0325045399,
0.0609953403,
-0.0100186942,
-0.0052914224,
-0.0104120634,
0.0390142985,
0.0363333523,
0.0121056531,
-0.0175294317,
-0.0257683769,
0.0202327278,
-0.0050127078,
0.0171373766,
0.0012943151,
-0.0513724796,
0.0082959495,
0.020499574,
0.0287302434,
-0.0104626492,
0.0350929387,
0.038202256,
-0.0266822893,
0.0166607946,
0.0958034024,
0.0143048977,
-0.0145053007,
0.0222205147,
0.0269343704,
0.0044558663,
0.0164813269,
-0.0370433219,
-0.0561295338,
-0.0487234034,
0.0285573304,
0.0539252087,
0.0173086952,
0.0300238933,
-0.0200826991,
-0.0777963474,
0.0860658288,
0.0357942171,
-0.0621786416,
-0.0620522723,
-0.0067259129,
-0.0188963506,
-0.0231035706,
0.0253248289,
-0.0050617484,
0.0032391078,
0.0176584385,
0.0349628814,
0.0066601196,
-0.0696184263,
-0.0314107649,
-0.0654676929,
0.1154082865,
0.0738670528,
0.0553947538,
-0.0305665098,
-0.0310132559,
-0.0276683401,
0.0193490516,
-0.0041043074,
0.0327725932,
0.0616020001,
0.0232452787,
-0.0103381639,
0.0158890691,
0.0574880578,
-0.0249525886,
-0.0008839395,
0.0209356006,
-0.0060407277,
0.0145736123,
0.004435203,
-0.0448505208,
0.0612062924,
0.0099850651,
0.0729490817,
0.0498486087,
-0.00625904,
0.0221250281,
-0.0108999908,
0.0068035824,
-0.1326031089,
-0.027117379,
0.0073210127,
0.0011288672,
-0.0822914317,
-0.0511748344,
-0.0064788908,
0.0088500464,
0.0138637973,
0.0135862827,
-0.0328073874,
-0.0320594944,
0.0061464137,
-0.083845593,
0.0093089174,
-0.0293585751,
-0.006844515,
-0.0324744135,
-0.0620697029,
0.0563134849,
-0.023510728,
-0.0186884943,
0.0635166094,
-0.0485674217,
-0.0244449656,
-0.0107413167,
0.0462334678,
0.0166638307,
0.0377384797,
0.0379161127,
-0.0016919181,
0.0444465131,
0.0688420385,
-0.0029268872,
0.0287043918,
0.0477362946,
-0.0159982238,
0.0085194763,
0.0097161159,
-0.0763227195,
0.0673281327,
-0.0137028713,
0.0444888659,
0.0275125671,
-0.0115066385,
0.0207640529,
-0.0154754408,
-0.0055383677,
-0.0591742285,
0.0342313796,
-0.0479042418,
-0.0261301696,
-0.0362151042,
-0.0098461388,
-0.0482926928,
0.0295842402,
0.0532065071,
0.0567017645,
-0.0283242799,
0.0341380723,
-0.0199476276,
-0.002376999,
-0.0317434594,
0.0214271974,
-0.0013705883,
-0.0632122904,
0.0158334579,
-0.0231812187,
0.0246301424,
-0.0036282821,
0.0378443748,
0.0085681742,
0.0297201052,
-0.0167326145,
0.0002171228,
-0.001734519,
-0.0124721928,
0.0504344925,
-0.0104588363,
0.0179726388,
-0.0497253127,
0.0470115654,
0.0500195771,
-0.0043090982,
0.0677023232,
-0.004338271,
0.0151105355,
-0.0020178242,
0.0420684442,
-0.0051225177,
-0.0450841412,
0.0093752546,
-0.0266967602,
-0.0003431546,
-0.0130928522,
0.0670055002,
-0.0719470084,
0.0244621169,
-0.0247617252,
-0.0022366215,
-0.0250466242,
0.0039438237,
-0.0462237783,
-0.028442584,
0.007398393,
0.0344424509,
-0.0147778289,
-0.0414743759,
0.0025834155,
-0.0277606435,
0.0291261226,
-0.0197052713,
0.0412547886,
0.0032262425,
-0.0079019275,
0.012775627,
0.0159207899,
-0.0402067602,
-0.0499495864,
-0.0074345162,
-0.0031435401,
-5.12751444e-33,
-0.0540956669,
0.0059644622,
-0.0123202642,
-0.0004979277,
-0.0399465375,
-0.0087678339,
-0.0537309311,
-0.0045563476,
0.0188042689,
0.0070289043,
0.0206958856,
0.009736497,
0.0047023837,
0.0519176908,
0.0131257018,
0.0108521897,
0.0931084305,
-0.0116109038,
-0.0461725332,
0.0461717732,
0.0206854418,
0.0064542671,
-0.0049297558,
-0.0576249175,
-0.0585276075,
-0.0169045813,
-0.0463218503,
-0.0300352219,
0.0508900099,
0.0450189449,
-0.0094847968,
0.0520874038,
-0.0419533886,
-0.0520342402,
-0.0020629298,
-0.0151486006,
-0.0504593365,
0.0035696125,
-0.0090995869,
0.0289945342,
0.0132849356,
-0.035627611,
0.0383355543,
0.0074165426,
-0.0512173958,
-0.0293693207,
0.0522982217,
-0.040917553,
-0.0087895244,
-0.1110311747,
-0.0547415018,
0.0127238482,
-0.0380254872,
-0.0692272261,
0.0217774399,
0.0492956862,
0.0005748307,
0.0176473372,
-0.0303257909,
0.0702532232,
0.0316212028,
0.0202538688,
0.0618271604,
0.0297882613,
0.0007416295,
0.0485476665,
0.0102993585,
-0.044253543,
-0.0361780748,
0.0288250763,
-0.0074585574,
0.0593515895,
0.0240444001,
0.0459863059,
0.0510017313,
-0.0244555175,
0.0040281606,
0.0655258745,
-0.0712742656,
-0.0219908599,
0.0397293419,
0.0588598177,
-0.0198860317,
0.0284200646,
-0.0642955676,
-0.0101458328,
-0.0295038521,
-0.0384793356,
0.0288280323,
-0.0029123127,
-0.0246944372,
-0.0329000913,
0.0127706211,
-0.0240578093,
0.0339087583,
-0.0094503388,
-0.0524486415,
0.027002139,
-0.0223951992,
-0.0302512087,
0.0352156535,
0.0019848342,
0.1362870038,
0.027441239,
0.0281213634,
0.0155515624,
0.0134596918,
0.0721742138,
-0.0548412427,
-0.0144056091,
-0.0159547459,
0.0202571489,
0.0071540996,
0.004896991,
0.0039407439,
0.0267452653,
-0.0533817671,
-0.0143335834,
-0.0233520828,
0.0698641613,
-0.0057955524,
-0.0314734094,
-0.0290893875,
0.0039388742,
-0.0477374606,
0.0361674167,
-0.0347371586,
-0.0555679873,
0.0176624805,
-0.050417807,
-0.0798128247,
-0.0053517795,
2.637e-7,
-0.0342158079,
0.0041468753,
0.0105983363,
0.0152931847,
0.0158057008,
0.0377377532,
-0.0153174084,
0.0187254492,
-0.003243763,
-0.015836807,
0.0520178452,
-0.0005911057,
0.0664786845,
0.0307040047,
-0.0884090289,
-0.0023847439,
-0.0651545823,
0.0083462764,
-0.0038851772,
-0.0192927364,
0.0347790644,
0.0723186731,
-0.0175506435,
-0.0308826324,
0.0463642105,
-0.0192553289,
0.0474340841,
-0.0288391188,
0.0182378646,
-0.0437128544,
0.0422343872,
0.0294891875,
-0.0257067326,
-0.0111391274,
-0.0455380753,
0.0018012681,
0.0560829081,
0.0287104677,
-0.0037205142,
-0.0391201861,
-0.007388432,
0.0613957904,
0.026645029,
-0.0034469422,
0.0433740728,
-0.019452069,
-0.027685741,
-0.0295949113,
-0.0740454495,
0.0279598944,
-0.0232431125,
-0.0409781113,
-0.019014556,
-0.028251702,
0.0337442271,
0.0291261096,
-0.0143207936,
-0.0389112122,
-0.0028550585,
-0.0084899552,
-0.0422860421,
-0.0345244259,
-0.035584297,
-0.04282986,
0.0043128119,
-0.0053711766,
-0.009878939,
1.98840701e-34,
0.0361902826,
-0.0440714955,
0.016140312,
-0.0304713696,
0.0157856196,
0.0193139575,
0.0331312977,
-0.0081496416,
-0.0138017656,
-0.0313239172,
-0.0304819625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19384v1 | The Remarkable Robustness of LLMs: Stages of Inference? | 2024-06-27T17:57:03 | 2024-06-27T17:57:03 | Vedang Lad, Wes Gurnee, Max Tegmark | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We demonstrate and investigate the remarkable robustness of Large Language
Models by deleting and swapping adjacent layers. We find that deleting and
swapping interventions retain 72-95\% of the original model's prediction
accuracy without fine-tuning, whereas models with more layers exhibit more
robustness. Based on the results of the layer-wise intervention and further
experiments, we hypothesize the existence of four universal stages of inference
across eight different models: detokenization, feature engineering, prediction
ensembling, and residual sharpening. The first stage integrates local
information, lifting raw token representations into higher-level contextual
representations. Next is the iterative refinement of task and entity-specific
features. Then, the second half of the model begins with a phase transition,
where hidden representations align more with the vocabulary space due to
specialized model components. Finally, the last layer sharpens the following
token distribution by eliminating obsolete features that add noise to the
prediction. | [
0.0332896076,
0.0264332723,
-0.034511961,
0.0664421022,
-0.0345466509,
0.0164063629,
-0.0115997195,
0.0078608608,
-0.0181409549,
-0.062176235,
-0.0420063473,
0.002475135,
-0.0167304501,
0.0126775578,
0.0451570489,
-0.0476149619,
0.0522697009,
-0.0402970389,
-0.0099084983,
-0.0121688126,
-0.0217104144,
0.0073847468,
0.0046964972,
0.0454573818,
0.0124172168,
0.0064065713,
-0.0022680177,
0.0156039745,
-0.0221377537,
-0.0024962106,
0.0063524833,
0.053136114,
0.0233373903,
0.0340858921,
0.0000020424,
-0.0690340921,
0.016852526,
-0.0300757457,
-0.0622712933,
-0.0090772817,
0.0369533338,
-0.0188038964,
-0.0005432937,
-0.0274597295,
-0.0257923529,
0.0040071127,
0.0219228864,
0.046609655,
0.0041160583,
0.0806323588,
0.0037059195,
-0.0362231284,
0.0061491001,
-0.0240928419,
-0.0325813778,
-0.0315565467,
0.0193801504,
-0.0587637052,
-0.0266370159,
0.0077830302,
-0.0318315364,
0.02947204,
0.0123653859,
0.0315449238,
0.0030022333,
0.0383588299,
0.0134922136,
-0.044590991,
-0.0007602156,
0.0465172231,
-0.0335293785,
-0.01450813,
-0.0071262657,
-0.0157382675,
0.027912816,
0.0033911024,
-0.0445466638,
0.0188687574,
0.0137291951,
0.0509995483,
0.0327286758,
-0.0379071869,
0.0611915663,
0.0279301461,
-0.0091060856,
0.0705089048,
0.0070936303,
-0.0293363389,
0.0078843627,
0.0075787739,
-0.0220797062,
-0.0517021939,
-0.0198748223,
-0.0009411531,
-0.0163274016,
0.0285773389,
-0.0161705166,
-0.000103956,
0.0098212063,
-0.0371191278,
0.0240206867,
0.030195957,
-0.0466004163,
0.0342552736,
-0.0402858853,
0.029765306,
0.0035409036,
0.0237345081,
-0.0488876626,
-0.0080542797,
-0.018376248,
-0.0244651064,
0.0059184134,
0.0676838383,
-0.0345868282,
0.017161971,
-0.0693251938,
0.0290278103,
0.0004936562,
-0.0132842865,
0.0108600194,
0.0309657101,
-0.0309851822,
-0.0157614406,
-0.0422453806,
0.0116821704,
-0.0168103594,
0.06137022,
-0.0056074527,
-0.0650327429,
-0.02353126,
0.0135038961,
-0.0018197672,
-0.0531511381,
0.0067033493,
0.0866205841,
-0.0184055269,
-0.0545932055,
-0.058417365,
-0.0279257502,
-0.028280938,
-0.0527039506,
0.0251751319,
-0.043905966,
0.0160845537,
0.0064082472,
-0.009501976,
-0.0650550574,
-0.0038461031,
-0.0202893987,
-0.0705472156,
0.0866629481,
-0.00956144,
0.0149101801,
0.0169640053,
0.0195786655,
-0.0404749215,
0.0756589323,
0.0194398481,
0.0435994305,
0.0312272292,
-0.0064887484,
-0.0029012465,
0.0435591042,
-0.0012200095,
-0.0023870319,
-0.0421059579,
-0.0189083666,
-0.0104758171,
-0.0017830409,
0.0569654666,
0.0252123997,
-0.0309961922,
-0.0246967133,
0.080244638,
0.0667850375,
0.0139469998,
0.0177123044,
0.0217192527,
-0.0146145262,
0.0097999228,
0.0382763855,
-0.108419992,
-0.0005931223,
-0.0268773306,
-0.0132280029,
-0.0114711523,
0.0271162726,
-0.0338121057,
-0.0309809446,
-0.049412284,
-0.002639848,
0.0159778036,
-0.0034193113,
0.0536555238,
0.0294358842,
-0.0339637659,
0.0809987038,
0.0536332019,
-0.0433850549,
0.0080318963,
-0.0917969346,
0.0245680921,
0.048849389,
0.0284895394,
-0.0184436068,
-0.0166859031,
0.0323561169,
0.0300459731,
0.0421466194,
0.0060625505,
-0.0027949293,
0.0637522936,
-0.0319657922,
-0.0306125805,
-0.0152895628,
0.046236366,
0.0002565429,
0.0157037806,
-0.0349669419,
0.006133595,
-0.0767358616,
0.0153221739,
0.0369813368,
-0.045317281,
-0.0235779304,
-0.0201727636,
-0.001428228,
0.0150482124,
0.0141079193,
0.0181225315,
0.0079392074,
0.0383401588,
-0.0301003307,
0.0123262005,
0.031968262,
-0.055070851,
-0.0328808166,
0.0182484463,
-0.0018403286,
0.0091878548,
0.0142010329,
-0.0462435782,
-0.0217875317,
0.0523112081,
-0.0128632328,
0.0467415601,
-0.0430671535,
0.0406487435,
-0.0226741266,
0.0053726733,
-0.0203745309,
0.0636750087,
-0.0189970806,
0.00690844,
0.0023631898,
0.0074618608,
-0.0356076472,
-0.0303066671,
-0.0187477972,
0.0188301075,
0.0017619391,
-0.0267520994,
-0.016659217,
-0.030432241,
-0.0616153367,
-0.0324124061,
-0.1128871217,
-0.0316128768,
-0.018644616,
0.0123172747,
0.0322034284,
0.0047263694,
-0.0088987965,
-0.0315874442,
0.0265949648,
-0.0028774766,
-0.0044032428,
0.0495170616,
0.0223356374,
-0.0133864405,
-0.0175045636,
-0.0436986201,
-0.0102628144,
0.0001224201,
0.0491790995,
-0.0370869972,
-0.0504548214,
-0.0400404669,
0.0013516363,
-0.0343994312,
0.0302457344,
-0.016954679,
-0.01358175,
0.0077617411,
0.0035489916,
0.0491436049,
0.0507764444,
-0.0286791045,
0.0664967969,
0.0571915433,
-0.034171097,
-0.0481744334,
0.0077009569,
-0.0089192027,
-0.0148576032,
-0.0632234812,
-0.0275228266,
-0.0210845433,
0.0984222963,
0.0357736684,
0.0086624455,
-0.0384557657,
0.030479487,
-0.0180472694,
-0.0327001214,
-0.0034430448,
-0.0205599461,
-0.0425720327,
0.0305354819,
-0.0424381606,
-0.0570562445,
0.0669930801,
-0.0051711197,
0.0055825501,
0.0072131995,
-0.0125583075,
-0.0095831724,
0.0753210112,
0.0112712104,
-0.0072698956,
0.0185241047,
-0.0416368246,
-0.0876768082,
-0.0119185662,
0.0008244382,
-0.0251370296,
0.0683528781,
-0.0655273572,
-0.0097117089,
-0.0007474574,
-0.0482687689,
-0.0459245481,
-0.0305584595,
-0.0365500972,
0.0375858471,
-0.0035115462,
0.0054399613,
-0.0424424894,
-0.0303973295,
-0.0023550873,
0.0354808271,
0.0003900396,
0.0189215541,
-0.013819566,
0.0122716688,
0.021448534,
0.0494652726,
0.0111634508,
-0.0314213187,
0.0356755778,
0.0769634768,
0.0068920585,
-0.0147903217,
-0.0097353505,
0.0310466494,
0.0458635911,
-0.042785082,
-0.0371616632,
0.0196336415,
0.0903640687,
-0.0450780988,
-0.0141065102,
0.1165703088,
0.0013452952,
-0.028665157,
0.0402523242,
-0.0199514218,
0.0162347183,
0.0346141458,
-0.0144121582,
-0.0755679309,
-0.042581737,
0.0347760953,
0.0041492619,
0.0067736814,
-0.0243094694,
0.0141457478,
-0.101200901,
0.0527887642,
-0.0048414795,
-0.0374379307,
0.0015420277,
-0.0472269803,
0.0315038189,
-0.0114153922,
0.0651826859,
0.0298408382,
-0.0113589196,
-0.0141364178,
0.0185711235,
-0.0088370917,
-0.0466919206,
0.0093684662,
-0.0371724889,
0.0478427,
0.0398096703,
0.0087536145,
-0.010186838,
-0.0181864165,
0.0834709257,
-0.0085269548,
0.048730962,
-0.0382226594,
0.0614753775,
0.0026944368,
0.0204012021,
-0.0123266289,
0.013333845,
0.0076312292,
-0.0459854789,
-0.004236565,
0.0556906462,
-0.0208447333,
-0.041766692,
-0.0109956907,
-0.0240779743,
-0.0611608736,
0.0961316526,
0.0470023416,
-0.0342751779,
-0.0316752568,
-0.0239595808,
-0.0115405973,
-0.0121858083,
-0.0142597668,
-0.005388902,
-0.0173286647,
0.0137148052,
-0.0507769398,
-0.0228025578,
0.0281142425,
-0.0009585996,
0.0098808426,
0.0234956257,
-0.0363560468,
-0.0164205804,
-0.026751237,
0.0330464393,
-0.0178223234,
0.0012856279,
-0.0205160901,
0.0003237425,
0.0175190028,
-0.0464102477,
-0.0113228187,
-0.0204152465,
-0.0927881151,
-0.0824488625,
0.0213825572,
0.0286602881,
0.0261002462,
0.0587647595,
0.0051323404,
-0.08330971,
0.0717787072,
0.0078295479,
-0.0001114987,
0.064602904,
0.0224353354,
-0.0075531853,
0.0102699259,
0.07409513,
-0.0516528748,
0.0282160901,
0.0731126294,
0.0383690335,
-0.0028139746,
-0.0274063442,
-0.0117450086,
0.0023249651,
0.0814007372,
-0.0190638937,
-0.0168858282,
-0.0399928167,
0.0280963667,
-0.0116522983,
-0.0173706897,
-0.0170701053,
0.0295173116,
0.0220446624,
0.0443250202,
-0.0090198945,
0.0127738146,
-0.0174525175,
0.0679462776,
-0.0469414517,
0.0088210152,
0.0016953025,
-0.023992084,
0.0074026738,
0.0343413912,
-0.0231164936,
0.032027889,
-0.0235542487,
0.0067465785,
-0.0146567551,
0.0149428677,
0.0033946743,
-0.0061619412,
-0.0696714595,
0.0260066818,
-0.077442579,
-0.0163492449,
-0.0178510901,
0.0364842005,
0.0464140736,
-0.0089526121,
0.0365451947,
-0.0077465624,
-0.0144139901,
-0.0083676577,
0.0211785045,
0.0017123845,
0.0074050408,
0.0535755791,
0.0158328842,
-0.0397006981,
-0.0036171265,
0.0655892938,
0.010611196,
0.0660444796,
-0.0140638174,
0.0159501527,
-0.0266793743,
-0.0568317883,
0.0244761277,
0.0479162708,
-0.0238968302,
0.0105784014,
-0.0286573935,
-0.0863645971,
0.0236481484,
-0.0152871786,
0.0047069299,
-0.023719769,
0.0188725386,
0.0739199519,
0.0274397898,
-0.029263543,
-0.0072750589,
-0.0075838435,
0.0527071431,
-0.0192685276,
-0.0110705541,
-7.040837207e-33,
-0.0068641431,
-0.0061537656,
-0.0009224428,
-0.0242224932,
-0.0148699563,
0.0031815621,
-0.0328015238,
0.0171294063,
-0.0328880399,
0.0129202874,
-0.0160479713,
0.0183367655,
0.0234805942,
0.0112969112,
0.0113888932,
-0.0311513469,
0.0505460836,
-0.001586742,
-0.0180707499,
-0.0221269727,
0.0111031877,
0.0403448492,
0.1007878333,
-0.014215786,
0.0437171087,
0.0131164342,
-0.0114981448,
0.0565385893,
-0.0132336235,
0.0545338541,
-0.0078697791,
0.0537608676,
0.0488205291,
-0.0294889249,
-0.0283049904,
-0.001783032,
-0.0790974498,
-0.0352038965,
0.0833938718,
-0.0082154237,
-0.0345466472,
-0.0439026989,
0.0813779086,
0.016005449,
-0.0569750294,
-0.0080199018,
0.0245601591,
-0.0242315643,
-0.0116648702,
-0.0068707927,
-0.0545997806,
0.0144475829,
0.0250334535,
0.0134400232,
0.0276033226,
0.0071307127,
-0.0002398493,
0.0215572864,
-0.0717793107,
-0.0077864248,
-0.0033196763,
0.0480242632,
0.0626726896,
0.0608648024,
-0.0234800912,
0.0779910237,
0.0462194048,
0.0177340042,
-0.036950063,
-0.0183903482,
0.0501722246,
0.0709685534,
0.0294301752,
0.0139893498,
0.0289400481,
0.0003563993,
-0.0593660697,
-0.007022738,
0.0092390953,
0.0615557767,
0.0373722613,
0.0448075421,
-0.0109125255,
-0.0521285534,
-0.0605851039,
-0.0187604968,
-0.0543983318,
-0.0228025317,
0.016867375,
0.0172431394,
0.0170610063,
-0.0057138284,
0.0012190224,
-0.0323721915,
-0.0091961678,
0.0034393719,
0.0037517163,
-0.0087741232,
0.0193497334,
0.0084465649,
-0.0285013914,
-0.0280179158,
-0.009475112,
0.0137132807,
0.0018667311,
0.0119205676,
0.0291918553,
0.0157868844,
-0.0454797596,
-0.0025397416,
-0.0424991101,
-0.0288015138,
0.0038624997,
0.0322975777,
0.051889006,
0.0206483528,
-0.0114510097,
0.0166387241,
0.0451673493,
0.0137809925,
-0.0468950868,
0.0258547738,
0.0067210374,
0.0369619653,
-0.0221878253,
-0.0141012603,
-0.0017127846,
0.0156454537,
0.0263222009,
-0.0471220687,
-0.0261319,
0.0243778601,
2.867e-7,
0.0355180949,
0.0352890752,
0.003217218,
-0.0156012252,
0.0265087169,
0.0197725855,
-0.0187295265,
0.0212866887,
0.0367719829,
-0.0165761765,
-0.0048733694,
0.0297133308,
0.0615149774,
0.0193694308,
-0.1030537337,
-0.0055569042,
-0.0621241555,
0.0193248298,
-0.0215189215,
0.0077101137,
0.0172648933,
0.0946597606,
0.0314073749,
-0.0377279148,
-0.041122485,
-0.0452351682,
0.0275745932,
-0.0576159135,
-0.0011689028,
-0.0198383294,
0.0226095356,
0.0124932779,
0.0355560817,
0.0278128441,
-0.0166523568,
0.032011319,
-0.0170212947,
0.0628597885,
-0.0251684412,
-0.0384962931,
-0.0219530035,
-0.0069433409,
0.0092816753,
-0.0405398645,
0.0761742443,
-0.0457682163,
-0.0469957516,
-0.0203636326,
-0.0042912411,
0.0010475094,
-0.0141649824,
-0.0183101725,
-0.0108592212,
0.0244111475,
0.0231332108,
0.0032996207,
-0.036443267,
-0.0832216069,
-0.0613862239,
0.0163753033,
-0.0714752227,
-0.0939689204,
-0.008822415,
-0.0095299324,
0.0302157775,
-0.0860088915,
0.007259625,
2.495345607e-34,
0.0163408462,
0.0157122519,
0.0369469412,
0.0755461305,
0.0018420555,
-0.0213406775,
0.0261018779,
0.0131576164,
0.0166071989,
-0.0788893402,
-0.0115115559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19371v1 | Suri: Multi-constraint Instruction Following for Long-form Text Generation | 2024-06-27T17:50:35 | 2024-06-27T17:50:35 | Chau Minh Pham, Simeng Sun, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing research on instruction following largely focuses on tasks with
simple instructions and short responses. In this work, we explore
multi-constraint instruction following for generating long-form text. We create
Suri, a dataset with 20K human-written long-form texts paired with
LLM-generated backtranslated instructions that contain multiple complex
constraints. Because of prohibitive challenges associated with collecting human
preference judgments on long-form texts, preference-tuning algorithms such as
DPO are infeasible in our setting; thus, we propose Instructional ORPO
(I-ORPO), an alignment method based on the ORPO algorithm. Instead of receiving
negative feedback from dispreferred responses, I-ORPO obtains negative feedback
from synthetically corrupted instructions generated by an LLM. Using Suri, we
perform supervised and I-ORPO fine-tuning on Mistral-7b-Instruct-v0.2. The
resulting models, Suri-SFT and Suri-I-ORPO, generate significantly longer texts
(~5K tokens) than base models without significant quality deterioration. Our
human evaluation shows that while both SFT and I-ORPO models satisfy most
constraints, Suri-I-ORPO generations are generally preferred for their coherent
and informative incorporation of the constraints. We release our code at
https://github.com/chtmp223/suri. | [
0.0175694358,
0.0497050881,
0.0126337474,
-0.0129714133,
-0.0192290861,
-0.0121738594,
0.0012866905,
0.0025391998,
0.0189388469,
-0.0360885188,
-0.0309471078,
-0.0417633727,
0.0282109845,
-0.0015760238,
0.0286826622,
-0.0637767985,
0.0348521583,
-0.0248100124,
-0.0432819352,
0.025441071,
0.0326963328,
0.0101767089,
-0.033899609,
0.0156452227,
0.0141135007,
-0.0412363112,
-0.0381147265,
0.032550253,
0.0266933739,
-0.0310550947,
0.0254354794,
0.0545913726,
0.0073151425,
-0.0027632159,
0.0000019638,
-0.0401741043,
-0.0360832028,
-0.0099216048,
0.0006647225,
0.0135008404,
0.0311438609,
-0.0028414167,
-0.0499837995,
0.028248284,
-0.0042306567,
0.0567955375,
0.0431119092,
0.0364990979,
0.0856813118,
0.0955769196,
0.0007457785,
0.0099133225,
0.0113402167,
-0.0261396002,
0.0265256353,
0.0378044918,
-0.0061749979,
-0.0506285429,
0.040109776,
0.0273399521,
0.0112690572,
0.0071185222,
0.0260936692,
-0.0099738073,
-0.0108220065,
0.0076180119,
0.0084045613,
-0.0092526283,
-0.0336038172,
0.0817777961,
0.0376200601,
0.0100193787,
0.0060775657,
-0.0090676909,
0.0113761332,
-0.0092244996,
-0.0289019924,
0.0163414124,
-0.0146164391,
0.0100713382,
0.0138973603,
0.0044637076,
-0.0226950459,
-0.0293578133,
0.0231254306,
0.0264814254,
0.0210774466,
-0.0684117526,
-0.0020151769,
0.0048062569,
-0.0349068455,
-0.0452731624,
0.0434062257,
0.0293989386,
-0.0470780991,
0.0238355901,
-0.0896102265,
-0.0251034014,
0.0482551232,
-0.0301560704,
0.0709375963,
0.059645135,
-0.0092830323,
-0.0064716991,
-0.0386579782,
0.1035877541,
-0.0482490174,
0.0363216028,
-0.0456004851,
0.0680565983,
-0.0476959385,
-0.0174767058,
-0.0128286295,
0.0366167799,
-0.0646625832,
-0.0212426465,
-0.0674559399,
0.0300674345,
-0.0073883617,
0.0271625742,
0.055613365,
0.0018795668,
-0.0168171357,
0.0253787134,
-0.0356974415,
0.0195826739,
-0.0344725586,
-0.0106308246,
0.0048981193,
0.0147765493,
-0.0073681483,
0.0505244471,
-0.0039198878,
-0.03080393,
-0.0123641379,
0.0694845617,
-0.0464645885,
0.0111967651,
-0.0320891328,
-0.0503351688,
-0.0312714316,
-0.042198021,
-0.0006960703,
-0.0493606068,
0.0070902943,
-0.0130649516,
-0.0148888296,
-0.0297455098,
0.0220734458,
0.053965006,
0.0057179499,
0.016765397,
0.0080783656,
-0.0087890644,
-0.0131530669,
-0.0028672416,
0.0165863298,
0.0261479225,
0.0448250286,
0.0459559597,
-0.0016899812,
-0.0017137531,
0.0096667148,
0.0544981919,
0.015806973,
0.0125188986,
-0.0060173138,
-0.0036252197,
0.0029642214,
0.0592308417,
0.048042614,
0.0678240061,
-0.0013973105,
0.0105849393,
0.0510976575,
0.0084917927,
0.0290862639,
-0.0271231756,
0.0481838174,
0.0200328063,
-0.0341023393,
0.0709560066,
-0.034643732,
0.0445751995,
0.0110910079,
0.0366040245,
0.0290171206,
0.0143982414,
-0.0078116385,
-0.0490249358,
-0.0055723572,
-0.0051485891,
-0.0130353328,
-0.0238387939,
0.016992094,
0.0109519176,
-0.0999574661,
0.0278215464,
0.0149415601,
-0.0751166269,
-0.003157346,
-0.0123652276,
0.022930596,
0.1083493829,
0.0541601777,
-0.0013191539,
-0.0230997577,
-0.0129586076,
-0.0014635493,
0.0625676885,
0.0218042769,
0.0069403178,
-0.0072301608,
-0.0552532673,
-0.0356199965,
0.0113473115,
-0.0048506134,
0.0214606617,
0.0159572288,
-0.0035762608,
0.0178827178,
0.0296758451,
-0.0436670557,
0.0535276197,
-0.0262687374,
-0.0663158745,
-0.0273643695,
0.0323329046,
0.0141236745,
0.0350328609,
0.0190865379,
0.0200202931,
0.0394404083,
-0.0217494573,
0.0173835475,
-0.0131349573,
-0.0874055773,
-0.057642851,
0.0193354692,
-0.0349084809,
-0.016801266,
0.0018668687,
-0.0061476394,
-0.0571450144,
-0.012598305,
-0.0412042849,
0.0136695597,
-0.0060889274,
0.0233874097,
0.041950088,
-0.0461835712,
-0.0488902517,
0.0377000049,
-0.0171396546,
0.0078335647,
0.0537023619,
-0.0221783649,
0.0073330388,
-0.0540821292,
0.001536651,
-0.0094273249,
-0.0128652789,
-0.0000724233,
0.0270396248,
0.0529198349,
-0.0575238876,
-0.0611281581,
-0.0637048185,
0.0450907201,
-0.0123510789,
0.0312289931,
0.0319481865,
-0.0026237371,
-0.0066222623,
-0.0028084726,
-0.0634332672,
-0.0528889969,
-0.0168980546,
-0.0097318711,
0.0332195982,
0.0099356612,
-0.0163683612,
-0.0358956568,
-0.0090256892,
-0.024373319,
-0.0304894727,
0.0079580834,
0.0090395277,
-0.0996636003,
0.0624666438,
-0.0181082319,
0.0095278136,
0.0100669758,
-0.0460567623,
0.0414923131,
0.0217688289,
0.0972766653,
0.0714198649,
0.0049603214,
0.0194503311,
0.0409371443,
-0.0053864438,
-0.0654211044,
0.0195141267,
-0.0368263498,
-0.0213984214,
0.0036803654,
-0.0570227467,
0.0048290649,
0.0620686971,
0.020689236,
0.0301678088,
-0.0865158141,
-0.0293933414,
0.0028476114,
0.0034154279,
0.0132843237,
-0.0213316549,
-0.0520655885,
-0.0023877912,
-0.0291276127,
-0.0540673621,
0.0784740597,
-0.0471163988,
0.00440457,
-0.0386367142,
0.0203335527,
-0.0259355381,
0.0064852699,
-0.001518214,
0.016148949,
0.0234254766,
-0.0200268216,
-0.0688546523,
0.0393142179,
0.0257435478,
-0.0280450638,
0.0037081926,
-0.0504476987,
-0.0211866386,
-0.0218476467,
-0.0417377576,
-0.0401970632,
-0.0342108682,
0.0613718517,
-0.0136283115,
0.0586619265,
-0.0459509902,
-0.0243299585,
0.00565656,
0.0255455971,
0.0461142994,
-0.0327382535,
0.0063625211,
-0.0677999631,
0.0003300554,
0.0530106723,
-0.0170067046,
-0.0241724122,
-0.0603773631,
0.0029600351,
0.0241121128,
0.0425757617,
-0.0251767486,
0.0129506616,
0.0120442789,
0.0281877164,
-0.0291422401,
-0.0076414151,
0.029704066,
0.0978268683,
-0.0405676477,
-0.0142543772,
0.1080248207,
0.0223017018,
-0.0320854038,
-0.0119213248,
-0.0019448816,
0.0882841423,
-0.0003602446,
0.0116821919,
-0.0721513405,
-0.0272468142,
-0.002630661,
0.0817045048,
-0.0171288084,
-0.0039753919,
-0.0292995442,
-0.1025761291,
0.0055419211,
0.0343158394,
-0.0267576221,
-0.0114689833,
-0.0151618803,
-0.0143400989,
0.0036266178,
0.0175146144,
0.0283096321,
-0.0211668815,
0.0039497702,
0.0317305736,
0.002664319,
-0.012512695,
-0.0055155945,
-0.0270613041,
0.0432503857,
0.0698462278,
-0.0036121735,
0.0424381942,
-0.0628316626,
0.02980786,
-0.0076540783,
0.0224341191,
-0.005216721,
0.0221360046,
-0.0105646625,
0.0048200004,
-0.0461473055,
0.0726124719,
-0.0558426641,
0.0159396268,
0.0169523563,
0.0574755035,
-0.0035737699,
0.0159674436,
-0.0188351739,
-0.0063624387,
0.0172137562,
0.0512220599,
0.0188239757,
-0.0676595643,
-0.0365634561,
-0.039466016,
-0.0176499635,
-0.1096154079,
0.02051498,
0.0071499571,
-0.058782883,
0.0052366536,
-0.0924851298,
-0.054741662,
0.0228895489,
0.048209656,
0.0206471607,
-0.0180361364,
0.0314245857,
-0.0485834107,
-0.0164759681,
0.0088554425,
0.0020733487,
0.0164986979,
-0.1169357076,
-0.04364039,
-0.0056731608,
-0.0145032806,
0.0170766599,
0.004873659,
-0.0580884069,
-0.0717159659,
-0.0219288245,
0.0837234184,
0.0197656937,
0.0520944558,
0.022246711,
0.0024773637,
-0.0112954965,
0.0445055366,
0.0048061446,
0.0026502323,
0.010170388,
0.0096990038,
-0.0064649233,
-0.0079495404,
-0.0055804537,
-0.0236354154,
0.0048298128,
0.0411470085,
-0.0284476988,
-0.0203226525,
0.0465033762,
0.0065700011,
0.0103597753,
-0.0601330921,
0.0065215291,
-0.037620198,
0.0285426751,
-0.0321665481,
0.0034578405,
-0.0498536117,
0.0345498845,
0.0270346012,
-0.0333352759,
0.0324437879,
-0.0325275958,
-0.0426727273,
0.0144276889,
-0.0496386848,
0.0366460755,
-0.0198797062,
0.0373671949,
0.0430845842,
0.0098204622,
-0.0174228642,
0.0525896512,
-0.0151528334,
0.0630690753,
0.0098317564,
0.0753136054,
0.0269600153,
0.0294146538,
0.0203578975,
0.0440128259,
0.0010959578,
0.0192414653,
-0.0608558543,
-0.0226830654,
0.0274467897,
0.0138512282,
0.0768235326,
-0.0059742625,
0.0132910088,
-0.0125511074,
0.0710124373,
-0.0297013484,
-0.0089232,
-0.0059635169,
0.0294824541,
0.0107012773,
-0.0287887063,
0.0804199874,
0.0099118855,
-0.0049464311,
-0.0280808192,
0.0166091919,
-0.0705155879,
-0.0275887866,
0.0250679012,
0.0162052568,
-0.0213371702,
-0.014956953,
-0.016105717,
-0.0168724749,
-0.0069490094,
0.0271600801,
0.0137206633,
-0.0123076839,
0.0572853275,
0.0036772522,
-0.0621643737,
-0.0165680852,
-0.022777345,
-0.0274919979,
-0.0364549309,
-0.0420116298,
-0.0258293916,
-5.937319845e-33,
-0.0666259304,
-0.051068753,
0.0312025938,
-0.0112991026,
-0.0358319394,
-0.0331759341,
-0.0189370401,
0.010772611,
0.0462491475,
-0.0259462129,
0.0156791601,
-0.0515335836,
0.019593155,
0.0281977598,
0.0160491243,
-0.0027896948,
0.0330050327,
-0.0001633859,
-0.0562907644,
0.0193795655,
0.0753830597,
0.0029655017,
0.0274041854,
-0.0494151935,
0.0603023954,
-0.0313335508,
-0.0309233498,
0.0008202649,
-0.0233651958,
0.0922818184,
0.0072270031,
0.0008705613,
-0.0004659863,
-0.0134284897,
-0.0317423455,
0.0491907671,
-0.0409881547,
-0.0102755595,
0.0062911822,
0.0116282888,
-0.0545055047,
-0.0696619749,
0.0239391383,
-0.0259761065,
-0.0379453301,
0.008931634,
0.0378260463,
-0.0157824494,
0.005247633,
-0.0029784671,
-0.0686844215,
0.0017172428,
-0.0158708356,
-0.062177334,
-0.0068855705,
0.083889924,
-0.0015891353,
-0.0079143895,
-0.0376953743,
0.0383100733,
0.0309513472,
0.0522743575,
0.0610970519,
0.023398282,
-0.0044338126,
0.0171995144,
-0.0067174798,
-0.0189900156,
-0.0032241195,
0.0036868539,
-0.0064886012,
0.0302104112,
0.0425868407,
0.0128552122,
0.0384570099,
0.0026415293,
-0.027666105,
0.0433241948,
-0.0153712723,
-0.0128031829,
0.0211111903,
0.012583592,
-0.0378568545,
-0.0061892122,
-0.0168154631,
-0.0140110292,
-0.0033302042,
-0.0320073403,
0.0374543108,
0.0348498225,
-0.0068976739,
-0.0240045749,
0.0322877914,
0.0312759131,
0.0008137662,
-0.0175453331,
-0.0460997075,
0.0306882896,
-0.0369859003,
-0.0007344602,
-0.0694128349,
-0.0528557152,
0.0526282378,
-0.0129729668,
0.0170747582,
0.0382321365,
0.0376448296,
0.010709676,
-0.0622937158,
0.0234791338,
-0.0327132009,
0.0405007675,
-0.0074936883,
-0.0154166166,
0.0348939523,
-0.0259448532,
-0.0138886767,
0.0943627208,
-0.0040906714,
-0.0121373367,
-0.046327889,
-0.040531233,
0.0025691818,
0.0170989111,
-0.0199179389,
0.0266904198,
-0.0025303501,
0.0102106705,
-0.0236547347,
-0.028215332,
-0.0027303081,
0.0197603833,
2.63e-7,
-0.000402212,
0.0486016013,
0.062510334,
0.0140699288,
-0.0078952238,
0.0234381985,
-0.005102782,
0.0269142929,
-0.0199301727,
-0.0293121655,
0.0246893279,
0.0012603139,
0.0513196029,
-0.0125901271,
-0.0741629228,
-0.0076182433,
-0.0418551043,
0.0048387242,
-0.051899109,
0.0206189975,
0.1165092066,
0.0248678476,
-0.0190631803,
0.0250262786,
0.0051940987,
0.034285821,
0.0556527004,
0.0053373836,
-0.0021104955,
-0.0077821556,
-0.0015020847,
-0.0573700964,
-0.0552323125,
-0.0016594196,
-0.0055396012,
-0.0195797682,
0.0023573036,
0.0777047947,
0.0174307525,
-0.0599875264,
0.0403202362,
-0.0047913268,
-0.0163245685,
-0.011028518,
0.0199132785,
-0.0067857448,
0.0104830069,
0.0262693185,
-0.0100535834,
-0.0156220896,
0.022906838,
-0.0268458799,
-0.0028985541,
0.0069620204,
0.0171218831,
0.0013789678,
-0.0135038178,
-0.025154151,
-0.0201402642,
0.0105523672,
-0.0468489602,
-0.0369468816,
-0.063695237,
0.0466405526,
-0.0011948043,
-0.0720313787,
-0.0401242599,
2.649784442e-34,
0.0044385986,
-0.0316903405,
0.0300245602,
0.0186120551,
0.0202024616,
-0.0133098308,
-0.0215814859,
0.0356255136,
0.0485731475,
-0.0642539337,
-0.0429861359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00121v1 | Granite-Function Calling Model: Introducing Function Calling Abilities via Multi-task Learning of Granular Tasks | 2024-06-27T17:47:26 | 2024-06-27T17:47:26 | Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Kinjal Basu, Mayank Agarwal, Sadhana Kumaravel, Matthew Stallone, Rameswar Panda, Yara Rizk, GP Bhargav, Maxwell Crouse, Chulaka Gunasekara, Shajith Ikbal, Sachin Joshi, Hima Karanam, Vineet Kumar, Asim Munawar, Sumit Neelam, Dinesh Raghu, Udit Sharma, Adriana Meza Soria, Dheeraj Sreedhar, Praveen Venkateswaran, Merve Unuvar, David Cox, Salim Roukos, Luis Lastras, Pavan Kapanipathi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown tremendous promise in
serving as the backbone to agentic systems, as demonstrated by their
performance in multi-faceted, challenging benchmarks like SWE-Bench and
Agent-Bench. However, to realize the true potential of LLMs as autonomous
agents, they must learn to identify, call, and interact with external tools and
application program interfaces (APIs) to complete complex tasks. These tasks
together are termed function calling. Endowing LLMs with function calling
abilities leads to a myriad of advantages, such as access to current and
domain-specific information in databases and knowledge sources, and the ability
to outsource tasks that can be reliably performed by tools, e.g., a Python
interpreter or calculator. While there has been significant progress in
function calling with LLMs, there is still a dearth of open models that perform
on par with proprietary LLMs like GPT, Claude, and Gemini. Therefore, in this
work, we introduce the GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING model under an Apache 2.0
license. The model is trained using a multi-task training approach on seven
fundamental tasks encompassed in function calling, those being Nested Function
Calling, Function Chaining, Parallel Functions, Function Name Detection,
Parameter-Value Pair Detection, Next-Best Function, and Response Generation. We
present a comprehensive evaluation on multiple out-of-domain datasets comparing
GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING to more than 15 other best proprietary and open
models. GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING provides the best performance among all
open models on the Berkeley Function Calling Leaderboard and fourth overall. As
a result of the diverse tasks and datasets used for training our model, we show
that GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING has better generalizability on multiple tasks
in seven different evaluation datasets. | [
0.0157122649,
0.0580789074,
-0.0128819868,
0.0093687503,
-0.0098030381,
0.0216911845,
-0.0078201704,
-0.0213192366,
0.0206426494,
-0.0258162692,
-0.0691529512,
-0.0056107901,
-0.0291672908,
0.0287501812,
0.0198997911,
-0.044353094,
0.0506387651,
-0.0485826395,
-0.0146174859,
0.0099408906,
-0.0433922075,
0.0176111646,
0.0008812055,
0.0456165038,
0.0034678779,
-0.032738328,
-0.0106021408,
0.0110504618,
0.0112327477,
0.0203738455,
0.0062493756,
0.0224222019,
0.0346390344,
0.080491893,
0.0000021437,
-0.059947107,
-0.0139049022,
-0.0000705561,
-0.0480215214,
-0.0131744668,
0.0392769985,
-0.0150533905,
-0.0067641814,
0.0264146496,
-0.0424159728,
-0.0246329419,
0.0622430257,
-0.042789571,
0.0359769613,
0.0577218309,
0.0288071409,
-0.0138714062,
0.0295297205,
-0.0163197778,
-0.02155797,
-0.0450074412,
-0.0045389808,
0.0134322708,
0.0015577773,
-0.0188212711,
0.0148154227,
0.0113303773,
0.0286604129,
0.0186062623,
0.0072969147,
0.0461821631,
-0.0177912954,
-0.0152663756,
-0.0188830383,
0.0686287358,
-0.0707997605,
-0.0421513915,
0.0266132504,
-0.0014080324,
0.0009817699,
0.0186185203,
-0.0098423185,
0.0094999988,
0.0050196801,
-0.0015610728,
0.0342361964,
0.0046837227,
0.0294146538,
0.0000106663,
-0.0087226592,
0.0353340507,
-0.0246956423,
-0.0216270499,
0.0349147096,
-0.0351809785,
-0.0325217694,
-0.0297579449,
-0.0003938794,
0.0658844933,
-0.0336870886,
0.0260644704,
-0.0258107875,
-0.0249842629,
0.0301269814,
-0.0305086225,
0.0195114762,
0.0378707498,
-0.0253011882,
0.0251385793,
-0.0456754752,
0.0445411354,
0.0142400982,
-0.0026687928,
-0.0057660611,
0.025550032,
-0.0644955859,
-0.0010504383,
-0.0170670804,
0.0461416356,
-0.0330597013,
-0.0109568536,
0.0155036803,
0.0205759536,
-0.010484552,
0.0512222908,
0.0087375985,
-0.0234575756,
-0.0522074625,
-0.0159361977,
-0.052007325,
0.028456049,
-0.0207169075,
-0.0230511855,
0.0034376932,
-0.0456950255,
-0.0093352413,
-0.0349674895,
-0.0056203413,
0.0003904694,
0.0287767109,
0.0945271701,
-0.0037514758,
0.0188680552,
-0.0339551792,
-0.0388672911,
0.0652507842,
-0.0866927654,
-0.0025715954,
-0.084871769,
0.0044323099,
0.0042903754,
0.00002848,
-0.0132488776,
0.0227197018,
-0.013040253,
0.011804075,
0.075685285,
-0.0178806242,
-0.0044985642,
0.0283348896,
0.0001200609,
-0.0232826211,
0.0793993473,
-0.0065845228,
0.0023280419,
0.0092009092,
0.0008205802,
0.0042918692,
0.0140351849,
-0.013190655,
-0.0035816829,
0.040540766,
0.0407458283,
0.0409387983,
0.0338873677,
0.0361768045,
0.028550202,
-0.0067954813,
-0.0387605131,
0.0408794433,
0.0068339296,
-0.0188217815,
0.0159921609,
0.1144020632,
0.0480818301,
0.0165820643,
-0.0065136347,
-0.0958424062,
0.0095826704,
-0.011555085,
0.0555475168,
-0.0469848998,
0.0346971191,
-0.0312020518,
-0.0709002763,
0.0156260561,
-0.0069090328,
-0.0351101384,
-0.0017520132,
0.0556135438,
0.0290455967,
-0.0668674707,
-0.0037563373,
0.0179007221,
-0.025837956,
-0.0244537666,
-0.0786447227,
-0.011762795,
0.0582684055,
0.0277567394,
-0.0840773284,
-0.0503319167,
-0.018776644,
-0.0080538718,
0.029205244,
0.0097953584,
-0.0311404523,
0.0009204669,
-0.0587909482,
0.008026965,
-0.0143381692,
0.0147502599,
0.0488385782,
-0.0085016992,
-0.0141533455,
0.0076700123,
-0.0023175848,
-0.0391382314,
0.0266631953,
-0.0042789304,
-0.0716199577,
0.0127874957,
0.020813182,
0.0290198214,
-0.0381441973,
-0.0243419483,
0.0093929954,
0.0257799011,
0.0112026306,
-0.0020237609,
-0.0137722809,
-0.0511265211,
-0.0092832865,
0.0186610594,
0.0395811312,
0.0000207076,
0.0383092538,
-0.0332376659,
-0.0482919961,
0.0268275831,
-0.0238314979,
0.0333193019,
0.0169826336,
0.0448060967,
0.0116761858,
-0.0430570319,
-0.0091292933,
0.0814622566,
-0.0141938375,
0.0022579513,
0.006294047,
0.0537632406,
0.0075583444,
-0.0100694252,
0.0014100808,
0.0043381639,
-0.0254342351,
0.0585869774,
-0.0210974682,
0.0077325287,
-0.0118803009,
0.0072314916,
-0.07067018,
0.0278004836,
-0.0302892402,
0.0207257736,
0.0249728356,
0.0110808779,
0.017003404,
-0.0579521656,
-0.0010359468,
0.045068495,
-0.0419339128,
0.0141692432,
0.0118784411,
0.0097116837,
-0.054147765,
-0.0414068513,
-0.0206923522,
-0.0353762954,
0.0433760881,
-0.0384243429,
0.0018198589,
-0.0429976955,
0.0592374653,
-0.0028292865,
0.0496505313,
-0.0375813656,
-0.0146330707,
0.0061356733,
-0.0168559104,
0.02861307,
0.0866950005,
-0.0479792878,
-0.01619469,
0.024165187,
0.033513695,
-0.0530376136,
0.0384293646,
-0.0111965779,
-0.0312400088,
-0.0407520831,
0.0124539863,
0.0183878392,
0.0877382979,
-0.0141772414,
-0.0003959505,
-0.0346227065,
-0.0156026948,
0.0393942408,
-0.0470482334,
-0.0045828321,
0.008611124,
-0.0186680444,
0.0188225117,
-0.020397624,
-0.0794782117,
0.0576732531,
-0.0024809157,
-0.0156020969,
-0.0499506295,
-0.0433196016,
-0.0288624801,
0.0918853357,
0.0524545945,
-0.001080771,
0.0272150058,
-0.0563192405,
-0.05994137,
0.0129681583,
0.0120205469,
-0.0308637731,
0.059636537,
-0.058584094,
-0.0185844246,
-0.0120913256,
-0.0831878856,
-0.0304769818,
0.03033402,
-0.038381353,
0.0515061282,
-0.0274183229,
-0.0047912053,
-0.0156055242,
-0.0042877807,
-0.0000405793,
0.0964108184,
-0.0153077599,
-0.0137834223,
-0.0426032469,
-0.0290122572,
0.0236661788,
0.0136703588,
0.0067522554,
0.0123581793,
0.0411642045,
-0.0072510326,
0.0662156865,
-0.0279245675,
-0.0251258891,
-0.0001239927,
0.0052410816,
-0.0780677274,
-0.0517502651,
0.0297265165,
0.0126255266,
-0.0911065862,
-0.0051193563,
0.0645030439,
0.0069746035,
-0.0387246609,
-0.002324621,
-0.0543113649,
0.0224425383,
0.0690404549,
0.0568185784,
-0.0695203394,
-0.0339949653,
0.0082611488,
0.011612677,
-0.0158970617,
-0.0123158563,
0.0390017927,
-0.1597292423,
0.0446163006,
-0.0042649214,
-0.0099457707,
0.0028874124,
-0.0505540557,
0.0090612341,
-0.0410107821,
-0.0317614749,
0.0272724591,
-0.0201384332,
-0.0011664636,
0.02406995,
-0.0367485657,
-0.023204999,
0.0149292396,
-0.0433437191,
0.0030489662,
0.0491337366,
-0.0045976513,
0.0091028493,
0.0122463778,
-0.00398792,
-0.0108689209,
-0.0004429252,
-0.0070847264,
0.04386767,
-0.0169752631,
-0.0091416528,
0.0414667875,
0.0472414605,
-0.0445759892,
0.0095802294,
0.0230826773,
0.0997192487,
-0.0142328478,
0.0325433724,
0.0036742438,
0.0040027802,
0.0361759402,
0.020893909,
0.0047585084,
-0.0114181656,
-0.0747442096,
-0.0521756224,
-0.0185903795,
-0.0478733592,
-0.0322856493,
0.0136625059,
-0.0060676257,
-0.0417920612,
-0.0426324941,
-0.022041196,
0.0800404251,
0.0327243395,
0.0219622087,
-0.0024950597,
0.0307348724,
0.0443940051,
-0.075233832,
-0.0271968357,
-0.0124816587,
0.0338036083,
-0.0336650237,
-0.0313735642,
0.0562966503,
-0.0299462881,
-0.0402617194,
0.0342826694,
-0.0594527125,
-0.0261334907,
-0.011525833,
0.0870350152,
0.0267064869,
0.0423851646,
-0.0525368378,
-0.0181485713,
0.0197359212,
0.0570111834,
-0.0918366835,
-0.048591923,
0.0515866168,
-0.0279243328,
0.0117359515,
0.0328793153,
-0.0689210296,
-0.0120571982,
0.0101926746,
0.0195176955,
-0.0498019159,
0.0212441683,
0.0187201928,
-0.0012388984,
-0.003610732,
0.0285615865,
-0.008831203,
-0.0080983238,
-0.0049309903,
0.0302801766,
-0.0193344355,
-0.0273415651,
0.0432665087,
0.014086755,
0.022864338,
0.0511640497,
-0.0296849478,
0.0350735858,
0.0243974645,
0.0153798237,
-0.0037174807,
-0.0035327673,
0.0474350862,
0.0306852218,
0.0059162877,
-0.0374585241,
-0.0015240653,
0.0394766144,
0.0305018779,
-0.0106452554,
0.0523467362,
-0.0003134875,
0.0167166684,
-0.0319383591,
-0.0013037126,
-0.0749527067,
-0.0737690181,
-0.0301178414,
-0.0179387331,
0.0574444048,
0.0109841432,
0.0347846635,
-0.0177183617,
-0.003125156,
-0.0181399696,
0.0458167233,
0.0095955785,
0.0001954852,
0.0175214745,
0.0374032781,
-0.0159608591,
-0.0293620471,
0.0787319988,
0.0171497911,
0.042895969,
0.0126370974,
-0.0070336955,
-0.0480855331,
-0.042209968,
-0.0109515432,
0.0165070221,
-0.018991584,
-0.0336611904,
-0.0412372723,
-0.0568339005,
-0.0226898547,
0.037846636,
0.0088117057,
-0.0670477226,
0.0494880825,
0.0619795881,
0.0268985461,
-0.0354770608,
-0.0625324994,
0.0082917875,
-0.0170995519,
-0.0059751933,
-0.0358554348,
-5.16326159e-33,
-0.0300706364,
0.0128078861,
0.026694078,
0.0491579361,
-0.0130585469,
0.0141113829,
-0.0107826777,
0.0051249261,
-0.0109021384,
-0.0036446687,
-0.0010495321,
0.0056652441,
0.0264378916,
-0.0258901902,
0.0475165285,
-0.0024104852,
0.0406220555,
-0.0467408448,
-0.0167798754,
0.0363451801,
0.0299724899,
0.0299190339,
0.0550330169,
-0.0355397277,
-0.0499044731,
0.0166226588,
0.0183495972,
0.0276065487,
-0.0234332997,
0.0599672757,
-0.0061591007,
0.017249994,
-0.0029974484,
-0.0530851558,
-0.0253089759,
-0.0078050173,
-0.0998665839,
-0.0153659787,
0.0201315638,
0.0197719913,
-0.0332664363,
-0.0445770733,
0.0580782779,
0.000420336,
-0.0051736278,
-0.0216179173,
0.0242868029,
-0.0405432023,
-0.03533829,
-0.0227059368,
-0.0905557871,
0.024238063,
0.0146142561,
-0.02917693,
0.0036314642,
0.0479194112,
-0.0157097932,
-0.0249844398,
-0.0194086246,
-0.003309974,
-0.0291468073,
0.0358647071,
0.0353624634,
0.0671436936,
0.0351761021,
0.0124903321,
0.0273854882,
0.0115579916,
-0.0211444516,
0.0245522633,
0.0113677206,
0.1134017259,
0.0161890164,
0.0135695133,
0.0237845574,
-0.0057726805,
-0.0307920948,
0.0095012458,
0.0749704465,
0.0174568072,
0.0069939732,
-0.0013034942,
-0.0402730517,
0.0121294353,
-0.0308636259,
0.0008948988,
-0.0155650722,
-0.0336647555,
0.0172741879,
0.0120682195,
0.0289505906,
0.0634078979,
0.0270128585,
-0.0134218307,
0.0208685212,
-0.0007782678,
-0.0256176516,
0.0540339537,
0.010153072,
-0.0059149982,
-0.0699664876,
-0.0257431418,
-0.0235336982,
0.0283510815,
0.0477697439,
0.0051184022,
0.0242347587,
0.0081901858,
-0.055136919,
0.0080729537,
-0.0592794828,
0.0165263321,
0.0087855291,
0.0593293011,
0.0343981907,
-0.0334706232,
0.0183638837,
0.0430396087,
-0.042155508,
-0.0521825738,
-0.0336941294,
0.0341460295,
-0.0258636381,
0.0421589836,
-0.0420785062,
-0.0447752587,
-0.0724837556,
-0.0136093637,
-0.0092121866,
-0.0279622413,
-0.0107347276,
0.0367802195,
2.878e-7,
-0.0092327623,
-0.0107810656,
0.0003033729,
0.0628710762,
0.0009258444,
0.0360662416,
-0.0178750847,
0.0497703031,
0.0134850945,
-0.0028549633,
0.0073516453,
-0.0021084361,
0.0546792187,
0.0249977633,
-0.0912664384,
-0.0466247201,
-0.0301254671,
-0.0044071749,
-0.0632644892,
-0.0228949189,
-0.0233526863,
0.1016888693,
0.0218065567,
0.0001265801,
0.0361510478,
-0.0336480588,
0.0285166372,
-0.0300873928,
-0.0073098,
0.0349754393,
-0.055905208,
0.051408235,
-0.0259743743,
0.0211847816,
0.0031331824,
0.0477608629,
0.007053772,
0.0958793387,
0.0244930834,
0.0292108487,
0.0343462639,
-0.029393319,
0.0266445186,
-0.0484889634,
0.0478511527,
-0.0113530625,
-0.0213470571,
0.0310266223,
-0.0185013898,
0.0047227144,
-0.0459591597,
-0.0164723676,
-0.0034920396,
-0.000180657,
0.0025345569,
-0.0170457512,
-0.0032101767,
-0.0356111117,
-0.000677002,
0.06311813,
-0.0270001516,
-0.0470841005,
-0.0349673964,
-0.0260331444,
-0.0069716116,
-0.0394845977,
-0.024989048,
2.848345872e-34,
0.0527392216,
-0.0217666607,
0.0189083107,
0.0165536329,
0.0521652699,
-0.0077800723,
-0.051839292,
0.0212206468,
0.0605868623,
-0.0356218591,
-0.0231510978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19358v1 | The Model Arena for Cross-lingual Sentiment Analysis: A Comparative Study in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-06-27T17:38:45 | 2024-06-27T17:38:45 | Xiliang Zhu, Shayna Gardiner, Tere Roldán, David Rossouw | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis serves as a pivotal component in Natural Language
Processing (NLP). Advancements in multilingual pre-trained models such as XLM-R
and mT5 have contributed to the increasing interest in cross-lingual sentiment
analysis. The recent emergence in Large Language Models (LLM) has significantly
advanced general NLP tasks, however, the capability of such LLMs in
cross-lingual sentiment analysis has not been fully studied. This work
undertakes an empirical analysis to compare the cross-lingual transfer
capability of public Small Multilingual Language Models (SMLM) like XLM-R,
against English-centric LLMs such as Llama-3, in the context of sentiment
analysis across English, Spanish, French and Chinese. Our findings reveal that
among public models, SMLMs exhibit superior zero-shot cross-lingual performance
relative to LLMs. However, in few-shot cross-lingual settings, public LLMs
demonstrate an enhanced adaptive potential. In addition, we observe that
proprietary GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 lead in zero-shot cross-lingual capability, but
are outpaced by public models in few-shot scenarios. | [
-0.0007499581,
0.0451223813,
-0.0052355444,
0.0722755343,
-0.0301015917,
0.0044924454,
0.0164262466,
-0.0135707418,
-0.0035720093,
-0.0389079452,
-0.092239894,
-0.0637534261,
-0.0426086523,
-0.0179683436,
-0.0219934341,
-0.0099600609,
0.0388476923,
-0.0078908661,
0.0000390872,
-0.0373036824,
0.0056625903,
-0.0011258415,
0.0271869227,
0.0036088396,
0.0385624953,
-0.0029146706,
0.0372079499,
-0.0304277427,
0.0194832273,
-0.0269962158,
0.0006519032,
0.0273054708,
-0.011807207,
0.038142845,
0.000001861,
-0.0414703228,
-0.0145339798,
0.0102387024,
0.0677509084,
0.0075698299,
0.0658145025,
-0.0573332831,
-0.0170603171,
0.0061893575,
-0.030673936,
-0.0456224754,
0.0604907721,
0.0618146621,
0.032251209,
0.0811810941,
-0.0236064699,
-0.042552229,
-0.0034700145,
-0.0345187932,
0.020913003,
-0.0581617765,
0.019874746,
-0.0179441702,
-0.0233257972,
0.0134212133,
-0.0289529134,
0.0261579994,
-0.015701199,
0.0109311463,
-0.0493916422,
-0.0031218026,
-0.0169848427,
0.0109020686,
-0.030057583,
0.0377502218,
-0.0127309896,
0.0000382258,
-0.0373113491,
-0.0233094469,
-0.0321736224,
-0.0209813379,
-0.0396603122,
0.0065216227,
0.0199572574,
0.057842385,
0.0545230992,
0.0184365138,
0.0248888582,
0.0105355522,
-0.027192926,
0.0595507175,
-0.0037206162,
-0.0385770053,
0.0649063811,
0.0891677663,
0.0102206878,
0.003658032,
0.0116249314,
-0.0124052763,
0.0255523976,
0.0258421414,
-0.0003293573,
-0.0014298442,
0.021017177,
-0.0823370293,
0.0437257402,
0.0287895706,
-0.039125111,
0.0584834963,
-0.0487826876,
0.0099744443,
-0.0566182323,
0.0076087643,
-0.0110250227,
-0.0382170528,
-0.0721726939,
0.019852031,
0.0198822487,
0.0406905338,
-0.0337346345,
0.0123255542,
-0.0520718507,
-0.0038463867,
0.00237086,
-0.0364963785,
0.023839891,
-0.0503689349,
0.0037272242,
-0.0066553638,
-0.0363694355,
0.0884135738,
-0.0106967278,
0.0187020488,
-0.0485266075,
-0.0605472364,
0.0022163244,
0.0210753419,
-0.0188046061,
-0.0506408103,
0.0345715396,
0.0680802017,
0.0090967268,
-0.0159306675,
-0.0512243435,
0.0078870282,
-0.0117737772,
-0.1015211344,
0.0508943796,
-0.0538158529,
0.0355431028,
0.0039771767,
0.0234005563,
0.0210240148,
0.0075548496,
-0.0043248576,
-0.0618696809,
0.0295828767,
0.0017705351,
-0.002533074,
-0.0369179957,
-0.0294218548,
0.0000693567,
0.1017522812,
-0.0353571959,
-0.0042435201,
0.0438419022,
-0.025960695,
-0.0204740483,
0.0387040712,
0.0141449841,
0.0159231611,
-0.0374542736,
0.0016754762,
-0.0264289733,
-0.0303107761,
0.0300124176,
0.0121157262,
-0.0035933522,
0.0080983555,
0.0529387705,
0.0091775162,
0.0170962121,
0.0456995852,
0.0182102546,
-0.0295404252,
-0.0137902061,
-0.0032703984,
-0.0027827297,
0.0268350188,
-0.0393006317,
-0.0121211763,
-0.0000017477,
0.0283887722,
-0.0402246267,
-0.0231898911,
-0.0043771463,
-0.0194888115,
0.0052944366,
-0.0058416347,
0.0722981319,
-0.0160039328,
-0.0273514669,
0.0377531685,
0.0563377962,
-0.0552672334,
-0.0190940965,
-0.0482502691,
0.032214094,
0.0437973998,
-0.0373074301,
0.0002476313,
-0.0198512822,
-0.0069572851,
-0.0168977734,
0.052770447,
0.0619354919,
0.0297895689,
0.0374870263,
-0.019968776,
0.006634681,
-0.0455065593,
0.0196893532,
0.0575469583,
-0.0074072182,
0.0807694122,
-0.0308083314,
-0.0064267805,
-0.0123745203,
-0.0232382249,
-0.0249117445,
-0.0214358475,
0.0212609749,
-0.0078030699,
0.0423183106,
0.0325371474,
-0.0363286361,
-0.021611901,
0.0079275118,
-0.0429055952,
-0.0340813696,
0.0310398638,
-0.0110674342,
-0.0559768043,
0.0133669376,
0.001845508,
0.0077052987,
0.008555322,
-0.044498682,
0.0003905568,
0.0406450182,
0.0417220518,
0.0510848388,
-0.0448793769,
-0.0128238415,
-0.0322439,
0.0508417673,
0.0402443931,
0.0295800436,
-0.0016660487,
0.0194341037,
-0.0197400078,
-0.0325038843,
0.0198620819,
0.0099009983,
-0.0581074134,
0.0636118576,
0.0211120304,
0.0142168254,
0.0264928434,
0.0323693827,
0.0027502785,
-0.0392540991,
-0.0686149374,
0.0087619536,
0.0002072217,
0.0477300249,
0.0293216519,
-0.0006582044,
-0.0143655865,
0.0166556034,
-0.0395536609,
0.0106135178,
0.0235302616,
0.0551959053,
0.0404023193,
0.0206876136,
0.0410569385,
-0.0440781675,
-0.0049206992,
0.0129178856,
0.0133906901,
-0.022607062,
-0.0540162325,
-0.0115558747,
0.0254613645,
-0.059112113,
0.0057371617,
-0.0049184808,
-0.0559671372,
-0.0251279213,
0.0045369114,
0.0109941848,
0.0160437431,
-0.0390592776,
0.0021740512,
0.0316166691,
-0.0255224295,
-0.0091603352,
0.0335661136,
0.0004343506,
-0.0402473919,
-0.0503305569,
-0.0110895131,
0.0122150145,
0.0774495229,
-0.0131677128,
-0.0184203032,
-0.0516923182,
-0.0103671839,
-0.0102057895,
-0.0225433595,
0.0101312893,
0.0401902162,
0.0147004174,
0.0186845958,
0.0110830683,
-0.0037953088,
0.0212017149,
-0.0204794761,
0.006038324,
-0.0539693125,
-0.0191086587,
-0.0549853705,
0.0329735503,
-0.0259952005,
0.0235039163,
-0.0250938591,
0.0230388027,
0.0156953223,
-0.042453751,
-0.0010332494,
-0.0176320337,
0.0184967425,
0.0108120823,
-0.0037470844,
-0.0158425476,
-0.0343958735,
0.0544617064,
-0.0274349302,
-0.0560017899,
0.0080129271,
0.0118179573,
-0.0006144719,
0.0012406718,
0.021898333,
0.0147586353,
-0.0315354206,
-0.0082349153,
0.002187354,
0.0292715505,
0.0143555216,
0.0069314837,
-0.0231551845,
0.0112849772,
-0.0310356803,
0.0209460221,
0.0203596931,
0.0020055487,
-0.0076194876,
-0.0077569648,
-0.0221786965,
0.0317743085,
0.0139611596,
-0.0549864285,
-0.0690026432,
0.0613833778,
-0.0440973155,
0.0499139652,
0.0576756857,
-0.0200311709,
-0.0560711883,
-0.0292980578,
-0.0244828612,
-0.0187538415,
0.0130075049,
0.0300725382,
-0.0770570263,
-0.0315016992,
-0.0217113141,
-0.0235660169,
-0.0087777255,
-0.011270511,
-0.0216349326,
-0.16028139,
0.0137531115,
-0.0176279917,
-0.0678960606,
-0.0069699557,
-0.0377218984,
0.003969843,
-0.0339853838,
0.0175806563,
-0.0670990422,
-0.0099117337,
-0.0162198599,
0.0014611647,
-0.0223022066,
-0.0526420958,
0.0355531387,
-0.0219573509,
0.0136887794,
0.0314795636,
0.0491461381,
-0.0332818031,
-0.0428222716,
0.0532945395,
-0.0283101667,
0.0137979388,
-0.0492472984,
0.0574543811,
-0.0182907414,
-0.0351276882,
0.0368580781,
-0.0478432588,
-0.0209040847,
0.0431956425,
0.008145649,
0.0812597498,
0.0473643951,
-0.0400740765,
-0.0062712529,
0.0358963013,
-0.005481963,
0.0597189292,
-0.0282303393,
-0.0589141808,
-0.0311969277,
-0.0015155618,
-0.0417584106,
-0.0402345024,
-0.036962945,
0.0030039391,
-0.0554169044,
-0.0588974357,
-0.0389683284,
-0.0590785369,
0.0032309708,
0.0203794967,
-0.0061637969,
0.0377430245,
-0.0056151282,
0.0130331507,
0.024107866,
0.0068383417,
-0.0215709992,
-0.0008100662,
-0.0277016889,
0.0182934273,
0.0756170601,
0.0003930357,
-0.0049449261,
-0.045595862,
-0.0430458486,
-0.0552753732,
-0.0402937159,
0.069119148,
0.0087991403,
-0.000207269,
0.0016578513,
-0.0285942424,
0.03562323,
0.049020391,
-0.0037546707,
0.0170124881,
0.064811945,
0.0590392463,
-0.0043133809,
0.0426166542,
-0.0168294664,
0.0355953611,
0.0252028704,
0.023389779,
0.0103032822,
-0.0265022069,
-0.0023507704,
0.0127456095,
0.0425740853,
0.0178496055,
-0.0240121018,
-0.0231099743,
0.0118929334,
-0.0334208645,
0.0097972024,
-0.0402942039,
-0.0343487933,
0.05048199,
-0.0269920211,
-0.0581299588,
0.0145816319,
-0.0336679257,
0.0125770373,
-0.0504981093,
0.0479044355,
0.0560971573,
0.0169533007,
-0.0153132081,
0.0587087646,
-0.0064190151,
-0.0330495872,
0.0398864187,
-0.0004293736,
-0.0340647474,
0.0251955185,
-0.0092652971,
0.0174799506,
0.0288613439,
-0.0055485344,
-0.0253870022,
-0.0301293936,
0.008486663,
0.0335435718,
0.0477660224,
-0.015704127,
0.0845043212,
-0.0011261499,
-0.0181581508,
-0.0127299437,
0.0114862826,
-0.023169769,
0.0079417173,
0.053158436,
-0.0296142139,
-0.0207596663,
0.0135201579,
0.0658945367,
-0.0261671375,
0.0442026928,
0.0486434363,
-0.0061838734,
-0.0196170919,
-0.0011707604,
0.0686717555,
-0.0463063866,
0.0121222315,
0.0056292112,
-0.0521353334,
-0.0612990595,
0.0507150032,
-0.0536603518,
-0.014806971,
-0.0032948081,
-0.0361885205,
0.0810481533,
0.0311298687,
0.0289887488,
-0.0634775385,
-0.0046114088,
-0.0184460804,
0.0117572797,
0.0408161655,
-6.554020181e-33,
-0.0035099303,
0.0381077901,
-0.009064394,
0.014177084,
-0.0153340483,
-0.0084588258,
-0.0315045305,
0.0337587707,
-0.024395721,
0.0355266854,
-0.0037191622,
-0.0045624664,
0.0118340841,
0.0067002494,
0.0396663584,
-0.0016136095,
0.0329233781,
-0.0159468837,
0.012480353,
0.0250543281,
0.0395301282,
0.0331281126,
0.1076547131,
-0.0606004037,
0.0434972756,
0.0040984908,
-0.0105793756,
0.0084400438,
0.031578213,
0.0491223745,
-0.0255257301,
0.0619868413,
0.0495057069,
-0.0404655151,
0.004901343,
0.0068309559,
0.0058024544,
-0.0268888939,
0.0518245548,
-0.009358204,
0.0438257158,
-0.0321866013,
-0.0111689493,
0.003229527,
-0.0202246271,
0.0012053866,
-0.0012253696,
-0.0274128467,
0.0214121621,
-0.0523086004,
-0.0820079297,
0.0282400381,
0.0269407257,
0.033598993,
0.0514065102,
0.0822935328,
0.0027593293,
0.0910886377,
-0.0324737951,
0.0161150862,
-0.0341957323,
0.0052552591,
0.0214901343,
-0.0438566394,
0.0029118578,
0.0532380529,
0.0261650942,
0.0156556033,
0.0130749,
0.0302750152,
0.0230724495,
0.0288195852,
0.0257770512,
0.109478265,
0.0345193334,
-0.0175809562,
-0.0699992627,
-0.0222203266,
0.0359708667,
-0.0072379638,
0.0628877282,
0.0113071026,
-0.0092537031,
-0.0069153835,
0.0129757859,
-0.0734010264,
-0.0296882726,
-0.0434446298,
0.0121121258,
-0.0021404114,
-0.0198415089,
-0.0157278385,
0.0580033064,
-0.0477266982,
-0.0685155839,
0.0299116839,
-0.0585239269,
0.0129578859,
0.0086832969,
0.0397469588,
-0.1004536524,
-0.0498539768,
-0.0615341179,
0.0255592819,
0.0022215603,
-0.0174861401,
0.060158588,
0.018386947,
-0.1031083614,
-0.0061913482,
-0.0441783071,
0.0382760726,
-0.0016641377,
0.0737435594,
-0.0055326135,
-0.0161176641,
-0.0144924177,
0.0647763535,
0.0295809414,
0.0097012185,
0.0069658873,
-0.0137972487,
-0.0005723753,
0.0027311991,
-0.0239274353,
-0.023418691,
-0.0059233899,
0.0211102627,
0.0010891745,
-0.056639839,
-0.0332992189,
0.0064463872,
2.708e-7,
0.0429258421,
0.0296289884,
-0.0399689116,
-0.0194067918,
0.010777887,
0.0522033386,
-0.0676277801,
0.0395742953,
0.0278638881,
0.0250387024,
-0.0316599309,
0.0320366248,
0.040793512,
0.0493447855,
-0.0473289229,
0.0102267098,
-0.0327187739,
0.022865558,
0.0032546406,
0.0131546911,
0.0195931681,
0.0875142515,
-0.0029429265,
-0.0034298217,
-0.032756798,
-0.0528124124,
0.0959801823,
-0.0723327696,
-0.0590293556,
0.0069820397,
-0.018049106,
0.0367472135,
-0.0436269604,
-0.0364708379,
-0.0012081312,
0.0625762269,
0.0093317311,
0.0585273989,
0.0372189768,
-0.0359385237,
0.0462884083,
0.0200518463,
-0.0085004074,
-0.0319375657,
0.0549660921,
-0.0464289375,
-0.0392035283,
-0.0641471297,
-0.0060956245,
-0.0055737356,
0.080523178,
-0.0364061892,
-0.0167720597,
0.0147011392,
0.0149800926,
-0.0156008461,
-0.0737825558,
-0.0220070332,
0.0022171654,
0.02289588,
0.0021482115,
-0.0336768776,
0.016911285,
0.0175289009,
0.0146216135,
-0.023084823,
0.048621431,
1.83799034e-34,
0.0684439838,
-0.0507467017,
0.0090659969,
-0.008147696,
0.0259831399,
0.0105030481,
-0.0284241252,
-0.0099152941,
-0.0184683315,
-0.0315169729,
0.0222625937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19356v1 | DiVERT: Distractor Generation with Variational Errors Represented as Text for Math Multiple-choice Questions | 2024-06-27T17:37:31 | 2024-06-27T17:37:31 | Nigel Fernandez, Alexander Scarlatos, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | High-quality distractors are crucial to both the assessment and pedagogical
value of multiple-choice questions (MCQs), where manually crafting ones that
anticipate knowledge deficiencies or misconceptions among real students is
difficult. Meanwhile, automated distractor generation, even with the help of
large language models (LLMs), remains challenging for subjects like math. It is
crucial to not only identify plausible distractors but also understand the
error behind them. In this paper, we introduce DiVERT (Distractor Generation
with Variational Errors Represented as Text), a novel variational approach that
learns an interpretable representation of errors behind distractors in math
MCQs. Through experiments on a real-world math MCQ dataset with 1,434 questions
used by hundreds of thousands of students, we show that DiVERT, despite using a
base open-source LLM with 7B parameters, outperforms state-of-the-art
approaches using GPT-4o on downstream distractor generation. We also conduct a
human evaluation with math educators and find that DiVERT leads to error labels
that are of comparable quality to human-authored ones. | [
-0.0205448158,
0.0519702323,
-0.0149362506,
0.0484380685,
-0.0148161594,
0.0300738066,
0.0149177359,
-0.0210749712,
0.0279267058,
-0.0357916877,
0.0400623195,
-0.0283212382,
-0.0534849428,
-0.0333062112,
0.0552412085,
-0.0673956424,
0.01169293,
-0.0526873954,
0.0037939078,
0.0039248806,
-0.0159635488,
-0.0322135836,
-0.0033275899,
-0.0216716304,
-0.0150240492,
-0.0745834634,
-0.0141270272,
-0.0146107432,
0.0331865214,
-0.0021823465,
0.0318819582,
0.0689923167,
-0.0229682531,
0.0321147107,
0.0000022937,
-0.0428944603,
-0.0212092232,
0.0060848175,
-0.0465056151,
0.0236430429,
0.0081969919,
0.0429783165,
0.0012152499,
-0.0049477378,
-0.0246792566,
0.0083018327,
0.0134005342,
0.018505739,
0.0898942202,
0.0529001802,
0.0178697966,
-0.0056061507,
0.0247235298,
-0.0031310783,
0.108510606,
-0.0448559523,
0.0349650122,
0.0249050725,
-0.0478860512,
0.0578167886,
-0.0681257844,
0.0242896471,
0.0362917595,
0.0060112551,
-0.0214110464,
-0.0193684548,
-0.0122309532,
-0.0024113501,
-0.0146802366,
0.0595210977,
-0.0267994236,
-0.0172069706,
-0.013803889,
-0.0487429313,
0.0239060149,
0.058184851,
-0.0449497625,
0.0171016417,
-0.0375715829,
-0.0313017853,
0.0188451093,
-0.0496496558,
0.0013951953,
-0.002083139,
-0.0171170011,
-0.0374620557,
0.0400292128,
-0.0576551259,
-0.006560409,
0.0231130254,
-0.0631556958,
-0.0342918076,
0.0382000543,
0.0080544036,
-0.0416616239,
0.0275356397,
-0.0635104254,
-0.1202402189,
0.0062521328,
-0.0186835192,
-0.0091253817,
0.0124232937,
-0.0212561376,
0.0007322473,
0.0226084571,
0.1016754434,
-0.0362889729,
0.0256404988,
-0.0167846568,
0.0146957636,
0.0020595714,
-0.0003147619,
0.0048839757,
0.0189038869,
-0.0076358751,
0.0360300653,
-0.0264207497,
0.0271289144,
-0.0478507653,
0.0478787236,
-0.0145095382,
-0.0033025378,
-0.0130452579,
-0.026284907,
-0.0218253694,
0.029112706,
-0.0167692248,
-0.0048930757,
-0.0055209617,
-0.0360245034,
-0.0232660137,
0.0693578273,
0.017058,
-0.0304571353,
-0.0001519178,
0.0735622942,
0.0049638096,
-0.0120924609,
0.0076094647,
-0.0128390333,
0.0189401563,
-0.0337276943,
-0.0045205257,
-0.0384575315,
-0.0002033225,
0.0149298105,
-0.013164157,
-0.0430803858,
0.0229792278,
0.042541869,
0.0110210562,
0.0278262608,
0.0193929281,
-0.0482356846,
0.0344439819,
-0.0039066416,
-0.0227128379,
0.0388354138,
0.0262052082,
-0.0176831894,
0.0498618074,
-0.0640481561,
0.0436214395,
0.0113844182,
0.019016685,
-0.0067389817,
0.0188559536,
-0.0034580284,
0.0337693132,
0.0324325226,
0.0130552445,
0.073809281,
-0.0103694079,
0.0144170346,
0.041685719,
0.0108707743,
-0.013523371,
0.0201367382,
0.020258842,
0.0097651016,
0.0037564314,
0.0377065241,
-0.0640236959,
-0.0024527821,
-0.0386867188,
0.0043829614,
0.0151855722,
-0.0048206043,
0.003164083,
-0.0841933489,
-0.0082056131,
0.0089968648,
-0.0332424641,
0.0284874532,
0.0744686723,
-0.0139316218,
-0.065281719,
0.0629403666,
-0.0048146425,
-0.0270477999,
0.0100870682,
-0.0417548604,
0.0702235848,
-0.0029285769,
0.0180299059,
-0.0512000099,
-0.0550769791,
-0.0178697109,
0.0088852458,
0.0464666151,
0.0511603393,
-0.0137315458,
-0.0245687813,
-0.0511862598,
-0.0115624489,
-0.0097197024,
0.0484842099,
-0.0151086049,
0.0218713488,
-0.004232097,
0.0268299021,
-0.0248269923,
-0.0379204117,
0.0373963267,
-0.0339337848,
-0.0823152959,
0.0052060657,
-0.0087977881,
0.0007998745,
0.0040675672,
0.0253810324,
0.0226446334,
0.0038155389,
-0.0075985864,
0.0180901848,
-0.0428953618,
-0.0378582962,
-0.0399911068,
0.0670637563,
-0.0379574224,
-0.0324929692,
0.0181158613,
-0.0669440627,
-0.0109468894,
0.0554999746,
-0.0518306829,
-0.0320673399,
-0.0027349116,
0.0145463683,
0.019473888,
-0.0098725855,
-0.0331807546,
0.091362156,
0.0148556521,
0.0753325224,
0.0289578773,
0.0712018386,
0.0044543147,
-0.0063015861,
0.0219799131,
-0.037674617,
-0.0156092653,
0.0539880991,
-0.0080105169,
0.0352843627,
-0.0874638855,
-0.0220724307,
0.0040805661,
0.0213772543,
-0.0242464133,
0.0160528459,
0.0244382694,
-0.0341166966,
0.0033569485,
-0.0019008496,
-0.0112968013,
-0.0096322335,
-0.0120488582,
-0.0210274775,
0.004626378,
-0.0201096591,
0.0123868696,
-0.0502383262,
-0.0062201042,
-0.0343957879,
0.0419427827,
0.0217987243,
0.0548110195,
-0.029663194,
0.0380086936,
0.0042105308,
-0.0032159039,
0.0111863269,
0.0409998,
0.0285453908,
-0.0419335067,
0.0920804441,
0.0281871762,
-0.0072075911,
0.0449444316,
-0.0076406542,
-0.0407851338,
-0.0641019195,
0.0327927396,
-0.0480202548,
-0.0390781164,
0.0012547619,
-0.0590891913,
0.0243978221,
0.055433359,
0.0341884606,
-0.0505329221,
-0.0334983133,
0.0651111379,
-0.0408189818,
-0.0060173953,
-0.033491537,
0.0326566212,
-0.0503746532,
0.0153275169,
-0.0035085944,
-0.0335583724,
0.0536685772,
0.0218464825,
0.0050598793,
-0.0630105957,
0.0427202024,
-0.004626567,
-0.0403761454,
0.0112745678,
-0.0312504545,
0.0166932102,
-0.0342801698,
-0.0439038724,
0.0208974835,
0.0192690436,
-0.0454937592,
0.0508087687,
-0.1025472134,
-0.0388978012,
0.0365352593,
0.0046950406,
-0.0555140376,
-0.0122563783,
0.0431805141,
-0.0188485254,
0.000218942,
-0.0159899611,
-0.0228608325,
-0.0509904362,
0.0313283727,
0.0037020009,
-0.0461248867,
-0.0252991766,
-0.0274979901,
0.0577295944,
0.0398219861,
0.0424914621,
0.0368809365,
-0.0909456834,
-0.0125221238,
0.0520479977,
0.0576720163,
-0.0182694625,
0.0409530252,
0.0186057575,
0.0124560753,
-0.0132412137,
0.00357162,
0.0365195461,
0.0751083344,
-0.0467056334,
-0.0611193925,
0.0812762752,
0.0222251154,
-0.0286208037,
-0.0300999004,
-0.0616617538,
0.0078879828,
0.0080296043,
-0.0167715959,
-0.0278072078,
-0.031071879,
-0.0018948822,
0.0537880249,
0.024192702,
-0.0104040205,
0.0222893469,
-0.101155512,
0.0442249738,
0.0338909328,
-0.0573643893,
-0.0157072935,
-0.0339838453,
-0.0178520642,
-0.0112068783,
0.0309368428,
0.0121593159,
0.0199407879,
0.0313652232,
0.0626442656,
0.0135445129,
-0.0374684557,
-0.0594463274,
-0.0172761492,
-0.0300417487,
0.0006266023,
-0.0094890762,
-0.0377858654,
-0.067133531,
0.0027812333,
-0.0766764283,
-0.076290749,
0.015588765,
0.0405598655,
0.0022097947,
-0.0061029322,
-0.0501282141,
0.061242003,
-0.0745436773,
-0.04318358,
0.0553622469,
0.0995999128,
0.0072373068,
-0.0150154904,
0.0074075316,
-0.0087958509,
0.0129255056,
0.0291027166,
0.0373103097,
-0.0560717434,
0.0118213901,
-0.059994854,
0.0553322546,
-0.0458129868,
-0.0019644387,
0.0264788345,
0.0031093287,
-0.0446639098,
-0.0029696703,
-0.0501143821,
0.0275315996,
0.0037342303,
-0.0036266684,
-0.020240603,
0.0139412535,
-0.0287766587,
-0.0055031031,
0.0328320898,
0.0020316173,
-0.0047112815,
-0.0268521942,
-0.0207980853,
-0.0405323617,
0.0240304973,
-0.0330677629,
0.0625048801,
-0.1437485069,
-0.042923674,
0.0169457756,
0.0733745992,
0.0132194869,
-0.0278636366,
0.0009911576,
-0.0028463369,
-0.036024794,
-0.0010736187,
0.0035355564,
0.0275522936,
-0.0147857703,
-0.0370537192,
-0.0084209284,
-0.0180761702,
-0.0059619886,
-0.026143156,
0.0225920733,
0.0404437371,
-0.0693709478,
0.0069015045,
0.0373413414,
0.0135093424,
0.001573029,
-0.0083556212,
-0.0051916344,
-0.0412968695,
0.0106291762,
0.0060247942,
-0.0438472703,
-0.0075996411,
0.0166907739,
0.0242169686,
-0.0372262523,
-0.000602794,
-0.0354101323,
-0.0217163712,
0.0134916548,
-0.0108235329,
0.0481273085,
0.0295254104,
0.0276011601,
0.0603122786,
-0.0094170347,
-0.0004387131,
-0.007786605,
0.0345395133,
0.074684523,
0.0239709169,
0.0807173774,
0.0180105399,
0.011902282,
0.0438531078,
-0.0472972468,
-0.001632335,
-0.0813424587,
-0.0482763276,
0.038256105,
0.0119302236,
0.0251349173,
0.0415068604,
-0.0105915368,
-0.0109392805,
-0.036999356,
0.0440035239,
0.0271078274,
-0.0109454291,
0.0348403379,
0.0281974934,
0.037947204,
-0.0481435768,
0.0396227501,
-0.0082212985,
0.0027649545,
-0.0185441989,
0.0033954198,
-0.0583911799,
0.0066996664,
-0.004818154,
0.0290562455,
0.016848553,
0.0143341133,
-0.0757534355,
-0.0781199858,
0.0257969033,
0.0303198341,
0.0163351614,
-0.0074582649,
0.0077385618,
0.0636925027,
-0.0466089919,
-0.0095472364,
0.001087161,
0.0721744299,
-0.0641395748,
-0.0334105752,
-0.0390244015,
-5.785721114e-33,
-0.0636625364,
-0.0722144842,
0.0180718247,
-0.0392253958,
0.0155702373,
-0.0104905572,
-0.0457169302,
0.0313170515,
0.023555452,
-0.0006216996,
0.0408716202,
0.0190342404,
-0.0095149009,
0.0690596998,
0.0256571304,
-0.0406713337,
-0.0022478949,
-0.0027558047,
-0.0013716787,
0.0284346454,
0.0261719394,
0.0121330582,
0.0673783869,
-0.0510772653,
0.0598250553,
-0.0460212715,
0.0115096178,
0.0066646161,
-0.0439053848,
0.0359046347,
-0.0409736596,
0.0598326512,
-0.0193295013,
-0.0286685601,
-0.0175852682,
-0.0272526052,
-0.0068614124,
-0.0632637218,
-0.0016873614,
0.0418910533,
-0.0591919944,
-0.0436383188,
0.0468701683,
0.0260300264,
-0.0320939682,
-0.0247348975,
0.0538800545,
0.0074243639,
-0.0172713883,
0.0406787992,
-0.0579156354,
0.0234284569,
-0.026290318,
0.01527528,
-0.0150628295,
0.0358573012,
-0.0025763093,
0.030152278,
-0.0341995545,
0.0144218914,
0.0617485568,
-0.0029179968,
0.0055027208,
0.0156924725,
-0.0166407265,
0.0320058614,
0.0508756526,
-0.0415430963,
0.0356849022,
-0.0063580894,
0.0151060671,
0.0328600146,
0.0872348472,
0.0366383865,
0.019812528,
0.0191543438,
-0.0469251126,
0.0152650811,
-0.0684326813,
0.0237107798,
0.0040406003,
-0.0302330367,
-0.0334248357,
-0.0061097946,
-0.0354986563,
-0.0242330376,
-0.0415516496,
0.0094789704,
0.0457712561,
-0.0414891057,
-0.0144860586,
0.0078966944,
0.0103293285,
0.0158788264,
0.0092191929,
-0.001993201,
-0.0101792188,
0.0307820663,
-0.0213537142,
0.0258450806,
-0.0291722585,
-0.0070011718,
-0.0087577719,
-0.0357812829,
0.0219323728,
0.0199683066,
-0.0280253161,
-0.0062924237,
-0.0414928421,
0.0128128426,
-0.0536533073,
0.0058009061,
0.0289450083,
0.0515181869,
0.0256013479,
0.0031081915,
-0.0209505428,
0.0493801311,
0.0112033496,
-0.0161737259,
-0.0050833728,
-0.0174481757,
-0.0089786528,
0.0137520852,
-0.0265824124,
-0.0515456833,
0.0109350765,
-0.0035524806,
0.0337177217,
-0.0764144436,
0.020219814,
-0.0184297841,
2.693e-7,
0.0476405434,
0.0651245639,
0.0158176329,
0.0282610245,
0.0027975349,
0.0640624613,
-0.0188483391,
-0.0183329415,
0.0445390008,
0.0095554357,
-0.0040447153,
0.0175320711,
0.017165821,
0.0375687554,
-0.0402938239,
-0.0142855374,
0.0374824032,
-0.0218790118,
-0.0194304157,
0.0384323969,
0.1014878154,
0.0444970652,
0.0325727388,
-0.0032370545,
-0.0089197941,
0.0016827644,
0.0458903573,
-0.0112773785,
-0.040761929,
0.0193791948,
0.0240875036,
-0.037210647,
0.0054445257,
0.02688233,
-0.0023795902,
-0.0437404811,
0.0396196768,
0.0390369967,
0.0327408798,
-0.0194371436,
-0.0521501377,
0.0135612972,
0.0176374558,
-0.0340397246,
-0.0048405672,
-0.0070021464,
0.0011060784,
0.0417588577,
-0.0698177367,
-0.0123495879,
0.0046794703,
-0.0071690595,
-0.0119000189,
-0.0352677703,
0.006157028,
0.0361123942,
0.0168818217,
-0.0099585587,
-0.0058099232,
0.0501150861,
-0.0501433425,
-0.0319434702,
-0.0341832526,
-0.0144722965,
0.0314480141,
0.0171389021,
-0.0083193788,
2.468016282e-34,
0.0541880764,
0.0205143951,
0.0397155397,
0.0260725748,
0.0119914003,
-0.0096937111,
0.0236879941,
0.0337024517,
0.0244616903,
-0.0415660664,
-0.0086912503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19354v1 | Fundamental Problems With Model Editing: How Should Rational Belief Revision Work in LLMs? | 2024-06-27T17:33:03 | 2024-06-27T17:33:03 | Peter Hase, Thomas Hofweber, Xiang Zhou, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The model editing problem concerns how language models should learn new facts
about the world over time. While empirical research on model editing has drawn
widespread attention, the conceptual foundations of model editing remain shaky
-- perhaps unsurprisingly, since model editing is essentially belief revision,
a storied problem in philosophy that has eluded succinct solutions for decades.
Model editing nonetheless demands a solution, since we need to be able to
control the knowledge within language models. With this goal in mind, this
paper critiques the standard formulation of the model editing problem and
proposes a formal testbed for model editing research. We first describe 12 open
problems with model editing, based on challenges with (1) defining the problem,
(2) developing benchmarks, and (3) assuming LLMs have editable beliefs in the
first place. Many of these challenges are extremely difficult to address, e.g.
determining far-reaching consequences of edits, labeling probabilistic
entailments between facts, and updating beliefs of agent simulators. Next, we
introduce a semi-synthetic dataset for model editing based on Wikidata, where
we can evaluate edits against labels given by an idealized Bayesian agent. This
enables us to say exactly how belief revision in language models falls short of
a desirable epistemic standard. We encourage further research exploring
settings where such a gold standard can be compared against. Our code is
publicly available at: https://github.com/peterbhase/LLM-belief-revision | [
0.0384473689,
0.0847957134,
-0.0186175667,
0.027566975,
-0.0621502288,
-0.014295999,
-0.0386974551,
-0.0305370744,
0.009177194,
-0.0549819954,
-0.0002982397,
-0.0271223057,
0.0279082656,
0.0136171896,
0.0101297768,
-0.0240587629,
0.0461641215,
-0.0200422481,
0.016440697,
-0.0131051103,
-0.0514599755,
-0.0399685577,
0.0071847737,
-0.0105915461,
0.015866505,
-0.0162744001,
-0.0564738587,
0.0012686908,
0.0196663365,
0.0051288251,
-0.03228366,
0.0364042632,
0.005139037,
0.0757433996,
0.0000021043,
-0.0511151142,
-0.0318815894,
0.0071046907,
-0.055216305,
0.0227832217,
0.0178762451,
0.0236603618,
-0.0380682386,
-0.0543330461,
-0.0298040137,
0.0414891168,
0.0519629419,
0.0228386335,
0.0156624243,
0.0714717582,
0.0159395989,
0.0023488055,
0.0518461242,
-0.0019726183,
0.0215984154,
-0.0273874104,
0.0671655238,
0.0398415625,
-0.0320774093,
0.0192310382,
-0.0319116488,
0.0446976833,
0.0283192806,
-0.0280682575,
-0.0188029893,
0.0001739755,
0.0178181008,
-0.0177107155,
0.0159326624,
-0.0067389123,
0.0910444334,
-0.0364930928,
-0.0227400642,
0.0063845632,
0.0377430841,
0.0611845739,
-0.0058122994,
0.0317376629,
-0.0146444961,
0.0107766828,
0.0524065308,
-0.0820574015,
0.0608096421,
-0.0030993037,
-0.0302860625,
0.1159307882,
0.0194124244,
-0.0166530907,
-0.0449706279,
0.0128171723,
-0.0199662317,
-0.1140311882,
-0.0745640025,
0.0132562649,
-0.0124833239,
0.0376176238,
-0.0284770522,
0.0701233,
-0.0174263958,
-0.0468042158,
0.0205931421,
0.0188409649,
0.0064042402,
0.0333163403,
0.0504741333,
-0.0006398496,
-0.0192252174,
0.0301446058,
-0.0003448021,
0.03226652,
-0.0523586236,
-0.0068394402,
-0.0053189746,
0.0164553765,
0.0326988213,
0.0613400973,
-0.0152117861,
0.0176342055,
-0.0239925794,
0.047202941,
-0.0218136031,
-0.0445652343,
-0.0414055958,
-0.0285775606,
-0.0735845193,
0.0011331859,
-0.0079640923,
0.0365408063,
-0.0030923637,
-0.0443267226,
-0.0119626652,
-0.040230494,
-0.0284205247,
0.0042782631,
-0.0175455138,
0.0524820499,
0.0357456729,
-0.0028671101,
-0.0449025296,
-0.0483705178,
-0.0093626995,
-0.032446485,
-0.016126452,
-0.0557900779,
-0.0184278861,
-0.0174740888,
-0.0049747881,
-0.0962168202,
-0.030331945,
-0.0591209903,
-0.0254435875,
0.0673158914,
-0.048160594,
0.0087967282,
0.0230706707,
0.0043382035,
-0.0514318384,
0.0452445373,
0.0551390126,
-0.0153568927,
0.0526333563,
0.0221468098,
0.0267875977,
0.0187169351,
-0.011702911,
0.0532075949,
-0.0357995071,
0.0240959413,
0.0258093365,
0.011301646,
-0.0080310302,
0.008242052,
-0.0144597506,
-0.019131327,
0.0789292976,
-0.0203823894,
-0.0092849052,
-0.010243793,
0.0141814221,
-0.0545245595,
0.0277737658,
0.0522035137,
-0.0540698729,
0.0034348739,
-0.0318342373,
0.0166334473,
-0.0270818807,
-0.0125569804,
0.0062511764,
-0.0616485737,
0.012203088,
0.0209323205,
-0.0075134011,
0.0082354685,
0.0250903461,
0.0124428952,
0.0297501553,
0.0505784564,
0.0193353537,
-0.0379205644,
-0.0201046988,
-0.0712069422,
0.0241012536,
0.0141472435,
0.0574153736,
-0.0577546172,
-0.043867141,
-0.0035316166,
-0.0231372211,
0.0235888772,
0.0749370456,
-0.0234716926,
-0.0163134672,
0.0071995682,
-0.0114199733,
-0.0511462428,
0.0485543273,
0.0081382394,
-0.014626666,
-0.008932271,
-0.0072011389,
-0.0366274975,
-0.0172708668,
0.0249346402,
-0.0536642894,
-0.0026866987,
-0.0642735139,
-0.0150396097,
0.0252471659,
-0.000794634,
-0.0407158881,
0.0125331115,
0.0203460641,
0.0564857163,
-0.0012935732,
0.0532697067,
0.0412290804,
0.0031875395,
0.0751710236,
-0.0300852619,
-0.0116797155,
-0.0117158666,
-0.024545094,
0.0067906841,
0.0247304067,
-0.0215983056,
0.0573906489,
-0.0025807202,
0.0616404079,
-0.0527292192,
-0.0520256944,
0.011770987,
0.0258462019,
-0.0281650219,
-0.023258416,
0.0217270255,
-0.0094547188,
0.0042311875,
-0.0528267249,
-0.0081137987,
0.0184160993,
0.0445360169,
-0.0034685356,
0.0384196565,
-0.0321674086,
-0.0420399718,
-0.0393412523,
-0.0214585029,
-0.0238572434,
-0.0039954288,
-0.0111843571,
0.0239437297,
-0.0008175174,
-0.0194427744,
0.02379754,
0.016373476,
-0.0001577815,
-0.0136199454,
0.0328862704,
0.0280939415,
0.0040427954,
-0.0424194932,
-0.0551247559,
0.0316253826,
-0.0061691534,
0.0247240402,
0.0256558787,
-0.0093664788,
-0.066677697,
0.0038885935,
-0.0881854072,
0.0016697849,
-0.0102206254,
-0.0070651462,
0.0241804272,
0.0194857996,
0.0281492025,
0.009519564,
-0.0201177858,
0.0341026299,
0.0814206377,
-0.0218200181,
-0.0079386476,
-0.0167319924,
0.0008756923,
-0.0352237523,
-0.0439218059,
-0.0658352077,
0.0008939893,
0.0706863776,
-0.0062186825,
-0.0324003734,
-0.0270326845,
0.0853417218,
-0.0151683334,
-0.0501124822,
0.0095378952,
-0.0190459583,
-0.014690456,
0.0657091737,
-0.0414054058,
-0.072327584,
0.0560217015,
-0.0207923409,
0.0466154516,
-0.0236788336,
0.0029277205,
-0.018215267,
0.0458546802,
0.0259565543,
-0.0119661009,
0.0270371344,
0.0533773303,
-0.0692449808,
-0.0068269083,
0.041053962,
0.0077993143,
0.0343865789,
-0.0923920423,
0.0161900055,
0.0205515139,
0.0050365501,
-0.0139294444,
-0.0046234219,
-0.0417844132,
-0.0052381824,
0.0061089569,
-0.0067950753,
-0.0073709916,
-0.0383766368,
0.0380575918,
0.0366722904,
0.0404088944,
-0.0149853425,
-0.0312264152,
-0.0460300483,
0.0245221797,
0.0183521789,
0.0740647987,
-0.0380988829,
0.0398599766,
0.0511571579,
0.0226361118,
-0.0361412056,
-0.0101882312,
-0.0252697598,
0.0010609145,
-0.0564023331,
-0.0351852141,
0.0138350558,
0.0418826006,
-0.0273340493,
-0.0098908162,
0.0976782292,
0.0444160141,
-0.0110304253,
0.0369956791,
-0.0627899915,
-0.0006940732,
0.02987005,
0.0067250282,
-0.0728282854,
0.0168942362,
0.0334647931,
-0.0133143477,
-0.071131058,
-0.0774851888,
-0.019631356,
-0.0341214463,
0.0274708085,
0.0312208012,
0.0278707799,
0.0087904977,
-0.0322450213,
0.0117564769,
-0.0224423334,
-0.0212969445,
0.0421525016,
0.0119590824,
0.0152457897,
-0.0222743265,
0.0100576626,
-0.0263185203,
-0.009377744,
-0.0317567438,
0.0546629019,
-0.0014446625,
0.0142980628,
-0.0195584912,
-0.0380048826,
0.0126783326,
0.0896012709,
-0.0125044053,
0.0045761177,
-0.0125384554,
0.0037468688,
0.0232440941,
0.0106193097,
0.0021970808,
0.0300956573,
-0.0571564175,
0.0412485451,
0.0644541904,
-0.0524366572,
-0.0231779199,
0.0071375305,
-0.0288945176,
-0.0187459905,
0.0690955147,
0.0293685049,
0.0138640748,
0.0321597941,
-0.0915140659,
-0.0232916232,
0.0419408046,
-0.0166029762,
-0.0189871769,
-0.0217424072,
0.0098436493,
-0.0666590929,
-0.0598921813,
-0.0109788794,
-0.0257339533,
0.0568607561,
-0.0152429407,
0.0258168764,
-0.0171425417,
-0.0158872809,
-0.0147525864,
-0.0783244595,
-0.0240363739,
-0.0218125787,
-0.0076685864,
0.0161315836,
-0.0572541729,
0.0073176296,
-0.0145889111,
-0.0173957273,
-0.084175244,
0.0415317751,
0.0463345125,
0.0316225514,
0.0518363528,
0.0025497682,
-0.0189597309,
-0.0098076239,
-0.0211480502,
0.0052116015,
0.0708424002,
0.0374819078,
0.0335966274,
-0.004386209,
0.0480484776,
-0.0328075364,
0.0030098306,
0.0292405635,
0.0036148995,
-0.0538716204,
-0.0767856985,
0.0312262829,
0.0289397575,
0.001807017,
0.0118643977,
-0.0167554282,
-0.0244839247,
0.051213406,
-0.0345270894,
-0.0254353248,
-0.0037976576,
0.0186250303,
-0.0027350378,
0.0201539416,
-0.0033537438,
0.0185982455,
-0.0349915512,
0.0506449454,
-0.001444382,
-0.0097770579,
0.0230409987,
0.0270478986,
0.0313271768,
-0.0058466615,
0.0090018827,
0.010036773,
-0.0407729261,
0.0453146696,
0.0449821427,
0.0193659775,
0.0408354104,
-0.035948962,
-0.0495986044,
-0.0140129924,
-0.0841886923,
-0.0724491626,
0.0081528304,
0.0435455702,
0.0281274952,
0.0260372274,
0.0303702969,
-0.079413265,
-0.0183024276,
-0.0321139432,
0.0162668526,
0.0811373889,
-0.0404657796,
0.0036699874,
-0.0061083981,
-0.0393103622,
0.0117874397,
0.0306457765,
-0.0088796904,
0.1407530308,
-0.0398046747,
-0.0219397116,
-0.050119821,
-0.0624716692,
-0.0365590528,
-0.0234191548,
-0.0013000037,
-0.0285058673,
-0.0832740441,
-0.0423433781,
0.0024035601,
0.0447388217,
-0.0155200213,
-0.029306788,
-0.0455174968,
0.0453546531,
0.0064380723,
0.0157173052,
-0.0332714729,
-0.0003691,
0.0134816542,
0.0237676874,
0.000157276,
-5.1681263e-33,
-0.0297247544,
-0.0087995473,
0.0378127359,
0.0076013096,
-0.0099422168,
-0.0425543189,
-0.0238303896,
0.0121224457,
-0.0127883563,
0.0340804569,
-0.0091908947,
0.0064458973,
0.0159155075,
-0.0361482501,
0.0127762938,
-0.0012343639,
0.0672713891,
0.0165980123,
-0.0542997941,
-0.048748184,
0.0326794796,
-0.0305973589,
0.0960523114,
-0.0253508743,
0.1049125642,
0.0116336122,
-0.0074820728,
0.0297490396,
-0.0652479678,
0.0236382354,
0.0032394209,
-0.0007502232,
0.0034736106,
-0.0347198136,
-0.0300866179,
-0.0492322333,
0.0306552108,
-0.0068552713,
0.0475311987,
0.0222531632,
0.0144527648,
-0.0653642043,
0.0080046318,
0.0363670997,
-0.0499622077,
0.0008162826,
0.0048110629,
-0.056496717,
0.0243993737,
0.0601745658,
-0.060353674,
0.0238352958,
0.0097835995,
0.0044068322,
-0.028169062,
-0.0321446247,
0.0242952742,
-0.0282936879,
-0.0698623955,
0.0288186148,
0.0875484049,
0.0158706326,
0.0501380637,
-0.0198395271,
0.0268288087,
0.0464728847,
0.0250386316,
0.0440806597,
-0.0205544867,
0.0025380882,
0.0021059464,
0.0102606779,
0.0195724331,
0.0732197687,
-0.013598524,
0.0312239286,
-0.0386280492,
0.0078254128,
-0.0154702477,
0.0267555043,
-0.0216819607,
0.0402173363,
-0.0158869885,
0.0093945162,
-0.0772437677,
0.0030227164,
-0.0020953047,
-0.0029786548,
-0.0174483526,
-0.0074178982,
-0.021424273,
-0.0117270472,
0.0017233222,
-0.044450704,
-0.0330252051,
-0.0205141176,
-0.0253252462,
0.026667729,
-0.0015744923,
-0.0230544619,
-0.017241301,
0.043248903,
-0.0088529941,
0.0114684673,
0.0050127767,
0.0226444714,
-0.012166515,
0.038776584,
-0.0025169807,
0.0171384625,
-0.0104582049,
-0.0150648123,
0.0297996346,
-0.0377858244,
0.035065826,
0.0084551536,
-0.0032101315,
-0.011745804,
0.0406687297,
-0.0112913707,
-0.0152799841,
0.0709147975,
-0.0062417984,
0.0343456231,
0.0060535944,
0.0040690936,
-0.00885309,
0.0350646637,
0.0438653752,
-0.014320313,
-0.011247172,
0.0043377466,
2.727e-7,
0.042256128,
0.0321581475,
0.0249505974,
0.0165427569,
0.0398046747,
0.0469475649,
-0.0293100569,
0.0003007005,
0.0211249832,
-0.0719079003,
0.0081924992,
0.0015223727,
0.0207913108,
0.0241510253,
-0.0191708449,
-0.0273130927,
-0.018350305,
0.0012531708,
-0.019969672,
-0.0064753168,
-0.0035118398,
0.0245904364,
0.0505682006,
0.0173808672,
-0.0267923698,
0.0093377456,
0.0490711071,
-0.0601630546,
-0.0301785264,
0.0495074689,
0.035750635,
-0.002386417,
0.0353686698,
0.0100482507,
0.0009262938,
-0.0066926084,
-0.0493322201,
0.0317727141,
0.0192838106,
0.026886208,
-0.0315900557,
-0.0313334577,
0.0055385805,
-0.0275153872,
0.0521241277,
-0.028021194,
-0.0348947048,
0.010225716,
-0.0402863212,
0.0042892969,
0.0189406443,
-0.0229889788,
0.0049902205,
0.0127631836,
-0.0159774739,
0.0568747334,
-0.0044858572,
0.0075030881,
-0.0481589288,
-0.0349739045,
-0.0207766369,
-0.1040168405,
-0.0043534134,
-0.0374955051,
0.0028134931,
-0.115343675,
0.018198289,
2.173119646e-34,
0.0314648822,
-0.0008979909,
0.0142561933,
0.0426545478,
0.0392891131,
-0.0271204002,
0.0169855114,
0.0063193562,
0.0318172202,
-0.0629909486,
-0.0103559913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19349v1 | IndoToxic2024: A Demographically-Enriched Dataset of Hate Speech and Toxicity Types for Indonesian Language | 2024-06-27T17:26:38 | 2024-06-27T17:26:38 | Lucky Susanto, Musa Izzanardi Wijanarko, Prasetia Anugrah Pratama, Traci Hong, Ika Idris, Alham Fikri Aji, Derry Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hate speech poses a significant threat to social harmony. Over the past two
years, Indonesia has seen a ten-fold increase in the online hate speech ratio,
underscoring the urgent need for effective detection mechanisms. However,
progress is hindered by the limited availability of labeled data for Indonesian
texts. The condition is even worse for marginalized minorities, such as Shia,
LGBTQ, and other ethnic minorities because hate speech is underreported and
less understood by detection tools. Furthermore, the lack of accommodation for
subjectivity in current datasets compounds this issue. To address this, we
introduce IndoToxic2024, a comprehensive Indonesian hate speech and toxicity
classification dataset. Comprising 43,692 entries annotated by 19 diverse
individuals, the dataset focuses on texts targeting vulnerable groups in
Indonesia, specifically during the hottest political event in the country: the
presidential election. We establish baselines for seven binary classification
tasks, achieving a macro-F1 score of 0.78 with a BERT model (IndoBERTweet)
fine-tuned for hate speech classification. Furthermore, we demonstrate how
incorporating demographic information can enhance the zero-shot performance of
the large language model, gpt-3.5-turbo. However, we also caution that an
overemphasis on demographic information can negatively impact the fine-tuned
model performance due to data fragmentation. | [
0.0686900243,
0.0818908215,
-0.0212447494,
0.0201284159,
0.0039760806,
0.0615401864,
0.0480709262,
0.0364068821,
0.0216791127,
-0.0547825061,
-0.0040051849,
-0.0326138362,
0.0022946827,
-0.0023605004,
-0.0023008238,
-0.0742478073,
0.0306388456,
0.0497258082,
0.0510451198,
-0.0144574167,
0.0296219978,
0.0364564806,
-0.0002274955,
0.034303844,
-0.0545831807,
0.0033654021,
0.0240157787,
-0.0033389619,
0.0540085956,
-0.0074307835,
0.0591917895,
0.0570088401,
-0.0141832083,
0.0525241345,
0.0000017673,
-0.0264621694,
0.0268567763,
0.0074215764,
0.0068247351,
-0.0174029525,
0.0852247402,
-0.0142413611,
-0.0258087963,
0.0446224734,
-0.0172124989,
-0.0005026967,
0.0424575955,
0.0356478244,
0.0643943846,
0.0584125184,
-0.0099010104,
-0.0234844778,
-0.0134052904,
0.0106609799,
0.0095956158,
0.0584926642,
0.0429856852,
-0.0744854584,
-0.060022369,
-0.020694511,
-0.0118333893,
0.0032310854,
0.0277099404,
0.0344496146,
0.0141386399,
-0.0250426475,
-0.0797143728,
-0.0580149107,
0.0464790016,
0.0411849879,
-0.0283119213,
-0.0060454789,
-0.0131674893,
0.0234552193,
-0.0239139814,
-0.0160283372,
-0.0123675289,
-0.0073938873,
-0.0356194228,
0.0244145021,
0.0235042311,
0.0190952811,
0.0415025875,
0.0789787024,
0.0226242747,
0.0219231416,
-0.0003129165,
-0.0252856594,
-0.0051638209,
-0.0268880557,
-0.0395693257,
0.0168740228,
0.0325287059,
-0.0171261672,
0.0036876269,
0.0156137524,
-0.0418690667,
-0.0395692885,
0.0205246359,
-0.106583558,
0.0106417686,
0.0570636727,
-0.0188888106,
0.0004851722,
0.0185768604,
0.0108854063,
0.0286896396,
0.0292022713,
0.0122653507,
-0.0120827146,
-0.0154837295,
0.0175296832,
0.006356346,
-0.0030740844,
0.0091657434,
0.0521345139,
-0.0654069781,
-0.0021770424,
-0.0494298972,
-0.0243484322,
0.0044671069,
-0.0003721216,
-0.0274338853,
0.004929889,
-0.0116978073,
0.0166898929,
-0.0444351919,
0.0124505321,
-0.0387906171,
-0.0705041885,
0.0224099662,
0.027929306,
-0.0306056049,
-0.0348272733,
0.03001865,
0.0501502864,
0.0206040423,
-0.024489766,
-0.0520662591,
-0.0031197846,
-0.0363430083,
-0.0558870248,
0.0235542208,
-0.0373661108,
0.0378646888,
0.0084766541,
-0.0283344351,
-0.0602983199,
0.0131393606,
0.0255004857,
-0.0340233892,
0.0824985355,
0.0304268394,
-0.016206108,
0.0704030618,
0.0385726318,
0.0299496874,
0.0820825472,
0.0195288509,
0.0118684312,
0.0417351276,
0.0012335208,
-0.02988014,
0.0610079393,
0.0415514223,
0.0568397455,
-0.0487683862,
0.0175437499,
-0.046122469,
-0.0449398644,
0.0027128975,
0.0212383494,
0.0190535598,
-0.0489328057,
0.0390267596,
0.0666928291,
-0.0342610776,
0.0566560999,
0.0194549151,
0.0248732027,
-0.0328218341,
-0.0465073325,
-0.0511748195,
-0.0335235745,
-0.0145448809,
-0.0518599041,
0.0436500683,
0.0743782222,
-0.0342474282,
-0.0267296638,
-0.028537536,
0.0060073799,
0.0560462587,
-0.0433481559,
0.0450174548,
-0.0086291786,
-0.0000013447,
0.0187535565,
0.0677663535,
-0.0249069128,
0.0139042092,
-0.0623770393,
0.0098343398,
0.0445193686,
0.0058941236,
-0.0137582701,
0.0088563003,
-0.0506023355,
-0.0112396702,
0.0397620611,
-0.0007541724,
-0.006327583,
-0.0017211171,
-0.0230839793,
-0.0202655196,
0.073527962,
0.0291513372,
0.0265144818,
0.0797720477,
0.0232990719,
0.0161038786,
0.0233773999,
-0.0284198727,
0.0225380547,
0.009620877,
-0.0461843163,
-0.0018774777,
0.021457687,
0.0743359476,
0.016001597,
-0.0247540325,
-0.0668189004,
-0.0107033672,
-0.01526557,
-0.0363869816,
-0.0042384104,
-0.0132566607,
-0.0096676098,
0.0179318897,
-0.0412338227,
-0.0292744674,
0.0654893667,
-0.000413161,
0.0286930688,
0.0666916221,
-0.0046270741,
-0.0248486381,
-0.0209369995,
-0.0266564582,
-0.0769811794,
0.0244266279,
-0.0174398832,
0.061540965,
-0.0380874686,
-0.0232663751,
0.0030306207,
-0.0599879995,
0.0354385898,
0.0151506439,
-0.0357226543,
-0.0322597139,
-0.0209264811,
0.032723818,
-0.0207591392,
0.0123658208,
-0.0095754461,
-0.0043664393,
-0.0865124911,
-0.0092045516,
-0.0244786423,
-0.0009413268,
-0.0016676461,
0.0008521691,
-0.0431357957,
0.0333361067,
0.0083261384,
-0.0476198494,
0.0391454324,
0.0227593407,
-0.0145111699,
-0.0562651828,
-0.0001255329,
-0.0061135096,
-0.0267857499,
-0.0316031352,
0.0350451097,
0.0115324371,
-0.1022728756,
0.0649612471,
-0.0361656211,
-0.043096263,
-0.0073154648,
-0.0109663131,
-0.0706002787,
0.0203247033,
0.0300867893,
-0.0140846064,
0.0435947105,
0.0466985479,
0.0835952386,
0.0086169168,
0.0121846981,
-0.0204482507,
0.0046220711,
-0.0089590838,
0.0407942086,
-0.0046297889,
-0.0445898548,
-0.0113062747,
0.0806773007,
0.041005265,
-0.0189805664,
-0.0730896965,
0.0129063847,
-0.0795549974,
-0.0285780057,
-0.0233093388,
-0.043495357,
-0.0170297474,
-0.0366659984,
-0.0315401368,
-0.0473261885,
0.0610998049,
0.0228232481,
0.0437147915,
-0.013162504,
-0.0149491243,
-0.0197705179,
0.0034971503,
-0.0171419736,
0.027271295,
-0.0239467956,
0.0058260928,
0.0049157175,
-0.0217179433,
0.0144622307,
-0.0294306464,
0.0105820261,
-0.0232670028,
0.0060197804,
-0.0080775907,
-0.0577570759,
-0.0554458834,
-0.0607815497,
-0.0334330499,
-0.0153186908,
0.0287404619,
-0.0076248515,
-0.021437563,
0.0382724069,
0.0197439007,
-0.0475860015,
0.0020831604,
0.0034533245,
0.0423348211,
-0.0319394618,
-0.0272803251,
-0.0662648752,
0.0259358659,
-0.0002608251,
-0.0207686163,
0.0459944084,
-0.0059583532,
0.0230278969,
0.0033443344,
0.0159060396,
0.0194355026,
0.0193261523,
-0.0074816598,
-0.0439067818,
0.0093942117,
-0.0100131929,
0.0097223604,
0.086679779,
0.0098932702,
-0.0264221951,
-0.0244167112,
-0.0154078426,
0.0446710438,
0.0062823971,
-0.0023597635,
-0.0792061239,
0.0119315609,
0.0073079574,
0.0239844453,
-0.0739634931,
-0.0448752865,
0.0200172104,
-0.0510035269,
0.003813264,
0.0130758714,
-0.0302341059,
-0.0357066579,
-0.0211903788,
0.0178053621,
-0.0173869282,
0.0486319363,
-0.0358388424,
0.0358349904,
0.0032265377,
0.0334629677,
-0.0745888576,
-0.0270433985,
0.0308302473,
-0.0001856294,
0.0359173194,
-0.0001932349,
0.0472800657,
-0.038162075,
0.0333621874,
0.050093513,
-0.0191228352,
-0.051618021,
-0.0636615604,
0.0475167707,
-0.0022343767,
-0.0473234467,
-0.0416466855,
0.051251255,
-0.0176922418,
0.0185909364,
0.0114205359,
0.0245525688,
0.0368024111,
-0.0009845607,
-0.0485983826,
0.0205018986,
-0.0089224745,
0.0536331758,
0.0221410636,
-0.0650820881,
0.0529058836,
-0.0978875309,
-0.0316708535,
-0.0388551615,
-0.0842728466,
-0.0006817302,
-0.0437773652,
-0.0435515232,
-0.0011201737,
-0.0381478332,
0.0216814652,
0.0080830036,
0.0205213483,
-0.0406455025,
0.0146405352,
-0.007803699,
-0.0447611511,
0.006898066,
-0.0004963479,
0.0224941876,
-0.0064013978,
-0.0015762635,
-0.0352608301,
0.0144641148,
-0.0257564262,
0.0154743856,
-0.0492833629,
-0.0354806632,
0.0939348489,
0.0353912152,
0.0164470542,
-0.008521568,
-0.0098895887,
-0.0482764207,
0.0766068473,
0.0704926178,
0.0038789194,
-0.0193006247,
0.0234379303,
-0.0045307889,
0.0129377488,
0.0355612226,
0.0040673874,
0.0383155569,
0.0368575975,
-0.0614643693,
-0.0685020462,
0.0147285303,
-0.0407351106,
-0.0230750553,
0.0361576192,
-0.0096217254,
-0.0747945458,
-0.0480726324,
-0.0222446248,
0.0210470445,
-0.0314862095,
0.006821251,
-0.0154566886,
0.0319088474,
-0.0018630931,
-0.0581316724,
-0.0025945145,
-0.0357670821,
0.0069940886,
-0.0548382066,
0.0200862065,
0.0166490562,
0.0503768958,
0.0195610747,
0.0021230723,
-0.0141014149,
0.0295946561,
-0.0263008587,
-0.02855286,
-0.0158891156,
0.0315059423,
-0.003042721,
0.0055735055,
0.045562353,
-0.0266077425,
0.0430628695,
0.0202836841,
-0.059494786,
0.0002389055,
-0.006758377,
-0.0238214284,
0.005883147,
-0.008275535,
-0.0331596136,
-0.0194217097,
-0.0051453281,
-0.0164517313,
-0.0345845632,
0.0147270076,
0.025080137,
-0.0266280472,
0.0166396033,
0.0370343514,
0.0308806133,
0.0344397277,
0.0911936834,
-0.0398410298,
-0.0058469991,
0.0000822033,
0.0353368968,
0.015414536,
0.002617927,
0.0222804435,
-0.051160574,
-0.045413021,
0.0037421295,
-0.0547045432,
0.0151701057,
0.0027330411,
0.0207524672,
0.0471407361,
-0.017246075,
0.0167241003,
-0.0017352598,
0.0020212906,
-0.0346164405,
-0.0423575565,
0.0121683544,
-5.674740856e-33,
-0.039386224,
0.0005983522,
-0.0377779342,
-0.0229091365,
0.0097071407,
-0.0217428524,
0.0492240638,
0.0218253639,
-0.0303472113,
0.0327037126,
0.0041863294,
0.0410935245,
0.0082491469,
0.0161149427,
0.002276327,
-0.0470372029,
0.0198787395,
-0.0048213964,
-0.0163363218,
0.0028776999,
0.0481568836,
0.0093369698,
0.033494655,
-0.0687019825,
0.0243182294,
0.0073696841,
-0.0120372158,
0.001242635,
0.0168944541,
0.0665860474,
-0.0241072141,
0.1053991765,
0.0320422687,
0.0009491649,
0.0237540565,
0.0473889522,
-0.0508773886,
-0.0016523381,
0.0035308315,
0.0164607149,
0.0377027914,
-0.0229669027,
0.0224803984,
0.0144500686,
-0.0271976124,
-0.0513029657,
0.0391636491,
-0.0327332132,
0.0054258001,
-0.0315302685,
-0.0363856331,
0.0330160856,
-0.0231802855,
0.0064254478,
-0.0242879819,
0.0473525375,
0.0404311903,
0.0220428929,
-0.064676322,
0.0023191967,
-0.0062881727,
-0.0055120466,
-0.0139073571,
-0.002037083,
0.011548629,
0.0527882837,
-0.0070246835,
0.0335933454,
-0.0235515386,
-0.0115512609,
0.0352392457,
0.0019309367,
0.0234547146,
0.0403448753,
0.0150513407,
-0.0665674806,
-0.0618583038,
-0.0078359665,
0.0679115504,
-0.001098084,
0.0174634028,
-0.0365328118,
-0.0678800792,
-0.0384566896,
-0.0076940069,
-0.0904730633,
-0.0356642157,
-0.0101341782,
0.0128088295,
-0.0149137303,
-0.03375303,
-0.0207279418,
0.0186438523,
-0.0134573849,
0.004442866,
0.0432887226,
-0.023820715,
0.0064823804,
0.018780183,
0.0531307943,
-0.0331265107,
-0.020085495,
-0.0121140694,
-0.0019982811,
0.0308301877,
-0.0130571285,
0.0717935339,
0.0284448955,
-0.0727118477,
0.0060331565,
0.0054188422,
0.0411153398,
-0.0092771603,
0.0920262262,
-0.0022673861,
0.0421966277,
0.0103106787,
-0.0139293782,
0.0368853621,
0.0041756122,
0.0124747269,
-0.0137646049,
-0.0481240526,
-0.0134885702,
0.0113589354,
-0.0193438549,
-0.017963212,
0.0409942865,
0.0109200589,
-0.0827975646,
0.0106315184,
-0.0660068691,
2.438e-7,
0.0226323176,
0.0637645498,
-0.0070072878,
-0.0038116032,
0.0174705442,
0.0369133651,
0.03702287,
0.0274346657,
-0.003741551,
0.0152803157,
-0.0201593041,
0.0452177525,
0.0252237841,
0.0568231642,
-0.0303223506,
-0.0269582067,
-0.0707729608,
0.006214133,
-0.0757308677,
0.00812029,
-0.0261377357,
0.1042507142,
0.0793510675,
-0.0469840616,
-0.0145880189,
-0.0098327408,
0.0391300358,
-0.0449703895,
-0.049293641,
0.001653919,
0.0624575242,
0.0434224755,
0.0397745408,
-0.0048297411,
-0.0117694065,
0.0117616961,
0.0039967592,
0.0698410198,
0.0050253491,
0.0127302911,
0.0196513105,
-0.0147794802,
-0.0252842661,
-0.0392509811,
0.0610641465,
-0.0051488741,
-0.0239879433,
-0.0231080242,
-0.0224875584,
-0.0277057029,
0.0593352541,
-0.024771031,
-0.0250289291,
0.0055304882,
0.0352935642,
-0.026621744,
-0.0075007891,
-0.0676587,
-0.0022563401,
-0.0141536891,
-0.0520124212,
-0.0383336619,
-0.0243513025,
0.0057613151,
0.0366560332,
0.0431702025,
0.0589706264,
2.038558834e-34,
0.0294178519,
0.0023175133,
-0.0181126855,
-0.0605433136,
0.047531981,
0.0193236992,
0.0133820092,
-0.0122265294,
0.0436620191,
-0.0174997654,
0.0163298845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19317v1 | Jump Starting Bandits with LLM-Generated Prior Knowledge | 2024-06-27T16:52:19 | 2024-06-27T16:52:19 | Parand A. Alamdari, Yanshuai Cao, Kevin H. Wilson | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present substantial evidence demonstrating the benefits of integrating
Large Language Models (LLMs) with a Contextual Multi-Armed Bandit framework.
Contextual bandits have been widely used in recommendation systems to generate
personalized suggestions based on user-specific contexts. We show that LLMs,
pre-trained on extensive corpora rich in human knowledge and preferences, can
simulate human behaviours well enough to jump-start contextual multi-armed
bandits to reduce online learning regret. We propose an initialization
algorithm for contextual bandits by prompting LLMs to produce a pre-training
dataset of approximate human preferences for the bandit. This significantly
reduces online learning regret and data-gathering costs for training such
models. Our approach is validated empirically through two sets of experiments
with different bandit setups: one which utilizes LLMs to serve as an oracle and
a real-world experiment utilizing data from a conjoint survey experiment. | [
0.042200733,
0.070261687,
0.0058922209,
0.0084495125,
-0.0115439631,
0.0065581361,
0.0184110515,
0.0024082211,
0.03430916,
-0.0444971062,
-0.0536442772,
-0.0257025138,
-0.0400537103,
-0.0015021339,
0.0047452054,
-0.0033326584,
0.0069892402,
-0.0803800672,
0.010160624,
-0.0405178517,
0.0036288609,
-0.0073328116,
0.0089907357,
0.0160769597,
0.0468602255,
0.0339355618,
-0.0156850629,
0.0007743826,
-0.0200592242,
-0.0629818439,
0.0165569596,
0.0299921576,
0.0423333608,
0.0380834751,
0.0000020504,
-0.0704049245,
-0.064559415,
-0.0394263417,
-0.0260193143,
0.0039616646,
0.059367083,
0.0588755198,
0.0252305288,
0.0115638021,
-0.0409508124,
0.0426308326,
0.0126263704,
0.0347421691,
0.0093507348,
0.0104195848,
-0.0016122223,
-0.0041283332,
0.0078359609,
-0.0330623426,
0.0451118127,
-0.049733948,
0.0358346328,
-0.0388934277,
-0.0021806245,
-0.0092137177,
-0.0003962974,
-0.0272907466,
-0.0216486733,
0.0241934359,
0.0234364979,
0.0142222308,
-0.0254976097,
-0.0060026436,
-0.0171005037,
0.0365799181,
-0.0193523206,
-0.0133174369,
0.01945813,
-0.0237326417,
-0.0038160756,
0.0070291003,
-0.0262698159,
0.0306454394,
-0.0134479217,
0.0425319336,
0.0429074652,
0.0144069642,
0.0348257087,
0.0436888337,
-0.0072587477,
0.0687966123,
-0.0197536647,
-0.0399596021,
0.0732815713,
0.0195215475,
-0.024572514,
-0.0214442182,
0.0162006579,
0.0029335588,
-0.073729448,
0.0257987697,
-0.0074808802,
0.0375701599,
0.0334575735,
-0.0319436118,
0.0563830286,
-0.0012059638,
-0.0129477931,
0.0519712977,
-0.0075905989,
0.0172172841,
-0.0107935537,
-0.0185580608,
-0.0166679844,
-0.023795452,
0.0026254707,
0.0029173682,
0.002428567,
0.0443785824,
-0.0046466682,
0.0052773147,
-0.0511294752,
0.0590437166,
-0.0064855334,
0.023994714,
-0.0222174805,
0.0207106043,
-0.0166581348,
0.0034689293,
-0.0908946097,
-0.0506752059,
-0.028503513,
0.023772452,
0.0185627099,
-0.0085761789,
0.0268595032,
0.006005975,
-0.0088012796,
-0.0503209978,
0.0383511595,
0.07026539,
0.0060689002,
-0.0391041376,
-0.0661272705,
-0.0296083894,
0.0077345814,
-0.0095720598,
-0.0537591204,
-0.0745033696,
0.0195390824,
-0.0013198165,
-0.0111168614,
-0.0004346753,
0.023472907,
0.0184121486,
-0.0420918353,
0.0644666851,
0.006813623,
-0.0266401228,
0.0277676415,
-0.026054915,
-0.0065579871,
0.0402919352,
0.0045853942,
0.0939561948,
0.0566943325,
0.0276603214,
-0.005495159,
0.0263675302,
0.0053117755,
0.0139136184,
-0.0193573646,
0.0094087543,
0.0067228,
0.054305438,
0.0265955012,
0.0184662603,
-0.0605890602,
-0.0069275633,
0.0633322075,
0.0380844511,
0.0342909209,
0.022249084,
0.0385644138,
0.0126323625,
-0.0211712979,
-0.0373093039,
-0.0208454356,
0.0196218323,
-0.0731150955,
0.0047553256,
0.0495988503,
0.0240583587,
0.004604442,
-0.0115076909,
0.0184050612,
-0.0083442237,
-0.0069968798,
0.0633838996,
0.0216553919,
-0.0323053636,
-0.0359786525,
-0.0457116216,
0.0583047643,
0.0116272653,
-0.0220807567,
-0.0148484651,
0.0496404171,
0.0934039801,
0.0523786731,
-0.0312623046,
0.0389024429,
-0.0377059691,
-0.0230041444,
-0.0299552307,
0.0482453145,
-0.0449343845,
0.0141339414,
-0.0396208577,
-0.0404332802,
0.021139117,
-0.0091751823,
0.0557382777,
0.0309213884,
0.0202319231,
-0.0208903681,
-0.0082951598,
0.019983381,
-0.0117088491,
-0.0549487025,
-0.0563051403,
0.040196076,
-0.0038948553,
0.0365724228,
-0.0413694642,
0.0158679541,
-0.0087819519,
0.0097652031,
0.0150050865,
-0.0333545841,
-0.0043582958,
-0.0410973653,
-0.0250787828,
0.027043622,
-0.010400882,
0.0407819785,
0.0045135417,
0.0126069868,
-0.0183988661,
-0.0364157036,
0.0084713055,
0.0631204695,
-0.0617554523,
0.0086306212,
0.001838513,
0.0252830684,
-0.0511879399,
0.0680976808,
0.0035448945,
0.025874719,
0.0021032682,
0.0013163032,
-0.0082399854,
-0.0900533497,
-0.0091371937,
-0.0219299495,
0.0269611347,
0.0084404433,
0.0311477687,
0.0185597558,
-0.0267355051,
-0.0094950302,
-0.1095907614,
0.002043633,
0.0189357623,
-0.0177014116,
-0.012740518,
-0.0012829859,
-0.0203164294,
-0.0287073702,
-0.0232366025,
0.0021192462,
-0.0087568555,
0.0389473103,
0.0229308475,
0.0251789615,
0.0026635556,
-0.0564461574,
-0.0097356914,
-0.0067871544,
0.0427087285,
0.0040228893,
0.0071972455,
-0.0101113524,
-0.0522452481,
-0.0064880466,
0.0225497391,
-0.0277758744,
0.053140901,
-0.020421369,
-0.0472299606,
0.0153241102,
0.04065644,
0.043617297,
0.0394765213,
0.0641903281,
-0.0091290781,
-0.0620121211,
0.0115597909,
-0.0105627086,
-0.022850845,
-0.0489722043,
-0.0225869752,
0.0331172757,
0.0607985817,
-0.0129106976,
0.020946119,
-0.01994312,
-0.0032797311,
0.0375422873,
-0.0382294953,
-0.0896667093,
0.0068176584,
-0.0365790725,
0.0683367252,
0.0261794254,
-0.0241725929,
0.0957909003,
0.0076669897,
0.0033995057,
-0.0018300518,
-0.0454046503,
-0.0478488617,
-0.0070821489,
0.0117449304,
0.0306986663,
0.0286662597,
-0.0053516096,
-0.029415166,
-0.0050549186,
0.0624906905,
-0.0335327797,
0.0205733739,
-0.0514010265,
0.0027745697,
0.0104338406,
-0.0598200932,
-0.0455167145,
-0.1106929183,
-0.0026781985,
-0.0305418521,
0.0386354402,
-0.0088827042,
-0.0270757601,
-0.0414008275,
0.0151876993,
0.0363750532,
0.0159127433,
-0.0451301374,
0.0273452308,
0.0368855521,
0.066281639,
-0.0172500629,
0.0399865136,
-0.045576714,
0.02744033,
0.0131583102,
0.0463580713,
-0.0340107791,
0.0071989577,
0.020829821,
0.0591923743,
-0.0427639224,
-0.0315645188,
0.0663932711,
-0.0301502589,
0.0242533479,
-0.012493209,
0.0772241801,
0.0413932614,
-0.095842272,
0.0041660322,
-0.0281041991,
0.0594940186,
0.01872571,
0.0572018176,
-0.0873453021,
-0.0334356539,
-0.0086008478,
0.062645331,
-0.0188188944,
-0.0818691775,
-0.0305961799,
-0.1025833264,
0.0141560361,
0.0053005926,
-0.0597361512,
0.05567744,
-0.0357548706,
-0.0319626816,
-0.0564518981,
-0.0090772957,
0.0266709514,
-0.038417656,
0.0127337724,
0.008198088,
-0.010672899,
0.0056586689,
0.0317518227,
-0.0284413565,
0.0274466071,
0.0537250899,
-0.0049184817,
0.0174144357,
0.0167843737,
-0.0367328636,
-0.0152207799,
0.00165351,
-0.0045000291,
0.0196758769,
-0.0541526787,
0.0319374911,
-0.0151465889,
0.0444634408,
-0.0078447405,
-0.0318952911,
0.0364835188,
0.0398936309,
-0.0261200909,
0.0047796313,
0.0208060015,
-0.0111579569,
0.0395560823,
0.056734398,
-0.0211290009,
-0.0795300305,
-0.0109371906,
-0.054273054,
-0.0506751351,
-0.0131032914,
-0.014283848,
-0.0095938677,
-0.0042576343,
0.010611359,
-0.0816601217,
-0.0247081351,
-0.010865611,
0.0324938223,
-0.0074246484,
0.0516582392,
-0.0440516025,
-0.0043397071,
-0.0081127444,
0.0126376199,
-0.0428845063,
0.0168278869,
-0.0655853003,
0.0214449931,
0.0480594933,
-0.0909375101,
-0.0228049345,
-0.0005284603,
-0.0891427249,
-0.0533830822,
0.0118507156,
0.0602796823,
0.0182236154,
0.0423553512,
-0.004189366,
-0.0728968158,
0.0566342212,
0.0131447511,
0.0015820744,
0.0075094085,
0.0267347936,
0.0644690022,
0.0138040418,
0.0250805728,
-0.0559278131,
-0.0176520608,
-0.0246618725,
-0.0009053597,
-0.0533958413,
-0.0067947698,
0.0263389312,
-0.0237356517,
0.0484102927,
-0.0588464141,
0.0154498853,
0.0011065196,
0.0118175736,
0.0206654426,
-0.035954617,
-0.0190185327,
-0.0184672158,
0.047272332,
-0.0126220295,
-0.0010775191,
-0.01203111,
0.0038164041,
0.0076422547,
-0.0247241147,
0.0013488519,
0.0634946525,
0.0066555762,
0.0509603731,
0.0142306061,
0.0092662545,
0.0335427299,
0.012051153,
0.0747236609,
-0.0119340783,
0.0560591631,
-0.0027964769,
-0.0224753581,
0.0104090413,
-0.0088603599,
-0.0499718636,
-0.0490630381,
-0.0253260825,
0.0303736143,
0.0393132791,
-0.05353567,
0.0101471934,
-0.0520037003,
0.0220457949,
-0.0122449631,
-0.0034810626,
-0.0466337167,
-0.0673168153,
0.0496280715,
0.0415249579,
-0.0155665278,
0.0788305551,
0.1089980379,
0.0474738218,
0.0134873753,
-0.0194709189,
-0.0411371738,
-0.0313357525,
-0.0079586571,
0.0561326854,
0.0732913986,
-0.0517727025,
-0.0242528822,
-0.0218552873,
0.0009243934,
-0.0214051846,
-0.0073627788,
0.0266317874,
-0.025813017,
0.0385839716,
0.035663534,
-0.0129470024,
0.0522471704,
-0.0734039843,
0.0359062105,
-0.0246250313,
-0.0341581814,
-0.0517362505,
-6.328893176e-33,
0.010147511,
-0.0405540504,
0.0336186104,
-0.0385475047,
0.0150536606,
-0.0453704484,
0.0052135442,
0.0116201947,
0.0297671948,
-0.0372289233,
-0.0280953608,
-0.0365164913,
0.0131228296,
0.0198074542,
0.0111526316,
-0.0050326604,
0.012648711,
0.0242234152,
-0.0159215089,
-0.0141069405,
0.0308623798,
0.0442063026,
-0.001605894,
-0.0495713055,
0.0113394074,
-0.0190520529,
-0.0270182434,
0.0082304971,
0.0018985844,
0.0507293083,
-0.0085378829,
0.0114558376,
-0.0110530173,
-0.0477501191,
0.0132109132,
-0.0255945735,
-0.0103037888,
0.0081615299,
0.0139126116,
-0.0037743268,
0.0272015128,
-0.0043955678,
-0.0139538804,
-0.0328059681,
-0.0077373562,
0.0382297747,
0.028215196,
-0.0322706327,
-0.0740348101,
-0.0331209525,
0.0038431128,
0.0025542935,
-0.0026850929,
0.0448972806,
0.0208510254,
0.0384313948,
-0.0127095198,
0.0535851456,
-0.0097614964,
0.0630986392,
0.0250968784,
-0.0199414007,
0.0135243284,
0.0110989083,
0.007320012,
0.0404600389,
0.018095661,
-0.0238708891,
0.0422828607,
0.0160771664,
-0.0148984604,
0.0327901132,
-0.0102871461,
0.0990943536,
0.0596960112,
0.0024009389,
-0.0015426762,
0.0579342619,
0.0463514514,
-0.0542702414,
0.0450800397,
0.0666949451,
-0.0261201635,
-0.0248091593,
-0.0240404792,
-0.0128622996,
-0.0324504301,
-0.0368641429,
0.0293630138,
0.0351692177,
0.0178152621,
-0.0056593665,
0.0161306541,
-0.0284526944,
-0.0549941547,
0.0068396204,
-0.0059767147,
0.0106662065,
0.0000840333,
0.0080218222,
-0.0779786035,
-0.0101703582,
-0.0087815672,
-0.0663824677,
-0.0054452606,
0.0035416908,
0.0190906674,
0.0302019287,
-0.0566942878,
0.0072275046,
0.0115213497,
-0.0029539084,
0.0022937031,
0.0046945661,
0.0495486856,
-0.0068216147,
-0.0133734206,
0.0585527681,
0.0011257154,
-0.0165064391,
-0.0388709232,
-0.0891203508,
-0.022583954,
0.0083222864,
-0.0085937409,
0.0030508728,
0.0042567425,
0.0043848339,
0.0385150164,
-0.0266761817,
0.0011234166,
0.0009797219,
2.699e-7,
-0.0279940683,
0.0529759713,
-0.0498542041,
-0.0433256142,
-0.0045394595,
0.0602689981,
-0.0014204715,
0.0086935945,
0.0154950358,
0.0436624326,
0.0554592051,
-0.004952867,
0.0349022709,
0.0399564728,
-0.0896578804,
-0.0407954119,
-0.015314674,
0.0082875518,
-0.0607768446,
-0.0322305188,
-0.0309801456,
0.0851020887,
0.0522930101,
-0.0255387556,
0.0385712534,
-0.0226117261,
0.0774737969,
-0.0795226619,
-0.0463724695,
-0.0245907791,
0.0093256291,
0.0009877606,
-0.0375630446,
-0.0087130899,
-0.0299448445,
0.0105592534,
-0.011612569,
0.0188986957,
0.0348789468,
-0.036817763,
-0.0122789154,
-0.0020688036,
0.0090444507,
-0.0452837683,
0.0562483594,
0.0004999779,
0.0087364893,
-0.0488549285,
0.0022525808,
-0.0442483611,
-0.0018018625,
-0.0508344993,
-0.0078575909,
-0.0208698809,
-0.0020941817,
0.0247664526,
0.0014264997,
-0.0568991341,
-0.0036192599,
0.0626163036,
-0.0089155175,
-0.0256217476,
-0.047765363,
0.0526978411,
0.0039175553,
-0.1040340364,
0.0421195664,
2.453670199e-34,
0.0289240573,
0.0179930143,
-0.0051713162,
-0.0017106297,
0.0246617086,
0.0323771425,
0.004913012,
0.0230423715,
0.0635635778,
-0.0432245508,
-0.0132199135
] |